DK4478_C000.fm Page i Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
Half Title Page VOLUME 45
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY
DK447...
116 downloads
828 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DK4478_C000.fm Page i Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
Half Title Page VOLUME 45
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY
DK4478_C000.fm Page ii Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
DK4478_C000.fm Page iii Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
Title Page VOLUME 45
Advances in CHROMATOGRAPHY EDITORS:
ELI GRUSHK A Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem, Israel
NELU GRINBERG Boehringer-Ingelheim Pharmaceutical, Inc. Ridgefield, Connecticut, U.S.A.
Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
DK4478_C000.fm Page iv Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number-10: 1-57444-735-1 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number-13: 978-1-57444-735-4 (Hardcover) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www. copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC) 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
DK4478_C000.fm Page v Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
Contributors Abby Brown Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Violet Calderon Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Dinora B. Chinchilla Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Frank A. Gomez Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Amber M. Hupp Department of Chemistry Michigan State University East Lansing, Michigan Daniela Hutanu Department of Chemistry Oregon State University Corvallis, Oregon Xiaoping Li Department of Chemistry Michigan State University East Lansing, Michigan
Victoria L. McGuffin Department of Chemistry Michigan State University East Lansing, Michigan Ruth Montes Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Colin F. Poole Department of Chemistry Wayne State University Detroit, Michigan Alejandra Ramirez Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California Vincent T. Remcho Department of Chemistry Oregon State University Corvallis, Oregon Sabine Schefzick Pfizer Global Research and Development Discovery Technologies Ann Arbor Laboratories Ann Arbor, Michigan Nicholas H. Snow Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry Seton Hall University South Orange, New Jersey
DK4478_C000.fm Page vi Friday, September 22, 2006 8:48 AM
Taguhi Sogomonyan Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California James D. Stuart Department of Chemistry University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut
Jose Zavaleta Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry California State University Los Angeles, California
DK4478_bookTOC.fm Page vii Friday, September 22, 2006 8:49 AM
Contents Chapter 1
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography...................................................................................1
Xiaoping Li, Amber M. Hupp, and Victoria L. McGuffin Chapter 2
Applications of Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis ............................................................................89
Colin F. Poole Chapter 3
Applications of Capillary Electrophoresis to Molecular Recognition and Analysis of In-Capillary Enzyme-Mediated Transformations................................................................................125
Jose Zavaleta, Dinora B. Chinchilla, Abby Brown, Alejandra Ramirez, Violet Calderon, Taguhi Sogomonyan, Ruth Montes, and Frank A. Gomez Chapter 4
Aptamers as Molecular Recognition Elements in Chromatographic Separations ..........................................................173
Daniela Hutanu and Vincent T. Remcho Chapter 5
Advances in High-Throughput High-Performance Liquid Chromatography and “Purification-Friendly” Combinatorial Library Design Strategies ................................................................197
Sabine Schefzick Chapter 6
Biological, Clinical, and Forensic Analysis Using Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography ...............215
Nicholas H. Snow Chapter 7
Determination of Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals Found in Environmental Samples by Gas Chromatography/ Mass Spectrometry...........................................................................245
James D. Stuart Index ......................................................................................................................275
DK4478_bookTOC.fm Page viii Friday, September 22, 2006 8:49 AM
DK4478_book.fm Page 1 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
1
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography Xiaoping Li, Amber M. Hupp, and Victoria L. McGuffin
CONTENTS I. Introduction....................................................................................................2 II. Theory ............................................................................................................2 A. Thermodynamics ...................................................................................4 B. Kinetics..................................................................................................8 III. Methods........................................................................................................10 A. Perturbation Methods ..........................................................................10 1. Temperature Jump Method ...........................................................11 2. Pressure Jump Method ..................................................................11 3. Dipole Jump Method.....................................................................12 B. Shallow Bed Method...........................................................................12 C. Chromatographic Methods..................................................................13 1. Frontal Method..............................................................................13 2. Impulse Method.............................................................................13 IV. Applications of Thermodynamic and Kinetic Methods..............................19 A. Partition ...............................................................................................19 1. Fundamental Studies of the Retention Mechanism......................20 2. Effect of Alkyl Chain Length and Bonding Density....................22 3. Effect of Support ...........................................................................33 4. Effect of Mobile Phase Composition............................................ 34 5. Effect of Solute Structure and Concentration............................... 37 B. Adsorption ...........................................................................................45 1. Poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) ........................................................45 2. Porous Graphitic Carbon...............................................................47 3. Other Organic Adsorbents............................................................. 52 4. Silica ..............................................................................................53 C. Ion Exchange.......................................................................................57 D. Size Exclusion .....................................................................................60
1
DK4478_book.fm Page 2 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
2
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
E.
Chiral ...................................................................................................62 1. Brush CSPs....................................................................................62 2. Inclusion CSPs ..............................................................................64 3. Polysaccharide CSPs .....................................................................68 4. Affinity CSPs.................................................................................73 V. Conclusion ...................................................................................................76 References................................................................................................................77
I. INTRODUCTION In liquid chromatography, the retention mechanisms broadly consist of partition, adsorption, complexation, ion exchange, and size exclusion [1]. These mechanisms may occur individually or in various combinations. When a combination of mechanisms occurs intentionally, that is, by specific and deliberate design, it is generally beneficial to the resulting separation. However, when a combination occurs unintentionally or by accident, it is generally detrimental to the separation. A deep understanding of the retention mechanism is necessary in order to maximize the beneficial contributions and minimize the detrimental contributions to the separation. This understanding is also helpful to guide the development of commercially available stationary phases with better performance. Thermodynamic information provides an understanding of the energetic interactions between the solute and the mobile and stationary phases, which are intrinsically related to the aspects of retention and selectivity. Kinetic information provides an understanding of the rates of mass transport processes, which are intrinsically related to the efficiency or plate height. Both thermodynamic and kinetic information are necessary in order to optimize resolution [1,2]. In this chapter, the fundamental theories of thermodynamics and kinetics are briefly summarized and the experimental methods of determining thermodynamic and kinetic parameters are described. The application of these methods to the most common retention mechanisms in liquid chromatography is reviewed. Because of the great depth and breadth of information available, particularly in thermodynamics, this review is not intended to be exhaustive, but rather illustrative of the characteristic features that distinguish each retention mechanism.
II. THEORY The thermodynamics and kinetics of solute transfer between the mobile and stationary phases in liquid chromatography can be treated in several ways. Most commonly, the retention process is treated as if it were analogous to a chemical reaction. For a partition mechanism, this may be represented as a simple first-order reaction, ⎯⎯ ⎯ → Xs Xm ← ⎯
(1.1)
DK4478_book.fm Page 3 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
3
for a solute (X) distributed between the mobile (m) and stationary (s) phases. For an adsorption, complexation, or ion exchange mechanism, where the number of stationary phase sites (S) is limited, a second-order reaction is more appropriate: ⎯⎯ ⎯ → XS Xm + S ← ⎯
(1.2)
⎯⎯ ⎯ → XS + Dm , Xm + DS ← ⎯
(1.3)
or
where D is a displacing agent that is added to the mobile phase. If the concentrations of stationary phase sites and the displacing agent are sufficiently large, these mechanisms may be treated as pseudo-first-order reactions. The treatment of the retention process as a chemical reaction involves a rather simplistic view. First, chemical reactions occur in homogeneous solution and the reactants have relatively well-defined energies and diffusion distances between them. The chromatographic system is intrinsically heterogeneous at the macroscopic level, as it involves two immiscible phases. Moreover, the phases themselves are also heterogeneous at the microscopic and molecular levels. The bulk mobile phase composition may be substantially different from that near the surface of the stationary phase or in the pores. The stationary phase may have several different types of retention sites or even different retention mechanisms. Because of these heterogeneities, the energy of the solute in the mobile and stationary phases is not as well defined as in a chemical reaction. Second, given sufficient time, the chemical reaction can achieve a state of equilibrium in which the rates of the forward and reverse reactions are equal and the activities (or concentrations) of the products and reactants remain constant. The chromatographic system, by virtue of dynamic flow, can never achieve this macroscopic state of equilibrium, but may, under suitable conditions, achieve a microscopic condition of steady state [2]. Despite this simplistic view, the treatment of liquid chromatography as a chemical reaction is prevalent, as it provides considerable insight into the rank and magnitude of the various contributions to the retention mechanism. If the retention process is considered as a chemical reaction, then an energy coordinate diagram (Figure 1.1) can be used to explain the analogous thermodynamic and kinetic contributions. In this diagram, the solute transfers from the mobile phase (Xm) to the stationary phase (Xs) through a high-energy transition state (X‡). The thermodynamic parameters, such as the change in molar enthalpy (ΔH) and molar volume (ΔV), are characterized by the difference between the final and initial states. These thermodynamic quantities represent the weighted average of all of the available states in the heterogeneous stationary and mobile phases, respectively. The kinetic aspects of the retention event can be described by using transition-state theory. The transfer from the mobile to stationary phase is characterized by a fast equilibrium between the mobile phase and transition state with preequilibrium
DK4478_book.fm Page 4 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
4
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
X‡
Energy
Km‡
ΔVm‡ ΔHm‡
kms
Xm ΔV ΔH Xs Reaction coordinate
FIGURE 1.1 Energy coordinate diagram depicting the transfer of solute X from the mobile phase (m) to the stationary phase (s). Associated thermodynamic and kinetic parameters are described in the text.
constant Km‡, followed by a rate-limiting step between the transition state and the stationary phase with rate constant kms. The kinetic parameters, such as the activation enthalpy (ΔHm‡) and activation volume (ΔVm‡), can be used to elucidate the kinetic description of the retention event. For the transfer from the stationary to mobile phase, the preequilibrium constant Ks‡ and rate constant ksm are used to determine the corresponding activation enthalpy (ΔHs‡) and activation volume (ΔVs‡). These kinetic quantities represent the weighted average of all available paths between the final and initial states. The derivation of these thermodynamic and kinetic quantities is described in the following sections.
A. THERMODYNAMICS As noted above, equilibrium is not attained due to the dynamic nature of the chromatographic system. However, at the microscopic level, steady-state conditions may be achieved in which the activity (or concentration) of the solute in the mobile and stationary phases (am and as, respectively) achieves a constant value: K=
as = kβ , am
(1.4)
where K is the equilibrium constant, k is the retention factor, and β is the phase ratio. The phase ratio is defined as the volume of the stationary phase divided by the volume of the stationary phase. The ratio of the equilibrium constants or retention factors for two solutes defines the selectivity (α): α=
K 2 k2 , = K1 k1
(1.5)
DK4478_book.fm Page 5 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
5
where the subscripts 1 and 2 denote the less and more retained solutes, respectively. This ratio may reflect the differences between members of a homologous series (methylene group selectivity), between solutes with the same aliphatic or aromatic structure but varying in functional group (functional group selectivity), or between chiral solutes (enantiomeric selectivity). The equilibrium constant is related to the change in molar Gibbs free energy (ΔG) by ln K =
−ΔG , RT
(1.6)
where R is the gas constant and T is the temperature. The selectivity for two solutes is correspondingly related as ln α = ln
K 2 − ΔΔG , = K1 RT
(1.7)
where ΔΔG represents the difference in molar Gibbs free energy for methylene selectivity, functional group selectivity, or enantiomeric selectivity. The Gibbs free energy is related to the changes in molar enthalpy (ΔH) and molar entropy (ΔS) by the Gibbs-Helmholtz equation [3]: ΔG = ΔH − T ΔS .
(1.8)
By substitution, the retention factor can be related to the molar enthalpy and molar entropy: ln k = ln K − ln β =
− ΔH ΔS + − ln β . RT R
(1.9)
The change in molar enthalpy can be determined by graphing the natural logarithm of the retention factor versus inverse temperature at constant pressure. This will yield a slope that is related to the change in molar enthalpy and an intercept that contains information about the change in molar entropy and the phase ratio. When the phase ratio is known, the molar entropy can be determined from the intercept. However, the phase ratio is often unknown and accurate determination of the molar entropy is not possible. The phase ratio and the molar entropy must be independent of temperature for accurate determination of the molar enthalpy. The change in molar enthalpy will be positive for an endothermic transfer and negative for an exothermic transfer of the solute from the mobile to stationary phase. Although there are some noteworthy exceptions (vide infra), most successful separations in liquid chromatography involve an energetically favorable exothermic process. The change in molar entropy will be positive when there is a favorable dissipation of energy through an increase in the number or distribution of microstates. This most commonly occurs
DK4478_book.fm Page 6 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
6
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
through a change in volume or concentration, leading to a change in configurational entropy as the solute is transferred from the mobile to the stationary phase. The selectivity for two solutes is correspondingly related as ln α =
− ΔΔH ΔΔS + . RT R
(1.10)
Thus, a graph of the natural logarithm of the selectivity vs. inverse temperature will yield from the slope and intercept the differential change in molar enthalpy (ΔΔH) and molar entropy (ΔΔS), respectively, associated with methylene selectivity, functional group selectivity, or enantiomeric selectivity. From the definition of molar enthalpy [3], ΔH = ΔE + P ΔV ,
(1.11)
where ΔE is the change in molar internal energy, V is the change in molar volume, and P is the pressure. Substitution of Equation 1.11 into Equation 1.9 yields ln k =
− ΔE P ΔV ΔS − + − ln β . RT RT R
(1.12)
The change in molar volume can be determined by graphing the natural logarithm of the retention factor vs. pressure at constant temperature. This will yield a slope that is related to the change in molar volume and an intercept that contains information about the molar internal energy, molar entropy, and phase ratio. These parameters must be independent of pressure for accurate determination of the molar volume. The change in molar volume will be positive when the solute occupies a larger volume and negative when the solute occupies a smaller volume in the stationary phase than in the mobile phase. The selectivity for two solutes is correspondingly related as ln α =
− ΔΔE P ΔΔV ΔΔS − + . RT RT R
(1.13)
Thus, a graph of the natural logarithm of the selectivity vs. pressure will yield from the slope the differential change in molar volume (ΔΔV) associated with the methylene selectivity, functional group selectivity, or enantiomeric selectivity. To gain a greater understanding of the balance of thermodynamic contributions to solute retention, enthalpy-entropy compensation is very useful. For a pair or series of solutes that obeys a linear free energy relationship [4], there exists a hypothetical temperature at which the relative changes in enthalpy and entropy are balanced and the net change in free energy is zero. By rearrangement of Equation 1.8, this compensation temperature (Tc) can be expressed as
DK4478_book.fm Page 7 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
Tc =
ΔΔH . ΔΔS
7
(1.14)
At this temperature, the pair or series of solutes would coelute and no separation would be achieved (α = 1.0). Hence, it is also called the isoselective or isoenantioselective temperature (Tiso) in chiral separations. A compensation temperature that is substantially greater than the ambient temperature suggests that the retention mechanism is enthalpy dominated, whereas a compensation temperature that is less than the ambient temperature is entropy dominated. The compensation temperature can be determined from the slope of a graph of the change in molar enthalpy versus the change in molar entropy, both derived from Equation 1.9. However, for statistical reasons, a linear relationship may be observed between ΔH and ΔS, even in the absence of enthalpy-entropy compensation [5]. Krug et al. [6] investigated different methods to identify true enthalpy-entropy compensation that is not influenced by statistical artifacts. By means of Equation 1.8, the free energy at a specific temperature (T) can be related to the free energy at the compensation temperature (Tc) by T ⎞ T ΔGTc ⎛ . ΔG = ΔH ⎜ 1 − ⎟ + ⎝ Tc ⎠ Tc
(1.15)
The retention factor can then be related to the free energy at the compensation temperature by ln k = −
ΔH ⎛ 1 1 ⎞ ΔGTC − + + ln β . R ⎜⎝ T Tc ⎟⎠ RTc
(1.16)
Thus, a graph of the natural logarithm of the retention factor vs. the change in molar enthalpy can be used to evaluate enthalpy-entropy compensation. If compensation occurs, this graph will be linear and the slope can be used to calculate the compensation temperature. The compensation temperature can be used to compare the retention mechanisms for different solutes, different mobile phases, or different stationary phases. As discussed by Ranatunga et al. [7], if the compensation temperatures are identical, then the relative contributions of enthalpy and entropy to the overall free energy are the same for the two systems. However, if compensation temperatures are different, then the underlying retention mechanism must be distinctly different. This concept of compensation is readily extensible [8]. In the same way that the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy are related through free energy in Equation 1.8, the changes in molar enthalpy and volume are related through the internal energy in Equation 1.11. Hence, for a pair or series of solutes that obey a linear internal energy relationship, there exists a hypothetical pressure at which the relative changes in enthalpy and volume are balanced and the net change in internal
DK4478_book.fm Page 8 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
8
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
energy is zero. By rearrangement of Equation 1.11, this compensation pressure (Pc) can be expressed as ΔΔH . ΔΔV
Pc =
(1.17)
A compensation pressure that is substantially greater than the operating pressure suggests that the retention mechanism is enthalpy dominated, whereas a compensation pressure that is less than the operating pressure is volume dominated. The compensation pressure can be determined from the slope of a graph of the change in molar enthalpy versus the change in molar volume, derived from Equations 1.9 and 1.12, respectively. Because these thermodynamic quantities are not derived by linear regression from the same experimental data, there are no difficulties with statistical artifacts. The compensation pressure can be used, in combination with the compensation temperature, to compare the retention mechanisms for different solutes, different mobile phases, or different stationary phases.
B. KINETICS Whereas thermodynamic information is vital, kinetic information provides a deeper understanding of the retention mechanism. There are two common approaches to describe kinetic behavior. The first approach, consistent with the thermodynamic treatment, is to consider the retention process as a chemical reaction. The general principles of chemical kinetics are then applicable [3]. The second approach, commonly used in chemical engineering, is to characterize the rates at which the individual mass transfer processes occur. Each of these approaches provides a valuable and complementary description of the retention process and will be described herein. If the retention process is treated as a first-order or pseudo-first-order reaction according to Equation 1.1, kms
⎯⎯⎯ ⎯⎯ →X , Xm ← k ⎯ s
(1.18)
sm
then kms and ksm are the corresponding rate constants for solute transfer from the mobile to stationary phase and from the stationary to mobile phase, respectively. These designations for the rate constants will be used throughout this chapter, regardless of the retention mechanism (partition, adsorption, ion exchange, size exclusion, etc.). These are “lumped” rate constants, that is, they comprise all contributions to the kinetic behavior, including the sorption/desorption event, diffusion in the mobile and stationary phases, diffusion in pores and stagnant layers, interfacial resistance to mass transfer, etc. The rate constants, which reflect the kinetic behavior, are related to the retention factor, which reflects the thermodynamic behavior, by k=
kms . ksm
(1.19)
DK4478_book.fm Page 9 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
9
By analogy to the thermodynamic treatment, the ratio of the rate constants for two solutes may be used to define the kinetic selectivity (αms and αsm). For example,
α ms =
(k ) (k )
ms 2
,
(1.20)
ms 1
where the subscripts 1 and 2 denote the less and more retained solutes, respectively. This ratio may reflect the kinetic differences associated with methylene selectivity, functional group selectivity, or enantiomeric selectivity. The detailed kinetic parameters (Figure 1.1) can be elucidated by applying a combination of thermodynamic and transition-state theories. The rate constant kms is expressed by the Arrhenius equation [3] as ⎛ − ΔEm ‡ ⎞ , kms = Am ‡ exp ⎜ ⎝ RT ⎟⎠
(1.21)
where Am‡ is the preexponential factor and ΔEm‡ is the activation energy for the transfer from the mobile to stationary phase. By rearrangement,
ln kms = ln Am‡ −
ΔEm‡ . RT
(1.22)
The activation energy can be determined by graphing the natural logarithm of the rate constant versus inverse temperature at constant pressure. This will yield a slope that is related to the activation energy and an intercept that contains information about the preexponential factor. The activation energy represents the energetic barrier that must be overcome for solute transfer from the mobile to stationary phase. The kinetic selectivity is correspondingly related as
ln α ms = ln
(k ) (k )
ms 2 ms 1
=
− ΔΔEm‡ , RT
(1.23)
where ΔΔEm‡ represents the difference in activation energy for methylene selectivity, functional group selectivity, or enantiomeric selectivity. By using classical thermodynamic relationships, the activation energy is given by ΔEm ‡ = ΔH m ‡ + RT − P ΔVm ‡ . By substitution into Equation 1.22,
(1.24)
DK4478_book.fm Page 10 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
10
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
ln kms = ln Am ‡ −
ΔH m ‡ + RT − P ΔVm ‡ . RT
(1.25)
The activation volume can be determined by graphing the natural logarithm of the rate constant vs. pressure at constant temperature. This will yield a slope that is related to the activation volume and an intercept that contains information about the activation enthalpy and preexponential factor. The activation enthalpy and preexponential factor must be independent of pressure for determination of the activation volume. The activation volume represents the volumetric barrier that must be overcome for solute transfer from the mobile to stationary phase. The activation enthalpy can then be calculated from the activation energy and activation volume via Equation 1.24. In a similar manner, the rate constant ksm can be used to determine the activation energy (ΔEs‡), activation volume (ΔVs‡), and activation enthalpy (ΔHs‡) for solute transfer from the stationary to mobile phase. These kinetic quantities provide a detailed description of the energetic and volumetric requirements of the retention process that complement the thermodynamic description. Another approach, which is more common in the engineering literature, is to evaluate the individual mass transfer processes that contribute to band broadening. Miyabe and Guiochon [9] identified four primary mass transfer processes: axial dispersion, external mass transfer, intraparticle diffusion, and sorption/desorption kinetics. Axial dispersion is broadening that occurs in the bulk mobile phase, including axial diffusion and multiple paths through the packed bed. External mass transfer occurs as the solute moves from the bulk mobile phase through the thin stagnant film at or near the particle surface. Intraparticle diffusion occurs as the solute migrates into the pore of the particle. This process consists not only of solute diffusion through the mobile phase in the pore, but also surface diffusion on the wall of the particle. Finally, as the solute sorbs to and from the surface, slow mass transfer arises from the sorption/desorption event. These mass transfer processes are considered as individual and separable contributions to the overall broadening and rate constant. The mathematical treatment of this approach will be described in Section III.C.2.a.
III. METHODS A. PERTURBATION METHODS Among the available methods for evaluation of thermodynamic and kinetic parameters, perturbation methods play an important role [10,11]. Perturbation methods represent the simplest approach, wherein the solute, mobile phase, and stationary phase of interest are contained in a small, static cell. A fast perturbation is applied to the equilibrium in order to alter the activity or concentration of the solute in the mobile and stationary phases (Equation 1.4). The perturbation may be achieved by rapidly changing conditions such as temperature, pressure, or dipole moment. After perturbation, the rate of relaxation of the system to the new conditions is monitored, followed by mathematical extraction of the equilibrium and rate constants. The
DK4478_book.fm Page 11 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
11
advantage of the perturbation methods is their simplicity, where thermodynamic and kinetic behavior can be measured without interference from flow contributions. The measured rate constants consist of the sorption/desorption process and diffusional contributions to mass transfer. One of the limitations of these methods is that they require perturbation, during which the actual thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of the system is altered. Hence, the determined values of equilibrium and rate constants are neither those of the initial state nor those of the final state after perturbation. In order to minimize the required perturbation, the equilibrium constant should be as close to unity as possible. This ensures the greatest change in activity or concentration for a given perturbation of the system. In addition, the perturbation must be applied uniformly to the entire system and with sufficient speed that it does not contribute to the observed kinetic behavior. Although these methods are very promising, their application to chromatographic systems has been relatively limited. 1. Temperature Jump Method The temperature jump method is the most versatile and useful of the perturbation methods. This method is based on the concept that chemical equilibria, including retention processes, are usually associated with a nonzero enthalpy change and thus are temperature dependent. The shift in the equilibrium constant depends on the change in molar enthalpy according to Equation 1.9: ⎛ ∂ ln K ⎞ ΔH ⎜⎝ ∂T ⎟⎠ = RT 2 . P
(1.26)
The temperature pulse can be induced by Joule heating [12–15], dielectric heating [16], or optical heating [17]. The instrument is relatively simple to construct and the speed of heating is sufficient for a wide range of inorganic, organic, and biochemical equilibrium reactions. 2. Pressure Jump Method The pressure jump method is based on the concept that chemical equilibria, including retention processes, display a more or less marked dependence on pressure. The shift in the equilibrium constant depends on the change in molar volume according to Equation 1.12: ⎛ ∂ ln K ⎞ − ΔV ⎜⎝ ∂P ⎟⎠ = RT T
(1.27)
The pressure pulse can be produced either by a sudden application or release of pressure in the system. The pressure jump method does not have as wide a range of applications as the temperature jump method because of the limited number of reactions that exhibit a sufficiently large pressure dependence. However, this method
DK4478_book.fm Page 12 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
12
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
has been beneficial for the study of sorption/desorption of charged species, due to their relatively large changes in molar volume [18]. 3. Dipole Jump Method The dipole jump method is based on the change in dipole moment induced by photoexcitation. Many chromophores exhibit different dipole moments in the ground and excited states as a consequence of electronic redistribution after photoexcitation. This change in the dipole moment can influence the relative affinity of the solute for the mobile and stationary phases [19]. The net change in solubility depends upon the magnitude of the change in the dipole moment as well as the absorption cross section and fraction of molecules in the excited state. Because high photon flux may be required to ensure large absorption cross sections, due care must be taken to avoid thermal heating. In addition, excited-state reactions of the solute must be avoided. In the absence of these effects, the shift in the equilibrium constant depends on the change in solute activity (or concentration) according to Equation 1.4.
B. SHALLOW BED METHOD The shallow bed method can be considered as an intermediate between perturbation methods and chromatographic methods. In this method, the stationary phase particles are packed in an extremely short (“zero length”) column. The experiments may be performed in two ways, by sorption (uptake) or desorption (release) methods. In the sorption method, a mobile phase solution containing the solute flows through the shallow bed at a high linear velocity. The concentration of the solute in the effluent solution is nearly identical to that in the influent solution. If the linear velocity is sufficiently high, the stagnant diffusion layer surrounding the particle will be thin. Hence, the time required for diffusion through this layer will be small compared to the time required for the slow intraparticle processes. As a result, the intraparticle processes will determine the observed sorption rate. After a certain time, the flow is stopped and the amount of solute that has been sorbed is measured by eluting it out of the shallow bed. This measurement provides a single point on the sorption curve. This experiment is then repeated for varied sorption times to construct the complete sorption rate curve. An alternative approach that is less time consuming and labor intensive is the desorption method. In this method, the shallow bed is preequilibrated by flow of a mobile phase solution containing the solute. To initiate the experiment, the flow is abruptly shifted to a solute-free mobile phase, which causes the solute to be desorbed from the bed. By detecting the eluted solute concentration as a function of time, the desorption curve can be constructed from a single experiment. Specifically, the concentration, C(t), is a function of the instantaneous molecular desorption rate of the solute, dni(t)/dt, and the flow rate, F, as follows: C (t ) =
( dn (t ) / dt ) . i
F
(1.28)
DK4478_book.fm Page 13 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
13
After integration, the desorption rate curve is constructed as t
∫
ni ( t ) = F C ( t ) dt .
(1.29)
0
The desorption rate curve is then fit by nonlinear regression to different theoretical models, such as the linear driving force model or spherical diffusion model, to extract the rate constants [20–23].
C. CHROMATOGRAPHIC METHODS Chromatographic methods are the most widely used methods for determining the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of a system. In contrast to perturbation methods, chromatographic methods are dynamic, with the mobile phase flowing through the column at all times. In this way, the contribution of flow phenomena to the zone profile cannot be neglected. The two most common chromatographic methods are the frontal and impulse methods. 1. Frontal Method In frontal analysis, the column is preequilibrated with the mobile phase. Then a solution containing a known concentration of solute in the mobile phase is introduced continuously. As the solute sorbs onto the stationary phase, the column becomes saturated and the concentration of solute eluting from the column gradually increases, forming a characteristic breakthrough curve. The mean position of the breakthrough curve can be related to the concentration and equilibrium constant of the solute as well as the sorption capacity of the column. The amount of solute sorbed is calculated from the breakthrough curve in order to derive a single point on the equilibrium isotherm. This process is repeated for progressively increasing concentrations of the solute to construct the complete isotherm. To obtain kinetic information, theoretical breakthrough curves are numerically calculated for each concentration step. These theoretical curves use different values of the rate constant in the transport model, together with the equilibrium isotherm determined from the breakthrough data. The theoretical breakthrough curves are then compared to the experimental ones. The rate coefficient is determined in such a way that the best agreement is observed between the theoretical and experimental breakthrough curves. In this approach, it is assumed that the rate constant remains invariant during each concentration step in the frontal analysis measurement and that this rate constant corresponds to the average concentration of each step [9]. 2. Impulse Method The impulse method is generally performed by injecting a small volume of the solute onto the column. The elution of the solute zone is monitored by on-column or
DK4478_book.fm Page 14 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
14
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
postcolumn detection. The retention factor and rate constants can be extracted by any of the following models. a. Plate Height Model In this model, the thermodynamic and kinetic parameters are determined from the mean and the broadening of the zone profile, respectively. The broadening or plate height may be determined in a variety of ways, but the most accurate is the statistical moments, as they make no assumptions about the shape of the zone profile. The first and second statistical moments are calculated from the zone profile as
M1 =
∫ C(t ) t dt ∫ C(t ) dt
(1.30)
and
∫ C(t )(t − M ) dt . ∫ C(t ) dt 2
M2 =
1
(1.31)
The first moment (M1) represents the mean retention time. It can be directly related to the retention factor by
k=
M1 − t0 , t0
(1.32)
where t0 is the elution time for a nonretained compound. The method of calculating kinetic rate constants is derived by extrapolation of Giddings’ work [2]. The plate height in the length domain (HL) can be related to the second moment (M2) in the time domain by 2
HL =
σ 2L M 2 ⎛ u0 ⎞ , = L L ⎜⎝ 1 + k ⎟⎠
(1.33)
where u0 is the mobile phase linear velocity. The mass transfer term (Cs) for slow kinetics in a system that exhibits a partition or adsorption mechanism is given by
Cs =
2k
(1 + k )
2
. ksm
(1.34)
DK4478_book.fm Page 15 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
15
Thus, ksm =
2 k u0 (1 + k )2 dH L
kms =
and
2 k 2 u0 , (1 + k )2 dH L
(1.35)
where dHL is the contribution to plate height arising from slow mass transfer. As discussed in Section II.B, Miyabe and Guiochon [9] evaluated the plate height contributions to various mass transfer processes. In their approach, the statistical moments can be further elucidated as M1 =
L δ0 u0
(1.36)
and M2 =
(
)
2L δ ax + δ f + δ d , u0
(1.37)
where δ0 is a dimensionless retention parameter, equal to 1 + k, and is given by δ 0 = ε + (1 − ε)(ε p + ρ p K ) .
(1.38)
The contributions to M2 from axial dispersion (δax), external mass transfer (δf), and intraparticle diffusion (δd) are given by ⎛D ⎞ δ ax = ⎜ 2L ⎟ δ 20 , ⎝ u0 ⎠ ⎛ Rp ⎞ δ f = (1 − ε) ⎜ ⎟ ε p + ρp K ⎝ 3k f ⎠
(
(1.39)
)
2
,
(1.40)
and ⎛ R p2 ⎞ δd = 1 − ε ⎜ ⎟ ε p + ρp K ⎝ 15 De ⎠
(
)
(
)
2
,
(1.41)
respectively, where ε is the interparticle void fraction, εp and ρp are the porosity and density of the packing material, Rp is the particle radius, DL is the axial dispersion
DK4478_book.fm Page 16 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
16
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
coefficient, kf is the external mass transfer coefficient, De is the intraparticle diffusivity, and K is the equilibrium constant. Under conditions where the rate of sorption/desorption is negligibly small, the plate height can be written as ⎛ M ⎞ ⎛ L ⎞ DL δ f δ d . H = ⎜ 22 ⎟ ⎜ = + + ⎝ M1 ⎠ ⎝ 2 u0 ⎟⎠ u02 δ 20 δ 20
(1.42)
The different parameters that are related to mass transfer processes can be estimated or calculated based on the above equations. For example, the external mass transfer coefficient, diffusion coefficient in the mobile phase, and pore diffusion coefficient can all be estimated, and the diffusion coefficient in the stationary phase can thus be calculated. More specific information on the foundations and applications of this model can be found in the excellent review by Miyabe and Guiochon [9]. The plate height model assumes that all contributions to variance, both symmetric and asymmetric, that are not directly attributable to fast processes such as axial dispersion arise from slow kinetics. There are several potential sources of error in this method. First, this method requires that the solute concentration be within the linear region of the isotherm, such that it does not contribute to the variance. Second, this method relies on the accurate calculation and subtraction of all fast mass transfer terms, which is difficult for packed columns in liquid chromatography. Empirical estimations of these parameters will introduce errors. Moreover, any extra-column contributions to variance, including those from the injector, detector, connectors, etc., must be accurately calculated and subtracted. Again, there are no theoretical methods for the calculation of these parameters, so empirical estimations are necessary. b. Exponentially Modified Gaussian Model Consider an incremental length of the chromatographic column. Zone broadening can arise from multiple paths, diffusion, and mass transfer processes that are fast relative to the time spent in the incremental length. These processes contribute to the symmetric broadening, which is described by a Gaussian function,
()
C t =
2 ⎛ ⎛ t − tg ⎞ ⎞ exp ⎜ −0.5 ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ , ⎜⎝ ⎝ σ g ⎠ ⎟⎠ 2 πσ g
A
(1.43)
where A is the area, tg is the retention time of the Gaussian component, and σg is the standard deviation of the Gaussian component. In addition, zone broadening can arise from mass transfer processes that are slow relative to the time spent in the incremental length. These processes contribute to the asymmetric broadening. For a partition or adsorption mechanism that can be considered as a first-order or pseudo-first-order reaction, this contribution is given by an exponential function,
DK4478_book.fm Page 17 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
(
⎛ − t − tg C t = A exp ⎜ ⎜⎝ τ
()
) ⎞⎟ , ⎟⎠
17
(1.44)
where τ is the standard deviation of the exponential component. The zone profile observed at the end of the total column length is the convolution of the Gaussian and exponential contributions, that is, the multiplication of the functions and integration within each incremental length. This convolution is given by the exponentially modified Gaussian (EMG) equation,
C (t ) =
⎛ σ 2g tg − t ⎞ A exp ⎜ 2 + ⎟ τ ⎠ 2τ ⎝ 2τ
⎛ ⎛ t−t σg ⎞ ⎞ g ⎜ erf ⎜ − ⎟ + 1⎟ . ⎜⎝ ⎜⎝ 2 σ g 2 τ ⎟⎠ ⎟⎠
(1.45)
The zone profile is fit to the EMG equation by nonlinear regression to extract the regression parameters (A, tg, σg, τ). From these parameters, the retention time, tr, is calculated as tr = tg + τ
(1.46)
and the corresponding retention factor is calculated as
k=
tr − t0 . t0
(1.47)
The method of calculating kinetic rate constants from the EMG model is derived by extrapolation of Giddings’ work [2,24]. The mass transfer term for slow kinetics in the partition or adsorption mechanism is given by Equation 1.34. By rearrangement, the rate constants are given by
ksm =
2 kt0 τ2
and
kms =
2 k 2 t0 . τ2
(1.48)
The EMG model assumes that all contributions to asymmetric broadening (τ) arise from slow kinetics. There are several potential sources of error in this method. First, this method requires that the solute concentration be within the linear region of the isotherm, such that it does not contribute to the asymmetry. Second, any extra-column contributions to asymmetry must be minimized or eliminated. In practice, this is achieved by detection at several points along the chromatographic column and subtraction of the parameters determined at each detector [24]. It is noteworthy that the EMG method does not require a priori estimation, whether by
DK4478_book.fm Page 18 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
18
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
theoretical or empirical means, of symmetric column or extra-column contributions to broadening. c. Giddings Model By means of stochastic theory [2], Giddings derived a model suitable for theoretical treatment of the adsorption mechanism under first-order or pseudo-first-order conditions,
C ( x ) = Aγ
k
x
(
)
(
)
I 1 2 γ kx exp − γx − γk ,
(1.49)
where γ is a dimensionless constant, equal to the product of the desorption rate constant (ksm) and the elution time of a nonretained compound (t0). After conversion from the time domain (t) to the retention factor domain (x), the zone profile is fit by nonlinear regression to Equation 1.49. From the regression parameters (A, k, γ), the corresponding retention factor and rate constants are calculated. The Giddings model assumes that all contributions to symmetric and asymmetric broadening arise from slow kinetics. There are several potential sources of error in this method. First, this method requires that the solute concentration be within the linear region of the isotherm, such that it does not contribute to the broadening. Second, this method requires that column contributions from multiple paths and diffusion in the mobile and stationary phases be negligible. Moreover, any extracolumn contributions, including those from the injector, detector, connectors, etc., must also be negligible. Unlike the plate height and EMG methods, there is no a posteriori method to correct for these contributions. d. Nonlinear Chromatography Models All of the impulse methods described above are suitable for thermodynamic and kinetic measurements within the linear region of the isotherm. However, some mechanisms such as adsorption, ion exchange, and complexation have stationary phases with a limited number of sites that may be easily overloaded. Hence, it is desirable to be able to evaluate their behavior under nonlinear conditions. A convenient method to extract thermodynamic and kinetic information from frontal profiles was reported by Thomas [25] and later modified for elution zone profiles by Wade et al. [26]. This model was derived for mechanisms that can be considered as second-order sorption and first-order desorption reactions (Equation 1.2) under linear and nonlinear conditions. This theoretical model is given by
⎛ Aγ ⎞ C ( x) = ⎜ 1 − exp − γKC 0 ⎝ KC 0 ⎟⎠
(
where
(
))
(
(
))
(
⎛ k x I 2 γ kx exp − γx − γk 1 ⎜ ⎜ − ⎜⎝ 1 T γk, γx 1 − exp − γKC 0
(
)(
(
))
) ⎞⎟
⎟ , (1.50) ⎟⎠
DK4478_book.fm Page 19 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
u
T (u, v ) = e
−v
∫e I ( −t
0
0
)
2 vt d t .
19
(1.51)
In this equation, γ is a dimensionless constant equal to the product of the desorption rate constant (ksm) and the elution time of a nonretained compound (t0), k is the retention factor, K is the equilibrium constant, and C0 is the initial concentration. After conversion from the time domain (t) to the retention factor domain (x), the zone profile is fit by nonlinear regression to Equation 1.50. From the regression parameters (A, k, γ, KC0), the corresponding retention factor and rate constants are obtained. The Thomas model assumes that all contributions to symmetric and asymmetric broadening arise from nonlinear isotherms and slow kinetics, which is a combination of mass transfer and sorption/desorption processes. There are several potential sources of error in this method. First, this method assumes the kinetics and the isotherm to be Langmuirian. Second, this method requires that column contributions from multiple paths and diffusion in the mobile and stationary phases be negligible. Moreover, any extracolumn contributions, including those from the injector, detector, connectors, etc., must also be negligible. Unlike the statistical moment and EMG methods, there is no a posteriori method to correct for these contributions. Other nonlinear chromatography models have been reviewed by Golshan-Shirazi and Guiochon [27,28]. Among those that provide both thermodynamic and kinetic information are the reaction-dispersive and transport-dispersive models. The reaction-dispersive model presumes that sorption/desorption kinetics are slow relative to the fast kinetics of mass transfer. The transport-dispersive model presumes that mass transfer kinetics are slow relative to the fast kinetics of sorption/desorption. These simplifications allow a numerical solution of the general rate model for comparison of theoretical and experimental zone profiles. Further information, including direct comparison of these models with the Thomas model, can be found in the review by Golshan-Shirazi and Guiochon [27].
IV. APPLICATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC AND KINETIC METHODS A. PARTITION Although a wide range of stationary phases are available, the vast majority of reversed-phase separations are performed with alkyl-bonded silica phases. These phases are based on dispersion (London) forces [1], the most universal of all interactions, and hence are broadly applicable. Although many studies have added insight and attempted to definitively characterize the retention mechanism, many questions and controversies still remain. It is the purpose of this section to review the thermodynamic and kinetic studies that have provided a better understanding of the underlying processes of retention. In addition, the following parameters will be examined with regard to their contribution to the retention mechanism: properties
DK4478_book.fm Page 20 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
20
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
of the alkyl-bonded phase and support, properties of the mobile phase, solute structure and concentration, as well as temperature and pressure. 1. Fundamental Studies of the Retention Mechanism For many years, there has been a lively debate concerning the retention mechanism in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. Many models have been developed to describe the retention mechanism, some of which are directly and others indirectly based on thermodynamic concepts. Examples of models that are directly based on thermodynamics include the general solution or solubility parameter model reviewed by Tijssen et al. [29] and the solvophobic model developed by Horvath et al. [30,31]. Models that are indirectly based on thermodynamics include the lattice models developed by Martire and Boehm [32] and Dill [33]. The first important issue to be addressed is whether the mechanism of reversedphase separation with alkylsilica phases is predominantly partition-like or adsorption-like in character. A theoretical perspective was provided by Dill [33], who developed lattice models for both the partition and adsorption mechanisms. In both mechanisms, the surface consisted only of alkyl chains and the underlying silica support was not considered. Solute retention was predicted by using simple, thermodynamically related parameters: the entropy of mixing of the solute, the configurational entropy of the bonded chain, and the contact interactions of the solute with the solvent and bonded chain. This model predicted that the extent of partitioning becomes more important with increasing chain length. Solute molecules have the lowest concentration near the proximal or bound end and the highest concentration near the distal or free end of the chain. As the bonding density increases and space between the chains becomes more restricted, adsorption becomes more important. In fact, partition is predicted to decrease to zero as the chains reach their maximum density of approximately 8.1 μmol/m2. However, under most typical conditions, the predominant mechanism for long-chain alkylsilicas, particularly octadecylsilica, is likely to be partition or partition-like in nature. Experimental studies have also been used to examine the partition and adsorption mechanisms in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. In a study by Tan and Carr [34], liquid-liquid extraction was used as a model of a true partition system and compared with monomeric octylsilica and octadecylsilica phases. The alkylbenzenes were used as model solutes in order to determine the change in free energy of a methylene group (ΔΔG; Equation 1.7) in each system. The ratio of the change in free energy of a methylene group for transfer from the mobile phase to bulk hexadecane to that for transfer from the mobile phase to the stationary phase was calculated. Values of this ratio that are close to unity denote a partition mechanism, where the methylene group can be fully embedded in the bonded phase chain. For both octylsilica and octadecylsilica, the observed ratio was close to unity when the concentration of methanol in the mobile phase was less than 70%, indicating a partition-like mechanism. Tan and Carr [34] further demonstrated that shorter chains have larger ratios ranging from 2.2 to 1.5 for methylsilica to hexylsilica, indicative of a more adsorption-like mechanism. Moreover, phases with low bonding density of 0.6 μmol/m2 have significantly higher ratios of 1.8 to 2.0, while those with higher
DK4478_book.fm Page 21 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
21
bonding densities of 1.4 and 2.3 μmol/m2 have smaller and approximately equal ratios of 1.3. These results confirmed the predictions of the lattice model of Dill [33]. Later studies by Park et al. [35] examined polymeric phases ranging from methylsilica to octadecylsilica. The ratios were closer to unity for the polymeric phases than for the corresponding monomeric phases. This implies that polymeric phases act more like bulk hexadecane and exhibit a more partition-like mechanism than do monomeric phases. For all stationary phases examined in these studies, larger ratios were observed when the concentration of methanol in the mobile phase was greater than 70%. The authors suggested that this did not necessarily imply that adsorption was dominant under these conditions, but instead that the structure of the bonded phase may be different or that methanol may be more soluble in the stationary phase at higher concentrations. These studies demonstrate that the retention of a nonpolar solute with both monomeric and polymeric alkylsilica phases is more similar to a partition-like mechanism than an adsorption-like mechanism. The second important issue is whether the driving force for the separation arises from interactions of the solute with the mobile phase or with the stationary phase. The solvophobic model developed by Horvath et al. [30,31] is based on the general concept that the predominant contribution to the net change in free energy of retention arises from processes taking place in the mobile phase. The model includes changes in free energy arising from the formation of a cavity in the solvent, the reduction in free volume of the solute, and the van der Waals and electrostatic interactions between the solute and solvent [36]. This model has been very successful in predicting trends in retention, particularly those upon a change in mobile phase composition and solute structure. However, this view was challenged in a critical study by Carr et al. [37], which demonstrated that interactions with the stationary phase contribute more to the free energy of retention than was previously thought. In order to separate the mobile and stationary phase contributions, partition coefficients for solute transfer were measured from the gas phase to water (as a model of the mobile phase) and from the gas phase to hexadecane (as a partition model of the stationary phase). These partition coefficients are summarized for the alkylbenzenes in Table 1.1. The partition coefficients to water are relatively small and decrease with increasing chain length of the alkylbenzene. In contrast, the partition coefficients to hexadecane are substantially larger and increase with increasing chain length. The corresponding changes in molar free energy, calculated from Equation 1.6, exhibit similar trends. The average free energy for transfer of a methylene group is 0.67 kJ/mol from the gas phase to water, –2.53 kJ/mol from the gas phase to hexadecane, and –3.20 kJ/mol from water to hexadecane. It is evident from these data that the attractive interactions of the solute with the stationary phase are significantly greater than the repulsive interactions with the mobile phase, and hence constitute the predominant contribution to their retention. This work was extended by Ranatunga and Carr [38], who determined the change in free energy for transfer of a methylene group as a function of the mobile phase composition. For all mobile phases examined (40 to 100% methanol-water and acetonitrile-water), the changes in molar free energy were positive. In other words, the transfer of alkylbenzenes from the organic mobile phase to the gas phase was an energetically unfavorable event. The contributions of molar enthalpy were
DK4478_book.fm Page 22 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
22
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.1 Partition Coefficient (K) and the Change in Molar Free Energy (ΔG) of Transfer for Alkylbenzenes to Water and n-Hexadecane as Models of the Mobile (m) and Stationary (s) Phasesa Solute Benzene Toluene Ethylbenzene n-Propylbenzene n-Butylbenzene CH2b
Km 4.26 3.94 3.22 2.27 1.75
Ks 633 2,210 5,830 16,600 48,500
ΔGm (kJ/mol)
ΔGs (kJ/mol)
ΔΔG (kJ/mol)
–3.59 –3.39 –2.90 –2.03 –1.39 0.67
–16.0 –19.1 –21.5 –24.1 –26.7 –2.53
–12.4 –15.7 –18.6 –22.1 –25.3 –3.20
a K and ΔG for transfer from gas to water at 25°C. K and ΔG for transfer from m m s s gas to n-hexadecane at 25°C. ΔΔG for transfer from water to n-hexadecane at 25°C. b Average change in molar free energy of methylene group calculated from toluene to n-butylbenzene.
Source: Adapted from Carr, P.W., Li, J., Dallas, A.J., Eikens, D.I., and Tan, L.C., Revisionist look at solvophobic driving forces in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 656, 113, 1993.
unfavorable and slightly greater than the favorable changes in molar entropy. In all cases, however, the mobile phase contributions were significantly less than the stationary phase contributions. The net changes in molar free energy, enthalpy, and entropy for a methylene group are summarized in Table 1.2. These studies conclusively demonstrate the predominant role of the stationary phase in the retention mechanism of reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 2. Effect of Alkyl Chain Length and Bonding Density Many studies have been performed to elucidate the role of the bonded phase in the retention process. Some of these studies have been focused on discerning the effect of alkyl chain length and bonding density, whereas others have examined the effect of the synthetic method. Krstulovic et al. [39] examined a series of silica bonded phases with alkyl chain lengths varying from 1 to 18. With increasing chain length, a small but systematic increase in the logarithm of selectivity for a homologous series of alkylbenzenes was observed in both methanol-water and acetonitrile-water mobile phases. The selectivity is related to the differential change in free energy of the methylene group, according to Equation 1.7. This effect, which was not observed in similar studies of liquid-liquid extraction (partition), was attributed to the more ordered structure of the alkyl chain after it was immobilized on the silica support. Tchapla et al. [40] provided more detailed measurements of retention factor and selectivity as a function of the alkyl chain length. They found that the methylene selectivity for several
DK4478_book.fm Page 23 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
23
TABLE 1.2 Thermodynamics of Transfer for a Methylene Group from Methanol-Water and Acetonitrile-Water Mobile Phases to n-Hexadecane Methanol-Water to n-Hexadecane
Acetonitrile-Water to n-Hexadecane
Percent Organic Modifier
ΔG (kJ/mol)
ΔH (kJ/mol)
T ΔS (kJ/mol)
ΔG (kJ/mol)
ΔH (kJ/mol)
T ΔS (kJ/mol)
40 50 60 70 80 90 100
–2.44 –2.06 –1.79 –1.51 –1.20 –0.94 –0.72
–2.78 –2.49 –2.11 –1.72 –1.09 –0.92 –0.89
–0.34 –0.44 –0.32 –0.21 0.11 0.03 –0.12
–1.82 –1.57 –1.39 –1.28 –1.10 –0.97 –0.77
–0.96 –0.44 –0.36 –0.75 –0.77 –0.91 –1.04
0.79 1.06 0.97 0.46 0.26 — –0.33
Source: Adapted from Ranatunga, R.P.J. and Carr, P.W., A study of the enthalpy and entropy contributions of the stationary phase in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 72, 5679, 2000.
homologous series decreased in a stepwise manner near a critical value of carbon number for each particular stationary phase. As shown in Figure 1.2, the decrease was observed between solutes with 4 and 8 carbons for a hexylsilica phase, yet was observed between 12 and 18 carbons for an octadecylsilica phase. The authors noted that this decrease in selectivity occurred when the length of the alkyl chain of the solute was equal to or exceeded that of the stationary phase. This seemed to suggest that the partition mechanism involves a vertical penetration of the solute into the stationary phase. When the solute carbon number is less than that of the stationary phase, all carbon atoms are able to intercalate and interact directly with the corresponding carbon atoms of the stationary phase. However, when the solute carbon number is greater, the remaining carbon atoms cannot enter the stationary phase and thus undergo weaker dispersive interactions. Hence, solutes with a carbon number greater than the chain length of the stationary phase are less retained and exhibit lower selectivity. Tchapla et al. [41] further examined the temperature dependence of butadecylsilica and octadecylsilica phases. The van’t Hoff plots (log k versus 1/T; Equation 1.9) showed linear behavior for all homologous series under all conditions in the temperature range of 25° to 60°C. Extrapolation of the data from the van’t Hoff plot showed two convergent points where the critical value for all homologous series was observed at carbon number 12–13 for the butadecylsilica phase and carbon number 14–15 for the octadecylsilica phase. From these plots, the change in molar enthalpy decreased while the change in molar entropy increased with increasing solute carbon number in the homologous series. However, a discontinuity was observed in each plot at the same critical carbon numbers cited above. All of these trends were viewed to be consistent with the previous explanation of vertical insertion of the solute into the stationary phase, where changes in both enthalpy and entropy were altered at the critical carbon number. Tchapla et al. [41] also performed
DK4478_book.fm Page 24 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
24
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
1.23
Selectivity
1.21 1.19 1.17 1.15 1.13 0
5
10
15 20 Carbon number (a)
25
30
0
5
10
15 20 Carbon number (b)
25
30
1.27
Selectivity
1.25 1.23 1.21 1.19 1.17
FIGURE 1.2 Selectivity versus carbon number plots for monomeric alkylsilica phases: (a) methylsilica, (b) hexylsilica, (c) octylsilica, (d) octadecylsilica. Mobile phase: 90% methanolwater, 25°C. Selectivity is the mean value for five homologous series: n-alkanes, n-alkyl chlorides, n-methyl esters of carboxylic acids, n-alcohols, and 2-n-alkanones. (Adapted from Tchapla, A., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G., Linearity of homologous series retention plots in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 56, 621, 1984.) Continued.
enthalpy-entropy compensation studies and determined compensation temperatures below and above the critical carbon number. In general, the solutes with shorter alkyl chains had larger compensation temperatures than those with longer chains. For example, Tc for alkanes below the critical carbon number was 542°C, while that above the critical carbon number was 477°C. Also, homologous series with more polar head groups had compensation temperatures that were consistently higher than those of series with nonpolar head groups. For example, Tc for methoxyalkanes
DK4478_book.fm Page 25 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
25
1.32
Selectivity
1.30 1.28 1.26 1.24
1.22 0
5
10
15 20 Carbon number
25
30
25
30
(c) 1.41 1.40
Selectivity
1.39 1.38 1.37 1.36 1.35 0
5
10
15 20 Carbon number (d)
FIGURE 1.2 Continued.
below the critical carbon number was 836°C, while that above the critical number was 594°C. These studies suggest a consistency in the retention mechanism of alkylsilica stationary phases. Similarly, Jinno and Ozaki [42] evaluated the enthalpy-entropy compensation of alkylbenzenes on octylsilica and octadecylsilica stationary phases. The change in molar enthalpy for the alkylbenzenes was constant and negative over the temperature range from –1° to 50°C. Enthalpy-entropy compensation was found to exist in all cases and the compensation temperatures were calculated. As the percent of water in the acetonitrile mobile phase was increased from 0.1 to 20%, the compensation temperature for octylsilica increased from 360 to 586 K, respectively, and that for octadecylsilica increased from 381 to 639 K, respectively. From the similarity in
DK4478_book.fm Page 26 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
26
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
these compensation temperatures, the retention mechanism of octylsilica and octadecylsilica was concluded to be the same. Miyabe and Guiochon [43] studied the kinetic properties of silica bonded phases with alkyl chain lengths ranging from 1 to 18 carbons. By using the plate height model, they determined the intraparticle diffusion (Equation 1.41) and the components of pore diffusion and surface diffusion for homologous alkylbenzenes. From the measured values of the surface diffusion coefficient, they calculated a hypothetical surface diffusion coefficient normalized for the carbon content of the stationary phase. By using an Arrhenius relationship (Equation 1.21), a graph of the preexponential (frequency) factor versus the activation energy of surface diffusion revealed enthalpy-entropy compensation behavior with a compensation temperature of 420 K. To validate this temperature, the authors adopted the suggestion of Krug et al. [5,6] and examined the compensation behavior from several perspectives to ensure that it was not a consequence of statistical error. A linear correlation was observed in a plot of ΔH versus ΔG for surface diffusion, with a compensation temperature of 390 K. Statistical tests confirmed the validity of this enthalpy-entropy compensation behavior. Based on these results, a simple model was derived that permitted estimation of surface diffusion coefficients under different experimental conditions with an accuracy of approximately ± 20%. These results confirm that the kinetic behavior arising from surface diffusion was similar for alkylsilica materials with varying alkyl chain length. The bonding density of alkylsilica stationary phases is another parameter that is of critical importance to the retention mechanism. Sentell and Dorsey [44] examined the partition coefficient for a series of monomeric octadecylsilica phases with bonding densities of 1.6 to 4.1 μmol/m2. They found that the partition coefficient increased linearly with bonding density up to 3.1 μmol/m2, after which it began to decrease. This trend was observed for a variety of aromatic solutes (ethylbenzene, biphenyl, p-terphenyl, naphthalene), mobile phases (methanol-water and acetonitrile-water), and temperatures (20° to 35°C). In the low-density region (< 3.1 μmol/m2), the alkyl chain order or packing structure had little effect on solute retention, whereas in the high-density region (> 3.1 μmol/m2), the chain packing was constrained and interfered with solute partitioning into the phase. These results confirmed the prediction of the lattice model of Dill [33], as discussed previously. Sentell and Dorsey [45] subsequently compared the selectivity of monomeric octadecylsilica phases as a function of bonding density. When the mobile phase composition was held constant (55% methanol-water), all changes in selectivity were attributed to free energy contributions arising from solute interactions with the stationary phase. For a homologous series of alkylbenzenes, the methylene selectivity was nearly constant at 1.96 ± 0.03 for all bonding densities from 1.74 to 4.07 μmol/m2. However, for a homologous series of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), the phenyl selectivity increased in an approximately linear manner from 7.05 to 8.18 with increasing bonding density. This increase was attributed to an increase in shape selectivity for the solutes (benzene, biphenyl, and p-terphenyl) as the bonding density increased and the alkyl chains became more ordered. Based on these observations, selectivity was determined for a series of four-ring PAHs with different annelation structures. A distinct correlation was observed between selec-
DK4478_book.fm Page 27 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
27
tivity and bonding density, which was related to the length-to-breadth ratio of the PAHs. The selectivity was also determined for the series of planar and nonplanar PAHs previously identified for stationary phase characterization by Sander and Wise [46]. For bonding densities from 1.74 to 3.56 μmol/m2, the selectivity of tetrabenzonaphthalene and benzo[a]pyrene was approximately 1.7. However, for bonding densities of 3.60 and 4.07 μmol/m2, the selectivity decreased to 1.56 and 1.63, respectively. Concurrently, a change in elution order was observed for benzo[a]pyrene and phenanthro[3,4-c]phenanthrene, indicative of a significant change in the stationary phase structure. The authors suggested that the shape selectivity observed for these monomeric octadecylsilica phases could be due to ordering of the alkyl chains rather than the degree of polymerization or thickness of the stationary phase. More detailed thermodynamic studies of the effect of bonding density were performed by Cole and Dorsey [47] using alkylbenzenes, nitroalkanes, and small PAHs as model solutes. As shown in Figure 1.3, van’t Hoff plots were linear for all solutes on monomeric octadecylsilica phases with bonding densities of 1.60 and 2.84 μmol/m2. On these phases, the change in molar enthalpy for benzene was –3.07 and –2.19 kcal/mol, respectively, and the change in molar entropy for benzene was –6.36 and –2.61 cal/mol K, respectively. Phases with bonding densities of 3.06 to 4.07 μmol/m2 were also examined, however, linear van’t Hoff plots were not observed over the temperature range from –5.0° to 80.0°C. As the bonding density increased, both ΔH and ΔS became less negative. This suggested that the entropic contribution became more significant than the enthalpic contribution as the bonding density increased. The chromatographic values for ΔH and ΔS were compared to thermodynamic values for dissolution of liquid benzene in water reported by Gill and Wadso (ΔH = 0.497 kcal/mol, ΔS = –13.8 cal/mol K at 298 K) [48]. Here, ΔH and ΔS represent the transfer from the nonpolar environment (benzene) to the polar environment (water), so the sign should be opposite from that of the chromatographic system. When this was considered, Cole and Dorsey [47] concluded that the thermodynamic values obtained for the chromatographic system were similar to those for dissolution. Cole and Dorsey [47] also examined the effect of enthalpy-entropy compensation and calculated compensation temperatures for each solute. They found that the difference in Tc values for a particular solute (e.g., toluene) on the phases with 1.60 and 2.84 μmol/m2 bonding density was greater than the difference in Tc for different solutes on the same phase, as shown in Table 1.3. This indicated that the difference in bonding density of the stationary phase contributed more significantly to the retention process than did the difference in solute structure. Other investigators have examined the effect of the synthetic method by which the alkylsilica stationary phase is prepared. Rimmer et al. [49] synthesized a series of bonded phases, tridecylsilica to octadecylsilica, by using monomeric, solution polymerized, and surface polymerized methods on the same silica support. Each alkyl chain length was synthesized by each method to yield 20 different phases. The monomeric phases had similar bonding densities of 1.19 to 3.64 μmol/m2. The solution polymerized phases had slightly higher bonding densities of 4.21 to 5.92 μmol/m2. The surface polymerized phases had the greatest variation in bonding density from 1.90 to 7.97 μmol/m2. The phases were compared with respect to
DK4478_book.fm Page 28 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
28
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
Retention factor
10
1
0.1 0.0028
0.0030
0.0032 0.0034 1/temperature (K−1)
0.0036
0.0038
0.0036
0.0038
(a)
Retention factor
10
1
0.1 0.0028
0.0030
0.0032
0.0034
1/temperature (K−1) (b)
FIGURE 1.3 Van’t Hoff plots for benzene on octadecylsilica columns (15 cm × 4.6 mm inner diameter) with varying bonding density: (a) 1.60 μmol/m2, (b) 2.84 μmol/m2, (c) 3.06 μmol/m2, (d) 3.56 μmol/m2. Mobile phase: 60% acetonitrile-water. (Adapted from Cole, L.A. and Dorsey, J.G., Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 1. Stationary-phase considerations, Anal. Chem., 64, 1317, 1992.) Continued.
methylene selectivity, shape selectivity, and band broadening. No significant chromatographic differences were found to result from the synthetic routes, other than the changes in bonding density mentioned above. The methylene selectivity, measured with homologous alkylbenzenes, was observed to increase slightly from 1.28 to 1.71 with bonding density. In contrast, selectivity for tetrabenzonaphthalene and benzo[a]pyrene decreased from 1.67 for a monomeric heptadecylsilica phase (3.56 μmol/m2), to 0.64 for a solution polymerized heptadecylsilica phase (5.50 μmol/m2),
DK4478_book.fm Page 29 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
29
Retention factor
10
1
0.1 0.0028
0.0030
0.0032 0.0034 1/temperature (K−1)
0.0036
0.0038
0.0036
0.0038
(c)
Retention factor
10
1
0.1 0.0028
0.0030
0.0032
0.0034
1/temperature (K−1) (d)
FIGURE 1.3 Continued.
to 0.19 for a surface polymerized heptadecylsilica phase (7.28 μmol/m2). The concomitant inversion in retention order indicated a significant change in the stationary phase structure. To further understand the influence of the synthetic method, Jinno et al. [50] examined the temperature dependence of monomeric octadecylsilica, monomeric octadecylsilica with endcapping, polymeric octadecylsilica, and diphenylsilica phases. Van’t Hoff plots for PAHs on the monomeric octadecylsilica phases and the diphenylsilica phase were linear in the temperature range from 20° to 200°C, yet showed very high curvature on the polymeric phases. The selectivity was calculated for each solute pair at each temperature on each of the stationary phases. The authors concluded that polymeric phases were more capable of discriminating the planar/nonplanar character of PAHs than monomeric phases. This distinction was more
DK4478_book.fm Page 30 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
30
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.3 Comparison of Compensation Temperatures for Toluene on Octadecylsilica Columns with Different Bonding Densitiesa Bonding Density (μmol/m2)
Tc for All Solutes (°C)
Tc for Toluene (°C)
Difference (°C)
1.60 2.84
400–800 500–1800
549 1517
968
a
Experimental conditions: 60% acetonitrile-water mobile phase.
Source: Adapted from Cole, L.A. and Dorsey, J.G., Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 1. Stationary-phase considerations, Anal. Chem., 64, 1317, 1992.
marked with polymeric phases synthesized from trichlorosilanes than those synthesized from dichlorosilanes. This selectivity decreased with temperature, with a critical point between 40° and 60°C, which coincided with the temperature range where a phase transition was proposed to occur. The occurrence of a phase transition has frequently been proposed for alkylsilica phases, particularly those with long alkyl chains, high bonding density, and polymeric synthesis. Wheeler et al. [51] reviewed the published literature in this area derived from calorimetric, spectroscopic, and chromatographic studies. The primary chromatographic evidence of a phase transition has been the nonlinear nature of van’t Hoff plots (Figure 1.3). This nonlinearity suggests that the change in molar enthalpy is not constant with temperature and, hence, that the heat capacity at constant pressure (ΔCP = (∂ΔH/∂T)P) is also not constant [8]. A change in heat capacity is the clearest indication of a phase transition. Morel and Serpinet [52,53] and Claudy et al. [54] directly confirmed this conclusion by using differential scanning calorimetry and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The transition temperature was observed to increase with the length and density of the alkyl chains bonded to the silica surface. By using adiabatic calorimetry, Van Miltenburg and Hammers [55] demonstrated that the phase transition is actually second order and extends over a broad temperature range from –203° to 37°C for octylsilica and from –123° to 32°C for octadecylsilica phases. This second-order phase transition is viewed as an order-disorder transition rather than a traditional solid-liquid or melting transition. An ordered alkyl chain consists of all trans carbon-carbon bonds and the degree of disorder is indicated by the number and position of gauche bonds. The ordered state, in which the contact area between adjacent alkyl chains is maximized, is enthalpically preferred but entropically unfavored. In contrast, the highly disordered state, in which the chains have a great conformational diversity with many gauche bonds, is entropically preferred but enthalpically unfavored. The phase transition is thought to occur progressively, beginning at the distal or free end of the alkyl chain then gradually prevailing to the proximal or bound end. Sander et al. [56] confirmed by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy that the bonded
DK4478_book.fm Page 31 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
31
TABLE 1.4 Retention Factor (k), Rate Constants (kms and ksm), and Characteristic Time (t = 1/(kms + ksm)) for Homologous Fatty Acids Separated on Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Solute
k
kms (s–1)
ksm (s–1)
t (s)
C10 C12 C14 C16 C18 C20 C22
0.56 1.29 3.12 7.88 18.8 38.5 67.3
5.05 2.68 2.26 1.62 0.98 0.83 0.90
9.08 2.08 0.72 0.21 0.052 0.021 0.013
0.071 0.21 0.34 0.55 0.97 1.18 1.09
a
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 298 K, 4570 psi. Source: Adapted from McGuffin, V.L. and Lee, C., Thermodynamics and kinetics of solute transfer in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 987, 3, 2003.
alkyl chains contain several gauche bonds at 44°C, with a high probability of occurrence at the distal end and very low probability at the proximal end. The degree of disorder is comparable to that of the corresponding n-alkane coated in a thin film on the silica surface, but less than that of the n-alkane in bulk solution. McGuffin and Lee [57] compared the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of a polymeric octadecylsilica phase (5.4 μmol/m2) below and above the transition temperature of 45°C. The retention factors and rate constants for a homologous series of fatty acids (C10 to C22) are summarized in Table 1.4. It is apparent that the retention factors increased systematically with carbon number by approximately two orders of magnitude. The retention factors for C10 to C22 decreased by 84.4 to 99.6%, respectively, as temperature was increased from 20° to 60°C. Hence, the phase transition had a significant effect on thermodynamic behavior. In Table 1.4, the increase in retention factor with carbon number was accompanied by changes in the rate constant for transfer from the mobile to stationary phase by approximately one order of magnitude and the rate constant for transfer from the stationary to mobile phase by approximately three orders of magnitude. Hence, the transition from the stationary to mobile phase seemed to have the greatest effect on kinetic behavior. The characteristic time (t = 1/(kms + ksm)) increased with carbon number for C10 to C18 fatty acids, but remained relatively constant thereafter. This is consistent with the mechanism described by Tchapla et al. [40,41], wherein the solutes insert vertically in the stationary phase. Hence, solutes with carbon number greater than that of the stationary phase (C18) inserted the same distance into the stationary phase and had comparable kinetic behavior. Above the transition temperature, the rate constants increased significantly and were comparable to those for monomeric octadecylsilica phases.
DK4478_book.fm Page 32 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
32
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.5 Retention Factor (k) and Rate Constants (kms and ksm) for PAHs Separated on Monomeric and Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Monomeric Octadecylsilica Solute
k
kms (s–1)
Phenanthrene Chrysene Picene Benzo[a]pyrene Phenanthro[3,4-c]phenanthrene Tetrabenzonaphthalene
0.25 0.41 0.71 0.65 0.51 1.10
≥ 400 ≥ 400 36 57 ≥ 400 ≥ 400
a
Polymeric Octadecylsilica
ksm (s–1)
k
kms (s–1)
ksm (s–1)
≥ 400 ≥ 400 43 79 ≥ 400 ≥ 400
0.44 1.15 6.14 2.36 0.70 1.29
≥ 400 221 118 207 ≥ 400 ≥ 400
≥ 400 132 9 57 ≥ 400 ≥ 400
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 293–303 K.
Source: Adapted from Howerton, S.B. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 75, 3539, 2003.
In subsequent studies, Howerton and McGuffin [58] compared the kinetic behavior of PAHs on monomeric (2.7 μmol/m2) and polymeric (5.4 μmol/m2) octadecylsilica phases. As shown in Table 1.5, the rate constants for transfer from the mobile to stationary phase were generally larger for the polymeric phase than for the monomeric phase. However, the rate constants for transfer from the stationary to mobile phase were generally smaller for the polymeric phase than for the monomeric phase. In other words, it was faster and more facile for solutes to enter, but slower and more difficult for them to exit the polymeric stationary phases with higher bonding density. All solutes on both monomeric and polymeric phases showed a decrease in rate constants as the retention factor was increased. Finally, a number of studies have examined the effect of other synthetic methods that modify the stationary phase structure. Vervoort et al. [59] compared six different octadecylsilica stationary phases, including polymeric phases, sterically protected phases, phases with bidentate alkyl chains and embedded polar groups, as well as those synthesized with high-purity silica. Based on linear van’t Hoff plots, it was concluded that basic pharmaceutical compounds showed no change in the retention mechanism over the temperature range from 280 to 360 K. The degree to which each compound interacted with the stationary phase depended on the stationary phase properties. For example, neutral compounds (e.g., benzene, phenol) showed similar ΔH values on each stationary phase, whereas the more basic compounds (e.g., nortriptyline) showed more negative ΔH and ΔS values on the polar embedded phases and those synthesized with high-purity silica. Neue et al. [60,61] developed a method to classify these various octadecylsilica materials that illustrates the utility of graphs of ln k versus ln k and graphs of ln α vs. ln α for different solutes, previously introduced by Vailaya and Horvath [62]. Layne [63] has similarly compared conventional, polar-embedded, and polar-endcapped octadecylsilica phases by
DK4478_book.fm Page 33 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
33
using various selectivity values for nonpolar, polar, and hydrogen-bonding solutes. These studies illustrate the importance of synthetic methods and the incorporation of polar groups, particularly for the separation of acidic and basic solutes. With a few noteworthy exceptions [64], detailed thermodynamic and kinetic evaluations of these phases have yet to be reported. 3. Effect of Support The underlying solid support also has a very significant influence on retention in reversed-phase separations. As noted in the studies discussed above, the most common support material is silica. Sander and Wise [65] compared bonded phases prepared on 22 silica materials with differing particle shape, diameter, density, surface area, and pore diameter. They observed large variations in bonding density on the silica materials when performed under the same synthetic conditions, 1.26 to 2.78 μmol/m2 for monomeric octadecylsilica phases and 2.57 to 5.35 μmol/m2 for polymeric octadecylsilica phases. Two parameters were found to have the greatest influence: pore diameter and silica pretreatment with acid or base. Differences in retention factor and selectivity of PAHs were most pronounced for these parameters on the polymeric phases. For example, the retention factor of benzo[a]pyrene varied from 1.56 to 13.60 and the selectivity of tetrabenzonaphthalene and benzo[a]pyrene varied from 0.62 to 1.33. The authors concluded that the underlying silica substrate has a great effect, often unpredictable and uncontrollable, on the retention and selectivity of alkylsilica phases. In addition, much attention has been paid to the adsorptive nature of silica and its detrimental effect on the partition mechanism of alkylsilica phases. In a seminal study, Nahum and Horvath [66] examined the effect of the silica surface on the retention factor and change in molar enthalpy for dibenzo-18-crown-6 in a methanol mobile phase. The retention factor was greatest on silica and decreased progressively on octadecylsilica with 5% and 12% carbon loading. The corresponding change in molar enthalpy was determined to be –8.797, –8.433, and –7.356 kcal/mol, respectively. If partition was the predominant mechanism here, then retention and molar enthalpy should increase with carbon loading. However, if adsorption was dominant, then the phase with the highest carbon loading should have the lowest concentration of residual adsorptive sites and thus the smallest effect of these sites on retention. Hence, the retention of hydrogen bonding solutes such as the crown ethers was shown to be largely controlled by the underlying silica support, even with high carbon loading of the bonded phase. In a two-part review by Nawrocki [67,68], the nature of the silica adsorption sites was discussed and several methods for their blockage and removal were reviewed and compared. The use of pure silica as an adsorption phase will be discussed further in Section IV.B.4. Although the most common underlying support is silica, many other supports such as zirconia, titania, and synthetic polymers have been used. Zirconia supports are more stable than silica supports and can handle extremes of pH and temperature that silica cannot. However, complete coverage of the surface is essential to avoid deleterious adsorption. Li and Carr [69,70] have performed a number of studies on zirconia-based reversed-phase systems. Changes in molar enthalpy were
DK4478_book.fm Page 34 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
34
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
determined for alkylbenzenes on polybutadiene (PBD)-coated zirconia in a temperature range of 40° to 100°C. The values ranged from –2.07 to –4.00 kcal/mol for benzene to n-pentylbenzene, respectively, and are similar to those reported for octadecylsilica phases. The enthalpy of transfer of a methylene group for the PBDzirconia phase (–0.39 kcal/mol) was comparable to those for octadecylsilica phases (–0.27 and –0.41 kcal/mol) as well. In fact, the hydrophobic selectivity of PBDzirconia was found to be comparable to conventional bonded phases [69]. A temperature study by Guillarme et al. [71] compared the thermodynamic behavior of octadecyl- and PBD-zirconia with octadecylsilica phases. Over a limited temperature range of 25° to 80°C, the van’t Hoff plots were linear for alkylbenzenes and other solutes on all phases. Over a wider temperature range of 25° to 200°C, however, distinct differences were observed. Typical silica-based phases showed linear van’t Hoff plots for both methanol-water and acetonitrile-water mobile phases. However, slight curvature in the van’t Hoff plots was observed for zirconiabased phases with pure water and acetonitrile-water mobile phases, while a linear relationship was observed with methanol-water mobile phases. The authors demonstrated that the curved van’t Hoff plots were not due to changes in the system pressure with temperature, which could obscure the true temperature-dependence of retention. A confirming study with more detailed thermodynamic measurements was performed by Coym and Dorsey [72]. They observed curvature in the van’t Hoff plots for nonpolar aromatic solutes on PBD-zirconia using a pure water mobile phase. From these plots, the changes in molar enthalpy were found to be significantly more negative (exothermic) at high temperature than at low temperature. For example, the change in molar enthalpy for toluene was reported to be –5.7 kJ/mol in the temperature range of 15° to 55°C and –31.3 kJ/mol in the temperature range of 125° to 175°C. The authors attributed the differences in molar enthalpy to a change in the hydrogen-bonding network in water that influences the solvation of the solute. In spite of this large difference in molar enthalpy, the retention factors were significantly smaller in the high temperature range than in the low temperature range. The authors suggested that water is strongly hydrogen bonded at low temperature, creating a large and highly favorable change in molar entropy (hydrophobic effect). However, water undergoes little or no hydrogen bonding at higher temperatures, which results in a smaller entropy change. At higher temperatures, the entropic contribution was speculated to be larger than the enthalpic contribution, which would result in a net decrease in retention. However, we note here that a temperature-dependent change in molar entropy cannot be separated from a temperature-dependent change in molar enthalpy by means of a van’t Hoff plot. Hence, the molar enthalpies reported by Coym and Dorsey [72] may not be accurate if their proposed mechanism is correct. Clearly, further studies of this phenomenon and its mechanism are warranted [64]. 4. Effect of Mobile Phase Composition Whereas the contributions of the alkylsilica stationary phase clearly predominate [37,38], the contributions of the mobile phase also greatly influence the retention and selectivity of reversed-phase separations. To elucidate these contributions, many
DK4478_book.fm Page 35 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
35
investigators have varied the type and composition of the mobile phase to examine changes in the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior. The most common mobile phases are aqueous mixtures of methanol, tetrahydrofuran, or acetonitrile. These solvents are chosen to enhance acid, base, or dipole interactions, respectively, and hence can influence the selectivity. To influence the retention, the proportion of water in the mobile phase is varied. The effect of water on retention has been investigated extensively. Grushka et al. [73] studied the effect of water on retention factor, selectivity, and the concomitant changes in molar enthalpy and entropy. As the water content was increased, the retention factors for a series of alkylbenzenes increased and the methylene selectivity increased. The selectivity was found to be more strongly dependent on the mobile phase composition than on the temperature. Values for ΔH became more negative as the water content increased, ranging from –1.82 to –4.39 kcal/mol in 90% methanol-water and ranging from –2.06 to –6.21 kcal/mol in 80% methanol-water for ethylbenzene to dodecylbenzene, respectively. Values for ΔΔH of the methylene group were also determined as –0.267 and –0.405 kcal/mol in 90% and 80% methanol-water, respectively. Therefore, it is energetically more favorable for the solute to be in the stationary phase as the water content of the mobile phase is increased. Cole et al. [74] investigated the role of the mobile phase by means of van’t Hoff plots for benzene. When water-rich mobile phases of protic solvents (e.g., methanolwater and propanol-water) were used, the van’t Hoff plots were highly curved over the temperature range from –5° to 80°C. The values of ΔH were positive for temperatures from –5° to 20°C and negative for temperatures from 30° to 80°C. When mobile phases with aprotic solvents (e.g., acetonitrile-water) were used, the van’t Hoff plots were more nearly linear. The authors concluded that the hydrophobic (solvophobic) mechanism may be reasonable for protic solvents, but is not adequate to explain the retention mechanism in other situations. A related mobile phase effect was observed by Sentell et al. [75] through the examination of retention and selectivity for several homologous series consisting of alkylbenzenes, phenylenes, and PAHs. The selectivity changed more with temperature for methanol-water than for acetonitrile-water mobile phases. This was attributed to the hydrogen-bonding capability of the methanol-water mobile phases, which led to a more structured mobile phase. It is noteworthy that the graphs of the logarithm of selectivity vs. inverse temperature were linear and the reported values for ΔΔH and ΔΔS for the methylene and phenyl groups were negative over all temperature ranges. Sander and Field [76] examined the retention behavior of N,N-diethylaniline and 2-propylbenzene on an octadecylsilica phase over a wide range of methanol-water compositions. The change in molar enthalpy values for both solutes, although all negative, increased with an increase in the methanol concentration. That is, the transfer became less favorable for higher concentrations of methanol. The change in molar entropy for both solutes, although all negative, slightly increased with an increase in the methanol concentration. The enthalpy term was found to be the predominant contribution to retention. Barman and Martire [77] examined the effect of methanol-water and ethanol-water composition on the retention of a series of alkylbenzenes by using a semiempirical relationship between the retention volume and the temperature and mobile phase composition. Through graphs of the logarithm of retention volume vs. the volume
DK4478_book.fm Page 36 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
36
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
fraction of water in the mobile phase, the enthalpic contribution was found to be greater and opposite the entropic contribution. That is, as the volume fraction of water was increased, the enthalpic contribution to the retention volume systematically increased, while the entropic contribution systematically decreased for xylenes, ethyltoluenes, and diethylbenzenes. In all cases, the enthalpic term was the predominant contribution to retention. Wu et al. [78] examined the thermodynamic behavior of methanol-water and acetonitrile-water mobile phases as a function of pH. The mobile phase type and composition greatly affected both the retention and selectivity of piperazine diastereomers. The neutral form of the diastereomers is predominant at pH 6.4, whereas the protonated form of the diastereomers is predominant at pH 3.0. At both pH values, the logarithm of the retention factor decreased monotonically with an increase in methanol-water or acetonitrile-water composition. However, the logarithm of the diastereomeric selectivity showed interesting behavior as a function of the mobile phase composition. For methanol-water systems at pH 6.4, the selectivity decreased linearly with composition. For acetonitrile-water systems at pH 3.0 and 6.4 and for methanol-water systems at pH 3.0, the selectivity initially increased, reached a maximum value, and then decreased with composition. The authors suggested that the retention mechanism is complex, passing from a region that is dominated by selective solvation of the piperazine moiety at a low concentration of the organic modifier to a region that is dominated by more general solvent strength effects at a high concentration of the organic modifier. Through examination of the temperature behavior, the thermodynamic behavior of the mobile phases was also found to differ. At pH 3.0, the slope of the van’t Hoff plot was negative for both methanol-water and acetonitrile-water mobile phases. This was attributed to a change in the pKa of the piperazine diastereomers with increasing temperature, which favored the neutral form that was more highly retained. At pH 6.4, where the neutral form was already predominant, the behavior of the two mobile phases was distinctly different. The logarithm of the retention factor decreased with increasing temperature in methanolwater, but slightly increased in acetonitrile-water. The slope of the logarithm of the selectivity factor versus inverse temperature was positive in the methanol-water system, suggesting that the retention process was enthalpy dominated according to Equation 1.10. In contrast, the slope was slightly negative in the acetonitrile-water system, suggesting that the retention process was entropy dominated. Another common type of mobile phase involves the use of a buffer or a mixture of buffer and organic solvent. Melander et al. [79] examined aromatic carboxylic acids, substituted hydantoins, and allantoin separated on octadecylsilica using aqueous 50 mM Na2HPO4 buffer (pH 2.0) or a mixture of this buffer with 6% acetonitrile. An enthalpy-entropy compensation plot (ln k vs. –ΔH; Equation 1.16) for the aromatic carboxylic acids showed indistinguishable slopes and intercepts for the two mobile phases. Thus, the retention mechanism for the solutes did not rely on the presence of an organic modifier in the mobile phase. Similar compensation behavior was observed for the hydantoin solutes for the two mobile phases. When two other solutes (not used in the original compensation plot) were separated using a higher concentration of 30% acetonitrile, it was found that they shared the same compensation behavior. It appeared that the balance of enthalpic and entropic forces was
DK4478_book.fm Page 37 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
37
indifferent to the presence of the organic modifier and that the mechanism of solute interaction with octadecylsilica was the same for a variety of solutes. The compensation temperature for the aromatic carboxylic acids was 647 K, whereas that for the substituted hydantoins was 596 K. These temperatures were compared to substituted benzene derivatives analyzed by Knox and Vasvari [80], where the compensation temperature was 639 K. At the 95% confidence level, the range of compensation temperatures was found to be between 554 and 755 K. Both sets of solutes examined by Melander et al. [79] fell in this range, suggesting an identical retention mechanism for the solutes investigated. Compared with the thermodynamic effects, relatively little work has been done to elucidate the kinetic effects of the mobile phase. Miyabe et al. [81] studied the effect of the organic modifier on retention and mass transfer kinetics for an octadecylsilica phase. The equilibrium constant (K) increased with the surface area of the alkylbenzene solutes for mobile phases of 50% tetrahydrofuran-water, 70% methanol-water, and 70% acetonitrile-water. The isosteric heat of sorption (Qst) was calculated from van’t Hoff data and related to K0, which is the value of K at 1/T = 0 or Qst = 0. The former parameter is related to the change in molar enthalpy, while the latter is related to the change in molar entropy. From the slope of a graph of K0 versus Qst, a compensation temperature of 400 K was determined for the 50% tetrahydrofuran-water mobile phase. A kinetic characterization was also performed. The relative importance of the individual mass transfer processes was evaluated for the alkylbenzene solutes. Axial dispersion (δax) contributed about 30%, fluid to particle mass transfer (δf) contributed from 30% to 40%, and intraparticle diffusion (δd) contributed from 30 to 35%. Since each of these mass transfer processes contributed approximately equally to the second moment, none could be neglected. Among the contributions to intraparticle diffusion, surface diffusion was shown to be more significant than pore diffusion. The surface diffusion coefficient was correlated to the molar volume of the solute through the use of an empirical equation. As the solute volume increased, the surface diffusion coefficient increased. The effect of the organic modifier was also observed, where the surface diffusion coefficient increased in the order methanol < tetrahydrofuran < acetonitrile. As this order is different from the order of retention strength, this suggests that the mobile phase has a different effect on surface diffusion than on retention. Based on these studies, the type and concentration of organic modifier as well as the type and concentration of buffer and pH have a significant effect on thermodynamic behavior. Presumably, these parameters also have a significant effect on kinetic behavior, however much work remains to be done in this area. 5. Effect of Solute Structure and Concentration The retention mechanism depends not only on the characteristics of the mobile and stationary phases, but also on the solute structure and properties. Many solutes are helpful for characterization of the retention process, particularly homologous series of aliphatic and aromatic solutes. These series provide information about the contributions to retention and selectivity from an individual methylene or benzene group. McGuffin and Chen [8] determined the changes in molar enthalpy and molar volume
DK4478_book.fm Page 38 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
38
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.6 Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔH) and Molar Volume (ΔV) for Homologous Fatty Acids Separated on Monomeric and Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Monomeric Octadecylsilica
Polymeric Octadecylsilica
Solute
ΔH (kcal/mol)
ΔV (ml/mol)
ΔH (kcal/mol)
ΔV (ml/mol)
C10 C12 C14 C16 C18 C20 C22
–1.7 –2.2 –2.6 –3.0 –3.4 –3.8 –4.2
1.9 0.1 –0.7 –1.4 –2.3 –3.2 –4.3
–10.6 –14.2 –17.8 –21.4 –25.2 –28.1 –30.5
–27.1 –37.4 –51.7 –68.6 –83.4 –92.0 –104.0
a
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 303 K.
Source: Adapted from McGuffin, V.L. and Chen, S.H., Molar enthalpy and molar volume of methylene and benzene homologues in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A 762, 35, 1998.
for a homologous series of saturated fatty acids, as summarized in Table 1.6. On a monomeric octadecylsilica phase (2.7 μmol/m2), the change in molar enthalpy ranged from –1.7 to –4.2 kcal/mol for C10 to C22, respectively. The differential change in molar enthalpy (ΔΔH) per ethylene group was relatively constant at –0.41 ± 0.02 kcal/mol. This suggests that each ethylene group contributes equally to the retention process from an energetic perspective. On a polymeric octadecylsilica phase (5.4 μmol/m2), the change in molar enthalpy was much greater and ranged from –10.6 to –30.5 kcal/mol for C10 to C22, respectively. The differential change in molar enthalpy per ethylene group was relatively constant at –3.65 ± 0.13 kcal/mol, approximately an order of magnitude greater than that on the monomeric phase. The changes in molar volume were similarly distinctive and informative. For the monomeric phase, the changes in molar volume ranged from 1.9 to –4.3 ml/mol for C10 to C22, respectively. A positive change indicates that the solute occupies a greater volume in the mobile phase than in the stationary phase, whereas a negative change indicates the reverse. The differential change in molar volume (ΔΔV) per ethylene group was –1.0 ± 0.4 ml/mol, which confirmed that each ethylene group contributes equally to the retention process from a volumetric perspective. On the polymeric phase, the changes in molar volume ranged from –27.1 to –104 ml/mol for C10 to C22, respectively. This change in molar volume is a significant proportion of the total molar volume, which is approximately 201 to 441 ml/mol for C10 to C22, respectively. The differential change in molar volume per ethylene group was –14.1 ± 2.8 ml/mol, approximately an order of magnitude greater than that on the monomeric phase. These studies provide a clear indication of the thermodynamic contributions of the methylene group to retention.
DK4478_book.fm Page 39 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
39
TABLE 1.7 Activation Enthalpy (ΔH) and Activation Volume (ΔV) for Homologous Fatty Acids Separated on Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Solute
ΔHm‡ (kcal/mol)
ΔHs‡ (kcal/mol)
ΔVm‡ (ml/mol)
C10 C12 C14 C16 C18 C20 C22
26.1 30.0 28.3 25.8 24.4 22.1 19.5
41.2 48.7 49.7 51.8 54.2 55.4 56.7
7.2 55.3 64.8 79.3 87.1 93.4 110.0
a
ΔVs‡ (ml/mol) 31.7 91.4 116.0 147.0 171.0 179.0 211.0
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 303 K.
Source: Adapted from McGuffin, V.L. and Lee, C., Thermodynamics and kinetics of solute transfer in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 987, 3, 2003.
The kinetic contributions to retention for the homologous fatty acids on the polymeric octadecylsilica phase were examined by McGuffin and Lee [57]. As shown in Table 1.4, the retention factor increased logarithmically and the rate constants decreased logarithmically with increasing carbon number. The rate constants from the mobile to stationary phase decreased by approximately one order of magnitude, while the rate constants from the stationary to mobile phase decreased by approximately three orders of magnitude for C10 to C22. Hence, under most conditions, the transfer from the stationary to mobile phase was the rate-limiting step in the retention mechanism. The concomitant changes in activation enthalpy and activation volume are summarized in Table 1.7. The activation enthalpy from the mobile phase to transition state showed small variations, but was roughly constant with increasing carbon number. In contrast, the activation enthalpy from the stationary phase to transition state increased monotonically with carbon number and was approximately twofold larger than the activation enthalpy from the mobile to stationary phase. These activation enthalpies were also substantially greater than the net change in molar enthalpy, given in Table 1.6. Hence, it is likely that the solutes do not enter and leave the stationary phase in a single step (as shown in Figure 1.1), but rather in a stepwise or progressive manner. When considered as a progressive process, the average increase in activation enthalpy in Table 1.7 was 1.6 ± 0.6 kcal/mol per ethylene group, which is energetically feasible within the chromatographic system. The activation volumes are also summarized in Table 1.7. The activation volume from the mobile phase to transition state increased monotonically by 11 ± 4 ml/mol per ethylene group. The activation volume from the stationary phase to transition state was approximately twofold larger and increased by 24 ± 9 ml/mol per ethylene group. These activation volumes were also substantially greater than the net change in molar volume, given in Table 1.6. Again, this suggests that the solutes do not
DK4478_book.fm Page 40 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
40
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
enter and leave the stationary phase in a single step, but rather in a stepwise or progressive manner. Zhao and Carr [82] examined the thermodynamic contributions of the methylene group for several nonpolar homologous series. The differential change in molar free energy (ΔΔG) per methylene group was determined for alkylbenzenes, alkylacetates, alkylphenones, alkylanilines, and nitroalkanes. The ΔΔG values were very similar, ranging from 0.303 to 0.322 kcal/mol, with an average deviation of ± 0.007 kcal/mol. Hence, the authors concluded that the terminal functional group of the homologous series has little effect on the net retention of the methylene group for alkylsilica phases. More detailed studies by Chen et al. [83] evaluated the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy for an extensive set of solutes. For homologous alkylbenzenes, p-alkylphenols, p-alkyliodobenzenes, p-alkylacetophenones, and p-alkylanilines, ΔH became systematically more negative as the alkyl chain length was increased. Although there were small variations between these homologous series, the differential change in molar enthalpy for the methylene group ranged from 1.69 to 1.91 kJ/mol, with an average deviation of ±0.09 kJ/mol. In addition, the intercept (ΔS/R – ln β) of the van’t Hoff plot became more negative with increasing alkyl chain length. These values were also relatively similar, ranging from 0.224 to 0.314. Hence, the terminal functional group of the homologous series appeared to have little effect on the enthalpic and entropic contributions to retention of the methylene group for alkylsilica phases. Carr et al. [84] examined the retention behavior of more polar functional groups, such as methoxyl, methyl ester, aldehyde, nitro, and cyano. Unlike methylene groups (Tables 1.1 and 1.2), these polar groups exhibited different values for the change in molar free energy in the chromatographic system and in a liquid-liquid extraction system using hexadecane as a model of the stationary phase. This suggests that a simple partition mechanism may not be sufficient to describe the retention of polar functional groups. Moreover, unlike methylene groups, the interactions of the polar groups with the mobile phase were energetically favorable and much greater than their interactions with hexadecane. This observation may suggest that the retention process is, in fact, driven by the mobile phase for polar groups. However, these interactions are not solvophobic, as suggested in the model of Horvath and Melander [30,31], but solvophilic in nature. Chen et al. [83] examined the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy for substituted benzenes, as summarized in Table 1.8. These values provide insight into the enthalpic and entropic contributions for individual functional groups. For solutes with a more negative change in molar enthalpy than benzene, their functional groups have a more energetically favorable interaction with the stationary phase or, equivalently, a less favorable interaction with the mobile phase. The most negative values were observed for chloro, bromo, iodo, and phenylketone functional groups. Conversely, for solutes with a less negative change in molar enthalpy than benzene, their functional groups have a more energetically favorable interaction with the mobile phase or, equivalently, a less favorable interaction with the stationary phase. The least negative values were observed for hydroxyl, methylenehydroxyl, and methylketone functional groups. Similar insight can be gained from the entropy term, provided that the accessible phase ratio remains constant for these solutes. For solutes with a more negative change in this term than
DK4478_book.fm Page 41 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
41
TABLE 1.8 Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔH) and Molar Entropy (ΔS/R – ln β) for Substituted Benzenes on Monomeric Octadecylsilicaa Solute
ΔH (kJ/mol)
ΔS/R – ln β
Benzene Benzyl alcohol Phenol Benzamide Benzonitrile Nitrobenzene Nitrosobenzene Fluorobenzene Chlorobenzene Bromobenzene Iodobenzene Acetophenone Benzophenone
–6.720 –5.293 –6.646 –7.513 –7.590 –6.946 –6.875 –6.798 –8.067 –8.343 –9.110 –5.408 –8.716
–2.975 –3.547 –4.048 –4.908 –3.906 –3.491 –3.261 –3.093 –3.209 –3.208 –3.332 –3.039 –3.596
a
Experimental conditions: 80% acetonitrile-water mobile phase. Source: Adapted from Chen, Z., Nakayama, T., Nakagama, T., Uchiyama, K., and Hobo, T., Thermodynamic approaches to intermolecular interaction and retention behavior in liquid chromatography, J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. Technol., 26, 2809, 2003.
benzene, their functional groups have a less favorable entropic contribution to retention. The most negative values were observed for amide, hydroxyl, nitrile, methylenehydroxyl, and phenylketone functional groups. Conversely, solutes with a less negative change in this term than benzene will have a more favorable entropic contribution. For these experimental conditions, no solutes had a less negative value than benzene. The balance of enthalpic and entropic contributions to retention has also been characterized. Vailaya and Horvath [62] analyzed thermodynamic data obtained by Alvarez-Zepeda et al. [85] for alkylbenzenes separated on an octadecylsilica phase. A graph of the change in molar enthalpy versus carbon number revealed a common intersection point for mobile phase compositions of 55 to 100% methanol-water. At this point, the isoenthalpic carbon number was approximately –4.5. Similarly, a graph of the entropy term (ΔS + R ln Vs) vs. carbon number revealed an isotropic carbon number of approximately –3. Because of the inequality of these values, the enthalpyentropy compensation temperature determined for varying mobile phase compositions was not constant, ranging from 1086 to 880 K. In contrast, graphs of the change in molar enthalpy and entropy versus mobile phase composition for carbon numbers ranging from two to six revealed a common isoenthalpic and isoentropic composition
DK4478_book.fm Page 42 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
42
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
of 117% methanol-water. Hence the enthalpy-entropy compensation temperature determined for varying carbon number was constant at 755 ± 28 K. Opperhuizen et al. [86] examined the enthalpy-entropy compensation behavior for an extensive series of alkylbenzenes, chlorobenzenes, chlorotoluenes, chloronaphthalenes, and chlorobiphenyls on an octadecylsilica phase. The slopes of the compensation plot (ln k vs. –ΔH) were almost identical for these solutes, which indicated that compensation temperatures were comparable at a fixed mobile phase composition. The compensation temperatures were 609 ± 14 K in 85% methanolwater and 552 ± 7 K in 90% methanol-water. The contribution of methylene and chloro groups to retention was also examined. Values for ΔΔH per methylene group increased from –1.71 to –1.56 kJ/mol, while values for ΔΔS increased from –2.81 to –2.79 J/mol K as the composition of the mobile phase increased from 85 to 90% methanol-water. Substitution of a chloro group gave a contribution to retention that was mechanistically comparable to the methylene group. These extrathermodynamic contributions were independent of the structure of the parent compound. In other studies, homologous series that vary in the number and position of benzene groups have been examined. McGuffin and Chen [8] determined the changes in molar enthalpy and molar volume for a series of PAHs, as summarized in Table 1.9. On a monomeric octadecylsilica phase (2.7 μmol/m2), the change in molar enthalpy for the cata-annelated homologous series of phenanthrene, chrysene, and picene ranged from –0.8 to –2.9 kcal/mol. The change in molar enthalpy per benzene group was not constant, which suggests that each additional benzene group did not contribute equally to the retention process from an energetic perspective. Benzo[a]pyrene, with the same number of aromatic rings (five) but a more condensed structure than picene, had a slightly less negative change in molar enthalpy of –2.2 kcal/mol. The nonplanar PAHs phenanthro[3,4-c]phenanthrene and tetrabenzonaph-
TABLE 1.9 Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔH) and Molar Volume (ΔV) for Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons Separated on Monomeric and Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Monomeric Octadecylsilica
Polymeric Octadecylsilica
Solute
ΔH (kcal/mol)
ΔV (ml/mol)
ΔH (kcal/mol)
ΔV (ml/mol)
Phenanthrene Chrysene Picene Benzo[a]pyrene Phenanthro[3,4-c]phenanthrene Tetrabenzonaphthalene
–0.8 –1.6 –2.9 –2.2 –1.0 –1.5
–1.9 –1.8 –3.1 –2.1 1.9 1.6
–3.6 –7.6 –15.8 –9.1 –4.5 –3.2
–1.7 –8.2 –28.4 –10.1 1.7 6.8
a
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 303 K.
Source: Adapted from McGuffin, V.L. and Chen, S.H., Molar enthalpy and molar volume of methylene and benzene homologues in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A 762, 35, 1998.
DK4478_book.fm Page 43 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
43
thalene have significantly fewer negative changes in molar enthalpy than would be expected based on their six-ring structure. In fact, they are more comparable to the three- and four-ring homologous PAHs. On a polymeric octadecylsilica phase (5.4 μmol/m2), the changes in molar enthalpy were significantly greater, but exhibited the same trends as the monomeric octadecylsilica phase. The changes in molar volume were similarly distinctive and informative. On the monomeric phase, the change in molar volume for the cata-annelated homologous series of phenanthrene, chrysene, and picene ranged from –1.9 to –3.1 ml/mol. The change in molar volume per benzene group was not constant, which suggests that each additional benzene group did not contribute equally to the retention process from a volumetric perspective. Benzo[a]pyrene, with the same number of aromatic rings (five) but a more condensed annelation structure than picene, had a slightly less negative change in molar volume of –2.1 ml/mol. In contrast, the nonplanar PAHs phenanthro[3,4c]phenanthrene and tetrabenzonaphthalene exhibit positive changes in molar volume. Hence, these solutes occupy a greater volume in the stationary phase than in the mobile phase. On the polymeric phase, the changes in molar volume were greater, but exhibited the same trends as the monomeric octadecylsilica phase. These studies, as well as others [75,83,87], provide a clear indication of the thermodynamic contributions of the benzene group to retention. The kinetic contributions to retention for the PAHs on the polymeric octadecylsilica phase were examined by Howerton and McGuffin [58]. The retention factors and rate constants are summarized in Table 1.5. The rate of transfer for the threering PAH phenanthrene and the six-ring nonplanar PAHs phenanthro[3,4-c]phenanthrene and tetrabenzonaphthalene were very fast and, in fact, were greater than the capabilities of the chromatographic measurement method (≥ 400 s–1). For the remaining PAHs, the rate constants decreased with increasing ring number and increased for more condensed annelation structure. Transfer from the mobile to stationary phase was the rate-limiting step for the monomeric octadecylsilica phase, whereas transfer from the stationary to mobile phase was the rate-limiting step for the polymeric octadecylsilica phase. The concomitant changes in activation enthalpy and activation volume for these PAHs are summarized in Table 1.10. The activation enthalpies increased with ring number and decreased for more condensed annelation structure. More detailed examination of the effect of annelation structure was reported by Howerton and McGuffin [87]. The activation enthalpies and volumes were substantially greater than the net changes in molar enthalpy and volume, given in Table 1.9. As noted previously, this suggests that the solutes do not enter and leave the stationary phase in a single step, but rather in a stepwise or progressive manner. The thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of nitrogen-containing PAHs (NPAHs) has also been elucidated on a polymeric octadecylsilica phase by McGuffin et al. [88]. The retention factors for the NPAHs were smaller than those for the parent PAHs in the methanol mobile phase, while the reverse was true in acetonitrile. In fact, retention factors for aza-PAHs increased by approximately an order of magnitude in acetonitrile compared to methanol. This was attributed to the ability of the NPAHs to interact only weakly with residual silanol groups on the silica surface in the protic solvent, but much more strongly in the aprotic solvent. In general, the NPAHs had more negative changes in molar enthalpy than their parent PAHs because
DK4478_book.fm Page 44 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
44
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.10 Activation Enthalpy (ΔH) and Activation Volume (ΔV) for Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons Separated on Polymeric Octadecylsilicaa Solute
ΔHm‡ (kcal/mol)
ΔHs‡ (kcal/mol)
ΔVm‡ (ml/mol)
ΔVs‡ (ml/mol)
Chrysene Picene Benzo[a]pyrene
19.9 55.7 18.0
27.5 71.9 27.3
77.9 153.0 54.0
84.6 181.0 64.2
a
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 303 K.
Source: Adapted from Howerton, S.B. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversedphase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 75, 3539, 2003.
of this adsorption. It is noteworthy, however, that the changes in molar enthalpy were relatively comparable in the two mobile phases. For example, benz[a]acridine had ΔH values of –6.6 ± 0.1 kcal/mol in methanol and –8.3 ± 2.1 kcal/mol in acetonitrile. Hence, the differences in thermodynamic behavior were attributed to changes in the intercept (e.g., molar entropy or phase ratio) rather than the slope (e.g., molar enthalpy) of the van’t Hoff plot. The kinetic behavior was equally dramatic, with rate constants differing by two to four orders of magnitude in the two mobile phases. For example, the rate constants for transfer of benz[a]acridine from the mobile to stationary phase were 47 and 1.3 × 10–2 s–1 in methanol and acetonitrile, respectively, at 303 K. The corresponding rate constants for transfer from the stationary to mobile phase were 80 and 2.9 × 10–3/s–1, respectively. In nearly all cases, the latter process was the rate-limiting step of the retention mechanism. These results clearly indicate the importance of adsorption on the underlying support in alkylsilica phases. Further studies with aqueous mobile phases and additives are desirable for more thorough characterization. The effect of solute concentration on kinetic behavior was examined by Miyabe and Guiochon [89] on an octadecylsilica phase. From the estimation of plate height, the axial dispersion coefficient was found to increase linearly with increasing concentration in the range of 0 to 102 g/ml of 4-(2-methyl-2-propyl)phenol. The mass transfer rate constant was also found to increase linearly with concentration. Among the kinetic contributions to the rate constant, the sorption/desorption and external mass transfer processes were negligibly small and intraparticle diffusion was dominant. Moreover, among the contributions to intraparticle diffusion, surface diffusion was shown to be much more significant than pore diffusion. Hence, the authors concluded that the concentration dependence of the rate constant arises primarily from the surface diffusion coefficient. This concentration dependence of the surface diffusion coefficient was explained by the chemical potential driving force model. These results are significant because they clearly indicate the important role of surface diffusion processes in the kinetic behavior of alkylsilica phases.
DK4478_book.fm Page 45 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
45
In summary, alkylsilica stationary phases operate predominantly by a partition mechanism, where the interaction of the solute with the stationary phase contributes more greatly than that with the mobile phase to the net change in free energy. The underlying support plays an important role in both the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior, often leading to a combined mechanism of partition and adsorption. As the alkyl chain length and bonding density increase, the changes in molar enthalpy increase and kinetic rate constants decrease. The mobile phase composition, likewise, influences changes in molar enthalpy by means of the water content and the type of organic modifier. The kinetic behavior is influenced by the organic modifier and its effect on the surface diffusion coefficient. Finally, the solute structure provides a broad view of the retention mechanism from both a thermodynamic and kinetic perspective.
B. ADSORPTION The adsorption mechanism has several features that distinguish it from the partition (absorption) mechanism. First, the stationary phase consists of an impermeable, solid surface. Common stationary phases include organic materials such as poly(styrenedivinylbenzene) (PS-DVB) and porous graphitic carbon (PGC), as well as inorganic materials such as silica and alumina. Most of these adsorbents are heterogeneous, having surface sites with different functional groups. These functional groups generally involve strong and selective interactions, including proton donor-acceptor (Brönsted acid-base) and electron donor-acceptor (Lewis acid-base) interactions, among others [1]. As a consequence of these strong interactions, there is often a fixed stoichiometry between the solute and the stationary phase, most frequently 1:1, but occasionally 2:1 or higher. Also, because the stationary phase is a solid with a fixed surface area, there are a limited number of surface sites. Consequently, the solute molecules are in competition for the surface sites and may be displaced by more strongly interacting species. These features of the adsorption mechanism make it distinctly different from partition. In this section, the thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of the most common adsorption phases will be reviewed. 1. Poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) The copolymer PS-DVB has long been used as a stationary phase for size exclusion chromatography and, more recently, for reversed-phase liquid chromatography [90,91]. The stationary phase is prepared by polymerization of styrene and divinylbenzene monomers in aqueous suspension in the presence of an initiator and porogen. By controlling such factors as the concentration of monomers, type and concentration of porogen, temperature, and time duration of the polymerization, the properties of the resulting particles can be regulated. The particles are spherical with well-defined diameter and pore size and with a semirigid to rigid structure, depending upon the degree of cross-linking. PS-DVB is a promising alternative to octadecylsilica for reversed-phase separations, as it is stable at pH 1 to 13, at temperatures up to 130°C, and can be used with a wide range of mobile phase solvents [92]. It does have some disadvantages, however, as polymer-based particles typically exhibit lower efficiencies and lower pressure capabilities than silica-based particles. Although PS-DVB
DK4478_book.fm Page 46 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
46
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.11 Isomeric Selectivity for Phenyltoluenes, Terphenyls, Stilbenes, and Terpinenes on Poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) and Octadecylsilica Phasesa Phenyltoluenes Stationary Phase PS-DVB Octadecylsilica a
Terphenyls
Stilbenes
Terpinenes
m-/o-
p-/m-
m-/o-
p-/m-
trans-/cis-
γ-/α-
1.26 1.05
1.00 1.00
2.13 1.23
1.09 1.09
1.13 1.03
1.08 1.13
Experimental conditions: 50% acetonitrile-water mobile phase, 303 K.
Source: Adapted from Zhao, J. and Carr, P.W., A comparative study of the chromatographic selectivity of polystyrene-coated zirconia and related reversed-phase materials, Anal. Chem., 72, 302, 2000.
has been well characterized in terms of column permeability, reproducibility, porosity, and loading capacity [93], many of the fundamental thermodynamic and kinetic properties have not been characterized. The following studies have proven to be invaluable in understanding the underlying retention characteristics of PS-DVB. A comparison of PS-DVB with other reversed-phase materials, such as octadecylsilica and PBD-coated zirconia and alumina, was performed by McNeff et al. [94]. The retention factors for a homologous series of alkylbenzenes were evaluated on each stationary phase using 40% acetonitrile-water with 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 3.2 as the mobile phase. A linear relationship was observed between the natural logarithm of the retention factor and the number of methylene groups for all phases. The retention was greatest on PS-DVB, followed closely by octadecylsilica, and much less on PBD-zirconia and PBD-alumina. Values for the change in molar free energy for a methylene group were –0.583 kJ/mol for PS-DVB, –0.880 kJ/mol for octadecylsilica, –0.826 kJ/mol for PBD-zirconia, and –0.906 kJ/mol for PBD-alumina. The PS-DVB phase had the smallest ΔΔG value, which accounted for the difference in hydrophobicity of this phase compared to the other reversed-phase materials. The selectivity factors for several phenyl-substituted isomers were calculated on a PS-DVB phase (PRP-1; Hamilton Company, Reno, NV) and compared to octadecylsilica by Zhao and Carr [82]. Values for the isomeric selectivity are summarized in Table 1.11. The PS-DVB phase showed increased selectivity over octadecylsilica for separation of the ortho- and meta- isomers of phenyltoluene and terphenyl, whereas the meta- and para- isomers were not well separated on either phase. The PS-DVB phase also showed increased selectivity for the trans- and cis-stilbenes. This study demonstrated an inherent difference in the molar free energy of retention for isomeric compounds on PS-DVB compared to octadecylsilica, which is often a characteristic feature of the adsorption mechanism compared to partition. The effect of the mobile phase has been examined by several investigators. Guillarme et al. [71] observed the mobile phase dependence of van’t Hoff plots for small organic solutes on a PS-DVB phase (PLRP-S; Polymer Laboratories, Shropshire, UK). Linear van’t Hoff plots were observed for methanol-water mobile phases,
DK4478_book.fm Page 47 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
47
while curvilinear van’t Hoff plots were observed for acetonitrile-water mobile phases in the temperature range from 20° to 180°C. Possible origins of the nonlinear behavior were discussed, including the ability of PS-DVB to swell as a function of temperature and mobile phase composition. Yarita et al. [95] used superheated water as a mobile phase for the separation of phenols on a PS-DVB phase. Van’t Hoff plots showed linear behavior with an increase in temperature from 100° to 150°C. It was suggested that ΔH and ΔS were independent of temperature, although values for these parameters were not given or discussed in any further detail. The kinetic behavior of PS-DVB has been investigated extensively by Cantwell and coworkers [22,23,96]. Li and Cantwell [22] examined the mass transfer kinetics of PS-DVB phases (PRP-1 and PRP-∞; Hamilton Company, Reno, NV) with 85% methanol-water mobile phase by using the shallow-bed technique in the sorption mode. The sorption rate of naphthalene on PRP-1, a macroporous PS-DVB phase, was monitored as a function of time and the data were fit to a biporous diffusion model. From this fit, it was calculated that 91 ± 3% of the total sorption was due to adsorption at the surface of the pore walls, while 9 ± 3% was due to partition in the matrix. The diffusion coefficient for pore diffusion was estimated to be 3 × 10–6 cm2/s, while that for matrix diffusion was no greater than 10–12 cm2/s. Thus, the slow intraparticle mass transfer rate was attributed to slow diffusion in the polymer matrix. To confirm this result, a nominally nonporous PS-DVB phase, PRP-∞, was examined by using a monoporous diffusion model. The effective diffusion coefficient was 4 × 10–9 cm2/s, which was consistent with the slow matrix diffusion observed in PRP-1, but the magnitude was not in good agreement. Bujalski and Cantwell [23] later used the shallow-bed technique in the desorption mode with correction for experimental artifacts by means of an impulse response function marker (phloroglucinol). This allowed more accurate estimation of the kinetic processes, resulting in a diffusion coefficient of 5.0 × 10–11 cm2/s for PRP-∞, which is in much better agreement with that for PRP-1. Ells et al. [96] examined the effect of swelling on mass transfer rates in PRP-∞. For this purpose, a good wetting solvent for PS-DVB, tetrahydrofuran, was added to the 70% methanol-water mobile phase. As the concentration of tetrahydrofuran was increased from 0 to 10%, the diffusion coefficient of naphthalene increased from 7 × 10–11 to 15 × 10–11 cm2/s. The tetrahydrofuran cosolvent caused two effects: increased swelling of the polymer matrix and decreased sorption capacity for naphthalene. The authors suggested that the latter effect was most likely correlated with the improvement in chromatographic peak shape. They proposed that tetrahydrofuran filled the small micropores between polymer chains, which prevented naphthalene from entering these micropores and thereby enhanced the rate of mass transfer. The use of PS-DVB for reversed-phase separations is growing as more fundamental knowledge of the retention mechanism is elucidated. While the preceding work has proven to be important, many more thermodynamic and kinetic studies are needed to fully elucidate the combined adsorption/partition mechanism. 2. Porous Graphitic Carbon Porous graphitic carbon is another common stationary phase for reversed-phase liquid chromatography that operates by an adsorption mechanism. Detailed studies
DK4478_book.fm Page 48 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
48
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.12 Retention Factor (k) and Kinetic Rate Constants (kms, ksm) for Alkylbenzenes on Porous Graphitic Carbona Solute
k
kms (s–1)
ksm (s–1)
Benzene Toluene Ethylbenzene n-Propylbenzene n-Butylbenzene n-Pentylbenzene n-Hexylbenzene
0.16 0.36 0.37 0.53 0.80 1.43 2.34
1.01 4.86 4.53 8.39 14.0 24.5 37.4
5.87 13.1 11.8 15.0 16.7 16.3 15.4
a
Experimental conditions: methanol mobile phase, 298 K.
Source: Adapted from Zhang, Y. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of porous graphitic carbon in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, submitted for publication.
of the synthesis, structure, and performance of PGC have been performed by Knox et al. [97] and Knox and Ross [98]. PGC is synthesized by injection and subsequent polymerization of a phenol-formaldehyde mixture inside the pores of silica particles. The material is heated to 1000°C in nitrogen, after which the silica is dissolved with potassium hydroxide. The remaining carbonaceous material is then heated at 2000°C in argon to form the PGC. The resulting particles are spherical with a diameter and pore size similar to the original silica template. The surface consists of intertwined ribbons of carbon, which impart mechanical strength and the ability to withstand high pressure. Two common forms are the Bernal structure of three-dimensional graphite layers ordered ABABAB and the Warren structure of two-dimensional graphite layers that are randomly ordered. The homogeneous graphitic surface is hydrophobic and highly polarizable, hence retention is largely controlled by solute polarity and size. A review by Hanai [99] summarizes the retention characteristics of PGC. In many studies, the retention and selectivity of homologous series have been used to characterize PGC and compare it with octadecylsilica and other reversedphase materials. Zhang and McGuffin [100] examined the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of alkylbenzenes and methylbenzenes on Hypercarb PGC (Thermo Electron Corp., Waltham, MA) with a methanol mobile phase. Representative data for the retention factors are summarized in Table 1.12. Van’t Hoff plots were linear over the temperature range from 23° to 53°C and pressure range from 1000 to 5000 psi (6.9 to 34.5 MPa). For all solutes examined under all conditions, negative values for ΔH indicated that transfer from the mobile to stationary phase was energetically favorable. The molar enthalpy became more negative as the carbon number increased. The differential change in molar enthalpy (ΔΔH) was determined to be
DK4478_book.fm Page 49 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
49
–2 kJ/mol for the alkylbenzenes and –2.5 kJ/mol for the methylbenzenes, which suggested that each methylene or methyl group produced a similar effect on retention. The change in molar volume was determined to be nearly zero, which was consistent with the adsorption mechanism of PGC. Representative data for the kinetic rate constants are also summarized in Table 1.12. The rate constants from the mobile to stationary phase increased as the number of methylene or methyl groups increased. However, the rate constants from the stationary to mobile phase remained relatively constant. The activation enthalpy from the mobile phase to transition state was small and relatively constant, whereas that from the stationary phase to transition state became progressively larger as the carbon number increased. Hence, the energetic barrier for desorption was most significant. In contrast, the activation volume, which represents the volumetric barrier, for both adsorption and desorption was nearly zero. These thermodynamic and kinetic properties were significantly different from those for octadecylsilica, as discussed previously [57]. Viron et al. [101] reported the behavior of fatty acid methyl esters with varying carbon number and degree of unsaturation. In general, the retention of all fatty acids was significantly greater on PGC than on representative octadecylsilica phases. The methylene selectivity for the PGC phase was 1.58 with a 50% methanol-dichloromethane mobile phase, while that for the octadecylsilica phases was 1.14 to 1.20 with a methanol mobile phase. Thus, both phases had a constant contribution to retention for each methylene group, but the interaction was stronger with PGC than with octadecylsilica. The addition of one to three double bonds caused a decrease in retention on both phases. However, the contribution to retention was not constant with each successive double bond. For PGC, the selectivity was 2.77 for addition of the first double bond, 1.59 for the second, and 1.04 for the third. For octadecylsilica, the selectivity was 1.38 to 1.66 for addition of the first double bond, 1.17 to 1.20 for the second, and 1.10 to 1.17 for the third. Thus, double bonds had greater interaction with PGC than with octadecylsilica. Interestingly, retention on the PGC phase increased with the degree of unsaturation for fatty acids with five or six double bonds. This behavior, which is inconsistent with conventional reversed-phase separations, was attributed to the stereochemistry of the double bonds and their ability to align well with the planar surface of the graphite. The effect of the mobile phase composition was evaluated by Gaudin et al. [102]. They examined a variety of mobile phases for the separation of fatty acid methyl esters on Hypercarb PGC. Methanol was selected as the reference solvent, as it is typically a weak eluent for PGC. By taking the logarithmic ratio of the methylene selectivity for methanol and the solvent of interest, the eluotropic solvent strength (ε°) was established. The values for methylene selectivity and solvent strength are summarized in Table 1.13. In general, the weakest solvents were more polar (methanol and acetonitrile), while the strongest solvents were less polar (tetrahydrofuran, dichloromethane, chloroform, and toluene). However, the size, geometry, and polarizability of the solvents also played a role in the solvent strength. To investigate the solvent strength of binary systems, one weak solvent was combined with one strong solvent and the selectivities were determined using the fatty acid methyl esters. Acetonitrile combined with equal amounts of dichloromethane or tetrahydrofuran led to equivalent solvent strengths. In contrast, dichloromethane-methanol mobile
DK4478_book.fm Page 50 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
50
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.13 Methylene Selectivity (αCH2) and Eluotropic Solvent Strength (ε°) for Mobile Phases on Porous Graphitic Carbon Mobile Phase
αCH2
ε°
Methanol Acetonitrile Acetone 1-Propanol Ethyl acetate Heptane Dichloromethane Tetrahydrofuran Chloroform Toluene
1.70 1.66 1.48 1.45 1.38 1.29 1.26 1.23 1.20 1.15
0.00 0.01 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.11 0.13 0.13 0.15 0.17
Source: Adapted from Gaudin, K., Chaminade, P., and Baillet, A., Eluotropic strength in non-aqueous liquid chromatography with porous graphitic carbon, J. Chromatogr. A, 973, 61, 2002.
phases were stronger than the corresponding tetrahydrofuran-methanol phases. Moreover, toluene-methanol and chloroform-methanol were stronger than tolueneacetonitrile and chloroform-acetonitrile mobile phases. It was determined that the use of binary solvents can greatly affect the eluotropic solvent strength of the mobile phase and, thus, the retention and selectivity on the PGC stationary phase. The effect of water on retention behavior was examined by Guillarme et al. [71]. The authors observed linear van’t Hoff plots for small organic molecules with both methanolwater and acetonitrile-water mobile phases on a Hypercarb PGC column. These results demonstrated that both ΔH and ΔS were independent of temperature over the range from 20° to 180°C for all mobile phases, including pure water. The separation of a variety of solutes can help to elucidate the retention mechanism of PGC. Koivisto and Stefansson [103] examined the retention of sulfonated and acetylated disaccharides on Hypercarb PGC at two extreme pH values and temperatures from 30° to 80°C. The retention order for the disaccharides was reversed at the two pH levels. At low pH (2.2), the strongest interactions arose from the sulfate ion such that retention increased logarithmically with the number of sulfate groups. At high pH (12), hydrophobic interactions were dominant, as in conventional reversed-phase separations, and retention decreased with the number of sulfate groups. These results suggested a possible change in retention mechanism at different pH values. To examine this in more detail, linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained at both pH values and were used to evaluate the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy. At low pH (2.2), retention increased with temperature and both ΔH and ΔS values were positive. The unfavorable changes in enthalpy and favorable changes
DK4478_book.fm Page 51 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
51
in entropy characterized the retention of all disaccharides. At high pH (12), retention decreased with temperature and both ΔH and ΔS values were negative for all disaccharides. There was no evidence of enthalpy-entropy compensation within this system at low or high pH values. Another oligosaccharide that has been studied extensively as both a solute and a mobile phase additive is cyclodextrin. Kwaterczak and Bielejewska [104] examined native and permethylated derivatives of α-, β-, and γ-cyclodextrins as solutes on Hypercarb PGC. For the native cyclodextrins, retention increased logarithmically with the number of glucose units (6, 7, and 8 for α-, β-, and γ-cyclodextrin, respectively). The glucose selectivity was constant at 2.37 for 15% ethanol-water mobile phase. Values for ΔH and ΔS became progressively more negative with an increasing number of glucose units, and the adsorption of native cyclodextrins was determined to be enthalpy dominated. The ratio of entropic and enthalpic forces (TΔS/ΔH) for the PGC phase was compared to that for a representative octadecylsilica phase. The values for PGC were typically smaller than those for octadecylsilica (e.g., 0.82 and 0.94, respectively, for α-cyclodextrin), indicating that the unfavorable entropy term plays a lesser role in the adsorption mechanism for PGC. For the permethylated cyclodextrins, retention decreased with the number of glucose units. While the ΔH values were negative, the ΔS values were positive, and the adsorption of permethylated cyclodextrins was determined to be entropy dominated. As in the previous study, there was no evidence of enthalpy-entropy compensation for either native or permethylated cyclodextrins on the PGC phase. The addition of cyclodextrin to the mobile phase can modify retention based on the solute functional groups, size, and strength of the complex that can be formed. Clarot et al. [105] used this approach to evaluate the retention of four terpene derivatives on PGC. When the β-cyclodextrin concentration was zero, linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained over the temperature range from 25° to 45°C. Both ΔH and ΔS values were negative, and the retention process was enthalpy dominated. Plots of ΔH vs. ΔS were linear, which indicated that the terpenes exhibited enthalpyentropy compensation on PGC with a compensation temperature of 39.5°C. When β-cyclodextrin was added to the mobile phase, the retention factors for all terpenes decreased, as would be expected for complexation. The equilibrium formation constants were determined as a function of temperature, and from these data linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained. Negative values for ΔG confirmed that stable complexes were formed; however, positive values for ΔH indicated that this process was energetically unfavorable. Values for TΔS were larger than those for ΔH, which indicated that complexation was an entropy-dominated process. Plots of ΔH vs. ΔS were linear, with a compensation temperature of 19.1°C. Because the compensation temperatures were similar for the mobile phases with and without β-cyclodextrin, the authors suggested that complexation and transfer from the mobile phase to the PGC stationary phase had a comparable influence on retention. They also noted that this behavior was not observed for octadecylsilica stationary phases, where complexation played a much greater role. Other additives can be introduced into the mobile phase to influence retention. Andre and Guillaume [106] examined the effect of sucrose (saccharose) concentration in a 70% methanol-water mobile phase for both PGC and octadecylsilica phases.
DK4478_book.fm Page 52 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
52
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
Langmuir and bi-Langmuir models were used to evaluate the data under nonlinear conditions. The Langmuir model was appropriate under all conditions for the octadecylsilica phase, which suggested that the addition of sucrose did not alter the interaction of the phenolic solutes with the stationary phase. More complex behavior was observed for the PGC phase, where the bi-Langmuir model was necessary. The apparent retention factor decreased with increasing concentration of sucrose up to a critical value of 0.03 M, where it then increased. For low concentrations of sucrose, retention was dominated by the contributions from phenol adsorption on the PGC surface. Hence, the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy became progressively less negative with increasing sucrose concentration due to competition for the adsorption sites. For higher concentrations of sucrose, retention was dominated by the association of phenolic solutes with sucrose adsorbed on the PGC surface. Under these conditions, the retention factor increased with increasing sucrose concentration and the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy became more negative. Enthalpyentropy compensation was observed within both regimes, with a compensation temperature of 357 K for low sucrose concentrations and 340 K for higher sucrose concentrations. The authors noted that this difference, which was statistically significant, confirmed the different retention mechanism in the two regimes. Porous graphitic carbon is a very useful stationary phase for reversed-phase separations because of the distinct differences in selectivity from octadecylsilica and PS-DVB. However, the general retention characteristics of PGC for nonpolar, polar, and ionic solutes should be examined in much more depth and detail through thermodynamic and kinetic investigations. 3. Other Organic Adsorbents Other types of organic phases can be used as adsorbents in reversed-phase chromatography. Chen et al. [83] examined the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy for substituted benzenes on phenylsilica and pyrenylsilica phases, as summarized in Table 1.14. These values provide insight into the enthalpic and entropic contributions for individual functional groups, which can be compared with the values for octadecylsilica in Table 1.8. For solutes with a more negative change in molar enthalpy than benzene, their functional groups have a more energetically favorable interaction with the stationary phase or, equivalently, a less favorable interaction with the mobile phase. For the phenylsilica phase, the most negative values were observed for amide, bromo, iodo, nitroso, and hydroxyl functional groups. For the pyrenylsilica phase, the most negative values were observed for iodo, fluoro, nitrile, and phenylketone groups. Conversely, for solutes with a less negative change in molar enthalpy than benzene, their functional groups have a more energetically favorable interaction with the mobile phase or, equivalently, a less favorable interaction with the stationary phase. For the phenylsilica phase, the least negative values were observed for methylenehydroxyl, nitro, chloro, and methylketone functional groups. For the pyrenylsilica phase, the least negative values were observed for methylenehydroxyl, amide, and methylketone groups. Similar insight can be gained from the entropy term, provided that the accessible phase ratio remains constant for these solutes. For solutes with a more negative change in this term than benzene, their functional groups have
DK4478_book.fm Page 53 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
53
TABLE 1.14 Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔH) and Molar Entropy (ΔS/R-ln β) for Substituted Benzenes on Phenyl and Pyrenyl Phasesa Phenylsilica
Pyrenylsilica
Solute
ΔH (kJ/mol)
ΔS/R – ln β
ΔH (kJ/mol)
ΔS/R – ln β
Benzene Benzyl alcohol Phenol Benzamide Benzonitrile Nitrobenzene Nitrosobenzene Fluorobenzene Chlorobenzene Bromobenzene Iodobenzene Acetophenone Benzophenone
–8.734 –7.510 –9.185 –9.423 –9.163 –8.609 –9.249 –9.074 –8.681 –9.250 –9.154 –8.329 –8.978
–4.356 –4.724 –5.119 –5.576 –4.724 –4.410 –4.609 –4.510 –4.173 –4.314 –4.167 –4.418 –4.202
–9.176 –7.344 –8.932 –7.832 –9.276 –8.947 –8.853 –9.248 –9.049 –9.141 –9.542 –8.397 –9.290
–4.268 –4.201 –4.843 –4.726 –4.420 –4.069 –4.032 –4.343 –3.969 –3.878 –3.829 –4.043 –3.778
a
Experimental conditions: 80% acetonitrile-water mobile phase.
Source: Adapted from Chen, Z., Nakayama, T., Nakagama, T., Uchiyama, K., and Hobo, T., Thermodynamic approaches to intermolecular interaction and retention behavior in liquid chromatography, J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. Technol., 26, 2809, 2003.
a less favorable entropic contribution to retention. For the phenylsilica phase, the most negative values were observed for amide, hydroxyl, methylenehydroxyl, nitrile, and nitro functional groups. For the pyrenylsilica phase, the most negative values were observed for hydroxyl, amide, nitrile, and fluoro groups. Conversely, solutes with a less negative change in this term than benzene will have a more favorable entropic contribution. For both the phenylsilica and pyrenylsilica phases, the least negative values were observed for chloro, bromo, iodo, and phenylketone functional groups. By comparison of Tables 1.8 and 1.14, it is apparent that these aromatic phases provide greater overall retention and different functional group selectivity than octadecylsilica phases. 4. Silica Silica is by far the most widely used adsorbent and solid support for liquid chromatography. Silica is superior to other supports in terms of efficiency, rigidity, and general performance. The weakly acidic silanol groups (Si–OH) and weakly basic siloxane groups (Si–O–Si) are primarily responsible for the adsorption mechanism. There have been extensive reviews concerning the physical and chemical nature of the silica surface [67,68,107,108].
DK4478_book.fm Page 54 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
54
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.15 Free Energy (ΔG kcal/mol) of Adsorption for Individual Functional Groups in Aliphatic (R) and Aromatic (Ar) Molecules on Silica Group X–CH3 X–CH2–Y X–C=C–Y X–F X–Cl X–Br X–I X–SH X–S–S–Y X–S–Y X–O–Y X2–N–Y X–(C=O)H X–NO2 X–CN X–(C=O)O–Y X–(C=O)–Y X–OH X–NH2 X–(S=O)–Y X–(C=O)OH X–(C=O)NH2
X = Ar Y = Ar
X=R Y = Ar
X=R Y=R
0.11 0.07 0.25 –0.15 –0.20 –0.17 –0.15 0.67
— 0.01 (0.25) — — — — — 0.94 1.29 1.83 2.52 — — — 3.45 4.69 — — 4.2 — —
0.07 –0.05 (0.25) 1.54 1.74 1.94 1.94 1.70 1.90 2.94 3.61 ~5.8 4.97 5.71 5.27 5.27 5.27 5.60 8.00 7.2 7.6 9.6
0.48 0.87 3.48 2.77 3.33 4.18 4.56 4.20 5.10 6.1 6.6
Source: Adapted from Snyder, L.R., Principles of Adsorption Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1968.
The vast majority of separations using silica as an adsorbent are performed in the normal-phase mode. Snyder [109–112] has performed detailed and extensive studies of normal-phase adsorption for solutes with widely varying structure. The retention of these solutes was used to calculate the group adsorption energy, which is the change in free energy for a specific functional group minus that for an equivalent volume of alkane. Selected values of the group interaction energy are summarized in Table 1.15. The adsorption energy for methyl and methylene groups is nearly zero, whereas that for aromatic and higher bond orders is slightly greater. In general, the adsorption energy for specific functional groups is greater in aliphatic solutes than in aromatic solutes. This trend arises because the electron density of the functional group remains localized in aliphatic molecules, but is dispersed throughout the aromatic ring, thereby decreasing its availability for interaction with the silica surface. Accordingly, aliphatic halogen compounds have very high adsorption energy relative to their aromatic counterparts. This results from the high
DK4478_book.fm Page 55 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
55
polarizability and dipole moment of the halogens, leading to greater interactions from dipole induction and orientation [1]. Stronger interactions arise for functional groups that undergo proton donor-acceptor or electron donor-acceptor interactions. For acidic groups such as thiol, hydroxyl, and carboxyl, the adsorption energy arises primarily from interaction with siloxane groups. For basic groups such as carbonyl, nitrile, and amine, the adsorption energy arises primarily from interactions with silanol groups. If the functional groups of the solute act independently then, to a first approximation, the group interaction energies are additive. Hence, the overall interaction energy can be estimated by summation of the individual values. However, if the functional groups of the solute do not act independently, then secondary structural effects can arise [109]. For example, if the groups are in close proximity, they can both adsorb to the silica surface at the same time and can mutually enhance adsorption. Alternatively, if the groups interact with one another, they can diminish interaction with the surface. In addition, bulky groups can cause steric hindrance of neighboring groups, which can reduce their interaction. Other secondary effects can arise from intramolecular electronic induction, especially in aromatic solutes. The change in local electron density may increase or decrease adsorption, depending upon the nature of the functional group. The effect of mobile phase composition has also been examined by Snyder [109,112] for normal-phase adsorption on silica. The eluotropic solvent strength (ε°) was calculated for representative solvents relative to pentane, as summarized in Table 1.16. In contrast to the behavior on PGC (Table 1.13), the solvent strengths on silica increased with polarity. The weakest solvents were those of lowest polarity (pentane, benzene, carbon tetrachloride), whereas the strongest solvents were those of greatest polarity (acetone, dioxane, acetonitrile). To investigate the solvent strength of binary systems, one weak solvent was combined with one strong solvent. Mathematical
TABLE 1.16 Eluotropic Solvent Strength (ε°) for Mobile Phases on Silica Mobile Phase
ε°
Pentane Carbon tetrachloride Benzene Chloroform Methylene chloride Ethyl ether Ethyl acetate Acetone Dioxane Acetonitrile
0.00 0.11 0.25 0.26 0.32 0.38 0.38 0.47 0.49 0.50
Source: Adapted from Snyder, L.R., Linear elution adsorption chromatography. XIII. A narrow pore silica, J. Chromatogr., 25, 274, 1966.
DK4478_book.fm Page 56 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
56
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.17 Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔH) and Entropy (ΔS) for Amino Acid Adsorption on Silica and Octadecylsilicaa Silica
Octadecylsilica
Solute
ΔH (kJ/mol)
ΔS (J/mol K)
ΔH (kJ/mol)
ΔS (J/mol K)
Glycine Alanine Valine Leucine Phenylalanine Glutamic acid Glutamine Tryptophan
–2.22 –1.39 –3.12 –2.49 –6.03 –1.59 –2.15 –2.19
–11.5 –8.6 –11.7 –9.4 –21.3 –15.5 –10.9 –12.3
–8.66 –8.95 –10.65 –14.11 –19.68 –11.32 –10.22 –31.36
–34.6 –35.1 –35.6 –39.1 –48.0 –49.8 –38.9 –79.7
a
Experimental conditions: water mobile phase.
Source: Adapted from Basiuk, V.A. and Gromovoy, T.Y., Comparative study of amino acid adsorption on bare and octadecyl silica from water using high-performance liquid chromatography, Colloid Surface A, 118, 127, 1996.
relationships were then developed to accurately predict the eluotropic strength of the solvent mixture [109]. More recently, separations in the reversed-phase mode have been investigated on silica as well. Basiuk and Gromovoy [113,114] compared the adsorption behavior of amino acids on silica and octadecylsilica with a water mobile phase. The amino acids had an unfavorable thermodynamic transition from water to silica (ΔG > 0), but a favorable transition to octadecylsilica (ΔG < 0). Van’t Hoff plots were obtained over the temperature range from 20° to 60°C and selected thermodynamic values are summarized in Table 1.17. The changes in molar enthalpy and entropy were negative for both silica and octadecylsilica, but significantly more negative for octadecylsilica. The unfavorable entropic contribution (T ΔS) was greater than the favorable enthalpic contribution on silica, indicating an entropy-dominated retention process under all conditions. In contrast, the enthalpic contribution was greater for some but not all amino acids on octadecylsilica. Enthalpy-entropy compensation was observed on both silica and octadecylsilica for all amino acids except glutamic acid and aspartic acid, probably owing to their second carboxyl group. Bidlingmeyer and Henderson [115] separated some polar lipophilic amines on silica using 70% methanol-water with 6 mM potassium phosphate (pH 7) as the mobile phase. The amines were separated with high efficiency and excellent peak symmetry in the reversed-phase mode. However, the van’t Hoff plots were observed to be nonlinear over the temperature range from 25° to 80°C. The authors concluded that this effect is most likely due to a mixed retention mechanism from both adsorption and ion exchange (electrostatic forces). The ion exchange mechanism will be discussed in more detail in Section IV.C.
DK4478_book.fm Page 57 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
57
Snyder [116] performed kinetic studies of the adsorption mechanism on silica in the normal-phase mode by means of the plate height method. For neutral solutes, the plate height remained constant with the change in solute retention volume. This suggested that the adsorption/desorption rate was relatively fast and did not contribute significantly to the plate height. The rate-limiting step involved slow diffusion in adsorbent pores or within the aggregate particle. For basic solutes, however, interaction with the acidic silanol sites caused severe broadening and asymmetry of the peak and decreased the column efficiency. Hence, many kinetic investigations have been strongly driven by the interest in eliminating undesirable peak tailing. Ohkuma and Hara [117] analyzed the experimental zone profiles by assuming that the kinetic origin of the tailing arose from slow adsorption/desorption processes. They separated the chromatographic peak into a Gaussian portion and a “tail” portion. They found the area of the “tail” portion decreased and its relative length with reference to the elution time increased with increasing flow rate. These observations suggested that the tail portion of the peak is strongly influenced by the kinetic effect of slow processes. Fornstedt et al. [118,119] investigated peak tailing phenomena and the influence of mass transfer kinetics in both linear and nonlinear chromatography. In linear chromatography, the kinetic origin satisfactorily explains the peak tailing [118]. The two-site model, which assumes two different types of adsorption sites having different equilibrium isotherms and different rates of mass transfer kinetics, has been utilized. The most pronounced tailing existed when the slow type of adsorption site had a smaller contribution to the retention than the fast type and the rate constant for the slow sites was 20 to 2000 times smaller than that of the fast sites. In nonlinear chromatography, both thermodynamic and kinetic origins contribute to tailing [119]. In addition to the heterogeneous mass transfer kinetics discussed above, the heterogeneous thermodynamics with overloading of the nonlinear isotherm may affect the tailing as well, especially when the kinetics of the slow type of site is relatively fast (e.g., larger than 100 min–1). Under these conditions, heterogeneous thermodynamics become the dominating contribution to tailing. In summary, the kinetics for adsorption/desorption of neutral solutes on silica is fast, however, the kinetics for desorption of basic solutes is much slower due to contributions from heterogeneous kinetics and heterogeneous thermodynamics.
C. ION EXCHANGE Ion exchange chromatography is a well-established technique for the separation of ionic species, including inorganic anions/cations and low molar mass acids/bases such as carboxylic acids, phosphoric acids, sulfuric acids, and amines. There have been many studies concerned with improvement of the separation process by innovation in the stationary phase and changes in mobile phase composition, pH, and ionic strength. Yet there have been relatively few thermodynamic or kinetic studies of ion exchange because of the small and relatively unpredictable dependence of selectivity on temperature. When ion exchange is the only mechanism involved, the separation may be either an endothermic or exothermic process. The process depends on the charge, size, and type of the ion. For example, the change in molar enthalpy was negative
DK4478_book.fm Page 58 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
58
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
for singly charged ions (iodide, thiocyanate, perchlorate) that were strongly retained on an anion exchange resin, but positive for multiply charged ions (sulfate, oxalate, phosphate) [120]. The process also depends on the type and concentration of the mobile phase, as there is competition with the solutes for the ion exchange sites. For example, the change in molar enthalpy was negative for many divalent metal ions on a cation exchange resin using an aqueous mobile phase containing 0.12 M perchloric acid, but positive using a mobile phase containing 3.0 mM phenylenediamine [121]. In general, the retention process occurs with little evolution or consumption of heat, typically less than 8 kJ/mol [122]. Temperature has not gained much attention in ion exchange chromatography, however, it can be a great tool for adjusting retention and selectivity in chelated ion exchange chromatography. Thus, it is interesting to examine the thermodynamic contributions to retention in chelated ion exchange chromatography. When silica bonded with glutamic acid was used as the stationary phase, both ion exchange and chelation played important roles in the separation of alkali, alkaline earth, and transition metal cations [123]. At lower ionic strength and pH 2.7, the ion exchange mechanism dominated and the retention factor decreased with increasing temperature. Under these conditions, the sorption was exothermic, with changes in molar enthalpy ranging from –3.97 to –9.29 kJ/mol. At higher ionic strength and pH 4.7, where the ion exchange mechanism was suppressed, the retention factor increased with increasing temperature. This was indicative of the large entropy contribution due to chelation, where several solvent molecules were released for each metal cation that was bound. Under these conditions, the sorption was endothermic with changes in molar enthalpy ranging from 10.1 to 30.6 kJ/mol. Other examples showed a similar chelating effect [124,125], which indicated temperature is an important parameter in chelated ion exchange chromatography. The retention models of ion chromatography with secondary equilibria were reviewed by Janos [126], with emphasis on acid-base and complexation equilibria. Detailed aspects of the retention mechanism and accurate determination of equilibrium constants are discussed. Regarding the kinetics for ion exchange chromatography alone, the sorption/ desorption process is usually fast and diffusion controlled [122]. Generally speaking, intraparticle diffusion is the greatest contribution to broadening when there is large particle size, low diffusivity in the particle, and low concentration of ion exchange sites. On the contrary, film diffusion controls the broadening with small particle size and high concentration of sites. When chelation occurs, however, these general considerations do not apply and kinetics are much slower, owing to the desorption process [124]. Recently, the application of ion exchange chromatography in the field of recovery, concentration, and purification of proteins has become more prevalent. The ability to characterize the thermodynamic and kinetic parameters involved in the ion exchange interaction of proteins is essential in scaling up for preparative separations. Bovine serum albumin (BSA) has been successfully utilized as a model protein in ion exchange chromatography for thermodynamic and kinetic investigations. The sorption of proteins is a relatively complicated process. It can be exothermic or endothermic, depending on the protein, the surface of the stationary phase, and the mobile phase composition. An exothermic process indicates the dominating force
DK4478_book.fm Page 59 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
59
to be an attractive interaction between the surface and the adsorbing proteins, whereas an endothermic process indicates favorable entropy-dominated interactions. An exothermic process is generally expected in ion exchange chromatography when there is electrostatic interaction between the oppositely charged surface and the protein. However, some noteworthy exceptions have been reported. Bowen and Hughes [127] investigated BSA sorption on two polymeric anion exchange stationary phases with calorimetric measurements. An endothermic heat of sorption was observed, which indicated that the driving force was probably the large change in entropy due to solvent (water) release. Similarly, Thrash et al. [128] obtained negative van’t Hoff plots over the temperature range of 25° to 40°C that were dominated by large entropy contributions. They used the preferential interaction model to estimate water release from the contact surface of the BSA protein and the anionic polyethyleneimine resin. At 25°C, the water release alone was a sufficiently large entropic contribution to overcome the unfavorable change in enthalpy. However, at a higher temperature of 37°C, other effects such as structural rearrangement must also contribute to the net change in molar entropy. The same speculation about structural rearrangement was suggested by Raje and Pinto [129], who reported an endothermic interaction between BSA and anionic polyethyleneimine resin with primary, secondary, and tertiary amine ligands. Repulsive electrostatic interactions between the sorbed molecules might be another important contribution to the endothermic process. Thrash and Pinto [130] compared the enthalpy contribution from repulsive interactions and the entropy contribution from water release, concluding that the former is more important than any other contributions. Thus, the cations in the mobile phase had a significant influence on the heat of sorption by shielding repulsive interactions between negatively charged protein molecules. In summary, the unusual endothermic interactions can be attributed to repulsive interactions, protein reconfiguration, or surface dehydration, depending upon the experimental conditions. The kinetics of protein sorption has gained attention recently because it has been realized that the poor separation efficiency of large biomolecules is due to their slow mass transfer kinetics. Weaver and Carta [131] investigated different types of resins for their equilibrium and kinetic properties using lysozyme as a model protein in batch experiments. These resins included a macroporous PS-DVB polymer (POROS 50 HS; Perceptive Biosystems, Inc., Boston, MA) and a composite material prepared by filling the pores of high-porosity polystyrene-coated silica particles with a polyacrylamide-based hydrogel (BioSepra S–HyperD M; Pall Corporation, East Hills, NY). While both sorbents could tolerate high linear velocity without compression or large pressure drop, they differed in their sorption capacity and kinetics. The gelcomposite sorbent had a 60% higher capacity than the macroporous sorbent because of their different means to reach loading capacity. The gel-composite sorbent was dependent upon the volume of hydrogel within the pores, while the macroporous sorbent was dependent upon the surface area. In their kinetic behavior, external film resistance played an important role at low protein concentrations for both sorbents. However, at higher concentrations, different models were utilized to describe the different sorbents. The pore diffusion model described the kinetics for the macroporous sorbent, with the concentration gradient in the pore fluid as the driving force and a pore diffusion coefficient of 1.1 × 10–7 cm2/s. The homogeneous diffusion
DK4478_book.fm Page 60 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
60
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
model described the kinetics for the gel-composite media, with the concentration gradient within the gel medium as the driving force and an apparent diffusion coefficient of 7.5 × 10–9 cm2/s. The authors concluded that the gel-composite sorbent was superior to the macroporous sorbent because of its higher dynamic capacity. Fernandez and Carta [132] and Fernandez et al. [133] also did similar research with BSA protein on the gel-composite HyperD resins using the batch and shallow bed techniques. In both cases, intraparticle mass transfer dominated at higher protein concentrations, but film resistance dominated at lower protein concentrations. The intraparticle mass transfer was independent of flow rate and independent of hydrodynamic conditions outside of the particles, which is consistent with a diffusionlimited transport mechanism. Heeter and Liapis [134] studied the sorption of BSA on a porous strong anion exchange resin using the frontal analysis method. Among the models examined, the dynamic nonlinear adsorption model for purely diffusive particles with a monodisperse porous structure was found to best describe the system behavior. The intraparticle diffusion coefficient was estimated to be 4.11 × 10–7 to 2.00 × 10–7 cm2/s for BSA concentrations of 1 × 10–5 to 5 × 10–5 g/cm3. The data were also evaluated to determine the contribution from intraparticle convection, which was found to be negligible. Conder and Hayek [135] came to similar conclusions about the dominant effect of intraparticle diffusion kinetics for BSA on polyethyleneimine, a weak anion exchange resin. Finally, Miyabe and Guiochon [136] provided more detail on the mass transfer kinetics for BSA on anion exchange resins. The lumped kinetic model showed a linear increase in the intraparticle mass transfer rate coefficient with BSA concentration. Further analysis showed that this dependence should be attributed to the concentration dependence of the surface diffusivity (Ds) and not the pore diffusivity (Dp). In summary, ion exchange chromatography of small ions is usually associated with small changes in molar enthalpy and entropy. The kinetic processes are usually relatively fast. However, when combined with chelating interactions, the kinetic rate decreases owing to slow desorption. Protein separations by ion exchange chromatography can be endothermic or exothermic processes. The kinetics are mainly limited by intraparticle diffusion, specifically surface diffusion, especially at high protein concentrations.
D. SIZE EXCLUSION Size exclusion chromatography, also known as gel filtration or gel permeation chromatography in aqueous or organic solvents, respectively, is utilized for the separation of industrial polymers, biopolymers, and other macromolecules as well as for the determination of molar mass distributions. Separation is achieved by the differential inclusion or exclusion of solutes as they pass through a column of porous particles. Solutes that are smaller than the pore diameter have a higher probability of entering the particles and, therefore, have a longer retention time than larger solutes that cannot enter the particles. From a thermodynamic perspective, size exclusion chromatography is distinguished from all other separation mechanisms. The interactions between the solute and the stationary phase surface are intentionally minimized or eliminated, such
DK4478_book.fm Page 61 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
61
that the changes in molar enthalpy are negligible. However, when solute molecules enter the pores, a number of solvent molecules are displaced which is accompanied by a change in the entropy of mixing. In addition, the mobility of the solute molecule may become more limited inside the pores, thereby decreasing the configurational entropy. Thus, size exclusion chromatography is thermodynamically associated with changes in entropy alone [137]. These entropy changes result from the concentration gradients as well as the flow and diffusion processes within the column, which lead to partial or full exclusion of macromolecules from the pores or other restricted regions. With a few noteworthy exceptions, the bulk of the theoretical and experimental evaluations of these phenomena were completed more than 30 years ago [138–142]. More recently, interest has focused on a technique known as liquid chromatography at the critical condition (LCCC). In this technique, separations are performed at the interface between the entropy-dominated size exclusion mechanism and the enthalpy-dominated adsorption mechanism. The entropic and enthalpic contributions are exactly balanced for a selected group of macromolecules (e.g., linear polystyrenes), such that enthalpy-entropy compensation is achieved. All molecules of the selected group are eluted at the void volume of the column, irrespective of their molar mass. Molecules that have slight differences in structure from the selected group (e.g., cyclic polystyrenes, PS-DVB copolymers, etc.) will have a different balance of entropic and enthalpic contributions and, hence, will be eluted before or after the void volume. The thermodynamic theoretical models of LCCC have been elucidated and reviewed by Gorbunov and Skvorcov [143]. The critical conditions can be tuned by adjusting the stationary phase composition, the mobile phase composition, or temperature, as summarized in an excellent review by Macko and Hunkeler [144]. Furthermore, at least one report demonstrates that pressure can also affect the critical conditions [145]. Among the papers searching for critical conditions, very few carried out systematic thermodynamic studies. Trathnigg et al. [146] performed a systematic study of polyoxyethylenes, including polyethylene glycols, fatty alcohol ethoxylates, and fatty acid polyglycol esters. For the oxyethylene unit in polyethylene glycol homopolymers, the critical conditions were realized on an octadecylsilica stationary phase with mobile phases of 85.8% methanol-water or 89.6% acetone-water. For both mobile phase systems, the van’t Hoff plots were linear over the temperature range from 15° to 35°C. The resulting changes in molar entropy and enthalpy were very small in the methanol-water system, but nearly tenfold larger in the acetone-water system. In the diblock and triblock polymers with hydrophobic alkoxy or ester groups, no compensation points were found. Philipsen et al. [147] performed thermodynamic studies on low molar mass polystyrenes and polyesters on an octadecylsilica stationary phase with tetrahydrofuran-water mobile phases. Linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained in almost all cases. The determined changes in molar entropy and enthalpy were negative for both polymers and became less negative with increasing concentration of tetrahydrofuran. They attributed the increase in enthalpy to the decreased affinity between the polymer and the stationary phase and the increase in entropy to the decreased number of polymer sites that interact simultaneously with the sorbent. Enthalpy-entropy compensation was identified for polystyrene oligomers in mobile phases containing different concentrations
DK4478_book.fm Page 62 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
62
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
of tetrahydrofuran. This indicated the same retention mechanism regardless of mobile phase composition. However, no enthalpy-entropy compensation temperature was identified for polystyrenes or polyesters at any mobile phase composition. Consequently, retention was not exactly independent of molar mass under the selected critical conditions. Kinetic studies of size exclusion chromatography have been relatively limited because the experimental zone profiles contain significant contributions from sample polydispersity and extracolumn dispersion. In general, sample polydispersity tends to dominate the observed broadening, making it difficult to extract the kinetic contributions. Investigations have shown that axial dispersion from multiple paths and slow mass transfer of the polymer within the stationary phase are the most important contributions to kinetic broadening [148]. Leypoldt et al. [149] noted that contributions from slow mass transfer are dependent on flow rate, whereas contributions from multiple paths and sample polydispersity are not. By judicious separation of these contributions, they demonstrated that restricted diffusion within the stationary phase depended upon the ratio of the radii of the solute molecule and the pore. In summary, size exclusion chromatography is traditionally treated as an entropydominated process and, thus, the solutes are separated based on their molar mass and size. Recently, the combination of entropy-dominated size exclusion with enthalpy-dominated adsorption has been used to facilitate group-specific separations that are independent of their mass and size. The kinetics aspects of size exclusion separations are often small compared to the effects of sample polydispersity.
E. CHIRAL Enantiomers are molecules that are mirror images of each other and nonsuperimposable. Because they have the same physical and chemical properties, enantiomers are very difficult to separate. As a consequence, chiral separations represent one of the most complicated classes of separation techniques. Chiral stationary phases (CSPs) may utilize multiple separation mechanisms, such as a combination of adsorption with ion exchange or complexation with size exclusion. These CSPs have been categorized according to the following types: brush (e.g., Pirkle-type), inclusion (e.g., cyclodextrin), polysaccharide (e.g., cellulose), and affinity (e.g., protein). In this section, the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of these different types of CSPs will be reviewed. 1. Brush CSPs Brush CSPs distinguish themselves from other CSPs by having a small chiral molecule covalently bonded to the solid phase, usually silica. The organic groups of the chiral molecule remain directed away from the silica surface, appearing as bristles of a brush. Among the brush CSPs, the most widely known and commercially successful are those developed by Pirkle and coworkers. Most of the Pirkle-type CSPs emphasize electron donor-acceptor interactions of the nonbonding (n) and aromatic (π) types. Chiral separations are achieved by establishing three points of interaction between an enantiomer and the CSP, where at least one of these inter-
DK4478_book.fm Page 63 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
63
actions is stereospecific [150]. Consequently, the other enantiomer is only able to sustain two points of interaction with the CSP and is less retained. Most separations with Pirkle-type CSPs are performed in the normal-phase mode. Although there have been few systematic thermodynamic studies of Pirkle-type CSPs, temperature has been successfully utilized as an optimization tool. Mazzo et al. [151] optimized the chiral separation of an antihypertensive drug, MK-286, with an N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)phenylglycine CSP. The retention factors and enantioselectivity increased with decreasing temperature, however, the broadening (plate height) also increased. Because of these concomitant changes, the resolution increased from 0.75 at room temperature to 1.25 at 0°C. Although no thermodynamic parameters were reported, it was probably an enthalpy-controlled process that facilitated separation at a lower temperature. Pescher et al. [152] optimized the separation of tertiary phosphine oxides with N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl) derivatives of phenylglycine, serine, and alanine as CSPs. They observed a similar effect of temperature, where the enantioselectivity with the phenylglycine CSP increased from 1.52 to 2.33 with a decrease in temperature from 50° to –15°C. A nonlinear dependence of enantioselectivity on temperature was observed by Weaner and Hoerr [153]. They investigated a series of fatty acid esters and amide epoxides on an N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)phenylglycine CSP. While the enantioselectivity of the ester decreased rapidly above 0°C, those of the amide reached a maximum at 10°C and remained constant up to 40°C. This behavior was attributed to the weak interaction forces between the ester and CSP and the relatively strong forces between the amide and CSP. Pirkle also observed some unusual temperature-dependent behavior [154]. In the separation of spirolactam enantiomers on an N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)phenylglycine CSP, a nonlinear van’t Hoff plot was obtained. The curvature of these plots was dependent on the concentration of 2-propanol in the mobile phase, which indicated a temperaturedependent interaction of 2-propanol with the stationary phase or with the solute. However, the natural logarithm of enantioselectivity versus the inverse temperature gave a linear relationship, which indicated that this behavior affected both enantiomers equally and had little influence on the chiral recognition mechanism. Another example with the separation of N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)-1-phenylethylamine enantiomers showed an initial decrease in enantioselectivity with a reduction in temperature, followed by an inversion of elution order and a subsequent increase in enantioselectivity [155]. The observed temperature effects showed a dependence on the type and concentration of organic modifier in the mobile phase. Pirkle and Welch [156] systematically investigated the role of solvation on the separation of N-(2-naphthyl)alanine derivatives on an N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)leucine CSP. In general, both retention and enantioselectivity decreased with increasing mobile phase polarity in both normal- and reversed-phase modes. The van’t Hoff plots, obtained over a temperature range of 0° to 90°C, were used to evaluate the thermodynamic changes in molar enthalpy and entropy as a function of mobile phase composition. Under all conditions, the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy were negative, as were the differential changes (ΔΔH and ΔΔS) for each pair of enantiomers. The enthalpy and entropy changed in a similar manner with the polarity of the mobile phase, which indicated that the highly exothermic sorption was accompanied by a correspondingly large loss in entropy. The authors noted that this
DK4478_book.fm Page 64 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
64
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
behavior is analogous to enthalpy-entropy compensation, as discussed previously. The steric effects of the organic modifier were further investigated by Blackwell et al. [157]. Their detailed study used linear, branched, and cyclic alcohols, ranging in size from ethanol to octanol, in the normal-phase mode with amide derivatives of 1-phenylethylamine as model solutes. As shown in Table 1.18, the enantioselectivity varied slightly (1.15 to 1.35) as a function of the modifier structure for an N-(3,5dinitrobenzoyl)phenylglycine CSP. The enantioselectivity was higher and varied more (1.53 to 2.44) with modifier structure for an N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)-4-amino1,2,3,4-tetrahydrophenanthrene CSP (Whelk-O; Regis Technologies, Inc., Morton Grove, IL). For both CSPs, the lowest selectivities were observed for 1-hexanol and cyclohexanol. The highest selectivities were observed for bulky modifiers, such as 2-propanol, 2-butanol, and 2-methyl-2-propanol. The highest selectivities were the result of a dramatic increase in retention of the second enantiomer. Based on detailed thermodynamic measurements, the authors suggested that the bulky modifiers cannot penetrate into the tight complex formed between the second enantiomer and the CSP. They also suggested that chiral separations giving large enantioselectivity (α > 2), such as those with the Whelk-O CSP, were not consistent with the classic three-point interaction model of Dalgliesh [150]. These separations exhibited a wide range of selectivities, were not well described by linear solvation energy relationships, and did not exhibit consistent enthalpy-entropy compensation behavior with varying modifier structure. Thermodynamic studies can also be used to examine the nature of the surface for covalently bonded CSPs. Pirkle and Readnour [158] designed a chromatographic system utilizing π-basic CSPs with a series of π-acidic solutes, bis-(2,4-dinitrophenyl)-α,ω-diaminoalkanes (bis-DNPs). The number of methylene groups in the bisDNPs was varied in order to influence their ability to interact with the CSP. The enthalpy of sorption, determined from van’t Hoff plots, was expected to be maximized (most negative) when the length of the bis-DNPs matched the distance between strands of the stationary phase. By using this approach, the authors found the maximum enthalpy when the number of methylene groups was equal to five. For CSPs having different surface coverage (0.36 to 1.36 μmol/m2), the maximum enthalpy occurred with the same number of methylene groups, but with different maximum enthalpy values. These interesting results suggested that the strands were not randomly distributed on the silica surface, but clustered with similar distributions of interstrand distances. The surface coverage thus affected the size of the cluster rather than the average distance between clusters. 2. Inclusion CSPs The most common examples of inclusion CSPs are the native and derivatized cyclodextrins. Cyclodextrins are cyclic oligosaccharides containing six or more Dglucose units connected through α-1,4-glycosidic bonds. The structure of β-cyclodextrin contains seven glucose units with 35 chiral centers, while α- and γ-cyclodextrins contain six and eight glucose units, respectively. In aqueous media, the hydroxyl groups are oriented toward the exterior surface, which makes the interior
–0.343 –0.445 –0.605 –0.486 –0.617 –0.433 –0.509 –0.391 –0.195 –0.195 –0.105 –0.505
ΔΔH (kcal/mol) –0.70 –0.97 –1.41 –1.11 –1.48 –0.96 –1.16 –0.86 –0.31 –0.32 –0.06 –1.37
ΔΔS (cal/mol K) 488 459 430 437 416 454 438 456 627 617 1814 369
Tiso (K) 2.01 2.06 2.44 1.92 2.28 1.89 2.25 1.78 1.71 1.67 1.53 1.60
α –0.891 –0.908 –1.242 –0.742 –1.087 –0.670 –1.027 –0.649 –0.604 –0.452 –0.265 –0.589
ΔΔH (kcal/mol) –1.56 –1.56 –2.32 –1.16 –1.96 –0.95 –1.77 –1.00 –0.93 –0.47 –0.02 –1.00
ΔΔS (cal/mol K)
573 581 534 638 555 706 578 650 651 957 13980 587
Tiso (K)
N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)-4-amino-1,2,3,4-tetrahydrophenanthrene
Source: Adapted from Blackwell, J.A., Waltermire, R.E., and Stringham, R.W., The role of modifiers in high selectivity chiral separations on Pirkle-type columns, Enantiomer, 6, 353, 2001.
Experimental conditions: 20% alcohol–heptane mobile phase, 30°C.
1.25 1.29 1.35 1.27 1.32 1.27 1.30 1.24 1.18 1.18 1.15 1.16
Ethanol 1-Propanol 2-Propanol 1-Butanol 2-Butanol 2-Methyl-1-propanol 2-Methyl-2-propanol 1-Pentanol 3-Methyl-1-butanol 1-Hexanol Cyclohexanol 1-Octanol
a
α
Modifier
N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)phenylglycine
TABLE 1.18 Enantioselectivity (α), Differential Changes in Molar Enthalpy (ΔΔH) and Entropy (ΔΔS), and Isoenantioselective Temperature (Tiso) for 1-Phenylethylacetamide Enantiomers Separated on Pirkle-Type CSPs with Various Alcohol Modifiersa
DK4478_book.fm Page 65 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography 65
DK4478_book.fm Page 66 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
66
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
of the cavity relatively nonpolar and hydrophobic. Consequently, solutes may enter the cavity and be retained by dispersion and hydrogen bonding interactions. Cyclodextrins were first immobilized to solid supports in 1978 [159]. Since then, extensive work has been done to improve the stability and versatility of cyclodextrin silica CSPs, which made possible their commercialization in the 1980s. However, despite the large number of publications, only limited information is available on the thermodynamic characterization of these CSPs, and even less information is available on the kinetic characterization. Both thermodynamic and kinetic information are important for elucidation of the retention mechanism. The earliest studies of temperature effects were focused on optimization of the separation process [160,161]. In these studies, lower temperature was shown to increase retention, due to stronger interactions between the solutes and the CSP, and also to increase enantioselectivity. A more detailed study of temperature was carried out by Cabrera and Lubda [162]. They separated two chiral pharmaceuticals, oxazepam and mephobarbital (Prominal), on native β-cyclodextrin silica operated in the reversed-phase mode. A decrease in temperature caused an increase in retention factor for both solutes, however, it caused different effects on their enantioselectivity. The enantioselectivity was increased by reducing the temperature for oxazepam, but by increasing the temperature for mephobarbital. The van’t Hoff plots were linear for both solutes over the temperature range of 5° to 40°C. From the thermodynamic data, the authors concluded that the differences in enantioselectivity were related to the enthalpy-controlled separation of oxazepam enantiomers (ΔΔH = –332 cal/mol, ΔΔS = 55 cal/mol) and the entropy-controlled separation of mephobarbital enantiomers (ΔΔH = 374 cal/mol, ΔΔS = 419 cal/mol). Morin et al. [163] also studied the effect of temperature on β-cyclodextrin silica with a series of six imidazole derivatives. Over the temperature range of 20° to 55°C, the van’t Hoff plots for all solutes were linear at pH 7.0 and 7.5, but curved at pH 6.5, 8.0, and 8.5. The curved plots showed a minimum in the logarithm of the retention factor between 35° and 40°C. The changes in molar enthalpy and entropy were determined from the van’t Hoff plots. An enthalpyentropy compensation analysis revealed that the retention mechanism was the same for all solutes at pH 7.0 and 7.5, and also the same for all solutes at pH 6.5, 8.0, and 8.5. From thermogravimetric analysis and differential scanning calorimetry, the authors speculated that a phase transition occurred at 43°C between the ordered and disordered state of the cyclodextrin cavity at pH 6.5, 8.0, and 8.5, but not at pH 7.0 and 7.5. In the disordered state, a gain in freedom of the hydroxyl groups on each edge of the cyclodextrin cavity was obtained with the minimum extent of hydrogen bond formation between them. In contrast, in the ordered state, a loss in freedom of the hydroxyl groups was obtained with the maximum extent of hydrogen bond formation. As a result, the hydrophobic character, surface tension, and structure of the cyclodextrin cavity were all affected, thereby altering the retention mechanism. Peyrin et al. [164] investigated the inclusion phenomena between β-cyclodextrin silica CSP and a series of dansyl amino acids with the salting-out agent sucrose. When the solute transfers from the mobile to stationary phase, sucrose is displaced from the cyclodextrin cavity. With a simple physicochemical model, the number of displaced sucrose molecules can be determined and the relative extent of solute inclusion can thus be calculated. The authors concluded that the L-enantiomers of
DK4478_book.fm Page 67 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
67
the dansyl amino acids displaced a constant number of 1.9 sucrose molecules regardless of the R group. In contrast, the D-enantiomers displaced a larger number of sucrose molecules that decreased from 2.7 to 2.2 as the accessible surface area of the R group increased. Hence, the chiral recognition and enantioselectivity decreased with increasing size of the R group. The theoretical value of the accessible surface area that corresponded to no chiral resolution was 191 Å2. It is noteworthy that the equivalent length of the R group (7.8 Å) is equal to the internal diameter of the native β-cyclodextrin cavity. The authors concluded that the inclusion process was largely dependent on steric hindrance. Temperature was also varied from 20° to 45°C to observe the thermodynamic effects on enantioselectivity. The negative ΔΔH and ΔΔS values were determined from the linear van’t Hoff plots, which indicated an enthalpy-controlled separation for all dansyl amino acids. The ΔΔH and ΔΔS values became less negative with increasing accessible surface area of the R group and more negative with increasing sucrose concentration. A similar approach was utilized by Guillaume et al. [165] using water as a surface tension modifier in the mobile phase. In this case, water was displaced when the dansyl amino acids were transferred to the β-cyclodextrin cavity. Similar results were concluded on the relative degrees of inclusion of the D- and L-enantiomers and the importance of steric effects in the chiral recognition mechanism. The effect of pressure on the separation process with a β-cyclodextrin silica CSP was investigated by Ringo and Evans [166]. With the positional isomers of nitrophenol as model solutes, a shift in retention with modest pressure change (300 bar) was observed and correlated to the change in partial molar volume for the complexation process. The same method was applied to chiral separations with barbiturates, β-blockers, and anticoagulants as model solutes [167–169]. Most chiral compounds showed a dependence of the retention factor, enantioselectivity, and separation efficiency on pressure. The retention factor dependence reflected the statistical nonzero changes of molar volume for the complexation processes. As illustrated in Table 1.19, the retention factors exhibited an increase or no change with pressure, and the change in molar volume was negative or negligible in the reversed-phase mode. However, in the polar-organic mode, the retention factors showed a decrease with pressure, and the change in molar volume was positive or negligible. The change in molar volume ranged from –12 to 17 cm3/mol. The enantioselectivity dependence reflected the unequal changes in molar volume between the enantiomers. Mephobarbital, metoprolol, and warfarin demonstrated a dependence of selectivity on pressure, with both positive and negative dependence observed. These pressure experiments provided insight into the differential volume of enantiomeric complexes formed with β-cyclodextrin. Recently, Wang and Ching [170] and Yu and Ching [171] investigated both the thermodynamic and kinetic behavior of derivatized β-cyclodextrin silica CSPs. The equilibrium and kinetic constants for the chiral separation were obtained by moment analysis on the basis of the equilibrium-dispersive and transport-dispersive (solidfilm linear driving force) models. The overall mass transfer coefficients, axial dispersion coefficients, and equilibrium constants were used to simulate the enantiomeric band profiles. Excellent correlation between simulated and experimental results confirmed the accuracy of the method as well as the results. The overall mass
DK4478_book.fm Page 68 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
68
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 1.19 Effect of Pressure on Retention Factor (k) and Change in Molar Volume (ΔV) on a βCyclodextrin Silica Phase Operated in the Reversed-Phase Modea Δk/k (%) R-
Solute Hexobarbital Mephobarbital Ibuprofen Chlorthalidone Benzoin
12 11 2 1 –2
± ± ± ± ±
ΔV (cm3/mol)
S3 2 5 18 11
11 10 2 2 –2
± ± ± ± ±
2 3 4 18 8
R-
S-
–12 –11 –3 –2 0
–12 –10 –4 –3 +1
a
Experimental conditions: methanol-water–acetic acid– triethylamine mobile phase, 295 K. Source: Adapted from Ringo, M.C. and Evans, C.E., Pressure-induced changes in chiral separations in liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 69, 4964, 1997.
transfer coefficients were determined to be 58 min–1 and 73 min–1 for S- and Rfluoxetine; respectively, and 669 min–1, 846 min–1, and 106 min–1 for the coeluted SRS- and SSR-nadolols, RRS-nadolol, and RSR-nadolol, respectively. These kinetic data indicate that mass transfer processes in the derivatized β-cyclodextrin silica CSPs are relatively rapid. 3. Polysaccharide CSPs Polysaccharides such as amylose and cellulose are naturally occurring, optically active polymers. Amylose is composed of glucose units connected with α-1,4glycosidic bonds and adopts a helical structure in its native form. Cellulose is based on β-1,4-glycosidic bonds and adopts a more linear structure. Native polysaccharides have long been known to exhibit chiral selectivity [172], however, their chiral resolving abilities are not sufficient for practical usage. Poor resolution and broad peaks are obtained due to nonstereoselective binding and slow mass transfer processes, especially diffusion through the polymer network. In comparison, derivatized polysaccharide CSPs have much better chromatographic and enantiomeric properties, which has led to their successful commercialization. The chiral recognition mechanism for polysaccharide CSPs is generally thought to consist of cohesive attraction followed by steric fit of the chiral solute into the chiral surface. The structural differences between amylose and cellulose are responsible for the difference in their retention mechanisms. As a result, the thermodynamics and kinetics associated with the separation process are different as well. The temperature dependence of chiral discrimination was investigated by Smith et al. [173]. Two analogues of cromakalim, a potassium channel activator, were
DK4478_book.fm Page 69 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
69
separated on cellulose derivatized with tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (Chiralcel-OD; Daicel Chemical Industries, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) over the temperature range from 0° to 42°C. Although the two analogs differ only by replacement of a benzoyl group with an n-pentanoyl group, they showed different temperature dependence. The benzoyl enantiomers exhibited an increasing trend in resolution with increasing temperature, whereas the n-pentanoyl enantiomers had a decreasing trend. The van’t Hoff plots were linear for all enantiomers, from which the changes in molar enthalpy and entropy were determined. A large difference was observed for ΔΔH (1.929 and 4.265 kJ/mol for the benzoyl and n-pentanoyl enantiomers, respectively), but relatively small difference for ΔΔS (10.3 and 13.6 J/mol K, respectively). The isoenantioselective temperature, which is analogous to the enthalpy-entropy compensation temperature, also differed greatly (–86°C and 41°C, respectively). Hence, the benzoyl enantiomers exhibited an entropy-dominated separation, whereas the n-pentanoyl enantiomers had an enthalpy-dominated separation. The authors concluded that increased temperature should be beneficial for any chiral separation that predominantly involves π-type electron donor-acceptor interactions and, conversely, that decreased temperature should be beneficial for separations that predominantly involve hydrogen bonding interactions. This general conclusion was confirmed by Kuesters and Spoendlin [174] for the separation of rolipram and a series of structurally related compounds on the same Chiralcel-OD CSP over the temperature range from 10° to 60°C. These aromatic compounds showed an unusual entropydominated separation with ΔΔH of 1.62 kJ/mol and ΔΔS of 5.72 J/mol K for rolipram, similar to the entropy-dominated separation of the benzoyl analog discussed above. More enthalpy-dominated separations were observed by Mesplet et al. [175] for some phosphoramidate derivatives of anti-human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) nucleosides. A detailed mechanistic investigation was undertaken by O’Brien et al. [176] with a diol intermediate for a leukotriene D4 antagonist separated on cellulose derivatized with tris(4-methylbenzoate) (Chiralcel-OJ; Daicel Chemical Industries, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan). A nonlinear van’t Hoff plot was observed over the temperature range of 5° to 50°C for both retention factor and selectivity, as shown in Figure 1.4. At low temperature (region II), the enantioselectivity was entropy controlled with positive values for ΔΔH and ΔΔS, but at high temperature (region I), it was enthalpy-controlled with negative values for ΔΔH and ΔΔS. This temperature dependence was very unusual. In general, the entropy contribution (T ΔΔS) should tend to increase with increasing temperature and overcome the enthalpy contribution (ΔΔH), thereby changing the separation mechanism from enthalpy-dominated to entropy-dominated with increasing temperature. The unusual temperature dependence observed by O’Brien et al. [176] suggested a phase transition in the CSP. The transition observed in the van’t Hoff plots occurred at a temperature of approximately 18°C, where a conformational change in the stationary phase was confirmed by infrared spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry. The thermodynamic behavior was also examined for different mobile phase compositions in the normal-phase mode. With an increase in concentration of the organic modifier, 2-propanol, an increase in ΔΔH was observed in both regions I and II, accompanied by an increase in ΔΔS. These two effects canceled each other by means of enthalpy-entropy compensation and
DK4478_book.fm Page 70 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
70
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
10
Retention factor
R enantiomer Region II R enantiomer Region I
S enantiomer Region II S enantiomer Region I
1 0.0030
0.0031
0.0032
0.0033
0.0034
0.0035
0.0036
−1)
1/temperature (K (a) 1.8
Region II
Selectivity
1.7
Region I 1.6
1.5 0.0030
0.0031
0.0032 0.0033 0.0034 1/temperature (K−1)
0.0035
0.0036
(b)
FIGURE 1.4 Van’t Hoff plots of (a) retention factor (k) and (b) enantioselectivity (α) for the diol enantiomers on the Chiralcel-OJ column (25 cm × 4.6 mm inner diameter). Mobile phase: 40% 2-propanol-hexane. (Adapted from O’Brien, T., Crocker, L., Thompson, R., Thompson, K., Toma, P.H., Conlon, D.A., Feibush, B., Moeder, C., Bicker, G., and Grinberg, N., Mechanistic aspects of chiral discrimination on modified cellulose, Anal. Chem., 69, 1999, 1997.)
DK4478_book.fm Page 71 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
71
resulted in a negligible change in molar free energy. This explains why an increase in the concentration of 2-propanol had virtually no effect on enantioselectivity. The authors suggested that the loss of interaction energy for the more retained R-enantiomer relative to the S-enantiomer with increasing 2-propanol concentration was balanced by a relative increase in the space available for the R-enantiomer when it entered the stationary phase. This was indicative of a swelling of the cellulose CSP with increasing 2-propanol concentration. The kinetic behavior was also evaluated by means of the plate height method. For the more retained R-enantiomer, the reduced plate height was large at temperatures up to 10°C, but showed a sharp decrease above 15°C. However, for the S-enantiomer, the reduced plate height showed a gradual decrease over the entire temperature range of 5° to 50°C. These data suggest that slow mass transfer processes occurred for the R-enantiomer at lower temperatures. This behavior was attributed to the relatively slow inclusion of the R-enantiomer at low temperature, where the cellulose chains are rigid. In closely related studies, Wang et al. [177–179] reported some unusual temperature effects with polysaccharide CSPs. They separated the enantiomers of dihydropyrimidinone (DHP) acid and its methyl ester on both amylose and cellulose derivatized with tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (Chiralpak-AD and ChiralcelOD; Daicel Chemical Industries, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan). A nonlinear van’t Hoff plot was observed for R- and S-DHP acid on Chiralpak-AD, but a linear relationship was observed on Chiralcel-OD. Moreover, the van’t Hoff plots obtained with Chiralpak-AD upon cyclic heating and cooling between 5° and 50°C were not superimposable, as shown in Figure 1.5. This suggested an irreversible, thermally induced conformational change of Chiralpak-AD at approximately 30°C. Solid-state NMR was utilized to verify and to characterize this conformation change. Booth and Wainer [180] investigated the separation of mexiletine and a series of structurally related solutes on Chiralpak-AD CSP. Although a nonlinear van’t Hoff plot was observed for one solute (which was subsequently eliminated), linear van’t Hoff plots were observed for all others over the temperature range from 0° to 30°C. The change in molar enthalpy was, thus, constant and negative for these solutes. An enthalpyentropy compensation plot of ln k vs. –ΔH was then constructed. The data for these solutes fell into two distinct groups, with linearity observed within each group. This linearity was indicative of an enthalpy-entropy compensation phenomenon within that group of solutes. The two groups had different compensation temperatures and, hence, different retention mechanisms. It was interesting to note that one group contained the solutes with hydroxyl substituents, while the other group contained all other solutes. The frontal analysis method has been utilized by Rearden et al. [181] and SeidelMorgenstern and Guiochon [182] to elucidate thermodynamics and mass transfer kinetics. The sorption isotherms of Troeger’s base were determined on a microcrystalline cellulose triacetate CSP over a temperature range of 30° to 60°C. Whereas the S-enantiomer exhibited a Langmuir isotherm, the R-enantiomer could best be described by a quadratic equation for an S-shaped isotherm. The sorption enthalpies of both enantiomers increased with increasing temperature. The mass transfer kinetics for the S-enantiomer were studied by two different models, the equilibriumdispersive and transport-dispersive (solid-film linear driving force) models. The two
DK4478_book.fm Page 72 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
72
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
Retention factor
100
10
1 0.0030 0.0031 0.0032 0.0033 0.0034 0.0035 0.0036 0.0037 1/temperature (K−1) (a)
Selectivity
10
1 0.0030 0.0031 0.0032 0.0033 0.0034 0.0035 0.0036 0.0037 1/temperature (K−1) (b)
FIGURE 1.5 Van’t Hoff plots of (a) retention factor (k) and (b) enantioselectivity (α) for DHP acid on the Chiralcel-AD column (25 cm × 4.6 mm inner diameter). Mobile phase: 15% ethanol-hexane with 0.1% trifluoroacetic acid. Methods: (a) R-(–)-DHP acid, heating (), cooling (); S-(+)-DHP acid, heating (), cooling (). (b) heating (), cooling (). (Adapted from Wang, F., O’Brien, T., Dowling, T., Bicker, G., and Wyvratt, J., Unusual effect of column temperature on chromatographic enantioseparation of dihydropyrimidinone acid and methyl ester on amylose chiral stationary phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 958, 69, 2002.)
DK4478_book.fm Page 73 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
73
approaches gave almost identical results. The mass transfer rate constant was determined to be around 7 to 11 min–1 for concentration steps from 0 to 3.2 g/L of Troeger’s base. 4. Affinity CSPs Proteins are naturally occurring, optically active polymers composed of L-amino acids. As a result, immobilized proteins on solid supports are capable of discriminating enantiomers. Protein-based CSPs are of special interest because of their unique enantioselective properties and wide range of applications. Chromatographic methods are distinguished on the basis of whether the proteins are soluble or immobilized, where the latter is known as affinity chromatography. The most commonly used proteins are as follows: (1) albumins, such as human serum albumin (HSA) and BSA; (2) glycoproteins, such as α1-acid glycoprotein, ovomucoid, and avidin; (3) enzymes, such as cellobiohydrolase I, lysozyme, and pepsin; and (4) other miscellaneous proteins, such as β-lactoglobulin. Although protein CSPs are widely used, the elucidation of their retention mechanism is relatively difficult due to their complex structures. These complex structures are the result of different amino acid sequences (primary structure) as well as different disulfide bridges, hydrogen bonding, and other types of intramolecular bonding (secondary and tertiary structure). Because of their structure, protein CSPs usually rely on different numbers or types of binding sites for discrimination of enantiomers. To retain the protein structure and avoid denaturation, most separations are performed in the reversed-phase mode. Both elution and frontal analysis methods have been used to characterize the binding constants, as well as thermodynamic and kinetic parameters. Loun and Hage [183,184] have systematically investigated the chiral separation mechanism of a HSA CSP by using warfarin as a model solute. From frontal analysis, it was found that both enantiomers have a single type of binding site in the same area of HSA. Temperature-dependent measurements of the equilibrium constant, obtained over the temperature range from 4° to 45°C, enabled the calculation of specific thermodynamic parameters. Although the changes in molar free energy were similar for R- and S-warfarin (–7.5 and –7.7 kcal/mol, respectively, at 37°C), the contributions from molar enthalpy and entropy were different. The R-enantiomer had a smaller contribution than the S-enantiomer from the enthalpy change (–3.5 and –5.6 kcal/mol, respectively), but a larger contribution from the entropy change (13 and 7 cal/mol K, respectively). The larger entropy change for R-warfarin indicated that more solvent molecules were released during the binding, while the larger enthalpy change for S-warfarin indicated stronger interaction during the binding. This is consistent with a model in which R-warfarin interacts with amino acid residues deep within the binding pocket of HSA mainly by hydrophobic interactions, whereas S-warfarin interacts with residues at or near the outer rim of the binding site mainly by polar interactions. The effect of the mobile phase was investigated by increasing the concentration of the polar organic modifier 2-propanol in aqueous phosphate buffer. Concomitantly, the retention factor for R-warfarin decreased, but that for S-warfarin increased. This result provided further support for the authors’
DK4478_book.fm Page 74 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
74
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
suggestion that R-warfarin interacted by nonpolar interaction, while S-warfarin interacted by polar interaction. From elution analysis, the plate height model was utilized to study the band broadening processes and to measure sorption/desorption kinetics. With an increase in temperature, both the sorption and desorption rate constants increased while the equilibrium constant decreased. The faster kinetics resulted in a decrease in plate height and an increase in column efficiency. The measurement of mass transfer kinetics at different temperatures allowed the calculation of activation energy, activation enthalpy, and activation entropy. Although the activation energy was similar for R- and S-warfarin (10.8 and 11.5 kcal/mol, respectively, at 37°C), the contributions from activation enthalpy and entropy were different. The R-enantiomer had a larger activation enthalpy (10.5 and 1.9 kcal/mol), but a smaller activation entropy (–0.9 and 31 cal/mol K) than the S-enantiomer. The large positive activation enthalpy for R-warfarin indicated more bonds breaking than forming during the complex-formation process, whereas the more negative activation entropy for S-warfarin indicated a higher degree of order. These results also corresponded well with the retention model presented previously. In this way, thermodynamic and kinetic information help to elucidate specific retention and separation mechanisms. Similar experiments were performed for another chiral solute, tryptophan, by Yang and Hage [185–187]. Both D- and L-tryptophan had a single type of binding site, but unlike the warfarin enantiomers, they were in different areas of HSA. The strength of L-tryptophan binding was enthalpy dominated, while Dtryptophan was entropy dominated. Consequently, L-tryptophan showed greater changes when varying the temperature, pH, ionic strength, and modifier concentration of the mobile phase. These changes were predominantly due to changes in the equilibrium constant, but also to changes in the moles of binding sites (phase ratio). From kinetic studies, L-tryptophan showed much greater broadening and, hence, slower kinetics than D-tryptophan. The primary contribution was the much slower desorption rate of L-tryptophan from the HSA phase. Fornstedt et al. [188–190] and Goetmar et al. [191] systematically investigated another type of protein CSP, immobilized cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I), with some β-andrenergic blocking agents as chiral solutes. The sorption isotherms for both Rand S-propranolol were fit well to the bi-Langmuir model. One of the contributions was the same for both enantiomers, whereas the other was different. The common contribution was considered to be the nonchiral (type I) interaction, while the other was the chirally selective (type II) interaction. It was suspected that the chirally selective interaction involved the formation of ion pairs on this CSP. Thus the saturation capacity of the type II sites was lower because of the limited number of ionic sites. As a result, the enantioselectivity decreased with an increase in solute concentration and eventually vanished when the nonchiral interactions became predominant. Also, due to the ionic nature of the chirally selective sites, retention behavior was pH dependent. At pH 4.7, the retention times of both enantiomers decreased with increasing temperature from 5° to 55°C. However, at pH 5.5, the retention time of the more retained S-propranolol increased, while that of R-propranolol decreased with increasing temperature. Thus, at this pH, an unusual increase in chiral selectivity was observed with an increase in temperature. Detailed thermodynamic parameters were determined at this pH to try to explain this phenomenon.
DK4478_book.fm Page 75 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
75
The changes in molar enthalpy and entropy on type I sites were calculated as –1.1 kcal/mol and 0.1 cal/mol K, respectively. On type II sites, R-propranolol had negative changes in molar enthalpy and entropy at –1.9 kcal/mol and –2.6 cal/mol K, respectively, whereas S-propranolol had positive changes at 1.6 kcal/mol and 11.6 cal/mol K, respectively. The authors attributed the large positive entropy change to a considerable decrease in the organization of water molecules around the chiral (type II) sites in the protein CSP. The positive enthalpy change suggested that this disorganization was associated with weakening of the hydrogen bonding of water molecules. The endothermic interaction for the S-enantiomer and exothermic interaction for the R-enantiomer accounted for the unusual temperature-dependent behavior. Peak tailing was observed at both low and high concentrations of solutes. At low concentrations, the type II sites were within the linear range of the isotherm. The tailing observed was a result of slow heterogeneous mass transfer kinetics. At high concentrations, the type II sites were saturated and no longer within the linear range. As a result, the more pronounced tailing observed was a combination of heterogeneous thermodynamics and heterogeneous kinetics. The transport-dispersive model using the solid-film linear driving force model with homogeneous kinetics failed to account for the pronounced peak tailing, while the same model with heterogeneous kinetics accounted well. For example, a sorption rate constant of 10,000 min–1 and desorption rate constant of 18/min–1 were determined for best fit to the experimental zone profile produced with 100 μl of 0.36 mM propranolol. The rate constants were found to be concentration dependent. With higher concentrations of 1.02 and 1.55 mM propranolol, the sorption rate constant was decreased to 90 min–1 and 60 min–1, respectively, when the desorption rate constant was held constant at 18 min–1. Some other interesting thermodynamic studies have been performed on other types of protein CSPs. Gilpin et al. [192] separated tryptophan enantiomers on a BSA CSP at varying temperatures and pH values. For D-tryptophan, the van’t Hoff plot was reasonably linear over the temperature range from 0.5° to 45°C. However, for L-tryptophan, a nonlinear plot was observed with a maximum value at approximately 20° to 24°C. The authors noted that the initial increase in the retention factor of L-tryptophan with temperature is thermodynamically inconsistent with a simple retention mechanism, where binding occurs at a fixed number of specific sites with a constant, negative change in molar enthalpy. They speculated that the observed nonlinearity may be due to an increase in the number of binding sites due to gross changes in protein surface orientation or an increase in the binding energy due to induced conformational changes of the protein. These changes are apparently not consequential for D-tryptophan, which does not have a specific binding site with BSA. Amyloglucosidase was immobilized onto the silica support by Strandberg et al. [193]. Both retention and enantioselectivity increased with column temperature. The ionic strength of the mobile phase and the concentration of the organic modifier 2-propanol both affected the chiral selectivity. The pH of the mobile phase affected the charges of the CSP and solute, thereby influencing their interactions. A pH above the isoelectric point of the protein CSP introduced more electrostatic interaction between the positively charged solute and the negatively charged protein. The thermodynamic results indicated that the interaction could be enthalpy or entropy dominated, depending on the mobile phase composition. An inversion of elution order
DK4478_book.fm Page 76 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
76
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
was observed for enantiomers of mosapride on an α1-acid glycoprotein CSP with a change in temperature and pH [194]. A linear van’t Hoff plot was obtained at a lower pH (4.2), but a nonlinear plot was obtained at a higher pH (7.4). Thermodynamic results showed the separation was enthalpy dominated at a lower pH, but entropy dominated at a higher pH. A vancomycin-based CSP was used to separate a series of dansyl amino acids in the temperature range of 0° to 28°C [195]. Linear van’t Hoff plots were obtained for all enantiomers. However, their thermodynamic parameters were distinguished in two groups, where the first group had a more negative ΔH with smaller molecular size (e.g., dansyl valine and leucine) and the second group had a much less negative ΔH with a larger molecular size (e.g., dansyl tryptophan). Enthalpy-entropy compensation was observed for the chiral compounds within the same group, indicating a similar retention mechanism. The size of the solute affected its retention and chiral recognition by affecting the hydrophobic interaction and steric hindrance with the CSP. Berthod et al. [196] observed linear van’t Hoff plots on four macrocyclic glycopeptide CSPs with 71 chiral compounds, which indicated that no conformational transitions were observed for these CSPs. Most chiral separations were enthalpy controlled, with a few exceptions, depending on the mobile phase composition and the solute structure as well. Enthalpy-entropy compensation was observed in most cases. In summary, protein CSPs have a much more complex structure than those CSPs containing only small chiral molecules. Temperature and pH are the most important parameters that control retention and separation behavior in this type of CSP. Broader peaks are usually observed due to the slow mass transfer kinetics. More investigations need to be performed to increase mass transfer kinetics and enable greater column efficiency for protein CSPs.
V. CONCLUSION Thermodynamic studies provide a detailed description of the equilibrium (or steady-state) aspects of the retention mechanism, including energetic, enthalpic, entropic, and volumetric contributions. Kinetic studies provide a complementary description of the nonequilibrium (or nonsteady-state) aspects, including the same energetic, enthalpic, entropic, and volumetric contributions. With alternative methods of data analysis, kinetic studies can also provide an account of the rank and magnitude of mass transfer processes. This detailed knowledge is necessary to transform routine applications of liquid chromatography from trial-and-error efforts to rational and efficient optimizations. Moreover, this knowledge is helpful to guide the development of new stationary phases with improved thermodynamic and kinetic performance. Among the common retention mechanisms in liquid chromatography, the most systematic and thorough thermodynamic and kinetic studies have been performed for partition using alkylsilica stationary phases operated in the reversed-phase mode. These studies have provided a cohesive picture of the retention event that, while not fully complete, includes the effects of stationary phase composition, mobile phase composition, solute structure, as well as temperature and pressure. Other mechanisms, such as adsorption, ion exchange, and size exclusion, are reasonably well
DK4478_book.fm Page 77 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
77
understood from a thermodynamic perspective, but not sufficiently well characterized from a kinetic perspective. The most complicated separations are those that combine multiple mechanisms, such as chiral separations. For these complex separations, the small number of studies that have been performed with unrelated stationary phases and solutes provide, at best, an unclear and incomplete description. Much more systematic work needs to be done to elucidate their thermodynamic and kinetic behavior more fully. In addition, much work remains to be done in the nonlinear regime of the isotherms so that all sites on these stationary phases can be adequately characterized.
REFERENCES 1. McGuffin, V.L., Theory of chromatography, in Chromatography, 6th ed., Fundamentals and Applications of Chromatography and Related Differential Migration Methods — Part A: Fundamentals and Techniques, Heftmann, E., ed., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2004, pp. 1–93. 2. Giddings, J.C., Dynamics of Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1965. 3. Atkins, P.W., Physical Chemistry, 6th ed., W.H. Freeman, New York, 1997. 4. Leffler, J. and Grunwald, E., Rates and Equilibria of Organic Reactions, Wiley, New York, 1963. 5. Krug, R.R., Hunter, W.G., and Grieger, R.A., Enthalpy-entropy compensation. 1. Some fundamental statistical problems associated with the analysis of van’t Hoff and Arrhenius data, J. Phys. Chem., 80, 2335, 1976. 6. Krug, R.R., Hunter, W.G., and Grieger, R.A., Enthalpy-entropy compensation. 2. Separation of the chemical from the statistical effect, J. Phys. Chem., 80, 2341, 1976. 7. Ranatunga, R., Vitha, M.F., and Carr, P.W., Mechanistic implications of the equality of compensation temperatures in chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 946, 47, 2002. 8. McGuffin, V.L. and Chen, S.H., Molar enthalpy and molar volume of methylene and benzene homologues in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 762, 35, 1998. 9. Miyabe, K. and Guiochon, G., Measurement of the parameters of the mass transfer kinetics in high performance liquid chromatography, J. Separat. Sci., 26, 155, 2003. 10. Bernasconi, C.F., Relaxation Kinetics, Academic Press, New York, 1976. 11. Harris, J.M. and Marshall, D.B., Direct measurement of sorption/desorption kinetics in reversed-phase chromatographic systems, J. Microcolumn Sep., 9, 185, 1997. 12. Dawson, A., Gormally, J., Wyn-Jones, E., and Holzwarth, J., Comparison of results obtained in kinetic studies of the interaction between cationic dyes and sodium carboxymethylcellulose using the Joule-heating temperature-jump and laser temperature-jump methods, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun., 8, 386, 1981. 13. Waite, S.W., Marshall, D.B., and Harris, J.M., Temperature-jump investigation of sorption/desorption kinetics at reversed-phase chromatographic silica/solution interfaces, Anal. Chem., 66, 2052, 1994. 14. Ellison, E.H., Waite, S.W., Marshall, D.B., and Harris, J.M., Joule-discharge heating studies of pore connectivity in silica gel: Influence of pore diameter, chemical modification, and particle size, Anal. Chem., 65, 3622, 1993. 15. Waite, S.W., Harris, J.M., Ellison, E.H., and Marshall, D.B., Temperature-jump relaxation kinetics at liquid/solid interfaces: Fluorescence thermometry of porous silica heated by a Joule discharge, Anal. Chem., 63, 2365, 1991.
DK4478_book.fm Page 78 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
78
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45 16. Caldin, E.F. and Field, J.P., Kinetics of complex formation between zinc mesotetraphenylporphyrin and some nitrogen bases in aprotic solvents, studied by an improved microwave temperature-jump method, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 78, 1923, 1982. 17. Waite, S.W., Holzwarth, J.F., and Harris, J.M., Laser temperature jump relaxation measurements of adsorption/desorption kinetics at liquid/solid interfaces, Anal. Chem., 67, 1390, 1995. 18. Marshall, D.B., Burns, J.W., and Connolly, D.E., Direct measurement of liquid chromatographic sorption-desorption kinetics and the kinetic contribution to band broadening, J. Chromatogr., 360, 13, 1986. 19. Shield, S.R. and Harris, J.M., Triplet-state photoexcitation dipole-jump relaxation method to observe adsorption/desorption kinetics at a reversed-phase silica/solution interface, Anal. Chem., 74, 2248, 2002. 20. Gowanlock, D., Bailey, R., and Cantwell, F.F., Intra-particle sorption rate and liquid chromatographic bandbroadening in porous polymer packings. I. Methodology and validation of the model, J. Chromatogr. A, 726, 1, 1996. 21. Li, J., Litwinson, L.M., and Cantwell, F.F., Intra-particle sorption rate and liquid chromatographic bandbroadening in porous polymer packings. II. Slow sorption rate on a microparticle packing, J. Chromatogr. A, 726, 25, 1996. 22. Li, J. and Cantwell, F.F., Intra-particle sorption rate and liquid chromatographic bandbroadening in porous polymer packings. III. Diffusion in the polymer matrix as the cause of slow sorption, J. Chromatogr. A, 726, 37, 1996. 23. Bujalski, R. and Cantwell, F.F., Continuous desorption rate measurement from a shallow-bed of poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) particles with correction for experimental artifacts, J. Chromatogr. A, 1048, 173, 2004. 24. Howerton, S.B. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 75, 3539, 2003. 25. Thomas, H.C., Heterogeneous ion exchange in a flowing system, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 66, 1664, 1944. 26. Wade, J.L., Bergold, A.F., and Carr, P.W., Theoretical description of nonlinear chromatography, with applications to physicochemical measurements in affinity chromatography and implications for preparative-scale separations, Anal. Chem., 59, 1286, 1987. 27. Golshan-Shirazi, S. and Guiochon, G., Comparison of the various kinetic models of non-linear chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 603, 1, 1992. 28. Guiochon, G., Preparative liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 965, 129, 2002. 29. Tijssen, R., Schoenmakers, P.J., Bohmer, M.R., Koopal, L.K., and Billiet, H.A.H., Lattice models for the description of partitioning/adsorption and retention in reversedphase liquid chromatography, including surface and shape effects, J. Chromatogr., 656, 135, 1993. 30. Horvath, C., Melander, W., and Molnar, I., Solvophobic interactions in liquid chromatography with nonpolar stationary phases, J. Chromatogr., 125, 129, 1976. 31. Horvath, C. and Melander, W., Liquid chromatography with hydrocarbonaceous bonded phases; theory and practice of reversed phase chromatography, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 15, 393, 1977. 32. Martire, D.E. and Boehm, R.E., Unified theory of retention and selectivity in liquid chromatography. 2. Reversed-phase liquid chromatography with chemically bonded phases, J. Phys. Chem., 87, 1045, 1983.
DK4478_book.fm Page 79 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
79
33. Dill, K.A., The mechanism of solute retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Phys. Chem., 91, 1980, 1987. 34. Tan, L.C. and Carr, P.W., Revisionist look at solvophobic driving forces in reversedphase liquid chromatography II. Partitioning vs. adsorption mechanism in monomeric alkyl bonded phase supports, J. Chromatogr. A, 775, 1, 1997. 35. Park, J.H., Lee, Y.K., Weon, Y.C., Tan, L.C., Li, J., Li, L., Evans, J.F., and Carr, P.W., Revisionist look at solvophobic driving forces in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. IV. Partitioning vs. adsorption mechanism on various types of polymeric bonded phases, J. Chromatogr. A, 767, 1, 1997. 36. Horvath, C. and Melander, W., Reversed-phase chromatography and the hydrophobic effect, Am. Lab., 10, 17, 1978. 37. Carr, P.W., Li, J., Dallas, A.J., Eikens, D.I., and Tan, L.C., Revisionist look at solvophobic driving forces in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 656, 113, 1993. 38. Ranatunga, R.P.J. and Carr, P.W., A study of the enthalpy and entropy contributions of the stationary phase in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 72, 5679, 2000. 39. Krstulovic, A.M., Colin, H., Tchapla, A., and Guiochon, G., Effects of the bonded alkyl chain length on methylene selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 17, 228, 1983. 40. Tchapla, A., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G., Linearity of homologous series retention plots in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 56, 621, 1984. 41. Tchapla, A., Heron, S., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G., Role of temperature in the behavior of homologous series in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 60, 1443, 1988. 42. Jinno, K. and Ozaki, N., Enthalpy-entropy compensation of octylsilica stationary phase in reversed-phase HPLC, J. Liq. Chromatogr., 7, 877, 1984. 43. Miyabe, K. and Guiochon, G., Extrathermodynamic study of surface diffusion in reversed-phase liquid chromatography with silica gels bonded with alkyl ligands of different chain lengths, J. Phys. Chem. B, 109, 12038, 2005. 44. Sentell, K.B. and Dorsey, J.G., Retention mechanisms in reversed-phase chromatography: Stationary-phase bonding density and partitioning, Anal. Chem., 61, 930, 1989. 45. Sentell, K.B. and Dorsey, J.G., Retention mechanisms in reversed-phase chromatography: Stationary phase bonding density and solute selectivity, J. Chromatogr., 461, 193, 1989. 46. Sander, L.C. and Wise, S.A., Synthesis and characterization of polymeric C18 stationary phases for liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 56, 504, 1984. 47. Cole, L.A. and Dorsey, J.G., Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 1. Stationary-phase considerations, Anal. Chem., 64, 1317, 1992. 48. Gill, S.J. and Wadso, I., An equation of state describing hydrophobic interactions, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 73, 2955, 1976. 49. Rimmer, C.A., Sander, L.C., Wise, S.A., and Dorsey, J.G., Synthesis and characterization of C13 to C18 stationary phases by monomeric solution polymerized and surface polymerized approaches, J. Chromatogr. A, 1007, 11, 2003. 50. Jinno, K., Nagoshi, T., Tanaka, N., Okamoto, M., Fetzer, J.C., and Biggs, W.R., Effect of column temperature on the retention of pero-pyrene-type polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons on various chemically bonded stationary phases in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 436, 1, 1988.
DK4478_book.fm Page 80 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
80
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45 51. Wheeler, J.F., Beck, T.L., Klatte, S.J., Cole, L.A., and Dorsey, J.G., Phase transitions of reversed-phase stationary phases: Cause and effects in the mechanism of retention, J. Chromatogr. A, 656, 317, 1993. 52. Morel, D. and Serpinet, J., Gas chromatographic evidence for phase transitions in very compact octadecyl bonded silicas, J. Chromatogr., 200, 95, 1980. 53. Morel, D. and Serpinet, J., Influence of the liquid chromatographic mobile phase on the phase transitions of alkyl-bonded silicas studies by gas chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 214, 202, 1981. 54. Claudy, P., Letoffe, J.M., Morel, D., and Serpinet, J., Long-chain alkyl grafts and mixed alkyl-alkane layers at the surface of macroporous silicas: Their gas chromatographic properties below and above the phase transition, J. Chromatogr., 329, 331, 1985. 55. Van Miltenburg, J.C. and Hammers, W.E., Transitions in chemically bonded organic phases on silica: Specific heat measurements by adiabatic calorimetry, J. Chromatogr., 268, 147, 1983. 56. Sander, L.C., Callis, J.B., and Field, L.R., Fourier-transform infrared spectrometric determination of alkyl chain conformation on chemically bonded reversed-phase liquid chromatography packings, Anal. Chem., 55, 1068, 1983. 57. McGuffin, V.L. and Lee, C., Thermodynamics and kinetics of solute transfer in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 987, 3, 2003. 58. Howerton, S.B. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 75, 3539, 2003. 59. Vervoort, R.J.M., Ruyter, E., Debets, A.J.J., Claessens, H.A., Cramers, C.A., and de Jong, G.J., Characterization of reversed-phase stationary phases for the liquid chromatographic analysis of basic pharmaceuticals by thermodynamic data, J. Chromatogr. A, 964, 67, 2002. 60. Neue, U.D., Alden, B.A., and Walter, T.H., Universal procedure for the assessment of the reproducibility and the classification of silica-based reversed-phase packings. II. Classification of reversed-phase packings, J. Chromatogr. A, 849, 101, 1999. 61. Neue, U.D., Van Tran, K., Iraneta, P.C., and Alden, B.A., Characterization of HPLC packings, J. Separat. Sci., 26, 174, 2003. 62. Vailaya, A. and Horvath, C., Exothermodynamic relationships in liquid chromatography, J. Phys. Chem., 102, 701, 1998. 63. Layne, J., Characterization and comparison of the chromatographic performance of conventional, polar-embedded, and polar-endcapped reversed-phase liquid chromatography stationary phases, J. Chromatogr. A, 957, 149, 2002. 64. Liu, Y., Grinberg, N., Thompson, K.C., Wenslow, R.M., Neue, U.D., Morrison, D., Walter, T.H., O’Gara, J.E., and Wyndham, K.D., Evaluation of a C18 hybrid stationary phase using high-temperature chromatography, Anal. Chim. Acta, 554, 144, 2005. 65. Sander, L.C. and Wise, S.A., Influence of substrate parameters on column selectivity with alkyl bonded-phase sorbents, J. Chromatogr., 316, 163, 1984. 66. Nahum, A. and Horvath, C., Surface silanols in silica-bonded hydrocarbonaceous stationary phases 1. Dual retention mechanism in reversed-phase chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 203, 53, 1981. 67. Nawrocki, J., Silica surface controversies, strong adsorption sites, their blockage and removal. Part I, Chromatographia, 31, 177, 1991. 68. Nawrocki, J., Silica surface controversies, strong adsorption sites, their blockage and removal. Part II, Chromatographia, 31, 193, 1991.
DK4478_book.fm Page 81 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
81
69. Li, J. and Carr, P.W., Effect of temperature on the thermodynamic properties, kinetic performance, and stability of polybutadiene-coated zirconia, Anal. Chem., 69, 837, 1997. 70. Li, J. and Carr, P.W., Retention characteristics of polybutadiene-coated zirconia and comparison to conventional bonded phases, Anal. Chem., 68, 2857, 1996. 71. Guillarme, D., Heinisch, S., and Rocca, J.L., Effect of temperature in reversed phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 1052, 39, 2004. 72. Coym, J.W. and Dorsey, J.G., Reversed-phase retention thermodynamics of purewater mobile phases at ambient and elevated temperature, J. Chromatogr. A, 1035, 23, 2004. 73. Grushka, E., Colin, H., and Guiochon, G., Retention behaviour of alkylbenzenes as a function of temperature and mobile phase composition in reversed-phase chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 248, 325, 1982. 74. Cole, L.A., Dorsey, J.G., and Dill, K.A., Temperature dependence of retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. 2. Mobile-phase considerations, Anal. Chem., 64, 1324, 1992. 75. Sentell, K.B., Ryan, N.I., and Henderson, A.N., Temperature and solvation effects on homologous series selectivity in reversed phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chim. Acta, 307, 203, 1995. 76. Sander, L.C. and Field, L.R., Effect of eluent composition on thermodynamic properties in high-performance liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 52, 2009, 1980. 77. Barman, B.N. and Martire, D.E., Factors influencing retention and resolution of substituted alkylbenzenes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 34, 347, 1992. 78. Wu, N., Yehl, P.M., Gauthier, D., and Dovletoglou, A., Retention and thermodynamic studies of piperazine diasteromers in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 59, 189, 2004. 79. Melander, W., Campbell, D.E., and Horvath, C., Enthalpy-entropy compensation in reversed-phase chromatography. J. Chromatogr., 158, 215, 1978. 80. Knox, J.H. and Vasvari, G., Performance of packings in high-speed liquid chromatography. III. Chemically bonded pellicular materials, J. Chromatogr., 83, 181, 1973. 81. Miyabe, K., Sotoura, S., and Guiochon, G., Retention and mass transfer characteristics in reversed-phase liquid chromatography using a tetrahydrofuran-water solution as the mobile phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 919, 231, 2001. 82. Zhao, J. and Carr, P.W., A comparative study of the chromatographic selectivity of polystyrene-coated zirconia and related reversed-phase materials, Anal. Chem., 72, 302, 2000. 83. Chen, Z., Nakayama, T., Nakagama, T., Uchiyama, K., and Hobo, T., Thermodynamic approaches to intermolecular interaction and retention behavior in liquid chromatography, J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. Technol., 26, 2809, 2003. 84. Carr, P.W., Tan, L.C., and Park, J.H., Revisionist look at solvophobic driving forces in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. III. Comparison of the behavior of nonpolar and polar solutes, J. Chromatogr., 724, 1, 1996. 85. Alvarez-Zepeda, A., Barman, B.N., and Martire, D.E., Thermodynamic study of the marked differences between acetonitrile/water and methanol/water mobile-phase systems in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 64, 1978, 1992. 86. Opperhuizen, A., Sinnige, T.L., Van Der Steen, J.M.D., and Hutzinger, O., Differences between retentions of various classes of aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography: Implications of using retention data for characterizing hydrophobicity, J. Chromatogr., 388, 51, 1987.
DK4478_book.fm Page 82 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
82
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
87. Howerton, S.B. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamics and kinetics of solute transfer in reversed-phase liquid chromatography: Effect of annelation in polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, J. Chromatogr. A, 1030, 3, 2004. 88. McGuffin, V.L., Howerton, S.B., and Li, X., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of nitrogen-containing polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 1073, 63, 2005. 89. Miyabe, K. and Guiochon, G., A kinetic study of mass transfer in reversed-phase liquid chromatography on a C-18 silica gel, Anal. Chem., 72, 5162, 2000. 90. Coutinho, F.M.B., Neves, M.A.F.S., and Dias, M.L., Porous crosslinked spherical resins for diversified applications: Packing materials for size exclusion chromatography, Macromol. Symp., 189, 27, 2002. 91. Tanaka, N. and Araki, M., Polymer-based packing materials for reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Adv. Chromatogr., 30, 81, 1989. 92. Andersen, T., Nguyen, Q.T., Trones, R., and Greibrokk, T., Studies on the long-term stability of particulate and monolithic poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) capillaries in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, Analyst, 129, 191, 2004. 93. Oberacher, H., Premstaller, A., and Huber, C.G., Characterization of some physical and chromatographic properties of monolithic poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) columns, J. Chromatogr. A, 1030, 201, 2004. 94. McNeff, C., Zigan, L., Johnson, K., Carr, P.W., Wang, A., and Weber-Main, A.M., Analytical advances of highly stable stationary phases for reversed-phase LC, LCGC North Am., 18, 514, 2000. 95. Yarita, T., Nakajima, R., and Shibukawa, M., Superheated water chromatography of phenols using poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) packings as a stationary phase, Anal. Sci., 19, 269, 2003. 96. Ells, B., Wang, Y., and Cantwell, F.F., Influence of solvent uptake and swelling by poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) column packings on sample sorption rate and band broadening in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 835, 3, 1999. 97. Knox, J.H., Kaur, B., and Millward, G.R., Structure and performance of porous graphitic carbon in liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 352, 3, 1986. 98. Knox, J.H. and Ross, P., Carbon-based packing materials for liquid chromatography: Structure, performance, and retention mechanism, Adv. Chromatogr., 37, 121, 1997. 99. Hanai, T., Separation of polar compounds using carbon columns, J. Chromatogr. A, 989, 183, 2003. 100. Zhang, Y. and McGuffin, V.L., Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of porous graphitic carbon in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, submitted for publication. 101. Viron, C., Andre, P., Dreux, M., and Lafosse, M., Evaluation of porous graphitic carbon as stationary phase of the analysis of fatty acid methyl esters by liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 49, 137, 1999. 102. Gaudin, K., Chaminade, P., and Baillet, A., Eluotropic strength in non-aqueous liquid chromatography with porous graphitic carbon, J. Chromatogr. A, 973, 61, 2002. 103. Koivisto, P. and Stefansson, M., Retention studies of sulphated glycosaminoglycan disaccharides on porous graphitic carbon capillary columns, Chromatographia, 57, 37, 2003. 104. Kwaterczak, A. and Bielejewska, A., Comparison of retention of native cyclodextrins and its permethylated derivatives on porous graphitic carbon and silica C18 stationary phases, Anal. Chim. Acta, 537, 41, 2005.
DK4478_book.fm Page 83 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
83
105. Clarot, I., Cledat, D., Guillaume, Y.C., and Cardot, P.J.P., Chromatographic study of terpene-β-cyclodextrin complexes on porous graphitic carbon stationary phase, Chromatographia, 54, 447, 2001. 106. Andre, C. and Guillaume, Y.C., Saccharose effects on surface association of phenol derivatives with porous graphitic carbon, J. Chromatogr. A, 1029, 21, 2004. 107. Nawrocki, J., The silanol group and its role in liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 779, 29, 1997. 108. Stella, C., Rudaz, S., Veuthey, J.L., and Tchapla, A., Silica and other materials as supports in liquid chromatography: Chromatographic tests and their importance for evaluating these supports. Part I, Chromatographia, 53(suppl.), S113, 2001. 109. Snyder, L.R., Principles of Adsorption Chromatography, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1968. 110. Snyder, L.R., Linear elution adsorption chromatography. V. Silica as adsorbent. Adsorbent standardization, J. Chromatogr., 11, 195, 1963. 111. Snyder, L.R., Adsorption from solution. IV. Aromatic hydrocarbons on silica, J. Phys. Chem., 67, 2622, 1963. 112. Snyder, L.R., Linear elution adsorption chromatography. XIII. A narrow pore silica, J. Chromatogr., 25, 274, 1966. 113. Basiuk, V.A. and Gromovoy, T.Y., Comparative study of amino acid adsorption on bare and octadecyl silica from water using high-performance liquid chromatography, Colloid Surface A, 118, 127, 1996. 114. Basiuk, V.A. and Gromovoy, T.Y., Estimation of thermodynamic parameters for amino acid adsorption on silica from water using high-performance liquid-chromatographic technique, Pol. J. Chem., 70, 476, 1996. 115. Bidlingmeyer, B.A. and Henderson, J., Investigation of retention on bare silica using reversed-phase mobile phases at elevated temperatures, J. Chromatogr. A, 1060, 187, 2004. 116. Snyder, L.R., An experimental study of column efficiency in liquid-solid adsorption chromatography HETP values as a function of separation conditions, Anal. Chem., 39, 698, 1967. 117. Ohkuma, T. and Hara, S., Tail-producing slow adsorption-desorption process in liquid-solid chromatography, J. Chromatogr., 400, 47, 1987. 118. Fornstedt, T., Zhong, G., and Guiochon, G., Peak tailing and mass transfer kinetics in linear chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 741, 1, 1996. 119. Fornstedt, T., Zhong, G., and Guiochon, G., Peak tailing and slow mass transfer kinetics in nonlinear chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 742, 55, 1996. 120. Hatsis, P. and Lucy, C.A., Effect of temperature on retention and selectivity in ion chromatography of anions, J. Chromatogr. A, 920, 3, 2001. 121. Fortier, N.E. and Fritz, J.S., The effect of temperature on single-column ion-chromatography of metal ions, Talanta, 34, 415, 1978. 122. Helfferich, F., Ion Exchange, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1962. 123. Elefterov, A.I., Kolpachnikova, M.G., Nesterenko, P.N., and Shpigun, O.A., Ionexchange properties of glutamic acid-bonded silica, J. Chromatogr. A, 769, 179, 1997. 124. Kolpachnikova, M.G., Penner, N.A., and Nesterenko, P.N., Effect of temperature on retention of alkali and alkaline-earth metal ions on some aminocarboxylic acid functionalised silica based ion exchangers, J. Chromatogr. A, 826, 15, 1998. 125. Bashir, W., Tyrrell, E., Feeney, O., and Paull, B., Retention of alkali, alkaline earth and transition metals on an itaconic acid cation-exchange column: Eluent pH, ionic strength and temperature effects upon selectivity, J. Chromatogr. A, 964, 113, 2002.
DK4478_book.fm Page 84 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
84
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
126. Janos, P., Retention models in ion chromatography: The role of side equilibria in ionexchange chromatography of inorganic cations and anions, J. Chromatogr. A, 789, 3, 1997. 127. Bowen, W.R. and Hughes, D.T., Ion exchange of proteins: a microcalorimetric study of the adsorption of bovine serum albumin on anion-exchange materials, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 158, 395, 1993. 128. Thrash, M.E., Jr., Phillips, J.M., and Pinto, N.G., An analysis of the interactions of BSA with an anion-exchange surface under linear and non-linear conditions, Adsorption, 10, 299, 2005. 129. Raje, P. and Pinto, N.G., Importance of heat of adsorption in modeling protein equilibria for overloaded chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 796, 141, 1998. 130. Thrash, M.E., Jr. and Pinto, N.G., Characterization of enthalpic events in overloaded ion-exchange chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 944, 61, 2002. 131. Weaver, L.E., Jr. and Carta, G., Protein adsorption on cation exchangers: Comparison of macroporous and gel-composite media, Biotechnol. Prog., 12, 342, 1996. 132. Fernandez, M.A. and Carta, G., Characterization of protein adsorption by composite silica-polyacrylamide gel anion exchangers I. Equilibrium and mass transfer in agitated contactors, J. Chromatogr. A, 746, 169, 1996. 133. Fernandez, M.A., Laughinghouse, W.S., and Carta, G., Characterization of protein adsorption by composite silica-polyacrylamide gel anion exchangers. II. Mass transfer in packed columns and predictability of breakthrough behavior, J. Chromatogr. A, 746, 185, 1996. 134. Heeter, G.A. and Liapis, A.I., Model discrimination and estimation of the intraparticle mass transfer parameters for the adsorption of bovine serum albumin onto porous adsorbent particles by the use of experimental frontal analysis data, J. Chromatogr. A, 776, 3, 1997. 135. Conder, J.R., and Hayek, B.O., Adsorption and desorption kinetics of bovine serum albumin in ion exchange and hydrophobic interaction chromatography on silica matrices, Biochem. Eng. J., 6, 225, 2000. 136. Miyabe, K. and Guiochon, G., Kinetic study of the concentration dependence of the mass transfer rate coefficient in anion-exchange chromatography of bovine serum albumin, Biotechnol. Prog., 15, 740, 1999. 137. Yau, W.W., Kirkland, J.J., and Bly, D.D., Modern Size-Exclusion Liquid Chromatography, Wiley, New York, 1979. 138. Casassa, E.F., Equilibrium distribution of flexible polymer chains between a macroscopic solution phase and small voids, J. Polym. Sci. B, 5, 773, 1967. 139. Casassa, E.F. and Tagami, Y., Equilibrium theory for exclusion chromatography of branched and linear polymer chains, Macromolecules, 2, 14, 1969. 140. Casassa, E.F., Theoretical models for peak migration in gel permeation chromatography, J. Phys. Chem., 75, 3929, 1971. 141. Brooks, D.E., Hanes, C.A., Hritcu, D., Steels, B.M., and Mueller, W., Size exclusion chromatography does not require pores, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 97, 7064, 2000. 142. Netopilik, M., Relation between the kinetic and equilibrium quantities in size-exclusion chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 1038, 67, 2004. 143. Gorbunov, A.A. and Skvorcov, A.M., Statistical properties of confined macromolecules, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci., 62, 31, 1995. 144. Macko, T. and Hunkeler, D., Liquid chromatography under critical and limiting conditions: A survey of experimental systems for synthetic polymers, Adv. Polym. Sci., 163, 61, 2003.
DK4478_book.fm Page 85 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
85
145. Nefedov, P.P. and Zhmakina, T.P., Effect of temperature, solvent composition, and pressure on adsorption and chromatography of polystyrenes on macroporous glasses, Vysokomol. Soed. A, 23, 276, 1981. 146. Trathnigg, B., Rappel, C., Fraydl, S., and Gorbunov, A., Liquid chromatography of polyoxyethylenes under critical conditions: A thermodynamic study, J. Chromatogr. A, 1085, 253, 2005. 147. Philipsen, H.J.A., Claessens, H.A., Lind, H., Klumperman, B., and German, A.L., Study on the retention behaviour of low-molar-mass polystyrenes and polyesters in reversed-phase liquid chromatography by evaluation of thermodynamic parameters, J. Chromatogr. A, 790, 101, 1997. 148. Dawkins, J.V., High performance gel permeation chromatography of polymers, Pure Appl. Chem., 54, 281, 1982. 149. Leypoldt, J.K., Frigon, R.P., and Lee, W., Chromatogram broadening of proteins and dextrans in size exclusion chromatography, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 29, 3533, 1984. 150. Dalgliesh, C.E., Optical resolution of aromatic amino acids on paper chromatograms, J. Chem. Soc., 137, 3940, 1952. 151. Mazzo, D.J., Lindemann, C.J., and Brenner, G.S., Subambient temperature highperformance liquid chromatographic determination of the enantiomers of ((6,7dichloro-2,3-dihydro-2-methyl-1-oxo-2-phenyl-1H-inden-5-yl)oxy)acetic acid, Anal. Chem., 58, 636, 1986. 152. Pescher, P., Caude, M., Rosset, R., and Tambute, A., Enantiomeric separation of tertiary phosphine oxides on Pirkle’s chiral stationary phase: Mobile phase and temperature optimization, J. Chromatogr., 371, 159, 1986. 153. Weaner, L.E. and Hoerr, D.C., Separation of fatty acid ester and amide enantiomers by high-performance liquid chromatography on chiral stationary phases, J. Chromatogr., 437, 109, 1988. 154. Pirkle, W.H., Unusual effect of temperature on the retention of enantiomers on a chiral column, J. Chromatogr., 558, 1, 1991. 155. Pirkle, W.H. and Murray, P.G., An instance of temperature-dependent elution order of enantiomers from a chiral brush-type HPLC column, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 16, 285, 1993. 156. Pirkle, W.H. and Welch, C.J., An investigation into the role of solvation in a well characterized chiral recognition system, J. Liq. Chromatogr., 14, 2027, 1991. 157. Blackwell, J.A., Waltermire, R.E., and Stringham, R.W., The role of modifiers in high selectivity chiral separations on Pirkle-type columns, Enantiomer, 6, 353, 2001. 158. Pirkle, W.H. and Readnour, R.S., Chromatographic approach to the measurement of the interstrand distance for some chiral bonded phases, Anal. Chem., 63, 16, 1991. 159. Harada, A., Furue, M., and Nozakura, S., Optical resolution of mandelic acid derivatives by column chromatography on crosslinked cyclodextrin gels, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Chem., 16, 189, 1978. 160. Hinze, W.L., Riehl, T.E., Armstrong, D.W., DeMond, W., Alak, A., and Ward, T., Liquid chromatographic separation of enantiomers using a chiral β-cyclodextrinbonded stationary phase and conventional aqueous-organic mobile phases, Anal. Chem., 57, 237, 1985. 161. Aboul-Enein, H.Y., Islam, M.R., and Bakr, S.A., Direct HPLC resolution of racemic nomifensine hydrogen maleate using a chiral beta-cyclodextrin-bonded stationary phase, J. Liq. Chromatogr., 11, 1485, 1988. 162. Cabrera, K. and Lubda, D., Influence of temperature on chiral high-performance liquid chromatographic separations of oxazepam and prominal on chemically bonded β-cyclodextrin as stationary phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 666, 433, 1994.
DK4478_book.fm Page 86 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
86
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
163. Morin, N., Guillaume, Y.C., Peyrin, E., and Rouland, J.C., Retention mechanism study of imidazole derivatives on a β-cyclodextrin-bonded stationary phase: Thermal analysis contributions, Anal. Chem., 70, 2819, 1998. 164. Peyrin, E., Guillaume, Y.C., and Ravel, A., Degree of solute inclusion in native β-cyclodextrin: Chromatographic approach, Anal. Chem., 72, 1263, 2000. 165. Guillaume, Y.C., Robert, J.F., and Guinchard, C., Role of the water as a surface tension modifier for the retention of a series of dansylaminoacids on a β-CD stationary phase, Talanta, 55, 263, 2001. 166. Ringo, M.C. and Evans, C.E., Pressure-dependent retention and selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separations using β-cyclodextrin stationary phases, Anal. Chem., 69, 643, 1997. 167. Ringo, M.C. and Evans, C.E., Role of modest pressures in chirally selective complexation interactions, J. Phys. Chem. B, 101, 5525, 1997. 168. Ringo, M.C. and Evans, C.E., Pressure-induced changes in chiral separations in liquid chromatography, Anal. Chem., 69, 4964, 1997. 169. Ringo, M.C. and Evans, C.E., Effect of mobile-phase composition on pressureinduced shifts in solute retention for LC separations using β-cyclodextrin stationary phases, J. Microcol. Sep., 10, 647, 1998. 170. Wang, X. and Ching, C.B., Kinetic and equilibrium study of the separation of three chiral center drug, nadolol, by HPLC on a novel perphenyl carbamoylated β-cyclodextrin bonded chiral stationary phase, Sep. Sci. Technol., 37, 2567, 2002. 171. Yu, H.W. and Ching, C.B., Kinetic and equilibrium study of the enantioseparation of fluoxetine on a new β-cyclodextrin column by high performance liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 54, 697, 2001. 172. Kotake, M., Sakan, T., Nakamura, N., and Senoh, S., Resolution into optical isomers of some amino acids by paper chromatography, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 73, 2973, 1951. 173. Smith, R.J., Taylor, D.R., and Wilkins, S.M., Temperature dependence of chiral discrimination in supercritical fluid chromatography and high-performance liquid chromatography, J. Chromatogr. A, 697, 591, 1995. 174. Kuesters, E. and Spoendlin, C., Influence of temperature on the enantioseparation of rolipram and structurally related racemates on Chiralcel-OD, J. Chromatogr. A, 737, 333, 1996. 175. Mesplet, N., Saito, Y., Morin, P., and Agrofoglio, L.A., Liquid chromatographic separation of phosphoramidate diastereomers on a polysaccharide-type chiral stationary phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 983, 115, 2003. 176. O’Brien, T., Crocker, L., Thompson, R., Thompson, K., Toma, P.H., Conlon, D.A., Feibush, B., Moeder, C., Bicker, G., and Grinberg, N., Mechanistic aspects of chiral discrimination on modified cellulose, Anal. Chem., 69, 1999, 1997. 177. Wang, F., O’Brien, T., Dowling, T., Bicker, G., and Wyvratt, J., Unusual effect of column temperature on chromatographic enantioseparation of dihydropyrimidinone acid and methyl ester on amylose chiral stationary phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 958, 69, 2002. 178. Wang, F., Dowling, T., Ellison, D., and Wyvratt, J., Comparison study of Chiralpak AD-H with AD columns in chromatographic enantioseparation of dihydropyrimidinone acid and its methyl ester, J. Chromatogr. A, 1034, 117, 2004. 179. Wang, F., Wenslow, R.M., Jr., Dowling, T.M., Mueller, K.T., Santos, I., and Wyvratt, J.M., Characterization of a thermally induced irreversible conformational transition of amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) chiral stationary phase in enantioseparation of dihydropyrimidinone acid by quasi-equilibrated liquid chromatography and solid-state NMR, Anal. Chem., 75, 5877, 2003.
DK4478_book.fm Page 87 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
The Thermodynamic and Kinetic Basis of Liquid Chromatography
87
180. Booth, T.D. and Wainer, I.W., Mechanistic investigation into the enantioselective separation of mexiletine-related compounds, chromatographed on an amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) chiral stationary phase, J. Chromatogr. A, 741, 205, 1996. 181. Rearden, P., Sajonz, P., and Guiochon, G., Detailed study of the mass transfer kinetics of Troeger’s base on cellulose triacetate, J. Chromatogr. A, 813, 1, 1998. 182. Seidel-Morgenstern, A. and Guiochon, G., Modeling of the competitive isotherms and the chromatographic separation of two enantiomers, Chem. Eng. Sci., 48, 2787, 1993. 183. Loun, B. and Hage, D.S., Chiral separation mechanisms in protein-based HPLC columns. 1. Thermodynamic studies of (R)- and (S)-warfarin binding to immobilized human serum albumin, Anal. Chem., 66, 3814, 1994. 184. Loun, B. and Hage, D.S., Chiral separation mechanisms in protein-based HPLC columns. 2. Kinetic studies of (R)- and (S)-warfarin binding to immobilized human serum albumin, Anal. Chem., 68, 1218, 1996. 185. Yang, J. and Hage, D.S., Characterization of the binding and chiral separation of Dand L-tryptophan on a high-performance immobilized human serum albumin column, J. Chromatogr. A, 645, 241, 1993. 186. Yang, J. and Hage, D.S., Role of binding capacity versus binding strength in the separation of chiral compounds on protein-based high-performance liquid chromatography columns: Interactions of D- and L-tryptophan with human serum albumin, J. Chromatogr. A, 725, 273, 1996. 187. Yang, J. and Hage, D.S., Effect of mobile phase composition on the binding kinetics of chiral solutes on a protein-based high-performance liquid chromatography column: Interactions of D- and L-tryptophan with immobilized human serum albumin, J. Chromatogr. A, 766, 15, 1997. 188. Fornstedt, T., Zhong, G., Bensetiti, Z., and Guiochon, G., Experimental and theoretical study of the adsorption behavior and mass transfer kinetics of propranolol enantiomers on cellulase protein as the selector, Anal. Chem., 68, 2370, 1996. 189. Fornstedt, T., Sajonz, P., and Guiochon, G., Thermodynamic study of an unusual chiral separation: Propranolol enantiomers on an immobilized cellulase, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 119, 1254, 1997. 190. Fornstedt, T., Goetmar, G., Andersson, M., and Guiochon, G., Dependence on the mobile-phase pH of the adsorption behavior of propranolol enantiomers on a cellulase protein used as the chiral selector, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 121, 1164, 1999. 191. Goetmar, G., Fornstedt, T., and Guiochon, G., Retention mechanism of β-blockers on an immobilized cellulase: Relative importance of the hydrophobic and ionic contributions to their enantioselective and nonselective interactions, Anal. Chem., 72, 3908, 2000. 192. Gilpin, R.K., Ehtesham, S.E., and Gregory, R.B., Liquid chromatographic studies of the effect of temperature on the chiral recognition of tryptophan by silica-immobilized bovine albumin, Anal. Chem., 63, 2825, 1991. 193. Strandberg, A., Nystrom, A., Behr, S., and Karlsson, A., Use of immobilized amyloglucosidase as chiral selector in chromatography: Control of enantioselective retention and resolution in liquid chromatography, Chromatographia, 50, 215, 1999. 194. Karlsson, A., Skoog, A., and Ohlen, K., Effect of temperature on the reversal in the retention order of the enantiomers of mosapride on Chiral-AGP, J. Biochem. Biophys. Meth., 54, 347, 2002.
DK4478_book.fm Page 88 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
88
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
195. Slama, I., Jourdan, E., Villet, A., Grosset, C., Ravel, A., and Peyrin, E., Temperature and solute molecular size effects on the retention and enantioselectivity of a series of D,L dansyl amino acids on a vancomycin-based chiral stationary phase, Chromatographia, 58, 399, 2003. 196. Berthod, A., He, B.L., and Beesley, T.E., Temperature and enantioseparation by macrocyclic glycopeptide chiral stationary phases, J. Chromatogr. A, 1060, 205, 2004.
DK4478_book.fm Page 89 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
2
Applications of Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis Colin F. Poole
CONTENTS I. Introduction..................................................................................................89 II. Extraction Solvents......................................................................................93 A. Extraction of Organic Compounds .....................................................94 B. Liquid-Phase Microextraction...........................................................100 C. Supported Liquid Membranes...........................................................101 D. Extraction of Inorganic Compounds.................................................101 E. Supercritical Fluid Extraction from Ionic Liquids ...........................103 III. Liquid Chromatography.............................................................................104 IV. Electrophoresis...........................................................................................106 A. Capillary Electrophoresis ..................................................................107 V. Gas Chromatography .................................................................................109 A. Retention Mechanisms ......................................................................109 B. Chromatographic Selectivity.............................................................111 C. Chemical Reactivity Problems..........................................................117 D. Open-Tubular Columns .....................................................................117 VI. Conclusion .................................................................................................119 References..............................................................................................................120
I. INTRODUCTION Under the umbrella of green chemistry, ionic liquids have emerged as potentially useful solvents for minimizing solvent waste from chemical processes [1,2]. For these applications, their favorable properties include low or negligible vapor pressure, an ability to dissolve a wide range of inorganic and organic compounds, high thermal stability, large electrochemical windows, and low flammability. Their negligible vapor pressure minimizes environmental contamination through evaporation,
89
DK4478_book.fm Page 90 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
90
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
a major concern for conventional organic solvents, allows their use in vacuum systems without loss, and facilitates product recovery by distillation or sublimation. In addition, ionic liquids are increasingly being studied for reasons of specific advantages in rate, specificity, and yield, as much as a simple replacement for volatile organic solvents [3,4]. These aspects of ionic liquids are reviewed elsewhere [1–3,5–7]. The use of ionic liquids as solvents in analytical chemistry has not received the same attention as has their use in organic chemistry [8–11]. The purpose of this review is to provide supporting material to define a role for ionic liquids in extraction and separations in addition to describing their applications in these fields. Ionic liquids are low-melting salts forming liquids composed entirely of ions. They are expected to have properties that differ from molecular liquids because of the presence of Coulombic forces, as well as properties in common with molecular liquids, because many of the ions contain nonionic structures and functional groups that interact with each other through conventional intermolecular interactions. The majority of useful ionic liquids are organic salts containing organic cations with organic or inorganic anions. Inorganic ionic liquids tend to have relatively high melting points, are usually chemically reactive, and are poor solvents for organic compounds, rendering them less useful as general purpose solvents for extraction and separations. The term ionic liquid is a suitable keyword for searching the recent literature. Its general adoption as a keyword though is quite recent, and for comprehensive coverage, particularly of the older literature, fused salts, molten salts, and liquid organic salts should also be used. In the past, the term ionic liquid was used quite broadly to describe studies in the liquid state for any thermally stable melt. For technical and laboratory applications, the emphasis has changed to salts with low melting points producing solvents that can be used over a wide temperature range. Today, more than 200 organic salts with melting points below room temperature are known (room temperature ionic liquids) [8] and these salts account for most of the current interest in ionic liquids as general purpose solvents for extraction and separations. Some typical ions used to prepare room temperature ionic liquids are shown in Table 2.1 and Figure 2.1. Methods to predict melting points and physical properties (e.g., density, viscosity, conductivity, thermal stability, etc.) of ionic liquids are poorly developed [3,12–15]. Given the enormous number of possible cation and anion combinations representing different ionic liquids, this limits approaches for the identification of further useful ionic liquids with tailored properties for specific applications to trial and error processes. Qualitatively it seems that low symmetry, weak hydrogenbonding interactions, and effective charge dispersion for either or both ions are properties likely to yield organic salts that are liquid at room temperature or have low melting points [3,16]. These factors reduce the lattice energy of the crystalline form of the salt and hence lower the melting point. Physical properties for some representative ionic liquids are summarized in Table 2.2. The largest number of known room temperature ionic liquids are from 1,3dialkylimidazolium salts containing tetrafluoroborate, hexafluorophosphate, bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide, tricyanamide and perfluoroalkanesulfonate anions [8]. The selection of the anion seems to have a strong influence on the viscosity of the
DK4478_book.fm Page 91 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
91
TABLE 2.1 Typical Cations and Anions Used in the Synthesis of Low Melting Point Ionic Liquids Cations
Anions
Alkylammonium Tetraalkylammonium Tetraalkylphosphonium 1,3-Dialkylimidazolium 1,2,3-Trialkylimidazolium 1-(Alkoxyalkyl)-3-alkylimidazolium 1-(Hydroxylalkyl)-3-alkylimidazolium N-Alkylimidazolium N-Alkylisoquinolinium N-Alkylpyridinium 1-Alkylpiperidinium 2,3-Dialkylindolinium 1-Alkyl-4-fluoroalkyl-1,2,4-triazolium Bis(N,N-dialkyl)dimethylguanidinium
Bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide Hexafluorophosphate Tetrafluoroborate Alkylsulfate Perfluoroalkylsulfonate Alkylcarboxylate Perfluoroalkylcarboxylate Dicyanamide Nitrate Dialkylphosphate Thiocyanate Diethyleneglycolmonomethylethersulfate
H3 C + N R
R N
+
+
+ N
N
R (a)
N
(b)
R (c)
R
(d)
FIGURE 2.1 Representative structures of organic cations used to prepare low melting point ionic liquids. (a) = 1,1′-alkylpyrolinium; (b) = 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium; C = N-alkylpyridinium; and D = N-alkylisoquinolinium.
ionic liquid [3,17,18]. Low viscosity is associated with small anions that have a diffuse negative charge and do not take part in hydrogen bonding. Low is a relative description, however, and typical ionic liquids have viscosities greater than 20 cP at room temperature. These viscosities are larger than desirable for many applications in extraction and separation, and this remains a significant factor restricting wider use. The density of 1,3-dialkylimidazolium ionic liquids is typically greater than water and decreases almost linearly with increasing alkyl chain length [1,16]. These density differences favor separation of immiscible ionic liquids from water by settling. A number of 1,3-dialkylimidazolium salts with weakly basic anions show exceptional thermal stability, allowing their use in an inert atmosphere at temperatures above 250°C, and in a few cases above 350°C [3,8,18–20]. Even if thermal stability determined by rising temperature thermal gravimetric analysis — the most common method — tends to overestimate thermal stability for practical purposes compared with equilibrium isothermal weight loss measurements, the lack of significant vapor pressure over wide temperature ranges remains one of the
DK4478_book.fm Page 92 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
92
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 2.2 Physical Properties of Some Room Temperature Ionic Liquidsa
Ionic liquid Di-n-propylammonium thiocyanate Ethylammonium nitrate Tetra-n-butylammonium 2-hydroxy-4morpholinopropanesulsonate Tetra-n-hexylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide N-hexyl-N,N,N-triethylammonium triethyl-n-hexylboride 1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium heptafluorobutyrate 1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate 1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate 1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoroacetate 1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate 1,3-Diethylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide 1,3-Diethylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate 1-Ethyl-3,5-dimethylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide 1-Ethyl-3,5-dimethylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium dicyanamide 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium heptafluorobutyrate 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoroacetate 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate N-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium dicyanamide 2-Methyl-1-propylpyrrolinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide a
Melting Point (°C)
Density (g/ml)
Viscosity (cP)
Temperature Limit (°C)
5.5 12.5
0.964 1.122
85.9 32.1 4699
–6.8
1.11
435
0.847
258
1.333
182
10
1.373
450
349
–81
1.208
219
403
–78
130 120 170
130
1.209
73 (20°C)
16
1.290
90 (20°C)
14
1.452
35 (20°C)
23
1.330
53 (20°C)
–39
1.470
37
6
1.334
51 (20°C)
1.520 (22°C)
28
400
1.06
21 (20°C)
275
–3 –21
1.450 (22°C)
105 (20°C)
1.248 (20°C)
66.5 (20°C)
–14
1.285
35 (20°C)
–9
1.390
45 (20°C)
–55
0.930
50 (20°C)
1.460 (20°C)
57
5.8
19
Temperature is 25°C unless indicated otherwise.
400
DK4478_book.fm Page 93 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
93
outstanding properties of the 1,3-dialkylimidazolium salts. Flashpoints for 1,3dialkylimidazolium salts are generally at least 100°C higher than for conventional organic solvents [21].
II. EXTRACTION SOLVENTS Ionic liquids can simultaneously dissolve organic and inorganic substances and form immiscible solvent systems with molecular liquids having a wide range of polarities. Most ionic liquids are fully or partially miscible with organic solvents of intermediate polarity (e.g., methanol, acetonitrile, tetrahydrofuran, dichloromethane, acetone, etc.). Immiscible solvent systems are most commonly formed with organic solvents of low polarity (e.g., hexane, toluene) or water. A table of solvent miscibility with water and common organic solvents for ionic liquids is given in Poole [8]. These results are based mainly on simple physical observations of mixing. There is less information available for mutual solubility of solvents in biphasic systems [22–24]. For example, the solubility of water in 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate corresponds to 2.3% (w/w), which on a mole fraction scale is about 0.25 (or 1.1 M) [22,25]. The solubility of 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate in water is about 2% (w/w). For 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate, the solubility of water in the ionic liquid is about 10.8% (w/w) and the ionic liquid in water is about 1.8% (w/w). In addition, it is well known that many ionic liquids strongly absorb water from the atmosphere in various amounts (e.g., 0.2 to 2.0 M) [26,27]. The absorption of water is strongly influenced by the potential of either ion to form hydrogen bonds. Thus, it is quite likely that under conditions for liquid-liquid extraction, ionic liquids will absorb appreciable amounts of water when water is a countersolvent, and probably contain appreciable amounts of water when handled under typical laboratory conditions. This poses a problem for liquid-liquid extraction, namely, the possibility of carryover reducing the selectivity of extraction from an aqueous solution and variable selectivity when the countersolvent is organic. In the latter case, results might be expected to depend on the exposure history of the ionic liquid and variations in sample hydration. Gutowski et al. [28] demonstrated that mixtures of water and miscible ionic liquids can be induced to form aqueous biphasic systems by addition of a water-structuring salt (potassium phosphate), producing a mechanism to expand the number of available liquid-liquid systems for study and creating alternative extraction media to polymerbased aqueous biphasic systems. Phase diagrams for binary and ternary solvent systems in which one component is an ionic liquid are known for only a few systems: 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-butan-1-ol, where alkyl = butyl, pentyl, hexyl, heptyl, and octyl [29]; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide with propan-1-ol, butan-1-ol, and pentan-1-ol [30]; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water-ethanol [31,32]; 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water with acetonitrile, methanol, and propan-1-ol [25,33]; 1-octyl3-methylimidazolium chloride-benzene with heptane, decane, and hexadecane [34]; and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide and 1-butyl3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide with water, acetone, and
DK4478_book.fm Page 94 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
94
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
propan-2-ol [35]. In most cases the interest has been to record the physicochemical details of the systems and to make comparisons with molecular liquids. In this regard, the results are not remarkable, except perhaps for the ternary 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water-ethanol system, which forms a single phase region for mixtures containing from 0.5 to 0.9 mole fraction ethanol, even though the ionic liquid is only partially miscible with either water or ethanol [31,32]. Berthod and Carda-Broch [33] took advantage of the biphasic ternary system 1butyl-3-methylimidazolium-water-acetonitrile (2:1:2) to overcome the problem of the high viscosity of the ionic liquid to facilitate separation by countercurrent chromatography. The biphasic ternary system afforded a good density difference between the two liquid phases and viscosities low enough to allow the mobile phase to be pumped through the apparatus. The phase diagram for ternary mixtures of 1octyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride and benzene with heptane, dodecane and hexadecane was used to assess the possibility of using the ionic liquid to selectively extract benzene from hydrocarbon fuels [34]. The authors speculate that the ionic liquid is suitable for removing small amounts of benzene from n-alkanes in the preparation of high-purity n-alkanes. The ionic liquids 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate were shown to be effective for the selective removal of sulfurcontaining aromatic compounds from hydrocarbon fuels [36]. Sulfur compounds with a C5 aromatic ring (e.g., thiophene) were more favorably absorbed from hydrocarbon fuels by the ionic liquids, while sulfur-containing nonaromatic compounds and aromatic hydrocarbons and n-alkanes were only poorly absorbed. 1Octyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate was demonstrated to be useful for the extraction of n-butanol from fermentation broth (production of biofuels) with recovery of the alcohol from the ionic liquid by pervaporation [37]. These latter two studies are mainly of industrial interest. In the sections that follow, emphasis will be on analytical laboratory-scale applications.
A. EXTRACTION
OF
ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
Partition coefficients for several organic compounds were reported for the biphasic systems containing the ionic liquids ethylammonium nitrate, n-propylammonium nitrate, or di-n-propylammonium thiocyanate and hexane, toluene, n-octanol, or dichloromethane (Table 2.3) [38–40]. Low polarity compounds are strongly distributed to the organic solvents, but those compounds capable of acting as either hydrogen-bond acids or bases are selectively extracted by the ionic liquids. Dichloromethane and n-octanol saturated with ethylammonium nitrate competes more effectively with the ionic liquid for polar solutes in general. Di-n-propylammonium thiocyanate extracts a larger amount of all solutes than ethylammonium and npropylammonium nitrates from hexane. Isolated compounds can be effectively recovered from the ionic liquids by back-extraction into an organic solvent after dilution with water or buffer. When gas chromatography is used for the determination step, extractive derivatization (e.g., alkylation, acylation, and silylation) is the preferred technique, avoiding the accumulation of ionic liquid on the column, resulting in poor detector baseline stability [39]. A number of applications were presented for
DK4478_book.fm Page 95 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
95
TABLE 2.3 Partition Coefficients for Organic Compounds in Biphasic Systems Containing Ethylammonium and n-Propylammonium Nitrate and Din-Propylammonium Thiocyanate Ionic Liquids and Organic Solventsa Ionic Liquidb EAN
Organic Solvent n-Hexane
Toluene
Octanolc
Dichloromethaned
PAN
Hexane
Toluenee
Solute Naphthalene 1-Nitronaphthalene 4-Ethylnitrobenzene N-Methyl-2-nitroaniline N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline N,N-Diethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine 1-Nitronaphthalene 4-Ethylnitrobenzene N-Methyl-2-nitroaniline N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline N,N-Diethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine 1-Nitronaphthalene 4-Ethylnitrobenzene N-Methyl-2-nitroaniline N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline N,N-Diethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine 4-Ethylnitrobenzene N-Methyl-2-nitroaniline N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline N,N-Diethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Naphthalene 1-Nitronaphthalene N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine 1-Nitronaphthalene N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine
Partition Coefficient 0.09 0.71 0.27 1.73 7.47 4.00 1.37 28.8 6.16 0.05 0.03 0.15 1.64 0.09 0.07 3.93 0.18 0.22 0.18 0.61 0.85 0.58 0.19 0.19 0.85 0.03 0.07 0.40 0.07 0.03 2.10 0.29 1.72 78.5 9.00 33.0 5.83 0.12 2.61 0.24 8.44 0.14 Continued.
DK4478_book.fm Page 96 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
96
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 2.3 (Continued) Partition Coefficients for Organic Compounds in Biphasic Systems Containing Ethylammonium and n-Propylammonium Nitrate and Din-Propylammonium Thiocyanate Ionic Liquids and Organic Solventsa Ionic Liquidb
DPAT
Organic Solvent
Solute
Partition Coefficient
Dichloromethanef
Naphthalene 1-Nitronaphthalene N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine Naphthalene 1-Nitronaphthalene N-Methyl-4-nitrolaniline N,N-Dimethyl-4-nitroaniline 2-Naphthol Pyridine
0.07 0.08 0.35 0.10 2.88 0.67 2.45 9.22 132 18.0 1.67 4.26
Hexane
a
Calculated with the concentration of the solute in the ionic liquid as the numerator. DPAT = di-n-propylammonium thiocyanate; EAN = ethylammonium nitrate; PAN = n-propylammonium nitrate. c Octanol/EAN = 100:11 (v/v). d Dichloromethane/EAN = 100:18 (v/v). e Toluene/PAN = 100:9 (v/v). f Dichloromethane/PAN = 100:29 (v/v). b
the isolation and determination of polar compounds in complex matrices, including shale oil, dust extracts, soap, tobacco condensate, and urine samples. The largest number of partition coefficients are available for the biphasic systems formed by 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate and water or heptane (Table 2.4) [1,9,25,41,42]. In addition, Liu et al. [42] list partition coefficients for 15 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water biphasic system and Berthod and Carda-Broch [33] list partition coefficients for some simple aromatic compounds in the biphasic system formed by 1-butyl3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-acetonitrile-water. These partition coefficients were determined by classical shake flask or slow stir methods and by countercurrent chromatography. N-alkylisoquinolinium hexafluorophosphate ionic liquids (alkyl = octyl and tetradecyl) were shown to be more effective than 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate at extracting simple aromatic compounds from water [43]. Water-containing 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate was shown to form 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium fluoride on heating [44]. This reaction should be taken into account when considering methods to recover isolated compounds from this, and probably other, hexafluorophosphate-containing ionic liquids [44]. The partition coefficients in Table 2.4 are for the neutral form of ionizable compounds. Additional data for the distribution constants of partially and fully
DK4478_book.fm Page 97 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
97
TABLE 2.4 Partition Coefficients for Biphasic Systems Formed by 1-Butyl-3Methylimidazolium Hexafluorophosphate and Water or n-Heptane log P Counter Solvent Solute
Water
Acenaphthene N-Acetyl cysteine 2-Aminobenzamide 3-Aminophenol Aniline Anthracene Ascorbic acid Benz[a]anthracene Benzamide Benzene Benzo[b]fluoranthene Benzo[k]fluoranthene Benzo[a]pyrene Benzoic acid 4-Bromoaniline 2-Bromobenzoic acid 1-Bromo-2-nitrobenzene 4-Bromophenol Caffeic acid Catechol 2-Chlorobenzoic acid 3-Chlorophenol 4-Chlorophenol Chrysene 2,3-Diaminotoluene Dibenzo[a,h]anthracene 2,3-Dihydroxybenzoic acid 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic acid 3,4-Dihydroxybenzoic acid 3,5-Dinitrobenzoic acid 2,4-Dinitrophenol 2,6-Dinitrophenol 1,3-Diphenylenediamine Ferulic acid Fluoranthene Fluorene 2-Fluorophenol Glutathione 4-Hydroxybenzoic acid Indeno[1,2,3cd]pyrene
3.71 –0.155 0.851 0.613 1.568 4.15 –2.097 4.22 0.681 2.146 4.31 4.30 4.32 1.724 2.301 1.322 2.633 1.940 0.301 0.613 1.176 2.013 1.859 4.22 1.114 4.31 0.342 0.000 –0.244 1.580 1.431 1.481 0.792 1.146 4.20 3.82 1.398 –0.921 0.362 4.36
n-Heptane
Solute Descriptors E
S
1.604
1.05
1.556
1.130 0.955 2.290
2.079 –0.194
1.613 1.633 1.929 0.959 2.114
1.973 1.881
A
B
V
0
0.22
1.259
1.15 0.96 1.34
0.65 0.26 0
0.79 0.41 0.28
0.875 0.816 1.454
0.990 0.610
1.50 0.52
0.49 0
0.67 0.14
0.973 0.716
0.730 1.190
0.90 1.19
0.59 0.31
0.40 0.35
0.932 0.991
1.180 1.080
1.32 1.17
0 0.67
0.26 0.20
1.066 0.950
0.970
1.07
0.85
0.52
0.834
0.909 0.915 3.027
1.06 1.08 1.73
0.69 0.67 0
0.15 0.20 0.33
0.897 0.898 1.823
1.260 1.220
1.40 1.62
0.05 0.05
0.54 0.59
1.124 1.124
2.377 1.604 0.660
1.55 1.04 0.69
0 0 0.61
0.24 0.20 0.26
1.357 1.259 0.792
0.930
0.92
0.87
0.53
0.990
2.079
1.944
1.447
Continued.
DK4478_book.fm Page 98 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
98
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
TABLE 2.4 (Continued) Partition Coefficients for Biphasic Systems Formed by 1-Butyl-3Methylimidazolium Hexafluorophosphate and Water or n-Heptane log P Counter Solvent Solute Naphthalene 1-Naphthol 2-Naphthol 3-Nitrobenzoic acid 2-Nitrophenol 4-Nitrophenol Phenanthrene Phenol Phthalic acid Pyrene Pyrocatechol Resorcinol Theaflavine Toluene 4-Toluic acid 4-Toluidine
Water 3.34 1.756 1.989 1.342 2.041 1.538 4.06 1.204 1.053 0.041 4.21 0.845 –0.046 0.000 2.380 1.301 1.544
n-Heptane
2.708 0.653
1.799
Solute Descriptors E
S
A
B
V
1.340 1.520 1.520 0.996 1.015 1.070 2.055 0.805
0.92 1.05 1.08 1.41 1.05 1.72 1.29 0.89
0 0.61 0.61 0.70 0.05 0.82 0 0.60
0.20 0.31 0.40 0.44 0.37 0.26 0.26 0.30
1.085 1.144 1.144 1.106 0.949 0.949 1.454 0.775
2.808
1.71
0
0.28
1.585
0.980
1.00
1.10
0.58
0.834
0.601 0.730 0.923
0.52 0.90 0.95
0 0.60 0.23
0.14 0.38 0.52
0.857 1.073 0.957
2.362
–0.420 1.568 1.398
ionized compounds are available in Carda-Broch et al. [25] and in the biphasic system formed by 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-acetonitrilewater in Berthod and Carda-Broch [33]. In general terms, the distribution constants for the neutral form of an ionizable compound are more favorable for extraction by the ionic liquid than the ionic form. Manipulation of the pH of the aqueous phase is an effective means of adjusting selectivity, in agreement with common practice for molecular liquids [25,41,45]. Subsets of the partition coefficient data in Table 2.4 were analyzed by CardaBroch et al. [25] and Abraham et al. [46] using the solvation parameter model. The model, in a form suitable for liquid-liquid extraction, is set out below [47–49]: log P = c + eE + sS + aA + bB + vV,
(2.1)
where log P is the partition coefficient for a varied group of neutral compounds between the ionic liquid and countersolvent. The capital letters (E, S, A, B, V) are solute descriptors, available for more than 4000 compounds, and are required to fit the experimental data (log P) to the model. The complementary properties indicated by the lowercase letters (e, s, a, b, v) are the system constants. These constants characterize the difference in the contribution of cavity formation and intermolecular interactions to solvation in the ionic liquid and countersolvent. Thus, e is an indication of how the difference in electron lone pair interactions between the solvent-
DK4478_book.fm Page 99 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
99
TABLE 2.5 System Constants for the Solvation Parameter Models for Liquid-Liquid Partitioning between 1-Alkyl-3-Methylimidazolium Hexafluorophosphate and Water or Heptane 1-Butyl-3-Methylimidazolium
1-Hexyl-3-Methylimidazolium
System Constant
Water [25]
Water [46]
Heptane [23]
Water [46]
e s a b v c
1.29 –0.73 –0.76 –2.39 0.64 1.79
0.45 0.23 –1.76 –1.83 2.15 –0.17
3.28 –0.75 2.77 2.46 –2.80 –0.10
0.05 0.40 –1.48 –2.11 2.30 –0.13
a
a Model for the full data indicated in the table: e = 0.93 (± 0.78); s = 1.00 (± 0.60); a = 2.24 (± 0.32); b = 0.004 (± 0.02); v = 0.48 (± 0.89); and c = 0.87 (± 0.78). Multiple correlation coefficient = 0.972, standard error = 0.25, Fischer statistic = 31, and number of solutes = 15.
saturated ionic liquid and ionic liquid-saturated solvent contributes to extraction; s indicates the contribution of the difference in dipole-type interactions; a (hydrogenbond basicity) and b (hydrogen-bond acidity) indicate contributions to the difference in hydrogen-bonding interactions; and v is the difference in cohesion between the two phases. The c term is an equation constant and is not assigned any chemical meaning. The system constants for the 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water, 1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water, and 1butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-heptane biphasic systems are summarized in Table 2.5 [25,46]. The agreement for the 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water system is poor. The system constants from Blanchard and Brennecke [25] are difficult to rationalize in chemical terms and are based on a small dataset (12 compounds) with high cross-correlation between the E and S solute descriptors (r = 0.85) and a relatively poor model fit (overall multiple correlation coefficient ρ = 0.954). A larger number of partition coefficients with known solute descriptors are now available, as indicated in Table 2.4, and the system constants for the 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate-water system can be recalculated, as indicated in Equation 2.2: log P = 1.19 (± 0.87) + 0.81 (± 0.51)E – 0.76 (± 0.43)S – 1.58 (± 0.35)A – 0.01 (± 0.05)B + 1.29 (± 1.24)V.
(2.2)
The multiple correlation coefficient for this model is 0.913, the standard error of the estimate is 0.53, the Fischer statistic is 27, and the number of solutes is 33. This model is not very good either chemically or statistically. Since we know that the solute descriptors are not in large error, the problem must be errors in the experimental log P values. In which case, the data in Table 2.4 should be used with caution. The model proposed by Abraham et al. [46] makes chemical sense, and is based on
DK4478_book.fm Page 100 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
100
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
a set of partition coefficients determined by a single group, but only published in the form of a figure, so they cannot be compared directly with the values in Table 2.4. Interpretation of Abraham et al.’s model indicates that 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate saturated with water is less cohesive and hydrogenbond acidic and basic than water, but slightly more dipolar/polarizable and has a greater affinity for electron lone pair interactions. Solute properties that favor extraction into the ionic liquid phase are increasing size and dipolarity/polarizability (V, E, and S). Solute properties that diminish extraction by the ionic liquid are the capacity of the solute for hydrogen-bonding interactions (A and B). The model for partitioning of neutral solutes in the 1-butyl-3-methylimidazoliumheptane system [25] exhibits the same problems as the ionic liquid-water system, and must be considered suspect. The indication that the heptane phase is more dipolar/polarizable than the ionic liquid is difficult to defend. The addition of further data from Table 2.4 to those used originally results in a more sensible chemical model, but with poor statistics. To obtain a model with the confidence needed for reliable interpretation, we must await the availability of higher quality partition coefficients.
B. LIQUID-PHASE MICROEXTRACTION Ionic liquids are suitable for use as suspended droplets for headspace and directimmersion extraction from aqueous samples [11,50–54] and as fiber-supported films for solid-phase microextraction [55]. The absence of vapor pressure, adequate viscosity, the ability to dissolve a wide range of compounds, and the availability of ionic liquids immiscible with water are favorable properties for these applications. Enrichment factors of about 5 to 175 for a wide range of compounds (e.g., benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene (BTEX), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, phthalate esters, phenols, amines, herbicides, organometallics) have been obtained using the ionic liquids 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphates (alkyl = butyl, hexyl, or octyl) and drop sizes of 3 to 5 μl. Extractions by liquid-phase microextraction usually occur under nonequilibrium conditions and enrichment factors depend in a complex way on the sampling time, partition coefficients, temperature, analyte diffusion coefficients, and the viscosity of both the ionic liquid and sample solution. The relatively high viscosity of ionic liquids allows larger drop sizes to be used compared with typical organic solvents. This is expected to increase the extraction yield, but in practice, this advantage is often offset to a large extent by slow mass transfer of analytes at the droplet interface. The studies described above are largely exploratory, but it is clear that the enrichment factors obtained are generally inadequate for trace analysis. Ionic liquids can be injected onto reverse-phase liquid chromatographic columns without problems. For gas chromatography, direct injection is not feasible because ionic liquids are nonvolatile. This difficulty can be circumvented by using the ionic liquid as a fiber-supported film coating [55]. Some ionic liquids are sufficiently stable to resist drainage from the fiber support during analyte recovery by thermal desorption. However, the thin film of ionic liquid limits sample detectability compared with conventional immobilized poly(siloxane)-coated fibers.
DK4478_book.fm Page 101 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
101
C. SUPPORTED LIQUID MEMBRANES Supported liquid membranes are prepared from a thin porous membrane with an ionic liquid immobilized inside the porous structure. Transport of material from the sample side of the membrane (donor) to the other side (acceptor) is mediated by the properties of the ionic liquid and the membrane. It is important that the ionic liquid has low solubility in the sample and acceptor phases to ensure stability and longterm performance. 1-Alkyl-3-methylimidazolium (alkyl = butyl, octyl, decyl) hexafluorophosphate and 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate have been used as the immobilized liquid in various polymeric membranes for the separation of amines and amino acid esters in their neutral and ionized form [56–60]. The transport of organic compounds through the membrane seems to involve two mechanisms [59,60]: an initial phase in which transport is largely regulated by the selectivity of the ionic liquid toward each solute, and a secondary phase mediated by the formation of water microenvironments. Since the solubility of water in the ionic liquids is not negligible (even though their mixtures form biphasic systems), over the course of time, water microenvironments are formed by diffusion of water into the ionic liquid. The mobility of these water microenvironments eventually dominates the transport mechanism, with a complete loss of selectivity. This is unfavorable for selective extraction, and if these preliminary studies are confirmed as a general transport mechanism, then ionic liquids will have a limited role in supported liquid membrane extraction. Miyako et al. [58] presented an interesting example of the use of an ionic liquid-supported membrane for the separation of the enantiomers of ibuprofen. These authors used an enzyme to selectively methylate (S)-ibuprofen in the presence of (R)-ibuprofen, the (S)-ibuprofen methyl ester was then selectively transported through an ionic liquid-supported membrane to the acceptor phase, where the methyl ester was hydrolyzed by a different enzyme to release the (S)-ibuprofen. Since (S)-ibuprofen is more hydrophilic than its methyl ester, it is not transported back through the supported ionic liquid membrane. This method has possibilities for the isolation of pure enantiomers on a preparative scale. Since ionic liquids are nonvolatile, they do not add any contamination to a gas stream. This quality gives ionic liquids an innate advantage over traditional solvents used for absorbing gases. A porous alumina membrane saturated with 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide demonstrated a selective permeability for carbon dioxide over nitrogen of 127 [61]. It was speculated that with further technical development, ionic liquid-supported membranes would be competitive with amine scrubbers for the recovery of carbon dioxide from flue gas streams.
D. EXTRACTION
OF INORGANIC
COMPOUNDS
Common ionic liquids are noncoordinating solvents. In the absence of a complexing agent to facilitate the extraction of metal ions, ionic liquids do not exhibit useful extraction properties for metal ions from aqueous solution [62]. In this regard, they behave like conventional molecular solvents used for metal extractions. There is no evidence to date for facilitated extraction through ion exchange where metal ions are selectively attracted into the ionic liquid with displacement of the ionic liquid
DK4478_book.fm Page 102 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
102
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
cation to the aqueous phase. The purpose of the complexing agent is to dehydrate the metal ions and to offer a more hydrophobic environment to facilitate solvation of the metal ions by the ionic liquid phase. To ensure complete transfer of metal ions from the aqueous phase, the complexing agent should reside preferentially in the ionic liquid with only limited distribution to the aqueous phase. A number of complexing agents in the biphasic systems containing 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium or 1-octyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate or bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide and water adjusted to a suitable pH have been shown to fulfill this condition. The applications reported include extraction of a variety of transition metals using 1-pyridylazo-2-naphthol (PAN) and 1-thiazolylazo-2-naphthol (TAN) [62]; extraction of Cd2+, Hg2+, Pb2+, Zn2+, Cu2+, and Ag+ by dithizone [63]; extraction of actinides by octyl(phenyl)-N,N-diisobutylcarbamoylmethyl phosphine oxide (CMPO) [64–66]; extraction of group I and II metals by crown ethers [67–70]; and extraction of group I and II metals by calix[4]arenes [71,72]. The extraction of metal ions by 1-pyridylazo-2-naphthol, 1-thiazolylazo-2-naphthol, and dithizone shows the expected pH dependence typical of extractions with conventional solvents [62,63]. The recovery of metal ions from dithizone complexes dissolved in ionic liquids by back extraction into an aqueous solution of suitable pH has been demonstrated. Ionic liquids containing octyl(phenyl)-N,N-diisobutylcarbamoylmethylphosphine oxide in the presence of tri-n-butyl phosphate show an unusually large extraction efficiency for lanthanides, uranyl complexes, and 137Cs and 90Sr compared with conventional water-immiscible organic solvents [64–66]. Octyl(phenyl)-N,N-diisobutylcarbamoylmethylphosphine oxide is a neutral complexing agent and requires an anion such as nitrate to transfer metal ions into low polarity organic solvents. A useful practical advantage of ionic liquids is that the high extraction efficiency extends to much lower concentrations of nitric acid compared with conventional solvents. Addition of tri-n-butyl phosphate to nitric acid solutions containing Sr2+ was shown to markedly increase the extraction of Sr2+ by dicyclohexano-18-crown-6 into 1alkyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amides [70]. This is accounted for by adduct formation between strontium, the crown ether, and tri-nbutyl phosphate, resulting in enhanced extractability by the ionic liquids. Increasing the alkyl chain length of the 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cation reduces this enhancement effect. The selectivity order for the extraction of group I and II metal ions into 1alkyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate by dicyclohexano-18-crown-6 was K+ > Rb+ > Cs+ > Na+ > Li+ [69]. This order reflects the relative complexing ability of the crown ether for alkali metal cations and is similar to results for conventional solvents. Solutions of calix[4]arene-bis(tert-octylbenzo-crown-6) in 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amides provide efficient extraction of Cs+ ions from aqueous solution under conditions that gave negligible extraction with traditional organic solvents [71]. Pyridinocalix[4]arene in 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate demonstrated enhanced extraction efficiency for Ag+ compared to chloroform and high selectivity over Cu2+, Zn2+, Co2+, and Ni2+[72]. Task-specific ionic liquids containing both ionic and complexing groups in a single structure have been developed for the extraction of metal ions [73,74]. Attaching a metal ion coordinating group directly to the imidazolium cation makes the complexing agent an integral part of the hydrophobic phase and greatly diminishes
DK4478_book.fm Page 103 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
103
the chance for loss to the aqueous phase. Ionic liquids containing imidazolium groups and thiol, thiourea, or urea substituents with hexafluorophosphate counterions were shown to be effective for the extraction of Hg2+ and Cd2+ ions from aqueous solution when used alone as the hydrophobic phase or as a mixture with a conventional ionic liquid. An ethylene-glycol functionalized bis-imidazolium ionic liquid with bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide counterions showed high selectivity for the extraction of Hg2+ in the presence of Cs+ [74]. Mercury could be recovered from the ionic liquid by changing the pH of the aqueous phase. Extending the ethylene glycol monomer chain length or introducing other chelating atoms (e.g., sulfur or nitrogen) might extend the range of task-specific ionic liquids for metal extractions.
E. SUPERCRITICAL FLUID EXTRACTION
FROM IONIC
LIQUIDS
While distillation remains a reasonable option for the recovery of volatile compounds from ionic liquids, supercritical fluid extraction is an attractive alternative for the recovery of thermally labile compounds and offers a suitable alternative to liquidliquid extraction [74,75]. There are several reports providing details of the solubility of gases and simple organic compounds as a function of temperature and pressure in 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium ionic liquids with hexafluorophosphate, tetrafluoroborate, nitrate, and ethylsulfate anions and for N-butylpyridinium tetrafluoroborate [75,77–79]. A phase diagram for the binary system of fluoroform and 1-ethyl-3methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate is also available [80]. For product recovery from ionic liquids, most attention has focused on the use of supercritical fluid carbon dioxide [75–78]. The phase behavior of carbon dioxide with ionic liquids differs significantly from molecular liquids. While large amounts of carbon dioxide dissolve into the ionic liquids, this occurs without appreciable expansion of the liquid. It is assumed that this is due to the strong Coulombic forces between ions that resist changes to the ion spacing. Once the void pace within the ionic liquid is saturated, even under very high pressure, no more carbon dioxide can dissolve into the ionic liquid. On account of this unique behavior, ionic liquid–carbon dioxide systems remain two-phase, even at high pressures. Although large quantities of carbon dioxide dissolve in the ionic liquid-rich phase, reducing the ionic liquid viscosity, virtually no ionic liquid dissolves in the carbon dioxide-rich phase. This allows for product recovery by fluid expansion with minimal contamination by the ionic liquid. The lack of any appreciable solubility of ionic liquids in the carbon dioxide phase can be attributed to the extremely low vapor pressure of ionic liquids and the inability of carbon dioxide to adequately solvate ions in the gas phase. The nonextractability of ionic liquids by carbon dioxide was demonstrated in early studies of supercritical fluid chromatography with silica-supported ionic liquids as the stationary phase [81]. In a study of 20 various model compounds dissolved in 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate, it was shown that more than 95% recovery was possible for all compounds using supercritical fluid carbon dioxide [75]. As would be expected, compounds requiring the most carbon dioxide for extraction were those with the lowest volatility and strongest interactions with the ionic liquid. It should be noted, however, that small amounts of water in the ionic liquid dramatically reduce the solubility of carbon dioxide and can shift the pH toward the acid side, both factors
DK4478_book.fm Page 104 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
104
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
being potential problems for extracting real samples [77]. Also, it has been shown that open-tubular columns coated with 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate can be used to determine partition coefficients with supercritical fluid carbon dioxide over a wide range of temperature and density conditions [82].
III. LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY Ionic liquids are not widely used in liquid chromatography [38–40,83–85]. They are generally too viscose to use as mobile phases, typically one to three orders of magnitude higher than desirable. In addition, they are more expensive than traditional solvents and often exhibit poor transmittance of low-wavelength ultraviolet (UV) light (sometimes due to the presence of impurities). The viscosity of some ionic liquids can be reduced to manageable ranges by dilution with water or an organic solvent and by increasing the column temperature. Aqueous solutions of alkylammonium thiocyanates corrode stainless steel surfaces as well as demonstrating poor baseline stability [38]. The aqueous solutions of tetra-n-alkylammonium sulfonates are strongly basic and rapidly degrade silica-based column packings [84]. The aqueous and organic solutions of alkylammonium nitrate [38,39,83] and acetate [85] ionic liquids are generally compatible with silica-based column packings. Except for hydrogen-bond acids, most polar compounds are not eluted from typical reversephase columns by alkylammonium nitrate-water mobile phases. For hydrogen-bond acids, retention factors (log k) are usually a linear function of the volume fraction of ethylammonium or n-propylammonium nitrates for the composition range of 20 to 60% (v/v) ionic liquid [38]. Ethylammonium nitrate has a similar solvent strength to tetrahydrofuran for hydrogen-bond acids, while n-propylammonium nitrate is even stronger. A typical separation of a mixture of hydrogen-bond acids is shown in Figure 2.2. The large change in relative retention for 2,4-dinitrophenol in changing the mobile phase from methanol-water to n-propylammonium nitrate-water is particularly notable. The solvent strength of ethylammonium acetate is indicated as similar to methanol, with a wider range of potential applications when compared with the alkylammonium nitrate ionic liquids [85]. The alkylammonium nitrate and acetate ionic liquids can be used as strengthadjusting solvents with miscible organic solvents (e.g., methanol, ethanol, 2-propanol, acetonitrile, tetrahydrofuran, etc.) [83]. This facilitates elution of a wider range of polar and hydrogen-bond acid compounds from chemically bonded column packings. Except for 2-propanol, most solvent modifiers exhibit a linear change in the retention factor (log k) with the volume fraction of organic solvent for the composition range of 50% to 90% (v/v) organic solvent. The solvent strength of organic solvents in alkylammonium nitrate solutions is generally different from their values in water. Liquid-liquid chromatographic separations have been performed with alkylammonium nitrate ionic liquids coated on silica supports with mobile phases containing various amounts of chlorinated hydrocarbons or ethers in hexane [39,40]. The columns were prepared by the dynamic coating technique and were stable for many hours of operation using mobile phases saturated with the ionic liquid. One appli-
DK4478_book.fm Page 105 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
105
4 2 1 4 1 5
2 3
5
3 (a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.2 Separation of hydrogen-bond acids by reverse-phase chromatography on a 25 cm × 1 mm inside diameter column packed with Spherisorb ODS 1 (10 μm) (Waters Corp., Milford, MA) with a mobile phase flow rate of 50 μl/min. The mobile phase was (a) watermethanol (3:2) and (b) water-n-propylammonium nitrate (3:2). Identification: 1 = anthranilic acid; 2 = 2,4-dinitrophenol; 3 = 1,2-diamino-4-nitrobenzene; 4 = 4-nitroaniline; and 5 = 3nitroaniline. (From Shetty, P.H., Youngberg, P.J., Kersten, B.R., and Poole, C.F., J. Chromatogr., 411, 61, 1987. With permission.)
cation of these columns is the facile determination of liquid-liquid partition coefficients. Coated columns have also been used for the separation of structural isomers (Figure 2.3) [39]. Ionic liquids at concentrations of 2 to 60 mM have been used as mobile phase additives for the separation of amines on chemically bonded stationary phases [86–89]. In this instance, it is unclear whether the fact that the additives are ionic liquids is of importance. Weak bases and ammonium salts, in general, are commonly used as mobile phase additives for the same purpose and are just as effective. 1Alkyl-3-methylimidazolium ionic liquids are assumed to be adsorbed onto the stationary phase surface, suppressing the activity of free silanol groups. This results in improved peak shapes and decreased retention for amines and increased retention for acids. In addition, the repulsion between the imidazolium cation and ionized amines may play a role in minimizing silanol-group interactions. Ionic liquids are also useful deactivating agents for the separation of peptides by normal-phase thinlayer chromatography [90]. Liquid chromatographic techniques are suitable for detecting impurities in ionic liquids. Ion exchange chromatography with suppressed conductivity detection (ion chromatography) is suitable for detecting halide impurities at low parts per million concentrations in ionic liquids [91]. Reverse-phase liquid chromatography can be used to determine UV-absorbing impurities in 1,3-dialkylimidazolium-based ionic liquids [92,93]. Cation exchange chromatography provides higher selectivity for the separation of short-chain 1,3-dialkylimidazolium and N-alkylpyridinium cations
DK4478_book.fm Page 106 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
106
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
5 6 7
1
2
3 4
(a)
(b)
(c)
FIGURE 2.3 Separation of structural isomers by liquid-liquid chromatography using an ionic liquid as the stationary phase. The column was 20 cm × 1 mm packed with LiChrospher Si 100, 10 μm particle size (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). The ionic liquid was coated on the silica support by passing a solution of 25% (v/v) n-propylammonium nitrate solution in acetonitrile through the column overnight (at least 50 column volumes) at a flow rate of 5 μl/min. The acetonitrile was then washed out of the column with methylene chloride (about 3 h at 50 μl/min) and the column equilibrated with the mobile phase for the separation. The volume of ionic liquid adsorbed by the support was typically 0.035 ml and the phase ratio about 0.2. The mobile phase was (a,c) hexane-methyl t-butyl ether (4:1) and (b) hexanemethylene chloride (4:1). The mobile phase was saturated with n-propylammonium nitrate before use. Identification: 1 = 2-nitrophenol; 2 = 4-nitrophenol; 3 = 1-naphthol; 4 = 2-naphthol; 5 = norethindrone acetate; 6 = norgestrel; and 7 = norethindrone.
than reverse-phase chromatography. Ion-pair chromatography is preferred for more hydrophobic cations [93]. Cation exchange sorbents are suitable for the isolation of ionic liquid cations by solid-phase extraction [94].
IV. ELECTROPHORESIS Electrophoresis in fused inorganic salts and their eutectic mixtures was developed in the 1960s for the separation of inorganic ions and isotopes [95–97]. Later, electrophoresis in ionic liquids was used to study fundamental aspects of ion solvation, transport, and complex formation in the absence of competition from water molecules. Electrophoresis in inorganic ionic liquids requires a special apparatus that can tolerate the high temperatures and corrosive nature of these solvents and their electrolysis products. Separations were generally performed in the flatbed mode using glass fiber or asbestos paper strips as well as powdered thin-layer supports. As a separation method, inorganic ionic liquids are virtually
DK4478_book.fm Page 107 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
107
unused today, while interest in organic ionic liquids, largely in capillary electrophoresis, is just beginning.
A. CAPILLARY ELECTROPHORESIS High viscosity, variable purity, and interference in absorbance detection at low wavelengths are the main problems inhibiting the wider use of organic ionic liquids in capillary electrophoresis at present. Ionic liquids have been used as background electrolytes in aqueous [98–100] and nonaqueous [101–104] capillary electrophoresis. The most common cosolvents are water, acetonitrile, and mixtures of acetonitrile and methanol. Ionic liquids are promising candidates for use as background electrolytes, where dilution with a cosolvent reduces their viscosity. The addition of an ionic liquid to organic solvents changes the electroosmotic flow of the system. The change is most dramatic for acetonitrile and less so for methanol. Changes in the cation have a greater effect on the electroosmotic flow than changes in the anion. In solvents of low polarity, a lack of free ions diminishes the effectiveness of ionic liquids as background electrolytes. 1,3-Dialkylimidazolium-based ionic liquids are adsorbed onto the capillary wall from an aqueous solution. In so doing, they reverse the direction of the electroosmotic flow, more or less independent of pH [98,105]. Ionic liquids can be covalently bonded to the capillary wall in a several-step process that achieves the same result as physical coating [98,106]. A column of this type with an electrolyte solution containing 7.5 mM lactic acid, 0.6 mM 18-crown-6, 12 mM α-cyclodextrin, and 100 mM 1-hexyl3-methylimidazolium hydroxide to adjust the electrolyte pH to 4 provided baseline separation of eight alkaline and alkaline earth metal ions plus nickel, lead, and ammonium in less than 14 min [106]. A number of different samples, including DNA fragments [107], proteins [105], metal ions [98,106], ionic dyes [102], anthraquinones [100], phenols [99,103], poly(phenols) [108,109], etc., were separated using 1,3-dialkylimidazolium-based ionic liquids as a major component of the electrolyte solution without significant operational difficulties. The separation of poly(phenols) is shown in Figure 2.4 [109]. A contributing factor to this separation is the association of the poly(phenols) with 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cations both at the capillary wall and in solution. The migration order of halophenols in an aqueous electrolyte solution indicates that the 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cations of the ionic liquid are likely associated with the phenols, since they migrate as if carrying a partial positive charge [99]. β-Cyclodextrin was used as an additive to achieve baseline separation of four anthraquinones in a plant extract with a background electrolyte containing 60 mM 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate in pH 10 buffer [100]. Model proteins were separated in buffers containing 90 mM 1-ethyl3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [107]. The ionic liquid was responsible for reversing the direction of the electroosmotic flow and repelling basic proteins from the silica surface, improving peak shapes. Ionic liquids were used as modifiers in micellar electrokinetic chromatography with polymeric surfactants for the separation of both chiral and achiral compounds [110]. The main effect of adding from 1 to 20 mM 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate ionic liquids to the background electrolyte was adjustment of the
DK4478_book.fm Page 108 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
108
Advances in Chromatography, Volume 45
Absorbance (mAU)
∗
A
∗
B
C
10
21
31
42
FIGURE 2.4 Separation of poly(phenols) using (A) 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate, (B) 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate, and (C) 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate. The electrolyte solution contained 150 mM ionic liquid in water. The fused-silica capillary column was 50 cm × 50 μm inside diameter, operating voltage 16 kV, and absorbance detection at the anode end at 240 nm. (From Yanes, E.G., Gratz, S.R., Baldwin, M.J., Robinson, S.E., and Stalcup, A.M., Anal. Chem., 73, 3838, 2001. With permission.)
electroosmotic flow, with little evidence that the ionic liquids modified the selectivity of analyte-surfactant interactions. Capillary electrophoresis is a suitable technique for determining UV-absorbing ionic impurities in ionic liquids [111]. Citrate buffers provide improved separation and peak shapes for 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cations. A pH 4 citrate buffer of 200 mM concentration was indicated as optimum with respect to peak shapes and resolution of 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cations. High buffer concentrations likely diminish interactions with the silica surface, thus reducing tailing. For 1,3-dialkylimidazolium cations, ion mobility was shown to be a linear function of the mass of the cation, regardless of the type of alkyl or aryl substitution. Consequently cations with different structures, but the same mass, are not separated. Capillary electrophoresis was used to detect chloride ion impurities in 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide and bromide impurities in 1-butyl-3methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [112]. The background electrolyte consisted of 2-amino-2-methyl-1,3-propanediol and sodium dichromate of various concentrations, but with a constant 6:5 molar ratio in water. The halide ions are detected by indirect absorption at 254 nm with sodium dichromate as the indicator electrolyte. Using both electrokinetic injection and the water plug method for online concentration, quantification of chloride and bromide ions at the parts per million level was achieved.
DK4478_book.fm Page 109 Thursday, September 14, 2006 1:35 PM
Ionic Liquids in Extraction, Chromatography, and Electrophoresis
109
V. GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY Early studies of ionic liquids as stationary phases in gas chromatography are reviewed in Poole et al. [113]. In addition, gas chromatography is widely used to determine the physicochemical properties of ionic liquids, reviewed in Poole [8] and Poole et al. [114]. These articles contain a large amount of data useful for the selection of ionic liquids for particular applications. In this section, studies that extend our understanding of the characteristic properties of ionic liquids as stationary phases for gas chromatography are high