Contributors PENELOPE J. BROTHERS (223), Department of Chemistry. The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand BARR...
35 downloads
2000 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Contributors PENELOPE J. BROTHERS (223), Department of Chemistry. The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand BARRETT EICHLER ( I ), Department ofChemistry, University ofcalifornia-Davis. Davis, California 956 I5 MARK G. HUMPHREY (47) Department of Chemistry, Australian National University. Canberra, ACT 0200 Australia LALEH JAFARPOUR (ISI), Department of Chemistry. University of New Orleans, New Orleans, Louisiana 70 148-2920 IL NAM JUNG ( 145). Organosilicon Chemistry Laboratory. Korea Institute of Science and Technology, Seoul 130-650, Korea NIGEL T. LUCAS (47), Department of Chemistry. Australian National University. Canberra, ACT 0200 Australia STEVEN P. NOLAN (181) Department of Chemistry, University of New Orleans. New Orleans. Louisiana 70148-2920 SUSAN M. WATERMAN (47). Department of Chemistry, Australian National University. Canberra ACT 0200 Australia ROBERT WEST (I), Department of Chemistry, University of Wisconsin. Madison, Wisconsin 53706-1396 BOK RYUL YOO ( l45), Organosilicon Chemistry Laboratory. Korea Institute of Science and Technology. Seoul 130-650, Korea
vii
ADVANCES
IN ORGANOMETALLIC
CHEMISTRY,
VOL. 46
Chemistry of G roup 14 Heteroallenes BARRETT
EICHLER
Department of Chemfsfry University of California-Davis Davis, California 95616
ROBERT WEST Department of Chemistry University of Wisconsin Madison, Wisconsin 53706 I. II. III.
IV.
V.
Introduction Bonding Theory Synthesis and Reactions A. Transient I-Silaallenea B. Transient I-Silaketcnes. C. Stable Heteroallenes Physical Properties A. X-ray Structure Determination. B. NMR Spectroscopy Future Prospects References.
,........
.............. .............. .............. .............. ..............
I 2 5 5 14 I/ 34 34 40 43 43
I INTRODUCTION
An allene (or 1,2-propadiene) is a moiety with two cumulated double bonds between three atoms (R2C=C=CR2). The central atom of the allene is therefore sp-hybridized. The r-bond of one double bond is orthogonal to the other and this unusual n-bonding arrangement can lead to unique electronic effects (Fig. I). This also results in steric properties at the ends of the allene by forcing the substituents to also be orthogonal to each other. This review will focus on allenes which have at least one carbon atom replaced by a heavier group I4 atom, commonly referred to as a heteroallene. Group I4 heteroallenes have appeared in the literature over the last 20 years, and stable examples of this moiety have been synthesized since 1992. Heteroallenes that do not have a group 14 heteroatom will not be discussed, although it is useful to consider phosphaallenes, which have been reviewed by Regitz in 1990.’ To date, heteroallenes with the heteroatom at the end of the allene, the one position, have been easier to synthesize because of their thermodynamic stability compared to those with the heteroatom as the middle atom, the two position.
1 All rights
Copyright c’ 2001 by Academic Press. of reproduction in any form reserved. 006%3055/01 $35.00
2
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
II
BONDING
THEORY
Heteroallene structures can be regarded as depending on the extent ofcontribution from each of two bonding arrangements (Fig. 2). Bonding Model A depicts both the heteroatom and the carbon atom in the triplet state, forming one a-bond and one r-bond to make a formal double bond. Lappert et 01.‘~’first postulated bonding Model B, and illustrated bonding between the heteroatom and the carbon atom in singlet states that “may be described as a ‘double’ n-donor-acceptor interaction.” according to Griitzmacher et ~l.‘~ Differences between these two models
Model
\. /
A
M.
1
./
.(‘=c‘
h \
\ /
M=c‘=(‘
/ \
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes TABLE RELATIVE ENEKGIES OF C2HISi H$.Y=Si=CH:
H$i=C=CHJ
I ISOMEKS (kcal IIIOHjSi-C=CH
) Ref.
leads to obvious differences in geometry in order to maximize orbital overlap. Model A should lead to a linear allene backbone and Model B should produce a structure bent at the central carbon, as well as pyramidalization at the heteroatom. The key issue in determining which model applies to a particular system is the singlet-triplet energy difference’ for both atoms involved in bonding. Typically, the triplet state is favored only for carbon, whereas silicon, germanium, tin, and lead favor the singlet state. The filled orbitals of the heavier atoms are progressively richer in s-character and therefore the singlet state becomes more energetically favorable as one moves down the periodic table. Thus, the pure carbon allene bonding is dominated by the triplet contribution, and so the Ci=CI=C3 bond angle should be I80 ‘. In the heteroallenes, the bond angle may deviate from I80 ‘, and the bending is predicted to increase as the size of the heteroatom increases. The empirical results. which agree very well with this view, will be discussed later. Several groups have reported ab initio calculations of CzH$Si isomers’m7,“‘: some of the results are listed in Table I. The most stable structure is ethynylsilane. Relative to this molecule, I silapropadiene is less stable by about 25-30 kcal mop’ (Ref. 12(f) places the energy of the parent silaallene ca. 55 kcal mall’ above ethynylsilane) and 2-silapropadiene is even more unstable, lying ca. 50 kcal mall’ above ethynylsilane. This is consistent with the fact that I-heteroallenes have been isolated, but 2-heteroallenes are still unknown. A recent calculation’” of the relative energies of CH$iO isomers shows that a bent silylene-carbon monoxide adduct (lone pair donation from carbon to empty p-orbital on silicon) is the most stable. and the planar/linear H$i=C==O isomer (strong double bond between silicon and carbon) lies 16.6 kcal mol’ higher in energy (Fig. 3). Earlier energy calculations of (CH&SiCO provide contrasting results depending on the methods used-MNDO/AM I calculations predict the minimum energy structure is the planar/linear silaketene, but ah initio calculations favor the pyramidal silylene-CO adduct. Although no stable heteroketenes have been synthesized to date, structural, spectroscopic, and reactivity data from related heteroketenimines (Sects. IIIC3 and IV) also suggest that the silylene-CO adduct is more stable.
4
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WES-I
slylene-carbon
monoxide
lineal-/planar silaketene
adduct
FI(~. 3.
It is instructive to examine the atomic charges predicted for various propadienes. The normal polarization of the Si=C double bond in silenes is calculated to be strongly polarized, Si+-C-, with large net charges of fO.46 on silicon and -0.67 on carbon (Table II). In allene itself, the C=C bonds are also substantially polarized, with net negative charge on the outer two carbon atoms6 In 2-silaallenes. the net charges on silicon and carbon are predicted to be quite similar to those in silenes, but in I-silaallenes, the net charges on all three atoms are greatly reduced. The normal allene polarization evidently cancels out much of the Si=C polarization. Thus, I -silaallenes are far less polar than silenes and 2-silallenes, and so may be less reactive toward polar reagents. Calculations have been reported only for silaketenes (see below), but similar trends are likely for the other group I4 heteroallenes. Apeloig and co-workers have pointed out that decreased polarity of the Si=C double bond is also calculated for silenes with oxygen substitution, i.e.. H2Si=CH(OSiH3).” In this case. the reduced net charges are due to resonance electron donation by oxygen. The calculations are in accord with the greater Si=C bond length. increased ‘“Si shielding. and decreased ‘jC shielding found in Coxygen-substituted silenes. compared with ailenes lacking oxygen substituents. Atomic charges were calculated ” for parent silaketene, HlSiCO, using generalized atomic polar tensor (GAPT) population analysis. Two geometries were investigated-the “doubly bonded” planar and the “silylene-CO adduct” bent. The most important point relative to the examination of heteroallenes is that the planar structure has a significantly more negative charge on silicon (-0.05, C = + I .27) than does the bent structure (f0.32. C = +0.X I ). Based on the charge calculations for silaallenes, a slight negative charge on silicon seems unlikely, making the bent structure a better model than the planar structure.
TABLE
II
rs,=c.pn’
Si. Chg.
Ref.
171.x 170.2 170. I
+o.lh +o 17 fO.50
9 IO IO
Chemistry
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
SYNTHESIS
AND REACTIONS
A. Transient I-Silaallenes
Extensive studies of the photolysis and thermolysis of alkynylsilanes and silacyclopropenes were carried out by Kumada and Ishikawa, beginning in 1977. The first report of a group 14 heteroallene in the literature was the proposal by this group of a transient I -silaallene as a product of the photolysis of a I alkynyldisilane (la)“” (Scheme I). When this precursor was irradiated in the presence of methanol, a I .3-silyl migration occurred. The major products (400/r) were methoxysilaethenes. whose existence can be explained as being methanol adducts of I -silacyclopropene (2). Two additional methoxysilanes were isolated in a combined yield of 2 I YCand were rationalized as methanol trapping products of the intermediate silaallene 3. A similar photolysis of la in the presence of acetone produced the transient acetone adduct of the I -silaallene, a 2-silaoxetane,
PhC-CSiMqSiMcj
hv
-
A Ph
MC2 Si -
t SiMci
2
I
PhC=CSiMe;
MeOH
(PTMSA)
PI1
SiMe,
PI1 +
MeOMqSi
H
II
Ph
SiMqOMe
Ph
H
+ MeiSi
II %HhhlE
MqSi i
SiMezOMc
6
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WE.3
Mc;Si
3
MqC=O
\
( MezSiO),, % ‘HI:Mb
2.
which decomposed to an allene (4-5s isolated yield) and a siloxane (Scheme 2). This type of decomposition has been seen with other 2-silaoxetanes made from the ketone cycloadducts of silenes.13 It was proposed that photolysis of both la and 2 can eliminate :SiMez and phenyltrimethylsi1ylacetylene (PTMSA). Although this silylene elimination was not observed for the reaction in Scheme I, PTMSA was isolated in 5% yield in another reaction using methanol, and in 10% yield from the acetone trapping reaction in Scheme 2. Further studies’2h-” spanning nearly I5 years suggested that photolysis of other alkynylpolysilanes can, but do not necessarily, form I-silaallenes. In the paperlzh following the original communication, six I -alkynylpolysilanes were irradiated in the presence of methanol, but only four of the six (Sa-c, e) gave methanol adducts of I-silaallenes [~--EC). ( I )I. There is no clear-cut substituent pattern leading to I silaallenc production, but it seems that those precursors having more phenyl groups lead to higher yields of I -silaallene trapping products (cis + trans yields: 5a = l6%, 5b = 34%. 5c = 44%, 5e = 28%). The alkynylpolysilanes Sa-c and e were also irradiated from 3 to 9 h in the absence of methanol followed by immediate methanolysis of the photolysis products. None of the methanol adducts of I-silaallenes was found from these experiments, indicating that the I silaallenes. if formed, survived for only a very short time in solution. R’
II
hv
t+C‘ZC’SiR’R2R’
(a) R ’
R’ = MC. R’ = SIMCJ’II
(b) R’
Me. R’ = Ph. R’ = SiMq
(c) R’
R’=
(cl) R’ = R’= (c) R’
Ph. R’
SiMc,
Me. R’ = SiMc2S~Mc;
Me. R’
(1) R’ = K’
R’=
>=(
)
R’ = SIMC; SIMC:
II
cis-6
+
MeOH
5
S,R’K?OMC
I<’
II
II
SIR’R’OM~
mm-6
(I)
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes
MelSi
I
(MejSi)$J=C’=SiMesl 9
I
I
1 MeOH
J
SiMqOMe (MqSi)2C=(.: ti
10 SCHEMt:
3.
In another study,“’ Kumada and Ishikawa proposed that the stable 1-silacyclopropene 7, when irradiated in the presence of methanol, equilibrated with 1-alkynylpolysilane 8 and produced the methanol adduct (10) of the 1-silaallene 9 in 36% yield (Scheme 3). From previous studies using ultraviolet radiation as the photon source, it was shown that 8 was the most likely precursor to I-silaallene 9. Compound 7 was never indicated as a direct source of 9. From the observation that 8 is stable to visible light, whereas 7 is not, the authors inferred that the silaallene can be created from both 7 and 8. When 7 was irradiated with UV light for IO h, 7 and 8 were found in a constant 2/3 ratio irrespective of the time of irradiation, showing that 7 and 8 were equilibrating with each other. Irradiation of 7 with UV light in the presence of methanol gave methanol adduct (10) of I -silaallene 9 in 32% yield. But when a Pyrex filter (allowing only visible light to reach 7) was included in the photolysis with methanol present, compounds 8 and 10 were produced in 60 and 16% yields, respectively, clearly indicating that 7 . was converting to 9 when photolyzed. Experiments reported in 1982’Id by the same group provided the first example of heteroallene dimerization. In this work, head-to-head dimerization of I silaallenes Ila-c (Scheme 4) was observed, forming l,2-disilacyclobutanes 12a-c with two exocyclic double bonds.
8
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
hv MelSiC-CSIArlSiMq
(MeqSI),C‘=(‘=SiAr:
___f
I
I
Ila-c
(a) Ar = wtolyl
(yield
= 20%~)
(b) Ar =/I-tolyl
(yield
= 21%)
(c) Ar = o-tolyl
(yield
= 2%‘)
*
m-adiatcd
in the prescncc
his-trimethylsilylacetylene improve
(Me$i)&‘N
//(SiMe?)> C-C’ I ArzSi-SiAr,
of
I
to
yteld
12a-c
When alkynyldisilanes 13a and b were photolyzedizg in the presence of freshly generated dimesitylsilylene (Mes?Si:), the silylene added to the Si=C double bond of I -silaallenes 14a and b to form disilacyclopropanes 15a and b (Scheme 5). Even without the independently generated silylene. photolysis of 13b produced 15b in 8% yield, but compound 13a gave only traces of Ea. In the case of 15b, the dimesitylsilylene most likely originated from silacyclopropene 16.
RCE-CSiMqSiMq
hv
h
R \ Mc;Si
13a,b
C=C‘=SIMes2
/
14a,b
’
[ :SiMw] hv
MCSz Si
R
A
[ :SiMesl]
t
SiMq
RCCSiMel
16a,b
1 i
(a) R
SlMc
(b)
Ph
R
SiMe,
R \
c
3’
Chemistry
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
PhCGCSiR’R’SiMe
1
1
(a) R,=R2= Me (b) RI-R,= SiMe3 (c) RI= SiMq, Rx: Mes
180-200°C I O-20 h, Ni cat.
PhC=<‘SIMe? I I LlNi-SiR’R’
17 -
- NiLz
NiLz PTMS ‘A
x2
I R’R? PhC-CPh II \ Me;SIC,Ci,CSiMe;
Ph
,, Si, _
.,SiMe3
Mc3Si>~c\Sl/c=(\Yh
klR2
R’R’
20
21
- NIL-,
Me2
23
PTMSA
Me:
24
SCHEME 6.
The Kumada/Ishikawa group also investigated thermolytic reactions ofalkynylpolysilanes and silacyclopropenes in the presence of nickel catalysts and implicated a I-silaallene-nickel complex as an intermediate in the reaction pathway to the observed products.“h-k When alkynylpolysilanes la-c (Schemes 6 and 7) were heated to 1SO-2Oo’C for 20 h in the presence of a catalytic amount of NiCI,(PEt& (la,b) or Ni(PEt3)d (lc) and two equivalents of PTMSA, products
IO
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
I
R’=R’-
-NiLI
SiMq
PTMSA I
Ph
1 PhC=CSiMel I \ ,Me MqSi ’ Ni %iFvlt 1~2
MelSib--C
I ‘C-SiR’R’
‘1 I
I I PhC‘=CSiMej
25 27 - NiLl
PTMSA
;“z MejSiC ’
‘CPh
II
IICSiMei
Ph<
‘Si.( Me’
‘SiMeJ
26
were observed.“h Intermediates 17 (a nickelsilacyclobutene) and 18 and 19 (two isomeric I-silaallene-nickel complexes) were proposed to be in equilibrium with each other and were formed initially by a 1,3-trimethylsilyl shift. Intermediate 17a added PTMSA (Scheme 6) with loss of NIL? to form silole 20a (32%), whereas intermediate 18a simply underwent head-to-tail dimerization (-NiL2, IS%). Intermediate 19a performed an unusual rearrangement where the nickel moves a -SiMe* fragment from a -SiMe3 group to the cr-carbon, replacing the -SiMe? fragment with the remaining methyl group, forming intermediate 22a. This then added PTMSA to give a perfectly statistical distribution of isomers 23a (23%) and 24a (23%). The greater steric bulk of lb (two SiMe? groups) over that 2130
11
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes 2la (74%)
/“...
20 h cat. C12(PEt?)~Ni-PhC-CPh
PhC-CSiSiMqMeJ
cat.CI~(PEtl)~Ni-Me$iSiMe~H 200°C.2” h/.
Ia
MQ Ph\-
kCSi ’ ‘c=c’ Me;Si ’ ‘Si MC2
SiMe; ‘Ph
2la (28%),20a (3%). 23a + 24a (5%~)
2la (78%)
of la (two Me groups) caused the alkynylpolysilane to follow a completely different mechanistic pathway (Scheme 7). Compound lb did not produce any of the same compounds as la, instead forming 26 (58%) and 27a (19%). Compound 26 presumably formed via intermediate 17b, which rearranged in a manner similar to the formation of intermediate 22, and then added PTMSA. Compound 27b is the adduct of PTMSA with 1-silaallene intermediate 18b. Thermolysis of la with various nickel catalysts gave some surprising results (Scheme 8).lzh Possibly the most unexpected finding was that the thermolysis of la with NiClz(PEt& in the absence of PTMSA left la unchanged, but when it was heated with a catalytic amount of NiCl,(PEt&PhCCSiMe;, dimerization product 21a (28%) and PTMSA adducts 20a (3%) and 23 + 24a (5%) were obtained. Again in the absence of PTMSA, heating la with NiC17(PEt3)2-PhCCPh gave 21a (74%) and with NiCl2 (PEt&-Me$iSiMe2H also gave 21a (78%). To see if silacyclobutenes (28) would react in the same manner as the alkynylpolysilanes (1) and respond similarly to steric differences, compounds 28a and b were heated in the presence of NiCIz(PEt& and PTMSA (Scheme 9).“’ Cornpound 28a gave silole 20a in 94% yield, “j but the only isolable products from the thermolysis of 28b were 26 (51%) and 27b (36%). The products from the thermolysis of silacyclopropene 28b were very similar to that for alkynylsilane lb, but for some reason there were many fewer products for the thermolysis of 28a than for alkynylsilane la. These results suggest that the more sterically hindered lb
12
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST R’ ‘&/
R’
200°C. 20 h
w cat. NiCIz(PEt3)2
I\
PhC’=C‘SiMq
20a(94%)
28a 135°C. 15 I1 28b
L-
26(51%)
cat. NiCl2(PEt~)~ SC‘HI-.hlli
+
27b(36%)
9.
and 28b prefer the I -silaallene intermediate 18b, whereas the smaller precursors la and 28a prefer the nickelsilacyclobutene intermediate 17a, although electronic differences cannot be ruled out as important factors. To further illustrate the effect of steric hindrance, a bulky mesityl group was added to the alkynylpolysilane (lc) (Eq. (2)). “’ When lc was heated in the presence of Ni(PEt& and PTMSA, compounds 27c (77%) and 2Y (I I%-a compound similar to 26) were obtained, which is a product distribution similar to that of bulky lb.
;‘1 195°C 20 h IC
Ni(PEt3)4, PTMSA
MelSiC ’
-
27c(77%)
+
‘CPh
II
II
Ph(
C’Mc
‘Si.( MciSi
/
\
(2)
Mcs
29
Numerous other studies” by Ishikawa and co-workers, with or without nickel catalysts, have reinforced the importance of I -silaallenes and nickel-complexed I-silaallenes as intermediates in the pathways of the photolyses and thermolyses of alkynylsilanes. Barton and co-workersI performed flash vacuum pyrolysis (FVP) on trimethylsilylvinylmethylchlorosilane (30), resulting in the production of trimethylchlorosilane (30%), trimethylvinylsilane (I 1.5%) and most interestingly, ethynylmethylsilane (34, I I .9%). A proposed mechanism for the synthesis of 34 (Scheme IO) begins with the loss of trimethylchlorosilane to form silylene 31, which can rearrange either to silaallene 32 or to silirene 33, both of which can lead to the isolated ethynylsilane. Maier et al.’ studied the FVP of another vinylsilane, 35 (Scheme II). They proposed that, instead of leading directly to the observed products, silaallene 37
Chemistry
800°C
4 x 10m4torr 1
13
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
H
\
1 Si=(.=CI12 / fl MC 32
\ /
l12MeSi---C’ECfI
%‘HfihlE
10
was in an equilibrium process with silylene 36 and that the silylene directly made silacyclopropene 38, which photolyzed to ethynylsilane 39.
The early photolysis studies of Kumada and Ishikawa have been greatly augmented by recent investigations of the laser flash photolyses by Leigh and his students, in which the silapropadienes have been characterized spectroscopically.‘h.‘7 Thus, the flash photolysis of 40 using a KrF excimer laser produced transient compounds 41 and 42, along with a non-decaying species, 43” (Scheme 13). These products were identified on the basis of their UV absorption spectra and reactivity. Silaallene 41 is a minor (-15%) photoproduct, but could be identified because it is relatively long lived compared with silylene 42, and has rather strong electronic absorption bands at 275 and 325 nm. Compound 41 reacted with MeOH, r-BuOH, HOAc, acetone, and 02; absolute rate constants were obtained for these reactions by quenching studies. Also investigated by the group was the flash photolysis of la, leading to 2 and 3, the transient products postulated earlier by Kumada and Ishikawa, as well as dimethylsilylene and the stable product PTMSA.” Quenching reactions and UV spectroscopy again identified the products. Silaallene 3 reacts
14
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT W E S T
Me;SiH$i
35
650°C
IO-’ mbar
MqSiH 1
39
38 SC‘HEMI~ I I.
more rapidly with quenching agents than does 41, by factors of 20 to 1000. The difference is suggested to result from a combination of steric effects and hyperconjugative stabilization of the Si=C bond in 41 by the trimethylsilyl substituent.
B. Transient
I-Silaketenes
Using CO-saturated hydrocarbon matrices, Pearsall and Westlx photolyaed silylene precursors at 77 K and monitored CO coordination to the silylenes by UV-vis spectroscopy (Scheme 13). Bis(trimethylsilyl)silanes 44a-c or Si(,Met:! were irradiated at 254 nm to create silylenes 45a-d, which reacted with CO, causing new peaks to ca. 290 and 350 nm, which were attributed to complex 46a-d, a resonance structure of silaketene 47a-d. Silylene adducts form fairly weak bonds. as seen by warming of the matrices. In the case of silylene adducts where one R = Mes, the CO dissociates and the corresponding disilene 48a-c peaks in the UV-vis spectra observed upon warming (Rl = Me most likely produced silane rings SiiMeh. etc.).
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes
15
Me$C~CSiMqSiMe3 40 hv
hexane McOH
Me$ Me$i
\
Me C=C=Si’
/ 41
+
\
MqSi:
+
Mc&CEC’SiMe$3iMc~ 43
42
Me
MTSIASiMe ?
3
46%
McOtl
MeOH
MeOH
Me,Sl
SiMezOMe >--<
t
+
t MCjSI
MezSi H
/ \
tl
H Me&
OMe
SiMcrOMe P<
SiMei 23%
12% %‘Hf:ME
12
A separate study of the interaction of :SiMez with CO in an argon matrix (Scheme 14) was carried out by Arrington et al. ” Dodecamethylcyclohexasilane or dimethyldiazidosilane were irradiated in the presence of CO at I5 K and produced a silylene-CO adduct. This species was detected by infrared (CO stretch = I962 cm-‘) and UV-vis (peak at 342 nm) spectroscopies and the intensities of the peaks increased upon warming, indicating that more of 46d was being formed at higher temperatures owing to the increased mobility of the reactants in the matrix. Maier and co-workersx condensed formaldehyde and elemental silicon at 12 K in an argon matrix and photolyzed the mixture to form silaketene HzSiCO, which is similar in structure to the silylene-CO adduct mentioned above. The reactants first form siloxiranylidene 49 (which equilibrates with an unknown species postulated as the planar/linear silaketene 50 when exposed to 3 I3-nm-wavelength light) and then forms complex 51 when photolyzed at 366 nm (Scheme 1.5). This species could also be formed by photolyzing diazidosilane 52 in the presence of CO, and complex 51 equilibrates with Sic0 (53) and Hz. The CO infrared shift for this bent structure was calculated at 2129 cm-‘, which is shifted -8Ocm-’ from the calculated value of free CO, at 22 10 cm- ‘. The experimentally observed value was reported at 2038-2047 cm-’ at I2 K.
0:
-
R$G=C’=O 47a-d A
i (a) (b) (c) (d)
R= R= R= R=
Mesz Ma; OPh-2,6-iPr Ma; tBu MeI
48a-c
(SiMe),,
46d
.. si. .
Ar +
HX==O
I2
hv (3 13 nm)
i-i
. K
-
/\
hv (435
HzC’-0
HzSi=(‘=O
:’
nm) SO
49
I
hv (366
llnl)
‘lV (2’)o ““‘J-
H2Sl(N&
hvl313
:s1=(‘=0
nm) 53
52 SC‘HthlF
15
Chemistry
McO
17
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
I-PI
I-Pr
Br
; ,D
OMc
54
I
I
56
OMc
55 hle?
2.4.6.rri-t-butylphenyl,
I -Ad
= I -adamantyl SCHINE
16.
C. Stable Heteroallenes
The first stable silaallene, 56, was synthesized in 1993”‘.-I2 by the intramolecular attack of an organolithium reagent at the B-carbon of a fluoroalkynylsilane (Scheme 16). Addition of two equivalents of t-butyllithium in toluene at 0 ‘C to compound 54 gave intermediate 55. The cY-lithiofluorosilane then eliminated lithium fluoride at room temperature to form the 1-silaallene 56, which was so sterically hindered that it did not react with ethanol even at reflux temperatures. 1-Silaallene 56 was the first, and so far the only, multiply bonded silicon species to be unreactive toward air and water. The X-ray crystal structure and NMR spectra of 56 is discussed in Sect. IVA. In 1997,2’ the intermolecular addition of organolithium reagents to fluoroalkynylsilanes was used to synthesize three novel, stable I-silaallenes. In this
18
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT W E S T
R”Li
7’
R-Sj-C--(‘Pi1 F 57a,b,c
1
A, -LiF
(a) R, R’= Tip, R”= t-Bu (b) R- Mes*. R’, R”= t-Bu (c) R= Mm*. R’=t-Bu. R”= Pb
Ph R’//,,,
SizxzCzC’ \
R’
R”
59
Tip = 2,4,6-tri-isopropylphenyl Mes*= 2,4,6-tri-/-butylphenyl
salt-elimination approach, one equivalent of the organolithium reagent is added to a solution of a sterically hindered (to prevent attack at silicon) fluoroalkynylsilane 57. The organic part of the organolithium compound adds to the B-carbon of the alkyne and the lithium is transferred to the a-carbon, forming cr-lithiosilane 58 (Scheme 17). Compound 58a was stable at 0°C in solution and was trapped by methanol, forming the cr-hydrovinylsilane 60a (Eq. (3)). The TMEDA complex of compound 58a was studied by X-ray crystallography, clearly showing that this intermediate is present in solution prior to the formation of 1-silaallene 59. These intermediates were not detected for I-silaallenes 59b or 59~. Further warming (25 ‘C for 2 h for 59a; 0 C for I h for 59b; 25’ C for 3 days for 59~) led to elimination of lithium fluoride, providing I-silaallenes 59a-c. PI1
58a
MeOH
t-Bu
t F
H
(3)
60a
I-Silaallene 59a decomposes to silacyclobutane 61 (Eq. (4)) upon heating to 135°C in solution. This sole decomposition product was created from the insertion of the Si=C double bond of the silaallene into one of the ovtho tertiary carbon isopropyl C-H bonds, which are preferred (or more acidic) over the primary carbon methyl C-H bonds on the isopropyl groups, which would form a less strained five-membered ring.
Chemistry
19
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
.
i-Pr l
135°C *w
i-Pr
I
,i;:!
‘Tip
59a
(4) %-Ph 1 r-Bu
61
Only one type of reaction occurred for I-silaallenes 59b and 59~ (Eq. (5)). The greater steric bulk of the substituents on silicon led to a similar insertion of the Si=C double bond into a C-H bond on one of the ortho r-butyl groups on the Mes* group, forming the five-membered ring 62. In this reaction, there is no longer a tertiary C-H bond to insert into, giving only one option for insertion into a C-H bond, that of rearrangement to the silacyclopentane. The insertion occurred in three separate pathways for 59b. The first was observed when 59b was heated to 90~ C overnight. The second method for synthesis of 62b was to stir 59b with excess ethanol at room temperature for several hours. The same rearrangement occurred upon mixing at -78°C when a catalytic amount of acid in excess ethanol was added to 59b. Excess deuterated ethanol and 5 mol% D#Od added to 59b incorporated a deuterium atom in the cu-vinylic position (>95’%, 63), suggesting initial protonation (deuteration) at the I-silaallene central carbon (Scheme l8), thereby creating a reactive silicenium ion, which inserts into an ortho r-butyl C-H bond, liberating H+ and making 64. I -Silaallene 59~ is less sterically hindered and forms 62c under mild conditions of excess ethanol at room temperature in only a few seconds.
A, EtOH or EtOH(H+)
59b,c
R (b) R= t-Bu (c) R= Ph
62b,c
(5)
Compound 59a underwent intermolecular reactions characteristic of silenes (Scheme 19). Water added instantly across the Si=C double bond of the I -silaallene is expected to give vinylhydroxysilane 65 in 7 I % yield, and methanol was added
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT W E S T
20
EtOD(D’)
59b
_
-Ph
Ph
Ph
’ t-Bu
HO
H
65 Ph t-Bu
Me0
11
SCHtMvlr:
” I’).
Chemistry
t-Bu-Si--C‘eC
21
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
2 t-BuLi
t-Bu-Si--C‘=C
25°C
t-Bu
- LiF
/ IO
SCHEME
20.
to provide vinylmethoxysilane 66 in 78% yield. Benzophenone also reacted with 59a to give a mixture of E- and Z-isomers of 1,2-oxasiletane 67 in 22% isolated yield. Two more novel silaallenes were reported in 199.5” and 1999”. I-Silaallene 70”,” was synthesized (Scheme 20) from alkynylfluorosilane 68 and two equivalents of r-butyllithium to give intermediate 69, which eliminates lithium fluoride upon warming to room temperature for 2 to 6 h yielding bright yellow silaallene 70. Compound 70 is stable in rehuxing neutral or slightly basic ethanol for 3 days, but undergoes a rearrangement (Scheme 2 1) similar to that of silaallenes 59b and 59~ when submitted to slightly acidic conditions in refluxing ethanol, giving 71. Silaallene 70 also photolyzes to insert the Si=C double bond into the C-H bond of the nearest methyl group on the fluorenyl moiety to form the strained silane 72. Silaallene 73” was synthesized in an manner analogous to that of 70. Compound 73 was stable at room temperature over I month, but in the presence of any protic source (i.e., water, methanol), it underwent a rearrangement different than that observed for 70, inserting into a methyl C-H bond (74) on the octamethylfluorenyl moiety rather than into one of the groups on silicon (Eq. (6)). It is believed that the favored mode of rearrangement for these groups is that of silaallene 73, but 70
22
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WES-I
is too sterically hindered to do so, and therefore the Si=C double bond is near enough only to the group on silicon to react to form 71.
-
H‘
(6)
West et al. have recently described the synthesisZJ and reaction? of a Igermaallene. Germaallene 76 (Eq. (7)) is analogous to silaallene 59a and is synthesized by intermolecular addition of t-butyllithium to precursor 75, followed by salt elimination at -78°C. This germaallene is not stable above 0°C in solution. but remains intact until heated above 90°C in the solid state. In either case, the
23
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes
germaallene performs an insertion of the Ge=C double bond into a C-H bond on an ortho isopropyl group, forming four-(77) and five-membered (78) rings (Eq. (8)) in a ratio of approximately 3:2, depending on which C-H bond is inserted into. Compound 76 also added external reagents such as water and alcohols across the Ge=C double bond to make compounds 79a-c (Eq. (9)). Benzophenone was too large to add to the germaallene at O”C, but benzaldehyde added readily to provide oxagermetane 80 (Scheme 22). Germaallene 76 also reacts with acetone to give the unexpected trapping product 79a. PI1
t-BuLi Tip$;e--CC-Ph
v
/
Tip+=C’=C -78°C’
I F
\
(7) t-Bu
76
75
0°C (solution) e > 90”~ (solid) 76
i-Pr
+
i-Pr-
t-h 77 (60%)
t-Bu
I
I ROH 76
’
(a) R= H (b)R=Me (c) R= Et
Tip
//c-ph
;e--C I OR
I H
79
(9)
Another germaallene was also reported in 1998 by Okazaki rt a/.rc,h Initially, the report of a germaallene trap with chalcogens, alkylidenetelluragermirane 86a, appeared in I 997.26”The germylene precursor 82 is made in situ from dichlorogermane 81 and two equivalents of lithium naphthalenide (Scheme 23). The addition
24
BARRETT
Tbt(Mes)GeClz 81
-
2 LiNp -2
Mea \(je=(‘=C Tht
/
EICHLER
AND
ROBERT
WEST
[ Tbt( Mes)Ge 1 82
LiCl
Mes *
:I
t 82
rht-(ie--C’=(’ I I C‘I C’I
- 81
’
85
8
:I
84
(a) E=Tc (h) E- S (c) E- SC
86 Tht= 2,4,h-tris[his(trimcthyls~lyl)methyl]phenyl WHEMF~
21.
Chemistry of dichloromethylenefluorene leads rinated
by the addition
dichlorogermane from
83 and tributylphosphine
first to compound
84, which
(MC) (Eq. amide
from
elemental
Ma sulfur Ma
in order lo reversibly melhod
was reactud abstract
with
88. Germaallene
85 also
to that of gertnaallenc
76 to make
temperature
(50%
for 3 days
This re;tction
ways.“‘”
excess
phosphorus
by addition 85 reacted
87 and with mcsitonilrile
four-membered
tri-
atom away from the germaallene.
dehalogeilation
underwent
complete)
also
In the first method
hex:tmcthyl
C. Germnnllenc
24) to give methoxyvinylgerInllne
compound
crystals.
atom isolated
respectively.
the teIIurium
to 84 al -72
it tellurium
and the final
and the alkylidenexclen~t~ertiiiranc
in two other
(Eq. ( I I )) utilized
of /-butyllithimm
(Scheme
and selenium.
85, regenerating
then abstracts
;IS orange
(Mb)
lo the solution.
and c;tn bc dechlo-
I-gertnaallene
tributylphosphine
in 10% yield
85 can be synthesized
( 10)). compound
The second alents
to make
tclluride
in 5% yield
82 to give
the alkylidenethiagermilane
Gertnaallene
isolated
The germaullcne
telluride
~tlkylidenctellut-agcrmirane produced
MU
of germylcne
81 in the process.
tributylphosphine
2.5
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
cyclization
of two equiva:ith
oxide
in a manner
ring 89, upon
methanol
storage
to give similat 111room
or at X0 C for 13.5 h.
(I 1)
3. HPrc,,nXl~trrli,llirlp.\ The addition w;1s investigtted like framework. stuble
of isocyanates
I -silaketenimines
starting
dimcrization
products
91, generated
by photolysis
react with four
(isoelectronic
to CO) to group
in order to set if the resulting In the lirst study, Weidenbruch from silylenes
of silaketenitnines.
isocyanates
In this investigation,
of hexa-t-butyltrisilacyclopropane
(92a-d)
(Scheme
13 citrbene
analogs
molecules would have an allencet c,1.27a,h attempted to synthesiLc and isocyanates, but only produced
25). The reaction
di-t-butylsilylene (90). was allowed presumably
to
forms
26
BARRETT
EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
I ’ blC& MeOH 85
*
Tht-Ge-
I
I MC0
I ’ ’
% //(‘ .(“ I
87
Thr-
S~‘HI.Lll:
I -silaketenimines I ,3-alkyl isolated
when
but when
which
(depending
cyanotrialkylsilane
R =
phenyl
;1 mixture
(YSc-minor
(94a-65%)
ofthe
product)
on substituent
or dimerizc.
the steric bulk W;IS increased
dimerization. dimer
93a-d,
shifted
7-I
Only
R) either
rearrange
the head-to-tail
and 2.4,6-tri-methylphenyl
dimer (94b--45%
to R = 2,4.6-tri-isopropylphenyl
head-to-tail was produced.
dimer
(94c-76%
When
to ;I was ).
to hinder
) and the head-to-head
even more steric hindrance
was
cmploycd (also to prove that the isocyanatc KIS not simply adding twice to the disilene formed in the photolysis to make the same dimer product) by changing R to 2,4.6-tri-f-butylphenyl
(Mes”‘),
the silaketcnimine
rearranged to give compound 96. The mechanism similar isomerization with 3 2,4.6-tri-t-butylphenyl chlorostannanes
did not dimerizc.
but rather
is not well understood. but :I group W;IS also reported for
by the same group.“’
The first stable group I4 heteroallene, a I -stannaketenimine (99), was reported by Griitzmacher et al. in I 992.‘h Compound 99 was synthesized in 9 I % yield by adding diarylstannylene 97 and mesityl isocy:unide 98 in hexane (Eq. ( 12)). The bonding in 99 can be described as ;I stannylene-isocyanide adduct rather than a
Chemistry
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
(GBLI?) Si
hv -
/\
1 (t-Bu),Si:
1+
27
(1-t3u)2Si=Si(t-t~~1)2
91
(1-RtI),Si---Si(l-Utl),
:C‘=N-R
92
1
90
] T-
(t-BL+SI=C‘=N-R
H’
NR /I ../(‘\
(~-Bu)~SI,
,Sl(t-Bu)z ‘ii NR
94
96 (a) (b) (c) (cl)
RR= Rp Rp
I’ll Mea Tip Ma*
stannaethene and this is illustrated through the reactivity of99 (Scheme 16). When 2,3-dimethylbutadiene was added to 99, mesityl isocyanide 98 was displaced and compound 100 was isolated. which is the addition product of the butadiene to stannylene 97. A similar situation occurred when r-butanol is added to 99: r-butanol not only expels 98, but also replaces both of the aryl groups on tin with t-butoxy groups to give stannylene 101. RzSn:
+
:C=N-Mes
97
98
-
RzSn=C‘=N-Mes
99
(12)
R- ~.~.~-(CFJ)~C~,H:
The reactivity of a silylene 103 with isocyanides was probed by Okazaki et (I/. in 1997.‘8 When disilene 102 is heated to 60 C in THF or CfiDc,, it dissociates
28
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
of silylene 103 (Scheme 27) and in the presence of various 104a-c, I-silaketenimines 105a-c are formed, on the basis of NMR
into two equivalents isocyanides results
and trapping
reactions.
Similar
to the I-stannaketenimine
just mentioned.
105a-care best thought of as silylene-isocyanide adducts and a better depiction of lOSa-c is shown in Scheme 28. Although stable in the absence of external reagents. compounds 105a-c reacted with triethylsilane to data and calculations
suggest
that
give good yields of the corresponding displacement triethylsilanc the reaction
of the isocyanidc Si-H of
bond.
isocyanides
and subsequent
The lability
105a-c with MeOH,
and silane 106, indicating addition
of the isocyanides which
provides
‘I”\
THt: 01’(‘,,D,,
102
(a) R Tip (b) R- Tbt (C) R- vcs*
I
a facile
103 across the
is also demonstrated methoxysilanc
ho ‘C’ Mea(Tbt)SI=Si(Tbt)Mcs
of silylene
Mcs
(,
2’: 103
by
107 and. in
Chemistry
29
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
III
the case of only compound normally central
105a,
is unusual attaches carbon
;I small for
amount
to the heteroatom
atom.
of compound
I -heteroallenes
The
authors
(i.e.. silicon) suggest
step of the mechanism is protonation the methoxy group at the silicon for the carbon in proving retains
108. The
in thnt the oxygen
isolation
of the methoxy
and the hydrogen
that for both
of this group
adds to the
107 and 108, the initial
of the silicon atom followed 107 (eliminating isocyanide
by attack of 10Sa) and at
for 108. Regardless of the mechanism. compound 108 is important the existence of 105a, since it is the only trapping product which
the isocyanide
that for stannaketenimine.
portion
of the silaketenimine.
silaketenimines
105a-c
In a manner replaced
identical
the isocyanides
to with
30
BARRETT
EICHLER
AND
ROBERT
WEST
2.3-dimethylbutadiene to produce compound 109. Anothercolnpound. silanol 11 1, was isolated from the reaction mixture. the cxiatence of which is proposed to be 110 durin, (7 work-up. although direct attack the hydrolysis of strained compo~~nd of compound 109 by water cannot be ruled wt. 4. Iletr,r)~)llo.s/~llcltrll~~rrr.\
EscudiC and co-workers”’ synthesized ;L mctastable I -germa-3-phosphaallenc (114) in I996 by the salt-elimination method, ;I process they called “debromollLIorination” (Scheme 29). In a reaction that was followed by “P NMR. one eyuivalent of /I-butyllithium was added to 112 at -90 C to form intermediate 113. llpon warming to approximately -60 C. lithium fluoride was eliminated. forming germaphosphaallene 114 in hS-70% yield. Compound 114 was stable up to -SO C. whereupon it dimerized in the absence of trapping agents. This process not only gave the expected head-to-tail dimer 115 (between the two Ge=C bonds), but also an unexpected dimerization product (116) resulting from the reaction
Chemistry
31
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
-60°C
-LiCI
t [ TipPhSi=C’=PMcs*] MeOtl 122 J// TipPhSJ--(l‘=pMca* OMe
tl
123
PhTip Si ’
Muh*P=(\Si,
‘(~zz,$,~~”
+
p
Pl171p
213
124
S(‘HI:MI- 30.
of a Ge=C were
performed
pected with
bond
with a P=C
methanol,
similar thesized -80 denced
providing analog,
in Scheme
method
C gave a-lithiochlorosilane by the downfield
C afforded
similar
dimer
(124)
between
and one P=C
two Si=C bond
(125)
work
experiments giving
the ex-
by quenching by making
a
112 was syn-
to that for the germaphosphaallene.
of 119 at carbon was observed
to precursor
by r-butyllithium by “P
NMR
119) and was isolated
at
(as evias the
warming 120 to -60 C. the elimination of lithium silaphosphaallene 122. Methanol addition to 122 at 123 in SO%> yield.
warmed above -20 C in the absence of trapping similar to the dimerization of germaphosphaallene bond
followed
(112). Compound
120, which
shift compared
methoxysilane
methanol,
I-germa-3-phosphallene
30. Dehalogenation
hydrolysis product 121. Upon chloride was complete, giving -60
up the
a I -sila-3-phosphaallene
by a salt-elimination
as shown
Two trapping
114: one with 117, the other with methyllithium methylgermane 118.
er o/.~” followed
silicon
molecule.
on germaphosphaallene
methoxygermane
Escudi6
bond of another
bonds
When
and the product
in a 2:3 ratio.
the silaphosphaallene
was
agents, it dimerized in a manna 124. This gave ;I head-to-tail of dimerization
at one Si-C
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
127
Wibcrg (126)
ct rrl. ” havejust
to date in which
elements.
and
by adding
recently
more specifically,
tri-I-butylsilyl
warming
to -25
naallene
is separated
published
all of the atoms
arc all tin
sodium
C to provide
the synthesis
in the allene ato~m.
mixture
by fractional
9.8 h), which
or SnlN(SiMcj)?l?
crystallization
sodium
and Sn(OtRu)l
2 days.
Like
stannylcne
can be independently in pentane
the stannaketenimine complexes
can bc considered
manifests
as a mixture
at -78
One other
study
consisting
of group
I3
which
crystals
C and
the tristan-
(Scheme
to form cyclotristunnene
synthesized
by stirring
3 I ). 127
tri-t-hutylsilyl
‘C for 3 days and then at 25 C for another
mentioned
earlier.
the tendency
itself‘ in the bent structure of the resonance
of more
group
at - I96
from
as blue
ing to the authors, is best described as structures and isolation of this I ,2,3-tristannaallene illustrates other heteroallenes
heavy
126 was synthesi&
of compounds,
Care is taken not to warm 126, because it rearrange5 (r j I2 =
only hctcroallene
are
Compound
to Sn(OtBu)l a
ol‘the
hachbone
structures
126sd
4). which
and. accord-
126b and 126~. The synthesis that it is feasible
than one heavy
I4 heteroallcnes
of tin to form
of 126 (Fig.
involving
group
to synthesis
I4 atom.
transition
metals
was rc-
ported in 1995. Jones VI trl.3’ described the isolation of a ruthenium complex of‘ a I-silaallene (132-Scheme 32). The I-silaallene also interacts with a hydrogen atom as well as the ruthenium metal center. Jones rt tri. describe this view
Chemistry
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
33
126a
i/* ..
.. R:SnHsnN
SnR 2
RISn
fSnNSnR, 126~
126b
/
.. kS”.\snR Rg+l’ 126d
Br ‘h?C=C
/ \
n-BuLi ‘SiHMq
128
LI
/
Ph:c‘=C
-70°C
‘SitIbIs
129
c’p*( P(‘y3)RuC‘I
LI(‘l
I
130
(a) L= (‘y (b) Lp Ph. Me, Me
LP \R/Cp* / : \\.
Ph2C=c’
132
\:.,‘H
i
c’Y,P p* Ph&‘=C’
/
\ Me?Si-H
ziq 131
34
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
as “a I -silaallene
that is stabilized
metal-hydrogen
bond.”
intermediate
129, to which
131 which arrested
above
later.
exchange
45 C led to multiple
yielding
structure
of’
in C&,
decomposition
a
intermediate atom was
so than
similar
lor I day. and did not react with
be performed
132b without
with to give
132a was obtained
132a was stable (more
to 45°C
could
Xl %) to form
and interaction
at low temperature
atom from the silicon
crystal
Compound
upon warming
(PLj)
warming.
ligation
(130) was added.
An X-ray
atom.
be discussed
CO. Ligand (with
Cp”(PCy~)RuCI
by the ruthenium
silene complexes)
metal
128 was lithinted
132a (42%) after the hydrogen
produced
and will
by both
Compound
by replacing
PCyi
harming
the silaallene
products
unreported
with
PMe,Ph
moiety.
Heating
by the authors.
IV PHYSICAL A. X-ray Structure The crystal vide valuable
PROPERTIES
Determination
structures”.’
of a variety
information
toward
of‘ heteroallenes
the understanding
have been solved of the bonding
and pro-
in this series
of molecules. If one were for an allene
to ask a first-year (C=C=C)
All things
considered.
all-carbon
allene”
should they
(133)
bond
lengths
before, more This
on
would
with
be noted that due to crystal
a
capon
substitution
this case as bending (Table III). In three studies
but how
two and
much
values
of 179.0
may deviate
slightly
the early
shrink
in Table
was
or an
III. It must
the bond angles and
from the ideal. As mentioned state is
of the allenc.
N) hcteroallene
angle
will be
agrees with theory
in
(I 79 ) to tin ( IS4
suggested
that
)
I -silaallencs
framework. Later calculations by Trinquier and that the I-silaallene framework would be nonwould
59a, which (Table
is listed
From carbon
I~XOS,~~“~“’ it
angle
degrees.”
and an example
atom. Experiment
deviate
were seen with the isolation
I-silaallenes 56 and 172.0 . respectively
“IX0
in the one position
Ce. Sn; E=C.
systematically
the moiety
the bond
(C < Si < Ge < Sn < Pb). the singlet
(M=Si,
would have a linear Si=C=C Malricu’ predicted qualitatively linear.
be correct.
what answer
forces and steric restraints.
with a heavier
angles from
likely
angle
student
most likely
state for the atom
means that the M=C=E
quantitative
bond
the group
over the triplet
chemistry
most
packing
of these molecules descending
favored
bent more
organic
be. they would
III).
from
IX0
and structural
was unclear. determination
The
First of the
have very similar Si=C=C angles of 17.1.5 This is an average deviation of 7.3 from
linearity-signiticant, but relatively small the germanium and tin substituted allenes.
compared
to the deviations
shown
by
Chemistry
35
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
MC
I<,,‘,, (.=(
=(.’ \
VICd
PI1
133 R- (blC)C 4-(‘1
I70.0
?OO.O
l.il3LJJ
I ilXii)
34
173.5
.360.0
I .701(J)
1.3:!45)
20
I so.2
i-Ix.4
1.7X%2)
1.3147)
2-I
I.S.3.‘)
700.0
237(i)
1.1’8r.31
2h
I’h)Mc
1-P
1-1’1
, \__I
\IC\‘/,, SI==( =c I-.\d’ 56 1-1’:1.’
:I
1-1’1
I-l3Ll
“Ph.
/
(;c=c’=(’
\
-r,p’
16
I’ll MC\
I< I/,,
/
Sn=C‘=N I<’ 99
The I -silaallene calculations preceded the isolation of’the by 12 years, but despite the isolation of’ a stannaketenimine
first stable silaallenc in 1992’” and a ger-
tnaallene in I 99X,‘J no calculations yet for analogs larger than silicon.
of bond angles or lengths have been perf’ormed Given some guidelines and values provided by
Trinquier
calculation
and Malrieu,3
;I simple
can be performed
(Scheme
33) to
36
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
predict whether or not a parent group 14 I-heteroallene will be linear or bent. Consider the example of a I-germaallene. According to the above authors, if ON% tn ) > CAEs+r (condition I). the structure will be linear, and if O.S(E,,,) CAEssr (condition 2). the structure will be bent. E,+, is the strength of a typical 0 fn planar double bond that is to be formed and C AEssr is the sum ofthe singlettriplet energy separations for the two fragments being brought together. Using values from the Malrieu/Trinquier paper, C AEs- r (68.5 kcal/mol) is larger than @SE,, 7r) (45-53 kcal/mol) for the parent I-germallene, satisfying condition 2. Therefore, germallenes should be bent. This is the case for germallene 76, which has an M=C=C angle of 159.2 This deviates from linearity by 20.8 , more than twice that for the silaallenes. Stannaketenimine 99 deviates by 26. I , although the nitrogen atom in the 3-position may affect this angle. Tristannaallene 126 is bent to a similar degree. 155.8’, although the emormous supersilyl [ Si(t-Bu),] groups may prevent more severe deviation from a linear geometry, and Wibergj’ has proposed that there may be a contribution to bending from the lone pair on the central tin atom. In order to achieve maximum orbital overlap between atoms M and C in bonding model B (Fig. 2) the plane made by RzM bends away from the vector made by the M=C bond (Fig. 5). resulting in pyramidalization of atom M. A simple test of the extent of pyramidalization at a particular atom can be performed by summing all of the bond angles around M and comparing the result to the ideal of 360 ’(for sp’ atoms). The sum of the bond angles in allene 133 around the I -position carbon total up to be exactly 360.0 , as expected. An unexpected result is that silaallene 56 also totals 360.0 around silicon, whereas silaallene 59a bond angles add up to 357.2 Germaallene 76 deviates somewhat more from planarity with a total of 348.4 The sum of the bond angles around tin in stannaketeniminc 99 comes to a meager
Chemistry
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
37
290.9 , indicating a severe distortion from planarity. even surpassing the pyramidalization of an idealized sp3-hybridized atom (3 x 109.5 = 328.5 ). Tristannaallene 126 averages 344.0’ for the angles around the I - and j-tins. These angles are much smaller than for the stannaketenimine. but pyramidalization around tin may be prevented due to the severe steric constraints caused by the large tri-tbutylsilyl ligands. Trans bending of the substituents and bending at the central carbon for silaketene (H$iCO) become dominant for its calculated structure.” The Si-C-O angle is calculated to be 167.4 and the angle created between the Si-C bond and the vector bisecting the two Si-H bonds becomes a very sharp 89.0 The calculated bond lengths for this yet unseen moiety are I.891 A (Si-C) and I, 14X A (C-O). The reason group 14 heteroallenes were not isolated until 1992 is undoubtedly because of the reactivity of the M=C (or M=M in the case of the trislannallene) double bond. Four Si=C double bond lengths were calculated in the early 1980s for I -silaallenes; I .696 r\ by Lien and Hopkinson,’ I.703 w by Gordon and Koob.(’ I.702 A by Krogh-Jespersen,“’ and I .62 r\ by Ishikawa rt rrl. “‘In excellent agreement with the majority of the theoretical results, silaallene 59a has a Si=C bond length of 1.693(3) A and silaallene 56 has a bond length of 1.704(4) A. Although no calculations have been performed for germa- or stannaallcnes, comparisons can be made to germenes and stannenes. Germaallene 76 was found to have a Ge=C double bond length of I .7X3(2) r\. which falls right in the middle of values observed for germencs 134 [ I .827(4)].1’“.’ 135 [ I .X03(4) A],3h and 136 1I .77 I ( 16) r\]j7 (Table IV). Amazingly, the Sn=C double bond length [2.397(j) A] in stannaketenimine 99 is longer than both of the Sn-C single bonds [2.306(2), 2.314(j) A] to the ipso carbons of the R groups and is considerably longer than most other reported stannene Sn=C bond lengths 1137-140; 2.03-2.38 r\, Table V]. The long Sn-C bond length in 99 reaffirms that the bonding interaction between tin and carbon is weak and is best described as a stannylene-carbene adduct. Tristannaallene 126 has an average Sn=Sn distance (two Sn-Sn bonds per molecule and two diastereomers) of 2.68 I\, which is the shortest Sn-Sn bond length next to its rearrangement product cyclotristannene 127 (2.59 p\) (Table VI). The synthesis of three silaketenimines 105a-c prompted Tokitoh and Okazaki’s to calculate the optimized geometry of a model compound, Ph$iCNPh. This model reinforced that 105a-c are truly Lewis acid-base pairs, with the isocyanide donating its carbon lone pair to an empty p-orbital perpendicular to the lone pail
38
BARRETT
AND
ROBERT
WEST
I .X03(4,
730
1.771l101
37
l’hl
1 bl ‘< I I,,
EICHLER
‘(.‘=( / ‘~
+/ ls/’
‘\
I ip
136
and two phenyl distance bond,
substitucnts
on silicon.
( I .X63 ,&)13’ bond and the Si--C=N
C(isocyanide)
angle
Si-C(isocvanide) isocyanidc
length
bond
binding
is bent (163.4
These
energy
than even tin average
I .8X2 d, is predicted
angle
is 99.4
A long [longer
bonds
for the Si--C(isocyanide)
). The average
and
Si-C,,,.:
angles.
C(Ph,,,,,,)-Si-
along
(25. I kcal/~~~ol). rcaftirm
with
3 weak
that this is ;1 silylenc-
adduct.
The C=C
bond oi‘the
heteroallcne
because
ol‘ its lack of reactivity,
double
but should
tigation
of these compounds.
In calculating
moiety Si=C
the three athremcntioned groups also calculated A by Lien and Hopkinson,’ I.296 I\ by Gordon Jespersen,“’
and I .29 A by lahiknwu
is often double
76 has a C=C
double
As noted
(59a).
bond length
[ I .3 l4(2)
by Griito~~acher
bonds
the C=C
rt trl. “’ Although
inves-
l’or I -silaallenes.
bond lengths: I .3 I2 I.395 A by Krogb
isolated
I -silaallene
C=C
lengths, they are at least A for 59a. Germaallene
r\] only 0.01 A shorter and co-workers.
in discussion\
in a thorough
and Koob.”
double bond lengths are slightly longer than the calculated consistent with lengths of I .324(s) A for 56 and I .325(3) analog
ignored
not be overlooked
the C=N
than its silicon bond
length
[ I. 15X(3) r\] for stannaketenimine 99 is “typical for isocyanides.“‘h The structures of two group I4 heteroallenes that are complexed
to other atoms
have
(132a)
been
determined-a
ruthenium
complex
of a I -silaallene
and
a
Chemistry
39
of Group 14 Heteroallenes TABLE
V
S-TANNFNF BON) LENGTIIS
M=C Len$h
(.A,
t-r&l I
(Me3Si):HC \ /
(Mcisi)zllc‘
,P\ Sn=c
C‘(SiMe;):
3.0?5(4)
\I3/ I t-Bu
137 t-Uu
17h
3.032(5 1
tellurium bond
complex
length
for silaallenes Si-C(sp’)
of a I -germaallene
of I .805(6)
A, which
56 (I ,704
single
bonds
gests an sp’-hybridized authors
propose
drogen
atoms,
.&) and 59a
(I .693
than
but is still
central
carbon,
bond
that this molecule
bond angle
between
stabilized
length
of
lengths
than
normal
12X.6(4)
allenic
ruthenium,
is not only bond
the bond
shorter
not an sp-hybridized
atom but also by a hydrogen atom. Compound 86a has a germanium-carbon is shorter is longer
A),
longer
.90 1\).31 The Si=C=C
‘-electron
132a has ;I silicon-carbon
Compound
(I .85-I
a 3-center indicating
(%a).
is considerably
carbon.
silicon,
bugThe
and hy-
by a ruthenium 1X3(2)
r\,
which
than Ge-C single bonds of germirane derivatives ( I .92-2.07 A).“’ but than the Ge=C double bond lengths listed in Table IV ( I .77-l .83 A).
The relatively angles sum to
short
Ge=C
354.4 (which
bond and the fact su ggests considerable
that
the
three
sp’character
C-Cc-C at germanium)
bond led
40
BARRETT EICHLER AND ROBERT W E S T
(Mc;Si)zH(’
127 \
(Mc;Si)211(‘
( Mc;Si)JSI
/
1.. SI(SIMc~);
142 \ II/
145 [R
‘(‘H(S~fvlq,~
/
(Me;Si);Si
,U-I(SIM~~)~
St1=St1
1.Xx7(h)
-1Xh
2.X3.7(I )
4xc
Ii
S,,ZSn/ 1.. SI(SIM~);
[(‘(H)SiMel((‘pHiN)]~I
the authors to propose that this molecule is in fact a n-complex of a tellurium atom with the Ge=C double bond of a I -germaallene. The Ge=C=C bond angle is 149(l) ‘, almost directly in between the bonding angles for sp- (180 ) and sp’-hybridized (120’ ) carbons, and is only IO larger than the Ge=C=C bond angle of I -germaallene 76. 6. NMR Spectroscopy
Possibly the most characteristic piece of information one can obtain to prove the existence of a I-heteroaallene is the central carbon “C NMR chemical shift. This carbon chemical shift is very deshielded. typically being greater than 200 ppm,‘” which stands out from most other carbon resonances in a normal organic molecule. Most of the group I4 I-heteroallenes listed in Table VII have shifts greater than 200 ppm. Also, as the heteroatom becomes larger, the resonance moves farther downfield.
41
Chemistry of Group 14 Heteroallenes TABLE VII ‘-‘C CIII:b4lCAl. SkllFTS 01. CkNTRAI. CRKHON OR (;ROL~I’ I-! ~-H~:ERoALL.~.N~:s I -Heteroallcne 56 5% 5% 59C
70 73 76 85 I osa 105b 10%
114 122
’‘C. vhit’t of Cenual 225.7 175 7 -__ 216.3
227.0 228.2 237. I 235. I 343.6 209.2 IY6.6 I7X.S 2x0.9 769. I
Carbon
(ppm)
Reference
20 2.3 2.3 73 72 72 7-1 2hb 2x 2x 2x 29 30
The I-silaallenes in Table VII have chemical shifts in the range of 2 16 to 237 ppm. It is interesting to note how changing a tert-butyl group to a phenyl group on the carbon end of silaallenes 59b and 59~ can change the chemical shift by greater than IO ppm. but when the two phenyls of 59c are changed to a fluorenyl group (70), the chemical shift moves by only 0.3 ppm. Germaallene 76 is the exact germanium analog of silaallene 59a, and this substitution of germanium for silicon relocates the central carbon shift almost IO ppm downfield to 235. I ppm. Adding a phosphorous to the 3-position of a germaallene (giving germaphosphaallene 114) moves the central carbon chemical shift a substantial 45 ppm to 280.9 ppm.” Changing the germanium atom to a silicon (112) moves the silicon back upfield to 269. I ppm. The central “C shift for model silaketenimine Ph$iCNR was calculated to be 17X ppm. which agreed especially well with the shift for 10% (178.5, 105a = 209.2 ppm, 105b = 196.6 ppm). Reiterating the idea that the n-complexes 132a and 86a are not truly heteroallenes, one must consider the central carbon ‘?I NMR chemical shifts. Silaallene complex 132a starts to approach allene status with a chemical shift of 175.5 ppm, but the most deshielded carbon for alkylidenetelluragermirane 86a is only 153.04 ppm. Another useful tool for analyzing the structure of heteroallenes containing silicon is ‘%i NMR. Typically. sp’-hybridized silicon atoms have a chemical shift *Although it is not 3 group I4 heteroallene. arsapho\phaallene” Mes*A%=C=PMes* (+29Y.S ppm) over-emphasizes the point that the central carbons of heteroallenes are gently de\hielded. For reference. I-phovphaallene”3 Mes*P=C=CPhz has n central carbon shiii of f237.6 ppm and 1.3. dipho\phaallene’” Mes*P=C=PMes* h;l\ il shift of +276.2 ppm.
42
BARRETT
MQSI
EICHLER AND ROBERT WEST
,OSIMt2:
\ Si=(
\
Me3Si’
146
-II 2
147
144.7
I-13u
SiMe:
Me, Si=(”
\
MC’ I-Bu,
SIMe(t-r3u)z
Mes s,=si’
Mes’
cis,trans-14X
\
04.7 (Cl\), 90.3 (Irm\)
I-DU
MW,
MW Si=Si
’ \
MW’
63.7
149 Mos
13 I 16.2 4x.4
5Ya 13 56 5Yh SYC 70 122
downfield with
of +I0
respect
5s. I 5x.7 4x.0 s7.7
ppm
(with
respect
to tetramcthylsilane)
to sp3-hybridized
silicons.
of + IO ppm.
This
by two examples
(Table
and silaallenes
VIII).
Brook’s
silcne
electron
density
is evidenced
(146)“‘”
which
are no exception.
through
at the silicon
the resonance atom
usually
and have
each of silenes”
I -Silaallenes structure
than does Wiherg’s
are deshielded
resonances
have been compared
in Fig. 6. which silene
(147),J’h
shifting the resonance farther upheld than the analogous ailene. The chemical shifts are definitely closer to Brook’s silene than Wiberg’s.
R;Si
upfield
and disilencsJ5 puts
to
more
thereby silaallenc
Chemistry Replacing dramatic
a carbon
change
silaketenimine measured
with
upfield
Ph2SiCNR
in different
lo%-c
a nitrogen
ofthe
(-47.9
(6 = -38.9
-57.9
to
shit’&
also follow
(aryl)
by changing silaallenc
silicon
has
alkyI/aryl 59~1, with
This
ing rhe composition more)
on the ‘“Si chemical position
3 to
a
range 01’48
I‘ragment
pp111.
to
carbon
similar
to
silaallcne\
and
16.1 (73) ppm.
of’heteroallencs. much
as
chang-
of’ an et’fect (if’ not
a suhstituent.
Switching
122) moves
on silicon.
59b, with one
those for the two diary1
is the most deshiclded
it has two aryl groups
upfield
of 55. I. whereas
substituted
SC) ppm;
can have
and there
in silaallencs
( I .i. I ppm).
at 13. I (59a)
(silaphosphaallene
which
shift
alkyl/aryl
upfield
group
shift moves
Silaallene
uptield
ppm
on the
but when
is also observed
chemical
shift 215does changing
phosphorus
to 75.7
to date, even though
40
effect
(alkyl)
the chemical
shifts for the central
of the allenc
bon
values
and silaallencs
near 90 ppm,
shift
Ibr all of’the
arc considerably chemical
large
shilis
resonances
silaallenes
shift downfield
one tert-butyl
shift
has a “‘Si
two aryl groups.
Like the ‘?.I NMR
at
with
to diary1 substituents.
on silicon.
(56, 59b, 59c, 70) lie in the narrow substituted
;I
silaketenimines
such as disilenes.
chemical
subslituents group
that of the disilenes.‘“Si
for
to have a significant
atoms
(148)
‘“Si
;I
30 to 63.7 ppm.
and one aryl
to the observed
temperatures
(149). ‘5’1 in this case mesityl,
by approximately alkyl
was close
vs aryl-seems
The disilcnc”
group
are two aryl groups
ppm)
causes
‘“Si shift in model
ppm).
of sp’-hybridized
this trend.
one mcsityl
of a I -silaallene
shiti. The calculated
and at various
The type ofsubstituent--alkyI chemical
in the 3-position
‘“Si chemical
solvents
43
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
%i
the car-
the ““si chemical
shirt for a silaallcne
which
should
keep the shifl
upfield. The
central
considerable range
tin
of monomeric
+2313),‘“”
R =
The terminal =
+374
shift
in tristannaallene
character,
stannylenes
ppm).~7h
[ 140
=
(6 =
R2Sn=SnR2
f710 (R =
shifi
supports
is +2733
that
tin
has
is in the
(Me~Si)~CCH2CH3C(Si.Me3)2
(6 =
R/R
(+X)3
p~iii).~“’
ppm.
this
which
(6 = +332X),““”
rin aloms have achemical tins
126
as its value SnR2 IR,
[CH(SiMej)l]
three-coordinate (6
““Sn
stannylene
= Trip/Tbt
ppm)
137
Tip. 0 = +437
(6 = +220X)].‘“’
nearothersp’-hybridized, (6 =
+X35
ppm),‘ih
13X
ppm)““j.
FUTUREPROSPECTS How
might
I -silaallenes
this is fairly
lield well
develop
in the future?
understood,
At this
time,
and that of’ I -germaallenes
the chemistry
of’
is at least par-
tially explored. Perhaps the series can be extended to I-stannaallenes, but these are predicted to have quite limited stability. The isolation of the I .2.3-tristannaallcne shows
that any combination
of heteroatoms
may
be combined
to form
allenes
44
BARRETT
EICHLER
AND
ROBERT
WESl
and the series may be extended to silicon or germanium. 2-Heteroallenes are predicted to be less stable than their l-isomers. but nevertheless may be isolable. 13Diheteroallenes, on the other hand, should have stability comparable to the known I -heteroallenes, and are therefore attractive targets for synthesis. Examples already known arc the 13phosphasilaallcne and phosphagermaallcne described in Sect. IIIC4. Since stable silaketenimines and a stannaketenimine have been synthesized, it seems that germaketenimines should also be available. The synthesis oftin heteroallenes indicates that lead analogues may soon be included in thi:, c/as\ of interesting molecules. As yet there is no firm evidence for heteroallenes of the group I3 elements: these are likely to be investigated in the future. Finally. the flash photolytic studies of silaallenes which have provided much insight into their formation (see Sect. IIIA2) will probably be continued and expanded to include other members of the heteroallene family.
RI:I.I:KEN(‘ES
(3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (X) (9) ( IO) (I I I
Trinquirr. G.; Mall-ieu. J.-I’. .1. Aur. (‘II~I. Sw. 1987, 109. 5303. Barth&t. J. C.: TI-inquirr. G.: Bcrtrand. C;. ./. A/II. Clrcw. So,. lY7Y, /O/. 3785. Lien. M. fl.: Hopkinaon. A. C. Clwur. P/T!,. Idr/f. 1981. SO, II-I. Gordon, M. S.; Kooh. R. D. J. h. Clrcm. Sot. IY81, IO.?, 1939. Maier. G.: Pad. H.; Reihcnauer. H. I? Augcx C‘lwr~s. Irrf. fd. Eqq/. lYY5, .I-!. 1439. Maier. G.: Rciwnaurr. H. P.: Egenoll. Ii. Or~str,~o,l~~,fr////~.\ 1999, IS, 2 15.5. Apeloig. Y.: Knrni. M. J. hr. C/MI. SW. 1984, /Oh. 6676. Krogh-Jespersen. K. J. (‘on~p. ~‘hw. 1982, 3. 57 I Cioslow\ki, J.; Hamilton, T.: Scusxia. G.: He\\.. 13. A. Jr.; Hu, J.; Schaad. L. J.: Dupuis. M ./. hr. C/W,?l. .SOC~.1990, I /,7. 31 x3. ( 12) (a) lahikawa, M.: Fuchikami. T.: Kumada. M. .I. Arx C‘lrrw. .Soc 1977, YY. 245: (h) Ishikaw. M.: Sugisawn, H.: Yumnmoto. K.: Kumada. M. J. O~:qtrrrowr. (‘lwu~. 1979, 179. 377: (c) Ishihaua. M.: Nishimut-a. K.: Sugiuwa. H.: Kumada. M..I. Or:~or~owr C‘l~eu~.1980, IYJ, 147:(d) Ishihawa. M.: Ni\himum. K.: Ochiai, H.; Kumada. M. ./. Oqruww~. Clrcw. 1982, ?.?h. 7: (e) I\hikwa. M.: Kwnr. D.: Fuchikami. T.; Ni\himura. K.: Kumada. M.: Higwhi. T.: M~yamoto. S. ./. A~rr. Ciwru. Scw. 1981, 103. 2124: (f) Ihikawa, M.: Sugisawa, H.: Fuchikumi, T.; Kumada. M.: Yamahe, T.: Kawahami. H.; Fuhui. K.: Ueki, Y.: Shi/uka. H. ./. Aw. CIwn. So<.. lY82, IO-I, 2872: (g) Ihhikawa, M.; Sugisawa, H.: Kumada. M.; tiiguchi. T.: Matsul, K.: Hirota K.: Iyoda. J. O,;~tr,l~,n~rf~l//ir,.\ 1983, 2. I7-1; (h) IShikawa. M.: Matwawa, S.: Hi!-otw. K.: Kamitot-i. S.; Higuchi. T. O,-gr~nonrc,/~t/li[,v 1984, .i, 1930; (i) I\hikoua. M.: Mathwaua. S.: Higuchi. ‘I‘.: Kamitori, S.: Hirotsu. K. Or~~“~~j/~~“/o/l;[,,\ lY85, 4. 2040: (j) Id~ikawa, M.: Sugisanu. H.; Iiorata. 0.; Kumada. M. ./. Or,cyuwmct. (‘/rem. 1981, 217. 43: (k) I\hikawa, M.; Ohshita. J.: Ito. Y. Oigi~,~o,,~~f~~//ic~\ 1986, 5. IS IX. ( I3) Brook. A. G.: Brook, M. A. A&. O~~~trm~~rraf.Clrcm. 1996, .jY, 7 I.
Chemistry (I-I)
of Group 14 Heteroallenes
45
(7X) (29)
(a) Ishikawa. M.; Fuchihami. T.: Kumada. M. J. AUI. C/rc~r. Sot. 1979, 101. 1348: (b) Ishikawa. M.: Sugisawa. H.: Fuchikami. T.; Kumada. M.: Yamabe. T.: Kawakanli, H.: Fukui, K.: Ueki. Y.: S.: Sugi\awa. Shi/uka, H. ./. 4rn. C/lrv?~. Sot. 1982, 104. 2872: (c) Ishihawa. M.; Matsuawa, H.: Yano. F.: Kamitori. S.: Hlguchi. T. J. -\r~. Chcvn. Sot. 1985, /07. 7706; (d) lahiknwa. M.: Ohshita. J.: Ito, Y.: lyocla. J. ./. AUI. C‘hrr~~. Sot. 1986, /OX. 7117: (e) Ohshita. J.: Isomura. Y.: I\hihawa. M.: O~~cl,lo,rrrttr//ic,,~ 1989, h’. 70.50: (f) I\hihawa. M.; Nomura, Y.: Torakl. E.; Kunai, A.; Oh\hita. .I. J. Oqonc~ncv. C’lxv~. 1990, -
(30)
Rlgon.
(15) t 16) ( 17) (IX) f 19) (20) (21)
(22) (23) (21) (2% (26) (27)
/i. 3070. L.: Ranaivonjatovo.
H.: EvxdiC.
J.: Duhourg,
A.; Drclcrcq,
J.-P. C‘lrc~rr. E/c/: ./. 1999, .i,
771. (31 1 Wiberg, N.; Lerner, H.-W.; Va\i%ht. S.-K.: Wagner, S.: Karaghio\toff. K.: Niith. H.: Ponikwx. W. ht: J. /wy. C‘lrrm. 1999, I2 I 1. (12) Yin. J.: Kloain, J.; Abboud, K. A.: Jane\. W. M. ./. 111~. Clrctv. Sot,. 1995, 117, 3298. (3.3) For a recent review of structure\ of main group multiple bonds. vx: Power. P. P. C/x,/a Kcl: 1999, YY. 3463. (34) Groth. P. Aa Chr,,~. SU&. 1973, 27. 3302. 1.35) (a) Meyer. H.; Baun~, G.: Massa. W.: Berndt, A. i\rlgcr~: Clinv. /,lt. EC/. &g/. 1987, 26, 79X: (b) Meyrr. H.; Baunl. G.; Mama. W.: Bergcr, S.: Berndt. A. An~c’n: C/?c,~r. /rz/. EC/. keg/. 1987, 26, 546; (c) Berndt. A.: Meyer, H.: Baum. G.: Massa, W.: Berger, S.: PUI? A/J/I/. C‘lrm. 1987, 5Y. IO1 I. (36) Lazq, M.: Escudi6. J.: Couret. C.; Sat@, J.; DIGiger, M.; Dammel. R. Aqgrn: C/le~l. /nr. Et/.
Eq/.
1988, 27, 828.
46
BARRETT
EICHLER
AND
ROBERT
WEST
ADVANCES
IN ORGANOMETALLIC
CHEMISTRY,
VOL. 46
“Very M ixecFMetal Carbonyl Clusters SUSAN M . WATERMAN,
NIGEL T. LUCAS, and MARK G. HUMPHREY Department of Chemistry Australian National University Canberra, ACT 0200, Australia
I. II.
III.
IV. V.
Into-oduction Kcacti\ity Srudic\ A. General comment\. B. Ligand Substitution C. Ligand Addition. D Lipd Tran\fot-mation?. E. Core Transformation\ F. Catalytic Studie PhyGcal Measuremcnta A. General Comment\. B. Fluxionality C. Electrochemistry. D. Othct- Physical Methods. Conclusion and Outlook Appendix: Abbreviation\ IWerence~
37 38 3x 49 64 07 79 I Oh I IO I I6 I I6 12s 130 I35 IX> I17
I INTRODUCTION Transition reasons.’
metal
carbonyl
The oil crisis
catalysts
or models
research
since that time.
clusters
facilitates
complexes. molecules potential
for catalysis, substrate
a
attracted
interest
encouraged
interest
for
coordination not readily
of metal atoms within of accessible
as “electron
reservoirs.”
a
oxidation
a number
in clusters
and this has been an enduring
transformations
large number
to function
have
The multimetallic
The aggregation with
clusters
of the mid-1970s
theme
of organic achievable
metal cluster
in cluster
molecules
at
at mononuclear core can afford
states which
Fluxionality
of
as pre-
at metal
may have the clusters
may
provide an effective model of substrate mobility at surfaces active as heterogeneous catalysts. As clusters become progressively larger in sire. they may be expected to adopt metallic character, and the intermediacy of a “metametallic” potentially interesting physical properties has been proposed.’ The pre-eminent
factor controlling
has been the existence
or otherwise
the development of efficient
state with
of areas of cluster chemistry
routes into the clusters
themselves.
47 All rights
Copyright c 2001 by Academic Press. of reproduction in any form reserved. 0065-3055/01 $35.00
48
ef a/
WATERMAN
Most
early
syntheses
has been effective metal
clusters.
clusters
have become
environment
for a number and structural
of physical
properties
A significant or ad,jacent
parate
metals
afford
such clusters
above
would
have
activation, more
clusters
comprised
A number
aspects
as
groups.
for
group
4-10.
from
properties transition
metals
(PGM)
with
affect
catalyzed
actitrans-
metals.
appeared.xm”
containing
review
and
exalnples
clusters
has recently
carbonyl
by three or more
this definition
is somewhat
are coupled
to non-PGM.
arbitrary.
metals, synthetic
to 19% inclusive.
mixed”-metal
separated
However,
similar
summarizing
9 heterometallic
metals
substrate
discrimination
late transition
have
a
of “very
if
metal
precatalysts.
clusters
published
clusters
and should their
to listed
an electropositive
facilitate
clusters
h-group
homometallic
heterogeneously
metals
dis-
procedures
bond may enhance
may
although
the same
of the properties
of reagents.
Many
from
incorporating
as synthetic
coupling
(which
aspects,
metals
and a number
on mixed-metal
While
ligand
have focused
and investigations
clusters
may bc effective
containing
and physical
groups
that platinum
contain
is surprising.
is possible).
of group
those containing
defined
This
of hcterometallic
” This review.
studies
mixed-metal
for a range
and structural
on the reactivity
reactivity
clusters
processes
been
site selectivity,
rare.
to mid-transition
of reviews
reactivity
appeared.
systematic
For example,
of these metals
has largely
or on synthetic and
early
of the heterometallic
activation,
to show sharp differences
for fluxional
to a range of mixed-metal
the signiticancc
metal to give a polar metal-metal
couple
the focus
of Stone
are now well established.
than one process
formations
analyses
advances
etc.), but thus far most reports
reported.
and metalloselectivity
energies
when
been
is very different.
and electronegative
theoretical
but far fewer
be expected
the heterometal
to the pioneering
of mixed-metal
groups,
for mixedmixed-metal
and the experimental
(substrate
arc comparatively
number
group
studies:
to synthesize
groups.3~~7 Access
responses.
not surprisingly.
but is less useful
procedures
to assess
of properties
electrochemical
on synthetic
research
the possibility
type which,
clusters
due largely
and others,
and their
affords
mobility,
available,
and Mingos
and Vahrenkamp, clusters
it and hope”
In the last 20 years, general
by Hoffmann
vation
were of the “heat
for a range of homometallic
focuses clusters. d-block it ensures
II REACTIVITY
STUDIES
A. General Comments L&and viewed,
activation but
few
and transformation of “very
examples
at heterometallic mixed”-metal
clusters have been rcclusters effecting these
“Very Mixed”-Metal
transformations mations
were identified
at “very
aubsequcnt activity
of “very
particular
mixed”-metal
tion. and substrate heteromctallic below
bond-,
proceed
LO ligand
addition,
overlap
types
were published
metalLmctal
bonds
or unique
substitution
and so have been mentioned
rcacGona
corresponding
reactions
of studies
to
active-
in the seclions
intermediates
exchange
A number
reagents
substrate
classifications with
in the re-
of directing
is unavoidable:
01‘ metal
intermediates.
Iransfortnations,
the polar
Iran&r-
interests
enhanced
the reactivity tncchanisms.
and cerlain
way of core-expanded Iigand
some
by associative
major
are the possibility
utilizing While
of ligand
in this Chapter above,
or face-specificity),
transformation
are self-explanatory,
all reports
summarized
As mentioned clusters
environment.
frequently
volve
clusters
review.
sites (metallo-.
almost
at the time;”
mixed”-metal
to the earlier
49
Carbonyl Clusters
cart occur
by
catalysis
in-
modeling briefly
in both rclcvant
seclions.
B. Ligand Substitution . ot dtttering
The presence into ligand disparity
substikttion: between
core also reduces rendering
The
the effective
the possibility
should
be enhanced
introduction
of differing
symmetry
ligands
isolated
mobility.” clusters
in Section
have involved
ties provides
availability
phosphines
from
range
of steric
which
ing samples Studies tr-
suitable
for single
substitution ot’ phosphinc
or ~etranuclcat-
at “very
crystal
clusters.
X-ray
mixed”-metal
substitution
studies. clusters
all trimetallic
of organotnetallic
and electronic
have delined
proper-
of site- and the substitution
cluster; instead, phosthe prospects 01‘obtain-
The results
of’ phosphine
arc summarized
have thus far focused
with almost
II.B.2.
investigations
sites of‘ ;I range of phosphines at a “very mixed”-metal phines have frequently been employed solely to enhance phosphite
mixcd”-
;tnd these are sumtnarkd
in Section
out syskmatic
but there are few studies
metal
due to donot
ot’ “very
the most fundamental
a broad
by core
predicted
studies
or phosphitcs.
are considered
of carrying
those
the
and others
have met with
clusters labilika
substitution
are among with
the possibility
mctallo-selectivity,
of ligand
ligands
and phosphites
Their
differ
clusters.
and nfi’ording
by Vahrenkatnp
of substitution
ofien
majority
I1.B. I All other
Phosphines reagents.
The
products
homometallic
in mixed-metal
a sequence
the
into a cluster
metals
inequivalent.
Attetnpts
of site rcactivitics”
but although
of metnlloselectivity upon accentuating
over that ofrelated
sites for incoming
a “hierarchy
success,
GUI be defined, metal
introduces
of site- as well as metallo-selectivity.
to define
ligand
the metals.
coordination
prospect some
metals
this selectivity
almost
examples
in Table
excltusively
pseudorctrahedral
and I. on
::
TABLE
I
It SI’BSTITI TIOK -\T VEKY MIXtt)-MEr-\L
CLL’STFRS
[Mot&(/r ~-CC0~menth~l)(CO)7(L)(~/‘-CiHi)l 1I. = P(OM+. PQ3] (1LloCo~(,i~-CCO~menthyl)~COl~,~~~rphoiJ~,~~~L)](L = CH,Pr’. C,,H-i [M~CO~(~:-CCO~PI-‘)(~~-L)(CO)~(I~~-C‘~M~~)~(L=dppr. arphm) [WCo-.(/t ~-CMej(CO)?(PHPh2)(~li-C,H,,] [WCol(/r :-CC~,H,Me-J)(C0),(PMe2Ph,r,li-L)I (I-=CiHi. CsH$5iMq) IWCO~(II:-CC~H,M~-~)(CO)~,(L)~~I~~~L’)I il.= PMqPh. L’ =CiHi. C>H,SiMr;: 1. = P(OMe);. 1.’=CiHi, IWCol(,l7-CChH,Mz-l)(~c-dpp1ll)(CO)(,r,i~~L)] (L. = C’5H>. CjH$5iMr;) [WCO~(I~-H)(/I~-CC~H~M~-~)(/~-PP~~)(C‘O)~(PM~~P~)(,~~-C~H~~~ ~WCo~(,r-,~‘-CEtCEt(‘EtCEt)(/~-~~~-CEtCEt)(COl,[P~OM~~~} I IW~lr(~r;~CC~,H~Me-~)(jr-CC~H~~~~~)~Cl)(CO):(PPh~)(~~‘-C~H~)~] lMoMCo(/i ~-S,(CO):(L)(I,‘-C~H~)~ [M = Fc. Ku. L = (S-PMePhPr: M = Ru. L = P(O~i~)-menth~lJI’I~~l ~Mo~eC’o(/~~-S)~/c-dppe)tCO~~,(~~~~CiH,~l~~~ IMFe(‘o(/cl-PM~)tCO),(l.i(~~i-L’)i (hl = klo. 1%‘L. = PPh:. PMe:Ptr. I.‘= (‘
Product Clustel
PtlOSrtilnE/PHOirHI
Metal Coordinating P-Donor Lipand
5
52
WATERMAN
by virtue
of a /L+apping
(CO)g($-L)] C5H.$iMej,
CUH7) have been reacted
derivatives
the specific
the bidentate
the cobalt
plant)
atoms
increases
not
on increasing
to afford
isolated
PCy;
the reaction
0
0
g derivatives
(3: I mixture
[ WCo,(/( between
(Fig.
and metallosclectivity
the ligand
d-cquatorially
The related
from
and biden-
I ). with
ligatin g at equatorial sites (with proposed to ligate at an axial site:
are diastereotopic,
to the phosphine
(/1-L)(CO)h(17~-C~Mes)].” was
P(OMe);
[MC(~~(/LI-CCO~P~‘)(CO)~(II’-C~M~~)]
unds dppe and arphos
and monodentate
products.‘“,‘“.‘”
and the bulky
atoms
[ MCo2(j~I-CR)
L = C;H5, C5H4Pr’,
although for most of the sites were not detined. NMR studies have clar-
and monodentate
the cobalt
9 clusters
CO? menthyl;
with phoaphites
cobalt-ligated
substitution
arphos
discrimination)
Similarly.
&group
of the (+)-menthylester-containin
to the MoCol
significantly, (no
to afford
the structures
respect
The group
(M = Mo, W; R = Me, Cc,H4Me-3,
tate phosphines ified
ligand.
et a/
cone angle
of diastereomers reacted
with
cobalt-ligated
obtained).
the bidentate
lig-
[ MC~$/L?-CCOJPI-‘)
3-CMc)(CO),(PHPhl) [ WCoz(/r
between
fl-om the phosphite
(,&CsH5)]
~-CMC)(CO)~(~~‘-C~H.~)I
0
0
(
(
(‘
c
“Very Mixed”-MetalCarbonyl Clusters
53
and PHPhZ. but is a presumed reaction intermediate en route to P-H activation (Section II.D.2.). The product of P-H cleavage in this case, namely [WCol(Il-H)(ln3-CC~,HJMe-4)(/1-PPh2)(CO)~,(~~’-C~H~)l, reacted with PMezPh to afford a Co-ligated product.‘” [ WCo:(ll-,I’-CEtCEtCEtCEt)(p-q-CEtCEt)(CO)s] reacted with P(OMe)j by displacement of carbonyl at the later transition metal.” Similarly, [W’Ir(pjCC~~H~Me-4)(~-CC~,H~Me-4)(CI)(CO)~(q-CgH5)2] reacted with PPh3 to afford an iridiun-ligated product, but the site of substitution was not determined.” The other trimetallic clusters to have been investigated are all chiral by virtue of four differing core constituents. The group 6-group &group 9 clusters [MFeCo(pjS)(CC))~($-C~HJR)] (M = MO. W: R = H, Me) have been reacted with monodentate and bidentate phosphines (Fig. Z).“.” The initial studies with these phosphines were undertaken with the goal of resolving the cluster enantiomers. A r-accmic mixture of clusters and the optically active phosphine (R)-PMePhPt afforded diastereomeric products which could be separated by crystallization. The phosphine was then removed by carbonylation to give the cluster enantiomers with an optical purity of%!-IOOcir~.‘” Reaction ofthe ruthenium-containing analogue [MoRLICO(/J~-S)(CO)~($-C~H~)] with optically active PMePhPr and P(Omcnthyl)Ph2 gave mixtures ofdinstcreoisomers [ M~RuCO(/QS)(CO)~(L)($ CjHj)] [L = (S)-PMePhPr. P(O-(-)-menthyl}Ph?]: in this case. the diastereoisomers could be separated chromatographically. but the pure enantiomers could not bc recovered. More recently. reaction of the (methylcyclopentadienyl )tungsteniron-cobalt example with dppc has been studied. In contrast to the monodentate phosphine derivative above, in which the phosphine ligates at the cobalt atom trur~.sto the Co-Fe vector, the bidentatc ligand bridges the Co-Fe linkage and coordinates ~UU~.Y to the Fe-MO and Co-S bonds. The related phosphinidene clusters [MFeCo(lr-PMe)(CO),(L)(?~~-CsH~)J (M = MO. W; L = PMe;Ph, PPh?) resulted from degradation of [MFeCol(/l?-PMe)(/l-AsMez)(CO)s(q-CjHi)] with the appropriate ligand: cobalt ligation was proposed on the basis of spectrlll data. but the substitution site was not ascertained.‘” The analogous [WFeCo(/l?PMc)(C0)7(L)($L’)] (L = PMe?, PMezPh: L’ = C5Hs. CSMe5) was formed by
54
WATERMAN et a/
reaction of [WFeCo(/17-PMe)(CO)s(,l~-L’)I with L. The reaction proceeded by way of an isolable adduct in which two equivalents of ligand have been added and two metal-metal bonds have been cleaved; heating the adduct in vacuum formed a closocluster product by elimination ofC0 and L.” Substitution at chiral alkylidyne clusters has also been demonstrated. The clusters [ MoCoNi(kr j-CR)(C0)5(t75C5H5)2] [R = Me. C(O)Ph] reacted with both PMe2PhZX and (R)-PMePhPr’” to afford cobalt-substituted derivatives, not unexpected as the other metal atoms are ligated by cyclopentadienyl groups: the incoming ligand was shown to be trur~~.v to the Co-C vector for the benzoyl-containing cluster (Fig. 3). Phosphine substitution at [MRuCo(H)(p~-CMe)(CO)s( $-CSH5)] (M = MO, W) surprisingly occurred at the group 8 metal rather than the group 9 metal to afford [MRuco(H)(/~jCMe)(CO),(L)($-C,H,)I (L = PMej, PMelPh. PMePhl, PPhl): the iron- and osmium-containing analogues were resistant to thermal CO substitution.3’1 The alkyl-coordinated clusters [MRuCo(y I-CR)(CO),( $CMe(CO:Me)NHC(O)Me} (I$C~H~)] (M = Mo, W; R = Me. Ph) reacted with both PPh? and CO by way of deinsertion ofacetamido acrylic acid methyl ester to form. in the case of phosphine. a ruthenium-ligated product.“’ cluster The dimolybdenum-dicobalt [Mo~C~~(/~~-S)(/~?-S)~(CO)~()IC5H4Me)2]. which desulfurized organic thiols (Section lI.D.2.). reacted with phos” J7 Kinetic studies showed that reaction phines by ligand substitution at cobalt.--. proceeded by two elementary steps: initial formation of an adduct followed by loss ofC0 (Fig. 4). The extent of substitution is dominated by electronic considerations; while phosphine substitution proceeded to give bis-substituted derivatives. reaction with isocyanides afforded tris-substituted products (see Section II.B.2.). These substitution reactions proceeded at room temperature: heating the PHzPh-substituted product led to double P-H bond cleavage and coordination of PJ-phosphinidene (Section II.D.2.). The same cluster reacted with bidentate phosphines to afford cobalt-chelated products (Fig. 5). with excess dmpe affording a bis-substituted derivative.3’ In contrast. the related cluster [Mo2C02(~~-S)~(CO)1(11”-C5H4Me)21
“Very Mixed”-Metal
I/ .111\
FIG. 3.
Monodentate
Carbonyl Clusters
55
iI\
P-donor- ligand substitution
at IM~~C~~(~~J-S)(,~,-S)~(CO)?(,~~-C~H,M~)~~:
(i) L= P(OM~)J. PH2Ph. PHPh:. PBu:. PP~I. PMel. (ii) L= P(OMe)l. PHPh2.
rcacted with dppe to form a product in which the bidentate ligand is believed to span the Co-Co vector. and in the presence of excess dppe afforded D polymeric product. but the products were incompletely characterized.jj The tungsten-triiridium cluster [WIr-JCO), ,(~$C~HS)] and its molyhdenum analogue have also been extensively investigated (Fig. 6). Reaction of
56
WATERMAN
[ Wlr$C0)1
1(11~-C5Hg)] with
ature in a stepwise ligated
derivatives
ofwhich phites
as mixtures
were ascertained reacted
containing greater
mixtures steric
isostructural
phosphincs
the mono-.
ofinterconvcrting
to atl‘ord
mixtures
constraints;
only
with
of
varying
mono-
in solution,
and
q5-CjH5)] extent
at iridium
to afford
niono-
temper-
. icnctccl were
Phos-
The 4d metaland
reacted
and his-substituted
the identitie\
with
of’ substitution.
his-substitution
iridiuin-
studies.“.‘s
products.“’
;~n;~logo~~s
[ M~~I~~(/~I-CO)(/I-CO)(CO),(/~~-C~H~)~~
tate phosphines
at room
and spectroscopic
[ Molr~(/~-CO)$CO)x(
ol~clusters
proceeded
his-, and tria-suhatituted ihomers
by crystallographic
similarly
homologue
affording
monodentatc to afford
manner
et al.
less control, reacted with
ohserved.” with
The
monoden-
products.“’
Hiden-
tate phosphines reacted with [WIr3(CO)I I(~&CiHi)] at iridium to aftord diaxially ligated edge-bridged products, an unexpected result with the linear diphosphine dppa. [ W2Pt2(/1 ;-CC~HIMe-4)(/L-CC~,H,Mc-4)(CO)~( to’-cod)( I~‘-C~H~)~] reacted with
PMePh-
to allord and
the
at platinum
by displacement
of the “lightly
stabilizing”
cod ligand
[WIPt2(/13-CC,HJMe-4)(~-CC~,HJMe-3)(CO)~(PMePh~)~(~~.i-C~H,i)~I.~’ ruthenium-ligated
product
(Fig.
7)
IW2RuPt(El;-CC~,H~Mc-4)(/1-CC,,H~Me--1)(C0)7(,li-C~H5)1l clusters IMFeCo,(Il?-E)(/L-AsMe2)(CO)x(tj’-CgHj)]
was
obtained
on
reaction
of
with PMezPh.““Thc (M = MO, W: E = S. PMe)
“Very Mixed”-Metal
reacted ucts;
with
donor
the only
ligated even
ligands
products
RNC,
were
phosphine
accompanied could
to afford
core
but reaction being
ligands with obtained
degradation
nuclearity
were
The vast majority at
coordinated
(Section
nuclearity
W)
contain
be expected
to undergo
was somewhat
complex.
II.E.2.).JX
facile with
metals.
or acetylene
prod-
the cobalt8). although
products,‘”
by CO. The chain
and
complexes
“lightly
atnbilizing”
ligand
substitution.
core-expanded
prod-
”
ofphosphine/phosphite-substituted
late transition CO
(Fig. lower
replaced
(M = Cr. MO,
and might
phosphines
by other
be readily
[ M2Pt(CO)(,(NCPh)$rI”-CSHs)~] benzonitrile
ligation
~lnd PRj
the cluster
1MFeCo2(/l.i-PMe)(~-AsMel)(C0)7(PPIlI)(,15-C~Hs)] these clusters
the incoming
ucts
P(OR)3
to retain
57
Carbonyl Clusters
In contrast.
phosphite
products ligands
in [ RePtj(/L-dppnl)i(CO)3(L)]4
PPh 3 * (‘0
involve displaced .J2 which
Y-ligand rheniumxc
the
58
WATERMAN et al.
MC2’//w,
c
(’
/?I’\
\,
,
Y’
I p’\w/p’
(‘
p’\J
(‘
I”\Jpt
Mc \
-
‘1
MC
addition ylene
products adducts
the more
from reaction
were formed
electron-rich
at rhenium,
rather
tion studies
on larger
the formation CsH&] from
oL‘ L with [RePt3(~1-dppt~,)3(CO)~]‘.
as the starting
cluster
[RePt3(~13-0)2(~~-dppm)7(C0)3]i
than addition, “very
on reaction
mixed”-metal
with
clusters
The CO/acct-
is comparatively
electron
underwent phosphite.“,”
poor;
substitution
Ligand
substitu-
arc very rare. one example
being
of [M(~2W.iPth(/*3-CChHJMe-4)?(/13-CMe)J(CO)Io(PMe,Ph)1(,7sdisplacement of the weakly-bound cod ligands in [MoZW3Pt&li-
CC~,H~Me-4)~(~~~-CMe)~(CO)lo(~~“-cod)~(~~5-C5H5)5] by PMelPh (Fig. 9).“”
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Almost sition
all other examples
metal
honylation
and involved of clusters
also replace
FK;. IO.
[Mn2P~(CO),21.
of Ii&and
replacement
the introduction
occurs
phosphines
easily
under
have occurred
or replacement
with
some
readily
displaced
circumstances:
proceeded
to
stream after
ofC0
passed
2 h the latter
Nitriles
and dienes
clusters;
through cluster
carbonylation [MozCo$/~j-
in a facile
a solution
of the cluster affording
are ‘*lightly
not surprisingly. fashion
stabilizing”
reaction
to afford
the
ligand
akstance
a halide
ligands
[MnzPt(CO)I1]
ligand
(a alou
(Fig.
acceptor
I ()).>j
and
I I).”
in the precursor
the ~l’-cotl by carbonyls replacement W)
to give
In the tungsten-containing and the terminal
carbonyl
CO proceeded
(M = Mo.
proceeding
however, products.‘”
metal
with
In contrast.
(TI[PF(,]).
cluster
at transition
was displaced
C0)~(~~-dppm)2(CO)(-dppm)20(,~‘-CsHi)I ’ (Fig. pies, both the chloro
product
conditions
for a few minutes);
at ~MPd~(~~~-CO)~(/~-dpp~~i)~Cl(~~~-CiH5)1 of
substitution
mild
trinuclear
[CrlRh(~ri-S)1(/1-SBu’)(C0),(1/5-C~H5)~1.’~
chloro
the
of [Mn2Pt(CO)lo(NCPh)2]
in [Cr2Rh(/l:-S)2(~r-SBu’)(?~~-cod)(?~~-Cg] ford
of IWFeCo2(lli-PMe)(ln-
under
had degraded
II). Car-
but CO can
afforded afford
I WFeCo7(/13-PMe)(y-AsMe2)(CO)x(l7’-C5fI~)l
ligands,
for example.
and carbonylation
AsMel)(C0)7(PPh;)(175-CjHj)1
at the late tran-
of CO (Table
of [ Mo2Co7(E1i-PPh)(/I;-S)3(CO)(PH2Ph)(,I’-C5H~Me),I PPh)(/r3-S)3(CO),(,Is-C~H,Me)~],~~
59
Carbonyl Clusters
carhonyl
ligand to
af-
of the required
lMPd2(/13cxanligand
in
1+
CO t ‘1-1I PF, I
II
Pt Rh Pd I’d Pd co CO CO
co - KKC
CO co
PPhj - CO PH:Ph - C‘O PhCN - CO ,I’-cod i 2CO (‘I- + co co - BrCl - BI KO - 2cp CO - RNC‘
KO
+ 2co co 3(‘0
2PllC~Pll - 2x + 2cI - 30
2co - s 2co - Pl1C:H ZCO ---f diw ?CO - Mc:SiC~SiMc~ 7(Y) - McC2Me
cp - 1. (L = CH3(‘02. Cl I
TABLE
“Very Mixed”-Metal
FK;. Bu’.
(ii)
I?.
Iwnitrile
athtitution
ZRNC. R = Bu’.
(iii)
Carbonyl Clusters
61
at [Mo~CO~(/LJ-S)(/~ ~-S)~(CO),(,,‘-(‘~~-l,~l~)~~: (I) RNC. R = Mc. 3RNC. R = Me. Bu’.
the product can be displaced by bromide. Metal exchange procedures to form “very mixed”-metal clusters (Section [I.E. I .) have utilized [Ni($-CgHs)?] and [ Ni(CO)(&CSH5)12 as sources of “Ni($-CsH5).” but the former also delivers the cyclopentadienyl group which can displace carbonyl ligands: reaction of [MoCo7(/1#ZCO?Pr’)(CO)x(ll’-C5H)1 witheither [Ni($-CgH5)2] orthemore logical cyclopentadiene afforded [ MoCo~(~~3-CC07Pri)(~~-CO)(CO)~(~~s-C5Hj)~].s’ The carbonyl ligands in IMo2C~~2(~J-S)(,~i-S)2(CO)-I(~~s-CgH~Me),] and [ MoZCoZ(LLJ-S)J(CO)l( qs-CjHJMe)21 can be displaced by isocyanicles,J7~‘7~‘X though reaction of the former only proceeded to form the tris-substituted product (Figs. 12, 13). Both clusters desulfurized isothiocyanates, with the resultant isocyanides forming substitution products.“x Carbonyl sulfide can be used as a source of sulfide ligands. Thus. reaction of [Mo$Zo&L~-S)(~~-S)?(CO)~(qs-CsH,Me)Z] with COS afforded (Mo?CO$/I~-S)J (C0)2($-CSHIMe)~J. a process which can be reversed upon carbonylation (Fig. l4).5x The same cluster added one equivalent of phenylacetylene in a /A?-$fashion across a MoCol face with loss of two CO ligands and rearrangement of the /LA-sulfdo ligand into a pi-coordination mode.“” The tetrahedral cluster [WIr7(CO)I ~(I$-CSH~)], in contrast, added two equivalents of diphenylacctylene, one at a heterometallic Wlr-, face, and the other at the unique homometallic Ir: face.“’ Studies of phosphine and phosphite substitution at (WCO~(/~-CC~,HJM~4)(CO)s(q’-L)] (L = C5H5, C5H3SiMe3) summarized in Section I1.B. 1. have been extended to embrace diars and (for L=CSH5) Me$iCECSiMei.‘” For diars, a cobalt-ligated product was obtained, but the specific substitution sites were not ascertained. whereas the alkyne was shown to coordinate in a /L-$fashion across
62
WATERMAN et a/
a W-Co linkage. But-2-yne replacement of two CO ligands at [WFeRh(/l,\CR)(/I-CO)(CO),;(HB(~~)~}(~~~-C~H~)~ (R = Me. C~,HJM~-~) occurred to al‘ford ;I /I-$l-ligating internal acetylene bridging the W-Rh bond.“’ The II’-coordinated edge-bridging cyclopentadicnyl ligmd in [MoPd7(lrj-CO)(/1-ll~-CSH,)(,~CO)z(PR~)?(lj-C5Hs)l (R= Pr’. Et) was replaced on reaction with CHICOIH or SiClMe;. affording [MoPdl(/li-CO)(,L-CO)7(/1-L)(PR)2(,7j-CH~)l (L= CHICO1, Cl).“’ Other reports of ligand replacement at “very mixed”-metal clusters involve ;I Ihrnmal oxidation state change. Reaction of 1Mo$?o$/l 1-S)4(CO)2(q5-CiHJEt)2] with halogens or diphenyl disulfide afforded [ Mo2Col(/~ 3-S)4(X)7( I~‘-C~H~E~)~] (X = Cl. Br, I, SPh),“3.“1 with a formal oxidation at the cobalt atoms, and clcavage of the Co-Co linkage (Fig. IS). All product clusters are paramagnetic in the solid state (but less so in solution), wnith higher spin states disfavored as the
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
63
x, x = I. (‘I
r-donor ability ofX increases. Oxidation at the late transition metal was also seen upon heating [MoRh3(/13-AsRh(CO)(I75-CsH~)](~~-CO)~(~~~-C~Hs)~] in CHCl+ with the “action” occurring at the non-cluster rhodium atom (Fig. 16).“5 In contrast, the earlier transition metal was oxidized in ;1 stepwise fashion upon reacting [RePt3(lr-dppm)3(CO)j]+ with molecular oxygen, with (overall) a formal increase of+6 in oxidation state (Fig. 17).“” The oxidation product isolated was sensitive to the reaction conditions, with hydrogen peroxide or molecular oxygen/photolysis affording products lacking metal-metal bonds.“7
I’ J
RI1
WATERMAN
64
et a/
C. Ligand Addition A range ofelectrophiles ligand
displacement,
have been added to “very
and thcsc are summarized
the reactions
of clusters
with nucleophiles
is frequently
arbitrary,
though,
latter. The examples which
the formal
electron
count
cluster
addition
at “very
reactions reactions
as ligand
the former
of the latter collected
by compensating The
with
bond
mixed”-metal
in this section. substitution
often
on the cluster
mixed”-rnctal
sometimes
111 collects
of (W2Pt(,-I-PPh2)2(CO)5(,75-CHS)LI
with
[ Au(PPhJ)]
HBFJ
afforded
with
adducts
the electrophile
ing stereochemistry
with
bond.
afforded
(Fig.
whereas
HCI
respect
lX).““Theclusteranion
reacted linkage.“’
with
HBFJ
Protonation
by
been
contrasted;
bridging
a W-Pt
to the bridging
a product
accompanied
examples
with
groups
a terminal
two and
of‘ ligand
sources
of Ht.
[ Au(PPhj)]PF(,
linkage.
but with
dil’fer-
across
the other
W-Pt
Pt-bound
hydrido
ligand
[MoCo2(/1~-CC~,H1Me-4)(/r-PPh2)(CO)(,(r75-CjHs)]~ across the heterornetallic addition of H
at the related
of the
to those in
clusters.
and the isolobal
’ , have
01
addition
by way
are restricted
increases,
Table
without
or ligand
proceeding
in this section
cleavage(s).
clusters
The classification
1WCo,(IL-H)(II~-CMe)(ll-PPh2)(CO)h(lli-
MO-Co
66
WATERMAN
CsH5)] age.
was shown
but
stable
by ‘H NMR
the product
adding
at the only
lar cluster
anion to afford
;1 variety
of bases,
acy
pentanuclear
the reaction
the reverse
with
methoxidc
derivative.7’
occurred
Most
linkage.
hydrido
Mo-MO
bond to afford
the butterfly
PBu’C~,H~-2-PBu’)(CO)(,()li-C~Hg)21;
bridging
mentioned
in Section
S)~(CO)4(~$C5H~Me)~] ing Co-S
either
past
the ad~tuct.‘~
The
by way ofan 57 although
unsaturated
cluster
PPh,)2(y-CO)(CO)~(II’-CSHi)ll.
with
molecule
rhodium
of CO
at the terminal
adduct
Ihrmal group
by P-C
Llnsaturation.“.“’ 9 clusters
bond
formal
has been the subject
CO)~(C0)7(,~5-CjHi)ll RCIR’)(,~-CO)l(CO)l( I,4’-Cr,H,C-CChH~N02.
reacted qS-CjH+j CH?Br),
with acompensat-
reaction
of several
double
to afford
did not proceed
bonds.
[ W2Rhl(/~
added
one
3-CMe)(/l-
I~).Theproductsubscqucntly
eliminated
chemistry
with
at cobalt.
W=Rh
atom
(Fig.
The acetylene
to react.”
IW~Rhl(/(3-CMe)(/~-CMeC(0)}(/L-
and then
formation,
cluster by cleav-
at [ Mo~CO~(/L~-S)(/L~-
for PMel
CMeC(0)}(~n-PPhl)2(EI-CO)(CO)I(,15-CiH5)~I isomerized
the Mn-Pt
the isostructural
failed
substitution
(Fig. 4).”
this. proba-
[ MolCo2(/l.r-ll~-NO)(,~~-,,~-
the same conditions,
I1.B. I . ligand
occurred
bond cleavage
isomers,
to the tetrahedral
[ MoCoi(~~:-~~‘-PBu’C~,H~-2-PBu’)(,r-CO)(C0)~(r~”-CjHS)] As
chemwith
proceeded
cluster
under
with
addition
two
[Mo2Col(/li-,l’-PBu’C~~H~-2-PB~,’)(,~-CO)(CO)~,(~li-CgH5)1j age ofthe
stoichiometric proceeded
Consistent
to give
01‘ NOBFJ
triangu-
via the intermedi-
linkage.
ligund
” Addition
[Re4Pt(jrelectrophile
spiked
with
reaction
01‘ the electrophile occurred
to the incoming Re-Pt
The
proceeding
at the heterometallic
of [MnRe2Pt(I(-H)2(CO)l_II~
cluster
the incoming
linkage.”
link’ is un-
hc protonated
can
[ReTPt(LL-H);(CO),J\:
corresponding
(W-Co)
“bow-tie” with
Re-Pt
[Re3Pt(p-H)2(CO)14]
or the unbridged
at a heterometallic
reversibly,
non-hydrido-bridged
has therefore
protonation
The
he protonated
of a carbomethoxy
istry bly
of HBF1.‘”
can also
CFjSOjH
to also occur
IWCo2(lr-H)2(,li-CMe)(EI-PPh~)(CO)(,(,15-C~Hi)]
in the absence
H)5(CO)lh]-
et al.
CO to regenerate
of tetrahedral
mixed
the
g~-oul~ 6-G
studies.
acetylenes
For example, IMo21r2(/1afford IMoZlrZ(,lJ-q’ to
(R = R’ = Ph. H: R = H. R’ = Ph. 4ChH4N02. with
a butterfly
metal
core
gcomctry
h-med
“Very Mixed”-Metal by Mo-Mo pleting
cleavage.
a Mo11r&Y2
and the acetylene
octahedron:
trends acetylene
> terminal
phenylacctylenc.
ascribed
The
related
clusters reacted
ilarly
/IJ-$alkyne
reaction
between
contrast.
> internal
acctylcncs
of steric
and
and
to afford
occupying
to the II-Ir
of reaction
;I butterfly
rcactcd
Wlr?
] W~CO~(,~-CO)~(CO)~(~~~_
clcfi
products, was
and ;I sin-
obtained
diphenylncetylene
with
studies
eft’ccts.“’
from
the
to ai‘ford
In
the acetylenes
ifrrc~/-
face-capping
the
ll.B.2.).“’
faces (Section
of’ reactivity
the
and l~henylacctylcnc.7”
with
c//irl ] WIr3(/(.;-,I’-PhC7Ph)7(CO),(,I-CjHj)] II-1 and one of’the
con>
electronic
analogous
]MoCo~(,K0)3(CO)x(rl’-C5H4Me)] I(I$-C,H~)]
vector
rates revealed
alkyneand4nitrophenylacetylenc
to ;I combination
with
] WIrq(CO)I
A number
parallel
analysis
[W21r2(CO)Io(~&H5)~]7X
C5H4Me)2]7h ligated
lying
qualitative
alkyne
67
Carbonyl Clusters
of the coordinatively
unsaturated
(51 e) clusters
]RcPt3(/1-dppm)~(CO)~]~ and ( RcPt;(EI-df’p”i);(0)~]~t. in which the apical rhcni~1111s differ by 6 in I’ormal oxidation state. have been reported. The cluster ] RePtI( ~cdppm);(O)l]+
(itself
\,i;l the addition more
reactive rhenium
(Fig.
by reaction
of’ ]RePtj(/r-clpl.“ii);(CO);]
[RePt;(/~;-0)2(/r-dppm)3(CO);]
to ligand
~lppm)~(CO)~]-~. the
formed
product
addition
than
’ rcactcd
20).4’~‘“~“”
and
Cluster
with
halide
ions
with
by
]RePt3(~~-dppm)3(0),]
‘~ similarly
II.B.3.)
analogue neutral
capping
’ with
Section
its carhonyl-ligated
] RcPtj(lc-dpl)“l)j(CO)c] atom.
’ “:
] RePt:(/l-
donor
the
ligands
wirh
at
lltce
triplatinum
rcactcd
OZ.
was
halides.
and \vith Hg. Tl(acac). and SnX3 . by capping the triplatinum f’xe. ~LI( carbonylation also occurred at the triplatinum face. and reaction with phosphitc occurred at platinum. dation
the latter
two
state” analogue
both
(Fig.
contrastin
2(I).“’ +
g with
the chemistry
The related
cluster
at the “low
cation
] RePt3(/l
oxi-
:-0),(/1-
~~pp”‘h(CO)iI+, the lrioxo
intermediate in the transf’orntation of tricnrbonyl cluster to (see above), reacted with phosphitcs to afford ] RcPt$/l 3-0)2(/(-
cluster
dppm)~(CO),( logucs. rather
P(OR)j)
the more
]+ (R = Me. Ph):.“,”
electron
than the addition
D. Ligand Metal of ways.
unlike
rich dicarbonyl-dioxc, products
(Section
the tricarbonyl
cluster
afforded
or trioxo
;m;l-
the sllbstitution
1I.B. I .).
Transformations
clusters many
have been shown of which
more
metal
atoms
clf‘ect
bond
cleavage
to transform
are not possible
in specific
geometric
and formation
organic
\ubstratea
at monometallic relationships
and stabilize
in a large numba .I4 two OI
complexes; are Krcquently
the resulting
required
ligand
to
iragments.
The bond polarity in mixed-metal clusters which may enhance substrate activation should be maxitnized in progressing to “very mixed”-metal systems. For example. coupling oxophilic and carbophilic metals should facilitate C-heteroatom cleavage heteroatom
linkages,
but this
together in a “very mixed”-metal by formation of strong M-C
is one area that has been
little
exploited.
cluster and MLigand
L
I-
Ph~t
PI, .P
“Very Mixed”-Metal
69
Carbonyl Clusters
hlc
1'
Me
I
(‘
(
PI
transformations ifications
ligands
Transformations of C-H
bond
ters have
ligands
at C-donor
appeared.
arc summarized
ligands
or C-H
Protonation
carbon.
formation utilized into
occurring
nated vinylidene
;I a-alkyl
linkage
Thus ployed
by formal (Fig.
at a single
face,
at a M-M
ultimately
deficiency
but the reverse
at tungsten
24);
insertion unlike
alkyne,
The remaining
of an alkene
by
examples
in this
section,
of C-C
alone
activation
or in concert
and/or
with
C-C
cluster-bound
of C-H
bond
to form
the “action”
formation alkylidyne
(‘H,K c
M’
the reaction
metal.3’
either
7-
the easier. The coordi-
example
into an Ru-H
(‘ H
\:/
but at the
relieved
appears
/13-?/‘-ligated
23).‘5.x6
other
reaction
R
,,,‘-
clus-
bond,
occurred
faces (Fig. 22).“5
by thermolyzing
I ,2-H shift (Fig.
far, all examples alkynes,
protonation
range ofheterotrimetallic
can be formed
occurred
occurred
wider
by ;I formal
formation
occurs
examples
mixed”-metal
(Fig. 2 I ).s’ Otherexamples ofC-H formation have vinylidene can be converted source.XS.Xh Coordinated
at a trimetallic
at a much
proceeding
IV. Several
at “very
clusters
electron
mod-
linkage
Hz as the hydrogen
alkylidyne
in Table
formation
at most
1I.D. I ., while
II.D.2.
are collected
bond
with the consequent
of an $-aryl
in Section
in Section
in [WRePt(/AXZ6HIMe-4)(CO)U(PMe;),] Akylidyne
I’MC, I’\le :
are reviewed
activation
H
I:t,O - s
PMC,
at C-donor
of other
HRF,
PMC;
(1)
,,$ -
-
Iv’-
(ii)
\/
-M”(
have
en-
or CO.
72
WATERMAN
Phenylvinylidene
was
dimerized
et al.
in a head-to-head
[RelNiz(El-r-112-C=CHPh)(~~-CO)(CO)(,(Ii’-CgHs)21. atoms
in
the
wing-tip
positions:“’
CHPh)(CO)6($CgH5)z] tip positions.
dicobalt-dimolybdenum ceeding action
addition
of excess internal proceeded
fly cluster
units. The major ing from
product
insertion
W-h
has the potential
one CpW(CO)? cluster
which
reacted
two cluster-bound age
with
products
Reactions bridging
cluster
excess
acetylenes,
two alkylidyne could
of alkynes
as C-C
ligands with ligands
in the wing-
face of a sulfur-rich
fashion.
the reaction
prorc-
ditungsten-diiridium
formation.
to afford
a butter-
ally1 and alkylidyne
a mono-acetylene
adduct
result-
1I.C.). which could not be converted in core con(Fig. 26). “.” Modification
affect Ir(CO)j
product
selection.
fragment
afforded
of the same acetylene
and ;I butterfly
cluster
and a dimer
not be interconverted
alkylidyne
nickel
bond (Section
an isolohal
with
atoms
with cluster-bound was
with
(Fig. 25).“” In contrast,
at a tetrahedral
as well
to dramatically
unit with
rhenium
molecules
of the same reaction
into a W-W
to the allyI(alkylidyne)-containing position
with
PhCSCPh
thermolyzing
IRe2Ni,(~~~-l/‘-PhC=CCH=
in a had-to-head
cleavage)
on cluster
across a Co?Mo
acetylene
cleavage
from
cluster
also
ofthe
acetylene
by C-C
(resulting
product
was dimerized
cluster,
by stepwise
cluster
the
is a butterfly
Phenylacetylene
manner a butterfly
(Fig.
trinucleul proceeded
to afford
resulting
frorn
of diphenylacetylene:
27).“’ group h-group by
Thus.
coupling
9 clusters the
replacing
an isostructural
a product Ir-lr
with cleav-
again.
these
incorporating
C’-donor
ligands.
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
73
Diphenylacetylene and Shexyne reacted with [MolCo(/l3-CH)(C0),(175-C5Hj)71 to afford chain-lengthened organic ligands with allylic ligation, but whereas the former also gave a product resulting from PhCrCPh cleavage and C-C bond formation, the latter gave a product from coupling the ally1 unit with CO (Fig. 2X).‘* 2-Butyne and Shexyne reacted in a similar fashion at tungsten-dicobalt alkylidyne clusters as at the dimolybdenum-cobalt cluster above; coupling of acetylene. CChHJMe-4, and CO gave a WCo?-supported CJ fragment, although the presence of bridging phosphido led to a side reaction involving P-C formation (Fig. 29).‘” Alkylidyne groups have hecn cleaved, as well as coupled, when a sufficiently reactive substituent is present; reaction of [MCol(lrl-CCOZEt,(C0)x(,75CIHJMe)] (M = MO, W) with IFe(CO)j]‘p/Ht afforded [MCO&Qq’-CCO) (,I-CO)(CO),(~~~-C~H~M~)I by cleavage of the ethoxy group, in addition to
74
the
expected
metal-exchange
[Co~(p?-CCI)(CO)g]
underwent
WATERMAN
et a/
product.
The
C-Cl
[MoCo2(~-13-CH)(CO)x(r15-C5Hs)l. ‘)h Alkyldiazocarboxylates
reacted
with
age and coordination
of the resultant
one CHCOlR
bridges
bridging atom
ligand
a W-Ir
(Fig.
an Ir-lr
This
product
could
chloromethylidyne
bond,
Ii&and
as well as metal exchange
[ W,lr~(CO)l,~(
carbene
bond and the estercarbonyl
30).““~“’
“’
cleavage
units while
q5-CgH5)1] in two distinct the other
coordinating not be obtained
by C-N
clcav-
environments;
caps ;I W?Ir
to the oxophilic by C-C
in
to afford
face by tungsten
cleavage:
both
“Very Mixed”-MetalCarbonyl Clusters
75
reaction of [ W21r2(CO)to( $-CjHj)l] with RO$ZCH=CHCO,R, and attempted hydrogenation of [W71r2(/1J-rl~-Et02CC~COIEt)(CO)xl. were unsuccessful. Solvent dichlorornethane has been activated; reaction with [ M~Q~(/LJ-S)(/L ~-S)?(/L;CO)(I/‘-dmpe)l(,l’-C~H~Me)~l proceeded by C-H and double C-Cl activation to afford the methylidyne-containing cluster 1M~~C~Q(,L;-CH)(p i-S);(112-tlmpe)2(,1iCSHJMe)2]im.3’ The examples above involve the cluster mediating the transformation of organic substrates and stabilizing the resultant residues by coordination. Several clustercoordinated functionalizedcyclopentadienyl groups have also been modified while maintaining their qs-ligation. For example. the cyclopentadienyl substituents in IMoFeCo(E13-S)(CO)~(~~~-CSH1R)l [R = CHO, C(O)Me], [ (MF~C~(/L~-S)(CO)~ (,~T-C~H~)]I(~~-C(0)-4-C~~H~C(O)]~ (M = Mo. W), [MoR~Co(/l-Sc)(CO)~(lljCsH4C(0)Me] 1, and [MFeNi(,L3-S)(CO)S(,15-CiHj)(175-CjH~C(0)R}l (M = Mo. W; R = H. Me) wet-e reduced by N~BHJ to alf‘ord [MoFeCo(,n3-S)(CO)X(l,‘C,H,R’)j [R’ = CH20H. CH(OH)Me]. [ (MFeCo(EI;-S)(CO)x(,l’-CiH1)]l
KO
76
WATERMAN
et al.
(p-CH(OH)-4-C,H.$.IHOH] 1. [ MoRuCo( /I~-SC)(CO)~( II’-CSHJCHMeOH}]. and [ MFeNi(/l;-S)(C0)5(17’-CjH5)( &Y~H&HROH)]. respectively:“‘~“’ the secondary alcohol derivatives [ MFeNi(~~~-S)(CO)5(~~5-CsHs)(r$CsH~CHMeOH)] were then alkylated by Et,OBF, to afford ether derivatives [ MFeNi(~r3-S)(CO)s(qsCsHj)( $-CsHJCH(OEt)Me]j.“’ The ketone functional group in [ MFeNi(/r;S)(CO)~($C~HS)( $‘-CSH~C(O)M~) 1 (M = Mo, W) reacted with 2.4-dinitrophenylhydrazine to afford the expected phcnylhydrazone derivatives [ MFcNi (~~~-S)(C0)s(~‘-C~Hs)~~~~-CjHJC(Me)=NNH-2,4-C~,H(N02,2)].”’
Very few reports concerning transformations of ligands with other donor atoms exist (Table V). P-H activation at secondary phosphines is the most common motif. with the metal-metal bonds at the heterometallic facts stabilizing the resulting fragments in each case (Figs. 3 I, 32. 33).“‘.7”.“7 In the formation of both
PHPh-.
Ph, I’ MC------
P-H d~ation: PHPh: i PPh2 + H P-H activation: PHPhz + PPh2 + H P-H activation: PHR?+PR2+H(R=Et.Ph) P-H activation: PH2Ph - PPh + HI P-C. C-H activation. C-H fotmution: PPhj + PPhC6H4-2 + CoHh Ar-S activation: Ar-S + Ar + S S-R. S-H activation: RSH+ S+KH P-C. C-H formation: PPh2 + H + RC-CR i PPh$(,i\-CR=C‘HR) C-C activation. P-C formation (‘RlcCO i PPh; 4 (‘hlcPPhl + CO
IWCol{p I-C(C~,H~M~-~)CRCRCO](I,CO)(CO),(PPhz(~~i,-CR=CHR)}(~,‘-CjHi )I (R = Ms. Er) [W;R~~(/~~-CM~)(/~-CM~~(/I~CM~PP~~)(~~-CO)~(~~I’Fh2)(COil(ij”-C,I ii);]
Co-Co
bond\/Mo~Co
bond,
MO-CO hondq
Ir; face
Mo(‘o? fact
MO-Pt bond\/.Mo- Pt. Pt-PI bond\
Mo-Co.
Face/Bond/Metal Coordinating Tran\formed Ligand
x2. 102
20
s2
100. IOI
99
52.98
20
97
70
Ref.
78
WATERMAN
et a/
[ MoCol(,l-H)(En7-CC~,H,Mc-4)(~~-PPhl)(CO)(,(,li-C’iH~)17” PR:)$CO)s(
I]-CSHS)I
tion metal was observed double
P-H
More coordinated [ WIr3(CO), tion. (Fig. ,crs..
:i
and
l.,(PPh~),(117-C5Hs)l suggests
coordination (Fig.
36). At higher
rircd
a range
in propylene of propene:
the product
dpp~n)~(CO)j(S)]~ Examples
were
of “very
arc still I-arc. with
at mixed
[ RePt?(/r
fuels.
for
the
At low ternpcriitures.
but OII warming bond (Fig.
CILIS-
acti\,e
the thiophe-
cvcntually
clen\cd
cluster
rlesulf~~-
37). The C-S
;-S)~(lc-dppm):(CO);]
with
bonds
m)lution
’ and [ RePt;(/l-
residues.““.“‘”
cluster-assisted extant
product
conditions
iiiolybdcnum-cob~~lt
and the C-S compounds
in this sec-
the reaction
combination
of liquid at a cobalt.
of heating
I;ICC. The
by [RePt~(/I-dpl~iii)j(CO):It
the sulfide
literature
under
;I metal
organic
mixed”-metal
both
cleaved
on
examplcs
the same molybdenLlm-cobnlt
cleaved
clusters
contained
observed
other
contain
linkage
of sulfLlr-cont3iniil~ sultide
unlike
14).51.0t;
Orthornetallation
was
reported
occurrcd
temperatures,
(Fig.
at the homometallic
hydrodesulfurir.~ition
a heterometallic
Not surprisingly.
cleavage.
cleaugc.
benzene
(x = I-3):‘)‘)
is coordinated
of thiophenoxide
bridged
of
that the M-P bond wa
important
and
(WCO$/l-
at the later tranai-
is also possible
of C-hctcroatom
elimination
residue
of‘phosphine
activation
phosphines
35). C-S cleavage has been 5'-..5s (77 hX.I0I1.101.l0~.11~-1 which
industrially noxide
P-H
at primary
are examples
PPh;
the ligated
distribution
to precede
activation
interesting
Lllld
(R = Et. Ph).‘” coordination
C-hctcroatom
bond formation
exan~plcs
phosphido ligund with ;I C-ligand. Phosphido. bled stercospecilically to afford PPh:((.i.\-CR=CHR)
involving coupling and alkyne hydrido. (Fig. 29),“’
while
of bridging were asscnan unusual
“Very Mixed”-MetalCarbonyl Clusters
79
isomcrization replaced the bridging phosphido at a W-Rh linkage with a bridging carbonyl. affording the PhlP=CMe ligand (Fig. 3X).‘“’ E. Core Transformations The premise of this review is that synthetic procedures for “very mixed”-metal clusters are comparatively well understood, but that reactivity and physical properties are less well studied. Metal core transformations (modifications of a preexisting cluster) fall into both the synthesis and reactivity categories. A summary is presented here, but as they have been reviewed elsewhere (see Refs. 4, lO7-109), the account below is necessarily brief. Section 1I.E.I. considers core transformations where the cluster core nuclearity is preserved. whereas Section II.E.2. summarizes reactions involving a change in core sire. I Mettrl t::rchrru,Ly Efficient routes into “very mixed”-metal clusters by metal exchange reactions have been developed, principally by Vahrenkamp and co-workers. Metal exchange
80
WATERMAN
et al.
“Very Mixed”-Metal reactions
are those
replaced same
in which
by a different
total
number
of metal
bc expected
to be quite
with
occurring
others
systematic
or more group
atoms.
complex,
of a cluster
exchange
proceed
reactions
reactions
units.’ Specific
the heterometal
vertices
are
containing
by one-step
and substitution
oforganometallic
to introduce
groups
a new cluster
metal
reactions
addition
and incorporation
have been utilized
metal-ligand to afford
Although
many
by multistep
addition
reagents
one
metal-ligand
81
Carbonyl Clusters
the could
processes, involving classes ot
by metal exchange
reactions: A. Metal R. Metal
carbonyl anionskyclopentadienylmetal carbonyls/cyclopentadienylmetal
carbonyl anions carbonyls/nickclocene/
IPt(r72-C2H~)(PPh2)21 C. Cyclopentadienylmctal
carbonyl
arsenides
D. Cyclopentadienylmetal
carbonyl
hydrides/chlorides
Lund Table of reagents routes The
a classification
by each reaction
have been by far the most popular:
are considerably
the group utilired
VI contains
6 metals.
trinuclear
more
limited
The arsenide clusters
in the “very
in scope,
with
exchange
and hydride/chloride
examples
route has been defined
[CO~(/L~-CR)(CO),~]
mixed”-metal
type. The first two classes
the arsenide
thus far confined
mechanistically
arc the most reactions
common
reported
to 39).
precursors
thus far (Fig. 40),
s
M = MO. M
-(‘(I
(Fig.
(‘0
82
83
$
(M = Mo. W)
(M =Cr.
[MRuCo(~~-S)(CO)x(,~i-CiHj)l
l-S)(CO)x(,li-C.cH,Mr)]
(K = MC. t’h~
(R = Me. H. Cl)
[MCo3(~-CO)~(CO)s(ll’-C.iHi)l (M = MO. W) [CrWPd2(/1:-CO)~(,l-CO),(PPh~)~(,I”-CjHs)2]
[MoRuCo(,l?-,l’-RC?H)(CO)x(,l’CSHi)l
[MoFcCo(/l
[MoCo2(,1?-CR)(C0)8(115-CiHi)]
IMCo2(,r1~CR)(CO)x(,li-CsHs)] (M =Cr. Mo. W. R = H. Me, Ph: M = MO. W. R = Cf,H~Me-I)
MO. W)
(M. M ’ = Mu. W)
IMFeCo(~ri-S)(CO)x(,I’-CiH?)I
(M = Mo. R = ?rlr. Ph.
[MoFeCo(E13-PPh)(CO)x(ri’-CiHi)l IMM’Fc(/l?-S)(C0),(,)‘-C5H;)j
[MoCo2(,li-PPh)(~-AsMe?)(CO)(,oI
IMCo2(,(~-C;eR)(CO)s(,li-CiHF)] Bu’: M = W. R = Bu’)
[MCo2(,li-CR)(CO)x(,~“-CiHj)l (M = Mo. R = CO?menthyl. H: M = W. R = H)
[Mo2C02(,1-CO)?tC0),(,~~-C~H~)~l [Mo,Ni?(lrJ-A~)(/13-As)(CO),(,~~-Cir~~)~,l
[MoC”~(~-C0)3(CO)x(,l’-CjHi)l
IMoNi2(,li-CCO?Pr’)(CO)~(,li-CiH?);I
Ml.,,
[WH(CO)I
(IZ/loCI(CO);(rii-CjHi)l
[CO,(CO)I~I. [MH(CO):(,jk’iHi)] IC~~Pdl(/l:-C0)2t/1-CO),(PPh;)~(,,”-CiHi)II. (qkiH>)] [Rr;Pt(/(-H):(CO),~I-.
tR = Mc).
(R = Me. H. Cl) [MoCI(CO):(,li-CjH,Mr)l
(KuCO~(/I I-,~‘-RC~H)ICO)<,I.
(hloH(CO):(ri’-(.iHi)l IFe2Co(/r-H)(//;-S)((‘0)91.
IMoCI(CO);(,l’~C~H~)]
VI (Corlrimret/)
I(‘oi(lr~-CR)(CO)vl:
TABLE
I)
D
0
I)
D
I)
FIG. 10. S)n~hrws UT ~111\4licl)ne-cnpped CIUIICI~ hq mtal exchange: (i) IMoX(C.C)):(,,i-C.~Hi)l. X = H. Cl: R = Me. (Ii) IM(CO);(r~5-C~Hs)jm. BPK M =Cr. Mo. W: R=H. Me. (iii) [M(A\M~~)(CO);(,I’-CH~)~. M =c’r. MO. W: R=H. IMC. Ph. C~HJM~-I. (iv) IppnllM(CO)l(rii-CiH5)1: R=CI (v) [M(CO)3(~~‘-C~H~)jm Nat. K+: M=Cr. Mo. W: R=CI. (vi) [M’(CO)?(,li-CiHi)]: ICI =Mo: M ’=Mo. W. (iii) [M(CO)I(II~-C;H~)]~: M= MO. W CiH,R’)/-: M = Mu. \V. R’ = C(O)H. C(O)Mc. C02Et. R = Ph. M = Mu. \V. R’ = H. R = H. Mr. Ph. M = MO. R’ = H I<-Sil;tj. II. (Lilii [bl(CO);i,/iR = C02menth~l: M = MO. W. K’ = C’02lzt. K = Me: M = Mo. W: R’ = Mr. R = Ph. CO?Et. (ix) [Fr(C0)~1’~/ Hi: R’ = C(O)H. C(O)Me. COzEt: R = Ph M = Mo, M ’ = Fe: R’ = H. R = CO? menthyl: M = MO. M ’ = Fe. R’ = Me. R = C@Et: M = MO. W. M ’ = Fe. (x1 [M’(CO),J’-/H+: R = II. Me. Ph: M = Mo W: M ’ = Ru. OS: M. M ’ = Mo. W. R = Ph. CO2Et: K’ = Me. (xi) [M(CO)~(qi-L)12: M = W. L = CiHj. K = Me: M = Mo. 1. = C‘H,Pr’. CsHi. CqH7. R = CO: menthyl: M =Mo. L= C+I<. CiH4Me. C5hlr5. R= Pr’. (xi~) [Ni(Co)(,~~-CiHi)l-): M = MO. L= $CyHi: R = Pr’. Mr. (xiii) INi(qi-CiHs)~l: M = Mo L = ,/“-CiHi: R = Pr’.
86
WATERMAN et a/
as the Co(CO)j unit is the most readily displaced group in metal exchange reactions. 16.17.28.30.5~~.110.112.1Ih.117.13-1 Early studies in this area have been reviewed;’ more recently, extensions to the metal exchange procedure have been explored using different /L~-CR groups. and varying coligands on the metal exchange reagents. Forcxample. the reactions between ICo3(~n3-CR)(CO),,I (R = SiEt,. H. Cl. Br) and [M(CO)~(I&H~)\~ (M = MO. W) afforded [ MCol(/l.;-CR)(CO)x(,IS-CjH)]. the reactivity of the /I-CR apical substituent resulting in low yields ofthc products.’ Ii The reactions of [C(~~(/II-CPh)(C0)9] and [ M(CO)7( qi-C5HIR)]- [M = MO, W: R = C(O)H. C(O)Me. COlEt] afforded [MCol(,lj-CR)(CO)H(~li-C5H~R)I; incorporation of an electron-withdrawing group on the cyclopentadienyl ligand reduced the activity of the exchange reagent.“’ “I An alternative route to IMCol(/t I-CR)(CO)~( rli-C5Hi)] (M = Cr. MO. W; R = H. Me, Ph) involving clectron transfer catalysis has been demonstrated.’ “I Reaction of [C~~(E~~-CR)(CO)~I.the metal exchange reagent. and a catalytic amount ol‘sodium diphenylketyl under varying conditions afforded the desired clusters in good yield. This reaction procecdcd rapidly at room temperature, in contrast to the classical metal exchange reaction which required heatin f in benzene for 3 days.‘“.“’ Many examples of sequential metal exchange at face-capped trinuclear clusters have been reported. Two successive metal exchange reactions cm afford tetrahedral clusters which are chiral by virtue 01‘havine(Tfour different core coiistituents (Fig, 40). Metal exchange can proceed by ;I further step: the cluster [MoNil(Cli-CPr’)(CO)~(Ij-CiHj),ISh is an example ol‘metal exchange in which all three CO(CO)J units ofthe prccursorclustcr have been replaced with other moieties. While the apical substituent in these clustera has usually been an alkylidync group. other face cappin g ligands have also been successfully employed. Foi example, the clusters IMFeCo(lr:-X)(CO)x(ll’-C.iH5)I (M = MO. W; X = S. SC. PNEtl),lY 12’) IMoFeCo(/li-S)(CO)x(,15-CiH~R)I [R = C(O)H.C(O)Me.COz Et].“’ I{ MFeCo(br ?-S)(CO)x(,lS-CiH,))l IMoRuC~(E~~-S)(CO)~(I]-C~H~)I,‘~” and (IL-R)] [M = Mo. W; R = ~-CH$Z~,HJCH~. ~-C(O)C~,HJC(O)I”’ were formed by metal exchange reactions with [M’Co2(/1;-X)(CO)UI (M’ = Fe, Ku). itself prepared by metal exchange from the precursor cluster ICO~(~L:-X)(CO)~)] (Fig. 1-l ). The metal exchange products [ MFeCo(El?-S)(CO)x(,I5-C5HJR)I (M = Mo. W: R = CHO, OMc. CO?Me) reacted with nickclocene in rctluxing THF to afford IMFeNi(El:-S)(CO)i(,I’-C~H5)(r7’-CsH~R)J.’” IFe,Co(lr-H)(lli-S)(CO)uJ. prcpared from [ FeCo~(/li-S)(CO)sl. reacted with IM~CI(CO)I(II”-C~HJM~)~ to afford [MoFeCo(~~-S)(CO)x(,15-C5H~Me)] and IM~~F~(/~~-S)(CO)~OI”-C~H~M~)~I.’” Similarly.reaction between [R~CO,(/~~-S)(CO)~~]and Nal[(CO)jM{ I/‘-CTHJC(O)4-Cc,HJC(0)-II’-CjHJ}M(CO)jl (M = Mo, W) has afforded the clusters IMRuCo (/li-S)(CO)x{ ~~s-C~H~C(Oj-4-C~H,C(O)-)15-C~H~}MRuCo(~~i-S)(CO)x] in which the exchange reagent links two cluster cores (Fig. 42).‘“.“’ and [MRuCo(y,S)(CO)&$CiHJR)] IM = Mo, W; R = C(O)H. C(O)Mc, C(O)Ph. 4-C(0)C,HJ
FIG. 41. Sqnthtws ot‘ cluer\ I\ 1~11other face-cappill g Iigrrntl~ bp meral rxchan;e: (I) [W(CO)~(J~~-C~H~)]~. M = Se. PRu’. PPh. PNEt2. PSEt. (iii) [MoCI(C0)3(,1’-CiH,Me)l. X = S. Ci;,) [Fe(C0)~1’-. H-. (VI IM’(AsMe)(CO)i(ll’-CiHj)l. W. M = Ku. X = S: [M’(CO)i(,l’-CiHi)]~. M = I+. M ’ = MO. W. X = S. Se. PNEt2. (\i) IM’(AsMe2)(CO)?(,,‘-CjHj,l. hl’ = MO. W: [M’IA\M~~)(C.O);(,~~C~~~~~~. M ’ = Cr. MO. W. M = Ku. X = S. (viii) IM’I<.~);(,,~-C~H~)]~.M’ = Ma W. (ix) W. K = C(O)H. C(O)Me. (‘O:Et. U&Mc. M = Fr. X = S. (x1 IM”(C0)7(,li-CiH,R’)I~ M ” = Mo. W. R’ = H. C(O)Me. M = MO. w.
Ku. X = PPh. Iii) hl = Fe. X = S M = Fe. X = S. M ’= Cr. MO X = S. (vi?) LM’(CO)dqi-C~Hs)J2 [M’(CO)~(I,‘-C~HJR)] : M = Mo CO?Me. Me, R = CO?Et. C02Me
88
WATERMAN
et a/
s
Ku- \!/
c-0 I
0
CO
,' (‘
+
M
0
l'-
(‘ M
C02Mc] were obtained by metal exchange from the same ruthenium-dicobalt precut-sol and analogous functionalized (cyclopentadienyl)metal carbonyl anions. “x” Related reactions of the selenido-containing cluster IRuCO~(/L 3-Se) (CO)u] with the functionalized (cyclopentadienyl)molybdenum carbonyl anion reagents afforded the analogous [MoRuCo(,l-Se)(CO)x(~~~-C5HIK)I. and with the linked dianionic dimolybdenum reagent afforded [ MoRuCo(/l j-Se)(CO)x( ,j5C~H~C(O)-~-C~H,C(O)-)~‘-C~H~}MOKUC~(/~~~ A capping arsenic atom has been employed; one or two Mo(CO)$ q5-CjH.i) vertices in the trimolybdcnum precursor IMo(~~-As)(CO)(,(,I’-C~H~)~~ were replaced (Fig. 43).“‘.“” The flexibility of this procedure has been further demonstrated utilizing clusters with capping germylidyne groups (Fig. 44).“’ Metal exchange methods have also been utilized with alkyne-bridged clusters. For example. LRuC~~(~~~-)~~-RC~R’)(CO)cI] was the precursor to 1MoRuCo(k~ 3-~~‘RC2R’)(CO)x(~$CjH5)] (R, R’ = Ph, Me), [ MoRuNi(,li-11’-MeC2Me)(CO)i(rliCjH5)2], and (MoRuRh(jl-q’-MeCZMc)(CO)s( q5-CiHg)) (Fig. 35). “’ Although metal exchange procedures to afford “very mixed”-metal clusters have been utilized most frequently with trinuclear clusters, reactions involving tetrunuclear clusters have also been successful. The reaction of [ COJ(/L-CO)JCO)~,] with [MH(CO)~(&$H~)j (M = Mo, W) afforded the tetrahedral cluster [ MCoJlcCO)i(CO)x(q5-C5Hs)].13”A similarreaction between [ CO~(~L-CO)~(CO)(,(II~-I .3,% CbH3Mej)] and IMo(C0)3(,15-CiHi)]l likewise afforded [MCo;(/XO);(CO)x
“Very Mixed”-MetalCarbonyl Clusters
89
, ICO((‘O),(I~‘-C~H~)I
\
(t15-CiHj)], togetherwith [MolCol(~l-C0)3(CO)7(115-CsH5)11 (Fig. 46).‘;‘Thc butterflycluster ICr2PdZ(,I;-C0)7(/L-CO)~(PPh~)~(~~~-C.iH~)~l reacted with [ WH(C0); (qS-CiH~)] to afford [CrWPd2(/1;-C0)7(/1-CO)J(PPhl),(,15-CiHj)~l (Fig. 47).“” The “spiked” triangular cluster [ Re3Pt(y-H);(CO)IJ] reacted with ;1range of metal carbonyl anions ([HRe~(CO)~~j-, (Mn(C0)5]m, [ W(CO)j(r75-C~H5)]p. ICO(CO)J] ) and metal carbonyl hydrides (IReH(CO)a(PPh3)I. [ReH(CO)j(PPh\)z]) to afford
WATERMAN
90
“spiked” triangular cluster products. Metal tnixcd”-metal clusters may also be possible.
et al.
exchang ’ at higher nuclearity but has yet to be exploited.
“very
Reactions ofclusters with tnonortucltm ordinuclear metal complexes frequently provide ;I method of expanding the metal core nuclearity under controlled conditions. The majority been prepared frotn it-and-hope”)
of mediumand high-nuclearity homotnetallic clusters has lower-nuclearity cluster precursors by thertnolyses (‘.heat-
reactions.
This
is less true
of the heteromctallic
clusters
in this
“Very Mixed”-Metal
section.
with
trolled
means
three
synthetic
of obtaining
tion by a tnetal complex complex
(“redox
of flexible
nucleophile
condensation”),
ligands.
high-nuclearity
and
cluster
VII collccls
“very
of pre-existing
cursor
cluster:
Sulfido angular
on a cluster,
or a cluster
nucleophile
on a metal
clusters
stepwise
synthesized (M =Co,
linkage)
the lighter the
cluster
heavier
core,
SBu’)( If-cod)(q5-CiH5)2] Heating
rather
yieldin
usual
transfer
r$cyclopentadienyl
dependent
to afford
substitution
on the prc-
ICO,(/I~,
g the crystallographically with cluster
a spiked
by
characterized
butterfly
expansion.
I~‘:I/~‘-
reacted coordination
Photolysis
of the tri-
or [Cr2Rh(/li-S)1(/1-
of (Fel(p-S)I(CO)&
afforded
the clusters
(M = Co, R = MC; M = Rh. R = H)
the tetrahedral
some metal-metal
the “bow-tie”cluster
or contraction
[Rh~(/AJ0)3(CO)I,]
[Cr$Zo(~3-S)2(~-SBu’)(CO)~(q5-C afforded
alower nuclearitycluster a butterfly coordination
Table
[Cr(C0)3(qh-PhCzPh)]
products
cluster
in the presence
than the expected
tnaintain
and
successful.
by expansion
fragmented
[CrlFe~M(/13-S)1(/1-SBu’)(C0)(,(,7’-C5HIR)21 (Fig. 49).‘57
:I variety
of tnetliutn-
highly
[Cr$Yo(/~~-S)2(/1-SBu’)(C0)2(q5-C~H~Me)2]
diphenylacetylene
employing
assetnbiy
Rh) with
afforded
cluster
tI~:‘16-PhC2Ph)(,l-CO)~(CO)ll,l. (Fi g 48). ‘55 bridging ligands can facilitate clusters
procedures
and stars have all proved
acetylene
PhC2Ph)(CO)&Yr(CO)j], [CrRhJlrs, geometry
a coilsubstitu-
complexes.
whereas
of the
to afford
Nucleophilic
of [MJ(/I-CO)~(CO)~,I
has a pendant
extensively
nuclearity.
systematic
mixed”-metal
(which
etnployed
of different bridge-assisted
Stone’s chains
cluster
The reaction
expansion
procedures clusters
91
Carbonyl Clusters
jHs)2]
cluster
in the presence
JCr$Zo(/~3-S)JCO)(
of
r~~-CjH~)j].
product.‘“’
connectivity
Sulfide bridging lipand< can also upon cluster fragmentation. Reaction of
ICt-~Ni(/l3-S)I(/I-SBu’)~(t~~-C~Hs~~]
and [Co2(CO)t;]
afforded
[Cr2Col(~~-S)(~I-S)7(CO)~(r7’-CSHj)(175-C~H~BLt’)] geometry: this cotnplex reaction also involves
of a tertiary
butyl
group
ligands
(Fig.
50).‘J’
frotn
the IL-SBu’
ligand
to one
with an unof the
OE sti
ttl
cl-1
ftl
C f
3
93
94
P
II r
95
96
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
97 Ph c (‘0
‘/ CO
. Rh
Expansion electrophiles L = CiH5;“” M=Pt, (Fig.
of the capped has
octahedral the
[ R~~(/Q-C)(CO)~I]‘~
clusters
M = Pd, L = q3- I -phenylallyl;
L=Me?‘“’ 5 I ).
afforded ). with
I .4-bicapped
with
lRe7M(~I~,-C)(C0)2,(L)1’-
platinum
group (M = Pd.
‘Q M = Pt. L = I$ I -methylallyl:‘“’ octahedral
coordination
geometries
98
WATERMAN
A number
of mononuclear
and binuclear
in the formation
and expansion
the coordinatively
unsaturated
(M = Re, Mn) ally
short
(Fig.
afforded
52).“’
The
co)dco)~),,I’-~
forded
Re-Pt (11
utilized.
bond
reaction
[ Re~Pt(C0)1,]‘~.
with
metry,‘5’
whereas
(CO),
with a butterfly
:I7
reaction
[Rc3Pt(/l-H)(,(CO)I(l,
with reaction
or metal
carbonyl
anions
sion
the
of
metal
[RezPt(/l-H)1(CO)x(M’}I W(C0)3(~&C5Hi), cursors
core
the
butterfly
(Fig. S3).”
a bow-tie
core
afforded
[RejPt(/l-H)
displacement affkcling
[(M’) CO(CO)~J
can also be successfully
= Mn(CO)5. (Fig.
SS).7’.73
employed;
it reacted
the structurally (Fig.
Re(CO)4(PPh3), High oxidation
with
with
characterkd
S4).7’ In a related
of the rl’-cod the spiked
reaction
gco-
[Re,Pt(/r-H)1(CO)x(,I.r-cod)]
core geometry
nuclearity.
[(Pt3(/~-
complexes af[ Re(COI,]
(“swallow”)
of [RelPt(ln-H)7(CO)x(r~‘-~~~l)l caused
example
clusters
and [ Re7(/1-H)z(CO)s];
of H2 to al’ford
‘. unusLl-
rhenium
with
[RQ(/L-H)(H)$CO)~J
of [Pt( I~‘-uK!)~\
of
[M(CO)i]
of the rhenium
of I( Ptl(,r-CO)~(CO)I),,J’-
in the presence
ries of reactions,
for
the nnturc
an edge-bridged
Reaction
with
the columnar
I‘rom
on
core geometry
by reaction
[ RQ(/L-H)$CO)~]
fhrmed
with
have been utilized clusters.
[MPtj(/c-dppm)l(CO)il
bein, (7 noted
c IO) are dependent
For example,
was prepared
clusters
distances
clusters
complexes
platinum-rhenium
[ Pti(,lI-CO)(/1-dppm)31’t
the tetrahedral
metal-metal
rhenium
of mixed cluster
et a/
metal
\e-
hydrides
ligand and expantriangular clusters Rc(CO);(PPh;)2. state rhenium pre-
of [ Pt3(~c-CO);(PCy;)-,I
with
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
1"
Pt
’ [Re,(~-H)2((‘O)xI w
H
100
WATERMAN
ef al
. structurally characterized IRelO,] gave [ RePt~(/l-O)l(/l-OH)(CO)~(PCy-,)~]i with the unusual bi-butterfly cot-e geometry shown in Fig. SO.‘sx The rectangular cluster IP~J(,I-OA~)~(,~-CO)-~I~ ’ has acetate groups which are readily displaced; reaction with ( Mo(CO)-l(~&CgHi)]mm afforded IMoiPd4(,c {CO)I(/I-CO)~(,I’-C~H~)J~‘~ with a tetra-edge-bridged quart: core geometry. and the palladium atoms in the unusual + I /? oxidation state.‘“‘.‘“” whercas reaction with [Mn(CN)(CO)I(~IS-CSH~M~)l-~ gave [Mn~Pd~(~l-NC)I(CO),7(lj5-CgH-I Me)J].“” which consists of two MnlPd? chains linked together by bridging CNtnoietics (Fig. 57). The V-shaped cluster IWPdl(/l~-CO)(/I-CO),(/r-OH)(Ph)~ (PPh3)$ q5-C5Hg)] reacted with [ WH(CO);( &CTH~) 1to afford the butterfly cluster [ W,Pd2(/~3-C0)2(~-CO)J(PPh3)l( ,$CiH5)l].“” The closely related clusters [ MzPdl( /l>-CO)I(/I-CO)J( PRJ)z( I15-C.iH,)21 (M = Cr. MO, W: R = Pr’. Et) wwc
i
“Very Mixed”-Metal
formed
by
nucleophilic
[ MPd,(/13-CO)(/K
displacement
metal
have
been
clusters.
forded
in the introduction seldom
Heating
(I % ) yield.“” suitable
allhrded
by
[ M(CO)j(
On
employed
to this section, to afford
higher
q’-C~H~)l
purely
therrnolytic
nuclearity
“very
[ W21r2(CO)lo(175-C5HS)21
the heptanuclear
(R = H, Me) provide with
of chloride
101 at
I)(I-~-CO)~(PR~)~(II~-C~H~)].~”
As was mentioned cedures
Carbonyl Clusters
cluster
m refluxing [W;lr~(/l-H)(C0),2(17S_CjH5)11
thermolysis. a source
organometallic
the
clusters
promixed”-
tetrahydrofuran in a very
al‘pool
[ M~~(,~~-As)(CO)(,(II~-C~H~R)~~
of MoAa(
$C5H4R)
reagents:
thus.
fragments
reaction
with
which
can combine
[Co(C0)2(q’-CiHj)l
[ MOCO~(/~~-AS)(/~~-CO)~(~~‘-C~H~)~(IJ’-C~H~R)],’~~
whereas
reaction
with[Rh(C0)~(~~5-C~HS)](R=H)~~~vc[MoRh,(/~l-As)(~c;-CO),(CO)(~~i-C~H~)~I (Fig.
58).“5
In
contrast.
photolysis
of
[ Moi(,ll-A~)(CO)(,(,~‘-CjHs);I
in
the
102
WATERMAN
et al.
presence ol‘INi(CO)(lj’-CjHj)]? afforded the metal exchange product IMoNi$/L {As)(CO)~(I&C~H~)~] together with [MolNil(,l~-As)(El;-As)(C0)7(,lj-CsHi)(,1. shown crystalloeraphically to consist of Moj and MoNi2 triangles linked by ;I /c4-As bridge.‘ZX The triangular cluster [Nij(/l;-CO),(rli-C,Hs);] reacted with [ Mo(C0)$q5-CsH5)]2 by core expansion rather than metal exchange. affording the pat-magnetic [ MoNi;(Eci-CO);(,I’-CsH~)~] (Fig. 59): structural characterization 01‘ the analoguc [MONi~(EL;-CO);OJ’-C~HS)3(I,‘-CiHIM~)] (prepared by an alternntive route from dinuclear precursors) contirmed the tctruhedral core geometry.“‘” Rraunstein and co-workers ha\,e demonstrated the utility of carbonylmetalate anions and dppni-stabilized triangular Inixcd-metal clusters as precursors to clustcrs wilh spiked triangular core geometries. with the products retaining the facecapping and bridging ligands of the mixed-metal precursor (Fig. 60).55~142~‘1i The exocyclic metal-metal bonds can be cleaved in some imtances. carbon I~OIIOV clusters by loss of the ligated ide and halide reacting with the -‘spiked” triangular with one ecluivalcnt metal spike. ‘Q Reaction of[ Mo,Pt(CO)(,(NCPh),(IJS-C5Hj)7]. ofdppe proceeded with cluster core expmsion to afford the spiked triangular clustcl IMo2Pt,(CO)(,(dppc)(115-CjHj)ll, with the bidentatc Iigmnd chelating at ;I platinum
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
103
atom.“’ Similarly, the palladium-containing analogues [M,Pd(CO)(,(NCPh)2(IjSC5H5)2] (M =Cr, MO. W) reacted with phosphines to give the isostructural [ M2Pd2(CO)6(PR3)~(q5-C~H5)~].” In contrast, the platinum-containing chain complexes [ M2Pt(C0)6(NCPh)$ $-C5HJR)z] (M = Mo, W; R = H, Me) reacted with phosphines to afford the butterfly clusters IM2Pt3(~~I-CO)(y-CO)J(L)2(,ISC-;HIR)2] [L = phosphines. PhlPCHIPPh~Mn(CO),(rI’-C5HJMe)].~~..i’ As can be seen in Fig. 40. a significant number of mixed-metal clusters have been derived from the triangular cluster [Co3(~.(I-CR)(CO)~,]. Whereas further treatment with molybdenum, tungsten. or nickel complexes us~lally induces additional metal exchange, treatment of [MoCO,(~“~-CCO~P~‘)(CO)~(,~‘-C~H~)I, [ MoNiz(/iICCO,Pr’)(CO)~(lj’-CgH5)3]. or lMoCo,(lr~-CCOIPr’)(,r-CO)(CO)I(lli-C~H~)~] with [Fe?(p-CO)I(CO)(,] resulted in cluster expansion forming [ MoFcCo~(lr~and CCOzPr’)(CO)I IO~~-C~H~)]. IMoFeNil(/13-CC01Pr1)(CO)j(II-~-CSHS)i], respectively. with butterfly coordinaIMoFeCo2(/li-CC02Pr’)(C0)5(q5-CsH5)j]. tion geometries (Fig. 6 I).‘” Similarly, photolysis of [MRLICo(Il~-)I~-MeC2Me) (C’O)x($CjHj)] (M = Mo) in the presence of [Fe$/KO)JCO)(,] afforded [ MoFeRuCo(/l~-,7’-MeC2Me)(CO),0(115-C5H,i)]. and both the molybdenum and tLln:rsten-containing clusters reacted with [ Rh(CO)$ &YiH5)] to lip-m
104
WATERMAN
et a/
[ MRuCoRh(~13-r71-MeC1Me)(CO),(,~i-C5HS)II sitnilar
fashion.
metal exchange
CM~)(CO)~(I$C~H~)] products
with
(M = MO, W) [Ru(C0)~j’~
(M = Mo. W) afforded
S. PR, CR;
R = MC. Ph, Bu’;
AsMe~)(C0)7(r&C5H5)~l reacted
with
(M.
CO under
slightly
of ;I Co-As
unit
tetranuclear
intertnediates
metal-tnetal
bonds using
formation
and eleven
metal
work
has been
the preparation
elevated
and
preasurcs
with
trinuclear
tetranuclear
clusters
[MM’M”C~(EI-S)(/Icore
products;
(7 to addition
corrcspondin, have reported R = Me,
fragmentation at normal
and
pressure.
of CO and rupture
under
has been
of I MoWzPtz(/l
CO)~(,(-PPh2)2(C0)2(II~-CsHs)il
conditions.
of two
of group
This
briefly
work
here.
h-group
(M’ = MO. has been
Figure
re-
63 reveals
of three. four, five. six. seven. nine. ~I.1S,-lh.I~‘I. 151)IS’,ISh IhI).I(,S atld this
to embrace of the Rug
to include
4)(/1-CC~,H1Me-4)(/1-CO)~(C0)5( examples. with the preparation
only
complexes mild
extended
a source
expanded
expansion [LM’(CO)$XYR)J
Ph. C(,HJMe-4).
bc summarized
of chain
aloms
the systematic
(M = Ni. PO and
and will
the logical
[ Ru(CO)~(I~%‘~H~)],
all combinations)
to afford
I/‘-CiMq:
elsewhere’
methodology
the core-expanded
The
(M = MO, W: M’ = Fe. Ru, Co; E =
nol
[M(q’-cod)?]
L = q5-CsHj.
viewed
In a
are observed.“’
Stone and co-workers IO clusters
62~.‘“~
at [MCO&L;-
M’ = MO. W; M” = Fc, Ru: not all combinations)
elimination
W:
as by-products
[M~Co~(~~~-~~2-M~C~Me)(CO)XoJS‘CjHj)7].”’
[MM’Co2(/n3-E)(~~-AsMe~)(CO)x(t$C5H~))
(Fig.
and [OS(CO)J]‘~
other
metal-tigand
i‘l.agnicnt).J”
merallacarborane
1-,17-7.9-Me2-7.C)-C1B
systems
More
clusler
recently,
compounds
toHx- I2-OC)(/1
(c.g. this with
q-CChH~Mc-
I$C~H~)~] (Fig. &I).“” and tunfst”i-t-hodiutn of [WIRh,(/lj-CMe)(/l-CMc){/(-C(Me)C(0)}(/Ifrom
[W7Rh2(/1-CMe)lIr-C(Me)C(O))(/1-C0)
(~~-PPh~)I(CO)I(~~‘-CjH~)~l.X2-‘0’ Attempts toextcnd the lengths ofchains beyond seven metal atoms resulted in chain cyctization to form macrocyclic “s(ar” clusters in instances where the heptametallic precursor has terminal gr(jLtps (Fig, (~~),‘“‘~‘““-‘“‘~‘“5 but the chains can be successfully heptametaltic intermediate attributed to differing chain
has terminal conformations.
[ Pt(q’-cod)]
groups
tungsten carbyne extended if the (Fig.
63).
;I result
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
105
1;~;. 63. Formation of chain clu\ter\: (i) [Pt(qkJ)~]; M = Ni. Pt: M’ = Mo. W: R = Mc. Ph. (‘(,H4Mc-4: 1. = ,&C5Hs. q5-CsMq. (ii) [ W(=CR)(CO)2(L)]: M = Ni. Pt: M’ = MO, W: R =Cc,H4Me1. Mc: L = q’-C~H~. ,,‘-C>Mey: not all combination\. (iii) [Pt(q’-cod):l: M = Ni. Pt. M’= Mo. W: K=Mr ld=~li-C~Mc~. (iv) 2-3.S[Pt(,~1-cocl)~J: M=Ni. Pt: M’=Mo. W: R=Cc,11,M+4, Me: l.= q5-C~Hi. I/‘-CiMq. (v) [W(=CR)(CYX2(L)I. 3 atm CIH4: M = Ni. Pt: M’= MO, W: K = C6H4Mc4. Mc: L = rl-C?Hc q5-C5Mc~: not all combination?. (vi) [NI(I~~-c~~)~]: M = Ni. Pt: M’= W: R = Me, 1. = ~,~-CiMei. (cli) [We], 3 atm C~HJ: M = Pt: M’ = W: R = Mc: L = ,/‘-CiHi. rli-C<Mci. (viii) I .S[Pt(1,‘-cotl)21: M = Pt: M’ = MO: R = Cc,H4Me-1, Mc: L = qi-C5Hi. ,J~-C~M~;. (1ri)21W(~Me)(CO)(,1’-CiHi)l: M’= MO. M”= W:L=,~~-C~Hi.(1)~.~IPt(,~~-cod)~1,ji~tlllC~H,.
106
WATERMAN
et al.
RI ” (‘R /\
(a 1
(hi
(a) M = Mo. K = Cc,HJMe-4: M = W. R = Ph. ~bt M = Pt. M’ = Si. XI” = FIG. 05. “St~“clu\ter\: W. R = Cc,H4Me-4. Ph: M = Ni, M’ = PI. M” = W. R =Cc,H,Me-4. PI>: M = NI. M’ = Pt. M” = Mo. R = Cc,H,Me-J.
F. Catalytic Research
Studies into
utilitarian
cluster
potential.
ular interest
as many
and late transition Attempts while ‘oeneral 2 reviews
has been driven
involving
established metals
to model precursors
to be comprehensive
transformations clusters
are discussed
clusters
catalyzed
processes
and petroleum
arc summarized
while
the tabulated below
focuses
and
is of particcouple
mid
reforming).
in Section respectively.
has been summarized
the discussion
interest
1I.F. I .,
and heterogeneous
11.F.2. and II.F.3.,
catalysis
and R~s&‘“‘.‘“~
intrinsic
as homogeneous
in Sections
cluster
in scope,
by both
mixed”-metal
hydrodesulfurization
mixed”-metal
area of mixed-metal by Braunstein
“very
heterogeneously
(e.g.,
catalytic
the use of “very
catalysis
catalysis
Catalysis
results
The
in excellent are intended
on the more
recent
results.
Reactivity studies of organic ligands with mixed-metal clusters have been utilized in an attempt to shed light on the fundamental steps that occur in heterogeneous chemistry
catalysis
(Table
and surface-adsorbate
VIII).
although interactions
the correspondence is often
poor.‘6”
between While
cluster
some ofthesc
studies have been mentioned in Section II.D., it is useful to revisit them in the context of the catalytic process for which they are models. Shapley and cc-workers have examined the solution chemistry of tungsten-iridium clusters in an effort to understand
hydrogenolysis
of butane.
The reaction
of excess diphenylacctylene
with
Ke-1’1
W-11
Mu-Co
Metal\
IR~Pt~(l.r-dppm)i((‘O);]IRePti(~-dpprn)?(CO);]\ullide
IW?lr2(CO),,,(rl’-(.,Hi)~/
+ propylene wttide i- cxce\\ propytcnc
+ PhC=CPh
[Mo2Co~(/l?-S),(SPh)z(,i’-CiH1Et)~] + HZ + CO IWhXCO), ,(&‘iHi)] + PhC=CPh
[Mo?C~~(/~,~S)(/~I-S)~(CO)~(,~~-C~H,M~)~] + KSH (R = Bu’. MqCHCH2CH2. Ph) IM~~CO~(,~,-S)(,~;-S)~(CO),(,,~-C~H~~~~)~~ + his-2.3-dirnethylthiil-ant IMo?COZ(/I,-S)(~~-S)~(CO),O~~-C~H,M~)~I + diphenytthictane (c,is or r~zu~.~) IM~~C~~(/~~-S)(/~:-S)~(CO),(,I’-C~H~M~)~] + SCNBu’ IMo~CO~(~&~)(~L ~-S)~(CO),(,li-CjHIMe)21 + thiophenc\ lMo:Co$/1 ;-S)~I<.~)~(,,~~C~II,E~)~~ + PhSSPh [MoIC~~(I-I;-S),(CO)?O~~-C~H,E~)~~ + PhSH IMo?(‘o?(~d I~S),(CO)~(I,‘-CiH,Et)?l + PhSH + CO
Precurror (‘lu\ter
IM02C01(/1;-S),(SPh)2(~li-C~H,Et)21 IMo2Co~(/l~-S)~(SPh)2(l,‘~CjH,Et)~]. PhSSPh. PhS(C‘O)Ph PhSSPh IWIri(p ;-CPh)(lr-CPh)(/l-rigCPhCPhCPhCPh)(CO)j(,l”CiH,,] [W,~I-~(,I:-CP~)(/~I-~~~-CP~CPI~CP~) (,(-CO)~(CO),(,~‘-C.~H~)II jRrPt~(/l-dpp11l)i(C‘[~)~(S)I- + propcne IRePt;(/~~-S)~(/~-dppm)~(CO):Ii + propcnc
[M~~C”~(,~~-SI~(S)(I~‘-C~H,M~)~~ + <-,\-I.% diphcnylpropene [Mo~CO~(/QS)(/I ;-S)2(CO);(CNR)(,I-C~H,M~)~]. [M~~(.o~(/~~-S),(CNB~‘)((.O)(,~~-C~H~M~),~ Saturated and unsauiratrd C,-C, hydl-ocarhow
Product(\)
Tran,formatwn
Modeled
IO6
105. I06 105. I06
7x
62
63.64
63.64
63.64
63.64
68. 103
6X. 103
I03
68. to1
6X. 103. 104
Rd.
108
WATERMAN
et al.
+RSH. -RII
[ Wlr$CO),
I(I]-C~H~)]
afforded
two products.
one of which,
CPh)(/l-rl’-CPhCPhCPhCPh)(CO)i(&CTH5)], the tungsten C=C
scission
via C-C
cluster
to give two
resulting
formations
products,
Curtis
C-C
and co-workers
CsH4Et)2]
have
to understand
lead to C-S
scission
tion reactions
with
processes
studied
alumiiia-supported
desulfuriation
carbons, ligand
cluster
details
investigated.“” Reaction of thiophenol electron-deficient,
were desulfurized
of the thiol with
paramagnetic
which.
in the presence
forded
PhSSPh. cycle
C-C
cleavage:
of organosull‘ur
process.
compounds ;-S)J(CO):(IJ’-
The reaction
catalysts.
pathways
The bimetallic thiols
to RNC.
which
cluster
to parent
hydro-
(Fig.
and unsaturated
clusters
that
hydrodesulfltri/a-
CI-&
replaced
a carbony
of CO,
The combination (Fig.
reactions
IMo~C~~(I~~-S)J(CO)?( regenerated
[ Mo,Co?(
I
( Mo~CO~(I~,-S)(/I~-S)I(CO);
desull‘urization
cluster
66):
hydro-
and (M~~C~~(~~~-S)J(CNR)(CO)(II-C~HIM~)~I.””.’”~
tic and mechanistic
catalytic
suggest
trans-
hydrogenolqsis.“’
dcsulfurizcd
isocyanidc-coordinated
(CNR)(qS-C5HJMe)l]
These
hydrogenolyais
to the commercial
were saturated
The
in butane
[ Mo,COI(EIi-S),(C0)2(,15-CgHJMe)lI
products
and isothiocyanates affording
27).“’
with diphenylaccty-
XXI [ Mo$I02(/1
“MoCoS”
[Mo?COI(II~-S)(,IJ-S)7(CO)I(IJ5-CjH~Me)21 and the cubane
(see Fig.
formation.‘”
studies
in ethane
the rcaction
the desult’urizution
carbons
involved
r/‘-CiH~Me)~]
have been compared
thiophene
bond
cithel
or dimerizution
and phenylmethylidyne
has allylic
and C-C
intermediate
)(/lj-S)$CO)q(
moieties system
as experimental
catalysts,
dehydrogenated
[ M~$ZOI(/IJ-S
one of which scission
core with
have undergone
has also been reacted
to illustrate
over the cluster-derived
alkylidyne
[ WIr$/l?-CPh)(l1(buttcrtly)
ligands
an iridacyclopentadienyl
from
are believed
of an adsorbed with
the alkync
[ W,Ir~(CO)lo(115-CsH~)~]
and yielded
fragments
position;
to give jr!- and Ir;-coordinated
coupling
related lent
atom at the “hinge”
has an open
Kinehave
~~i-C~H4Et)~l jr?-S)JSPh)$
the original
of these two reactions
carbonyl constitutes
also been f’ormcd
the
&C5H4Et)2J. cluster
and af-
the basis of a
67).““.“’
Supported bimetallic Re-Pt catalysts are important in selective reforming of petroleum. It is believed that sulfiding the catalyst before use: gives RcS units which act as inert diluents to reduce the size of :I local ensemble of platinum atoms. Selectivity for desirable dchydrocycli/,ation and isomerizntion reactions
“Very Mixed”-Metal
PllS ‘\
is thereby
increased,
jacent
platinum
Rc-Pt
clusters
with
sulfide,
;I cluster
with
lene sulfide
under
mild
conditions
was then desulfurized
dation
ot’ the 0x0 clusters
dppm)j(C0)3]+
RePt, with
faces,
in metal-metal
propene
sulfide
has recently
and the sulfur
coordinated
in the cluster
complexes
bonding
Homogeneous
atom
catalysis
by transition
with
sulfur sulfi-
;-O),(/L-
an equivalent
in a PJ-fashion
“” Examples
gave propy-
two face-capping “)s”06 * si*lilar and [RePti(/r
(Fig.
clus-
sulfide
a second
been studied;
in
‘~ (n = I
of propylene
molecule.
metal clusters
of the speci tic transformations.
to the tetrahedral
and propenc:
[RePti(LLi-O)(p-dppm)$CO)jl’
propylene
was generated
were added
ad-
On reaction
[ RePti(/l-dppm)z(S),,(CO,i]
to give a cluster
and another
several of rhenium
hypotheses.
of one equivalent sulfur
requires
sulfidation
for these
atoms
to give
a rhenium-coordinated
bridging
perspective
as evidence
one or two sulfur
atoms
propene
studied
which
Metalloselective
[RePti(/l-dppm)3(CO)J+,
or 2). Reaction
of alkanes,
is diminished.
has been
109
c
and hydrogenolysis
atoms,
propylene
ter cation
Carbonyl Clusters
with
of
a decrease
6X).‘“”
has been reviewed of very mixed-metal
from
the clus-
ters catalyzing processes homogeneously are collected in Table IX. As is generally the case with homogeneous catalysis, the catalytic precursor is well defined. but the nature of the active catalyst is unclear. Sulfided cial
bimetallic
clusters
hydrodesulfurization
geneous
catalytic
behavior
which
(HDS) studied.
mimic
catalysts Reaction
the metal have
been
composition prepared
of thiophenol
with
of commer-
and their
homo-
[ Mo$~,(/L~-S)
111
112
WATERMAN
(P~-S),(CO)J( ~‘-CSHJM~)~] forded only a stoichiometric cally.
The
(Fig.
l4).5x
reacted
cluster
under catalytic conditions amount of HDS products:
regeneration
Under
( I61 %), The residual
to yield
The
octanuclear
laliphatic
(PhCH,OH,
PhlCHOH)
bond and proton
69). The same cluster
Heterogeneous with bimetallic
COS
was recrystallized
was
and PhS(CO)Ph to give
NaZIMo?PdJ(/L3-CO)I(,I-CO)~(~~~-C~Hs)~l
of aliphatic
(MeOH. alcohols.
[MojZo?
catalysis catalysts
transfer
was inefficient
a
EtOH,
Pr”OH.
Dehydration
was
Bu’CH20H)
proceeded
I’ound
and ary-
slowly
under
solutions containing the catalyst under an was not required. Alcohols having no hy-
drogen atom in the u-position were unable available suggest that the reaction proceeded (Fig.
by CO to give
(I7 I c/. based on cluster)
product
mild conditions (60-80 C) in alcohol argon atmosphere: an acidic medium
across the Mo-Pd
dcsulfidation
(S7%‘)?“’
cluster
dehydration
( 1000 psi CO. I SO C) afPhSSPh is formed catalyti-
[MolCo,(l13-S)J(CO)z(11S-CjH1Et)21
PhSSPh
organometallic
(~@)I(SPh)2(,j5-CsHJEt)~] to catalyze
step involved
the same conditions,
with thiophenol
et al.
to undergo elimination. via oxidative addition to give an intermediate in the hydrogenolysis
by metals has been of long-standing metal particular focus. “)‘) Transition
All the data of the alcohol carbene
specie\
of alcohols.‘“”
intercst,‘x7m’“u carbonyls have
“Very Mixed”-Metal
113
Carbonyl Clusters
HI0 (I<(‘1 I I,,
attracted being
attention
Examples Table
as precursors
examined
as precursors
of heterogeneous
catalysis
with
catalysts,‘“’ particles
heterometallic
of controlled
by cluster-derived
cluster\
stoichiometry.
species
are collected
in
X.
A MgO-supported (t/5-CiHj)lj
(Fig.
by IR, EXAFS, hydrogenation
W-Pt 70),
TEM at 1
precursors.
catalyst,
Hz stream of HZ. CO, than
than for
a
from at 400
an
and
order
catalyst
1WIPt(CO)(,(NCPh)2 C, and characterized
OZ. Activity
in toluene
of magnitude prepared
hm
less
fm
the two
I Sh
catalyst
[ Mo7Rh(,L-CO)(CO)d(,75-CjH)31 at room
a
and 60 C was more
monometallic
cwcuation
has been prepared
under
and chcmisorption atrn
cluster-derived
silica-supported
catalyst
reduced
the bimetallic A
to active to bimetallic
temperature.
was
(Fig.
prepared 70)
Decomposition
ti-om
by
anaerobic
impregnation
CH$Zl~
solution,
processes
were
followed observed
01 by at the
“Very Mixed”-Metal beginning
of the CO hydrogenation
decomposition
was complete
ity (ca. 50%’ conversion) higher clude
selectivity
W)
The
were
activated
clusters
in activity
of active
oxygen-containing
under
and subjected
clopcntadienyl
Product
ligands
70)
near
I80 to 300
and its activity
cluster-derived
catalyst
while
activity
cracking
The
compared
and activities
tetrahedral
showed
a
rable
evolution metal
[lr4(CO)1~]
profiles
observed were
the hydrogenolysis activity
(S-10
production
of /l-butane
times)
(7675%) greater
to [It-i + 2Mo2 1. Metal-metal
A catalyst and
were
activation from
All
sample.
on y-A1203
A catalyst
IPtMel(ll%od)]
and treated
catalyst.
identical:
the
presultiding.
for both.
with compa-
catalysts
prepared
from
under
equivalent
exhibited
absorption from
mixture conditions
ot
active
foi
enhanced
toward
ethane
the [Mo21rZ]
(ca. 50%)
spectroscopy
a
were
catalyst
but activity
com-
materials
were
in the activated
was prepared
photoelectron
and
mixtures
In contrast.
interactions
and
on alumina,
in HJ. Materials
spectra.““’ [Re2Pt(CO)I,] (XPS),
chemisorbed cluster was treated with Hz at about I50 C resulting and formation of rhenium subcarbonyls; at 400’ C the sample decarbonylated.
of CO?,
Catalco
nearly
but selectivity
for Cl and C3 production
by IR. X-ray
amounts
stoichiometric
the Molr
the use of Mo K edge X-ray
supported
characterized
during prepared
the same
parable
with
catalysts
at 2 IS C; the [R/loll-~] catalyst
showed
characterized
selectivity
small
of cy-
[ Molr;(l.c-CO)~(CO)x(,l’-C~Hs)]
over the 111-A+ 3Mo2] was
(TPD)
used in the hydrodesulfuriza-
was
70) have been deposited
[Mo2(CO)(,()I-CsHi),].
TiO?.
by evolution
increase
clusters (Fig.
of ;-
SiO2.
in activity upon I 9x in the reduced form.
was enhanced
compositions and
greater
heteromctallic
[ Mo,Ir2(,L-CO)?(C0)7075-CZHi)ll methane
AllO.;,
with the commercial
of both
the for-
decomposilion with
a
[ Mo+ZO$IIJ-S)(/I
oxides
C, together
as
catalyst.
the proportion
100 C. followed
catalyst
6 metal
prevented
increasing
CO
A signiti-
rhodium
precursors
on the refractory
commenced
from
by FTIR.
of a group
supported
pre-
(M = MO,
and EPR.
them to temperature-programmed
ofC0
distributions
as catalyst ct trl. have
CHJ. and Me2.S. The alumina-supported tion of thiophene.
the presence
catalysts
catalyst
characterized (TPR).
for CH4 production, Curtis
(Fig.
Hz. Evolution
with
clusters
products.‘“’
S)~(CO)J(Il’-CjH~Me)2] and MgO,
and cluster
for a monometallic-derived
sites responsible
monoxide
rhodium
[M2Rh(/l-CO)(CO)~(,I’-C5H5)1]
observed
was
The use of these heterometallic mation
monometallic
reduction
to that observed
K the activ-
of carbon
silica-supported
both
At 523 smaller
prepared samples. but has been extended to in-
Hydrogenation
at 37.1 K in Hz and the catalyst
relative
slightly
conventionally “)j This
temperature-programmed
cant increase promoter,
employing
reactor.
exhibited
products.
g homologue.
silica-adsorbed
chemisorption.
in the flow
and tungsten-promoted
has also been compared cursors.
with
oxygenated
the tungsten-containin
on both molybdenum-
at 1 MPa
and the catalyst
compared
toward
115
Carbonyl Clusters
(Fig.
in fragmentation was completely
of [ Re3(Ll-H)3(CO)II] showed
70)
and TPR. The
the rhenium
and to
116
WATERMAN
be present
in a high valent
platinum
is believed
the rhenium
in the sample
Dehydration catalyst
cationic
form
to facilitate
prepared
derived
from
from
has also been examined.
posed under
llowing
Hz at 400
acterized
(Re,Pt(CO),zI
initial
1Pt(NH,)?
to be more
revealed
the cluster-derived
the others:
its resistance
to deactivation
stabilizing
the dispersion
of the platinum.
Each
metallic
transmission showed maintain from
and platinum
MO-Pd
supported
palladium, electron
microscopy,
that the presence the palladium
in
the monometallic
and by weaker
a
TPD
highly
dispersed
than
from the bimetallic
by chemisorption of adsorbed
temperatures
CO. and EXAFS.
The data
precursor
highly
form.
the sample
prepared
palladium
particles
was
In
contrast.
characterized
to
of Hz, CO. and 0,.
in the bimetallic
dispersed
in
70) and monometallic
of molybdenum
precursors
MO-Pd
pre-
Characteriration
H 2 at various
in
I‘rom
to the role of rhenium
(Fig.
was treated
were charmade
than catalyst\
have been prepared
and characterized
to each other
The catalyst
to be more
was attributed 204
+
was deconand
\alt precursors.
catalyst
catalysts
sample
cluster
to deactivation
[Mo7Pd2(En;-CO)1(El-CO)J(PPh3)1(,7i-CiH~)?l
precursors. form
rhenium
The
I Pt( NH?)?]( NO;)?
wore similar
) u toluenc.
resistant
by EXAFS
model
and
ol‘methylcyclohcxane
(>90%
from
MgO-supported
to be near
of a [ Re?Pt(CO),?l-derived
](N03)1
C for 4 h. The catalysts
pared conventionally
cluster
form.
and is likely
The alumina-supported
conversion
was found
in ;L metallic
[RelPt(CO)12].“‘3
for the dchydrogenation
by high
of rhenium
in the prcscnce
NHJRcOJ]
in their selectivities
and the platinum
the reduction
of tnethylcyclohexane
and catalysts
et a/
by larger
helped
to
interactions.~“’
III PHYSICAL A. General
Comments
The focus of research and structure. been largely
MEASUREMENTS
on “very
and the limited restricted
mixed”-metal
physical
to fluxionality
clusters
measurements
has been on their synthesis
ot’these
and electrochemical
clusters
ofligand fluxionality are summarized in Section 1II.A. and reports ical investigations are reviewed in Section 1II.B. The few reports behavior
of these clusters
are summarized
are discussed
in Section
in Section
have thus far
investigations.
Studies
ofelectrochemof the magnetic
1II.C. I ., and theoretical
studies
III.C.2.
B. Fluxionality Ligand the majority
Huxionality of reports
on metal
clusters
focusing
on carbonyl
has been
the subject
migration
of many
on homometallic
studies, tri- and
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
117
tetranuclear clusters.‘.“‘5 ‘I’ Extending fluxionality studies to mixed-metal clusters affords a significant advantage; mechanistic details may be more accessible due to the decreased symmetry and effective labeling provided by introduction of the heterometal. Additionally. though. activation energies for ligand scratnbling in mixed-metal clusters may diIt‘er markedly frotn those of their homotnetallic ~malogucs, and it would be expected that this difference will be accentuated utilizing “very mixed”-metal clusters. A combination of decreased symmetry. labeled core nuclei. and differing encrgetics for processes involving tnetals with disparate electi.oneFativities may permit discrimination of fluxional pathways not possible in hotnometallic clusters. Despite these significant advantages, comparatively few reports of fluxionality at “very mixed”-metal clusters have appeared. Three major classes of fiuxional behavior are commonly observed in clusters: (A) Metal localic;ed scratnbling. ~tsually seen in M(C0); or M(CO)?L groups. (B) Intermetallic ligand migrations. visually involving CO or hydrides (although examples with phosphines and alkynes are extant) and proceeding via edge-bridged or face-capped intcrmediate5. (C) Metal fratnework rearrangements. Exatnples of all three classes of Huxional behavior have been observed at “very mixed”-metal clusters. It should be emphasized that absolute atomic motions are not accessible: considering ligands rotatin, (7 around a fixed metal core or a metal core rotating within a tixed ligand polytope are equally valid viewpoints (the latter has been docutnentcd in the solid state: see, for example, Ref. 205 ). The former description has been utilized f:u- more often in literature reports and. following this convention, this review summarizes specific cases in terms of lisands exchanging by rotating around a metal core where possible. Table XI sutnmarizes reports of ligand fluxionality at “very mixed”-metal clusters. A number of studies (e.g., Refs. 28, 8 I. I 16, 2 13. 2 14) have reported that both metal-localized and global carbonyl Huxionality occur but give little mechanistic detail. The following discussion focuses on the examples for which detailed studies have been undertaken and/or those for which mechanistic speculation is available. A number of exatnples of metal-localized ligand scrambling have been documented. Rotation of the Ru(C0)~(&gH5) units about the Zr-Ru bonds in the V-shaped IZrRu2(CO)l(r15-CjHj)~] resulted in equivalence ofthe cat-bony1 ligands (Fig. 7 1 ):‘I3 replacing the cyclopentadienyl ligands by CH$CH2NSiMej)z reduced significantly the barrier to rotation in the ruthenium-containing analogue and its iron-containing homologue.“’ A similar rotation ofthe W(CO),( 1$C5MeS) group in [WCO~(~~-CC~HJM~-~)(CO)~(I$C~M~~)] has also been noted.“” A detailed study of the rotation of the M(C0)2(t$-C5RdR’) vertices (M = Mo. W: R. R’ = H. Me) in [MCo:(~3-CC02Pri)(CO)(,(L)($-C5R3R’)] (L = 2C0, Ph2PCHICH2PPhl. Ph7AsCH7CH2PPh,) I’.’ ” revealed that the barriers to rotation of the group 6 tnetalcontaining vertices in these clusters (3742 kJ tnol-‘) are similar to those of the
118
119
120
WATERMAN
Tripodal
(,13-CC02Pr’)(CO),(L)( NMR
studies.
in
vertices
M(C0)2(~5-CjH5.,,Me,,) (,7’-CjH5~,,Mcn)?l.”
Co(C0);
&RqR’)]
A similarly
rapid
et a/
tetrahedral rotation
that turnstile
it could motion
Two
was retarded
localized
was observed
H)2(CO)x(PPhj)2]; bony1
ligands
sponded
to a trigonal
Ph).“”
followed
rotation ofthe
ogous
tripodal
process unit,
Re(C0);
is facile at
procea
phosphine groups
as
car-
correwell
as
has been docu-
e.g. (OS~(/~-H)(/~I-CR)(CO)~~~~
(R =
at room
in the bicapped octahedral IRe,Pt(/1(,Upon cooling a sample of the temperature.‘“’ at the base of the PtMe:
at the three rheniums
rotation:
IRelPt(/l-
of the three
energy
but involving
at the
rotation
the three rhcniums
isostructural
the higher
atom
rotation
at the triangular
of this type at M(CO)4 clusters.
in solution
at one cobalt
a scrambling
wab
while
at the same metal,
in homometallic
by cessation
gation
observed
energy
exchange
Tripodal
C)(Me)3(C0)31]‘m cluster,
twist
Three-fold
previously
H, OMc,
groups.
were
in the Re(C0)3(PPh;)
carbonyls.“x mented
ethyl
processes
the lower
in [ MoCo?
out
but Co(CO)j 71
by ad.jaccnt
exchange
rapid
not bc frozen
in ( WCol(p-EtC,Et)(,l-qJ-CEtCEtCEtCEt)(CO)x], other cobalt
[ M~(E~I-II’-RC~R)(CO)~
was sufficiently
cap
was
at the base of the Rc(C0)3
[Re7Pt(~r~,-C)(C0)~~(r~‘-2-methylullyl)I’decoalescencc
of resonances
froren
lirst.
cap. Investirevcaledanal-
was observed
in the reverse
order to that in the PtMe+ontaining cluster, but it was not clear ii’ this results from a reversal 01‘relative activation cnergics or from chemical shift order. Tetrapodal rotation
of the [Re(C0)3(L)]
[L = P(OMc)3,
P(OPh),J;
barrier to rotation, Several examples
a
vertex
was observed
in [ RePti(El-dl)pni);(CO).i(L,)J-
the trimethylphosphite-containing
result ascribed of intcrmetallic
cluster
had a lower
to steric considerations.‘l’ hydride migration in rhenium-platinum
clus-
ters have been investigated. Hydride hopping between the two Re-Pt edges in trian? occurred at a lower energy than gular IRcIPt(,l-H)2(CO)8(L)] [I, = rl’-cod. (PPh i )_I A similar hydride migration between the two rotation of’ the Pt(H)(L) moiety.“’ Re-Pt edges was observed in the spiked-triangular IRelPt(EI-H)3(CO)lj1”J and
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
121
[ Re3Pt(/~-H)3(C0,Me)(CO)ti]~,7’ and the “scorpion” [ R~~P~(,-I-H)~(CO)~X~~;‘~an intermediate in which both exchanging hydrides arc bridging Re-Pt linkages in the triangular fragment of the cluster was proposed (Fig. 72). Similarly, the hydrides bridging the Re-PI bonds in the “bowtie” cluster [RelPt(p-H)5(CO)th]m exchange rapidly, with only one ‘H NMR signal ti)r these hydrides observed down to I93 K.7’ Alkyne migration at [MoFcNi(ll3-,l’-PhC1CO~Pt-‘)(CO)(,(rl’-C~H~)~l has been examined;“” a formal rotation of the alkyne rclativc to the metal triangle proceeding by a “modified windscreen wiper” mechanism was proposed (Fig. 73). Carbonyl exchange between tnetals has been the most frequently studied intertnerallic ligand migration in homotnetallic clusters, ~LIL the few exatnplex which have been exatnined in the “very mixed”-metal domain have afforded inconcluhive results. At the triangular cluster [MoCOL(/I~-CCOIPI.‘)(II-P~?E(:H~CH~PP~,) (CO)(,(l15-CsMe5)J, the mechanism interconverting molybdenum- andcobalt-bound carbonyls was not conclusively established. but rnlation of the [Mo(C0)2(11~-
122
W A T E R M A N et a/
Platinum-hound on warming turc ol‘two
isomers
[ Re(CO)j(PPh wrved
phoaphine
;I solution
and I-hcnium-ligatt~l
is formed
which
;)I unit (see abow).
earlier
was proposed,
involving
Pt; face. Thiolate [ Mo,Co$/r
cluster
the intermcrliacy
migration
between
the Co-(‘0
axis and a barrier
2-PBu’)(/l~CO)(CO)(,(
I~‘-C~H~)~]
X0 C. it undcrgocs
an i~mversihle
his-phosphido Few
procc~
in the butterfly
ligand
examples methods
\pannin, (7 MO-CO
of metal at ?er),
Il-amoworh
the MO-CO
bonds:
one’ ligated (Fig.
74).
timcwde
hwc
4 study
cobalt The
with
respect
triangular
through
M and the midpoint
isolobal
analogue
the harrier I .3 hJ nwl
of a d”-ML5
to rotation
to the other
clusters
MO. W: M ’ = (‘(I. Rh) underwent
ligantl
of‘ the M ’-Rh alhcnc
vector
con~plcx.
been that rather.
a molecular
ofthe
M(CO)j
obscr\~ed
the
observed
by clu\-
the Ruxionala twisting mirror
01‘
plane
(M = Cr. unit about an axis
(Fig. 75).““”
The cluster
ij an
In thi\ context.
it is intcrcsting
that
in IMo(‘oRh(,r-C’O)1(C(>)i(,ii-C,Mc,)21
’) is in the rang
with
of the V-shaped
rotation:
intruduwcl
rotation
’.““)
hcatecl at 75-
IMM’Kh(,l-CO)1(CO)~(lii-C~Mci)2J ;I l’ornd
the thi-
:-q’-PBu’Cc,H.,-
when
~e\ealed
was not alhyne
anion
wctors.2’7
tcr IWCol(,(~EtC2Et)(,1-)I”-CEtCEtCEtCEt)(C‘O),1 ity on the NMR
cluster
to at’i’ortl an isomer
and C’o-Co clustcrx.
the
OCCLII’\ with
mrra~qelncnts
mixed”-lnctal
1’
bridging
01‘42 * 3 kJ mol
in [ Mo2Col(/r
tr~unsi’~)rmation
to that
P(OMe):)
ligancl triply
to this motion ligand
britlgcs
has heen ohsimilar
;-C0)(/~Ippm)~(
bonds
The o-phcnylencbis(/r-/o.t-butylphosphido)
NMR
migration
;-S)~(,~-S)(,~-SC~,H_IM~-~)(CO),(,I.~-(‘~H~M~)~I~
elate crossing
twist at ;I
phosphite
ol‘a phosphitc
CO-MO
;I niix-
trigonal
” a Huxional (Pt;(/r
exchange:
27.1 K:“7.1’X
by ;I Irc\trictcd
Intcrmctallic
in the hon~on~etallic
irreversibly
ahow
intcrcomcrt
at [RePt;(/r-dl’p~ii)l(O)~(P(OMe))I~’:
observed
carbonyl
of‘ [Ke,Pt(~l-H)l(CO)s(PPIi~)~I
for hinclerotl
rotation
(AGIS
= 52.3 +
at &ML5
organic
“Very Mixed”-Metal
123
Carbonyl Clusters
\
alkene complexes (AC$=35-80 kJ molK’). A similar rotation, about an axis through the tungsten and midpoint ofthe /I-C-Pt vector, was proposed to explain the equivalence of the radial carbonyls in [W~Re2Pt(@X~,H4Me-3)2(CO)181.X4 The clusters [MF~C~~(/~~-E)(E~-ASM~~)(CO)~(~~’-C~H~)~ (M = Mo, W; E = S. PMe) exist as isomers corresponding to differing positions of the iron and cobalt atoms; detailed equilibration and isomerization studies showed that isomer interconversion does not occur under rigorously clean conditions. but instead requires the presence of impurities, suggesting that radical type metal-metal bond cleavages initiated the isomerization process.‘” Examples of intermolecular ligated metal exchange are also extant. The Vshaped clusters IMPd2(,-~-CI)(CO)~(L)2(175-C5HS)1 (M = Cr. MO, W; L = dmba. dmat) underwent exchange by dissociation and reassociation of the carbonymetallate anion [M(CO)$&~HS)](Fig. 76).2’5 The spiked triangular cluster IR~-~P~(/~-H)~(CO)IJ] exchanged the “spike” fragment [ReH(CO)s] in solution (Fig. 77), in a process which is a formal substitution at a square planar platinum.“’ Such reactions are usually associative; accordingly. a strong dependence on the concentration of added [ReH(CO)S] was noted. “Very mixed”-metal clusters offer significant advantages in Huxionality studies. but these advantages remain to be fully exploited. Studies of tetrahedral rhodium and mixed rhodium-iridium clusters have revealed intermetallic carbonyl ligand site exchange proceeding by way of merry-go-round and change-of-basal-face processes.z06 Substitution of Rh by Ir in the apical site slowed down the former
124
WATERMAN
process.
rationalized
of electron tripodal
rotation
accelerated
process.
electron
density
ofthese
examples
tive energies
involved
of activation.
mixed”-metal
and mixed
metal.
as the
Sd orbit&
an electronic
Replacing
clusters
should
One problem
the apical
from a remote
the vertices
in homometallic
accentuate
these effects,
for fluxional
processes
equivalence
of’ligated
metal
fragments
coordination
number
metal,
and possibly
isostructural
Ir(CO)j [ WIrJCO),
sten, with a sterically processes pies above),
remote
a (formally)
demanding
from
this problem
UC
in proceeding
I( q5-C~H5)]
cyclopentadienyl
the heterometal
(such
ligandl. as with
plane
bonds.
Both
metal affecting
h-CO
rela-
clusters
to alt‘otd
but this remains
involves
by W(C0)$q5-C~H5) introduces
underwcnt
Rh removing
imolving
is that isolobal (e.g.. replacing
clusters
electronegative
between effect
a shift
CO-containing
of Ir by Rh in the basal
more
mally)
higher
Rh inducing
(7 the bridging
rhodillm-iridiLlm
Substitution
rationalized
from the apical
be demonstrated.
face and stabilkin,
iridium
at the apical
this
from the more electronegative
to the basal
state. Tetrahedral
~IX~III~
“very
as resulting
density
et a/.
introducing
increased from
steric
However.
to tung-
for fluxional
the rhodium-iridium
Ii<.
a (f’oreffects
[ Ir~(CO)ll]
eight coordinate
may not bc important.
to
the heteromctal
cxan-
“Very Mixed”-Metal
125
Carbonyl Clusters
C. Electrochemistry The
electrochemical
clsewhcre.“’ as “electron pablc
sinks:”
of multiple
maximized
subjected
with
cyclic
mixed”-metal
to detailed
range of systematically of [ Coj(/13-E)(CO)L,] clusters
capping
group
important an
CMe.
(M = Mo.
may either
reaction
between
by electrolysis
PTol.
GeMc.
Two reduction
processes
ically
irreversible
carhonyl
process,
step: both moving
tion decreased
from a terminal in the order
followed
These
clusters
or provide
Jensen
Cr > Mo=W.
arc chemically
capped 1 (M = Cr. tag-
S. Se) where structural
the
rigidity
(‘I I//. ’“’ have described
(CrCol.
MoCo2.
route
of 3 M-Co
to bridge
(Fig.
WCoz).
with
78).
The
can
be initintcd
I-CR)(CO)~(
direct
I~~-C~H~)) and chem-
and chemically accompanied
on apical
und under
reactive
with the IMoCo2(1(;-CR)(CO)s(,15-CsHS)I
by a
The peak ceparasubstitucnt.
of the elcctrogenerated
temperatures more
bond
theac metals.
with a dependence
out at several
counterparts.
active
by ~111electrochemically
\vith experiments mospheres.
CPh, PMe.
for the [MCo$/l
in the characterization
tricobnlt
especially
The first, an clectrochemically
cleavage position
a
1I.E. I .).
[Co3(/~;-CPh)(CO)~,,I”‘-‘.
EPR data has been used carried
in generating
and K[Mo(C0)~(17-CsH5)]
were observed was
deal
and [ MM’Co(,r;-E)(CO)s(
activated
for the couple
steps involved
of reports
&C5Hi)
CBu’.
examples
(M = Cr. Mo. W; R = Me. Ph) clusters. reversible
GcPh)
thermully
[CO~(/~I-CP~)(CO)~,,I at the potential
ha\.c
(Section
intensively.
state changes.
alkylidync
the cLssical
clusters
[ MC~$/L:-E)(CO)~(
be electrochemically oxidation
of some
than
be
clusters
of electrochemical
procedures
mixed”-metal
formulas
CPh.
in subsequent yields
“very
W; M’ = Fe. Ru; E =CMe.
electrosyntheais
higher
of metal exchange
have been studied
of general
W: E = CH.
;I summary
should
clusters.
varied
triangular
provides
which
mixed”-metal
to act
may be C;I-
of heterometals
the majority
contains
reviewed
potential
atoms
effects
Few “very studies:
their
metal
response.
XII
the success
derivatives Mo.
Table
has been
from
of several
electrochemical
mixed”-metal
given
clusters stems
The incorporation
clusters.
only.
of&&very
Not surprisingly,
CTH~)]
an aggregate
the electrochemical
voltammctry
investigations
clusters
state changes.
to tune
in “very
been
of heterometallic
in examining
in principle,
redox
the opportunity
wide
behavior
The interest
urgon
than their
species. and CO at-
homonucleal
clusters
the most
“Very Mixed”-Metal
chemically
I-eve,-sible.““.“”
The d.c. polarognums
the ~-elated gcrmaniLlm-capped also showed
of’the
supported
by EPR data; the second
(Fig.
X-ray
dif‘fraction
structure
bond.
L~o\~-ternpcratur~ ligmnd
occurred
protonation,
through
and
radical
anion
duction
more
difficult
precursor.
than
clcctron,
While higher
WFe)
to its sulfur trimetallic
capped
clu\tcr
wma.
three (-
an irrevcrsiblc
to arise
of. the neutral showed
radical
reduction.
clusters
[Cr$Jo(/r
have
also been
I~roiii a fasl
two-electron
+O.L? process
(R =
;-Se)(CO)s(
of an electron
Addition nletals
and
intensively
Cyclic
(+0.X()
revealed
one-electron
V). Another
mm
studied.
readcluxtct
clusters
of
01‘ the tetm l’our oxidation
transfer
tetra-cupped
=
;I one-
cnplmf
voltnmmetry
in DMF
V) reversible
(M,M,
proceeded
i-
ncgativc
untlctwent
IOr the \eleniunl
the moat
investigated.
I’C-
[ WFcCo(/~
at more
q5-CiHS)]
tol-
made iron-dicobalt
clustera reduced
at IOU
rmction
heteromctal
[M,M~CO(/~~-S)(CO)~(,I~-C~H~)I
been
iI)
cvm
l’ragmciilatioi1
of the third
~-S)I(CO)O~‘-C~H~M~).:I
I .07, -0.33,
I’oI-III.
bridging
of‘ its phosphinideite-~~ll~p~~f
[ MoFeCo(/c
Multi-
isomcrization
irreversible.
Ph) W~IV irrr\crsihly
the lighter 12’) analogue.
specks.
that rapid
IILloFeCo(,l~-PR)(CO)x(~li-CjHi)]
Introduction
reduction
of the pho-
gave an isonm
The CV 01‘ the deproto-
;tnd electlochemically
with
have
two
seclucm
waves: the first wa\‘e w:as full>
to give the MO-CO
clusters and
quasi-reversible
nuctearity
q’-CjHj)]-.
clusters
(R = Me,
IOr the clusters
relati\,e
migration
17x.‘2” The ;III;I~O~OLIS tullgstcn-contaiiiili~
chalcogen-cnpped MoRu.
species
deprotonation
wa\‘e. however,
limuation,
PR)(CO)s(I15-CjH<)] potentials.“” The
induced
two oxidation
migration
is believed
lowing
MoFc.
thermally
to the formation
the second
of the trimctallic
tenipcratures,
ily
showed
vi3 11-PPh? bridge
undtmvent
and cationic
was established by ;I 4nglc-crystal that the jr-PPhz ligand bridges a MO-CO
~-CCI,H~M~-~)(/(-PPI~~)(CO)(,(
Ph. Ru’) w~1.s chemically
cliister
,,‘-C5H~)Jm
radical
bond, and aubscquent
and corresponded
Reduction Me.
and had
irreversible
of the radical
to the Co-Co
f’orm of this isomer
ple scanning
to
. an asaignmcnt
L+TISchemically
to give
co~lfimecl
study, which
phido
of [MoCo~(/1
Ph)
corrcspondcd
1-GeR)(CO)K(,~i-C5H5)]
process
oxidations
79). The
re\,crsiblc
jMoCo$/~
(R = Me.
(reversible)
[ MoCo~(lr;-CCr,H,Mc-~)(,~-PPh,)(CO)(,(
one-electron
tially
rlated
anion
of‘
of an ECE mechanism.“”
the characteristics The anion
voltnmmo~rams
IMoCol(lni-GeR)(CO)x(rli-C~H~)I
formation
rc\,crsible
and cyclic
waves. The tirst proccas
two reduction radical
127
Carbonyl Clusters
:steps, and
cluster
which
ha hcen clectrochemically studied is [ Mo~CO~(,I:-S),(C~)~(,I’-C?H~~~)!~. Recent work 01‘ Mansour rt rrl. showed that this compound undergoes ;I single. rc\,ersible. one-electron reduction at ~ I .04 V. a signilicantty more positive reduction potcntiul than that 01‘its electron-rich 62 CVE nitrosyl analogu~ [ hlolCol(,li-S)~(NO)~( I]~C~HJ3)~/
(-
I.53 V).‘j’
The clectrochcmistry
SK/i ;-S)2(C0)1(r15-CgH,Me)~I
was complicated
ol‘the
butterlly
cluster
IM~QCO~(/I~-
by an ~lectl-ode-sul-I‘LIct:
rcaction
“Very Mixed”-Metal
2e
x *
r
-I .30 v
that led to small spurious this problem anodic (Fig.
cathodic
wave at - I .63 V, behavior
sweep at -0.70
two-electron
wave
at -I
reduction
clusters
cores.
have
reversible
that can be explained
by an EEC-type
mechanism
[MoCol(Il3-II’-PBu’C(,HJ-2-PBU1)(/1-CO)(CO),(,I’-C.iHi)l
contrasting oxidation
observed
electrochemical wave
at 0.65
for the former
The sulfur-capped Fairly simple
waves
were observed
and O.Oc) V were
behavior;
V (E, = I80
cluster
electrochemical
processes. ;I third,
at - I.58 and -2.
irreversible.“’
The first two reversible
“quasi-reversible”
The oxidation versible
oxidation
containing
I I V, while
(-
at -2.23
for this cluster
clusters
II
at -0.
reoxidation
complex,
by four
at -2.04
though.
successive
by
An initial
oxidations
V). irre-
thought
being
studies
Et. Bu’).
the
centers
All
more
electron
combinations
ti~rmally
rich.
on the systematically
~7 to degradation
were
by lormation
results
processes
reduction cyclic voltammothree facile electron-transfer
clusters
correspondin,
The stability blc clusters
reduction
relative
reduction
curred in two some chemical was reasonably
dis-
one-electron
oxidation
V (reverse
IM~M’~(/LI-CO)~(~~-CO)J(PR~)?(,~~-C~HS)~~
panied
wave
The lower oxidation potential of’ the tungstento their molybdenum analogues is consistent with
by the electrochemical
M’(I)
;I quasi-
processes.‘3’
tLlngsten-containing
R = Ph. Me.
exhibited no oxidation
I. I I. - I .7 I V) were followed
is more
at 0. I6 V was followed
to be due to ECE
while
Reversible,
uncomplicated showed
reductions
reduction
behavior
the latter mV),
tetrahedral
[Mo2Ni’(/13-S)I(C0)7(I]i-C5HJMe)’l
behavior.
An of [ W,Co,(~;-S).~(CO)i(ll’-CSH-rEt)21
gram
and with
(up to 0.75 V).”
tetrahedral
played
tion:
.40 V. This to a reverse
80).“’
The
ters
V eliminated
at -I
.8S V that is coupled
[Mo7Co~(~3-~~2-PBu’C6HJ-2-PBu’)(~~-CO)(CO)~,(~~~-C~H~)~~.
was
- ,”
c
the reduction
a well-defined
by a further
fa\l
- x’-
-1.85 v
peaks; starting
and produced
is f’ollowcd
Ic
x’~ I
129
Carbonyl Clusters
trend
varied
was
underwent
an irreversible
of’ the cluster
into
identified
to M’(0) (confirmed
confirmed
tetrametallic
(M = Cr. MO, W;
electroreduced
of [ M(CO)~(q’-CjH5)]~
This
in one by IR).
clus-
M’ = Pd. Pt: tw+clectron fragments: step.
accon-
Oxidation
oc-
distinct one-electron transfers. with the second accompanied by decomposition. The radical cation generated by the first oxidation stable and has been studied by EPR as a IO6 K frozen solusuggested
that the HOMO
is located
on the metals
of the dications was dependent on the solvent, being [M1Pt2(/13-C0)2(~1-CO)-1(PPhZ)l(lj5-C5H5)2]
in the cluster.
with the most sta(M = MO or W).
130
WATERMAN
et a/
I’h,P
While
the reduction
tion potentials only
plays
potentials
were reasonably
;I limited
role
[ W2Pt2(/1;-CO)l(/l-CO)J[
CsHJMe)l]
(Fig. 8 I ). with
pendant
dation
wave
consistent
manganese
with
IX V. Oxidation
by a reduction
peak at -0.67
the EPR
rcsult~.‘“~‘~’
Mn(CO),(,,‘-C~H,Mc] displayed
In particular.
a single
analogue.
at -0.
cl‘t’cects. the oxidnthat the phoaphinc
metal centers,
was seen at - I .4S V (c.1‘. - I .U
appeared
followed
to R substituent Thih COLII~ indicate
PPh2CH,PPh2(
to its ldtriphenylphosphinc)
reduction
from
insensitive.
in the HOMO,
The related ilaritics
were scnsitkc
V);
of the cluster
an associated occurred
]7(/jisome sinirrevcr\ible rcver\e
oxi-
at 0.86 V and was
V in the rcvcr%e scan, thought
to originate
an ECE proccss.‘x
The anodic
scans of the three
C)(C0)2,(11”-CIHi)]‘. ?-mcthylallyl)] second
showed
almost
increased
completely
in theorcler
potential,
octanuclear
two oxidation
wavch.
irrcversiblc.
Oxidation
[ Re,Pt(/r~,-C)(CO)II(
(,lh-C)(C0)2,(1,1-C;Hj)]L~ large diffcrencc between state of platinum
relntcd
anionic
[Rc7Pt(,~(r-C)(C0)21(Mc);]‘~
the Iir\t
metal is Pt(lV).
in the cluster
with
and the
for the first proccsx
,~i-‘-methylallyl)]’
while
(Re,Pd(~r(,-
quasi-reversible
potentials
(0.42 V) < [ RqPd
(0.48 V) < [Re,Pt(,r(,-C)(CO)~,(Me)l]‘~ the latter two can perhaps be cxplaincd
in these compounds:
the capping
clusters
and ]Re7Pt(,(h-C)(CO)II(II‘~
(0.64V). The by the osidation
the highest
in the other clusters
oxidation
the capping
metal
is M(II).‘“’
D. Other Physical The electronic.
Methods
optical.
and magnetic
properties
of metal
clusters
are of great
current interest.’ but these properties have been little studied with “very mixed”metal clusters. This is to some extent 21 refkction of the difticulty of preparing high-nuclearity examples; many of these interesting properties become important
upon
increasing
cluster
size.
The
limited
magnetic
studies
to date
are
“Very Mixed”-Metal TABLE
in Section
Few other
studies
1II.D. I _. with complementary
ha\,c been reported.
gies of[RePt;(/l-dppm).~(CO)~]‘, dppnl)~(CO).J(S)]’ energies.
which
Sulfidation
platinum
The
limited
marid
at
mixed”-metal
an increase
XIII.
Re
along
when
measurements
carbonyl
clusters
(Fig.
group
the /I;-S
of “very behavior
and
groups
[ R~PL;(/I-
XPS
the
is thrmcd,
but
data
arc
o:ticlatim
at
are t’ormed.’
mixed”-metal ot’ mme
01‘ the
cner-
and [ RePtJ/lsuccessively
”
clusters
arc
~LIII~-
anti-lrromagnetic
X3) has been studied
dependcnces
IlI.D.2.
the aerics in Re 4f(7,‘2) binding affords
the Re=S
as
The magnetic
Temperature
in Section
the XPS binding
i-S)1(/1-dppm)i(CO);1’,
sulfidation
magnetic
in Table
~orhers.
reveal
oxidation
on subsequent
king
IRePt;(/li-S)1(~l-dppm)3(CO)-,I
[RePt,(,l
and
with
MO studies
one example
of IRePti(/l-dpptll)i(CO)~]’
dppm)l(CO);(S)]’ consistent
XIII
IShl S I L~t)ll:S01 VI.l
b~,\GNI:I
summtrized
131
Carbonyl Clusters
magnetic
“\cq
bq’ Pnsynskii
mcl co-
susceptibilities
x,,,
of‘
ICr2Cn(/~ ;-S)~(,~-SRL~‘)(CO)~(II-C.~HJR)~I (R = H. Me) have been detertnincd LISing the Faraday n~ethod.2’i.‘“i From x ,,,. the effective magnetic nmnentx /l,,t were calculated plots coupled WKI-acy ~ltts~s ited
using
fitted
the formula
~~~~~= m
. and plots of 11~1, vs T prepared.
the Heiscnberf-Dirnc-Mun
ions ICr(III).
spin 3/Z:
of’ the cotnpkxes
Co(I)
Vleck
(HDVV)
is diamagnetic]
in the ground
in eft‘ecti\,e
magnetic
moment
li)r two
in the absence
state. The related
[CrIM(IIJ-S)I(EI-SBLt’)(CO)(PPh.~)(,li-CiHs)21
;I decrease
model
of’ orbital
de-
phosphine-substituted
(M = Rh. II-) also with
The
exchangc-
tetnperaturc.
M/hi&
exhihagreed
132 with
WATERMAN the HDVV
nmdel.
In contrast
et al.
to the clus~cra
above.
the tetratnetallic
clulr~erx
ICI-IC~(,~;-S)I(CO)(,~~-<:H,R)~] (R = H. Me) were found to be diamagnetic x ,,, < 0). consistent with the I X-clcctron saturation of each metal atoni.‘4J.2”’ magnetic
susceptibilities
W) in solution magnetic value
tnomen~
merits
to I .39 ~~~~a( 40
the fact that these
The
C. The
clusters
to rationalkc
behavior
cluster
to an aerngc
( I .72 ~1,~). moliotonicallq
tungskn-nickel /r t3 at 40
At 30 C, the
corresponds
per molecule
cluster
C. These
are EPR-silent.
studied
bonding.
has encouraged
suggest
orbitals
structural
is prcscnted participated
111~
has magnetic
data.
in combination
tempcratitre-dcpcndent
(R = H. Mc)
tnent
[Crz(,l;-S),(,I-SBu’)(rli-CiHj)]~
(EH)
method.“’
atom\
with the chromium
Interaction
XIV.
rli-C5H~R)2]
(Fig.
magnetic In order
of the lower resulted
calculated lying
p-orbitals
and electromixed”-metal to determine
and metal-ligand
and [CrzCo$/@)(/13-
X3). the electronic has
d-orbitals
in Table
and
;I list of “very
in the tnctal~tnetal
of [ Cr1Co(/c;-S)I(/I-SBit’)(C0)2(
S),(CO)I(~ji-CgH~R)7]
data.
MO calculations:
by MO methods
chromium-based
interactions
cluskra
(M = MO.
of ten~peratures.‘4”
cquilibrin.
need
chemical which
electrons
of‘ I I9 /rt3 at 30 C and 0.03
sin,+-triplet
t15-CiHs).:(Ili-CsH~Me)I
over ;I tmgc
01‘ the molybdenum-nickel
of less than two unpaired
decreasing with
of [ MNi:(/l;-CO).;(
have been measured
(i.e.. The
structure
of the fl-ag-
by the Extended
Hiickcl
of the bridging
in the destabilization
ol‘the
sulfur
d-orhitals:
“Very Mixed”-Metal
the unusual portancc
ordering
of energy
of the 0-S
dichromium thought
ti-agment
to explain
C~HJR)J],
in contrast
For forming
Cr-Co
to participation
.04
this
MO
from
bridges with
of the
fragments
was
of [Cr~Col(/ll-S)(/r?-S)~(CO),(~~~which
orbitals.
with
unshared
is consistent
the in-
orhitals
with two COG
of half-occupied
sulfide
Bonding
the chromium
electron
pairs
the decrease
Icss than the sum or covalent
calculations
(/~-CO)(C0)2(11’-CjHj)ll as
resulted
half-occupied
possess ot’all
four
atoms
corre-
of the sulfur
atoms
in Cr-S
radii ol‘Cr
distances
to
( 1.36 A) and S
atoms.
Fenshe-Hall actions
because of the
a. significantly
A,
bonds
behavior
of formally
in “double-bonding:” ( I
< 6(d-d)]
use of four
to ICr2Co(,lj-S)2(,1-SBu’)(CO)Z(lj5-CgH~R)~1
properties
(s, p,. p,, and p,) orbitals
2.25-2.30
(S (d-d)
The
the diamagnetic
antifci-I-omagnetic sponds
levels
interactions.
133
Carbonyl Clusters
bctwecn
the latter
the odd electron
is effectively
pal changes
between
CI-~(BJH,)(,~‘-C~H~)~ and longer
(Fig.
Cr-B
acting
the ground fragment
distances
were
carried
8.1) in order Co(C0); as
on
[Cr2Co(,l~-)7h-B,H,) the nature
of the inter-
and Cr,( BqH,)( q5-C5Hs)2
;I cluster
“ligand”
state molecule in the cluster
and involved
out
to determine
(Cr2(B-IH8)(115-CjHs)ll
resulted
increases
to the former. in a shorter
in energy
Cr-Cr
I’ragments. The
princiand the distance
for those lingmcnt
or-
hitals which are Cr-Cr antibonding and Cr-B bonding. Interaction of an empty 0 orbital ofthe Cr(CO)j l’ragment with II tilled B-H-Cr orbital caused the hydrogen atom to become Cr-B-Co face-bridgin g. rather than edge-bridging.” In order to explain why the bridging vinylidene group of [ MoCO?(,I~-)I’-CCH,) (CO)s(q’-CgH’) cobalt atom,
I- (Fig. 83) leans toward the molybdenum atom ratller than a EHMO calculations have been employed. Results showed that the
134
WATERMAN
vinylidcne
capping
unit was particularly
the molybdenum
atom,
cial migration was shown
1 X3-273
The electronic
utilizing
in the clusters
in 1M$CO),( and
‘wd
hp,,
from
ha\,e ken
rl’-C.~Hi)~1
was rcali/cd \/ia ki,,
bridging
coordination
01‘ al I carbonyl
I I eV. while
the experinicntally ‘ill energy.-
greatest
(M=Mo.
group\
CO group.
W) (Fig. between
M=M
hetwccn
the orbitals
5d,:
co~~seqw~~ccs
coordinated
to M. into terminal
destabilization
fconictry
the
bonding
ha\ been con\idcrcd;
led to an cnergctic
ova
metal-metal
The energetic
bonds
determined
ol‘thc
Multiple
by o interactions
of ;I terminal
singlet
of the bonding
and Sd,, orbital.
barrier.
experimental
molybclcnLlm-bc,ncied
I‘ragments.
one of‘ the M-Rh
energy
NMR
The nature
in tcrn1\
with
Antara&
a sharp lncthyl
symmetry
calculations.
analy4
71 interactions ligand
with
cxhihitcd
and [Kh(CO)(II’-CiH~J]
interaction
tolerated.
ii large transition
is in accord
the higher
EHMO
of the step by step transl’ormation ;I carbonyl
by direct
is better
of [M~Rh(/I-CO)(CO).,(,j’-CiH~);I
structure
IM$CO)~(II~-C~H~)~I
Thij analoguc
K raulting
83) has been studied
charge
possessing
group,
disfavored.
the climethylvinylidelle
the range
weI1 stahili7ed
the positive
01‘ the C=CH? to be severely
data, where
bonds
where
et al.
01‘ about
w24 calculated
to h;I\ct the
binding
The calculated applied
EHMO
energy
levels for MzM>&
to [ Mol(‘o~(,l-r-S)(,(~-S)2(CO)~(
type cuhane
I&C~HJM~)J~
clusters
have been
(Fig. 8.1) in order to explain
bondinn ,s beh,lvior.“ It was suggested that the HOMO would ha\:c o(Mo-MO) ‘ ’ character and that the LIMO was most likely 0 (MO-MO): addition of electrons to the cluster
is hclievcd
by electrochcniical in [ Mo~CO~(/~~-S)(/I methods.” to I.57
IO result
studies
3-S)2(CO)4(
The total M-S for the M-/i
of electron\). /cJ-li~and rationale
The rather
sulfur
that overlap (60% )I.
of the MO-MO,
11l.C.).
q’-CsHj)2]
overlap
WIIC
population
than concentrated
/c4-S to metal bonds.
with
the metal
they
spread
in three
own’
bonds
ligands EHMO
four
is I.55 compared the s;mc M-S
distributions
the /I~-CO
have been
used
with the Mo atoms
the CO rr-syhtcnl.
The Ni-CO
to support
{-S)z( ,I’-CiH<)Jl 1(-1-,1’-coordination this assignment. “’ Orbital
were both o-bonding bonding
was
and Inulticenter
best described
numhel
bonds
in the
provides
the
ofthe
/i4-
the p-orbitals
The butterlly metal core of [ MolNi2(/~JU)(/1 a crystallographically contirmed carbonyl with calculations
using
in the 11 ;-ligand
[overlap
supported
studied
donate
It is primarily
cl-orbitals
a proposal of the sultido
to the /[J-S atom that
population
overlap
Bonding
has also been
;-S 1~ond.s (suggesting
for the longer
co-s
in cleavage
(see Section
MO-S
(40% ).
is bridged by (Fig. 83). MO interactions 01‘ bonding
as a dative
bond
with from
Ni to the 17‘ orbitals of the carbonyl. Low C-O overlap population rcllectod the additional electron donation into the C-O antibonding orbitals and was consistent with 2 low I’(~~). The bonding in [RcPti(,l-dppm)3(C0)It donation
01‘ electron
density
from
three
can
filled
he
Pt-Pt
understood bonding
in term\ orbitala
of the of‘ ;I Pti
“Very MIxed”-Metal (/l-dppm)3 ment
fragment
(or [ ReO?j’
bonding
and
cluster
electrons
dinatively
to the three
). In the MO
antibonding just
unsaturated
by selective
limiting
ionsaddat
dppm);(CO)~l.
I
o\:erlap
Analysis
although
are six
ot‘ this coor-
. but the latter
to two donor-acceptor
using
unoccupied
of I
the simplified
is weak.
the model
The
the Pt&lj-I)
six-electron
is cxpectcd.
cluster
[ RcPt;(/r-
[ RePtj(/l~-I)(I(-HIPCH7 The tilled
calculations
interaction donor
con-
[ReP~~(~~~-l)(/l-
niethod.7”
p, orbitals.
two
When
bonding
analogue
the EHMO
platinum
can XI as ;I wcnk
with
has only
bonds.
rhenium-platinLIm
of the interaction to give
the net bonding
Lmd that iodide
to form
and there
Reaction
[RePtj(/l-dppm);(CO);]+toyield
’ has been made with
frag-
combine
e symmetry.
MOS.~‘.““.“‘~‘~’
&. weaker
the Pt-,faceof
H~PCH~PH~)~(CO);]+ PHJ)~(CO)~]
aI +
donatin, ~7 to [Re(CO),]’ the interaction
pared to (RePti(jl-dppm)i(CO)J] Halide
with
of a [Re(CO);]’ orbitals
(53 CVE) with CO gives [RcPt~(/l-dppnl)~(CO)~]i The bonding may still be considered in terms
fragment
orbitals.
each
orbitals
the fragment
to rhenium.”
of 3 PI$jL-dppm)X acceptor
acceptor
fill the bonding
cluster
addition
vacanl
treatment.
MOs
which
135
Carbonyl Clusters
I>-orbital\
of that.
suggest
is covalent
in nalure
by using all its filled /I-orbitals
in bonding. In order EH
to study
calculations
bondin
have
OH)(CO)~(O)(PH;)JI acter
‘.“’
in the central
ripheral
g in IR~P~s(/~-O)~(~.~-OH)(CO)~(OR~O~)~~’C~~),I
been
carried
met&metal
on the model
Calculations
Re-Pt
bond.
bonds.
;uid the very unusual
out
indicak
with
data
su ggests
show
a degree
triple-bond
char-
due to the prcsencc
of’ pe-
;I very
short
of multiple
in [RePt.i(/r-O);(/l-OH)(CO)~(OReO;)(PCy;),I
‘.
IRePt5(/r-O);(/l-
at least ;I partial
complicarions
Structural
structure
clutcr
Re-Pt
metal-rnctal
‘. consistent
with
distance bonding
the thcorc~ical
result\.
IV CONCLUSION With
flexible
systematic tution
routes
into “very
investigations
generally
proceeds
with
not site-selective;
many is often
twined. Characterization which generally results spectroscopic
studies
of C-Ii&and
this involves of heterometallic
mixed”-melal
of their reactivity
one configuration
amplcs
AND
OUTLOOK clusters
and physical
metalloselectivily.
oE these complexes sufficiently
stable
in hand. the time is ripe fat properties.
Ligand
but the reactions are highly
fluxional.
so that mixtures
substi-
are l‘rcquen~lq and more
of’ isomers
than
are ob-
of these configurations has largely been crystallographic. in one configul-ation only being identified: comprehensive are needed
to identify
transformation
a heterometallic centers
all confgurations.
have been reported bond
in effecting
or fact.
This
likely
the transformation\.
A number
and. in almost indicates
of ex-
all instances. the importance
but mechanistic
studies
136
WATERMAN
to confirm
this remain
all instances.
ters with
“very
mixed”-metal
metal combinations
Re-Pt
of clusters
mixed”-metal
to stabilize catalysis
the resulting
in hcterogencouc clearly.
there
have been intensively
has yet to he fully
in controlling
optical
properties)
importance
ligand
exploited.
mobility
are almost
catalysis is great
untouched.
v ABBREVIATIONS
arphos
I -(diphenylarsino)-2-(diphenylphosphirl~))~th~ll~
C
coulometry
cod
I.5cyclooctadiene
CV
cyclic
CVE
cluster
DCP
d.c. polarography
voltammetry valence
electrons
dmat
3-(dimethylethylarnino)loluenc-C,
dmba
dimethyl
N
henzylamine-C’-N
dmpe
I .2-bis(dimethyIphosphino)ethanc
DPP
differential
dppa
bis(diphenylphosphino)acctylenc
pulse polarography
dPPC
I .2-hia(diphenylphosphino)cthanc
dwl ECE
bis(diphenylphosphino)mcthanc electrochemical-chemical-electl-o~ll~l~li~~ll
EEC
electrochemical-electrochemical-~helni~~ll
ETCS EXAFS
electron cxtendcd
tran~f‘cr-catalyzed x-ray absorption
synthesis tine structure
HDS
hydrodesulfurization
Pz TEM
pyrarolyl transmission
THF TPD
tetrahydrofuran
TPR XANES
temperature-ploframtned reduction x-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy
XY
XYlYl
electron
tcmperaturc-programined
only
microscopy desorption/decomposition
in In-
by clus-
(e.g., MO-Co
scope
properties
01
The sig-
electrochemical
properties These
in
for exploring
recently.
and tuning
physical
in the future.
APPENDIX:
unlikely
and that the fragments.
The physical
studied
and other
though
on the cluster,
have been dominated
with other metal combinations.
clusters
ofheterometals
of increasing
center
reforming);
nificance
nonlinear
possible.
elsewhere
cluster
effective
in petroleum
response netism.
occurs
unit is the favorable of”very
the potential
out; it i.s always
that the transformation
heterometallic vestigations HDS;
to be carried
et al.
(c.g..
are likely
magto be
“Very
Mixed”-Metal
We thank the Australian Research Council Poqr&mte Awrd. imd M.G.H. :icknowledpe\ Senior Research Fellowship.
Carbonyl
Clusters
137
t’or support. N.T.L. is the recipient of an Australian :m ARC Auhtralinn Rc\earch Fellowhip and :m ARC
Rl
(3) (3) I5 I (0) (7, (8) (9) ( IO) (I IJ ( I3 ( 13) ( IJ) ( IS) ( 16) f 17) ( IX) ( 19) (20) (2 I ) (22) (2% (2-t) (25, (26) (27) (18) (291 (30) (3 I J (32)
Srone. F. G. A. &w. (‘lwrr.. /,I/. U. Ei~,r/. 19X4, 22. X9. Vahrcnhwnp. H. C‘~urrwur.\ /JIO,;~. Clw~r. 1985, 4, 251. V;lhwnkanlp, H. &h: O~;~ouww/. Chw. 19X3, 22. 169. Mingos. D. M. P AX. (‘/w/u. Kc\. 1984, 17. 3 I I. Holf‘mnnu, R. ,I/I,~~,I\: c‘l/c/,/.. //I/. EC/. Fl,q/. 1982, 2/. I7 I I. Gtadfelter. W. L.: Geoffroj. G. L. iIth: O~,q0/fofrwr. Uwrr. 1981, lx. 207. Farrugia. 1,. J. In (‘~,,,r/‘,~/rc,,~ti~,~, O,;~r,fr~,/l~c,trr/lic, C/wri.\rv\~ II: Abel. E. W.: Stone. 1;. G A.: Wilkinwn, G.. Eda.: t’qwnon Prw: Oxford. 1994. Vol. IO, 0. 4. Chi. Y. In C‘or,~/,~~,he,r.\i~,eOl;~or~l,ff~ctrrIlic ~/~~wi.~f~~~II: Ahel. E. W.: Stow. F. G. A.: Wilkinson. (;.. Etly., Pergnmon PI-~\\: Oxtiwd. 199-I. Vol. 6. Ch. 3. Br-rice. M. I. J. O,~i’c/,r~~~wr. C/w/,r. 1983, 2-V. 417. Koherl\, D. A.: Gcot’froy. G. I,. In C.~,r/r/“.~,/rr,lti~,c 0,;9~,rllfr,rcto//;[, clw,,~i.\rr~: Abet. E. W.: Stone. F. G. A.: Wilhlnson, G. Edg.: Pcrgamwl Prcsh: Oxford, 1982. Vol. 6. pp. 701. C’owlock. M. <‘.: Sh:rplcy. J. R. c;wri/. (‘hcu~. /?<,I: 1995, I-l.?. XII. %pp;~, E.: Tiripicchio, A.: Brwwtein. P. (‘oo~r/. (‘/wu~. Kc\: 1985, 65. 2 IO. V;ihl-cnk:mq H. P~~IP /I/>/I/. C’/w,rr. 1989, hl. 1777. Clark. I). T.: Sutin. K. A.: McGlinchq. M. J. O,~f,,l~,,lic,r~,//ic,\ 1989, 8. 155. Sutin. K. A.: Kolih. J. W.: Mtekw. M.: Bouseard. P.; Sayer, B. G.: Quilliam. M. A.: Faggiwi, ii.: Lock. C. J. L.: McGlinchey. M. _I.: J;~ouen. G. O~~o,fl,,,rc~tc///i(,\ 1987, h, 339. Jcffcry. J. C.: Lawcnce-Smith, J. G. ./. O~;qr~~wwt. C‘lwr. 19X5, 280. C31. C’hercurl. M. J.: Chetcuri. P. A. hl.: Jefl?t-j. J. C.: hlilts. R. M.: Mitrpi-achachon. P.: Pichering. S. J.: Stow. F. G. A.: Wood\\;lrd. P. .I. (‘/~/JI. Sot. /I~//cjrt 7>0,,,. 1982. 699. Dunn. P.; Jcffery. J. C., Shet-wwd. P. ./. Ogwrwrw/. Clwur. 1986, .{I 1. C5S. Scou. I. D.: Smith. D. 0.: Went. M. J. ./. CI,c,ir. Sock.. /Ici/tr,,r T,.c/r~.s.19X9, 137.5. Jct’t’c~-y. J. (‘.: Rut/. M. 4.: Stone. F. G. A ./. C’/rr,u. .(‘.: C‘hcn. S.-N ; Warlf. X.: Sun. W-H.: Wang. H.-Q.: Y;mg. S.-Y. /‘i~/~lwt/nu~ 1996. 1.5, 2613. Miiltcr. hl.: Schachr. H.-T.: Fiwher, K.: tm\llng. J.: Ciiitlich. I?: V;lhrenknrnp, H. /rw,:$. Clwut. I’lm~idt~. R. P.; V&c-enkamp. H. O,:i’r,fior,,~,~r//lir~.v 19X7, 6,. 492. t3eurich. H.: Btumhot’w. R.: V~lhl-cnharnp. H. C/~/II. Hc,/: lY82, //5. 2409. l3lun~t~o~cr, R.: V:ihrenkanip. H. C’lwrir. /fc,/: 1986, I/Y, 6X3. Schachr. H.-T.: V:~hrcnhamp. t1. Ch~wr. Nc,,: 1989, 122. 7239. Mnni. I).: Sch;lchr, H.-T.: Powell. A.: V;ihrrnkamp. H. O,~[/lr,,rrrrrlr//;~,.\ 1987, 6. 1160. <‘urno\L. 0. J.: Kmnpf. J. W.; c‘urti\. hl. II.: Shen. J.-K.: Bnwto. F. ./. ;tw. (‘lwur. .%,c,. 1994. Ilh. 221.
138
WATERMAN
et a/
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
139
140
WATERMAN
et a/
“Very
Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl
Clusters
141
142
WATERMAN
et al.
“Very Mixed”-Metal
Carbonyl Clusters
143
ADVANCES
IN ORGANOMETALLIC
CHEMISTRY,
VOL. 46
Friedel-Crafts Alkylations with Silicon Compounds IL NAM JUNG
and BOK RYUL YOO Organosikon Chemistry Laboratory Korea Institute of Soence & Technology Seoul 130-650 Korea
I. II.
tnt1-oduction Characteristics of FI-~edel-Crd’t~ Alhylation\ with Silicon ~on~potmd~ A Renclivitm and Mechmim. K. Orientation and Iwmcr Diwihution\ ........... c Tran~~~lkyl~~tion\ and Reorientation\ ... I~ricdel-Cc-aft5 Alkylation of Areneh with AIh~~~ylchloro\ilane\ ............ ;I. Alkylation with Allylchlot-osilnnch H. AIhylntion uith Vi~~ylchloro~ila~~~~ .............
III.
IV.
Iso I.50 I .io 1x8 I65 165 I (1’) Il.3 17x I78
Ft-id-Ct-aft\ Alkylntiom of At-cneh A ith (C’hloroalhyl)\il~~n~~ ,\. Alhylation with (cr,~(‘hlol-oalhyI)~il~une~ .......... .......... I3 Alhyl;ltionwth tf~ichloroalh)l)\ila~~~~~ .......... c‘. Alhylation ~ith(Trichlol-onlcthyl)hilall~\ (‘onclu\ion and Prospect\. ................. Rcicrcncea. ........................
V.
I INTRODUCTION Friedel-Crafts quite tion
some
alkylations
titne
and
of benzene
by Friedcl pounds
with
and Crafts
much amyl
introduce pounds
work
halides.
was
substituents
first
described
In the following dcrivatives
done
have been studied
in this
field
amylbcnzene
Friedel-Crafts
onto
(phenylethyl)trichlorosilanc,
acids’-”
to produce
alkenes.
and the petrochetnical alkyl
by Lewis
has been
chloride
in 1877.‘,3
such as organic
laboratory
catalyzed
alkylations
and alkynes
industry
as valuable rings.’
with
6’1 (11. in
a monotner
that was hydrolyzed
reported
1953,
with
by Wagner
year, Petrov
organic
the Friedel-Crafts
for
routes
silicon
to
cotn-
the preparation
01‘
to polysiloxanea.’
alkylation
At that time. the silicon
com-
used in the
and established
Alkylation
the rcac-
was first reported
are now widely
aromatic
with (chloroalkyl)silanes.X
since
for
industry
of benzene was gt-ow-
ing rapidly and supplying monomers on ;I large scale by the direct synthesis ot organochlorosilanes, a process discovered by Rochow.” Alkylations with silicon compounds such as alkenylchlorosilanes’O~ I3 and (chloroalkyl)silanes’4~“’ were expected
to be a way
and a few articles Fricdel-Crofts
of preparin g useful monomers for polysiloxane products. on this topic were published by 1968. 10~20 Soon after, interest in
alkylations
with
silicon
compounds
faded due to the difhculties
of
145 Copyright ~12001 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. 0065-3055/01 $35.00
146
JUNG AND YOO
the syntheses
and separations
ofalkenylchlolosilancs”.”
and (chloloalkyl)chloro-
silanes.‘3~‘4 In 1993, a successful and ally1 chloride tives lalion
using
direct
synthesis’”
gave us a motive
allylchlorosilanes.‘”
of various
aromatic
and naphthalencs lysts. This
work
with
We hale compounds
This matic
rcvieu
will
describe
compounds
catalyzed
rainvestigated
allylchlorosilu~ies~f’
wilh
alkylation
the chemistry silicon
deriva-
the FriedclPCr;tfts
alky-
hcnrencs.
with
progrcs\
of this intcresling
01‘ Lewis
has been
ol‘ the Friedel-Craiis in particular
biphcnyls. acid
cata-
vinylchlorosil~uics~‘.~’ macle in the dc-
class of orgnosilicon
compounds.
metal
of benzcnc
iii the presence to alkylation
Substantial
of the chemis&y
h-om silicon
the alkylation
SLICK as substituted
has also been extended
and (chloroalkyl)chlorosilanes.‘” velopment
ofallyldichlorosilane
Ihr exploring
compounds.
alkylation
the aluminum
of arochloride
reactions.
II
CHARACTERISTICS OF FRIEDEL-CRAFTS WITH SILICON COMPOUNDS In this section. alkylation
the rcactivities
of aromatic
and the mechanism orientation
compounds
compounds
in the presence
01‘ the alkylation
reactions
and isomer
as the decomposition
oforganosilicon
distribution
and reorientation
and the insertion
reaction
chloride
be discussed. Lund associated
to chlorosilancs.
of alkylatcd
01‘ allylsilylation
for the FriedclKM’ts
of aluminum
will
in the products
ot‘ chloroalkylsilanes
as trunsalkylation
ALKYLATIONS
products and other
will
along
caMyst with
the
problems
such
Side reactions
such
also be mentioned.
related
reactions
will
be
explained.
A. Reactivities
and Mechanism
The reactivities ofalkenylsilancs in the presence of a Lewis acid vary depending upon the nature of substituents on silicon as shown in Table I. in the presence of aluminum chloIn the cast of alkylation usin g allylsilancs ride as a catalyst, allylsilanes the silicon react with aromatic to give alkylated
products.
2-q-
containin, o one or more chlorine compounds at room temperature I -silylpropanes,‘”
while
substituents
on
or below
0 C
allyltrimcthylsil~une
did
not give the alkylated product but instcad ditnerized to give the allylsilylation product. S-(trimcthylsilyl)-4(trimethylsilyltncthyl)I-pcntenc (Eq. ( I )).30 In the alkylation rcaction, the reactivity of allylsilancs increased as the number of chlorine
Friedal-Crafts
Alkylations
TABLE
atoms
on
the silicon
increased,
147
with Silicon Compounds I
but decreased as the number of methyl
go-oups
in-
creased. SIMe, .CI,,
(Friedel-Crafts
alkylatlon) ME!
AICI, Cl, Me, Si
t Me ,SIHMe Me (allylsilylation)
Alkylation with vinylchlorosilanes requires a relatively higher reaction tcmperature and prolonged reaction time. likely due to the lower stability of the carbocation intermediates. It is well known in the literature that aluminum chloride, a strong Lewis acid. is a very effective catalyst in Friedel-Crafts alkylations with silicon
148
JUNG AND YOO
compounds,7.“.l”~‘“.~“~‘S
chloride action
21 small
amomit
of anhydrous
aluminum
initiates
the reaction.3’
reactants with
In the Friedel-Crafts
catalyst.
air
the r-bond
,f7 to silicon.
bilizcd
This
by the electron-donating
/~-stabili~ation’~~~~ through
protonation
on the aromatic the catalytic
scribed
above.
facilitates
group carbon
the protonatcd g silyl
of aluminum
which
intermediates
silicon.
than protodesilylation. give higher
yields
The substituent activity
which effect
the aluminum one
compared
is similar
not react with
chloride-catalyrcd chlorine
the co-
is largely
retarded
of the clcctroncgativc
undergo
alkylation
show higher
fasta
reactivity
to that of allylsilanes.
01‘ methyl
atom
groups
xd
with
atom
However.
products.J’
allylsilancs
on the silicon
The rc-
on the silicon
increased.
to gi\,e alkylatcd
of arenes
substituents
chloride
;I Me;SiCI-AICI;
” “’ In contrast.
ol‘ chlorine
benrcne
alkylation
for al-
to allyltrin~ethylsilane.~”
as the number
as the number
dots
or more
intermediates
than
and
to the presence
due
cation
of vinylsilanes increased
but decreased
vinyltrimethylsilane
of alkencs:
cm
as de-
by hydrogen
gi\,cs propcne
is why ~~llylchlorosilancs
in the alkylation
of vinylsilancs
increased.
The
cation
on silicon:“‘This
groups
for allylchlorosilanes
col?jugation
m-,7
chlorine
on
which
initiates
[j-stabilization
ol‘allyltrin~ethyIsilane
a-
a cation
silylalkylated
tar allyItrin~cthylsilane
the allylsilylation
cation
due to less et’t’cctive atom(s)
I -silylpropyl
g methyl
:I\
is gcncrated
This proton
intcrmediatc
effective
chloride
catalyzes
to give
through
the
is sta-
Elcctrophilic
alkenylsilanes.
of the electron-donatin
m
ring generates
with
group
in the interacts
known
ion
of a proton.
alkylation
the re-
cation
conjugation
01‘the ally1 group.”
the regeneration
be more
can
because
lapse of the fi-silyl
0-7~
carbcnium
by deprotonation
is follo~~ecl with
chloride
silylethyl
which
the protodesilylation”‘.‘“.”
complex.
through
secondary
from present
ion intermediate
the intcrmediatc
stable
of the Friedel-Crafts
This
in the presence
silanes.
silyl
by the electron-donntin
lylchlol-osilunes
hydrogen
of the aromatic
01‘allylsilanea.
In the case
be stabilized
inevitably
ion on the n-bond along
cycle
from
with aluminum
resulting
to give the carhenium
the more
ring.’
ol’arenea
chloride
moisture
proton
because
of the terminal
compounds
with
The
occurs
and
tack of this carbcnium aromatic
chloride
of alkenylsilanes
carbon
alkylations
of hydrogen
In
or vinyl-
of silanes
are
required. The reactivity of(w-chloroalkyl)chlorosilanes for the alkylation ofarenes varies depending upon the length of the w-chloroalkyl group and the substituents on the silicon. Generally, the reactivity increases as the length ofthe alkyl group on the silicon of (try-chloroalkyl)chlorosilanes That
may
silanes
be mainly
and the aromatic
attributed
ring. and partly
The rearrangement of alkylating and chloride exchange between known.’
These
indicate
increases to the steric
from
methylene
hindrance
to the electronic
to propylene.“.”
between nature
the incoming
of the silyl group.
agent under Friedel-Crafts reaction conditions aluminum chloride and alkyl chloride are well
that the alkylation
proceeds
via the transitory
existence
of
Friedal-Crafts carbocations
resulting
Alkylations
149
with Silicon Compounds
from complexation
between
the alkylating
agent and Lewis
acid catalyst. AICI-, Brown
and Grayson
reported
chloride
was
in AICI;,
and first order
third
nucleophilic chloride ionization
The ing upon
of
acid catalysts.
differences
The ratio
indicates favors
group
of
bulk
probably
solely
by an
by the rate
of the concentration the alkylation.
777rt~7
COLIC
position
od7o
or alkylation-dealkylation
adducts
predominantly.
atoms.
the 777~~~7 isomer and/)at-ll isomers
ol
derived
the Lewis from
Considering
interaction
hindrance
the
benzenes.
increases
reason
from for the
The yield ol‘the
as the reaction of aluminum
are the kinetically r77m7
between
arising
may bc the principal
of the resulting
stable
of halogen-substituted
/MM
Steric
in the presence
or-t/w and /IO/X adducts more
to the steric
substituted
777~~~~7 isomer
temperatures
the thermodynamically
at
dependence
with
ally1 groups.
rates oithe
and that of the
or at higher
that the
at the
arc obtained with
products
pc77‘~7
of
deprnd-
on the benzene
products
of the products
and
mixture
varies
allylsilanes decreases as the size of No o,-r/7~~-~~lkyl~~ti~)r~products increases.“.”
and the incoming groups
products
due to the temperature
benzenes ring
an isomeric
of the substituents
reactions
to the
wfho
gives
of the alkylation
isomerination
in the alkylation
The alkylation
ortl7o
and steric
on the benzene
and isomeriLation
proceeded
undergoing
of isomeric
in the case of isopropylbenzene
decreases
long periods
order
chloride-aluminum
bc independent
compound
ratio
distributions
temperatures.
the size of the alkyl isomer
nature
and/or
the subatituents the isopropyl
polar alkyl
benzyl
first
rate determining
;I
be determined
henzenes
The
of monosubstituted
are obtained
a
that
If the reaction
should
and
of the aromatic
isomeric
formation
alkylation
on should
monosubstituted
the electronic reaction
isomer
chloride
/“/rlr-products.’
and
Different
different
component
indicates
in the alkylation.‘”
with
component,
and isomer Distributions
alkylation
o~~~/w. ~ttr,
This
the rate ofalkylation
reactions
in aromatic
chloride.
by the aromatic
propel-tics
B. Orientation
first order
in benzyl
of the alkyl
or nuclcophilic
R’AICI,
that the rate of alkylation
overall:
is involved
mechanism,
of ionization
ring.
order
attack adduct
+ RCI -
proceeds chloride.
ortho fat This
controlled
products
alkylated
benzcnes
product.
benzenes
with allylsilanes
the high
gives
electronegativities
ortho and of halogen
was expected to be the major product. The predominance of in the products indicates that the resonance effect of halogen
substituents lo the benzene effects. ‘(’ The isomerization
ring should be considered in addition of the products from the alkylation
is faster than that of the products
obtained
from
the reaction
to their electronic of alkylbenzenes
of halobenzenes.
150
JUNG AND YOO
C. Transalkylations Alkylation onto
and Reorientations
of benzene
the ring.
Di.
tri.
does not stop with and
higher
production
of higher
ing a molar
excess of benzene
The alkylation
alkylation
of benzene
of aluminum
chloride
the introduction
alkylation
compounds
product5
bc controlled
can
and by variations
with
temperature
than the 1.3.5trialkylated silylalkyl
compound
peralkylated
with
product.
less alkylated
gave no higher
due to higher
LIS-
parameter\.
alkylation
proclproducts
steric interactions
among
the
groups.
It is also from
with allylsilanes
by
in the presence
for 4 h gave along
The
extent
SOII~C
excess vinylmethyldichlorosilane
at room
the alkylation
to
group
produced.
in other experimental
hexakis[2-(methyldichlorosily1)ethyl]benzene.” ucts. However.
ot’ one alkyl
are also
well
known
one position
aromatic
ring to another
The intramolecular intermolecular processes
that
alkyl
to another through
alkyl
transfer
can
be transferred
ring
and intermolecularly
dealkylotion
alkyl-transfer
arc normally
groups
on the same is called is rcferrcd
reactions reorientation
cataly7,ed
intramolecul~lrlq from by Lewis
or isomerization
to as disl”up(~rtionation.
one acid.
and the
Reorientation
faster than disproportionation.
FRIEDEL-CRAFTS ALKYLATION OF ARENES WITH ALKENYLCHLOROSILANES This
section
hydrocarbons as
will
ally1 and vinyl.
on silicon
describe
The reaction
containing
will be discussed
alkylation
reactions
short chain alkenyl
of aromatic groups
in terms of the suhstituent
such effect
and the urene rings.
A. Alkylafion
with Allylchlorosilanes
Nametkin and co-workers with allylchlorosilanes in 2-(Aryl)propylsilanes (Ph-X:
the Friedel-Crafts
with alkenylchlorosilanes
tirst reported the presence
were obtained
from
the alkylation of aluminum
of benzene derivatives chloride as catalyst.”
the alkylation
of substituted
benzenes
X = H, Cl. Br) with allylsilanes such as allyldichlorosilane and allyltrichloI’-.” The yields ranged from 34 to 66% depending upon the substituents
i&lane. on the benzene ring, but information distribution was not reported.
concerning
reaction
rates and product
isomer
Friedal-Crafts After
succeeding
tncntal lung
silicon
Alkylations
in the direct
with
;I mixture
rt nl. reinvestigated
allyldichlorosilanes
synthesis
of allyldichlorosilnne
of ally1 chloride
the Friedcl-Crafts
in detail
151
with Silicon Compounds by reacting
and hydrogen
reactions
chloride
01‘benzene
ele-
in 1993.‘”
derivatives
with
(Eel. (2))
X = H, Me, Cl R’ =H.Me R’ = halldes. alkyl, Ph. OPh. etc
The results
ofthese
ot‘aluminum As shown
and
lation.
with
obtained electron
donating
lltcilitated
the t-eaction.JJ’.J”
ulkylation
reaction.
The reactivities
on the substituents
chlorine
tltoms
lane, readily
in the presence Among
with
ride catalyst
I‘rom 70 to 78%‘. The results deactivated
groups
on benzene
the electrophilic
l’or the alkylation ofbenzenc Allylchlorosilanes benzencs
chloride,
fI-otn 60
temper;ttures the alkygeneralI>
nature
of’ the
derivatives varied dehaving more than I