Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry
ADVISORY BOARD B. Feringa University of Groningen, The Netherlands E. Fukuzumi Osaka University, Japan E. Juaristi CINVESTAV-IPN, Mexico J. Klinman University of California, Berkeley C. Perrin University of California, San Diego Z. Rappoport The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel H. Schwarz Technical University, Berlin, Germany C. Wentrup University of Queensland, Australia
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Volume 42
Editor
J. P. RICHARD Department of Chemistry University at Buffalo, SUNY Buffalo, NY 14260-3000, USA
Amsterdam – Boston – Heidelberg – London – New York – Oxford Paris – San Diego – San Francisco – Singapore – Sydney – Tokyo Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
ACADEMIC PRESS
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier 84 Theobald’s Road, London WC1X 8RR, UK Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA First edition 2008 Copyrightr 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made ISBN: 978-0-12-374093-9 ISSN: 0065-3160
For information on all Academic Press publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com
Printed and bound in Great Britain 08 09 10 11 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Editor’s Preface
ix
Contributors to Volume 42
xi
Cycloaromatization reactions: the testing ground for theory and experiment
1
IGOR ALABUGIN, BORIS BREINER and MARIAPPAN MANOHARAN 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Introduction: bonds lost and bonds formed, or chemical bookkeeping 1 Cycloaromatization reactions: breaking p-bonds and breaking the rules 2 The diversity of cycloaromatization reactions 3 The relative role of s- versus p-effects at the early reaction stage 6 s-Effects on reactant stability 10 p-Effects on reactant stability 22 Transition state effects: communication of orthogonal orbitals in the transition state of radical-anionic cyclizations 23 8 Effects on product stability 27 9 Conclusion 31 References 31
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides – structure, properties, reactivity and biological activity
35
STEPHEN A. GLOVER 1 2 3 4 5 6
Introduction 35 Synthesis 39 Structure 43 Chemical reactivity 59 Biological activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides Conclusions 115 Acknowledgements 116 References 117
97
The Interplay between experiment and theory: computational NMR spectroscopy of carbocations HANS-ULLRICH SIEHL 1 Introduction 125 2 Alkyl and cycloalkylmethyl cations 126 v
125
vi 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
CONTENTS Vinyl cations 133 Cycloalkyl cations 142 m-Hydrido-bridged carbocations 144 Bicyclic and polycyclic carbocations 145 p-Stabilized carbocations 150 Heteroatom stabilized carbocations 156 Final remarks 158 Conclusions 160 Acknowledgments 160 References 160
Dynamics of guest binding to supramolecular systems: techniques and selected examples
167
TAMARA C.S. PACE and CORNELIA BOHNE 1 2 3 4
Introduction 167 Techniques 169 Examples of supramolecular dynamics studies 185 Conclusions 216 Acknowledgements 217 References 217
Mechanisms of oxygenations in zeolites
225
EDWARD L. CLENNAN 1 2 3 4
Introduction 225 Zeolites 226 Experimental considerations 230 Intrazeolite photooxygenations 232 Acknowledgement 261 References 262
Metal-catalyzed alcoholysis reactions of carboxylate and organophosphorus esters
271
R. STAN BROWN and ALEXEI A. NEVEROV 1 2 3 4 5
Introduction 271 Background theory 274 Titrations in alcohol 276 Metal ion alcoholysis and titration in alcohol 278 Transition metal ion and Ln3+ catalysts of transesterifications of neutral carboxylate and organophosphate esters 284
CONTENTS 6 Transition metal ion and La3+-catalysis of the alcoholysis of phosphate diesters 7 Conclusions 324 Acknowledgements 325 References 325
vii 308
Author Index
333
Cumulative Index of Authors
351
Cumulative Index of Titles
353
Subject Index
363
This page intentionally left blank
Editor’s Preface Volume 42-Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry The six chapters in this volume each focus on a significant topic in organic chemistry, and branch out to include themes from biochemistry, theoretical chemistry, and materials chemistry. The cyclization reaction of linear enediynes to form aromatic ring compounds has attracted the attention of organic chemists, because of the extensive electronic reorganization involved. There has been a tremendous increase in interest in the parent Bergman cyclization reaction since the discovery that this and related reactions play a central role in the in vivo activation of tumor-specific DNA cleaving agents. Igor Alabugin presents a lucid description of the interplay between experimental and theoretical studies to map the electronic reorganization that occurs as one moves from the linear enediyne reactant to the partly aromatic transition state for these complex reactions. The generation of carbocations in strongly acidic media, and the characterization of their structure by NMR in the 1950s was a breathtaking accomplishment that led to the award of the Nobel Prize in Chemistry to George Olah. Over the past 50 years NMR spectroscopy has evolved as the most important experimental method for the direct study of structure and dynamics of carbocations in solution and in the solid state. Hans-Ullrich Siehl provides an excellent review of computational studies to model experimental NMR spectra for carbocations. This chapter provides an example of how the fruitful interplay between theory and experiment has led to a better understanding of an important class of reactive intermediates. Supramolecular systems perform complex chemistry not accessible to their molecular components. These systems are extraordinarily difficult to study, because of the diverse set of skills required for the design, synthesis, characterization, and mechanistic analyses of a single supramolecular complex. The chapter by Cornelia Bohne focuses on a particularly valuable skill, and presents an overview of modern techniques used for kinetic analyses of reactions that occur in supramolecular complexes, with an emphasis on the characterization of fast reactions. Zeolites are aluminosilicate solids with cavities of dimensions comparable in size to small- or medium sized organic molecules. Many fascinating questions have been raised about the effect of confinement of organic reagents in these cavities on chemical reactivity. The progress towards answering these questions for oxygenation reactions in zeolites is reviewed in a chapter by Edward Clennan. ix
x
EDITOR’S PREFACE
The design of catalysts of the cleavage of RNA and DNA, and the determination of the mechanism for these cleavage reactions has considerable intellectual appeal, and the potential to produce cleavage reagents with applications in medicine. These studies are most-often carried out in water, with the ultimate aim of developing in vivo applications for particularly powerful catalysts. It has become clear in recent years that the activity of these catalysts is sometimes reduced in water compared with alcohol solvents with lower dielectric constants than water. This observation has proven useful in developing conditions for detoxification of organophosphorus nerve agents by alcoholysis reactions. The chapter by R. S. Brown summarizes the results of recent studies on the mechanism for metal-catalyzed alcoholysis reactions of carboxylate and organophosphorus esters. In the second chapter with a biological theme, Stephen Glover summarizes what is known about the structure, physical, spectroscopic, chemical and biological properties of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. The convergence of several functional groups at a single nitrogen results in interesting chemical properties for these compounds as well as in their mutagenic activity, which is a useful probe for drug-DNA interactions. John P. Richard University of Buffalo
Contributors to Volume 42 Igor Alabugin Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Fl 32306-4390, USA Cornelia Bohne Department of Chemistry, University of Victoria, PO Box 3065, Victoria, BC, V8W 3V6, Canada Boris Breiner Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Fl 32306-4390, USA R. Stan Brown Department of Chemistry, Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario K7L 3N6, Canada Edward L. Clennan Department of Chemistry, University of Wyoming, 1000 East University Avenue, Laramie, WY 82071, USA Stephen A. Glover School of Science and Technology, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia Mariappan Manoharan Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Fl 32306-4390, USA Alexei A. Neverov Department of Chemistry, Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario K7L 3N6, Canada Tamara C.S. Pace Department of Chemistry, University of Victoria, PO Box 3065, Victoria, BC, V8W 3V6, Canada Hans-Ullrich Siehl Institute of Organic Chemistry I, Ulm University, AlbertEinstein-Allee 11, D-89069, Ulm, Germany
xi
This page intentionally left blank
Cycloaromatization reactions: the testing ground for theory and experiment IGOR ALABUGIN, BORIS BREINER and MARIAPPAN MANOHARAN Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL, USA 1 Introduction: bonds lost and bonds formed, or chemical bookkeeping 1 2 Cycloaromatization reactions: breaking p-bonds and breaking the rules 2 3 The diversity of cycloaromatization reactions 3 4 The relative role of s- versus p-effects at the early reaction stage 6 5 s-Effects on reactant stability 10 Strain and antiaromaticity in cyclic enediynes 11 Control of strain through ligand–metal coordination 16 Steric assistance of ortho substituents 17 Control of steric repulsion with positively charged ortho substituents 20 Hybridization effects 21 6 p-Effects on reactant stability 22 7 Transition state effects: communication of orthogonal orbitals in the transition state of radical-anionic cyclizations 23 8 Effects on product stability 27 s-Effects 27 p-Effects 30 9 Conclusion 31 References 31
1 Introduction: bonds lost and bonds formed, or chemical bookkeeping Chemical reactions involve the reorganization of electron density in which bonds are broken and formed in accordance with the reaction mechanism. The energetic consequences of such reorganization are accounted for by the reaction thermodynamics. Unless a very weak bond is broken with a significant increase in entropy, bond breaking is thermodynamically unfavorable and leads to the formation of highly reactive intermediates: radicals and diradicals through bond homolysis, anions and cations through heterolysis, and carbenes as a result of a-elimination. On the other hand, bond formation is favorable and when a strong bond is formed, serves as a thermodynamic sink that often terminates a cascade of chemical transformations, thus balancing the thermodynamic checkbook or registering a profit. In a perfect world of balanced checkbooks, the bond breaking and bond forming processes are synchronized, as it happens (albeit not always perfectly) in concerted pericyclic reactions. Even when such synchronization is not perfect, unimolecular 1 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 42 ISSN 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(07)42001-9
r 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved
2
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
rearrangements are still rarely accompanied with a change in the number of chemical bonds. In other words, the number of chemical bonds generally is conserved.
2 Cycloaromatization reactions: breaking p-bonds and breaking the rules An interesting breakdown of the tendency for the conservation of chemical bonds occurs in the so-called cycloaromatization reactions1 (Scheme 1). In these reactions, a s-bond is formed at the expense of two p-bonds and, thus, the process leads to a net loss of one chemical bond that is intrinsically unfavorable thermodynamically. Formation of the new s-bond leads to ring closure, whereas the net loss of a bond leads to the formation of two radical centers, which can be either inside (the ‘‘endo’’ pattern in Scheme 1) or outside of the newly formed cycle (the ‘‘exo’’ pattern). Note that s-radicals are formed through the endo path, while exo-closures may produce either a s-radical when a triple bond is involved or a conjugated p-radical when the new bond is formed at the central carbon of an allene. The parent version of this process is the transformation of enediyne 1 into p-benzyne diradical2 (the Bergman cyclization), shown in Scheme 2. This transformation requires significant thermal energy to overcome the activation barrier and is endergonic. The endergonicity of the Bergman cyclization is not surprising and stems logically from the net loss of a bond in the product. What is surprising is that the energy penalty (DH) for this intrinsically unfavorable
a
X
a X
c
b X b
endo, endo
endo, exo c
c′
X
X
exo, exo bis-allene
exo, exo bis-alkyne
Scheme 1 Schematic representation of cycloaromatization reactions. Double lines correspond to the out-of-plane p-systems of a bis-alkyne reagent. Only orbitals of the in-plane p-system in the reactant and of new s-bond and radical centers in the product are shown explicitly.
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
3 H
. 2RH
1
. 2
H
Scheme 2 Bergman cyclization of (Z)-3-ene-1,5-diyne.
transformation is only 8–9 kcal/mol.3 This low value results from the aromatic stabilization of the product provided by the completely conjugated system of out-ofplane p-orbitals at each carbon of the enediyne system. Thus, even though the outof-plane p-array does not directly participate in the bond forming/bond breaking event, it is not a simple bystander in the overall process. Developing aromatic stabilization in the conjugated out-of-plane system plays an important role in deepening the potential energy well for the diradical product to the extent that this species can be trapped by external reactions such as H-atom abstraction or addition to a p-system. The goal of this review is to dissect the relative contributions of the two orthogonal p-systems in the most general sense and provide a clear and general analysis of electronic effects in the Bergman cyclization as they apply to and originate from these two different sources. We will outline the relative role of the two systems in defining the kinetics and thermodynamics of the parent Bergman cycloaromatization pathway, delineate factors that affect these systems separately and discuss ways to provide communication between the two orthogonal p-systems. This review will be selective rather than comprehensive since a number of excellent and detailed reviews are available on various aspects of the chemistry (and biochemical application) of cycloaromatization reactions in the recent literature: Rawat and Zaleski4 compared and contrasted geometric and electronic effects in thermal Bergman cyclizations to those of the recently developed metalloenediynes, while Basak and coworkers5 concentrated even more closely on the use of enediynyl ligands in chelation-controlled Bergman cyclizations. The Schreiner group6 reviewed the application of computational methods toward a variety of cycloaromatization reactions and Ko¨nig and coworkers7 provided a compendium of experimental results related to the electronic effects on the Bergman cyclization. Intricate details of biological activity of natural enediynes were most recently reviewed by Shen and coworkers,8 whereas medicinal utility of designed enediynes was expertly discussed by Jones and Fouad.9
3
The diversity of cycloaromatization reactions
Fig. 1 summarizes cyclizations of the two prototype molecules, (Z) hex-3-ene-1,5diyne and (Z) hept-3,5,6-triene-1-yne. In all of these processes, bonds are formed from in-plane p-orbitals in the presence of an orthogonal p-system. However, it is clear that the properties of the newly formed cyclic conjugated systems can be quite
4
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
a
a
b
b
Schreiner
Bergman c
d
d c
Schmittel
Myers-Saito
Fig. 1 Cycloaromatization reactions of (Z) hex-3-ene-1,5-diyne and (Z) hept-3,5,6-triene1-yne. X
X R
R′
R
R′
X = NH, O, S, PH, + NH2 , OH+, SH+, CH-, etc.
Scheme 3 Formation of 5-membered heterocycles through cyclization reaction.
different. A new aromatic system is formed only in the Bergman and Myers-Saito cyclizations, and thus, in a sense, only these two processes in Fig. 1 are bona fide cycloaromatization reactions. Note also that s,s-diradicals are produced from enediynes, whereas s,p-diradicals are formed from enyne allenes. The benzene ring is not the only aromatic moiety that can be formed in a cycloaromatization process and formation of other aromatic systems was considered as the driving force of new cycloaromatization processes. For example, Matzger (X ¼ S)10 and Schreiner11 investigated whether the 5-membered aromatic heterocyclic systems of pyrrole, thiophene, and furan can be formed in these processes (Scheme 3), while Alabugin12 (Scheme 4) and Rabinovitz13 (Scheme 5) investigated anionic species where cycloaromatization benefited (albeit to a different extent) from the aromaticity of the cyclopentadienyl anion. Whitlock et al.14 discovered a reductive cyclization of enediynes promoted by lithium naphthalenide that provides substituted fulvenes and suggested a dianionic mechanism (Scheme 6). However, even now it is still unclear whether the enediyne dianion is indeed the cyclizing species or whether the initially formed acyclic radicalanion cyclizes first to give a fulvene radical-anion which is further reduced by lithium to give the cyclic dianion. Aromaticity of the products is only one of the factors accounting for the efficiency of these cyclizations as evidenced by the discovery of a dianionic synthesis of nonaromatic 5-membered heterocycles by Tamao and coworkers who found that reduction of bis(phenylethynyl)dialkylsilanes with lithium naphthalenide resulted in formation of a cyclized product by endo–endo cyclization15 (Scheme 7). Under analogous conditions, cyclic 1,2-bis(silylethynyl)benzenes afford 1,4-dilithio-2,3-disylylnaphthalenes via dianionic endo–endo cyclization leading to the formation of a 6-membered ring (Scheme 8).16
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS F
5
F
F N
N F
+.
-.
F F N
F
hv
F F
F
F F
F
F F
F
N
F
*
F
F F
F
N
N
F
F
F
H R
R R
R
R = tetrafluoropyridinyl (TFP)
H
Scheme 4 Reductive C1–C5 cyclization of enediynes.
Δ
K, 2H I2
Scheme 5 Thermal and reductive cyclizations of cross-conjugated enediynes.
Along similar lines, Wenthold applied the radical-anionic idea to the Cope rearrangement,17 which can be considered a more saturated analog of the Bergman cyclization.18 The radical-anionic Cope rearrangement was found to have an inverted potential energy surface with the cyclic intermediate being more stable than the radical-anion corresponding diene. Consequently, one-electron reduction of 2,5-dicyano-1,5-hexadiene results in spontaneous cyclization under the experimental conditions. Certainly, the role of photochemical excitation may be displayed in different ways19 and even in those cases when no aromatic system is formed, topologically
6
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
D
1. Li / naphthalene 2. D2O D
Scheme 6 Dianionic cyclization of enediynes promoted by double lithium naphthalenide reduction.
Ph
Ph
Ph
Ph
lithium naphthalenide (4 equivalents)
Si R
Li
Li
Si
R
R
R
Scheme 7 Dianionic endo–endo cyclization of diethynylsilanes. Li
Si
Si
lithium naphthalenide Si
Si Li
Scheme 8 Endo–endo reductive cyclization of cyclic 1,2-bis(silylethynyl)benzenes.
similar cyclization photoreactions are still possible. A classic example involves the photochemical cyclization of diethynylmethanes discovered by Zimmerman and Pincock20 around the same time as the thermal Bergman cyclization was reported by Bergman. The reaction proceeded upon direct irradiation of the diyne in isopropyl alcohol or, alternatively, when triplet-sensitized by acetophenone or xanthone. As in the Bergman cycloaromatization, two hydrogen atoms are abstracted from a suitable donor (Scheme 9). Taken together these data suggest that the family of cycloaromatization reactions will continue to grow and new interesting transformations may be discovered in the future.21 Thus, understanding of general factors which can be used to control cycloaromatization process should be of significant value for organic chemistry.
4
The relative role of r- versus p-effects at the early reaction stage
Although data presented in the previous section illustrate the diversity of cycloaromatization reactions, most of the following discussion will concentrate on the Bergman cyclization – a reaction that has been studied intensively in recent decades due to its role in the mechanism of biological activity of natural anticancer antibiotics.8,9 We will take advantage of the large body of data produced by this
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
7
hν 2-propanol
Scheme 9 Photochemical cyclization of diethynylmethanes. Although this reaction is topologically analogous to the cyclization reactions discussed earlier, it does not lead to an aromatic product.
research and use this archetypal reaction to illustrate the general electronic factors involved in a typical cycloaromatization process. Since both in-plane and out-of-plane p-systems are involved, a clear dissection of their respective roles in the cycloaromatization process is beneficial for the analysis of electronic effects on reactivity. Galbraith et al.22 approached this problem by utilizing valence bond (VB) theory, which provided insight into the structural and electronic nature of the transition state and illustrated the role of the s- and p-frameworks. The dominant VB configuration in the enediyne was found to play only a small role in the p-benzyne diradical, while the role of the dominant VB configuration (accounting for the biradical) in the product was seemingly insignificant in the starting material. The avoided crossing of the energy curves of these two VB configurations leads to the transition state, but the changes in the electronic wave function and in geometry are non-synchronous. The transition state (TS) was found to be 80% product-like geometrically and 70% reactant-like electronically in an apparent violation of the Hammond postulate.23 This is a direct consequence of the high stabilization energy provided by the formation of the aromatic system, the development of which only has significance once the reaction approaches the product. Independently, Alabugin and coworkers utilized classic molecular orbital (MO) correlation diagrams for understanding cycloaromatization processes. The advantage of this approach is that it clearly describes changes accompanying the cyclization process at the level of individual MOs and allows comprehensive analysis of electronic reorganization that accompanies the cyclization processes including the relative roles of the two orthogonal p-arrays. As an example of the latter approach, let us analyze the MO correlation diagram for the Bergman cyclization of the parent enediyne given in Fig. 2. This diagram shows the transformation of MOs of the starting material to MOs of TS and the product. The most important change at the TS stage is the dramatic increase in the energy of HOMO-1 of the enediyne, which is paralleled by the decrease in the energy of LUMO+1 due to the transformation of these in-plane orbitals (bonding and antibonding respectively) into non-bonding MOs (radical centers). Destabilization of the HOMO-1 is the most dramatic energy penalty that the molecule has to pay to reach the TS. This effect is partially offset by the s-bond forming interaction that stabilizes HOMO-2 (in phase combination of the in-plane enediyne p-orbitals). Developing aromatic stabilization of the out-of-plane p-system lags behind the
8
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
A
S A
S
LUMO A
LUMO HOMO
S HOMO A S
A
S Reactant
TS
Product
Fig. 2 MO correlation diagrams for the Bergman cyclization (adopted from ref.24). Out-ofplane MOs are shown in black, in-plane MOs are shown in blue.
above changes but becomes progressively more and more important as the reaction coordinate approaches the p-benzyne product. The above correlation diagrams can be used to illustrate the relative timing of changes in the s- and the p-systems. It is obvious from Fig. 2 that at the TS stage the s-system is more involved in the electronic reorganization process and that changes in the out-of-plane p-system mostly occur after the cyclization TS is passed. This analysis eliminates description of the Bergman cyclization as a 6e electrocyclic reaction that involves the out-of-plane p-system (Fig. 3). The Bergman cyclization should be considered the first step of an asynchronous [2+2] cycloaddition, interrupted by the aromatic stabilization of the intermediate 1,4-diradical, or as a Cope rearrangement interrupted by aromatic stabilization of the TS.18
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
9
Fig. 3 Incorrect description of the Bergman cycloaromatization as a 6p-electrocyclic ring closure (top). A better description shown for comparison (below).
It is interesting to use MO correlation diagrams for a comparison of the two alternative cyclizations of enediynes (Fig. 4): the Bergman cyclization and the C1–C5 cyclization (Fig. 1b,a), investigated first computationally by Schreiner.25 In both these processes, a s bond is formed at the expense of the same two in-plane p-bonds in either an endo–endo (Bergman) or an endo–exo (C1–C5) fashion (Fig. 4). Not surprisingly, the changes in in-plane MOs are comparable in the two diagrams and consistent with these p-bonds being broken in order to form the new s-bond. In contrast, changes in the out-of-plane MOs are significantly different. In contrast to the Bergman cyclization where the enediyne highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) is strongly stabilized, such stabilization is small in the non-aromatic didehydrofulvene product of the C1–C5 cyclization. Another interesting difference is that the LUMO+2 of the reactant correlates with the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the product in the C1–C5 cyclization instead of LUMO+1. Such changes illustrate the different properties of the out-of-plane conjugated systems formed in the two processes (aromatic for the Bergman and non-aromatic for the C1–C5 cyclization). The above analysis illustrates why it is helpful to consider the enediyne moiety as two independent p-systems. As discussed above, the conjugated out-of-plane p-system of the reactant is smoothly transformed into the conjugate p-system of the product (e.g., the aromatic system of benzene) without an overall change in the number of bonds. We will refer to this group of electrons as ‘‘out-of-plane MOs’’ or simply as ‘‘the p-system’’. In contrast, the two in-plane p-bonds are transformed in a more drastic way to the new s-bond and a pair of radical centers. We will refer to this system of orbitals as ‘‘in-plane p-bonds’’ or as ‘‘the s system’’. Since the breaking p-bonds and the developing radical centers are orthogonal to the out-of-plane p-system and the aromatic system develops mostly after the system proceeds through the transition state, the activation barrier for the Bergman cyclization is relatively insensitive to effects in the p-system. This provides a challenge for the substituent control of such reactions: it is not always clear whether hyperconjugative and inductive s-effects are sufficiently strong to control these reactions efficiently. On the other hand, the well understood p-effects are usually indirect and they display themselves mostly in reaction thermodynamics.27 Due to the different role of s- and p-effects, we will separate the general description of electronic effects into s- and p-effects in this study. s-Effects include
10
I. ALABUGIN ET AL. LUMO+2 (reactant)
LUMO+1 (reactant)
H H
Energy
Energy
H
HOMO
H
HOMO
H H
Reaction cooordinate
Reaction cooordinate
Fig. 4 The crossings of in-plane and out-of-plane frontier MOs in the radical-anionic Bergman and C1–C5 cyclizations, respectively calculated at the B3LYP/6-31G** level. Adapted from reference26.
the in-plane p- and s-orbitals. We will analyze these effects (which can be either stabilizing or destabilizing) at the three reaction stages (reactants, TS, and products) separately. All three possibilities can have a significant effect on the reaction enthalpy and activation energy of the cycloaromatization reaction. The ability to influence the reaction at or near the transition state provides the most direct way to control the reaction rates but reactant stabilization/destabilization is also a viable approach. Effects on the products are indirect but can be readily understood using dissection of kinetic and thermodynamic contributions to the reaction barrier provided by the Marcus theory, an approach that we used in the analysis of other pericyclic reactions28 and radical cyclizations.29
5
r-Effects on reactant stability
In a seminal work, Koga and Morokuma suggested that the high activation energy of the Bergman cyclization is due to the strong electron repulsion between the
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
11
in-plane occupied acetylene p-orbitals.30 These authors also pointed out that the lower activation energy of the Myers-Saito cyclization can be attributed to the decrease in electron repulsion due to the transoid orientation of the interacting p-orbitals.31 Recently, we analyzed the role of electron repulsion relative to bond breaking and antiaromaticity effects on a quantitative basis using Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) analysis.24 Two other destabilizing factors were considered at the initial stage of the cyclization in addition to four-electron repulsion between the filled in-plane acetylenic p-orbitals – distortion/breaking of the acetylenic bonds as a result of their bending, and the fact that, at a distance of ca. 3 A˚, the in-plane p-orbitals become parallel and reach a geometry that resembles the antiaromatic TS of the symmetry forbidden [2s+2s] cycloaddition (vide infra).
STRAIN AND ANTIAROMATICITY IN CYCLIC ENEDIYNES
The effect of cyclic constraints that bring the two ends of the enediyne system closer together is extensively studied. This is not surprising because nature utilizes the higher reactivity of cyclic enediynes in the naturally occurring enediyne antibiotics. When the enediyne moiety is incorporated in a large cycle (more than 10 carbon atoms), the Bergman cyclization is not fast enough to proceed at physiologically relevant temperatures. In contract, enediynes in 9-membered cycles are too unstable to be isolated (unless stabilized by additional electronic effects, vide infra), whereas 10-membered enediynes cyclize within hours (Fig. 5, Table 1).32 Nicolaou and coworkers33 suggested a simple empirical criterion based on ‘‘the c–d distance’’ (the proximity of the terminal carbons of the enediyne moiety) as a measure of increased ring torsion, which is relieved when the compounds undergo the Bergman cyclization. Only below the ‘‘critical upper limit’’ (the c–d distance of 3.2–3.3 A˚), the cyclization is expected to proceed at a measurable rate at ambient temperature. More elaborate analysis incorporates the relative strain energies of the ground and
c (CH2)n d
c
OH
c
OH
c
OH
c
d
OH
d
OH
d
O O
d I
OH
II
III
O
IV
Fig. 5 Cyclic model enediynes used by Nicolaou to establish the critical distance model.
12
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
Table 1 Calculated c–d distances and stabilities of cyclic enediynes Compound
n
Ring Size
c–d Distance (A˚)
Stability
I II III IV
1 2 3 – – – –
9 10 11 10 10 10 10
2.84 3.25 3.61 3.20 3.29 3.34 3.42
Unknown t1/2 ¼ 18 h at 251C Stable at 251C t1/2 ¼ 11.8 h at 371C t1/2 ¼ 4 h at 501C t1/2 ¼ 2 h at 501C Stable at 251C
Cl
Cl
Fig. 6 Cyclization of the first isolable a 9-membered enediyne.
transition states.34,35 In the 11-membered system, the distance is only slightly larger (ca. 3.5 A˚), yet such enediynes are rather unreactive.36 Overall, 9-membered enediynes are usually too unstable to be utilized in the design of new anticancer drugs. An interesting way to overcome this limitation was shown recently by Jones and coworkers who utilized an electronic effect in a rare example of intentional deceleration of the Bergman cyclization (Fig. 6). Substitution of a hydrogen atom with a chlorine atom at the vinylic position of a 9-membered cyclic enediyne37 decreased the cyclization rate and allowed the first enediyne with a 9-membered ring to be isolated. Nevertheless, the half-life of this compound was found to be only 6 min at 313 K, corresponding to an activation barrier of o18 kcal/mol. An extensive computational analysis expanded the range of the c–d distances for reactive cyclic enediynes to 2.9–3.4 A˚.38 By comparing unsubstituted enediynes with dialkyl-substituted enediynes, it was found that the activation enthalpy is dependent on factors other than the c–d distance and that reactivity hinges on a subtle interplay of steric and electronic effects that accompany distortion caused by incorporation into a macrocycle. For example, since alkyl substituents stabilize acetylenic bonds to a greater extend than olefinic bonds,39 such substituents stabilize the starting material, thus increasing both the activation barrier and the reaction endothermicity. Despite the contribution of the above factors, it is clear that bending of the two alkyne moieties toward each other increases the energy of the system as illustrated by the three plots in Fig. 7.24 These plots illustrate the relation between the ring size and calculated cyclization parameters in more detail and dependence of the total energy of the system from the c–d distance. Interestingly, simple bending of alkyne moiety reproduced the effect of cyclic restraints reasonably well. A similar conclusion has been reached even earlier by Kraka and Cremer.40
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
13
35
Energy, kcal/mol
30 25
3
20 2
15 10
1
5 0 (4.50)
(4.00)
(3.50)
(3.00)
(2.50)
(2.00)
(1.50)
C1-C6 distance, Ang
Fig. 7 Internal reaction coordinate (IRC) computations for the Bergman cyclization of model enediynes.
It is clear that although initially the effect is relatively small and can be easily masked by other steric or electronic factors, its importance increases as the bending progresses. Where does the energy increase come from? Can we offer an electronic description to the phenomenological term ‘‘strain’’? A priori, one can consider such factors as four-electron repulsion of filled in-plane orbitals and distortion/breaking of the acetylenic bonds as a result of their bending. Fig. 8 illustrates that weakening of the triple bonds is only of minor importance at the early reaction stage: changes in the C1-C2 NBO p-bond orders (both in-plane and out-of-plane) at C1–C6 distances above 3 A˚ are negligible. Interestingly, even at the TS, the in-plane p-bonds are only 30% broken. This resilience of the acetylenic p-bonds toward bending agrees well with the observation that electronic changes in the Bergman cyclization lag behind the changes in geometry.22 Electron repulsion between the filled in-plane p-orbitals and decrease in the stabilizing p–p* interactions are more important for reactant destabilization and increased reactivity of cyclic enediynes. In particular, we found that the repulsive four-electron interaction between the occupied in-plane acetylenic p-orbitals is indeed the largest and the most important contribution to the ground state destabilization, in good agreement with the suggestion of Koga and Morokuma.30 This interaction increases continuously along the IRC path and accounts for the bulk of the energy increase in the early part of the reaction path. In contrast, the stabilizing p–p* interactions that lead to formation of the C1–C6 s-bond and to cleavage of the C1–C2 and C5–C6 p-bonds – the changes most directly associated with the Bergman cyclization – display a more complicated pattern. Their magnitude decreases at first, vanishes at the Nicolaou’s threshold and rapidly increases at distances shorter than 3 A˚.
14
I. ALABUGIN ET AL. R 1
πi(C1-C2)
0.95
Bond order
0.9
πo(C1-C2)
0.85 0.8 TS
0.75 0.7 0.65 (4.50)
(4.00)
(3.50)
(3.00)
(2.50)
(2.00)
(1.50)
C1-C6 distance, Ang
Fig. 8 The changes in the NBO p-bond order of in-plane (pi, circles) and out-of-plane (po, diamonds) acetylenic bonds along the IRC pathway for the Bergman cyclization of (Z)-hex-3-ene-1,5-diyne.
Due to the lack of increase in stabilizing p–p* interactions at the reaction stage where the destabilizing four-electron repulsive interactions increase steadily, the inward bending of alkyne moieites in unstrained enediynes leads to continuously developing reactant destabilization without any compensation from the increased C1–C6 bonding. Only in the 9-membered enediyne the decrease in the C1–C6 distance results in an immediate increase in the extent of C1–C6 s-bond formation. Fig. 9 illustrates that the two acetylenic systems become nearly parallel at C1–C6 distances close to 3 A˚ where the constructive overlap of the p-orbital with one of the p*-nodes is compensated by a destructive overlap with the other p*-node (Fig. 9, bottom). From a conceptual point of view, the properties of the in-plane p-system at the 3 A˚ threshold bear a striking resemblance to the interaction of the two p-bonds in D2h cyclobutadiene where the p–p* interaction is zero and the p–p repulsion is considerable, thus accounting for the extreme instability of this antiaromatic molecule.41 Even more relevant is a comparison with the TS of the symmetry forbidden thermal [2s+2s] cycloaddition (Fig. 10) which prompted us to call this region ‘‘antiaromatic’’.42 The ‘‘antiaromatic region’’ is not important for the reactivity of the parent enediyne because the activation energy is determined only by the energy difference between the reactant and the TS. However, for the cyclic enediynes in Fig. 7 in which the C1–C6 distances are 3.39 and 2.92 A˚, respectively, ‘‘antiaromaticity’’ of the reactant should be relevant to the reaction kinetics. In addition, the role of repulsion between the in-plane filled orbitals is accentuated by a parallel decrease in the attractive two-electron interaction between the p and p* orbitals which vanishes at the 3.2 A˚ distance between the terminal carbon atoms.
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
15
Fig. 9 NBO contours of orbitals involved into the in-plane p–p and p–p* interactions for the reactant (a), IRC point at 3 A˚ C1–C6 separation (b) and TS (c). Repulsive p–p interaction is shown on top. Bond-forming p–p* interaction is shown at the bottom.
H H
H H
H H
H H
Fig. 10 Comparison of the ‘‘antiaromatic region’’ (i.e., the in-plane p–p* interaction pattern at 3 A˚ C1–C6 distance) with the antiaromatic TS of the [2s+2s] cycloaddition.
This analysis confirms that the effect of cyclic constraints is not purely steric but also has an electronic component. Another aspect of this dichotomy is shown in Fig. 11 which illustrates the decrease in the energy gap between the frontier in-plane p-MOs. The decrease in the C1–C6 distance destabilizes the occupied MO where the interaction between the end orbitals is antibonding and, at the same time, stabilizes the empty MO where the p*-orbitals overlap constructively. As a result, the efficiency of the photochemical Bergman cyclization should increase and, indeed, the most efficient photo-Bergman cyclizations reported in the literature involve cyclic enediynes.43 Again, the analogy with interrupted [2+2] photocycloaddition is instructive.
16
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
Fig. 11 Comparison of the energy gap between highest occupied in-plane MO and lowest unoccupied in-plane MO in acyclic (left) and cyclic (right) benzannelated enediynes. Incorporation of the enediyne moiety into a cyclic structure simultaneously increases the energy of the occupied MO and lowers the energy of the unoccupied MO. CONTROL OF STRAIN THROUGH LIGAND– METAL COORDINATION
An elegant way to control both strain and electronics is to take advantage of metal coordination to an enediynyl ligand – a topic that has been reviewed intensively44 and, thus, will be discussed rather briefly here. The influence of metal complexation on enediynes can be divided into several aspects: It can work through either s-donor coordination or p-complexation, resulting in any combination of geometric changes (analogous to the change in c–d distance proposed by Nicolaou) or by their influence on the electronic environment of the enediyne moiety. Strain-based systems work the same way as the cyclic enediynes: they reduce the c–d distance in the molecule. The first example was provided by Buchwald and coworkers,45 who used metal complexation of a PPh2 substituted enediyne to produce a species with considerably lower activation barrier (compared to the noncoordinated enediyne) (Scheme 10). While in the unbound enediyne the c–d distance is 4.1 A˚, this distance is diminished upon metal complexation: 3.3 A˚ for Pt(II) and Pd(II), and 3.4 A˚ for Hg(II). The Pt and Pd species cyclize in the solid state at only slightly elevated temperatures, and give Bergman products below ambient temperature in solution. While the change in reactivity was attributed to the change in distance between the alkyne termini, an accelerating influence of the metal cannot be ruled out. Since both s acceptors and p donors at the alkyne termini are known to facilitate the Bergman cyclization, Zaleski and coworkers established a model46 in which the coordination of a Lewis acid (metal ion) would change the electronic environment in favor of diradical formation (Scheme 11). Metal coordination was assumed to accelerate the reaction by inductive effects. A comparison of the reactivity of the benzylated compound in presence of Mo was used to rule out any p influence on the acetylenes. Zaleski and coworkers47 later expanded upon this line of work by using tetradentate enediyne ligands, in which the reactivity could be modulated by metal complexation (Scheme 12). The advantage of tetradentate ligand systems is the fact that they help to avoid dimerization, and that with the right choice of metal (and therefore the right
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS PPh2
17 Ph2 P MCl2 P Ph2
MCl2 PPh2
Ph2 P MCl2 P Ph2
Δ Pt: 61°C Pd: 81°C
Scheme 10 Metal coordination activates enediynes by drastically reducing the distance between the acetylenic carbons. S
SK
S
SK
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S S
[MoCp2Cl2], CHD, 60°C 30 min, 40 %
S S
S Cp Mo S Cp
Ph [MoCp2Cl2], CHD
no reaction
60°C, THF/MeOH Ph Ph
DMSO, CHD, 180 °C
S
S
24 h, 60 %
S
S
Ph
S
S
S
S
Ph
Ph
Ph DMSO, CHD Ph
180 °C, 24 h
S DMSO, CHD, 120°C Mo Cp Cp 5 h, 15% S
no reaction
S S
S Cp Mo S Cp
Scheme 11 Model systems illustrating enediyne activation through metal complexation.
coordination geometry), tuning of both the c–d distance and electronic effects is easily accomplished.
STERIC ASSISTANCE OF ORTHO SUBSTITUENTS
An additional way to use strain for control of reactivity is steric assistance. This effect can be easily introduced through a choice of appropriate ortho substituents in benzannelated enediynes (Scheme 13). Whereas activation energies for the neutral para substituents lie within a range of only 0.6 kcal/mol,48 the presence of ortho-NO2, NH2, CHO, CF3, and syn-OMe groups results in large changes in the activation energy (Fig. 12).49 Depending on the substituent, three different factors account for these changes: steric assistance (decrease in steric destabilization in TS), extra stabilization of the TS, and decrease in TS stabilization. In particular, the NO2, CF3, syn-CHO, and syn-OMe groups were predicted to decrease the activation energy for Bergman cyclization by destabilizing reactants through steric repulsion between the ortho-substituent and the in-plane acetylenic
18
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
S
S N
Δ
N M
Mn+
S
N
−Mv+
N
S
N
S
N
S
Scheme 12 Tetradentate enediyne ligands used to achieve enediyne activation by metal complexation while avoiding dimerization at the metal.
Repulsion or Attraction X
X
H
X
.
Heat
H-donor
. H +
X = H, F, Cl, CH3, CN, CF3, OH, NO2, CHO, OCH3, NH2, NH3
Scheme 13 Bergman cyclization of enediynes bearing ortho-substituents. H
R
H
H
H
O
H
H
R
33
o-OMe(a,e)
o-OMe(a,s)
o-Me
p-OH
o-OH(a) o-Cl
32 o-CN
p-NO2
p-CN
R2 = 0.9631
30
p-CHO
p-NH2(p) p-OMe p-Me
p-CF3 p-Cl
H O
o-NH3
0.015
0.02
0.025
H
H
o-CHO(s)
0.03
H
o-OMe(s,s) O H H
o-CHO(a)
o-NO2
27 0.01
p-NH2(np) o-NH2(np)
+
28
p-
o-CF3
29
o-NH2(p)
o-OH(s)
o-F
31 p-NH3
O
o-OMe(s,e)
0.035
0.04
0.045
0.05
Fig. 12 Correlation between the calculated activation energy of the Bergman cyclization and the product of natural charges at the terminal acetylenic atoms of benzannelated enediynes. Only para substituents obey the correlation. Adapted from reference49.
orbitals. This interaction becomes less significant in the TS when the acetylene moiety is bent away from the ortho-functional group. As a result, the TS and the product are destabilized to a lesser extent than the starting material and the activation barrier is decreased through the classic steric assistance mechanism.50 The steric nature of this effect is clear from the comparison with the respective para
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
19
isomers. For example, the ortho-nitroenediyne is less stable than the para isomer by 5.8 kcal/mol at B3LYP/6-31G** level because of the steric repulsion discussed above. The difference in stability decreases to 2.8 kcal/mol in the TS and to 2.0 kcal/ mol in the product accounting for the 3 kcal/mol decrease in the cyclization barrier and 3.8 kcal/mol decrease in reaction endothermicity (Fig. 13). Sterically compact ortho substituents such as Me, OH, anti-OMe, F, Cl, and CN destabilize the ground and transition states to a similar degree. As a result, changes in the activation energy are minor. The net effect of these substituents on the cyclization rate is similar to that of the para substituents, and the corresponding computational data fit well into the correlation in Fig. 12.49 Steric compression of enediyne moiety by ortho substituents is further illustrated in Fig. 14, which clearly shows that steric destabilization is accompanied by decrease in the distance between carbons C1 and C6. These computational predictions have been tested experimentally. Kinetic measurements confirmed that both ortho-NO2 and ortho-CHO substituents substantially decrease activation energies for the Bergman cyclization supporting earlier computational predictions.51 Ortho substitution also allows one to control other steps in the cycloaromatization cascade. For example, intra-molecular hydrogen-atom (H-atom) abstraction from the ortho-OCH3 group effectively intercepts the p-benzyne intermediate in the Bergman cycloaromatization of 2,3-diethynyl-1-methoxybenzene before this 30 TS
2.2 2.8
25
Repulsion O N+
O
20
15
10
P
1.2 2.0 8.1 6.6
24.1 30.9 12.3 10.4
20.9 27.9
R
5 5.4 5.8 0
-5
Fig. 13 The steric assistance mechanism for the ortho-effect. Energy profile for the para-isomer is given in dotted lines whereas data for ortho-isomer are shown in solid lines. Calculations were performed at the BLYP/6-31G** (in bold) and B3LYP/6-31G** levels. P stands for products, R stands for reactants. Adapted from reference49.
20
I. ALABUGIN ET AL. 4.25
H
C1-C6 distance in ortho-enediyne, Å
4.2
anti-CHO
4.15 syn-CHO
4.1 4.05
NO2 y = -0.0478x + 4.1961
4
R2 = 0.9778
3.95 3.9 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
δE(para-ortho)Reactant, kcal/mol
Fig. 14 The correlation between C1–C6 distance and relative energies of ortho and para isomers of substituted benzannelated enediynes.
intermediate undergoes either retro-Bergman ring opening or external H-atom abstraction. This process leads to the formation of a new diradical and renders the cyclization step essentially irreversible.52
CONTROL OF STERIC REPULSION WITH POSITIVELY CHARGED ORTHO SUBSTITUENTS
Since four-electron repulsion is the dominant factor in the reactant destabilization, any structural perturbation that either increases electron repulsion in the reactant or decreases the electron repulsion in the TS will decrease the activation energy for the cyclization. One way for placing an accelerating substituent in direct spatial proximity to the in-plane p-orbitals is to use appropriate ortho substituents in benzannelated enediynes. It was shown that ortho substituents exert a large effect on the cyclization rate and proposed that this observation can be used for the design of pH-sensitive enediynes.49 The acid-catalyzed Bergman cyclizations are interesting because cancer cells are more acidic (pH 5.5) 53 than normal cells (pH 7.5).54 Thus, the significant increase in reactivity upon protonation can be used in the design of tumor-specific DNA cleaving agents.55 Table 1 provides examples of amino enediynes which become much more reactive toward the Bergman cyclization upon protonation on nitrogen because the presence of a positively charged ammonium moiety alleviates the p–p repulsion of the in-plane p-orbitals. The computational results given in Table 2 illustrate that acceleration of the Bergman cyclization by protonation of a spatially close amino group is a general phenomenon. The accelerating effect of ammonium groups is transmitted mainly through space, and there are several promising structural classes of amino enediynes with a wide range of basicity and reactivity which can be activated through protonation.
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
21
Table 2 Calculated energetics in kcal/mol for the Bergman cyclizations of protonated and unprotonated aminoenediynes Protonated Enediynesa
+
NH3
st ec
st ec
+
NH3
+
NH3
syn anti
Neutral Amines
DE6¼
DH6¼
DG6¼
DEr
DE6¼
29.2 28.4
28.6 27.1
29.7 29.1
10.6 11.7
32.3
30.3 30.2
29.6 29.3
31.3 31.1
9.6 9.2
31.5
25.5 29.9
24.6 28.7
26.2 30.4
10.0 10.2
27.2
a
st, staggered; ec, eclipsed. a The reaction barriers for the Bergman cyclization of corresponding neutral amino enediynes.
Interestingly, both donor (syn-OMe) and acceptor (NO2) substitution can increase the accelerating effect of an ortho ammonium group when the steric interference with the above substituents ‘‘pushes’’ the adjacent acetylene moiety toward the other acetylene group, increasing the C1–C6 bonding. This is an example of an interesting cooperating effect between two ortho-substituents further illustrated in Fig. 15.
HYBRIDIZATION EFFECTS
As a direct consequence of Bent’s rule,56 carbon compounds with a significant amount of s-character in their bonds to an electronegative element, e.g., fluoroalkynes, are unstable. Thus, reactions which involve change in hybridization at a carbon atom bearing such an acceptor can be promoted when the amount of s-character at the reactive atom decreases. The role of rehybridization in a variety of chemical and supramolecular processes has been extensively analyzed and reviewed recently.55,58 An illustrative example of how rehybridization can be used to control the Bergman cyclization is provided by substituent effects at the alkyne termini of enediynes. This effect in cycloaromatization chemistry was first studied by Schreiner and coworkers, who found dramatic acceleration of the Bergman cyclization upon
22
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
O
O
Me
+
NO2
NH3
NO2
NH3
+
NH3
NH3+
NO2
O
+
Me
Ea=25.6
Ea=25.5
Push-push
Ea=30.8 Pull-pull
Ea=22.6
Me
Ea=25.7
Push-pull
Fig. 15 Predicted cooperative effects on activation energies (in kcal/mol) at the B3LYP/ 6-31G** level for model enediynes (‘‘push’’ and ‘‘pull’’ denote through-space repulsive (steric) and attractive (H-bonding) interactions of ortho-substituents with in-plane p-orbitals of an adjacent acetylene moeity).
introduction of s acceptors at the terminal carbons of (Z)-1,5-hexadiyne-3-ene.59 In particular, cyclization of the enediynes with terminal fluoro-substituents was predicted to have the lowest barrier and be significantly exothermic. A subsequent experimental study found that the reverse reaction (retro-Bergman ring opening) in this system is endothermic, thus confirming the earlier computational predictions.60 In contrast, the computational work of Jones and Warner found that acceptor substituents positioned at the ene part of the enediyne moiety decelerate the reaction61 in full accord with the earlier experimental results of Jones and coworkers. Rehybridization provides a unified explanation for these two sets of results.57 Since the transition state is reactant-like22 and TS and reactant have the same dominant Lewis structures, application of the NBO method for the analysis of the transition state is straightforward. The hybrid orbital ‘‘h’’ that connects the terminal acetylene carbon to the substituent undergoes the most dramatic rehybridization (sp-sp2 or 48%-33% s-character) in the Bergman cyclization of enediyne I in Fig. 16. According to Bent’s rule, terminal fluorine substitution destabilizes the reagent by preventing this hybrid orbital from attaining its ‘‘natural’’ sp-hybridization (in other words, it is unfavorable to direct a hybrid orbital with 50% of s-character toward a strong acceptor). As a result, the hybrid h has only 36–37% of s-character in the reactant – a dramatic effect of F substitution! However, the differences in hybridization decrease in the TS, illustrating that the destabilizing effect of electron acceptor in the reactant is removed by rehybridization in the TS (Fig. 17).
6
p-Effects on reactant stability
As mentioned in the preceding section, p-effects on the stability of the reactants are going to be rather subtle in thermal cyclizations, since the determining factor in the activation barrier for this reaction is the formation of the bond between in-plane orbitals. One way to accelerate this reaction would be to destabilize the reactant p-system. The challenge is in designing a system where the reactant destabilization is not transferred to the transition state and product as well. An elegant approach to
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS TSRBC
X=H X=F TSBC
41.0
36.59 21.0
35.6
17.1
27.9
31.2 3.3 3.9
0
3.3 X
X
X
X
X ED1
30.07
23.88
F
F
23.22 22.94 ED1
BZY
F
F
s-char of C, %
Energy, kcal/mol
23
TSBC
BZY
TSRBC
ED2
X ED2
Reaction coordinate
(a)
(b)
Reaction coordinate
Fig. 16 (a) Comparison of potential energy profile for the formal Cope rearrangement of 3,4-difluorohexa-1,5-diyne-3-ene with that of (Z)-hexa-1,5-diyne-3-ene, (b) Rehybridization in the C(F) bond along the reaction path. ED1 ¼ 3,4-difluoro-hex- 3-ene-1,5-diyne; ED2 ¼ 1,6-difluoro-hex-3-ene-1,5-diyne; BZY ¼ difluoro-1,4-didehydrobenzezne; TSBC ¼ the transition state for the Bergman cyclization; TSRBC ¼ the transition state for the retro Bergman cyclization. 1.212 I
1.265
4.480 Ea = 31.2 1.210 F
I
4.452
1.978 ΔEr = 3.3 1.268 F 2.052
Ea = 24.0
F
F ΔEr = -17.1
F
F
Fig. 17 The Bergman cyclizations of parent and fluoro-substituted enediynes with the triple bond and the incipient bond lengths and the activation energies calculated at the BS-UB3LYP/6-31G** level.
achieve such selective reactant destabilization is described in the next section which describes systems with selective destabilization of reactants and efficient communication between the p and s arrays.
7 Transition state effects: communication of orthogonal orbitals in the transition state of radical-anionic cyclizations In order to activate remote substituent effects in cycloaromatization reactions, two orthogonal p-systems need to find a way to communicate. At first glance, this task
24
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
seems impossible due to the lack of overlap between orthogonal orbitals. Even though small deviations from planarity remove strict p-orthogonality and mix the two p-systems, the mixing is insignificant. However, the mixing can be amplified due to the inverse proportionality of orbital interaction energy to the energy gap between the interacting orbitals. As a result, even a small spatial overlap can be amplified dramatically if the energy gap between filled and unfilled interacting orbitals approaches zero, or, in other words, when filled and unfilled MOs cross. Such MO crossings occur in cycloaromatization reactions as a direct result of the bondforming interaction that transforms the in-plane p-orbitals into an s-bond and a pair of non-bonding MOs (two radical centers) as shown in Fig. 18. Consequently, in the vicinity of the TS the highest occupied in-plane MO (HOMO-1) is destabilized to the extent that it becomes the new HOMO, whereas the unoccupied in-plane MO is stabilized to become the LUMO. In other words, in the reactant both HOMO and LUMO correspond to out-of-plane orbitals but, at shorter C1–C6 or C1–C5 distances, the frontier MOs are localized at in-plane non-bonding (radical) orbitals. LUMO+2 (reactant)
LUMO+1 (reactant)
H H
SOMO (reactant) SOMO (product)
Energy
Energy
SOMO (reactant)
SOMO (product)
H
H
H H
Reaction coordinate
Reaction coordinate
Fig. 18 Crossings of in-plane and out-of-plane frontier MOs in radical-anionic Bergman and C1C5 cyclizations (crossings for photochemical, dianionic and radical-cationic cyclizations involve the same MOs but differ in the number of electrons).
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
25
In this analysis, the activation barrier for both C1–C6 and C1–C5 cyclizations of enediyne radical-anions can be described as the avoided crossing between the out-ofplane and in-plane MOs (configurations). One-electron reduction populates the out-of-plane LUMO of the enediyne moiety. At the TS (the crossing), the electron is ‘‘transferred’’ between the orthogonal p-systems to the new (in-plane) LUMO. This effect leads to the accelerated cyclization of radical-anions of benzannelated enediynes, a large sensitivity of this reaction to p-conjugative effects of remote substituents and the fact that this selectivity is inverse compared to that of the Bergman cyclization. Similar electronic effects should apply to the other reductive cyclization reactions that were mentioned in the introduction. In the case of the Bergman cyclization and the C1–C5 cyclization of enediynes, both the activation barrier for cyclization as well as the thermodynamics of the reaction became more favorable upon one-electron reduction compared to the thermal counterparts. The cyclization barrier drops by up to 12 kcal/mol (in the C1–C5 cyclization) and the process becomes exothermic (as opposed to the endothermic cyclizations of the neutral counterparts) as illustrated in Fig. 19 and Fig. 20. Fig. 21 explains the accelerating effect of donor substituents on the radicalanionic Bergman cyclization. Donor substituents destabilize the radical-anion of the starting material while p-acceptors have an opposite effect. However, these effects (both the stabilization by acceptors and the destabilization by donors) are significantly decreased in the product where the extra electron is transferred in the in-plane system and, thus, direct conjugation is not present anymore. Since the crossing point between the two states representing the starting material and the reactant is the cyclization TS, the energy difference between starting material and the crossing point is the activation energy. When the starting material is destabilized but the TS is not, the activation energy is low. When the starting material is stabilized, but . E, kcal/mol
46.1 40.1 .
H 34.0
31.2 29.5 . . .−
3 3.3
11.9 -
.
H .
-16.7
-
Fig. 19 The reaction energy profiles for thermal (on the left) and radical-anionic (on the right) C1–C6 and C1–C5 cyclizations of the parent enediyne computed at the B3LYP/ 6-31G** level.
26
I. ALABUGIN ET AL. E, kca l/mol 45.1 40.4
.
28.5 .
H
24.8
13.4 .
.
23.1
-.
6
0.3
H
-
.
. -18.8 -
Fig. 20 The reaction energy profiles for thermal (on the left) and radical-anionic (on the right) C1–C6 and C1–C5 cyclizations of the parent benzannelated enediyne computed at the B3LYP/6-31G** level.62 Ea, kcal mol-1
X X
X=NH2 LUMO (diradical)
X=H X=NO2 R LUMO (enediyne)
X
SOMO (radical-anion)
SOMO (radical-anion)
P
X Reaction coordinate
Fig. 21 The crossings of in-plane and out-of-plane frontier MOs in the radical-anionic Bergman cyclizations. A similar effect is observed in the C1–C5 cyclization.
stabilization is lost in the TS, the activation energy is high. Although new in cycloaroamatization chemistry, this approach is just another example of the classic ‘‘reactant stabilization’’ and ‘‘reactant destabilization’’ concepts often utilized in enzyme chemistry.
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
8
27
Effects on product stability
At this stage, both s- and p-effects are important. However, the influence of the p-effects dramatically increases. In fact, it is the formation of a p-aromatic system in the cycloaromatization reactions that makes these processes energetically feasible.
s-EFFECTS
Interaction of non-bonding electrons The non-bonding electrons can be coupled either directly through space (TS) or indirectly through antibonding (s*) bridge orbitals (through bond (TB) coupling). The most well-recognized of the s-effects is the TB interaction of the two radical centers in p-benzynes and related molecules.63 A well-recognized effect of this interaction is displayed in the lower reactivity of p-benzyne in H-abstraction reactions relative to that of the phenyl radical.55 TB interaction, which is absent in monoradicals,54 provides an additional 3–5 kcal/mol of stabilization energy to the p-benzyne-type diradicals. Since this stabilizing energy is lost with the first H-atom abstraction, the p-benzyne diradicals are less reactive and more selective than simple phenyl radicals. Interestingly, coupling between the non-bonding orbitals is dramatically enhanced upon one-electron reduction of p-benzynes or didehydrofulvenes, possibly because the TS interaction adds to the TB coupling.12b
Zwitterionic products Full -polarization in diradicals can give rise to zwitterionic products. First examples were studied in detail by Carpenter and coworker who investigated solvent effects on rates and product distribution in Myers-Saito cyclizations.64 Polar solvents and substitution patterns that stabilize either positive or negative charges (or both) favor the zwitterionic products. For example, the presence of a dimethylamino group leads to stabilization of cations and isolation of pyrrolo-quinolines, rather than pyrido-indoles from eneyne-carbodiimides, as reported by Wang and coworkers (Scheme 14).65 Even though these products are not formed by a diradical mechanism, these polar species may still have relevance to DNA damage, because of the potential alkylating ability of their electrophilic (cationic) sites. Another example of a zwitterionic product of a cycloaromatization reaction was given by Kerwin and coworkers. Their ‘‘skipped’’ (aza)enediynes rearranged to yield (aza)eneyne-allenes that subsequently cyclized under addition of methanol (in a byproduct), which is consistent with a partitioning between a diradical and a zwitterionic reaction pathway (Scheme 15).66
28
I. ALABUGIN ET AL. Me2N
Me N
+ N
Me2N
NPh
NH Ph isolated in 84% yield N
N Ph N thermolysis in presence of 5 eq. trimethylsilyl chloride
Me2N
R = H, Me
Me2N
N
N
Ph
N N R not formed
Scheme 14 Zwitterionic Myers-Saito-type cyclization from reference65. H
X R
+
X
H H
R
-
X
methanol
OMe
R
R = Ph, H X = N, CH
Scheme 15 Formation of a methanol adduct in cyclization of eneyne-allenes, formed from ‘‘skipped’’ enediynes.
Strain increase: effect on the photochemical Bergman cyclization A very interesting experimental observation of Jones et al. illustrates a different effect of strain on the efficiency of photochemical Bergman cyclizations.43d Variations in the size of the cycle which does not incorporate the whole enediyne system, but only the vinyl part of the enediyne moiety (in contrast to the previously discussed data) affect the yield of the cycloaromatized product. Initially, an increase in the ring size leads to an increase in yield (Scheme 16). Increased ring strain in the C-4 (n ¼ 2) and C-5 (n ¼ 3) products may be a reason for lower yields (and longer irradiation times). The effect of strain on cyclizations is well-documented outside of cycloaromatization chemistry, as well. For example, annealing of a cyclopentene ring leads to a decrease in the cyclization rate and an inversion of the 5-exo/6-endo selectivity for all three patterns shown in Fig. 22. Interestingly, after reaching the maximum at the 6-membered cycle, the yields drop again. This decrease in efficiency occurs despite the appreciable reduction in the distance between the terminal acetylenic carbons relative to the 6-membered analogue. Here, the efficiency may simply be a function of how photochemical excitation is distributed in the reactive excited state. Calculated enediyne geometries suggest the cyclization is more efficient for those enediynes where the terminal phenyl groups are rotated outside of the enediyne plane (Table 3). Rotation of the aromatic ring out of the enediyne plane forces the aromatic p-orbitals to overlap with the in-plane p-orbitals of the enediyne system as illustrated
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
29
H H H
n(H2C)
Ph
hν 2-propanol
n(H2C)
Ph H
yield n=2; 0% n=3; 13% n=4; 22% n=5; 16% n=6; 14%
Scheme 16 Model enediynes used in photochemical Bergman cyclization.
15
16
14
Fig. 22 Radicals used to study the effect of strain on the efficiency of 5-exo and 6-endo-dig cyclizations. Table 3 C1–C6 (‘‘c–d’’) distances in model enediynes Distance (A˚)
Ring Size n¼2 n¼3 n¼4 n¼5 n¼6
4.941 4.284 4.018 3.947 3.893
R
R R
R R
R Aryls are "in plane", the π-systems are orthogonal
R R Aryls are "out-of plane", the π-systems are in conjugation
Fig. 23 Effect of orientation of the aromatic ring on the conjugation with the enediyne system.
in Fig. 23. This involves the in-plane p-orbitals in a more extended conjugated system and decreases the energy gap between frontier in-plane orbitals. The key role of the in-plane p-system suggests that the excitation should be delivered to this system in order for the cyclization to proceed efficiently.
30
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
p-EFFECTS
The most obvious effect on cycloaromatization, as the name implies, is the formation of an aromatic system. By delocalizing electrons in an aromatic ring, the product gains a high degree of stability, which is reflected in the small endothermicity of the Bergman cyclization and the exothermicity of the Myers-Saito cyclization. Since the Schmittel and Schreiner cyclizations are not true cycloaromatization reactions per se, they do not have the beneficial effect of the formation of an aromatic system and are therefore much are more endothermic than their counterparts. Product stabilization is much more pronounced when the enediyne or ene-yneallene starting materials are not already part of an aromatic system, since forming an aromatic system constitutes a much higher degree of stabilization than expanding an aromatic system (Fig. 24). Conjugation of the radical center provides additional stabilization to the p-radical formed by the Myers-Saito and Schmittel cyclizations. Both the Schmittel and the Schreiner cyclization do not formally produce an aromatic system, Schleyer, Schreiner and co-workers compared these reactions to the Bergman and Myers-Saito cyclization using standard aromaticity criteria, such as magnetic susceptibility exaltations, aromatic stabilization energy (ASE), and nucleus independent chemical shift (NICS). Interestingly, the degree of cyclic electron delocalization found in these systems is comparable to that found in benzene. The effect of benzannelation however is smaller in magnitude, and for Schreiner cyclization it has an opposite effect leading to a slight decrease in reaction endothermicity.
Bergman
Erel.: 25.2 (Erel.: 24.6)
Erel.: 8.5 (Erel.: 14.4)
Erel.: 41.0 (Erel.: 37.2)
Erel.: 41.3 (Erel.: 37.4)
Erel.: 18.7 (Erel.: 19.5)
Erel.: -9.7 (Erel.: -4.5)
Erel.: 30.0 (Erel.: 25.2)
Erel.: 12.9 (Erel.: 11.9)
Schreiner
Myers-Saito
Schmittel
Fig. 24 Relative energies for the transition states and radical products for the different cyclization pathways (benzannelated systems in parentheses).
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
31
These results, of course, contrast the significant effect of benzannelation in radical-anionic cycloaromatization reactions discussed above12 where not just the formation of a new aromatic cycle but also restoration of aromaticity in the previously existing cycle occurs at the same time in the cyclorearomatization process.
9
Conclusion
The great potential utility of cycloaromatization reactions is matched by the inherent complexity of electronic changes that accompany these processes. This complexity stems from the presence of two orthogonal p-arrays, both of which undergo significant changes during the reactions. The asynchronous nature of s- and p-effects opens numerous opportunities to control these processes and will continue to provide challenges for experimentalists and theoreticians alike. Even though some of the general factors controlling the Bergman cyclization are applicable to newly discovered cycloaromatization reactions, new phenomena such as communication of orthogonal orbitals in radical-anionic, radical-cationic and dianionic cycloaromatizaton and cyclorearomatization will continue to stimulate future development of this interesting field.
References 1. We are omitting reactions such as the trimerization of acetylene on transition metal catalysts, even though they could be considered cycloaromatization reactions 2. Bergman, R.G. (1973). Acc. Chem. Res. 6, 25 3. Roth, W.R., Hopf, H. and Horn, C. (1994). C. Chem. Ber. 127, 1765; Wenthold, P.G. and Squires, R.R. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116, 6401; Davico, G.E., Bierbaum, V.M., De Puy, C.H., Ellison, G.B. and Squires, R.R. (1995). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117, 2590 4. Rawat, D.S. and Zaleski, J.M. (2004). Synlett 393; Bhattacharyya, S. and Zaleski, J.M. (2004). Curr. Topics Med. Chem. 4, 1637 5. Basak, A., Mandal, S. and Bag, S.S. (2003). Chem. Rev. 103, 4077 6. Schreiner, P.R., Navarro-Vazquez, A. and Prall, M. (2005). Acc. Chem. Res. 38, 29 7. Klein, M., Walenzyk, T. and Ko¨nig, B. (2004). Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun. 69, 945 8. Galm, U., Hager, M.H., Van Lanen, S.G., Ju, J., Thorson, J.S. and Shen, B. (2005). Chem. Rev. 105, 739 9. Jones, G.B. and Fouad, F.S. (2002). Curr. Pharm. Design 8, 2415 10. Lewis, K.D., Wenzler, D.L. and Matzger, A.J. (2003). Org. Lett. 5, 2195; Lewis, K.D., Rowe, M.P. and Matzger, A.J. (2004). Tetrahedron 60, 7191 11. Kawatkar, S.P. and Schreiner, P.R. (2002). Org. Lett. 4, 3643 12. (a) Alabugin, I.V. and Kovalenko, S.V. (2002). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124, 9052; (b) Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 4495 13. Eshdat, L., Berger, H., Hopf, H. and Rabinovitz, M. (2002). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124, 3822; Treitel, N., Eshdat, L., Sheradsky, T., Donovan, P.M., Tykwinski, R.R., Scott, L.T., Hopf, H. and Rabinovitz, M. (2006). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128, 4703 14. Whitlock Jr., H.W., Sandvick, P.E., Overman, L.E. and Reichardt, P.B. (1969). J. Org. Chem. 34, 879 15. Tamao, K., Yamaguchi, S. and Shiro, M. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116, 11715 16. Yamaguchi, S., Miyasato, M. and Tamao, K. (2003). Chem. Lett. 32, 1104
32
I. ALABUGIN ET AL.
17. Wenthold, P.G. (1999). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 2, 2357; Hammad, L.A. and Wenthold, P.G. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 10796 18. Navarro-Va´zquez, A., Prall, M. and Schreiner, P.R. (2004). Org. Lett. 6, 2981 19. Clark, A.E., Davidson, E.R. and Zaleski, J.M. (2001). Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 2650 20. Zimmerman, H.E. and Pincock, J.A. (1973). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 95, 3246 21. Schreiner, P.R. and Bui, B.H. (2006). Eur. J. Org. Chem. 5, 1162 22. Galbraith, J.M., Schreiner, P.R., Harris, N.R., Wei, W., Wittkopp, A. and Shaik, S. (2000). Chem. Eur. J. 6, 1446 23. Leffler, J.E. (1953). Science 117, 340; Hammond, G.S. (1995). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 77, 334 24. Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2003). J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 3363 25. Prall, M., Wittkopp, A. and Schreiner, P.R. (2001). J. Phys. Chem. 105, 9265 26. Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 4495 27. The only known exception is the fascinating class of radical-anionic and dianionic cyclizations where p-effects can be activated through MO crossings 28. Alabugin, I.V., Manoharan, M., Breiner, B. and Lewis, F. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 9329 29. Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2005). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 12583; Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2005). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 9534 30. Koga, N. and Morokuma, K. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 113, 1907–1911 31. For theoretical analysis of the Myers-Saito cyclization, see: (a) Engel, B. and Hanrath, M. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 6356–6361; (b) Schreiner, P.R. and Prall, M. (1999). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 8615–8627 32. In very small macrocycles (7- and 8-membered rings), cyclization is not expected, despite the very short c–d distance of of 2.5 and 2.6 A˚, respectively. The ring strain in the cyclized product would simply be too high 33. Nicolaou, K.C., Smith, A.L. and Yue, E.W. (1993). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90, 5881 34. Snyder, J.P. (1989). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 111, 7630 35. Magnus, P., Carter, P., Elliott, J., Lewis, R., Harling, R., Pitterna, T., Bauta, W.E. and Fortt, S. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114, 2544 36. Wandel, H. and Wiest, O. (2002). J. Org. Chem. 67, 388 37. Plourde, G.W., Warner, P.M., Parrish, D.A. and Jones, G.B. (2002). J. Org. Chem. 67, 5369 38. Schreiner, P.R. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 4184 39. This notion has been the subject of a recent controversy, which was resolved 40. Kraka, E. and Cremer, D. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116, 4929 41. Jafri, J.A. and Newton, M.D. (1978). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 100, 5012 42. One can argue that the presence of the in-plane C3-C4 bond and the 6-electron out-ofplane p-system renders the whole molecule non-antiaromatic. Therefore, we use the quotation marks for the term ‘‘antiaromatic region’’. However, use of this term is justified because the lack of the p–p* stabilization along the strong p–p repulsion provides an appealing analogy to antiaromatic molecules 43. (a) Funk, R.L., Young, E.R.R., Williams, R.M., Flanagan, M.F. and Cecil, T.L. (1996). J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 118, 3291; (b) Kaneko, T., Takanashi, M. and Hirama, M. (1999). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 38, 1267; (c) Choy, N., Blanco, B., Wen, J., Krishan, A. and Russell, K.C. (2000). Org. Lett. 2, 3761; (d) Jones, G.B., Wright, J.M., Plourde II, G., Purohit, A.D., Wyatt, J.K., Hynd, G. and Fouad, F. (2000). J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 122, 9872 44. Rawat, D.S. and Zaleski, J.M. (2004). Synlett 393; Bhattacharyya, S. and Zaleski, J.M. (2004). Curr. Topics Med. Chem. 4, 1637; Basak, A., Mandal, S. and Bag, S.S. (2003). Chem. Rev. 103, 4077; as wel l asKo¨nig, B. (2000). Eur. J. Org. Chem. 12, 381 45. Warner, B.P., Millar, S.P., Broene, R.D. and Buchwald, S.L. (1995). Science 269, 814
CYCLOAROMATIZATION REACTIONS
33
46. Bhattacharyya, S., Pink, M., Baik, M. and Zaleski, J.M. (2005). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 44, 592 47. Bhattacharyya, S., Dye, D.F., Pink, M. and Zaleski, J.M. (2005). Chem. Commun. 5295; For a review on metal-bound enediynes, see: Rawat, D.S. and Zaleski, J.M. (2004). Synlett 3, 393 48. Kim, C.-S. and Russell, K.C. (1998). J. Org. Chem. 63, 8229; Choy, N. and Russell, K.C. (1999). Heterocycles 51, 13; Kim, C.-S. and Russell, K.C. (1999). Tetrahedron Lett. 40, 3835; Kim, C.-S., Diez, C. and Russell, K.C. (2000). Chem. Eur. J. 6, 1555 49. Alabugin, I.V., Manoharan, M. and Kovalenko, S.V. (2002). Org. Lett. 4, 1119 50. Eliel, E.L., Wilen, S.H. and Doyle, M.P. (2001). Basic Organic Stereochemistry, p. 459, Wiley-Interscience, New York 51. Zeidan, T., Kovalenko, S.V., Manoharan, M. and Alabugin, I.V. (2006). J. Org. Chem. 71, 962 52. Zeidan, T., Manoharan, M. and Alabugin, I.V. (2006). J. Org. Chem. 71, 954 53. Osinsky, S.P., Levitin, I.Y., Bubnovskaya, L.N., Ganusevich II, Sigan, A.L., Tsykalova, M.V. and Zagorujko, L.I. (1999). Exp. Oncol. 21, 216; Tannock, I.F. and Rotin, D. (1989). Cancer Res. 49, 4373 54. Kraka, E. and Cremer, D. (2000). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 8245 55. Hoffner, J., Schottelius, J., Feichtinger, D. and Chen, P. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 376–385 56. Bent, H.A. (1961). Chem. Rev. 61, 275 57. (a) Alabugin, I.V. and Manoharan, M. (2007). J. Comp. Chem. 28, 373; (b) Additional examples of rehybridization are analyzed in Alabugin, I.V., Manoharan, M., Buck, M. and Clark, R.J. (2007) Theochem, 813, 21–27 58. For an analysis of rehybridization effects in supramolecular chemistry, see: Alabugin, I.V., Manoharan, M., Peabody, S. and Weinhold, F. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 5973; Alabugin, I.V., Manoharan, M. and Weinhold, F. (2004). J. Phys. Chem. A 108, 4720 59. Prall, M., Wittkopp, A., Fokin, A.A. and Schreiner, P.R. (2001). J. Comp. Chem. 22, 1605 60. Wenk, H.H., Balster, A., Sander, W., Hrovat, D.A. and Borden, W.T. (2001). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 40, 2295 61. Jones, G.B. and Warner, P.M. (2001). J. Am. Chem Soc. 66, 2134 62. The starting points for both C1–C5 and C1–C6 cyclizations are characterized using C1–C6 distances to stress that starting point for both cyclizations is the same enediyne radical-anion. However, for transition states and products of C1–C5 and C1–C6 cyclizations, the respective incipient bond length (C1–C5 or C1–C6) was used as the reaction coordinate 63. (a) Hoffman, R., Imamura, A. and Hehre, W.J. (1968). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 90, 1499; Hoffman, R. (1971). Acc. Chem. Res. 4, 1; (b) Paddon-Row, M.N. (1982). Acc. Chem. Res. 15, 245; (c) Gleiter, R. and Schafer, W. (1990). Chem. Res. 23, 369–375; (d) Brodskaya, E.I., Ratovskii, G.V. and Voronkov, M.G. (1993). Russ. Chem. Rev. 62, 975 64. Hughes, T.S. and Carpenter, B.K. (1999). J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 2, 2291 65. Li, H., Petersen, J.L. and Wang, K.K. (2003). J. Org. Chem. 68, 5512 66. Feng, L., Kumar, D., Birney, D.M. and Kerwin, S.M. (2004). Org. Lett. 6, 2059
This page intentionally left blank
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides – structure, properties, reactivity and biological activity STEPHEN A. GLOVER School of Science and Technology, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia 1 Introduction 35 General 35 Background 37 2 Synthesis 39 3 Structure 43 General 43 Theoretical structures 44 X-ray structures 47 Spectroscopic properties 51 4 Chemical reactivity 59 Solvolysis studies – AAl1 reactivity 60 Nucleophilic substitution reactions – SN2 reactivity 70 Thermal decomposition reactions 90 5 Biological activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 97 Mutagenicity in the Ames Salmonella/microsome assay 97 Anticancer activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 115 6 Conclusions 115 Acknowledgements 116 References 117
1
Introduction
GENERAL
The properties of amides are determinants of the structure and characteristics of a wide range of molecules and particularly those of peptides and proteins.1 Universally, amides and amide linkages are characterised by a nitrogen that is largely sp2 hybridised and in which the lone pair resides in a 2pz orbital. As a consequence there is a strong interaction between the amide nitrogen and the carbonyl. While this has traditionally been described as a resonance delocalisation involving I and II in Fig. 1a, contemporary views strongly favour a third resonance contributor III in which there is s back donation from carbon to the sp2 hybridised nitrogen.2,3
35 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 42 ISSN 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(07)42002-0
r 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved
36
S.A. GLOVER
According to Wiberg, the p donation from nitrogen is best described as a Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO)—Lowest Unoccupied Molecular Orbital (LUMO) interaction in which case there is little charge transfer to oxygen since this contributes weakly to the LUMO (Fig. 1b).2 Either way, the predominant interaction is between the nitrogen lone pair and the carbon of the carbonyl bond and the double bond character is the prime cause of both planarity at nitrogen and the restricted rotation about C–N bonds in amides. Properties of hydroxamic esters largely mirror those of amides. The attachment of one oxygen to the amide nitrogen does not dramatically alter the degree of pyramidality at nitrogen or the extent of lone pair delocalisation/interaction with the carbonyl.4–8 A good number of amides are not planar at nitrogen owing to twisting due to steric interactions (Fig. 2a),9–17 configurational properties that close the angles at nitrogen (Fig. 2b)11,18–20 or lactams that lock the nitrogen lone pair out of alignment with the carbonyl 2pz orbital (Fig. 2c).21–24 The result in all cases is a disconnection between the nitrogen lone pair and the amide carbonyl. In these cases, the amide nitrogen tends towards sp3 hybridisation and the C–N bonds assume single bond character. All these amides constitute the class of ‘‘twisted amides’’ although in Fig. 2b, twisting may be the result of lone pair disconnection rather than the cause thereof. However, they can all best be regarded as N-acylamines. Kirby’s configurationally rigid 1-azaadamantan-2-one 1 is the extreme of this class.21–23,25 The nitrogen properties of this lactam are clearly amine-like while the carbonyl is ketonic in all respects. Twisted amides undergo rapid hydrolysis or reduction22,25–30 and exhibit enhanced reactivity.31
O C
O C
N
O C
N
COLUMO O N
R C
NHOMO
N
I
II
III
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1 (a) Resonance and (b) HOMO–LUMO interaction in simple amides.
R3
O
O R3 C
C N
R N
N
R2
O
R1 (a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 2 (a) A sterically twisted amide; (b) an angularly constrained amide; (c) a twisted lactam.
37
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
N
O
R3
O O
N H 2
1 a b c d
Y X
R2
O C
C O
N O
R1
3
X=Y=OR X=Cl,Y=OR X=OR,Y=NR2 X=Y=Halogen
The author has identified another class of amides that possess pyramidal nitrogens but are devoid of any steric or configurational imposition that results in enforced twisting about the amide linkage. ‘‘Anomeric amides’’, are defined as amides that bear two heteroatoms at the amide nitrogen 2.32 There is ample evidence of pyramidality in N,N-dioxoamides 2a, N-halo-N-oxoamides 2b and N-aminoN-oxoamides 2c. N,N-dihaloamides 2d may well fall into the same class. In all of these, the amide nitrogen responds to the collective electronegativity of the substituents by rehybridising from sp2 to sp3. This enables an electron density distribution that better satisfies the electron demand of the nitrogen substituents, X and Y. The configurational change results in smaller angles at nitrogen and reduced p-character of the lone pair orbital with attendant disconnection from the amide carbonyl as evidenced by spectroscopic properties, radically reduced amide isomerisation barriers, reactivity patterns and theoretical attributes.6,32–36 This review will cover the structural, physical, spectroscopic, chemical and biological properties of the most widely studied class of these anomeric amides, the N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 3. These not only exhibit all the structural and spectroscopic characteristics of anomeric amides 2, their reactivity patterns embrace a range of reactions at the amide nitrogen that in many respects parallel those at a saturated carbon.37–46 In addition, they are mutagenic as well as DNA damaging agents that have anticancer capability.37,38,40,46–50 To date nearly a hundred of these have been synthesised in our laboratory while, recently, a range of urea and urethane analogues have also been reported.51–53
BACKGROUND
Aromatic amines 4 are metabolised in vivo by cytochrome P450 mediated oxidation to phenolic and hydroxylamine derivatives 5 and 6. Phase II conjugation of the latter with PAPS or acyl transferase results in formation of the sulfuric or acetic acid esters 7. Nitrogen conjugation to give the N-acetyl analogues is also possible (Scheme 1).54–65 These metabolites have been shown to produce arylnitrenium ions 8 under solvolytic conditions and McClelland and Novak have demonstrated, respectively
38
S.A. GLOVER OH NH2
NH
NH2
P450
Ar
Ar
Ar
5
6
HO 4
Acetylase (PAPS) N Ar
H (Ac)
Ar
8
(SO3–) OAc N H (Ac)
7
Scheme 1.
by Laser Flash Photolysis (LFP) and azide clock methods, that the lifetimes of these nitrenium ions are discriminating; those aromatic amines that produce long-lived arylnitrenium ions are generally more carcinogenic and the rates of hydration of these ions in water are critical.66–85 Arylnitrenium ions are highly delocalised and steric hindrance to hydration at the 4-position seems to be critical in determining the lifetimes in solution. Nitrenium ions from carcinogenic 4-biphenylamine 9, N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene 10, 2-naphthylamine 11 and benzidine 12 have been shown to have much longer lifetimes than other, less harmful arylamines and their reaction with guanine to afford C-8 (G-C8) adducts 13 is the primary cause of mutations of DNA.86–89 O
NH2
NHAc
9
Ar
N
(Ac)H
N
NH2 NH2 11
NH2 12
NH
N
10
N
N H2
Deoxyribose 13
In 1984, we demonstrated that N-alkoxy-N-acyl nitrenium ions 15 could be generated by the reaction of N-alkoxy-N-chloroamides 14 with Lewis acids such as Ag+ and Zn2+ and used these to form heterocycles by intramolecular aromatic substitution reactions (Scheme 2).90 In this manner, several novel N-acyl-3,4-dihydro-2,1benzoxazines 16a and N-acyl-4,5-dihydro-(1H,3H)-2,1-benzoxazepines 16b were made. Subsequent work91,92 and that of Kikugawa93–96 produced numerous syntheses involving alkoxynitrenium ions including formation of natural products.97–99 In a seminal theoretical paper, we showed that, at the Modified Neglect of Differential Overlap (MNDO) level, phenylnitrenium ions 17 as well as NH2, PH2,
39
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES (CH2 )n O N Cl
(CH2 )n O N
Lewis acids R' O
(CH2 )n O N
R' O
14
R' O
15
16 a n=2 b n=3
Scheme 2.
SH and OH-substituted nitrenium ions 19a–d and their N-formyl analogues have singlet ground states with a similar degree of p-overlap with the electron-deficient nitrogen (p-bond orders 40.9). Ab initio calculations (HF/6-31G*) on heteroatomsubstituted nitrenium ions showed that all the heteroatoms strongly stabilised the singlet state relative to their triplet state.100 Extensive double bond character in hydroxynitrenium ion was also determined by Schwarz and coworkers.101 N
H (CHO)
N
R X
N
H (CHO)
19 17
18
a X=NH2 b X=PH2 c X=SH d X=OH
For phenylnitrenium ions, we85 and others 72,78,102–104 have computed that there is extensive positive charge delocalisation into the aromatic ring and arylnitrenium ions are best described as 4-imino-2,5-cyclohexadienyl-1-yl carbenium ions 18. From appraisal of their respective resonance stabilisation, arylnitrenium ions and alkoxynitrenium ions should form with similar facility. On account of the fact that N-acetoxy-N-acetyl arylamines 7 are penultimate carcinogens in the metabolism of aromatic amines, N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 3 were designed to test their potential as DNA-damaging agents.
2
Synthesis
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 20 are synthesised from N-chlorohydroxamic esters 22 by replacement of chlorine by a carboxyl group (Scheme 3). Initially we employed silver acetate in anhydrous ether to make N-acetoxy derivatives.47 However, most have been made using sodium carboxylates in dry acetone by analogy with Finkelstein chemistry.5,38–40,42,43,46,48,49,105 The reactions can be monitored conveniently by thin layer chromatography and N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides generally
40
S.A. GLOVER
R1O
OAc (COR2) N O
H N 3
R 21
i ii
R1Br
Cl R1O
N
O
ButOCl 1
3
H N
O
R O
R 22
O
KO
R3 20
R1ONH2
3
R 23
Et3N
Cl
O 3
R 24
i AgOAc anhydrous diethyl ether ii NaOAc (NaOCOR2) anhydrous acetone
Scheme 3.
oxidise to brown spots on silica plates. Yields vary depending upon the stability of the N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamide to hydrolysis but in most instances, conversion is clean, or minor impurities (such as the corresponding alkyl esters) can be removed using centrifugal chromatography. Scheme 3 outlines synthetic strategies for the introduction of a range of substituents on the amide, alkoxyl and acyloxyl side chains. Hydroxamic esters 23 are readily synthesised from potassium salts of hydroxamic acids 21 according to Cooley et al.7 or by condensation of the corresponding acid chloride 24 with an alkoxyamine. This group has synthesised a wide range of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides that can be categorised as follows:
1. N-Acetoxy-N-alkoxybenzamides 25, with variation in the alkoxyl side chain 2. N-Acetoxy-N-butoxyarylamides 26, with variation on the benzamide ring 3. N-Acetoxy-N-arylmethyloxybenzamides 27, with variation on the benzyloxyl side chain 4. N-Aroyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 28, with variation on the ester side chain 5. N-Acyloxy-N-butoxyamides 29, with variable amide and acyloxyl side chains 6. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyacetamides 30, with variable alkoxyl and acyloxyl side chains 7. N-Benzoyloxy- and N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 31–33, bearing one or more para-tert-butyl substituents 8. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 34 and 35 where two amide groups are tethered by alkoxyl or acyl chains 9. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 36 and 37 of a specialised nature
41
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
O
O R
Bu
N O AcO
O
X
N O AcO
AcO
25
26
27
a R=Et b R=Pr c R=Bu d R=Pentyl e R=Octyl f R=Pri g R=Bui h R=Penti i R=But j R=2-butyl
a X=H b X=MeO c X=Ph d X=Me e X=Cl f X=Br g X=NO2 h X=m-NO2 i X=But
a Y=H b Y=MeO c Y=PhO d Y=Ph e Y=Me f Y=Cl g Y=Br h Y=NO2 i Y=But
O
O R3
N O O O
Z
Y
N O
CH3
N O O O R2
28 a Z=H b Z=MeO c Z=Ph d Z=Me e Z=Cl f Z=CHO g Z=CN h Z=NO2 i Z=But j Z=CF3 k Z=m-NO2 l Z=m-MeO
O Bu
R1 N O O O R2
29 2
3
a R =Ph, R =Et b R2=Ph, R3=Pri c R2=Ph, R3=But d R2=Ph, R3=neopentyl e R2=Ph, R3=1-Adamantyl f R2=R3=Ph g R2=Pr, R3=Ph h R2=Pri, R3=Ph i R2=(S)-2-butyl, R3=Ph j R2=Neopentyl, R3=Ph k R2=1-Ad, R3=Ph l R2=But, R3=Ph m R2=Me, R3=2-naphthyl n R2=Me, R3=fluoren-1-yl o R2=Me, R3=9,10-anthraquinone-2-yl p R2=Me, R3=pyren-1-yl r R2=2-naphthyl, R3=Ph s R2=2,6-dimethylphenyl, R3=Ph t R2=3,5-dimethylphenyl, R3=Ph u R2=Me, R3=3,5-dimethylphenyl v R2=hexyl, R3=But w R2=hexyl, R3=Ph x R2=5-hexen-1-yl, R3=But y R2=5-hexen-1-yl, R3=Ph
30 1
2
a R =Bu, R =Me b R1=Bu, R2=Ph c R1=Bn, R2=Me d R1=Bn, R2=Ph e R1=Bu, R2=2-Np f R1=CH2(1-Np),R2=Me g R1=CH2(2-Np),R2=Me h R1=(CH2)2(2-Np),R2=Me i R1=(CH2)3(2-Np),R2=Me j R1=Bu, R2=fluoren-1-yl k R1=Bu, R2=pyren-1-yl l R1=Bu, R2=CH2(pyren-1-yl) m R1=Bu, R2=CH2(2-naphthyl) n R1=Bu, R2=(CH2)2(2-naphthyl)
42
S.A. GLOVER O
R3 N O O O
R1
Y
O
R1
O N O
O O
O
N O
R3
O CH3
But
R2 31 a R1=R2=H,
But 32 a Y=H; b Y=But,
R3=But
b R1=But , R2=R3=H c R1=R2=But, R3=H; d R1=H, R2=R3=But; e R1=R3=But, R2=H; f R1=R2=R3=But
O
O
O N O
Ph
(CH2)3
AcO 34
2
O
N O
a
O N O
O CH3
O
d O
b
CH3
36 a R =H b R1=Cl
Ph
c
O
1
O N OAc
(CH2)n N OAc 35 a n=7 b n=8
R1
O But
33 a R1=R2=But
37 a b c d
a,b,=Me, c,d=H a,b=H, c,d=Me a,b,d=H, c=Me a=Me, b,c,d=H
Recently, Shtamburg et al. synthesised a variety of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyureas 38, N-acyloxy-N-alkoxycarbamates 39 as well as N-acetoxy-N-ethoxybenzamide 25a by an analogous procedure using appropriate sodium carboxylates in CH3CN.51–53 Compound 39h was synthesised from ethyl N-butoxy-N-chlorocarbamate using our NaOAc in acetone method.106
43
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES OCOR2
OCOR2 R1O
N
O
R1O
O OR3
NR32 38
39
a R1=R2=R3=Me b R1=R3=Me, R2=Et c R1=R3=Me, R2=Pri d R1=R3=Me, R2=Ph e R1=Prn, R2=R3=Me f R1=Prn, R2=Me, R3=Me,H g R1=Prn, R2=Ph, R3=Me,H h R1=Et, R2=Me, R3=CH2(1-Np),H i R1=Et, R2=Me, R3=H j R1=Bu,R2=Me, R3=H k R1=n-dodecyl, R2=Me, R3=H
3
N
a R1=R2=R3=Me b R1=R3=Me, R2=Et c R1=n-octyl,R2=R3=Me d R1=R2=Me, R3=Et e R1=Me, R2=Ph, R3=Et f R1=Pri, R2=Me, R3=Et g R1=Me, R2=4-ClC6H4, R3=Me h R1=Bu, R2=C6H4, R3=Et
Structure
GENERAL
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are archetypal anomeric amides. The combined electronegativity of the alkoxyl and acyloxyl oxygens strongly alters the geometry at the amide nitrogen and the attendant pyramidality manifests itself in radically reduced or negligible amide conjugation; the nitrogen lone pair is in an sp3 rather than a 2pz orbital (Fig. 3a). As a consequence, relative to amides and hydroxamic esters, they should have much longer N–C(O) bonds, low barriers to E–Z isomerisation and higher carbonyl stretch frequencies in their IR spectra. However the barrier to nitrogen inversion is likely to be low since, in the planar transition state for inversion, the lone pair can interact with the carbonyl (Fig. 3b). In contrast to N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides, dialkoxyamines, which are also pyramidal at nitrogen, have abnormally high nitrogen inversion barriers. Here the planar inversion transition state is destabilised by sp2 hybridisation, which necessitates shorter N–O bonds, as well as lone pair repulsion.107–111 O R C
poor overlap N OAc
sp3N
O low barrier
R C AcO
OR
N
‡ O C
N
R
OR OAc
OR (a)
(b)
Fig. 3 (a) Poor p overlap in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides; (b) stabilisation of the inversion transition state.
44
S.A. GLOVER σ*N— OR
O R
N
O
σ*N— OAc
nO
RCO
E
AcO σ*N—OAc
O
σN— OR
nO
σN— OAc
nOAc
(a)
R
90°
OAc
(b)
(c)
Fig. 4 (a) Anomeric overlap in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides; (b) lone pair stabilisation through an nO–s*N–OAc interaction; (c) optimum conformation for anomeric overlap in Nacyloxy-N-alkoxyamides.
In addition to these unusual amide characteristics, the bisoxo substitution and the sp3 hybridisation at nitrogen results in a strong anomeric interaction between nO, the alkoxyl oxygen lone pair and the s*N–OAc bond (Fig. 4a). This is a common feature of all bisheteroatom-substituted amides that we have studied.32 In the case of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides this anomeric interaction is likely to be strongest of the two possible anomeric effects; the s*N–OAc is lower in energy than s*N–OR while the alkoxyl oxygen p-type lone pair would be higher in energy than that of the acyloxyl ether oxygen (Fig. 4b). As illustrated in Fig. 4c, to maximise such interactions, the optimum geometry would require twist angles about the donor oxygen–nitrogen bond of around 901. Computed structures for model N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, X-ray diffraction data for a number of congeners, as well as spectroscopic evidence fully support these qualitative arguments.
THEORETICAL STRUCTURES
Both AM1 calculations on N-acetoxy-N-methoxybenzamide38 and ab initio 6-31G* calculations on N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 405,45 predict a strongly pyramidal nitrogen. Its lowest energy conformation at HF/6-31G* is depicted in Fig. 5a while structural data are provided in Table 1 together with that for N-methoxyformamide 41. O H
O N OCH3
H
O NHOCH3
H
NH2
CHO 40
41
42
The conformation in which the amide carbonyl and the formloxy groups are syn and both methyl and formyloxy carbonyl groups are exo to the nitrogen pyramid is lowest in energy. The average angle at nitrogen was 110.31 while dihedral angles give a Winkler–Dunitz amide distortion index of wN ¼ 58.5 (Table 1).112,113 The N–CO (1.405 A˚) and amide CQO (1.178 A˚) bond lengths are respectively longer and
45
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Fig. 5 (a) HF/6-31G* lowest energy conformation of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide; (b) Newman projection along the O1–N bond.
Table 1 Selected structural and spectroscopic properties of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 31b and 31f, -urea 38i, -carbamate 39g, theoretical models 40 and 41 and 1-aza-2-adamantanone 1 Parametera
31b
31f
38i
39g
40b
41b
1
rC ¼ O (A˚) rCN(A˚) rNOR(A˚) rNOAcyl(A˚)
1.2070 1.4414 1.4017 1.4396
1.2052 1.4394 1.4014 1.4414
1.222 1.426 1.398 1.426
1.198 1.424 1.396 1.474
1.178 1.405 1.360 1.375
1.188 1.373 1.373
1.210 1.455 – –
b1 (1) b2 (1) b3 (1) Sb (1) d (1)c ob4 (1)d
110.6 109.0 104.5 324.1 35.9 108.0
109.4 108.6 105.5 323.5 36.5 107.8
113.5 111.6 108.5 333.5 26.5 111.2
113.4 111.4 109.3 334.1 25.9 111.4
110.8 110.6 109.4 330.8 29.2 110.3
115.0 114.1 111.3 340.4 19.6 113.5
109.0 109.0 110.0 328.0 32.0 109.3
49.3 21.4 135.8 163.6
50.4 19.3 134.0 165.0
25.6 39.1 162.0 148.6
34.9 29.2 153.0 158.7
33.8 28.8 150.3 155.3
24.0 28.0 158.4 154.4
60.0 120.0 120.0 60.0
13.9 5.0 65.6 96.2 137.6 1730 174.2
15.5 4.4 65.3 96.7 141.6 1726 174.2
6.8 7.7 57.1 104.0 69.0 1720 158.5
2.9 7.9 56.3 95.5 67.1 1785
2.5 4.10 58.5 102.3 112.6
2.0 2.4 49.6
90.0 0.0 60.0
o1 o2 o3 o4
(1) (1) (1) (1)
t(1)e wC (1)e wN (1)e C–O–N–O(CO) (1) C(O)–O–N–OR(1) nmax (cm1) d13C amide CQO a
See Fig. 9 for definition of angles. Geometry calculated at HF/6-31G* level of theory. c d ¼ 360Sb. d ob4 ¼ Sb/3. e Amide distortion parameters defined in accordance with Winkler–Dunitz.112,113 b
1731 200
46
S.A. GLOVER H
N
O
O H
O2CH
MeO
O
MeO N
H
H
CO 1852(s)/1818(a) (1.171) CN 1182 (1.462) t = 90°;
= 105.8° -472.824551
(a)
H H
N
O
CO 1861(s)/1824(a) (1.172) CN 1190 (1.452) t = 90°; = 104.2° -472.833170
H
O H
CO 1784 (1.193) CN 1231 (1348) t=0˚; =120° -169.887003
H N
HCO2
HCO2
H OMe
CO 1796 (1.188) CN 1229 (1.373) t=2.0°; = 113.5° -284.349123
CO1838(s)/1819(a) (1.178) CN 1232 (1.405) t = 0.5°; =110.3° -472.845200
MeO
N
H N
O
H
N
MeO
O H
CO 1843 (1.178) CN 1020 (1.436) t = 90°; =105.2° -284.324215
(b)
CO 1813 (1.183) CN 1083 (1.427) t = 90°; =107.5° -169.858270
(c)
Fig. 6 Amide CQO and C–N vibrational frequencies (cm1) and bond lengths (A˚; in parentheses), twist angles (t), average angles at nitrogen ob4 computed at HF/6-31G* level for ground state and orthogonal conformations of (a) N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40, (b) N-methoxyformamide 41 and (c) formamide 42. Energies (Hartrees) at B3LYP/6-31G*// HF/6-31G* level.
shorter than those computed for N-methoxyformamide (1.373 A˚ and 1.188 A˚) reflecting significantly decreased interaction with the amide carbonyl. The CH3–O–N–OCHO dihedral angle was 102.31 at the HF/6-31G* level reflecting a strong nO–s*N–OCHO anomeric overlap in this direction (Fig. 5b). The dihedral angle HCO–O–N–OMe of 112.61 reflects a poorer alignment for the alternative nOCHO–s*N–O interaction. The anomeric overlap in the preferred conformation also results in a shorter CH3O–N bond in 40 (1.360 A˚) than that found for methoxyformamide 41 (1.373 A˚) despite the reduced sp3 character in the latter (ob4 ¼ 113.5, wN ¼ 49.61). However, a more meaningful comparison would be with O-methylhydroxylamine, which like 40 at the HF/6-31G* level, is sp3 hybridised at nitrogen with an N–O bond length of 1.399 A˚. Gas-phase vibrational frequencies can be computed using molecular orbital methods,114,115 which can also provide structural data about transition states or unstable conformations. Fig. 6 gives HF/6-31G* gas-phase carbonyl and C–N stretch frequencies for ground-state and fully twisted conformations of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide (Fig. 6a), N-methoxyformamide (Fig. 6b) and formamide (Fig. 6c). Fully twisted formamide and N-methoxyformamide have carbonyl stretch frequencies that are 29 and 47 cm1, respectively, higher than the planar or near-planar ground state structures. The C–N stretch frequencies are however reduced concomitantly by 147 and 208 cm1, respectively, indicating a significant loss of lone pair overlap in the twisted forms. The carbonyl vibrational frequencies for The frequency change is small when compared to the difference between CQO (1700 cm1) and C–O
(1100 cm1) stretches in line with the prevailing view that in planar amides relatively little charge is transferred to oxygen. The changes in frequency represent a small stiffening of the carbonyl bond at best.
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
47
both twisted forms of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 are strongly coupled but the averages of both the symmetrical and asymmetrical stretch frequencies (1835 and 1842 cm1) are comparatively similar to that of the ground state conformation (1828 cm1) (Fig. 6a). In this case, the C–N stretch frequency is reduced by only 50 or 42 cm1. Thus, when compared with formamide or N-methoxyformamide, both the carbonyl stretch and the C–N bond stretch frequencies are much less sensitive to the orientation of the sp3 lone pair. The small changes in the frequencies and bond lengths upon twisting the lone pair of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide out of conjugation (Fig. 6a) would suggest that, at HF/6-31G* level in the gas phase at least, some residual interaction is lost. However, it should be borne in mind that changes in the degree of pyramidality will also affect bond lengths. While the C–N bond length in the ground state of 40 (1.405 A˚) is of the same order as twisted formamide 42 (1.427 A˚), the bond lengthens by 0.005–0.006 A˚ in the twisted forms of 40. To a large degree this must be due to the tighter angles at nitrogen, which result in orbitals with greater p character. The extent of nitrogen lone pair-carbonyl overlap is also reflected in the barriers to E–Z isomerisation. B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* barriers to rotation in formamide (18.0 kcal mol1), methoxyformamide (15.6 kcal mol1) are similar in concurrence with our results in an earlier study using B3LYP/6-31G(D) optimised geometries.6 However both barriers are significantly higher than the smallest barrier for isomerisation of formyloxymethoxyformamide (7.5 kcal mol1; nitrogen lone pair and carbonyl syn). Though the nitrogen of the hydroxamic ester is computed to be significantly pyramidal (wN ¼ 49.6), the similarity in IR stretch frequencies and isomerisation barriers to those of the formamide confirm that the impact of one oxygen substituent upon amide characteristics is far smaller than that brought about by bisoxo-substitution. The calculated variations in CQO and C–N vibrational frequencies for formamide (+29 and 147 cm1, respectively) upon twisting the lone pair into the OCN plane are in accordance with changes in bond lengths (0.001 and+0.008 A˚ respectively) and reflect the contemporary view that p-donation to the carbonyl carbon in the planar form does not result in an equivalent loss in CQO pi-bond character.2 Similar results are found for N-methoxyformamide. The small differences in CQO bond lengths between planar (sp2 N) and twisted (sp3 N) formamide and methoxyformamide, as well as the similarity in CQO bond length of all three amides in the ground state (sp2 N in 42, sp3 N in 40) also lend support to Wiberg’s HOMO–LUMO theory of amide resonance.
X-RAY STRUCTURES
X-ray data are available for several N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 31b and 31f,5 an N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyurea 38i and an N-acyloxy-N-alkoxycarbamate 39g.51 The structure of all four is dominated by pyramidality at the amide nitrogen. While amides are typically planar or close to planar with average angles at nitrogen close
48
S.A. GLOVER
to 1201 in the overwhelming majority of structures studied to date,5 these bisoxosubstituted species have nitrogen atoms that are highly sp3 hybridised. Fig. 7 depicts crystal structures of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 31b and 31f and those of urea 38i and carbamate 39g are given in Fig. 8. Principal bond lengths, angles at nitrogen and Dunitz amide distortion parameters (Fig. 9) are listed in Table 1 together with those for Kirby’s most twisted amide 1.
Fig. 7 ORTEP116 depiction of (a) N-benzoyloxy-N-(4-tert-butylbenzyloxy)benzamide 31b and (b) N-(4-tert-butylbenzoyloxy-N-(4-tert-butylbenzyloxy)-4-tert-butylbenzamide 31f with displacement ellipsoids shown at the 20% level.
49
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Fig. 8 ORTEP116 depiction of (a) N-acetoxy-N-ethoxyurea 38i and (b) methyl N-4chlorobenzoyloxy-N-methoxycarbamate 39g with displacement ellipsoids shown at the 20% level.
τ
O ω3
ω2 AcO1
R3
C
ω1 O2R ω4
τ=1/2(ω1+ω2) χC=(ω1−ω3+π) = (ω4−ω2+π) χN=(ω2−ω3+π) = (ω4−ω1+π) (a)
β3 AcO1 O2R β2 N β1 C O
R3 (b)
Fig. 9 (a) Winkler–Dunitz parameters for defining twist (t) and pyramidality (wN, wC) in amides; (b) angles at nitrogen.
Crystal data for all four amides are uniformly similar. While amides 31b and 31f (|wN| ¼ 65.61 and 65.31, respectively) are more pyramidal than the urea and carbamate (|wN| ¼ 57.11 and 56.31, respectively) all four possess sp3-hybridised nitrogens. Average angles at nitrogen ob4 for the two amides are smaller than that required by pure tetrahedral geometry as exemplified by the tetrahedral nitrogen in 1-aza-2-adamantanone 1. In all cases, the high degree of pyramidality attributed to the presence of two electronegative oxygen atoms at nitrogen, confirms the predictions of HF/6-31G* calculations.5 On the basis of geometries for all acyclic amides in the Cambridge Structural Database in 2002,117 amides 31b and 31f are the most pyramidal amides of this type.5 Sp3 hybridisation at nitrogen results in decreased lone pair 2pz character, which manifests itself in three ways: (i) Diminished co-linearity between nitrogen lone pair and carbonyl carbon 2pz orbitals
50
S.A. GLOVER
(ii) Long N–C bond lengths (iii) Reduced E–Z isomerisation barriers All four structures bear testimony to these facts. Both 31b and 31f exhibit a significant degree of twisting around the N–C(O) bond (t ¼ 13.9 and 15.51, respectively). The experimental barrier to E–Z isomerisation in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides has been estimated to be below 8–9 kcal mol1 32 in line with the theoretical barrier for 40 (7.5 kcal mol1). Since the lone pair on nitrogen resides in an sp3 hybrid orbital, twisting angles are likely to arise from steric interactions or crystal packing rather than any residual p-orbital overlap considerations. Nitrogen lone pairs in urea 38i and carbamate 39g are closer to the carbonyl carbon 2pz plane (Table 1). The N–C(O) bonds (rC–N, Table 1) are all long when compared with normal, acyclic amides (average bond length of 1.359 A˚, median 1.353 A˚5). Although N–C(O) bonds of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides cannot be compared directly with tertiary N,N-dialkylamides on account of the different hybridisation at nitrogen, they are only slightly shorter than the corresponding bond in the fully twisted lactam 1-aza-2-adamantanone 1 even though the twist angle in 31b and 31f is relatively small (Table 1). The urea and carbamate carbonyl bond lengths cannot be compared directly with the amides. However, the crystallographic carbonyl bond lengths in the amides, 31b and 31f, are similar to that in 1-aza-2-adamantanone 1 (Table 1). In general, when compared with C(O)–N bonds, there is much less variation in carbonyl bond lengths in planar and twisted amides24 and the same is true of anomeric amides. In general, carbonyl bond lengths are relatively insensitive to the degree of lone pair interaction. Kirby has attributed this to a negative hyperconjugative effect involving an nO–s*C–N interaction impacting in an opposite sense upon the CQO bond length21 but, as has been proposed by Wiberg, transfer of nitrogen p-density to the carbonyl p* orbital is the main process and oxygen gains relatively little electron density from this.2,3 Similar arguments can account for the relative insensitivity of CQO bonds to loss of p-overlap through pyramidalisation at nitrogen in N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides. Geometries of all four amides indicate a preference in the solid state for a conformation in which the alkoxyl oxygen lone pair, nOR, is largely collinear with the s*N–OAc bond. Dihedral angles for C–O–N–OAc in Table 1 are all close to 901. This anomeric interaction is clearly predominant as the alternative, C(O)–O–N–OR dihedral angles indicate poor nOAc–s*N–OR interactions. As a consequence, N–OR bonds should be shorter than normal. As with the theoretical models, a comparison between experimental N–OR bond lengths and those of the parent hydroxamic esters is inappropriate on account of differences in hybridisation at nitrogen; in hydroxamic esters nitrogen is much closer to sp2 hybridised leading naturally to shorter N–O bonds. However, a comparison can be made to the experimental bond length in hydroxylamines since the nitrogen is fully tetrahedral in these, as well as in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. Typically, the N–O bond in hydroxylamines is of the order of 1.44–1.46 A˚ and values in this range have also been computed for the fully twisted hydroxamic esters (Fig. 6b) where the nitrogen also assumes a pyramidal
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
51
geometry.6 The rNOR distances of 1.402, 1.401, 1.398 and 1.396 A˚ in 31b, 31f, 38i, 39g respectively represent very significant shortening, presumably on account of an effective nO–s*N–OAc anomeric interaction. SPECTROSCOPIC PROPERTIES
Carbonyl stretch frequencies, carbonyl 13C and amide 15N chemical shifts for a wide range of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are listed in Table 2 together with those of the precursor hydroxamic esters. Spectroscopically, mutagens can be categorised into six types: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi)
N-Alkanoyloxy-N-alkoxyarylamides (entries 1–41) N-Alkoxy-N-aroyloxyarylmides (entries 42–52) N-Alkanoyloxy-N-alkoxyalkylamides (entries 53–58) N-Alkoxy-N-aroyloxyalkylamides (entries 59–68) N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyureas (entries 69–72) N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxycarbamates (entries 73–77)
Infrared spectroscopy N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are characterised by two high frequency double bond absorptions corresponding to the stretching modes of the ester and amide carbonyls. The acyloxyl substituents are ester groups but the bonding to nitrogen results in higher than normal CQO stretch frequencies. For aliphatic groups (R2 ¼ alkyl, Table 2, entries 1–41 and 53–58), these are all in the range of 1767 cm1 through to 1800 cm1 whereas carbonyls of saturated esters are generally found between 1735 and 1750 cm1.124,125 Acetoxy compounds have carbonyls that are uniformly close to or 41790 cm1 while at the lower end of the range are higher alkylamides (entries 12–19). Bulky pivaloyloxy and adamantane-1-carboxy esters in 29k and 29l (entries 18 and 19) exhibit distinctly lower carbonyl absorptions of 1767 and 1771 cm1 in line with the known impact of sterically induced angular deformation at carbonyls,124,126 although, as discussed below, steric effects upon solvation cannot be discounted.127 Carbonyls of aroyloxyl groups (R2 ¼ Aryl, Table 2, entries 42–52 and 59–68) range from 1750 to 1767 cm1 and are similarly increased relative to normal aromatic esters (1715–1730 cm1). Most benzoyloxy compounds give carbonyls between 1760 and 1765 cm1 but those that are para–substituted with donor groups, as well as those with polycyclic aroyloxyl groups, have carbonyls in the lower range of 1750–1760 cm1. Thus the impact of hydroxamic ester substitution through nitrogen at the ester oxygen is to raise the acyloxyl carbonyls into the range for acid chlorides and acid anhydrides.128
R1
Entry/ structure
13
C and selected
R2
R3
15
N chemical shiftsa (CDCl3) for N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides
Amide n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
Ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
Hydroxamic ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
26c38 26f38 26e38 26d38 26g38 26b38 26i38 26h118 29m48 29n119 29p119
Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu
Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me Me
4-Biphenylyl p-Brphenyl p-Clphenyl p-Mephenyl p-NO2phenyl p-MeOphenyl p-Butphenyl m-NO2phenyl 2-Naphthyl Fluoren-1-yl Anthraquinone2-yl
1721 (173.01) 1731 (173.12) 1728 (172.85) 1730 (173.93) 1730 (172.15) 1728 (173.18) 1721 (173.70) 1727 (171.39) 1724 (174.03) 1742b 1726b
1794 (166.24) 1791 (167.94) 1792 (167.82) 1790 (168.01) 1790 (167.83) 1790 (168.02) 1794 (168.08) 1794 (167.71) 1792 (167.98) 1785b 1792b
1684 1696 1695 1695 1695 1692 1679 1693 1684 1681 1672
(166.38) (165.45) (165.29) (166.44) (164.14) (166.12) (166.42) (164.00) (166.70) (167.10) (182.40)
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
29g119 29w120 29y120 29h119 29i119 29j119 29k119 29l119
Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu
Pr 1-Hexyl 5-Hexen-1yl Pri (S)-2-Butyl Neopentyl 1-Adamantyl But
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
1721 (174.4) 1723 (174.2) [124] 1730 (174.4) 1721 (174.3) 1725 (174.5) 1721 (174.4) 1723 (174.4) 1722 (174.7)
1774 1782 1783 1775 1774 1778 1767 1771
1654 1654 1654 1654 1654 1654 1654 1654
(165.65) (165.65) [197] (165.65) (165.65) (165.65) (165.65) (165.65) (165.65)
20
25a38
Et
Me
Phenyl
1789 (166.18)
1679 (166.50) [200]
21 22
25b48 25f38
n-Pr Pri
Me Me
Phenyl Phenyl
1789 (168.18) 1788 (166.21)
1678 (166.42) 1684 (166.77)
23 24 25
25c47 25g38 25j121
Bu Bui 2-Bu
Me Me Me
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
1795 (167.80) 1790 (166.05) 1790 (168.30)
1654 (165.65) 1684 (166.54) 1685 (166.90) [200]
26 27 28
25i121 25e47,48 27a47
But Octyl Benzyl
Me Me Me
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
1724 (174.25) [124] 1724 (174.30) 1724 (174.68) [127] 1732 (173.90) 1724 (174.15) 1719 (174.90) [127] 1707 (174.9) 1728 (174.29) 1728 (174.12)
1786 (168.40) 1798 (168.21) 1798 (168.08)
1686 (167.90) 1684 (166.51) 1678 (166.26)
S.A. GLOVER
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
(170.49) (171.10)) (171.0) (174.5) (173.9) (169.5) (174.4) (175.7)
52
Table 2 Infrared carbonyl absorption frequencies (CHCl3), (R1ON(OCOR2)COR3) and precursor hydroxamic esters
R1
Entry/ structure
R2
R3
29 30 31 32 33 34 35
27g38 27f38 27h38 27d38 27i38 27e38 27c38
p-Brbenzyl p-Clbenzyl p-NO2benzyl 4-Biphenylyl p-Butbenzyl p-Mebenzyl p-PhObenzyl
Me Me Me Me Me Me Me
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
36
27b38
Me
Phenyl
37
37a
2,6-diMebenzyl
Me
Phenyl
38 39
37b121 37c121
3,5-diMebenzyl 3-Mebenzyl
Me Me
Phenyl Phenyl
40 41
37d121 34105
2-Mebenzyl – (CH2)6–
Me Me
Phenyl di-Phenyl
42 43 44 45 46
29f49 28b40 28i40 28d40 28a40
Bu Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl
Phenyl p-MeOphenyl p-Butphenyl p-Mephenyl Phenyl
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
47 48 49 50 51 52
28e40 28f40 28j40 28g40 28h40 28c119
Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl Benzyl
p-Clphenyl p-CHOphenyl p-CF3phenyl p-CNphenyl p-NO2phenyl 4-Biphenylyl
Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl Phenyl
53 54 55
29v120 29x120 30a105
Bu Bu Bu
1-Hexyl 5-Hexen-1-yl Me
But But Me
1731 (174.04) 1731 (174.08) 1732 (174.20) 1729 (174.14) 1725 (173.94) 1729 (174.14) 1725 (174.17) [124] 1725 (174.17) [124] 1727 (174.20) [124] 1728 (174.10) 1729 (174.20) [124] 1726 (174.20) 1724 (174.3)
Ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N] 1791 1793 1793 1791 1790 1791 1795
(168.02) (168.02) (168.19) (166.10) (167.89) (168.10) (168.15)
Hydroxamic ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N] 1680 1687 1691 1674 1685 1681 1690
(166.50) (166.68) [203] (166.59) (164.91) (167.89) (166.24) (157.97) [196]
1795 (168.15)
1684 (159.93) [203]
1791 (168.20)
1684 (166.70)202]
1791 (168.10) 1792 (168.10)
1686 (166.00) 1684 (165.60) [196]
1792 (168.10) 1789 (168.20)
1650 (166.20) 1662 (166.00)
1728 (174.50) 1718 (174.25) 1738 (174.36) 1733 (174.36) 1731 (174.28) [123] 1734 (174.20) 1735 (174.07) 1734 (174.12) 1732 (174.04) 1733 (173.93) 1729 (174.40) [123]
1758 1750 1756 1756 1758
(164.00) (164.04) (164.21) (164.21) (164.13)
1654 1678 1678 1678 1678
(165.50) (166.26) (166.26) (166.26) (166.26) [197]
1759 1761 1765 1763 1764 1757
(163.25) (163.21) (163.07) (162.70) (162.37) (164.20)
1678 1678 1678 1678 1678 1678
(166.26) (166.26) (166.26) (166.26) (166.26) (166.26) [197]
1718 (182.50) 1719 (182.50) 1746 (176.20)
1779 (170.70) 1785 (170.50) 1797 (167.70)
1683 (176.00) 1683 (176.00) 1678 (167.90)
53
p-MeObenzyl
121
Amide n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 2 (continued )
54
Table 2 (continued ) R1
Entry/ structure
R2
R3
Amide n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
Ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
Hydroxamic ester n (cm1) (d13C) [d15N]
56 57 58
30c105 35a122 35b122
Benzyl di-benzyl di-benzyl
Me Me Me
Me –(CH2)7 –(CH2)8
1736 (176.30) 1742b 1741 (178.48)
1793 (167.90) 1794b 1791 (167.43)
1690 (168.00) [196] 1689 (154.50) 1690b
59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68
30d105 30b105 29a46 29b46 29c46 29d46 29e46 30e105 30j123 30k123
Benzyl Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu Bu
Ph Ph Ph Ph Ph Ph Ph 2-Naphthyl 1-Fluorenyl 1-Pyrenyl
Me Me Et Pri But Neopentyl 1-Adamantyl Me Me Me
1738 1738 1745 1736 1728 1735 1721 1737 1746 1743
1762 1765 1766 1767 1763 1763 1755 1757 1756 1751
1690 1678 1664 1657 1683 1653 1681 1678 1678 1678
69 70 71 72
38e52 38f52 38k52 38l51
n-Pr Pr Bu Et
Me Me Me Me
N(Me)2 NHMe NH2 NH2
73 74 75 76 77
39a52 39c52 39d52 39e51 39h106
Me Octyl Me Me Bu
Me Me Me 4-Clphenyl Ph
OMe OMe OEt OEt OEt
(176.50) (176.50) (180.10) (182.60) (182.80) (177.20) (182.20) (176.5) (176.5) (176.70)
1732c 1730c 1730c 1720c 1780c 1780c 1755c 1785c (158.5) 1762d (158.2)
(164.10) (164.10) (164.10) (164.10) (164.00) (163.80) (164.10) (164.30) (164.10) (165.20)
1784c 1795c 1790c 1798c 1805c 1805c 1780c 1780 (163.7) 1772d (164.3)
(168.00) (167.90) (171.80) (174.90) (176.20) (169.50) (175.40) (167.90) (167.90) (167.90)
1695c 1685c 1680c 1680c 1765c 1745c 1765 1724d (157.7)
a15
N shift relative to nitromethane 0 ppm. Not recorded. c Solid state or thin film IR. d Thin film IR. b
S.A. GLOVER
55
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
In contrast to CQO bond lengths, CQO vibrational frequencies are very much more sensitive to the extent of lone pair overlap in amides. In particular, increasing combined electronegativity of substituents at nitrogen and the attendant pyramidalisation and electronic effects result in a marked increase in the nC ¼ O values although the changes reflect only small variations in force constants.32 With the exception of 25i (entry 26) arylamides (R3 ¼ aryl, Table 2, entries 1–52) exhibit carbonyls in the range of 1718–1742 cm1, on average some 51713 cm1 higher than their precursor hydroxamic esters. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyalkylamides (R3 ¼ alkyl, Table 2, entries 53–68) exhibit carbonyls on average 57715 cm1 higher than the hydroxamic esters from which they are derived and their amide absorptions appear on average about seven wave numbers higher than their arylamide counterparts. Clearly, most, if not all sp2 character at nitrogen is lost upon bisoxo substitution and the extent of nitrogen lone pair interaction with the amide carbonyl is radically altered. As a consequence, the carbonyl stiffens measurably. N-AcetoxyN-tert-butoxybenzamide 25i has an anomalously low carbonyl (1707 cm1) that may suggest a smaller degree of pyramidality in this substrate due to steric hindrance. The vibrational frequencies of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides correspond to that observed for the twisted 1-aza-2-adamantanone 1 (1731 cm1).21,23 Where an amide nitrogen lone pair (either through twisting/pyramidalisation or pyramidalisation alone) loses conjugation with the carbonyl, the configuration is analogous to an ester rather than a ketone. As with esters, acid halides and anhydrides, or peresters,129 the carbonyl stretch frequency is higher than that of ketones and aldehydes on account of destabilisation of the polar form of the carbonyl by the strongly –I effect of the nitrogen or in these compounds, bisoxo-substituted nitrogen (Fig. 10 (II)). Steric effects on both the amide and the acyloxyl side chain are similar. Tert-butyl and adamantyl groups on the amide side chain in 29v, 29x, 29c, and 29e (Table 2 entries 53 and 54, 63 and 65) result in lower stretch frequencies that, on average, are only 40 cm1 higher than their precurser hydroxamic esters. Streck and coworkers have suggested that such changes in dialkyl ketones can be ascribed to destabilisation of resonance form II through steric hindrance to solvation which, in the case of tert-butyl counteracts the inductive stabilisation.127 When comparing the series of (para-substituted benzoyloxy)benzyloxybenzamides (28a–j, Table 2, entries 43–52), one notable exception is the 4-methoxy analogue 28b, which exhibits a much lower carbonyl stretch at 1718 cm1. The through resonance of the methoxyl lone pair reduces the electron-withdrawing effect of the acyloxyl substituent possibly resulting in a lower degree of pyramidality at the amide nitrogen and better resonance into the amide carbonyl.
O C
O C R
N I
R
N II
Fig. 10 Resonance forms in twisted or pyramidal amides.
56
S.A. GLOVER
Three other series of related anomeric amides have been studied in these laboratories. The closely related N,N-dialkoxyamides exhibit carbonyls in their solution infrared spectra in the range of 1705–1715 cm1, some 20–30 cm1 higher than hydroxamic esters.32 The significantly higher range for N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides can clearly be ascribed to the increased electron-withdrawing effect of the ester functionality as opposed to an alkoxyl group. N-Chlorohydroxamic esters are also anomeric and their carbonyl stretch frequencies are in the range of 1720–1745 cm1, on average 40 cm1 higher than their hydroxamic esters precursors in line with the lower electronegativity of chlorine.32 In addition, related N-alkoxy-N-aminoamides in the form of N,N0 -dialkoxy-N,N0 -diacylhydrazines are less pyramidal at nitrogen and have solution state carbonyls in the range of 1700–1722 cm1 for arylamides and 1733–1744 and 1707–1723 cm1 for non-degenerate carbonyls of acetamides.35,130 N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are clearly the most pyramidal of all anomeric amides reported to date. The situation with N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyureas and carbamates is similar although infrared data were mostly determined by liquid film or condensed phase (KBr/nujol mull).52,131 However, the limited data for N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyureas (Table 2, entries 69–72) give amide carbonyl frequencies ca. 1730 cm1 that are raised by some 37–40 cm1 by acyloxylation. Values for carbamates (Table 2, entries 73–77) are higher (mostly 1780 cm1) but are raised to a lesser extent (10–20 cm1) relative to their parent carbamates. Clearly, carbonyl vibrational frequencies will be influenced strongly by the adjacent amino or alkoxyl group in both analogues. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy 13
C NMR spectroscopy. 13C NMR resonances for both carbonyls of the N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides and that of the parent hydroxamic ester are given for most compounds in Table 2. With the exception of para–substituted benzyloxy-N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, amide carbonyl 13C NMR values of 56 congeners differ from those of their precursor hydroxamic esters by on average +8.0(70.6) ppm. Steric and electronic effects influence hydroxamic esters and N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides similarly. This includes substrates with branching a to the amide carbonyl. Two classes of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are worthy of mention: a. Mutagens with benzyloxy and para–substituted benzyloxy side chains 27a–i (Table 2, entries 28–36) are an exception. Their carbonyl shifts differ by between 6–16 ppm relative to their parent alkoxyamides. In this subset, this variation is almost entirely due to changes in the carbonyl chemical shift of the hydroxamic ester (d168–158) since N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are all very close to d174. This proves to be another manifestation of pyramidality at nitrogen in N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides. Hydroxamic esters are largely sp2 hybridised at nitrogen and the similarity in carbonyl stretch frequencies in hydroxamic esters and simple amides confirms their strong resonance interaction. This results in some positive polarisation at the amide nitrogen but overall, lone pair overlap with the carbonyl
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
57
carbon would be facilitated by donor groups and disfavoured by electronwithdrawing substituents on the alkoxyl group. However, amide carbonyl chemical shifts in the analogous N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, where nitrogen is strongly sp3 hybridised and which exhibit little or no amide resonance, are insensitive to the electronic effect of alkoxyl substituents at nitrogen. Amide carbonyl vibrational frequencies for the series behave similarly; while those of the hydroxamic esters in this subset vary between 1678 and 1691 cm1, the N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamide carbonyls span only six wave numbers. b. Branching a to the amide carbonyl (Table 2, entries 53, 54, 62, 63 and 65) affects the mutagen and hydroxamic esters similarly and causes a marked downfield shift of up to 6 ppm relative to the acetamide substrate (Table 2, entry 60). Branching a to the ester carbonyls results in a downfield shift of 8 ppm relative to acetoxyl esters (Table 2, entries 15, 16 18 19 versus 23). Associated CQO infrared stretches are also lowered in these substrates and both trends support stabilisation of the polar resonance form II in Fig. 10. A simple model of inductive stabilisation is indicated but steric effects must also be implicated. Pri, But and 1-adamantyl produce similar downfield shifts of around 8 ppm on both the amide and ester side chains, despite the greater inductive effect of the tertiary systems. Similarly, neopentyl, where branching is removed one carbon from the carbonyl produces only a small shift of o1 ppm, which is smaller than the 3 ppm produced by unbranched ethyl (on R3) or propyl (on R2), which have a similar or weaker inductive effect. Streck and coworkers showed that in a range of solvents, the 13C carbonyl shifts in dialkyl ketones were affected similarly by branching at the a-position.127 In chloroform, the carbonyls of di-tert-butylketone and diisopropylketone were 11–12 ppm downfield of that of acetone, which they attributed to a mixture of inductive and steric effects. With tertiary systems, particularly in dipolar solvents, hindrance to solvent stabilisation of the polar, basic form of the carbonyl offsets the inductive stabilisation of the branched alkyl. 13C NMR data presented here support this. While amide carbonyl chemical shifts in N-acetoxy-N-alkoxyamides are uniformly shifted to higher frequency by about 8 ppm relative to their precursor hydroxamic esters, they are not ketonic and appear some 20 ppm upfield of aryl/alkyl ketones. The shift in the ‘‘most twisted’’ amide 1 is at a significantly higher frequency (200 ppm) and has been labelled as aldehydic by Kirby and coworkers.22 However, rigid bicyclic ketones exhibit much higher carbonyl 13C NMR shifts and 200 ppm represents a shift to higher field of similar magnitude relative to 2-adamantanone, which has a carbonyl 13C NMR resonance at 218 ppm. The origin of this upfield shift from that of ketones, parallels that of esters, anhydrides and acid chlorides. Contrary to conventional reactivity arguments, which imply that substitution at carbonyls by electronegative atoms reduces electron density at the carbonyl carbon and hence promotes addition to carbonyls, a systematic study of 13C NMR shift data for ester carbonyls shows that electron density is actually greater at such carbons (reactivity enhancement is actually due to destabilisation of the ground states of the esters by the electron-withdrawing substituents).132,133 Our observations are in line with those of Neovonen et al. Electron-withdrawing nitrogen in
58
S.A. GLOVER
twisted/pyramidal amides destabilises resonance form II (Fig. 10) relative to ketones. These carbonyls have greater double bond character resulting in higher electron density at carbon, higher field carbonyl chemical shifts and higher nCQO. 15
N NMR spectroscopy. 15N NMR data have been obtained for a limited number of mutagens and hydroxamic esters and chemical shifts are presented in Table 2. Secondary and tertiary amide nitrogens generally resonate in the region of 200 to 250 ppm relative to nitromethane.134 Formamide resonates at 267.5 ppm and N,N-dimethyl-p-toluamide resonates at 282.6 ppm.135 15N in N-butoxybenzamide (Table 2, entry 13) resonates much further downfield at 195.7 ppm relative to nitromethane and that of other hydroxamic esters in this study all resonate between 196 and 203 ppm. The large shift to higher frequency of ca. 87 ppm relative to N,N-dimethyl-p-toluamide represents a significant impact of electronegative oxygen on the electron density at an amide nitrogen. An acyloxyl group would be expected to be more strongly electron-withdrawing than an alkoxyl group but bisoxo substitution in N-heptanoyloxy-N-butoxybenzamide 29w (Table 2 entry 13) results in a smaller downfield shift of about 73 ppm. Downfield shifts for other N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides were similar. Successive alkoxylation of isobutoxyamine to give N-ethoxy-N-methoxyisobutoxyamine results in 15N downfield shifts of 96 and 72 ppm.136 Thus acyloxylation would be expected to produce a downfield shift at least of the order of 100 ppm. Computed properties, IR carbonyl stretch frequencies as well as isomerisation barriers in hydroxamic esters support a largely intact interaction between the nitrogen lone pair and the carbonyl in these amides resulting in a significant donation of the lone pair to the carbonyl carbon despite the electronegativity of the alkoxyl oxygen. However, bisoxo substitution, as is generally found for anomeric amides, results in strong pyramidalisation at nitrogen and attendant disconnection of the nitrogen and carbonyl. The complete localisation of the lone pair on nitrogen in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides must, to a degree, offset the electron-withdrawing effect of the acyloxyl group. Yamada has demonstrated that twisting amides (though without complete pyramidalisation) produces relatively small upfield shifts of only 12 ppm.137 However, when compared with N,N-dimethyl-p-toluamide, the amide nitrogen in N-p-toluoylaziridine, which like N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides has a completely pyramidal nitrogen, is upfield by some 34 ppm.135 On the strength of this, it would appear that in N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, pyramidalisation and loss of amide resonance probably accounts to a large degree for the smaller than expected shift. The role of steric effects is unclear but the anomeric effect could also contribute to an increase in electron density at nitrogen. X-ray data for the two N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides, a urea and a carbamate outlined above show clear evidence, both from bond lengths and conformations, of an anomeric interaction; RO–N bonds are short when compared to alkoxyamines. This interaction is responsible for SN1, SN2, homolytic and rearrangement reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides (vide infra) and has also been supported computationally. Acyloxylation of the hydroxamic esters results in both pyramidalisation as well as anomeric donation from the
59
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
alkoxyl oxygen to the s*NOAc orbital according to Fig. 4a. This could also result in increased electron density at nitrogen. The smaller shift of 72 ppm upon a second alkoxylation of isobutoxyamine might also reflect increased anomeric interactions in N-ethoxy-N-methoxyisobutoxyamine.136 Dynamic 1H NMR spectroscopy. In stark contrast to parent hydroxamic esters, which usually exhibit line broadened alkoxyl group resonances in their 1H NMR spectra, at or even significantly above room temperature,138,139 in CDCl3 the alkoxyl and acetoxyl protons in N-acetoxy-N-alkoxybenzamides give rise to sharp signals well below room temperature. In d8-toluene, the benzylic and acetoxyl methyl resonances of N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 43 showed significant line broadening below 250 K but remained isochronous down to 190 K. O
O
C Ph
C N
OCH2Ph
OAc 43
Ph
N
OCH2Ph
Cl 44
These results clearly indicate that barriers to all isomerisation processes are at least less than about 8 kcal mol1. In N-benzyloxy-N-chlorobenzamide 44 the amide isomerisation was not observable but the anomeric overlap resulted in diastereotopic benzylic hydrogens, which at coalescence afforded a barrier for rotation about the N–OBn bond of around 10.3 kcal mol1.32 Like its N-chloro analogue, the amide isomerisation barrier in 43 is too low to be observed by 1H NMR and even though there is definitive X-ray and theoretical evidence for anomeric effects in N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides, the barrier to isomerisation about the N–OBn bond must be lower than 10.3 kcal mol1. The nO–s*N–Cl anomeric interaction in 44 is predicted to be stronger than the nO–s*N–OAc interaction in 43 on purturbation arguments.32
4
Chemical reactivity
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are intrinsically reactive at the amide nitrogen. Three factors contribute to this: (i) Sp3 character of the nitrogen itself, which results in reactivity akin to sp3 carbon. SN1 and SN2 reactivity, both of which are improbable at sp2 carbon and planar amide nitrogens, become feasible (ii) The substitution pattern strongly favours an nO–s*N–OAc anomeric effect resulting in weakening of the N–OAc bond (iii) Alkoxyl oxygen lone pair involvement promotes heterolytic SN1 and SN2 reactions at nitrogen, homolysis reactions as well as molecular rearrangements (vide infra)
60
S.A. GLOVER
As part of our programme aimed at understanding the source of their chemical mutagenicity, we have fully investigated the reactivity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides under a range of conditions. They have been shown to undergo acid-catalysed solvoysis reactions producing alkoxynitrenium ions, SN2 reactions with a range of organic and inorganic nucleophiles, homolysis reactions that produce alkoxyamidyl radicals as well as the heteroatom rearrangements on nitrogen (HERON) rearrangement, an intramolecular reaction discovered in these laboratories. Urea and carbamate analogues undergo alcoholysis to give N,N-dialkoxyamides.
SOLVOLYSIS STUDIES – AAL1 REACTIVITY37– 40
The first indication that N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides reacted by an acid-catalysed process came from preliminary 1H NMR investigations in a homogeneous D2O/ CD3CN mixture, which indicated that N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide 25c reacted slowly in aqueous acetonitrile by an autocatalytic process according to Scheme 4 (k is the unimolecular or pseudo unimolecular rate constant, K0 the dissociation constant of acetic acid and K the pre-equilibrium constant for protonation of 25c).38 Upon addition of a solution of sulfuric acid in D2O the reaction of N-acetoxyN-alkoxyamides obeys pseudo-unimolecular kinetics consistent with a rapid reversible protonation of the substrate followed by a slow decomposition to acetic acid and products according to Scheme 5. Here k is the unimolecular or pseudo unimolecular rate constant and K the pre-equilibrium constant for protonation of 25c. Since under these conditions water (D2O) was in a relatively small excess compared with dilute aqueous solutions, the rate expression could be represented by the following equation:
d½S d½AcOH ½S½H3 Oþ ¼ ¼ k½SHþ ¼ k:K ¼ k0 ½S dt dt ½H2 O
½H3 Oþ ¼ kH ½H3 Oþ . where the pseudo-unimolecular rate constant k0 ¼ ½Hk:K 2 O K' AcOH + H2O K
H3O+ + S SH+
k
AcO– + H3O +
SH+ + H2O
products + AcOH
Scheme 4.
H3O+ + S SH+
k
K
SH+ + H2O
products + AcOH
Scheme 5.
(1)
61
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Pseudo unimolecular rate constants k0 for sulfuric acid-catalysed solvolysis of 25c in CD3CN/D2O (adjusted to a constant ratio of 3.8:1) were found to be linearly dependent upon the acid concentration (Fig. 11) and the gradient afforded a composite rate constant kH of (2.4170.10) 102 l mol1 s1 at 308 K. From the intercept, ko, the rate constant for uncatalysed solvolysis, was at least three orders smaller and zero within experimental error. A similar linear dependence and near-zero uncatalysed rate constant was demonstrated for other N-acetoxyN-alkoxybenzamides given in Table 3. Scheme 6 depicts three possible hydrolysis mechanisms.140 The first (pathway (i)) is normal acid-catalysed ester hydrolysis in which attack of solvent (H2O) upon the protonated intermediate is rate determining. The second (pathway (ii)) is the 6 5
104k' (s-1)
4 3 2 1 0 0.010
0.020
[H3O+](mol.l-1)
Fig. 11 308 K.
Dependence of k0 on acid concentration in the solvolysis of 25c in CD3CN–D2O at
Table 3 Rate constants for acid independent and uncatalysed solvolysis of N-acetoxyN-alkoxybenzamides in CD3CN/D2Oa at 308 K Substrate (R, X)
1 1 102k308 s ) H (l mol
25a (R ¼ Et) 25c (R ¼ Bu) 25f (R ¼ Pri) 25g (R ¼ Bui) 26b (X ¼ MeO) 26d (X ¼ Me) 26e (X ¼ Cl) 26f (X ¼ Br) 26g (X ¼ NO2)
3.82 (0.22) 2.41 (0.10) 30.19 (1.63) 1.91 (0.15) 29.56 (3.04) 8.96 (0.62) 1.02 (0.13) 1.19 (0.07) 0.245 (0.02)
a
CD3CN/D2O 3.8:1.
105k308 (s1) o 1.76 2.31 5.40 0.02 1.47 13.40 4.24 0.43 2.40
(2.90) (1.30) (9.15) (1.96) (14.30) (8.50) (2.58) (1.50) (0.70)
r 0.996 0.995 0.996 0.994 0.984 0.999 0.975 0.997 0.990
62
S.A. GLOVER O
+
O PhCON
H3O+ fast
CH3
[0.48]
+
O H
PhCON
OBu
+
O
H2 O Path (i) AAc2
CH3 OBu
slow
H2 O
Path (ii)AAl2 slow
Path (iii)AAl1 slow [0.33]
+
PhCO N OBu
+ +
+
O
H OH
O PhCON
fast
H2 O
H
AcOH H2 O
CH3 OBu + H O 2
[0.69]
H
+
O H [0.69]
PhCON
+ +
AcOH H2 O
+
AcOH H3O+
OBu
fast
fast [1.00]
OH PhCON OBu
+
Scheme 6.
disfavoured AAl2 process which would involve displacement of acetic acid through nucleophilic attack by a water molecule at nitrogen. Pathway (iii), the AAl1 mechanism is typically found for the acid-catalysed hydrolysis of tertiary alkyl or benzyl esters, which generate stabilised carbenium ions.141 Rate equation (1) indicates that kH should be inversely proportional to the activity of water for solvolysis by the AAl1 mechanism and independent of it if the bimolecular processes (pathways (i) and (ii)) pertain. Fig. 12 illustrates that acid independent rate constants at different volume fractions of D2O in CD3CN, kH, were linearly dependent upon the inverse of aD2 O in CD3CN as determined from the corresponding activities of H2O in CH3CN.142 This is in accord with the AAl1 mechanism (pathway (iii), Scheme 6). Further evidence for the AAl1 mechanism was obtained from a solvent kinetic isotope study. The theoretical kinetic isotope effects for intermediates in the three reaction pathways as derived from fractionation factors are indicated in parentheses in Scheme 6.143,144 For the AAl1 mechanism (pathway (iii)) a solvent KIE (kH2 O =kD2 O ) between 0.48 and 0.33 is predicted while both bimolecular processes (pathways (i) and (ii)) would have greater values of between 0.48 and 0.69. Acidcatalysed hydrolysis of ethylene oxide derivatives and acetals, which follow an A1 mechanism, display KIEs in the region of 0.5 or less while normal acid-catalysed ester hydrolyses (AAc2 mechanism) have values between 0.6 and 0.7.145,146 From rates of the solvolysis of 25c at different sulfuric acid concentrations in D2O/CD3CN and H2O/CD3CN (Fig. 13), the observed solvent KIE was found to be 0.44 (70.02) confirming, therefore, that the transition state for solvolysis lies along
63
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES 0.225
KH(l mol s-1)
0.175
0.125
0.075
0.025 1.125
1.175
1.225
1.275 1/aH O
1.325
1.375
1.425
2
Fig. 12 Dependence of kH for 25c on activity of water in CD3CN–D2O at 308 K.
6 5
kH(H2O)/kH(D2O) =0.44 CD3CN/D2O
104k' (s-1)
4 3 2
CD3CN/H2O
1 0 0.004
0.014
0.024
[H3O+](mol l-1)
Fig. 13 Dependence of k0 on acid concentration for solvolysis of 25c in CD3CN–D2O and CD3CN–H2O at 308 K.
pathway (iii), between the protonated ester and nitrenium ion. Fractionation factors and solvent kinetic isotope effects are not expected to differ greatly in aqueousorganic mixtures.147 Thus N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides undergo acid-catalysed solvolysis forming N-acyloxy-N-alkoxynitrenium ions. However, the rate of uncatalysed reaction was negligible under the same conditions. Anomeric weakening of the N–O bond in the neutral species is insufficient to promote heterolysis. However, protonation of the acyloxyl group, renders this substituent at nitrogen more electronegative (Fig. 14a)
64
S.A. GLOVER
C H
O
C O
O sp3 N R O
R'
C
H nO — σ*NO (a)
δ+ O
C O
R'
O δ+ R N O
O C N O sp2 HO
R
C O R'
(b)
(c)
Fig. 14 (a) Anomerically weakened NO bond in the protonated intermediate; (b) transition state; (c) products from AAl1 reaction of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides.
Population of the s*NOAc orbital weakens the bond rendering it unstable, resulting in formation of a resonance-stabilised nitrenium ion (Fig. 14c). Arrhenius data and acid independent rate constants at 308 K, k308 H , for a wide range of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxybenzamides are given in Table 4. With the exception of the benzoyloxylated series, 28, the activation energies are in the region of those cited for the acid-catalysed hydrolysis of tertiary alkyl, diphenylmethyl and a-methylallyl esters namely ca. 29 kcal mol1 141 Entropies of activation are positive in keeping with a dissociative transition state but for the most part are much more positive than the ester values (ca. 9.5 cal K1 mol1), which accords with much looser and later transition states with substantial alkoxynitrenium ion character (Fig. 14b). AAc2 hydrolysis of esters have strongly negative DSz between 24 and 36 cal K1 mol1.148 The isopropoxy compound 25f reacts about an order of magnitude faster than 25a, 25c and 25g. A measurably larger DSz is consistent with additional relief of steric compression in the transition state; the protonated intermediate (Fig. 14a) would be sp3 hybridised at nitrogen while the alkoxynitrenium ion (Fig. 14c) would be sp2 hybridised at nitrogen. The isobutoxy compound 25g, in which the branching is one methylene removed from the oxygen atom has similar parameters to straight chain substrates 25a and 25c. Para-substituents on the benzamide side chain in 26, the benzyloxy side chain in 27 and the benzoyloxy side chain in 28 would be expected to affect the rate determining step differently. The influence of para-substituents on the benzamide and benzyloxyl side chains upon the pre-equilibrium protonation step is likely to be negligible considering their remoteness from the site of protonation and their electronic influence must rather impact upon the rate determining N–O bond heterolysis step. Parasubstituents on the leaving group should impact upon both the protonation and bond heterolysis steps. HF/6-31G* calculations on N-methoxy-N-benzoylnitrenium ion gave a geometry in which N2pz–O2pz are coplanar yielding a N–O bond order of 1.6 and a bond length of 1.191 A˚, which is typical of pure N–O double bonds (Fig. 15a).149,150 The LUMO (Fig. 15b) was localised on the C(O)NO atoms with some contribution into the aromatic ring and the positive charge resides on the nitrogen, the alkoxy substituent and the acyl group. Group charges for these were N ¼ +0.1, OCH3 ¼ +0.47
65
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 4 Arrhenius and rate data for acid-catalysed solvolysis of N-acetoxy-Nalkoxybenzamides (25, 26, 2738,39 and 2840)a,b ln A
EA (kcal mol1)
DSz (cal K1mol1)
102 k308 H (l mol1 s1)c
r
25a (R ¼ Et) 25c (R ¼ Bu) 25f (R ¼ Pri) 25g (R ¼ Bui)
41.46 42.02 45.73 41.27
(0.43) (1.15) (2.02) (0.29)
27.37 27.92 28.64 27.66
(0.29) (0.69) (1.27) (0.19)
21.85 22.95 30.33 21.47
(0.24) (2.17) (1.34) (0.17)
3.72 2.60 33.50 1.92
0.996 0.998 0.995 0.994
26b (X ¼ MeO) 26c (X ¼ Ph) 26d (X ¼ Me) 26e (X ¼ Cl) 26f (X ¼ Br) 26g (X ¼ NO2) 26i (X ¼ But)
43.05 44.92 44.01 39.05 39.96 31.25 44.56
(1.29) (1.06) (0.13) (2.37) (0.63) (0.78) (1.23)
26.99 29.45 28.66 26.46 27.04 22.76 29.04
(0.81) (0.67) (0.17) (1.50) (0.41) (0.50) (0.76)
25.01 28.80 26.92 17.05 18.87 1.58 27.99
(2.56) (2.10) (0.53) (4.71) (1.24) (1.55) (2.44)
33.860 3.899 5.875 1.452 1.455 0.252 5.337
1.000 0.999 1.000 0.995 1.000 0.999 0.999
27a (Y ¼ H) 27b (Y ¼ MeO) 27c (Y ¼ PhO) 27d (Y ¼ Ph) 27e (Y ¼ Me) 27f (Y ¼ Cl) 27g (Y ¼ Br) 27h (Y ¼ NO2) 27i (Y ¼ But)
45.01 44.50 38.19 42.99 47.06 41.89 40.01 34.43 43.82
(1.32) (2.60) (2.80) (0.78) (0.71) (1.26) (0.45) (1.09) (0.94)
30.57 28.37 25.46 29.19 31.14 29.26 28.16 25.63 29.26
(0.84) (1.65) (1.72) (0.50) (0.45) (0.79) (0.29) (0.69) (0.60)
28.90 27.87 15.36 24.89 32.96 22.69 18.96 7.88 26.53
(2.63) (5.18) (5.56) (1.55) (1.41) (2.51) (0.88) (2.17) (1.86)
0.499 14.870 3.160 0.876 2.062 0.265 0.239 0.057 1.821
0.999 0.993 0.999 1.000 1.000 0.999 1.000 0.998 1.000
28a (Z ¼ H) 28b (Z ¼ MeO) 28d (Z ¼ Me) 28e (Z ¼ Cl) 28f (Z ¼ CHO) 28j (Z ¼ CF3) 28g (Z ¼ CN) 28h (Z ¼ NO2)
39.44 41.20 40.50 38.83 39.10 40.10 36.20 37.00
(0.58) (1.30) (1.20) (0.84) (1.30) (1.20) (1.30) (1.70)
17.84 21.30 20.04 16.67 17.05 19.15 11.32 12.99
(1.15) (2.65) (2.39) (1.67) (2.58) (2.39) (2.58) (3.37)
27.49 28.56 28.23 27.08 27.04 27.56 25.22 25.53
(0.38) (0.84) (0.72) (0.53) (0.84) (0.79) (0.79) (1.05)
0.411 0.395 0.369 0.424 0.578 0.689 0.630 0.863
0.999 0.997 0.998 0.999 0.997 0.998 0.997 0.995
a
CD3CN:D2O 3.8:1. Errors in parentheses. c From Arrhenius data at 308 K. b
and PhCO ¼ +0.42. Substituents at nitrogen that can stabilise this developing charge would be expected to accelerate the heterolysis step. Using Arrhenius derived rate constants at 308 K for substrates 25c, 26b–g and 26i (Table 4) an excellent fit was obtained with Hammett s+ substituent constants yielding a r-value of 1.4 (r ¼ 0.995). While s+ correlations are expected where there is direct conjugative interaction between the aryl substituent and the positively charged centre,151,152 the fit in this case is consistent with a significant build up of localised positive charge on nitrogen in the rate determining step. The small negative Hammett r-value is appropriate for nitrenium ion formation beta to the aromatic ring and rate enhancement by electron-releasing substituents can best be ascribed to a diminution of positive charge at the amide carbonyl carbon in 45 thereby facilitating the development of positive charge at nitrogen. A similar correlation
66
S.A. GLOVER
Fig. 15 (a) HF/6-31G* optimised geometry and (b) LUMO of N-methoxy-Nbenzoylnitrenium ion.
(s+, r ¼ 0.74) has been reported for the acid-catalysed decomposition of o-diazoacetophenones in which carbenium ion character is also developed alpha to the carbonyl.153,154 Y δO δ+ OBu N δ+ X
O
CH3
O
O N
δ+ MeO
O
CH3
O δ+ H
δ+O H 45
OBu
46
Ph
N
δ+ O C H2
O
CH3
δ+O H 47
The Arrhenius parameters for this series of compounds show the usual trend expected for a unimolecular heterolysis in the rate-determining step. Electronreleasing groups (negative s+) have much more positive DSz indicative of a looser transition state together with a higher EA as a consequence of the greater degree of N–O bond stretching. With the exception of 26b all the substrates in this series exhibit an isokinetic relationship (Fig. 16, ln A ¼ 0.5EA16.5, r2 ¼ 0.998). The deviation (of 3 ln A units) from this relationship by the para-methoxy substrate would suggest a different mechanism of activation. Para-methoxylation in 26b results in a more organised transition state than those found with other activating substituents and the reaction is also driven by a slightly lower EA. The tighter transition state could in part be due to the planarity requirements for conjugative interaction with the carbonyl. However, by analogy with the decomposition of the o-diazoacetophenones, a resonance interaction in the transition state such as that in 46 would also account for these activation parameters.153,154 The products resulting from acid-catalysed solvolysis of N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 26 in acetonitrile–water mixtures, as illustrated in Scheme 7, are
67
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES 48 46 27b
44
26b
42 R2 = 0.999
lnA
40
27c
38 R2 = 0.997
36
R2 = 0.974
34
26 27 28
32 30 5.00
10.00
15.00
20.00 25.00 E A(Kcalmol-1)
30.00
35.00
40.00
Fig. 16 Isokinetic relationships for acid-catalysed solvolysis of 26, 27 and 28 in CD3CN/D2O at 308 K.
acetic acid, butanol 50, benzoic acids 52, butanal 54, benzohydroxamic acids 55 and butyl benzoates 56. All of these products except acetic acid are derived from the N-hydroxy-N-butoxybenzamide intermediate 49 which is formed by capture of the nitrenium ion 48 by water (Scheme 7).38,39 Aldehyde 54 and the hydroxamic acids 55 were generated together in an acidcatalysed elimination reaction (Scheme 7 pathway (ii)). A crossover experiment indicated that esters are formed in a concerted rearrangement concomitant with the likely formation of the hydroxynitrene 57 (Scheme 7 pathway (iii)); while there is no evidence to date for the formation of hydroxynitrene, joint solvolysis of equimolar quantities of N-acetoxy-N-butoxy-p-chlorobenzamide 26e and N-acetoxyN-benzyloxybenzamide 27a afforded significant quantities of butyl p-chlorobenzoate (36%) and benzyl benzoate (54%) as the only esters. This is an example of a HERON reaction, which has been identified in these laboratories as a characteristic rearrangement of bisheteroatom-substituted amides.32,33,42,43,155–158 Since ester formation was shown to prevail in neutral or low acid concentrations, it could involve the conjugate anion of the hydroxamic acid (vide infra).158 The source of alcohol 50 is most probably acid-catalysed hydrolysis of 49 to the nitrosocarbonylbenzene intermediates 51, which, like acid chlorides, react with water to give benzoic acids 52 (Scheme 1 pathway (i)).159 Acylnitroso intermediates 51 were trapped as the Diels–Alder adducts 53 in reactions in CH3CN/H2O and in 18 the presence of cyclopentadiene. In CH3CN/10% H18 O 2 O, 53 was enriched in
68
S.A. GLOVER O Ar
CH2Pr N O
O
H+
O Ar
N O + 48
– AcOH
O
O
H2O
CH2Pr
Ar
H+
CH3
CH2Pr
N O HO 49 O
O Ar H
CH2Pr N O O + H+
H2O
O
Path (i) HOCH2Pr
Ar OH 52
Ar N O
50
O
51
N 53
H
+
O
HH
Ar
CPr N HO
Path (ii)
O
Ph O N O HO
CH2Pr
O
OH Ar
PrCHO + Ar N
54
Ph
O
OH
55
NH OH
O
Path (iii)
+
Ar
N OH
OBu 56
57
Scheme 7.
providing unequivocal evidence for both the trapping of the nitrenium ion intermediate 48 by solvent water molecules and subsequent hemiacetal-like hydrolysis to the nitrosocarbonylbenzene 51.39 Studies at different acid strengths indicated that pathways (i) and (ii) (Scheme 7) were favoured over the non-acid-catalysed HERON reaction pathway (iii) at higher acid concentrations. Substituents on the benzyloxy side chain in 27a–i would be expected to affect ease of alkoxynitrenium ion formation through their inductive influence at the alkoxyl oxygen, which, because alkoxynitrenium ions are strongly delocalised, gains significant positive charge in the transition state 47. An isokinetic plot using Arrhenius data for this series indicated that 27b (X ¼ MeO) and 27c (X ¼ PhO) deviated markedly from the rest of the series, which gave a good linear relationship (Fig. 16, ln A ¼ 0.54EA23.0, r2 ¼ 0.974).39 Substrates in this series were found to react by two mechanisms; those bearing +M substituents, 27b–d, reacted by an E1 process (Scheme 8, pathway (i)) while the remainder, like N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 26, reacted through the AAl1 process (Scheme 8, pathway (ii)). Evidence for this dichotomy was obtained from kinetic isotope effects and 18O incorporation studies 39 in CH3CN/10% H18 2 O. Whereas the normal AAl1 reaction (pathway (ii)) in CH3CN/10% H18 2 O would yield labeled Diels–Alder product 60, reaction of 27b under these conditions gave 18O labeled benzyl alcohol 59 and unlabelled 53. Benzyl cation 58 is lost in the
69
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
C5H6
O O CL2
Ph N O
X E1
O
CL2
Ph O CH3
N O O
–AcOH
O+ H
H218O X 18
L L 58
Path (ii) AAl1 Slow
–AcOH
O N
Ph
X
N O
Slow Path (i)
O+ H
CH3
‡
O
O H
Ph 53 X
CL2 59
Path (iii) O
O Ph N +
O
H218O
CL2 O
X
Ph
N O
Ph
CL2
18
18
O18
C5H6
N
X
N O H+ O H
O 60
CL2
Ph
HO
Scheme 8.
Ph
H+
N O O Z O
O
O
O Ph
K
Ph
Ph
Ph
Ph N O
k
N O O +O H
Z
O Z HO
Scheme 9.
rate-determining step rather than through a fast elimination from the benzyloxynitrenium ion (Scheme 8, pathways (ii) and (iii)). Acid-independent rate constants for 27b and 27d where L ¼ H and D gave significant second order isotope 3 2 D effects, kH H/kH ¼ 1.32 and 1.18, respectively, indicative of sp to sp rehybridisation of the benzylic carbon in the transition state. In contrast, substrates with +I (27e, Scheme 8, X ¼ Me) and M (27h, Scheme 8, X ¼ NO2) afforded kH/kD ¼ 1.02 and 0.99. Reaction product studies were consistent with this change of mechanism. 27b gave benzyl alcohol, benzoic acid and benzoic anhydride and no products from solvolysis intermediate N-benzyloxy-N-hydroxybenzamide.39 For series 27, two Hammett correlations are therefore operative. Substrates 27b–d bearing +M substituents correlate with s+ with r ¼ 2.0, while the remainder (27a, 27e–i) correlate with s with r ¼ 1.6.39 No change in mechanism was found for the benzoyloxy series 28. Fig. 16 illustrates a uniform isokinetic relationship. Here substituents Z impact on both protonation and heterolysis steps (Scheme 9). Electron donating substituents increase the basicity of the benzoyl carbonyl, which promotes protonation and hence shifts the
70
S.A. GLOVER
equilibrium constant K, to the right. However, electron donating substituents, while increasing the concentration of the protonated intermediate, decrease the partial positive charge at the carbonyl carbon thereby reducing the ease of N–O bond heterolysis (and magnitude of k). These opposing effects manifest themselves in low overall sensitivity to the electronic effects of the para substituents. Rate constants at 308 K (Table 4) correlate with Hammett s substituent constants with positive slope but with a low gradient (r ¼ 0.32, r2 ¼ 0.87).40 A similar sensitivity has been reported for normal acid-catalysed solvolysis of alkyl benzoates where substituents also influence protonation and solvolysis steps in the opposite sense.160 Reversible protonation of benzoic acids has a reported r+ value of 1161 thus a similar sensitivity in the protonation of 28 would yield a r-value for the heterolysis step in the region of+1.5 and entirely consistent with build up of negative charge at a centre indirectly conjugated to the substituent.y
NUCLEOPHILIC SUBSTITUTION REACTIONS – SN2 REACTIVITY
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides have been found to undergo SN2 reactions with a number of organic and inorganic nucleophiles including anilines, thiols, hydroxide and azide anions. Reaction products from all of these processes are themselves reactive anomeric amides and outcomes have uncovered novel chemistry of this unusual class of compounds. In SN2 reactions, substituents at the central atom that can stabilise cationic character will also stabilise the SN2 transition state leading to products. As well as lowering the energy, such stabilisation moves SN2 saddle points in the direction of cationic species resulting in incipient cationic character in the transition structure and longer bonds to both the nucleophile and the leaving group.162–165 Work in these laboratories and elsewhere has established that nitrenium ions are strongly stabilised by neighboring heteroatoms (see background section and Fig. 15).38,91–95,97–100,166,167 This, together with the fact that N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides possess a tetrahedral nitrogen bearing a good leaving group, should promote SN2 reactions leading to displacement of carboxylate. The anomeric substitution results in negative hyperconjugation and anchimeric assisted weakening of the N–OAc bond (Scheme 10). Reactions with aromatic amines – the HERON reaction N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are mutagenic towards TA100 and TA98 strains of Salmonella typhimurium without metabolic activation. They are direct-acting mutagens and react as electrophiles directly with nucleophilic centres in DNA.38–40,46–49,50 The principle DNA target of many electrophiles at physiological pH is known to be N7 of Guanine (G-N7), the most nucleophilic centre in the y logðk0 X =k0 H Þ ¼ logðK X =K H Þ þ logðkX =kH Þ ¼ 1:0sþ þ rs and a plot of ðlogðk0 X =k0 H Þ þ sþ Þ versus s yields a better correlation (r2 ¼ 0.94) and a r-value for the heterolysis step in the region of +1.5.
71
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES Nu R
O C
O δ+ OR
N O δ–
R
C
N
–OAc
Nu
OR
O CH3
Scheme 10.
CH3
O N
O
NH Ph OR
CH3
61
N
AcOH
N Ph
RO
AcO
62
25
Ph
O
CH3 N N
OR 63
H3C
N
N
Ph 64
N
N
CH3
Ph 65
Scheme 11.
major groove.60,168–171 N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides have been shown to damage DNA at this position.49,105 To evaluate their relative potential for reaction towards G-N7 and other nucleophiles, the rates of reaction of various N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides with the aromatic base N-methylaniline, have been determined routinely.41–43 Initially, a reaction of N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide 25c with N-methyl aniline 61 in d4-methanol or aqueous acetonitrile, afforded an excellent yield of butyl benzoate 63(R ¼ Bu) and acetic acid. Close examination of these highly coloured reaction mixtures indicated the presence of crystals of N,N0 -dimethyl-N,N0 diphenyltetrazene 65 (Scheme 11, R ¼ Bu). The reaction is promoted by polar solvents as reactants are unchanged in pure acetonitrile. A crossover experiment using a mixture of N-acetoxy-N-butoxy-p-toluamide 26d and N-acetoxy-N-ethoxybenzamide 25a afforded clean yields of butyl p-toluate and ethyl benzoate thus pointing to an intramolecular rearrangement.41 The process, which is depicted in Scheme 11 and which appears to be common to all classes of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, involves an SN2 reaction leading to displacement of the acyloxyl group and formation of the intermediate N-alkoxy-N(N0 -methylanilino)benzamide 62. These are strongly anomeric on account of a highenergy lone pair on nitrogen and the electronegative oxygen of the alkoxyl group. Anomeric weakening of the N–O bond in 62 results not in heterolysis to alkoxide
72
S.A. GLOVER O
NR2
O
N H
Ar O R (a)
1.49Å
c aN 1.77Å b 1.79Å
O
NH2 H
1.50Å c a
1.74Å b
O H
O H
(b)
(c)
N
NH2
1.81Å
Fig. 17 (a) Transition state for a HERON reaction of an N-alkoxy-N-aminoamide; computed transition states for migration of hydroxyl in N-amino-N-hydroxyformamide at (b) AM1 (a ¼ 651, b ¼ 451 and c ¼ 651) and (c) HF/6-31G* (a ¼ 631, b ¼ 481 and c ¼ 691) levels.
ion, which would be energetically unfavourable, but rather migration of the alkoxyl group from the amide nitrogen to the carbonyl carbon and heterolysis of the N–C bond. This results in the formation of 1-methyl-1-phenyldiazene 64, which under the reaction conditions dimerizes to the tetrazene 65. These rearrangement processes are characterised by a transition state in which the alkoxyl group migrates from the amide nitrogen to the carbonyl carbon (Fig. 17a) and therefore involves HEteroatom Rearrangements On Nitrogen the HERON reaction.z155,157,158 This reaction, though published in the early 1990s, was named in the literature in a 1995 paper in which we presented a semiempirical molecular orbital treatment of the HERON reactions of a range of anomeric amides.155 AM1 predicted, adequately, the pyramidal ground state properties of various anomeric amides, as well as the relative propensity for HERON migration of a variety of geminal heteroatom substituents on nitrogen. In general, the activation energy was lowered with an amino substituent and more electronegative migrating atoms or electron deficient groups. In the case of N-hydroxy-N-aminoformamide, a transition state was predicted that indicated partial bonding between the migrating oxygen and both the amide nitrogen and carbon atoms in a plane perpendicular to that of N–CQO (Fig. 17b). The amide bond was largely unaltered. A similar result was obtained from HF/6-31G* calculations (Fig. 17c). Subsequently, a DFT evaluation of the HERON reaction of N-methoxyN-dimethylaminoformamide to give methyl formate and 1,1-dimethyldiazene confirmed the earlier predictions at the AM1 and HF/6-31G* level on the simpler system (Fig. 18). The activation energy in the gas phase is modest at 21.4 kcal mol1 and the rearrangement is predicted to be exothermic by some 5.5 kcal mol1.33 The transition state geometry shows that the N–C bond is intact and the carbonyl bond is virtually unaltered relative to the starting structure. An intrinsic reaction coordinate study indicated that the N–C bond cleaves in concert with O–C bond formation after the transition state. In essence, this reaction represents an intramolecular SN2 reaction on the amide carbonyl. Further analysis of the computed transition state indicates the charge redistribution (Fig. 18). Predictably N2 becomes z First presented to the 2nd Heron Island Conference on Reactive Intermediates and Unusual Molecules, Heron Island, Australia, 1994.
73
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
1.51Å
1.22Å
Group charges in the ground and transition state.
N2 N1 1.27Å 2.00Å
— N2(CH3)2 — N1 — OCH3 — CHO
1.71Å
GS
TS
0.00 0.00 -0.02 +0.02
+ 0.51 -0.19 -0.34 -0.01
EA = 21.4 kcalmol-1
H=5.5 kcalmol -1 1.21Å
N1 N2
O
1.39Å
1.39Å O
Fig. 18 B3LYP/6-31G*-derived energetics, ground and transition state properties for the HERON reaction of N-methoxy-N-dimethylaminoformamide to 1,1-dimethyldiazene and methyl formate.
more positive at the transition state while N1 and the migrating group develop negative charge. Electron-releasing groups on the donor nitrogen and electron-withdrawing groups on the migrating oxygen should lower the energy of the transition state, and the rearrangement should also proceed better in polar solvents that can stabilise this charge separation. Interestingly, there is no appreciable change in charge at the carbonyl and neither electron-donor groups nor electron-withdrawing groups at this position should exert a major influence upon the energetics of the reaction. Experimental evidence in support of these computational results has accrued from a number of reactivity studies. The HERON rearrangement of the intermediate N-alkoxy-N-(N-methylanilino)benzamides proceeds with a low activation energy in methanol as it has never been detected under the reaction conditions even at temperatures well below ambient.42,43 This is not surprising as the B3LYP/6-31G* activation energy for the model reaction in the gas phase is an upper limit and it would probably be significantly lower in solution. However, the related dimeric N,N0 -diacyl-N,N0 -dialkoxyhydrazines 66 are stable, but rearrange above room temperature to esters 67 and nitrogen in stepwise HERON rearrangements (Scheme 12).131,156 These hydrazines are unsymmetrical and exhibit all the characteristics of anomeric amides including pyramidality at nitrogen and anomeric effects where one nitrogen is a lone pair donor to the adjacent s*NOAc bond.35 Here the product from the first HERON reaction, N-acyl-N-alkoxydiazene 68, ultimately undergoes a second HERON process with very low EA.36,172
74
S.A. GLOVER O
O OR
R' N
HERON
N
R' OR
R'
RO
OR
67
+ N2
R' O
O
66
HERON
N N
67
68
a R=Et, R'=4-C6H4X b R=CH2(4-C6H4X), R'=CH3
Scheme 12.
Using these hydrazines we have verified the electronic effects predicted from the theoretical studies.33 A series of 4-substituted N,N0 -dibenzoyl-N,N0 diethoxyhydrazines, 66a, correlated with Hammett s+ constants with r ¼ 0.35, (r2 ¼ 0.98). Here electron-releasing groups stabilise developing positive charge at the donor nitrogen. N,N0 -diacetyl-N,N0 -dibenzyloxyhydrazines, 66b, correlated with Hammett s constants with r ¼ +1.02 (r2 ¼ 0.91) in keeping with stabilisation of developing negative charge at the migrating oxygen.33 Kinetic studies. HERON reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, which can be conveniently followed by NMR in d4-methanol by monitoring the disappearance of the mutagen or aniline and formation of ester and tetrazene, conform to classical bimolecular kinetics being first order in both mutagen and N-methylaniline.41–43,46,105 Arrhenius parameters and bimolecular rate constants (308 K) for a range of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 25–30 are collated in Table 5. Typically, SN2 reactions of alkyl halides by anionic displacement involving charge delocalisation in the transition state exhibit entropy values in the range –4.5 to –9.5 cal K1 mol1. The entropies of activation for SN2 reactions at the amide nitrogen are however in the region of –24 cal K1 mol1 as would be expected for an associative transition state in which there is increased charge separation relative to the ground state (Fig. 19).174 Solvation will be more important and a contribution to the negative DSz must also be the more ordered arrangement of solvent molecules about the transition state.174 This effect is offset to a small extent by relief of steric compression. Anomerically substituted amides have pyramidal nitrogens as a consequence of dual substitution at nitrogen with electronegative atoms.5,6,32–36 Consequently there is a sharper angle at nitrogen in the ground state than in the transition state, where nitrogen approximates sp2 hybridisation. The activation energies are modest and reflect partial bond formation/breaking in a normal SN2 reaction. These reactions have an analogy in the SN2 reactions of a-haloketones such as phenacyl bromides.175 The rate-enhancing effect of a-carbonyl groups on SN2 processes at carbon is well known, and has been attributed to conjugation of the p-orbital on carbon in the SN2 transition state with the carbonyl p-bond,164,175–177 stabilisation of ionic character at the central carbon as outlined by Pross,164,178 as well as electrostatic attraction to the carbonyl carbon.176 Although there
75
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 5 Arrhenius activation energies, entropies of activation and rate constants at 308 K for reaction of N-acetoxy-N-alkoxybenzamides 25, N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 26, N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 2842,43 and other N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides with N-methylaniline in d4-methanol Substrate (R, X, Y, Z)
ln A
EA (kcal mol1)
DSz (cal K1 mol1)
104 k308 2 (l mol1 s1)
r
25a (R ¼ Et) 25b (R ¼ Pr) 25c (R ¼ Bu) 25d (R ¼ Pent) 25e (R ¼ Oct) 25f (R ¼ Pri) 25g (R ¼ Bui) 25h (R ¼ Penti)
15.86 19.49 17.78 19.89 13.94 19.48 17.53 18.90
(1.7) (1.1) (0.5) (0.1) (1.4) (1.0) (1.1) (0.7)
11.90 13.61 12.62 13.84 10.55 14.75 13.00 13.30
(0.93) (1.00) (0.39) (0.16) (0.69) (0.87) (0.75) (0.62)
30.98 23.76 27.16 22.98 34.80 23.79 27.66 24.93
(3.3) (2.1) (1.0) (0.2) (2.9) (1.9) (2.1) (1.4)
276.5 628.4 581.5 643.3 363.0 96.7 239.3 581.5
0.994 0.992 0.999 1.000 0.991 0.993 0.993 0.995
26b (X ¼ OMe) 26c (X ¼ Ph) 26d (X ¼ Me) 26e (X ¼ Cl) 26f (X ¼ Br) 26g (X ¼ NO2) 26i (X ¼ But)
15.91 15.56 13.35 12.11 21.15 15.11 18.54
(1.1) (1.2) (0.1) (1.0) (0.9) (2.3) (0.9)
11.59 11.28 10.49 9.05 14.64 10.87 13.07
(0.67) (0.70) (0.14) (0.38) (1.04) (1.23) (0.71)
30.88 31.57 35.97 38.43 20.47 32.46 25.65
(2.2) (2.5) (0.2) (2.0) (1.7) (4.6) (1.7)
481.5 559.3 222.3 678.3 609.4 693.9 585.4
0.993 0.992 1.000 0.996 0.987 0.983 0.994
28a (Z ¼ H) 28b (Z ¼ OMe) 28d (Z ¼ Me) 28e (Z ¼ Cl) 28i (Z ¼ But)
14.60 14.30 5.91 19.61 21.13
(2.6) (1.8) (0.0) (1.3) (0.4)
11.16 11.64 6.37 13.48 15.39
(1.50) (1.05) (0.00) (0.79) (0.19)
33.48 34.08 50.73 23.53 20.52
(5.3) (3.6) (0.0) (2.6) (0.7)
260.8 87.7 109.8 881.2 177.0
0.991 0.996 1.000 0.998 1.000
27a (Y ¼ H) 29a (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ Et) 29f (R2 ¼ R3 ¼ Ph) 29l R2 ¼ But, R3 ¼ Ph) 30a (R1 ¼ Bu, R2 ¼ Me) 30b (R1 ¼ Bu, R2 ¼ Ph) 30c (R1 ¼ Bn, R2 ¼ Me) 30d (R1 ¼ Bn, R2 ¼ Ph)
14.73 (1.73) 17.90 (1.7)
11.53 (0.95) 15.56 (0.95)
33.18 (5.5) 26.97 (3.3)
155.6 5.32
0.993105 0.996173
18.6 (3.0)
12.20 (1.67)
25.06 (7.9)
2550.0
0.983105
13.50 (1.0)
11.54 (0.57)
35.56 (2.0)
45.8
0.993119
14.28 (1.48)
12.63 (0.95)
34.14 (5.0)
16.9
0.995105
11.89 (1.27)
10.17 (0.30)
38.91 (6.0)
87.5
0.986105
17.48 (1.96)
15.03 (1.67)
27.69 (6.9)
8.2
0.989105
19.98 (1.27)
15.92 (0.72)
23.39 (4.5)
23.4
0.998105
is no comparative rate data for reactions on amines or alkoxyamine, these arguments could also apply to substitution at the amide nitrogen in N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides. These transition state properties have been modelled computationally at the HF/6-31G* level.45 The transition state geometry and properties for the reaction of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 with ammonia giving 69 (Scheme 13), is illustrated in Fig. 20. In the transition state the nucleophile and leaving group,
76
S.A. GLOVER Ph Me O N R
Ph NH
O
Me N H δ+
OR' OAc
N
O
OR'
N
N(Me)Ph
R
R
OR' δ– OAc
Fig. 19 Ground state and transition state geometries for the bimolecular reaction of N-methylaniline and N-acetoxy-N-alkoxyamides. δ+ NH3
NH3 O H
O CH3 N H O O 40
O H
O N O CH3 δ- O
H
NH3
N
O CH3
O
O H
O H
69
Scheme 13.
Fig. 20 HF/6-31G* optimised geometry and changes in group charges (relative to reactants) for the transition state for SN2 displacement of formate from N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 by ammonia.
though displaced in the direction of the amide nitrogen lone pair, are approaching linearity and the amide nitrogen lone pair, the methoxyl group and the amide formyl substituent are approximately coplanar. Deviation from the classical linear transition state for SN2 displacement at carbon is not unexpected considering the complex interplay of lone pairs on N2, O3 and O5. The methoxyl group is oriented to maximise alignment of the p-type lone pair on O5 with the N2–O3 bond and
77
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
therefore the s*N–O orbital, suggesting it plays a negative hyperconjugative role even at the transition state. The reaction is clearly concerted, the acetoxyl group departing as N–N bond formation occurs. At the 6-31G* level of theory the amide carbonyl is close to the C4–N2–O5 plane and largely disconnected with the amide nitrogen lone pair which lies in the same plane. Analysis of the group electrostatic charges in the ground state of the reactants and the transition state supports the experimental solvation effect described above and which leads to more strongly negative DSz values. Fig. 20 gives the changes in total charge on the nucleophile (Dq ¼ +0.34) and the formyloxyl leaving group (0.67). The greater build-up of negative charge in the formyloxyl group compared to positive charge accrual on the nucleophile is indicative of a non-synchronous process and of partial nitrenium ion character in the transition state (Dq(N) ¼ 0.23). A detailed analysis of the charges on each fragment along the reaction coordinate showed that even at the N1–N2 bond distance of 2.5 A˚, where the charge on ammonia is only +0.04 and the geometry at nitrogen is virtually unchanged and tetrahedral, the formate has well developed anionic character (0.54). The bulk of the positive charge (+0.54) resides mainly on the amide nitrogen and the methoxyl group and represents partial alkoxynitrenium ion character. This is transferred in part to the ammonia nitrogen at the transition state and the bulk of the difference in charge is computed to reside on the amide nitrogen.45 B3LYP//HF/6-31G* energies for reactants, transition state and products for the reaction in Scheme 13 are presented in Table 6. In accordance with the increased charge separation in the transition state and products, the gas-phase EA of 22.6 kcal mol1 for the reaction reduces to just 4.4 kcal mol1 with inclusion of semiempirical solvation energies in water while the overall reaction, which is very endothermic in the gas phase becomes exothermic by 5.1 kcal mol1 with solvation.179 The calculated EA is lower than the experimental values for substitution by N-methylaniline in methanol which fall in the range of 6–15 kcal mol1 (Table 5).42,43 However, in aqueous solution these barriers would be lower than in methanol. Analogous calculations for the reaction of ammonia with N-formyloxy-N-methyl formamide predict a much higher activation barrier, which emphasises the role of the alkoxyl substituent in SN2 reactions on N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides.45 Table 6 B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* energies of reactants, transition states and products for the reaction of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide with ammonia (Scheme 13)a Structure NH3 CHON(OCHO)OCH3 40 [CHON(NH3)OCH3]+ 69 HCO–2 T.s. (Fig. 20) a
E (Hartree)
Eaq (Hartree)b
56.5472467 472.841903 340.008802 189.175640 529.353172
56.5579596 472.842752 340.116406 189.292434 529.393668
Lowest energy conformers; ZPE not included. Incorporates solvation energies calculated by the SM5.4 method of Cramer.179
b
78
S.A. GLOVER
Electronic effects. Nucleophilic attack is favoured by electron-withdrawing groups on the amide and the acyloxyl side chains. Interpolated bimolecular rate constants at 308 K for the series of para-substituted N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 25c, 26b–g and 26i (Table 5) gave a weak but positive Hammett correlation with s constants (r ¼ 0.13, r ¼ 0.86).42,43 These SN2 reactions are analogous to those of aniline and substituted pyridines with phenacyl bromides, which have similar Arrhenius activation energies and entropies of activation in methanol (EA ¼ 14–16 kcal mol1, DSz ¼ 27 to 31 cal K1 mol1) and 4-substituted phenacyl halides afforded a similar Hammett correlation with pyridine in methanol (s, r ¼ 0.25).175 The bimolecular rate constants for the limited series of N-benzoyloxyN-benzyloxybenzamides in Table 5 correlated strongly with Hammett s constants (r ¼ 1.7, r ¼ 0.97).42,43 Stabilisation of developing carboxylate character supports the computed charge redistribution in the transition state.45 Rate constants for the reaction of a series of substituted anilines 70–72 with N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide 25c are presented in Table 7. NH 2 R
R
R'
R' 70
a R=Me, R'=H b R=Et, R'=H c R=H, R'=Me
NHR
NH 2
71
X 72 a X=MeO b X=Me c X=H d X=Cl e X=Br f X=NO 2
a R=Me b R=Ph
Table 7 Bimolecular rate constants for the reaction of anilines 70–72 with N-acetoxyN-butoxybenzamide 25c in d4-methanol42, 43 Aniline 71a N-Mea 70c 3,5-diMe 70a 2,6-diMe 70b 2,6-diEt 71b N-Phb 72f X ¼ NO2 72d X ¼ Cl 72c X ¼ H 72e X ¼ Br 72b X ¼ Me 72a X ¼ OMe a
104 k308 (l mol1 s1) 2
104 k298 (l mol1 s1) 2
104 k278 (l mol1 s1) 2
581.5 193.4 8.4 15.4 –
290.9
62.8 22.9 0.9 1.0 – 36.7 68.6 89.6 106.0 273.3 929.0
From Table 5. Included for comparison only.
b
–
1.6
79
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Data for 72 correlated with Hammett s+ with r ¼ 0.91, r ¼ 0.95, which accords with the developing charge separation in the transition state. However, the Hammett reaction constant is smaller than that determined for the reaction of substituted anilines at alkyl and acyl carbon centres (r ¼ 2.0 to 3.0)180 and together with the strong sensitivity to substituents on the leaving group, reflects an early transition state in which positive charge is not transferred directly to the nucleophile. Rather, because of incipient stabilisation by the alkoxyl group, there is significant nitrenium ion character. Steric effects. As expected, bulky groups on the mutagen as well as on the nucleophile have a significant impact on ease of SN2 reaction at nitrogen. Rate constants at 308 K reflect the trends that would be expected for the relative steric influences of the alkoxy side chains in 73 (Table 5). Substrates with unbranched propyl, butyl and pentyl chains all exhibit similar rates at 308 K as would be expected. However the substrates 25f (R ¼ Pri) and 25g (R ¼ Bui) exhibit significantly lower rates than 25a (R ¼ Et) and 25b (R ¼ Pr), respectively, in accordance with their higher degree of steric hindrance brought about by branching. 25h with isopentyloxy and 25c with butyloxy side chains react with similar rates indicating that branching remote from the reactive site has little influence. Analysis of relative activation parameters provides more insights into the variations in these rate constants. An isokinetic plot of EA versus ln A for straight chain and isopentyl substrates is linear and all substrates, where branching of the alkyl chain is at least d to the reactive centre, nitrogen, behave similarly (Fig. 21, filled squares).43,181,182 The isopentyloxy and butyloxy substrates 25h and 25c have very similar transition state 21 20
y = 1.8588x - 5.8462 R2 = 0.9914
19
25f
LnA
18 25g
17 16 15 14 13 10
11
12 13 E A(kcalmol-1)
14
15
Fig. 21 Isokinetic relationship for SN2 reaction of N-methylaniline with N-acetoxyN-alkoxybenzamides 73 in d4-methanol.
80
S.A. GLOVER
properties so branching d to the nitrogen has little effect. In the associative step, factors that facilitate overlap in the classical SN2 transition state complex will lower the energy of the transition state. However, more effective overlap must involve greater reorganisation resulting in a reduction in DSz, which becomes more negative. Structure 25f bearing isopropyloxyl and, to a lesser extent, 25g with isobutyloxyl deviated from the isokinetic relationship (Fig. 21, open squares) reflecting different transition state characteristics brought about by the steric crowding closer to the reaction site. It is likely that in these cases, to attain the same degree of reorganisation as needed in the straight-chain substrates, a higher activation energy is needed. Alternatively, straight chain substrates with the same activation energy as the isopropyl and isobutyl compounds would need an earlier transition state requiring less reorganisation. O O Ph
O R
AcO R Et, Pr, Bu, pentyl, octyl Pri, Bui, pentyli
Bu
N O
N O O O R
R=Me, Et, Pri, But, CH2But, 1-adamantyl
R=Me, Pr, (S)-2-butyl, Pri, But, CH2But, 1-adamantyl, Ph
R
Bu
N O
73
Ph
BzO
74
75
Steric effects on the amide side chain in 74 were marked. Out of a series of N-benzoyloxy-N-butoxyalkylamides 30b, 29a–e, only acetamide, 30b, and propanamide, 29a, afforded Arrhenius data in the normal temperature range 260–290 K. Rate constants at 308 K (Table 5) indicated that the propanamide (5.3 l mol1 s1) reacted an order of magnitude slower than the acetamide (87.4 l mol1 s1) and further branching at the a carbon through isopropyl substitution in 29b, tert-butyl in 29c and adamantyl in 29e completely inhibited SN2 attack by N-methylaniline at the amide nitrogen, even at higher temperatures.46,173 Removing branching to the b carbon in the neohexamide 29d returned reactivity, which was slow at the only temperature studied (2.2 l mol1 s1 at 313 K).46 SN2 reactivity with neutral nucleophiles like N-methylaniline parallels that of a-haloketones with amines, which are also strongly affected by steric effects on the a0 -carbon.183 In general, the rates of SN2 reactions are strongly adversely influenced by steric effects and branching b to the reactive centre and the same appears to be true for N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. Rates of reaction of a-haloketones are also radically different with ionic nucleophiles relative to neutral amino nucleophiles, which react much more slowly. This has been attributed to a tighter transition state with ionic nucleophiles like acetate and azide leading to a classical SN2 transition in which there is additional stability through orbital overlap with the carbonyl carbon 2pz orbital.183,184 Azide has been found to react with N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides and N-chloro-N-alkoxyamides, even those with branching a to the carbonyl (vide infra).
81
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 8 Bimolecular rate constants for the reaction of N-methylaniline with N-acyloxy-Nbutoxybenzamides 75 (25c, 29f–l) in d4-methanol at 308 K Substrate (R, R2) 25c (R ¼ H) 29g (R2 ¼ Pr) 29h (R2 ¼ Pri) 29i (R2 ¼ (S)-2-butyl) 29j (R2 ¼ CH2But) 29k (R2 ¼ Ad) 29l (R2 ¼ But) 29f (R2 ¼ Ph) a
104 k303 (l mol1 s1)
pKAa
22.9 122.0 91.0 97.0 78.0 61.0 33.8 1844.0
4.76 4.82 4.85 4.80 4.79b 4.86b 5.03 4.20
pKA of departing carboxylic acid. Calculated value.
b
Steric effects of branching on the acyloxyl side chain in 75 are insignificant. Table 8 gives relative rate constants for the reaction of N-methylaniline with a range of N-butoxy-N-alkanoyloxybenzamides 25c, 29a–l in d4-methanol at 303 K and the corresponding value for N-butoxy-N-benzoyloxybenzamide 29f together with pKAs of the leaving group carboxylic acid.119 Comparison of rate constants for straight chain and branched substrates clearly indicates that steric influences are minimal. Log of the reaction rate constant yields a reasonable linear correlation with pKA (gradient ¼ 4.8, r ¼ 0.969), which supports the theoretical transition state properties in which substantial charge transfer to the carboxyl group takes place. Steric effects on the nucleophile, aniline, were clearly evident. Rate constants for bimolecular attack of 2,6-dimethyl- 70a, 2,6-diethyl- 70b, and 3,5-dimethylaniline 70c at 308 K indicate that the ortho-substituted anilines react more than an order of magnitude slower at the same temperature (Table 7). Structure 70c must be able approach the reactive nitrogen more closely.42,43 A comparison of the rate constants for reaction of aniline 72c, N-methyl- 71a and N-phenylaniline 71b provides further evidence of steric effects although the very small rate constant for the diphenylamine could also be accounted for by reduced nucleophilicity on account of lone pair resonance into the additional phenyl ring. Bimolecular reactions of aniline with N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are model SN2 processes in which reactivity is dictated by a transition state that resembles normal SN2 processes at carbon. Electronic influences of substituents support a nonsynchronous process which has strong charge separation at the transition state and which is subject to steric effects around the reactive centre, at the nucleophile but not on the leaving group. The sp3 character of nitrogen and disconnection between the amino group and the amide carbonyl renders these reactions analogous to the displacement of halides in a-haloketones. The mutagenic activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides is believed to involve SN2 reactions of guanine N7 at the amide nitrogen with displacement of carboxylate.49 Remarkably, their biological activity is similarly affected by substituents at the amide nitrogen (vide infra).
82
S.A. GLOVER
Reactions with hydroxide ions Treatment of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxybenzamides 76a with dilute aqueous sodium hydroxide, at room temperature, resulted in the rapid formation of alkyl benzoates 67.40 A crossover experiment using N-acetoxy-N-butoxy-p-chlorobenzamide 26e and N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 27a resulted in the exclusive formation of butyl p-chlorobenzoate (46%) and benzyl benzoate (43%) esters along with the hydrolysis products, p-chlorobenzoic acid and benzoic acid indicating that ester formation involves an intramolecular process. Using a series of N-(p-substituted benzoyloxy) mutagens 28a, 28d–h, it was shown to occur by SN2 reaction of hydroxide at nitrogen, which gives as intermediate the hydroxamic acid 77 (Scheme 14).40 The presence of excess base ensured conversion of the hydroxamic acid intermediate into the conjugate anion 78 resulting in a HERON reaction leading to formation of ester 67 and presumably NO. The formation of non-crossover esters in the acid-catalysed solvolyses of N-acetoxyN-alkoxyamides at low acid concentrations has also been observed (Scheme 7, pathway (iii)) and presumably involves the conjugate anion of the hydroxamic acid 49.39 While the lone pair on the hydroxyl oxygen of hydroxamic acid 77 would be tightly bound resulting in a weak nOH–s*N–OR interaction, the anion 78 would possess a high energy pair of electrons that would enhance the anomeric effect and drive the rearrangement. HF/6-31G* optimised structures and B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* energies of model ground state 78b, transition state 79b, and rearranged product 80b of the HERON step are illustrated in Fig. 22. The transition state 79b for rearrangement of N-methoxy-N-methanohydroxamate anion is computed to be early; the N1–O2 bond is appreciably longer at the transition state, the O2–N1–C1 angle is large and the carbonyl is essentially intact (Fig. 22b). Unlike the HERON reaction of
O
R'
O O OH R' HO– R' S 2 N OR N N OH N O O –R''CO2– RO RO R'' O 76 77 78
O R'
R'
67 a R=Bn,R'=Ph, R''=Ar b R=Me, R=R''= H
N O δ– 79
NO OR
Scheme 14.
O
R δ–O
O
OR
R'
NO
80
83
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Fig. 22 HF/6-31G* optimised geometries and B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* energies (Hartree) of (a) ground state 78b, (b) transition state 79b, and (c) HERON rearranged product 80b. Table 9 Bimolecular rate constants for the reaction of dilute hydroxide with 28a, 28d–h at 275.4 K Substrate (Z) 28d (Z ¼ Me) 28a (Z ¼ H) 28e (Z ¼ Cl) 28f (Z ¼ CHO) 28g (Z ¼ CN) 28h (Z ¼ NO2)
(l mol1 s1) k275 2 2.27 3.16 3.82 4.91 6.97 8.14
(0.39) (0.65) (0.69) (0.59) (0.09) (1.26)
N-alkoxy-N-aminoamides, where the amide bond breaks in concert with the migration, the transition state in this case leads to the tetrahedral alkoxide intermediate 80b (Fig. 22c), which decomposes to methyl formate by elimination of NO. B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* gave an activation energy for the HERON step of only 5.3 kcal mol1 (10.0 kcal mol1 including solvation effects). Formation of the tetrahedral intermediate was exothermic by 10.7 kcal mol1 and the overall reaction producing methyl formate and NO is endothermic by 21 kcal mol1 with solvation, which suggests reversibility of the HERON step in this case.158 Rate constants for the reaction of base with N-aroyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 76a (using 28a, 28d–h) could only be obtained at low temperature (275.4 K) and low base concentration and are presented in Table 9. Rates correlated with Hammett s constants with positive slope (r ¼ +0.55, r ¼ 0.992) in keeping with the BAl2 rather than the BAc2 mechanism of base hydrolysis of benzoate esters, which correlate with Hammett s but with a much larger r value in the range 2.0–2.4. The observed sensitivity to substituents is in keeping with stabilisation by electron-withdrawing groups of partial carboxylate character in the transition state. Reaction with azide ions N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides also react rapidly with azide to give quantitative yields of non-crossover esters and two equivalents of nitrogen. As with hydroxide, the
84
S.A. GLOVER N R'
O N
N
N OR O R'' O
O
δ– N
SN2
N R'
N
N
N N
OR
O δ–
N N OR
O
R''
R'
O
R'' O
O
76
81
83
82 -N2 O
N2 +
OR
HERON
R'
N N
OR
R' O
67
68
a R=alkyl, R'=alkyl,aryl, R''=CH3 b R=Me, R'=R''=H
Scheme 15.
reaction rates are fast, but could be monitored dilatometrically in aqueous acetonitrile at 294 K. At this temperature, a reaction between N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 27a showed first order dependence upon concentrations of both mutagen and azide and yielded a bimolecular rate constant of ca. 1.9 l mol1 s1.44 The product formation is outlined in Scheme 15. The intermediate N-alkoxy-N-azidoamide 82a, which is also formed rapidly from N-alkoxy-N-chloroamides, reacts by loss of nitrogen to give 1-acyl-1-alkoxydiazene 68a. The same intermediate was formed in the stepwise decomposition of N,N0 -diacyl-N,N0 -dialkoxyhydrazines (Scheme 12)131,156 and its HERON decomposition to ester 67a and nitrogen, a very low EA process, has been verified computationally.36,172 In our detailed theoretical study of reaction pathways of the model N-azidoN-methoxyformamide 82b we showed that decomposition by loss of nitrogen was the energetically most favourable process with an EA of only 5.3 kcal mol1 at B3LYP/6-31G*.36 In addition this step is exothermic by 42–44 kcal mol1. Thermal decomposition of 68b to methyl formate 67b and nitrogen has an EA of only 2.9 kcal mol1 and is exothermic by 95 kcal mol1. Overall, the conversion of 82b to methyl formate 67b and two molecules of nitrogen is thus predicted to be exothermic by 137–139 kcal mol1. The nucleophilic attack of azide on 76b was also modeled at the pBP/DN*//HF/ 6-31G* level (Table 10, Fig. 23).44 In the gas phase the transition state is preceded by an ion–molecule complex (Fig. 23a) which is at a minimum on the reaction coordinate and in which the azide anion is 3.7 A˚ from the amide nitrogen, and approaching the axis of the formyloxy–nitrogen (N1–O9) bond but in which the azide possesses all the anionic charge. The reaction is computed to be exothermic in the gas phase (DE ¼ 13.3 kcal mol1) and more so with solvation (DE ¼ 17.0 kcal mol1) but
85
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 10 pBP/DN*//HF/6-31G* energies of reactants, ground state complex, transition state and products for reaction of azide with N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 76ba Structure
E (Hartree)
Eaq (Hartree)b
HCON(OCHO)OMe 76b N 3 [76b–N3] complex HCON(N3)OMe 82b HCO 2 83b T.s. 81b
473.05455 164.31803 637.39671 448.09735 189.29648 637.40085
473.06748 164.43783 637.50844 448.11401 189.41833 637.49775
a
ZPE not included. Energies include AM1 solvation energies.
b
N4
N2
N3
N3
N4 N2
O8
C7 C6
O11 N1 O9 C10
(a)
O5
N1–N2=3.722Å N1–O9=1.383Å O9–N1–N2=166.5° N1–N2–N3=135.6° C7-N1–O9=109.9° O9-N1–O5=107.6° C7–N1–O5=111.5° O8–C7–N1–N2=162.9°
O5 C6 C7
N1
O8 O9 C10
O11
N1–N2=2.403Å N1–O9=2.053Å N2–N3=1.170Å N3–N4=1.140Å N1–C6=1.479Å N1–O5=1.251Å C7–N1–N2=74.3° C7–N1–O9=84.9° O5–N1–N2=92.9° O5–N1–O9=98.9° N2–N1–O9=158.6° C7–N1–O5=109.1° O8–C7–N1–O5=175.4° O9–N1–O5–C6=97.4° O8–C7–N1–O5=174.9°
(b)
Fig. 23 HF/6-31G* geometries for (a) the ground state complex and (b) the transition state in the reaction of azide anion with N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 76b.
the transition state, while at a saddle-point, is lower in energy than the ion–molecule complex (EA ¼ 2.6 kcal mol1) in accord with the expected stabilisation due to charge delocalisation; the charge on azide (1) is shared by both the azide (0.76) and the formate group (0.62) in the transition state. Decreased solvent stabilisation of the transition state relative to the intermediate complex is important and inclusion of semiempirical solvation energies resulted in a small positive EA of 6.7 kcal mol1. A similar EA was determined for the reaction of ammonia but there solvation, which exerts greater stabilisation in the transition state than on the ground state, reduced the gas phase EA from 22.6 to 4.4 kcal mol1. The computed energetics suggests a facile SN2 reaction in agreement with the experimental findings. Attack of hydroxide, though not modelled computationally, has similar, large rate constants in aqueous organic medium. Rate constants for the reaction of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides with aromatic amines or glutathione are slower by two to three orders of magnitude.42,43,105,185 In the computed transition state (Fig. 23b) the azide and formyloxyl groups are approaching colinearity (N2–N1–O9 ¼ 158.61) and the SN2 displacement is
86
S.A. GLOVER
predicted to be concerted but non-synchronous. The increase in negative charge of the formate group [Dqformate ¼ 0.65] is larger than the decrease in negative charge over the azide group [Dqazide ¼ +0.24], which is indicative of more N1–O9 bond stretching than N2–N1 bond formation. In this respect the transition state is similar to that reported for the corresponding reactions of ammonia with the same mutagen model.45 However, the transition states for those reactions, involving neutral nucleophiles, exhibited significant charge separation as opposed to the charge delocalisation in the azide reaction transition state. Near coplanarity of O8–C7–N1–O5–C6 indicates that the lone pair on N1 is completely out of conjugation with the carbonyl at the transition state and both the C7 and O5 p-orbitals are aligned with the partial bonds between N1 and the incoming azide and departing formate. The EA for azide reaction on N-formyloxy-N-methylformamide was 22.2 kcal mol1 higher than reaction with the N-methoxy model. A similar result was obtained to the reactions of ammonia and reinforces the activating influence of N-alkoxy groups upon SN2 reactions in anomeric N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. Finally, the corresponding reactions of azide with N-chloro-N-alkoxyamides has been used as an excellent source of highly hindered esters.44 The rearrangement of 68–67 (Scheme 15), apart from being highly favourable energetically, is characterised by an early transition state with little disruption to the carbonyl. In these HERON reactions, the N–C(O) bond breaks in concert with the MeO–C bond formation after the transition state along the reaction coordinate and the process is akin to an SN2 reaction on an acyl carbon. Accordingly ester formation is not restricted by the constraints in normal Fischer esterification where formation of the tetrahedral intermediate is destabilised by bulky alcohol and acyl groups.186–188 Reaction with thiols185 Glutathione is a biological reducing and conjugating agent with a manifold of physiological functions.189 It is present in cells in concentrations up to 5 mmol and reacts with a range of xenobiotics, in particular molecular electrophiles or metabolites. Its role in this regard is to render such molecules soluble and excretable.190,191 N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are molecular electrophiles and react with DNA inducing mutagenic changes. Preliminary work has indicated that they interact with glutathione in cells and an NMR study of the behaviour of N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide 25c and glutathione 84 in d6-DMSO/D2O indicated rapid consumption of both reactants. The products were the oxidised form of glutathione 86, the hydroxamic ester butoxybenzamide 85, and acetic acid (Scheme 16). By monitoring NMR integrals the reaction was shown to be bimolecular (k303 ca. 2 102 l mol1 s1) but 2 thiol was consumed at twice the rate of 25c. The reaction that best accounts for the products invokes initial attack upon N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide by glutathione giving N-butoxy-N-(S-glutathiyl)benzamide intermediate 88a (Scheme 17). Rapid, non-rate-determining reaction of 88a with a second molecule of glutathione yields the disulfide 89a and hydroxamic ester 85. N-Acetylcysteine was unreactive but L-cysteine
87
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES O
O O
N O
N H
CH3 D2 O/d6-DMSO
O
O
85
25c
AcOH HOOC
H2N O HOOC
H N
H2N
O
O
HN
N H
O
COOH
N H
COOH
S 2
HS 86
84
Scheme 16.
H S R R
87
O
OBu N OAc
O –AcOH
N S
OBu
R 25c
: SH
S
R
O
R
88
S 89
Ph
N H 85
OBu
a RS=glutathiyl b RS=(L)-cysteinyl methyl ester c RS=(L)-cysteinyl ethyl ester
Scheme 17.
methyl and ethyl esters 87b and 87c reacted in a similar fashion to glutathione. In particular, the L-cysteine ethyl ester reaction with several N-benzoyloxyN-benzyloxybenzamides 28 could be monitored nicely by 1H NMR in d4-methanol under pseudo unimolecular conditions and over a range of temperatures. Arrhenius studies afforded data presented in Table 11. Activation energies and entropies of activation are in the same region as those for SN2 reactions of neutral N-methylaniline. Large negative DSz values are again in accord with increased charge separation with attendant solvation in the transition state. The rate constants at 298 K correlate with Hammett s values with r ¼ 1.13 (r ¼ 0.985) in keeping with a development of benzoate character in the transition state. The reactions of glutathione and cysteine esters have been modeled by the reaction of methanethiol with N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 at the BP/ DN*//6-31G* level.45 The transition state (Fig. 24) possesses similar characteristics
88
S.A. GLOVER
Table 11 Arrhenius activation energies, entropies of activation and rate constants at 298 K for reaction of N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 28 with L-cysteine ethyl ester in d4methanol EA (kcal mol1) DSz (cal K1 mol1) 104 k298 (l mol1 s1) 2
ln A
Substrate (Z)
28a (Z ¼ H) 9.46 28b (Z ¼ OMe) 21.89 28d (Z ¼ Me) 10.43 28e (Z ¼ Cl) 14.36 28h (Z ¼ NO2) 15.30
(1.17) (3.84) (1.89) (2.49) (3.02)
8.71 16.36 9.22 10.80 10.79
(0.7) (2.2) (1.1) (1.3) (1.6)
S1
43.66 18.99 41.73 33.94 32.07
51.3 31.3 57.0 200.0 523.2
0.9862 0.9819 0.9738 0.9716 0.9786
S1-N2 = 2.062Å N2-O3 = 2.408Å N2-C4 = 1.501Å N2-O5 = 1.296Å S1-N2-O3 = 147.3° C4-N2-O5 = 109.0° C4-N2-O3 = 69.5° C4-N2-S1 = 100.3° O5-N2-O3 = 103.9° O5-N2-S1 = 108.7° N2-S1-C10 = 95.3°
C10
C6
N2
O5
(2.3) (7.6) (3.8) (4.9) (6.0)
r
O3-N2-O5-C6 = -80.9° O7-C4-N2-O5 = -14.4°
O7 C4 O9 O3
C8
Δq (OCHO) = -0.72 Δq (CH3SH) = +0.40 Δq (CHO) = +0.06 Δq (N) = +0.25 Δq (OCH3) = +0.02
Fig. 24 HF/6-31G* optimised geometry and changes in group charges (relative to reactants) for the transition state for SN2 displacement of formate from N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 by methanethiol.
to that for the reaction of ammonia. The nucleophile and leaving groups are approaching colinearity (147.31) and the methoxyl group is nearly orthogonal to the departing NO(CHO) bond (80.91) which is marginally longer (2.408 A˚) than where ammonia (2.316 A˚) was concerned. Nitrenium ion character is likewise developed in an asynchronous transition state. Charge separation (Dq (OCHO) ¼ 0.72; Dq (CH3SH) ¼ +0.4)) is greater for the thiol reaction which can be accounted for by the lower electronegativity of sulfur although the rates of L-cysteine ethyl ester correlate with Hammett s with slightly lower sensitivity (r ¼ 1.1) than the reaction with anilines (r ¼ 1.7). The model reaction has a low EA of 4.2 kcal mol1 and is exothermic by 5.9 kcal mol1 (Table 12). Clearly the experimental energies are higher than that predicted for the model reaction but the bulkier cysteine residues can be expected to influence the ease of reaction relative to methyl in methanethiol.
89
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 12 pBP/DN*//HF/6-31G* energies of reactants, transition states and products for the reaction of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 with methanethiola Structure
E (Hartree)
Eaq (Hartree)
CH3SH CHON(OCHO)OCH3 40 [CHON(SHCH3)OCH3]+ HCO 2 T.s. (Fig. 24)
438.77211 473.05454 722.34182 189.29648 911.79233
438.77458 473.05540 722.42609 189.41328 911.82333
a
Lowest energy conformers; ZPE not included.
O X
N O 90
OR
O
R'OH X
Me
N
OR
+ AcOH
OR'
O a X=NR''2 b X=OR''
91
Scheme 18.
Alcoholysis reactions Kostyanovsky and coworkers have demonstrated that prolonged reaction of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyureas 90a in neat alcohols leads to displacement of acetate and formation of symmetrical and mixed N,N-dialkoxyureas 91a (Scheme 18).52 The reactions work with primary alcohols (MeOH, EtOH and PrOH) but 2-propanol required longer reaction times. Tert-butanol was unreactive, presumably for steric reasons. The corresponding carbamates 90b reacted similarly giving 91b, but in certain cases the major product was, instead, the dialkylcarbonate. Methanolysis of ethyl N-acetoxy-N-methoxycarbamate 92 afforded ethyl methylcarbonate 96 and the dimethoxy product 95 in 44% and 34% yields, respectively, which was accounted for by SN1 reactions to give the alkoxynitrenium ions 93 that undergo loss of alkoxynitrene to form the alkoxycarbonyl acyl cation 94 (Scheme 19, pathway (i)). It is possible and energetically more feasible that this reaction proceeds rather by a HERON rearrangement (Scheme 19, pathway (ii)). While this reaction is likely to be slow, the alcoholysis reactions were carried out over long reaction times. These authors also reported that N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides did not undergo methanolysis under the same conditions but treatment of N-acetoxy-N-ethoxybenzamide 25a in more forcing conditions with NaOMe in DME afforded a mixture of ethyl and methylbenzoate, 97 and 98 (Scheme 20). They attributed the formation of the former to a HERON reaction and methyl benzoate to the direct attack of methoxide at the amide carbonyl. It is seems plausible that the HERON reaction to give ethyl benzoate 97 involves the anion of N-ethoxybenzohydroxamic acid 99, formed by methoxide reaction at
90
S.A. GLOVER O
O
MeOH
OMe
EtO
N OAc
EtO
-AcOH Path (i)
92
N
OMe
O
-MeON EtO
93
94 MeOH
Path (ii) O N OMe
EtO
O
HERON
OMe
-MeON
OMe
EtO
95
96
Scheme 19.
MeO –/DME
O Ph
N
OEt
O
O Ph
OEt
Ph
OMe
OAc 25a
97 O
-MeOAc X
98
HERON N
OEt
O 99
Scheme 20.
the ester carbonyl, by analogy with the reaction of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides and hydroxide discussed above.
THERMAL DECOMPOSITION REACTIONS
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are thermally unstable at modest temperatures. The pyramidality at nitrogen and anomeric weakening of N–O bonds results in decomposition by several pathways including both heterolytic and homolytic processes. Homolytic cleavage of weakened N–OAcyl bonds results in formation of a longlived alkoxyamidyl radical and a reactive acyloxyl radical. Preliminary studies have indicated that the alkoxyamidyls, so produced can intercept the products of acyloxyl radical reactions. However, the N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are also suitably disposed to HERON rearrangements in which the acyloxyl substituent migrates to give anhydrides. Recently, examples of both types of processes have been demonstrated.192
91
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Free radical decomposition A number of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxybenzamides 100 have been shown to decompose in mesitylene at temperatures above 1001C giving a complex mixture of products including the N-alkyl adduct 106, the corresponding alkyl ester 108, anhydride 101 and a product (up to 60% yield in cases), which was characterised as 1,4,2-dioxazoline 104 (Scheme 21). Minor products included hydroxamic ester 105 and mesitylene adduct 109. Formation of both adduct 106, mesitylene adduct 109 and heterocycle 104 can be ascribed to homolysis (Scheme 21, pathway (i)). Decarboxylation of acyloxyl radical gives radicals, R0 d, which either combine with the persistent free radical 102 giving 106 or, by abstracting hydrogen from solvent, give 3,5-dimethylbenzyl radicals, which combine with 102 to give 109. Formation of the dioxazoline 104 would appear to require hydrogen abstraction from the oxymethylene position of radical 102 to give the diradical 103, which undergoes cyclisation. B3LYP/6-31G* calculations predict the all cis singlet state of 103e is more stable than the lowest triplet state by some 26 kcal mol1 and, as indicated in Scheme 21, is strongly dipolar (Table 13). Intramolecular hydrogen transfer to the carbonyl oxygen followed by electron transfer is less likely due to the absence of an obvious oxidant. In addition, hydrogen transfer from carbon to oxygen in the methoxyformamidyl 102e is computed to be endothermic by 13 kcal mol1 using B3LYP/6-31G*. These unusual products as well as adducts 109 and 106 may be attributed to the persistence of alkoxyamidyls; they are isoelectronic with nitroxyl radicals and have significant delocalisation onto oxygen and hence, thermodynamic stability. The ESR
O R'' –NOCH2R
N O 100 –NOCOR'
O 101
O
OCH2R R' O
O
R''
N
O
O
R''
103
N
O
104
R' Δ
Mesitylene Path (i)
O R''
H H
O
R
N O
OCH2R NH
O R''
R''
102
– N2
105
O
O
OCH2R
N R''
108
N
R''
R
R
O
OCH2R N R' 106
HERON Path (iii)
O R''
R
H
O
HERON Path (ii)
O R''
R'
107
OCH2R
OCH2R N
R'' 2
109
Scheme 21.
a R =4-ClPh; R'=Me, R''=Ph b R= 4-ClPh, R'=Me, R''=But c R= Pr, R'=Hexyl, R''=Ph d R= Pr, R'=Hexyl, R''= But e R=R'=R''=H
92
S.A. GLOVER
Table 13 B3LYP/6-31G* energies of optimized geometries for reaction of methyl radical with methoxyamidyl S0 102e Structure 103e S0 (cis– cis) 103e T1 (trans– trans) CH4 102e (trans– trans) CH3d T.s. (Fig. 25b) DEb EAc
Energy (au) 283.076675 283.034466 40.518428 283.713092 39.838234 323.528342 0.0437771 0.0229837
Energy (kcal mol1) 0.0 26.4a
27.4 14.4
a
Relative to So. E (CH4+103e S0) – E (CH3d+102e). c E (T.s.) – E (CH3d+102e). b
hyperfine coupling constant to nitrogen in amidyls (AN) is typically 1.48 mT while that of N-alkoxyamidyls is 1.04 mT, indicating a significant delocalisation away from the nitrogen atom.193,194 Unlike electrophilic amidyls, which add to alkenes and arenes, alkoxyamidyls are more nucleophilic and persistent.194 Their lifetimes in solution appear to enable capture of less stable free radicals formed in their presence either in solvent cage reactions or after escape from the solvent cage. In the case of formation of diradicals 103 leading to the dioxazoline 104, the nature of the abstracting species is as yet unclear although alkyl radical is more likely than acyloxyl radical, which would decarboxylate rapidly at these temperatures. N-Alkyl adduct 106 is most probably formed in a cage reaction. Formation of ester 108 could involve dimerisation of alkoxyamidyls 102 and thermal rearrangement of the hydrazines 107 to esters and nitrogen according to Scheme 12, although a HERON reaction (Scheme 21, pathway (iii)) cannot be discounted under these conditions (vide infra). Anhydrides 101 are almost certainly formed by a HERON reaction (Scheme 21, pathway (ii)). Yields of products are extremely variable and highly dependent upon reaction conditions (temperature, concentration, atmosphere) and the nature of the side chains. For instance, N-acetoxy-4-chlorobenzyloxybenzamide 100a afforded mostly ester 108a and little cyclic product whereas the corresponding pivalamide 100b gave dioxazoline 104b, ester 108b and anhydride 101b in proportions of 6:1:9.6. Similarly, N-butoxy-N-heptanoyloxybenzamide 100c gave dioxazoline 104c, ester 108c and anhydride 101c in proportions of 2.2:1:5.1 but the corresponding pivalamide 100d afforded mostly anhydride 101d. The hydrogen abstraction from alkoxyamidyl 102 has been modeled at B3LYP/ 6-31G* level by the reaction of methyl radical (R0 ¼ CH3 d), with methoxyformamidyl 102e giving 103e and methane. Energies are presented in Table 13. Formation of methane and 103e from alkoxyamidyl and methyl radical has an activation barrier of only 14.4 kcal mol1 but this would be expected to be lower
93
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
1.093Å
1.236Å
1.354Å 1.396Å O1
N1 C2 O2 C1 1.438Å
1.536Å
1.218Å
1.237Å H2
(a)
N1 1.385 154.3° O2 C1 1.369 1.223
C2 H1 1.364
1.357Å 1.419Å
N1 C1 O2
1.269Å
O1
O1C1N1O2=0.2° C1N1O2C2=0.2° N1O2C2H1=-0.1° N1O2C2H2=179.9°
H1 C2 H2
O1
(b)
(c)
Fig. 25 B3LYP/6-31G* structures for (a) methoxyformamidyl 102e, (b) transition state and (c) 103e from methyl radical reaction with N-methoxyformamidyl. Table 14 Arrhenius activation energies, entropies of activation and rate constants at 373 K for thermal decomposition of N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 26a, 26b, 26d, 26e and N-acetoxy-N-(4-nitrobenzyloxy)benzamide 27h in mesitylene192 ln A
Substrate (X, Y) 26a (X ¼ H) 26b (X ¼ MeO) 26d (X ¼ Me) 26e (X ¼ Cl) 27h (Y ¼ NO2)
27.27 29.99 31.28 26.03 30.05
(2.02) (3.21) (0.56) (1.59) (5.28)
EA(kcal mol1) 27.65 29.45 31.17 26.04 30.08
(1.55) (2.45) (0.44) (1.20) (4.05)
DSz (cal K1 mol1) 6.32 0.92 1.63 8.78 0.81
(4.0) (6.4) (1.1) (3.2) (10.5)
105 k373
r
4.20 5.62 1.99 10.7 2.53
0.9938 0.9931 0.9996 0.9958 0.9823
with larger alkoxy or benzyloxy groups. The transition state is computed to be early along the reaction coordinate (Fig. 25b), resembling methyl and amidyl radicals. The methyl radical centre is largely planar at the transition state and transfers about 0.12 electrons to the alkoxyamidyl. In keeping with this, hydrogen abstraction followed by heterocycle formation should be favoured by electron-withdrawing groups at the oxymethylenic position (C2 in Fig. 25b), and yields of heterocycle 104a with 4-nitrobenzyloxy- and 4-chlorobenzyloxy groups were greater than with benzyloxy or 4-methylbenzyloxy substituents. Reaction leading to the triplet diradical is exothermic by 1.0 kcal mol1 but singlet formation would be exothermic by 27.4 kcal mol1. Arrhenius data for thermal decomposition of several N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides is presented in Table 14. While the reactions, when monitored by HPLC obeyed first order kinetics, rate constants must represent the summation of rate constants of parallel processes, which were not followed individually, and EA and DSz represent an envelope of energies and entropies for several processes.
HERON reactions Thermal decomposition of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides in mesitylene yielded, in certain cases, significant quantities of anhydrides formed by intramolecular processes. HERON reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides would be expected to favour migration of acyloxyl groups since anomeric effects are strongest in this direction
94
S.A. GLOVER O R3
Na+
O
Path (i) R
3
Na+
O2CR2 N OR1 N OR1 O 111 112 C R2 O O O Na+ NaH+ R3 2 Path (ii) R3 R N OR1 N OR1 O C O O 114 113 C R2 O Na+ O R2 Na+ O R3 C O Path(iii) R3 N O2CR2 N O O R1 O 116 115 R1
Scheme 22.
(Figs. 4 and 5b). However, such reactions ought only to manifest themselves in gaseous or non-polar media; in aqueous or polar organic solutions (H2O/CH3CN, CH3OH) heterolysis to solvated alkoxynitrenium and carboxylate ions is favoured as evidenced by the AAl1 solvolysis reactions described earlier in this chapter. SN2 reactions too are favoured in polar solvents on account of polar separation in the transition states. Anhydrides have never been observed as side-products from the AAl1 or SN2 reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides by our group37–43 or in Shtamburg’s recent studies.52 Mesitylene, on the other hand, is a high boiling, nonpolar medium in which it is reasonable to expect HERON reactions, provided these are energetically possible. Such reactions ought also to be feasible in the gas phase at higher temperatures. The first unequivocal evidence for HERON reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides emerged from ESI-tandem mass spectrometric studies on a number of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides.158 Under these conditions, free from solvent, the sodiated parent ion 110 can be detected, which fragments under collision induced dissociative conditions into three sodiated product ions (Scheme 22, Table 15). These products exhibited masses corresponding to the sodiated N-alkoxyamidyl radical 111, which in most cases was the major pathway (Scheme 22, pathway (i)) but the second most intense product ion was the sodiated anhydride 113 formed through HERON rearrangement of the acyl group (Scheme 22, pathway (ii)). The ester 115 that would be formed through an alternative HERON migration of the alkoxyl group (Scheme 22, pathway (iii)) was a weak product ion in all cases where it was present, and absent in the fragmentations of all aliphatic amides 110h–l. The fragments from these reaction processes are presumed to be acyloxyl radical 112, alkoxynitrene 114 and acyloxynitrene 116.
95
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES Table 15
a b c d e f g h i j k l
M/z for sodiated ions from ESI-MS of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides 110a–la 110
111
113
115
274 302 362 404 370 426 336 288 302 394 316 330
215 243 303 345 249 305 215 167 181 273 195 209
187 215 275 317 249 249 249 201 215 307 229 243
201 229 – – 235 291 – Trace – – – –
a
ESI conditions in positive ion mode: H2O/MeOH; drying gas 350 1C; capillary ¼ 30 V; CID ¼ 5 to 30 eV.
R3
O
Na+
N OR1 O C R2 O
110 a R1=Bu, R2=Me, R3=Ph b R1=Bu, R2=Me, R3=3,5-diMeC6H3 c R1=Bu, R2=Me, R3=fluoren-1-yl d R1=Bu, R2=Me, R3=2-anthraquinon-2-yl e R1=R2= R3=Ph f R1=4-But, R2=R3=Ph g R1=Bu, R2= R3=P h
h R1=Bu, R2= Ph R3=n-Pr i R1=Bu, R2= Ph R3=Bui j R1=Bu, R2= Ph R3=1-Ad k R1=Bu, R2= Ph R3=But l R1=Bu, R2= Ph R3=neopentyl
According to B3LYP/6-31G* calculations on N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 and its HERON rearrangement transition states, in the gas phase, migration of acyloxyl group is favoured over the alkoxyl group by about 4 kcal mol1 (Table 16). Two conformations of the methoxyl migration (Fig. 26c and d) were found with very similar energies. The three transition states (Fig. 26b–d) are relatively similar with the migrating formyloxyl oxygen O1 in Fig. 26b or methoxyl oxygen O3 in Fig. 26c and d perpendicular to the O3–N1–C1 or O1–N1–C1 planes, respectively. The HERON transition state for formyloxyl group migration (Fig. 26b) appears looser and later, which would be expected on account of the polarities involved. The N1–O1 and C1–O1 bonds in Fig. 26b are longer than those to O3 in either Fig. 26c or d. The magnitude of the activation energies indicates that such migrations are unlikely to compete with heterolysis of the N–OAc in polar solvents. While the influence of the spectator sodium ion on these reactions is unknown, clearly the ESI-MS-MS data reflects the expected migration tendencies of acyloxyl versus
96
S.A. GLOVER
Table 16 B3LYP/6-31G* computed energies for ground state and HERON migration transition states for N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 Structure
E (Hartree)
Relative E (kcal mol1)
Frequency (cm1)
Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig.
472.851865 472.790221 472.782035 472.783513
0.0 38.7 43.4 42.9
271i 210i 282i
26a 26b 26c 26d
O4 1.416Å 1.203Å
N1
O2
C3
1.382Å
C1
C2
1.446Å
<110.4°>
O3 O1 2.071Å
O2
O1
76°
N1
C2
1.559Å-
C1 O4
C3
1.799Å-
(a)
O3
(b)
C3
C3
O2 O3
O3 1.723Å
N1
C2
2.041Å
C1 (c)
1.798Å
N1
O4
C2 O1
O2
1.467Å 56°
61°
1.496Å
O4
1.939Å
O1
(d)
C1
Fig. 26 B3LYP/6-31G* geometries for (a) ground state of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide 40 and transition states for migration of (b) formyloxyl and (c,d) methoxyl groups.
alkoxyl moieties in these substrates. The alkoxyl oxygen, though more electronegative than nitrogen, is a better donor atom than the acyloxyl oxygen, which is bonded to an electron withdrawing carbonyl carbon. Hence, the acyloxyl group migration would be preferred. The formation of anhydrides 101 in the thermal decomposition reactions of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides in non-polar mesitylene (Scheme 21, pathway (ii)) can thus be attributed to HERON migration of acyloxyl groups. However, the similarity of EAs for the two isomeric transition states raises the possibility that in these reactions some, or all of the ester might be generated by HERON migration of the alkoxyl substituent (Scheme 21, pathway (iii)).
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
5
97
Biological activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides constitute a class of mutagenic compounds and the premise that, as N-alkoxy analogues of metabolites from aromatic amines, they would act as electrophiles towards DNA, proved to be correct. Almost all those N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides tested to date are mutagenic in the Ames test.195,196 Moreover, unlike the aromatic amines that spawned the research into this class of amides, they are direct-acting mutagens that damage DNA without the need for metabolic activation, i.e. they are in an ultimate mutagenic form.47–49 It is widely understood that metabolic activation is intrinsic to the mode of action of many substances that are known to be carcinogenic60,65,170,197–199 and metabolites so produced are more active than their precursors. Usually such metabolites are electrophilic towards DNA and react with the DNA bases at nucleophilic positions such as N7, N2 and O6 of guanine (G-N7, G-N2 and G-O6) or N3 of adenine (A-N3).169,170,200 Pullman and Pullman illustrated that the electrostatic potential in the region of N7-G is not only the most negative, but that the magnitude of the negative potential increases significantly at guanines in single-stranded and duplex DNA.169 It is this site in the major groove that is most often modified by alkylating agents such as mustards, alkyl sulfonates or dialkylsulfates.170,200 These form primary alkyl cations, or, as in the case of aziridinium ions from nitrogen mustards, masked alkyl cations which are hard Lewis acids and would be expected to react at N7-G according to Pearson’s hard–soft acid/base theory. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are no exception and have been shown to react with plasmid DNA at G-N7 in the major groove at physiological pH as well as at A-N3 in the minor groove in slightly acidic solution.49,105 However, the active form is not the alkoxynitrenium ion as originally advocated, rather N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides behave as molecular electrophiles towards DNA. Their direct mutagenicity makes them excellent vehicles for investigating mechanisms of mutagenesis and structural influences upon the mutagenic process and we have utilised many analogues as probes for drug–DNA interactions.46,49,50
MUTAGENICITY IN THE AMES SALMONELLA/MICROSOME ASSAY195,196
The Ames test is a bacterial assay for identifying substances that can produce genetic damage that leads to mutations and it utilises various mutant forms of S. typhimurium that have a histidine requirement that is reverted by mutagenic agents. In the presence of these, they produce this amino acid, which is essential for their growth. Assays are performed on agar plates and mutations are registered through colonies proliferated from reverted bacterial cells. The test is quantitative and in the right dose range usually affords linear dose response curves; numbers of revertants (colonies) are proportional to the exposure to mutagenic material. One of the most widely used strains, TA100, is reverted by point mutations, that is, by basepair substitutions upon replication after DNA damage, which restores the genetic functionality. Such damage can be inflicted by electrophilic species.
S.A. GLOVER
1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
-S9
0
0.03
0.06 0.12 (μmol/plate)
Revertants
Revertants
98
0.25
(a)
1000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0
y = 3056.8x + 157.48 R2 = 0.9934
y = 2716.3x + 161.3 R2 = 0.9953
0
0.1 0.2 (μmol/plate)
0.3
(b)
Fig. 27 Dose–response plots for N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 28a in S. typhimurium TA100: (a) comparison of activity with and without S9 and (b) linear plots without S9.
The assay can be performed using mutagenic substances that react directly with DNA or, where metabolic activation is necessary, with pre-mutagen in the presence of rat liver homogenate that is enriched in mixed function oxidases (termed S9). Metabolic oxidation (if that is what is required) results in ultimate or penultimate mutagenic forms, which act as electrophiles towards S. typhimurium. N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides have been shown to mutate S. typhimurium TA100 to the same extent both with, and without the need for metabolic activation.47,48 Fig. 27a illustrates activities of N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 28a at various doses both in the presence and absence of S9. Activity is largely the same at all but the maximum dose where the activity in the absence of S9 is reduced owing to toxicity of mutagen at this dose level (such toxicity is removed in presence of S9). Fig. 27b shows duplicate linear dose responses for this mutagen and typifies both the linearity and reliability of the assay with N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. In these assays, there is a background spontaneous reversion (value at zero dose), which is subtracted from reversion rates at all doses. Gradients yield mutagenic activity at 1 mmol per plate, which are used for comparative purposes. O
O
O
N O
N
N O
117
118
O
O
O
O 28a
The need for electrophilicity at the amide nitrogen was demonstrated by comparison of the mutagenic activity of 28a with that of two analogues with similar structure, N-benzoyloxy-N-benzylbenzamide 117, which possesses a leaving group but without anomeric destabilisation and N-benzyl-N-benzyloxybenzamide 118,
99
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES 1800.0 1600.0 y = 2572.3x + 282.58 R2 = 0.9914
Revertants
1400.0 1200.0
28a
1000.0 800.0 600.0 400.0
117/118
200.0 0.0 0
0.1
0.2
0.3 0.4 (μmol/plate)
0.5
0.6
Fig. 28 Mutagenic activities N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 28a, N-benzoyloxyN-benzylbenzamide 117 and N-benzyl-N-benzyloxybenzamide 118 in S. typhimurium TA100 without S9. KM
kA
[Mutagen]
[Mutagen][DNA]
[Adduct]
+ [Carboxlate]
Path (i) Path(ii)
kN
– Carboxylate
Path(iii)
KN [Nitrenium ion] + [Carboxylate]
kN [Nitrenium ion][DNA]
Scheme 23.
which is a hydroxamic ester without a leaving group at nitrogen.49,105 While the latter is not an electrophile and would not be expected to undergo either nitrenium ion formation nor SN2 reactions at nitrogen, 117 could in principle react by either mechanism. However calculations of SN2 activation energies for replacement of formate from N-formyloxy-N-methylformamide by ammonia, methanethiol and azide all indicated a much higher barrier for this process when compared to the N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide.44,45 In a direct comparison, N-benzoyloxyN-benzyloxybenzamide 28a gave an excellent dose response over the range 0–0.5 mmol per plate while 117 and 118 were completely inactive over the same dose range and returned only background reversion rates (Fig. 28). The experiment showed that only a nitrogen bearing a leaving group anomerically destabilised by the geminal alkoxyl oxygen (an anomeric amide), is reactive. The activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides can be attributed to direct attack of the mutagens upon DNA (Scheme 23, pathway (i)) or, as was originally proposed, reaction to form N-acyl-N-alkoxynitrenium ions (Scheme 23, pathway (ii)). In either
100
S.A. GLOVER
case, two processes are involved, which are described by equilibrium constants KM and kA along pathway (i) and by KN and kN along pathway (ii). Equilibrium constants KM and KN represent respectively binding of intact mutagen or nitrenium ion into the grooves of DNA. Rate constants kA and kN are respective rates of reaction of bound mutagen or nitrenium ion at G-N7 of DNA. O
O R
X
N O AcO
25
O Bu
N O AcO
26
O Y
N O
N O O O
AcO
27 Z
28
Table 17 presents mutagenic activities in S. typhimurium TA100 at 1 mmol per plate without S9 for a wide range of mutagens investigated to date. A number of qualitative observations can be made:
A comparison of the activity levels of N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamides 26, N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 27 and N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 28 with common para substituents showed increasing mutagenicity with size or hydrophobicity. Activities increased with increasing aromatic substitution. Activity increases with larger alkoxyl substituents in N-acetoxy-N-alkoxybenzamides 25 indicating a hydrophobic effect upon mutagenicity (entries 1–4). The greater relative activity of all tested members of series 28 (entries 22–32) when compared with the N-acetoxy analogue, 27a (entry 14), as well as variation in activity of various 28 congeners and other mutagens with different leaving groups showed clearly that the mutagens must bind intact to DNA rather than generate N-acyl-N-alkoxynitrenium ions intracellularly, since 27a and all members of 28 would generate the same ionic intermediate. If this were the case, mutagenic activities would be similar. Mutagenic activities across series 28 (entries 22–32) showed a distinct dependence upon the electronic effect of the substituent; activity is greatest with electron donor and weakest with electron-withdrawing substituents at Z. Steric effects of substituents on various side chains are important as exemplified by tert-butylated mutagens (entries 13, 21, 30, 41–47). While substrates bearing one tert-butyl group on the para position of either the benzyloxy, benzoyloxy or benzamide rings have slightly lower activities within each series, the presence of two or more such groups leads to strongly reduced activities.
Activity is strongly influenced by mutagen functionality and structure, its reactivity, hydrophobicity and the steric effects of substituents.
X,Y,Z,Ra 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
log Pc
pKAd
E 2s e
E 2s f
E 3s g
Ih
Calc.i
2.49 2.53 2.88 2.40
1.54 2.02 4.11 1.86
4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
2.35 2.48 3.06 2.44
0.14 0.05 0.18 0.04
2.50 2.73 2.92 2.48 2.54 2.69 2.16 2.45 2.37
2.44 2.32 4.12 2.93 3.0 3.27 2.48 2.48 4.15
4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76
0 0.55 2.41 1.24 0.97 1.16 1.76 0 2.78
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2.60 2.49 2.73 2.56 2.62 2.67 2.37 2.61 2.69
0.10 0.24 0.19 0.08 0.08 0.02 0.21 0.16 0.32
2.63 2.70 3.06 3.09 2.78 2.76 2.74 2.60
2.93 2.81 3.96 4.61 3.42 3.49 3.76 4.64
4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.76
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0.55 0.55 2.41 1.24 0.97 1.16 2.78
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2.73 2.62 2.94 2.83 2.68 2.74 2.79 2.78
0.10 0.08 0.12 0.26 0.10 0.02 0.05 0.18
3.22 3.06 3.70 3.29 3.12
4.83 4.70 6.51 5.32 5.39
4.20 4.31 4.21 4.37 3.99
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0.55 2.41 1.24 0.97
0 0 0 0 0
3.15 3.08 3.39 3.20 3.17
0.07 0.02 0.31 0.09 0.05
Diff.j
101
22 23 24 25 26
PhCON(OAc)OR (R) 25a Et 25b Pr 25e Octyl 25f Pri X-C6H4CON(OAc)OBu (X) 26a H 26b MeO 26c Ph 26d Me 26e Cl 26f Br 26g p-NO2 26h m-NO2 26i But PhCON(OAc)OCH2C6H4-Y (Y) 27a H 27b MeO 27c PhO 27d Ph 27e Me 27f Cl 27g Br 27i But PhCON(O2CC6H4-Z)OBn (Z) 28a H 28b MeO 28c Ph 28d Me 28e Cl
log TA100b
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 17 Ames mutagenicity data for Salmonella typhimurium TA100 and physicochemical parameters for N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides together with predicted activities according to QSAR (Equation 4)
102
Table 17 (continued ) log TA100b
log Pc
pKAd
E 2s e
E 2s f
E 3s g
Ih
Calc.i
2.87 2.96 2.69 3.20 2.94 3.23
4.58 4.86 4.86 6.54 4.86 4.70
3.73 3.55 3.42 4.35 3.45 4.09
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
1.01 0.51 1.76 2.78 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
2.88 2.97 2.83 3.39 3.00 3.09
0.01 0.01 0.14 0.19 0.06 0.14
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
28f CHO 28g CN 28h NO2 28i But 28k m-NO2 (bzyl) 28l m-MeO (bzyl) R1CON(O2CR2)OR3(R1,R2,R3) 34 Ph,Me,-(CH2)629f Ph,Ph,Bu 30a Me,Me,Bu 30b Me,Ph,Bu 30c Me,Me,Bn 30d Me,Ph,Bn 37a Ph,Me,2,6-diMeBn 29u 3,5-diMePh, Me,Bu
2.96 2.70 1.94 2.65 2.22 2.90 3.04 2.74
3.55 4.34 0.54 2.44 1.04 2.93 3.91 3.42
4.76 4.20 4.76 4.20 4.76 4.20 4.76 4.76
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2.91 3.01 2.07 2.48 2.21 2.62 3.01 2.87
0.05 0.31 0.13 0.17 0.01 0.28 0.03 0.13
41 42 43
31a 31b 33a
4-ButPh,Ph,Bn Ph,Ph, 4-ButBn 4-ButPh,Me, 4-ButBn
3.50 3.05 2.89
6.54 6.54 6.31
4.20 4.20 4.76
2.78 0 2.78
0 2.78 2.78
0 0 0
0 0 0
3.24 3.19 2.86
0.26 0.14 0.03
44 45 46 47
31c 31d 31e 32a
Ph, 4-ButPh , 4-ButBn 4-ButPh, 4-ButPh,Bn 4-ButPh,Ph, 4-ButBn Ph,3,5-diButPh,Bn
1.86 2.61 1.64 2.07
8.24 8.24 8.24 8.24
4.35 4.35 4.20 4.38
0 2.78 2.78 0
2.78 0 2.78 0
2.78 2.78 0 0
0 0 0 0
3.44 3.48 3.28 4.13
1.58 0.87 1.64 2.06
48 49 50 51 52 53 54
29m 30g 29r 30f 30h 30i 30m
2-Naphthyl,Me,Bu Me,Me, CH2-2-Np Me,2-Np,Bu Me,Me, CH2-1-Np Me,Me,(CH2)2-2-Np Me,Me, (CH2)3-2-Np Me, CH2-1-Np, Bu
3.59 3.57 3.64 3.53 3.41 3.47 3.41
3.44 2.03 3.44 2.03 2.31 2.73 3.38
4.76 4.76 4.16 4.76 4.76 4.76 4.30
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
3.74 3.34 3.61 3.34 3.42 3.54 3.62
0.15 0.23 0.03 0.19 0.01 0.07 0.21
27 28 29 30 31 32
Diff.j
(0.71) (1.09) (0.89) (1.05) (0.85) (0.79) (0.65)
S.A. GLOVER
X,Y,Z,Ra
X,Y,Z,Ra 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71
30k Me,1-Pyr,Bu 30l Me, CH2-1-Pyr,Bu 29n 2-Fl,Me,Bu 29o 2-Aq,Me,Bu RCON(OBz)OBu (R) 29a Et 29b Pri 29c But 29d CH2But 29e 1-Ad PhCON(O2CR)OBu (R) 29g Pr 29h Pri 29i (S)-2-Bu 29j CH2But 29k 1-Ad 29l But 29s 2,6-diMePh 29t 3,5-diMePh
log TA100b
log Pc
pKAd
E 2s e
E 2s f
E 3s g
Ih
Calc.i
Diff.j
3.92 3.70 2.93 2.39
4.59 4.54 4.18 2.83
3.68 4.30 4.76 4.76
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
1 1 1 1
3.83 3.95 3.94 3.57
0.09 0.25 1.01 1.18
2.39 2.41 1.96 2.38 2.51
3.10 3.66 4.37 4.31 5.12
4.20 4.20 4.20 4.20 4.20
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
2.66 2.82 3.02 3.00 3.23
0.27 0.41 1.06 0.62 0.72
2.47 2.05 2.23 2.42 2.73 2.30 2.43 2.73
3.51 3.66 4.08 4.31 5.12 4.37 5.31 5.30
4.82 4.85 4.80 4.80 4.86 5.03 3.56 4.34
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2.91 2.96 3.06 3.13 3.36 3.19 3.14 3.30
0.44 0.91 0.83 0.71 0.63 0.89 0.71 0.57
(0.95) (0.61) (0.15) (0.32)
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Table 17 (continued )
a
103
X, Y, Z, and R’s are substituents specified for each series; Np ¼ naphthyl, Pyr ¼ pyrenyl, Fl ¼ fluorenyl, Aq ¼ 9,10-anthraquinone-2-yl and Ad ¼ 1-adamantyl. b Log of the gradient of the dose-response plot in the linear region; activity at 1 mmol per plate. c Log P is the hydrophobicity (log octanol–water partition coefficient) calculated according to the Ghose–Crippen algorithm.201 d pKA of the carboxylic acid corresponding to the N-acyloxyl substituent. e Taft steric parameter for para substituent on benzamide side chains. f Taft steric parameter for para substituent on benzyloxy side chains. g Taft steric parameter for para substituent on benzoyloxy side chains. h Indicator variable for polycyclic aromatics; I ¼ 1 if present, I ¼ 0 if absent. i Calculate log TA100 according to QSAR (Equation 4). j Difference between predicted and observed log TA100; values in parentheses are computed with I ¼ 0.
104
S.A. GLOVER
Activity and structure The observation that different leaving groups impart quite different mutagenic activity is good support for binding of the drugs to DNA before reacting. Activity must follow pathway (i) of Scheme 23 where the overall structure controls the equilibrium constant KM. Further support for this came from in vitro DNA damage studies from which we showed that the DNA damage profiles of mutagens with different substitution patterns vary markedly and, as well, have different pH dependence.49,105 Since mutagens with identical backbones and different leaving groups would produce common nitrenium ions, which would give rise to identical damage patterns, these results are inconsistent with nitrenium ion formation (Scheme 23, pathway (ii)). However, they do not distinguish between intact binding followed by nitrenium ion formation (Scheme 23, pathway (iii)) as opposed to direct SN2 attack upon the bound mutagen. Activity and stability Series 28 contains a diverse range of electronic effects on the benzoyloxy ring. A plot of log TA100 against Hammett s constants for all but the 4-methoxy 28b (toxic) and 4-phenyl 28c (significantly more hydrophobic) was linear with negative gradient (Fig. 29).48 In reactivity, the same series of mutagens exhibited positive Hammett correlations for AAl1 acid catalysed solvolysis (r ¼ +0.32) and SN2 reactivity with N-methylaniline (r ¼ +1.7), hydroxide (r ¼ +0.55) and L-cysteine ethyl ester (r ¼ +1.1), all reactions in which the benzoyloxyl group leaves with electrons and which are therefore accelerated by electron-withdrawing groups. The negative Hammet r-value for 3.7 ρ = -0.49 R = 0.913
3.5
Log TA100
3.3
3.1
Me
H
m-MeO Cl
But
CN 3-NO2
2.9
CHO
2.7
2.5 -0.2
4-NO2
0
0.2
σ
0.4
0.6
0.8
Fig. 29 Hammett correlation of mutagenicities of 28 at 1 mmol per plate without S9.
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
105
mutagenicity therefore indicates that activity correlates not with their reactivity (which would require a positive r-value) but with their stability to chemical reactions. Furthermore, activity should correlate positively with pKA of the departing carboxylic acid although this dependency is likely to be greater for Series 28. Experimental or calculated pKAs for all substrates are found in Table 17. This inverse correlation has been noted in other instances of biological activity. The cytotoxic activity of a range of duocarmycin analogues behaved similarly.202,203 In these situations, biological activity will be reduced for reactive substrates that are consumed intracellularly or in a biological assay. In the case of N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides, those mutagens that are less prone to solvolysis or reaction with adventitious nucleophiles such as glutathione, will be present at higher concentrations at DNA, the intracellular target. Activity and hydrophobic effects The dependence of drug activity and most other biological interactions on hydrophobicity is well established.204 Qualitatively, the mutagenicity of N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides shows a clear dependence upon this property, which can be represented by the log of the octanol–water partition coefficient, P. Log P can be evaluated additively by a variety of algorithms and using the Ghose–Crippen method,201 mutagenic activity of mutagens of entries 1–43 in Table 17 correlated with log P according to the following equation: log TA100 ¼ 0:20ð0:02Þ log P þ 2:06; ð0:09Þ ðn ¼ 43; r ¼ 0:819; s ¼ 0:2; F ¼ 84Þ
(2)
Relatively little is known about the role of specific interactions, including the role of hydrophobicity, in targeting small molecules to DNA.205,206 A number of studies have pointed to hydrophobicity being a factor in determining the activity of mutagenic intercalating agents207,208 and of a number of classes of indirect-acting mutagens.204,209 The latter must undergo metabolic activation to an electrophilic form and the impact of structural changes upon binding to DNA is unclear as other hydrophobic interactions, predominantly those with activating enzymes, play a role. There is reasonable evidence from a range of studies that mutagens requiring metabolic activation have a log P dependence in the region of 1.0. To date, with the exception of one study on sulfonate esters, the activities of direct-acting mutagens have been thought to be independent of hydrophobicity and this has even been seen as a characteristic of direct mutagenicity.204–206 Equation 2 indicates that the activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides, unquestionably a class of direct-acting mutagens, is dependent upon their hydrophobicity.48 The lower coefficient in these studies must relate to their association with bacterial DNA. Activity and steric effects The influence of steric effects on mutagenicity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides is clear from the data presented in Table 17. Despite their much higher hydrophobicities, all
106
S.A. GLOVER
mono tert-butylated mutagens, exhibit lower or similar activity to that of their unsubstituted variant (Table 17, entries 13/5, 21/14, 30/22, 41/22, 42/22 and 43/14). The N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides bearing two or more tert-butyl groups exhibit radically reduced activities considering their increased hydrophobicity (Table 17, entries 44–47). Steric effects are also apparent in the activities of several mutagens in series 28. In Fig. 29 the 4-tert-butyl group in 28i, the 4-nitro substituent in 28h and perhaps the CHO in 28f result in lower activity than would be expected on electronic grounds alone. Realistic prediction of the mutagenic activities of this class of mutagens requires a physicochemical evaluation of steric effects of substituents and the most widely utilised measures of such are Taft steric parameters, Es (Table 17).204,210 Quantitative structure activity relationships (QSAR) governing activity of N-acyloxyN-alkoxyamides Entries 1–43 in Table 17 constitute an excellent training set for QSAR. Substrates from classes 25–28 have representative electronic, and steric requirements as well as wide ranging hydrophobicity (over five log P units). Multivariate analysis incorporating log P, pKA and steric effects E1s , E2s and E3s for para substituents on the benzamide, benzyloxy and benzoyloxy side chains afforded a QSAR (Equation 3): log TA100 ¼ 0:29ð0:03Þ log P þ 0:21ð0:09ÞpK A þ 0:15ð0:04ÞE 1s þ 0:16ð0:04Þ E 2s þ 0:11ð0:05Þ E 3s þ 0:86ð0:46Þ ðn ¼ 43; r ¼ 0:897; s ¼ 0:16; F ¼ 30:3Þ
ð3Þ
Relative to QSAR (2), there was a considerable improvement in the correlation, which showed a strong dependence upon log P and, as expected from the full set, a moderate pKA dependence. Based on the errors, steric impact is real for the benzamide and the benzyloxy side chains while that for the benzoyloxy is less reliable.50 Observed versus predicted mutagenicities from QSAR (3) are plotted in Fig. 30 (filled squares). The mutagenic activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides reflects their interaction with the primary target, which in this case is bacterial DNA. The predictive model (Equation 3) allows discovery of structural factors that either increase or diminish DNA damage. Such effects can operate either upon binding to DNA or reactivity with DNA. Both types of structural impacts have been observed. Intercalation effects50. The mutagenicities of seven naphthalene-containing mutagens (119, Table 17, entries 48–54) are plotted in Fig. 30 (circles). All six show mutagenic activity on average about 0.9(70.1) log TA100 unit higher than predicted from QSAR (3), which would indicate a greater propensity to damage DNA over and above that determined by hydrophobicity and pKA alone. Activity enhancement
107
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES 4.0
Observed TA100
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5 1.5
2.0
2.5 3.0 Predicted TA100
3.5
4.0
Fig. 30 Predicted versus observed mutagenic activities (log TA100) for (a) mutagens in Table 17 (entries 1–43, filled squares) and (b) naphthalene substrates (entries 48–54, circles) based upon QSAR (3).
is most probably greater than that considering that steric impact of such groups is not accounted for in QSAR (3). Mutagenicity data is supported by DNA damage studies, which showed significantly greater damage for mutagens bearing naphthalene.49,105 O R3
O R1
N O O C R2 O R1= 2-Np, 1-Np, CH2-2-Np, (CH2)2-2-Np and R2=R3=Me R2= 2-Np, CH2-2-Np and R1=Bu, R3=Me R3=2-Np and R1=Bu, R2=Me
119
Me
O Bu
N O O C R O R=1-pyrenyl, CH2(1-pyrenyl)
120
R
Bu N O O C Me O
R=2-Fluorenyl, 9,10-anthraquinon-2-yl
121
Such activity enhancement can be ascribed to planarity of the naphthalene nucleus and its disposition for p–p stacking between the DNA base pairs. There is no literature precedence for involvement of naphthalene in such processes unless it is p electron deficient.211,212 However, our results suggest that both alkylated and acylated naphthalenes are intercalators with bacterial DNA.
108
S.A. GLOVER
Reconstitution of the QSAR to incorporate an indicator variable I for the presence (I ¼ 1) or absence (I ¼ 0) of a naphthalene nucleus yields QSAR (4). log TA100 ¼ 0:28ð0:03Þ log P þ 0:21ð0:09ÞpK A þ 0:14ð0:04Þ E 1s þ 0:15ð0:04Þ E 2s þ 0:09ð0:05Þ E 3s þ 0:86ð0:07ÞI þ 0:93ð0:44Þ ðn ¼ 50; r ¼ 0:927; s ¼ 0:16; F ¼ 45:6Þ
ð4Þ
Observed versus predicted mutagenicities from QSAR (4) and incorporating all seven naphthalene containing mutagens are plotted in Fig. 31 in which naphthalene data are represented by open circles. Predicted activities of all mutagens by this equation are presented in Table 17. For entries 48–58, values in parentheses are differences between predicted (I ¼ 0) and observed activities. Remarkably, comparison of the dependence upon the indicator variable I, and log P gives an estimate of the value of including naphthalene anywhere in a mutagen’s structure. Naphthalene is worth 3 log P units of hydrophobicity to binding to DNA. It is presumed that the intercalative binding increases residence time upon DNA resulting in greater probability of the DNA damage leading to a mutation event. The parent hydroxamic acid of 30g, N-(2-naphthylmethyloxy)acetamide was completely inactive in the Ames test so that the activity of the mutagen, is not due to naphthalene intercalation itself.213 The fact that presence of naphthalene on the leaving group is equally effective lends further support for pathway (i) in Scheme 23, which invokes pre-association of intact mutagens with DNA. QSAR (4) would appear to be a useful measure of whether other similar polycyclic aromatics can intercalate with DNA. Two pyrene-containing mutagens N-butoxyN-(1-pyrenecarboxoyloxy)acetamide and N-butoxy-N-(1-pyreneacetoxy)acetamide 29k
4.0
29l
Observed TA100
3.5
3.0
29n
2.5
29o
2.0
1.5 1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
Predicted TA100
Fig. 31 Predicted versus observed mutagenic activities (log TA100) for (a) mutagens in Table 17 (entries 1–43 (squares), 48–54 (circles)) and (b) other polycyclic substrates (entries 55–58, triangles, diamonds) based upon QSAR (4).
109
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
120 fit QSAR (4) with indicator value I ¼ 1 and deviate significantly with I ¼ 0 (Fig. 31, triangles; Table 17, entries 55 and 56). Presumably the pyrene nucleus has a similar intercalative binding ability to naphthalene. However, data for a fluorene analogue and a mutagen bearing an anthraquinone-2-yl structure 121 best fit with I ¼ 0, (Fig. 31, diamonds; Table 17, entries 57 and 58). Both these may not intercalate in the same manner. To generalise these findings more mutagens bearing pyrene, fluorene and anthraquinone moieties must be tested. Other polycyclic aromatic systems can be treated likewise. Thus, the mutagenicities of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides may provide an intracellular means of quantifying structural elements of molecules in terms of their ability to target drugs to DNA; they can be used as probes for drug–DNA interactions.50 Steric effects46. The mutagenicities of all mono 4-tert-butylated mutagens 26i, 27i, 28i, 31a,b and di-tert-butylated 33a (Table 17, entries 13, 21, 30, 41–43) are predicted well according to the QSAR (4) (Fig. 32, filled squares). In particular, the activities of the triarylated mutagens 28i, 31a and 31b bearing a single tert-butyl group are adequately predicted. Binding and reaction of these mutagens with DNA would appear to be unimpeded by the presence, on one aryl ring, of the bulky tert-butyl group. However mutagenicities for 122 and 123 with more than one tert-butyl group were markedly lower. The four di-tert-butylated N-benzoyloxy-N-benzyloxybenzamides 31c–e and 32a (Fig. 32, solid circles, Table 17, entries 44–47) deviate very significantly from the predicted values and the triarylated mutagens 31f and 32b were completely inactive. 4.5
Observed TA100
4.0 3.5 3.0 30b 29a
29d
29e 32a
2.0 29c 1.5 1.5
31d
29b
2.5
2.0
2.5
31c 31c
3.5 3.0 Predicted TA100
4.0
4.5
Fig. 32 Predicted versus observed mutagenic activities (log TA100) for mutagens in Table 17 (entries 1–43, 48–58 squares), di-tert-butylated analogues 31c–e, 32a (122, 123, entries 44–47, closed circles) and alkylamides 30b, 29a–e (124, entries 36, 59–63, triangles) based upon QSAR (4).
110
S.A. GLOVER O
O
R3
R1 N O O C O
R N O O C O
R2 But
R1= R2=But, R3=H R1=R3=But, R2=H R2=R3=But, R1=H R1= R2=R3=But
But R=But, H 123
122
Lack of reactivity towards SN2 reactions at nitrogen would in itself account for low mutagenic activity. However, the tert-butyl groups on 31c–f and 32a,b are well removed from the reactive nitrogen and, as well, SN2 reactions of mutagens 31c–e with N-methylaniline in methanol at 303 1C occur with relatively similar rate constants to that of unsubstituted 28a, and of mono tert-butylated systems 28i and 31a,b (Table 18). The steric impediment of para aryl substituents to damage of DNA and which is accounted for in the QSAR’s (3) and (4) through Taft steric parameters E1s , E2s and E3s , presupposes that the mutagen can enter the major groove where bulkiness of substituents presumably impacts upon alignment of the mutagen for reaction with guanine. The radical decrease in activity of mutagens 31c–f and 32a,b suggests that, in these cases, the drugs cannot react with DNA since they are either too large to enter the major groove or, once in the groove, are unable to achieve the transition Table 18 Bimolecular rate constants for the reaction of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides bearing bulky substituents with N-methylaniline in d4-methanol Substrate (Z, R1, R2, R3)
104k303(l mol1 s1)
Substrate (R1, R2, R3)
104k313(l mol1 s1)
193.3a 117.2a 798.5c
30b (R1 ¼ Bu,R2 ¼ Ph) 29a (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ Et) 29d (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ neopentyl) 29b (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ Pri) 29c (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ But) 29e (R2 ¼ Ph, R3 ¼ 1adamantyl)
97.2b 8.1 2.2
28a, Z ¼ H 28i Z ¼ But 31a R1 ¼ R2 ¼ H,R3 ¼ But 31b R1 ¼ But, R2 ¼ R3 ¼ H 31c R1 ¼ R2 ¼ But, R3 ¼ H 31d R1 ¼ H R2 ¼ R3 ¼ But, 31e R1 ¼ R3 ¼ But, R2 ¼ H a
From reference 43. From reference.105. c From reference 46. d No reaction at this temperature. b
578.5c 353.0c 156.6c 369.8c
d d d
111
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
state for reaction with G–N7, the putative site of DNA attack. A comparison of the activity of 33a with that of 31e, or the mono tert-butylated N-benzoyloxyN-benzyloxybenzamides 28i, 31a,b with the di-tert-butylated substrates 31c–e suggests that there is a critical bulk beyond which, even with conformational flexibility, inclusion in the major groove or reaction of the nucleotide at the electrophilic amide nitrogen becomes difficult. The computed transition state for SN2 reaction at nitrogen requires the ‘‘backside’’ attack of the nucleophile on the nitrogen and approximately on line with the bond to the acyloxyl leaving group.45 With such constraints the transition state may be reached with one tert-butyl group on one of the three benzene rings but is unattainable with two such substituents. With respect to the generalised Scheme 23, it is likely that the di-tert-butylayted mutagens have a very low KM. Fig. 33a gives the AM1-optimised transition state for the reaction of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide with 9-methylguanine. Using the angular and bond length constraints in this transition state (at G-N7, mutagen N1 and formyloxy oxygen O1), mutagen 31b models into the major groove as shown in Fig. 33b. It is clear, even form this crude representation that, while one tert-butyl group can be accomodated along the direction of the groove, para positions on the other two aromatic rings could not include a second tert-butyl substituent without imposition of very significant steric constraints. Notably, X-ray data5 or AM1 calculations on tri-tert-butylated mutagen 31f provide an indication of the maximum dimensions between any two tert-butyl groups as between 14 and 17 A˚, which greatly exceed the width of the major groove of B-DNA (12 A˚).
N7-N1 = 1.643 Å N1-O1 = 1.976 Å
12Å
O4
C3 N1
N7
6Å O1
C1 O3
O2
(a)
C2
(b)
Fig. 33 (a) AM1-optimised transition state for reaction of N-formyloxy-N-methoxyformamide with G-N7; (b) conformation of 31b in the major groove of DNA constrained to transition state in (a) with side chains minimised by molecular mechanics.
112
S.A. GLOVER
While all di-tert-butylated substrates exhibit no or low activity, 31d is less affected. While this may be attributed to the particular configuration, it is also the least reactive towards SN2 reactions (Table 18), which, on account of the inverse relationship between mutagenicity and reactivity, would generate higher activity. O R
Bu N O O C Ph O
R=Me, Et, Pri, But, CH2But, 1-adamantyl 124
Mutagenicity of a limited number of alkylamides 124 have been investigated.46,50,105 In particular, the series 29a–e together with 30b (Fig. 32, triangles, Table 17, entries 36, 59–63) constitute a series with increasing branching adjacent to the amide carbonyl. Remarkably, the deviations from the predicted mutagenicities increase through the series Me(30b)oEt(29a)oPri(29b)oBut(29c), the latter being virtually inactive. The deviation of the bulky 1-adamantamide derivative 29e is similar to that of the pivalamide 29c. Clearly branching at the a-carbon is an important factor controlling activity. Comparison of the activity of the pivalamide 29c with that of the neohexamide 29d also indicates a diminishing steric influence as the tert-butyl group is moved one methylene away from the carbonyl. Unlike the di and tri-tert-butylated mutagens 31c–f and 32a,b the overall dimensions of substrates 29a–b would not be expected to impede their access to the major groove. We attribute the systematic reduction in activities to an increase in the activation barrier for reaction at G-N7 as a consequence of branching at the a-carbon. The ease of SN2 reaction of these substrates with N-methylaniline broadly supports this (Table 18). The rate constant at 313 K for reaction of propanamide 29a is an order of magnitude smaller than that of the acetamide 30b,105 while mutagens with the isopropyl and the tert-butyl amide side chains, 29b,c, are unreactive with N-methylaniline at this temperature. In addition, while the pivalamide 29c is unreactive, the neohexamide 29d, in which the branching is one methylene removed from the reactive nitrogen is susceptible to SN2 reaction with N-methylaniline, albeit with a smaller rate constant than 29a. The adamantane carboxamide mutagen 29e is also resistant to SN2 reactions at nitrogen. Clearly there are some differences between reactivity and mutagenic activity, in that the isobutyramide substrate 29b, which exhibits impaired mutagenicity, is unreactive towards SN2 reactions with N-methylaniline and the adamantamide 29e, though resistant to SN2 reaction with N-methylaniline at matching temperatures, is still marginally mutagenic. However, such reactions are also dependent upon the nature of the nucleophile and the solvent environment. For instance, while the tert-butyl-containing amide side chain in 29c completely inhibits attack by
113
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
N-methylaniline at nitrogen, similarly substituted N-chloroamides react readily with azide, which is known to be a stronger nucleophile.44 Differences between experimental SN2 reaction rates and the mutagenicity data may also be related to the influence of the hydrophobic environment within the major groove; solvent organisation about a polar SN2 transition state44,45 accounts for substantially negative entropies of activation in the reactions of these mutagens with N-methylaniline (Table 5). Such a contribution would presumably be different or absent in reactions at G-N7. Overall, though, relative mutagenicities in this series follow SN2 reactivities and would appear to be controlled by steric inhibition of the substitution reaction at the amide nitrogen rather than any steric inhibition to binding in the major groove. In these substrates the magnitude of kA in Scheme 23 would appear to be limiting. As pyramidal amides5,32 their SN2 reactivity with neutral nucleophiles like N-methylaniline parallels that of a-haloketones with amines, which, as described in an earlier section, are also strongly affected by steric effects on the a0 -carbon.183 SN2 reactions are in general strongly and adversely influenced by steric effects and branching b to the reactive centre and the same appears to be true for N-acyloxy-Nalkoxyamides 30b and 29a–e. Broadly speaking, their mutagenic activity is affected similarly. The arguments presented herein lend the strongest support to SN2 attack by G-N7 at the amide nitrogen of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides and for pathway (i) in Scheme 23 rather than pathway (iii) in which, once bound to DNA, the mutagens undergo SN1 formation of reactive nitrenium ion. Though beyond the scope of this review, steric inhibition of mutagenicity by remote214,215 and proximal alkyl substituents 216,217 has recently been established by Boche and coworkers in studying the Ames mutagenicity of 4-nitro- and 4-aminobiphenyls. The effects with these are more difficult to interpret than our mutagens since in both cases enzymatic activation is involved (nitroreductase [–NO2] and cytochrome P450 oxidases [–NH2]) and intercalative binding is also a possibility. Inhibition to reaction with G-C8 was also proposed to explain reduced mutagenicities. In our system, metabolic activation is not required. Furthermore, there is no suggestion that simpler mutagens without polycyclic aromatics intercalate with DNA.50 It is clear from this study that bulky distal groups can have a significant influence upon the actual groove binding with bacterial DNA whereas proximal branching inhibits reaction with DNA. O Ph
Bu N O O C R O
R=Me, Bu, Pri,(S)-2-Bu But, CH2But, 1-adamantyl, 2,6-diMePh, 3,5-diMePh 125
114
S.A. GLOVER
Activities of another group of mutagens 125 bearing increasingly bulky leaving groups showed yet a third type of steric effect. All alkyl groups adjacent to the benzoyloxy carbonyl in 29g–l (Fig. 34, filled circles, Table 17, entries 64–69) reduced activity but branching resulted in an average deviation from the predicted activity of 0.8(70.1) log TA100. In this series, rates of SN2 reaction with aniline were correlated negatively with pKA of the departing carboxylic acid and were independent of steric effects (Table 8). Like alkylamides 29a–e, this series would gain access to the major groove but substituents in this case present no barrier to SN2 reactivity. Rather, the bulkiness must impact upon ease of reaction with DNA (upon kA in Scheme 23) by imposing constraints on the transition state for reaction at G-N7. The activity difference between dimethylated benzoyloxy systems 29s and 29t (Fig. 34, triangles, Table 17, entries 70 and 71) supports this. While the 3,5dimethylbenzoyl system in 29t would subtend the normal small angle between the aromatic ring and the carbonyl, the 2,6-dimethyl substitution would result in a high degree of twisting resulting in greater steric demand (Fig. 35). Notably, N-(2,6-dimethylbenzyloxy)-N-acetoxybenzamide 37a and N-acetoxyN-butoxy-3,5-dimethylbenzamide 29u (Fig. 34, black squares, Table 17, entries 39 and 40) were well modelled by QSAR (4). The difference between predicted and observed activities for 37a (0.03) and N-acetoxy-N-isopropoxybenzamide 25f (0.04) (Table 17, entry 4) suggests that steric effects proximate to the reactive nitrogen but on the alkoxyl side chain are less important in terms of reactivity with DNA. This is most probably a consequence of the greater flexibility in this side chain relative to the acyloxyl or amide groups.
4.5
Observed TA100
4.0 3.5 3.0 29t 29g 29j 29s 29I 29h 29i
2.5 2.0 1.5 1.5
2.0
2.5
29k
3.0 3.5 Predicted TA100
4.0
4.5
Fig. 34 Predicted versus observed mutagenic activities (log TA100) for mutagens in Table 17 (entries 1–43, 48–58 squares), 29g–l(entries 64–69, circles) and 29t and 29s (entries 70 and 71, triangles) based upon QSAR (4).
115
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES O
O Ph
N O
OBu
Ph
O
H3 C
N O
OBu O
CH3 H3C 29s
CH3 29t
Fig. 35 Conformations in N-(2,6-dimethylbenzoyloxy)- and N-(3,5-dimethylbenzoyloxy)N-butoxybenzamides. ANTICANCER ACTIVITY OF N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
Preliminary investigations highlighted the cytotoxic and anticancer activity of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides. Four mutagens, N-acetoxy-N-butoxybenzamide 26a, N-acetoxy-N-benzyloxybenzamide 27a, N-(4-methylbenzoyloxy)-N-benzyloxybenzamide 28d and N-acetoxy-N-butoxy-2-naphthamide 29m were found to be reproducibly cytotoxic towards P388 mouse leukemia but with IC50 values in the range of 15–19 mmol. QSAR (4) provides a means of selecting side chains for optimal mutagenicity and DNA damage. N-Butoxy-N-(pyrene-1-carboxoyloxy)acetamide 30k with a log TA100 ¼ 3.92, is the most potent mutagen we have discovered to date. This together with three other mutagens N-benzoyloxy-N-butoxybenzamide 29f (log TA100 ¼ 2.7), N-acetoxy-N-(2-naphthylmethyloxy)-acetamide 30g (log TA100 ¼ 3.57) and N-butoxy-N-(2-naphthoyloxy)benzamide 29r, (predicted log TA100 ¼ 4.14) were tested in the NCI 60 cell line in vitro screen.218 The standardised screen evaluates activity in 60 human cancer cell lines. Overall quality of activity is measured by a mean over all strains of the growth inhibition index (average of the doses causing 50% growth inhibition, GI50, across all 60 cell lines), and can be used for comparative purposes. Of the four mutagens, the pyrene analogue was most active with a mean GI50 of 4.63. Data from the other three mutagens gave GI50 values close to the cut-off concentration of 1 104 M. The mean GI50 of 30k rivals that of some anticancer agents widely used in cancer chemotherapy (busulfan 3.7; cyclophosphamide 3.67; melphalan 4.8; uracil nitrogen mustard 4.63).219 However, the establishment of QSAR (4) and further refinement in its predictive accuracy should lead to identification of better anticancer drug candidates based upon the N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides.
6
Conclusions
N-Acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides are a class of biologically active amides, which are members of the recently identified class we have termed anomeric amides. These are
116
S.A. GLOVER
amides with two heteroatoms bonded at the nitrogen. Structurally, spectroscopically and chemically, this functional group is best described as an N-acylamine since the nitrogens are sp3 hybridised resulting in little or no amide nitrogen overlap with the carbonyl. In N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides the heteroatoms are oxygens and this review has dealt with the unique manifestations of this substitution pattern where substituents are acyloxyl and alkoxyl groups. The physical and spectroscopic properties of N-acyloxy-N-alkoxyamides confirm pyramidality at nitrogen and the disconnection of the nitrogen lone pair from the amide carbonyl. The presence of an acyloxyl and an alkoxyl group at nitrogen also results in an anomeric interaction between the oxygens, which is facilitated by the sp3-hybridised nitrogen. Experimental observations, including X-ray analysis are fully supported by results from computational chemistry. Anomeric weakening of the N–OAc bond results in four principle types of reactions:
AAl1 (or SN1)-type leading to alkoxynitrenium ions with acid-catalysis SN2-type with various organic and inorganic nucleophiles Homolytic dissociation reactions leading to stabilised alkoxyamidyl radicals HERON reactions either directly, or of products of solvolysis or SN2 displacement
They are direct-acting mutagens towards S. typhimurium TA100 with demonstrable ability to react with plasmid DNA at G-N7 or A-N3. The versatile synthetic protocol has enabled us to synthesise and test, reliably, many representatives and establish a working QSAR that has enabled us to understand intimate details of their interaction with bacterial DNA. Their biological activity can be sheeted home to binding to DNA followed, most likely, by an SN2 reaction with G-N7. Electronic and steric effects of substituents are in accord with this mechanism. The QSAR (4) cannot only highlight structural factors most likely to impact positively or negatively upon their biological activity, it can be used to probe drug–DNA interactions. QSAR (4) has already enabled identification of candidates with reasonable anticancer activity and can direct future synthesis and design to this end. This study probably represents the most systematic and detailed analysis of any set of direct-acting chemical mutagens to date.204
Acknowledgements The author acknowledges the many research students who have made significant contributions to this work as well as invaluable collaborations with Dr. Antonio Bonin, Prof Jeanne Buccigross, Prof Mike Novak, Prof Arvi Rauk and Dr. David Tucker.
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES
117
References 1. Greenberg, A., Breneman, C. and Liebman, J.F. (2000). The Amide Linkage: Structural Significance in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Material Science. Wiley & Sons, Inc, New York 2. Wiberg, K.B. (2000). Origin of the amide rotational barrier. In The Amide Linkage. Structural Significance in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Materials Science, Greenberg, A., Breneman, C.M. and Liebman, J.F. (eds), p. 33. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York 3. Wiberg, K.B. and Breneman, C. (1992). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114, 831 4. Challis, B. and Challis, J. (1979). Amides and related compounds. In Comprehensive Organic Chemistry, Nitrogen Compounds, Carboxylic Acids, Phosphorous Compounds, Sutherland, I.O. (ed.), Vol. 2, p. 957. Pergamon Press, Oxford 5. Gillson, A.-M.E., Glover, S.A., Tucker, D.J. and Turner, P. (2003). Org. Biomol. Chem. 1, 3430 6. Glover, S.A. and Rauk, A. (1996). J. Org. Chem. 61, 2337 7. Cooley, J.H., Bills, W.D. and Throckmorton, J.R. (1960). J. Org. Chem. 25, 1734 8. Johnson, J.E., Nalley, E.A., Kunz, Y.K. and Springfield, J.R. (1976). J. Org. Chem. 41, 252 9. Yamada, S. (1999). Rev. Heteroatom Chem. 19, 203 10. Yamada, S. (2000). Sterically hindered twisted amides. In The Amide Linkage. Structural Significance in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Materials Science, Greenberg, A., Breneman, C.M. and Liebman, J.F. (eds), p. 215. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, New York 11. Yamada, S. and Homma, A. (2002). Chem. Commun. 2656 12. Yamada, S. and Noguchi, E. (2001). Tetrahedron Lett. 42, 3621 13. Cow, C.N., Britten, J.F. and Harrison, P.H.M. (1998). Chem. Commun. 1147 14. Duspara, P.A., Matta, C.F., Jenkins, S.I. and Harrison, P.H.M. (2001). Org. Lett. 3, 495 15. Matta, C.F., Cow, C.C., Sun, S., Britten, J.F. and Harrison, P.H.M. (2000). J. Mol. Struct. 523, 241 16. Bain, A.D., Chen, H. and Harrison, P.H. (2006). Can. J. Chem. 84, 421 17. Matta, C.F., Cow, C.C. and Harrison, P.H.M. (2003). J.Mol. Struct. – Theochem. 660, 81 18. Otani, Y., Nagae, O., Naruse, Y., Inagaki, S., Ohno, M., Yamaguchi, K., Yamamoto, G., Uchiyama, M. and Ohwada, T. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 15191 19. Ohwada, T., Achiwa, T., Okamoto, I., Shudo, K. and Yamaguchi, K. (1998). Tetrahedron Lett. 39, 865 20. Alkorta, I., Cativiela, C.C., Elguero, J., Gil, A.M. and Jime´nez, A.I. (2005). New J. Chem. 29, 1450 21. Kirby, A.J., Komarov, I.V., Kowski, K. and Rademacher, P. (1999). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin 2, 1313 22. Kirby, A.J., Komarov, I.V. and Feeder, N. (2001). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin 2, 522 23. Kirby, A.J., Komarov, I.V., Wothers, P.D. and Feeder, N. (1998). Angew. Chem. – Int. Edit. Engl. 37, 785 24. Greenberg, A. (2000). The amide linkage as a ligand: its properties and the role of distortion. In The Amide Linkage. Structural Significance in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Materials Science, Greenberg, A., Breneman, C.M. and Liebman, J.F. (eds), p. 47. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York 25. Kirby, A.J., Komarov, I.V. and Feeder, N. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 7101 26. Bashore, C.G., Samardjiev, I.J., Bordner, J. and Coe, J.W. (2003). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 3268 27. Brown, R.S. (2000). Studies in amide hydrolysis: the acid, base and water reactions. In The Amide Linkage. Structural Significance in Chemistry, Biochemistry and Materials Science, Greenberg, A., Breneman, C.M. and Liebman, J.F. (eds), p. 85. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York
118
S.A. GLOVER
28. Lopez, X., Mujika, J.I., Blackburn, G.M. and Karplus, M. (2003). J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 2304 29. Morgan, K.L., Rawlins, M.L.M. and Montgomery, M.N. (2005). J. Phys. Org. Chem 18, 310 30. Mujika, J.I., Mercero, J.M. and Lopez, X. (2005). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 4445 31. Yamada, S. and Katsumata, H. (1999). J. Org. Chem. 64, 9365 32. Glover, S.A. (1998). Tetrahedron 54, 7229 33. Glover, S.A., Mo, G. and Rauk, A. (1999). Tetrahedron 55, 3413 34. Glover, S.A. and Rauk, A. (1999). J. Org. Chem. 64, 2340 35. Glover, S.A., Mo, G., Rauk, A., Tucker, D. and Turner, P. (1999). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 2053 36. Glover, S.A. and Rauk, A. (2002). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1740 37. Campbell, J.J., Glover, S.A. and Rowbottom, C.A. (1990). Tetrahedron Lett. 31, 5377 38. Campbell, J.J., Glover, S.A., Hammond, G.P. and Rowbottom, C.A. (1991). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 2067 39. Bonin, A.M., Glover, S.A. and Hammond, G.P. (1994). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1173 40. Bonin, A.M., Glover, S.A. and Hammond, G.P. (1998). J. Org. Chem. 63, 9684 41. Campbell, J.J. and Glover, S.A. (1992). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1661 42. Campbell, J.J. and Glover, S.A. (1999). J. Chem. Res. (S) 8, 474 43. Campbell, J.J. and Glover, S.A. (1999). J. Chem. Res. (M) 8, 2075 44. Glover, S.A. and Mo, G. (2002). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1728 45. Glover, S.A. (2001). Arkivok xii, 143 46. Andrews, L.E., Bonin, A.M., Fransson, L., Gillson, A.-M.E. and Glover, S.A. (2006). Mutat. Res. 605, 51 47. Gerdes, R.G., Glover, S.A., Ten Have, J.F. and Rowbottom, C.A. (1989). Tetrahedron Lett. 30, 2649 48. Bonin, A.M., Banks, T.M., Campbell, J.J., Glover, S.A., Hammond, G.P., Prakash, A.S. and Rowbottom, C.A. (2001). Mutat. Res. 494, 115 49. Banks, T.M., Bonin, A.M., Glover, S.A. and Prakash, A.S. (2003). Org. Biomol. Chem. 1, 2238 50. Andrews, L.E., Banks, T.M., Bonin, A.M., Clay, S.F., Gillson, A.-M.E. and Glover, S.A. (2004). Aust. J. Chem. 57, 377 51. Shishkin, O.V., Zubatyuk, R.I., Shtamburg, V.G., Tsygankov, A.V., Klots, E.A., Mazepa, A.V. and Kostyanovsky, R.G. (2006). Mendeleev Commun. 222 52. Shtamburg, V.G., Klots, E.A., Pleshkova, A.P., Avramenko, V.I., Ivonin, S.P., Tsygankov, A.V. and Kostyanovsky, R.G. (2003). Russ. Chem. Bull. 52, 2251 53. Shtamburg, V.G., Tsygankov, A.V., Klots, E.A. and Kostyanovsky, R.G. (2004). Mendeleev Commun. 208 54. Kadlubar, F., Fu, P.P., Jung, H., Shaikh, A.U. and Beland, F.A. (1990). Environ. Health Perspect. 87, 233 55. Beland, F.A. and Kadlubar, F.F. (1990). Metabolic activation and DNA adducts of aromatic amines and nitroaromatic hydrocarbons. In Chemical Carcinogenesis and Mutagenesis, Cooper, C.S. and Grover, P.L. (eds), p. 267. Springer Verlag, Secaucus 56. Lin, D.X., Bryant, M.S., Maleveille, C., Friesen, M., Bartsch, H., Lang, N.P. and Kadlubar, F.F. (1994). Environ. Health Perspect. 102, 11 57. Kadlubar, F.F. (1985). Environ. Health Perspect. 62, 19 58. Kadlubar, F.F., Miller, J.A. and Miller, E.C. (1978). Cancer Res. 38, 3628 59. Humphreys, W.G., Kadlubar, F.F. and Guengerich, F.P. (1992). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 8278 60. Blackburn, G.M. and Kellard, B. (1986). Chem. Ind. 607, 687, 770 61. Boche, G., Bosold, F. and Schroder, S. (1988). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 27, 973 62. Famulok, M., Bosold, F. and Boche, G. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 28, 337
N-ACYLOXY-N-ALKOXYAMIDES 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103.
119
Bosold, F. and Boche, G. (1990). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 29, 63 Famulok, M. and Boche, G. (1989). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 28, 468 Colvin, M.E., Hatch, F.T. and Felton, J.S. (1998). Mutat. Res. 400, 479 Panda, M., Novak, M. and Magonski, J. (1989). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 111, 4524 Helmick, J.S., Martin, K.A., Heinrich, J.L. and Novak, M. (1991). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 113, 3459 Helmick, J.S. and Novak, M. (1991). J. Org. Chem. 56, 2925 Novak, M., Kahley, M.J., Eiger, E., Helmick, J.S. and Peters, H.E. (1993). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115, 9453 Davidse, P.A., Kahley, M.J., McClelland, R.A. and Novak, M. (1994). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116, 4513 Fishbein, J.C. and McClelland, R.A. (1995). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 663 Novak, M. and Lin, J. (1999). J. Org. Chem. 64, 6032 McClelland, R.A., Davidse, P.A. and Hadzialic, G. (1995). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117, 4173 Novak, M., Kahley, M.J., Lin, J., Kennedy, S.A. and James, T.G. (1995). J. Org. Chem. 60, 8294 Novak, M. and Kennedy, S.A. (1995). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117, 574 Fishbein, J.C. and McClelland, R.A. (1996). Can. J. Chem. 74, 1321 McClelland, R.A., Kahley, M.J. and Davidse, P.A. (1996). J. Phys. Org. Chem. 9, 355 McClelland, R.A. (1996). Tetrahedron 52, 6823 McClelland, R.A., Kahley, M.J., Davidse, P.A. and Hadzialic, G. (1996). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118, 4794 Sukhai, P. and McClelland, R.A. (1996). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1529 Novak, M., Kayser, K.J. and Brooks, M.E. (1998). J. Org. Chem. 63, 5489 Novak, M. and Rajagopal, S. (2001). N-Arylnitrenium ions. In Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry, Tidwell, T.T. and Richard, J.P. (eds), p. 167. Academic Press Ltd., London Ramlall, P. and McClelland, R.A. (1999). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 225 Novak, M. and Rajagopal, S. (2002). Chem. Res. Tox. 15, 1495 Glover, S.A. and Novak, M. (2005). Can. J. Chem. 83, 1372 Kennedy, S.A., Novak, M. and Kolb, B.A. (1997). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119, 7654 McClelland, R.A., Gadosy, T.A. and Ren, D. (1998). Can. J. Chem. 76, 1327 McClelland, R.A., Ahmad, A., Dicks, A.P. and Licence, V.E. (1999). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 3303 Cheng, B. and McClelland, R.A. (2001). Can. J. Chem. 79, 1881 Glover, S.A., Goosen, A., McCleland, C.W. and Schoonraad, J.L. (1984). J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 1, 2255 Glover, S.A., Goosen, A., McCleland, C.W. and Schoonraad, J.L. (1987). Tetrahedron 43, 2577 Glover, S.A., Rowbottom, C.A., Scott, A.P. and Schoonraad, J.L. (1990). Tetrahedron 46, 7247 Kikugawa, Y. and Kawase, M. (1984). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106, 5728 Kikugawa, Y. and Shimada, M. (1987). Chem. Lett. 1771 Kawase, M., Kitamura, T. and Kikugawa, Y. (1989). J. Org. Chem. 54, 3394 Kikugawa, Y. (1996). Rev. Heteroatom. Chem. 15, 263 Wardrop, D.J. and Basak, A. (2001). Org. Lett. 3, 1053 Wardrop, D.J., Landrie, C.L. and Ortiz, J.A. (2003). Synlett 9, 1352 Miyazawa, E., Sakamoto, T. and Kikugawa, Y. (2003). J. Org. Chem. 68, 5429 Glover, S.A. and Scott, A.P. (1989). Tetrahedron 45, 1763 Schroder, D., Grandinetti, F., Hrusak, J. and Schwarz, H. (1992). J. Phys. Chem. 96, 4841 Li, Y., Abramovitch, R.A. and Houk, K.N. (1989). J. Org. Chem. 54, 2911 Srivastava, S., Ruane, P.H., Toscano, J.P., Sullivan, M.B., Cramer, C.J., Chiapperino, D., Reed, E.C. and Falvey, D.E. (2000). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 8271
120
S.A. GLOVER
104. Sullivan, M.B., Brown, K., Cramer, C.J. and Truhlar, D.G. (1998). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 11778 105. Banks, T.M. (2003). Reactivity, Mutagenicity and DNA Damage of N-acyloxy-N-Alkoxyamides. Ph.D., University of New England 106. Clements, B. and Glover, S.A. Unpublished data 107. Mu¨ller, K. and Eschenmoser, A. (1969). Helv. Chim. Acta 52, 1823 108. Rudchenko, V.F. (1993). Chem. Rev. 93, 725 109. Epiotis, N.D., Cherry, W.R., Shaik, S., Yates, Y.L. and Bernardi, F. (1977). Structural Theory of Organic Chemistry. Part III, p. 131, Springer-Verlag, Berlin 110. Mu¨ller, K. (1970). Helv. Chim. Acta 53, 1112 111. Shustov, G.V., Zolotoi, A.B. and Kostyanovsky, R.G. (1982). Tetrahedron 38, 2319 112. Dunitz, J.D. (1979). X-Ray Analysis and Structure of Organic Molecules. Cornell University Press, London 113. Winkler, F.K. and Dunitz, J.D. (1971). J. Mol. Biol. 59, 169 114. Hehre, W.J., Radom, L., v.R. Schleyer, P. and Pople, J.A. (1986). Ab Initio Molecular Orbital Theory. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, New York 115. Scott, A.P. and Radom, L. (1996). J. Phys.