VOLUME 44
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY
VOLUME 44
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY EDITORS:
ELI GRUSHK A Hebrew University ...
30 downloads
811 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
VOLUME 44
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY
VOLUME 44
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY EDITORS:
ELI GRUSHK A Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem, Israel
NELU GRINBERG Boehringer-Ingelheim Pharmaceutical, Inc. Riverside, Connecticut, U.S.A.
Boca Raton London New York
A CRC title, part of the Taylor & Francis imprint, a member of the Taylor & Francis Group, the academic division of T&F Informa plc.
Published in 2005 by CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2005 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number-10: 0-0000-0000-0 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number-13: 978-0-0000-0000-0 (Hardcover) Library of Congress Card Number XX-XXXXX This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC) 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Authorxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx titlexxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx p. cm. xxxxxxxxxxxxx Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-0000-0000-0 xxxxxxxxxx 1xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx 2004 xxxxxx'xx--dc22
XX-XXXXX
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com Taylor & Francis Group is the Academic Division of T&F Informa plc.
and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
Foreword With Volume 44 of the Advances in Chromatography series I say goodbye, reluctantly, to Phyllis R. Brown, who served as one of the editors of the series. Advances in Chromatography was started by J. Calvin Giddings and Roy A. Keller in 1965. Very quickly, the series became an important tool for quick dissemination of new developments in the field. In Volume 12 of the series (1975) Jack Cazes and I joined Giddings and Keller as editors. In 1976 (Volume 14) Phyllis replaced Roy Keller. Jack Cazes left the series in the mid 1980s and Cal Giddings stepped down from his position as executive editor in 1993. Over the last 10 years or so Phyllis and I were the sole editors of the Advances in Chromatography series. Several years ago Phyllis retired from her position as a chemistry professor at the University of Rhode Island, and now she has decided that the time has come to hand over her editorial responsibilities to the younger generation. Nelu Grinberg was selected to replace Phyllis, and with this volume he makes his debut as an editor. Phyllis served as an editor for almost 30 years. In many respects she was the primary moving force of the series. The fact that Advances in Chromatography is still going strong after 40 years is due to her foresight, determination, diligence, and perseverance. Phyllis has a very good eye for recognizing the latest developments in chromatography and related techniques. Her purpose was always to “bring to our readers the latest developments and advances at the forefront of the field.” Using her many acquaintances and contacts, we succeeded in staying on top of the field and providing our readers with up-to-date reviews in all areas of chromatography and other elution techniques. Based on her own research, Phyllis recognized very early the usefulness of HPLC in life sciences. She saw to it that the Advances in Chromatography series educates its readers about the power of the technique as applied to the biological field. I want to thank Phyllis very much for her friendship as well as for her help, encouragement, and patience all through our years together as editors. I would like to welcome Nelu Grinberg as my new co-editor. I have known Nelu for many years and I am well familiar with the caliber of his work and with his commitment, as a scientist, to excellence. Nelu and I will strive to maintain the excellence of the series that was so important to Phyllis. Judging from the cooperation between us in producing the present volume of the Advances in Chromatography, the future of the series remains bright. Eli Grushka Jerusalem
Contributors Andrew J. Alpert PolyLC, Inc. Columbia, Maryland Gabriela Cimpan Sirius Analytical Instruments, Ltd. Forest Row, U.K. John Comer Sirius Analytical Instruments, Ltd. Forest Row, U.K. Mauricio Dantus Merck and Company Rahway, New Jersey Andrew G. Ewing Departments of Chemistry and Neural and Behavioral Sciences The Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania Simion Gocan Analytical Chemistry Department Babes-Bolyai University Cluj-Napoca, Romania Michael J. Gray Nanoscale Organisation and Dynamics Group University of Western Sydney Sydney, Australia
Tyge Greibrokk Department of Chemistry University of Oslo Oslo, Norway Y.V. Kazakevich Seton Hall University South Orange, New Jersey R. LoBrutto Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation East Hanover, New Jersey Elsa Lundanes Department of Chemistry University of Oslo Oslo, Norway Tracy L. Paxon Department of Chemistry The Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania R. Andrew Shalliker Nanoscale Organisation and Dynamics Group University of Western Sydney Sydney, Australia Rodger W. Stringham Chiral Technologies, Inc. West Chester, Pennsylvania
Table of Contents Chapter 1 Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips ...........................................................1 Tracy L. Paxon and Andrew G. Ewing Chapter 2 Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography ....................................................45 Elsa Lundanes and Tyge Greibrokk Chapter 3 Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography.......................................79 Simion Gocan, Gabriela Cimpan, and John Comer Chapter 4 Concepts and Practice of Multidimensional High-Performance Liquid Chromatography ....................................................................................................177 R. Andrew Shalliker and Michael J. Gray Chapter 5 High-Performance Liquid Chromatography in the Pharmaceutical Industry: Application, Validation, and Regulatory Issues Under the PAT Framework .......237 Mauricio Dantus Chapter 6 The Use of Polysaccharide Phases in the Separation of Enantiomers.................257 Rodger W. Stringham Chapter 7 Chaotropic Effects in RP-HPLC ...........................................................................291 R. LoBrutto and Y.V. Kazakevich Chapter 8 Chromatography of Difficult and Water-Insoluble Proteins with Organic Solvents....................................................................................................317 Andrew J. Alpert Index......................................................................................................................331
1
Separations in MultipleChannel Microchips Tracy L. Paxon The Pennsylvania State University, University Park
Andrew G. Ewing The Pennsylvania State University, University Park
CONTENTS 1.1 1.2
1.3
1.4 1.5
1.6
1.7
Introduction ......................................................................................................2 Microfabrication of Multiple-Channel Microchips .........................................3 1.2.1 Glass Substrates ...................................................................................3 1.2.2 Polymer Substrates...............................................................................3 Multiple-Channel Microchip Designs .............................................................4 1.3.1 Rectilinear Microchip Designs ............................................................4 1.3.2 Radial Microchip Designs ...................................................................6 1.3.3 Bioassay Microchip Designs ...............................................................8 1.3.4 Continuous Sample Introduction Microchip Designs .........................8 Channel Filling and Sample Loading..............................................................8 Injection Methods ............................................................................................9 1.5.1 T-Type Injections................................................................................10 1.5.2 Optically Gated Injection...................................................................13 1.5.3 Capillary Sample Introduction...........................................................15 Detection Methods .........................................................................................17 1.6.1 Single-Point Confocal Detection .......................................................18 1.6.2 Translation-Stage Confocal Detection...............................................18 1.6.3 Scanning Methods of Detection ........................................................19 1.6.3.1 Confocal Fluorescence Detection with a Galvanometric Scanner.......................................................19 1.6.3.2 Confocal Fluorescence Detection with a Rotary Scanner....................................................................19 1.6.3.3 Fluorescence Detection with an Acousto-Optical Deflection Scanner..............................................................22 1.6.4 Fluorescence Detection with a Charge-Coupled Device (CCD) ......22 Applications of Multiple-Channel Microchips..............................................23 1.7.1 DNA Separations ...............................................................................24
1
2
Advances in Chromatography
1.7.1.1
Separations Involving Restriction Enzyme Digests — DNA Fragment Analysis ....................................................24 1.7.1.2 Genotyping..........................................................................25 1.7.1.3 Sequencing in Multiple-Channel Microchips ....................27 1.7.2 Affinity Electrophoresis for Immunoassays in Microchips ..............29 1.7.3 Dynamic Analysis of Reactions with Multiple-Channel Electrophoresis ...................................................................................30 1.7.3.1 Application to DNA............................................................30 1.7.3.2 Application to RNA Reactions...........................................32 1.8 Conclusions and Future Perspectives ............................................................32 Acknowledgments....................................................................................................35 References................................................................................................................35
1.1 INTRODUCTION Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has been reviewed extensively for a variety of applications [1]. The technique provides fast separation times and small sample requirements; however, CE is a serial technique that significantly limits throughput. To address this, capillary array electrophoresis, in which separations are performed in an array of parallel silica capillaries, was introduced by Mathies [2] and subsequently has been used to perform high-speed, high-throughput deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sequencing [3, 4] and DNA fragment sizing [5]. This method has proven to be an invaluable technique for the completion of the human genome project. However, sample introduction into a large number of capillaries and the physical manipulation of these capillaries can be difficult and cumbersome. The miniaturization of capillary electrophoresis onto a microchip was thus realized in the early 1990s [6] and miniaturization has been used to increase performance by reducing analysis times and reagent volumes [6−9]. Since then, extensive advances have been made in the area of microchip technology, allowing for the analysis of a variety of substances including amino acids [10], small drug molecules [11], peptides [12], oligonucleotides [13], proteins [14, 15], and DNA fragments [16]. Initial microchip separation devices consisted of a single separation channel and a T-type injector. Developments have since been made to multiplex many separation channels on a single microchip, thereby providing a means to achieve high throughput separations [16−25]. However, multiple channels require multiple reservoirs, thus increasing the complexity of multi-channel microchip designs. Other factors that must be considered when dealing with multiplexed microchips include fabrication, bonding, filling, sample introduction, and complex electronics required to perform injections and separations, as well as simultaneous detection for multiple separations. The objective of this chapter is to present recent advances in multichannel microchip design, sample introduction, and detection of various analytes for high throughput analyses.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
3
1.2 MICROFABRICATION OF MULTIPLE-CHANNEL MICROCHIPS Microchip fabrication is based on techniques developed by the semiconductor industry and has traditionally been performed on glass substrates but polymeric microchips have also been produced. The multi-channel microchip fabrication process is similar to the process for single channel microchips; however, the masks become increasingly more complex with an increase in channel number. Additionally, fabrication of large numbers of channels on a single microchip requires the substrates to be essentially free of defects. Thus, the challenge is to fabricate defect-free multiplechannel microchips in a reproducible, cost-effective manner. Developments to this effect have been reviewed by Gao et al. [26], and therefore will be only briefly discussed here.
1.2.1 GLASS SUBSTRATES Channels and other microchip features are typically defined on glass plates using photolithography and wet chemical etching techniques [7, 9, 27−29]. Microchips have been fabricated on soda lime glass slides and, more commonly for multiplechannel microchips, on Borofloat glass wafers. The traditional photolithographic process normally begins with the deposition of various metals followed by layers of photoresist onto a clean glass substrate; however, amorphous silicon has recently been used as a sacrificial mask prior to photoresist deposition [16, 30]. In the modified protocol, glass substrates are pre-etched in hydrofluoric acid followed by deposition of a thin layer of amorphous silicon using a plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition system [30]. Spin-coating a layer of photoresist onto the plate and subsequent illumination of the substrate through a mask containing the multiplechannel pattern follows. The photoresist is developed and the channel pattern is transferred to the silicon film by reactive etching with SF6 plasma. The channels are then etched into the glass by a concentrated hydrofluoric acid solution. The photoresist layer is stripped off with high-pressure O2 plasma. Holes are drilled into either the etched plate or a second glass plate that has not been subjected to this procedure, to provide access holes to each channel. The plates are finally aligned and thermally bonded, thereby enclosing the channels [31].
1.2.2 POLYMER SUBSTRATES Polymeric materials have been employed as alternative substrates as they lend themselves to mass fabrication of affordable microfluidic devices [32−37]. Currently, the most widely used replication process to fabricate channel structures for separations is hot embossing [32, 33, 38, 39]. After fabrication of the master, the master and planar polymer substrate are heated, placed under vacuum and brought together with a controlled force. This force presses the channel structure into the polymer, creating the desired microstructures. Alternatively, injection molding is used in polymer microchip fabrication. In this process, the raw polymer material in granular form is melted and injected under high pressure into an evacuated cavity containing
4
Advances in Chromatography
the master [32, 40–42]. The molten polymer cools in a few seconds, allowing for rapid production of identical structures. Casting is another polymer microchip fabrication method in which a mixture of an elastomer precursor and its curing agent are poured over the master template [32, 34, 36, 37]. After a few hours, the solidified polymer is removed from the master, exposing the desired channel structure. Regardless of the fabrication technique used, the open channels must be bonded to a planar surface to form closed channels that can be used for separations. There are a variety of methods for bonding including lamination, gluing, heat, and pressure application, laser welding, and ultrasonic welding. For more information on these polymer methods, refer to Becker and Gartner [32].
1.3 MULTIPLE-CHANNEL MICROCHIP DESIGNS Significant advances have been made over the last 10 years in the area of multiplechannel microchips. Channel layouts have progressed from single channels, with as many as four reservoirs for sample introduction, to as many as 384 channels with 481 reservoirs for separation and sample introduction, respectively, as demonstrated by Mathies and coworkers [31]. Since the fabrication of multiple features on a glass microchip does not significantly increase the cost of production, as compared to fabrication of a single feature, parallelization is a cost effective way to increase throughput. All of the components of a microchip are fabricated on a single substrate. However, as the number of separation channels and reservoirs increases, so does the complexity of sample loading, electrical connections to apply injection and separation potentials, as well as parallel channel detection. Thus, microchip design is continually being improved to achieve higher throughput and address the challenges of chip complexity. Several chip designs have emerged from such development and include rectilinear, radial, and bioassay microchips.
1.3.1 RECTILINEAR MICROCHIP DESIGNS Parallel analysis on a microchip was demonstrated in 1994 by Wooley and Mathies when they performed ultra-high-speed DNA fragment separations on a parallelchannel microchip [43]. In this microchip design, 15 channels are etched into soda lime glass. The channel dimensions vary in size to include 3.5 cm long by 30, 50, and 70 μm wide channels, with 30, 70, and 120 μm cross-channels. Their work has characterized two different injection methods — stack injection and plug injection — and addresses both the effect of channel geometry and the effect of electric field on separation. Procedures to fill these channels with hydroxyethyl cellulose- (HEC) sieving matrices has been developed, and separations of FX174 Hae III fragments with excellent resolution achieved in less than 2 minutes. Additionally, ultra-highspeed DNA sequencing has been accomplished on similar microchips using fourcolor fluorescence detection [44]. In an attempt to simplify detection, Woolley and coworkers [24] have designed and fabricated a capillary array electrophoresis microchip (Figure 1.1a) that has the capacity to analyze 12 different samples in parallel in under 160 seconds. This microchip design consists of 12 independent pairs of injection (A, 8 mm long) and
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
5
FIGURE 1.1 (a) Mask design for the 12-channel capillary array electrophoresis chip for highspeed DNA genotyping. (From Woolley, 1997.) (b) Mask design of the 16-channel capillary electrophoresis chip for parallel DNA sequencing. Sixteen identical 250 μm twin-T injectors are used for all channels. (Inset) Detail of the compensation of different channel lengths. (From Liu, 2000.) (c) Mask pattern for the 96-sample capillary array electrophoresis microplate for genetic analysis. (From Simpson, 1998.)
separation (B, 8 μm deep, 60 μm wide, and 60 mm long) channels, as well as two optical alignment channels (C), which are patterned and etched on a glass microscope slide. With just 12 channels, 41 access holes are required to provide sample, buffer, and waste reservoirs on this microchip. These studies provide a separation method in which high-speed, parallel separations of DNA restriction fragments and PCR products can be analyzed. Furthermore, this microchip design demonstrates that microfabricated multi-channel microchips provide a powerful method for rapid highthroughput DNA diagnostics in which ten base pair (bp) resolution has been achieved. Studies to perform DNA sequencing on a 16-channel microchip (Figure 1.1b) has been completed by Liu et al. [45] This microchip is fabricated on a 10-cm diameter wafer with two eight-channel groups, each with a common anode reservoir. Each channel has its own sample and waste reservoir in the twin-T injector configuration as well as its own cathode reservoir. The Mathies group has expanded upon previous work by creating a capillary array electrophoresis microchip in which two different samples are serially separated in 48 parallel channels for a total of 96 sample analyses [30]. The microchip design
6
Advances in Chromatography
employed in these experiments consists of 48 individual separation channels etched in a 150 μm periodic array in the detection region (Figure 1.1c) [30]. The channels branch out to form an 8 × 12 array of reservoirs. These arrays of reservoirs are spaced 9 mm apart such that samples and buffer can be loaded via an eight-channel pipettor. The separation channels are 10 cm in length, spanning the area between the injection region and the anode. Two injection reservoirs (B and C) are coupled to each separation channel, thus allowing for individual serial injections into each channel. In order to simplify the microchip design, the researchers group the channels such that only one waste reservoir (D) is required for every four channels. By the same rationale, the cathode reservoirs (E) are connected to groups of six or twelve channels. The anode (F) is placed off-center and is common to all 48 channels. Overall, 127 holes are drilled into the etched plate to provide access to the channels, followed by thermal bonding to a flat glass wafer. The investigators report high quality bonding over the entire surface of the microchip. Using this device, 96 samples have been separated in two runs of 48 samples (corresponding to the samples in reservoirs B and C) in less than 8 minutes. Nineteen different samples have been dispensed among the 96 sample reservoirs, thereby providing five-fold redundancy in sample analysis. This work further multiplexes separation channels on a microchip by combining reservoirs to reduce the number of access holes thereby creating a more simplified device; however, this design can result in sample cross-contamination. Serial injections are an effective method of increasing the sample throughput with a limited number of separation channels and will be discussed in detail later in this review.
1.3.2 RADIAL MICROCHIP DESIGNS The design, fabrication, and operation of a radial capillary array electrophoresis microchip and scanner for high-throughput DNA analysis was presented in 1999 and has been applied in various DNA applications including genotyping, sequencing and single nucleotide polymorphism typing [16, 30, 46–49]. A 96-channel radial microplate (Figure 1.2a) has more recently been used for the detection of 2,4,6trinitrotoluene (TNT) [50]. These applications are discussed later in this review. This microchip consists of 96 individual channels in a radial design with a common anode reservoir in the center of a circular 10 cm-diameter wafer and an array of channels extending toward injector units at the perimeter of the wafer [16]. The distance from the injector to the detection point is 33 mm. Channels are grouped into four 24channel quadrants, each terminating at the center of the microchip. Access holes for each of the reservoirs have been drilled prior to thermal bonding. This radial design is preferred over former rectilinear designs [24, 30] because it is easier to fabricate and all of the channels are straight, thereby eliminating resolution problems associated with curved channels [51]. Additionally, the radial design allows for the use of a radial scanner for detection purposes. This will be discussed further in the section on detectors [16]. Additional studies by the Mathies group have led to the development of a 96folded-channel radial microchip (Figure 1.2b) in order to improve separation efficiency [49]. Initial studies considered the parameters that cause turn-induced band
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
7
FIGURE 1.2 (a) Mask pattern for the 96-channel radial capillary array electrophoresis microchip utilized for various DNA applications including genotyping and single nucleotide polymorphism typing, as well as the detection of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene. (From Medintz, 2000.) (b) Mask pattern used to form a 96-channel radial capillary array electrophoresis microplate with folded channels for increased (16 cm) separation length. Enlarged view of the folded-channel layout and the novel hyper-turn geometry. (From Medintz, 2001.) (c) Layout of the 384-lane capillary array electrophoresis microchip on a 200 mm diameter wafer for ultra-high throughput genetic analysis. (From Emrich, 2002.)
broadening and investigated ways to modify channel geometry such that the broadening could be reduced [52]. These devices are a modified version of the aforementioned 96-channel microchips and have been fabricated using the same method. By using optimized folded channels, separation quality is maintained while the separation efficiency is significantly enhanced due to the increased channel length. The investigators suggest these devices will be useful in the development of optimized DNA-sequencing multi-channel microchips with enhanced performance, throughput, and device packing [47, 49, 52, 53]. In fact, the 96-folded-channel radial microchip has been used for DNA genotyping and sequencing [47, 49]. The pioneering work with 96-channel radial microchips has enabled the design, fabrication, and implementation of a 384-channel radial microchip (Figure 1.2c)
8
Advances in Chromatography
[31] for massively parallel genetic analysis, providing a new tool for accelerating gene mapping, pharmacogenomic screening, forensics, and proteomics. This microchip design consists of 4 quadrants of 24 quartets distributed radially around a common anode reservoir. Each channel has its own unique sample reservoir and each quartet shares a common cathode. This microchip contains no waste reservoirs; therefore, injections are made directly onto the separation lanes. The elimination of waste reservoirs allows for more tightly packed channels but also results in less well-defined sample plugs, as described below. The researchers report that using a multiple-step electrokinetic injection method along with short injection times helps to minimize the size-biased injection effect of the less well-defined sample plug [31].
1.3.3 BIOASSAY MICROCHIP DESIGNS To date, DNA analysis has been the major focus of the multiplexed microchip designs presented but work to integrate immunoassays onto microchips is underway in several laboratories. Initial studies have focused on single channel devices [54–61], although there has been a recent desire to incorporate multiple bioassay channels onto a single device [50, 62–66]. To this end, Cheng et al. [62] have designed a sixchannel microfluidic immunoassay device. This device consists of six independent mixing, reaction, and separation channels as well as two channels for alignment purposes (Figure 1.3) [62]. The separation channels are 9.3 cm in length and bent around two or three corners in order to fit on the substrate. The corners are rounded to a curvature of 300 μm such that sample plug distortion is minimized [51]. Using this device, simultaneous direct immunoassays for ovalbumin and for anti-estradiol have been performed. Mixing, reaction, and separation have been performed within 60 seconds in all cases and in less than 30 seconds when optimized conditions are employed. Another high-throughput homogeneous immunoassay for the sensitive detection of TNT has been developed by Bromberg and Mathies using the 96-channel radial capillary array electrophoresis microdevices previously described [50].
1.3.4 CONTINUOUS SAMPLE INTRODUCTION MICROCHIP DESIGNS Several microchip designs have been developed to facilitate sample introduction and will be discussed in detail in the injection methods section. Briefly, the Ewing group has utilized straight channels for multiplexing separations using optically gated sample introduction as well as straight, open channels with a specialized capillary sample introduction scheme [66–69]. These unique methods of sample introduction have allowed dynamic reactions to be studied with minimal user intervention.
1.4 CHANNEL FILLING AND SAMPLE LOADING In single channel microchip electrophoresis, channel filling is straightforward. The separation media is placed in one reservoir and is either vacuum- or pressure-pumped through the lane. Multiplexing this process is not a trivial task but the concept remains the same as for single channel devices. Different methods have been developed to facilitate channel filling and sample loading. A single pipette is often used
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
9
FIGURE 1.3 Illustration of the six-channel layout of the immunoassay device referred to as SPIDY. Each reaction cell has reservoirs for sample (S1), antibody (S2), sample injection waste (SW), and running buffer (B). Expansion on the left illustrates the sample loading double-T injector design. The bottom right expansion illustrates the antibody (Ab) and antigen (Ag) mixer in the reaction cell. The lower left expansion illustrates the pattern of channels at the buffer waste (BW) reservoirs used during separations. Expansion in the upper right of the detection zone, across which a laser beam is swept, illustrates the separation of two components in the size separation channels. (From Cheng, 2001.)
to fill a single channel or multiple channels on a simple microchip; however, as the number of channels on the microchip increases, this process becomes increasingly difficult. In one approach, an 8-channel pipette has been used to load sample onto a 16-channel microchip from a microtiter plate (a second transfer is required to load all 16 samples) [45]. In another approach, a capillary array for filling 96 reservoirs (Figure 1.4) has been developed by the Mathies group [16], providing a simple method for simultaneously transferring separation medium into a radial 96-channel microchip. In this method, pressure is applied and all 96 channels are filled simultaneously. Samples are loaded onto this microchip in a similar manner. The advantage of capillary sample introduction in this method is that the rectilinear format of the microtiter plate can be coupled to the radial design of the previously described highdensity microchips.
1.5 INJECTION METHODS Sample injection is a straightforward process on a microchip but as the number of channels increases, so does the complexity of the electronics required to perform the injections. For a thorough review of sample introduction techniques for
10
Advances in Chromatography
FIGURE 1.4 Schematic of the 96-sample capillary loader. Pressurization of the rectilinear microtiter dish chamber (left) is used to transfer 96 samples to the sample reservoirs of the radial microplate (right). (From Shi, 1999.)
microfabricated separations devices, readers are directed to Roddy et al. [67] Three common methods of sample injection — T-type, optical gating, and capillary sample introduction — will be discussed briefly below.
1.5.1 T-TYPE INJECTIONS T-type injection was originally developed for single lane microchips [6, 7, 70]; however, it has also been extensively applied in the area of multiplexed microchips [31, 71]. Typically, a single channel with a side arm (sample channel) is used to perform these injections. A potential is first applied across the sample channel to load the sample, and the potential is switched and then applied across the separation channel to accomplish separation (Figure 1.5a). Various other T-type injectors have been developed to improve the control of fluid flow within the microchip channels and to increase the reproducibility of sample plug volumes, including the cross-T [24, 25, 43, 72, 73], twin-T [16, 46, 47, 49, 74], and double cross-T [30, 62]. In the cross-T injection design, as developed by Harrison and coworkers, potential is applied across the sample channel, filling the region where the channels intersect. The potential is then switched and applied across the separation channel to accomplish separation (Figure 1.5b) [27]. As shown in Figure 1.1a and Figure 1.1b, the cross-T has been applied to multiplexed microchips; however, the large number of reservoirs required for this approach quickly becomes too cumbersome to individually address. Effenhauser and coworkers designed a double-T injector that has been more recently applied to multi-channel microchips [9, 13, 30, 62, 75] and requires fewer reservoirs. The Mathies group has utilized a double-T injection scheme on their rectilinear 48-channel microchip (Figure 1.6) [30] in an attempt to minimize the number of separation channels. As a result, twice as many samples can be analyzed with half the number of separation channels. The development of radial microchips has allowed for a significant reduction of reservoirs by incorporating a single common anode at the center of the microchip [16, 31, 46, 48–50, 53, 74]. Each of the radial
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
Buffer reservoir
11
Buffer reservoir +
+ Sample reservoir +
Sample reservoir Sample waste +
Waste reservoir
Buffer waste
Injection
Separation (a)
Injection
Separation (b)
FIGURE 1.5 (a) Typical microchip schematic including sample injection (left) and sample separation (right) using T-type injection. Potential is applied between positive and ground. The arrows indicate the direction of flow in the channel. (Adapted from Manz, 1992.) (b) Typical microchip schematic including sample injection (left) and separation (right) using a cross T-injector. Potential is applied between positive and ground. The arrows indicate the direction of flow in the channel. (From Harrison, 1993.)
microchips discussed in this chapter utilize various T-type injection schemes. Both the 96-straight-channel microchip and the 96-folded-channel microchip function with twin-T injectors [16, 46–49, 53, 74] (Figure 1.7a) [74]. However, the 384channel microchip utilizes the simpler, more compact T-type injector (Figure 1.7b) [31]. Additional studies have focused on investigating both the T-type and cross-T injection configurations in narrow sample channels [71, 72] to eliminate the need for leakage control during the injection process (Figure 1.8) [72]. In this design, eight parallel separation channels with different injection designs are employed with a common anode and a common cathode for the application of separation potential. The sample channels are of smaller dimension than traditional sizes used and have been studied to optimize injection on microfabricated devices. The fabrication of these microchips involves production of a glass master and subsequent pouring of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) onto the master to form the channel structures. Each of the eight channels is individually equipped with a set of sample injection and waste reservoirs by punching holes in the PDMS layer at both ends of the sample channel. In this design, the sample channel widths are one fifth that of the separation channel. Using these narrow sample channels, a 10-fold increase in sensitivity and a 2-fold increase in column efficiency over conventional injection methods have been reported. Additionally, the narrow sample channels decrease injection volumes; thus, no leakage control is required and this narrow channel injection method provides a simplified version of traditional cross and T-type injectors [62]. Additional studies by Beard and coworkers have investigated field-amplified sample stacking of biogenic amines on microfabricated electrophoresis devices [71]. The stacking method utilizes T-type injection through narrow sample channels on a six-channel microchip where all channels share both the anodic and cathodic
12
Advances in Chromatography Sample 1
Sample 2
B
C
Cathode
Anode D
Waste
Cathode
Anode Sample 1
Sample 2
B
C (a)
Waste
Waste
Cathode
Anode
Cathode
Anode
Sample 1
Sample 2
Sample 1
Sample 2
(b)
(c)
Waste
Waste
Cathode
Anode
Cathode
Anode
Sample 1
Sample 2
Sample 1
Sample 2
(d)
(e)
FIGURE 1.6 (a) Layout of the double-T sample injector. The sample injector includes four sample reservoirs, two separation columns, and one common waste reservoir, labeled as in Figure 1.1c. (b–e) Fluorescence images illustrating the operation of the injector with fluorescein. (From Simpson, 1998).
reservoirs (Figure 1.9a) [71]. The distances between the injection intersection and the buffer inlet determine the length of the sample plug, and voltage switching on a microchip with a common anode and cathode provides a simple method of simultaneously stacking samples in multiple channels for subsequent separation (Figure 1.9b) [71].
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
13
33 mm
Sample
Waste Cathode
Detection Common area anode
Twin-T injector (a)
8.0 cm
Detection point (b)
Cathode 0
S3
S2
5 S1
S4 10 (mm) (c)
FIGURE 1.7 (a) Twin-T injector design for 96-channel radial capillary array electrophoresis microplate. Two individual channels share common cathode, waste, and anode reservoirs. (From Mednitz, 2000.) (b) Single quartet of channels with their T-type injectors for 384channel radial capillary array electrophoresis microplate. All channels in a quartet share a common cathode reservoir located closest to the edge of the wafer. The T-type injector design is shown in detail below. (From Emrich, 2002.)
1.5.2 OPTICALLY GATED INJECTION Optical gating, first developed for liquid chromatography in small diameter capillaries [76, 77] and for capillary electrophoresis [78], provides an alternative to traditional T-type injection on a microchip. This injection method requires no potential switching and requires only two reservoirs per channel, lending itself nicely to multiplexed microchip electrophoresis. This injection technique, introduced on a single channel microchip by Lapos and Ewing [79], has been used to demonstrate fast, serial, and reproducible injections on a single-channel microchip. In order to
14
Advances in Chromatography
Power supplies
Platinum wire
Buffer inlet
Injectors
Detection window
Conventional cross injector
NSC cross injector
NSC tee injector
Buffer outlet
Power supplies
FIGURE 1.8 Schematic layout of a chip composed of eight channels with different injection designs. On the right are the expanded views of three typical injectors: conventional cross, narrow sample channel cross, and narrow sample channel T-injectors. (From Zhang, 2001.)
achieve optically gated sample introduction, the laser is split into two beams. The more intense gating beam is used to perform sample introduction by time-discriminated photobleaching of the sample, and the less intense beam is used for detection (Figure 1.10a). To perform an injection, potential is applied and fluorescently-labeled sample continuously flows from the sample reservoir to the waste reservoir. Initially, the gating laser beam continuously photobleaches fluorescently labeled analytes as they pass through the channel. The gating beam is then briefly blocked, thereby allowing a small, unphotobleached sample plug to move past the injection window. This plug is separated and finally detected by laser-induced fluorescence detection as it passes through the probe beam. Through the entire injection, separation, and detection process, the potential never needs to be switched or toggled; therefore, the electronics required for optical gating remain extremely simple compared to traditional injection methods. As previously mentioned, optically gated sample introduction requires fewer reservoirs than other injection methods and does not require side arms for injection. Therefore, optically gated injection should allow easier integration of a large number of separation channels onto a single microchip than traditional injection methods. In a demonstration of this principle, a schematic of a multiple-channel optical gating microchip (Figure 1.10b) shows five 8-cm channels that converge in the center of the microchip to facilitate detection [22]. Since the advent of this microchip injection method, optical gating has been applied to the analysis of amino acids [22, 79], DNA fragments [23, 80], and enzyme reactions [61].
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
15
Buffer outlet (floating)
Power supply *Diagram not to scale
1
100 um
Buffer
Buffer outlet Sample reservoir
Detection window
Sample
Sample loading
Platinum wires 1
2
3
4
5
Buffer inlet (ground) Buffer outlet (ground) Buffer
6 2
100 um
Sample
Buffer inlet
Sample reservoir Stack & separate (floating)
Buffer
Buffer inlet
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 1.9 (a) Schematic layout of the six-channel capillary electrophoresis array microdevice used to investigate sample stacking on microfabricated electrophoresis devices. (b) Illustration of the stacking process within the channel network with supporting CCD footage: (1) Sample loading. (2) Sample stacking and separation. (From Beard, 2003.)
1.5.3 CAPILLARY SAMPLE INTRODUCTION In contrast to most of the injection methods reviewed here, the capillary sample introduction technique is another scheme that does not require the toggling of voltages to perform injection. The use of a capillary for sample introduction eliminates the need for individual sample and waste reservoirs, making this microchip design quite simple (Figure 1.11a). Additionally, capillary sample introduction provides an effective means to interface the microchip with the macroscopic world. In this approach, the lanes of the microchip are filled with linear polyarylamide and plugs of sample are injected into each of the lanes (Figure 1.11b) either electrokinetically or by pressure [66, 68, 69]. Without interrupting the separation potential, injections are performed via a computer-controlled micromanipulator. In one example using capillary introduction, a five-channel microchip specifically fabricated to accommodate automated capillary sample introduction in a continuous manner has been used. The microchip design involves five open-ended channels such that one common anode and one common cathode can be employed [68]. Traditional photolithographic techniques have been used to create a microchip with parallel channels 12.7 cm in length, 500 to 700 μm wide, and 250 to 350 μm deep. The etched bottom plate is thermally bonded to a flat top plate, creating five enclosed straight channels for the analysis of various biological reactions. Given reasonable parameters, it is
16
Advances in Chromatography
Gating beam
Probe beam
Sample reservoir
Waste reservoir
1
2
3
4
e
5 (a)
2 mm
3 cm 8 cm (b)
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
17
FIGURE 1.10 (a) Schematic illustrating optically gated injection. Fluorescently labeled sample is continuously electrophoresed through the channel. The gating beam is used to perform sample introduction by time-discriminated photobleaching of the sample. The gating beam continuously photobleaches fluorescently labeled analytes as they pass through the channel (1). An injection is accomplished by blocking the gating for a specific time (2); thus, a plug of unphotobleached samples moves past the injection window (3), is separated (4) and detected (5) by laser-induced fluorescence detection as it passes through the probe beam. (b) Schematic of five-channel optical gating microchip. (From Xu, 2002.)
theoretically possible to carry out 550 separations in 1 hour by increasing the number of lanes on the microchip to 37 [68]. The increased throughput and the simplicity of the chip design and electronics make capillary sample introduction an attractive alternative to the traditional methods of sample introduction.
1.6 DETECTION METHODS Electrochemical detection, mass spectrometry, chemical luminescence, and laserinduced fluorescence have been the most popular methods for detecting separation analytes on single-channel microchips. Readers are directed to a review by Uchiyama et al. [81] for more information on these techniques. While these detection methods
FIGURE 1.11 (a) Chip design for capillary sample introduction with five open separation channels. (A) Microfabricated separation channel. (B) Glass partition. (b) Digital photos in chronological order (A–H) of manipulator-controlled movement of a capillary in and out of two channels of a chip. Injection of sample occurs at (C) and (H). (From Smith, 2001.)
18
Advances in Chromatography
are commonly applied to single channel microchips, detection on multi-channel microchips requires more complicated instrumentation. As a result, laser-induced fluorescence detection is by far the most common detection method for multi-channel microchips due to its inherent sensitivity and adaptability [2, 6]. Many variations of confocal laser-induced fluorescence detection, as developed by the Mathies group in the early 1990s [2, 3, 82], have been adapted for different microchip designs and have been reviewed extensively [3, 4, 26, 83, 84]. Confocal methods, scanning methods, and charge-coupled device (CCD) detection methods will be reviewed in the sections below.
1.6.1 SINGLE-POINT CONFOCAL DETECTION Single-point confocal detection has been previously described [3–5, 82, 85] and provides the basis for all other types of confocal detection. Briefly, a laser beam is collimated and subsequently reflected by a dichroic beam splitter through an objective lens. The beam is focused on the center of the microchip channel at the point of desired detection. Emitted fluoresence and scattered excitation laser light from the channel are collected and collimated by the objective lens. The light is then passed through a dichroic beam splitter and the emission wavelength is focused through an achromatic lens and pinhole that is confocal with the achromatic lens. Only fluorescence from the separation channel in the microchip is passed through the pinhole while scattered light is blocked. This increases the signal-to-noise ratio and allows sensitive detection of a variety of fluorescent molecules. Typically, photomultiplier tubes (PMT) or CCDs are used to detect the emitted fluorescence passing through the pinhole. Confocal detection has been applied to multi-channel microchips for detection in individual channels where multiple confocal detection units have been set up for each channel [45]. The adaptations for multi-channel microchip detection utilizing only a single detector will be discussed below [16, 24, 30, 31, 43, 46, 47, 49, 53, 74, 86].
1.6.2 TRANSLATION-STAGE CONFOCAL DETECTION The development of confocal detection with a translation stage was originally applied to capillary array electrophoresis and called a confocal-fluorescence capillary array scanner [2]. In this method, a computer-controlled stage is used to translate the capillary array past the optical system such that data can be collected from all capillaries in the array. Similarly, the translation stage has been adapted for use with multi-channel microchips where the microchip is moved back and forth through the excitation laser beam [22–24, 30, 61]. In one particular application, the 12-channel rectilinear microchip shown in Figure 1.1a is placed on a computer-controlled translation stage [24]. The detection laser beam is focused on the detection region of the microchip, and the microchip is translated through the beam. Fluorescence is collected by the objective, passed through a dichroic beamsplitter, and divided into two fluorescence channels with a second dichroic beamsplitter. The signal from each channel is then focused with a lens onto a confocal spatial filter prior to detection with a PMT (Figure 1.12a) [24]. This detector has been further improved to include
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
19
the detection of four independent fluorophores; however, the four-color work has been completed on a capillary array [87]. In another application, the five-channel optical gating microchip shown in Figure 1.7b has been traversed through both the gating and detection (probe) beams, and fluorescence has been collected in the traditional confocal manner (Figure 1.12b) [23]. In this arrangement, the microchip is fixed to a translation stage that is attached to a voice coil actuator. The actuator is used to move the microchip back and forth at a repetition rate of 10 Hz, causing the two beams to scan repeatedly across all five channels on the microchip. This technique has been used to investigate amino acid [22] as well as oligonucleotide [23] separations. In both of these applications, the microchip is attached to a translation stage and moves through the stationary detection beam.
1.6.3 SCANNING METHODS
OF
DETECTION
A variety of detection methods exist in which the microchip remains stationary while the laser beam is manipulated such that all channels on a multi-channel device can be illuminated and thus detection of multiple channels can be achieved. Galvanometric scanner confocal, rotary scanner confocal, acousto-optical deflection (AOD) scanner, and CCD detection will be reviewed in the following sections. 1.6.3.1 Confocal Fluorescence Detection with a Galvanometric Scanner High-speed, high-throughput separations are characteristic of microchip separations. Detection methods are therefore continuously being improved to allow for the detection of entire peak profiles as a fluorescent analyte is detected. The galvanometric scanner (Figure 1.13a) [30] has been developed and used for high throughput genetic analysis on the microfabricated 96-sample capillary array electrophoresis microchip of the design shown in Figure 1.1c [30]. The laser beam is focused through a 0.33 numerical aperture scan lens system designed for quantitative field analysis to a 5-μm region [88]. The beam is scanned across 48 stationary channels at 40 Hz and data are collected through the detection optics including a dichroic beamsplitter, emission filter, lens, pinhole, and PMT in the same manner as traditional confocal detection. DNA sequencing using four-color detection on a similar instrument has also been carried out with this system [87]. 1.6.3.2 Confocal Fluorescence Detection with a Rotary Scanner The scan speed for detection with a translation stage is limited; therefore, a new confocal detection system with a rotary scanner has been developed (Figure 1.13b) [16]. This detection system consists of a rotating objective head coupled to a fourcolor confocal detection unit. A laser is directed through a series of mirrors and dichroic beamsplitters through the rotating central hollow shaft of a stepper motor. The beam is then displaced by a rhomb prism and focused into the microchip by a
20
Advances in Chromatography
Computer Amplifier
Mirror Spatial filter Lens 645 mm LP filter
PMT
Dichroic beam splitier 488 mm laser
Spectral filter
Mirror Dichrole beam splitier Objective
CAE chip
Translation stage Detection zone
Buffer reservoirs (a)
CPU
Mirrors
Lens Shutter
Argon ion laser
Motor controller
IIV
Beam splitter Gating beam
Chip fixed on a translation stage Objective
Probe beam
Collimator/expander Dichroic mirror
Keithley Voice coil actuator
Filter Photomultiplier tube
(b)
FIGURE 1.12 (a) Schematic of the laser-excited confocal-fluorescence scanner and a capillary array electrophoresis chip. (From Woolley, 1997.) (b) Multichannel system setup with optically gated sample introduction and laser-induced confocal-fluorescence detection. (From Xu, 2004.) The laser beam is stationary in both of these detection schemes while the chip is attached to a stage that translates each channel through the beam.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
21
FIGURE 1.13 (a) Schematic of the laser-excited galvanoscanner and the capillary array electrophoresis microplate assembly. (From Simpson, 1998.) (b) Schematic of the rotary confocal-fluorescence scanner used to detect separations on radial capillary array electrophoresis microplates. (From Shi, 1999.)
22
Advances in Chromatography
rotating microscope objective. This objective also serves to collect the emission wavelength derived from the sample. The fluorescence is passed along the reverse optical path through the dichroic beamsplitter to the four-color confocal fluorescence detector [16, 87]. This detection system has proven capable of scanning and collecting information at rates up to 20 revolutions per second with 5000 points collected per revolution per channel. In this detection scheme, the microchip is stationary while the microscope objective rotates and has been employed for various DNA applications as well as for an immunoassay. 1.6.3.3 Fluorescence Detection with an Acousto-Optical Deflection Scanner Thus far, all of the fluorescence detection methods described require the physical movement of either the microchip or the laser beam. Conversely, an AOD scanner does not require physical movement of either the microchip or a laser (Figure 1.14), resulting in scanning rates as high as 30 Hz [73]. This method of detection, as developed by Landers and coworkers [25, 73], allows flexible, high-speed, selfaligning scanning for fluorescence detection in multi-channel microchip electrophoresis. The scanning unit of the AOD scanner is dictated by a transparent crystal that changes the direction of laser light based on the frequency of the acoustic wave propagating through it [21, 25, 73]. In brief, the laser light is refracted as it travels through the crystal and the degree of refraction is adjusted by changing the frequency of the acoustic wave generated within the crystal using a piezoelectric transducer. A computer-controlled voltage-to-frequency converter controls this transducer, moving the laser from channel to channel. The AOD scanner is unique in that it is possible to address individual, nonadjacent channels and thus data may be collected from any number of channels in any order. Using this method, a dichroic beamsplitter, an objective, and a bandpass filter have been used to collect emission wavelength light, while a CCD camera and a video capture device have been used in place of a PMT for detection purposes for the investigation of amino acids as well as DNA digest samples.
1.6.4 FLUORESCENCE DETECTION DEVICE (CCD)
WITH A
CHARGE-COUPLED
Clearly, addressing each channel on a microchip can be challenging. Most detection methods reviewed thus far have utilized some variation of confocal detection. Confocal methods, however, are not the only way to monitor fluorescence detection on a multiple-channel microchip. In the past, CCDs have been thought to be incompatible with multi-channel microchip separations [26]; however, CCDs have been used successfully on capillary array electrophoresis systems [89–91] and are now being applied to microchip separations. Ewing and coworkers have used a detection scheme in which an argon ion laser beam is expanded and focused into a line across all channels on a microfabricated microchip (Figure 1.15) [68]. This is similar to detection schemes developed earlier for ultrathin slab gel electrophoresis [92–97].
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
23
FIGURE 1.14 Acousto-optic detection system and multichannel chip. (a) Deflection of the incident laser beam by the acousto-optic crystal. Deflection angle is determined by the frequency of the acoustic wave. (b) Optical setup. (c) Eight-channel microchip configuration. (d) Detection region of the microchip for laser beam scanning. (From Ferrance, 2001.)
As sample passes through the laser line, a CCD camera perpendicular to the microchip detects the emission fluorescence [66, 68, 69]. Pictures are taken at predetermined intervals and compiled such that a complete image of the separations in all lanes is obtained. This detection method allows simultaneous detection of analytes from separations occurring in each channel, thereby providing another methodology that physically eliminates the need for translating the microchip or scanning the laser beam across all channels.
1.7 APPLICATIONS OF MULTIPLE-CHANNEL MICROCHIPS Microfluidic devices continue to be utilized for an increasing number of applications. For instance, single-channel devices have been applied to the analysis of DNA for sizing, genotyping, and sequencing as well as for the integration of PCR on a microchip. Many single-channel devices have also been used for the analysis of proteins, peptides, tryptic digests, enzyme assays, immunoassays, catecholamines, and many other biological analyses that have been reviewed by Bruin [98]. The current chapter has presented multiple-channel microchip designs, injection and detection methods, and will now discuss several bioanalytical applications of these multiplexed devices.
24
Advances in Chromatography
FIGURE 1.15 Charge-coupled device detection. Schematic of the chip setup with capillary sample introduction. Laser-induced fluorescence detection is achieved by focusing an argon ion laser into a line across the chip. A liquid nitrogen-cooled CCD is used to collect the fluoresence. (Adapted from Smith, 2001.)
1.7.1 DNA SEPARATIONS 1.7.1.1 Separations Involving Restriction Enzyme Digests — DNA Fragment Analysis Restriction enzymes are DNA-cutting enzymes found in bacteria. Because they cut within the molecule, they are often called restriction endonucleases. A restriction enzyme recognizes and cuts DNA only at a particular sequence of nucleotides, typically four to eight base pairs in length [99]. Restriction enzymes are essential for analyzing chromosome structures, mapping and sequencing very long DNA molecules, isolating genes, and creating new DNA molecules for cloning purposes. DNA fragments produced by the action of a restriction enzyme can serve as a fingerprint of an overall DNA molecule. Multiple-channel microchips provide a method for the rapid analysis of these DNA fragments. Woolley and Mathies carried out a separation of FX174 Hae III DNA restriction fragments on a 15-channel microchip, proving that microchips are capable of highresolution electrophoretic separations [43]. These separations have been completed in only 120 seconds [43]. Additionally, this process demonstrate the high-speed sizing of PCR-amplified HLA-DQa alleles [43]. This experiment laid the groundwork for high-speed, high-throughput DNA separations on multiple-channel microchips. Simultaneous separation and detection of the double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) fragments of pBR322 has been accomplished by Huang et al. on an eight-channel microchip using AOD [25]. Further studies conducted by the Mathies group employ
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
25
a radial 96-channel microchip — initially using one-color detection — for the separation of 96 pBR322 MspI samples labeled with TOTO [16]. In addition to separations of short DNA fragments, there are examples in the literature of microchip separations of long DNA molecules. A nanofluidic channel device, consisting of many entropic traps, has been designed and fabricated for the separation of long DNA molecules [100]. This nongel-based method for the separation of DNA has been used to separate a T2–T7 DNA mixture [100]. The device used is composed of multiple channels with narrow constrictions and wider regions that cause size-dependent trapping of DNA at the onset of a constriction. Under these conditions, electrophoretic mobility differences are created and separation without the use of a gel matrix or pulsed electric fields could be accomplished. With this technology, samples of long DNA molecules have been efficiently separated, and multiple-channel devices operating in parallel have been demonstrated [100]. Further development of this technique has demonstrated that a microfabricated entropic trap array can be useful in separating large (5 to 200 kbp) DNA molecules efficiently (within 30 minutes) by DC electrophoresis on a microchip platform without a sieving matrix [101]. The investigators report further development of the technique, with emphasis on the optimization of separation selectivity and resolution for these DNA, and comment on the requirement and feasibility of separating megabase-pair DNA with the entropic trap array device [101]. Membrane-mediated restriction digestion and rapid analysis of cleaved DNA fragments has been accomplished using a 96-channel gel microchip electrophoresis separation system [58]. Complete digestion of an FX174 plasmid DNA by Hae III (a 101 base pair PCR product of the pUC19 cloning vector by Sma I) as well as the GFP/pABarMCS construct by Bst EII, Hind III, Bam HI and by the combination of Sac I and Sma I enzymes, have been accomplished in a few minutes on a membrane. Membrane-mediated sample loading [102] has been used to inject these samples into the separation device. The researchers report the possibility of the analysis of up to 6400 samples per day, particularly when robotic liquid handling is employed [58]. Continuous monitoring of a restriction enzyme digest of DNA on a five-channel microchip has also been demonstrated; however, this digestion was monitored dynamically and will be presented in a different application later in this review [66]. A variety of multiple channel electrophoresis devices have been utilized for the analysis of DNA fragments and as technology progresses these multiplexed microchips will be employed for various other DNA applications. 1.7.1.2 Genotyping The development of safer and more effective individualized medicine is possible through the increased understanding of how a particular genotype interacts with a potential drug. Traditional methods of genotyping, typically slab-gel electrophoresis and more recently capillary electrophoresis, are serial techniques that make them both cumbersome and labor intensive. Thus, these techniques are not well suited for large-scale genetic testing. Multi-channel microchip electrophoresis has proven to be a high-throughput, cost-effective alternative to traditional methods.
26
Advances in Chromatography
Hereditary hemochromatosis (HHC) is associated with an increased risk of cirrhosis, cardiomyopathy, and hepatic cancer; thus, early detection through rapid and low-cost screenings can allow early diagnosis and treatment, and a normal life span for patients. Towards this goal, genotyping of HLA-H, a marker gene for the diagnosis of HHC, has been performed on a 12-channel microchip to demonstrate the rapid analysis of biologically relevant samples [24]. Further studies have been conducted to demonstrate the functionality of a microfabricated 96-sample capillary array electrophoresis microchip for the separation and fluorescence detection of a restriction fragment marker for the diagnosis of HHC [30]. This restriction fragment marker for HHC is derived from the HFE gene and separations of 96 HFE amplicons have been performed on a 48-channel microchip [30]. A total of 19 different samples have been used for a 5-fold redundancy in sample analysis. Thus, serial injections proved to be an effective method of increasing the sample throughput with a limited number of separation channels [30]. Furthermore, this work illustrates the utility of multi-channel microchips for genetic disease screening. In an attempt to reduce the cost of high-throughput applications such as population screening for genetic diseases, Sassi and coworkers have demonstrated rapid, parallel separations of D1S80 alleles in a plastic 16-channel microchip [86]. D1S80 alleles are amplified from genomic DNA extracted from whole blood and separated. One of every four channels contains the reference alleles. Ultimately, the authors have demonstrated the feasibility to perform high-throughput genotyping in injection-molded, plastic multi-channel microchips. They report that with appropriate internal standards and optimization of microchip design and separation conditions, the accuracy of typing on these polymeric microchips could be improved to match the accuracy of conventional slab-gel electrophoresis [86]. In another genotyping experiment, the 96-channel radial microchip described earlier in this review has been used to perform an analysis of methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) allelic variation. To accomplish this, PCR amplicons of the MTHFR gene are digested with Hinf I and detected in two-color mode [16]. The same 96-channel device is used to perform high-speed single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) typing of an HHC mutation [74]. In these studies, fluorescently labeled sequence-specific primers are used to generate allele-specific products for the S65C polymorphism. The PCR product is subsequently separated and typed. Thus, the authors have demonstrated the potential of using covalently labeled sequence specific PCR amplicons with multi-channel microdevices for high-throughput SNP genotyping analyses [74]. Another study has focused on genotyping energy-transfer-cassette-labeled, short-tandem-repeat amplicons with four-color detection [46]. Covalent labeling with energy-transfer (ET) tags can be used to increase the throughput of genotyping analyses using multi-channel microchip electrophoresis. In this study, 122 samples are separated and genotyped in 96 channels in less than 8 minutes [46]. Thus, the work demonstrates the powerful combination of energy-transfer-cassette labeling and multi-channel electrophoresis for high-performance, short-tandem-repeat analysis. Similarly, demonstration of the combined use of an allele-specific polymerase chain reaction (ASPCR) with energy transfer primers and multiple-channel microchip electrophoresis has also been conducted on the 96-channel radial microchip
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
27
[48]. Previous analyses have employed one- or two-color detection; however, this study demonstrates the use of four-color DNA analysis for genotyping using ET labels [48]. A different type of 96-channel gel microchip has been used for high-throughput genotyping of repeat polymorphisms in the regulatory region of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR) [103]. To accomplish this, the injection end of the gel features a straight edge with no individual wells. Samples are injected onto the gel microchip by membrane-mediated loading technology using 96-tab membranes. Automated spotting of the loading membrane is accomplished with a robot directly from a 96-well PCR plate [103]. The researchers report separation and visualization of the PCR amplicons from either the 5-HTTLPR short allele or the 5-HTTLPR long form in a few minutes [103]. Massively parallel genetic analysis is attractive for high-throughput evaluation of genetic variation and multi-channel microchips are a valuable tool in this endeavor. A microfabricated 384-channel microchip has been developed and utilized for massively parallel genetic analysis. For instance, the simultaneous genotyping of 384 individuals for the common hemochromatosis-linked H63D mutation in the human HFE gene has been achieved in only 325 seconds (Figure 1.16) [31]. The H63D mutation is detected by digestion of a PCR product with Mbo I. Mutant amplicons remain undigested while wild-type amplicons are cleaved into two fragments [31]. This study introduces a powerful new tool for accelerating gene mapping, pharmacogenomic screening, forensics and proteomics as well as providing a massively high-throughput bioanalyzer [31]. Significant advances have been made in the area of genotyping on multi-channel microchips in the recent past. The ability to perform rapid high-throughput population screening on integrated multiplexed devices in the clinical setting can be envisioned in the near future. 1.7.1.3 Sequencing in Multiple-Channel Microchips DNA sequencing involves the determination of the precise sequence of nucleotides in a sample of DNA and thus requires excellent resolution of separated peaks such that strands that differ by only a single nucleotide can be differentiated. Single capillaries, capillary arrays, and single channel microchips have been employed for DNA sequencing and have been reviewed elsewhere [104]. Multiple-channel microchips have been applied to DNA sequencing and provide higher throughput than traditional methods [26]. Optimization of high-speed DNA sequencing has been performed in a fourchannel microchip [105]. The separation matrix, separation temperature, channel length and depth, injector dimensions, and injection parameters have been optimized such that one-color sequencing separations of single-stranded M13mp18 DNA could be accomplished [105]. Additionally, four-color sequencing separations have been performed in 7-cm long channels, and experiments completed in under 20 minutes with 99.4% accuracy to DNA sizes up to 500 bp [105]. These optimization studies have significantly advanced sequencing on microfabricated devices. A 48-channel microchip has been utilized to separate single-stranded DNA fragments up to 500 bases in length [106]. Using this separation device, a 400-base
28
Advances in Chromatography
FIGURE 1.16 DNA microchip application. Electropherograms collected for massively parallel genetic analysis on the 384-lane microcapillary array electrophoresis chip. RFLP fragments are highlighted in lanes 1 (wild type) and 193 (heterozygote). Genotyping of the samples is possible in 379 lanes (98.7% success rate). Electrophoresis is completed within 325 seconds. (From Emrich, 2002.)
read has been obtained with 97% accuracy and 440 bases are sequenced with 93% accuracy on a 10 cm channel. These experiments utilize a novel transmission imaging spectrograph for detection and provides an increase in sample throughput by color multiplexing [106]. Throughput has been significantly increased but accuracy suffers in these experiments. Additional sequencing data has been collected using a 16-channel microchip as shown in Figure 1.1b. After optimization of injection time, temperature, and template
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
29
concentration, four-color DNA sequencing has been performed in 16 microfabricated channels [45]. Greater than 99% accuracy is observed for the base-called sequence of 543 bases. Separations carried out in less than 15 minutes typically resolve 457 ± 35 bases with 99% accuracy and 512 ± 44 bases with 98% accuracy [45]. DNA sequencing is highly dependent on the separation resolution; hence, several groups have employed longer channels to increase resolution. Devices containing 48 independent straight microchannels, 50 cm in length, have been fabricated [107]. Single-base resolution for read lengths greater than 600 bases has been achieved with this device and the sequence has been called to 640 bases with 98% accuracy [107]. Additionally, a 96-channel hyper-turn microchip has been developed [47, 49]. This microchip is suited for DNA sequencing where long separation lengths are required. The 16-cm-long hyper-turn channel device initially provides 96 parallel, high-quality DNA sequencing separations to approximately 500 bases in less than 30 minutes [47]. More recently, high-throughput DNA sequencing has been performed and coupled to four-color fluorescence detection [49]. Data have been successfully collected from 95 of the 96 channels where an average read length of 430 bp has been obtained. The probability of incorrectly calling or identifying a base for over 80% of the read length is 0.01% [49]. This technology is capable of producing sequencing data at a rate of 1.7 kbp/min, which the authors report is a 5-fold increase over current commercial capillary array electrophoresis instruments [49]. An interesting hybrid device consisting of a microchip containing multiple twinT injectors attached to an array of capillaries that serve as separation channels has been used to sequence over 1000 real-world samples [108]. The investigators report an average Phred20 read of 675 bases in about 70 minutes with a success rate of 91% as compared to similar samples on MegaBACE 1000 where the average Phred20 read is about 550 to 600 bases in 120 minutes with a success rate of about 80 to 90% [108]. Sequencing with a high degree of accuracy is highly desirable when searching for minute differences in DNA sequences. Thus far, multiplexed microchip electrophoresis has proven to be an efficient platform for increasing throughput for sequencing studies.
1.7.2 AFFINITY ELECTROPHORESIS MICROCHIPS
FOR IMMUNOASSAYS IN
The immunoassay is one of the most important analysis methods for biological molecules. Thus, it is clear why so many groups are interested in integrating immunoassay on a microchip, particularly for its application in point-of-care analysis. There are several methods for conducting an immunoassay on a microchip; however, most have been accomplished on single channel devices. A small-volume heterogeneous immunoassay system has been demonstrated by Hayes et al. in microchannels exploiting magnetic manipulations of small paramagnetic particles [56]. Kitamori’s group has integrated heterogeneous immunoassay systems with microfabricated separation devices as well [64, 109, 110]. Most recently, a bead-bed immunoassay system suitable for simultaneous assay of multiple samples has been constructed on a microchip [64]. The microchip used in these experiments utilized branching
30
Advances in Chromatography
channels and four reaction and detection regions. This device has been used for the simultaneous analysis of four interferon γ samples by a three-step sandwich immunoassay [64]. The assay time for the four samples is 50 minutes, a significant improvement over the 35 minutes it takes for one sample to be analyzed in the single channel assay [64]. The Harrison group has been at the forefront of immunoassay on microfabricated devices [111–116] and has recently developed a multi-channel microfluidic analysis system employing affinity capillary electrophoresis for immunoassay [62]. In this application, a six-channel immunoassay device (depicted in Figure 1.3) has been used to complete simultaneous direct immunoassays for ovalbumin and for antiestradiol. Mixing, reaction, and separation are performed in less than 60 seconds, and in 30 seconds under optimized conditions. This work demonstrates the multiplexing of mixing and reaction steps as well as injection and separation, thus providing increased throughput for complex sample processing [62]. Additional information on enzyme assays and immunoassays on microfabricated devices can be found in a review by Guijt and coworkers [57]. Recently, Bromberg and Mathies developed a homogeneous immunoassay for the detection of TNT and some of its analogues utilizing a single channel microfabricated device [117]. Following this, a high-throughput homogeneous immunoassay for the detection of TNT has been developed using 46 channels of the already described 96-channel radial microchip (Figure 1.2a) [50]. This assay is based on competition between the fluorescein-labeled trinitrobenzene derivative (TNB-Fl) and TNT for antibody binding sites. Sample preparation, reagent mixing, and incubation have been performed off the microchip, whereas injection and separation of the reactants and detection of the resulting complex have been performed on the microchip. Data collected from 46 channels showed nine different TNT sample concentrations, and each trace represented three serial injections (Figure 1.17a) [50]. A calibration curve has been constructed by plotting the ratio of signal intensity for free TNB-Fl to the signal intensity for the antibody-TNB-Fl complex as a function of the TNT concentration (Figure 1.17b) [50]. The equilibrium binding constant, binding rate constant, and dissociation rate constant of the labeled TNT have been determined. Consequently, this study demonstrates the feasibility of using multichannel microfabricated devices to simultaneously analyze multiple samples with homogeneous immunoassay methods. In the future, this technology could be used to probe for the presence of explosives in environmental samples or to perform highthroughput clinical assays [50].
1.7.3 DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF REACTIONS WITH MULTIPLE-CHANNEL ELECTROPHORESIS 1.7.3.1 Application to DNA While the function of restriction enzymes has been explored in the laboratory, much remains to be learned about their structures, their binding characteristics, and their mechanisms of cleavage. A separations-based method of continuously sampling from a DNA restriction enzyme digest has been developed by Roddy et al., providing a
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
1
5
2
10
8
15
Relative fluorescence
31
3 6 4
25
Ratio
20
4
0.2
5 0.1
2
30
6
0 0
35
7
0
100
0
1 200
2
3 300
TNT (ng/ml) (b)
40
8 45
0
9 100 Time (sec)
200
(a)
FIGURE 1.17 TNT microchip bioassay. (a) Multichannel homogeneous TNT immunoassay performed on a microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis device. Nine samples are dispensed to 46 wells (numbered to the left side of the figure). TNT sample concentrations: 0, 0.3, 1, 3, 10, 20, 50, 100, and 300 ng/mL for samples 1–9, respectively. Each trace presents three consecutive injections. The first peak marks the beginning of the 30-second injection, the second peak is the Ab-TNB-FL complex and the third peak is the free TNB-Fl. (b) Calibration curve for TNT assay obtained by plotting the ratio of signal intensity of free TNBFl to the signal intensity of the Ab-TNB-Fl complex as a function of the TNT concentration. Each point is an average of signals obtained from wells of the same TNT concentration. (From Bromberg, 2004).
means to monitor changes in substrate and product concentrations over the course of the reaction [66]. This method utilizes a capillary as a sampling device to transfer sample from a single reaction mixture to a microfabricated device with an array of separation lanes and has been initially optimized by separating Hae III-digested pBR322 [68]. More recently, this methodology has been applied to the analysis of a restriction enzyme digest during the course of digestion. Specifically, a fluorescently-labeled 62 base pair double-stranded DNA fragment containing a single Kpn
32
Advances in Chromatography
I site has been chosen to demonstrate the ability of this multi-channel separation device to monitor the progress of a dynamic reaction [66]. In brief, the reaction is initiated offline and as the sample enteres the microchip, the reaction is quenched on-line. Therefore, each injection into the microchip captures a time-point during the reaction such that all of the fragments are observed [66]. The results of a digest carried out at 45˚C using one unit of Kpn I per 13 ng of DNA have been reconstructed by plotting the fluorescence signal at the laser line collected by the CCD camera over time (Figure 1.18a) [66]. A cross-section of intensity vs. time for the separations shown in lane five yields a series of electropherograms (Figure 1.18b) [66]. A distinct change in sample composition has been observed as time progresses. This methodology has provided continuous analysis of the products of a digest reaction, thereby contributing to the fundamental understanding of restriction enzyme binding and activity as well as enhancing practical knowledge for the use of restriction enzymes as essential tools in the laboratory [66]. 1.7.3.2 Application to RNA Reactions RNA enzymes, or ribozymes, behave similarly to protein-based enzymes; thus, there is heightened interest in understanding the mechanism of cleavage of these molecules. The applications of RNA catalysts can be expanded as kinetic information is ascertained. Kinetic analysis of ribozymes typically involves the tedious process of collecting and quenching reaction time points and then fractionating by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). As a way to automate and simplify this process, continuous analysis of ribozyme reactions have been demonstrated by Paxon et al. [69] Completely automated capillary sample introduction on a five-channel microchip with laser-induced fluorescence detection is employed to examine a 30-nucleotide ribozyme cleavage reaction that is sensitive to the lead ion. The ribozyme cleavage is initiated by 10 μM Pb2+ and the progress of this reaction is monitored for 60 minutes. A cross-section of a single channel is shown as a relative intensity vs. separation time (min) electropherogram in Figure 1.19a [69]. The first peak in each doublet set of peaks represents the fluorescently labeled 6-mer elution while the second peak is indicative of the 30-mer elution. Raw data from Figure 1.19a have been plotted as peak height vs. injection time and are shown in Figure 1.19b. Product formation and starting material cleavage showed mirror image behavior. The presence of only two peaks has shown to be consistent with a simple cleavage reaction as well as the absence of side reactions, RNA degradation, and alternative conformations. Fraction cleaved vs. injection time has been plotted in Figure 1.19c and kinetic information about this ribozyme has been obtained. This work demonstrated, through the use of a simple ribozyme model, the potential of multi-channel microchips with capillary sample introduction to provide valuable kinetic information for biologically relevant RNA and protein enzymes.
1.8 CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PERSPECTIVES Microchip separations have evolved considerably since their inception in the early 1990s, particularly in the area of multiplexing. There are numerous areas where
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
33
0 500
Time (s)
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 0
200
0
400 600 Pixel number
800
1000
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
Intensity (a)
2500
Intensity
2000 1500 1000 500 0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Time (min) (b)
FIGURE 1.18 DNA digestion assay. (a) Reconstructed plot of time vs. pixel number across the width of the chip. The shaded bar represents fluorescence intensity collected by the CCD. The capillary moved right to left depositing samples into the chip, so the lane farthest to the right is lane 1. (b) Cross section through lane 5 of the plot in (a) showing intensity vs. time. (From Roddy, 2003.)
34
Advances in Chromatography
Relative intensity
7000 5250 3500 1750 0 0
10
20
40 30 Separation time (min)
50
60
70
(a) 1
7000
0.8
5000 4000
Feleaved
Peak height
6000
3000
0.6 0.4
2000 6-mer 30-mer
1000 0 0
20
40
Injection time (min) (b)
60
0.2 0
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Injection time (min) (c)
FIGURE 1.19 RNA ribozyme cleavage assay. (a) Cross-section through lane two of a leadzyme reaction in the presence of 10 μM lead acetate illustrating fluorescence intensity vs. separation time. Asterisk highlights 5′ product (6-mer). (b) Plot of peak height for the 6mer and 30-mer strands vs. injection time for the experiment shown in (a). (c) Plot of fraction cleaved vs. time of injection. (From Paxon, 2004.)
multi-channel microchip separations require new advances to be made including detection methods and application to real-world samples. Indeed, a number of applications from DNA to proteins to immunoassays have been developed around this technology to date. Detection methods for multiple-channel microchips have been limited to laser induced fluorescence detection. However, work has been published on detection methods on single channel devices including sheath flow detection [118], electrochemical detection [119–125], and mass spectrometry [18, 126–134]. One can envision any number of detection methods applied to multiplexed microchips for increased sensitivity when analyzing biological samples present at very low concentrations or in limited amounts. Multiple-channel microchips hold the promise of higher throughput separations and, as capillary array electrophoresis replaced single capillary and slab-gel electrophoresis in the high throughput separations that were needed to sequence the
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
35
human genome, multi-channel microchips might play an equally important role in the future of separations on chips. In addition, these microchip designs are a probable precursor to integrated systems requiring multiple channels of any kind, and the fundamental science and engineering developed in this area should be invaluable. An important part of the future of multi-channel microchips appears to be the use of these systems to follow reaction dynamics, and this will lead to more detailed and cellular applications in biology. In another context, multi-channel microchips could be used to mimic the concentration profiles in biological systems with different amounts of solutes in different channels representing spatially differing concentrations in cells, organs, or circulatory systems. In still another direction, the Orwar group has developed a multi-channel microchip for screening drugs with a cell sensor that is scanned at the outlet of multiple channels [135–138]. Although this has not yet been used for separations in the traditional sense, the use of multiple channels allows different reagents or drugs to be transported to where a cell acts as a biological detector. This is yet another example of the versatility of the multi-channel microchip concept. This chapter has presented recent advances in multi-channel microchip designs, sample introduction, and detection. Furthermore, high-throughput analyses of complex analytes have been demonstrated utilizing these multiplexed microchips. This chapter has outlined the enormous potential and current challenges for the multichannel microchip community and discussed a variety of applications that illustrate the immense growth in the field of multiplexed separations.
ACKNOWLDGMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the NSF and NIH for funding, in part, the research presented here. We thank our co-workers past and present for work that is referenced herein. Additionally, we thank current members of the Ewing research group for helpful comments about this manuscript.
REFERENCES 1. Issaq, H.J. A decade of capillary electrophoresis. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(10), 1921–1939. 2. Mathies, R.A. and Huang, X.C. Capillary array electrophoresis — An approach to high-speed, high-throughput DNA sequencing. Nature, 1992, 359(6391), 167–169. 3. Huang, X.H.C., Quesada, M.A., and Mathies, R.A. DNA sequencing using capillary array electrophoresis. Analytical Chemistry, 1992, 64(18), 2149–2154. 4. Huang, X.H.C., Quesada, M.A., and Mathies, R.A. Capillary array electrophoresis using laser-excited confocal fluorescence detection. Analytical Chemistry, 1992, 64(8), 967–972. 5. Clark, S.M. and Mathies, R.A. High-speed parallel separation of DNA restriction fragments using capillary array electrophoresis. Analytical Biochemistry, 1993, 215(2), 163–170.
36
Advances in Chromatography 6. Harrison, D.J., Manz, A., Fan, Z.H., Ludi, H., and Widmer, H.M. Capillary electrophoresis and sample injection systems integrated on a planar glass chip. Analytical Chemistry, 1992, 64(17), 1926–1932. 7. Manz, A., Harrison, D.J., Verpoorte, E.M.J., Fettinger, J.C., Paulus, A., Ludi, H., and Widmer, H.M. Planar chips technology for miniaturization and integration of separation techniques into monitoring systems — Capillary electrophoresis on a chip. Journal of Chromatography, 1992, 593(1-2), 253–258. 8. Harrison, D.J., Glavina, P.G., and Manz, A. Towards miniaturized electrophoresis and chemical-analysis systems on silicon — An alternative to chemical sensors. Sensors and Actuators B-Chemical, 1993, 10(2), 107–116. 9. Effenhauser, C.S., Manz, A., and Widmer, H.M. Glass chips for high-speed capillary electrophoresis separations with submicrometer plate heights. Analytical Chemistry, 1993, 65(19), 2637–2642. 10. von Heeren, F., Verpoorte, E., Manz, A., and Thormann, W. Micellar electrokinetic chromatography separations and analyses of biological samples on a cyclic planar microstructure. Analytical Chemistry, 1996, 68(13), 2044–2053. 11. Ramseier, A., von Heeren, F., and Thormann, W. Analysis of fluorescein isothiocyanate derivatized amphetamine and analogs in human urine by capillary electrophoresis in chip-based and fused-silica capillary instrumentation. Electrophoresis, 1998, 19(16-17), 2967–2975. 12. Zhang, B.L., Foret, F., and Karger, B.L. A microdevice with integrated liquid junction for facile peptide and protein analysis by capillary electrophoresis/electrospray mass spectrometry. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(5), 1015–1022. 13. Effenhauser, C.S., Manz, A., and Widmer, H.M. Manipulation of sample fractions on a capillary electrophoresis chip. Analytical Chemistry, 1995, 67(13), 2284–2287. 14. Liu, Y.J., Foote, R.S., Jacobson, S.C., Ramsey, R.S., and Ramsey, J.M. Electrophoretic separation of proteins on a microchip with noncovalent, postcolumn labeling. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(19), 4608–4613. 15. Liu, Y.J., Foote, R.S., Culbertson, C.T., Jacobson, S.C., Ramsey, R.S., and Ramsey, J.M. Electrophoretic separation of proteins on microchips. Journal of Microcolumn Separations, 2000, 12(7), 407–411. 16. Shi, Y.N., Simpson, P.C., Scherer, J.R., Wexler, D., Skibola, C., Smith, M.T., and Mathies, R.A. Radial capillary array electrophoresis microplate and scanner for highperformance nucleic acid analysis. Analytical Chemistry, 1999, 71(23), 5354–5361. 17. Manz, A., Graber, N., and Widmer, H.M. Miniaturized total chemical-analysis systems — A novel concept for chemical sensing. Sensors and Actuators B-Chemical, 1990, 1(1-6), 244–248. 18. Xue, Q.F., Foret, F., Dunayevskiy, Y.M., Zavracky, P.M., McGruer, N.E., and Karger, B.L. Multichannel microchip electrospray mass spectrometry. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(3), 426–430. 19. Figeys, D., Ning, Y. B., and Aebersold, R. A microfabricated device for rapid protein identification by microelectrospray ion trap mass spectrometry. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(16), 3153–3160. 20. Figeys, D. and Aebersold, R. High sensitivity analysis of proteins and peptides by capillary electrophoresis tandem mass spectrometry: Recent developments in technology and applications. Electrophoresis, 1998, 19(6), 885–892. 21. Huang, Z.L., Jin, L.J., Sanders, J.C., Zheng, Y.B., Dunsmoor, C., Tian, H.J., and Landers, J.P. Laser-induced fluorescence detection on multichannel electrophoretic microchips using microprocessor-embedded acousto-optic laser beam scanning. IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, 2002, 49(8), 859–866.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
37
22. Xu, X.M., Roddy, T.P., Lapos, J.A., and Ewing, A.G. Parallel analysis with optically gated sample introduction on a multichannel microchip. Analytical Chemistry, 2002, 74(21), 5517–5522. 23. Xu, H.W., Roddy, E.S., Roddy, T.P., Lapos, J.A., and Ewing, A.G. Parallel separations of oligonucleotides with optically gated sample introduction on multi-channel microchips. Journal of Separation Science, 2004, 27(1-2), 7–12. 24. Woolley, A.T., Sensabaugh, G.F., and Mathies, R.A. High-speed DNA genotyping using microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis chips. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(11), 2181–2186. 25. Huang, Z., Munro, N., Huhmer, A.F.R., and Landers, J.P. Acousto-optical deflectionbased laser beam scanning for fluorescence detection on multichannel electrophoretic microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 1999, 71(23), 5309–5314. 26. Gao, Q.F., Shi, Y.N., and Liu, S.R. Multiple-channel microchips for high-throughput DNA analysis by capillary electrophoresis. Fresenius Journal of Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 371(2), 137–145. 27. Harrison, D.J., Fluri, K., Seiler, K., Fan, Z.H., Effenhauser, C.S., and Manz, A. Micromachining a miniaturized capillary electrophoresis-based chemical-analysis system on a chip. Science, 1993, 261(5123), 895–897. 28. Jacobson, S.C., Hergenroder, R., Koutny, L.B., and Ramsey, J.M. High-speed separations on a microchip. Analytical Chemistry, 1994, 66(7), 1114–1118. 29. Manz, A., Verpoorte, E., Effenhauser, C.S., Burggraf, N., Raymond, D.E., Harrison, D.J., and Widmer, H.M. Miniaturization of separation techniques using planar chip technology. HRC: Journal of High Resolution Chromatography, 1993, 16(7), 433–436. 30. Simpson, P.C., Roach, D., Woolley, A.T., Thorsen, T., Johnston, R., Sensabaugh, G.F., and Mathies, R.A. High-throughput genetic analysis using microfabricated 96-sample capillary array electrophoresis microplates. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 1998, 95(5), 2256–2261. 31. Emrich, C.A., Tian, H.J., Medintz, I.L., and Mathies, R.A. Microfabricated 384-lane capillary array electrophoresis bioanalyzer for ultrahigh-throughput genetic analysis. Analytical Chemistry, 2002, 74(19), 5076–5083. 32. Becker, H. and Gartner, C. Polymer microfabrication methods for microfluidic analytical applications. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(1), 12–26. 33. Rotting, O., Ropke, W., Becker, H., and Gartner, C. Polymer microfabrication technologies. Microsystem Technologies, 2002, 8(1), 32–36. 34. Duffy, D.C., McDonald, J.C., Schueller, O.J.A., and Whitesides, G.M. Rapid prototyping of microfluidic systems in poly(dimethylsiloxane). Analytical Chemistry, 1998, 70(23), 4974–4984. 35. Ford, S.M., Kar, B., McWhorter, S., Davies, J., Soper, S.A., Klopf, M., Calderon, G., and Saile, V. Microcapillary electrophoresis devices fabricated using polymeric substrates and x-ray lithography. Journal of Microcolumn Separations, 1998, 10(5), 413–422. 36. Effenhauser, C.S., Bruin, G.J.M., Paulus, A., and Ehrat, M. Integrated capillary electrophoresis on flexible silicone microdevices: Analysis of DNA restriction fragments and detection of single DNA molecules on microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(17), 3451–3457. 37. McDonald, J.C., Duffy, D.C., Anderson, J.R., Chiu, D.T., Wu, H.K., Schueller, O.J.A., and Whitesides, G.M. Fabrication of microfluidic systems in poly(dimethylsiloxane). Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(1), 27–40.
38
Advances in Chromatography 38. Heckele, M., Bacher, W., and Muller, K.D. Hot embossing — The molding technique for plastic microstructures. Microsystem Technologies, 1998, 4(3), 122–124. 39. Roetting, O., Heckele, M., and Bacher, W. Reactive ion etching for the production of metal microstructures by hot embossing. Microsystem Technologies, 1999, 6(1), 11–14. 40. McCormick, R.M., Nelson, R.J., AlonsoAmigo, M.G., Benvegnu, J., and Hooper, H.H. Microchannel electrophoretic separations of DNA in injection-molded plastic substrates. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(14), 2626–2630. 41. Hooper, H., McCormick, R., Alonso, G., Wang, H., and Benvegnu, D. Microchannel electrophoresis in injection molded substrates. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, 1997, 213, PMSE-333. 42. Spesny, M. and Foret, F. Microdevice for separation and quantitative fraction collection. Electrophoresis, 2003, 24(21), 3745–3747. 43. Woolley, A.T. and Mathies, R.A. Ultra-high-speed DNA fragment separations using microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis chips. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 1994, 91(24), 11348–11352. 44. Woolley, A.T. and Mathies, R.A. Ultra-high-speed DNA-sequencing using capillary electrophoresis chips. Analytical Chemistry, 1995, 67(20), 3676–3680. 45. Liu, S.R., Ren, H.J., Gao, Q.F., Roach, D.J., Loder, R.T., Armstrong, T. M., Mao, Q.L., Blaga, I., Barker, D.L., and Jovanovich, S.B. Automated parallel DNA sequencing on multiple channel microchips. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2000, 97(10), 5369–5374. 46. Medintz, I.L., Berti, L., Emrich, C.A., Tom, J., Scherer, J.R., and Mathies, R.A. Genotyping energy-transfer-cassette-labeled short-tandem-repeat amplicons with capillary array electrophoresis microchannel plates. Clinical Chemistry, 2001, 47(9), 1614–1621. 47. Medintz, I.L., Paegel, B.M., and Mathies, R.A. Microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis DNA analysis systems. Journal of Chromatography A, 2001, 924(1-2), 265–270. 48. Medintz, I., Wong, W.W., Berti, L., Shiow, L., Tom, J., Scherer, J., Sensabaugh, G., and Mathies, R.A. High-performance multiplex SNP analysis of three hemochromatosis-related mutations with capillary array electrophoresis microplates. Genome Research, 2001, 11(3), 413–421. 49. Paegel, B.M., Emrich, C.A., Weyemayer, G.J., Scherer, J.R. ,and Mathies, R.A. High throughput DNA sequencing with a microfabricated 96-lane capillary array electrophoresis bioprocessor. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2002, 99(2), 574–579. 50. Bromberg, A. and Mathies, R.A. Multichannel homogeneous immunoassay for detection of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) using a microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis chip. Electrophoresis, 2004, 25(12), 1895–1900. 51. Culbertson, C.T., Jacobson, S.C., and Ramsey, J.M. Dispersion sources for compact geometries on microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 1998, 70(18), 3781–3789. 52. Paegel, B.M., Hutt, L.D., Simpson, P.C., and Mathies, R.A. Turn geometry for minimizing band broadening in microfabricated capillary electrophoresis channels. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(14), 3030–3037. 53. Medintz, I.L., Paegel, B.M., Blazej, R.G., Emrich, C.A., Berti, L., Scherer, J.R., and Mathies, R.A. High-performance genetic analysis using microfabricated capillary array electrophoresis microplates. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(18), 3845–3856.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
39
54. Martynova, L., Locascio, L.E., Gaitan, M., Kramer, G.W., Christensen, R.G., and MacCrehan, W.A. Fabrication of plastic microfluid channels by imprinting methods. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(23), 4783–4789. 55. Wang, J., Chatrathi, M.P., Tian, B.M., and Polsky, R. Microfabricated electrophoresis chips for simultaneous bioassays of glucose, uric acid, ascorbic acid, and acetaminophen. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(11), 2514–2518. 56. Hayes, M.A., Polson, N.A., Phayre, A.N., and Garcia, A.A. Flow-based microimmunoassay. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(24), 5896–5902. 57. Guijt, R.M., Baltussen, E., and van Dedem, G.W.K. Use of bioaffinity interactions in electrokinetically controlled assays on microfabricated devices. Electrophoresis, 2002, 23(6), 823–835. 58. Guttman, A., Ronai, Z., Barta, C., Hou, Y.M., Sasvari-Szekely, M., Wang, X., and Briggs, S.P. Membrane-mediated ultrafast restriction digestion and subsequent rapid gel microchip electrophoresis of DNA. Electrophoresis, 2002, 23(10), 1524–1530. 59. Kricka, L.J. Prospects for microchips in immunoassays and immunoassay tests at the point-of-care. Journal of Clinical Ligand Assay, 2002, 25(4), 317–324. 60. Lim, T.K., Ohta, H., and Matsunaga, T. Microfabricated on-chip-type electrochemical flow immunoassay system for the detection of histamine released in whole blood samples. Analytical Chemistry, 2003, 75(14), 3316–3321. 61. Xu, H.W. and Ewing, A.G. A rapid enzyme assay for beta-galactosidase using optically gated sample introduction on a microfabricated chip. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2004, 378(7), 1710–1715. 62. Cheng, S.B., Skinner, C.D., Taylor, J., Attiya, S., Lee, W.E., Picelli, G., and Harrison, D.J. Development of a multichannel microfluidic analysis system employing affinity capillary electrophoresis for immunoassay. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(7), 1472–1479. 63. Xue, Q.F., Wainright, A., Gangakhedkar, S., and Gibbons, I. Multiplexed enzyme assays in capillary electrophoretic single-use microfluidic devices. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(18), 4000–4007. 64. Sato, K., Yamanaka, M., Takahashi, H., Tokeshi, M., Kimura, H., and Kitamori, T. Microchip-based immunoassay system with branching multichannels for simultaneous determination of interferon-gamma. Electrophoresis, 2002, 23(5), 734–739. 65. Jiang, X.Y., Ng, J.M.K., Stroock, A.D., Dertinger, S.K.W., and Whitesides, G.M. A miniaturized, parallel, serially diluted immunoassay for analyzing multiple antigens. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 2003, 125(18), 5294–5295. 66. Roddy, E.S., Price, M., and Ewing, A.G. Continuous monitoring of a restriction enzyme digest of DNA on a microchip with automated capillary sample introduction. Analytical Chemistry, 2003, 75(15), 3704–3711. 67. Roddy, E.S., Xu, H.W., and Ewing, A.G. Sample introduction techniques for microfabricated separation devices. Electrophoresis, 2004, 25(2), 229–242. 68. Smith, E.M., Xu, H.W., and Ewing, A.G. DNA separations in microfabricated devices with automated capillary sample introduction. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(2), 363–370. 69. Paxon, T.L., Brown, T.S., Lin, H.N., Brancato, S.J., Roddy, E.S., Philip C. Bevilacquaa, P.C., and Ewing, A.G. Continuous monitoring of enzyme reactions on a microchip: Application to catalytic RNA self-cleavage. Analytical Chemistry, 2004, 76(23), 6921–6927.
40
Advances in Chromatography 70. Seiler, K., Harrison, D.J., and Manz, A. Planar glass chips for capillary electrophoresis — Repetitive sample injection, quantitation, and separation efficiency. Analytical Chemistry, 1993, 65(10), 1481–1488. 71. Beard, N.R., Zhang, C.X., and deMello, A.J. In-column field-amplified sample stacking of biogenic amines on microfabricated electrophoresis devices. Electrophoresis, 2003, 24(4), 732–739. 72. Zhang, C.X. and Manz, A. Narrow sample channel injectors for capillary electrophoresis on microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(11), 2656–2662. 73. Ferrance, J. and Landers, J.P. Exploiting sensitive laser-induced fluorescence detection on electrophoretic microchips for executing rapid clinical diagnostics. Luminescence, 2001, 16(2), 79–88. 74. Medintz, I., Wong, W.W., Sensabaugh, G., and Mathies, R.A. High speed single nucleotide polymorphism typing of a hereditary haemochromatosis mutation with capillary array electrophoresis microplates. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(12), 2352–2358. 75. Effenhauser, C.S., Paulus, A., Manz, A., and Widmer, H.M. High-speed separation of antisense oligonucleotides on a micromachined capillary electrophoresis device. Analytical Chemistry, 1994, 66(18), 2949–2953. 76. Monnig, C.A., Dohmeier, D.M., and Jorgenson, J.W. Sample gating in open tubular and packed capillaries for high-speed liquid chromatography. Analytical Chemistry, 1991, 63(8), 807–810. 77. Monnig, C.A. and Jorgenson, J.W. On-column sample gating for high-speed capillary zone electrophoresis. Analytical Chemistry, 1991, 63(8), 802–807. 78. Moore, A.W. and Jorgenson, J.W. Study of zone broadening in optically gated highspeed capillary electrophoresis. Analytical Chemistry, 1993, 65(24), 3550–3560. 79. Lapos, J.A. and Ewing, A.G. Injection of fluorescently labeled analytes into microfabricated chips using optically gated electrophoresis. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(19), 4598–4602. 80. Roddy, E.S., Lapos, J.A., and Ewing, A.G. Rapid serial analysis of multiple oligonucleotide samples on a microchip using optically-gated injection. Journal of Chromatography A, 2003, 1004(1-2), 217–224. 81. Uchiyama, K., Nakajima, H., and Hobo, T. Detection method for microchip separations. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2004, 379(3), 375–382. 82. Quesada, M.A., Rye, H.S., Gingrich, J.C., Glazer, A.N., and Mathies, R.A. Highsensitivity DNA detection with a laser-excited confocal fluorescence gel scanner. Biotechniques, 1991, 10(5), 616–622, 624–625. 83. Dolnik, V., Liu, S., and Jovanovich, S. Capillary electrophoresis on microchip. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(1), 41–54. 84. Lee, T.T. and Yeung, E.S. Capillary electrophoresis detectors: Lasers. Methods in Enzymology, 1996, 270, 419–449. 85. Zhu, H.P., Clark, S.M., Benson, S.C., Rye, H.S., Glazer, A.N., and Mathies, R.A. High-sensitivity capillary electrophoresis of double-stranded DNA fragments using monomeric and dimeric fluorescent intercalating dyes. Analytical Chemistry, 1994, 66(13), 1941–1948. 86. Sassi, A.P., Paulus, A., Cruzado, I.D., Bjornson, T., and Hooper, H.H. Rapid, parallel separations of D1S80 alleles in a plastic microchannel chip. Journal of Chromatography A, 2000, 894(1-2), 203–217. 87. Kheterpal, I., Scherer, J.R., Clark, S.M., Radhakrishnan, A., Ju, J.Y., Ginther, C.L., Sensabaugh, G.F., and Mathies, R.A. DNA sequencing using a four-color confocal fluorescence capillary array scanner. Electrophoresis, 1996, 17(12), 1852–1859.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
41
88. Alexay, C., Kain, R., Hanzel, D., and Johnston, R. Fluorescence scanner employing a macro scanning objective. Proceedings of SPIE: The International Society for Optical Engineering, 1996, 2705 (Fluorescence Detection IV), 63–72. 89. Kambara, H. and Takahashi, S. Multiple-sheathflow capillary array DNA analyzer. Nature, 1993, 361(6412), 565–566. 90. Quesada, M.A. and Zhang, S.P. Multiple capillary DNA sequencer that uses fiberoptic illumination and detection. Electrophoresis, 1996, 17(12), 1841–1851. 91. Pang, H.M., Pavski, V., and Yeung, E.S. DNA sequencing using 96-capillary array electrophoresis. Journal of Biochemical and Biophysical Methods, 1999, 41(2-3), 121–132. 92. Hietpas, P.B., Bullard, K.M., Gutman, D.A., and Ewing, A.G. Ultrathin slab gel separations of DNA using a single capillary sample introduction system. Analytical Chemistry, 1997, 69(13), 2292–2298. 93. Ewing, A.G., Gavin, P.F., Hietpas, P.B., and Bullard, K.M. Continuous separations in microfabricated channels for monitoring ultrasmall biological environments. Nature Medicine, 1997, 3(1), 97–99. 94. Bullard, K.M., Hietpas, P.B., and Ewing, A.G. Capillary sample introduction of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products separated in ultrathin slab gels. Electrophoresis, 1998, 19(1), 71–75. 95. Bullard, K.M., Gavin, P.F., and Ewing, A.G. Electrophoretic separation schemes in ultrathin channels with capillary sample introduction. Trac-Trends in Analytical Chemistry, 1998, 17(7), 401–410. 96. Hietpas, P.B., Bullard, K.M., and Ewing, A.G. Characterization of electrophoretic sample transfer from a capillary to an ultrathin slab gel. Journal of Microcolumn Separations, 1998, 10(6), 519–527. 97. Bibeau, D.R., Smith, K.B., Smith, E.M., and Ewing, A.G. Separations of DNA fragments with a coated 25-μm capillary coupled to a 25-μm high open channel. Journal of Microcolumn Separations, 1999, 11(8), 567–575. 98. Bruin, G.J.M. Recent developments in electrokinetically driven analysis on microfabricated devices. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(18), 3931–3951. 99. Pingoud, A. and Jeltsch, A. Structure and function of type II restriction endonucleases. Nucleic Acids Research, 2001, 29(18), 3705–3727. 100. Han, J. and Craighead, H.G. Separation of long DNA molecules in a microfabricated entropic trap array. Science, 2000, 288(5468), 1026–1029. 101. Han, J.Y. and Craighead, H.G. Characterization and optimization of an entropic trap for DNA separation. Analytical Chemistry, 2002, 74(2), 394–401. 102. Guttman, A. Sample stacking during membrane-mediated loading in automated DNA sequencing. Analytical Chemistry, 1999, 71(16), 3598–3602. 103. Nemoda, Z., Ronai, Z., Szekely, A., Kovacs, E., Shandrick, S., Guttman, A., and Sasvari-Szekely, M. High-throughput genotyping of repeat polymorphism in the regulatory region of serotonin transporter gene by gel microchip electrophoresis. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(18), 4008–4011. 104. Carrihlo, E. DNA sequencing by capillary array electrophoresis and microfabricated array systems. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21, 55–65. 105. Liu, S.R., Shi, Y.N., Ja, W.W., and Mathies, R.A. Optimization of high-speed DNA sequencing on microfabricated capillary electrophoresis channels. Analytical Chemistry, 1999, 71(3), 566–573.
42
Advances in Chromatography
106. Simpson, J.W., Ruiz-Martinez, M.C., Mulhern, G.T., Berka, J., Latimer, D.R., Ball, J.A., Rothberg, J.M., and Went, G.T. A transmission imaging spectrograph and microfabricated channel system for DNA analysis. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(1), 135–149. 107. Backhouse, C., Caamano, M., Oaks, F., Nordman, E., Carrillo, A., Johnson, B., and Bay, S. DNA sequencing in a monolithic microchannel device. Electrophoresis, 2000, 21(1), 150–156. 108. Liu, S.R., Elkin, C., and Kapur, H. Sequencing of real-world samples using a microfabricated hybrid device having unconstrained straight separation channels. Electrophoresis, 2003, 24(21), 3762–3768. 109. Sato, K., Tokeshi, M., Odake, T., Kimura, H., Ooi, T., Nakao, M., and Kitamori, T. Integration of an immunosorbent assay system: Analysis of secretory human immunoglobulin A on polystyrene beads in a microchip. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(6), 1144–1147. 110. Sato, K., Tokeshi, M., Kimura, H., and Kitamori, T. Determination of carcinoembryonic antigen in human sera by integrated bead bed immunoasay in a microchip for cancer diagnosis. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(6), 1213–1218. 111. Colyer, C.L., Tang, T., Chiem, N., and Harrison, D.J. Clinical potential of microchip capillary electrophoresis systems. Electrophoresis, 1997, 18(10), 1733–1741. 112. Chiem, N.H. and Harrison, D.J. Monoclonal antibody binding affinity determined by microchip-based capillary electrophoresis. Electrophoresis, 1998, 19(16-17), 3040–3044. 113. Chiem, N.H. and Harrison, D.J. Microchip systems for immunoassay: An integrated immunoreactor with electrophoretic separation for serum theophylline determination. Clinical Chemistry, 1998, 44(3), 591–598. 114. Jiang, G.F., Attiya, S., Ocvirk, G., Lee, W.E., and Harrison, D.J. Red diode laser induced fluorescence detection with a confocal microscope on a microchip for capillary electrophoresis. Biosensors & Bioelectronics, 2000, 14(10-11), 861–869. 115. Qiu, C.X. and Harrison, D.J. Integrated self-calibration via electrokinetic solvent proportioning for microfluidic immunoassays. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(18), 3949–3958. 116. Taylor, J., Picelli, G., and Harrison, D.J. An evaluation of the detection limits possible for competitive capillary electrophoretic immunoassays. Electrophoresis, 2001, 22(17), 3699–3708. 117. Bromberg, A. and Mathies, R.A. Homogeneous immunoassay for detection of TNT and its analogues on a microfabricated capillary electrophoresis chip. Analytical Chemistry, 2003, 75(5), 1188–1195. 118. Ertl, P., Emrich, C.A., Singhal, P., and Mathies, R.A. Capillary electrophoresis chips with a sheath-flow supported electrochemical detection system. Analytical Chemistry, 2004, 76(13), 3749–3755. 119. Woolley, A.T., Lao, K.Q., Glazer, A.N., and Mathies, R.A. Capillary electrophoresis chips with integrated electrochemical detection. Analytical Chemistry, 1998, 70(4), 684–688. 120. Martin, R.S., Gawron, A.J., Lunte, S.M., and Henry, C.S. Dual-electrode electrochemical detection for poly(dimethylsiloxane)-fabricated capillary electrophoresis microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 2000, 72(14), 3196–3202. 121. Lunte, S.M., Martin, R.S., Gawron, A., Lacher, N., Fogarty, B., and Reagan, F. Bioanalytical applications of microchip capillary electrophoresis with electrochemical detection. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, 2001, 221, U102–U102.
Separations in Multiple-Channel Microchips
43
122. Lapos, J.A., Manica, D.P., and Ewing, A.G. Dual fluorescence and electrochemical detection on an electrophoresis microchip. Analytical Chemistry, 2002, 74(14), 3348–3353. 123. Fogarty, B.A., Lacher, N.A., Pasas, S., Vanadeever, W.R., Martin, R.S., Davies, M.I., Heppert, K,. and Lunte, S. Bioanalytical applications of microchip electrophoresis with electrochemical detection. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, 2003, 225, U151–U151. 124. Osbourn, D.M. and Lunte, C.E. On-column electrochemical detection for microchip capillary electrophoresis. Analytical Chemistry, 2003, 75(11), 2710–2714. 125. Lacher, N.A., Lunte, S.M., and Martin, R.S. Development of a microfabricated palladium decoupler/electrochemical detector for microchip capillary electrophoresis using a hybrid glass/poly(dimethylsiloxane) device. Analytical Chemistry, 2004, 76(9), 2482–2491. 126. Ramsey, R.S. and Ramsey, J.M. Microchip devices for fluidic manipulation and esi mass spectrometry. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, 1997, 214, ANYL-150. 127. Xue, Q.F., Dunayevskiy, Y.M., Foret, F., and Karger, B.L. Integrated multichannel microchip electrospray ionization mass spectrometry: Analysis of peptides from onchip tryptic digestion of melittin. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry, 1997, 11(12), 1253–1256. 128. Meng, Z.J., Qi, S.Z., Soper, S.A., and Limbach, P.A. Interfacing a polymer-based micromachined device to a nanoelectrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(6), 1286–1291. 129. Lazar, I.M., Ramsey, R.S., Sundberg, S., and Ramsey, J.M. Subattomole-sensitivity microchip nanoelectrospray source with time-of-flight mass spectrometry detection. Analytical Chemistry, 1999, 71(17), 3627–3631. 130. Lazar, I.M., Ramsey, R.S., Jacobson, S.C., Foote, R.S., and Ramsey, J.M. Novel microfabricated device for electrokinetically induced pressure flow and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Journal of Chromatography A, 2000, 892(1-2), 195–201. 131. Lazar, I.M., Ramsey, R.S., and Ramsey, J.M. On-chip proteolytic digestion and analysis using “wrong-way-round” electrospray time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Analytical Chemistry, 2001, 73(8), 1733–1739. 132. Svedberg, M., Pettersson, A., Nilsson, S., Bergquist, J., Nyholm, L., Nikolajeff, F., and Markides, K. Sheathless electrospray from polymer microchips. Analytical Chemistry, 2003, 75(15), 3934–3940. 133. Ssenyange, S., Taylor, J., Harrison, D.J., and McDermott, M.T. A glassy carbon microfluidic device for electrospray mass spectrometry. Analytical Chemistry, 2004, 76(8), 2393–2397. 134. Yang, Y.N., Kameoka, J., Wachs, T., Henion, J.D., and Craighead, H.G. Quantitative mass spectrometric determination of methylphenidate concentration in urine using an electrospray ionization source integrated with a polymer microchip. Analytical Chemistry, 2004, 76(9), 2568–2574. 135. Sinclair, J., Pihl, J., Olofsson, J., Karlsson, M., Jardemark, K., Chiu, D.T., and Orwar, O. A cell-based bar code reader for high-throughput screening of ion channel-ligand interactions. Analytical Chemistry, 2002, 74(24), 6133–6138. 136. Olofsson, J., Karlsson, M., Pihl, J., Sinclair, J., and Orwar, O. Microfluidic chips for time-resolved high-throughput patch-clamp studies. Biophysical Journal, 2003, 84(2), 488a–488a.
44
Advances in Chromatography
137. Pihl, J., Sinclair, J., Olofsson, J., Sahlin, E., Karlsson, M,. and Orwar, O. A microfluidic tool for studies of multi-component concentration dependent ion channel effecters. Biophysical Journal, 2004, 86(1), 482a–482a. 138. Farre, C., Sinclair, J., Pihl, J., Olofsson, J., and Orwar, O. Microfluidic chip solutions for patch-clamp-based high-content-screening. Biophysical Journal, 2004, 86(1), 482a–482a. 139. Sinclair, J., Pihl, J., Olofsson, J., Farre, C., and Orwar, O. Microfluidic devices for high-content ion channel screening. Biophysical Journal, 2004, 86(1), 355a–355a.
2
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography Elsa Lundanes University of Oslo, Norway
Tyge Greibrokk University of Oslo, Norway
CONTENTS Abstract ....................................................................................................................45 2.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................46 2.2 Temperature Effects on Retention and Selectivity ........................................46 2.3 Conventional Analytical LC...........................................................................49 2.3.1 Columns and Stationary Phases.........................................................49 2.3.2 Temperature Programming and Instrumentation ...............................51 2.3.3 Applications .......................................................................................52 2.4 Capillary LC...................................................................................................56 2.4.1 Columns and Stationary Phases.........................................................56 2.4.2 Temperature Programming and Instrumentation ...............................63 2.4.3 Applications .......................................................................................65 References................................................................................................................66
ABSTRACT Temperature has a large effect on retention, selectivity, and column efficiency and has long been accepted as an important parameter in liquid chromatography (LC). Despite this fact, temperature has not been very actively utilized in the past, mainly because of reported stability problems of the most commonly used stationary phases. However, more interest in the application of temperature for retention control has come of late because of the trend of miniaturization in chromatography and the availability of temperature-stable stationary phases. This work gives an overview of temperature effects on retention and selectivity in chromatography, especially on reversed-phase columns. Instrumental requirements, especially with respect to performing temperature gradient elution, are discussed and applications on both conventional-sized analytical columns and capillary columns are included.
45
46
Advances in Chromatography
2.1 INTRODUCTION Even though temperature influences parameters like solubility, diffusivity, mobile phase polarity, and viscosity, temperature has not been very actively used in liquid chromatography and most analyses are carried out at ambient temperature. However, in recent years there has been an increasing awareness of the potential of temperature for achieving better chromatographic resolution by either improvement in selectivity or chromatographic efficiency. At high temperatures, the viscosity is reduced and the diffusion rate is increased; thus, the mass transfer rate between the stationary and mobile phase is increased as well as the efficiency [1, 2] and it is possible to decrease the analysis time substantially [3, 4]. The temperature effect upon retention was extensively studied in reversed-phase systems as can be seen in review articles [2, 5–7] and some recent publications [4, 8–15]. However, temperature has also been actively used for retention control in normal-phase [16, 17], ion exchange [18, 19], and hydrophobic interaction chromatography [20], as well as on temperature-responsive stationary phases [21–24]. Despite the advantages of using high temperatures, the stability of the stationary phases commonly used in liquid chromatography (LC) today has hampered the development of temperature-optimized analytical methods. This review will elaborate upon the influence of temperature upon retention and selectivity as well as methods using temperature actively to optimize the separations both in conventional sized columns and smaller-diameter columns. This review will not include temperature effects in electrochromatography but information on this topic can be found elsewhere [6, 25]. Also, note that temperature regulation of retention may have been used in papers not included in this review, since the focus is on studies where temperature has been actively and explicitly used.
2.2 TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON RETENTION AND SELECTIVITY Because reversed-phase chromatography is the separation mode used in about 80 to 90% of LC methods, the majority of studies involving temperature effects have been on reversed-phase stationary phases. The relationship between the retention factor, k, and the column temperature is well known [26, 27] and can be described by the equation: ln k = – ΔH/RT + ΔS/R + ln Φ
(2.1)
where R is the universal gas constant, T is the temperature, ΔH and ΔS are the enthalpy and entropy of a solute transfer from the mobile phase to the stationary phase, respectively, and Φ is the phase ratio of the column (the stationary to mobile phase volume ratio). The linear relationship between ln k and 1/T found in most studies with reversed-phase chromatography is also found in normal-phase as well as in cation-exchange chromatography [28]. The retention behavior in reversed-phase LC has been discussed on the basis of enthalpy−entropy compensation (EEC) between ΔH and ΔS (see [29] and references
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
47
3.5 3
In k or α
2.5 2
Benzene Toluene Selectivity
1.5 1 R2 = 0.989
0.5 0 0.0028
0.0030
84
60
0.0032 0.0034 1/T (1/K) 40
21
0.0036
0.0038
5
−10
T(ºC)
FIGURE 2.1 Van’t Hoff plots of benzene, toluene, and their difference, which is the methylene selectivity. The phase−ratio-dependent plots of benzene and toluene are non-linear while the phase-ratio-independent methylene selectivity plot is linear. Again, this suggests a phaseratio dependence in the van’t Hoff plots of benzene and possibly toluene. Experimental conditions: water-methanol (60:40) mobile phase, ODS stationary phase, at a flow-rate of 1.00 mL/min. From [41].
therein). ΔH and ΔS associated with the retention mechanism can be estimated by using the van’t Hoff equation (Equation 2.1). In reversed-phase chromatography, the value of ΔH is typically 7 to 15 kJ/mol for small solutes [2, 29–38], while larger molecules like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) [28] usually have larger (negative) enthalpies. A common intersection point has been found for the ln k vs. 1/T lines of homologues in reversed-phase systems [39]. However, because of changes in the molecular conformation, plots of ln k vs. 1/T (van’t Hoff plot) often appear nonlinear for biopolymers like proteins [40]. However, Chester and Coym presented mathematical evidence and showed that phase ratio changes can also cause deviation from linearity for smaller molecules in van’t Hoff plots in the temperature range –5 to 80˚C [41] (see Figure 2.1). A wider temperature range was explored by Guillarme et al. [4], who studied the effect of temperature on the solute behavior on reversed-phase stationary phases that are thermally stable in the temperature range from 30 to 200˚C. All van’t Hoff plots were linear in the narrow temperature range 25 to 80˚C on all the types of stationary phases; however, within a larger range of temperature, a quadratic model was required. Nonlinear van’t Hoff plots were observed in the case of acetonitrile−water mixtures or water as mobile phase, while the plots of log k vs. 1/T for the Hypercarb column (20 to 180˚C) was linear whatever the organic solvent (methanol or acetonitrile) used. Jinno et al. [42] studied the effect of temperature in reversed-phase chromatography down to 50˚C and found that the retention mechanism in the lower temperature range is similar to that of the
48
Advances in Chromatography
normal temperature range when the water content of the mobile phase exceeds 10%. Mobile phases of pure water at superheated temperatures, between 100 and 200˚C, have also been explored and significant differences in the enthalpy of the retention process at high temperatures (–30 to –40 kJ/mol) were found, as compared to that at low temperatures of 15 to 55˚C (–6 to –13 kJ/mol) [43]. In a recent paper, the effect of temperature on the retention of ionizable compounds was addressed [44] and the authors pointed out that differences in ionization enthalpies of the buffers resulted in different eluent pH when the temperature was raised. Li [45] also found that buffers can play a very important role in affecting retention and selectivity with changes in temperature. The retention times of some bases increased with increasing temperature in the investigated range up to 70˚C using a mobile phase pH of about 7.8 [46]. The peak shapes also significantly improved, especially for weak bases (pKa ≈ 8). The increase in retention and improvement in efficiency were explained by the reduction in the pKa of bases with temperature, leading to reduction in protonation. Quaternary ammonium compounds showed normal behavior, i.e., reduced retention with increasing column temperature. The relationship in Equation 2.1 shows that for the same change in temperature, the retention factor of solutes with large ΔH is more strongly affected than that of solutes with small ΔH, providing different selectivity at different temperatures. Thus, a change in temperature can give a separation of solutes not obtained at the initial temperature explored. The effect of temperature upon retention is, however, rather small compared to the effect provided by an increase in mobile phase strength. A 4˚C increase in temperature was found to correspond to a 1% methanol increase [47], while another study showed that a 5˚C change in column temperature had the same effect on retention as a 1% change in acetonitrile concentration [48]. Similar values for neutral solutes were later found in another study using reversed-phase columns [49]. This result means that the elution strength window of temperature is much less than that of an organic modifier in a reversed-phase system and temperature programs cannot generally replace solvent gradients. In a series of papers, Snyder et al. [50–53] optimized reversed-phase separations of different solutes by changing the temperature or the solvent gradient to improve the selectivity, while Dolan et al. varied the temperature and solvent gradient steepness for maximizing the resolution using computer simulations [54]. These researchers showed that simultaneous changes in temperature and either gradient time (tG) or solvent strength (% B) is effective for control of selectivity in reversed-phase LC. When a solvent gradient is undesirable, isocratic separation can be optimized by varying the temperature and the mobile phase strength [55]. Neue and Mazzeo performed a theoretical study on optimization of solvent gradients at elevated temperatures and showed that the reduction in viscosity and improvement in diffusivity — and hence the mass transfer — made it possible to increase the speed of the separation [56]. The temperature dependence on retention using different mobile phases to assess the validity of hydrophobic theory as the driving force for retention has been addressed [57], as well as the influence of the temperature (23 to 73˚C) on the equilibrium isotherm [58].
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
49
2.3 CONVENTIONAL ANALYTICAL LC 2.3.1 COLUMNS
AND
STATIONARY PHASES
In almost all the papers mentioned above, silica-based reversed-phase columns have been used, mostly C18 columns. The mechanism of separation using C1, C4, C8, and C18 has been shown to be the same in the temperature range 0 to 77˚C [59] and changes in relative retention with temperature were approximately constant for different values of the gradient time tG for different C18 and C18 reversed-phase columns [60]. Raman spectroscopy has been used to study the temperature-induced surface changes in high-density C18 stationary phases [61]. Conformations and interchain coupling of the alkyl components of these phases were found to be sensitive to temperature and surface coverage, and each of the high-density C18 stationary phases exhibited subtle temperature-dependent phase changes. Linear van’t Hoff plots were produced for various monomeric and polymeric C18 phases over temperature ranges of about 30 K using water-containing mobile phases [27, 35, 62–64]. ΔS˚ values were provided only in a few studies [63, 64]; however, in the temperature range –5 to 80˚C, the entropic contribution to retention becomes more significant with respect to the enthalpic contribution when the stationary phase bonding density is increased for monomeric C18 phases [65] and the stationary phase structure gives an important contribution to selectivity, particularly at subambient temperatures [66]. In an early study, Chmielowiec and Sawatzky also showed that entropy effects can be large for molecules like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons on these phases [67]. The influence of temperature upon separation on C30 phases has been addressed in several studies [68, 69] and Albert et al. [68, 70] found that the strongly temperature-dependent separation characteristics of polymeric C30 phases correlated with the alkyl chain arrangement at the silica surface. By FTIR studies, titania-based self-assembled monolayer C30 phases were found to possess a higher degree of conformational order than zirconia- and silica-based C30 [71]. The stability of the commonly used silica-based reversed-phase materials has been a limiting factor for exploiting temperature for retention and selectivity control and the benefits of using higher temperatures for separation have not been achieved. Silica-based materials have been used up to 100˚C [72, 73] as can be seen in Figure 2.2, even though temperatures above 60˚C are usually not recommended [4, 15]. In addition to the temperature, the mobile phase composition, including the type of buffer used and the pH, influences the column lifetime of silica-based phases. In a recent paper, Claessens and van Straten [74] reviewed the chemical and thermal stability of reversed-phase stationary phases. Different silica-based, zirconia-based, and polymer columns are compared and they concluded that for many separation needs, specific silica reversed phases offered sufficient thermal stability from subambient and up to 90˚C. However, they also pointed out that reversed-phase stationary phases based on other inorganic substances and polymers may be needed for methods requiring higher thermal stability. In the recent study by Guillarme et al. [4], silica-based columns were used only in the temperature range 20 to 100˚C due to thermal instability, while the porous carbon, PS-DVB, and zirconia-based columns
50
Advances in Chromatography
mAU 80 70
(a)
60 50 40 30 20 10 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
min
10
15
20
25
30
min
10
15
20
25
30
min
mAU 80 70
(b)
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
5
mAU 80 70
(c)
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
5
FIGURE 2.2 Separation of polymers of average mass (A) 30,000, (B) 15,000, and (C) 8,000 on a non-porous Hytach C18 column operated at 100˚C with a gradient of 0 to 100% B in 60 min, where A is 400 mM NaClO4 and solvent B is 400 mM NaClO4 in acetonitrile-water (20:80). From [73].
could be used up to 180˚C. That the carbon columns and polymeric columns display better thermal stability has also been reported by others [4, 15, 75] and the influence of temperature on retention and selectivity on the polymeric columns has also been studied using the solvation parameter model [76]. An alumina-based C18 material was used up to 150˚C [77] but these materials have not been widely used. As mentioned above, zirconia-based stationary phases have been reported to be stable at high temperatures (see also [3, 78, 79]). The effect of temperature on the thermodynamic and dynamic properties of the zirconia-based stationary phases were investigated by Carr et al. [80] who found that, depending on the solute, the temperature can be a very important variable to also improve the selectivity on these
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
51
3
400
(b) 4 300
2 1
200
5
Absorbance (mAU)
100
0 500
0.0
0.2
3
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0 (a)
400
4
2 1
300 200
5 100 0 0
3
6
9
12
15
Time (min)
FIGURE 2.3 Chromatograms of a reversed-phase mixture on PBD-coated zirconia. Plot A is the chromatogram at 30˚C and 1 mL/min and plot B is the chromatogram at 100˚C and 5 mL/min. Solutes: 1, uracil; 2, p-nitroaniline; 3, methyl benzoate; 4, phenetole; and 5, toluene. From [3].
phases. By using high temperatures, very fast separations using high flow rates are possible [3]. An 18-fold improvement relative to that at lower temperatures and normal flow rates was reported on these phases (see Figure 2.3).
2.3.2 TEMPERATURE PROGRAMMING
AND INSTRUMENTATION
A majority of the studies on the influence of temperature in analytical-sized columns has been performed using conventional equipment and isothermal conditions. The column thermostatting devices used vary widely in their design, and the actual temperature in the column may be quite different when two different LC systems are used [81, 82]. In most cases, mobile phase preheating is performed by either placing a preheating tube into a column liquid bath or an air circulation oven. A water or oil bath is more efficient than the air bath [83]; however, a recent study
52
Advances in Chromatography
concludes that it is quite possible to use an air system with analytical sized columns up to 150˚C and with columns with I.D. of 1 mm or less up to 200˚C [4]. Spearman et al. [82] monitored the effective column temperature by exploiting the shape selectivity and hydrophobicity of selected solutes, and suggested a method to distinguish between temperature and mobile phase composition differences that cause nonreproducibility in transferring methods between instruments and laboratories. They also found a marked increase in efficiency as the mobile phase temperature was reduced below the column temperature, in contrast to claims that thermal equilibration is essential [81, 83, 84]. The use of temperature gradients for retention control and selectivity optimization has not been widely used in analytical LC even though a temperature-programmed separation on alumina was published in 1966 [85], as well as a temperature-programmed (15 to 50˚C) separation of PAHs on a 4.6 mm I.D. C18 column in 1979 [67]. One of the reasons for the near-absence of temperature programming in analytical sized systems is that this methodology has been associated with radial temperature gradients and subsequent band broadening [81]. Poppe and Kraak [83] showed that the difference in temperature between the incoming mobile phase and the column was detrimental to the efficiency, a problem confirmed by others [81, 84]. Wolcott et al. suggested that the temperature difference between the entering mobile phase and the column oven should be within ±6˚C [81], and Djordjevic et al. [86] showed that analytical sized columns can be used with temperature programming if a mobile phase preheater is installed. In a recent study, Molander et al. [87] demonstrated that the column I.D. is not a critical limiting factor when performing temperature programming in LC, at least for columns narrower than 4.6 mm I.D. in the temperature range 30 to 90˚C. However, the relative apparent efficiency was inversely proportional to the column I.D., making the capillary columns generally more attractive for use with temperature gradients with respect to efficiency, as will be elaborated upon later in this review. Others have also found that with narrow-bore columns, the thermal mismatch effects are reduced significantly and can be neglected due to the fast heat transfer [47, 84]. However, despite these reports, temperature gradient elution was used in a few studies using microbore [88, 89] and conventional sized columns [11, 15, 90]. A thermal gradient technique that combined flow and temperature programming was suggested by Moore and Synovec [91] for microbore LC.
2.3.3 APPLICATIONS Even though most published studies utilizing temperature in LC have been of more or less fundamental character, temperature has also been actively used in conventional LC to solve separation needs, the goal of most analysts. In the majority of studies, C18 or C8 reversed-phase materials were used despite the fact that the largest influence of temperature has been found for long alkyl chain length stationary phases [7]. By optimizing the temperature, isothermal solvent gradient separation of 11 carotenoid isomers was obtained on a C30 column in the temperature range 15 to 25˚C [9]. The use of C30 stationary phases for determination of carotenoids, retinoids, and other related compounds in food has been reviewed [92].
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
53
Snyder et al. actively used temperature to optimize the separation of tryptic digests as well as other peptide and protein samples on C18 columns in the temperature range 20 to 60˚C [93, 94]. In a series of papers, Hodges et al. also studied the temperature selectivity effects of peptides in reversed-phase LC [13, 95–97] using both silica-based C8, CN [13, 95, 97] and PV-DVB [96] columns and a temperature range (isothermal) from 5 to 80˚C. They argued that variations in temperature can be used to affect significant changes in selectivity among peptide analogues and that a temperature-based approach to reversed-phase LC can be used to distinguish varying amino acid substituents at the same site of the peptide sequence. Lee et al. [12] studied the effect of temperature on the retention behavior of 14-residue cyclic and linear cationic peptides on a C18 column in the range 5 to 80˚C as a method to detect and measure self-association of small molecules. Temperature-controlled (35 to 60˚C) reversed-phase LC has also been used to obtain separation of phenylthiohydantoin-amino acids [98]. In this case, a temperature step program was used simultaneously with a solvent gradient. In a study on the effect of temperature (20 to 60˚C) and flow rate on the chromatography of basic compounds on a C18 column [8], the efficiency was improved at higher temperatures. However, the retention of bases often showed an anomalous increase with temperature, and the complex retention mechanisms were also dependent upon the buffer cation concentration. Guiochon et al. [10] studied the effect of temperature and pressure on protein adsorption equilibrium in reversed-phase C8 columns and found that the retention time increased substantially (up to 300%) when the pressure or the temperature increased in the pressure range 47 to 147 bar, and temperature range 25 to 50˚C. The relation between temperature and ln k is nonlinear with a parabolic shape. Dolfinger and Locke [99] studied the effect of temperature and eluent composition on the selectivity on different fluorinated and hydrocarbon reversed-phase columns for separation of 15 taxanes and found an increase of k for the xylosyl taxanes with increasing temperature in the range 25 to 55˚C on the C8 column, while the other taxanes behaved more normally. The same pattern was observed on one of the fluorinated phases. The separation of DNA fragments (21 to 587 bp) on nonporous C18 alkylated PS-DVB and alkylated wide-pore silica columns was studied in the temperature range 25 to 60˚C, and the optimum temperature was found between 40 and 50˚C using a solvent gradient [100]. Increasing the temperature changes the solvent polarity [101], and superheated water [102] and superheated deuterium oxide [11] have also been used as mobile phases in reversed-phase chromatography. Superheated water (170 to 200˚C) was used for the separation of steroids on a polymer-coated zirconia column and a complementary retention and retention mechanism compared to that on a traditional silica-based C18 and acetonitrile-water mobile phase at 40˚C was found; however, unique selectivity was obtained. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis of a ginger extract was obtained, on-line and off-line, by temperature programmed elution (50 to 130˚C) on a silica-based C18 column using superheated deuterium oxide (see Figure 2.4). The authors reported the efficiency was much better on the silica-based reversed-phase column than on a PBD-zirconia phase using superheated deuterium oxide as mobile phase. Dimethyl sulfoxide-modified subcritical water has been used for the separation of polar and nonpolar analytes such as polyhydroxybenzenes,
2.70:2
15.0
3.10:1
30.0
45.0
60.0
mU
Advances in Chromatography
72.5
54
min 47.0
40.0
35.0
30.0
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
−1.7 0.0
Zingerone
FIGURE 2.4 Separation of a 30-μL ginger extract on Xterra RP18 column using superheated deuterium oxide as mobile phase. Conditions: temperature 50 to 130˚C at 4˚C/min; eluent, deuterium oxide at 0.5 mL/min; detection, 280 nm. From [11].
phenol derivatives, alkylated benzenes, and PAHs using a silica-based C18 column, which was found to be stable in the temperature range 25 to 125˚C [103]. Methanol− water mixtures at elevated temperatures up to 140˚C have been used for the separation of nonpolar analytes like PAHs and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) on a silica-based C18 column [104]. By using ion-pair reversed-phase chromatography on a C8 column and optimizing the temperature in the range 35 to 55˚C, an almost complete separation of 23 trinitrotoluene metabolites and EPA Method 8338-compounds was achieved [14]. Increased temperature resulted in shorter retention time and better resolution, especially for the amino aromatics. The influence of temperature on the separation of steroids on a C18 column with a mobile phase modified by β-cyclodextrin was studied in the temperature range 5 to 80˚C [105] and the plot of ln k vs. 1/T was nonlinear in the investigated range. Ion-pair chromatography of aminoalcohol enantiomers on a carbon column using a mobile phase with N-derivatized peptides as the chiral selector was studied in the temperature range from –5 to 25˚C [106]. The
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
55
plots of ln k vs. 1/T were almost linear and the best separation was obtained at the lower temperatures. The effect upon retention in hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) has also been studied, and nonlinear van’t Hoff plots are found for aromatic alcohol homologues on a silica-based polyethylene glycol column in the temperature range 0 to 80˚C [20]. The effect of temperature on the separation of polar compounds like urea, sucrose, and glycine on a diol column used in HIC has also been studied and ln k was found to decrease linearly with increasing temperature in the range 30 to 60˚C [107]. The influence of temperature in ion chromatography has not been widely examined. However, a study on the separation of aluminum and its fluoro, oxalate, and citrate species, where the temperature was varied in the range –10 to 55˚C on a cation exchanger, revealed that the distribution of the species varied with temperature and that temperatures below 10˚C could be used to suppress disintegration of the fluoride and oxalate ligands [18]. The retention and resolution of alkali metal on chelating stationary phases increased with decreasing temperature in the investigated range 1 to 75˚C and the dependence of ln K on 1/T could be approximated by second-order polynomials [108]. The temperature-responsive phases are made with the intention that the temperature should influence the retention. Hosoya et al. [109] developed a poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) polymer-based stationary phase that provided temperature-dependent separation selectivity in drug separation in the temperature range 30 to 50˚C. Separations of peptides and proteins were also explored on an N-isopropylacrylamide polymer-modified column in the temperature range 5 to 10˚C [21]. An N-isopropylacrylamide copolymer-modified silica column was developed and applied for the separation of five steroids having various hydrophobicities [110]. The retention increased with increasing temperature (5 to 50˚C); however, the van’t Hoff plots were not linear. The retention of some proteins was also studied at temperatures of 5 and 30˚C, the latter giving the highest retention. The poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)bonded stationary phase showed an increase in retention and column efficiency with an increase in temperature between 30 and 40˚C using benzene derivatives and alkyl phenyl ketones as model substances [22]. The temperature-responsive properties were reduced with increasing methanol content of the mobile phase and lost at 40% or higher. The temperature-responsive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-modified silica was also examined for its suitability to provide separation of steroids, alkaloids and substituted anilines [23]. In this case, the temperature-responsive phase showed changes in surface properties with an increase in temperature (5 to 55˚C) with a methanol content up to 20%. The temperature-responsive chiral polymer column composed of L-valine diamide derivatives provided enantiomeric separation of amino acid derivatives in the temperature range 0 to 70˚C in aqueous mobile phases (containing 1% methanol) [24]. The retention increased with increasing temperature and the enantioselectivity was also enhanced with temperature up to a critical temperature. The effect of temperature on the enantioseparation of 71 chiral compounds was studied on four macrocyclic glycopeptide chiral selectors — teicoplanin, its aglycone, ristocetin A and vancomycin — using both reversed-phase, normal-phase, and polar ionic mode
56
Advances in Chromatography
(PIM) mobile phases [111]. In the majority of cases, the enantioseparation decreased or even vanished when the temperature was increased. All van’t Hoff plots were linear, showing that the selector did not change in the investigated temperature range (5 to 45˚C). The retention of enantiomers on silica-based tris(1,3-dimethylphenylcarbamate)-derivatized cellulose was studied in the temperature range 12 to 40˚C in the reversed-phase mode using various mobile phase compositions [112]. The van’t Hoff plots were linear, the retention increased with decreasing temperature and the thermodynamic data revealed that the enantio separation was enthalpy-controlled. A human serum albumin (HSA) chiral stationary phase has also been explored for its potential to give separation of dansyl amino acids in the temperature range 3 to 27˚C [113]. Different van’t Hoff plot shapes were observed with different mobile phase pH, indicating a change in retention mechanism.
2.4 CAPILLARY LC The main advantage of narrow I.D. columns is the possibility to achieve lower detection limits when using concentration sensitive detectors, and this is especially advantageous when the sample amount is limited. The first attempts to study the effects of temperature with narrow-bore columns was in the 1980s [114–118] but it is the advent of packed capillary columns that has spurred the interest in using temperature as a parameter in liquid chromatography. In the following sections, the recent achievements in capillary LC utilizing the temperature for retention control and separation optimization are presented.
2.4.1 COLUMNS
AND
STATIONARY PHASES
The low thermal mass of the capillary columns results in a quick response to temperature changes, making rapid temperature programs possible. Thus, capillary columns with temperature gradients have recently been demonstrated in several studies (see Table 2.1). Most of the recent studies on temperature in capillary chromatography have been carried out using packed columns; however, both monolithic columns [119–121] and open capillary columns [122–126] have been utilized. So far, open tubular columns have not gained much interest because of either the requirement of a narrow I.D. or of very high temperatures. Monolithic polystyrene/divinylbenzene (PS-DVB) capillary columns have been used for separation of nucleic acids, proteins, and tryptic digests. Because of the polymerization-related variation in surface area of these monolithic columns, temperature regulation has been applied to optimize the resolution and obtain harmonized elution profiles for columns in parallel [119, 120] (see Figure 2.5). The inner diameter of these columns were 0.2 mm or less and they had a relatively short length of about 6 cm. Generally, temperatures above 40˚C are used isothermally [119, 120, 127–131] but temperaturegradient programming has also been used [121]. A methacrylate monolithic column intended for electrochromatography has also been used in the LC mode and showed a decrease in retention with increasing temperature (12 to 50˚C) [132]. The most common inner diameters of the packed capillary columns are 0.25 and 0.32 mm, but 0.50 mm I.D. has also been used (see Table 2.1). The column body
ACN/phosphate buffer (pH 7) 25–90 (I) MeOH/0.8% H3PO4 (56/44) 20–65 (G)
30–120 (G) 68–55 (inv. G) 30–80 (I)
0.05 × 150 mm nonporous PB-zirconia 0.30 × 150 mm Hypersil C18 BDS (3)
30–90 (G) 50–100 (G+I)
0.32+ × 150 mm Hypersil ODS (3) 0.50 × 100 mm PBD-ZrO2 (3)
0.25 × 200 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) 0.50 × 100 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) 0.20 × 100 mm Hypercarb (5)
15–70 (I) 30–150 (G+I) UV ELSD + ESITOFMS UV UV
ELSD
UV
UV and MS
Detector
Lab-made cLC-oven
UV UV
“Tailor-made” UV cLC-oven ELSD Col. oven UV
GC-oven GC-oven
cLC-oven GC-oven
30–120 (G)
ACN/water ACN/20 mM phosphate pH 7 (50/50) ACN ACN/THF/water (40/5/55) ACN/water; pH 2.2 and 12
GC-oven
50–120 (I+G)
22–70 (I)
Heating System
0.18 × 60 mm PLRP-S 300 PS-PVB (5) ACN/water/TFA 0.18 × 60 mm monolithic PS-PVB 0.32 × 350 mm Hypersil ODS (3) Ethyl acetate/ACN/TEA/AA (45.0/44.5/10.0/0.1) 0.32 × 100 mm PS-PVB SAX (10) pH-gradient of amine buffers 0.32 × 600 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) Acetone/ACN
ACN/water/additive
Mobile Phase(s)
Temperature Range (°°C) (G = Gradient, I = Isothermal) Col. oven or circulating water bath GC-oven
0.20 × 60 mm monolithic PS-PVB
Dimension and Packing Particle Diameter (µm)
TABLE 2.1 Temperature Studies on Capillary Columns
Split 20
500a 100b 0.06
0.05 0.05
100 0.05–0.5
0.5
0.05
0.5
Inj. Vol. (µL)
Ref.
Polymer additives PEG 4000-3500 Sulfated glycosaminoglycan disaccharides Test compounds Chlorophenoxy acid herbicides
Hindered amine light stabilizers Proteins Polyglycerol fatty acid esters Alkylbenzenes Test compounds
Proteins
[140] [156]
[138] [155] [144]
[87] [139]
[19] [146]
[153]
[121]
Peptides, proteins [162]
Analyte(s)
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography 57
0.32 0.32 0.32 0.32
× × × ×
400 400 300 250
mm mm mm mm
Kromasil C18 (3.5) Hypersil ODS (3) Hypersil ODS (3) Hypersil ODS (3)
0.30 × 150 mm Spherisorb ODS2 (3)
Temperature Range (°°C) (G = Gradient, I = Isothermal)
ACN/ammonium acetate pH 7 (69/31) ACN/DCM, THF/water, ACN/water ACN/water (30/70) MeOH/citric acid pH 3.1 (5/95)
Col. oven cLC-oven
51–57 (I) 10–90 (I+G)
80–30 (inv. G) 30–100 (G)
8–75 (G)
cLC-oven, GC-oven cLC-oven GC-oven
cLC-oven
GC-oven
80–95 (G)
15–70 (G)
GC-oven
cLC-oven GC-oven
Col. oven
Heating System
110–170 (G)
54–57 (I) ACN/(TEA+EDTA; pH 7) gradient 5–90 (G) ACN added TEA+FA ACN/ammonium formate pH 35–100 (G) 4 (25/75)
Mobile Phase(s)
0.32 × 1000 mm 4000Å Nucleosil silica TCB/isododecane/BuOH (5) 0.32 × 250 mm Hypersil ODS (3) ACN/ammonium formate pH 6 (40/60) 0.20 × 60 mm monolithic PS-DVB × 4 ACN/TEEA pH 7 0.32 × 200 mm C18 columnsc (3) MeOH and ACN/water pH 2–7
0.25 × 250 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) 0.32 × 300 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5)
0.20 × 60 mm monolithic PS-DVB
Dimension and Packing Particle Diameter (µm)
TABLE 2.1 (CONTINUED) Temperature Studies on Capillary Columns
ELSD Electrochemical
UV
UV
LIF UV
UV
ELSD
UV UV
UV
Detector
0.55 0.06
0.2
5
1 0.05
1000b
0.06
500b at 5˚C 10
1
Inj. Vol. (µL)
PEG 1000 Tyrosines, DOPA
Diisocyanate derivatives DNA fragments Acidic, basic, neutral compounds Triazine herbicides Polystyrenes
Nucleic acids, proteins Irganox 1076 Citalopran, fluoxetine, paroxetine + metabolites Polymer blend
Analyte(s)
[163] [151]
[149]
[158]
[119] [49]
[135]
[17]
[136] [157]
[120]
Ref.
58 Advances in Chromatography
cLC-oven GC-oven GC-oven GC-oven
GC-oven
10–70 (G) 30–150 (G) 25–70 (I) 40–150 (I+G)
50–150 (G)
ACN/dichloromethane (70/30) 0.32 × 400–700 mm Hypersil ODS (3/5) ACN/DMF and other nonaqueous solvents 0.32 × 250 mm Suplex pKb-100 (5) ACN/5% ammonium acetate/AA (94.9/5/0.075) 0.32 × 230–435 mm Hypersil ODS (5) ACN or 0.32 × 230 mm Kromasil C18 (5) MeOH/AA/pyridine/water (85/4/1/10) 0.32 × 700 mm Hypersil ODS or BDS ACN/DMF (90/10) or (3/5) or Kromasil C18 (5) ACN/pyridine (95/5)
0.32 × 400 mm YMC C30 (5)
GC-oven
70–130 (G)
cLC-oven GC-oven
7–90 (G) 30–160 (G)
ACN ACN or ethyl acetate/ACN (10/90)
0.32 × 350–1000 mm Kromasil C18 (5) ACN/MIBK (75/25)
GC-oven GC-oven GC-oven
50–120 (G) 30–130 (G) 30–130 (G)
ACN ACN and ACN/MIBK ethyl acetate/ ACN/TEA (40/50/10)
cLC-oven cLC-oven GC-oven
0.32 × 300 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) 0.32 × 350–1000 mm Kromasil C18 (5) 0.32 × 350 mm Hypersil ODS (3) 0.32 × 350 mm Hypersil BDS (5) 0.32 × 350 mm Kromasil C18 (5) 0.32 × 280 mm Kromasil C18 (5) 0.32 × 280 mm Hypersil ODS (3) 0.32 × 700 mm Hypersil BDS (5)
6–90 (G+I) 5–90 (G) 28–120 (G)
ACN/water ACN/(TEA+FA) ACN/TEA (95/5)
0.32 × 250 mm Hypersil C18 (3) 0.32 × 500 mm Kromasil C18 (3.5) 0.32 × 400 mm Hypersil ODS (3)
ELSD
ICP-MS
UV-VIS
UV or ELSD
UV-VIS
ELSD
UV ELSD
UV + FT-IR ELSD ELSD
UV ELSD ELSD
0.06
0.06
100
0.06
20 at 10˚C
0.06 at 100˚C
100 at 7˚C 0.05
0.06 0.06 0.50
0.05 100 at 5˚C 0.05
[159]
[168]
[134] [150]
[166] [167] [147]
[164] [165] [148]
[171]
[170]
Fatty amides, [172] glycerylmonoste arate
Retinol, retinoic acids Tetreethyl- and tetramethyl lead
Polymer additives [169]
Irganox 1076 Polymer additives and glyceryl monostearate Hydrocarbon waxes Retinyl esters
Iodixanol Ceramides Hindered amine stabilizers Polymer additives Technical waxes Hindered amine stabilizers
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography 59
c
b
a
MeOH/acetate buffer pH 5 (30/70) ACN/water ACN/water (72/28) MeOH/water ACN/DMF or ACN/N,Ndimethylacetamide ACN/water or MeOH/water ACN/water or MeOH/water MeOH or ACN/water
Mobile Phase(s)
Lab. made Lab. made Lab. made
GC-oven SFC-oven GC-oven GC-oven
30–120 (G) 24–80 (I) 25–150 (I+G) 50–150 (G) 100–150 (I) 100–200 (I) 30–80 (G)
Lab.-made
Heating System
150 (I)
Temperature Range (°°C) (G = Gradient, I = Isothermal)
cold zone at 10˚C using a column switching system columns used: Zorbax C18 (XDB, SB and Extend), Hypersil ODS, XTerra MS 18 and YMC C30
AA = acetic acid FA = formic acid TCB = trichlorobenzene
0.05 × 1500 mm SB-methyl-100 0.05–0.1 × 8000mm octyl polysiloxane 0.08–0.25 × 1000–5000 mm Develosil ODS (3/5/7/10)
0.05 × 2000 mm cyano and octyl polysiloxane 0.18 × 250 mm Zorbax SB ODS (6) 0.2 × 800 mm Phenomenex C18 (5) 0.05 × 1500 mm octyl polysilixane 0.32 ×700 mm Hypersil ODS (3/5)
Dimension and Packing Particle Diameter (µm)
TABLE 2.1 (CONTINUED) Temperature Studies on Capillary Columns
UV UV UV
UV UV UV + MS UV
UV
Detector
0.07 0.005 0.1–0.2
0.06 0.06 0.01 0.06
10
Inj. Vol. (µL)
Test compounds Test compounds p-nitrobenzyl esters of fatty acids
Alkylbenzenes Test compounds Test compounds Polymer additives
Test compounds
Analyte(s)
[123] [122] [175]
[48] [173] [125] [174]
[126]
Ref.
60 Advances in Chromatography
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
61
Signal intensity
Column 1 55ºC
Column 1 55ºC
Column 2 56ºC
Column 2 55ºC
Column 3 57ºC
Column 3 55ºC
Column 4 55ºC 0
2
12
4 Time (min)
6
13 14 % acetonitrile (a)
8
15
Column 4 55ºC 0
2
10
4 6 Time (min) 11
8
10
12 13 % acetonitrile
14
(b)
FIGURE 2.5 Adjustment of the chromatographic elution profiles of different columns by means of variation of column temperature. (a) The same sample was injected onto four different columns kept at the same temperature in a commercially available enforced air circulation oven with Peltier cooling. Because of differences in surface area, retention of DNA fragments varies between columns. (b) Variation of the individual column temperatures allows harmonization of chromatographic profiles. Columns, 4 × monolithic PS/DVB, 60 × 0.2 mm i.d., mobile phase, (A) 100 mM TEAA at pH 7.0, (B) 100 mM TEAA at pH 7.0, 25% acetonitrile; linear gradient, (a) 45–61% B in 8.0 min, (b) 38–56% B in 10 min; flow rate, 2.0–3.0 μL/min; temperature, (a) 55˚C, (b) 55–57˚C; detection, LIF, emission monitored at 525 nm; injection volume, 1 μL each; sample, equimolar mixture of two FAM-labeled 209bp Y chromosome alleles differing in a single base (168 A > G). From [119].
62
Advances in Chromatography
material is most often fused silica — PEEK shielded fused silica and glass-lined steels have also been employed in some commercial columns, but these are less suited for temperature-gradient programming. The length of the packed columns varies from 100 to 1000 mm, depending on the particle size and the desired resolution. A particle size of 3 or 3.5 μm is most common and the columns are relatively short. When the inner diameter of the column is reduced, the injection volume must be reduced accordingly (the down-scale factor) to maintain high efficiency. Typical injection volumes in capillary LC should be in the range 0.05 to 0.1 μL (see Table 2.1). However, packed capillary columns can be used advantageously for trace determination of analytes in samples of limited sample size [133] by using larger sample volumes that can be introduced either by on-column focusing techniques [134] or by column switching techniques [135, 136]. Injection of large volumes without detrimental effect on the column efficiency can be achieved by solute focusing with a solvent with low elution strength [137], or by temperature [138]. Up to 1.0 mL of sample has been applied utilizing solvent-promoted focusing in a 0.32 mm I.D. column switching system [135, 137] (see Figure 2.6). In reversedAUFS
0.02
3 0.01
1 4 2
0.00
20
40
60
min
FIGURE 2.6 Packed capillary column-switching LC separation of 12 ng of each of the 12MP derivatives of 2,6-TDI (1), HDI (2), 2,4-TDI (3) and MDI (4) from a spiked air sampling filter on a 3 μm Hypersil ODS (0.32 × 250 mm) column. The injection volume was 1.0 mL and the mobile phase was acetonitrile: 10 mM ammonium formate (pH 6.0) (40:60, v/v). A temperature program from 80˚C (37 min) to 95˚C (25 min) using a temperature ramp of 5.0˚C/min was used. From [135].
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
63
phase systems, the retention is usually lower at low temperatures and up to 500 μL of a sample containing a hydrophobic analyte has been introduced at 5˚C using a column switching system [136]. In this case both the sample solvent and eluting mobile phase consisted of 100% acetonitrile and the analyte Irganox 1076 was completely retained at the 27 mm-long C18 enrichment column at 5˚C. A subsequent temperature program from 5 to 90˚C provided optimal separation of the analyte from the matrix components, which was coextracted from the polymer sample using 100% acetonitrile as extraction solvent. Of the packed capillary columns, silica-based reversed-phase column materials have been most extensively studied (see Table 2.1). Only a limited number of studies have been published using other materials like silica and ion exchange. In an early study, Jinno and Hirata investigated the (low) temperature effect in normal phase micro LC [16], and lately Molander et al. [17] resolved an extruded polymer blend by using temperature-programmed (110 to 170˚C) elution on large-pore silica stationary phase. The separation was obtained according to both size exclusion and normal phase interaction. Isoelectric point (pI) separation of proteins by pH-gradient ion-exchange with temperature control was recently demonstrated on a packed capillary column [19]. The temperature tolerance of the zirconia materials has promoted their use for high temperature separations [15, 79, 139, 140]; however, only one paper on their use in capillary LC has been published [139]. Polybutadiene-modified zirconia packed in 0.1 mm I.D. glass-lined stainless steel columns was found to be stable at 100˚C using acetonitrile/phosphate buffer (pH 7) as mobile phase. On the other hand, in temperature-programming mode (not exceeding 100˚C), a rapid decrease in both column efficiency and retention factors was observed. Even though carbon materials have shown high stability under temperature-programmed high-temperature LC conditions [15], carbon materials have been used mostly at ambient temperature in capillary LC [141–143]. So far, only one study has used the temperature for retention control [144]. Linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained for sulphated glycosamin glycan disaccharides, however, of different sign at acidic (2.2) and alkaline (12) pH. The effect of temperature on retention on the cellulose triacetate enantioselective stationary phase has been studied [145], but so far no separation using the temperature-responsive stationary phases [21–24] have been demonstrated on capillary columns.
2.4.2 TEMPERATURE PROGRAMMING
AND INSTRUMENTATION
The temperature range studied in capillary LC has been limited on the high end mainly by the stability of the packing material but, in some cases, also by the stability of the solutes. Temperatures below 5˚C have seldom been explored due to the lower efficiency at low temperature and by the available ovens (see Table 2.1). Only two commercially available LC ovens with the option for temperature programming exist with temperature ranges of 5 to 150˚C and < 0 to 200˚C, respectively. The former oven (cLC-oven) has been used in a number of publications, as can be seen in Table 2.1, but the drawback is the slow cooling back to 5˚C after performing a run. For
64
Advances in Chromatography
temperature programming, the ovens should provide rapid return to the start of the temperature program; however, the Peltier elements in the larger ovens are too slow and cryo-cooling is required for a rapid return to start. If temperatures below 0˚C are needed (e.g., for focusing of solutes), an oven with two separate temperature zones is advantageous [138]. For temperatures above ambient, GC-ovens are suitable both for isothermal and temperature-programmed elution. Other laboratory-made devices for column temperature control have also been used, as shown in Table 2.1. The repeatability of retention time with temperature programs has been found to be comparable to that obtained with solvent gradient elution. The relative standard deviations (%RSDs) were in the range 0.5 to 1.4 for a 30 to 150˚C (at 1.5 K/min) gradient [146], 0.4 to 1.2 for a 7 to 90˚C (at 3 K/min) gradient [134], and 2 for a 30 to 120˚C (at 5 K/min) gradient [138]. Temperature programming has been used in a number of applications (Table 2.1) to obtain separation in a reasonable time with a good efficiency. Temperatures up to 90˚C have been used on silica-based C18 columns with aqueous mobile phases, even though temperatures above 60˚ are not recommended [15]. When nonaqueous mobile phases are used, higher temperatures may be utilized. Andersen et al. separated hindered amine stabilizers using nonaqueous mobile phases and temperature programming from 30 to 120/130˚C on C18 columns [146–148]. Temperatures up to 200˚C have been used on the open tubular columns by Liu et al., obtaining over 1 mill theoretical plates in 50 minutes using a 20 m-long column [122]. The majority of studies on capillary LC with temperature control have utilized UV detection or evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) (see Table 2.1). When temperature−gradient programming is used in combination with UV detection, a rising baseline is often observed due to refractive index changes but a rising baseline can also be due to column bleeding [15]. The rising baseline may be corrected mathematically by a commercial software package [149] or by dual wavelength measurements and corrections [77]. The nebulizer of the ELSD has been modified for the low flow rates used in capillary LC to obtain improved limits of detection and increased linearity [150] and baseline drift with temperature−gradient programming is normally not a problem. The laboratory-made electrochemical detector (ECD) for packed capillary columns also showed a rising baseline with temperature programming but the drift could be corrected mathematically [151]. Mass spectrometry (MS), especially with electrospray ionization, benefits from the low flows used in capillary LC and the compatibility between temperature programming in LC and MS was shown more than a decade ago [152]. However, MS has only been applied in a few studies where the temperature has been used actively for retention control in capillary LC [146, 153]. Since temperature programming can be expected to affect the electrospray ionization process less than solvent gradients, temperature gradient programming in LC with MS detection can in many cases be a better choice than solvent gradient elution. Low-volume flow cells for NMR have now become commercially available and the combination of capillary LC and NMR seems very promising compared to conventional-sized systems when the sample amount is limited [154]. Resonance shifts due to changes in solvent composition are avoided by isocratic elution and much better detection limits can be achieved.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
65
A small overpressure is necessary to keep the mobile phase in the liquid phase when temperatures above the boiling point of the mobile phase are applied. This is normally done by connecting a fused silica capillary with small I.D. (15 to 30 μm) between the column and the detector when MS or ELSD is used and by using a similar capillary from the detector to waste when UV detection is utilized.
2.4.3 APPLICATIONS Even though most of the studies on temperature effects in capillary columns have utilized test compounds (see Table 2.1) for exploring the separation power of packed capillary column systems, a limited number of papers have also shown the applicability of this methodology for real-life samples [19, 134, 136, 155–159]. Capillary LC with large-volume injection and temperature-programmed elution was used for the determination of Irganox 1076 that was extracted from low-density polyethylene by microwave-aided extraction with acetonitrile [134]. In this case, acetonitrile was used both as injection solvent (100 μL) and as the mobile phase. By utilizing temperature-promoted, large-volume solute focusing, sample volumes up to 500 μL could be used to improve the detection limit to 0.6 ppm [136]. The concentration of retinyl palmitate in Arctic seal liver was determined using a nonaqueous temperature-programmed reversed-phase separation with large-volume oncolumn injection [159]. A method for the simultaneous determination of three selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and their metabolites in solid phase extracts from plasma, using temperature-programmed aqueous reversed-phase separation with on-column focusing of large injection volumes, provided quantification limits in the concentration range 0.05 to 0.26 μM [157]. The presence of eight triazines in ground water was determined using temperature-programmed elution on a reversed-phase column after large volume injection [158], while chlorophenoxy acid herbicides and their esters were determined in extracts from soil using large-volume injection and temperature-programmed elution on a C18 reversed-phase column [156] (see Figure 2.7). The detection limits reported were between 0.3 and 0.5 μg/g of soil. Low levels of polyethylene glycols (PEG) in extracts from low-density polyethylene could be determined by large-volume injection, temperature-programmed elution on a C18 reversed-phase column using a column switching system [155]. In this case, inverse temperature programming from 68 to 45˚C was used since the retention of PEGs increases with increasing column temperature, a fact explained by conformational changes of PEGs at different temperatures. One special application is the isoelectric point separation of proteins by capillary pH-gradient ion exchange chromatography, where the temperature was used to optimize the separation of skimmed milk proteins [19]. Temperature has been actively used for high-resolution chromatographic determination of nucleic acids on PS-DVB monolithic columns as well as on packed PSDVB columns [160]. In addition to their use in genomic research, the PS-DVB monolithic columns have also been used in proteomics [161]. Huber et al. recently published a study on the effect of temperature and mobile phase additives on peptide and protein analysis on PS-DVB monoliths [162] where they showed that the efficiency improved significantly upon increasing the temperature up to 70˚C. The
66
Advances in Chromatography
2, 4-D
2, 4-D methyl ester
2, 4-DB 2, 4-D butyl ester
b a
0
10 Time, min
20
FIGURE 2.7 LC chromatogram of (a) unspiked soil; (b) soil spiked with 4.0 μg/g of chlorophenoxy acids. Column: LC Packing Hypersil C18 BDS, 3 μm, 150 mm × 0.3 mm I.D. Mobile phase: MeOH/H3PO4 0.8% aqueous solution (56/44, v/v). Flow rate in column: 10 μL/min. Temperature gradient from 20 to 65 ˚C at 9˚C/min. Injection volume: 20 μL. From [156].
selectivity of peptide elution was significantly modulated by the temperature, whereas the effect on protein analysis was only minor. The construction of monolithic capillary arrays, fine-tuned by using the temperature (see also Figure 2.5), allows high-throughput analyses and their use will probably increase in the years to come.
REFERENCES 1. Ooms, B. Temperature control in high performance liquid chromatography. LC-GC, 1996, 14, 306–313. 2. Greibrokk, T. and Andersen, T. High-temperature liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1000, 743–755. 3. Li, J.W., Hu, Y., and Carr, P.W. Fast separations at elevated temperatures on polybutadiene-coated zirconia reversed-phase material. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 3884–3888.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
67
4. Guillarme, D., Heinisch, S., and Rocca, J.L. Effect of temperature in reversed phase liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1052, 39–51. 5. Dolan, J.W. Temperature selectivity in reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 965, 195–205. 6. Greibrokk, T. and Andersen, T. Temperature programming in liquid chromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 899–909. 7. Sander, L.C. and Wise, S.A. The influence of column temperature on selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography for shape-constrained solutes. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 910–920. 8. McCalley, D.V. Effect of temperature and flow-rate on analysis of basic compounds in high-performance liquid chromatography using a reversed-phase column. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 902, 311–321. 9. Böhm, V. Use of column temperature to optimize carotenoid isomer separation by C30 high performance liquid chromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 955–959. 10. Szabelski, P., Cavazzini, A., Kaczmarski, K., Liu, X., Van Horne, J., and Guiochon, G. Experimental studies in pressure/temperature dependence of protein adsorption equilibrium in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 950, 41–53. 11. Saha, S., Smith, R.M., Lenz, E., and Wilson, I.D. Analysis of ginger extract by highperformance liquid chromatography coupled to nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy using superheated deuterium oxide as the mobile phase. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 991, 143–150. 12. Lee, D.L., Mant, C.T., and Hodges, R.S. A novel method to measure self-association of small amphipathic molecules. J. Biol. Chem., 2003, 278, 22918–22927. 13. Chen, Y., Mant, C.T., and Hodges, R.S. Temperature selectivity effects in reversed phase liquid chromatography due to conformation differences between helical and non-helical peptides. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1010, 45–61. 14. Borch, T. and Gerlach, R. Use of reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-diode array detection for complete separation of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene metabolites and EPA Method 8330 explosives: Influence of temperature and ion-pair reagent. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1022, 83–94. 15. Marin, S.J., Jones, B.A., Felix, W.D., and Clark, J. Effect of high-temperature on high-performance liquid chromatography column stability and performance under temperature-programmed conditions. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1030, 255–262. 16. Jinno, K. and Hirata, Y. Investigation of the low temperature effect in normal phase micro high performance liquid chromatography. J. HRC & CC, 1982, 5, 85–90. 17. Molander, P., Greibrokk, T., Iveland, A., and Ommundsen, E. Simultaneous dualmechanism separation of a semicrystalline polymer blend on large-pore silica by temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 136–140. 18. Busch, M. and Seubert, A. Influence of column temperature on the ion chromatographic separation of aluminum species. Anal. Chim. Acta, 1999, 399, 223–235. 19. Andersen, T., Pepaj, M., Trones, R., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Isoelectric point separation of proteins by capillary pH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1025, 217–226. 20. Wei, Y., Yao, C., Zhao, J., and Geng, X. Influences of the mobile phase composition and temperature on the retention behaviour of aromatic alcohol homologues in hydrophobic interaction chromatography. Chromatographia, 2002, 55, 659–665.
68
Advances in Chromatography 21. Kanazawa, H., Yamamoto, K., Kashiwase, Y., Matsushima, Y., Takai, N., Kikuchi, A., Sakurai, Y., and Okano, T. Analysis of peptides and proteins by temperatureresponsive chromatographic system using N-isopropylacrylamide polymer-modified columns. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal., 1997, 15, 1545–1550. 22. Go, H., Sudo, Y., Hosoya, T., Ikegami, T., and Tanaka, N. Effects of mobile-phase composition and temperature on the selectivity of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)bonded silica gel in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1998, 70, 4086–4093. 23. Song, Y.-X., Wang, J.-Q., Su, Z.-X., and Chen, D.-Y. High-performance liquid chromatography on silica modified with temperature-responsive polymers. Chromatographia, 2001, 54, 208–212. 24. Kurata, K., Shimoyama, T., and Dobashi, A. Enantiomeric separation using temperature-responsive chiral polymers composed of L-valine diamide derivatives in aqueous liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1012, 47–56. 25. Jiskra, J., Claessens, H.A., and Cramers, C.A. Thermodynamic behaviour in capillary electrochromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2002, 25, 569–576. 26. Snyder, L.R. Temperature-induced selectivity in separations by reversed-phase liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1979, 179, 157–172. 27. Grushka, E., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G. Retention behavior of alkylbenzenes as a function of temperature and mobile phase composition in reversed-phase chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1982, 248, 325–339. 28. Takeuchi, T., Kumaki, M., and Ishii, D. Role of column temperature in open-tubular microcapillary liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1982, 235, 309–322. 29. Miyabe, K. and Guiochon, G. Thermodynamic interpretation of retention equilibrium in reversed-phase liquid chromatography based on enthalpy-entropy compensation. Anal. Chem., 2002, 74, 5982–5992. 30. Colin, H., Diez-Masa, J.C., Guiochon, G., Czajkowska, T., and Miedziak, I. The role of the temperature in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography using pyrocarbon-containing adsorbents. J. Chromatogr., 1978, 167, 41–65. 31. Knox, J.H. and Vasvari, G. The performance of packings in high-speed liquid chromatography. III. Chemically bonded pellicular materials. J. Chromatogr., 1973, 83, 181–194. 32. Colin, H. and Guiochon, G. Introduction to reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1977, 141, 289–312. 33. Colin, H. and Guiochon, G. Comparison of some packings for reversed-phase highperformance liquid — solid chromatography. II. Some theoretical considerations. J. Chromatogr., 1978, 158, 183–205. 34. Horvath, C. and Melander, W. Liquid chromatography with hydrocarbonaceous bonded phases, theory and practice of reversed phase chromatography. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1977, 15, 393–404. 35. Issaq, H.J. and Jaroniec, M. Enthalpy and entropy effects for homologous solutes in HPLC with alkyl chain bonded phases. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1989, 12, 2067–2082. 36. Alvarez-Zepeda, A., Barman, B.N., and Matire, D.E. Thermodynamic study of the marked differences between acetonitrile/water and methanol/water mobile-phase systems in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 1978–1984. 37. Guillaume, Y.C. and Guinchard, C. Retention mechanism of weak polar solutes in reversed phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1996, 68, 2869–2873. 38. Guillaume, Y.C. and Guinchard, C. ACN clusters in a water/ACN mixture, with implications for the RPLC weak polar solute retention. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 183–189.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
69
39. FuAn, W., JianChi, S., YingChen, G., YiHong, W., and Yan, Z. Rule of intersection point between retention of homologues and column temperature in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Microchem. J., 1995, 52, 200–204. 40. Bai, Q. and Geng, X. The temperature convergence of biopolymers in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Chromatographia, 2001, 54, 335–338. 41. Chester, T.L. and Coym, J.W. Effect of phase ratio on van ‘t Hoff analysis in reversedphase liquid chromatography, and phase-ratio-independent estimation of transfer enthalpy. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1003, 101–111. 42. Jinno, K., Ohshima, T., and Hirata, Y. Investigation of the low temperature effect in reversed phase micro high performance liquid chromatography. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1982, 5, 621–624. 43. Coym, J.W. and Dorsey, J.G. Reversed-phase retention thermodynamics of pure-water mobile phases at ambient and elevated temperature. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1035, 23–29. 44. Castells, C.B., Gagliardi, L.G., Rafols, C., Roses, M., and Bosch, E. Effect of temperature on the chromatographic retention of ionizable compounds. I. Methanol-water mobile phases. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1042, 23–35. 45. Li, J. Effect of temperature on selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, a thermodynamic analysis. Anal. Chim. Acta, 1998, 369, 21–37. 46. Buckenmaier, S.M.C., McCalley, D.V., and Euerby, M.R. Rationalisation of unusual changes in efficiency and retention with temperature shown for bases in reversedphase high-performance liquid chromatography at intermediate pH. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1060, 117–126. 47. Bowermaster, J. and McNair, H.M. Temperature programmed microbore HPLC-Part I. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1984, 22, 165–170. 48. Chen, M.H. and Horvath, C. Temperature programming and gradient elution in reversed-phase chromatography with packed capillary columns. J. Chromatogr. A, 1997, 788, 51–61. 49. Tran, J.V., Molander, P., Greibrokk, T., and Lundanes, E. Temperature effects on retention in reversed phase liquid chromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 930–940. 50. Zhu, P.L., Snyder, L.R., Dolan, J.W., Djordjevic, N.M., Hill, D.W., Sander, L.C., and Waeghe, T.J. Combined use of temperature and solvent strength in reversed-phase gradient elution. I. Predicting separation as a function of temperature and gradient conditions. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 756, 21–39. 51. Zhu, P.L., Dolan, J.W., and Snyder, L.R. Combined use of temperature and solvent strength in reversed-phase gradient elution. II. Comparing selectivity for different samples and systems. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 756, 41–50. 52. Zhu, P.L., Dolan, J.W., Snyder, L.R., Hill, D.W., VanHeukelem, L., and Waeghe, T.J. Combined use of temperature and solvent strength in reversed-phase gradient elution. III. Selectivity for ionizable samples as a function of sample type and pH. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 756, 51–62. 53. Zhu, P.L., Dolan, J.W., Snyder, L.R., Djordjevic, N.M., Hill, D.W., Lin, J.T., Sander, L.C., and Van Heukelem, L. Combined use of temperature and solvent strength in reversed-phase gradient elution. IV. Selectivity for neutral (non-ionized) samples as a function of sample type and other separation conditions. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 756, 63–72.
70
Advances in Chromatography 54. Dolan, J.W., Snyder, L.R., Djordjevic, N.M., Hill, D.W., Sounders, D.L., Van Heukelem, L., and Waeghe, T.J. Simultaneous variation of temperature and gradient steepness for reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography method development. I. Application to 14 different samples using computer simulation. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 803, 1–31. 55. Wolcott, R.G., Dolan, J.W., and Snyder, L.R. Computer simulation for the convenient optimization of isocratic reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separations by varying temperature and mobile phase strength. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 869, 3–25. 56. Neue, U.D. and Mazzeo, J.R. A theoretical study of the optimization of gradients at elevated temperature. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 921–929. 57. Cole, L.A., Dorsey, J.G., and Dill, K.A. Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 2. Mobile-phase considerations. Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 1324–1327. 58. Kim, H., Gritti, F., and Guiochon, G. Effect of the temperature on the isotherm parameters of phenol in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1049, 25–36. 59. Issaq, H.J., Fox, S.D., Lindsey, K., McConnell, J.H., and Weiss, D.E. Effect of temperature on HPLC separations using C1, C4, C8, and C18 alkyl chain bonded silica columns. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1987, 10, 49–70. 60. Dolan, J.W., Snyder, L.R., Blanc, T., and Van Heukelem, L. Selectivity differences for C18 and C8 reversed-phase columns as a function of temperature and gradient steepness. I. Optimizing selectivity and resolution. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 897, 37–50. 61. Ducry, M.W.J., Orendorff, C.J., Pemberton, J.E., and Sander, L.C. Structure-function relationships in high-density octadecylsilane stationary phases by Raman spectroscopy. 1. Effects of temperature, surface coverage, and preparation procedure. Anal. Chem., 2002, 74, 5576–5584. 62. Tchapla, A., Heron, S., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G. Role of temperature in the behavior of a homologous series in reversed phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1988, 60, 1443–1448. 63. Yamamoto, F.M., Rokushika, S., and Hatano, H. Comparison of thermodynamic retention behaviors on various C18 columns different in their hydrophobicity. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1989, 27, 704–709. 64. Sander, L.C. and Field, L.R. Effect of eluent composition on thermodynamic properties in high-performance liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1980, 52, 2009–2013. 65. Cole, L.A. and Dorsey, J.G. Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 2. Stationary-phase considerations. Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 1317–1323. 66. Sentell, K.B., Ryan, N.I., and Henderson, A.N. Temperature and solvation effects on homologous series selectivity in reversed phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chim. Acta, 1995, 307, 203–215. 67. Chmielowiec, J. and Sawatzky, H. Entropy dominated high performance liquid chromatographic separations of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons. Temperature as a separation parameter. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1979, 17, 245–252. 68. Albert, K. Correlation between chromatographic and physiochemical properties of stationary phases in HPLC: C30 bonded reversed-phase silica. Trends Anal. Chem., 1998, 17, 648–658. 69. Bell, C.M., Sander, L.C., and Wise, S.A. Temperature dependence of carotenoids on C18, C30 and C34 bonded stationary phases. J. Chromatogr. A, 1997, 757, 29–39.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
71
70. Pursch, M., Strohschein, S., Händel, H., and Albert, K. Temperature-dependent behaviour of C30 interphases. A solid-state NMR and LC-NMR study. Anal. Chem., 1996, 68, 386–393. 71. Srinivasan, G., Pursch, M., Sander, L.C., and Müller, K. FTIR studies of C30 selfassembled monolayers on silica, titania and zirconia. Langmuir, 2004, 20, 1746–1752. 72. Yang, Y. Stationary phases for high-temperature liquid chromatography. LC-GC Europe, 2003, 16, 37–41. 73. Bullock, J. High-temperature reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic analysis of a synthetic copolymer on a non-porous support. J. Chromatogr. A, 1995, 694, 415–423. 74. Claessens, H.A. and van Straten, M.A. Review on the chemical and thermal stability of stationary phases for reversed-phase liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1060, 23–41. 75. He, P. and Yang, Y. Studies on the long-term thermal stability of stationary phases in subcritical water chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 989, 55–63. 76. Bolliet, D. and Poole, C.F. Influence of temperature on retention and selectivity in reversed phase liquid chromatography. Analyst, 1998, 123, 295–299. 77. Renn, C.N. and Synovec, R.E. Thermal gradient microbore liquid chromatography with dual-wavelength absorbance detection. Anal. Chem., 1991, 63, 568–574. 78. Li, J.W. and Carr, P.W. Effect of temperature on the thermodynamic properties, kinetic performance, and stability of polybutadiene-coated zirconia. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 837–843. 79. Dunlap, C.J., Carr, P.W., McNeff, C.V., and Stoll, D. Zirconia stationary phases for extreme separations. Anal. Chem., 2001, 73, 598A–607A. 80. Li, J.W. and Carr, P.W. Evaluation of temperature effects on selectivity in RPLC separations using polybutadiene-coated zirconia. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 2202–2206. 81. Wolcott, R.G., Dolan, J.W., Snyder, L.R., Bakalyar, S.R., Arnold, M.A., and Nichols, J.A. Control of column temperature in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 869, 211–230. 82. Spearman, L., Smith, R.M., and Dube, S. Monitoring effective column temperature by using shape selectivity and hydrophobicity and the effects of mobile phase temperature. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1060, 147–151. 83. Poppe, H. and Kraak, J.C. Influence of thermal conditions on the efficiency of highperformance liquid chromatographic columns. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 282, 399–412. 84. Thompson, J.D., Brown, J.S., and Carr, P.W. Dependence of thermal mismatch broadening on column diameter in high-speed liquid chromatography at elevated temperatures. Anal. Chem., 2001, 73, 3340–3347. 85. Hesse, G. and Engelhardt, H. Temperatureprogrammierung bei der adsorptionschromatographie von lösungen. J. Chromatogr., 1966, 21, 228–238. 86. Djordjevic, N.M., Fowler, P.W.J., and Houdiere, F. High temperature and temperature programming in high-performance liquid chromatography: Instrumental considerations. J. Microcol. Sep., 1999, 11, 403–413. 87. Molander, P., Olsen, R., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. The impact of inner diameter on chromatographic performance in temperature gradient liquid chromatography. Analyst, 2003, 128, 1341–1345. 88. Biggs, W.R. and Fetzer, J.C. Thermal gradient liquid chromatography: Application to selective element detection by inductively coupled plasma emission spectrometry. Anal. Chem., 1989, 61, 236–240.
72
Advances in Chromatography
89. Kim, W.-S., Lee, J.Y., Lee, S.K., Park, Y.H., and Lee, D.W. Investigation of retention behavior for herbicides in micro-HPLC with temperature changes. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 2003, 26, 3357–3369. 90. Hu, W., Hasebe, K., and Haddad, P.R. Temperature effects on retention in reversedphase liquid chromatography of nucleosides and their bases using water as the mobile phase. Anal. Commun., 1997, 34, 322–324. 91. Moore, L.K. and Synovec, R.E. Axial thermal gradient microbore liquid chromatography by flow programming. Anal. Chem., 1993, 65, 2663–2670. 92. Sander, L.C., Sharpless, K.E., and Pursch, M. C30 stationary phases for the analysis of food by liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 880, 189–202. 93. Hancock, W.S., Chloupek, R.C., Kirkland, J.J., and Snyder, L.R. Temperature as a variable in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic separations of peptide and protein samples. I. Optimizing the separation of a growth hormone tryptic digest. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 686, 31–43. 94. Chloupek, R.C., Hancock, J.R., Marchylo, B.A., Kirkland, J.J., Boyes, B.E., and Snyder, L.R. Temperature as a variable in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic separations of peptide and protein samples. II. Selectivity effects observed in the separation of several peptide and protein mixtures. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 686, 45–59. 95. Mant, C.T., Chen, Y., and Hodges, R.S. Temperature profiling of polypeptides in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. I. Monitoring of dimerization and unfolding of amphipathic γ-helical peptides. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1009, 29–43. 96. Mant, C.T., Tripet, B., and Hodges, R.S. Temperature profiling of polypeptides in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. II. Monitoring of folding and stability of twostranded γ-helical coilded-coils. J. Chromatogr., 2003, 1009, 45–59. 97. Chen, Y., Mehok, A.R., Mant, C.T., and Hodges, R.S. Optimum concentration of trifluoroacetic acid for reversed-phase liquid chromatography of peptides revisited. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1043, 9–18. 98. Hayakawa, K., Hirano, M., Yoshikawa, K., Katsumata, N., and Tanaka, N. Separation of phenylthiohydantoin-amino acids by temperature-controlled reversed-phase highperformance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 846, 73–82. 99. Dolfinger, R. and Locke, D.C. Dependence of selectivity on eluent composition and temperature in the HPLC separation of taxanes using fluorinated and hydrocarbon phases. Anal. Chem., 2003, 75, 1355–1364. 100. Issaq, H.J., Xu, H., Chan, K.C., and Dean, M.C. Effect of temperature on the separation of DNA fragments by high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrophoresis: A comparative study. J. Chromatogr. B, 2000, 738, 243–248. 101. Yang, Y., Belghazi, M., Lagadec, A., Miller, D.J., and Hawthorne, S.B. Elution of organic solutes from different polarity sorbents using subcritical water. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 810, 149–159. 102. Fields, S.M., Ye, C.Q., Zhang, D.D., Branch, B.R., Zhang, X.J., and Okafo, N. Superheated water as eluent in high-temperature high-performance liquid chromatographic separations of steroids on a polymer-coated zirconia column. J. Chromatogr. A, 2001, 913, 197–204. 103. Kondo, T., Yang, Y., and Lamm, L. Separation of polar and non-polar analytes using dimethyl sulfoxide-modified subcritical water. Anal. Chim. Acta, 2002, 460, 185–191. 104. Jones, A. and Yang, Y. Separation of nonpolar analytes using methanol-water mixtures at elevated temperatures. Anal. Chim. Acta, 2003, 485, 51–55.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
73
105. Zarzycki, P.K., Wierzbowska, M., and Lamparczyk, H. The influence of temperature on the high performance liquid chromatographic separation of steroids using mobile phases modified by β-cyclodextrin. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal., 1996, 14, 1305–1311. 106. Karlsson, A. and Charron, C. Reversed-phase ion-pair chromatography at a column temperature below 0˚C using three generations of Hypercarb as solid-phase. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 732, 245–253. 107. Tanaka, H., Zhou, X., and Masayoshi, O. Characterization of a novel diol column for high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 987, 119–125. 108. Haidekker, A. and Huber, C.G. Ion chromatography on chelating stationary phases: Separation of alkali metals. J. Chromatogr. A, 2001, 921, 217–226. 109. Hosoya, K., Kimata, K., Araki, T., Tanaka, N., and Frechet, J.M.J. Temperaturecontrolled high-performance liquid chromatography using a uniformly sized temperature-responsive polymer-based packing material. Anal. Chem., 1995, 67, 1907–1911. 110. Kanazawa, H., Kashiwase, Y., Yamamoto, K., Matsushima, Y., Kikuchi, A., Sakurai, Y., and Okano, T. Temperature-responsive liquid chromatography. 2. Effects of hydrophobic groups in N-isopropylacrylamide copolymer-modified silica. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 823–830. 111. Berthod, A., He, B.L., and Beesley, T.E. Temperature and enantioseparation by macrocyclic glycopeptide chiral stationary phases. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1060, 205–214. 112. Kazusaki, M., Shoda, T., Kawabata, H., and Matsukura, H. Influence of mobile phase composition on thermodynamic properties in high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Liq. Chromatogr. R.T., 2001, 24, 141–151. 113. Peyrin, E., Guillaume, Y.C., and Guinchard, C. Interactions between dansyl amino acids and human serum albumin using high-performance liquid chromatography: Mobile-phase pH and temperature considerations. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 4979–4984. 114. Takeuchi, T., Watanabe, Y., and Ishii, D. Role of column temperature in micro high performance liquid chromatography. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1981, 4, 300–302. 115. Hirata, Y. and Sumiya, E. Temperature-programmed reversed-phase liquid chromatography with packed fused-silica columns. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 267, 125–131. 116. Bowermaster, J. and McNair, H. Microbore high-performance liquid chromatographic columns: Speed, efficiency, sensitivity and temperature programming. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 279, 431–438. 117. Jinno, K., Phillips, J.B., and Carney, D.P. Temperature-controlled high-speed microcolumn liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1985, 57, 574–576. 118. McNair, H. and Bowermaster, J. HPLC column performance and temperature programming capabilities. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1987, 10, 27–31. 119. Premstaller, A., Xiao, W., Oberacher, H., O’Keefe, M., Stern, D., Willis, T., Huber, C.G., and Oefner, P.J. Temperature-modulated array high-performance liquid chromatography. Genome Res., 2001, 11, 1944–1951. 120. Premstaller, A., Oefner, P.J., Oberacher, H., and Huber, C.G. Capillary array highperformance liquid chromatography of nucleic acids and proteins. Anal. Chem., 2002, 74, 4688–4693. 121. Andersen, T., Nguyen, Q.-N.T., Trones, R., and Greibrokk, T. Studies on the longterm thermal stability of particulate and monolithic poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) capillaries in reversed-phase chromatography. Analyst, 2004, 129, 191–197. 122. Liu, G., Djordjevic, N.M., and Erni, F. High-temperature open-tubular capillary column liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 592, 239–247.
74
Advances in Chromatography
123. Djordjevic, N.M., Stegehuis, D., Liu, G., and Erni, F. Improved ultraviolet detection in high-temperature open-tubular liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 629, 135–141. 124. Ryan, K., Djordjevic, N.M., and Erni, F. Temperature programming in open tubular liquid chromatography. J. Liq. Chromatogr. R.T., 1996, 19, 2089–2099. 125. Nyholm, L.M., Sjöberg, P.J.R., and Markides, K.E. High-temperature open tubular liquid chromatography coupled to atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 755, 153–164. 126. Nyholm, L.M. and Markides, K.E. Column preparation for reversed-phase hightemperature open tubular column liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 813, 11–20. 127. Premstaller, A., Oberacher, H., and Huber, C.G. High-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry of single- and double-stranded nucleic acids using monolithic capillary columns. Anal. Chem., 2000, 72, 4386–4393. 128. Huber, C.G., Premstaller, A., Xiao, W., Oberacher, H., Bonn, G.K., and Oefner, P.J. Mutation detection by capillary denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography using monolithic columns. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods, 2001, 47, 5–19. 129. Oberacher, H., Oefner, P.J., Hölzl, G., Premstaller, A., Davis, K., and Huber, C.G. Re-sequencing of multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms by liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Nucleic Acids Res., 2002, 30, e67/1–e67/6. 130. Premstaller, A., Oberacher, H., Rickert, A., Huber, C.G., and Oefner, P.J. Multiplex analysis of single-nucleotide extension products on a 16-capillary, denaturing, highperformance liquid chromatography array. Genomics, 2002, 79, 793–798. 131. Oberacher, H., Premstaller, A., and Huber, C.G. Characterization of some physical and chromatographic properties of monolithic poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) columns. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1030, 201–208. 132. Dulay, M.T., Quirino, J.P., Bennett, B.D., Kato, M., and Zare, R.N. Photopolymerized sol-gel monoliths for capillary electrochromatography Anal. Chem., 2001, 73, 3921–3926. 133. Vissers, J.P.C., Claessens, H.A., and Cramers, C.A. Microcolumn liquid chromatography: Instrumentation, detection and applications. J. Chromatogr. A, 1997, 779, 1–28. 134. Molander, P., Haugland, K., Hegna, D.R., Ommundsen, E., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Determination of low levels of an antioxidant in polyolefins by large volume injection temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 864, 103–109. 135. Molander, P., Thomassen, A., Lundanes, E., Fladseth, G., Thorud, S., Thomassen, Y., and Greibrokk, T. Determination of 1-(2-methoxyphenyl)-piperazine derivatives of airborne diisocyanates by packed capillary liquid chromatography with pre-column large-volume enrichment. J. Sep. Sci., 2001, 24, 947–954. 136. Molander, P., Holm, A., Lundanes, E., Hegna, D.R., Ommundsen, E., and Greibrokk, T. Temperature-promoted large-volume solute enrichment in column-switching miniaturized liquid chromatography: Determination of an antioxidant. Analyst, 2002, 127, 892–897. 137. Holm, A., Molander, P., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Determination of rotenone in river water utilizing packed capillary column switching liquid chromatography with UV and time-of-flight mass spectrometric detection. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 983, 43–50.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
75
138. Holm, A., Molander, P., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Novel column oven concept for cold spot large volume enrichment in high throughput temperature gradient capillary liquid chromatography. J. Sep. Sci., 2003, 26, 1147–1153. 139. Andersen, T., Nguyen, Q.-N.T., Trones, R., and Greibrokk, T. Mesoporous polybutadiene-modified zirconia for high-temperature packed capillary liquid chromatography: Column preparation and temperature programming stability. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1018, 7–18. 140. Xiang, Y., Yan, B., Yue, B., McNeff, C.V., Carr, P.W., and Lee, M.L. Elevatedtemperature ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography using very small polybutadiene-coated nonporous zirconia particles. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 983, 83–89. 141. Holm, A., Solbu, K., Molander, P., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Sensitive biomonitoring of phthalate metabolites in human urine using packed capillary column switching liquid chromatography coupled to electrospray ionization ion-trap mass spectrometry. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 2004, 378, 1762–1768. 142. Törnkvist, A., Sjöberg, P.J.R., Markides, K.E., and Bergquist, J. Analysis of catecholamines and related substances using porous graphitic carbon as separation media in liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 801, 323–329. 143. Törnkvist, A., Nilsson, S., Amirkhani, A., Nyholm, L.M., and Nyholm, L. Interference of the electrospray voltage on chromatographic separations using porous graphitic carbon columns. J. Mass Spectrom., 2004, 39, 216–222. 144. Koivisto, P. and Stefansson, M. Retention studies of sulphated glycosaminoglycan disaccharides on porous graphitic carbon capillary columns. Chromatographia, 2003, 57, 37–45. 145. Chen, J., Steenackers, D., and Sandra, P. Micro LC on cellulose triacetate (CTA): Influence of particle diameter and column temperature. J. Microcol. Sep., 1993, 7, 259–263. 146. Andersen, T., Holm, A., Skuland, I.L., Trones, R., and Greibrokk, T. Characterization of complex mixtures of polyglycerol fatty acid esters using temperature and solvent gradients in packed capillary LC. J. Sep. Sci., 2003, 26, 1133–1140. 147. Trones, R., Andersen, T., Greibrokk, T., and Hegna, D.R. Hindered amine stabilizers investigated by the use of packed capillary temperature-programmed liquid chromatography I. Poly((6-((1,1,3,3-tetramethylbutyl)-amino)-1,3,5-triazine-2,4-diyl)(2,2,6, 6-tetramethyl-4-piperidyl)imino)-1,6-hexanediyl((2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidyl)imino). J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 874, 65–71. 148. Trones, R., Andersen, T., Hegna, D.R., and Greibrokk, T. Hindered amine stabilizers investigated by the use of packed capillary temperature programmed liquid chromatography II. Poly-(N-β-hydroxyethyl-2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-hydroxypiperidyl succinate). J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 902, 421–426. 149. Bruheim, I., Molander, P., Theodorsen, M., Ommundsen, E., Lundanes, E., and Greibrokk, T. Temperature-programmed packed-capillary liquid chromatographic separation of polystyrenes. Chromatographia, 2001, 53, S266–S270. 150. Trones, R., Andersen, T., and Greibrokk, T. Improved modification of a laser lightscattering detector for use in packed capillary high temperature liquid chromatography. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1999, 22, 283–286. 151. Nordstrom, O., Molander, P., Greibrokk, T., Blomhoff, R., and Lundanes, E. Evaluation of temperature programming for gradient elution in packed capillary liquid chromatography coupled to electrochemical detection. J. Microcol. Sep., 2001, 13, 179–185.
76
Advances in Chromatography
152. Yoo, J.S., Watson, J.T., and McGuffin, V.L. Temperature-programmed microcolumn liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry. J. Microcol. Sep., 1992, 4, 349–362. 153. Andersen, T., Skuland, I.L., Holm, A., Trones, R., and Greibrokk, T. Temperatureprogrammed packed capillary liquid chromatography coupled to evaporative lightscattering detection and electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry for characterization of high-molecular-mass hindered amine light stabilizers. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1029, 49–56. 154. Sandvoss, M., Roberts, A.D., Ismail, I.M., and North, S.E. Direct on-line hyphenation of capillary liquid chromatography to nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy: Practical aspects and application to drug metabolite identification. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1028, 259–266. 155. Skuland, I.L., Andersen, T., Trones, R., Eriksen, R.B., and Greibrokk, T. Determination of polyethylene glycol in low-density polyethylene by large volume injection temperature gradient packed capillary liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1011, 31–36. 156. Rosales-Conrado, N., Leon-Gonzalez, M.E., Perez-Arribas, L.V., and Polo-Diez, L.M. Determination of chlorophenoxy acid herbicides and their esters in soil by capillary high performance liquid chromatography with ultraviolet detection, using large volume injection and temperature gradient. Anal. Chim. Acta, 2002, 470, 147–154. 157. Molander, P., Thomassen, A., Kristoffersen, L., Greibrokk, T., and Lundanes, E. Simultaneous determination of citalopram, fluoxetine, paroxetine and their metabolites in plasma by temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography with on-column focusing of large injection volumes. J. Chromatogr. B, 2001, 766, 77–87. 158. Leon-Gonzalez, M.E., Perez-Arribas, L.V., Polo-Diez, L.M., Panis, C., and San Andres, M.P. Determination of triazine herbicides by capillary liquid chromatography with on-column focusing and temperature gradient. Anal. Chim. Acta, 2001, 445, 29–34. 159. Molander, P., Thommesen, S.J., Bruheim, I.A., Gundersen, T.E., Trones, R., Greibrokk, T., and Lundanes, E. Temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography separation with large volume on-column focusing injection of retinyl esters. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1999, 22, 490–494. 160. Oefner, P.J. and Huber, C.G. A decade of high-resolution liquid chromatography of nucleic acids on styrene-divinylbenzene copolymers. J. Chromatogr. B, 2002, 782, 27–55. 161. Walcher, W., Oberacher, H., Troiani, S., Hölzl, G., Oefner, P.J., Zolla, L., and Huber, C.G. Monolithic capillary columns for liquid chromatography — Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry in proteomic and genomic research. J. Chromatogr. B, 2002, 782, 111–125. 162. Walcher, W., Toll, H., Ingendoh, A., and Huber, C.G. Operational variables in highperformance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry of peptides and proteins using poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) monoliths. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1053, 107–117. 163. Andersen, T., Molander, P., Trones, R., Hegna, D.R., and Greibrokk, T. Separation of polyethylene glycol oligomers using inverse temperature programming in packed capillary liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2001, 918, 221–226. 164. Molander, P., Theodorsen, M., Lundanes, E., Soerenssen, D.M., and Greibrokk, T. Temperature effects on packed-capillary liquid chromatography of the x-ray contrast agent Iodixanol. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 2000, 38, 157–161.
Temperature Effects in Liquid Chromatography
77
165. Molander, P., Holm, A., Lundanes, E., Greibrokk, T., and Ommundsen, E. Separation of ceramides by sub-ambient temperature-assisted large volume injection in temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography. J. High. Resolut. Chromatogr., 2000, 23, 653–655. 166. Bruheim, I., Molander, P., Lundanes, E., Greibrokk, T., and Ommundsen, E. Temperature-programmed packed capillary liquid chromatography coupled to Fouriertransform infrared spectroscopy. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 2000, 23, 525–530. 167. Molander, P., Ommundsen, E., and Greibrokk, T. Separation of technical waxes by temperature-programmed packed-capillary liquid chromatography. Chromatographia, 2000, 51, 349–352. 168. Molander, P., Ommundsen, E., and Greibrokk, T. High temperature injection in capillary high temperature liquid chromatography. J. Microcol. Sep., 1999, 11, 612–619. 169. Molander, P., Trones, R., Haugland, K., and Greibrokk, T. Aspects and applications of non-aqueous high temperature packed capillary liquid chromatography. Analyst, 1999, 124, 1137–1141. 170. Molander, P., Gundersen, T.E., Haas, C., Greibrokk, T., Blomhoff, R., and Lundanes, E. Determination of retinoids by packed-capillary liquid chromatography with largevolume on-column focusing and temperature optimization. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 847, 59–68. 171. Trones, R., Tangen, A., Lund, W., and Greibrokk, T. Packed capillary high-temperature liquid chromatography coupled to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 835, 105–112. 172. Trones, R., Andersen, T., Hunnes, I., and Greibrokk, T. Modified laser light-scattering detector for use in high temperature micro liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 814, 55–61. 173. Sheng, G., Shen, Y., and Lee, M.L. Elevated temperature liquid chromatograpy using reversed-phase packed capillary columns. J. Microcol. Sep., 1997, 9, 63–72. 174. Trones, R., Iveland, A., and Greibrokk, T. High-temperature liquid-chromatography on packed capillary columns with nonaqueous mobile phases. J. Microcol. Sep., 1995, 7, 505–512. 175. Hirata, Y. and Jinno, K. High resolution liquid chromatography with a packed micro glass capillary column. J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 1983, 6, 196–199.
3
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography Simion Gocan Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
Gabriela Cimpan Sirius Analytical Instruments Ltd., Forest Row, U.K.
John Comer Sirius Analytical Instruments Ltd., Forest Row, U.K.
CONTENTS 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9
Introduction ....................................................................................................80 Lipophilicity: Concept and Definitions .........................................................81 The Uses of Lipophilicity ..............................................................................81 logP, logD, and Other Terms for Expressing Lipophilicity ..........................82 The Effect of Chemical Reactions on Partitioning .......................................83 Octanol and Other Partition Solvents ............................................................87 Calculations Involving LOGP ..........................................................................90 logP Measurement by Shake-Flask ...............................................................91 Lipophilicity Measurement by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)...............................................................................94 3.9.1 HPLC with Octanol-Coated Columns ...............................................96 3.9.2 Other Methods using Octanol-Coated Columns .............................100 3.9.3 ELogP Method .................................................................................100 3.9.4 Reversed-Phase HPLC (RP-HPLC).................................................102 3.9.5 The extrapolation method, logkw .....................................................102 3.9.6 Isocratic logk Values ........................................................................105 3.9.7 The Significance of Slope S ............................................................106 3.9.8 Correction for Ionization .................................................................107 3.9.9 The Influence of Stationary Phase on Lipophilicity Measurements...................................................................................108 3.9.10 Mobile Phase Composition and Lipophilicity.................................112 79
80
Advances in Chromatography
3.9.10.1 Organic Modifier...............................................................112 3.9.10.2 Buffer in the Mobile Phase ..............................................114 3.9.10.3 Ionic Strength.................................................................... 114 3.9.10.4 Masking Agents ................................................................115 3.9.10.5 Association in Water.........................................................116 3.9.10.6 Association in the Organic Phase.....................................116 3.9.10.7 The Effect of Temperature ...............................................116 3.9.10.8 Gradient RP-HPLC...........................................................117 3.9.11 Chromatographic Hydrophobicity Index (CHI) ..............................117 3.9.12 Abraham-Type Equations for RP-HPLC .........................................125 3.10 Lipophilicity Estimation by Thin-Layer Chromatography .........................127 3.10.1 Relationship between RM and Molar Fraction X of the Organic Modifier in the Mobile Phase ............................................128 3.10.2 Influence of pH ................................................................................131 3.10.3 Influence of Mobile Phase Composition on RM0 Value..........................................................................................132 3.10.4 Influence of Stationary Phase on RM0 Value ...................................133 3.10.5 Specific Hydrophobic Surface Area of the Solute ..........................134 3.10.6 Relationship between Intercepts (RM0) and Slopes (a1) ..................135 3.10.7 RM Determination and Correlation with Partition Coefficients, logP .............................................................................143 3.11 Chromatographic Determination of Hydrophilic–Lipophilic Balance........145 3.11.1 Drug Lipophilicity............................................................................146 3.11.2 Miscellaneous...................................................................................148 3.11.3 Studies using Both RP-HPLC and RP-HPTLC ..............................149 3.12 Other Chromatographic Methods ................................................................154 3.12.1 Micellar Liquid Chromatography (MLC)........................................154 3.12.2 Reversed-Phase Ion Pair Chromatography (RP-IPC)......................155 3.12.3 Countercurrent Chromatography (CCC) .........................................156 Acknowledgments..................................................................................................157 Glossary .................................................................................................................157 References..............................................................................................................158
3.1 INTRODUCTION Many methods have been studied in an attempt to find a suitable model for the difficult, classical partition experiment in a shake-flask vessel. Liquid chromatography provided a particular approach due to the possibility of using a liquid mobile phase and a liquid or liquid-like stationary phase. This chapter will review different liquid chromatographic methods for measuring lipophilicity, including liquid-liquid chromatography, reversed-phase liquid chromatography (isocratic, gradient, and micellar methods) and counter current chromatography. This chapter will not review liquid chromatography with stationary phases that mimic the biological environment such as affinity chromatography or immobilized artificial membrane chromatography, as these form a distinct group of methods and
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
81
comprehensive reviews have been published recently [1–5]. Neither will it review micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MECK) or microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography (MEECK), as these techniques are based on capillary electrophoresis and details can also be found in a recent review [6].
3.2 LIPOPHILICITY: CONCEPT AND DEFINITIONS Lipophilicity is a general concept that characterizes the affinity of molecules for lipid-like structures. A related term, hydrophobicity, refers to water’s “dislike” of a molecule. The two terms are often used interchangeably in the literature but it has been agreed that hydrophobicity relates to the forces between the nonpolar groups in an aqueous environment. Water’s internal molecular organization excludes nonpolar moieties; therefore, hydrophobicity is only one component of the more general term lipophilicity [7]. For many years, confusion existed between lipophilicity and hydrophobicity and both terms were used to characterize molecules that show a preference for a nonpolar phase. The definitions agreed by IUPAC for these terms are [8]: lipophilic, adj., -ity, n.: Having an affinity for fat and high lipid solubility: a physicochemical property which describes a partitioning equilibrium of solute molecules between water and an immiscible organic solvent, favouring the latter, and which correlates with bioaccumulation. hydrophobic, adj., -ity n.: Describing the character of a molecule or atomic group which is insoluble in water, or resistant to wetting or hydration. Hydrophobic interaction: the tendency of hydrocarbons (or of lipophilic hydrocarbon-like groups in solutes) to form intermolecular aggregates in an aqueous medium, and analogous intramolecular interactions. The name arises from the attribution of the phenomenon to the apparent repulsion between water and hydrocarbons. However, the phenomenon ought to be attributed to the effect of the hydrocarbon-like groups on the water-water interaction. Hydrophobicity contributes towards lipophilicity but the two terms are not synonymous. Hydrophobic interaction is a different process and can be found as a driving force in lipophilicity studies.
3.3 THE USES OF LIPOPHILICITY Since the pioneering work of Overton and Meyer at the beginning of the 20th century [9, 10], when compound partition in olive oil was found to correlate well with biological activity, much work has been done to standardize experimental conditions and to understand molecular influences on lipophilicity. Applications of lipophilicity can now be found in the pharmaceutical industry, in environmental applications, toxicology, and any other field involving a potential biological effect on a living
82
Advances in Chromatography
organism. It has been widely used in quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR) and in drug and pesticide design as well as in toxicology studies either in the pharmaceutical or environmental sciences. Lipophilicity has been used in the following areas of study: •
• • • •
• • • •
Estimation of solubility — lipophilicity is used (in conjunction with other parameters) to estimate the aqueous solubility by a range of semi-empirical equations [11] Environmental applications [12] General [13] Pesticide occurrence in the environment [14] Drug discovery in the pharmaceutical industry. When creating a new molecule with potential biological activity, knowledge of its lipophilicity helps to build an understanding of its absorption, distribution, metabolism, excretion, and toxicity (ADMET) [15] Oral absorption [16] Serum albumin binding [17] Permeability [18] CNS penetration [19]
According to EU regulations, lipophilicity (expressed as logPo/w) is a required value for any new commercially available chemical and a liquid chromatographic method for this measurement has been approved [20, 21].
3.4 logP, logD, AND OTHER TERMS FOR EXPRESSING LIPOPHILICITY Lipophilicity is generally expressed by the partition between water and a waterimmiscible solvent. Traditionally, the partition coefficient was defined as the ratio between the equilibrium concentration of a compound (C) in a water-immiscible solvent (s) and its concentration in water (w) [22, 23]. In 1891 Walther H. Nernst was appointed as Extraordinary Professor at Göttingen University. During the same year, he developed the distribution law: If two liquids (or solids) a and b are partially immiscible and if there is a third component i present in both phases that behaves individually as an ideal solute (if it is sufficiently dilute), the ratio of its concentrations (x) is independent of the individual values of x. xia = constant xib
(3.1)
Nernst’s law of distribution is described today by the equation for the partition coefficient of a solute between two immiscible phases:
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
P=
[C ]s [C ]w
83
(3.2)
The term C refers to the neutral form of the molecule and the square brackets that enclose it denote that its concentration is at equilibrium. According to IUPAC recommendations from 1993, the partition coefficient Po/w or Ko/w is a “measure of lipophilicity by determination of the equilibrium distribution between octan-1-ol and water, as used in pharmacological studies and in the assessment of environmental fate and transport of organic chemicals.” From the same source, the partition coefficient is the ratio of the distribution of a substance between two phases when the heterogeneous system (of two phases) is in equilibrium; the ratio of concentrations (or, strictly speaking, activities) of the same molecular species in the two phases is constant at constant temperature. The partition coefficients most frequently used in acute toxicology are lipid/water and octan-1-ol/water distributions. From now on in this review the term “octanol” will refer to octan-1-ol unless otherwise stated [8]. Measurable P values are usually in the range 10–2 to 107. As these values extend over several orders of magnitude, they may by expressed logarithmically (as log10) and logP is often used instead of P for practical reasons. If the molecule is ionisable, the pH of the aqueous phase will influence the concentrations of the ionised and neutral forms of the molecule.
D=
∑ [C ] ∑ [C ]
s
(3.3)
w
D is the distribution coefficient of a compound at a defined pH and will take into account both neutral and ionized species present in the aqueous and in the organic phase. Partition coefficients have been widely used to define the lipophilic character of compounds [24] and logP and logD have been extensively included in quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR) [25].
3.5 THE EFFECT OF CHEMICAL REACTIONS ON PARTITIONING The dissociation of ionizable compounds in the aqueous phase is the most common reaction that accompanies the partition in an octanol-water system. Two simple cases, a monoprotic acid and monoprotic base, will illustrate how dissociation influences the partition. The ionization of a monoprotic acid in solution may be written as, HA ⇔ H+ + A–
(3.4)
84
Advances in Chromatography
Organic solvent HA
Water
HA
H+ + A−
FIGURE 3.1 Solvent–water system and the species partition for a weak acid.
The neutral species, HA, will be able to partition in the lipophilic solvent, while the ionized species will stay in water. Therefore, the organic solvent will contain only the HA form, while the aqueous phase will contain both HA and A– forms. In this case, the distribution coefficient can be expressed as follows:
D=
[ HA ]0 [ HA ]w + ⎡⎣ A – ⎤⎦w
(3.5)
where the indices “o” and “w” stand for organic solvent and water, respectively, and the square brackets symbolize that the concentrations of species at equilibrium is taken into consideration. The ionization process in the aqueous phase is governed by the ionization constant,
Ka =
⎡⎣ A – ⎤⎦ ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ [ HA ]w w w ⇒ ⎡⎣ A – ⎤⎦ = K a w ⎡⎣ H + ⎦⎤ [ HA ]w w
(3.6)
The distribution coefficient will have the expression: P ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ P ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ P = = D= ≈ Ka Ka ⎛ ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ + K a Ka ⎞ 1 + [ HA ]w ⎜⎜ 1 + ⎡ + ⎤ ⎟⎟ ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ ⎝ ⎣H ⎦ ⎠
[ HA ]0
(3.7)
The logarithm of this approximation is, logD = logP + log[H+] – logKa
(3.8)
logD = logP + pKa – pH
(3.9)
which may be written as:
S
O
NH3+
N
H
XH2+
H H
O
XH0
H
XH
N CH3
±
COO−
NH3+
N
CH3
HO
O
O−
O
H H NH
S
CH3
O
H
X−
NH2
N
N CH3
COO−
−
CH3 X
0
25
50
75
100
0
25
50
75
100
1
1
2
2
3
XH2+
3
XH2+
4
4 6 7 8
9
6
7
8
9 pH (concentration scale)
5
XH0
Distribution of species
pH (concentration scale)
5
XH±
Distribution of species
FIGURE 3.2 The distribution of species for Ampicillin (a zwitterion) and for morphine (an ampholyte).
HO
O
HO
S
CH3
NH
O
CH3
NH+
Morphine (an ampholyte) pKas = 9.26, 8.17
HO
O
HO
Ampicillin (a zwitterion) pKas = 7.14, 2.55
O
NH
H H
COOH
CH3 XH2+
% Species % Species
CH3
10
10
11
11
12
X−
12
−
X
13
13
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 85
86
Advances in Chromatography
A similar equation can be derived for monoprotic bases, whose ionization may be written as, B + H+ ⇔ BH+
(3.10)
Considering that the only reaction is the base ionization in water, the organic solvent will contain only the neutral base, B, while the aqueous phase will contain both neutral and ionized base, B and BH+, and the following approximation may be derived: logD = logP – pKa + pH
(3.11)
In many applications concerned with biological activity of different organic compounds (e.g., drug discovery, toxicology studies), it is considered that the distribution coefficient at pH = 7.4, the pH of the blood, is sufficient to give an estimate for the in vivo human absorption of compounds. However, the distribution of species can change dramatically with the pH, as in the gastrointestinal tract where pH can vary from 1 to 8 depending on the fed–fasted state and the part of the tract considered (Figure 3.3 and Figure 3.4). The relationship between logP and logD has been derived for amphoteric compounds as a function of the two dissociation constants, pKa1 and pKa2 [26]: logP = logD + log (1 + 10pH – pKa1 + 10pKa2 – pH)
(3.12)
Figure 3.5 shows the lipophilicity profiles for partitioning of diprotic molecules. The curves were drawn using the “What-if” feature of Sirius’ RefinementPro software for simulated samples with aqueous pKa values of 8 and 5. Although the pKa values of real samples may differ, the shapes and relative positions of the curves will follow the examples below for different classes of molecule. A detailed description of lipophilicity-pH profiles for acids, bases, and ampholytes can be found in [27]. 2 1
LogD
0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −5
0
1
2
3
4
5
6 7 pH
8
9 10 11 12 13
FIGURE 3.3 Lipophilicity profile for morphine, pKas = 9.26, 8.17; logP = 0.90.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
5
87
Desipramine pKa = 10.14 Diclofenac pKa = 3.99
4
Diphenhydramine pKa = 8.26
3 Phenobarbital pKa = 7.43
LogD
2
Triamterene pKa = 3.92
Nifuroxime pKa = 10.56
1
0 −1 −2 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
pH
FIGURE 3.4 logD = f(pH) for acids (negative slope) and bases (positive slope).
If a compound is suspected to form dimers in one of the phases, this process has to be taken into consideration when defining logD [28]. Applications in the pharmaceutical industry tend to correlate logP/logD values with drug absorption in vivo. In many cases, a good correlation is obtained if octanol is used for the partition measurements and the logD values measured at pH 5 to 7.4 (physiological pH values) provide more relevant information compared with logP [29]. Although the IUPAC recommended notation for partition coefficient is K, the large majority of publications still use logP and logD to differentiate between the partition of the neutral and charged molecule. For this reason, we will keep the same notations throughout this chapter.
3.6 OCTANOL AND OTHER PARTITION SOLVENTS Octanol was not the first partition solvent used as a model for the in vivo process. Olive oil was one of the first investigated lipophilic solvents but differences between batches and difficult standardization led to the use of other solvents such as paraffin oil. Hansch later proposed the use of octanol and the largest database in the world for partition coefficients is based on the octanol–water system [30–32]. Today, octanol–water partition coefficients (logPo/w) are established as a significant physical property correlated with biological activity. An important reason is the ability of octanol to form clusters in an aqueous environment, thus providing a
10
H2Z = H2Z* Z = Z* logPH2Z > logPZ
H2Z = H2Z* Z = Z* logPH2Z = logPZ
Less octanol, low ionic strength
HX = HX*
Less octanol, low ionic strength
B = B*
Less octanol, low ionic strength
H2A = H2A*
H2Z = H2Z* Z = Z* logPZ > logPH2Z
More octanol, high ionic strength
HX = HX* X = X* logPHX > logPX
Special case-very rare
B = B* BH = BH* logPB = logPBH
Special case-very rare
H2A = H2A* HA = HA* logPH2A = logPHA
Most zwitterionic molecules are hydrophilic, logD values are usually negative
More octanol, high ionic strength
H2X = H2X* HX = HX* logPHX > logPH2X
More octanol, high ionic strength
B = B* BH = BH* logPB > logPBH
More octanol, high ionic strength
2 0 H2A = H2A* −2 HA = HA* −4 logP H2A > logPHA −6 pH −8 2 4 6 8
FIGURE 3.5 Lipophilicity profiles for diprotic molecules.
4: Zwitterion One acid, one base group (acid pKa < basic pKa), HZ is the “neutral” species but is zwitterionic: HZ± pKa equations: H + Z = HZ, H + HZ = H2Z
3: Ordinary ampholyte One acid, one base group (acid pKa > basic pKa), HX is the neutral species pKa equations: H + X = HX, H + HX = H2X
2: Base Two base groups, B is the neutral species pKa equations: B + H = BH, BH + H = BH2
1: Acid Two acid groups, H2A is the neutral species pKa equations: H + A = HA, H + HA = H2A
88 Advances in Chromatography
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
89
model for the partition into a real biological membrane. Octanol has an amphiprotic character and, as well as displaying lipophilic interaction, it can form hydrogen bonds. It can therefore interact with with neutral or ionized molecules and with ionpairs [33, 34]. The partition of a solute between water and octanol must take into account the interactions between the solute and the water present in the organic phase, as octanol can dissolve a significant amount of water (2.3 to 2.5 M). Experimental evidence exists that amphiprotic and aprotic solutes can either “drag” water molecules or “exclude” them from the octanol phase. It appears that besides octanol–water clusters containing a variable number of octanol molecules around water, there also exist an octanol–water complex having a highly organized structure with a water molecule in the center and four octanol molecules around it bound by hydrogen bonds. Any interaction between the solute and octanol is likely to disturb this arrangement [35, 36]. Octanol and water can both participate in hydrogen bonding because both have hydroxyl groups and, therefore, a considerable amount of water can dissolve in octanol. The distribution of a compound between octanol and water is mainly dependent on the differences between the interactions of the lipophilic part of the molecule with water and with the organic solvent rather than the interaction of the polar and hydrogen bonding groups [37]. The extent to which the octanol model is the right choice to model human, animal, or plant membranes, as well as environmental distribution of toxins, still has to be established. Nevertheless, a very large number of correlations between the logPo/w value and biological activity have been reported during the last 50 years. Although octanol is commonly used in lipophilicity studies, the partition in other solvents is sometimes a better model for the in vivo process. For example, it is known that hydrogen bonding plays little role in transport across the blood–brain barrier, which is better modelled by alkane–water systems. Many alkanes have been used including hexane, cyclohexane, heptane, isooctane, dodecane, and hexadecane. Other investigated systems include chloroform–water (H-donor) and di-n-butylether (H-acceptor) [38]. A correlation between the partition coefficient in heptane/water and absorption from the cerebrospinal fluid was reported in 1959, where it was noted that the oxidative dealkylation of foreign N-alkylamines by rabbit liver microsomes appeared to be limited to compounds that were lipid soluble, as shown by high chloroform to water partition coefficients at physiological pH. Since the microsomal hydroxylation of aromatic compounds also appeared to be limited to lipid soluble substances, an intracellular fat-like boundary was suggested that separates normally occurring polar substances from the highly nonspecific microsomal enzymes [39]. The choice of four solvents has been proposed for measuring partition coefficients, dependent upon the specific application of the data obtained. These are octanol (amphiprotic), alkanes (neutral), chloroform (proton donor), and propylene glycol dipelargonate (PGDP) (proton acceptor) [40]. Octanol-water systems have been used to model serum protein binding as well as the interaction with membranes formed mainly of proteins. Biological membranes can have very different hydrogen bonding properties ranging from neutral — when
90
Advances in Chromatography
the partition in an alkane may be a better model — to structures comprising mainly proton donor groups, modelled by chloroform [41]. They can also comprise mainly proton acceptor groups as in phospholipid membranes, where the partition in propylene glycol dipelargonate may be a better model [41, 42]. According to Buchwald and Bodor, the main reasons for using octanol-water for lipophilicity estimations are: • • • • • •
Large database of experimental data Octanol has low vapor pressure at room temperature and is therefore suitable for different experimental methods Octanol has low UV absorption and therefore does not interfere in the measurement of solute concentration Octanol retains some of the hydrogen-bonding ability of water and is able to dissolve a significant amount of water There are many methods available that reasonably model the partition in the octanol-water system (e.g., RP-HPLC) There are many correlations between the logP value of a compound and its biological activity and therefore it is reasonable to assume that compounds with certain logP values will be absorbed in vivo [43]
Other systems, like oil-water or hexadecane-water, may be better models for the blood–brain barrier than octanol-water. However, the chromatographic applications are limited and the rest of this chapter will describe methods that model the partition in an octanol-water system.
3.7 CALCULATIONS INVOLVING
LOGP
There are a number of methods for calculating logP from chemical structures and for using logP values in other mathematical models and predictions. These have been reviewed [44] and are summarized below: • • • • •
Group contribution models: Hansch [45, 46], Rekker [47, 48], Fujita [31] Atomic contribution or surface area models [49] Molecular methods [50] Linear solvation energy relationships (LSER) [51] Commercially available software for logP calculation: CLogP [52–54], ACD [55], ADME Boxes [56], KowWin, ALogP, IAlogP, XLOGP [57]
The link between the partition in different water-solvent systems can be achieved by applying the Collander equation or by free energy solvation relationships. In 1951, Collander observed the linear relationship between the partition coefficients obtained in different alkanol-water systems, 1 and 2 [58]: logP1 = a logP2 + b
(3.13)
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
91
where a and b are coefficients. The Collander equation looked very promising in the beginning because it allowed a transfer from a measured partition coefficient in a defined partitioning system to another one. In practice, the Collander equation has limited application to solutes with similar hydrogen bonding characteristics [34]. Another attempt to generalize the theory of lipophilicity is seen in the linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) defined by Abraham et al. (see RP-HPLC section). LSER equations have been used to compare published partition coefficients in octanol-water (613 compounds), hexadecane-water (370 compounds), alkanewater (200 compounds) and cyclohexane-water (170 compounds) [59]. The main factors governing the partitioning of a compound in the octanol-water system are its dipolarity/polarizability and hydrogen bond basicity, which orient the compound towards water, and its molecular size, which orients the compound towards octanol. In alkane-water systems, polarizability and all forms of hydrogen bonding orient the compound towards water while molecular size orients the compound towards alkane.
3.8 logP MEASUREMENT BY SHAKE-FLASK The shake-flask method has changed very little over the decades and is still the reference for any new method of measuring lipophilicity. The compound is mixed with two immiscible solvents until equilibrium is reached, then the two phases are separated as well as possible and the solute concentration is measured in both of them. If the concentration measurement is difficult in one of the phases, the compound concentration can be measured in the other phase and the concentration in the unmeasured phase obtained by the difference from the total compound quantity. It is essential to mutually presaturate both phases for a successful experiment. Water is usually the lower layer (e.g., when using octanol or cyclohexane) but sometimes can be the upper layer (e.g., when using chloroform). The subscript “o/w” refers to octanol-water partitioning, as in Po/w. In many cases, the equilibrium is established in 5 to 30 minutes but sometimes a longer time is required. Although, in theory, the equilibration time is infinite, the system is considered as reaching equilibrium when two consecutive measurements from both phases show no detectable concentration change. However, this approach requires care as any sampling from one phase will modify the compound concentration and, therefore, the partition process. Also, the shaking of the two immiscible solvents can produce stable emulsions, making the two phases very difficult to separate. Shake-flask experiments can be prone to serious errors and the published logP data should be reviewed carefully, as up to 1 unit span range is indicated for many compounds with reported logPo/w values in the range 1.2 to 5.6 [20]. Although the need to measure the partition coefficients exists in many industrial areas, the pharmaceutical industry has the largest number of samples. The last decade has seen the development of the high-throughput methods for screening compound libraries. Several automated approaches have been developed since the shake-flask approach was decided to be the reference method in industry for logP/logD measurements. An automated shake-flask method for high-throughput logD measurements in an octanol-water system has been described by Valkó [60]. This micro
92
Advances in Chromatography
shake-flask method is performed in capped vials and the dual phase system is sampled by a needle piercing the vial cap. The method was developed for the measurement of logD values at pH = 7.4. A similar system has been described for samples in 96 well plates, where the entire liquid handling is performed by a robotic system. Samples are taken from the octanol and aqueous phase and are consequently analysed by reversed-phase highperformance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). The system was validated for a set of chemically diverse compounds as 1 mg/mL stock solutions in octanol in 96 well plates. Liquid handling was performed by a Beckman Biomek 2000 robot (Beckman Instruments, Fullerton, CA, USA). The aqueous phase was 400 μL phosphate buffer (pH = 7.4) and the organic phase was 200 μL octanol. A quantity of 200 μL of the solute stock solutions was transferred into each of the wells. Different methods for creating the dual-phase system were investigated, all of them leading to the same analyte concentration and the same final volumes. The plates were sealed and placed in a reciprocal shaker for 30 minutes, then centrifuged. Aliquots were taken from both phases by sampling at different heights and analysed by isocratic and gradient RP-HPLC on an ODS column. Similar samples were taken from both phases and analysed in the same RP-HPLC conditions from the solution resulting from the other two procedures, the Eppendorf shake-flask and the manual plate method. Details of the methods are shown in Table 3.1. This automated method was fully validated for logD values in the range 2 to 4 against the logD values obtained from the Eppendorf shake-flask method and against the manual plate method [61]. The system described above can measure 24 to 96 samples per day. The methods were validated for equilibration time and reproducibility within the same method. Very good correlations (r2 = 0.996 to 1.000) were obtained between the data produced by the three methods. A commercially available instrument using automated shake-flask method is manufactured by Analiza Inc. [62] Octanol–buffer solutions at different pH values are preprepared and the sample is injected into the dual-phase system. When the equilibrium is established, the vials are centrifuged for the phase separation. Aliquots are sampled from both phases and analysed by UV, nitrogen detector, or LS-MS. This system can measure up to 200 samples per day with a typical logD range from 3 to 4. A micro shake-flask experiment was reported for derivatives of purine and pyrimidine nucleosides. The compounds were stored as 0.5 mg/mL DMSO stock solutions. For experiments, 20 μL aliquots of the stock solutions were dissolved in 1 mL buffer saturated octanol and then the compound was partitioned between the octanol and 1 mL aqueous phosphate buffer phase (pH = 7.0) in a Mixxor apparatus (Genex Corp., Gaithersburg, MD, USA). Instead of shaking, this apparatus uses piston strokes. The mass transfer after 6 piston strokes is equivalent to 40 shakes in a separatory funnel. The phases were separated by centrifugation and aliquots from both phases were analysed by HPLC on an ODS column and acetonitrile-phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) mobile phase [63]. Compiling the data from personal experience and from the numerous published papers, the drawbacks are summarized here for the shake-flask method:
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
93
TABLE 3.1 Experimental Settings for Three Methods for Measuring the Distribution Coefficients, logD Eppendorf Method Method
shake-flask
Sampling Samples (stock solutions)
manual 1 mg/mL analyte in octanol (1.8 mL Eppendorf vials) octanol-phosphate buffer pH 7.4 100, 300, 400 μL stock solution mixed with 400, 200 or 100 μL octanol, then 500 μL aqueous phosphate pH 7.4 was added. The procedure was done with the same volumes, but starting with aqueous solutions for the hydrophilic compounds, then adding octanol. 3
Partition system Experimental
Manual Plate Method modified shakeflask in 96 well plates manual
octanol-phosphate buffer pH 7.4 200, 300 or 400 μL stock solution plus 200, 100 or 0 μL octanol (or phosphate buffer pH 7.4 solutions), then 400 μL of the other phase was added.
Automated Method modified shake-flask in 96 well plates automated 1 mg/mL analyte in octanol (96 well plates) octanol–phosphate buffer pH 7.4 400 μL phosphate buffer (100 mM pH 7.4) were pipetted in each well; 0, 100, 200 μL octanol added to each well, then 400, 200 and 300 μL respectively, analyte stock solution was also added
Repeat experiment/ 3 3 compound Compound partition reciprocal shaker, 5 min reciprocal shaker, 30 min Phase separation centrifugation centrifugation centrifugation Amount of sample 10 μL of organic and 80 10 μL of organic various injected in the μL of aqueous phase and 80 μL of HPLC system aqueous phase Analyte concentration measured by: Isocratic RP-HPLC: 100 mm long column, packed with 2 μm TKS gel Super-ODS (TosoHaas, Stuttgart, Germany); mobile phase: acetonitrile in 25 mM phosphate buffer with 0.2% triethylamine, pH 3.0; acetonitrile concentration adjusted to obtain retention times about 5 min; flow rate 1 mL/min UV detection, 260 nm Fast Gradient RP-HPLC: 50 mm long column packed with 2 μm TKS gel Super-ODS (TosoHaas, Stuttgart, Germany); mobile phase A: 0.07% (v/v) formic acid in acetonitrile/water (95:5) mobile phase B: 0.1% (v/v) formic acid in water The gradient starts with 100% B up to 100 A in 3.5 min and held there for 1 min. The total cycle time was 5.5 min
94
Advances in Chromatography
1. The formation of extremely stable emulsions that cannot be separated can prevent the accurate measurement of the analyte concentration in both phases. Complete separation is desirable as any droplets of octanol in water can contain significant quantities of the investigated compound. Even when octanol/water emulsions are quite stable, the two phases usually separate after 10 minutes of centrifugation. It takes a longer time to separate the phases when using propylene glycol dipelargonate (PGDP) as the partition solvent. 2. Measurement of extreme logP/logD values (e.g., for very hydrophilic or very hydrophobic compounds) requires a disproportionate volume ratio of the aqueous and solvent phase. In this situation, it is very difficult to sample a reasonable amount of solution from the phase with the smaller volume and automatic sampling is almost impossible. 3. The sample concentration must be less than the critical micelle concentration. 4. The sample concentration must be set below the aqueous solubility limit. 5. Some compounds, particularly the lipophilic compounds, can adhere to the surface of the vessel. 6. Some compounds can form micelles in the aqueous phase, act as surfactants that concentrate at the interface between the two liquids, or form foams. These compounds cannot be measured by a shake-flask method or any other method requiring agitation. 7. Compounds must have high purity. Measuring the exact concentration of compound in both phases is crucial. If a separation method is used for the quantification, the method is also applicable for impure compounds. When the volume ratio between the two solvent phases is high, an aliquot may be sampled from the larger volume before a suitable solvent is added to homogenously mix the two formerly immiscible phases, after which an aliquot is sampled from the resulting solution.
3.9 LIPOPHILICITY MEASUREMENT BY HIGHPERFORMANCE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY (HPLC) Chromatography has been intensively studied because of its remarkable capacity for separating compounds from the most complex mixtures. Assuming constant temperature, chromatographic separation is determined by three main properties: the chemical structure of the solute, the physicochemical properties of the mobile phase and of the stationary phase, respectively [64]. Of all chromatographic methods, liquid chromatography was of particular interest for lipophilicity measurement because of the similarity between the solute partition in a chromatographic system, having a liquid mobile phase and a liquid-like stationary phase, and the solute partition in a dual liquid phase environment.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
95
What determines whether compound will spend more time in the mobile phase or in the stationary phase of a chromatographic system? The answer lies in the interactions between the solute and the two phases. These interactions include van der Waals forces, hydrogen bonding, interactions between dipoles, electron donor or acceptor interactions, and solvophobic interactions. Liquid chromatography is a more complex system than gas chromatography (GC), where the intermolecular interactions in the mobile phase are minimized by the gaseous state of the mobile phase. Therefore, creating model equations for the partition in a liquid chromatographic system is a complex task that has to take into account many variables. Reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC) is the generic name of a range of liquid chromatographic methods in which the stationary phase is less polar than the mobile phase. RP-LC is usually employed for lipophilicity estimations as it is easier to immobilize a nonpolar, viscous phase on the stationary phase than to use it as a liquid. RP-LC has other advantages over the traditional shake-flask method: • • •
• • • •
The method requires a much smaller amount of sample It is simple and rapid It is relatively insensitive to impurities, as it is a separation method — however, the impurity peak can have a larger area than the main compound if the impurity has a better UV absorption than the sample It can be used for a larger lipophilicity scale than is practically possible in shake-flask experiments Other practical problems encountered in shake-flask experiments are eliminated, like the formation of stable emulsions Universal detection methods can be used for the large majority of samples There is a linear relationship between the chromatographic retention parameter and the organic solvent concentration in the mobile phase
Liquid–liquid partition chromatography was pioneered by Martin and Synge, who received a Nobel prize for the separation of amino acids on a silica stationary phase with an aqueous mobile phase [65]. They also provided the first theoretical explanation of chromatographic separation by introducing the concept of theoretical plates, based on the plates used in column fractionation by distillation. Solvophobic interactions are an important part of the retention in RP-LC. Retention in liquid–liquid chromatography is a complex process that must take into account three major equilibria: the solute partition between the two liquid phases, one stationary and the other one mobile; the solute adsorption on the solid support; and the solute absorption at the liquid–liquid interface. Secondary processes such as diffusion into the pores of the solid support and flow patterns through the column are also present and can be a source for retention problems [66]. Thus, the retention is a function of the partition coefficients and the volumes of the two liquid phases. This is reflected by the retention factor (k) in an isocratic system,
96
Advances in Chromatography
k=
CSVS V =K S C M VM VM
(3.14)
where CS and CM are the solute concentration in the stationary and mobile phase, respectively, and VS and VM are the volume of stationary phase and mobile phase, respectively. The value K is the partition coefficient of the solute between the two phases. The retention in a chromatographic system can be expressed by the retention volume (VR) or by the retention time (tR): VR = VM (1 + k)
(3.15)
tR = tM (1 + k)
(3.16)
where tM is the dead time and can be measured for every column as the retention time of a completely unretained compound. Combining Equation 3.15 and Equation 3.16, the retention factor (k) can be expressed as, k=K
VS VR − VM = VM VM
(3.17)
K=
VR – VM VR′ = VS VS
(3.18)
and
Therefore, the partition coefficient between the two phases can be calculated from the retention data and the column parameters. This direct calculation involves errors in estimating the accurate volumes and is much easier to correlate k values with the partition coefficients in a true liquid dual-phase system. The retention in liquid–liquid chromatography is based on the different solvation of the analysed compound in the two phases. By contrast, the retention in reversedphase liquid chromatography is based on the hydrophobic effect caused by the exclusion of the solute by the water molecules in the mobile phase. As a consequence, the compound will orientate with the polar groups towards the aqueous stationary phase and the nonpolar, bulky part of the structure towards the hydrocarbonaceous stationary phase [67, 68].
3.9.1 HPLC
WITH
OCTANOL-COATED COLUMNS
Chromatography with octanol-coated columns is an interesting option for measuring the partition coefficient between an aqueous buffer and octanol. Usually, octanol is physically retained on a silica stationary phase and the mobile phase is an aqueous buffer containing different amounts of methanol or acetonitrile. The method was
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
97
described over 25 years ago [69]. McCall showed that logk values for benzene derivatives are in good agreement with logP values (shake-flask), especially for simple hydrocarbons, but significant deviations appear with increasing polarity of compounds [70]. HPLC methods using octanol-coated columns were reported as early as the 1970s. The stationary phase in the column was C18 Corasil, 37 to 50 μm particle size, in a 50 cm long column and 2 mm I.D. The column was coated with octanol following McCall’s method [70]. High purity octanol was injected directly into the column and the mobile phase was aqueous buffer and 25% (v/v) methanol in aqueous buffer (pH 7). The baseline normally stabilized in 30 to 45 minutes. Pyridine Noxide, formamide or simply methanol were used to measure the dead time and the peaks were detected by UV. Flow rate was 1 to 2 mL/min. The correlation with logD measured by the shake-flask method was highly linear for neutral derivatives of N-(-styryl)formamide. However, no linear correlation was seen for compounds with hydrogen-bonding capabilities, leading to the conclusion that methanol present in the mobile phase has a crucial influence [71]. In Mirrlees’ method, silanized kieselguhr was packed in columns (L = 10 to 30 cm, 4.6 mm I.D.) that were then dynamically coated with octanol. The mobile phase was water or pH adjusted buffer saturated with octanol. Pyridine N-oxide or tyrosine (both with logP < 1.5) were added for t0 estimation. Retention times of standards were run for each logP range and elution times up to 2 hours could be measured accurately. Values of logP in the range 0.3 to 3.7 were measured by varying the column length and flow rate. The column could be recoated with octanol after 50 hours of use. A remarkable slope equal to unity was obtained for the correlation between logP values and logarithm of retention times. The method seems to have two limitations. The first concerns compounds with poor solubility that tended to give lower logP values than expected, probably because the elution time was too short to reach equilibrium. The second limitation concerns compounds such as propanolol, where both charged and neutral species were extracted into octanol. This occurred because the pH of the mobile phase (7.4) was rather lower than the pKa of propranolol (9.56). In this case, the logD result obtained was lower than logP for the unionized compound. The authors also reported that a high salt concentration (above 0.1 M) in the buffer used for the mobile phase can influence the resulting logP/logD value. If the coating is not uniform, the resulting peaks will show a degree of splitting, making the choice of the correct retention time difficult. The recommended time for coating and octanol elution is 6 to 24 hours and recoating is normally completed in 2 hours. The flow rate was 0.2 to 8 mL/min and the volume of injected sample was typically 10 μL [69]. Although the chromatographic method using liquid octanol is promising, the authors stated that “it cannot be too strongly emphasized that, on all the available evidence, the only true model for octanol is octanol itself.” Octanol-coated HPLC silica-based columns were used by Slater et al. to measure the partition values for over 20 compounds. The results were compared with the corresponding logP/logD values obtained by potentiometric titration. The correlation between logPHPLC and logPliterature was very good (r = 0.991). Similar results were obtained for the correlation between logPpH-metric and logPliterature, where the intercept
98
Advances in Chromatography
was very close to zero (0.06), the slope close to 1 (0.9928) and a correlation coefficient of r = 0.994 [72]. Diatomaceous earth (Hyflosupercel, Johns Manville Inc., U.S.) has also been used as a support for nonpolar liquid coatings. This porous material is irregularly shaped and has different particle sizes but absorbs nonpolar liquids such as octanol and PGDP for long periods of time. No silanization is required if the material is treated with HCl, washed and dried. Mobile phase degassing is recommended to avoid spiking from the air bubbles trapped in the UV cell but it is not always necessary [34]. A modified HPLC method using octanol-coated columns is now commercially available from Sirius Analytical Instruments Ltd. on the instrument called ProfilerLDA [73]. The columns have a proprietary stationary phase and are dynamically coated with octanol. When the column is equilibrated, the samples are injected and the elution is continuously UV monitored. The software will automatically convert the retention times in logD values at the pH of the mobile phase. Usually, pH = 7.4 is used for the assays as it is the physiological pH value. The pH of the mobile phase can be modified for other physiologically relevant values (e.g., pH = 6.5). The instrument was designed for high-throughput screening of new chemical entities, mostly in the pharmaceutical industry, and can measure one sample in about 15 minutes. Samples are taken directly from 10 mM DMSO stock solutions from 96well plates. Typically, a 5 μL sample is injected into a 20 μL injection loop, filled with methanol, then injected into the column. The effluent is monitored by multi-wavelength UV spectroscopy. To maximize peak height vs. background noise, a maximum of 75 wavelengths are summed together and plotted against a logarithmic time scale. The range of available methods and logD range is shown in Table 3.2. The lifetime of an octanol-coated column is about 300 injections, although up to 600 injections have been reported without a significant change in the stationary phase uniformity. These numbers may seem low when compared with typical HPLC columns, which can withstand thousands of injections before showing the first degradation signs,
TABLE 3.2 Sirius ProfilerLDA
LogD range Column length Flow rate Eluent
Method 1 (low logD range)
Method 2 (medium logD range)
Method 3 (high logD range)
1.0 to 2.0 15 cm 3.5 mL/min 10 mM phosphate buffer; pH 7.4; 0.15 M ionic strength
1.5–3.5 1 cm 12 mL/min 10 mM phosphate buffer; pH 7.4; 0.15 M ionic strength
3.0–4.5 1 cm 12 mL/min 10 mM phosphate buffer containing 30% (v/v) methanol; pH 7.4; 0.15 M ionic strength
All methods use the same column type, coated with octanol; average run is 15 min/sample.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
99
TABLE 3.3 logD7.4 Values Measured on GLpKa and ProfilerLDA
Compound
Predicted logD7.4 Value (ACD) [55]
logD7.4 Measured on ProfilerLDA (HPLC)
logD7.4 Measured on GLpKa (potentiometric)
3-chlorophenol Carazolol Carbendazim Chlorpromazine Desipramine Diclofenac Flurbiprofen Ibuprofen Indomethacin Lidocaine Nifuroxime Nitrazepam Papaverine Propanolol Quinine Tetracaine Tramadol Triamterene
2.42 1.58 1.42 3.36 1.23 0.11 0.92 0.77 –0.07 1.20 0.73 2.84 3.38 1.36 1.72 2.59 0.77 1.27
2.47 1.64 1.51 3.54 2.08 1.15 1.05 1.21 0.95 1.72 1.17 2.07 2.98 1.38 2.27 2.50 0.77 1.08
2.59 1.58 1.89 3.69 1.74 1.11 0.71 1.21 1.02 1.79 1.34 2.31 2.89 1.24 2.31 2.29 0.56 1.21
Compound Type acid base ampholyte base base acid acid acid acid base acid ampholyte base base base base base base
All measurements were performed at the same ionic strength, 0.15 M KCl. Sirius Analytical Instruments Ltd., Forest Row, U.K.
but this liquid-liquid chromatographic system works in a fragile thermodynamic equilibrium and care has been taken to provide a specific flow pattern that extends the column lifetime. The linearity of the relationship between the retention parameter and logD values is periodically checked with standards [74, 75]. Data in Table 3.3 show good correlation between the experimentally measured logD values at a pH of 7.4 by two different methods. ProfierLDA is based on the method described above, while GLpKa is based on a potentiometric titration method of the compound in aqueous solution in the presence of a layer of octanol. The potentimetric method for measuring pKa and logP/logD values is well documented [76–80]. Calibration is required at least once a day for octanol-coated columns to assess the coating uniformity. Column lifetime ranges from 10 to 600 injections, depending on the coating method and instrument used. Very lipophilic compounds have long retention times, often up to a couple of hours. The peaks will be broad and the peak shape nonsatisfactory for a usual HPLC experiment but the retention times can still be assessed with reasonable accuracy and the resulting logP values have a better confidence range than in shake-flask experiments. The lifetime of PGDP coated columns is usually longer that of octanol-coated columns [40, 42].
100
Advances in Chromatography
One of the difficulties of using octanol-coated columns is keeping the octanol in the column — usually by physical forces — and maintaining its initial volume constant during the elution. To the best of our knowledge, there is only one commercially available modified HPLC instrument using immobilized octanol on a solid packing [73]. Another difficulty in using octanol as stationary phase is related to the low number of theoretical plates compared with other HPLC columns and, consequently, a low capacity to separate impurities.
3.9.2 OTHER METHODS
USING
OCTANOL-COATED COLUMNS
One of the first methods for measuring partition coefficients used generator columns with a diluted solution of propylbezene in octanol to cover a silica-based column packing [81]. The octanol–water partition coefficients can be calculated from the measured propylbenzene concentrations in the equilibrated octanol and aqueous phase. The columns can be reused by pumping methanol to remove the organic phase and dried by flowing through a warm stream of nitrogen. The dried column is ready for recoating. The partition coefficient values obtained from the generator column method were used to evaluate six methods for Po/w estimation of highly hydrophobic aromatic hydrocarbons, one a measurement by RP-HPLC and the others computational methods using fragments or molecular descriptors [82]. The solvent-generated technique was designed to overcome the problems of poor modelling of the octanol–water partition by liquid chromatography with a “solid” stationary phase consisting of a long alkyl chain, bonded to a solid support, with similar properties with a liquid phase. The reported chromatographic systems used C8 and C18 chemically bonded silica as stationary phase: LiChrospher Si RP-8 and RP-18 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), and Nucleosil Si C8 (Macherey-Nagel, Düren, Germany). The mobile phase was 40% methanol with aqueous buffer (phosphate buffer pH = 2.0 for acids and pH = 7.5 for bases), both saturated with octanol following a special procedure to avoid the formation of stable emulsions and allowing a few drops of octanol on top of the mobile phase reservoir at all times to ensure saturation [83]. The formation of the octanol stationary phase was generated by flowing octanolsaturated phosphate buffer through the column. A group of neutral, acidic and basic aromatic compounds was analyzed by this method. The retention factor (logk) was measured on all columns by RP-HPLC and by the solvent generation method and then compared with logPo/w. The column intercomparison showed that the retention (logk values) were more reproducible when using the solvent generation method than when using traditional RP-HPLC. Also, the estimated logPo/w values were in good agreement with experimental logPo/w values. Other applications of the method are described in [84, 85].
3.9.2 ELogP METHOD Classic C8 and C18 silica-based stationary phases and octanol-enriched methanolwater mobile phases were tested by Minick et al. for lipophilicity measurements [86]. If methanol in the aqueous mobile phase is mixed with a small amount of
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
101
octanol, the new system will have similar characteristics with the dual phase octanolwater because octanol is significantly more lipophilic than methanol and should concentrate in the stationary phase, competing with methanol molecules and producing a more octanol-like stationary phase by minimizing hydrogen-bond discrimination. The aqueous part of the mobile phase was buffered with phosphate buffer (0.005 M) or with 4-morpholinepropanesulfonic acid (MOPS, 0.02 M) buffer to pH = 7.4. MOPS is an organic salt and should be less susceptible to precipitation at higher methanol concentration. The nature of the salt used to buffer the mobile phase had no significant influence on the retention of compounds. Amino modifiers such as n-decylamine (0.15%, v/v) or N,N-diethylamine (0.075%, v/v) were added to the deionized/distilled water used for the mobile phase to mask silanophilic interactions with the stationary phase. N-decylamine provided better correlations between logkw and logPo/w than N,N-diethylamine for both C8 and C18 stationary phases. This research work concluded that 0.25% octanol added to the methanol used for the mobile phase is the optimum amount to mimic a true octano–water environment. Higher concentrations were also tested but resulted in octanol separation when methanol was less than 50% (v/v). The method should provide a dynamic coating with octanol of the stationary phase, producing similar results to those obtained with a column coated with liquid octanol by direct injection [69]. Lombardo et al. used Minick’s method with octanol-enriched mobile phase and silica-based columns for the lipophilicity estimation of neutral compounds [15]. In Lombardo’s chromatographic system, the octanol from the mobile phase formed a fine molecular coating on the silica support of the column [87]. In this case, the presence of the amine masking agent was not necessary in the mobile phase. The retention parameter was called ELogP and was compared with logP and logD values, respectively. The ELogP values for neutral compounds [15] and for neutral and basic compounds [88] were reported in Lombardo’s work. The column used in Lombardo’s studies was deactivated, electrostatically coated Supelcosil LC-ABZ. The mobile phase was 15 to 70% (v/v) methanol in 20 mM MOPS buffer, pH = 7.4. The aqueous buffer was saturated with octanol and methanol contained 0.25% (v/v) methanol. A quantity of 0.15% (v/v) n-decylamine was added to the buffer for logD estimations to minimise the interactions between the charged compounds and the stationary phase. Extrapolated logkw values were used for correlations. The difference between the obtained ElogD values and experimental logD values were in the range 0.10 to 0.58 for 90 structurally unrelated drugs. Equation 3.19 describes the correlation between experimental logD values (obtained by other methods or reported in the literature) and extrapolated logkw values for the 90 drugs, covering the lipophilicity range from 1.49 for terbutaline sulphate (experimental logD value was 1.35) to 5.95 for amiodarone (experimental logD value was 6.1) [88]: logD = 0.207 + 1.127 log kw
(3.19)
n = 90, r2 = 0.964 The intercept and the slope are reasonably close to zero and unity, respectively, offering a good correlation between the shake-flask and RP-HPLC experiments. This
102
Advances in Chromatography
method is suitable for accurate lipophilicity estimation of neutral and basic compounds with unrelated structures but it is not recommendable for acids. The authors believe that specific interactions take place between anions and the stationary phase, despite adding different masking agents (some of them being zwitterions or anions) to the mobile phase [15, 88]. Even when great care is taken to model octanol–water partition, a compound can follow different partition patterns in the chromatographic separation and in a shake-flask experiment. The larger the surface between the two phases, the greater the chances that other factors such as surface activity and shape will also influence the partition [89].
3.9.4 REVERSED-PHASE HPLC (RP-HPLC) In reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC), the stationary phase is nonpolar (or less polar than the mobile phase) and the mobile phase is polar (or more polar than the stationary phase). Octadecylsilane (ODS) is one of the most popular packings used in RP-HPLC and the alkane chains form a molecular “fur” on the silica gel granule. RP-HPLC with a purely aqueous mobile phase is not the best experimental design for separation. The alkane “fur” needs a small amount of organic solvent in the mobile phase to help the alkane chains raise from a flat position and allow the free circulation of the solvent molecules. Methanol and acetonitrile are the most popular solvents used as organic modifiers in the mobile phase for RP-HPLC experiments related to lipophilicity estimations. However, the use of ethanol has also been reported [90]. Any organic compound that has a lipophilic and a hydrophilic part of the molecule will interact with both chromatographic phases with the lipophilic part positioned towards the stationary phase and the hydrophilic groups towards the mobile phase. Many authors believe that the retention in a reversed-phase chromatographic system with a C18 or C8 stationary phase is due to the hydrophobic exclusion of the solute molecule from the structural organization of water molecules in the mobile phase rather than on a specific interaction between the solute and the stationary phase.
3.9.5 THE
EXTRAPOLATION METHOD, LOGKW
The retention factor k, normally expressed as logk (log10k), is used for correlations with logPo/w. The relationship between logk — sometimes called capacity factor — and the fraction of organic modifier in the aqueous mobile phase (ϕ) is one of the most studied in RP-HPLC. The relationship is often linear (Equation 3.20) but, in many cases. there is parabolic dependence, especially at low organic solvent concentration (Equation 3.21): logk = a1 + b1 ϕ
(3.20)
logk = a2 + b2 ϕ + c2 ϕ2
(3.21)
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
103
where a1, b1, a2, b2 and c2 are coefficients. logk = logkw + S ϕ
(3.22)
This relationship is not linear for the entire range of organic modifier concentration in the mobile phase but is a good approximation for 0.5 < logk < 1.5 [89]. The extrapolated retention factor value (logkw) shows the retention of a compound in a chromatographic environment where only buffered water is used as a mobile phase. The value of logkw cannot usually be measured directly because of extremely long elution times. Therefore, the solute partition between the stationary phase and water could be a good approximation for the partition between an organic phase (e.g., octanol) and water if there are physicochemical similarities between the organic solvent and the stationary phase. All extrapolation methods rely on the linearity of Equation 3.22, assuming that the linearity is preserved even at low concentrations of organic solvent in the mobile phase. Sometimes, the extrapolation is performed from very high concentrations of organic solvent in the mobile phase (40 to 50%, v/v) without having an idea about how retention changes at lower concentrations. In practice, it is not always possible to measure retention times for very lipophilic compounds at low organic solvent concentration in the mobile phase because of very long elution times and distorted peaks The linearity of Equation 3.22 changes when water exceeds 90% (v/v) in the mobile phase. The logk values of nonpolar compounds measured in methanol-water systems are lower than the values predicted by extending the linear correlation; therefore, any prediction will provide a higher value than the real one. For polar compounds, however, the real logk values are higher than the extrapolated ones and any prediction will underestimate the real logk value [91]. A similar trend in the sign of the error between the measured and the extrapolated logkw values was found for acetonitrile-water mixtures (Figure 3.6). Accurate determination of the dead time (tM or t0) is very important, especially for logk values lower that 1 (e.g., for polar compounds) [92]. Errors in measuring the dead time will affect the k values and, ultimately, the correlation with logP values.
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 3.6 ODS structure in water and in water with methanol.
104
Advances in Chromatography
Most RP-HPLC applications for lipophilicity measurements use ODS stationary phases and methanol–buffer mobile phases. Standard procedures are still to be established as the methods are quite diverse. A compound’s capacity to donate or accept hydrogen bonds influences its partition between the alkyl-bonded stationary phase and the mobile phase. To eliminate this influence, some methods require the extrapolation of logk values to logkw (mobile phase containing 100% water). The extrapolation to 0% organic modifier in the mobile phase is based on the assumption that the linearity of the relationship between the retention factor logk and the concentration of the organic solvent in the aqueous mobile phase is maintained for the entire concentration range, even in the range 0 to 5%. In many cases, it is not possible to measure logkw because of the very high elution times. A linear relationship between logP and logkw for over 50 monosubstituted heteroaromatic series — derivatives of pyridine, pyrazine, prymidine, pyridazine, thiazole, and furane — was reported with a very good correlation coefficient, r2 = 0.95 [93]. According to Yamagami [93], logP values correlate well with logkw values for most substituents but, in some cases, usually for strong hydrogen-bond acceptors, the error in estimating logP is quite high and the obtained logkw value is usually higher than the real one. These conclusions may strongly depend on the type of stationary phase, particularly the amount of free silanol groups [94]. There are many studies reporting the use of logkw for lipophilicity studies. Most of them use methanol–water or methanol–aqueous buffer binary mobile phases with logkw obtained from extrapolations against methanol content [95–100]. The linearity of the relationship between logk and Φ depends on the solvent concentration in the mobile phase. Linearity is maintained for methanol–water mobile phases if the methanol concentration is in the range 30 to 70% (v/v). Outside this range, the relationship can show a pronounced curvature dependent on the retained compound [101]. When acetonitrile is used in the binary mobile phase, the relationship is almost always quadratic [102]. Values of logkw should be the same regardless of the column type and the organic solvent in the mobile phase but often this is not the case [103]. Different organic modifiers used in the mobile phase have different capacities to wet the same stationary phase. Moreover, the same mobile phase will not cover the same type of stationary phases from different manufacturers or from different batches in the same way. As a consequence, the intercept value (logkw) will be dependent on the mobile phase composition and the type of stationary phase used. Very good correlations of logkw to logP have been reported for benzene, furan, benzofuran, 1-Me-pyrrole, and 1-Me-indole derivatives in a chemically bonded, reversed-phase HPLC system with methanol-water mobile phase (r = 0.998 to 1.000). Most of these compounds do not form hydrogen bonds or are weak hydrogenbond acceptors. Pyrrole and indole derivatives are hydrogen-bond donors, so the logkw values have the tendency to underestimate the logP values. The corresponding ester derivatives are strong hydrogen-bond acceptors; therefore, the logkw values will overestimate the corresponding logP values. Good correlations between the isocratic logk50 measured at 50% methanol in the aqueous mobile phase were also obtained for these type of compounds. However, it is well known that the isocratic retention parameters in HPLC usually give good correlations with logP values for
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
105
congeneric series of compounds. The correlation is not so good when considering a group of chemically unrelated compounds [98]. A good correlation between isocratic logk and experimental logP was obtained for a noncongeneric but closely related group of acidic heterocycles. The chromatographic measurements were performed on a Waters μBondapak C18 column (10 μm packing particle size) with a mobile phase formed by 90% (v/v) distilled water adjusted to a pH of 3.5 with acetic acid, 5% isopropanol, and 5% methanol [104]. logk = 0.675 logP + 0.236
(3.23)
r = 0.964 It has been suggested that logkw is not a suitable parameter to be used in correlations and contributes to poor prediction performance. The value of logkw seems to correlate better with logP in homologous series of compounds and the correlation is rather poor when considering a chemically diverse set of compounds [6].
3.9.6 ISOCRATIC
LOGK
VALUES
The isocratic retention factor, logk, obtained on C18 silica-bonded phase was investigated in an interlaboratory study to determine its suitability for predicting partition coefficients in octanol-water [105]. The results showed that RP-HPLC is a reliable method to replace the reference method, shake-flask partitioning. However, there are a number of conditions to be met: at least six reference substances should be used, the minimum water content of the eluent should be 25% (v/v) and the extrapolation beyond the calibration range of logPo/w should only be carried out for logPo/w > 6. Many studies report isocratic logk values correlating reasonably well with logP values. Usually, logk50 is taken into consideration, obtained for 50% organic modifier in the mobile phase. Yamagami reported [93] an extremely good correlation between logP and logk50 (aqueous mobile phase containing 50% methanol) for series of lipophilic pyrazines and monosubstituted pyrazines covering six orders of magnitude. Measuring only logk50 values saves time compared with measuring logk at different concentrations of the organic solvent in the mobile phase and extrapolating to a hypothetical value of logkw that would be obtained with 100% water in the mobile phase. Why does 50% water in the mobile phase seem to provide a better correlation with logP values than the extrapolated chromatographic parameter, logkw? One possible answer is that when methanol is the organic modifier, the stationary phase is dynamically coated with methanol and gains octanol-like properties. If this hypothesis is true, the chromatographic system with octadecyl silane as stationary phase and equal parts of methanol and water (buffer) in the mobile phase could be more similar to the octanol-water system than any other methanol concentrations in the mobile phase [93]. Other studies also mention an isocratic logk [106–108].
106
Advances in Chromatography
3.9.7 THE SIGNIFICANCE
OF
SLOPE S
Because many experimental results from literature show that logkw values do not always model octanol–water partition correctly, some researchers have investigated the significance of the slope (S) with a view to using it as a second independent variable together with logkw: logP = aS + b logkw + c
(3.24)
where a, b, and c are coefficients [89]. A chromatographic hydrophobicity index (Φ0) was suggested to better model the octanol-water partition in a RP-HPLC system. The index (Φ0) was defined as the organic phase concentration (methanol or acetonitrile) in the mobile phase required to produce a capacity factor of logk = 0 [109] (see also 3.9.11). In this case, the retention time is double the dead time (tR = 2t0) and the molar fraction of the solute is the same in the mobile and the stationary phase (see Equation 3.15 and Equation 3.16): k=K
VS CV = S S VM C M VM
(3.25)
where CS and CM are the solute concentration in the stationary and mobile phase, respectively, and VS and VM are the volume of stationary and mobile phases. The value K is the partition coefficient of the solute between the stationary phase and the mobile phase at a defined composition. The logarithm of this equation can be expressed as: log k = log K + log
VS = Sϕ + log kw VM
(3.26)
A similar relationship can be written for Kw, the partition coefficient between the stationary phase and a purely aqueous mobile phase: log kw = K w + log
VS VM
(3.27)
Taking into account Equation 3.22, Φ0 can be expressed as: ϕ0 = −
log kw S
(3.28)
The Chromatographic Hydrophobicity Index concept was validated on a large number of compounds structurally related or not: nicotinate derivatives, hydroxyl aromatics, herbicides, substituted aromatics, aromatic hydrocarbon derivatives, 143
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
107
unrelated drug molecules, morphine derivatives, tricyclic drug molecules, deoxyuridine derivatives, benzodiazepines, aniline and phenol derivatives, adenosine monophosphate derivatives, β-lactam antibiotics, and barbiturate derivatives. The comprehensive study has proved that Φ0 is characteristic for every compound and depends only on the type of organic modifier, temperature, and pH. It is independent of the type of reversed-phase packing in the chromatographic column, the column dimensions, flow rate, and the mobile phase composition of the measurements. The Φ0 values obtained for acetonitrile and for methanol are in excellent correlation with each other, r = 0.96 for 72 compounds. The correlation between Φ0, ACN and logP for 140 compounds (r = 0.88) was slightly better than the correlation between Φ0, MeOH and logP for 448 compounds (r = 0.787) [109] where ACN is acetonitrile and MeOH is methanol.
3.9.8 CORRECTION
FOR IONIZATION
If compounds are ionized at the mobile phase pH, a correction for the right logkw must be applied to the apparent extrapolated logk value (logkwapp): logkw = logkwapp + log (1 + 10a(pH – pKa))
(3.29)
where a = 1 for monoprotic acids and a = –1 for monoprotic bases. More complex equations can be derived for multiprotic acid and bases [38]. Horvath has reported an equation between the capacity factor of a neutral molecule (kn) and the capacity factor of the same molecule but ionized (ki): Ka ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ Ka 1+ ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦
kn + k j k=
(3.30)
where k is the capacity factor at a pH where the molecule is partially ionized and Ka is the ionisation constant [110, 111]. The retention of amphoteric compounds is directly dependent on the mobile phase pH, organic modifier in the mobile phase, and the presence of ion pairs. The chromatographic retention for seven ampholytes (niflumic acid, pyridoxine, norfloxacin, pefloxacin, morphine, nitrazepam, sulfadimine, and 11-amino undecanoic acid) was investigated on a Hypersil 5 ODS, 5-μm packing particle size, from Bioseparation Technique Ltd. (Budapest, Hungary) with 50-50 (v/v) methanol–aqueous phosphate buffer solutions, pH = 3 to 8 [26]. The pH of the aqueous buffer was shifted up 1 unit after mixing with equal parts of methanol. Two different categories were investigated, one involving zwitterionic amphoteric compounds when only the zwitterionic species exist at the pH of the isoelectric point (e.g., 11-amino undecanoic acid) and the other involving true ordinary amphoterics when the solution of the pH of the isoelectric point contains both ionized and
108
Advances in Chromatography
neutral species (e.g., nitrazepam and sulfadimine). The retention of the compounds that have a neutral species in the solution is definitely increased around the pH of the isoelectric point. It is reasonable to assume that the maximum retention of a compound will take place at a pH close to the isoelectric point and that the retention at the pH of the isoelectric point will be dramatically different for the compounds in the second category compared with the first category. The ion pairing process could explain why retention increases in pH regions where only ionized species are expected. The results of this study suggest there are enough similarities between the partition in a chromatographic system C18/methanol–water and the octanol–water dual-phase system to support the use of chromatographic retention parameters to model the partition between octanol and water [26]. A detailed study of ionizable compound retention in HPLC can be found in the literature [112, 113].
3.9.9 THE INFLUENCE MEASUREMENTS
OF
STATIONARY PHASE
ON
LIPOPHILICITY
The stationary phase most widely used in lipophilicity studies by RP-HPLC comprises hydrocarbon chains, usually C8 or C18, bonded on a silica-based support. Depending on the manufacturing process, the resulting stationary phase can be monomeric, where only one bond is formed per silane molecule, or polymeric, where multiple bonds are formed between the chains. The monomeric layer has a brushlike structure, activated by the presence of an organic modifier in the mobile phase, while the polymeric structure is not completely known. Both phases have unreacted, free silanol groups but their accessibility to passing molecules from the mobile phase or from the sample, is higher in the monomeric type. Different C18 silica-based stationary phases were studied with methanol-water eluents to investigate the reliability of the extrapolated logkw value. The variability of obtained logkw values was within 2 to 4%, showing that, if correctly determined, it is a solute property and independent of the stationary phase [114]. However, this result should be taken with caution because the practice shows poor reproducibility between similar types of stationary phases of different origin. One of the main problems of silica-based columns is their poor reproducibility when produced by different manufacturers. Although the structure seems identical, there are large differences in the chromatographic properties [115]. Values of logk obtained on a typical RP-HPLC system do not encode the same factors contributing to logPo/w values (e.g., logk values are influenced by the solute hydrogen-bond acidity while logPo/w values are not) [116]. Also, the alkyl-bonded stationary phase is not a bulk liquid and the solute has to penetrate it vertically, unlike the solvation in octanol [117]. Retention properties for 18 RP-HPLC columns were studied in an attempt to find similarities between the retention and the column type [118]. The correlations between logkw and logP were also investigated, showing that the slopes of the linear relationships are less than 1, ranging from 0.79 to 0.86. End-capping of silica-based stationary phases provide more reliable lipophilic correlation because of the blocking of some of the free silanols [87].
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
109
Silica-based stationary phases, whether derivatized or not, are suitable for dynamic coating with octanol and provide a system similar to the octanol-water dual phase. However, they are not suitable for coating with other solvents that may be of interest for correlations with biogical properties. A C18 stationary phase coderivatized with styrene divinylbenzene copolymer was reported and could be suitable for alkane coating [96]. Because of the limited chemical stability of silica-based stationary phases used in RP-HPLC, these phases cannot be used for important biologically active weak bases, such as alkaloids, with pKa values above 7.0. Other stationary phases (nonsilica based) were therefore investigated in an attempt to find correlations between the retention factor and lipophilicity. Alkyl-bonded alumina stationary phases have similar retention mechanisms as alkyl-bonded silica phases but have better stability at high pH. Alumina has a couple of advantages over silica gel — it is stable over a wide pH range and has no active silanol groups. An experimental study investigated the retention of alkaloids on three octadecyl-bonded stationary phases, octadecyl alumina (ODA), octadecyl silica (ODS) and octadecyl-modified polystyrene-divinylbenzene (ACT-1), and also on polybutadiene-coated alumina (PBD) [119]. Mixtures of methanol-buffer were used in all cases with different concentrations of methanol to obtain a retention factor in the range of 4 to 6. The aqueous phase was buffered at pH = 7.4 with phosphate buffers in all cases except ODA columns, where 4-morpholinopropanesulfonate (MOPS) was used because of the column instability in phosphate environment. The ionization of bases can be suppressed on ODA columns by working with high pH values in the mobile phase, up to 11.0. The correlations between logk and calculated logPo/w values for the studied alkaloids have better correlation coefficients for ODA columns (r = 0.953 to 0.980) than for ODS (r = 0.938 to 0.970), PBD (r = 0.881 to 0.985) and ACT-1 columns (r = 0.686 to 0.804). Poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) stationary phases are stable over the pH range 1 to 14 but the correlation with logPo/w for structurally unrelated compounds is not very good [120]. Shrinking and welling has been reported for these stationary phases [121]. Other stationary phases used in lipophilicity studies are: • • •
•
Monolithic silica columns [122, 123] Monolithic columns based on polystyrenes, polymethacrylates and polyacrylamides [124] Octadecylpolyvinyl copolymer — this stationary phase can provide good correlations with logP values but can also strongly retain specific compounds [125] Alkylamide silica (alkyl chains attached to the polar alkylamide moiety) [126, 127]
Good correlations for congeneric compounds are reported in O’Gara et al. and Czajkowska et al. [128, 129] and not so good in Buszewski et al. [130] Nonsilicabased stationary phases would not have the residual silanol groups and will be
110
Advances in Chromatography
sufficiently stable at high pH values. Hydrocarbon-coated alumina, zirconia, titania and ceria are also resistant to high pH values [131–134]. Two polyethylene-coated columns, one silica-based (PECSiO2) and the other zirconia based (PECZrO2), were investigated for their hydrophobic properties by testing 25 simple, structurally diverse organic compounds [135]. The mobile phase was 10% methanol in phosphate buffer, pH = 7.2. In some cases, the capacity factor had to be measured with 80% methanol in the mobile phase and the corresponding logk values for 10% methanol obtained by extrapolation against the concentration of the organic modifier in the mobile phase. The comparison between the capacity factors for the same experimental conditions on the two investigated columns has a correlation coefficient r = 0.976 for the 25 investigated compounds (Equation 3.31): logkPECZrO2 = 0.224 + 0.988 logkPECSiO2
(3.31)
n = 25, r = 0.976 The intercept and the slope are reasonably close to zero and unity, respectively, suggesting that the columns have similar properties with stronger retention on the silica-based column. Although the studied chromatographic systems looked promising, the LSER studies showed that a direct correlation with logPo/w values is not possible in this case. However, a good lipophilicity scale and quantitative-structureretention relationships (QSRR) prediction models can be easily obtained. Poly(butadiene)-coated alumina columns, Spherisorb A5Y (ES Industries, Marlton, NJ, USA) or home-made, were also used for lipophilicity evaluation of basic, neutral and acidic compounds. The mobile phase was methanol–buffer (1:1, v/v) with the pH adjusted to keep the compounds in the neutral form (a pH of 1.65 for acids and up to 11.5 for bases). The relationship between logk and logP for 24 unrelated organic compounds was linear with a good correlation coefficient (r = 0.96) but, more importantly, a high pH could be used in the mobile phase to measure the retention of basic compounds in their neutral form [136, 137]. The chromatographic retention data on the diol stationary phase was found to provide better correlations with logPo/w than RP-HPLC for series of polar polycyclic aromatic compounds (N-PAC) [138]. The study used two columns: an ODS (Phenomenex Prodigy ODS-2) and a Diol type (Nucleosil 7 OH, Macherey Nagel). Experiments with n-hexane as eluent showed no difference in retention times of benzene and nitro-benzene on the ODS column, confirming a negligible amount of residual silanol groups. The mobile phase was a mixture of methanol and water, 35 and 50% (v/v) methanol for the Diol column and 65, 75, and 85% (v/v) methanol for the ODS column. The retention data in the RP-HPLC systems were compared with partition coefficient values obtained from generator column experiments, on Chromosorb W generator columns (dimethyl chlorosilane, treated, and acid washed) and an extractor column packed with polygosil 35-42 octadecyl silica. Octadecyl polyvinylalcohol copolymer (ODP) columns can be used with 100% water in the mobile phase where no masking agent is required and the packing is stable at pH from 1 to 14 [139–141].
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
111
The influence of organic modifiers in the formation of the stationary phase in RP-HPLC was investigated for methanol, acetonitrile, and tetrahydrofuran [142]. The formation of the stationary phase for C8 and C18 bonded silica involves the adsorption of molecules from the aqueous mobile phase. The organic modifiers used in the mobile phase can selectively enrich the stationary phase while the residual silanol groups will prefer molecules with hydrogen-bonding capabilities like water, methanol, acetonitrile, and tetrahydrofuran. Methanol was widely used in aqueous mixtures and was particularly studied [143]. The concentration of methanol in the aqueous mobile phase was varied from 0 to 100% and the amount of methanol and water that bonds to the C8 or C18 stationary phase was measured by gas chromatography with flame ionization detection (for methanol) and thermal conductivity detection (for water). The increase of methanol fraction in the mobile phase leads to an increase of the amount of methanol bonded to the stationary phase. The effect is more pronounced for C18 phases than for C8. On solvation with methanol, C8 forms a “brush-like” structure on the surface of the solid packing, allowing direct access of the solvent molecules to the free silanol groups. There are structural differences between the C8 and C18 stationary phases, resulting in C18 chains being closer to each other than C8. As a consequence, a lower methanol concentration (less than 20%, v/v) will not open the C18 chains in the same way it does with C8, so the methanol layer on the stationary phase will be less on C18 than on C8. At high methanol concentrations, C18 will also show a “brush-like” structure, allowing the solvent molecules access to all binding sites in the stationary phase. Due to the stationary liquid phase formed on the C8/C18 silica support, the retention mechanism is governed by partition. What happens when the mobile phase is 100% aqueous in a C8/C18 chromatographic environment? Water molecules have been found on the stationary phase and their presence can be explained either by adsorption on the active sites or by being trapped under the hydrocarbon chains. Either way, the retention mechanism will be governed by adsorption rather than partition [143]. A nonporous, ultra-small (1.5 μm), C18 stationary phase was investigated for its suitability in RP-HPLC lipophilicity studies. The column was NPS RP-18 (Micrascientific, Northbrook, IL) and the mobile phases were binary aqueous mixtures, methanol-phosphoric acid (0.03 M) and acetonitrile-phosphoric acid (0.03 M) with various concentrations of organic modifier including 0% (v/v) [144]. Very good correlations between logk and Φ were found in all cases (r2 = 0.99) for the investigated structurally diverse compounds. The following equations were obtained for logPo/w to logkw correlations: logPo/w = 0.87 + 1.18 logkw,ACN,
r2 = 0.977
(3.32)
logPo/w = 1.11 + 0.90 logkw,MeOH,
r2 = 0.961
(3.33)
where logkw,ACN and logkw,MeOH are the extrapolated values for zero content of acetonitrile and methanol, respectively, in the mobile phase. The slopes in the above equations are a measure of the mobile phase sensitivity to changes in the
112
Advances in Chromatography
hydrophobicity of the studied compounds. Both slopes are close to unity, showing a good correlation between logPo/w and logkw with acetonitrile being more sensitive than methanol to structural changes in the solute. Specially formulated stationary phases allow the use of pure aqueous mobile phases in a reversed-phase mechanism. Trifluorpropyl siloxane, commonly used in gas chromatography, has been applied on nonporous glass microspheres [145]. The benefits of a RP-HPLC column that works with pure water as a mobile phase range from low solvent consumption to the possibility of directly measuring the logkw value without the problems faced by the extrapolation method. The retention mechanism on the trifluorpropyl siloxane stationary phase has been proven to be a reversed phase mechanism, similar to the RP-HPLC environment on silica-C18. The relationship between logk and logPo/w has an excellent correlation coefficient (r = 0.998) for ten hydrophobic simple organic compounds.
3.9.10 MOBILE PHASE COMPOSITION
AND
LIPOPHILICITY
3.9.10.1 Organic Modifier Pure water cannot be used on most chromatographic columns, and thus an organic modifier is usually added. The retention on hydrocarbon stationary phases with water as eluent never correlates with logP and many efforts have been made to find the most suitable organic modifier in the mobile phase [34]. Methanol, acetonitrile, and tetrahydrofuran are popular organic modifiers in RPHPLC. In theory, the extrapolated logkw values should be the same regardless of the organic modifier used in the mobile phase. Significant differences exist in practice, making the extrapolation method unreliable. Also, the linear relationship between the retention factor, logk, and the concentration of organic solvent in the mobile phase, tends to curve at high water concentration. The errors depend on the nature of the organic modifier (see related text on the extrapolation method) and can be as much as 10% for methanol-water mixtures and 20% for acetonitrile-water mobile phases [91]. The hydrocarbon-bonded silica-based stationary phase has a brush-like structure at high concentration of organic solvent in the mobile phase. This structure collapses when high water content mobile phases are used, significantly reducing the active surface area of the stationary phase. This could be one of the reasons why the extrapolation method fails to accurately predict the logkw values. Methanol is by far the most popular organic modifier used in RP-HPLC. Good correlations are obtained between logP and logk/logkw for the large majority of studied congeneric compounds: logP = a logk + b
(3.34)
In many cases, the slope (a) is close to unity and the intercept (b) is close to zero, indicating a solid correlation between the forces involved in the two methods. Methanol has hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor properties, changing the cohesion of the water molecules and influencing the way that a solute will interact with the mobile phase.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
113
Acetonitrile is a weak hydrogen bond acceptor and will usually have a greater impact on the solute solvation than methanol. Acetonitrile also has a high dipole moment and can participate in selective dipole–dipole interaction with certain solutes. The participation of residual silanol groups in the retention process is more pronounced in organic modifiers other than methanol [95, 144]. Raman spectroscopy has shown that acetonitrile molecules self-associate as a function of their concentration in an aqueous environment. Solutes will interact with all acetonitrile aggregates and species that exist in the mobile phase [146]. Often, these interactions are not quantifiable and are not taken into account when predicting retention at different acetonitrile concentrations in the eluent. Tetrahydrofuran (THF) is more hydrophobic than methanol and leads to shorter retention times. It seems that THF drags enough water towards the stationary phase to mask the influence of the free silanol groups, so the addition of a hydrophobic amine (e.g., n-decylamine) as a masking agent is not necessary. THF disrupts the cohesion between water molecules in the mobile phase to a greater extent than methanol and, therefore, may show more selectivity in the retention of some compounds. THF is usually employed in concentrations less than 60% (v/v) in the aqueous mobile phase and the relationship between the retention factor, logk, and the THF concentration is often quadratic, not linear. Studies have investigated the influence of the organic modifier, methanol, acetonitrile or THF on the retention of basic compounds. Significantly worse results were obtained for acetonitrile than for methanol or tetrahydrofuran [147, 148]. The influence of organic solvent modifier on the retention of basic compounds was studied on seven C18 columns from different manufacturers and on one C8 column. Nine basic compounds were studied: pyridine (pKa = 5.17), nicotine (pKa = 7.87), amphetamine (pKa = 9.9), codeine (pKa = 7.95), diphenhydramine (pKa = 9.0), nortriptyline (pKa = 10.0), procainamide (pKa = 9.2), quinine (pKa = 8.52), and 2-[N-methyl-N-(2-pyridyl)-amino]ethanol (PAE) (pKa = 6.8) [149]. All compounds have been analyzed with isoeluotropic mobile phases on all columns. The mobile phases were: methanol–phosphate buffer (0.064 M, pH = 7.0, 65:35, v/v), THFphosphate buffer (0.03 M, pH = 7.0, 25:75, v/v), and acetonitrile–phosphate buffer (0.0375 M, pH = 7.0, 40:40, v/v). The columns contained new stationary phases for RP-HPLC, recommended by the manufacturers for the analysis of basic compounds. This study confirms that the organic modifier plays an important role in the retention of basic compounds, resulting in different peak shapes. Acetonitrile produced the worst results and THF may be a better choice than methanol for basic compounds. The chromatographic behavior also depends on the nature of the analyzed solutes. A high pKa value of the solute introduces an extra difficulty in measuring the retention of the neutral form. An interesting “loading” effect was observed for repeated rapid injection of solutes, sometimes improving the peak shape due to previous activation of the stationary phase from the solute. This effect suggests that it is better to inject single samples rather than mixtures. Nonpolar mobile phases have been used for quantitative-structure-retention relationships (QSRR) for series of chalcone, cis, and trans isomers [150]. Eighteen chromatographic systems (three stationary phases and six mobile phases, as shown in Table 3.4) were investigated. The chromatographic parameters obtained for the
114
Advances in Chromatography
TABLE 3.4 Chromatographic Systems with Nonpolar Mobile Phases for the Investigation of Retention of 36 Chalcones, E and Z Configurations Stationary Phase
Mobile Phase
Zorbax ODS LiChrospher 100 DIOL Spherisorb AP (n-propyl picryl ether)
Heptane containing 0.5% (v/v) of THF, dioxane, ethanol, propanol, octanol, and DMF
systems in Table 3.4 for 36 chalcones were correlated with molecular descriptors and logPo/w values calculated from atomic contributions. The logPo/w calculations will not take into consideration the differences between isomers and provide the same value for both of them. The authors claim that it is possible to accurately evaluate logPo/w values with this method, although this was not the purpose of the study. 3.9.10.2 Buffer in the Mobile Phase Buffer is usually added to the mobile phase to maintain a suitable pH for the separation and to maintain the solutes in a neutral or ionised form. Phosphate buffer is very popular and easy to use for a large range of pH values but has the risk of forming ion-pairs with cations. Instead, a zwitterionic buffer can be used, e.g., morpholinopropane sulfonic acid (MOPS). Knowing the pKa of a molecule, the concentration of species can be calculated at each pH. However, it is difficult to predict retention as a function of pH because there are unexpected interactions between the solute and the free silanol groups or the metal contaminants [151]. Most silica-based chemically bonded columns are not stable at pH values above 8.0 because the silica support starts to dissolve [152]. The degradation process is accelerated if the method used for manufacturing the stationary phase produces large surface areas. Several C18 reversed-phase columns from different manufacturers were studied in detailed ageing tests at high pH. Densely bonded monomeric C18 was found to better protect the silica support against solvation in the high-pH mobile phase and acetonitrile prolongs the column life if used as methanol replacement in the aqueous mobile phase. Also, phosphate buffers accelerate the degradation process when compared to similar conditions with organic buffers [153]. Many chromatographic lipophilicity studies are performed at pH = 7.4 because this is the physiological pH. However, the common silica-based stationary phase is partially ionised at pH values higher than 7.0. If the solutes are also partially ionized at this pH, extra interactions occur in the chromatographic system that are difficult to quantify and the peak shape is often not ideal. 3.9.10.3 Ionic Strength The ionic strength of the mobile phase has a significant influence on retention on silica-based alkyl-bonded stationary phases. Experimental results have demonstrated
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
115
that ionized organic acids can be excluded from the pores of the stationary phase [154]. This exclusion results in a shorter migration time through the column compared with the eluent molecules and, consequently, in a negative retention factor, k. While the influence of ionic strength on RP-HPLC has not been widely studied, ionic strength has a significant effect on solvent–water partitioning of ionizable compounds. Solute ions can form ion-pairs with ions from the background electrolyte or buffer in the aqueous phase. These ion-pairs can partition into octanol and other solvents with hydrogen-bonding capacity and the logP of the ion-pair increases with ionic strength of the aqueous phase. However, logP of the neutral species is not significantly affected by ionic strength. 3.9.10.4 Masking Agents The interactions between solutes and the free silanol groups present in the stationary phase packing can lead to significant errors. Masking agents are sometimes added to the mobile phase to minimize these interactions. Examples of masking agents and their volumes in the mobile phase include: 1. n-decylamine, 0.15% (v/v). 2. N,N-dimethyloctylamine, 0.15% (v/v). 3. Diethylamine, very small amounts (can increase the measurable chromatographic parameter to an equivalent logP = 8) [155]. 4. Triethylamine (TEA), propylamine, morpholine, glucosamine, N,N-various substituted ethylethanolamines, hydroxylamine, tetramethylammonium chloride, amino alkane derivatives, imine derivatives (a comprehensive list of masking agents used in the RP-HPLC mobile phase can be found in Kaliszan et al.) [156]. 5. Quaternary piperazine derivatives were applied in capillary electrophoresis for dynamically coating the silica walls but they can have potential applications in RP-HPLC [157, 158]. 5. Imidazolinium tetrafluorate ionic liquids, used for a number of basic drugs in RP-HPLC systems on LiChrospher RP-18 column (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). The logkw values were calculated from the gradient of the range 95 to 0% (v/v) buffer in methanol-buffer mobile phases. The experiments were run with and without ionic liquids in both solvents. The masking agents influenced the retention of basic drugs on the silica-based stationary phases. The relationship between logP and logkw was significantly better for a series of basic drugs when the imidazolinium tetrafluorate ionic liquids were present in the mobile phase (r improved from 0.83 to 0.92) [156]. Although masking agents are employed to block the free silanol groups, they can introduce unwanted, additional ion-pair equilibria. Also, their presence in the mobile phase causes slow equilibration of the chromatographic system when changing the mobile phase composition and they cannot be used in gradient systems [159].
116
Advances in Chromatography
In many cases, reversed-phase chromatography is a good tool for correlation models between retention parameters and lipophilicity but there are many situations where the method fails to correctly model the partition in shake-flask experiments. This occurs mainly due to the differences between a chromatographic system and a shake-flask experiment: • • • • • •
Differences in hydrogen-bonding interactions Compound and mobile phase interactions with unprotected silanol groups on the stationary phase Pore size effects in packed columns poor reproducibility on different batches of the same column type, even from the same manufacturer Limited pH operating scale for many silica-based columns Long elution times for lipophilic compounds, sometimes 2 to 4 hours
Silica gel is by far the most used stationary phase for RP-HPLC applications in lipophilicity studies. However, silica-based column packings have a major disadvantage, expressed by their surface activity (i.e., the free silanol groups). Masking or controlling these effects is difficult in practice and can influence the chromatographic behavior of basic compounds and of acidic solutes [160]. Free silanol groups exist in all modern columns because the chemically bonded phase will cover less than 60% of them [161] and the effectiveness of the masking agents from the mobile phase is limited, covering about one third [162–164]. 3.9.10.5 Association in Water Solute association in water is difficult, especially due to the cohesion between water molecules. Some carboxylic acids produce dimers in water but this process can be neglected as the dimerization constants are usually less than 1 [165]. 3.9.10.6 Association in the Organic Phase The self-association of many solutes in non-polar solvents is particularly known for carboxylic acids, which have a strong tendency to dimerize at concentrations higher than 10–4 M [166]. Another form of solute self-association in the mobile phase is micelle formation. Compounds with hydrophobic chains and polar or ionizable groups will form micelles in water, reducing the value of partition coefficients. To measure the true logP value, the experiments should be conducted at solute concentrations lower than critical micelle concentration (CMC), which sometimes may prove difficult as CMC can be as low as 10–5 M [166]. 3.9.10.7 The Effect of Temperature It is well known that solubility can change dramatically with temperature, but will logP values change with temperature? It has been estimated that a difference logP = ±0.1 can be expected for ΔT = 10 K. The small effect of temperature on logP values can be explained by the increase of mutual solubility of water and octanol
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
117
[24]. Although the temperature has little effect on logP values at room temperature, accurate and reproducible results should be obtained in a thermostated environment. Poole and Poole have analyzed the published literature using RP-HPLC for lipophilicity measurements and concluded that many methods have been limited to studies of congeneric series of compounds, failing to provide similar quality results when structurally unrelated compounds are studied [6]. The chromatographic environment provides a partial model for the octanol–water system and has many properties that cannot be found in a dual phase liquid system, e.g., specific interaction with the stationary phase or flow-through porous media. An important problem arises from the lack of reproducibility between similar column packings from different manufacturers and, sometimes, from the same manufacturer. Silica-based columns are the most popular but many have a restricted pH range (2 to 7.5) due to silica instability in basic solutions. The authors applied the solvation parameter model to determine the individual intermolecular interactions responsible for the partition of the neutral molecules in octanol-water and in RP-HPLC systems, and compared these systems. They found that three chemically bonded phases (Supelcosil LC-ABZ [167, 168], Nucleosil RP18 [103], and Hypersil ODS [103]) provided similar system constants as the octanolwater in a shake-flask experiment when used with methanol–water mixtures as mobile phase. Good models [6] are also provided by Supecosil LC-ABZ dynamically coated with octanol from the mobile phase — 5 to 70% methanol containing 0.25% (v/v) octanol in MOPS buffer (20 mM, pH = 7.4) [15, 88] — and silica-gel columns coated with dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine with 10% (v/v) acetonitrile in water as mobile phase [167]. The chromatographic parameters used in correlation with experimental logP/logD values were logkw or logk in methanol-water systems. Published examples are shown in Table 3.5. 3.9.10.8 Gradient RP-HPLC Although isocratic chromatographic data can provide very good correlations with logPo/w, the experimental time can be quite long. Gradient HPLC is used frequently in all liquid chromatographic applications to speed up the elution time or to provide a different mobile phase polarity for the separation of mixtures of compounds with different polarities (e.g., natural products). During a gradient run, any point of the run time is equivalent to a particular organic solvent concentration. It is possible to estimate the eluent composition at any time by knowing the dead volume and the dwell volume of the chromatographic system [89].
3.9.11 CHROMATOGRAPHIC HYDROPHOBICITY INDEX (CHI) The Chromatographic Hydrophobicity Index (CHI) for gradient RP-HPLC was defined as a linear dependence to the retention time (tR) obtained by running a linear acetonitrile-buffer gradient: CHI = A tR + B
(3.35)
logkw, S
logkw, S
logkw, S
n-alkylbenzenes
Alkane derivatives
n-alkanols
logk, logkw
logk
Drugs, various in suppository formulations
Fullerene-C60 derivatives
Aurones, substituted logk and related compounds Dipyridylsulphides logk
logkw, S
Method
Alkanes
Compounds 50–95% acetonitrile-water
Mobile Phase logkw–S
Correlation 0.99–1.00
R2 Comments
Differences in logkw are useful for column standardization 60–95% methanol-water logkw–S 0.99–1.00 Differences in logkw are useful for 50–95% acetonitrile-water column standardization methanol-water logkw–S 0.997–0.998 The factors controlling logkw and S and solute size and hydrogenacetonitrile-water bond basicity 50–95% acetonitrile-water C18, various 0.99–1.00 Differences in logkw are useful for logkw–S manufacturers column standardization Hypersil 5 MOS (BST, 52% acetonitrile in aqueous logk – calculated 0.904–0.973 Correlation improves when Hungary) 0.083 M triethyl ammonium logP (CLogP, considering only subseries or phosphate (TEAP), pH 2.25 Daylight, USA) excluding outliers 30% methanol in 13 mM logk – biological 0.800 Silasorb C18, 7.5 μm, logMIC = 0.548 logk +1.241 (Lachema, Brno, phosphate buffer pH 7.0 MIC = Minimal Inhibitory (antituberculous) Concentration Czechoslovakia) activity 0.963 LiChrospher 100 RP-18 25–75% (v/v) methanol Good correlations for nine logkw– CLogP structurally unrelated drugs (ACD Labs) (Merck, Darmstadt, (range differs for different Germany) drugs) in 5 mM phosphate buffer, pH 7.2 — methanol-water 90:10 (v/v) logk, no other RP-HPLC was able to rank the Jupiter C18 correlation (Phenomenex, Torrance, with 0.1% (v/v) lipophilicity of the compounds; CA, USA); LiChrospher trifluoroacetic acid a comparison with reported RP-8 and RP-18 membrane absorption is in good (Merck, Darmstadt, agreement Germany)
C18, various manufacturers C18, various manufacturers C18, various manufacturers
Column, Packing
TABLE 3.5 Examples of RP-HPLC Correlations logP–logk
[174]
[173]
[172]
[171]
[169]
[170]
[169]
[169]
Ref.
118 Advances in Chromatography
logkw
N-butyl-paminobenzoate
N-hydroxyethyllogk, logkw amide of aryloxyalkylen and pyridine carboxylic acids
ln kw
N-alkylbenzenes
Various C18 columns methanol or acetonitrile in water or phosphate buffer (pH 7.0)
0.97–1.00 0.99–1.00 0.94–0.98
logk vs. Φ logkw vs. CLogP logkw vs. calculated logP (Rekker)
[175]
[175]
Despite the high pH, repeatability [178] and accuracy were good (all standard deviations less than 4%) 0.987–0.999 Detailed data presented [179] 0.989–0.995
0.998 0.99
Measurements performed at 23, [176] 27 and 40˚C — for neutral compounds (worse correlations when all compounds) considered) 0.995–0.999 Good correlation for ln (loge) not [177] only for log data
n-decylamine masking agent is not necessary because of the THF presence in the mobile phase
logkw or logk–logP (calculated Rekker)
logk vs. Φ logk vs. Φ logkw vs. logPo/w
Potential anticancer activity
logkw or logk–logP (calculated Rekker)
C18-SIL-X-5, 5 μm isocratic elution with 60–95% ln k vs. organic solvent column (Perkin Elmer) methanol in water concentration logPo/w vs. logkw Radial Pack Resolve C18 methanol-phosphate buffer logkw–logPo/w (Waters), 10 μm (2:1, v/v) pH 11.2
9 H-xanthene logkw, logk at Lichrosorb RP-18, 10 μm methanol in 0.02 M 3various morpholinopropane containing an sulphonic acid buffer (pH aminoalkanamides organic modifier 7.4) in the presence of nor nitrosoureido concentration decylamine (0.2%) as group masking agent 9 H-tioxanthene logkw, logk at Lichrosorb RP-18, 10 μm THF in 0.02 M 3containing an various morpholinopropane aminoalkanamides organic sulphonic acid buffer (pH or nitrosoureido modifier 7.4) group concentration Heteroaromatics, logk, logkw LiChrosorb RP-18 methanol-water cyclic aza acetonitrile-water compounds
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 119
logkw
Peptides
Correlation
0.95
0.995
R2
logkw determined 0.85–0.88 on the three on (1) columns vs. logP 0.91–0.94 of amino acid on (2) 0.93–0.94 side chain on (3)
(1) 20 mM MOPS buffer in logPo/w–logkw water, containing 0.15% (v/v) n-decylamine, pH 7.4 (MOPS = 3-morpholinopropane sulphonic acid) (2) 94.75% (v/v) methanol – 5% diethylamine in water (pH 7.4, adjusted with acetic acid – 0.25% v/v octanol) methanol-water, 80:20 (v/v) logPo/w vs. logk
Mobile Phase
(1) LiChrosorb RP-8, 5 0–40% methanol – 0.05 M μm (Merck); KH2PO4 (pH 7.0) (2) PLRP-S, 8 μm containing poly(styrenedivinyl benzene) (Polymer Laboratories); (3) Polyethylene, 20–40 μm, custom made column
Resolve C18, 5 μm (Waters)
logk
PCBs polychlorinated biphenyls (pesticides)
Column, Packing
C18, C8
Method
Non-congeneric logkw series of ionizable drug molecules
Compounds
TABLE 3.5 (CONTINUED) Examples of RP-HPLC Correlations logP–logk Ref.
[181] PCBs have very high lipophilicity, logP = 5–7, so the retention and accumulation in organisms is of particular concern Polyethylene has a homogenous [182] hydrophobic adsorption surface; additional inhibition of polar peptide-solid phase interaction not required. Polymer-based stationary phases are suitable for lipophilicity determination of peptides.
n-decyl amine added in the [180] mobile phase to minimize the solute-silanol interaction; also extends the upper measurable lipophilicity range to logD = 8.3 Octanol added in the mobile phase to mimic the octanol hydrogen bonding activity
Comments
120 Advances in Chromatography
logkw
logkw
Very lipophilic compounds, logP = 3.54–5.95
C18
Delabond C8 column, 5 μm, (Keystone Sci., Belfonte, PA, USA)
logkw–S logk
methanol in 0.05 M sodium log(1/MIC) vs. acetate buffer (pH 5.0) with logkw antimicrobial or without N,Nactivity (MIC) dimethyloctylamine methanol-water logkw vs. logPo/w
C18, Nucleosil 7 (Dalian 70–100% methanol – water Institute of Chemical Physics, Academic Sinica)
logkw
Teicoplanin antibiotics
Capcell Pak C18 (Shiseido, Japan)
logk, logkw
94.75% (v/v) methanol – 3% logkw–S (v/v) diethylamine pH 7.4; 18–92.5% methanol in 30 mM aqueous MOPS buffer methanol (30, 50, 70%, v/v) logk vs. logPo/w in phosphate buffer pH 7.4 logkw vs. LogP
Phenyl N-methyl and phenyl N,N-dimethylcarbamates Sulphur containing compounds
Hypersil, 3 μm MOPS
logkw, S
Phenones
0.957–0.999 Po/w measured shake flask. [184] Estimation of logPo/w (calc) from chromatographic data: logPo/w (calc) = 1.031 S + 1.682 logkw + 1.262, r = 0.930 The best chromatographic system: 61% methanol – 39% water 0.908 N,N-dimethyloctylamine usually [185] decreases the retention, except the situations when it may form ion pairs [186] 0.97
[183]
Differences in logkw are useful for [169] column standardization
0.987–0.997 50% methanol in the mobile phase provides the best results 0.981 for LogP predictions
0.99–1.00
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 121
122
Advances in Chromatography
where A and B are coefficients determined from similar chromatographic separations of suitable standards. CHI values were successfully correlated with logP, meaning that a single gradient run can provide the lipophilicity estimation for a compound. The coefficients A and B are dependent on the experimental conditions (e.g., flow rate, column length, gradient time, column) [187]. The CHI measurement takes 5 minutes and covers a 6 to 7 logP unit range of lipophilicity. CHI values are easy to calculate from retention times and can also be transformed into a logarithmic scale for comparison with logP/logD data [89]. Valkó et al. have shown that CHI values can be treated as linear free-energy related parameters, just like logP or logk values [188]. The authors used 20 different chromatographic systems for a diverse set of 29 compounds. The column packing was a range of silica-based ODS with different endcapping and carbon content from various suppliers; modified packing with diol and nitrile groups; polymer coated alumina-based, polymer-based, immobilized artificial membrane (with phospholipids); and permethylated -cyclodextrin. The mobile phase was 50 mM aqueous ammonium acetate (pH = 7.4) with acetonitrile used as an organic modifier. The fast gradient followed the pattern: 0% acetonitrile for the first 0.5 minutes, then to 100% acetonitrile in 3.5 minutes, maintained at 100% acetonitrile for 1 minute, then quickly to 0% acetonitrile in 0.2 minutes and maintained at this concentration for 2.3 minutes. Ten reference compounds were used for the method calibration and their logk values were plotted against the organic modifier concentration in the mobile phase (Φ). Usually three to five concentrations were used in isocratic HPLC experiments for this plotting and the ratio negative-intercept/slope (–logkw/S) (see definition in related isocratic HPLC text) provided the Φ0 values (the hydrophobicity index) for the reference compounds [109]. A good linear correlation has been shown to exist between the gradient retention times (tR) and the isocratically determined Φ0 values [187, 188]: ϕ0 = A tR + B
(3.36)
The coefficients A and B determined for standards were used to obtain CHI values (Equation 3.35). The correlation between the CHI values for the different ODS columns was quite good (r > 0.991) while the correlation between ODS and other types of stationary phase was not as good, showing that other columns have different selectivities. This method is a high-throughput technique for lipophilicity estimation of new molecules and the CHI values showed significant correlation (r = 0.996) with the molecular descriptors. The retention of tripeptide and dipeptide derivatives was measured on ODS, nitrile, immobilized artificial membranes, and permethylated -cyclodextrin columns with acetonitrile as organic modifier in 50 mM ammonium acetate buffer (pH = 7.4) for the gradient HPLC. The acetonitrile concentration was increased in steps of 5% and the elution of peptides took less than 10 minutes [189]. The fast-gradient method can determine quickly the structural parameters of similar oligopeptide derivatives. CHI values correlate well with molecular descriptors, making it possible to explain the hydrophobicity of molecules in terms of hydrogen-bond basicity and acidity as well as dipolarity/polarizability.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
123
The logD values obtained with the CHI method differ significantly from the logD obtained in an octanol–water system. For neutral molecules, H-donor compounds usually have lower logD values than the logD obtained in the octanol-water system while ionisable molecules show a higher logD value [89]. The CHI lipophilicity scale from 1 to 100 can be used to express the logP scale, from 1 to 5, rather than providing an exact value for logP/logD. Perfluorooctyl stationary phase with 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) gradient provides a very different selectivity in terms of the solvation equation compared with ODS stationary phases and acetonitrile or methanol used as organic modifiers in the gradient mobile phase [190]. Trifluoroethanol adsorbs more strongly on the fluorinated stationary phase than on C18 phases; therefore, its strong hydrogen-bond acidity and weak hydrogen-bond basicity will highly influence the retention selectivity [191]. This property was investigated for 60 structurally unrelated compounds on three different types of C18 columns: Luna C18 (Phenomenex), XTerra MS C18 (Waters), and Fluorophase RP (Keystone Scientific). For basic compounds, the aqueous phase was 50 mM ammonium acetate (pH = 10.5) and for acidic or neutral compounds the aqueous phase was prepared from 0.1% phosphoric acid (pH = 2.0). The organic modifiers were acetonitrile, methanol, and TFE. The fast gradient followed a 5 minute pattern starting from 0% organic solvent in the mobile phase for 0.5 minute, increasing linearly to 100% organic solvent in 2.5 minutes, maintained for 0.5 minute, then decreasing to 0% organic solvent. The biggest selectivity difference between the investigated stationary phases was observed when TFE was used in the mobile phase instead of methanol or acetonitrile. Another approach used linear and nonlinear gradient elutions for a standard mixture of aromatic hydrocarbon derivatives on a LiChrospher 100 RP-18 column, 5 μm particle size (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). The linear gradient elution was applied to an acetonitrile-water mobile phase. The acetonitrile-water ratio changed from 20:80 to 100:0 (v/v) in 40 minutes. Using linear gradients, the exponential regression produced a poor estimation of compounds with low LogPo/w values [192]. The kG parameter was introduced by Krass et al. for the fast gradient elution [193]: kG =
VG − VD − VM VM
(3.37)
where VG is the gradient volume, VM is the dead volume and VD is the gradient “dwell volume” corresponding to the delay in the transport of the mobile phase between the gradient mixer and the top of the column. The authors reported good correlations between kG and logkw, not kw. Snyder et al. have shown that it is possible to obtain an approximate logkw value from a single gradient run and to obtain an exact value from two gradient runs [194]. The equation for the analyte retention time is: tR =
t0 log ( 2.3 k0 b + 1) + t 0 + t D b
(3.38)
124
Advances in Chromatography
where
b=
Vm ΔΦS tG F
(3.39)
and t0 is the column dead time; b is the steepness parameter; k0 is the k-value for 0% organic modifier in the mobile phase; tD is the gradient delay time equal to VD/F; VD is the equipment hold-up or “dwell” volume; ΔΦ is the Φ change during the gradient; Φ is the volume fraction of the strong solvent in the mobile phase; S is an analyte parameter equal to d(logk)/dΦ; VM is the column dead volume; tG is the gradient time; and F is the flow rate. Kaliszan et al. have compared the logkw values of 31 drugs, obtained from isocratic and gradient runs on columns packed with octadecyl bonded silica gel and polybutadiene-coated alumina with methanol or acetonitrile in buffer (mixtures of phosphoric, acetic or boric acids and sodium hydroxide to obtain the required pH) as mobile phase [195]. The logkw values for gradient and isocratic runs were calculated with the DryLab software [196]. Very good linear correlations (r = 0.953 to 0.983) were obtained between logkw (isocratic) and logkw (gradient) on both columns, for methanol and for acetonitrile in the mobile phase. When methanol was the organic modifier in the mobile phase, the correlation was slightly better than for acetonitrile. The linear correlation between the logkw (gradient) values and logP values reported in the literature was not as good (r = 0.804), probably due to the uncertainty of some reported logP values. Kerns et al. have applied a rapid-gradient LC-MS method for the initial profiling of lipophilicity in drug discovery [197]. They measured 70 structurally diverse drugs on a Polaris C18-A column (MetaChem Technologies, Torrance, CA) and a linear mobile phase gradient with solvent A as 100% 10 mM ammonium acetate (adjusted to pH = 7.4 with ammonium hydroxide and acetic acid) and solvent B as 100% acetonitrile. The gradient started with 0% B and after 2.5 minutes reached 95% of B, at 4.0 minutes was 95% B, at 4.1 minutes decreased to 0% B, and was kept to 0% B until the timer reached 5.5 minutes. The experiments were performed at 40˚C and a flow rate of 0.8 mL/min. The identity of all peaks was confirmed by mass spectroscopy (MS). The samples were also run at a pH of 6.9 and 7.9 to test the pH influence on the lipophilicity measurements, which was negligible. The method was calibrated with six compounds having logD values at pH = 7.4 (logD7.4) from 2.00 to 5.50. The experiment has shown that the volume of injected sample has a critical influence on the predicted lipophilicity and therefore the injection volume was set at 5 μL. The method provided a good linear correlation between the predicted logD7.4 values using the described method and the literature logD7.4 values (r = 0.94). However, the method should not be used for compounds with molecular mass less than 200 or retention times less than 1.5 minutes because the logD7.4 values are not well predicted. The reproducibility of the method was very good with r = 0.999.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
125
The relative hydrophobicity and lipophilicity of 63 compounds with known permeability through the blood-brain barrier was measured by partitioning in dextran-poly(ethylene glycol)-buffer (pH = 7.4), octanol-buffer (pH = 7.4) and by RP-HPLC [198]. Very lipophilic compounds with logD > 3 could not be partitioned in the aqueous Dex-PEG two phase system. The experimental results suggested that the logD7.4 values obtained by HPLC correlate better with the compound’s ability to cross the blood-brain barrier than the shake-flask experiments for octanol-water. There was a rather poor correlation (r = 0.918) between the lipophilicity values obtained by octanol-water partitioning and the HPLC experiments. Jandera et al. have introduced the oligomeric gradient capacity obtained by gradient HPLC for the separation of compounds with small differences in polarity or for separating samples containing compounds with a wide polarity range [199]. The type of stationary phase used in gradient RP-HPLC experiments significantly influences the sample polarity range that can be covered by using a gradient of organic solvents in water/buffer. The gradient lipophilic capacity (P1) is based on the retention of standard compounds with a repeat lipophilic structural unit (e.g., methylene) and can help the characterization of polarity range available for gradient separation of different samples. Oligo(ethylene glycol)s were analyzed on ten different C18 stationary phases and 5-minute gradient runs with methanol, ethanol, and acetonitrile as mobile phase.
3.9.12 ABRAHAM-TYPE EQUATIONS
FOR
RP-HPLC
A useful link between chromatography and partitioning is provided by Abraham’s solvation equations. In these equations, solute molecules are characterized by “descriptors” that include size, hydrogen bonding acidity, and hydrogen bonding basicity. These descriptors can be derived from measured data or rapidly estimated from structure by a fragment scheme and used for a qualitative chemical insight into the behavior of molecules in two-phase systems. Abraham has written or coauthored hundreds of papers in this area, making him one of the most widely cited authors in the chemical literature. The Abraham equation is usually written as logSP = c + r R2 + s Π2H + a Σα2H + b Σβ2H + v Vx
(3.40)
where logSP is a property for a series of solutes in a fixed solvent system (e.g., logP, logk); c is a constant (close to zero for a well-derived equation); r, s, a, b, and v are coefficients whose sign and magnitude are related to the solute property; and the remaining terms are solute descriptors. Abraham’s original symbols are widely used in the literature but the alphabetical versions are more convenient for computer keyboard entry and have been used in Absolv software (Sirius Analytical Instruments Ltd., Forest Row, Sussex, U.K.) [116].
126
Advances in Chromatography
Abraham’s Original Symbol
Alphabetical Version of Symbol
R2
E
Π2 H Σα2H Σβ2H Vx
S A B V
Meaning of Descriptor An excess molar refraction that can be obtained for complex solutes by the addition of solvents Solute dipolarity/polarizability The solute overall or effective hydrogen-bond acidity The solute overall hydrogen-bond basicity The McGowan characteristic volume that can be calculated from molecular structure
A useful introduction to Abraham’s method is provided in a recent reference. This paper explains the origins and meanings of the descriptors, shows how descriptors are calculated from software, and explains how the approach may be used to predict the oral absorption of drugs and penetration of the blood-brain barrier [200]. Zissimos et al. described several methods for calculating Abraham descriptors from seven HPLC systems and from measurements of logP in partitions between water and four different partition solvents: octanol, chloroform, cyclohexane, and toluene [201, 202]. Many papers have published equations for predicting properties by Abraham’s method. For example, Yamagami et al. have determined these parameters for water−octanol, water−chloroform, water−octane and water−dibutyl ether systems for pyrazines, pyrimidines, and pyridazines [203]. As well as predicting properties in shake-flask systems, Abraham’s method has been used to interpret the behavior of molecules in chromatographic systems. Luna C18 columns can provide a good model for logP estimation of neutral compounds with no significant hydrogen-bonding acidity when using acetonitrileaqueous buffer (40%, v/v) as mobile phase. The mobile phase pH was adjusted to 7.4 for neutral compounds, 10.5 for bases and 2 for acids. The same chromatographic system becomes unsuitable for compounds acting as hydrogen-bond acids [204]. The Abraham equation was: logk = –0.14 + 0.31 E – 0.58 S – 0.51 A – 1.58 B + 1.79 V
(3.41)
showing reasonable correlation with the octanol−water partition system. The correlation between chromatographic parameters obtained in isocratic and gradient RP-HPLC was studied for 55 unrelated compounds. Gradient RP-HPLC was performed on ODS2-IK5 Inertsil column (Capital HPLC Ltd., Broxburn, Scotland). For the acidic compounds, the mobile phase was a mixture of aqueous 0.1% phosphoric acid and acetonitrile. For the basic compounds, the mobile phase was 50 mM ammonium acetate buffer, adjusted to pH = 9.5 with ammonium hydroxide. The isocratic chromatographic runs were done at various concentrations of acetonitrile in the mobile phase: the gradient runs started with 0% acetonitrile for 1.5 minutes, increasing linearly to 100% acetonitrile during the following 9 minutes, then coming back to 0% acetonitrile in 2 minutes.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
127
The isocratic slope S (Equation 3.22), logkw, logk50 (at 50% acetonitrile in the mobile phase), the isocratic chromatographic hydrophobicity index (ϕ0), and the gradient chromatographic hydrophobicity index, CHI, were investigated via an Abraham-type equation for logP. The regression coefficients were similar in most cases but not identical. All the retention parameters obtained by gradient RP-HPLC are a measure of lipophilicity and are influenced by the same properties, i.e., solute dipolarity/polarizability, solute capacity to act as hydrogen bond donor or acceptor, molecular volume. While an increase of solute polarity or hydrogen bonding capacity will decrease the chromatographic retention parameters, the increase in molecular volume will lead to an increase in lipophilicity. The study demonstrates that the CHI values obtained by rapid-gradient RP-HPLC encode the same information with isocratic logk values obtained at 30 to 70% acetonitrile [205]. A computer program called Absolv has been introduced to the market for calculating Abraham descriptors as well as solute properties. The first version was introduced by Sirius in 2000. It was superseded by a new version created by Pharma Algorithms Inc. (Toronto, Canada) that was introduced as an accessory to their ADME Boxes software in 2004. Although there is very large number of correlations between chromatographic parameters and logPo/w values, it cannot be stated that the octanol-water system and the chromatographic partitioning are comparable [89].
3.10 LIPOPHILICITY ESTIMATION BY THIN-LAYER CHROMATOGRAPHY Thin-layer cromatography (TLC) was the first form of liquid chromatography used for the measurement of partition coefficients. The method is simple and evolved along with other chromatographic methods to a high standard of reproducibility and reliability. High-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) used with automated sample applicators and automated densitometric detection will provide quantitative and qualitative results having similar accuracy and reproducibility to HPLC. The retention parameter used in TLC is Rf and is defined by the ratio between the distance migrated on the plate by the compound (x) and the distance migrated by the solvent front in the same time (xf) with all distances measured from the start line: Rf =
x xf
(3.42)
Martin and Synge, Nobel Prize winners in 1952 for the invention of partition chromatography, were the first to provide a thermodynamic model for this method [206]. They showed that Rf values are related to P values according to Equation 3.43 [207]:
128
Advances in Chromatography
⎞ ⎛ 1 P = a⎜ − 1⎟ R ⎠ ⎝ f
(3.43)
where a is a constant. This finding was followed by the introduction of the RM value [208], defined in a similar way to the capacity factor (k) in HPLC. This relationship is shown in Equation 3.44 and in subsequent correlations between RM values and logP: RM =
1 −1 Rf
(3.44)
In the late 1960s, Snyder and Soczewinski contributed to the development of the semi-empirical model of adsorption chromatography [209, 210]. In 1965, Boyce and Milborrow published the first correlation between RM values obtained on TLC plates and biological activity using the example of some N-alkyltritylamines [211]. TLC has some advantages over HPLC for the assessment of logP: • •
•
The throughput of TLC is higher than than of HPLC. The impregnated layers used in TLC are stable at extreme pH values. Most packing materials used in HPLC columns, especially the silica based ones, are stable only between pH = 2 and pH = 8. Solvents with strong UV absorbance (e.g., acetone) can be used for reversed-phase experiments in TLC because the solvent is completely removed from the plate before the detection. This result means that the entire range of solvents can be used in TLC, unlike HPLC where the solvent use is limited by the instrumentation.
Lipophilicity estimations by TLC are usually done on silica gel layers, either C8 or C18 derivatized or impregnated with a nonpolar liquid phase, and aqueous organic mobile phases. The experimental setup uses the RM values obtained at a specified mobile phase composition or extrapolated RM0 values for a 100% aqueous phase for the correlations with logPo/w data in a similar way as the correlations in RP-HPLC.
3.10.1 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RM AND MOLAR FRACTION X THE ORGANIC MODIFIER IN THE MOBILE PHASE
OF
The literature reports a large number of very good linear correlations between the RM and logP values for neutral and ionic compounds. The correlations between logP and logk (in RP-HPLC) or RM (in reversed-phase TLC, or RP-TLC) are frequently linear for nonionic and ionic compounds. When a compound contains one or more ionizable substituents, the pH and the ionic strength of the eluent will modify the apparent lipophilicity according to the ratio of neutral and ionized species [212].
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
129
The influence of mobile phase pH and ionic strength on retention was investigated for phenothiazine drugs in [213, 214]. As mentioned earlier, RM was defined in TLC in a similar way with the retention factor (k) in HPLC. Taking into consideration Equation 3.17 defining k, a similar relationship can be written for RM: RM = K
VS = Kr VM
(3.45)
where r is the phase volume ratio (VS/VM) for the stationary and mobile phase, respectively, and K is the partition coefficient of a compound between the stationary phase and the mobile phase. If the stationary phase is octanol and the mobile phase is water (or aqueous buffer) and if the compound is in the neutral form, K equals Po/w. The term r is a constant for a defined chromatographic system. If the compound is partially ionized under the experimental conditions, K equals D (the distribution coefficient). In this case, the logarithm of Equation 3.45 can be written as: RM = logP + log r
(3.46)
RM = logD + log r
(3.47)
or
Hulshoff and Perrin [213, 214] expressed RM values taking the acidity constant into account: ⎛ P = D ⎜1 + ⎜⎝
⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ ⎞ ⎟ K a ⎟⎠
(3.48)
⎛ P = D ⎜1 + ⎜⎝
Ka ⎞ ⎟ ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦ ⎟⎠
(3.49)
for a monoprotic base and
for a monoprotic acid. Rearranging the equations, RM can be expressed in Equation 3.50 for a base: RM = logP + log f + log r
(3.50)
where f = Ka/(Ka + [H+]), the fraction of the drug present as free base in mobile phase.
130
Advances in Chromatography
Extensive experimental results show the existence of a linear relationship between the retention parameter (RM) and the concentration of organic modifier (usually methanol) in the mobile phase (Φ) in a similar way with the RP-HPLC experiments: RM = a + b ϕ
(3.51)
Because RM and logP are related, a similar equation can be written for logP: logP = a + b ϕ
(3.52)
where a and b are coefficients. Therefore Equation 3.51 becomes: RM = a + b ϕ + log f + log r
(3.53)
When ϕ equals zero (i.e., the aqueous mobile phase does not contain any solvent), logP = a. Equation 3.11 may also be written: RM = logP + log r + log f + b ϕ
(3.54)
RM – log f = logP + log r + b ϕ
(3.55)
Rearranging:
The linear plotting of RM – log f values vs. ϕ will have the slope b and the intercept logP + log r. When ϕ = 0, RM = logP + log r
(3.56)
RM0 is the value at ϕ = 0 (0% organic modifier in the mobile phase), when the experimental conditions are set to have the compounds only in the nonprotonated form. Almost 50 years ago, Boyce and Milborrow proposed the use of RM values obtained from TLC experiments as a reliable alternative to the classical logP determinations [211]. As in HPLC, methanol and acetonitrile are the most popular organic modifiers for the polar mobile phase and silica gel impregnated with a nonpolar solvent or chemically bonded with C18 were used as a nonpolar stationary phase. Planar chromatography has a great advantage over HPLC: it can cope with solvents that are strong absorbers in UV (e.g., acetone) because the solvents are completely removed from the plate before detection. Very good linear correlations were also obtained between chromatographic systems using acetone as organic modifier in the mobile phase and logPo/w. In binary aqueous organic eluents, the organic solvent has a decisive influence on the overall chromatographic distribution equilibrium reflected in the RM values of the investigated solutes. Generally, there is a good linear correlation between RM and X (Equation 3.57) where X is the fraction of organic
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
131
modifier in the aqueous mobile phase. However, deviations from linearity are frequently found when the water concentration in the mobile phase is more than 90%. RM = ao + a1 X = RM0 + a1 X
(3.57)
The RM values extrapolated to zero organic solvent content — X = 0 : (RM)X=0 = a0 = RM0 — depend on the structure of the compounds and are considered to be a good estimation for lipophilicity in the same way that logkw values obtained by RPHPLC are. The intercept values (RM0) can be correlated with the compound lipophilicity and the slope (a1) can be considered a measure of mobile phase strength or, in other words, the mobile phase contribution to the solute retention [12]. The absolute values of the negative slopes (a1) of the TLC Equation 3.57 are dependent on the organic modifier used in the mobile phase and decrease in the order acetone > acetonitrile > methanol [215]. In an ideal experiment using a particular stationary phase, the nature of the organic solvent (methanol, acetonitrile, or acetone) in the mobile phase should have little influence on the extrapolated RM0 values. Experimental results confirm this idea, although there are many exceptions. The slopes and intercepts of the RM – ϕ linear correlations usually have values close to 1 and 0, respectively, showing the correct nature of the correlation. In RP-TLC, very hydrophilic compounds can migrate reliably even at 0% organic solvent in mobile phase. The experimentally measured RM0 values correlate well with the extrapolated RM0 values, showing the validity of the presumption that the real RM0 values follow the linearity between RM and X [216]. To support these findings, the chromatographic behavior of 33 xanthine derivatives was studied by RP-TLC on silica gel GF254 impregnated with silicone DC 200 (350 cS) (Applied Science Labs, State College, PA) at pH = 7 and pH = 9 [217, 218]. A very good correlation was reported between the extrapolated (RM0extrap) and experimental RM0 values (RM0exp): RM0exp = 0.036 (± 0.010) + 0.972 (± 0.013) RM0extrap
(3.58)
n = 33, r = 0.997, SD = 0.043, F = 5523 where n is the number of compounds, r is the correlation coefficient, SD is the standard deviation and F is the statistical parameter for the F-test. The intercept and slope were very close to 0 and 1, respectively, showing the validity of the extrapolated methods. Similar results were reported for six serotonergic ligands for RP-TLC experiments with acetone, acetonitrile, or methanol as organic modifier [219].
3.10.2 INFLUENCE
OF PH
The experimental values (RM0exp) of a series of xanthine derivatives were measured by RP-TLC on silica gel GF254 plates when the mobile phase was a glycine buffer, with pH = 7.0 and pH = 9.0 providing the following relationship [217]:
132
Advances in Chromatography
RMexp pH 7.0 = –0.481 (± 0.057) + 1.079 (± 0.100) RMexp pH 9.0
(3.59)
n = 27, r = 0.907, SD = 0.298, F = 116.7, P < 0.005 A similar study was performed on 14 adenosine derivatives and the relationship between the RMexp values of adenosine derivatives at pH = 7.0 and those at pH = 9.0 are given by Equation 3.60: RMexp pH 7.0 = –0.062 (± 0.092) + 1.029 (± 0.105) RMexp pH 9.0
(3.60)
n = 14, r = 0.943, SD = 0.168, F = 96.15, P < 0.005 The higher standard deviation obtained for xanthine derivatives suggests that not all the compounds were equally affected by the increase in the pH of the chromatographic system. By contrast, the increase in pH did not seem to have a significant influence on the chromatographic migration of the adenosine derivatives. In this case, the intercept and slope have values closer to 0 and 1, respectively. The measured RM values for strong bases by RP-TLC on silica-based stationary phases are significantly affected by the influence of the pH of the mobile phase on the silanol groups. Dross et al. have studied the effect of the mobile phase pH on RM values for 17 monoamine oxidase inhibitory drugs by RP-TLC on paraffinimpregnated silica gel using water-methanol systems containing acetic acid, sodium acetate, and sodium chloride [220, 221]. The influence of solvent pH on RM values was also investigated on a series of 1,2-benzisothiazol-3(2H)-ones. The RM0 values were measured by RP-TLC using acetone, acetonitrile, and methanol as organic solvent moderator [222].
3.10.3 INFLUENCE OF MOBILE PHASE COMPOSITION ON RM0 VALUE Methanol, acetone, and acetonitrile are the most widely used organic solvents in the aqueous phase for RP-TLC experiments. Biagi et al. have used all these solvents in binary aqueous mobile phases at pH = 7.0 for lipophilicity measurements of 15 steroids on silica gel GF254 layers impregnated with silicone oil [215]. The linear relationships between the extrapolated RM0 values for the three organic modifiers have shown very good correlation coefficients, described by Equation 3.61 and Equation 3.62: RM0methanol = 0.116 (±0.061) + 0.947 (±0.040) RM0acetone
(3.61)
n = 15, r = 0.989, SD = 0.077 RM0acetonitrile = –0.014 (±0.048) + 0.966 (±0.032) RM0acetone n = 15, r = 0.993, SD = 0.061
(3.62)
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
133
where n is the number of studied compounds, r is the correlation coefficient and SD is the standard deviation. Many reported studies have concluded that the RM0 values obtained from extrapolations based on different organic solvents in the mobile phase are very similar [215, 219, 223, 224]. Alternatively, some results suggest that better correlations with logPo/w are obtained when methanol is used [220]. Values for lipophilicity based on RM0 values of 17 monoamine oxidase inhibitory drugs was determined by RP-TLC [225]. The effect of salt concentration on the reversed-phase retention was investigated by adding ammonium chloride to the mobile phase. Each drug showed predictable retention behavior and the RM values decreased linearly with the increase of methanol concentration in the mobile phase. The presence of ammonium chloride led to a decrease in retention and this effect was more evident at low salt concentration, indicating that when the salt concentration is close to the saturation value, the retention will not change greatly. Also, the influence of ammonium chloride is dependent on the methanol concentration.
3.10.4 INFLUENCE
OF
STATIONARY PHASE
ON
RM0 VALUE
The stationary phase has a crucial effect on the chromatographic behavior of different solutes. The stationary phase used in a lipophilicity study is usually hydrophobic, e.g., cellulose [226] or silica based. The large majority of lipophilicity studies by RP-TLC are performed on silica gel layers, impregnated with hydrophobic, oily liquids, or chemically derivatized with hydrocarbon chains (C8 or C18). The plate impregnation is usually done with octanol [227], liquid paraffin [211, 228], or silicone oil [215, 216, 229]. Paraffin oil and silicone oil were popular attempts to produce a nonpolar stationary phase on a silica gel layer. The chromatographic migration of benzophenones in RP-TLC has shown that the replacement of paraffin oil by silicone oil can cause significant changes in the retention of compounds containing particular functional groups [230]. The compounds have different retention on kieselguhr and silica gel layers coated with silicone oil but the influence of the solid support seems negligible when coating the layer with paraffin oil. These subtle influences on the retention of compounds make it difficult to explain the changes in lipophilicity. Although silica gel is the most widely used stationary phase in RP-TLC experiments for lipophilicity studies, the relationship between the retention on other stationary phases and lipophilicity has been investigated. The chromatographic behavior of some neutral, acidic, and alkaline compounds was studied by RP-TLC using different layers: Kieselgel 60 HF254 (Merck), MN-Aluminium oxide G (Macherey-Nagel) and Cellulose powder MN 300 (Macherey-Nagel), all impregnated with different amounts of paraffin oil. The mobile phase was water, water-methanol (1:1 or 3:1, v/v) or water-acetonitrile (1:1 or 2:1, v/v). The retention of all compounds increased in all experiments with the amount of paraffin oil present in the stationary phase. The lowest RM value was determined on cellulose support. Alkaline compounds showed higher RM values on silica gel layers and acidic compounds on aluminium oxide [231]. The lipophilicity of 21 amino acids was investigated on different stationary phases: silica gel, aluminium oxide, cellulose, Kieselguhr and mixtures of these,
134
Advances in Chromatography
impregnated with paraffin oil and using water as mobile phase, and a comparison of RM values obtained in all systems was presented by Gullner et al. [232] While the nature of the stationary phase has a strong influence on the absolute RM values, very good correlations have been obtained between RM values obtained for the same series of compounds on different stationary phases [217]. For instance, the correlation between the RM values obtained on RP-TLC plates impregnated with silicone and those obtained on C18 RP-HPTLC plates (Whatman KC18F) for 43 of xanthine and adenosine derivatives at pH = 7.0 is given by Equation 3.63: RM0 silicone = –0.272 (± 0.040) + 0.610 (± 0.023) RM0 C18
(3.63)
n = 43, r = 0.972, SD = 0.154 The intercept value, significantly different from zero, is due to the difference in the nature of the stationary phases used. The C18 RP-HPTLC system seems to be more lipophilic than silicone RP-TLC and the extrapolated RM0 values obtained on C18 plates are higher than the experimental silicone RP-TLC values; therefore, the slope is lower than 1. Although there are significant differences between the two systems, the two sets of extrapolated values, RM0 silicone and RM0 C18, have a satisfactory correlation for the studied xanthine and adenosine derivatives [217]. Data about the influence of TLC layers coated with complexating, ion-exchanging, and ion pairing agents on retention, with particular attention paid to the determination of molecular lipophilicity and comparison between impregnated and chemically modified silica gel layers, was studied by Garssini-Strazza et al. [233] The influence of pH on the surface of the TLC layer was also investigated for silica gel. The separation of peptides at a surface pH of 2.0, 4.5, 7.5, and 9.0, using methanol as organic modifier in the concentration range 0 to 90% (v/v), was discussed in relation with the silanophilic effect and the peptide structures by Cserháti and Szögyi [234]. Although silica gel is the general choice for the stationary phase when investigating compound lipophilicity, there are studies showing good correlations on alumina oxide. The lipophilicity of 18 phenols and aniline derivatives was investigated on DC-Alumina-oxide F254 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and Polygram UV254 silica gel plates (Macherey-Nagel, Düren Germany) impregnated with 2.5 and 10% (v/v) paraffin oil in n-hexane and a mixture of methanol-water as mobile phase. The degree of stationary phase impregnation has a greater effect on the compound retention than the support chemical nature [235].
3.10.5 SPECIFIC HYDROPHOBIC SURFACE AREA
OF THE
SOLUTE
The slope (a1) of the linear correlation between RM values and the concentration of organic modifier (Φ) in the mobile phase (Equation 3.57) is related to the specific hydrophobic surface area of the solute. Many studies have shown that the lipophilicity as well as the specific hydrophobic surface of solutes can be determined from the linear relationship between the RM values and the concentration of methanol in the mobile phase [236–241].
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
135
The lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic areas of 18 nonsteriodal anti-inflammatory drugs have been determined by RP-TLC for subsequent use in QSAR studies. The chromatographic experiments were performed on Polygram UV-3254-3 plates (Macherey-Nagel, Düren, Germany) impregnated by overnight development in nhexane-paraffin oil (95:5, v/v); water-methanol was used as mobile phase, the methanol concentration ranging from 0 to 35% (v/v) in steps of 5%. The experimental data showed that the hydrophobicity parameters for nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs are highly dependent on the presence of acetic acid, sodium acetate, and sodium chloride in the mobile phase [236]. The drugs fall into two groups, dissociable acidic and alkaline. The influence of salts on lipophilicity and hydrophobic surface area was investigated by RP-TLC for 11 sulfosuccinic acid esters [237]. The experiments were performed in ion-free eluents and in eluents containing sodium chloride, potassium chloride, magnesium chloride, and calcium chloride. It is important to note that the salt influence was greater for specific hydrophobic surface area estimations than for hydrophobicity. An interesting result was reported for the RP-TLC data on the lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic surface area of 31 commercial pesticides with water-methanol mixtures as mobile phase. The RM values decreased linearly with increasing concentration of methanol in the mobile phase. Although the chemical structures of pesticides were extremely different, the lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic surface area of pesticides were highly intercorrelated [238]. Principal component analysis (PCA) showed that when both lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic surface area were taken into consideration, the herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides could not be distinguished, all forming only one class. The differences in the biological activity of the investigated pesticides cannot therefore be attributed only to their lipophilicity or their specific hydrophobic surface area. The determination of lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic surface area by RPTLC following the methods described above was performed on many different classes of compound, such as fused-nitrogen heterocycles [239], anti-hypoxia drugs [242], or bioactive heterocyclic compounds [241].
3.10.6 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INTERCEPTS (RM0) AND SLOPES (a1) Many publications use the term “congeneric” to classify a group of structurally related compounds. In RP-TLC the “congenerity” of compounds can be expressed by the linearity between the extrapolated parameters RM0 and the slopes a1. In order to understand the relationship between slopes and intercepts of the TLC equations, the physico-chemical meaning of these two parameters must be discussed. The intercept (RM0) can be considered a measure of the compound partitioning between a polar mobile phase and a nonpolar stationary phase. The value RM0 can sometimes be measured directly but, for the majority of the compounds, RM0 is obtained by extrapolating the retention parameter RM to a theoretical retention that would be obtained with 100% aqueous mobile phase. The slope a1 indicates the rate at which the solubility of solute increases in mobile phase. The correlation between RM0 and
136
Advances in Chromatography
a1 is usually linear for series of congeneric compounds (Equation 3.64) [215, 216, 243]: RM0 = b0 + b1 a1
(3.64)
The congenerity can be broken by the presence of ionizable groups, which can modify the interactions of the components with the nonpolar stationary phase or polar mobile phase. The physicochemical significance of the slope can be expressed: 1. As reflecting the nature of the compound and mainly determined by the interaction between the solute and the mobile phase 2. In terms of the so-called displacement model, which assumes that a monomolecular layer of mobile phase molecules is adsorbed on the stationary phase and that any other molecule from the mobile phase, solvent or compound, can be retained on the stationary phase only by displacing the molecules already absorbed 3. On the concept of hydrophobic surface area availability [216] RM and slope increase when the retention increases, suggesting that both parameters are related to the same physicochemical factors. Table 3.6 shows results for a series of ionizable quinolines studied on silica gel impregnated with silicone, using methanol, acetone, or acetonitrile in the mobile phase. The results for all three systems seem consistent and good linear correlations were obtained between the parameters RM – ϕ and RM0 – a1. However, there are differences between the piperazine ring and the cinoline ring and sometimes not all the members of a chemical series fit the same linear correlation [216, 243]. The relationship between the intercept and the slope of the linear RM – ϕ dependence was reviewed for series of steroids, nitroimidazothiazoles, phenols, triazines, prostaglandins, 5-nitroimidazoles, dermorphins, 4-nitropyrazoles, 1,4dihydropyridines, naphthalenes, and quinolines [216]. The investigations of different series of compounds in different chromatographic environments led to the conclusion that the relationship between the slope and the intercept of the TLC equations (Equation 3.57) is linear and can be considered a fundamental aspect of the lipophilicity estimations by RP-TLC but only for strictly congeneric compounds [216, 219]. A recent study used the parameter C0 (where C0 = RM0/a1) instead of RM0. However, the correlations between logP and C0 for series of thiazoles are not better than between logP and RM0. Different organic modifiers in the mobile phase were also investigated [244]. Another interesting observation is that the slope of TLC equations in different solvent systems correlate well with the solvent strength parameter (E0) of acetone, acetonitrile, and methanol [215]. The solvent strength is defined by the 1/E0 value and is 1.78 for acetone, 1.54 for acetonitrile, and 1.5 for methanol. The ratios between the slopes in different solvents and the ratios between solvent strength values are shown in Table 3.7 [215, 243]. The ratio between the slopes in two different solvent systems is close to the ratio between the 1/E0 values for the corresponding solvents
Antiarrhythmic and antihypertensive, 1-[2 hydroxy- or 1-[2acetoxy-3-(4-aryl-1piperazinyl)pyrrolidin-2one derivatives
Antiarrhythmics
2-amino-3-cyano-4,5diphenylfurane derivatives
2-(aminoacetylamino) thiazole derivatives
Amido esters of ethanolamine derivatives
Compounds Mobile Phase
silica gel 60 F254 silanized precoated plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) RP-18 F254S plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
acetonitrile (65/35 to 50/50, v/v) in 0.02 N ammonium acetate buffer (pH 7.4) 21.4–78.5% (v/v) acetone, or 14.3% (v/v) methanol in water 0.996–0.974
0.900
C18 bonded silica gel methanol-water 0.985–0.993 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) silica gel plates methanol-water (7:3, impregnated with 5% v/v) and 2% aqueous liquid paraffin in light ammonium hydroxide petroleum ether silica gel 60 F254 RP-18 40–80% methanol in 0.990–0.999 (Merck, Darmstadt, water Germany)
Stationary Phase
Linear Correlation RM – ϕ r
0.992
0.990
Linear Correlation RM0 – a1 r
0.991
0.897 for RM at 50% acetonitrile
0.918
0.979
0.929
Linear Correlation RM0 – logP r
Correlation with calculated values logP (SYBYL 6.4 Tripos)
Calculated logP values using Rekker’s fragmental constant method Correlation with calculated values CLogP
RM values range from 0.153 to –0.753
Tab 2
Comments
TABLE 3.6 Examples of RP-TLC Lipophilicity Studies on Different Classes of Compounds (where r = Correlation Coefficient)
[259, 260]
[252, 255]
[258]
[256]
[257]
Ref.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 137
Polygram UV254 plates (MachereyNagel, Düren, Germany)
Stationary Phase
β-adrenoceptor antagonists n-octanol on RP-TLC plates 1-aryl-2-imine-3silica gel RP-18 F254S arylaminocarbonyl (Merck Darmstadt, imidazolidines Germany) Benzamides silica gel 60 F254 silanised precoated plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) 1,2-benzisothiazol-3(2H)- precoated RP-18 F254S ones plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
Anticancer drugs
Compounds
10–75% (v/v) methanol, ethanol, 1propanol, 2-propanol, actonitrile, dioxane or tetrahydrofurane in water phosphate buffer (pH 7.4) 60–90% (v/v) methanol in 4% aqueous acetic acid acetonitrile (65/35 to 50/50, v/v) in 0.02 N ammonium acetate buffer (pH 7.4) 40–80% acetone in water; 20–60% acetonitrile in water; 40–80% methanol in water (all v/v)
Mobile Phase
Linear Correlation RM0 – a1 r Linear Correlation RM0 – logP r Comments
0.992–0.999 (acetone) 0.987–0.996 (acetonitrile) 0.992–0.999 (methanol)
0.900
0.999–0.984
0.992–0.999 (acetone) 0.987–0.996 (acetonitrile) 0.992–0.999 (methanol)
0.992 (calibration compounds) 0.716 for RM at 50% acetonitrile
Correlation with calculated values CLogP
Experiment conducted at 37˚C logPTLC = 3.870–5.452
lipophilicity mapping for 22 anticancer drugs, using multivariate mathematicalstatistical methods
Linear Correlation RM – ϕ r
TABLE 3.6 (CONTINUED) Examples of RP-TLC Lipophilicity Studies on Different Classes of Compounds (where r = Correlation Coefficient)
[264]
[252, 255]
[32, 262]
[212]
[261]
Ref.
138 Advances in Chromatography
silica gel 60 F254 silanized precoated plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) Chalcones and cyclic silanized silica gel 60 chalcone analogs F254 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) activated by washing with methanol, drying and heating at 106˚C for 1 hour Carbonyl derivatives 1-(1- silica gel RP-18 F254S arylimidazolin-2-yl)-3 (Merck Darmstadt, arylureas Germany) Estrane and secoestrane RP-18 silica gel F254 derivatives (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) 2-hydrazinothiazolic silica C8 plates F254 derivatives (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
β-blockers
75–90% (v/v) methanol in water
60–90% (v/v) methanol in 4% aqueous acetic acid methanol-water
acetonitrile (65/35 to 50/50, v/v) in 0.02 N ammonium acetate buffer (pH 7.4) 40–75% (v/v) methanol or acetone in water
0.999
> 0.99
0.992–0.999
> 0.99
0.900
[32, 262]
logPTLC = 3.394–5.193
0.930–0.937
logP values calculated with ACD/logP or with Rekker’s method. Although the chromatographic behavior is ideal, no direct correlation was found with biological activity.
[266]
Calculated logP (Rekker) [263]
[265]
logPo/w measured by shake-flask
0.996
0.992 (calibration compounds) 0.868
[252, 255]
Correlation with calculated values CLogP
0.960 for RM at 50% acetonitrile
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 139
Mobile Phase
40–80% (v/v) 0.969–0.998 (methanol) methanol in water; 30–70% (v/v) acetone 0.947-0.999 (acetone) in water
HPTLC plates RP-18 F254S (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
Maleic, succinic, and phthalic acid derivatives
> 0.98
methanol-water, methanol-glycine buffer pH 1.95, and methanol-glycine buffer pH 10
slurry of silica gel GF254 aqueous buffer alone, 0.941–0.999 obtained with 0.09 M saturated with HCl for pH 1.2 or with silicone, or mixed 0.36 M NaOH for pH with various amounts 9.0; the silica gel layer of acetone, methanol, was impregnated with or acetonitrile silicon DC 200 (Applied Science, State College, PA, USA)
Stationary Phase
N- and O-substituted silica gel RP-18 F254 alkanoic acids of 1,2plates (Merck, benzisothiazol-3(2H)-one Darmstadt, Germany)
Ionizable quinolines
Compounds
Linear Correlation RM – ϕ r 0.972 (acetonebuffer pH 9.0) 0.943 (methanolbuffer pH 9.0) 0.866 (acetonitrilebuffer pH 9.0) 0.960 (acetone-buffer pH 1.2) significant correlation for structurally different compounds
Linear Correlation RM0 – a1 r Tab 3-4
Comments
0.931 (methanol- logP values calculated buffer pH 1.95) Hyper Chem 5.0 Chem 0.879 (methanol- Plus 2.0 water) 0.893 (methanolbuffer pH 10)
Linear Correlation RM0 – logP r
TABLE 3.6 (CONTINUED) Examples of RP-TLC Lipophilicity Studies on Different Classes of Compounds (where r = Correlation Coefficient)
[268]
[267]
[243]
Ref.
140 Advances in Chromatography
Serotonergic ligands
Phenothiazine
glycine buffer at pH 9.0 0.999–0.829 alone or mixed with various amounts of acetone, methanol or acetonitrile 30–70% (v/v) acetoneglycine buffer pH 9.0
0.900
silica gel 60 F254 silanized precoated plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) Kieselguhr G or Kieselguhr G and cellulose impregnated with oleyl alcohol or liquid paraffin silica gel GF254 impregnated with silicone DC200 (350 CS) (Applied Science, State College, PA, USA) and C18 Whatman KC18F HPTLC plates
Phenothiazines
acetonitrile (65/35 to 50/50, v/v) in 0.02 N ammonium acetate buffer (pH 7.4) methanol-water
RP-18 F254S TLC plates methanol (25–65%, RM0 (95% (Merck Darmstadt, v/v), buffer and acetic confidence) = 1.613–2.508 Germany) acid mixtures
N-substituted amides of piperazine-hydroxybutyric acid
N-benzylamides of -(4RP-18 F254S TLC plates methanol (25–65%, RM0 (95% benzylpiperazine)-(Merck Darmstadt, v/v), buffer and acetic confidence) = 1.055–1.747 hydroxybutyric acid Germany) acid mixtures N-hydroxyethylamides of silica gel RP-8 F254 60–90% (v/v) aryloxyalkylene and methanol in water HPTLC plates pyridine carboxylic acids (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
0.928 (acetone) 0.946 (acetonitrile) 0.994 (methanol)
0.9994
0.922 (on silicone) 0.870 (on C18)
0.977
0.832 for RM at 50% acetonitrile
0.874
0.990–0.992
0.893
[213, 214]
[252, 255]
[269]
[179]
[269]
Correlation with [219] calculated values CLogP (QSAR Program Version 1.87, BioByte, Claremont, CA, 1994)
logP values calculated with Pallas (CompuDrug Chemistry Ltd., 1995) logP values calculated with Rekker’s method or from Pomona College database (Claremont, CA, USA) logP values calculated with PALLAS (CompuDrug Chemistry Ltd., 1995) Correlation with calculated values CLogP
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography 141
Xanthine and adenosine derivatives
Vinpocetine and related compounds
Thiazoles
Compounds
RP-HPTLC on Whatman KC18F plates
silica gel impregnated with silicone
homemade plates with silica gel 60 GF254, (Merck, Drmstadt, Germany) impregnated with paraffin oil silanized silica gel 60 F254 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany)
Stationary Phase
aqueous buffers alone or mixed with various amounts of acetone; glycine buffer pH 9.0 or sodium acetateVeronal buffer pH 7.0 methanol-phosphate buffer pH 7.0
4–34% (v/v) methanol; 0.999–0.951 4–24% (v/v) acetone; or 1–20% (v/v) dioxane in concentrated ammonia 35–65% (v/v) acetone 0.989–0.997 in 0.1 M NaOH
Mobile Phase
Linear Correlation RM – ϕ r
0.993
Linear Correlation RM0 – a1 r
0.952
0.935
0.997
0.830 (methanol) 0.956 (acetone) 0.945 (dioxane)
Linear Correlation RM0 – logP r
[244]
Ref.
CLogP values calculated with CLOGP Program, Version 3.42, Pomona College, Claremont, CA
The value r for the linear [246] correlation RM0 – a1 was obtained from data in Table 3.1 [48] CLogP values calculated [218] with CLOGP Program, Version 3.42, Pomona College, Claremont, CA
Comments
TABLE 3.6 (CONTINUED) Examples of RP-TLC Lipophilicity Studies on Different Classes of Compounds (where r = Correlation Coefficient)
142 Advances in Chromatography
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
143
TABLE 3.7 Ratios between Slopes in Different TLC Systems and Solvent Strength Ratio of Slopes a1 Compounds Steroids Prostaglandins Dermorphins Triazines Naphthalenes and quinoline Quinolones Mean
Ratio of Slopes b1
Acetone/ Acetonitrile
Acetone/ Methanol
1.12 1.07
1.70 1.67 1.36 1.37 1.53
1.52 1.56
0.91 0.83
1.33
0.94
1.13 1.09 ± 0.02
1.39 1.50 ± 0.06
1.22 1.41 ± 0.08
1.15
1/E0 1.70
1.47
1.03
Acetonitrile/ Acetone/ Methanol Acetonitrile
Acetone/ Methanol
Acetonitrile/ Methanol
0.59 0.71 0.82 0.63 0.71
0.65 0.86
0.87 0.89 ± 0.02
0.73 0.70 ± 0.03
0.84 0.76 ± 0.05
0.86
E0 0.59
0.68
0.68
Data from [215]
for all studied chemical series. Similar results were obtained for serotonergic ligands [219]. Also, the ratio between the slopes b1 (Equation 3.64) are in good agreement with the ratio between the E0 values for the same solvents. In particular, the ratios between the mean slopes of the TLC equations in different solvent systems are close to the ratios between the 1/E0 values from the corresponding solvent pairs, with the exception of the acetone system where the slopes seem to be lower than expected on the basis of the 1/E0 values. In fact, the acetone/methanol slope ratio (1.50) is lower than the corresponding reciprocal solvent strength ratio (1.70).
3.10.7 RM DETERMINATION AND CORRELATION COEFFICIENTS, LOGP
WITH
PARTITION
Determination of logP by TLC is based on the linear relationship between the chromatographic retention, RM and the octanol/water partition coefficient (logPo/w), usually determined by shake-flask for a set of reference compounds. Many studies exist in the literature reporting linear correlations between RM or RM0 and logP, either calculated or experimentally measured, for series of congeneric or structurally unrelated compounds. This approach was applied for the lipophilicity study of 17 compounds of 2methyl-4-oxo-3H-quinazoline-3-alkyl-carboxylic acid derivatives. Twelve standard compounds, five quizolones, and seven pyrido[1,2-a]pyrimidines, were selected to investigate the suitability of pyrido-pyrimidines as standards for the chromatographic logP determination of quizolones [245]. The logP values were measured by the shake-flask method at 25˚C in mutually saturated octanol and water phases. The pH was set to the isoelectric points for two compounds while the rest were measured at pH = 7.4. The concentrations of the compounds were measured by UV spectroscopy in aliquots taken from each phase.
144
Advances in Chromatography
Each logP value was obtained as an average of 12 parallel measurements. The RPTLC lipophilicity measurements were performed on silanized precoated plates with UV indicator (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and methanol-water (55:45, v/v) as mobile phase. Before applying the sample, the plates were washed in methanol, dried, and heated at 160˚C for one hour. Spot detection was done under a UV lamp or by densitometry. The seven pyrido-pyrimidines were selected as standards because their logP values have a wider range, from 0.21 to 2.08 log units (Equation 3.65): logPshake-flask = 1.18 + 3.77 RM, r = 0.996
(3.65)
The calibration for the complete set of 12 compounds is shown in Equation 3.66: logPshake-flask = 1.00 + 3.36 RM, r = 0.995
(3.66)
Equation 3.66 was used to estimate logP values of ten other compounds from the same series. The standard deviation on the measurement of all logPTLC values was ±0.06 log unit, generating an acceptable confidence range of ±0.05 for the logP values. Another recent publication used calibration methods to characterize lipophilicity of vinpocetine and related compounds by RP-TLC [246]. The RP-TLC experiments were carried out on silanized silica gel 60F254 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). The use of methanol was insufficient to move the highly lipophilic compounds from their starting point; therefore, 35 to 65% (v/v) acetone was chosen as the cosolvent. The investigated compounds were bases, so the aqueous part of the eluent was 0.1 M NaOH to maintain them in the unprotonated form. The spots were determined by densitometry at 279 nm. The partition coefficients were measurements by a stir-flask method in saturated octanol-water system at 25˚C. Concentration of compounds was determined in the aqueous phase by UV spectrometry at several values above 250 nm, before and after adding the octanol phase. Equation 3.67 was obtained for five pyrido[1,2-a]pirimidines used for the calibration set. logPshake-flask = 0.422 + 1.157 RM0, r = 0.995
(3.67)
The logPTLC and logPshake-flask values show a good agreement for chlorpromazine (3.54 and 3.75, respectively) and progesterone (5.13 and 5.07, respectively) and these compounds were added to the calibration set (Equation 3.68): logPshake-flask = 0.419 + 1.147 RM0, r= 0. 997
(3.68)
Equation 3.68 was used for the determination of logPTLC values of the eburnone alkaloids with values ranging from 2.94 to 4.85. Dross et al. used RP-18 F254S RP-TLC plates and various mixtures of methanolbuffer at pH = 7.0 with 0.1 M ionic strength in the mobile phase and obtained a reasonable correlation of the chromatographic data with logPo/w for 65 aromatic compounds [220] (Equation 3.69):
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
RM0 = 0.151 + 1.008 logPo/w, r = 0.970
145
(3.69)
These values have been analyzed by Abraham et al. [247] using linear free energy relationship analysis (LFER) for 76 compounds and obtaining Equation 3.70: RM0 = 0.259 + 0.239R2 – 0.662π2H – 0.666Σα2H – 3.006Σβ2O + 3.603Vx (3.70) n = 76, r = 0.9891, SD = 0.206 where the solute descriptors are R2, an excess molar refraction; π2H, the dipolarity/polarizability; α2H and β2O, the overall or effective hydrogen-bond acidity and basicity; and Vx, the McGowan characteristic volume (see related text on Abraham equation). The extrapolated RM0 values from aqueous methanol are well correlated with logPo/w, and the ratio of coefficients in the LFER equations for RM0 and logPo/w are very close. However, the correlations between TLC data and logPo/w for amines (especially heterocyclic) must be evaluated carefully before use for logPo/w predictions because of possible secondary equilibrium.
3.11 CHROMATOGRAPHIC DETERMINATION OF −LIPOPHILIC BALANCE HYDROPHILIC− The hydrophilic−lipophilic balance (HLB) is a valuable parameter for the classification of nonionic surfactants. It is possible to measure HLB values by the classic shake-flask method but chromatographic methods can overcome the practical problems of investigating surfactants in an aqueous environment. A number of publications have reported that the chromatographic parameter determined by RP-HPLC on C18 columns [248–250] or RP-TLC [223] extrapolated to 100% aqueous eluent can be considered a good predictor of the HLB value. RP-TLC was used for the determination of the HLB values of some polyethoxylated nonionic surfactants: (i) octylphenol and nonylphenol ethoxylated of increasing molar ratios of ethylene oxide, Triton X® and Triton N® series (from Rohm and Haas); and (ii) polyethoxyl lauryl, stearyl and oleyl ethers, Brij® (from ICI Americas) [251]. The HLB values of these surfactants were taken from literature. The RP-TLC experiments were performed on Nano-Sil-C18-100 UV254 plates (from Aldrich) at a constant temperature of 30˚C. The mobile phase was acetone–water for Triton® and tetrahydrofuran–water for Brij series. The retention was not significantly affected by adsorptive side effects due to free silanol groups. Good linear correlations were obtained for nine Triton products (Equation 3.71 and Equation 3.72) and for five Brij compounds: RM0 = 4.58 (± 0.08) – 0.07 (± 0.01) HLB, r = 0.991
(3.71)
RM0 = 3.49 (± 0.20) – 0.11 (± 0.02) HLB, r = 0.951
(3.72)
146
Advances in Chromatography
3.11.1 DRUG LIPOPHILICITY Mannhold et al. [252] investigated four groups of drugs: antiarhythmics (AA), βblockers (BB), phenothiazines (PT), and benzamides (BA). The calculation of octanol-water logP values was achieved by two approaches, the hydrophobic fragmental constant method of Rekker [253] and the computerized version of the Hansch procedure [254]. Calculated fragmental constants (Σf) and logP values (ClogP) for 48 test compounds were compared with the measured logP values. Differences up to 0.49 between the calculated and measured logP values were considered as acceptable (a), differences greater than 1.0 as unacceptable (b), and differences in between as disputable (c). The comparison of the two calculation procedures led to the following conclusions: 26 Σf values and 26 ClogP values fell in category (a); the Rekker system calculates 12 compounds in category (c) and 10 in category (b); the corresponding numbers in the ClogP system are 11 compounds in category (c) and 11 in (b). The measured logP values indicate significant variation in lipophilicity, AA > BB > BA > PT. Dross et al. studied the same four groups of drugs — 15 AA, 11 BB, 13 PT and 9 BA — by RP-TLC on silica gel 60 F254 silanized precoated plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and acetonitrile (65:35 to 50:50, v/v) in 0.02 N ammonium acetate buffer (pH = 7.4) as mobile phase [255]. The same authors published in a previous paper the logPobs, ClogP, and Σf values [252]. The logP* values were obtained from the Med Chem Data Base THOR. Equation 3.73 through Equation 3.76 are reported [255] for 48 compounds, except Equation 3.74, which was obtained for 24 compounds: RM0 = 0.682 + 0.214 logPobs,
r = 0.919
(3.73)
RM0 = 0.709 + 0.206 logP*,
r = 0.944
(3.74)
r = 915
(3.75)
RM0 = 0.585 + 0.210 Σf, RM0 = 0.814 + 0.174 ClogP,
r = 0.899
(3.76)
A simple correction for the mobile phase pH and the pKa constant of ionizable compounds could be misleading, especially when acetonitrile is present, because this solvent can significantly change the pH of the aqueous mixture. Repeating the correlations of the extrapolated and precisely pKa-corrected RM0 values for the four sets, the correlation between logP and RM0-corrected values worsens significantly. The authors concluded that the correction for pH for the partition of ionizable compounds is necessary only in the shake-flask procedure, where the complete equilibrium of ionized and unionized forms is fully achieved. Apparently, the correction is not necessary in TLC [255]. The retention of phenotiazines (Rf values) can be predicted using Equation 3.77 [214]:
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
Rf =
a0 + a1 ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦
147
(3.77)
1 + a0 + a1 ⎡⎣ H + ⎤⎦
where a0 = 1/(P r) and a1 = 1/(P r K). (P is the partition coefficient, r is the phase volume ratio — a constant for a defined chromatographic system — and K is the dissociation constant in methanol–water mixtures and depends on the solution concentration). The biological activity of 2-(aminoacetylamino)thiazole derivatives was correlated with the retention parameters obtained by RP-TLC on silica gel plates impregnated with liquid paraffin (Table 3.6) [256]. The dependent variable is the percent inhibition of carrageenin-induced edema in mice with the i.p. administration of 2.2 × 103 mmol/100 g body weight of the tested compounds (Equation 3.78): log % = –0.793 (± 0.596) – 1.518 (± 0.381) RM
(3.78)
n = 5, r 0.958, SD = 0.048, F = 33.43 The logP values for N-substituted amides of α-piperazine-γ-hydroxybutyric acid (A) and derivatives of N-benzylamides of α-(4-benzylpiperazine)-γ-hydroxybutyric acid (B) were calculated using the PrologP module of the PALLAS system (CompuDrug Chemistry Ltd., 1995). This program predicts the partition coefficient of the neutral species of compounds in octanol-water systems and PrologP has three fragment databases for calculating logP values. The obtained values are: logPCDR, logPATOMIC and logPcombined. The value of logPCDR is obtained with the CDR Database, based on Rekker’s collection of hydrophobic fragmental constants [270]. The value of logPATOMIC is calculated from atomic fragments and the combined logP values are obtained as the weighted average of values from the equation: logPcombined = Σ wi logPin
(3.79)
where wi the weight of database i and logPi the logP value predicted using database i. The logPcombined of the molecule is calculated as the sum of the contributions of fragments and interactions. The correlation between RM and the calculated data is given by Equation 3.80 and Equation 3.81 for amides in series A and B, respectively: RM0 = 0.708 + 0.746 logPcombined,
r = 0.893
(3.80)
RM0 = 0.408 + 0.626 logPcombined,
r = 0.874
(3.81)
The lipophilicity index (RM0) was determined by RP-TLC for - and -quinolinyl sulfides [271]. The silica gel 60 F254 (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) impregnated with paraffin oil was used as reversed-phase stationary phase and aqueous methanol (60 to 80% in steps of 5%, v/v) as mobile phase. The value of RM0 was extrapolated
148
Advances in Chromatography
for each compound for zero concentration of the methanol in the eluent. The results show that the introduction of a sulfide substituent significantly increases the lipophilicity of the compounds, changing the lipophilicity index RM0 from 0.51 to 0.92. N-hydroxyethylamides of aryloxyalkylene and pyridine carboxylic acids have shown growth-stimulating effect in the Moewus test with Lepidium stativum [272]. The lipophilicities of the compounds were investigated on C8 silica gel plates with methanol-water mixtures as mobile phase (Table 3.6). A very good linearity was obtained for RM – ϕ, RM – a1 and RM0 – logP correlations, showing that the studied compounds are congeneric. The lipophilicity of aniline and 36 ring-substituted aniline derivatives was determined by RP-TLC in the presence of different salts on silica gel impregnated with NaCl, KCl, MgCl2, CaCl2, AlCl3 , and tetramethylammonium hydroxide or with these salts added to the eluent [273]. The plates were impregnated by immersing them in a solution of 5% paraffin oil in n-hexane. The mobile phase was water–methanol (4:1, v/v) with or without the presence of salts. In most cases, the salts decreased the retention power of silica, resulting in increased mobility of aniline derivatives. The monovalent cations had the lowest impact on selectivity while AlCl3 and tetramethylammonium hydroxide had the highest. The correlation between RM values and logPo/w (calculated, Hansch method [65]) was better in all cases in salt-free systems. The lipophilicity of 1,2-benzisothiazol-3(2H)-ones was investigated by RP-TLC but, in this case, the correlation with logPo/w was not relevant as the purpose of the study was to determine a lipophilicity scale [264]. The correlations between the extrapolated RM0 values for the three chromatographic systems are shown in Table 3.6 with slope and intercept close to 1 and 0, respectively, and are described by Equation 3.82 and Equation 3.83: RM0,acetone = 1.114 RM0,acetonitrile – 0.174, r = 0.983
(3.82)
RM0,methanol = 1.210 RM0,acetone – 0.236, r = 0.998
(3.83)
3.11.2 MISCELLANEOUS The measurement of the RM values of a series of triazine herbicides was performed by RP-TLC on silica gel impregnated with silicone [274]. Acetone, methanol, or acetonitrile were used as organic modifier of the mobile phase. The influence of the organic solvent on RM values and composition of the mobile phase was investigated. The RM values of twelve colchicines and eight colchiceinamides were determined using RP-TLC on silica gel impregnated with 5% liquid paraffin [275]. The RM0 values were calculated by extrapolation from the linear range of a plot of RM values vs. the composition of the mobile phase, ϕ. In the colchicine series, substitution at the nitrogen in position C7 decreased the lipophilicity, whereas in the colchiceinamide series, substitution at nitrogen in position C10 increased the lipophilicity. The influence of the substituent groups on RM values was also discussed. Other RP-TLC applications in lipophilicity studies include a new group of 2,4dihydroxythiobenzanilides with fungistatic activity [276]; coumarine derivatives
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
149
designed as possible anti-inflammatory/antioxidant agents [277]; only a poor relationship exists between lipophilicity and anti-inflammatory activity; derivatives of the phenyl glycine octal ester [278]; good correlation of RM0-calculated logP but a poor relationship between the lipophilicity and the anti-inflammatory activity; nonionic surfactants [279, 280]; good linear correlation between RM0 values and the specific hydrophobic surface, so these surfactants can be considered as a homologous series of solutes independently of their structural inhomogeneity; 2-cyano-3-methylthio-3-substituted amine-acrylates [281]; and piperazine derivatives [282].
3.11.3 STUDIES
USING
BOTH RP-HPLC
AND
RP-HPTLC
Arylalkanoic acids (arylacetic acids, aryloxobutanoic acids and cinnamic acids) were analysed on two columns: μBondapak (Waters, C18, 30 cm × 3.9 mm I.D.) and 5 μm Spherisorb ODS (custom, 25 cm × 3.9 mm I.D.). The flow rate was 1 mL/min in all cases and the mobile phase was a mixture of phosphate buffer (pH = 3.0) and methanol in various ratios. The correlation coefficient for logP vs. logk50 and logkw varied in the range 0.980 to 0.996 [283]. The slopes (s) above have very different values for the correlations logP vs. RM and logP vs. RM0, suggesting that the slope is dependent on the strength of the organic modifier and on the nature of the solutes (Table 3.8). The slopes (a) of the linear relationships between RM and the concentration of organic modifier in the mobile phase correlate well with logP values. The same situation is true when comparing the chromatographic parameters RM0, logk, RM , or logkw at a defined mobile phase composition with the slope, a. These correlations, with a very good statistical significance, may introduce a new parameter for lipophilicity estimations. The lipophilicity of -carbolines was analyzed by RP-TLC and RP-HPLC and the chromatographic parameters compared with logP values. In the RP-TLC experiments, silica gel G was impregnated with silicone G by developing the plates in 5% silicone solution in diethyl ether, and the mobile phase was a glycine buffer (pH = 13.0, aqueous or mixed with various amounts of acetone) and saturated with silicone. The investigated compounds were assumed nonionized at pH = 13.0. The HPTLC experiments were performed on Whatman KC 18F plates with 45 to 80% (v/v) methanol in phosphate buffer (pH = 7.0). RP-HPLC was done on a μBondapack C18 column (30 cm × 3.9 mm I.D.) (Waters, Milford, MA, USA) and the mobile phase was 20 to 80% (v/v) methanol in phosphate buffer (pH = 7.0) at a flow rate of 1 mL/min. The RM values obtained by TLC correlated well with logP values, with r = 0.952 and an intercept close to zero. Worse correlations were obtained for RM(TLC) vs. RM(HPTLC) with r = 0.793 and for RM(TLC) vs. logk with r = 0.841. Intercept values for the latter equations were quite far from zero, indicating systematic errors. A significant correlation was found between RM, logk or logP and receptor binding affinity. One of the influencing factors could be the same pH (7.0) in all experiments [284]. TLC and RP-HPLC lipophilicity studies for cardiac glycosides and digitalis were reported by Biagi, et al. [285] The TLC experiments were performed on silica gel
Stationary Phase Mobile Phase
r for logP r for logP vs. RM0 vs. RM TLC
r = correlation coefficient s = the slope of RM vs. ϕ a = slope of RM vs. ϕ ϕ = organic modifier concentration in the mobile phase Data from [283]
0.992 0.995 r = 0.996 (s = 0.108) (s = 0.081) for logP vs. slope a (TLC exp) 0.987 (s = 0.968 (s = r = 0.951 0.211) for logP vs. slope 0.137) a (TLC exp) Cinnamic acids acetone in buffer 0.993 (s = 0.989 (s = r = 0.983 0.157) for logP vs. slope (pH 3.4) 0.122) a (TLC exp) 16-Φ substituted estra- silanized silicagel acetone-water r = 0.950–0.988 1,3,5(10)-trienes for RM vs. a Androstane-type silica gel G layer impregnated with silicone oil acetone-water r = 0.995–0.971 steroids for RM vs. a Benzodiazepine Silicoplat F254 impregnated with paraffin oil acetonitrile-phosphate r = 0.951 for RM derivatives buffer pH 4.6 vs. a Dermorphine-related r = 0.921–0.987 silica gel G impregnated with silicone oil methanol-aqueous derivatives for RM vs. a buffer pH 7.0 Dansylamides
silanized Kieselgel 60 F254 plates (E. Merck, acetone in buffer Darmstadt, Germany) impregnated with 5% (pH 3.4) ethereal solution of silicone oil Aryloxobutanoic acids acetone in buffer (pH 3.4)
Aryl acetic acids
Compound
TABLE 3.8 Comparison of Lipophilcity Studies by TLC and HPLC
r = 0.975–0.999 for logkw vs. a r = 0.925–0.997 for logk vs. a
r = 0.971 for logP vs. slope a (HPLC exp)
r = 0.929 for logP vs. slope a (HPLC exp)
r = 0.984 for logP vs. slope a (HPLC exp)
HPLC
150 Advances in Chromatography
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
151
G impregnated with silicone (prepared by developing the plates in 5% silicone solution in diethyl ether) and the mobile phase was aqueous buffer (sodium acetateVeronal buffer, pH = 7.2) alone or with various concentrations of acetone presaturated with silicone oil. RP-HPLC was done on μBondapack C18 column (10 μm particle size, 30 cm × 3.9 mm I.D.) (Waters, Milford, MA) and mobile phase was 20 to 70% acetonitrile in water at a flow rate of 1 mL/min. RM0 values were measured and calculated for a range of the most hydrophilic cardiac glycosides. The experimental values showed that the extrapolation procedure from a range of RM values obtained at different mobile phase compositions to 0% organic modifier provides the same value as the experimental RM0 value. The extrapolated RM0 values were obtained for the studied cardiac glycosides from digitalis by extrapolating the RM values determined with acetone concentrations ranging from 0 to 24%, or from around 40 to around 60% depending on the lipophilicity of the compounds. The logP values, RM0 and logk from three laboratories were in good agreement with each other (r = 0.914 to 0.964), showing that the chromatographic retention data was a good lipophilicity index for the studied compounds [285]. A similar study was performed for series of benzodiazepines on LiChrosorb RPC18 column (250 × 4.6 mm I.D.), with 30 to 70% (v/v) acetonitrile in phosphate buffer (pH = 4.8) for the RP-HPLC experiments. Values of logk and logkw were used for lipophilicity correlations and for comparison with the RM values obtained by RP-TLC on Silcoplat F254 plates (Labor-MIM) impregnated with paraffin oil with mobile phase 0 to 32.5% acetonitrile in phosphate buffer (pH = 4.8) [286]. The equation: RM = RM0 + b1 C1 + b2 logC2
(3.84)
was determined for the studied benzodiazepines, where C1 and C2 are acetonitrile and buffer concentrations in the mobile phase and b1 and b2 are constants. The buffer concentrations (C2) were 6, 12, 30, 60, and 90 mM KH2PO4. The correlation coefficients for the above equation were r2 = 0.917 to 0.984 for 18 benzodiazepines. Retention was shown to decrease with increasing acetonitrile and buffer concentrations but the impact of the acetontrile concentration is six to nine times higher than that of the buffer concentration. There is a significant correlation between logkw and RM0, expressed by the equation: logkw = c1 + c2 RM0 + c3 b1 + c4 b2, r2 = 0.7492
(3.85)
where RM0, b1 and b2 are constants and c1 through c4 are equation coefficients. Although the correlation coefficient r2 has a good value, the retention in RP-HPLC still cannot be predicted from the chromatographic parameters in RP-TLC. One explanation for this discrepancy may be that the stationary phase is covered differently in HPLC and TLC experiments, resulting in different responses of the chromatographic system to the changes in the concentration of the organic modifier in the mobile phase. Principal component analysis (PCA) of the data obtained from
152
Advances in Chromatography
the two chromatographic systems showed that the retention mechanisms in RP-TLC and RP-HPLC are similar but not identical. The lipophilicity of aromatic alkoxy and hydroxyl acids was analyzed on RP18 F254 TLC plates (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and on Nucleosil C18 columns (5 μm, 200 × 4 mm) by RP-HPLC. The mobile phase was 20 to 45% (v/v) acetonitrile or 40 to 90% (v/v) methanol in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH = 2) [287]. The extrapolated retention parameters for 0% organic modifier in the mobile phase, RM0 and logkw, were different in most cases for methanol and acetonitrile. However, a very good correlation was observed between the retention parameters obtained for methanol and those obtained for acetonitrile (ACN), making the conversion of data obtained in one chromatographic system to the other possible: RM0,methanol = 1.115 RM0,ACN + 0.147,
r = 0.913
logkw,methanol = 0.968 logkw,ACN + 0.241,
r = 0.938
(3.86) (3.87)
While in most cases the expected contribution of different substituents (e.g., hydroxyl) was observed, the influence of the methoxy group was not very clear. In RP-HPLC experiments, retention increased or decreased according to the position of the methoxy group in the molecule. However, this effect was not observed in the RP-TLC experiments, suggesting that steric effects are more important in HPLC than in TLC. Taking into account the data reported in the above mentioned work, the following equations have been derived: logkw,methanol = 0.364 + 0.789 RM0,methanol, logkw,ACN = 0.193 + 0.967 RM0,ACN,
r2 = 0.978
r2 = 0.951
(3.88) (3.89)
The good correlations suggest that retention parameters can be predicted for the studied compounds on the RP-HPLC system from the retention in a RP-TLC experiment. Different flavonoid compounds were used to investigate the correlation and repeatability between TLC and HPLC experiments, taking into consideration different TLC layers from different manufacturers, different solvent volume fraction, different organic modifiers in the mobile phase and different acid modifiers with the same solvent [288]. The TLC experiments were performed on three different reversed-phase C18 precoated layers: TLC KC18F (Whatman, Clifton, NJ), TLC precoated plates RP-18 F254S (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), and HPTLC precoated RP-18W F254S (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany); the mobile phase was methanol, acetonitrile, and THF in binary mixtures with aqueous buffer with pH from 2 to 3 (80 mM citric or acetic acid, 8 mM sodium disodium hydrogenphosphate). The TLC retention data were compared with the HPLC experiments performed on a μBondapack C18 column (Waters, Milford, MA). The correlations logk vs. RM are very good for the RP-HPLC and RP-TLC systems with slopes close to 1 and almost constant and intercept values close to 0
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
153
(0.20) when methanol is the organic modifier. No other plate-solvent combination gives the same result; this fact reflects that the TLC system is more suitable to model HPLC experiments than the HPTLC plates for mobile phases consisting of methanolbuffer mixtures. The Δlogk and ΔRM values were also investigated in an attempt to explain different molecule behavior. In the HPLC system with methanol in the mobile phase, the group contributions were independent of the mobile phase composition, column type, and acid modifier. The retention data from TLC and HPTLC experiments agreed with these findings. A general agreement between the HPLC and TLC data was also found for THF and acetonitrile as organic modifiers in the mobile phase. For some substituent contributions, a parallel behavior between Δlogk and ΔRM values was observed while for others, the steric effect was not so clear, probably due to secondary polarity and composition gradient effects from the chromatographic system. The fact that TLC models HPLC experiments well makes it a good method due to the possibility of enhancing the peak capacity through bi-dimensional development. Compounds of 1,2,4-triazoles are known to be biologically active with pronounced antimicrobial activity and these compounds have various applications as herbicides and fungicides [289]. HPLC experiments used LiChrosorb RP-8 column (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany; 5 μm, 150 × 4.6 mm I.D.). The mobile phases were binary mixtures of methanol-water and acetonitrile-water containing 10 to 60% (v/v) organic modifier. Values of logkw values were obtained, then the isocratic chromatographic hydrophobicity index (ϕ0) was calculated as the ratio between the intercept (logkw) and the slope, S: ϕ0 = –logkw/S
(3.90)
The parameter ϕ0 is characteristic for every compound and is independent of the reversed phase column used, column length, flow rate, and the mobile phase composition. The TLC experiments used a stationary phase of silica gel impregnated with paraffin oil. The silica gel powder was mixed with a solution of paraffin oil in diethyl ether (3.5%, v/v), then a fluorescent indicator F254 was added and the layer spread on glass plates. The newly prepared plates were left to dry at room temperature, then used for the experiments. The mobile phase was 20 to 60% methanol in water. A reasonably good correlation was found between the chromatographic parameters obtained by the two methods: logkw = 1.69 RM0 – 0.023, r = 0.938
(3.91)
A good correlation was also obtained between logkw values and calculated logP values (ACD software), with correlation coefficients in the range 0.945 to 0.996 for both solvent systems. The correlations between the isocratic chromatographic index and logP were of the same quality for methanol and acetonitrile in the mobile phase with r = 0.928 to 0.986. Similar research work and good correlations between the chromatographic parameters obtained in RP-TLC and RP-HPLC have been reported
154
Advances in Chromatography
for 2,4-dihydroxythiobenzanilides (potential fungicides) [290] and for N-alkylamides of benzomorpholine-2-carboxylic acid [291]. A comprehensive study has taken into consideration extensive published chromatographic parameters for β-lactam antibiotics in an attempt to find a unified hydrophobicity scale [292]. Although it is convenient to compare the large amount of chromatographic data from literature available for antibiotics with the partition in octanol-water, poor correlations seem to be previously obtained due to the selfassociation of β-lactam antibiotics in hydrophilic media. An independent hydrophobicity scale would be based on a linear relationship between the free energy of partitioning in organic-water systems, ΔGi = αΔGj + β
(3.92)
where ΔGi(j) is the free energy of solute transition from water to organic phase i (or j). The value ΔGi(j) is also proportional with the partition coefficient (logP) and with the retention parameters in chromatographic systems, logk or RM (from different experimental conditions reported in the literature). The slope, intercept, and correlation coefficients were reported for Equation 3.92 when one of the variables was an experimentally determined value (logP, logk, RM) and the other variable was calculated for the hydrophobicity scale of six penicillins. The correlation coefficients were in the range 0.98 to 0.99 in most cases, although some significant outliers are also present [292].
3.12 OTHER CHROMATOGRAPHIC METHODS 3.12.1 MICELLAR LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY (MLC) Micellar liquid chromatography (MLC) is a form of liquid chromatography where the mobile phase is enriched in a compound above its critical micellar concentration (CMC). The migration of a compound in an MLC system is based on a competing partitioning between the aqueous mobile phase and the micelles and the aqueous mobile phase and the alkyl-bonded stationary phase [293]. Details about calculating the partition coefficient in MLC can be found in Khaledi and Breyer [294]. A linear relationship exists between the retention factor in MLC and the micelle concentration; therefore, the partition of a compound between the aqueous phase and the micelles can be easily determined. Good correlations between the MLC retention factor (logk) and experimental logP values were reported for various compounds on C8 and phenyl columns with CTAB micellar system [294], for β-adrenolytic drugs with SDS micellar system and n-propanol as organic modifier [295] and for barbiturates with Brij35 as micellar system [296]. Micelle formation as a form of solute self-association is not desirable as it will lower the partition coefficient and experiments should be done at concentrations lower than the critical micelle concentrations. However, micelles can be formed intentionally in the mobile phase as a different media into which the solute could partition.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
155
The micelle–water partition coefficient has been measured with an HPLC system but the peaks obtained can be quite broad [297]. Fluoroquinolones were measured by this method on Bondapack C18 columns with an isocratic mobile phase, methanol-water (1:1, v/v), 25 mM phosphate buffer (pH = 2.75), and 1 mM sodium heptanesulphonate as the micelle formation agent [298]. A Spherisorb C8 column was used for benzene derivatives and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons with sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) and cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) for the micelle formation in the concentration 0.05 to 0.14 M. The micellar phase was modified with 3, 5, or 10% of an alcohol (methanol, n-propanol, and n-butanol were tested). The correlation between k vs. logP seems better than logk vs. logP and both methods should be applied [299]. The column efficiency in MLC is inferior to hydroorganic systems and deteriorates as the hydrophobicity of solutes increases [300, 301]. Although “chromatography” is included in the name, other methods are not forms of liquid chromatography but of capillary electrophoresis. MEKC is a modified capillary electrophoresis method that allows the separation of neutral and ionized compounds due to a micellar phase added to the electrolyte, while MEEKC uses a microemulsion in the electrolyte formed by a water-immiscible solvent (e.g., heptane). Both methods use a dual system for the separation, one electrophoretic (electrolyte in an electric field) and the other chromatographic-like (the solute partition between the aqueous electrolyte bulk and the micelle or microemulsion phase). Lipophilicity estimations are possible in MEKC and MEEKC due to the chromatographic component of the migration process and good correlations have been reported between the retention parameter and logP values. However, these methods will not be discussed in this chapter. Details about these methods can be found in Poole and Poole [6].
3.12.2 REVERSED-PHASE ION PAIR CHROMATOGRAPHY (RP-IPC) The lipophilicity of 21 aminoaryl sulphonic acids was studied by RP-HPLC and RP-IPC. The experiments were performed on reversed-phase packing material, Polygosil-ODS, and Spherisorb-ODS. The mobile phase used in RP-HPLC was 10 mM phosphate buffer, while the mobile phase used in the RP-IPC experiments was methanol-water at different ratios with 4 mM tetrabutylammonium iodide, an ionpairing agent. The pH was roughly 7.0 for all experiments. The correlations between logk values and logPo/w in the presence of the ion-pairing agent were much better (r = 0.995) than those obtained by RP-HPLC (r = 0.911). Some organic modifiers in the aqueous mobile phase in the RP-HPLC experiments could be argued as having improved the correlations, but this situation was not investigated [302]. Similar results were reported for the same ion-pairing agent, tetrabutylammonium iodide, but for a series of phenylamine and naphtylamine sulphonic acids [303]. The method is interesting but has poor reproducibility [298, 303].
156
Advances in Chromatography
3.12.3 COUNTERCURRENT CHROMATOGRAPHY (CCC) Countercurrent chromatography (CCC) is an interesting separation method derived from two classical partition methods, countercurrent distribution (CCD) and liquid chromatography (LC). CCC does not use a solid support and is a form of liquidliquid chromatography. Droplets of a liquid mobile phase are forced to flow through an immiscible liquid stationary phase and a large contact interface is formed between the two phases. Centrifugal CCC brings the benefit of rotation forces, making possible applications in analytical or preparative scale [304–306]. If octanol is the stationary phase and water the mobile phase, the P/logP values are obtained directly from the compound retention and no correlation is used. A measurable logP range from 2.0 to 2.3 can be obtained by modifying the ratio of stationary and mobile phase volumes. The extension of the measurable logP range up to 4.5 is possible by modifying the octanol phase with mixtures of hexane, acetonitrile, cyclohexane, chloroform, or methanol. In this case, a correlation to the true logPo/w must be introduced. Very lipophilic compounds can also be measured by the same method by reversing the role of the phases, using water as a stationary phase and octanol as a mobile phase; however, this method brings larger errors [307]. Centrifugal partition chromatography (CPC) can be used for the determination of logPo/w coefficients if octanol and water are employed as the two immiscible liquid phases. However, for accurate logPo/w estimations, the chromatographic system must be in equilibrium and the chromatographic relationships between the retention factor and the mobile phase volume must be proved true. In many cases, the latter condition has been difficult to demonstrate. CPC uses a direct measurement where the aqueous stationary phase is placed in a coil and droplets of octanol flow through the coil. The compounds are injected and the UV absorbance is detected at the coil exit. The coil rotates at over 700 rpm, the flow rate is usually around 4 mL/min and the base line stabilizes in 30 minutes. In its normal mode, CPC can measure logPo/w in the range 0.5 to 2.5. In its dual mode, the flow direction is changed from descending to ascending after a predetermined time. The compounds are injected in the system as solutions in octanol and are then eluted in octanol without having to spend a long time in the column. The measurable logPo/w range is extended to 4.1 in dual mode CPC, although errors can be introduced due to the change in the flow direction and possible leaks [308]. Cocurrent chromatography was introduced in an attempt to solve the high retention of very lipophilic compounds and their tendency of staying too long in the column, trapped in the stationary phase. In this method, two immiscible mobile phases flow in the same direction, octanol with a small flow and water with a high flow, until the retained compound exits the column. The cocurrent mode is especially useful for lipophilic compounds with logPo/w > 3. The technique appeared promising but it generates a large amount of effluent that cannot be recycled due to mixing with a common solvent for detection, a serious drawback [309]. Although CPC has the potential of measuring true logPo/w, the technique was not widely used due to technical difficulties and ambiguous data interpretation. The counter-current methods are difficult to operate, the instrumentation is difficult to clean, requires skilled operators, uses large quantities of solvents and applies to a
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
157
limited logP range. Details about partitioning in octanol or liposomes can be found in a recent publication [310].
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are grateful to our colleagues at Sirius who provided support with data and figures and who showed patience during the busy editing time. We also thank Klara Valkó (GlaxoSmithKline, U.K.), Michal Markuszewski (Medical University of Gdansk, Poland) and Rebeca Ruiz (University of Barcelona, Spain) for support. We are grateful to Henk Claessens (Technical University Eindhoven, Netherlands) for kindly guiding the steps through the Ph.D. thesis.
GLOSSARY CCC CPC CTAB D
E0 end-capping ΔG HPLC HPTLC K isocratic isoeluotropic logk logkw logk50 logP
logD logPo/w MEEKC MEKC MLC MOPS
countercurrent chromatography centrifugal partition chromatography cetyltrimethylammonium bromide distribution coefficient, defined as the ratio of concentrations of all species of a solute dissolved in each phase of a system consisting of two separate phases at equilibrium at a particular pH. solvent strength chemical reaction between the free silanol groups and a low reactivity substance free energy high-performance liquid chromatography high-performance thin-layer chromatography partition coefficient between any immiscible phases (equivalent to P for octanol-water systems) same mobile phase composition throughout the experiment mobile phases with different composition but with the same elution power retention (or capacity) factor in chromatography isocratic retention factor when the mobile phase is purely aqueous isocratic retention factor when the mobile phase contains 50% (v/v) organic modifier logarithm of the partition coefficient (P), defined as the ratio of concentrations of a solute dissolved in each phase of a system consisting of two separate phases at equilibrium at a pH where the solute is unionized log10 of D log10 of P microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography micellar electrokinetic chromatography micellar liquid chromatography 4-morpholinepropanesulfonic acid
158
Advances in Chromatography
octanol ODS P Po/w r r2 RM RM0 RP-HPLC RP-IPC RP-HPTLC SDS X ϕ ϕ0
n-octanol octadecylsilane partition coefficient between two immiscible (liquid) phases; refers to the neutral form of the molecule partition coefficient between n-octanol and water (or aqueous buffer) correlation coeffcient square of the correlation coeffcieint (r and r2 were kept in the text according to the published data from the references) retention in thin layer chromatography RM value when the mobile phase is purely aqueous reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography reversed-phase ion pair chromatography reversed-phase high-performance thin-layer chromatography sodium dodecyl sulphate fraction of the organic modifier in the mobile phase concentration of the organic modifier in the aqueous mobile phase isocratic hydrophobicity index measured by RP-HPLC
REFERENCES 1. Kaliszan, R. Effect of separation conditions on chromatographic determination of hydrophobicity of acid xenobiotics. J. Chromatogr. B, 1998, 717, 125–134. 2 Valkó, K. Application of high-performance liquid chromatography based on measurements of lipophilicity to model biological distribution. J. Chromatogr A, 2004, 1037, 299–310. 3 Valkó, K., Nunhuck, S., Bevan, C., Abraham M.H. and Reynolds, D.P. Fast gradient HPLC method to determine compounds binding to human serum albumin. Relationships with octanol/water and immobilized artificial membrane lipophilcity. J. Pharm. Sci., 2003, 92, 2236–2248. 4. Abraham, M.H., Gola, J.M.R., Kumarsingh, R., Cometto-Muniz, J.E. and Cain, W.S. Connection between chromatographic data and biological data. J. Chromatogr. B, 2000, 745, 103–115. 5. Mannhold, R., Kubinyi, H. and Timmerman, H., eds. Lipophilicity in drug action and toxicology. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 4, VCH, Weinheim, 1996. 6. Poole, S.K. and Poole, C.F. Separation methods for estimating octanol-water partition coefficients. J. Chromatogr. B, 2003, 797, 3–19. ˇ V., Testa, B. and van de Waterbeemd, H. Lipophilicity, the empirical tool and 7. Pliska, the fundamental objective: An introduction. Lipophilicty in drug action and toxicology. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 4, VCH, Weinheim-New York, 1996, 1–5. 8. http://www.iupac.org. 9. Mayer, H. Zur Theorie der Alkoholnarkose I. Welche Eigenschaft der Anaesthetika bedingt ihre narkotische Wirkung? Archiv f. Experimentelle Pathologie un Pharmakologie, 1899, 42, 109–118.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
159
10. Overton, E. Studien ber die Narkose, zugleich ein Beitrag zur allgemeinen Pharmakologie, Gustav Fischer. Jena, Switzerland, 1901. 11. Yalkowsky, S.H. and Banerjee, S. Methods of estimation for organic compounds. Aqueous Solubility, Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1991. 12. Cimpan, G. The lipophilicity characterization of some groups of organic compounds by reversed-phase partition chromatography. Ph.D. thesis, 1997. 13. Lyman, W.J., Reehl, W.F. and Rosenblatt, D.H. Handbook of Chemical Property Estimation Methods, McGraw-Hill, New York, Chs. 1, 2, and 4, 1982. 14. Noble, A. Partition coefficients (n-octanol-water) for pesticides. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 642, 3–14. 15. Lombardo, F., Shalaeva, M.Y., Tupper, K.A., Gao, F. and Abraham, M.H. ELogPoct: A tool for lipophilicity estimation in drug discovery. J. Med. Chem., 2000, 43, 2922–2928. 16. Lipinski, C.A., Lombardo, F., Dominy, B.W. and Feeny, P.J. Experimental and computational approaches to estimate solubility and permeability in drug discovery and development settings. Adv. Drug Delivey, 1997, 23, 3–25. 17. Comenarejo, G., Alvarez-Pedraglio, A. and Lavandera, J.-L. Cheminformatic models to predict binding affinities to human serum albumin. J. Med. Chem., 2001, 44, 4370–4378. 18. Camenish, G., Folkers, G. and van de Waterbeemd, H. Review of theoretical passive drug absorption models: Historical background, recent developments and limitations. Pharm. Acta Helv., 1996, 71, 309–327. 19. van de Waterbeemd, H., Smith, D.A. and Jones, B.C. Lipophilicity in PK design: Methyl, ethyl, futile. J. Comp.-Aided Mol. Des., 2001, 15, 273–286. 20. OECD Guidelines for Testing of Chemicals. Vol. 117, Partition coefficient (noctanol/water). High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) Method, OECD, Paris, 1989. 21. Harnish, M., Möckel, H.J. and Schultze, G. Relationship between logPow, shake-flask values and capacity factors derived from reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography for n-alkylbenzenes and some OECD reference substances. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 282, 315–332. 22. Nernst, W. Verteilung eines Stoffes zwischen zwei Lösungsmitteln und zwischen Lösungsmitteln und Dampfraum. Z. Phys. Chem., 1891, 8, 110–139. 23. http://www.nernst.de. 24. Leo, A., Hansch, C. and Elkins, D. Partition coefficients and their uses. Chem. Rev., 1971, 71, 525–616. 25. Hansch, C. and Leo, A. Substituent Constants for Correlation Analysis in Chemistry and Biology. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1979. 26. Takács-Novák, K., Szász, Gy., Budvári-Bárány, Zs., Józan, M. and Lre, A. Relationship study between reversed phase HPLC retention and octanol/water partition among amphoteric compounds. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1995, 18, 807–825. 27. Comer, J. and Tam, K. Lipophilicity profiles: Theory and measurement. Pharmacokinetic Optimisation in Drug Research, Wiley-VCH, 2001, 275–304. 28. Strong, L.E., Brummel, C.L., Ryther, R., Radford, J.R. and Pethybridge, A.D. Dimerization of some substituted benzoic acids in aqueous solution from conductance measurements. J. Solution Chemistry, 1988, 17, 1145–1167. 29. Faller, B. and Wohnsland, F. Physicochemical parameters as tools in drug discovery and lead optimization. Pharmacokinetic Optimisation in Drug Research, Wiley-VCH, 2001, 258–273.
160
Advances in Chromatography
30. Hansch, C. and Fujita, T. ρ-σ-π Analysis: A method for the correlation of biological activity and chemical structure. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1964, 86, 1616–1626. 31. Fujita, T., Iwasa, J. and Hansch, C. A new substituent constant, π, derived from partition coefficients. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1964, 86, 5175–5180. 32. Hansch, C. and Leo, A. Exploring QSAR-Fundamentals and Applications in Chemistry and Biology. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, 1995, 97–543. 33. Leo, A., Hansch, C. and Church, C. Comparison of parameters currently used in the study of structure-activity relationships. J. Med. Chem., 1969, 12, 766–771. 34. Taylor, P.C. Hydrophobic Properties of Drugs, Comprehensive Medicinal Chemistry: The Rational Design, Mechanistic Study and Therapeutic Application of Chemical Compounds. Pergamon Press, New York, 1990, 241–294. 35. Tsai, R.-S., Fan, W., El Tayar, N., Carrupt, P.-A., Testa, B. and Kier, L.B. Solutewater interactions in the organic phase of a biphasic system. 1. Structural influence of organic solutes on the “water-dragging” effect. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1993, 115, 9632–9639. 36. Fan, W., Tsai, R.-S., El Tayar, N., Carrupt, P.-A. and Testa, B. Solute-water interactions in the organic phase of a biphasic system. 2. Effects of organic phase and temperature on the “water-dragging” effect. J. Phys. Chem., 1994, 98, 329–333. 37. Tute, M.S. Lipophilicity: A history. Lipophilicity in drug action and toxicology. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 4, VCH, Weinheim 1996, 7–26. 38. van de Waterbeemd, H. and Manhold, R. Lipophilicity descriptors for structureproperty correlation studies: Overview of experimental and theoretical methods and a benchmark of logP calculations. Lipophilicity in drug action and toxicology. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 4, VCH, Weinheim 1996, 401–418. 39. Gaudette, L.E. and Brodie, B.B. Relationship between the lipid solubility of drugs and their oxidation by liver microsomes. Biochem. Pharmacol., 1959, 2, 89–96. 40. Leahy, D.E., Taylor, P.J. and Wait, A.R. Model solvent systems for QSAR. Part I. Propylene glycol depelargonate (PGDP). A new standard solvent for use in partition coefficient determination. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1989, 8, 17–31. 41. Abraham, M.H., Chada, H.S. and Mitchell, R.C. Hydrogen bonding. 33. Factors that influence the distribution of solutes between blood and brain. J. Pharm. Sci., 1994, 83, 1257–1268. 42. Leahy, D.E., Morris, J.J., Taylor, P.J. and Wait, A.R. Model Solvent system for QSAR. Part 2. Fragment values (F-values) for the critical quartet. J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans., 1992, 2, 723–731. 43. Buchwald, P. and Bodor, N. Octanol-water partition: Searching for predictive models. Curr. Med. Chem., 1998, 5, 353–380. 44. Leo, A.J. Calculating logPoct from structures. Chem. Rev., 1993, 93, 1281–1306. 45. Hansch, C., Maloney, P.P., Fujita, T. and Muir, R.M. Correlation of biological activity of phenoxyacetic acids with hammett substituent constants and partition coefficients. Nature, 1962, 194, 178–180. 46. Hansch, C., Muir, R.M., Fujita, T., Maloney, P.P., Geiger, F. and Streich, M. The correlation of biological activity of plant growth regulators and chloromycetin derivatives with hammett constants and partition coefficients. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1963, 85, 2817–2824. 47. Rekker, R.F. and Manhold, R. Calculation of drug lipophilicity. The Hydrophobic Fragmental Constant Approach, VCH, Weinheim, 1992. 48. Dross, K.P. and Rekker, R.F. Drug lipophilicity in QSAR practice. I. A comparison of experimental with calculative approaches. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1990, 9, 21–28.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
161
49. Viswanadhan, V.N., Ghose, A.K., Revankar, G.R. and Robins, R.K. Atomic physicochemical parameters for three dimensional structure directed quantitative structureactivity relationships. 4. Additional parameters for hydrophobic and dispersive interactions and their application for an automated superposition of certain naturally occurring nucleoside antibiotics. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci., 1989, 29, 163–172. 50. Bodor, N., Gabanyi, Z. and Wong, C.-K. A new method for the estimation of partition coefficient. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1989, 111, 3783–3786. 51. Kamlet, M., Abboud, J.-L., Abraham, M. and Taft, R. Linear solvation energy relationships. 23. A comprehensive collection of the solvatochromic parameters, π, α, and β, and some methods for simplifying the generalized solvatochromic equation. J. Org. Chem., 1983, 48, 2877–2887. 52. http://clogp.pomona.edu. 53. http://www.biobyte.com. 54. http://www.daylight.com/daygci/clogp. 55. http://www.acdlabs.com. 56. http://ap-algorithms.com. 57. Caron, G. and Ermondi, G. A comparison of calculated and experimental parameters as sources of structural information: the case of lipophilicity-related descriptors. Mini Rev. Med. Chem., 2003, 3, 821–830. 58. Collander, R. Partition coefficients of alcohols (including ethanol) in octyl alcohol/water and oleyl alcohol/water systems. Acta Chem. Scand., 1951, 5, 774–780. 59. Abraham, M.H., Chadha, H.S., Whiting, G.S. and Mitchell, R.C. Hydrogen bonding. 32. An analysis of water-octanol and water-alkane partitioning and the logP parameter of seiler. J. Pharm. Sci., 1994, 83, 1085–1100. 60. Valkó, K. Separation methods in drug synthesis and purification. Handbook of Analytical Separations, Vol.1, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2000, 539–542. 61. Hitzel, L., Watt, A.P. and Locker, K.L. An increased throughput method for the determination of partition coefficients. Pharm. Res., 2000, 17, 1389–1395. 62. http://www.analiza.com. 63. Ford, H. Jr., Merski, C.L. and Kelley, J.A. A rapid microscale method for the determination of partition coefficients by HPLC, J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1991, 14, 3365–3386. 64. Kaliszan, R. Quantitative structure-chromatographic retention relationships. Chemical Analysis, Vol. 93, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1987. 65. Martin, A.J.P. and Synge, R.L.M. A new form of chromatogram employing two liquid phases. 1. A theory of chromatography. 2. Application of the microdetermination of the higher mono-amino acids in proteins. Biochem. J., 1941, 35, 1358–1368. 66. Vailaya, A. Liquid-liquid partition chromatography. Encyclopedia of Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 2001, 494–497. 67. Pesek, J.J. and Matyska, M.T. Reversed-phase chromatography: Description and applications. Encyclopedia of Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 2001, 719–722. 68. Snyder, L.R. Theory of chromatography. Chromatography, 5th ed., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1992. 69. Mirrlees, M.S., Moulton, S.J., Murphy, C.T. and Taylor, P.J. Direct measurement of octanol-water partition coefficients by high pressure liquid chromatography. J. Med. Chem., 1976, 19, 615–619. 70. McCall, J.M.. Liquid-liquid partition coefficients by high pressure liquid chromatography. J. Med. Chem., 1975, 18, 549–552.
162
Advances in Chromatography
71. Unger, S.H., Cook, J.R. and Hollenberg, J.S. Simple procedure for determining octanol-aqueous partition, distribution and ionisation coefficients by reversed-phase high-pressure liquid chromatography. J. Pharm. Sci., 1978, 67, 1364–1367. 72. Slater, B., McCormack, A., Avdeef, A. and Comer, J.E.A. pH-metric logP comparison of partition coefficients determined by HPLC and potentiometric methods to literature values. J. Pharm. Sci., 1994, 83, 1280–1283. 73. http://www.sirius-analytical.com. 74. Comer, J.E.A. High-throughput measurements of logD and pKa in drug bioavailability. Estimation of solubility, permeability, absorption and bioavailability. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 18, Wiley-VCH, 2003, 21–45. 75. Box, K., Elliott, S. and Cimpan, G. High throughput pKa and logD7.4 measurements. PharmaChem, June 2003, 55–59. 76. Caron, G., Steyaert, G., Pagliara, A., Reymond, F., Crivori, P., Gaillard, P., Carrupt, P.-A., Avdeef, A., Comer, J., Box, K.J., Girault, H.H. and Testa, B. Structure-lipophilicity relationships of neutral and protonated–blockers. Part I. Intra and intermolecular effects in isotropic solvent systems. Helvetica Chimica Acta, 1999, 82, 1211–1222. 77. Comer, J.E.A., Avdeef, A. and Box, K.J. Limits for successful measurement of pKa and logP by pH-metric titration. American Laboratory, 1995, 4, 36C–36I. 78. Comer, J., Chamberlain, K. and Evans, A. Validation of pH-metric technique for measurement of pKa and logPow of ionizable herbicides. SAR and QSAR in Environmental Research, 1995, 3, 307–313. 79. Comer, J.E.A. The acid test, ionization and lipophilicity of drugs, influence on biological activity. Chemistry in Britain, 1994, 30, 983–986. 80. Avdeef, A. and Comer, J.E.A. Measurement of pKa and logP of water-insoluble substances by potentiometric titration. QSAR and Molecular Modelling, ESCOM Science Publishers BV, Leiden, 1993, 386–387. 81. DeVoe, H., Miller, M.M. and Wasik, S.P. Generator columns and high pressure liquid chromatography for determining aqueous solubility and octanol-water partition coefficients of hydrophobic substances. Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards, 1981, 86, 361–366. 82. Doucette, W.J. and Andren, A.W. Estimation of octanol/water partition coefficients: Evaluation of six methods for highly hydrophobic aromatic hydrocarbons. Chemosphere, 1988, 17, 345–359. 83. Cichna, M., Markl, P. and Huber, J.F.K. Determination of true octanol-water partition coefficients by means of solvent generated liquid-liquid chromatography. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal., 1995, 13, 339–351. 84. Huber, J.F.K., Pawlowska, M. and Markl, P. Selection of the solid support — A crucial step for the realization of solvent generated liquid-liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 500, 257–280. 85. Huber, J.F.K., Meijers, C.A.M. and Hulsman, J.A.R.J. Prediction of partition coefficients in liquid-liquid systems and its experimental verification for steroids by static and chromatographic measurements. Anal. Chem., 1972, 44, 111–116. 86. Minick, D.J., Frenz, J.H., Patrick, M.A. and Brent, D.A. A comprehensive method for determining hydrophobicity constants by reversed phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Med. Chem., 1988, 31, 1923–1933. 87. Pagliara, A., Khamis, E., Trinh, A., Carrupt, P.-A., Tsai, R.-S. and Testa, B. Structural properties governing retention mechanisms on RP-HPLC stationary phases used for lipophilicity measurements. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1995, 18, 1721–1745.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
163
88. Lombardo, F., Shalaeva, M.Y., Tupper, K.A. and Gao, F. ELogP: A tool for lipophilicity determination in drug discovery. 2. Basic and neutral compounds. J. Med. Chem., 2001, 44, 2490–2497. 89. Valkó, K. Application of high-performance liquid chromatography based measurements of lipophilicity to model biological distribution. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1037, 299–310. 90. Ellgehausen, H., Hondt, C.D. and Fuerer, R. Reversed-phase chromatography as a general method for determining octanol/water partition coefficients. Pestic. Sci., 1981, 12, 219–227. Cited in: Nobel, A. Partition coefficients (n-octanol-water) for pesticides. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 642, 3–14. 91. Hsieh, M.M. and Dorsey, J.G. Accurate determination of logkw in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Implications for quantitative structure-retention relationships. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 631, 63–78. 92. Minik, D.J., Frenz, J.H., Patrick, M.A. and Brent, D.A. A comprehensive method for determining hydrophobicity constants by reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography. J. Med. Chem., 1988, 31, 1923. 93. Yamagami, C. Recent advances in reversed-phase HPLC techniques to determine lipophilicity. Pharmacokinetic Optimisation in Drug Research, Wiley-VCH, 2001, 383–400. 94. van de Waterbeemd, H., Kansy, M., Wagner, B. and Fischer, H. Lipophilicity measurement by reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). Lipophilicity in drug action and toxicology. Methods and Principles in Medicinal Chemistry, Vol. 4, VCH, Weinheim 1996, 73–87. 95. Braumann, T. Determination of hydrophobic parameters by reversed-phase liquid chromatography: Theory, experimental techniques, and application in studies on quantitative structure-activity relationships. J. Chromatogr., 1986, 373, 191–225. 96. Lambert, W.J. Modeling oil-water partitioning and membrane permeation using reversed-phase chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 656, 469–484. 97. Yamagami, C., Ogura, T. and Takao, N. Hydrophobicity parameters determined by reversed-phase liquid chromatography. I. Relationship between capacity factors and octanol-water partition coefficients for monosubstituted pyrazines and the related pyridines. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 514, 123–136. 98. Yamagami, C., Yokota, M. and Takao, N. Hydrophobicity parameters determined by reversed-phase liquid chromatography. VIII. Hydrogen-bond effects of ester and amide groups in heteroaromatic compounds on the relationship between the capacity factor and the octanol-water partition coefficient. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 662, 49–60. 99. Garst, J.E. Accurate, wide-range high-performance liquid chromatographic method for the estimation of octanol/water partition coefficients. II. Equilibrium in partition coefficient measurements, additivity of substituent constants and correlation of biological data. J. Pharm. Sci., 1994, 73, 1623–1629. 100. Hammers, W.E., Meurs, G.J. and de Ligny, C.L. Correlations between liquid chromatographic capacity ratio data on lichrosorb RP-18 and partition coefficients in the octanol-water system. J. Chromatogr., 1982, 247, 1–13. 101. Valkó, K., Snyder, L.R. and Glajch, J.L. Retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography as a function of mobile-phase composition. J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 656, 501–520. 102. Schoenmakers, P.J., Billiet, H.A.H. and de Galan, L. Influence of organic modifiers on the rentention behaviour in reversed-phase liquid chromatography and its consequences for gradient elution. J. Chromatogr., 1979, 185, 179–195.
164
Advances in Chromatography
103. Poole, C.F., Gunatilleka, A.D. and Poole, S.K. In search of a chromatographic model for biopartitioning. Adv. Chromatogr., 2000, 40, 159. 104. Lipinski, C.A., Fiese, E.F. and Korst, R.J. pKa, logP and MedChem CLogP fragment values of acidic heterocyclic potential bioisosters. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1991, 10, 109–117. 105. Klein, W., Kördel, W., Wei, M. and Poremski, H.J. Updating the OECD test guideline 107 “Partition coefficient n-octanol-water,” OECD laboratory intercomparison test on the HPLC method. Chemosphere, 1988, 17, 361–386. 106. Kucha, M., Rejholec, V., Kraus, E., Miller, V. and Rábek, V. Influence of intramolecular interactions on chromatographic behaviour of arylaliphatic acids. I. Comparison of reversed-phase thin-layer and high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 280, 279–288. 107. Bechalany, A., Tsantili-Kakoulidou, A., El Tayar, N. and Testa, B. Measurement of lipophilicity indices by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography: Comparison of two stationary phases and various eluents. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 541, 221–229. 108. Kucha, M., Rejholec, V., Kraus, E., Miller, V. and Rábek, V. Influence of intramolecular interactions on chromatographic behaviour of arylaliphatic acids. I. Comparison of reversed-phase thin-layer and high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 280, 279–288. 109. Valkó, K. and Slégel, P. New chromatographic hydrophobicity index (0) based on the slope and intercept of the logk versus organic phase concentration plot. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 631, 49–61. 110. Horvath, C., Melander, W. and Molnar, I. Liquid chromatography of ionogenic substances with nonpolar stationary phases. Anal. Chem., 1977, 49, 142–154. 111. Hanai, T. Structure-retention correlation in liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 550, 313–324. 112. Espinosa, S., Bosch, E. and Roses, M. Retention of ionisable compounds in highperformance liquid chromatography. XI. Global linear salvation energy relationships for neutral and ionisable compounds. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 945, 83–96. 113. Espinosa, S., Bosch, E. and Roses, M. Retention of ionisable compounds in highperformance liquid chromatography. IX. Modelling retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography as a function of pH and solvent composition with acetonitrile-water mobile phases. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 947, 47–58. 114. Braumann, Th., Genieser, H.-G., Lüllmann, C. and Jastorff, B. Determination of hydrophobic parameters by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Effect of stationary phase. Chromatographia, 1987, 24, 777–782. 115. van Straten, M.A., Lynch, R.J. and Claessens, H.A. The role of stationary phase in reversed-phase liquid chromatography in the application of solvent optimization procedures. LC-GC Int., 1995, 8, 143–150. 116. Abraham, M.H., Chadha, H.S. and Leo, A.J. Hydrogen bonding 35: Relationship between high performance liquid chromatographic capacity factors and water-octanol partition coefficients. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 685, 203–211. 117. Tchapla, A., Colin, H. and Guiochon, G. Linearity of homologous series retention plots in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1984, 56, 621–625. 118. Kaliszan, R., van Straten, M.A., Markuszewski, M., Cramers, C.A. and Claessens, H.A. Molecular mechanism of retention in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography and classification of modern stationary phases by using quantitative structure–retention relationships. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 855, 455–486.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
165
119. Haky, J.E. and Vemulapalli, S. Comparison of octadecyl-bonded alumina and other stationary phases for lipophilicity estimation by high performance liquid chromatography. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1990, 13, 3111–3131. 120. Kaliszan, R. Quantitative structure-retention relationships applied to reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 656, 417–435. 121. Bechalany, A., Rothlisberger, T., El Tayar, N. and Testa, B. Comparison of various non-polar stationary phases used for assessing lipophilicity. J. Chromatogr., 1989, 473, 115–124. 122. Tanaka, N., Nagayama, H., Kobayashi, H., Ikegami, T., Hosoya, K., Ishizuka, N., Minakuchi, H., Nakanishi, K., Cabrera, K. and Lubda, D. Monolithic silica columns for HPLC, micro-HPLC, and CEC. J. High Resol. Chromatogr., 2000, 23, 111–116. 123. Cabrera, K., Lubda, D., Eggenweiler, H.-M., Minakuchi, H. and Nakanishi, K. A new monolithic-type HPLC column for fast separations. J. High Resol. Chromatogr., 2000, 23, 93–99. 124. Zou, H., Huang, X., Ye, M. and Luo, Q. Monolithic stationary phases for liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 954, 5–32. 125. Dawkins, J.V., Gaggot, N., Lloyd, L.L., McConville, J.A. and Warner, F.P. Reversedphase high-performance liquid chromatography with a C18 polyacrylamide-based packing. J. Chromatogr., 1988, 452, 145–156. 126. Buszewski, B., Schmid, J., Albert, K. and Bayer, E. Chemically bonded phases for the reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic separation of basic substances. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 552, 415–427. 127. Feibush, B. and Santasania, C.T. Hydrophilic shielding of hydrophobic, cation- and anion-exchange phases for separation of small analytes: Direct injection of biological fluids onto high-performance liquid chromatographic columns. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 544, 41–49. 128. O’Gara, J.E., Alden, B.A., Walter, T.H., Petersen, J.S., Niederländer, C.L. and Neue, U.D. Simple preparation of a C8 HPLC stationary phase with an internal polar functional group. Anal. Chem., 1995, 67, 3809–3813. 129. Czajkowska, T., Hrabovsky, L., Buszewski, B., Gilpin, R.K. and Jaroniec, M. Comparison of the retention of organic acids on alkyl and alkylamide chemically bonded phases. J. Chromatogr. A, 1995, 691, 217–224. 130. Buszewski, B., Gadzaa-Kopciuch, R.M., Markuszewski, M. and Kaliszan, R. Chemically bonded silica stationary phases: Synthesis, physicochemical characterization, and molecular mechanism of reversed-phase HPLC retention. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 3277–3284. 131. Nawrocki, J., Rigney, M.P., McCormick, A. and Carr, P.W. Chemistry of zirconia and its use in chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 657, 229–282. 132. Blackwell, J.A. and Carr, P.W. Development of an eluotropic series for the chromatography of Lewis bases on zirconium oxide. Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 863–873. 133. Trüdinger, U., Müller, G. and Unger, K. Porous zirconia and titania as packing materials for high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 535, 111–125. 134. Blackwell, J.A. and Carr, P.W. The role of Lewis acid-base processes in ligandexchange chromatography of benzoic acid derivatives on zirconium oxide. Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 853–862. 135. Nasal, A., Kaliszan, R., Forgács, E., Cserháti, T. and Abraham, M.H. Polyethylenecoated silica and zirconia stationary phases in view of quantitative structure-retention relationships. Chromatographia, 1996, 43, 484–490.
166
Advances in Chromatography
136. Kaliszan, R., Blain, R.W. and Hartwick, R.A. A new HPLC method of hydrophobicity evaluation employing poly(butadiene)-coated alumina columns. Chromatographia, 1988, 25, 5–7. 137. Kaliszan, R., Petrusewicz, J., Blain, R.W. and Hartwick, R.A. Determination of hydrophobicity parameters on polybutadiene-coated alumina and their application in quantitative structure-activity relationship analysis. J. Chromatogr., 1988, 458, 395–404. 138. Helweg, C., Nielsen, T. and Hansen, P.E. Determination of octanol-water partition coefficients of polar polycyclic aromatic compounds (N-PAC) by high-performance liquid chromatography. Chemosphere, 1997, 34, 1673–1684. 139. Altomare, C., Cellamera, S., Carotti, A. and Ferappi, M. Linear solvation energy relationships in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Examination of Deltabond C8 as stationary phase for measuring lipophilicity parameters. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1993, 12, 261–268. 140. Vallat, P., Fan, W., El Tayar, N., Carrupt, P.-A. and Testa, B. Solvatochromic analysis of the retention mechanism of two novel stationary phases used for measuring lipophilicity by RP-HPLC. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1992, 15, 2133–2151. 141. Altomare, C., Tsai, R.-S., El Tayar, N., Testa, B., Carotti, A., Cellamare, S. and De Benedetti, P.G. Determination of lipophilicity and hydrogen-bond donor acidity of bioactive sulphonyl-containing compounds by reversed phase HPLC and centrifugal partition chromatography and their applications to structure-activity relations, J. Pharm, Pharmacol., 1991, 43, 191–197. 142. Yonker, C.R., Zwier, T.A. and Burke, M.F. Investigation of stationary phase formation for RP-18 using various organic modifiers. J. Chromatogr. A, 1982, 241, 269–280. 143. Yonker, C.R., Zwier, T.A. and Burke, M.F. Comparison of stationary phase formation in RP- for methanol-water systems. J. Chromatogr. A, 1982, 241, 257–268. 144. Jenke, D.R. Liquid chromatographic estimation of octanol/water partition coefficients with a high efficiency, nonporous, ultrasmall particle size reverse phase stationary phase. J. Liq. Chromat. & Rel. Technol., 1996, 19, 2227–2245. 145. Foster, M.D. and Synovec, R.E. Reversed phase liquid chromatography of organic hydrocarbons with water as the mobile phase. Anal. Chem., 1996, 68, 2838–2844. 146. Rowlen, K.L. and Harris, J.M. Raman spectroscopic study of solvation structure in acetonitrile/water mixtures. Anal. Chem., 1991, 63, 964–969. 147. Claessens, H.A., Vermeer, E.A. and Cramers, C.A. Comparison of reversed-phase performance for some commercial C-18 HPLC columns, LC-GC Int., 1993, 6, 692. 148. McCalley, D.V. Influence of organic solvent modifier and solvent strength on peak shape of some basic compounds in high-performance liquid chromatography using a reversed-phase column. J. Chromatogr. A, 1995, 708, 185–194. 149. McCalley, D.V. Effect of organic solvent modifier and nature of the solute on the performance of bonded silica reversed-phase columns for the analysis of strongly basic compounds by high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 738, 169–179. 150. Azzaoui, K. and Morin-Allroy, L. Quantitative structure-retention relationships for the investigation of the retention mechanism in high performance liquid chromatography using apolar eluent with a very low content of polar modifiers. Chromatographia, 1995, 40, 690–696. 151. Lewis, J.A., Lommen, D.C., Raddatz, W.D., Dolan, J.W. and Snyder, L.R. Computer simulation for the prediction of separation as a function of pH for reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. I. Accuracy of a theory-based model. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 592, 183–195.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
167
152. Kirkland, J.J., van Straten, M.A. and Claessens, H.A. High pH mobile phase effects on silica-based reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic columns. J. Chromatogr. A, 1995, 691, 3–19. 153. Claessens, H.A., van Straten, M.A. and Kirkland, J.J. Personal communication, 1996. 154. Knox, J.H., Kaliszan, R. and Kennedy, G.F. Enthalpic exclusion chromatography. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Symp., 1980, 15, 113. Cited in Lipophilicity and pKa estimates from gradient high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 965, 117–127. 155. Belsner, K., Pfeifer, M. and Wilfert, B. Reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography for evaluating the lipophilicity of pharmaceutical substances with ionization up to logPapp = 8. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 629, 123–134. 156. Kaliszan, R., Marsza, M.P., Markuszewski, M.J., Bczek, T. and Pernak, V. Suppression of deleterious effects of free silanols in liquid chromatography by imidazolinium tetrafluoroborate ionic liquids. J. Chromatogr. A., 2004, 1030, 263–271. 157. Sebastiano, R., Gelfi, C., Righetti, P.G. and Citterio, A. Novel, trifunctional diamine for silica coating in capillary zone electrophoresis. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 894, 53–61. 158. Olivieri, E., Sebastiano, R., Gelfi, C., Righetti, P.G. and Citterio, A. Quantitation of protein binding to the capillary wall in acidic, isoelectric buffers and means for minimizing the phenomenon. J. Chromatogr. A, 2000, 894, 273–280. 159. Snyder, L.R., Kirkland, J.J. and Glajch, J.L. Practical HPLC Method Development, Wiley, New York, 1977. 160. Gilroy, J.J., Dolan, J.W. and Snyder, L.R. Column selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. IV. Type-B alkyl-silica columns. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 1000, 757–778. 161. Bayer, E. and Paulus, A. Silanophilic interactions in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1987, 400, 1–4. 162. Hansen, S.M., Helboe, P. and Thomson, M. Bare silica, dynamically modified with long-chain quaternary ammonium ions — The technique of choice for more reproducible selectivity in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 544, 53–76. 163. Nawroki, J. and Buszewski, B. Influence of silica surface chemistry and structure on the properties, structure and coverage of alkyl-bonded phases for high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Cromatogr., 1988, 449, 1–24. 164. Tan, L.C. and Carr, P.W. Study of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography using linear solvation energy relationships. II. The mobile phase. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 799, 1–19. 165. Taylor, P.J. Comprehensive Medicinal Chemistry, in: Rational design, mechanistic study and therapeutic application of chemical compounds. Volume 4, Qualitative drug design, Sammes, P.G., Hansch, C., Taylor, J.B.; Ramsden, C.A. (Eds.), Oxford: Pergamon Press, UK, 1989. 166. Dearden, J.C. and Bresnen, G.M. The measurement of partition coefficients. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1988, 7, 133–144. 167. Abraham, M.H., Chadha, H.S., Leitao, R.A.E., Mitchell, R.C., Lambert, W.J., Kaliszan, R., Nasal, A. and Haber, P. Determination of solute lipophilicity, as log P(octanol) and log P(alkane) using poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) and immobilised artificial membrane stationary phases in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1997, 766, 35–47.
168
Advances in Chromatography
168. Dias, N.C., Nawas, M.I. and Poole, C.F. Evaluation of a reversed-phase column (Supelcosil LC-ABZ) under isocratic and gradient elution conditions for estimating octanol-water partition coefficients. Analyst, 2003, 128, 427–433. 169. Nong, C., Lehtonen, P. and Yukui, Z. The linear S-logkw correlation (LSLC) analysis for homologous series in reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). Chinese J. Chromatogr., 1995, 13, 373–378. 170. Chen, N., Zhang, Y. and Lu, P. Effects of molecular structure on the logkw index and linear S-logkw correlation in RP-HPLC. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 633, 31–41. 171. Hallagas, B., Patonay, T., Kiss-Szikszai, A., Dobos, Zs., Hollósy, F., Ers, D., Orbi, L., Kéry, Gy. and Idei, M. Comparison of measured and calculated lipophilicity of substituted aurones and related compounds. J. Chromatogr. B, 2004, 801, 229–235. ˇ J., Klimesová, ˇ 172. Klimes, V. and Waisser, K. Chromatographic behaviour of dipyridylsulphides. Relationship between logk values and structure by RP-HPLC. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 595, 334–336. 173. Dimitrova, B., Doytchinova, I. and Zlatkova, M. Reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography for evaluating the distribution of pharmaceutical substances in suppository base-phosphate buffer system. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal., 2000, 23, 955–964. 174. Natalini, B., Capodiferro, V., Mattoli, L., Marinozzi, M., Constantino, G. and Pellicciari, R. Chromatographic separation and evaluation of the lipophilicity by reversedphase high-performance liquid chromatography of fulerene-C60 derivatives. J. Chromatogr. A, 1999, 847, 339–343. 175. Tsantili-Kakoulidou, A., Filippatos, E., Todoulou, O. and Papadaki-Valiraki, A. Use of RP-HPLC in lipophilicity studies of 9 H-xanthene and 9 H-tioxanthene derivatives containing an aminoalkanamide or a nitrosoureido group. Comparison between the capacity factors and calculated octanol-water partition coefficients. J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 654, 43–52. 176. de Voogt, P., Wegener, J.W.M., Brinkman, U.A.Th. and Govers, H. Retention of neutral and basic heteroaromatic hydrocarbons in RPLC systems and its use in predictive studies. I. Concentration of the organic modifier. The Science of the Total Environment, 1991, 109/110, 69–87. 177. Harnisch, M., Möckel, H.J. and Schulze, G. Relationship between logPo/w shake-flask values and capacity factors derived from reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography for n-alkylbenzenes and some OECD reference substances. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 282, 315–332. 178. Grouls, R.J.E., Ackerman, E.W., Korsten, H.H.M., Hellebrekers, L.J. and Breimer, D.D. Partition coefficients (n-octanol/water) of N-butyl-p-aminobenzoate and other local anaesthetics measured by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. B, 1997, 694, 421–425. 179. Cimpan, G., Irimie, F., Gocan, S. and Claessens, H.A. Role of stationary phase and eluent composition on the determination of logP values of N-hydroxyethylamide of aryloxyalkylen and pyridine carboxylic acids by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. B, 1998, 714, 247–261. 180. Belsner, K., Pfeifer, M. and Wilffert, B. RP-HPLC for evaluation the lipophilicity of pharmaceutical substances with ionisation up to logPapp = 8. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 629, 123–134. 181. de Kock, A.C. and Lord, D.A. A simple procedure for determining octanol-water partition coefficients using reverse phase high performance liquid chromatography (RPHPLC). Chemosphere, 1987, 16, 133–142.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
169
182. Rothemund, S., Krause, E., Ehrlich, A. and Bienert, M. Determination of peptide hydrophobicity parameters by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 661, 77–82. 183. Yamagami, C. and Katashiba, N. Hydrophobicity parameters determined by reversed phase liquid chromatography. XI. Prediction of logP values for phenyl N-methyl and phenyl N,N-dimethylcarbamates. Chem. Pharm. Bull., 1996, 44, 1338–1343. 184. Hong, H., Zhou, D., Han, S., Wang, L., Zhang, Z. and Zou, G. Retention of aromatic sulfur containing compounds on RP-HPLC: Correlation with partition coefficients and molecular connectivity indices. J. Liq. Chrom. & Rel. Technol., 1996, 19, 1617–1629. 185. Altomare, C., Carotti, A., Cellamare, S., Carrieri, A., Ciabatti, R. and Malabarba, A. Lipophilicty of Teicoplanin antibiotics as assessed by reversed phase high performance liquid chromatography, quantitative structure-property and structure-activity relationships. J. Pharm. Pharmacol., 1994, 46, 994–999. 186. Guesdon, M.-P., Dallet, Ph. and Dubost, J.-P. Comparaison des logP et des logKw d’une série de molécules très lipophiles. Bull. Soc. Pharm. Bordeaux, 1994, 134, 83–92. 187. Valkó, K., Bevan, C. and Reynolds, D. Chromatographic hydrophobicity index by fast-gradient RP-HPLC: A high-throughput alternative to log P/log D. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 2022–2029. 188. Valkó, K., Plass, M., Bevan, C., Reynolds, D. and Abraham, M.H. Relationships between the chromatographic hydrophobicity indices and solute descriptors obtained by using several reversed-phase, diol, nitrile, cyclodextrin and immobilised artificial membrane-bonded high-performance liquid chromatography columns. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 797, 41–55. 189. Plass, M., Valkó, K. and Abraham, M.H. Determination of solute descriptors of tripeptide derivatives based on high-throughput gradient high performance liquid chromatography retention data. J. Chromatogr. A, 1998, 803, 51–60. 190. Du, C.M., Valkó, K., Bevan, C., Reynolds, D. and Abraham, M.H. Characterizing the selectivity of stationary phases and organic modifiers in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic systems by a general solvation equation using gradient elution. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 2000, 38, 503–511. 191. Valkó, K., Espinosa, S., Du, C.M., Bosch, E., Rosés, M., Bevan, C. and Abraham, M.H. Unique selectivity of perfluorinated stationary phases with 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol as organic mobile phase modifier. J. Cromatogr. A, 2001, 933, 73–81. 192. Kaune, A., Knorrenschild, M. and Kettrup, A. Predicting 1-octanol-water partition coefficient by high-performance liquid chromatography gradient elution. Fresenius J. Anal. Chem., 1995, 352, 303–312. 193. Krass, J.D., Jastorff, B. and Genieser, H.G. Determination of lipophilicity by gradient elution high-performance liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1997, 69, 2575–2581. 194. Snyder, L.R. and Dolan, J.W. Initial experiments in high-performance liquid chromatographic method development. I. Use of a starting gradient run. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 721, 3–14. 195. Kaliszan, R., Haber, P., Baczek, T., Siluk, D. and Valkó, K. Lipophilicity and pKa estimates from gradient high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 965, 117–127. 196. http://www.lcresources.com. 197. Kerns, E.H., Di, L., Petusky, S., Kleintop, T., Huryn, D., McConnel, O. and Carter, G. Pharmaceutical profiling method for lipophilicity and integrity using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. B, 2003, 791, 381–388.
170
Advances in Chromatography
198. Gulyaeva, N., Zaslavsky, A., Lechner, P., Chlenov, M., McConnell, O., Chait, A., Kipnis, V. and Zaslavsky, B. Relative hydrophobicity and lipophilicity of drugs measured by aqueous two-phase partitioning, octanol-buffer partitioning and HPLC. A simple model for predicting blood-brain distribution. European J Med. Chem., 2003, 38, 391–396. 199. Jandera, P., Halama, M. and Novotná, K. Stationary phase effects in gradient highperformance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2004, 1030, 33–41. 200. Abraham, M.H., Ibrahim, A., Zissimos, A.M., Zhao, Y.H., Comer, J. and Reynolds, D.P. Application of hydrogen bonding calculations in property based drug design. Drug Discov. Today, 2002, 7, 1056–1063. 201. Zissimos, A.M., Abraham, M.H., Du, C.M., Valkó, K., Bevan, C., Reynolds, D., Wood, J. and Tam, K.Y. Calculation of Abraham descriptors from experimental data from seven HPLC systems, evaluation of five different methods of calculation. J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 2002, 12, 2001–2010. 202. Zissimos, A.M., Abraham, M.H., Barker, M.C., Box, K.J. and Tam, K.Y. Calculation of Abraham descriptors from solvent-water partition coefficients in four different systems, evaluation of different methods of calculation. J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 2002, 3, 470–477. 203. Yamagami, C., Takao, N. and Fujita, T. Hydrophobicity parameter of diazines. III. Relationship of partition coefficients of monosubstituted diazines and pyridines in different partitioning systems. J. Pharm. Sci., 1993, 82, 155–161. 204. Du, C.M., Valkó, K., Bevan, C., Reynolds, D. and Abraham, M.H. Rapid method for estimation octanol-water partition coefficient (logPoct) from isocratic RP-HPLC and a hydrogen bond acidity term (A). J. Liq. Chromatogr. Rel. Technol., 2001, 24, 635–649. 205. Du, C.M., Valko, K., Bevan, C., Reynolds, D. and Abraham, M.H. Rapid gradient RP-HPLC method for lipophilicity determination: A solvation equation based comparison with isocratic methods. Anal. Chem., 1998, 70, 4228–4234. 206. Martin, A.J.P. and Synge, R.L.M. A new form of chromatogram employing two liquid phases. Biochem. J., 1941, 35, 1358–1368. 207. Kowalska, T. and Prus, W. Theory and mechanism of thin-layer chromatography. Encyclopedia of Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 2003, 821–825. 208. Bate-Smith, E.C. and Westall, R.G. Chromatographic behavior and chemical structure. 1. Some naturally occurring phenolic substances. Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1950, 4, 427–440. 209. Snyder, L.R. Principles of Adsorption Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1968. 210. Soczewinski, E. Solvent composition effects in thin-layer chromatography systems of the type silica gel-electron donor solvent. Anal. Chem., 1969, 41, 179–182. 211. Boyce, C.B.C. and Milborrow, B.V. A simple assessment of partition data for correlating structure and biological activity using thin-layer chromatography. Nature, 1965, 208, 537–539. 212. Jack, D.B., Hawker, J.L., Rooney, L., Beerahee, M., Lobo, J. and Patel, P. Measurment of the distribution coefficients of several classes of drug using reversed-phase thinlayer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. 1988, 452, 257–264. 213. Hulshoff, A. and Perrin, J.H. Chromatographic characterization of phenothiazine drugs by a reversed-phase thin-layer technique. J. Chromatogr. 1976, 129, 249–262. 214. Hulshoff, A. and Perrin, J.H. A reversed-phase thin-layer chromatographic method for the determination of relative partition coefficients of very lipophilic compounds. J. Chromatogr., 1976, 120, 65–79.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
171
215. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Sapone, A. and Recanatini, M. Determination of lipophilicity by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. II. Influence of the organic modifier on the slope of the thin-layer chromatographic equation. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 669, 246–253. 216. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M. and Sapone, A. Determination of lipophilicity by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. I. Basic aspects and relationship between slope and intercept of TLC equations. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 662, 341–361. 217. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Gamba, M.F. and Guerra, M.C. Partition data of penicillins determined by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1969, 41, 371–379. 218. Biagi, G.L., Guerra, M.C., Barbaro, A.M., Barbieri, S., Recanatini, M., Borea, P.A. and Pietrograde, M.C. Study of the lipophilicity character of xanthine and adenosine derivatives. I. RM and logP values. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 498, 179–190. 219. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Sapone, A., Borea, P.A., Varani, K. and Recanatini, M. Study of lipophilic character of serotonergic ligands. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 723, 135–143. 220. Dross, K., Sonntag, C.H. and Mannhold, R. Determination of the hydrophobicity parameter RMw by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1994, 673, 113–124. 221. Dross, K., Sonntag, C.H. and Mannhold, R. On the precise estimation of RM values in reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography including aspects of pH dependence. J. Chromatogr., 1993, 639, 287–294. 222. Slawik, T. and Kowalski, C. Lipophilicity of a series of 1,2-benzisothiazole-3(2H)ones determined by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 952, 295–299. 223. Barbaro, A.M., Pietrogrande, M.C, Guerra, M., Cantelli, G., Borea, P.A. and Biagi, G.L. Relationship between the chromatographic behaviour of dermophin-related oligopeptides and the composition of the mobile phase in reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. Comparison of extrapolated RM values. J. Chromatogr. 1984, 287, 259–270. 224. Barbaro, A.M., Guerra, M.C, Biagi, G.L., Pietrogrande, M.C. and Borea, P.A. Influence of the mobile phase composition on the reversed-phase thin layer chromatographic behaviour of a series of prosta glandins. Comparison of extrapolated RM values. J. Chromatogr., 1985, 347, 209–218. 225. Cserháti, T. and Magyar, K. Lipophilicity determination of some monoamine oxidase inhibitors: The effect of methanol and ammonia chloride. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 575, 57–62. 226. Pyka, A.J. The topological indices and RM values of benzoic acid derivatives: a structure-activity investigation. Planar Chromatogr., 1994, 7, 108–116. 227. Dzimiri, N., Fricke, U. and Klaus, W. Influence of derivatization on the lipophilicity and inhibitory actions of cardiac glycosides on myocardial sodium-potassium ATPase. J. Pharmacol., 1987, 91, 31–38. 228. Wilson, J. Ion-pair reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography of organic acids: Reinvestigation of the effects of solvent pH on RF values. J. Chromatogr., 1986, 354, 99–106. 229. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Sapone, A. and Recanatini, M. Determination of lipophilicity by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. I. Basic aspects and relationship between slope and intercept of TLC equations. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 662, 341–361.
172
Advances in Chromatography
230. Bijloo, G.J. and Rekker, R.F. Influence of stationary phase modifications on lipophilicity measurement of benzophenone using reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1986, 351, 122–127. 231. Cserháti, T., Darwish, Y.M. and Matolcsy, G. Effect of support characteristics on the determination of the lipophilicity of some neutral, acidic and alkaline compounds by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1983, 270, 97–104. 232. Gullner, G., Cserháti, T., Bordas, B. and Szögyi M. Mixed support in the reversedphase thin-layer chromatography of amino acids. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1986, 9, 1919–1931. 233. Garssini-Strazza, G., Carunchio, B. and Girelli, A.M. Flat-bed chromatography on impregnated layer. J. Chromatogr., 1989, 466, 1–35. 234. Cserháti, T. and Szögyi, M. Determination of the lipophilicity of some peptides. Effect of surface pH of silica. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 520, 249–256. 235. Cserháti, T. and Forgács, E. Effect of TLC support characteristics and coating on the lipophilicity determination of phenols and aniline derivatives. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 2000, 40, 564–568. 236. Forgács, E., Cserháti, T., Kaliszan, R., Haber, P. and Nasal, A. Reversed-phase thinlayer chromatographic determination of the hydrophobicity parameters of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1998, 11, 383–387. 237. Cserháti, T., Forgács, E., Kiss, G.C. and Augustin, J. Effect of salts on the hydrophobicity parameters of sulfosuccinic acid esters studied by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1997, 10, 441–446. 238. Darwish, Y., Cserháti, T. and Forgács, E. Relationship between lipophilicity and specific hydrophobic surface area of a non-homologous series of pesticides. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1993, 6, 458–462. 239. Cserháti, T., Forgács, E. and Hajos, G. Determination of the lipophilicity of fusedring nitrogen heterocycles by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1998, 11, 64–69. 240. Wallerstein, S., Cserháti, T. and Fischer, J. Determination of the lipophilicity of some anti-hypoxia drugs: Comparation of TLC and HPLC methods. Chromatographia, 1993, 35, 275–280. 241. Darwish, Y., Cserháti, T. and Forgács, E. Reversed-phase characteristics of some bioactive heterocyclic compounds. J. Chromatogr., 1994, 668, 485–494. 242. Wallerstein, S., Cserháti, T. and Fischer, J. Determination of the luipophilisity of some anti-hypoxia druds: comparation of TLC and HPLC methods. Chromatographia, 1993, 35, 275–280. 243. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M. and Recanatini, M. Determination of lipophilicity by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. III. Study of the TLC equations for a series of ionizable quinolone derivatives. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 678, 127–137. 244. Perisic-Janjic, N.U., Dajakovi-Seculi, T.L. and Popov-Pergal, K. Effect of the stationary phase and the mobile-phase modifier on the retention of some thiazoles. Correlation with the lipophilicity of the compounds. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2003, 16, 363–368. 245. Almási, J., Takács-Novák, K., Kökösi, J. and Vámos, J.J. Characterization of potential NMDA and cholecystokinin antagonists. II. Lipophilicity studies on 2-methyl-4-oxo3H-quinazoline-3-alkyl-carboxylic acid derivatives. Int. J. Pharm. 1999, 180, 13–22. 246. Mazák, K., Vámos, J., Nemes, A., Rácz, Á. and Noszál, B. Lipophilicity of vinpocetine and related compounds characterized by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2003, 996, 195–203.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
173
247. Abraham, M.H., Poole, C.F. and Poole, S. Solute effect on reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. A linear free energy relationship analysis. J. Chromatogr. A, 1996, 749, 201–209. 248. Greenwald, H.L., Kice, E.B., Kelly, M. and Kelly, J. Determination of the distribution of non-ionic surface active agents between water and isooctane. Anal. Chem., 1961, 33, 405–468. 249. Schott, H. Hydrophilic-lipophilic balance and distribution coefficients of non ionic surfactants. J. Pharm. Sci., 1971, 60, 648–649. 250. Hahn, L. and Sucker, H. HLB determination by HPLC. Tenside Surf. Det., 1989, 26, 192–194. 251. Trapani, G., Altomare, C., Franco, M., Latrofa, A. and Liso, G. Determination of hydrophile-lipophile balance of some polyethoxylated non-ionic surfactants by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. Int. J. Pharm., 1995, 116, 95–99 252. Mannhold, R., Dross, K.P. and Rekker, R.F. Drug lipophilicity in QSAR practice. I. A comparison of experimental with calculative approaches. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1990, 9, 21–28. 253. Nys, G.G. and Rekker, R.F. The concept of hydrophobic fragmental constants (fvalues). II. Extension of its applicability to the calculation of lipophilicities of aromatic and heteroaromatic structures. Eur. J. Med. Chem., 1974, 9, 361–375. 254. Leo, A., Jow, P.Y.C., Silipo, C. and Hansch, C. Calculation of hydrophobic constant (logP) from π and f-constant. J. Med. Chem., 1975, 18, 865–868. 255. Dross, K.P., Mannhold, R. and Rekker, R.F. Drug lipophilicity in QSAR practice. II. Aspects of RM determinations, critics of RM-corrections, interrelations with partition coefficients. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 1992, 11, 36–44. 256. Geronikaki, A. and Hadjipavlou-Litina, D.J. Lipophilicity and antiinflamatory activity of some 2-(aminoacetylamino)thiazole derivatives. Pharmazie, 1993, 48, 948–949. 257. Gocan, S., Irimie, F. and Cimpan, G. Prediction of the lipophilicity of some plant growth-stimulating amido esters of ethanolamine using reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 675, 282–285. 258. Cimpan, G. and Miclu, V. Normal phase thin layer chromatography and a lipophilicity study by reversed phase thin layer chromatography of some 2-amino-3-cyano-4,5diphenylfurane derivatives. Studia Universitatis Babe-Bolyai, Chemia, 1997, 42, 225–231. 259. Malawska, B., Kulig, K. and Winiewska, M. Determination of the lipophilicity of antiarrhythmic and antihypertensive 1-[2-hydroxy- or 1-[2-acetoxy-3-(4-aryl-1-piperazinyl)propyl]-pyrrolidin-2-one derivative. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2000, 13, 187–190. 260. Kulig, K. and Malawska B. Estimation of the lipophilicity of antiarrhythmic and antihypertensive active 1-substituted pyrrolidin-2-one and pyrrolidine derivatives. Biomed. Chromatogr., 2003, 17, 318–324. 261. Forgács, E. and Cserháti, T. Effect of various organic modifiers on the determination of the hydrophobicity parameters of a non-homologous series of anticancer drugs. J. Chromatogr. A, 1995, 697, 59–69. 262. Matosiuk, D. and Jówiak, K. Determination of lipophilicity of carbonyl derivatives of 2-aminoimidazolines-2 by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. Part 1. Lipophilicity of 1-(1-arylimidazolin-2-yl)-3-arylureas and 1-aryl-2-imine-3-arylaminocarbonilimidazolidines. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2000, 13, 52–56. 263. Petrovi, S.M,. Lonar, E. and Pejanovi, V. Corelation between retention 1-octanolwater partition coefficients of some extrane derivatives in reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 2002, 40, 569–574.
174
Advances in Chromatography
264. Sawik, T. and Kowalski, C. Lipophilicity of a series of 1,2-benzisothiazol-3(2H)-ones determined by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2002, 952, 295–299. 265. Tacács-Novák, K., Perjési, P. and Vámos, J. Determination of logP for biologically active chalcones and cyclic chalcone analogs by RPTLC. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2001, 14, 42–46. 266. Cimpan, G., Bota, C., Coman, M., Grinberg, N. and Gocan, S. A lipophilicity study for some 2-hydrazinothiazolic derivatives with antifungal activity by reversed phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Liq. Chrom. & Rel. Technol., 1999, 22, 29–40. 267. Sawik, T. and Paw, B. Lipophilicity of some N- and O-substituted alkanoic acids of 1,2-benzisothiazol-3(2H)-one determined by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatograph. J. Liq. Chrom. & Rel. Technol., 2004, 27, 1043–1055. 268. Gocan, S., Cimpan, G. and Panea, T. Normal phase TLC and reversed phase HPTLC of some plant growth stimulators. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1994, 7, 435–439. 269. Malawska, B. Determination of lipophilicity of some N-substituted amides of γpiperazine-γ-hydroxybutiric acid. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1998, 11, 137–140. 270. Rekker, R.F. and de Kort, H.M. The hydrophobic fragmental constant, an extension to a 1000 data point set. Eur. J. Med. Chem.-Chimica Therapeutica, 1979, 14(6), 479–488. 271. Malankiewicz, M.J. and Pluta, K. TLC Separation of - and -quinolinyl sulfides. J. Planar Chromatogr., 1994, 7, 484–486. 272. Irimie, F. Ph.D. thesis, Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania, 1993. 273. Cserháti, T. and Bordás, B. Determination of the lipophilicity of some aniline derivatives by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. The effect of salts. Chromatographia, 1986, 21, 312–316. 274. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Sapone, A. and Recanati, M. Thin-layer chromatography study of the lipophilicity of triazine herbicides influence of different organic modifiers. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 625, 392–396. 275. Glavic, D. RM values of some colchicines and colchiceinamides determined by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 591, 367–370. 276. Matysiak, J., Niewiadomy, A., Macik-Niewiadomy, G. and Kornillowicz, T. Dependence of fungistatic activity of 2,4-dihydroxythiobenzanilides on the structure and lipophilic nature of the compounds. Eur. J. Med. Chem., 2000, 35, 393–404. 277. Kontogiorgis, C. and Hadjipavlou-Litina, D. Biological evaluation of several coumarin derivatives designed as possible anti-inflammatory/antioxidant agents. J. Enzyme Inhib. Med. Chem., 2003, 18, 63–69. 278. Kontogiorgis, C., Hadjipavlou-Litina, D. and Schulz, E. Antioxidant activity of DL -phenyl-amino acid octyl esters with anti-inflamatory activity. Correlation of the structure with lipophilicity. Arzneimittelforschung, 2001, 51, 485–488. 279. Cserháti, T. Lipophilicity determination of non-homologous series of nonionic surfactants by means of reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods, 1993, 27, 133–142. 280. Cserháti, T., Forgács, E. and Oros G. Effect of salt concentration and pH on the hydrophobicity parameters of surfactants studied by TLC and spectral mapping technique. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods, 1999, 38, 1–15. 281. Wang, Q.S., Zhang, L., Yang, H.Z. and Liu, H.Y. Lipophilicity determination of some potential photosystem II inhibitors on reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1999, 37, 41–44.
Lipophilicity Measurements by Liquid Chromatography
175
282. Kastner, P., Kuchar, M., Kilinmes, J. and Dosedlova, D. Relationship between structure and reversed-phase thin-layer chromatographic lipophilicity parameters in a group of piperazine derivatives. J. Chromatogr. A, 1997, 766, 165–170. 283. Hucha, M., Kraus, E. and Jelínková, V. Influence of mobile phase composition on evaluation of lipophilicity by partition chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 557, 399–411. 284. Biagi, G.L., Pietrogrande, M.C., Barbaro, A.M., Guerra, M.C., Borea, P.A. and Cantelli Forti, G. Study of the lipophilic character of a series of -carbolines. J. Chromatogr., 1989, 469, 121–126. 285. Biagi, G.L., Barbaro, A.M., Guerra, M.C., Borea, P.A. and Recanatini, M. Lipophilic character of cardiac glycosides. RM values as lipophilicity parameters. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 504, 163–178. 286. Valkó, K., Olajos, S. and Cserháti, T. Prediction of the high-performance liquid chromatographic retention behavior of some benzodiazepine derivatives by thin-layer chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1990, 499, 361–371. 287. Bidló-Iglóy, M. Reversed-phase thin-layer and high-performance liquid chromatography of aromatic alkoxy and hydroxy acids. J. Chromatogr., 1989, 475, 321–329. 288. Dondi, F., Grassini-Strazza, G., Kahie, Y.D., Lodi, G., Pietrogrande, C., Reschiglian, P. and Bighi, C. Comparison of reversed-phase thin-layer and high performance liquid chromatography of flavonoid compounds. J. Chromatogr., 1989, 462, 205–217. ˇ N.U., Aanski, M.M., Janji, N.J., Lazarevi, M.D. and Dimova, V. Study of the 289. Perisic, lipophlicity of some 1,2,4-Triazole derivatives by RPHPLC and TLC. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2000, 13, 281–284. 290. Róyo, J.K., Matysiak, J., Niewiadomy, A. and Abiska, A. Reversed-phase HPLC and HPTLC characterization of potential fungicides. J. Planar Chromatogr., 2000, 13, 176–181. 291. Bieganowska, M. Chromatographic retention data of N-alkylamides of benzomorpholine-2-carboxylic acid in the study of structure-activity relationships. Chromatographia, 1984, 18, 456–458. ˘ 292. Petrauskas, A.A. and Svedas, V.K. Hydrophobicity of -lactam antibiotics. Explanation and prediction of their behavior in various partitioning systems and reversed-phase chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1991, 585, 3–34. 293. Kaliszan, R., Nasal, A. and Markuszewski, M.J. New approaches to chromatographic determination of xenobiotics. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 2003, 377, 803–811. 294. Khaledi, M.G. and Breyer, E.D. Quantitation of hydrophobicity with micellar liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1989, 61, 1040–1047. 295. Detroyer, A., Vander Heyden, Y., Carda-Broch, S., Garciá-Alvarez-Coque, M.C. and Massart, D.L. Quantitative structure-retention and retention-activity relationships of -blocking agents by micellar liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 2001, 912, 211–221. 296. Martin-Biosca, Y., Molero-Monfort, M., Sagrado, S., Villanueva-Camanas, R.M. and Medina-Hernández, M.J. Development of predictive retention-activity relationship models of barbiturates by micellar liquid chromatography. Quant. Struct.-Act. Relat., 2000, 19, 247–256. 297. Tanaka, A., Nakamura, K., Nakanishi, I. and Fujiwara, H. A novel and useful descriptor for hydrophobicity, partition coefficient micellar-water, and its application to a QSAR study of antiplatelet agents. J. Med. Chem., 1994, 37, 4563–4566.
176
Advances in Chromatography
298. Martorell, C., Calpena, A.C., Escribano, E., Poblet, J.M. and Freixas, J. Influence of the chromatographic capacity factor (log k) as an index of lipophilicity in the antibacterial activity of a series of 6-fluoroquinolones: Relationship between physicochemical and structural properties and their hydrophobicity. J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 655, 177–184. 299. Garcia, M.A. and Marina, M.L. Study of the k or log k-logPow correlation for a group of benzene derivatives and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in micellar liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A, 1994, 687, 233–239. 300. Li, X. and Fritz, S. Mixed surfactants as mobile phase additives for the separation of organic compounds by HPLC. Anal. Chem., 1996, 68, 4481–4488. 301. Rodgers, A.H. and Khaledi, M.G. Influence of pH on retention and selectivity in micellar liquid chromatography: Consequences of micellar-induced shifts of ionization constants. Anal. Chem., 1994, 66, 327–334. 302. Zou, H., Zhang, Y., Hong, M. and Lu, P. Comparison of measurements of noctanol/water partition coefficient of organic ions by RP-HPLC and RP-IPC. Progress in Natural Science, 1995, 5, 106–112. 303. Zou, H., Zhang, Y., Hong, M. and Lu, P. Measurement of partition coefficients by reversed phase ion-pair chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 1992, 625, 169–175. 304. Foucault, A. Countercurrent chromatography. Anal. Chem., 1991, 63, 569–579. 305. Marston, A. and Hostettmann, K. Counter-current chromatography as a preparative tool, and perspectives. J. Chromatog. A, 1994, 658, 315–341. 306. http://www.pharma-tech.com. 307. Berthod, A. Centrifugal partition chromatography. Chromatographic Science, Vol. 68, Marcel Dekker, 167–196. 308. Berthod, A., Menges, R. and Armstrong, D. Direct octanol/water partition coefficient determination using co-current chromatography. J. Liq. Chromatogr., 1992, 15, 2769–2785. 309. Gluck, S.J., Martin, E. and Benko, M.H. Centrifugal partition chromatography for the determination of octanol-water partition coefficients, in in Foucault, A.P. (Ed), Centrifugal Partition Chromatography. Chromatographic Science, Vol. 68, Marcel Dekker, 1994, 199–218. 310. Avdeef, A. Absorption and drug development. Solubility, Permeability and Charge State, Wiley Interscience, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 2003.
4
Concepts and Practice of Multidimensional HighPerformance Liquid Chromatography R. Andrew Shalliker University of Western Sydney, Australia
Michael J. Gray University of Western Sydney, Australia
CONTENTS 4.1
4.2 4.3
4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7
Introduction ..................................................................................................178 4.1.1 Selectivity in Liquid Chromatography ............................................179 4.1.2 Solvent Selectivity ...........................................................................179 4.1.3 Stationary Phase Selectivity.............................................................180 4.1.4 Temperature Selectivity ...................................................................182 4.1.5 Mobile Phase pH Selectivity ...........................................................184 One-Dimensional Separations......................................................................184 Multidimensional Separations......................................................................185 4.3.1 Assessment of the Separation Potential ..........................................185 4.3.1.1 SMO Treatment of the Two-Dimensional Approach .......186 Types of Chromatographic Separation Displacements ...............................188 Two-Dimensional Chromatographic Systems .............................................191 Sample Dimensionality ................................................................................192 Orthogonality in Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatography .....................193 4.7.1 Determination of Orthogonality for Two-Dimensional Separations .......................................................................................195 4.7.2 Statistical Approaches ......................................................................197 4.7.2.1 Correlation Coefficients and Color Maps ........................197 4.7.2.2 Principle Component Analysis .........................................199 4.7.2.3 Information Theory...........................................................200 4.7.2.4 Geometric Approach to Factor Analysis ..........................202 4.7.2.5 Combination Methods ......................................................204
177
178
Advances in Chromatography
4.8
Application of Multidimensional Liquid Chromatography ........................208 4.8.1 Designing Two-Dimensional Separations in Accordance with the Findings of Orthogonality Studies ....................................212 4.8.2 Contour Maps...................................................................................215 4.8.3 Two-Dimensional System Design....................................................215 4.8.4 Dual- and Quad-Column Second-Dimension Designs....................218 4.9 Anomalies in Multidimensional Separations...............................................224 4.10 Conclusion....................................................................................................226 Acknowledgments..................................................................................................228 References..............................................................................................................228
4.1 INTRODUCTION High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is a long established method used for the separation, identification, and determination of chemical components in complex mixtures [1]. This analytical tool is employed for the qualitative identification and quantitative determination of separated species [1, 2] and finds widespread application in almost all areas of science. Many different modes of liquid chromatography exist that depend on the type of liquid and the type of stationary phase. For example, the technique referred to as normal phase liquid chromatography (NPLC) employs a polar stationary phase and a nonpolar mobile phase. The reverse of this process, referred to as reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), utilizes a nonpolar stationary phase and a polar mobile phase. In both these techniques, the stationary phase is usually a chemically modified solid support with either a polar or nonpolar ligand, depending on the desired mode of separation. Ion exchange liquid chromatography is a technique for separating ionic species where the solid support is chemically modified using an ionic ligand. Separation of charged species depends on the pH and electrolytic strength of the mobile phase. Ion exclusion and ion-paired chromatographies are two other techniques employed for the separation of ionic substances. Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) separates species according to their molecular size. Molecules traverse a porous stationary phase in a mobile-phase environment that is unfavorable for enthalpic interactions. The molecules are consequently separated according to their entropic exclusion from within the porous network. This technique is also referred to as gel permeation chromatography (GPC). Affinity chromatography is a technique with widespread use in the biosciences. In this technique, the stationary phase is modified with a solute receptor targeted for the retention and hence isolation of a specific solute. Chiral chromatography is employed for the separation of enantiomers. The stationary phase is modified with chiral ligands that preferentially retain one enantiomer; the technique is spatially selective. Chiral mobile phases can also be employed to exploit the “handedness” of the target molecules. These illustrations of the different modes of separation are by no means comprehensive but they do show the vast number of liquid chromatographic processes at the disposal of the chromatographer. In fact, too many different stationary phases exist to list here but a scan through any supplies catalogue will
Concepts and Practice of High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
179
illustrate the vast choices available to the chromatographer. Even then, there are many specialty stationary phases that are not commercially available. As a consequence, by appropriate selection of the most suitable techniques, there is virtually no sample — regardless of the complexity — that cannot be reduced to a simpler form, allowing for analysis of the sample constituents. In this chapter, we are not concerned with mechanisms of retention; rather, our interest lies in selectivity. The aim of this chapter is therefore to investigate processes in which selectivity can be exploited in order to gain separation. One way to increase selectivity and also increase the peak capacity of a liquid chromatographic system is to incorporate more than one separation dimension — that is, utilize the process referred to as multidimensional liquid chromatography. Here, multiple separating columns are coupled together in an automated system in such a manner as to improve the separation potential, allowing complex samples to be resolved into simpler systems. Before we begin our discussion on multidimensional chromatography, we must first discuss single-dimensional systems and understand factors that control selectivity.
4.1.1 SELECTIVITY
IN
LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY
Chromatographic separation depends on the selective retention of the stationary phase. The selectivity (α) can be expressed as a relative adjusted retention, referred to as the selectivity or separation factor [3]:
α=
k2 k1
(4.1)
where k1 and k2 are the retention factors of compound 1 and compound 2, respectively. By definition, α is greater than or equal to α unity and when α = 1, there is no separation. An increase in the separation selectivity is a powerful technique for improving resolution because it is only through the adjustment of selectivity that resolution can be increased and separation time can be decreased. Factors that influence the separation selectivity include the chemical composition of the stationary and mobile phases, temperature and mobile phase pH. However, it is often difficult to predict selectivity changes and a trial-and-error approach is often made when determining conditions for a change in α.
4.1.2 SOLVENT SELECTIVITY Solvent selectivity is well-documented and can have an enormous effect when choosing a chromatography system for a certain separation. Retention in RPLC, for example, is described in terms of the free energy change upon the transfer of solute from the mobile phase to the stationary phase. In two-phase partitioning processes of solutes, the enthalpic interactions determine the equilibrium, which is driven by the molecular interactions between the sample solute and the two phases [4]. The equilibria between the solutes and the mobile phase are primarily the result of four types of interactions: dispersion, dipole, hydrogen bonding, and dielectric [3].
180
Advances in Chromatography
Similar interactions occur between the sample and the stationary phase [3] and when different sample components have different equilibria and interactions, chromatographic selectivity is established. The ability of a sample or solvent molecule to interact in all four ways is commonly referred to as the polarity. It is well known that polar solvents dissolve polar compounds and, conversely, nonpolar solvents dissolve nonpolar solutes [3]. The effect of these intermolecular interactions on the retention behavior of a solute undergoing separation in liquid chromatography can be illustrated in the separation of the oligostyrenes, as shown in Figure 4.1. Each peak (labeled 3 to 13) corresponds to a different oligomer with the first peak (n = 3) corresponding to the trimer (i.e., an oligomer containing three configurational repeating units). On a C18 column with a methanol mobile phase, all the polystyrene diastereomers are eluted at the same time for each respective molecular weight. The uniformity and systematic band displacement suggests that all components have been completely separated; however, when an acetonitrile mobile phase is employed for the same separation, some of these bands shoulder, as shown in Figure 4.1b. This shouldering is due to the presence of different tactic isomers [5], which perfectly coelute in the C18methanol system, but when the mobile phase is changed to acetonitrile, the expression of diastereomer separation becomes apparent [6]. Various processes have been used to classify solvent selectivity but perhaps the most widely cited is the solvent-selectivity triangle proposed by Snyder [3]. This classification scheme is based on the gas–liquid distribution constants originally reported by Rohrschneider [7]. In this triangle, solvents are grouped on their ability to donate or accept protons and to induce a dipole moment. Eight distinct groups characterize the solvents in this triangle; solvents yielding similar selectivity are grouped in clusters. Separation selectivity is achieved by substituting one solvent from one group with that of a different solvent from another group. Substitution with solvents within the same selectivity group should result in little change to the separation selectivity. More recently, Kamlet et al. [7a] found that this classification was not entirely correct, since the test compounds used by Rohrschneider [7] could exhibit mixed-interaction tendencies. An alternative solvent-selectivity triangle [8] based on the Kamlet-Taft solvatochromic classification system was developed. Here, the solutes were less influenced by mixed-interaction effects. A comparison of the two solvent-selectivity triangles proposed using the data of Rohrschneider, and the Kamlet-Taft solvatochromic classification system revealed that for aliphatic solvents, the two triangles are, in general, similar with little difference in the relative assignment of different solvents according to their dipolarity, acidity, and basicity. However, the triangle proposed using the Kamlet-Taft system did show some important practical differences, especially in the case of reversed-phase liquid chromatography.
4.1.3 STATIONARY PHASE SELECTIVITY Selectivity can also be adjusted by changing the type of stationary phase. In general, this is less convenient than a change in mobile phase selectivity but it is an essential part of multidimensional liquid chromatographic systems. A change in stationary phase selectivity is also a powerful technique for improving resolution while possibly
Concepts and Practice of High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
200
5 6
160 Intensity (mV)
181
7 4
120 8 n=3
80
9 40
10 11
12
13
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Retention time (min) (a)
120 120
5 Intensity (mV)
6 100 4 Intensity (mV)
n= 3 80
n=6
100
7
80 60 40 20
60
0 8
6
40
7
Retention time (min) 9
20
10
11
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Retention time (min) (b)
FIGURE 4.1 Chromatogram of an oligomer separation of polystyrene with a molecular weight of 760 daltons. Column C18 Nucleosil 10 μm particle diameter (100 × 4.6 mm). (a) Mobile phase 100% methanol, flow rate 1.0 mL/min. (b) Mobile phase 100% acetonitrile, flow rate 1.0 mL/min.
182
Advances in Chromatography
decreasing the analysis time. An enormous array of stationary phases are available to the chromatographer but even if we limit discussion to reversed phase chromatography, a vast choice still remains, such as C18, C8, C4; a variety of polar endcapped reversed-phases and columns, such as the Synergi (Phenomenex) and the Xterra (Waters); and specialty columns like the Cosmosil range. Stationary phases that are highly specific towards diastereoisomer separations, such as the carbon clad zirconia (CCZ, ZirChrom Separations Inc.) and the HyperCarb (Merck) are also available in reversed-phase mode. Each of these phases can impart the possibility of different selectivity to separations governed by differences in retention mechanisms exhibited by solutes as they interact on the surface. As an example, two reversed-phase surfaces are worth contrasting (C18 and CCZ) that offer very different retention behavior, enabling them to be coupled in multidimensional systems that are RP-RP [9]. The C18 column needs no introduction in reversed-phase LC, as it is the most widely employed of all columns; however, the CCZ is relatively new and does not receive widespread application. The CCZ surface functions as an adsorption surface, commonly more retentive towards compounds with functional groups and is often more selective for the separation of isomers. The improved resolution of isomers results from very high sensitivity of the solid carbon surface to the geometric organization of the solute rather than from differences in column efficiency, as is usually observed for other reversed-phase methods [10, 11]. The separation of cis and trans-stilbene demonstrates the profound affect that solute structure and shape has on the diastereomeric selectivity of the carbon media. Each of the diastereomers has a unique shape and thus presents a different surface of electron density to the carbon phase [11] and this difference gives rise to the enormous selectivity factor observed. The separation of diastereomers of low molecular weight polystyrenes is another example where the selectivity between the C18 and CCZ surfaces is very different. Limited diastereomeric selectivity has been observed on conventional reversed-phase columns, such as the C18, where retention is largely governed by the molecular weight of the polymer. The chromatograms in Figure 4.2 illustrate this effect: In this figure, the separation of the diastereomers of the oligostyrene with four configurational repeating units and a sec-butyl end-group is illustrated. Eight diastereomers are present in this sample since the sec-butyl end-group has a site of stereochemistry. In Figure 4.2a, the separation of the eight diastereomers on the C18 column with an acetonitrile mobile phase all coelute in basically two bands. However, when on the CCZ column (also with an acetonitrile mobile phase, Figure 4.2b), the selectivity increases and seven of the eight isomers are resolved. The separation on the CCZ column is almost independent of molecular weight [9].
4.1.4 TEMPERATURE SELECTIVITY A change in the separation temperature can also change the separation selectivity [12, 13], particularly in ion-exchange and ion-pair chromatography. Little effect is often observed in liquid–liquid or liquid–solid chromatography; however, some interesting results have been reported on CCZ surfaces. When temperature is employed to alter the selectivity, decreasing the solvent strength is usually necessary
Concepts and Practice of High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
183
35 30
Intensity (mV)
25 20 Eight diastereomers 15 10 5 0 0
2
4
6 Retention time (min)
8
10
12
(a)
12
10
Intensity (mV)
8 Eight diastereomers 6
4
2
0 0
2
4
6 Retention time (min)
8
10
12
(b)
FIGURE 4.2 Illustration of the isomeric separation of sec-butyl oligostyrene (n = 4) on (a) a C18 column (Allsphere C18, 250 mm × 4.6 mm, Pd 5 μm) and (b) a carbon clad zirconia column (Self packed, 50 mm × 4.6 mm, Pd 3 μm). Flow rate 1.0 mL/min. Detection 262 nm. Injection volume 20 μL. Isocratic elution in 100% acetonitrile.
184
Advances in Chromatography
following an increase in temperature because an increase in temperature usually results in a decrease in retention.
4.1.5 MOBILE PHASE PH SELECTIVITY The separation selectivity of ionizable acids or bases can also be altered by a change in the pH of the mobile phase. When a change in the pH gives an optimum change in the separation selectivity but retention falls outside the desired range, the solvent strength can be adjusted essentially independently of selectivity by varying the proportions of components in the mobile phase, such as adjusting the salt concentration in the separation.
4.2 ONE-DIMENSIONAL SEPARATIONS One-dimensional liquid chromatography employs a single separation process on one chromatography column. That is, only one mechanism (ideally) is responsible for the retention of the solutes onto the stationary phase. For example, in size-exclusion chromatography, separation is governed by the size of the molecular species. Enthalpic interactions between the solute and the stationary phase surface are minimized [14]. If the mobile phase conditions are such that enthalpic interactions between the solute and the stationary phase are significant, the size exclusion process becomes more complicated than if only a single mechanism were responsible for the separation. Multiple mechanisms often lead to a reduction in the separation potential. Despite the fact that modern chromatographic columns are far superior to those of a decade ago, the actual separation power has only marginally increased because, as chromatographic columns have improved, overlapping components have begun to emerge from bands previously considered as single component peaks. Many samples are far more complex than first believed and the peak capacity of a single dimensional system is simply inadequate to resolve the required number of components. The peak capacity of a separation can be defined as the maximum number of peaks that can fit side by side into the available separation space, where each peak is resolved from neighboring peaks to satisfy some analytical goal [15–17]. Peak capacity provides a measure of the maximum number of components that can be resolved on a chromatographic run [16]. A peak capacity of 40 suggests that 40 single component peaks can fit side-by-side into the allowed retention volume range. However, this ideal situation virtually always exceeds the practical reality of the separations using current technologies [16]. Components are rarely uniformly distributed within the separation process and instead fall randomly along the chromatogram [18]. Davis et al. [18] has shown that single chromatographic separation systems often fail to separate even the simplest of complex samples, largely as a result of the random distribution of peaks throughout the separation. Consequently, component overlap theory (SMO) was developed using Poisson statistics to account for the random band displacement [18–20]. With this theory, Davis et al. predicted that the maximum number of randomly distributed bands that can be separated is approximately 37% of the theoretical limit if the bands were uniformly spaced. Moreover,
Concepts and Practice of High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
185
they showed that the number of single component peaks on the chromatogram would not exceed about 18% of the peak capacity even under the most favorable conditions. Finally, they showed that a chromatogram must be approximately 95% vacant in order to provide a 90% probability that a given component of interest will appear as an isolated peak [18]. The principal conclusion from these theories is that chromatograms of multicomponent complex mixtures contain a large fraction of unresolved or multicomponent peaks, and that complete separation of such mixtures by a single column is inadequate for the resolution of all the components. The statistical limitations on separations for a single chromatographic separation have been interpreted by many as a strong incentive for carrying out a separation incorporating more than one type of chromatographic system. A striking example of the limitations of a single chromatographic separation is shown by the separation of low molecular weight oligostyrenes using reversed-phase chromatography. Typically, a C18 column with a methanol mobile phase will bring about separation of the oligomers [21, 22] (Figure 4.1a) but the diastereomers begin to resolve when the mobile phase is changed to acetonitrile (Figure 4.1b). The resolving power of the (one-dimensional) LC system in this instance is insufficient for the complete separation of all the tactic isomers [23] because the sample components’ retention depends upon two different sample attributes: molecular weight and stereochemistry. These limitations and the desire to resolve increasingly complex mixtures have provided incentive for the development of multidimensional chromatography.
4.3 MULTIDIMENSIONAL SEPARATIONS 4.3.1 ASSESSMENT
OF THE
SEPARATION POTENTIAL
In an effort to overcome the limitation of single-dimension chromatographic separations, a great deal of work has been done on techniques that employ multiple retention processes. Multidimensional separation techniques constitute a powerful class of methods in which different separation steps, based on different selective retention processes, are linked [24]. Linkage of separation steps is usually tailored such that each dimension is selective towards a particular sample attribute and, for the sake of simplicity, this discussion will be limited to two-dimensional (2D) separations. The term “two-dimensional chromatography” has its origin in flat-bed or thin-layer chromatography, where chromatographic development is defined by migration of sample components in one direction followed by migration in a second dimension, perpendicular to the first [25–27]. Coincidently, Guiochon and coworkers [28] in the early 1980s suggested a theoretical two-dimensional liquid chromatographic column that operated in a similar manner to a 2D-TLC plate. Such a system, however, would prove to be difficult to manufacture and operate correctly. A 2D liquid chromatographic system is thus one in which two separate LC columns are linked in successive stages. Two-dimensional separation systems encompass an enormous array of combinations of separation systems. Even within distinct techniques such as liquid
186
Advances in Chromatography
chromatography, the variety in selectivities and even combination order varies greatly. Some common examples to realize the potential of 2D separations include IEC-RPLC [29–31], SEC-RPLC [32], RPLC-NPLC [33, 34], LC-CE [35–37], and LC-GC [38–41]. The power of a 2D separation may be measured by the twodimensional peak capacity. Multidimensional techniques have an intrinsic ability for providing significantly larger peak capacities relative to single step separation systems that, in turn, reduce the probability of component overlap [24]. Theoretically, the peak capacity of a 2D separation is calculated by a multiplicative law in which the peak capacity of a 2D separation is the product of the individual peak capacities of the constituent one-dimensional separations (e.g., NT = N1 × N2) [27, 42–44]. Typically, in a coupled system, maximum resolution and peak capacity (separation space) occur when the retention mechanisms are different. The more divergent the retention mechanisms are in each dimension, the greater the separation potential [45]. Separative potential will decrease as retention correlation between separation dimensions increases until perfect correlation is obtained, whereby the two-dimensional system will have a separative power equivalent to a single-mode chromatographic step [45]. Figure 4.3a shows the theoretical peak capacities for two separate chromatographic separations (one- and two-dimensional) in which the peak capacity is equal to the number of boxes along any one axis. The maximum peak capacity of the twodimensional chromatographic separation (first dimension × second dimension) is represented by the total number of boxes and is equal to the product of the peak capacities of the individual separations. Figure 4.3b shows the component peaks distributed randomly over a two dimensional space that has enough space so as to minimize the overlap of individual peaks (represented as ellipses). Substantial peak overlap occurs along any one axis of the two-dimensional plot, shown in Figure 4.13b. In this case, the chromatogram that would be observed along a single chromatographic dimension becomes crowded with substantial band overlap. Thus, a reduction in peak crowding and hence overlap is realized when the chromatographic separation is expanded to a higher dimensional separation [27, 46]. 4.3.1.1 SMO Treatment of the Two-Dimensional Approach Davis has further extended the statistical work of the SMO theory and broadened its applicability to two-dimensional separations. According to SMO in one dimension, the number of single component peaks is calculated by Equation 4.2 [18]: S = nc αe–2α
(4.2)
The maximum number of single component peaks per peak capacity unit is: (s/nc)max = 1/2 e–1 = 0.1839
(4.3)
where s is the expected number of singlet spots or peaks, nc is the peak capacity and α is a saturation factor (equal to m/nc where m is the statistical approximation
Concepts and Practice of High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
2nd
187
dim
ens
ion
(a)
on
nsi
1st
e dim
(b)
FIGURE 4.3 (a) Two-dimensional peak capacity as determined by the multiplicative rule. (b) The reduction in band overlap in going to two dimensions.
to the number of detectable peaks). In two dimensions, the number of single component peaks is calculated by Equation 4.4 [47]: s = m e–4α
(4.4)
Therefore, the probability that a peak will exist as a single component peak is less than that in a one-dimensional separation (by a factor of e–2α). The number of singlecomponent peaks per unit peak capacity is calculated using Equation 4.5 for a twodimensional separation. s/nc = αe–4α
(4.5)
Davis and coworkers were able to show that by differentiating Equation 4.4 with respect to α and equating the result to zero, the maximum value of s/nc (0.092) occurs α = 1/4. Two-dimensional separations actually perform less efficiently per unit peak capacity than corresponding one-dimensional separations [15, 47]. According to Equation 4.4 and Equation 4.5, the maximum number of single component peaks is approximately 9% of the peak capacity, compared to a one-dimensional separation where the number of single component peaks is estimated as approximately 18%.
188
Advances in Chromatography
This discrepancy occurs in a two-dimensional system because overlap can occur in two dimensions [47] and may seem detrimental to the aim of the separation problem; however, the enormous peak capacity afforded by the coupling of two separate dimensions nullifies this effect. As an example, a one-dimensional system having a peak capacity of approximately 50 may be expected to resolve with an 18% probability and obtain nine single-component peaks that are randomly distributed throughout the chromatogram. By comparison, a two-dimensional system having a peak capacity of 50 and 10 in the first and second dimensions, respectively, could be expected to resolve 45 randomly distributed single component peaks with a 9% probability.
4.4 TYPES OF CHROMATOGRAPHIC SEPARATION DISPLACEMENTS Displacements in a two-dimensional separation can be categorized into two broad groups [48]: (1) simultaneous displacement, where the displacement of a sample component zone across the two dimensions of the 2D field occurs at the same time; and (2) sequential displacement, where move