Advances in
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR PHYSICS
VOLUME 18
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME N. ANDERSEN L. A. COLLINS A. S. DI...
30 downloads
1640 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
ATOMIC A N D MOLECULAR PHYSICS
VOLUME 18
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME N. ANDERSEN L. A. COLLINS A. S. DICKINSON
G. W. F. DRAKE A. HIBBERT B. R . JUNKER WALTER E. KAUPPILA J . MORELLEC
S. E. NIELSEN D. W. NORCROSS D. NORMAND
G. PETITE D. RICHARDS LEONARD ROSENBERG TALBERT S. STEIN
ADVANCES I N
ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS Edited by
Sir David Bates DEPARTMENT OF APPLIED MATHEMATICS AND THEORETICAL PHYSICS THE QUEEN’S UNIVERSITY OF BELFAST BELFAST. NORTHERN IRELAND
Benjamin Bederson DEPARTMENT O F PHYSICS NEW YORK UNIVERSITY NEW YORK, NEW YORK
VOLUME 18 1982
@) ACADEMIC PRESS A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishen
York London Paris San Diego San Francisco S o Paul0 Sydney Tokyo Toronto New
COPYRlGHT @ 1982, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RLCORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, W I T H O U T PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM T H E PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kiriador~Edition ortblished bv ACADEM~C PRESS, INC. (LONDON) 24/28 Oval Road, London N W 1 7DX
LTD.
LIBRARY OF CONGR~SS CATALOG CARDN U M B E R : 65- 18423 ISBN 0 -12-003818--8 P R l N T t D IN T H E UNITED STATES O F AMERICA 82 83 x4 8 5
9 8 76 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
...
Vlll
CONTRIBUTORS
Theory of Electron-Atom Scattering in a Radiation Field Leonard Rosenberg
I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI .
Introduction Bremsstrahlung Asymptotic States Scattering Theory Generalized Low-Frequency Approximations Concluding Remarks References
Positron-Gas Scattering Experiments Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kauppila I. Introduction 11. Experimental Techniques for Total Cross-Section Measurements 111. Total Cross-Section Results IV. Differential Scattering Cross Sections V. Inelastic Scattering Investigations VI. Resonance Searches VII. Possible Future Directions for Positron Scattering Experiments References
1 6 14
23 37 49 50
53 55 64 84 86 91 92 93
Nonresonant Multiphoton Ionization of Atoms J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
I. Introduction 11. The Theory of Multiphoton Ionization 111. Absolute Measurements of Multiphoton Ionization
Cross Sections V
98 101 119
vi
CONTENTS
IV. Experimental Results: Comparison with Theory V. Destructive Interference Effects VI. New Trends VII. Conclusion References
Classical and Semiclassical Methods in Inelastic Heavy-Particle Collisions A . S . Dickinson and D . Richards I . Introduction 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Angle-Action Variables Rotational Excitation Uniform Approximations Semiclassical Theories Conclusions References
133 140 151 157 I 60
166 167 170 183 186 198 200
Recent Computational Developments in the Use of Complex Scaling in Resonance Phenomena B . R . Junker I. Introduction 11. Gamow-Siegert States 111. Complex-Coordinate Theorems; and Properties of the Wave Functions IV. Variational Principle V. Variational Calculations VI . Many-Body Theories VII. Nondilation Analytic Potentials VIII . Complex Stabilization Method IX. Discussion References
Direct Excitation in Atomic Collisions: Studies of Quasi-One-Electron Systems N . Andersen and S . E . Nielsen I. Introduction Theoretical Models 111. Experimental Techniques IV. Results and Discussion V. Conclusions References 11.
208 210 214 227 229 243 244 247 256 260
266 27 1 279 287 303 305
CONTENTS
vii
Model Potentials in Atomic Structure A . Hibbert I. Introduction 11. Simple Semiempirical Model Potentials 111. Potentials Based on Hartree-Fock Formalism IV. Core Polarization V. Relativistic Model Potentials VI. Conclusions References
309 31 1 317 327 332 336 338
Recent Developments in the Theory of Electron Scattering by Highly Polar Molecules D . W . Norcross and L . A . Collins I. Introduction 11. General Formulation 111. Approaches and Approximations IV. Applications V. Conclusion Nomenclature References
34 1 350 360 377 390 392 393
Quantum Electrodynamic Effects in Few-Electron Atomic Systems G . W . F . Drake I. Introduction 11. One-Electron Systems 111. Light Muonic Systems IV. Two-Electron Systems V. Few-Electron Systems VI. Concluding Remarks and Suggestions for Future Work References
399 401 424 426 446 454 456
INDEX CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES
46 1 478
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
N. ANDERSEN, Physics Laboratory 11, H. C. eJrsted Institute, University of Copenhagen, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark (265) L. A. COLLINS, Group T4, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545 (341) A. S. DICKINSON,* Laboratoire d’Astrophysique, Universiti de Bordeaux, Talence , France ( 165) G. W. F. DRAKE, Department of Physics, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, Canada N9B 3P4 (399) A. HIBBERT, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, The Queen’s University of Belfast, Belfast BT7 INN, Northern Ireland (309)
B. R. JUNKER, Department of the Navy, Office of Naval Research, Arlington, Virginia 22217 (207) WALTER E. KAUPPILA, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan 48202 (53) J. MORELLEC, Service de Physique des Atomes et des Surfaces, Centre d’Etudes Nucle’aires de Saclay, 91 191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France (97)
S. E. NIELSEN, Chemistry Laboratory 111, H. C. eJrsted Institute, University of Copenhagen, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark (265) D. W. NORCROSS, Joint Institute for Laboratory Astrophysics, University of Colorado, National Bureau of Standards, Boulder, Colorado 80309 (341) D. NORMAND, Service de Physique des Atomes et des Surfaces, Centre d’Etudes Nucleaires de Saclay, 91 191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France (97) G. PETITE, Service de Physique des Atornes et des Surfaces, Centre d’Etudes Nucleaires de Saclay, 91 191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France (97) D. RICHARDS, Faculty of Mathematics, Open University, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, England (165)
*Present address: Department of Atomic Physics, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NEI 7RU, England.
ix
X
CONTRIBUTORS
LEONARD ROSENBERG, Department of Physics, New York University, New York, New York 10003 (1) TALBERT S. STEIN, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan 48202 (53)
ll
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS. VOL. 18
THEORY OF ELECTRON-A TOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD LEONARD ROSENBERG Department of Physics Nett. York University N e w Y d , Nett' York
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Bremsstrahlung . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. InfraredProblem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Bloch-Nordsieck Theory: Coherent States . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Asymptotic States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Electron in a Plane Wave Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Dressed-Target States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Scattering Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Formulation, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Approximation Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Generalized Low-Frequency Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . A. Connection with the Classical Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Modified Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Intermediate Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Strong Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
. . . .
1 6 6 10 14 14 17 23 23 28 37 37 40 43 46 49 50
I. Introduction Interest in the theory of electron-atom scattering in a radiation field has increased in recent years as a result of the important role it plays in the study of plasma heating (Geltman, 1977), gas breakdown (Kroll and Watson, 1973), and laser-driven fusion (Brueckner and Jorna, 1974). Of course, the theory has long been a subject of study, particularly in connection with the bremsstrahlung process. Owing to the dominance of stimulated emission and absorption, the theory of scattering in a laser field takes on a form somewhat different from the more familiar theory of spontaneous bremsstrahlung. However, the underlying physics is the same in the two cases, and it is interesting to trace the connections. In the lowfrequency domain the two theories show a remarkable confluence, as will 1 Copyright @ 1982 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003818-8
2
Leonard Rosenberg
be described here in some detail. The problem of scattering in a lowfrequency laser field has come under close theoretical scrutiny recently for several reasons. The effect of the field on the projectile becomes more pronounced for a given field intensity at the lower frequencies. Furthermore, the theoretical analysis simplifies considerably in the low-frequency limit; the projectile-field interaction, on the one hand, and the projectile interaction with the target atom, on the other, can be accounted for by separate calculations, whereas at higher frequencies the dynamics of the various interactions are inextricably mixed. The low-frequency domain is also of interest on more general grounds since it provides an example of the applicability of the correspondence principle to the analysis of the motion of the projectile in the field. The feature of the theory of scattering in an external field which most clearly distinguishes it from the field-free version is the necessity, in the former case, of replacing the usual plane wave solutions, describing propagation of the colliding particles in asymptotic states, by solutions which properly account for the interaction of the particles with the field. The modified plane wave solution for the electron may be thought of as representing the sum of an infinite set of perturbation terms which account for the stimulated emission and absorption of laser photons; the influence of the target atom on the electron is ignored here since the colliding particles are assumed to be well separated in initial and final states. The effect of the target-field interaction on the asymptotic states must also be included. Of course, it is only during a finite time interval that the particles are influenced by the field. This physical feature may be accounted for in the formalism by requiring the field to vanish outside a certain space-time domain and by introducing localized wave packets to describe the motion of the particles (Neville and Rohrlich, 1971). In practice one usually takes these packets to be infinitely broad and allows the field to be of infinite extent, although, as emphasized by Kruger and Jung (1978), a more realistic description of the spatial and temporal properties of the field can be crucial in many cases. Application of the apparatus of time-dependent scattering theory leads to the following qualitative picture. The colliding particles propagate in a field-free region in the remote past. This is indicated as region 1 in Fig. 1, which is a schematic representation of the strength of the particle-field interaction during the various stages of the scattering process. We wish to determine the probability for a transition which takes the system from such an initial state to a final state in the distant future, where the particles are once again free of the influence of the field (region 5 ) . Penetration of the particles through the fringe region (separating regions 1 and 2) effectively switches on the field. One may think of this as an adiabatic process,
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATI’ERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
3
PRECOLLISION
I I I
I I
+ t-+a
FIG.1 . Schematic representationof the field intensity experienced by the electron-atom system in different stages of the collision process.
in which the state of the system at any instant is determined as the solution of the wave equation appropriate to the instantaneous value of the field intensity. The field is thought of as being switched off in an analogous way. Assuming that the intensity dependence of these “dressed states” is known, we can trace the evolution of the wave function as the system passes through the fringe regions by simply varying the intensity parameter appropriately. In practice we calculate the probability for transitions between dressed states (the system passing from region 2 to region 4). These probabilities are related to the observed transitions by following the development of the dressed states as the interaction is slowly switched on and then off. A discussion of the scattering problem based on this adiabatic picture has been presented by Deguchi et nl. (1979) in the context of the many-body Green’s function formalism. The necessity of introducing modified plane wave states is by no means peculiar to the problem of scattering in an external field. Level shifts associated with sporituneoirs emission and reabsorption of photons by a charged particle are a familiar feature of renormalized perturbation theory. Modified plane waves also play a role in the theory of scattering in the presence of a long-range Coulomb interaction. Here, as in the case of scattering in a radiation field, there is a residual interaction which must be incorporated in the construction of the asymptotic states. Three-body scattering theory provides still another example in which long-range interactions must be accounted for at the outset (Faddeev, 1961). The interparticle potentials may be of short range, but a pair of particles may interact with the third particle acting as a distant spectator. The effect of this interaction, which takes place over an infinite domain of configuration space, must be included in formulating the problem (setting up the bound-
4
Leonard Rosenberg
ary conditions or, in an integral equation approach, choosing the kernel) to avoid mathematical difficulties. It is sometimes helpful to keep in mind the formal analogy connecting the three-body problem with the scattering problem of present interest; the external field plays the role of the third body. With the introduction of modified plane waves the theory of scattering in an external field can be developed in parallel with the field-free version. In effect one replaces each plane wave by a superposition of infinitely many such waves, each term in the expansion corresponding to the presence of a definite number of virtual photons in the field. Such sums must be truncated in actual calculations, and convergence must be checked numerically. A review of this approach to relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the presence of an intense laser field has been given by Mitter (1975). In the present treatment of the subject we will be concerned, for the most part, with methodology; computational techniques which are capable of dealing with the intense field version of the theory and realistic atomic models are still at an early stage of development. The emphasis we shall place on the low-frequency domain is a reflection of the fact that here interesting and useful results can be extracted from the theory without detailed numerical computation. The external field has the effect not only of modifying the scattering process through an alteration of the plane wave states but also of inducing processes which would not take place in the absence of the field. As a primary example consider an electron-atom system which can form a bound (negative ion) state. The existence of this state will not appreciably affect the scattering in the absence of the field for scattering energies well above threshold. In the presence of the field, however, the incident electron can lose just the proper amount of energy through stimulated emission so that it becomes temporarily bound in the ionic state. This is, of course, an unstable state since the system can absorb energy from the field. The net effect is the appearance of an induced resonance. The second half of this process, in which energy is absorbed and the electron liberated, is of considerable interest in its own right. The observation that multiphoton ionization can be viewed as a component of a scattering process is potentially useful since approximation methods developed for scattering may be carried over to the study of ionization. This point will be illustrated below in the description of a low-frequency approximation for multiphoton ionization. The unstable nature of atomic states in the presence of the external field should in principle be accounted for in setting up a formal theory of scattering by composite targets. Of course, if the lifetime of the unstable
ELECTRON-ATOM SCA’lTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
5
target is large compared with the collision time, the instability will have little practical effect. For sufficiently strong fields target ionization will play a major role, and very little attention has thus far been given to the treatment of this effect. In practice the dressing of the atomic target by the field has been accounted for either in first-order perturbation theory (Mittleman, 1980) or in a resonance approximation which allows for virtual transitions involving a few bound states of the target (Hahn and Hertel, 1972; Gersten and Mittleman, 1976a; Mittleman, 1976). The term “resonance” is meant here to include the strong coupling among nearly degenerate states which can occur at low frequencies; the significance of this effect in the context of the scattering problem was discussed by Perel’man and Kovarskii (1973). The dressed-atom states required in such applications can be constructed using well-known approximation techniques (Shirley, 1965). It may be mentioned here that these techniques frequently involve the use of a gauge transformation as a method for introducing the electric-dipole approximation in the description of the interaction between the bound system and the field (Gopert-Meyer, 1931; Power and Zienau, 1959). An analogous procedure can be used in the electron-atom scattering problem; such a gauge transformation turns out to be particularly useful in the development of low-frequency approximations, as discussed below. A useful review of the theory of single-photon bremsstrahlung in electron-atom scattering has been given by Johnston (1967). Geltman (1977) has compared the classical and quantum formulations of the treatment of multiphoton processes in free-free transitions and has provided a brief review of applications to the study of plasma heating by an intense laser beam. A survey of the theory of free-free transitions, along with a description of beam experiments, has been given by Gavrila and Van der Weil (1978). The status of experimental studies of the subject has been reviewed more recently by Andrick (1980). Atom-atom scattering in an external field is a subject of some interest (De Vries et al., 1980), but we shall not touch upon it here. Another aspect of the subject of free-free transitions not discussed here deals with the use of laser beams to create a population of target atoms in an excited state (Hertel and Stoll, 1977; Bhaskar et nl., 1977). Our emphasis will be on recent developments in the theory of multiphoton processes in electron-atom scattering. We shall be particularly concerned with the connections which exist between the time-dependent and time-independent versions of the theory, the relationship between the classical and quantum descriptions in the low-frequency limit, and on the unification of our understanding of stimulated and spontaneous multiphoton processes for low-frequency radiation fields.
Leonard Rosenberg
6
11. Bremsstrahlung A. INFRARED PROBLEM
We begin with a discussion of the theory of spontaneous bremsstrahlung, with emphasis on the special features associated with the infrared limit. While this is a well-studied subject, it provides us with an interesting example of a nonperturbative treatment of the particle-field interaction, a treatment which has much in common with methods discussed later in connection with the stimulated bremsstrahlung problem. Particular care must be taken in describing the electron in initial and final states; the energy of the electron-field system is well defined asymptotically so that states differing in the number of infrared photons can have closely spaced levels. This near degeneracy leads to a breakdown of ordinary perturbation theory. In the case of spontaneous emission the breakdown has a dramatic effect-it leads to the well-known infrared divergences-which was first analyzed by Bloch and Nordsieck ( 1937). We shall now sketch the Bloch-Nordsieck analysis in the context of nonrelativistic potential scattering. A generalized version, which allows for an atomic target, and which includes a higher order correction in the frequency, has been worked out recently (Rosenberg, 1980b). Since the spacing between energy levels hw is small (compared, say, with the electron kinetic energy) in the low-frequency limit, one expects that a classical description of the electron interaction with the radiation field, corresponding to the limit h + 0, will be appropriate. (One might also expect difficulties with the usual perturbation expansion since e'/hc x for h 0.) Let us then recall some basic results of classical radiation theory. Consider the scattering of an electron from a center of force; the electron momentum changes from p to p' in the course of the collision. The scattering potential is assumed to be of short range so that the concept of a finite collision time T~ is valid. Let R,., represent the energy radiated in the frequency interval 0 s w zs oy , where the maximum frequency wY is small enough so that oflc << 1. Writing R,., = Z(o) do, we have (Jackson, 1975) -+
-+
1;"
Here ro(r) is the position vector of the electron, lp = ( d r o / d t ) / c ,and p = d p / d r . In the nonrelativistic limit we have p << 1, and since ro/c f l r , the exponential may be replaced by exp i d (dipole approximation). Similarly, the contribution coming from lp x p may be neglected, and the retardation
-
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
7
factor (1 - p-i)-* may be replaced by unity. Finally, since << 1 and the integrand is nonvanishing only for times during which the collision takes place, expiwt may be set equal to unity. With these approximations we have 2
where v = p/p, v’ = p’/p, and p is the electron mass. In this long-wavelength approximation the radiation is independent of the details of the orbit; the actual collision may be replaced by one which changes the velocity instantaneously from v to v’. Since I ( w ) is nonzero for w --., 0, an attempt to interpret the bremsstrahlung spectrum in terms of a photon picture runs into difficulty. Thus, let us define the average number of photons emitted during the collision as fi = /:M d i , with hw(dii,) = I ( w ) dw. The approximation (1) then leads to
which diverges logarithmically; an infinite number of photons are emitted with a finite energy loss. This indicates that the usual perturbation analysis in terms of individual photons is based on an inappropriate physical model. In a correct quantum theory, divergences of the above type still arise, but are properly interpreted as divergences in photon number, not transition probabilities. We shall first go through a heuristic treatment of the quantum analysis; a more formal discussion appears in Section I1,B. We begin with the auxiliary device of placing the system in a box of volumeL3, which makes the photon spectrum discrete. The radiation energy can then be expressed as a sum over modes (which reproduces the classical expression in the limit L 3 + x ) of the form M
Rpjp=
hw*(Pi,,- prp)2 f=O
where pfp= ( h ~ ~ ) - ~ ( 2 ~ h e * / ~ * w ~ L ~ ) * ’ ~ p * X ~
Here wf and X i represent the angular frequency and polarization vector, respectively, for the ith mode. It is then natural to identify
Hi
=
(pip,
-
pip)*
(3)
8
Leonard Rosenberg
as the average number of photons radiated into theith mode. Since we are ultimately interested in calculating cross sections, we would really like to know the distribution function P(ni.)giving the probability of emission of ni photons into theith mode. It should satisfy P ( n 0 = 1 and En* niP(ni)= f i t . Then
En,
would represent the joint probability for emitting n , photons in mode 1, n2 photons in mode 2, etc. This could then be used to calculate the bremsstrahlung cross section for scattering accompanied by the emission of ni. photons into the ith mode. The condition W T ~<< 1 suggests the physical picture in which the collision takes place essentially instantaneously, with a probability determined by the cross section d d O for ) scattering in the absence of the interaction with the radiation field. We have seen, furthermore, that the dipole approximation adopted for the classical calculation of the radiation energy, which is equivalent to the neglect of electron recoil on absorption and emission of photons, leads to a radiation formula which is independent of the detailed nature of the collision. These considerations suggest the product form n2, .
d&,
. . , nM) = P(n,, n2, . . . , n M ) d d 0 )
(5)
for the bremsstrahlung cross section. Actually, this result is not very useful in itself. The probability of emitting ajnite number of photons must vanish for L 3+ since in that limit the average photon number is infinite. It follows that da(n,, n2, . . .) vanishes for L3+ =. This is not disturbing since the quantity of experimental interest is not d v ( n , , n 2 , . . .), but rather its sum over final states containing unobservable photons; these are “soft” photons whose frequencies lie below some limiting value w,, say. The summed cross section will be finite and measurable. The above discussion can be summarized in the form of two sum rules. First, the total scattering cross section, obtained from Eq. ( 5 ) by summing over all n,, n2, . . . , n M , is given by the cross section d d O )for scattering without any influence from the field. Second, the average energy radiated, defined by weighting the photon energy X i hoIntwith the collision probability, reduces to the classical radiation energy Rptpassociated with the instantaneous collision picture. These sum rules are correct to lowest order in 0 ~ 7 It~ is . remarkable that with the first-order correction term included the results can still be expressed in terms ofthe field-free scattering cross section (Rosenberg, 1980a). Analogous sum rules for scattering in a low-frequency laser field are discussed in Section V. ( ~ 1
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
9
The distribution P(n,) remains to be determined. Since we ignore recoil of the electron, the source is unchanged by photon emission-each photon is emitted under identical circumstances. One might then expect a Poisson distribution
P h i ) = (nr!)-le-Ei(at)ni
(6)
It is instructive to consider a more detailed, but still heuristic, justification of this formula. Let us recall the analogy between a radiation field containing n photons of frequency o and a harmonic oscillator of natural frequency w in then th quantum state (Sargent er al., 1974). Actually, we have a radiation field which, for a given mode, may be described classically in terms of an electric field of a specified frequency o and an amplitude corresponding to the specified energy h on. The harmonic oscillator analog would be a time-dependent state corresponding to a wave packet whose center oscillates about the equilibrium point in simple harmonic motion with frequency w and amplitude d. One takes the initial wavefunction to be a minimum packet centered at x = d and allows it to evolve according to the Schrodinger equation. The solution was obtained by Schrodinger (1926) and is reproduced in the text by Schiff (1968). From the solution one can determine the probability that the oscillator will be found in the stationary state with quantum number n . It is a Poisson distribution with Ti determined so that the average energy hwii = j K d 2 , where K is the stiffness constant of the oscillator. This argument lends credence to the claim that the low-frequency bremsstrahlung photon distribution follows a Poisson law. In any event, we have a simple mechanical model for a so-called coherent state of the radiation field. A proper derivation of the Poisson distribution will be given later. As an example consider the emission of a single observable photon during the collision; its frequency is w,, with w, < w,,, < w M .Summing the distribution (4) over soft-photon occupation numbers, with n, = ,a, for j > s, we obtain
2..
11, .111..
~ ( n , n,, , .!I,
. .. , nM) =
n M
e-%irn
e-Dfim
f=&l
Here exp( - D ) is a radiation-damping factor representing the probability that no hard photons are omitted. Observe that had we not summed over M soft photons the damping factor would have been exp(-xi-o nil, which becomes exp(-A), with Ti given by Eq. (2) in the limit L3 + m. Since i diverges, one finds zero probability for emission of a single hard photon and any finite number of soft photons. This is consistent with the earlier observation that, in fact, an infinite number of photons are emitted. However, if we expand the exponential-this corresponds to treating the
Leonard Rosenberg
10
electron-field coupling in perturbation theory-the divergence in ii at the low-frequency end of the integration range gives rise to a divergence in the transition probability. This unphysical result is the infrared catastrophe. Returning now to the case where we do sum over unobservable photons, we find M
Here w^ represents the region in k space satisfying w, S kc 5 wy. The result of the integration is
The differential cross section for scattering with an electron observed in a solid angle d o and a photon of polarization A observed in a solid angle don with wave number between k and k + dk is
This is of the form w ( d 3 a / d Rdw d R i ) = A. where w > 0 and A . is frequency independent and is obtained from a knowledge of the field-free scattering cross section. Low (1958) was able to calculate a correction term of order w , again in terms of the physical field-free cross section. Kroll and Watson (1973) obtained an analogous result for stimulated bremsstrahlung. These results can be derived as special cases of a more general formulation of the scattering problem discussed below.
B. BLOCH-NORDSIECK THEORY: COHERENT STATES Infrared difficulties in scattering theory are avoided by making an appropriate choice of modified plane waves. The necessity of including the effects of the electron-field interaction in the asymptotic states is clear physically. Furthermore, failure to do so leads to mathematical problems when one attempts to construct a formal proof of the existence of the scattering matrix (Blanchard, 1969). A comprehensive review of modern treatments of the infrared problem in quantum electrodynamics has been given by Jauch and Rohrlich (1976). Since the problem arises from soft photon interactions, we shall ignore, for the purpose of the present discus-
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
11
sion, hard photon interactions in constructing the modified plane waves. Their effects can be included later on by doing perturbation theory. Furthermore, we retain the essential features of the problem if we consider here the potential scattering case, work in the dipole approximation, and drop the A term in the electron-field interaction. (These limitations can be relaxed.) We look for asymptotic states satisfying (He + HF+ H’)I+) = El+) where He is the electron kinetic energy operator. With the sum over modes understood in the following to be cut off so that only soft photons (wt < w,) are included, we have, in the occupation number representation, HF = hwtaiat and H ’ = -(e/pc)p*A. Here af and a; are the annihilation and creation operators, respectively, for photons in the ith mode and A
( 2 5 r h ~ ~ / o ~ L ~ )+” a:) ~A~(a~
= i
is the vector potential in the dipole approximation. We work in a basis in which the polarization vector hi is real. Since the electron momentum p is conserved in the dipole approximation, the solution will be of the form IJlop) = Ip)WpIO). We are assuming that the only photons present are in the photon cloud associated with the electron. More generally, we could have, in addition, a beam of incident photons, in which case the vacuum state 10) would be replaced by the appropriate occupation number state. With the energy eigenvalue associated with the above state expressed as Eop= ( p 2 / 2 p ) + Ap, the Schrodinger equation is easily seen to be equivalent to the commutation relation r
1
which is satisfied by W, = exp[X.ipf,(af - a,)]; the level shift is given by Ap = hofpf,. This solution may be verified with the aid of the identities (Bjorken and Drell, 1965)
-xi
eA+B
= eAeBe-[A.Bl/2
,
[A, a B ]= [A, B ] e B
which hold when [A, B ] commutes withA andB. Note that the relation Eop h o f p j pwhich has been obtained for the energy eigenvalue is easily understood in classical terms by recognizing that the work done in accelerating the electron from rest to the momentum p includes a contribution arising from the radiation reaction force. This contribution, which accounts for the work done by the field, is the negative of the energy radiated during the acceleration process (Landau and Lifshitz, 1962). If one includes only the soft photon modes and assumes that the = ( p 2 / 2 p )-
cf
12
Leonard Rosenberg
acceleration time is short compared with the period 2n-/w,, the energy radiated reduces to El h w i p f p ;the negative of this is just the expression obtained above for the level shift. The quantum origin of the level shift lies, of course, in the emission and reabsorption of photons. It is a simple matter to establish the property, well known in the theory of coherent states (Glauber, 1963),
wp.wp=
Wp-,,
(7)
Using this result we can calculate the amplitude for scattering with the emission of n, photons in the ith mode. In the Born approximation it is
.
( n l . n 2 , . . . n,lW~~(p'(VJp)W,IO) =
V(p' - p ) ( n l , n2, . . . , n,lW,-,,10)
The matrix element of WP-,, can be calculated. Its square gives the probability of finding photons with the occupation numbers n , , n 2 . . . . , ris in the final state. This probability turns out to be precisely the Poisson distribution mentioned earlier: n2, .
. . , n , l ~ , - , , 1 0 ) 1= ~ P(n1)P(n2) *
P(n,)
with P(n,) given by Eqs. (3) and (6). In this way much of the earlier heuristic discussion is justified. The cross section is da/dR
=
(du'"'/dR)HornP(nl,n2,
. . . , n,)
More generally, that is, to all orders in the scattering potential V , we expect that the Born cross section should be replaced by the exact fieldfree cross section to good approximation (Nordsieck, 1937). The following physical argument may be offered to support this expectation. Nonperturbative methods are required to construct the asymptotic states because of near degeneracies. (Two states with the same electron energy but different photon number are very closely spaced.) The p,, functions play the role of effective coupling parameters-they are matrix elements of H ' / h w , . This operator may be taken to be of zero order, with H' and hwi each of first order. As for the intermediate states the collision time is so short compared with the period 2r/ol(here we assume that there are no resonances in the field-free scattering cross section-that requires special attention) that a well-defined energy cannot be ascribed to the electron during the collision. The energy denominator in the Green's function is not of the order of the photon energy (as it is in the asymptotic propagator) but some average excitation energy-large compared with the electron-field interaction energy (Bebb and Gold, 1966). This indicates that ordinary perturbation theory is sufficient to account for the effect of the field in
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
13
intermediate states. To lowest order we may ignore the field. The potential V may be replaced, to this order, by the field-free scattering operator, yielding the improved approximation dvldfl
= (da‘O’/dfl)P(n,, n2, . . , n,) *
(8)
Suppose that the initial state contains a large number of photons in a single mode (the ith mode, say) corresponding to the presence of a monochromatic laser beam of intensity Z = (nihwc)/L3.The photon number can change in the scattering process through absorption or stimulated emission. With effects of spontaneous emission ignored-they introduce corrections of order l/ni compared with the leading term-one finds (dropping the mode indexi), (n’lWp-pJJn) = J,!-,,,(X), whereJ is the Bessel function of the first kind and
X
=
(ho)-’(e/~~)(8rr~Z/o*)”*(p’ - p)*X
The cross section d v ( n - n‘)/dfl for the absorption (n - n ’ > 0) or emission ( n - n ’ < 0) of a specified number of laser photons is then obtained, by suitable modification of the argument leading to Eq. (8), in the form da(n
-
n’)/dfl= (dv‘O’/dfl)J:,,,(X)
(9)
To improve on Eq. (8), one must include the effect of the electron-field interaction in intermediate states. As mentioned above, the first-order correction term has been calculated; the result can still be expressed in terms of the measurable field-free scattering cross section. The improved cross-section sum rule (Rosenberg, 1980a) differs from the lowest order version in the appearance of small kinematic corrections; these account for the energy loss in accordance with the classical mechanism of radiation reaction in which a loss of kinetic energy is accompanied by the radiation of an equal amount of energy into the field. Low (1958) obtained a low-frequency approximation of a similar nature for single-photon spontaneous bremsstrahlung. The nontrivial feature common to these lowfrequency theorems is the fact that the scattering amplitude which enters is on the energy shell. The contributions to the amplitude associated with photon emission or absorption before or after the scattering takes place are off the energy shell, but these off-shell effects are canceled when the contribution associated with radiation in an intermediate state is included. Kroll and Watson (1973) obtained an analogous result, an improvement over Eq. (9), for scattering in a laser field. A convenient way to arrive at these first-order corrections is by means of a gauge transformation. We return to this matter in Section V in the broader context of scattering by an atomic target.
Leonard Rosenberg
14
111. Asymptotic States A. ELECTRON IN A PLANE WAVEFIELD It was first shown by Volkov (1935) that the Dirac equation for an electron interacting with an external plane wave field can be solved exactly. These solutions play an essential role in the formulation of intense field quantum electrodynamics and have been studied by a number of authors. For reviews see Eberly (1967) and Mitter (1975). Here we shall derive these solutions starting with the nonrelativistic Schrodinger equation (Keldysh, 1965; Bunkin and Fedorov, 1966). The fact that the field is intense justifies the use of a classical description. It is useful to keep in mind the close connection between the classical and quantum descriptions of the field; as will be seen below, the relation is essentially one of Fourier transformation. Consider a multimode field with each mode having the same propagation direction which we take to be the z axis. The classical vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is given by the sum over modes A,
=
0
+ A+e-ik.ll
$&i(Aieikitl
1
i
with k, = oi/c and 11 = z - ct. By retaining the z dependence we include electron recoil effects, typically of order v / c , which had been neglected in the discussion of Section 11. The transverse polarization vector Ai is represented as X i = i cos xi + i!; sin x i , where the angle xr specifies the state of polarization for each mode. Note the relations &*A: = 1 and &*At = cos 2 x i . We look for a solution of the Schrodinger equation
a
ifi - V, = at
(-ihV
-
eA,/c)2 q P
2P
in the form Wp = exp -i(Epr/h)$,, with JlP(r,1) = exp i [ ( p * r / h )+ S,]. If we define E , = p 2 / 2 p + A , where A = ( e 2 / 2 p c 2 ) d fwe , obtain an equation for S, of the form
$xi
Here we have omitted terms involving (d2S,/du2)and (dS,/di02since they may be seen to give rise to corrections which are negligible in the nonrelativistic limit. Equation ( 11) is easily integrated. Rather than continue with an analysis of the multimode field we restrict the following discussion to the single
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
15
mode case for simplicity. [The need for representations of the laser field more realistic than this has been emphasized by Kruger and Jung (1978) and by Zoller (1980).] By suitable choice of normalization we have (dropping the mode index i)
S,(ku) = p sin@
+ 0) +
(Y
sin 2ku
(12a)
Here we have defined a = (A cos 2x)/2q
(12b)
with q
=
h 4 1 - PZ/PC)
(12c)
and have introduced the real parameters p and 0 as the magnitude and phase, respectively, of the complex number
b In terms of the intensity I alternative forms
= (-e/pcW*p/q = w 2 d 2 / 8 7 r c and
(124
wavelength A , we have the
with A. = 1 p m and Zo = 1 MW/cm2. Choosing the nominal values A = 10 pm and p2/2p = 10 eV we find that an intensity 2 lo2 MW/cm2 is required before p takes on values k 1, a domain which (as will become more apparent in the following) signals the onset of significant multiphoton effects. It should also be noted that for1 S lo6 MW/cm2, and with the wavelength and energy chosen as above, the term involving a in Eq. (12a) will be small compared with the first term; taking (Y = 0 leads to a considerable simplification in the analysis. For circular polarization (x = ~ / 4 (Y ) vanishes identically. Introducing the Fourier expansion
with inverse
Leonard Rosenberg
16
we may represent the semiclassical wave function as r
qp(r,t ) =
2 ymexp[-i(Ep m=-z
-
rnhw)t/h
+ i(p - rnhk)*r/h]
(14)
One may interpret this expansion in terms of the absorption and emission of photons; these are, of course, virtual processes, not kinematically allowed. Real emission and absorption of laser photons can take place in the presence of another particle to which the electron can transfer momentum. Properties of the expansion coefficients y m have been discussed by Nikishov and Ritus (1%4), Brown and Kibble (1964), Reiss (1962, 1980b), and Leubner (1981). We take note of the following: y m ( j ,0)
(1)
(1W
= e-’moJ-m(p)
(2) Recursion relation: According to Eq. (13) we may write 2t?iym= (inI-1
IoZn
d(eimb)
exp i [ p sin(+
+ e) + a sin 241
Integrating by parts we immediately obtain 2mym + p[eieym+i+ e-’ym-ll
+ 2a[ym+, +
~m-21
= 0
(15b)
(3) Addition formula: x
Here the primes on p and a indicate the appearance of the momentum p’ rather than p in the definitions (12d) and (12b). Equation (15c) is verified by using the integral representation (13) to evaluate the left-hand side. The sum over I can then be performed using the relation 2.
(27r)-I
2
expi/(+ - 4’)
=
fi(4 - 4’)
(16)
/=--3
and the complex numbers j and 6’ combined by vector addition. [The analogy between the addition formula (15c) and the relation (7) for the coherent states is clear.] The suitability of the choice of wave functions (14) as the modified plane waves in the formulation of a theory of scattering in a laser field is confirmed by constructing a wave packet solution from a linear superposition of these states, following the prescription of Neville and Rohrlich (1971). One finds that the center of the packet follows a trajectory determined by the classical equations of motion for an electron in the field, thereby permitting a proper physical interpretation of the theory. (The classical trajectories will be discussed in more detail later on.)
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
17
In a quantum treatment of the field the vector potential appropriate to the case where only a single mode is occupied initially, and spontaneous emission into unoccupied modes is ignored, is A
=
( 2 n h ~ ' / o L ~ ) ~ ' ~ (+ a XatX*e-ikz) e'~~
The asymptotic wave function is written as exp -i(Enpf/h)+np, where Jlnp satisfies
It represents the state which evolves from the unperturbed state In ; p) (corresponding to the field containing n photons, the electron having momentum p) as the electron-field interaction is switched on adiabatically. One looks for I+,,p) in the form of a superposition of unperturbed states, all with the same total momentum p + nhk but with different numbers of virtual photons in the field; the problem then reduces to a deterrnination of the expansion coefficients. It turns out (Kelsey and Rosenberg, 1979) that the coefficients are just the ym introduced in Eq. (14), that is,
I+,rp)
X
ym(b,
=
+ m ;P
-
mhk)
(18)
lIl=-x
where b and a are defined as above using the correspondence I = w 2 d 2 / 8 n c= ( n h w / L 3 ) c .This assertion is easily verified by substituting the expansion (18) into the Schrodinger equation (17). With the energy = p 2 / 2 p + A + nhw = Ep + nhw, we find that Eq. (17) will chosen as Erp be satisfied provided that the expansion coefficients satisfy the recursion relation ( 15b). Thus, choosing the expansion coefficients in the form (13) does indeed provide us with a solution. The addition formula (1%) may be = 8,,.,,8(p'- p). used to establish the orthonormality relation (+,7~pf~Jl,lp) The connection between the quantum and semiclassical solutions is summarized by the relation
(n
+ ml+,,,>= T-'
/oTdte-imml
+P
3
T
= 2m/w
(19)
A general discussion of the relation between the external field description and the fully quantized theory has been given by Bialynicki-Birula and Bialynicka-Birula (1976).
B. DRESSED-TARGET STATES Let us temporarily ignore the presence of the projectile and study the target-field states. The basic approximation made here is to treat these
18
Leonard Rosenberg
states as if they were stable, that is, we ignore the possibility of ionization of the target by the field. To deal with the case where the ionization rate is significant would require a formulation of the scattering problem in terms of initial states containing more stable subsystems. The problem of scattering with three or more subsystems in the initial state is a difficult one, even in the absence of an external field, particularly if these subsystems carry a net charge so that long-range Coulomb interactions must be accounted for. Not surprisingly, little attention has been given to this problem. Of course, even if one ignores target ionization by the field, ionization can take place by electron impact. Such a process involves a final state containing three charged particles interacting with the field, and the wave function for such a state is not known in closed form. We shall not consider processes of this complexity here since a theoretical investigation in this area, based on approximate treatments of the final-state wave function, has only just begun (Cavaliere et a / . , 1980; Baneji and Mittleman, 1981). The eigenvalue equation for the isolated target is expressed as H,lb,) = r y J b , )v, = 0, 1, . . . . In the presence of a single-mode field, but with no target-field interaction, the state vector in the occupation number representation is of the form In )lb,,).After the interaction has been turned on, we have the eigenvalue equation (HT
+ HF + Hk)lDun) = E v n l D v n )
(20)
The energy can be written as Eyn= c,, + nhw + r,, where r, represents the level shift induced by the field. It can be shown that r, depends only on the intensity of the incident beam. That is, ignoring photon depletion effects, r,, is fixed as n varies by a finite amount from one photon state to another. For this reason we have omitted a subscript n on r,. (A similar situation was encountered earlier in connection with the projectile-field level shift A.) The time-dependent wave function associated with the dressed atom state D,,, is I*”,) = exp --i(E,,,t/#i)~D,,). A quantum description of the field has been adopted above. The connection with the semiclassical procedure can be made in a manner analogous to that described earlier for the projectile-field states. Here we base the discussion on the general theory of periodic potentials and in particular on the so-called quasi-energy method (Zeldovich, 1973). Thus, we look for a solution of ih(@Pl,/dt)= (HT + X;)*,,where Xk,the interaction Hamiltonian in the semiclassical description, is period-ic in time, with period T = 2 r / w . Introducing the quasi-energy E, we write V,,= exp(-iE,r/h)D,, where D, is periodic. It may then be expanded in the Fourier series ?j
D,
=
2
m=-m
rm(V)~imw~
(21)
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
19
In analogy with Eq. (19) we expect that the relation (m
+ nlD,,)
=
T T-lI0
dte-‘”’’’’‘D,
(22)
provides the connection between the semiclassical and quantum solutions. (It is assumed that the solutions have the correct adiabatic limit, passing over to the unperturbed solutions as the interaction with the field is turned Off.)
To establish the above connection, we must show that the D,,can be expanded as
wiih the same expansion coefficients as appear in Eq. (21). This is accomplished by examining the coupled equations which determine the expansion coefficients; they turn out to be identical in the quantum and semiclassical cases. Thus, inserting the expansion (23) into the quantum equation (20) we obtain the equations
(HT+ (n + m)hw
-
m
E,,)rm(u) +
( n + mlH;ln
+ m ’ ) r m t ( u=) 0
m)=-m
(24)
for the expansion coefficients. (In practice this infinite set of coupled equations must be truncated in order to generate approximate solutions; the discussion is purely formal at this stage.) In a similar way we insert the expansion (2 1) into the semiclassical equation [HT
+ X; - i h ( a / d t ) ] D ,= E,D,
(25)
Since Xk is periodic, we may exhibit its time dependence in the form 22’; = (Xk)meimwl. The coupled equations for the expansion coefficients then become
zi=-m
(HT+ mhw - E,)Tm(v) +
m
m’=-.X
(%‘b)m-mflrmt(v) = 0
This is seen to agree with the quantum version (24), provided that one makes the identification E,, = E, + nhw and notes the relation (Baym, 1969) ( n + mlH;ln + m ’ ) = (X;)m-m,. In atomic radiation theory, and in problems involving intense external fields as well, one frequently represents the atom-field interaction in the dipole approximation. That is, in the semiclassical form, Xi + - e z l rl*E,(O, f), where the sum runs over target electron coordinates and EJr, t ) = (-l/c) d & / a t is the classical electric field. This repre-
Leonard Rosenberg
20
sentation is expected to be valid in the nonrelativistic domain and for fields of relatively long wavelength. The dipole approximation is conveniently introduced through a gauge transformation. (For a recent discussion see Reiss, 1980a). We review that procedure here; it will be useful in the scattering problem as well. In its semiclassical form the gauge transformation is generated by the function A = -El rl-Ac(rl,t), which introduces the transformation ql,+ exp(iAe/hc)P,, in the dressed-target wave function. This is equivalent, in the quantum treatment, to a unitary transformation represented by exp(g,), with (Sachs and Austern, 1951)
where Z is the number of target electrons. The eigenvalue equation satisfied by the transformed state 6 , ,= exp( -g,)D,, is obtained by transformation of the Hamiltonian appearing in Eq. (20). This is accomplished by first noting the relation pl - eA(rl)/c
=
es'{pl
+ (e/c)hl*E(r,)}e-g~
where A is a unit vector in the z direction and E(r,)
=
i ( ~ / c ) ( 2 n h c ~ / w L ~ ) ~-~citX*e ~(~Xe'~.~ -Iker)
represents the quantum form of the electric field. The transformation of HF is carried out using the expansion e0THFe-OT
= HF + [ g T ,
&I + (1/2 !)[gT,[gT,HF13+
*
*
.
Since the double commutator is a c number, the terms shown explicitly are actually the only ones which contribute. Note that the operators ci and N t may be thought of as representing quantities of order n On the other hand, the double commutator is independent of the external field strength; it represents a level shift arising from spontaneous emission and absorprJ*E(r,), tion and may be ignored here. Using the relation [ g , . H F ] = e Ey==, we find that the transformed eigenvalue equation is (HT
with
+ HF + i7&)p1#,) = El,,pLj,)
(27)
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
21
In the nonrelativistic limit and in the long wavelength regime we have H$ = - ~ , e r J * E ( Oto) good approximation. In general all states of the isolated target are coupled through the interaction with the field, and it will not be possible to find exact solutions of Eq. (27). Approximate solutions can be found by truncating the space of states which form the basis. As a simple example suppose we have a twofold degeneracy. In the low-frequency limit, the effective strength of the coupling between these two states will be given by the ratio of the interaction energy to the photon energy (in analogy with the situation encountered earlier in the discussion of the projectile-field states). This coupling may be large even for moderate external field strengths. One would account for it exactly and attempt to include coupling to other states in ordinary perturbation theory. If the degeneracy were not exact, one could account for the splitting using an almost degenerate perturbation theory (Rosenberg, 1980~).To give some flavor of the calculational procedure, let us assume that the unperturbed states of the target Ib,) and Ib,) are degenerate, with energy E . With all other states ignored, the eigenvalue equation to be solved is of the form (27), with HT= ~ [ b ,(b,1 ) + Ib, ) ( b21]and, in the dipole approximation, assuming linear polarization,
We look for a solution in2the form (23), or rather its gauge-transformed version, with T,(v) = CKll&’(v)b,. v = 1, 2, subject to the condition In,.,,)+ lb,,)ln)as the interaction is switched off. From the Schrodinger equation (27) we obtain a set of coupled recursion relations for the expansion coefficients c k ) ; these become decoupled when they are reexpressed in terms of the combinations ck) ? c g ) .By comparison with the recursion relations for the Bessel functions we readily identify these linear combinations with Bessel functions .I% Y),,,where ,,(
and m ’ = m - (EL,,,- E - n h w ) / h w . The irregular (Neumann) solution must be excluded to ensure the normalizability of the state vector. By the same reasoning rn’ must be an integer. We take m ‘ = m since E,,, must reduce to E + nhw as the target-field coupling is switched off adiabatically. These considerations lead to the result
Leonard Rosenberg
22
with Em = e + nhw. The orthonormality property of the solutions may be verified using the integral representation.
and the closure relation (16). Having determined the expansion coefficients we may construct the semiclassical version of the above solution using the correspondence (22). This leads to
ID,)
C 2
=
t[exp(iY cos w t )
+ (-
l)VfKexp(-iY cos wr)]lb,) (31)
K=l
One easily verifies that this satisfies the version of the Schrodinger equation (25) appropriate to the dipole approximation as well as the adiabatic condition 0, + b , , for Y + 0 (Keldysh, 1965; Kovarskii and Perel'man, 1972). Once the dressed-target states have been constructed, they may be used in conjunction with the projectile-field states to arrive at a solution of the Schrodinger equation appropriate to the asymptotic domain in which the field interacts with both the projectile and the target, the latter taken to be infinitely massive. The semiclassical version of the solution is simply the = El. + Ep. We may anticipate = P,,P,, with quasi-energy product that a knowledge of the semiclassical solution allows us to construct the = exp(-iE,npr/h)$L,np using the analog of Eq. (19) quantum solution or (22). This would lead to the representation (n
+ ml$,,nP)=
m
I'm-m,YmrIp- m ' h k )
(32a)
m' n-m
with the coefficients Tm-m.and ymlobtained from the Fourier series expansion of the semiclassical dressed-target and dressed-electron solutions, respectively. Equation (32a) is equivalent to
It may be verified directly (Rosenberg, 1978) that this form satisfies the Schrodinger equation in its quantum form, namely, (He
+ HT + HF + H')IJlunp )
=
EvnpIJlmp )
(33)
provided that the r coefficients satisfy Eqs. (24), and the energy is given by Ev,,p = Eyp+ nhw. The version (32a) has an obvious physical interpretation as the probability amplitude for finding an additional m photons in the
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
23
field given that n photons were present initially. Since the electron and the target emit photons independently, one forms the product of the amplitude for emission of in ' photons by the electron with the amplitude for emission of the remaining nz - rn ' photons by the target, and then sums over all m ' to arrive at Eq. (32a).
IV. Scattering Theory A. FORMULATION By adopting the semiclassical picture we may take over standard timedependent scattering theory (Schiff, 1968), but with suitably modified asymptotic states. [Some of the mathematical problems which arise in this generalization of ordinary scattering theory to include an external radiation field have been discussed by PrugoveEki and Tip (1974)l. To begin with the simplest case let us consider single channel potential scattering. In the asymptotic domain the wave function satisfies Eq. (10) in which the potential V does not appear. The full Schrodinger equation is
We saw in Section 111 that in the case of a single-mode field (to which we specialize in the following) the asymptotic wave function may be expanded in the form
According to Eq. (19) the Fourier coefficient function +,(m)and the solution of the quantum equation (17) are related by ( n + ~ Z I J " , ~ ) = $,(m). It may be demonstrated (Kroll and Watson, 1973) that the periodicity property of the asymptotic wave function is preserved when the scattering potential V is included. In analogy with Eq. (34) we have
Here again we may relate the coefficient function to the solution of the corresponding quantum version of the Schrodinger equation. We have ( n + ml&J = $,(rn), where = E,,pl$np)and H = He + H ; + HF + V. This relation between the quantum and semiclassical wave functions
24
Leonard Rosenberg
may be verified by repeating the argument which led to Eq. (22) or, equivalently, by comparison of the Lippmann-Schwinger integral equations satisfied by these scattering wave functions. The transition matrix element is
which is, of course, an integration over space and time in the coordinate representation. This matrix element may be written, with the aid of the Fourier expansions (34) and ( 3 3 , as m
Rather than formulate the scattering problem in the semiclassical picture, we may, alternatively, make use of the occupation number representation (Rosenberg, 1977). The scattering matrix element for the transition In; p ) -+In'; p ' ) is S,,,p,:np
=
6,l,,l
&P'
-
P) - 27ri6(EdP,-
~,lp)T,l~p~:"p
with
The rules of correspondence between the semiclassical and quantum wavefunctions now allow us to express the semiclassical matrix element (36) as an infinite sum of terms, each corresponding to a transition involving the emission or absorption of a definite number of photons; we find
A relativistic version of this connection formula has been used by Brown and Goble (1968). An alternative expression for the T-matrix element is obtained by representing the wave function in terms of the resolvent G(E) = ( E - H ) - l as =
IhP> + G(~,lp)vl+,,p)
A positive infinitesimal contributior to the energy Enpwill be understood here, rather than explicitly indicated. Equation (37) then becomes Tn'p':np
= (+n*pflV+ VG(Enp)Vl+np)
(38)
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
25
With initial and final states assumed known the calculational problem reduces to a construction of the matrix elements (rn'IG(E)lrn)of the resolvent. In general, of course, only a finite number of photon states can be included, and one must study the convergence of the calculated amplitudes as the dimensionality of the matrix representation of G is increased. Preliminary studies of this nature have been made by Jung and Taylor (1981). As indicated above, the calculational problem may also be formulated in terms of an integral equation of the Lippmann-Schwinger type. One writes G(E) = Go(E)+ Go(E)VG(E),where Go is defined formally as [ E - ( H - V)]-I and has the eigenfunction expansion r
.
This leads to the integral equation
with the Born amplitude given by V,r'p':,1p
=
~$fl~p~l~l$,~p~
(41)
An alternative version of the integral equation is provided by the so-called space translation method (Henneberger, 1977). The above discussion may be extended to include the case of a composite target. It will be convenient to treat the scattered electron as distinguishable from the target electrons with the understanding that antisymmetrization will ultimately be imposed by taking the proper linear combination of direct and exchange amplitudes. The asymptotic states satisfy equations of the form (33), which we write more compactly as ( H - E,,)[$,,) = V,,l$,,). Here /3 is a channel index which not only represents the set of observables which defines the state but also serves to distinguish the projectile from the target electrons. V, is the net interaction between projectile and target. The transition amplitude takes the form TB'B =
with E,,, = E,, and E
=
($fi,IV,,
+
V,,,(E - H)-'Vp($p)
(42)
E,, + i0. The differential cross section is
dm/m=
(2n)4h2Cc*(p
yp)p-pfp12
It was pointed out earlier that passage to the electric-dipole approximation, which is useful in the construction of the target-field states, can be effected by introducing a unitary transformation. Such a transformation also proves to be useful in setting up low-frequency approximations, as described later on. Since we are dealing with a system containing the
Leonard Rosenberg
26
target plus an additional electron the transformation operator is taken to be exp(g), with %+ 1
g = (ie/hc)
rj*A(rj) 1=1
The sum now runs over the coordinate indices of dI the electrons. The Hamiltonian of the system may be expressed as H = exp(g)H exp(-g), with
{ [p, + (e/c)irj
=
E(rj)I2
-
2P
l=l
e r j E(rj)]
+ HF + V
(43)
Here V represents the sum of interparticle Coulomb potentials. To study the effect of this transformation on the asymptotic states, we define &, = exp( -~,)I/J~, with g , given by Eq. (26). (A channel label specifying which of the electrons is the projectile is omitted to simplify notation.) The Schrodinger equation satisfied by JIB is readily seen to be (He+ HT + HF + HL + = E p l & ) , with g& given by Eq. (28). Writing g = g , + g , , we have exp( -g)JlP = exp( -g,)&. An analogous relation is obtained for the final-state wave functions using the appropriate decomposition g = g: + g ; . Since the resolvent transforms as (E - H)-I = exp(g)(E H)-Iexp(-g), it follows that Eq. (42) is equivalent to
n;)I$,)
T~~~= (e-o;JlgllVB+
v,.(E- H)-1V,1e-geJIB)
(44)
The transformed electron-field states appearing in Eq. (44) are of the form exp( -ge)$,,p. They may be constructed by expanding the exponential and making use of the representation (18) for $,,,; this leads to ~-oeI$,,~)
= 1E-m
1'"
(d4/2r)eil@piSp(@)
0
x [I - (ie/hc)A,(r$) re
+ . . .]In + I)lp - Ihk)
where re is the electron coordinate. Ignoring photon depletion effects, we set [ u , (it] = 0, in which case the expansion may be put back in exponential form. Then, with re recognized as the generator of momentum translations, we find cgeI$,,,)
=
5 1'" (dr$/2r)e"@eisp~@)
I=-
m
x In
O
+ I>lp - (e/c)Ac(4) - Ihk)
(45)
As may be seen from this result, the correspondence (19) between the
semiclassical and quantum solutions is preserved under the gauge transformation.
27
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
While we are focusing primarily on the free-free transition, some discussion of the bound-free transition is appropriate since the two processes are closely related physically. In multiphoton ionization, for example, the electron which has been ejected from the atom, but is still within the range of the atomic potential, can absorb energy from the laser field. In experiments performed recently (Agostini et al., 1979) electrons which have absorbed more than the minimum number of photons required for the ionization to proceed have been observed. A proper description of the dynamics of the final state, in which the electron, target, and field are mutually interacting, involves all of the scattering-theoretic apparatus with which we have been concerned here. In particular, in the strong-field or low-frequency limit a perturbative treatment of the final-state electron-field interaction will be inadequate. It becomes necessary then to modify the standard perturbation approach to multiphoton ionization (Lambropoulos, 1976) in order to build in the properly modified final-state wave functions at the outset. Since multiphoton ionization can be thought of as the second half of an induced resonance (as discussed in Section I), it is natural to make use of the scattering formalism as the basis for the development of a modified ionization theory. In fact, the procedure for applying scattering theory to the treatment of unstable states is worked out in the text by Goldberger and Watson (1964). A transcription of that method to the external field problem of interest here begins with an analysis of the resolvent (E - H)-' appearing in the expression (44) for the T matrix. The resonance corresponds to a near singularity in the resolvent. To isolate this contribution, we identify the discrete intermediate state IB ) in which the electron is temporarily bound. This negative ion state satisfies H'O'IB) = 8 ) B ) ,whereH'O' = - HF - H' is the electron-atom Hamiltonian. The resonance condition 8 + n & o = p 2 / 2 p + E" + nhw expresses the fact that the intermediate state IR) = IB)lno) is nearly The resolvent may be decomposed degenerate with the initial state I ,!J~, ~). into resonant and nonresonant parts with the aid of the projection operators P = IR ) (RI and Q = 1 - P . We have the identity (Mower, 1966)
c
=
G' + ( 1 + G'F)IR)(E
-
ER)-'(R[(l + H'G")
where cp= [ Q ( E - H)Q]-' and ER
=
8
+ ~ & C+ O(RI(H' + H ' G G ' ) I R )
It follows that Tf3.,= T$, with the replacement of Tfi,R(E- ER)-ITR,. Here
+ T i l P ,where TBIpis obtained from Eq. (44),
c by cQ.The resonant contribution is T i , , - -
TB*R= (e-g&&,I(Vp' + V p l C Q H ' ) l R )
=
(46)
28
Leonard Rosenherg
may be identified with the ionization amplitude and TRBis the timereversed amplitude for the process of capture into the intermediate unstable state. Expansion of the resolvent GQin Eq. (46) in powers of the interaction H ' generates a perturbation series for the ionization amplitude corresponding to successive absorption of photons. It differs from the standard perturbation expansion in that the effect of the field on the final state of the electron-atom system is built into the wavefunction. The first term T
can be related to the tunneling contribution to the total ionization rate; we return to this point in Section V,D. It should be noted that a scattering-theoretic approach has been used by Damburg and Kolosov (1978) to study the problem of ionization of hydrogen in a static electric field.
B. APPROXIMATION TECHNIQUES I . Potetitid S c u t t u i t i g
Reliable approximations to the transition matrix can be obtained only under special circumstances, some of which are discussed below. To begin with, we consider scattering by a potential which is weak enough so that the iterative solution of Eq. (40) can be replaced by its first term, Eq. (41). Using the expansion (18) along with the addition formula ( I ~ c ) , we find
TI+.)IP
($,I
P
IVIJl,,p) = y l l , - , , ( b-
b ' , CY
-
a')V(p' + n ' h k
-
p
-
nh k)
If we ignore the photon momentum in comparison with that of the electron-this is equivalent to assuming a spatially homogeneous semiclassical field A,. = RedA exp(--id)-we have a - a' = 0. According to Eq. (ISa), the y coefficient may be replaced by the product of an (irrelevant) phase factor and a Bessel function of argument X =
Ifi
-
6'1 = I(hW)-l(e/pc)d A * ( p ' -
p)I
(48)
The differential cross section then becomes
~ i t h p ' ~ / 2=p (p2/2p)+ ( n - n ' ) h w . In the limit of vanishing field strength we find, of course, that T,,,p..,rp +
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
29
anfnt[p 2 / 2 p , (p' - P)~]], where t(e,T ) is the physical amplitude for scattering in the absence of the field; it is obtained from the off-shell amplitude
t ( e ; q', 9) = (q'l[V + V(e - H e - V)-'Vl1q)
by setting q2/2p = q"/2p = e, with (q' - q)* = T . A perturbative treatment valid in the weak-field regime may be set up by expanding the resolvent appearing in Eq. (38) in powers of the interaction. The weakfield behavior of the y coefficients is obtained by expanding the exponential in Eq. (13). The first few terms obtained in this way are, to first order, yo = 1,
y1 zz
-+p 9
y-1
= +b
(49)
Ordinary perturbation theory is recovered in this way. However, if the frequency is low enough, the parameters p and a , which measure the effective strength of the coupling with the field in asymptotic states, need not be small. As discussed earlier in connection with the infrared problem, the coupling is enhanced in the low-frequency limit by virtue of the near degeneracies in the spectrum of the electron-field states; adjacent energy levels EllPare separated by h w . To account for this effect we retain the exact form (18) for the asymptotic states. Then, with electron-field interactions ignored in intermediate states we have G(E)= (E - He - V HF)-l, and the approximate T matrix becomes
If the t matrix is a slowly varying function of the energy, the energy variable in Eq. (50) may be replaced by p 2 / 2 p as a first approximation. The sum can then be performed using Eq. (15c), giving T,I,P,.IIP
= y'l,-,,(b - b', 0)t(p2/2p; P', P)
(51)
where again we have set a = a'. The differential cross section obtained in this way agrees with that derived earlier [see Eq. (9)] using the coherent state representation of the field. The addition formula El J f ( X ) = 1 allows us to equate the total cross section, obtained by summing the approximation (9) over all final states of the field, to the field-free cross section. This is analogous to the Bloch-Nordsieck sum rule for scattering accompanied by the radiation of unobservable soft photons, as discussed in Section I1 (see also Jung, 1979). An improved version of this sum rule is presented in Section V. Equation (51) has been frequently used in the description of plasma heating through the inverse bremsstrahlung process (Geltman, 1977). In such applications the target is a positive ion so that the (unscreened) potential contains a Coulomb tail. Since the scattering theory from which
30
Leonard Rosenberg
the approximation ( 5 1) was derived was based on the use of asymptotic states in which the effect of the Coulomb tail was ignored, the validity of this approximation requires further justification. A useful extension to include the Coulomb case is made difficult by the unavailability of exact solutions of the Schrodinger equation for an electron in the presence of both a laser field crud a Coulomb potential. An attempt to bypass this problem has been proposed (Rosenberg, 1979b). While the practicality of that calculational procedure has not been investigated, it can be employed to derive a low-frequency approximation the leading term of which is of the form (51). The derivation involves the use of asymptotic states obtained by replacing plane waves by Coulomb waves. Approximations of this type have been suggested by Jain and Tzoar (1978) and, in connection with the problem of ionizing collisions, by Cavaliere et c i l . (1980). Some mathematical work dealing with the existence of the wave operator for 1975). Coulomb scattering in a laser field has been done (Combe et d., Further work on this important problem is called for. In order to compare approximate representations of the free-free cross section with results obtained from experiments involving pulsed laser fields, the temporal shape of the laser pulse must be accounted for. Kriiger and Jung (1 978) have suggested an approximate description of the classical vector potential in the form A, = Re d ( t ) X exp(-iwr). With the assumption that the amplitude function d(r)is slowly varying in time intervals of order m-', Kriiger and Jung (see also Gersten and Mittleman, 1976b) were able to derive a time-averaged version of Eq. (9) of the form
with X ( t ) = ( e / p c h o )sP(t)X*(p' - p). The integration goes over the duration of the pulse, or that part of it which may be selected electronically in an actual experiment. The cross-section sum rule is unchanged by this averaging procedure. Spatial averaging may also be introduced (Jung, 1980). Multiphoton free-free transitions have been detected by Weingartshofer et t i / . (1977, 1979). In these experiments electrons are scattered from argon atoms and hydrogen molecules in the presence of a CO, laser field. Since the energy spread of the incoming electron beam was much greater than the widths of the resonances in the e-Ar and e-H, systems, resonance effects are effectively averaged over and may be ignored. It also appears safe to ignore the effect of the field on the target since in these experiments the photon energy hw = 0.117 eV is small compared with the target excitation energies, and the maximum laser flux (5lo8 W/cm') corresponds to an electric field whose magnitude is small compared with typical atomic field strengths. It was not possible to check for quantitative
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
31
agreement between theory and experiment since the spatial and temporal laser flux distribution was not known with sufficient accuracy. However, qualitative agreement with Eq. (52) was observed, and the results were consistent with the cross-section sum rule. It has been suggested (Jung, 1980) that one might work backward and use the free-free transition measurements to determine the average power density of the laser field. The multiple absorption of photons by electrons in free-free transitions has been observed by Lompre et (11. (1979). In that experiment the electrons have a thermal energy of lo-' eV, which is small compared with the energy 1.17 eV of the photon. The validity of the low-frequency approximation is therefore questionable in this case. In fact, the experiments were interpreted not in terms of Eq. ( 52) but rather by assuming that the N-photon absorption process depends on the laser intensity as I N . The lowest nonvanishing order of perturbation theory in the electron-field coupling implies such a power law behavior. The absorption of as many as eight photons has been detected in this experiment. 2. E&t
of Scrittrr'itig Resotwnces
As pointed out by Kriiger and Jung (1978), Eq. (50) represents a convenient starting point for the study of resonant scattering in a laser field. If the field-free scattering amplitude is resonant at an energy e,, the amplitude (50) will show resonances for initial electron kinetic energies p 2 / 2 p = e o , eo & ho,eo ? 2hw, etc., corresponding to the fact that the electron can exchange energy with the field before or after the resonant interaction. To be more explicit, we suppose that an isolated resonance exists whose width is small compared to hw. Let I, be the integer closest to [ ( p 2 / 2 p )e o ] / h w .Then, ignoring the nonresonant background in Eq. (50), we have Consider now single-photon absorption in the weak-field limit. The relevant y coefficients are well represented by the expressions given in Eq. (49). With p 2 / 2 p = eo - ho,we have lo = - 1 and T,l,p,;,lp= tbr(e,; p', p), corresponding to a single photon absorbed in the initial state. There will be a second resonance at p 2 / 2 p = e, (1, = 01, with amplitude ( - b ' / 2 ) * t ( e 0 ; p', p) corresponding to a single photon absorbed in the final state. The validity of this weak-field soft-photon approximation has been checked by Jung and Kriiger (1978) in a two-state square-well potential model. They compared it with the exact (to first order in the electron-field coupling) numerically determined free-free matrix element for absorption (see also Kriiger and Schulz, 1976). Experiments on e-Ar scattering in a weak COz laser field near the argon resonances at 1 1 eV (Andrick and Langhans,
Leonard Rosenberg
32
1978; Langhans, 1978) are in full agreement with this simple theory (or rather its generalization to account for two closely spaced resonances). The appearance of resonances leads to a modification of the crosssection sum rule (Mittleman, 1979~).In the no-recoil approximation, with the A' contribution to the interaction ignored, and with the field assumed Suppose ). that t has a to be linearly polarized, we have y l ( p ) -+ .I& resonance at energy eo with a width sufficiently small compared to h w so that for 1 # l o , the amplitude t in Eq. (50) may be treated as a smooth function of the energy. We may then write t = t R + t N R , where in the energy domain Ie - eol > h w , f R is negligible, while t N R is a smooth function for all energies. The low-frequency approximation (50) then takes the form T".p.:npJn,-n-/,(P')J-/,(P)tR[(P2/211.) - Iohw; p', PI
+
Jti
d(p -
p')fNR(p2/2/J-;
p', p)
(53)
The addition formula ( 1 5 3 , which in this case reduces to the Graf addition formula for the Bessel function, allows us to evaluate the sum
where
With the laser absent only d u ' " ' / d R is measurable; the laser, through the parameter p , allows for an additional measurement. The second (nonresonant) term in Eq. (53)vanishes for scattering in the forward direction for n' # n because of the vanishing of the Bessel function. (More generally it will vanish if the momentum-transfer vector is perpendicular to the direction of polarization.) This suggests that the laser field may be used to suppress the contribution to the scattering cross section which is only weakly dependent on energy, thereby allowing for an observation of the pure resonance scattering, unobscured by interference with the background. The method may also be useful in separating threshold cusps from the background. Model calculations, involving a single spatial dimension and a finite-dimensional photon Fock space, performed by Jung and Taylor (1981) confirm this background suppression effect. Comparison of the one-dimensional version of Eq. (50) with the essentially exact numerical results shows that the low-frequency approximation explains all of the qualitative features of the energy dependence of the cross section for free-free transitions with the exception of the fielddependent shift of the resonance position.
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
33
In the absence of an external field electron-atom scattering resonances of the “closed-channel” type can be understood in terms of composite bound states of a modified Hamiltonian from which one or more of the low-lying target states have been projected out. These composite bound states give rise to pole singularities in the effective potential, which in turn generate the resonance contributions to the scattering amplitude. This effective potential formalism (Feshbach, 1958)can easily be generalized to account for the presence of the external laser field (Gersten and Mittleman, 1976a; Rosenberg, 1977). In addition to providing the basis for a description of the effect of the field on closed-channel resonances (the dynamic Stark shift of the resonance position is one such effect), this formalism can be used to generate approximation techniques of the close-coupling type which have been widely used in field-free atomic scattering problems. Resonance theory has been applied by Mittleman (1978, 1979d) to the analysis of a “two-state’’ resonance process seen in an experiment performed by Langendam and Van der Weil (1978). They observed transitions, induced by the absorption of a single laser photon, between two resonant states of the e-Ne system. The interest in this process lies in the fact that the resolution is limited not by the energy spread of the incident electron beam but rather by the width of the resonances. This dramatically improved energy resolution allows for detailed examination of the fine structure of the resonant states. A detailed calculation of cross sections for single-photon absorption in multichannel e-H scattering in a laser field has been carried out by Conneely and Geltman (1981), who applied the close-coupling procedure to calculate the required continuum wave functions. They find that the presence of closed channel electron scattering resonances can enhance the background free-free absorption in the forward direction by several orders of magnitude. 3.
Mil Itichn11 n el
S critt ering
We now consider scattering from a model target atom whose spectrum consists of a finite number of discrete bound states, the effect of the continuum being assumed to be negligible. This example provides an illustration of how the response of the target to the field can be accounted for within the effective potential formalism. Referring to Eq. (44) for the transition matrix, we identify the Born amplitude
v ~= (e-oeJIpllVle-QeJIo) , ~
(54)
as the effective potential. (Since we ignore exchange here, we are able to simplify notation by dropping the channel index p on the projectile-field interaction operator V , .) The transition matrix satisfies a multichannel
34
Leonard Rosenberg
version of the Lippmann-Schwinger integral equation (401, which takes the form Tflyj =
Vflcfl+
V8,&fl
-
E@,)-’T@,,
(55)
8”
where the integration over projectile momenta is understood to be included in the sum over intermediate states. The asymptotic states appearing in Eq. (54) are constructed according to the procedure described in Section III,B, the overbar reminding us to make use of the gaugetransformed version (28) of the target-field interaction. Ignoring recoil effects in the representation (45) of the projectile-field state, one finds
x exp{i[S,(4) - S P W l ) (P‘(4J)IV”d4)lP(4))
Here we define P(4J) = p - eA&)/c, representing the momentum of an electron moving in a classical field A c ( 4 ) ;4 is interpreted as the phase - w f of the field in the dipole approximation and p is the time-averaged momentum. P’(4) is similarly defined. We also have V,,,,,(4) = ( ~ , , ( d ) ~ V ~ ~where , ( d ) El(&) ), = T,(v) exp(-irn&) is the gaugetransformed version of Eq. (2 1) for the semiclcrssiccrl target-field wave function. If the field is not too strong, this Fourier expansion may be approximated by a finite sum, and the sum over intermediate photon states in the integral equation ( 5 5 ) may be truncated. The resultant set of coupled equations may be solved numerically and the convergence of the procedure checked by repeating the calculation with a larger set of photon states included (Jung and Taylor, 1981). Numerical calculations for realistic systems are required to determine the range of applicability of this approach. We may, however, anticipate a simplification at low frequencies. In an adiabatic picture of the scattering process (Mittleman, 1979a), which is reasonable physically if the period of the field is large compared with the collision time, one imagines the phase of the field to be held fixed during the collision. Furthermore, one ignores the fluctuation of the field energy in intermediate states since its contribution will be small in the low-frequency limit. In this picture the scattering operator T l r C L ,corresponding (b), to the instantaneous phase 4, satisfies the coupled operator equations
Em
Note that while the effect of the field on the target is contained in the potential V,,,,,, thefin’rn of Eq. (56) is identical to that appropriate to the
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
35
field-free case; it is much simpler to deal with than the original version ( 5 5 ) . The physical transition matrix is obtained from the scattering operator by constructing a weighted average over the phase of the field of the form
x ( P’( 411T l d ($)IP( 4))
(57)
To justify this representation one goes back to Eqs. (551, lets o + 0 in the energy denominator, and then verifies that Eq. (57) provides a solution if the operators T,,,(+) satisfy Eqs. (56). The differential cross section is du(n - n ’ ) / d ~= (27T)4F2)15(P’/p)~~Y1nIP);YnP~2 With the approximation (57) for the T matrix, and with p t 2 / 2 k = ( p 2 / 2 p ) + E,. - El,, in the low-frequency limit, we have the sum rule
d u ( n - n’)/dR n-p+--m
= Jozn
~
(d4/2n){(2.rr)4p-2tl * ( P ‘ / ~ ) I
~
~~ ( 4 I)z,)I
~
The quantity enclosed in braces is the cross section for an instantaneous collision corresponding to the phase of the field. The total cross section is represented above as the incoherent average over the phase. The electron with initial momentum p is thought of as following a classical trajectory once it enters the field, arriving at the target with momentum p e A J + ) / c ; it then follows a classical trajectory until the field is switched off, leaving the electron with momentum p‘. If the field is not strong enough to appreciably distort the atomic wave functions it may still play an important role in the dynamics if the energy of the laser photon closely matches the level separation of a pair of target states. Such a situation has been analyzed by Gersten and Mittleman (1976a) for e-H scattering in a field which can cause resonant transitions between the Is and 2p states of hydrogen. The target then has an induced dipole moment even in the absence of the projectile so that the effective potential has long range components quite distinct from those which appear in the field-free case. However, some of the novel effects predicted in this theory will actually not be observed due to the loss of coherence of the dressed atomic states arising from spontaneous emission (Mittleman, 1976). The effect of the field on the target can be significant, even for nonresonant fields of moderate strength, if the target spectrum contains near
+
~
Leonard Rosenberg
36
degeneracies and the laser frequency is sufficiently low (Perel'man and Kovarskii, 1973; Brandi et ul., 1978). This can be seen clearly in the example worked out in Section III,B, in which two degenerate states of an atom are coupled by interaction with the field. The &v.ti\,e coupling strength is the parameter Y , defined in Eq. (29), which increases like w - I for fixed electric field strength. This near singularity does not appear in intermediate states of the scattering process where integration over a continuum of energies smooths out the effect of small energy denominators. To see the effect of target degeneracies more explicitly, let us place the problem in the context of the effective potential formalism described above and assume that the field is weak enough so that the target-field interaction may be ignored except for the coupling it induces between degenerate states. Solving the target-field eigenvalue problem in the subspace of degenerate states we construct semiclassical solutions which satisfy, at each instant, the closure relation I'
1'
the sum running over states in the degenerate subspace. [This relation may be verified directly for the case of a twofold degeneracy using the representation (311.1 The closure property may be used to replace the sum over dressed intermediate states in Eq. (56) by a sum over bare states. Formally, one looks for a solution of Eq. (56) in the form Tvtu= ). Ignoring target-level shifts, one finds that Eq. (56) will be satisfied, pro) 6,. - He - H T ] - l t . This identifies vided thatt satisfies f = V + V [ ( p 2 / 2 p + t as the field-free scattering operator, the physical t matrix being given by tY.P.:YP = (p'l (b$lb,,>lp).In evaluating the T matrix (57), we suppose the field to be weak enough so that P(4) = p and P'(4) = p'. Suppose further, for definiteness, that the initial target state 16,) is nondegenerate and that transitions to two degenerate states 16,) and 16,) are considered. Using the explicit solutions (3 1) for the dressed target in the final state (corresponding to a linearly polarized field) along with the representation (30) of the Bessel function, we find, for v' = 1 ,
(o,,,lrl&
-itip,:,lp sin[(n -
n')e]},
(58)
where X is defined in Eq. (48) and tan 8 = Y / X . For v' = 2 , we must interchange the indices 1 and 2 in Eq. ( 5 8 ) . If we adopt this low-frequency approximation for the T matrix, we are led to the sum rule
ELECTRON-ATOM SCAlTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
37
In this approximation, then, the differential cross section for scattering into one or the other of the two degenerate states of the target reduces, when summed over final states of the field, to the corresponding differential cross section for scattering in the absence of the field. Let us note, finally, that the above analysis may be used as the basis for an almost degenerate perturbation theory (Rosenberg, 1980c), the level separation being treated as a small parameter.
V. Generalized Low-Frequency Approximations A. CONNECTION W I T H T H E CLASSICAL LIMIT In this section we review recent developments in the theory leading to improved and extended low-frequency approximations. As we have seen, such approximations are useful since they allow one to express the transition probability in terms of the measurable cross section for scattering in the absence of the field. They also play a role in providing analytic expressions for the amplitude against which numerical approximation procedures can be tested. Aside from these practical considerations, the development of nonperturbative techniques is of interest in the study of the relationship between quantum and classical formulations of electrodynamics (Bialynicki-Birula, 1977); such a study can lead to useful insights. The relevance of the classical limit shows up clearly in the Bloch-Nordsieck analysis of the spontaneous infrared radiation problem reviewed in Section 11. One sees that the use of classical currents to describe the source of the radiation field is justified if the field consists of a large number of very soft photons. Further insight into the nature of low-frequency approximations came from the demonstration (Low, 1958) that soft-photon amplitudes (single-photon bremsstrahlung was the particular process studied by Low) are determined, up to the first two orders in an expansion in powers of the frequency, by the charge of the projectile and the on-shell amplitude for scattering in the absence of the field. Low’s derivation was based on general considerations of current conservation, Lorentz invariance, and simple analytic properties of the scattering matrix. The particle-field interaction was treated to lowest order of (renormalized) perturbation theory. The work of Brown and Goble (1968) on relativistic scattering in an external low-frequency radiation field may be thought of as representing an extension of Low’s theorem to the problem of stimulated (or inverse) bremsstrahlung, with the particle-field interac-
38
Leonard Rosenberg
tion treated to all orders. There is some merit in reconsidering this problem with the aid of the nonrelativistic Schrodinger equation since the dynamics can then be specified completely and the argument can be carried through in a much more explicit fashion. The low-frequency approximation described in Section IV,B represents a first step in this direction. One expects, in view of the results of Low and of Brown and Goble, that the approximation can be extended to include a correction term of higher order in the frequency without requiring off-shell information. One is also led to expect that the Bloch-Nordsieck analysis could be extended to higher order in a fairly simple way. With the above considerations in mind, let us begin with a review of the classical treatment of scattering in a low-frequency external field (Brown and Goble, 1968; Kroll and Watson, 1973). Since the collision time is assumed to be short compared with the period of the field, we may determine the cross section by assuming that the collision occurs instantaneously. The effect of the field on the target, and on the electron-atom system during the collision, will be ignored. The electron with initial momentum p enters the field adiabatically (in the sense discussed in Section I). The subsequent motion is most easily visualized in a reference frame in which the initial momentum is zero, with the field assumed for the moment to be plane polarized. The electron is forced to oscillate along the direction of the electric field with frequency w . As a result of this motion there is a magnetic force which induces an oscillatory motion of frequency 2 0 in the direction of propagation of the beam. This results in a trajectory in the form of a figure-eight with axis along the direction of polarization. The work done by the field during the adiabatic passage of the electron into the field may be calculated by assuming the vector potential to be of the form A, = dX exp( - ylfl) cos( k *r - wt), with y + 0 : then, 0 with v = - e A , / p c , the work done is determined as e E , - v dt = e Z d 2 / 4 p c 2This . level shift can be expressed (for arbitrary polarization) as
A
JozT
(d4/27r)r2A36)/2pc2
and corresponds to the quantum mechanical level shift determined in Section II1,A. A transformation back to the original reference frame, taking into account the alteration of the magnetic force along k which is caused by this transformation, leads to the classical momentum
P(4) = p
-
( e / c ) A , ( 4 )-
(R/c)
x [ p * ( e / p c . ) A , ( 4) ( e ' / 2 ~ ~ c . ~ ) A+ %4 $)
(59)
The momentum is expressed here as a function of the phase 4 rather than the time (to which it is proportional to first order in v / c ) . This variable
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
39
change just compensates for the effect of the magnetic force in the direction of A,, as may be verified by solving the equations of motion directly (Rosenberg, 1979~).One sees in this way that the solution (59) holds for arbitrary polarization. [The exact relativistic solution has been given by Landau and Lifshitz (1962) and by Brown and Goble (1968).] The kinetic energy of the electron in the field is
+ (1 - p * R / p ~ ) - ' [(-e/pc)p*A, + (e2A!/2pc2)- A]
P 2 ( 4 ) / 2 p= (p2/2p)+ A x
with average value (p2/2p) + A. If there were no collision, this average energy would remain fixed. The instantaneous collision changes the momentum to P'(+), defined as in Eq. (59) but with p + p', and evaluated at the same scattering phase 4. Energy conservation requires that eJ4) = P , , , ~ . ( $ ) ,where
ey,(4) = ( P 2 ( 4 ) / 2 p +)
E"
(60)
The average energy does change as a result of the collision since the dirrction of the instantaneous momentum is changed. The energy transferred from the radiation field to the electron for a particular scattering phase 4 is @'2/2p) +
€,,,
- ( p 2 / 2 p )- E , =
hods;.(+) - SL(+)]
(61)
where, recalling Eqs. (11) and (12), we have
Since the scattering phase is not observed, the classical cross section is obtained by averaging over this phase; it takes the form duC =
lozT (d4/27r) d d 0 ) ( + )
(634
Here ddo'(4) is the cross section for scattering in the absence of the field and may be expressed (assuming a qlranrum description of the electronatom interaction) in terms of the on-shell scattering amplitude t ( r , 7);we have
du"'(4)
=
( 2 ~ ) ~ ( p / p )/ hd 3' p ' 6(e,fp44) - e.p(4))(t(evp(4), r(4))I2 (63b)
with e,,J4) defined by Eq. (60) and
T(4)
(p'(4) -
p(+))*
(64)
Note that the phase space factor has been taken to be d3p' rather than d T ' ( 4 ) . This is justified since the Jacobian of the transformation from P'
40
Leonard Rosenberg
to p‘ is unity (to first order in u / c ) , and it is the more convenient choice since p’ rather than P’ is the observable momentum. To determine the average energy transferred from the field to the electron, call it ( ( p f 2 / 2 p )+ E,, - ( p2/2p) - E, ), we multiply the energy transfer corresponding to a given scattering phase 4, shown in Eq. (61), by the collision probability, average over the phase, and divide by the average collision probability. That is, we write (( p ’2/2p) + cup- ( p2/2p) - E , , ) = dU,/da,, with
dUc = (27T)“p/p)h’
y=(d4/27T) p3Pf[(P‘2/2P) + 0
x Ne,,*p4b)- e&))lr(evp(+),
~(4))l’
lE”,
-
( p 2 / 2 p ) - GI
(65)
These classical formulations have been used as the basis for numerical analyses of free-free transition processes (Geltman, 1977). In the following sections we adopt the quantum mechanical description and point out the correspondence between the classical and quantum pictures which exists at low frequencies. B. MODIFIEDPERTURBATION THEORY
An incident laser beam of intensity I and frequency w corresponds to a classical electric field of root mean square amplitude (4571/c)lI2. For I = 10l6W/cm2, this amplitude will be of the order log V/cm, characteristic of the field strength inside the atom. We suppose in the following that I << 10l6 W/cm2, in which case it will be reasonable to treat the particle-field interaction appearing in the modified Hamiltonian H , Eq. (43), in perturbation theory. The starting point is the expression (44) for the transition matrix, which was obtained from the version (42) by means of a gauge transformation. In the process one has effectively replaced the “ p * A ” form of interaction by the “r*E” form. The appearance of the additional factor w/c in passing from the vector potential to the electric field amplitude suggests that this replacement will be particularly useful in the lowfrequency domain. One must be careful, however, if there are near degeneracies in the target spectrum, or if scattering resonances are present, since the appearance of small energy denominators may invalidate the conclusion that the r * Einteraction is of lower order than the p - A term. To deal with the degeneracy problem, one must take into account the effectively strong coupling of the nearly degenerate target states at the outset and perturb about the residual interaction (Rosenberg, 1980~).This complication will be ignored in the following. The effect of a scattering reso-
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
41
nance has been discussed by Feshbach and Yennie (1962) in the context of the low-frequency , single-photon bremsstrahlung process. These authors point out that a correction, which in the present formulation arises from the second term in the expansion ( E - H)-1 = ( E - H(0)- H F )-1 + (E
-
-
H(U)- H,)-lH’(E - H(0)- HF)-l +
...
(66)
and which is treated as a second-order term and dropped in the derivation of the Low theorem, is actually of first order in the resonant case. Unfortunately, this term is rather more difficult to estimate than the remaining first and zero-order terms given explicitly by Feshbach and Yennie. An external-field version of the Feshbach-Yennie low-frequency approximation is presented in Section V,C. Putting aside the effects of resonances as well as target degeneracies we may develop the perturbation theory by expanding the resolvent, as shown in Eq. (66). An iterative procedure for solving Eq. (27) for the dressed target states can be set up in a similar way. However, the projectile-field asymptotic states which appear in Eq. (44), and are represented explicitly in Eq. (45), must be treated nonperturbatively since here near degeneracies play an essential role. The effective coupling strength is determined by the function SJd) in Eq. (45). Its derivative, shown in Eq. (62), is measured by the ratio of the electron-field interaction energy to the photon energy. Let 9 represent the maximum value of this ratio considered as a function of the phase variable 4. [For moderate field strengths the parameter a in Eq. (12a) will be negligible in which case 92 = p ] . It is convenient to distinguish the following three regimes (Rosenberg, 1981). (1) 9 << 1, weak coupling. Here ordinary perturbation theory suffices for the determination of the electron-field asymptotic states. If, for the sake of numerical orientation, we choose hw = 0.1 eV,p2/2p = 10 eV, and I = lo6 W/cm2 we find 92 = 0.1, indicating that the weak-field regime encompasses a sizable range of laser intensities. (2) 92 1, intermediate coupling. (3) 9 2 >> 1, strong coupling.
-
With the photon and electron energies fixed at 0.1 eV and 10 eV, respectively, an intensity of lo1*W/cm2 gives 9 = lo2. Note that even at this intensity the laser field strength is still two orders of magnitude below the nominal atomic field strength of lo0 V/cm. As will be seen explicitly below, the strong-coupling regime is characterized physically by the existence of fluctuations in the field energy which are, on the average, large
42
Leonard Rosenberg
compared with ho;one must account for the effect of a large number of soft photons acting coherently. In the following we confine our discussion to the case where the interaction R’ is ignored completely; this is the lowest order in the modified perturbation expansion discussed above. [It should at least be mentioned that a determination of higher order terms in the expansion, while difficult in general, is of some interest since such corrections involve off-shell scattering information which is not otherwise easily obtainable; see, e.g., Mittleman (1979b).l Thus, we retain only the first term in the expansion (66). Similarly, with H ; set equal to zero, we have
IJI,,,)Jb”), I S D 4 l#dp,)l~lJ,) (67) and the field-induced level shift of the target is ignored. Introducing the field-free scattering amplitude
ISd
+
+
r(e;q’, q) = ( h , I (q’l[v,
+
Vde - ~(o))-lv~llq)lhJ)
(channel indices on the r amplitude are suppressed for simplicity) and making use of the representation (45). we find
with E
=
El,‘,,and q’ = p‘ - (e/c)A&’) - (I q =
P
-
+n
-
n’)hk
(e/c)A,(4) - Ihk
Electron recoil effects lead to corrections of order v/c;these are small but not always negligible in the nonrelativistic domain and are included here for completeness. The extent to which the t amplitude is off the energy shell is measured by the scalar variables
6=E 6’ = E
-
( n + I)ho - ( q 2 / 2 p )-
-
( n + I)hw - ( 4 ’ 2 / 2 p )- el,#
el,
Using Eqs. (69) and the definition (62) we find
6
+
= - ~ ( l S;(&))*
6‘ =
-q’((n
+ 1 - n ’ ) + S;,(+’))
(70)
To continue the analysis of the approximation (68), it will be convenient to discuss the intermediate- and strong-coupling regimes separately. Before doing so, we interpose a comment on the derivation of Eq. (68). The
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
43
assumption that the electric-dipole interaction is a small perturbation on the intermediate-state propagator might be questioned since the projectilefield interaction operator -eE*r, is unbounded. One could argue, on the other hand, that only the region within the range of the scattering potential contributes appreciably to the spatial integrations so that re is effectively bounded by the range of the potential (Feshbach and Yennie, 1%2). To give a more direct argument, we express the amplitude (it will be sufficient to consider the case of potential scattering) as T,,fp8:,,p = (&,p,IT(E)I&p), where = exp( -ge)l+np)and satisfies the operator integral equation
T(E) =
v + VG,(E)T(E)
-
Here Gocan be represented in the form (39) but with t,hnLnp + +,lp. Now the approximation (68) is equivalent to and this version can be verified by showing that the right-hand side provides an approximate solution to the representation of the integral equation (71) in the basis formed by the states {In;p)}. We shall not go through the demonstration here but merely remark that the problem of the unbounded nature of the dipole operator is avoided in this approach; rather, it is a low-frequency argument of the type which will reappear in the following two subsections. The argument explicitly requires that t be nonresonant so that, as indicated earlier, one should anticipate that an approximation based on Eq. (68) will omit certain first-order correction terms in the case of resonant scattering. C. INTERMEDIATECOUPLING The photon energy and the electron-field interaction energy will be taken here to be quantities of first order and their ratio assumed to be of order unity. We now show that the amplitude (68), evaluated to first order, can be expressed in terms of the on-shell amplitude t ( e ,7 ) for scattering in the absence of the field. Let us first observe that the parameters $, and t' are effectively of first order. It is true that the index I ranges over all integers, but contributions to the sum in Eq. (68) corresponding to 111 >> 1 will be negligible due to rapid oscillations of the integrand as 4 and 4' vary between 0 and 2n. The argument would fail if the phase were stationary for some value of I, but this possibility is excluded by the assumption that S; is at most of order unity. Assuming that the off-shell amplitude t is a smooth function of 5 and t',we expand it in a Taylor series about 6 = 5' = 0 and ignore second- and higher order terms. The leading term is the
44
Leonard Rosenberg
on-shell amplitude t(E - (n + I)ho; (q' - q)2). The first-order correction vanish. To see this, note terms, one proportional to 5 and the other to that in the term proportional to 5 we- may write leftmelSp(m)= - i[(d/d+)eft m ] p f S p ( m ) [ I ,
and integrate by parts. The surface term vanishes so that we have effectively replaced 1 by -SL. (An additional contribution coming from the derivative of I with respect to 4 is of higher order and may be dropped.) In a similar way we see that the first-order correction term proportional to 6' makes no contribution. Equation (68) is still fairly complicated since it involves a double integral as well as an infinite sum. Now according to Eqs. (69), and the condition k*A, = 0, we have, to first order, (4' - 9)'
= TO -
2(p'
-
p)*(e/c)[A,(4') - A J 4 ) l
where T~ =
(p' - p
+ (n'
-
n)hk)*
The t amplitude may be expanded in a Taylor series about leading term is seen to be
(72) The
T = T ~ .
2
T , , ~ , , ~ ~ ~ : ~ , , , ,y:+l-n,(fi', ,= a ' ) y l ( b ,a ) t ( E - (n + /)nu. To)
(73)
I=-=
Upon examining the correction term, one finds (Rosenberg, 1981) that in the absence of resonances it is actually of second order and hence may be neglected. Iff is resonant, this second-order correction is promoted to first order. When this correction is added to the leading term (73) one findsfor the case of linear polarization, where A is real and the calculation simplifies somewhat-that the form (73) is retained, but with T~ shifted to (Pi - Pl)*, where pi
=
P - Ihk - pl[q/(p*A)lA
pi
=
p' - (n
+ 1 - n')hk - p(n + 1 - n')[q'/(p'.A)]A
Consider now single-photon emission in the weak-coupling limit of the low-frequency approximation (73). Keeping only the terms corresponding to I = 0 and I = 1 and making use of the approximations (491, we find T,,,,,+I~,:,~,,, zs (j'/2)"r[(p2/2p) +
To] -
(j/2)"f[(p2/2p) +
EY -
hu.
TO]
(74)
This represents an external field version of the low-frequency approximation for single-photon bremsstrahlung (Low, 1958; Feshbach and Yennie,
45
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
1962; Heller, 1968). In the resonant case, we add to Eq. (74) a first-order correction term of the form
AT = ( e / c ) ( 8 ~ c l / w ~ ) ” ~( pp)*X* ’ X
(a/a7){f[(P2/2P)f
EY
- h w , TI -
l(P2/2P)
Eu, T)IJr=r,
The resulting approximation corresponds to that displayed in Eq. (21) of Feshbach and Yennie (1962), specialized to the case considered here of a neutral, infinitely massive target. Those authors suggested that a knowledge of the spontaneous bremsstrahlung amplitude in the neighborhood of a resonance could be used to obtain information on the phase change experienced by the on-shell scattering amplitude as the energy variable passes through the resonance value. With the aid of the laser, useful extensions of investigations of this type to include stimulated bremsstrahlung should be feasible. In the absence of resonances the t amplitude in Eq. (73) may be expanded to first order as
f ( E - ( n + / ) h U , To)
f -
/hw(df/de)
with t and its derivative evaluated at the energy E - nhw. The sum over I may be performed by writing
-/-ylG, a) =
1’“( d 4 / 2 ~ ) e ” ~ e * ~ ~ ( ~ ’ S ; ( + ) 0
and using the closure relation (16). This leads to the alternative version (Rosenberg, 1979a, 1981)
lo 2H
T , W , ~ ;=~ ~ , (d+/27r) exp[i(n’ - n)41 x exp{i[S,(+) - Sp~(+)lMeup(+),7 0 )
(75)
with cup(+) given by Eq. (60). Relativistic versions of Eqs. (73) and (75) have been derived (Rosenberg, 1980d) from the general formulation of the low-frequency approximation developed by Brown and Goble (1968). The total cross section, summed over all final states of the field, is given by the expression
If the low-frequency approximation (75) is used to represent the T matrix the sum over ti’ may be performed, the result then reducing to the classical expression given in Eqs. (63). Tomcarryout the sum one introduces the representation 6(x) = (27~)-’[-=ds exp(ixs) for the energyconserving 6 function in Eq. (76). The sum could now be performed were
Leonard Rosenberg
46
it not for the t i ’ dependence of order, T~
t(e,,,, T
sz (p’ -
P ) ~+
(/I‘
T~
- n)2hk*(p’ - p)
= r(elJp,(p’ - p)? +
~ )
in Eq. (75). We therefore write, to first
(11’ -
n)2hk*(p‘- p) at/th17=,p,
(77)
The replacement n ’ - n + Sb. - S ; is justified, to the requisite accuracy, by an integration by parts; Eq. (75) is then transformed to
x exp{i[S,(4) - Sp44)lMer.p(4)r ~(4))
(78)
with ~ ( 4defined ) as in Eq. (64). At this stage, all of the 12’ dependence is in exponential form, and the sum in Eq. (76) may be carried out using Eq. (16). This leads to the stated result, namely, that the quantum total cross section reduces to the classical value d a , in the low-frequency limit. We may also compare the classical and quantum expressions for the average energy transferred from the field to the electron. The classical expression, as we have seen, is given by the ratio of dU,, defined by Eq. (65), to da,. Proceeding analogously in the quantum case, we determine the average energy lost by the field, call it ( ( n - n ’ ) h w ) ,by defining
dU
( 2 r r ) ‘ ( p / p ) h 2 ~ d 3 p ’-( nn ’ ) h w 6(E,,,,,,
=
- El.np)lTl,,n,p,:r.np12 (79)
n’
Then ( ( n - n ’ ) h w )is obtained as the ratio d U / d a . The sum in Eq. (79) is readily evaluated using the approximation (78), along with an integration by parts. The result is just the classical expression dU, and, since we have already identified da with da,to first order, we have confirmed the equality, to this order, of the classical and quantum expressions for the average energy transferred to the electron. The similarity between these sum rules and those derived by Bloch and Nordsieck (recall the discussion of these sum rules in Section II,A) should be noted. We shall see that the sum rules just obtained for the case of intermediate coupling hold in the strongcoupling regime as well.
D. STRONG COUPLING
If the ratio of the electron-field interaction energy to the photon energy is large compared to unity, fluctuations in the field energy will, on the
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
47
average, greatly exceed h w . As a result, it will no longer be appropriate to treat the off-shell parameters 6 and t', given by Eqs. (70), as first-order quantities. Instead, we may apply a stationary-phase argument. The phases in Eq. (68) are stationary when the conditions I +Sb(+) = Oand ( n + I - n') + Sl,.(c$) = 0 are satisfied. Since these correspond precisely to the conditions 5 = 5' = 0, the evaluation of the r amplitude in Eq. (68) at the points of stationary phase places it on the energy shell. The energy variable is E - (11 + I)hw, but with I replaced by -Sb(c$) (resonances are assumed not to be present here), this becomes
E
-
nhw
+ hwSl,(c$) = ( P 2 ( 4 ) / 2 p )+ G = eu,,(4)
Since the energy variable, in this form, is independent of I, the sum in Eq. (68) may be performed. The result is Eq. (75) so that version of the low-frequency approximation is justified for both intermediate- and strong-coupling regimes. In evaluating the total cross section we use the approximation (75) in Eq. (76). The replacement n ' - n + S ; , - Sl, in the expression (77) for ther amplitude is now justified by the stationary phase argument. [There are values of n' for which 'the phase in Eq. (75) is not stationary for any 4 in the range of integration, but such terms make a negligible contribution to the sum over photon states.] The transition matrix may then be taken to be of the form (78) and the derivations of the sum rules for the total cross section and the average energy transferred to the electron go through as described above for the case of intermediate coupling. The results may be summarized by stating the following external field version of the BlochNordsieck theorem: (1) In the static, or extreme strong-coupling limit, where the frequency approaches zero with the electric field strength fixed, the average number of photons emitted or absorbed approaches infinity. This follows from the fact that for any finite value of n' - n the amplitude (75) vanishes due to the increasingly rapid oscillations of the integrand as the static limit is approached. (2) The total probability for scattering, independent of the number of photons emitted or absorbed, can be obtained from a knowledge of the cross section appropriate to scattering in the absence of the radiation field. The field affects the kinematics of the collision in a manner which allows for a classical interpretation of the interaction of the electron with the field. (3) While the average number of photons emitted or absorbed is infinite in the static limit, the energy transferred between the electron and the field is finite and calculable from a classical description of the electron-field
Leonard Rosenberg
48
interaction, with the collision assumed to take place instantaneously and without influence from the field.
If we ignore electron-recoil effects of order p / p c and specialize to the case of linear polarization, in which case &(4) = &A cos 4, the condition that the phase in Eq. (75) be stationary takes the form ( n’ - n ) h o
=
-(e/pc)[(p’ - p) *&A
COS(~,,)]
With cos 4s,,thus determined, we have
F’(4s,)= p + A n ’
-
n)hoA/[A*(p‘
-
p)]
and eL,p(&p) = [Pz(&,,)/2p]+ E,. . The momentum-transfer variable reduces to (p’ - p)‘ in the no-recoil approximation. Equation (75) then becomes T,,.,,.p,.wlp = -’l~(XMel,p(4sP), (P‘ - P)*) $1
(80)
with X given by Eq. (48). This is the result of Kroll and Watson (1973) generalized to the case of scattering by an atomic target. The approximation (80) can also be justified for the intermediate-coupling regime (Mittleman, 1980). An approximation of the strong-coupling type can be applied to the multiphoton ionization problem as formulated in Section IV,A. Let us examine the lowest order approximation, Eq. (47), for the bound-free transition amplitude. Since we are ignoring contributions from the modified interaction H ’ , we adopt the approximation (67) for the final state. Using the appropriate version of Eq. ( 4 9 , we find
Tj&
=
1;
( d 4 / 2 ~ )exp[-i(no -
n’)41 exp[-iS,,(4)]Fp,(q(4))
(81)
where F,,(q)
(ql (b,.,lVfi,IB)
q(4) = p‘ - (e/c)A,(4) - (no - n ’ ) h k Since the energy absorbed by the negative ion must exceed the electron affinity - 8, we must have no - 12’ >> 1 in the low-frequency limit. This suggests an approximate evaluation of the integral in Eq. @I), based on the method on steepest descents. The stationary phase condition is no - n ’ + SL, = 0. For those values of 4 thus determined (they are complex in the present case), one finds that q 2 ( 4 ) / 2 p= - E ” , . With q satisfying this condition, the function Fp’(q) is determined from a knowledge of the asymptotic normalization of the bound-state wave function of the negative ion (Goldberger and Watson, 1964). This normalization factor can be re-
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
49
lated to the residue of the bound state pole in the physical field-free scattering amplitude. A detailed analysis of the approximation (81) along the lines just indicated has been carried out by a number of authors (Keldysh, 1965; Nikishov and Ritus, 1966, Perelomov ef al., 1966). The expression for the total ionization probability obtained in this way has a very simple physical interpretation. The result is identical to that which would be obtained by calculating the probability for ionization by a field E, = ,&J sin of for t fixed, this calculation being performed using the tunneling approximation for ionization by a static field (Oppenheimer, 1928). The ionization probability thus obtained is then averaged over a period. It is interesting to note the similarity between this adiabatic picture of the ionization process and that which emerges from the sum rules for free-free transition probabilities.
VI. Concluding Remarks The emphasis placed on low-frequency approximations in this review reflects the fact that theoretical progress to date has been largely restricted to this regime. It is in some sense fortunate that our understanding of the dynamics of the scattering process is greatest in the low-frequency domain, where, for a given field strength, the effective coupling is largest and the interesting multiphoton effects are most prominent. Additional interest is attached to the low-frequency approximation since it provides insight into the study of the connection between the classical and quantum descriptions of the particle-field interaction. This connection is most apparent in the form taken by the sum rules discussed in Section V. One has also been able to clarify, in the study of low-frequency approximations, the relationship which exists between the theory of scattering in an external field and the treatment of spontaneous infrared radiation. Here again the relationship shows up most clearly in the sum rules. In all of these considerations special care must be given to the case of resonant scattering. It seems likely that in this case particularly the external field can serve as a probe, revealing details of the scattering process not readily available by other means. It is not difficult to identify deficiencies and limitations in the theoretical picture developed thus far. One of the most glaring is the lack of a practical and generally applicable procedure for dealing with targets which carry a net charge. “Coulomb problems” also arise in the study of impact ionization in the presence of the external field. Even when the initial electron energy lies below the ionization threshold, the target can be
50
Leonard Rosenberg
ionized by the field in the precollision or postcollision stages; one requires, strictly speaking, a theory of scattering by an unstable target. It should also be emphasized that much of the theoretical work has been based on an oversimplified description of the laser field which precludes detailed comparison with experimental results. Finally, there is the sheer complexity of the calculational problem which will demand a considerable amount of ingenuity in the development of reliable approximation techniques.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported in part by the Office of Naval Research under Contract No. N00014-76-C-0317 and by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. PHY-7910413.1
am indebted to Dr. R. Shakeshaft for reading the manuscript and for making a number of useful comments and suggestions.
REFERENCES Agostini, P., Fabre, F., Petite, G., Mainfray, G., and Rahman, N. K . (1979). Phys. Rev. Lett. 42, 1127. Andrick, D. (1980). Proc. I t i t . Conf. Pltys. Electron. A t . Collisions, I l t h . 1979 p. 697. Andrick, D., and Langhans, L. (1978). J. Pltys. B 11, 2355. Baneji, J., and Mittleman, M. H. (1981). J. Phys. B 14, 3717. Baym, G. (l%9). “Lectures on Quantum Mechanics,” Chapter 13. Benjamin, New York. Bebb, H. B., and Gold, A. (1966). Phys. Re\*. 143, 1. Bhaskar, N. D., Jadusziliwer, B., and Bederson, B. (1977). Pkys. Rev. L e f t . 38, 14. Bialynicki-Birula, I. (1977). Actu P / i y s . Austriacu. SuppI. 18, I11. Bialynicki-Birula, I., and Bialynicka-Birula, Z. (1976). Phys. Re\*. A 14, 1101. Bjorken, J. D., and Drell, S. D. (1965). “Relativistic Quantum Fields.” p. 203. McGrawHill, New York. Blanchard, P. (1969). Commrrn. Moth. Phys. 15, 156. Bloch, F., and Nordsieck, A. (1937). Phys. Re\,. 52, 54. Brandi, H. S., Koiller, B., Lins d e Barros, H. G. P., Miranda, L. C. M., and Castro, J. J. (1978). Phys. R e ) , .A 17, 1900. Brown, L . S., and Goble, R. L. (1968). Pliys. Rev. 173, 1505. Brown, L. S., and Kibble, T. W. B. (1964). Pliys. Rev. 133, A705. Brueckner, K. A., and Jorna, S. (1974). Rev. Mod. Pl?ys. 46, 325. Bunkin, S . V.,and Fedorov, M. V. (1966). Soit. P h y s . 4 E T P (Engl. Transl.) 22, 884. Cavaliere, P.,Ferrante, G., and Leone, C. (1980). J . Pltys. B 13, 4495. Combe, P., Mourre, E., and Richard, Y. L. (1975). Cornmuti. Math. Phys. 43, 161. Conneely, M. J., and Geltman, S. (1981). J. Pltys. B 14, 4847. Damburg, R. J . , and Kolosov, V. V. (1978). J . P h y s . B 11, 1921. Deguchi, K., Taylor, H. S . , and Yaris, R. (1979). J . Phys. B 12, 613.
ELECTRON-ATOM SCATTERING IN A RADIATION FIELD
51
DeVries, P. L., Lam, K. S.,and George, T. F. (1980).Proc. fnr. Cod. Electron. A t . Collisions. Ilth, 1979 p. 683. Eberly, J. (1%7). Prog. Opt. 7, 361. Faddeev, L. D. (1961). Sov. Phys.-JETP (Engl. Transl.) 12, 1014. Feshbach, H. (1958). Ann. Phvs. ( N .Y . ) 5 , 357. Feshbach, H., and Yennie, D. R. (1%2). Nucl. Phys. 37, 150. Gavrila, M., and Van der Weil, M. (1978). Comments A t . Mol. Phys. 8, 1. Geltman, S . (1977). J . Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 82, 173. Gersten, J., and Mittleman, M. H. (1976a). Phys. Rev. A 13, 123. Gersten, J., and Mittleman, M. H. (1976b). In “Electron and Photon Interactions with Atoms” (H. Kleinpoppen and M. R. C. McDowell, eds.), p. 553. Plenum, New York. Glauber, R. J. (1963). Phys. Rev. 131, 2766. Goldberger, M. L., and Watson, K. M. (1964). “Collision Theory.” Wiley, New York. Gopert-Mayer, M. (1931).Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) [51 9, 273. Hahn, L., and Hertel, I. V. (1972).J . Phys. B 5, 1995. Heller, L. (1968). Phys. Rev. 174, 1580. Henneberger, W. C. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 16, 1379. Hertel, I. V., and Stoll, W. (1977). Adv. At. Mol. Phys. 13, 113. Jackson, J. D. (1975). “Classical Electrodynamics,” 2nd ed. Wiley, New York. Jain, M., and Tzoar, N. (1978). Phys. Rev. A 18,538. Jauch, J. M., and Rohrlich, F. (1976). “The Theory of Photons and Electrons,” Suppls. S3 and S4. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. Johnston, R. R. (1%7). J . Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer 7, 815. Jung, C. (1979). Phys. Rev. A 20, 1585. Jung, C. (1980). Phys. Rev. A 21, 408. Jung, C., and Kriiger, H. (1978).Z . Phys. A 287, 7. Jung, C., and Taylor, H. S . (1981). Phys. Rev. A 23, 1115. Keldysh, L. V. (1%5). Sov. Phys.-JETP (Engl. Transl.) 20, 1307. Kelsey, E. J., and Rosenberg, L. (1979). Phys. Rev. A 19, 756. Kovarskii, V. A., and Perel’man, N. F. (1972). Sov. Phys.-JETP (Engl. Trans/.) 34, 738. Kroll, N. M., and Watson, K. M. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 8, 804. Kriiger, H., and Jung, C. (1978).Phys. Rev. A 17, 1706. Kriiger, H., and Schulz, M. (1976). J . Phys. B 9, 1899. Lambropoulos, P.(1976). Adv. A t . Mol. Phys. 12, 87. Landau, L. D., and Lifshitz, E. M. (1%2). “The Classical Theory of Fields,” 2nd ed. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts. Langendam, P. J. K., and Van der Weil, M. J. (1978). J . Phys. B 11, 3603. Langhans, L. (1978).J . Phys. B 11, 2361. Leubner, C. (1981). Phys. Rev. A 23, 2877. Lompre, L. A., Mainfray, G., Manus, G., and Farkas, Gy. (1979). Phys. Rev. Lett. 43, 1243. Low, F. E. (1958).Phys. Rev. 110, 974. Mitter, H. (1975).Acta Phys. Austriaca, Suppl. 14, 397. Mittleman, M. H. (1976). Phys. Rev. A 14, 1338. Mittleman, M. H. (1978).Phys. Rev. A 18, 685. Mittleman, M. H. (1979a).Phys. Rev. A 19, 99. Mittleman, M. H. (1979b). Phys. Rev. A 19, 134. Mittleman, M. H. (1979~).Phys. Rev. A 20, 1%5. Mittleman, M. H. (1979d).J . Phys. B 12, 1781. Mittleman, M. H. (1980). Phys. Rev. A 21, 79. Mower, L. (1%6). Phys. Rev. 142, 799.
52
Leonard Rosenberg
Neville, R. A., and Rohrlich, F. (1971). P h y s . Re\*. D 3, 1692. Nikishov, A. I., and Ritus, V. I. (1964). Sort. Phys.-JETP ( B i g / . Trunsl.) 19, 529. Nikishov, A. I., and Ritus, V. I. (1%6). Sov. Phys.-JETP ( E n p l . T r a n s / . )23, 168. Nordsieck, A. (1937). Phys. Rev. 52, 59. Oppenheimer, J. R. (1928). Phys. Rev. 31, 66. Perel’man, N. F., and Kovarskii, V. A. (1973). Sov. Phvs.-J€TP (Engl. Trans/.) 36, 436. Perelomov, A. M., Popov, V. S., and Terent’ev, M. V. (1966). Sov. Phys.-JETP (EnpI. Trans/.) 23, 924. Power, E. A., and Zienau, S. (1959). Philos. Trcrns. R . Soc. London, Ser. A 251, 427. PrugoveEki, E., and Tip, A. (1974). J . Phys. A 7, 586. Reiss, H. R. (1%2). J . Math. Phys. 3, 59. Reiss, H. R. (1980a). Phys. Rev. A 22, 770. Reiss, H. R. (1980b). Phys. Rev. A 22, 1786. Rosenberg, L. (1977). Phys. Re\,. A 16, 1941. Rosenberg, L. (1978). Phys. Rev. A 18, 2557. Rosenberg, L. (1979a). Phys. Rev. A 20, 275. Rosenberg, L. (1979b). Phys. Rev. A 20, 457. Rosenberg, L. (1979~).Phys. Re,,. A 20, 1352. Rosenberg, L. (1980a). Phys. Rcw. A 21, 157. Rosenberg, L. (1980b). Phys. Reif. A 21, 1939. Rosenberg, L. (1980~).Phys. Rev. A 22, 2485. Rosenberg, L. (198Od). Phys. Rev. D 22, 527. Rosenberg, L. (1981). Phys. Rev. A 23, 2283. Sachs, R. G., and Austern, N. (1951). Phys. Rev. 81, 705. Sargent, M., 111, Scully, M. O., and Lamb, W. E.. Jr. (1974). “Laser Physics,” App. H . Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts. Schiff, L. I. (I%@. “Quantum Mechanics,” 3rd ed. McGraw-Hill, New York. Schrodinger, E. (1926). NNtrtrw,isuenschafteri 14, 664. Shirley, J. H. (1965). Phys. Rev. B 138, 979. Volkov, D. M. (1935). Z. Phys. 94, 250. Weingartshofer, A., Holmes, J. K., Caudle, G., Clarke, E. M., and Kriiger, H. (1977).Phys. Rev. LCW. 39, 269. Weingartshofer, A., Clarke, E. M., Holmes, J. K., and Jung, C. (1979). Phys. Re\*. A 19, 237 I. Zeldovich, B. (1973). So\*. Phys.-Vsp. (EnpI. Trans/.) 16, 427. Zoller, P. (1980). J. Phys. B 13, L49.
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS,VOL. 18
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS TALBERT S . STEIN and WALTER E. KAUPPILA Department of Physics and Astronomy Wuyrie State University Detroit, Michigan
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Positron-Beam Production . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Total Cross-Section Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Total Cross-Section Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Inert Gases at Low Energies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Inert Gases at Intermediate Energies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I Introduction
11 Experimental Techniques for Total Cross-Section Measurements
C. Positron and Electron Comparisons for the Inert Gases . . . . . . D. Tests of the Sum Rule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Molecular Gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Differential Scattering Cross Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Inelastic Scattering Investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Positronium Formation Cross Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Excitation and Ionization Cross Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Resonance Searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Possible Future Directions for Positron Scattering Experiments . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
53 55 55
60 64 64 76 79 80 82 84 86 86 89 91 92 93
I. Introduction Although the first electron-atom total cross section (QT) measurements were reported in the early 1920s (Ramsauer, 1921a), and the positron has been known to exist since the early 1930s (Anderson, 1933),there were no direct measurements of positron-atom total cross sections until the early 1970s (Costello et a f . , 1972a). One of the main obstacles to performing such measurements earlier was the difficulty of producing a sufficiently intense e+ beam of well-defined low energy. Positron-atom scattering experiments are of interest because they involve interactions of antimatter with matter, and also because they can help provide a better understanding of the scattering of electrons by atoms and molecules, a subject of great importance to many different fields of 53 Copyright @ 1982 by Academic Press, Lnc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003818-8
54
Talberr S. Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
science and technology such as plasma physics, laser development, gaseous electronics, astrophysics, and studies of the earth’s upper atmosphere. During the past decade, additional interest in positron-atom (molecule) collisions has been stimulated by the discoveries of 0.51 MeV e + annihilation gamma rays coming from solar flares (Chupper d., 1973) and from the direction of the center of our galaxy (Leventhal et nl., 1978). Such annihilation gamma rays can provide considerable information on the type of environment which exists at the site of their origin if sufficient information can be obtained on the ways in which positrons interact with H, H2, and other atoms and molecules of astrophysical interest (Crannell et d., 1976; Bussard et d.. 1979). Comparisons between e+-atom (molecule) and e--atom (molecule) scattering reveal some interesting differences and similarities. The static interaction (associated with the Coulomb field of the undistorted atom) is attractive for electrons and repulsive for positrons, while the polarization interaction (resulting from the distortion of the atom by the passing charged projectile) is attractive for both projectiles. The exchange interaction contributes to e- scattering (due to the indistinguishability of the projectile and electrons in the target atoms) but does not play a role in e+ scattering. The combined effect of the static and polarization interactions is that they add to each other in e- scattering, whereas there is a tendency toward cancellation in e + scattering. This results in smaller total scattering cross sections, in general, for positrons than for electrons at low energies. As the projectile energy is increased, the polarization and exchange interactions eventually become negligible compared with the static interaction (which has the same magnitude for positrons and electrons). This results in a merging of the corresponding e+ and e- scattering cross sections at sufficiently high projectile energies. Two scattering processes which occur for positrons (but not for electrons) are annihilation and positronium (Ps) formation (real and virtual). Annihilation is not expected (Massey, 1976) to be a significant effect at the energies which have been used in e + scattering experiments (>0.2 eV). On the other hand, Ps formation has been found to be an important factor in e+-gas collision studies. A compact survey of the e+-gas scattering measurements reported during the first decade of activity in this area is provided in Tables IA and IB. Total scattering cross sections have been measured for the inert gases and a variety of molecules by several different groups. However, Table IA indicates that experimental areas beyond QT measurements, such as differential cross sections, elastic, excitation, ionization, and Ps-formation cross sections, and searches for resonances (temporary bound states) are in very early stages of exploration. Positron scattering experiments have been discussed in two recent review articles (Griffith and Heyland, 1978;
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
55
Griffith, 1979) and in recent progress reports (Kauppila and Stein, 1982; Stein and Kauppila, 1982),but the field is evolving sufficiently rapidly that there are several different experiments which have been reported since the review articles were written. Our main goals in writing this article are to ( I ) point out what we feel are the most significant developments in the first decade of e+-gas scattering experiments, (2) search for some consistent patterns in the experimental results in cases where several different groups have investigated the same collision processes, (3) present some puzzling questions raised by the new generation of experiments which go beyond QT measurements, and (4) indicate some experimental areas of e+-gas scattering which we feel would be interesting and feasible to investigate in the near future.
11. Experimental Techniques for Total Cross-Section Measurements A. POSITRON-BEAM PRODUCTION
The difficulty and expense of producing intense, monochromatic e+ beams stands in sharp contrast to the relative ease with which one can produce such beams of electrons. Table I1 summarizes the characteristics of the e+ beams used by various groups that have reported QT measurements. The experiment of Costello et d.(1972a) utilized a %-MeV electron linear accelerator to produce positrons by pair production (PP). All of the other laboratories listed in Table I1 use commercially available 22Naas e+ sources, except for the Detroit group, which uses the proton beam of a 4.75-MeV Van de G r a d accelerator to produce an llC e+ source by the reaction “B(p, n)”C (Stein et d.,1974). A variety of moderators used in either a backscattering ( B ) or transmission ( T ) mode, have been found to yield low-energy positrons with relatively narrow energy distributions when exposed to the high-energy, broad energy-width fluxes resulting from p+ decay. Two properties of moderators which are of particular interest in e+ scattering experiments are ( I ) the energy width of the emitted slow e+ energy distribution, AEFWH”(“full width at half-maximum”), and (2) the “conversion efficiency” ( 6 ) defined as the ratio of the slow e+ emission rate of the moderator to the total rate of positron production by the radioactive source. For the moderators which have been used in e+-gas scattering experiments, E ranges from less than lo-’, in the case of the Au-plated mica transmission moderator used by Jaduszliwer et al. (1972) to lop5 in the
TABLE IA A
Gas
SURVEY OF THE
Energy range (eV) ~
He
0.3-1000
Ne
0.25-1000
Ar
0.4-1000
Kr
REPORTED POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING MEASUREMENTS
Gas
Groupsa
~
~
Groups"
~
G I , T I , LI, L2, T2, T4, L3, T5,SI, L7, S2, Al, D3, BI, A3, L9, B2, D5 L2, L3, T3, T6, L7, D3, S3, A3, L9, B2, D5 L1, L2, L3, T3, T6, DI, L7, S3, L9, A4, B2, D5 L2, L3, L7, D4, B2, D6
0.35-960
Energy range (eV)
Xe H2 D2
Nz 0,
co
COP CHI
L3, D4, A4, 8 2 , D6 L4, D2, L8, LIO, D8 L4 L4, D2, LIO, S4, D8 L6, L10 L4 L6, D2, L10, D8 L10
0.35-800 1-600 4-400 0.5-1000 2-600 2-400 0.5-600 19-600
I
Differentid cross sections
Gas
Energy range (eV)
Range of angles
Group
Ar
2.2-8.7
20-60"
A2
Gas
Energy range (eV)
He Ar
14-34 7- I8
Energy range (eV)
Gas
4.5-20 4-18
Gas
Energy range (eV)
Group
Total inelastic cross sections
50-170
He
L5
Partictl excitation plus ionization cross sections
23-50 20-40 15-40
He Ne Ar
A5, A6 A6 A6
Resonctnce searches ~~
~~
Gas
Energy ranges (eV)
Ar
8.5-9.5, 11.0-12.0 ~~~
~~
Energy increments (eV)
Beam-energy width (eV)
Group
0.025
D7
~~
Groups are listed in chronological order. See Table IB for an explanation of researchgroup codes and reference codes.
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
57
TABLE IB KEYT O RESEARCH GROUPS A N D REFERENCES LISTED I N T A B L E1A
Code
Research group
A
University of Texas at Arlington
B
University of Bielefeld Wayne State University (Detroit)
D
G
L
Gulf Energy and Environment, Inc. University College London
Reference code A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6
B1
B2 DI D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8 GI
LI L2 L3 L4
L5 L6 L7 L8 L9 L10 LI 1 S
T
University College of Swansea University of Toronto
S1
s2 s3 s4 TI T2 T3 T4 T5 T6
Reference Burciaga et [ I / . (1977) Coleman and McNutt (1979) Coleman et cil. (1979) Coleman et n / . (1980a) Coleman and Hutton (1980) Coleman er ril. (1981) Wilson (1978) Sinapius el id. (1980) Kauppila et a / . (1976a) Kauppila et cil. ( I977a) Stein et a / . (1978) Dababneh el c d . (1980) Kauppila et ril. (1981a) Kauppila et ril. ( I98 1b) Stein ef [ I / . (1981) Hoffman er ril. (1982) CosteUo et cil. (1972a)
Canter et etl. (1972) Canter et ril. (1973) Canter et N I . (1974a) Coleman er rr/. (1974) Coleman et a / . (l975b) Coleman et a/. ( 1 9 7 5 ~ ) Coleman er e l / . (1976a) Griffith and Heyland (1978) Griffith er ( I / . (1979a) Charlton et ril. (1980b) Charlton er ril. (1980~) Dutton et cil. (1975) Brenton et ril. (1977) Brenton er 01. (1978) Dutton et c r / . (1981) Jaduszliwer et a / . (1972) Jaduszliwer and Paul (1973) Jaduszliwer and Paul (1974a) Jaduszliwer and Paul (1974b) Jaduszliwer et a / . (1975) Tsai et a/. (1976)
TABLE I1 POSITRON-BEAM CHARACTERISTICS FOR TOTALCROSS-SECTION EXPERIMENTS
Laboratory"
Source
Moderator*
Gulf London Toronto Swansea Detroit Texas Bielefeld
PP 22Na '%a 22Na "C 22Na 22Na
T: AulAI B: MgO/Au T Admica' B: MgOIAu T Boron B: MgOIss B: Cu(0FHC)
(I
Energy analysis
AEFWHM
TOF TOF !WE
1-2
4
0.14E
ER
TOF TOF
(eV)
-1
-1 co.1
1.5 0.4 at 6 eV
References can be found in Table IB. T refers t o transmission, B t o backscattering, Au/Al to gold over aluminum, etc. Other moderators used include T: Ni, B: MgO/brass, B: MgO/Au.
Energy range (eV) 1-26 2-1000 4-300
13-1000 0.3-800 2-50 1-6
I0
Scattering region Ell
4 II
4 B ,I
4, -FF
Detector
(no./ sec)
2Y CEM 2Y 2Y CEM
Few 100 Few
y.
Y CEM
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
59
case of the MgO-coated Au “venetian blind” backscattering moderator was used by Canter et al. (1972). A conversion efficiency of 3 x reported for a MgO-coated Au backscattering moderator by Canter et al. (1974b) in an experiment which detected efficient Ps formation on various solid surfaces. Although the MgO-coated Au moderator has a relatively high conversion efficiency, it has the disadvantage of emitting a rather broad e+ energy distribution (AEFWHM 2= 1-2 eV) possibly due to the charging of the insulating powder grains. The existence of a narrow, low-energy peak in the e+ energy spectrum emitted by a successful moderator was attributed in the early stages of moderator development (Costello et al., 1972b; Tong, 1972) to the thermalization of high-energy positrons in the moderator, and their subsequent ejection from the surface due to a “negative” work function for positrons in certain metals. However, typical energy widths of the lowenergy e+ peaks observed for the first few successful moderators were relatively broad (-1 eV), until Stein et al. (1975) observed a very narrow energy width (AEFWHM < 0.1 eV), low-energy peak in the energy spectrum of positrons emitted from their boron moderator which did, in fact, appear to be consistent with a thermal energy distribution at room temperature. Throughout the development of the moderators listed in Table 11, investigators have recognized that the conversion efficiencies of various moderators were sensitive to their surface conditions, but none of the experiments referred to in Table I1 was done with well-characterized surfaces. In the first experiment using atomically clean (submonolayer contaminated surfaces) in an ultrahigh vacuum (-1O-lO Torr), Mills et al. (1978) demonstrated that positrons implanted in a clean single-crystal target can diffuse back to the surface and be emitted as Ps or as free positrons. The positrons are emitted predominantly in a forward lobe (Murray and Mills, 1980), with a maximum energy interpreted as the positron negative work function of the surface (Murray et al., 1980). These observations by Mills and co-workers have led to the fabrication of new e+ moderators with very high conversion efficiencies and narrow energy widths. Mills (1980) has found that a clean single-crystal Cu( 11 1) moderator which has been exposed to H2S in situ, and cooled to 100 K, combined with a low self~ source has an efficiency of 1.5 x the highest absorption 5 s Ce+ reported efficiency for an e+ moderator. The narrowest energy width ( < O . 1 eV) achieved by Mills et al. (1978) with their single-crystal Al( 100) moderator is about the same as that achieved by Stein et al. (1975) with their boron-moderated “C source. The single-crystal moderators referred to above may be somewhat difficult to adapt to e+-gas scattering experiments, since the conversion efficiencies of such moderators may be affected by their exposure to thc
60
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
various target gases admitted to the scattering region. There have been some recent advances in moderator technology in moderate vacuums (-lo-’ Torr) which could also be useful in future e+-gas scattering experiments. As an example, Dale et a / . (1980) find that a tungsten vane moderator (prepared by heating to 2200°C in a vacuum) is stable in air, and if used with a better geometry (a larger solid angle for stopping fast positrons), the estimated conversion efficiency would be 0.7 x However, its energy width is relatively broad (1-2 eV). As a result of the relatively low intensities of the e + beams used in scattering experiments, most groups use a rather long scattering region and an axial magnetic field (sometimes curved) to transport the e+ beam through that region. The laboratories (listed in Table 11) which do not use an axial magnetic field in the scattering region are Swansea, where the positrons move along a circular path in a transverse magnetic field (a Ramsauer type of system), and Bielefeld, where the positrons move in a field-free (FF) scattering region (except for a single axial magnetic focusing lens). For energy-analysis of the e+ beams, the Gulf, London, Texas, and Bielefeld groups use time of flight (TOF), Toronto uses a 90” electrostatic analyzer ( W E ) , Swansea uses a transverse magnetic field with beamdefining apertures (BJ, and Detroit uses a retarding electrostatic field (I&). In all cases except for Toronto, the method of energy analysis also provides some discrimination against the detection of scattered positrons. The e+ energies used in Q T measurements range from 0.3 eV at Detroit to of the slow 1000 eV at Swansea and London. The energy widths, AEFWHM, e + beams used in scattering experiments are typically about 1 eV or more, except for the Detroit energy width of less than 0.1 eV. Three methods used for detecting positrons are to ( I ) observe the two coincident annihilation gamma rays (2y) with two NaI scintillation counters, (2) observe one or both annihilation gamma rays (y) with a single NaI well counter, and (3) use a Channeltron electron multiplier (CEM). The detected primary beam currents (Z,) range from less than l/sec to more than 1OO/sec.
B. TOTALCROSS-SECTION EXPERIMENTS The basic experimental method used by all of the groups which have measured QT is to study the attenuation of the e+ beam as it passes through a gas scattering region. Under “ideal” experimental conditions, QT can be obtained from the expression
I =
~ o ~ ~ - ’ ~ L Q ~
(1)
61
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
where lo is the detected beam intensity with no gas in the scattering region,l is the detected beam intensity with gas of number densityn in the scattering region, and L is the path length of the e+ beam through the scattering region. The Bielefeld and Detroit systems (shown in Figs. 1 and 2, respectively) represent two significantly different experimental approaches to measuring QT. However, they share a feature that distinguishes them from the other experiments listed in Table 11; namely, in each case, absolute total cross sections for positrons and electrons have been measured in the same apparatus, using the same technique. In the Bielefeld experiment (Sinapius et a / . , 1980) the fast positrons from a 22Na source strike an OFHC Cu tube moderator used in a backscattering mode, yielding slow positrons and secondary electrons, which are used for the respective QT measurements. When a fast positron passes through a thin scintillator foil on its way to the Cu moderator, light is emitted which, when detected by a photomultiplier tube (PMT), provides one of the timing marks needed for the TOF measurement. A second timing mark is provided by the detection of the projectiles (with a CEM) which have traveled through the straight, approximately field-free scattering region. The use of a weak magnetic lens helps to focus divergent projectiles through the exit aperture without increasing their path length in the scattering region by more than 3%. The pressure in the scattering region is measured by an ionization gauge. Sinapius et 01. (1980) have recognized the need to apply an average 18% downward correction to the e+-He measurements of Wilson (1978) due to scattering in the vicinities of the moderator and the accelerating exit lens. In the Detroit experiments (Kauppila et al., 1977b), the electrons for the e- QT measurements are produced by a type-B Philips cathode, which
,Scattering reglon
Extraction grldr 1 IDeflectlon Dhtes
-
I
\ Moderator
Source
/
/
Magnetic rhleld
Exlt
Ion gauge -c
I
lenr
FIG. I . Bielefeld experimental setup for measuring total scattering cross sections. (From Wilson, 1978.)
62
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
Magnetic Shielding
limating Apertures
Retarding Element Channeltron
Detector
FIG. 2. Detroit experimental setup for measuring total scattenng cross sections. (From Kauppila el crl , 1976a.)
replaces the boron target used to generate the positrons for the e+ QT measurements. The gas number density in the scattering region is determined from pressure and temperature measurements using a capacitance manometer (MKS Baratron) and thermocouples, respectively. The increase in the effective path length of projectiles due to spiraling in the axial magnetic field of the scattering region has been estimated to be a maximum of 1% (Kauppila et nl., 1977b). The Detroit group has also checked for the possibility that the target gases being studied could directly affect e+ or e- emission from the respective sources and have found no measurable direct effects of this type with the gases for which Detroit has reported QT values.
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
63
In total cross-section experiments, care must be taken to minimize the number of scattered positrons which reach the detector, since inadequate discrimination against scattered positrons during the measurement of I [in Eq. ( l ) ] will result in measured cross sections being too low. In TOF experiments, some discrimination against scattered positrons is provided by their longer flight times compared with unscattered positrons. The angular discrimination achieved by the TOF method depends on the geometry of the experiment (e.g., the length of the scattering region and the distance between the scattering region and the detector), the beam energy and energy width, and the timing resolution of the electronics. Griffith et ul. (1978) in a reassessment of the angular discrimination capabilities of the original London total scattering system, have determined that an additional source of angular discrimination arises from the fact that appreciably stronger axial magnetic fields exist in their positron-detection region than in the major portion of their scattering region. This arrangement of magnetic fields results in a “magnetic reflection” of positrons scattered at sufficiently.large angles in the forward direction. Griffith et al. (1978) estimate that at 2 eV, the experiment of Canter et al. (1972) was able to discriminate against all positrons elastically scattered at angles greater than lo”, rather than the estimate by Canter et al. (1973) of 40-55”. We suspect that the recent reassessment by Griffith et al. (1978) is incomplete due to their neglect of the effect of positrons which scatter in their 150mm-long detector magnetic field region (refer to Fig. 1 of Coleman et al., 1973), which accounts for more than 15% of the total length of their scattering region. Since positrons scattered in the detector region are very close to the detector, the ability of their TOF approach to discriminate against such scattered positrons would be significantly worse, and could appreciably degrade their overall angular discrimination. The Texas group (Coleman et d.,1980a) has estimated an upper limit of the angular discrimination of their TOF system to be about 20”. In non-TOF experiments, there are several different techniques which have been used to discriminate against scattered positrons. One method is to use a retarding electrostatic field between the scattering region and the detector which serves as a potential “hill” for the axial energy of the positrons. If the retarding potential is set sufficiently close to the actual positron beam energy, it is possible to have 100% discrimination against inelastic scattering for many target atoms (e.g., the inert gases) and partial discrimination against small-angle elastic scattering, depending on the retarding field and the e+ beam energy distribution. Another method of discriminating against scattered positrons is to use a well-collimated e+ beam that must pass through a small aperture between the scattering region and the detector. The geometry of the beam and exit aperture will
64
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kauppila
then provide discrimination against small-angle scattering. The Toronto group (Jaduszliwer and Paul, 1973) relied on the use of collimators in their beam scattering region, variations in their axial magnetic field strength, and Monte Carlo calculations to compensate for small-angle elastic scattering, and the use of a retarding field to discriminate against inelastically scattered positrons. The group at Swansea (Brenton et NI., 1977) used a retarding field and beam-collimating apertures for discrimination in their Ramsauer-type experiment. Although the Bielefeld group (Sinapius ef d., 1980) used TOF for analyzing their beam energy, they employed the geometrical approach (i.e., a collimated beam with a small exit aperture) to obtain an angular discrimination estimated to be 7". The ability of the Detroit group to discriminate against scattered positrons by using a retarding field and well-defined e+ beam with a small exit aperture from the scattering region has recently been analyzed by Kauppila et ( I / . (1981a). Since their retarding potentials are generally within a few tenths of a volt of their e + beam energy for energies less than 100 eV and within a few volts for energies up to 800 eV, the Detroit group should have 100% discrimination against inelastic scattering for the inert gases where the minimum energy lost by inelastically scattered positrons is more than 5 eV. For e+energies from 1 to 20 eV, Dababneher 01. (1980) have estimated angular discriminations of 15-20" for their Kr and Xe measurements, while for energies above 100 eV, Kauppilaer al. (1981a) estimate angular discriminations of less than lo". The Detroit group (Kauppilaet a/., 1981a) obtains better angular discriminations (typically 5" for all energies) for their recent e- measurements than for their e+ measurements at the same energy in the same apparatus because the more intense (by a factor of 10 or more), and nondecaying e- beams permit better overall tuning conditions to be achieved. However, the earlier Detroit low-energy e- measurements (for He and Ar by Kauppila et d . , 1976a, 1977b) were made with tuning conditions similar to those used for the low-energy positron work of Dababneh et al. (1980) and should have similar angular discriminations.
111. Total Cross-Section Results A. INERT GASESAT Low ENERGIES
The QT measurements for e+-He collisions are shown in Fig. 3, along with the results of several theoretical calculations. All of these measurements are absolute except the normalized ( n ) values of Sinapius el d.
65
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
o ~ ~ ' " 5 ' ' " ' ' 10" ' " ' ' 15" "
20
Positron Energy (eV)
F I G .3. Low-energy e+-He total cross-section measurements (symbols) and theoretical calculations (curves). The thresholds for inelastic processes are indicated by the labeled arrows: "n" refers to normalized results; only the name of the lead author for each set of reported results is shown in the figure [e.g., Coleman (1979) refers to Coleman t'i NI. (1979).1 (Unless otherwise specified, the same conventions will be used in all of the following figures.) (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
(1980). The values reported by Sinapius et al., are the results of Wilson (1978) corrected for scattering in the moderator and accelerator regions of their apparatus, which lowered Wilson's results by an average of 18%. Most of the measurements lie in a fairly narrow band in Fig. 3. One of the interesting qualitative features is the observation of a RamsauerTownsend effect (a minimum in QT) by Stein et al. (1978) and Sinapius et d.(1980) near 2 eV, with a steeply rising cross section at the lowest energies. All of the theoretical results in Fig. 3 indicate the existence of a cross-section minimum. Cross-section minima such as this were first observed by Ramsauer (1921b, 1923), Townsend and Bailey (1922), and Ramsauer and Kollath (1929) for low-energy e--Ar, Kr, and Xe collisions. These minima were so deep that it appeared that the target gases were nearly transparent to the projectile electrons. The RamsauerTownsend minima arise from quantum mechanical effects associated with a net attractive interaction between the projectile and the target atoms. Another interesting feature of most of the experimental data in Fig. 3 is the noticeable increase in Q T as the energy is increased above the Ps formation threshold, which shows up most clearly in the narrow energywidth measurements of Stein ef a/. (1978). The e+ experimental QTresults for Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe are displayed in
66
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
Positron Energy (eV) F I G . 4. Low-energy e+-Ne total cross section results. UN refers to the (2p-d) unnormalized results and N refers to the (2s-p) + (2p-d) normalized results of Montgomery and LaBahn (1970). (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
Figs. 4-7, along with the results of several theories. In a qualitative sense, the shapes of the theoretical curves at low energies are quite similar to some of the experimental results. Stein et al. (1978) observe a rather deep Ramsauer-Townsend effect in Ne near 0.6 eV. Kauppila et al. (1976a) observe a shallow cross-section minimum in Ar near 2 eV. There are
McEachran (1979)
_--- Schrader (1979) _- Montgomery (1970) -__Massey (1966) Positron Energy (eV)
FIG.5 . Low-energy e+-Ar total cross-section results. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
POSITRON-GAS SCA'ITERING EXPERIMENTS
67
. . V
0
Dobobnrh (1980) Sinapiu, (1980)n Canter (1973) Mc Eochron (1980) Schrader (1979) Mmey (1966)
-_0
"
.
"
*
"
"
.
.
"
t
10 20 Positron Energy (eV)
30
FIG.6. Low-energy e+-Kr total cross-section results. (FromStein and Kauppila, 1982.)
dramatic increases in the measured QT values above the Ps formation thresholds for all the inert gases, illustrated most clearly in the narrow energy-width measurements made in Detroit (Kauppilaer ul., 1976a; Stein et d.,1978; Dababneh et ul., 1980). The theoretical cross section curves which extend above the Ps formation thresholds in Figs. 3-7 do not account for inelastic scattering, and thus are not expected to show the
Dobabneh (1980) (1980)n o Coleman (198Oa) v Canter (19740) McEochran (1980) ---- Schrodrr (1979)
+ Sinopiur
-
0
0 0
"
.
.
t
"
.
10
.
"
'
*
"
20
30
Positron Energy (eV)
FIG.7. Low-energy e+-Xe total cross-section results. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
68
abrupt increases near the Ps formation thresholds which show up in the experimental results. The qualitative features of the low-energy e+ QT curves for the inert gases are summarized in Fig. 8 with the measurements of Stein rt (11. (1978) for He and Ne, Kauppilaet al. (1976a) for Ar, and Dababneh rt d. (1980) for Kr and Xe. For comparison, the corresponding e- Q.,.curves are also provided in Fig. 8, where the results of Ramsauer (1921b, 1923) and Ramsauer and Kollath (1929) for Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe, and Milloy and Crompton (1977) for He, are used for energies below a few electron volts, and the results of Kauppilart crl. (1976a, 1977b) for Ar and He, Stein et a/. (1978) for Ne, and Dababneh et al. (1980) for Kr and Xe are displayed at the higher energies. It is interesting to note that the situation regarding the existence of Ramsauer-Townsend effects in the inert gases is nearly reversed for positrons compared with electrons in the sense that positrons exhibit Ramsauer-Townsend minima only for the lighter inert gases (He, Ne, and possibly a shallow minimum for Ar), whereas electrons exhibit Ramsauer-Townsend minima only for the heavier inert gases (Ar, Kr, and Xe). Another interesting observation that is apparent when comparing the general nature of the e + and e- curves shown in Fig. 8 is the dramatic
OO
5
I0
15
20
Porllron Energy (eV1
25
10
20
3
Electron Energy (eV1
FIG.8. Total cross-section curves for low-energy e+-inert gas and e--inert gas scattering. The arrows (in the order of increasing energy) refer to the thresholds for positronium formation, atomic excitation and ionization for e + scattering, and atomic excitation and ionization f o r e - scattering. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
69
increase in Q T at each of the lowest energy inelastic thresholds (due to Ps formation) for e+ scattering and the lack of any noticeable changes in QTat the lowest inelastic thresholds (due to atomic excitation) for electrons. The e+-He curve also indicates a noticeable increase in the slope at the threshold energy for atomic excitation by e+ impact which was first pointed out by Coleman et al. (1975a) in an analysis of the data of Canter et al. (1973). When making these comparisons, it is important to realize that narrow resonances (not shown in Fig. 8) exist near several of the inelastic thresholds for e- scattering, while none have yet been observed for e+ scattering (see Section VI). The e + curves in Fig. 8 can be used to obtain estimates of the Ps formation cross sections (Qps) (crosshatched regions) for e+ energies between the thresholds for Ps formation and atomic excitation, assuming that the elastic scattering cross sections are smoothly varying as the e+ energy increases through the Ps formation thresholds. (For a further discussion of QB refer to Section V,A.) It is not a simple matter to ascertain which e+ QT measurements are the most reliable. Two recent review articles (Griffith and Heyland, 1978; Griffith, 1979) discuss errors in several of the experiments represented in Figs. 3-7. Although experimental groups will often make estimates of potential systematic errors in their experiments, the estimated magnitudes of such errors may be incorrect, and there may be systematic errors which are overlooked that are as large or larger than those which are painstakingly considered. An approach initiated by the Detroit group (Kauppila et ul., 1976a) is to make the corresponding measurements for each gas with electrons and positrons using the same experimental approach and system. An advantage of this approach is that most of the potential systematic errors should equally affect the e- and e + measurements. The Detroit e--He results (Kauppila et al., 1977b) are within a few percentage points of several other sets of absolute measurements (Milloy and Crompton, 1977; Kennerly and Bonham, 1978; Blaauw et al., 1980) and theoretical calculations (Callaway et al., 1968; Yau et al., 1978; Nesbet, 1979; Fon et al., 1981). The Detroit e- measurements for the other inert gases (Kauppila et d.,1976a; Stein et al., 1978; Dababneh et al., 1980) have been compared with other e- measurements and appear to be reliable. The absolute e--inert gas QT measurements of Sinapius et al. (1980) and some normalized e--He and e--Ar Q T measurements of Charlton et al. (1980a) are also in quite good agreement with the results discussed above. It is informative to examine the Q T results for low-energy e+-inert gas collisions, keeping in mind the e--inert gas results referred to above. For the e+-He case, Fig. 3 indicates that there are several calculations that agree quite well with the experiments in the vicinity of the RamsauerTownsend minimum. The variational calculation of Campeanu and Hum-
70
Talbert S.Stein and Walter E . Kauppila
berston ( 1977) and an exchange adiabatic approximation calculation of Massey et a/. (1966) remain in quite good agreement with several of the experiments u p to the highest energies of overlap. Since the calculation of Campeanu and Humberston is likely to be the most elaborate of all the above calculations, it is of interest to consider comparisons between this theory and the various experiments. Considerable attention (Campeanu and Humberston, 1977; Humberston, 1978; Humberston and Campeanu, 1980) has been devoted to trying to explain the discrepancy between their calculations and the measurements made in Detroit (Stein et a/., 1978; Kauppila et d.,1976b) and Texas (Burciaga et a/., 1977; Coleman et ul., 1979) for energies below 6 eV, where the experiments are lower. Humberston (1978) contends that the Detroit and Texas results are both too low below 6 eV due to the neglect of positrons scattered through small angles and that the measurements of Canter et d.(1973), which are claimed to agree with Campeanu and Humberston (1977) below 6 eV, are more accurate in the vicinity of 2 eV. Humberston (1978) deduces that at 2 eV, the discrepancy between the results of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) and those of Stein et a / . (1978) could be explained by an angular discrimination of 12", while an angular discrimination of 20" could explain the discrepancy with the results of Burciaga et a / . (1977). In order to determine if differing angular discriminations could provide a consistent explanation for the discrepancies between the results of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) and the various experimental results, we have calculated the percent error introduced into the total elastic for e+-He and e--He collisions due to variscattering cross section ous values of angular discrimination at various energies. The results for positrons, summarized in Fig. 9, were obtained using the s-wave phase shifts of Campeanu and Humberston (1977), the p-wave phase shifts of Humberston and Campeanu (1980), the lowest set of d-wave phase shifts of Drachman (1966), and the higher phase shifts (up to 1 = 20) from the formula of O'Malley e f a/. (1961):
(eel)
61
=
~k'P/((21+ 3)(21 + 1)(21 - 1))ao
(2)
whereP is the static dipole polarizability (1.3830:) of the target atom (He) and k is the wavenumber of the projectile. The corresponding percent errors for e--He collisions, also shown in Fig. 9, were obtained using the s-, p-, and d-wave phase shifts of Callaway et a / . (1968) (from their "EP" calculation) and the higher phase shifts (up to 1 = 20) from the formula of O'Malley et d. (1961) given above. Figure 9 clearly illustrates that the percent error in Qe,(and therefore in QT)for a particular angular discrimination reaches a maximum for e+-He collisions in the region of the Ramsauer-Townsend minimum (about 2 eV). An experiment with a large
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
71
40 s wove IHIB-Cornpconu (1977)
Q .c
g 30
-
p wove lH5)-Hurnberston (1980) d wow-Drachman 11966) (3-201- OMolley (1961)
-
).
t,p,d wove Colloway (1968) I:(3--2O)-O'Malley (1961)
5
0 c .L
2
20
-
fi
8
10
FIG.9. Calculated percent errors (using the phase shifts listed) in measured e+-He and e--He total cross sections due to the neglect of small-angle elastic scattering for various angular discriminations. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
value for the angular discrimination could thus be expected to show a deeper Ramsauer-Townsend effect than actually exists. The angular discrimination in the experiment of Stein et al. (1978) was initially estimated to be about 13" at 2 eV. Figure 9 indicates that an angular discriminatioii of about 17"could explain the difference between the e+-He results of Stein et NI. (1978) and the theoretical results of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) near 2 eV shown in Fig. 3. The more recent and more complete analysis of the angular discrimination for low-energy positrons by Dababneh ef a / . (1980) (using the same apparatus as that used by Stein et a/., 1978), which gave an angular discrimination of 15-20' for e+ energies between 1 and 20 eV, is consistent with the 17" value required to explain the difference between the measurements of Stein et al. (1978) and the values of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) in the vicinity of 2 eV. The results of Canter et al. (1973) agree with those of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) below 3.5 eV, but are measurably higher than the curve of Campeanu and Humberston (1977) between 3.5 and 6 eV, and this is inconsistent with any explanation based on angular discrimination alone. Coleman et NI. (1980a) estimate that the angular discrimination of their apparatus is less than 20", which, taken with the percent error results shown in Fig. 9, would suggest a consistency of the e+-He results of Coleman et a/. (1979) with those of Campeanu and Humberston (1977),
72
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kauppila
except for the lowest energies (<3 eV) where Coleman et d.41979) would still be too low. Of all the measurements, the corrected, normalized values reported by Sinapius et nl. (1980), who estimate an angular discrimination of 7, are in the best agreement with Campeanu and Humberston between 1 and 6 eV. A major part of the discrepancy between the e+-He measurements of Sinapius et 01. (1980) and Stein et d . (1978) could be due to the differing angular discriminations of the respective experiments. An observation which at first glance seems inconsistent with an angular discrimination argument is that the measurements of Stein et d.(1978) for e+-He above 7 eV are measurably higher than the curve of Campeanu and Humberston (1977), shown in Fig. 3. However, we found that the curve in Fig. 3 (obtained from the H14 curve of Fig. 1 of Campeanu and Humberston, 1977) was noticeably lower at energies above the RamsauerTownsend minimum than one which we obtained using the s-wave phase shifts of Campeanu and Humberston (1977), the p-wave phase shifts of Humberston and Campeanu (1980), the lowest set of d-wave phase shifts of Drachman (1966), and higher phase shifts (up to 1 = 20) from the formula of O’Malley et (11. (1961) referred to above, with only part of the discrepancy between the two theoretical curves being accounted for by the inclusion of the higher partial waves. The resulting theoretical curve is shown in Fig. 10, along with the measurements of Canter et (11. (1973) and Stein et a / . (1978). The percent error estimates shown in Fig. 9 indicate
FIG. 10. Low-energy e+-He total cross-section measurements of Canter i’f ctl. (1973) and Stein rt ( I / . (1978) compared with a theoretical curve obtained by using the phase shifts referred to in Fig. 9. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
POSITRON-GAS SCAmERING EXPERIMENTS
73
that a 15-20" angular discrimination (as estimated by Dababneh et al., 1980) would result in a remarkable consistency between the theoretical results in Fig. 10 and the measurements of Stein et al. (1978) not only at 2 eV, but also for all energies above 2 eV. The measurements of Canter et al. (1973) agree with the theoretical curve below 3.5 eV, are higher than the curve between 3.5 and 6 eV and lower than the curve between 7 and 13.6 eV. It is interesting to note from the percent error curves in Fig. 9 that a 15-20' angular discrimination for the low-energy e--He QT measurements would introduce less than a 5% error in those measurements from 0 to 13.6 eV in contrast to the e+-He case, which suggests that the excellent agreement of the Detroit e--He results with several other experiments and theories may be an indication that systematic errors in the Detroit measurements, other than that due to angular discrimination, are relatively small. (For some additional considerations of the e+-He situation, the reader is referred to Wadehra et al., 1981.) We have used calculations of phase shifts available in the literature to make percent error (in Qel) estimates (Table 111) for various angular discriminations and projectile energies for positrons colliding with the heavier inert gases (Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe) in order to search for some consistent patterns in the measurements of QTfor these gases. Although we have only displayed the results obtained from one particular set of theoretical phase shifts for each gas in Fig. 9 and in Table 111, we computed percent errors using different sets of theoretical phase shifts and found that the general trends and magnitudes of the percent errors were surprisingly insensitive to the particular set of theoretical phase shifts which we used, provided that we used ten or more phase shifts, supplementing the phase shifts obtained from a particular theoretical calculation with the higher phase shifts up to I = 10 or more obtained from the formula of O'Malleyer al. (1961) referred to above. Thus, the conclusions that we draw in the following discussion using the percent error results in Fig. 9 and in Table 111 would not be significantly affected by our particular choice of the sets of available theoretical phase shifts. There is a very intriguing consistency between the Bielefeld and Detroit experimental results when the percent error data in Fig. 9 and Table I11 are taken into account. With the exception of Ne, the measurements of Sinapius et al. (1980) are consistently higher than those of Detroit (Kauppila et al., 1976a; Stein et al., 1978; Dababneh et al., 1980) for each of the heavier inert gases, as was the case for He. Our percent error estimates suggest that a significant part of the discrepancies between the measurements of Sinapius et d.(1980) and Detroit for Ar (Kauppila et d.,1976a), Kr, and Xe (Dababneh et al., 1980) could be related to the differing angular discriminations of the respective experiments (-7" for Bielefeld and
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kauppila
74
15-20" for Detroit) as was the case for He. Furthermore, our percent error estimates for the e+-Ne case indicate that the differing angular discriminations of the Bielefeld and Detroit experiments would not result in a noticeable discrepancy between their measurements above 2 eV. Figure 4 indicates that the Bielefeld e+-Ne results are in reasonably good agreement with the Detroit results (Stein rt nl., 1978)above 2 eV but are lower at the lowest energies. If the Detroit e+-Ne QTresults should be shifted upward TABLE 111 PERCENTAGE ERRORS I N Q P , FOR QT MEASUREMENTS D U ETO F I N I T E A N G U L AD RI S C R I M I N A T I O N " Error in System et-Ne
e+-Ar
e+-Kr
QPI
(5%) with angular discrimination (degrees)
Energy (eV)
5"
10
15
20
25
30
45
60
90
0.14 0.54 1.22 2.18 3.40 4.90 6.66 8.70 11.02 13.60
0.6% 1.8 1.1 0.6 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2
2.4 6.8 3.8 2.0 1.3 I .o 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.7
5.2 13.9 7.5 3.8 2.4 1.8
8.7 22.2 11.4 5.5 3.3 2.4 1.9 1.6 1.5 1.4
13.0 31.2 15.3 7.0 4.1 2.8 2.2 1.9 1.8 1.8
17.6 40.4 18.7 8.1 4.6 3.1 2.4 2.1 2.2 2.5
33.3 64.4 25.2 9.5 5.0 3.7 3.7 4.5 5.8 7.5
49.1 79.7 26.7 9.8 6.4 6.8 8.6 11.4 14.7 18.4
75.1 88.3 30.3 20.6 22.7 27.5 33.3 39.4 45.4 51.0
0.14 0.54 1.22 2.18 3.40 4.90 6.66 8.70 11.02 13.60
0.3 0.8 1.7 2.3 2.5 2.5 2.6 2.6 2.5 2.5
1.3 3.2 6.5 8.2 8.7 8.8 8.7
2.9 6.8 13.3 16.4 16.8 16.5
8.5
8. I 7.8
14.8 13.8 12.8
5.0 11.4 21.5 25.6 25.4 24.1 22.3 20.3 18.3 16.4
7.6 16.7 30.4 35.2 33.9 31.0 27.8 24.5 21.4 18.7
10.5 22.6 39.7 44.4 41.3 36.5 31.6 27.0 23.1 20.0
21.5 41.2 65.1 65.9 55.3 44.6 35.9 29.7 26.1 24.5
34.2 58.8 83.2 76.4 59.2 45.8 37.9 34.6 34.8 37.2
60.3 83.7 %.8 79.3 62.0 55.7 57.0 61.3 66.1 70.1
0.14 0.54 1.22 2.18 3.40 4.90 6.66 8.70 11.02 13.60
0.3 0.9 1.8 2.4 2.8 3.1 3.3 3.3 3.4 3.3
1.3 3.5 6.8 8.6 9.8 10.6 10.9 10.9 10.7 10.3
2.8 7.4 13.8 17.2 18.9 19.7 19.6 18.9 17.9 16.7
4.9 12.3 22.3 26.8 28.4 28.5 27.4 25.5 23.4 21.2
7.4 18.0 31.6 36.6 37.5 36.4 33.7 30.3 26.9 23.9
10.3 24.2 41.0 45.9 45.4 42.4 38.0 33.2 28.9 25.3
21.1 43.8 66.5 67.0 59.5
33.7 61.8 83.8 76.5 62.8 51.8 45.2 42.9 43.8 46.6
59.8 86.1 95.6 78.9 66.6 64.0 66.7 70.6 74.0 76.3
1.5
1.2 1.1 1.1
15.8
50.5
42.3 36.3 32.7 31.5
75
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS TABLE 111 (continued) Error in Qel (%) with angular discrimination (degrees) System et-Xe
"
Energy (eV)
5"
10
15
20
25
30
45
60
90
0.14 0.54 1.22 2. I8 3.40 4.90 6.66 8.70 11.02 13.60
0.3%) 1.0 1.9 2.6 3.3 3.8 4.2 4.5 4.6 4.7
1.2 3.9 7.0 9.4 11.6 13.2 14.1 14.5 14.6 14.4
2.6 8.2 14.3 18.5 22.0 24.2 25.0 24.8 24.1 22.9
4.6 13.6 22.9 28.6 32.9 34.7 34.5 33.1 31.0 28.5
7.0 19.9 32.4 38.9 43.0 43.7 41.9 38.8 35.2 31.6
9.8 26.6 41.9 48.5 51.5 50.4 46.6 41.9 37.3 33.3
20.1 47.7 67.2 69.3 65.7 58.5
32.3 66.4 83.5 77.8 68.4 60.0 55.2 54.3 55.9 58.6
58.2 89.4 93.1 79.7 73.8 74.6 77.5 79.9 81.0 81.1
51.0
45.5 42.4 41.6
Sources of phase shifts used in these calculations:
e+-Ne: ef-Ar: e+-Kr: e+-Xe:
/ I
= =
/ = I =
0 t o / = 3, Schrader (1979); 0 to I = 6, McEachran ct d.(1979); 0 t o / = 6, McEachran ef c d . (1980): 0 to / = 6, McEachran et e l / . (1980);
/ = 4 to / = I = 7 to / = I = 7 to/ = I = 7 to / =
20, O'Malley et crl. ( l % l ) . 20, O'Malley et c d . ( l % l ) . 20, O'Malley ct id. ( l % l ) . 20, O'Malley et e l / . (1961).
in energy by a few tenths of an electron volt (as discussed in Section V,A), this would make the agreement between Bielefeld and Detroit even better. The measurements of London (Canter et al., 1973) for the heavier inert gases do not appear to fit any consistent pattern in relation to the other experiments. The results of the Texas group (Colemanet a/., 1979, 1980a) are in rather good agreement with Detroit for He, Ne (Stein et d . , 1978), and Ar (Kauppilaet d . , 1976a), and with London (Canter et al., 1974a)for Xe . On the basis of the consistency of the low-energy Detroit and Bielefeld e+ QTresults for the inert gases when the angular discriminations of those experiments are taken into account, we feel that there is a reasonable chance that the Bielefeld results (having an estimated angular discrimination of about 7") may be the closest of all the measurements to being correct within their restricted energy range (1-6 eV). However, it should be recalled that the Bielefeld measurements can be subject to an appreciable correction (Sinapius et a/., 1980) when QT depends strongly on the positron energy, and this could affect their reliability. The Detroit experiments should yield reliable QT values if a correction is made for their angular discrimination (estimated to be 15-20" for the low-energy e+ experiments). Using Fig. 9 and Table I11 to make such corrections, one finds, for instance, that at 2.2 and 13.6 eV in He, the results of Stein ef d.(1978) could be about 19 and 5% low, respectively; at 2.2 and 13.6 eV in Ne, the
76
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
results of Stein et d.(1978) could be about 5 and 1% low, respectively; at 2.2 and 8.7 eV in Ar, the results of Kauppila et a / . (1976a) could be about 21 and 18% low, respectively; at 1.2 and 6.7 eV in Kr, the results of Dababneh et d.( I 980) could be about 18and 23% low, respectively; and at 1.2 and 4.9 eV in Xe, the results of Dababneh et ti/. (1980) could be about 19 and 29% low, respectively. Similar corrections for the Bielefeld work would range from less than 1% for Ne to about 8% for Xe. B. INERT GASESAT INTERMEDIATEENERGIES Experimental results for He, Ne, and Ar at intermediate energies are shown in Figs. 11-13 along with several theoretical calculations. The measurements reported by Griffith c't d.(1979a) were obtained by normalization of their results to the measurements of Coleman et d . (1976a) between 30 and 100 eV. The other measurements in Figs. 11-13 are absolute. Above 50 eV, the measurements of Toronto (Jaduszliwer et d., 1975; Tsai et d . , 1976), Swansea (Brenton ct d.,1977, 1978), and Detroit (Kauppila rt d . . 1981a) are in good agreement (generally within 10% of each other) for these gases. The normalized measurements of Griffith ct d.(1979a) are also in good agreement with the other results for He and Ne, except from 1
2
3
4
I
I
I
k (iia,,)
5
6
7
8
I
I
I
I
9
Koupp~Ia(198101
\ \\
o Brenlon 11977) A Coleman (19760) + Jodurzlwer (19751 v Conler (1973) -.-Byron (197B)EBS Dewongen (1977)DW Byron (1977MM lnahull (19751B*G,mel. Dcrongen 11977)DW,e lnohuli (1974)EB
-
I &-A 0'
I " ' "
' " ' I
'
' '
I
'
'
I
'
'
I
400 700 1000 Positron Energy (eV) Fib. I I . Intermediate-energy e+-He total cross-section results. The results displayed for Jaduszliwer C I trl. (1975) are interpolated values. The codes for the theoretical results are identified in the text. except for the Bethe-Born (BB) theory of Inokuti and McDowell (1974). (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.) 20 50
100
200
77
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS k (i/ao)
1
2
-
k l
.
3
4
5
6
7
8
I
1
I
1
I
I
Kauppila (1981a) Coleman (1979) Griffith (1979a)n 0 Brenton (1978) 4 Coleman (1976a) + Tsai (1976) v Canter (1973)
4 N -
E
y
I
2-
* g o .
0
E
2
c
2
"
? I
:o
-
9
0 A
.
. O
+
f 0
I-
2
..
- ------ Dewangen (1977)DW Byron (197730M 0
-.-.-
c 0
g
lnokuti (1975)B.G,lnel; Dewangen (1977)DW,el
.
0
A
.
'
'
'
~.
Positron Energy (eV)
I ? . Intermediate-energy e+-Ne total cross-section results. (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.) Fit,.
k(t/a,) 1 k I
2
3
4
5
6
7
I
I
I
I
1
I
'#
01
100
1
Kauppila (1981a) Coleman (1980a) A Griffith (1979a)n 0 Brenton (1978) 4 Coleman (1976a) + Tsai (19761 v Canter (1973) Joachain ( 1 9 7 n O M I
.
' *.*'
' ' * I * n
20 50
8
___-
'
'
"
200 400 Positron Energy (eV)
'
*
I
700
.
'
IOOC
F I G . 13. Intermediate-energy e+-Ar total cross-section results. OM1 refers to the method I "optical model'' calculation of Joachain ct ol. (1977). (From Stein and Kauppila, 1982.)
78
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
200-400 eV for He, where Griffith et a / . are 10-15% lower. For Ar, the measurements of Griffith et d . (1979a) are about 10% higher than Tsai vt ( I / . (1976) and Kauppilaet cil. (1981a) below 100 eV, and more than 10% lower than Tsai et nl. (1976), Kauppila et t i / . (198la), and Brenton et r i l . (1978) above 200 eV. The higher energy results of Canter et r i / . (1973, 1974a) and Coleman et cil. (1976a) are lower than the other measurements, and this has been attributed to their inadequate discrimination against small-angle scattering. On the basis of these comparisons, it seems that the most reliable measurements for energies above 50 e V are those of Toronto (Jaduszliwer ef d . , 1975; Tsai et d.,1976), Swansea (Brenton ef N/., 1977, 1978), and Detroit (Kauppila et N I . . 1981a). The Detroit group has also made the corresponding e- measurements on the same gases (using the same apparatus and technique), which are in remarkable agreement with the recent measurements of Blaauw et r i l . (1980) and Wagenaar and de Heer (1980). The only significant differences between the e- measurements of these two laboratories could be explained by their differing angular discriminations for elastic scattering estimated to be less than I" for the Amsterdam group and typically 5-6" for Detroit. For positrons at energies above 100 eV, the estimated angular discriminations for the Detroit work are generally 6-8" for He, Ne, and Ar (Kauppila et d . , 1981a). Hence, the measurements made in Detroit are subject to corrections, which would increase their values by an amount depending on the nature of the differential elastic scattering of positrons, and the contribution of elastic scattering to QT. Using the e+-He differential elastic cross sections calculated by Byron and Joachain (1977) [using an optical model (OM) formalism], Kauppilaer t i / . (1981a) estimate that their e+-He measurements may be an average of 1% too low due to the neglect of small-angle elastic scattering from 100500 eV. In surveying the various e+-He theoretical results, Kauppila et t i / . (l981a) found that by adding the inelastic cross sections that can be calculated from the Bethe theory with an additional "gamma" term (related to the number of electrons in the target atom) of Inokuti et a / . (1975) and Kim and Inokuti (1971), and the elastic scattering cross sections calculated by Dewangen and Walters (1977) using a distorted wave second Born approximation (DW), QTvalues (designated B + G, DW in Fig. 1 I ) are obtained which agree to within 2% of their measurements above 200 eV. Brenton et t i / . (1977) are in good agreement with this composite theory up to their highest energy, 1000 eV. The theoretical calculations for Ne and Ar, shown in Figs. 12 and 13 are reasonably close to the measurements, but do not merge with them at the highest energies of overlap. For Kr and Xe, the measurements of Canter et nl. (1973, 1974a) and Coleman et a/. (1976a) are
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
79
significantly lower than the recent results reported by Kauppila et NI. (1981b). C. POSITRON A N D ELECTRON COMPARISONS FOR THE INERT GASES Comparisons have been made by Kauppila et d.(1981a,b) of the e+inert gas and e--inert gas total cross sections up to 800 eV. For the He comparisons (up to 650 eV) shown in Fig. 14, the Detroit measurements 1981a) have been used for all e+ ener(Stein et a / . , 1978; Kauppila er d., gies and for e- energies above 2 eV, while the measurements of Milloy and Crompton (1977) were used for e- energies below 2 eV. Since the e+-He and e--He measurements (from 2 to 600 eV) shown in Fig. 14 have been made with the same experimental apparatus and techniques, most of the potential systematic errors should equally affect the e+ and e- measurements. The partial neglect of small-angle elastic scattering, on the other Energy (eV) 0 2 10
50
100
200
400
60C
F I G . 14. Comparison of measured e+-He and e--He total cross sections. The lowest inelastic thresholds for each projectile are indicated by arrows. (From Kauppila cf c d . , 1981a.)
80
Tulbeit S . Stein and Walter E . Kuuppila
hand, is a source of error which, in general, does not affect the e + and emeasurements equally, since it depends on the angular discrimination (estimated to be roughly 5" for all e- energies and ranging from 15-20" at low energies to 6- 10" at higher energies for positrons) and on the differential elastic cross sections. The e'-He comparison in Fig. 14 provides a striking illustration of some of the differences and similarities in e+ and escattering. At low energies the e + cross section is about two orders of magnitude smaller than the e- cross section. This is consistent with the fact that the static and polarization interactions are both attractive in the e- case, whereas there is a tendency toward cancellation of these interactions in the e+ case. In sharp contrast to the vastly different cross sections at low energies, there is an observed merging (to within 2%) of the e- and e + results above 200 eV. Kauppila e f d.(1981a) estimate that the maximum amounts by which their cross-section measurements could be too low due to the neglect of small-angle elastic scattering are 2% for electrons and 1% for positrons. The merging of the QT curves was not expected to occur at such low energies. The e +and e- distorted wave second Born approximation (DW) calculations of Dewangen and Walters ( 1977) do not merge (to within 2%) until 2000 eV, while the composite (B + G, DW) calculations of Inokuti r t t i / . (1979, Kim and Inokuti (l971), and Dewangen and Walters referred to in Section II1,B merge (to within 2%) at 1000 eV. At 200 eV, the DW calculations for electrons are 21% higher than the corresponding e+ calculations, while there is a 14% difference for the B + G , DW composite theory and a 21% difference for the eikonal Born series (EBS) calculations of Byron (1978). The comparison e' measurements of the Detroit group for Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe (Kauppila et d . , 1981a,b) do not indicate any merging of the cross sections at the highest energies studied.
D. TESTSOF
THE
S U MR U L E
An aspect of total scattering of positrons and electrons by atoms that has received considerable attention in recent years is the question concerning the validity of the sum rule, which is based on the forward dispersion relations of Gerjuoy and Krall (1960). For scattering by the inert gases, in which the projectile and the target atoms do not form bound states, the sum rule has the form (Bransden and McDowell, 1969)
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
81
whereA is the scattering length,fi andfEBare the first Born elastic scattering amplitudes in the forward direction for direct and exchange scattering, I, is the projectile wave number, all in atomic units, and Q T is the total scattering cross section in units of m i ; . By using available e+-He and e+-Ne QT measurements (which at the highest energies are extrapolated to the Born approximation) to evaluate the integral in Eq. (3) and theoretical results for the other terms in Eq. (3), it has been determined by Bransden and Hutt (1979, Byron rf (11. (1979, de Heer ef al. (1976), Hutt rt d.(1976), Tsai et (11. (1976), Brenton et (11. (1977), Griffith et al. (1979a), and Kauppila et d.(1981a) that the sum rule is valid when applied to e+-He, Ne scattering and not valid for e--He, Ne scattering. The sum rule tests by Kauppila et (11. (1981a) displayed in Table IV provide a summary of the current situation for e*-He, Ne, Ar scattering. In the latter work we feel there are possible uncertainties on the order of a few percentage points in the evaluation of the integral term for each projectile-target combination, which is based on a fit to the QT measurements of Kauppila et d.(1976a, 1977b, 1981a) and Stein ef d . (1978). Similarly there are small uncertainties associated with some of the other terms in Eq. (3) which get progressively larger as one goes from He to Ar (where there is no known calculation of J'E). From Table IV it is seen that the sum rule also appears to be valid for e+-Ar scattering as was first suggested by Tsai et (11. (1976). The apparent validity of the sum rule for positron-atom scattering and its invalidity for electron-atom scattering has been studied by Byron et al. (1975), de Heer ef (11. (1976), Hutt et NI. (1976), and Tip (1977), and is understood to arise from the nature of singularities in the exchange ampliTABLE IV SUM-RULE TESTSOR e'-He, Ne,
System e--He e+-He e--Ne e+-Ne e--Ar e+-Ar
.t'E
A
+ 1.178b - 0.48*
+O.P -0.614" 1.7h -3.0 to -4.W ~
AND
+0.796c -0.796' +3.21' -3.21' +9.7' -9.7'
Ar SCATTERING"
-A - .f!
+ 3.943'
+.tE
I .969 1.276 I .891 3.824
0 +5.32If 0 Unknown 0
-
12.7-13.7 ~
2.56 I .25 5.10 3.88 14.1 13.4
~~
From Kauppila ei id. (1981a). O'Malley (1977). Ho (1977). Campeanu and Humberston (1977). Naccache and McDowell(1974). Hutt C I d.(1976). McEachraner crl. (1978). O'Malley (1963). Tsai et ( I / . (1976). Hara and Fraser (1975). a
J
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
82
tude which causes the sum rule to fail for electron scattering. No such difficulties arise for positron scattering since there are no exchange effects between the incident positrons and target electrons. E. MOLECULAR GASES The low-energy (up to 40 eV) QTmeasurements for e+-Hz, N2, and CO, scattering are shown in Figs. 15-17, along with a few available theoretical results. Earlier measurements by Coleman et al. (1974) for Hzare not included because they have been remeasured and reported by Griffith and Heyland (1978). The measurements of Charlton er al. (1980b) are normalized. The measurements for H2 shown in Fig. 15 indicate the existence of a broad minimum below 9 eV and a dramatic increase near the Ps formation threshold. Another process (besides Ps formation) which could contribute to the large increase is dissociation of Hz, which becomes energetically favorable near 8.8 eV (the H2dissociation energy is 4.48 eV). A fixed-nuclei approximation calculation of the elastic scattering cross section by Hara (1974) is in quite good agreement with the measurements. An adiabatic nuclei approximation calculation by Baille et d.(1974) is somewhat lower than the measurements but similar in shape. The QT measurements of Hoffman er d.(1982) for N2 (Fig. 16) also show a broad minimum with increasing cross sections at the lowest energies and near the Ps formation threshold. The measurements of Coleman et cil. (1975~) for N, are generally lower than Hoffman et a/. and do not indicate an I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
A.
i
I
0
i
0
"
..v
.c 31
"t
01 0
cn
Hoffman (1982) Charlton (1980b)n v Coleman 0976b) -Hara (19741 --- Baille 0974)
.V
2 2-
IHt
*.
A
2
0
0
FIG.15.
0
I
4
8
12
I
1
I
20 24 28 32 Positron Energy (eV) 16
I
I
36
40
Low-energy e+-HZtotal cross-section results. (From Hoffman et
(I/.,
1982.)
83
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS 1
I
1
1
I
-6 8 l
N
.II
s
7
4
8
12
1
I
1
.
/ N E * A A
“0
1
32 36 40
16 20 24 28 Positron ‘Energy (eV)
FIG.16. Low-energy e+-N, total cross-section results. (From Hoffman et a / . , 1982.)
increase at the lowest energies. For e+-CO, scattering (Fig. 17) the meaare much lower (20-40%) than the surements of Coleman et a/. (1975~) results of Hoffman et a/. (1982),with the latter measurements revealing an interesting bump just above the Ps formation threshold. Comparisons of e*-H, total cross sections by Hoffman et al. (1982) are shown in Fig. 18. The e*-H, results merge for energies above 200 eV, but the merging could be fortuitous if there is appreciable small angle elastic scattering for Hz. Similar comparisons for e2-N, by Hoffman et al.’(1982) 15
-
I
.*
010
-
- ..
c
.,”
2 -In
.%...
.
..p
A
1
0
*
A
I
’
.
vvvv
V
V
Hoffman 0 9 8 2 ) Charltan (1980b)n v Coleman ( 1 9 7 5 ~ ) A
-
0
I - -
0
I
1
A
vv vvvvv~v~vvvv
c
1
*.*.
a”.*”
8- :
1
roz* IPS :.
-0
Y
I
co,
O
5 s
I
:n e*
N
1
1
1
1
I
1
1
1
1
1
I
Positron Energy (eV)
FIG.17. Low-energy e+-COP total cross-section results. (From Hoffman el d..1982.)
84
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kuuppilu
-0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
k(l/ao)
FIG.18. Comparison of measured e+-Hzand e--Hz total cross sections. (From Hoffman et 01.. 1982.)
indicate that the e--N, results remain above the e+-N2 results up to the highest energies studied (700 eV).
IV. Differential Scattering Cross Sections Coleman and McNutt (1979) have recently reported the first measurements of differential cross sections for the elastic scattering of 2-9 eV positrons by Ar for angles from 20-60”. A schematic diagram of their 1980b) is shown in Fig. 19. In their experiment, apparatus (Coleman et d., slow positrons pass through a I-cm-long gas cell and then travel approximately 25 cm through an evacuated straight flight tube in a strong axial magnetic field to a detector (Channeltron electron multiplier). The larger the angle through which a positron is scattered in the gas cell, the longer its TOF will be in the axial magnetic field. By alternately admitting gas into and then evacuating the gas cell, TOF histograms such as those shown in Fig. 20 are obtained. A “tail” can be observed on the long-time side of the “gas” TOF spectrum, which is associated with detected posi-
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
c
85
Solenoid
FIG. 19. Texas time-of-flight spectrometer for measuring differential cross sections for elastic scattering. (From Coleman rr u l . , 1980b.)
trons which have undergone forward elastic scattering. The “difference” spectrum is obtained by subtracting an appropriately adjusted “vacuum” TOF spectrum from the “gas” spectrum. Differential cross sections can be obtained by correlating the “difference” TOF spectrum with various angles of forward elastic scattering. The differential cross sections measured by Coleman and McNutt (1979) for e+-Ar collisions are compared
GAS 0
VACUUM
’DIFFERENCE
0- 200
i e
40“
* \
TCF (nsec)
FIG.20. TOF histogram with and without argon in the gas cell to illustrate the increase in flight time corresponding to elastic scattering at various angles. (From Coleman and McNutt, 1979.)
86
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
10
SCATTERING ANGLE FIG.21. Differential e+-Ar scattering results for different positron mean energies. The error bars represent statistical standard deviations. (From Coleman and McNutt, 1979.)
with the calculations of Schrader (1979) (solid lines) and “scaled-down’’ calculations of McEachran et 01. (1979) (broken lines) in Fig. 21. The agreement between experiment and theory is reasonable. Coleman et crl. (1980b) have also measured differential scattering cross sections for e--Ar collisions in the same apparatus and using the same technique as used for their positron studies and obtain reasonable agreement with other recent e--Ar results.
V. Inelastic Scattering Investigations A. POSITRONIUM FORMATION CROSS SECTIONS The crosshatched regions of the e+ QT curves illustrated in Fig. 8 can be used to provide estimates of the Ps formation cross sections (Qps)in the
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
87
inert gases. Such estimates assume a smooth extrapolation of the elastic scattering cross sections from below the Ps formation thresholds and also depend on the e+ energy calibration. Recent resonance searches by the Detroit group in Ar (Stein et al., 1981) described in Section VI indicate that the energy calibration used by the Detroit group could be low by a few tenths of an electron volt. This appears to be supported by the locations of the sharp onsets of Ps formation in the inert gases shown in Fig. 8, since the abrupt increases in QT occur at assigned energies which are a few tenths of an electron volt below the predicted Ps formation thresholds (indicated by arrows in Fig. 8). In order to compare the Detroit estimates of Qpswith other experimental and theoretical results, we have extracted QB curves for He, Ne, and Ar from the crosshatched regions in Fig. 8, but we have shifted the energy calibrations used by the Detroit group upward (0.2-0.4 eV) in order to match the observed and predicted thresholds for Ps formation. The Detroit QB results for He, Ne, and Ar, based upon the QT measurements of Stein et al. (1978) and Kauppila et al. (1976a), are shown in Fig. 22, where they are compared with several other sets of experimental and theoretical results. Charlton et al. (1980~)have recently made the first direct measurements of the energy dependence of the orrho-positronium formation cross section (Q,,-ps)in He, Ar, Hz, and CH, by passing a slow e+ beam through a scattering chamber and counting triple coincidences from the 3y decay of 0-Ps. In order to compare their Qo-Psenergy dependence with the other results shown in Fig. 22, we have normalized the relative He and Ar results of Charlton et al. (1980~)by scaling their values to match the Detroit curves at the respective excitation thresholds of He and Ar. We have also set the positron energy by adding 1.8 and 2.0 V to the “applied voltage” quoted by Charlton et al. for He and Ar, respectively, in order to match the predicted Ps formation thresholds with the observed onsets. Implicit in this normalization scheme is the assumption that the Qo-ps energy dependence would be the same as the Q, energy dependence. It is interesting that the Qo-psvalues indicated by Charlton ef al. (1980~)increase only up to roughly 4 eV above the respective Ps formation thresholds for He and Ar and then begin to diminish. Based on their direct measurements, Charlton et al. (1980~)have estimated the ratio of Q,,.ps(Ar)/Q,,-p,(He) for the peak values to be 6.5. The normalized Q,,-ps results of Charlton et al. (1980~)shown in Fig. 22 indicate a ratio of QB(Ar)/Qps(He)for the peak values of about 25, which is much larger than the ratio based on the direct measurements of the London group. The Qpsvalues of Coleman et al. (1975a) for He (based upon e+ lifetime and QT measurements) are in good agreement with the QPsvalues based upon the QT measurements of Stein et al. (1978) (and with the normalized values of
88
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
FIG.22. Positronium formation cross sections for e+-He, e+-Ne, and e+-Ar scattering. The S and K curves are Q,., values based on the Qr measurements of Stein rt a / . (1978) and Kauppila el ( I / . (1976a), respectively: the closed circles are the QePj results of Charltonrt t i / . (1980~)normalized as described in the text; the open squares are estimates from Coleman t t id. (1975c), based on the QTmeasurements of Canter er a ( . (1974a); C refers to estimates by Coleman E I ( I / . (1975a), based on e + lifetime and QT measurements; the FBA (first Born approximation) and FOEA (first-order exchange approximation) calculations (for Ps formed in the IS state) are from Mandal er a/. (1980), where the suffixes “a” and “b” refer to “postinteraction” and “prior interaction,” respectively: the DWA (distorted-wave approximation) calculation is from Mandal et a / . (1979); F refers to a calculation by Fels and Mittleman (1969) using a projection operator technique and the Temkin form of the polarization potential; B, P, and NP refer to the Born approximation, distorted-wave approximation (with polarization), and distorted-wave approximation (without polarization) calculations, respectively, by Gillespie and Thompson (1977).
Charltonrr al. (1980~)up to about 22 eV), but end up being about twice as large as the normalized values of Charlton et al. (19804 at 24.5 eV, while their results (Coleman et id., 1975a) for Ne and Ar are much lower than the QPs values based upon the QTmeasurements of Stein et al. (1978) and Kauppila et id. (1976a), respectively. In a recent TOF investigation (not represented in Fig. 22) of inelastic e+-He scattering, Griffith et (11. (1979b) made estimates of QB (based on numerous assumptions) which indicate that Qpsreaches a peak value of about 0.48 x 10-l“ cm2,roughly five times the peak value indicated by the normalized results of Charlton et a/. (1980~).The position of the peak indicated by Griffith et a/. (1979b) is 10-15 eV above the Ps formation threshold as compared with 4 e V above that threshold for the results of Charlton er al. (1980~). None of the theories shown in Fig. 22 has a shape which matches the results of Charlton et al. (1980~)for He. It is also interesting to note the
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
89
poor agreement of the different theories with each other and with the experiments in the case of He. One indication of the extent of the disagreements between theories and experiments in the case of He is that none of the available theories could be placed in reasonable locations on the graph of the experimental results without the use of the indicated scaling factors ranging from A5 to 10. Results of a first Born approximation calculation of QPs for He by Massey and Moussa (1961) have not been included in Fig. 22 because Mandal et 611. (1975) have indicated that numerical errors were made in that calculation. The Born approximation results of Gillespie and Thompson (1977) for Ne and Ar remain above all of the experimental values. The Born values of Qps for Ar are still rising at the highest energies studied by Gillespie and Thompson (8-9 eV above the Ps formation threshold) in contrast to the Q,,-ps observations of Charlton et d.(1980~).The distorted wave approximation (P, NP) calculations of Gillespie and Thompson (1977) for Ne indicate a threshold behavior similar to the QPsvalues based on the QTmeasurements of Stein et a/. (1978) but begin to level off just above 15 eV whereas the values of Stein et al. continue a rapid increase up to the excitation threshold of Ne (16.6 eV). For Ar the distorted wave approximation (P)calculation of Gillespie and Thompson (1977) indicates an energy dependence roughly similar to the Q,,+? results obtained by Charlton ef a/. (1980~)but the theoretical QPs values are much lower than the normalized values of Charlton et a/. ( 1980~). B.
EXCITATION A N D IONIZATION
CROSS SECTIONS
Using the TOF apparatus shown in Fig. 19 (the same apparatus used for measurements of differential cross sections), Coleman and Hutton (1980) have obtained lower bounds on total excitation cross sections for 23-31 eV e+-He collisions. In this energy range, well-defined secondary peaks were observed in the TOF spectra corresponding to positrons which have lost 20.6 eV of energy and have been scattered in the forward direction at angles less than 70". A TOF spectrum for an incident e+ energy of 25.8 e V is shown in Fig. 23. At incident e+ energies above 30 eV, a secondary peak associated with ionization overlaps the excitation peak, making it difficult to assign excitation cross sections. The secondary peak corresponding to a 20.6 eV energy loss indicates that in the projectile energy range from 23 to 31 e V the total excitation cross section is dominated by excitation of the 2lS state, and that there is appreciable small angle scattering associated with this excitation process. This work has recently been extended to Ne and Ar (Coleman et al., 1981),
90
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila 25.8 eV
t
1
* - I
TOF (nrrc) FIG.23. TOF spectrum showing primary (unscattered) and secondary (excitation) peaks for positrons with a mean incident energy of 25.8 eV colliding with He. (From Coleman and Hutton, 1980.)
and lower bounds on “excitation plus ionization” cross sections have also been measured for He, Ne, and Ar. In Fig. 24 we summarize the current state of affairs regarding the partitioning of e+ total scattering cross sections for He and Ar between the elastic and inelastic scattering channels. The curves shown in Fig. 24 are portions of the QT and the extrapolated elastic cross section curves from Fig. 8 [based on the results of Stein et a / . (1978) and Kauppilaet a / . (1976a)l. The increase in the Detroit results due to inelastic scattering should be reliable as a consequence of the ability of the Detroit experiments to discriminate 100% against inelastically scattered positrons. The Qo.psresults of Charlton et a / . (19804 (normalized as discussed in Section V,A), and the partial excitation and partial “excitation plus ionization” cross sections of Coleman et a / . (1981) have been added to the respective extrapolated elastic cross section curves. It is clear from Fig. 24 that if the extrapolations of the elastic scattering cross sections above the Ps formation thresholds are valid, then a large part of the inelastic scattering cross section for He and Ar is unaccounted for by the normalized 0-Psformation cross section measurements of Charlton et al. (1980~)and the partial excitation and partial “excitation plus ionization” cross-section measurements of Coleman at a / . (1981). Griffith et a / . (1979b) have also used their TOF system with a localized scattering region and a long flight tube to investigate intermediate energy e+-He inelastic scattering. From studies of the shapes and positions of secondary peaks observed in their “gas-in’’ TOF spectra, Grfith et a / .
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
91
-’.O Positron Energy (eV) FIG.24. Inelastic cross sections for e+-He and e+-Ar scattering. The solid and broken curves are the total cross section and extrapolated elastic cross section curves from Fig. 8, respectively. The open circles represent the relative ortho-positronium formation measurements of Charlton er d . (198Oc) normalized in the same manner as described for Fig. 22 and added to the broken curves. The asterisks and plus signs represent the partial “excitation” and ‘‘excitation-plus-ionization” cross-section measurements, respectively, by Coleman and Hutton (1980) and Colemaner al. (1981), added to the broken curves.
have deduced that ionization is the dominant inelastic process in e+-He scattering between 100 and 500 eV.
VI. Resonance Searches Resonances have been predicted to exist for e+-H scattering just below then = 2 atomic excitation threshold (Doolen et al., 19781, and associated with the first excited state of Ps in the e+-H system (Doolen, 1978), and some possible theoretical evidence of a resonance in the e+-He system near 20.375 eV (above the Ps formation threshold and just below the first singlet excitation of He) has been provided by Ho and Fraser (1976). Up to the present time, there have not been any experimental observations of e+ scattering resonances. Stein et a/.(1981) are currently using their narrow energy width (<0.1 eV) e+ beam in a transmission experiment to search for e+ scattering resonances. Figure 25 shows measurements of the transmitted beam current versus the voltage applied to the e+ source over 1.0-V ranges centered near the Ps formation threshold (9.0 eV) and the
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
92
50K
90K Lo
c
c
0
u)
4-
V
e
0
V
(b)
(a)
801
.5
9.0 Applied Volts
9.
40t
I
.o
L
11.5 Applied Volts
12.
FIG.25. Transmitted positron beam currents in Ar versus voltage applied to the positron source. The error bars represent statistical uncertainties. (From Stein et ( I / . , 1981.)
lowest atomic excitation threshold (1 1.5 eV) for Ar. These data were taken at 25-mV intervals, with the primary beam attenuated by about 50%. In the data for Ar shown in Fig. 25 there is no convincing evidence of a resonance (which would be expected to manifest itself as a relatively narrow structure in the transmitted beam current). There is also no evidence of resonances in preliminary searches with He and H2. However, there is still useful information that is obtained from these studies. An abrupt change in the slope of the transmitted current curve appears in Fig. 25a which should correspond to the abrupt increase in the total cross section at the Ps formation threshold (see Fig. 8). The slope change in Fig. 25a occurs at 8.8 V, whereas the Ps formation threshold is known to be 9.0 eV. This implies that an applied voltage of 8.8 V corresponds to an e+ energy of 9.0 eV in the scattering region, which is consistent with the observation that the Detroit e+ QTcurves in Fig. 8 appear to be starting their abrupt increases a few tenths of an electron volt below the predicted Ps formation thresholds. The curve in Fig. 25b does not show an appreciable change in its slope as the energy is increased through the atomic excitation threshold (1 1.5 eV) and this is supported by the corresponding QT curve for Ar in Fig. 8, which is quite smooth between I 1 and 12 eV.
VII. Possible Future Directions for Positron Scattering Experiments A glance at Table I conveys the feeling that there are many feasible, interesting e+ scattering experiments still waiting to be done for the first
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
93
time. Even in the area of Q T measurements, there are a large number of obvious candidates for target atoms and molecules which have not been studied at all. Atomic hydrogen, and the alkali atoms would be of particular theoretical interest as target atoms due to their relatively simple structure. We have discussed several “second generation” experiments which have gone beyond Q T measurements. Although such efforts demonstrate the feasibility of investigating e+differential cross sections, inelastic scattering cross sections, and resonances, it seems that these areas can still be regarded as essentially “wide open” for improved experimental techniques and for the first measurements on many different collision systems. As an example, in the area of differential cross-section measurements, only one gas (Ar) has been studied, and it has only been studied in a very limited energy range (2.2-8.7 eV) and over a very restricted range of angles (20-60”). The studies of inelastic scattering up to the present time may have raised more questions than they have answered, and indicate a need for additional direct measurements of Ps formation, excitation and ionization cross sections.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We would like to thank Mr. Kevin Hoffman, Mr. Paul Felcyn, and Mr. Diab Jerius for their helpful assistance, and Ms. Evelyn Williams for typing the manuscript. We acknowledge, with gratitude, the support of the National Science Foundation for our Research program.
REFERENCES Anderson, C. D. (1933). Phys. Reit. 43, 491. Aulenkamp, H., Heiss, P., and Wichmann, E. (1974). Z. Phys. 268, 213. Baille, P., Darewych, J. W., and Lodge, J. G. (1974). Cun. J . P h y s . 52, 667. Blaauw, H. J., Wagenaar, R. W., Barends, D. H., and de Heer, F. J. (1980).J. Phys. B 13, 359. Bransden, B. H., and Hutt, P. K. (1975). J . Phys. E 8, 603. Bransden, B. H., and McDowell, M. R. C. (1%9). J . Phys. E 2, 1187. Brenton, A. G., Dutton, J., Harris, F. M., Jones, R. A., and Lewis, D. M. (1977).J. Phys. B. 10, 2699. Brenton, A. G., Dutton, J., and Hams, F. M. (1978). J . P h y s . E 11, L15. Burciaga, J. R., Coleman, P. G., Diana, L. M., and McNutt, J. D. (1977). J. Phys. B 10, L569. Bussard, R. W., Ramaty, R., and Drachman, R. J. (1979). Astrophys. J . 228, 928. Byron, F. W., Jr. (1978).Phys. Rev. A 17, 170.
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E. Kauppila
94
Byron, F. W., Jr., and Joachain, C. J. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 15, 128. Byron, F. W., Jr., de Heer, F. J., and Joachain, C. J. (1975). Phys. Re\*. Lerr. 35, 1147. Callaway, J., LaBahn, R. W., Pu,R. T., and Duxler, W. M. (1968). Phys. Re\,. 168, 12. Campeanu, R. I., and Dubau, J. (1978). J. Phgs. B 11, L567. Campeanu, R. I., and Humberston, J. W. (1977). J . Phys. B 10, L153. Canter, K. F., Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., and Heyland, G. R.(1972).J. Phps. B 5, L167. Canter, K. F., Coleman, P. G., Griflith, T. C., and Heyland, G. R.(1973).J. Phps. B 6, L201. Canter, K. F., Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., and Heyland, G. R. (1974a). Appl. Phys. 3, 249. Canter, K. F.,Mills, A. P., Jr., and Berko, S. (1974b). Phys. Re),. Lett. 33, 7. Charlton, M., Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R., and Twomey, T. R. (1980a). J. Phys. B 13, L239. Charlton, M., Griffith,T. C., Heyland, G. R., and Wright, G. L. (1980b). J . Phys. B 13, L353. Charlton, M., Griffith,T. C., Heyland, G. R., Lines, K. S . , and Wright, G. L. (1980~).J. f'hys. B 13, L757. Chupp, E. L., Forrest, D. J., Higbie, P. R.,Suri, A. N., Tsai, C., and Dunphy, P. P. (1973). Nfitiire (Loridori) 241, 333. Coleman, P. G., and Hutton, J. T. (1980). Phys. Re\-. Lett. 45, 2017. Coleman, P. G., and McNutt, J. D. (1979). Phys. ReLv. Lett. 42, 1130. Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., and Heyland, G. R. (1973).Proc. R . Soc. L O ~ I ~Ser. O N A 331, 561. Coleman, P. G., Griffth, T. C., and Heyland, G. R. (1974). Appl. Phys. 4, 89. Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R.,and Killeen, T. L. (1975a). J. Phys. B 8, L185. Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R.,and Killeen, T. L. (1975b). J. Phys. B 8, L454. Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R.,and Killeen, T. L. (1975~). Atom. Phps. 4, 355.
Coleman, P. G., Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R., and Twomey, T. R. (1976a). Appl. Phys. 11, 321. Coleman, P. G., Griffith,T. C., Heyland, G. R.,and Twomey, T. R. (1976b). Private communication as reported by Griffith and Heyland (1978). Coleman, P. G., McNutt, J. D., Diana, L. M., and Burciaga, J. R. (1979). Phys. Re\,. A 20, 145. Coleman, P. G., McNutt, J. D., Diana, L. M., and Hutton, J. T. (1980a). Phys. Re\,. A 22, 2290. Coleman, P. G., McNutt, J. D., Hutton, J. T., Diana, L. M., and Fry, J. L. (1980b).Reis. Sci. 1ri.striirn. 51, 935. Coleman, P. G., Hutton, J. T., Cook, D. R., Diana, L. M., and Sharma, S. C. (1981). Proc. l i l t . C q f . Phys. Electron. Atom. Collisions, 12th Abstr., p. 426. Costello, D. G., Groce, D. E., Herring, D. F., and McGowan. J. W. (1972a). Ctrri. J. Phys. 50, 23. Costello, D. G., Groce, D. E., Herring, D. F., and McGowan, J. W. (1972b). Phys. Rev. B 5, 1433. Crannell, C. J., Joyce, G., Ramaty, R.,and Werntz, C. (1976). Astrophys. J. 210, 582. Dababneh, M. S., Kauppila, W. E., Downing, J. P., Laperriere, F., Pol, V., Smart, J. H., and Stein, T. S . (1980). Phys. Rev. A 22, 1872. Dale, J. M., Hulett, L. D., and Pendyala, S . (1980). Surf. Interface Anal. 2, 199. Darewych, J. W., and Baille, P. (1974).J . f h y s . B 7, L1.
POSITRON-GAS SCATTERING EXPERIMENTS
95
de Heer, F. J., Wagenaar, R. W., Blaauw, H. J., and Tip, A. (1976). J . Phys. B 9, L269. Dewangen, D. P., and Walters, H. R. J. (1977).J. Phys. B 10, 637. Doolen, G. D. (1978). I n t . J. Quotit. Chem. 14, 523. Doolen, G. D., Nuttall, J., and Wherry, C. J. (1978). Phys. Rev. Lett. 40, 313. Drachman, R. J. (1966). f h y s . Rev. 144, 25. Dutton, J., Harris, F. M., and Jones, R. A. (1975). J . Phys. B 8, L65. Dutton, J., Evans, C. J., and Mansour, H. L. (1981). Proc. I n t . ConJ Phys. Electron. Atom. Collisions. 12th Abstr., p. 428. Fels, M. F., and Mittleman, M. H. (1969). PhyA. Rev. 182, 77. Fon, W. C., Berrington, K. A., and Hibbert, A. (1981). J. Phys. B 14, 307. Gerjuoy, E., and Krall, N. A. (1960). Phys. Rev. 119, 705. Gillespie, E. S., and Thompson, D. G. (1975). J . f h y s . B 8, 2858. Gillespie, E. S., and Thompson, D. G. (1977). J. Phys. B 10, 3543. Griffith, T. C. (1979). Adv. Atom. M o l . Phys. 15, 135. Griffith, T. C., and Heyland, G. R. (1978). Phys. Rep. 39, 169. Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R., Lines, K. S., and Twomey, T. R. (1978).J. Phys. B 11, L635. Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R., Lines, K. S., and Twomey, T. R. (1979a). Appl. Phys. 19, 431.
Griffith, T. C., Heyland, G. R., Lines, K. S., and Twomey, T. R. (1979b). J . f h y s . B 12, L747. Hara, S. (1974). J . Phys. B 7 , 1748. Hara, S., and Fraser, P. A. (1975). J . Pliys. B 8, 219. Ho, Y. K. (1977). J . Phys. B 10, L149. Ho, Y. K., and Fraser, P. A. (1976). J . Phys. B 9, 3213. Hoffman, K. R., Dababneh, M. S., Hsieh, Y.-F., Kauppila, W. E.,Pol, V., Smart, J. H., and Stein, T. S. (1982). Phys. Rev. A 25, 1393. Humberston, J. W. (1978). J. Pliys. B 1 1 , L343. Humberston, J. W., and Campeanu, R. I. (1980). J . Phys. B 13, 4907. Hutt, P. K., Islam, M. M., Rabheru, A., and McDoweU, M. R. C. (l976).J. Phys. B 9,2447. Inokuti, M., and McDowell, M. R. C. (1974). J. Phys. B 7 , 2382. Inokuti, M., Saxon, R. P.,and Dehmer, J. L. (1975). I n t . J. Rodiat. P h p . Chem. 7 , 109. Jaduszliwer, B., and Paul, D. A. L. (1973). Can. J. Phys. 51, 1565. Jaduszliwer, B., and Paul, D. A. L. (1974a). Can. J . Phys. 52, 272. Jaduszliwer, B., and Paul, D. A. L. (1974b). Can. J. Phys. 52, 1047. Jaduszliwer, B., Keever, W. C., and Paul, D. A. L. (1972). Can. J. Phys. 50, 1414. Jaduszliwer, B., Nakashima, A., and Paul, D. A. L. (1975). Can. J . f h y s . 53, %2. Joachain, C. J., Vanderpoorten, R., Winters, K. H., and Byron, F. W., Jr. (1977). J. Phys. B 10, 227. Kauppila, W. E., and Stein, T. S. (1982). Con. J. Phys. 60,471. Kauppila, W. E., Stein, T. S., and Jesion, G. (1976a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 36, 580. Kauppila, W. E., Stein, T. S . , Pol, V., and Jesion, G. (1976b). Proc. I n t . Conf. Positron Annihilation, 4th (Helsingor A b s t r . ) p. 25. Kauppila, W. E., Stein, T. S., Smart, J. H., and Pol, V. (1977a). Proc. I n t . Cotif. Phys. Electron. Atom. Collisions, 10th Abstr., p. 826. Kauppila, W. E., Stein, T. S., Jesion, G., Dababneh, M. S.,and Pol, V. (1977b). Rev. Sci. lnstrrim. 48, 822. Kauppila, W. E . , Stein, T. S. , Smart, J. H., Dababneh, M. S.,Ho, Y. K.,Downing, J. P., and Pol, V. (1981a).fhys. Rev. A 24, 725. Kauppila, W. E., Dababneh, M. S., Hoffman, K. R., Hsieh, Y.-F.,Pol, V., and Stein, T. S. (1981b). Proc. I n t . Conf. Phys. Electron. Atom. Collisions, 12th Abstr., p. 422.
96
Talbert S . Stein and Walter E . Kauppila
Kennedy, R. E., and Bonham, R. A. (1978). Phys. Rev. A 17, 1844. Kim, Y.-K., and Inokuti, M. (1971). Phys. Re\,. A 3, 665. Leventhal, M . , MacCallum, C. J., and Stang, P. D. (1978). Astrophys. J . 225, L1 I . McEachran, R. P., Morgan, D. L., Ryman, A. G., and Stauffer, A. D. (1977).J. Pliys. B 10, 663. McEachran, R. P.,Ryman, A. G., and Stauffer, A. D. (1978). J . Phys. B 11, 551. McEachran, R. P., Ryman, A. G., and Stauffer, A. D. (1979). J. Pliys. B 12, 1031. McEachran, R. P., Stauffer, A. D., and Campbell, L. E. M. (1980). J. Phys. B 13, 1281. Mandal, P., Ghosh, A. S., and Sil, N. C. (1975). J. Phys. B 8, 2377. Mandal, P., Guha, S., and Sil, N. C. (1979). J. P/iys. B 12, 2913. Mandal, P., Guha, S., and Sil, N. C. (1980). Phys. Rev. A 22, 2623. Massey, H. S. W. (1976). Phys. Todcry 29 (3), 42. Massey, H. S. W., and Moussa, A. H. (1961). Proc. Pliys. Soc. 77, 811. Massey, H. S. W., Lawson, J., and Thompson, D. G. (1966).In “Quantum Theory of Atoms, Molecules, Solid State” (P.-0. Lowdin, ed.), p. 203. Academic Press, New York. Milloy, H. B., and Crompton, R. W. (1977). Phys. Rev. A 15, 1847. Mills, A. P., Jr. (1980). Appl. Phys. L e t t . 37, 667. Mills, A. P., Jr., Platzman, P. M., and Brown, B. L. (1978). Phyh. Rev. Lett. 41, 1076. Montgomery, R. E., and LaBahn, R. W. (1970). C m . J . f l i p s . 48, 1288. Total cross section values were provided by R. E. Montgomery and R. W. LaBahn, (private communication). Murray, C. A., and Mills, A. P., Jr. (1980). Solid Stccte Cornmrrn. 34, 789. Murray, C. A., Mills, A. P., Jr., and Rowe, J. E. (1980). S i y f . Sci. 100, 647. Naccache, P. F., and McDowell, M. R. C . (1974). J . Phys. B 7, 2203. Nesbet, R. K . (1979). J. Phvs. B 12, L243. O’Malley, T. F. (1963). Phys. Re\,. 130, 1020. O’Malley, T. F. (1977). Phys. Lett. 64A, 1%. O’Malley, T. F., Spruch, L., and Rosenberg, L . (1961). J. M d i . Pliys. 2, 491. Ramsauer, C. (1921a). A n n . Phys. ( L e i p z i ~ 64, ) 513. Ramsauer, C. (1921b). Ann. Phys. ( L c i p z i g ) 66, 546. Ramsauer, C. (1923). Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 72, 345. Ramsauer, C., and Kollath, R. (1929). Ann. Phys. ( L e i p z i g ) 3, 536. Schrader, D. M. (1979). Phys. Re\*. A 20, 918. Sinapius, G., Raith, W., and Wilson, W. G. (1980). J . Phys. B 13, 4079. Stein, T. S., and Kauppila, W. E. (1982). I n “Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions” (S. Datz, ed.), p. 311. North-Holland Publ., Amsterdam. Stein, T. S., Kauppila, W. E., and Roellig, L. 0. (1974). Reiq. Sci. Instrrrm. 45, 951. Stein, T. S . , Kauppila, W. E., and Roellig, L. 0. (1975). PIiys. Lett. SlA, 327. Stein, T. S . , Kauppila, W. E., Pol, V., Smart, J. H., and Jesion, G. (1978). Phys. Re\’. A 17, 1600. Stein, T. S., Laperriere, F., Dababneh, M. S. , Hsieh, Y-F., Pol, V., and Kauppila, W. E . (1981). Proc. 1nt. Coi!f: Pkys. Electron. Atom. Collisions, l2th Abstr., p. 424. Tip, A. (1977).J. Phys. B 10, LII. Tong, B. Y. (1972). Phys. Rein. B 5, 1436. Townsend, J. S., and Bailey, V. A. (1922). Philos. M n g . 43, 593. Tsai, J-S., Lebow, L., and Paul, D. A. L. (1976). Ctrn. J . PAys. 54, 1741. Wadehra, J. M.. Stein, T. S., and Kauppila, W. E. (1981). J. Pltys. B 14, L783. Wagenaar, R. W., and de Heer, F. J. (1980). J . Phys. B 13, 3855. Wilson, W. G. (1978). J. Pliys. B 11, L629. Yau, A . W., McEachran, R. P., and Stauffer, A. D. (1978). J . Phys. B 11, 2907.
.
.
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS VOL 18
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS J . MORELLEC. D . NORMAND. and G. PETITE Seri3ic.e d e Pliysiyiie des Atnnies et des Siirjuces Centre d'Eriides Niiclkiires de Sacloy G[f-.sirr-Yi.ette. Frcince
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . The Theory of Multiphoton Ionization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . The Method of Bebb and Gold . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . The Truncated-Summation Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Implicit Summation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Numerical Results: Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Effect of Light Polarization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Coherence (Photon Statistics) Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H . Breakdown of Lowest Order Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . Ill . Absolute Measurements of Multiphoton Ionization Cross Sections . . . A . General Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Principle of the Experiment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Direct Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Saturation Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Identification of the Ionization Process Investigated: Background Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Recent Improvements in the Measurement of the Laser Intensity Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Experimental Results: Comparison with Theory . . . . . . . . . . . A . Absolute Cross Sections in Linearly Polarized Light . . . . . . . B . Effects of the Laser Light Polarization . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Destructive Interference Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Two-Photon Ionization of Cesium Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Three-Photon Ionization of Potassium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . New Trends . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Above-Threshold Ionization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Angular Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Double Multiphoton Ionization of Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
98 101 101 104 105 106 109 114
115 117 119 119 121
126 128 131 132 133 133 138 140 140 143 149 151 151 155 156 157 160
97 Copyright 0 1982 by Academic Press. Inc . All rights of reproduction in any form reserved . ISBN 0-12-003818-8
98
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
I. Introduction This is a review of nonresonant multiphoton ionization processes with emphases on the experimental aspect. Following the review by Lambropoulos (1976), our prime concern here is on works published since then. We have tried to be as exhaustive and objective as possible; however, it is not inconceivable that some important contributions to the field have passed unnoticed. Such omissions should be considered as completely involuntary. Multiphoton ionization is merely one aspect of the extensive field of multiphoton processes. Its history can be traced back to the early 1960s, with the first predictions and theoretical treatments of multiphoton ionization (Geltman, 1963; Keldysh 1964), the first experimental observation being reported by Voronov and Delone ( 1965). The continued interest it has aroused ever since may be due to several reasons: (1) its importance in technological applications such as isotope separation, laser induced fusion, and gas breakdown; (2) the continuous challenge it has represented to theory concerning a large variety of problem such as high-order perturbation theories, nonperturbative treatments of atom-light interaction, or to experiment, as attested by the only recently solved problem of absolute measurement of multiphoton ionization probabilities; (3) the fact that it becomes, as pointed out early by Bunkin and Prokhorov (1964), the dominant process when intensity is increased. A typical multiphoton ionization process is represented in Fig. 1. In such a process, photons with energy too low to ionize the atom are "piled up" to reach the ionization threshold. The atom therefore has to transit through a succession of intermediate states. In the most general case, such intermediate states are not eigenstates of the atom, and they are therefore often referred to as "virtual" states. Although the question of the nature of the lifetime of virtual states is rather ambiguous, it may generally be considered to be very short, that is, on the order of one sec). Therefore, multiphoton ionization can be deoptical cycle (= fined as the ionization of an atom through simultaneous absorption of several photons. Bounds between multiphoton ionization and the laser intensity are represented in Fig. 2. It can be shown that the probability of an N-photon process is, in the framework of the lowest order perturbation theory, proportional to the Nth power of the laser intensity, and thus is represented in log-log coordinates by a straight line of slope N . Several of these curves, corresponding to different orders of multiphoton ionization processes, are represented in Fig. 2, and they show that when the order of the process is increased, the intensity required for their observation in-
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
99
-7-
FIG.1.
Schematic diagram of a multiphoton ionization process.
creases. Multiphoton ionization processes have been observed for intensities ranging from lo7 W/cmZ(two-photon ionization of alkalis) to a few 1015 W/cmz (21-photon ionization of helium). The latter figure is close to the atomic unit of intensity and brings up the question of the limits of the validity of perturbation theory. W (sec-') A
105
107
10'
laser intenrity ( W cm-' )
Fib. 2. Multiphoton ionization probability as a function of the laser intensity for different Nth-order processes.
100
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
Another cause for breakdown of the lowest order perturbation theory is the possible presence of resonances in the multiphoton ionization process. Resonances are due to the coincidence between the energy of an allowed atomic transition and that of an integer number of photons, or equivalently to the fact that an allowed multiphoton transition toward a given atomic state is energy conserving. Resonant multiphoton ionization processes have caused a great upsurge of interest in recent years. However, they will be excluded from the scope of this contribution, since they were reviewed recently (Georges and Lambropoulos, 1980). Section I1 is devoted to a survey of the results obtained when lowest order perturbation theory is applied to the problem of multiphoton ionization. In fact, most of the fundamental theoretical work on nonresonant multiphoton ionization is quite old and has been extensively reviewed by Lambropoulos ( 1976). Recent improvements in the theory of multiphoton ionization deal with situations where lowest order perturbation theory breaks down, namely, the case of resonant processes and that of very high laser intensities. Resonant multiphoton ionization is excluded from the scope of this contribution, and there is no experimental evidence of a breakdown of lowest order perturbation theory for the strongest laser intensities used in nonresonant multiphoton ionization experiments to date. Therefore, to obtain a reasonable self-consistency and also avoid unnecessary overlap between this review and that of Lambropoulos (1976), we only give a brief survey of the formal theory of nonresonant multiphoton ionization (NRMPI) and put the emphasis on the points which have recently been subject to decisive improvements as concerns the comparison between theory and experiment. The experimental part of this contribution is divided in two sections. Section I11 reviews a number of experiments which have been performed with currently available solid state lasers to measure absolute values of multiphoton ionization cross sections at a few selected wavelengths. The results of the different methods of determination of the ionization cross section are compared with the results of different calculations in Section IV. Section V is devoted to a different type of experiment, those performed with dye lasers whose ability to continuously scan wide ranges of wavelength allows one to demonstrate and measure cross-section interference minima occurring between two resonances. The effects of light polarization are also reviewed in Section V because they were expected in some theoretical works to be particularly dramatic around the interference minima (Lambropoulos and Teague, 1976; Declemy er cil., 1981; Delone er d.,1981).
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
101
This contribution ends with Section VI, which is devoted to new trends appearing in the field. The measurement of the characteristics of the outgoing electron allows one to obtain experimental informations on the angular distribution of the differential cross section which cannot be obtained with the current ion detection technique. Experiments on the energy spectrum of the outgoing electron gave rise to a new line of experiments on above threshold ionization (ATI), a process in which the atom absorbs more than the minimum number of photons necessary for ionization. Both of these fields together with the question of double ionization, represent a possible future area for experiments on multiphoton ionization of atoms. Recent developments have been reported in fields closely related to multiphoton ionization such as the ionization of small molecules and multiphoton ionization of atoms at high pressures, where collective effects can be of importance. They have not been included because they require quite different theoretical treatment, and also because, with only little anticipation, one can think that they both could be the subject of a review by themselves.
11. The Theory of Multiphoton Ionization A. GENERAL FORMALISM
It is now a common statement that NRMPI is conveniently handled by lowest order perturbation theory. Both semiclassical and full quantum treatment of the multiphoton ionization problem are possible. Since we neglect the influence of spontaneous processes throughout this article, both have to lead to identical results. However, one may be more convenient than the other for a specific problem. Semiclassical formalism will, for instance, handle the problem of the influence of laser bandwidth more easily, whereas the full quantum mechanical treatment has proved to be very useful in the case of resonant multiphoton ionization. The latter will be presented here, since a large majority of authors seem to prefer it. The Hamiltonian of the system “atom plus field” is where H,A is the atomic Hamiltonian, H R is the Hamiltonian of the free
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
102
radiation field, and V is the atom-field interaction Hamiltonian. The radiation Hamiltonian can be written as
where for simplicity the laser field is supposed to be reduced to a single longitudinal mode of frequency w k , wave number k , and polarization A , and ( I & and (ikA represent the usual creation and anihilation operators (Messiah, 1965). The eigenstates of H R are the usual Fock states Inkh) (Messiah, 1965) defined by the occupation number of the mode ( A , A). The eigenstates of H,, are obtained as the direct products of an atomic state ) by a field state In ). At t = 0, the atom is supposed to be in its ground state lg) and the field populated by 17 photons, so that our initial state can be written as
The interaction Hamiltonian is, in most cases, given by the electric dipole approximat ion
where Ekh is the polarization vector of the laser mode and L is the dimension of the quantization volume ( h = c = 1 is assumed throughout this article). Suppose that the atom ionizes by absorption of N photons. The final state of the system will be
If)
where is an atomic state belonging to the continuum. If we neglect the influence of the ionization processes involving absorption of more than N photons, which is discussed at the end of this section, the ionization probability at the time t can be computed from the evolution operator of the system as
U(r) can be computed in different ways. An integral equation can be derived from the Schrodinger equation (Bebb and Gold, 1966), leading to
U'"(t) = 1 - i
1; V ' " ( t ' ) U ' " ( t ' )
dr'
(7)
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
103
where the operators are written in the interaction representation, that is,
vtryt) = p,,tVe-wIlr
(8)
U ( t ) can also be computed from the resolvent operator of the system (Goldberger and Watson, 1964) defined as a function of the complex variable Z by
G(Z) = ( Z - H ) - '
(9)
U ( t ) is obtained through
U(r) = (27ri)-1
I, -~zG(z) ~IZ r
(10)
For positive times, Z can be replaced by x + i q , and the integration carried out over X from += to -= and the limit taken for q + +O. Because of its ability to incorporate resonance effects in an almost straightforward way, the resolvent operator formalism has been used in most of the recent work on multiphoton ionization (Beers and Armstrong, 1975; Gontier and Trahin, 1979; Petite et a / . , 1979). In the case of nonresonant multiphoton ionization by moderate fields, an exact solution of Eqs. (7) or (9) and (10) is not necessary. NRMPI can be accounted for by computing the lowest order, nonvanishing term of the perturbation expansion of U(r),that is, the N-order term for a N-photon process. This is often referred to as the "weak field approximation." The resolvent operator can be expanded in power series of V G(Z) = G"(Z)[l
+
2 (VGO(Z))n] n=1
where Go(Z) = (Z - HO)-'
(12)
whose matrix elements can easily be computed. The N-order term in the expansion of U F I ( t )is then calculated from G$Y'(Z) = (FIGo(Z)(VGo(Z))NIZ)
(13)
through an integral similar to Eq. (10). It is then a matter of algebraic manipulation to obtain the N-photon ionization probability. For detailed calculations, the reader is referred to Lambropoulos (1976) or to the original articles. The ionization probability then is written as
104
J . Morellee, D . Normand, and G . Petite
where the energies w I , w A, and wF incorporate the energies of the photons that “dress” the different atomic states. The summation is carried over ( N - 1) intermediate states, which are allowed to span the complete atomic spectrum. p ( w F ) represents the density of final states. A similar result could be obtained from Eq. (7) through an iterative procedure up to the orderN in V“’(Bebb and Gold, 1966). It is then an easy matter to separate the field quantities from the atomic quantities in Eq. (14). As long as the ionization probability remains small compared to unity, that is, far from the saturation of the ionization process, an ionization rate can be defined whose dependence toward the photon flux F (photons/cm2 sec) is W):)
=
gNF.V
(15)
where uN is the total generalized N-photon ionization cross section given by
I
uN = [ ( 2 7 ~ ( ~ ) ~ ” / / 4 r r ~ ] t IM>,S’p n Q w ~ dR,
(16)
where CY is the fine-structure constant, Q is the wave number of the outgoing electron, and the integration is over the direction of propagation of the outgoing electron; M # ) contains the dependence of w N on the atomic structure and is defined by
) r depends on the laser polarization, and u1 . . * aN-l are where r ( A= N - 1 pure (undressed) atomic states. The calculation of Ml;) is now the dominant problem in the determination of the ionization probability. Calculation of M)? will rest upon several approximations. First, for all atoms, except hydrogen, the wave functions and thus the transition matrix elements are not known exactly, and one has to resort to approximations such as the quantum defect method (QDM) or more or less precise model potentials for their evaluation. Another difficult task is to perform the summation over an infinite set of atomic states, including the continuum. This summation cannot be performed exactly (at least explicitly), and one has to resort to approximations. Different kinds of approximations with different levels of accuracy have been proposed, and we now review the main approaches which have been used.
B . THEMETHODOF BEBBAND GOLD If, in Eq. (17), the denominator can be factorized, since the summation runs over complete sets of atomic states, closure relations can be used,
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
I05
and the numerator thus takes the form of a simple&’-order matrix element between lg) and I f ) . This is achieved by using an “average frequency” W(v)independent of the state to replace the atomic frequency ( w ~ ,-, wg) in each summation. A little algebra shows that this average frequency is determined for the vth summation by
M:i) being given by
Further simplification can be obtained by assuming that there is a single average frequency w independent of the order v, so that N-1
N-1
Although the number of matrix elements to be evaluated has been greatly reduced by this procedure, the evaluation of the average frequency by Eqs. (18) and (20) still involves infinite summations. However, if approximate average frequencies can be found, which can be done by trial and error, for instance, the calculation ofM#’has been greatly reduced. Bebb and Gold (1966) have applied this method to the case of hydrogen and rare gases, and their results are compared later to those of more sophisticated treatments. As a further simplification Morton (1967) proposed to replace the numerators in Eq. (17) by an “average matrix element” by using one “effective energy level.” By this method Morton has calculated the multiphoton ionization generalized cross section for hydrogen, noble gases, and alkalis.
C. THETRUNCATED-SUMMATION METHOD Another way of circumventing the problem of the infinite summation in Eq. (17) can be based on the following remarks. Starting with a given atomic state, the matrix element of I . ( ~ ) decreases as one goes to higher states. Meanwhile, the corresponding energy denominator starts to increase after a certain state. Therefore, a rapid drop of the contribution of higher states to each sum can be expected, and a good accuracy can be obtained by considering only a limited number of atomic states. Moreover, it is usually possible to estimate the error introduced by this trunca-
106
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G.Petite
tion by using sum rules. The dimension of the summation being kept within reasonable limits, there is a large choice of methods available for the determination of the matrix elements. Usually quantum defect method (QDM) (Bates and Damgaard, 1949; Seaton, 1958; Burgess and Seaton, 1960) can be used when suitable, but also model potential calculations or even experimental determinations of the oscillator strengths can be used with profit. The truncated summation method has been used by different authors, mainly in the case of alkalis (Bebb, 1966, 1967; Lambropoulos and 1976). Teague, 1976; Teague and Lambropoulos, 1976a,b; Teague et d., The three techniques we have reviewed thus far deal with the evaluation of the infinite sum in Eq. (17). Attempts have been made to calculate the multiphoton ionization probability avoiding the explicit calculation of this infinite sum. The two most successful approaches have been the use of the Schwartz and Tiemann technique, and the use of the Green’s function method. D. IMPLICITSUMMATION
I . Tlir Method
of’ Sdi iiwrt:
cirid
Ticnitrriri
This method is based on the implicit summation technique introduced by Dalgarno and Lewis (1955; Dalgarno, 1963) and later reformulated by Schwartz and Tiemann (1959). The principle of this method can be presented with a great simplicity using the resolvent operator formalism. Consider a two-photon ionization process. The two-photon ionization probability is computed from the matrix element of the resolvent operator,
where, since we are interested in lowest order processes, we have retained in V the part representing photon absorption only, denoted v-. Straightforwardly, one has
The determination of G ii)(Z)now rests upon the calculation of the matrix element
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
107
We define the ket I VL2)(Z)) by
Ivp’(z))= ( Z
-
H,)-’V-lg)
(23)
1 V P ) ( Z ) is now the solution of the inhomogeneous differential equation (Z - H,)IV;Yz)) = v - J g )
(24)
This method can be generalized to any order by an iterative procedure, If I V Y - ” ( Z ) ) is defined by )VbN-I)(Z)) (GoV-)“-21g)
(25)
I V k v ) ( Z) and therefore G # ) ( Z ) is determined by the following differential equation: ( Z - H , ) ( V p ( Z ) )= V-lVb“-’)( Z ))
(26)
The determination of I V ~ + ” ( Z )and ) , that of Gil)(Z), now rests upon the solution of a set of ( N - 1) inhomogeneous differential equations. It is worth noting that these equations are not coupled. However, they have to be solved by increasing order to obtain the equation giving G # ) ( Z ) . The formal simplicity of the method as presented above must not conceal the fact that most of the algebra, particularly all the angular algebra, still has to be performed in the ‘ Y ’ representation, leading to rather complicated calculations. 1970; Rapoport et d.,1969; Klarsfeld, 1969, It was shown (Zon et d., 1970; Karule, 1971) that in the case of two-photon ionization of hydrogen, analytic solutions can be found in terms of hypergeometric functions. Comparison with earlier results obtained through numerical solutions of the differential equation (Zernik, 1964) led to a very good agreement. The multiphoton case has been thoroughly studied by Gontier and Trahin (1968, 1971) in the case of hydrogen. Results are presented for multiphoton processes of order up to eight. In the case of two-photon ionization, their numerical results are in excellent agreement with the other works quoted above. For completeness, we should add to the above-mentioned work on two-photon processes calculations by different authors (Robinson and Geltmann, 1967; Mizuno, 1973; Choudhury and Gupta, 1974; Chang and Poe, 1974) in which the summation is carried out implicitly as in the Dalgarno and Lewis (1955) technique. In a recent work on the four-photon ionization of cesium (Crance and Aymar, 1980a; Aymar and Crance, 1979), the same technique is used to compute multiphoton bound-bound and bound-free matrix elements.
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
108
The Green’s function method is based on the following remark. If we isolate the uth summation in Eq. (171, it contains the expression
which can be written in the I’ representation
which is nothing but the single-electron Green’s function of the atom G (r, r’; R) evaluated at the energy R = w g + m k . G(r, r’; 0)can be found as the solution of the following differential equation: (H,4(r)- R)G(r, r‘; 0) =
-
&r
-
r’)
(27)
M).:’ can be written, using the Green’s function as the following N-fold integral : M);) =
I
d3rp . . .
I
~ ~ r ~ + ~ ( r rNPl; ~ ) r wg ~+ ~ (( Nr -~ 1,) q . )
x I’!$?IG(rN-1rN-2;Wg -k ( N
- 2)Wk)
Details on the algebra involved in this method can be found in Lambropoulos (1976) or in the original papers. As for the Schwartz and Tiemann method, analytical solutions can be found in the case of hydrogen. Karule (1971) has calculated the generalized cross section for the two-photon ionization of hydrogen. However, this method leads to almost inextricable calculations for processes of higher orders. The use of the Sturmian representation of the Green’s function (Karule, 1975; Maquet, 1977) has allowed generalized cross sections for orders up to 16 to be calculated, giving, in addition, valuable information on the effect of light polarization. Comparison between these results and those obtained by the method of Schwartz and Tiemann shows a very good agreement. For atoms other than hydrogen, where the Green’s function is not known analytically, phenomenological Green’s functions have been constructed (Zon et d . , 1970, 1972: Davydkin et d.,1971) using QDM. Results have been obtained in the case of He 2’sand He 2%. Manakov r t t i / . ( 1973) have calculated the multiphoton ionization cross-section of alkalis
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
109
by neodymium and ruby laser light, fundamental and frequency doubled, linearly and circularly polarized. Other work on alkalis has been published since (Flank and Rachman, 1975; Flank et d.,1976; Laplanche et d., 1976a; Manakov et d.,1978; Rachman et (11.. 1978). In a recent article on the two-photon ionization of Cs, Declemy ct nl. (1981) include the effect of spin-orbit coupling. Before concluding this review of the different methods of calculation of the multiphoton ionization probability, and turning to the presentation of numerical results, we would like to add some comments on the precision which can be expected from the different methods presented above. The first three methods (average frequency, average matrix element, truncated summation) are subject to limitations of two kinds: (1) how the approximate summation approaches the exact infinite summation, and (2) exactly how the atomic quantities (wave functions, transition matrix elements) are known. The last two methods (Schwartz and Tiemann, Green’s function) are subject to the second limitation only. Therefore, they are expected to give more accurate results. One can even say that, in the case of hydrogen, they should give the best possible results for multiphoton ionization generalized cross sections, as far as lowest order perturbation theory holds. E. N U M E R I C ARESULTS: L DISCUSSION
The purpose of this section is twofold: to give a reasonably complete review of the numerical values calculated for different multiphoton ionization generalized cross sections and to comment on the possible causes of the discrepancies among different results in an attempt to determine the advantages and the drawbacks of the different methods. In the discussion, we shall emphasize the results which can possibly be compared with recent experimental work, whose reliability, as far as absolute measurements of multiphoton ionization cross sections are concerned, has been considerably improved. The case of hydrogen obviously does not fall in this category. There are few experimental results on multiphoton ionization of hydrogen (Lu Van at d., 1973). Its interest lies in the fact that, exact solutions being available in this case, it is a good test for more approximate treatments which have to be used for other atoms. Table I presents the comparison between results obtained by Morton (1967), Bebb and Gold (1966), and Gontier and Trahin (1971) on multiphoton ionization of hydrogen in its ground state, for four different wavelengths (the emission wavelengths of the neodymium and ruby lasers, fundamental and frequency doubled). Re-
110
. I Morellec, . D . Normand, and G . Petite TABLE I
MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION RATESFOR ATOMIC HYDROGEN"
h
(8)
10,600 6943 5300 347 I
N
Morton ( 1967)
Bebb and Gold ( 1966)
Gontier and Trahin (1971)
I2 8 6 4
3.9(154) 7.1(99) 1.5(71) 1.5(42)
3 .O( 149) 3.6(96) 3.3(70) 6.6(43)
0.9(96) 1.25(69) -
~~
~
~~
" Numbers in parentheses indicate the power of ten by which the first number has to be divided to obtain the ionization rate.
sults obtained by Karule (1975) and Maquet (1977) are identical to those of Gontier and Trahin (1971). Only the last publication of different authors has been utilized. We have tabulated the ionization rate (in sec-I) corresponding to a laser intensity of 1 W/cm2. The numbers in parenthesis indicate the power of ten by which the first number has to be divided to obtain the ionization rate. Whenever comparison is possible, Bebb and Gold results are closer than Morton's to those of Gontier and Trahin, which were obtained without approximation and whose reliability is confirmed by the agreement between different results obtained by different methods of equivalent accuracy. This leads to the conclusion that Bebb and Gold results can be relied on, at least as an indication of the order of magnitude of the ionization rate. Comparison between the results of Bebb and Gold (1966) and Gontier and Trahin (1971) is shown in Fig. 3, where the ionization rate is plotted versus the laser wavelength, for six- and eight-photon ionization of hydrogen. The discrepancies between the two sets of results increase in the region where the ionization rate is minimum. This can be easily understood from the fact that the minima of the ionization rates are due to destructive interferences between several ionization channels. It is well known that, in such a case, a precise determination of the different transition amplitudes is necessary to account for the interference minimum. Table I1 shows results obtained by different authors on two-photon ionization of atomic hydrogen in its ground state. The quantity tabulated in W-' cm4. These results are obtained for linearly is ( u l l ) x polarized light. Very complete data on multiphoton ionization of hydrogen in various excited states can be found in Maquet (1975).' Different conventions have been used in the literature, essentially theoretical, to present the results on ionization cross sections. In general, throughout this contribution we have respected the author's choice. The two usually used are ( I ) the generalized multiphoton
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
111
a (10.98 15
I
\
i
10”
i 10”
\ lo10
I ‘
ii I(
5000
, ,
I
h
I
7000
5129 h8 69L3 7180 FIG.3 . Six- and eight-photon generalized MPI cross sections of atomic hydrogen versus Gontier and Trahin (1971); (- . -) Bebb and Gold (1966); the photon wavelength (A): (-) ) I = I is a reminder that the ionization process starts from the fundamental state I s of H.
Alkalis have received considerable attention from both the experimentalists and the theoreticians. Calculations in alkalis rest upon approximations such as QDM or model potential, but their atomic properties are well known, which makes them one of the best tools for comparison between theory and experiment. ionization cross section uN= W / F Nin units of cmzNsecN-l; (2) that used in Table I1 (and also in Fig. 3, and by many other authors). Here u is the usual cross section in cmx ( W I F ) , and ( u / P 1 )is an intensity-independent quantity of the same kind as u N ,but in units of W1-N anzN. Of course, these two representations are linked by the elementary relation uN= E Z - l (u/P”+)where E,, is the photon energy (J). The subscript notation has been reserved throughout to the generalized multiphoton cross section (1).
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
112
TABLE I1 TWO-PHOTON IONIZATION CROSSSECTIONS FOR ATOMIC HYDROGEN"
Bebb and Gold .A
(A,
925 975 I020 I100 1200 I300 1400 1600 1700
( 1966)
10 660
I10 70 68 84
Chan and Tang ( 1969) 51.5 67.5 4.01 630 128 84.5 91.5 103
Klarsfeld ( 1969)
Gontier and Trahin (1971)
55.2 4.05 580 128 84.5 91.4 102
55.2 4.05 580 128 84.5 91.4 102
Kristenko and Vetc hinkin (1976)
Laplanche (1976b)
Karule (1978)
1.29 61.7 55.2 4.05 580 128 84.5 91.4 102
2.04 49.2 70.8 4.04 642 128 84.7 91.8 103
2.03 49. I 70.9 4.0 642 I27 84.5 91.5 103
Pi
trl.
( u l f )x 10'' for two-photon ionization of atomic hydrogen (u = W / F is the ionization cross section). Bebb and Gold, average frequency method; Chan and Tang, Gontier and Trahin: Schwartz and Tiemann's method. Others: Green's function method (units, W-' cm4).
Table I11 compares results obtained on the ionization rate of alkalis by different authors for a set of commonly used laser wavelengths. Bebb (1966, 1967) used a truncated summation method and QDM; Manakov et d.(1973) used the Green's function method and QDM, and so did Laplanche ef d.(1976a) and McGuire (1981). Results were obtained by Manakov et d.(1978) using the Green's function method and a model potential instead of QDM. Other results have been obtained by Teague et a / . (1976) for the three-photon ionization of Cs and K at 6943 and by Crance and Aymar (1980a)and Aymar and Crance (1980) for the two- and four-photon ionization of Cs at 5300 and 10,600 A. These results will be commented upon in Section I11 as concerns their comparison with experimental results. A general comment on Table I11 is that the overall dispersion of the results quoted there is about one order of magnitude. This would be rather poor in the case of hydrogen, but given the uncertainty on alkalis oscillator strengths and the nonlinearity of the processes, this must be considered as a satisfying agreement in this case. The largest discrepancies are observed close to resonances (three-photon ionization of Cs at 6943 A) or in the vicinity of deep mimina between two resonances (five-photon ionization of Na at 10,600 A, two-photon ionization of Cs at 5300.A). It has been proven since that resonant multiphoton ionization requires a more sophisticated treatment than lowest order perturbation theory, and we have already mentioned that the regions of the minima require a precise knowledge of the atomic wave functions. This is particularly emphasized by the strong
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
113
TABLE 111 MPI GENERAl.17ED CROS5 SECTIONS FOR ALKALIS" Two-photon ionization generalized cross sections
Atom Li Na K Rb
cs
A
(A)
3471 3471 3471 5300 3471 5300 3471 4300
Bebb (1966) 7.8 (50) 6.0 (53) 3.1 (50) 5.1 (50) 2.9 (49) 2.6 (49) 9.0 (50)
('I
Manakov t d . (1973)
2.42 (49) 6.25 (52) 3.08 (50) 1.61 (49) 2.53 (50) I .08 (49) 2.52 (49) 7.41 (49)
Manakov d.(1978)
McGuire (1981)
1.14 (49) 5.52 ( 5 2 ) 7.24 (50) 1.12 (49) 4.16 (49) 1.55 (48) 4.16 (49) 1.55 (48)
1 .o (49) 4.0 (51)
('1
4.0 (49) 1.5 (50) 4.0 (49) 2.0 (49)
Three-photon ionization generalized cross sections
Atom Li Na K Rb cs
A
(A)
5300 5300 6943 6943 6943 6943
Bebb (1967) 9.0 (81) 4.3 (77) 7.0 (80) 9.0 (78) 6.3 (78)
Manakov (1973)
('I t i / .
2.33 (78) 9.33 (78) 1.87 (79) I . 14 (78) 9.57 (78)
Manakov r i d . (1978)
Laplanche (1976a)
McGuire (1981)
-
2.0 (81) 2.0 (81) I .o (77) 5.0 (80) 4.0 (78) 1.0 (77)
PI t i / .
7.14 (82)
-
1.05 (77) 2.00 (79) 3.68 (78) 1.02 (77)
9.31 (78) 3.72 (79) I . 17 (77) I .oo (77)
Four- and five-photon ionization generalized cross sections Atom
A
(A)
N
Manakov (1973)
i'r t i / .
Manakov (1978)
C! ( I / .
~~
Li Na K Rb
cs
6943 10,600 10,600 10,600 10.600 10,600
4 5
5
4 4 4
3.52 (106) I .37 (137) 3.96 (138) 4.38 (107) 1.32 (107) 5.16 (107)
5.14 9.18 2.14 7.14
(142) (108) (108) (108)
'' In unitspf cmZvsecN-l. Numbers in parentheses indicate the negative power of ten by which the first figure has to be multiplied 17.8 (50) reads 7.8 x
dispersion between the results obtained by the same authors (Manakov rt ol., 1973, 1978),in such cases, by methods which differ only by the potential used (QDM and Fues potential, respectively). Concerning McCuire's results (19811, it should be mentioned that, as stated by this author, due to
114
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
his particular use of QDM, his dispersion curves may be subject to an overall wavelength shift. This has especially important consequences in the areas of the curve which exhibit rapid variation, that is, those areas close to resonances and interference minima. Rare gases have also received considerable attention from experimentalists, but far less than theoreticians. This is due to their rather complicated structure, which makes them difficult to handle, at least, for the higher members of the series. However, both Bebb and Gold (1966) and Morton (1%7) have given results on different rare gases for a set of different laser wavelengths, and the comparison of their results is given by Morton (1967). A special case is that of helium. Three-photon ionization probabilities of helium in both the P S and 2's states have been calculated by Zon et crl. (1972) and more recently by Olsenet d . (1978), Lompre et a/. (1980), and Aymar and Crance (1980). Figure 4 shows the comparison between these last two results (identical) and Olsen's, and the agreement is found to be excellent. The results of Zon er al. (1972) agree rather well with these in the case of the triplet state (within 15%) but differ by about a factor of three in the case of the singlet state, which may be due to the presence of a two-photon resonance nearby which cannot be satisfactorily accounted for in lowest order perturbative treatment.
F. EFFECTOF LIGHTPOLARIZATION All the results quoted so far have been obtained for linearly polarized light. Number of authors have published results on the effect of light polarization, which will be reviewed in this section. The influence of the light polarization on the ionization probability arises from two different causes. First, the evaluation of the matrix elements in the numerator of Eq. (17) requires some angular algebra, and the Clebsh-Gordon coefficients which appear in this algebra will depend on the polarization index A . Second, all the intermediate transitions appearing in the ionization process are subject to selection rules on the angular momentum. For instance, dipole-selection rules for a single-electron atom will be, for a one-photon transition, AJ = 5 1 , O (0 c* 0 forbidden), A M = 0 for light linearly polarized along the quantization axis, and A M = 2 I for light circularly polarized, and propagating along the quantization axis, the plus (minus, respectively) sign corresponding to the right (left, respectively) polarization. It is an easy matter (with the help, for instance, of Kastler diagrams) to demonstrate that the differences between the M selection rules result in a limitation of the number of channels available for ionization by circular light compared with linear light. Calculation of the effect of light polarization on multiphoton ionization
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
t
lo8'
115
11111111111 u,350 4
14,400
14,440
Laser frequency ( cm-') (-)
FIG.4. Three-photon ionization generalized cross sections of He (2's)and He (2?3): Lompre et c d . (1980); ( + + + ) Olsen et d.(1978).
of hydrogen have been published by Zon et al. (1972), Gontier and Trahin (1973), Karule (1978); and Maquet (1977). In addition, Zon er a/. (1972) present results of the same kind on the 23S, and 2's states of helium. The case of alkalis has been treated by Manakov et al. (1973, 1978), Lambropoulos and Teague (1976), Teague er al. (1976), Laplanche et al. (1976a), and Declemy e t a / . (1981). Particular interest has been paid to the case of two-photon ionization of cesium in the region of the minimum of ionization between the 6P and 7P resonances (see Section V). Finally we should mention that polarization effects can lead to very exciting application of multiphoton ionization as a source of polarized electrons. G . COHERENCE (PHOTON STATISTICS) EFFECTS When writing the ionization probability in the form WN = uNFN,we have supposed that the laser field was monochromatic, that is, time independent. This, of course, is not the case in most of the experiments, and the influence of the laser coherence on multiphoton ionization has received much attention. However, apart from the problem of resonant
I16
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
processes, which is still under investigation, no new work has been published since the review of Lambropoulos (1976), to which the reader is referred for precise information. Let us just recall a few basic facts. Equation (15), the ionization probability, has been derived in the case of a purely monochromatic field, a condition seldom fulfilled in experiments. Real laser fields will exhibit amplitude and phase fluctuations which have to be averaged in the calculation of the ionization probability. I n general, we must therefore write the ionization probability as WN
=
uNGN
(29)
where GN is the Nth moment of the photon distribution, which can be computed from the diagonal matrix elements of the density matrix of the initial field state P,, by (Glauber, 1963a,b)
Equation (15) can then be considered as a special case of Eq. (29) when a single longitudinal mode laser (whose field is best represented by a Glauber state, or coherent state) is considered. If we consider instead the case of an incoherent (or “chaotic”) light, we can prove (Glauber, 1963b) G 7‘ = N I G C O H (3 1) * N It follows that incoherent light is N ! more efficient than coherent light when an N-order process is considered. This is due to the “bunching effect” associated with noncoherent light (Mandel and Wolf, 1965). This can be easily understood from the fact that, in a nonresonant multiphoton ionization process, the atom has to transit through a number of intermediate states whose “lifetime” is very short (less than sec) since they are not energy conserving. Therefore, the simultaneous absorption of N photons has a better chance to occur if these photons are bunched (incoherent light) than if they are not (coherent light). The two typical cases mentioned above are closely enough realized by single longitudinal mode lasers (coherent light) and lasers operating on a large number of modes (50 or more: chaotic light). For intermediate situations (a few modes, mode-locked lasers, etc.) one has to rely on specific models for the state of the field (Debethune, 1972). Figure 5 shows the behavior of the sixth-order correlation function of a laser field as a function of the number of modes in the case of stationary independent modes. It is a particularly noticeable property of multiphoton ionization that a n N-photon process can be used to measure the Nth moment of the field, and therefore provides an excellent experimental check of laser fields statistical models (Sanchez, 1975).
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
t
L
/
117
/
FIG.5 . Sixth-order moment of a laser field as a function of the number of modes of the laser for stationary independent modes (SIM).
H. BREAKDOWN OF LOWEST ORDER PERTURBATION THEORY
There are some physical situations where the lowest order perturbation theory is no longer a satisfying tool for handling multiphoton ionization. The most common of these situations is that of resonant processes. Since they are not within the scope of this article, we shall limit ourselves to a few indications and refer the reader to a review by Georges and Lambropoulos (1980). In the derivation of the expression (14) of the ionization probability from the expansion (13) of the resolvent operator, a number of terms have been neglected. This was done because these terms were oscillating at a frequency equal to the energy detuning from intermediate states, and therefore averaged to zero (Lambropoulos, 1976). This, of course, is no longer true in the case of resonant processes, and results in a divergence of bq. (14) when one of the denominator vanishes. Different approaches have been used to solve this problem. Two of them have been particularly successful: the method of projection operators (Gontier and Trahin, 1979; Petite et d.,1979) and that of the effective Hamiltonian (Beers and Armstrong, 1975; Crance and Feneuille, 1977; Crance, 1978), both applied to the dressed-atom model (Cohen-Tannoudji, 1967). It has been demonstrated that, in the case of resonant processes, it is generally impossible to
118
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
define an ionization rate. Moreover, two different types of resonances can be distinguished, depending upon whether the resonant state is more strongly coupled to the continuum (crossing resonances) or to the initial state (anticrossing resonances). Energy shift and width effects can be accounted for this way in a satisfactory manner. Alternating current Stark shift of atomic states also can have important effects in some cases of nonresonant processes. This may occur in the vicinity of the interference minimum between two resonances; the energy shift of the atomic states, as well as the corresponding modifications of the wave functions, can result in a shift of the position of the minimum analogous to the resonance shifts observed in resonant processes (Morellec et d., 1976; Grinchuk et d., 1975; Petiteet d., 1979) and have similar effects. Edwards and Armstrong (1980) predict deviations of the law of variation of the ionization probability on the laser intensity from the I .v law. This result was obtained by computing terms up to the sixth order of the laser field for a two-photon ionization process. They found that this effect could be detectable for laser intensities of a few hundred megawatts per square centimeter or higher. However, this has not been observed by Normand and Morellec (19811, even for an intensity of 40 GW/cm2,and the discrepancy probably results from interaction volume effects. The problem of multiphoton ionization under very high laser intensities is another example of the possible breakdown of the lowest order perturbation theory. This can be expected from the following simple argument. There is neither mathematical nor physical sense in treating the electromagnetic field as a perturbation when it exceeds the atomic field seen by the electron. There is a need for a nonperturbative theory of multiphoton ionization, and although no completely satisfactory theory has been built thus far, a few attempts have been made in this direction, which should lead in the not too far future to the solution of this problem. Gontier et ti/. (1976), in a fully quantized formalism, have developed a method of summation of all the proper diagrams contributing to a given ionization process. In this way, they are able to determine an analytic continuation of the perturbation series in regions where it does not converge anymore. A “resummed” resolvent operator obtained by this method has been successfully applied to the problem of resonant processes (Gontier and Trahin, 1979), and the influence of higher order terms on angular distribution has been studied with a similar method (Gontier tv d., 1975). The final results of such calculations are expressed as continuous fractions which have to be truncated, but it must be clear that such a truncation does not restrict the maximum order of the diagrams accounted for. The same authors (Gontier et d.,1981) recently published a generalization of the Schwartz and Tiemann method to the case of resummed
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
119
operators which should be a solution to the problem of ultrastrong fields, and although no numerical application of their method is available yet, there is a hope that such calculations will be possible in the near future. Another approach has been proposed (Chu and Reinhardt, 1977). It is based on the analytical continuation of the Floquet Hamiltonian (Shirley, 1965) of the atom plus field system, obtained through a dilatation transformation I' refe. Although no further work on this method has been published yet, it seems to be a promising approach to the problem of strong fields.
-
111. Absolute Measurements of Multiphoton Ionization Cross Sections A. G E N E R ACONSIDERATIONS L Although a large diversity exists in experimental arrangements reported in the MPI domain, some general features can be usefully recalled in a ' schematic representation (Fig. 6). The main purposes of this basic apparatus are as follows: (1) Preparing the target of gaseous atoms in the vacuum vessel. The vacuum pump reduces the pressure of residual gases to to Torr. Then the gas is introduced at a pressure whose upper limit of about Torr (-4 x 1013atoms/cm3)preserves the strictly independent behavior of the atoms involved in the interaction. When the target is an alkali atomic beam, the density is in general limited to 10°-1010 ~ m - ~ .
C
F I G .6. Experimental setup for a MPI experiment.
120
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite
( 2 ) Ionizing the atoms in the middle of the interelectrode system. The lenses are placed inside or outside the vacuum cell, depending on their focal length. The choice depends on the intensity required at the focus for the MPI process investigated. Typical focal sections of cm’ and a few 10+ cm2 are obtained by focusing a single-mode laser radiation with cylindrical or spherical lenses, respectively (Cervenan and Isenor, 1974; Alimov et ( I / . , 1973; Lompre et a/., 1977; Normand and Morellec, 1980). This allows an increase of the laser intensity by a factor of u p to lo6. (3) Separating the electric charges by a transversal electric field. Classically, the ions are repelled toward a time-of-flight mass analyzer, and the ion signal is then amplified by an electron multiplier.
Parasitic surface emission of ions and electrons due to light reflections inside the vessel is limited by tilting the windows or using antireflection coated windows. However, the most efficient precaution against surface effects is collection over a small angular aperture a (Fig. 6). The photodiode and the calorimeter measure, respectively, the time duration and the laser pulse energy. The photometric arrangement allows one to determine the spatial distribution of the laser intensity. When experiments are devoted to qualitative studies of multiphoton ionization (MPI) such as the dependence of the ion production on the laser intensity, the influence of light polarization, or resonances on the ionization rate, they do not need the measurement of the spatiotemporal laser intensity distribution I ( r , 1 ) . In that case, one has only to detect an ion signal which is proportional to the number of ions N t and measures the laser pulse energy eL, whose spatial and temporal distributions are assumed to be constant from pulse to pulse. Conversely, the determination of MPI cross sections require quantitative measurements of N t and Z(r, t ) . Until the advent of single-mode Iasers, the rotating-prism, Q-switched lasers delivered incoherent pulses of bad reproducibility and large spectral width. This led to bad estimates of spatiotemporal intensity distribution, resulting in large errors in g N and obviously poor agreement with the theoretical values of mN then available (three-photon ionization of singlet and triplet metastable states of helium, Bakos et a/., 1970; two- and fourphoton ionization of potassium, Held et d., 1972; two-, three-, four-, and five-photon ionization of potassium and sodium, Delone et d.,1974; three-photon ionization of cesium, Evans and Thonemann, 1972). These experiments have been reviewed (Lambropoulos, 1976), and we shall focus instead on more recent results obtained under more precise conditions, mainly as concerns the laser coherence properties and the accuracy of laser intensity determination.
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
B. PRINCIPLE OF
THE
121
EXPERIMENT
I . Gencwrl Determincition
of the Ion
field
Using Eq. (15), the ionization rate, it is possible to determine the experimental ion yield, that is, the number of ions created by a given laser pulse. We assume that the dependence of the laser intensity on space and time can be factorized in the following way: I(r,
1) =
IMf(r)g(r)
(32)
where f(r) and g(t) are the spatial and temporal normalized intensity distributions and I,,, is the maximum laser intensity derived from the photon flux F by I,,, = F / E p where E p is the photon energy (J). Then, the number of ions created by the laser pulse can be written as Ni = noUNTNFNVN
where no is the neutral density, and V , and tion volume and time, defined by VN =
1,f”(
r) dv
7,
(33) are the Nth-order interac(34)
where the volume integral is over the whole space. The expression (33) of the ionization yield is valid only in the case where this yield is weak enough so that the depletion of neutral atoms can safely be neglected. Some experiments utilize the behavior of the ionization in the saturation region in order to deduce the ionization probability, a point which we discuss later. The measurements of Niand no are different for each experiment and will be described further (Section 111,D).The quantities T ~ ,Z, and V , appear to be measured in the same way in all laboratories: the Nth-order interaction time T, [Eq. (35)] is generally derived from the measurement of the time duration of the laser pulse T by means of a fast photodiode. Some experiments have been performed using picosecond laser pulses. In this case, more sophisticated equipment (in most cases, built around a streak camera) was used to measure the pulse duration; T is obtained from the pulse as follows: T = g ( t ) dr. The maximum laser intensity I,,, and the Nth-order interaction volume V , are determined by photodensitometry. Figure 7 shows isodensitograms of photos taken in different Z positions on the laser propagation axis in the +X
122
J . Morellec, D . Normand, and G . Petite 53
SL
1m m FIG.7. Isodensitometric mapping of the laser beam section for four different positions along the propagation axis in the region of the best focus.
vicinity of the best focus and for constant shot-to-shot laser energy (Morellec rf d., 1976). The energy which crosses any plane of the Z axis during one pulse is EL
=
eZ =
I
I(x, y ,
Z,
t ) d.r dy d f
(36)
el., the laserenergy, is measured by a calorimeter. From Eqs. (32) and (36)
we deduce EL = TIM
I
f(X,
Y , Z) dx dY
(37)
f(s,y , z) is a dimensionless factor. If the origin of the coordinates is chosen at the best focus, we havef(o, 0,0 )= 1 . Let
I
f ( x , y,
0)d.r
dy
=
So
(38)
The term So is obtained from the isodensitometry of the photo located at the best focus. The maximum laser intensity is then IM
=
ELITSO
(39)
Finally, the generalized multiphoton ionization cross section u,,,can be expressed with Eqs. (33) and (39) as a function of all the interaction parameters :
NONRESONANT MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION OF ATOMS
123
The Nth-order interaction volume VNhas been defined in Eq. (34). Contrary to the measurement of I,, which requires the densitometry of only one photo located at the best focus, the measurement of VN needs the processing of a set of photos between z = 0 and zmaxvalues for which the ion production becomes negligible. The distribution function of the ion production in a z plane is SN(z) = J.f"(x, Y , 2) dx dY
The Nth-order interaction volume results from the integration of SN(z): (41) The determination of I, explicitly requires the separation of the time and space distribution functions, as in Eq. (32). This condition was not fulfilled in the case of lasers Q-switched by rotating prisms in the first multiphoton experiments. Then, the direction of emission of the laser system chan