Advances in
IMAGING AND ELECTRON PHYSICS VOLUME
159 Cold Field Emission and the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
PETER W. HAWKES CEMES-CNRS Toulouse, France
Advances in
IMAGING AND ELECTRON PHYSICS VOLUME
159 Cold Field Emission and the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Edited by
PETER W. HAWKES
CEMES-CNRS, Toulouse, France
AMSTERDAM • BOSTON • HEIDELBERG • LONDON NEW YORK • OXFORD • PARIS • SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO • SINGAPORE • SYDNEY • TOKYO Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands 32 Jamestown Road, London NW1 7BY, UK 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA First edition 2009 Copyright # 2009, Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://www.elsevier.com/ locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-12-374986-4 ISSN: 1076-5670 For information on all Academic Press publications visit our Web site at elsevierdirect.com Printed in the United States of America 09 10 11 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Preface Contributors Future Contributions
1. The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope and Related Topics
xi xv xvii
1
A. V. Crewe 1. Introduction 2. Some Chicago Aberrations: A Personal Collection Acknowledgments 3. Electron Microscope Studies: Achievements of the Crewe Lab Introduction Construction (Reference Group A) Source Development (Reference Group B) STEM Development and Atomic Images (Reference Group C) The Field Emission SEM (Reference Group D) Energy Loss and Radiation Damage (Reference Group E) Secondary Electron Production (Reference Group F) DNA Labeling (Reference Group G) Nucleosomes (Reference Group H) Attempts at Aberration Correction (Reference Group I) Theoretical Electron Optics (Reference Group J) Optimization and the Super-High-Resolution SEM (Reference Group K) Image Processing (Reference Group L) Three-Dimensional Reconstruction (Reference Group M) Hemoglobin Work (Reference Group N) References (of Chicago Aberrations) References (of DOE Report)
2. A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
2 6 13 13 14 16 17 18 19 20 21 21 22 23 27 28 30 31 32 37 38
63
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind 1. Introduction 2. Work Function
63 65
v
vi
Contents
3. Energy Distribution 3.1. Theoretical Background 3.2. Analytical versus Numerical Results 3.3. Measured Values of the FWHM for the Tungsten Cold-Field Electron 4. Source Optics 5. Column Optics Using the Cold-Field Electron Source 6. Current Stability 6.1. High-Frequency Current Fluctuations 6.2. Long-Term Current Drift 6.3. Cold-Field Electron End-of-Life Mechanisms 7. Summary Acknowledgments References
3. History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
67 67 68 72 79 82 86 87 88 94 97 98 98
101
Joseph S. Wall, Martha N. Simon, and James F. Hainfeld 1. Introduction 2. Instrument Design Parameters 3. Heavy Metal Cluster Labeling 4. Early User/Collaborator Projects 5. Recent Work 6. Conclusion Acknowledgments References
4. Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
101 102 106 108 115 115 115 116
123
Hiromi Inada, Hiroshi Kakibayashi, Shigeto Isakozawa, Takahito Hashimoto, Toshie Yaguchi, and Kuniyasu Nakamura 1. Introduction 2. The Dawn of Hitachi Electron Microscopes (by Hiromi Inada) 2.1. Crewe STEM Shock and Field Emission Development 3. Cold FE-SEM Studies and Expansion to Different Fields 3.1. CFE-STEM Development at HCRL 3.2. CFE-SEM Development at Naka Works 3.3. Studies of Field Emission Stability 4. Expansion of High-Voltage TEMs and STEMs 4.1. Holography Studies by Tonomura with FE-TEMs 4.2. Multistage Acceleration CFEG for TEM Applications 4.3. Commercialized Analytical CFE-TEM/STEM 5. Development of 50-kV STEM in 1970s (by Shigeto Isakozawa) 5.1. Development of Hitachi’s 50kV Prototype CFE-STEM
124 125 125 128 128 131 132 137 137 138 139 141 141
Contents
5.2. Bright-Field Images Obtained with 50-kV CFE-STEM 5.3. Single-Atom Observation 5.4. Development of the Electron Energy-Loss Spectrometer 5.5. Further Development of 50-kV CFE-STEM 6. Hitachi’s First Commercialized Dedicated STEM (by Takahito Hashimoto) 6.1. 200-kV Analytical CFE-TEM, HF-2000 6.2. ‘‘Gate Viewer,’’ Trigger for Dedicated STEM 6.3. Novel Functions for HD Series 7. Cutting-Edge Applications with Customized HD Models (by Toshie Yaguchi) 7.1. 120-kV FE UHV for Nanotubes 7.2. 200-kV FE Ultrahigh-Resolution STEM 7.3. 3D Structural and Elemental Analysis 8. Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM (by Kuniyasu Nakamura) 8.1. Atomic-Level Characterization Instrument 8.2. Theoretical Consideration of Advantages of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.3. Evaluation of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.4. Advanced Application Results with HD-2700C 9. Conclusion and Future Prospective (by Hiroshi Kakibayashi) Acknowledgments References
5. Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
vii
142 144 147 149 150 150 154 161 165 165 165 169 170 170 172 173 176 181 182 182
187
P. W. Hawkes 1. Introduction 2. The AEI STEM-1 3. The Siemens ST100F 3.1. The New ELMISKOP ST100F Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Introduction Construction of the ELMISKOP ST100F Advantages of the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Imaging with Low Radiation Damage Conclusion 3.2. Image Forming Systems General Remarks The Imaging Process Image Forming Properties of Magnetic Lenses Strong Lenses Lens Systems for CTEM and STEM: Similarities and Differences Requirements for Analytical Microscopy Acknowledgments References
188 188 191 195 195 195 198 198 201 203 203 204 205 208 210 215 217 217
viii
Contents
6. A History of Vacuum Generators’ 100-kV Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope
221
Ian R. M. Wardell and Peter E. Bovey 1. The Early Days 2. Design Considerations for a Commercial STEM 2.1. The Objective Lens 2.2. The Specimen Stage 2.3. The Electron Gun 2.4. Location of Analytical Facilities 2.5. The Resultant Assembly 3. The First STEMs and HB5 Development 3.1. The Optical Column 3.2. Stage Development 3.3. Early Airlock and Manipulator 3.4. The Dark-Field Detector 3.5. Secondary Electron Detector 3.6. Diffraction Facilities 3.7. The Energy Analyzer Mk1 3.8. Electronics 4. Improved Resolution 4.1. The MIT HB5 4.2. The University of Illinois HB5 5. Other Developments 5.1. Beam-Blanking Plates 5.2. Detectors and the Virtual Objective Aperture 5.3. Stage Motor Drives 5.4. New Airlock 5.5. Energy Analyzer Mk2 5.6. Gun Lens 5.7. High-Excitation Objective Lens 6. Stages and Cartridges 6.1. Basic Cartridges 6.2. Beryllium Cartridges 6.3. Cold Stage 6.4. Cryo-Transfer System 7. The HB501 7.1. General Development 7.2. HB501UX and High-Resolution Imaging 8. Special and Variant Instruments 8.1. University of Glasgow’s HB5 8.2. The HB501A 9. The HB601
222 224 225 225 226 226 227 227 232 238 240 241 245 246 249 251 254 254 255 256 256 257 261 262 264 266 266 268 268 269 269 270 271 271 273 273 275 276 278
Contents
10. Postscript Acknowledgments References
7. Development of the 300-kV Vacuum Generator STEM (1985–1996)
ix
280 282 283
287
H. S. von Harrach 1. Prelude in Oxford (1973–1975) 2. The MIDAS Project (1985–1988) 2.1. System 2.2. Gun Lens 2.3. Objective Lens 2.4. Side-Entry Stage 2.5. MIDAS Performance 3. The HB603 300-kV STEM instruments 3.1. The Prototype Design Phase 4. MIT and ANL Designs 5. Oak Ridge Design 6. Lehigh Design 7. Testing, Testing 8. Record-Breaking Results 8.1. Source Brightness 8.2. Energy Spread 8.3. ADF Resolution 8.4. X-Ray Microanalysis 9. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
8. On the High-Voltage STEM Project in Toulouse (MEBATH)
288 288 289 289 290 291 291 292 293 305 307 310 311 316 316 316 316 317 320 321 322
325
Bernard Jouffrey 1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction The Building Generator The Column 4.1. The Source 4.2. Accelerating Tube 4.3. Lenses 4.4. Spectrometers 5. Suspension of the Platform and the Microscope 6. Recording of The Signal 7. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
325 328 333 336 336 342 346 348 349 351 352 352 353
x
Contents
9. Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy: Biological Applications
357
Andreas Engel 1. Introduction 2. Image Formation 2.1. Electron-Sample Interactions 2.2. The Optical System 2.3. Detectors 2.4. Single-Electron Counting 2.5. Imaging Modes 3. Imaging Thin Sections 4. Imaging Negatively Stained Samples 5. Mass Measurements Using the Basel STEM 5.1. Principle 5.2. Estimate of the Statistical Error 5.3. Mass Determination of Biological Samples 6. Specific Examples of STEM Imaging and Mass Measurements 7. High-Throughput Visual Proteomics 8. Conclusions and Perspectives Acknowledgments References
10. STEM at Cambridge University: Reminiscences and Reflections from the 1950s and 1960s
358 359 359 360 360 361 363 363 365 366 366 369 371 373 378 380 382 382
387
K. C. A. Smith 1. STEM as a Diagnostic Tool for SEM 2. The Observation of Specimens in Water Vapor by Means of STEM 3. High-Voltage STEM Using a Single-Field Condenser—Objective Lens References
Contents of Volumes 151–158 Index
387 393 400 405
407 411
Preface
Tom Mulvey (right) with Elmar Zeitler, Berlin 1990* I have the sad duty of recording the death of our other Honorary Associate Editor, Tom Mulvey, who died on 16 July 2009, a few days before his 88th birthday. He was born on 26 July 1921 in Manchester; during the wartime years he served in the Navy and was sent to the Far East where he was responsible for anti-submarine operations. After being demobbed, he was awarded the MSc degree by Manchester University for a substantial study of electrostatic lenses and then spent several years in the Metropolitan–Vickers research establishment at Aldermaston Court. It was during this period that he met Rita, his future wife, for whom he cared devotedly during the last years of her life. In 1965, he joined the Birmingham College of Advanced Technology, later the University of Aston in Birmingham (today Aston University) and was made Emeritus Professor on his retirement in 1986. The last years of his life were spent near his son Nicholas, close to Oxford. In addition to his own research, he took over from V. E. Cosslett as editor of Advances in Optical & Electron Microscopy and later became an Associate Editor of Advances in Imaging & Electron Physics, to which he contributed several biographical articles on the pioneers of electron microscopy: Ernst Ruska, Dennis Gabor and Jan le Poole; he also wrote the Royal Society memoir on V. E. Cosslett and * Courtesy of Prof. Dr B. Lencova´
xi
xii
Preface
translated Ruska’s book on the early history of the electron microscope. The history of electron microscopy is richer by the presence of his many articles, of which the first (Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 13, 1962, 197–207) is truly remarkable, written before most of the fundamental documents for such a study had been published; a more extended account appeared in Proc. RMS 2 (1967) 201–227. The volume of these Advances that he guest-edited on ‘‘The Growth of Electron Microscopy’’ was a splendid achievement. His research interests were wide-ranging and he introduced many unconventional lens designs. Among the most memorable were boiling-water lenses, pancake lenses, single-polepiece lenses and snorkel lenses, the dimensions of which were often indicated in units of ‘‘England’s Glory’’ matchboxes. For his 80th birthday (but rather belatedly), the Royal Microscopical Society (of which he was an honorary Fellow) brought together many of his friends for a celebration in Birmingham, which is commemorated in a long section of the Proceedings of the society (39, 2004, 206–233). A much fuller biography is to be found there, as well as tributes from many of those present; a bibliography of his publications was published for an earlier birthday and occupies four pages of the Journal of Microscopy (179, 1995, 101–104). One aspect that emerges from the tributes is just how entertaining he could be – he had an unlimited stock of anecdotes about present and past colleagues and jokes ranging from the politically highly incorrect to the purely frivolous. He was also a Distinguished Scientist and Fellow of the Microscopy Society of America and was awarded the gold Kr i z ´ık medal of the Czech Academy of Sciences. He will be greatly missed and we extend our sympathy to all his family. The scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) has a long history, going back to the 1960s. In the present volume, its development is traced from its inception in the Argonne National Laboratory and the University of Chicago, where A. V. Crewe built the first simple instruments, the success of which owed much to the quality of the field-emission gun. Albert Crewe was unfortunately not able to prepare a new account for this volume and, with his approval, two older documents are reproduced here: ‘‘Some Chicago aberrations’’ and a long report submitted to the US Department of Energy in 1992, which includes a very full list of publications. The field-emission source is the vital element of the STEM, for the brightness of thermionic guns is insufficient for a high-resolution instrument. Chapter 2 offers a review of cold field-emission source properties by L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind, both major contributors to our understanding of these guns. They cover both early developments and current research preoccupations. The following group of chapters describes specific instruments and commercial developments. J. S. Wall was a member of Crewe’s team
Preface
xiii
when the first STEMs were being constructed and, as he explains, he was later recruited by Brookhaven National Laboratory to advance the construction of their STEM. Together with M. N. Simon and J. F. Hainfeld, he describes the design of this early home-made instrument and subsequent developments. The spectacular images obtained by Crewe awakened interest worldwide, not least in Japan. Hitachi in particular was stimulated to enter the STEM field and in Chapter 4, H. Inada, H. Kakibayashi, S. Isakozawa, T. Hashimoto, T. Yaguchi and K. Nakamura describe the early work that made STEM development possible and such topics as holography that also benefited from highly coherent sources. The various models are presented, together with some of the most impressive results. The closing paragraphs bring the story up to the aberration-corrected era. This does not exhaust the STEM projects in Japan. For example, a high-voltage instrument constructed at Nagoya University is described by M. Hibino, H. Shimoyaya and S. Maruse ( J. Electron Microsc. Tech. 12, 1989, 296–304) and an aberration-corrected STEM is also available from JEOL. In Europe, Siemens, AEI and Vacuum Generators all embarked on STEM projects. The VG instruments are described at length by I. R. M. Wardell, P. E. Bovey and S. von Harrach in Chapters 6 and 7. But for Siemens and AEI, I was unable to find authors and have therefore written an account of their STEMs myself, based on published information and personal communication from several of those involved (Chapter 5). It was natural that the Laboratoire d’Optique Electronique in Toulouse, already home to two high-voltage transmission electron microscopes, should embark on the design and construction of a high-voltage STEM. In Chapter 8, B. Jouffrey, who launched and piloted this project, describes the principal stages in the preparations for this instrument, which alas was never completed. The foregoing chapters contain much description of instrumentation while Chapter 9 is a reminder that the STEM has proved an invaluable tool for microscopists in many fields of application. Here, A. Engel shows how fruitful it has been in biology. We conclude with a chapter by K. C. A. Smith, who was not only a pioneer of the scanning electron microscope in the Cambridge University Engineering Department but was also responsible for the design and construction of the first Cambridge high-voltage electron microscope, built in the Cavendish Laboratory in the 1960s. It was at that time that the idea of operating the microscope in the STEM mode came to him and it is this little-known early effort that is recorded here. It is worth emphasizing that it was first mentioned in print in 1968, the same year as Crewe’s key paper in the Journal of Applied Physics. This volume should also have contained two more chapters, by M. S. Isaacson and O. L. Krivanek. Circumstances have prevented them
xiv
Preface
from completing their chapters in time and their contributions will therefore appear in later volumes of the Advances. I greatly regret that they do not appear here, for M. S Isaacson was one of the pioneers of the STEM while O. L. Krivanek not only produced the first successful corrector of spherical aberration for the STEM but also suggested to me that a thematic volume on STEM would be timely. As always, I am most grateful to all the contributors for writing such readable and informative accounts. Peter W. Hawkes
Contributors
A. V. Crewe Enrico Fermi Institute and Department of Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, USA L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind FEI Co. Hillsboro, Oregon, USA Joseph S. Wall, Martha N. Simon, and James F. Hainfeld Biology Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11073, USA Hiromi Inada, Hiroshi Kakibayashi, Shigeto Isakozawa, Takahito Hashimoto, Toshie Yaguchi, and Kuniyasu Nakamura Hitachi High-Technologies Corp., Tokyo, Japan
1
63 101
123
P. W. Hawkes CEMES-CNRS, Toulouse, France
187
Ian R. M. Wardell Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Brighton, United Kingdom
221
Peter E. Bovey Lindfield, West Sussex, United Kingdom
221
H. S. von Harrach FEI Electron Optics, Eindhoven, The Netherlands
287
Bernard Jouffrey Laboratoire de Structures, Sols et Mate´riaux (LMSS-Mat), E´cole Centrale Paris, Unite´ Mixte de Recherche (UMR), National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS) 8579, Chaˆtenay-Malabry, France
325
Andreas Engel M. E. Mu¨ller Institute for Structural Biology, Biozentrum, University of Basel, Klingelbergstrasse 70, Basel, CH-4056 Switzerland, and Department of Pharmacology, Case Western Reserve University, 10900 Euclid Avenue, Wood Bldg 321D, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, USA
357
K. C. A. Smith Fitzwilliam College, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0DG, United Kingdom
387
xv
Future Contributions
S. Ando Gradient operators and edge and corner detection K. Asakura Energy-filtering X-ray PEEM W. Bacsa Optical interference near surfaces, sub-wavelength microscopy and spectroscopic sensors Baranczuk, J. Giesen, Z. K. Simon and P. Zolliker (vol. 160) Gamut mapping C. Beeli Structure and microscopy of quasicrystals C. Bobisch and R. Mo¨ller Ballistic electron microscopy G. Borgefors Distance transforms Z. Bouchal Non-diffracting optical beams A. Buchau Boundary element or integral equation methods for static and time-dependent problems B. Buchberger Gro¨bner bases E. Cosgriff, P. D. Nellist, L. J. Allen, A. J. d’Alfonso, S. D. Findlay, and A. I. Kirkland Three-dimensional imaging using aberration-corrected scanning confocal electron microscopy T. Cremer Neutron microscopy C. J. Edgcombe New dimensions for field emission: effects of structure in the emitting surface
xvii
xviii
Future Contributions
A. N. Evans (vol. 160) Area morphology scale-spaces for colour images A. X. Falca˜o The image foresting transform R. H. A. Farias and E. Recami Introduction of a quantum of time (‘‘chronon’’) and its consequences for the electron in quantum and classical physics R. G. Forbes Liquid metal ion sources C. Fredembach Eigenregions for image classification ¨ lzha¨user A. Go Recent advances in electron holography with point sources M. Haschke Micro-XRF excitation in the scanning electron microscope L. Hermi, M. A. Khabou and M. B. H. Rhouma (vol. 162) Shape recognition based on eigenvalues of the Laplacian M. I. Herrera The development of electron microscopy in Spain M. S. Isaacson Early STEM development J. Isenberg Imaging IR-techniques for the characterization of solar cells K. Ishizuka Contrast transfer and crystal images A. Jacobo Intracavity type II second-harmonic generation for image processing L. Kipp Photon sieves G. Ko¨gel Positron microscopy T. Kohashi Spin-polarized scanning electron microscopy O. L. Krivanek Aberration-corrected STEM R. Leitgeb Fourier domain and time domain optical coherence tomography B. Lencova´ Modern developments in electron optical calculations
Future Contributions
xix
H. Lichte New developments in electron holography M. Mankos, V. Spasov and E. Munro (vol. 161) Principles of dual-beam low energy electron microscopy M. Marrocco Discrete diffraction M. Matsuya Calculation of aberration coefficients using Lie algebra S. McVitie Microscopy of magnetic specimens J. D. Mendiola-Santiban˜ez, I. R. Terol-Villalobos and I. M. Santilla´n-Me´ndez (vol. 161) Determination of adequate parameters for connected morphological contrast mappings through morphological contrast measures I. Moreno Soriano and C. Ferreira (vol. 161) Fractional Fourier transforms and geometrical optics M. A. O’Keefe Electron image simulation D. Oulton and H. Owens Colorimetric imaging D. Paganin and T. Gureyev Intensity-linear methods in inverse imaging N. Papamarkos and A. Kesidis The inverse Hough transform K. S. Pedersen, A. Lee and M. Nielsen The scale-space properties of natural images Y. Pu (vol. 160) Harmonic holography G. X. Ritter and G. Urcid (vol. 160) Lattice algebra approach to endmember determination in hyperspectral imagery R. Ru¨denberg (vol. 160) Origin and background of the invention of the electron microscope, Memoir H. G. and P. Rudenberg (vol. 160) Origin and background of the invention of the electron microscope, Commentary R. Shimizu, T. Ikuta and Y. Takai Defocus image modulation processing in real time S. Shirai CRT gun design methods
xx
Future Contributions
A. S. Skapin The use of optical and scanning electron microscopy in the study of ancient pigments T. Soma Focus-deflection systems and their applications P. Sussner and M. E. Valle Fuzzy morphological associative memories I. Talmon Study of complex fluids by transmission electron microscopy M. E. Testorf and M. Fiddy Imaging from scattered electromagnetic fields, investigations into an unsolved problem N. M. Towghi Ip norm optimal filters E. Twerdowski Defocused acoustic transmission microscopy Y. Uchikawa Electron gun optics K. Vaeth and G. Rajeswaran Organic light-emitting arrays V. Velisavljevic and M. Vetterli (vol. 161) Space-frequence quantization using directionlets M. H. F. Wilkinson and G. Ouzounis (vol. 161) Second generation connectivity and attribute filters E. Wolf (vol. 162) History and a recent development in the theory of reconstruction of crystalline solids from X-ray diffraction experiments
Chapter
4 Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes Hiromi Inada, Hiroshi Kakibayashi, Shigeto Isakozawa, Takahito Hashimoto, Toshie Yaguchi, and Kuniyasu Nakamura
Contents
1. Introduction 2. The Dawn of Hitachi Electron Microscopes (by Hiromi Inada) 2.1. Crewe STEM Shock and Field Emission Development 3. Cold FE-SEM Studies and Expansion to Different Fields 3.1. CFE-STEM Development at HCRL 3.2. CFE-SEM Development at Naka Works 3.3. Studies of Field Emission Stability 4. Expansion of High-Voltage TEMs and STEMs 4.1. Holography Studies by Tonomura with FE-TEMs 4.2. Multistage Acceleration CFEG for TEM Applications 4.3. Commercialized Analytical CFE-TEM/STEM 5. Development of 50-kV STEM in 1970s (by Shigeto Isakozawa) 5.1. Development of Hitachi’s 50kV Prototype CFE-STEM
124 125 125 128 128 131 132 137 137 138 139 141 141
Hitachi High-Technologies Corp., Tokyo, Japan Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59004-0. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
123
124
Hiromi Inada et al.
5.2. Bright-Field Images Obtained with 50-kV CFE-STEM 5.3. Single-Atom Observation 5.4. Development of the Electron Energy-Loss Spectrometer 5.5. Further Development of 50-kV CFE-STEM 6. Hitachi’s First Commercialized Dedicated STEM (by Takahito Hashimoto) 6.1. 200-kV Analytical CFE-TEM, HF-2000 6.2. ‘‘Gate Viewer,’’ Trigger for Dedicated STEM 6.3. Novel Functions for HD Series 7. Cutting-Edge Applications with Customized HD Models (by Toshie Yaguchi) 7.1. 120-kV FE UHV for Nanotubes 7.2. 200-kV FE Ultrahigh-Resolution STEM 7.3. 3D Structural and Elemental Analysis 8. Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM (by Kuniyasu Nakamura) 8.1. Atomic-Level Characterization Instrument 8.2. Theoretical Consideration of Advantages of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.3. Evaluation of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.4. Advanced Application Results with HD-2700C 9. Conclusion and Future Prospective (by Hiroshi Kakibayashi) Acknowledgments References
142 144 147 149 150 150 154 161 165 165 165 169 170 170 172 173 176 181 182 182
1. INTRODUCTION Hitachi started researching and developing electron microscopes in 1940 and has since developed and manufactured many electron microscopes. Cold-field emission (CFE) technology developed in a number of different directions. Crewe invented the field emission scanning transmission electron microscope (FE-STEM) and used an early version to observe individual atoms. Stimulated by his reports, Hitachi began developing a CFE-STEM in the mid-1960s and invited Crewe to serve as a consultant to Hitachi. He introduced his CFE technology and helped Hitachi develop and commercialize STEMs and scanning electron microscopes (SEMs). Hitachi’s prototype CFE-STEM opened a new world of analytical electron microscopes equipped with an X-ray analyzer and energy spectrometer. The HFS-2 FE-SEM, which was built at Hitachi’s Naka Works in 1972, was the first step in Hitachi’s development of FE-SEMs. A 50-kV CFE-TEM
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
125
was developed at Hitachi’s Central Research Laboratory (HCRL) by Tonomura and his group in 1973 for application to electron holography, which enabled higher image resolution. To incorporate a sophisticated FE electron gun into microscopes, it was necessary to create an ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) (of the order of 108 Pa) to fundamentally stabilize the FE current. This chapter describes Hitachi’s efforts over the past 40-plus years to develop CFE technology and STEMs. We also introduce cutting-edge application data obtained with the latest CFE-STEMs (with and without an aberration corrector), highlight Hitachi’s contributions to FE technology development, and show how the knowledge gained has been passed from generation to generation at Hitachi. Additionally, we show how CFE SEM/ STEM technologies were established.
2. THE DAWN OF HITACHI ELECTRON MICROSCOPES (BY HIROMI INADA) K. Kasai, one of the founders of the 37th Subcommittee of the Japanese Society for the Promotion of Science, with regard to electron microscopes, moved to Hitachi from one of the Japanese National Laboratories, Electrotechnical Laboratory in 1939 and began to develop electron microscopes by using the experience he gained working on cathode ray oscillography in Germany. His guiding principle was that one should work in a manufacturing company to be able to do innovative practical development. Kasai joined forces with B. Tadano at Hitachi and, in 1940, they developed the first Hitachi TEM (model HU-1) (Komoda 1996a). A second TEM with improved resolution (the HU-2) was developed and installed at Nagoya Imperial University (now Nagoya University) in 1943. Hitachi established a central research laboratory (HCRL) in Kokubunji, a suburb of Tokyo, in 1942 where it continued developing electron microscopes despite the wartime conditions.
2.1. Crewe STEM Shock and Field Emission Development 2.1.1. Trigger for Field Emission Microscopes A. V. Crewe reported the successful development of an SEM equipped with a CFE gun (CFEG) in 1964 (Crewe, 1964; Crewe et al., 1970a). This report greatly affected Hitachi researchers, who were seriously fighting to obtain the highest TEM resolution in the mid-1960s (Komoda 1996b). Crewe and his group were provident in terms of advantages of CFE and the progress of UHV technology, and they began pioneering development of an STEM equipped with a CFEG in the early 1960s. They
126
Hiromi Inada et al.
achieved a resolution of 0.5 nm and successfully observed individual atoms of uranium and thorium, even though their microscope had a simple design and contained a single-electron magnetic lens with a CFEG. This breakthrough observation overturned the conventional wisdom about electron microscopy at that time and revealed the power of FE technology. Moreover, they directly observed individual atoms with a STEM, not a TEM, whereas most scientists believed that only a TEM could achieve such high-resolution imaging (Crewe et al., 1968a,b; Crewe, Wall, and Langmore, 1970b). Hitachi started developing SEMs in the early 1960s and commercialized the first thermionic gun SEM (model HSM-2) in 1969. Conventional SEMs with a thermionic gun at that time had a resolution of 10 nm, which was much worse than that of TEMs (0.3 nm); hence, nobody compared performance between TEMs and SEMs. However, Crewe’s development of an SEM in 1964 made it possible to compare SEMs with TEMs using the same criteria. An SEM can be used to acquire time series of various types of signals (secondary, transmission electron, X-ray, and energy loss) from a specimen simultaneously by focusing on an electronically specific point and/ or area by imaging it with a narrow scanning electron beam. The development of the CFE-SEM meant the birth of a new scientific instrument capable of simultaneous nanometer-order analysis and imaging. Although some scientists (Eggenberger, Hart, and Libal, 1968; Siegel et al., 1968; Wiesner and Everhart, 1969) had started early FEG electron microscopes, none of the electron microscope vendors had succeeded in building a CFE-SEM. Accordingly, Hitachi was driven to quickly develop a CFE-SEM due to its importance. R. Ueda (Nagoya University) said in the preface of the first issue revival of the Journal of Electron Microscopy in 1975, ‘‘Crewe STEM was excellent and nobody had imagined before such achievement and his outstanding concept’’ (Ueda, 1975). This statement reflects the sensational effect the FE-SEM had at that time.
2.1.2. Field Emission Gun Development at Hitachi Hitachi launched a major project in 1969 to produce ultrahigh-resolution FE-SEMs and FE-TEMs. As a microscope manufacturer, Hitachi focused on ease of use and ease of production, as well as on imaging capability. In 1970, Hitachi invited Crewe to serve as a technical consultant for its development of a CFE-SEM. Field emission was discovered by R. W. Wood in the nineteenth century (Wood, 1897). Millikan and Lauritsen (1928) and E. W. Mu¨ller (1937) studied the characteristics of this type of emission. FE patterns
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
127
were investigated (Gomer, 1961), and study of FE as a source of electrons began in 1955 (Butler, 1966; Dyke et al., 1953; Everhart, 1967; Martin, Trolan, and Dyke, 1960). FE electrons can be obtained by applying several thousand volts to the tip of a metal needle (FE tip) with a radius of less than 100 nm. The energy spread of the emitted electrons is narrow (0.2–0.3 eV) because the emitter runs at room temperature. FE electrons are emitted through the potential barrier of the surface from near the Fermi level because the barrier is thinned by the application of a negative electronic field with a strength of 107 V/cm to the metal surface, which is the tunnel effect. The current density J(A/cm2) is obtained using equation 1 from Fowler and Nordheim (Fowler and Nordheim, 1928), and the density strongly depends on the electric field applied to the FE tip and on the work function of the metal. ( ) F2 6:83 105 f3=2 vðyÞ 2 exp J ¼ 1:54 10 ; (4.1) ft2 ðyÞ F where t2(y) and v(y) are elliptic functions nearly equal to 1, F is the electric field strength, and f is the cathode work function. The thermionic electron current density is obtained using the Richardson–Dushman equation. The CFE current density (104–106 A/cm2) is three orders of magnitude larger than that of the thermionic electrons (1–10 A/cm2). The FE source is ideally a point source, and the diameter of the virtual source ranges from 5 to 10 nm because of the small FE tip, which is 1/1000 the source size of the thermionic emission (1–10 m). Thus, changing the FE source can reduce the beam spot size; that is, it can improve SEM image resolution. An electron gun should be designed to have less spherical aberration and mechanical vibration. Crewe used the Butler electrostatic lens, which has less spherical aberration than his prototype design, for his CFE-STEM and thereby obtained high resolution. An FE electron gun with a Butler lens consists of an FE tip and a diode region for the extraction and acceleration electrodes (Figure 1). A. Tonomura at HCRL used a microcomputer to optimize the Butler lens shape and minimize the aberration (Shimoyama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989; Tonomura and Komoda, 1973). Table 1 shows a comparison of the characteristics of emitters with FE and thermionic electron guns. Although applying the FE gun to electron microscopes was an obvious next step, it took many years to develop such a microscope that was practical. This was due to the instability of the FE current and the difficulty of achieving an UHV of the order of 108 Pa.
128
Hiromi Inada et al.
FE tip V1 1st anode
V0
2nd anode
FIGURE 1
Schematic diagram of FE gun with Butler electrode lens.
TABLE 1 Characteristics of Emitters
Source brightness Source size Energy spread Temperature Vacuum pressure Lifetime
Field emission W<310>
Thermionic emission (Tungsten filament)
109 A/cm2 sr 5–10 nm 0.3 (eV) 300 K (R.T.) <10–8 Pa 1 year
5 105 A/cm2 sr 1–10 m 2 (eV) 2800 K <10–3 Pa 50 hours
3. COLD FE-SEM STUDIES AND EXPANSION TO DIFFERENT FIELDS 3.1. CFE-STEM Development at HCRL In 1968, a group at HCRL organized by T. Komoda began developing a CFE-STEM (Komoda et al., 1972). The prototype CFE-STEM consisted of (i) a gun chamber evacuated to 1 108 Pa and separated from the microscope column by a differential aperture and (ii) a microscope column evacuated to 3 105 Pa. A Butler FE gun and two stages of electromagnetic lenses (Figure 2) produced a convergent beam on the
Field emission gun
Aperture
Ion-pump (1) 2 ⫻ 10−10 torr Ion-pump (2) 5 ⫻ 10−8 torr
Condenser lens (stigmator) Objective lens (deflector) Ion-pump (3) Specimen stage Detector (P.M. tube)
FIGURE 2
1 ⫻ 10−6 torr
(Left) Schematic diagram of FE-STEM developed at HCRL and (right) general view of Hitachi’s first FE-STEM.
130
Hiromi Inada et al.
specimen when an acceleration voltage of 50 kV and an extraction voltage of 5 kV were applied. A tungsten <310>-oriented FE tip in NaOH electropolished was used as an electron source. Komoda’s group developed a pulsed power supply to stabilize the polishing and thereby maintain the quality of the FE tip. They calculated the electron path and aberrations with a microcomputer to optimize the Butler lens to machine it more precisely and thus minimize spherical aberration (Tonomura, 1973). Ultimately, a brightness of 5 108 A/cm2 was obtained. A side-entry specimen stage holding the specimen, a movable aperture, and a cold finger were inserted into the 6.5-mm gap in the objective lens pole piece, which had a bore of 2 mm. A transmission electron detector consisting of a phosphor and a photomultiplier was placed at the bottom of the microscope column. A contrast aperture was inserted immediately above the detector to control the detection angle and to produce three kinds of contrast. Crewe and Wall (1970c) and Zeitler (Zeitler et al., 1970a,b) asserted that a bright-field (BF) STEM image is equivalent to a conventional TEM image by reciprocity. The use of a contrast aperture resulted in (i) a BF-STEM detection angle of less than 10 mrad without elastic scattered electrons, (ii) a phase contrast of less than 2 mrad, producing a small illumination angle TEM image, and (iii) a dark-field (DF) STEM detection angle of more than 10 mrad, enabling detection of elastic scattered electrons. Hitachi achieved a resolution of 1 nm with their instrument and observed BF and DF contrast reversal of evaporated Au particles, the equal-thickness fringe of MgO single crystals, and a microtome tissue section (Figure 3) that clearly indicates a double-cell membrane.
FIGURE 3 Tissue section of biological specimen showing double-layered structure of cell membrane.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
131
3.2. CFE-SEM Development at Naka Works Another FE project had been started by the Naka Works. A team led by S. Saito had the goal of producing an FE-SEM capable of secondary electron (SE) detection. This goal was set because the market and target were clear and because no one had achieved very fine feature analysis (on the order of 3 nm) for biological studies. The resolution available with tungsten-filament SEMs (10 nm) was insufficient. However, most electron microscopes produced in the 1970s were for biology, and scientists were looking for impressively beautiful electron micrographs. Hence, these were obviously tough years for scanning microscopes, which produced rough pixel images that were unacceptable to most scientists. Saito was dispatched to Perkin-Elmer Ultek Inc. to learn about and investigate UHV technologies for practical use, and they introduced. In 1970, Hitachi Naka Works invited Crewe to serve as a consultant to Hitachi and assist with the development of a CFE-SEM for two years. The Naka engineers brought a drawing board to a conference room to help them concentrate on working closely with Crewe to design a new concept microscope (Figure 4). They eventually succeeded in developing the world’s first commercialized CFE-SEM, model HFS-2, in 1972 (Komoda and Saito, 1972b) (Figure 5). It had an aberration-optimized Butler lens, a variable acceleration voltage of 1–25 kV, and resolution of 3 nm. The microscope column was separated into three chambers by using differential pumping apertures, and the chambers were pumped with individual ion pumps. The CFEG maintained a vacuum pressure of 108 Pa even when the pressure in the specimen chamber was 103 Pa. For longer running time, two FE tips were inserted into the gun, which eliminated the need to vent the gun chamber. The column had a single stage condenser lens and an objective lens, enabling the illuminating electron beam
FIGURE 4 Photograph taken at meeting with Professor Crewe of Chicago University and Hitachi colleagues during his consultancy (1972).
132
Hiromi Inada et al.
FIGURE 5
Hitachi’s first commercial FE-SEM (model HFS-2).
to be varied widely in size, resulting in a probe size of 2–20 nm and a probe current of 10 pA to 2 nA. This CFE-SEM has been installed in major biology research facilities. Collaborative work with K. Tanaka of Tottori University led to the development of instruments with much higher resolution. Since then the resolution and FE stability of CFE-SEMs have continued to be improved (Figure 6). Thanks to the development of an in-lens pole-piece design, CFE-SEMs now have much higher resolution (<1 nm), and a recent CFE-SEM (model S-5500), which has an environment-resistant design, has a resolution of 0.4 nm in SE image (Figure 7).
3.3. Studies of Field Emission Stability The biggest problem in applying CFE technology to microscopes is improving FE stability and operation. It is not an exaggeration to state that progress in CFE technology is equivalent to progress in UHV technology. The improvements made include automatic V0/V1 ratio control for the Butler lens, noise reduction for the electronics, and beam monitor incorporation for user operation of the sophisticated FE technique. The FE current fluctuates, and instability of the emission current increases with the probe current. This instability is one of the problems that must be overcome for FE technology to be used practically. Figure 8 illustrates the general behavior of the FE current as a function of time after flashing. Flashing the FE tip causes gas molecules on the tip surface to desorb and smooths the surface. An extraction voltage (V1) of 2–5 kV is then applied to obtain a total emission current of 1–100 A. Immediately after flashing, the FE current decreases as a gas monolayer builds up on the emitter surface. Stable region, relatively flat emission
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
133
500 Å
T2-bacterio phage ; taken by ultra high resolution SEM, model HFS-2 (Prof.A.V.Crewe, Chicago University, U.S.A, 1972)
T2-bacterio phage ; taken by ultra high resolution SEM, model UHS-t1 (Prof.K.Tanaka, Tottori University, Japan) (1988)
FIGURE 6 Secondary electron micrograph image comparison of T2 bacteriophage, recorded with HFS-2 (left, in 1972) and with prototype in-lens–type FE-SEM for Professor Tanaka at Tottori University (right, in 1988).
16
HSM-2
14 Thermionic electron SEMs SEM resolution (nm)
12 10
HSM-2A
8 6
HFS-2 (5 nm)
4
Field emission SEMs
S-700
S-800
2
S-900 0 1960
1970
1980
S-5000 S-5200 S-5500 1990
2000
2010
Year
FIGURE 7 Progress in image resolution of Hitachi FE-SEMs. The resolution of an early thermionic gun is plotted for comparison. Spatial resolution improved to sub-nanometer order with introduction of model S-900 due to incorporating in-lens design optics.
Hiromi Inada et al.
Emitter destroyed by vacuum arc
Emission current
IE
134
Current decreasing due to adsorption
Current increasing due to ion bombardment
IMIN Time Flashing
Cyclical lifetime
FIGURE 8 General behavior of field emission current as a function of time after flashing (Shimoyama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989).
current flows; however, continuous absorbing, desorbing, and migration of gas molecules occurs on the emitter surface; this derives FE noise, which is very fast random current fluctuation. After the region is kept stable for several hours (<10 hours), the FE current rises with a large fluctuation, which possibly destroys the tip. The emission current decreases as a function of the work function of the absorbing gas in accordance with Eq. (4.1). H. Todokoro et al. (Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982) of HCRL investigated the fluctuations in the FE current with the vacuum pressure of the FE gun and experimentally found that current stability is affected by ion bombardment of the FE source. The experiments were done using a vacuum chamber equipped with two FE guns (A and B). Gun A had a single FE tip and was used to record the total emission current under various vacuum pressures. The relative fluctuation, DI/I, as a function of the product of the pressure and emission current (P I) is shown in Figure 9. It is proportional to the logarithm of P I above 7 1012 PaA. This indicates that the fluctuation increase is caused by ion bombardment of the residual gas molecules. This fluctuation represents a function of P I, not of I. Below 7 1012 PaA, the relative fluctuation is less than 1% and constant, probably due to migration of the absorbed gas molecules on the FE tip surface. The results of this experiment show that FE current fluctuation caused by ion bombardment increases when the product of pressure and emission current exceeds a threshold. Gun B had two emitters 5 mm apart that were supplied with individual high voltages simultaneously to verify the origin of the ions (Figure 10). Emitter I emitted a current ranging from 5 to 250 A, and emitter II emitted a constant current of 5 A. As Figure 11 shows, the emission fluctuation of emitter II was maintained despite the very close placement of the emitters
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
135
15 4 ⫻ 10−8 Pa −7 4.5 ⫻ 10 Pa 1 ⫻ 10−6 Pa −6 4.5 ⫻ 10 Pa DI∞/I∞(%)
10
5
0
10−13
10−12
10−11 P ⫻ I∞(Pa.A)
10−10
10−9
FIGURE 9 Relative emission fluctuation as a function of product of gun pressure and total emission current. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982.
and their sharing of the same ambient gas pressure. This shows that the bombarding ions are generated close to the emitters. H. Shimoyama described the history of improvements in emission current (Shimovama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989). For example, the total emission current steadily increased year by year due to improvements in vacuum technology, surface treatment, and reproductive FE tips. For instance, the emission current obtained was only a few microamperes in the 1970s compared with 100 A in the 1980s. A small desktop FE-SEM (model S-310) (Figure 12, W400 D500 H500 mm, released in 1976) sparked the idea for a critical dimension (CD)-SEM. The CD-SEM used a simple optics CFEG and a single objective lens, and it had a resolution of 10 nm in TV rate scanning. The gun had a single-electrode design, and the acceleration voltage was the same as the extraction voltage (4–6 kV). This microscope had an emission current (20 A) 10 times higher than previous microscopes, resulting in improved spatial resolution of quickly scanned images. Accordingly, it was an important breakthrough for improving FE stability and emitting a higher FE current. The model S-310 microscope was suitable for nonconductive specimens, such as cloth and semiconductor devices without charge-up, because of its low acceleration voltage. It nevertheless did not meet customer needs at that time (the late 1970s) because most users apparently expected beautiful art-like electron microscope images. It was better
Hiromi Inada et al.
136
V1
V1⬘
REC. REC.
Emitter I
Emitter II
Anode
1 cm
FIGURE 10 Experimental apparatus of Gun B. Two FE tips were placed face to face and had the same anode distance of 10 mm. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982. Emitter I
1.1 1.0
5 mA
10 mA
50 mA
100 mA
250 mA
0.9
1 min 3 ⫻ 10−7 Pa 1.1 Emitter II 1.0 5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
0.9
FIGURE 11 Emission current fluctuations for two simultaneously operating FE tips obtained using different emission currents. Emitter I had emission current of 5 A to 250 A, whereas emitter II was controlled to emit a constant 5 A. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
137
FIGURE 12 Overview of desktop S-310 FE-SEM, which is now displayed in the reception area of Hitachi High Technologies America.
suited for the early 21st century when there was a boom in interest for small SEMs. The S-310 low-kilovolt microscope, on the other hand, gave an essential for semiconductor device in line dedicated CD-SEM.
4. EXPANSION OF HIGH-VOLTAGE TEMs AND STEMs 4.1. Holography Studies by Tonomura with FE-TEMs Researchers at HCRL had an idea for using FE guns on TEMs at the very beginning of CFE-STEM development. TEM resolution had improved drastically through the 1970s under the heat of competition, and the ultimate resolution had been reached with conventional TEM. Gabor invented holography in 1948 (Gabor, 1949) to compensate for spherical aberration. Although A. Tonomura et al. (1968) proved the practicability of electron holography in their pioneering work using Hibi’s pointed filament (Hibi, 1956) in 1968, the resolution of the reconstructed image was not satisfactory due to poor electron beam interference. Tonomura et al. developed, in 1972, with Butler lens FE source as a gun applicable of acceleration voltage of 50 kV, for electron holography (Figure 13) (Tonomura and Komoda, 1973). They developed an 80-kV CFE-TEM with higher coherency in 1978 and obtained as many as 3000 lines of Fresnel fringes (Tonomura et al., 1979b) compared with the 300 fringes obtained up until then, and thereby ensured the realization of practical electron holography. The lattice resolution was improved to 0.062 nm due to a chromatic aberration effect. The Aharonov–Bohm effect was proven experimentally in 1982 (Tonomura et al., 1979b, 1982, 1998) with
138
Hiromi Inada et al.
FIGURE 13
Overview of 50-kV FE-TEM (Tonomura, 1972).
the 80-kV CFE-TEM. They also studied the use of holography using a 1-MeV CFE-TEM (Kawasaki et al., 2000) at Hitachi’s Advanced Research Laboratory and investigated the dynamics of vortices (magnetic-flux quanta) in high– transition temperature (Tc) superconductors. Using this 1-MeV CFE-TEM, they obtained 10,000 Fresnel fringes and a lattice resolution of 0.049 nm.
4.2. Multistage Acceleration CFEG for TEM Applications Many remarkable CFE-TEM experiments have been done with the 80-kV CFE-TEM at HCRL; however, it was difficult to exceed an acceleration voltage of 80 kV with the Butler lens electron gun because of discharge between the emitter and electrodes. Endo of HCRL and his group developed a multistage electrode gun that produced an acceleration voltage of 125 kV to improve coherency and resolution. The distance between the emitter and ground electrode in the multistage electrode gun was
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
139
Insulator housing
Field emission tip Electrodes Insulator
FIGURE 14 Cross-sectional image of FE gun with multistage acceleration tube (Tonomura, 1984).
approximately 10 times that in the Butler lens gun (Tonomura, 1984) (Figure 14). This new CFEG produced a total emission current of 100 A and a consequent probe current of 8 nA. This gun incorporated countermeasures against outside magnetic fields. Extra care was needed when mounting the FE tip because of its tall design. This multistage electron gun was used not only for electron holography studies (Tonomura et al., 1982) but also for 100-kV analytical CFE-TEM (Koreeda et al., 1990).
4.3. Commercialized Analytical CFE-TEM/STEM Tomita and Naka Works designers developed the first analytical CFETEM (model H-600FE) equipped with an energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectrometer and an electron energy-loss spectrometer (EELS) analyzer. It was installed at Osaka University in 1986. This TEM used a multistage electrode gun to produce 100 kV. It had SE and two STEM detectors and a maximum specimen tilt angle of 60 , and it had a lattice resolution of 0.14 nm and an STEM resolution of 1 nm (Koreeda et al., 1990) (Figure 15). An energy spread of 1 eV was obtained with a serial EELS designed by S. Isakozawa of the Naka Works.
Electron microscope column (FE-Gun)
Energy dispersive X-ray micro analysis C-F discri
SEM. det.
EDX. det. Def. coil
SEM. image
0 I P1 P2
EELS. control EELS. det Slit
STEM. det
Ratemeter
FIGURE 15 (Left) Side view 100-kV field emission analytical TEM/STEM (H-600FE) installed at Osaka University. (Right) Schematic diagram of H600FE with analytical tools (SEM, EDS, and EELS detectors) (Koreeda et al., 1990).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
141
5. DEVELOPMENT OF 50-KV STEM IN 1970S (BY SHIGETO ISAKOZAWA) 5.1. Development of Hitachi’s 50kV Prototype CFE-STEM The basic design for Hitachi’s 50-kV CFE-STEM was developed by S. Nomura and H. Todokoro at HCRL. S. Saito, Y. Minamikawa, and Kakiuchi at Naka Works worked on the detailed designs and the production of a prototype. Table 2 shows the specifications of the FE-STEM prototype. Figure 16 shows a schematic diagram of the basic design. A CFE cathode is used for the electron source. Condenser and objective lenses demagnify the electron beam, which is accelerated to 50 kV to form a spot with a diameter of 0.3 nm on the specimen. To meet the requirements for high-resolution observation, the specimen stage was designed on the basis of a TEM specimen stage. Specimens have to be thin sections and are placed on a 3-mm diameter grid. Forward-scattering electrons are detected with an annular dark-field (ADF) detector. The electron intensity detected by the detector is displayed on a cathode ray tube (CRT). As the driving signals of the CRT are synchronized with the raster scan signals, the arrangement of the electron intensity signals forms a DF-STEM image. UHV technologies were not well established in the 1970s, so the reliability of CFE sources was sufficient only for obtaining several microamperes of emission current for only a few hours with a 50-kV acceleration voltage. Nevertheless, this was good enough to observe a single atom. Much work was undertaken by Nomura and Todokoro to improve
TABLE 2
Specifications of the prototype FE-STEM
Item
Resolution Maximum acceleration voltage Maximum magnification Gun type Time for exchanging specimen Vacuum evacuation system
Column structure Electron optics
Specifications
0.3 nm 50 kV 10,000,000 Cold-field emission 10 minutes Three-stage differential pumping system Ion pump (60 L/sec, 20 L/sec, 150 L/sec) Components connected with metal gaskets Illuminating, objective, projection lenses
142
Hiromi Inada et al.
Field emission gun
CRT for display
Probe forming lens
X ray detector
Specimen
Electron detector(A) Electron energy loss spectrometer
Slit
Electron detector(B) (B)
FIGURE 16
Concept of FE-STEM by Nomura.
stage stability, reduce noise from the scan coil current, reduce specimen contamination, and so on. They were then able to obtain high-resolution STEM images. They also invented new techniques—for example, a specimen exchange method to evacuate air with a sorption pump and then insert it into the UHV chamber. Development of the 50-kV CFE-STEM was completed in 1975. Figure 17 shows an overall view of the CFE-STEM developed by Hitachi. Note that an EELS was mounted on the bottom of the microscope column. The basic design concept enabled not only single-atom observation, but also element analysis with atomic spatial resolution.
5.2. Bright-Field Images Obtained with 50-kV CFE-STEM Figures 18 and 19 show lattice fringes of carbon graphite and single-crystal Au film acquired to confirm the mechanical and electrical stabilities and probe size of the FE-STEM prototype. As the reciprocity relationship between conventional TEM (CTEM) and STEM had been studied at HCRL, it was well known that crystal lattice fringes could be obtained with BF-STEM exactly like those obtained with CTEM. The BF-STEM images in Figures 18 and 19 clearly show that crystal lattices with spacings of 0.34 and 0.20 nm can be observed. This means that the electron beam spot size was 0.3 nm or less and that the instrument was stable enough to obtain atomic resolution. The image in Figure 19 is certainly the first example of observing lattice fringes with spacing of 0.2 nm using BF-STEM.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 17
General view of FE-STEM.
4Å
3.
FIGURE 18 Lattice fringe of carbon graphite (bright-field image).
3 nm
FIGURE 19
A 0.2-nm lattice fringe of single-crystal Au (bright-field image).
143
144
Hiromi Inada et al.
5.3. Single-Atom Observation The intensities of electrons elastically scattered from 2-nm-thick carbon and from thorium single atoms were calculated by Nomura. The acceleration voltage was assumed to be 100 kV, and the electron beam spot size was assumed to be 0.3 nm. Figure 20 shows the relationship between the intensities of the scattered electrons and the scattering angle. It shows that electrons scattered from a thorium atom are distributed at a higher angle than carbon atoms and that their intensity is higher even at a scattering angle of 150 mrad or higher. DF imaging using CTEM, which uses a narrower range of scattering angles (less than 10 or at most 30 mrad), cannot achieve efficient detection. DF-STEM imaging with an ADF detector (which covers from 20–200 mrad) can drastically improve detection efficiency. The calculated relationship between atom image contrast and electron probe diameter is plotted for three probe sizes in Figure 21. Image contrast is defined as Iz/Ic, where Ic is the signal intensity from the carbon atoms supporting the thin film, and Iz is the signal intensity from the summation of a single atom and its supporting carbon. Taking the statistical variation in the number of carbon atoms in the supporting film into consideration, we can observe a single atom if the image contrast is higher than 1.5 (broken line). The smaller the probe diameter, the higher the image contrast. In reality, a signal intensity of 10–12 A or more is needed to obtain images with a better signal to noise ratio (SNR). If the ratio of detected
(I/I0)
Scattered electrons intensities
0.20
0.15
A thorium atom
0.10
0.05
Carbon film
(15 C atoms)
0 0
50
100 (mrad.) Scattered angle
150
FIGURE 20 Intensity angular distribution of scattered electrons (calculated by Nomura).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
145
4.0
3.0 Contrast
ize
es
b Pro
2.0
5Å 10Å
1.0
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number
FIGURE 21
Atom observation contrast dependence on probe size (calculation). 100 I0=1 ⫻ 10−10A 100 kV
(Å) 10
Wgun W
5
106
FE gun
1
F E
LaB6 LaB6gun
Electorn probe diameter
50
108 107 (A/cm2.sr.) Brightness
109
FIGURE 22 Relationship between probe size and brightness of electron gun for 1 1010 A probe current.
electrons scattered by a single atom to the incident electrons is 1%, the probe current must be 1010 A or larger. For a probe current of 1010 A, the relationship between probe size and electron gun brightness is as plotted in Figure 22. It shows that an FE gun must have a probe diameter of 0.5 nm or less. Specimen contamination was a serious problem. Magnification must be set to several million times to obtain images of single atoms. The STEM images became increasingly brighter trial by trial and eventually became completely white due to specimen contamination.
146
Hiromi Inada et al.
An anti-contaminator for the TEM was introduced to reduce the residual gas pressure surrounding the specimen, but no significant improvements were obtained. When a crystal lattice image is taken with a TEM, the area of interest is illuminated with an electron beam several micrometers in diameter. The image is recorded on a sheet of film at several hundred thousand times magnification and then magnified even more with an optical enlarger when the image is printed on photographic paper. The final image must be displayed on a CRT in the case of STEM. At several million times magnification, which is necessary for atomic resolution observations, a very small area of interest (several tens of nanometers) is scanned with an extremely fine electron probe. Therefore, specimen contamination in STEM is much worse than in TEM as the size of the target area is smaller by a magnitude of four. The ultimate answer to this problem was to illuminate an electron beam on the surrounding area of interest (i.e., on a wider raster scan area) at a lower magnification and a higher density for a longer time (20–30 minutes) before observation. This preliminary irradiation thins the contaminants in an area wider than the area of interest, which reduces their effect on the imaging. The effects of this preliminary irradiation last for 10 to 20 minutes. Schematic diagrams of the STEM detecting conditions are shown in Figure 23. Condition A is equivalent to the usual conditions for DF image observation with CTEM using the tilted-beam illumination technique. Condition B1 corresponds to the maximum illumination solid angle with CTEM. Condition B2 corresponds to the large angle (up to 60 mrad) obtainable only with STEM. Photographs of a thin carbon film (2-nm thick) taken under each of these detection conditions are shown in Figure 24. High-contrast spots are almost negligible under condition B2 but they still remain under condition B1. These results suggest that high-contrast spots in carbon film images are due to the interference of scattered electron waves and that they can be removed only by increasing the detector solid angle to 60 mrad. (A)
(B1)
9mrad
9mrad 9mrad
18mrad
(B2) 9mrad 60 mrad
9mrad 9 mrad 18mrad
FIGURE 23
Schematic diagrams of STEM detecting conditions.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
(A)
(B1)
147
(B2)
10 nm
FIGURE 24 Dark-field images of carbon film (2-nm thick) captured under respective detection conditions of Figure 23.
5 nm
FIGURE 25
Dark-field image of carbon film approximately 2-nm thick.
The DF image of carbon obtained under condition B2, in which only the thickness contrast is observed, is shown in Figure 25. A droplet of thorium nitrate in 105 molar CH3OH solution was placed on this film. The image was observed using STEM. As shown in Figure 26, bright spots and spot clusters were observed. The individual bright spots were nearly the same size as the spots making up the spot clusters. Single atoms of thorium made those spots (Todokoro, Nomura, and Komoda, 1977).
5.4. Development of the Electron Energy-Loss Spectrometer In the 1970s, electron probe microanalyzers were used to analyze the elements in small targets. However, they were unable to detect Na or lighter elements (C, O, N, etc.), and characteristic X-ray signals from light elements could not be detected. The efficiency of signal acquisition is defined as detected signal intensity divided by illuminating electron
148
Hiromi Inada et al.
5 nm
FIGURE 26
Dark-field image of thorium atoms on carbon film.
intensity. The amount of detected characteristic X-ray signals is limited by the fluorescence yield and the detector solid angle. With EELS, the inelastic scattering electrons that cause inner shell excitations are distributed over a smaller scattering angle and are directly detected by the spectrometer. EELS was thus expected to be suitable for atomic resolution analysis because of its highly efficient signal acquisition and unlimited ability to detect lighter elements. In 1976 Nomura and Todokoro developed an EELS that could be attached to an FE-STEM. It was a magnetic sector type with a trajectory radius of 11 cm. The target energy resolution was 0.5 eV at 50 kV. The detection system was the serial type, composed of a slit, a scintillator, and a photo-multiplying tube. The energy-loss spectra were recorded with a chart recorder. A photograph of the prototype EELS mounted under the FE-STEM column is shown in Figure 27. Although EELS research was well under way, this attachment of an EELS to an FE-STEM was one of the earliest, and the fundamentals of the analytical STEM concept were established by this work. Figure 28 shows the analytical energy-loss spectrum results for boron nitride particles with a diameter of 20 nm supported on thin carbon film. Figure 28a shows an STEM image taken when electrons without energy loss were used; it is a ‘‘no-loss image.’’ Figure 28b shows an energy-filtered STEM image taken when electrons with an energy loss of 190–210 eV were used. This loss corresponds to the energy loss of boron K-shell excitation. Figure 28c shows line analysis of 190–210 eV. Figure 28d shows the electron energy-loss spectrum taken when the electron probe was focused on a boron nitride particle. The K-shell excitation edges of boron (B), nitrogen (N), and carbon (C) from the supporting film are evident in the spectrum.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 27
149
Developed EELS equipped with STEM.
Estimating that the probe diameter was 1 nm and that the diameter of the boron nitride was 20 nm, Nomura concluded that 7 1021 g of boron and 9 1021 g of nitrogen were detected.
5.5. Further Development of 50-kV CFE-STEM Many research institutes and laboratories with electron microscopes attempted to duplicate Crewe’s observation of single atoms, but only HCRL was able to do so, using the FE-STEM developed by Komoda, Nomura, and Todokoro. This prototype STEM was equipped with the most advanced technologies at that time, such as a CFEG, producing a UHV, a highly stable electronic power supply, and electron optics with atomic resolution performance. Moreover, this FE-STEM had the Hitachi-made EELS and a nondispersive X-ray detector and thus was the origin of the present analytical STEM concept. HCRL contributed to the development of the most advanced technologies for electron microscopes, and Hitachi’s Naka Works was
150
Hiromi Inada et al.
(d)
(a)
⫻1000
Relative intensity
B,K
(b)
200Å
⫻100 C,K
N,K
⫻10
(c) 0
300 Energy loss (eV)
600
FIGURE 28 Analytical results of boron nitride using EELS. (a) d ¼ 0 eV, no-loss image. (b) d ¼ 190–210 eV, energy-filtered image. (c) Line analysis of d ¼ 190–210 eV. (d) Energy loss spectrum.
responsible for commercializing and producing them. Commercialization of a dedicated FE-STEM based on this concept was suspended after many discussions and meetings because the market was mostly demanding TEMs at that time.
6. HITACHI’S FIRST COMMERCIALIZED DEDICATED STEM (BY TAKAHITO HASHIMOTO) 6.1. 200-kV Analytical CFE-TEM, HF-2000 During the 1970s, Tonomura and his group at HCRL were competing to achieve the best TEM image resolution. They expected a breakthrough when they applied electron holography to a TEM. The spherical aberration of the TEM objective lens determines the image resolution, and electron holography is an imaging method that does not suffer the effects
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
151
of spherical aberration because it does not use a lens. They also developed an electron gun with high brightness, which is essential for obtaining high-quality holograms. The FE-TEM they developed in 1978 is shown in Figure 29. The result was improved TEM image resolution. They obtained the highest image resolution ever obtained until then: lattice fringes of Ni (220) with half spacing (0.062 nm). Using electron holography, Tonomura’s group investigated spherical aberration correction for high-resolution imaging (Tonomura et al., 1979a), observed magnetic domains (Tonomura, et al., 1980), observed magnetic fields (Matsuda et al., 1982), and investigated magnetization of recording media (Osakabe et al., 1983). Using phase-shift amplified-interference electron microscopy, they measured the thickness of the recording media (Endo et al., 1984). In 1986, they used electron holography to confirm the existence of the Aharonov–Bohm effect (Osakabe et al., 1986; Tonomura et al., 1986).
FIGURE 29
FE-TEM developed by Hitachi CRL.
152
Hiromi Inada et al.
Work on high-voltage FEG technologies was transferred to Hitachi’s Naka Works. In 1983 Hitachi delivered a custom-made 100-kV analytical FE-TEM (model H-600FE) (Kamino and Tomita, 1983). It had outstanding analytical performance, especially in terms of spatial resolution. Electron probes with a diameter of 5 nm or less were available. Their probe current for EDX or EELS analysis was 10 times larger than the LaB6 gun model, and the illumination angle for nano-probe electron diffraction was one-tenth that of the LaB6 gun model. Advancement in the performance of commercial 200-kV TEMs began to slow in the early 1980s because their resolution had almost reached the theoretical limit. The makers of 200-kV TEMs were in a dead heat. One approach to further improvement was to increase the acceleration voltage. From 1984 to 1986, JEOL Ltd. released a series of 400-kV TEMs (the JEM-4000 series). In 1986 Hitachi released a 300-kV TEM (model H-9000). The TEM competitors were still in a dead heat. Hitachi’s engineers decided to develop a new model with something so special that competitors would not be able to catch up. The key technology for the hoped-for breakthrough was the field emission gun (FEG). With the aim of enabling new applications of electron holography and practical nanoanalysis, Hitachi launched a project to develop a new model. Two researchers, M. Ichihashi and H. Murakoshi, moved from HCRL to Naka Works to work on developing a mass-production 200-kV FEG. The result was the development of a 200-kV FE-TEM (model HF-2000) (Isakozawa et al., 1989). This model, shown in Figure 30, was an epochmaking instrument in electron microscopy. Its nano-probe illumination performance with enough (several hundred nanoamperes) beam current, smaller (<0.4 eV) energy spread, and better beam coherency enabled many applications that were previously impossible. Many universities, research institutes, and laboratories used this model to analyze precipitates in steel (Hashimoto et al., 1991), the concentration of elements on stacking faults (Kamino et al., 1992), the metal particles on catalysts, the electronic states of semiconductors, and the stoichiometry of insulator oxides. In addition to Tonomura’s group, D. Joy, L. Allard and E. Vo¨lkl made extensive holographic studies of ferroelectric domain walls (Zhang et al., 1993; Vo¨lkl et al., 1999), p-n junctions, and semiconductor device dopant profiles. Steeds at Bristol University obtained the first convergentbeam–coherent electron diffraction pattern (Vine et al., 1992). In 1992 the first 300-kV FE-TEM (Murakoshi, Ichihashi, and Kakibayashi, 1992) was developed by researchers at HCRL. Technologies developed for the prototype were transferred to the production model (HF-3000) (Figure 31). Philips introduced an FE-TEM in 1990 (the CM-20 FEG), and JEOL released a new FE-TEM in 1992 (the JEM-2010 F). Both models were equipped with a Schottky emission gun (SEG). Most of Hitachi’s TEMs
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 30 200-kV FE-TEM (HF-2000).
FIGURE 31
300-kV FE-TEM (HF-3000).
153
154
Hiromi Inada et al.
used a high-angle takeoff EDX geometry with a takeoff angle of 68 and a detection solid angle of 0.033 sr. Competitors used a lower-angle takeoff geometry (20–25 ) and a solid angle of 0.13 sr. The higher the takeoff angle, the better the reproducibility of the EDX analysis results. The higher the takeoff angle, the shorter the X-ray path length in the specimen, resulting in reduced absorption in the specimen, especially for characteristic X-rays from light elements such as oxygen. This characteristic enables flexible positioning and orientation of the specimen, which ensures highly reproducible analysis. Although the probe current of the FEG is several times higher than that of the SEG, the analytical sensitivity of the total system was only half that of competitive models because the detection solid angle was one-quarter that of theirs. The HF-2000 thus started losing competitiveness. STEM performance was another weak point. An objective lens using a high-angle takeoff geometry must have a larger upper polepiece bore to enable the X-ray signal to pass through. Therefore, its prefield lens is relatively weaker. The guaranteed smallest probe size of the HF-2000 was a diameter of 1 nm. This was small enough for EDX analysis and STEM observation with a maximum magnification of several hundred thousand times but was too large to obtain atomic-resolution STEM images.
6.2. ‘‘Gate Viewer,’’ Trigger for Dedicated STEM The weakness of the HF-2000 led Hitachi to start developing a new model. Initially, the project leader, Isakozawa, planned to create a ‘‘super FE-TEM.’’ It would have the largest detection solid angle among all commercial TEM models and atomic-resolution STEM capability. In the mid-1990s, the design rule for semiconductor research and development was 250 to 180 nm. FE-SEMs were widely used for confirming process validity and identifying the causes of failures and defects. SEMs were used by individuals such as device researchers, materials scientists, and electronics engineers. Most FE-SEMs in those days already had sufficient resolution (less than several nanometers) even at an acceleration voltage of 1 kV or lower and had an autofocusing function. Specimens were prepared relatively easily with cleaving silicon tips. Semiconductor companies, of course, had TEMs. TEM image resolution had already reached the sub-nanometer range, but specimen preparation, instrument operation, and image interpretation were very difficult compared with those of SEMs. In many cases, only handfuls of ‘‘expert operators’’ were allowed to use TEMs, and the time required to obtain investigation results could range from several days to a full week. This was too slow for the decisionmaking stage for establishing the process for next-generation devices. The manager of Hitachi’s Marketing Division, M. Kato, suggested to the design team that the semiconductor industry wanted electron microscopes with TEM-like image resolution and SEM-like ease of use. He knew that
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
155
such an instrument would have to be newly developed and he called it ‘‘Gate Viewer.’’ The thickness of the gate oxide layer in large-scale integrated circuits was already only several tens of nanometers and would reach 2 nm by 2000 (Committee of Semiconductor Technology, 1999). To measure a scale of 2 nm, the image resolution must be better than one-tenth the scale: 0.2 nm. Due to the strong edge effect, SEs from the substrate and gate electrode make it impossible to observe the gate oxide layer, even if a small probe were achieved. Only a TEM or an FE-STEM could achieve such a small resolution. Compared with TEMs, STEMs are advantageous in terms of the precision of the magnification setting because the number of components that need tuning is smaller. Precise magnification enables accurate measurement of the dimensions in images. Hitachi had accumulated experience in critical dimension (CD)-measurement SEMs, and even general-purpose FE-SEMs had a CD-measurement function in those days. For STEMs, the preparation of a thin specimen seemed to be the bottleneck, as it was for TEMs, but the focused ion beam (FIB) instrument (model FB-2000) that had become prevalent enabled fabrication of thin specimens with a specific area and a specific thickness without exceptional skill (Ishitani et al., 1994). A dedicated FE-STEM has the potential to be such an instrument, fulfilling the concept of the Gate Viewer, and so it was chosen as the basis of the new model. Development of the Gate Viewer FE-STEM (model HD-2000) began in the fall of 1995. It featured several advantages: (i) atomic-resolution imaging, (ii) the highest EDX sensitivity, (iii) multisignal reception from specimen, (iv) an FIB-compatible specimen holder, and (v) easy operation. Figure 32 shows the configuration of the HD-2000. The FEG was basically the same as that of the HF-2000, and several improvements and modifications to the microscope had increased reliability and productivity. The illumination lens system, composed of double-stage condenser lenses and an objective lens, was newly designed. A condenser-objective objective lens with a small spherical aberration coefficient was used so that a 0.2-nm or smaller probe could be used and that an EDX detector with the largest detection solid angle among all TEM models could be accommodated. For seamless operation with lower magnification, a scan coil with a larger inner diameter was used. A projector lens was used to select the detection angle for BF-STEM and DF-STEM. An Everhart– Thornley SE detector, a BF-STEM detector, and a DF-STEM detector were included in the standard configuration. There were several auxiliary ports for mounting a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera to be used for observing electron diffraction patterns and ronchigrams and for mounting an EELS on the lower column. The high-resolution FE-SEM in late ’90s was controlled with a scan generator, an image processor, and a personal computer. A scan generator with a low electrical noise level was initially used. As with an SEM,
156
Hiromi Inada et al.
FE-gun
Condenser lens
SE detector EDX detector*
Scan coil
Objective lens
Specimen
Scattered electron
Display
Projector lens DF-STEM detector
Retractabl Retractabl
Image sensor*
(CCD camera) BF-STEM detector
Transmission electron
SEM
DF-STEM
Scan generator Signal processor Control unit EDX analyzer
FIGURE 32 Configuration of Gate Viewer FE-STEM (HD-2000) (with optional EDX and charge-coupled device (CCD) camera).
higher magnification was achieved by reducing the amplitude of the scan coil current. However, this resulted in electrical noise. Pinstripe patterns, which the engineers thought were the very first BF-STEM lattice fringes, were caused by the electrical noise. The fringe spacing remained constant when the magnification was changed from 2 to 5 million times. A steady step-by-step improvement process was necessary to obtain actual lattice fringes. At the earliest stage of development, the prototype had a TEM lower column and a CCD camera for observing the spot size and directly setting the illumination angle. A ‘‘diffraction-limited’’ probe (Spence and Zuo, 1992) can be formed by demagnifying the electron source image. The optimum convergence angle, aOpt, for obtaining the smallest probe, dmin, is calculated from only the spherical aberration coefficient and electron wavelength (l), as shown in Eqs. (4.2) and (4.3) (Crewe, 1985).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
aOpt ¼
4l Cs
157
1=4 (4.2)
d min ¼ 0:43Cs1=4 l3=4
(4.3)
Figure 33 shows a TEM image of the smallest probe taken with an experimental TEM column in which the HD-2000 objective lens pole piece had been installed. The line profile of Figure 33 is shown in Figure 34. Measured probe
0.42 nm
FIGURE 33 Smallest measured probe.
Intensity (a.u.)
12
8 0.17 nm FWHM 4
0 −0.6
−0.4
FIGURE 34
−0.2 0.0 0.2 Distance (nm)
Line profile of Figure 33.
0.4
0.6
158
Hiromi Inada et al.
HD-2000 200 kV x 5000 k TE
FIGURE 35
6.00 nm
A BF-STEM image of thin single-crystal Au film taken with HD-2000.
The simulated full-width at half maximum (FWHM) with Cs ¼ 1.3 mm and the l at 200 kV ¼ 0.00251 nm was 0.17 nm, which is in good agreement with the theoretical value of 0.16 nm. Figure 35 shows an example of a BF-STEM image of thin single-crystal Au film. The smaller the probe, the smaller the probe current. A probe current of several tens of picoamperes (pA) is sufficient for STEM and SEM imaging. The smallest probe was achieved with this amount of probe current. For practical EDX analysis, a probe current of several hundreds of pA is necessary. Several illumination modes had to be fixed. The illumination modes were designed to have a constant illumination angle, aOpt, and a variable spot size and probe current. When the illumination angle is kept constant, probe size d can be approximately calculated using Eq. (4), 1 is the magnification of the where ds is the electron source size and M electron source image on the specimen. The contribution of chromatic aberration is negligible. sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 1 2 (4.4) ds d ffi dmin þ M A virtual source image is strongly demagnified in high-resolution mode, but the number of emitted electrons passing through the objective aperture is limited. In emissive mode, the virtual source image is moderately demagnified, and a larger number of electrons pass through the
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
159
Virtual source
C1 cross over
C1 lens C1 cross over C2 lens OBJ.AP. C2 cross over
OBJ lens Specimen Emissive mode
FIGURE 36
High resolution mode
Illumination modes. (Left) Emissive mode. (Right) High-resolution mode.
objective aperture (OBJ. A.P.). Figure 36 illustrates the differences in the ray diagrams for illumination modes. If the illumination angle at the specimen is kept constant, the typical probe size and probe current are f0.2 nm and 20 pA for high-resolution mode and f0.5 nm and 200 pA for emissive mode. Figure 37 shows a comparison of images formed with various detector signals. The specimen was a silicon device (a hemispherical grained capacitor test element group [TEG]) with a layer structure: SiO2 base layer, thick poly-Si layer with 100-nmf hemispherical bumps on the top side surface, thin Si3N4 layer, amorphous Si layer, and SiO2 top layer. The SEM image in Figure 37a shows the surface of a sectioned specimen. The BF-STEM image (37b) and DF-STEM image (37c) show cross-sectional views. The BF-STEM image is equivalent to a TEM image because of the reciprocal relationship between BF-STEM and TEM. A strong diffraction contrast is evident in the poly-Si layer. This characteristic can be used to distinguish crystalline areas or even crystal grains, but it can also make it difficult to interpret what is seen in the image. The DF-STEM uses scattered electrons, a larger atomic number (Z), a heavier density (r), or greater thickness (t). The diffraction contrast is averaged and moderated because a DF-STEM detector acquires all related diffracted waves. Especially with a larger scattering angle, the atomic number is the dominant factor affecting the contrast, so a DF-STEM image is often called a ‘‘Z-contrast image.’’ In image 37c, the substance with the largest density is
160
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b) SiN
a-Si
Poly-Si SiO2
100 nm (c) SiN
(semi-spherical grained capacitor TEG)
a-Si
Poly-Si SiO2
FIGURE 37 Images of Si device. (a) SEM, (b) BF-STEM, and (c) DF-STEM.
Si3N4 and the smallest is SiO2. The Si3N4 layer covering the poly-Si bumps is clearly evident. The amorphous and poly-Si layers have a similar contrast. Therefore, we can obtain much information about a specimen from SEM and STEM images. A. Ninomiya, an industrial designer in the Hitachi Design Division, drew a conceptual image of the HD-2000. He took into account that higher-resolution electron microscopes are generally installed in a quiet room on a stable floor in a small stray magnetic field without acoustic noise. These conditions are completely different from those of a clean room used for semiconductor fabrication; these rooms have a continuous downflow, noise from air conditioners and suction pumps, floor vibration with a frequency close to the resonance frequency of the HD-2000 with antivibration mounts, and so on. He thus designed the electron gun and microscope column to be covered with a permalloy shield and the EDX detector, evacuation pipes, and cables to be contained in an enclosure. As shown in Figure 38, the HD-2000 had a clean and photogenic appearance. In fact, it won the Good Design Award from the Japan Industrial Design Promotion Organization in 1998. The HD-2000 was released in 1998 (Hashimoto et al., 1998). A production model was exhibited at the 50th annual meeting of the Japanese Society of Microscopy. Installation was done over a weekend, and the machine was in operation during the entire exhibition period, displaying BF-STEM images of evaporated Au particle lattice fringes.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 38
161
Photograph of Gate Viewer FE-STEM (HD-2000).
6.3. Novel Functions for HD Series 6.3.1. Energy-Dispersive X-Ray An EDX detector with a solid angle of 0.3 sr was designed by S. Foote of Noran Instruments (now Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc.) soon after the objective lens design was completed. Achieving the highest EDX sensitivity is an extremely important development objective. This solid angle was 2.5 times larger than those of competitors and the largest among all commercial electron microscopes. The shielding parts were redesigned to eliminate iron and cobalt system peaks from the objective lens pole piece. The original shielding parts could stop only scattered electrons, not bremsstrahlung X-rays. Subsequently, several models of EDX systems (e.g., EDAX, Horiba, and Oxford systems) were released.
6.3.2. Diffraction The diffraction capabilities of FE-TEMs were emphasized as an advantage by the various competitors. Diffraction patterns can also be observed with a dedicated STEM. With a condenser-objective objective lens, a diffraction pattern is formed on the back focal plane and projected onto STEM detectors, as shown in Figure 39. In standard STEM observation or
162
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b) Incident beam Specimen Objective lens <= B.F.P. (diffraction pattern)
Transmission electron Simplified TEM
Actual TEM (d)
(c) Incident beam
(e) Objective lens pre-field
Objective lens Specimen
Objective lens post-field
Transmission electron
CBED pattern
Simplified STEM Actual STEM
FIGURE 39
Reduced convergence angle
BF-STEM CCD camera detector STEM nano diff. mode
Diffraction patterns formed in TEMs and STEMs.
analytical mode, the convergence angle is set to achieve the smallest possible probe size for a given probe current. Figure 40 shows the calculated relationship between the probe size and convergence angle of an electron beam for a constant probe current of 200 pA. The Cs of the objective lens was 1.3 mm, and l at 200 kV was 0.00251 nm. The probe size was calculated using the root mean square method with quadrature addition of the image size of the electron source on the specimen, the size of the disk of confusion by diffraction, and the spherical aberration. Figure 40 shows that the optimum convergence angle for the smallest probe at a probe current of 200 pA was 8 mrad. The diffraction pattern under this setting was the convergentbeam electron-diffraction pattern, as shown in Figure 41a. When the mode is ‘‘nano-diffraction’’ with a convergence angle of 1.5 mrad, the probe is larger than in the standard STEM mode. Nevertheless, the probe is still operational up to several hundred kX of magnification, and a diffraction pattern with mostly parallel illumination can be observed. Figure 41b shows the diffraction pattern for Au thin film with the nanodiffraction mode. This mode is set by changing the lens current while
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
163
Probe size (nm)
1.0E + 01
1.0E + 00
1.0E - 01
1.0E - 02 0.1
Diffraction Spheerical aberr. e- source image RMS
1 10 Convergence angle (mrad)
100
FIGURE 40 Convergence angle and probe size.
(a)
(b)
Standard STEM (emissive)
Nano diffraction mode
FIGURE 41 Comparison of diffraction patterns from Au film [001]. (a) standard STEM (emissive) mode with a 7 mrad; (b) nano-diffraction mode with a 2 mrad.
keeping the specimen height and objective aperture fixed. First, the probe is raster-scanned to determine the field of view. Then, the probe is placed at the point of interest on the image, and an electron diffraction pattern is obtained with the CCD camera mounted at the bottom of the column. Figure 42 shows an example DF-STEM image of a dynamic random access memory (DRAM) and diffraction patterns from several points of the image with nano-diffraction mode.
164
Hiromi Inada et al.
Si crystal grain
ONO layer
Insulator Capacitor
Substrate HD 2000 200 kv ⫻ 60.Dk ZC
500 nm
DF-STEM image
Insulator (amorphous SiO2)
Substrate (Si single crystal)
FIGURE 42 DF-STEM image of Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) and diffraction patterns for nano-diffraction mode.
6.3.3. HD-2300 SEG and Auto Functions The HD-2300 was released in 2003. It was equipped with a 200-kV SEG developed by S. Watanabe. If the brightness of electron guns is compared with the speed of a runner, the FEG is a sprinter and the SEG is a marathoner. The SEG is stable 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 52 weeks a year during the lifetime of its zirconium-oxide–coated tungsten cathode. The FEG model (HD-2300C) was produced for performance-oriented customers. Automated focus adjustment and astigmatism-correction functions (Inada et al., 2004) were also developed for this model. These functions were generally very useful to a majority of users, though setting the optimum defocus amount for high-resolution STEM observation at several million times magnification was beyond its capability. Most observations were done at magnifications from 500,000 to 1,000,000 times. This range was
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
165
too high for an FE-SEM operated at a lower acceleration voltage but was within the coverage of the functions. Magnification calibration function for the STEM was developed, because semiconductor manufacturers needed high accuracy device size measurement and nanotechnology features ranging from a few nm to tens of nm in size (Inada et al., 2005). By using the combined technique of micro scale, metrology standard silicon grating specimen and silicon single crystal thin film, the microscope enables to provide the absolute magnification error of less than 2% for all magnification range for the STEM. These features (stable higher performance and easier operation) matched the needs of the semiconductor industry.
7. CUTTING-EDGE APPLICATIONS WITH CUSTOMIZED HD MODELS (BY TOSHIE YAGUCHI) 7.1. 120-kV FE UHV for Nanotubes For element-selective single-atom imaging, K. Suenaga et al. developed the HD-2000 UHV 120-kV CFEG-STEM equipped with an EELS in 2003. With its newly developed magnetic lens and the EELS, it had improved spatial resolution and sensitivity, enabling to identify individual atoms. They used this system with spectrum imaging to identify elements. They also detected a single gadolinium (Gd) atom in a carbon (C) nanohorn (Hashimoto et al., 2004). Figures 43a and b show a BF-STEM image and the corresponding elemental map of Gd and C, respectively. Elemental maps were created from electron energy-loss spectra recorded at 150 eV (Gd-N edge) and 300 eV (CK edge) with 0.5-nm spatial resolution. The numbers in Figure 43b denote the number of Gd atoms, which was determined using the integrated EELS intensity normalized by the inelastic cross section. The map clearly reveals a single Gd atom at the tip of the single-wall carbon nanohorn. This was a pioneering study that identified individual atoms in nanostructures.
7.2. 200-kV FE Ultrahigh-Resolution STEM K. Kimoto et al. (2007a) developed a high-resolution dedicated STEM with high stability for acquisition of distortion-free STEM images and high SNR analysis in 2006. It was developed based on a 200-kV commercial instrument (the HD-2300 FE-STEM) to which many modifications were made. A narrow-gap objective lens was used. Two postspecimen lenses were used to control the detection angles for the BF and ADF detectors. The SEG was replaced with a CFEG, which had a narrow energy spread of sub-0.5 eV (Kimoto and Matsui, 2002; Kimoto et al., 2005). A narrow energy spread is
166
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
5 nm (b)
2 1
2
1
FIGURE 43 BF-STEM image of (a) gadolinium with single-wall carbon nanohorn and (b) corresponding chemical map for Gd (yellow) and C (red). (The number labels in the picture (b) indicate the number of Gd atoms.) (Courtesy of Dr. K. Suenaga, AIST.)
advantageous for analyzing the fine structure of electron energy-loss spectra. To prevent thermal drift, a shield box was placed over the high-voltage generator. A heavy metallic cover was used for the specimen stage to reduce acoustic vibration. The column was covered with rubber sheets to reduce temperature fluctuation (Muller and Grazul, 2001). The microscope was installed in a room of an anti-seismic building at the National Institute for Materials Science. Temperature fluctuations in the room were within 0.2 C/hr. The stray magnetic field in the room was less than 0.2 mG near the STEM column. Noisy apparatuses were placed in a separate room. Figure 44 shows the STEM image drifts measured during a period of 61 minutes. The average drift speed was 0.12 nm/min. Due to the high stability, the atomic columns in the ADF images could be observed. Moreover, a single europium (Eu) dopant atom in b-SiAlON phosphor and small atomic displacement of 10 pm were directly observed (Kimoto et al., 2009; Saito et al., 2009). Many sets of images were sequentially acquired with drift correction using a digital beam control unit (DigiScan, Gatan) and averaged using
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
167
60 −4
50
30
Position (nm)
−3
40
20 −2 10
−1
0 0 (start) −1
0
1 2 Position (nm)
3
FIGURE 44 Measured STEM image drift during 61-minute observation. Numbers in graph denote elapsed time in minutes.
Si
1 nm
Eu
FIGURE 45 ADF STEM image of b-SiAlON:Eu2þ. The upper inset in the solid-line rectangle shows single-scanning image obtained in conventional manner, resulting in severe quantum noise. The lower inset in dotted rectangle shows simulation result. White arrows show Eu atom positions.
168
Hiromi Inada et al.
image acquisition and analysis software (DigitalMicrograph, Gatan). Final images were obtained with a high SNR. The ADF image revealed Eu dopant in the continuous atomic channel in a b – Si3N4, as shown in Figure 45. Using the STEM with EELS and localized inelastic scattering, Kimoto et al. (2007b) performed two-dimensional elemental analysis with atomiccolumn resolution for the first time. Figure 46 shows an example result. An atomic column of La, Mn, and O in layered manganite (La1.2Sr1.8Mn2O7) was visualized two-dimensionally. (a)
(b)
(c)
0.5 nm
La, Sr Mn O
(d)
(e)
5.2/9.2
(f)
1.2/13.0
3.5/10.2
FIGURE 46 Atomic-column imaging using STEM and EELS. (a) Enlarged ADF image of analyzed area overlapped with crystal structure. (b) Calculated incident probe shape for EELS and ADF observations. (c)–(f) Core-loss images of La-N4,5, O-K, Mn-L3,2, and La-M5,4. Colored circles in (c)–(f) indicate the corresponding positions of atomic columns. (Courtesy of Dr. K. Kimoto, NIMS.)
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
169
7.3. 3D Structural and Elemental Analysis Submicrometer-resolution three-dimensional (3D) structural analysis is becoming increasingly indispensable for structural evaluation and failure analysis as devices become more integrated and smaller. To meet this need, 3D characterization techniques have been developed that use an FIB system in combination with an STEM and TEM. In this approach, a specially designed FIB-STEM–compatible specimen-rotation holder is used from initial specimen preparation through final STEM characterization. The specimen is milled to a pillar shape and mounted on the tip of a needle stub loaded in the rotation mechanism of the specimen holder. Typical specimen dimensions for 3D structural and elemental analyses are less than 200 nm in diameter and 5–10 m in length. The specimen holder enables 360 rotation and 20 tilt even in an instrument with a narrow-gap, high-resolution pole piece (Kamino et al., 2004). Since the specimen can be rotated a complete 360 , the incident electron beam, detectors, and spectrometers can view it without obstruction over the full rotation range. This enables multidirectional observation of the specimen. In addition, a complete set of images can be taken. Using this stack of images, nanometer-scale tomograms without missing zone can be reconstructed. EDX analysis has been used for 3D elemental distribution analysis. Since the specimen had a pillar shape, the projected specimen shape remained identical at any rotation angle; consequently, the tilt series of observations and analyses were not affected by differences in shape and thickness. The limited signals of X-ray maps have been enhanced by principal component analysis (PCA) (Watanabe and Williams, 2004) in combination with X-ray spectrum image acquisition. Application of PCA enhances the weak signals in elemental distribution maps acquired in an extremely short time. Therefore, elemental distributions can be acquired for even shorter acquisition times, thereby reducing the total acquisition time for a complete tilt-series measurement (Yaguchi et al., 2008). Nevertheless, it took more than 12 hours for complete acquisition of a tilt series of X-ray maps. Figure 47 shows the 3D-reconstructed Ti (image a) and As (image b) distribution around a tungsten contact plug in a Si semiconductor device from 37 Ti-K edge maps at rotation angles between 0 and 180 with 5 steps. Note that the As dopant distribution, which is critical for semiconductor performance, was obtained three-dimensionally for the first time. EELS was also applied as another method. The elemental mapping was performed with a STEM using a real-time EELS imaging system consisting of a three-window energy filter mounted beneath the STEM detectors. This unique EELS imaging system originally had a two-window energy filter when it was developed in 2000 (Kaji et al., 2001). It was modified to have a three-window energy filter in 2008. Since electrons in
170
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b)
50 nm
50 nm
FIGURE 47 3D-reconstructed (a) Ti and (b) As distributions around tungsten contact plug. They were obtained from a tilt series of 37 Ti K and As K maps over a tilt range of 0–180 with a 5 step. Simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique was used for 3D reconstruction. (Reproduced with permission of Yaguchi, 2008.)
the three energy-loss ranges are collected simultaneously, a real-time energy-filtered elemental map can be obtained in a shorter time with the modified system.
8. ABERRATION-CORRECTED CFE-STEM (BY KUNIYASU NAKAMURA) The 16th International Microscopy Congress was held in Sapporo in September 2006. Emperor Akihito and Empress Michiko were special guests at the conference. Hitachi High-Technologies (HHT) Corp. exhibited an HD-2700 Cs-corrected STEM. Before the president of HHT introduced the exhibited instruments, he congratulated the royal couple on the birth of their first grandson, Prince Hisahito, who was born that morning. The HD-2700 performed well during the five-day exhibition, demonstrat˚ ngstrom image resolution. The combination of atomic resoluing sub-A tion and analytical probe current had been realized.
8.1. Atomic-Level Characterization Instrument The HD-2700 is a second-generation, commercial-dedicated STEM and is a promising successor to the HD-2000 and HD-2300. It supports both a CFEG and an SEG electron source. The CFEG is suitable for high-end research work, such as atomic-resolution imaging with EELS/EDS analysis. The SEG is better for long-term use, such as device inspection in the semiconductor industry. Its spherical aberration-correcting optics was a joint
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
171
project of CEOS (Heidelberg, Germany) and Hitachi. In addition to this new technology, much effort was devoted to stabilizing the entire system. Theoretically, the factors that limit the performance of a microscope are spherical aberration and chromatic incoherence, including the energy spread of the electron source. Incorporating a spherical aberration corrector and a CFEG is a feasible way to push the instrument to the next limiting criteria. However, performance degradation easily occurs due to zeroth-order aberration, such as instability of the high-tension, lenses and deflectors, specimen vibration due to acoustic waves or a stray magnetic field, drift of the optical conditions and specimen due to thermal instability, and specimen contamination. The highest attainable performance is unobtainable until all zeroth-order aberrations are eliminated. Figure 48 shows the appearance of the HD-2700. The complete covering helps reduce thermal instability and prevents transmission of acoustic waves from the environment. An ion pump is attached close to the specimen, which greatly reduces specimen contamination. The electronics systems for the high-tension, lenses and deflectors is highly advanced. Ultimate performance is obtained with the help of a spherical aberration corrector.
Microscope column with whole cover
Cold-FEG
Condenser aperture Condenser lens
Operating console
Ion pump
Spherical aberration corrector
Objective lens Specimen stage
FIGURE 48 Appearance (left) and several elements inside whole cover (right) of aberration-corrected HD-2700 CFEG-STEM.
172
Hiromi Inada et al.
8.2. Theoretical Consideration of Advantages of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM Aberration correction using a multipole element is a conventional technique for improving the performance of an electron microscope, and there are several advantages of using a corrector (Erni et al., 2009; Nellist et al., 2004). Two types of correctors are commercially available (Haider et al., 1998; Krivanek, Dellby, and Lipini, 1999). However, neither type can correct chromatic aberration in principle. Thus, a CFEG is the best electron source for obtaining the ultimate performance of an aberration-corrected STEM because of its narrow energy spread. For an aberration-corrected system, a wave aberration function that includes all higher-order aberrations should be considered to estimate the attainable resolution. The incoherent broadening effect caused by chromatic aberration (variation of defocus) should also be incorporated. The wave aberration function w(o) is denoted as follows: 1 2 1 1 3 1 4 1þ o 2þ o A1 þ ooC A2 þ o2 oB A3 o wðoÞ ¼ Re 2 2 3 4 1 1 5 2 C3 þ o3 oS 3þ o 2 B4 þ o4 oD 4 A4 þ o3 o þ o2 o 4 5 1 6 1 3 C5 þ o4 o 2 S5 þ o5 oR 5 þ .. A5 þ o3 o þ o (4.5) 6 6 o ¼ l u expði yÞ;
(4.6)
denotes the complex conjugate of o), u is where o is the complex angle (o the spatial frequency, y is the azimuthal angle, and Re represents the real part. The details of all aberration coefficients are available elsewhere (Mu¨ller et al., 2006). The probe intensity profile in real space is given by IðrÞ ¼ cðrÞ cðrÞ (4.7)
2p wðoÞ AðoÞ cðrÞ ¼ FT exp i l
(4.8)
AðoÞ ¼ 1 for o a; AðoÞ ¼ 0 for o > a;
(4.9)
where FT represents Fourier transform operation. For incorporating chromatic aberration, extended defocus C10 is introduced: 0
C1 ¼ C1 þ CC
DE ; E
(4.10)
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
173
where CC is the chromatic aberration coefficient, DE is the variation in electron energy, and E is the primary electron energy. Each wave aberration corresponding to the extended defocus is integrated by weighting the Gaussian distribution of the energy variation. The probe intensity profile is defined again as functions of r and C10 . " # ð 1 ðE DEÞ2 0 0 0 Iðr; C1 Þ ¼ cðr; C1 Þcðr; C1 Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi exp dDE (4.11) 2s2 2ps 1 s ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DE0 ; 2 2 ln 2
(4.12)
where DE0 is defined in terms of the FWHM of the electron source energy spread. Figure 49 shows the calculated d59 criterion probe size (Haider, Uhlemann, and Zach, 2000) at 200 kV for a CFEG (DE0 ¼ 0.3 eV) and an SEG (DE0 ¼ 0.8 eV) as a function of the convergence angle. The residual and intrinsic aberrations listed in Figure 49 are assumed to emulate an actual system. The minimum probe sizes for the CFEG and SEG meet at a convergence angle of 25 mrad. The smallest attainable probe is 0.08 nm ˚ ngstrom for the CFEG and 0.1 nm for the SEG. For a CFEG, the sub-A probe size remains in the range of 20–35 mrad. This is a big advantage of a CFEG. If the axial brightness of the gun is assumed to be the same for a CFEG and the SEG—although a CFEG is brighter than an SEG—a two times larger probe current is available if a CFEG with a 0.1-nm probe is used at 35 mrad compared with that if a SEG with a 0.1-nm probe is used at 25 mrad.
8.3. Evaluation of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.3.1. Information Transfer with High-Angle ADF-STEM image Figure 50 shows DF-STEM images of Si (110) single crystals for (image a) uncorrected and (image b) corrected states. The corresponding power spectra are shown in images c and d, respectively. The superimposed images were simulated using an extended multislice method (Nakamura et al., 1997). The well-known dumbbell structure is clearly seen, and the SNR was much improved after correction. For the corrected STEM image, the information limits of 0.083 nm (Si (533)) and 0.078 nm (Si (444)) were transferred in the power spectrum, as predicted from Figure 49. These results confirm that a CFE-STEM with an aberration corrector is now an essential tool that can be used to routinely obtain atomic-resolution images.
174
Hiromi Inada et al.
0.35 ΔEo = 0.3 eV ΔEo = 0.8 eV
d59 probe size (nm)
0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
0
10
Symbol A1 C1 A2 B2 A3 C3 S3 A4 A5 B4,D4,C5, S5, R5 CC
FIGURE 49
20 30 40 50 Convergence angle (mrad) Amplitude 1.04 nm 0 nm 6.66 nm 7.24 nm 525.7 nm −3.23 mm 213.1 nm 8 . 3 1 mm 3.1mm Not included 1.7mm
60
Initial phase(deg) −41.8 30 65 −72 136.2 23.8 0 -
Calculated d59 probe size as a function of convergence angle.
8.3.2. Low-Kilovolt Capability The aberration correction can damage the specimen because the current density of the probe is increased more than tenfold. Such damage could be avoided by reducing the electron dose and electron energy. The imaging capability of the HD-2700 with aberration correction and low-kilovolt operation was theoretically considered and tested. Figure 51 shows the calculated 2D probe profile at 80 kV. The parameters for this calculation are listed in the figure. The profile has a sharp peak at the center and tails caused by residual higher-order aberrations. The estimated resolution as d59 criterion was 0.11 nm. Figure 52 shows a DF-STEM image of an Si (110) single crystal and the corresponding power spectrum at 80-kV operation. The dumbbell structure is clearly evident, and an information limit of 0.105 nm (Si (333))
175
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
(a) (c)
(b) 444
(d)
335 004
0.136 nm
FIGURE 50 DF-STEM images of Si (110) single crystals for (a) uncorrected and (b) corrected states; images (c) and (d) are power spectra corresponding to images (a) and (b), respectively.
6e - 3
Intensity (a.u.)
5e - 3 E ΔE0 C3 C5 A5
4e - 3 3e - 3 2e - 3
: 80 keV : 0.3 eV : 10 m m : 2 mm : 2 mm
1e - 3 0e + 0 −0.5 −0.4 −0.3 −0.2 −0.1 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Distance (nm)
FIGURE 51
Calculated 2D-probe profile at 80 kV and its line profile.
0.4
0.5
176
Hiromi Inada et al.
333
0.136 nm
FIGURE 52 DF-STEM image of Si (110) single crystal and corresponding power spectrum at 80-kV operation.
was transferred. The feasibility of atomic-scale analysis at 80 kV was confirmed by this result.
8.4. Advanced Application Results with HD-2700C The customized HD-2700C CFE-STEM was installed at the Center for Functional Nanomaterials at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) by a group led by Y. Zhu and J. Wall in 2007. This is like a story of transmigration because the HD-2700 is a descendant of the FE-STEM on which Crewe consulted, and it was installed in the laboratory in which works Joe Wall, one of Crewe’s co-researchers on the initial CFE-STEM development in the 1960s. One of the most impressive results obtained with the HD-2700C is described below (Inada et al., 2009; Zhu and Wall, 2008).
8.4.1. Stability of EELS In the Brookhaven system, the critical parts of the high-tension circuit were carefully identified, and an anti-electromagnetic field shield and floor-vibration damping system were attached to the high-tension generator. In addition to these efforts, BNL built a highly stabilized microscope room in the Center for Functional Nanomaterials building, which was completed in 2007. As a result, the fluctuations in high tension were reduced. Figure 53 shows a time chart of the zero-loss peak of 200-keV electrons for a 130-sec duration. The spectra were acquired using a spectrometer (Enfina ER, Gatan), and the energy dispersion was 0.05 eV/channel. This time chart indicates that the stability of the total system was 0.5 ppm for
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
177
(a)
Energy (eV)
0.2 0.1 0 −0.1
0
10
(b) 2.0 ⫻ 104
20
30
40
50
60 70 80 Time (s)
90 100 110 120 130
9.0 mA
9.0 mA
4.0 mA
4.0 mA
2.0 mA 1.0 mA
2.0 mA
1.2 ⫻ 104
1.0 mA
0.4 eV
4 ⫻ 103 0 −1.0
−0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0 1.5 Energy (eV)
2.0
2.5
3.0
FIGURE 53 Time chart of zero-loss peak of 200-keV electrons for 130-sec duration.
long-term acquisition. An energy resolution of 0.30–0.35 eV in terms of FWHM was demonstrated for 10-sec acquisition, and one of 0.4 eV was demonstrated even under typical electron-extraction conditions to get a probe current large enough for spectrum imaging.
8.4.2. Visualization and EELS Analysis of Single Uranium Atom Figure 54 shows (image a) a DF-STEM image of uranium (U) individual atoms and clumps of U on carbon support film, (image b) an image intensity profile along the ‘‘spectrum imaging’’ line showing a single atom profile of 0.08 nm, and (c) the EELS integrated intensity profile at the U-O4,5 edge (96–150 eV) after background subtraction. The probe convergence angle and collection angle into the spectrometer were 28 and 30 mrad, respectively. This result indicates that the corrected CFEG probe was small enough and had sufficient current density to detect single atoms. Although a uranium atom has a strong scattering amplitude and should be an ideal point scatterer, the corrected CFE-STEM has the capability to resolve other single atoms by imaging or spectroscopy.
Hiromi Inada et al.
178
(b) Intensity (arb. unit)
⫻105
(a)
Spectrum imaging
HAADF-STEM
120 0.08 nm
80
40 0
0.2
0.4
2 nm
Survey image
Electron counts (e−)
(c) 1200
0.6 (nm)
0.8
1.0
0.8
1.0
U-O4,5 mapping 0.13 nm
800
400
0
0.2
0.4
0.6 (nm)
FIGURE 54 (a) DF-STEM image of uranium (U) individual atoms and clumps of U on carbon support film. (b) Image intensity profile along ‘‘spectrum imaging’’ line. (c) EELS-integrated intensity profile at U-O4,5 edge after background subtraction.
8.4.3. EELS Spectrum Mapping of Pd/Pt Core Shell Catalyst Figure 55a shows a DF-STEM image of a palladium (Pd) nano-catalyst (core) with a platinum (Pt) shell, images b and c show the electron energy-loss (EEL) spectrum for the particle indicated by the arrow in image a, image d shows a DF-STEM image of a particle, and images e–g show the corresponding spectrum mapping images of the particle of image d for Pd, Pt, and C, respectively. The core-shell structure is clearly distinguished by the elemental mapping images. The most remarkable result is that the distribution of a very small amount of Pt was detected using the PtM4,5 edge, which is the high-energy loss portion, such as 2200 eV. This is a key benefit of an aberration-corrected probe.
8.4.4. EELS Column-by-Column Mapping of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2) Figure 56a shows a DF-STEM image of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2) viewed along the [010] direction; image b shows a survey image showing the area for spectrum mapping and drift compensation; image c shows a DF-STEM image and corresponding elemental maps for Ca, O, and Co, respectively; image d is an overlay of the Ca, O, and Co maps; and image e is the EEL spectrum of the area. The experimental conditions were 64–341 mrad for the DF-STEM collection angle, 0.5 eV/channel for the energy dispersion,
(b)
(a)
(c)
Carbon support
500 400
12
C-k
e−
20 nm
4
100
2 300
400
eV
20370 e− (e)
(d)
6
200
0
Pt−M4,5
8
Pd−M4,5
300
Carbon support
10
500
600
0 2000
3780 e− (f)
2100
2200 eV
2300
2400
64400 e− (g)
5 nm HAADF-STEM
Pd mapping
−2560
Pt mapping
−6390
C mapping
−5198
FIGURE 55 (a) DF-STEM image of palladium (Pd) nano-catalyst with (platinum) Pt shell; (b) and (c) EEL spectra for particle indicated by arrow in image (a); (d) DF-STEM image of the particle; and (e)–(g) corresponding spectrum mapping images of the particle in image (d) for Pd, Pt, and carbon, respectively.
CaO CaO CoO CoO2 CoO2
(a)
(c) Ca
0.5 nm
O
1 nm
(b)
(d)
(e)
Spectrum image
Ca
e− ⫻ 103
30 2.19 ⫻ 2.19 nm
20
Spatial drift
O
10 0 300
1 nm
2 nm
Co
ADF-STEM survey image
Ca
O
400
500
Co
600 eV
700
800
900
Co
FIGURE 56 (a) DF-STEM image of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2); (b) survey image for spectrum mapping and drift compensation; (c) DF-STEM image and corresponding elemental maps of calcium (Ca), oxygen (O), and cobalt (Co), respectively; (d) overlay of Ca, O, and Co maps; and (e) EEL spectrum of area.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
181
70 70 pixels for the scanning area at a 0.032-nm pixel distance, and a 0.05sec dwell time for each pixel. The atomic columns of each element are clearly evident in each element map, and the overlaid image reconstructs the elemental atomic columns without arrangement of atomic columns in accordance with corresponding crystal structure shown in Figure 56(a).
8.4.5. Single Atom Imaging Using Secondary Electrons Zhu et al. demonstrated high resolution secondary electron imaging. Figure 57 shows a pair of SEM and DF-STEM images of uranium individual uranium atoms and clumps on a carbon thin film (~2nm). Quantitative intensity analysis of DF-STEM reveals the areas marked by small circles are individual atoms. They have achieved 0.1 nm spatial resolution with SEM detector imaging with aberration-corrected CFE-STEM (Zhu et al., 2009).
9. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE PROSPECTIVE (BY HIROSHI KAKIBAYASHI) Many of Hitachi’s undertakings in developing and manufacturing STEMs were introduced in this chapter. The fusion of TEM technology by Hitachi started before World War II, and the CFE technology introduced by Crewe played an important role in Hitachi’s development of FE-STEMs. These were not fortuities. The very strong enthusiasm of the researchers and designers at Hitachi met the challenge to develop the world’s highest(a)
(b)
2 nm
FIGURE 57 Imaging individual uranium atoms with secondary electrons. Simultaneous acquisition of the SEM image using secondary electrons and back scattered electrons (a) and the DF-STEM image using forward scattered electrons (b), of uranium oxide nanocrystals and individual uranium atoms (raw data).
182
Hiromi Inada et al.
performance STEMs. Their enthusiasm enabled Hitachi to develop various types of STEMs, from the 50-kV STEM in 1975 to the latest HD-2700 dedicated STEM. Along the way, M. Haider and H. Rose developed Cs-correction technology and it was introduced into the HD-2700. The result was elemental and chemical-bonding–state mapping and highresolution STEM image observation at an atomic order. These microscopes contributed to the fine structure analysis of nano-materials, nano-electronic devices, and nano-biomaterials in various fields. CFESTEMs have become an essential analytical tool in many fields. In the future, STEMs will be needed that can feed back atomic-level information by higher throughput for material and device processes. Moreover, it will become necessary to implement simultaneous atomic observation and manipulation under process ambient conditions. This means that STEMs will progress from being analytical tools to atomic-controlling instruments. Hitachi will continue to research and develop the ultimate instrument.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Masashi Watanabe of Lehigh University, Kazutomo Suenaga of the National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), and Koji Kimoto of the National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS) for their invaluable advice and support. We also thank Yimei Zhu, Joe Wall, Lijun Wu, and Dong Su of Brookhaven National Laboratory for allowing the use of their invaluable STEM imaging and analysis data. In addition, we acknowledge Maximilian Haider, Peter Hartel, Heiko Mu¨ller, Frank Kahl, and Thomas Riedel for their help in the development of the spherical aberration corrector. We acknowledge and appreciate the advice about historical field emission technologies offered by Shobu Saito, Hideo Todokoro, Mikio Ichihashi, and Masahiro Tomita. Finally, we thank our colleagues at Hitachi High-Technologies Corp., Hidehito Obayashi, Mitsugu Sato, Kazui Mizuno, Takeo Kamino, Yasumitsu Ueki, Mitsuru Konno, Yuya Suzuki, Tadao Furutsu, Kazutoshi Kaji, Satoru Fukuhara, Hisaya Murakoshi, Takeshi Kawasaki, Tetsuya Akashi, Yoshifumi Taniguchi, Koichiro Saito, and Kaname Takahashi for their support and fruitful discussions.
REFERENCES Butler, J. W. (1966). Digital computer techniques in electron microscopy. 6th Int. Cong. for Electron Microscopy (Kyoto) 1, 191. Committee of Semiconductor Technology Roadmap of Japan (1999). STRJ Report 1999. Japan Electronics and Information Technology Industries Association. Crewe, A. V. (1964). Scanning techniques for high voltage microscope, in Proc. AMU-ANL High Voltage Electron Microscope Mtg. (Argonne National Laboratory), pp. 68–81. Crewe, A. V. (1985). Towards the ultimate scanning electron microscope, in Scanning Electron Microscopy 1985 II. Chicago: SEM Inc., pp. 467–472. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968a). Electron gun using a field emission source. Rev. Sci. Inst. 39, 576–583.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
183
Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1970). Contrast in a high resolution scanning electron microscope. Optik 30, 461–474. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970a). High resolution scanning electron microscopy of nucleic acid salts. Microscopie Electronique (Grenoble) 1, 467–468. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970b). The visibility of single atoms. Science 168, 1338–1340. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968b). A high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 5861–5868. Dyke, W. P., Trolan, J. K., Dolan, W. W., and Barnes, G. (1953). The field emitter: Fabrication, electron microscopy, and electric field calculations. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 570–576. Eggenberger, D. N., Hart, R. K., and Libal, A. C. (1968). A field emission high voltage gun. Proc. EMSA 26, 330–331. Endo, J., Kawasaki, T., Matsuda, T., Osakabe, N., and Tonomura, A. (1984). Sensitivity improvement in electron holographic interferometry, in Proc. 13th Int’l. Commission for Optics. Sapporo, pp. 480–481. Erni, R., Rossell, M. D., Kisielowski, C., and Dahmen, U. (2009). Atomic-resolution imaging with a sub-50-pm electronprobe. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 096101. Everhart, T. E. (1967). Simplified analysis of point-cathode electron sources. J. Appl. Phys. 38, 4944–4957. Fowler, R. H., and Nordheim, L. (1928). Electron emission in intense electric fields. Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A119, 173–181. Gabor, D. (1949). Microscopy by reconstructed wavefronts. Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A197, 454–487. Gomer, R. (1961). Field Emission and Field Ionization. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Kabius, B., and Urban, K. (1998). Toward 0.1 nm resolution with the first spherically corrected transmission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 47(5), 395–405. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., and Zach, J. (2000). Upper limit for the residual aberrations of a high-resolution aberration-corrected STEM. Ultramicroscopy 81, 163–175. Hashimoto, T., Nakamura, K., Kakibayashi, H., Shimovama, W., Ohashi, T., Sato, H., Tanaka, H., Yotsuji, T., Aizawa, S., Saito, K., Sato, Y., Ichihashi, M., and Isakozawa, S. (1998). Development of the HD-2000 high voltage field emission scanning electron microscope. Proc. ICEM 14, 85–86. Hashimoto, T., Sato, Y., Ueki, Y., Kamino, T., Isakozawa, S., Ikematsu, Y., Uemori, R., and Morikawa, H. (1991). Nano-area analysis by an energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer mounted on a field emission transmission electron microscope. Proc. EMSA 49, 352–353. Hashimoto, A., Yorimitsu, H., Ajima, K., Suenaga, K., Isobe, H., Miyawaki, J., Yudasaka, M., Iijima, S., and Nakamura, E. (2004). Selective deposition of a gadolinium(III) cluster in a hole opening of single-wall carbon nanohorn. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 527–530. Hibi, T. (1956). Pointed filament (I) its production and its applications. J. Electron Microsc. 4, 10–15. Inada, H., Watanabe, S., Tanaka, H., Takane, A., Aizawa, S., Shimovama, W., Ohashi, T., Hashimoto, T., Isakozawa, S., and Nakamura, K. (2004). Development of automatic adjustment functions for the HD-2300 scanning transmission electron microscope. Proc. 8 APEM 60–61. Inada, H., Terauchi, D., Tsuneta, R., Ozawa, M., Aizawa, S., Nakamura, K., Takane, A., Konno, M., and Tanaka, H. (2005). Development of high accuracy automatic magnification calibration function for scanning transmission electron microscope. Conference Proc. from 31st Int. Symp. for Testing and Failure Anal. 436–439. Inada, H., Wu, L., Wall, J., Su, D., and Zhu, Y. (2009). Performance and image analysis of the aberration-corrected Hitachi HD-2700C STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 58, 111–122.
184
Hiromi Inada et al.
Isakozawa, S., Kashikura, Y., Sato, Y., Takahashi, T., Ichihashi, M., and Murakoshi, H. (1989). Proc. EMSA 47, 112–113. Ishitani, T., Tsuboi, H., Yaguchi, T., and Koike, H. (1994). Transmission electron microscope sample preparation using a focused ion beam. J. Electron Microsc. 43, 322–326. Kaji, K., Ueda, K., Aoyama, T., Taya, S., Tanaka, H., and Isakozawa, S. (2001). Development of a real-time jump ratio imaging system equipped with a STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 15–21. Kamino, T., and Tomita, M. (1983). Effect of FE gun in analytical electron microscope. Hitachi Technical Data ‘‘EM’’ Sheet 36. Kamino, T., Ueki, Y., Hamajika, H., Sasaki, K., Kuroda, K., and Saka, H. (1992). Direct evidence for Suzuki segregation obtained by high-resolution analytical electron microscopy. Phil. Mag. Lett. 66, 27–31. Kamino, T., Yaguchi, T., Konno, M., Ohnishi, T., and Watanabe, M. (2004). A method for multidirectional TEM observation of a specific site at atomic resolution. J. Electron Microsc. 53, 583–588. Kawasaki, T., Yoshida, T., Matsuda, T., Osakabe, N., Tonomura, A., Matsui, I., and Kitazawa, K. (2000). Fine crystal lattice fringes observed using a transmission electron microscope with 1MeV coherent electron waves. Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 1342–1344. Kimoto, K., Asaka, T., Nagai, T., Saito, M., Matsui, Y., and Ishizuka, K. (2007b). Elementselective imaging of atomic columns in crystal using STEM and EELS. Nature 450, 702–704. Kimoto, K., Ishizuka, K., Asaka, T., Nagai, T., and Matsui, Y. (2005). 0.23 eV energy resolution obtained using a cold field emission gun and a streak imaging technique. Micron 36, 465–469. Kimoto, K., and Matsui, Y. (2002). Software techniques for EELS to realize about 0.3 eV energy resolution using 300 kV FEG-TEM. J. Microsc. 208, 224–228. Kimoto, K., Nakamura, K., Aizawa, S., Isakozawa, S., and Matsui, Y. (2007a). Development of dedicated STEM with high stability. J. Electron Microsc. 56, 17–20. Kimoto, K., Xie, R. J., Matsui, Y., Ishizuka, K., and Hirosaki, N. (2009). Direct observation of single dopant atom in light-emitting phosphor of b–SiAlON:Eu2þ. Appl. Phys. Lett. 94, 041908. Komoda, T. (1996a). Electron microscopes and microscopy in Japan. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 96, 653–657. Komoda, T. (1996b). Electron microscopes and microscopy in Japan: Instrumentation. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 96, 685–722. Komoda, T., and Saito, S. (1972). Experimental resolution limit in the secondary electron mode for a field emission source scanning electron microscope. Proc. 5th Annual Scanning Electron Microsc. Symp. (Chicago) 129. Komoda, T., Tonomura, A., Ohkura, A., and Minamikawa, Y. (1972). A scanning transmission electron microscope using a field emission electron fun., Proc. 6th Int. Conf. on X-ray Optics and Microanalysis, pp. 483–488. Koreeda, A., Ishibashi, T., Shimizu, K., Tomita, M., Kimura, C., and Okano, H. (1990). Development and applications of an analytical electron microscope with a field emission electron gun. Mater. Charact. 25, 375–395. Krivanek, O. L., Dellby, N., and Lipini, A. R. (1999). Toward sub-angstrom electron beams. Ultramicroscopy 78, 1–11. Martin, E. E., Trolan, J. K., and Dyke, W. P. (1960). Stable, high density field emission cold cathode. J. Appl. Phys. 31, 782–789. Matsuda, T., Tonomura, A., Suzuki, R., Endo, J., Osakabe, N., Umezaki, H., Tanabe, H., Sugita, Y., and Fujiwara, H. (1982). Observation of microscopic distribution of magnetic field by electron holography. J. Appl. Phys. 53, 5444–5448.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
185
Millilkan, R. A., and Lauritsen, C. C. (1928). Relations of field-currents to thermionic-currents. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U S A 14, 45–49. Murakoshi, H., Ichihashi, M., and Kakibayashi, H. (1992). A 300-kV field-emission transmission electron microscope. Proc. EMSA 50, 936–937. Muller, D. A., and Grazul, J. (2001). Optimizing the environment for sub-0.2 nm scanning transmission electron microscopy. J.Electron Microsc. 50, 219–226. Mu¨ller, E. W. (1937). Elektronenmikroskopische Beobachtungen von Feldkathoden. Z. Physik 106, 541–550. Mu¨ller, H., Uhlemann, S., Hartel, P., and Haider, M. (2006). Advancing the hexapole Cscorrector for scanning transmission electron microscope. Microsc. Microanal 12, 442–455. Nakamura, K., Kakibayashi, H., Kanehori, K., and Tanaka, N. (1997). Position dependence of the visibility of a single gold atom in silicon crystals in HAADF-STEM image simulation. J. Electron Microsc. 46, 33–43. Nellist, P. D., Chisholm, MF., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Murfitt, M. F., Szilagyi, Z. S., Lupini, A. R., Borisevich, A., Sides, W. H. Jr., and Pennycook, S. J. (2004). Direct subAngstrom imaging of a crystal lattice. Science 305, 1741. Osakabe, N., Matsuda, T., Kawasaki, T., Endo, J., Tonomura, A., Yano, S., and Yamada, H. (1986). Experimental confirmation of the Aharanov-Bohm effect using a toroidal magnetic field confined by a superconductor. Phys. Rev. A 34, 815–822. Osakabe, N., Yoshida, K., Horiuchi, Y., Matsuda, T., Tanabe, H., Okuwaki, T., Endo, J., Fujiwara, H., and Tonomura, A. (1983). Observation of recorded magnetization pattern by electron holography. Appl. Phys. Lett. 42, 746–748. Saito, M., Kimoto, K., Nagai, T., Fukushima, S., Akahoshi, D., Kuwahara, H., Matsui, Y., and Ishizuka, K. (2009). Local crystal structure analysis with 10-pm accuracy using scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Electron Microsc. 58, 131–136. Shimoyama, H., Ichihashi, M., and Tamura, N. (1989). Emitter and electron gun. J. Electron Microsc. 38, S1–S9. Siegel, B. M., et al (1968). Electron Microscopy (Rome) I, 141. Spence, J. C. H., and Zuo, J. M. (1992). in Electron Micro Diffraction. New York: Plenum, p. 175. Todokoro, H., Nomura, S., and Komoda, T. (1977). Observation of atom images by means of field emission STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 26, 213–214. Todokoro, H., Saito, N., and Yamamoto, S. (1982). Role of ion bombardment in field emission current instability. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 21, 1513–1516. Tonomura, (1972). Tonomura, A. (1973). Optimum design of accelerating electrodes for a field emission electron gun. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 12, 1065–1069. Tonomura, A. (1984). Application of electron holography using a field-emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 33, 101–115. Tonomura, A. (1998). Electron Holography, 2nd ed., Berlin: Springer. Tonomura, A., Fukuhara, A., Watanabe, H., and Komoda, T. (1968). Optical reconstruction of image from Fraunhofer electron-hologram. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 7, 295. Tonomura, A., and Komoda, T. (1973). Field emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 22, 141–147. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., and Endo, J. (1979a). Spherical aberration correction of electron lens by holography. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 18, 1373–1377. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Endo, J., Todokoro, H., and Komoda, T. (1979b). Development of a field emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 28, 1–11. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Endo, J., Arii, T., and Mihama, K. (1980). Direct observation of fine structure of domain walls by electron holography. Phys. Rev. Lett. 44, 1430–1433.
186
Hiromi Inada et al.
Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Suzuki, R., Fukuhara, A., Osakabe, N., Umezaki, H., Endo, J., Shinagawa, K., Sugita, Y., and Fujiwara, H. (1982). Observation of Aharonov-Bohm effect by electron holography. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1443–1446. Tonomura, A., Osakabe, N., Matsuda, T., Kawasaki, T., Endo, J., Yano, S., and Yamada, H. (1986). Evidence for the Aharanov-Bohm effect with magnetic field completely shielded from electron wave. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 792–795. Ueda, R. (1975). Young scientists should have the courage to gamble. Electron Microscopy 10, 1 [in Japanese]. Vine, W. J., Vincent, R., Spellward, P., and Steeds, J. W. (1992). Observation of phase contrast in convergent-beam electron diffraction patterns. Ultramicroscopy 41, 423–428. Vo¨lkl, E., Allard, L. F., and Joy, D. C. (1999). Introduction to Electron Holography, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers. Watanabe, M., and Williams, D. B. (2004). Improvements of elemental mapping via X-ray spectrum imaging combined with principal component analysis and zero-peak deconvolution. Microsc. Microanal. 10(Suppl. 2), 1040–1041. Wiesner, J. C., and Everhart, T. E. (1969). Point cathode electron sources. Proc. EMSA 27, 174–175. Wood, R. W. (1897). A mew form of cathode discharge and the production of X-rays, together with some notes on diffraction. Preliminary communication. Phys. Rev. 5, 1–10. Yaguchi, T., Konno, M., Kamino, T., and Watanabe, M. (2008). Observation of threedimensional elemental distributions of a Si-device using a 360-degree-tilt FIB and the cold field-emission STEM system. Ultramicroscopy 108, 1603–1615. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970a). Scanning transmission electron microscopy, I. Optik 31, 258–280. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970b). Scanning transmission electron microscopy, II. Optik 31, 359–366. Zhang, X., Joy, D. C., Zhang, Y., Hashimoto, T., Allard, L., and Nolan, T. A. (1993). Electron holography techniques for study of ferroelectric domain. Ultramicroscopy 51, 21–30. Zhu, Y., and Wall, J. (2008). Aberration-corrected electron microscopes at Brookhaven national laboratory. Adv. Imaging Electr. Phys. 153, 481–523. Zhu, Y., Inada, H., Nakamura, K., and Wall, J. (2009). Imaging single atoms using secondary electrons with an aberration-corrected electron microscope. Nature Materials 8, 808–812.
Chapter
1 The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope and Related Topics A. V. Crewe
Contents
1. Introduction 2. Some Chicago Aberrations: A Personal Collection Acknowledgments 3. Electron Microscope Studies: Achievements of the Crewe Lab Introduction Construction (Reference Group A) Source Development (Reference Group B) STEM Development and Atomic Images (Reference Group C) The Field Emission SEM (Reference Group D) Energy Loss and Radiation Damage (Reference Group E) Secondary Electron Production (Reference Group F) DNA Labeling (Reference Group G) Nucleosomes (Reference Group H) Attempts at Aberration Correction (Reference Group I) Theoretical Electron Optics (Reference Group J) Optimization and the Super-High-Resolution SEM (Reference Group K) Image Processing (Reference Group L)
2 6 13 13 14 16 17 18 19 20 21 21 22 23 27 28 30
Enrico Fermi Institute and Department of Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, USA Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59001-5. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1
2
A. V. Crewe
Three-Dimensional Reconstruction (Reference Group M) Hemoglobin Work (Reference Group N) References (of Chicago Aberrations) References (of DOE Report)
31 32 37 38
1. INTRODUCTION Any book on the scanning electron microscope (STEM) must begin with Albert Crewe, even though the early scanning microscopes of Manfred von Ardenne and Andre´ Le´aute´ were, strictly speaking, scanning transmission instruments. Unfortunately, Crewe’s health does not permit him to write a new account of his STEM work and so, with his approval, I am reproducing two earlier accounts of his contributions to electron optics and in particular, to the STEM. The first of these, ‘‘Some Chicago Aberrations,’’ an expanded version of his lecture at the Microscopy Society of America meeting in 2002, was published in Microscopy and Microanalysis. The other, much longer document is a report submitted to the U.S. Department of Energy, written with Oscar H. Kapp; this gives a full account of Crewe’s work during the period 1964–1992. I readily recognize that there are passages in this report that Crewe might have altered if he had been able to prepare it for republication—but in the circumstances, it seems best to reproduce it as written. Crewe was born in Bradford, in Yorkshire, on February 18, 1927, the only son of Wilfred and Edith Crewe, and studied physics at the University of Liverpool, graduating in 1947. In 1949, he married Doreen Blunsdon; they have four children, Jennifer, Sarah, Elizabeth, and David. In 1949, he was awarded his Ph.D. for his thesis on synchrotron design and in 1955, Crewe was invited to the University of Chicago as a visiting research associate, to work on the Chicago synchrotron. In 1958, he moved to the nearby Argonne National Laboratory, where a largeparticle accelerator was planned. He soon became director of the Particle Accelerator Division at Argonne. In 1961, Crewe was appointed director of the entire laboratory and at the same time became interested in electron microscope design. Unaware of the work of Charles Oatley and his students in the Cambridge University Engineering Department, Crewe designed a new type of scanning electron microscope (SEM), which was to become known as the STEM. In 1966, a workshop was organized at Argonne, the object of which was to design a high-voltage electron microscope; a one-million-volt instrument had been in
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
3
operation in Toulouse since 1960 and high-voltage electron microscope projects had been launched in England and Japan. Scientists were invited from Europe and Japan as well as from the United States and a design was completed but the project did not receive funding. In 1967, Crewe decided to return to his post at the University of Chicago, where he had been granted full professorship in 1963, and the first results from his first prototype STEM, with a field emission gun, were published soon after. I still have a vivid memory of his description of the planned microscope at an Institute of Physics meeting on ‘‘Non-Conventional Electron Microscopy’’ in Cambridge in 1965, where many of Oatley’s group were in the audience. The subsequent part of his story is told in the papers reproduced in this volume. His work has been honored by many awards, including the following:
FIGURE 1 The quadrupole-octupole corrector is shown mounted on to a vacuum flange. Seven rectangular iron yokes are visible, the four equally spaced quadupoles and three interleaving octupoles. The electron beam was contained inside a Pt/Ir tube (not visible). The corrector was approximately 15 cm in height.
4
A. V. Crewe
FIGURE 2 The sextupole corrector is shown partially assembled. The field lens is in the center of the photograph and the beam tube is visible. The sextupoles were wound in grooves machined into the outer surface of the beam tube. Various ion pumps and valves are visible.
Chicagoan of the Year in Science (Chicago Junior Chamber of
Commerce, 1962)
Honorary degrees from the University of Missouri (1967), Lake Forest
College (1968), Elmhurst College (1969), and the University of Liverpool (2001) National Academy of Sciences (1972) Electron Microscopy Society of America’s Distinguished Service Award (1976) Albert A. Michelson Medal of the Franklin Institute (1977) William Wrather Distinguished Service Professor and later Emeritus (1978) Ernst Abbe Award (1979) NewYork Microscope Society (1979)
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
5
E F C2
M
D
C1
B
A
G
FIGURE 3 Schematic of mirror system. The optical path of the system comprises two major regions. In the first region, electrons from a thermal field emission source (A) travel along the optical axis and can be brought into a first focus at the first grid (C1) by a magnetic field which is produced by a solenoid (G). A defining aperture (B) is placed about midway between the source and the first specimen. After being focused on the first specimen, the electrons enter the second region and refocus at a second grid (C2). The distance between the first and second grids is approximately the same as that between the source and the first grid. Also in the second region is an electrostatic mirror field that is produced by assigning potentials to a series of copper discs (M). Properly adjusted, the mirror field can reflect and refocus electrons at the reverse side of the first grid. Two sets of scanning coils (D, E), one at each of the first and second regions, provide the deflection fields to scan the focused electrons across the grids. They can be operated independently or synchronously. A pair of stigmator coils (F) are installed to correct the astigmatism.
Duddell Medal, The Institute of Physics, London (1980) Honorary Fellow of the Royal Microscopical Society (1984) Honorary Fellow of the Electron Microscope Society of China (1989).
—Peter W. Hawkes
6
A. V. Crewe
2. SOME CHICAGO ABERRATIONS: A PERSONAL COLLECTION* by A. V. Crewe The Enrico Fermi Institute and Department of Physics, University of Chicago The account that follows is almost entirely based on my own memory, which is not a very reliable instrument. However, some of the events can be documented and references will be given whenever possible. If no reference is given, it simply means that some details have become lost in the mists of memory. It is to be hoped that sins of omission will be forgiven because they are unintended. This account is not intended to be a review and is more accurately describable as a personal recollection. This is the story of the work in Chicago on the correction or reduction of lens aberrations. It was an effort that extended over a period of almost 40 years, although it was never the primary focus of the work of the laboratory. That was always the development and exploitation of the field emission electron gun, particularly in the STEM and the SEM. That program began in 1963 and within a year or two the properties of the field emission source were established to be good enough that the ultimate performance of these instruments was determined by the objective lenses, not the source. This in turn meant that the lenses and their aberrations became matters of primary interest because the size of the focused electron probe is determined by the magnitude of the spherical (Cs) and the chromatic aberration (Cc). Everyone is aware that there has been much recent progress on the problem of correcting the aberrations of magnetic lenses, some of it in Chicago, but much more in Germany and here in the United States by Krivanek. The problem is now essentially solved but we must not forget that all this progress has had precedents and that, in Newton’s words, ‘‘we stand on the shoulders of giants.’’ Expressing a purely personal opinion, there are three historic events that greatly impressed me and convinced me that correction was both necessary and possible. Two of these were from the same author. I refer, of course, to Otto Scherzer. It was he who, in 1936, established the salient characteristic of the aberrations— Cs is always negative and Cc is always positive (Scherzer, 1936). It was a monumental calculation and is justifiably memorialized as the Scherzer theorem. It occupies 37 pages in the version given in the book by El Kareh and El Kareh. He once told me that he was conscripted into the German army and chose to work as a nighttime telephone operator for the simple reason that there were no calls in the night and he could do his own work. * Reproduced with permission from Microscopy and Microanalysis 8 (2002), Supplement 2, 24 and 10(4), 2004,
414–419, courtesy of Cambridge University Press, copyright Microscopy Society of America.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
7
He completed the final calculations in one night. I asked him why on earth he even attempted to put the result in the form of a sum of squares, which is the key step in the proof. He simply replied, ‘‘I thought it would work.’’ The fact that the aberrations are always present means that the resolution of a microscope is determined by the magnitude of these aberrations 1=4 together with the effects of diffraction. The optimum depends upon Cs 1=2 or Cc , depending upon which of the two aberrations is dominant. Since the two coefficients are always finite, the only way to make substantial improvements is to find a way to correct them, and that means that one must avoid one of the three assumptions in the theorem, namely cylindrical symmetry, absence of space charge, and time independence. In a second paper Scherzer found a way to build a corrector by abandoning cylindrical symmetry. It was in 1947, after WWII, that he proposed a system of electron optical elements that could, in principle, correct both Cs and Cc by using cylindrical lenses (Scherzer, 1947). There are many names associated with the subsequent development of the corrector problem, principally Scherzer in Darmstadt, of course, but also Seeliger and Mollenstedt. There were also very significant contributions from the Cambridge group, Burfoot, Archard, and Hawkes, but I am not going to attempt to give the complete history here. I only want to say that, for me, the final step was the work of Deltrap. He actually built a system of four quadrupoles and three octupoles and showed that it would indeed correct spherical aberration (Deltrap, 1964). Specifically he used the image of a rectangular grid to show that he could reverse the sign of the third-order aberrations. His equipment was much too large for use in a microscope, and he was concentrating on the problem of increasing the current in a probe rather than in improving the resolving power, but nevertheless the principle was established. All that remained was to miniaturize the system. The Chicago side of the story is a small one and it begins in 1966 at Argonne National Laboratory. At that time we were beginners in electron microscopy and we (Isaacson, Wall, and Johnson) were attempting to get a field emission tip to function as the source of electrons in the first STEM. There was not much encouragement to think that it could be made to work, nothing except the skill of those students. Nevertheless, one could hope. As I recall, we had managed to keep a field emission tip in operation for a few hours at a time and we had a resolution of 1 nm or so. Performance was not good but it seemed to be getting better day by day. It seemed logical therefore to take a long-term look at the future. In this respect, Zworykin’s book (Zworykin et al., 1945) impressed me greatly. It still does. The account of the aberration problem that he gave seemed conclusive and he demonstrated that there was no suitable way to avoid the issue. The next significant event was reading a lengthy paper by Septier in which he described the suggestion for a corrector that had been
8
A. V. Crewe
made by Scherzer and particularly the translation of that suggestion into the modern terminology of quadrupoles and octupoles (Septier, 1966). This made a corrector very amenable because I had been involved in high-energy physics and especially various aspects of accelerator technology. Quadrupoles and systems of quadrupoles were then in heavy use for controlling and focusing external beams. I had already designed and built several of them, and even though they weighed thousands of times more than would be needed in electron microscopy, the principles were the same. Extending to octupoles was also no problem. Later still, Deltrap’s thesis was published and was very impressive. He had developed a great intuitive feeling for the optics of quadrupole systems and his demonstration that a system of quadrupoles and octupoles could be made to work was conclusive. I have a copy of his thesis that I treasure and my only regret is that the hand-drawn figures have completely faded away. It looked like a very good idea and the STEM was clearly the instrument of choice for a corrector because there is no need to worry about the off-axis aberrations. Whereas a conventional microscope must carry the image information through the lens and its corrector, the STEM only needs to correct a paraxial beam. (Actually, it was many years later that we proved this—working with Parker and Golladay (Crewe and Parker, 1976; Parker, Golladay, and Crewe, 1976). David Cohen was a physicist who had worked with me on the construction of the 12-GeV Argonne accelerator and as that project neared completion, he was looking for something else to do, something different, and he asked for any suggestions. The corrector problem seemed to be an appropriate one. He enlisted the help of Phil Meads, who was then with Wm. Brobeck and Associates, because Phil had developed a computer program for particle beam lines that could handle multipoles. Together they produced a set of guidelines for an aberration corrector that had four quadrupoles and three octupoles (Crewe, Cohen, and Meads, 1968). When applied to a 30-kV STEM, the whole thing looked feasible—except for the mechanical tolerances, which were expected to be around 0.1 mm for the position of the pole pieces. A few months later, while preparing to leave Argonne to return to the University of Chicago, Walter Mankawich appeared on the scene. He was a skilled engineer and machinist at the University of Chicago who could machine metal to micron tolerances. He also was looking for a challenge and he had heard that I was due to return there in a few months. We began a long journey together. His primary work was the design and construction of the STEM and associated equipment but he used every spare moment to build jigs and fixtures for the fabrication of a corrector. It seemed reasonable at that point to assume that he could build the system with a 1-mm tolerance and that we could make up the difference
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
9
between 1 mm and 0.1 mm by adding trim coils to adjust the magnetic potential on the poles. A couple of stories about Walter are appropriate here. Every precision machinist has precision steel blocks in his toolbox, 1-inch cubes, etc. Walter did not trust the ones that were available commercially, and however expensive, he made his own. I once asked him to make a pair of slits to be placed in vacuum for an electron spectrometer. He made them to fractional wavelength tolerances using speculum metal that he made himself. He made the magnetic spectrometer also and when it was put together, I mentioned that I admired the way that the joint between the pieces was almost invisible. He apologized, tapped the metal with a leather mallet, and the joint disappeared. Vernon Beck took over the project when he joined the group. He changed the design somewhat and added many new features (Crewe and Beck, 1974), and we built an entirely new STEM to test the device because it was too large to fit into the vacuum chamber of the existing STEM. It also happened that both Michael Thomson and Harold Rose spent a year or so in our laboratory in those years, but although both of them had experience in the correction business, they had other interests and did not get involved in the work. Building a corrector was, obviously, a long-term effort and they were only here for a short time. Walter and Vernon completed the corrector in 1976 and all 40 pole pieces were within the 1-mm tolerance limit, but when we attempted to operate it we were not able to make it work (Beck, 1977). In spite of the 40 trim coils we could not find a suitable setting. The effective centers of the quadrupoles and octupoles could not be brought together. My own conclusion at the time—right or wrong—was that the iron of the pole pieces was not sufficiently uniform, but it is also possible that the many power supplies were not stable enough. In any case, no other student would take a chance on it and so the work on aberration correction stopped. The essence of the problem was that we had 40 knobs to turn and only the image to look at. It may be noted that image analysis was in its infancy at that time. I recall that we had a state-of-the-art Nova computer with a magnificent memory of 32 K—not M, but K! A Fourier transform took a very long time indeed. It would be fair to say that the corrector failed because commercially available technology was not yet good enough and neither was our own. We were ahead of our time. Parenthetically, we might note that we eventually obtained a computing system, thanks to the persuasive efforts of David Saltzman. It arrived too late for this corrector, but one of the first calculations he and I performed was the wave optical optimization of diffraction and aberrations, both the third order and the fifth. We obtained limiting resolutions 1=6 of 0:43Cs1=4 l3=4 and 0:48C5 l5=6 , respectively (Crewe and Salzman, 1982).
10
A. V. Crewe
The factor of 0.43 for the third-order case agrees with the identical value obtained by Mulvey some time previously (Haine, 1961), but the factor of 0. 48 for the fifth-order case was new. It is important because it can be used to calculate the size of the optimum aperture. One might note that some time later Koops published his work in Darmstadt (Koops, 1978). He also failed to make his system work, even though his technology was better than ours. It was shortly afterwards that Scherzer published what I believe to be his last paper (Scherzer, 1978). In that paper he pointed out that the only problem with making the corrector work was that there was not enough financial support. The principle was good but the money was insufficient. It is a sentiment that I can fervently echo. It is appropriate here to make a few comments on the side. Vernon Beck was an outstanding student and I am not sure that his academic records have ever been surpassed. For this reason, there was a feeling among my students that if he could not make the thing work, nobody could. This alone prevented any further attempts. In addition to this, there is a culture in the United States that looks down on failures of any kind. It is a ‘‘one strike’’ rule. If something is a failure nobody wants to try again, with the prospect of failing a second time. It was not a personal problem, but it was certainly an issue for the funding agency (in this case, the Department of Energy [DOE]). Having failed, I could not ask for more support because it might fail again. Perhaps this is also due to the fact that the students were all physicists who were working towards a Ph.D. Null results are not acceptable for a thesis. In fact, although the work on the corrector was 90% of his effort, Vernon’s thesis was on another subject altogether. In fact, this thesis is of some interest today because it was on the subject of left-right asymmetry in scattering from single atoms, a contrast technique that is now possible because of the success of correctors. The next significant event came while giving a series of lectures on electron optics to my research group, namely the theory of electron guns, round lenses, quadrupoles, and octupoles. After finishing the course one of the students (I think it was Marylin Listvan) pointed out that I had not mentioned sextupoles at all. This was enough to force me to calculate their properties. It is easy enough to write down the equations of motion and solve them in a series approximation. Of course, there was no first-order focusing and the second-order result was just what you would expect, a round beam would become a three-pointed star. The surprise came in the third-order result. It came as an astonishment that the third-order aberrations were cylindrically symmetric about the axis and of the opposite sign to those of round lenses (Crewe, 1980). (This result had also been noted by Hawkes but I was unaware of his result.) Any of my students will happily point out that my calculations are notoriously full of errors so they needed to be checked. David Kopf
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
11
performed the check, using his own methods and he found no errors (Crewe and Kopf, 1980a,b). So now we were in the position of having a very simple device, a sextupole, that had very desirable third-order properties because it could conceivably correct the aberrations of a round lens, but on the other hand, it had very undesirable second-order properties, producing a pronounced three-pronged star. The problem then was to find an electron optical system that eliminates the second-order focusing effect while retaining the third-order aberrations. It is very embarrassing to say that it took a few months before the solution appeared. I am reminded here of a story that I recently heard. It is that Winston Churchill once said ‘‘Americans always do the right thing— after trying everything else!’’ In this case, it was only by recalling the use of field lenses in light optics that the solution appeared. These lenses are often used to image one aperture onto the next one in order to preserve the intensity of the light. In our case, we can place a non-rotating round lens (actually two identical but opposing lenses) between two sextupoles, imaging one onto the other. With a suitable physical or electrical rotation between the two sextupoles the desired result is obtained, the second-order focusing effect can be removed because one sextupole cancels out the other, but the two thirdorder terms add (Crewe, 1982). This was published in July 1981 and became the basis for other work. For example, Shao and Jiye later added to the concept by considering the fifth-order aberrations as well and devising a way to control them (Crewe and Jiye, 1985; Jiye, Shao, and Crewe, 1985; Shao and Crewe, 1987). One of the advantages of using sextupoles is that the required excitation is small enough that one can use air coils—no iron is needed. With some funding from the National Science Foundation (NSF) we began construction of a 200-kV STEM with a sextupole corrector. This voltage was chosen so that the chromatic aberration caused by the inherent energy spread of the electron beam would not limit the final probe size. Unfortunately, when the microscope was more than half finished, their enthusiasm ran out and funding was terminated. We had to abandon the project. All was not lost, however, because Chen and Mu, who worked in the lab for a year or two each, returned to China and proceeded to build the sextupole corrector and installed it on an SEM column. They demonstrated that the total aperture aberration could be made to change sign using the same method as Deltrap (Chen and Mu, 1990). So the whole thing was not lost. It is unfortunate that their work is not widely recognized. The third—and maybe final—attempt at correction occurred as a result of an academic exercise, namely an attempt to develop electron optics ‘‘ab initio,’’ in a simplified notation, starting with uniform fields, a purely personal exercise. Surprisingly, the uniform field is normally treated in monographs, perhaps because it is too simple, but it is curious that there
12
A. V. Crewe
are many, many papers on the aberrations of various lenses, but none that I could recall that gave the aberration constants for uniform fields. Having considered the magnetic and the electrostatic fields separately, the next logical step was to consider a uniform magnetic field superimposed on a uniform electrostatic field with an arbitrary angle between them (Chen and Mu, 1990; Crewe, 1992a). The focusing properties are remarkably simple and the most interesting case was the magnetically focused electrostatic mirror. It turned out to have third-order aberrations with opposite sign to those of a round lens. It was then possible to design a system with zero aberrations. We built such a device (Crewe, 1992b), and Frank Tsai showed that he could indeed eliminate both chromatic and spherical aberration (Crewe et al., 2000; Tsai, 2000). He used the characteristics of the focused probe itself to do this. This concept remains a curiosity because it is difficult to design a useful optical system. The only one appears to be a STEM configuration. Once again we obtained DOE support for such a STEM system, and once again the funding was terminated when the project was incomplete. I have mentioned the funding problem several times now and I would like to add some comments on the subject. The first thing to be said is that the work in the early years was generously supported by the DOE and predecessors, but later we encountered a situation where there was no U.S. government agency that supported instrument development for its own sake. All agencies insisted upon having specific uses for any instrument project. Generalizations were not acceptable. It was useless to suggest that improved resolution is always needed and generates its own uses. Such statements were unacceptable. In the past I have even gone so far as to point out that Galileo could never have been funded if these rules are applied. He knew nothing of the moons of Jupiter before he took a look at the planet. Similarly, Hooke, who made the most fundamental discovery in biology—the cell—did not know that they were there until he looked. On the other hand, one could argue that it is entirely reasonable to insist on having a specific use in mind for a new instrument. In principle this sounds good, but there are some drawbacks. One of these is that the reviewers are drawn from the community of appropriate users. In my case this has meant that proposals are reviewed by biologists, who, in general, are not experts in microscope design or in solution to second-order differential equations. In fact, I have had at least two good proposals turned down because one of the reviewers gave a negative review but started out by saying, ‘‘ I know nothing about this subject but. . .’’ and then proceeded to prove it. Hardly a peer review! This attitude on the part of the agencies may be changing slowly because the NSF has recently supported one of our proposals for a low-voltage microscope. We can only applaud this change.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
13
In summary, the net result of our efforts in Chicago on the aberration problem is not very encouraging. We have had one technical failure (the quadrupole-octupole system), two funding failures (the sextupole and the STEM with the uniform field corrector), one vicarious success (the Chen–Mu sextupole system), and one real one (the magnetically focused mirror). But perhaps we did stimulate some ideas and help to keep the corrector business going.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author is deeply indebted to all the students, associates, and collaborators who are mentioned in the text, and perhaps to others if there have been any lapses of memory. At its peak, this laboratory was a hive of activity and all in it were self-starters. They needed only a few occasional suggestions and very little guidance in carrying out the work described above. Thanks are also due to the DOE and its predecessors who provided the funding for virtually all the research. Some of the later work was supported by the NSF and the Block fund of the University of Chicago. The author is also indebted to the NSF for the support of our current project.
3. ELECTRON MICROSCOPE STUDIES: ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE CREWE LAB* Progress Report DOE ER60437-7, for Period 1 July 1964 to 1 June 1992. By A. V. Crewe and O. H. Kapp, The University of Chicago, The Enrico Fermi Institute and The Department of Physics.
ABSTRACT This is a report covering the research performed in the Crewe laboratory between 1964 and 1992. Because of limitations of space we have provided relatively brief summaries of the major research directions of the facility during these years. A complete bibliography has been included and we have referenced groups of pertinent publications at the beginning of each section. This report summarizes our efforts to develop better electron microscopes and chronicles many of the experimental programs, in materials science and biology, that acted both as a stimulus to better microscope design and also as a testing ground for many instrumental innovations. * Notice: This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by the United States government. Neither
the United States not the Department of Energy, nor any of their employees, nor any of their contractors, subcontractors, or their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsbility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, productor process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privatcly owned rights.
14
A. V. Crewe
Introduction In the following pages we will attempt to chronicle the successes and the failures of the work of this laboratory from its inception in 1964 to the present. We will not try to cover all the administrative changes that have taken place, but merely note that the work began under the auspices of the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC), continued through the era of Energy Research and Development Administration (ERDA), and is now funded by the Department of Energy (DOE). These changes were not functionally important because for most of these years, in fact until the past year, the personnel in the program management in Washington were the same. It is impossible for us to tell the whole story in such a short space beause there is so much to tell. For example, our records indicate about 500 publications of various kinds, all the way from abstracts of presentations at the annual meetings of the microscope society to full-length papers to chapters of books. Our records do not indicate how many invited talks have been given, but that must number in the hundreds. As one example, for the purposes of writing this report, we counted the number of references to our work in the Citation Index in the past 12 years. We counted more than 1000 such references and this was only to full-length papers with my name as the first one on the paper. It does not count references to shorter publications or to papers with someone else’s name in first place. From this we can surmise that the total number of references to our work must be several thousand. We must conclude that our work has been appreciated. We should also say at the outset that the work in this laboratory has been done by a large number of people over a number of years. There have been about a dozen graduate students and about as many undergraduates, postgraduates, and other visitors. We will try to acknowledge all of them, but undoubtedly we will miss some. This research program began when the author was still the Director of Argonne National Laboratory, in 1963. At that time, I conceived a new principle for the construction of an electron microscope. The general idea was to focus a beam of electrons into a very small probe and then scan the probe across the specimen in a raster fashion. The electrons passing through the specimen would pass through an energy analyzer and selected electrons would be used to provide the contrast in the image. This concept was very new and it had the desirable property of separating the resolution (the probe size) from the contrast mechanism. However, it was completely unconventional. This type of microscope is now known as the STEM (scanning transmission electron microscope). At that time, we were unaware of the efforts in England to develop a scanning microscope that used a totally different contrast mechanism, the secondary electrons. This was a successful effort and that type of microscope came to be called the SEM (scanning electron microscope). Perhaps
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
15
it was a good thing that we knew nothing of this work since we might well have been very discouraged by the resolution calculations made by this group. They had come to the conclusion that a resolution better than ˚ was not possible! In fact, we had dimly appreciated this about 50 A problem, which is associated with the type of electron source that they were using and which was the only one known at the time. Independently, we had concluded that the source would be a problem and we had decided to use a field emission tip for our electron source, even though they did not really exist anywhere. After checking with experts in the laboratory that the idea really was a new one, a prototype version of such an instrument was designed and construction began. The mechanical parts were made in the Argonne shops while the electronics group designed and built the electronics. This was no easy task since the original concept involved the use of technology that was either not available at all or was only just coming into the marketplace. To take just one example, as we have pointed out above, the electron source was conceived to be a field emission source. While the phenomenon of field emission was well known, nobody had ever made an electron source based on this principle. The effect was still being used primarily for research into the effect itself. In fact, the vacuum levels that were needed for field emission were so far removed from the levels that could be maintained in a practical instrument that the experts in the field stated that it simply could not be done. We decided to produce the best possible vacuum and hope for the best. For the record, it is relevant here to present the objections and comments that were made about this proposal at the time. These adverse comments had no real effect since ‘‘peer review’’ had not then been conceived and I was the director of the laboratory and therefore had some freedom in the matter of decision making. The first objection wss the one given above, namely that field emission could not be made to work as a practical source of electrons. Specifically, we were told that the effect could only be seen when the vacuum level was in the 1015 torr range, a vacuum level that required the whole instrument to be placed in liquid helium, and that the best that could be done in a working instrument would be in the 1010 torr range, a difference of a factor of 105! The second objection was that no specimen could possibly tolerate a vacuum of 1010, and even if they did survive, they would not represent the real object, the structures would be completely destroyed. The third objection was that we could never maintain even the vacuum level of 1010 in a working instrument because we would have persistent vacuum leaks and in any case, the only vacuum equipment on the market were the pumps and a few types of feedthroughs, notably linear motions. No rotary motions or electrical feedthroughs could be bought.
16
A. V. Crewe
The fourth objection concerned the electronics. How could we possibly ˚ make the electronics stable enough to focus electrons into a spot a few A in diameter? The fifth objection was in the matter of a suitable image display system. The only image displays at the time were TV, which was then notably inferior, and oscilloscopes, which once again were so far short of the image quality available on the glass plates and film used in conventional electron microscopy as to be laughable. These comments were made by the experts in the various fields and were obtained by the simple expedient of talking to them and asking for advice. In fact, the only encouragement that I ever received was from people who knew nothing about technology but simply wanted better microscopes and welcomed any attempt to provide them. There is absolutely no doubt that a proposal to construct this microscope would never have passed a peer review. The objections were good ones and there were few if any replies that I could give. Nevertheless, we proceeded with the project in the belief that all these problems could be solved. Nowadays, this type of proposal does not stand a chance. The peer review system, while having its merits, effectively prevents an innovator from even trying to do what he believes to be possible. The system does not allow for the situation where there are no peers. This comment is not meant to be arrogant, nor is it to be taken in the intellectual sense of the word, but simply to say that it is quite impossible for an innovator to set down on paper all the relevant thoughts that pass through his mind. Any rational discussion of these thoughts would occupy many days of talk and may not even lead to a definite conclusion. Peer review by mail does not allow the opportunity for discussion and without this discussion it can easily turn into a vehicle for anonymous and even defamatory carping. We are reminded here of the recent explanations of the award of the Nobel Prize in economics to Prof. Coase here at the University of Chicago. Many years ago he presented his views to the faculty. At the start of the discussions the vote was 20 to 1 against him. Stigler has pointed out that the vote would have been even worse if Coase had not been allowed to vote! At the end of a very long discussion, the vote was 21 to 0 in favor of his views. One wonders what might have happened if he had been forced to pass a peer review by mail in order to be able to proceed with his work. It would never have been done.
Construction (Reference Group A) When we began the design and construction of the instrument, nobody at Argonne (or indeed almost anywhere else) had experience with ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) engineering and we all had to learn. Although there were some commercially available vacuum seals, we were forced to
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
17
design many custom versions. The vacuum vessel that was built at that time is still in use and has never suffered from vacuum leaks. It is now 27 years old and still viable. It may be of some interest that the person who did the welding of all the mechanical joints was Frank Meyer. A few years later he put his experience to good use and founded Meyer Tool and Engineering Co. here in Illinois. This company specializes in highvacuum and cryogenic fabrication and is known throughout the United States. He does a great deal of work for Argonne and Fermilab. At the very least this project gave the design and fabrication groups at Argonne some much needed experience and led to the formation of an industrial company of some size and competence.
Source Development (Reference Group B) At Argonne I was joined by the first three graduate students who worked in my laboratory, Wall, Isaacson, and Johnson. Together, we decided to find out how to build and operate a field emission source. For this purpose we designed and built a special unit for the rapid testing of the sources and in the course of about two years we began to understand the process and how to obtain good performance. That work has continued to this day, because we still do not know enough. Nevertheless, we learned enough in those two years that we could operate a field emission source for a sufficient length of time to have a practical microscope. What we learned was that while the total emission current was far less in our kind of vacuum than that in a more perfect one, we could nevertheless obtain enough current for our needs. This was totally unpredicted. As our work proceeded, we were able to operate our tips for a day, then a week, then a month, and finally, for several years without having to change them. This meant that our sources were even more reliable than even the very best conventional source. This, again, was totally unexpected and so out of the ordinary that very few people believed our results. It was during this period that we were successful in obtaining our first images in the microscope. These images were unremarkable as regards the resolution but they did demonstrate that unusual contrast could be obtained. In fact, we published some images taken at various energy loss intervals. These images were the first to indicate the analytical power of the instrument and in that respect, it was the ancestor of many modern instruments. Shortly after this work I resigned as laboratory director in order to return to the University of Chicago and the instrument was taken to the University. At that time, the AEC (as it was then) decided to continue support of the project and placed it in the biological science area. This was an arbitrary decision since the research was applicable to many areas of science but until recently this has not been a problem. This is a very important point in view of the recent difficulties that we have
18
A. V. Crewe
encountered. The attitude of the program managers was always that the work was of high quality and that it could be considered to be a success even if the work did not directly benefit the biological sciences. As a result of this, we have always felt free to pursue productive lines of thought even if the ultimate benefit was to the material sciences anywhere else. It would be a great loss if ideas generated in one area could not be followed through simply because of the narrow interests of the immediate source of funding. We have never been prevented from following our own noses but it appears now that this concept is not universally appreciated.
STEM Development and Atomic Images (Reference Group C) In the period after our return to the University, we made several improvements to the microscope, but found that we could not obtain a resolution ˚ and we then began some investigations into the better than about 10 A theory of probe formation, an effort that continues today. We soon found that we had set our apertures incorrectly and when the aperture was ˚ . However, properly adjusted, the resolution immediately improved to 5 A this was not the end of the story. We had been joined by Elmar Zeitler who was on a one-year leave of absence. He gave our group some seminars on electron scattering and it became evident to me from these talks that our electron collection system could be improved. This inspired the idea of the annular detector for the elastically scattered electrons, perhaps the most important of all the contrast mechanisms. After installing an annular ˚ all the time, but we detector, we found that our resolution was really 2.5 A had not been able to see it because the contrast was too low. In turn, this led to other ideas, notably that the use of the annular detector together with the energy loss spectrometer allowed us to provide almost complete separation between the elastic and the inelastic electrons. This meant that we were in a position to measure the mass of particles in the microscope and to measure the atomic number. Two pieces of information and two unknowns to solve for, the classical mathematical situation. Since that time, mass measurement and ‘‘Z’’ contrast have become very important, the one in biology and the other more recently in materials science. As we began to take images of smaller and smaller particles, we found that we could even obtain excellent images of unstained single-stranded DNA. something that could not be done in a conventional microscope. This led me to do the first calculations on the possibility of obtaining images of isolated atoms. The calculations indicated that this was easily done for the case of heavy atoms. Accordingly we looked around for a suitable sample and we were fortunate to have the cooperation of Michael Beer from Johns Hopkins. He brought along a sample of a thorium compound that he had been experimenting with for the purpose of
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
19
staining amino acids in DNA. All attempts to image the atoms in this or any other specimen had failed. We were able to obtain clear images on the very first attempt. Later, we continued to pursue this capability, pushing it as far as it would go. We imaged lighter and lighter atoms, finding a practical limit at about zinc. We also tried to answer our critics (and there were many) by taking several successive images of the same atoms. To this date, I do not believe that anyone can do this using a conventional microscope. The act of viewing destroys that area of the specimen. But we could indeed do it because we had carefully investigated the contamination problem and learned how to control it. These lessons are still not heeded by most microscope operators. The final demonstration of our capabilities was the production of movies showing the motion of atoms on the surface of the specimen, movies which involved taking hundreds of successive images of the same atoms. These movies were taken in 1974, long before anyone else could obtain even one image of an atom. Perhaps it is worthwhile to point out that very few people have been able to match this performance. The instrument that was put on the market by Vacuum Generators did not have a high enough resolution to be able to image single atoms until the introduction of their new machine just two years ago. Hitachi built a STEM for their research laboratory about 1980 and produced atom images, but they never introduced it to the market. Apart from that, the only microscopes that are able to image single atoms are the ones at Brookhaven (one of them is from Johns Hopkins) whose designs are heavily based on ours. The concept of the original instrument (now called the STEM) was taken up by only one company, Vacuum Generators of England. They simply took our basic design and turned it upside down for convenience. In all other respects, it was identical to ours. There is no doubt at all that they violated the patents that were taken out by the AEC. Although I pointed this out to the AEC, they did nothing about it and I was informed that no royalties were ever received. In light of the fact that they have sold instruments with a total value in the neighborhood of 50 million dollars, these royalties alone could easily have kept our laboratory operating.
The Field Emission SEM (Reference Group D) Shortly before we all returned to the University we decided to adapt the field emission source to the SEM microscopes then being developed in Cambridge, England. When we calculated the resolution that we might expect, we found that we did not need any magnetic lenses in order to be able to compete with the miscroscopes then being sold. We found that our electron gun could provide all the focusing power that we needed. Naturally, this approach would not have been adequate for a commercial instrument
20
A. V. Crewe
because it could not provide the flexibility of operation that would be needed for general use. Nevertheless, we felt that there was a place for such a simplified approach. At the University we succeeded in making this device work and we took many images with it. In fact, we used no lenses at all except for the lens action of the gun itself and we were able to demonstrate a resolution equal to the very best that could be done anywhere. This concept was taken up by one of the engineers who worked on the project at Argonne. He teamed up with Vincent Coates and they formed their own company, Coates and Welter. They produced the very first commercial instruments that used field emission sources. Their microscope design was almost identical to the one that we worked on together. This company was eventually sold to American Optical and then later the technology was sold back to Coates, who founded Nanometrics, a company that still makes field emission microscopes, primarily for the semiconductor industry. One other company took up our ideas and developed instruments and that is Hitachi of Japan. They decided to take our advice that field emission sources were the only ones capable of allowing the production of high-resolution SEM instruments. They invested an enormous amount of effort into this program, with spectacular results. Violating no patents, because they were only interested in the SEM, which was not covered by those patents, they developed many high-performace instruments over the years. We have been reliably informed that they have sold more than 1700 microscopes with a total value that must be close to 500 million dollars. In view of this success, all the major manufacturers are now selling field emission microscopes, and it may not be long before all microscopes are of this kind. It would be safe to say that this laboratory is the source of a billion dollar industry.
Energy Loss and Radiation Damage (Reference Group E) When we decided to build the instrument described above, the development of the SEM was not our main concern. We were really more interested in the interaction of the electron beam with the specimen in the microscope. It was well known, of course, that the electron beam produces damage in the specimen and there had been demonstrations of the loss of information in the diffraction pattern obtained from crystalline specimens. Unfortunately, there was little if any numerical data, principally because the conventional TEM is not a quantitative device. Also, since we had installed a spectrometer on the STEM in the faith and belief that the information obtained from it would be useful for image contrast, we needed to know more about the processes involved. For these various reasons, we had installed a spectrometer of our own design on the simple SEM and we began a series of experiments to study
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
21
the phenomena of energy loss and specimen damage. The work was done by a succession of graduate students, among them were Isaacson, Johnson, Lin, and Ramamurti. Since one of our primary targets was DNA, the first specimens that were studied were the four bases and later we included some amino acids. In each case, we could measure the rate of destruction of the specimen in terms of mass loss, loss of the energy loss peaks, and loss of diffraction information. Using all this knowledge, we could put together a more or less complete picture of the damage process. We could even connect these processes in a general way with the known radiation chemistry (the G- values). It is interesting that this picture was complete enough that Unwin returned to Cambridge from a conference in Europe where I presented these results and then used them to design his famous experiment (with Henderson) on the imaging of the purple membrane. In fact, our series of experiments were conclusive enough that the numbers that were produced are the ones still in use today. They provide the basis for taking the steps needed to avoid radiation damage.
Secondary Electron Production (Reference Group F) One other significant experiment that was done with this setup was an investigation into the origin of secondary electrons. This work was done by Voreades and is not generally known in the community. He chose to publish his results in a rather obscure journal. Since the results were used for his thesis he was entirely in control of the publication of his data. In fact, the data was very important and eventually led me to reconsider the resolution limits of the SEM and this investigation had far-reaching effects. Acting on my suggestion, Voreades set up an arrangement for detecting the secondary electrons in time coincidence with the energy loss electrons. In this way he could show that all regions of the energy loss spectrum contributed to the secondary electron current and that the electrons came from a very thin region near the surface. In carbon, this ˚ thick. For heavier materials, the layer corresponded to a layer only 20 A was even thinner. This result allowed us to generate a picture of the process whereby energy loss events produce secondary electrons that wander around in the body of the material and emerge from the surface if they have enough energy to escape. This is a simple model and it works.
DNA Labeling (Reference Group G) The story of the DNA labeling experiments is an interesting one with both good news and bad. It has relevance for the work now underway on the human genome project.
22
A. V. Crewe
When we demonstrated that single atoms could be seen in the microscope, one of the students (Langmore) decided to try to use this capability for visually sequencing strands of DNA. In the final version, the idea was to replicate single strands of DNA using thiolated bases. If this could be done selectively, the bases could then be labeled with mercury since the sulphur atom was exposed and reactive. The microscope would then be used to determine the spacing of the labels. The whole process could then be repeated by using different thiolated bases so that in the end there would be a great deal of redundancy in the data and sequencing should be virtually unambiguous. Langmore succeeded in doing all the wet chemistry and was able to demonstrate that the various steps were all feasible and the reactions were selective enough to ensure success. This feat alone deserves a medal! The difficulty came when the specimen was put into the microscope. What he observed was that the mercury atoms moved away from their original positions and the movement was large enough that the whole experiment was doomed. In fact, it was Langmore who first noted the movement of atoms on the surface of the carbon film, an observation that led us to investigate this whole phenomenon. That investigation took too long to be of any value in the sequencing attempt and Langmore eventually worked on a different specimen for his thesis. That series of experiments on the motion of single atoms indicated that the atoms were moving entirely due to their thermal energy, or rather the ratio of the thermal energy to the binding energy on the film. One can conclude from this that it may yet be possible to do the type of experiment that Langmore envisaged. What would be needed would be a system with a higher atom-carbon binding energy and to operate at low temperatures. Unfortunately, we have never had another student who wanted to try to develop this technology, but this does not invalidate the conclusion.
Nucleosomes (Reference Group H) The specimen that Langmore chose for his thesis was the nucleosome. He obtained very good images of them and used the data that had been obtained on the energy loss problem in a very clever way. He allowed the specimen to become damaged by the radiation and used the fact that the DNA was less sensitive to radiation damage than the protein. In this way he could determine the location of the DNA and he proposed a structure for the nucleosome. It is noteworthy what happened next. After graduation he went to the Medical Research Counsel (MRC) in Cambridge, England, where he wanted to continue the work on nucleosomes but was not allowed to since that problem was reserved for some of the ‘‘greats.’’ The structure of nucleosomes that was eventually published
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
23
by the Cambridge group was virtually identical to Langmore’s structure, but his work only received a glancing reference!
Attempts at Aberration Correction (Reference Group I) It is well known that the limiting factors in the resolution of the electron microscope are the effects of the lens aberrations. This was fully recognized in the early days and the whole problem of lens aberrations has received a lot of attention over the years. The major contribution to this problem was made by Scherzer in 1936 when he showed that the aberration coefficients of the lenses are always of the same sign. The coefficient of spherical aberration is negative and that of chromatic aberration is positive. He was very careful to state the conditions under which this statement is true and the result is known today as Scherzer’s theorem. It applies to static fields with cylindrical symmetry and when the fields are defined by Laplace. This theorem implies that the aberration coefficients can never be zero, although this can only be inferred. Many people have confirmed his results (including me) and it can be assumed that he was absolutely correct. In effect, we showed that the only fields that can give zero coefficients are quite impractical because they involve fields that go to infinity at some point. It is natural then to try to design lenses with smaller aberrations. Many investigators have tried to do this over the past 50 years or so and it is reasonably safe to assume that everything that can be done in this direction has been done. In fact, the situation is a very difficult one. The coefficent of chromatic aberration is closely equal to the focal length of the lens and the only possiblilty is to reduce that number. Even if the required field strengths could be obtained, there would be no room for the specimen. In addition, the resolution limit defined by the chromatic aberration depends on the square root of the coefficient. This means that if we want to make an improvement of a factor of two, we need to improve the aberration coefficient by a factor of four. The situation is even worse when the limit of resolution is determined by the spherical aberration. This coefficient is, at best, about one half the focal length and the resolution depends on the fourth root of the coefficient so that an improvement by a factor of two means that the coefficient of spherical aberration must be reduced by a factor of sixteen. It can be said quite positively that no such factor can be found by design improvements. It was clear to Scherzer that the limit of resolution could only be reduced by using field distributions that avoided one or more of the constraints that he had identified. In 1946 he devised a system of multipole lenses that together could act as a correction system for a normal
24
A. V. Crewe
lens. Over the course of the next few years he and his students investigated the optical requirements of this corrector and came to some alarming conclusions. In particular, they discovered that the alignment requirements were very severe indeed. For example, all the 40 or so pole pieces needed to be placed in their proper positions within one tenth of a micron. This, of course, is mechanically impossible. Some encouragement was obtained when Deltrap published his thesis for work done in Cambridge. He constructed a model of the Scherzer corrector, scaling up the system to bench size in order to be able to test the functionality without, of course, being able to obtain high resolution. He simply wanted to show that the general principle would work. It did. In due time, the Scherzer group devised ways to overcome all the problems, at least on paper. Construction began around 1970 but the system never worked. Shortly before he died, Scherzer wrote that the primary reason for the failure was the inadequate financial support for the project. I personally believe that he was quite correct in this conclusion. At that time, this was the most ambitious electron optical project ever conceived but the manpower that he had available was very limited. Even while our group was still at Argonne, I began to think about the problem of aberration correction because it was certain that sooner or later we would run into the resolution problem. It seemed to me that the corrector design problem would be different for a STEM than for a conventional microscope and I asked David Cohen to look into the problem. He enlisted some outside help and eventually came up with a design that looked simpler than the Scherzer one. I redesigned the system to fit the parameters of our microscope and looked around for someone to build it. Here, we were fortunate that we had decided to return to the University of Chicago because there we found perhaps the only person in the country with the skills to fabricate the lenses to the tolerances that seemed necessary. That was Walter Mankowich. Over the course of the next few years he devised a method of making the pole pieces that seemed to be good enough. In fact, when the system was finally assembled, all 40 pole pieces were within 1 micron of their design positions, a truly remarkable feat. Naturally we knew that this would not be good enough for the system to work properly and we had incorporated trimming coils to provide the final adjustment. It turned out later that Scherzer had instituted essentially the same system of trimming coils. In the meantime, we had built a special microscope for testing the corrector. This was a 100-kV instrument that was put together by Vernon Beck, the graduate student who wanted to attempt the correction. Unfortunately, we could never make the corrector work. The reasons were varied, but the main reason was that the mechanical center of the multipole lenses was very different from the magnetic center and in addition, the magnetic center moved around with the excitation so that we could
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
25
never align the system and maintain this alignment. After many heartbreaking attempts, we were forced to admit defeat. Until 1980, the Scherzer corrector was the only known method for correcting aberrations in the electron microscope, and as we have just pointed out, it could not be made to work. However, in that year we invented a new method that looked very promising. In some purely theoretical studies on the electron optical properties of the various multipole elements, we discovered that the third-order aberration of a sextupole lens is cylindrically symmetric and has the opposite sign of aberration from that of a round lens. Some time later, we devised a system of lenses that can use this effect to form a new type of corrector. The publication of the sextupole corrector paper attracted a great deal of attention and in the interval since then a number of people have checked the calculations using a variety of different methods. There is universal agreement that the calculations are correct and that a corrector can be made. We carefully investigated the construction problem and evaluated a few different options. One was to build a demonstration column that would simply confirm that the principle would work. Such a column would not have the high-resolution possibilities of a full-scale version. Another option was to build a system that would have the high-resolution capabilities. To do this, however, meant that we would have to build an entirely new piece of equipment. The reason for this is that correcting the spherical aberration alone would not give a convincing improvement in the case of a microscope operating at the voltage that we normally use (30 kV). Chromatic aberration becomes important surprisingly soon. We looked at this problem very carefully and in doing so we were forced to reevaluate the limiting factors in the resolution capabilities of all probe forming microscopes. As we will show later, this work led to some very significant improvements in other microscopes. In fact, the whole sextupole corrector project will have been worth the effort even if it never works! In the end, we proposed the construction of a 200-kV STEM with a sextupole correcting element. This proposal was made to the National Science Foundation (NSF) and was eventually funded, but not at the requested level. The entire system of lenses and corrector has been designed and everything has been fabricated with the exception of a few portions of the electronics. Some of the components have also been tested. Unfortunately, the support has not been adequate for completion of the project and progress has therefore been very slow in recent years. It should be noted that two of the visitors who worked in our laboratory, Er-gang Chen and Mu, returned to China and began working on the problem of the sextupole corrector. They chose to build a simpler version that they could use for demonstration purposes. Within the past year or so they have produced real evidence that the corrector works. They have
26
A. V. Crewe
done this in the same way that Deltrap showed the original Scherzer corrector works. They will eventually try to obtain high resolution and we wish them well. Until this past summer, the sextupole corrector was still the only corrector that shows promise of allowing the design and construction of an electron microscope of super-high resolution in the normal voltage range for transmission microscopes. However, we have now invented a new method of aberration correction that seems to be much simpler. One of the electron optical elements that Scherzer did not take into account and which is excluded by his theorem is the electron mirror. It has been known for decades that the mirror has the property that the sign of both aberration coefficients are opposite to those in the normal round lens. The difficulty has always been that the first-order properties of the mirror are difficult to deal with and the mirror optics themselves have never been given much scrutiny. A discussion of the properties of the mirror can be found in old texts such as Zworykin, but one finds little encouragement there for the construction of a working system. Nevertheless, there have been several investigations in the past and recently the mirror was revived by Rempfer, who proposed an idea for a corrector. It is reasonably certain that the Rempfer idea will not work, at least for high-resolution systems, for a variety of reasons that are too complicated for discussion here. We began our own investigation into mirrors quite recently and during the past summer, we developed some new ideas on a particular form of mirror that seems to have all the desirable properties without any of the ‘‘side effects.’’ We developed a complete proposal for a mirror corrector and have transmitted a proposal containing that idea to the NSF. This mirror corrector has the nice property that both spherical and chromatic aberration can be corrected. It is interesting that we cannot yet confirm the details of operation of the corrector using numerical calculations because there do not appear to be any numerical methods for the solution of this type of problem. The difficulty is the reversal of the direction of motion. It may be that there are some techniques that can be used but we have not yet found them. However, there is no doubt that correction can occur because the physics of the problem is very simple and the effect can easily be demonstrated on paper. At the moment we are developing an extension of the principle that might allow the design of a super-high-resolution SEM. In summary, we can say that in 1946 Scherzer invented a corrector. He worked on the problem for more than 35 years and was unable to make it work. We tried to make the same kind of corrector work and we also failed. In 1980 we invented a second type of corrector. That corrector is still under construction here and the Chinese have also begun to develop the idea. Our work has been impeded by lack of funds. In 1991
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
27
we invented a third corrector and this one seems to be simpler than the others and more likely to work. We believe that this general concept will lead to yet another corrector, this time for the SEM. Such a development would have significant applications in biology and also in the semiconductor industry. Finally, as we will see later, this whole problem area led us to a reassessment of the resolution problem and to general improvements in the microscope business that are still having ramifications today.
Theoretical Electron Optics (Reference Group J) Throughout this whole period we have been interested in the theoretical aspects of electron optics and although this is not our main activity, it has often been necessary to extend the field in order for us to proceed with the experimental work. As one example, we have performed countless calculations of the properties of magnetic lenses. The vast majority of these calculations have never been published because it was felt that they had no general interest to the community. Nevertheless, these calculations have given us a unique insight into the properties of lenses and that, in turn, has enabled us to design lenses for particular purposes with far more confidence than we could have done otherwise. It may be noted that lens design is as much an art as it is a science. It is surely possible to calculate the focal properties of any lens that one cares to specify. The problem is how to specify the lens in the first place. Only by having the experience can one guess at the most appropriate design for a particular purpose. In other words, one gets to know where not to look. Our interest in the problem of aberrations has also forced us into theoretical electron optics. Not only were we motivated to develop the theory for our correctors, but it was also necessary to investigate very carefully the foundations of Scherzer’s theorem. This led to some interesting, if academic, conclusions that had not been noticed previously. In fact, we were able to give convincing proof that zero aberrations could only be obtained with magnetic fields that have pathological parameters and cannot be made in practice. We have described some of our other efforts in theory above, but we can add here a brief description of our latest efforts. Over the course of twenty-five years or so, we have developed a set of what we might call ‘‘rules of thumb’’ for the design of lenses and electron guns. These rules seemed to work, but were not based on any known theory. We set out to develop that theory about two years ago. In a series of three papers we took a close look at the focal properties of weak lenses, both electrostatic and magnetic. We developed a theory and performed some careful calculations to verify the results. The calculations were not easy to perform for the simple reason that we were looking at the extreme
28
A. V. Crewe
case of very weak lenses and this takes an inordinate amount of computer time. Fortunately, we have our own mainframe computer so that we could afford the time. The results were extremely interesting and have now been published. This allows anyone to obtain approximate values for the focal length and the aberration coefficients of both types of lens. These approximations are good enough that they also work even for stronger lenses. The most recent theoretical work was described above, namely the study of the motion of electrons in uniform fields. These calculations were described in the section on aberration correction. It might be suspected that this type of field had been thoroughly investigated in the past since it is an obvious problem. Indeed, this is true except for the fact that these were very early investigations by the pioneers in the field and the algebra was done long ago, long before the question of aberrations had been raised and before they had been well defined. Since we could not find an adequate treatment of the problem in the literature, it seemed worthwhile to write down the equations and solve them. We looked at four separate configurations of magnetic and electrostatic fields and obtained the solutions to the equations of motion. The interesting thing was that we found that two of the configurations had aberrations of the opposite sign to the normal ones. This raised several issues and suggested several applications of the ideas. Two of the applications are in the area of high-resolution microscopy and will be the subject of our renewal proposal. Other possibilities include improved mass spectromenters and improvements to ion microscopes.
Optimization and the Super-High-Resolution SEM (Reference Group K) The work that we did on the optimization of the parameters of scanning microscopes bears some discussion here. A few years ago it became apparent that the resolution of the SEM was ˚ . The microscopes from all the manufacturers had the stuck at about 15 A same resolution and it appeared that nothing could be done about it. Many investigators were concerned with this issue and our involvement in it was motivated by a suggestion by a distinguished colleague that the only way to obtain better resolution would be to design and build a 200-kV SEM. This was obviously bad physics because it completely ignored the non-local nature of the production of secondary electrons. It should be noted that it may be unfair to criticize that colleague since we had considerably more experience with this problem. Not only had we done some research in the area of secondary electron production (see the discussion above), but we had some earlier experience with the
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
29
theory of cloud chambers and bubble chambers and other detectors in high-energy physics. The general concept of non-local inelastic scattering is common knowledge in those areas, but not in microscopy, although any graduate student in physics ought to have some familiarity with the concept. In any case, it seemed important to perform an in-depth study of the physics of the resolution problem. We had already begun such a study for the STEM and it was a natural extension to consider the SEM. With regard to the STEM, the factors to be studied included spherical aberration, and diffraction. In our case, since we were considering the possibility of correcting the spherical aberration, the particular focus was on the effect of the fifth-order aperture aberration. These calculations were done using wave-optical analysis and represented the best that could be done with the problem. We had hoped that this study would put to rest forever the gross approximation to the resolution problem that occurred often in the literature, namely taking the r.m.s. of all these effects, an operation that is akin to taking the average of an apple, an orange, and a banana. Unfortunately, that statement still appears and we have given up correcting the authors. In the case of the SEM, which operates at lower voltages and where the contrast mechanism uses inelastic scattering, we must take into account the fact that these collisions can occur at large distances from the elec˚. trons. That is to say, the classical impact parameter can be several A Fortunately, we were well aware of this problem in microscopy since it is this fact that limits the use of inelastic scattering for high resolution images in the STEM. We have often demonstrated this by taking simultaneous images of atoms using elastic and inelastic electrons. At 35 kV, the effect is very obvious and we had already published the data. It was then only necessary to extend the argument to the case of the SEM. The conclusions of this study were that with proper optimization of the aperture in the SEM, using wave-optical calculations instead of gross ˚ , and that the best averaging, the resolution should improve to about 5–7 A operating voltage would be about 5 kV. The only manufacturer who listened to these arguments and did something about it was Hitachi, although all of them had access to the information. Hitachi designed a special instrument, the 900 series, and it ˚ to 7 A ˚. worked. Overnight, the best resolution of the SEM went from 15 A It took several years before the other manufacturers caught up with Hitachi, but today virtually all of them offer such an instrument, with the exception of the one U.S. manufacturer (Amray). We believe that this one contribution would justify the whole cost of our research support.
30
A. V. Crewe
Image Processing (Reference Group L) As a result of the measurements that we made on the radiation sensitivity of biological materials, we began to investigate the imaging properties of our microscope. The conventional electron microscope was very well suited for the study of molecules that could be crystallized into a regular array. This was the technique that was used by Unwin and Henderson in their study of the purple membrane. They were able to reconstruct the molecule from the information in the diffraction pattern, information that came from many different molecules. By using many different molecules to provide an image of just one, they could minimize the effects of radiation damage. We could not do this with the same degree of efficiency and therefore we would tend to produce more damage in the specimen. The reverse side of the coin is that the conventional microscope is not very good for taking images of molecules that cannot be formed into a regular array. Many molecules are such that they can only be imaged one at a time. On the other hand, the STEM can provide very good images of isolated molecules and the contrast is so good that excellent images can be obtained with far less dose than in the conventional TEM. We therefore began a program of imaging molecules and developing digital image processing techniques to take advantage of these capabilities. The first work in this area was by Golladay, who studied negatively stained myosin. By careful digital analysis of the image, working line by line and doing very careful averaging, he was able to locate the uranyl atoms with considerable precision. In doing so he introduced us to the general idea of digital image processing. Partially because of this success, we began to develop a more complete processing system using a Nova computer with the vast (for then) memory of 32 k. In order to avoid the repetitious work of programming, we developed an interactive image processing system where most of the operations could be done using a trackball and cursor. Later this capability was transferred to the IBM mainframe when we acquired one. We used the same philosophy and we have continued to add to its capabilities. The net result is a very powerful image processing system that can be operated by inexperienced operators. Virtually everything can be done without the need to do any programming at all. More recently, this program has been rewritten and transferred to a workstation environment since the capabilities of these devices are now at least as good as our original mainframe. The use of this system will be described in subsequent sections.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
31
Three-Dimensional Reconstruction (Reference Group M) The hemoglobin program in this laboratory initially concentrated on the use of low-dose images because this opened up several new possibilities. Specifically, by adding many such images together we could produce one image with good signal to noise ratio without sustaining the commensurate amount of damage. In this way we could produce the same quality of image that can be obtained from a conventional microscope when the specimen can be formed into two-dimensional ordered arrays. Unfortunately, this cannot be done with hemoglobin but our low-dose method is potentially just as good and the STEM can operate with lower doses than a conventional microscope. The images that were obtained by this method were very good indeed and furthermore, we were able to obtain images in three different projections, corresponding to three views taken 45 degrees apart. It was therefore natural to think of performing some kind of reconstruction in order to look at the molecule in 3D. Unfortunately, there was no existing algorithm to do this and there were many indications that it could not be done at all. All the algorithms for 3D reconstruction required many different views and indeed, required them to be taken at regular intervals. We simply could not do this; we had only three views but the images were of high quality. In considering this problem it seemed possible that other investigators had ignored some factors and that they were using other methods that had inherent inconsistencies. First of all, the only method that we could find that seemed to apply to our specimen was a form of algebraic reconstruction. In this method the first step is to add the three projections together into a 3D array. This step appeared to be wrong and indeed we felt that it could conceivably introduce significant errors. The reason for the suspicion is that any reasonable operation on the data ought to at least retain zeros. That is to say, if there is no mass apparent at a particular location in the image, then this is a valuable piece of information that must be maintained. The algebraic method does not do this. That first step can introduce mass into one of the projections from one of the others. We preferred to think of the problem in terms of probabilities. If a certain mass density is seen at a particular location in one of the projections, that mass has an equal probability of being found at any of the locations along the line of sight. The characteristic of probabilities is that they must be multiplied together, not added. Therefore our first step consists of multiplying the three projections together in order to find the starting point for the reconstruction. This automatically retains all zeros. The point that appeared to have been missed is that the biological material that we are using in the microscope has a uniform density.
32
A. V. Crewe
If there is any material at all at a particular point, then it has everywhere the same density. There either is or is not some material at a lattice point. The problem is then a Boolean one. We are looking for ones and zeros, with nothing in between. Given these two facts, our reconstruction problem reduces to utter simplicity. We multiply the probabilities in order to obtain a starting 3D matrix. We then take the maximum value and assume that there is indeed a one at that point. The value that existed at that point is then replaced with a one and the matrix is recalculated. Once again, the maximum value is replaced with a one and so on until the total mass discovered equals the total mass of the original object. Surprisingly, the method worked, although the first run took a great deal of computer time. Subsequently the method has been refined in order to increase the speed. The reconstructions obtained by this method and the various refinements that have been added since are the best that have ever been obtained of this molecule and the data matches that obtained subsequently elsewhere. All the evidence that we have indicates that this method does produce an accurate reconstruction.
Hemoglobin Work (Reference Group N) We have had a program of study into the structure and function of the invertebrate hemoglobins that has extented over the past thirteen years. The invertebrate hemoglobins represent a very broad range of respiratory proteins both in terms of structure and function. Their morphology can vary from single myoglobin-sized subunits to aggregates of several million molecular weight. In addition, their functional characteristics are complex and represent a variety of solutions to the need to deliver oxygen to tissue under profoundly different environmental conditions such as deep sea hydrothermal vents and oxygen-depleted polluted rivers. As a result of this complexity they represent attractive candidates for the study of structure-function relationships. Our primary approach has been to modify the protein using biochemical techniques, observe the attendant functional modifications, and relate this to the observed structure in the STEM. This work began when a graduate student of Serge Vinogradov (O. Kapp) traveled to our laboratory in the Fall of 1979 seeking STEM examination of his hemoglobin preparations. Kapp learned the use of the STEM from our then chief technician, Mitsuo Ohtsuki. Ultimately Kapp’s thesis included a large amount of work done in this laboratory. Following his thesis defense (Spring 1982) he joined our group as a research associate. When Dr. Ohtsuki returned to Japan in 1985, Kapp took over the operation of the microscopes and presently holds positions at the Enrico Fermi Institute and also an assistant professorship in the Biological Sciences Division.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
33
A particularly significant aspect of this work was the close working relationship of a biochemist with a top-notch electron microscope technician and physics-oriented graduate students. Generally, close proximity of the aforementioned groups is rare and the usual condition is one in which there are problems of communication due to everything from lack of physical proximity to differences in culture and language that are a natural part of the indoctrination of each discipline. Our research into 3D reconstruction techniques was stimulated by the desire of Kapp to obtain 3D structural data from STEM images of his preparations. Three of our Ph.D. students worked on this topic and a substantial number of publications resulted. In addition to obtaining 3D reconstuctions of several invertebrate hemoglobins, we were able to obtain reconstructions of depleted preparations in which one or more subunits were missing. With this team we were able to correlate the results of biochemical separation techniques such as column chromatograhy and Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate (SDS) electrophoresis with data from the STEM and subsequently obtained differential reconstructions which mapped the location of the missing subunits by comparison with the 3D map of the native molecules. One of the earliest observations we made by STEM of the invertebrate hemoglobins was the greater-than-expected dimensions obtained for intact, native dodecamers. The annelid extracellular hemoglobins are composed of a bilayer of hexameric structures forming a complex with a ˚ and a height of about 200 A ˚ . All previous reports diameter of about 300 A of this group of proteins pointed towards dimensions of about 250 160 ˚ . Because the STEM has no post-specimen optics and images are taken A in-focus our dimensions are likely to be more reliable because of the absence of phase contrast reversal effects at an unknown resolution limit. Our dimensions were corroborated by the dimensions obtained for wet crystals of Lumbricus hemoglobin by Prof. Warner Love. This along with other observations led us to believe that STEM of negatively stained specimens of these proteins provided useful and meaningful results. One of the first experiments we performed in the STEM was the examination of the alkaline dissociation products obtained by exposure of Lumbricus hemoglobin to pH 9 for 24 hours followed by column chromatography to separate the various size classes. In addition, these fractions were combined and re-exposed to neutral pH to generate a reassociated molecule. This observation led to experiments in which we would remove various subunits and observe the subsequent effect on the reassociation process. Subtle changes in the morphology of the reassociated molecule could be observed using false-color display. For example, a 5% difference in scattering cross-section of the 1/12th subunit, a difference not visible in grey-level display, was easily discerned using a color
34
A. V. Crewe
palette of just 256 colors. We demonstrated that these subtle structural alterations were reproducible and were associated with dramatic changes in the functional characteristics of the molecule. For instance, the intact, native hemoglobin of Lumbricus displays a Hill coefficient n of about 4.3 at neutral pH. The reassociated molecule, however, provided values of about 2.3, the same value obtained for the putative 1/12th subunit. We also observed the dissociation-reassociation process described above for hemoglobin preparations that had been exposed to acid pH and then returned to neutral pH. The same functional alterations in the molecule were also observed. This work then led to the examination of preparations in which one or more subunits were removed before reassociation. One of the most striking results obtained with the STEM was the observation of hexagonal bilayers in preparations of Lumbricus hemoglobin in which the smallest heme-containing subunit (by SDS–PAGE) was completely absent. The location of this subunit was approximated by subtracting the 3D reconstruction of the native hemoglobin from the 3D reconstruction of the depleted preparation. The central hole in the molecule was nearly identical in size in the two preparations and it was thus assumed that the depletion about the outer periphery of the reassociated molecule was due to the absence of this particular subunit. Our research into 3D reconstruction techniques was stimulated by a desire to obtain 3D structural data from STEM images of various biological specimens. Three of our Ph.D. students worked on this topic and a substantial number of publications resulted. In addition to obtaining 3D reconstuctions of several invertebrate hemoglobins, we were able to obtain reconstructions of depleted preparations (described above) in which one or more subunits were missing. With this team we were able to correlate the results of biochemical separation techniques such as column chromatograhy and SDS electrophoresis with data from the STEM and other techniques such as neutron scattering and low-angle x-ray scattering. One of the problems encountered in the reconstruction of non-periodic objects is the determination of the relative orientation in which the biological macromolecule appears on the substrate. We looked at this problem using multivariate statistical techniques and developed algorithms for classification of molecules into subgroups according to orientation. This work began with classification of orientation about a single rotation axis and then was extended to consider all orientations (two axes, the third being the electron beam path). The thesis of one student, Salzman, was based on work in this area. A particularly striking discovery in the hemoglobin work was the demonstration of the presence of a ‘‘bracelet’’ protein which is implicated in maintaining the integrity of the quaternary structures of these molecules. These subunits, which contain no heme prosthetic groups, form a
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
35
bracelet, or torroid, upon which the remaining subunits bind. The hexagonal bilayer appearance of these giant proteins has an absolute requirement for the presence of these ‘‘linker’’ subunits. STEM examinations of preparations depleted of this subunit showed no hexagonal bilayer structures in the general field of view. Several ancillary techniques were developed as a result of the presence of an IBM 4381 super-mini mainframe in the lab starting in the early 1980s. This essentially unlimited access to reasonable fast (by present standards) computational power allowed us the luxury of algorithm exploration on a scale that would have not been attempted if we were required to pay for compute cycles. One example has already been mentioned, and that is our development of 3D reconstruction algorithms for use with STEM projection image data. Another example is the development of a technique to compute the stoichiometry of a multisubunit protein using a linear equations approach. We were able to demonstrate that the subunit stoichiometry of a protein can be calculated if the amino acid analysis is known for each isolated subunit and also the intact molecule. Expressed as a series of linear equations (subunit coefficients on the left hand and the intact molecule analysis on the right hand of the equation), a least squares solution will provide values for this overdetermined set of equations (20 amino acids ¼ 20 equations, usually in four or less unknowns) which agree very closely with known values and provide reasonable stoichiometries for the unknown ratios of the invertebrate hemoglobins. This problem is not trivial because the hemoglobins TABLE I
Reference Groups (Papers and Abstracts in Bibliography)
A. (Construction)
Papers Abstracts
26,27,38,42,39 36,34
B. (Field Emission)
Papers Abstracts
41,31 32,35,51
C. (STEM of Atoms)
Papers
Abstracts
37,43,46,65,66,67,68,70,73,74,90,98,105, 107,110,124,160,203,211,215,238, 248,254 33,49,50,53,55,56,59,61,62,75,76,77,80, 81,91,92,93,96,99,100,101,129,132, 146,134,142,163,166,167,179,182,186, 193,197,217,244,252,260,261,263,265
D. (SEM)
Papers Abstracts
54,57,69,71,72,97 44,52,58,60,78,64,176
E. (Energy Loss)
Papers
87,89,106,108,150,156,159,162,245 (continued)
36
TABLE I
A. V. Crewe
(continued)
Abstracts
84,85,102,103,115,116,120,175,177,178, 180,191,195,144,171
F. (Secondaries)
Papers Abstracts
206 138
G. (DNA)
Papers Abstracts
82,83,104,133
H. (Nucleosomes)
Papers Abstracts
154,185,233
I. (Cs)
Papers
198,286,302,319,280,367,372,373, 503,504 45,95,137,181,187,192,196,285,298,201
J. (Theory)
Papers
Abstracts
Abstracts
208,209,214,221,239,272,279,283,287, 384,420,422,423,425,430, 431,432,437, 439,461 398,417,418,419,459,460
K. (Optimization)
Papers Abstracts
282,325,353,464 291,296,297,306
L. (Image Processing)
Papers Abstracts
308,322,448 313,294,316,320,326,329,365,381,385
M. (3D Reconstruction)
Papers
207,346,347,357,371,375,392,393,304, 396,429,462,473,474 113,355,356,358,379,400,403
Abstracts N. (Hemoglobin Work)
Papers
Abstracts
321,327,337,338,339,347,348,349,357, 363,370,377,382,383,392,393,394, 396,404,411,421,427,429,443,444,466, 467,468,473,474,488,389,390,491,494, 495,498,503 300,307,312,314,318,324,334,356,358, 359,360,361,362,364,365,378,379,380, 381,386,387,395,413,414,415,426, 440,441,442,445,446,457,458,459,463, 464,465,479,480,481,482, 483,484,496,497
of many annelid hemoglobins contain approximately 200 copies of anywhere from 3 to 7 different subunits. Over the past several years we have been recognized as leaders in the field of invertebrate hemoglobin structure and function. In the past year
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
37
Vinogradov and Kapp were the editors of a volume of papers that were the results of a meeting on the subject of the structure and function of the invertebrate respiratory proteins. In work closely allied to the study of protein structures we have developed a fairly extensive library of subroutines for examination of protein crystal structure and sequence alignment. Specifically, we rewrote the Needleman and Wunsch dynamic programming technique from FORTRAN into APL so that we could easily modify the interpreted code ‘‘on the fly.’’ This work has allowed us to more closely relate the results of STEM examination of biological macromolecules with the growing list of crystal structures contained in the Brookhaven database. Recently we have begun to simulate STEM images using the Brookhaven coordinates in an attempt to obtain a better understanding of radiation damage, orientation classification, and substrate effects in experimental STEM images.
REFERENCES (OF CHICAGO ABERRATIONS) Beck, V. (1977). Aberration correction in the STEM. Optik 53, 241–255. Chen, E. G., and Mu, C. J. (1990). In ‘‘Proceedings of the International Symposium on Electron Microscopy, Beijing, China,’’ (Kuo, K. and Yao, J., eds.), p. 28–35. World Scientific, Singapore. Crewe, A. V., Cohen, D., and Meads, P. (1968). A multipole element for the correction of spherical aberration. Fourth European Conference on Electron Microscopy, p. 183 Rome. Crewe, A. V. (1980). The sextupole as corrector. Electron Microscopy 1, 36–37. Crewe, A. V. (1982). A system for the correction of axial aperture. Aberrations in electron lenses. Optik 60, 271–281. Crewe, A. V. (1992a). Electron motion in tuned fields, I. The algebra. Ultramicroscopy 41, 269–277. Crewe, A. V. (1992b). Electron motion in tuned fields, II. Some applications. Ultramicroscopy 41, 279–285. Crewe, A. V., and Kopf, D. A. (1980a). Limitations of sextupole correctors. Optik 56, 391–399. Crewe, A. V., and Kopf, K. (1980). A sextupole system for the correction of spherical aberration. Optik 55, 1–10. Crewe, A. V., and Parker, N. W. (1976). Correction of third-order aberrations in the scanning electron microscope. Optik 46(2), 183–194. Crewe, A. V., and Beck, V. (1974). A quadrupole-octupole corrector for a 100 KeV STEM. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 426–427. Crewe, A. V., and Jiye, X. (1985). Correction of spherical and coma aberrations with a sextupole-round lens-sextupole system. Optik 69, 141–146. Crewe, A. V., and Salzman, D. A. (1982). On the optimum resolution of a corrected STEM. Ultramicroscopy 9, 373–378. Crewe, A. V., Ruan, S., Korda, P., and Tsai, F. (2000). Studies of a magnetically focused electrostatic mirror, I. Experimental test of first order properties. J. Microscopy 197, 110–117. Deltrap, J. H. M. (1964). ‘‘Correction of spherical aberration of electron lenses.’’ Thesis, Cambridge University, Pembroke College.
38
A. V. Crewe
Haine, M. E. (1961). ‘‘The Electron Microscope, The Present State of the Art.’’ p. 58. Interscience, New York. Jiye, X., Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1985). The wave electron optical properties of a magnetic round lens corrected with sextupoles. Optik 70, 37–42. Koops, H. (1978). Erprobung eines chromatisch korrigierten elektronenmikroskopischen Objektives. Optik 52, 1–18. Parker, N. W., Golladay, S. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). A theoretical analysis of third-order aberration correction in the SEM and STEM. Proc. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 24–25. Scherzer, O. (1936). Some defects of electron lenses. Z. Physik 101, 593–603. Scherzer, O. (1947). Spha¨rische und chromatische Korrektur von Elektronen-Linsen. Optik 2, 114–132. Scherzer, O. (1978). Limitations for the resolving power of electron microscopes. Proc. 9th Int. Conf. Electron Microscopy Vol. III, pp. 123–129. Septier, A. (1966). The struggle to overcome spherical aberration in electron optics. Advances in Optical and Electron Microscopy 1, 204–274. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). Spherical aberrations of multipoles. J. Appl. Physics 62, 1149–1153. Tsai, F. (2000). Studies of a magnetically focused electrostatic mirror, II. Aberration correction. J. Microscopy 197, 118–135. Zworykin, V. K., Morton, G. A., Ramberg, E. G., Hillier, J., and Vance, A. W. (1945). ‘‘Electron Optics and the Electron Microscope.’’ John Wiley & Sons, New York.
REFERENCES (OF DOE REPORT) 1951–59 1. Crewe, A. V., and Litherland, A. E. (1951). The Effects of Geometry on Scattering Distributions in the Wilson Cloud Chamber. J. Sci. Inst. 28, 182. 2. Crewe, A. V. (1951). The Multiple Scattering of m Mesons. Proc. Phys. Soc. 64, 660. 3. Crewe, A. V., and Evans, W. H. (1952). The Diffusion Cloud Chamber. Atomics 3, 221. 4. Crewe, A. V., and Ashmore, A. (1953). The Multiple Scattering of 7.5 Mev Deuterons in Metals. Proc. Phys. Soc. 66, 1172. 5. Crewe, A. V., Alston, M. H., Evans, W. H., Green, L. L., and Wilmott, J. G. (1954). The Scattering of 17.5 Mev Neutrons in Helium. Proc. Phys. Soc. 67, 657. 6. Crewe, A. V., Alston, H. M., and Evans, W. H. (1954). A Stereoscopic Reprojection Apparatus for Neutron Scattering Experiments. J. Sci. Inst. 31, 252. 7. Crewe, A. V., Alston, M. H., and Evans, W. H. (1954). Some Practical Aspects of Diffusion Cloud-Chamber Operation. Rev. Sci. Inst. 25, 547. 8. Crewe, A. V., and LeCouteur, K. J. (1955). The Extracted Proton Beam of the Liverpool Synchrocyclotron. Rev. Sci. Inst. 26, 725. 9. Crewe, A. V. (1955). Beam Extraction from the Liverpool Synchrocyclotron. Proc. Roy. Soc. 232, 242. 10. Crewe, A. V., and Kruse, U. E. (1956). Regenerative Beam Extraction on the Chicago Synchrocyclotron. Rev. Sci. Inst. 27, 5. 11. Crewe, A. V. (1956). Pion Production in the Pion-Nucleon Collisions at 240 Mev. Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc. 1, 276. 12. Crewe, A. V. (1956). Beam Extraction on Weak Focusing Machines. Proc. CERN Symposium 1, 141. 13. Crewe, A. V., Alston, M. H., Evans, W. H., and von Gierke, F. (1956). Positive Pion Production in Proton-Proton Collisions at 383 Mev. Proc. CERN Symposium 1, 334.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
39
14. Crewe, A. V., Alston, M. H., Evans, W. H., and von Gierke, F. (1956). A Study of Positive Pion Production in Proton-Proton Collision at 383 Mev. Proc. Phys. Soc. 69. 15. Crewe, A. V., and Cohen, Stanley (1957). Regenerative Action in High Energy Accelerators. Nuclear Instruments 1, 31. 16. Crewe, A. V., Kruse, U. E., Miller, R. H., and Pondrom, L. G. (1957). Search for Asymmetries in the Scattering and Decay of Pions. Phys. Rev. 108, 1531. 17. Crewe, A. V., Pondrom, L. G., and Kruse, U. E. (1958). pþ Production in Hydrogen by 450 Mev Protons. Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc. 3, 196. 18. Crewe, A. V. (1958). Magnetic Spectrometer for 1 Bev/c Momentum. Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc. 3, 333. 19. Crewe, A. V. (1958). Magnetic Spectrometer for 450 Mev Protons. Rev. Sci. Inst. 29, 880–884. 20. Crewe, A. V., Garwin, E., Ledley, B., Lillethun, E., March, R., and Marcowitz, S. (1959). Charge Independence in the Reactions r þ d ! p0 þ He3 and r þ d ! pþ þ H3 at 450 Mev. Phys. Rev. Letters 2, 269–270. 21. Crewe, A. V., Ledley, B., Lillethun, E., Marcowitz, S., and Pondrom, L. G. (1959). Elastic Proton-Deuteron Scattering at 450 Mev. Phys. Rev. 114, 1361–1365. 22. Crewe, A. V. (1959). Notes on External Particle Beams from the Argonne 12.5 Bev Synchrotron. Proc. Int’l Conf. on High-Energy Accelerators and Instrumentation CERN. 23. Crewe, A. V. (1959). The Argonne Zero Gradient Synchrotron (ZGS). Proc. Int’l Conf. on High-Energy Accelerators and Instrumentation CERN.
1960–65 24. Crewe, A. V., Ledley, B., Lillethun, E., Marcowitz, S., and Rey, C. (1960). Charge Independence in the Reactions r þ d! p0 þ He3 and r þ d ! pþ þ H3 at 450 Mev. Phys. Rev. 118, 1091. 25. Nambu, Y., and Jona-Lasinio, G. (1961). Dynamical Model of Elementary Particles Based on an Analogy with Superconductivity. II. Phys. Rev. 124, 246–254. 26. Crewe, A. V. (1963). A New Kind of Scanning Microscope. Journal de Microscopie 2, 369. 27. Crewe, A. V. (1964). Scanning Techniques for High Voltage Microscopes. Proc. AMUANL High Voltage Electron Microscope Mtg. Argonne National Laboratory, pp. 68–81. 28. Crewe, A. V., and Katz, J. J. (1964). ‘‘Nuclear Research USA.’’ Dover Publishers Inc, New York. 29. Crewe, A. V., and Katz, J. J. (1964). ‘‘Research USA.’’ McGraw Hill Book Co, New York. 30. Crewe, A. V., George, R. D., Ratner, L. G., and Teng, L. C. (1965). Experimental Area Beams from the ANL 12.5 Bev Proton Synchrotron. Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc. 10, 654. 31. Crewe, A. V. (1965). Some Effects of Quadrupole Misalignments in a Microscope. ‘‘AMU-ANL High Voltage Electron Microscope Newsletter, July 6.’’
1966–69 32. Butler, J. W. (1966). Digital Computer Techniques in Electron Microscopy. Proc. 6th Int’l Congress for Electron Microscopy. Kyoto, p. 191. 33. Crewe, A. V. (1966). Energy Loss Techniques in a Scanning Microscope. Proc. 6th Int’l Congress for Electron Microscopy. Kyoto, p. 635. 34. Crewe, A. V. (1966). Experiments with Quadrupole Lenses in a Scanning Microscope. Proc. 6th Int’l Congress for Electron Microscopy. Kyoto, p. 627. 35. Crewe, A. V. (1966). Experiments with a Field Emission Electron Gun. Proc. 6th Int’l Congress for Electron Microscopy. Kyoto, p. 629. 36. Crewe, A. V. (1966). A Transmission Scanning Microscope. Proc. 6th Int’l Congress for Electron Microscopy. Kyoto, p. 631. 37. Crewe, A. V. (1966). Scanning Electron Microscopes: Is High Resolution Possible? Science 154, 729–738.
40
A. V. Crewe
38. Crewe, A. V., Butler, J. W., and Welter, L. M. (1967). A Computer-Controlled Electron Microscope System. Proc. Roy. Microsc. Soc. MICRO 67. 39. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Welter, L. M., and Wall, J. (1967). Experiments with Quadrupole Lenses in a Scanning Microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 38, 4257–4266. 40. Crewe, A. V. (1967). Science and the War on . . .. Physics Today 20, 25–30. 41. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). Electron Gun Using a Field Emission Source. Rev. Sci. Inst. 39, 576–583. 42. Lewis, R. N., Jung, E. A., Welter, L. M., Van Loon, L. S., and Chapman, G. L. (1968). Flexible High Voltage Supply for Experimental Electron Microscope. Rev. Sci. Instr. 39, 1522–1526. 43. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). A High Performance Transmission Scanning Microscope. Fourth European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy. Rome, p. 7. 44. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1968). A Simple Scanning Microscope of Medium Performance. Fourth European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy. Rome, p. 75. 45. Crewe, A. V., Cohen, D., and Meads, P. (1968). A Multipole Element for the Correcting of Spherical Aberration. Fourth European Regional Conference on Electron Microscopy. Rome, p. 183. 46. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). A High-Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 5861–5868. 47. Welter, L. M., Stroud, A. N., and Resh, D. L. (1968). Scanning Energy Analyzing Microscopy of Chromosomes. Biophys. Soc. Abstracts, 12th Ann. Mtg. 48. MacKenzie, A. P. (1968). Freeze-Dehydration for the Scanning Electron Microscope. Biophys. Soc. Abstracts, 12th Ann. Mtg. p. A190. 49. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). A High Resolution Scanning Microscope. Proc. 26th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 50. Crewe, A. V. (1968). The Potentials of Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 26th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 352. 51. Crewe, A. V., and Isaacson, M. (1968). The Use of Field Emission Tips in a Scanning Microscope. Proc. 26th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 52. Crewe, A. V., Johnson, D., and Isaacson, M. (1968). An Electron Gun Scanning Microscope. Proc. 26th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 53. Thomson, M. G. R., and Crewe, A. V. (1968). The Possibility of Improving Scanning Microscope Images by After-Treatment. Proc. 26th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 54. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1969). A Simple Scanning Electron Microscope. Rev. Sci. Inst. 40, 241–246. 55. Crewe, A. V. (1969). High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy. Proc. 2nd Ann. Scanning Microscope Symposium. IIT Research Institute, p. 11. ˚ Scanning Microscope. Proc. 27th Ann. 56. Crewe, A. V. (1969). Closing the Gap—A 5A EMSA Mtg. p. 6. 57. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1969). A High Performance Energy Analyzer for Use in Electron Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 14. 58. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1969). Secondary Electron Detection in a Field Emission Scanning Microscope. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 16. 59. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1969). Scanning Microscopy of Thin Biological Specimens. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 48. 60. Johnson, D., and Morieraty, P. (1969). Examination of Schistosome Cercariae and Schistosomules by Scanning Electron Microscopy. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 50. 61. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1969). The Theoretical Contrast in Scanning and Conventional High Resolution Microscopes. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 170.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
41
62. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1969). High Resolution Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 27th Ann. EMSA Mtg. p. 172. 63. Stroud, A. N., Welter, L. M., Resh, D. A., Habeck, D. A., Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1969). Scanning Electron Microscopy of Cells. Science 164, 830–832.
1970 64. Smith, J. V., Anderson, A. T., Newton, R. C., Olsen, E. J., Wyllie, P. J., Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M. S., and Johnson, D. (1970). Petrologic History of the Moon Inferred from Petrography, Mineralogy and Petrogenesis of Apollo 11 Rocks. Proc. Apollo 11 Lunar Sci. Conf. 1, 897–925. 65. Crewe, A. V. (1970). High Resolution Scanning Microscopy of Biological Specimens. Berichte der Bunsen-Gesell. fur Phys. Chem. 74, 1181–1187. 66. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. I. Optik 31, 258–280. 67. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. II. Optik 31, 359–366. 68. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1970). Contrast in a High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscope. Optik 30, 461–474. 69. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1970). Secondary Electron Detection in a Field Emission Scanning Microscope. Rev. Sci. Inst. 41, 20–24. 70. Crewe, A. V. (1970). The Current State of High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy. Quarterly Reviews of Biophysics 3, 1–39. 71. Anderson, A. T., Crewe, A. V., Goldsmith, J. R., Moore, P. B., Newton, J. C., Olsen, E. J., Smith, J. V., and Wyllie, P. J. (1970). Petrologic History of the Moon Suggested by Petrography, Mineralogy and Crystallography. Science 167, 587. 72. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., Johnson, D., and Smith, J. V. (1970). Scanning Electron Microscopy of Lunar Spherules. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 34. 73. Crewe, A. V. (1970). Field Emission and an Electron Gun, Microscope Design Using Field Emission and Contrast Mechanisms in a High Resolution Scanning Microscope. ‘‘Lectures presented at Centre for Scientific Culture.’’ Erice, Sicily. 74. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970). Visibility of Single Atoms. Science 168, 1338–1340. 75. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., and Wall, J. (1970). High Resolution Capabilities in Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1. Grenoble. 76. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1970). Contrast Methods in a High Resolution Scanning Microscope—the Use of Multiple Detectors. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1, 35. Grenoble. 77. Thompson, M. G. R., and Zeitler, E. (1970). Phase Contrast in the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1, 63. Grenoble. 78. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1970). A Simple Multi-Purpose Scanning Microscope. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1, 209–210. Grenoble. 79. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970). High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy of Nucleic Acid Salts. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1, 467–468. Grenoble. 80. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970). Single Atom Visibility. Proc. 7th Int’l Congress Electron Microscopy 1, 485–486. Grenoble. 81. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., Wall, J., and Beer, M. (1970). Single Atom Contrast in a Scanning Microscope. Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 250–251. ˚ Scanning Microscope. 82. Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970). Studies of DNA Using a 5A Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 252–253. 83. Langmore, J., and Wall, J. (1970). Conformational Study of tRNA, Using the High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscope. Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 254–255.
42
A. V. Crewe
84. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1970). Electron Beam Damage in Biological Molecules. Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 264–265. 85. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1970). The Energy Loss of 20 KEV Electrons in Biological Molecules. Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 86. Crewe, A. V., and Saxon, J. (1970). Interference Experiments with a Field Emission Source. Proc. 28th Ann. EMSA Mtg.
1971 87. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1971). Electron Energy Loss Spectra of the Nucleic Acid Bases. Nature 231, 262–263. 88. Crewe, A. V. (1971). High Resolution Scanning Microscopy of Biological Specimens. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. 261, 61–70. London. 89. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1971). A High Resolution Electron Spectrometer for Use in Transmission Scanning Electron Microscopy. Rev. Sci. Inst. 42, 411–420. 90. Crewe, A. V. (1971). A High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscope. Scientific American 224, 26–35. 91. Zeitler, E. (1971). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Proc. 4th Ann. SEM Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 25–31. 92. Crewe, A. V. (1971). A 100 Kv Transmission Scanning Microscope. Proc. 29th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 93. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1971). Quantitative Analysis in High Resolution Transmission Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 29th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 94. Crewe, A. V., and Beck, V. (1971). A New Color Display System for Scanning Transmission Microscopes. Proc. 29th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 95. Crewe, A. V., and Saxon, J. (1971). Electron Holography and the Correction of Spherical Aberration. Proc. 29th Ann. EMSA Mtg. ˚ in Diameter. Proc. 7th Nat’l 96. Crewe, A. V. (1971). Production of Electron Probes a Few A Conf. on Electron Probe Analysis. 97. Sheffield, J. B., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1971). Visualization of Surface Structures on Embryonic Cells with a Simple Electron Gun Scanning Microscope. Experimental Cell Research 64, 49–56. 98. Crewe, A. V. (1971). ‘‘High Intensity Electron Sources and Scanning Electron Microscopy’’,. Electron Microscopy in Material Science, pp. 162–207. Academic Press, New York.
1972 99. Crewe, A. V., and Retsky, M. (1972). Single Atom Visibility. Proc. 30th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 100. Crewe, A. V., and Zeitler, E. (1972). A 100 Kv High Resolution Scanning Transmission Microscope. Proc. 30th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 101. Crewe, A. V. (1972). Imaging of Single Atoms in Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 30th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 102. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1972). Characteristic Energy Loss of Fast Electrons in Biological Materials. Biophys. Soc. Abstr. 16th Ann. Mtg. 48a. 103. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1972). Implications of Electron Beam Damage in Electron Microscopy. Biophys. Soc. Abstr. 16th Ann. Mtg. 49a. 104. Crewe, A. V., Cozzarelli, N. R., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. P. (1972). Development of DNA Base-Specific Stains for Electron Microscopy. Biophys. Soc. Abstr. 16th Ann. Mtg. 52a.
1973 105. Crewe, A. V. (1973). Production of Electron Probes Using a Field Emission Source. In ‘‘Progress in Optics XI’’, (Wolf, E., ed.), pp. 223–246. Braunschweig, North Holland.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
43
106. Isaacson, M., Johnson, D., and Crewe, A. V. (1973). Electron Beam Excitation and Damage of Biological Molecules; Its Implications for Specimen Damage in Electron Microscopy. Rad. Res. 55, 205–224. 107. Langmore, J. P., and Wall, J. (1973). The Collection of Scattered Electrons in Dark Field Electron Microscopy. Optik 38, 335–350. 108. Crewe, A. V. (1973). Considerations of Specimen Damage for the Transmission Electron Microscope, Conventional Versus Scanning. J. Mol. Biol. 80, 315–325. 109. Johnson, D., and Isaacson, M. S. (1973). Cytosine Reflectance Measurements Using Electron Energy Loss Spectra and Synchrotron Radiation. Optics Communications 8, 406–408. 110. Wall, J. (1973). Development of the High Resolution Scanning Transmission Microscope. Scanning Electron Microscopy, pp. 158–163. 111. Langmore, J., Wall, J., Isaacson, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1973). Carbon Support Films for High Resolution Electron Microscopy. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. 76–77. 112. Wall, J., Langmore, J., Isaacson, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1973). Resolution Attainable with the Present Day STEM. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 230–231. 113. Isaacson, M., Langmore, J., Wall, J., and Crewe, A. V. (1973). Inelastic Scattering in Electron Microscopy. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 254–255. 114. Zeitler, E. (1973). Reconstruction of Objects from their Projections Using Orthogonal Functions. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 268–269. 115. Johnson, D. E., and Isaacson, M. (1973). Low Z Elemental Analysis Using Energy Loss Electrons in a Scanning Microscope. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 290–291. 116. Isaacson, M. (1973). Inelastic Scattering and Beam Damage of Biological Molecules. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 478–479. 117. Lamvik, M. K., Isaacson, M. S., and Crewe, A. V. (1973). Studies of Aggregates of Two Muscle Proteins with Scanning and Conventional Transmission Electron Microscopy. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 600–601. 118. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., Wall, J., and Isaacson, M. (1973). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy at High Resolution. Proc. 31st Ann. EMSA Mtg. 119. Beck, V. (1973). Slow Scan Display System for a Scanning Electron Microscope. Rev. Sci. Inst. 44, 1064–1066.
1974 120. Isaacson, M. (1974). Characteristic Energy Loss of Electrons in Biological Materials. Proc. 4th Int’l Conf. on YUV Phys. Hamburg. 121. Rose, H. (1974). Phase Contrast in Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Optik 39, 416–436. 122. Wall, J., Isaacson, M., and Langmore, J. P. (1974). The Collection of Scattered Electrons in Dark Field Electron Microscopy. Optik 39, 359–374. 123. Roth, T. A. (1974). The Field Emitter: Electric Field Calculation. J. Applied Phys. 45, 4771–4773. 124. Crewe, A. V. (1974). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. J. Microscopy 100, 247–259. 125. Crewe, A. V., and Groves, T. (1974). Thick Specimens in the CEM and STEM I. Contrast. J. Applied Phys. 45, 3662–3672. 126. Hainfeld, J., and Isaacson, M. (1974). Human Red Cell Studies Using Scanning Electron Microscope. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 162–163. 127. Lamvik, M. K., Pullman, J. M., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). Unstained Biological Specimens in High Resolution Electron Microscopy. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 234–235. 128. Panem, S., Lin, P. S. D., Crewe, A. V., and Kirsten, W. H. (1974). Scanning Electron Microscopy of Murine Oncornavirus Infected Cells. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 252–253.
44
A. V. Crewe
129. Crewe, A. V. (1974). The High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 316–317. 130. Zeitler, E., and Isaacson, M. (1974). Simplified Calculation of Phase Contrast for Finite Detector and Illumination Angles. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 370–371. 131. Crewe, A. V., and Beck, V. (1974). Resolution Limits Imposed by Specimen–Electron Interactions. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 372–373. 132. Isaacson, M., Langmore, J., and Rose, H. (1974). Measurements of the Non-Local Nature of the Inelastic Scattering of Electrons in Carbon. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 374–375. 133. Langmore, J. P., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). Progress Towards the Sequencing of DNA by Electron Microscopy. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 376–377. 134. Langmore, J. P., Isaacson, M. S., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). The Study of Single Heavy Atom Motion in the STEM. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 378–379. 135. Munch, J., and Zeitler, E. (1974). Interference Experiments with a Field Emission Electron Microscope. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 386–387. 136. Roth, T. A., Munch, J., and Zeitler, E. (1974). The Effect of Top-Anode Distance on Field Emission Current. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 420–421. 137. Crewe, A. V., and Beck, V. (1974). A Quadrupole-Octupole Corrector for a 100 KEV STEM. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 426–427. 138. Voreades, D., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). Correlation Between Inelastic Electron Scattering and Secondary Electron Production. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 428–429. 139. Groves, T., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). The Use of Thick Specimens in a STEM. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 550–551. 140. Lin, P. S. D. (1974). On Some Testing Specimens for High Resolution SEM. Proc. 32nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 556–557. 141. Lamvik, M. K., and Lin, S. D. (1974). A New Specimen Mounting System for Scanning Electron Microscopy. J. Microsc. 101, 329–331. 142. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., Isaacson, M., and Retsky, M. (1974). Understanding Single Atoms in the STEM. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 143. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., Lamvik, M., and Pullman, J. (1974). Scanning Electron Microscopy of Unstained and Selectively Stained Biological Specimens. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 144. Crewe, A. V., and Zeitler, E. (1974). Radiation Damage and Energy Analysis in the STEM. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 145. Zeitler, E., and Crewe, A. V. (1974). Design and Construction of a 1 MEV Scanning Microscope. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy, pp. 40–41. Canberra. 146. Crewe, A. V. (1974). High Resolution Scanning Microscopy. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 147. Crewe, A. V., and Groves, T. (1974). The Use of Thick Specimens in the STEM and CEM. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 148. Crewe, A. V., and Lin, P. (1974). Experience with High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopes with Field Emission Sources. Proc. 8th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Canberra. 149. Isaacson, M., and Langmore, J. P. (1974). Determination of the Non-Localization of the Inelastic Scattering of Electrons by Electron Microscopy. Optik 41, 92–96. 150. Lin, S. D. (1974). Electron Radiation Damage of Thin Films of Glycine, Diglycine, and Aromatic Amino Acids. Rad. Res. 59, 521–536. 151. Isaacson, M., and Langmore, J. (1974). The Preparation and Observation of Biological Specimens for the High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Proc. 7th Ann. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 19–26. 152. Beorchia, A., and Bonhomme, P. (1974). Experimental Studies of Some Dampings of Electron Microscope Phase Contrast Transfer Function. Optik 39, 437–442.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
45
1975 153. Shau-da-Lin, P., and Lamvik, M. K. (1975). High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy at the Subcellular Level. J. Microsc. 103, 249–257. 154. Langmore, J. P., and Wooley, J. C. (1975). Chromatin Architecture: Investigation of a Subunit of Chromatin by Dark Field Electron Microscopy. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. USA 72, 2691–2695. 155. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J., and Isaacson, M. (1975). Resolution and Contrast in the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. In ‘‘Physical Aspects of Electron Microscopy and Microbeam Analysis,’’ (Siegel, B. and Beaman, D. R., eds.), pp. 47–62. John Wiley & Sons, New York. 156. Isaacson, M. S. (1975). Inelastic Scattering and Beam Damage of Biological Molecules. In ‘‘Physical Aspects of Electron Microscopy and Microbeam Analysis,’’ (Siegel, B. and Beaman, D. R., eds.), pp. 247–258. John Wiley & Sons, New York. 157. Lin, P. S. D., and Becker, R. P. (1975). Detection of Backscattered Electrons with High Resolution. Proc. of the Ann. Scanning Electron Microscopy Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 61–70. 158. Groves, T., and Lamvik, M. K. (1975). The Measurement of Signal Intensities for Thick Specimens in the STEM. Proc. of the Ann. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. IIT Res. Institute, pp. 79–83. 159. Crewe, A. V., and Isaacson, M. (1975). Electron Microspectroscopy. Ann. Rev. of Biophys. and Bioeng. 4, 165–184. 160. Crewe, A. V. (1975). Electron Microscopes Using Field Emission Source. Surf. Sci. 48, 152–160. 161. Groves, T. (1975). Thick Specimens in the CEM and STEM. Ultramicroscopy 1, 15–31. 162. Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1975). The Microanalysis of Light Elements Using Transmitted Energy Loss Electrons. Ultramicroscopy 1, 33–52. 163. Beck, V., and Crewe, A. V. (1975). High Resolution Imaging Properties of the STEM. Ultramicroscopy 1, 137–144. 164. Ohtsuki, M., and Zeitler, E. (1975). Minimal Beam Exposure with a Field Emission Source. Ultramicroscopy 1, 163–165. 165. Groves, T. (1975). Plural Scattering and Thick Specimens in Transmission Electron Microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 1, 170–172. 166. Crewe, A. V. (1975). High Resolution Scanning Microscopy—What Next? Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 18–19. 167. Parker, N. W., Isaacson, M., and Langmore, J. P. (1975). Studies of the Adsorption and Diffusion of Single Heavy Atoms on Light Element Substrates Using the STEM. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 104–105. 168. Lin, P. S. D., and Lamvik, M. K. (1975). A Simple Transmission Stage for a Scanning Electron Microscope. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 134–135. 169. Lin, P. S. D. (1975). On the Contrast of High Resolution Backscattered Electron Images. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 206–207. 170. Lin, P. S. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1975). Simultaneous Study of Both the Surface and Interior Structure of Biological Specimens in a Scanning Electron Microscope. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 208–209. 171. Johnson, D. E., and Isaacson, M. (1975). The Detection of Transmitted Energy Loss Electrons for Elemental Analysis. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 236–237. 172. Lamvik, M. K., and Crewe, A. V. (1975). Mass Determination by Direct Measurement of Electron Scattering. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 240–241. 173. Johnson, D. E. (1975). An Image Reconstruction System Applied to High Voltage Microscopy. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 292–293.
46
A. V. Crewe
174. Lamvik, M. K., and Lin, S. D. (1975). An Improved Specimen Mount for Scanning Electron Microscopy. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 132–133. 175. Hainfeld, H., and Isaacson, M. (1975). Electron Energy Loss in Membrane Components: Possibilities of Contrast and Identification in the STEM. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 506–507. 176. Lamvik, M. K. (1975). Scanning Secondary Electron Microscopy of Myofibrils Using Transmission Techniques. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 556–557. 177. Ramamurti, K., Crewe, A. V., and Isaacson, M. (1975). Low Temperature Beam Damage to Biological Specimens in the Electron Microscope. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 608–609. 178. Isaacson, M., Langmore, J., Lamvik, M., Lin, P., Golladay, S., Hainfeld, J., Pullman, J., and Furlong, D. (1975). Mass Loss of Biological Molecules in the Electron Microscope. Proc. 33rd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 676–677. 179. Crewe, A. V. (1975). Recent Developments and Future Prospects for STEM. Proc. EMAG Mtg. Bristol, pp. 1–2. 180. Ramamurti, K., Crewe, A. V., and Isaacson, M. (1975). Low Temperature Mass Loss of Thin Films of L-Phenylalanine and L-Tryptophan Upon Electron Irradiation—A Preliminary Report. Ultramicroscopy 1, 156–158.
1976 181. Parker, N. W., Golladay, S. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). A Theoretical Analysis of ThirdOrder Aberration Correction in the SEM and STEM. Proc. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 37–44. 182. Crewe, A. V. (1976). Some Thoughts on the Future of the STEM. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 24–25. 183. Isaacson, M. (1976). The Potential of the High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope in the Biological and Materials Science: Fact and Fiction. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 26–28. 184. Hainfeld, J., Isaacson, M., and Sogard, M. (1976). The Use of Microspectroscopy in the STEM for the Identification of Membrane Components. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 30–31. 185. Langmore, J. (1976). Quantitative Studies of Unstained Biological Structures in the STEM. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 31–33. 186. Crewe, A. V. (1976). Design Trends in the STEM. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 65–66. 187. Crewe, A. V., Beck, V., and Parker, N. W. (1976). Correction of Third Order Aberration in the STEM. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 322–323. 188. Crewe, A. V., and Zeitler, E. (1976). A One Million Volt Scanning Microscopy: Progress Report. Proc. Sixth European Conf. on Electron Microscopy, pp. 322–323. 189. Pullman, J., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). Darkfield Microscopy of Unstained Specimens at High Beam Dosages. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 380–381. 190. Lamvik, M. K. (1976). Electronmicroscopic Mass Determination Without a Densitometer: Quantitative Electron Microscopy Using Photographic Methods. Proc. 34th EMSA Mtg. pp. 380–381. 191. Johnson, D. E., and Isaacson, M. (1976). Elemental Analysis of Thin Films Using Inner Shell Electron Energy Losses. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 414–415. 192. Parker, N. W., Golladay, S. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). Third-Order Aberration Correction in the SEM and STEM. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 464–465. 193. Isaacson, M. S., Kopf, D., Parker, N. W., and Utlaut, M. (1976). Some Observations on the Adsorption of Heavy Atoms on Carbon Substrates. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 498–499.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
47
194. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). Evaporative Cooling of High Current Density Mini-lenses. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 536–537. 195. Ramamurti, K., Crewe, A. V., and Isaacson, M. S. (1976). Electron Beam Damage at Low Temperatures. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 554–555. 196. Beck, V., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). Progress in Aberration Correction in the STEM. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 578–579. 197. Isaacson, M. S., Kopf, D., Parker, N. W., and Utlaut, M. (1976). Observations of Surface Diffusion at the Atomic Level by Means of Microcinematography in the STEM. Proc. 34th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 584–585. 198. Crewe, A. V., and Parker, N. W. (1976). Correction of Third Order Aberrations in the Scanning Electron Microscope. Optik 183–194. 199. Crewe, A. V. (1976). Very Low Voltage Electron Microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 1, 267–269. 200. Crewe, A. V., and Lin, P. S. D. (1976). The Use of Backscattered Electrons for Imaging Purposes in a Scanning Electron Microscope. Ultramicroscopy 1, 231–238. 201. Parker, N. W., Golladay, S. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1976). A Theoretical Analysis of ThirdOrder Aberration Correction in the SEM and STEM. Proc. 9th Ann. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. Part I IIT Research Institute. 202. Isaacson, M. S., and Parker, N. W. (1976). The Potential of Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy for Studying Surface Phenomena on an Atomic Scale. Proc. 9th Ann. Scanning Electron Microscope Symposium. IIT Research Institute, pp. 345–352. Part II. 203. Isaacson, M. S., Langmore, J., Parker, N. W., Kopf, D., and Utlaut, M. (1976). The Study of the Adsorption and Diffusion of Heavy Atoms on Light Element Substrates by Means of the Atomic Resolution STEM. Ultramicroscopy 1, 359–376. 204. Lamvik, M. K., and Groves, T. (1976). Minimization of Dose as a Criterion for the Selection of Imaging Modes in Electron Microscopy of Amorphous Specimens. Ultramicroscopy 2, 69–75. 205. Isaacson, M. S., and Silcox, J. (1976). Report of a Workshop on Analytical Electron Microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 2, 89–104. 206. Voreades, D. (1976). Secondary Electron Emission from Thin Carbon Films. Surf. Sci. 60, 325–348. 207. Lerche, I., and Zeitler, E. (1976). Projections, Reconstructions and Orthogonal Functions. J. of Mathematical Analysis and Applications 56, 634–649.
1977 208. Crewe, A. V. (1977). Post-Specimen Optics in the STEM: I. General Considerations. Optik 47, 299–311. 209. Crewe, A. V. (1977). Post-Specimen Optics in the STEM: II. A Corrected Spectrometer. Optik 47, 371–380. 210. Marsh, G. E. (1977). Accelerator System for 1-MV STEM. Rev. Sci. Inst. 48, 841–843. 211. Isaacson, M., Kopf, D., Langmore, J., Parker, N. W., and Utlaut, M. (1977). Abstract: Atomic Resolution Observations of Heavy-Atom Adsorbates on Low-Atomic-Number Substrates. J. Vac. Sci. Tech. 14, 434. 212. Lamvik, M. K., and Langmore, J. P. (1977). Determination of Particle Mass Using Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Scanning Electron Microscopy 1, 401–409. 213. Ohtsuki, M., and Zeitler, E. (1977). Young’s Experiment with Electrons. Ultramicroscopy 2, 147–148. 214. Crewe, A. V. (1977). Ideal Lenses and the Scherzer Theorem. Ultramicroscopy 2, 281–284. 215. Isaacson, M., Kopf, D., Utlaut, M., Parker, N. W., and Crewe, A. V. (1977). Direct Observation of Atomic Diffusion by Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. 74, 1802–1806.
48
A. V. Crewe
216. Ohtsuki, M., White, S. L., Zeitler, E., Wellems, T. E., Fuller, S. D., Zwick, M., Makinen, M. W., and Siegler, P. B. (1977). Electron Microscopy of Fibers and Discs of Hemoglobin S Having Sixfold Symmetry. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. 74, 5538–5542. 217. Isaacson, M., Kopf, D., and Utlaut, M. (1977). Progress in Single Atom Microscopy. Proc. 35th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 78–79. 218. Isaacson, M., and Utlaut, M. (1977). Considerations on the Use of Electron and Photon Beams for Determining Micro-Chemical Environment. Proc. 35th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 240–241. 219. Collins, M. L., and Parker, N. W. (1977). Preparation of Titanium Microgrids for Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Proc. 35th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 322–323. 220. Sogard, M., and Deutsch, D. (1977). Observation of Human Low Density Lipoproteins in the STEM. Proc. 35th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 472–473.
1978 221. Crewe, A. V. (1978). Collision Broadening in Electron Beams. Optik 50, 205–212. 222. Isaacson, M., and Utlaut, M. (1978). A Comparison of Electron and Photon Beams for Determining Micro-Chemical Environment. Optik 50, 213–234. 223. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Isaacson, M. S. (1978). Design of Magnetic Spectrometers with Second-Order Aberrations Corrected. Optik 51, 333–351. 224. Isaacson, M., and Gomer, R. (1978). Extended Range Field Emission Spectroscopy. J. Appl. Phys. 15, 253–256. 225. Isaacson, M. (1978). All You Might Want to Know About ELS (But Are Afraid to Ask): A Tutorial. Scanning Electron Microscopy I, 763–776. 226. Orr, J., Toan, N., Ohtsuki, M., Wellems, T., and Haselkorn, R. (1978). Glutamine Synthetase from Cyanobacterium Anabaena-7120. Federation Proceeding 37, 1431. 227. Parker, N. W., Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M. S., and Mankawich, W. (1978). A New Analytical Electron Microscope. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy I, pp. 18–19. Toronto. 228. Kopf, D., Utlaut, M., Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Mankawich, W. (1978). Some Instrumental Aspects of Single Atom Microscopy. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy I, pp. 20–21. Toronto. 229. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Isaacson, M. (1978). Magnetic Spectrometers with Corrected Second-order Aberration. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy I, pp. 20–21. Toronto. 230. Golloday, S. (1978). Analysis of STEM Micrographs of Thick Objects. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy II, pp. 106–107. Toronto. 231. Furlong, D. (1978). Use of the STEM to Obtain Information from One Level of a Complex Biological Object. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy II, pp. 108–189. Toronto. 232. Ohtsuki, M., and Sogard, M. (1978). Observation of Biological Macromolecules Using Various Electron Microscopic Methods. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy II, pp. 170–171. Toronto. 233. Usala, S., Isaacson, M., and Martin, T. (1978). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy of Unstained Nucleosomes. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy II, pp. 170–171. Toronto. 234. Isaacson, M., Collins, M. L., and Listvan, M. (1978). Electron Beam Damage of Biomolecules Assessed by Energy Loss Spectroscopy. 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy III, pp. 61–69. Toronto. 235. Crewe, A. V. (1978). Is There a Future for the STEM? 9th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy III, pp. 197–204. Toronto. 236. Lamvik, M. K. (1978). Muscle Thick Filament Mass Measured by Electron Scattering. J. Mol. Biol. 122, 55–68.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
49
237. Hainfeld, J., and Isaacson, M. (1978). The Use of Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy or Studying Membrance Architecture: A Preliminary Report. Ultramicroscopy 3, 87–95. 238. Crewe, A. V. (1978–79). Direct Imaging of Single Atoms and Molecules Using the STEM. Chemica Scripta 14, 17–20. 239. Crewe, A. V. (1978–79). Some Space Charge Effects in Electron Probe Devices. Optik 52, 337–346.
1979 240. Crewe, A. V. (1978–79). Direct Imaging of Single Atoms and Molecules Using the STEM. Chemica Scripta 14, 17–20. 241. Crewe, A. V. (1978–79). Some Space Charge Effects in Electron Probe Devices. Optik 52, 337–346. 242. Deutsch, D. G., and Sogard, M. (1979). Observation of Human Low Density Lipoproteins in the STEM and FECTEM. Micron 10, 25–28. 243. Isaacson, M., Kopf, D., Ohtsuki, M., and Utlaut, M. (1979). Contamination as a Psychological Problem (Letter to the Editor). Ultramicroscopy 4, 101–104. 244. Isaacson, M., Kopf, D., Ohtuski, M., and Utlaut, M. (1979). Atomic Imaging Using the Dark-Field Annular Detector in the STEM (Letter to the Editor). Ultramicroscopy 4, 101–104. 245. Isaacson, M. (1979). Electron Beam Induced Damage of Organic Solids: Implications for Analytical Electron Microscopy. Ultramicroscopy 4, 193–199. 246. Hwang, D. M., Utlaut, M., Isaacson, M. S., Solin, S. A., and Minarski, L. (1979). Electron Energy Loss Studies of C8K. Bull. Amer. Phys. Soc. 24, 372. 247. Ohtsuki, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Crewe, A. V. (1979). Dark Field Imaging of Biological Macromolecules with the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. (USA) 76, 1228–1232. 248. Crewe, A. V. (1979). Development of High Resolution STEM and Its Future. J. Electron Microscopy 28, S9–S16. 249. Crewe, A. V. (1979). Direct Imaging of Atoms in Crystals and Molecules. ‘‘Nobel Symposium.’’ Stockholm. 250. Utlaut, M., Hwang, D., Isaacson, M., and Solin, S. (1979). Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy of Potassium Intercalated Graphite. Proc. 14th Biennial Conf. on Carbon. University Park, p. 316. 251. Isaacson, M., Utlaut, M., and Ohtsuki, M. (1979). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy of Very Thin Evaporated Carbon Films. Proc. 14th Biennial Conf. on Carbon. University Park, pp. 103–104. 252. Isaacson, M., Utlaut, M., and Ohtsuki, M. (1979). Direct Observation of the Diffusion of Heavy Atoms on the Surface of Thin Amorphous Carbon Films. Proc. 14th Biennial Conf. on Carbon. University Park, pp. 105–106. 253. Ohtsuki, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Crewe, A. V. (1979). Preparation and Observation of Very Thin, Very Clean Substrates for Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Scanning Electron Microscopy II, 375–382. 254. Isaacson, M., Ohtsuki, M., and Utlaut, M. (1979). Electron Microscopy of Individual Atoms. In ‘‘Introduction to Analytical Electron Microscopy’’, (Hren, J., Goldstein, J. I., and Joy, D. C., eds.) pp. 343–368. Plenum Publishing Co, New York. 255. White, S. L. (1979). Images of Unstained Hemoglobin from the STEM. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 18–19. 256. Isaacson, M. S., and Ohtsuki, M. (1979). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy and Electron Microdiffraction of Ferritin. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 20–21. 257. Golladay, S. D., and Lamvik, M. K. (1979). Platinum Labeling of Methionine in Tropomyosin Paracrystals. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 26–27.
50
A. V. Crewe
258. Usala, S., Brownstein, B., Haselkorn, R., and Agrawal, H. O. (1979). Transcription Associated with Bacteriophage 06 Nucleocapsid. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 32–33. 259. Ohtsuki, M. (1979). Dark Field STEM Observation of Negatively Stained Tobacco Mosaic Virus (TMV): Effects of Radiation Damage. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 130–131. 260. Utlaut, M., Ohtsuki, M., and Isaacson, M. (1979). Observations of the Diffusion of Heavy Atoms on Thin Amorphous Carbon Films. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 466–467. 261. Utlaut, M. (1979). Measurements of Single Atom Diffusion at Different Temperatures. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 470–471. 262. Isaacson, M., Ohtsuki, M., and Utlaut, M. (1979). Can We Determine the Structure of Thin Amorphous Films Using Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy? Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 498–499. 263. Isaacson, M., and Utlaut, M. (1979). On the Chemical Identificaion of Individual Atoms. Proc 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 524–525. 264. Listvan, M. (1979). Thin Polycrystalline Graphite Films for High Resolution Microscopy. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 544–545. 265. Utlaut, M., and Isaacson, M. S. (1979). A Comparison of Measured Single Atom Distributions with Random Distributions. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 546–547. 266. Crewe, A. V. (1979). Something Old, Something New for the STEM. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 560–563. 267. Sogard, M. R. (1979). Resolution in Electron Backscattering: A Monte Carlo Study. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 564–565. 268. Ohtsuki, M., and Isaacson, M. S. (1979). Simple Test Specimens for Measuring Lattice Resolution and Probe Size of a STEM. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 568–569. 269. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Isaacson, M. S. (1979). Design of Aberration-Corrected Magnetic Spectrometers. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 578–579. 270. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Crewe, A. V. (1979). A New Analytical Electron Microscope. Proc. 37th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 588–589. 271. Becker, R. P., and Sogard, M. (1979). Visualization of Subsurface Structures in Cells and Tissues by Backscattered Electron Imaging. Scanning Electron Microscopy II, 835–870. 272. Crewe, A. V. (1979). Some Limitations on Electron Beam Lithography. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 16, 255–259. 273. Isaacson, M. (1979). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy at Near-Atomic Resolution: The Present State of the Art. Ultramicroscopy 4, 365. 274. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M. S., and Zeitler, E. (1979). Progress in Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy at the University of Chicago. In ‘‘Unconventional Electron Microscopy for Molecular Structure Determination’’, (Hoppe, W. and Mason, R., eds.), pp. 23–48. Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn, Braunschweig. 275. Hwang, D. M., Utlaut, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Solin, S. A. (1979). Electron-Energy Loss Study of Stage-1 Potassium-Intercalated Graphite. Phys. Rev. Letters 43, 882–886. 276. Crewe, A. V. (1979–80). Electron Microscopy. In ‘‘Encyclopedia of Physics’’, (Lerner, A. V. and Trig, A. V., eds.).
1980 277. Crewe, A. V. (1979–80). Electron Microscopy. In ‘‘Encyclopedia of Physics’’, (Lerner, A. V. and Trig, A. V., eds.). 278. Crewe, A. V. (1980). Color Conversion in Electron Microscopy. Scanning 3, 176–181. 279. Crewe, A. V. (1980). Imaging in Scanning Microscopes. Ultramicroscopy 5, 131–138. 280. Crewe, A. V., and Kopf, D. A. (1980). Limitations of Sextupole Correctors. Optik 56, 391–399. 281. Isaacson, M., Utlaut, M., and Kopf, D. (1980). Computer Processing of Electron Microscope Images. In ‘‘Topics in Current Physics’’, (Hawkes, P. W., ed.). Springer-Verlag, New York.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
51
282. Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1980). Optimal Imaging Techniques in the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope: Applications to Biological Macromolecules. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. (USA) 77, 4051–4054. 283. Crewe, A. V. (1980). The Physics of the High Resolution Scanning Microscope. Rep. Prog. Phys. 43, 621–639. 284. Hwang, D. M., Solin, S. A., Utlaut, M., and Isaacson, M. S. (1980). Electron Energy Loss Studies of Stage-2 Potassium Intercalated Graphite. Bull. of the APS 25, 336. 285. Crewe, A. V. (1980). The Sextupole as Corrector. Electron Microscopy I, 36–37. 286. Crewe, A. V., and Kopf, D. (1980). A Sextupole System for the Correction of Spherical Aberration. Optik 55, 1–10. 287. Crewe, A. V., and Kopf, D. (1980). The Use of Non-optimal Apertures in the STEM. Optik 55, 325–327. 288. Sogard, M. R. (1980). Backscattered Electron Energy Spectra for Thin Films from an Extension of the Everhart Theory. J. Appl. Phys. 51, 4412–4416. 289. Sogard, M. R. (1980). An Empirical Study of Electron Backscattering from Thin Films. J. Appl. Phys. 51, 4417–4425. 290. Hwang, D. M., Utlaut, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Solin, S. A. (1980). Dielectric Functions of Stage One Potassium Intercalated Graphite Single Crystals Determined by Electron Microscopy. Physica 99B, 435–440. 291. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1980). The Use of Optimal Scanning in the STEM. 7th European Congress on Electron Microscopy. Netherlands. 292. Crewe, A. V., Lin, P., and Schuler, J. (1980). 1 MeV STEM: A Progress Report. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 6–7. 293. Crewe, A. V., Kopf, D., Ohtsuki, M., and Usala, P. (1980). Further Uses of Color in Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Proc 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 294. Kirkland, E. M., Freeman, W. T., Ohtsuki, M., and Siegel, B. M. (1980). Digital Image Processing of STEM Images of Tobacco Mosaic Virus (TMV). Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 40–41. 295. Listvan, M., Crewe, A. V., and Mankawich, W. (1980). A Temperature-Controlled High Resolution Stage. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 58–59. 296. Crewe, A. V. (1980). Theory of Optimal Scanning in the STEM. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 60–61. 297. Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1980). Application of the STEM Optimum Imaging Method on a Biological Macromolecule. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 62–63. 298. Crewe, A. V. (1980). A New Possibility for Correcting Cs. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 274–276. 299. Crewe, A. V., Mittleman, R. K., and Rosman, R. L. (1980). Preparation of Thin Graphite Supporting Films. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 410–411. 300. Kapp, O. H., Ohtsuki, M., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1980). Structural Investigation of Invertebrate Hemoglobins Using the STEM. Proc. 38th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 676–677. 301. Utlaut, M. (1980). Direct Observation of the Behavior of Heavy Single Atoms on Amorphous Carbon Substrates. Phys. Rev. B 22, 4650–4660. 302. Crewe, A. V. (1980). Studies on Sextupole Correctors. Optik 57, 313–327. 303. Isaacson, M., and Ohtsuki, M. (1980). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy of Small Inhomogeneous Particles: Applications to Ferritin. Scanning Electron Microscopy I, 73–80. 304. Ohtsuki, M. (1980). Observation of Unstained Biological Macromolecules with the STEM. Ultramicroscopy 5, 317–323. 305. Ohtsuki, M. (1980). Test Specimens for a Dark Field STEM Imaging: Measuring Lattice Spacing and Electron Probe Size of a STEM and Testing Visibility of Atoms of Various Atomic Numbers. Ultramicroscopy 5, 325–332.
52
A. V. Crewe
1981 306. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1981). Optimal Scanning and Image Processing with the STEM. Ultramicroscopy 7, 13–18. 307. Kapp, O. H., Ohtsuki, M., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1981). Oxygen Binding Study and High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) of Alkaline Dissociation Products of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin. Proc. 7th Int’l Biophysics Congress and 3rd Pan-American Biochemistry Congress. Mexico City, p. 60. 308. Kirkland, E. J., Freeman, W. T., Ohtsuki, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Siegal, B. M. (1981). Computer Image Processing of STEM Images of Tobacco Mosaic Virus. Ultramicroscopy 6, 367–376. 309. Kopf, D. A. (1981). Measurement of the Intensity Distribution in a STEM Probe. Optik 59, 89–110. 310. Ohtsuki, M. (1981). Preparation. ‘‘Observation, and Imaging Methods for High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy of a Biological Specimen.’’ Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan. 311. Snipes, J., Ohtsuki, M., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1981). Nucleation of Indium Atoms on an Amorphous Carbon Substrate. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 220–221. 312. Kapp, O. H., Ohtsuki, M., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1981). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) of Annelid Extracellular Hemoglobins. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 432–433. 313. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1981). Digital Processing of STEM Images. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 314. Kapp, O. H., Ohtsuki, M., Robin, N., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1981). Alkaline Dissociation Products of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin Viewed with the STEM. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 434–435. 315. Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1981). Results from a New Analytical Electron Microscope. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 378–379. 316. Kirkland, E. J., Freeman, W. T., Ohtsuki, M., Isaacson, M. S., and Siegel, B. M. (1981). Digital Image Processing of STEM Images of Tobacco Mosaic Virus. Proc. 39th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 317. Hwang, D. M., Utlaut, M., and Solin, S. A. (1981). Electron Energy Loss Studies of Potassium Intercalated Graphite. Synthetic Metals 3, 81–88. 318. Vinogradov, S. N., Kapp, O. H., and Ohtsuki, M. (1981). The Extracellular Hemoglobins and Chlorocruorins of Annelids. In ‘‘Electron Microscopy of Proteins’’, (Harris, J. R., ed.), Vol. 3, pp. 135–164. Academic Press Inc, London.
1982 319. Crewe, A. V. (1982). A System for the Correction of Axial Aperture Aberrations in Electron Lenses. Optik 60, 271–281. 320. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1982). A Digital Processor for Use with STEM Images. Proc. 10th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Hamburg, West Germany, pp. 531–532. 321. Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1982). A Thirteenth Subunit Revealed in Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin in STEM Low Dose Images. Proc. 10th Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy. Hamburg, West Germany, pp. 493–494. 322. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1982). A ‘‘Stand Alone’’ Image Processing System for STEM Images. Ultramicroscopy 9, 101–108. 323. Crewe, A. V., and Scaduto, F. (1982). A Gradient Field Spectrometer for STEM Use. Proc. 40th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 324. Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1982). Observation of a Central Subunit in Annelid Extracellular Hemoglobin Using the STEM Digital Processing Techniques. Proc. 40th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 704–705.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
53
325. Crewe, A. V., and Salzman, D. (1982). On the Optimum Resolution for a Corrected STEM. Ultramicroscopy 9, 373–378. 326. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1982). Digital Processing of STEM Images and False Color Displays. Hitachi Instrument News 11, 2–5. 327. Kapp, O. H., Vinogradov, S. N., Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1982). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy of Extracellular Annelid Hemoglobins. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 704, 546–548. 328. Golladay, S. D. (1982). Tropomyosin Structure and Intermolecular Contacts in Mg Paracrystals (Ph.D. Thesis). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 705, 277–283. 329. Crewe, A. V. (1982). A Low Cost Image Analysis System for Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy Low-Dose Images. Scanning Electron Microscopy IV, 1597–1601.
1983 330. Chen, E. G., Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1983). Attractive and Repulsive Forces Between Clusters: A STEM Study of Platinum Clusters. Proc. 41st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 334–335. 331. Ohtsuki, M., Schuler, J. J., Crewe, A. V., and Ichinokawa, T. (1983). Specimen Heating Stage with In situ Evaporator in UHV-STEM for the Observation and Characterization of Monolayered Superstructures. Proc. 41st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 308–309. 332. Listvan, M. A. (1983). The Development of Order in a System of Metal Clusters. Proc. 41st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 336–337. 333. Listvan, M. A., and Andres, R. P. (1983). Production and STEM Examination of Controlled-Size Clusters. Proc. 41st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 338–339. 334. Kapp, O. H., Ohtsuki, M., Crewe, A. V., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1983). Observation of Reconstituted Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin with the STEM. Proc. 41st Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 594–655. 335. Vinogradov, S. N., Polidori, G., Van Gelderen, J., and Kapp, O. H. (1983). The Dissociation of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of. Nephtys incisa, Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 76B, 207–214. 336. Listvan, M. A. (1983). Direct Observations of Small Gold Clusters and In Situ Cluster Growth by STEM. J. Mol. Catalysis 20, 265–278. 337. Vinogradov, S. N., and Kapp, O. H. (1983). Removal of Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate from Proteins by Ion Retardation Chromatography. In ‘‘Part J of Methods in Enzymology’’, (Hirs, C. H. W. and Timasheff, S., eds.), pp. 259–263. Academic Press, New York. 338. Vinogradov, S. N., and Kapp, O. H. (1983). Dissociation and Reassociation of Earthworm Hemoglobin. Life Chemistry Reports (Suppl. 1), 147–156. 339. Vinogradov, S. N., Kapp, O. H., Messerschmidt, U., Schwartz, E., and Pilz, I. (1983). Nephtys: An Unusual Extracelleular Annelid Hemoglobin with a Central Subunit. Life Chemistry Reports (Suppl.1), 197–202. 340. Crewe, A. V. (1983). High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Science 221, 325–330. 341. Hwang, D. M., Parker, N. W., Utlaut, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1983). Observation of Nonhexagonal Superlattices in High-stage Cesium Intercalated Graphite. Phys. Rev. B 27, 1458–1461. 342. Ohtsuki, M. (1983). A High Resolution STEM and its Application to the Observation of Biological Macromolecules. J. Cryst. Soc. Japan 25, 38–50. 343. Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1983). Direct Observation of Biological Macromolecules with the Atomic Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Phys. Soc. of Japan 38, 550–556. 344. Kritchman, E. M. (1983). Ideal Second Stages in Tandem with Spherical Mirrors. Solar Energy 30, 481–482. 345. Crewe, A. V., and Ohtsuki, M. (1983). Evidence for a Central Substructure in a Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin Obtained with STEM Low-dose and Digital Processing Techniques. J. Ultrastructure Research 83, 312–318.
54
A. V. Crewe
1984 346. Crewe, A. V., and Crewe, D. A. (1984). Inexact Reconstructions from Projections. Ultramicroscopy 12, 293–298. 347. Crewe, A. V., Crewe, D. A., and Kapp, O. H. (1984). Inexact Three Dimensional Reconstruction of a Biological Macromolecule from a Restricted Number of Projections. Ultramicroscopy 13, 365–372. 348. Kapp, O. H., Polidori, G., Mainwaring, M., Crewe, A. V., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1984). The Reassociation of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin Dissociated at Alkaline pH. J. Biol. Chem. 259, 628–639. 349. Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). The Size and Shape of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of. Tubifex tubifex, Biochimica et Biophys. Acta 789, 294–301. 350. Chen, E. G., Ohtsuki, M., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). A STEM Study of a Platinum Deposit on an Amorphous Carbon Film: The Effects of Contact Voltage in the Nucleation Process. Surf. Sci. 144, 465–476. 351. Lewis, R. S., and Ohtsuki, M. (1984). Interstellar Carbon Grains from the Murchison Meteorite: Electron Microscopy. Proc. 47th Annual Meteoretical Soc. Meeting, p. L-8. Albuquerque, NM. 352. Ohtsuki, M., Edelstein, C., and Scanu, A. M. (1984). Similarity in Structures of Canine High Density Lipoproteins Containing Either Apo A-I or Human Apo A-II as Assessed by a Scanning Transmission Electron Micrsocpy Digital Techniques. Arteriosclerosis 4, 566a. 353. Crewe, A. V. (1984). Optimisation of a STEM. Proc. Roy. Microsc. Soc. MICRO 84 19, S59. 354. Crewe, A. V. (1984). Very High Resolution: A Place for the STEM. Proc. 42nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 372–375. 355. Crewe, A. V., and Crewe, D. A. (1984). Inexact Reconstruction: A. The Basic Method. Proc. 42nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 634–635. 356. Kapp, O. H., Crewe, D. A., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). Inexact Reconstruction: B. Application to a Biological Object. Proc. 42nd Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 636–637. 357. Crewe, A. V., Crewe, D. A., and Kapp, O. H. (1984). Three Dimensional Reconstruction of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin from a Restricted Number of STEM Projections. Biophysical Journal 45, 371A. 358. Crewe, D. A., Crewe, A. V., and Kapp, O. H. (1984). Inexact Three Dimensional Reconstruction of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin. Proc. ASBC/AII Meeting, p. 1562. St. Louis. 359. Schwartz, C., Vinogradov, S. N., Kapp, O. H., Crewe, A. V., and Mainwaring, M. (1984). Molecular Size and Subunits of Myxicola chlorocruorin. Proc. ASBC/AII Meeting, p. 1562. St. Louis. 360. Kapp, O. H., Crewe, A. V., Mainwaring, M. G., Schwartz, C., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1984). The Size and Shape of the Hemoglobin of Macrobdella decora. Proc. ASBC/AII Meeting, p. 1578. St. Louis. 361. Mainwaring, M. G., Vinogradov, S. N., Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). Acid Dissociation and Reassociation of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin. Proc. ASBC/AII Meeting, p. 1579. St. Louis. 362. Vinogradov, S. N., Kapp, O. H., Crewe, A. V., and Mainwaring, M. (1984). Studies of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Amphitrita ornata. Proc. ASBC/AII Meeting, p. 1579. St. Louis. 363. Vinogradov, S. N., Van Gelderin, J. A., Polidori, G., and Kapp, O. H. (1984). Dissociation of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of. Nephytys, Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 76B, 207–214. 364. Kapp, O. H., Crewe, A. V., Mainwaring, M. G., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1984). The Size and Shape of the Hemoglobin of Macrobdella decora. Proc. 8th Intl. Biophys. Congr. p. 234. Bristol, England.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
55
365. McNamara, G. R., Kapp, O. H., Barrett, T. A., Mooney, P. E., Jiye, X., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). A New Image Processing System for STEM Images. Proc. 8th Intl. Biophys. Congr. p. 234. Bristol, England. 366. Crewe, A. V. (1984). An Introduction to the STEM. J. Ultrastr. Res. 88, 94–104. 367. Crewe, A. V. (1984). The Sextupole Corrector 1. Algebraic Calculations. Optik 69, 24–29. ˚ STEM.’’ Enrico Fermi Institute, The 368. Ohtsuki, M. (1984). ‘‘An Introduction to the 2.5A University of Chicago. 369. Ohtsuki, M., and Schudy, E. (1984). Assessment of Morphology of Assymmetrical Biological Macromolecules with Digital Techniques. J. Ultrast. Res. 89, 303–308. 370. Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1984). Comparison of the Molecular Size and Shape of the Extracellular Hemoglobins of Tubifex tubifex and Lumbricus terrestris, Biochim. et Biophys. Acta 789, 294–301.
1985 371. Crewe, A. V., and Crewe, D. A. (1985). Inexact Reconstruction: Some Improvements. Ultramicroscopy 16, 33–40. 372. Crewe, A. V., and Jiye, X. (1985). Correction of Spherical and Coma Aberrations with a Sextupole-Round Lens-Sextupole System. Optik 69, 141–146. 373. Jiye, X., Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1985). The Wave Electron Optical Properties of a Magnetic Round Lens Corrected with Sextupoles. Optik 70, 37–42. 374. Shao, Z., and Jiye, X. (1985). Two Dimensional Phase Retrieval from Image and Diffraction Patterns in Electron Microscopes. Optik 71, 15–22. 375. Jiye, X., and Shao, Z. (1985). Three Dimensional Algebraic Reconstruction from Three Mutually Orthogonal Projections. Optik 71, 143–148. 376. Crewe, A. V. (1985). Towards the Ultimate Scanning Microscope. Scanning Electron Microscopy II, 467–472. 377. Vinogradov, S. N., Standley, P. R., Mainwaring, M. G., Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1985). The Molecular Size of Myxicola infundibulum chlorocruorin and its Subunits. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 828, 43–50. 378. Jiye, X., and Kapp, O. H. (1985). Classification of Projection Images by Multivariate Matrix Analysis. Proc. FASEB Mtg. p. 1096. Anaheim, CA. 379. Kapp, O. H., and Jiye, X. (1985). Three Dimensional Reconstruction of a Biological Object Using Multivariate Matrix Analysis. Proc. FASEB Mtg. p. 1096. Anaheim, CA. 380. Kapp, O. H., Crewe, D. A., Crewe, A. V., Mainwaring, M. G., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1985). Three Dimensional Reconstruction of the Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris from STEM Projections. 13th Int’l Congress of Biochemistry. Amsterdam. 381. McNamara, G. R., Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1985). A New Image Processing System for STEM Images. Proc. 13th Int’l Congress of Biochemistry. The Netherlands. 382. Jiye, X., and Kapp, O. H. (1985). Classification of Projection Images by Multivariate Matrix Analysis. Optik 70, 101–108. 383. Kapp, O. H., and Jiye, X. (1985). Classification of Electron Microscopic Images by Multivariate Matrix Analysis. Optik 70, 146–151. 384. Jiye, X., and Shao, Z. (1985). A Study of an Inhomogeneous Gradient Magnetic Field Spectrometer with a Curvilinear Axis. Optik 71, 73–79. 385. Salzman, D., O’Connor, M., Smith, R., Goodman, A., and Breslau, D. (1985). A Unified Environment for Image Processing, Graphics, and Instrument Control. Proc. 1st Int’l Conf. on Computer Workstations. pp. 173–180. San Jose, CA. 386. Lamy, J., Sizaret, P. Y., Musmeci, T., Kapp, O. H., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1985). Has Annelid Erythrocruorin a 6-fold Axis of Symmetry? Int’l Symposium on Invertebrate Oxygen Carriers Tutzing, West Germany. 387. Kapp, O. H. (1985). Capabilities of the STEM: Present and Future. Frontiersin Science Symposium, 190th American Chemical Society. Chicago.
56
A. V. Crewe
388. Levi-Setti, R., Crow, G., Wang, Y. L., Parker, N. W., and Mittleman, R. K. (1985). HighResolution Scanning-Ion-Microprobe Study of Graphite and its Intercalation Compounds. Phys. Rev. Let. 54, 2615–2618. 389. Crewe, A. V. (1985). Gravure in the Digital Age. Gravure Technical Assoc. Convention. Chicago. 390. Crewe, A. V. (1985). The Chicago Microscope Project. IBM-ACIS Conf. Santa Clara. 391. Crow, G., Wang, Y. L., Parker, N. W., Mittleman, R., Qian, X. W., and Solin, S. A. (1985). Applications of Microscopic Probes in the Study of Graphite Intercalation Compounds. ‘‘Synthetic Metals.’’
1986 392. Jiye, X., and Kapp, O. H. (1986). Three Dimensional Algebraic Reconstruction from Projections of Multiple Grey Level Objects. Optik 72, 87–94. 393. Kapp, O. H., and Jiye, X. (1986). Eigenvalue Analysis for Classifying Projection Images of an Object with Arbitrary Orientation. Optik 73, 51–55. 394. Jiye, X., and Kapp, O. H. (1986). Eigenvalue and Eigenvector Analysis in Multivariate Matrix Theory for Classifying Projection Images. Optik 72, 143–148. 395. Kapp, O. H., and The High Resolution, S. T. E. M. (1986). Now and Later. NAS Conference on Recent Advances in Electron and Light Imaging in Biology and Medicine. New York. 396. Jiye, X., and Kapp, O. H. (1986). Supplement to Three Dimensional Algebraic Reconstruction from Projections of Multiple Grey Level Objects. Optik 73, 10–12. 397. Jiye, X. (1986). Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics, Suppl. 17. in Academic Press. 398. Crewe, A. V. (1986). Limits of the STEM. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 764–765. 399. Mu, C., and Wolbach, W. (1986). Particulate Carbon at the Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 782–783. 400. Mu, C., and Shao, Z. (1986). Inexact Reconstruction with Added Noise. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 184–185. 401. Mittleman, R. K., and Parker, N. W. (1986). SbC15 Intercalated Graphite. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 780–781. 402. Mittleman, R. K., and Parker, N. W. (1986). Micrograph Image Processing System. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 872–873. 403. Barrett, T. (1986). Reconstruction with Noisy Data. Proc. 44th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 186–187. 404. Mainwaring, M. G., Lugo, S. D., Fingol, R. A., Kapp, O. H., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1986). The Dissociation of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris at Acid pH and its Reassociation at Neutral pH. J. Biol. Chem. 261, 10899–10908. 405. Crewe, A. V. (1986). What to Teach About the Physics of the SEM. ‘‘SEM Mtg.’’ New Orleans. 406. Crewe, A. V. (1986). Thoughts on Images and Objects. Institute for Imaging Science. Univ. of Chicago. 407. Crewe, A. V. (1986). High Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. Frontiers of Electron Microscopy in Materials Science. Argonne National Laboratory. 408. Crewe, A. V. (1986). Is There a Limit to the Resolving Power of the SEM? Proc. XIth Int’l Congress on Electron Microscopy III, pp. 2105–2108. Kyoto. 409. Crewe, A. V. (1986). A Totally New Computer-Controlled High Resolution SEM. 5th Ann. Symposium on Adv. in Electron Microscopy. Beaufort, NC. 410. Crewe, A. V. (1986). Scanning Electron Microscopy at the Atomic Level. Proc. 1st Int’l New Materials Conf. and Exhibition 1, pp. 43–45. Osaka. 411. Vinogradov, S. N., Lugo, S. D., Mainwaring, M. G., Kapp, O. H., and Crewe, A. V. (1986). Bracelet Protein: A Quaternary Structure Proposed for the Giant Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris. Proc. Nat’l Acad. Sci. Sciences (USA) 83, 8034–8038.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
57
412. Listvan, M. (1986). Determination of Time Dependence of Domain Growth by Direct Observation of Small Metal Clusters. Surf. Sci. 173, 294–309. 413. Lugo, S., Kapp, O. H., Mainwaring, M., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1985). The Dissociation of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris at Acid pH and its Reassociation at Neutral pH. 30th Ann. Mtg. Biophysical Society; Biophysical Journal 49, p. 543a. 414. Vinogradov, S. N., Lugo, S., Mainwaring, M., and Kapp, O. H. (1985). Bracelet Protein: A New Model of the Quaternary Structure of Lumbricus terrestris Hemoglobin. 30th Ann. Mtg. Biophysical Society; Biophysical Journal 49, 543a. San Francisco. 415. Lugo, S., Kapp, O. H., Mainwaring, M., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1985). The Dissociation of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris at Neutral pH. 30th Ann. Mtg. Biophysical Society; Biophysical Journal 49, p. 543a. San Francisco.
1987 416. Parker, N. W., Mittleman, R. K., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). New Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Microanalytical System. Rev. Scientific Instruments 58, 174–182. 417. Shao, Z. (1987). Probe Size and 5th-Order Aberration. 45th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 134–135. 418. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). Chromatic Aberration and Low-Voltage SEM. Proc. 45th Ann. EMSA Mtg. 546–547. 419. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). Spherical Aberrations of Multipoles. J. Appl. Physics 62, 1149–1153. 420. Shao, Z. (1987). A Study on Multipole Systems as Correctors. Optik 75, 152–157. 421. Shao, Z., Mu, C., and Kapp, O. H. (1987). Inexact Reconstruction of Multiple Grey Level Objects from their Projections. Optik 76, 12–17. 422. Crewe, A. V. (1987). Optimisation of Small Electron Probes. Ultramicroscopy 23, 159–168. 423. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). Chromatic Aberration Effects in Small Electron Probes. Ultramicroscopy 23, 169–174. 424. Mittleman, R. K., Parker, N. W., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). Electron Diffraction Study of SbCl5 Intercalated Graphite. Phys. Rev. B 36, 7590–7600. 425. Beck, V. D. (1987). A Wave Optical Treatment of Space Charge. Optik 76, 167–169. 426. Kapp, O. H., Mainwaring, M. G., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). A Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopic Examination of the Hexagonal Bilayer Structures Formed by the Reassociation of Three Out of the Four Subunits of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terrestris. Proc. FASEB Mtg. 46, p. 2266. Philadelphia. 427. Kapp, O. H., Mainwaring, M. G., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1987). A Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopic Examination of the Hexagonal Bilayer Structures Formed by the Reassociation of Three Out of the Four Subunits of the Extracellular Hemoglobin of Lumbricus terresris. Proc. Nat’l Acad. of Sciences (USA) 84, 7532–7536. 428. Mittleman, R. K. (1987). Electron Diffraction Study of Rubidium-Intercalated Graphite Through the Deintercalation Process. Phys. Rev. B 36, 6001–6011.
1988 429. Mu, C., Shao, Z., and Kapp, O. H. (1988). Three Dimensional Reconstruction from Noisy Projections. Optik 79, 99. 430. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). A Study on the Optimisation of Apertures in an Aberrated Probe Forming System. Optik 79, 105–110. 431. Shao, Z., Beck, V. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). A Study of Octupoles as Correctors. J. Applied Phys. 64, 1646–1651. 432. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). Ideal Lenses and the Scherzer Theorem: A Supplement. Ultramicroscopy 26, 385. 433. Shao, Z. (1988). Toward High-Resolution Low-Voltage SEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 218–219.
58
A. V. Crewe
434. Crewe, A. V. (1988). Instrumentation for a Corrected STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 652–653. 435. Crewe, A. V. (1988). Some Notes on the History of the STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 234–235. 436. Mooney, P. E. (1988). A Compact, Digital, Optically Isolated Control and Support System for a Field Emission Source on the 200 Kv STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 654–655. 437. Shao, Z. (1988). Correction of Spherical Aberrations in the Transmission Electron Microscope. Optik 80, 61–75. 438. Shao, Z. (1988). New Lens for a Low Voltage SEM. Rev. Scientific Instruments 59, 1985. 439. Shao, Z. (1988). On the 5th Order Aberration in a Sextupole Corrected System. Rev. Scientific Instruments 59, 2429–2437. 440. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1988). Quaternary Structure and Molecular Weight of the Giant Extracellular Hemoglobins. ‘‘Asilomar Conference on Oxygen Binding Heme Proteins.’’ Pacific Grove, CA. 441. Vinogradov, S. N., and Kapp, O. H. (1988). Determination of the Stochiometry of Multi-subunit Proteins. Asilomar Conference on Oxygen Binding Heme Proteins. Pacific Grove, CA. 442. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1988). Bracelet Structures Obtained From Invertebrate Hemoglobins. Proc. Protein Society. San Diego, CA. 443. Suzuki, T., Kapp, O. H., and Gotoh, T. (1988). Novel S-S Loops in the Giant Hemoglobin of Tylorrhynchus heterochaetus. J. Biol. Chem. 263, 18524–18529. 444. Mu, C., Shao, Z., and Kapp, O. H. (1988). Three Dimensional Reconstruction from Noisy Projections. Optik 79, 99. 445. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., Mainwaring, M. G., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1988). The Molecular Dimensions and Masses of Annelid Extracellular Hemoglobins and Chlorocruorins. 32nd Ann. Mtg. Biophys. Soc. Arizona. 446. Vinogradov, S. N., Mainwaring, MG., and Kapp, O. H. (1988). The Structure of the Annelid Extracellular Hemoglobins. 32nd Ann. Mtg. Biophys. Soc. Arizona. 447. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). A Study on the Optimisation of Apertures in an Aberrated Probe Forming System. Optik 79, 105–110. 448. Shao, Z., Beck, V. D., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). A Study of Octupoles as Correctors. J. Applied Phys. 64, 1646–1651. 449. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1988). Ideal Lenses and the Scherzer Theorem: A Supplement. Ultramicroscopy 26, 385. 450. Shao, Z. (1988). Toward High-Resolution Low-Voltage SEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 218–219. 451. Crewe, A. V. (1988). Instrumentation for a Corrected STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 652–653. 452. Crewe, A. V. (1988). Some Notes on the History of the STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 234–235. 453. Mooney, P. E. (1988). A Compact, Digital, Optically Isolated Control and Support System for a Field Emission Source on the 200 Kv STEM. Proc. 46th Ann. EMSA Mtg. pp. 654–655. 454. Shao, Z. (1988). Correction of Spherical Aberrations in the Transmission Electron Microscope. Optik 80, 61–75. 455. Shao, Z. (1988). New Lens for a Low Voltage SEM. Rev. Scientific Instruments 59, 1985. 456. Shao, Z. (1988). On the 5th Order Aberration in a Sextupole Corrected System. Rev. Scientific Instruments 59, 2429–2437. 457. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1988). Quaternary Structure and Molecular Weight of the Giant Extracellular Hemoglobins. Asilomar Conference on Oxygen Binding Heme Proteins. Pacific Grove, CA.
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
59
458. Vinogradov, S. N., and Kapp, O. H. (1988). Determination of the Stoechiometry of Multi-subunit Proteins. Asilomar Conference on Oxygen Binding Heme Proteins. Pacific Grove, CA. 459. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1988). Bracelet Structures Obtained From Invertebrate Hemoglobins. Proc. Protein Society. San Diego, CA.
1989 460. Shao, Z. (1989). Extraction of Secondary Electrons in a Newly Proposed Immersion Lens. Rev. Scientific Instruments 60, 693–699. 461. Crewe, A. V., Clayton, D. L., Crewe, D. A., and Moscicka, K. (1989). User-Friendly Field Emission. Proc. 47th Annual EMSA Mtg. San Antonio, TX 462. Crewe, A. V. (1989). Small, Cool Lenses. Proc. 47th Annual EMSA Mtg. San Antonio, TX 463. Kapp, O. H., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Direct Calculation of Subunit Stoichiometry from Amino Acid Compositions of Multimeric Proteins and Their Subunits. International Symposium on Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers. Leuven, Belgium. 464. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Comparison of the Three-Dimensional Reconstructions of the Hemoglobins of Lumbricus terrestris and Macrobdella decora from STEM data. International Symposium on Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers. Leuven, Belgium. 465. Kapp, O. H., Schmuck, M., Pilz, I., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Comparison of the Molecular Dimensions and Hydrodynamic Properties of Annelid Hemoglobins Obtained by STEM and SAXS. International Symposium on Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers. Leuven, Belgium. 466. Kapp, O. H., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Direct Calculation of Subunit Stoichiometry from Amino Acid Compositions of Multimeric Proteins and Their Subunits. Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers, pp. 213–217. University of Leuven Press. 467. Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Comparison of the ThreeDimensional Reconstructions of the Hemoglobins of Lumbricus terrestris and Macrobdella decora from STEM data. Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers, pp. 229–233. University of Leuven Press. 468. Kapp, O. H., Schmuck, M., Pilz, I., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1989). Comparison of the Molecular Dimensions and Hydrodynamic Properties of Annelid Hemoglobins Obtained by STEM and SAXS. Invertebrate Dioxygen Carriers, pp. 219–223. University of Leuven Press. 469. Shao, Z., and Lin, P. S. D. (1989). A High Resolution Low Voltage Electron Optical System For Very Large Specimens. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 60, 3434. 470. Shao, Z., and Wu, X. D. (1989). Appl. Phys. Lett. 55, 2696.
1990 471. Crewe, A. V. (1990). Some thoughts on ultra-high Resolution. Int. Symp. Elec. Micro., Beijing, China, p. 1. World Scientific. 472. Crewe, A. V. (1990). Beyond One Angstrom. Proceedings of the XIIth International Congress for Electron Microscopy. 473. Kapp, O. H., Qabar, A. N., Bonner, M. C., Walz, D. A., Wall, J. S., Vinogradov, S. N., Stern, M. S., and Schmuck, M. (1990). Quaternary Structure of the Giant Extracellular Haemoglobin of the Leech. Macrobdella Decora, J. Mol. Biol. 213, 141. 474. Kapp, O. H., Qabar, A. N., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1990). Calculation of Subunit Stoichiometry of Large, Multisubunit Proteins from Amino Acid Compositions. Anal. Biochem. 184, 74–82. 475. Shao, Z., and Wu, X. D. (1990). Properties of a Four-Electrode Adjustable Electron Mirror as an Aberration Corrector. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 61, 1230. 476. Shao, Z., and Wu, X. D. (1990). A study on Hyperbolic Mirrors as Correctors. Optik 84, 51.
60
A. V. Crewe
477. Wu, X. D., and Shao, Z. (1990). A Qualitative Analysis of Chromatic Aberration of ‘‘Thick’’ Electrostatic Lenses. Optik 84, 66. 478. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1990). Progress on the Sextupole-Corrected Sub-Angstrom Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope: An Abstract. 1990 Midwest SPIE Meeting, pp. 27–29. Rosemont, IL, Sept. 479. Zmola, C., and Kapp, O. H. (1990). Image Processing Utilizing an APL Interface: An Abstract. 1990 Midwest SPIE Meeting, pp. 27–29. Rosemont, IL, Sept. 480. Zmola, C., and Kapp, O. H. (1990). Networking of an Electron Microscope Laboratory Internally and to the Internet: An Abstract. 1990 Midwest SPIE Meeting, pp. 27–29 Rosemont, IL, Sept. 481. Ryan, M. J., and Kapp, O. H. (1990). Development of an Image Processing System on a Second Generation RISC Workstation: An Abstract1990 Midwest SPIE Meeting, Rosemont, IL, Sept. 27–29. 482. Kapp, O. H., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1990). The Structure of the Hemoglobin of Eudystilia Vancouverii: Evidence for Isolated Bracelet Protein. 10th International Biophysics Congress-Satellite Meeting. Whistler, British Columbia. 483. Vinogradov, S. N., Mainwaring, M., and Kapp, O. H. (1990). The Quaternary Structure of the Giant Hemoglobins and Chlorocruorins. 10th International Biophysics CongressSatellite Meeting. Whistler, British Columbia. 484. Kapp, O. H., Mainwaring, M. G., Vinogradov, S. N., and Crewe, A. V. (1990). The Extracellular Hemoglobin of Amphitrite Ornata: Its Molecular Size, Subunits and Its Dissociation. 10th International Biophysics Congress-Satellite Meeting. Whistler, British Columbia.
1991 485. Crewe, A. V. (1991). An Algebraic approach to the symmetrical einzel lens. Optik 88, 118–125. 486. Crewe, A. V. (1991). A New Characterization of the Magnetic Lens. Optik 89, 70–74. 487. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1991). Progress on the Sextupole-Corrected Sub-Angstrom Resolution Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. SPIE Proceedings 1396, 298–310. 488. Zmola, C., and Kapp, O. H. (1991). Image Processing Utilizing an APL Interface. SPIE Proceedings 1396, 51–55. 489. Zmola, C., and Kapp, O. H. (1991). Networking of an Electron Microscope Laboratory Internally and to the Internet. SPIE Proceedings 1396, 331–334. 490. Ryan, M. J., and Kapp, O. H. (1991). Development of an Image Processing System on a Second Generation RISC Workstation. SPIE Proceedings 1396, 335–339. 491. Walz, D., Chin, J., Timkovich, R., Wall, J., Kapp, O., and Vinogradov, S. (1991). Hierarchy of Globin Complexes: The Quaternary Structure of Eudistylia vancouverii. J. Mol. Biol. 222, 1109–1129. 492. Shao, Z., and Crewe, A. V. (1989). On the Resolution of the Low-Energy Electron Reflection Microscope. Ultramicroscopy 31, 199–204. 493. Shao, Z., and Wang, Y. L. (1990). On the Optimisation of Ion Micro-Probes. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B. 8, 95–99. 494. Sharma, P. K., Qabar, A. N., Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1991). The principal subunit of earthworm hemoglobin is a dodecamer of heme containing chains. In ‘‘Structure and Function of Invertebrate Oxygen Binding Proteins: Proceedings Biophysical Society Satellite Symposium of the Xth International Biophysics Congress’’, (Vinogradov, S. N. and Kapp, O. H., eds.), pp. 65–72. Springer-Verlag. 495. Sharma, P. K., Qabar, A. N., Kapp, O. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1991). Studies of the Dissociation of Eudistylia Vancouverii chlorocruorin. In ‘‘Structure and Function of Invertebrate Oxygen Binding Proteins: Proceedings Biophysical Society Satellite
The Work of Albert Victor Crewe on the STEM
61
Symposium of the Xth International Biophysics Congress’’, (Vinogradov, S. N. and Kapp, O. H., eds.), pp. 79–86. Springer-Verlag.
1992 496. Kapp, O. H., and Chen, C.-T. (1992). Reconstruction from Limited Projection Data. SPIE Proceedings on Biomedical Image Processing and Three-Dimensional Microscopy. San Jose, pp. 26–29 Feb. 9–14. 497. Chen, C.-T., Kapp, O. H., and Wong, W. H. (1992). Stochastic Reconstruction of Incomplete Data Sets Using Gibbs Priors in Positron Emission Tomography. SPIE Proceedings on Biomedical Image Processing and Three-Dimensional Microscopy. San Jose, pp. 131–134 Feb. 9–14. 498. Kapp, O. H., and Ruan, S. (1992). Analysis of STEM images on a RISC workstation with an APL interface. Proc. SPIE 1778, 117–119. 499. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1992). An Automatic Field Emission Tip Conditioning System. Review of Scientific Instruments 63, 4056–4060. 500. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1991). Progress on the sextupole-corrected sub-angstrom resolution scanning transmission electron microscope. SPIE Proceedings 1396, 298–310. 501. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1992). An Automatic Field Emission Tip Conditioning System for the sub-angstrom field-emission STEM. In ‘‘SPIE Proceedings’’, (Ruan, S. and Kapp, O., eds.), SPIE Proceedings 1778, pp. 103–106. 502. Ruan, S., and Kapp, O. H. (1993). Scan System for a Sextupole-corrected Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope. Review of Scientific Instruments 64, 667–671. 503. Vinogradov, S. N., Walz, D. A., Pohajdak, B., Moens, L., Kapp, O. H., Suzuki, T., and Trotman, C. N. (1993). Adventitious Variability? The Amino Acid Sequences of Nonvertebrate Globins, Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B 106, 7–26. 504. Crewe, A. V. (1991). The Three Element Electrostatic Lens. Optik 90, 151–157. 505. Crewe, A. V. (1992). Electron motion in Tuned Fields. I. The Algebra. Ultramicrscopy 41, 269–277. 506. Crewe, A. V. (1992). Electron motion in Tuned Fields. II. Some Applications. Ultramicroscopy 41, 279–285.
Chapter
2 A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
Contents
1. Introduction 2. Work Function 3. Energy Distribution 3.1. Theoretical Background 3.2. Analytical versus Numerical Results 3.3. Measured Values of the FWHM for the Tungsten Cold-Field Electron 4. Source Optics 5. Column Optics Using the Cold-Field Electron Source 6. Current Stability 6.1. High-Frequency Current Fluctuations 6.2. Long-Term Current Drift 6.3. Cold-Field Electron End-of-Life Mechanisms 7. Summary Acknowledgments References
63 65 67 67 68 72 79 82 86 87 88 94 97 98 98
1. INTRODUCTION The room temperature field electron (FE) source, coined the cold-field electron (CFE) source to distinguish it from the high-temperature thermal-field electron (TFE) and Schottky electron (SE) emission modes of operation, is currently used in some transmission electron microscopy (TEM), FEI Co. Hillsboro, Oregon, USA Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59002-7. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
63
64
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) products. A review of the key source characteristics (e.g., energy spread, brightness, emitter geometry, life, and stability) of the CFE source needed for successful electron optical applications are given. The TFE and SE modes of operation (Swanson and Schwind, 2009) and the basic science of field emission have been covered by numerous reviews (Dyke and Dolan, 1956; Gomer, 1961; Good and Mu¨ller, 1956; Hawkes and Kaspers, 1989; Modinos, 1984; Mu¨ller, 1951; Murphy and Good, 1956; Swanson and Bell, 1973) and are not addressed herein. Many of the early post–World War II investigations of field emission phenomena came from three groups led by Professors Erwin Mu¨ller (Pennsylvania State University), Robert Gomer (University of Chicago), and Walter Dyke (Linfield Research Institute, McMinnville, Oregon). One of the authors (L.W.S) was a part of the latter two groups. The Dyke group had an early emphasis on a variety of possible applications of CFE and TFE sources and formed Field Emission Corporation in the early 1960s and was the first company to use the FE source in a commercial product. Another research group at the University of Chicago led by Professor Albert Crewe in the late 1960s was instrumental in the successful application of the CFE cathode to both SEM (Crewe, Wall, and Walter, 1968) and STEM (Crewe, Isaacson, and Johnson, 1969) applications. Subsequently a variety of companies (e.g., Coats and Welter, Hitachi, JEOL, Vacuum Generators, and others) used the CFE cathode for commercial SEM, TEM, and STEM applications. Although the W/ZrO SE source (Swanson and Schwind, 2009) has since become the primary FE source used in most commercial SEM and TEM instruments, the CFE source may have some advantages for the highest-resolution STEM, TEM, and EELS applications. Despite the fact that a great variety of refractory metals, metalloids, semiconductors, carbon nano tubes, and a variety of nano tips have been investigated for their FE properties, the tungsten CFE source with an apex radius in the 100- to 200-nm range has continued to be the choice for commercial applications using the CFE source. Among other requirements, for a FE source to be useful for electron optical applications it must have its dominant emission direction on the optical axis and be resistant to long-term current drift and high-frequency current fluctuations in practical vacuum environments. As discussed in more detail in Section 2, it is necessary to orient the tungsten crystal so that the low work function planes are situated on the emitter apex. Simultaneously the FE source must provide adequate values of the brightness and energy spread at the required beam current. In this review, attention will be focused on results obtained from the tungsten CFE source oriented with the <310> and <111> crystallographic directions along the source axis. Emission characteristics of
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
65
interest for TEM and SEM applications such as energy spread and brightness are discussed in Sections 3 and 4. A comparison between a CFE and SE source in a typical SEM column is given in Section 5 and Section 6 addresses current stability issues.
2. WORK FUNCTION Figure 1 shows the emission pattern from a tungsten emitter fabricated from drawn polycrystalline wire. For most electron optical applications, the useful current is contained in a small solid angle centered on the emitter axis. Unfortunately, emitters electrochemically etched from drawn tungsten are always oriented with the high work function (110) plane perpendicular to the emitter axis, resulting in negligible emission for a small acceptance aperture centered on the emitter axis. Interestingly, as shown in Table 1, the variation in work function with crystal face has an approximate inverse relationship with the atomic plane density in accordance with the semi-quantitative theoretical expectations put forth by Smoluchowski (1941). This has implications for the high-frequency current fluctuations discussed in Section 6. In the early 1960s the Dyke group at the Linfield Research Institute developed a zone melting technique using seed crystals of various
211
100
110
FIGURE 1 Emission pattern of a clean W<110> oriented emitter with the major crystal planes noted.
66
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
TABLE 1 Work function (Measured at 77 K and 300 K) and flicker noise values for various planes of tungsten
Crystal Plane
310 111 112 100 110
Work Function (eV)
Atom Density (nm–2)
%Flicker Noise (0–1 kHz) at 500 K*
4.25 0.08* 4.47 0.02{ 4.96 0.09* 4.63 0.02{ 5.25 0.02{
6.34 5.79 8.19 10.03 14.18
8.3 2.6 2.4 1.1 0
* From Swanson and Crouser (1967) by averaging values from various FE methods. { From Strayer et al. (1973) using an FE-retarding potential method.
orientation to zone melt 2-mm diameter polycrystalline tungsten rod into an oriented single-crystal rod that could subsequently be electrochemically etched to a 0.12-mm diameter wire, from which single-crystal emitters of various orientations could be fabricated. This allowed oriented single-crystal FE sources to be created from almost all refractory materials, including the borides and carbides of refractory metals (Mackie and Hinrichs, 1988). Without the ability to control the emission angular distribution by reliably orienting one of the low work function (i.e., high emission current density) planes on the apex of the FE source, as is the case for many varieties of carbon nano tubes (Dean and Chalamala, 1999; DeJonge et al., 2004), the FE source would be of little value for electron optical applications. In some cases, localization of emission on the emitter axis was accomplished through the formation of nano bumps on the emitter apex or the formation of a pyramid-shaped source FE (as opposed to a hemispherical shape) with a near single-atom emitting area that relies on localizing the emission to the emitter apex by virtue of localizing the highest electric field (Binh and Garcia, 1992; Kuo et al., 2006; Mu¨ller et al., 1993, Qian, Scheinfein, and Spence, 1993). None of these nano-tip sources has yet appeared on the commercial scene. From the list of the work function values for the major planes of tungsten given in Table 1 (Strayer et al., 1973; Swanson and Crouser, 1967), it is clear that to have one of the low work function planes located at the emitter apex the emitter axis orientation must be <310> or <111>. Historically, the W<310>-oriented emitter has been the emitter orientation used for most commercial applications because of its low value of work function. In a subsequent discussion it will be pointed out that the <111>-oriented tungsten may have some advantages despite its slightly higher work function value.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
67
3. ENERGY DISTRIBUTION 3.1. Theoretical Background The original derivation by Young (1959) of the total energy distribution J(e) based on the Sommerfeld free-electron model for the CFE source is JðeÞ ¼ JFN ee=d =dð1 þ ee=pd Þ;
(2.1)
where p ¼ kT/d, e ¼ E-Ef is the emitted electron energy relative to the Fermi level Ef and JFN is the T ¼ 0 K current density given by the Fowler– Nordheim (FN) equation as e3 F2
exp½4ð2me ’3 Þ1=2 vðyÞ=F 8p’htðyÞ2 1:54x106 F2 exp½6:831x109 ’3=2 vðyÞ=F A=m2 ; ¼ 2 ’tðyÞ
JFN ¼
(2.2)
where F and ’ are the electric field (in volts/meters) and work function (in electron volts), respectively, and d ¼ heF=4pð2me ’Þ1=2 tðyÞ ¼ 9:760x1011 F=’1=2 tðyÞ ðeVÞ:
(2.3)
The variables v(y) and t(y) arise from the inclusion of the image potential in the derivation of the FN equation and are tabulated functions (Good and Mu¨ller, 1956) of the variable y ¼ (e3F/4peo)1/2/’ ¼ 3.7495 10–5 F1/2/’. Accurate empirical relationships for v(y) and t(y) have been formulated by Forbes (2006). The temperature range over which the approximations in deriving Eq. (2.1) are valid is defined by p < 0.7. It can be shown that the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the total energy distribution (TED) at T ¼ 0 K is 0.69 d. In addition, the average initial transverse energy of the emitted electrons, d (Swanson and Bell, 1973) can be obtained directly from the TED. For a TED taken at 77 K, the value of d can be obtained directly from the trailing edge of the TED from the slope of lnJ(e) versus e. In the case of a retarding energy analyzer where the integral of the TED curve is measured, d can be obtained from the slope of ln[(I-Io)/Io] versus e, where Io is the maximum collected current (Swanson and Crouser, 1967). The two most important parameters characterizing an FE source are ’ and b, where b ¼ F/Vo (Vo is the extraction voltage). If Eq. (2.2) is written in terms of the emitter I(Vo) characteristics " # aðbVo Þ2 b’3=2 vðyÞ exp ; (2.4) I¼ bVo ’tðyÞ2
68
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
the slope mfn ¼
b’3=2 sðyÞ b
(2.5)
of the FN plot (i.e., ln(I/Vo2) vs. 1/Vo) can provide a value of ’3/2/b, where b is a function of emitter radius and cone angle and the emitter to anode spacing. Complicating matters further, the b factor is not constant over the emitting planes of the hemispherical emitter apex (Swanson and Crouser, 1967; Dyke et al., 1953a). Thus, if one uses an FE tube that deflects the beam over a probe aperture such that one can obtain emission from various off-axis crystal planes, a constant b factor cannot be assumed. In short, from the slope of the FN plot alone it is difficult to obtain an accurate value of b and ’. As shown by Young and Clark (1966) and implemented by others (de Jonge et al., 2004; Swanson and Crouser, 1967,), the values of both ’ and b can be obtained if the slope of the FN plot and the value of d obtained from the TED are both available. Combining Eqs. (2.3) and (2.5), the following expression for ’e is obtained: ’e ¼
3mfn dtðyÞ 2Vo sðyÞ
(2.6)
where Vo is the extractor voltage at which the TED was obtained and s(y) is the derivative dv(y)/d(1/Vo). The value of ’ can be inserted in Eq. (2.5) to obtain the corresponding value of b.
3.2. Analytical versus Numerical Results The fundamental equation for current density can be expressed in terms of the normal energy W (Murphy and Good, 1956) ð W Ef 4peme kT 1 dW; (2.7) DðWÞ ln 1 þ exp JðF; TÞ ¼ kT h3 0 where D(W) and W are the tunneling coefficient and the electron energy normal to the surface, respectively. Similarly, the current density of electrons with total energy E is ð 4peme f ðEÞ E DðWÞdW; (2.8) JðEÞ ¼ h3 0 where f(E) is the Fermi–Dirac function. Eqs. (2.7) and (2.8) can be integrated numerically to provide values for the current density J(N) and FWHM(N). D(W) is found by numerically solving the one-dimensional Schro¨dinger equation for the following potential barrier:
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
69
8 7
V(z)(eV)
6 5
j
YA
YC
YB
Ef
4 3 2 zc
1 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
z (nm)
FIGURE 2 Diagram of the surface potential defined by the Eq. (9) image potential model. Incoming, reflected, and transmitted wave functions cA, cB, and cC, respectively, are indicated.
0 for z < zc VðzÞ ¼ Ef þ ’ eFz e2 =16pe0 z
for z > zc
(2.9)
as depicted in Figure 2. The image potential term in Eq. (2.9) is artificially set at 0 at zc. The wave function for the starting condition for the numerical integration for large positive z to the right of the potential barrier is given by c ¼ Cexp(ikz). For negative z to the left of the potential barrier, the wave function separates into an incident and reflected component as c ¼ Aexp(ikz) þ Bexp(–ikz). The tunneling coefficient follows as 2 C (2.10) DðWÞ ¼ A The complete analytical expression for the current density JTF for an emitter that includes the effect of a finite temperature can be obtained by integrating Eq. (2.1) as follows: ð1 pp ; (2.11) JðeÞde ¼ JFN JTFE ¼ sinðppÞ 0 where the dimensionless parameter p < 0.7. To obtain the analytical expressions J(e) and JTFE, a variety of approximations must be made that include the well-known Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) approximation in the derivation of JFN. The degree to which these approximations affect the validity of Eqs. (2.1) and (2.7) was discussed previously (Bahm,
70
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
Schwind, and Swanson, 2008). They compared the above analytical expressions (A) with an accurate numerical (N) calculation of JTFE J (A) and J(e) throughout the CFE, TFE, and SE regimes. Figures 3 and 4 show the ratios of the FWHM(A)/FWHM(N) and J(A)/J(N) obtained from the numerical and analytical (i.e., Eqs. (2.1) and (2.11)) as a function of T for various work function and J(N) values in the low-temperature (i.e., p < 0.7) range. As observed earlier (Bahm, Schwind, and Swanson, 2008), the analytical and numerically calculated values for the FWHM agree within a few percent over the range of ’, J, and T normally encountered for the low-temperature CFE and the higher-temperature TFE emission regimes. In contrast, J(A)/J(N) in Figure 3 shows a significant variation (up to 30%) from unity over the temperature and work function range that Eq. (2.11) is expected to be valid. For the numerical calculations a value of Ef ¼12 eV was used for tungsten (Mattheiss, 1965). Interestingly, the Eq. (2.11) analytical expression for J(A) does not depend on Ef, whereas J(N) exhibits a strong dependence on Ef as shown in Figure 5. In contrast, the FWHM(N) values are relatively independent of over the range Ef ¼ 4 to 18 eV. Since the discrepancy occurs only between J(N) and J(A), we suspect the problem lies with the approximations associated with D(W) in formulating the analytical expression for JFN. Further studies are necessary to determine the exact cause of the discrepancy between J(N) and J(A). 1.50 j = 4.0 eV j = 4.5 eV j = 5.0 eV
1.45 1.40 1.35
J(A)/J(N)
Ratios
1.30 1.25 1.20 1.15 1.10
FWHM(A)/FWHM(N)
1.05 1.00 0.95 0.90 0
200
400
600 T (K)
800
1000
1200
FIGURE 3 Variation of analytical and numerically calculated current density and FWHM ratios versus T for J(N) ¼ 1 108 A/m2 and the indicated work function values.
71
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
1.30 1.25 1.20
J(A)/J(N)
1.15
Ratio
1.10 1.05 1.00 FWHM(A)/FWHM(N) 0.95
J(N) = 107A/m2 J(N) = 108A/m2 J(N) = 109A/m2
0.90 0.85 0.80 0
200
400
600 T (K)
800
1000
1200
FIGURE 4 Variation of analytical and numerically calculated current density and FWHM ratios versus T for ’ ¼ 4.5 eV and the indicated J(N) values.
1.5 J(A)/J(N) FWHM(A)/FWHM(N)
1.4 1.3
Ratio
1.2 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0
2
4
6
8
10 Ef (eV)
12
14
16
18
20
FIGURE 5 Variation of analytical and numerically calculated current density and FWHM ratios versus Ef for ’ ¼ 4.5 eV and F ¼ 4.5 109 V/m. J(A) and FWHM values are 8.12 108 A/m2 and 0.238 eV, respectively, and independent of Ef.
72
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
The calculated values of FWHM(N) in Figures 6 and 7 versus T for various values of ’ and J(N) show that the sensitivity of FWHM(N) to J(N) and ’ diminishes with increasing T. The results given in Table 2 for a CFE source operating at T ¼ 300 K show that the dependence of the FWHM(N) values on both work function and current density is minimal. Decreasing values of both ’ and/or J(N) result in a slightly lower value for the FWHM(N).
3.3. Measured Values of the FWHM for the Tungsten Cold-Field Electron Other than the fact that, according to Table 1, the (310) plane of clean tungsten possesses the lowest work function, it is not clear why historically it has persisted as the most favored orientation for most commercial applications. From the standpoint of crystallographic symmetry and the amplitude of intrinsic current fluctuations at low temperatures (to be discussed in section 6.1), a case can be made that the (111) plane might be the preferred plane for electron optical applications. The slight decrease in FWHM(N) with decreasing ’ at a fixed value of J(N), according to Table 2, will provide a minimal advantage for a low ’ CFE source. In addition, the vacuum environment encountered in most commercial 0.50 4.00 eV 4.50 eV 5.00 eV
0.45
FWHM(N) (eV)
0.40 0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
T (K)
FIGURE 6 Variation of the FWHM(N) versus T for the indicated values of work function for J(N) ¼ 1 108 A/m2.
73
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
0.50 J(N) = 107 A/m2 J(N) = 108 A/m2 J(N) = 109 A/m2
0.45
FWHM (N) (eV)
0.40 0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0
FIGURE 7
200
400
600 T (K)
800
1000
1200
Variation of the FWHM(N) versus T for the indicated values of J(N) for ’ ¼ 4.50 eV.
TABLE 2 Calculated values of the FWHM(N) and F for the indicate values of J and w at T ¼ 300 K J (A/m2)
’ (eV)
F(V/nm)
FWHM(N) (eV)
1 10 1 108 1 108 1 107 1 108 1 109
4.0 4.5 5.0 4.5 4.5 4.5
3.368 4.004 4.680 3.532 4.004 4.616
0.207 0.222 0.239 0.206 0.222 0.244
8
applications is such that the CFE source very quickly receives an adsorbed layer of residual gases that alters the work function from the atomically clean surface. Measurement of the energy distribution for the W(310) and W(111) planes of the CFE source has little value for electron optical analysis without the simultaneous measurement of the cathode current density or the more easily measured current per solid angle, referred to as the angular current density (I0 ). As shown by Wiesner and Everhart (1974), for an FE source with apex radius r the following relationship between I0 and J(N) exists:
74
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
I 0 ¼ JðNÞ
r 2
(2.12)
m
where the angular magnification of the emitted electron m ¼ ao/y is defined as the ratio of the initial launch angle y to the final angle ao with respect to the emitter axis. Implicit in Eq. (2.12) is the assumption that J and I0 are uniform over the solid angle defined by the beam acceptance aperture, as is usually the case for electron optical applications and TED measurements. Using a sphere-on-orthogonal-cone structure (Dyke et al., 1953a) to model the emitter shape and equipotential surfaces between the cathode and anode, Wiesner and Everhart (1973) calculated a variety of emitter parameters as a function of emitter shape. They found that 0.39 <m < 0.64 depending on details of the emitter shape. For source/extractor electrode geometries other than the sphere-on-orthogonal-cone shape modeled by Wiesner and Everhart (1973), trajectory ray-tracing simulation is required to compute the exact value of m. Results of the limited TED measurements will be reviewed where the experimental (FWHM(E)) and I0 values are both available or can be determined from the data. Table 3 summarizes measurements of the key emitter parameters obtained from TED data and FN plots measurement by Swanson and Crouser (1967) for the low work function (111) and (310) planes of clean tungsten. For these relatively low values of I0 , the FWHM (E) values for the (111) and (310) planes are 0.25 and 0.23 eV, respectively, and are in close agreement with the numerically calculated values. However, it will be shown that for larger values of I0 , typically of interest for meaningful electron optical applications, the FWHM(E) values are substantially larger than the calculated values. Experimental values of the TED for an FE source are usually measured using a differential (Braun et al., 1978) or a retarding potential analyzer (Simpson, 1961). The former analyzer type measures the differential curve of Eq. (1), whereas the latter measures the integral of Eq. (1) with e ¼ VR ’c ;
TABLE 3
Plane
W(111) W(310)
(2.13)
Summary of emission parameters for W(111) and W(310) planes at T ¼ 77 K * V b J(N) I0 (A/sr) ’ (eV) (volts) d (eV) (m–1) (A/m2)
0.61 0.54
4.47 4.34
1306 0.154 1230 0.149
2.68 1.02x107 2.70 8.57x106
FWHM(E) (eV)
FWHM (N) (eV)
0.25 0.23
0.21 0.21
* From Swanson and Crouser (1967). The I0 values were derived from the given data. FWHM(E) and FWHM (N) are the experimental and calculated values, respectively.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
75
where VR is the emitter to collector electrode bias potential and ’c is the effective work function of the collector electrode. An important advantage of the integral analyzer is the relative ease with which the TED and I0 can be simultaneously measured. Figure 8 shows a typical output from an integral analyzer where the experimental curve has been fit to the theoretical curve with d, T, and ’c as the adjustable parameters. The Eq. (1) theoretical curve is also shown in Figure 8 using the indicated values for the adjustable parameters. From the value for d and the slope mFN of the FN plot, the work function ’ and b factor can be determined from Eqs. (5) and (6) for the particular crystal plane seen by the opening angle of the analyzer. Fitting the theoretical expression Eq. (1) to the experimental data in Figure 8 requires a temperature of 530 K, even though the measurement was carried out at 300 K. This anomaly is due to the well-known and well-studied effect (Boersch, 1954) caused by statistical mutual Coulomb interactions between electrons in the high current density region near the cathode surface and, to a lesser extent, by the finite resolution of the analyzer. This energy-broadening effect, which has been studied extensively both experimentally (Bell and Swanson, 1979;
1.0
I' = 10mA/sr T = 530 K d = 0.19 eV jc = 3.47 eV
Normalized I or J(E)
0.8
0.6 Differential curve theory Integral curve theory
0.4
Integral curve experimental
0.2
0.0 3.0
3.2
3.4
3.6
3.8 4.0 Voltage
4.2
4.4
4.6
4.8
FIGURE 8 The normalized, experimental retarding potential current obtained from a W<111>-oriented emitter at 300 K and I0 ¼ 10 A/sr is shown along with the best fit to the calculated curve using T, d, and ’c as adjustable parameters. The differential curve calculated from the experimentally derived ’ and F is also shown.
76
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
0.8 CFE b (a) W<310> (b) W<310> (c) W<310> (d) W<111>
0.7
FWHM (eV)
0.6
(mm−1) 1.30 1.90 1.02 1.14
0.5
(a) (b) (c)
0.4 (d)
0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0
20
40
60
80 100 120 140 Angular intensity (mA/sr)
160
180
200
FIGURE 9 The experimental FWHM(E) values for the TED versus I0 obtained from the indicated planes of the tungsten CFE source at 300 K. Values for ’ and b are given in Table 4.
Fransen et al., 1998; Kim et al., 1997; Troyon, 1988) and theoretically ( Jansen, 1990), will be discussed as it relates to W<310> and W<111> CFE sources. Figure 9 compares experimental data obtained in this laboratory for clean W<310> and W<111> oriented emitters with similar data obtained by Troyon (1988). Table 4 provides the respective values of ’, b, r, and m obtained from the TED and I(V) data. The m values, obtained from Eq. (12) using measure r from Figure 10, are in the range expected from trajectory simulations (Wiesner and Everhart, 1973) for a spherical apex emitter. As observed in previous investigations (Schwind, Magera, and Swanson, 2006; Swanson and Schwind, 2009), the FWHM(E) values increase beyond the respective intrinsic (i.e., calculated) values with increasing I0 . Although the data are limited, the contribution of the energy broadening to the FWHM(E) values within Troyon’s and our datasets appears to diminish with increasing b. Because of differing source/anode geometries, comparison of the influence of b on the FWHM values between the two data sets is not possible. Nevertheless, the variation of the energy broadening with b within the two datasets is counter to that observed for the larger-radius SE emitter (Schwind, Magera, and Swanson, 2006). Figure 11 provides a more detailed analysis of the energy broadening for the W<310> and W<111> CFE sources at 300 K where a convolution program (Bronsgeest et al., 2007) has been used to extract the energy-
77
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
(a)
Acc.V Magn 500 nm 10.0 kV 50 000 x 11/29/05 dE W310
(b)
det Landing E TLD 5.00 keV
mag 70 000 x
HFW 2.15 mm
WD 3.6 mm
500 nm FEI NanoSEM 630
FIGURE 10 SEM photos of the W<310> (a) and W<111> (b) CFE sources used to obtain the data for Figures 8–10.
TABLE 4 Emission characteristics obtained from the indicated CFE sources at T¼300 K* Plane
r (nm) {
W(310) W(310){ W(310) W(111)
— — 160 120
’e (eV)
b (m–1)
4.40 4.40 4.32 4.40
1.30 1.90 1.02 1.14
* Values of the apex radius r were determined from the Figure 11 SEM photos. { Obtained from Troyon (1988) where the value of ’ was derived from the given I(V) data.
m
— — 0.66 0.62
78
(a)
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
0.35 (a) Exp. (b) Intrinsic (c) Boersch
0.30
(a)
FWHM (eV)
0.25
(b)
0.20 0.15
(c)
0.10 0.05 0.00 0 (b)
2
4
6 8 10 Angular intensity (mA/sr)
12
14
16
0.6 (a) Exp. (b) Boersch (c) Intrinsic
0.5
(a)
FWHM (eV)
0.4
0.3
(b) (c)
0.2
0.1
0.0 0
20
40
60 80 Angular intensity (mA/sr)
100
120
140
FIGURE 11 Relative contributions of the experimental, intrinsic, and Boersch FWHM values versus I0 for the W<111> (a) and W<310> (b) CFE sources at 300 K.
broadening Boersch effect from the experimental TED. The Boersch contribution is described by a two-parameter bell-shaped distribution. One of the fitting parameters is the FWHM(B) of the bell-shaped distribution. By fitting the convolution of the intrinsic energy distribution and the bell-
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
79
shaped distribution with its two fitting parameters to the experimental TED, the Boersch contribution could be adequately determined. The results are presented in Figure 10 in terms of the experimental FWHM(E), intrinsic FWHM(N) (i.e., calculated), and the Boersch FWHM(B) contributions. A comparison between the W<111> and W<310> results shows that the energy broadening as determined by the FWHM(B) values not only increases with I0 , but is substantially larger for the W(310) source, which also possesses the smaller value of b. It has been shown for SE sources thatFWHMðBÞ / b j I 0n (Schwind, Magera, and Swanson, 2006; Swanson and Schwind, 2009). However, the limited data reported here for the W<310> and W<111> CFE sources suggest that FWHMðBÞ / bj I 0n . Since all formulations for the variation of b with the cathode/anode geometry give b / 1=rp (Swanson and Schwind, 2009), we conclude from Troyon’s (1988) results (given in Figure 9) and the more recent results for the W<310> and W<111> CFE sources (given in Figure 10) that the Boersch effect diminishes with decreasing source apex radius. Most theoretical and empirical formulations of the energy broadening for high current density FE sources (Knauer, 1981) or for beam crossovers ( Jansen, 1990) are of the form FWHMðBÞ /
I 0l : rk Vos
(2.14)
It therefore appears that the exponent k in Eq. (2.14) may be negative for the CFE source. Further experimental and theoretical investigation will be required to complete our understanding of the role of the source radius in the Boersch effect for the CFE source.
4. SOURCE OPTICS In addition to knowledge of the source energy spread and beam angular intensity as described previously, it is also important to simultaneously know the source reduced brightness Br to fully describe the source optical properties. Unfortunately, Br is not easily measured under the same experimental conditions that the FWHM(E) and I0 values are obtained. A practical definition of Br requires a proper definition of the virtual source size dv as seen from the extractor electrode at voltage Vo. If I is uniform over the acceptance aperture subtending the source, Br is defined by the following relationship: Br ¼
4I 0 pd2v Vo
(2.15)
Bronsgeest et al. (2008) pointed out that a proper definition of dv must take into account the current density distribution in the source image
80
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
plane. A useful definition for dv that avoids assumptions regarding the intensity profile is the diameter containing a certain fraction FC of the current. For FC ¼ 0.5, various intensity profiles yield a common value for dv measured by scanning the beam across the knife edge and defining dv by the 25% to 75% edge resolution. In addition, the total probe size obtained by the addition of various aberrations, using the FC ¼ 0.5 definition as described by Barth and Kruit (1996), is free of assumptions regarding the spatial distributions of the various aberrations. The value of dv obtained for FC ¼ 0.5 is denoted as (Bronsgeest et al., 2008) r ET 1=2 ; (2.16) dv 50 ¼ 1:67 m Vo where ET is the average initial transverse energy of the emitted electrons. For the CFE emission regime, ET ¼ d; thus, by combining Eqs. (2.15) and (2.16) the following expression for the practical brightness Br50 is obtained: I 0 m 2 Br 50 ¼ 1:44 : (2.17) d r Eliminating m/r from Eq. (2.17) by use of Eq. (2.12) leads to Br 50 ¼ 1:44
JðNÞ ¼ 1:44Br ; pd
(2.18)
where Br ¼ J(N)/pd is the familiar expression for the differential or axial brightness (Worster, 1969). As observed previously (Bronsgeest et al., 2008), the practical source brightness exceeds the axial brightness by 44%. For SEM and TEM applications, one is interested in a FE source that simultaneously provides a large value of Br50 and a small value of FWHM(E). If ’ and bVo are known, Br50 can be calculated using Eq. (2.18). The latter is plotted versus FWHM(E) in Figure 12 for the W<310> and W<111> sources. Since the W<111> curve lies to the left in Figure 12, it is favored over the W<310> source based on the above criteria. The relatively large calculated values of Br50 in Figure 12 are primarily due to the small values of dv50, or, equivalently, the large values of J(N) for these CFE sources. Values of dv50 obtained from Eq. (2.16) and J (N) (obtained knowing b, Vo, and ’) are given in Tables 5 and 6. The average dv50 values are 2.90 and 2.29 nm for the W<310> and W<111> sources, respectively. The latter values of dv50 are an order of magnitude smaller than the typical dv50 values for the SE source (Swanson and Schwind, 2009). The mutual Coulomb interactions that cause the energy broadening also cause a random, non-focusable modification of the electron trajectories. This leads to a radial broadening dblur of the virtual source size and
81
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
5.E + 09 5.E + 09 4.E + 09
Br (A/m2srV)
4.E + 09
CFE
b (mm−1)
(a) W<111> (b) W<310>
1.14 1.01
(b)
3.E + 09 3.E + 09 2.E + 09 2.E + 09 (a) 1.E + 09 5.E + 08 0.E + 00 0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35 FWHM (eV)
0.40
0.45
0.50
FIGURE 12 Graph shows the source reduced brightness Br versus the corresponding FWHM(E) values for the two CFE sources. TABLE 5
Values of various emission parameters for the W<310> CFE at 300 K*
I0 (A/sr)
7.5 19 44 62 116
F (V/nm)
J(N) (A/m2)
d (eV)
dv50 (nm)
FWHM(E) (eV)
FWHM(B) (eV)
3.840 4.040 4.242 4.340 4.545
1.38 108 3.22 108 6.93 108 9.94 108 19.5 108
0.190 0.201 0.211 0.216 0.227
2.76 2.90 2.98 2.98 2.89
0.357 0.380 0.427 0.412 0.507
0.199 0.247 0.271 0.236 0.369
* The relevant values of ’, b, r, and m are given in Table 4.
TABLE 6
Values of various emission parameters for the W<111> CFE at 300 K*
I0 (A/sr)
2 5 10 15
F (V/nm)
J(N) (A/m2)
d (eV)
dv50 (nm)
FWHM(E) (eV)
FWHM(B) (eV)
3.735 3.932 4.104 4.206
5.42 107 1.32 108 2.71 108 4.02 108
0.165 0.174 0181 0.186
2.78 2.31 2.28 2.29
0.237 0.273 0.301 0.319
0.039 0.062 0.080 0.093
* The relevant values of ’, b, r, and m are given in Table 4.
82
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
a concomitant decrease in Br50. Although dblur occurring at a beam crossover in an optical column has been extensively studied (Jansen, 1990; Kruit and Jansen 2009), the nonhomogeneous field accelerating the particles in the region near the emitter surface of the FE source renders it impossible to treat the radial broadening analytically. Nevertheless, it is expected that the calculated values of Br50 above 1 109 A/m2srV in Figure 12 will be substantially lowered due to the radial broadening that increases dv50 beyond the value calculated via Eq. (2.16).
5. COLUMN OPTICS USING THE COLD-FIELD ELECTRON SOURCE In a focusing column the conservation of the source brightness Br down to the target leads to the following useful relations between the probe current Ip, and the convergence half angle ai, the virtual source size dp (dp ¼ Mdv50) and image (Vi), and the object (Vo) side voltages: Ip ¼
p2 Vi Vi Br ðai dp Þ2 ¼ pI 0 ðMai Þ2 4 Vo
(2.19)
where Br is defined by (E. 15). The total beam size in the image plane is usually limited by a combination of lens chromatic aberration dc, spherical aberration ds, diffraction dl, coulomb interactions dblur, and virtual source size dv. The contributions of these terms to the total beam size in the image plane have been given by Barth and Kruit (1996) in terms of the beam size dt50 that contains 50% of the beam current as follows: dl ¼
663:6
ðnmÞ
(2.20)
dV ai ðnmÞ Vi
(2.21)
1=2
Vi ai
dc ¼ 600Cc
ds ¼ 1:8x104 Cs a3i ðnmÞ dt 50 ¼
h
d4l
þ
1:3=4 d4s
þ M dv 50 þ 2
2
1:3=2 i2=1:3 M2 d2blur
(2.22) 1=2 þ
d2c
;
(2.23)
where M is the overall column magnification. The image-side voltage Vi is in volts, the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients (Cs and Cc, respectively) are in millimeters, and dV is the full width containing 50% of the particles (FW50) value in electron volts of the energy spread. The above formulation of the aberration contributions gives results that are comparable to the more rigorous wave optical approach.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
83
The total chromatic Cct and spherical Cst aberration coefficients of a two-lens optical system are given by (Orloff, 1983) 3=2 Vi (2.24) Cct ¼ Cci þ Cco M2 V0 3=2 Vi ; (2.25) Cst ¼ Csi þ Cso M4 V0 where Cci and Csi are the image-side aberration coefficients of the objective lens and Cco and Cso are the object-side aberration coefficients of the gun lens. Sources with a large value of dv50 (e.g., an SE source with dv50 30 to 60 nm) require the column to be operated in a strongly demagnified mode. This, combined with a high Vo (e.g., 5 kV), results in such a small gun lens aberration contribution that it can typically be ignored or at most considered a minor contribution to the total column aberrations. To illustrate the latter and other contrasts between the CFE and SE sources, a comparison between the commonly used W<100>ZrO SE and the W<111> CFE sources will be made using aberration coefficients of a typical focusing column. Tables 7 and 8 give source parameters and the focusing column aberration coefficients used to calculate dt50 versus Ip for a high (30-kV) and low (1-kV) beam voltage. A computer program was used to calculate the optimum values of M for a range of ai values to minimize dt at each value of ai using Eqs. (2.19) to (2.25). The results of the latter calculations are TABLE 7
Working distance and column aberrations used for the figure 13 analysis
Cso (mm)
20
TABLE 8
0
Cso (mm)
Cci (mm)
Csi (mm)
Working Distance (mm)
75
0.58
0.49
1.0
Source parameters used for the figure 13 analysis
I (A/sr) Vo (V) r (nm) m FW50 (eV) dv50 (nm) ’ (eV) T ( K)
W(111)
W(100)ZrO
15 3693 120 0.62 0.214 2.29 4.40 300
200 4032 370 0.21 0.37 16.8 2.92 1800
84
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
(a) 100 (b) (a) WZrO SE (b) W(111) CFE
dt50 (nm)
(a)
10
(a) (b) 1 0.01
0.1
1
10
100
1000
10,000
100,000 1000,000
Ip (pA)
(b) 100
(b) (a) WZrO SE (b) W(111) CFE
(a)
dt50 (nm)
10
1
(a)
(b)
0 0.01
0.1
1
10
100 Ip (pA)
1000
10,000
100,000 1000,000
FIGURE 13 Plots of the beam size dt50 versus beam current Ip for a typical SEM column for a beam voltage of 1 kV (a) and 30 kV (b). The W<111> CFE source is compared with a W(100)ZrO SE source. Source and column parameters are given in Tables 7 and 8. The dashed lines show the effect of eliminating the gun lens aberrations.
given in Figure 13. Not surprisingly, for Ip < 1000 pA the CFE source provides a lower value of dt than the SE source, although less so for the 30-kV beam voltage. The individual contributions to dt are detailed in
85
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
(a)
100
10
(a) Total (b) Diffraction (c) Chromatic (d) Spherical (e) Virtual source
(c)
d (nm)
(a) 1 (d) (b) 0.1 (e)
0.01 0.1
1
10
100
1000
10,000
1000
10,000
100,000
Ip (nA) (b)
100
d (nm)
10
(a) Total (b) Diffraction (c) Spherical (d) Chromatic (e) Virtual source
1 (a) (b) (c) 0.1
(e) (d)
0.01 0.1
1
10
100
100,000
Ip (nA)
FIGURE 14 Aberration contributions for the Figure 13 (a) dt versus Ip results for a beam voltage of 1 kV (a) and 30 kV (b).
Figure 14 for the CFE source. For Ip < 1000 pA diffraction, chromatic and spherical aberrations are the primary contributors to dt at Vi ¼ 1 kV, whereas at Vi ¼ 30 kV the primary contributions come from the spherical and
86
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
diffraction terms. At Ip ¼ 1000 pA, all aberrations contribute more or less equally. For different values of Cst and Cct, the relative contributions will be altered. The improvement in performance for Ip < 1000 pA using the CFE source comes with the requirement for a larger value of M (Figure 15), which in turn leads to a larger contribution from the gun lens (see dashed curves in Figure 13) to the overall aberration load in accordance with Eqs. (2.24) and (2.25). As noted previously (Kruit, Bezuijen, and Barth, 2006), this is a consequence for any CFE that achieves a large value of Br by virtue of a small value of dv as opposed to a large value of I0 (see Eq. (2.15)), which is the case for the SE source. The larger required value of M for the CFE source implies more mechanical stability and magnetic shielding requirements for the column. Not withstanding beam current stability issues, the CFE source is a superior source for applications requiring a high resolution or a highly coherent focused beam.
6. CURRENT STABILITY For electron optical applications, current stability considerations are confined to a relatively small fraction of the total current contained in a 1 to 10 mr semi-angle centered on the optical axis of the source. Since the basic 10 (a) W(111) CFE (b) WZrO SE
M
1
0.1
0.01
(a) (b)
0.001 0.1
1
10
100 Ip (pA)
1000
10,000
100,000
FIGURE 15 Graph shows the optimum column magnification M corresponding to the Figure 13 (a) dt versus Ip results.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
87
mechanisms associated with long current drift and short-term current fluctuations differ, it is instructive to consider the current stability issues in terms of high-frequency fluctuations about a mean current and longterm current drift usually in the direction of reduced current. According to the FN Eq. (2.2), current fluctuations and drift are due to fluctuations or drift in ’ and/or b. Ignoring the pre-exponential term in Eq. (2.2), it can be shown that small current fluctuations dI are given by dI b’3=2 3b’1=2 d’; ¼ 2 dF ¼ F 2F I
(2.26)
where b ¼ 6.83 109 (V/m(eV)–3/2), dF ¼ Vdb. The workfunction fluctuations d’ originate from fluctuations in the adsorbed molecules or atoms dn in the emitting area Ap subtended by the acceptance aperture as follows: d’ ¼ cdn;
(2.27)
where c ¼ 4pm/Ap, where m is the dipole particle per adsorbed particle. Thus, a change in ’ can come about only from a change in the adatom coverage n/Ap or m. To change I due to a change in b requires either a microscopic geometric change (atomic size within Ap) or a macroscopic geometric change in the emitter shape.
6.1. High-Frequency Current Fluctuations The following mechanisms can contribute to varying degrees to fluctuations in I: 1. With a specific pressure of residual gases, fluctuations in n can be caused by adsorption/desorption processes. 2. Fluctuations in m can occur due to thermal induced transitions between two bonding states of adsorbed molecule (Kleint, 1971). 3. Fluctuations in n will occur for mobile adsorbed molecules or atoms due to surface diffusion in and out of Ap (Gomer, 1973). It has been shown that mechanism 3 in the list above can occur even for an atomically clean surface due to mobile, self-adsorbed atoms on a particular crystal plane (Swanson, 1978). These intrinsic current fluctuations vary significantly with crystal plane as shown in Table 1 where the value of dI/I values are approximately inversely proportional to the surface atom density of the respective crystal plane. As an illustration of the highly anisotropic nature of this current fluctuation mechanism, dI/I (310)/dI/I(100) ¼ 7.5 at 500 K (see Table 1) and increases to 67 at 900 K (Swanson, 1978). The temperature threshold where these fluctuations exceed the statistical shot-noise level is as low as 300 K for the (310)
88
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
plane for a frequency bandwidth of 10 kHz (Swanson, 1978). Interestingly, the Table 1 summary of current fluctuations suggests a lower value for the W(111) versus the W(310) plane. To illustrate the extreme sensitivity of a CFE source to a small change in ad atomdensity (n/Ap); Ap ¼ 19.6 nm2 for a typical optical column application with ao ¼ 10 mr, r ¼ 150 nm and m ¼ 0.6. For the W(111) plane, the latter value of Ap contains 114 substrate atoms; thus, one atom diffusing in or out of Ap represents a 1% change in n/Ap. Besocke and Wagner (1973, 1975) observed that the workfunction of the W(110) plane decreased monotonically with increasing concentration of adsorbed tungsten atoms on the W(110) terrace. According to Eq. (2.26), a 1% variation in ’ would cause a 28% variation in I for a CFE source with a workfunction of 4.5 eV and a typical applied field of 3.5 109 V/m. Similarly, a 1% variation in b would result in an 18% variation in I. Clearly, both ’ and b must be controlled to stabilize current from a CFE source. Investigations by Saitou (1977) and Todokoro Saitou, and Yamamoto, (1982) suggest that current fluctuation due to ion bombardment dominates when PxIt > 7 10–12 PaA, whereas current fluctuations due to mobility of adsorbed gas molecules dominates at lower values of PxIt. As shown elsewhere (Swanson and Schwind, 2009), the magnitude of the current fluctuations for an SE source increases with decreasing emitter radius and acceptance aperture solid angle. This result is not unexpected since the rms amplitude of concentration fluctuations for a mobile adsorbed layer is proportional to Ap–1/2 (Swanson, 1978). However, as the radius approaches that of a single atom, as is the case for some versions of room temperature nano tips (Kuo et al., 2006), the lifetime with respect to atomic displacement appears to be exceedingly large. All fluctuations due to atomic motion eventually cease, and only shot noise from the statistics of the emission process remains as the CFE source temperature is reduced below room temperature.
6.2. Long-Term Current Drift If adsorption of foreign molecules from the gas phase or from electronstimulated desorption (ESD) of neutrals and ions (Madey and Yates, 1971) from electrode surfaces were eliminated, then all adsorbate-induced noise and long-term drift related to workfunction change would be minimal. Such a result was approached by the Dyke group in 1960 (Martin, Trolan, and Dyke, 1960) where stable emission current with limited fluctuation and drift was obtained for more than 2500 hours for total currents in excess of 100 A. This result was obtained with a tungsten CFE source in a sealed-off tube with excellent vacuum (<10–10 Pa) and electrode surfaces that were carefully outgassed and configured so that all secondary electrons (including elastically scattered electrons) were contained. A periodic
89
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
brief thermal flash of the CFE source at 2000 K to remove contaminants and smooth the emitter surface extended the stable emission to 12,000 hours without any indication of a limit on further operation. Field emission devices using a CFE source with electrode surfaces that cannot be properly outgassed and uncontained elastically scattered electrons typically display a current fall off similar to that shown in Figure 16. The current decay after thermal cleaning of the cathode is substantial during the first hour of operation, even though a remotely positioned vacuum gauge suggests an adequate base pressure. The gas flux F is denoted by F ¼ 2:64x1024
sP ðMTÞ
1=2
ðatoms=m2 secÞ;
(2.28)
where the P, M, and s are the pressure in Pascals, the molecular weight of the gas, and the sticking coefficient, respectively. Assuming a monolayer of residual gas requires 1019 atoms/m2, for P ¼ 4.0 108 Pa and s ¼ 0.1, one obtains from Eq. (2.28) the order of 105 seconds (28 hours) to form a monolayer. Given that the current fall-off for curve (a) in the Figure 16 CFE source is much faster than would be expected based on adsorption of electronegative gases from the residual vacuum, one
1.0 It(mA) I⬘(mA/sr) Vo(volts) 15 30 3774 3 5 3367 15 30 3780
Angular intensity (normalized)
0.9 (a) (b) (c)
0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5
(c)
0.4 0.3 0.2
(b) 0.1 (a) 0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
Time (h)
FIGURE 16 Normalized angular intensity versus time for a W<111> CFE source at 300 K at the indicated starting conditions (see inset). The pressure and acceptance aperture semi-angle were 4.0 108 Pa and 0.56 mr, respectively. Curve (c) was taken with the extractor voltage off between data points.
90
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
concludes that a local pressure increase at the emitter occurs and is due to other causes. In view of the significant reduction in the rate of emission current decrease observed in curve (b) as the initial total current It is decreased from 15 to 3 A, it is clear that neutrals generated by the total emission current are largely responsible for the increase in local pressure. The latter is confirmed by comparing curves (a) and (c) of Figure 16, where the rate of decrease in emission current is reduced even more by switching the current on only briefly during the current measurement. By use of a Faraday cup with a small acceptance aperture (a1/2 ¼ 0.56 mr), only a small fraction of the total current was measured in the Figure 16 results. This resulted in an extremely small emitting area (<0.1 nm2) seen by the Faraday cup and accounts for the relatively large amplitude of the current fluctuations. These results are generally in accordance with the early observations of the Dyke group (Martin, Trolan, and Dyke, 1960), who put forth the following mechanisms governing long-term current stability for a CFE source in a high-vacuum environment: 1. In most situations the emission current decreases due to adsorption of electronegative neutral gas generated by primary electrons impinging on the anode surface and, of equal importance, from elastically reflected electrons that impinge on other nearby grounded surfaces. 2. Ions formed by the primary electron beam that impinge on a clean emitter cause an increase in current due to cathode sputtering and localized increases in the b factor. 3. Because of the configuration of the electric field near the emitter apex, only ions formed in a narrow, pencil-like cylinder centered on the emitter axis are able to impinge on the emitting area. Since a sharp maximum in the cross section for electron impact ionization occurs at a few hundred volts, most of the ions impinging on the emitting area are formed near the emitter. More recent investigations have confirmed and clarified the above mechanisms. For example, it is now known that the ESD cross section for neutral generation exceeds the cross section for ion generation by 100 for many electronegative adsorbates on metal surfaces (Madey and Yates, 1971). Further investigation of the ion trajectories formed by ESD at the anode and by electron impact ionization of neutrals in the gas phase confirms that very few ions created in this space reach the emitting area of the CFE source (Vernickel and Welter, 1970). Only those ions formed near the emitter and in a cylindrical volume of diameter approximately three times the emitter radius and centered on the emitter axis impinge on the actual emitting area. These ions impinge on the cathode with energy of 10% of the interelectrode potential (Smith, 1984).
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
91
Angular intensity (normalized)
1 (a) (b)
ϕp (i)(eV ) mp (f )/mp (i) 4.35 0.60 4.34 1.62
(a)
0.1 (b)
I
II
III
0.01 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Time (h)
FIGURE 17 Normalized angular intensity versus time for a W<310> CFE source at 300 K. Acceptance aperture semi-angle was 5.0 mr. Initial values of the work functions and ratio of the final to initial FN plot slopes are indicated in the inset.
Figures 17 and 18 show life test data taken in this laboratory in a highvacuum environment using a CFE source and a Faraday cup behind the anode with a small aperture that subtended a 5.0 mr half-angle at the emitter. Emitter radii were 150 nm, thereby limiting the probe currents in Figures 17 and 18 to an emitting area of 1.8 nm2. To demonstrate the life cycle mechanisms, It and the accompanying values of I0 in Figures 17 and 18 are larger than commonly used in practical applications. Unlike the experiment described above by the Dyke group, no provision was made to either outgas the anode or contain the elastically scattered electrons. Therefore we expect an increase in local pressure at the emitter due to ESD from nearby surfaces where the primary and scattered electrons impinged. In addition to the information provided in the captions and insets for Figures 17 and 18, Table 9 provides additional emission parameters and results for the life tests in Figures 17 and 18. Curve (a) of Figure 17 is a typical life cycle I(t) curve for a CFE source at 300 K in this environment. Following Yeong and Thong (2006), the life cycle is divided into three distinct regions as follows: after thermal cleaning is region I, where the total and probe currents decreases rapidly by one to two orders of magnitude; next is region II, where the rapid downward current drift stabilizes for a period of time depending on the base vacuum and the neutral flux at the emitter due to ESD by the primary and scattered electrons; and region III is defined by an increase in the amplitude of current fluctuations and an increasing rate in the upward current drift.
92
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
1
Angular intensity (normalized)
ϕp (i)(eV ) mfn (f )/mfn (i) T(K) (a) (b)
4.14 4.08
1.50 1.23
300 820
(b)
0.1
(a) 0.01
0
10
20
30
40 Time (h)
50
60
70
80
FIGURE 18 Normalized angular intensity versus time at two emitter temperatures for a W(310) CFE source. The acceptance aperture semi-angle was 5 mr. Initial values of the work function and ratio of the final and initial FN plot slopes are indicated in the inset.
Yeong and Thong (2006) concluded that mechanisms occurring in the various regions were as follows: Region I. Adsorption of electronegative gases leads to an increase in work function and adsorbate-induced flicker noise as describe in Section 6.1. Region II. Equilibrium coverage of adsorbed gases is reached and the emitting area undergoes occasional ion impact, leading to a mottled field emission pattern with occasional bright spots. Depending on the opening angle of the aperture, current fluctuation amplitudes of a few to several percent and occasional large current spikes are observed. The time duration of region II can be substantially extended as shown in curve (b) of Figure 17, presumably due to a reduction in ESD flux since the base pressure was similar to that of curve (a). Region III. An increase in both the current and the amplitude of current fluctuations occurs due to random formation of adsorbate/substrate nano-protrusions. If left unattended the current increase in region III rapidly reaches a critical point and triggers a catastrophic arc destroying the emitter (Dolan, Dyke, and Trolan, 1953; Dyke et al., 1953b). Additional insight into the above mechanisms can be gained by noting the ratio of the final to initial FN plot slopes mfn (f)/mfn(i) (see Eq. (2.5)) given in the inset of Figure 17. The combination of ion bombardment and
TABLE 9 Data for figures 17 and 18 long-term stability tests*
17a 17b 18a 18b
Temperature ( K)
Test Duration (hr)
P (10–8pa)
b (m–1) Initial
It (A) Initial
I’ (A/sr) Initial
Tr (sr–1) Initial
It (A) Final
300 300 300 820
15 29 21 73
3.5 3.5 2.4 2.7
0.962 1.871 0.889 0.888
100 150 100 100
2023 530 1880 1479
20.2 3.5 18.8 14.8
13.6 9.1 0.3 2.4
* The transmission Tr is defined as the ratio of I0 /It and initial and final values of It, I0 , and Tr are given.
I’ (A/sr) Tr (sr1) Final Final
479 41 28.2 157
35 4.5 94 27
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
Figure
93
94
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
formation of nano-protrusions in the emitting area occurring in region III of curve (a) leads to a decrease in ’ (due to sputtering of electronegative adsorbate molecules) and an increase in b (due to formation of nanoprotrusions). The latter would result in a decrease in mfn(f )/mfn(i) as observed. In contrast, for curve (b) of Figure 17 region III was not reached during the 30 hours of operation; therefore the dominant mechanism in play was workfunction increase due to adsorption and a limited change in b due to ion impact. In this case, we expect an increase in mfn(f )/mfn(i) as observed in the inset in Figure 17. Further evidence of surface modification during operation in region III is given in Table 9, where the final value of the transmission (Tr ¼ I0 /It) has increased for curve (a) of Figure 17 while remaining nearly unchanged for curve (b). In most cases, the equilibrium coverage y of adsorbed molecules follows an equation of state y(P,T), such that y decreases with increasing T at a constant P. This is illustrated in Figure 18, where a life test on a W<310> CFE source at 300 K is compared with a similar test at 820 K. The test for curve (a) carried out at T ¼ 300 K was terminated after 21 hours before entering the unstable region III regime. In contrast, the test for curve (b) carried out at 820 K was terminated after 73 hours and showed no sign of entering the unstable region III regime. The value of I0 in curve (b) in Figure 18 decreased to 11% of its starting value compared with 1.5% for curve (a). From the inset in Figure 18, the mfn(f )/mfn(i) ratio increased for both curves, thereby indicating that an increase in workfunction was the primary cause of the current change for both tests. At 820 K the atomic displacements due to ion sputtering of the cathode are rapidly annealed, thereby minimizing localized protrusion growth as discussed by Yeong and Thong (2006). These results show that operation at an elevated temperature can not only maintain a higher I0 , but also significantly extend the region II regime longevity. However, an increase in temperature to further reduce the gas coverage will increase surface mobility and lead to undesirable field-induced emitter shape change (Bettler and Charbonnier, 1960) and, according to Figures 6 and 7, will increase the intrinsic FWHM(N).
6.3. Cold-Field Electron End-of-Life Mechanisms In this section, a few other mechanisms are discussed that cause end of life for the CFE source when a catastrophic arc, such as may occur with extended operation in region III, does not occur. Use of the CFE source in a commercial SEM or TEM usually involves software that implements an automated thermal processing of the source at the transition between regions II and III to reduce the prospect of a catastrophic vacuum arc and to return the emitter state to the starting region I condition. This thermal processing requires heating the source to a temperature and time
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
95
sufficient to remove most adsorbed gases (e.g., CO, N2, H2, H2O) and anneal atomic displacements due to cathode sputter damage of the surface. Usually a 60-sec heating period in the range of 1600 to 1800 K is sufficient to remove most contaminants except the last traces of WOx (Bell, Swanson, and Crouser, 1969). Care must be taken not to exceed 1800 K during thermal processing to prevent massive dulling of the emitter and the concomitant decrease and increase in b and Vo, respectively. Radius growth for a single-crystal W<100> source was measured experimentally (Swanson and Schwind, 2009) and when analyzed according to a surface tension–based radius-dulling model (Barbour et al., 1960, Dyke et al., 1960) gave the following relation: Ed 5 at 4 4 ðmm4 Þ; exp (2.29) rf ri ¼ 2:18 10 kT T where ri, rf, Ed, and a ( in radians) are the initial and final emitter radii, activation energy for diffusion, and emitter cone semi-angle, respectively. The two emitter shapes shown in Figure 19 were fabricated by different electrochemical etching processes (Melmed, 1991) and are typical of the shapes used in commercial applications of both CFE and SE sources. The emitter shape in Figure 19b, formed by an AC electrochemical etching procedure, has a cone semi-angle of 7 to 10 (measured at 1-k magnification) for an apex radius of 200 to 500 nm. In contrast, the emitter shape in Figure 19a, formed by a DC electrochemical etching procedure, has a minimum cone semi-angle of 3 to 4 at the emitter apex and increases with distance from the apex. For the latter emitter shape, the minimum apex radius achievable is typically 50 to 100 nm, depending on the etching parameters. The emitter shape depicted in Figure 19a is the most commonly used shape for CFE sources because of its smaller apex radius. According to Eq. (2.29), Figure 19a with its smaller initial value of a is a more desirable shape to minimize the dulling rate. Inserting the measured value of Ed ¼ 2.78 eV (Swanson and Schwind, 2009), ri ¼ 100 nm and a ¼ 3 into Eq. (2.29), the radius increases by 20% after 19 hours at T ¼ 1800 K. Because of the exponential dependence of the dulling rate on temperature, increasing the temperature to 2000 K reduces the latter time to 3.5 hours. If one assumes a 60-sec heating period at 1800 K to restore the emitter to its original pre–region I status and a 25-hour operating interval between heating cycles, the CFE source lifetime with respect to a 20 % increase in radius would be 28,500 hours. However, a heating temperature of 2000 K would reduce the latter lifetime value to 5,250 hrs. Another more subtle end-of-life mechanism for the tungsten CFE source is severe carbon contamination depicted in Figure 20 for a W<110> source. Carbon is not easily removed by heating at 2000 K and increases over time by heating the source at elevated temperatures in
96
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
(a)
Magn 350 x
100 mm 8/7/2007 DC 128A
(b)
Acc.V Magn 10.0 kV 350 x
6/12/06
100 mm CMC ETCH 67319
FIGURE 19 Typical emitter shapes (a) formed by d.c. and (b) a.c. etching techniques (Melmed 1991).
the presence of partial pressures of almost any carbonaceous gas. As shown in Figure 20b, carbon contamination increases the high work function (100) region (see Figure 1) that eventually engulfs the (310) and (210) planes. For a W<310> oriented CFE source a perplexing symptom of severe carbon contamination would be a gradual reduction in the probe current without an accompanying reduction in total current. The only method of removing carbon contamination without seriously dulling the emitter is heating at 1200 to 1500 K in a partial pressure of oxygen. An examination of the Figure 20b emission distribution suggests that a similar result may occur for a W<111> emitter orientation.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
(a)
(310)
97
(b)
(210)
FIGURE 20 Field emission patters of a W<110> clean (a) and heavily carbon-contaminated (b) source. The location of the originally low work function (310)–(210) crystal planes are noted.
7. SUMMARY This review has touched on both positive and negative attributes of the CFE source with respect to microscopy applications. On the positive side, the following features stand out: (i) FWHM values 0.3 eV and lower were measured for I0 < 10 A/sr; however, the broadening of the FWHM due to the mutual Coulomb interactions becomes substantial for higher values of I0 . (ii) Because of the relatively small values of the virtual source for a CFE emitter, a reduced brightness in the range of 109 A/m2 srV was measured for FWHM values in the range of 0.3 to 0.4 eV. (iii) For SEM and STEM applications, the CFE source can outperform the Schottky source in terms of resolution at small beam currents—this is especially true for low voltage SEM applications, although advances in aberration correctors may mitigate this advantage. (iv) In an ultra–high-vacuum environment where ESD is minimized, there is no fundamental limit to source lifetime. On the negative side are the following: (i) Current fluctuations and longterm drift remain a practical challenge due to ESD and practical limits on achievable vacuum. (ii) The latter problem can be dealt with by a periodic high-temperature flash at 1800 K to restore the emitter to its clean and smooth surface condition; however, care must be taken to minimize emitter dulling. (iii) The small virtual source size of the CFE source leads to a higher column magnification necessary for optimum performance; this, in turn, leads to an increased contribution of the gun lens aberrations which, if not obviated, minimizes the advantage of the high source brightness. As these challenges are addressed, the future of the CFE source for high-resolution probe applications appears positive.
98
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are grateful to K. Liu and G. Magera for providing experimental data for this study and to the FEI Co. management for support. One of the authors (L.W.S.) is grateful for the early encouragement and opportunities provided by Professors R. Gomer and W.P. Dyke to study field emission phenomena.
REFERENCES Bahm, A. S., Schwind, G. A., and Swanson, L. W. (2008). Range of validity of field emission equations. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B26, 2080–2084. Barbour, J. P., Charbonnier, F. M., Dolan, W. W., Dyke, W. P., Martin, E. E., and Trolan, J. K. (1960). Determination of the surface tension and surface migration constants for tungsten. Phys. Rev. 117, 1452–1459. Barth, J. E., and Kruit, P. (1996). Addition of different contributions to the charge particle probe size. Optik 101, 101–109. Bell, A. E., Swanson, L. W., and Crouser, L. C. (1969). A field emission study of oxygen adsorption on the (110), (211), (111) and (100) planes of tungsten. (1968). Surf. Sci. 10, 254–274. Bell, A. E., and Swanson, L. W. (1979). Total energy distributions of field-emitted electrons at high current density. Phys. Rev. B19, 3353–3364. Besocke, K., and Wagner, H. (1973). Adsorption of W on W(110)–work function reduction and island formation. Phys. Rev. B8, 4597–4600. Besocke, K., and Wagner, H. (1975). Adsorption of tungsten stepped tungsten surfaces studied by work function measurement. Surf. Sci. 53, 351–358. Bettler, P. C., and Charbonnier, F. M. (1960). Activation energy for the surface migration of tungsten in the presence of a high-electric eield. Phys. Rev. 119, 85–93. Binh, V. T., and Garcia, N. (1992). On the electron and metallic ion emission from nanotips fabricated by field surface melting technique: experiments on W and Au tips. Ultramicroscopy 42–44, 80–90. Boersch, H. (1954). Experimentelle bestimmung der energieverteilung in thermisch ausgelo˝sten elektronenstrahlen. Z. Phys. 139, 115–146. Braun, E., Forbes, R. G., Pearson, J., Pelmore, J. M., and Latham, R. V. (1978). An advanced field electron emission spectrometer. J. Phys. E: Sci. Instr. 11, 222–228. Bronsgeest, M. S., Barth, J. E., Schwind, G. A., Swanson, L. W., and Kruit, P. (2007). Extracting the Boersch effect contribution from experimental energy spread measurements for Schottky electron emitters. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B25, 2049–2054. Bronsgeest, M. S., Barth, J. E., Swanson, L. W., and Kruit, P. (2008). Probe current, probe size, and the practical brightness for probe forming systems. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B26, 949–955. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). A high-resolution transmission electron microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 5861–5868. Crewe, A. V., Isaacson, M., and Johnson, D. (1969). A simple scanning electron microscope. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 40, 241–246. Dean, K. A., and Chalamala, B. R. (1999). Field emission microscopy of carbon nanotube caps. J. Appl. Phys. 85, 3832–3836. De Jonge, N., Allioux, M., Doytcheva, M., Kaiser, M., Teo, K. B. K., Lacerda, G., and Milne, W. I. (2004). Characterization of the field emission properties of individual thin carbon nanotubes. Appl. Phys. Lett. 85, 1607–1609. Dolan, W. W., Dyke, W. P., and Trolan, J. K. (1953). Field emission initiated vacuum arc. II. The resistive heated emitter. Phys. Rev. 91, 1054–1057.
A Review of the Cold-Field Electron Cathode
99
Dyke, W. P., Charbonnier, F. M., Strayer, R. L., Floyd, R. L., Barbour, J. P., and Trolan, J. K. (1960). Electrical stability and life of the heated field emission cathode. J. Appl. Phys. 31, 790–805. Dyke, W. P., and Dolan, W. W. (1956). Field emission. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 8, 89–183. Dyke, W. P., Trolan, J. K., Dolan, W. W., and Barnes, G. (1953a). The field emitter: fabrication, electron microscopy, and electric field calculations. J. Appl. Phys. 24, 570–576. Dyke, W. P., Trolan, J. K., Martin, E. E., and Barbour, J. P. (1953b). Field emission initiated vacuum arc. I. Experiments on arc initiation. Phys. Rev. 91, 1043–1054. Forbes, R. (2006). Simple good approximations for the special elliptic functions in standard Fowler-Nordheim tunneling theory for a Schottky-Nordheim barrier. Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 113122-1–113122-2. Fransen, M. H., Faber, J. S., van Rooy, T. L., Tiemeijer, P. C., and Kruit, P. (1998). Experimental, evaluation of the extended Schottky model for ZrO/W electron emission. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B16, 2063–2071. Gomer, R. (1961). Field Emission and Field Ionization. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Gomer, R. (1973). Current fluctuations from small regions of adsorbate covered field emitters: A method for determining diffusion coefficients on single crystal planes. Surf. Sci. 38, 373–393. Good, R. H. Jr., and Mu¨ller, E. W. (1956). Field emission. Handbuch der Physik 21, 176–185. Hawkes, P. W., and Kaspers, E. K. (1989). Theory of electron emission, in Principles of Electron Optics, Vol. 2: Applied Geometrical Optics. New York: Academic Press, pp. 918–933. Jansen, G. H. (1990). Coulomb interactions in particle beams. Adv. Electron Electron Phys. 22 (Suppl.), 1–535. Kim, H. S., Yu, M. L., Thompson, M. G. R., Kratschmer, E., and Chang, T. H. P. (1997). Energy distributions of Zr/O/W Schottky electron emission. J. Appl. Phys. 81, 461–465. Kleint, Ch (1971). Surface diffusion model of adsorption-induced field emission flicker noise. I. Theory. Surf. Sci. 25, 394–410. Knauer, W. (1981). Energy broadening in field emitted electron and ion beams. Optik 59, 337–356. Kruit, P., Bezuijen, M., and Barth, J. E. (2006). Source brightness and useful beam current of carbon nanotubes and other very small emitters. J. Appl. Phys 99, 024315–1–024315-7. Kruit, P., and Jansen, G. H. (2009). Space charge and statistical Coulomb effects, In ‘‘Handbook of Charged Particle Optics,’’ New York: CRC Press, J. Orloff. , ed. 2, pp. 341–389. Kuo, H. S., Hwang, I. S., Fu, T. Y., Lin, Y. C., Chang, C. C., and Tsong, T. T. (2006). Preparation of single-atom tips and their field emission behaviors. J. Surf. Sci. Nanotechnol. 4, 233–238. Mackie, W. A., and Hinrichs, C. H. (1988). Preparation of ZrCx single crystals by an arc melting floating zone technique. J. Cryst. Growth 87, 101–106. Madey, T. E., and Yates, J. T. (1971). Electron-stimulated desorption as a tool for studies of chemisorption. J. Vac. Sci. Technol 8, 525–555. Martin, E. E., Trolan, J. K., and Dyke, W. P. (1960). Stable, high density field emission cold cathode. J. Appl. Phys. 31, 782–789. Mattheiss, L. F. (1965). Fermi surface in tungsten. Phys. Rev. 139, 1893–1904. Melmed, A. J. (1991). The art and science and other aspects of making sharp tips. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B9, 601–660. Modinos, A. (1984). Field, Thermionic and Secondary Electron Emission Spectroscopy. New York: Plenum Press. Mu¨ller, E. W. (1951). Das Feldionenmikroskop. Z. Physik 131, 136–142. Mu¨ller, H. U., Volkel, B., Hoffmann, M., Woll, Ch., and Grunze, M. (1993). Emission properties of electron point sources. Ultramicroscopy 50, 57–64.
100
L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind
Murphy, E. L., and Good, R. H. Jr (1956). Thermionic emission, field emission, and the transition region. Phys. Rev. 102, 1461–1473. Qian, W., Scheinfein, M. R., and Spence, J. C. (1993). Brightness measurements of nanometersized field-emission-electron sources. J. Appl. Phys. 73, 7041–7045. Orloff, J. O. (1983). The correct expression for the chromatic disk of confusion. Optik 63, 369–372. Saitou, N. (1977). Trajectory analysis of ions formed in the field emitter inter-electrode region. Surf. Sci. 66, 346–356. Schwind, G. A., Magera, G., and Swanson, L. W. (2006). Comparison of parameters for Schottky and cold field emission sources. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B24, 2897–2901. Simpson, J. A. (1961). Design of retarding field energy analyzers. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 32, 1283–1293. Smith, R. (1984). Role of ion bombardment in field emission current instability. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 17, 1045–1053. Smoluchowski, R. (1941). Anisotropy of the electronic work function of metals. Phys. Rev. 60, 661–674. Strayer, R. W., Mackie, W. A., and Swanson, L. W. (1973). Work function measurements by the field emission retarding potential method. Surf. Sci. 34, 225–248. Swanson, L. W. (1978). Current fluctuations from various crystal faces of a clean tungsten field emitter. Surf. Sci. 70, 165–180. Swanson, L. W., and Bell, A. E. (1973). Recent advances in field electron microscopy of metals. Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 32, 193–309. Swanson, L. W., and Crouser, L. C. (1967). Total-energy distribution of field-emitted electrons and single-plane work functions for tungsten. Phys. Rev. 163, 622–641. Swanson, L. W., and Schwind, G. A. (2009). In ‘‘Review of ZrO/W Schottky Cathode, Handbook of Charged Particle Optics,’’ CRC Press: New York, (J. Orloff, ed), ed. 2, pp. 1–28. Todokoro, H., Saitou, N., and Yamamoto, S. (1982). Role of ion bombardment in field emission current instability. Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 21, 1513–1516. Troyon, M. (1988). Energy spread of different electron beams. Part II: field emission electron beams. Microsc. Spectrosc. Electron. 13, 49–64. Vernickel, H., and Welter, H. (1970). Calculation of the ion-trajectories in front of a field emission tip. Inst. for Plasma Physics, Garching bei Munchen ?IPP7/2-6/88. Wiesner, J. C., and Everhart, T.,E. (1973). Point-cathode electron sources-electron optics of the initial diode region. J. Appl. Phys. 44, 2140–2148. Wiesner, J. C., and Everhart, T. E. (1974). Point-cathode electron sources-electron optics of the initial diode region: errata and addendum. J. Appl. Phys. 45, 2797–2798. Worster, J. (1969). The brightness of electron beams. Br. J. Appl. Phys. (J. Phys. D) 2, 457–462. Yeong, K. S., and Thong, J. T. L. (2006). Life cycle of a tungsten cold field emitter. J. Appl. Phys. 99, 104903–1–104903-6. Young, R. D. (1959). Theoretical total-energy distribution of field-emitted electrons. Phys. Rev. 113, 110–114. Young, R. D., and Clark, H. E. (1966). Effect of surface patch fields on field-emission workfunction determinations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 17, 351–353.
Chapter
3 History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory Joseph S. Wall, Martha N. Simon, and James F. Hainfeld
Contents
1. Introduction 2. Instrument Design Parameters 3. Heavy Metal Cluster Labeling 4. Early User/Collaborator Projects 5. Recent Work 6. Conclusion Acknowledgments References
101 102 106 108 115 115 115 116
1. INTRODUCTION We begin with the origins of the STEM facility at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL), followed by a description of the particular design of the BNL scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM). We include a short section on the early heavy metal cluster development, followed by a history of the early user/collaborators. The STEM concept was pioneered by von Ardenne at the same time as the early development of the transmission electron microscope (TEM). However, his efforts were limited by the low brightness of available sources, lack of suitable electronics, and poor recording media. Development of the field emission electron gun by Crewe et al. (1968) solved the first problem. Commercially available electronics components provided Biology Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11073, USA Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59003-9. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
101
102
Joseph S. Wall et al.
most of the electronics needs, especially the slow-scan to TV image converters. The annular detector dark-field (DF) geometry developed by Crewe and Wall made possible imaging of unstained DNA (Crewe and Wall, 1970) and single heavy atoms (Crewe, Wall, and Langmore, 1970). Initial biological results by Wall (1971) indicated that specimen preparation and radiation damage were the main limiting factors in STEM imaging of biological specimens, but that with suitable precautions quantitative measurements could answer important questions. Even at that early stage it was possible to show that filamentous viruses were single cylinders with mass per unit length (M/L) of 1.6 kDa/A, and ‘‘split’’ structures were actually side-by-side aggregates of two particles rather than separate strands of a single virus. The early progress with the STEM at the University of Chicago attracted the attention of John Blewett and Elliott Shaw at Brookhaven, who obtained funding from the National Science Foundation, National Institutes of Health (NIH), and the Department of Energy in 1971 to develop a STEM facility along the lines of already functioning user facilities at BNL. The initial plan was to copy one of the Chicago designs and M. Isaacson was recruited to oversee the construction. When Isaacson returned to Chicago in 1973, J. Wall was recruited with the understanding that design modifications would be considered (not permitted in the original plan). By then it was clear that specimen preparation was severely limiting the quality of results. Therefore, a new design of the lens, specimen changer, and detectors was developed, emphasizing optimum conditions for the specimen.
2. INSTRUMENT DESIGN PARAMETERS The guiding principle for the BNL design was to achieve quantitative imaging at high resolution with high reliability. Therefore, considerable attention was devoted to isolation from environmental influences using a soundproof room within a room and a 6-ton isolation block on air bags (Figure 1). Detuning and vibration damping reduced the sensitivity of the gun to vibration (50 demagnification from gun to specimen made this crucial). Lifetime of the field emission tip was a primary concern for operation as a user facility. Therefore, the operating voltage was reduced from 100 keV to 40 keV and current limiting was included, resulting in typical tip life of 5–10 years with a vacuum of 10–11 torr (ion-pumped). Optics of the STEM were optimized to provide detector acceptance angles and magnification independent of specimen position in the lens gap. A projection aperture in the gun and a condenser lens below the gun permitted rapid switching to low-magnification mode with the objective off (scan size 3 mm to 5 m with a 10-nm probe) for locating areas of
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
103
FIGURE 1 BNL STEM located in soundproof room. From top: vibration monitor, switchable conditioning resistor in Lucite enclosure, FE gun chamber, condenser/beam tube/ isolation valve, objective lens chamber, detectors, floating 6-ton concrete block on air springs (under outrigger frames). Extending to the right is the specimen changer with horizontal bellows drive for specimen insertion and vertical bellows drive for selecting one specimen (of six) located in the vacuum transfer cartridge (atop central block).
interest (AOIs) to high magnification with the objective on (scan size 16 m to 32 nm with a 0.3-nm probe diameter). Double deflection through the comma-free point on the axis permits offsetting AOIs 10 m from the optical axis without significant loss of resolution. Early measurements of radiation damage at room temperature versus liquid nitrogen convinced us to operate the lens cold. This enabled use of some permanently lubricated conducting plastic components in the specimen stage without compromising the 10–9 torr vacuum, thus providing smooth motions without galling. The excitation coil for the objective was encased in copper and water cooled. The remainder of the iron yoke, pole pieces, and specimen stage were thermally isolated and operated at low
104
Joseph S. Wall et al.
temperature by circulating helium gas through a vacuum-insulated transfer line from an external liquid nitrogen bath. Detectors were made of europium-doped calcium fluoride and mounted on quartz light pipes connected to photomultipliers for quantum efficiency. The annular detectors were each split in half with each half on a separate light pipe to give uniform sensitivity over their surface. The detectors have fixed acceptance angles of 0–15 mrad (bright-field [BF]), 15–40 mrad (small-angle DF [SA]), and 40–250 mrad (large-angle DF [LA]). All detector signals are normalized by the sum (BF þ SA þ LA) to yield percent scattering, independent of beam current. This eliminates streaks in the image resulting from tip current variation. The external freeze dryer, vacuum transfer cartridges, specimen changer, and specimen stage were designed as a unit. To obtain quantitative images for mass measurement and mass mapping, specimens must be freeze-dried from volatile buffer. Air-drying crushes most specimens due to the surface tension of water while also forming a meniscus around objects, concentrating salts at their periphery. The ion-pumped freeze dryer (Figure 2a) accommodates one cartridge of six frozen grids (Figure 2b) during the overnight cycle. A retractable LN2 cold trap (Figure 2c) surrounds each grid on three sides and solidifies the vapors from the specimens. At the end of the computer-controlled cycle the cartridge is closed and sealed, moved to the STEM with the grids under vacuum, and inserted through an air lock into the specimen changer. A tweezers on a bellows drive picks up a grid from one cartridge slot (indexed by a perpendicular drive) and carries it into the specimen stage.
(a)
FIGURE 2 (Continued)
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
105
(b)
(c)
FIGURE 2 (a) Ion-pumped freeze-drying system with vacuum transfer cartridge extending toward the left in the foreground. The grey panel contains the computer interface with manual override switches. The ion pump is separated from the chamber by a pneumatically controlled valve, as is the turbo-pumped fore line (not shown). A residual gas analyzer extends to the left in the background. A laptop computer (not shown) connects to the system via a single USB cable. (b) Specimen exchange cartridge with the specimen holding rack extended. For transfer to STEM, this rack is drawn into the outside tube and sealed via one O-ring. (c) Cold trap (retractable) that is lowered to surround the specimens on three sides during freeze-drying, after which it is then withdrawn for transfer.
The only components that have changed radically over the years have been the computer systems for control, data acquisition, and display and the off-line system for analysis. Initially we had a PDP11–10 with a
106
Joseph S. Wall et al.
PEP-400 (Princeton Electronics Products) scan converter to display the slow-scan image on a TV monitor. This was replaced by a VAX750, then a 486–66 personal computer (PC), and now a 2.8-GHz PC with digital control of scan format, position, and size, as well as acquisition of detector signals. The emphasis has always been on minimum-dose techniques, such as selecting AOIs for focusing and imaging while viewing a low-magnification (low-dose) image, then recording first-scan images. An important adjunct to the instrumentation is our off-line software for mass measurement. A key feature is repeatable masking of particles to determine the background value in clean areas between particles. The current version, PCMass, is provided to all our users and supports automated particle (or filament segment) selection and manual measurement. Numerous features are included to assess quality of structure preservation relative to predefined models and reproducibility of mass measurements. All of these features have proven their importance since the official opening of the facility in October 1977. The BNL STEM remains in the forefront of biological electron microscopes in reliability, productivity, and performance.
3. HEAVY METAL CLUSTER LABELING Work using the STEM at Brookhaven began with a careful study of the first premise of the facility—namely, that single heavy atoms could serve as specific labels for biological specimens (Figure 3). It was determined
FIGURE 3 STEM.
Uranium single atoms and clumps on a 2-nm thick carbon film imaged with BNL
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
107
that these predictions were overly optimistic and that a dose of at least ˚ 2 was needed for adequate signal to noise ratio (SNR) (Wall, 1000 el/A 1978–1979), whereas dose-response measurements for mass loss and loss of resolution on freeze-dried specimens set a useful imaging limit at ˚ 2 with the specimen cooled to –140 C. Furthermore, the 10–100 el/A heavy atoms were found to move significantly from one scan to the next (Wall, Hainfeld, and Bittner, 1978). Early experiments with S. Lippard and J. Barton (then at Columbia) confirmed the low label SNR for filamentous virus fd, which had each of the 5000 coat protein subunits labeled with platinum. A promising alternative label was tetra-mercuri methane ˚ radius. This (TAMM), which had four mercury atoms within a 3-A behaved well biochemically, giving 100% labeling, but decomposed in the electron beam (Lipka, Lippard, and Wall, 1979). The student, J. Lipka, came to Brookhaven to work on a variety of promising tungsten clusters. At the same time D. Safer (University of Pennsylvania) made some undecagold derivatives based on the published methods of Bartlett and Singer. This gold cluster was shown to be sufficiently stable for easy visualization in the STEM, although a dose of ˚ 2 was required (Wall et al., 1982). The fact that the gold cluster 100 el/A had 21 functional groups on its surface made it interesting to work with. Biotinylating the surface groups and reacting with avidin produced spectacular ladder images that gave this effort momentum (Safer et al., 1982). Safer’s interest was in labeling actin filaments and this was much more difficult because it required a monofunctional gold cluster). At the dose used for single cluster visibility in the STEM, some disorder resulted. However, using a lower dose below undecagold visibility, cryo–electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and image-averaging studies of these same samples gave useful results (Milligan, Whittaker, and Safer, 1990). At the same time as the actin work, P. Frey (University of Wisconsin) developed his own method for preparing monofunctional undecagold and used it to label pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH) complex. The 96 sulfhydryl (SH) groups on the ends of the flexible arms of this multi-enzyme complex were labeled and gave impressive images, which were, however, difficult to interpret (CaJacob et al., 1985; Yang et al., 1994). At this point J. Hainfeld decided that the gold and/or the tungsten clusters were important enough for the future of STEM to justify a full-time effort. The Advisory Committee supported this decision and Hainfeld obtained separate NIH funding for his work, particularly development of larger clusters and biological projects. A number of new functionalized small gold clusters were developed and used in STEM projects, including glycoprotein labeling ((Lipka, Heinfeld, and Wall, 1983), small Fab0 -antibody-undecagold probes ((Hainfeld, 1987), tetrairidium labels (Furuya et al., 1988; Cheng et al., 1999), tungstate labels (Hainfeld et al., 1990), bacteriophage T4 baseplate labels (Watts, Hainfeld, and Coombs, 1990), transfer ribonucleic
108
Joseph S. Wall et al.
20 nm
FIGURE 4 Nanogold clusters (67 gold atoms) on a thin carbon film. Note the tendency for arrays and chains with 2.6-nm spacing.
acid (tRNA) labels (Hainfeld et al., 1991), 1.4-nm nanogold (Figure 4) (Hainfeld and Furuya, 1992), phosphorylase kinase label (Wilkinson et al., 1994; Traxler et al., 2001), PDH complex labels (Yang et al., 1994), amyloid beta protein labeling (Gregori et al., 1997), fibrinogen labeling (Mosesson et al., 1998), adenosine triphosphate–gold particles (Hainfeld et al., 1999a), metallosomes (Hainfeld et al., 1999b), Ni-NTA-gold clusters (Hainfeld et al., 1999c), gold-DNA nanostructures (Xiao et al., 2002), enzyme electron transfer (Xiao et al., 2003), nanoparticle-protein arrays (Hu et al., 2007), nanoparticle size control (Brin˜as et al., 2008). Due to the usefulness of these small functionalized gold nanoparticles as general EM labels, the company Nanoprobes, Inc. (Yaphank, NY) was started by J. Hainfeld in 1990. Hainfeld also began a long-lasting interest in medical applications of heavy atom clusters (Hainfeld, 1995).
4. EARLY USER/COLLABORATOR PROJECTS The BNL STEM facility has a long history of working with other laboratories with particular expertise in the biology/biochemistry and preparation of interesting samples. We have concentrated on maintaining the microscopy and analyses to be routinely and easily available rather than going into a field of biology. This has given us a broad range of users and collaborators. Some of the early history is recounted below. Many of these early projects have led to more recent ones, which we will try to mention. The first external biological project was a study of native and reconstituted nucleosomes by C. Woodcock (University of Massachusetts), which confirmed most of the previous EM observations (Woodcock,
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
109
Frado, and Wall, 1979, 1980). Subsequent study of dinucleosomes permitted image averaging (Woodcock and Frank, 1984). Woodcock also measured M/L of chromatin fibers to test various nucleosome packing models (Woodcock, Frado, and Rattner, 1984). J. Langmore (University of Michigan) performed similar measurements to aid in his interpretation of X-ray patterns, and V. Ramakrishnan (then at BNL) also conducted a STEM study in conjunction with his neutron scattering work (Gerchman and Ramakrishnan, 1987). None of these studies was definitive in proving one of the competing models for the packing of nucleosomes into chromatin fibers due to the lack of uniformity of the specimens. Woodcock and his collaborators continue to be productive STEM users (Francis, Kingston, and Woodcock, 2004). The first definitive STEM biological project was on fibrinogen and set the standard for future collaborations. Trinodular TEM fibrinogen images were interpreted either as aggregates or as the active species. E. Shaw, then a protein chemist at BNL and co-founder of the STEM project, was able to persuade leading advocates of opposing views to agree on a joint STEM experiment to interpret conflicting results. M. Mosesson (then at Downstate Medical Center and a proponent of the aggregate interpretation) and R. Haschemeyer (Cornell University Medical College) each provided specimens that were freeze-dried on our carbon films. The resulting images were so clear-cut that they have become a classic example of STEM specimen preparation (Mosesson et al., 1981). Trinodular ˚ long and 75 A ˚ wide with a mass of 340 kDa were objects 430 A found isolated on a perfectly clean background (Figure 5). The central domain was less intense and somewhat variable in mass but the outer nodules were reproducibly 111 17 kDa, consistent with their
FIGURE 5 Fibrinogen single molecules freeze-dried on a thin carbon film. The rod-shaped object is a tobacco mosaic virus included as an internal control for mass and structural preservation.
110
Joseph S. Wall et al.
assignment as D domains. Negative staining with uranyl acetate gave much greater internal detail. Interestingly, compact molecules of 340 kDa also were observed and a deletion was localized to the central domain. This study effectively answered any uncertainties about the trinodular nature of the fibrinogen molecule. Mosesson became a long-term collaborator and recruited a network of blood biochemists for follow-up studies on clotting factors (Mosesson et al., 1985, 1990a,b) and lipid vesicle-bound clotting complexes. Mosesson’s own work concentrated on the initial steps of fibrin polymerization after thrombin activation and he produced a controversial new model based on STEM mass mapping and gold labeling (Mosesson et al., 1993). Much of this has now been confirmed. Another early focus of the STEM was specific DNA–protein interactions. Initial results showed problems in maintaining the complex on the grid, so P. Hough and I. Mastrangelo (then at BNL) began an extensive investigation of the requirements for preserving significant structures for STEM imaging (Hough et al., 1982). Their first result to attract the attention of the biochemists was the demonstration that simian vacuolating virus 40 T (SV40 T) antigen bound at the adenovirus origin of replication as a double hexamer (Mastrangelo et al., 1985, 1989; Ryder et al., 1985). This is widely accepted now but was totally unexpected and had important implications for the mechanism of opening the DNA to start replication. Other studies elucidated the mechanism of action of long-range interactions (Hough et al., 1987; Mastrangelo et al., 1991). Nonspecific nucleic acid– protein interactions were also studied by Egelman and his collaborators (Stasiak et al., 1994; Turnquist et al., 1992; Yu and Egelman, 1992, 1993). Our first project with A. Steven (NIH) concerned the M/L of intermediate filaments (IF), and the demonstration that reconstituted filaments had many of the same characteristics as native (Steven et al., 1982, 1983a,b). However, controversy arose from the observation that these filaments were 15 nm wide instead of the accepted 10-nm diameter. Steven and Steinert were able to rationalize this by observing that a portion of the IF protein was very similar in all types of filament, while the remainder was quite variable. This led to the now-accepted concept that the IF structure is somewhat like myosin with the tails wound together in a tight filament, whereas the head groups protrude from the surface (Steinert, Steven, and Roop, 1985; Steven et al., 1985). The structures observed in thin sections were the central shaft but the less-dense head groups were not visible. To test this, radial mass density profiling was developed (Steven et al., 1984), which found wide application in our studies of T4 tail tubes, bacterial flagella, pili, and filamentous viruses. Work on coated vesicles extended the radial density method to spherical particles and viruses. Many of the same techniques have been applied to study of Alzheimer’s filaments (Ksiezak-Reding and Wall, 1994; Ksiezak-Reding et al., 1996), filamentous
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
111
hemagglutinin (Makhov et al., 1994), and flagellar microtubules (Nojima, Linck, and Egelman, 1995). Consider the case of T4 tail fibers shown in Figure 6. The lower image is an average of freeze-dried whole tail fibers. The first observation is that the fibers are trimers, based on total mass, rather than dimers as stated in textbooks. A. Steven has shown that one can divide the fiber into a series of 17 nodular domains and connecting segments and correlate the mass of each nodule with the predicted folding pattern of the protein sequence. The M/L of the connecting segments is only compatible with a triplestranded b sheet, a structure which has been predicted but never observed. Based on the STEM studies, this was proposed to be the first example. X-ray studies have now confirmed that prediction. The upper image shows an average of STEM images of tail fibers embedded in methylamine vanadate. Note the improved spatial resolution lack of phase-contrast fringes in the LA image. Alasdair Steven and his laboratory have continued as major STEM users. In the recent past, they have done some very elegant analyses of prion protein filaments (Sen et al., 2007). One of the key achievements of the STEM program was elucidation of the dynein structure (Figure 7) in collaboration with K. Johnson (then at Penn State). This motor protein for microtubules consists of three head groups connected by thin threads to a base plate and resembles a ‘‘bouquet of flowers’’ (Johnson and Wall, 1983). This success attracted a number of Johnson’s colleagues to replicate this work on their systems (Hastie et al., 1988; Marchese-Ragona and Wall, 1995; Marchese-Ragona, Wall, and Johnon, 1988; Witman et al.. 1983) which have all been shown to be variations on the same theme.
FIGURE 6 T4 viral tail fibers. The lower image is an average of freeze-dried whole tail fibers used for mass measurement, demonstrating that the fibers are trimers. A. Steven has shown that the fiber can be divided into a series of 17 nodular domains and connecting segments, correlating the mass of each nodule with the predicted folding pattern of the protein sequence. The upper image shows similar fibers embedded in methylamine vanadate (a negative stain), giving improved spatial resolution but not compatible with accurate mass measurement.
112
Joseph S. Wall et al.
FIGURE 7 Single molecules of the microtubule motor complex dynein used to determine that the mass is 1.87 MDa and to provide a model for the structure.
The ribosome projects of M. Boublik were among the most comprehensive STEM studies. The goal was to image the reassembly process for both 30S and 50S subunits, then repeat with labeled subunits. The early retirement and untimely death of Boublik prevented us from completing the labeling work. However, several important labeling results were obtained. We also examined 16S and 23S RNA from Escherichia coli ribosomes in distilled water and various buffers, including reconstitution buffer, demonstrating an interesting progression of structures, but none with the degree of compactness of the reconstituted ribosome. Two quantitative measures were essential elements of the entire reconstitution study. First, mass and M/L mapping demonstrated that molecules were intact and not decorated with salt (giving an objective criterion for exclusion of contaminated or defective molecules). They also demonstrated that backbone and side branches tended to be either two- or four-stranded. A second P useful measure was the apparent radius of gyration defined by Rg ¼ (M(x,y) (x–x0)2 (y-y0)2), where (x0,y0) are the coordinates of the center of mass of the selected particle and the summation is taken over all pixels within the particle image. This is not strictly comparable to the small-angle scattering Rg because it is not averaged over all possible orientations, but it does agree surprisingly well in the cases tested. Its main use is in comparing the degree of compactness of particles prepared under similar or different conditions. The aims of this study were to define intermediates in the assembly pathway and to label individual proteins and trace their progress through the entire reassembly process. The first aim was accomplished, but unfortunately the second aim has not yet been fully realized. However, several interesting labeling results were obtained with tRNA. The reassembly experiments followed protocols worked out biochemically and were highly successful. 30S (Mandiyan et al., 1991) and 50S ((Tummina et al., 1994) subunits were each subjects of major publications detailing initial folding steps, stable intermediates, major rearrangements and final assembly. The key element in both these studies was the quantitation of both mass and Rg, which (1) demonstrated that added subunits were incorporated in correct amounts, (2) allowed critical size comparison, and (3) screened out flawed experiments.
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
113
Multi-enzyme complexes have a compact core with binding sites at the edges and faces for other enzymes and a flexible arm involved in transport of substrate along the enzyme pathway. Three projects have given significant results with the BNL STEM: (1) PDH (with P. Frey et al., University of Wisconsin, CaJacob et al., 1985; Yang et al., 1994); (2) a-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase (T. Wagenknecht, Albany; N. Francis and D. De Rosier, Brandeis) and (3) branched-chain a-keto acid dehydrogenase (M. Hackert, L. Reed et al., University of Texas). In each case the stoichiometry was established in addition to the overall arrangement of subunits. In the case of PDH, extensive gold labeling studies were performed. One of the most difficult complexes that has given useful STEM results is the basal body studies by G. Sosinsky (then at Brandeis), N. Francis and D. DeRosier (also at Brandeis) (Sosinsky et al., 1992). This structure serves as the motor to drive the flagellum, providing motive power for the bacterium. The hook, shaft, and various rings comprising this structure had been defined by cryo-EM, but the relative masses of different structures were not determined. In this case, several deletion mutants were available to determine incremental mass with and without the selected unit. These specimens are difficult to prepare entirely free of detergent and the internal TMV standard was degraded by bound detergent. Nevertheless, good differential mass measurements were obtained using the hook portion of well-preserved basal bodies as a local standard. A similar project was recently completed by Blocker and Hodgkinson (Figure 8) in which mass mapping was critical in determining the percentage of mass in the knob at the end of the needle (Hodgkinson et al., 2009).
50 nm
FIGURE 8 Needle complexes from Shigella flexneri T3SS (the cause of dysentery) freeze-dried and marked for mass measurement.
114
Joseph S. Wall et al.
The filamentous virus projects of L. Day (New York Public Health Research Laboratory) have been among the most controversial. The collaboration between Wall and Day dates back to the beginning of the STEM project. Based on biochemical, biophysical, and STEM studies, as well as extensive modeling, Day has proposed a model for the structure of Pf1, which has the DNA phosphates along the axis and the bases pointed outward (Liu and Day, 1994; Kostrikis et al., 1991). The untimely death of S. Reisberg, Day’s graduate student for much of this work, limited the number of STEM publications, but many of the concepts were based on Reisberg’s STEM data. Other types of filamentous viruses have more normal structures and almost all have been characterized with the STEM as to length, M/L, and radial density profile. Many other virus projects have been active over the years (Cheng et al., 1994). One early result is the observation that Sindbis nucleocapsid has T ¼ 4 symmetry, rather than T ¼ 3 as listed in textbooks (Paredes, Simon, and Brown, 1992). Similarly, both T7 (Steven et al., 1988) and T4 (Cerritelli et al., 1996) tail fibers were found to be trimers instead of the dimers quoted in texts. Many of the virus projects were interested in assembly intermediates and mechanisms (Briggs et al., 2004; Carlson et al.. 2008; Cerritelli and Studier, 1996a,b; Parker, Wall, and Hunter, 2001; Vogt and Simon, 1999; Wingfield et al., 1995; Yu et al., 2001). Several large invertebrate protein complexes have considerable historical significance with many interesting questions remaining. These are particularly useful as controls for specimen preparation, STEM imaging and image analysis. S. Vinogradov (Wayne State) and collaborators have studied a wide variety of giant hemoglobins (Kapp et al., 1990, Lamy et al., 1996; Martin et al., 1996; Sharma et al., 1996; Zal et al., 1996) and M. Hamilton (Fordham University) has investigated a wide variety of hemocyanin structures (Hamilton et al., 1989). Chaperone proteins and heat shock proteins (Hsps) were a lively STEM topic several years ago when A. Horwich (Yale University) began his studies on GroEL and similar proteins. The success of J. Trent (Yale, now Argonne National Laboratory) on TF55 (Trent et al., 1991) led to a series of collaborations to establish the relationship between most of the known chaperonins. The Horwich lab showed that the protein being folded was located in the central cavity of GroEL (Braig et al., 1993) and went on to obtain the three-dimensional structure of GroEL by X-ray crystallography. The Lindquist lab studied Hsp 104 (Parsell, Kowal, and Lindquist, 1994). John Flanagan’s work on ClpP (Flanagan et al., 1995) led to his solving the X-ray structure shortly thereafter. A few projects have had success with membrane proteins in the STEM. Gina Sosinsky was able to show that different types of connexins could be distinguished by mass in gap junction membranes (Sosinsky, 1995). Collier’s group was able to study pore formation with anthrax toxin (Milne et al., 1994).
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
115
In all these projects we have tried to demonstrate a level of impartiality and dedication that has attracted projects and collaborations from all quarters. We have worked with high school teachers and leaders in many fields with equal mutual respect and motivation to find answers. In answer to the complaint that we do not have any strong in-group biological projects, we point to our track record of finding the best available collaborators in a timely fashion. Our approach eliminates any aura of competition or feeling that anyone’s ideas or results may be diluted or even co-opted. Our successes are their successes.
5. RECENT WORK The STEM has been particularly productive recently in terms of samples requiring M/L measurements. This has included projects from David Eisenberg’s lab at UCLA to measure the M/L of some amyloid fibrils, samples from Ulrich Baxa and A. Stevens’ lab at NIH studying prions and amyloid fibrils, several plant viruses from Gerald Stubbs’ laboratory at Vanderbilt University (Kendall et al., 2008), and pili from Ed Egelman. On other projects, Nicole Francis of Harvard Medical School and Mavis McKenna of University of Florida had been earlier STEM users, as were Ed Egelman from the University of Virginia and Thomas Marlovits in Austria, who have a current joint project. Several new projects, by Ubarretxena from Mt. Sinai School of Medicine and Sakmar’s lab in Rockefeller University, are new to the STEM. Within BNL, we have projects from the Center for Functional Nanomaterials as well as those from the Biology Department.
6. CONCLUSION The BNL STEM continues to be a unique facility offering direct mass measurement of individual biomolecules and complexes to the biological community worldwide and visualizing and developing small gold nanoparticle labels. Even though newer microscopes have been developed, the BNL STEM has remained at the forefront of EM for quantitative mass measurements and simultaneous visualization (in focus) of proteins, DNA, and heavy metal labels in the same sample.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are grateful to K. Liu and G. Magera for providing experimental data for this study and to the FEI Co. management for support. One of the authors (L.W.S.) is grateful for the early encouragement and opportunities provided by Professors R. Gomer and W.P. Dyke to study field emission phenomena. We thank Beth Lin for preparing STEM specimens and
116
Joseph S. Wall et al.
Frank Kito for design and maintenance of instrumentation. The STEM is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Health and Environmental Research. Formerly supported by NIH Biotechnology Resources and NIBIB.
REFERENCES Braig, K., Simon, M., Furuya, F., Hainfeld, J. F., and Horwich, A. L. (1993). A polypeptide bound by the chaperonin groEL is localized within a central cavity. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90, 3978–3982. Briggs, J. A., Simon, M. N., Gross, I., Kra¨usslich, H. G., Fuller, S. D., Vogt, V. M., and Johnson, M. C. (2004). The stoichiometry of Gag protein in HIV-1. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 11, 672–675. Brin˜as, R. P., Hu, M., Qian, L., Lymar, E. S., and Hainfeld, J. F. (2008). Gold nanoparticle size controlled by polymeric Au(I) thiolate precursor size. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130(3), 975–982. CaJacob, C. A., Frey, P. A., Hainfeld, J. F., Wall, J. S., and Yang, H. (1985). Escherichia coli pyruvate dehydrogenase complex. Particle masses of the complex and component enzymes measured by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Biochemistry 24, 2425–2431. Carlson, L. A., Briggs, J. A., Glass, B., Riches, J. D., Simon, M. N., Johnson, M. C., Mu¨ller, B., Gru¨newald, K., and Kra¨usslich, H. G. (2008). Three-dimensional analysis of budding sites and released virus suggests a revised model for HIV-1 morphogenesis. Cell Host Microbe 11, 592–599. Cerritelli, M. E., and Studier, F. W. (1996a). Assembly of T7 capsids from independently expressed and purified head protein and scaffolding protein. J. Mol. Biol. 258, 286–298. Cerritelli, M. E., and Studier, F. W. (1996b). Purification and characterization of T7 head-tail connectors expressed from the cloned gene. J. Mol. Biol. 258, 299–307. Cerritelli, M. E., Wall, J. S., Simon, M. N., Conway, J. F., and Steven, A. C. (1996). Stoichiometry and domainal organization of the long tail-fiber of bacteriophage T4: A hinged viral adhesin. J. Mol. Biol. 260, 767–780. Cheng, N., Conway, J. F., Watts, N. R., Hainfeld, J. F., Joshi, V., Powell, R. D., Stahl, S. J., Wingfield, P. E., and Steven, A. C. (1999). Tetrairidium, a four-atom cluster, is readily visible as a density label in three-dimensional cryo-EM maps of proteins at 10–25 A resolution. J. Struct. Biol. 127(2), 169–176. Cheng, R. H., Caston, J. R., Wang, G.-J., Gu, F., Smith, T. J., Baker, T. S., Bozarth, R. F., Trus, B. L., Cheng, N., Wickner, R. B., and Steven, A. (1994). Fungal virus capsids are cytoplasmic compartments for the replication of double-stranded RNA, formed as icosahedral shells of asymetric Gag dimers. J. Mol. Biol. 244, 255–258. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J. S., and Welter, L. M. (1968). An electron gun using a field emission source. Rev. Sci. Instr. 39, 576–583. ˚ resolution. J. Mol. Biol. Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. S. (1970). A scanning microscopy with 5 A 48, 375–393. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J. S., and Langmore, J. (1970). Visibility of single atoms. Science 168, 1338–1340. Flanagan, J. M., Wall, J. S., Capel, M., Schneider, D. K., and Shanklin, J. (1995). Scanning transmission electron microscopy and small-angle scattering provide evidence that native Escherichia coli ClpP is a tetradecamer with an axial pore. Biochemistry 34, 10910–10917. Francis, N. J., Kingston, R. E., and Woodcock, C. L. (2004). Chromatin compaction by a polycomb group protein complex. Science 306, 1574–1577. Furuya, F. R., Miller, L. L., Hainfeld, J. F., Christopfel, W. C., and Kenny, P. W. (1988). Use of Ir4(CO)11 to measure the lengths of organic molecules with a scanning transmission electron microscope. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110, 641–643.
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
117
Gerchman, S. E., and Ramakrishnan, V. (1987). Chromatin higher-order structure studied by neutron scattering and scanning transmission electron microscopy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84, 7802–7806. Gregori, L., Hainfeld, J. F., Simon, M. N., and Goldgaber, D. (1997). Binding of amyloid beta protein to the 20S proteasome. J. Biol. Chem. 272, 58–62. Hainfeld, J. F. (1995). Gold, electron microscopy, and cancer therapy. Scanning Micros. 9, 239–254. Hainfeld, J. F. (1987). A small gold-conjugated antibody label: Improved resolution for electron microscopy. Science 236, 450–453. Hainfeld, J. F., Foley, C. J., Maelia, L. E., and Lipka, J. J. (1990). Eleven tungsten atom cluster labels: High-resolution, site-specific probes for electron microscopy. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 38, 1787–1793. Hainfeld, J. F., Sprinzl, M., Mandiyan, V., Tumminia, S. J., and Boublik, M. (1991). Localization of a specific nucleotide in yeast tRNA by scanning transmission electron microscopy using an undecagold cluster. J. Struct. Biol. 107, 1–5. Hainfeld, J. F., and Furuya, F. R. (1992). A 1.4-nm gold cluster covalently attached to antibodies improves immunolabeling. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 40, 177–184. Hainfeld, J. F., Liu, W., and Barcena, M. (1999a). Gold-ATP. J. Struct. Biol. 127, 120–134. Hainfeld, J. F., Furuya, F. R., and Powell, R. D. (1999b). Metallosomes. J. Struct. Biol. 127, 152–160. Hainfeld, J. F., Liu, C. M. R., Halsey, C. M. R., Freimuth, P., and Powell, R. D. (1999c). NiNTA-gold clusters target his-tagged proteins. J. Struct. Biol. 127, 185–198. Hamilton, M. G., Herskovits, T. H., Furcinitti, P. S., and Wall, J. S. (1989). Scanning transmission electron microscopic study of molluscan hemocyanins in various aggregation states. Comparison with light scattering molecular weights. J. Ultrastr. Mol. Str. Res. 102, 221–228. Hastie, A. T., Marchese-Ragona, S. P., Johnson, K. A., and Wall, J. S. (1988). The structure and mass of mammalian respiratory ciliary outer arm 19S dynein. Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton 11, 157–166. Hodgkinson, J. L., Horsley, A., Stabat, D., Simon, M., Johnson, S., da Fonseca, P. C., Morris, E. P., Wall, J. S., Lea, S. M., and Blocker, A. J. (2009). Three-dimensional reconstruction of the Shigella T3SS transmembrane regions reveals 12-fold symmetry and novel features throughout. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 16(5), 477–485. Hough, P. V. C., Mastrangelo, I. A., Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., Simon, M. N., and Manley, J. L. (1982). DNA-protein complexes spread on N2-discharged carbon film and characterized by molecular weight and its projected distribution. Nucleosome formation in an in vitro transcription system. J. Mol. Biol. 160, 375–386. Hough, P. V. C., Mastrangelo, I. A., Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., Sawadogo, M., and Roeder, R. G. (1987). The gene-specific initiation factor USF (upstream stimulatory factor) bound at the adenovirus type 2 major late promoter: Mass and three-dimensional structure. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84, 4826–4830. Hu, M., Qian, L., Brin˜as, R. P., Lymar, E. S., and Hainfeld, J. F. (2007). Assembly of nanoparticle-protein binding complexes: From monomers to ordered arrays. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 46(27), 5111–5114. Johnson, K. A., and Wall, J. S. (1983). Structure and molecular weight of the dynein ATPase. J. Cell Biol. 96, 669–678. Kapp, O. H., Qabar, A. N., Bonner, M. C., Stern, M. S., Walz, D. A., Schmuck, M., Pilz, I., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. (1990). Quaternary structure of the giant extracellular haemoglobin of the leech Macrobdella decora. J. Mol. Biol. 213, 141–158. Kendall, A., McDonald, M., Bian, W., Bowles, T., Baumgarten, S. C., Shi, J., Stewart, P. L., Bullitt, E., Gore, D., Irving, T. C., Havens, W. M., Ghabrial, S. A., et al. (2008). Structure of flexible filamentous plant viruses. J. Virol. 82, 9546–9554.
118
Joseph S. Wall et al.
Kostrikis, L. G., Reisberg, S. A., Simon, M. N., Wall, J. S., and Day, L. A. (1991). Export of infectious particles by Escherichia coli transfected with RF DNA of Pf1, a virus of Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain K. Molec. Microbiol. 5, 2641–2647. Ksiezak-Reding, H., and Wall, J. S. (1994). Mass and physical dimensions vary in two distinct populations of paired helical filaments in Alzheimer disease. Neurobiol. Aging 15, 11–19. Ksiezak-Reding, H., Tracz, E., Yang, L., Dickson, D. W., Simon, M., and Wall, J. S. (1996). Ultrastructural instability of paired helical filaments from corticobasal degeneration as examined by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM). Am. J. Pathol. 149(N2), 639–651. Lamy, J. N., Green, B. N., Toulmond, A., Wall, J. S., Weber, R. E., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1996). The giant hexagonal bilayer hemoglobins. Chem. Rev. 96(N8), 3113–3124. Lipka, J. J., Lippard, S. J., and Wall, J. S. (1979). Visualization of polymercurimethane labeled fd bacteriophage in the STEM. Science 206, 1419–1421. Lipka, J. J., Hainfeld, J. F., and Wall, J. S. (1983). Undecagold labeling of a glycoprotein: STEM visualization of an undecagold phosphine cluster labeling the carbohydrate sites of human haptoglobin-hemoglobin complex. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 84, 120–129. Liu, D. J., and Day, L. A. (1994). Pf1 virus structure: Helical coat protein and DNA with paraxial phosphates. Science 265, 671–674. Makhov, A. M., Hannah, J. H., Brennan, M. J., Trus, B. L., Kocsis, E., Conway, J. F., Wingfield, P. T., Simon, M. N., and Steven, A. C. (1994). Filamentous hemagglutinin of Bordetella pertussis: A bacterial adhesin formed as a 50–nm monomeric rigid rod based on a 19-residue repeat motif rich in beta strands and turns. J. Mol. Biol. 241, 110–124. Mandiyan, V., Tumminia, S., Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., and Boublik, M. (1991). Assembly of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit reveals protein dependent folding of the 16S rRNA domains. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 8174–8178. Marchese-Ragona, S., Wall, J. S., and Johnson, K. (1988). Structure and mass analysis of 14S dynein obtained from Tetrahymena cilia. J. Cell Biol. 106, 127–132. Marchese-Ragona, S. P., and Wall, J. S. (1995). Scanning–transmission electron–microscopic analysis of the isolated dynein ATPase. Meth. Cell Biol. 47, 171–175. Martin, P. D., Kuchomov, A. R., Green, B. N., Oliver, R. W. A., Braswell, E. H., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1996). Mass spectrometric composition and molecular mass of Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobin: A refined model of its quaternary structure. J. Mol. Biol. 255, 154–169. Mastrangelo, I. A., Hough, P. V. C., Wilson, V. G., Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., and Tegtmeyer, P. (1985). Monomers through trimers of large tumor antigen bind in region I and monomers through tetramers bind in region II of simian virus 40 origin of replication DNA as stable structures in solution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82, 3626–3630. Mastrangelo, I. A., Hough, P. V. C., Wall, J. S., Dodson, M., Dean, F. B., and Hurwitz, J. (1989). ATP-dependent assembly of double hexamers of SV40 T antigen at the viral origin of DNA replication. Nature 338, 658–662. Mastrangelo, I. A., Courey, A. J., Wall, J. S., Jackson, S. P., and Hough, P. V. (1991). DNA looping and Sp1 multimer links: A mechanism for transcriptional synergism and enhancement. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 5670–5674. Milligan, R. A., Whittaker, M., and Safer, D. (1990). Molecular structure of F-actin and location of surface binding sites. Nature 348, 217–221. Milne, J. C., Furlong, D., Hanna, P. C., Wall, J. S., and Collier, R. J. (1994). Anthrax protective toxin forms oligomers during intoxication of mammalian cells. J. Biol. Chem. 269, 20606–20612. Mosesson, M. W., Hainfeld, J., Haschemeyer, R. H., and Wall, J. S. (1981). Identification and mass analysis of human fibrinogen molecules and their domains by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM). J. Mol. Biol. 153, 695–718.
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
119
Mosesson, M. W., Nesheim, M. E., DiOrio, J., Hainfeld, J. F., Wall, J. S., and Mann, K. G. (1985). Studies on the structure of bovine factor V by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM). Blood 65, 1158–1162. Mosesson, M. W., Church, W. R., DiOrio, J. P., Krishnaswamy, S., Mann, K. G., Hainfeld, J. F., and Wall, J. S. (1990a). Structural model of factors V and Va based on scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) images and STEM mass analysis. J. Biol. Chem. 265, 8863–8868. Mosesson, M. W., Fass, D. N., Lollar, P., DiOrio, J. P., Knutson, G. J., Hainfeld, J. F., and Wall, J. S. (1990b). Structural model of porcine factors VIII and VIIIa based on scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) images and STEM mass analysis. J. Clin. Invest. 85, 1983–1990. Mosesson, M. W., DiOrio, J. P., Siebenlist, K. R., Wall, J. S., and Hainfeld, J. F. (1993). Evidence for a second type of fibril branch point in fibrin polymer networks, the trimolecular branch junction. Blood 82, 1517–1521. Mosesson, M. W., Siebenlist, K. R., Meh, D. A., Hainfeld, J. F., and Wall, J. S. (1998). The location of the carboxy-terminal region of g chains in fibrinogen and fibrin D domains. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 95, 10511–10516. Nojima, D., Linck, R. W., and Egelman, E. H. (1995). At least one of the protofilaments in flagellar microtubules is not composed of tubulin. Curr. Biol. 5, 158–167. Paredes, A. M., Simon, M. N., and Brown, D. T. (1992). The mass of the Sindbis virus nucleocapsid suggests it has T ¼ 4 icosahedral symmetry. Virology 187, 329–332. Parker, S. D., Wall, J. S., and Hunter, E. (2001). An analysis of Mason-Pfizer monkey virus Gag particles by scanning transmission electron microscopy. J Virol. 75, 9543–9548. Parsell, D. A., Kowal, A. S., and Lindquist, S. (1994). The S. cerevisiae Hsp 104 protein: Purification and characterization of ATP-induced structural changes. J. Biol. Chem. 269, 4480–4487. Ryder, K., Vakalopoulou, E., Mertz, R., Mastrangelo, I., Hough, P., Tegtmeyer, P., and Fanning, E. (1985). Seventeen base pairs of region I encode a novel tripartite binding signal for SV40 T antigen. Cell 42, 539–548. Safer, D., Hainfeld, J. F., Wall, J. S., and Riordan, J. (1982). Biospecific labeling with undecagold: Visualization of the biotin binding sites on avidin. Science 218, 290–291. Sen, A., Baxa, U., Simon, M. N., Wall, J. S., Sabate, R., Saupe, S. J., and Steven, A. C. (2007). Mass analysis by scanning transmission electron microscopy and electron diffraction validate predictions of stacked beta-solenoid model of HET-s prion fibrils. J. Biol. Chem. 282, 5545–5550. Sharma, P. K., Kuchumov, A. R., Chottard, G., Martin, P., Wall, J. S., and Vinogradov, S. N. (1996). The role of the dodecamer subunit in the dissociation and reassembly of the hexagonal bilayer structure of Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobin. J. Biol. Chem. 271, 8754–8762. Sosinsky, G. E., Francis, N. R., DeRosier, D. J., Wall, J. S., Simon, M. N., and Hainfeld, J. (1992). Mass determination and estimation of subunit stoichiometry of the bacterial hookbasal body flagellar complex of Salmonella typhimurium by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 4801–4805. Sosinsky, G. (1995). Mixing of connexins in gap junction membrane channels. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92, 9210–9214. Stasiak, A., Tsaneva, I. R., West, S. C., Benson, C. J. B., Yu, X., and Egelman, E. H. (1994). The Eschericia coli RuvB branch migration protein forms double hexameric rings around DNA. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 91, 7618–7622. Steinert, P. M., Steven, A. C., and Roop, D. R. (1985). The molecular biology of intermediate filaments. Cell 42, 411–419. Steven, A. C., Wall, J., Hainfeld, J., and Steinert, P. M. (1982). The structure of fibroblastic intermediate filaments: Analysis by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 3101–3105.
120
Joseph S. Wall et al.
Steven, A. C., Hainfeld, J. F., Trus, B. L., Wall, J. S., and Steinert, P. M. (1983). Epidermal keratin filaments assembled in vitro have masses-per-unit-length that scale according to average subunit mass: Structural basis for homologous packing of subunits in intermediate filaments. J. Cell Biol. 97, 1939–1944. Steven, A. C., Hainfeld, J. F., Trus, B. L., Wall, J. S., and Steinert, P. M. (1983). The distribution of mass in heteropolymer intermediate filaments assembled in vitro: STEM analysis of vimentin/desmin and bovine epidermal keratin. J. Biol. Chem. 258, 8323–8329. Steven, A. C., Hainfeld, J. F., Trus, B. L., Steinert, P. M., and Wall, J. S. (1984). Radial distributions of density within macromolecular complexes determined from dark-field electron micrographs. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 6363–6367. Steven, A. C., Trus, B. L., Hainfeld, J. F., Wall, J. S., and Steinert, P. M. (1985). Conformity and diversity in the structures of intermediate filaments. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 455, 371–380. Steven, A. C., Trus, B. L., Maizel, J. B., Unser, M., Parry, D. A. D., Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., and Studier, F. W. (1988). The molecular structure of a viral receptor-recognition protein: The GP17 tail-fiber of bacteriophage T7. J. Mol. Biol. 200, 351–365. Traxler, K. W., Norcum, M. T., Hainfeld, J. F., and Carlson, G. M. (2001). Direct visualization of the calmodulin subunit of phosphorylase kinase via electron microscopy following subunit exchange. J. Struct. Biol. 135, 231–238. Trent, J. D., Nimmesgern, E., Wall, J. S., Hartl, F.-U., and Horwich, A. L. (1991). A molecular chaperone from a thermophilic archaebacterium is related to a eukaryotic protein t complex polypeptide-1. Nature 354, 490–493. Tumminia, S. J., Hellmann, W., Wall, J. S., and Boublik, M. (1994). Visualization of the protein–nucleic acid interactions involved in the in vitro assembly of the Eschericia coli 50S ribosomal subunit. J. Mol. Biol. 235, 1239–1250. Turnquist, S., Simon, M., Egelman, E., and Anderson, D. (1992). Supercoiled DNA wraps around the bacteriophage Phi-29 head-tail connector. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 10479–10483. Vogt, V. M., and Simon, M. N. (1999). Mass determination of rous sarcoma virus virions by scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Virol. 73, 7050–7055. Wall, J. S. (1971). A high resolution scanning microscope for the study of single biological molecules. University of Chicago PhD dissertation. Wall, J. S. (1978). Limits on visibility of single heavy atoms in the scanning transmission electron microscopy – an experimental study. Chem. Scripta 14, 271–278. Wall, J., Hainfeld, J., and Bittner, J. (1978). Preliminary measurements of uranium atom motion on carbon films at low temperatures. Ultramicroscopy 3, 81–86. Wall, J. S., Hainfeld, J. F., Bartlett, P. A., and Singer, S. J. (1982). Observation of an undecagold cluster compound in the scanning transmission electron microscope. Ultramicroscopy 8, 397–402. Watts, N. R. M., Hainfeld, J., and Coombs, D. H. (1990). Localization of the proteins gp7, gp8, and gplO in the bacteriophage T4 baseplate with colloidal gold F(ab)2 and undecagold Fab0 conjugates. J. Mol. Biol. 216, 315–325. Wilkinson, D. A., Marion, T. N., Tillman, D. M., Norcum, M. T., Hainfeld, J. F., Seyer, J. M., and Carlson, G. M. (1994). An epitope proximal to the carboxyl terminus of the a-subunit is located near the lobe tips of the phosphorylase kinase hexadecamer. J. Mol. Biol. 235, 974–982. Wingfield, P. T., Stahl, S. J., Williams, R. W., and Steven, A. C. (1995). Hepatitis core antigen produced in Escherichia coli: Subunit composition, conformational analysis, and in vitro capsid assembly. Biochemistry 34, 4919–4932. Witman, G. B., Johnson, K. A., Pfister, K. K., and Wall, J. S. (1983). Fine structure and molecular weight of the outer arm dyneins of Chlamydomonas. J. Submicros. Cytol. 15, 193–197. Woodcock, C. L. F., Frado, L.-L. Y., and Wall, J. S. (1979). Direct molecular weight determination of chromatin particles by STEM. J. Cell Biol. 83, 156a.
History of the STEM at Brookhaven National Laboratory
121
Woodcock, C. L. F., Frado, L.-L. Y., and Wall, J. S. (1980). Composition of native and reconstituted chromatin particles: Direct mass determination by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77, 4818–4822. Woodcock, C. L. F., and Frank, J. (1984). Nucleosome mass distribution using image averaging. J. Ultrastr. Res. 89, 295–302. Woodcock, C. L. F., Frado, L.-L. Y., and Rattner, J. B. (1984). The higher order structure of chromatin: Evidence for a helical ribbon arrangement. J. Cell Biol. 99, 42–52. Xiao, S., Liu, F., Rosen, A. E., Hainfeld, J. F., Seeman, N. C., Musier-Forsyth, K., and Kiehl, R. A. (2002). Assembly of nanoparticle arrays by DNA scaffolding. J. Nanoparticle Res. 4, 313–317. Xiao, Y., Patolsky, F., Katz, E., Hainfeld, J. F., and Willner, I. (2003). ‘‘Plugging into enzymes’’: Nanowiring of redox enzymes by a gold nanoparticle. Science 299(5614), 1877–1881. Yang, Y.-S., Datta, A., Hainfeld, J. F., Furuya, F. R., Wall, J. S., and Frey, P. A. (1994). Mapping the lipoyl groups of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex by use of gold cluster-labels and scanning transmission electron microscopy. Biochemistry 33, 9428–9437. Yu, F., Joshi, S. M., Ma, Y. M., Kingston, R. L., Simon, M. N., and Vogt, V. M. (2001). Characterization of Rous sarcoma virus Gag particles assembled in vitro. J. Virol. 75, 2753–2764. Yu, X., and Egelman, E. H. (1992). Structural data suggest that the active and inactive forms of Rec A filament are not simply interconvertible. J. Mol. Biol. 227, 334–346. Yu, X., and Egelman, E. H. (1993). The LexA repressor binds within the deep helical groove of the activated RecA filament. J. Mol. Biol. 231, 29–40. Zal, F., Lallier, F. H., Wall, J. S., Vinogradov, S. M., and Toulmond, A. (1996). The multihemoglobin system of the hydrothermal vent tube worm Riftia pachyptila. I. Reexamination of the number and masses of its constituents. J. Biol. Chem. 271, 8869–8888.
Chapter
4 Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes Hiromi Inada, Hiroshi Kakibayashi, Shigeto Isakozawa, Takahito Hashimoto, Toshie Yaguchi, and Kuniyasu Nakamura
Contents
1. Introduction 2. The Dawn of Hitachi Electron Microscopes (by Hiromi Inada) 2.1. Crewe STEM Shock and Field Emission Development 3. Cold FE-SEM Studies and Expansion to Different Fields 3.1. CFE-STEM Development at HCRL 3.2. CFE-SEM Development at Naka Works 3.3. Studies of Field Emission Stability 4. Expansion of High-Voltage TEMs and STEMs 4.1. Holography Studies by Tonomura with FE-TEMs 4.2. Multistage Acceleration CFEG for TEM Applications 4.3. Commercialized Analytical CFE-TEM/STEM 5. Development of 50-kV STEM in 1970s (by Shigeto Isakozawa) 5.1. Development of Hitachi’s 50kV Prototype CFE-STEM
124 125 125 128 128 131 132 137 137 138 139 141 141
Hitachi High-Technologies Corp., Tokyo, Japan Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59004-0. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
123
124
Hiromi Inada et al.
5.2. Bright-Field Images Obtained with 50-kV CFE-STEM 5.3. Single-Atom Observation 5.4. Development of the Electron Energy-Loss Spectrometer 5.5. Further Development of 50-kV CFE-STEM 6. Hitachi’s First Commercialized Dedicated STEM (by Takahito Hashimoto) 6.1. 200-kV Analytical CFE-TEM, HF-2000 6.2. ‘‘Gate Viewer,’’ Trigger for Dedicated STEM 6.3. Novel Functions for HD Series 7. Cutting-Edge Applications with Customized HD Models (by Toshie Yaguchi) 7.1. 120-kV FE UHV for Nanotubes 7.2. 200-kV FE Ultrahigh-Resolution STEM 7.3. 3D Structural and Elemental Analysis 8. Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM (by Kuniyasu Nakamura) 8.1. Atomic-Level Characterization Instrument 8.2. Theoretical Consideration of Advantages of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.3. Evaluation of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.4. Advanced Application Results with HD-2700C 9. Conclusion and Future Prospective (by Hiroshi Kakibayashi) Acknowledgments References
142 144 147 149 150 150 154 161 165 165 165 169 170 170 172 173 176 181 182 182
1. INTRODUCTION Hitachi started researching and developing electron microscopes in 1940 and has since developed and manufactured many electron microscopes. Cold-field emission (CFE) technology developed in a number of different directions. Crewe invented the field emission scanning transmission electron microscope (FE-STEM) and used an early version to observe individual atoms. Stimulated by his reports, Hitachi began developing a CFE-STEM in the mid-1960s and invited Crewe to serve as a consultant to Hitachi. He introduced his CFE technology and helped Hitachi develop and commercialize STEMs and scanning electron microscopes (SEMs). Hitachi’s prototype CFE-STEM opened a new world of analytical electron microscopes equipped with an X-ray analyzer and energy spectrometer. The HFS-2 FE-SEM, which was built at Hitachi’s Naka Works in 1972, was the first step in Hitachi’s development of FE-SEMs. A 50-kV CFE-TEM
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
125
was developed at Hitachi’s Central Research Laboratory (HCRL) by Tonomura and his group in 1973 for application to electron holography, which enabled higher image resolution. To incorporate a sophisticated FE electron gun into microscopes, it was necessary to create an ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) (of the order of 108 Pa) to fundamentally stabilize the FE current. This chapter describes Hitachi’s efforts over the past 40-plus years to develop CFE technology and STEMs. We also introduce cutting-edge application data obtained with the latest CFE-STEMs (with and without an aberration corrector), highlight Hitachi’s contributions to FE technology development, and show how the knowledge gained has been passed from generation to generation at Hitachi. Additionally, we show how CFE SEM/ STEM technologies were established.
2. THE DAWN OF HITACHI ELECTRON MICROSCOPES (BY HIROMI INADA) K. Kasai, one of the founders of the 37th Subcommittee of the Japanese Society for the Promotion of Science, with regard to electron microscopes, moved to Hitachi from one of the Japanese National Laboratories, Electrotechnical Laboratory in 1939 and began to develop electron microscopes by using the experience he gained working on cathode ray oscillography in Germany. His guiding principle was that one should work in a manufacturing company to be able to do innovative practical development. Kasai joined forces with B. Tadano at Hitachi and, in 1940, they developed the first Hitachi TEM (model HU-1) (Komoda 1996a). A second TEM with improved resolution (the HU-2) was developed and installed at Nagoya Imperial University (now Nagoya University) in 1943. Hitachi established a central research laboratory (HCRL) in Kokubunji, a suburb of Tokyo, in 1942 where it continued developing electron microscopes despite the wartime conditions.
2.1. Crewe STEM Shock and Field Emission Development 2.1.1. Trigger for Field Emission Microscopes A. V. Crewe reported the successful development of an SEM equipped with a CFE gun (CFEG) in 1964 (Crewe, 1964; Crewe et al., 1970a). This report greatly affected Hitachi researchers, who were seriously fighting to obtain the highest TEM resolution in the mid-1960s (Komoda 1996b). Crewe and his group were provident in terms of advantages of CFE and the progress of UHV technology, and they began pioneering development of an STEM equipped with a CFEG in the early 1960s. They
126
Hiromi Inada et al.
achieved a resolution of 0.5 nm and successfully observed individual atoms of uranium and thorium, even though their microscope had a simple design and contained a single-electron magnetic lens with a CFEG. This breakthrough observation overturned the conventional wisdom about electron microscopy at that time and revealed the power of FE technology. Moreover, they directly observed individual atoms with a STEM, not a TEM, whereas most scientists believed that only a TEM could achieve such high-resolution imaging (Crewe et al., 1968a,b; Crewe, Wall, and Langmore, 1970b). Hitachi started developing SEMs in the early 1960s and commercialized the first thermionic gun SEM (model HSM-2) in 1969. Conventional SEMs with a thermionic gun at that time had a resolution of 10 nm, which was much worse than that of TEMs (0.3 nm); hence, nobody compared performance between TEMs and SEMs. However, Crewe’s development of an SEM in 1964 made it possible to compare SEMs with TEMs using the same criteria. An SEM can be used to acquire time series of various types of signals (secondary, transmission electron, X-ray, and energy loss) from a specimen simultaneously by focusing on an electronically specific point and/ or area by imaging it with a narrow scanning electron beam. The development of the CFE-SEM meant the birth of a new scientific instrument capable of simultaneous nanometer-order analysis and imaging. Although some scientists (Eggenberger, Hart, and Libal, 1968; Siegel et al., 1968; Wiesner and Everhart, 1969) had started early FEG electron microscopes, none of the electron microscope vendors had succeeded in building a CFE-SEM. Accordingly, Hitachi was driven to quickly develop a CFE-SEM due to its importance. R. Ueda (Nagoya University) said in the preface of the first issue revival of the Journal of Electron Microscopy in 1975, ‘‘Crewe STEM was excellent and nobody had imagined before such achievement and his outstanding concept’’ (Ueda, 1975). This statement reflects the sensational effect the FE-SEM had at that time.
2.1.2. Field Emission Gun Development at Hitachi Hitachi launched a major project in 1969 to produce ultrahigh-resolution FE-SEMs and FE-TEMs. As a microscope manufacturer, Hitachi focused on ease of use and ease of production, as well as on imaging capability. In 1970, Hitachi invited Crewe to serve as a technical consultant for its development of a CFE-SEM. Field emission was discovered by R. W. Wood in the nineteenth century (Wood, 1897). Millikan and Lauritsen (1928) and E. W. Mu¨ller (1937) studied the characteristics of this type of emission. FE patterns
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
127
were investigated (Gomer, 1961), and study of FE as a source of electrons began in 1955 (Butler, 1966; Dyke et al., 1953; Everhart, 1967; Martin, Trolan, and Dyke, 1960). FE electrons can be obtained by applying several thousand volts to the tip of a metal needle (FE tip) with a radius of less than 100 nm. The energy spread of the emitted electrons is narrow (0.2–0.3 eV) because the emitter runs at room temperature. FE electrons are emitted through the potential barrier of the surface from near the Fermi level because the barrier is thinned by the application of a negative electronic field with a strength of 107 V/cm to the metal surface, which is the tunnel effect. The current density J(A/cm2) is obtained using equation 1 from Fowler and Nordheim (Fowler and Nordheim, 1928), and the density strongly depends on the electric field applied to the FE tip and on the work function of the metal. ( ) F2 6:83 105 f3=2 vðyÞ 2 exp J ¼ 1:54 10 ; (4.1) ft2 ðyÞ F where t2(y) and v(y) are elliptic functions nearly equal to 1, F is the electric field strength, and f is the cathode work function. The thermionic electron current density is obtained using the Richardson–Dushman equation. The CFE current density (104–106 A/cm2) is three orders of magnitude larger than that of the thermionic electrons (1–10 A/cm2). The FE source is ideally a point source, and the diameter of the virtual source ranges from 5 to 10 nm because of the small FE tip, which is 1/1000 the source size of the thermionic emission (1–10 m). Thus, changing the FE source can reduce the beam spot size; that is, it can improve SEM image resolution. An electron gun should be designed to have less spherical aberration and mechanical vibration. Crewe used the Butler electrostatic lens, which has less spherical aberration than his prototype design, for his CFE-STEM and thereby obtained high resolution. An FE electron gun with a Butler lens consists of an FE tip and a diode region for the extraction and acceleration electrodes (Figure 1). A. Tonomura at HCRL used a microcomputer to optimize the Butler lens shape and minimize the aberration (Shimoyama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989; Tonomura and Komoda, 1973). Table 1 shows a comparison of the characteristics of emitters with FE and thermionic electron guns. Although applying the FE gun to electron microscopes was an obvious next step, it took many years to develop such a microscope that was practical. This was due to the instability of the FE current and the difficulty of achieving an UHV of the order of 108 Pa.
128
Hiromi Inada et al.
FE tip V1 1st anode
V0
2nd anode
FIGURE 1
Schematic diagram of FE gun with Butler electrode lens.
TABLE 1 Characteristics of Emitters
Source brightness Source size Energy spread Temperature Vacuum pressure Lifetime
Field emission W<310>
Thermionic emission (Tungsten filament)
109 A/cm2 sr 5–10 nm 0.3 (eV) 300 K (R.T.) <10–8 Pa 1 year
5 105 A/cm2 sr 1–10 m 2 (eV) 2800 K <10–3 Pa 50 hours
3. COLD FE-SEM STUDIES AND EXPANSION TO DIFFERENT FIELDS 3.1. CFE-STEM Development at HCRL In 1968, a group at HCRL organized by T. Komoda began developing a CFE-STEM (Komoda et al., 1972). The prototype CFE-STEM consisted of (i) a gun chamber evacuated to 1 108 Pa and separated from the microscope column by a differential aperture and (ii) a microscope column evacuated to 3 105 Pa. A Butler FE gun and two stages of electromagnetic lenses (Figure 2) produced a convergent beam on the
Field emission gun
Aperture
Ion-pump (1) 2 ⫻ 10−10 torr Ion-pump (2) 5 ⫻ 10−8 torr
Condenser lens (stigmator) Objective lens (deflector) Ion-pump (3) Specimen stage Detector (P.M. tube)
FIGURE 2
1 ⫻ 10−6 torr
(Left) Schematic diagram of FE-STEM developed at HCRL and (right) general view of Hitachi’s first FE-STEM.
130
Hiromi Inada et al.
specimen when an acceleration voltage of 50 kV and an extraction voltage of 5 kV were applied. A tungsten <310>-oriented FE tip in NaOH electropolished was used as an electron source. Komoda’s group developed a pulsed power supply to stabilize the polishing and thereby maintain the quality of the FE tip. They calculated the electron path and aberrations with a microcomputer to optimize the Butler lens to machine it more precisely and thus minimize spherical aberration (Tonomura, 1973). Ultimately, a brightness of 5 108 A/cm2 was obtained. A side-entry specimen stage holding the specimen, a movable aperture, and a cold finger were inserted into the 6.5-mm gap in the objective lens pole piece, which had a bore of 2 mm. A transmission electron detector consisting of a phosphor and a photomultiplier was placed at the bottom of the microscope column. A contrast aperture was inserted immediately above the detector to control the detection angle and to produce three kinds of contrast. Crewe and Wall (1970c) and Zeitler (Zeitler et al., 1970a,b) asserted that a bright-field (BF) STEM image is equivalent to a conventional TEM image by reciprocity. The use of a contrast aperture resulted in (i) a BF-STEM detection angle of less than 10 mrad without elastic scattered electrons, (ii) a phase contrast of less than 2 mrad, producing a small illumination angle TEM image, and (iii) a dark-field (DF) STEM detection angle of more than 10 mrad, enabling detection of elastic scattered electrons. Hitachi achieved a resolution of 1 nm with their instrument and observed BF and DF contrast reversal of evaporated Au particles, the equal-thickness fringe of MgO single crystals, and a microtome tissue section (Figure 3) that clearly indicates a double-cell membrane.
FIGURE 3 Tissue section of biological specimen showing double-layered structure of cell membrane.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
131
3.2. CFE-SEM Development at Naka Works Another FE project had been started by the Naka Works. A team led by S. Saito had the goal of producing an FE-SEM capable of secondary electron (SE) detection. This goal was set because the market and target were clear and because no one had achieved very fine feature analysis (on the order of 3 nm) for biological studies. The resolution available with tungsten-filament SEMs (10 nm) was insufficient. However, most electron microscopes produced in the 1970s were for biology, and scientists were looking for impressively beautiful electron micrographs. Hence, these were obviously tough years for scanning microscopes, which produced rough pixel images that were unacceptable to most scientists. Saito was dispatched to Perkin-Elmer Ultek Inc. to learn about and investigate UHV technologies for practical use, and they introduced. In 1970, Hitachi Naka Works invited Crewe to serve as a consultant to Hitachi and assist with the development of a CFE-SEM for two years. The Naka engineers brought a drawing board to a conference room to help them concentrate on working closely with Crewe to design a new concept microscope (Figure 4). They eventually succeeded in developing the world’s first commercialized CFE-SEM, model HFS-2, in 1972 (Komoda and Saito, 1972b) (Figure 5). It had an aberration-optimized Butler lens, a variable acceleration voltage of 1–25 kV, and resolution of 3 nm. The microscope column was separated into three chambers by using differential pumping apertures, and the chambers were pumped with individual ion pumps. The CFEG maintained a vacuum pressure of 108 Pa even when the pressure in the specimen chamber was 103 Pa. For longer running time, two FE tips were inserted into the gun, which eliminated the need to vent the gun chamber. The column had a single stage condenser lens and an objective lens, enabling the illuminating electron beam
FIGURE 4 Photograph taken at meeting with Professor Crewe of Chicago University and Hitachi colleagues during his consultancy (1972).
132
Hiromi Inada et al.
FIGURE 5
Hitachi’s first commercial FE-SEM (model HFS-2).
to be varied widely in size, resulting in a probe size of 2–20 nm and a probe current of 10 pA to 2 nA. This CFE-SEM has been installed in major biology research facilities. Collaborative work with K. Tanaka of Tottori University led to the development of instruments with much higher resolution. Since then the resolution and FE stability of CFE-SEMs have continued to be improved (Figure 6). Thanks to the development of an in-lens pole-piece design, CFE-SEMs now have much higher resolution (<1 nm), and a recent CFE-SEM (model S-5500), which has an environment-resistant design, has a resolution of 0.4 nm in SE image (Figure 7).
3.3. Studies of Field Emission Stability The biggest problem in applying CFE technology to microscopes is improving FE stability and operation. It is not an exaggeration to state that progress in CFE technology is equivalent to progress in UHV technology. The improvements made include automatic V0/V1 ratio control for the Butler lens, noise reduction for the electronics, and beam monitor incorporation for user operation of the sophisticated FE technique. The FE current fluctuates, and instability of the emission current increases with the probe current. This instability is one of the problems that must be overcome for FE technology to be used practically. Figure 8 illustrates the general behavior of the FE current as a function of time after flashing. Flashing the FE tip causes gas molecules on the tip surface to desorb and smooths the surface. An extraction voltage (V1) of 2–5 kV is then applied to obtain a total emission current of 1–100 A. Immediately after flashing, the FE current decreases as a gas monolayer builds up on the emitter surface. Stable region, relatively flat emission
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
133
500 Å
T2-bacterio phage ; taken by ultra high resolution SEM, model HFS-2 (Prof.A.V.Crewe, Chicago University, U.S.A, 1972)
T2-bacterio phage ; taken by ultra high resolution SEM, model UHS-t1 (Prof.K.Tanaka, Tottori University, Japan) (1988)
FIGURE 6 Secondary electron micrograph image comparison of T2 bacteriophage, recorded with HFS-2 (left, in 1972) and with prototype in-lens–type FE-SEM for Professor Tanaka at Tottori University (right, in 1988).
16
HSM-2
14 Thermionic electron SEMs SEM resolution (nm)
12 10
HSM-2A
8 6
HFS-2 (5 nm)
4
Field emission SEMs
S-700
S-800
2
S-900 0 1960
1970
1980
S-5000 S-5200 S-5500 1990
2000
2010
Year
FIGURE 7 Progress in image resolution of Hitachi FE-SEMs. The resolution of an early thermionic gun is plotted for comparison. Spatial resolution improved to sub-nanometer order with introduction of model S-900 due to incorporating in-lens design optics.
Hiromi Inada et al.
Emitter destroyed by vacuum arc
Emission current
IE
134
Current decreasing due to adsorption
Current increasing due to ion bombardment
IMIN Time Flashing
Cyclical lifetime
FIGURE 8 General behavior of field emission current as a function of time after flashing (Shimoyama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989).
current flows; however, continuous absorbing, desorbing, and migration of gas molecules occurs on the emitter surface; this derives FE noise, which is very fast random current fluctuation. After the region is kept stable for several hours (<10 hours), the FE current rises with a large fluctuation, which possibly destroys the tip. The emission current decreases as a function of the work function of the absorbing gas in accordance with Eq. (4.1). H. Todokoro et al. (Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982) of HCRL investigated the fluctuations in the FE current with the vacuum pressure of the FE gun and experimentally found that current stability is affected by ion bombardment of the FE source. The experiments were done using a vacuum chamber equipped with two FE guns (A and B). Gun A had a single FE tip and was used to record the total emission current under various vacuum pressures. The relative fluctuation, DI/I, as a function of the product of the pressure and emission current (P I) is shown in Figure 9. It is proportional to the logarithm of P I above 7 1012 PaA. This indicates that the fluctuation increase is caused by ion bombardment of the residual gas molecules. This fluctuation represents a function of P I, not of I. Below 7 1012 PaA, the relative fluctuation is less than 1% and constant, probably due to migration of the absorbed gas molecules on the FE tip surface. The results of this experiment show that FE current fluctuation caused by ion bombardment increases when the product of pressure and emission current exceeds a threshold. Gun B had two emitters 5 mm apart that were supplied with individual high voltages simultaneously to verify the origin of the ions (Figure 10). Emitter I emitted a current ranging from 5 to 250 A, and emitter II emitted a constant current of 5 A. As Figure 11 shows, the emission fluctuation of emitter II was maintained despite the very close placement of the emitters
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
135
15 4 ⫻ 10−8 Pa −7 4.5 ⫻ 10 Pa 1 ⫻ 10−6 Pa −6 4.5 ⫻ 10 Pa DI∞/I∞(%)
10
5
0
10−13
10−12
10−11 P ⫻ I∞(Pa.A)
10−10
10−9
FIGURE 9 Relative emission fluctuation as a function of product of gun pressure and total emission current. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982.
and their sharing of the same ambient gas pressure. This shows that the bombarding ions are generated close to the emitters. H. Shimoyama described the history of improvements in emission current (Shimovama, Ichihashi, and Tamura, 1989). For example, the total emission current steadily increased year by year due to improvements in vacuum technology, surface treatment, and reproductive FE tips. For instance, the emission current obtained was only a few microamperes in the 1970s compared with 100 A in the 1980s. A small desktop FE-SEM (model S-310) (Figure 12, W400 D500 H500 mm, released in 1976) sparked the idea for a critical dimension (CD)-SEM. The CD-SEM used a simple optics CFEG and a single objective lens, and it had a resolution of 10 nm in TV rate scanning. The gun had a single-electrode design, and the acceleration voltage was the same as the extraction voltage (4–6 kV). This microscope had an emission current (20 A) 10 times higher than previous microscopes, resulting in improved spatial resolution of quickly scanned images. Accordingly, it was an important breakthrough for improving FE stability and emitting a higher FE current. The model S-310 microscope was suitable for nonconductive specimens, such as cloth and semiconductor devices without charge-up, because of its low acceleration voltage. It nevertheless did not meet customer needs at that time (the late 1970s) because most users apparently expected beautiful art-like electron microscope images. It was better
Hiromi Inada et al.
136
V1
V1⬘
REC. REC.
Emitter I
Emitter II
Anode
1 cm
FIGURE 10 Experimental apparatus of Gun B. Two FE tips were placed face to face and had the same anode distance of 10 mm. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982. Emitter I
1.1 1.0
5 mA
10 mA
50 mA
100 mA
250 mA
0.9
1 min 3 ⫻ 10−7 Pa 1.1 Emitter II 1.0 5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
5 mA
0.9
FIGURE 11 Emission current fluctuations for two simultaneously operating FE tips obtained using different emission currents. Emitter I had emission current of 5 A to 250 A, whereas emitter II was controlled to emit a constant 5 A. Reproduced with permission of Todokoro, Saito, and Yamamoto, 1982.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
137
FIGURE 12 Overview of desktop S-310 FE-SEM, which is now displayed in the reception area of Hitachi High Technologies America.
suited for the early 21st century when there was a boom in interest for small SEMs. The S-310 low-kilovolt microscope, on the other hand, gave an essential for semiconductor device in line dedicated CD-SEM.
4. EXPANSION OF HIGH-VOLTAGE TEMs AND STEMs 4.1. Holography Studies by Tonomura with FE-TEMs Researchers at HCRL had an idea for using FE guns on TEMs at the very beginning of CFE-STEM development. TEM resolution had improved drastically through the 1970s under the heat of competition, and the ultimate resolution had been reached with conventional TEM. Gabor invented holography in 1948 (Gabor, 1949) to compensate for spherical aberration. Although A. Tonomura et al. (1968) proved the practicability of electron holography in their pioneering work using Hibi’s pointed filament (Hibi, 1956) in 1968, the resolution of the reconstructed image was not satisfactory due to poor electron beam interference. Tonomura et al. developed, in 1972, with Butler lens FE source as a gun applicable of acceleration voltage of 50 kV, for electron holography (Figure 13) (Tonomura and Komoda, 1973). They developed an 80-kV CFE-TEM with higher coherency in 1978 and obtained as many as 3000 lines of Fresnel fringes (Tonomura et al., 1979b) compared with the 300 fringes obtained up until then, and thereby ensured the realization of practical electron holography. The lattice resolution was improved to 0.062 nm due to a chromatic aberration effect. The Aharonov–Bohm effect was proven experimentally in 1982 (Tonomura et al., 1979b, 1982, 1998) with
138
Hiromi Inada et al.
FIGURE 13
Overview of 50-kV FE-TEM (Tonomura, 1972).
the 80-kV CFE-TEM. They also studied the use of holography using a 1-MeV CFE-TEM (Kawasaki et al., 2000) at Hitachi’s Advanced Research Laboratory and investigated the dynamics of vortices (magnetic-flux quanta) in high– transition temperature (Tc) superconductors. Using this 1-MeV CFE-TEM, they obtained 10,000 Fresnel fringes and a lattice resolution of 0.049 nm.
4.2. Multistage Acceleration CFEG for TEM Applications Many remarkable CFE-TEM experiments have been done with the 80-kV CFE-TEM at HCRL; however, it was difficult to exceed an acceleration voltage of 80 kV with the Butler lens electron gun because of discharge between the emitter and electrodes. Endo of HCRL and his group developed a multistage electrode gun that produced an acceleration voltage of 125 kV to improve coherency and resolution. The distance between the emitter and ground electrode in the multistage electrode gun was
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
139
Insulator housing
Field emission tip Electrodes Insulator
FIGURE 14 Cross-sectional image of FE gun with multistage acceleration tube (Tonomura, 1984).
approximately 10 times that in the Butler lens gun (Tonomura, 1984) (Figure 14). This new CFEG produced a total emission current of 100 A and a consequent probe current of 8 nA. This gun incorporated countermeasures against outside magnetic fields. Extra care was needed when mounting the FE tip because of its tall design. This multistage electron gun was used not only for electron holography studies (Tonomura et al., 1982) but also for 100-kV analytical CFE-TEM (Koreeda et al., 1990).
4.3. Commercialized Analytical CFE-TEM/STEM Tomita and Naka Works designers developed the first analytical CFETEM (model H-600FE) equipped with an energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectrometer and an electron energy-loss spectrometer (EELS) analyzer. It was installed at Osaka University in 1986. This TEM used a multistage electrode gun to produce 100 kV. It had SE and two STEM detectors and a maximum specimen tilt angle of 60 , and it had a lattice resolution of 0.14 nm and an STEM resolution of 1 nm (Koreeda et al., 1990) (Figure 15). An energy spread of 1 eV was obtained with a serial EELS designed by S. Isakozawa of the Naka Works.
Electron microscope column (FE-Gun)
Energy dispersive X-ray micro analysis C-F discri
SEM. det.
EDX. det. Def. coil
SEM. image
0 I P1 P2
EELS. control EELS. det Slit
STEM. det
Ratemeter
FIGURE 15 (Left) Side view 100-kV field emission analytical TEM/STEM (H-600FE) installed at Osaka University. (Right) Schematic diagram of H600FE with analytical tools (SEM, EDS, and EELS detectors) (Koreeda et al., 1990).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
141
5. DEVELOPMENT OF 50-KV STEM IN 1970S (BY SHIGETO ISAKOZAWA) 5.1. Development of Hitachi’s 50kV Prototype CFE-STEM The basic design for Hitachi’s 50-kV CFE-STEM was developed by S. Nomura and H. Todokoro at HCRL. S. Saito, Y. Minamikawa, and Kakiuchi at Naka Works worked on the detailed designs and the production of a prototype. Table 2 shows the specifications of the FE-STEM prototype. Figure 16 shows a schematic diagram of the basic design. A CFE cathode is used for the electron source. Condenser and objective lenses demagnify the electron beam, which is accelerated to 50 kV to form a spot with a diameter of 0.3 nm on the specimen. To meet the requirements for high-resolution observation, the specimen stage was designed on the basis of a TEM specimen stage. Specimens have to be thin sections and are placed on a 3-mm diameter grid. Forward-scattering electrons are detected with an annular dark-field (ADF) detector. The electron intensity detected by the detector is displayed on a cathode ray tube (CRT). As the driving signals of the CRT are synchronized with the raster scan signals, the arrangement of the electron intensity signals forms a DF-STEM image. UHV technologies were not well established in the 1970s, so the reliability of CFE sources was sufficient only for obtaining several microamperes of emission current for only a few hours with a 50-kV acceleration voltage. Nevertheless, this was good enough to observe a single atom. Much work was undertaken by Nomura and Todokoro to improve
TABLE 2
Specifications of the prototype FE-STEM
Item
Resolution Maximum acceleration voltage Maximum magnification Gun type Time for exchanging specimen Vacuum evacuation system
Column structure Electron optics
Specifications
0.3 nm 50 kV 10,000,000 Cold-field emission 10 minutes Three-stage differential pumping system Ion pump (60 L/sec, 20 L/sec, 150 L/sec) Components connected with metal gaskets Illuminating, objective, projection lenses
142
Hiromi Inada et al.
Field emission gun
CRT for display
Probe forming lens
X ray detector
Specimen
Electron detector(A) Electron energy loss spectrometer
Slit
Electron detector(B) (B)
FIGURE 16
Concept of FE-STEM by Nomura.
stage stability, reduce noise from the scan coil current, reduce specimen contamination, and so on. They were then able to obtain high-resolution STEM images. They also invented new techniques—for example, a specimen exchange method to evacuate air with a sorption pump and then insert it into the UHV chamber. Development of the 50-kV CFE-STEM was completed in 1975. Figure 17 shows an overall view of the CFE-STEM developed by Hitachi. Note that an EELS was mounted on the bottom of the microscope column. The basic design concept enabled not only single-atom observation, but also element analysis with atomic spatial resolution.
5.2. Bright-Field Images Obtained with 50-kV CFE-STEM Figures 18 and 19 show lattice fringes of carbon graphite and single-crystal Au film acquired to confirm the mechanical and electrical stabilities and probe size of the FE-STEM prototype. As the reciprocity relationship between conventional TEM (CTEM) and STEM had been studied at HCRL, it was well known that crystal lattice fringes could be obtained with BF-STEM exactly like those obtained with CTEM. The BF-STEM images in Figures 18 and 19 clearly show that crystal lattices with spacings of 0.34 and 0.20 nm can be observed. This means that the electron beam spot size was 0.3 nm or less and that the instrument was stable enough to obtain atomic resolution. The image in Figure 19 is certainly the first example of observing lattice fringes with spacing of 0.2 nm using BF-STEM.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 17
General view of FE-STEM.
4Å
3.
FIGURE 18 Lattice fringe of carbon graphite (bright-field image).
3 nm
FIGURE 19
A 0.2-nm lattice fringe of single-crystal Au (bright-field image).
143
144
Hiromi Inada et al.
5.3. Single-Atom Observation The intensities of electrons elastically scattered from 2-nm-thick carbon and from thorium single atoms were calculated by Nomura. The acceleration voltage was assumed to be 100 kV, and the electron beam spot size was assumed to be 0.3 nm. Figure 20 shows the relationship between the intensities of the scattered electrons and the scattering angle. It shows that electrons scattered from a thorium atom are distributed at a higher angle than carbon atoms and that their intensity is higher even at a scattering angle of 150 mrad or higher. DF imaging using CTEM, which uses a narrower range of scattering angles (less than 10 or at most 30 mrad), cannot achieve efficient detection. DF-STEM imaging with an ADF detector (which covers from 20–200 mrad) can drastically improve detection efficiency. The calculated relationship between atom image contrast and electron probe diameter is plotted for three probe sizes in Figure 21. Image contrast is defined as Iz/Ic, where Ic is the signal intensity from the carbon atoms supporting the thin film, and Iz is the signal intensity from the summation of a single atom and its supporting carbon. Taking the statistical variation in the number of carbon atoms in the supporting film into consideration, we can observe a single atom if the image contrast is higher than 1.5 (broken line). The smaller the probe diameter, the higher the image contrast. In reality, a signal intensity of 10–12 A or more is needed to obtain images with a better signal to noise ratio (SNR). If the ratio of detected
(I/I0)
Scattered electrons intensities
0.20
0.15
A thorium atom
0.10
0.05
Carbon film
(15 C atoms)
0 0
50
100 (mrad.) Scattered angle
150
FIGURE 20 Intensity angular distribution of scattered electrons (calculated by Nomura).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
145
4.0
3.0 Contrast
ize
es
b Pro
2.0
5Å 10Å
1.0
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Atomic number
FIGURE 21
Atom observation contrast dependence on probe size (calculation). 100 I0=1 ⫻ 10−10A 100 kV
(Å) 10
Wgun W
5
106
FE gun
1
F E
LaB6 LaB6gun
Electorn probe diameter
50
108 107 (A/cm2.sr.) Brightness
109
FIGURE 22 Relationship between probe size and brightness of electron gun for 1 1010 A probe current.
electrons scattered by a single atom to the incident electrons is 1%, the probe current must be 1010 A or larger. For a probe current of 1010 A, the relationship between probe size and electron gun brightness is as plotted in Figure 22. It shows that an FE gun must have a probe diameter of 0.5 nm or less. Specimen contamination was a serious problem. Magnification must be set to several million times to obtain images of single atoms. The STEM images became increasingly brighter trial by trial and eventually became completely white due to specimen contamination.
146
Hiromi Inada et al.
An anti-contaminator for the TEM was introduced to reduce the residual gas pressure surrounding the specimen, but no significant improvements were obtained. When a crystal lattice image is taken with a TEM, the area of interest is illuminated with an electron beam several micrometers in diameter. The image is recorded on a sheet of film at several hundred thousand times magnification and then magnified even more with an optical enlarger when the image is printed on photographic paper. The final image must be displayed on a CRT in the case of STEM. At several million times magnification, which is necessary for atomic resolution observations, a very small area of interest (several tens of nanometers) is scanned with an extremely fine electron probe. Therefore, specimen contamination in STEM is much worse than in TEM as the size of the target area is smaller by a magnitude of four. The ultimate answer to this problem was to illuminate an electron beam on the surrounding area of interest (i.e., on a wider raster scan area) at a lower magnification and a higher density for a longer time (20–30 minutes) before observation. This preliminary irradiation thins the contaminants in an area wider than the area of interest, which reduces their effect on the imaging. The effects of this preliminary irradiation last for 10 to 20 minutes. Schematic diagrams of the STEM detecting conditions are shown in Figure 23. Condition A is equivalent to the usual conditions for DF image observation with CTEM using the tilted-beam illumination technique. Condition B1 corresponds to the maximum illumination solid angle with CTEM. Condition B2 corresponds to the large angle (up to 60 mrad) obtainable only with STEM. Photographs of a thin carbon film (2-nm thick) taken under each of these detection conditions are shown in Figure 24. High-contrast spots are almost negligible under condition B2 but they still remain under condition B1. These results suggest that high-contrast spots in carbon film images are due to the interference of scattered electron waves and that they can be removed only by increasing the detector solid angle to 60 mrad. (A)
(B1)
9mrad
9mrad 9mrad
18mrad
(B2) 9mrad 60 mrad
9mrad 9 mrad 18mrad
FIGURE 23
Schematic diagrams of STEM detecting conditions.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
(A)
(B1)
147
(B2)
10 nm
FIGURE 24 Dark-field images of carbon film (2-nm thick) captured under respective detection conditions of Figure 23.
5 nm
FIGURE 25
Dark-field image of carbon film approximately 2-nm thick.
The DF image of carbon obtained under condition B2, in which only the thickness contrast is observed, is shown in Figure 25. A droplet of thorium nitrate in 105 molar CH3OH solution was placed on this film. The image was observed using STEM. As shown in Figure 26, bright spots and spot clusters were observed. The individual bright spots were nearly the same size as the spots making up the spot clusters. Single atoms of thorium made those spots (Todokoro, Nomura, and Komoda, 1977).
5.4. Development of the Electron Energy-Loss Spectrometer In the 1970s, electron probe microanalyzers were used to analyze the elements in small targets. However, they were unable to detect Na or lighter elements (C, O, N, etc.), and characteristic X-ray signals from light elements could not be detected. The efficiency of signal acquisition is defined as detected signal intensity divided by illuminating electron
148
Hiromi Inada et al.
5 nm
FIGURE 26
Dark-field image of thorium atoms on carbon film.
intensity. The amount of detected characteristic X-ray signals is limited by the fluorescence yield and the detector solid angle. With EELS, the inelastic scattering electrons that cause inner shell excitations are distributed over a smaller scattering angle and are directly detected by the spectrometer. EELS was thus expected to be suitable for atomic resolution analysis because of its highly efficient signal acquisition and unlimited ability to detect lighter elements. In 1976 Nomura and Todokoro developed an EELS that could be attached to an FE-STEM. It was a magnetic sector type with a trajectory radius of 11 cm. The target energy resolution was 0.5 eV at 50 kV. The detection system was the serial type, composed of a slit, a scintillator, and a photo-multiplying tube. The energy-loss spectra were recorded with a chart recorder. A photograph of the prototype EELS mounted under the FE-STEM column is shown in Figure 27. Although EELS research was well under way, this attachment of an EELS to an FE-STEM was one of the earliest, and the fundamentals of the analytical STEM concept were established by this work. Figure 28 shows the analytical energy-loss spectrum results for boron nitride particles with a diameter of 20 nm supported on thin carbon film. Figure 28a shows an STEM image taken when electrons without energy loss were used; it is a ‘‘no-loss image.’’ Figure 28b shows an energy-filtered STEM image taken when electrons with an energy loss of 190–210 eV were used. This loss corresponds to the energy loss of boron K-shell excitation. Figure 28c shows line analysis of 190–210 eV. Figure 28d shows the electron energy-loss spectrum taken when the electron probe was focused on a boron nitride particle. The K-shell excitation edges of boron (B), nitrogen (N), and carbon (C) from the supporting film are evident in the spectrum.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 27
149
Developed EELS equipped with STEM.
Estimating that the probe diameter was 1 nm and that the diameter of the boron nitride was 20 nm, Nomura concluded that 7 1021 g of boron and 9 1021 g of nitrogen were detected.
5.5. Further Development of 50-kV CFE-STEM Many research institutes and laboratories with electron microscopes attempted to duplicate Crewe’s observation of single atoms, but only HCRL was able to do so, using the FE-STEM developed by Komoda, Nomura, and Todokoro. This prototype STEM was equipped with the most advanced technologies at that time, such as a CFEG, producing a UHV, a highly stable electronic power supply, and electron optics with atomic resolution performance. Moreover, this FE-STEM had the Hitachi-made EELS and a nondispersive X-ray detector and thus was the origin of the present analytical STEM concept. HCRL contributed to the development of the most advanced technologies for electron microscopes, and Hitachi’s Naka Works was
150
Hiromi Inada et al.
(d)
(a)
⫻1000
Relative intensity
B,K
(b)
200Å
⫻100 C,K
N,K
⫻10
(c) 0
300 Energy loss (eV)
600
FIGURE 28 Analytical results of boron nitride using EELS. (a) d ¼ 0 eV, no-loss image. (b) d ¼ 190–210 eV, energy-filtered image. (c) Line analysis of d ¼ 190–210 eV. (d) Energy loss spectrum.
responsible for commercializing and producing them. Commercialization of a dedicated FE-STEM based on this concept was suspended after many discussions and meetings because the market was mostly demanding TEMs at that time.
6. HITACHI’S FIRST COMMERCIALIZED DEDICATED STEM (BY TAKAHITO HASHIMOTO) 6.1. 200-kV Analytical CFE-TEM, HF-2000 During the 1970s, Tonomura and his group at HCRL were competing to achieve the best TEM image resolution. They expected a breakthrough when they applied electron holography to a TEM. The spherical aberration of the TEM objective lens determines the image resolution, and electron holography is an imaging method that does not suffer the effects
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
151
of spherical aberration because it does not use a lens. They also developed an electron gun with high brightness, which is essential for obtaining high-quality holograms. The FE-TEM they developed in 1978 is shown in Figure 29. The result was improved TEM image resolution. They obtained the highest image resolution ever obtained until then: lattice fringes of Ni (220) with half spacing (0.062 nm). Using electron holography, Tonomura’s group investigated spherical aberration correction for high-resolution imaging (Tonomura et al., 1979a), observed magnetic domains (Tonomura, et al., 1980), observed magnetic fields (Matsuda et al., 1982), and investigated magnetization of recording media (Osakabe et al., 1983). Using phase-shift amplified-interference electron microscopy, they measured the thickness of the recording media (Endo et al., 1984). In 1986, they used electron holography to confirm the existence of the Aharonov–Bohm effect (Osakabe et al., 1986; Tonomura et al., 1986).
FIGURE 29
FE-TEM developed by Hitachi CRL.
152
Hiromi Inada et al.
Work on high-voltage FEG technologies was transferred to Hitachi’s Naka Works. In 1983 Hitachi delivered a custom-made 100-kV analytical FE-TEM (model H-600FE) (Kamino and Tomita, 1983). It had outstanding analytical performance, especially in terms of spatial resolution. Electron probes with a diameter of 5 nm or less were available. Their probe current for EDX or EELS analysis was 10 times larger than the LaB6 gun model, and the illumination angle for nano-probe electron diffraction was one-tenth that of the LaB6 gun model. Advancement in the performance of commercial 200-kV TEMs began to slow in the early 1980s because their resolution had almost reached the theoretical limit. The makers of 200-kV TEMs were in a dead heat. One approach to further improvement was to increase the acceleration voltage. From 1984 to 1986, JEOL Ltd. released a series of 400-kV TEMs (the JEM-4000 series). In 1986 Hitachi released a 300-kV TEM (model H-9000). The TEM competitors were still in a dead heat. Hitachi’s engineers decided to develop a new model with something so special that competitors would not be able to catch up. The key technology for the hoped-for breakthrough was the field emission gun (FEG). With the aim of enabling new applications of electron holography and practical nanoanalysis, Hitachi launched a project to develop a new model. Two researchers, M. Ichihashi and H. Murakoshi, moved from HCRL to Naka Works to work on developing a mass-production 200-kV FEG. The result was the development of a 200-kV FE-TEM (model HF-2000) (Isakozawa et al., 1989). This model, shown in Figure 30, was an epochmaking instrument in electron microscopy. Its nano-probe illumination performance with enough (several hundred nanoamperes) beam current, smaller (<0.4 eV) energy spread, and better beam coherency enabled many applications that were previously impossible. Many universities, research institutes, and laboratories used this model to analyze precipitates in steel (Hashimoto et al., 1991), the concentration of elements on stacking faults (Kamino et al., 1992), the metal particles on catalysts, the electronic states of semiconductors, and the stoichiometry of insulator oxides. In addition to Tonomura’s group, D. Joy, L. Allard and E. Vo¨lkl made extensive holographic studies of ferroelectric domain walls (Zhang et al., 1993; Vo¨lkl et al., 1999), p-n junctions, and semiconductor device dopant profiles. Steeds at Bristol University obtained the first convergentbeam–coherent electron diffraction pattern (Vine et al., 1992). In 1992 the first 300-kV FE-TEM (Murakoshi, Ichihashi, and Kakibayashi, 1992) was developed by researchers at HCRL. Technologies developed for the prototype were transferred to the production model (HF-3000) (Figure 31). Philips introduced an FE-TEM in 1990 (the CM-20 FEG), and JEOL released a new FE-TEM in 1992 (the JEM-2010 F). Both models were equipped with a Schottky emission gun (SEG). Most of Hitachi’s TEMs
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 30 200-kV FE-TEM (HF-2000).
FIGURE 31
300-kV FE-TEM (HF-3000).
153
154
Hiromi Inada et al.
used a high-angle takeoff EDX geometry with a takeoff angle of 68 and a detection solid angle of 0.033 sr. Competitors used a lower-angle takeoff geometry (20–25 ) and a solid angle of 0.13 sr. The higher the takeoff angle, the better the reproducibility of the EDX analysis results. The higher the takeoff angle, the shorter the X-ray path length in the specimen, resulting in reduced absorption in the specimen, especially for characteristic X-rays from light elements such as oxygen. This characteristic enables flexible positioning and orientation of the specimen, which ensures highly reproducible analysis. Although the probe current of the FEG is several times higher than that of the SEG, the analytical sensitivity of the total system was only half that of competitive models because the detection solid angle was one-quarter that of theirs. The HF-2000 thus started losing competitiveness. STEM performance was another weak point. An objective lens using a high-angle takeoff geometry must have a larger upper polepiece bore to enable the X-ray signal to pass through. Therefore, its prefield lens is relatively weaker. The guaranteed smallest probe size of the HF-2000 was a diameter of 1 nm. This was small enough for EDX analysis and STEM observation with a maximum magnification of several hundred thousand times but was too large to obtain atomic-resolution STEM images.
6.2. ‘‘Gate Viewer,’’ Trigger for Dedicated STEM The weakness of the HF-2000 led Hitachi to start developing a new model. Initially, the project leader, Isakozawa, planned to create a ‘‘super FE-TEM.’’ It would have the largest detection solid angle among all commercial TEM models and atomic-resolution STEM capability. In the mid-1990s, the design rule for semiconductor research and development was 250 to 180 nm. FE-SEMs were widely used for confirming process validity and identifying the causes of failures and defects. SEMs were used by individuals such as device researchers, materials scientists, and electronics engineers. Most FE-SEMs in those days already had sufficient resolution (less than several nanometers) even at an acceleration voltage of 1 kV or lower and had an autofocusing function. Specimens were prepared relatively easily with cleaving silicon tips. Semiconductor companies, of course, had TEMs. TEM image resolution had already reached the sub-nanometer range, but specimen preparation, instrument operation, and image interpretation were very difficult compared with those of SEMs. In many cases, only handfuls of ‘‘expert operators’’ were allowed to use TEMs, and the time required to obtain investigation results could range from several days to a full week. This was too slow for the decisionmaking stage for establishing the process for next-generation devices. The manager of Hitachi’s Marketing Division, M. Kato, suggested to the design team that the semiconductor industry wanted electron microscopes with TEM-like image resolution and SEM-like ease of use. He knew that
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
155
such an instrument would have to be newly developed and he called it ‘‘Gate Viewer.’’ The thickness of the gate oxide layer in large-scale integrated circuits was already only several tens of nanometers and would reach 2 nm by 2000 (Committee of Semiconductor Technology, 1999). To measure a scale of 2 nm, the image resolution must be better than one-tenth the scale: 0.2 nm. Due to the strong edge effect, SEs from the substrate and gate electrode make it impossible to observe the gate oxide layer, even if a small probe were achieved. Only a TEM or an FE-STEM could achieve such a small resolution. Compared with TEMs, STEMs are advantageous in terms of the precision of the magnification setting because the number of components that need tuning is smaller. Precise magnification enables accurate measurement of the dimensions in images. Hitachi had accumulated experience in critical dimension (CD)-measurement SEMs, and even general-purpose FE-SEMs had a CD-measurement function in those days. For STEMs, the preparation of a thin specimen seemed to be the bottleneck, as it was for TEMs, but the focused ion beam (FIB) instrument (model FB-2000) that had become prevalent enabled fabrication of thin specimens with a specific area and a specific thickness without exceptional skill (Ishitani et al., 1994). A dedicated FE-STEM has the potential to be such an instrument, fulfilling the concept of the Gate Viewer, and so it was chosen as the basis of the new model. Development of the Gate Viewer FE-STEM (model HD-2000) began in the fall of 1995. It featured several advantages: (i) atomic-resolution imaging, (ii) the highest EDX sensitivity, (iii) multisignal reception from specimen, (iv) an FIB-compatible specimen holder, and (v) easy operation. Figure 32 shows the configuration of the HD-2000. The FEG was basically the same as that of the HF-2000, and several improvements and modifications to the microscope had increased reliability and productivity. The illumination lens system, composed of double-stage condenser lenses and an objective lens, was newly designed. A condenser-objective objective lens with a small spherical aberration coefficient was used so that a 0.2-nm or smaller probe could be used and that an EDX detector with the largest detection solid angle among all TEM models could be accommodated. For seamless operation with lower magnification, a scan coil with a larger inner diameter was used. A projector lens was used to select the detection angle for BF-STEM and DF-STEM. An Everhart– Thornley SE detector, a BF-STEM detector, and a DF-STEM detector were included in the standard configuration. There were several auxiliary ports for mounting a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera to be used for observing electron diffraction patterns and ronchigrams and for mounting an EELS on the lower column. The high-resolution FE-SEM in late ’90s was controlled with a scan generator, an image processor, and a personal computer. A scan generator with a low electrical noise level was initially used. As with an SEM,
156
Hiromi Inada et al.
FE-gun
Condenser lens
SE detector EDX detector*
Scan coil
Objective lens
Specimen
Scattered electron
Display
Projector lens DF-STEM detector
Retractabl Retractabl
Image sensor*
(CCD camera) BF-STEM detector
Transmission electron
SEM
DF-STEM
Scan generator Signal processor Control unit EDX analyzer
FIGURE 32 Configuration of Gate Viewer FE-STEM (HD-2000) (with optional EDX and charge-coupled device (CCD) camera).
higher magnification was achieved by reducing the amplitude of the scan coil current. However, this resulted in electrical noise. Pinstripe patterns, which the engineers thought were the very first BF-STEM lattice fringes, were caused by the electrical noise. The fringe spacing remained constant when the magnification was changed from 2 to 5 million times. A steady step-by-step improvement process was necessary to obtain actual lattice fringes. At the earliest stage of development, the prototype had a TEM lower column and a CCD camera for observing the spot size and directly setting the illumination angle. A ‘‘diffraction-limited’’ probe (Spence and Zuo, 1992) can be formed by demagnifying the electron source image. The optimum convergence angle, aOpt, for obtaining the smallest probe, dmin, is calculated from only the spherical aberration coefficient and electron wavelength (l), as shown in Eqs. (4.2) and (4.3) (Crewe, 1985).
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
aOpt ¼
4l Cs
157
1=4 (4.2)
d min ¼ 0:43Cs1=4 l3=4
(4.3)
Figure 33 shows a TEM image of the smallest probe taken with an experimental TEM column in which the HD-2000 objective lens pole piece had been installed. The line profile of Figure 33 is shown in Figure 34. Measured probe
0.42 nm
FIGURE 33 Smallest measured probe.
Intensity (a.u.)
12
8 0.17 nm FWHM 4
0 −0.6
−0.4
FIGURE 34
−0.2 0.0 0.2 Distance (nm)
Line profile of Figure 33.
0.4
0.6
158
Hiromi Inada et al.
HD-2000 200 kV x 5000 k TE
FIGURE 35
6.00 nm
A BF-STEM image of thin single-crystal Au film taken with HD-2000.
The simulated full-width at half maximum (FWHM) with Cs ¼ 1.3 mm and the l at 200 kV ¼ 0.00251 nm was 0.17 nm, which is in good agreement with the theoretical value of 0.16 nm. Figure 35 shows an example of a BF-STEM image of thin single-crystal Au film. The smaller the probe, the smaller the probe current. A probe current of several tens of picoamperes (pA) is sufficient for STEM and SEM imaging. The smallest probe was achieved with this amount of probe current. For practical EDX analysis, a probe current of several hundreds of pA is necessary. Several illumination modes had to be fixed. The illumination modes were designed to have a constant illumination angle, aOpt, and a variable spot size and probe current. When the illumination angle is kept constant, probe size d can be approximately calculated using Eq. (4), 1 is the magnification of the where ds is the electron source size and M electron source image on the specimen. The contribution of chromatic aberration is negligible. sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2 1 2 (4.4) ds d ffi dmin þ M A virtual source image is strongly demagnified in high-resolution mode, but the number of emitted electrons passing through the objective aperture is limited. In emissive mode, the virtual source image is moderately demagnified, and a larger number of electrons pass through the
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
159
Virtual source
C1 cross over
C1 lens C1 cross over C2 lens OBJ.AP. C2 cross over
OBJ lens Specimen Emissive mode
FIGURE 36
High resolution mode
Illumination modes. (Left) Emissive mode. (Right) High-resolution mode.
objective aperture (OBJ. A.P.). Figure 36 illustrates the differences in the ray diagrams for illumination modes. If the illumination angle at the specimen is kept constant, the typical probe size and probe current are f0.2 nm and 20 pA for high-resolution mode and f0.5 nm and 200 pA for emissive mode. Figure 37 shows a comparison of images formed with various detector signals. The specimen was a silicon device (a hemispherical grained capacitor test element group [TEG]) with a layer structure: SiO2 base layer, thick poly-Si layer with 100-nmf hemispherical bumps on the top side surface, thin Si3N4 layer, amorphous Si layer, and SiO2 top layer. The SEM image in Figure 37a shows the surface of a sectioned specimen. The BF-STEM image (37b) and DF-STEM image (37c) show cross-sectional views. The BF-STEM image is equivalent to a TEM image because of the reciprocal relationship between BF-STEM and TEM. A strong diffraction contrast is evident in the poly-Si layer. This characteristic can be used to distinguish crystalline areas or even crystal grains, but it can also make it difficult to interpret what is seen in the image. The DF-STEM uses scattered electrons, a larger atomic number (Z), a heavier density (r), or greater thickness (t). The diffraction contrast is averaged and moderated because a DF-STEM detector acquires all related diffracted waves. Especially with a larger scattering angle, the atomic number is the dominant factor affecting the contrast, so a DF-STEM image is often called a ‘‘Z-contrast image.’’ In image 37c, the substance with the largest density is
160
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b) SiN
a-Si
Poly-Si SiO2
100 nm (c) SiN
(semi-spherical grained capacitor TEG)
a-Si
Poly-Si SiO2
FIGURE 37 Images of Si device. (a) SEM, (b) BF-STEM, and (c) DF-STEM.
Si3N4 and the smallest is SiO2. The Si3N4 layer covering the poly-Si bumps is clearly evident. The amorphous and poly-Si layers have a similar contrast. Therefore, we can obtain much information about a specimen from SEM and STEM images. A. Ninomiya, an industrial designer in the Hitachi Design Division, drew a conceptual image of the HD-2000. He took into account that higher-resolution electron microscopes are generally installed in a quiet room on a stable floor in a small stray magnetic field without acoustic noise. These conditions are completely different from those of a clean room used for semiconductor fabrication; these rooms have a continuous downflow, noise from air conditioners and suction pumps, floor vibration with a frequency close to the resonance frequency of the HD-2000 with antivibration mounts, and so on. He thus designed the electron gun and microscope column to be covered with a permalloy shield and the EDX detector, evacuation pipes, and cables to be contained in an enclosure. As shown in Figure 38, the HD-2000 had a clean and photogenic appearance. In fact, it won the Good Design Award from the Japan Industrial Design Promotion Organization in 1998. The HD-2000 was released in 1998 (Hashimoto et al., 1998). A production model was exhibited at the 50th annual meeting of the Japanese Society of Microscopy. Installation was done over a weekend, and the machine was in operation during the entire exhibition period, displaying BF-STEM images of evaporated Au particle lattice fringes.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
FIGURE 38
161
Photograph of Gate Viewer FE-STEM (HD-2000).
6.3. Novel Functions for HD Series 6.3.1. Energy-Dispersive X-Ray An EDX detector with a solid angle of 0.3 sr was designed by S. Foote of Noran Instruments (now Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc.) soon after the objective lens design was completed. Achieving the highest EDX sensitivity is an extremely important development objective. This solid angle was 2.5 times larger than those of competitors and the largest among all commercial electron microscopes. The shielding parts were redesigned to eliminate iron and cobalt system peaks from the objective lens pole piece. The original shielding parts could stop only scattered electrons, not bremsstrahlung X-rays. Subsequently, several models of EDX systems (e.g., EDAX, Horiba, and Oxford systems) were released.
6.3.2. Diffraction The diffraction capabilities of FE-TEMs were emphasized as an advantage by the various competitors. Diffraction patterns can also be observed with a dedicated STEM. With a condenser-objective objective lens, a diffraction pattern is formed on the back focal plane and projected onto STEM detectors, as shown in Figure 39. In standard STEM observation or
162
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b) Incident beam Specimen Objective lens <= B.F.P. (diffraction pattern)
Transmission electron Simplified TEM
Actual TEM (d)
(c) Incident beam
(e) Objective lens pre-field
Objective lens Specimen
Objective lens post-field
Transmission electron
CBED pattern
Simplified STEM Actual STEM
FIGURE 39
Reduced convergence angle
BF-STEM CCD camera detector STEM nano diff. mode
Diffraction patterns formed in TEMs and STEMs.
analytical mode, the convergence angle is set to achieve the smallest possible probe size for a given probe current. Figure 40 shows the calculated relationship between the probe size and convergence angle of an electron beam for a constant probe current of 200 pA. The Cs of the objective lens was 1.3 mm, and l at 200 kV was 0.00251 nm. The probe size was calculated using the root mean square method with quadrature addition of the image size of the electron source on the specimen, the size of the disk of confusion by diffraction, and the spherical aberration. Figure 40 shows that the optimum convergence angle for the smallest probe at a probe current of 200 pA was 8 mrad. The diffraction pattern under this setting was the convergentbeam electron-diffraction pattern, as shown in Figure 41a. When the mode is ‘‘nano-diffraction’’ with a convergence angle of 1.5 mrad, the probe is larger than in the standard STEM mode. Nevertheless, the probe is still operational up to several hundred kX of magnification, and a diffraction pattern with mostly parallel illumination can be observed. Figure 41b shows the diffraction pattern for Au thin film with the nanodiffraction mode. This mode is set by changing the lens current while
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
163
Probe size (nm)
1.0E + 01
1.0E + 00
1.0E - 01
1.0E - 02 0.1
Diffraction Spheerical aberr. e- source image RMS
1 10 Convergence angle (mrad)
100
FIGURE 40 Convergence angle and probe size.
(a)
(b)
Standard STEM (emissive)
Nano diffraction mode
FIGURE 41 Comparison of diffraction patterns from Au film [001]. (a) standard STEM (emissive) mode with a 7 mrad; (b) nano-diffraction mode with a 2 mrad.
keeping the specimen height and objective aperture fixed. First, the probe is raster-scanned to determine the field of view. Then, the probe is placed at the point of interest on the image, and an electron diffraction pattern is obtained with the CCD camera mounted at the bottom of the column. Figure 42 shows an example DF-STEM image of a dynamic random access memory (DRAM) and diffraction patterns from several points of the image with nano-diffraction mode.
164
Hiromi Inada et al.
Si crystal grain
ONO layer
Insulator Capacitor
Substrate HD 2000 200 kv ⫻ 60.Dk ZC
500 nm
DF-STEM image
Insulator (amorphous SiO2)
Substrate (Si single crystal)
FIGURE 42 DF-STEM image of Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) and diffraction patterns for nano-diffraction mode.
6.3.3. HD-2300 SEG and Auto Functions The HD-2300 was released in 2003. It was equipped with a 200-kV SEG developed by S. Watanabe. If the brightness of electron guns is compared with the speed of a runner, the FEG is a sprinter and the SEG is a marathoner. The SEG is stable 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 52 weeks a year during the lifetime of its zirconium-oxide–coated tungsten cathode. The FEG model (HD-2300C) was produced for performance-oriented customers. Automated focus adjustment and astigmatism-correction functions (Inada et al., 2004) were also developed for this model. These functions were generally very useful to a majority of users, though setting the optimum defocus amount for high-resolution STEM observation at several million times magnification was beyond its capability. Most observations were done at magnifications from 500,000 to 1,000,000 times. This range was
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
165
too high for an FE-SEM operated at a lower acceleration voltage but was within the coverage of the functions. Magnification calibration function for the STEM was developed, because semiconductor manufacturers needed high accuracy device size measurement and nanotechnology features ranging from a few nm to tens of nm in size (Inada et al., 2005). By using the combined technique of micro scale, metrology standard silicon grating specimen and silicon single crystal thin film, the microscope enables to provide the absolute magnification error of less than 2% for all magnification range for the STEM. These features (stable higher performance and easier operation) matched the needs of the semiconductor industry.
7. CUTTING-EDGE APPLICATIONS WITH CUSTOMIZED HD MODELS (BY TOSHIE YAGUCHI) 7.1. 120-kV FE UHV for Nanotubes For element-selective single-atom imaging, K. Suenaga et al. developed the HD-2000 UHV 120-kV CFEG-STEM equipped with an EELS in 2003. With its newly developed magnetic lens and the EELS, it had improved spatial resolution and sensitivity, enabling to identify individual atoms. They used this system with spectrum imaging to identify elements. They also detected a single gadolinium (Gd) atom in a carbon (C) nanohorn (Hashimoto et al., 2004). Figures 43a and b show a BF-STEM image and the corresponding elemental map of Gd and C, respectively. Elemental maps were created from electron energy-loss spectra recorded at 150 eV (Gd-N edge) and 300 eV (CK edge) with 0.5-nm spatial resolution. The numbers in Figure 43b denote the number of Gd atoms, which was determined using the integrated EELS intensity normalized by the inelastic cross section. The map clearly reveals a single Gd atom at the tip of the single-wall carbon nanohorn. This was a pioneering study that identified individual atoms in nanostructures.
7.2. 200-kV FE Ultrahigh-Resolution STEM K. Kimoto et al. (2007a) developed a high-resolution dedicated STEM with high stability for acquisition of distortion-free STEM images and high SNR analysis in 2006. It was developed based on a 200-kV commercial instrument (the HD-2300 FE-STEM) to which many modifications were made. A narrow-gap objective lens was used. Two postspecimen lenses were used to control the detection angles for the BF and ADF detectors. The SEG was replaced with a CFEG, which had a narrow energy spread of sub-0.5 eV (Kimoto and Matsui, 2002; Kimoto et al., 2005). A narrow energy spread is
166
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
5 nm (b)
2 1
2
1
FIGURE 43 BF-STEM image of (a) gadolinium with single-wall carbon nanohorn and (b) corresponding chemical map for Gd (yellow) and C (red). (The number labels in the picture (b) indicate the number of Gd atoms.) (Courtesy of Dr. K. Suenaga, AIST.)
advantageous for analyzing the fine structure of electron energy-loss spectra. To prevent thermal drift, a shield box was placed over the high-voltage generator. A heavy metallic cover was used for the specimen stage to reduce acoustic vibration. The column was covered with rubber sheets to reduce temperature fluctuation (Muller and Grazul, 2001). The microscope was installed in a room of an anti-seismic building at the National Institute for Materials Science. Temperature fluctuations in the room were within 0.2 C/hr. The stray magnetic field in the room was less than 0.2 mG near the STEM column. Noisy apparatuses were placed in a separate room. Figure 44 shows the STEM image drifts measured during a period of 61 minutes. The average drift speed was 0.12 nm/min. Due to the high stability, the atomic columns in the ADF images could be observed. Moreover, a single europium (Eu) dopant atom in b-SiAlON phosphor and small atomic displacement of 10 pm were directly observed (Kimoto et al., 2009; Saito et al., 2009). Many sets of images were sequentially acquired with drift correction using a digital beam control unit (DigiScan, Gatan) and averaged using
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
167
60 −4
50
30
Position (nm)
−3
40
20 −2 10
−1
0 0 (start) −1
0
1 2 Position (nm)
3
FIGURE 44 Measured STEM image drift during 61-minute observation. Numbers in graph denote elapsed time in minutes.
Si
1 nm
Eu
FIGURE 45 ADF STEM image of b-SiAlON:Eu2þ. The upper inset in the solid-line rectangle shows single-scanning image obtained in conventional manner, resulting in severe quantum noise. The lower inset in dotted rectangle shows simulation result. White arrows show Eu atom positions.
168
Hiromi Inada et al.
image acquisition and analysis software (DigitalMicrograph, Gatan). Final images were obtained with a high SNR. The ADF image revealed Eu dopant in the continuous atomic channel in a b – Si3N4, as shown in Figure 45. Using the STEM with EELS and localized inelastic scattering, Kimoto et al. (2007b) performed two-dimensional elemental analysis with atomiccolumn resolution for the first time. Figure 46 shows an example result. An atomic column of La, Mn, and O in layered manganite (La1.2Sr1.8Mn2O7) was visualized two-dimensionally. (a)
(b)
(c)
0.5 nm
La, Sr Mn O
(d)
(e)
5.2/9.2
(f)
1.2/13.0
3.5/10.2
FIGURE 46 Atomic-column imaging using STEM and EELS. (a) Enlarged ADF image of analyzed area overlapped with crystal structure. (b) Calculated incident probe shape for EELS and ADF observations. (c)–(f) Core-loss images of La-N4,5, O-K, Mn-L3,2, and La-M5,4. Colored circles in (c)–(f) indicate the corresponding positions of atomic columns. (Courtesy of Dr. K. Kimoto, NIMS.)
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
169
7.3. 3D Structural and Elemental Analysis Submicrometer-resolution three-dimensional (3D) structural analysis is becoming increasingly indispensable for structural evaluation and failure analysis as devices become more integrated and smaller. To meet this need, 3D characterization techniques have been developed that use an FIB system in combination with an STEM and TEM. In this approach, a specially designed FIB-STEM–compatible specimen-rotation holder is used from initial specimen preparation through final STEM characterization. The specimen is milled to a pillar shape and mounted on the tip of a needle stub loaded in the rotation mechanism of the specimen holder. Typical specimen dimensions for 3D structural and elemental analyses are less than 200 nm in diameter and 5–10 m in length. The specimen holder enables 360 rotation and 20 tilt even in an instrument with a narrow-gap, high-resolution pole piece (Kamino et al., 2004). Since the specimen can be rotated a complete 360 , the incident electron beam, detectors, and spectrometers can view it without obstruction over the full rotation range. This enables multidirectional observation of the specimen. In addition, a complete set of images can be taken. Using this stack of images, nanometer-scale tomograms without missing zone can be reconstructed. EDX analysis has been used for 3D elemental distribution analysis. Since the specimen had a pillar shape, the projected specimen shape remained identical at any rotation angle; consequently, the tilt series of observations and analyses were not affected by differences in shape and thickness. The limited signals of X-ray maps have been enhanced by principal component analysis (PCA) (Watanabe and Williams, 2004) in combination with X-ray spectrum image acquisition. Application of PCA enhances the weak signals in elemental distribution maps acquired in an extremely short time. Therefore, elemental distributions can be acquired for even shorter acquisition times, thereby reducing the total acquisition time for a complete tilt-series measurement (Yaguchi et al., 2008). Nevertheless, it took more than 12 hours for complete acquisition of a tilt series of X-ray maps. Figure 47 shows the 3D-reconstructed Ti (image a) and As (image b) distribution around a tungsten contact plug in a Si semiconductor device from 37 Ti-K edge maps at rotation angles between 0 and 180 with 5 steps. Note that the As dopant distribution, which is critical for semiconductor performance, was obtained three-dimensionally for the first time. EELS was also applied as another method. The elemental mapping was performed with a STEM using a real-time EELS imaging system consisting of a three-window energy filter mounted beneath the STEM detectors. This unique EELS imaging system originally had a two-window energy filter when it was developed in 2000 (Kaji et al., 2001). It was modified to have a three-window energy filter in 2008. Since electrons in
170
Hiromi Inada et al.
(a)
(b)
50 nm
50 nm
FIGURE 47 3D-reconstructed (a) Ti and (b) As distributions around tungsten contact plug. They were obtained from a tilt series of 37 Ti K and As K maps over a tilt range of 0–180 with a 5 step. Simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique was used for 3D reconstruction. (Reproduced with permission of Yaguchi, 2008.)
the three energy-loss ranges are collected simultaneously, a real-time energy-filtered elemental map can be obtained in a shorter time with the modified system.
8. ABERRATION-CORRECTED CFE-STEM (BY KUNIYASU NAKAMURA) The 16th International Microscopy Congress was held in Sapporo in September 2006. Emperor Akihito and Empress Michiko were special guests at the conference. Hitachi High-Technologies (HHT) Corp. exhibited an HD-2700 Cs-corrected STEM. Before the president of HHT introduced the exhibited instruments, he congratulated the royal couple on the birth of their first grandson, Prince Hisahito, who was born that morning. The HD-2700 performed well during the five-day exhibition, demonstrat˚ ngstrom image resolution. The combination of atomic resoluing sub-A tion and analytical probe current had been realized.
8.1. Atomic-Level Characterization Instrument The HD-2700 is a second-generation, commercial-dedicated STEM and is a promising successor to the HD-2000 and HD-2300. It supports both a CFEG and an SEG electron source. The CFEG is suitable for high-end research work, such as atomic-resolution imaging with EELS/EDS analysis. The SEG is better for long-term use, such as device inspection in the semiconductor industry. Its spherical aberration-correcting optics was a joint
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
171
project of CEOS (Heidelberg, Germany) and Hitachi. In addition to this new technology, much effort was devoted to stabilizing the entire system. Theoretically, the factors that limit the performance of a microscope are spherical aberration and chromatic incoherence, including the energy spread of the electron source. Incorporating a spherical aberration corrector and a CFEG is a feasible way to push the instrument to the next limiting criteria. However, performance degradation easily occurs due to zeroth-order aberration, such as instability of the high-tension, lenses and deflectors, specimen vibration due to acoustic waves or a stray magnetic field, drift of the optical conditions and specimen due to thermal instability, and specimen contamination. The highest attainable performance is unobtainable until all zeroth-order aberrations are eliminated. Figure 48 shows the appearance of the HD-2700. The complete covering helps reduce thermal instability and prevents transmission of acoustic waves from the environment. An ion pump is attached close to the specimen, which greatly reduces specimen contamination. The electronics systems for the high-tension, lenses and deflectors is highly advanced. Ultimate performance is obtained with the help of a spherical aberration corrector.
Microscope column with whole cover
Cold-FEG
Condenser aperture Condenser lens
Operating console
Ion pump
Spherical aberration corrector
Objective lens Specimen stage
FIGURE 48 Appearance (left) and several elements inside whole cover (right) of aberration-corrected HD-2700 CFEG-STEM.
172
Hiromi Inada et al.
8.2. Theoretical Consideration of Advantages of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM Aberration correction using a multipole element is a conventional technique for improving the performance of an electron microscope, and there are several advantages of using a corrector (Erni et al., 2009; Nellist et al., 2004). Two types of correctors are commercially available (Haider et al., 1998; Krivanek, Dellby, and Lipini, 1999). However, neither type can correct chromatic aberration in principle. Thus, a CFEG is the best electron source for obtaining the ultimate performance of an aberration-corrected STEM because of its narrow energy spread. For an aberration-corrected system, a wave aberration function that includes all higher-order aberrations should be considered to estimate the attainable resolution. The incoherent broadening effect caused by chromatic aberration (variation of defocus) should also be incorporated. The wave aberration function w(o) is denoted as follows: 1 2 1 1 3 1 4 1þ o 2þ o A1 þ ooC A2 þ o2 oB A3 o wðoÞ ¼ Re 2 2 3 4 1 1 5 2 C3 þ o3 oS 3þ o 2 B4 þ o4 oD 4 A4 þ o3 o þ o2 o 4 5 1 6 1 3 C5 þ o4 o 2 S5 þ o5 oR 5 þ .. A5 þ o3 o þ o (4.5) 6 6 o ¼ l u expði yÞ;
(4.6)
denotes the complex conjugate of o), u is where o is the complex angle (o the spatial frequency, y is the azimuthal angle, and Re represents the real part. The details of all aberration coefficients are available elsewhere (Mu¨ller et al., 2006). The probe intensity profile in real space is given by IðrÞ ¼ cðrÞ cðrÞ (4.7)
2p wðoÞ AðoÞ cðrÞ ¼ FT exp i l
(4.8)
AðoÞ ¼ 1 for o a; AðoÞ ¼ 0 for o > a;
(4.9)
where FT represents Fourier transform operation. For incorporating chromatic aberration, extended defocus C10 is introduced: 0
C1 ¼ C1 þ CC
DE ; E
(4.10)
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
173
where CC is the chromatic aberration coefficient, DE is the variation in electron energy, and E is the primary electron energy. Each wave aberration corresponding to the extended defocus is integrated by weighting the Gaussian distribution of the energy variation. The probe intensity profile is defined again as functions of r and C10 . " # ð 1 ðE DEÞ2 0 0 0 Iðr; C1 Þ ¼ cðr; C1 Þcðr; C1 Þ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi exp dDE (4.11) 2s2 2ps 1 s ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi DE0 ; 2 2 ln 2
(4.12)
where DE0 is defined in terms of the FWHM of the electron source energy spread. Figure 49 shows the calculated d59 criterion probe size (Haider, Uhlemann, and Zach, 2000) at 200 kV for a CFEG (DE0 ¼ 0.3 eV) and an SEG (DE0 ¼ 0.8 eV) as a function of the convergence angle. The residual and intrinsic aberrations listed in Figure 49 are assumed to emulate an actual system. The minimum probe sizes for the CFEG and SEG meet at a convergence angle of 25 mrad. The smallest attainable probe is 0.08 nm ˚ ngstrom for the CFEG and 0.1 nm for the SEG. For a CFEG, the sub-A probe size remains in the range of 20–35 mrad. This is a big advantage of a CFEG. If the axial brightness of the gun is assumed to be the same for a CFEG and the SEG—although a CFEG is brighter than an SEG—a two times larger probe current is available if a CFEG with a 0.1-nm probe is used at 35 mrad compared with that if a SEG with a 0.1-nm probe is used at 25 mrad.
8.3. Evaluation of Aberration-Corrected CFE-STEM 8.3.1. Information Transfer with High-Angle ADF-STEM image Figure 50 shows DF-STEM images of Si (110) single crystals for (image a) uncorrected and (image b) corrected states. The corresponding power spectra are shown in images c and d, respectively. The superimposed images were simulated using an extended multislice method (Nakamura et al., 1997). The well-known dumbbell structure is clearly seen, and the SNR was much improved after correction. For the corrected STEM image, the information limits of 0.083 nm (Si (533)) and 0.078 nm (Si (444)) were transferred in the power spectrum, as predicted from Figure 49. These results confirm that a CFE-STEM with an aberration corrector is now an essential tool that can be used to routinely obtain atomic-resolution images.
174
Hiromi Inada et al.
0.35 ΔEo = 0.3 eV ΔEo = 0.8 eV
d59 probe size (nm)
0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
0
10
Symbol A1 C1 A2 B2 A3 C3 S3 A4 A5 B4,D4,C5, S5, R5 CC
FIGURE 49
20 30 40 50 Convergence angle (mrad) Amplitude 1.04 nm 0 nm 6.66 nm 7.24 nm 525.7 nm −3.23 mm 213.1 nm 8 . 3 1 mm 3.1mm Not included 1.7mm
60
Initial phase(deg) −41.8 30 65 −72 136.2 23.8 0 -
Calculated d59 probe size as a function of convergence angle.
8.3.2. Low-Kilovolt Capability The aberration correction can damage the specimen because the current density of the probe is increased more than tenfold. Such damage could be avoided by reducing the electron dose and electron energy. The imaging capability of the HD-2700 with aberration correction and low-kilovolt operation was theoretically considered and tested. Figure 51 shows the calculated 2D probe profile at 80 kV. The parameters for this calculation are listed in the figure. The profile has a sharp peak at the center and tails caused by residual higher-order aberrations. The estimated resolution as d59 criterion was 0.11 nm. Figure 52 shows a DF-STEM image of an Si (110) single crystal and the corresponding power spectrum at 80-kV operation. The dumbbell structure is clearly evident, and an information limit of 0.105 nm (Si (333))
175
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
(a) (c)
(b) 444
(d)
335 004
0.136 nm
FIGURE 50 DF-STEM images of Si (110) single crystals for (a) uncorrected and (b) corrected states; images (c) and (d) are power spectra corresponding to images (a) and (b), respectively.
6e - 3
Intensity (a.u.)
5e - 3 E ΔE0 C3 C5 A5
4e - 3 3e - 3 2e - 3
: 80 keV : 0.3 eV : 10 m m : 2 mm : 2 mm
1e - 3 0e + 0 −0.5 −0.4 −0.3 −0.2 −0.1 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Distance (nm)
FIGURE 51
Calculated 2D-probe profile at 80 kV and its line profile.
0.4
0.5
176
Hiromi Inada et al.
333
0.136 nm
FIGURE 52 DF-STEM image of Si (110) single crystal and corresponding power spectrum at 80-kV operation.
was transferred. The feasibility of atomic-scale analysis at 80 kV was confirmed by this result.
8.4. Advanced Application Results with HD-2700C The customized HD-2700C CFE-STEM was installed at the Center for Functional Nanomaterials at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) by a group led by Y. Zhu and J. Wall in 2007. This is like a story of transmigration because the HD-2700 is a descendant of the FE-STEM on which Crewe consulted, and it was installed in the laboratory in which works Joe Wall, one of Crewe’s co-researchers on the initial CFE-STEM development in the 1960s. One of the most impressive results obtained with the HD-2700C is described below (Inada et al., 2009; Zhu and Wall, 2008).
8.4.1. Stability of EELS In the Brookhaven system, the critical parts of the high-tension circuit were carefully identified, and an anti-electromagnetic field shield and floor-vibration damping system were attached to the high-tension generator. In addition to these efforts, BNL built a highly stabilized microscope room in the Center for Functional Nanomaterials building, which was completed in 2007. As a result, the fluctuations in high tension were reduced. Figure 53 shows a time chart of the zero-loss peak of 200-keV electrons for a 130-sec duration. The spectra were acquired using a spectrometer (Enfina ER, Gatan), and the energy dispersion was 0.05 eV/channel. This time chart indicates that the stability of the total system was 0.5 ppm for
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
177
(a)
Energy (eV)
0.2 0.1 0 −0.1
0
10
(b) 2.0 ⫻ 104
20
30
40
50
60 70 80 Time (s)
90 100 110 120 130
9.0 mA
9.0 mA
4.0 mA
4.0 mA
2.0 mA 1.0 mA
2.0 mA
1.2 ⫻ 104
1.0 mA
0.4 eV
4 ⫻ 103 0 −1.0
−0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0 1.5 Energy (eV)
2.0
2.5
3.0
FIGURE 53 Time chart of zero-loss peak of 200-keV electrons for 130-sec duration.
long-term acquisition. An energy resolution of 0.30–0.35 eV in terms of FWHM was demonstrated for 10-sec acquisition, and one of 0.4 eV was demonstrated even under typical electron-extraction conditions to get a probe current large enough for spectrum imaging.
8.4.2. Visualization and EELS Analysis of Single Uranium Atom Figure 54 shows (image a) a DF-STEM image of uranium (U) individual atoms and clumps of U on carbon support film, (image b) an image intensity profile along the ‘‘spectrum imaging’’ line showing a single atom profile of 0.08 nm, and (c) the EELS integrated intensity profile at the U-O4,5 edge (96–150 eV) after background subtraction. The probe convergence angle and collection angle into the spectrometer were 28 and 30 mrad, respectively. This result indicates that the corrected CFEG probe was small enough and had sufficient current density to detect single atoms. Although a uranium atom has a strong scattering amplitude and should be an ideal point scatterer, the corrected CFE-STEM has the capability to resolve other single atoms by imaging or spectroscopy.
Hiromi Inada et al.
178
(b) Intensity (arb. unit)
⫻105
(a)
Spectrum imaging
HAADF-STEM
120 0.08 nm
80
40 0
0.2
0.4
2 nm
Survey image
Electron counts (e−)
(c) 1200
0.6 (nm)
0.8
1.0
0.8
1.0
U-O4,5 mapping 0.13 nm
800
400
0
0.2
0.4
0.6 (nm)
FIGURE 54 (a) DF-STEM image of uranium (U) individual atoms and clumps of U on carbon support film. (b) Image intensity profile along ‘‘spectrum imaging’’ line. (c) EELS-integrated intensity profile at U-O4,5 edge after background subtraction.
8.4.3. EELS Spectrum Mapping of Pd/Pt Core Shell Catalyst Figure 55a shows a DF-STEM image of a palladium (Pd) nano-catalyst (core) with a platinum (Pt) shell, images b and c show the electron energy-loss (EEL) spectrum for the particle indicated by the arrow in image a, image d shows a DF-STEM image of a particle, and images e–g show the corresponding spectrum mapping images of the particle of image d for Pd, Pt, and C, respectively. The core-shell structure is clearly distinguished by the elemental mapping images. The most remarkable result is that the distribution of a very small amount of Pt was detected using the PtM4,5 edge, which is the high-energy loss portion, such as 2200 eV. This is a key benefit of an aberration-corrected probe.
8.4.4. EELS Column-by-Column Mapping of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2) Figure 56a shows a DF-STEM image of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2) viewed along the [010] direction; image b shows a survey image showing the area for spectrum mapping and drift compensation; image c shows a DF-STEM image and corresponding elemental maps for Ca, O, and Co, respectively; image d is an overlay of the Ca, O, and Co maps; and image e is the EEL spectrum of the area. The experimental conditions were 64–341 mrad for the DF-STEM collection angle, 0.5 eV/channel for the energy dispersion,
(b)
(a)
(c)
Carbon support
500 400
12
C-k
e−
20 nm
4
100
2 300
400
eV
20370 e− (e)
(d)
6
200
0
Pt−M4,5
8
Pd−M4,5
300
Carbon support
10
500
600
0 2000
3780 e− (f)
2100
2200 eV
2300
2400
64400 e− (g)
5 nm HAADF-STEM
Pd mapping
−2560
Pt mapping
−6390
C mapping
−5198
FIGURE 55 (a) DF-STEM image of palladium (Pd) nano-catalyst with (platinum) Pt shell; (b) and (c) EEL spectra for particle indicated by arrow in image (a); (d) DF-STEM image of the particle; and (e)–(g) corresponding spectrum mapping images of the particle in image (d) for Pd, Pt, and carbon, respectively.
CaO CaO CoO CoO2 CoO2
(a)
(c) Ca
0.5 nm
O
1 nm
(b)
(d)
(e)
Spectrum image
Ca
e− ⫻ 103
30 2.19 ⫻ 2.19 nm
20
Spatial drift
O
10 0 300
1 nm
2 nm
Co
ADF-STEM survey image
Ca
O
400
500
Co
600 eV
700
800
900
Co
FIGURE 56 (a) DF-STEM image of (Ca2CoO3)0.62 (CoO2); (b) survey image for spectrum mapping and drift compensation; (c) DF-STEM image and corresponding elemental maps of calcium (Ca), oxygen (O), and cobalt (Co), respectively; (d) overlay of Ca, O, and Co maps; and (e) EEL spectrum of area.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
181
70 70 pixels for the scanning area at a 0.032-nm pixel distance, and a 0.05sec dwell time for each pixel. The atomic columns of each element are clearly evident in each element map, and the overlaid image reconstructs the elemental atomic columns without arrangement of atomic columns in accordance with corresponding crystal structure shown in Figure 56(a).
8.4.5. Single Atom Imaging Using Secondary Electrons Zhu et al. demonstrated high resolution secondary electron imaging. Figure 57 shows a pair of SEM and DF-STEM images of uranium individual uranium atoms and clumps on a carbon thin film (~2nm). Quantitative intensity analysis of DF-STEM reveals the areas marked by small circles are individual atoms. They have achieved 0.1 nm spatial resolution with SEM detector imaging with aberration-corrected CFE-STEM (Zhu et al., 2009).
9. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE PROSPECTIVE (BY HIROSHI KAKIBAYASHI) Many of Hitachi’s undertakings in developing and manufacturing STEMs were introduced in this chapter. The fusion of TEM technology by Hitachi started before World War II, and the CFE technology introduced by Crewe played an important role in Hitachi’s development of FE-STEMs. These were not fortuities. The very strong enthusiasm of the researchers and designers at Hitachi met the challenge to develop the world’s highest(a)
(b)
2 nm
FIGURE 57 Imaging individual uranium atoms with secondary electrons. Simultaneous acquisition of the SEM image using secondary electrons and back scattered electrons (a) and the DF-STEM image using forward scattered electrons (b), of uranium oxide nanocrystals and individual uranium atoms (raw data).
182
Hiromi Inada et al.
performance STEMs. Their enthusiasm enabled Hitachi to develop various types of STEMs, from the 50-kV STEM in 1975 to the latest HD-2700 dedicated STEM. Along the way, M. Haider and H. Rose developed Cs-correction technology and it was introduced into the HD-2700. The result was elemental and chemical-bonding–state mapping and highresolution STEM image observation at an atomic order. These microscopes contributed to the fine structure analysis of nano-materials, nano-electronic devices, and nano-biomaterials in various fields. CFESTEMs have become an essential analytical tool in many fields. In the future, STEMs will be needed that can feed back atomic-level information by higher throughput for material and device processes. Moreover, it will become necessary to implement simultaneous atomic observation and manipulation under process ambient conditions. This means that STEMs will progress from being analytical tools to atomic-controlling instruments. Hitachi will continue to research and develop the ultimate instrument.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Masashi Watanabe of Lehigh University, Kazutomo Suenaga of the National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), and Koji Kimoto of the National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS) for their invaluable advice and support. We also thank Yimei Zhu, Joe Wall, Lijun Wu, and Dong Su of Brookhaven National Laboratory for allowing the use of their invaluable STEM imaging and analysis data. In addition, we acknowledge Maximilian Haider, Peter Hartel, Heiko Mu¨ller, Frank Kahl, and Thomas Riedel for their help in the development of the spherical aberration corrector. We acknowledge and appreciate the advice about historical field emission technologies offered by Shobu Saito, Hideo Todokoro, Mikio Ichihashi, and Masahiro Tomita. Finally, we thank our colleagues at Hitachi High-Technologies Corp., Hidehito Obayashi, Mitsugu Sato, Kazui Mizuno, Takeo Kamino, Yasumitsu Ueki, Mitsuru Konno, Yuya Suzuki, Tadao Furutsu, Kazutoshi Kaji, Satoru Fukuhara, Hisaya Murakoshi, Takeshi Kawasaki, Tetsuya Akashi, Yoshifumi Taniguchi, Koichiro Saito, and Kaname Takahashi for their support and fruitful discussions.
REFERENCES Butler, J. W. (1966). Digital computer techniques in electron microscopy. 6th Int. Cong. for Electron Microscopy (Kyoto) 1, 191. Committee of Semiconductor Technology Roadmap of Japan (1999). STRJ Report 1999. Japan Electronics and Information Technology Industries Association. Crewe, A. V. (1964). Scanning techniques for high voltage microscope, in Proc. AMU-ANL High Voltage Electron Microscope Mtg. (Argonne National Laboratory), pp. 68–81. Crewe, A. V. (1985). Towards the ultimate scanning electron microscope, in Scanning Electron Microscopy 1985 II. Chicago: SEM Inc., pp. 467–472. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968a). Electron gun using a field emission source. Rev. Sci. Inst. 39, 576–583.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
183
Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1970). Contrast in a high resolution scanning electron microscope. Optik 30, 461–474. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970a). High resolution scanning electron microscopy of nucleic acid salts. Microscopie Electronique (Grenoble) 1, 467–468. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Langmore, J. (1970b). The visibility of single atoms. Science 168, 1338–1340. Crewe, A. V., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968b). A high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscope. J. Appl. Phys. 39, 5861–5868. Dyke, W. P., Trolan, J. K., Dolan, W. W., and Barnes, G. (1953). The field emitter: Fabrication, electron microscopy, and electric field calculations. J. Appl. Phys. 5, 570–576. Eggenberger, D. N., Hart, R. K., and Libal, A. C. (1968). A field emission high voltage gun. Proc. EMSA 26, 330–331. Endo, J., Kawasaki, T., Matsuda, T., Osakabe, N., and Tonomura, A. (1984). Sensitivity improvement in electron holographic interferometry, in Proc. 13th Int’l. Commission for Optics. Sapporo, pp. 480–481. Erni, R., Rossell, M. D., Kisielowski, C., and Dahmen, U. (2009). Atomic-resolution imaging with a sub-50-pm electronprobe. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 096101. Everhart, T. E. (1967). Simplified analysis of point-cathode electron sources. J. Appl. Phys. 38, 4944–4957. Fowler, R. H., and Nordheim, L. (1928). Electron emission in intense electric fields. Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A119, 173–181. Gabor, D. (1949). Microscopy by reconstructed wavefronts. Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A197, 454–487. Gomer, R. (1961). Field Emission and Field Ionization. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press. Haider, M., Rose, H., Uhlemann, S., Kabius, B., and Urban, K. (1998). Toward 0.1 nm resolution with the first spherically corrected transmission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 47(5), 395–405. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., and Zach, J. (2000). Upper limit for the residual aberrations of a high-resolution aberration-corrected STEM. Ultramicroscopy 81, 163–175. Hashimoto, T., Nakamura, K., Kakibayashi, H., Shimovama, W., Ohashi, T., Sato, H., Tanaka, H., Yotsuji, T., Aizawa, S., Saito, K., Sato, Y., Ichihashi, M., and Isakozawa, S. (1998). Development of the HD-2000 high voltage field emission scanning electron microscope. Proc. ICEM 14, 85–86. Hashimoto, T., Sato, Y., Ueki, Y., Kamino, T., Isakozawa, S., Ikematsu, Y., Uemori, R., and Morikawa, H. (1991). Nano-area analysis by an energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer mounted on a field emission transmission electron microscope. Proc. EMSA 49, 352–353. Hashimoto, A., Yorimitsu, H., Ajima, K., Suenaga, K., Isobe, H., Miyawaki, J., Yudasaka, M., Iijima, S., and Nakamura, E. (2004). Selective deposition of a gadolinium(III) cluster in a hole opening of single-wall carbon nanohorn. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 527–530. Hibi, T. (1956). Pointed filament (I) its production and its applications. J. Electron Microsc. 4, 10–15. Inada, H., Watanabe, S., Tanaka, H., Takane, A., Aizawa, S., Shimovama, W., Ohashi, T., Hashimoto, T., Isakozawa, S., and Nakamura, K. (2004). Development of automatic adjustment functions for the HD-2300 scanning transmission electron microscope. Proc. 8 APEM 60–61. Inada, H., Terauchi, D., Tsuneta, R., Ozawa, M., Aizawa, S., Nakamura, K., Takane, A., Konno, M., and Tanaka, H. (2005). Development of high accuracy automatic magnification calibration function for scanning transmission electron microscope. Conference Proc. from 31st Int. Symp. for Testing and Failure Anal. 436–439. Inada, H., Wu, L., Wall, J., Su, D., and Zhu, Y. (2009). Performance and image analysis of the aberration-corrected Hitachi HD-2700C STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 58, 111–122.
184
Hiromi Inada et al.
Isakozawa, S., Kashikura, Y., Sato, Y., Takahashi, T., Ichihashi, M., and Murakoshi, H. (1989). Proc. EMSA 47, 112–113. Ishitani, T., Tsuboi, H., Yaguchi, T., and Koike, H. (1994). Transmission electron microscope sample preparation using a focused ion beam. J. Electron Microsc. 43, 322–326. Kaji, K., Ueda, K., Aoyama, T., Taya, S., Tanaka, H., and Isakozawa, S. (2001). Development of a real-time jump ratio imaging system equipped with a STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 50, 15–21. Kamino, T., and Tomita, M. (1983). Effect of FE gun in analytical electron microscope. Hitachi Technical Data ‘‘EM’’ Sheet 36. Kamino, T., Ueki, Y., Hamajika, H., Sasaki, K., Kuroda, K., and Saka, H. (1992). Direct evidence for Suzuki segregation obtained by high-resolution analytical electron microscopy. Phil. Mag. Lett. 66, 27–31. Kamino, T., Yaguchi, T., Konno, M., Ohnishi, T., and Watanabe, M. (2004). A method for multidirectional TEM observation of a specific site at atomic resolution. J. Electron Microsc. 53, 583–588. Kawasaki, T., Yoshida, T., Matsuda, T., Osakabe, N., Tonomura, A., Matsui, I., and Kitazawa, K. (2000). Fine crystal lattice fringes observed using a transmission electron microscope with 1MeV coherent electron waves. Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 1342–1344. Kimoto, K., Asaka, T., Nagai, T., Saito, M., Matsui, Y., and Ishizuka, K. (2007b). Elementselective imaging of atomic columns in crystal using STEM and EELS. Nature 450, 702–704. Kimoto, K., Ishizuka, K., Asaka, T., Nagai, T., and Matsui, Y. (2005). 0.23 eV energy resolution obtained using a cold field emission gun and a streak imaging technique. Micron 36, 465–469. Kimoto, K., and Matsui, Y. (2002). Software techniques for EELS to realize about 0.3 eV energy resolution using 300 kV FEG-TEM. J. Microsc. 208, 224–228. Kimoto, K., Nakamura, K., Aizawa, S., Isakozawa, S., and Matsui, Y. (2007a). Development of dedicated STEM with high stability. J. Electron Microsc. 56, 17–20. Kimoto, K., Xie, R. J., Matsui, Y., Ishizuka, K., and Hirosaki, N. (2009). Direct observation of single dopant atom in light-emitting phosphor of b–SiAlON:Eu2þ. Appl. Phys. Lett. 94, 041908. Komoda, T. (1996a). Electron microscopes and microscopy in Japan. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 96, 653–657. Komoda, T. (1996b). Electron microscopes and microscopy in Japan: Instrumentation. Adv. Imaging Electron Phys. 96, 685–722. Komoda, T., and Saito, S. (1972). Experimental resolution limit in the secondary electron mode for a field emission source scanning electron microscope. Proc. 5th Annual Scanning Electron Microsc. Symp. (Chicago) 129. Komoda, T., Tonomura, A., Ohkura, A., and Minamikawa, Y. (1972). A scanning transmission electron microscope using a field emission electron fun., Proc. 6th Int. Conf. on X-ray Optics and Microanalysis, pp. 483–488. Koreeda, A., Ishibashi, T., Shimizu, K., Tomita, M., Kimura, C., and Okano, H. (1990). Development and applications of an analytical electron microscope with a field emission electron gun. Mater. Charact. 25, 375–395. Krivanek, O. L., Dellby, N., and Lipini, A. R. (1999). Toward sub-angstrom electron beams. Ultramicroscopy 78, 1–11. Martin, E. E., Trolan, J. K., and Dyke, W. P. (1960). Stable, high density field emission cold cathode. J. Appl. Phys. 31, 782–789. Matsuda, T., Tonomura, A., Suzuki, R., Endo, J., Osakabe, N., Umezaki, H., Tanabe, H., Sugita, Y., and Fujiwara, H. (1982). Observation of microscopic distribution of magnetic field by electron holography. J. Appl. Phys. 53, 5444–5448.
Hitachi’s Development of Cold-Field Emission Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopes
185
Millilkan, R. A., and Lauritsen, C. C. (1928). Relations of field-currents to thermionic-currents. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U S A 14, 45–49. Murakoshi, H., Ichihashi, M., and Kakibayashi, H. (1992). A 300-kV field-emission transmission electron microscope. Proc. EMSA 50, 936–937. Muller, D. A., and Grazul, J. (2001). Optimizing the environment for sub-0.2 nm scanning transmission electron microscopy. J.Electron Microsc. 50, 219–226. Mu¨ller, E. W. (1937). Elektronenmikroskopische Beobachtungen von Feldkathoden. Z. Physik 106, 541–550. Mu¨ller, H., Uhlemann, S., Hartel, P., and Haider, M. (2006). Advancing the hexapole Cscorrector for scanning transmission electron microscope. Microsc. Microanal 12, 442–455. Nakamura, K., Kakibayashi, H., Kanehori, K., and Tanaka, N. (1997). Position dependence of the visibility of a single gold atom in silicon crystals in HAADF-STEM image simulation. J. Electron Microsc. 46, 33–43. Nellist, P. D., Chisholm, MF., Dellby, N., Krivanek, O. L., Murfitt, M. F., Szilagyi, Z. S., Lupini, A. R., Borisevich, A., Sides, W. H. Jr., and Pennycook, S. J. (2004). Direct subAngstrom imaging of a crystal lattice. Science 305, 1741. Osakabe, N., Matsuda, T., Kawasaki, T., Endo, J., Tonomura, A., Yano, S., and Yamada, H. (1986). Experimental confirmation of the Aharanov-Bohm effect using a toroidal magnetic field confined by a superconductor. Phys. Rev. A 34, 815–822. Osakabe, N., Yoshida, K., Horiuchi, Y., Matsuda, T., Tanabe, H., Okuwaki, T., Endo, J., Fujiwara, H., and Tonomura, A. (1983). Observation of recorded magnetization pattern by electron holography. Appl. Phys. Lett. 42, 746–748. Saito, M., Kimoto, K., Nagai, T., Fukushima, S., Akahoshi, D., Kuwahara, H., Matsui, Y., and Ishizuka, K. (2009). Local crystal structure analysis with 10-pm accuracy using scanning transmission electron microscopy. J. Electron Microsc. 58, 131–136. Shimoyama, H., Ichihashi, M., and Tamura, N. (1989). Emitter and electron gun. J. Electron Microsc. 38, S1–S9. Siegel, B. M., et al (1968). Electron Microscopy (Rome) I, 141. Spence, J. C. H., and Zuo, J. M. (1992). in Electron Micro Diffraction. New York: Plenum, p. 175. Todokoro, H., Nomura, S., and Komoda, T. (1977). Observation of atom images by means of field emission STEM. J. Electron Microsc. 26, 213–214. Todokoro, H., Saito, N., and Yamamoto, S. (1982). Role of ion bombardment in field emission current instability. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 21, 1513–1516. Tonomura, (1972). Tonomura, A. (1973). Optimum design of accelerating electrodes for a field emission electron gun. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 12, 1065–1069. Tonomura, A. (1984). Application of electron holography using a field-emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 33, 101–115. Tonomura, A. (1998). Electron Holography, 2nd ed., Berlin: Springer. Tonomura, A., Fukuhara, A., Watanabe, H., and Komoda, T. (1968). Optical reconstruction of image from Fraunhofer electron-hologram. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 7, 295. Tonomura, A., and Komoda, T. (1973). Field emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 22, 141–147. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., and Endo, J. (1979a). Spherical aberration correction of electron lens by holography. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 18, 1373–1377. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Endo, J., Todokoro, H., and Komoda, T. (1979b). Development of a field emission electron microscope. J. Electron Microsc. 28, 1–11. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Endo, J., Arii, T., and Mihama, K. (1980). Direct observation of fine structure of domain walls by electron holography. Phys. Rev. Lett. 44, 1430–1433.
186
Hiromi Inada et al.
Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., Suzuki, R., Fukuhara, A., Osakabe, N., Umezaki, H., Endo, J., Shinagawa, K., Sugita, Y., and Fujiwara, H. (1982). Observation of Aharonov-Bohm effect by electron holography. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1443–1446. Tonomura, A., Osakabe, N., Matsuda, T., Kawasaki, T., Endo, J., Yano, S., and Yamada, H. (1986). Evidence for the Aharanov-Bohm effect with magnetic field completely shielded from electron wave. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 792–795. Ueda, R. (1975). Young scientists should have the courage to gamble. Electron Microscopy 10, 1 [in Japanese]. Vine, W. J., Vincent, R., Spellward, P., and Steeds, J. W. (1992). Observation of phase contrast in convergent-beam electron diffraction patterns. Ultramicroscopy 41, 423–428. Vo¨lkl, E., Allard, L. F., and Joy, D. C. (1999). Introduction to Electron Holography, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers. Watanabe, M., and Williams, D. B. (2004). Improvements of elemental mapping via X-ray spectrum imaging combined with principal component analysis and zero-peak deconvolution. Microsc. Microanal. 10(Suppl. 2), 1040–1041. Wiesner, J. C., and Everhart, T. E. (1969). Point cathode electron sources. Proc. EMSA 27, 174–175. Wood, R. W. (1897). A mew form of cathode discharge and the production of X-rays, together with some notes on diffraction. Preliminary communication. Phys. Rev. 5, 1–10. Yaguchi, T., Konno, M., Kamino, T., and Watanabe, M. (2008). Observation of threedimensional elemental distributions of a Si-device using a 360-degree-tilt FIB and the cold field-emission STEM system. Ultramicroscopy 108, 1603–1615. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970a). Scanning transmission electron microscopy, I. Optik 31, 258–280. Zeitler, E., and Thomson, M. G. R. (1970b). Scanning transmission electron microscopy, II. Optik 31, 359–366. Zhang, X., Joy, D. C., Zhang, Y., Hashimoto, T., Allard, L., and Nolan, T. A. (1993). Electron holography techniques for study of ferroelectric domain. Ultramicroscopy 51, 21–30. Zhu, Y., and Wall, J. (2008). Aberration-corrected electron microscopes at Brookhaven national laboratory. Adv. Imaging Electr. Phys. 153, 481–523. Zhu, Y., Inada, H., Nakamura, K., and Wall, J. (2009). Imaging single atoms using secondary electrons with an aberration-corrected electron microscope. Nature Materials 8, 808–812.
Chapter
5 Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1 P. W. Hawkes
Contents
1. Introduction 2. The AEI STEM-1 3. The Siemens ST100F 3.1. The New ELMISKOP ST100F Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Introduction Construction of the ELMISKOP ST100F Advantages of the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Imaging with Low Radiation Damage Conclusion 3.2. Image Forming Systems General Remarks The Imaging Process Image Forming Properties of Magnetic Lenses Strong Lenses Lens Systems for CTEM and STEM: Similarities and Differences Requirements for Analytical Microscopy Acknowledgments References
188 188 191 195 195 195 198 198 201 203 203 204 205 208 210 215 217 217
CEMES-CNRS, Toulouse, France Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59005-2. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
187
188
P. W. Hawkes
1. INTRODUCTION The images published by Crewe and colleagues showing that scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) was a real rival to the conventional transmission electron microscope (CTEM) and to the recently developed scanning electron microscope (SEM) caused a flurry of excitement among the constructors of electron microscopes and the potential users of this new instrument. Only three years had elapsed since the first commercial SEM, the Cambridge Instrument Company’s Stereoscan, had been launched and one might have expected the same company to develop a STEM. In practice, however, it was two well-established builders of transmission electron microscopes who embarked on the production of commercial models of the STEM—AEI and Siemens—and a newcomer to the electron microscope field, Vacuum Generators. Despite considerable efforts, no one from Siemens or AEI could be found to write the history of their STEM instruments. The present short account is based on the few publications devoted to these microscopes and some unpublished material that has been made available to me. The earliest paper I have found on the AEI STEM appeared in 1973, while the Siemens ST100F was launched at the 1975 meeting of the German Electron Microscopy Society (DGE), held in Berlin.
2. THE AEI STEM-1 The earliest indication of interest in developing a STEM at AEI that I have encountered is a two-page note by Alderson (1971) in the AEI house journal. The prototype STEM was first described at conferences in England and the United States by Banbury and Bance (1973a,b), at which date it was sufficiently advanced to provide early images. Its later history can be followed in the papers by Banbury (1974) at the International Congress on Electron Microscopy at Canberra and by Banbury et al. (1975) and Ray et al. (1976) at the Electron Microscope Society of America and the Electron Microscopy and Analysis Group meetings, respectively. The 1973 papers tell us that The AEI gun has a triode structure which differs significantly from the wellknown design of Butler (1966) and Crewe et al. (1968). The geometry chosen produces a divergent beam from a virtual source whose position remains constant over a wide range of operating voltages, thus simplifying changes of working voltage. The cathode and first anode assembly forms a prealigned structure mounted on a single substantial insulator, eliminating the need for precise mechanical tip alignment in ultra high vacuum. . .. The vacuum system is in three sections using ion and sublimation pumps throughout, to maintain a clean vacuum system in which the specimen
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
189
contamination rate is much lower than for a conventional microscope. The actual rate is largely dependent on the care with which the specimen/specimen holder and the internal surfaces of the specimen chamber are handled. Typically the specimen chamber will reach a vacuum below 10–7 torr in under two hours from atmospheric pressure with the unbaked system in clean condition; it is bakeable up to 1000 C for further reduction of the working pressure. The gun is isolated by a double differential system, and a vacuum liner tube extending up to the lower pole of the objective lens keeps all coils isolated from the high vacuum. The operating pressure in the gun is normally at or below 10–10 torr and the gun has been designed for operation up to 100 kV. The prototype has a top-entry specimen stage based on the well-tried EM802 stage (Lucas, 1970) with some minor modifications for operation in the region of 10–7 torr. The instrument is fitted with an airlock through which the specimen can be changed in two to three minutes. . .. The modular electronic design is all solid state with digital scan and compact EHT supplies. The system has provision for convenient extension of the video processing facilities and for remote control of the electron probe.
The authors go on to describe the operating modes envisaged and, in their summary, they tell us that ‘‘The initial resolution was of the order of ˚ , which is being improved in parallel with the development of the 10 A instrument. The design of the AEI field emission gun has resulted in stable and reliable operation up to and beyond 80 kV.’’ A figure shows a thin section of conventionally stained brain tissue, photographed directly from a 312-line monitor, at 80 kV; the exposure time was 5 s and two magnifications are displayed, 80,000 and 200,000. Two years later, the prototype had been installed in the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge. Ray et al. (1976) tell us that It has a triode cold field emission gun operating over the range 20 kV to 80 kV which uses a <111> oriented single crystal tungsten tip. The tip has given 1000 hours of trouble-free operation in a vacuum of 5 10–9 Pa. A total emission current of up to 10 mA can be drawn from the tip and this produces a brightness of approximately 1013 A m–2sr–1 in a 0.3 nm probe with a probe current stability of better than 1% rms over a period of several minutes. The source size produced by the gun is estimated to lie between 3 nm and 5 nm in diameter. The source is demagnified by two magnetic lenses, a condenser and an objective, to give a gaussian spot size 0.l nm in diameter in high resolution operation. Two lenses give a certain degree of freedom in setting up the final probe size and probe current. Specimens are mounted on conventional 3 mm grids which are accommodated by a topentry stage. The specimen chamber is pumped by an ion/sublimator pump combination and the pressure is maintained at 10–6 Pa. An airlock permits specimens to be changed in about 5 minutes.The electronics incorporates a digital scan generator which allows computer control of the picture point period, raster resolution and mode of operation. The number of picture points can be varied from 256 256 to 4096 4096.
190
P. W. Hawkes
FIGURE 1
Friedrich Thon with the Siemens ST100F.
Routine resolution of 0.3 nm can be obtained as measured using lattice fringe images or the background phase contrast detail in the image of a carbon film. These images are recorded using a relatively small collector aperture (5 millirads) and a wide objective aperture: Figure 1,1 shows a lattice fringe image from an area of graphitized carbon, the fringe spacing corresponding to 0.34 nm. This was recorded at 80 kV with an instrumental magnification of 8 million and a recording time of 16 s. Figure 2,2 shows (111) lattice fringes in a single crystal silicon specimen with a 0.3l nm spacing, recorded under similar conditions. The facility for displaying images directly at very high magnifications combined with the possibilities of contrast enhancement through signal processing make STEM a potentially very powerful instrument for studying lattice fringe images and their variation with instrumental parameters. Contamination is not a problem with this type of specimen and an image such as Figure 1 can be displayed continuously on the screen for 30 minutes or more. The microscope is equipped with a double focusing magnetic sector electron energy analyser, with a resolution of approximately 1.4 eV at 80 kV. The analyser can be used to give an energy spectrum from a stationary probe in switched ranges from 0–10 eV to 0–1000 eV with a continuous offset of 0–1000 eV. Alternatively the probe can be scanned in the usual way whilst the energy analyser is set to some particular energy band-pass. In this manner a filtered image can be obtained. A particular advantage of STEM
1 2
Not reproduced here. Not reproduced here.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
FIGURE 2
191
Dieter Willasch and the Siemens ST100F.
is the ease with which such high-resolution energy-loss images can be obtained since the analyser transmits a time resolved image rather than a spatially resolved image.
Once it was installed in the Laboratory of Molecular Biology, the STEM-1 failed to live up to its promise. The spot was indeed small, but the efficiency of the detector was poor and the vacuum system defective. After a year of frustration, the instrument, which had been purchased for about £70,000, was sold to the European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL) in Heidelberg for £10,000 in the hope that some parts could be reused but this was apparently not the case. A cryoSTEM was built at the EMBL and performed much better ( Jones et al., 1985; Jones and Haider, 1989).
3. THE SIEMENS ST100F Information about this instrument is far more abundant and includes detailed descriptions in German and English (Willasch, 1975, 1976a,b; Gauger et al., 1975; Kempin et al., 1975; Krisch et al., 1975, 1976a,b, 1977; Hubert et al., 1978). The articles by Blaschke (1972) and Thieringer (1972) are perhaps forerunners of the STEM development. The first description that I have seen is the paper by Willasch delivered at the meeting of the DGE in 1975, in Berlin, which includes nine sets of micrographs obtained with the instrument:
192
P. W. Hawkes
1. A comparison of STEM and CTEM bright-field images of an adenovirus preparation 2. A bright-field image of muscle tissue 3. STEM and CTEM bright-field images of a 1-mm thick liver section 4. A bright-field image of an oxygen-doped chromium foil, 200 nm thick 5. Bright-field images of the 0.34-nm lattice fringes of graphitized carbon with two different scan fields 6. Bright-field and dark-field images of mitochondria 7. Bright-field images of gametocytes, 1 mm thick 8. Bright-field and dark-field images of the alloy MP35N þ Ti, as recorded and after differentiation 9. An example of selected-area diffraction, showing the bright-field image of a brass specimen and the diffraction pattern from a region about 10 nm across. Several other papers in the same volume of BEDO describe individual features of the instrument in more detail: Krisch et al. (1975) describe the signal-processing unit, Gauger et al. (1975) present a 100-kV field-emission system, and Kempin et al. (1975) give information about the objective lens. Similar information is provided in the article in the Siemens Review by Krisch et al. (1976a; in German, 1976b). The most recent account is to be found in a typescript by Schliepe (1978), which includes many technical details and extensive discussion; this is the text of a paper delivered at a Colloquium u¨ber Elektronenschreiber und Rasterelektronenmikroskopie: Physikalische Grundlagen, Gera¨tetechnik und Anwendungen, held in the Optisches Institut of the Technische Universita¨t, Berlin, and organized by B. Lischke and H. Niedrig. The papers were not, however, published other than for internal circulation. Rather than paraphrase all this material, I reproduce below the contents of two Siemens Analytical Application Notes prepared by D. Willasch: Note 204 on ‘‘The new ELMISKOP ST100F scanning transmission electron microscope’’ and Note 212 on ‘‘Image forming systems.’’ The late Friedrich Thon, Dieter Willasch, and Reinhard Schliepe were largely responsible for the design of this microscope. Figures 1 and 2 show Thon and Willasch with the instrument. Figure 3 shows the image of an adenovirus, about 50 nm in diameter. Figure 4 gives an overall view of the control panel and the column. Other members of the development team were the late Karl-Heinz Mu¨ller and Burkhard Krisch. I have found no reliable published information about the number of ST100F microscopes built and sold. I am therefore especially grateful to Dr. Cilly Weichan, formerly of Siemens, who has provided many of the following details. The order in which the microscopes are listed has no particular significance.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
193
FIGURE 3 Image of an adenovirus, obtained with the Siemens STEM.
FIGURE 4 ST100F.
Overall view of the ELMISKOP ST100F. The column and control panel of the
194
P. W. Hawkes
1. A demonstration model was installed in Karlsruhe and at least one publication refers to it explicitly (Ruel et al., 1978, who studied softwood specimens). It was subsequently returned to Berlin for final checking before delivery to a Siemens customer. The late Dr. Joachim Stabenow at BASF in Ludwigshafen-am-Rhein showed interest in it, but BASF did not purchase an ST100F. 2. An ST100F was ordered by Don Williams, director of the Medical Research Council Laboratory in Belville, adjacent to the Tygerberg Hospital, Cape Town. It worked very well but there were specimen preparation problems. With a few exceptions contamination was very fast and this problem slowed us down. The installation of a quartz window into the specimen chamber through which the specimen could be irradiated with UV from an HBO 200 burner (for varying periods) before the beam was turned on helped somewhat. But the problem was never really solved. More interesting was the work we did interfacing the STEM directly to an HP 2000 system using a 16-bit IO card from HP. We overcame the problem of interruption from the RTE IV operating system by the use of a »flywheel » driver that bypassed the OS. In this way very fast image collection was possible.
In 1982, however, Don Williams left South Africa and his successor, Wynand Murray, failed to obtain any results with the microscope and it was scrapped, even though in good working order, as was one of the latest Siemens transmission electron microscopes, a CT150. 3. A third Siemens STEM was destined for a research laboratory in the University of Sa˜o Paolo in Brazil. Funding came from Hospitalia, jointly supported by Siemens and the University. Both partners contributed to the construction and equipment of a new laboratory. But when the time came to install the microcope, it was found that the air conditioning was not capable of maintaining the necessary room temperature (18–19 C): The power supply was insufficient for the demands of the system. The microscope was therefore never installed. 4. The remaining instruments remained in Germany. One was ordered by the late Karl Zierold for the Max-Planck-Institut fu¨r Molekulare Physiologie in Dortmund, where is was installed toward the end of 1978. This instrument performed perfectly and was in regular use in Zierold’s laboratory until 1999, when the Institute moved from the Rheinlanddamm to new premises and the ST100F was left behind. The first fieldemission cathode functioned for about one year; its replacement continued to operate efficiently throughout the lifetime of the microscope. Zierold was a specialist of cryo–electron microscopy and many special accessories were constructed in the workshop of the Institute: a cryotransfer system, specimen holders, and a cooling system in high vacuum, among others. This very satisfactory performance was largely due to the expertise of Mr. Gerd Trogemann, the Siemens service engineer.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
195
5. Another instrument was ordered by the late Walter Hoppe, director of the Max-Planck-Institut fu¨r Biochemie in Munich. He planned to use it for ptychography (Hoppe, 1982) but it seems that no results were obtained with it though the technician responsible for it claimed that it worked satisfactorily. Toward the end of the 1980s, it was transferred to Tu¨bingen, where Hannes Lichte used it to pursue STEM holography, which he had launched in 1988 using a modified Siemens Elmiskop 1A. Two Ph. D. dissertations resulted (Leuthner, 1992, see Leuthner et al., 1989; Sum, 1995, see Leuthner et al., 1990). 6. A final ST100F was ordered by Dr. Blank for the Institut fu¨r Transurane [Institute for Transuranium Elements] in Leopoldshafen; it seems to have failed to reach its guaranteed performance and been refused by the Institute.
3.1. The New ELMISKOP ST100F Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope by D. Willasch
Introduction Scanning transmission electron microscopy, the origins of which go back to work done by M. von Ardenne (1938) in the Thirties, has met with amazingly increasing interest since about 1969 as a new technique in electron microscopy. Scanning transmission microscopy closes the gap between conventional transmission electron microscopy and surface scanning microscopy by applying the scanning principle to imaging of objects which can be penetrated by the electron beam. The starting point for constantly increasing activities in this field was formed by the pioneering work done by Crewe and his coworkers at the University of Chicago (Crewe and Wall, 1970). They built the first, high-resolution scanning transmission microscope. Now there is no more doubt that the scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) will assume a position of equal importance with the conventional transmission microscope (CEM or CTEM) and the surface scanning microscope (SEM), although its broad application has not been possible yet so far, especially in the area of high resolution. However, the main reason for this is that such microscopes have been available to only a few users until now.
Construction of the ELMISKOP ST100F For these reasons we have developed a high-performance scanning transmission microscope which has been designed for a great variety of different fields of application and combines ease of operation with wide
196
P. W. Hawkes
technical possibilities: the ELMISKOPÒ ST100F (Fig. 4) (Krisch et al., 1976). The microscope has been designed as a compact unit, i.e. the entire electronic instrumentation is incorporated in the apparatus. No further supply units are required. The internal arrangement is: microscope stand with microscope column and control panel. The microscope column consists of a 100 kV field emission gun with a cathode which is specially processed to achieve particularly long operating times even at the relatively uncomplicated UHV of 109 mbar. The brightness of the source at 100 kV is better than 109 A/cm2 ster, and is thus higher by a factor of 1000 than in a thermionic system. In addition to oxygen-treated (100)-oriented tips, other tips as well may be used. An electrostatic single-lens condenser is incorporated in the electron gun. It allows for optimum beam adjustment to various operating conditions; magnetic condenser lenses can thus be dispensed with. Below the electron gun there is a differentially pumped unit with automatic valve, equipped with two differential apertures and evacuated by ion getter pumps. This unit separates the electron gun vacuum from the oil-free specimen stage vacuum which is better than 107 mbar. The objective lens leaves adequate room for accommodating a eucentric goniometer as well as additional analytical equipment while offering minimum aberration coefficients which permit a resolution of 0.2 nm. The detector unit containing one detector each for bright-field and dark-field imaging adjoins the objective lens at the bottom. An energy spectrometer can be connected to it below. The column cross-section and the ray path for imaging are illustrated in Fig. 5. The cross-over formed by the einzel-lens system is focused onto the specimen by the objective lens in the case of high and medium magnifications, and by a mini-lens in the case of low magnifications. Two dynamic deflection systems scan the probe over the specimen. Two more dynamic deflection systems behind the specimen adjust the beam to the detectors and the energy analyzer, thereby permitting diffraction techniques too. Two static deflection systems are used for the alignment. The arrangement of the controls and CRT’s as well as the recording system can be seen in Fig. 4. The settings of all essential operating functions are displayed by a display panel, most of them in digital form. The most important electronic components are: Vacuum control: The entire vacuum system is monitored automatically; if vacuum malfunctions occur, the appropriate protective measures are taken automatically. Scanning system: The magnification can be set from 50: 1 to 10,000,000:1. A great variety of scanning modes can be selected, including TV frequency and digital scan. Focusing and control system for the objective lens: The sensitivity of the focusing control is adjusted automatically to the respective
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
197
Field emission gun Field emission gun with einzel-lens SF6 Insulator Differentially pumped unit with valve
Illumination aperture
Static deflection systems
Mini lens
Dynamic deflection systems
Objective aperture
Objective lens
Specimen
Detector unit Energy spectrometer
FIGURE 5
Detector aperture Dark-field detector Bright-field detector
Microscope column and ray path of the ELMISKOP ST100F.
magnification. The defocusing value is indicated digitally. The stage coordinates and the goniometer tilt and rotation angles are adjusted by means of a motor with feedback of the coordinates or tilting angles, resp. High-voltage and field emission system: The acceleration voltage can be set in five fixed steps from 20 kV to 100 kV and continuously from 10 kV to 30 kV. Various illumination modes and the beam current can be set by means of the field emission control. Signal detection and processing system: Three separate measuring channels for bright-field, dark-field, and reference signals are set automatically to optimum values. Combination of the signals by addition, subtraction or division as well as further processing of the signals is possible. CRT’s: The image can be observed on two CRT’s with diagonals of 31 cm each. If an image storage unit is used, further advantages as well as optimum control of low exposure work will result. Recording system: The resolution of the recording scope is better than 2000 lines. A motor-driven 6 6 roll-film camera is used for recording. 35-mm or Polaroid cameras can also be connected. The controls for aligning, trimming and additional functions which are not required for microscope operation are arranged above the control panel and are normally hidden by a flap.
198
P. W. Hawkes
Advantages of the Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Images which can be interpreted directly
Bright-field imaging with large circular detector (objective aperture detector aperture) or dark-field imaging with annular detector furnishes contrast transfer conditions which can be interpreted directly (Crewe, 1974). Phase contrast effects, which occur in the images of conventional microscopes or the STEM with small detector aperture in the form of granulation, are avoided in this way. Figure 6 demonstrates the reduced phase contrast influence when Adeno viruses are imaged, as compared to the CEM image of the same specimen. A bright-field image of a thin section of muscle tissue is shown in Fig. 7. When focusing such periodic structures, uncertainties in selecting the focus do not arise. Ambiguities during interpretation are excluded by the optical transfer properties of the microscope.
Imaging with Low Radiation Damage In dark-field imaging with large annular detector – the optimum mode of operation of a scanning transmission microscope – almost all elastically scattered electrons can be collected without loss of resolution. Damage to sensitive objects can thus be kept distinctly lower in the scanning microscope than in a conventional microscope (Crewe et al., 1974). Moreover images with minimum exposure can be achieved by shifting the scanning field to a previously non-irradiated specimen area without any noticeable change in focusing. This is quite easy because only that specimen area is irradiated by electrons which appears on the observation CRT. (a)
(b)
FIGURE 6 Comparison of STEM bright-field image (left) and CEM bright-field image (right), using an Adeno virus preparation.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
FIGURE 7
199
Bright-field image of muscle tissue.
Better imaging conditions in the case of thick specimens
The inelastic scattering which is unavoidable in thick specimens does not lead in the STEM to any deterioration in resolution due to chromatic aberration, because no imaging lenses are used behind the object. For this reason, it is possible – especially in the case of amorphous specimens of low atomic number – to image even relatively thick layers with a resolution which can be achieved in a conventional microscope at much higher acceleration voltages only (Cowley, 1974; Groves, 1975). An example is presented in Fig. 8 on a section of about 1 mm thickness, as compared to the CEM. Signal processing and electronic contrast enhancement
Due to the fact that the information is serially displayed there is a quantitative electronic signal available which can be processed electronically in a defined manner. This allows for processing and combining various signals in a manner adjusted optimally to the respective application. It is also possible to feed the image information directly into a computer. The contrast possibilities are illustrated in Fig. 9 on an oxygen-doped chromium layer. Optimum analysis possibilities
The field emission gun offers ideal conditions for generating extremely high currents in extremely small probes. Quantitative analysis of minute specimen details thus is possible at short recording times. Diffraction examinations in micro-areas of less than 10 nm diameter as
200
P. W. Hawkes
FIGURE 8 Comparison of STEM bright-field image (left) and CEM bright-field image (right), using a liver section sample (thickness about 1 mm).
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 9 Bright-field image of an oxygen-doped chromium layer; thickness about 200 nm.
well as topography and material contrast imaging by means of secondary and backscattered electron detectors are possible. The electrons can be selected according to energy by means of an electron energy loss spectrometer. The signals of the elastically scattered and inelastically scattered electrons can thus be separated and can be linked to one another in a defined manner. Ease of operation
Constant image brightness and focusing, regardless of the magnification, are the direct result of the scanning principle. Changes in magnification do not result in image rotations or image shifts (zoom effect).
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
FIGURE 10
FIGURE 11
201
Bright-field images of the 0.34 nm lattice planes of carbon black.
Bright-field image (left) and dark-field image (right) of mitochondria.
A few applications on various specimens are illustrated by Fig. 10 to 14.
Conclusion The new ELMISKOP ST100F high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscope was developed with the goal of providing users with an apparatus combining the advantages of STEM technique (analytical microscopy) and of great ease of operation. The major optical components of the microscope are: Field emission gun with a maximum acceleration voltage of 100 kV.
Stable emission and a long life time of the cathode are achieved even at a vacuum of 109 mbar by using an oxygen-processed tip and a threestage accelerator. An electrostatic einzel-lens located in front of the accelerator ensures optimum adjustment to all acceleration voltages and modes of operation.
202
(a)
P. W. Hawkes
(b)
FIGURE 12 Bright-field image of gametocytes in different states; section thickness about 1 mm.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
FIGURE 13 Images of MP 35 N þ Ti alloy: (a) bright-field imaging; (b) as (a), but differentiated; (c) dark-field image in the light of a reflection; (d) as (c), but differentiated.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
(a)
203
(b)
FIGURE 14 Micro area diffraction by means of the ELMISKOP ST100F. (a) bright-field image of an etched brass specimen; (b) diffraction pattern of an area of (a) having a diameter of about 10 nm. Objective lens combining low aberrations (Cs ¼ Cc ¼ 1.3 mm) with a
large gap, thereby providing adequate space for specimen manipulators (e.g., a fully eucentric goniometer) and accessories (EDAX, SEM). Energy spectrometer for investigations involving inelastic electrons and energy-loss spectroscopy. A number of possibilities and advantages in using the ELMISKOP ST100F on various specimens are shown.
3.2. Image Forming Systems* by D. Willasch
General Remarks The intention of this paper is to give a short review of the most important image forming systems and their properties for the conventional transmission electron microscope (CTEM) and the scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM). For the better understanding of those, who are not concerned with imaging theory, lens design, and electron optics, it will be necessary to repeat some principles and definitions. It is not intended to deduce and evaluate solutions for electron optical problems in a rigorous way as they can be found in many textbooks. They are used * Abstract of a key-note paper given at the workshop on ‘‘Analytical Electron Microscopy’’ at Cornell
University, Ithaka, August 1976.
204
P. W. Hawkes
in this context only to discuss the properties of certain systems, and to give an insight into the difficulties of designing electron microscope imaging systems. The main interest will be directed towards the electron optical and design problems of advanced microscopes, especially in analytical microscopy.
The Imaging Process Generally speaking, the purpose of an image forming system is to transform an object information into an image, which then can be interpreted by an observer. One of the fundamental problems of electron microscopy results from the fact that the specimens are three-dimensional and that the object information commonly sought in electron microscopy (i.e. the arrangement of atoms and molecules making up the specimen) has to be described by a complex function with three variables. The complete information is carried in amplitude and phase of the electron wave field which has passed through the object. But the image can be observed only as a two-dimensional intensity distribution, represented by a real function with two variables. That is why in general several assumptions and approximations are necessary to interpret an image and to understand the imaging process. In order to describe the imaging, it is useful to project the function containing the object information into a plane shortly behind the object, so a complex function c0(x0, y0) is obtained. x0, y0 are the coordinates in this projection plane. With very thin objects it is identical with the object plane. The image forming system transforms this function into the wave function ci(xi, yi) in the image plane and the recording system squares it so that the image intensity distribution is I ¼ jci(xi, yi)j2 xi, yi are the coordinates in the image plane. In an ideal imaging system, xi ¼ Mx0, yi ¼ My0, with M as the system magnification. In order to get a faithful image of an object property, the image forming process should be linear, i.e. the output signal has to be linearly related to the input signal, in the case of coherent illumination the image intensity I(xi, yi) to the wave function c0(x0, y0). In integral form this means ðð Gðxi ; yi ; x0 ; y0 Þ C0 ðx0 ; y0 Þdx0 dy0 (5.1) Iðxi ; yi Þ ¼
where the function G describes the imaging qualities of the image forming system. It is clear that by far not all imaging modes and systems will obey this equation. Also certain approximations in respect to the object function c0 have to be made to obtain linear imaging. It is known, for instance, that high resolution coherent bright field imaging of a weak phase or amplitude object is linear, but not the coherent dark field image.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
205
However, if an incoherent imaging mode is used as in high resolution bright field and dark field STEM, equation (5.1) is fulfilled, since then instead of c0 jc0j2 is the input signal. Another requirement on a good imaging system, especially the objective lens, is that its aberrations shall have the same effect on all image points, i.e. that the aberration discs depend only on the relative distance to the corresponding Gaussian image point (the image point obtained with an aberration free system). If this is fulfilled, the image is called isoplanatic and (5.1) can be written as ðð Gðxi x0 ; yi y0 Þ C0 ðx0 ; y0 Þdx0 dy0 ; (5.2) Iðxi ; yi Þ ¼
i.e. as a convolution integral. Fourier transforming this (denoted by F) we get:
F½I ¼ F½G F½C0 ;
(5.3)
where the Fourier spectrum of the object function is directly related to the spectrum of the image intensity. F[G] is called the contrast transfer function and G the pulse response function, i.e. G is the response of the system to a very steep pulse, for instance a delta function. The concept of contrast transfer functions is very important for describing the properties of optical systems, as resolution and contrast, and is nowadays widely used. Transfer functions can be determined both by theory and experiment.
Image Forming Properties of Magnetic Lenses In modern electron microscopes magnetic lenses are in nearly all cases used as image forming elements. Despite their different use and design the basic configuration is always the same (Fig. 15): A current that runs in iron-shrouded coils generates a magnetic field distribution in the gap of N
FIGURE 15 Schematic cross section of a magnetic lens.
206
P. W. Hawkes
the shroud, that can be specially formed by pole pieces. The field is rotationally symmetrical about the optical axis z, and the field distribution B(z) along this axis approximates very often a bell-shaped curve. The excitation of such lenses is conveniently described by the parameter pffiffiffiffiffiffiffi N I= U , where N I are the ampere turns and U* the relativistically corrected accelerating voltage of the electron beam. In order to determine the imaging properties of a lens one has to solve, for a certain lens field, the Lorentz equation (second order differential equation) of electron motion. The ray path is determined when e.g. the starting point in the object plane z ¼ z0 and the slope are given. If one has two independent solutions, e.g. s(z) and t(z) with s(z0) ¼ 1, s’(z0) ¼ 0, and t(z0) ¼ 0, t’(z0) ¼ 1, all other solutions can be found by superposition. From these trajectories the image plane and magnification of the lens can easily be attained, as is illustrated in Fig. 16. The focal length of a weak lens, where the focal length is large compared to the extent of the lens field in z-direction, is given by
1 e ¼ f0 8mU
1 ð
B2 ðzÞdz
(5.4)
1
with e ¼ electron charge and m ¼ electron mass. The image rotation which occurs in magnetic lenses is given by rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 ð e BðzÞdz; (5.5) F0 ¼ 8mU
1
i.e. the rotation can be reversed by reversing the excitation of the lens. Focal length, focal position and principal planes are found, when trajectories with s(1) ¼ 1, s’(1) ¼ 0 and sþ(þ1) ¼ 1, sþ’(þ1) ¼ 0 are chosen as shown in Fig. 17. Object plane
lmage plane t(z)
1
45⬚
z
g s(z) M
zo
zi
FIGURE 16 Ray trajectories in a magnetic lens to determine image plane and magnification.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
H−
s− (z)
H+
s+ (z)
1
1 F−
F+
207
z
fo
FIGURE 17 Ray trajectories in a magnetic lens to determine focal length f0, focal points Fþ and F and principal planes H and Hþ.
The aberrations that occur in electron lenses can be classified as geometrical aberrations, chromatic aberrations, and diffraction error. Geometrical and chromatic aberrations are determined from the ray trajectories by calculating the deviation of the aberrated ray trajectory from an ideal one without aberrations. In the third order approximation of this calculation there are 8 geometrical aberrations: spherical aberration, isotropic and anisotropic astigmatism, field curvature, isotropic and anisotropic distortion, isotropic and anisotropic coma. If there is not good rotational symmetry of the lens field, we have in addition to these also axial astigmatism; if there is defocussing, we have to consider this, too. As to chromatic aberration one distinguishes between axial chromatic aberration, i.e. the shift of the image plane due to the chromatic error and the chromatic aberrations of magnification and image rotation, which occur on off-axis points. It would lead too far to discuss these aberrations in detail, but we can say which aberrations have significant influence on the image in different modes of operation. Since all geometrical aberrations except spherical aberration vanish on the axis, they can be neglected in high resolution microscopy where only a small area around the optical axis is imaged (case of isoplanasy). The same is true for the chromatic aberrations: only axial chromatic aberration remains at high magnification. So one can conclude that for assessing the resolution of an electron lens system only spherical aberration, axial chromatic aberration, diffraction error and defocussing have to be considered. If correction of axial astigmatism is not sufficient this has to be considered, too. The situation is different at medium or low magnifications, when off-axis regions are imaged. Then means for correcting some of the other aberrations have to be found, as we will see later. The theoretical resolution limit of a lens system is obtained by calculating the aberration discs of the different aberrations and adding them properly. The resolution limit in electron microscopy, imposed by spherical aberration and diffraction error under optimum focus
208
P. W. Hawkes
conditions is c Cs1/4 l3/4 (Cs ¼ coefficient of spherical aberration, l ¼ electron wavelength). The factor c lies between 0.4 and 0.6 and depends on the degree of beam coherence. In modern electron microscopes the resolution limit due to axial chromatic aberration lies in the same order of magnitude. It is given by Cc a DW W , with Cc ¼ coefficient of axial chromatic aberration, a ¼ objective aperture and DW/W ¼ lens current and high voltage instabilities including the energy spread of the gun.
Strong Lenses The two main aberrations that limit the resolution of electron microscopes besides the diffraction error are spherical and axial chromatic aberration. Since it is very difficult to correct them, one has to find proper design and operating conditions to minimize their influence. This can be done by choosing high lens excitations, i.e. short focal length, since the coefficients of spherical and chromatic aberrations decrease with increasing excitation in the same order as the focal length (Fig. 18). Then the object plane lies within the lens field, and the lens has to be considered a strong lens. The magnetic field between the pole pieces is proportional to the lens excitation divided by the gap width and should stay in the order of 10 kG, since beyond this value saturation effects in the iron occur. That means that with a large gap one needs high excitation values to get small aberration coefficients. But not only the gap width, also the dimensions of the pole piece bores influence the field distribution. That is why the way the specimen is introduced influences the design of a lens strongly. With a side entry specimen stage one keeps the bores quite small, so that the gap width is the determining factor. With a top entry stage the upper bore has to be larger, which then is the determining factor while the gap is small. 10 f0.z0
cd
(mm)
5
f1 f0 cd 1
z0 5
10
15
f0
cF 20
25
NJ VU
FIGURE 18 Dependence of focal length and lens aberrations on lens excitation.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
209
11 10 9 8 7 6
1 2 3 4 5
8 Bottom objective pole piece section 1 Specimen stage (pole piece) 2 Specimen 9 Cooling rod 3 Aperture slide 10 Top objective pole piece section 4 Thermistors (pole plate) 5 Objective coil 6 Cooling water chambers 11 Specimen cartridge in the working position 7 Objective stigmator
FIGURE 19
Schematic cross section of the objective lens of the ELMISKOP 102.
To illustrate the design of a high resolution lens, Fig. 19 shows the cross section of a top entry stage lens, as used in the ELMISKOPÒ 102. The specimen is introduced through the 9 mm diameter upper bore into the gap. The stage mounts on the upper pole piece, the specimen in the cartridge is coupled with the stage by cone fitting. High mechanical stability can be achieved by providing good coupling between the upper and lower pole piece and between the upper pole piece and the stage. The coils are beneath the pole piece, so that the space above the lens is kept free for additional equipment. One of the advantages of such a lens is the rotationally symmetrical design, providing very good mechanical and thermal stability. It is demonstrated by the fact that with this lens a ˚ was attained. line resolution of 0.7 A Since focal length, spherical, and chromatic aberration decrease with increasing excitation it is interesting to find out what happens at very high excitations. Figure 20 shows the ray paths within a lens field at three different excitation values for parallel illumination. Path I is the case used in conventional objective lenses: the optical axis is crossed only once; the object is located in the first half of the field. Path II represents the telecentric mode, which is used in the condensor-objective lens according to Riecke and Ruska. Now the object is in the center of the field, the first half of the field acts as a condensor, the second half as objective lens, thus reducing focal length and aberrations. With this kind of lens, aberration coefficients below 1 mm can be obtained at the expense of a very small gap (/3 mm). A disadvantage of the lens for routine use in CTEM is the fact that only small areas of the specimen can be illuminated which is very
210
P. W. Hawkes
B (z) B max 1
III
II I
Z B
A
−1
FIGURE 20 pffiffiffiffiffiffiRay trajectories for parallel illumination pffiffiffiffiffiffi for different lens excitations:
¼ 14, conventional mode; (II) Nl= U ¼ 19, telecentric mode; (I) Nl= pUffiffiffiffiffiffi (III) Nl= U ¼ 28, second zone mode. (A) Object position for CTEM; (B) object position for STEM.
inconvenient at low and medium magnifications. Path III illustrates the pffiffiffiffiffiffi case of an excitation of Nl= U ¼ 28. Now the ray path crosses the optical axis twice, and if one arranges the object in the second half of the lens field for CTEM, focal length and aberration coefficients of the objective part are further reduced, while nearly two thirds of the lens field act as condensor system for parallel illumination (second zone mode). Thus the disadvantages of the telecentric mode are avoided. The most important point, however, is that this lens can combine low aberrations with a large gap and therefore it is very well suited for analytical attachments and STEM.
Lens Systems for CTEM and STEM: Similarities and Differences Now we come to design principles and properties of lens systems, i.e. combinations of electron lenses that are widely used in advanced electron microscopes of the CTEM and STEM type.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
211
Electron gun
First condensor lens Second condensor lens Airlock and beam deflection system Specimen Objective lens First intermediate lens Second intermediate lens Intermediate viewing screen Projector lens Shutter Viewing chamber
Final viewing screen
Plate camera TV flange
FIGURE 21
Schematic cross section of the ELMISKOP 102 column.
In CTEM as well as in STEM the resolution is determined mainly by the objective lens, in a STEM also called the final probe-forming lens. In CTEM one uses in addition to the objective lens several imaging lenses (Fig. 21) to further magnify the image, change magnification in a large range, compensate certain aberrations and switch from the imaging mode to diffraction. In a relatively simple lens system the objective lens is succeeded by an intermediate lens and a projector lens. The intermediate lens images the image plane of the objective into the object plane of the
212
P. W. Hawkes
projector. This again is imaged onto the screen of the microscope. With this combination it is possible to apply Boersch’s ray path for diffraction, i.e. by changing the excitation of the intermediate lens one can alternatively image the back focal plane of the objective lens, where the first diffraction pattern occurs, onto the final screen. By introducing an aperture into the plane of the first intermediate image, selected area diffraction is obtained. If another intermediate lens is used (double intermediate lens), as shown in Fig. 21, one gets a high degree of flexibility, thus being able to keep the objective lens focus constant in a wide range of magnifications, to gain in the low and the high magnification range and to compensate for aberrations and image rotation. Magnetic lenses show image rotation, which depends according to equation (5) on the lens excitation. So at magnification changes the final image tends to rotate. Since the direction of rotation reverses with reversed excitation, it is possible to compensate this effect, in some degree, by proper combination of excitation changes in several of the lenses. More important then compensating this effect is the compensation of some geometrical and chromatic aberrations that cannot be neglected at low and medium magnifications, e.g. isotropic distortion, chromatic aberration of magnification and rotation. Isotropic distortion is known also as pin cushion and barrel distortion. Chromatic aberrations of magnification and rotation must be considered when examining thicker objects with energy losses at lower magnification. By proper combination of imaging lenses, distortion and other aberrations can partly be compensated because of two facts: 1. The coefficients of geometrical aberrations are excitation dependent and change sign at certain excitation values. This is demonstrated in Fig. 22. 2. By reversing the lens polarity some aberration coefficients change sign. When knowing this, one can optimize a lens system in respect to the desired compensations by computer. The basic arrangement of a high resolution STEM imaging system, as first introduced by Crewe, consists, besides of the objective lens, of one or two additional condensor lenses. They have the purpose of demagnifying the tip. As long as the demagnification factor is large enough (i.e. that the Gaussian image of the tip is smaller than the aberration disc) the resolution in STEM with high brightness guns is the same as in CTEM. Since in STEM change of magnification is done by deflection systems, the condensor system can be run at a relatively constant excitation. But it is possible to do without a magnetic condensor, when an electrostatic condensor system in the field emission gun itself is used. This way it is easy to adjust to different illuminating modes and the distance between tip and specimen gets rather small. Another feature of STEM is quite
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
213
Isotropic coma Chrom. aberr. of rotation 1
Chrom. aberr. of magnif. Field curvature
Isotropic distortion Anisotropic astigmatism Isotropic astigmatism 0
6
7
8
9
10
11
NI/√U* 12
13
14
FIGURE 22 Aberration coefficients of an intermediate lens as a function of lens excitation.
important: Chromatic aberrations, as far as they originate from energy losses in the specimen, do not exist, because no imaging lenses are used behind the specimen. Besides of this, as was shown by Crewe, all geometrical aberrations, except spherical aberration, can be compensated for by proper alignment and feeding of the deflection systems. This means, that in STEM it is not necessary to use lens systems for this purpose as in CTEM, but electronic means, which is a great advantage. That is why the requirements on the condensor system are relatively low in STEM, except for the last probe forming lens (objective lens), which must fulfill the same requirements with respect to resolution as in CTEM. Because of this in STEM strong magnetic lenses are used as objective lens. Since its purpose is to form a very small probe with a diameter in the ˚ ) and not to order of the resolution limit of the microscope (2 to 5 A illuminate a larger field of view it seems obvious to use the telecentric mode of operation (preceding section). The disadvantages are, however, that to obtain low aberrations quite a small gap must be used, and the separation between scattered and unscattered beam, which is necessary for an efficient detector design, is unsatisfactory. Therefore one can either use an excitation near the telecentric mode, lower excitation or very high
214
P. W. Hawkes
excitation (second zone case), which seems to be the optimum, since then a large gap can be combined with low aberrations. Another important design principle should be mentioned: The most sensitive region in respect to mechanical vibrations and stray fields is in a CTEM between objective lens and first intermediate lens, since here the first magnification takes place. Therefore it is necessary to couple these elements very rigidly. In a STEM the same holds between tip and objective lens. Figure 23 shows an example for the design of an advanced STEM imaging system; it is the column of the ELMISKOP ST100F. The objective lens represents a high excitation lens with large gap for analytical attachments and goniometer devices. The coefficients of spherical and chromatic aberration are 1.3 mm both, allowing a resolution of 0.2 nm. The field emission gun incorporates an electrostatic einzel-lens condensor. For SEM imaging and obtaining a wide field of view at low magnifications, a mini-lens is integrated into the upper part of the objective lens. Since the objective lens is run in the second zone mode and the stage allows movement in z-direction, the scattering angles can be matched very well to the detectors. For adjusting to optimum illuminating conditions for the energy analyzer another mini-lens in the lower part of the objective lens could be incorported.
Field emission cathode with ‘einzel’ lens system
F.E.gun
SF6 Insulator
Differentially pumped aperture with valve
Illumination aperture
Static deflection systems
Dynamic deflection systems Mini lens Objective aperture
Objective lens Specimen
Detector aperture Detector area Dark-field detector Energy analyzer Bright-field detector
FIGURE 23 Schematic cross section of the column and ray path of the ELMISKOP ST 100F.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
215
Requirements for Analytical Microscopy Although the first and, until recently, main interest in electron microscopy was to create electron images and interpret them, there is a steadily increasing trend to get more information out of the instrument. This is due to the fact that an electron beam impinging on a specimen is not only scattered, but generates several secondary events that carry a lot of information about the specimen. Figure 24 demonstrates this by showing some of the signals that can be obtained from a specimen. Besides studying transmission electron images, there have been many successful efforts to use especially the surface image and X-ray and energy loss analysis in addition. In a STEM, a combination of these different techniques is relatively easy to attain, since the information is collected seriesly. That is why scanning attachments to CTEMs have been designed in recent years. When combining analytical techniques with an electron microscope one always has to compromise between the requirements for an optimum analysis system and the imaging system. This also holds when different imaging modes, e.g. STEM and CTEM, are to be combined. Generally, one needs for analytical microscopy a wide lens gap or a large upper pole piece bore, to position the X-ray detector (e.g. energy-dispersive system) as close as possible to the specimen to get a high yield. In addition, it is desirable, especially in material science investigations, to have specimen
XMA
Signal of backscattered electrons BS hnR SE
SEA
hnL
Signal of secondary electrons Specimen current signal
SEA
Signal of luminescence
SEA
Dark-field signal
SEA
Signal of energy loss
SEA
FIGURE 24
Possibilities for obtaining signals from a specimen.
Bright-field signal
216
P. W. Hawkes
manipulation facilities, which also require space around the specimen. On the other hand, by opening the lens gap or the upper bore, there will be a loss of resolution, which can only be tolerated to a certain extend. A way to solve this problem is to use a high excitation lens in the second zone mode, as described in section ‘‘Strong Lenses’’. With this type of lens one can obtain with a gap width of 8 mm aberration coefficients of 1.3 mm and with a gap width of 12 mm coefficients around 2 mm. Such a lens has another important feature: If the specimen is not located in the second half of the lens field as for CTEM, but in the first half, this part then acts as probe forming lens (Fig. 20) with low aberration coefficients for STEM. Now we will consider the case, where CTEM, STEM, and surface imaging are to be used alternatively with the same instruments as in CTEM with scanning attachments. To combine CTEM and STEM, one usually uses the complete illumination system of the CTEM including the two condensor lenses. Besides working in the telecentric mode there are two possible ways for the change from CTEM to STEM mode: 1. One uses an objective lens, that is capable of high excitations and keeps the position of the object constant while the excitation of the lens is changed between two values. In one excitation state a probe is focussed into the object plane (STEM), in the other the object plane is imaged into the intermediate lens (CTEM). Since one of these states uses lower, the other higher excitation there is always a difference in aberration coefficients and possible resolution between them. Due to the large difference in excitation there is also the danger of loosing alignment when changing the excitation. 2. Change of excitation can be avoided, when the specimen is shifted to the back focal plane for STEM, then the aberrations and alignment are the same in both cases. But, of course, for this a good mechanical lift stage is necessary. In order to obtain surface images, either secondary or backscattered electrons can be used. The backscattered electron detector is a solid state detector that can be arranged within or above the upper bore of the objective lens. To use secondary electrons is more difficult. Since they are slow, and the specimen is located within a strong magnetic field, they follow the lines of force of the field. Thus it is necessary to use an objective lens with relatively large upper bore to extract them from the lens field. Therefore, the SE-detector can only be arranged properly in a lens with asymmetric shroud as demonstrated in Fig. 25. For a lens with symmetric iron shroud it is best to switch off the objective lens for SEM imaging and arrange the detector in the gap, but then one must take care that the demagnification of the source is still large enough to get good SEM resolution.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
217
10 kV SE
300 V SE-detector
FIGURE 25 Detection of secondary electrons in a high resolution objective lens.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am most grateful to the many people who have provided the information on which this chapter is based. For the AEI STEM, Mrs. John Banbury and several present or past members of the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge: Richard Henderson, Nigel Unwin, Aaron Klug, and Annette Faux. For the Siemens ST100F, Frau Alexandra Kintner at the Siemens archives, Dieter Willasch and Reinhard Schliepe, who were directly involved in the development of the instrument, and Frau Dr. Cilly Weichan, formerly of Siemens; Don Williams and also Robin Cross, Alan Hall, Dave Johnson, and Bryan Sewell (the Cape Town STEM); Frau Sabine Dongard (the Dortmund instrument); Wolfgang Baumeister and Hannes Lichte (the Munich–Tu¨bingen model); Manfred Essig (the BASF microscope in Ludwigshafen); and Antonio Sesso (the Brazil microscope). The instrument destined for the Institute for Transuranium Elements remains a mystery. The micrographs were clearer in the original documents, they have lost some sharpness in reproduction.
REFERENCES Alderson, R. H. (1971). High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy. AEI Electron Microscope News 2, 2. Ardenne, M. von (1938). Das Elektronen-Rastermikroskop. Praktische Ausfu¨hrung. Z. techn. Physik 19, 404 Banbury, J. R. (1974). Operation of an experimental high voltage field emission STEM. Proc. 8th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Canberra 1, 44–45. Banbury, J. R., and Bance, U. R. (1973a). A prototype field emission scanning transmission electron microscope. In ‘‘Proc. Scanning Electron Microscopy, Newcastle,’’ (W. C. Nixon ed.), pp. 164–168. Institute of Physics, London. Banbury, J. R., and Bance, U. R. (1973b). A prototype field-emission scanning transmission electron microscope. Proc. EMSA 31, 296–297. Banbury, J. R., Drummond, I. W., and Ray, I. L. F. (1975). Performance and applications of a high resolution field emission STEM. Proc. EMSA 33, 112–113. Blaschke, R. (1972). Einige anwendungstechnische Gesichtspunkte fu¨r Raster-Elektronenmikroskopie im Durchstrahlungsbereich. Beitra¨ge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberfla¨che 5, 965–976.
218
P. W. Hawkes
Butler, J. W. (1966). Digital computer techniques in electron microscopy. Proc. 6th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Kyoto 1, 191–192. Cowley, J. M. (1974). Scanning transmission electron microscopy of thick and crystalline specimens. Proc. 8th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Canberra I, 18–19. Crewe, A. V. (1974). High resolution scanning microscopy. Proc. 8th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Canberra I, 20–21. ˚ resolution. J. Molec. Biol. 48, Crewe, A. V., and Wall, J. (1970). A scanning microscope with 5A 375–393. Crewe, A. V., Eggenberger, D. N., Wall, J., and Welter, L. M. (1968). Electron gun using a field emission source. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 39, 576–583. Crewe, A. V., Langmore, J. P., Lamvik, M. K., and Pullman, J. (1974). Scanning electron microscopy of unstained and selectively stained biological specimens. Proc. 8th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Canberra II, 162–163. Gauger, W., Gottschlich, H.-J., Krisch, B., Veneklasen, L. H., and Zschimmer, M. (1975). 100kV Feldemissionsstrahler. Beitra¨ge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberfla¨che 8, 331–338. Groves, T. (1975). Thick specimens in the CEM and STEM. Resolution and image formation. Ultramicroscopy 1, 15–31. Hoppe, W. (1982). Trace structure analysis, ptychography, phase tomography. Ultramicroscopy 10, 187–198. Hubert, G., Willasch, D., and Krisch, B. (1978). Results on obtaining strutural and analytical information with high lateral resolution in a STEM. Proc. 9th Int. Cong. Electron Microsc. Toronto 1, 22–23. Jones, A. V., and Haider, M. (1989). Modular detector system for scanning transmission electron microscope. Scanning Microsc. Part 3, 33–42. Jones, A. V., Homo, J.-C., Unitt, B. M., and Webster, N. (1985). The CryoSTEM: a STEM with superconducting objective lens. J. Microsc. Spectrosc. Electron. 10, 361–370. Kempin, H.-J., Mu¨ller, K. H., Rauch, M., von Scha¨fer, N., and Vollborn, K. (1975). Ein Hochauflo¨sungsobjektiv mit Goniometer. Beitra¨ge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberfla¨che 8, 339–346. Krisch, B., Mu¨ller, K.-H., Rindfleisch, V., and Schliepe, R. (1975). Signalelektronik fu¨r hochauflo¨sende Durchstrahlungs-Rastermikroskopie. Beitra¨ge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberfla¨che 8, 325–330. Krisch, B., Mu¨ller, K.-H., Schliepe, R., and Willasch, D. (1976a). The ELMISKOP ST100F, a high-performance transmission scanning elecron microscope. Siemens Rev. 43, 390–393. Krisch, B., Mu¨ller, K.-H., Schliepe, R., and Willasch, D. (1976b). ELMISKOP ST100F, ein Durchstrahlungs-Rasterelektronenmikroskop ho¨chster Leistung. Siemens Z. 50, 47–50. Krisch, B., Mu¨ller, K. H., Rauch, M., von Schliepe, R., and Thieringer, H. M. (1977). Analytical microscopy using a high-resolution STEM. Scanning Electron Microsc 423–430. Leuthner, T. (1992). Off-axis STEM-Holographie. Dissertation, Tu¨bingen. Leuthner, T., Lichte, H., and Herrmann, K.-H. (1989). STEM-holography using the electron biprism. Phys. Stat. Sol. (A) 116, 113–121. Leuthner, T., Sum, J., Lichte, H., and Herrmann, K.-H. (1990). STEM-holography. Proc. 12th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Seattle 1, 224–225. Lucas, J. H. (1970). A 60 double tilt stage for the AEI EM820. Proc. 7th Int. Cong. Electron Microscopy, Grenoble 1, 159–160. Ray, I. L. F., Drummond, I. W., and Banbury, J. R. (1976). A high resolution field emission scanning transmission electron microscope with energy analysis. In ‘‘Developments in Electron Microscopy and Analysis, Proceedings of EMAG1975,’’ ( J. A. Venables ed.), pp. 11–14. Academic Press, London & New York. Ruel, K., Barnoud, F., and Goring, D. A. I. (1978). Lamellation in the S2 layer of softwood tracheids as demonstrated by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Wood Sci. Technol. 12, 287–291.
Two Commercial STEMs: The Siemens ST100F and the AEI STEM-1
219
Schliepe, R. (1978). Das ELMISKOP ST 100 F. Aufbau, Funktionsweise und Anwendungen eines hochauflo¨senden Durchstrahlungs-Rasterelektronenmikroskops (STEM). Typescript, Siemens Archives. Sum, J. (1995). Off-Axis STEM-Holographie. Erweiterte Untersuchung der Grundlagen und Einsatz eines Computers zur Mikroskopsteuerung und Signalauswertung. Dissertation, Tu¨bingen. Thieringer, H. M. (1972). Transmission scanning electron microscopy and energy analysis with the Siemens ELMISKOP 101. Proc. EMSA 30, 450–451. Willasch, D. (1975). Das neue Transmissions-Rasterelektronenmikroskop ELMISKOP ST100F. Beitra¨ge zur elektronenmikroskopischen Direktabbildung von Oberfla¨che 8, 757–770. Willasch, D. (1976a). High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy; aspects and trends of a new method. J. Microsc. Spectrosc. Electron. 1, 505–506. Willasch, D. (1976b). Features and applications of a high resolution scanning transmission electron microscope. Proceedings 15th Annual Conference of EMSSA, pp. 1–2.
Chapter
6 A History of Vacuum Generators’ 100-kV Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope Ian R. M. Wardell* and Peter E. Bovey†
Contents
1. The Early Days 2. Design Considerations for a Commercial STEM 2.1. The Objective Lens 2.2. The Specimen Stage 2.3. The Electron Gun 2.4. Location of Analytical Facilities 2.5. The Resultant Assembly 3. The First STEMs and HB5 Development 3.1. The Optical Column 3.2. Stage Development 3.3. Early Airlock and Manipulator 3.4. The Dark-Field Detector 3.5. Secondary Electron Detector 3.6. Diffraction Facilities 3.7. The Energy Analyzer Mk1 3.8. Electronics 4. Improved Resolution 4.1. The MIT HB5 4.2. The University of Illinois HB5 5. Other Developments 5.1. Beam-Blanking Plates 5.2. Detectors and the Virtual Objective Aperture 5.3. Stage Motor Drives
222 224 225 225 226 226 227 227 232 238 240 241 245 246 249 251 254 254 255 256 256 257 261
* Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Brighton, United Kingdom {
Lindfield, West Sussex, United Kingdom
Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, Volume 159, ISSN 1076-5670, DOI: 10.1016/S1076-5670(09)59006-4. Copyright # 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
221
222
Ian R. M. Wardell and Peter E. Bovey
5.4. New Airlock 5.5. Energy Analyzer Mk2 5.6. Gun Lens 5.7. High-Excitation Objective Lens 6. Stages and Cartridges 6.1. Basic Cartridges 6.2. Beryllium Cartridges 6.3. Cold Stage 6.4. Cryo-Transfer System 7. The HB501 7.1. General Development 7.2. HB501UX and High-Resolution Imaging 8. Special and Variant Instruments 8.1. University of Glasgow’s HB5 8.2. The HB501A 9. The HB601 10. Postscript Acknowledgments References
262 264 266 266 268 268 269 269 270 271 271 273 273 275 276 278 280 282 283
1. THE EARLY DAYS Vacuum Generators (VG) was founded in 1962 by Bernard Eastwell and the late Vic Treasure as an ultra-high vacuum (UHV) technology company. The primary objective was to meet the growing worldwide need of academic and industrial research and development laboratories for UHV systems and associated components. The company’s growth strategy, however, was not simply to satisfy this generic market demand but to develop instrumentation that could address a wide variety of research projects requiring a UHV environment. The first example of this strategy was the development of a low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) system, such as that used by Reid and Mykura (1969), for the study of surface structures in a clean environment. Shortly thereafter retarding field LEED Auger was introduced (Bishop, Rivie`re, and Coad, 1971), followed by the development of a hemi-cylindrical Auger electron spectrometer (Bishop, Coad, and Rivie`re, 1972/3). The latter device was the result of a cooperative project between VG and Hugh Bishop and John Rivie`re at the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Laboratories, Harwell. VG’s X-ray photo-electron spectrometer (XPS) system (Brundle et al., 1974) was introduced in the early 1970s; the work by Brundle and Roberts (1972) using this equipment helped establish electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis (ESCA) as an important surface analysis technique.
A History of Vacuum Generators’ 100-kV Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope
223
All these instruments required UHV conditions for their operation and it was against this background of UHV technology–based developments that the imagination of VG’s founders was captured by the widely publicized work of Albert Crewe (Crewe et al., 1968, 1969, 1971; Crewe and Wall, 1970) on his high-resolution cold field-emission source scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) in Chicago. Eastwell and Treasure were familiar with field emission electron sources as a result of their time at the Mullard Research Laboratories, Salfords, UK, where they had worked before establishing VG. Instrumentation based on the field emission source therefore presented another opportunity for the company to exploit its core UHV technology. A collaborative project was set up with a group at the National Physical Laboratory (NPL), Teddington, that included Peter Stuart, Martin Seah, Milt Lilburne, and Albert Franks. The objective was to develop ˚ resolution, to be known jointly a field emission source STEM with 10-A as the HB10. The nomenclature ‘‘HB’’ was derived from the high brightness of the field emission source. VG would supply the UHV and other engineering expertise and NPL the electron optical design. In June 1970, VG recruited one of the authors (PEB) to liaise with NPL on the project and, in particular, to work with them to develop a stable field emission source for a commercial instrument (Lilburne, Herd, and Stuart, 1970). This resulted in the decision to select <310>-or