Advances in
ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS V O L U M E 51
Editors PAUL R. B ERMAN
University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan C HUN C. L IN
University of Wisconsin Madison, Wisconsin H ERBERT WALTHER
University of Munich and Max-Planck-Institut für Quantenoptik Garching bei München Germany
Editorial Board C. J OACHAIN
Université Libre de Bruxelles Brussels, Belgium M. G AVRILA
F.O.M. Insituut voor Atoom- en Molecuulfysica Amsterdam, The Netherlands M. I NOKUTI
Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Illinois
Founding Editor S IR DAVID BATES
Supplements 1. Atoms in Intense Laser Fields, Mihai Gavrila, Ed. 2. Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics, Paul R. Berman, Ed. 3. Cross Section Data, Mitio Inokuti, Ed.
ADVANCES IN
ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS Edited by
H.H. Stroke DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS NEW YORK UNIVERSITY NEW YORK
Volume 51
Amsterdam · Boston · Heidelberg · London · New York · Oxford Paris · San Diego · San Francisco · Singapore · Sydney · Tokyo
ELSEVIER B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC1X 8RR UK
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Inc., and the following terms and conditions apply to its use:
Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2005
ISBN: 0 12 003851 X ISSN: 1049-250X ∞ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of
Paper). Printed in USA.
Dedicated to B ENJAMIN B EDERSON
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
C ONTRIBUTORS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xiii
Introduction, by H. Henry Stroke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
Appreciation of Ben Bederson as Editor of Advances in Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, by Herbert Walther . . . . . . . . . . .
9
Benjamin Bederson Curriculum Vitae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
Research Publications of Benjamin Bederson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17
A Proper Homage to Our Ben, by Harry Lustig . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23
Benjamin Bederson in the Army, World War II, by Val L. Fitch . . . .
29
Physics Needs Heroes Too, by C. Duncan Rice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
35
Two Civic Scientists—Benjamin Bederson and the other Benjamin, by Neal Lane . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
41
An Editor Par Excellence, by Eugen Merzbacher . . . . . . . . . . . . .
49
Ben as APS Editor, by Bernd Crasemann . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
57
Ben Bederson: Physicist–Historian . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
65
Roger H. Stuewer 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wartime Reminiscences . . . . . . . . Physics and New York City . . . . . . APS Forum on the History of Physics Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
65 66 69 73 74 74
viii
Contents
Pedagogical Notes on Classical Casimir Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
75
Larry Spruch 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dimensional Analysis and Physical Arguments The Vanishing of E¯ Cl . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An Unauthorized Thank You . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
76 77 78 81 81
Polarizabilities of 3 P Atoms and van der Waals Coefficients for Their Interaction with Helium Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
83
X. Chu and A. Dalgarno 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Theory: Dynamic Polarizabilities . . Numerical Method . . . . . . . . . . Results: Static Dipole Polarizabilities Van der Waals Coefficients . . . . . . Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
84 84 86 88 89 90 90
The Two Electron Molecular Bond Revisited: From Bohr Orbits to Two-Center Orbitals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
93
Goong Chen, Siu A. Chin, Yusheng Dou, Kishore T. Kapale, Moochan Kim, Anatoly A. Svidzinsky, Kerim Urtekin, Han Xiong and Marlan O. Scully 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. A. B. C. D.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recent Progress Based on Bohr’s Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General Results and Fundamental Properties of Wave Functions . . . Analytical Wave Mechanical Solutions for One Electron Molecules . Two Electron Molecules: Cusp Conditions and Correlation Functions Modelling of Diatomic Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alternative Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Separation of Variables for the H+ 2 -like Schrödinger Equation . . . . . The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) for Large λ . . . . . . . . . . . . The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) as λ → 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . Expansions of Solution Near λ ≈ 1 and λ 1: Trial Wave Functions of James and Coolidge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. The Many-Centered, One Electron Problem in Momentum Space . . .
95 107 111 135 145 155 184 191 191 192 192 193 194 196 198
Contents
ix
F. Derivation of the Cusp Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1 ∇ 2 − 2m ∇2 G. Center of Mass Coordinates for the Kinetic Energy − 2m 1 1 2 2 H. Verifications of the Cusp Conditions for Two-Centered Orbitals in Prolate Spheroidal Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Integrals with the Heitler–London Wave Functions . . . . . . . . . . . J. Derivations Related to the Laplacian for Section 6.4 . . . . . . . . . . K. Recursion Relations and Their Derivations for Section 6.4 . . . . . . . L. Derivations for the 5-Term Recurrence Relations (6.81) . . . . . . . . M. Dimensional Scaling in Spherical Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
203 208 210 216 217 222 231 232 236
Resonance Fluorescence of Two-Level Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
239
H. Walther 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Theory of the Spectrum of Resonance Fluorescence . . . . . . . . . . 3. Total Scattered Intensity, Intensity Correlations, and Photon Antibunching . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. More Theoretical Results—Variants of the AC Stark Effect . . . . . . 5. Experimental Studies of the Spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Spectrum at Low Scattering Intensities and Extremely High Resolution 7. Experiments on the Intensity Correlation—Photon Antibunching . . . 8. Photon Correlation Measured with a Single Trapped Particle . . . . . 9. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
239 240 244 245 247 251 260 266 269 270
Atomic Physics with Radioactive Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
273
Jacques Pinard and H. Henry Stroke 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Introduction . . . . . . “Off-line” Experiments “On-line” Experiments Bohr–Weisskopf Effect References . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
274 275 280 294 296
Thermal Electron Attachment and Detachment in Gases . . . . . . . .
299
Thomas M. Miller 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. FALP Apparatus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Electron Attachment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
300 303 309
x
Contents 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Electron Detachment Electron Affinity . . . New Plasma Effects . Concluding Remarks Acknowledgements . References . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
323 329 330 332 334 336
Recent Developments in the Measurement of Static Electric Dipole Polarizabilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
343
Harvey Gould and Thomas M. Miller 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deflection in Electric Field Gradients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Light Force Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Interferometry Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laser-Cooled Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alkali Polarizability, Lifetime and the Dispersion Coefficient . . . . . Ionic Polarizabilities from Lifetimes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Core Polarizability from Microwave Spectroscopy of Rydberg Atoms and Ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
344 346 347 349 350 352 354 354
Trapping and Moving Atoms on Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
363
355 356 357 357
Robert J. Celotta and Joseph A. Stroscio 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . Moving Atoms . . . . . . Atom Dynamics . . . . . Summary and Comments Future Expectations . . . Acknowledgements . . . References . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
364 365 369 380 380 382 382
Electron-Impact Excitation Cross Sections of Sodium . . . . . . . . . .
385
Chun C. Lin and John B. Boffard 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Excitation out of the Ground State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
385 387
Contents 3. 4. 5. 6.
Excitation out of Laser Excited States Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
xi . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
401 407 409 409
Atomic and Ionic Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
413
Edward Pollack Ben Bederson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Collisions Involving Heavy Solar Wind Ions 3. Collisions Involving H0 Projectiles . . . . . . 4. Proton Collisions in the Io Plasma Torus . . 5. Surface Collisions with Highly-Charged Ions 6. Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
414 414 416 422 441 443 446 447
Atomic Interactions in Weakly Ionized Gas: Ionizing Shock Waves in Neon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
451
Leposava Vuškovi´c and Svetozar Popovi´c 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Electron Impact Ionization from Excited Neon Energy Pooling Processes in Neon . . . . . . . Ionizing Shock Waves in Neon . . . . . . . . . Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
452 455 457 462 466 466 466
Approaches to Perfect/Complete Scattering Experiments in Atomic and Molecular Physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
471
H. Kleinpoppen, B. Lohmann, A. Grum-Grzhimailo and U. Becker 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introductory Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Analysis of Atomic Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Angle and Spin Resolved Analysis of Resonantly Excited Auger Decay Complete Experiments for Half-Collision; Auger Decay . . . . . . . . Analysis of Molecular Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
472 474 496 512 519 523 527
xii
Contents
Reflections on Teaching . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
535
Richard E. Collins Dedication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Recollections . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Characteristics of Great Teachers . 4. Characteristics of Great Teaching 5. Rewards of Teaching . . . . . . . 6. Who Should Teach? . . . . . . . . 7. Recognition of Excellent Teaching 8. Evaluation of Teaching . . . . . . 9. Assessment of Students . . . . . . 10. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . 12. References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
535 536 537 543 545 549 550 552 553 555 556 557 557
I NDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C ONTENTS OF VOLUMES IN T HIS S ERIAL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
559 575
CONTRIBUTORS
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the author’s contributions begin.
H. H ENRY S TROKE (3, 273), Department of Physics, New York University, 4 Washington Place, New York, NY 10003, USA H. WALTHER (9, 239), Max-Planck-Institut für Quantenoptik, Hans-Kopfermann-Strasse 1, 85748 Garching, Germany H ARRY L USTIG (23), The City College of the City University of New York, 138th Street & Convent Avenue, New York, NY 10031, USA, and The American Physical Society, One Physics Ellipse, College Park, MD 20740-3844, USA VAL L. F ITCH (29), Department of Physics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA C. D UNCAN R ICE (35), University of Aberdeen, Kings College, Aberdeen, AB24 3FX, UK N EAL L ANE (41), Department of Physics and Astronomy, Rice University, Houston, TX 77005, USA E UGEN M ERZBACHER (49), Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, CB#3255, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3255, USA B ERND C RASEMANN (57), Physics Department, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA ROGER H. S TUEWER (65), Program in History of Science and Technology, Tate Laboratory of Physics, University of Minnesota, 116 Church Street SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA L ARRY S PRUCH (75), Department of Physics, New York University, 4 Washington Place, New York, NY 10003, USA X. C HU (83), ITAMP, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA A. DALGARNO (83), ITAMP, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA G OONG C HEN (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Mathematics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA xiii
xiv
Contributors
S IU A. C HIN (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA Y USHENG D OU (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA K ISHORE T. K APALE (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA M OOCHAN K IM (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA A NATOLY A. S VIDZINSKY (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA K ERIM U RTEKIN (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA H AN X IONG (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA M ARLAN O. S CULLY (93), Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA, Depts. of Chemistry and Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Princeton University, NJ 08544, USA, and MaxPlanch-Institut für Quantenoptik, D-85748 Garching, Germany JACQUES P INARD (273), Laboratoire Aimé Cotton, Bât. 505, Faculté des Sciences, F91405 Orsay, France T HOMAS M. M ILLER (299, 343), Air Force Research Laboratory, Space Vehicles Directorate, Hanscom Air Force Base, MA 01731-3010, USA H ARVEY G OULD (343), MS: 71-259, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA ROBERT J. C ELOTTA (363), Electron Physics Group, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899-8412, USA J OSEPH A. S TROSCIO (363), Electron Physics Group, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899-8412, USA C HUN C. L IN (385), Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA J OHN B. B OFFARD (385), Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA E DWARD P OLLACK† (413), Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269, USA
† Deceased.
Contributors
xv
L EPOSAVA V UŠKOVI C´ (451), Department of Physics, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA 23529, USA S VETOZAR P OPOVI C´ (451), Department of Physics, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA 23529, USA H.H. K LEINPOPPEN (471), Atomic & Molecular Physics, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA, Scotland B. L OHMANN (471), Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster, Institut für Theoretische Physik, Wilhelm-Klemm-Str. 9, D-48149 Münster, Germany A. G RUM -G RZHIMAILO (471), Institute of Nuclear Physics, Moscow State University, Moscow 119992, Russia U.U. B ECKER (471), Fritz-Haber-Institut der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Faradayweg 4-6, D-14195 Berlin/Dahlem, Germany R ICHARD E. C OLLINS (535), The University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
This page intentionally left blank
BENJAMIN BEDERSON
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
INTRODUCTION H. HENRY STROKE
I am always suspicious when asked by Ben Bederson to get involved in some editorial work: once it cost me more than two years of intensive work when he persuaded me to edit “The Physical Review: The First 100 Years” [1] for the American Physical Society (APS) and the American Institute of Physics. On a second occasion, he legated to me the editorship of what is now CAMOP [2], and which has kept me occupied for over thirty years. Eugen Merzbacher in his contribution to this volume attests to Ben’s persuasiveness. In spite of these experiences, when asked to edit this book dedicated to him, I accepted with pleasure. For over fifty years Ben has played an important part in my life as a physicist, and also personally. The contributions in this volume are largely devoted to the legacy of Ben’s work, his influence in physics and on students and colleagues with whom he collaborated. Tom Miller, who has worked with Ben, looked into his antecedents [3]. I am grateful to him for providing the Bederson academic lineage: • Ogden Nicolas Rood, BS (Princeton, 1852) Professor and Head of Department, Columbia University • Robert Andrews Millikan, PhD (Columbia University, 1895) “On the Polarization of Light Emitted from the Surfaces of Incandescent Solids and Liquids” • Leonard Benedict Loeb, PhD (University of Chicago, 1916) “On the Mobilities of Gas Ions in High Electric Fields” • Leon Harold Fisher, PhD (University of California, Berkeley, 1944) “Three Problems in Electrical Discharges through Gases” • Benjamin Bederson, PhD (New York University, 1950) “Formative Time Lags of Spark Breakdown in Air” Titles of the theses are listed. Rood apparently did not have a PhD. Among his research fields were acoustics and optics. He authored a book on colorimetry, “Modern Chromatics”, which was valued as a reference by Impressionist painters, and he was a noted painter himself. Ben’s first post-World War II research was in the field of gas discharges. He described this early work in a talk at the 1992 Gaseous Electronics Confer3
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51002-4
4
H.H. Stroke
ence [4]. The talk also included the ensuing developments that led ultimately to his electron-scattering experiments. In 1950, Ben was on the staff in the Research Laboratory of Electronics (RLE) at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) when I first met him in the Atomic Beams Laboratory. I had taken a course in atomic physics with Jerrold Zacharias which inspired me to look for research in the same laboratory. I detail this part of Ben’s career because (1) it entailed physics that he did not pursue afterwards, and (2) it laid the experimental foundations for his physics thereafter. There were many exciting experiments and Ben was involved in a number of them. One of the important ones concerned the anomalous gyromagnetic ratio, gJ , of the electron. Quantum electrodynamics was in its relatively early stages and an atomic beam magnetic resonance (ABMR) experiment on hydrogen would be most important. But, compared to a number of earlier experiments with alkali atoms, where production of the atomic beam and its detection were easy, for hydrogen there were problems on both end. Alkali atomic beams are easily ionized by the process of surface ionization on a hot, high-work function, wire. The resulting ion current is readily measured. Hydrogen, however, is normally a molecule. So, Ben and his coworkers built an “atomizer” based on Wood’s tube [5], where his expertise in gas discharges was put to use in producing the hydrogen atomic beam. The detection part proved to be a great challenge as well: hydrogen has an ionization potential of 13.6 eV and its electron cannot be removed as with alkalis. John King [6] suggested instead the possibility of attaching an electron to the hydrogen atom on a very low work function surface: the electron affinity of hydrogen is only ≈0.7 eV. This was my first real experiment in physics, and it did not succeed. Ben invented a modification of the Pirani gauge, a device in which the incident gas atoms cool a heated wire, causing a measured change in resistance: In Ben’s scheme the incoming beam gas was compressed, increasing the sensitivity by several orders of magnitude. This work is described in the theses of two undergraduate students, Germaine Bousquet and Alan Odian [7] and in the review by King and Zacharias [8]. The other effort in the laboratory was in nuclear structure. This was only about one year after the introduction of the nuclear shell model by Maria Goeppert Mayer and J. Hans D. Jensen, and still before the collective model of the nucleus of Aage Bohr and Ben R. Mottelson. Only about a half dozen spins of odd–odd (odd-proton number, odd-neutron number) nuclei were known at the time and their coupling schemes were a matter of conjecture. After my rookie stage—cleaning oil diffusion pumps and spending months tracking down vacuum leaks in atomic beam apparatus, which by today’s standards would be considered quite primitive—I finally inherited my own ABMR system. With Ben and Vincent Jaccarino we succeeded in measuring the nuclear spin and magnetic moment of 134 Cs, a radioactive isotope with a half life of about 750 days. The experiment was
INTRODUCTION
5
done with a very strong source, the activity of which was close to 1010 becquerels. It would be difficult to obtain approval for such a quantity today! Ben also collaborated on an atomic beam experiment with potassium isotopes to measure the effect of the distributed nuclear magnetization on the atomic electron–nuclear interaction [9]. This effect had been observed with rubidium isotopes for the first time by Francis Bitter only a short while earlier. Ten years before then, Hans Kopfermann, in the first edition of his book on nuclear moments [10], remarked that this effect is much too small ever to be observed! Ben left for New York University (NYU) two years before work started in Zacharias’ laboratory on the first atomic clock, based on an ABMR in cesium. It was the prototype of today’s time and frequency standard. Three years after Ben left MIT, I came to Princeton as a postdoc. Shortly after I arrived, in April 1955, I was asked if I would be willing to meet Albert Einstein and tell him about the efforts that he heard were going on at MIT on a precision clock (the so-called fountain clock) that may be able to detect the gravitational red shift predicted by his theory [11]. I recall this as we are celebrating in 2005 the 100th anniversary of Einstein’s great papers—also commemorating the 50th anniversary of his death. Though I have recounted this event countless times, and will certainly incur Ben’s wrath in telling it again, the day of this memorable meeting was also another occasion for Ben’s (mild) persuasion: he introduced me to my future wife, Norma, who was an apartment-mate of his future wife Betty. Eight years later he exercised his power of persuasion once more that resulted in my giving up another academic offer in favor of NYU. This spans the early part of Ben’s career. The contributions in this volume continue the story. An aspect which is not covered is his importance in organizing scientific meetings. First there was the International Conference on the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions (ICPEAC) which he launched at NYU in the late 1950’s. Then there was the International Conference on Atomic Physics (ICAP), which also had its beginnings at NYU [12], unfortunately marred in the middle of the conference by the news of the assassination of Robert F. Kennedy on 6 June 1968. ICAP was an outgrowth of the “Brookhaven Conferences”, initiated and organized for many years by Victor Cohen. Initially they were devoted exclusively to atomic beam experiments, but they were soon extended to the rapidly growing new fields of atomic physics. ICPEAC and ICAP continue to this day as thriving meetings of the international community of atomic physicists. Ben played a seminal rôle in both of them. The people who have contributed to this volume have had interactions with Ben through his diverse interests and activities. A number were PhD students and postdocs in his laboratory, and colleagues with whom his interests intersected. These contributions constitute the latter part of the volume—first, theoretical then, experimental work. The first part of the volume is more personal, introduced by
6
H.H. Stroke
an epitomic poem on Ben’s career by Harry Lustig, emeritus Treasurer of the APS, who held the financial reins on Ben when he was the Editor-in-Chief of the Society. Val Fitch goes back to the early Bederson, at the time when both served at the Los Alamos Laboratory in World War II. Duncan Rice, Principal of the University of Aberdeen, writes from the point of view of a historian who had to be educated in the sciences while he was Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Science at NYU by Ben, then Dean of the Graduate School. Neil Lane writes of Ben as a citizen in the science community. Eugen Merzbacher and Bernd Crasemann recall Ben’s major activity as Editor-in-Chief of the APS. Finally, in this first part, Roger Stuewer comes to Ben’s latest activity, after having attained Emeritus status both at NYU and at the APS: historian of science and Editor of the History of Physics Newsletter (APS). Larry Spruch, long-time Ben’s colleague at NYU, provides a pedagogical paper on Casimir effects. Alex Dalgarno writes on dipole polarizabilities. Ben’s laboratory made significant contributions for their measurements with the introduction of the E–H gradient balance method [13], balancing electric and magnetic moment deflections in congruent magnetic and electric fields. Marlan Scully and collaborators contribute to the Molecular part of the name of this publication with their paper on molecular bonds. The last part groups the more experimental papers. Herbert Walther, who has been sharing the editorship of Advances in Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics (AAMOP) with Ben, discusses the current status of resonance fluorescence of two-level atoms, a subject that goes back seventy-five years to Victor F. Weisskopf’s doctoral thesis [14]. Parenthetically, in this paper Weisskopf also gives the theory underlying level-crossing spectroscopy. With Jacques Pinard, we give a brief review of atomic physics with radioactive atoms, to which Ben contributed early on. Two topics close to Ben’s interests, gaseous electronics and dipole polarizabilities, are treated extensively by Tom Miller and with Harvey Gould. Robert Celotta, extending Ben’s lineage, and Joseph Stroscio bring us upto-date on single-atom manipulation. Chun Lin, who with Paul Berman and Ennio Arimondo, is taking over as editor of AAMOP from Ben Bederson and Herbert Walther, writes on electron-impact excitations in collaboration with John Borrard. Edward Pollack, who was also a graduate of Ben’s laboratory, contributed his work on collision physics.1 A long-time collaborator of Ben’s, Lepša Vuškovi´c, joined by Svetozar Popovi´c, is back to Ben’s first field of research, gaseous electronics. Hans Kleinpoppen and his collaborators return to the subject which some years back Ben described as The “Perfect” Scattering Experiment [13].
1 When I first wrote this sentence, the verb was in the present. It is with great regret that we learned of Ed’s sudden passing. His friends and colleagues, a number of whom are contributors to this volume, express all their sympathy to his wife, Rita, and to the other members of their family.
INTRODUCTION
7
At the end, Richard Collins contributes an essay in which Ben’s influence as a teacher is recalled. I thank all the authors for having participated in creating this volume to honor a great colleague and a good friend, one who has contributed much to physics and to many of us as physicists by his insight, enthusiasm, and imagination. Anita Koch, Book Editor at Elsevier, has been most helpful and patient in its preparation. I particularly appreciate the historical input by Tom Miller. Finally, but not least, I am indebted to Eugen Merzbacher for critical reading and many constructive comments which have aided me in the preparation of this work.
References [1] Stroke H.H. (Ed.), “The Physical Review: The First Hundred Years, A Selection of Seminal Papers and Commentaries”, AIP Press, The American Physical Society, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1995. Includes CD-ROM. [2] Comments on Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics, published by Physica Scripta, Royal Swedish Academy of Science, Stockholm. [3] From library reference series on American Dissertations and R.A. Millikan’s autobiography. [4] Bederson B., Electron–atom scattering using atomic recoil, in: “Gaseous Electronics Conference”, Boston, MA, October 1992. [5] Wood R.W., “Physical Optics”, Dover, New York, 1967, p. 125. [6] King J.G., RLE (MIT) Quarterly Progress Report, 15 October 1950, p. 29. [7] Odian A.C., “An Improved Stern–Pirani Molecular Beam Detector”, S.B. Thesis, Department of Physics, MIT, June 1951; Bousquet A.G., “An Improved Stern–Pirani Detector for a Hydrogen Beam”, Id., June 1952. [8] King J.G., Zacharias J.R., Some new applications and techniques of molecular beams, in: Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics, vol. 8, Academic Press, New York, 1956. [9] Pinard J., Stroke H.H., Atomic physics with radioactive atoms, this volume. [10] Kopfermann H., “Kernmomente”, Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig, 1940. In the translation, “Nuclear Moments” (Academic Press, New York, 1958), this statement has of course vanished. [11] Naumann R., Stroke H., Einstein and the atomic clock, Physics World 9 (1996) 76; Naumann R.A., Stroke H.H., Apparatus upended: A short history of the fountain A-clock, Physics Today 49 (May 1996) 89; Naumann R.A., Stroke H.H., Nobelists played roles in implementation of ‘Fountain’ experiment, Physics Today 51 (February 1998) 15. [12] Bederson B., Cohen V.W., Pichanick F.M.J. (Eds.), “Proceedings of the First International Conference on Atomic Physics”, Plenum Press, New York, 1969. [13] See Research publications of Benjamin Bederson, this volume. [14] See reference in H. Walther, Resonance fluorescence of two-level atoms, this volume.
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
APPRECIATION OF BEN BEDERSON AS EDITOR OF ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS
This volume of Advances in Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics is dedicated to our highly esteemed colleague and friend, Ben Bederson, who was Editor of this series as of Volume 10 (published in 1974), when he succeeded Immanuel Estermann, the second founding Editor of the series together with Sir David Bates. Ben remained Editor up to Volume 50, making 40 volumes and three supplementary volumes shaped by him. During that period the name of the series was changed when Optical Physics was added to the title with Volume 26, published in 1989. This was done to emphasize the various new optics-based techniques playing a constantly increasing role in atomic and molecular physics. Furthermore, an editorial board supported the editors with proposals for new articles and with much other advice. Some board members contributed by generating supplementary volumes. The articles in Advances are a very good indicator of the enormous development of atomic and molecular physics in that period. Starting with Volume 33 (1995), after Sir David retired, I had the pleasure to work with Ben Bederson in editing Advances. It was great co-operating with Ben. He has an extensive view over the entire field resulting from his own research work and then as a member of many organizing bodies for meetings. He was, for example, one of the driving forces when the very successful conference series on Atomic Physics (ICAP) and the International Conference of the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions (ICPEAC) were established. Later, he became Editor-in-Chief of the American Physical Society, where he was confronted with physics publishing in general and problems of the new possibilities afforded by electronic publishing and problems presented by the enormous increase of physics papers during the eighties and at the beginning of the nineties. Ben’s outstanding insight into the entire field was always an enormous advantage when the authors for forthcoming volumes were being selected. His intuition for finding interesting and promising topics was unique and a great help in keeping the series in high demand. The Advances series met a challenge in the late nineties, when book-publishing in general got into financial difficulties. At this 9
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51003-6
10
H. Walther
time it was planned to merge Advances, still very successful, with a not so successful journal. Fortunately, this problem could be solved, leaving the series in good shape again. Now, new editors are coming on board so that the future also looks promising and bright. The atomic and molecular physics community thanks Ben for the outstanding work he performed as Editor of this highly successful series.
Herbert Walther
Garching, December 2004
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE
DATE OF BIRTH 1921
November 15
EDUCATION 1946 1948 1950
B.S. CCNY M.A. Columbia University Ph.D. New York University
FAMILY 1956
PRINCIPAL POSITIONS Scientific Aide 1944–46 Research Assistant and Instructor 1948–50 Staff Member (postdoc) 1950–52 Professonial rank 1952–92 Chair 1973–76 Dean 1986–89 Professor Emeritus 1992– Editor-in-Chief 1993–1996 Editor-in-Chief Emeritus 1997–
Married—Betty Weintraub Bederson Children—Joshua, Geoffrey, Aron, Benjamin
Manhattan Project, Los Alamos, NM (US Army, Special Engineering Detachment) New York University
Research Laboratory of Electronics, MIT (in J.R. Zachariasí atomic beams lab.) New York University, Physics Dept. New York University, Physics Dept. Graduate School of Arts and Science, New York University New York University American Physical Society American Physical Society
11
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51004-8
12
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE
OTHER POSITIONS Visiting Scientist 1962 Visiting Fellow 1968–69 Lecturer 1969 Visiting Fellow 1973 Lecturer 1984 Co-Director, Lecturer 1989 Visiting Fellow 1990 Co-Director, Lecturer 1992 Vice-Chair, Chair, Past-Chair 2000–2002 EDITORIAL Co-Editor (with Wade L. Fite) 1968 Editor 1978–1992
Co-Editor (with Sir David R. Bates) 1974–1992 (with Herbert Walther) 1993–2004 Co-Coordinator 1971–1974 Correspondent 1969–1971
Laboratoria Gas Ionizzati (CNEN) Frascati, Italy Joint Institute for Laboratory Astrophysics, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO Summer School in Atomic Physics, Bari, Italy Center for Theoretical Studies, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL NATO Advanced Study Institute, Palermo (Santa Flavia), Italy Winter College on Atomic and Molecular Physics: Photon-assisted collisions. International Center for Theoretical Physics, Trieste, Italy Institute for Theoretical Atomic and Molecular Physics, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, MA Winter College on Coherence in Atom–Radiation Interactions, International Center for Theoretical Physics Forum on History of Physics, American Physical Society
Methods of Experimental Physics, Atomic and Electron Physics, Vol 7A: Atomic Sources and Detectors, Vol 7B: Atomic Interactions, Academic Press Physical Review A, A1: Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics; A15: Statistical Physics, Plasmas, Fluids, and Related Interdisciplinary Topics, American Physical Society Advances in Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, Annual Series, Academic Press
Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics, Gordon and Breach
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE Associate Editor 1969–1999 Co-Editor (with F. Pichanik and V.W. Cohen) 1969 Co-Editor, with Sir H.S.W. Massey and E.W. McDaniel 1988 Editor 1999
Editor 2004–2007
13
Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables, Academic Press Atomic Physics: Proceedings of the First International Conference on Atomic Physics, Plenum Press, NY Applied Atomic Collision Physics, Five Volumes, Academic Press
Reviews of Modern Physics Special Issue in honor of the Centenary of the American Physical Society 71, 1999. Also published in hard cover, under the title “More Things in Heaven and Earth”, Springer-Verlag Forum on History of Physics Newsletter
PhD STUDENTS J.M. Hammer, H. Malamud, K. Rubin, J. Perel, A. Salop, E. Pollack, P. EnglanderGolden, K. Lulla, G. Sunshine, R.E. Collins, M. Goldstein, J. Levine, E.J. Robinson, P. Dittner, I.L. Klavan, R.J. Celotta, A. Kasdan, R. Molof, L. Schwartz, L. Schumann, F. Murray, V. Tarnovsky, S. Ron, R. Dang, P. Weiss, A. Tino, R. Kremens, T. Guella, G.-F. Shen, M. Zuo, T.Y. Jiang, C.H. Yang POSTDOCS AND VISITING COLLEAGUES B.B. Aubrey, D.M. Cox, H.H. Brown Jr., N.D. Bhaskar, J.A.D. Stockdale, T.M. Miller, B. Jaduszliwer, B. Stumpf, L. Vuskovic, J.T. Park RESEARCH INTERESTS Atomic collision phenomena and atomic structure; electronic and atomic interactions with polarized atoms and electrons; interactions of radiation fields, including laser fields, with atoms and molecules. Fundamental concepts in quantum mechanics. Measurements of electric polarizabilities of atoms, molecules and molecular clusters. Interactions of particles and fields with metal and alkali halide clusters. PROFESSIONAL MEMBERSHIPS, AWARDS Fellow, American Physical Society Fellow, American Association of Advancement of Science
14
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE
Honorary Member, Sigma Pi Sigma (Physics Honorary Society) Townsend Harris Medal, CCNY, 1993 CONSULTING AND ADVISING POSITIONS National Bureau of Standards Visiting Panel, Atomic Physics Division Advisory to the N.A.S. 1962–64 National Science Foundation Advisory Panel for Graduate Traineeships in Physical Science 1964–65 Member of Various IDA–ARPA panels and committees on atomic processes in upper atmosphere 1960–67 National Academy of Sciences—National Research Council Advisory Committee to Army Research Office ñ Durham 1968–74 Trustee and Member of Board of Directors, Institute for Medical Research and Studies 1960–73 Chairman, Committee on Atomic and Molecular Physics, National Academy of Sciences National Research Council 1960–73 Physical Advisory Committee, Physics Division, National Science Foundation 1973–76 Vice-Chairman, Chairman, Division of Electron and Atomic Physics, American Physical Society 1974–75 Chairman, Subcommittee on Energy, NAS-NRC Committee Atomic and Molecular Science 1975–76 Committee on Atomic and Molecular Science, NAS 1976–79 Committees on Science and Society and Science and Public Policy, NYAS 1977 Chairman, Nominating Committee DEAP-APS; Davisson–Germer Award Nominating Committee 1977 Evaluation Panel for the Joint Institute for Laboratory Astrophysics, Boulder, Quantum Physics Division, NBS (Chairman, 1979) 1978–80 Visiting Committee (Chairman, 1980), Argonne National Laboratory, Physics Division
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE
15
1978–80 Board of Governors, N.Y. Academy of Sciences 1977–79 Chairman, Panel for Absolute Physical Quantities, National Measurement Laboratory, National Bureau of Standards (NRC-NAS) 1980–83 Chairman, Survey Subcommittee, Committee on Atomic and Molecular Science (NRC-NAS) 1979–82 Visiting Panel (Physics Representative) Office of Naval Research 1985 Presidential Young Investigators Award Committee, NSF 1983–84 Vice-Chairman, Chairman, Chinese Scholars Program, Chinese Academy of Sciences–APS 1986–91 CONFERENCES Organizer and Secretary First and Second International Conference on the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions (ICPEAC) (New York University and University of Colorado) 1958–61 Member of Program and Steering Committees, ICPEACs 3, 4, 5 1963–67 Organizing Committee First International Conference on Atomic Physics (ICAP), New York University 1968 Vice Chairman, Gordon Conference on New Directions in Atomic Physics 1973–79 Vice Chairman, ICPEAC 13 (Berlin) 1983 Chairman, ICPEAC 14 (Stanford University) 1985 Executive Committee, ICPEAC 15 (Brighton, England) 1987 International Organizing Committee, ICAP 1968–88 International Program Committee, ICAP 1980–92 TEACHING Professor Bederson has taught a significant fraction of the regular undergraduate and graduate courses of the Physics Department over the years. He regularly
16
BENJAMIN BEDERSON CURRICULUM VITAE
taught the required area course in Advanced Atomic Physics, a third year graduate course, every other year. He has also regularly taught two “popular” physics courses. One is “Sound and Music”, a physics-oriented course on acoustics and music. The other is “Physics and Society”. This course was initiated by Professor Bederson in 1972, the first “popular” course to be offered in the Physics Department. He has taught it on the CBS “Sunrise Semester”. He has also presented a Humanities Seminar entitled “Human Values and Technological Choice”. PATENTS Nonelectric rectangular wave generator—2,706,256 Particle separation apparatus utilizing congruent inhomogeneous magnetostatic and electrostatic fields—3,113,207
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
Formative time lags in spark breakdown, with L.H. Fisher, Phys. Rev. 75, 1324 (1949). Also, PhD Thesis, New York U., Dissertation Abstracts International, Source Code SO-14. Search for the transition of streamer to Townsend form of spark in air, with L.H. Fisher, Phys. Rev. 75, 1615 (1949). Further measurements of formative time lags of spark breakdown in air at low overvoltages, with L.H. Fisher, Phys. Rev. 78, 331 (1950). Interpretation of formative time lags of spark breakdown in air at low overvoltages, with L.H. Fisher, Phys. Rev. 78, 331 (1950). Formative time lags of spark breakdown in air in uniform fields at low overvoltages, with L.H. Fisher, Phys. Rev. 81, 109 (1951). Determination of the ratio of the gJ (2 S1/2 ) values for potassium and hydrogen. The gyromagnetic ratio of the electron, with W.B. Pohlman and J.T. Eisinger, Phys. Rev. 83, 475 (1951). Magnetic moment of K40 and the hyperfine structure anomaly of the potassium isotopes, with J.T. Eisinger and B.T. Feld, Phys. Rev. 86, 73 (1952). Nonelectric rectangular wave generator, with M. Silver, Rev. Sci. Inst. 23, 133 (1952). Nuclear spin and magnetic moment of 55 Cs134 , with V. Jaccarino and H.H. Stroke, Phys. Rev. 87, 676 (1952). Low energy scattering of electrons by atoms, with J. Hammer and H. Malamud, Phys. Rev. 100, 1229 (1955). Measurement of the total, differential and exchange cross sections for the scattering of low energy electrons by potassium, with K. Rubin and J. Perel, Phys. Rev. 117, 151 (1960). An atomic beam E–H gradient spectrometer, with J. Eisinger, K. Rubin and A. Salop, Rev. Sci. Inst. 31 (1960); also “Proceedings of the International Symposium on Polarization Phenomena of Nucleons”, Basel, 1961; Helv. Phys. Act., Supp. IV. Measurement of the polarizability of the alkalis using the E–H gradient balance method, with A. Salop and E. Pollack, Phys. Rev. 124, 1431 (1961). 17
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51005-X
18
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
Measurement of total cross sections for the scattering of low-energy electrons by lithium, sodium and potassium, with J. Perel and P. Englander, Phys. Rev. 128, 1148 (1962). Absolute measurements of total cross sections for electron scattering by sodium atoms (0.5 eV–50 eV), with A. Kasdan and T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 8, 1562 (1963). Determination of the polarizability tensors of the magnetic substates of 3 P2 metastable argon, with E. Pollack and E.J. Robinson, Phys. Rev. 134, 1210 (1964). Metastable 3 P2 rare-gas polarizabilities, with E.J. Robinson and J. Levine, Phys. Rev. 146, 95 (1966). Absolute measurements of total cross sections for the scattering of low energy electrons by atomic and molecular oxygen, with G. Sunshine and B.B. Aubrey, Phys. Rev. 154, 1 (1967). Elastic differential spin exchange cross sections for scattering of slow electrons by potassium, with R.E. Collins, M. Goldstein and K. Rubin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 1366 (1967). Crossed-beam electron–neutral experiments, in: B. Bederson and W.L. Fite (Eds.), Atomic Interactions Part A, Atomic and Electron Physics, Vol. 7, Academic Press, 1968, p. 67. Measurement of the electric dipole polarizabilities of metastable mercury, with J. Levine and R. Celotta, Phys. Rev. 171, 31 (1968). Potassium-electron elastic spin-exchange: comparison of experiment with a closecoupling calculation, with R.E. Collins, M. Goldstein and K. Rubin, Phys. Lett. A 27, 440 (1968). Electron-alkali metal inelastic recoil experiments with spin-analysis: experimental method and the small-angle behavior of the 4 2 S1/2 –4 2 P1/2,3/2 excitation of potassium, with K. Rubin, M. Goldstein and R. Collins, Phys. Rev. 182, 201 (1969). The perfect scattering experiment I, II, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 1, 41; 65 (1969). Summary of recent spin-analyzed electron-potassium differential cross section measurements, with R.E. Collins, M. Goldstein and K. Rubin, in: F. Bopp and H. Kleinpoppen (Eds.), “Physics of the One- and Two-Electron Atoms”, NorthHolland, Amsterdam, 1969, p. 642 ff. Report on elastic collisions of low-energy electrons with alkali metals I, II, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 1 (1970). Total electron–atom collision cross sections at low energies—A critical review, with L.J. Kieffer, Rev. Mod. Phys. 43, 601 (1971). Differential spin-exchange and elastic scattering of low-energy electrons by potassium, with R.E. Collins and M. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. A 3, 1976 (1971).
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
19
Measurements of the total cross sections for scattering of low-energy electrons by metastable argon, with R. Celotta, H.H. Brown Jr. and R. Molof, Phys. Rev. A 3, 1622 (1971). Electron–atom excitation with spin-analysis, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 2, 160 (1971). Differential cross sections with spin-analysis for 4 2 S1/2 –4 2 P1/2,3/2 excitation of potassium by electrons, with M. Goldstein and A. Kasdan, Phys. Rev. A 5, 660 (1972). Energy loss of a low energy ion beam in passage through an equilibrium cesium plasma, with L.L. Klavan, D.M. Cox and H.H. Brown Jr., Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1254 (1972). Electron polarization behavior in collisions, in: “Atomic Physics III, Proceedings of Third International Conference on Atomic Physics”, Plenum Press, New York, 1972, pp. 401–427. Absolute measurements of total cross sections for electron scattering by sodium atoms (0.5–50 eV), with A. Kasdan and T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 8, 1562 (1973). Production of polarized electrons with the help of a tunable dye laser, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 4, 103 (1973). Measurements of the average dipole polarizabilities of the alkali dimers, with R.W. Molof, T.M. Miller, H.L. Schwartz and J.T. Park, J. Chem. Phys. 61, 1816 (1974). Measurements of electric dipole polarizabilities of the alkali metal atoms and the metastable noble gas atoms, with R.W. Molof, H.L. Schwartz and T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 10, 1131 (1974). Measurement of the static electric dipole polarizabilities of barium and strontium, with H.L. Schwartz and T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 10, 1924 (1974). Energy loss of a low-energy ion beam in passage through an equilibrium cesium plasma, with D.M. Cox, H.H. Brown Jr. and I. Klavan, Phys. Rev. A 10, 1409 (1974). Transport properties of a weakly-ionized cesium plasma, with D.M. Cox, H.H. Brown Jr., L. Schumann and F. Murray, Phys. Rev. A 10, 1711 (1974). Spin-polarization in electron–atom scattering, with T.M. Miller, in: “Electron and Photon Interactions with Atoms, Proceedings of International Symposium”, Stirling, Scotland, Plenum Press, NY, 1976, pp. 191–202. Measurement of the polarizability of calcium, with T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 14, 1572 (1976). Differential spin exchange in the elastic scattering of low energy electrons by rubidium, with B. Jaduszliwer and N.D. Bhaskar, Phys. Rev. A 14, 162 (1976). Atomic and molecular polarizabilities—a review, with T.M. Miller, in: Advances in Atomic and Molecular Physics, Vol. 13, Academic Press, NY, 1977, pp. 1–55.
20
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
Scattering of low energy electrons by excited state sodium atoms using a photon and electron atomic beam recoil technique, with N. Bhaskar and B. Jaduszliwer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 38, 14 (1977). A high temperature atomic beam source, with J.A. Stockdale, L. Schumann and H.H. Brown Jr., Rev. Sci. Inst. 48, 938 (1977). Total cross sections for the scattering of low-energy electrons by excited sodium atoms, with B. Jaduszliwer, R. Dang and P. Weiss, in: “Proceedings of Coherence and Correlation Workshop”, London, Plenum Press, NY, 1979. Total cross sections for the scattering of low-energy electrons by excited sodium atoms in the 3 2 P3/2 , mJ = ±3/2 state, with B. Jaduszliwer, R. Dang and P. Weiss, Phys. Rev. A 21, 808 (1980). Report on ICPEAC 9, Experimental, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 9, 173 (1980). Developments in techniques for the production of quantum-state selected atomic and molecular beams, in: N. Oda and K. Takayanagi (Eds.), “Book of Invited Papers, Proc. of ICPEAC 9”, North-Holland, 1980, pp. 821–830. Absolute total cross sections for the scattering of low-energy electrons by lithium atoms, with B. Jaduszliwer, A. Tino and T.M. Miller, Phys. Rev. A 24, 1249 (1981). Measurements of total cross section for electron scattering by Li2 (0.5–10 eV), with T.M. Miller and A. Kasdan, Phys. Rev. A 25, 1777 (1982). Electric dipole polarizabilities of alkali halide dimers, with B. Jaduszliwer and R. Kremens, in: American Chemical Society Symposium Series, Vol. 179, Ch. 20 (1982). Electron scattering by highly polar molecules: A benchmark experiment, with B. Jaduszliwer, A. Tino and P. Weiss, Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1644 (1983). Polarizability of 5s2 5p(2 P1/2 ) atomic indium, with J.A.D. Stockdale, T.M. Miller and T. Guella, Phys. Rev. A 29, 2977 (1984). Small angle (e− , Na) scattering in the 6–25 eV range, with B. Jaduszliwer, P. Weiss and A. Tino, Phys. Rev. A 30, 1255 (1984). Measurements of the electric dipole polarizabilities of the alkali-halide dimers, with R. Kremens, B. Jaduszliwer, J. Stockdale and A. Tino, J. Chem. Phys. 81, 1676 (1984). Electron scattering by highly polar molecules, with B. Jaduszliwer and A. Tino, Phys. Rev. A 30, 1269 (1984). Electron–atom photon interactions in a laser field, with B. Jaduszliwer, G.-F. Shen and J.-L. Cai, in: “Colloque International Atomic and Molecular Collisions in a Laser Field”, Abbaye de Royaumont, France, 1984; Journal de Physique 46, Supp. No. 1, C1-241 (1985). Polarization effects in electron–atom collisions, in: “Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Study Institute, Palermo”, Plenum Press, New York, 1985.
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
21
Total cross sections for electrons scattered by 3 2 P3/2 sodium atoms, with B. Jaduszliwer, G.F. Shen and J.-L. Cai, Phys. Rev. A. 31, 1157 (1985). Quantitative analysis of the deflection of a sodium beam by laser radiation, with B. Jaduszliwer and G.F. Shen, Phys. Rev. A 33, 3792 (1986). Scattering of electrons by alkali-halide molecules: LiBr and CsCl, with L. Vuskovic, M. Zuo, G.F. Shen and B. Stumpf, Phys. Rev. A 40, 133 (1989). Absolute elastic differential cross sections of electrons scattered by 3 2 P3/2 sodium, with M. Zuo, T.Y. Jiang and L. Vuskovic, Phys. Rev. A 41, 2489 (1990). Absolute small angle differential electron excitation cross sections for the resonant transition in sodium, with T.Y. Jiang, C.H. Ying and L. Vuskovic, Phys. Rev. A 42, 3852 (1990). Polarizabilities of the alkali halide dimers II, with T. Guella, T.M. Miller, J.A.D. Stockdale and L. Vuskovic, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 6857 (1991). Absolute cross sections for low energy electron excited-sodium scattering, with T.Y. Jiang, L. Zuo and L. Vuskovic, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 915 (1992). Measurements of the dc electric dipole polarizabilities of the alkali dimer molecules, homonuclear and heteronuclear, with V. Tarnovsky, L. Vuskovic and B. Stumpf, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 3894 (1993). Threshold-energy region in the electron excitation cross sections of the sodium resonant transition, with C.H. Ying, F. Perales and L. Vuskovic, Phys. Rev. A 48, 1189 (1993). Superelastic electron scattering by polarized excited sodium, with T.Y. Jiang, Z. Shi, C.H. Yang and L. Vuskovic, Phys. Rev. A 51, 3773 (1995). Communications in Physics, Physics Today 50, 63 (November 1997). OTHER PUBLICATIONS An atomic beam recoil method for studying the scattering of electrons by atoms, with K. Rubin, Technical Report No. 1, N-ONR-285 (15), N.Y.U., 1958. Elastic scattering of electrons by atomic hydrogen, with J. Hammer and H. Malamud, Technical Report No. 2, N-ONR-285 (15), N.Y.U., 1958. Velocity analysis of high speed atomic beams by a Stern–Gerlach magnet and by phased electron beam chopping, with K. Rubin, NYO-10, 117, U.S.A.E.C. Technical Report, N.Y.U., 1962. Atomic and molecular physics, A report by the National Academy of Sciences National Research Council Committee on Atomic and Molecular Physics. (National Academy of Science, 1971, Co-editor, with S.J. Smith and L. T. Crane.) Lasers—from abstraction to reality, Journal of Science College Teachers 3, 322 (1974); also Speaking of science, Conversations with outstanding scientist, Vol. II, 1973, No. 8 (with J.K. Hulm and E. Edelson); A.A.A.S. Cassette.
22
RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS OF BENJAMIN BEDERSON
Atomic and molecular science and energy-related research, A report of the NASNRC Committee on Atomic and Molecular Science, NAS-NRC, Washington, DC, 1976 (Editor). Atomic physics—a renewed vitality, Physics Today 34, 188 (November 1981) (50th Anniversary of American Institute of Physics issue). Atoms, in: “Encyclopedia of Applied Physics”, VCH Publishers, with AIP, German Physical Society, and Japan Society of Applied Physics, 1990. Atomic Physics, in: “Academic Press Dictionary of Science”, 1991. Atoms, in: “Encyclopedia of Applied Physics”, VCH Publishers, with AIP, German Physical Society, and Japan Society of Applied Physics, 1990. Atomic Physics, in: “Academic Press Dictionary of Science”, 1991. Informal discussion on the history of the International Conference on Atomic Physics, with V. Hughes, H. Shugart et al., AIP Conf. Proc. 233, 585 (1991). Guest Comment: Some Personal Reflections on Physical Review, Am. J. Phys. 60, 873 (1992). SEDís at Los Alamos: a personal memoir, Physics in Perspective 3, 52–75 (2001). “A Century of Physics”, by D.A. Bromley, Book review, Physics Today 55, 53 (October 2002). Sheldon Datz, with Joseph Martinez and Herbert Krause, Physics Today 55, 88 (November 2002). “Selectivity and Discord: Two Problems of Experiment”, by Allan Franklin, Book review, Physics Today 56, 53 (August 2003). The physical tourist: Physics and New York City, Physics in Perspective 5, 87– 121 (2003). Albert Einstein, J. Robert Oppenheimer, Edward Teller, three articles for the “Encyclopedia on Science and Technology Ethics”, Gale-Macmillan Reference USA, Woodbridge, CT, 2005, ISBN: 0-02-865831-0. Fritz Reiche and the International Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars, Physics in Perspective 7 (4) (2005).
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
A PROPER HOMAGE TO OUR BEN1 H. LUSTIG Professor Emeritus of Physics, The City College of the City University of New York Treasurer Emeritus, The American Physical Society
A proper homage to our Ben, To tell about the now and then, To honor one so free of meanness, Would take the tongue of Demosthénes, The dubious sweetness of R. Jastrow,2 Prolixity of Fidel Castro. So as to make it short and terse, I must perforce resort to verse, (I might have said that to save time One is obliged to turn to rhyme.) As Frost showed, if you want to snow ‘em, Don’t be profound, just make a poem. Ben Bederson got grace and knowledge, Where else, at good old City College, Where students were great and staff tried to teach, Where he took years of Public Speech, But never abandoned his Bronxian jargon: De gustibus, there ain’t no arguin’. When war broke out he took his stand; He joined the Army and was sent To work out at Los Alamos. He must have had a ‘mallow boss, 1 This tribute was “inspired” by a doggerel which the author read at the party in 1996, toasting and roasting Ben Bederson, on the occasion of his retirement as Editor-in-Chief of The American Physical Society (APS). It has never been published. This revised and updated version probably shouldn’t be either. 2 Robert Jastrow, space physicist, former director of the Goddard Institute for Space Studies.
23
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51006-1
24
H. Lustig For Bederson in uniform Is stranger by far than cuneiform.3 With peace restored it was his object To launch his own Manhattan project. He ended up at NYU, Got Ph.D. and Betty too. The rest is not a mystery, But (slightly revisionist) history. After a stint at MIT New York was where he chose to be. It wasn’t the money, it wasn’t his group; It was the sweet and sour soup Soon he appeared on all the lists Of great atomic physicists. Then everyone was heard to say “Bederson—Editor—Phys. Rev. A”. For fourteen years he labored on; (See chapter by B. Crasemann4 ). But finally he mused: “Oh bah, Heute gehört mir Phys. Rev. A”. (He actually said: “Oy veh, All I have is Phys. Rev. A”.) “If APS knows what to do, Morgen die ganze Phys. Review”. And so from editorial star, He now became the mighty czar Of all of our publications— A job that calls for drive and patience; For telling quality from kitsch; For spending countless days at Ridge;5 For dealing with Council,6 with E-Pub,7 with REC;8 For listening to wisdom as well as to Dreck.
3 Val Fitch, “Benjamin Bederson in the Army, World War II”, this volume. 4 Bernd Crasemann, “Ben as APS Editor”, this volume. 5 Ridge, Long Island, the location housing The American Physical Society’s publishing operations. 6 The governing body of The American Physical Society. 7 A working group to advance electronic publishing. 8 The Ridge Editorial Council, a group made up of resident editorial staff.
A PROPER HOMAGE TO OUR BEN
25
He guided the journals with aplomb, In print, on line, on CD-ROM. His grasp was firm, his reach was clear. Not even Goudsmit9 was his peer. He dealt with staff, with referees, With authors and their fervent pleas. By turns he was profound and funny And even made us lots of money. For years he led our journals’ growth, True to the ephebic oath, Until one day the blessed Merzbacher Task Force caused some Schmerz.10 But this as well he took in stride. So that we could proclaim with pride, When papers didn’t pass the door: “That’s quite all right, for less is more”. It was that insight, let’s confess, That left us then Ben-Bederson-less. Less aggravation, fewer horrors For Ben, and fewer tzores. No more papers from Krajina11 No more threat of a subpoena12
9 Samuel Goudsmit (1902–1978), co-discoverer, with George Uhlenbeck, of electron spin. Scientific
head of the Alsos mission (which was formed during World War II to try to detect the status of the German nuclear weapons effort), and the autocratic, but highly effective, long-term boss (Managing Editor, 1951–1966, Editor-in-Chief, 1967–1975) of The Physical Review. 10 Confronted with the dilemma that the journals were growing and library subscriptions declining, causing prices to be raised, a task force headed by Eugen Merzbacher recommended controlling growth by “ratcheting up” the standards for the acceptance of manuscripts. In spite of this decision, submissions and the journals have continued to grow. 11 The Krajina Region (making up about one third of Croatia) is on the frontier between Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina with a university in the city of Knin. Heavily populated by Serbs, Krajina proclaimed itself an autonomous Serbian province after Croatia declared its independence from Yugoslavia in 1991. The authors of a paper submitted from this university demanded that their by-line give Krajina as the country of origin. But no government, nor the United Nations, had recognized Krajina as a country. Resisting significant pressure from both Serbs and Croats, Bederson wisely decided that the location of the authors was simply Knin, period. 12 Beginning during the reign of Ben’s predecessor, David Lazarus, the APS was subjected to frivolous lawsuits and threats of lawsuits, mostly for what was published and not published in its journals.
26
H. Lustig No more threats and no more crap From Santilli13 or from Stapp.14 No more cutting to the bone; No more deals with Andy Cohen.15 No more scraping off the barnacles; No more trek with Adams16 chronicles. No POC17 to give him shpilkes No more accolades from Wilkins.18 No more trips to regions rustic;19 No more Franz and no more Lustig.20 But though now living on his Rente For Ben no dolce far niente Imperatively categorical His oeuvre became historical: He writes in PiP21 and is a mover In FHP22 (please read R. Stuewer23 ).
(See Harry Lustig, “To advance and diffuse the knowledge of physics: An account of the one-hundredyear history of the American Physical Society”, American Journal of Physics 68 (7) (July 2000), 595–636.) 13 Ruggero Maria Santilli of The Institute for Basic Research, who complained bitterly about the rejection of his papers “disproving” Einstein’s relativity, which he attributed to Jewish domination of APS’ journals. 14 Henry P. Stapp, who experienced some difficulty in having his manuscript “Theoretical model of a purported empirical violation of the predictions of quantum theory” published in The Physical Review A, 50 (1) (July 1994). 15 Ben’s interlocutor in unsuccessful negotiations to entangle The Physical Review D with Paul Ginsparg’s (Los Alamos) preprint archive. 16 Peter Adams, in a singular arrangement, was the permanent, full-time, in-house editor of The Physical Review B. 17 APS’ Publications Oversight Committee (POC). 18 John Wilkins, the formidable chair of the POC, who seldom dispensed compliments. The rhyming with “shpilkes” is weak, but the interaction was strong. 19 Such as Ashford, Ohio, to negotiate with a small company for the production of Physical Review Letters. 20 Judy Franz was (and still is) the Executive Officer of the APS, and Harry Lustig (the author of this doggerel) was its Treasurer. With Ben Bederson, the Editor-in-Chief, they formed the triumvirate that ran the APS. 21 The journal Physics in Perspective, edited by John S. Rigden and Roger H. Stuewer. 22 The APS Forum on History of Physics. 23 Roger H. Stuewer, “Ben Bederson: Physicist–Historian”, this volume.
A PROPER HOMAGE TO OUR BEN But still, it hardly need be said, The famous Bederson sextet: Ben senior, Betty, and four sons (Of whom not one is yclept Hans) Makes time for family palaver; Bravo to Ben, to Betty brava; Bravi to Josh, to Geoff, to Aron, And to Ben junior, for their carin’. Will our hero still climb higher, From Bederson to Biedermeier? Will there be cause for future cheers, Another Festschrift in ten years? We wish it and we make this toast: To Ben, santé, l’chaim, Prost. This is the best that I can do: A most imperfect clerihew.
27
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
BENJAMIN BEDERSON IN THE ARMY, WORLD WAR II VAL L. FITCH Department of Physics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
Many years ago I wrote a brief account of some of my experiences as a GI during WWII working at the Los Alamos Laboratory. I recounted the following story. “Saturday morning inspection also remained on the schedule but became devoid of spit and polish. The new company commander would stride down the length of the barracks at something less than the speed of light and that was it, for another week. On one morning, however, something struck him on the head as he sped down the aisle. He pulled himself to a stop a few strides later, turned around to see some curious object wildly gyrating on a string from the ceiling of the barracks. “What’s this?” asked the captain. “That’s a bagel, sir”, said my fellow platoon member standing at attention beside his bunk. “Well, it’s pretty dangerous up there, you’d better eat it”, said the captain and continued on his way. My friend had received a box of bagels from his home in New York City. In his rather desperate homesickness he had suspended one of the bagels on a string from the ceiling so he could lie back on his bunk and admire it. It just happened to catch the top of the head of the unusually tall captain”. Later in the same essay I revealed that, well after the war, “the bagel lover is now chairman of the physics department of a well-known university, again comfortable in the environment of a big city”. As you have guessed, my fellow platoon member was Ben Bederson. I have been asked to describe what life was like for Ben at Los Alamos during WWII. Ben and I were members of an army group “Special Engineering Detachment”. We were SEDs. The contribution of this group to the Manhattan project appears to be one of the better kept secrets of the war, certainly the least appreciated, despite the fact that, at Los Alamos, by the end of the war, nearly 50% of the technical personnel were SEDs. As one example, in Richard Rhodes’ otherwise excellent account of The Making of the Atomic Bomb, there is but one reference to the SEDs, viz., “The general’s decision started Norris Bradbury and his crews of Special Engineering Detachment GI’s—SEDs, the science-trained recruits were called . . .”. 29
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51007-3
30
V.L. Fitch
How did this army group come about? At the end of 1943 recruiting new civilian staff for Los Alamos was becoming impossible. The war had been going full tilt for over two years, all technically trained people in the country were already in positions where their skills were being utilized. In addition, draft boards were under increasing pressure to meet their quotas, and occupational deferments were a thing of the past. Furthermore, there was no possibility that enough adequate housing could be constructed to attract new civilian employees. It was at this time that someone hit on the idea to bring to Los Alamos army people who had had technical training; in chemistry, engineering, physics, mathematics, etc. Not only could the manpower problem be addressed but, since the army personnel could be housed in barracks, the housing could be minimal, recreational facilities, food— everything could be minimal. Living in barracks, the soldiers would need only about 40 sq. feet per person, quite different from the needs of civilians living in apartments. As fast as the barracks were constructed, the ranks of a Special Engineering detachment began to be filled out. From late in 1943 onward their ranks swelled at about forty per month. According to the book, Critical Assembly, Colonel M.H. Trytten would find the SEDs and General Grove’s office, using its power of highest priority, would arrange to have them transferred to Los Alamos. The needs of the laboratory spanned the gamut, from skilled machinists to explosive experts, from chemists to physicists and electrical engineers and the SEDs reflected the needs. Some had advanced degrees, a few had PhDs (draft boards were often hard-pressed to fill their quotas and no one was totally exempt). Many were like Ben and myself, drafted into the army from college where we had had 3 or more years majoring in physics or mathematics. Mainly we functioned as research assistants to the senior scientists who were the core of the Oppenheimer team. Ben was among the first of the SEDs and he discovered that, in the barracks to which he was assigned, he was bunked next to a machinist by the name of David Greenglass who was eventually revealed as a spy for the Soviets and the brother of Ethel Rosenberg. According to Ben, hot political arguments were generated by Greenglass’ extreme pro-Soviet positions. Conveniently for Ben, it was also at this time that the machinists were moved to barracks of their own since they did shift work on the limited number of machines and their hours disrupted the sleep of others. Ben moved to the barracks where I ended up on arrival. It was a curious situation for the SEDs. We were in the army, slept in barracks, and ate in an army mess hall. At the same time, working in the fenced-in technical area, we were beholden to civilians. It was frustrating for the cadre of army officers under whose command we were. We were soldiers, weren’t we? We must be kept in condition to fight a war. Discipline must be maintained. So we were awakened early in the morning for calisthenics—we had spit-and-polish inspections. While we did not have KP, we were assigned duties to keep the latrines clean.
BENJAMIN BEDERSON IN THE ARMY
31
Perhaps the most apt description of most of the SEDs was that we were intellectual foot soldiers. We were skeptical of anything the army told us if not downright cynical. On one occasion there was a formal military review prompted by a visit by General Groves. The town turned out to watch. Bernice Brode, one of the scientists wives, described the soldierly skills of the SEDs as follows. “The SED boys were terrible, they couldn’t keep in step. Their lines were crooked. They didn’t stand properly. They wore glasses. They waved at friends and grinned. Once, when a sergeant became irritated by his yawning, halfhearted crew doing their morning calisthenics he shouted, ‘if you guys think I like this job, you got another thing coming’, one of the SED boys offered to lead the calisthenics drill in his place. He shouted orders in imitation of the sergeant’s voice: ‘thumbs up, thumbs down, thumbs wiggle-waggle’. Even the sergeant broke down and dismissed them”. The barracks, each housing sixty men, were single floor with double-decker bunks extending out from the walls with an aisle perhaps 10 feet wide running down the center. In this center aisle there were four coal-burning potbellied stoves spaced at equal intervals down the length of the building. A coal bin was outside at the end. When I arrived in the summer of ’44 I looked at those stoves and knew full well, when it got cold, who was going to keep those stoves fired up. We would be assigned, on a rotating basis, stove duty. Later in the summer of ’44 it was George Kistiakowsky who changed all that. Kisty was a famous Harvard chemist, an émigré from Russia, who spoke English with a rich and fascinating accent. He was gregarious, loved people, and clearly had a high regard for those people who worked for him. He was a natural leader and the SEDs under his direction would follow him to the end of the earth A fair fraction of the SEDs worked for Kisty in the development of the high explosive lenses used in the implosion gadget. In fact, some SEDs were group leaders in his division. Kisty felt that the military was going too far, that the attempts to maintain strict military discipline were just petty harassments, and, of course, we all agreed He carried the issue to General Groves who apparently refused to do anything even as Kistiakowsky threatened to resign. Then all at once, we had a new company commander who had some sense of what was important. He was very relaxed about discipline. Now, indigenous labor did not only the KP but also cleaned the latrines, calisthenics were gone. The Saturday morning inspection of quarters was continued but in a much more relaxed manner and I think we all agreed that it should. Some order must be preserved with 60 men living in a single room. After these changes, morale improved significantly. We were still responsible for keeping the barracks heated but in our case, one of our comrades, Bill Davis, volunteered to take the job for a small weekly reimbursement from each of us. He was older than most, married and could use the extra money. He was a graduate of Dartmouth and while in college had been on the ski team. Indeed, he had trained with the ski troops of the 10th Mountain Infantry division
32
V.L. Fitch
and while there had been picked out for work at Los Alamos. He was the one who gave me my first skiing lessons. This new, relaxed, atmosphere suited Ben. He had not taken well to army discipline and was always challenging the rules. Consequently, he was frequently short-listed for reprimand and was often saved from demotion by the intercession of his civilian supervisors in the tech area. Now, the relation between the army and the SEDs, especially Ben, relaxed significantly. Ben apparently got to know Kistiakowsky at work. I came to know him on the local ski slope. I have already mentioned that Bill Davis got me interested in skiing and, through the fall, spent Sundays (remember, in WWII everyone worked six days a week) working on the local slope cutting down trees to widen the trails. Kisty came by, saw how laborious the whole process was and deployed some of his crew the next day to wrap explosives around the trees and simply blow them up. It was a marvelous solution. Kisty was an avid skier and it was on the ski slope that I got to know him, occasionally bumming a ride back to town with him instead of bumping along in the back of an army 6 X 6 truck. So Ben and I were housed in the same barracks and had remarkably parallel activities at work. However, we knew each other only casually. We had a different circle of friends. Ben’s interests were much more intellectual than mine. He and his friends, as members of his Mushroom Society, would sit about in the evenings in the tech area listening to Mahler recordings on their home-built hi-fi system. It would be some years before the level of my own music sophistication was up to Mahler. I was in the hiking, skating, skiing, square dancing crowd (as were many of the luminaries; Fermi, Peierls, Weisskopf). Ben worked with Don Hornig (Hornig was later to be President Johnson’s science adviser) on the development of the X-unit which generated the high voltages that went to the detonators on the 32 lenses of the implosion device. I worked for Ernest Titterton, a member of the British mission, and was concerned with measuring the degree of simultaneity of all detonators firing. Part of the program involved flight testing using dummy bombs dropped from B-29s which took off from Wendover, Utah, and released their loads on targets in the Salton Sea in southern California. Enlisted men like Ben and me could not go to Wendover and tell the army air force officers what to do. So we were privileged to travel there in civilian clothes posturing as scientists from Washington. The army gave us each $200 to spend in Santa Fe on civilian clothing. In retrospect, it is hard to imagine what this meant to us. After all, in WWII, if any military person was found in civilian clothes he was automatically a deserter. Of course, we carried special papers giving us the approval to appear as civilians. I made the trip to Wendover in April of ’45 and Ben in May so we didn’t overlap there. Subsequently, Ben became part of the team that went to Tinian to assemble and ready Fat Man, the plutonium implosion gadget, for delivery. I went to Alamogordo to participate in
BENJAMIN BEDERSON IN THE ARMY F IG . 1. The crew from Los Alamos that went to Tinian Island to prepare for delivery thin man (the gun weapon) and fat man (the implosion gadget). Ben is in the third row, fifth from the left. Other familiar figures include, in the first row, Norman Ramsey, fifth from left and George Reynolds, eighth. In the second row, Philip Morrison, second, Robert Serber, eleventh, and Luis Alvarez, fourteenth, all from the left. General T.F. Farrell, 2nd in command to General Groves, is also in the second row, eighth from the left. [The author is grateful to Michael Vickio, president of the Manhattan Project Heritage Preservation Assoc., Inc., for supplying the photograph.]
33
34
V.L. Fitch
the first test at Trinity, where, among other activities, we set about to measure the degree of simultaneity of the firing of the 32 detonators. The SEDs were an eclectic bunch. After the war many went on to get PhDs. Some of them, like Ben, became important figures in physics. There were, among the SED alumni, some who became distinguished mathematicians, e.g., John Kemeny, who invented the Basic programming language, and who later was a highly successful president of Dartmouth. Also, Peter Lax, who became the director of the Courant Institute at New York University, and a colleague of Ben’s. The question inevitably arises, how do you feel about having worked on the development of the atom bomb and its subsequent use? I agree with Ben who addresses this question at the end of his memoir of his days at Los Alamos. He said, “It is virtually obligatory for any atom bomb memoir to include a discussion of the merits of President Harry S. Truman’s decision to drop the bomb. I can take care of this obligation here by simply describing what I have told students at New York University whenever they would confront me with this question. I would point out that had the bombs not been used, many of the men and women in the class would not be there, since one of their parents or grandparents would not have survived the inevitable invasion of Japan. This was, and is, a very compelling argument”.
References [1] L.R. Groves, “Now It Can be Told” (1962). [2] D. Hawkins, “The Los Alamos Story, Toward Trinity” (1961). [3] L. Hoddeson et al., “Critical Assembly. A Technical History of Los Alamos during the Oppenheimer Years” (1993). [4] J. Wilson, “All in Our Time. The Reminiscences of Twelve Nuclear Pioneers” (1975). P. Abelson, L. Alvarez, H. Anderson, K. Bainbridge, F. de Hoffman, V. Fitch, O. Frisch, M. Kamen, J.H. Manley, B. McDaniel, A. Wattenberg, R.R. Wilson. [5] L. Badash et al., “Reminiscences of Los Alamos, 1943–1945” (1980). John Dudley, Edwin McMillan, John Manley, Elsie McMillan, George Kistiakowsky, Joe Hischfelder, Laura Fermi, Richard Feynman, Bernice Brode, Norris Bradbury. [6] B. Bederson, SEDs at Los Alamos: A personal memoir, Physics in Perspective 3 (2001) 52–75. This is Ben’s own fascinating account of his days at Los Alamos, even how he learned to drive a car. And his experiences on Tinian were unique to him. [7] R.C. Sparks, “Twilight Time, A Soldiers Role in the Manhattan Project at Los Alamos”, Los Alamos Historical Society, 2000. The experiences of an SED machinist who was head of a machine shop. [8] F.M. Szasz, “British Scientists and the Manhattan Project” (1992).
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
PHYSICS NEEDS HEROES TOO C. DUNCAN RICE∗ University of Aberdeen, United Kingdom
It’s a very long time since Ben Bederson and I served at New York University, and I haven’t become a scientist in the intervening years. But I do have a comment on some directions in modern policy debate about science, at least in my own country, and some thoughts on the reason why it’s critical to have people like Ben at the top. The year 2005 has been designated by the United Nations as “The International Year of Physics”. The purpose, as I understand it, is twofold. On the one hand it is to commemorate the hundredth anniversary of Einstein’s publication of three groundbreaking papers on Brownian motion, special relativity and the photoelectric effect. On the other, it is to use the occasion to promote world-wide the importance of the study of physics. In view of my present role, I should perhaps champion James Clerk Maxwell instead of Einstein. He was for a time a Professor of Natural Philosophy at Marischal College, Aberdeen. The embarrassment is that we fired one of Britain’s greatest scientists. Until 1860 Aberdeen consisted of two Colleges, King’s and Marischal. When they merged to form the new University I now lead, it had two professors of physics. Maxwell was at the newer College, Marischal. Even though he was married to the daughter of its Principal, he was the one they let go at the merger. This, it is said, was in part because he was the more junior scientist, and in part because the other was considered a better teacher. I have no son-in-law or daughter-in-law equivalents to trouble my conscience but it is every President’s or Principal’s nightmare to think you have let some future genius such as Maxwell leave on your watch. Actually Maxwell had not been entirely comfortable in the austere culture of Northern Scotland. He once wrote to a friend that “No jokes of any kind are understood here. I haven’t made one for two months, and if I feel ∗ C. Duncan Rice was Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences at NYU between 1985–1994, and also Vice-Chancellor between 1991–1996. He is now Principal and Vice-Chancellor of the University of Aberdeen, in the United Kingdom.
35
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51008-5
36
C.D. Rice
one coming on I bite my tongue”. Ben Bederson would not have been happy in mid-Victorian Aberdeen. Great academic gaffes aside, Einstein is perhaps the brand name of physics in the popular domain—although I note that Physics World recently voted Maxwell’s Electromagnetism theory as being more significant than the work of Einstein or Newton. I am as quick as anyone inside the academy to write off such events or polls as gimmicks—unless, of course, they give me or my institution a high ranking. But in either case, physics clearly faces a contemporary challenge in demonstrating its importance to the academy and to society—and to that end perhaps we need all the help we can get from gimmicks or any other means. It is now some years since I was a colleague of Ben’s at NYU. I left America in 1996, and am no longer close enough to be able to comment knowledgeably on the position of physics there. Certainly in Britain the declining number of students taking physics courses is an ongoing concern. In Scotland, for example, the numbers of those enrolling in courses where physics is an element have declined by about 10% between 1998 and 20021 . This has at least something to do with widening curricular choices, but together with other comparable trend lines it suggests ignorance about the beauty, the importance, and the accessibility of physics. From a British perspective, however, physics is at risk from a wider challenge to universities engaged in teaching and research on pure science. There is a constant danger that the public, or their political representatives, fall into believing that basic science is a luxury—that knowledge without immediate application is remote from the solution of ‘real-life’, practical problems. On this side of the English speaking Atlantic, higher education debate is biased towards questions about the marketable commodities or direct contributions to economic development produced by scientific teaching. In political debate at least, applications and training have become popular surrogates for research and teaching. Perhaps that has always been so, but it seems ever to get worse. But we have to recognise the dilemma for modern universities. A full-service physics department is extraordinarily expensive, because it would encompass the full spectrum of activity—solid state, atomic, high energy and astronomy, each with a theoretical as well as an experimental wing. It’s not surprising then that as institutions try to manage in conditions of financial restraint, physics has become distributed around the academy. Under severe financial pressures in the eighties, my University, once the employer of James Clark Maxwell, was forced to abolish research physics. But that’s not to say that physics has disappeared or become invisible. There are ways, cheaper but admittedly less attractive, of presenting physics other than through a traditional departmental structure. Physicists can be 1 ‘Science Policy in Scotland’, Institute of Physics Report, Policy Paper 2003-1, p. 15.
PHYSICS NEEDS HEROES TOO
37
located in applied mathematics, engineering, in chemistry or even medical departments. At Aberdeen, indeed, we have a Department of Biomedical Physics. But it is essential to retain some major physics departments. In Scotland we are having to face this very issue—with the added challenges of having relatively small institutions, in a small and limitedly prosperous democracy. Our Funding Council, the Government’s ‘arms length’ organisation that oversees the distribution of public money to universities, has in the past year begun a targeted effort to bring together respective elements of physics activity across universities in Scotland into a ‘pooling’ arrangement or, as it has been termed, a “Super Department”. This may or may not work, but it’s worth trying because Scotland’s individual universities in general lack the critical mass needed to compete at the very highest level. While there are some significant and significantly sized physics units in Scotland, notably at Edinburgh, the solution may be our best bet in maintaining a high quality physics presence in a small country. Of all disciplines, the tradition of sharing large scale and expensive equipment is perhaps more familiar to physicists than to other scientists. Incidentally, Scottish science faces similar issues in chemistry, and we are taking comparable approaches to cooperation there. But in terms of the public culture of science in a country like this, the physics issue is part of doing everything possible to keep alive in our universities the concept of pure science. Pure science may be expensive, may even seem a luxury to some, but we cannot do without it. That’s especially true of physics, which has dominated the twentieth century. It is as hard to think of a facet of human life that is not touched in some way by physics research as it is easy to reel off a list of technologies it has spawned. The end of the Cold War may have lessened the place of physics in the minds of policy makers. That is the nature of political prioritisation at work, but it ignores the fact that there is so much physicists still don’t know. And what they still have to find out will, among many other things, make huge contributions to preventing disease, and to jump-starting new technologies on which economic growth depends. The problem is that we don’t know where the connections between pure physical research and new applications will unfold—but we do know that many will be based on improved understanding of physics. Our most important work at Aberdeen since Maxwell was Mallard’s success in turning an understanding of nuclear magnetic resonance into the critical diagnostic technology of M.R.I.— but no scientist knew in advance what the application of the pure research would be. Whatever the local position, there is a public interest in governments and funding bodies not losing sight of the importance of pure or curiosity driven research. Since returning to Scotland from New York to become Principal at Aberdeen in 1996 I have frequently found myself making arguments in defense of pure research—most often in the context of the humanities. Much of what I have argued there applies to physics too. The reason is that in public debate, or policy, in
38
C.D. Rice
Britain we increasingly seem to be defining the worth of universities in terms of how useful they can be. Unless we can commercialise research or explain a discipline by its immediacy to graduate employment these areas are often left out of contemporary debate about why our universities matter to society. That can only lead to scholarly impoverishment and ultimately economic weakness if allowed to slip from the work of universities. At NYU I was Dean of a Faculty of Arts and Sciences. These two broad areas are at the intellectual heart of any major university. It’s simply difficult to be a truly great university if you don’t pursue them. That is one argument for why they matter. A more compelling one is that it is the very purpose of a university to be the place where there is room to pursue academic inquiry without knowing what practical application will follow from it. Knowledge, the expansion of knowledge, the understanding and appreciation of the world around us, these are at the core of what a university exists for—and if such things have no place in a university then where do they? And democratic society faced with the myriad of moral debates attached to science, needs more than ever to have academics taking part in that debate instead of leaving it to politicians with short-term and often self-serving agendas. In the context that I describe, physics or pure science, or universities for that matter, have to come out fighting for what they are and why they matter. And we need inspirational academic leaders and figures to do that—inside and outside the academy. In writing that I am deeply conscious that leadership is such a frequently and sloppily used word that it ceases to mean anything. There are foundations dedicated to extending leadership or even teaching it! One of these in the UK states its ‘values’ as being “professionalism, transparency, accountability, respecting equality and diversity, commitment to services of the highest quality, appreciation of the diversity of individual higher education institutions, and responsiveness to our stakeholders”. Where is the reference to qualities such as vision, risk taking, inspiration, and core values? I don’t doubt all this is well intentioned but I simply find these types of ‘leadership’ organisations to be a post-modern fallacy. What I am sure of is that people know when they are led by people that inspire them. It is from that emotional experience that leaderships skills if they can be taught at all are learned. Ben Bederson was first and foremost a scientist, with an old style Bronx personality. But his importance to NYU was in the clarity with which he saw the importance of science as an end in itself, and the centrality of values of excellence and curiosity to the academy. That’s what I mean by the kind of leadership we may now undervalue, and what Ben taught me most about. So that brings me to a question about the nature of personalities needed to lead in science. For our purposes, of course, the question about scientific leadership is not just how it affects other scientists, but how it manages to communicate with people like myself who are from entirely different disciplines. I don’t think that
PHYSICS NEEDS HEROES TOO
39
kind of skill can be taught, and my recollection of working with Ben was that he had it in spades. I won’t ever forget his patience. When I came to NYU, though I had had extensive experience in a large university at Yale, it was so junior and so focused on the humanities as to be irrelevant. My most recent job had been as academic dean at a small liberal arts college. One of Ben’s first jobs, I am ashamed to say, was to describe to me the established divisions of physics, and to explain gently that having only one solid state scientist probably wouldn’t work very well—or even, I remember to my surprise, that it wasn’t practical (for instance) to have Larry Spruch or Henry Stroke teach astronomy. Once I understood the picture better, of course, his central message was that if something couldn’t be done well it wasn’t worth doing at all. Maybe it was all much easier for him because he is so good at creating commonalties with people from entirely different backgrounds. That in turn was partly because of his transparent humanity. I suppose he and I share an elitism about the importance of very high intellectual quality, but for a young leader in a hurry like myself that sometimes led to being oblivious about real human problems. Again I don’t forget one meeting where he took up the cause of a young—possibly not very able—technician who was in some kind of brawl with our personnel people. Ben brought me over to his side just by pointing to the bureaucracy of a very large institution chiseling away at some minor increase to what he described as this person’s ‘pitiful little salary’. The other part of the communication was the cross-cultural one. In retrospect, that may have been even more important than my initiation into the fundamental structure of the physics profession. I had arrived at NYU with no Yiddish vocabulary at all, and was unable even to conduct myself appropriately in a delicatessen. Ben gave me my first window into the values and the humour of Jewish New York—but that was also the reverse of his own insatiable curiosity about other cultures, his insistence that people of all sorts and backgrounds simply had to be taken for what they are, and his endless wide-eyed amazement at the pomposity and self-importance of Wasps. I have drifted off into the personal. But there are some fundamental lessons to be drawn from Ben’s work as a dean that are much more instructive than the stuff from leadership academies and management journals. First, it isn’t worth being a leader unless every decision is based on believing in bone, blood, and brain—forgive my loose grasp of anatomy—that the only science worth doing is superb science. Secondly, leading the scientists is fine, but it won’t amount to a hill of beans unless the leader can also explain to non-scientists what is going on. And finally, the leader becomes unattractive and therefore ineffective if he or she doesn’t combine respect for the most elite scientists with compassion for the people at the bottom of the system.
40
C.D. Rice
There is only one final point. All my contacts with Ben demonstrated how much he loathed bureaucracy even when he and I had to embody it. I don’t mean by this that he wasn’t acutely aware of the importance of being financially responsible— but he believed that administration was there to serve science and the world of ideas, and not to hamper it. I can’t speak for him, but I think that it was the frustration with the way modern universities aren’t always able to prevent bureaucracy becoming over-rigid that ultimately made him fed up with administration. But of course it is precisely the kind of people who object to the weight of administration who are the ones we need as university leaders. I suspect that most of the readers of this essay will be Americans. The only consolation is that the stranglehold of bureaucracy on British universities is even worse than anything either Ben or I encountered in a private American university.
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
TWO CIVIC SCIENTISTS—BENJAMIN BEDERSON AND THE OTHER BENJAMIN NEAL LANE Rice University
I have known and greatly admired two Benjamins in my lifetime—Benjamin Franklin, whom I could only read about in the history books, and Benjamin Bederson, whom I had the great good fortune to have as a colleague in the field of atomic physics. The April 2003 meeting of the American Physical Society, held in Philadelphia, included a session on Benjamin Franklin, with contributions by scientists and historians. The following comments about Franklin are based on my contribution to that session and an article in Physics Today that followed.1 These two Benjamins, born 215 years apart, had different backgrounds and experienced different circumstances, but at an important fundamental level, they had much in common. Both have made important contributions to science and to this country. They were both city gentlemen, Franklin in Boston, and later, Philadelphia, and Bederson in New York City. Given their high intellect, easy manner and good humor, I believe they would have greatly enjoyed one another’s company. Perhaps they would have co-authored a paper. Their physical appearance is quite different, though to this author’s eye, neither appears to have placed an unreasonably high priority on having a high density of hair on top. Ben Bederson, in his fascinating article “The Physical Tourist—Physics and New York City”,2 notes that Ben Franklin’s likeness stands among the many American scientists and other dignitaries honored with busts in the Colonnade on the campus of the Bronx Community College, formerly the University Heights campus of New York University (NYU). The reader might conclude that my comparison is a bit of a stretch, given over two hundred years of accumulated lore surrounding Franklin and the large number of books written about his life, including the recent excellent biography by Walter 1 Neal Lane, Benjamin Franklin, civic scientist, Physics Today 56 (10) (2004) 24. 2 Benjamin Bederson, The physical tourist—physics and New York City, Physics in Perspective 5
(2003) 87–121. 41
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51009-7
42
N. Lane
Isaacson.3 Well, I would only say, give Bederson some time. This volume is a very good start. The point of the two-Bens comparison in my contribution to this volume is a serious one. It is my way of expressing my great admiration and affection for Ben Bederson and my appreciation for all he has done for science throughout the world, for physics in particular, and through his work as a scientist, teacher, scholar and historian, for our American society. But, my message is also about the uncertain future of science and the responsibility of scientists that goes beyond their work in the laboratory and classroom. This is the role of “civic scientist”, a phrase that I believe was coined in the mid-1990’s by one of the speechwriters at NSF, Ms. Patricia Garfinkel. I’ll use Ben Franklin and Ben Bederson to explain what, I think, the concept of the “civic scientist” is all about. First on my list, a “civic scientist” must truly be a scientist of the first rank. Although most of the history books have understated Ben Franklin’s scientific achievements, he was a scientist of the first rank, known and respected on both sides of the Atlantic. He began his scientific career after he already had established a successful career in business. Even so, his scientific achievements, particularly his contributions to understanding electricity, were recognized in his time with perhaps what would be comparable to the distinction of a Nobel Prize today. His careful laboratory experiments led to his “elastic” fluid model of electricity, which suggested a particulate aspect of electricity made up of two kinds of matter, having opposite charges. Franklin suggested a wave-like aspect of light as well.4 He was a practical scientist, in the mode of Bacon and Descartes, applying his new understanding of electricity to invent the lightning rod, among other new devices. Ben Bederson, without question, is an outstanding, internationally acclaimed scientist, as other contributions to this volume confirm. When he was awarded the Townsend Harris Medal (CCNY) in 1993, a portion of the citation, which was printed in the announcement summarizing his accomplishments, read: “During a research career spanning some five decades, Benjamin Bederson has been and is among the dozen or so leading experimental atomic physicists in the world. . . At NYU he developed an atomic beams laboratory, one of the first in the world to study atomic collisions and structure using beam techniques.” And Bederson’s patents testify to his commitment to insure that the science provides benefits to the public that pays for it. Franklin might have been particularly interested in Bederson’s patent on a “particle separation apparatus utilizing congruent inhomogeneous magnetostatic and electrostatic fields”.5 3 Walter Isaacson, “Benjamin Franklin—An American Life”, Simon and Schuser, New York, Lon-
don, Toronto, Sydney, Singapore, 2003. 4 Bernard Cohen, “Science and the Founding Fathers”, W.W. Norton and Company, New York and London, 1995, pp. 141–147. 5 Benjamin Bederson Curriculum Vitae, this volume.
TWO CIVIC SCIENTISTS
43
Second on my list of attributes of a “civic scientist” is wisdom. Ben Franklin was much older than his fellow patriots but he did seem wiser beyond his years on matters of state and everyday life. About the latter, he once wrote, only partly in jest: “If man could have half his wishes he would double his troubles!” 6 Instead of waxing philosophical about future forms of government, Franklin tended to apply what he knew from experience to solve specific problems. He freely shared opinions on a variety of matters, and made his points with humor and clarity. Franklin carried his scientific inclinations to government when, over a year before the Constitutional Convention, he wrote to a colleague “We are, I think, on the right Road of Improvement, for we are making Experiments!”7 Ben Bederson has never been said to lack opinions or good ideas. And, he articulated them so effectively, in his New York friendly way, that he usually won the argument. Throughout his career, organizations, communities and individuals have come to him seeking wisdom, for example, through his many editorial appointments, his selection as chair of the National Academies of Sciences— National Research Council Committee on Atomic and Molecular Sciences, during its formative years, as well as his tenure as Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, at NYU. Bederson’s legendary good humor conveys a warmth that is obviously genuine and has allowed him to deal with unhappy authors, reviewers and, I’m sure, students, faculty and administrators. Age aside, Ben Bederson has always been regarded as one of the most original thinkers and wisest colleagues in his field. Third on the list, a “civic scientist” should be able to effectively communicate with the public. Franklin’s well honed skills as a writer on various topics for the public, for example, his “Poor Richard’s Almanac”, also gave him the ability to explain science. The distinguished science historian, Bernard Cohen has noted that Franklin’s book “Observations and Experiments on Electricity” “ranks among the most notable books on science of that age and of any other age”.8 It was published in ten editions and four different languages. And, it was read not only by scientists but by the general public.9 Ben Bederson’s writing is at the same time informative, well documented, and simply a pleasure to read. This is true of his scientific publications as well as his works on history. His article2 on physics and NYC is a literary gem and a treat for
6 James C. Humes, “The Wit and Wisdom of Benjamin Franklin”, Harper Collins, New York, 1995,
p. 76. 7 Cohen (ref. 4), pp. 189–190. 8 Cohen (ref. 4), p. 139. 9 Cohen (ref. 4), p. 144.
44
N. Lane
anyone who is interested in the history of science or this extraordinary American city. He is a stickler for clarity and the highest standards in writing and publishing. Fourth on the list, a “civic scientist” should understand the value of compromise and be able to build consensus. Consistent with his pragmatic nature, Franklin possessed the ability to form consensus and negotiate a positive outcome. In Cohen’s words: “Above all, he [Franklin] was an important force in effecting compromise on certain crucial issues”.7 It is Franklin who is credited with the compromise of equal-state representation in the Senate, reversing his previous position, and population-based representation in the House of Representatives. Ben Bederson certainly shared with Franklin an ability to bring people together to reach a positive outcome. It served him well in his many editorial responsibilities over the years, as he made important, but sometimes, controversial changes in policy. His personal warmth and collegial style engendered trust, respect, and affection among all those he worked with, at home and abroad. He was a key figure in the founding of the International Conference on the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions (ICPEAC), in the late 1950’s. In his article in Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics,10 Bederson described the early days of this important conference, which still thrives today. While not saying so himself, I would speculate that Ben’s skills in building consensus and establishing trust were important to successfully reaching some of those early challenging agreements, including the decision to invite physicists from the U.S.S.R. to the conference in the midst of the cold war. Indeed, physicists from the former Soviet Union became regular participants, which allowed a peaceful dialogue to occur—at least in physics—between the U.S. and U.S.S.R. throughout the cold war. ICPEAC was held in Leningrad in 1967. Finally—and perhaps this sums it all up—a “civic scientist” is a scientist who uses his or her special scientific knowledge and skills to influence policy and inform the public. Ben Franklin advanced the standards of journalism and enhanced the power of the press as a means of getting the truth out to the people, along with some witty common sense. He had a special relationship with the print medium, as a printer, author, bookseller, and founder of a public library.11 Ben Bederson, through his writings and editorial responsibilities, including editor of Physical Review A: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics, and later, editor-in-chief of The American Physical Society (APS), where he was responsible for all publications of the APS, focused on raising the standards of scientific
10 Benjamin Bederson, ICPEAC—the early days, Comments on Atomic and Molecular Physics 9
(1980) 173. 11 Cohen (ref. 4), p. 140.
TWO CIVIC SCIENTISTS
45
publication, leading the way in the use of modern information technology and establishing a higher level of fairness in the review process. And as editor of the Forum on the History of Physics Newsletter and the Newsletter of the APS, he is putting a historically accurate human face on physics. Ben Franklin served in government policymaking, not as an elected official, but in other official capacities, including that of advisor to President George Washington. (One could say that Franklin was the first “Presidential Science Advisor”.) Ben Bederson has also served government by giving freely of his good advice, chairing or serving as a member of many advisory and review committees of federal agencies and national laboratories throughout his career. He was a key advisor to the National Science Foundation’s physics programs for several years. Ben Franklin established the Junto, a mutual-aid association of young tradesmen and artisans, who, along with their other activities, performed scientific experiments.12 Ben Bederson was instrumental in organizing a number of international scientific conferences, which were somewhat akin to mutual-aid associations for physicists from all over the world, including the U.S.S.R., who wished to understand atomic physics. Even in the years Franklin was spending most of his time on government matters, he considered himself a scientist—of the practical kind. He took both comfort and delight in his scientific experiments, expressing the desire to continue unfettered on this path, until the duties of patriot and diplomat took him in another direction. Ben Franklin was not simply a good scientist who engaged in public service. He was a scientist who used his scientific nature, intuition and analysis in ways only a scientist could do, thus making him especially effective in the policy and public domain. Ben Bederson was born two centuries too late to discover, first hand, the physical nature of electricity, that having been done by Franklin. But, he was able to use that knowledge of electromagnetic forces, in the most creative ways, to generate and control atomic beams and probe complex atomic systems, particularly under the disturbed conditions that occur during collisions. Ben Bederson did not have the opportunity to help establish a new Republic or fight a king and country across the Atlantic. But early in his life, he was called upon to defend the U.S. During WWII, Ben was a member of the U.S. Army Special Engineering Detachment, serving as a Scientific Aide to the Manhattan Project in Los Alamos. He did not have to give up his physics research career for public service, as Franklin had done, because Bederson’s call to service came before he had established a physics career.
12 Cohen (ref. 4), p. 148.
46
N. Lane
Ben Franklin, in playful modesty, referred to himself as “a printer”, when asked his profession. I don’t know how Ben Bederson would answer such a question. But, he would certainly say “physicist”, and then could follow with “teacher, scholar, administrator, historian, editor and writer, and humble public servant”. Ben Franklin lived in a world of dramatic change. He was at the forefront of overturning the old ideas—old paradigms—of government, a time of enlightenment in politics complementing that in science. We, as scientists, face a similar situation in our own time. We are not, of course, fighting to remove a colonial master. But over 200 years after the founding of this great country and the gaining of independence and freedom for generations of our ancestors, we are again threatened by forces and ideologies that would take away the very freedoms that Franklin and his contemporaries fought so hard to obtain. At the same time, the discoveries, advances and future promise of science— including atomic, molecular and optical physics—have never been more exciting. Nothing should be allowed to hold back future discoveries and deny the nation and the world the benefits that will flow from them.The nation will need its scientists to continue to make the great scientific breakthroughs. But they will be called upon to do other things as well. A renewed focus on the unique contributions and responsibilities of scientists seems particularly timely, given the present state of the world, disturbing trends in how science is seen by society and government, and potential harm that can be done to people living today and those of future generations by the misuse of science and technology. The world’s problems will not be solved by science and technology alone; but without question, science and technology must be a significant part of the solution. And scientists will increasingly be called upon not only to continue to make the great scientific discoveries but to work with policy makers and the American public to insure that science and technology do, indeed, provide the benefits they promise. Following the horrible attacks of 9/11 and the collapse of the twin towers of the World Trade Center, observed by Ben Bederson from the window of his Manhattan apartment, we are a nation living in fear and confusion about who our friends and enemies are and how to protect our families and friends from future horrors. The 9/11 attacks did not use the modern developments of science and technology, although the situation may be different in the future and prudent steps should be taken to counter terrorist activity. But an unreasonable fear of terrorism can easily result in government actions that remove long cherished rights and freedoms (including scientific freedoms) from U.S. citizens and others who wish to visit, study and work in our country. Some of this is happening at the present time. Freedoms, once removed, are not so easy to win back. Quite aside from reactions to genuine or perceived concerns about national and domestic security, science appears to be losing out to attacks by special interest groups—business, religious, ideological—that have strong political muscle at the
TWO CIVIC SCIENTISTS
47
present time and agendas that are in conflict with the pursuit of scientific truth. Many scientists feel that the very integrity of science is under attack. There are other areas where science is threatened; perhaps the most striking is in K-12 education, if only because we seem to have made so little progress in recent decades. The most serious problem is that the science and math teachers have insufficient knowledge in the subjects they are asked to teach, are paid too little to make teaching an attractive career, and often have to work in poor conditions with inadequate resources and too little time to do their job. To make matters worse, teachers must cope with political pressures, even laws in some states that attack science, e.g., the teaching of evolution in biology. Even at the university level, the challenge of reaching more than a tiny fraction of the university undergraduates with some understanding of physics has been a formidable one that remains largely unmet on most campuses. However, Ben Bederson, through his “popular” physics courses “Sound and Music” and “Physics and Society”, which he established in 1972 and which he has taught on CBS “Sunrise Semester”, as well as the Humanities Seminar entitled “Human Values and Technological Choice”, has provided a model we should all attempt to emulate. The attitude toward science held by the American public remains positive, according to the National Science Board.13 But, far too few citizens feel they have any real understanding of scientific and technical issues. While we live in a time when the power of science and technology to change people’s lives is so immense, ironically, science is under attack from some influential quarters. There is the risk that a society that continues to be uninformed about science will begin to mistrust science and fail to support it, financially and philosophically. It is a crucial time for scientists, in the role of “civic scientists”, to become more visible in society. Ben Franklin and Ben Bederson are, in my opinion, model “civic scientists”. Both Bens had—and in Bederson’s case, still does have—an enormously productive and influential scientific life, which broadened into a life of public service, as they put all of their knowledge and skills to work for the improvement of society. I did not have the chance to meet Benjamin Franklin. But, Benjamin Bederson was a leader in his field when I finished my PhD at Oklahoma University and set out to begin my career. He was immediately helpful, friendly and welcoming to a “kid from Oklahoma” who had so much to learn. I feel enormously grateful to Ben Bederson for helping me in those early years, as he helped so many others, and, of course, for his enormous contributions to physics, to the history and literature of physics, to education, and to society.
13 National Science Board (of the National Science Foundation), “Science and Engineering Indicators”, 2004, Chapter 7.
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
AN EDITOR PAR EXCELLENCE EUGEN MERZBACHER Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, CB#3255, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3255, USA, e-mail:
[email protected]
Over the years Ben Bederson has called me up from time to time, out of the blue, announcing his arrival for a visit in my office or at my home the next day, or even the same day. He would fly in and out within a few hours, sometimes en route from or to Alaska (where one of his sons lives)—allowing no more time than needed for lunch in one of our college eateries. More to the point, his schedule would provide for just enough leisure to talk me into some new assignment in the physics community or into letting him place my name in nomination on some election ballot. His persuasive powers were, and are, astonishing. Superficially, on these visits Ben would appear relaxed as if he had nothing else to do in the foreseeable future, but by the time we reached dessert he would have delivered his message and his “invitation”. I never thought of him as very athletic, but he certainly knew how to twist my arm. He was always forthright about the time and effort required for the duties that he had in mind for me, but he stressed the support that he could make available to ease the burden. Needless to say, I (almost) always capitulated to his dulcet entreaties, and shortly thereafter we were in the car again on the way back to the airport, usually talking about the “weirdness” of quantum mechanics that bothered Ben long before it became a favorite topic for science writers. Ben was true to his promises: Anyone who succeeded him, whether in the position of chair of DAMOP (Division of Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics of the APS) or ICPEAC (International Conference on the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions) or any other of his many roles in our community, would find the house in good order. He usually had resolved messy old problems and identified important new issues on the horizon. I was always in awe of Ben’s people skills and tried to learn from him, but I could never come close to achieving his deftness in charming his quarry. Finally, the day of revenge came in 1991, when I was fortunate to participate in recruiting him to a five-year term (1992–1996) as Editor-in-Chief of The American Physical 49
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51010-3
50
E. Merzbacher
Society (APS).1 The physics community owes him a profound debt of gratitude for his far-sighted stewardship of the premier research journals that serve all of us. This essay, in his honor, recounts my interactions with Ben during this period. I should have known Ben! As soon as he accepted the position of Editor-inChief, he established an APS Task Force on Publication Policy2 and twisted my arm to serve as its chair. Our job was to analyze some urgent problems that all sections of the Physical Review (PRA through PRD, alphabetically, shortly thereafter augmented by PRE)3 and the other APS research journals, Physical Review Letters (PRL) and Reviews of Modern Physics, were facing, and to formulate recommendations for ensuring their future into the early 21st century.4 We were asked to consider: (1) a policy on growth of the journals; (2) a policy on launching new journals in emerging areas of physics; (3) the implications of all this for space owned by the APS at Ridge, NY, and leased at Woodbury, NY, housing editorial and production facilities; (4) the future of editorial operations, evaluating the pros and cons of in-house and remote editing and their relative costs, as well as the optimal level of copy and technical editing; (5) the implications for acquiring new hardware (computers, etc.); and last but certainly not least, (6) the inexorable drive toward electronic publishing. These questions and issues reflected the wisdom of David Lazarus, Ben’s predecessor as Editor-in-Chief (1981–1991), and Ben’s farsighted vision of the scientific publishing business, for which his long-term editorship of Advances in Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics and of PRA (1978–1992) had prepared him.5 Ben himself was an indispensable ex officio member of the Task Force, as were the other two Operating Officers of the Society, the Executive Secretary and the Treasurer. Ben asked questions and listened carefully to the discussion by the members, most of whom had been selected because of their extensive experience with the operations of the APS publishing enterprise. He was savvy enough not to push his own agenda for the future of the journals—but of course in the end 1 Letter of 27 June 1991, from E. Merzbacher to B. Bederson, with details of Bederson’s appointment as Editor-in-Chief of the research publications of The American Physical Society. 2 This group was also known as the Task Force on Publication Operations Planning. Its members were H. H. Barschall, Benjamin Bederson, Alan A. Chodos, James A. Krumhansl, David Lazarus, Harry Lustig, Barrett H. Ripin, Jack Sandweiss, Myriam Sarachik, N. Richard Werthamer, and Eugen Merzbacher (chair). Its final report and recommendation to the APS Council is dated 31 March 1992. 3 The five sections of the Physical Review represent the following subjects: PRA, Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics; PRB, Condensed Matter and Materials Physics; PRC, Nuclear Physics; PRD, Particles, Fields, Gravitation, and Cosmology; PRE, Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics. 4 For a concise account of the history of the journals and their status near the end of the twentieth century, see the Preface by Benjamin Bederson in “The Physical Review, The First Hundred Years, A Selection of Seminal Papers and Commentaries”, H. Henry Stroke, ed., American Institute of Physics, New York, 1995, pp. xi–xiii. 5 See Bernd Crasemann’s article on Ben as APS Editor in this volume.
AN EDITOR PAR EXCELLENCE
51
most of our recommendations conformed to his well-considered plans and provided him with the organizational, i.e., political, support that he needed for their successful implementation. One might wish that our country’s leadership would include more people as astute as Ben! Much of the Task Force’s advice was of a technical nature and directed to the Publications Oversight Committee and the management of the APS and its publications. One central issue, however, called for a more formal policy resolution by the governing bodies of the Society, because of its profound implications for the financial health of the APS: the near-explosive growth of the Physical Review, both with regard to submission and acceptance of manuscripts. Although the late Heinz Barschall expressed some technical reservations, based on his long experience as Editor of PRC, the Task Force submitted a unanimous report to the APS Council for endorsement in late March 1992 in the form of a resolution: It is the policy of the American Physical Society that the Physical Review shall continue to accept for publication those manuscripts that advance physics and have been found to be scientifically sound, of high quality, and in satisfactory form. No arbitrary quantitative limits [i.e., quotas] will be set on the acceptance of papers published in the Physical Review. Only editorial judgments of scientific merit, arrived at through the editorial process utilizing the peer review (refereeing) system, may be used to control the content of the Physical Review. As in the past, the [American Physical] Society will implement this policy as fairly and efficiently as possible and without regard to national boundaries.
As Editor-in-Chief, Ben spared no effort to ensure, preferably by gentle persuasion but by decree if necessary, that the editorial process of APS would adhere to this policy statement. The Task Force conducted its review with an awareness of the economic implications and costs of the proposed publication policy, but was not asked to spell out how the expansion in staff, space, and facilities, required by the projected continuing growth of the journals, would be funded. When it comes to implementing lofty principles that have budgetary consequences, tensions inevitably arise between the guardians of editorial purity and the Society’s Treasurer, who is also the Publisher of the Physical Review and responsible for keeping the organization solvent. The priorities of the Editor-in-Chief had to be reconciled with the fiduciary responsibilities of the Treasurer. In the event, their shared keen understanding of the physics community, their mutual commitment to high standards of quality, and their enlightened views of the intricacies of the global system of scientific publishing guided the officers in making decisions that have proved to be sound and prescient. Fortunately, those were relatively rosy economic times, allowing the realization, on his watch, of many of Ben’s initiatives, including the addition of new space for new editors working with new technologies, without impinging adversely on the Society’s activities that benefit the physics community but bring in little or no revenue (e.g., educational programs, international outreach, public affairs initiatives).
52
E. Merzbacher
Journals, however, are dynamic systems, and there is never a time when the leadership of APS can afford the luxury of ignoring the pressures on the income side of the ledger sheet. While adhering to the principle that an APS member subscriber should not have to pay more than necessary to defray the incremental cost of subscription fulfillment and mailing of one copy of the journal, how much of a surcharge over the raw production costs might APS reasonably impose on its primary customers, the world’s science libraries? On the other hand, what fraction of the cost of producing research articles should be borne by authors as a legitimate levy against their research budgets, and what form should such charges take (e.g., page charges, article charges, abstract charges, etc.)? Editor-in-Chief Bederson was constantly involved in discussions of these questions.6 His outlook was invariably optimistic, and for the good of physics he was willing to take risks, without being reckless. His heart was always on the side of the individual author, the member subscriber, and the consumer, meaning the reader, but he never lost sight of the overriding objective—to go for the best physics and to foster the highest standards of quality in our research journals. Meanwhile, the flood of submissions of manuscripts from all over the world to Physical Review and PRL continued to rise unabated, causing severe strains in the editorial system. It seemed as if authors regarded every new hurdle a challenge, intended to enhance the appeal of publishing in our journals. At the same time, library budgets and library shelf space could no longer keep up with the rapid inflation in numbers of journals, volume of printed pages, and the attendant skyrocketing costs. The journals were growing and becoming ever more expensive, while the number of subscribers was steadily dropping—two trends that, if not soon reversed, were bound eventually to lead to a catastrophe. The Physical Review was in danger of becoming the victim of its very success as the premier physics research publication. Ben found himself in the middle of the gathering storm. Early in 1994 Ben Bederson paid me again one of his dreaded visits,7 and before I knew it I had agreed to chair an APS Task Force on Journal Growth. In the charge to the new Task Force, Ben, together with Michael Turner (then Chair of the APS Publications Oversight Committee), laid out the problem: For many years now submissions to our research journals have grown inexorably, more or less linearly with time. While we are appreciative of the fact that growth generally implies a healthy situation, growth also carries with it a number of problems. It happens that essentially all of our growth is from non-US sources at the present time. But perhaps even more importantly, we simply do not understand the reasons for our growth,
6 Today these issues are again hotly debated, especially in the life sciences community. See the model proposed by the Public Library of Science at its website, http://www. publiclibraryofscience.org/. 7 My memory is fuzzy here. This visit may have been virtual, by telephone.
AN EDITOR PAR EXCELLENCE
53
and, not understanding them, we might equally well not anticipate significant decreases in submissions, should they occur. You should also consider the question of limitation on growth . . . Bear in mind that the coming decade must surely witness the arrival of electronic journals . . . You should consider the likely impact these developments will have on our journals.8
Ben provided the new Task Force with constant encouragement and support, but scrupulously avoided any personal interference in its independent deliberations. Unlike the earlier Task Force on Publication Policy, which relied entirely on existing data, the new Task Force undertook several studies and surveys of its own.9 1. Members of the Task Force made a quality study of the Physical Review to assess the possibility of controlling the growth of the APS journals without compromising their excellence. They concluded that the application of more stringent acceptance criteria might stem the tide, at least temporarily. 2. A survey of foreign-address authors found that these authors have every intention of submitting even more papers to the APS journals, which enjoy the greatest international prestige, are regarded in many subfields as the best vehicle to publicize and validate an author’s work, and are universally accessible. 3. A study on The Growth of Physics Journals was conduced by Heinz Barschall as a follow-up on his earlier study of The Cost of Physics Journals.10 The data again confirmed what a relative bargain the APS journals (and the journals published by the American Institute of Physics) are for the libraries, compared to most other journals in our field, although few of them experienced the same explosive growth that confronted Ben Bederson. Ben understood clearly, and the Task Force concurred, that in the midst of a revolution in Information Technology, adjustments in policy and procedure cannot be expected to be current for more than a few years and must be flexible enough to accommodate to the impending advances in electronic publishing. Almost everyone agreed that the system of anonymous peer review should be preserved, because it confers significant value upon a published paper. In the short term, the Task Force saw no need for radical measures (such as fixed annual page budgets), but it urged that
8 Memo of 10 March 1994, from Benjamin Bederson to APS Task Force on Journal Growth. The
members of the Task Force on Journal Growth were Heinz H. Barschall, Wick Haxton, John R. Kirtley, T. Maurice Rice, Barrett H. Ripin, Jin-Joo Song, Erick J. Weinberg, and Eugen Merzbacher (chair). 9 Report of APS Task Force on Journal Growth, 8 February 1995. 10 Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 33 (1988): 1437–1447. For a fascinating account of the protracted litigation caused by this report, see the carefully documented article by Harry Lustig, Am. J. Phys. 68 (2002): 595–636.
54
E. Merzbacher
• the standards of scientific quality be raised by applying stricter acceptance criteria, • the appeals procedures be streamlined and guidelines be adopted that, while still safeguarding the rights of authors, would cut back on time-consuming exchanges between editors and authors, and • incentives should be offered to authors who submit articles electronically and disincentives be imposed on those whose papers require manual processing and heavy copyediting. Building on his experience as editor of Physical Review A from 1978 until 1992,5 Ben introduced during his five-year term as Editor-in-Chief many of these and other reforms. At every step, he worked tirelessly to justify and maintain the reputation of the APS journals for scientific excellence. He took initiatives that kept the journals in tune with the changing landscape of physics,11 and he insisted on scrupulous editorial fairness. The American Physical Society has made it easy to evaluate the impact of Ben’s efforts on the journals. A well-organized website12 provides a cornucopia of statistical information on the Physical Review and Physical Review Letters, over a forty-year period, including some instructive graphs. After a steep rise in submissions in the early part of the Bederson tenure, there was a notable slowing down in the second half of Ben’s term, but recently the upward trend has resumed, reaching a growth rate of about six percent per year. Since 1988, more manuscripts have originated outside than within the U.S., and there are now over three times as many foreign submissions as domestic ones. Amazingly, and to the delight of the hard-strapped libraries, in 2005 the subscription prices for APS journals will decrease for the first time in memory, despite continuing growth.13 The shift to electronic information technology, implemented by a cost-conscious editorial and operational staff, is largely responsible for the savings that are making this extraordinary turn-around possible. While he could not have done it alone, Ben deserves much credit for preparing the APS publications system for the challenges of the twenty-first century. To appreciate this accomplishment one only has to look at the Physical Review OnLine Archive (PROLA),14 which goes back to the inaugural issue of The Physical Review in 1893—an event whose hundredth anniversary fell into Ben’s tenure as Editor-in-Chief.4 Even as he has managed to hold numerous responsible administrative positions —often several of them simultaneously—Ben has never become the proverbial 11 For example, in 1993 Physical Review A15 became Physical Review E, a separate section, now covering statistical physics, nonlinear, and soft matter physics. 12 http://forms.aps.org/general.html#stats. 13 http://librarians.aps.org/2005pricing.html. 14 http://prola.aps.org/.
AN EDITOR PAR EXCELLENCE
55
bureaucrat. His deep love for physics, history, music, good food, New York City and the Berkshires, and his devotion to his family and many friends have always been on the front burner. What a wonderful man we have in our midst! I am grateful to Bernd Crasemann and Roger Stuewer for sharing drafts of their contributions to this volume with me, to Harry Lustig for helpful advice, and to George Basbas for useful information. This is also a good place to acknowledge the valuable and cheerful support that Nicole Wachsman provided to the APS task forces whose work is summarized in this article. The title of this essay was subliminally suggested by Roger Stuewer’s concluding paragraph.
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
BEN AS APS EDITOR BERND CRASEMANN Physics Department, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA
Ben Bederson served as Editor of Physical Review A (PRA) from 1978 until 1992, when he was appointed Editor-in-Chief of the American Physical Society (1992– 1996), to deal with problems of a generally different nature. I succeeded Ben as Editor of PRA and I still have that job. This sketch is intended to relate some of the highlights of Ben’s contributions as Editor and some personal impressions of his style and the impact he made on APS’ editorial procedures and guiding philosophy. Many colleagues kindly contributed vignettes from memory. Ben relates that his introduction to the Editorial Office started “with a bang”: The (then) Editor-in-Chief overruled the PRA Editor’s decision to reject a manuscript and had it reinstated. This incident led Ben immediately to start steps that would bring about greater accountability in the editorial process and lead to authors’ right to appeal editors’ decisions formally to an Editorial Board (which he created) for adjudication; a further appeal, regarding fairness of procedure only, could then be lodged with the Editor-in-Chief. Ben does not recall overruling editors as Editor-in-Chief at any time, “an affirmation that editors [are] generally fair and conscientious in exercising their authority”. The appeals recourse, probably unique among scientific journals, is praiseworthy for being very democratic. Yet, with the number of submissions to PRA having risen to some 3000 per year at present, appeals (often used by authors with little understanding of science) have become increasingly like the ring about the cormorant’s neck, taxing eminent Editorial Board members’ and overworked editors’ time to the limit. During a current reassessment of future plans for the Journal, modification of this provision may need to be addressed. The foregoing episode is an example of Ben’s attitude toward his editorial staff, authors and readers. The overriding aspect was his collegial approach, perhaps grounded in his long-time association with academia, as a member of the Physics faculty and, in 1986–1989, Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of New York University. He trusted editors and staff and carefully listened to their advice on proposed changes of substance in Journal policy and operations. Twice 57
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51011-5
58
B. Crasemann
a year Editors Meetings were held, in which significant items were debated and often subjected to a vote by participants. This approach enhanced loyalty and dedication of the “A-Team”, whose members came to consider themselves participants in the noble aims of the Society. These aims were distilled in Article 2 of a Constitution drafted by a representative Council, soon after the founding of the APS in 1899: “The objective of the Society shall be the advancement and diffusion of the knowledge of physics.” Implicit in this proclamation and an amendment added in 1971 is the volunteerism of the many persons engaged in carrying out and overseeing the Society’s tasks—a spirit that persists to this day, despite growth of the tasks. In the editorial milieu, this volunteerism has been a special boon as exercised beyond Editors and Staff by our referees, of whom now some 6000 lend advice every year to PRA editors. Ben’s years in the Editorial Office spanned a period of drastic changes, in spirit as well as in technology. Carol Kraner, who led the PRA in-house staff until her retirement in 1996, recalls: “When Ben was first appointed Editor of PRA, the editorial offices were located on the third floor of the Physics building at Brookhaven National Laboratory. The journals were able to use the mainframe computer of the Physics Department; in fact my first job was proofreading punch cards and then, if I was really lucky, I could take the trays of cards down to the computer room and try to run the job. This was done at the end of the work day and on several occasions the job wouldn’t run because of errors, which meant that the offending cards had to be routed out and corrected and then the job be taken down to be run again”. Continues Carol: “I mention this because one of Ben’s ideas when he first came was to give a more personal touch to communications with both authors and referees. Adding editorial notes to the computer-generated forms and letters wasn’t possible except for a few already programmed sentences. A battle ensued between secretarial services and Ben’s wishes. It was even suggested that he be “trained”. Of course that was impossible, so some letters and notes were hand-typed. The software to handle these requests was eventually developed, but not for a long time; the pressure was constant . . .” Ben’s personal touch extended not only to authors and referees, but also very much to Associate and Assistant Editors and Staff. Margaret Malloy, who succeeded Carol upon her retirement as in-house manager and has continued to be the guardian of the “A-Team” spirit, recalls: “Memorable, to me, was when I was teasing Ben (he had just taken over as Editor-in-Chief) about his ‘bonding’ with the Editorial Assistants and he asked what I thought he could do to ‘bond’ better. I teasingly told him that he could take us all out to eat at the Russian Tea Room. Well, he smiled and said: ‘I can do that’. True to his word, he invited the 20 of us to his apartment (Georgetown Plaza, overlooking the East River and the skyline) for drinks followed by a dinner at an elegant restaurant (the One Fifth Avenue, the
BEN AS APS EDITOR
59
Russian Tea Room being closed). This was on December 6, 1995. It was a memorable affair; I still have a picture, hanging on my office door, of Ben surrounded by the Assistants. It was taken that night in his apartment. We used to joke about playing duets together (we both play violin) . . .” Adds Carol to the theme: “We did manage to have fun together outside the job too. Henry Stroke may remember when we borrowed his bicycle one noon at NYU. With Ben, on his decrepit rusty bike which had only one pedal (but he could make it work), we rode to Chinatown for a dim sum lunch. And we managed to play tennis a few times, once on the roof of the athletics building at NYU and once or twice at meetings of the APS Division of Atomic and Molecular Physics (DAMOP). He was a pretty cagey player with a bagful of spins, slices, and drop shots that made me run a lot. Even as our friendship grew, however, our professional relationship stayed formal. It was really the challenge of editing that we loved and that remained the most important part of our relationship”. A reminiscence from Tom Miller, who worked at NYU at the time, further illustrates the toil exerted by editorial staff under circumstances that now appear quite primitive. “For the selection of referees, a computer database was not constructed until the early 80’s. Before, Ben used a private set of dog-eared 3 × 5-in. cards he leafed through . . .” [In fact, when I took over Ben’s job in 1992, I inherited a copy of this set which I still consult on occasion, largely for historical interest.] “The computer terminal that communicated with the Brookhaven office was in a supply closet in the [NYU] Graduate Dean’s (Ben’s) office, having something to do with phone lines and power. Once a day, you’d open the closet door, pull up a chair, assign referees, and deal with staff questions”. Interacting with referees is by no means dull. Tom recalls a referee report from J.S. Bell at Queen’s University in Belfast, whom Ben had asked to evaluate a manuscript that dealt with Bell’s Inequality. The review started off: “J.S. Bell would turn over in his grave if he were to see this paper”. When Physical Review celebrated its Centennial in 1993, Ben with characteristically stern conviction of the importance of referees’ anonymity, turned down a suggestion that he tell about this incident, saying “No, no, we can’t use a referee’s report”. (The statute of limitations may have expired by now.) Carol’s successor Margaret Malloy at times cheers up the Editorial Board at one of its staid meetings with passages from recent referee reports. Here are a few examples: From a PRB referee: “I cannot review this paper as it is wrong and I did it first”. Brute honesty: “This paper should be rejected for the following reasons: (1) No one cares about this anymore; (2) anyone who could referee it is probably dead; (3) all who read it will wish they were”. Team spirit: “I have downloaded the manuscript to review. However, it looks terribly familiar. In fact, I saw it the other night in bed. My husband (the delin-
60
B. Crasemann
quent reviewer) was reading it. Can I suggest that you let me apply some pressure to him to return a review, rather than have me begin reading this lengthy manuscript?” Many changes that came about during Ben’s dozen years at the helm, innovative at the time, have grown symbiotically into the modus operandi of the Editorial Office. From the time of his appointment in 1978, Ben was a “remote” editor, retaining his base at NYU while working closely with the journal editorial staff in Ridge, Long Island. The staff was headed by Carol Kraner, assisted by Margaret Malloy who rose to the position when Carol retired. Explains Ben, being a “remote” editor did not imply a lack of involvement, but indicated that I remained a faculty member at New York University and conducted editing business by mail, telephone and email, with virtually daily interaction with the staff, interspersed with occasional visits to Ridge. On the whole this system worked very smoothly, attributable in no small part to the skill and dedication of the Ridge editorial staff, although of course we had our occasional foul-ups, discontented authors and dilatory referees. These are problems which will never go away.” The “remote” approach in fact worked so well that I was appointed on a similar basis to succeed Ben, the distance from Oregon to Long Island being even greater than from Manhattan, the ease of communication leaping ahead with more sophisticated technology, and especially with the World-Wide Web coming into use. These advances and their application through Journal Information Systems Director Bob Kelly and his ingenious staff have led to a new age of editing. Long-time APS colleague Amy Halsted has illustrated this, citing a 1993 piece by Gary Taubes in Science (259, 1246) entitled “Publication by electronic mail takes physics by storm”. Completion of the “PRISM” code now allows APS editors and staff (and, to a limited extent, referees) to view manuscripts and related correspondence electronically—thus propelling us toward the long-time aim of a “paperless office”. The electronic approach has made it possible to engage six of the present seven PRA Associate Editors on a “remote” basis, as consultants, at considerable savings—except for Margaret Malloy, who had to remain in Ridge to coordinate the whole effort. Other APS journals benefit similarly. It also seems likely that this dispersal of editors keeps them closer to researchers and places where scientific frontiers are actually being expanded—an antidote against Ridge becoming an ivory tower! The move toward electronic communication, and especially to help get the journals and archives to appear online, is considered by Ben to have been “one of [his] proudest achievements, though hardly performed alone”. The earliest effort in this direction was unsuccessful: A major library journal distributor, OCLC, was hired to produce Physical Review Letters online. They soon reneged on the deal, however, after discovering that they “were not quite ready for prime time”. Fortunately, the American Institute of Physics rescued the process.
BEN AS APS EDITOR
61
Another advance, way overdue, was introduced in Ben’s second year on the job: a more logical division of subjects, followed by concomitant new titles and splitting of the Journal. Writes Ben: “When I first became Editor, Physical Review A had the subtitle ‘General Physics’. I never cared for this designation. It gave the impression of being a catch-all for anything that could not fit properly into a truly specialized journal, implying, it seemed, second-class status. In fact, the topics covered under the rubric ‘General Physics’ have turned out to be as lively, cutting-edge and stimulating as any other subfields of physics”. More realistic labeling and some redistribution of subjects led, in July 1990, to a split between Physical Review A, dealing with Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics, and a new Physical Review E, now subtitled Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics. In a subsequent “very revolutionary action”, instituted in 1993, Ben’s first year as Editor-in-Chief, the covers of APS journals, previously referred to as ‘the Jolly Green Giant’ or more derogatorily as ‘the Green Monster’, were all changed, with each of the Physical Review journals given its own color. PRA became, and remains, silver. “An expected outcry against the violation of our glorious green tradition never materialized” states Ben. There were some dark periods. While the APS has never sued anybody, the Society since 1987 has had to defend itself in the courts in four cases, all connected with publishing. (A detailed account of these fascinating episodes is given by Harry Lustig in his splendid article on the history of the American Physical Society (see [4]). Two plaintiffs sued the Society for not publishing their work, one sought to punish APS for publishing an author’s work, and in one case a third party attempted to compel the Society to reveal the identity of a referee of a manuscript that was not accepted for publication. Ben and I became personally involved when the APS was accused of improperly refusing to publish a manuscript. Physical Review A had accepted an article by a University of Maryland research associate. When the author’s colleagues found out about it, through prepublication of the abstract, they complained that the work had in fact been done jointly with them and that publishing the article (a Brief Report) without recognition of them would be improper. The Journal decided to suspend publication unless and until the matter could be resolved. The author thereupon sued his collaborators and the APS, as well as Ben and me personally, for $1,000,000 each, claiming that the refusal by the Physical Review to proceed with the publication of his manuscript after he had received notification of its acceptance constituted a breach of contract. The APS responded that there was no contract, that the Physical Review’s letter of acceptance contained conditions that were never satisfied, and that even if the parties had created a contract, there was no breach because the journal had not refused to publish the manuscript. The court agreed and dismissed the case. The lead lawyer for the APS had been Richard Meserve, a physicist and Fellow of the APS who has successfully represented the Society in all of the cases
62
B. Crasemann
until 1999, when he was confirmed as head of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Ben was amused by the large sum for which we were being sued, purportedly because we had prevented the author’s receiving a Nobel Prize, and commented: “If a Brief Report is worth a million dollars, what would be the price of a Rapid Communication?” Another trying time took place when Ben became a party to a huge struggle over the issue of page charges, particularly in Physical Review D, which ultimately led the APS to eliminate all required page charges for all its journals except for Physical Review Letters. The highlights upon which we have touched made Ben’s career as Editor singularly fruitful in solid accomplishments and also, perhaps more importantly, in the subtle ways in which he set the tone, built up the morale and fostered the team spirit among editorial workers. States Carol Kraner: “I believe that Ben’s greatest contribution to the PR journals was that he never settled for the status quo but was always thinking of new ways to improve and enrich the editorial process. What comes through in my recollections is my great admiration for Ben’s breadth of thought and creativity as an editor as well as for the man himself”. Adds Margaret Malloy: “Ben always had a down-to-earth charm about him that was very endearing. He is a brilliant man who also has a great sense of humor”. Those of us who had the privilege of working with Ben cherish the memory of an inspiring and productive relationship, seasoned with mutual respect and devotion to the aims of the APS publishing enterprise. We are happy that Ben appears to have similar recollections when he writes, “My over 12 years involvement with the APS journals has become one of the most interesting and rewarding periods of my life”. The writer is much indebted to Ben Bederson for sharing his recollections from the period covered in this chapter [1]. Friends and colleagues have been generous in communicating relevant experiences and observations. Notably, recollections by Carol Kraner [2] and Margaret Malloy [3] have been refreshing. Harry Lustig’s carefully researched article on APS’ history has been an important resource on context and details of many events related here [4]. Tom Miller contributed valuable recollections from early days of Physical Review A editorial operations [5]. Amy Halsted kindly made her Master’s Thesis available in which she describes the decision-making process that ended up with the APS moving from New York to College Park, Maryland [6]; this contains much valuable background material. Numerous pleasant conversations with other friends at meetings, in the APS Editorial Office and, particularly, on the “A-Team” have helped to round out my own impressions of this fragment of APS publishing. Needless to say, the writer is responsible for any errors or omissions.
BEN AS APS EDITOR
63
References [1] [2] [3] [4]
B. Bederson, private communication. C. Kraner, private communication. M. Malloy, private communication. H. Lustig, To advance and diffuse the knowledge of physics: an account of the one-hundred-year history of the American Physical Society, Am. J. Phys. 68 (2000) 595. [5] T.M. Miller, private communication. [6] A. Halsted, “From Manhattan to Maryland—The American Physical Society and its Relocation”, Master Thesis, Baruch College of the City University of New York, 1993 (unpublished).
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
BEN BEDERSON: PHYSICIST–HISTORIAN ROGER H. STUEWER1 Program in History of Science and Technology, Tate Laboratory of Physics, University of Minnesota, 116 Church Street SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wartime Reminiscences . . . . . . . . Physics and New York City . . . . . . APS Forum on the History of Physics Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
65 66 69 73 74 74
Abstract I discuss Ben Bederson’s contributions to the history of physics, focusing particularly on two articles he published in Physics in Perspective, one on his wartime experiences as a soldier in the U.S. Army’s Special Engineering Detachment, the other on physics in New York City. I also discuss his work for the Forum on the History of Physics of the American Physical Society.
1. Introduction Four years after P.W. Bridgman won the Nobel Prize in Physics for 1946 for his work in high-pressure physics, he offered what he called “impertinent reflections” on the history of science. It “seems to me”, Bridgman wrote, “that the one most important thing to realize about science is that it is a human activity”, a point of view that will be stressed “automatically” if “science is taught with a large admixture of history”, which will serve a purpose “that is increasingly important in our present day, namely to impart an adequate appreciation of the fundamental conditions under which science flourishes”. One of the lessons to be learned from the 1 Roger H. Stuewer is Professor Emeritus of the History of Science and Technology at the University of Minnesota. He came to know Ben as a member of the Executive Committee of the APS Forum on the History of Physics and as Co-Editor-in-Chief of the journal Physics in Perspective, as he describes in this article.
65
2005 Published by Elsevier Inc. ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51012-7
66
R.H. Stuewer
[2
history of science, Bridgman continued, is that instead of scientific ideas following a “logical order” of development, “the impartial historian will be compelled to invert the process by showing how seldom the course of scientific development has been the logical course”. The insight that the progress of science is often illogical is perhaps more important to the scientist himself than to the layman, and constitutes one of the reasons why the scientist is concerned with his history. This suggests that perhaps one of the most important fields of service of history of science is to the scientist . . . .
Bridgman concluded by challenging both scientists and historians: The upshot of all this skepticism and criticism is my conviction that the most profitable sort of history of science, at least for the scientist himself and perhaps for others, is contemporary history . . . . This will involve not only scanning contemporary literature . . . but intimate personal contact with the scientists themselves, attendance at scientific meetings and prodding of the individual scientists by correspondence or personal interview to disclose the more personal aspects which a false scientific modesty often inclines him to believe are irrelevant. This is going to demand a high degree of technical competence on the part of the historian himself, the acquiring of which will put serious demands on his abilities and demand long preparation. For this reason it seems to me that perhaps it will prove that the historians of science best able to serve this purpose will be scientists themselves who in their later years and out of the fullness of their experience are moved, because of an intrinsic interest, to set down their reminiscences. I believe, further, that an informed and intelligent recording of contemporary scientific history will be of value not only for the scientist himself, but will also have cultural and educational value for the layman (Bridgman, 1955 [1950]).
Bridgman’s words are as true today as they were a half century ago, and they relate directly to Ben Bederson, who is exactly the kind of distinguished physicisthistorian to whom Bridgman was referring.
2. Wartime Reminiscences Four years ago, because of his intrinsic interest in the history of physics, Ben published his reminiscences about his wartime service in the U.S. Army’s Special Engineering Detachment (SED) at Los Alamos in Physics in Perspective (Bederson, 2001), a journal that John S. Rigden and I founded three years earlier. Ben tells how in 1942, after two and a half years as a physics major at the City College of New York (CCNY), he was drafted into the army, was sent to take an electrical-engineering course in an Army Specialized Training Program at Ohio State University in Columbus, and then in January 1944 was assigned to the U.S. Army’s SED, serving first for a brief period at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, and then at Los Alamos. At Los Alamos Ben worked essentially as a research assistant to senior scientists on various aspects of explosives, first under the British physicist Philip B.
2]
BEN BEDERSON: PHYSICIST–HISTORIAN
67
Moon, testing the “strain gauges” attached to cylindrical hollow tubes containing explosives. Then, after the Russian–American chemist George B. Kistiakowsky, head of the Explosives Division, gave a small group of SEDs, including Ben, a complete overview of the bomb work (far beyond their “need to know”, thus belying the later myth of strict compartmentalization for security purposes), Ben worked under the American chemist Donald Hornig, developing and testing the switches that had to be triggered simultaneously to ignite the 32 detonation fuses at the apexes of the implosion lenses in the plutonium bomb (Fat Man). Because of the expertise he acquired in this work, in the spring of 1945 Ben had to fly frequently to the Air Force base at Wendover Field on the Utah–Nevada border to help train B-29 bomber crews in the assembly and use of these switches and other gear.2 That also was the reason he was among the SEDs who received orders to go to the South Pacific in May, after the defeat of Germany, to assemble, test, and select the best spark-igniter triggers for Fat Man. He flew out of Albuquerque on July 9 on a B-29 (the famous Green Hornet), which after several stopovers for refueling landed on the island of Tinian in the Marianas, the launching pad for the American bombing raids on the Japanese mainland. Fat Man was dropped on Nagasaki on August 9, 1945, and at the end of that month Ben received orders to return to Los Alamos, where he worked as a nuclear-reactor inspector until he was discharged from the army at Fort Bliss, Texas, in January 1946. Ben makes clear that his wartime experiences, as was the case for so many others, were crucial for his future career as a physicist. The element of luck can never be discounted. His modest educational background in physics by 1942 might well have been overlooked by the U.S. Army (which is not famous for its perceptiveness), and he could easily have been sent into combat in the European or Far Eastern theaters of war, perhaps getting wounded or even killed, as a close friend of his was at the end of 1944 in the Battle of the Bulge. Instead, his commanding officer in Columbus, Ohio, recognized Ben’s talent in physics and engineering and set him on a course to serve, eventually along with about 1800 other soldiers at Oak Ridge and Los Alamos, in the U.S. Army’s Special Engineering Detachment. Given that break, however, Ben then began to shine: At Los Alamos his “blue badge”, a kind of “second-class admission ticket”, was replaced with a “white badge”, giving him almost unlimited access to the Tech Area, where the main bomb work was being carried out. It also gained him admission to the weekly Tuesday-evening colloquia where progress reports were given by Enrico Fermi (the first one Ben heard) and other eminent scientists, enabling him to acquire “a pretty complete picture of most of the important aspects of the bomb work” and
2 Ben reveals that he used these opportunities to occasionally walk across the border in the evenings to the Nevada side to legally play blackjack, being “convinced at the time [that this game] could be conquered by counting cards”.
68
R.H. Stuewer
[2
to learn a great deal of science and engineering along the way. Further, despite constant homesickness, so familiar to every GI, Ben met and established lifelong friendships with many of his fellow SEDs as well as with senior scientists at Los Alamos. At the same time, he was given pause when he later learned that two of his fellow SEDs, David Greenglass, his communist-propagandizing bunk neighbor for a time, and Ted Hall, an occasional third participant in the Mushroom Society that he and Norman Greenspan formed to play classical music loudly at night,3 had been exposed as Soviet spies. Ben, like other SEDs, smarted under the knowledge that his army paycheck was under $100 per month and thus much less than that received by civilians at Los Alamos with lesser responsibilities and duties who, moreover, did not have to perform early-morning calisthenics and stand for Saturday-morning inspections. Still, Ben fondly remembered that he was excused from latrine duty and KP (which as a former GI myself, though a decade later and not in wartime, filled my heart with envy). That lesson in the venerable army tradition of “rank hath its privileges” was followed by others, as when Ben was given special authorization to wear civilian clothes, as well as a shoe-ration certificate for a pair of civilian shoes to wear on his flights to Wendover Field so as not to reveal to Air Force officers that a lowly soldier, far below their military ranks, was empowered to give them instructions. This also exposed a clue to another aspect of Ben’s future professional life, his commitment to history, since he carefully preserved these authorization documents for posterity. Similarly, he began keeping a diary when he left Albuquerque for Tinian on July 9, 1945, making entries into it almost every day until he returned to the United States at the end of August. He opened a further window into his personality when he recalled that among the items he packed into his footlocker for later shipping to Tinian was a novel to reread, Thomas Mann’s The Magic Mountain, “partly because of my identification with the protagonist Hans Castrop”. He carried with himself, however, the Modern Library edition of The Pocket Book of Verse, which he would pull out and read when standing in line— an experience familiar to every GI. “To this day”, Ben said, “I can recite by heart many of the poems in this splendid volume”. Ben’s homeward flight was marked by another significant event, a conversation he had with a fellow passenger, Edward C. Stevenson, who soon would become professor of physics at the University of Virginia, who advised him to go to graduate school after completing college: “I had not thought of this before”, Ben recalled. Ben took Stevenson’s advice: He declined to take part in the nuclear
3 After returning to Los Alamos from Tinian, Ben built his own 50-watt hi-fi amplifier, which he called the Bederson Belchmaster, and which he was able to get through army inspection and ship home to New York when he was discharged in January 1946.
3]
BEN BEDERSON: PHYSICIST–HISTORIAN
69
tests scheduled to take place in the South Pacific in 1946, even at the amazing salary of $1000 per month for six months—more than ten times his army pay. Instead, he returned to New York, completed his B.S. degree at City College that year, his M.A. degree at Columbia University in 1948, and his Ph.D. degree in physics at New York University in 1950, writing his thesis under Leon Fisher, a civilian friend of his at Los Alamos.4
3. Physics and New York City Ben witnessed another kind of war on September 11, 2001, when he saw the destruction of the South Tower of the World Trade Center from the window of his apartment in New York City. At that time he was about midway through a draft of another article that John S. Rigden and I had asked him to write for Physics in Perspective, an article on “Physics and New York City”, for its Physical Tourist section (Bederson, 2003). People throughout the world were horrified by the images they saw either directly, as Ben did, or on their television screens, and along with Ben people throughout the world knew that New York City, America, and the world had been forever transformed. Ben’s task immediately assumed great poignancy, and instead of writing “a relatively straightforward tour of the many sites in New York related to physics”, he wrote what he “unabashedly could call a story in praise of both my city and its physics, and how they have worked together to produce the remarkable pattern that stands unique in the world”. A New Yorker his entire life, Ben began by discussing the achievements of “three extraordinary people”, Thomas Alva Edison (1847–1931), an American born in the Midwest, and two Serbs, Nikola Tesla (1857–1943) and Michael Idvorsky Pupin (1858–1935), pointing out the locations of Edison’s powergenerating and distribution plants, Tesla’s several laboratories and living quarters, and Pupin’s educational roots (Cooper Union and Columbia University), bust, and apartment where he lived in his later years. Ben then took his readers to the Colonnade of the Hall of Fame for Great Americans overlooking the Harlem River in the Bronx, where 98 busts of noteworthy Americans have been erected (with 4 more to come after funds for them have been secured). These include busts of Benjamin Franklin (1706–1790), Peter Cooper (1791–1883), Samuel F.B. Morse (1791–1872), George Westinghouse (1846–1914), Alexander Graham Bell (1847–1922), Edison, the physicists Joseph Henry (1797–1878), Josiah Willard
4 In 1949 Ben needed one additional course in statistical mechanics as a requirement for his Ph.D. degree, which turned out to be given by the German-born theoretical physicist Fritz Reiche (1883– 1969) and was the most memorable course he ever took at NYU. Ben has presented a warm portrait of Reiche’s life and work in yet another article in Physics in Perspective (Bederson, 2005).
70
R.H. Stuewer
[3
Gibbs (1839–1903), and Albert A. Michelson (1852–1931), and the astronomers Maria Mitchell (1818–1889) and Simon Newcomb (1835–1909). Ben particularly admires the words of Gibbs that accompany his bust: “One of the principal objects of theoretical research is to find the point of view from which the subject appears in its greatest simplicity”. Ben noted next that Albert Einstein (1879–1955), after arriving at Ellis Island with his wife Elsa on April 2, 1921, gave the first lecture he ever delivered in America five days later at City College. He then told a heartwarming story about how Max Born (1882–1970) secured financial support for the famous atomicbeam experiments of Otto Stern (1888–1969) and Walther Gerlach (1889–1979) in Frankfurt in the early 1920s from Henry Goldman (1857–1937), head of the Goldman Sachs & Co. investment house; how Born later secured further financial support from Goldman for his own institute in Göttingen; and how after 1933 Born intervened with Goldman to secure financial support for Einstein’s work in assisting Jewish refugees from Germany. Continuing his focus on prominent physicists, Ben next sketched the deep personal and educational roots of Isidor I. Rabi (1898–1988), J. Robert Oppenheimer (1904–1967), Richard P. Feynman (1918–1988), and Julian Schwinger (1918–1994) in New York City. All except Rabi were born in New York City, although he spent his entire career there, and all except Oppenheimer later won Nobel Prizes in Physics. New York City high schools, Ben averred, “have been a breeding ground for physicists for at least three quarters of a century” and have produced a large number of future Nobel Laureates, as well as a vastly greater number of physicists who have had distinguished careers, with assorted accompanying honors . . . almost all of them within the free public school system. Many of these physicists were children of immigrants, or immigrants themselves, some coming from families living in poverty, at the lowest rungs of the economic ladder.
Three high schools “are particularly oriented to science, and to which admission is determined by competitive examinations throughout the city”, namely, the Bronx High School of Science, the Stuyvesant High School in Manhattan, and the Brooklyn Technical High School. The first is the leader in producing future Nobel Laureates (Leon N. Cooper, Melvin Schwartz, Sheldon L. Glashow, Steven Weinberg, Russell A. Hulse), but the second and third can claim one each (Roald Hoffman, Arno Penzias). Others too make the list: James Monroe High School and Walton High School, both in the Bronx (Leon Lederman, Rosalyn Yalow), the Manual Training High School (now John Jay High School) in Brooklyn (I.I. Rabi), Columbia Grammar (Murray Gell-Mann), and Far Rockaway High School (Richard Feynman and Burton Richter). Townsend Harris High School, which was established as part of City College, also can claim among its graduates one future Nobel Laureate (chemist Herbert Hauptman) and was long regarded as the elite of the elite—until the beloved Mayor Fiorello La Guardia abolished it in 1942. (“I don’t often make mistakes”, La Guardia said later, “but when I do it’s
3]
BEN BEDERSON: PHYSICIST–HISTORIAN
71
a beaut”.) Now resuscitated in Queens in 1984 by a group of alumni, Townsend Harris is today “as dynamic as it was in its first incarnation”. The New York Academy of Sciences in Manhattan, which was founded under another name in 1817 and assumed its present one in 1876, has sponsored numerous meetings, conferences, and symposia over the years, but perhaps its “most important role” has been its leadership, particularly by physicists, in advocating human rights. Its most noteworthy case was that of Andrei Sakharov (1921–1989), “one that played a significant role in loosening the tight grip of communism on the U.S.S.R.”. Sakharov first visited the Academy in 1988 and credited it with his release from exile in Gorki two years earlier. Turning to colleges and universities and concentrating only on those with major physics departments, Ben first calls our attention to Fordham University in the Bronx, where Victor F. Hess (1883–1964), Nobel Laureate of 1936 for his discovery of cosmic rays, taught after his immigration to the United States following the Anschluss of Austria in 1938 until his retirement in 1956. Unique among New York physicists, in 1947 Hess convinced the New York Board of Transportation to allow him to carry out experiments on the radiation emitted from rocks at the bottom of the 191st Street subway station, 180 feet below street level, a site well-protected from cosmic rays. Unique in another respect, this time as an educational institution, is the Cooper Union for the Advancement of Science and Art (Cooper Union for short), which was founded in 1859 and subsequently nurtured by the self-educated inventor and industrialist Peter Cooper (1791–1883). It remains unique to this day as a completely tuition-free college whose students are selected competitively; in fact, it was recently ranked as the “hardest school to get into” in the United States. Next on Ben’s list is the City University of New York (CUNY), the administrative umbrella organization for all of the public city colleges in New York, the major ones being City College (CCNY), Brooklyn College, Hunter College, Queens College, and Lehman College, each of which has its own undergraduate physics program but whose graduate programs are unified by the CUNY Graduate School at 365 Fifth Avenue, where some graduate classes also are taught. While all of CUNY’s colleges can claim well-known students and distinguished faculty members, both past and present, the “jewel in the crown” is City College in upper Manhattan, which was founded as the Free Academy in 1847. The American diplomat Townsend Harris (1804–1878) was instrumental in its founding, with its mission “to educate the whole people”. Almost all of its students came “from the city’s poorer population, were very talented and came from striving families having high ambitions for their children”, who “themselves were aware that the best way to escape working-class constraints was through the professions”. Prior to World War II, they were taught by a “small but select faculty” who worked with them to turn them into “generations of physicists who have become virtually legendary in their number and accomplishments”, as is evident from the partial list
72
R.H. Stuewer
[3
of them that Ben provided. In the postwar period, the transformation to a department with a flourishing Ph.D. program in physics began under the chairmanship of Harry Lustig in 1965–1970 and “reached its peak” under the presidency of Robert Marshak in 1970–1979. The department remains today “extraordinarily vital and productive”. Ben’s home institution, New York University at Washington Square in Manhattan, was founded as the University of the City of New York in 1831 “by a number of wealthy and influential New Yorkers who believed that their city should have an institution of higher education that would be accessible to children of middleclass and even working-class parents” who could not afford to send their children to prestigious Ivy League colleges. From its beginning, NYU was defined as a university, thus granting advanced degrees much earlier than Columbia University, for example. Around the beginning of the last century, NYU acquired a second campus at University Heights in the Bronx, and after World War II the Courant Institute of Mathematical Science, named after the distinguished German–American mathematician Richard Courant (1888–1972), also was established at Washington Square, all together thus effectively forming for a time three NYU physics departments, each with a distinguished history. Two future Nobel Laureates, Clifford G. Shull (1915–2001) and Frederick Reines (1883–1998), did their graduate work at the University Heights campus. Later, when that campus was sold to New York State, physics was consolidated at Washington Square, where it flourishes today in many of its subfields. Ben finally discusses Polytechnic University (founded as Brooklyn Polytechnic in 1854), the dominant engineering school in New York City and the second oldest one in the nation, and Columbia University, which is in “a class by itself on the New York physics scene” and “has had a glorious history that stretches back over a century”. To substantiate his claim, Ben lists 28 Nobel Laureates in Physics who were visiting professors at Columbia, who received their Ph.D. degrees there, or who were or are on the faculty there. Noteworthy also is that just prior to World War II, John R. Dunning (1907–1975) and his colleagues carried out pioneering research on nuclear fission in the basement of Pupin Hall, and during the war they, together with prominent physicists from other universities, did the same on the gaseous-diffusion process for separating the uranium isotopes, which later found massive implementation in the enormous Manhattan Project plants at Oak Ridge, Tennessee. Ben closes by giving a guided tour of Manhattan,5 pointing out the sites he discussed earlier as well as additional ones, such as that extraordinary national 5 Ben notes that in Manhattan, except for lower Manhattan and Greenwich Village, 20 street blocks equal 1 mile and distances between avenues equal 2.5 city blocks or 1/8 mile, the former being walkable in about 30 minutes “if you obey the traffic lights—which, of course would set you off immediately as a tourist”.
4]
BEN BEDERSON: PHYSICIST–HISTORIAN
73
treasure, the New York Public Library.6 It is “inspiring to note”, Ben reflects, how a “few visionaries” made such a great difference in the life of New York City, especially singling out two, Peter Cooper and Townsend Harris, both of whom “had an intense belief in free education as the best way to help children from lower and middle-class families to live creative and fruitful lives”. While they “represented the best of New York”, they also “serve as symbols for the multitude of other idealistic and far-sighted business leaders, teachers, and parents who contributed so much to the environment” of New York City. “And, of paramount importance, from the very beginning the arms of America embraced and welcomed the magnificent influx of talented people, physicists and others alike, into New York and beyond”. As his final thought, Ben leaves his readers with the words of the Ephebic Oath, once taken by young males in ancient Athens and now taken by all entering freshmen at Townsend Harris High School, urging that they are particularly appropriate after the attack of September 11, 2001, on New York City: I shall never bring disgrace to my city, nor shall I desert my comrades in the ranks; but I, both alone and with my many comrades, shall fight for the ideals and sacred things of the city. I shall willingly pay heed to whoever renders judgment with wisdom and shall obey both the laws already established and whatever laws the people in their wisdom shall establish. I, alone and with my comrades, shall resist anyone who destroys the laws or disobeys them. I shall not leave my city any less but rather greater than I found it.
4. APS Forum on the History of Physics Ben’s intrinsic interest in and commitment to history found further expression when he was elected as Chair of the Forum on the History of Physics of the American Physical Society, serving in 2001–2002. Then, when the Forum decided to establish a committee charged to define the nature of a new prize to recognize outstanding scholarship in the history of physics, and to raise the substantial funds required to support it, he also agreed to serve as chair of this committee. The American Institute of Physics soon became a cosponsor of the prize, which with the approval of both organizations has been named after another distinguished physicist-historian as the Abraham Pais Prize for the History of Physics. I was privileged to serve as a member of the APS-AIP Prize Committee during 2002– 2005,7 and I thus can attest personally to the outstanding leadership that Ben 6 Among the countless treasures deposited in the Manuscripts and Archives Division of the New York Public Library are the records of the Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars (1933–1945), which Ben used in his research on Fritz Reiche (Bederson, 2005). 7 The other members are Stephen G. Brush (who resigned in 2004), Gloria B. Lubkin, Harry Lustig (who has now replaced Ben as Chair), Michael Riordan, and Spencer R. Weart.
74
R.H. Stuewer
[6
provided to it. We met at the APS meetings in Albuquerque in April 2002 and in Philadelphia in April 2003, and both before and after these meetings we had more or less monthly conference calls, defining and refining the nature of the prize, exploring means of raising funds for it, and determining the criteria to be used in the selection of its recipients. Under Ben’s leadership, all of these aspects of the prize were brought to successful conclusions. The first recipient of the Abraham Pais Prize for the History of Physics is Martin J. Klein (Yale University), who delivered his Pais Prize Lecture, “Physics, History, and the History of Physics”, at the APS meeting in Tampa, Florida, in April 2005, appropriately during the World Year of Physics 2005. Ben’s stellar leadership here, however, did not truncate his service to the APS Forum on the History of Physics: In early 2004, he agreed to become Editor of the Forum’s Newsletter—a position that no one is more qualified to occupy than Ben.
5. Conclusion P.W. Bridgman was right: Physicist–historians play a vital role in writing “informed and intelligent . . . contemporary scientific history [that] will be of value not only for the scientist himself, but will also have cultural and educational value for the layman”. Ben Bederson is a physicist–historian who satisfies Bridgman’s imperative par excellence. I, like many others, have had the great good fortune that my worldline intersected with his.
6. References Bederson, B. (2001). SEDs at Los Alamos: A Personal Memoir. Physics in Perspective 3, 52–75. All quotations appear in this article. Bederson, B. (2003). Physics and New York City. Physics in Perspective 5, 87–121. All quotations appear in this article. Bederson, B. (2005). Fritz Reiche and the Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars. Physics in Perspective 7 (4). Bridgman, P.W. (1955). Impertinent reflections on history of science [1950]. In: Reflections of a Physicist. Philosophical Library, New York, pp. 338–360. Quotations on pp. 346–347, 353–355, 360.
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
PEDAGOGICAL NOTES ON CLASSICAL CASIMIR EFFECTS LARRY SPRUCH Department of Physics, New York University, 4 Washington Place, New York, NY 10003, USA
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dimensional Analysis and Physical Arguments The Vanishing of E¯ Cl . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An Unauthorized Thank You . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
76 77 78 81 81
Abstract Quantum electrodynamics (QED) gives finite values for properties for which preQED calculations give infinity. One can take the difference between two infinities. For the (Casimir) interactions between two ideal uncapped parallel plates at a tem¯ perature T = 0, for example, the (renormalized) energy per unit area, E(T = 0), the difference between the unrenormalized energies of the virtual photons in the region between the plates in the presence and absence of the plates, is finite. The same is true for T > 0, where real photons are also present: one then considers both ¯ ). For T ∼ ∞, the real ¯ ) and the (renormalized) free energy per unit area, E(T E(T ¯ photons dominate and E(T ∼ ∞) becomes classical (h-independent). The (renor¯ malized) classical result E¯Cl can also be obtained within a classical framework, the ¯ )) is zero. We ¯ ) (not E(T ultraviolet catastrophe notwithstanding. One finds that E(T give a more “physical” proof of that fact than the original proof. Thus, since the ¯ ∼ ∞) = kB T N¯ , where N¯ is the difclassical energy per mode is kB T , E(T ference between the number of modes per unit area in the region between the plates in the presence and absence of the plates. That N¯ = 0 is not obvious; the plates are uncapped and the adiabatic theorem is not immediately applicable. The evaluation of N¯ reduces to a one-dimensional problem for which the adiabatic theorem is immediately applicable, so that N¯ = 0 and therefore E¯ Cl = 0. We comment briefly on a few other Casimir effects. 75
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51013-9
76
L. Spruch
[1
1. Introduction Classical physics is bedevilled by infinities. Thus, the Rayleigh–Jeans law—more appropriately the Rayleigh law—for the electromagnetic energy density in free space at temperature T in the frequency interval ω to ω + dω is dω (1) , 2π 2 c3 where kB T is the energy for a mode. The energy density, the integral over ω, is therefore infinite, “the ultraviolet catastrophe”. Quantum electrodynamics, QED, made it possible to obtain finite values for the Lamb shift, Casimir effect, . . . . An ¯ ), with its associated interesting Casimir effect is the free energy per unit area, E(T force per unit area, F¯ (T ), between two open-ended ideal parallel plates at temperature T , one at z = 0 and one at z = l3 . (Throughout, an overline on a quantity ¯ represents the value per unit area of the quantity.) E(0) has long been known; it ¯ was obtained by Casimir (1948). One approach in calculating E(0) is to take the difference between the energy per unit area in the region between the plates in the presence and absence of the plates. Each energy is infinite, but if one recognizes that the plates are transparent to high energy photons and introduces a cut-off, that is, a convergence factor, the difference is finite.( Infinities can be avoided, as shown for example, by Brown and Maclay (1969), Schaden and Spruch (1998) and Gutzwiller (1990); the results in the last reference are based on Gutzwiller’s semi-classical approximation to the energy Green’s function.) At T = 0 only virtual photons, with zero-point energies h¯ ω/2, are present. For T > 0, real photons are also present. If the separation of the walls is changed ¯ 3 . With the high frequency photons slowly, with T constant, F¯ (T ) = −∂ E/∂l having been cut-off, one can interpret T ∼ ∞ as the inequality kB T h¯ ω for all ω. It has been found for a number of systems that, as is to be expected, ¯ E(T ∼ ∞) and F¯ (T ∼ ∞) are independent of h¯ . See for example, Milonni (1994). The results will be written as E¯Cl (T ) and F¯Cl (T ). It is natural to ask if the classical results can be derived within the framework of classical physics, that is, without the detour into QED. (It might seem obvious that it would be simpler, if possible, to avoid the detour, but obvious or not it isn’t necessarily true. In the Planck distribution frequencies with h¯ ω kB T fall of exponentially; there is no natural cut-off for the Rayleigh–Jeans distribution, u(ω) dω. We note, parenthetically, that u(ω) dω follows immediately from the distribution given by the uncertainty principle, 2d 3 pd 3 x/(2π h) ¯ 3 , on using 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 d p/h¯ = d k = d ω/c = 4πω dω/c .) In any event, it has been shown by Schaden and Spruch (2002) that the detour can be avoided, at least for parallel plates. A theoretical physicist in the 1890’s could have determined F¯ (T ) for the plates, the ultraviolet catastrophe notwithstanding. Of course, without a knowledge of QED or even of quantum mechanics, u(ω)dω = 2kB T ω2
2]
CLASSICAL CASIMIR EFFECTS
77
it would not have been possible to estimate the range of validity of the result, namely, that kB T hc/ ¯ l3 . (c/ l3 is the only frequency that can be formed from c and l3 .) Furthermore, experimental confirmation at that time would have been inconceivable. ¯ ) can be obtained in a clasWe will not consider the proof that for T ∼ ∞, E(T sical context—we have just above given the reference to the proof—but we will ¯ ) = 0, give a new argument for an essential element of the proof, namely, that E(T ¯ )). ¯ where E(T ) is the energy per unit area (not the free energy per unit area E(T The important contribution is the original rigorous proof by Feinberg et al. (2001), but our argument may be helpful. An essential point is the following. For E¯ Cl = 0, the standard relation E¯Cl = ¯ ECl −T S¯Cl reduces to E¯Cl = −T S¯Cl , where S¯Cl , the classical entropy per unit area, is not uniquely defined. However, F¯Cl = −T ∂ S¯Cl /∂l3 , and ∂ S¯Cl /∂l3 is uniquely defined. ¯ ) = 0 for plates, we comment Before turning to a more detailed proof that E(T briefly on the energies of some systems.
2. Dimensional Analysis and Physical Arguments Some insights into Casimir energies can be gained by studying a few simple systems. Consider a massless scalar meson field at T = 0 in the one-dimensional region 0 ≤ x3 ≤ l3 , satisfying Dirichlet or Neumann boundary conditions at each end. On dimensional grounds one finds the quantum result EQu (T = 0) = EQu (h¯ , c, l3 ) = C1 h¯ c/ l3 ;
(2)
the dimensionless constant C1 has not here been determined. For arbitrary T one cannot determine even the form of EQu (h¯ , c, kB T , l3 ) by dimensional analysis alone. However, as T ∼ ∞, the real photons dominate completely, EQu becomes independent of h¯ (and c), and one finds the classical result ECl (c, l3 ) ∼ C2 kB T , independent of l3 . (We need not include T ∼ ∞ in the argument; the subscript Cl implies that T ∼ ∞.) From the experimental viewpoint this is not an interesting system, because one normally measures forces, not energies, and the force is here zero, but there is the interesting feature that one can obtain at least the forms of ECl without having obtained EQu (T ). The situation is much the same for an electromagnetic (EM) field within a thin conducting spherical shell. The shell manifests itself via the boundary conditions it imposes; neither the charge nor the mass of the electron enters.The forms are then EQu (T = 0) = C3 h¯ c/R and ECl = C4 kB T . Indeed, the argument is the same for any obstacle or cavity completely defined by one length. For an EM field in a conducting box, l1 × l2 × l3 , with l1 l3 and l2 l3 , it follows on physical grounds that EQu and ECl are each proportional to l1 l2 . One
78
L. Spruch
[3
then deduces, for T = 0, that EQu (h¯ , c, l1 , l2 , l3 ) = l1 l2 EQu (h¯ , c, l3 ) = C5 hc ¯
l1 l2 l33
,
(3)
while ECl = C6 kB T l1 l2 / l32 . We note that for each of the above cases ECl has the same form as ECl ; the coefficients will differ. The argument can be extended somewhat. Consider a cavity completely characterized by lengths l1 , l2 , . . . , lM . The surface can be arbitrarily curved, for M = ∞ is allowed. (The results may not be valid for a non-ideal surface, nor in the presence of atoms.) We can then write EQu (T = 0) = hcf ¯ (l1 , . . . , lM ),
(4)
where f has the dimensions of 1/length but is otherwise arbitrary. If we scale each length by the factor K, EQu will be changed by a factor 1/K. The classical form is ECl = kB T g(l1 , . . . , lM ),
(5)
where g is dimensionless but otherwise arbitrary. ECl does not change if each length is scaled. We have not faced the serious problem of determining even the signs (but see later) of the E’s, let alone their magnitudes. (As noted above, Casimir (1948) determined C5 .)
¯ Cl 3. The Vanishing of E Since classically each mode has an energy kB T , it follows that E¯ Cl = kB T N¯ , where N¯ is the difference between the number of modes per unit area in the region between the plates in the presence and absence of the plates. Furthermore, we need not determine the frequency distribution of N¯ ; we need only know N¯ itself, the difference in the total number of modes per unit area. The modes, with wave functions described in terms of x1 , x2 , x3 , are uncoupled. The (unnormalized) wave function is ψ(x) = ψ(x1 , x2 )
∞
eiπn3 x3 / l3 − e−iπn3 x3 / l3 ,
(6)
n3 =1
where +∞ ψ(x1 , x2 ) =
+∞
−∞
dk2 eik2 x2 =
dk1 eik1 x1 −∞
dk eik ·x
(7)
3]
CLASSICAL CASIMIR EFFECTS
79
with k = (k1 , k2 ) and x = (x1 , x2 ). We therefore have N¯ = N¯ 12 N3 , where N¯ 12 = N1 N2 is the number of x -dependent modes per unit area and N3 is the number (not the number per unit area) of x3 -dependent modes. Since N¯ 12 is unchanged as l3 is changed, the evaluation of N¯ reduces to the evaluation of N3 , that is, to a one-dimensional problem, with 0 ≤ x3 ≤ l3 , where l3 is slowly changed. Since the energy levels for the one-dimensional problem are discrete, N3 = 0, and therefore N¯ = 0, and finally E¯ Cl = 0, which we set out to show. There is however, a proviso, that N¯ 12 be finite; if N¯ 12 = ∞ the statement that N¯ 12 = 0 would not be meaningful. Now we assumed there is a frequency ω0 such that the “ideal” walls are perfectly reflecting for ω < ω0 and perfectly transparent for ω > ω0 . (The value of ω0 need not concern us. It is of order 1016 Hz for a real metal.) The index of refraction in the vacuum is, of course, unity. Let n(ω) be the index of refraction of the wall. For a wave normal to the surface the transmission coefficient is T = 2/(1 + n). We must therefore assign the values n = ∞ for ω < ω0 and n = 1 for ω > ω0 . But then, by Eqs. (7.39a) and (7.41a) of Jackson (1975), T = 1 for any incident angle θ other than π/2. Since the wave vector k has a component k3 = ±n3 π/ l3 , θ will not be π/2. Only waves with ω < ω0 propagate forever between the walls, so that the number of such waves per unit area is finite. N¯ 12 is indeed finite. There is still a difficulty. We invoked the fact that k3 = 0 to show that waves could not travel forever parallel to the modes, and that represents a coupling between the walls, a coupling which we stated did not exist. We can bypass the difficulty by assuming that the region between the plates is not an ideal vacuum but contains an infinitesimal number density of atoms. There would then be some absorption and propagation over infinite lengths would not be possible. We hope that most physicists will feel comfortable with the argument, but note that Feinberg et al. (2001) did not need any such assumption. If one is to obtain the frequency distribution, one cannot factor N¯ . ω for the mode for ψ given by Eq. (6) is 1/2 π 2 2 + k c. ω = n3 (8) l3 ω is not a monotonic function of l3 . Some frequencies increase and some decrease as l3 is decreased, with thresholds at ωn = n3 πc/ l3 . The frequency distribution is known and was used by Feinberg et al. (2001) in their proof that ECl = 0. We note with some disbelief that an argument that persisted in the literature for years was ¯ that E(T = 0) < 0 because there were, presumably, fewer modes in the region between the plates in the presence than in the absence of walls. The argument was shown to be wrong by Boyer (1974). (That the argument cannot be true for T ∼ ∞ follows from the validity of the adiabatic theorem even for uncapped plates.) It should be mentioned that since the energy per mode for T ∼ ∞ is kB T for almost any system, the determination of ECl reduces to the determination
80
L. Spruch
[3
of N ; one need not know the frequency distribution. This opens up the very interesting possibility of a quite different approach to the determination of ECl . The following discussion is very crude and preliminary, ignoring the distinction between the energy internal and external to the sphere. We are interested in the possibilities of the method just noted rather then in the results, and we study massless scalar mesons satisfying Dirichlet boundary conditions within a spherical shell of radius R; the shell need not be thin and is not ideal. The number density n(k) of modes with wave number k in a volume V of area S and curvature K, given by McKean and Singer (1967), is 1 S V 2 k − K + O k −2 . Sk + (9) 8π 2π 2 6π 2 (The k dependence of the various terms follows on dimensional grounds. The volume term is that due to Weyl.) The number density nfree (k) in free space of volume V is the volume term in Eq. (9). When applied to the sphere, under the assumption that, as for the electromagnetic radiation, the shell is transparent to mesons with k > k0 —the k0 is not that for EM radiation—one finds for the difference N in the total number of modes that propagate within the region occupied by the sphere, in the presence and absence of the sphere, n(k) =
k0 N =
4πR 2 1 1 2 + · · · dk − 4πR k + 8π 6π 2 R
0
2 (10) (k0 R) + · · · . 3π [The sphere is now characterized not by R alone but by R and a length l0 = 1/k0 . (Our previous argument, which gave ECl = const · kB T , is no longer valid.) It is important to recognize that in our earlier arguments one assumed that a cutoff existed but that the details of the cutoff were irrelevant. In the present context the nature of the cutoff plays a more significant role.] For k0 R 1, the first term in Eq. (10) dominates, and N < 0. The estimate of N is crude—higher order terms were neglected, and the cutoff was rough—but we might well expect the result N < 0 to be valid, and therefore ECl = kB T N for the sphere to be negative. For applications to an electromagnetic field within a non-ideal shell, k0 is defined by k0 h¯ c ≈ 10 eV, or k0 ≈ (1/20) nm−1 . The form of n(k) differs somewhat from that of Eq. (9); in particular, there is no surface term. In line with a remark in Section 2, we mention that Schaden and Spruch, unpublished, have shown that the sign of a number of Casimir energies follows from a knowledge of the form of the semi-classical approximation to the energy Green’s function G(E), as given by Gutzwiller (1990), for the problem at hand. (The phase of G(E) plays a central role.) The energy itself needs not be calculated. = − 14 (k0 R)2 +
4]
CLASSICAL CASIMIR EFFECTS
81
(A side remark. It would be nice if, as a variation of an ancient Roman tradition, physicists granted posthumous awards—in state lie—to those who were not, but might well have been, Nobelized. My suggestions would include Casimir, on whose work this and some thousand other papers have been based, and R.E. Peierls and V.F. Weisskopf.) I thank M. Schaden for a very helpful discussion.
4. An Unauthorized Thank You Professor Bederson asked that one refrains from personal comments, but it would be remiss on my part were I not to mention the enormous influence Ben has had on my career. I had been trained as a nuclear theorist but on coming to New York University, my interests gradually switched to atomic theory. My work (with L. Rosenberg, T.F. O’Malley, and others) on atomic scattering theory (and, in particular on bounds on scattering lengths) and on the effect of induced electric dipole moments on the energy- and angular-dependence of low-energy electron– atom scattering was stimulated by Ben’s work on electron–hydrogen scattering and on the polarizabilities of atoms. His constant encouragement has been much appreciated.
5. References Boyer, T.H. (1974). Van der Waals forces and zero-point energy for dielectric and permeable materials. Phys. Rev. A 9, 2078–2084. Brown, L.S., Maclay, G.J. (1969). Vacuum stress between conducting plates: An image solution. Phys. Rev. 184, 1272–1279. Casimir, H.B.G. (1948). On the attraction between two perfectly conducting plates. Jon. Ned. Akad. Wetensch. Proc. 51, 793–795. Feinberg, J., Mann, A., Revzen, M. (2001). Casimir effect: The classical limit. Ann. Phys. 288, 103– 136. Gutzwiller, M.C. (1990). “Chaos in Classical and Quantum Mechanics”. Springer, Berlin. The results in Ref. 3 are based on Gutzwiller’s semiclassical approximation to the energy Green’s function. Jackson, J.D. (1975). “Classical Electrodynamics”, 2nd Edn. Wiley, New York. McKean, H.P., Singer, I.M. (1967). Curvature and the eigenvalues of the Laplacian. J. Differential Geom. 1, 43–69. Milonni, P.W. (1994). “The Quantum Vacuum”. Academic, New York. Schaden, M., Spruch, L. (1998). Infinity-free semi-classical evaluation of Casimir effects. Phys. Rev. A 58, 935–953. Schaden, M., Spruch, L. (2002). A classical Casimir effect: The interaction of ideal parallel walls at a finite temperature. Phys. Rev. A 65, 034101(4).
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
POLARIZABILITIES OF 3P ATOMS AND VAN DER WAALS COEFFICIENTS FOR THEIR INTERACTION WITH HELIUM ATOMS X. CHU and A. DALGARNO∗ ITAMP, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Theory: Dynamic Polarizabilities . . Numerical Method . . . . . . . . . . Results: Static Dipole Polarizabilities Van der Waals Coefficients . . . . . Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
84 84 86 88 89 90 90
Abstract Time-dependent density functional theory with self-interaction correction is applied to obtain the scalar and tensor dynamic polarizabilities of atoms in 3 P states. The static polarizabilities are in good agreement with previous values. The dynamic polarizabilities are then used to evaluate the leading term in the long range interaction between the 3 P atoms and helium. They are significant in determining the likelihood that the 3 P atoms can be trapped in a helium buffer gas.
∗ I (AD) met Ben in New York in 1959 at the first International Conference on the Physics of Electronic and Atomic Collisions. Ben was the inspiration for the conference and the series that followed. The 24th will be held this year in Argentina. Amongst his many national and international activities, Ben was introducing clever ways of measuring atomic polarizabilities. His experiments were a great stimulus to my efforts to devise methods for their calculation. I see from my paper with Xi Chu that I am still working on the same problem. It is all Ben’s fault.
83
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51014-0
84
X. Chu and A. Dalgarno
[2
1. Introduction The effectiveness of the buffer gas loading technique introduced by Doyle and his collaborators [1–4] in creating an ultra-cold gas of atoms depends on the relative efficiency of elastic and inelastic collisions of the atoms with 3 He atoms at temperatures below 0.4 K. Inelastic collisions lead to trap loss. For atoms in states of non-zero orbital angular momentum inelastic collisions may be probable, as is the case for collisions of O(3 P) oxygen atoms [5], and the resulting gain in energy would then limit the range of atoms that can be cooled and trapped. The inelastic cross sections are controlled by the energy separations of the interaction potentials of the different symmetries of the molecular system formed by the approach of the helium atom and the gas atom [6]. It has been shown by explicit calculations of the interaction potentials that the electronic anisotropy between Ti(3 F) and He atoms and Sc(2 D) atoms and He atoms is suppressed by the shielding of the valence electrons and the resulting inelastic to elastic cross section ratio is small [7], a prediction confirmed by measurements [4]. Thus a wide range of complex atoms in non-zero angular momentum states may be trappable. Scattering at low temperatures is sensitive to the interactions at large internuclear distances R and the range of candidate atoms can be explored through calculations of the long range anisotropy. At large R the interaction potentials vary as C6 R −6 . We have developed a version of time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) for the calculation of the long range interactions and we have applied it to the calculation of the scalar value of the coefficient C6 for many complex atoms [8]. For atoms in P states the molecular states have or symmetry and the scalar values of C6 are averages over the two symmetries. We extend the theory to obtain the values of C6 of the individual symmetries. The method makes use of the expression of C6 as an integral over the products of dynamic polarizabilities over imaginary frequencies. The accuracy of the results can be assessed by comparing the static polarizabilities with measurements, many of which have been carried out by Bederson and his associates [9–14]. We present results for C, O, Si, S, Ge, and Se interacting with helium.
2. Theory: Dynamic Polarizabilities If the electric field is taken parallel to the z-axis, the dynamic electric dipole poz (iω) at imaginary frequencies iω of a P state atom with angular larizabilities αM momentum quantum number L = 1, magnetic quantum number M, eigenstate
2]
3P
ATOMS INTERACTION WITH HELIUM ATOMS
85
|P M, and eigenvalue Ep may be written z (iω) = 2 αM
(Et − Ep )|tM|Dz |PM|2 , (Et − Ep )2 + ω2 t
(1)
where Dz is the component along the z-axis of the electric dipole moment, Et is the eigenvalue of state with eigenfunction |tM. In Eq. (1) all quantities are expressed in atomic units. If the field is perpendicular to the z-axis, the polarizx (iω) or α y (iω) [α x (iω) = α y (iω)] is given by Eq. (1) with D or D ability αM x y M M M z in place of Dz and with tM ± 1| in place of tM|. For P state atoms, α±1 (iω) = α0x (iω). The scalar polarizability is given by α0 (ω) = {α0z (ω) + 2α1z (ω)}/3 and the tensor polarizability by α2 (ω) = {α0x (ω) − α0z (ω)}/3. We evaluate the dynamic polarizabilities by applying time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) [8] to an atom perturbed by a frequency-dependent external field vext (r, ω) and extracting the linear response function χσ,M (r, r , ω), where r and r are electron position vectors, σ is the spin label, and ω is the frequency. The response function may be expressed in the form χσ,M (r, r , ω) = χkσ,M (r, r , ω) k
=
∗ (r)φ (r)φ (r )φ ∗ (r ) φkσ jσ kσ jσ
ω + (j σ − kσ )
k,j
−
∗ (r ) φj∗σ (r)φkσ (r)φj σ (r )φkσ
ω − (j σ − kσ )
,
(2)
where φkσ and φj σ are orbital wave functions of the occupied and unoccupied orbitals respectively, and kσ and j σ are the corresponding orbital energies. The spin-orbitals are solutions of the equation 2 2 h¯ ∇ − (3) + Vσ (r) φiσ (r) = iσ φiσ (r). 2me The potential Vσ (r) is the optimized effective potential with an explicit selfinteraction correction. It has the form [8] ρ(r ) + Vxc ρα (r), ρβ (r) + VσS (r), Vσ (r) = VN (r) + dr (4) |r − r | where VN (r) is the electron–nuclear interaction, Vxc is the exchange-correlation potential, VσS (r) is the self-interaction correction, and ρσ (r) is the electronic spindensity ρσ (r) =
Nσ i=1
ρiσ (r) =
Nσ
φiσ (r) 2 , i=1
(5)
86
X. Chu and A. Dalgarno
[3
where Nσ is the number of orbitals whose spin quantum number is σ and ρ(r) = ρα (r) + ρβ (r). The dynamic polarizabilities are given by z z χσ,M r, r , iω δvσ,M αM (iω) = (6) r , iω z dr dr , σ z δvσ,M (r , iω)
is the frequency-dependent scalar potential that reflects the where shielding of the applied field by the electron–electron interaction [8]. The polarz is obtained by setting vext (r, iω) ≡ z and solving self-consistent izability αM equations z z δvσ,M r , ω dr (r, ω) = z + Kαα,M r, r , ω δvα,M z r , ω dr , + Kαβ,M r, r , ω δvβ,M (7) in which Kαα,M
∂Vxc
χα,M (r , r , ω) r, r , ω = χα,M r, r , ω dr +
|r − r | ∂ρα (r) ρα (r) n σ ρiσ (r) χiσ,M (r , r , ω) + − dr ρσ (r) |r − r | i=1
∂Vxc,iσ
− χiσ,M r, r , ω , (8) ∂ρiσ (r) ρσ (r)
χβ,M (r , r , ω) dr . |r − r |
Kαβ,M r, r , ω =
(9)
y
x or α may be obtained by replacing z by x or y and δv z The polarizability αM M σ,M y x by δvσ,M or δvσ,M .
3. Numerical Method To evaluate αM (iω), we use cylindrical coordinates (r, ϕ, z) defined in terms of Cartesian coordinates (x, y, z) by x = r cos ϕ,
y = r sin θ,
z = z.
(10)
The atomic orbitals take the form eimj σ ϕ φj σ (r) = √ φj σ (r, z), 2π
mj σ = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . ,
(11)
3P
3]
ATOMS INTERACTION WITH HELIUM ATOMS
σ where σ N j =1 mj σ = M. Equation (3) becomes 1 ∂ m2 ∂2 1 ∂2 + − (r, z) φj σ (r, z) + + V − σ 2 ∂r 2 r ∂r ∂z2 r2 = j σ φj σ (r, z), where
87
(12)
ρ(r, z) + VSIC,σ (r, z), (13) |r − r | 1 Nσ 2 in which Z is the nuclear charge and ρ(r, z) = 2π σ i=1 |φiσ (r, z)| , and VSIC,σ (r, z) is the self-interaction correction term. Because the atomic system is rotationally invariant, the linear response function can be re-written in the following form, m χσ,M r, r , iω = (14) r, z, r , z , iω , eimϕ e−imϕ χσ,M Z + Vσ (r, z) = − √ 2 r + z2
d 3r
m=0,±1
where φkσ (r, z)φj σ (r, z)φkσ (r , z )φj σ (r , z ) m r, z, r , z , iω = χσ,M iω + (j σ − kσ ) k,j
−
φj σ (r, z)φkσ (r, z)φj σ (r , z )φkσ (r , z ) iω − (j σ − kσ )
with the restriction that mj σ ≡ mkσ + m. Accordingly, Kσ1 σ2 ,M r, r , ω = eimϕ e−imϕ Kσm1 σ2 ,M r, z, r , z , ω .
(15)
(16)
m=0,±1
We numerically integrate z (iω) = αM
∞ ∞ ∞ ∞
0 r, z, r , z , iω χσ,M
σ
0 −∞ 0 −∞ z × δvσ,M r , z , iω z dr
x αM (iω)
1 = 2 σ
∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ 0 −∞ 0 −∞
dz dr dz ,
1 r, z, r , z , iω χσ,M
x r , z , iω r dr dz dr dz × δvσ,M
(17)
88
X. Chu and A. Dalgarno 1 + 2 σ x × δvσ,M
∞ ∞ ∞ ∞
[4
−1 r, z, r , z , iω χσ,M
0 −∞ 0 −∞
r , z , iω r dr dz dr dz ,
(18)
where ∞ ∞ z (r, z, ω) δvα,M
=z+
z 0 r, z, r , z , ω δvα,M r z , ω dr dz Kαα,M
0 −∞
∞ ∞
z 0 r, z, r , z , ω δvβ,M r , z , ω dr dz , Kαβ,M
+ 0 −∞
(19)
and ∞ ∞ x (r, z, ω) δvσ,M
=r+
−1 1 Kαα,M r, z, r , z , ω + Kαα,M r, z, r , z , ω
0 −∞
x r , z , ω dr dz × δvα,M ∞ ∞ +
−1 1 Kαβ,M r, z, r , z , ω + Kαβ,M r, z, r , z , ω
0 −∞ x r , z , ω dr dz . × δvβ,M
(20)
A two-dimensional generalized pseudo-spectral method [15,16] is used for the numerical calculations. A non-uniform spatial grid distribution is generated with a denser mesh near the origin. Many fewer grid points are needed compared to equal spatial distribution methods. The kinetic energy matrix elements take simple analytical forms and the potential energy matrix is diagonal in the coordinate representation. The convergence with respect to the number of grid points is exponential and high accuracy and efficiency are achieved. The calculated polarizabilities at imaginary frequency iω behave correctly at large frequencies, varying asymptotically as N/ω2 where N is the total number of electrons of the system.
4. Results: Static Dipole Polarizabilities In Table I we present the calculated static isotropic polarizabilities α0 (ω = 0) of 3 P atoms from carbon to selenium in units of a03 . The table includes the range of values that have been derived earlier by a diversity of theoretical methods.
3P
5]
ATOMS INTERACTION WITH HELIUM ATOMS
89
Table I Isotropic static dipole polarizabilities α0 (ω = 0) in units of a03 . Atom Range This paper
C
O
Si
S
Ge
Se
(11.0, 11.8) 11.3
(4.73, 5.61) 5.29
(36.2, 36.8) 37.9
(19.1, 19.6) 19.3
(41.6, 41.7) 41.1
(25.3, 26.1) 25.5
Table II Tensor static dipole polarizabilities α2 (ω = 0) in units of a03 . Atom
C
O
Si
S
Ge
Se
Range (0.66, 0.97) (−0.15, −0.37) (2.97, 3.00) (−1.07, −1.50) (3.66, 4.65) (−1.47, −2.01) This paper 0.72 −0.36 2.93 −1.21 4.65 −1.92
They are taken from lists assembled by Andersson and Sadlej [17], Stiehler and Hinze [18], Rerat et al. [19], Medved et al. [20], Lupinetti and Thakkar [21], and Chu and Dalgarno [8]. The values obtained here lie within the range of previous calculations and are probably as reliable as any. The calculated values of the tensor polarizability are compared in Table II with the results of [17–21]. The agreement is satisfactory. The tensor polarizability is negative for atoms with more than half-filled shells and positive for atoms with less than half-filled shells.
5. Van der Waals Coefficients At large values of R, the interaction potential of the 3 and 3 molecular states formed by the approach of the 3 P atom and the helium atom vary as C6M /R 6 , where M = 0 corresponds to the state and M = ±1 to the state. The van der Waals coefficients may be expressed as integrals over the product of the frequency-dependent polarizabilities of the 3 P atom and the frequency-dependent polarizabilities αHe in the form 2 1 z x (iω)αHe (iω) dω + (iω)αHe (iω) dω. αM αM C6M = (21) π π Precise values of αHe have been calculated by Jamieson et al. [22]. The values of C6M for the and states are presented in Table III. The fractional anisotropy γ =3
C60 − C6±1
C60 + 2C6±1
(22)
is also listed in Table III. It ranges between −0.049 for carbon to 0.061 for germanium.
90
X. Chu and A. Dalgarno
[7
Table III C6M for the X 3 and A 3 states of 3 P atoms interacting with helium in atomic units. Atom
γ
C
O
Si
S
Ge
Se
7.15 7.51 −0.049
4.85 4.67 0.038
16.5 17.31 −0.048
13.1 12.7 0.031
17.4 18.5 −0.061
16.7 15.8 0.056
The inelastic rate coefficients depend on the anisotropy also at intermediate and small separations and cannot be predicted without explicit solution of the scattering equations. Calculations have been carried out for oxygen which may provide an indication of the order of magnitude to be expected. For O(3 P) colliding with 3 He at 1 K in a magnetic field of 1 T the inelastic rate coefficient is 5 × 10−11 cm3 s−1 [5].
6. Acknowledgement This work is supported by the Chemical Sciences, Geosciences and Biosciences Division of the Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Office of Science, U.S. Department of Energy.
7. References [1] Doyle J.M., Friedrich B., Kim J., Patterson D., Nature 431 (2004) 281. [2] Weinstein J.D., deCarvalho R., Guillet T., Friedrich B., Doyle J.M., Nature 395 (1998) 148. [3] Weinstein J.D., deCarvalho R., Amar K., Boca A., Odom B.C., Friedrich B., Doyle J.M., J. Chem. Phys. 109 (2004) 2656. [4] Hancox C.I., Doret S.C., Hummon M.T., Luo L., Doyle J.M., Nature 431 (2004) 281. [5] Krems R.V., Dalgarno A., Phys. Rev. A 68 (2003) 013406. [6] Krems R., Groenenboom G.C., Dalgarno A., J. Phys. Chem. A 108 (2004) 8941. [7] Krems R., Klos J., Rode M.F., Szcze´niak M.M., Chalasi´nski G., Dalgarno A., Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 013202. [8] Chu X., Dalgarno A., J. Chem. Phys. 121 (2004) 4083. [9] Bederson B., Robinson E.J., Adv. Chem. Phys. 10 (1966) 1. [10] Schwartz H.L., Miller T.M., Bederson B., Phys. Rev. A 10 (1974) 1924. [11] Molof R.W., Schwartz H.L., Miller T.M., Bederson B., Phys. Rev. A 10 (1974) 1131. [12] Miller T.M., Bederson B., Stockdale J.A.D., Jaduzliwer B., Phys. Rev. A 14 (1976) 1572. [13] Miller T.M., Bederson B., Adv. At. Mol. Phys. 13 (1977) 1. [14] Guella T.P., Miller T.M., Bederson B., Stockdale J.A.D., Jaduzliwer B., Phys. Rev. A 29 (1984) 2977. [15] Chu X., Chu S.I., Phys. Rev. A 63 (2001) 013414. [16] Chu X., Chu S.I., Phys. Rev. A 63 (2001) 023411. [17] Andersson Q., Sadlej Q., Phys. Rev. A 46 (1992) 2356.
7] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
3P
ATOMS INTERACTION WITH HELIUM ATOMS
Stiehler J., Hinze J., J. Phys. B 28 (1995) 4055. Rerat M., Bussery B., Freçón M., J. Mol. Spectrosc. 182 (1997) 260. Medved M., Fowler P.W., Hutson J.M., Mol. Phys. 98 (2000) 453. Lupinetti C., Thakkar A.J., J. Chem. Phys. 122 (2005). Jamieson M.J., Drake G.W.F., Dalgarno A., Phys. Rev. A 51 (1995) 3358.
91
This page intentionally left blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 51
THE TWO ELECTRON MOLECULAR BOND REVISITED: FROM BOHR ORBITS TO TWO-CENTER ORBITALS∗ GOONG CHEN1 , SIU A. CHIN2 , YUSHENG DOU2,† , KISHORE T. KAPALE2,3,4 , MOOCHAN KIM2,4 , ANATOLY A. SVIDZINSKY2,4 , KERIM URTEKIN2 , HAN XIONG2 and MARLAN O. SCULLY2,4,5,6 1 Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Mathematics, Texas A&M University, College Station,
TX 77843, USA 2 Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Physics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA 3 Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA 4 Depts. of Chemistry, and Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton,
NJ 08544, USA 5 Institute for Quantum Studies and Dept. of Chemical and Electrical Engineering, Texas A&M
University, College Station, TX 77843, USA 6 Max-Planck-Institut für Quantenoptik, D-85748 Garching, Germany
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. The Bohr Molecule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. Simple Correlation Energy from the Bohr Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. Correlated Two-Center Orbitals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Context . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6. Outline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Recent Progress Based on Bohr’s Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Interpolated Bohr Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. General Results and Fundamental Properties of Wave Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. The Born–Oppenheimer Separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Variational Properties: The Virial Theorem and the Feynman–Hellman Theorem . 3.3. Fundamental Properties of One and Two-Electron Wave Functions . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
95 95 96 100 101 103 106 107 108 111 111 114 117
∗ MOS wishes to express his appreciation and admiration for Prof. Benjamin Bederson for his insights into and nurturing of AMO physics. Most recently, Ben’s work focused on the experimental determination of atomic polarizabilities. The classic determination was in bulk material. However, Ben developed a beautiful atomic beam method which he brought to marvelous perfection. It is a pleasure to dedicate this article to him. † Now at Dept. of Physical Sciences, Nicholls State University, Thibodaux, LA 70310, USA.
93
© 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved ISSN 1049-250X DOI 10.1016/S1049-250X(05)51015-2
94
G. Chen et al.
4. Analytical Wave Mechanical Solutions for One Electron Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. The Hydrogen Atom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. H+ 2 -like Molecular Ion in Prolate Spheroidal Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. The Many-Centered, One-Electron Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Two Electron Molecules: Cusp Conditions and Correlation Functions . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. The Cusp Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Various Forms of the Correlation Function f (r12 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Modelling of Diatomic Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. The Heitler–London Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2. The Hund–Mulliken Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3. The Hartree–Fock Self-Consistent Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4. The James–Coolidge Wave Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5. Two-Centered Orbitals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Alternative Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1. Improvement of Hartree–Fock Results Using the Bohr Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2. Dimensional Scaling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Conclusions and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. Appendices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Separation of Variables for the H+ 2 -like Schrödinger Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) for Large λ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) as λ → 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Expansions of Solution Near λ ≈ 1 and λ 1: Trial Wave Functions of James and Coolidge E. The Many-Centered, One Electron Problem in Momentum Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Derivation of the Cusp Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 ∇2 − 1 ∇2 . . . . . . . . . . G. Center of Mass Coordinates for the Kinetic Energy − 2m 2m2 2 1 1 H. Verifications of the Cusp Conditions for Two-Centered Orbitals in Prolate Spheroidal Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Integrals with the Heitler–London Wave Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Derivations Related to the Laplacian for Section 6.4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K. Recursion Relations and Their Derivations for Section 6.4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.1. A(m; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.2. F (m; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.3. S(m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.4. T (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.5. H0 (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.6. H1 (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.7. Hτ (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (1) K.8. Hτ (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (2) K.9. Hτ (m, n; α) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . L. Derivations for the 5-Term Recurrence Relations (6.81) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Dimensional Scaling in Spherical Coordinates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
135 137 138 143 145 145 147 155 155 158 162 166 174 184 184 185 191 191 192 192 193 194 196 198 203 208 210 216 217 222 222 222 223 225 225 226 227 229 230 231 232 236
Abstract Niels Bohr originally applied his approach to quantum mechanics to the H atom with great success. He then went on to show in 1913 how the same “planetaryorbit” model can predict binding for the H2 molecule. However, he misidentified the correct dissociation energy of his model at large internuclear separation, forcing him
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
95
to give up on a “Bohr’s model for molecules”. Recently, we have found the correct dissociation limit of Bohr’s model for H2 and obtained good potential energy curves at all internuclear separations. This work is a natural extension of Bohr’s original paper and corresponds to the D = ∞ limit of a dimensional scaling (D-scaling) analysis, as developed by Herschbach and coworkers. In a separate but synergetic approach to the two-electron problem, we summarize recent advances in constructing analytical models for describing the two-electron bond. The emphasis here is not maximally attainable numerical accuracy, but beyond textbook accuracy as informed by physical insights. We demonstrate how the interplay of the cusp condition, the asymptotic condition, the electron-correlation, configuration interaction, and the exact one electron two-center orbitals, can produce energy results approaching chemical accuracy. To this end, we provide a tutorial on using the Riccati form of the ground state wave function as a unified way of understanding the two-electron wave function and collect a detailed account of mathematical derivations on the exact one-electron two-center wave functions. Reviews of more traditional calculational approaches, such as Hartree–Fock, are also given. The inclusion of electron correlation via Hylleraas type functions is well known to be important, but difficult to implement for more than two electrons. The use of the D-scaled Bohr model offers the tantalizing possibility of obtaining electron correlation energy in a non-traditional way.
1. Introduction 1.1. OVERVIEW We are in the midst of a revolution at the interface between chemistry and physics, largely due to the interplay between quantum optics and quantum chemistry. For example, the explicit control of molecules afforded by modern femtosecond lasers and adaptive computer feedback [1] has opened new frontiers in molecular science. In such studies, molecules are controlled by sculpting the amplitude and phase of femtosecond pulses, forcing the molecule into predetermined electronic and rotational–vibrational states. This holds great promise for vital applications, from the trace detection of molecular impurities, such as dipicolinic acid as it appears in anthrax [2], to the utilization of molecular excited states for quantum information storage and retrieval [3]. We are thus motivated to rethink certain aspects of molecular physics and quantum chemistry especially with regard to the excited state dynamics and coherent processes of molecules. The usual discussions of molecular structure are based on solving the many-particle Schrödinger equation with varying degree of sophistication, from exacting Diffusion Monte Carlo methods, coupled cluster expansion,
96
G. Chen et al. Table I The binding energy of H2 molecule based on “exact” two-center H+ 2 orbitals.
Orbital Jaffé (6.55) Hylleraas (6.58)
Binding energy (eV) No free parameter
1 free (screening) parameter
4.50 4.51
4.60 4.62
When we allow the α and B parameters of Eqs. (6.55) and (6.58) to vary, we obtain a binding energy of 4.7 eV. The binding energy is comparable to the experimental value of 4.7 eV.
configuration interactions, to density functional theory. All are intensely numerical. Despite these successful tools of modern computational chemistry, there remains the need for understanding electron correlations in some relatively simple way so that we may describe excited states dynamics with reasonable accuracy. In this work, we propose to reexamine these questions in two complementary ways. One approach is based on the recently resurrected Bohr’s model for molecules [4]. In particular, we show that by modifying the original Bohr’s model [5] in a simple way, specially when augmented by dimensional scaling (D-scaling), we can describe both the singlet and triplet potential of H2 with remarkable accuracy (see Figs. 2, 5). In another approach, following the lead of the French school of Le Sech [6,7], we use correlated two-center orbitals of the H+ 2 molecule to model H2 ’s ground and excited state. This approach worked well, even when only a simple electron correlation function is used, see Table I. The Bohr model and D-scaling technique taken together with good (uncorrelated) molecular orbitals is especially interesting and promising. As discussed in Section 1.3, the Bohr model yields a good approximation to the electron–electron Coulomb energy, which can be used to choose a renormalized nuclear charge and a much improved (correlated) two electron wave function.
1.2. T HE B OHR M OLECULE Figure 1 displays the Bohr model for a hydrogen molecule [5,4], in which two nuclei with charges Z|e| are separated by a fixed distance R (adiabatic approximation) and the two electrons move in the space between them. The model assumes that the electrons move with constant speed on circular trajectories of radii ρ1 = ρ2 = ρ. The circle centers lie on the molecule axis z at the coordinates z1 = ±z2 = z. The separation between the electrons is constant. The net force on each electron consists of three contributions: attractive interaction between an electron and the two nuclei, the Coulomb repulsion between electrons, and the centrifugal force on the electron. We proceed by writing the energy function E = T + V , where the kinetic energy T = p12 /2m + p22 /2m for electrons 1 and 2
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
97
F IG . 1. Cylindrical coordinates (top) and electronic distances (bottom) in H2 molecule. The nuclei Z are fixed at a distance R apart. In the Bohr model, the two electrons rotate about the internuclear axis z with coordinates ρ1 , z1 and ρ2 , z2 , respectively; the dihedral angle φ between the (ρ1 , z1 ) and (ρ2 , z2 ) planes remains constant at either φ = π or φ = 0. The sketch corresponds to configuration 2 of Fig. 2, with φ = π .
can be obtained from the quantization condition that the circumference is equal to the integer number n of the electron de Broglie wavelengths 2πρ = nh/p, so that we have T = p 2 /2m = n2 h¯ 2 /2mρ 2 ; the unit of distance is taken to be the Bohr radius a0 = h¯ 2 /me2 , and the unit of energy the atomic energy, e2 /a0 , where m and e are, respectively, the mass and charge of the electron. The Coulomb potential Energy V is given by V =−
Z Z Z 1 Z2 Z − − − + + , ra1 rb1 ra2 rb2 r12 R
(1.1)
where rai (i = 1, 2) and rbi are the distances of the ith electron from nuclei A and B, as shown in Fig. 1 (bottom), r12 is the separation between electrons. In cylindrical coordinates the distances are 2 R R 2 , rbi = ρi2 + zi + , rai = ρi2 + zi − 2 2 r12 = (z1 − z2 )2 + ρ12 + ρ22 − 2ρ1 ρ2 cos φ, here R is the internuclear spacing and φ is the dihedral angle between the planes containing the electrons and the internuclear axis. The Bohr model energy for a
98
G. Chen et al.
homonuclear molecule having charge Z is then given by n22 1 n21 E= + + V (ρ1 , ρ2 , z1 , z2 , φ). 2 ρ12 ρ22
(1.2)
Possible electron configurations correspond to extrema of the energy function (1.2). For n1 = n2 = 1 the energy has extrema at ρ1 = ρ2 = ρ, z1 = ±z2 = z and φ = π, 0. These four configurations are pictured in Fig. 2 (upper panel). For example, for configuration 2, with z1 = −z2 = z, φ = π, the extremum equations ∂E/∂z = 0 and ∂E/∂ρ = 0 read Z(R/2 − z) z Z(R/2 + z) + − 2 = 0, [ρ 2 + (R/2 − z)2 ]3/2 4[ρ 2 + z2 ]3/2 [ρ + (R/2 + z)2 ]3/2 (1.3) Zρ Zρ ρ 1 + 2 − = 3, [ρ 2 + (R/2 − z)2 ]3/2 [ρ + (R/2 + z)2 ]3/2 4[ρ 2 + z2 ]3/2 ρ (1.4) which are seen to be equivalent to Newton’s second law applied to the motion of each electron. Eq. (1.3) specifies that the total Coulomb force on the electron along the z-axis is equal to zero; Eq. (1.4) specifies that the projection of the Coulomb force toward the molecular axis equals the centrifugal force. At any fixed internuclear distance R, these equations determine the constant values of ρ and z that describe the electron trajectories. Similar force equations pertain for the other extremum configurations. In Fig. 2 (lower panel) we plot E(R) for the four Bohr model configurations (solid curves), together with “exact” results (dots) obtained from extensive variational calculations for the singlet ground state 1 g+ , and the lowest triplet state, 3 + [8]. In the model, the three configurations 1, 2, 3 with the electrons on opu posite sides of the internuclear axis (φ = π) are seen to correspond to the 1 g+ singlet ground states, whereas the other solution 4 with the electrons on the same side (φ = 0) corresponds to the first excited, 3 u+ triplet state. At small internuclear distances, the symmetric configuration 1 originally considered by Bohr agrees well with the “exact” ground state quantum energy; at larger R, however, this configuration’s energy rises far above that of the ground state and ultimately dissociates to the doubly ionized limit, 2H+ + 2e. In contrast, the solution for the asymmetric configuration 2 appears only for R > 1.20 and in the large R limit dissociates to two H atoms. The solution for asymmetric configuration 3 exists only for R > 1.68 and climbs steeply to dissociate to an ion pair, H+ + H− . The asymmetric solution 4 exists for all R and corresponds throughout to repulsive interaction of two H atoms. We then extend these “Bohr molecule” studies in several ways. In particular, we use a variant of the dimensional scaling (D-scaling) theory as it was originally developed in quantum chromodynamics and applied with great success to molecular and statistical physics [9,10]. This is based on an analysis in which the usual
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
99
F IG . 2. Energy E(R) of H2 molecule for four electron configurations (top) as a function of internuclear distance R calculated within the Bohr model (solid lines) and the “exact” ground 1 g+ and first excited 3 u+ state energy of [8] (dots). Unit of energy is 1 a.u. = 27.21 eV, and unit of distance is the Bohr radius.
kinetic energy terms in the Schrödinger equation are written in D dimensions, i.e., −
h¯ 2 ∂ 2 h¯ 2 ∂ 2 →− . 2 2m 2m ∂xi ∂xi2 3
D
i=1
i=1
(1.5)
This provides another avenue into the interface between the old (Bohr–Sommerfeld) and the new (Heisenberg–Schrödinger) quantum mechanics. In particular, when D → ∞ the two electron Schrödinger equation can be scaled and sculpted into a form which is when D → ∞ identical to the Bohr theory of the H2 molecule, and much better than when 1/D or other corrections are included.
100
G. Chen et al.
1.3. S IMPLE C ORRELATION E NERGY FROM THE B OHR M ODEL The Bohr model offers an effective way to treat most of the correlation energy absent in the conventional Hartree–Fock (HF) approximation. Here we show how a charge renormalization method can be applied to improve the ground state energy obtained in the HF approximation. We start from He-like ions and consider a nucleus with charge Z and two electrons moving around it. According to the Bohr model the ground state energy is given by the minimum of the following expression 1 Z 1 Z 1 1 , + − + − E= (1.6) 2 2 2 ρ1 ρ1 ρ2 ρ2 ρ12 + ρ22 − 2ρ1 ρ2 cos φ where φ is the dihedral angle between electrons. At the minimum φ = π and Eq. (1.6) reduces to 1 1 1 Z 1 Z E= (1.7) + − + . − 2 2 2 ρ1 ρ1 ρ2 ρ1 + ρ2 ρ2 Optimization with respect to ρ1 and ρ2 yields 1 1 2 ρ1 = ρ 2 = . , EB = − Z − Z − 1/4 4
(1.8)
The HF approximation in the framework of the Bohr model means that optimum parameters ρ1 and ρ2 are determined by minimization of Eq. (1.7) with no electron repulsion term, i.e., omitting the electron–electron correlation. In the HF approximation the Bohr model gives 1 Z , EB-HF = −Z 2 + . (1.9) Z 2 For the He atom (Z = 2) we obtain EB-HF = −3 a.u., while EB = −3.0625 a.u. Thus, the inclusion of correlation shifts the ground state energy down by ρ 1 = ρ2 =
1 = −0.0625 a.u. (1.10) 16 The Bohr model itself is quasiclassical and, as a consequence, it predicts the He ground state energy with only 5.4% accuracy (Eexact = −2.9037 a.u.). However, the Bohr model provides a quantitative way to include the correlation energy. Let us consider the He ground state energy calculated using the HF (effective charge) variational wave function 1 + r2 ) , (r1 , r2 ) = C exp −Z(r (1.11) B =− Ecorr
is a variational parameter (effective charge), which is determined by where Z + 5Z/8, = Z − 5/16. The wave 2 − 2Z Z Z minimizing the energy E = Z
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS mechanical HF energy is 5 2 W EHF = − Z − . 16
101
(1.12)
W = −2.8476 a.u. The difference between E W and the For Z = 2 we obtain EHF HF exact value is due to the correlation energy missing in the HF treatment. One can W we obtain notice that if we add the correlation energy (1.10) to EHF W B EHF + Ecorr = −2.9101 a.u.,
which substantially improves the answer and deviates by only 0.2% from the exact value. Such an idea can be incorporated by renormalization of the nuclear charge [11]. Let us define an effective charge Zeff by the condition W EB-HF (Zeff ) = EHF (Z),
which yields Zeff
1 = + 4
1 5 2 . + Z− 16 16
(1.13)
(1.14)
The effective charge improves the Bohr model energy by taking into account the difference between the quasiclassical and fully quantum mechanical description. The effective charge is calculated from the correspondence between the Bohr model in the HF approximation and the quantum mechanical HF answer. Now, if we take the Bohr model energy EB (Z) (1.8) (that includes correlation) but with Zeff instead of Z it improves the quantum mechanical HF answer: 5 2 1 1 W EB (Zeff ) = − Z − (1.15) − (Z) − . = EHF 16 16 16 The correction energy −1/16 is independent of Z and coincides with Eq. (1.10). Table II compares the quantum mechanical HF answer for the ground state energy of He-like ions and the improved value (1.15). Depending on Z Eq. (1.15) improves the accuracy 10–20 times.
1.4. C ORRELATED T WO -C ENTER O RBITALS From the preceding discussion it is clear that we need good (hopefully simple) HF wave functions. There is, of course, a great deal of work on this problem but we find the two-center orbital approach of Le Sech and coworkers [6,7,12–14] and of Patil [15] to be especially useful. In a previous publication [16], we attempted a
102
G. Chen et al.
Table II W and the value improved by the Ground state energy of the He-like ions in the HF approximation EHF Bohr model EB . The last two columns compare the accuracy of the HF and the improved result. Z
W (Z) EHF
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
−2.8476 −7.2226 −13.597 −21.9726 −32.3476 −44.7226 −59.0976 −75.4726 −93.8476
Z − Zeff
EB (Zeff )
Eexact
EHF (%)
EB (Zeff ) (%)
0.0441 0.0508 0.0540 0.0558 0.0570 0.0578 0.0584 0.0589 0.0592
−2.9101 −7.2851 −13.6602 −22.0351 −32.4102 −44.7852 −59.1602 −75.5352 −93.9102
−2.9037 −7.2799 −13.6555 −22.0309 −32.4062 −44.7814 −59.1566 −75.5317 −93.9068
1.93 0.79 0.42 0.26 0.18 0.13 0.10 0.08 0.06
0.22 0.072 0.033 0.019 0.012 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.003
first principle (semi-tutorial) presentation employing that the exact two-center orbitals obtained from solving the Schrödinger equation for the H+ 2 ion. As shown by Le Sech these are the most useful building blocks for constructing the electronic wave functions of the homonuclear H2 molecule. One simple form of the electronic ground state constructed with two-center orbitals is 1 H2 (1, 2) = H+ ,1σ (1)H+ ,1σ (2)χ00 1 + r12 , (1.16) 2 2 2 where H+ ,1σ is the solution of the Schrödinger equation for the H+ in prolate√2 2 spheroidal (ellipsoidal) coordinates, χ00 = [|↑1 ↓2 − |↓1 ↑2 ]/ 2 is singlet spin function, and (1 + 12 r12 ) is the Hylleraas correlation factor. See more detailed discussions of (1.16) in Sections 4–6 below. This wave function yields a binding energy of 4.5 eV for H2 molecule without any variational parameters. Variation with respect to a couple of parameters in the function (1.16) shifts the binding energy to 4.7 eV, giving remarkable agreement with the experimental value. To achieve the same result, sums over many one-centered atomic orbitals or Hylleraas type of wave function (cf. (4.30) below) that explicitly include the interelectronic distance are usually used. This has been demonstrated by the earlier work of Kolos and Wolniewicz [17]. Kolos and Szalewicz [18], and that of James and Coolidge [19], respectively. In these studies the introduction of a correlation factor, taking into account the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons, is naturally motivated by considering the trial wave function as broken into three parts, we write (r1 , r2 ) = (r1 )(r2 )f (r1 , r2 ),
(1.17)
where (r1 ) and (r2 ) are exact one electron solutions in the absence of interaction between electrons. For (r1 , r2 ) the Schrödinger equation (in atomic units)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
103
gives ∇2 Zb Za (r2 )f (r1 , r2 ) − 1 − − (r1 ) 2 ra1 rb1 ∇22 Zb Za − − (r2 ) + (r1 )f (r1 , r2 ) − 2 ra2 rb2 ∇2 ∇2 1 f (r1 , r2 ) + cross terms + (r1 )(r2 ) − 1 − 2 + 2 2 r12 Za Zb (r1 )(r2 )f (r1 , r2 ), = E− R
(1.18)
where cross terms mean terms that go as ∇1 (r1 ) · ∇1 f (r1 , r2 ), etc. The solution with only the first two terms is just that for H+ 2 . The functions (r1 ) and (r2 ) exponentially decay at large distances from the nuclei. The third term corresponds to the Schrödinger equation for two free electrons, ∇2 ∇2 1 f (r1 , r2 ) = εf (r1 , r2 ) − 1 − 2 + (1.19) 2 2 r12 that is the solution to Eq. (1.19) is well known [21] and is given in terms of Coulomb wave functions, i.e., confluent hypergeometric functions (see more detailed discussions in Section 5.2), which yields the (1 + r12 /2) Hylleraas factor as an asymptotic at small r12 . In order to place this part of the present review in perspective and be ready for the paradigm shift from the old quasi quantummechanical Bohr model to the new fully wave-mechanical Schrödinger–Born– Oppenheimer model, we next give a brief history of the molecular orbital concepts and computations.
1.5. C ONTEXT Molecular quantum chemistry is a fascinating success story in the annals of 20th Century science. In 1926, Schrödinger introduced the all-important wave equation which soon bore his name. In the following year Schrödinger’s new theory was applied to the simplest molecular systems of the hydrogen molecular ion H+ 2 by Burrau [22] and to the hydrogen molecule H2 by Heitler and London [23] and Condon [24]. In the same year, Born and Oppenheimer [25] published their important paper dealing with molecular nuclear motion. Further, in 1928, Hund and Mulliken [26] presented their venerable molecular orbital (MO) theory, which provided a powerful computational tool for chemistry and a foundation for the subsequent development of modern molecular science. Diatomic molecules such as H2 and HeH+ are the simplest of all molecules. Their analysis, modelling and computation constitute the bedrock of the study of
104
G. Chen et al.
chemical bonds in molecular structures. To quote a recent insightful article by Cotton and Nocera [27]: “It can be said without fear of contradiction that the two-electron bond is the single most important stereoelectronic feature of chemistry.”
Indeed, the description of the covalent bond in diatomics, based on the methods of Heitler–London and Hund–Mulliken, is one of the crowning achievements of quantum mechanics and fundamental physics. Computational quantum chemistry dawned in 1927 with the advent of the Heitler–London method. However, the accuracy of these early numerical results were not satisfactory, as can be seen from the following quotation (Hinchliffe [28, p. 254]): “The calculated bond length and dissociation energy [of MO theory] are in poor agreement with experiment than those obtained from simple VB [valence bond] treatment (Table 15.3), and this puzzled many people at the time. It has also led them to believe that the VB method was the correct way forward for the description of molecular structure . . . .”
New ideas were then proposed to improve the numerical accuracy of the Heitler–London and Hund–Mulliken method. The first idea of configuration interaction (CI) is to incorporate excited states into the wave function. The second idea of correlation introduces explicit dependence of the interelectronic distance in the wave function. The idea of correlation was first demonstrated by Hylleraas [29] in 1929 for the helium atom and by James and Coolidge [19] in 1933 for H2 . The use of configuration interaction and correlation are key evolutionary steps in improving the original ideas of Heitler–London and Hund– Mulliken. We can quote the following from Rychlewski [30]: “. . . Very soon it has been realized that inclusion of interelectronic distance into the wave function is a powerful way of improving the accuracy of calculated results . . . . Today, methods based on explicitly correlated wave functions are capable of yielding the “spectroscopic” accuracy in molecular energy calculations (errors less than the orders of one µ Hartree) . . . .”
For more than two electrons, it is difficult for most numerical methods to include electron correlations directly except in Monte Carlo simulations. When it is possible, as in the two electron case, excellent results can be achieved with very compact wave functions. Molecular calculations are inherently more difficult than atomic calculations. The fundamental difficulty is well stated by Teller and Sahlin [31]: “The molecular problem has a greater inherent complexity than the corresponding atomic problem . . . . In atoms, degeneracy due to spherical symmetry causes many levels to have nearly the same energy. This grouping of levels is responsible for the presence of a shell structure in atoms, and this shell structure is in turn the primary reason for the striking and simple behavior of atoms and the consequent successes of
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
105
the independent-electron approximation for atomic systems. In passing from atoms to molecules the symmetry is reduced and the amount of degeneracy for the electronic levels becomes smaller, and, as a consequence, the power of the independent-particle model is decreased relative to the atomic case.”
Nothing illustrates this loss of symmetry, and its consequent loss of validity of the independent-particle picture better than the complete failure of the molecular orbital picture to account for the correct dissociation energy of H2 . At large internuclear separation, the symmetry is greatly reduced, and the independent occupation of single-particle molecular orbitals fails catastrophically. This failure can of course be averted by configuration-interaction, but this extra work makes it plain that molecular problems are inherently more complicated than atomic problems. Fortunately, for the investigation of ground and excited molecular states near equilibrium, one is far from the dissociation limit; the loss of symmetry complicates the calculation of the molecular orbital, but the independent particle model remains a good approximation. In the case of H2 , a natural candidate is the orbital of the two-center oneelectron molecular ion. Such orbitals will be referred to as diatomic orbitals (DO) or, in more complicated cases, shielded diatomic orbitals (SDO) when shielding is a factor to be considered. The early (1930s) ansatz wave functions of James and Coolidge [19] are expressed in terms of prolate spheroidal coordinates of the two electrons with respect to the two centers of the diatomic nuclei. However, their wave functions are not DOs in that they are not expansions of the exact one electron H+ 2 states. Rather, their approach is CI with a basis conveniently chosen for numerical evaluation. Their work is the forerunner of the Polish quantum chemistry group [8,17,18] of Kolos, Wolniewicz, etc., which have achieved the highest accuracy in numerical computation of two-electron molecules. The high accuracy obtained by Kolos and Wolniewicz in [17] is admirable, but as noted by Patil et al. [15], “. . . It is, however, perhaps somewhat unfortunate that these very impressive accomplishments have largely discouraged further fundamental studies on novel approaches to obtain accurate wave functions more directly . . . .”
A similar comment was made much earlier by Mulliken [32]: “[T]he more accurate the calculations become the more concepts tend to vanish into thin air.”
Thus the human quest for comprehension remains, and the recent research on novel approaches to obtain accurate wave functions have indeed yielded accurate, physically motivated, and compact two-electron wave functions. Patil et al. [33,34,36–39] have advocated the construction of coalescence wave functions by incorporating both cusp and asymptotic conditions. We have provided a detailed review with simplified derivations of this development in Section 3. The other approach is the use of diatomic orbitals. Historically, the original idea of using
106
G. Chen et al.
DOs as basis for diatomic molecules seems to begin from the work of Wallis and Hulburt [40]. More extensive references and history can be found in the works of Mclean et al. [41], Teller and Sahlin [31] and Shull [42]. Wallis and Hulburt’s result was not particularly successful, because there was no explicit electron correlation and solving the two-center wave function was difficult. According to Aubert et al. [12, Part I, p. 51]: “. . . the use of these functions, i.e., diatomic orbitals (DOs), within the oneconfiguration molecular-orbital scheme has not been very successful, owing to the difficulty of taking into account the interelectronic interactions and, moreover, owing to the complexity of calculations.”
The calculation of H+ 2 wave function improved over the years, culminating in the extensive tabulations by Teller and Sahlin [31]. In 1974–75, Aubert, Bessis and Bessis published a three-part series [12] detailing how to determine SDOs for diatomic molecules. These three papers emphasize the determination of shielded DOs. Surprisingly, the use of DO with correlation to study H2 was not undertaken until 1981 by Aubert-Frécon and Le Sech [13]. Le Sech et al. have since then made further refinements to the method (Siebbeles and Le Sech [14], Le Sech [6]). Our study of the DO’s approach was motivated by our strong interest in the modelling and computation of molecules. We were especially attracted by DOs as a natural and accurate description of chemical bonds. In Scully et al. [16], largely unaware of the prior work done by Aubert-Frécon and Le Sech of the French school, we obtained simple correlated DOs for diatomic molecules with good accuracy. The present paper represents part of our continued efforts in this direction. In this work, we will first study the mathematical properties of wave functions such as their cusp conditions, asymptotic behaviors, and forms of correlation functions. We summarize methods, techniques and formulas in a tutorial style, interspersed with some unpublished results of our own. It it not our intention to complete an exhaustive review on this vast subject, rather, only to record developments relevant to our interest in sufficient details. We apologize in advance for any inadvertent omissions.
1.6. O UTLINE The present paper is organized as follows: (i) In Section 2, we present some recent progress of an interpolated Bohr model. (ii) In Section 3, we discuss some general and fundamental properties of atoms and molecules, including the Born–Oppenheimer separation, the Feynman– Hellman Theorem, Riccati form of the ground state wave function, proximal and asymptotic conditions, the coalescent construction and the dissociation limit.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
107
(iii) In Section 4, we introduce the basics of the 1-electron two-centered orbitals from the classic explicit solutions of Hylleraas and Jaffé. The one-centered and multi-centered orbitals will also be reviewed. (iv) In Section 5, we present the details of the derivations of the all-important cusp conditions of Kato, and show examples as to how to verify them in prolate spheroidal coordinates. We also provide a glossary of various correlation functions that satisfy the interelectronic cusp condition. (v) In Section 6, we discuss numerical modelling of diatomic molecules and compare results with the classic methods such as the Heitler–London, Hund– Mulliken, Hartree–Fock and James–Coolidge, and the new approach of twocentered orbitals by Le Sech et al. (vi) In Section 7 we discuss alternative methods for molecular calculations based on the generalized Bohr model and the dimensional scaling. (vii) Finally, in Section 8 we give our conclusions and present an outlook.
2. Recent Progress Based on Bohr’s Model The diatomic molecules in a fully quantum mechanical treatment addressed in Section 1.5 requires solution of the many-particle Schrödinger equation. However, such an approach also requires complicated numerical algorithms. As a consequence, for a few electron problem the results become less accurate and sometimes unreliable. This is pronounced for excited electron states when the application of the variational principle is much less involved. Therefore, invention of simple and, at the same time, relatively accurate methods of molecule description is quite desirable. In this section we discuss a method which is based on the Bohr model and its modification [4]. In particular, we show that for H2 a simple extension of the original Bohr model [5] describes the potential energy curves for the lowest singlet and triplet states just about as nicely as those from the wave mechanical treatment. The simplistic Bohr model provides surprisingly accurate energies for the ground singlet state at large and small internuclear distances and for the triplet state over the full range of R. Also, the model predicts the ground state is bound with an equilibrium separation Re ≈ 1.10 and gives the binding energy as EB ≈ 0.100 a.u. = 2.73 eV. The Heitler–London calculation, obtained from a two-term variational function, yields Re = 1.51 and EB = 3.14 eV [23], whereas the “exact” results are Re = 1.401 and EB = 4.74 eV [8]. For the triplet state, as seen in Fig. 2, the Bohr model gives a remarkably close agreement with the “exact” potential curve and is in fact much better than the Heitler–London result (which, e.g., is 30% higher for R = 2). One should mention that in 1913, Bohr found only the symmetric configuration solution, which fails drastically to describe the ground state dissociation limit.
108
G. Chen et al.
The simple Bohr model offers valuable insights for the description of other diatomic molecules. For N electrons the model reduces to finding configurations that deliver extrema of the energy function 1 n2i E= + V (r1 , r2 , . . . , rN , R), 2 ρi2 N
(2.1)
i=1
where the first term is the electron kinetic energy, while V is the Coulomb potential energy. In such formulation of the model there is no need to specify electron trajectories nor to incorporate nonstationary electron motion. Eq. (2.1) assumes that only at some moment in time the electron angular momentum equals an integer number of h¯ and the energy is minimized under this constraint. In the general case, the angular momentum of each electron changes with time; nevertheless, the total energy remains a conserved quantity. Let us now discuss the ground state potential curve of HeH. To incorporate the Pauli exclusion principle one can use a prescription based on the sequential filling of the electron levels. In the case of HeH the three electrons can not occupy the same lowest level of HeH++ . As a result, we must disregard the lowest potential energy curve E(R) obtained by the minimization of Eq. (2.1) and take the next possible electron configuration, which is shown in Fig. 3 (upper panel). For this configuration, n1 = n2 = n3 = 1, however, the right energy corresponds to a saddle point rather than to a global minimum. In order to obtain the correct eff = 1.954. The dissociation limit we assign the helium an effective charge ZHe charge matches the difference between the exact ground state energy of the He atom and the Bohr model result. Fig. 3 shows the ground state potential curve of HeH in the Bohr model (solid curve) and the “exact” result (dots) obtained from extensive variational calculations [43]. The Bohr model gives a remarkably close agreement with the “exact” potential curve. 2.1. I NTERPOLATED B OHR M ODEL The original Bohr model assumes quantization of the electron angular momentum relative to the molecular axis. This yields a quite accurate description of the H2 ground state E(R) at small R. However, E(R) becomes less accurate at larger internuclear separation as seen in Fig. 2. To obtain a better result one can use the following observation. At large R each electron in H2 feels only the nearest nuclear charge because the remaining charges form a neutral H atom. Therefore, at large R the momentum quantization relative to the nearest nuclei, rather than to the molecular axis, must yield a better answer. This leads to the following expression for the energy of the H2 molecule n22 1 n21 Z Z Z 1 Z2 Z E= (2.2) + − − − + + . − 2 2 2 ra1 ra1 rb1 ra2 rb2 r12 R rb2
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
109
F IG . 3. Energy E(R) of HeH molecule for the electron configuration shown on the upper panel as a function of internuclear spacing R calculated within the Bohr model for n1 = n2 = n3 = 1, eff = 1.954 (solid line) and the “exact” ground state energy of [43] (dots). ZHe
For n1 = n2 = 1 and R > 2.8 the expression (2.2) has a local minimum for the asymmetric configuration 2 of Fig. 2. We plot the corresponding E(R) without the 1/R term in Fig. 4 (curve 2). At R < 2.8 the electrons collapse into nuclei. At small R we apply the quantization condition relative to the molecular axis which yields curve 1 in Fig. 4. To find E(R) at intermediate separation we connect smoothly the two regions by a third order polynomial (thin line). Addition of the 1/R term yields the final potential curve, plotted in Fig. 5. The simple interpolated Bohr model provides a remarkably close agreement with the “exact” potential curve over the full range of R. As an example of application of the interpolated Bohr model to other diatomic molecules, we discuss the ground state potential curve of LiH. The Li atom contains three electrons, two of which fill the inner shell. Only the outer electron with the principal quantum number n = 2 is important in forming the molecular bond. This makes the description of LiH similar to the excited state of H2 in which two electrons possess n1 = 1 and n2 = 2. So, we start from the H2 excited state and apply the interpolated Bohr model as described above. Then, to obtain E(R) for
110
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 4. The Bohr model E(R) for H2 molecule without 1/R term. Curves 1 and 2 are obtained based on the quantization relative to the molecular axis (small R) and the nearest nuclei (large R), respectively. Thin line is the interpolation between two regions.
F IG . 5. Ground state E(R) of H2 molecule as a function of internuclear distance R calculated within the interpolated Bohr model (solid line) and the “exact” energy of [8] (dots).
LiH, we take the H2 potential curve and add the difference between the ground state energy of Li (−7.4780 a.u.) and H in the n = 2 state, i.e., add −7.3530 a.u.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
111
F IG . 6. Ground (1 + ) state energy E(R) of LiH molecule as a function of internuclear distance R calculated within the interpolated Bohr model (lower solid line) and the “exact” energy of [44] (dots). Upper solid curve is the first excited (3 + ) state energy of LiH obtained from the Bohr model 3 g+ E(R) of H2 molecule by adding the difference between the ground state energy of Li and H.
The final result is shown in Fig. 6 (lower solid line), while dots are the “exact” numerical answer from [44]. One can see that the simple interpolated Bohr model provides quite good quantitative description of the potential curve of LiH, which is already a relatively complex four electron system.
3. General Results and Fundamental Properties of Wave Functions Having examined the quasi-quantum mechanical Bohr model in the preceding two sections, we now attend to the fully quantum mechanical model and its approximation and analysis.
3.1. T HE B ORN –O PPENHEIMER S EPARATION The underlying theoretical basis for problems involving a few particles in atomic and molecular physics is the Schrödinger equation for the electrons and nuclei,
112
G. Chen et al.
which provides satisfactory explanations of the chemical, electromagnetic and spectroscopic properties of the atoms and molecules. Assume that the system under consideration has N1 nuclei with masses MK and charges eZK , e being the 1 electron charge, for K = 1, 2, . . . , N1 , and N2 = N K=1 ZK is the number of electrons. The position vector of the Kth nucleus will be denoted as R K , while that of the kth electron will be r k , for k = 1, 2, . . . , N2 . Let m be the mass of the electron. The Schrödinger equation for the overall system is given by
N2 N1 N2 N1 2 2 2 ZK e2 2 ∇K − ∇k − 2MK 2m |R K − r k | K=1 k=1 K=1 k=1 N2 N1 1 e2 ZK ZK e2 1 + + (R, r) 2 |r k − r k | 2 |R K − R K |
H (R, r) = −
k,k =1 k=k
K,K =1 K=K
= E(R, r),
(3.1)
where H is the Hamiltonian and R = (R 1 , R 2 , . . . , R N1 ),
r = (r 1 , r 2 , . . . , r N2 ).
The above equation is often too complex for practical purposes of studying molecular problems. Born and Oppenheimer [25] provide a reduced order model by approximation, permitting a particularly accurate decoupling of the motions of the electrons and the nuclei. The main idea is to assume that in (3.1) takes the form of a product (R, r) = G(R)F (R, r).
(3.2)
Substituting (3.2) into (3.1), we obtain
N2 N2 N1 2 2 ZK e2 ∇k − 2m |R K − r k | k=1 K=1 k=1 N2 1 e2 + F (R, r) 2 |r k − r k |
−
G(R)
k,k =1 k=k
+
N1 2 1 2 ∇K + − 2MK 2 K=1
N1 K,K =1 K=K
+ T1 + T2 = EG(R)F (R, r),
ZK ZK e2 G(R) F (R, r) |R K − R K | (3.3)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
113
where T1 ≡ −G(R)
N1 2 ∇K G(R) · ∇K F (R, r), MK
(3.4)
N1 2 ∇ 2 F (R, r). 2MK K
(3.5)
K=1
T2 ≡ −G(R)
K=1
The essential step in the Born–Oppenheimer separation consists in dropping T1 and T2 in (3.3). This leads to the separation of the electronic wave function
N2 N2 N2 N1 2 2 2 e Z e 1 K − ∇k2 + − F (R, r) 2m 2 |r k − r k | |R K − r k | k=1
k,k =1 k=k
K=1 k=1
= Ee (R)F (R, r),
(3.6)
and a second equation for the nuclear wave function
N1 2 1 − ∇2 + 2MK K 2 K=1
N1 K,K =1 K=K
ZK ZK e2 + Ee (R) G(R) |R K − R K |
= EG(R), where Ee (R) is the constant of separation. In “typical” molecules, the time scale for the valence electrons to orbit about the nuclei is about once every 10−15 s (and that of the inner-shell electrons is even smaller), that of the molecular vibration is about once every 10−14 s, and that of the molecule rotation is every 10−12 s. This difference of time scale is what make T1 and T2 in (3.4) and (3.5) negligible, as the electrons move so fast that they can instantaneously adjust their motions with respect to the vibration and rotation movements of the slower and much heavier nuclei. The Born–Oppenheimer separation breaks down in several cases, chief among them when the nuclear motion is strongly coupled to electronic motions, e.g., when the Jahn–Teller effects [45,46] are present. It also requires corrections for loosely held electrons such as those in Rydberg atoms. Research work on non-Born–Oppenheimer effects, the inclusion of the spinorbit coupling, and on models without using the Born–Oppenheimer separation by treating the coupled dynamical motions of the electrons and nuclei simultaneously, may be found in Yarkony [47] and Öhrn [48], for example.
114
G. Chen et al.
3.2. VARIATIONAL P ROPERTIES : T HE V IRIAL T HEOREM AND THE F EYNMAN –H ELLMAN T HEOREM The variational form of (3.1) is min |H | = E,
(3.7)
|=1
where the trial wave functions = (R, r) belong to a proper function space (which is actually the Sobolev space H 1 (R3(N1 +N2 ) ) in the mathematical theory of partial differential equations [20, Chapter 2]). The (unique) solution 0 attaining the minimum of |H | is called the ground state and the associated value E0 ≡ 0 |H |0 is the corresponding ground state energy. Excited states k with successively higher energy levels may be obtained recursively through min|H | ≡ Ek = k |H |k , where is subject to the constraints
(3.8)
| = 1, |0 = |1 = · · · = |k−1 = 0,
for k = 1, 2, 3, . . . .
There are two useful theorems related to the above variational formulation: the virial theorem and the Feynman–Hellman theorem. We discuss them below. Let ψ be any trial wave function. The expectation value of the kinetic energy is
N N2 1
2 2 2
2 Ekin ≡ − (3.9) ∇ − ∇ .
2MK K 2m k K=1
k=1
Now, consider the scaling of all spatial variables by 1 + λ: R ≡ (R, r) −→ (1 + λ)(R, r) ≡ (1 + λ)R.
(3.10)
Subject to the above transformation (3.10), we have 1 Ekin . (1 + λ)2 kin with respect to λ, we see that it is the same as By taking the variation of E taking the variation of Ekin with respect to . Thus
d
= δEkin , Ekin dλ λ=0
1 d
E = −2(1 + λ)−3 λ=0 · Ekin = −2Ekin = δEkin . kin 2 dλ (1 + λ) λ=0 (3.11) kin = E
For the potential energy, the expectation is given by Epot ≡ |V | ≡ V ,
(3.12)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
115
where V consists of the 3 summations of Coulomb potentials inside the bracket of (3.1) (but V can be allowed to be any potential whose negative gradient is force). The spatial scaling (3.10) implies the change of displacement δ = λ, which is now regarded as infinitesimal. Therefore,
d δEpot = ψ ∗ (R)V (1 + λ)R ψ(R) dR)
dλ λ=0
R3N
ψ ∗ (R) R · ∇V (R) ψ(R) dR
= R3N
= R · ∇V ≡ Virial,
(3.13)
where Virial is the quantum form of the classical virial. For = 0 , the variational form (3.7) demands that δH = δEkin + δEpot = 0.
(3.14)
Substituting (3.11) and (3.13) into (3.14), we obtain −2Ekin + Virial = 0.
(3.15)
This is the general form of the virial theorem for an isolated system of an atom or a molecule. In the particular case that N2 N1
V (R) = −
K=1 k=1
+
1 2
N2 Zk e2 e2 1 + |R K − r k | 2 |r k − r k |
N1 K,K =1 K=K
k,k =1 k=k
ZK ZK e2 , |R K − R K |
which is the power law Rn (where R is the distance) with n = −1, the classical virial property holds: Virial = nEpot = −Epot
(3.16)
as R · ∇Rn = nRn−1 R · ∇R = nRn . From (3.15) and (3.16), we obtain the virial theorem for an (exact, not trial) wave function: 2Ekin + Epot = 0,
(3.17)
116
G. Chen et al.
or 1 Ekin = − Epot . (3.18) 2 This property is used as a check for accuracy of calculations and the properness of the choices of trial wave functions. The next, Feynman–Hellman theorem, shows how the energy of a system varies when the Hamiltonian changes. Assume that the Hamiltonian of an atom or molecule system depends on a parameter α, H = H (α). For example, α may represent the internuclear distance of the molecular ion H+ 2 . The exact wave function = (α) also depends on α, so does the energy of the system E = E(α). Let’s see how E(α) changes with respect to α, i.e., dE(α) d ∗ (α)H (α)(α) dr = dα dα ∂ ∗ (α) ∂H (α) = H (α)(α) dr + ∗ (α) (α) dr ∂α ∂α ∂(α) dr + ∗ (α)H (α) ∂α ∂ ∗ (α) ∂H (α) = E(α) (α) dr + ∗ (α) (α) dr ∂α ∂α ∂(α) dr + E(α) ∗ (α) ∂α
∂H (α) d (α) (α) + ∗ (α) (α) dr = E(α) dα ∂α
∂H (α)
(α) = (α)
∂α as (α)|(α) = 1 and is independent of α. The above is the Feynman–Hellman theorem. Its advantage is that oftentimes ∂H (α)/∂α is of a very simple form. For example, for the H+ 2 -like equation (4.13), upon taking α = R we have Zb rb Za Zb ∂H =− 3 R+ 3 ∂R R rb and the average force on the nucleus B is Zb rb Za Zb ∂E R− = . F=− ∂R R3 rb3 That is the force and, hence, the potential energy curve requires calculation of Zb rb /rb3 only. This substantially simplifies the problem since the matrix element from the ∇ 2 is no longer necessary.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
117
3.3. F UNDAMENTAL P ROPERTIES OF O NE AND T WO -E LECTRON WAVE F UNCTIONS 3.3.1. Riccati Form, Proximal and Asymptotic Conditions In this subsection, we introduce the Riccati form of the ground state wave functions as a unified way of understanding and deriving various cusp, asymptotic and correlation functions. This forms the basis by which compact wave functions for diatomic molecules can be derived. Consider the Schrödinger equation with a spherically symmetric potential in reduced units, −
1 2 ∇ ψ(r) + V (r)ψ(r) = Eψ(r), 2µ
where µ = 1 is the central-force case, and µ = coordinate case. We will be primary interested in
(3.19) 1 2
is the equal-mass, relative
Z (cf. (4.12) below), (3.20) r however, the long range Coulomb potential is special in many ways and we can best understand the Coulomb-potential wave function by comparing and contrasting it to the short-range, Lennard-Jones potential 1 1 VLJ (r) = 0 12 − 6 . (3.21) r r Vc (r) = −
Since the ground state of (3.19) is strictly positive and spherically symmetric, it can always be written as (unnormalized) ψ(r) = e−S(r) .
(3.22)
Substituting this into (3.19) gives the Riccati equation for S(r) 1 2 1 ∇ S(r) − ∇S(r) · ∇S(r) + V (r) = E0 . 2µ 2µ
(3.23)
Since ∇S(r) = S (r)ˆr and ∇ · rˆ = 2/r, we have simply, 1 1 1 2 S + S − S + V (r) = E0 . 2µ µr 2µ
(3.24)
The advantage of this equation is that since the RHS is a constant E0 , all the singularities of V (r) must be cancelled by the derivatives of S(r). In particular, if we are only seeking an approximate ground state, then a reasonable criterion would be to require S(r) to cancel the most singular term in V (r). For both the Coulomb and the Lennard-Jones case, the potential is most singular as r → 0. We will refer to this as the proximal limit. For both cases, the singularity of V (r)
118
G. Chen et al.
is only polynomial in r and therefore we can assume S(r) = ar n ,
(3.25)
giving explicitly 1 1 2 2 2n−2 + V (r) = E0 . an(n + 1)r n−2 − a n r 2µ 2µ
(3.26)
Note the structure of this equation, if the V (r) has a repulsive polynomial singularity, then it can always be cancelled by the r 2n−2 term, leaving a less singular term r n−2 behind. For example, in the Lennard-Jones case, the most singular term is cancelled if we set −
0 1 2 2 2n−2 + 12 = 0, a n r 2µ r
(3.27)
yielding, n = −5, and for µ = 12 , the famous McMillan correlation function for quantum liquid helium, 1√ 0 r −5 . 5 However, if V (r) has an attractive singularity, then it can only be cancelled by the r n−2 term, and if n ≤ 0, would leave behind a more singular term instead. This means that an attractive potential V (r) cannot be as singular, or more singular, than −1/r 2 , otherwise, the Schrödinger equation has no solutions. Fortunately, for the Coulomb attraction (3.20), the −Z/r singularity can be cancelled by setting S(r) =
Z 1 an(n + 1)r n−2 − = 0, 2µ r
(3.28)
yielding, for µ = 1, n = 1, S(r) = Zr. For electron–electron repulsion with µ =
1 2
and Z = −1, we would have instead
1 S(r) = − r. 2 In the Coulomb case, these proximal conditions are known as cusp conditions. A more thorough treatment of the cusp condition for the general case will be given in Section 5.1 and Appendices F and H. The proximal criterion of cancelling the leading singularity of V (r) can be applied generally to any V (r). The cusp conditions are just special cases for the Coulomb potential. Note that in (3.28), the Coulomb singularity is actually cancelled only by the S /(µr) term of the
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
119
Riccati equation, 1 Z S − = 0, µr r since requiring S to be a constant at the singular point forces S = 0. Thus the cusp condition can be stated most succinctly in term of the Riccati function S(r): wherever the nuclear charge is located, the radial derivative of S(r) at that point must be equal to the nuclear charge. Next, we consider the asymptotic limit of r → ∞. In the case of short range potential, such that V (r) → 0 faster than 1/r, we can just completely ignore V (r) in (3.24). Substituting in S(r) = αr + β ln(r) gives 1 β 1 1 β 2 β − − + α+ α+ = E0 . 2µ r 2 2µ r µr r
(3.29)
The constant terms determine α = −2µE0 = 2µ|E0 |. Setting the sum of 1/r terms zero gives, 1 α(1 − β) = 0, µr
(3.30)
which fixes β = 1. The remaining terms will decay faster than 1/r and can be neglected in the large r limit. Thus the asymptotic wave function for any shortranged potential (decays faster than 1/r) must be of the form ψ(r) →
1 −αr e . r
(3.31)
(we wish to reserve the possibility that However, for the Coulomb potential −Z/r Z can be distinct from Z and unrelated to E0 ), we must retain it among the 1/r terms in (3.30), Z 1 α(1 − β) − = 0, µr r
(3.32)
resulting in β =1−
µZ . α
(3.33)
120
G. Chen et al.
Thus the general asymptotic wave function for a Coulomb potential has a slower decay, ψ(r) →
1 −αr e . rβ
(3.34)
= Z, α = Z, β = 0, For a single electron in a central Coulomb field, µ = 1, Z and ψ(r) → e−Zr ,
(3.35)
the decay is the slowest, very different from (3.31). For more than one electron, β does not vanish and the correct asor more than one nuclear charge, α = Z, ymptotic wave function is (3.34). We tend to forget this fact because we are too familiar with the single-electron wave function, which is the exception, rather than the norm. The proximal and asymptotic conditions are very stringent constraints: wave functions that can satisfy both are inevitably close to the exact wave functions. Satisfying the proximal condition alone is sufficient to guarantee an excellent approximate ground state for all radial symmetric potentials such as the LennardJones, the Yukawa (V = 1r e−αr , α > 0), and the Morse potential (V = e−2αr − 2e−αr , α > 0). Needless to say, the proximal condition alone determines the exact ground state for the Coulomb and the harmonic oscillator potential. The significance of the proximal condition has always been recognized. The current interest [34] in deriving compact wave functions for small atoms and molecules is based on a renewed appreciation of the importance of the correct asymptotics wave functions. 3.3.2. The Coalescence Wave Function Consider the case of two electrons orbiting a central Coulomb field, 1 1 Z Z 1 − ∇12 − ∇22 − − + ψ(r1 , r2 ) = Eψ(r1 , r2 ). 2 2 r1 r2 r12
(3.36)
Imagine that we assemble this atom one electron at a time. When we bring in the first electron, its energy is E1 = −Z 2 /2, with wave function ψ(r1 ) = exp(−Zr1 ) localizing it near the origin. When electron 2 is still very far away, we can write the two-electron wave function as ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−Zr1 −S(r2 ) .
(3.37)
Substituting this into (3.36) yields the Riccati equation for S(r2 ), 1 Z 1 1 1 1 2 + = E0 + Z 2 . S − S + S − 2 2 r2 r2 r12 2
(3.38)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
121
The RHS defines the second electron’s energy, E2 ≡ E0 + 12 Z 2 , whose magnitude is just the first removal or ionization energy. Since electron 2 is far away, and electron 1 is close to the origin, r12 ≈ r2 . Thus electron 2 “sees” an effective Coulomb √ field −Z/r2 with Z = Z − 1. This is the case envisioned in (3.32) with α = −2E2 . The asymptotic wave function for the second electron is, therefore, −β
ψ(r2 ) → r2 e−αr2 ,
(3.39) −β
with β = 1 − (Z − 1)/α. Since β is always less than one, the r2 term is only a minor correction. Its effect can be accounted for by slightly altering α. The important point here is that the second electron need not have the same Coulomb wave function as the first electron. This coalescence scenario would suggest, after symmetrizing (3.37), the following two-electron wave function: ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−Zr1 −αr2 + e−αr1 −Zr2 .
(3.40)
For the case where there are more than two electrons, one can imagine building up the atom or molecule sequentially one electron at a time. Each electron would then acquire a different Coulomb-potential wave function. This sequential, or coalescence scenario of approximating the ground state, in many cases, resulted in better wave functions than considering all the electrons simultaneously, which is the traditional Hartree–Fock point of view; see Section 6.3. In the case of He, the simple effective charge approximation ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−Zeff r1 e−Zeff r2 with Zeff = Z −
5 = 1.6875, 16
(3.41)
2 = −2.8476, while the “exact” value is −2.9037. The standard gives Evar = −Zeff HF wave function of the form
ψ(r1 , r2 ) = φ(r1 )φ(r2 ) improves [35] the energy to Evar = −2.8617. For comparison, the coalescent wave function (3.40) can achieve Evar = −2.8674 at α = 1.286. Patil [34], by √ restricting α to be consistent with the output variational energy via α = −2Evar − 4, obtained Evar = −2.8671 at α =√1.317. All√these values of α are very close to the exact asymptotic value of α = −2E2 = 2(0.9037) = 1.344, lending credence to the coalescence construction. For arbitrary Z, by approximat2 , we can estimate α by ing E0 by −Zeff 2 − Z 2 (≈ Z − 5/8). α = 2Zeff (3.42)
122
G. Chen et al. Table III Ground state energy of the He-like ions as calculated from various wave functions.
Z
E(Coales) E(Approx.) E(Abs.Min.) E(exact) fLS
fPJ
1 + 12 r12
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
−2.8673 −7.2355 −13.6072 −21.9802 −32.3539 −44.7280 −59.1023 −75.4768 −93.8514
−2.9017(4) −7.271(1) −13.642(1) −22.014(2) −32.386(3) −44.755(3) −59.129(4) −75.502(4) −93.875(5)
−2.8898(7) −7.264(1) −13.634(2) −22.011(2) −32.382(3) −44.753(3) −59.127(4) −75.494(4) −93.885(5)
−2.8757 −7.2490 −13.6232 −21.9978 −32.3725 −44.7473 −59.1221 −75.4970 −93.8719
−2.8757 −7.2488 −13.6230 −21.9975 −32.3723 −44.7471 −59.1220 −75.4969 −93.8718
−2.9037 −7.2799 −13.6555 −22.0309 −32.4062 −44.7814 −59.1566 −75.5317 −93.9068
−2.9016(3) −7.268(1) −13.637(2) −22.004(2) −32.376(3) −44.740(4) −59.115(4) −75.490(6) −93.859(6)
For Z = 2, this gives α = 1.30 (for small Z, we need to use the full expression rather than the approximation), an excellent estimate. This obviates the need for Patil’s self-consistent procedure to determine α, and produces even slightly better results. The coalescent wave function (3.40) with this choice for α, defines a set of parameter-free two-electron wave functions for all Z. The resulting energy for Z = 2 − 10 is given in Table III. In 1930, Eckart [49] has used wave functions of the form ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−ar1 −br2 + e−br1 −ar2
(3.43)
to compute the energy of a two-electron Z-atom. His resulting energy functional is 1 EEck (Z, a, b) = −Z(a + b) + 1 + C(a, b) 1 2 2 × K(a, b) + a + b + abC(a, b) , (3.44) 2 where 64a 3 b3 . (a + b)6 (3.45) He obtained an energy minimum −2.8756613 for He at a = 2.1832 and b = 1.1885. (We have used his energy expression to re-determine the energy minimum more accurately.) While the improvement in energy is a welcoming contribution, it seems difficult to interpret the resulting wave function physically. How can an electron “sees” a nucleus with charge greater than 2? To gain further insight into Eckart’s result, and coalescence wave function in general, we note that (3.43) can be rewritten as χ(r1 , r2 ) = e−A(r1 +r2 ) cosh B(r1 − r2 ) , (3.46) K(a, b) =
20a 3 b3 a 2 b2 ab + + a + b (a + b)3 (a + b)5
and
C(a, b) =
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
123
with A = (a+b)/2 and B = (a−b)/2. This form has the HF part e−A(r1 +r2 ) . If we substitute Eckart’s values, we see that A = (2.1832+1.1885)/2 = 1.6859, which is nearly identical to the effective charge value (3.41). This is not accidental. If we use the approximation (3.42) for α, then the coalescence wave function (3.40) would automatically predict 1 5 (3.47) (Z + α) = Z − ! 2 16 Thus within the class of Eckart wave function (3.43), the coalescence scenario correctly predicts the path of optimal energy as being along A = Zeff . Moreover, this improvement in energy, which has laid dormant in Eckart’s result for three quarters of a century, can now be understood as due to the radial correlation cosh term in (3.46), built-in automatically by the coalescence construction. This term is the smallest (=1) when r1 = r2 , but is large when the separation r1 − r2 is large, i.e., it encourages the two electrons to be separated in the radial direction. This suggests that we should reexamine Eckart’s energy functional in terms of parameters A and B. Expanding (3.44) to fourth order in B yields, A=
3 1 2 3 2 EEck (Z, A, B) = −Zeff + (A − Zeff )2 − y + y 2 − y , 8 2 2A
(3.48)
where y ≡ B 2 /A. If B = 0, A = Zeff this yields the effective charge energy 2 . Regarding the effect of B as perturbing on this fixed choice of A, the −Zeff 1/A ≈ 1/Z term can first be ignored. Minimizing y simply yields EEck (Z, A, B) = −Zeff −
3 1 − 128 128Zeff
(3.49)
at 1 B2 = , (3.50) A 8 where we have restored the 1/A term. This remarkably simple result is the content of Eckart’s energy functional. The energy is lower from the effective charge value by a nearly constant amount 3/128. In column three of Table III, we compare this approximate energy (3.49), with the absolute minimum of the Eckart’s energy functional on the fourth column. The agreement is uniformly excellent. By comparison, we see that the coalescence construction, without invoking any minimization process, also gives a very good account of the energy minimum. y=
3.3.3. Electron Correlation Functions Coalescence wave functions are better than HF wave function because they have built-in radial correlations. To further improve our description of He, as first realized by Hylleraas [29], one can introduce electron–electron correlation directly
124
G. Chen et al.
by forcing the two-electron wave function to depend on r12 explicitly. (A more detailed discussion of correlation functions will be given in Section 5.2 below.) Again, our analysis is simplified by use of the Riccati function. Let ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−S(r1 ,r2 ,r12 ) ,
(3.51)
but now consider S(r1 , r2 , r12 ) = Zr1 + Zr2 + g(r12 ).
(3.52)
We have ∇1 S = Zˆr1 + g rˆ 12 , 2Z 2g ∇12 S = + + g , r1 r12 and (3.36) in terms of S reads
∇2 S = Zˆr2 + g rˆ 21 , 2Z 2g ∇22 S = + + g , r2 r12
2g + 1 − (g )2 − Zg (ˆr1 − rˆ 2 ) · rˆ 12 − Z 2 = E0 . r12 In order to eliminate the 1/r12 singularity, we must have g +
(3.53)
1 lim g (r12 ) = − . r12 →0 2 Thus, one can consider a series expansion for g(r12 ) starting out as 1 1 2 + ···. g(r12 ) = − r12 + Cr12 (3.54) 2 2 Keeping only up to the quadratic term, in the limit of r12 → 0, (3.53) reads 1 − Z 2 + O(r12 ) = E0 . (3.55) 4 If g(r12 ) were exact, the LHS above would be the constant ground state energy for all values of r12 . Inverting the argument, we can exploit this fact to determine C at r12 = 0, provided that we can estimate the ground state energy E0 . The simplest estimate for a two electron atom would be E0 = −Z 2 , implying that 3C −
1 . (3.56) 12 However, since the effective charge approximation for the energy is much better, 2 , thus fixing we should take instead, E0 = −Zeff 1 1 2 5 5 1 2 + Z − Zeff = + Z− . C= (3.57) 12 3 12 24 32 C=
The determination of the quadratic term of g(r12 ) was advanced only recently by Kleinekathofer et al. [50]. (If we also improve the one-electron wave function
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
125
from exp(−Zr) → exp(−Zeff r), then C must go back to the value (3.56). The coefficient C therefore depends on the quality of the single electron wave function.) The wave function (3.51) can now be written as ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−Zr1 e−Zr2 f (r12 ),
(3.58)
where
1 f (r12 ) = exp r12 (1 − Cr12 ) . 2
(3.59)
Since the above argument is only valid for small r12 , the large r12 behavior of f (r12 ) is not determined. It seems reasonable, however, barring any long range Coulomb effect, to assume lim f (r12 ) −→ constant.
(3.60)
r12 →0
The form (3.59) can have behavior (3.60) if we just rewrite it as r12 . fPJ (r12 ) = exp 2(1 + Cr12 )
(3.61)
This Padé–Jastrow form has been used extensively in Monte Carlo calculations of atomic systems [51]. Alternatively, to achieve (3.60), Patil’s group [34,50] have suggested the form 1 1 + 2λ − e−λr12 ; 2λ which has the small r12 expansion fP (r12 ) =
cf. (5.2.3) and Fig. 12,
1 λ 2 fP (r12 ) = 1 + r12 − r12 + ···. 2 4 By comparing this with similar expansion of (3.59), we can identify 5 5 1 1 Z− − . λ = 2C − = 2 12 32 3
(3.62)
(3.63)
(3.64)
Le Sech’s group [14] have employed the form 1 fLS (r12 ) = 1 + r12 e−ar12 , 2
(3.65)
with 1 λ. 2 This function is not monotonic; it reaches a maximum at r12 = 1/a before level off back to unity; cf. Fig. 11 in Section 5.2. However, this point may not be practically relevant, since most electron separations do not reach beyond the maximum. a=
126
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 7. Comparison of three electron–electron correlation functions.
For the sake of comparison, we may use the maximum of Le Sech’s correlation function as its asymptotic limit. This is the natural thing to do because all three functions can now be characterized by their asymptotic value as r12 → ∞: 1 1 fPJ (r12 ) → exp ≈ 1+ , 2C λ + 1/2 1 fP (r12 ) → 1 + , 2λ 1 fLS (r12 ) → 1 + . eλ Their approaches toward unity are approximately λ−1 , 12 λ−1 , and 13 λ−1 , respectively. Note also that as λ increases with Z, the asymptotic value of f (r12 ) decreases, this is the correct trend long observed in Monte Carlo calculations on atomic systems [51]. For Z = 2, we take C = 1/2, λ = 1/2, a = 1/4 and compare all three correlation functions in Fig. 7. Also plotted is the simple linear and quadratic forms. The simplest linear correlation function, (1 + 12 r12 ), is very distinct from the other three. We now have all the ingredients needed to construct an optimal wave function for He. First, with the introduction of explicit electron correlation function, there is no need for the radial correlation introduced by the coalescence wave function,
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
127
i.e., we are free to abandon the radial correlation function cosh(B(r1 − r2 )). Second, the asymptotic form of the wave function exp(−αr) should be maintained. However, this asymptotic wave function, when extended back to small r, violates the cusp condition. These concerns can be simultaneously alleviated by replacing the second electron’s wave function via e−αr2 → e−Zr2 cosh(βr2 ). At small r2 , the cosh function is second order in r2 and therefore will not affect the cusp condition. At large r2 , cosh(βr2 ) → exp(βr2 ), and the choice β =Z−α
(3.66)
will give back the correct asymptotic wave function. Upon symmetrization, we finally arrived at the following compact wave function for He: ψ(r1 , r2 , r12 ) = e−Zr1 −Zr2 cosh(βr1 ) + cosh(βr2 ) f (r12 ). (3.67) This wave function, first derived by Le Sech [52], satisfies all the cusp and asymptotic conditions. We fixed α, β and C by (3.42), (3.66) and (3.57), respectively, and there are no free parameters. The only arbitrariness is the form the correlation function f (r12 ). Since fP (r12 ) is bracketed by fPJ (r12 ) and fLS (r12 ), we only need to consider the latter two cases. For Z = 2–10, the resulting ground state energy for the two electron atoms are given in Table III. 3.3.4. The One-Electron Homonuclear Wave Function The one-electron, homonuclear two-center Schrödinger equation 1 Z Z − ∇2 − − ψ(r) = Eψ(r), 2 ra rb
(3.68)
where ra = |r + R/2|, rb = |r − R/2|, can be solved exactly, as will be shown in Section 4.2 below. However, its ground state wave function can also be accurately prescribed by proximal and asymptotic conditions. For Z = 1, this is hydrogen molecular ion problem. As first pointed out by Guillemin and Zener (GZ) [53], when R = 0, the exact wave function is ψ(r) = e−2Zr
(3.69)
and when R → ∞, the exact wave function is ψ(r) = e−Zra + e−Zrb .
(3.70)
They, therefore, propose a wave function that can interpolate between the two, ψGZ (ra , ra ) = e−Z1 ra −Z2 rb + e−Z2 ra −Z1 rb .
(3.71)
128
G. Chen et al.
At R = 0, ra = rb = r, one can take Z1 = Z2 = Z. At R → ∞, one can choose Z1 = Z and Z2 = 0. At intermediate values of R, Z1 and Z2 can be determined variationally. This GZ wave function gives an excellent description [53] of the ground state of H+ 2 . As explained by Patil et al. [15], another reason why this is a good wave function is that (3.71) can satisfy both the cusp and the asymptotic condition. We can simplify Patil et al.’s discussion by rewriting the GZ wave function, again, in the form B(ra − rb ) , ψGZ (ra , rb ) = e−A(ra +rb )/2 cosh (3.72) 2 when R = 0, A = 2Z, and when R → ∞, A = B = Z. The imposition of the cusp condition can be done most easily in terms of the Riccati function. We, therefore, write ψGZ (ra , rb ) = e−S(ra ,rb ) ,
(3.73)
with
A(ra + rb ) B(ra − rb ) S(ra , rb ) = − ln cosh . 2 2 The cusp condition at ra = 0 is then easily computed,
BR ∂S
= Z, A + B tanh = 2Z. ∂r 2
(3.74)
a ra =0,rb =R
One can verify that this is also the cusp condition at rb = 0. From (3.74), one sees easily that at R = 0, A = 2Z, and when R → ∞, A + B = 2Z. At finite R, the asymptotic limit r → ∞ means that ra = rb = r and the GZ wave function approaches ψGZ (ra , rb ) → e−Ar . On the other hand, the exact wave function must be of the form (3.34) √
ψ(ra , rb ) → e− 2|E0 |r−β ln(r) , (3.75) √ √ with β = 1 − 2Z/ 2|E0√ |. Since 2Z ≥ 2|E0 | ≥ Z, we can estimate that at intermediate values of R, 2|E0 | ≈ 32 Z, suggesting a negligible β ≈ − 13 . Thus it is suffice to take A ≈ 2|E0 |. (3.76) Guillemin and Zener have allowed both A and B to be variational parameters. Patil et al.’s estimate [15] of A is essentially that of (3.76) but with slight improvement to incorporate the variation due to β = 0. We adhere to the cusp condition (3.74) but allow A to vary. In practice, it is easier to just let B vary and fix A via the cusp condition (3.74). In all cases, this wave function can provide an excellent description of the hydrogen molecular ion, with energy derivation only on the order of 10−3 Hartree over the range of R = 0 − 5.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
129
3.3.5. The Two-Electron Homonuclear Wave Function The two-electron homonuclear Schrödinger equation is, 1 2 1 2 Z Z Z Z 1 − ∇1 − ∇2 − − − − + ψ(r1 , r2 ) 2 2 r1a r1b r2a r2b r12 = Eψ(r1 , r2 ).
(3.77)
Let’s denote the one-electron two-center GZ wave function as φ(r) = e−Aσ cosh(Bδ), where we have defined ra + rb ra − rb σ = , δ= . 2 2 (The variables σ and δ here will correspond, respectively, to λ and µ of the prolate spheroidal coordinates in Section 4.2.) To describe the two-electron wave function, if one were to follow the usual approach, one would begin by defining the Hartree–Fock-like wave function ψ(r1 , r2 ) = φ(r1 )φ(r2 ) = e−A(σ1 +σ2 ) cosh(Bδ1 ) cosh(Bδ2 ).
(3.78)
However, this molecular orbital approach is well known not to give the correct dissociation limit of H2 . In the limit of R → ∞, we know that φ(r) → e−Zra + e−Zrb
(3.79)
and therefore ψ(r1 , r2 ) → e−Zr1a + e−Zr1b e−Zr2a + e−Zr2b → e−Zr1a e−Zr2b + e−Zr1b e−Zr2a + e−Zr1a e−Zr2a + e−Zr1b e−Zr2b .
(3.80)
Only the first parenthesis, the Heilter–London wave function, gives the correct energy of two well separated atoms with energy E = 2(− 12 Z 2 ). The remaining parenthesis describes, in the case of H2 , the ionic configuration of H− H+ , which has higher energy than two separated neutral hydrogen atoms. Thus the molecular orbital approach (3.78) will always overshoot the correct dissociation limit. This is a fundamental shortcoming of the molecular orbital approach and cannot be cured by merely improving the one-electron wave function, i.e., by use of the exact one-electron, two-center wave function. Even the coalescent construction cannot overcome this fundamental problem. In the large R limit, the inner electron’s wave function must be (3.79), and hence no matter how one constructs the outer electron’s asymptotic wave function, one can never reproduces the Heilter– London wave function. In both the molecular orbital and the coalescent approach,
130
G. Chen et al.
one must resort to configuration interaction to achieve the correct dissociation limit. Even if one were to use the exact one-electron wave function in doing configuration interaction, as it was done by Siebbeles and Le Sech [14], the energy still overshoots the correct dissociation limit if the correlation (1 + 12 r12 ) is used. This is because we must have f (r12 ) → const in order to reproduce the Heilter– London limit. However, one can learn from Guillemin and Zener’s approach, and insist on a wave function that is correct in both the R = 0 and R → ∞ limit. This seemed a very stringent requirement, but surprisingly, it is possible. The wave function is ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−A(σ1 +σ2 ) cosh B(δ1 − δ2 ) f (r12 ). (3.81) For R = 0, σ1 = r1 , σ2 = r2 , and the above function reduces to ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−A(r1 +r2 ) f (r12 ). which is not a bad description of He. In the limit of R → ∞, if we take A = B = Z, we have ψ(r1 , r2 ) = e−Zr1a e−Zr2b + e−Zr1b e−Zr2a f (r12 ), = e−Zr1a e−Zr2b + e−Zr1b e−Zr2a , (3.82) since f (∞) → 1. Thus wave function (3.81) is the simplest homonuclear two electron wave function that can describe both limits adequately. The wave function (3.81) for H2 without f (r12 ) has been derived some time ago by Inui [54] and Nordsieck [55]. However, they were only interested in improving the wave function and energy at the equilibrium separation and were not concerned with whether the wave function can yield the correct dissociation limit. To estimate the form of the correlation function f (r12 ), we repeat our analysis as in the Helium case. The two-electron wave function can again be written in the Riccati form (3.51), but now with S(r1 , r2 , r12 ) = Zr1a + Zr2b + g(r12 ),
(3.83)
where we have assumed the unsymmetrized form of the Heilter–London wave function. The resulting equation for g is also similar to (3.53), 2g + 1 2 1 g + − g − Zg (ˆr1a − rˆ 2b ) · rˆ 12 − Z 2 + O = E0 . r12 R (3.84) In the Helium case, the dot product term vanishes in the limit of r12 → 0, here it does not. In the case where the two electrons meet along the molecular axis, rˆ 1a = zˆ , rˆ 2b = −ˆz, rˆ 12 = −ˆz, the resulting equation 2g + 1 2 1 2 g + (3.85) − g + 2Zg − Z + O = E0 r12 R
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
131
can be solved by setting E0 = −Z 2 , and expanding 1 1 2 + ···. g(r12 ) = − r12 + Cr12 2 2 In the limit of r12 → 0, (3.85) reads 3C −
1 − Z + O(r12 ) = 0, 4
(3.86)
(3.87)
giving Z 1 + . 3 12 This agrees with Patil et al.’s result [15] of C=
(3.88)
1 1 = (2Z − 1), 2 3 but without the need of consulting hypergeometric functions. For the H2 case, C = 5/12 = 0.42. In our calculation with wave function (3.81), with fPJ (r12 ) given by (3.61), the energy minimum at intermediate values of R is at C = 0.40, in excellent agreement with the predicted value. Since C ≈ 0.50 for Helium, C’s variation with R is very mild. The resulting energy for the wave function (3.81), is given in Fig. 8 (solid line). We vary the parameter B, while the other parameters A and C are fixed by Eqs. (3.74) and (3.88). The parameter B is 0.8 for R < 2, and moves graduately toward one at larger values of R. The energy at equilibrium is as good as Siebbeles and Le Sech’s calculation [14] with unscaled H+ 2 wave functions and correlation 1 function (1 + 2 r12 ) (triangles). Without configuration interaction, Siebbeles and Le Sech’s energy overshot the dissociation limit as shown. The wave function (3.81) can be further improved by adding a coalescence component à la Patil et al. [15]. This will be detailed in the next subsection. λ = 2C −
3.3.6. Construction of Trial Wave Functions by Patil and Coworkers The previous discussion demonstrates that relatively simple wave functions which incorporate the cusp conditions and the large distance asymptotics, having no or only a few variational parameters, can be constructed to yield fairly accurate results. Here we mention other similar trial wave functions studied in the literature. The importance of the local properties in the calculation of the chemical bond has been emphasized by Patil and coworkers [36,15,56,37–39]. Their analysis is in the spirit of our previous discussion, however, yields more complicated trial wave functions. Here we briefly mention the main aspects of the construction scheme and, to be specific, consider the ground state of H2 molecule described by the Schrödinger equation (3.77).
132
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 8. Ground state potential curve E(R) of H2 for different trial wave functions. Triangles correspond to “Le Sech” molecular orbital calculation with exact H+ 2 one-electron orbitals. Our wave function (3.81) (solid line) gives the correct dissociation limit. Patil et al.’s results are shown as small dot (functions (3.93), (3.96), (3.97)) and dash (function (3.107)) lines. Large dots are “exact” values of [8].
Let us assume that r2 r1 , R, 1. Then r12 ≈ r2a ≈ r2b ≈ r2 and the Hamiltonian reads 2 = − 1 ∇12 − Z − Z + Z − 1 ∇22 − (2Z − 1) . H 2 r1a r1b R 2 r2
(3.89)
The first four terms in (3.89) yield the H+ 2 problem, while the last two terms correspond to motion of a particle in a Coulomb potential with an effective charge 2Z − 1. This Hamiltonian allows us to separate variables and write (r1 , r2 ) = H+ (r1 )ϕ(r2 ), where the function ϕ(r2 ) satisfies the equation 2 1 (2Z − 1) − ∇22 − (3.90) ϕ(r2 ) = −εϕ(r2 ), 2 r2 ε = EH+ − E > 0 is the ionization energy of the H2 molecule, and E is the 2 ground state energy of H2 . As a result, the asymptotic behavior of (r1 , r2 ) at r2 r1 , R, 1, is √ √ (2Z−1)/ 2ε−1 (r1 , r2 ) ≈ r2 (3.91) exp − 2εr2 H+ (r1 ), 2
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
133
which is similar to the coalescence wave function (3.39) for He. Now assume that r2 r1 R, 1, then H+ (r1 ) is given by Eq. (3.75) and, therefore, 2
√ 2Z/ 2ε1 −1 (2Z−1)/ 2ε−1 r2 exp − 2ε1 r1
(r1 , r2 ) ≈ r1
√
−
√ 2εr2 ,
(3.92)
where ε1 = Z 2 /R − EH+ > 0 is the separation energy of electron in H+ 2 . The 2 power-law factor slowly varies as compared to the exponential decaying contribution. Hence, one can assume the power-law factor to be a constant or approximate the combination r a exp(−br) as (r − r0 )a a r exp(−br) = exp(−br + a ln r) ≈ exp −br + a ln r0 + , r0 where r0 can be determined as a variational parameter or chosen to be r0 = R + 1/b [15]. To incorporate the cusp conditions and the large distance asymptotic the trial wave function is separated into two parts (r1 , r2 ) = (r1 , r2 )fP (r12 ),
(3.93)
where fP (r12 ) is the Patil et al. electron–electron correlation function given by Eq. (3.62). Roothaan and Weiss [57] have made a very accurate numerical investigation of the desired correlation function for the ground state of the He atom. In the vicinity of r12 = 0, the correlation function is linear and satisfies the cusp condition. It monotonically increases and approaches a constant as r12 becomes very large. Clearly the function fP (r12 ) satisfies these conditions (see Fig. 12). In the united atom limit (R = 0) it was found that the energies computed with the variationally determined λ are essentially the same as given by the analytical expression, 5 1 (3.94) Z− 12 3 derived from a theory in which 1/r12 is treated as a perturbation [36]. In a molecular system, as R increases, one should expect λ to decrease monotonically and become vanishingly small for R → ∞. The small and large R behavior is satisfied provided [33] λ=
λ=
5Z/6 − 1/3 . 1 + 10Z 3 R 2 /(15Z − 6)
(3.95)
The electron–nucleus cusp conditions do not uniquely define the space wave function (r1 , r2 ). If one wishes to maintain the electronic configuration idea with an independent particle picture, one can adopt the following form of (r1 , r2 ): (r1 , r2 ) = φ(r1 )φ(r2 ),
(3.96)
134
G. Chen et al.
with φ(rj ), j = 1, 2, being the Guillemin–Zener [53] trial wave function for H+ 2 φ(rj ) = exp(−z1 rj a − z2 rj b ) + exp(−z2 rj a − z1 rj b ),
(3.97)
where z1 > 0, z2 > 0 are variational parameters. Alternatively, z1 and z2 can be determined from the cusp conditions at rj a = 0 and rj b = 0 for j = 1, 2. The wave function (3.96), (3.97) is identical to (3.78) which are known not to give the correct dissociation limit of H2 . However, for the pedagogical reason we briefly discuss it here. As r1a approaches zero (r1 , r2 ) → φ(r2 ) (1 − z1 r1a ) exp(−z2 R) + (1 − z2 r1a ) exp(−z1 R) . (3.98) Imposing the cusp condition (r1 , r2 ) → G(r2 )(1−Zr1a ) we obtain an equation for z1 and z2 : z1 = Z + (Z − z2 ) exp −(z1 − z2 )R . (3.99) Thus, if z1 and z2 are related as in Eq. (3.99), then the electron–nucleus cusp conditions are automatically satisfied. The second equation for z1 and z2 can be determined by the asymptotic condition. For r2 r1 R, 1 Eqs. (3.96), (3.97) yield (r1 , r2 ) ≈ exp −(z1 + z2 )r1 − (z1 + z2 )r2 . (3.100) From the other hand, according to Eq. (3.92), the wave √ must have the √ function following exponential behavior (r1 , r2 ) ∼ exp(− 2ε1 r1 − 2εr2 ). The two parameters z1 and z2 do not allow to match the asymptotic exactly. However, one can approximately choose [33] Z2 (3.101) − E. R Equations (3.99), (3.101) determine z1 and z2 self-consistently together with the ground state energy E. Kleinekathöfer et al. [33] used the trial function (3.93), (3.96), (3.97) with λ, z1 and z2 determined from Eqs. (3.95), (3.99), (3.101). The wave function has no free parameters and yields 4.661 eV for the binding energy of the H2 molecule which is very close to the exact value of 4.745 eV. However, E(R) becomes less accurate at large R and fails to describe the dissociation limit. The corresponding E(R) is shown as a small dot line (Patil et al. 1) in Fig. 8. Both the cusp conditions and the large distance asymptotic can be satisfied exactly provided more sophisticated trial functions are introduced. For example, for small and intermediate R, Patil et al. [15] suggested to use a combination of “inner” and “outer” molecular orbitals which are build from the Guillemin–Zener z1 + z2 = ε1 + ε =
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS one-electron wave functions: m (r1 , r2 ) = φin (r1 )φout (r2 ) + φin (r2 )φout (r1 ) fP (r12 ),
135
(3.102)
where the “inner” orbital is φin (rj ) = exp(−z1 rj a − z2 rj b ) + exp(−z2 rj a − z1 rj b ).
(3.103)
Analogously, an “outer” orbital is defined as φout (rj ) = exp(−z3 rj a − z4 rj b ) + exp(−z4 rj a − z3 rj b ).
(3.104)
All the parameters z1 , z2 , z3 and z4 are determined by the cusp and asymptotic conditions. At large R, the atomic orbital wave function provides a better description of the two electron system. The appropriate wave function is [15] a (r1 , r2 ) = (r1 , r2 ) + (r2 , r1 ) fP (r12 ), (3.105) where
(r1 , r2 ) = exp −Z(r1a + r1b + r2a + r2b )
! × cosh(z5 r1b ) cosh(z6 r2a ) + cosh(z6 r1b ) cosh(z5 r2a ) . (3.106) Eq. (3.105) satisfies all the electron–nucleus cusp conditions. At the same time, it has two free parameters z5 and z6 which can be used to satisfy the two asymptotic conditions. For a description in the entire range of internuclear distances, one can use a linear combination of the two wave functions just discussed = m + Da ,
(3.107)
where D is a variational parameter. For H2 the molecular orbital m dominates in the region R < 1.7, while the atomic orbital a dominates at R > 1.7. With this complicated one parameter wave function Patil et al. [15] obtained 4.716 eV for the binding energy of H2 molecule and a very accurate potential curve in the entire range of R. The corresponding E(R) is shown as a dash line (Patil et al. 2) in Fig. 8. Similar wave functions which take full advantage of the asymptotic and proximal boundary conditions are useful in variational calculations of larger systems [38].
4. Analytical Wave Mechanical Solutions for One Electron Molecules From now on throughout the Sections 4, 5 and 6, unless otherwise noted, we assume the Born–Oppenheimer separation, where there are N nuclei, containing
136
G. Chen et al.
Zk protons located at R k , respectively, for k = 1, 2, . . . , N , and Ne electrons. Each electron’s coordinates are denoted as r j , j = 1, 2, . . . , Ne , where r j = (xj , yj , zj ). The steady-state equation, in atomic units, can be written as H ψ = Eψ, H =− +
e 1 ∇j2 + 2
N
j =1
1≤j
1≤j
e 1 Zk − rj k |r j − R k |
N
N
(4.1)
j =1 k=1
Zj Zk , |R j − R k |
where ψ = ψ(r 1 , r 2 , . . . , r Ne ), rj k ≡ |r j − r k |,
∇j2 ≡
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 + + , ∂xj2 ∂yj2 ∂zj2
j, k = 1, 2, . . . , Ne .
We wish to solve the eigenvalue problem (4.1). Closed-form solutions to (4.1) are hard to come by in general. What is known today is the following: (i) Ne = 1, N = 1: This is the case of hydrogen atom H (or H-like ions with a single nucleus and electron) whose solutions are known explicitly in closed form, to be briefly reviewed in Section 4.1. (ii) Ne = 1, N = 2: + This is the H+ 2 (or H2 -like) two-centered molecular ion, whose solutions are separable and expressible as an infinite series of products of special functions in prolate spheroidal coordinates, where coefficients of the series are not explicitly given. Such are the two renowned classic solutions due to Hylleraas and Jaffé, to be discussed in Section 4.2. (iii) Ne = 1, N ≥ 3: This one-electron multi-centered molecular ion has an analytic solution due to Shibuya and Wulfman [58] in terms of integral equations on the unit hypersphere of the 4-dimensional momentum space. This will be reviewed in Section 4.3. Except for Case (i) above, one must resort to numerical methods in order to derive quantitative and qualitative information, for all cases where Ne = 1, N = 1. Our particular interest in this paper is the diatomic case, with Ne = N = 2, using the orbitals in Cases (i) and (ii) above as the building blocks.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
137
4.1. T HE H YDROGEN ATOM When Ne = N = 1, with Z1 = 1 and R 1 = 0, Eq. (4.1) becomes 1 2 1 ψ(r) = Eψ(r), r ∈ R3 , − ∇ − 2 r
(4.2)
the Born–Oppenheimer separation of the hydrogen atom. We write (4.2) in spherical coordinates in view of the symmetry involved: 1 ∂2 1 2 (rψ) + 2 2 ψ + ψ − 2Eψ = 0, r ∂r 2 r r
(4.3)
where
1 ∂ ∂ ∂2 ≡ + sin θ sin θ ∂θ ∂θ sin2 θ ∂φ 2 r = the radial variable, 0 < r < ∞; 1
2
θ = the colatitude,
0 ≤ θ ≤ π;
φ = the azimuth,
0 ≤ φ ≤ 2π.
(the Legendrian); (4.4)
Equation (4.2) has separable solutions ψ(r) = ψ(r, θ, φ) = R(r)Y (θ, φ).
(4.5)
The angular variables are quantized first as we know that angular functions are the spherical harmonics Y (θ, φ) = Ym (θ, φ) = m (θ )m (φ), = 0, 1, 2, . . . , m = , − 1, . . . , −, on the unit sphere S2 ≡ {r ∈
R3
(4.6)
| |r| = 1}, satisfying
2 Ym (θ, φ) = −( + 1)Ym (θ, φ),
(4.7)
where in (4.6), m (φ) = (2π)−1/2 eimφ ,
(2 + 1)( − |m|)! 1/2 |m| m (θ ) = P (cos θ ) 2( + |m|)! |m|
(P
is the associated Legendre function).
Using (4.5)–(4.7) in (4.2), we obtain the equation for the radial function ( + 1) 2 1 R+ (rR) − − 2E R = 0. r r r2
(4.8)
(4.9)
(4.10)
138
G. Chen et al.
Solutions to the eigenvalue problem (4.10) that are square integrable over 0 < r < ∞ are known to be
(n − − 1)! −r (2r) L2+1 R(r) = Rn (r) = (−2) n+ (2r)e , 2n[(n + )!]3 (4.11) 1 1 En = − 2 , n = 1, 2, . . . , independent of , 2n where L2+1 n+ are the associated Laguerre functions such that for ν, α = 0, 1, 2, . . . α x Lν + (α + 1 − x) Lαν + νLαν = 0, ex x −α d ν −x ν+α e x Lαν (x) = ν! dx ν (when α = 0, L0ν (x) is simply denoted as Lν (x)). In the subsequent sections, we will utilize mainly the ground, or 1s state of the hydrogen atom, where n = 1, = 0, i.e., 1 (r) = √ e−r ; 2
cf. Fig. 10.
(4.12)
4.2. H+ 2 - LIKE M OLECULAR I ON IN P ROLATE S PHEROIDAL C OORDINATES We now consider the eigenvalue problem for two-centered H+ 2 -like molecular ion with one electron and two fixed nuclei with effective charges Za and Zb . Given R the internuclear separation distance, we want to find E and such that Za Zb Za Zb 1 2 + − = E. − ∇ − (4.13) 2 ra rb R In Appendix A we show how to separate the variables through the use of the ellipsoidal (or, prolate spheroidal) coordinates (see Fig. 9) R 2 R 2 λ − 1 1 − µ2 cos φ, y= λ − 1 1 − µ2 sin φ, x= 2 2 (4.14) R λµ. 2 In such coordinates the wave function can be written as z=
= (λ)M(µ)eimφ . Separation of variables yields
d d 2 m2 λ −1 + A + 2R1 λ − p 2 λ2 − 2 = 0, dλ dλ λ −1
(4.15)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
(a)
139
(b)
F IG . 9. (a) Elliptical coordinates (λ, µ). (b) Prolate spheroidal coordinates (λ, µ, φ) with λ = (ra + rb )/R and µ = (ra − rb )/R. The range of coordinates is 1 ≤ λ ≤ ∞, −1 ≤ µ ≤ 1 and 0 ≤ φ ≤ 2π .
R(Za + Zb ) R1 ≡ (4.16) , λ ≥ 1; 2
dM d m2 1 − µ2 + −A − 2R2 µ + p 2 µ2 − M = 0, dµ dµ 1 − µ2 R(Za − Zb ) R2 ≡ (4.17) , |µ| ≤ 1. 2 Note that A and p are unknown and must be solved from (4.16) and (4.17) as eigenvalues of the coupled system. Once A and p are solved, then E can be obtained from (A.8). In the next two subsections, we address the issues of solving (4.16) and (4.17), respectively. 4.2.1. Solution of the -Equation (4.16) To solve (4.16), it is important to understand the asymptotics of the solution. Rewrite (4.16) as 2 m2 2 2 λ − 1 (λ) + 2λ (λ) + A + 2R1 λ − p λ − 2 (λ) = 0. λ −1 (4.18) First, consider the case λ 1; we have 2 m2 2λ A + 2R1 λ 2 λ (λ) + −p 2 − (λ) 0 = (λ) + 2 λ −1 λ2 − 1 λ − 1 (λ2 − 1)2 ≈ (λ) − p 2 (λ),
for λ 1.
(4.19)
140
G. Chen et al.
This gives (λ) ≈ a1 e−pλ + a2 epλ ,
for λ 1, where p > 0.
(4.20)
But the term a2 epλ has exponential growth for large λ, which is physically inadmissible and must be discarded. Thus (λ) ≈ a1 e−pλ ,
for λ 1.
(4.21)
A finer estimate than (4.21) can be stated as follows (λ) = a0 e−pλ λβ
∞ cj λj
(λ 1),
(4.22)
j =0
where β ≡ R1 /p − 1, c0 = 1, c1 = (p 2 − β 2 − 2β)/(2R1 − 2pβ − p), and a0 is an arbitrary constant. Proof is given in Appendix B. Next, we consider the case λ > 1 but λ ≈ 1. In such a limit we have (see Appendix C) (λ) ≈ (λ − 1)|m|/2
∞
ck (λ − 1)k .
(4.23)
k=0
Our results in (4.21) and (4.23) suggest that the form (λ) = e−pλ (λ − 1)|m|/2 λβ f (λ),
for some function f (λ),
(4.24)
would contain the right asymptotics for both λ 1 and λ ≈ 1. Here, obviously, f (λ) must satisfy
f (1) = 0, lim f (λ) ≤ C, for some constant C > 0. (4.25) λ→∞
Actually, in the literature [59–61], two improved or variant forms of the substitution of (4.24) are found to be most useful: (i) (Jaffé’s solution [60]) ∞ |m|/2 λ−1 n (λ) = e−pλ λ2 − 1 (λ + 1)σ gn , λ+1 n=0
σ ≡
R1 − |m| − 1. p
(4.26)
This leads to a 3-term recurrence relation αn gn−1 − βn gn + γn gn+1 = 0, where
n = 0, 1, 2, . . . ;
g−1 ≡ 0,
(4.27)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
141
αn = (n − 1 − σ )(n − 1 − σ − m), βn = 2n2 + (4p − 2σ )n − A + p 2 − 2pσ − (m + 1)(m + σ ),
(4.28)
γn = (n + 1)(n + m + 1), and, consequently, the continued fraction β0 α1 = γ1 α2 γ0 β1 − α3 β2 − βγ32−···
(4.29)
for A and p. (ii) (Hylleraas’ solution [29]) (λ) = e−p(λ−1) (λ2 − 1)|m|/2
∞ n=0
cn Lm (x), (m + n)! m+n
x ≡ 2p(λ − 1),
(4.30) where Lm is the associated Laguerre polynomial and c satisfy the 3-term ren m+n currence relation αn cn−1 − βn cn + γn cn+1 = 0,
n = 0, 1, 2, . . . ;
c−1 ≡ 0,
(4.31)
where αn = (n − m)(n − m − 1 − σ ), βn = 2(n − m)2 + 2(n − m)(2p − σ ) − A − p 2 + 2pσ + (m + 1)(m + σ ) ,
(4.32)
γn = (n + 1)(n − 2m − σ ), and the same form of continued fractions (4.29). 4.2.2. Solution of the M-Equation (4.17) Equation (4.17) has close resemblance in form with (4.16) and, thus, it can almost be expected that the way to solve (4.16) will be similar to that of (4.16). First, we make the following substitution M(µ) = e±pµ M(µ),
−1 ≤ µ ≤ 1,
in order to eliminate the p2 µ2 term in (4.17). We obtain ± 2p 1 − µ2 M 1 − µ2 M 2 m2 = 0. + (−2R2 ∓ 2p)µ + p − A − M 1 − µ2
(4.33)
(4.34)
142
G. Chen et al.
To simplify notation, let us just consider the case M(µ) = e−pµ M(µ), but note pµ that for M = e M(µ), we need only make the changes of p → −p in (4.37) below. Write M(µ) = e−pµ
∞
m fk Pm+k (µ),
(4.35)
k=0
Pnm (µ)
where are the associated Legendre polynomials, and substitute (4.35) into (4.17). We obtain a 3-term recurrence relation αn fn−1 − βn fn + γn fn+1 = 0,
n = 0, 1, 2, . . . ;
f−1 ≡ 0,
(4.36)
where αn =
1 −2nR2 + 2pn(m + n) , 2(m + n) − 1
βn = A − p 2 + (m + n)(m + n + 1), ! 2m + n + 1 γn = −2R2 − 2p(m + n + 1) , 2(m + n) + 3
(4.37)
and, consequently, again the continued fractions of the same form as (4.29). The continued fractions obtained here should be coupled with the continued fraction (4.29) for the variable µ to solve A and p. In the homonuclear case, R2 = R(Za − Zb )/2 = 0, Eq. (4.17) reduces to m2 2 2 2 1 − µ M + −A + p µ − M = 0. 1 − µ2 In this case, several different optional representations of M can be used: (a)
∞ |m|/2 M(µ) = 1 − µ2 ck µ2k , k=0 ∞ 2 |m|/2 M(µ) = 1 − µ ck µ2k+1 ;
(4.38)
k=0
(b)
∞ |m|/2 m M(µ) = 1 − µ2 ck Pm+2k (µ),
|m|/2 M(µ) = 1 − µ2
k=0 ∞
(4.39) m ck Pm+2k+1 (µ);
k=0
(c)
∞ |m|/2 ck (1 ∓ µ)k . M(µ) = e±pµ 1 − µ2 k=0
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
143
In Appendix D we discuss expansions of solution near λ ≈ 1 and λ 1 and their connection with the James–Coolidge trial wave functions. As a conclusion of this section, we note that the eigenstates of the hydrogen atom given in the preceding subsection can also be easily represented in terms of the prolate spheroidal coordinates. We let the nucleus of H (i.e., a proton) sit at location a where (0, 0, −R/2) with Za = 1 while at location b where (0, 0, R/2) we let Zb = 0. Thus, the hydrogen atom satisfies Eq. (4.13) in the form 1 2 1 Hψ = − ∇ − (4.40) ψ = Eψ. 2 ra Now, in terms of the prolate spheroidal coordinates (A.3) in Appendix A, and ψ(λ, µ, φ) = (λ)M(µ)(φ),
where (φ) = eimφ
(4.41)
in the form of separated variables, we have ∂ 1 ∂ 4 ∂ 2 2 ∂ − λ −1 M+ 1−µ M 2 R 2 (λ2 − µ2 ) ∂λ ∂λ ∂µ ∂µ
2 1 (λ2 − µ2 )m2 M − M = EM, − 2 2 Rλ−µ (λ − 1)(1 − µ ) which has two fewer terms than (A.6) does as now Zb = 0. Set p 2 = −R 2 E/2, we again have (4.16) and (4.17) except that now R1 = R2 = R/2 therein. The rest of the procedures follows in the same way with some minor adjustments as noted above. The above discussion also leads to a sequence of identities between (4.6) and (4.41), as R ψ (1) (x, y, z) = ψ (2) x, y, z + , 2 where ψ (1) (x, y, z) is an eigenstate of the hydrogen atom obtained from (4.2) but expressed in terms of the Cartesian coordinates (x, y, z) while ψ (2) (x, y, z) is that for the solution of (4.40).
4.3. T HE M ANY-C ENTERED , O NE -E LECTRON P ROBLEM When Ne = 1 and N ≥ 3 in (4.1), we have a molecular ion with three or more nuclei sharing one electron. A simple example is a CO2 -like structure, with N = 3. For such a problem, separable closed-form solutions are extremely difficult to come by from the traditional line of attack. However, we want to describe an elegant analysis by Shibuya and Wulfman [58] (see also the book by Judd [62]) which works in momentum space and expand electron’s eigenfunction as a linear combination of 4-dimensional spherical harmonics. This analysis may offer
144
G. Chen et al.
useful help to the modelling and computation of complex molecules after proper numerical realization. The model equation reads N 1 2 Zj − ∇ − ψ(r) = Eψ(r), r = (x, y, z) ∈ R3 , (4.42) 2 |r − R j | j =1
where Rj are positions of the nuclei. Appendix E shows how to reduce the problem to a matrix form. Here we provide the answer for the energy; it is determined from the solution of the eigenvalue equation √ P c = −2Ec, (4.43) where c is an infinite-dimensional vector, P is an infinite matrix with entries ∗ 1 nm Pnnm Snnmm (Rj ) Zj S (Rj ), m = n nm j
n m
n, n , n = 1, 2, 3, . . . ; , , = 0, 1, 2, . . . ; m, m , m = −, − + 1, . . . , −1, 0, 1, . . . , − 1, ;
(4.44)
the matrix S is given by an integral over 4-dimensional unit hypersphere S3 with the surface element d = sin2 χ sin θdχdθdφ, nm Sn m (Rj ) = exp(iRj · p)Ynm ()Yn m () d, (4.45) S3
Ynm () is a product of the spherical function Ym (θ, φ) and the associated Gegenbauer function Cn (χ) Ynm () = (−i) Cn (χ)Ym (θ, φ). The 3-dimensional vector p in Eq. (4.45) has components px = p sin θ cos φ, py = p sin θ sin φ, √ where p = −2E tan(χ/2).
pz = p cos θ,
In practice, the infinite matrix P in (4.44) is truncated to a finite size square matrix according to the quantum numbers (nm) for which the restriction n ≤ n0 is specified for some positive integer n0 . In the derivation, if we restrict N = 1, Z1 = 1 and set R 1 = 0, then the matrix P is diagonal and we recover the hydrogen atom as derived in Section 4.1. Obviously, if N = 2, by setting R 1 = (0, 0, −R/2) and R 2 = (0, 0, R/2), we should also be able to recover those H+ 2 -like solutions given in Section 4.2.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
145
The 1-electron one-centered or two-centered orbitals derived in Section 4.1 and 4.2 will be utilized frequently in the rest of the paper. At the present time, there is very limited knowledge about the 1-electron many-centered orbitals as discussed in Section 4.3 There seems to be abundant space for their exploitation in molecular modelling and computation in the future.
5. Two Electron Molecules: Cusp Conditions and Correlation Functions 5.1. T HE C USP C ONDITIONS In the study of any linear partial differential equations with singular coefficients, it is well known to the theorists that solutions will have important peculiar behavior at and near the locations of the singularities. We have first encountered such singularities in Section 3.3.1. Here we give singularities of the Coulomb type a more systematic treatment. The critical mathematical analysis was first made by Kato [63] in the form of cusp conditions for the Born–Oppenheimer separation. Consider the following slightly more general form of the Schrödinger equation for a 2-particle system − E ψ = 0, H (5.1) where = − 1 ∇12 − 1 ∇22 − Za − Zb − Za − Zb + q1 q2 + Za Zb . H 2m1 2m2 r1a r1b r2a r2b r12 R (5.2) The operator H has five sets of singularities, at r1a = 0,
r1b = 0,
r2a = 0,
r2b = 0
and r12 = 0.
(5.3)
It has been proved by Kato [63] that the wave function ψ is Hölder continuous, with bounded first order partial derivatives. However, these first order partial derivatives ∂ψ/∂xi , etc., i = 1, 2, . . . , 6, are discontinuous at (5.3). In the terminology of the mathematical theory of partial differential equations, (5.2) is said to have a nontrivial solution in the Sobolev space H 1 (R6 ). We now discuss the cusp conditions at these singularities. What is a cusp condition? It can be simply explained in the following paragraph. Let us elucidate it for the two particle Hamiltonian (5.2); for a multi-particle Hamiltonian the idea is the same. In order for the wave function ψ to satisfy the eigenvalue problem (5.1) at the singularities (5.3), the kinetic energy operators −∇12 /2m1 and −∇22 /2m2 , after acting on ψ, must produce terms that exactly cancel those singularity terms
146
G. Chen et al.
in the potential in order to give us back just a constant E times ψ, because the wave function ψ is bounded everywhere in space, including the points where the nuclei are located, without exception. One can see that, if the cusp conditions are not satisfied, then there is some unboundedness at the singularities (5.3) which can affect the accuracy in numerical computations. Conversely, if the cusp conditions are satisfied, this normally improves the numerical accuracy. In case we don’t know the exact eigenstate, but only a certain trial wave func − E)φ = 0 will not be satisfied, in general. Rather, we have tion, say φ, then (H − E φ(r 1 , r 2 ) = f (r 1 , r 2 ) H for some function f depending on the spatial variables r 1 and r 2 . However, we can insist on choosing parameters in φ such that the residual f (r 1 , r 2 ) is a bounded function everywhere; in particular, f (r 1 , r 2 ) cannot contain any singularity at (5.3). We say that the trial wave function φ satisfies (i) the electron–nucleus cusp condition at a (resp. b) if f is not singular at a (resp. b); (ii) the interelectronic (or electron–electron) cusp condition if f is not singular when r12 = 0. For example, in the simple case of a hydrogen atom, = − 1 ∇2 − 1 , H 2 r let φ(r) = Ce−αr be a trial wave function. Then for any E,
(α − 1)e−αr α 2 −αr H −E φ =C − E+ e . r 2 The singularity 1/r can be eliminated only by choosing α = 1. This is the cusp condition, which actually forces φ to be the ground state (with E = −1/2). The profile of φ, as shown in Fig. 10 illustrates the appearance of a cusp at the origin. In Appendix F we derive the cusp conditions for the two particle electron wave function ψ of (5.1):
∂ψ
∂ψ
= −m1 Za ψ(r1a = 0), = −m1 Zb ψ(r1b = 0), ∂r1a r1a =0 ∂r1b r1b =0 (5.4)
∂ψ
∂ψ
= −m2 Za ψ(r2a = 0), = −m2 Zb ψ(r2b = 0), ∂r ∂r 2a r2a =0
∂ψ
m1 m2 = q1 q2 ψ(r12 = 0).
∂r12 r12 =0 m1 + m2
2b r2b =0
(5.5) (5.6)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
147
F IG . 10. A 1-dimensional cross section of φ(r) = e−r showing a cusp.
Equations (5.4), (5.5) are the electron–nucleus cusp condition, while Eq. (5.6) is the interelectronic condition. In forming trial wave functions from one-centered or two-centered orbitals for a homonuclear diatomic molecule a commonly used wave function is 1 f (r12 ) = 1 + r12 (cf. (1.17)) (5.7) 2 where φ(r i ), i = 1, 2, is an orbital for the molecular ion. In Appendix F we show that (5.7) satisfies the interelectronic cusp condition. If, however, φ1 = φ2 , then the trial wave function 1 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = φ1 (r 1 )φ2 (r 2 ) 1 + r12 2 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = φ(r 1 )φ(r 2 )f (r12 ),
satisfies the interelectronic cusp condition if and only if φ2 (r)∇φ1 (r) − φ1 (r)∇φ2 (r) = 0. The actual verifications of cusp conditions for specifically given examples of trial wave functions in the cases of one-centered orbitals or their products are not difficult. But such work is nontrivial when the trial wave functions are expressed in terms of prolate spheroidal coordinates. In Appendix H we illustrate through concrete examples how to carry out this task.
5.2. VARIOUS F ORMS OF THE C ORRELATION F UNCTION f (r12 ) We have learned the importance of the interelectronic cusp condition in Section 5.1. But there are, in addition, three important constructs that are crucial for diatomic calculations: orbitals, configurations and electronic correlation. In
148
G. Chen et al.
this section, we compile a list of often cited correlation functions f which help the satisfaction of the interelectronic cusp conditions in the context of Eq. (5.6). The study of the other two, i.e., orbitals and configurations, will be addressed in the next section. 5.2.1. f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 This is the simplest possible interelectronic configuration function. The specific form is due to the correlation cusp condition only. We derive it as follows (see Patil et al. [15]). Consider two charged particles which are described by the Schrödinger equation 1 2 1 2 q1 q2 − (5.8) ∇ − ∇ + ψ = ψ. 2m1 1 2m2 2 r12 First, transform the above equation to the center-of-mass coordinates (cf. Appendix G) 1 2 q1 q2 1 2 − (5.9) ∇ − ∇ + ψ = ψ, 2M S 2µ r12 r12 where M = m1 + m2 , m1 r 1 + m2 r 2 , S= m1 + m2
µ=
m1 m2 , m1 + m2
(5.10)
r 12 = r 1 − r 2 .
In the ground state ψ is independent of S. Near the singularity point r12 = 0, the wave function ψ has a local representation as a power series 2 ψ = C0 + C1 r12 + O r12 (5.11) . ∂ ∂ Substituting (5.11) into (5.9) and using ∇r2 = r12 ∂r (r 2 ∂r ) we obtain C1 3C2 1 + q1 q 2 C 0 + − + C1 q 1 q 2 + · · · − r12 µ µ 2 = C0 + C1 r12 + O r12 .
The above mandates that the coefficient of 1/r12 must vanish, that is C1 = µq1 q2 C0 , which for µ = 1/2 (i.e., m1 = m2 ), and q1 = q2 = 1, yields C1 =
1 C0 . 2
(5.12)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS This gives us the small r12 behavior 1 ψ = C0 1 + r12 , 2
149
(5.13)
2 ) terms. The asymptotic expression (5.13) where we have dropped all the O(r12 motivates the choice of f (r12 ) in such particular form. This simple f (r12 ) captures short distance interelectronic interaction very well. It offers elegant representations of molecular orbitals and great facility to computation. Nevertheless, its asymptotic behavior of linear growth for large r12 is not physically correct. When we write molecular orbitals as
ψ(r 1 , r 2 , r12 ) = φ(r 1 , r 2 )f (r12 ), if the function φ(r 1 , r 2 ) is already quite small in the region where r12 becomes large compared to 1, then this simple f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 can work quite well (Kleinekathöfer et al. [36, pp. 2841–2842]). 5.2.2. f (r12 ) = 1 +
r12 −r12 /d 2 e
(d > 0)
This function was proposed by Hirschfelder [64] where d is a variational parameter. Its profiles is shown in Fig. 11. It satisfies the cusp condition near r12 = 0. This function was used by Siebbles et al. [65]. Nevertheless, Le Sech et al. [65,7] reported that in performing variational calculations by writing f (r12 ) = 1 + r212 e−αr12 , they found that α is computed to be very close to 0 for small and intermediate R. That is, it virtually degenerates into f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 .
F IG . 11. Graph of f (r12 ) = 1 + (r12 /2)e−r12 /d , where the maximum happens at r12 = d.
150
G. Chen et al.
However, at large R one should use α = 0 in order to obtain the correct dissociation limit. From physical considerations, there is no reason to believe why f (r12 ) should have a local maximum as shown in Fig. 11. Even though the choice of this f (r12 ) seems satisfactory asymptotically for both r12 small and large, it may not be satisfactory for medium values of r12 . 5.2.3. f (r12 ) = 1 −
1 −λr12 1+2λ e
(λ > 0)
This correlation function is partly motivated by Hirschfelder’s work [64], and partly by Hylleraas study of the helium atom [29]. It was introduced by Kleinekathöfer et al. [36]. At small r12 we have the expansion f (r12 ) =
2λ λ 2 1 ± ··· . 1 + r12 − r12 1 + 2λ 2 4
Therefore the cusp condition is satisfied for any λ > 0. This λ can be either used as a variational parameter, or be determined from a given Hamiltonian. For example, for a helium-like 2-electron atom with nuclear charge Z, using a perturbation argument, Kleinekathöfer et al. [36] analyzed that the best value for λ is λ=
5 1 Z− . 12 3
This f (r12 ) has a monotone profile and correct asymptotics for both r12 small and large. See Fig. 12.
F IG . 12. Graph of f (r12 ) = 1 − 1/(1 + 2λ)e−λr12 .
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
151
5.2.4. f (r12 ) = e(1/2)r12 This f (r12 ) satisfies the correlation-wave equation 1 2 1 2 1 1 − ∇1 − ∇2 + e(1/2)r12 = − e(1/2)r12 2 2 r12 4 with a negative energy −1/4. For small r12 , its expansion is 2 1 . e(1/2)r12 = 1 + r12 + O r12 2 Therefore, it satisfies the correlation-cusp condition and its asymptotics for small r12 is good. However, this f (r12 ) has exponential growth for large r12 and is thus physically incorrect. 5.2.5. f (r, r12 ) =
sinh(tr) tr
·
F0 (1/(2k),kr12 ) r12
Where Fj (η, ρ) is the Coulomb wave function regular at the origin, j is an integer, t, k are separation of variables constants and r = |r1 + r2 |. This is perhaps the most complex form of the correlation function in the literature, given by Aubert-Frécon and Le Sech [13]. It comes from solving
1 2 1 2 1 − ∇1 − ∇2 + (5.14) f = f. 2 2 r12 Rewrite the above in center-of-mass coordinates: 1 1 f = f. − ∇S2 − ∇r212 + 4 r12
(5.15)
Assume that f depends only on r, r12 and γ , where γ is the angle between S and r 12 (see Fig. 13).
F IG . 13. The variables r, r12 and angle γ in the center-of-mass coordinates.
152
G. Chen et al.
Then Eq. (5.15) can be written as ∂ 1 ∂ ∂f 1 ∂ 1 ∂ 2 ∂f − 2 r2 − 2 1 − q2 f r12 − 2 ∂r12 ∂r ∂q r ∂r r12 ∂r12 r12 ∂q ∂f 1 1 ∂ f = f, q ≡ cos γ . 1 − q2 + − 2 (5.16) ∂q r12 r ∂q Equation (5.16) can be separated by writing f = Pj (q)g j (r)uj (r12 ), where ∂Pj ∂ 1 − q2 = −j (j + 1)Pj , ∂q ∂q
(5.17)
Pj is the Legendre polynomial of degree j and g j (r) and uj (r12 ) satisfy, respectively, 2
d 2 d j (j + 1) (5.18) + + g g j (r) = 0, − r dr dr 2 r2
2 2 d j (j + 1) 1 d + − − + uj (r12 ) = 0, (5.19) u 2 2 r12 dr12 r12 dr12 r12 with = g + u . Take g = −t 2 ,
u = k 2 ,
j = 0.
(5.20)
Then P0 (q) = 1,
gt0 (r) =
sinh(tr) , tr
u0k =
F0 (1/(2k), kr12 ) , r12
where the function F0 (η, ρ) belongs to the class of regular Coulomb wave function FL (η, ρ), satisfying d2 2η L(L + 1) FL (η, ρ) + 1 − − FL (η, ρ) = 0 ρ dρ 2 ρ2 for the two parameters η and L. Note that t and k in (5.20) can be used as variational parameters. For small r12 , 1 1 2 , kr12 = C · kr12 1 + r12 + O (kr12 ) F0 2k 2
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS and, thus, u0k (r12 )
153
F0 (1/(2k), kr12 ) 1 2 = = C · k 1 + r12 + O (kr12 ) r12 2
satisfies the correlation-cusp condition for any given k. For large r12 , the Coulomb wave function FL (η, ρ) has an asymptotic expansion FL = g cos θL + f sin θL , π θL ≡ ρ − η ln zρ − L + σL , 2 σL ≡ arg (L + 1 + iη), ∞ ∞ f ∼ fk , g∼ gk , k=0
f0 = 1,
k=0
g0 = 1,
fk+1 = ak fk − bk gk , (2k + 1)η , ak = (2k + 2)ρ
gk+1 = ak gk + bk fk , L(L + 1) − k(k + 1) + η2 bk = . (2k + 2)ρ
Thus lim u0 (r12 ) r12 →∞ k
= lim
r12 →∞
F0 (1/(2k), kr12 ) = 0. r12
1 , 2, −2Zr12 5.2.6. f (r12 ) = 1F1 − 2Z Here 1F1 (a; b; x) is the confluent hypergeometric function satisfying the differential equation dw d 2w + (b − x) − aw = 0. (5.21) dx dx 2 This f (r12 ) was given by Patil et al. [15] for the case when the internuclear separation R is large: x
3 . Z Its derivation can be motivated as follows. Consider Z Z Z Z Z2 1 1 2 1 2 + + + + + H = − ∇1 − ∇2 − 2 2 r1a r1b r2a r2b r12 R R
(5.22)
(5.23)
for an H2 -like molecule. Guillemin–Zener-type one-electron wave functions [53] suggest the molecular orbital for large R: = e−Zr1a −Zr2b + e−Zr1b −Zr2a f (r12 ). (5.24)
154
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 14. For large R, electron e1 is localized near A, and electron e2 is localized near B.
When R is large, electron 1 is localized around A and electron 2 is localized around B, as shown in Fig. 14. We have r1b r1a ,
r2a r2b .
(5.25)
Because of (5.25), we have, from (5.24), = e−Zr1a −Zr2b + e−Zr1b −Zr2a f (r12 ) ≈ e−Zr1a −Zr2b f (r12 ).
(5.26)
ψ = Eψ, we obtain Substituting (5.26) into H
1 2 1 1 2 − ∇1 + ∇2 f + Z(∇1 f ) · (ˆr 1a + rˆ 2b ) + f =O . 2 r12 R
(5.27)
Note that Eq. (5.27) contains the effect of cross terms. For large R, the electron– electron correlation is most significant when the two electrons are collinear and in between the two nuclei. In this situation, either r12 is antiparallel to r 1 − r a , or r12 is parallel to r 2 − r b . Now, using the center-of-mass coordinates and dropping all the O(1/R) terms, we obtain 2 ∂ 2 ∂ ∂f 1 − (5.28) + f − 2Z = 0. f+ 2 r ∂r r ∂r ∂r12 12 12 12 12 The solution to (5.28), after setting it into the form of (5.21) is 1 f (r12 ) = 1F1 − , 2, −2Zr12 . 2Z For small r12 , the expansion is 1 (2Z − 1) 2 r12 + · · · . f (r12 ) = 1 + r12 − 2 12
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
155
Therefore, the correlation-cusp condition is satisfied. For large r12 , the asymptotics is f (r12 ) ∼ C(−2Zr12 )1/(2Z) (cf. [66, p. 508, 13.5.1]).
6. Modelling of Diatomic Molecules In this section, we give a survey of major existing methods for the numerical modelling of diatomic molecules. These methods provide approximations of wave functions either in explicit form through properly selected ansatzs, or in implicit form through iterations as numerical solutions of integro-partial differential equations. The methods and ansatzs to be described below are (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
The Heitler–London method; The Hund–Mulliken method; The Hartree–Fock (self-consistent) method; The James–Coolidge wave function; Two-centered orbitals.
Items (1)–(3) above historically are associated with one-centered orbitals, while (4), (5) are based on two-centered orbitals. But this dichotomy is not inflexible. An example is a hybrid type containing both one-centered and two-centered orbitals considered in Section 3.3.6. We now discuss them in sequential order below. Each approach has a set of modelling parameters which can be optimized through calculus of variations. In particular, we will point out what these parameters are.
6.1. T HE H EITLER –L ONDON M ETHOD This method has the longest history. It was developed by Heitler and London during the 1920s soon after Heisenberg laid the quantum mechanical foundation of ferromagnetism. The method is usually called the valence-bond (or atomic orbital) method. In this method, each molecule is thought of as composed of atoms, and the electronic structure is described using atomic orbitals of these atoms. Here we present a version of refined Heitler–London approach due to Slater [67]. In the method, electron spin-orbitals are taken from a determinant
156
G. Chen et al. Table IV Spin-orbital wave functions of singlet and triplet states. Ms (total spin)
Spin-orbital wave functions Singlet state
[a(1)b(2) + b(1)a(2)][α(1)β(2) − β(1)α(2)]
0
Triplet states
[a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2)][α(1)α(2)] [a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2)][α(1)β(2) + β(1)α(2)] [a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2)][β(1)β(2)]
1 0 −1
u1 (1)
u2 (1)
.
.
.
un (1)
u1 (2) u2 (2) .. .
... ... .. .
un (2) . . .
u1 (n)
u2 (n) ..
, .
un (n)
(6.1)
which satisfy the Fermionic property of the Pauli exclusion principle. The orbitals in (6.1) are called the Slater orbitals. Let us consider the 2-electron case, i.e., n = 2 in (6.1). The spin-orbital ui (j ), i, j = 1, 2, consists of (i) the electron-atomic orbital part α 3 −αr1a α 3 −αr2a , a(2) = , e e a(1) = π π α 3 −αr1b α 3 −αr2b b(1) = , b(2) = , e e π π
(6.2)
(6.3)
where in (6.2) and (6.3), the atomic electron wave functions are centered at, respectively, a and b; (ii) the spin part spin α(1), α(2), α(j ) = |s, ms ↑,
for j = 1, 2,
spin β(1), β(2), β(j ) = |s, ms ↓,
for j = 1, 2.
(6.4)
The linear combinations of the total spin-orbital wave function that are antisymmetric are tabulated in Table IV. The singlet state has lower energy than the triplets. For example, if we aim to calculate the ground state of H2 , we use Table IV as the trial wave function to minimize the total energy , subject to | = 1, H (6.5) where = − 1 ∇12 − 1 ∇22 − 1 − 1 − 1 − 1 + 1 + 1 , H 2 2 r1a r r2a r2b r12 R 1b = N a(1)b(2) + b(1)a(2) , N = a normalization factor.
(6.6) (6.7)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
157
in (6.6) can Heisenberg, and Heitler–London’s basic point of view is that H be written as = − 1 ∇12 − 1 + − 1 ∇22 − 1 H 2 r1a 2 r2b 1 1 1 1 + − − + + , r1b r2a r12 R where the terms inside the third pair of parentheses above can be viewed as a “perturbation”. Since the Heitler–London method is quite fundamental in molecular chemistry, let us give some details about the calculation of (6.5) given (6.6) and (6.7). Define
S ≡ the overlap ≡ a(1) b(1) α3 = e−αr1a e−αr1b dx · (dx = dx1 dx2 dx3 ) π R3
(αR)2 = e−αR 1 + αR + . 3 Then a(1)b(2)|a(2)b(1) = a(1)|b(1)b(2)|a(2) = S 2 , and the normalized state for the singlet or the triplets, without spin, is =
a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) , 2(1 ± S 2 )
such that | = 1.
The total energy of the singlet and triplet states can now be written as E± =
1 1 1 a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) − ∇12 − ∇22 2 2 2 2(1 ± S ) 1 1 1 1 1 1
− − − − + + a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) . (6.8) r1a r1b r2a r2b r12 R
The integrals involved are given in Appendix I. Using these integrals, we are able to write down the total energy E = KE + P E as follows: KE± = kinetic energy
1 1 = a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) − ∇12 2 2 2(1 ± S ) 1 2
− ∇2 a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) 2 α2 = 1 ∓ 2KS ∓ S 2 ; 1 ± S2
158
G. Chen et al.
P E± = potential energy
1 1 1 = − a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) − 2 r1a r1b 2(1 ± S ) 1 1 1 1
− − + + a(1)b(2) ± a(2)b(1) r2a r2b r12 R α α = −2 + 2J + J ± 4KS ± K + , 2 w (1 ± S ) where w = αR, the other symbols are defined in Appendix I. The parameter α can be used as the variational parameter to minimize (6.5) [68]. Consider the special case when α = 1. Then E± = −1 + where
H0 = R6
H0 ± H1 , (1 ± S 2 )
1 1 1 1 a 2 (1)b2 (1) − − + + dx dy r1b r2a r12 R
1 R is the Coulomb integral, and 1 1 1 1 H1 = a(1)b(1)a(2)b(2) − − + + dx dy r1b r1a r12 R = 2J + J +
R6
S2 R is the exchange integral. According to numerical values computed in Slater [67, Table 3.2], e.g., it is known that H1 is usually many times larger than H0 , and is largely responsible for the attraction between atoms in forming a molecule. In Fig. 15 we plot the ground 1 g+ and first excited 3 u+ state potential energy curves E(R) of the H2 molecule. When α = 1 the ground state curve yields the binding energy of 0.116 a.u. = 3.16 eV; the value must be compared with 4.748 eV obtained by Kolos and Roothaan [8]. When α (effective charge) is treated as a variational parameter [69] the calculation yields the binding energy of 0.139 a.u. = 3.78 eV and the bond length of 1.41 Bohr radii. For the 3 u+ state the effective charge and the α = 1 curves are practically indistinguishable. = 2KS + K +
6.2. T HE H UND –M ULLIKEN M ETHOD In 1927, Robert Mulliken worked with Friedrich Hund and developed the Hund– Mulliken molecular orbital theory in which electrons are assigned to states over
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
159
F IG . 15. Ground and first excited state energy E(R) of H2 molecule for the Heitler–London wave function (solid lines) and the “exact” energy of [8] (dots).
an entire molecule. Hund–Mulliken’s molecular orbital method was more flexible and applicable than the traditional Valence-Bond theory that had previously prevailed. Because of this, Mulliken received the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1966. The approach has some similarity to the Heitler–London’s, so we can inherit the notation from there. Its special feature is that a linear combination of the molecular gerade (g) and ungerade (u) states are used: 1 + g : 1 − g :
g+g− u+ u−
u : g + u− − g − u+
1
3 + u : g + u+
u : g + u− + g − u+
3
3 − u :
g − u−
a(1) + b(1) a(2) + b(2) ↑1 ↓2 − ↓1 ↑2 , √ √ √ 2(1 + S) 2(1 + S) 2 a(1) − b(1) a(2) − b(2) ↑1 ↓2 − ↓1 ↑2 , √ √ √ 2(1 − S) 2(1 − S) 2 a(1)a(2) − b(1)b(2) ↑1 ↓2 − ↓1 ↑2 , √ 2 2(1 − S 2 )
(6.9) a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2) ↑1 ↑2 (Ms = 1), 2(1 − S 2 ) a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2) ↑1 ↓2 + ↓1 ↑2 (Ms = 0), √ 2 2(1 − S 2 ) a(1)b(2) − b(1)a(2) ↓1 ↓2 2(1 − S 2 )
(Ms = −1),
160
G. Chen et al.
with
α 3 −αria a(i) = , e π a(i) + b(i) g: √ 2(1 + S)
α 3 −αrib , e π a(i) − b(i) , √ 2(1 − S)
b(i) =
i = 1, 2,
u:
i = 1, 2.
Especially, note that the first three states in (6.9), i.e., 1 g+ , 1 g− and 1 g− signify the possibility of double occupancy of the two electrons at a single nucleus as products of a(1)a(2) and b(1)b(2) appear in the wave functions. Such states, chemically, represent ionic bonds. On the other hand, the last three states in (6.9) i.e., 3 u+ , 3 u0 , 3 u− , agree with the triplet states in Table IV. We denote the six molecular orbitals in (6.9) in sequential order as 1 , 2 , . . . , 6 . Then the energy of any linear combination 6j =1 cj j corresponds to a quadratic form:
6 6 6
cj j H ck k = Hj k c¯j ck ,
j =1
k=1
j,k=1
where Hj k are the (j, k)-entry of the following symmetric matrix H11 H12 H12 H22 H1 u H= , H3 u H3 u (6.10) H3
1
1 u 1 1
H22 = g − H g− , H11 = g + H g+ , 1 1 3 j 3 j H1 u = u H u , H3 u = u H u , j = +, 0, −. Specifically,
1 ∓ S ∓ 2K H11 , H22 = α 1±S −2 + 2J ± 4K 1 5/8 + J + 2K ± 4L +α + + , 1±S w 2(1 ± S)2
1 5/8 − J H12 = g + H g− = α , 2(1 − S 2 ) 2 1 5/4 − 2K −2 + 2J − 4KS 2 1 + 2KS + S + + , +α H1 u = α w 1 − S2 1 − S2 2(1 − S 2 ) 1 1 + 2KS + S 2 −2 + 2J + J − 4KS − K + , + α H3 u = α 2 w 1 − S2 (1 − S 2 )
2
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
161
F IG . 16. Ground and first excited state E(R) of H2 molecule for the Hund–Mulliken wave function (solid lines) and the “exact” energy of [8] (dots).
where
1 1 a 2 (1)a(2)b(2) dx dy L= α r12 5 5 1 −w −2w 1 −e + . w+ + =e 8 16w 8 16w
The other symbols are defined in Appendix I. In the calculation of the ground state energy, the sub-block of 2 × 2 matrix in the upper left corner of (6.10) plays the exclusive role as the remaining diagonal 4 × 4 block in (6.10) contributes no effect. We thus determine the ground state energy E by the determinant
H11 − E H12
= 0,
H12 H22 − E ) 1( 2 . H11 + H22 ± (H11 − H22 )2 + 4H12 E± = 2 The value E− will correspond to the ground state energy. For the Hund–Mulliken method discussed above, again α is the variational parameter. In Fig. 16 we plot the ground 1 g+ and first excited 3 u+ state potential energy curves E(R) of the H2 molecule. When α = 1 the ground state curve yields the binding energy of 0.119 a.u. = 3.23 eV. The effective charge calculation yields the binding energy of 0.148 a.u. = 4.03 eV and the bond length of 1.43 Bohr radii. The 3 u+ curve is identical to the Heitler–London E(R) (see Fig. 15).
162
G. Chen et al.
6.3. T HE H ARTREE –F OCK S ELF -C ONSISTENT M ETHOD This is perhaps the best known method in molecular quantum chemistry and it works for multi-electron and multi-center cases. In computational physics, the Hartree–Fock calculation scheme is a self-consistent iterative procedure to calculate the optimal single-particle determinant solution to the time-independent Schrödinger equation. As a consequence to this, while it calculates the exchange energy exactly, it does not calculate the effect of electron correlation at all. The name is for Douglas Hartree, who devised the self consistent field method, and Vladimir Fock who reformulated it into the matrix form used today and introduced the exchange energy. The starting point for the Hartree–Fock method is a set of approximate orbitals. For an atomic calculation, these are typically hydrogenic orbitals. For a molecular calculation, the initial approximate wave functions are typically a linear combination of atomic orbitals. This gives a collections of one electron orbitals, which due to the Fermionic nature of electrons must be antisymmetric; the antisymmetry is achieved through the use of a Slater determinant. Once an initial wave function is constructed, an electron is selected. The effect of all the other electrons is summed up, and used to generate a potential. This is why the procedure is sometimes called a mean-field procedure. This gives a single electron in a defined potential, for which the Schrödinger equation can be solved, giving a slightly different wave function for that electron. This process is then repeated for all the other electrons, which complete one iteration of the procedure. The whole procedure is then repeated until the self-consistent solution is obtained. Here we discuss the method in detail. Consider the Hamiltonian of a multielectron and multi-center molecular system (with n electrons and N nuclei, respectively) under the Born–Oppenheimer separation in the following form = −1 H 2
n j =1
∇j2
+
1≤j
1 Zk . − rj k |r j − R k | n
N
(6.11)
j =1 k=1
For a closed-shell system, all electrons are paired up and n must be an even number. The trial wave function is chosen in the form of a Slater determinant ψ = φ1 (r 1 )φ¯ 1 (r 2 )φ2 (r 3 )φ¯ 2 (r 4 ) · · · φn/2 (r n−1 )φ¯ n/2 (r n ) , where . . . denotes determinant and each φi corresponding to a ui in (6.1) is a molecular orbital (MO) and the one without a “bar” on top denotes a spin-orbital with α-spin (spin-up), and the one with a “bar” on top denotes a β-spin (spin-down) orbital. We assume that the MOs (the spatial part) are orthonormal: φi∗ (r)φj (r) dr = δij , R3
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
163
and we stipulate this orthonormality in our subsequent calculations. For the ground state calculation, we use the Ritz variational method. Substituting the trial |ψ, we have wave function into ψ|H n/2 ψ = 2 ψ H hii + (2Jij − Kij ), i
i=1
where, hij =
(6.12)
j
φi∗ (r)
k=1
R3
Jij =
N 1 2 Zk − ∇ − φj (r)dr, 2 |r − R k |
φi∗ (r)φi (r)
R6
Kij =
1 φj (r )φj∗ (r )drdr = (ii|jj ), |r − r |
φi∗ (r)φj (r)
R6
1 φi (r )φj∗ (r ) drdr = (ij |ij ). |r − r |
Minimizing (6.12) subject to ψ|ψ = 1 leads to a set of n/2 Hartree–Fock equations for the spatial molecular orbital φj (r): n/2 n [2Jr − Kr ] φj (r) = εj φj (r), j = 1, 2, . . . , , F φj (r) = h + 2 r=1 (6.13) with h being the single electron Hamiltonian Zk 1 , h = − ∇2 − 2 |r − R k | N
k=1
Jr being the Coulomb interaction operator defined by
1 ∗ Jr φj (r) = φr (r )φr (r ) dr φj (r) |r − r | R3
and Kr being the energy exchange operator defined by
1 ∗ Kr φj (r) = φr (r )φj (r ) dr φr (r). |r − r | R3
F , called the Fock operator, involves those unknown MOs (φj (r)’s) complicatedly (note that summations in F are over all occupied orbitals, including φj (r) itself); this is not a simple eigenvalue problem. A self-consistent field (SCF) method is needed to solve the Hartree–Fock equation. For that, we take all MOs
164
G. Chen et al.
in F to be known by guessing a set of MOs and plugging them into F . Then, the Hartree–Fock equation becomes a normal eigenvalue problem. We solve this problem and compare the resulting MOs (eigenvectors) to those MOs we substitute into F . If they are different, we put these new MOs back to F and do the same calculation again. This is done iteratively until all φj ’s converge. The problem is then how do we guess (or express) those MOs. An often used method is what we called the linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) method. In this method, we expand the unknown MOs linearly in a fixed basis set, such as Cµi χµ (r), Cµi ∈ C; C is the complex number field. φi (r) = µ (6.14) Here, χµ (r) can be any functions deemed appropriately (not required to be orthonormal), and they are often approximations to atomic orbitals with respect to the individual centers. We still refer them as atomic orbitals (AOs) in the following. By multiplying φi∗ (r) on Eqs. (6.13) and integrating with respect to r, we can rewrite those HF equations (6.13) as Fij = εi δij , with Fij = hij +
(6.15)
2(ij |rr) − (ir|j r) .
r
If we then substitute expansions (6.14) back into the new HF equations (6.15), we obtain Fµν Cνi = Sµν Cνi εi , (6.16) ν
ν
where
Sµν = Fµν
Dλσ
χµ (r)χν (r) d 3 r = δµν ,
1 1 = hµν + Dλσ (µν|λσ ) − (µλ|νσ ) − (µσ |νλ) , 4 4 λσ =2 Cλi Cσ i . i
The whole procedure for the Hartree–Fock Self-Consistent Field (HF-SCF) calculation can be summarized as follows: (1) Choose a basis set {χµ }. (2) Calculate integrals over this basis set (and store in memory). (3) Guess the MO coefficients Cµi .
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
165
(4) Construct D and then F . (5) Solve Eqs. (6.16) for new Cµi , and iterate until convergence results. Note here the total electronic energy can be calculated by use of Eq. (6.12). Good choice of the basis set is very important to the HF-SCF method. Otherwise, basis set can fail the whole calculation, produce bad or wrong results or make calculations become very expensive. A natural choice of the basis are hydrogenic wave functions, or Slater-type orbitals (STOs) STO χl,m = exp(−ζ rA )rAl Ylm (θA , φA ),
where Ylm are the spherical harmonics and the STO is centered on the nucleus A. This basis set works nicely for atoms as well as for diatomic molecules (some numerical integrations are required) and linear polyatomics (a large number of numerical integrations need to be done). No algorithm for nonlinear molecules has been developed till now. Another basis set is the Gaussian-type orbitals (GTOs). This basis set is proposed by Boys [70] in the following form GTO χl,m = exp −αrA2 rAl Ylm (θA , φA ), or in Cartesian form, GTO n χl,m = exp −αrA2 xAl yAm zA . This basis set has been widely used since those multicenter integrals in F can be easily done [70] over this basis set. In principle, it works for all molecules. However, there is a trade-off. GTOs are totally conjectural functions which have no concrete physical meanings. Because of this, GTOs are seldom used to form basis sets directly. They are often used to estimate STOs (by expressing one STO into linear combination of several GTOs) and then form the basis set, such as the STO-3G (3 GTOs are used to estimate one STO) basis set. So far we have discussed the HF-SCF method for closed-shell systems. For the open-shell systems, there are unpaired electrons, orbitals could be doubly occupied or singly occupied. This makes calculations more complicated. The simplest way to deal with this problem is to treat one doubly occupied orbital as two independent orbitals. For example, orbitals φi and φ¯i are treated independently and they are not required to have the same spatial part. With a few modifications, the closed-shell HF-SCF method can be migrated to this case, which is called the unrestricted open-shell HF-SCF method. If we do put restrictions on φi and φ¯i requiring them to have the same spatial part, then we need to treat the doubly occupied and the singly occupied orbitals differently. Calculations can be done still in a more complicated way called the restricted open-shell HF-SCF method [71]. Many strategies have been developed to improve the HF-SCF calculations such as introducing unoccupied molecular orbitals (virtual orbitals), or using two
166
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 17. Ground state E(R) of H2 molecule calculated by the self-consistent Hartree–Fock method (solid line) and the “exact” energy (dots).
(double-zeta basis set) or three (triple-zeta basis set) STOs to describe one molecular orbital (note here that STOs could be linear combinations of GTOs). The HF-SCF method succeeds in many purposes of calculations such as the ground state energy, chemical bond lengths, angles calculations, etc. It yields 3.636 eV for the binding energy of H2 molecule [8] (to be compared against the exact value of 4.745 eV). Nevertheless, this method fails to describe the long distance behavior of a chemical bond (see Fig. 17). More subtly, the HF method views that each electron interacts with a mean potential field generated by the other electrons. It does not take into account the electron correlation. Researchers have been trying to mend these by combining other methods, such as the multiconfigurational SCF, configuration interaction and interelectronic correlation terms in their calculations.
6.4. T HE JAMES –C OOLIDGE WAVE F UNCTIONS James and Coolidge [19] suggested a wave function of the form 1 −α(λ1 +λ2 ) ψ= e 2π
∞ m,n,j,k,p=1
p n j k n m k j Cmnj kp λm 1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 + λ1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 ρ (6.17)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
167
for the H2 -molecule, where ψ is a function of five variables λj =
rj a + rj b ; R
µj =
rj a − rj b , R
j = 1, 2,
(6.18) 2r12 ρ= . R From homonuclear (such as H2 ) symmetry considerations, j + k in (6.17) must be even. But this restriction can be removed for heteronuclear cases. For given R > 0, the coefficients α, and Cmnj kp for finitely many indices m, n, j, k and p, can be used as variational parameters to minimize the energy ψ|H |ψ, subject to the normalization condition ψ|ψ = 1.
(6.19)
For example, for fixed α and R in (6.17) and (6.18), introduce a Lagrange multiplier λ for the constraint (6.19) and choose only a total of s terms in (6.17) by truncation, then the variational problem ψ + λ ψ|ψ − 1 min ψ H (6.20) ψ
leads to a set of s linear equations [19, p. 826] for the coefficients Cj , j = 1, 2, . . . , s, (H11 − λS11 )C1 + (H12 − λS12 )C2 + · · · + (H1s − λS1s )Cs = 0, (H12 − λS12 )C1 + (H22 − λS22 )C2 + · · · + (H2s − λS2s )C2 = 0, .. . (H1s − λS1s )C1 + (H2s − λS2s )C2 + · · · + (Hss − λSss )Cs = 0 (6.21) where φj , Hij = φi H Sij = φi |φj , φi is a typical summand term in (6.17) without the coefficient Cj , for i, j = 1, 2, . . . , s. Solving (6.21) then leads to the ground state ψ0 and its energy E0 . The trial wave function (6.17) may be further adapted to ψ=
1 −α1 λ1 −α2 λ2 −β1 µ1 −β2 µ2 e e 2π ∞ p n j k n m k j × Cmnj kp λm 1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 ± λ1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 ρ m,n,j,k,p=1
for the calculation of heteronuclear cases and excited states.
(6.22)
168
G. Chen et al.
Next, we address the analytic treatment and provide a complete compendium for the integrals given in (6.17)–(6.22), which constitutes the keystone in the twocentered variational treatment. The model Hamiltonian that we will be using here is the (homonuclear case) H2 as given in (6.6). Let us rewrite the James–Coolidge wave function as (1, 2) = (6.23) Cr r (1, 2), r
where 1 −α(λ1 +λ2 ) mr nr jr kr r (6.24) λ1 λ2 µ1 µ2 r12 . e 2π We remark that for the heteronuclear case and for excited states, the trial wave function (6.23), (6.24) can be easily re-adjusted to the form (6.22) with relative ease. In the evaluation of the energy for given two-electron trial wave functions, a typical term is of the form 1 n j k · · · e−α(λ1 +λ2 ) λm Z ν (m, n, j, k; ) = 1 λ2 µ1 µ2 r12 4π 2 × M ν cosν (φ1 − φ2 ) dλ1 dλ2 dµ1 dµ2 dφ1 dφ2 , (6.25) where 1/2 , M = λ21 − 1 λ22 − 1 1 − µ21 1 − µ22 (6.26) r (1, 2) =
and ν, m, n, j , k and are integers ( ≥ −1 and others are nonnegative integers). Using the above function, we can write every integration in terms of Z ν (m, n, j, k; ). For example, the Coulomb interaction energy between the nuclei and electrons may be easily written as follows: 1 ra1 1 rb1 1 ra2 1 rb2
2 , R(λ1 + µ1 ) 2 = , R(λ1 − µ1 ) 2 = , R(λ2 + µ2 ) 2 = . R(λ2 − µ2 ) =
(6.27) (6.28) (6.29) (6.30)
The evaluation of the Coulomb interactions can be done in terms of Z. The evaluation of the Laplacian matrix element, however, somewhat more involved. But it also can be expressed via Z ν . We provide details of the derivation in Appendix J.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
169
Since we can write every term in the energy in terms of Z ν , let us express Z ν via simpler functions defined by recurrence relations. Such relations are given in Appendix K. For ≥ 1 and ν = 0, one can reduce to 0 or −1 using the following identity: R2 2 λ1 + λ22 + µ21 + µ22 − 2 − 2λ1 λ2 µ1 µ2 − 2M cos(φ1 − φ2 ) . 4 (6.31) For ν = 0 and = 0, the integration can be evaluated as follows. Given 2 r12 =
Z 0 (m, n, j, k; 0) ≡ Z(m, n, j, k; 0) 1 n . . . e−2α(λ1 +λ2 ) λm = 1 λ2 4π 2 j
× µ1 µk2 dλ1 dλ2 dµ1 dµ2 dφ1 dφ2 ,
(6.32)
note that the φ integrals are trivial to evaluate and the µ integrals survive only for even integers j and k, i.e., +1 µj dµ = −1
2 , j +1
we arrive at Z(m, n, j, k; 0) =
for even j ;
A(m; α)A(n; α)
0,
(6.33)
4 , (j + 1)(k + 1)
for even j, k, for odd j or k, (6.34)
where we have introduced the function ∞ A(m; α) =
e−αλ λm dλ,
(6.35)
1
for the λ integration. Using integration by parts one can show that the A(m; α) satisfies the recursion relation 1 −α e + mA(m − 1; α) , A(m; α) = (6.36) α with e−α . (6.37) α Thus we have given a recipe for the evaluation of Z(m, n, j, k; 0) for arbitrary values of the power parameters m, n, j , and k. A(0; α) =
170
G. Chen et al.
Next, consider the case where = −1, i.e., Z(m, n, j, k; −1) 1 n j k 1 dλ1 dλ2 dµ1 dµ2 dφ1 dφ2 . . . . e−2α(λ1 +λ2 ) λm = 1 λ2 µ1 µ2 2 r12 4π (6.38) Recalling the Neumann expansion for 1/r12 : ∞ τ 1 2 (τ − |ν|)! 2 ν = (−1) (2τ + 1) r12 R (τ + |ν|)! ν=−τ τ =0
× Pτν (λ< )Qντ (λ> )Pτν (µ1 )Pτν (µ2 )eiν(φ1 −φ2 ) ,
(6.39)
where λ< = min(λ1 , λ2 ), λ> = max(λ1 , λ2 ) and Pτν , Qντ are the associated Legendre functions of the 1st and 2nd kind, respectively. After the angular integration, only terms corresponding to ν = 0 survive, as long as the wave function has no angular or r12 dependence. Separating the λ and µ integrals, we arrive at Z(m, n, j, k; −1) =
∞ 2 (2τ + 1)Rτ (j )Rτ (k)Hτ (m, n; α), R
(6.40)
τ =0
where Rτ and Hτ are defined by 1 Rτ (j ) ≡
µj Pτ (µ) dµ, −1 ∞ ∞
Hτ (m, n; α) ≡ 1
n e−α(λ1 +λ2 ) λm 1 λ2 Pτ (λ< )Qτ (λ> ) dλ1 dλ2 .
(6.41)
(6.42)
1
In the discussion to follow we give recursion relations for the evaluation of the various auxiliary functions. For τ = 0, H0 (m, n; α) = A(m; α)F (n; α) + A(n; α)F (m; α) − T (m, n; α) − T (n, m; α).
(6.43)
Here, F (m; α) can be evaluated for arbitrary m by noting its recursion relation ∞ F (m; α) =
e−αλ λm Q0 (λ) dλ
1
1 mF (m − 1; α) α − (m − 2)F (m − 3; α) − A(m − 2; α)
= F (m − 2; α) +
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS and the initial values 1 e−α eα F (0; α) = (ln 2α + γ ) − Ei [−2α] , 2 α α
171
(6.44)
and
1 1 1 1 −α 1 α F (1; α) = (ln 2α + γ )e + 2 − Ei [−2α]e − + 2 , 2 α α α α (6.45) where ∞ Ei(−x) = −
e−t dt t
(6.46)
x
and γ = 0.577216 . . . is the Euler constant; see Appendix I. Similarly the quantity T (m, n; α) can be determined for arbitrary values of m, n through T (m, n; α) ≡
m m! α ν F (n + ν; 2α) ν! α m+1 ν=0
1 mT (m − 1, n; α) + F (m + n; 2α) = α with the initial value 1 F (n; 2α). (6.47) α Note that we have so far considered only a special case where τ = 0. We turn to the case where τ = 1. Once again we note the recursion relation for H1 (m, n; α): T (0, n; α) =
H1 (m, n; α) = H0 (m + 1, n + 1; α) − S(m, n + 1; α) − S(n, m + 1; α) (6.48) where S(m, n; α) can be determined according to S(m, n; α) ≡
m m! α ν A(n + ν; 2α) ν! α m+1 ν=0
1 mS(m − 1, n; α) + A(m + n; 2α) = α with initial value S(0, n; α) =
1 A(n; 2α). α
(6.49)
172
G. Chen et al.
We now have shown relations needed to evaluate Hτ (m, n; α) for particular values of τ = 0, 1. Here we summarize the evaluation for τ > 1 through the following recursion relations: Hτ (m, n; α) =
1. (2τ − 1)2 Hτ −1 (m + 1, n + 1; α) τ2 + (τ − 1)2 Hτ −2 (m, n; α) − (2τ − 1)(2τ − 3) ! × Hτ −2 (m + 2, n; α) + Hτ −2 (m, n + 2; α) + 2(2τ − 1)(2τ − 5)Hτ −3 (m + 1, n + 1; α) − (2τ − 1)(2τ − 7)
! × Hτ −4 (m + 2, n; α) + Hτ −4 (m, n + 2; α) + 2(2τ − 1)(2τ − 9)Hτ −5 (m + 1, n + 1; α) + one of the following:
(even τ )
+ 2; α) − (2τ − 1) H0 (m + 2, n; α) + H0 (m, n !/ − S(m + 1, n; α) − S(n + 1, m; α) ,
(odd τ )
1, n + 1; α) − S(m, n + 1; α) + (2τ − 1) 2H0 (m + !/ − S(n, m + 1; α) ,
where the starting values H0 (m, n; α) and H1 (m, n; α) are already given in (6.43) and (6.48). For nonzero ν, the integral Z ν can be written in terms of various simple function as discussed below. It is fairly straightforward to obtain the recursion relation for the Z ν function, just by inspection of the equation. For ≥ 1, Z ν (m, n, j, k; ) = Z ν (m + 2, n, j, k; − 2) + Z ν (m, n + 2, j, k; − 2) + Z ν (m, n, j + 2, k; − 2) + Z ν (m, n, j, k + 2; − 2) − 2Z ν (m, n, j, k; − 2) − 2Z ν (m + 1, n + 1, j + 1, k + 1; − 2) − 2Z ν+1 (m, n, j, k; − 2).
(6.50)
The above recursion relation can be proved in a straightforward manner by using 2 in the elliptical coordinates introduced in (6.31). the expansion of r12 Higher order terms of Z ν are given by Z 1 (m, n, j, k, −1) = −
∞ 2 (2τ + 1) 1 R (j )Rτ1 (k)Hτ1 (m, n; α) (6.51) R τ 2 (τ + 1)2 τ τ =1
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
173
and Z 2 (m, n, j, k, −1) ∞ 2 (2τ + 1) = R 2 (j )Rτ2 (k)Hτ2 (m, n) R (τ − 1)2 τ 2 (τ + 1)2 (τ + 2)2 τ τ =2
∞ 1 (2τ + 1) Rτ (j ) − Rτ (j + 2) Rτ (k) − Rτ (k + 2) R τ =0 × Hτ (m + 2, n + 2; α) − Hτ (m + 2, n; α) − Hτ (m, n + 2; α) + Hτ (m, n; α) .
+
For the = 0 case, Z 1 (m, n, j, k; 0) = 0, Z 2 (m, n, j, k; 0) = A(m + 2; α) − A(m; α) A(n + 2; α) − A(n; α) 8 , × (j + 1)(j + 3)(k + 1)(k + 3) when j and k are even; otherwise Z 2 (m, n, j, k; 0) vanishes. The definitions and recurrence relations for Rτν and Hτν are given below: 1 Rτν (j )
≡
ν/2 j ν 1 − µ2 µ Pτ (µ)dµ,
−1
Hτν (m, n; α)
∞∞ ≡ 1 1
ν/2 n 2 e−α(λ1 +λ2 ) λm 1 λ2 λ1 − 1 ν/2 ν × λ22 − 1 Pτ (λ< )Qντ (λ> ) dλ1 dλ2 .
The higher order recursions for Hτν (m, n; α) for ν = 1 and ν = 2 are listed below: Hτ1 (m, n; α) =
τ (τ + 1)2 Hτ +1 (m, n; α) − τ (τ + 1)Hτ (m + 1, n + 1; α) (2τ + 1) τ 2 (τ + 1) Hτ −1 (m, n; α), + 2τ + 1
and Hτ2 (m, n; α) =
τ 2 (τ − 1)2 1 H (m, n; α) − (τ + 2)(τ − 1) (2τ + 1) τ +1 (τ + 2)(τ + 1)2 1 Hτ −1 (m, n; α). × Hτ1 (m + 1, n + 1; α) + 2τ + 1
174
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 18. Schematic correlation diagram for He, the united atom limit, and H2 , the separated-atom case.
The James–Coolidge wave functions may be said to have the most “brawny” power as thousands of coefficients Cmnj kp have been calculated with automated computer programs, yielding very accurate values for the binding energy of diatomic molecules. Nevertheless, there are certain associated shortcomings: (i) The physical insights about molecular bonding seem to be lost; (ii) The wave functions in general do not satisfy the correlation cusp condition; (iii) For large λ1 and λ2 , the asymptotic conditions are violated (see Appendix D).
6.5. T WO -C ENTERED O RBITALS Historically, the first use of two-centered orbitals for molecular calculations is attributable to Wallis and Hulbert’s paper [40] published in 1954. For a historical summary, see [31,42]. New push and progress have been made by a school of French researchers [6,12–14,72,73] since 1976. Their work has made the twocenter orbital approach to diatomic modelling and computation an admirable success. The contributions by the French school are manifold, generalizing most of the aspects of one-centered orbitals to two-centered ones. To introduce its basic elements, let us utilize some of the semi-tutorial material from Scully et al. [16]. Recall the correlation diagram for H2 molecule shown in Fig. 18 [16]. A typical form of the trial wave function for H2 , e.g., may be represented as H2 ,1sσ + c2 ψ H2 ,2pσ f (r12 ), ψ = c1 ψ (6.52)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
175
H2 ,1sσ and ψ H2 ,2pσ are chosen to be, respectively, where ψ H2 ,1sσ = ψ + (1)ψ + (2), ψ H ,1σ H ,1σ 2
2
H2 ,2pσ = ψ + (1)ψ + (2). ψ H ,2p H ,2p 2
(6.53)
2
From (6.52) and (6.53), we see that the trial wave function (6.52) (i) is uncorrelated if f (r12 ) ≡ 1. If f (r12 ) has explicit dependence on r12 , then (6.52) is correlated. A simple choice of f (r12 ) was 1 f (r12 ) = 1 + r12 , (6.54) 2 in Scully et al. [16], but many such correlation functions f satisfying the interelectronic cusp condition as given in Section 5.2 may be used also; (ii) has configuration interaction if c1 c2 = 0 in (6.52). It is found by [16] that: (a) For uncorrelated orbitals and without configuration interaction, i.e., f (r12 ) ≡ 1 and c2 = 0 in (6.52), the choice of ψH + ,1σ (j ) = N e−α1 λj 1 + B2 P2 (µj ) , j = 1, 2, (6.55) 2
in (6.53)1 , where P2 is a Legendre polynomial, gives the binding energy EB = 0.132 a.u. = 3.59 eV for H2 . Here, N is a normalization constant, and α1 and B2 are two variational parameters. (b) For correlated orbitals but without configuration interaction, i.e., f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 and c2 = 0 in (6.52), the choice of (6.55) yields the binding energy EB = 0.1710 a.u. = 4.653 eV for H2 . The choice f (r12 ) = 1 + κr12 , where κ is a variational parameter, slightly improves the answer and gives EB = 0.1713 a.u. = 4.661 eV. (c) For correlated orbitals with configuration interaction, i.e., f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 and c1 c2 = 0 in (6.52), the choice of (6.55) along with ψH + ,2p (j ) = N e−α2 λj P1 (µj ) + B3 P3 (µj ) (6.56) 2
in (6.53) (α1 , B2 , α2 and B3 are variational parameters) yields the binding energy EB = 0.1712 a.u. = 4.658 eV. For the correlation factor f (r12 ) with the variational parameter κ we obtain EB = 0.1721 a.u. = 4.682 eV. What is quite striking here is that if, instead of (6.55), we choose a finer twocentered orbital ψH + ,1σ (j ) = N e−α1 λj 1 + B2 P2 (µj ) + B4 P4 (µj ) , j = 1, 2, (6.57) 2
and perform calculations using three variational parameters α1 , B2 and B4 , then numerical results manifest that B2 totally dominates B4 , with a ratio |B4 /B2 | ≈
176
G. Chen et al.
2 × 10−3 . This shows that the simple orbital (6.52) with (6.55) is able to capture the essence of chemical bonding of H2 with very good accuracy. For a heteronuclear molecule such as HeH+ , a simple adaptation of the above scheme works equally well. Nevertheless, the authors have found that for large R, more terms involving both λ and µ variables should be included in (6.55), such as ψH + ,1σ (j ) = N e−α1 λj 1 + B2 P2 (µj ) + · · · + B2m Pm (µj ) 2 × 1 + A1 L1 (xj ) + · · · + An Ln (xj ) , xj = 2α1 (λj − 1), (6.58) where Ln (x) are Laguerre polynomials, so that good accuracy can be maintained in the calculation of E. Another choice of simple two-centered wave functions, in the same spirit of this subsection, was given by Patil [56], where he has generalized the one-centered Guillemin–Zener-type one-centered molecular orbitals (see Item (3)) by considering the gerade state ψg = N (1 + bλ)β e−aλ cosh(aµ)
(6.59)
and ungerade state ψu = N (1 + bλ)β e−aλ sinh(aµ)
(6.60)
+ for H+ 2 (or any homonuclear) ionic orbitals. Asymptotic behavior of H2 -like orbitals can be built in through β, which plays the same role as β in the Jaffé solution (4.22).
6.5.1. Le Sech’s Simplification of Integrals Involving Cross-Terms of Correlated Wave Functions Siebbeles and Le Sech [14] developed an ingenious approach to the evaluation of energy by applying integration by parts (or, Green’s Theorem) to avoid the quadratures of cross terms of the type ∇i (i j ) · ∇i f,
i, j = 1, 2,
(6.61)
where f is a correlation function, and i j is a product of two-centered orbitals. This is a fine feature of their approach. They choose wave functions of the form ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = φ(1, 2)(1, 2),
(6.62)
where (1, 2) plays the role of the correlation function (but may be more general than the) f discussed in (6.52), while φ(1, 2) = (1)(2),
(6.63)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
177
where (i), i = 1, 2, are the Hylleraas-type two-centered orbitals; cf. (6.77) below. Note here that each of 1 and 2 can have higher order molecular configurations such as 2sσg , 3pσu , 3dσg and 4f σu (in the computation of He, e.g., in [6]). Let the diatomic molecule’s Hamiltonian be H =−
1 2 ∇ + ∇22 + V (1, 2), 2 1
(6.64)
where
with
(1, 2) + 1 V (1, 2) = V r12
(6.65)
(1, 2) = − Za + Zb + Za + Zb . V r1a r1b r2a r2b
(6.66)
Let n (i), i = 1, 2, be eigenstates of the two center problem Zb 1 2 Za − n (i) = n n (i), i = 1, 2. − ∇i − 2 ria rib Denote φj (1, 2) to be solutions of 1 2 2 − ∇1 + ∇2 + V (1, 2) φj (1, 2) = Ej φj (1, 2). 2
(6.67)
(6.68)
Then 1 φj (1, 2) ≡ n1 (1)n2 (2) · √ α(1)β(2) − α(2)β(1) 2
(6.69)
satisfies (6.68) with Ej = n1 + n2 .
(6.70)
Now consider a trial wave function for (6.64) in the form φ(1, 2)(1, 2), where φ(1, 2) is of the form (6.69) while (1, 2) is intended to model the Coulombic repulsive effect from the 1/r12 term and, therefore, plays a similar role as (but may be more general than) the correlation function f (r12 ). Without loss of generality, φ(1, 2) and (1, 2) are assumed to be real. Denote the 6-dimensional Laplacian ∇62 ≡ ∇12 + ∇22 .
178
G. Chen et al.
Consider the matrix element Hij ≡ φi | − (1/2)∇62 + V (1, 2)|φj 1 = dr 1 dr 2 − φi ∇62 (φj ) + φi φj 2 V (1, 2) 2 R3 R3
=
1 dr 1 dr 2 − 2 φi ∇62 φj + φi φj ∇62 + 2φi ∇6 φj · ∇6 12 3 0 2
2 + φi φj V (1, 2) .
T1
(6.71)
To treat T1 , write
T1 = 2φi ∇6 φj · ∇6 = φi ∇6 φj · ∇6 2 ,
and note through an easy verification the following: 2φi ∇φj · ∇ 2 = − φi φj ∇ 2 2 + 2 ∇ · (φi ∇φj − φj ∇φi ) + ∇ · φi φj ∇ 2 + (φi ∇φj − φj ∇φi )2 .
(6.72)
But the LHS of (6.72) is equal to twice of T1 . So we now substitute one-half of the RHS of (6.72) for T1 in (6.71), obtaining 1 Hij = dr 1 dr 2 − 2 φi ∇62 φj +φi φj ∇62 2 0 12 3 T2
1 + φi φj ∇62 2 + 2 ∇6 · (φi ∇6 φj −φj ∇6 φi ) + φi φj 2 V (1, 2) , 04 12 3 T3
(6.73) where the divergence term ∇ · [. . .] in (6.72) disappears after integration in the 6-dimensional space provided that φi , φj , ∇(2 ) and 2 decay fast enough as |r 1 |, |r 2 | → ∞. The RHS of (6.73) is further simplified by utilizing 1 2 2 1 1 ∇ = |∇|2 + ∇ 2 , 4 2 2 and by combining T2 with T3 terms therein, leading to 1 1 dr 1 dr 2 φi φj |∇6 |2 − 2 φi ∇62 φj + φj ∇62 φi Hij = 2 4
+ φi φj 2 V (1, 2) .
(6.74)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
179
Now, with φ satisfying (6.68) we obtain
1 1 1 Hij = dr 1 dr 2 φi φj 2 (Ei + Ej ) + + φi φj |∇6 |2 . 2 r12 2 (6.75) Comparing (6.75) with (6.71), we see that all the cross-derivative terms ∇6 φj × ∇6 have been eliminated, and the only “burden of differentiation” has been placed only on |∇6 |2 in (6.75). If we choose = 1 + 12 r12 , then |∇6 |2 = |∇1 |2 + |∇2 |2 = 1/2 and (6.75) becomes
1 1 1 Hij = (6.76) dr 1 dr 2 φi φj 2 (Ei + Ej ) + + φi φj . 2 r12 4 But doesn’t have to be chosen as = 1 + 12 r12 . Le Sech has preferred a special form of as given in Section 5.2.2. Note that g and u can be used as variational parameters, so can be d in Section 5.2.2. In a personal communication from Le Sech to Scully (9/6/2004), Le Sech pointed out that the trial wave functions in the form of (6.62) with (1, 2) chosen as Section 5.2.2 is particularly suitable for the diffusion Monte Carlo method [73]. Regarding the two-centered orbitals n1 (1) and n2 (2) in (6.67) and (6.69), Aubert-Frécon and Le Sech [13, (4)] used a truncated summation from the Hylleraas series solution, cf. (4.30): = (λ, µ, φ) K
N
m/2 m cn e−p(λ−1) 2p(λ − 1) Ln 2p(λ − 1) , k=m n=0 (6.77) m where p is used as a variational parameter, and fk and cn are coefficients which can be determined from the Killingbeck procedures [74]. =
fkm Ykm (µ, φ)
6.5.2. Generalized Correlated or Uncorrelated Two-Centered Wave Functions The two-centered orbitals we have been using in this section to build up the molecular orbitals, whether they be correlated, uncorrelated, with or without configuration interaction, have been heavily influenced by the classic solutions due to Hylleraas and Jaffé, cf. (4.30) and (4.26). These two famous solutions were derived during the 1920s and 1930s with great ingenuity, their greatest advantages being that a 3-term recurrent relation of the series coefficients. The 3-term recurrences further lead to continued fractions which have enabled mathematicians to perform asymptotic analysis. That was during a time when no electronic computers were available and it was perhaps the only way to perform any theoretical analysis at all. Nowadays, fast computers are readily available so we don’t have
180
G. Chen et al.
to rely overly on 3-term recurrence relations. Five-term recurrence relations are just as good and can be treated with relative ease also by the Killingbeck algorithm [74], for example. Recall that for the single-electron, two-centered heteronuclear problem, separation of variables leads to 2 m2 = 0, λ − 1 + A + 2R1 λ − p 2 λ2 − 2 λ −1 R(Za + Zb ) R1 ≡ (6.78) 2 m2 M = 0, 1 − µ2 M + −A − 2R2 µ + p 2 µ2 − 1 − µ2 R(Za − Zb ) . R2 ≡ (6.79) 2 The appearances of the above two equations suggest the ansatz (λ) =
∞
fk,1 Pkm (λ),
k=0
M(µ) =
∞
fk,2 Pkm (µ),
(6.80)
k=0
where Pkm (λ) are the associated Legendre polynomials. Substituting (6.80) into (6.78) and (6.79) and equate coefficients of Pkm (λ) and Pkm (µ) to zero, see Appendix L, we obtain 5-term recurrence relations Akj fk−2,j + Bkj fk−1,j + Ckj fk,j + Dkj fk+1,j + Ekj fk+2,j = 0, k = 1, 2; j = 0, 1, 2, . . . ,
(6.81)
where p 2 (k − m − 1)(k − m) , (2k − 3)(2k − 1) 2Rj (k − m) =− , j = 1, 2, 2k − 1 p 2 (k − m + 1)(k + m + 1) = Ck2 = − k(k + 1) − A + (2k + 1)(2k + 3) p 2 (k − m)(k + m) , + (2k + 1)(2k − 1) 2Rj (k + m + 1) =− , j = 1, 2, 2k + 3 p 2 (k + m + 1)(k + m + 2) = Ek2 = . (2k + 3)(2k + 5)
Ak1 = Ak2 = Bkj Ck1
Dkj Ek1
(6.82)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
181
The two-centered orbitals derived above differ from those of Hylleraas and Jaffé. The ansatz (6.80) is not the only way to obtain two-centered orbitals. It is possible to derive several other solutions in different forms using different orthogonal polynomials. Numerical results indicate that these two-centered orbitals here give accuracy compatible to that corresponding to Hylleraas and Jaffé-type solutions. 6.5.3. Numerical Algorithm In contrast to the explicit analytic formulas for the quadratures of James–Coolidge wave functions given in Section 6.4 and in the affiliated Appendices J and K, here the integrals will be computed using the Gaussian quadrature routines. (The analytic formulas given earlier in Section 6.4 can then be compared with those obtained here as a good check.) For the two-electron problem, the number of coordinates are six, so that the energy calculation requires the 6-dimensional integration. Using the cylindrical symmetry, we can reduce two angular variables to one. The next simplification is the choice of the wave functions. If we only restrict the wave functions to be the James–Coolidge type, the 5-dimensional integration can be divided as one two-dimensional integration and two three-dimensional integration. However, if we include the exponential function of inter-electron distance, that is e−κr12 , this 5-dimensional integration should be evaluated as multidimensional integration, and the numerical accuracy should be carefully investigated. Here, we only restrict the wave functions to be the James–Coolidge type. The usual integration has the following form . . . 1 (λ1 )2 (λ2 )M1 (µ1 )M2 (µ2 ) n dλ1 dλ2 dµ1 dµ2 dφ1 dφ2 . × (φ1 − φ2 )r12
(6.83)
2 -identity, cf. (6.31), the exponent of r can be reduced into 0 or −1. Using the r12 12 For n = 0, the whole integration is divided into only 5 one-dimensional integrations. However, for 1/r12 , by the Neumann expansion the form of wave function includes sum of Legendre Polynomials with proper coefficients; cf. (6.39). Especially, the form of the λ-part is P (λ1 )Q(λ2 ), λ1 < λ2 , P (λ< )Q(λ> ) = (6.84) P (λ2 )Q(λ1 ), λ2 > λ1 .
This makes the form of integration over the λ variable as ∞∞
∞λ1 ··· =
0 0
∞∞ ··· +
0 0
··· 0 λ1
(6.85)
182
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 19. Comparison of potential curves of the H2 molecule computed with no correlation factor using the exact solution of the one-electron wave function (6.88) (small dots) and the Patil’s wave function (6.89) (solid line). The inner (outer) curves are the result without (with) configuration interaction. Squares are the “exact” ground state E(R) from [8]. Upper curves correspond to “excited states”.
The implementation of these numerical integration is automated by standard computer software. Let us describe the numerics for a homonuclear dimer H2 molecule and a heteronuclear dimer HeH+ molecular ion. The approximation of wave function of two-electron system into a multiplication of one-electron system can be easily made in the natural orbit expansion (r1 , r2 ) = (6.86) ck χk (r1 )χk (r2 ) where χk (r1 ) is the wave function of one-electron two-center problem. For the ground state, it’s well known that c1 ∼ 1, or (r1 , r2 ) χ1 (r1 )χ1 (r2 ).
(6.87)
There are a few alternatives to approximate the χ1 (r1 ). One is using the exact solution of one-electron two-center problem, 1sσg state. The Jaffé’s form is λ − 1 n −αλ σ (1 + λ) gn f2m P2m (µ), χ1 (r1 ) = e (6.88) λ+1 n m cf. (4.26).
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
183
F IG . 20. Same computations as with Fig. 19, but with the correlation factor.
And the other is Patil’s wave function χ1 (r1 ) = (1 + bλ)β e−αP λ cosh(aµ);
cf. (6.59).
(6.89)
We may also include configuration interaction, such as (r1 , r2 ) = c1 χ1 (r1 )χ1 (r2 ) + c2 χ2 (r1 )χ2 (r2 ),
(6.90)
where χ1 is 1sσg state and χ2 is 2pσu state. The result is shown in Fig. 19. Before the diagonalization (that is, CI), the asymptotic behavior of the ground state E(R) is monotonically increasing. By diagonalizing, the behavior at large R becomes almost flat, however, E(R) is slightly above the exact asymptotic value, −1 (htr). Next, we perform computations with correlation by using f (r12 ) = 1 + 12 r12 . Improvement can be readily seen in Fig. 20 which is much closer to the exact calculation done by Kolos [8]. In the calculations below (Figs. 19 and 20), “exact” solutions of H+ 2 -solutions were used (whose coefficients are obtained through truncated Killingbeck [74] procedures). Instead, one can use (6.55), (6.56), (6.57) by optimizing the coefficients α and B therein, or, for the Patil’s wave function, by optimizing the coefficients a and β in (6.59) and (6.60). By doing so, we obtain the energy curve
184
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 21. Ground state potential energy curve of the H2 obtained using the truncated exact wave functions of one-electron system with the correlation factor and several variational parameters. The curve yields the binding energy of EB = −0.1721 a.u. = 4.684 eV. Squares are the “exact” ground state E(R).
of the ground state as shown in Figs. 21 and 22, respectively. The energy curves are improved over a wide range of R values, and we obtain the binding energy of 0.171 a.u. = 4.65 eV, close to the experimental value. However, E(R) in Fig. 21 overshoots the dissociation limit.
7. Alternative Approaches 7.1. I MPROVEMENT OF H ARTREE –F OCK R ESULTS U SING THE B OHR M ODEL The Bohr model can also be applied to calculate the correlation energy for molecules and then improve the HF treatment. Figure 23 shows the ground state potential curve for H2 molecule calculated in the Bohr-HF approximation. Such an approximation omits the electron repulsion term 1/r12 in finding the electron configuration from Eq. (1.2). The difference between the Bohr and Bohr-HF potential curves yields the correlation energy plotted in the insert of Fig. 23.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
185
F IG . 22. Ground state potential curve of H2 computed from the Patil’s wave function with the correlation factor and variational parameters. The curve yields the binding energy of EB = −0.1713 a.u. = 4.662 eV. Squares are the “exact” ground state E(R).
In Fig. 24 we draw the ground state E(R) for the H2 molecule obtained with the Heitler–London trial function that has the form of the combination of the atomic orbitals [67]: ! = C exp −α(ra1 + rb2 ) + exp −α(rb1 + ra2 ) , where α is a variational parameter. Addition of the correlation energy from Fig. 23 improves the Heitler–London result and shifts E(R) close to the “exact” values. The improved potential curve yields the binding energy of 4.63 eV.
7.2. D IMENSIONAL S CALING Dimensional scaling offers promising new computational strategies for the study of few electron systems. This is exemplified by recent applications to atoms, as well as H+ 2 and H2 molecules [10,4]. D-scaling emulates a standard method of quantum chromodynamics [9], by generalizing the Schrödinger equation
186
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 23. Ground state E(R) for the H2 molecule in the Bohr and Bohr-HF models. Insert shows the correlation energy as a function of R.
F IG . 24. Ground state energy E(R) of the H2 molecule in the Heitler–London method and the improved E(R) after the addition of the correlation energy. Dots are the “exact” result from [8].
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
187
to D dimensions and rescaling coordinates [10]. The D → ∞ limit corresponds to infinitely heavy electrons and reduces to a classic electrostatic problem of finding an electron configuration that minimizes a known effective potential. = E for a two particle wave We start from the Schrödinger equation H function (r1 , r2 ). The H2 Hamiltonian in atomic units reads = − 1 ∇12 − 1 ∇22 + V (ρ1 , ρ2 , z1 , z2 , φ, R), H 2 2 where the Coulomb potential energy V is given by Eq. (1.1). In a traditional dimensional scaling approach the Laplacian is treated in D-dimension and the wave function is transformed by incorporating the square root of the Jacobian via → J −1/2 , where J = (ρ1 ρ2 )D−2 (sin φ)D−3 in cylindrical coordinates, and φ is the dihedral angle specifying relative azimuthal orientation of electrons about the molecular axis [75]. D-scaling in spherical coordinates is discussed in Appendix M. On scaling the coordinates by f 2 and the energy by 1/f 2 , with f = (D − 1)/2, the Schrödinger equation in the limit D → ∞ leads to minimization of the effective potential [75] 1 1 1 1 + + V (ρ1 , ρ2 , z1 , z2 , φ, R). E= (7.1) 2 2 2 ρ1 ρ2 sin2 φ The obtained electron configuration is sometimes called the Lewis structure because it provides a rigorous version of the familiar electron-dot formulas introduced by Lewis in 1916 [76]. Figure 25 (upper curve) displays the D → ∞ potential curve E(R) that exhibits no binding and substantially deviates from the D = 3 “exact” energy (dots). In the limit D → 1 the dimensional scaling reduces the Hamiltonian to the delta function model [77] 2 2 R R R = −1 d + d + − + − δ x − δ x − δ x H 1 1 2 2 dx12 2 2 2 dx22 R − δ x2 − (7.2) + δ(x1 − x2 ). 2 A variational solution of the one-dimensional wave equation [78] is pictured in Fig. 25 (lower curve). Also shown is an approximation to E(R) for D = 3 obtained by interpolating linearly in 1/D between the dimensional limits: 2 1 E∞ (R) + E1 (R). (7.3) 3 3 The interpolated D = 3 curve exhibits binding which indicates the feasibility of extending dimensional interpolation to molecules. E3 (R) =
188
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 25. Ground state energy E(R) of the H2 molecule in D = ∞, D = 1 and three-dimensional interpolation (solid lines). Dots show the “exact” D = 3 energy from [8].
A proper choice of scaling can improve the method. Here we discuss a dimensional scaling transformation of the Schrödinger equation that yields the Bohr model of H2 in the limit of infinite dimensionality [4]. For such a transformation, the large-D limit provides a link between the old (Bohr–Sommerfeld) and the new (Heisenberg–Schrödinger) quantum mechanics. The first-order correction in 1/D substantially improves the agreement with the exact ground state E(R). In the modified scaling the Laplacian depends on a continuous parameter D as follows ∂ 1 ∂ ∂2 1 ∂2 ρ D−2 + 2 2 + 2. ∇ 2 = D−2 (7.4) ∂ρ ∂ρ ρ ρ ∂φ ∂z For D = 3, Eq. (7.4) reproduces the 3D Laplacian. On scaling the coordinates by f 2 , the energy by 1/f 2 (recalling f = (D − 1)/2) and transforming the electronic wave function by = (ρ1 ρ2 )−(D−2)/2 ,
(7.5)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
189
the Schrödinger equation is recast as (K + U + V ) = E,
(7.6)
where 2
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 1 1 ∂2 ∂ 2 + 2+ 2+ 2+ + 2 , K=− (D − 1)2 ∂ρ12 ∂ρ2 ∂z1 ∂z2 ρ12 ρ2 ∂φ 2 (7.7) 1 (D − 2)(D − 4) 1 + 2 . U= 2(D − 1)2 ρ12 ρ2 In the D → ∞ limit the derivative terms in K are quenched. The corresponding energy E∞ for any given internuclear distance R is then obtained simply as the minimum of an effective potential 1 1 1 E= (7.8) + + V (ρ1 , ρ2 , z1 , z2 , φ, R). 2 ρ12 ρ22 This is identical in form to that for the Bohr model, Eq. (1.2), and we thus obtain for E∞ (R) the same solutions depicted in Fig. 2. This result for E∞ (R) differs in an interesting way from that obtained in a traditional study of the D → ∞ limit for the H2 molecule [75]. Here, in order to connect with the Bohr model, it is necessary to incorporate only the radial portion of the Jacobian in transforming the electronic wave function via Eq. (7.5). The customary practice, which employs the full Jacobian, introduces a factor of 1/(sin2 φ) into the centrifugal potential, as seen from Eq. (7.1). The modified procedure yields directly a good zeroth-order approximation. The ground state E(R) can be substantially improved by use of a perturbation expansion in powers of 1/D, developed by expanding the effective potential of Eq. (7.8) in powers of the displacement from the minimum [10]; for He and H+ 2 this has yielded highly accurate results [79]. Terms quadratic in the displacement describe harmonic oscillations about the minimum and give a 1/D correction to the energy. Anharmonic cubic and quartic terms give a 1/D 2 contribution. For the He ground state energy (the R = 0 limit for H2 ) a first-order approximation yields [4]1 4E∞ 0.1532 E(0) = (7.9) , 1 − D (D − 1)2
1 To improve convergence of the 1/D expansion a variant scaling involving a factor (2D + 9)/5D is used in front of the ∂ 2 /∂φ 2 term in Eqs. (7.4), (7.7).
190
G. Chen et al.
F IG . 26. Ground state energy E of H2 molecule as a function of internuclear distance R calculated within the dimensional scaling approach (solid lines) and the “exact” energy (dots).
where E∞ = −3.062 a.u. is the Bohr model He result [5,80]. For D = 3 Eq. (7.9) improves the ground state energy of He to E(0) = −2.906 a.u., which differs by 0.07% only from the “exact” value of −2.9037 a.u. [81]. To evaluate the 1/D correction for arbitrary R, it is convenient to introduce new coordinates 1 z˜ 1 = √ (z1 − z2 ), 2
1 z˜ 2 = √ (z1 + z2 ). 2
The effective potential of Eq. (7.8) then has a minimum at ρ1 = ρ2 = ρ0 , φ = π, z˜ 2 = 0. Along the coordinates ρ1 , ρ2 , z˜ 2 and φ the potential has a single well structure no matter what the internuclear spacing R is. However, along the z˜ 1 direction at R = 1.2 the potential changes shape from a single to a double well; such symmetry breaking is a typical feature exhibited at large D [82]. To avoid the inaccuracy of approximation by a single quadratic form one can solve the Schrödinger equation numerically along the z˜ 1 direction for the exact potential and add contributions from the harmonic motion associated with the other coordinates ρ1 , ρ2 , z˜ 2 and φ. The result is shown in Fig. 26 [4]. The 1/D correction improves E(R) and predicts the equilibrium separation to be Re = 1.62 with binding energy EB = 4.38 eV.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
191
8. Conclusions and Outlook Many major topics on diatomic molecules, and some other atoms and molecules in general, have been addressed in this article, giving it a very “locally diverse” or perhaps a somewhat disjoint look. But a simple, “global” picture may be viewed and understood in/from the following diagram:
This “unification” is by no means an easy task. Nevertheless, it was a goal we somehow envisioned to achieve when this research was started and we hope we have made at least some success. At present, in the study of ultrafast laser applications to chemical physics and molecular chemistry problems, there is a pressing need to understand the quantum-dynamical behavior of molecules and the associated properties of excited states and their computations. Many challenges are lying ahead and awaiting elegant solutions.
9. Acknowledgements We wish to thank Professor D. Herschbach for lectures given at Princeton in Fall 2003 which stimulate our interest in D-scaling, and Professor C. Le Sech for the personal communication cited in Section 6.5.1. We also thank Professor G. Hunter, who read the manuscript and offered constructive criticisms. This research is partially supported by grants from ONR (N00014-03-1-0693 and N00014-041-0336), NSF DMS 0310580, TITF of Texas A&M University, and the Robert A. Welch Foundation (#A1261).
192
G. Chen et al.
10. Appendices Appendix A. Separation of Variables for the H+ 2 -like Schrödinger Equation Let us consider (4.13). Here we show how to separate the variables through the use of the ellipsoidal (or, prolate spheroidal) coordinates (see Fig. 9) R 2 R 2 x= λ − 1 1 − µ2 cos φ, y= λ − 1 1 − µ2 sin φ, 2 2 (A.1) R z = λµ. 2 Note that the coordinates λ, µ and φ are orthogonal, and we have the first fundamental form ds 2 = dx 2 + dy 2 + dz2 = h2λ dλ2 + h2µ dµ2 + h2φ dφ 2 , where
2 ∂y 2 ∂z R 2 1 − µ2 , = + + = ∂λ ∂λ 4 λ2 − 1 2 2 2 ∂x ∂y ∂z R 2 λ2 − 1 h2µ = + + = , ∂µ ∂µ ∂µ 4 1 − µ2 2 2 2 ∂x ∂y ∂z R2 2 2 + + = λ − 1 1 − µ2 . hφ = ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ 4 h2λ
Thus
∂x ∂λ
2
1 ∂ hλ hφ ∂ ∂ hµ hφ ∂ + hλ hµ hφ ∂λ hλ ∂λ ∂µ hµ ∂µ ∂ hλ hµ ∂ + ∂φ hφ ∂φ ∂ 4 ∂ ∂ 2 2 ∂ = 2 2 λ −1 + 1−µ ∂λ ∂µ ∂µ R (λ − µ2 ) ∂λ
2 2 2 λ −µ ∂ + 2 . 2 (λ − 1)(1 − µ ) ∂φ 2
∇ 2 =
Note that through the coordinate transformation (A.1), we have R r + rb ra = (λ + µ), λ = a , 2 R equivalently, ra − rb R r = (λ − µ). µ = , b R 2
(A.2)
(A.3)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
193
Also, we have λ ≥ 1, −1 ≤ µ ≤ 1. Write = (λ)M(µ)(φ).
(A.4)
(φ) must be periodic with period 2π. Therefore (φ) = eimφ ,
m = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . .
(A.5) eimφ :
Substitute (A.2), (A.4) and (A.5) into (4.13), and then divide by ∂ 4 ∂ 1 ∂ 2 2 ∂ − 1 λ M + 1 − µ M − 2 R 2 (λ2 − µ2 ) ∂λ ∂λ ∂µ ∂µ
2 Zb (λ2 − µ2 )m2 M − M − 2 Rλ+µ (λ − 1)(1 − µ2 ) 2 Za Za Zb − (A.6) M + M = EM. Rλ−µ R 2
Further multiplying every term by − R2 (λ2 − µ2 ), we obtain ∂ ∂ 2 ∂ λ2 − µ2 2 ∂ m2 M λ −1 M+ 1−µ M − 2 ∂λ ∂λ ∂µ ∂µ (λ − 1)(1 − µ2 ) RZa Zb R2E − (λ2 − µ2 ) M = 0. + RZb (λ − µ) + RZa (λ + µ) − 2 2 0 12 3
R 2 E RZa Zb 2 − 2
(λ2 −µ2 )+R[(Za +Zb )λ+(Za −Zb )µ]
(A.7)
Set p2 =
1 −R 2 E + RZa Zb > 0. 2
(A.8)
We have p 2 > 0 here due to the fact that we are mainly interested in the electronic states that are bound states, i.e., not ionized. Let the constant of separation of variables be A. Then from (A.7) and (A.8) we obtain (4.16) and (4.17) in Section 4.2.
Appendix B. The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) for Large λ Here, we provide a quick proof of Eq. (4.22). From (4.19), we have 2λ A + 2R1 λ 2 (λ) + (λ) − p (λ) = − 2 λ −1 λ2 − 1
2 m2 λ 2 −1 − 2 −p (λ) . λ2 − 1 (λ − 1)2
(B.1)
194
G. Chen et al.
We now find the Laurent expansions of the coefficient functions on the right-hand side of (B.1) as follows: 2λ 2 2 0 2 0 = + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + ···, λ λ λ2 − 1 λ λ λ 1 A + 2R1 λ 1 1 = (A + 2R λ) 1 + + + · · · 1 λ2 − 1 λ2 λ2 λ4 2R1 2R1 A A = + 2 + 3 + 4 + ···, λ λ λ λ 2 2 0 0 p2 p λ −p 2 2 − 1 = − 2 + 3 − 4 ± ··· λ λ −1 λ λ λ −
(λ2
m2 0 0 m2 0 2m2 0 = + 2 + 3 − 4 + 5 − 6 ± ···. 2 λ λ − 1) λ λ λ λ
From these expansions above, we now use the ansatz c2 c1 + 2 + ··· (λ) = a0 e−pλ λβ 1 + λ λ by substituting it into (B.1) and equating all the coefficients of λ−n to zero for n = 0, 1, 2, . . . . We easily obtain β=
R1 − 1, p
c1 =
p 2 − β 2 − 2β . 2R1 − 2pβ − p
All the other coefficients cn can be determined in a straightforward way. Note that the asymptotic expansion (4.22) also gives (λ) − a1 e−pλ λβ
n cj = O e−pλ λβ(n+1) , j λ
for λ 1.
(B.2)
j =0
Appendix C. The Asymptotic Expansion of (λ) as λ → 1 Here we provide a proof of Eq. (4.23). Multiply (4.18) by (λ − 1)/(λ + 1) and rewrite it as 2λ 0 = (λ − 1)2 (λ) + (λ − 1) (λ) λ+1 (A + 2R1 λ − p 2 λ2 ) m2 + (λ − 1) − (λ) λ+1 (λ + 1)2 ≈ (λ − 1)2 (λ) + (λ − 1) (λ) −
m2 (λ), 4
for λ ≈ 1.
(C.1)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
195
A differential equation (such as (C.1)) set in the form (x − 1)2 y (x) + (x − 1)q(x)y (x) + r(x)y(x) = 0,
(C.2)
near x = 1, where q(x) and r(x) are analytic functions at x = 1, is said to have a regular singular point at x = 1. The solution’s behavior near x = 1 hinges largely on the roots ν of the indicial equation ν(ν − 1) + q(1)ν + r(1) = 0
(C.3)
because the solution y(x) of (C.2) is expressible as y(x) = b1 (x − 1)ν1
∞
ck (x − 1)k + b2 (x − 1)ν2
k=0
∞
dk (x − 1)k
k=0
(c0 = d0 = 1), where ν1 and ν2 are the two roots of the indicial equation (C.3), under the assumptions that ν1 > ν2 ,
ν1 − ν2 is not a positive integer.
(C.4)
However, if (C.4) is violated, then there are two possibilities and two different forms of solutions arise: (a) ν1 = ν2 . Then y(x) = b1 y1 (x) + b2 y2 (x),
(C.5)
where y1 (x) = (x − 1)ν1
∞
ck (x − 1)k
(c0 = 1)
(C.6)
k=0
and y2 (x) = (x − 1)ν1
∞
dk (x − 1)k + ln(x − 1) y1 (x)
(d1 = 1).
k=1
(C.7) Solution y2 in (C.7) should be discarded because it becomes unbounded at x = 1. (b) ν1 − ν2 = a positive integer. Then case (a) holds except with the modification that y2 (x) = (x − 1)
ν2
∞
dk (x − 1)k + c ln(x − 1) y1 (x)
k=0
(d0 = 1, c is a fixed constant but may be 0).
(C.8)
196
G. Chen et al.
Applying the above and (C.3) to Eq. (C.1): (λ − 1)2 (λ) + (λ − 1) (λ) −
m2 (λ) ≈ 0, 4
(C.9)
we obtain the indicial equation ν(ν − 1) + ν −
m2 = 0, 4
(C.10)
with roots ν1 =
|m| , 2
ν2 = −
|m| 2
(m can be either a positive or a negative integer). (C.11)
Thus either ν1 = ν2
(when m = 0)
or ν1 − ν2 = |m| = a positive integer,
where m = 0.
Again, we see that solution y2 in (C.8) must be discarded because it becomes unbounded at x = 1. Thus, from (C.6) and (C.9), we have (λ) ≈ (λ − 1)|m|/2
∞
ck (λ − 1)k .
(C.12)
k=0
Appendix D. Expansions of Solution Near λ ≈ 1 and λ 1: Trial Wave Functions of James and Coolidge In the pioneering work of James and Coolidge [19], the two-centered trial wave functions for H2 are chosen to be (ground state) ψ(λ1 , λ2 , µ1 , µ2 , ρ) 1 −α(λ1 +λ2 ) = e 2π
p n j k n m k j Cmnj kp λm 1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 + λ1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 ρ ,
(D.1)
m,n,j,k,p
and (excited state) ψ(λ1 , λ2 , µ1 , µ2 , ρ) = e−α(λ1 +λ2 ) m,n,j,k,p
p n j k n m k j Cmnj kp λm 1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 − λ1 λ 2 µ 1 µ 2 ρ ,
(D.2)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
197
where ρ = r12 is the distance between the two electrons of H2 , the coefficients Cmnj kp are computed from the minimization of the energy, plus possible orthogonality conditions. We examine the asymptotics of the trial solutions (D.1) or (D.2) based on the discussions in Section 4.2. We see that the exponent e−αλ1 in e−α(λ1 +λ2 ) would correspond to the factor e−pλ in (4.21) or (4.26). This is excellent as it reflects the exponential decay in the radial variable of the (first) electron. However, the other non-constant polynomial terms of the form j
k 1 n1 λm 1 λ2 µ1 µ2 ,
j
2 k λn1 2 λm 2 µ1 µ2 ,
with |m | + |n | ≥ 1, = 1, 2, (D.3)
possess polynomial growth rates in either λ1 or λ2 , which are at odds with the asymptotics in (4.22) since for large λ (which may be either λ1 or λ2 ), there should n2 m2 1 n1 not be any polynomial growth λm 1 λ2 or λ1 λ2 in (D.3) besides the exponential 1 n1 −pλ −pλ 1 2 decay factor e ·e . (One might argue that the polynomial growth λm 1 λ2 n2 m2 −pλ −pλ 1 2 or λ1 λ2 would be killed by the exponential decay e ·e . This can be true, however, only by increasing p and thus it causes the loss of accuracy.) One might still argue that the typical term in the series (4.26) for m = 0 (ground state) satisfies k σ λ−1 (λ + 1) λ+1 (σ − 1)(σ − k − 1) 1 2 1 = λσ 1 + (σ − k) + ··· + λ 1·2 λ σ = O λ , for λ 1. This means that either m or n in (D.3) should never exceed σ . Can’t we, at least, n2 m2 1 n1 use terms λm 1 λ2 or λ1 λ2 with some restrictions such as 0 ≤ m , n ≤ σ ;
σ ≡
R1 − 1, for m = 0, = 1, 2. p
The most important behavior of happens near λ = 1. For λ ≈ 1, the typical term in (4.26) satisfies λ−1 k (λ2 − 1)|m|/2 (λ + 1)σ λ+1 λ−1 |m| = 2|m|/2+σ −k (λ − 1)|m|/2+k 1 + +σ −k 2 2 2 (|m|/2 + σ − k)(|m|/2 + σ − k − 1) λ − 1 + + ··· 1·2 2 = (λ − 1)|m|/2 2|m|/2+σ −k (λ − 1)k + O (λ − 1)k+1 , for λ ≈ 1, λ > 1.
(D.4)
198
G. Chen et al.
When m = 0, the case of the ground state, the above expansion in terms of powers of λ is consistent with the terms involving powers of λ1 or λ2 in (D.3) since those powers in (D.3) can always be re-expanded in terms of powers of λ1 − 1 or λ2 − 1. However, when m = 1 (or m = ± odd integer, for that matter) for the excited state, the function in (D.3) is no longer consistent with those in (D.4) as far as the λ-variable is concerned because the factor (λ − 1)|m|/2 in (D.4) is unaccountable for those in (D.3). Indeed, we have indicated in (4.23) through asymptotic analysis that the factor (λ − 1)|m|/2 is inherent in the solution and, thus, must be properly taken into account. The discussion in this section points out some weaknesses in the choice of basis functions (D.1) or (D.2) based on the asymptotic arguments for λ 1 and λ ≈ 1. Such weaknesses may have contributed to the fact that many terms are required in (D.1) in order to calculate or to do the variational analysis of the energy E accurately for H2 by James and Coolidge [19]. Our conclusion for this subsection is: because of the vastly different asymptotic behaviors of (λ) for λ ≈ 1 and λ 1, the best strategy for numerical computation is to use two different representations for (λ), one for λ ≈ 1 and another for λ 1 and match them, say, at a medium-size value such as λ = 5 or 10. This, however, will invoke more computational work and is beyond the interest of the authors for the time being.
Appendix E. The Many-Centered, One Electron Problem in Momentum Space Here we derive the eigenvalue equation (4.43). We start from the model equation N 1 2 Zj − ∇ − (E.1) ψ(r) = Eψ(r), r = (x, y, z) ∈ R3 . 2 |r − R j | j =1
Recall the Fourier transform 1 (p) = e−ir·p ψ(r) dr. (2π)3/2
(E.2)
R3
Note that the Fourier transform of the potential term 1 1 e−ir·p dr |r − R j | (2π)3/2
(E.3)
R3
is a divergent integral in the classical sense. However, the modern mathematical theory of the “regularization of divergent integrals” [20, Chapter 3] makes (E.3)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS well defined: (E.3) = (2π)−3/2
e−i(r +R j )·p
R3 −3/2 −iR j ·p
≡ (2π)
e
1 dr |r |
lim
e
−ir ·p e
α→0 R3 ∞ π 2π
= (2π)−3/2 e−iRj ·p lim
α→0 0
0
199
(r ≡ r − R j ) −αr
r
dr
e−ir p cos θ−αr r 2 dr sin θ dθ dφ
0
−iR j ·p 4π −1/2 e = (2π)−3/2 e−iRj ·p lim 2 = 2(2π) . α→0 p + α 2 p2
(E.4)
Applying the Fourier transform to (E.1) by utilizing (E.4) and other well known properties such as convolution, we obtain N 1 2 Zj p − E (p) − (2π)−3/2 · 2(2π)−1/2 2 j =1 −iR j ·(p−p ) e × p dp = 0. (E.5) |p − p |2 R3
Define p02 = −2E,
(E.6)
then we obtain the integral equation
N Zj p 2 + p02 (p) = π2 j =1
R3
e−iR j ·(p−p ) p dp . |p − p |2
(E.7)
Now, we project the 3-dimensional momentum vector p onto the surface of the unit sphere, S3 , of the 4-dimensional space, the 1-1 correspondence ξ ↔ p through −1 ξ1 = 2p0 px p 2 + p02 = sin χ sin θ cos φ, 2 −1 = sin χ sin θ sin φ, ξ2 = 2p0 py p + p02 2 −1 ξ ∈ R4 , ξ = |ξ | = 1, (E.8) = sin χ cos θ, ξ3 = 2p0 pz p + p02 −1 = cos χ, ξ4 = p02 − p 2 p 2 + p02 0 ≤ χ ≤ π, 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2π, 0 ≤ φ ≤ π,
200
G. Chen et al.
while keeping in mind that px = p sin θ cos φ,
Then for ξ ↔ p, ξ ↔
p ,
py = p sin θ sin φ,
pz = p cos θ.
(E.9)
and κ be the angle between ξ and ξ , we have
cos κ = ξ · ξ ,
ξ − ξ 2 = ξ 2 + ξ 2 − 2ξ · ξ = 2 − 2 cos κ = 4 sin2 (κ/2).
(E.10)
Also, it is straightforward to verify that
ξ − ξ 2 =
4p02 |p − p |2 (p 2 + p02 )(p 2 + p02 )
.
Hence p02 1 = . 2 2 |p − p | (p 2 + p0 )(p 2 + p02 ) sin2 (κ/2)
(E.11)
Let d be the infinitesimal surface area of the 4-dimensional hypersphere S3 . Then from (E.8), d = sin2 χ sin θ dχ dθ dφ = − sin2 χ dχ d(cos θ ) dφ
(E.12)
while (E.9) gives the standard dp = p 2 sin θ dp dθ dφ = −p 2 dp d(cos θ ) dφ.
(E.13)
From (E.8)4 , we further obtain p 2 + p02 dp . = dχ 2p0
(E.14)
Equations (E.8) and (E.12)–(E.14) now give 2 p + p02 3 p 2 dp d. d = dp = 2p0 sin2 χ dχ
(E.15)
We can now use (E.11) to eliminate the denominator inside the Fourier integral of (E.7). Moreover, define ϕ() =
(p 2 + p02 )2 5/2
(p),
(E.16)
4p0
where ∈ S3 is the point ξ ↔ p. Then the integral equation (E.7) simplifies to n Zj e−iRj (p−p ) 1 p() = (E.17) ϕ d . p0 8π 2 sin2 (κ/2) j =1 S3
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
201
At this point, we need to introduce the hyperspherical harmonics on O3 , which constitute an orthonormal basis for square summable functions on S3 and are given by Ynm () = (−i) Cn (χ)Ym (θ, φ), n = 1, 2, . . . , = 0, 1, 2, . . . , m = −, − + 1, . . . , 0, 1, . . . , , (E.18) cf. (4.6)–(4.9) for Ym (θ, φ), where
Cn (χ) ≡
2n(n − − 1)! π(n + )!
1/2
sin χ
d d(cos χ)
Cn−1 (cos χ) ,
(E.19) are the associated Gegenbauer functions, and the Ck ’s are the Gegenbauer functions, with the generating function ∞
1 ≡ hj Cj (µ), 2 1 − 2µh + h
|h| < 1.
(E.20)
j =0
For ξ , ξ ∈ R4 ,
1 1 ξ 2 1 − 2 cos κ(ξ /ξ ) + (ξ /ξ )2
1 = 1 1 |ξ − ξ |2 ξ 2 1 − 2 cos κ(ξ/ξ ) + (ξ/ξ )2
ξ < 1, ξ ξ if < 1. ξ if
(E.21)
Denote ξ> = max(ξ, ξ ), ξ< = min(ξ, ξ ). Then (E.20) and (E.21) give the Neumann expansion ∞ ∞ 1 ξ
ξ> |ξ − ξ | ξ>n+1 n=0
which, in the limit as
ξ, ξ
n=1
→ 1, yields
1 1 (by (E.10)) 2 = 2 |ξ − ξ | 4 sin (κ/2) ∞ Cn−1 (cos κ). =
(E.22)
n=1
But by the addition theorem of angles, we have Cn−1 (cos κ) =
2π 2 ∗ Ynm Ynm (), n m
(E.23)
202
G. Chen et al. n ≥ 1, = 0, 1, 2, . . . , m = −, − + 1, . . . , 0, 1, . . . , ,
(E.24)
so from (E.22) we obtain 1 2
4 sin (κ/2)
= 2π 2
∞ n=1 ,m
1 ∗ , Ynm () Ynm n
and, thus, the kernel of the integral equation (E.17) can be written as
Zj e−iRj ·(p−p ) 8π 2 sin2 (κ/2)
= Zj
t
1 −iR ·p ∗ e−iR j ·p Yt () e j Yt , n
(E.25)
where t = (nm) runs triple summation indices according to (E.24). We now use the orthonormal basis functions (E.18) to make a re-expansion eiR j ·p Yt () = Sτ+ (R j )Yτ (), j = 1, 2, . . . , N, τ
where τ =
(n m )
Sτt (R j ) =
runs triple summation indices similarly to t. Then eiRj ·p Yt ()Yτ () d
(E.26)
S3
and (E.25) becomes
Zj e−iRj ·(p−p ) 8π 2 sin2 (κ/2)
= Zj
tτ τ
∗ 1 τ Stτ (R j ) St (R j )Yτ ()Yτ∗ . n
The orthonormal expansion of ϕ() in (E.17) is denoted as ct Yt (). ϕ() =
(E.27)
(E.28)
t
Substituting (E.27) and (E.28) into (E.17) and equating coefficients, we obtain ∗ 1 τ 1 t ct = St (R j ) Zj S (R j )cτ . p0 n t tτ j
This is an eigenvalue problem P c = p0 c,
(E.29)
where P is an infinite matrix with entries ∗ 1 t Ptt = Sτt (R j ) Zj S (R j ), n τ τ j
where c is an infinite-dimensional vector with entries ct . The value of p0 will yield the energy E from (E.6). One can obtain the wave function ψ(r) from applying the inverse Fourier transform to (p) through (E.16) and (E.8).
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
203
Appendix F. Derivation of the Cusp Conditions Here we derive the cusp conditions at the singularities of Eq. (5.3). Since the idea is the same for each of the five sets of singularities, we will only treat the most complicated case, r12 = 0. Use the center-of-mass coordinate system, see Appendix G, we can transform (5.2) into the form 2Za 2Zb = − 1 ∇S2 − 1 ∇r2 − − H 2M 2µ 12 |2R a + r 12 | |2R b + r 12 | Za Zb 2Za 2Zb q1 q 2 + − − + , |2R a − r 12 | |2R b − r 12 | r12 R
(F.1)
where S is the center of mass coordinate of two electrons, see Appendix G for the details of the notation. We now define the spherical means of a function. Given a point r 0 ∈ R3 , the spherical means of a function u(r) at r 0 on the sphere with radius ρ is defined to be 1 u(r 0 + ρν) dω, uav,ρ (r 0 ) ≡ (F.2) 4π S1
where Sρ is the sphere with radius ρ centered at r 0 , here ρ = 1; dω = sin θ dθ dφ, where ω represents all the angular variables; ν = (ν1 , ν2 , ν3 ), ν12 + ν22 + ν32 = 1; ν is the unit outward pointing normal vector on S1 . It is easy to see that if u(r) is continuous in a neighborhood of r 0 , then the spherical means just converge to the pointwise value: lim uav,ρ (r 0 ) = u(r 0 ).
ρ→0
over a small 3-dimensional ball Bρ0 with radius ρ0 centered We now integrate H at r12 = 0, for any S ∈ R3 , S = 0: 1 2 2Za 1 2 ∇ ψ(r 12 , S) − ∇ ψ(r 12 , S) − ψ(r 12 , S) − 2M S 2µ 12 |2R a + r 12 | Bρ0
2Zb 2Za ψ(r 12 , S) − ψ(r 12 , S) |2R b + r 12 | |2R a − r 12 | 2Zb − ψ(r 12 , S) |2R b − r 12 |
Za Zb q1 q2 ψ(r 12 , S) + ψ(r 12 , S) dr 12 = 0. + r12 R −
204
G. Chen et al.
Note that as ρ0 → 0, the integrals of all the terms above vanish (by their continuity at r12 = 0), except possibly those of −
q1 q2 ψ(r 12 , S). r12
1 2 ∇ ψ(r 12 , S), 2µ 12
Thus, we need only consider −
lim
ρ0 →0 Bρ0
1 2 q1 q2 ψ(r 12 , S) dr 12 = 0. ∇12 ψ(r 12 , S) + 2µ r12
(F.3)
Apply the Gauss Divergence Theorem to the first term of the integral to get 1 ∂ψ 1 2 − ∇ ψ(r 12 , S) dr 12 = − (r 12 , S) dSρ0 2µ 12 2µ ∂r12 Sρ0
Bρ0
=− Bρ0
q1 q2 ψ(r 12 , S) dr 12 . r12
(F.4)
But dSρ0 = ρ02 dω; thus Sρ0
∂ψ dSρ0 = ∂r12
S1
∂ψ dω1 · ρ02 ∂r12
=
ρ02 S1
∂ψ(r 12 , S) 2 ∂ψ(0, S) dω = 4πρ0 , (F.5) ∂r12 ∂r12 av,ρ0
2 dω dr , we where S1 = Sρ0 |ρ0 =1 . By using spherical coordinates, dr 12 = r12 12 have
Bρ0
q1 q2 ψ(r 12 , S) dr 12 = r12
ρ0 0
ρ0 = q1 q2 0
Sρ
q1 q2 2 ψ(r 12 , S) dω r12 dr12 r12
ψ(0, S) + ε(r 12 , S) dω r12 dr12 ,
Sρ
where ε(r 12 , S) → 0 as r 12 → 0. This follows from the fact that ψ(r 12 , S) is continuous at r 12 = 0 for any S.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS (Continuing from the above) ρ0
ρ2 r12 dr12 + ε˜ (ρ0 , S)4π 0 2
≡ q1 q2 ψ(0, S)
205
0
ρ02 + 2πρ02 ε˜ (ρ0 , S). 2 From (F.3)–(F.6), we now get ρ2 1 1 2 ∂ψ(0, S) = − ρ02 q1 q2 ψ(0, S) + 0 ε˜ (ρ0 , S). − ρ0 2µ ∂r12 2 2 av,ρ0 = q1 q2 ψ(0, S)4π
(F.6)
Dividing all the terms above by ρ02 and let ρ0 → 0, we have ε˜ (ρ0 , S) → 0 and, therefore, ∂ψ(0, S) = µq1 q2 ψ(0, S), for all S ∈ R3 . lim (F.7) ρ0 →0 ∂r12 av,ρ0 (This is Eq. (2.11) in Patil et al. [15].) Similarly, one can derive the electron– nucleus cusp condition at, e.g., r1a = 0, for (5.1) to be
∂ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = −m1 Za ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) r =0 , for all r 2 . lim (F.8) 1a ρ0 →0 ∂r1a av,ρ0 T HEOREM F.1. Assume that m1 = m2 and q1 = q2 = −1 in (5.1). Let (S, r 12 ) denote the CM and relative coordinates and ω12 denote the angular variables of the vector r 12 . Let ψ be a nontrivial solution of (5.1) such that its local Taylor expansion near r12 = 0 is of the form 2 , for r12 small, ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = C0 (S) + C1 (S)r12 + O r12 (F.9) where C0 (S) and C1 (S) are independent of ω12 while the remainder satisfies 2 ) = C (r , S)r 2 for some bounded function C which depends on r O(r12 3 12 3 12 12 and S. Then C1 (S) = 12 C0 (S) for all S and, consequently, 2 1 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = C0 (S) 1 + r12 + O r12 (F.10) . 2 P ROOF. We substitute the RHS of (F.9) into (F.7). There is no need to take the spherical mean on the left of (F.7) anymore as the dominant term on the RHS of (F.10) does not depend on the angular variables of r12 . We therefore obtain C1 (S) = µq1 q2 C0 (S) = q1 = q2 = −1.
1 C0 (S), 2
as µ =
m1 m2 1 = , m1 + m2 2
206
G. Chen et al.
Hence 2 1 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = C0 (S) + C0 (S)r12 + O r12 2 2 1 , = C0 (S) 1 + r12 + O r12 2
which is (F.9).
It looks as though the condition (F.9) is somewhat contrived. However, useful application can be seen shortly, in Theorem F.4. Similarly, we can obtain the cusp conditions at r1a = 0, r1b = 0, r2a = 0 and r2b = 0, as given in the following. T HEOREM F.2. Let ψ be either a nontrivial solution of (5.1) or a trial wave function for (5.1). Let r1a and ω1a denote, respectively, the radial and angular variables of the vector r 1a . Assume that for r1a sufficiently small, ψ satisfies the Taylor expansion 2 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = C0 (r 2 ) + C1 (r 2 )r1a + O r1a (F.11) , r1a small, for some functions C0 and C1 depending on r 2 only, where the remainder satisfies 2 ) = C (r , r )r 2 for some bounded function C depending on r and r . O(r1a 3 1 2 1a 3 1 2 Then 2 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = C0 (r 2 )(1 − m1 Za r1a ) + O r1a (F.12) , r1a small, 2 ) = C (r , r )r 2 . where O(r1a 3 1 2 1a
P ROOF. The kinetic energy term −1/(2m1 )∇12 , after the translation z1 → z1 +
R , 2
cf. (G.1) and Fig. 27 for notation,
becomes −1/(2m1 )∇r21a which is centered at (x1 , y1 , z1 ) = (0, 0, −R/2). Now apply the Hamiltonian = − 1 ∇r2 − Za H 2m1 1a r1a 1 2 Zb Za Zb q1 q 2 Za Zb + − ∇2 − − − + + 2m2 r1b r2a r2b r12 R
(F.13)
to (F.11). We need only focus our attention locally near r1a = 0 and ignore the terms in the bracket of (F.13) as they have no effect on the singularity at r1a = 0.
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
207
We obtain 2 Za − E ψ = − 1 1 ∂ r1a H C0 (r 2 ) + C1 (r 2 )r1a · C1 (r 2 ) − 2 2m1 r1a ∂r1a r1a
+ higher order terms in r1a 1 2C1 (r 2 ) Za · C0 (r 2 ) =− − + higher order terms in r1a . 2m1 r1a r1a
To eliminate the singularity at r1a = 0 above, it is necessary that C1 (r) + Za C0 (r 2 ) = 0. m1
The above gives (F.12), as desired.
E XAMPLE F.3. The trial wave function ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = φ(r 1a )φ(r 2b ), where φ(r) = e−αr is a one-centered orbital, satisfies condition (F.11) of Theorem F.2. One can easily apply Theorem F.2 to other singularities at r1b = 0, r2a = 0 and r2b = 0. T HEOREM F.4. Let φ(r) be a sufficiently smooth function. Let the Hamiltonian represents a homonuclear case: 2 = − 1 ∇12 − 1 ∇22 − Z − Z − Z − Z + 1 + Z . H 2 2 r1a r1b r2a r2b r12 R
Then the product function
1 ψ(r 1 , r 2 ) = φ(r 1 )φ(r 2 ) 1 + r12 2
satisfies the interelectronic cusp condition as given in (F.9). P ROOF. We represent the variables r 1 and r 2 in terms of the CM coordinates 1 r 1 = S + (r 1 − r 2 ) = S + 2 1 r 2 = S − (r 1 − r 2 ) = S − 2
1 r 12 , 2 1 r 12 , 2
where S = 12 (r 1 + r 2 ). Then for r12 small, by Taylor’s expansion, 1 φ(r 1 ) = φ S + r 12 2 11 T 1 r · D 2 φ(S) · r 12 + · · · , = φ(S) + ∇φ(S) · r 12 + 2 2! 4 12
208
G. Chen et al.
1 φ(r 2 ) = φ S − r 12 2 1 11 T = φ(S) − ∇φ(S) · r 12 + r · D 2 φ(S) · r 12 − · · · . 2 2! 4 12 Therefore 1 ψ = φ(r 1 )φ(r 2 ) 1 + r12 2 1 11 T = φ(S) + ∇φ(S) · r 12 + r 12 · D 2 φ(S) · r 12 + · · · , 2 2! 4 11 T 1 1 r 12 · D 2 φ(S) · r 12 ± · · · 1 + r12 φ(S) − ∇φ(S) · r 12 + 2 2! 4 2 1 = φ 2 (S) 1 + r12 + quadratic or higher order terms involving r12 . 2
Hence condition (F.9) is satisfied.
Appendix G. Center of Mass Coordinates for the Kinetic 1 1 ∇ 21 − 2m ∇ 22 Energy − 2m 1 2 The coordinates for electron 1 and 2 are, respectively, r 1 = (x1 , y1 , z1 ),
r 2 = (x2 , y2 , z2 ).
(G.1)
The kinetic energy operator is = − 1 ∇12 − 1 ∇22 , H 2m1 2m2 where ∇j2 =
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 + 2 + 2, 2 ∂xj ∂yj ∂zj
j = 1, 2.
Define the CM (center-of-mass) coordinate S: m1 r 1 + m2 r 2 S= m1 + m2 and (relative coordinate) r 12 = r 1 − r 2 . Here we derive the kinetic energy term in coordinates S, r12 . For any differentiable scalar function f (r 1 , r 2 ), we have df = ∇1 f · dr 1 + ∇2 f · dr 2 = ∇S f · dS + ∇12 f · dr 12 ,
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
209
F IG . 27. Various vectors are defined in this diagram.
where ∇S and ∇12 are the gradient operators with respect to the variables of S and r 12 . Then dr 1 dS [∇1 f, ∇2 f ] (G.2) = [∇S f, ∇12 f ] . dr 12 dr 2 But
dS dr 12
=
m1 m1 +m2
m2 m1 +m2
1
−1
Hence from (G.2) and (G.3), [∇1 f, ∇2 f ] = [∇S f, ∇12 f ]
dr 1 . dr 2
(G.3)
m1 m1 +m2
m2 m1 +m2
1
−1
;
1 − 2m 0 1 2 1 2 ∇1 1 H =− ∇ − ∇ = [∇1 , ∇2 ] ∇2 2m1 1 2m2 2 0 − 2m1 2 m1 m2 − 1 0 2m1 m1 +m2 m1 +m2 = [∇S , ∇12 ] 1 1 −1 0 − 2m 2 m1 1 ∇S m1 +m2 × m2 ∇12 −1 m1 +m2 − 2(m11+m2 ) 0 ∇S = [∇S , ∇12 ] ; ∇12 0 −1 1 + 1 2 m1
m2
210 or
G. Chen et al. 1 1 1 1 2 + ∇S2 − ∇12 2(m1 + m2 ) 2 m1 m2 1 2 1 2 =− ∇S − ∇ , 2M 2µ 12
=− H
where M ≡ m1 + m2 is the total mass of electrons and µ ≡ mass.
m1 m2 m1 +m2
is the reduced
Appendix H. Verifications of the Cusp Conditions for Two-Centered Orbitals in Prolate Spheroidal Coordinates In the work of Patil (see Eq. (2.15) in [56]), he indicated that for the ground state ψ (i.e., with azimuth quantum number m = 0) for the molecular ion with Hamiltonian = − 1 ∇12 − Za − Zb , H (H.1) 2 ra rb the “coelescense” condition at rb = 0 can be expressed as
1 ∂ψ
1 1 ∂ψ
+ = −Zb , (H.2) 2 ψ ∂rb θ=0 ψ ∂rb θ=π rb =0 the angle θ is introduced in Fig. 28. He then indicates that the above is “essentially the same” as Kato’s cusp condition. Actually, at least two ways are viable, which are going to be described below through some concrete examples. The first way takes a limiting approach in a similar spirit as Patil’s (H.2). The second way utilizes an explicit representation.
F IG . 28. A local spherical coordinate system (ra , θ, φ).
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
211
E XAMPLE H.1. For the Hamiltonian (H.1), motivated by the Jaffé solution (4.26), let us consider a trial wave function for the ground state: ψ(λ, µ) = e−αλ 1 + B2 P2 (µ) . (H.3) We want to consider the cusp condition in terms of the undetermined coefficients α and B2 in (H.3). Recall from (A.3) that (i)
ra → 0
is equivalent to
λ → 1, µ → −1;
(ii) rb → 0 is equivalent to λ → 1, µ → 1.
(H.4) (H.5)
The singularities in the Laplacian ∇ 2 in prolate spheroidal coordinates, according to (A.3), are discerned to be contained in λ2
1 1 1 = · . 2 λ+µ λ−µ −µ
, the following: Thus, we deduce that for (H.1), after substituting (H.3) into H (i) ψ ∼ H
1 F1 (λ, µ), λ+µ
for ra ≈ 0, where λ 1, µ ≈ −1,
(H.6)
where we have dropped terms not containing the singularity (λ + µ)−1 and collected the dominant terms corresponding to singularity (λ + µ)−1 in 2 F1 (λ, µ) = − 2 −2αλe−αλ 1 + B2 P2 (µ) + λ2 − 1 α 2 R (λ − µ) × e−αλ 1 + B2 P2 (µ) + e−αλ 3B2 1 − 3µ2 2Za −αλ − 1 + B2 P2 (µ) e R (ii) 1 G1 (λ, µ), λ−µ where, similarly, Hψ ∼
for rb ≈ 0, where λ 0, µ ≈ 1,
(H.7)
−2αλe−αλ 1 + B2 P2 (µ) + λ2 − 1 α 2 e−αλ × 1 + B2 P2 (µ) + e−αλ 3B2 1 − 3µ2 2Zb −αλ − 1 + B2 P2 (µ) . e R For (H.6) and (H.7) to stay bounded, it is necessary that F1 (1, −1) = 0 and G1 (1, 1) = 0. 2Za −α 1 F1 (1, −1) = − 2 −2αe−α (1 + B2 ) − 6B2 e−α − e (1 + B2 ) = 0, R R G1 (λ, µ) = −
2
R 2 (λ + µ)
212
G. Chen et al.
i.e., 3B2 (H.8) . 1 + B2 2Zb −α 1 G1 (1, 1) = − 2 −2αe−α (1 + B2 ) − 6B2 e−α − e (1 + B2 ) R R = 0,
α = RZa −
i.e., α = RZb −
3B2 . 1 + B2
(H.9)
These are the cusp conditions at ra = 0 and rb = 0. However, we need to remark that F1 (1, −1) = 0 and G1 (1, 1) = 0 are only necessary conditions for the desired boundedness because the limits in (H.6) and (H.7) do not exist in general as λ and µ may be related in infinitely many different ways to yield totally different limits as λ → 1 and µ → ±1. Thus, the above estimation approach has an ad hoc nature. Nevertheless, (H.8) and (H.9) do provide correct answers as to be cross-validified with (H.16) and (H.17) in Example H.2. In inspecting (H.8) and (H.9), we see that they are consistent when and only when Za = Zb , i.e., the homonuclear case. Therefore, (H.3) would not be a good choice of a trial wave function in the heteronuclear case. For the heteronuclear case, taking hints from the exact solutions (4.30) and (4.35), we choose the trial wave function (λ, µ) = e−αλ eβµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) . Here, α may be different to β even though the exact solution says α = β. We have ∼ H
1 F2 (λ, µ), λ+µ
where the singular terms are collected in −2αλe−αλ eβµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) + λ2 − 1 α 2 e−αλ eβµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) + e−αλ eβµ β 2 − β 2 µ2 − 2βµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) + 2β − 2βµ2 − 2µ (B1 + 3B2 µ) ! 2Za −αλ βµ e 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) , e + 1 − µ2 3B2 − R
F2 (λ, µ) = −
2
R 2 (λ − µ)
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
213
with the terms corresponding to the dominant singularity in 1 F2 (1, −1) = − 2 e−α−β −2α(1 − B1 + B2 ) + 2β(1 − B1 + B2 ) R 2Za −α−β e + 2(B1 − 3B2 ) − (1 − B1 + B2 ), R i.e., (B1 − 3B2 ) . 1 − B1 + B2 Similarly, the behavior near rb = 0 gives α − β = RZa +
∼ H
1 G2 (λ, µ), λ−µ
where 2 −2αλe−αλ eβµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) R 2 (λ + µ) + λ2 − 1 α 2 e−αλ eβµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) + e−αλ eβµ β 2 − β 2 µ2 − 2βµ 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) + 2β − 2βµ2 − 2µ (B1 + 3B2 µ) ! 2Zb −αλ βµ e e 1 + B1 P1 (µ) + B2 P2 (µ) ; + 1 − µ2 3B2 − R 1 −α+β −2α(1 + B1 + B2 ) − 2β(1 + B1 + B2 ) G2 (1, 1) = − 2 e R 2Zb −α+β e − 2(B1 + 3B2 ) − (1 + B1 + B2 ), R
G2 (λ, µ) = −
i.e., (B1 + 3B2 ) . 1 + B1 + B2 So, the cusp conditions give α + β = RZb −
B1 = −
3(RZa + 2β − RZb ) , 2(3 + 4α − 2RZa − 2RZb − RZa α − RZa β + R 2 Za Zb − αRZb + βRZb + α 2 − β 2 )
B2 = −
(2α 2 + 2α − 2RZa α − 2αRZb − RZa + 2βRZb − 2β 2 + 2R 2 Za Zb − RZb − 2RZa β) . 2(3 + 4α − 2RZa − 2RZb − RZa α − RZa β + R 2 Za Zb − αRZb + βRZb + α 2 − β 2 )
If, in addition, we set α = β, then 3(RZa + 2α − RZb ) , 2(2RZa α − R 2 Za Zb + 2RZa − 4α + 2RZb − 3) (−2R 2 Za Zb + RZa + 4RZa α + RZb − 2α) B2 = − . 2(2RZa α − R 2 Za Zb + 2RZa − 4α + 2RZb − 3)
B1 =
214
G. Chen et al.
E XAMPLE H.2 (Verification of the cusp conditions via explicit calculations). Consider the same Hamiltonian as given in (H.1). We translate the origin from (0, 0, 0) to (0, 0, −R/2) and set up spherical coordinates (ra , θ, φ) as shown in Fig. 28. From the cosine law, cf. Fig. 28, 1/2 rb = ra2 + R 2 − 2Rra cos θ 1/2 2 cos θ 1 cos θ =R 1− =R 1− ra + 2 ra2 ra + O ra2 . (H.10) R R R ψ near ra = 0, we need only As we are exploring the singularity behavior of H concentrate on the dominant terms of ra and, thus, we drop O(ra2 ) in (H.10) and approximate rb by cos θ rb = R 1 − ra . R Using (A.3), we therefore obtain ra λ = (1 − cos θ ) + 1, R r µ = a (1 + sin θ ) − 1. R The transformation (H.11) will greatly facilitate our calculations. Consider the trial wave function (H.3) again here. We have
∂ψ ∂µ 3 ∂λ B2 −αλ 2 =e + B2 µ + 3B2 µ −α 1− . ∂ra ∂ra 2 2 ∂ra From (H.11), we have 1 λ−1 ∂λ = (1 − cos θ ) = , ∂ra R ra ∂µ 1 µ+1 = (1 + cos θ ) = , ∂ra R ra
(H.11)
(H.12)
(H.13)
so we can use (H.11) and (H.13) to rewrite (H.12) as 2 ∂ψ 3 λ−1 B2 −α[(λ−1)+1] 2 =e + B2 (µ + 1) − 1 −α 1− ∂ra ra 2 2
µ+1 + 3B2 (µ + 1) − 1 · ra −α e = · e−α(λ−1) − α(1 + B2 )(λ − 1) + 3B2 (µ + 1) ra 12 3 0 O(ra )
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS 3 2 + αB2 2(λ − 1)(µ + 1) + 3B2 (µ + 1) 2 0 12 3
215
O(ra2 )
3 2 − B2 α(λ − 1)(µ + 1) . 2 0 12 3
(H.14)
O(ra3 )
If we set ra = ρ and then substitute (H.14) into the left-hand side (LHS) of (F.8), the two rightmost brackets on the RHS of (H.14) will become O(ra ) = O(ρ) and O(ra2 ) = O(ρ 2 ), and then vanish after ρ → 0. So we only need to consider the spherical mean of ∂ψ/∂ra over a sphere with radius ρ which is given by −α e ρ 1 −αρ/R(1−cos θ) e = −α(1 + B2 ) (1 − cos θ ) ρ R 4πρ 2 Sρ
ρ − 3B2 (1 + cos θ ) ρ 2 dω R 2ππ 1 1 1 −α −αρ/R αρ/R cos θ e α(1 + B2 ) · + 3B2 · =− e e 4π R R 0 0
1 1 cos θ sin θ dθ dφ + −α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 R R 1 1 k 1 e − e−k α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 = − e−α−αρ/R 2 k R
1 1 k 1 k −k −k + − 2 e −e + e +e −α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 · , (H.15) k R k with k ≡ αρ/R. Letting ρ → 0, we have k → 0, and 1 (RHS) of (H.15) = −e−α α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 · R ≡ (RHS) of (F.8) (modified for the case of molecular ion) = −Za e−α (1 + B2 ), i.e., α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 = RZa (1 + B2 ),
(H.16)
which is exactly (H.8). Similarly, at rb = 0, we can obtain α(1 + B2 ) + 3B2 = RZb (1 + B2 ), which is exactly (H.9).
(H.17)
216
G. Chen et al.
Appendix I. Integrals with the Heitler–London Wave Functions The integrals involved in Eq. (6.8) can be separated into eight types of elementary integrals: 1 1 (i) a(1) −∇12 a(1) dx = b(2) −∇22 b(2) dy 2 2 R3
1 = 2 (ii)
1 2
1 a(1) −∇12 b(1) dx = 2 α2
αJ = R3
(vi)
αK = R3
(vii)
b(1) −∇12 b(1) dx
R3
a(2) −∇12 b(2) dx
=
α2 ; 2
R3
αJ =
1 1 1 a 2 (1) − ; dx = α − + e−2w 1 + r1b w w 1 a(1)b(1) − dx = −αe−w (1 + w); r1b
R6
(viii)
w2 a(1)b(1) dx = e−w 1 + w + ; 3
S= R3
(v)
1 2 =− 1+w− w ; 2 2 1 a 2 (1) − dx = −α; r1a
R3
(iv)
1 a(2) −∇22 a(2) dy = 2
R3
R3
(iii)
R3
1 a 2 (1)b2 (2) dx dy r12
1 11 3 1 1 =α − e−2w + + w + w2 ; w w 8 4 6 1 αK = a(1)b(1)a(2)b(2) dx dy r12 R6
=
1 1 25 23 α −e−2w − + w + 3w 2 + w 3 5 8 4 3
6 2 + S (γ + ln w) + S 2 Ei (−4w) − 2SS Ei (−2w) , w
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
217
where w ≡ αR; 1 S ≡ ew 1 − w + w 2 ; 3 1 γ = Euler’s constant =
1 − e−t dt − t
∞
0
e−t dt = 0.57722 . . . ; t
1
∞ Ei (x) = integral logarithm = −(P.V.) −x
e−t dt t
(for x > 0),
here P.V. means “principal value” of a singular integral.
Appendix J. Derivations Related to the Laplacian for Section 6.4 Evaluation of the Laplacian in the prolate spheroidal coordinates for the general form of the wave function which includes electron–electron correlations explicitly is a demanding task. Here we provide the details of the calculations. The general form of each term in the wave function is s (1, 2) =
1 s (1)s (2)Ps (r12 ) 2π
(J.1)
with s (1) = Fs (λ1 )Gs (µ1 )
(J.2)
s (λ2 )M s (µ2 ). s (2) = F
(J.3)
and
It can readily be seen that the Laplacian ∇12 operates only on s (1). According to (A.6): ∂ (λ21 − µ21 ) ∂2 4 ∂ 2 λ1 − 1 ∇12 s (1) = + 2 2 2 2 2 2 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 R (λ1 − µ1 ) (λ1 − 1)(1 − µ1 ) ∂φ1 +
∂ ∂ 1 − µ21 s (1) ∂µ1 ∂µ1
218
G. Chen et al.
2 (λ1 − µ21 )Fs Gs ∂ 2 Ps 4 2 2 R 2 (λ1 − µ1 ) (λ21 − 1)(1 − µ21 ) ∂φ12 ∂(Fs Ps ) ∂ 2 ∂ 2 ∂(Gs Ps ) λ −1 1 − µ1 + Fs . + Gs ∂λ1 1 ∂λ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 (J.4) We first single out part of the second term in the square bracket above for further evaluation to obtain
∂(Fs Ps ) ∂ 2 ∂Fs ∂Ps ∂ 2 λ1 − 1 λ1 − 1 Ps = + Fs ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂Fs 2 ∂Fs ∂Ps ∂ 2 = Ps + 2 λ1 − 1 λ1 − 1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 ∂Ps ∂ 2 λ −1 + Fs . (J.5) ∂λ1 1 ∂λ1 =
Similarly, part of the third term inside the square bracket of (J.4) becomes
∂(Gs Ps ) ∂Gs ∂Ps ∂ ∂ = + Gs 1 − µ21 1 − µ21 Ps ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂ ∂G ∂Gs ∂Ps s 1 − µ21 + 2(1 − µ21 ) = Ps ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 ∂ ∂P s + Gs . (J.6) 1 − µ21 ∂µ1 ∂µ1 We can rewrite the Laplacian to take into account the separable functional dependence of the three parts of the wave function, that is, ∇ 2 Fs ∇ 2 Gs ∇ 2 Ps 1 2∇1 Fs · ∇1 Ps + 1 + ∇12 s (1) = 1 + 1 s (1) Fs Gs Ps Fs Ps 2∇1 Gs · ∇1 Ps + , Gs Ps
(J.7)
since ∇1 s (1) =
2(λ21 − 1)1/2 ∂s (1) 2(1 − µ21 )1/2 ∂s (1) eλ1 + e µ1 2 2 R(λ1 − µ1 )1/2 ∂λ1 R(λ21 − µ21 )1/2 ∂µ1 ∂s (1) 2 + e φ1 , (J.8) 2 2 1/2 1/2 ∂φ1 R(λ1 − 1) (1 − µ1 )
where, eλ1 , eµ1 , and eφ1 are the unit vectors pointing to the respective directions. Now, we use the actual functional forms of various parts of the wave function to complete the evaluation of the expectation value of the Laplacian. Setting
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS
219
s Fs (λ1 ) = e−αλ1 λm 1 , we obtain
∇12 Fs = = =
=
=
∂ ∂ 2 4 Fs λ1 − 1 2 ∂λ1 − µ1 ) ∂λ1 ! ∂ 2 4 s λ1 − 1 −αe−αλ1 λm + ms e−αλ1 λ1ms −1 1 2 2 R 2 (λ1 − µ1 ) ∂λ1 ∂ 4 s −αe−αλ1 λ1ms +2 − λm 1 2 2 2 ∂λ R (λ1 − µ1 ) 1 ! + ms e−αλ1 λ1ms +1 − λ1ms −1 4 s α 2 e−αλ1 λ1ms +2 − λm 1 2 2 R 2 (λ1 − µ1 ) − αe−αλ1 (ms + 2)λ1ms +1 − ms λ1ms −1 ms −2 s + ms e−αλ1 (ms + 1)λm 1 − (ms − 1)λ1 ! − ms αe−αλ1 λ1ms +1 − λ1ms −1 1 4Fs 2 2 α − 1 − 2α (m + 1)λ − m λ s 1 s 1 λ1 R 2 (λ21 − µ21 )
1 + ms (ms + 1) − (ms − 1) 2 . λ1 R 2 (λ21
j
Similarly, setting Gs (µ1 ) = µ1s , we obtain ∂ ∂ 4 1 − µ21 Gs 2 ∂µ1 − µ1 ) ∂µ1 ∂ 4 j −1 1 − µ21 js µ1s = 2 2 2 R (λ1 − µ1 ) ∂µ1 4Gs 1 js (js − 1) 2 − js (js + 1) . = R 2 (λ21 − µ21 ) µ1
∇12 Gs =
R 2 (λ21
(J.9)
Since the effect of the Laplacian on a given function is coordinate-free, we can consider the evaluation of ∇12 Ps (r12 ), through the spherical coordinates for a general function f (r12 ) of r12 to obtain ∇12 f (r12 ) = ∇r212 f (r12 ) =
1 d 2 df (r12 ) r12 . 2 dr dr12 r12 12
(J.10)
, Thus, with Ps (r12 ) = r12
∇12 Ps =
( + 1) 1 2 −2 −1 r12 l(l − 1)r12 = + 2r12 r12 Ps . r12 r12
(J.11)
220
G. Chen et al.
The other terms involved are ∂Ps −1 ∂r12 = lr12 ∂λ1 ∂λ1 2 R lPs M 2λ1 − 2λ2 µ1 µ2 − 2 cos(φ1 − φ2 )2λ1 = 2 8r12 λ1 − 1 Mλ1 R 2 lPs λ cos(φ − λ µ µ − − φ ) = 1 2 1 2 1 2 2 4r12 (λ21 − 1) 2 (λ21 − 1) λ1 R 2 lPs λ = − 1 − λ µ µ − M cos(φ − φ ) 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 (λ2 − 1) λ1 4r12 1 4 2 λ1 2λ2 µ1 µ2 R 2 lPs 2 2 2 2 , r + λ − λ − µ − µ + = 1 2 1 2 2 (λ2 − 1) R 2 12 λ1 8r12 1 (J.12) and
∂Ps R 2 lPs M 2µ1 − 2λ1 λ2 µ2 − cos(φ1 − φ2 )(−2µ1 ) = 2 ∂µ1 8r12 (1 − µ21 ) Mµ1 R 2 lPs µ cos(φ − λ λ µ + − φ ) = 1 1 2 2 1 2 2 4r12 (1 − µ21 ) (1 − µ21 ) µ1 R 2 lPs − 1 − µ21 + λ1 λ2 µ2 =− 2 2 µ1 4r12 (1 − µ1 ) − M cos(φ1 − φ2 )
4 2 µ1 2λ1 λ2 µ2 R 2 lPs 2 2 2 2 . r − λ − λ + µ − µ + 1 2 1 2 2 (1 − µ2 ) R 2 12 µ1 8r12 1 (J.13) Upon putting the above together, the Laplacian operation part of the Hamiltonian takes the form =−
1 ∇ 2 s (1) s (1) 1
2 ∇ 2 Gs ∇ 2 Ps ∇1 Fs 2∇1 Fs · ∇1 Ps 2∇1 Gs · ∇1 Ps = + 1 + 1 + + Fs Gs Ps Fs Ps Gs Ps 4 1 2 2 = α λ − 1 − 2α (m + 1)λ − m s 1 s 1 λ1 R 2 (λ21 − µ21 )
1 + ms (ms + 1) − (ms − 1) 2 λ1
ELECTRON MOLECULAR BONDS 221 4 1 ( + 1) + js (js − 1) 2 − js (js + 1) + 2 2 2 2 R (λ1 − µ1 ) µ1 r12 1 (−αλ1 + ms ) + 2 (λ1 − µ21 ) 2λ2 µ1 µ2