ALGEBRAIC N U M B E R S A N D H A R M O N I C ANALYSIS
North-Holland Mathematical Library Board of Advisory Editors:
M.Artin, H . Bass, J. Eells, W. Feit, P. J. Freyd, F. W. Gehring, H. Halberstam, L. V. Hormander, M. Kac, J. H. B. Kemperman, H. A. Lauwerier, W. A. J. Luxemburg, F. P. Peterson, I. M. Singer and A. C. Zaanen
Algebraic Numbers and Harmonic Analysis YVES MEYER Faculte' des Sciences d'orsaj; UniversitP de Paris-Sud, France
VOLUME 2
1972 NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY - AMSTERDAM
. LONDON
AMERICAN ELSEVIER PUBLISHING COMPANY, INC. - NEW YORK
NORTH-HOLLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY - AMSTERDAM LONDON AMERICAN ELSEVIER PUBLISHING COMPANY. INC. - NEW YORK
0 NORTH-HOLLAND
P U B L I S H I N G C O M P A N Y , 1972
AN rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transntirted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 77-1 83278 North-Holland ZSBN: 0 7204 2452 6 American Elsevier ZSBN: 0 444 10357 0
Publishers: NORTH-HOLLAND P U B L I S H I N G COMPANY - AMSTERDAM N O R T H - H O L L A N D P U B L I S H I N G COMPANY, LTD. - L O N D O N
Sole distributors for the U S A and Canada: A M E R I C A N E L S E V I E R P U B L I S H I N G COMPANY, I N C . 52 V A N D E R B I L T A V E N U E NEW YORK, N.Y. 10017
PREFACE
This book is dedicated to the memory of Raphael Salem: it contains most of his beautiful discoveries acd the proof of his conjecture about the role played by Pisot numbers in the problem of spectral synthesis. I wish to express my gratitude to Mrs Deschamps, S. Drury, J.-P. Kahane, Y. Katznelson, N. Lohou6, J.-P. Schreiber and N. Varopculos for stimulating discussions. It is a pleasure to thank Mme Dumas for her very careful preparation of the manuscript. I have greatly appreciated the patience of the publisher, and the Department of Mathematics of the University of Nantes was a quiet place to write this book. Institute of Mathematics, Nantes
PRINTED I N G E R M A N Y
CONTENTS
Preface
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
List of symbols
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter I .Diophantine approximations to real numbers . . . . . . 1. Some classical results in Diophantine approximations . . . . . 2. Measure-theoretical methods in Diophantine approximations . .
Introduction
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
3 Badly approximable real numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Diophantine approximations and prediction of the size of trigonometric sums . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Kronecker's theorem and problems with a large number of equations . . 6 Pisot and Salem numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Pisot numbers. Salem numbers and harmonious sets of real numbers . . 8.Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ChapterI1.Diophantine approximations and additive problems in locally compact abelian groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Preliminaries on 1.c.a. groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Harmonious sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 . Basic properties of harmonious sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Construction of harmonious sets in 1.c.a. groups (the lacunary case) . . . 5 Construction of relatively dense harmonious sets . . . . . . . . 6 Relatively dense harmonious sets of real numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Quantitative problems 8 Harmonious sets of real numbers closed under multiplication . . . . 9 Another definition of models of real numbers . . . . . . . . . 10 Harmonious sets in p-adic fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Counter-examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Pisot-Salem-Chabauty numbers in Q, . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Adeles and harmonious sets closed under multiplication . . . . . . 14 Characterization of harmonious sets by additive properties . . . . . 15.Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
.
Chapter I11 Uniqueness of representation by trigonometric series 1. Riemann's theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Symmetric sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Pisot numbers and uniqueness . . . . . . . . . . 4 Results for symmetric sets . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
vii
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
...
CONTENTS
VIII
. .
CONTENTS
5 Other results for symmetric sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Sets of uniqueness in general 1.c.a. groups . . . . . . . . . . . 7 The p-adic case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Generalizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Other results on the problem of uniqueness . . . . . . . . . . 10.Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
96 97 100 102 103 103
Chapter IV. Problems on a-periodic trigonometric sums . . . . . . . . 1.Elementarypropertiesofalmost~periodicfunctions . . . . . . . . 2 Classes of almost-periodic functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Dilations and classes of almost-periodic functions on the line . . . . . 4 . Classes of almost-periodic functions and a priori estimates on the size . . 5 Pisot numbers and coherent sets of frequencies: the real case . . . . 6.Asetofpowers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Pisot numbers and coherent sets of frequencies: the p-adic case . . . 8.ThegroupsCandRZ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Coherent sets of frequencies in 1.c.a. groups . . . . . . . . . . 10 Coherent sets of frequencies and restriction algebras . . . . . . . 11 Other definitions of coherent sets of frequencies . . . . . . . . . 12. Other relations between A(@. B(@ and Lz . . . . . . . . . 13 Slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums . . . . . . . . . . . . 14. Coherent sets of frequencies and isomorphisms . . . . . . . . . 15.Improvement on the preceding results when A is harmonious . . . . 16 A new characterization of Pisot numbers . . . . . . . . . . . 17. Slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums in the real case . . . . . . . 18.Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
104 105 106 109 110 110 112 112 113 114 115 119 120 121 126 128 136 138 139
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
140
.
. . . . . .
Interlude
.
Chapter V Special trigonometric series (complex methods) . . 1. The Laplace transform . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Paley-Wiener theorem . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Repartition of roots of entire function of exponential type 4 . Bernstein's inequality . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Other inequalities of Bernstein type . . . . . . . . 6 Irrational numbers and special trigonometric series . . . 7 Special trigonometric series: the a-periodic case . . . . 8. Special trigonometric series onp-adic fields . . . . . 9. Mean periodic functions . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
Chapter VI . Special trigonometric series (group-theoretic methods) . . . . A. Topological Sidon sets of real numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Definition and basic properties of topological Sidon sets . . . . . . 2 Examples of topological Sidon sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Construction of remarkable measures associated with topological Sidon sets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The union of two topological Sidon sets . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Topological Sidon sets and stability of coherent sets of frequencies . . . 6 Interpolation of bounded functions defined on a topological Sidon set by the Fourier-transforms of complex bounded Radon measures on R . .
. .
. . .
ix
. . .
7 Estimates for trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to a topo. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . logical Sidon set B Idempotent and semi-idempotent measures . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Idempotent measures on 1.c.a. groups . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Semi-idempotent measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. Behaviour at infinity of special a-periodic trigonometric series . . . . 11. Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter VII .Pisot numbers and spectral synthesis . . . . . . . . 1 Spectral synthesis and structure of closed ideals of a group algebra . 2 . Spectral synthesis and atomization of distributions . . . . . . 3 A strong form of spectral synthesis . . . . . . . . . . . 4 . Spectral synthesis and weighted approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Pisot numbers and spectral synthesis 6 . Bochner's property for a Banach algebra . . . . . . . . . . 7 Bochner's property and harmonic analysis . . . . . . . 8 The p-adic case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
194 199 199 206 211 212
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . . . .
. .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . Chapter VIII . Ultra-thin symmetric sets 1 Properties of ultra-thin symmetric sets . . . . . . 2. Functions whose spectra lie in ultra-thin symmetric sets . . . . . 3 Theorem I as a corollary of Theorem I1 4 Proof of Theorem 11: reduction to a problem on intervals 5 Symmetric coherent sets of frequencies . . . . . . 6. High frequencies and independence; complements . . 7 From the group R to the group Dm . . . . . . . 8 Spectral synthesis fails in A(Dm) . . . . . . . . 9 Spectral synthesis fails in A(E) and A(R) . . . . . 10 Counter.examples . A random set due to Salem . . . 11 Other random sets . . . . . . . . . . . 12.Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
Conclusion
. . . . . . . . .
Some open problems about symmetric sets
. . . . . . . . . . . . . 263 . . . . . . . . . . . . 264
Open problems . Special trigonometric series on local fields Appendix
Index
. . . . . . .
265
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
266
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 274
LIST O F SYMBOLS
llxlj (for a real number x) . 6 A , . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 A(E),llfll*(E, . . . . . . . 115 A(G),llfIl~co - . . - . . 99 A(R),lIfll,q~,. . . . . . . . 99 B(E),llfllb'(E). ' . . ' ' ' 115 I l f l l ~. . . . . . . 98 C(G) or V(G). . . . . . 201 V,(G) . . . . . . . . . . . 97 9,9' . . . . . . . . . . . 143 E(A) . . . . . . . . . . . . 140 E ( 0 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 E ( t l , ..., E k , ...) . . . . . . 88 f . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 f * g . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 f . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 ilflll . . . . . . . . . . . 98 11 f 11 . . . . . . . . . . . 97 G d , G A . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Hom (G, H) . . . . . . . . 40 I(E) . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 L1(G) . . . . . . . . . . . 98
INTRODUCTION
Harmonic Analysis was originally devoted to periodic phenomena. The analysis of a periodic function f is achieved by the computation of the Fourier coefficients and only the knowledge off on an interval of one period is needed. Almost periodic functions are the natural aperiodic generalization of continuous periodic functions. A representation off by a Fourier series exp 2niilt exists; the setA of all L for which a, ==! 0 is the spectrum off. But now for a computation of Fourier coefficients one needs to know the function up to the end of time. This is very troublesome in applications and the modern approach is to try to get global estimates on all almost periodic functions with a given spectrum A by means of local knowledge. Let A be a set of real numbers. We say that A is a coherent set of frequencies if there exist a C > 0 and a compact set K of real numbers such that sup [PI< C sup IPI for all trigonometric sums P whose frequencies R
K
belong to A. A remarkable set of algebraic numbers, studied (among others) by Vijayaraghavan, Pisot and Salem, plays a fundamental role in the determination of coherent sets of frequencies (Chapter I, Section 6 and Chapter IV, Section 5). The study of coherent sets of real (or p-adic) frequencies is the main subject of this book. But from one chapter to another the point of view and the methods vary considerably. (From algebraic number field theory to measure theory; from Diophantine approximations to Laplace transforms and complex methods.) Chapter I contains old and new things about Diophantine approximations. The reader who does not like this subtle theory may go directly to Section 6 of Chapter I, where Pisot numbers are defined. Now there are two possibilities. The reader may begin with Chapter V or Chapter VI or VIII, which are pairwise independent and independent of
2
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
the other ones, or may follow a more logical course: Chapters 11, 111, IV and then VII. In Chapter TI, harmonious sets are studied in general groups. Defined by remarkable properties of Diophantine approximations, they give the most interesting examples of coherent sets of frequencies. In Chapter 111, we seek connections between the arithmetical structure of a compact set E of real numbers and the behavior at infinity of functions whose spectra lie in E. The famous problems of uniqueness and multiplicity receive here new treatments by the use of harmonious sets. Pisot numbers play a decisive role in this topic. If A is a coherent set of frequencies, perturbed trigonometric sums C aA(t)exp 2ni3rt whose coefficients have slow variations (corresponding
(&)-I E. The global behavior of p, may be very different from the expected one of an almost periodic function. Spectral synthesis is the study of this local approximation of p, by uniformly bounded almost periodic functions; it works if wk/ok+ is a Pisot number or if o k tends to 0 very quickly but it fails in the general case (Chapters VII and VIII). his book has been written with the idea that it can ba read by a graduate student. However, it is not an introduction to harmonic analysis. Nevertheless important classical subjects have been exposed in full detail (Laplace transform, mean periodic functions, idempotent measures).
A=A
to 'secular perturbations' in astronomy) have excellent local approximations by the uniformly bounded corresponding pure trigonometric sums aA(t,) exp 2ni3rt (Chapter IV).
C
r=n
Complex methods are introduced in Chapter V and group theoretic methods in Chapter VI to get the best known results of the tqpe: 'from local to global' for almost periodic functions whose spectra lie in a given set A of real numbers. Recent results about Sidon sets are given here. Before giving the content of the remainder of the book, a mathematical situation which is fairly common in astronomy should be described. A function p, of the time is observed on the interval 0 < t < tl; pl seems to be periodic and for the sake of simplicity it will be assumed that cp = a + b cos o , t + c sin mlt (the period TI of g, is 2n/ol). Computations are made over many such intervals [t, t + l,], t < 1, (1, is great compared with 1,); a, b and c are actually three functions of the time whose period T, is very great compared with TI(the 'secular perturbations' in astronomy). We write a(t) = a, + a; cos co,t + a; sin 0 2 t a r d we get for b and c the corresponding relations. Now g, is an almost periodic function with nine coefficients and whose frequencies are of the + E~co,),cj = - 1, 0 or 1. More careful observations form (2n)-' are made on longer and longer intervals and, at each stage, coefficients which seemed constants become periodic functions with greater and greater periods. However, p, remains bounded. A mathematical model will be built in Chapter VIII; let E be the comckwk(ck = - 1, 0 or 1, and we assume pact set of all convergent sums that mk tends very rapidly to 0). The function g, described above is any complex valued bounded continuous function whose spectrum lies in
-
-
1:
3
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
CHAPTER I
D I O P H A N T I N E APPROXIMATIONS TO R E A L NUMBERS
A great number of problems in the theory of Diophantine approximations can be set in the following form. Let A,, ...,A, be n real numbers and E a positive real number. We seek a function T (E;A,, ...,A,) = T > 0, such that each interval of real numbers of length T contains a solution t to the Diophantine inequalities IltAkll < E (1 < k < n). (For a real number x, llxll is the distance from x to the nearest integer.) For fixed A,, .. .,A,, the dependence on E of the function T has a deep connection with the 'badly approximable' real numbers (Sections 2 and 3). The dependence of this function T (E;A,, ...,A,) on A1, ..., A, and on n leads to quite different problems: a sequence (Ak),>, of real numbers is a harmonious set if, for each positive E, there is a function T = T(E), such that each interval of length Tcontains at least one solution t of the infinite system of Diophantine inequalities lltAkll < E, 1 < k (Section 5). The study of harmonious sets and their uses in harmonic analysis is one of the main subjects of this book. In Section 6 we recall classical results about Pisot and Salem numbers. In Section 7 we prove the following theorem; let O be a real number greater than I : then the set of all powers Ok,k 2 0, of 8 is a harmonious set if and only if 19is a Pisot or a Salem number. 1. Some classical results in Diophantine approximations In Section 1, we give, without proofs and for the entertainment of the reader some celebrated theorems which will not be used in the remainder of this book.
1.1. What is a problem of Diophantine approximation? Roughly speaking, a problem of Diophantine approximation is always of the following type : there is a metrizable group G and a subgroup H of G, dense in G. An estimate of the 'complexity' of elements h in H i s given by
5
a sub-additive positive weight-function co : H -+ [0, + co]; 'complicated' elements h in H a r e those for which co(h) is great. Let d be a translationinvariant metric on G. The 'quality' of the approximation of an element g in G by elements h in H is defined by d (h, g) and the 'cost' of this approximation by co(h). The problem is to specify the connection between 'cost' and 'quality' of the approximation.
1.2. Approximation of real numbers by rationals. Dirichlet's and Roth's theorem Let, with the notations of Section 1.1, G = R be the field of real numbers and H = Q be the field of rational numbers. The complexity of a reduced fraction p/q is defined by Iql (p and q are rational integers relatively prime and q # 0); co (plq) = log Iql would be a subadditive weight function. For a given irrational real number a , one would like to compute, for each positive E, the least positive integer q ( ~ such ) that the system
< E, 1 < q < 4(&) (1.1) 1401 -PI has a solution. In fact a precise estimate of q ( ~ is ) generally unavailable, and we seek two functions ql(&)and q2(e), not too different, such that, for each positive E, (1.2) Iqa - pl < E and q 2 1 imply q 2 q,(~) 1qa - pl
<E
and 1 ,< q
< q2(&) has a solution.
(1.3)
The best case is when q,(~)= 0 (q,(&))but generally q,(~)= o (q,(~))and there is a gap between q , ( ~ )and q2(&).Dirichlet's theorem gives for any oc an upper estimate of q2(e).
I. For every real number a # 0 and every E in 10, 1[ we can solve THEOREM the system 1 Iqoc - pl < E and 1 < q < - . E
On the other hand no 'universal' lower estimate for q,(~)is possible. constructed with a very rapidly Liouville's numbers oc = growing sequence nk of integers, give examples where 9, is as small as desired. Such ol are transcendental real numbers and if oc is algebraic, we have the following celebrated result, known as Roth's theorem [82].
Ik>,,
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
THEOREM 11: Let a be an algebraic number and 6 a real number in ]0,1[ arbitrarily close to 1. There exists a positive real number depending on a and 6 such that the following holds: 0 < F < E ~lqa , - pl < E and q 2 1 -d imply q 2 E . If a is algebraic, q , ( ~ )> E-'; there is a gap between the estimate of 9, given by Roth's theorem afid the estimate of q, given by Dirichlet's theorem.
schmidt has, in fact, proved what is a very striking improvement on the *receeding result: with the same hypothesis, for each 7 > 0 the following multiplicative inequality has only a finite number of solutions
6
1.3. Simultaneous approximation of n real numbers. Schmidt's theorems Here G = Rn, n > 1, and H i s the dense subgroup of G consisting of all x = ( P , / ~ ,...,pn/q),where q 2 1 and p, are rational integers (1 < j < n). If one of the fractions p,/q is irreducible, q will be an estimate of the complexity of x ; such an x will be called a rational element in Rn and, if q = 1, x will be called an integer point in Rn. Let a , , ...,anbe n real numbers; the problem is to compute, for every positive E the least integer q ( ~ such ) that the system has a solution in rational integers p, , ...,pn and q. As above, we can divide this problem into two parts: (1) Find, for each positive E, an estimate of a function q,(&), such that
(2) Find, for each positive E, an estimate of a function q,(~), such that the system lqap - p,l
< E, . .., lqa,
- pnl < E and 1 < q
< q2(~)
(1.6)
has a solution. Here also, we have two theorems. Dirlchlet's theorem : If q,(s) = E-" and 0 < F < I, then (1.6) has a solution in rational integers. Schmidt's theorem :Let a, , . .., anbe n algebraic real numbers such that 1, a , , ..., anare linearly independent over Q. Then,for each 11 > 0 there is an E~ > 0 (depending on a , , ..., an and 7) such that, for 0 < E < FO, every integral solution q > 1 of llqal 11 < F, . . . , llqan(l< E is greater than -n+q (Ilxll is the distance from the real number x to the nearest ql(&) = e integer).
7
This means that if, for instance, a, is well approximated byp,/q, then the other a i s cannot simultaneously be well approximated by any pJ/q ([841 or 1851). 2. Measure-theoretical methods in Diophantine approximations We present here quite simple and powerful techniques, which will be very useful in the study of 'badly approximable' real numbers.
2.1. Minkowski's theorem Let p be Lebesgue measure on Rn, and let C be the cube 0 < x, < 1, 1 < j < n; p is normalized by p(C) = 1. Let Zn be the lattice of all integer points x in Rn, let Q : Rn -t Rn/Znbe the canonical homomorphism whose kernel is Zn, and v be Lebesgue measure on Rn/Zn normalized by v (Rn/Zn)= 1. Minkowski's theorem runs as follows: THEOREM 111: Let K be a compact subset of Rn. Assume that p(K) >, 1. There exist two distinct points x and y in K, such that y - x belongs to Zn. An immediate consequecce is the following result: COROLLARY 1 : Let K be a compact convex subset of Rn,symmetric about 0. Ifp(K) 2 2", K contains an integer point x dzyerentfrom zero. To get Corollary 1, we just apply Theorem I11 to 3K.
2 : Let I, , .. ., In be n linear forms over Rn. Assume that COROLLARY 11, . . ., In are linearly independent. Let D be the determinant of I,, ..., 1, and c, ,...,cnn positive real numbers such that c, , . .., cn >, D. There exists an integer point x, diferent from zero, such that ~l,(x)l < c,, ..., Iln(x)l 6 cn. The same result holds for pairwise-conjugate complex linear forms. Corollary 2 is a particular case of Corollary 1 and is a generalization of Dirichlet's theorem. Now we shall prove Theorem 111. It depends on the following lemma:
8
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
LEMMA 1 : Let E be any compact subset of Rn and let F = e(E) be the set of all residues modulo Zn. Then v(F) < p(E). If two distinct points of E are never congruent modulo Zn, then v(F) = p(E). Proof: We have an explicit formula to compute v(F). In fact v(F) = lim N-"p ( N++m
U
E + k) with k = (k,,
..., k,).
(1.8)
l
The two parts of Lemma 1 follow from this equality; if two distinct points of E are never congruent modulo Zn, then, for distinct k, E + k are pairwise disjoint. To prove (1.8) we remark that the measure space (Rn/Zn,v) can be identified with (C, p) where C is the unit cube 0 < xj < 1 , l < j < n and p the restriction to C of Lebesgue measure. In both cases the o-field is the a-field of Bore1 sets. Let g be the union of all E + k, k E Zn. With this identification, F becomes the intersection of C and g. We get v(F) = p (,&?n C) = lim N-"p ( g n NC) since J!? is ZnN++m
periodic. But, with only a finite number of exceptions whose number is O(Nn-l), the integer points k for which k f E intersects NC do satisfy 1 < kj < N for 1 < j < n. This ends the proof of (1.8). 2.2. Inhomogeneous problems Minkowski's theorem allows to solve homogeneous linear Diophantine problems. Is there a similar method to solve inhomogeneous linear Diophantine systems? Consider, for instance, the system
we seek a condition on a , , a,, a2 and a, implying the existence of an integer solution of (1.9) for every real cumber xl and x,. In Section 3 we shall see that, if for a suitable b = b (a,, a,) a sufficient condition is a1a2 2 b (a,, a,), just as in Mickowski's theorem, then there is a positive E such that if alaz < E , then (gal - p[ < a , and (qa, - pl < a, imply p = q = 0. Let K b e defined by la,y - xl < a 1 , lazy - xl
9
We give now a general result due to Kneser and Birch [ 5 ] , which is fairly near to being the best possible. THEOREM IV: Let S be a compact subset of Rn. Assume that the following two conditions are fuljilled:
(a) two distinct points of S are never congruent modulo Zn; (b) the Lebesguc measure of S, p(S), is positive. Let N be an integer defined by Np (S) 1 and let K be the compact subset of Rn deJned by K = S + + S (N times). Then, for each x in Rn, K + x intersects Zn. We recall that S + S (N times) is the set of all sums s, + + sN, where sj belongs to S (1 < j < N), Before proving this theorem let us see, by means of a11 example, why it is the best possible. Let S be defined in R2, by 0 < x < m-l, 0 < y < I < 1 (m > 2 is an integer). Then p(S) = Im-' and S fulfils (a). Here K is defined by 0 < x < Nm-', 0 < y < IN and K fulfils the conclusion of Theorem 1V if and only if N > m or Np (S) 2 I. Since I can be chosen arbitrarily near to 1, N cannot, in general, be less than the integer defined by Np (S) >/ 1. The part played by condition (a) of Theorem IV will be better understood in the study of badly approximable real numbers.
>
+
Let Sbe a convex compact subset of Rn,symmetricabout 0. COROLLARY: Assume that the Lebesgue measure of S, p(S), is positive and that the only integer point in S is 0. Let N be an integer defined by Np (S) 2 2"- l . Then, for each x in Rn, NS + x intersects Zn. The proof of Theorem IV depends on the following lemma (proved in Appendix A). LEMMA 2: Let A and B be two compact subsets of Rn/Zn.Then there are only two possibilities: (a) v (A B) 2 v(A) + v(B) (v is Lebesgue measure on Rn/Zn);or (b) A B = Rn/Zn. Now to the proof of Theorem IV. From Lemma 2, we deduce that if A is a compact subset of Rn/Zn,and if N is an integer such that Nv (A) 2 1, + A (N times) is the whole Rn/Zn.Applying this remark to then A + A = e(S), we get Theorem IV, since v(A) = p(S) by Lemma 1.
+
+
10
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
3. Badly approximable real numbers 3.1. More or less rapid ways offilling R/Z with residues modulo 1 of ma Let a be a real number and h : Z -+ R/Z the homomorphism defined by the condition that h(m) is the residue modulo 1 of mol. If a is an irrational number, h(Z) is dense in R/Z but there are more or less rapid ways of filling R/Z. To make this notion precise, a definition is needed. DEFINITION 1: For each positive 8, let T(E) be the least integer Q such that, for each real x, the system lqol + p - xl < 8, 0 < q < Q can be solved. Such a Q can also be defined by the condition that each interval [j, j + Q], j E Z contains a q such that llqnll < 8. There is a general relation between T(E) and 8. PROPOSITION 1 : For each irrational real number a , T(E) 2 1/28. Proof: Let, for each integer Q, Q (Q, 8) be the union of the Q + 1 'intervals' of R/Z defined by llqol - xll < 8, 0 G q < Q and v be Lebesgue measure on R/Z normalized by v (RIZ) = 1. We have v (Q (Q, 8)) < (Q + 1) v (Q (0, 8)) = (2Q + 2) E. If Q (Q, 8) = R/Z then Q + 1 > 1/28. If Q + 1 = 1/28 while Q (Q, 8) = R/Z, then v (Q (Q, 8)) = (Q + 1) v (Q (0,~)).This implies that the intervals defining Q (Q, 8) do not have any intersection of positive measure while their union is R/Z. This is only possible if a is rational. This inequality leads to the following definition: DEFINITION 2: Let a be an irrational real number and h(j), for each integer j, be the residue modulo 1 of ja. We say that h(Z)$lls R/Z rapidly if there is a positive number c such that, for each positive E, T(E) < C/E. In other words, for each positive 8, 0 < 8 < 1, and each real number x the system Iqn + p - xl < E, 0 < q < C/E can be solved.
3.2. Badly approximable real numbers We now connect the preceding notion with the quality of rational approximations of a.
TKEOREM V: Let a be an irrational real number and h the homomorphism from Z to R/Z such that: for each j in Z, h(j) is the residue modulo 1 of ja. Then the following three properties of a are equiualent: (a) h(Z) Jills R/Z rapidly; (b) there is a positive c such that, for each integer q 2 1, llqall 3 c/q;
NUMBERS
11
(c) ifoc = [a,, a,, ..., a,. . .] is the expansion of a as a continuedfraction, then the sequence of a, is bounded. Before proving theorem V, some remarks should be made. If a real number a has one of the equivalent properties (a), (b) or (c) we shall say is 'badly that a is a 'badly approximable' real number. As an example approximable' and each quadratic real number satisfies (b) or (c); in this case, the expansion into a continued fraction is, after some time, a periodic one. But property (c) shows that there are, apart from quadratic numbers, many badly approximable real numbers since the set of numbers defined by (c) has the same cardinality as R. The proof of the equivalence between (b) and (c) is classical but uses the theory of continued fractions; for these two reasons we refer to [12]. We shall now prove that (a) implies (b). If (b) is not fulfilled, a has good rational approximations and there is a sequence y, of real numbers tending to zero and a sequence q, of positive integers, tending to infinity such that la - pn/qr,l< Yn/q:; let m,, n 3 1, be a sequence of positive integers such that m, + + co while m,y, + 0 (n -+ co) and put N, = mnqn,en = m,y,. For each positive 8, consider, with the notation of Proposition 1, the subsetQ (N,, E)of R/Z. Since, for 1 G j Gmn,II jqnaII G&n/qn,wegetQ(Nn,8) c Q(qn,E + E , / ~ ~ThenQ(N,, ). 8) = R/Z implies Q (q, ,8 8,/qn) = R/Z and, by Proposition 1,2qn(8 + ~,/q,) > 1. If E = 1/34,, for suitably large n Q (N,, 8) is not the whole R/Z, while N,E tends to infinity with n; h(Z) does not fill R/Z rapidly. Now it must be shown that (b) implies (a). Let S(E) be the compact subset of R2 defined by Ix ayl < E and lyl < 468 (c is defined by condition (b)). Then two distinct points of s(&) are never congruent modulo Z2and ,US(&)= 46. Let N be an integer defined by cN 2 6 and K be the compact subset of R2 defined by Ix ayl G NE and lyl < cN/6~.Then Theorem IV shows that, for each x in R2, K + x intersects Z2. Changing into N-%, this means that, for each real x and y and each positive E,the Diophantine inequalities Ip + a q - xl < E and Iq - yl < cN2/68 can be solved.
+
+
+
+
THEOREM VI: Let a andp be two distinct real numbers. The three following conditions are equivalent: (a) there is a positive constant a such that for each (p, q) in ZZ distinct from (O,O), Iqa + PI lqr6 + PI 2 a ; (b) there is a constant b such that, if the product of the two positive real numbers E and 7 exceeds b, then the Diophantine inequalities lqa p - xl
+
12
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
g E, 1qb + p - yI g 7 can be solved for each pair of real numbers x and y; (c) a and p are badly approximable. Proof: Let c < a14 and, for each positive F, let K, be the compact subset of R2 defined by lya + xl g E, Iyp + xl g cs-l. Then (a) implies that two distinct points of K, are never congruent modulo Z2. The Lebesgue measure of K, is 4c/(la - PI) and if an integer N is defined by 4Nc g la - PI, Theorem V gives (b) with b = N2c. (b) => (c). We shall prove that a is badly approximable. The same argument will be valid forb. If we apply (b) to y = 0 and E < 1, the two imply, for a constant d, inequalities lqa + p ( < 1 and (qp + p ( < k / ~ 191 < dl&.For each E in (0, 1) and each real x, the inequalities lqa + p - xl g E, (ql g d ~ - lcan be solved; a is badly approximable. (c) => (a): Since a acd 16 are distinct irrational real numbers, there is a positive constant y such that lqa + pl g 1 implies Iqp + pl 2 y Iq(. If oc is badly approximable and lqa + pl < 1, (a) is a consequence of 6 > 0. If Jqb + pl g 1, we interchange the role played by cx (ql (qa + pl and b and if lqa + pl 2 1 and Iqb + pl > 1, their product is greater than one. We have proved (a). It is very surprising that quadratic numbers are the only naturally occurring examples of badly approximable real numbers, and hence it is all the more interesting that the set of badly approximable real numbers can be obtained constructively: by the continued fraction methcd. For the details we refer to [12]. 3.3. The Diophantine system (qaj - pj
- pjl < E, 1 < j < n
A natural generalization of the last problem is the following one: let o,, .. ., w, be n real numbers linearly independent over Q and h : R -+ (RIZ)" be the continuous homomorphism defined by h(t) = (Q (colt), .. .,Q (writ)) ; it should be recalled that, for a real number t, ~ ( t is) the residue modulo 1 o f t ; ~ ( tbelongs ) to RIZ. Let H be the subgroup h(R) of (R/Z)". Then by Kronecker's theorem (Appendix A), H is dense in (R/Z)" and It 1 is a natural estimate for the complexity of an element h(t) of H. The distance between two elements ~ ( x = ) (Q(x,), . . . , ~(x,))and ~ ( y= ) (~(y,),...,~(y,))of (R/Z)" is d e ~ o t e dIle(x) - e(y)ll and is defined by sup l(xj - yjl\ (x E Rn; x l , .. ., X, E R, y E Rn, y l , .. . , yn E R azd for l<j$n
each real t, Jltll is the distance from t to the nearest integer).
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
13
Our problem of Diophantine approximation will be to study how h(R) slls (R/Z)". Let, for each E in (0, $1, V(E)be the neighborhood of 0 in (R/Z)" defined by JjxllI < 8, ..., Il~,,ll< I and M(E) be the set of all real t such that h ( t ) ~V(E). If < W2 < < o n , t EM(&), t r e M ( & ) and It - t'l < 1/2w,, then It - t'l < 2~/w,(if, for a real x, 1x1 < +, then 1x1 = Ilxll). This remark leads to the following definition:
DEFINITION 3 : With the preceding terminology, let T(E)be thefirst returntime into V(E): -48) is the infimum oft > 1/2w, such that h(t) E V(E). Let tl = T(E),t:!, . . ., tk, .. . be thefollowing return-times into V(F) : tkfl is the infimum of t > tk + 1/2w,, such that h(t) E V(E). We set T(E) = sup (tk+l - tk). kS1
LEMMA 3 : I f we accept for T(E)an error not exceeding 2 ~ / o , ,T(E)can be dejined by one of the following three equivalent properties: (a) T(E)is the infimum of positive I such that each interval ofpo~itivereal numbers of length I contains a t such that sup ((toj((g E; lSj
(b) T(E)is the infimum ofpositive I such that each interval of realnumbers of length I has the preceding property; (c) T(E) is the infimum of positive 1 such that, for eachjinite set of real numbers x, , ... , x, the Diophantine inequalities 0 g t g I, (ltwj - xj\l g E (1 < j ,< n) can be solved. Lemma 3 will be proved, in a more general context, in Section 5.2. To present our fundamental definition, the following lemma will be needed : LEMMA 4: Let E and T be two positive real numbers. Assume that, for each r in (R/Z)". one canfind a real number t in [0, TI such that I(h(t) - rll < E. Then T 2 csl-", where c depends only on o , , ..., w,. To prove Lemma 4, some terminology is needed. For each x = (x,, ..., x,) in Rn, we put ~ ( x = ) (~(x,),... , ~(x,)),where ~ ( x , )is the residue n~odulo1 of the real number x, ; ~ ( x , )belongs to R/Z. Let f and g be two positive functions defined on 10, + a[;we write f ,-- g if there are two constants a and b such that, for each E in 10, +a[, af(&) g g(8) < bf (E). Let p be Lebesgue measure on Rn, v Lebesgue measure on Rn/Zn,and C (T, E) the set of all (x,, . .., x,) in Rn, such that xj = mjt rj, 0 g t < T, lrjl g F. The hypothesis of Lemma 4 implies that Q (C (T, E)) = Rn/Zn;using
+
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
14
Lemma 1, we get 1 = v (Q (C (T, E)) < ,uC (T, E) V^ Ten-' (T > 1, 0 < F < 1). This ends the proof of Lemma 4. We are led to the following definition, where w,, ...,wn and h are defined as above. DEFINITION 4: We say that h(R) fills (R/Z)" rapidly if there is a constant C (depending on h and n) such that, for each positive T and each r in (RIZ)", the distance from r to h ([0, TI) does not exceed CT-'~I"-~'. The following result is a generalization of Theorem V; rougly speaking, Theorem VI asserts that h(R) fills Tnrapidly if and only if w, , ..., w, are strongly independent over Z or have bad simultaneous approximations by rational numbers. THEOREM VII: Let w, , ...,wn be n real numbers linearly independent over Q and h : R -, (R/Z)" be the map dejined by: h(t) is the sequence of the residues modulo 1 of w,t, .. ., w,t. The following three assertions are equivalent: (a) h(R) jills (RIZ)" rapidly; (b) there is a y > 0 such that for each sequence p,, ...,pn of rational integers ]p,w, p,w,l >/ y ( sup Ipjl)-"+l;
+
+
lGjgn
(c) there is a 6 > 0 such that for each real number t 2 1, sup lltojll >/ dt - ( l / n - l ) 1CjGn Before this theorem can be proved, some remarks should be made. Condition (c) is equivalent to the following one: there is a positive a such that, for each T 2 1 the distance between h(0) and h ([I, TI) exceeds a ~ - " / " - ~ ' .In fact, by Dirichlet's theorem, here exists a sequence Tk tending to infinity in such a way that the distance between h(0) and h(Tk)is lzss than T~-('I~-'). The 'trajectory' reapproaches zero and, by Theorem VII, if the trajectory never reapproaches zero too closely, it fills (R/Z)" rapidly. To prove Theorem VII we replace (using arguments of Section 3.3) (c) with -(l/n-l) (d) for each T >/ 1 the distancefrom h(0) to h (11, TI) exceeds a T (a) . => (d): Let us assune that (a) is true and (d) is not. Then there is a sequence E~ of real numbers tending to zero and a sequence tk of real numbers tending to infinity such that Ilh(0) - h(tk)ll < ~ ~ t ~ - " l " -."Let mk be a sequence of integers tending to infinity in such a way that mksk = a k 4 0; put sk = mktk.Let Q (T,a ) be the set of all r in (R/Z)" whose distance to h ([0, TI) does not exceed a. Then Q (s,, a ) c -(I/,-1) ). ~f D (sk, a ) = (R/z)", then, by Lemma 4, (tk, a + mkEktk ,
oc+mk
-(l/n-l) k k
15
> atk-(I/~I-I) and
1f (a) were true, a would be smaller than C S ~ ' ~ ~ " - ' ) . Since skt[' tends to infinity this is not the case. (d) * (a): Let L be the subset of Rn defined by x1 = w,t + r l , ...,x, = w,t r,, 1 < t 6 T, lrjl < a / ( 6 ~ ~ / " - Then, ~ ) . by (d), two distinct points of L cannot be congruent modulo Zn. The measure of L is greater than some fixed b > 0 as soon as T 2 2. Let N be an integer greater than b - l . Then, by Theorem IV, for each x in Rn, NL x intersects Zn. This proves (a). As may easily be seen, the equivalence between (a) and (c) is based on a kind of duality in Diophantine approximations. Let us state a general result. To do so, some terminology is needed. Let x .y be the bilinear form x, y, + .. + x,y,, on Rn x Rn and, for each compact subset K of Rn, let K* be the set of all y in Rn such that sup Ix-yI< 1.
+
+
.
xeK
LEMMA5: I f K f Zn = Rnand 0 < a < 3, then (aK*) n Zn = (0). Proof: Let y E (aK*) n Zn. If y # 0, there is an x' in Rn defined by y x' = +.Since K + Zn = Rn, we can find an X' in Zn and x in K, such that x' = X' + x. Then y x' = y . X' + y x; l y . x( ,< a and ye x' would belong to Z + [-a, a]. But ye x' = 3 does not belong to Z [-a, a]. From now on c and dwill denote fixed constants (not always the same) depending only on wl ,...,on; whereas E and7 will be variable positive real numbers. Let D be the line of Rn defined by the parametric equations XI = colt, ... , X, = writ for real t and let C (c, E) be the compact subset of Rn defined by the two following conditions: (x,, ..., x,) E C (c, E) if Iqx, q,xn1 < E and if the distance from (xi, ..., xn) to this line D does not exceed CE-"~"'. If q = dl&,where d is small enough and K = C (c, E), then C (d, q) is contained in K*. Using Lemma 5 and this remark, we shall finish the proof of the equivalence between (a) and (c). Hypothesis (a) means that, for a big enough 6, C (c, E ) + Zn = Rn. Then, for small enough d and q, C (d, q) n Zn = (0) and thus (b) is proved. We now start from (b). For small enough d and q, two distinct points of C (d, q) are never congruent modulo Zn; on the other hand, the Lebes-
.
+
+
+
-
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
gue measure of C (d, q) exceeds a constant dl which is independent of q. Using Theorem IV, we can find an integer N, independent of q, such that NC (d, q) + Zn = Rn. We now apply Lemma 5 to get (c).
THEOREM VIII: Let A,, .. ., 1, be a sequence of real numbers. Assume that 1, A,, ...,A, are linearly independent over Q. The set of real t such that o1 = 1, ~2 = 11 + t, ...,O n + 1 = 1, t is a strongly independent sequence has the same Cardinality as R.
16
..
5 : Let ml , . ,w, be a sequence of n real numbers. We say DEFINITION that this sequence is strongly independent over the integers if and only ifone of the equivalent properties of Theorem VII is satisfied. If a , , ..., a, is a sequence of n real numbers such that 1, a , , . . .,a, is a strongly independent sequence, then the following equivalent properties are true : (a) there is a constant C such that, for each positive E and each sequence P I , ...,P,, of real numbers, the Diophantine inequalities Iqa, p, - PlI < E, ..., Iqa, + p, - P,I < E, 191 < CE-" can be solved. (b) there is a constant c such that for each sequence q, p l , .. ,p, of ... p,a, ql 2 c (l ssup lpjl)-" rational integers we have Iplal j$n (unless p, = - - - = p, = 0). (c) there is a constant d such that, for each q B 1, sup llqajll l<jsn 2 dq-'lIn).
+
+
+
+
3.4. Example. The algebraic case Let R be a real algebraic number field, n = do [R; Q], a,, ..., a, be the n Q-isomorphisms of R into C indexed in such a way that o,(9) is contained in R. Let wl, .., w, be any basis of R over Q.
.
PROPOSITION 2 : The sequence of real numbers ol(w ,), .. , a, (w,) is strongly independent over Z. Since independecce is not affected by changing a,(wl), .., o,(w,) into Aa, (m,), ..., Ao, (w,) for a real A, it may be assumed that w,, ...,w, are algebraic integers of the field 9. We shall prove condition (b). Let a > 0 be chosen in such a way that, for each algebraic integer 1 = p,w, + p,o,inR, loz(A)I < a l tsup Ipjl,..., bn(1)1 Q a SUP IP~I. l<j
.
+
-
1$ i < n
= p, = 0 for then the rational integer ol(l) a,@) case when p, = = m would have an absolute value less than 1 and this implies m = 0 and 1= 0. The following result of Cassels [34] shows that, apart from algebraic numbers, there are other interesting examples of strongly independent sequences.
17
+
4. Diophantine approximations and prediction of the size of trigonometric sums
4.1. What is prediction? Let A be a finite set of real numbers. We study the following trigonometric sums : P(t) = a, exp 2ni1t, ,€A
where a, are arbitrary complex numbers. Our fundamental problem is the following: if we know a set A of frequencies and the values taken by P on a large interval [-T, TI, can we predict what P will be on the whole real line? What is the extent of the error? To be more precise, we shall try to specify the connection between a positive T and an E in (0, 1) such that, for each P defined by (1.10),
This condition means that the relative error term on the size of P is less than E. If we replace A by A a , P(t) is replaced by exp 2nitaP (t) and (1.1 1) remains valid. Our problem is translation-invariant onA and in all the following we assume that 0 belongs to A. The result stated below expresses that we cannot get excellent predictions. The quality of the prediction depends, when 0 belongs to A, on the dimension of the vector space over Q generated by A.
+
PROPOSITION 3 : Let n be the cardinality ofA and m, 1 < m < n, be the dimension of the vector space over Q generated by A. There is a constant A, depending only on A, such that (1.11) implies T 2 A E - ' ~ - ~ " ~ . The proof of Proposition 3 depends on the following lemma: 6 : Let zl , ..., z, be n complex numbers of absolute value 1. Then LEMMA for each E in (0,I), the inequality lz, z,l 2 n (1 - E) implies I Z~ z , ~Q 2 J2nEfor 1 Q j, k Q n. Proof: Multiplying the zj's by a suitable complex number a of absolute value 1, we may assume that (z, + z,)!n = s is real and positive.
+
... +
+
18
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
+
+
x, = ns and since, Let us write zj = x j + iyj. We then have x , by hypothesis, s > 1 - s, we get (1 - x j ) < ns, which implies 1 - xi
z:
< ns, 1zj - 1 1 < J Z a n d
19
(c) for a constant c, for every positive E and every sequence x , , . .., x , real numbers, the Diophantine inequalities
6.
l.zj - z,l < 2 Let us return to Proposition 3. We define P(t) = exp 2niAt and, for each real number s, let P, be defined by : P,(t) = P ( t - s). Then (1.11) and Lemma 1 imply that we can find -in each interval of length 2T a real t such that lexp 2niAt - I I < 2 J2ns. We can write A as a sequence A,, ..., A,, such that A,, ..., A, are linearly independent over Q. Then, for 1 < j < m , there is in each interval of length T a t such that lexp 2niAjt - 1 ) < 2 &(l < j < m). By Lemma 4 of Section 3.3 we get T >/ As - ( m - 1 ) / 2 Proposition 3 leads to the following definition:
xnEn
6: L e t A be aJinite set of real numbers. Assume that 0 belongs DEFINITION to A and let m be the dimension of the vector space over Q generated by A. W e say that we can rapidly predict the size of trigonometric sums (1.10) if there is a constant C > 0 such that, for each E in 10, I [ , the supremum of IP(t)l for It1 < CE-("-')'~is not less than ( 1 - s) sup IPI. R
can be solved; (d) for a constant d and every sequence p,, ..., p, of rational integers we have either plAl ... + p,A, = 0 or Ip,A, + ..- + p,A,l 2 d ( SUP I ~ ~ l ) - ~ + l .
+
l<j
4.3. Proof of the main theorem The proof of Theorem IX depends on the following lemmas: 7: Let A, , ...,A,, be n real numbers and w , , ...,w, be a basis for LEMMA the Z-module generated by the Aj)s, 1 < j < n. Let us assume that each interval of length 2T contains a t such that lltAjljll < s for 1 < j < n. Then there is a constant a > 0 such that, for each sequence x,, ..., xm of real numbers, the Diophantine inequalities
It1
4.2. The main theorem concerning prediction From now on, A will denote a finite set of real numbers containing 0;m will be the dimension of the vector space over Q generated by A; we can write A as a sequence {A,, ..,A,} in such a way that A,, .., Am is a basis of this vector space. As in Section 3, we define, for each real number x , the residue ~ ( xof) x modulo 1 ;~ ( xbelongs ) to RIZ. Let h : R + (R/Z)" be the homomorphism defined by: h(t) is the sequence of the m residues Q (il,t), ...,Q ( L t ) . With this terminology, we have the following theorem:
.
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
.
THEOREM IX: The following two assertions are equivalent: (a) we can rapidly predict the size of trigonometric sums whosefrequencies belong to A ; (b) A,, ...,A, are strongly independent over Z . More precisely, we have that, for constants a, b, c ... depending only onA but not on the real number E in 10, 1[ the following four assertions are equivalent :
< T , ltwj - x j -pjl < as
for
1
<j < m
(1.12)
can be solved. bj,,Ak. Hence Proof: We have, for rational integers bj,,, oj = (Itil,l( < E for 1 < k < n implies I(troj(l< as for 1 < j < m ; each interval of length 2T contains such a real t. At this point, we use Lemma 3 in Section 3.3. Remark 1 : If A,, .. , A , is a basis for the vector space over Q generated by A, then there is an integer p such that the inequalities I(tAj((< E for 1 < j < m imply IIptAjljll < bs for 1 < j < n. To prove this remark, let us write the 2;s for which m 1 < j < n as linear combinations with rational coefficients of A,, .. .,A,. Then, for a suitable integerp and integers aj,,, paj = 2: aj,,lk ( m + 1 ,< j < n). This relation implies our remark. Remark 2: If each interval of length 2T contains a solution t of the Diophantine system IltAjII < s, 1 < j < m , then there is an integerp and a constant a sucht that, for each sequelxe x,, . .., xmof real numbers, the System It1 < pT, lltwj - xjll < as ( 1 ,< j < m ) can be solved. In the remainder of the proof the following notation will be used: let E be a set and f a complex valued function defined on E. Then we put Jlf l l , = sup If(x)l.
Z:
.
+
xeE
20
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
LEMMA 8: Let f : Rm-+ C be an indeJnitely diferentiable function. Assume that f is bounded and that the partial derivatives a2f/(aujduk), 1 < j, k < m are also bounded. Let M be sup Ild2f/(aujauk)lI,. For
+
lCj,kCm 2
(u, , .. ., urn)E Rmwe put luI2 = u: .. + u,. Then, if we can find a v in Rmsuch that I f(v)l = 11 f 11 ,, we have, for every u in Rm, u
=
Proof: The Taylor formula gives, for a linear form I over Rmand a u'in R ~ , ~ (= u f) ( ~ ) I (U - V ) 3 (u~ u j ) (uk - vk) a 2 f / ( a ~ j a (~U kO .) This implies I f(u)l B I f ( v ) I (U - v)] - M / 2 x j , k Iuj - vjjl luk - vkl g I f(v) + 1 (U - v)I - m M / 2 lu - vI2. For each u in RmIf ( v ) + I ( u - v)l > I f(v)l. Otherwise we would find a positive s and points v arbitrarily near to u, such that I f ( v ) I ( u - v)l g If (v)l + E lu - vl ;f ( u ) would be greater than f(v). This ends the proof of Lemma 8.
+ xj,k +
+
+
LEMMA 9: Let A = {A1, ... ,A,) be afinite subset of R and P be afinite trigonometric sum whose frequencies belong to A. Assume that each interval of length 2T contains a solution t of the system IltAjljll < a for 1 < j < n. Then,for a constant a, depending only on A, we have
Proof: Let w , , ...,w, be a basis of the Z-module generated by A. Then 4 = Z y P j , k w k ,where pj,, E Z. For complex numbers z, , ...,z , of absolute value 1 , we put Qj ( z , , ..., z,) P(t)
=
=
~ Y z ? . ~then ;
Z: ajQj (exp 2niwlt, ...,exp 2niomt).
Let f : Rm+ C be the Zm-periodic function defined by f (u, , ..., urn) ajQj (exp 2niul, ..., exp 2nium);f is indefinitely differentiable and there exists v in Rm such that I f(v)l = Il f ll ,. By Lemma 7, wz can find a real number t and integers p j , 1 < j < m, such that It] < T and ltwj - vj - pjl < aa. Let u E Rm be defined by uj = t o , - p j . By Lemma 8, =
21
< c n ~ n , . This impliesimmediately that for a constant Cdepending only . on A, M < CIIPll , Kronecker's theorem (Appendix B) shows that, for each v in Rm, we can find a sequence t,, p 2 1 , of real numbers such that exp 2niojtp -, exp 2nivj for 1 < j < m as p tends to infinity. It follows that 11 f / I m = 11 Pll , . Then (1.13) can be rewritten Now let us return to Theorem IX. (a) 3 (b): This follows immediately by the same proof as that used for Proposition 3. (b) => (a) : We already know (Theorem VI) that (b) implies the following: for a constant A, each interval of length contains a solution t of the Diophantine inequalities lltAjljll < E (1 < j < m). By the first remark following Lemma 7, each interval of length A ' E - ~ +contains ~ a solution t of the enlarged system IltAjljll < E ( 1 < j < n). Now using Lemma 9, we get (a). (b) e (c): This is an immediate consequence of Theorem VII.
5. Kronecker's theorem and problems with a large number o f equations 5.1. We shall state the usual forms of Kronecker's theorem and another equivalent formulation (a proof of Kronecker's theorem is given in Appendix B). 5.1.1. Let A,, . . .,A, be n real numbers linearly independent over Q. Then for each positive E and each sequence x1 , ..., x, of real numbers, the Diophantine inequalities - xjll < E, 1 < j < n have a solution. If 1 , A,, ..., A, are linearly independent over Q, we can find an integral solution q of the Diophantine inequalities
x:
Enan
Let & be the vector space over C of all trigonometric sums a* exp 2niAt. The dimension of 8 is n and all norms on d are equivalent. In particular there exists a constant c, such that, for each P in 6 , lanl
xAEn
Proof: (1.14) follows from 5.1.1 applied to the sequence x, = 1 , ..., x, of real numbers; then, for a suitable integer q, It - ql < s and replacing t in 5.1.1 by q, we get (1.14). Now if, A,, .. .,A, are not Q-linearly independent, we are led to another formulation. 5.1.2. Let A,, .. .,A, acd x,, ..., x, be 2n real numbers. The following ~ W Oconditions are equivalent: (a) for each positive E, there exists a real number t such that IItAj - xjll f & f o r 1< j < n ; x,,
22
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
23
(b) for each sequence p,, ...,p, of rational integers, plA, + p,A, = 0 impliesp,~, + .-.+ p,x, E 0 (mod 1). Condition (b) can be stated in the following form: let H be the subgroup of R generated by A; then there is a homomorphism % from H to R/Z, such that %(Aj) = xj (mod 1) for 1 < j < n. Proof of 5.1.3: + pnAn= 0 then, for every real t, p1t/l, ..(a) => (b): If p,Al + pntAn= 0 and using (a) we get, for each positive s, llplx, + + p,x,(l < ns, which implies (b). (b) (a): Using the structure theorems about submodules of free modules on principal rings, we can find m real numbers w, , ...,om linearly independent over Q, such that H = Zw, . - -+ Zw,. By 5.1.1, for each positive E,there exists a real number t such that 11 tcoj - xX(wj)II < E + Zw,, 1 < j < n, there is a for 1 < j < m. Since Aj E Zwl + ( Cs for 1 < j < n. constant C, independent of E, such that IltLj - - & ) I <
If we are also interested in the dependence on n and on A,, ..., A,, it is quite a different matter. The reduction to a problem dealing with w,, ,GO, drastically alters the estimates. We need new methods which will be introduced in Section 5.4. Nevertheless many problems remain unsolved. Let us give an example. Let P be a real algebraic number field, n be the degree of 9 over Q and ol , ...,on the n Q-isomorphisms ftom 9 into C indexed in such a way that 0, is real (ol(P) c R). For each positive E,let T (E, 9 ) = Tbe the least positive real number satisfying the following condition: for evely real number t there exists an algebraic integer A in 9 , such that It - ol(A)l < T while lo,(A)I < E-,, .. ., la,(A)l < s-l. We do not hope to get an explicit value for T but only to find a function f (e, 9 ) and two absolute constants a and b (independent of E and P) such that af(~,9) < T < bf(e, 9). Using the preceding methods, all we can show is that, for constants A and B depending on 9 , we have
5.2. A function T (el , A, ... , A,)
5.4. Linear Diophantineproblems with an infinite number of equations
+
+
+
. a .
+
DEFINITION 7: The following two properties of a positive number T are equivalent (a) for each sequence x, , . .., x, of real numbers satisfying condition (b) of 5.1.3, there is a solution t of IltA, - xjll < E, It] < T; (b) each interval of real numbers of length 2T contains a real number t such that lltAjll < E for 1 < j < n. Proof: (a) a (b): Apply (a) to xj = sxj, where s is the center of the given interval of length 2T. (b) a (a): Using 5.1.3. (b) let, s,, p >/ 1, be a sequence of real numbers such that llspAj - xjll -, 0 (p -, + a).The interval of centers, and length 2T contains a real number x, such that llxpSll < E, 1 < j < n. Let t, = s, - x,; then It,l < Tand we can extract from the t,'s a subsequence tending to t. We have (tl < T a ~ JltAj d - xjll < E, 1 < j < n.
5.3. Open problems Our aim is to find such a function T (E,Al, .. .,A,) = T. If we are only interested in the dependence of T on E for fixed A,, ...,A,, the problem can be reduced to that studied in Section 3, but instead of the A ~ swe , use a basis w,, .. .,w, of the Z-module generated by A.
...
Let A,, k 2 1, be a given sequence of real numbers. We study the sequences /Ik, k 2 1, of real numbers such that, for each positive e, there exists a solution t of the system IltAk - Bkll < s. As in Section 5, we find a necessary condition on the Bk's: for every integer n and rational integers p l , .. .,p,, we have the following implication: n
n
=0
z p k A k= 1
(mod 1).
(1.15)
1
DEFINITION 8: Let A be a set of real numbers, H the subgroup of R generated byA and%a mapfromA to R/Z. We write E Hom (A, R/Z) if x is the restriction to A of a homomorphism from H to R/Z. With this definition, (1.15) can be written: x E Horn (A, R/Z), where x is defined by %(Ak)E pk (mod 1).
DEFINITION 9: The set A of the AkYsis harmonious if for each positive E and each sequence pk, k 2 1, of real numbers satisfying the necessary condition (1.15) there exists a real number t such that, for each k 2 1,
Ilak - B ~ I
In other words, for each x E Hom (A, R/Z) and each positive s, we can solve the infinite sequence of Diophantine inequalities IltAk - x(A,))~< E, k > 1.
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS T O REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS T O REAL NUMBERS
Roughly speaking we try to guess whether a given sequence B,, k 2 1, real numbers, can be, modulo 1, a sequence tA,, k 2 1, for a suitable t. A set A is harmonious if each sequence B,, k 2 1, of real numbers which is not excluded for evident algebraic reasons is, with an arbitrarily small error (not depending on k), such a sequence of residues for a suitable t.
= 8. For each integer m, let K, be the compact subset of @ defined by K,,, = h ([-m, m)] + U(E).If A is harmonious, the union of all K,, m 2 1, is @. Baire's theorem shows that, for a suitable m, K, contains an open subset 9 of @. Since h(R) is dense in @, h(R) + Q = @; hence U h(t) + 9 = 8 and again using the compactness of @, we can find a
24
THEOREM X: Let (A,),,, be a sequence of real numbers andA be the set of A,. The following four conditions are equivalent: (a) A is harmonious; (b) for each positive E there is a positive T(E) such that, for each X E Hom(A, R/Z), the Diophantine inequalities lltA, -x(A,)ll
25
t oR
finite subset F of R such that h(F) + Q is 8. Define an integer I by F + [-m, m] c [-I, I]. Then @ = h(F) + 9 c h(F) + K,,, = h(F) + h ([-m, m]) + U(E)c h ([-I, I]) + U(E)= K,; this is (b).
6. Pisot and Salem numbers 6.1. Dejinition of Pisot numbers Throughout this section, the following definitions and terminology will be used. The ring of polynomials in one variable with integral coefficients will be denoted by Z[X]. We say that P in Z [ a is distinguished if the leading coefficient of P i s one; this means that P(X) = Xn + clXn-I + ... + cn,where cj E Z, 1 < j < n. We say that P(X) = c o x n+ clXn-l + ... + c, is reduced if c, , c, , ..., c, are relatively prime and if c, 2 1. A real algebraic integer is any real root of a distinguished P in Z [ a . An algebraic number is any root (real or complex) of a P in Z[w. The minimal polynomial of an algebraic number 8 is the reduced element Q of Z[X] of the least degree such that Q(8) = 0. Gauss has proved that the minimal polynomial of an algebraic integer is distinguished. If 8 is an algebraic number, the roots of its minimal polynomial are simple. The degree of an algebraic number is the degree of its minimal polynomial. In what follows, where 8 is an algebraic number, n will be the degree of 8, P(X) the minimal polynomial of 8 and 02,.. ., 8, the n - 1 other distinct (real or complex) roots of P(X). We write 82, . .., 8, for conjugates of 8 different from 8.
DEFINITION 10: A Pisot number is a real algebraic integer 8 greater than 1 whose other conjugates 8,, ..., 8, satisfy the inequalities lO2l < I, ...: l%l < 1. The set of all Pisot numbers is denoted by S.
26
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
6.2. Characterization of Pisot numbers among algebraic numbers THEOREM XI: Let 8 > 1 be a real algebraic number. The following two properties of 8 are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot number; a). (b) there is a I > 0 such that IlilOkll + 0 (k (We recall that, for each real x, llxll is the distance from x to the nearest integer.) It is not known whether transcendental numbers 8 can have propertY @). (a) => (b): If 8 is an algebraic integer, so is Ok for each k $ 0. The conjugates of Ok are 8:, . . ., 19: and ek + 8; + .-.+ 8: is a rational integer for each k > 0. Since 1 021 < 1, ..., l0,l < 1 we get, for a r in 10, 1[, 11 Okll = 0 (rk), which is an improvement on (b). (b) 3 (a) : The proof depends on a well-known theorem due to Fatou. ckXkwith real coefficients represents a We say that a formal series CkaO rational fraction if there exist two polynomials P(X) and Q(X) with real ckXk. We write ,&,o ckXk coefficients such that P(X) = Q(X) = P(x)lQ(x)Fatou's lemma: Assume that theformalseriesxk. ckXkhas thefollowing two properties: (a) ckE Z for all k 2 0; (b) Xk,o ckXkrepresents a rational fraction. Then there exist two elements A(X) and B(X) in Z[X], such that (a) A(X) and B(X) are relatively prime; (b) B(0) = 1 ; (c) Z k > O ckXk = A(X)IB(X). The proof of this result is given in Section 6.3. We can now conclude the proof of Theorem XI. If 8 is a real algebraic number let n be the degree of + c,. 8 and P(X) the minimal polynomial of 8; P(X) = coxn + By hypothesis AOk = p k + r k ,where rktends to 0. Put sk = copk+,+ + cnpk= -cork+,, - - cnrk; sk is a rational integer which tends to zero and if k is large enough, sk = 0. For k $ ko, rk satisfies the recurrence relations cork+, + -.. + cnrk= 0 ; since the roots of P are simple, + We now use the following we have rk = 2, Ok + j12 Of + lemma (proved in Section 6.3). -)
[I, n], lu,] > 1 implies uj = 0. If f(k) is bounded for k >, 1, then lvJl > 1 implies uj = 0. Returning to rk we have rk = x",j8:, where Aj = 0 if 10jl > 1. The pkXkrepresents the rational fraction formal series
xk,ko
+
xkao
---
27
a * -
LEMMA 10: Let u,, ..., u, and v , , ..., v, be 2n complex numbers. Assume that f(k) = u,& + ... + unv; tends to 0 (k -, +a). Then, for each j in
Omitting terms for which Aj = 0, the last fraction can be rewritten U(X)/V(X), where V(X) = (1 - OX) n1, j,n (1 - ejX). The dash means that the product is restricted to those jfor which Aj # 0; U and V are then relatively prime. ~t this point we use Fatou's lemma. We get U(X)/V(X) = ~ k r k o ~ k X k = A(X)/B(X); A(X) and B(X) are relatively prime, as are U(X) and WX), and B(0) = V(0) = 1. This impl~esB(X) = V(X). Let m be the degree of B(X) and C(X) = XmB(1/X) be the reciprocal polynomial of B(X); then C(X) is distinguished, 0 is a root of C(X) and the Oj for which Aj # 0 are the other roots of C(X). Hence 8 is a Pisot number. As a complement to Theorem XI it is interesting to study the set of A such that l]ilOklltends to 0. We need the following definition: 11 : Let K be an algebraic number field and wl , . . ., w, a DEFINITION basis of K over Q. Then a dual basis w r , .. .,w,* of K over Q is defined by the properties Tr (w,w?) = 1 if i = j , Tr (wp;) = 0 if i # j. We recall that, for x in K, Tr(x) = o,(x) + + o,(x) is a rational number. (We refer to [3] for the proof.)
PROPOSITION 4: Let 0 be a Pisot number, K be the jield of 8, K = Q(8) and w,, . .., w, be the dual basis of 1, 8, ..., en-'. Then \lAOkll + 0 (k -t + a)if and only if for an integer I, I > 0, and n rational integers p l , ..., p,, we haven = 8-'(p,w, + .-. + p,,~,). This last condition is sufficient. Since we are interested in the products ilek for k > 1, we may assume that I = 0 and iZ = p,wl + + p,w,. Let A,, ...,A,, be the conjugates of A; then,for each k 2 O,ilOk+ L,B; + An@ is a rational integer (for 0 < k < n - 1 it is a consequence of the definition of w,, . ..,w, and for k > n we use the recurrence relations Ok + clOk-l + ... cnOk-" = 0). The latter condition is necessary. Returning to the proof of Theorem XI, we see that for k 2 k,, ilek - ~ ~ 0 : - An8: E 2. Putting p = Mko, Pz = -A2@, ..., p, = -A,e?, we get for each k $ 0
+
+
pek
+ p2e; + ... + pne; = gk
E Z.
(1.16)
28
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
Let A be the matrix whose rows are Ok, 0 < k < n - 1 and 8:, 0 < n - 1 and B the matrix whose rows, indexed by j, are ak(wj),1 < k Then A B = I and (1.16) gives p = qowl + + 9,- ,on.
29
q,, are relatively prime, there is an integer h defined by the following property: p divides go, ..., qh but not qh+,. We have d = (9, + . .. qnXn)X k , o dkXk,whence
+
6.3. Proof of Fatou's lemma The proof uses the following two lemmas: LEMMA11 : Let x k S ckXk = S ( X ) be a formal series with rational coefficients. Assume that two polynomials P and Q can be found in C [ X ]such that S ( X ) = P(X)/Q(X).Then, there are two irreducible polynomials A(X) and B ( X ) in Z [ X ]such that B(0) # 0 and S ( X ) = A(X)/B(X). Proof of Lemma 1 1 : We can assume that P and Q are relatively prime. ... q,Xn; two elements Q, and Q, of Let us write Q ( X ) = q, + q l X C [ X ]are called equivalent if, for some complex il # 0, Q, = RQ, . Up to an equivalence, Q is determined by the relations c,q, c,+ ,q,,-, + ... ck+,qo = 0, k 3 k,. Since these linear equations have rational coefficients and a well-defined solution, this solution can be chosen to be rational. Hence P and Q are relatively prime elements of Z [ X ] .If Q(0) = 0 while P(0) # 0, P(X)/Q(X)cannot be a formal series with positive powers. Using Lemma 1 1 , we can find two relatively prime polynomials P and Q with integral coefficients such that S ( X ) = P(X)/Q(X)and Q ( X ) = q, # 0. We may assume that the coefficients of P and Q do not have a common integral divisor. If S ( X ) has integral coefficients, the coefficients of Q ( X ) are relatively prime; otherwise since P ( X ) = S ( X ) Q(X), a divisor d of these coefficients would be a divisor of all coefficients of P ( X ) . By Bezout's theorem, we can find two polynomials U and V with integral coefficients such that PU QV = d. Then d/Q = d k X k is a formal series with integral coefficients. At this point we use the following lemma :
+
+
+
+
+
LEMMA12 : If the n series
I,,,
+ 1 integers go, ...,q, are relativelyprime and ifthe
+ qnXn)= k>O z dkXk has integral coefficients, then go = + 1. d/(qo
+
(1.17)
It can be assumed that d 2 1 . If lqO1> 1, we shall show that (1.17) implies a relation of the same type d1/(q0+ ... + q,Xn) = d,'Xkwith 1 < d' < d. If we repeat this descent argument d times, we get a contradiction. Assume that Iq,l > 1 and letp be a prime divisor of 9,; since q,, . . .,
Xk,,
(1.18) implies that p divides do; (1.19) that p divides dl and so on; p also divides d = godo. Writing d = pd' and d, = pd,' we get the 'prime relation'. Proof of Lemma 10: Reordering v, , ..., v, if necessary, we can define a n integer m < n by the condition lull = = lvml > lv,+,l 3 ... 2 lunl. Let R = Iv,], vj = ~e'Oj,1 < j < m and let g(k) = u1efk"' + -.. urnelkwm;then R - k f ( k ) - g(k) tends to 0 ( k + co). If R < 1 there is nothing to prove. If R 2 1 and f ( k ) tends to 0, so does g(k). But an easy computation gives lim 1/K Jg(k)12= lull2 + + lumI2;if
+
xf
K++w
lim g(k)
=
0 , this square mean is 0 and the lemma is proved.
k++a
6.4. Characterization of Pisot numbers among real numbers Let 3f be a real number greater than 1 and il > 0. It is not known whether or not the assumption IIROkll -t 0 ( k + co) implies that 8 is a Pisot number. Nevertheless we have the following theorem due to Pisot.
+
THEOREM XII: Let 8 be a real number greater than 1 and 3, > 0. Assume that x y IlROkl12 < CO. Then 8 is a Pisot number and il belongs to thefield of 8. All that has to be proved is that 8 is algebraic. Let us writeMk = a, + r,, where a, E Z and Irk] < 3. To prove that 8 is algebraic, we seek an n 3 1 and integers p,, ...,p,, such that p, p,Bn = 0. Let p16 + ak = poak plak+, ...p, a,+,; if there exist n andp,, .. .,p, such that, f o r k 3 k , ,o , = 0, then 8 is an algebraic integer. In fact, R e k ( p , p, 8 + "' pnOn) = o , pork pnrk+nand the first term tends to zero p18 + p,On as k tends to infinity. Since 8 > 1 , this implies p, = 0. It therefore remains to find such an n and such p,, . .., p,. Let 11, = Ork - r k + , ( k 3 0). We have o,+, - 80, = p o r k +p,q,+,. Our aim is now to solve all the Diophantine inequalities lool < 3, 101 - Oaol < 5, ..., lo,,, - 8ok1 < 4,... Since o , is a rational integer,
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
0
.
.
+
+
+
+
+
30
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
the first inequality will imply o, = 0 ; substituting this value in the second one we get o , = 0, and so on. To solve such a system of Diophantine inequalities, we consider Minkowski's theorem. But here a technical difficulty arises: we ceed to compute the measure of the subset of Rn+l deficed by Ixoao + + x,aJ < 3,IxoqO+ ... + xnqnl < 3, Ixoql + ~,,q,,+~l < 3, ... This computation is not feasible and for this reason we are led to restrict our 1 equations Ixoao x,a,l < 3, lxoqo attention to the first n -.- xnqnl < +,. . . , I X ~ ~ , , - ~+ + x,qZn- l l < 4. Let D, be the determinant of these n + 1 linear forms. If 2"+lDn < 1 a non trivial integral solution p,, .., p , of this finite system can be found and we obtain 0, = 0, o , = 0, ..., on = 0. New, although we appear to be a long way from our goal, the followi~glemma enables us to conclude the proof in a few lines:
+ +
+
+
+
+
y,) to be the non-trivial integral solution (x, , ..., x,). Let o , = akxo + + ak+,x,. We shall prove, by induction on k, that o , = 0. We already know that 0, = - = on = 0. Writing A,, and combining each row with the n preceding rows and with coefficients x,, ..., x,,
,
we get
... an- 1 a,
An+l
+
1;
LEMMA 14: For each X = ( x , , ..., x,) in Rn, let 1x1~ = x: + + x,. Then the determinant of the n vectors X I , . .., X, in Rn is bounded by 1 x 1 1 -..IXnl. In our case we put Q , = + + qk2+n)112and, for a constant C depending only on 8 and not on n, we get ID,[ < C ~ " Q ,.,. ., en- . Since 2 8 ~ tends , to 0, the infinite product ( 2 0 ~is~0)and 2"D, tends to 0. 2
(llz
n;
,
6.5. Proof of the main lemma For each integer m 2 1, let A, be the determinant
The hypothesis implies that, if m is large enough A, = 0. We define n as the least integer m for which A, = 0. Then A,-, f: 0. We define ( y o , . . .,
=
... a2n-2 ......... ... a ~ n - 1
.
LEMMA 13 :Let a,, k > 0, be a sequence of rationalintegers. Assume that, for each sufficiently large value of n there exists a non-trivial integral solution of a,x, + + a,x, = 0, ...,a,x, + + a2,xn = 0; then there is an integer n and a non-trivial sequence of integers y o , ...,y, such that for each k > 0, a,y, + ak+,yn = 0. This lemma will be proved in Section 6.5. To finish the proof of the theorem, we have therefore to prove that for sufficiently large n, 2"+'D, < 1. In fact, if q 2 < + CO, lim 2"+lDn= 0 as the following inequality n-r+co of Hadamard shows.
31
..
a2,
,
Since A,, = 0, while A,-, # 0, we get on+, = 0. Using this new fact we compute A,,, = A,-lo~+2to get on+, = 0, and so on.
6.6. The set S of Pisot numbers is closed This remarkable fact was proved by Salem [17]. The proof depends on the following unexpected theorem: THEOREM XIII: For each Pisot number 8, there exist a real number 2, 1 < 2 < 8 and a sequence c,, k > 0, of rational integers such that C: (28, - ckI2 < 0. Before proving theorem XIII, let us see why it implies Salem's theorem. Let lltll be the distance from t to the nearest integer. The conclusion of Theorem XI11 can be written Z; l128kl12 < 9. Let 19, be a sequence of Pisot numbers and assume that 8, + 8 ( m+ +a ).For each 8, let A, be the corresponding real number given by Theorem XIII. Then the2, are bounded and there is a subsequence of the 2, tending to 2 > 1. By Fatou's inequality Zg JlAOkl12 < 9. Pisot's theorem implies that 8 is a Pisot number. Now to Theorem XIII! The proof depends on the following three observations : 6.6.1. Let D be the closed disc lzl < 1, g any holomorphic function on a neighbourhood of D, and g(z) = 1; rkzk the Taylor expansion of g. Then, by Parseval's equation, 1 2 lrkI2 = 1/2n jiX lg(eie)12do. 6.6.2. Let P(z) be any polynomial in z with real coefficients. Then if lzl = 1, IP(z)l = IP(l/z)l. 6.6.3. Let 8 be a Pisot number. Assume that a conjugate Oj of 8 is 118. Then we can find an integer p > 3 such that O2 - p8 + 1 = 0.
T t
32
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
n;
n[Zj"€Jk.
To prove the third observation, write 8 Ok = 80j If 8 is not a quadratic number and if 80j = 1, this product has an absolute value less than 1. But, for any algebraic integer 8 n"2k is a non-zero rational integer. Now to the proof! We first deal with the case when 8 is not a quadratic ... + a, the minimal polynomial of 8 unit. Let P(z) = zn alzn-I and Q(z) = 1 a l z a,zn the reciprocal polynomial. Then f ( z ) = P(z)/Q(z)has the following properties: (a) f ( z ) is meromorphic in the complex plane; ( b ) the poles off are 1/8, 1/8,, ..., 1/8, (by 6.6.3); (c) the Taylor expansion of f in lzl < 1/13 is f ( z ) = ckzk,whqre c, E Z. Since 110 is the unique pole z off, such that lzl < 1, and since this pole is simple, there exists a complex number ,u # 0 such that g(z) = f ( z ) - p/(l - 8z) is holomorphic in a neighbourhood of D. To estimate ,u, let us write
+
+
+
+
+
C:
Then P I and Q, are two reciprocal polynomials of degree n - 1 with real coefficients. We have ,u = (118 - 8) Pl (1/8)/Q1(118); therefore u , is real. On lzl = 1 , 6.6.2 gives IPl(z)/Ql(z)l = 1, and since Pl/Ql is holomorphic in a neighbourhood of D, the maximum modulus principle gives
therefore I,ul < 8 - (118) < 8. On lzl = 1 we have Ig(z)l < 1 + (,uI/(I3 - 1); using the bound Ipl < 8 - (1/8),we get l,ul < 28 - 2 and Ig(z)l < 3. The Taylor expansion of g in lzl < 118 is (c, - ,uOk)zk. Since g is holomorphic on a neighbourhood of D, this expansion is valid on a neighbourhood of D, acd 6.6.1 implies (c, - ,uOk)' < 9. We have l,ul < 8 and ,u # 0. If ,u < 0 we replace ,u with -,u and ck with -ck. If 0 < ,u < 1 let h be the first k such that ,uOk 2 1 and replace ,u with ,uOh = A. We have 9 2 ( c , + ~- ,u8h+j)2= (dj - A8i)2. If 8 is a quadratic unit such that 8, - p8 + 1 = 0 for some p 2 3, then 8 2 (3 + J J ) / 2 and since Ok + 8-k is a natural integer, we get
1: 1:
C:
22
33
6.7. Construction of Pisot numbers in a given real algebraic number field Let K be a real algebraic field, d c K be the ring of algebraic integers in K and w , , . ,w, a basis of the free Z-module d.Let o , , ...,on be the n Q-isomorphisms from K into Z indexed in such a way that o , = Id (the identity map from K to R). With this terminology we have the following result :
..
THEOREM XIV: Each positive real number A = plwl + + p,w, + p,oj (con)]< 1 for 2 < j < n is a ( p jE Z) such that Ip,oj (w,) + Pisot number of degree n in K. Each such Pisot number can be written in this way. + p p , , A is an algebraic integer. Assume Proof: If A = plwl + that il # 0.Then A > 1, for otherwise the product l o , (A) on@)would have an absolute value less than 1. Let m be the degree of A. If m < n, then n = mp and the complex numbers A = ol(A), o,(A), ...,on(A)are in fact m distinct complex numbers, each of them written p times. Hence a,@) = A is writtenp times; this is incompatible with A > 1 and loj@) < 1 for 2 < j < n. We have proved that the degree of A is n. In this case o,(A), ...,o,(A) are the conjugates of A different from A and A is a Pisot number. The converse implication is obvious.
The set of Pisot numbers of degree n lying in K is closed COROLLARY: with respect to multiplication. Proof: Since the o j , 2 < j < n, are multiplicative, the set of positive A inA such that loj(A)l < 1 for 2 < j < n is closed with respect to multiplication. Let r be the number of j such that oj(K) c R and put n = r + 2s, 1 < r < n, s 2 0. Assume that oj and oj+, are pairwise-conjugate for r 1 < j < r + s. Let d be the determinant whose elements are oj(cok), l<j
+
THEOREM XV: With the preceding terminology, each interval of real numbers of length T contains 2'- lnsld1- l T + o ( T )Pisot numbers of degree n belonging to the real algebraic number field K; the little o is uniform with respect to the position of the interval I.
34
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
6.8. The Salem class T DEFINITION 12: Let 8 be a real number greater than 1. We say that 8 is a Salem number and we write 8 E T if 8 is an algebraic integer, of degree say n, whose other conjugates 8,, ..., 8, satisfy the inequalities 1 8,l < 1, 2 6 j < n, with equality for at least one j. If the latter condition was not satisfied, a Salem number would be a Pisot number. ... an E Z [ X ] be the minimal polynoLet P ( X ) = Xn alXn-l mial of 8 and, reordering if necessary, let 8, be a root of P such that 18,1 = 1. The following lemma will be useful in constructing Salem numbers:
+
+
+
LEMMA 15: Let P in Z [ X ]be irreducible and let n be the degree of P. I f one root [ of P(z) = 0 satisfies l[l = 1, then P ( X ) = XnP (1IX). Proof: Let Q(X) = XnP ( l / X ) . Then Q ( X )E Z [ X ]and Q([) = 0 (since P ( n = P(5) = 0). Hence P and Q are not relatively prime and since P is irreducible over Z [ X ] , this implies P = cQ, where c belongs to Q. Using the fact that P i s distinguished, we get c = 1 ( c = - 1 would lead to P being divisible by X - 1). This lemma at once gives the following result: T J ~ O R EXVI: M Let 8 be a Salem number. The degree n of 8 is an even integer, say n = 2m, and the conjugates of 6 are 1 /€' and n - 2 pairwiseconjugate complex numbers of absolute value 1, (5, , &), .. ., (Cm-1, Sm-1). Construction of Salem numbers. We say that an algebraic number field K is totally real if the n Q-isomorphisms from K to C are real.
c,), (c2,
THEOREM XVII: Let K be a totally realjield, o , , .. .,on the n Q-isomorphisms from K into R a n d A the set of all real numbers t greater than 2 of the form t = o,(il), where the algebraic integer il satisjies the inequalities lo,(il)l < 2, ..., I~,,(il)l< 2. Let 8 be dejined by 8 8- = t. Then 8 is a Salem number and each Salem number can be constructed in this way. Proof: Let 8 be a Salem number and let P ( X ) be the minimal polynomial of 8. Using the transformation X + X - l = Y,we find a distinguished polynomial Q of degree m such that P ( X ) = XmQ ( X + X - l ) . The roots of Q are exactly the m distinct real numbers 8 8-l, 2 Re C1, .. , 2 Re On the other hand, if K i s totally real, let il be an algebraic integer in K such that ol(il) > 2, -2 < oj(il) < 2 for 2 < j < m. Let 8 > 1 be defined
+
+
.
35
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
by 8 + 8-I = o,(il); then 8 is an algebraic integer and the conjugates of 8 are 8-I and the 2m - 2 complex numpers of absolute value 1, (c,, ..., (Cm- tm-l) defined by 2 Re cj = oj(il) (2 6 j < m). Let d2 be the discriminant of the field K. It can be proved (Chapter V) ]dl-l + 0 (T) that each interval of real numbers of lengthT~ontains4~-lT distinct such Salem numbers 8 such that 8 -t 8-I belongs to K; the little o is uniform with respect to the position of the given interval but not uniform with respect to K.
ti),
6.9. Characterization of Pisot and Salem numbers. Characterization of Pisot and Salem numbers among algebraic numbers THEOREM XVIII: Let 8 be an algebraic real number greater than 1; the following two properties are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot or a Salem number; (b) for each positive E , there exists a positive il such that,for each k 2 0, ))~8k11 6 8. Proof: If 6 is a Pisot number, we put il = Om and (b) is fulfilled provided m is sufficiently large. If 8 is a Salem number, (b) will be proved in Section 7.2. The implication (b) => (a) can be proved exactly as in Theorem XI.
Charakterization of Pisot and Salem numbers among real numbers THEOREM XIX: Let 8 be a real greater than 1. The two followingproperties of 8 are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot or a Salem number; (b) for each positive E , there exists a positive T such that any interval of real numbers of length T contains a solution il to all the Diophantine inequalities I(ilBk(l< E ( k 2 0). This theorem will be proved in full detail in Section 7.2.
7. Pisot numbers, Salem numbers and harmonious sets of real numbers Let A,, k 2 0, be a sequence of real numbers. Let A be the set of all ilk and H the subgroup of R generated by A (H is the set of all finitz sums z k a O pkilk,pk E Z. Some definitions should be recalled. DEFINITION 13: Let X :A + R / Z be a mapping dejined by ~(1,)= elk (mod I), where a, is a given sequence of real numbers.
36
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
W e write x E Hom ( A , R / Z ) ifone of the following equivalen conditions holds: (a) x is the restriction to A of a homomorphism from H to R / Z ; (b) for each finite sequence of rational integers p k , k > 0, thefollowing implication is true x k g O pkAk = 0 * pkak E 0 (mod I ) . Here is an example. Let 8 be an algebraic i~iteger,n the degree of 8 and ilk = Ok, k > 0. With this terminology we have: 5 : Let a,, ...,a,-, be any sequence of n real numbers. PROPOSITION There is one and exactly one x in Horn ( A , R / Z ) , such that x(Ok) = a , (mod 1 ) for 0 < k < n - 1. (a) Proof of the uniqueness of X : Let P ( X ) = Xn + alXn-l + + an be the minimal polynomial of 8. We have, for each positive k , Ok+" + a18k+n-1+ ... + anOk = 0 , whence x(Ok+")+ alX (8k+n-1)+ + a,X (8,) E 0 (mod 1 ) and by induction on k , all the x(Ok)can be found from those for 0 < k < n - 1. (b) Proof of the existence of X. Let H = Z + ... + Zen-'; the independence over Q of 1 , 8, ..., O n - l implies that H i s a free Z-module and there is a homomorphism X' from H to R / Z , defined by ~ ' ( 8E~ a), (mod 1) for 0 < k < n - 1. The restriction of X' to A is X . Assume now that the a,, 0 < k < n - 1 are ratiocal real numbers. Then we have : PROPOSITION 6 : With the preceding terminology the mapping k -+ x(Ok) is periodic for k > k,. Letp be an integer such thatpol, E 0 (mcd I ) , 0 < k < n - 1 and let be the finite subgroup of R / Z consisting of residues modulo 1 of k/p, k E Z . Let E be (I',)" and let x , be the element x(Ok),..., x(Ok+"-l) of E. The proof of the uniqueness of x shows that a mapping pl from E to E exists such that x k + , = pl(xk) for all k 2 0. A standard argument then shows that k -+ x , is, eventually, a periodic mapping.
rp
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
If, however, the weak elements of Hom (A, R / Z ) do not give any substantial information about the possible sequences of residues of t2,, k 2 0 , they are of no interest. We recall the definition of harmonious sets.
14: A set A = {A,, A,, . .., Ak, ...) of real numbers is harDEFINITION monious if, for each x in Horn (A,R / Z ) and each positive E there exists a real number t such that, 11x(3Lk)- tA,ll < s for each positive k .
7.2. The connection with Pisot and Salem numbers THEOREM XX: Let 8 > 1 be a. real number a n d A = (1, 0, 02, ...} be the set of all powers of 8. Then A is harmonious if and only if 8 is a Pisot or a Salem number. Before proving Theorem XX, some remarks should be made. (a) Combined with Thecrem X it gives Theorem XIX. (b) Let 8 = ( 1 + JJ)/2, x E Horn (A,R / Z ) be defined by the following properties: ~ ( 1 = ) 0 , ~ ( 8=) 4,~ ( 8=~+, )and k + x(Ok) is periodic of pericd 3. For each positive s, let I b e the interval [ - E , s] and J t h e interval [i- F , 3 + E ] . Then a real number t can be found such that for k = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ,...
t O k € I ,J, J , I, J, J , I , ... mcdulo 1. This kind of periodic repetition mcdulo 1 can be found for all Pisot or Salem numbers. Now to the proof sf Theorem XX! (A) 13is a Pisot or a Salem number implies A is harmonious. The prcof depends on the following lemma: LEMMA 16: Let 8 be an algebraic integer, n the degree of 8, P ( X ) = Xn E any positive real number. Let A be the set (1, 8, . .., Ok,...). For each x E Hom(A, R / Z ) there exist a real number t and n - 1 complex numbers t, , .. ., t, with the following properties: (a) for each k > 0 , ~ ( 8=~tOk ) + (mod 1 ) ; (b) i f o m = 8 1 , t h e n t m = l l f o r a n y 2 < 1 < m < n ; (c) Itj[ < s for 2 < j < n and It1 < C(8)&-"+Iwhere C(8)depends only on 8.
+ alXn-I + ... + a, the minimal polynomial of 8 and
7.1. Weak and strong elements of Hom ( A , R / Z ) Among the x E Hom ( A , R / Z ) , we can distinguish weak and strong elements: let t be a real number and let a , be the residue modulo 1 of tA,; then x(Ak) = a k defines an element of Hom ( A , R / Z ) which will be called strong. On the other hand an element of Hom (A,R / Z ) which is not a strong homomorphism will be called a weak homomorphism. The periodic element of Hom ( A , RIZ) defined above is a weak homomorphism.
37
38
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
DIOPHANTINE APPROXIMATIONS TO REAL NUMBERS
Proof of the lemma: Let ~ ' ( 0 , )be the second term in (a) with an unspecified sequence (tl , t2, . .., t,) satisfying (b) and (c); then X' E Hom (A, R/Z) and to prove (a) for all k 2 0, it suffices to prove it for 0
Proof: We write xt, = p, + r, and assume that x # 0 Since to = 1 and t, tends to infinity there is a least integer h 2 1 for whichp, # 0. Then - ~s land this implies t,,/t,,-, 2 (1 - &)Is, lxthl 2 1 - 8, while I ~ t ~ < which contradicts t,+, < Otk if s < (1 + 0)-l. For E > 0, let Te be the set of all real numbers t such that, for some 2 in X and each k 2 0, jlx(Ok) - tOkll Q E. If s < 3 and x1 and x2 are different elements of X, then t, # t2. Hence Card Te = Card X if A is harmonious. If we can prove that Te is countable for sufficiently small 8, we get a contradiction. Since {O,$} is a finite subgroup of R/Z, X i s a group; hence Te - T, c T,,. If t E T,, then )12tOkll< 2s for all k 2 0. Using Lemma 1, we get that, if 2s < (1 + el-', then either t = 0 or It] 2 E. Since Te - Te c T,,, the distance between two distinct points of Teexceeds 28 if 48 < (1 + 0)-l and so the set Te is countable.
+ In2
+
1:Let 0 be a Pisot or a Salem number; let n be the degree of COROLLARY 8. There exists a constant C(0) depending only on 0, such that for each x E Hom (A, RIZ) and each positive s, the Diophantine inequalities lltOk - x(Ok)ll < E, It1 < s-,+lC (0) can be solved. COROLLARY 2: With the same terminology, each interval of real numbers of length &-"+lC(0) contains a solution t of the Diophantine inequalities lltOkll < s (k > 0). The two corollaries follow from the lemma and the inequalities l0,l < 1, 2 d j < n; instead of (a), we get IJx(Ok)- tOkll < (n - 1) E, which is the required approximation. (B) The set A = (1, 0, ..., Ok, ...} is harmonious implies 13' is a Pisot or a Salem number. We distinguish between two cases: (a) 8 is an algebraic number. By Theorem X, each interval of length T(E) contains a solution of the Diophantine inequalities lltOkll < E (k 2 0) and by Theorem XVIII, 8 is a Pisot or a Salem number. (b) 0 is a transcendental number. Then 1, 8, ..., Bk, ... are linearly independent over Q. Let X be the set of all mappings fromA to the subset (0, $1 of RIZ. Each x in X belongs to Hom ( A , R/Z) and Card (X) = Card (R). The following lemma is now needed. LEMMA 17: Let tk, k > 0, be an increasing sequence of real numbers tending to infinity in such a way that to = 1 and t,,, < 0t,. Then, for E < (1 0)-', the inequalities 1x1 < e, and jlxOkll d E for all positive k imply x = 0.
+
39
8. Notes
1. A proof of Roth's theorem can be found in [82] or in [4]. Schmidt's theorem is proved in [84] or in [85]. 2. A more general version of Theorem I11 is given in 1221. For a very complete discussion of inhomogeneous problems, the reader is referred to Chapter XI of [5]. 3. In [34] or [83], thick sets of badly approximable sequences are constructed. 4. Theorem IX is an unpublished result of the author. 5. A first version of harmonious sets (where independence over Q is required) can be found in [44]. 6. Recent work on Pisot numbers has led in four directions. (A) Pisot's conjecture is "8 > 1, A 2 1 and lim IlA0"ll = 0 imply that 0 is a Pisot number". Some partial results can be found in [33] or [74]. (B) Generalizations of Pisot numbers can be defined in p-adic fields or in adeles rings ([28], [29], [35] and [36]). (C) Rational or analytie transformations connected with the set of Pisot numbers have been studied in [77] and [78]. (D) Explicit processes to find all Pisot numbers are investigated in [25]. Other rings for which Fatou's lemma is valid are studied in [27]. Another proof of Salem's theorem (Section 6.6) can be found in [76].
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN G R O U P S
CHAPTER I1
D I O P H A N T I N E APPROXIMATIONS A N D ADDITIVE PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
41
Let T be the group of complex numbers of absolute value 1 with the usual topology. If H = T, Hom (G, T) is called the dual group of G; we write Hom (G, T) = GAand the elements of GAare called the characters of G. We shall use the following notation: for x in G and y in G A ,the value at x of the character y is written x,(x); if G = R, GA = R and, for real numbers x and y, x,(x) = exp 2nixy. Let K run over all compact subsets of G and E over all positive real numbers; the sets V(K, E) of ally in GA such that sup Ix,.(x) - 1)1 < E XEK
In many problems of approximation of functions or distributions defined on the real line, discretization is a very useful tool: R is replaced by discrete subgroups 2-kZ for larger and larger k and the given distribution becomes a discrete measure carried by 2-kZ. The p-adic field Q, does not contain discrete subgroups. How can distributions on Q, be discretized? By using harmonious sets instead of discrete subgroups: this fact will be proved in Chapter V, Section 8, and is the reason why we try to construct harmonious sets in locally compact abelian (1.c.a.) groups. Harmonious sets are defined in Section 2 by certain remarkable properties of Diophantine approximations, and their basic properties can be found in Section 3. For our purpose, harmonious sets A such that A + K = G, for a suitable compact set K, are of special interest; they are characterized by Theorem IV. At this point we know how to construct the most interesting examples of harmonious sets; they can be defined by remarkable additive propertics. Algebraic number field theory plays a decisive role in the determination of harmonious sets closed under multiplication.
1. Preliminaries on 1.c.a. groups
I.I. Let G be a locally compact abelian group (we write an 1.c.a. group), Gd be the same group with the discrete topology and H another 1.c.a. group; then Hom (G, H ) will denote the topological group of all continuous homomorphisms from G to H, the topology being that of uniform convergence on compact subsets of G. In this context, Hom (G,, H ) is the group of all homomorphisms from G to H and the topology of Hom (G,, H) is that of pointwise convergence.
are then a fundamental family of neighborhoods of 0 for the topology of GA. Now each x in G defines a character on GA by y -t x (x) and this mapping from G to Hom (GAY T) is an isomorphism ([15] p. 27); thus G is the dual group of GA.This is Pontryagin's duality theorem. If x belongs to Hom (G, T) and if sup Ix(x) - 1I < +, the subgroup xsG
x(G) o f T reduces to (1) and x = 1. Hence, if G is compact, GAis discrete; if G is discrete, GA is compact as either the duality theorem or an easy direct argument shows. The following lemma shows that the equation of closed subgroups H of G can be written with characters belonging to the dual group GAof G. 1 : Let G be a 1.c.a. group and H a closed subgroup of G. Each LEMMA element of Hom (H,T) is the restriction to H of an element of Hom (G, T). I f x in G does not belong to H, there exists a x in Hom (G, T) such that x is 1 everywhere on H but ~ ( x #) 1. This remarkable fact is proved in ([15] Section 2.1). Let G and H be two 1.c.a. group and h E Hom (G, H). We define a dual homomorphism h A E Hom ( H A ,G A )by the following rule: if v belongs to H A ,the value of hA(v)at a point x of G is X, (h(x)).
2: If h is injective, h A has a dense range and if h has a dense LEMMA range, h A is injective. Assume that h is injective. Let N be the closure of h A ( H A in ) GA.If N # GAan x # 0 can be found in G such that, for ally in N, ~ , ( y )= 1. But if y = h ^(v), x,(y) equals X, (h(x)) and then X, (h(x)) equals 1 for all v in HA;we have h(x) = 0 and hence x = 0 since h is injective. 1.2. A special case of Lemma 2 appears in the following situation. Let G be a 1.c.a. group and G, the same group with the discrete topology; let i : Gd -t G be the identity map. Put = GA and f = (Gd)". Then both
r
43
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
the maps iand i A :T-,F a r e injective and have dense range. The compact group p i s called the Bohr compactification o f r . Since the topology off is that of uniform convergence on finite subsets of G, we can rewrite the last statement in the following way: Kronecker's theorem: Let F = (I,. ..., I,) be a finite subset of G and x :F T a mapping such that, for each sequence p, , . ..,p, of rational integers, each relation pjIj = 0 implies (X(Aj))PJ= 1. Then for each positive E , there exists a y in GA such that ( ~ ( 1 , )- xY(I,)l < E , ..., IxWn) - xY(In)I < E Prooj: Let H be the subgroup of G, generated by F. Then the assumption on x means that x is the restriction to F of an element of Hom (H,, T) which, by Lemma 1, can be lifted to an element of Hom (G,, T) = p. At this stage, we use the density of iA(GA)in p.
(3) for each positive E and eachfinite subset F o f A , there exists a y in G A such that sup AEF Ix(I) - xy(I)l < E
42
1:
n:
1.3. Annihilators
The proof of Kronecker's theorem applies here. In Chapter I we were interested in a continuous homomorphism Q from R to R/Z whose kernel was Z; for a real number t, ~ ( t was ) the residue modulo 1 o f t . The group T is isomorphic to R/Z and, using this isomorphism, we can replace Q by the homomorphism h from R to T defined by h f t ) = exp 2nit In a general context, R becomes a 1.c.a. group G and h a charact e r of ~ G. The generalization of the residue modulo 1~ ( tof) the real number t is now the element ~ ( xof ) T for a given x in G (Xbeing fixed in GA). Let A be a subset of G and let ( z ~ ) , , a~ family of complex numbers of absolute value 1. We try to guess whether (z,)~,, is the family of ( x ( I ) ) ~ ~ ~ for a suitable x in Hom (G, T) or, at least, whether for each positive E , there exists such a x with sup Ix(I) - zAl < E. A necessary condition is: A
DEFINITION 1 : Let G be a 1.c.a. group and H a closed subgroup of G. The annihilator of H is the closedsubgroup H' of GAconsisting of all continuous characters on G which are 1 everywhere on H. LEMMA 3: The annihilator of H' is H. Obviously H i s contained in the annihilator of H'. If x 4 H there exists, by Lemma 1, a y in H' such that X, is 1 everywhere on H, but x,(x) # 1 and so x does not belong to the annihilator of H'. LEMMA 4: The dual group of GIH is H'. The proof is obvious.
the mapping I + z, belongs to Horn (A,, T). We are led to the following definition : DEFINITION 3: Let A be a subset of a 1.c.a. group G. We bay that A is harmonious if, for each x in Hom (A,, T) and each positive E there is a E in Horn (G, T) such that sup Jx(I) - E(I)l < E. A
Kronecker's theorem shows that a finite set is harmonious. By Proposition 1 , each subset of an harmonious set is still harmonious. 3. Basic properties of harmonious sets
2. Harmonious sets
Let A be a subset of G and x a map from A to T. DEFINITION 2 : W e write x E Hom (A,, T) if for each integer n > 1, each sequence p, , ...,p, of rational integers and each sequence I, , . . ., I , of elements o f A , each relation C; pjAj = 0 implies ( ~ ( 1 ~ ) )=" 1 . If H is the subgroup of G consisting of all ~ u m s Z " , ~ I ~pj, E Z, Aj E A , equipped with the discrete topology, x is the restriction to A of a X' in Hom (H,T).
n:
PROPOSITION 1 : Let x be a mapping from A to T. The following three properties ofil are equivalent: (1) x belongs to Hom (A,, T) ; (2) x is the restriction to A of a 2' in Horn (G,, T);
3.1. In all the following we shall restrict our attention to 1.c.a. groups G with the two extra properties (a) and (b): (a) G is a metrizable 1.c.a. group: the topology of G is defined by a translation-invariant metric; (b) G contains a countable dense subset, in which case G is said to be separable. Then the dual group GA of G also satisfies (a) and (b). With these additional assumptions on G, we have the following result: THEOREM I : Let G be a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group, A a subset of G, and for each positive E , let Me be the set of ally in G A (the dual group of G) such that sup IxY(I)- 1I < E . Then thefollowing threeporperties o f A A
are equiz-alent: (a) A is harmonious in G;
44
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
(b) for each positive E, there exists a compact subset K, of G A such that for every x in Hom (A,, T) there is a y in Ke satisfying the Diophantine inequalities sup Ix(A) - xY(A)l d E ; A
(c) for each positive E, there exists a compact subset Ke of GAsuch that M, + K, = GA. Proof: Let A = GAbe the dual group of G and f' the Bohr compactification o f r ; r can be regarded as a dense subgroup o f f . For each x in 1; and x in G, ~ ( xwill ) der ote the value at x of the character x E Horn (G,,T). Additive notation for the group operation in f will be used. (a) => (b): Let V(E)be the set of all x in such that sup Ix(A) - 1I < E; A
V(E) is a closed subset of f and hence, equipped with the induced topology, V(E) is compact. Let (K,),, be an increasing sequence of compact subsets of r such that U K, = F ; such a sequence exists since r is se-
,
n> 1
parable. Let L, = K, + V(E); L, is a compact subset of p. Condition (a) means that the union of all L,, n > 1 , is the whole of I? Baire's theorem, applied to the compact set f', shows that, if n is large enough, the interior L, of L, is not empty. For such an n, consider the translates L, + y, y ET.SinceP i s a dense subgroup off', L, + y = L, + r = f.Again
u
YEP
r
using the compactness off', a finite subset F of can be found such that L, F = 1;.Property (b) then holds with K, = K, + F. (b) => (c): We apply (b) to x = X, for some y in r:we get a y' in Ke such that sup IxY(I)- x,. (I)] < E. Then y - y' belongs to M, and
+
A
M , + K, = (c) => (a): Let V(E) be defined as at the beginning of the proof. Then V(E) contains M(E) and the compact subset V(E) + Ke of f contains M(E) + Ke = r. But r is dense in f. Hence Ke + V(E) = p andA is harmonious.
r.
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
45
PROPOSITION 2 : Let A be an harmonious subset of G. There exists a positive 6 such that the distance between any two distinct elements A in A exceeds 6. Before giving the proof we observe that, if A is harmonious, so are A + A and A - A. To get our result, it is sufficient to prove that, ifA is harmonious, 0 is isolated inA. Let us assume that a sequence3Lkf 0, k 2 1, tending to 0 can be found in A. Let M, and K, be as in Theorem I. Since convergence in G means uniform convergence on compact subsets of T, we have large sup IxY(Ik)- 11 < E for sufficiently large k ; the inequality YE&
sup Ixy(Ak)- 1I
< E then gives sup
,EM.
IxY(Ak)- 1I
< 2s. But for a given k ,
Ys r
the set of all xY(Ik),as y runs throughr, is a subgroup of T, not equal to {I), which, provided E is chosen small enough, cannot be contained in 12 - 11 < 2E. COROLLARY 1 : If G is a compact abelian group, each harmonious set is finite and conversely. COROLLARY 2: I f G is a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group. each harmonious set can be written as a sequence (l.k)ka,. If G = R, A, = Z and A, = Z J2 are harmonious sets; in this case each x in Horn (A, T) is the restriction to A of a X' in Hom (R T). But A, u A, is not harmonious, and the conclusion of Proposition 2 is not satisfied. Nevertheless the following result is valid: 11: L e t A be an harmonious set in G and F afinite subset of G. THEOREM Then the setsA u F a n d A + F are harmonious. It is sufficient to prove that A u F is harmonious. Let E be a positive real number and Me the set of all y in r such that sup Ixu(A) - 1I < E. We have Met, - Met, c M e and Theorem I1 is now A
an easy corollay of the following lemma.
Remark: Following Besicouitch, a subset M of P i s called relatively dense = r. Condition (c) of Theorem I can be rewritten: M(E) is relatively dense for each positive E .
if there is a compact subset K of r such that M + K
3.2. Union with aJinite set
5 : Let r be a 1.c.a. group, M a relatively dense subset of T and SZ LEMMA an open subset of the Bohr compactijication .?of T.Then (M - M) n 9 is relatively dense. To get Theorem I1 from Lemma 5, let SZ be the set of all x in f 01 E Horn (G,, T)) such that sup Ix(t) - 1I < E and let M = M (42). For t sF
The topology of G will be defined by a translation invariant metric d (x, x').
each y in (M - M) n 9 , we have sup Ix(x) - 11 < E and condition (c) xsAvF
of Theorem I gives Theorem 11.
46
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
To prove Lemma 5, let li? be the closure of M in f,N = M - M and iv = - ?i? be the closure of N in p. For each subset 9 of p and each y in M we have ( y 9)n 2 c y 9 n R. If Q is open, the union U ( y + Q) = M 9 contains 2.But iS? is compact acd so there is a
a
+ +
+
,EM
finite subset A c M such that 2 c A + Q. It follows that ?i? = ( A + 52) n M i s containedin A 9 n N. Let L be a compact subset o f r s u c h that L + 3 = p; this implies L A Q n iv = p and Lemma 5 is proved (with 2~ instead of E ) .
+
+ +
4. Construction of harmonious sets in 1.c.a. groups (the lacunary case) 4.1. When G is a compact abelian group, harmonious sets A in G are finite; when G is a discrete abelian group, each subset A of G is harmonious. The construction of harmonious sets in G is interesting when G is a 1.c.a. group which is neither compact nor discrete. To begin with, we shall see that many 1.c.a. groups G contain infinite harmonious sets; in general, the sets will be lacunary sequences and the reason for this fact will appear in the study of relatively dense harmonious sets. Some lemmas are needed. LEMMA 6 : Let A be a subset of a 1.c.a. group G. Assume that, for each positive E,there exists a relatively dense subset M , of G and a j n i t e subset F , o f A such that A EA, A$ F, and y E M , imply IxY(A)- 1 I < c. Then A is harmonious. Proof: In the terminology of Lemma 5, let M = M ( 4 2 ) and let Q be the open subset of f'(r= G A ) ,defined by Iz,(t) - 11 < E for all t in F&/2. Then M is relatively dense and, by Lemma 5, so isQ n ( M - M ) = N. But each y E N satisfies IxY(A) - 11 < E for all A in A and Theorem I now gives the result. A
,
COROLLARY 2: Let G = R and (t,),. be an increasing sequence of real numbers such that lim tk+,/tk = m. Then A = { t , , ..., t,, ...) is an harmonious set of real numbers. Proof: For each positive E , let the integer n be defined by the condition: k > n implies (1 2 ~ ) / t , + < , 2 ~ / t , .Then the inequalities [lxtkll < s are satisfied by real numbers x belonging to intervals of length 2&/tkwhose centres belong to Zlt,; if k > n each such interval contains a complete
+
+
[47
interval of the same type but with k + 1 replacing k ; hence each interval of this type with k = n contains an element of M , where M , is relatively dense and Fe is the complement of t , ,..., t,-, in A. At this stage we apply Lemma 6. In a 1.c.a. group T,the order of an element y is the smallest integer n > 1 such that ny = 0. THEOREM 111: Let G be a 1.c.a. group. Assume that G is not compact and that each neighborhood W of 0 in the dual group G A contains elements of arbitrarily high order. Let K be a compact subset of G. Then we canJind a sequence (A,),, of elements of G which is a K-stable harmonious set: this means that if(&),,, is another sequence such that A; - A, belongs to K for all k > 1, A = {A;, ...,A;, ...) is also harmonious.
,
4.2. This theorem establishes the existence of stable harmonious sets in many 1.c.a. groups. These sets cannot enjoy a rigid arithmetical structure in contrast with relatively dense harmonious sets, which do (Section 5). The proof of Theorem I11 depends on the following lemmas. The 1.c.a. group G satisfies the conditions of Theorem 111. 7: W e say that a subset E of T is &-dense,for some positive F , if LEMMA each interval of T of length E contains a z in E. Let W be a neighborhood of 0 in G A and let E be apositive realnumber. Then we canfind a y in Wsuch that x,,(rA) is &-densein T . Proof: If the lemma were false, the group ~ , ( rwould ^ ) be of order < n for all x in Wand for some n independent of y. Hence each y in W would be of order
+
YEV
Proof: Let n 2 1 6 / be ~ a positive integer, and let W be a neighbourhood of 0 sufficiently small to satisfy W + -.. + W ( n times) c Vand sup yeW,xeK
Ix,(x) - 11 < lln. Using Lemma 7 , we find a y f 0 in W such that xY(G)is l/n-dense in T and hence there is an x in G such that ~ , ( x lies ) in the arc of T defined by the parametric condition z = exp 2nit, 2/n < t < 3/n. For all y in K + x , ~ , ( y )lies in the arc defined by z = exp 2nit, lln < t < 41n. But y, 271, ..., ny are in Vand z, z2, ..., zn are in U ~ , ( y ) . Ysv Hence this latter set is &-densein T.
49
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN G R O U P S
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
4.3. Now we return to the proof of Theorem 111. We inductively define a sequence A,, ...,An, ... of elements of G and a sequence Vl , ..., V,, ... of neighborhoods of 0 i n r = GA such that, if 4; - 4, E K, each translate of Vn-, contains a translate of V, on which /Xy(4:) - 11 < l/n. Once this is done, Lemma 6 shows that the set A of all A;, n > 1, is harmonious. Assume that A,, ...,An, Vl, ..., Vn are defined and let us construct An+, and Vn+ . There is a neighborhood Wn+, of 0 in r = G A such that Wn+, + Wn+, c V, and, by Lemma 8, there is a A,+, in G such that U ~ ~ ( 4is' ) 1/(2 (n + 1))-dense in T for each 4' in A,+, + K. Let YEW,,+I V,+, c W,+, be the set of all y such that sup Ixy(Ar)- 11
Since the s u m k F is harmonious whenA1is, and since each part of an harmonious set is harn~onious,this theorem is a characterization of relatively dense harmonious sets in G in terms of models. The proof is divided into several stages. Firstly we enlarge the definition of models by replacing Rn by a general 1.c.a. group; we obtain a result similar to Theorem IV. Secondly using structure theorems for 1.c.a. group, we reduce this general 1.c.a. group to Rnand we introduce the finite set F.
48
,
5.2. More general definition of models and the first part of Theorem I V
rl'~A,,+l + K
+
+
Q (2n 2)-I and consider a translate y, Vn of Vn; taking z = Xyl(4~+l), we can find a y, in y, Wn+, such that I~,,(il;+,) - 11 1/(2 (n 1)). Thus y, Vn+ c y, Vn and we have IX~(X,+ ,) - 1I
<
+
+
+
,
< l/(n + 1) for all y running in y,
+ +
+ Vn+l.
5. Construction of relatively dense harmonious sets 5.1. The previous construction provides examples of lacunary stable harmonious sets. On the other hand, relatively dense harmonious sets have a fairly rich arithmetical structure that we shall now define. We characterize relatively dense harmonious sets in a 1.c.a. group G in terms of models. But what is a model? DEFINITION 4 (The models): Let G be a 1.c.a. group, n 3 0 an integer, D a closed, discrete and relatively dense subgroup of G x Rn, and p , : G x Rn t G, p, : G x R" t Rn the canonical projections. Assume that the intersection of D and (0) x Rn is equal to (0,O) and that p,(D) is dense in Rn. Let 9 be an open subset of R" with compact closure. The modeIA of G defined by n, p, ,p 2, D and 52 is the set of all x = p,(d) in Gfor all din D such that p,(d) lies in 9. A modelA in G is a set which is so definedfor suitable n, p, ,p, ,D andQ. Before giving the main theorem, some remarks should be made. If n = 0 we define R0 as (0). A subgroup D of G x Rn is discrete if, for a suitable neighborhood ' 9 of 0 in G x Rn, V n D = (0,O). THEOREM IV: Each model in G is harmonious and relatively dense. For each harmonious and relatively dense subset A of G there exists a modelAr in G and afinite subset F of G such that A is contained in A' F.
+
DEFINITION 5 : Let G and H be two 1.c.a. groups and p, : G x H -+ G, p, : G x H t H the canonical projections. We say that G produces H if there exists a closed subgroup D of G x H with the following properties: (a) D is discrete in G x H; (b) D is relatively dense in G x H; (c) if, for some y in H, (0, y) E D, then y = 0; (d) p2(D) is dense in H. We shall see later that such H can be defined in terms of G and relatively dense harmonious subsets of G, whence the name G 'produces' H. Let 8 be the compact group (G x H)/D and n the canonical homomorphism from G x H to 8 whose kernel is D. In all of what follows we shall write G instead of G x (0) and H instead of (0) x H. Since D n H = (01, the restriction of n to H is injective; since p,(D) is dense in H, D + G is dense in G x H a n d n(G) is dense in @. Let G A ,HAbe the dual groups of G and H a n d A the annihilator of D in GA x HA(GA x HAis the dual group of G x H a n d A is the subgroup of all characters in G A x HAwhich are 1 everywhere on D). Then A is isomorphic to 8"; we shall write A = 8" (Lemma 4, Section 1). Let D A be the dual group of D ; D A is compact and isomorphic to (GA x HA)/A and we shall write D A = (GA x HA)/A.Hence A is relatively dense in GA x H A .Since D is relatively dense, A is discrete (the proof is exactly as in Proposition 2). Let 9, and 9, be the two canonical projections q, : GA x HAt GAand 9, : GA x HA-+ HA and Q : G A x HAt D A the canonical homomorphism whose kernel is A. The dual homomorphism of n : H -, @ is 9, : A t HA; the first one is injective and hence the second has a dense range. The dual homomorphism of p, : D + H is Q : HAt D A; the
50
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
first one has a dense range and hence the second is injective. We have proved.
LEMMA 10: If G produces H, then for each open subset Q of H, there exists a compact subset C of G such that G x H = D (C x Q). Proof: Let C, and C2 be two compact subsets of G and H such that D + (C, x C2) = G x H. Since p2(D) is dense in H, we can find a finite subset F of D such that the compact set C, is contained inp,(F) 52 Let C, x (p2(F) Q) = D + C = C, - p,(F). We have G x H = D (C, - p,(F)) x Q = D C x Q.
+
+
+
51
5.4. Thejirst step towards the secondpart of Theorem IV The main result here is
9 : If G produces H, then GAproduces HA. LEMMA Before giving an interesting result, another lemma is needed:
+
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN G R O U P S
+
PROPOSITION 4: LetA be a subset of a 1.c.a. group G. IfA is harmonious and relatively dense, then A is contained in a model in the wide sense. To prove Proposition 4, the main problem is to find H 'produced' by A and G. Consider the group Hom (A,, T) with the topology ofpointwise convergence and let V , be the compact subset of Hom (A,, T) defined by sup lx(A) - 11 < 3. Then, the dual group HAof H will be the subgroup A
of Hom (A,, T) generated by V, ;the topology of HAand of Hom (A,, T) coincide on V, and H will be defined as the dual group of HA. Some new terminology is needed before giving details of the proof.
5.3. The first half of Theorem IV can now be proved. 3 : If G produces H, then for each open subset Q of H with PROPOSITION compact closure, the set A of allp,(d), d E D, such that p2(d) E 52 is harmonious and relatively dense. Such a A will be called a model in the wide sense. Proof: (a) A is relatively dense. We apply Lemma 10 to -52 instead of 9 ;we find a compact subset C of G such that each (x, 0) can be written ( x , 0) = d (t, o ) where d E D, t E Cand o E -Q. Hence x = p,(d) + t, 0 = p2(d) o.Then il = p,(d) EA and G = A + C. (b) A is harmonious. Let x be in Hom (A,, T); we can find 5 in Hom (D, T) such that 5 = x op, on the subset B of D defined byp2(d) E 52. This 5 belongs to the dual groupof D, whichis(GAx HA)/Aandcanbelifted to yield an element X of GAx HA.For each din D, we get xc(d) = xx(d) because A is the annihilator of D. Let V c HAbe an open neighbourhood of 0 sufficiently small to satisfy sup Ixe(y) - 11 < E; such a V can be found because Q has compact
+ +
BeV,ysQ
closure. Using Lemma 10, we get a compact subset Kof GA such that GA x HA = A + K x V. Hence for each X in GA x H A ,there is a 6 in A, an in K and a 8 in V such that X = 6 + (7, 8). By restriction of these characters to D, we have, for all din D, xx(d) = xr(d) = x,,(p,(d)) xe (p2(d)). Assume that p2(d) E Q (if p,(d) EA) and 8 E V; we obtain Ix, (p2(d)) - 11 < E, which implies (xr(d) - x,, (p,(d))l < E cr Ix(A) - ~,,(i))(< E for all i in A.
5.5. Some terminology A is the given harmonious set; R the subgroup of G, generated by A (R is not the real line); R A the compact dual group; j : R + G is the identical injection and h : GA + R A is the dual homomorphism; V(e) is the set of all x in R A such that sup (x(A) - 11 < E ; M(e) is the set of all x in GA nsn
such that sup ~x(A)- 11 < E; E is the group (without any topology) IsA
generated by V(3) in R A ;i.e. E is the set of all s u m s p , ~ , for all n > 1, p j E Z arid vj in V(f).
+
+ p,zh
5.6. Some lemmas LEMMA 11 : h(GA)is dense in R A . Proof: j is injective. LEMMA 12: E + h(GA) = R A . Proof: A is harmonious. LEMMA 13: There is a compact neighbourhood @ of 0 in GA,symmetric about 0 such that @ n M(+) = (0) and h(@) n V(f) = (0). Proof: There is a compact subset T i n G such that A + T = G. Let @ be defined by sup Ix,(x) - 1I < E . For v E V(+) n h(%) we ueQ,xsT
have sup IX.(X) - 11 < f
+ E ; if f + E
xeG
same proof holds for @ n M(+).
< 43 this implies v
=
0. The
52
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
5.7. Let V , = V(2-"). Then V , = - V, and V,,, + V,,, c V,. (V,),, is a sequence of neighborhoods of 0 in E defining topological group structure on E. Let F be the corresponding topology on Eand 9 the topology of the compact group R A .
,
LEMMA 14: For each p 3 1, Y and Finduce the same topology on V,. Proof: We write M , for M(2-"). SinceA is harmonious, M, is relatively dense and there exists a finite subset F, of G A such that % F, + M, = GA. We have h(M,) c V , and, since % is compact, so is V , + h(%) h(F,) which contains h ( G A )and is thus the whole of R A . From Baire's theorem or elementary arguments, we deduce that V, h(%)has a non-empty interior. But V,, - V , + c V , and we can replace @ by a V such that V - V c %; hence for a suitable V not depending on n V , h ( V ) is a neighbourhood of 0 in R A for each n 2 2. Lemma 13 shows that, if n > p, V , is the intersection of V p and V , + h ( V ) ; hence the topology F defined in V pby the V, is weaker than But r) V , = (0); V pis thus a Hausthe topology induced in V pby 9.
+
+
,
+
,
+
n>
dorff space under F and a compact Hausdorff space under 9. Hence 9-= Y o n V p .
5.8. We have proved that E is a locally compact abelian group. We shall attempt to construct in G A x E the discrete relatively dense subgroup A. Let 9 be the intersection of E and h(GA);we have LEMMA 15:9 is dense in E. Proof: Since A is harmonious, we have, for each n 2 1, h ( G A ) V , 3 E, which implies 9 V , = E. Let A be the subgroup of GA x E defined as the set of all pairs ( y , d ) where d E 9 and h(y) d = 0.
+
+
+
LEMMA 16 :A is a discrete relatively dense subgroup of G A x E; the intersection of A and (0) x E is (0,O) and q,(A) is dense in E. (We define q, : GA x E -+ G A and 9, : GA x E -+ E as in Section 6.) Proof: Let @ be as given by Lemma 13; we shall prove that the intersection of @ x V , with A is equal to (0, 0). If (y, d ) E A n (@ x V,), then d~ V , n h ( % ) = ( 0 ) a n d y ~ Mn~%= (0) Let K be a compact set in GA such that K + MI = G A .Then K x V , A = G A x E and A is relatively dense. To prove this, we need, for each x i n G A , y i n E , t o s o l v e x = d + r , y = -h(d) + s w i t h d ~ 9 , r ~ K a n d
+
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
53
s E V 1. This is equivalent to solving x = d + r and y + h(x) = s + h(r). But V , + h(K) = R A and the second pair of equations has a solution (s, r ) in V , x K. We put d = x - r and we have to show that d E 9 ;but h(d) = s - y = h ( x - r ) ~ E h(GA). n Finally if ( y , d ) belongs to A and to (0) x E, we have y = 0 and d = -h(y) = 0.
5.9. Let H be the dual group of E and D the annihilator of A in G x H ; p , : G x H -, G is the first projection andp, : G x H -+ H the second one. Then A n (0) x H = {0,0) andp,(D) is dense in H (these two propcrties are not changed under duality). LEMMA 17: There is a compact subset L of H such that A is contained in the set of allp,(d), d E D, .for which p,(d) E L . Proof: Let il be an element of A. Then il defines a character on R A since A belongs to R. By restriction to E, il defines a character X , on E = HAwhere 11 belongs to H. q ) then For each d = h(y) in 9, we have x,(y) = x,(d). The pair belongs to D, since for every ( y , d ) in A, we have x,(y) x,(d) = x,, (d + h(y)) = 1. Let 9 be the set of all q for il in A. Then sup Ix,(v) - 11 < 2-". VET',, The following lemmawill be used to prove that 9 is relatively compact in H. LEMMA 18: Let H be a 1.c.a. grOMp a n d 9 a subset of H. Assume that, for eachpositive E there exists a neighbourhood V ( E )of 0 in the dual group H A such that for all u in SZ and v in V(s),Ix,(u) - 11 < F . Then 9 is relatively compact in H. Proof: Let U be a neighbourhood of 0 in H. We have to find a finite subset F of H such that 9 c U + F. We can assume that, for some compact subset K of H A and some positive E, U is the set of all u in H such that Ix,(u) - 1I < E uniformly over v in K. Let N be a finite subset of H A such that V ( E / ~+) N contains K. Consider the restriction to N of the functions v + xV(u),where u belongs to 9. There exists a finite number u,, . .., u, of such u with the following property: for each u in 9 there is a j, 1 < j < n, such that sup Ix,(u) - xv(uj)JQ ~ 1 3 Let . F be {u,, .. ., u,);
+
voN
then U F contains 9. In fact if u belongs to SZ, we have, for a suitable j, lxV(u)- xv(uj)l < 613 and Ixw(u) - 11 < ~ / for 3 each v in N a n d each w in V ( E / ~and ) , Jx,(uj) - 11 < 4 3 . Hence Ix,,,(u) - xviw(uj)JQ E for all v in N a n d w in V ( E / ~and ) u - uj belongs to U .
54
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
5.10. Reduction of H to Rn Let G be a given 1.c.a. group, H a 1.c.a. group generated by G, O a relatively compact subset of HandQ' a relatively compact neighbourhood of 0 in H. Let A(Q) andA(SZ') be the models (in the wide sense) defined by O and Q' (the relatively dense discrete subgroup D of G x H i s the same in each of these two cases). There exists a finite subset F of G such that A(Q) is contained in A(Qf) + F: since p,(D) is dense in H, there is a finite subset A of D such that p,(A) + Q' 3 Q; we put F = p,(A). If we wish to know all harmonious and relatively dense subsets of G, it suffices to determine the sets A(Q1) for small SZ' since the family of harmonious and relatively dense subsets of G is closed under the operation of taking the sum with a finite set. At this stage, we use the structure theorem for 1.c.a. groups ([15], Section 2.4). LEMMA 19: Let H be a 1.c.a. group. Then H contains a closed and open subgroup H, which is the product of Rn, n 2 0 with a compact group H,. For effecting the reduction to Rn, the following two lemmas will be useful : LEMMA 20: Let G be a 1.c.a. group, H a 1.c.a. group produced by G, and H, an open subgroup of H. Then H, is produced by G. Proof: Define Dl to be the set of all d in D such that p,(d) E HI. LEMMA 21 : Let G be an 1.c.a. group, HZ a compact group and n 2 0. Assume that Rn x H2 is produced by G. Then Rn is produced by G. Proof: Define D, to be the set of all d, in G x Rnsuch that for an h in Hz and a din D, d, = (x, y), while d = (x, y, h) where x E G, y E Rnand h E H, . To get the reduced model, let O, be Q n HI and A, be the model delined by H , and Q,. Then A c A, F, where F is finite. Let Q, be the relatively compact subset of Rn which is the projection on Rn of 4, c Rn x Hz and A, the model defined by Rn and Q,. Then A, c A, and A c A, F. Theorem IV is thus proved.
+
+
6. Relatively dense harmonious sets of real numbers
6.1. Let G be the group R of real numbers. A closed and relatively dense discrete subgroup D of R x Rn (n 2- 1) is isomorphic to Zn and there exist n independent linear forms over Rn, I,, ..., In, such that each d i n D is a sequence (l,(p), . .. , In(p)) for some p E Zn.
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
55
The models of R are giken by an integer n 2 1, n such linear forms I,, ..., 1, and a relatively compact neighbourhood Sd of 0 in Rn-l :A is the set of all A = I,(p) such that 12(p), .. , In(p) E Q. The conditions on I, , ..., In are (a) I,, ..., In are linearly independent over the field R (D is relatively dense in Rn); (b) Il(xl, ..., xn) = o,x, + + cunxn,where cu, , ..., conare Z-linearly independent (the intersection of D and (0) x Rn-l is equal to (0,O)); (c) if 1 (x, , .. ., x,) = blxl + + b,xn, where b, , . .. , bn E Z, then I, I,, . . ., In are R-linearly independent (the second projection of D is dense in Rn-l). In this case, p, and p2 restricted to D are both injective. Each harmonious and relatively dense set of real numbers is contained in the sum A + F of a model A and a finite set F of real numbers. In fact we can prove more :
.
6.2. PROPOSITION 5: Let t,, k 2 1, be an increasing sequence of real numbers such that lim tk+,/tk< + co. If the set T = {t, , . . ., t,, . ..) k-r
+m
is harmonious, then T is contained in the sum A + F of a modelA and a finite set F. For the proof we use Lemma 8 of Chapter I, Section 7; then with the notations of Lemma 13, we have % n M(E) = (0) and h(%) n V(E) = (0) for E and % sufficiently small. The proof now runs as in Section 5.4. This result is accurate since if lim tk+,/tk= + co, T is harmonious (Section 4.1).
7. Quantitative problems
7.1. Let A be a model of real numbers. Can any information be given about the two positive numbers Z(E)and T(E) defined in the following way: if 0 = to < tl . < tk < is the increasing sequence of all positive t such that sup 11 tA11 < E,then t , = T(E)and T(E) = sup (tk+ - tk)?
- -.
LEA
,
k2O
To formulate results, we need the following definition: DEFINITION 6: Let A be a model of real numbers. The degree of A is the integer used in the definition of A; it is the dimension of the vector space over Q generated by A. To substantiate this remark, we use the obvious lemma:
r
LEMMA 22 : Let be a dense subgroup of Rn and LI a neighbourhood of' 0 in Rn. Then is generated by Q n
r
r.
56
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
r
< E which implies, since Q is bounded, that sup Ilr'All < cs. We have AsA lr'l < bs and Lemma 13 now gives r' = 0, for s sufficiently small. (A is
With the notation of Theorem IV, is here equal to p2(D), which is dense in Rn-l. Since p, and p2 restricted to D are injective mappings, p,(D) is generated by A. The two definitions of n are thus equivalent. The constants, not always the same, de noted by a, b, so, ... depend on A but not on E > 0. THEOREM V: Let A be a model of real numbers, n the degree of A, w, , ..., w, a basis of the Z-module generated byA and h : R -t Tnthe continuous homomorphism defined by h(t) = (exp 2niw1t, . .., exp 2nio,t) for t E R. Then the following five statements are equivalent: (a) for each E in 10, e0[, ~ ( s 2 ) (b) for each E in 10, so[, T(s) < be-"+,; (c) h(R)fills Tn rapidly (Definition 4 of Chapter I); (d) for all rational integers m, , ..., m,, Im,o, + mnwnl 2 d ( sup Imjl)-"+l (we exclude the case where m, = 0, ..., mn = 0);
+
1Sj4n
(e) for all rational integers m, , . . ., m, and all elements A,, ...,A, of A we have mlAl ..- m,A, = 0 or lm,A, mnAnl2 d ( sup Imjl)-"+l.
+
+
+
+
l$j$n
7.2. We shall use bold letters x to denote elements of Rnand put x' = p,(x), = p2(x); Ix"l is the Euclidean norm of x" in Rn-l. To get Theorem V, we use the following lemma; the notation is that of Theorem IV.
x"
LEMMA 23: Let y = (y', y") E Rn and let B be the set of all d in D, d = (d', d ) such that d~ Q. Then for constants go, a andb, we have (1) a (2) a (3)for each E in 10, c0[, where (I), (2), and(3) are thefollowingstatements: (1) there is a (6',S") in A (the annihilator of D) such that y' = 6', ly" - PI < a&; (2) sup Ild'y' d".y"ll < E (Iltll is the distance from t to the nearest
+
dsB
integer) ; (3) there is a (6',6") in A such that y' = 6', ly" - S"( < bs. Proof of Lemma 23 : (1) => (2): Obvious since Q is relatively compact. (2) => (3): Let F be a finite subset of B such that D is generated by F. Then sup Ilx'y' xU.y"ll < s implies the existence of a 6 = ( 8 , 6") in A xeF
+
such that y' = 6' + r', y" = 6" + r" and Ir'l < be, Ir"l < be. It must be proved that r' = 0. Replacing y' and y" in (2), we get sup Ild'r' + d.r"ll deB
57
relatively dense.)
I :
t
7.3. We now turn to Theorem V. If A were replaced by {w,,
. . ., w,},
Theorem V would become a restatement of Theorem VII of Chapter I. But in Theorem V, z(s) and T(E) are defined by an infinite set of Diophantine inequalities. Nevertheless, Theorem V is a corollary of Theorem VII of Chapter I. We shall give the proofs of the implications (a) => (b) => (e) in full. The other implications can be obtained by similar methods. Let A be the annihilator of D ; A is defined by the parametric representation y, = m,(p), ..., y, = m,(p) for n linearly independent linear forms m, , . . ., m, on Rn and p running through Zn. For each positive 7, let At(q) be the set of ally, = m,(p) for all p in Zn such that Im2(p)l < q, ..., Im,(p)J < q and for each positive E,let M(s) be the set of all real t such that sup IltAll < 8. nod
Lemma 23 shows that for each positive s, A' (as) c M(s) c Ar(bs). For eachpositive E andq, let S (E,7) be the subset of Rndefined by ]y'! < ys-nfl and ly"l < E . If (a) is satisfied, if 7 is small enough and if s lies in 10, sl[, S (s, q) n A = (0) (we here usell' (as) c M(s). TheoremIV of Chapter I (Section 2.2) shows that, for large enough 7 and each s in 10, E ~ [S, (E,7) + A = Rn. This gives (c) and with M(s) c A' (bs), it gives (b). Lemma 5 of Chapter I shows that for small enough 7 and each 8 > 1, S (8, q) n D = (0). For each positive C, let Ac be the set of all p,(d) E R for which d E D and Ip2(d)l < C. Then, for a sufficiently large C, A is contained in& and, if lmll + ... + lm,l < N, the set of all sums m,A, .. + mnAn,Aj EA, is contained i d N c . Since we know that S (NC, 7) n D = (0) if q is small enough, we have Im,i2, + + m,A,l 2 q (NC)-"+l mnAn = 0 if Im,l + Im,l < N. or m,A, + A special case of Theorem V occurs in models of algebraic numbers, which we now study.
+
+
+
e . 0
8. Harmonious sets of real numbers closed under multiplication
8.1. Let K be a real algebraic number field, n = do [K; Q], a, = Id, a,, ...,a, then Q-isomorphisms from Kto C, d the ring of algebraic integers in K and w, , . ..,ona basis of a2 over Z. With this terminology we have 6: For each positive number A, the set A of all A in d such PROPOSITION
58
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
that lo2(1) I < A, .. ., lon(3L>I< A is a model and hence is a harmonious set of real numbers. Such a A satisfies the equivalent conditions (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) of Theorem V. We can index the oj in such a way that o, , ..., or are real and for each j, r 1 < j < r s, oj and oj+, is a conjugate pair; we then have n = r 2s. We defifie I, (x,, ..., x,) = wlxl w,~,, 4 (x,, ..., x,) = oj(wl) x1 . . +(con) X, for 2 < j < r, Ij (xl , ..., x,) = Re oj(wl) x, -.. Re oj (w,) x, for r 1 < j < r s and Ij (x,, ... , x,) = Im oj ( m , ) x, + ... Im a, (w,) x, for r s 1 < j < n. Dedekind's lemma shows that ol , . .., on are C-linearly independent and hence I,, . . ., 1, are R-linearly independent. Let 9 be the compact subset of Rn-Idefined by lx21 < A, ..., lxrl < A, 2 2 xj xj+, < A for r 1 < j < r s. To prove thatAis a model defined by these lj a n d 9 , it remains to show that condition (c) of Section 6 holds: if o : K + Q is a Q-linear form over K such that o ( d ) c Z, we have to show that o, a,, ..., on are C-linearly i~dependent.Assume that for some z,o, (x) E Z for complex numbers z2, ...,z, we have z202(x) . each algebraic integer x in K. Choose such an algebraic integer 8 of degree n in K and apply these congruences to x = 8,. We get z28k, + -.. + zn8,k E Z for all k > 0 and the proof is now concluded as in Theorem XI of Chapter I.
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+ + +
+
+ - +
8.2. PROPOSITION 7: Let 8 be a real number greater than 1 andA the set of all finite sums o ckOk,where each E , = 0 or 1. Then the following two statements are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot number; (b) A is harmonious. (a) => (b): Let 8,, . .., 8, be the conjugates of 8 different from 8. Then each iZ in A is an algebraic integer of the field of 8 and, for 2 < j < n, loj(i2)1 < 1/(1 - I Ojl). Hence, by Proposition 6, A is harmonious. (b) => (a): There exists a real number t # 0 such that, for each i2 in A, IltiZll < 4. Put tok = p k r,, wherep, E Z and lrkl < 4. For each k 2 0 and cj = 0 or 1, we have Isor, &,rkl < 3 ; this inequality is true for k = 0 and can be proved by induction on k: if 1 = c0 + .skOk E ~ + ~ O ~then + ' ,ti2 = q &,r0 + + ckrk+ ~,,,r,,, = q ~ ~ + ~ , w h e r e q ~ Z a n d< I s3. ~+ HenceJs,,,l ,l = IltAljandI~,+~l < +. Separating the positive and negative r,, this implies that lrol ... lrrl < 3 and llt8kll < co. Hence 8 is a Pisot number.
xk>
+
+
+
+
x,"
+
+ + +
+ +
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
59
8.3. THEOREM VI: Let K be a real algebraic number field of degree n over Q andA the set of all Pisot or Salem numbers of degree n in K. ThenA is contained in 11, + co [, is harmonious and is closed under multiplication.
Conversely let M be contained in 11, +a[, harmonious and closed under multiplication. Then there exists a real algebraic number field K of degree n over Q such that M is contained in the set of all Pisot or Salem numbers of degree n in K. Proof:A is defined by iZ E d,1 > 1 and loj(iZ)I < 1 for 2 < j < n. Proposition 6 shows that A is harmonious and A is clearly closed under multiplication. Conversely let x be in M. The set of all powers of x is harmonious since M is closed under multiplication. Hence x is a Pisot or a Salem number; let n = do [x; Q] and K = Q[x]. We shall prove that M is contained in K. We already know that each y in M is algebraic over Z and hence algebraic over K; letp be the degree of y over K. I f p = 1 there is nothing to prove. If p > 1 there are exactly p K-isomorphisms from K[y] into C. Let z be one of these isomorphisms such that z = z(y) f y. Then z ( P y ) = xmz for each positive integer m; xmyand xmzare conjugate over K and hence also conjugate over Q. Since x > 1, we can find an m such that lxmzJ> 1 ; in this case xmyE M cannot be a Pisot or a Salem number (see [19] for the proofs of the algebraic tools used here).
9. Another definition of models of real numbers With the notation of Theorem IV, an equivalent definition of models of real numbers can be given with the help of the compact group 8 instead o_'H. Some fresh notation is needed. Let n be an integer, n 2 1 ; Tn be the n-dimensional torus; I7 : Rn + Tn be the canonical homomorphism whose kernel is Zn; N c Rn be an hyperplane in Rn; U c N be a compact subset of N; = U(U) be the corresponding compact subset of Tn; a , , .. ., a, be n real numbers linearly independent over Q ; a = (a,, ..., a,) be the corresponding vector in Rn;a does not lie in N; h : R + Rn be the injective map with dense range defined by h(t) = (exp 27ria1t, . . . , exp 2niant). With this terminology we have
60
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROPOSITION 8 : The set A of all real R such that h(il) E %! is a model of real numbers and each model of real numbers can be defined in this way. Proof: Using the notation of Theorem IV, G x H i s replaced by Rn, G is replaced by the line whose parametric equations are x , = a l t , ..., x, = ant;H i s replaced by Nand the restriction of ' h to Gisinjective; otherwise, still with the terminology of Theorem IV, p2(D) would not be dense in H. The numbers a,, ...,ol, can be defined, in the language of Section 6, by l1 ( a 1 , ..., a,) = 1, Ij ( a 1 ,. .., a,) = 0 for 2 < j < n. I f A is defined by Theorem VI, a , , ..., a, is a dual basis of a basis (a,, . .., w,) of algebraic integers in K. 10. Harmonious sets in p-adic fields
10.1. L e ~ be p a prime, Q, the p-adic field and A, the subset of Q , consisting of all ordinary rational numbers of the form mpn, where m and n E Z . The p-adic norm I 1, is defined on A, by Impn] = p-" if m , n E Z and p does not divide m. Then A, c Q c Q , and Q , can be defined as the completion of A, with respect to ( I,. The ring A, is principal. Since Z is contained in A,, J = I n Z is an ideal of Z for each ideal I of A,. Hence J = m Z and I c mA,. But, for each x in I, there exists a rational integer r such that xpr E Z . Hence x E m A , and the proof is complete. Let Z , be the closure of Z in Q,; Z , is an open and closed subgroup of Q , defined by ( x ( , < 1 and Z, n Q = Z. Each element x of Q , can be < r < +. This written uniquely as E + r, where 5 E Z , and r E A,, decomposition of x is called Artin's decomposition. We put r = @,(x). For each y in Q,, the mappingx, :Q, -t Tdefined by x,(x) = exp 2 n i ~ (xy) , is a continuous homomorphism and each element of Hom (Q,, T) can be written in this way. If x and y belong to A,, exp 2nieP ( x y ) = exp 2nixy and by a misuse of language we write exp 2nixy instead of xg(x). The dual group of Q , is Q, itself. Problems of repartition modulo 1 in R become here problems of repartition modulo Z,. The field Q, does not contain discrete subgroups. To discretize on Q,, harmonious subsets of Q, will be needed. We shall now learn how to construct these sets.
-+
61
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
10.2. On A, there are two norms: the p-adic one for which A, is dense in Q , and the Archimedean one, denoted by I 1 , for which A, is dense in R . These two points of view of A, are fundamental for the following 9: For each positive real number c, let A, be the set of all il PROPOSITION in A, such that I1I, < c. Then& is harmonious and relatively dense in Q,. Proof: Let D be the subgroup of Q , x R consisting of all (1,A) for 3L E A,; D is discrete since lRlp < 1 and 1%1, < imply A = 0. Let C be the compact subset of R defired by Jt1 < +. Consider A + Z , x C. This set is closed in Q , x R since A is discrete. To prove that A + Z , x C = Q , x R , we have to show that A + Z , x C contains A, x A,, which is dense in Q, x R. We are led to solve the system x = il + s, y = L t for each x and y in A,, where ilE A,, s E Z p and It 1 < 4. We replace this system by the equivalent one x = R + s, x - y = s - t ; the second equation can be solved with s E Z and < t < 3 and the first one then gives il in A,. At this stage, we apply Theorem IV. The harmonious sets A, play exactly the same role in Q , to discretize distributions as the subgroups hZ of R (h > 0). We refer to Chapter V, Section 8.
+
+
-+
10.3. To get all harmonious and relatively dense subsets of Q,, we have to find all discrete and relatively dense subgroups D of Q , x Rn; here n 2 1 since Q , does not contain such a D. We shall regard Q , as a module on the principal ring A,. PROPOSITION 10 :Let w , , ..., w, be n p-adic numbers linearly independent over A , and let a,, ..., a, be n - 1 p-adic numbers such that w1 a2w2 ... + a,w, 0. Let Y , , ..., Y , be n vectors in Rn linearly independent over R . For each positive c, a subgroup D of Q , x Rnis defined by the parat,w,, Y = t l Y l ... t,Y,, metric representation x = tlwl where t , , ..., t, E A, and It, - a2tllp < c, ..., It, - a,t,l, < c. Then D is a discrete and relatively dense subgroup of Q, x R" and the intersection of D with the subgroup (0) x R" of Q , x Rn is equal to ( 0 ) . Conversely let D' be a discrete and relatively dense subgroup of Q, x Ru such that the intersection of D' with the subgroup ( 0 ) x Rn of Q , x Rn is equal to ( 0 ) . Then there exists a subgroup D defined as in the first part of Proposition 10 such that D' is contained in D. (a) D is discrete. The inequalities 1x1, = Itlal ... tnanlP< I , It2 - a2tllp < c, ..., It, - a,t,l, < c imply Itllp < a, ..., It,[, < a. Let La be the set of all t,Y, + + t,Y, for t , , ..., t, in A, such that
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
62
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
63
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
Itl 1, < a, . .., Itnlp < a. Then Lais a lattice in Rn.The ordinary Euclidean norm in Rnis written I I , and we can find a positive E such that Y EL, and I YI, < E imply Y = 0. Hence D is discrete. (b) D is relatively dense. The subgroup of Q , defined by x = t l o l + ... tnon for those t , , . . ., t, in A, such that It2 - a 2 t l J p< c, ..., Itn - antllp < c is dense in Q,: if we want to get Ix - t,o, - t,02 ... - tno,lp < 1, we let t , be a number in A, sufficiently near (o, + a,w,
I f(x)lp < 1x1, and an easy computation give
+
When x tends to infinity ( f ( x ) ) / xis a Cauchy sequence in Q,; let LX be its limit. We have
+
... anon) x, we let t2 be a number in A, sufficiently near a 2 t l ,and on. Starting from this approximation of x, we shall modify t , , ..., tn to get a worse approximation of x, but a better approximation of a given Y in R" by t l Y , t:Yn(t;, ..., ti are the modified t,, ..., t,). Precisely, we define E > 0 by E < c, ~la,l, < c, . .., ~la,l, < c and replace t , by t; = t , r,, ..., tn by t; = tn rn, where r,, .. ., rn are ratiocal integers such that lrllp < E , ..,, Irnlp < E. We get It; - a2t;l, < c, ..., It; - ant;lp< c a n d Ix - t;ol - - tAonJp< d (d does not depend on x or on t i , ..., ti). The set of all corresponding t i Y , + tAY, has the form X L,; X depends on t , , ..., tn and L , is the lattice defined in the first part of the proof. Since L , is relatively dense, we can solve I Y - t i Y , - .. - t;Y,I, < a for each Y in Rn by judicious choice of r,, ..., rn (a depends only on Y , , .. ., Yn and 8 ) . Therefore D is relatively dense. To get the cor,verse result, the following lemma is needed: +
SO
+
which gives Lemma 24. Returning to Proposition 10, let D,,for each a in Q,, be the set of all Since D is relatively dense, d = ( x , Y ) in Q , x Rn, such that 1x1, < D,is relatively dense in aZ, x Rnprovided lalpissufficientlylarge. The projection L of Daon Rn is a discrete and relatively dense subgroup of Rn; therefore L = Z Y , + + ZY,. The only element common to D and Q , x (0) is 0 since their intersection would be a discrete subgroup of Q,. On the other hand we have assumed that the only element common to D and (0) x Rn is 0. Therefore, we can find n p-adic numbers w, , ...,on independent over Z such that ( o , , Y l ) E D, ..., (w,, Yn)E D. For each ( x , Y ) in D, there is a rational integer k such that (pkx,p k Y ) E D,.For each ( x , Y ) in D we can therefore write x = tlw, + . tnw,, Y = t,Y, + + tnYnfor a suitable sequence t,, ..., t, of elements of Apwn to A, A,, and the mappings fl , . ..,f, from H = A,wl defined by f l ( x ) = t,, ...,f,(x) = tn are additive. Moreover, if 1x1, < lalp, we get It,l, < 1 , ..., Itnip < 1. Lemma 24 shows that It, - L X , X ~ , < b, . .., Itn - anxlP< b ; if L X=, = an = 0, D could not be relatively dense and if, for example, a , # 0 Proposition 10 is proved.
+
+
+
+
+
-
LEMMA 24: Let H be a subgroup of Q , and f : H + Q , an additive function. Assume that x E Hand 1x1, < 1 imply I f(x)lp < 1. Then there exist a positive b andap-adic number LX such that,for each x in H, 1f ( x ) - a x / , < b. In the proof it will be assumed that H i s dense in Q,. The obvious modifications should be made in the other case. (a) 1x1, > 1 implies ( f ( x ) J , < 1x1,. In fact, if pk = ]xip,then pkx E Z , and since f is additive, f ( p k x ) = pkf(x) (k 1 since lxlp > 1). We get If(pkx)l, = Ipklp If(x)lp < 1. Therefore If(x)ln < 1x1,. (b) 1 < lyl, < 1x1, implies
+
+
+
10.4. DEFINITION 7: With the notation of Proposition 10, let A,. for each c > 0, be the set of all x = t l o l + t,wn in Q , such that It, 1 , < c, ..., ltnlm < c and It2 - a2tllp < c, ..., Itn - a,t,l, < c with t , E A,, ..., t,E A,. Such a A, is called a model in Q,.
+
I
THEOREM VII : Each model in Q , is harmonious and relatively dense. For each harmonious and relatively dense subset M of Q,, there exists a model A and afinite subset F of Q , such that M is contained in A F. Proof: Theorem IV and Proposition 10 give Theorem VII.
+
Since xZ is dense in the ball of radius Jx(,,we can find a rational integer m such that ly - mxl, < I ;this implies1f ( y ) - mf(x)lp < 1. The inequality
64
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROPOSITION 11: There exists a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group G with the following properties: (a) G is not compact; (b) G is torsion-free; (c) each harmonious subset A of G is finite. Proof: Let p be a prime, p Z 2, and let Z, be the compact group of p-adic integers. The compact subgrouppz, of Z, is defined by 1x1, < p - l and we denote by N the compact group (PZ,)~with the product-topology (convergence means componentwise convergence). To start with, we construct the group G (without topology): G is the subgroup of (Zp)Ndefined by the condition that w = (w,, ..., w,, ...) belongs to G if and only if o, belongs to pZ, for large enough k(i.e. k Z k(w), say). Since Z, is torsion-free, so is G. The subgroup N of (Zp)Ndefined by w, E ~ Z for , all k 2 0 is contained in G and a topology Fon G is given by the following two conditions: the topology F induces on N its topology as the compact group specified above and N is open in G. Then G is an 1.c.a. group; G is metrizable and separable and GIN is a countable discrete abelian group isomorphic to the direct sum of a countable set of copies of Z/pZ. Therefore G is not compact. Let h E Hom (G, N) be defined by h(x) = px; the kernel of h is (0). I f A c G is harmonious, so is h(A) = PA, and h(A) is contained in the compact subgroup N of G. Therefore h(A) is finite and so is A. The dual group r of G is the set of all sequences y = (y,),,,, where y, E A,/Z for all k Z 0 and y, E (pblZ)/Z for sufficiently large k. A fundamental sequence of neighbourhoods of 0 for tn e topology of r isdefined by y ~ r ~ i f a n d o n l y i f y=, = y,-I = 0 while y, ~ ( p - l z ) / Z for all k Z n. Hence each element y of is of order p (see Theorem 111 in Section 4.1).
(r,),,,
r,
12. Pisot-Salem-Chabauty numbers in Q, 12.1. The field of fractions of the principal ring A, is Q. Therefore if K is an algebraic extension of Q of degree n, the ring d of all algebraic integers over the ring A, which belong to K is a free A,-module and d = Apwl + ..- Apwn(see [19], p. 48, th. 1). Let SZ, be the algebraic closure ([19], 5 2.3, p. 39) of Q, and I 1, be the p-adic norm on 8, which extends the given one on Q,. Then for an
+
65
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
element x of Q,, the following two properties are equivalent: 1x1, < 1 and, for some n Z 1 and a,, ..., a, in Z,, xn alxn-l +a,=O (x is an algebraic integer over the ring Z,). The reader is referred to 131, theorem 2, Section 1, Chapter 4. Let o,, ...,on be the n Q-isomorphisms from K into Q, and z l , ... z, the n Q-isomorphisms from K into C.
+
+
.
12.2. In Theorem VI, we studied the setA of all Pisot or Salem numbers of maximum degree lying in a real algebraic number field K; A was contained in the free Z-module Zw, + .-.+ Zw, of all algebraic integers of K and, for each 1in A, we had loz(l)l < 1, . .., lo,(A)J < 1. Hence A was a model. In Q,, Theorem VII shows that a model is contained in a free A,module Apwl + . .. + A,w,. Let K be an algebraic number field of degree n over Q contained in Q,. If we try to define the set A of all Pisot and Salem numbers in K as a model closed under multiplication, we are led to consider a free A,-submodule of K closed under multiplication and therefore A is contained in the set of all algebraic integers over the ring A, ([19], Chapter 11). A model in Q, is defined by n - 1 inequalities involving p-adic norms and n conditions on Archimedean norms. If we seek models which stable with respect to multiplication we are led to the following definition: 8 :Let 8 be a p-adic number. We say that 8 is a Pisot-ChaDEFINITION bauty number if 0 is an algebraic integer over the ring A,, such that loz(8)lp < 1, ..., 10,(0)1, < 1, 1r1(8>lm< 1, ..., Irn(8)Im < 1, where n is thedegreeof 8 , K = Q(8) c Qpandol = Id: K + Q p , 0 2 ,..., onarethe n Q-isomorphismsfrom K into 8,. If, with the same notation, 8 is an algebraic integer over A,, and if lo2(8)Ip < 1, ..., Ion(0)lp < 1, Itl(8)lm < 1, ..., Irn(8)lm < 1, then 8 is said to be a Pisot-Salem-Chabauty number in Q,. 12.3. PROPOSITION 12 If 0 is a Pisot-Chabauty number in Q,, eP(Ok)tends to zero as k tends to infinity. I f 8 is algebraic, if181, > 1 and i f ~ , ( B ~tends ) to zero, 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number. I f 8 is a p-adic number, if 101, > 1 and if, for some p-adic number 1# 0 , x : (Q, (Mk))' < co,8 is a PisotChabauty number. Assume 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number. Then 0,(8), ..., on(@ are integers over the ring Z,. Since 8 is integral over A,, O k ( ~ ~ ( 8 ) ) ~ + ( ~ ~ ( 8E)A,) ~for each positive k. Hence ( ~ ~ ( 8 ) ) ~ ( ~ ~ ( 8 ) ) ~
+
+
+
+
+
66
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
belongs to Q, and is integral over Z,. Since Q, is integrally closed, ( ~ ~ ( 8 ) ) ~ + (0,(6))~E Zp ([19], 6 2.2, p. 36). We have Ok ( ~ ~ ( 8+) ) ~ + ( ~ ~ ( 6=) )( ~~ ~ ( 6+) ) ~ ( ~ ~ ( 0 )A,) ~ is; here a subring of Q, and of C. Hence the archimidean norm of this sum tends to zero ask tends to infinity and we can write Ok = 6, r, (k k 0) where 5, E Z, and r, + 0 (k + + CO).Moreover Irk( < + co. Next, assume 8 is algebraic and Q, (AOk)+ 0. There exist an integer 1 rational integers a,, ..., a, such that a, + a,On n 2 1 and n = 0 ; henceforallk 2 0, aoOk a,Ok+" = 0. WritingAOk = (,+r, -.. a,(,+,, we with E,EZ,, -3 < r, < 3,r,EA, and s, = a,(, observe that s, E Z, for all k k 0 and at the same time s, = -aork ... a,r,+,. Hence s, E Z, n A, = Z and s, = 0 for k 2 k,. On each principal ring, Fatou's lemma is valid (Chapter I, Section 6.2). Since A, is principal, we can find two relatively prime elements P(X) and Q(X) of A,[X] such that Q(0) = 1 andz,,, rkXk= P(X)/Q(X). Since Irklm+ 0 as k + KI, the rational fraction P(X)/Q(X) does not have pole in the closed disc lzlm < 1. Writing r, = LOk - &, we get P(X)/Q(X) = il/(l - OX) - x k > O EkXk.Since 1tk1,< 1, the series tkXkisconvergent if XEQ,, 1x1, < 1; therefore l/O is the unique root of Q in 52, whose absolute value is less than one. Hence 6 is a Pisot number. (Q, (AOk))2 < KI. We put ilOk = (, r, and rk= r, - Or,-, = OE,-, - E, (k 2 1). Then lqkJp< 101, and JrkJp< 1 1 1 , l O l ~ . Let D, be the determinant
+
+
+
+
1:
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
zk,,
-x:
+
+
If we show that for n 2 no D, = 0, we can (as Chapter I, Section 6.5) find an integer n (in fact the smallest n for which D, = 0) and n + 1 rational integers a,, ..., a, such that aork a,r,+, = 0 for all k 2 0. This implies AOk (a, ... a,On) E Z, for all k 2 0 and since a,On = 0. Therefore 8 is algebraic and is a 161, > 1, we get a, Pisot number. To prove that D, = 0 for large enough n, the following lemma will be needed:
+
+
+
+
+
+
LEMMA 25: I f x E A, and 1x1, 1x1, < 1, then x = 0. Proof: Write x = qpm, where p does not divide q; 1x1, = p-", 1x1, = 191 IpmI and 1x1, ]xi,, < 1 imply Iql < 1, hence q = 0 and x = 0. Since r: < CO,Hadamard's inequality (Chapter I, Section 6.4) shows that, for all positive E, D, = O(en) as n + + co. To get an estimate
x,"
+
67
of ID,I, we substract from each column of D, the preceding one multiplied by 0; we find r0 rl "'rn ...... .... D, = rn V n + l "'72n
..
...
+
We expand this new D, as a sum (or difference) of (n l)! elementary products of n + 1 terms chosen in D,; the p-adic norm of each of these products is bounded by (Alp 161;" and (D,I, < IAl, 101;". Hence ID,I, ID,I, < 1 for n sufficiently large and since D, and each r , belong to A,, Lemma 25 can be applied [35].
12.4. Let K be an algebraic number field contained in Q, and letA be the set of all Pisot-Salem-Chabauty numbers O in K whose degree is equal to the degree of K over Q. Just as in the real case, we get THEOREM VIII: The setA is harmonious and closed under multiplication. Conversely if M is an harmonious subset of Q, closed under multiplication, M is contained in FA where F is thefinite set of roots of unity lying in Kand A is defined as in the first part of the theorem. FA is the set of all products fjZ where f E F, A EA. The first part of Theorem VIII is an obvious application of Proposition 10. To get the second part, we proceed exactly as in the real case; for more details the reader is referred to [89]. The set of roots of unity in Q, is found by the method explained in [20], Chapter 11, Section 3.
12.5. As in the real case, we have the following characterization of PisotChabauty numbers : let 0 be a p-adic number andA the set of allfinite sums x k a O &,OR wheree, = 0 or 1. Then A is harmonious ifandonly if6 is a PisotChabauty number. Firstly, assume 19 is a Pisot-Chabauty number. Let K be the field of 8 and d = APm1 + + Apmnbe the ring of all elements of K which are integral over A,; o, : K + Q, is the identity mapping, o, , ...,onthe n - 1 other Q-isomorphisms from K into SZ, and z, , ...,z, are the n Q-isomorphisms from K into C. Then each il in A belongs to d ; lo2(A)lp < sup lo2(Ok)lP< 1, and so k2O
on; Iz1(4I, 6 11(1 - 1~1(6)1,), .-.3 Itn(%, < 1/(1 - Itn(f9lQJ). We apply Theorem VII. On the other hand, ifA is harmonious there is a p # 0 in Q, such that le, (PA)[ < for each A in A. We write r, = Q, (,uOk).Then, for all finite
+
68
69
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN G R O U P S
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELTAN G R O U P S
sequences ck,k >/ 0, where each ck = o or 1, I l x k 2 0 ~ k ~ k l< l (IIx11 is the distance from the real number x to the nearest integer). As in Proposition 7, we get lrkl < and Proposition 12 gives the result.
The adeles ring kAof k is constructed inductively. For each finite subset F of P containing all infinite places of k, kA(F) = k, D, is a locally compact ring. As a set, kA is the inductive limit of all kA(F)while kAis topologized by the condition that, for any finite subsets F and F' of P, kA(F) is an open subgroup of kA(F') whenever F is contained in F'. of kA is an arbitrary sequence of elements of An element X = k, such that Xu E D, for all places v of P with the possible exception of a finite number of places. For each x in k, there is only a finite number of finite places v = (n, K) such that n(x) does not belong to the maximal compact subring of K. Hence a mapping p: k -t kA can be defined by the rule: for each x in k, p(x) is the family of all (n,(~)),,~. It may easily be checked that p is an isomorphic embedding of k in kA, and so, with a slight abuse of language, we henceforth regard k as a subgroup of kA. Then k is discrete in kA and k is relatively dense in kA. Each k, can be embedded in kA: to each x in k, there corresponds an of kA given by Xw = x if w = u and Xw = 0 in all other element (Xw)wEp cases. From now on each k, will be regarded as a subring of kA: such closed subrings are called quasifactors of kA and, for each such quasi factor k, and each Xin kA,the component X, of Xwhose subscript is v will be called the projection of X onto k, .
rkSO +
13. Adeles and harmonious sets closed under multiplication
13.1. The introduction of adeles provides a remarkable interpretation of harmonious subsets of R and Q, closed under multiplication. The reader is referred to [3] and [22] throughout this section. A local field will be a commutative non discrete locally compact field. We will only be concerned with local fields of characteristic 0 in this section; they are of two types, namely R or C, or finite algebraic extensions K of a p-adic field Q, (from now on, K is no longer an algebraic number field as was the case in the preceding sections). The maximal compact subring of Q, is Z,, while the maximal compact subring of a finite algebraic extension K of a p-adic field Q, is the ring of all algebraic integers over Z,. If the local field Kis R or C, I ,1 will denote the usual absolute value. On each finite algebraic extension K of Q,, the p-adic valuation (of Q,) can be extended in a unique way and the maximal compact subring of K becomes the unit ball of K. Let k be an algebraic number field; k is an algebraic extension of Q of finite degree n. A completion (n, K) of k is an ordered pair consisting of a local field K and an isomorphic embedding n of k into K whose image n(k) is dense in K. Two completions are called equivalent if they only differ in that K is replaced by an isomorphic copy K' of K. A place v of k is an equivalence class of completions. It may easily be checked that all places v of an algebraic number field k constitute a set denoted by P. From now on, if v is a place of k, the corresponding local field K will be written k, and the valuation (or the absolute value) on Kwill be denoted by I I,. If K = R or K = C, the corresponding places are called infinite places and the corresponding absolute value will be denoted by I I,. All other places are called finite places. If u is a finite place of k, D, will be the maximal compact subring of the local field k,; 33, is defined by lxlv < 1.
ITuEF IIvgF
DEFINITION 9 : Let k be an algebraic numberjield and (n,, k,) a completion of k. W e shall write K = k,. A standard subset A of K is the set of all projections on k, of all x in k such that, for all places w # v in P, lxlw < 1.
13.2. It is remarkable that standard sets can be defined by Diophantine approximation properties. THEOREM IX :Let K be a localjield of characteristic 0 und letA be a subset of K. If such subsets A are ordered by inclusion, then the following two properties of A are equivalent: (a) A is a standard subset of K; (b) A is maximal among the class of those harmonious subsets of K which are closed under multiplication.
70
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
13.3. Proof of Theorem ZX when K
=
R
First of all, standard subsets of R must be specified. Since R is viewed as a completion of an algebraic number field k , it may be assumed that k is contained in R. Elements A of A are defined by three conditions : (a) A E k ; (b) for all primes p and all isomorphic embeddings TC : k -+ K of k into a dense subset of a finite algebraic extension K of Q,, ln(A)(, < 1. (c) if o, , o, , ..., on are the n Q-isomorphisms from k into C ordered in such a way that 0, is the identity mapping from k into R, then lo,(i)( < 1, ..., l~n(A)l< 1Let P(X) be the minimal polynomial of the algebraic number A, a, the leading coefficient of P, and m the degree of P. Let 9, be an algebraic closure of Q, and z , , ..., z, the roots of P(X) = 0 in 9 , . Then, for each j, 1 < j < m, there exists an isomorphic embedding zj : k + Qp(zj) such that zj(A) = z,. Hence (b) implies that all roots zj of P(X) in 9, must be algebraic integers over Z,. Classical relations between symmetric functions of roots and coefficients a,, a,, ..., a, of P imply that, for 1 < j < m, aj/ao E Z,. Since a,, a,, ...,a, are assumed to be relatively prime, p does not divide a,. But (b) must be valid for all primes p > 2; therefore a, = 1 and 1is necessarily an algebraic integer. A standard subsetA of R may be defined in the following way: ilbelongs to A if and only if +A = 1 or if there exists a real algebraic field k and +A is a Pisot or a Salem number of k whose degree equals the degree of k over Q. Theorem IX is simply a restatement of Theorem VI.
13.4. Standard subsets of C The same argument may be used to identify standard subsets of C. There exists a complex algebraic number field k and 1belongs to A if and only if l is a root of 1 lying in k or if A is a Pisot or a Salem number of k whose degree equals the degree of k over Q (such Pisot or Salem numbers are algebraic integers over Z all of whose conjugates p, with the exception of A and 2, satisfy lpl, < 1). A proof of Theorem IX for this case can be found in [42].
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
71
13.5. Standard subsets of Q, Let 9, be an algebraic closure of Q, . A standard subset A of Q, is then defined in the following way: there exists an algebraic number field k of degree n over Q, and an isomorphic embedding of k in Q, and then A is the set of all 1 in k such that (a) the leading coefficient a, of the minimal polynomial P(X) = aoXm + alXm-l + ... a, of A is a power o f p (a, = ph, h B 0); (b) all other roots A,, .. .,A, of P in 9, satisfy IAJ, < 1 (2 < j < m); (c) all roots [,, . . ., [, of P in C satisfy 1Cjl < 1 (1 < j < m). It may easily be proved that such a A is either a root of 1 lying in k or a PisotSalem-Chabauty number of k whose degree (over Q) is n. In this case, a proof of Theorem IX may be found in [89].
+
13.6. Why is a standard subset of a local field of characteristic 0 harmonious? The introduction of the adele ring kA of k gives a very easy proof. With the notation of Section 5, G is our local field K = k,, H i s the incomplete adele ring kj4 constructed from all places w v, and D is the discrete and relatively dense subgroup k of kA = k, x k i . Our standard subset A of K was defined to be the set of all projections onto K = k, of all d E k whose projections onto k i belonged to the compact set n,,,D,. Hence A is a model. The proof of Theorem IX in the general case may be found in [89].
+
14. Characterization of harmonious sets by additive properties 14.1. Let G be an 1.c.a. group andA a subset of G. We say that Ais discrete if for each ilinA there exists a neighbourhood V of A in G whose intersection with A contains only A. We say that A is relatively dense if there exists a compact subset K of G such that any translate of K intersects A. Finally for each subset A of G, A - A will denote the set of all differences A1 - 12,A, E A, A, EA. Using this notation, we can state THEOREM X : Let G be an 1.c.a. group andA a subset of G. The following two properties of A are equivalent: (a) A is discrete in G, A is relatively dense in G and there is a j n i t e subset F of G such that A - A is contained in A F; (b) A is relatively dense in G andA is harmonious.
+
F 72
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
Remarks: If F = (0) and ifA - A is contained in A + F, A is a subgroup of G. Theorem X shows, incidentally, that relatively dense harmonious sets are a natural generalization of discrete subgroups. 14.2. The proof of (b) (a) is obvious. ReplacingA by x, + A it may be assumed that 0 EA; such a translation does not alter property (a). Let A, = A - A. SinceA is relatively dense, there is a compact subset K of G such that each ill in A, can be written A, = il + r, where il EA and r E K; hence r E(A - A -A) n K = F. But A and hence also A - A - A are harmonious subsets of G; therefore F is a finite set and A - A c A + F. 14.3. To prove that (a) implies (b) the following lemma will be used: LEMMA 26: Let G and G' be two 1.c.a. groups, A a relatively dense subset of G, G, the group generated by A in G (GI may not be a closed subgroup of G) and h : G, -+ G' a homomorphism. Assume that a neighbourhood V of 0 in G, a neighbourhood Wof 0 in G' and a compact subset B of G' can be found such that h(A) is contained in B x E G, n V and h(x) E W imply x
(2.1) =
0.
(2.2)
Then A is harmonious. By Proposition 3, it suffices to prove that A is contained in a model. Definition 4 will be applied. Replacing G' by the closure H of h(Gl) in G', it may be assumed that h(G,) is dense in G'; obviously this substitution does not alter (2.1) and (2.2). Let D be the subgroup of G x H consisting of all pairs (t, h(t)), where t runs over GI. To show that G produces H, it suffices now to prove that conditions (a), (b), (c) and (d) of Definition 4 are satisfied. (a) D is discrete: obvious by (2.2); (b) D is relatively dense in G x H: let K be a compact subset of G such that each translate of K intersects A and let L be any compact neighbourhood of 0 in H. Since h(G,) is dense in H, there exists, for any y in H, a t in GI such that y E h(t) + L. On the other hand, by the definition of K, a il in A and an r in K can be found for each x in G, such that x - t = il r. Then t' = t + il has the following two properties: x E t' K and y E h(t') + L - B. (a) (0, y) E D implies y = 0. Obvious: y = h(0) = 0; (b) the second projection of D is dense in H: this was the definition of H.
+
73
14.4. The key of the proof is given by the following result about approximate additivity : For each m 2 0, let Rm be the m-dimensional Euclidean space (RO = (0)). If x = (x,, ..., x,), 1x1 = sup Ix,l. ldi<m
PROPOSITION 13: Let p : Z -+ Rmbe a mapping and C a positive constant such that for each j and k in Z.
Then an x can be found in Rmsuch that, for each j in Z and the same con stant C I d j ) - jxl < C . Writing g, = (y,, ..., v,), (2.3) holds for each vj by definition of the distance in Rm.We may thus restrict our attention to the case m = 1. As a first step, it will be proved that j-ly(j) tends to a limit x as ljl -, +a. Applying (2.3), inductively, we get (nA) - nv (A)I < nC for each n 2 1 and A > 0. Hence
If0
-
1, we get Ig,(nA
+ k) - p,(nA) - y(k)l < C. Hence
For each positive E, there is an A such that CIA as fixed, a positive N can be found such that
for each 0
< &/3;now regarding A
< k < A - 1. If m 2 NA and m' > NA (2.4) and (2.5) imply
+
The Cauchy sequence (v(j))/j tends to a limit x as j -+ ) p1(0)1 < C, the same holds as j + - co. IF(-j) + ~ ( j -
+ oo. Since
74
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
Let y ( j ) = g,(j) -jx. Then y ( j ) satisfies(2.3) and y ( j ) = oQ) as 1j l - ++ con It will be proved that Iyl < C. Assume that a positive E and an integer jexist such that Iy(j)l 2 C ( l +E). Replacing y by -y if necessary, it may be assumed that y(j) >, C ( I + E). Using (2.3) inductively, we get y (nj) 2 C nC&and y (nj) is not o ( n j ) as n tends to infinity (if j = 0, the last inequality obviously cannot hold). The following result can be proved by the same sort of argumer.t.
+
PROPOSITION 14: Let g,: Rn + Rm be a continuous mapping such that, for a constant C and every x and y in Rn Ig, ( x + y) - ~ ( x-) gj(y)l < C. Then ~ ( x=) I(x) y(x) where I : Rn + Rm is linear and Iy(x)l < C .
+
14.5. The proof of Theorem Xfor the case G
=
If A is discrete and js relatively dense in G and if A - A c A + F, then any sun1 or difference +A fA f A has the same properties. Moreover +A A f ..- + A is u~iformlydiscrete in the following sense: for E sufficiently small, a ball of radius E intersects this set in, at most, a single point. Replacing A by A - A, it may be assumed that 0 EA, A = -A; if A - A is proved to be harmonious, then A - 2 will be harmonious for each A in A, and hence so will A (Theorem 11). Let G, be the subgroup of G (Rnin this case) generated by A. To show that A is harmonious, we construct, using Proposition 14, a homomorphism h : GI -, Rm satisfying (2.1) and (2.2). To start with, the structure of GI will be described when G = Rn. Let B(a) be the ball of Rn defined by 1x1 < a. If a is large enough, each translate of B(a) intersects A. Let F, = B(a) n ( A -A). Starting from 0 it may be checked, by an obviousinduction thatAis contained in the Z-module G, generated by F,. Since F , is finite, the structure theorem of modules on principal rings shows that G, is a direct sum Z o , + ... + Zo,. We now describe a mapping g, : Rn + Rm to which Proposition 14 will be applied: the linear part I of p, will be used to construct the homomorphism h : G, + Rm. On A + A , g, is defined by: y(x) = (p,, ...,pm) if x = p , ~ , ... + ~ m w r n ( ~ j1~
+
- A) n 2B; hence g,(y) - g,(x) lies in a finite subset cf Zm. It follows that, for all x and y inA + A ,
I ~ Y ) - g,(x)l < c I Y
-
XI.
(2.6)
A paving of Rn with n + 1-simplexes can be constructed in such a way that the vertices belong t o l l + A and the distance between two vertices of the same simplex is less than 2a. Using this paving, we extend g, in the following way: the extension @ equals p, on A + A and is affine on each simplex of the paving. The following two properties of are immediate consequences of those of p,: for each 2 and A' in A, $j(2 + 2') = p(2) + q(A') (2.7) for each x and x' in Rn, ( q ( x ' )- q(x)l
Rn
+
+
+
75
< c Ix'
-
XI.
Each x in Rn can be written A(x) + r(x),where A(x) EA and Ir(x)l (2.7) and (2.8) give
IF ( x + x') - P(x) - F(x')l 6 c
(2.8)
< a; (2.9)
for each x and x' in Rn. By Proposition 14, g,(x) = l(x) + y(x), where 1 : Rn + Rm is linear and y :Rn -t Rm is bounded. We write 1 = (I,, . .., I,), where each lj is a linear form on Rn;there is a constant C such that, for each 2 = p , o , + + pmomin A, Igj(A) - l(A)1 < C, which can also be written e . 9
lpj - lj(A)l < C , 1
<j < m .
(2.10)
Let h, : G, -t Rm be the homomorphism defined by the formula (2.10) h,(t) = ( p , - I,(t), . ..,pm - Im(t))for each t = p,o, + ..- + pmo,,. Then, if E is small enough, It1 < E and Ih,(t)l < E imply t = 0 : if Ili(t)l < 3, ..., Ilm(t)I < 3 and if Ipi - Ii(t)l < 3, ..., Ipm - Im(t)I < 3, we get Jp,l < 1, . .., lpml < 1 ; the rational integers p, , . .. ,pm vanish and so does t . Lemma 26 and (2.10) show that A is harmonious.
14.6. The proof of Theorem X for the case G where K is a compact abelian group
=
Rn x K,
In outline the proof is exactly the same. We seek an integer m 2 0 and a homomorphism h, from the group G, generated by A into Rm with the two properties: h,(A) is bounded in Rm and for a suitable neighbourhocd
76
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
PROBLEMS I N LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
V of 0 in G and a suitable positive E, t E G, n V and Ih,(t)( < E imply t = 0. Such an h, will be called fit. G, must first be described. Since A is relatively dense in Rn x K and since A - A is uniformly discrete, the argument used in Section 14.5 applies here: G, is generated by a finite subset F, of G. A standard structure theorem gives: G, z Zm x @ where @ is a finite subgroup of K ([19], p. 27, Corollaire 1 of Th. 1). Let n : G -, = GI@ be the canonical homorphism whose kernel is the group @, d = n(A) and E = n(F). Obviously 1 - c 2 + E and 2 is relatively dense in G; if we construct a fit A, : (7 + Rm,then h, = A, o z will be also a fit homomorphism (since @ is finite). It suffices to work with d = Rn x (K/@)instead of G, in this case the group generated by 2 is isomorphic to Zm. From now on, we write G instead of G andA instead o f 2 and it may be assumed that the group G, generated by A is a direct sum Zw, . Zo,. We also write Kinstead of IY = K/@. Each x in G can be written x = (x', y), where x' E Rn, y E K; in all of what follows, 'prime' will denote projection on Rn. Let F, be the finite set (A + A - A -A) n ((0) x K); then (x', y) E A A and (x', z) EA A imply z - y E F,. Note that F, is contained in the group G, generated by A. Let A' be the projection of A on Rn and let g, :A' + A' -+ Zm be any mapping with the following property: for each x' in A' + A', the equality g,(xt) = p = (p,, .. .,pm)implies that x = p,o, + + pmombelongs to A + A and that x' is the projection of x on Rn. Let g,, and g,, be two such mappings pl. Then for each x' in A', g,,(xt) - vz(x1) E F , Let F be a piecewise affine extension of v ; : Rn -, Rmis given by the procedure of Section 14.5. Let A be the set of all p E Zm for which plwl ..- pmomE F1. Then all such mappings 6 have the following properties :
e
+ -+
+
+
-
+
0
-
+
for each u and v in A',
(u
+ v) - q(u) - @(v)E A
for each u and v in Rn, IP(v) - q(u)l
< c Iv - ul
(2.11) (2.12)
and two such jj differ by a bounded function. By proposition 14, = 1 y where I: Rn -, Rm is linear and y is bounded. We write I = (I,, .. ., 1,) and, for some constant C > 0 and
+
77
any il = (I1,y), I' and I(X) are connected by the relations
I
= p,o,
+
+ pmwmand
Ilj(A') - pjl
< C, 1 < j < m.
Let h, : G, -, Rmbe the homomorphism defined by h,(t)
=
(2.13)
(l1(tt) - p,,
.. ., lm(tl)- pm),where t = p,w, + ... + pmw, and t' is the projection of t on Rn. Asin Section 14.5 it may be checked that h, is fit; henceA is harmonious.
14.7. The proof of Theorem Xfor the general case Let G be an 1.c.a. group, A a discrete subset of G, L a compact subset of G and F a finite subset of G. We assume that A + L = G and A - A cA+F. Let V be a compact neighbourhood of 0 containing L avd F. The open subgroup 8 of G generated by V is a product Rn x Zp x K, where n >, 0, p >, 0 and K is a compact abelian group; see [7], Ch. I1 th. 9.8. Let A, = A n 8 and G, be the subgroup, without topology, of G generated by A, u F ; since 8is a relatively dense subgroup of Rn+"x K, an integer m >, 0 and a fit h, E Hom (G,, Rm) can be found such that h,(A,) is bounded in Rm(see Section 14.6). A constant a > 0, fixed from now on, is chosen with the two properties (i) if B c Rmis the ball 1x1 < a, h,(A,) and h,(F) are contained in B, and (ii) for each x in the finite set (A F + F) n (K + K - K), h,(x) E B. Let H be the subgroup without topology, of G generated by A. Using A = - A acd A - A c A + F, we have A A(ntimes) c A + & ' + - . . + F ( n - l t ~ m e s ) . H e n c e H cA + G , a n d H n @ = G , .
+
+
+
LEMMA 27 : A homomorphism h : H -+ Rmcan be found with thefollowing two properties (2.14) h(A) is contained in B h restricted to G , is h,.
(2.15)
Taking Lemma 27 for granted, h is fit since each sufficiently small x in G belongs to the open subgroup 8 and then h(x) = h,(x). Thus Lemma 26 implies that A is harmonious. The proof of Lemma 27 uses a standard transfinite induction of which the modern treatment is by Zorn's lemma. Consider the set of pairs (Ha, where for each a E A, H, is a subgroup of H containing G, and ha : Ha -, Rmis a homomorphism with the
80
PROBLEMS IN LOCALLY COMPACT ABELIAN GROUPS
If 8 is a Pisot number, the sets& are harmonious for all N > 1. Proposition 2 gives the result. 2. Let 8 be a p-adic number such that 181, > 1. Assume that there exists a function f : N + (0, + co) such that, for each integer m 2 0 and each sequence (p, , . . .,p,)of rational integers 8 2 f ( sup Ipjl).
CHAPTER I11
UNIQUENESS O F REPRESENTATION BY T R I G O N O M E T R I C SERIES
OGjGrn
Then 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number and each Pisot- Chabauty number has this property. The proof is similar to the one just given.
15. Notes The algebraic tools used in Section 13 may be found in [3] and in 1221. The completions of an algebraic number field k are R, C or finite extensions K, of the Q, associated with prime ideals p of the ring of algebraic integers of k. The reader is referred to [3] for an excellent discussion. A description of the multiplicative group of Q, may be found in [20].
With any sequence ( c ~of )complex ~ ~ numbers, ~ we associate a formal ckeikX.We say that the trigonoseries S = x+gckeikx;we put Sn(x) = metric series S converges to a finite function f : Q -+ C, where Q is an open subset of [O,2n], if Sn(x)+f ( x ) for each x in Q. It is indeed remarkable that a trigonometric series may converge to an integrable function f almost everywhere on [O,2n] without being the Fourier series of this function. The explanation of this fact comes from the study of the exceptional set E of x E [0,2n] for which S,(x) does not tend to f ( x ) ; E is called a set of multiplicity. If E is a compact set of real numbers, E is a set of multiplicity if and only if E carries a distribution T whose Fourier transform vanishes at infinity (Section 1). For symmetric compact sets E of Cantor type, almost complete results are given in Sections 3, 4 and 5. The p-adic case is studied in Section 6. The models defined in Chapter I1 play a fundamental role in the proofs.
r,
1. Riemann's theory 1.1. Three equivalent ways of defining a set of multiplicity are given in the following result:
I : LetE be a compact subset of [O,2n] and [O, 2n]\E be compleTHEOREM ment of E in [O,2n]. Then thefollowing three properties of Eare equivalent: (a) There exists a finite function f : [0, 2x1 + C in L1 [O, 2n] and a trigonometric series S such that Sn(x)+f ( x ) for all x in [0, 2n]\E while S is not the Fourier series o f f ; (b) There exists a trigonometric series S such that S,(x) + 0 ( n -+ + co) for each x in [O,2n]\E while not all coefficients of S vanish; (c) There exists a distribution T carried by E which is not the zero distribution and whose Fourier transform vanishes at infinity.
82
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
1.2. Before giving the proof of Theorem I, let us make some comments and give some explanations. If E possesses one of the equivalent properties (a), (b) or (c), E is called a set of multiplicity. If E is not a set of multiplicity, E is called a set of uniqueness. If for each x E [O. 2x]\E, a trigonometric series S converges to an integrable functionf, and if E is a set of uniqueness, then S is the Fourier series off. A trigonometric series is a formal series ckeikx. The Fourier transform f'of a distribution T with compact support is a complex valued continuous function defined on R by p(x) = (T, e-'"') which we loosely write J, e-iXtT(t) dt.
x
1.3. Now to the proof. Obviously (b) => (a). As we shall see, the proof of the implication (c) => (b) is very easy: the required S is the Fourier series of the distribution T. The proof of the implicationt (a) => (c) is deeper. If E = [O, 2x1, there is nothing to prove. Obviously the problem is translation-invariant and from now on it will be assumed that E is a compact subset of the open interval [0, 2x1. The Fourier series of a distribution T carried by E is the formal series
S (T; x)
=
C ckeikx, where -a,
1
ck = -J 276
e-"'T(t) dt.
1.4. The pseudofunctions
Proof: We put Dn(t) =
n
sin (n
-n
sin
C elkt =
+
i)
(t)
t
=
cos t 2 sin nt -+ cos nt. t sin 2
Let T be a pseudo-function carried by a compact subset E of the open interval 10,274. Then for each x in [0, 2x1, S, (T, x)
=
f?
D, (x - t ) T(t) dt .
If x does not belong to E, we can find an indefinitely differentiable 2n-periodic function a such that, on a neighborhood of E, COS
a ( t -x) =
t-x .-. L
t-x sin -
Then sin n (x - t) a (x - t) T(t) dt + J? cos n (x - t) T(t) dt. Sn(T, x) = Since Tis a pseudofunction, the second integral tends to 0, and by Lemma 1, so does the k s t one.
1.5. Proof of (c) => (b)
DEFINITION 1 : A distribution T carried by a compact subset of the open interval ]O,2n[ is called a pseudo-function if lirn p(k) = 0. Ikl-
DEFINITION 2: A function a : [O,2n] -, C belongs to A if the Fourier series of a is absolutely convergent. 1 : I f T is a pseudofunction and if& belongs to A, the product a T LEMMA is a pseudofunction. Under the Fourier transform, T becomes an element of c, and a an element of ll. The product a T becomes the convolution product of an element of c, and an element of I1; such a convolution belongs to co.
22
LEMMA 2: IfT is apseudofunction and ifS, (T, x) = p(k) eikx,then S, (T, x) -, 0 as n + + co,for each x not belonging to the support of T.
1 :
Let T be the pseudo-function carried by E and ckelkx= S the Fourier series of T. Then if T Z 0, the sequence ( c ~ is )not~ the~ zero ~ sequence. By Lemma 2, S,(x) tends to 0 for each x in [O,2n]\E and (b) is proved.
1.6. Sketch of the proof of the implication (a) => (c) + a, Let S = C ck eikx be the given trigonometric series and F the 2x-peri-a,
odic continuous function whose Fourier series is obtained by integrating the trigonometric series c, eikXtwice: we may assume that co = 0 and the Fourier series of F is xtz -ck/k2 eikx. We define d 2 - [ F ; x, h) by (F (x + h) F (x - h) - 2F(x))/h2 and D2(F; x) = lim A2 (F; x, h), D2 = lim inf A2 (F; x, h), D2 = lirn sup A2(F; X, h). -
1::
+
h-0
he0
h-0
84
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
I,,,
Then D2(F) = f on [O,2n]\E (Lemma 3). This implies that on each interval ]a, b[ contained in [0, 2n]\E. The distribution T whose Fourier series is c, eikxis then the sum f T I , where T , is a pseudofunction carried by E.
1::
+
1::
Let S = c, eikxbe the given trigonometric series. If E = [O, 2n] there is nothing to prove and from now on we shall assume that E is contained in the open interval 10, 2n[. If [O, 2n]\E contains an interval [a, b] the convergence of S, on [a, b] implies that c, einx+ c-, e-i"x tends to 0 on [a,b ] ;multiplying by einx,we see that c-, + c, eZinxtends to 0 on [a,b]. Hence c, (eZinx- eZina)tends to 0. If c, does not tend to 0, Ic,l 2 E for an infinite set J of integers; then E leZinx- eZinaI< Ic,l leZinx- e2'"'1 tends to 0 ( n E J ) and so does f,(x) = eZinX- eZinaon the whole interval [a, b]. Since I f,(x)I < 2, Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem gives j,bf,(x) dx -+ 0 ( n E J ) and a simple computation gives J,b eZinxdx-+ 0. On the other hand eZinaj,b dx = (b - a) eZinadoes not tend to 0. It follows immediately that c, -+ 0 when In1 -t + co. Since c, -t 0, we can define a distribution T by means of the formal series S and T is a pseudofunction. We may assume that c, = 0 and, integrating T twice, we obtain a continuous function F whose Fourier series is - c k / k 2 eikX.
1:;
1.8. D2(F) = f on [0, 2n]\E
x?:
3 : If lim A,(h) LEMMA
=
= 2 ( 1 - cos kh)/k2h2.
1 for eachjixed rational integer k and fi there
h+O
x:
is a constant A, independent of h, such that Ip,(h)l < A, then for each d,, lim Ak(h)d, exists and equals dk. convergent series
x?:
h+O
x?:
x?;
Proof: Writing d l k l= d , + d-,, it may be assumed we sum only over k > 1. We put D, = x:dkandwe getz,,, d,A,(h) = D,A,,, + C:D,~,(~). The first term tends to d,, while the second tends to 0 : for each positive E, there exists an n such that ID,I < &/2Afor k > n and this implies Dkpk(h)l < 812 while Zi Dkpk (h) clearly tends to 0 with h.
2:;
Ix:+l
In our case the inequality Ilk+ ,(h) - l,(h)l < A can be proved in the following way. Let o be the function 2 ( 1 - cos x ) / x 2 ;its derivative a' is continuous and belongs to L1, as a trivial computation shows. Then Ik+,(h) - 2.,(h) = o ( ( k 1) h) - ~ ( k h=) j ~ ~ ' l ' h d ( dt t ) andx?: Ipk(h)l +m (k+l)h IWr(t)l dl = IWr(t)l dt < 03. < jkh
+
X-,
1.9. F(x) = 1,"dy jz,f(t) dt
1.7. Definition of the distribution
We have A2 ( F ;x , h) = c, eikxAk(h),where I,(h) Let d, = c, eikxand ,u,(h) = A,+ ,(h) - jlk(h). We apply the following lemma:
85
+
+ A x -t B on each interval]^, b[ contained in
[O, 2nl\EThe proof depends on the following result:
PROPOSITION 1: Let ]a, b[ be an open interval of real numbers, f ajinite integrablefunction on ]a, b[,andF a continuousfunction on the closed interval [a, b]. Assume that D2F(x) = f ( x ) for each x in [a, b]. Then F(x) = jz dy j: f ( t ) dt Cx D. The proof of Proposition 1 may be reduced to the case where F and f are both real. The complex case is then dealt with by considering the real and imaginary parts of F separately. We need a number of lemmas.
+
+
4: Let F: [a,b] -+ R be continuous and such that D2F > 0 (the LEMMA value co is allowed) on [a,b]. Then F is convex on [a,b]. Proof: For each positive E , let F,(t) = F ( t ) + &t2.If each F, is proved to be convex, this will also be true of their uniform limit F. We have D 2 ~>, 2 ~ Let . a < x , < x2 < b, M , = (x,,F,(x,)), M , =(x2,F,(x,)) and let l(x) = a x be the equation of M , M 2 . It must be checked that, for each x in ( x , , x,), G(x) = F,(x) - l(x) < 0. The continuous function G, restricted to [ x , , x 2 ]attains its maximum at some point x , of [x, , x2]. If x , = x , or x , = x,, then G(x) < 0 on the whole of [x,, x z ] . If x, < X, < x 2 , then D2F, (x,) = D2G ( x 3 ) < 0, which contradicts B 2 ~>, 2s. Hence F, is convex.
+
+
5: For each function f : [a,b] -+ R which is real and integrable, LEMMA there exists an increasing sequence y,, n 1 , of integrable upper semicontinuous functions and a decreasing sequence y,, n 2 1 , of integrable lower semi-continuous functions such that q ~ , < f < y, and [,b (y,(x) - yn(x))dx -+ 0 ( n -+ + co). This is a classical result from integration theory. Note that the value co is admitted for y, and - co for pl,.
+
&EMMA
@(x) =
6 : If q~ is upper semi-continuous and integrable on [a, b ] , let dy y(t) dt. Then,for each xo in (a, b),
Jz
86
and, with the same notation, ify is lower semi-continuous and integrable on
Proof: For each positive E, a positive q can be found such that Ix - x,] < 7 implies p(x) 4 g,(x,) + E. The two functions @(x) and
differ only by a linear term and have the same generalized second derivative. Hence we may assume that @(x) = J:, dy J:, p(t) dt; if Ix - xol < q, @(x) < (x - x,)' (g,(xo) + E)/&which implies D2@(x0)4 g,(x0) + E for each positive E . If y(xo) = - co,the obvious modifications to be made in the proof are left to the reader. Proof of Proposition 1 : Let @, and !Pnbe defined in terms of yn and y n in the same way that @ was defined in Lemma 6. Let Gn = F - @,. Then, by Lemma 6, D2Gn = D2F - D2@, 2 f - g,, >/ 0. Hence Gn is convex and so is the uniform limit F(x) - j,"dy f(t) dt of the Gn, n 2 1. Using the same argument, we prove that Y,, - F is convex. Hence F(x) - J.X dy f,Y f (t) dt is both convex and concave. Proposition 1 is therefore proved.
1.10. Conclusion of the proof of (a) e- (c) We define TI by T - f; TI is the second distributional derivative of F(x) - f," dy f (t) dt, where a is a fixed point of [O,2n]. On each interval I contained in [O,2n]\E, this difference is linear and TI = 0. Hence TI is supported by E. Since the Fourier coefficients of Tand off tend to 0, so do those of TI and (c) is proved.
J:
1.1I. Equivalence of a periodic and a non-periodic problem THEOREM 11: Let E be a compact subset of the open interval ]O,2n[ and T a distribution carried by E. Then the following two properties of T are equivalen t : (a) lim e-iktT(t) dt = 0 ; Ik[++oo
(b)
lirn
Sin e-'"'T(t)
dt
=
0.
Ixl-r+m
Obviously (b) * (a). It remains to prove that (a) e- (b). Let a : [O,2n] [O, 11 be a Cw function such that a = 1 on a neighbourhood of Eand
+
87
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
or = 0 on a neighbourhood of 0 and of 2x. If 0 ,< u < 1, we define xu on [0, 2x1 by xU(t)= (e-lUt - 1) ~ ( t ) xu(t) ; is uniformly bounded in u and all derivatives of xu are uniformly bounded. Hence the Fourier series of is ak(u) e-lkt, where lak(u)l 4 a, and a, < co. If k < x < k 1, we write x = k uande-lXt - e-lkt - e-iktXu(t) on a neighbourhood of E. Then
xu
x?:
+
x+:
+
+
which tends to 0 as k or x tends to infinity for the reason given in Lemma 1 (convolution of co and 1').
1.12. The spectrum of a complex valued bounded continuousfunction Let Y be the space of complex valued indefinitely differentiable functions all of whose derivatives, together with the function itself decay rapidly at infinity. If cx belongs to 9, so does the Fourier transform g(x) = J?," e-lxta(t) dt of a [21]. The topology of Y is defined by a family of norms
under which Y is a Frechet space and a + & is an isomorphism of 9 '. The Fourier transform of a complex valued bounded continuous function p, is the distribution T defined by a(x) T(x) dx = jR &(t)~ ( tdt) for each a in Y. The spectrum of g, is, by dehition, the support of the Fourier transform of p,. We can thus give another definition of sets of multiplicity.
SR
DEFINITION 3 : A compact set E of real numbers is a set of multiplicity if there exists a complex valued continuousfunction 9.R + C vanishing at infrnity whose spectrum lies in E (we exclude the zero function). 2. Symmetric sets
2.1. We shall now define a family of compact sets of real numbers, the so-called symmetric sets about which striking results have been obtained on the question of uniqueness. (a) Dissection of type t on [a, b]. If [a, b] is an interval of real numbers and if 0 < 5- < 4,we say that we perform the dissection t on [a, b] if we
88
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
replace [a,b] by the union of the two closed intervals [a,a,] and [b,, b] of length (b - a) 5. These two intervals are disjoint if t < 3. (b) Sets E(5). For each 5 in 10, +[ and each interval [a,b],we define a set E(t) of Cantor type in the following way: we perform a dissection of type 5 on [a,b] and obtain the closed union El of two intervals of length (b - a) 5. On each interval of E l , we perform another dissection of type 6 and obtain the union E2 of four intervals of length (b - a) t2.At the kth step, we obtain a closed union E, of 2, intervals of length (b - a) 5,. We define E(5) to be the intersection of all the E,, k 2 1. Obviously the Lebesgue measure of E is 0. For the same 5, all the E(5) are homothetical to any one of them. be a sequence of real numbers con(c) Sets E (5, ,6,, .. .). Let (tk),> tained in 10, +[. The set E (5, ,12,...) is defined in the same way as E(5) but to pass from E, to E,, we perform a dissection of type 5, + on each interval of E,. The measure of the intersection E of all the E, is the infinite product (b - a) (25,). A formuIaforE(~)andE(E,,5,, ...): Let I = b - a and t, = 5, (1 - 5,). Then the elements x of E ( E l , t2, . ..) are given by all convergent series a I x y cktkfor all sequences (E,),, where each ck = 0 or 1. Definition 3 shows that if E is a set of uniqueness (or of multiplicity) so is each translate of E and each set homothetical to E. Hence, from now on, E ( E l , t,, ...) will be defined by taking a = 0, I = 1. Then x E E (t,,E2, ...) means x = ~,t,, E , = 0 or 1 , t, = 51 ... 5,-1 ( 1 - 5,). In the case where all 5, = 5, k 2 1 , we shall assume that a = 0 and I = 5/(1 - 5). From now on, we put 6 = 8-l, 8 > 2 and we write E(8) instead of this particular E ( 4 . No confusion is possible, since 8 > 2 cannot be a dissection ratio. Then x E E(8) means
(0, t k ) which assigns the mass 3 to each of these points. Then p, is the * o, and the Fourier transform of p, is the convolution product 0 , * (' + 3e-ixt') (3 + +e-ix'k) = e - i X s k COS t1x/2... COS tkx/2, where s, = t , ... t,. Let p be the weak star limit of the sequence of p,, k 2 1 ;p is carried by E and the Fourier transform i.j of p is e-'""? cos tkx/2.It should be observed that I,d(x)l = lcos tkx/21.
,
,
n:
,,
+
x?
m
x
=
C E , ~ - ~ =, E0 , or
1.
1
(3.1)
89
. . a
+
+
1-1:
3. Pisot numbers and uniqueness 3.1. Simple examples of sets of multiplicity and of uniqueness
A compact set E of positive Lebesgue measure is a set of multiplicity. The function which is 1 on E and 0 outside is an example of a pseudo-function carried by E. On the other hand, a countable compact set E is a set of uniqueness. In fact each complex valued bounded continuous function p, whose spectrum is a countable compact set is almost periodic ( [ l l ,p. 167, th. 5.20) and an almost periodic function cannot vanish at infinity without being identically 0. From these two examples, it might be conjectured that thin sets are sets of uniqueness and thick sets are sets of multiplicity. Testing this idea on the sets E(8),one would think that E(8) has more chance of being a set of uniqueness when 8 is great, since it seems obvious that the greater 8 is, the thinner E(8) is. (Using the Hausdorff dimension of a set, this is actually the case.) The truth is quite different, as Salem and Zygmund showed in 1955. 3.2. Pisot numbers and the problem of uniqueness THEOREM 111: The set E(8) is a set of uniqueness if and only i f 8 is a Pisot number.
2.2. Construction of measures carried by E(8) and E (6, , t2,...)
3.3. The easy part o f Theorem 111
For each k 2 1 , let F, be the finite subset of E (tl,t,, ...) defined by x E Fk if x = ejtj,E~ = 0 or 1 , and let p, be the measure carried by F, which assigns the mass 2-, to each of the 2, points of F,. Then pk 2 0, and the total mass of p, is 1. Let o,, k 2 1 , be the measure carried by
If 8 is not a Pisot number, we shall prove that the Fourier transform of the measure defined in Section 2.2 tends to 0 at infinity. Let n ( x ) be the infinite product cos 8-,x. To prove that n ( x ) tends to 0 at infinity we shall, since Ii' is an even function of x, compute h' on the interval [ O k ,
x:
ny
90
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
Then, putting x = Oku,1 < u P,(u) = J$-' lcos Ojul. Ok+l].
91
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
< 8, we have In(x)l < P,(u), where
3.5. Details of the proof (3.5, 3.6 and 3.7)
LEMMA 7: If O > 1 is not a Pisot number, P,(u) tends to 0 uniformly on each compact set not containing 0. Proof: For each real number x, let llxll be the distance from x to the nearest integer. Then 1 - lcos x Jand 2 -In2 Iln-'xllZ are equivalent when jcos XI-, 1. Therefore the convergence of the infinite product lcos OJul is equivalent to the convergence of the s e r i e ~ ~ ,Iln-' , ~ 0jul12;if u # 0, this convergence implies that 8 is a Pisot number (Chapter I, Theorem XII). Assume now that 19 is not a Pisot number. On each compact set K of real numbers not containing 0, P, is a decreasing sequence of continuous functions tending to 0. By Dini's theorem, the convergence is uniform. Put wk = sup Pk(u). Then w, -,0 ( k -, + co) and so In(x)l < w, on
Verijication of (a) : Let g, be the Fourier transform of S and g,, the Fourier transform of S,. Then p,,(x) = g, (Okx).Since p, vanishes at infinity, the complex valued continuous function g, is bounded. The three properties of y , are then clear. Verijication of (b): Since S, is carried by the compact subsei OkEof R, the image o, = h(Sk)is well defined by the rule (o,, a ) = (S,, oc o h ) ; *x is a test function on Tn and oc 0 h is an indefinitely differentiable function on the real line. Clearly o, is carried by h (OkE). + mnOn-' for Let h* : Zn + R be defined by h*(m) = m, + m20 + each m E Zn. The Fourier coefficients of o, are then
[Ok, Bk+']. Hence n ( x ) tends to 0 as x tends to infinity.
Since h* is injective, B,(m) + 0 for m # 0 while 6,(0) = 1; there is a constant A independent of k and m such that lBk(m)l< A.
nj,
l
B,(m)
=
gk (h*(m))= p,,
(h*(m))=
(mlOk +
-.. + mnOk+n-l).
3.4. The difficult part of Theorem 111 The main idea of the proof is to consider R as a dense subgroup of the compact group Tn Sketch of the proof: Let S be a distribution carried by E whose Fourier transform is equal to 1 at 0 and vanishes at infinity, let n be the degree of the algebraic number 8 and h :R -,Tn the continuous homomorphism from R to the n dimensional torus defined by h(t) = (exp 2nit, ..., exp 2niOn-It). (a) We define S, by S,(t) = O-kS (O-,t); Sk is a distribution carried by OkE,~$,(x)l < A, $,(o) = g(0) = 1, while gk(x)+ 0 if x # 0 where A denotes the Fourier transform. (b) We next define a distribution o, carried by h (OkE);a, is h(Sk)and tends in the weak star topology to the limit dx, where dx is the Haar measure on Tn. (c) Now if 6'is a Pisot number, h (OkE)is contained in a given compact subset K of Tn of measure 0 ; o, is then carried by K and hence so is the weak star limit dx of the sequence (o,); we thus have a contradiction If $(o) # 1, we replace S(t) by c e-'xof S(t); $(t) becomes c$(t + x,) and if $ does not vanish identically, there is a complex number c and a real x, such that c$ (x,) = 1 and c e-'"~' S(t)is always a pseudo-function. The proof is now complete.
3.6. Pseudomeasures and weak-star topology (end of verijication of (b)) Let A(Tn) be the Banach space of all continuous functions oc : Tn-, C , whose Fourier series are absolutely convergent; we put IlaII = Cmszn I &(m)l. It can be checked without difficulty that A(Tn)is a Banach algebra of functions on T n ;each sufficiently regular function belongs to A(Tn)and A(T") will be used as a space of test functions replacing the space D(Tn) of indefinitely differentiable functions. The dual of A(Tn)is the Banach space PM (Tn)of all distributions o on T n whose Fourier transforms are bounded; llall pM = sup IB(m)l. Each zn
complex valued Radon measure o belongs to PM (Tn);for this reason, we call the distributions of PM (Tn)pseudo-measures. The weak-star topology of PM (Tn)is the topology o (PM (Tn),A(Tn)) of simple convergence on A(Tn). A sequence o,, k >, 1 , of pseudomeasures tends to a weak-star limit o if and only if sup l \ ~ ~
+
92
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS O F REPRESENTATION
3.7. Verzjication of (c)
3.8. Some remarks on the proof
LetA be the set of all finite s u m s ~ k , o ~ kck~=k 0, or 1. Then, by the form (3.1) of elements of E, BkEis contained in A E. Let H be the linear map from R into Rn defined by H(t) = (t, Bt, ..., P 1 t ) and Z7 : Rn -,Tn the canonical projection defined by I7 (x, , .. ., x,) = (exp 2nix,, ... ,exp 2zixn). Let U be the compact subset of Rndefined by the parametric representation xi = ul u,, x2 = B2u2 .--+ Onun,..., X, = B"2'u2 + ... e;-'u,, where u, = - gk19k,,..., U, = for all E, = 0 or 1 ( E is~ the same, for each k > 0 in u, , .. ., u,). Then if Bi a r d O j are complex conjugate, so are u, and uj (1 < i < j < n): hence the numbers x,, 1 < p < n, are real and depend linearly on n - 1 real parameters and U is contained in an hyperplane L of Rn. On the other hand U is compact. Let V = H(E) and D = H(R); the straight line D is not contained in L since the determinant
+
+
+
+
+
1:
1:
The inclusion h(A) c n ( U ) , which is so crucial in the proof has already been proved in Proposition 8, Section 9, Chapter 11, for models of real numbers. When 8 is a Pisot number the set A of all finite sums &kek, E~ = 0 or 1 is contained in a model. The reason that we have here given a complete proof is to preserve the mutual independance of the different chapters of the book, while not forgetting the common features that unify them.
xkBO
4. Results for symmetric sets
4.1. An analogue of Salem-Zygmund's theorem will be proved for sets constructed with variable dissection ratios: E (El, t 2 , . ..) is a set of uniqueness if all the Ek ,k > 1, are the inverses of Pisot numbers whichlie in a given algebraic number field and which satisfy a very natural condition of uniformity. Let R be a real algebraic number field of degree n > 2. Let o l , .. .,5, be the n Q-isomorphisms from R into C ordered in such a way that a, is the identical map from 9 to R. The reader is referred to Section 2.1 for the definition of the compact set ,?(El, Ek, .. .) of all sums ektk,where tk = El 5k-1 (1 - tk).
zkal
does not vanish. Hence Rn is equal to the direct sum L O D ; using this decomposition, we compute the Lebesgue measure of U O V by Fubini's theorem. Since E has measure zero, the measure of V with respect to the Lebesgue measure of D is 0. Hence the measure of U V = U O Vis 0. Let K = Z7 ( U V). The measure of n ( C ) in Tn does not exceed the measure of Cin Rn(Chapter I, Section 2.1, Lemma 1). Hence the measure of the compact set K is 0. We shall prove that h ( A E) is contained in K or, equivalently, that H (A E ) is contained in U + V Zn. But H ( A + E) = H(A) H(E) = H(A) V, and there is no more to prove if H(A) is contained in U + Zn; this, however, is an obvious consequence of the congruences
+
+
+
+
+
+
Bk
3
- 13:
-
+
-
0: (mod 1).
Combining (3.2) with coefficients ek = 0 or 1 we get H(A) c U
(3.2)
+ Zn.
THEOREM IV: Let R be a real algebraic number field; let n 3 2 be the degree of 9. Let cx and p be two real numbers such that 0 < LX < 1 and > 2. Let (GO,),, be a sequence of algebraic integers in R such that (a) loj(cok)l 6 oi for all 2 < j < n and k > 1 ; (b) U k 2 p. Then, putting Ek = cok l, E (6, , E2, ...) is a set of uniqueness Before proving this theorem some comments should be made: we cannot have, in the case of symmetric sets, satisfactory necessary conditions. We shall prove in Chapter VII that if kt2 < CO, E (El, 52, .. .) is a set of uniqueness. Hence no necessary conditions of algebraic type exist. An obvious corollary is the following: let O be a real algebraic number field of degree n and F a finite set of Pisot numbers greater than 2, of degree n, lying in 9. Then each symmetric set E constructed with dissection ratios whose inverses lie in F is a set of uniqueness.
,
x?
+
94
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
If the degree of R over Q is 1, 9 = Q, Pisot numbers are rational integers and a weak version of Theorem IV says that if [,= lip,, p, 2 3, then E (5, ,[,, ...) is a set of uniqueness. The proof is easier than in the general case and is left to the reader as an exercise.
sufficiently small to ensure that K # Tn; the distance d is translationinvariant and K, c xk + K.
95
LEMMA 9 : Let W be a compact subset of Tn, m an integer 2 1, and F,, k 2 1, a sequence of finite subsets of Tn. Assume that Card F , < m for each k 2 1 and m I WI < 1, where / I denotes Lebesgue measure. Then K, = W F , admits a uniform room. Proof: Let WE (or Ki) be the set of all points in Tn whose distance from W (or K,) does not exceed E. Then We + f k = KL; hence IKlI < m I WEI.We choose E sufficiently small to ensure that m I WE/< 1, which is possible since lim I WEl = 1 Wl, and we apply Lemma 8.
+
4.2. Sketch of the proof Let S be a pseudofunction carried by E and such that S(0) = 1 (it has been shown in Section 3.4 how to reduce the problem to this case). Let S, Ekt) and let pl, be the Fourier transform of S,. = (5, ' S (tl Let 8 be an algebraic integer of degree n of K and h : R + Tn the continuous injective homomorphism defined by h(t) = (exp 27cit, .. , exp 2niBn-lt). (a) Let T, = h(S,). Then the weak-star limit of T, is the Lebesgue measure dx on Tn normalized by jTndx = 1; (b) There exists a compact subset K of Tn, K # Tn, and a sequence x, of elements of Tn such that Tk is supported by x, + K; (c) Then, if TL denotes the translated distribution T, (x - x,), (a) implies that the weak star limit of TL is dx. But T,' is carried by K. Hence dx is carried by K, and this is false.
&+O
.
4.5. Conclusion of the verification of (b) Let 8 be an algebraic integer of degree n of R and let 8, = 02(8), ..., 8, = 4 6 ) be its conjugates different from 8. The elements t of E are given by the formula Hence ([, ... tk)-l t = t' + t", where t' is an algebraic integer of 9 such that lo2(t')l < (1 + a ) (1 - a ) - I , . .., lon(tf)l < (1 + a) (1 - a)-' and t" belongs to the compact set R, of all sums
4.3. VeriJication of (a) The proof is essentially the same as that in Section 3.5.
4.4. Verijication of (b)
For eachj, 0 o1 (t'OJ) +
A new definition is needed.
DEFINITION 4: We say that a sequence K,, k > 1, of compact subsets of Tn admits a uniform room in Tn if there exist a compact subset K of Tn, K # Tn and a sequence x,, k 2 1, of points of Tn such that K, is contained in K + xkfor each k 2 1. LEMMA 8: Let K,, k 2 1, be a sequence of compact subsets of Tn andfor each k Z 1 and each E > 0, let Kl be the set of x in T" whose distance from K, does not exceed e. I f there exists a positive E such that the Lebesgue measure of KL is less than that of Tn, then K, admits a uniform room. Proof: In fact, K; # Tn;let x, in Tnbe such that d (x,, Kk) > E and let K be the set of all x in T" such that d (0, x) 2 E . We may assume that E is
< j < n - 1, t'8j is an algebraic integer of the field 9;hence
+ on(t18j) E Z and t'8j = u28; + ..- + un8i (mod 1)
(3.3)
where the complex numbers up corresponding to conjugate 8, are also conjugate and where lupl < (1 a) (1 - a)-l. (3.4)
+
Let U be the compact set of all (x, , ..., xn) in Rn defined by the parametric relations xj = U, 8;-' + ... + U,O;-~,1 < j < n, for all sequences (u,, .., un) satisfying (3.4). As in Section 3 it can be checked that U is a compact subset of a hyperplane L of Rn. We have H(t') E U + Zn. We shall now compute H(tU),Let N be a fixed positive integer whose exact value will be given shortly and let I be the closed interval of Rn defined by x = H(t), 0 < t < /I-N where /I is given as in Theorem IV.
.
96
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
Then there exists a finite subset D, of D = H(R) containing 2N points such that H(R,) c 1+ Dk as we observed in the construction of a symmetric set. Considel U + H(R,); this set is contained in the direct sum U @ ( I D,) = U @ I + D,. For some constant C depending only on 9, the Lebesgue measure of U @ I is CllUl II) = ClUl @ - N . We choose N so large that ClUl @-N2N< 1. This is possible since > 2.Weput W = + I),Fk = n ( D k ) a n d K k= W + F k , w h e r e n is the homomorphism from Rn to T n whose kernel is Zn. Lemma 9 shows that K, admits a uniform room in T n ( m = 2N and 1 WI < I U + I1 since L' is measure-decreasing) and this ends the proof of Theorem IV.
We shall prove that h (s,t) admits a uniform room in Tn.The proof can then be finished as in Section 4. I f t = x:cjtj, s,t = t' + t", where t" = s, ~ ~LettA, ~be the . set of the corresponding t ' ; each element ofA, is an algebraic integer il of the field R such that loj(l)l < c2aj/(aj- 1 ) for 2 < j < n. For each integer p, 1 < p < n, and each 1 in A,, we put u, = -aj@) and we have epL = a2(ep)u, + an(ep)un (mod I), (3.5)
+
n(u
97
Zp+l
+
where lujl < c2aJaj - 1 , 2 < j < n and where the uj corresponding to complex conjugate aj are also complex-conjugate. Let U be the set of all the right-hand sides of (3.5) for all uj satisfying the preceding conditions. Then U is compact and contained in a hyperplane L of Rn. We have H(t') E U zn. cjtj,E~ = 0 or 1 and V k = H(Rk). Let R k be the set of all sums sk Then as in the proof of Theorem IV, I is the image under H of [0, a N + l / ( l- a ) ] and D, is a set of 2N elements of D = H(R). We have V k c D k + I and H ( s , E ) c U + I + D , . Let W be n ( U + I ) , Fk = Zi'(Dk). We have IU + I1 < C l a N ,hence I WI < ClaN. For N sufficiently large Card Fkl Wl < 1 and the sequence of compact sets K, = W + F , admits a uniform room in Tn. The proof is concluded by remarking that h (skE)c K, since H ( t l )E U Zn and H(t") E Vk for each t' t" in skE.
+
5. Other results for symmetric sets
5.1. THEOREM V :Let 9 be a real algebraic numberfield, n the degree of 9, and a , , .. ., a, the n Q-isomorphisms from R to C , where a , is the identity map from R to R. Let a , a,, ..., a, be n real numbers such that 0 < a < 4,1 < a,, ... , 1 < an and aa, ... an = 1. Let C be a positive real number. Let (tk)ka bea sequence of algebraic integers of R such that 0 < t , < a k k and for 2 < j < n, laj(tk)l < Caj. Let E be the set of all sums &, cktk,ck = 0 or 1. Then E is a set of uniqueness. Before proving this theorem, some remarks should be made. Let e l , ..., en be a basis of the free Z-module of algebraic integers of 9. Let D be the determinant of the n vectors oj(e,), .. ., oj(e,), 1 < j < n. Minkowski's theorem (Chapter I, Section 2) shows that there exists an algebraic integer t , in R such that 0 < t, < a k and, for 2 < j < n, loj(tk)l < ca5 provided C 2 ID/. 5.2. Now to the proof. We have to define the dilations used to transform the pseudo-function S carried by E into S,. For each k > 1 , let s, be an algebraic integer of 9 such that 0 < s, < a - k and laj(sk)l < caj-, for 2 < j < n. By Minkowski's theorem, s, can be found if C 3 IDI. Then S , is defined by Sk(t) = SR'S (skit) and is carried by s,E. The continuous homomorphism h : R + T n is defined by
+
+
6. Sets of uniqueness in general 1.c.a. groups
A natural space PM(G) of distributions will be defined on each locally compact group. As usual we begin by defining the test functions. The reader is referred to 1151 throughout this section. 6.1. The spaces L1(G),M(G), Lm(G)and the Fourier transform In all the following, G will be a metrizable and separable locally compact abelian group. As usual %,(G) will denote the Banach space of all complex valued continuous functions on G vanishing at infinity; the norm of an element of V,(G) is 11 f l l m = sup If 1. G
h(t) = (exp 2nielt, ..., exp 2nient)
.
and the linear map H : R + Rn is given by H(t) = ( e l t , .. , e,t).
The dual space of %,,(G) is the Banach space M(G) of all complex valued bounded Radon measures ,u on G such that IIpII, the total variation
99
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
of p, is finite. Such a p can also be defined as a bounded complex valued o-additive set function on the Borel field of G. If G is a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group, there exists a non-zero m in M(G) (m is called a Haar measure on G) such that, for each Borel set E in G and each s in G, m (E s) = m(E); it is equivalent to state that for each f in Vo(G) and each s in G, f(x) dm (x) = JG f (X S) dm (x). The Lebesgue space of all classes of complex valued m-integrable functions f on G is denoted L1(G)-the classes are taken with respect to equality almost everywhere. The dual space of L1(G) is the Banach space Lm(G) of all classes of complex valued Lebesgue measurable bounded functions on G. On Lm(G)two topologies are of special interest. The first one is defined by the norm 11 f 11, = ess sup I f(x)l and the second one, denoted by F , is the topology o (Lm,L1) of pointwise convergence on L1 of the linear forms defined by elements of Lm(G). Iff belongs to Lm(G),the mapping from G toLm(G)defined by s+f,(f,(x) = f (x - s)) is continuous for F; this is not true for the sup-norm topology. Let r = GAbe the dual group of G. The Fourier transform of an f in
The homomorphisms from L1(G) to the complex field C are all of the form f +f(y) for a suitable y in r a ~ dunder , the Fourier transformation, L1(G) becomes a subalgebra A ( r ) of Vo(r); if a = j: for some f E L1(G) we put llnIIA(r) = Il f 11 ;this makes A(T) an isometric copy of the Banach algebra L1(G), in which convolutions are replaced by pointwise multiplications: this seems better, although the norm of an element a of A(r) cannot be computed directly from n.
L1(G) is an element of V,(r) defined byf(y) = jGx,,(x)f (x) dx, where denotes complex conjugation and, for each y in r , x,(x) is the value taken on x by the character y in T. For each p in M(G), the Fourier transform ,Li of p is a uniformly continuous bounded function defined on r by ,Li(y) = JG Xy(X) dp(x).
6.4. Pseudomeasures
98
+
+
SG
-
6.2. The convolution product The convolution product ,u * v of two elements p and v of M(G) is given by
6.3. Test functions On a 1.c.a. group G, the test functions are the complex valued continuous functioris n which belong both to L1(G) and to A(G); by the inversion formula ([15], p 22, th. 1.5.1) the Fourier transform 4 of n also has these two properties. In [15] it is proved that we can construct partitions of unity by means of these test functions. The vector space of test-functions will be denoted by d(G).
If y belongs to L m ( r )the Fourier transform S = @ of y is a distribution S defined by (S, a) = Jr y(y) &) dy for each test function ol in d(G). Since this integral is convergent for all & in L1(r), it is sufficient to assume that ol E A(G). Such an Sis called a pseudo-measure. We put 11 Sll., = llyll and, with this norm, the pseudo-measures form a Banach space denoted by PM (G). In the preceding terminology, the spectrum of y is the support of the pseudo-measure @. Note that each p in M(G) is a pseudo-measure; in this case y(y) = JG xy(x) dp (x) and p is the Fourier transform of the complex valued bounded continuous function y. 6.5. Compactly supportedpseudo-measures For a compactly supported pseudo-measure S, we can define a version of the Fourier transform $of S, which is a complex valued bounded continuous function on if $ = y E L m ( r ) , let n be an element of d(G), which is equal to 1 on a neighborhocd of the support of S and write S = Sol; hence g, = 3 = * = y is the required continuous bounded
r:
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
function, where the equality is an almost everywhere equality and y is the convolution of an element of L1(r) and an element of L w ( r )and is therefore continuous.
The dual group of Q, is Q , itself; each continuous character X : Q , -+ T is of the form ~ ( x = ) exp 2nixy for a suitable y in Q,. Let 8 be an element of Q , such that 181, > 2. Let E(8) be the compact set of all convergent sums ~ , 8 - ~ , = 0 or 1.
6.6. The scalar product of a compactly supported pseudo-measure S a n d a function g in B(G) is defined using the same function a : ag belongs to A(G) and ( S , g ) = ( S , a g ) ; this definition is independent of the particular a chosen.
7.2. THEOREM VI: The compact set E(0) is a set of uniqueness ifand only if 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number. The proof of the necessity of the condition is very similar to the proof given for the real case. We can construct as in Section 2.2 a probability measure ,u carried by E(8), whose Fourier transform is
100
C:
*
6.7. Homomorphisms of groups KY) Let GI and G, be two 1.c.a. groups and h : GI + G, a continuous homomorphism. For each f in A(G,), f 0 h = g belongs to B(Gl) and IlgllBcc,) < I l f llacc,, ([151, 4.2.1, P. 79). Hence for each compactly supported pseudomeasure S on G I , we can define a pseudo-measure h(S) on G, by the rule
6.8. Sets of multiplicity A compact subset E of G is said to be a set of multiplicity if there exists a non zero pseudo-measure S carried by E whose Fourier transform vanishes at infinity. An equivalent condition is that there exists a continuous complex valued function f : I'+ C vanishing at infinity whose spectrum lies in E.
7. The p-adic case 7.1. Let Q , be the p-adic field, A, be the subring of Q , consisting of all mpn,m E Z , n E Z , m a n d p relatively prime. Thep-adic norm is defined on A , by Impn], = p-" and for this norm A, is dense in Q,. But A, is also a subring of R and the norm (mpnl, is induced on A, by the Archimedean norm of R. Let Z , be the subring of all x in Q , such that 1x1, < 1 : Z , is the completion of Z with respect to the p-adic norm. Each x in Q , can be written uniquely in the form x = y + r where y E Z,, r E A, and 0 < r < 1. We put exp 2nix = exp 2nir.
101
=
n1+ 1
exp 2iO- ky 2
To study the behaviour of F at infinity, we divide Q, into the cells 181; < lyl, < 181:'~ which leads one to put y = Oku and k- 1
1
+ exp 2i@u
0
We get, if y = Okuand 1 < \ulp < IOl,, I$(y)l < Pk(u).If 0 is not a PisotChabauty number, Pk(u)tends uniformly to 0 on each compact subset of Q, not containing 0 by Pisot-Chabauty's theorem. Hence ok= sup 1 4 U l ~ q P
IPk(u)/ tends to 0 as k tends to infinity and, for 101: @(Y)I < m k .
< Iyl, < lOli'
,
7.3. E(8) is a set of uniqueness when 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number
xkaO
Let A be the set of all p-adic number ekek,where ek = 0 or 1 and where the sum is finite. The proof is implicitly contained in the statement that A is a part of a model. Sketch of the proof: Let S be a pseudofunction carried by E such that g(0) = 1. Let Sk be defined by Sk(x) = F k S ( 8 - k ~ )Skis ; then carried by ekE c A + E. (a) there is a compact group G and a continuous injective homomorphism h : Q , -+ G with the following properties: (1) h(Q,) is dense in G ; (2) there is a compact subset K of G of measure 0 such that h (A E ) c K;
+
102
UNIQUENESS O F REPRESENTATION
UNIQUENESS OF REPRESENTATION
(b) Putting T k = h(Sk),we get a bounded sequence of pseudo-measures carried by Kand converging in the weak star topology of pseudo-measures to the limit dx, where dx is the Haar measure of G. This is impossible. Details of the proof: Part (b) of the proof is an easy modification of the corresponding argument used in the real case. We have to check (a). Let n be the degree of 8, P the field Q(8) and 8 the product group Q p x R n ;w e w r i t e ( x , y ) ~ @ i f x ~ Q , a n d y ~Let R ~l ,. a 2 , ..., a , b e a + a,03-~ dualbasisofthebasis(1, 0, ..., 8"-l)definedby 1 a20j + = 0 for 2 < j Q n, I?,, ..., 8, b e i ~ gthe coajugates of 8 over Q . Then a,, ..., a, lie in 9 c Q , and, provided c > 0 is large enough, A is c o n t a i ~ e din the set M of all elements A of 9 of the form A = t , + t28 + t,On-l for all t , , . .., t, in A, satisfying the inequalities: It2 - a2tllp < c, ..., It, - antlJp< c, It,l, < c, ..., Itnl, < c (C1napterII, Section 10). Let D be the discrete and relatively dense subgroup of Q , x Rn consisting of all ( x , y) of the form x = t , + t28 ... tnBn-', y = ( t , , t 2 , ..., tn)for t , , ..., tn in A, such that It2 - a2t,lp < c, ..., It, - a,t,l, Q c. Let G be the quotient group @ID, li' the canonical projection of 8 onto G and h the restriction of L7 to Q,. Then the image of Q , under h is a dens: subgroup of G. Definition of K: Let B c Rn be the set of all y = ( y , , . .., y,) in Rn such that lyllm < c, ..., lynlm < C. Then K = n ( E x B). Since D is is measure-decreasing. Hence, if I I denotes the cordiscrete in @, responding Haar measures with suitable normalizations, JKI < IE x BI = JEl 1B1 = 0 since E has zero measure in Q,. h ( A + E ) is contained in K. Since h is the restriction of to Q, , it suffices to show that A + E c E x B + D. But for each A in A, we can find a y in B such that (A, 0) + (0, y) E D or, since -B = B, a y in B such that (A, 0) = (0, y) (mod D). If t E E, then ( A + t, 0 ) = (t, y) (mod D) and the proof is complete.
+
- a -
+
+
+
n
8. Generalizations As in the real case, the proof can be extended to symmetric sets constructed with variable dissection ratios whose inverses are 'uniform' Pisot numbers of a given algebraic number field contained in Q,.
THEOREM VII: Let P be an extension of the jield Q of finite degree n contained in Q , and let z , , . .., z, be the n Q-isomorphismsfrom 9 into C . Let 0 < a < 1 , and let (co,),, be a sequence of Pisot-Chabauty numbers
,
103
of degree n in R satisfying the condition of uniformity: Izj(cok)l, < a, for all 1 < j Q n and k > 1, and such that llcokllP> 2 for all k 2 1. Then the symmetric set E constructed with the sequence (ok-') of dissection ratios is a set of uniqueness. The definition of E is the same as that given in the real case : E is the set of all sums Cy s k t k ,E~ = 0 or 1, tk = 5, t k - 1 (1 - t k ) . 0
.
.
9. Other results on the problem of uniqueness In Chapter VII ultrathin symmetric sets will be studied: when the dissection ratios tend to 0 sufficiently rapidly, no arithmetical properties are needed to get sets of uniqueness. The exact condition is Cy 5; < + + and it is the best possible in the sense that the exponent 2 cannot be replaced by a larger one.
10. Notes
A remarkable survey on the problem of uniqueness and multiplicity is given in [2], Ch. XIV. A first version of Theorem IV may be found in [lo], where there is a requirement of periodicity on the sequence of dissection ratios. For other results, the reader is referred to [18], 191, [58] and [92].
105
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
CHAPTER IV
natural to expect f(to, t) to be a good approximation of f(t) in a suitable neighborhood of to. Surprisingly, two extra conditions are needed to obtain a good result: an a priori estimate of the behaviour off at infinity (I f(t)l < C exp ItuI, 0 < a < 1, is sufficient) and a remarkable arithmetical structure for A (it is sufficient to assume that A is a coherent set of frequencies).
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC T R I G O N O M E T R I C SUMS
1. Elementary properties of almost-periodic functions Almost periodicity is a useful and natural generalization of periodicity: a bounded continuous f : R + C is almost periodic if for each positive E , there exists a T(E) > 0 such that each interval of length T(E) contains an &-almostperiod z off, i.e. sup I f(t z) - f(t)l < E sup If 1.
+
R
R
The theory shows that T(E) depends on f in a very intricate way: to make any estimate of T(E) one needs to have knowledge off right up to the end of time and T(E) cannot be used to predict what f will be. The general theory only gives a posteriori estimates of &-almostperiods. This is quite restricting and our first problem is to get a priori estimates of &-almostperiods for reasonable spaces V of almost periodic functions. By reasonable spaces V, we mean spaces that are translation invariant and linear, and in this case the answer to our first problem is given by the following rule: the frequencies of any f in V belong to a given harmonious set. A second problem is to give a priori estimates of the size of almost periodic functions f belonging to such reasonable spaces, where the size off is taken to be sup (f1. We are led to the following problem: letA be a R
set of real numbers; do a compact set K and a constant C exist such that for any trigonometric sum whose frequencies belong to A, sup If ( < C R
sup If I? If they do exist, A is said to be a coherent set of frequencies. K
A third problem is to study the effect of slow perturbations on trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to a given set A of frequencies. Perturbations are said to be slow when constant coefficients are replaced by continuous functions whose spectra are contained in a small neighborhood of 0: in the real case, we get small frequencies and great periods as in the secular perturbations of astronomy. Iff(t) = al(t) exp 2niAt is such a slowly-perturbed trigonometric sum and if f(to, t) = al(to) exp 2niAt is the corresponding family of pure trigonometric sums, it is
Elen
Enen
We are mainly interested in spaces of trigonometric sums defined on a 1.c.a. group G; a trigonometric sum P is a sum ayXyof continuous characters with complex coefficients indexed by the dual group such that the complex numbers a, are equal to 0 for all y in r with the exception of at most a finite number of y; the set of all y E ~ S U that C ~ a, f 0 is called the spectrum of P or the set of frequencies of P. In the real case, P(t) = a,, exp 2nivt and the real numbers v for which a, # 0 are the frequencies of P. A great number of properties of such sums hold for uniform limits on G of trigonometric sums. We have just defined the space of almost periodic functions on G. We recall without proofs the elementary properties of complex valued almost periodic functions on G. The reader is referred to [ l l ] for the proofs. Let Vb(G) be the Banach space of all complex-valued bounded continuous functions on G. The norm off E Vb(G) is 11 f 11 = sup (f(x)l and XEG is also written sup If 1.
Eyer
r
EYER
G
For each f E Vb(G) and each s E G, the translated functionf, is defined by f,(x) = f(x - s) for all x in G; for each positive E , the set M (E,f ) of oalmost periods off is defined by s E M ( E , f ) if Ilf, -f 11, < f 11 ,This is a slight modification of the usual definition: the normalization by (1 f 11, is fundamental in the following.
.
DEFINITION 1 : A function f E Vb(G)is said to be almost-periodic ifone of the following two equivalent conditions is satisfied. (I) for each positive E, the set M ( E , f ) of &-almostperiods off is relatively dense; (2) for each positive E, there exist a finite subset F o f r and a trigonometric sum P(x) = ag,(x) such that Il f - Pll, < e. I f f is almost periodic, some precise information can be given about
I,,,
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
the sets F used in (2). The closed linear subspace of Vb(G)spanned by all thef,, s E G, is denoted by E(f).
2.2. In an attempt to generalize this situation, we are led to the following definition :
106
DEFINITION 2 : The spectrum, denoted by Sp ( f ) , of an almost periodic function f on G is the set of all y in the dual group of G such that the corresponding character X, belongs to E ( f ) . The theorem of spectral synthesis for almost periodic f~~nctions is an improvement of property 2 in Definition 1.
r
THEOREM I: Let f be a complex-valued almost periodic function deJned on an 1.c.a. group G a n d A be the spectrum o f f . Then there exists a sequence ( P k ) k 2 1of trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A such that At this point, it seems that the theory of almost periodic functions is going to be quite easy-going: we can define the Fourier series of almostperiodic functions, the Parseval relation is valid, and so on. How do new problems arise?
2. Classes of almost-periodic functions 2.1. We come back to the real line. The space, denoted by AP ( R ) , of all complex-valued almost-periodic functions on the real line is a huge space containing all complex-valued continuous periodic functions; indeed, AP ( R ) is not separable. The properties of an individual almostperiodic function on the line are very similar to the properties of an individual periodic function, but the common properties of all complexvalued continuous 2n-periodic functions are very different from the common properties of all almost periodic functions We shall list these properties :
DEF~NITION 3 : Let %? be a linear subspace of AP (G). We say that V is a class of almost-periodic functions i f V has the following three properties: (a) %? is closed in AP (G); (b) %? is translation-invariant; (c) for all positive F , there exists a relatively dense set M ( F )in G such hat for each s in M(E)and each f in 9, [ I f , f [ I , < ~ l l/ Ifm . Example : the space of all complex valued continuous 2n-periodic functions on the line is a class of almost-periodic functiors.
r
THEOREM 11: Let A be a harmonious subset of the dual group of a 1.c.a. group G. Let V(A)be the linear subspace of all almost-periodic functions on G whose spectra lie in A. Then %(A) is a class of almost periodic functions and each class of almost-periodic functions is a %?(A) for a suitable harmonious set A. It will be shown in the interlude that (4.4) holds for V ( A )if A is relatively decse in and if K is a suitable compact neighbourhood of 0.
r
2.3. Proof of theJrst half of Theorem I1 LEMMA1 : Let I be a real number in the open interval 10, n[ and a : R + [- 1, 11the continuous 41-periodicfunction dejinedby a(t) = a(- t )for all real t and a(t) = sin ( I - t ) / 2 i f 0 < t < 21. The Fourier expansion of ,a(t) is c, cos (k + t )~ 1 - It , where c, > 0 and c, = sin 112. Proof: An easy computation gives
Z:
Each t E 2nZ is a period for each 2mperiodic function. The 2n-periodic functions are given by their values on the compact subset [O,2n] of R. The space of all continuous 2n-periodic functions is closed in V b ( R ) and is translation invariant. If K is a compact subset of [O,2n], different from [0, 2n], each complex-valued continuous function on K can be extended to a 2n-periodic function.
107
2:
Ck =
21 cos 112 > o. (2k + 1)' n2 - 1'
2:
Hence c, < + oo, the function is the sum of its Fourier series and c, = a(0) = sin 112.
Z,"
LEMMA 2 : Let p = 2q + 1 be an odd integer and I = n / p There exists a sequence (dn)-, ,,,+, of complex numbers such that (a) Idn! = leil - 11 = 2 sin 112; (b) .if - I < x < I, eix - 1 = dn einx.
z?:
x?:
109
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
Proof: We write eix - 1 = eix" (eiX1' - e-ixlz) = 2i elXi2sin x/2. Put t = 1 - x and apply Lemma 1. The hypothesis that p is odd and 1 = n / p ensures that each e-Iti2 cos (k + +) nl-l t can be written eint, for some n E Z. It can be shown that the hypothesis 1 = n/p, p odd is necessary for (a) and (b) to hold.
Proof: Let A be the union of' all Sp ( f )for allf in V . Definition 2 shows that Xn belongs to V for each ilin A, and Theorem I shows that each f in A P (G) whose spectra lie in A belongs to V If V is a class of almost-periodic functions, we get Ix,(x) - I / < E for each x in M(E)and each il in A; since M ( E )is relatively dense, A is harmonious
108
.
3: For each real number 6 in [0, 11, there exists a sequence LEMMA (d,) -, ,,+, of complex numbers such that (a) 1d.l < 26; (b) lzI = 1 and lz - 11 < 6 imply z - 1 = dnzn. Proof: I is defined by 1 E [O,76/31 and sin 112 = 612, a n d p is the greatest odd integer less than rill. Then p > 3 and Lemma 2 yields the sequence + m Idn/ = 2 sinnl2p. more over,^ < n/l < p + 2 (dn)-mcn<+, such that < 2p implies sin n/2p < sin I < 2 sin 112 = 6.
1;:
CZg
r.
LEMMA 4: Let G be a 1.c.a. group, T the dual group a n d A a subset of Each element s of G such that sup (~,()3) - 11 = 6 < 1 is a 26-almost A
period of each almost-periodic function f whose spectrum lies in A. Since the subset of AP (G) defined by I l f , - f 1 1 , < 2611f ll ,is closed, Theorem I shows that we can restrict our attention to trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A. We define the sequence (dn)nEZ by Lemma 3 and a discrete measure o on G by o = dnen,, where E, is the unit point-mass at x. Then for each il in A, JG d~ = Cf_gdnxr (ns) = d. (xA(s))" = x&) - 1. Assume that f is a finite trigonometric sum cIxr;then f(s) - f(0) = Enen CI (xL@)- 1) = C I JG Xr do = J G do ~ implies I f ( 8 ) - f (011 < 26jlf 11,. To get the inequality I f ( s + x ) -f(x)l < 2611f 11, foreachxin G, we apply the preceding proof to the function g defined on G by t -+ f ( t +x). We now return to Theorem 11. I f A is harmonious, there is, for each positive 6, a relatively dense subset N(6) of G such that sup (x,(s) - 11 < 6
x+z
1 : :
ZI~A
CrEA
A
for each s E N(6). Lemma 4 gives Ilf, - f of Theorem I1 is proved [91].
1 1 , < 26 11 f 11 ,and the first part
2.4. The proof of the second part depends on the following lemma: 5: Let V c AP (G) be a closed linear subspace which is transLEMMA lation-invariant. Then there exists a subset A of the dualgrouprsuch that V is the set of all f in AP (G) whose spectra lie in A.
3. Dilations and classes of almost-periodic functions on the line Let 8 > 0 be a positive real number. The dilation with ratio O is defined on R by x + Ox. Iff is any complex-valued function on R, Tof will be the complex-valued function g defined by g(x) = f (Ox), rather than the expected f (0-'x). The product of two dilations is clearly another dilation and if V is a set of complex-valued functions on the line, we shall study the set S of all 8 > 0 such that To(%)c V . THEOREM 111: Let V be a vector space of almost-periodic functions on R. Assume that (a) V is translation-invariant; (b) for each positive E there is a relatively dense subset M ( E )of R such that each s E M ( E )is an E-almostperiod for all f in V ; (c) there is a function f in V which is not a constant. Let (To)oES be the semigroup of all dilations such that To(%)c V . Then there exists a real algebraic numberjeld K, of degree n over Q say, such that S is contained in (1) n 2, where is the set of all Pisot or Salem numbers of degree n lying in K. Before proving this theorem, a remark should be made. It may happen that the only 8 for which To(% ' ?) c V is O = 1. All the other such O are Pisot or Salem numbers. Proof: Let C be the closure of V with respect to the uniform norm. Then has the properties (a) and (b) and, using Theorem 11of Chapter IV, %?is the space of all almost-periodic functions f on the line whose spectra lie in an harmonious set A of real numbers. If O E S and O # 1 , we apply the inclusion To(@)c C to each element exp 2niAx, ilE A, of 8;we get 8A c A. Since there is a function f in V which is not a constant, there is a 2 in A which is not zero. Hence Sil c A is harmonious and so is S. We apply Theorem VI of Chapter I1 (Section 8) to S.
110
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
4. Classes of almost-periodic functions and a priori estimates on the size
r
We shall see that each harmonious subset A of the dual group of G is a coherent set of frequencies; the converse, however, is not true. PROPOSITION 1 : Let V be a class of almost periodic functions, M(E) a relatively dense set of s-almost periods for all f in V, and K(E) a compact subset of G such that K(E) + M(E) = G. For each f in V, sup If ( 2 (1 - E ) K.
Ilf ll m .
This means that, within a relative error not exceeding E, the functions in V are 'known' on the whole group as soon as they are known on K,, just as the 2n-periodic functions on the line are fully determined by their values on [O, 2n]. The proof of Proposition 1 is very simple. Each y in G can be written y = s + x, where s E M(s), x E Ke. Since each s E M(s) is a n &-almost period for each f in V, we get I f(y) - f(x)l < film; hence (f(y)l < sup (f( + f 11 a r d taking the supremum over y E G we get ProposiK.
tion 1. Let G = R and let (tk)k,O be an increasing sequence of positive real numbers such that (tk/tk+1)2< CO. Let A be the set of all finite where E, = 0 or 1. We shall prove (Chapter VIII, Secsums tion 5, Theorem IV) that, for each positive E,there exists a compact subset Ke of R such that sup If 1 2 (1 - E) [] f /Im for each almost periodic
FkaO
XkaO
+
K ,
function f whose spectrum lies in A. However, the sequence (tk)kSOcan be chosen in such a way that A is not harmonious (Chapter VIII, Theorem XI). 5. Pisot numbers and coherent sets of frequencies: the real case THEOREM IV: Let 8 be a real number greater than one andA, the set of all finite sumsxkgO&,Ok, where E, = 0 or 1. Then the following two properties of 8 are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot number; (b) A, is a coherent set of frequencies. Before proving Theorem IV, some remarks should be made : if 8 = 1, A, is the set N of all positive integers and A, is a coherent set of frequencies; if 8 = - 1, A, = Z and is a coherent set of frequencies. If 8 < - 1 the proof given below will show that A, is a coherent set of frequencies if
111
and only if - 8 is a Pisot number. If - 1 < 8 < 1, Proposition 3 below shows that A, cannot be a coherent set of frequencies. Now to the proof. (a) Assume 8 is a Pisot number: then A, is harmonious and hence A, is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) Now assume 8 is not a Pisot number. The following lemma will be needed. LEMMA 6: If 8 is not a Pisot number there exists a sequence (Pk)k,O of Jinite trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to Ae such that
(2) on each compact subset K of R not containing 0, P, tends uniformly to 0 as k tends to infinity. Proof of the lemma: Let Pk(t) = exp nit (1 + + 8,) cos n t cos nOkt; Pk(t) is a finite trigonometric sum of the type an exp 2ni;lt. If 8 is not a Pisot number, IP,(t)l = lcos ntj lcos nOktl is a decreasing sequence tending to 0 for each t # 0: if we write IcosnOkt12= 1 - sin2 n02t, this fact is a consequence of Pisot's theorem. Dini's theorem shows that (Pk)kaOtends uniformly to 0 on each compact set of real numbers not containing 0.
xnen
5.1. Proof of Theorem I V Assume that there exist a compact set K of real numbers and a positive C such that, for each trigonometric sum whose frequencies belong to A,, sup IP( < C sup IPI. Let s be a real number such that s K does not R
+
K
contain 0 and set Qk(t) = Pk(S + t). Then Q, is a finite trigonometric sum whose frequencies belong to A, sup JQkl-+ 0 as k + + co and K
IIQkllm= 1. Hence A, is not a coherent set of frequencies.
5.2. Improvement on the preceding result Let 8 be a Pisot number, q a real number in 10, 1[ and T(q) the infimum of those positive T for which sup IP(t)l 2 (1 - q) ll Pll for each ItkT
trigonometric sum P whose frequencies belong to A,. Two problems can be stated: what is the behaviour of T(q) as 11 t e ~ d s to O? What is the behaviour of T(q) as 7 tends to I ?
112
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROPOSITION 2: Let n be the degree of the Pisot number 8. There exist two positive constants a and b depending on 8, such that, for each q in 10, 1[, (-n+l)/z < , T(q) < bq(-nf1)/2. all This is the best possible result as Proposition 3 of Chapter I shows. This remarkable fact can be proved by the methods used in Chapter I, Section 4, and with the definition of models given in Chapter 11, Section 9. Observe that when q tends to 0, the quality of the prediction of the size of trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A increases at a corresponding 'cost', here the size of T(q), which is of the order of magnitude of v - ( " - ~ ) ' ~ . On the other hand when q tends to 1, the quality of the prediction decreases while the 'cost' of the prediction also decreases. What is the lower bound of this 'cost'? This is an open question. When q tends to 1, a natural conjecture is lim T(q) = DensA,. The density ofA, is defined V-+l
to be the uniform limit of T - l Card (A n [t, t + TI) as T tends to infinity. If 8 > 2 this density is 0, if 8 = 2 it is 1 and if 8 = (I + 4 5 1 2 (the golden number of Greek mathematicians) it is 3 + 3 &/lo. This conjecture will be provedin the case where Bis the quadratic Pisot number (1 + JT)/2 (Chapter V, Theorem 11).
113
Before proving Theorem IV, some remarks should be made :if 181, < 1, A, is an infinite subset of the unit ball of Q,. By Proposition 3 below, A, cannot be a coherent set of frequencies. We can therefore restrict our attention to those 8 in Q, such that 101, > 1. Now to the proof. (a) Assume 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number: A, is harmonious and hence A, is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) Now assume 0 is not a Pisot-Chabauty number. The following lemma will be needed:
7.2. LEMMA 7: If 8 is not a Pisot-Chabauty number, there exists a sequence (P,),,, ofjinite trigonometric sums whosefrequencies belong to A, such that (1) sup lpkl = Pk(0) = 1 . QP
(2) on each compact subset K of Qp not containing 0, P, tends uniformly to 0 as k tends to infinity. Proof of the lemma: We recall that eachp-adic number can be written uniquely as a sum x = 5 r, where E E Z, and -3 < r < 3,r E A,, where A, is the subring of Q generated by p-'. We put r = p,(x) and the characters on Q, are of the form x -+ exp 2nipP(xA) for a suitable A in Q,. A finite trigonometric sum on Q, can be written a* exp 2nipp (AX). For each k 2 1, IetF, be the subset ofall sumsEk,-'~~8j, = 0 or 1 inA, andlet P, be the trigonometric sum2- '&,FK exp 2n@, (Ax). Then P,(x) can be written 2(1 exp 2nip, (Bjx)) and lPkl = Ilk-' ICOS n ~ (8jx)l. , Chabauty's theorem (Proposition 12, Section 12, Chapter 11) shows that if 8 is not a Pisot-Chaubauty number, P,(x) tends to zero as k tends to infinity for each x # 0. The proof is concluded as in the real case.
+
CAEap
6. A set of powers Let 8 be a real number greater than one and A the set of all powers Ok, k >/ 0. It will be proved that A is always a coherent set of frequencies (Chapter VI, Theorem 11). However, some problems remain open. Conjecture: Let 8 and A be as above. Then the following two properties are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot or a Salem number; (b) for each positive q one can find a T(q) > 0 such that SUP Ip(t)l 2 (1 - 7) SUP Ip(t>l ItlG T ( q )
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
'nk-'
+
R
for each trigonometric sum P whose frequencies belong to A.
8. The groups C and R2
7. Pisot numbers and coherent sets of frequencies: the p-adic case
Complex Pisot numbers can be defined in the following way: a complex number 0 is a complex Pisot number if there exists an irreducible element P(X) = X n + a,Xn-' + ... + an of Z[X] with the following properties : (a) P(0) = P@) = 0 and 8 $- 8; (b) the other n - 2 roots z of P(z) = 0 satisfy lzl < 1.
7.1. THEOREM V: Let 8 be up-adic number andA, the set of allfinite sums Zk,oskBk, where E , = 0 or 1. Then the following two properties of 8 are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot-Chabauty number; (b) A is a coherent set of frequencies in Q,.
114
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
It can be proved [43] that for a complex number 8, which is not real, the following two properties are equivalent: (a) 8 is a complex Pisot number; (b) 8 is neither purely real nor purely imaginary and the set A, of all finite sums ,, .skek,E~ = 0 or 1, is a coherent set of frequencies. Pisot pairs (a, 16) in R2 are defined in the following way: an element (a, p) in R2 is a Pisot pair if there is an irreducible element P(X) + a, of Z[X] with the following properties: = X" + a,Xn-l + (a) P(a) = P(P) = 0; (b) the other n - 2 roots z of P(z) = 0 satisfy lzl < 1. It can be proved [43] that for an element (a, p) of R2, the following two properties are equivalent : (a) (a,p) is a Pisot pair or la1 and 1161 are two Pisot numbers; (b) the set A& of all finite sums ( z k a OE ~ O L ~ ,ckpk)E~ = 0, 1 is a coherent set of frequencies.
xkZ
xkaO
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
LEMMA 8:
If y ET,y' E
and y # y', then sup JxY(x)- xy.(x)l > xeG
115
43.
Proof: Let 6 = y - y'; then, for each x in G, (xY(x)- xY,(x)( I~a(x)- 1I. Since 6 # 0, the subgroup x,(G) of T is not the trivial subgroup (1). Hence there is an x in G such that Jx,(x) - 11 > J3. Now to the proof of Proposition 3. Let V be a neighborhocd of 0 in such that sup Ix,(x) - 1I < 1/(C 43). If S = y - y' E V, we have =
r
KxV
sup I~a(x)- 11 = sup Ixy,(x) - xy(x)I > l / ( J 3 C), which contradicts the K
K
definition of V. We shall say that A is uniformly discrete to express the conclusion of Proposition 3. If G is discrete, 7 is compact and each coherent set of frequencies A contained in T is finite. Hence coherent sets of frequencies are interesting when G is neither compact nor discrete.
10. Coherent sets of frequencies and restriction algebras
9. Coherent sets of frequencies in 1.c.a. groups The definition of a coherent set of frequencies will be given for the case of a general 1.c.a. group. DEFINITION 4: Let G be a 1.c.a. group, T the dual group of G and A a subset of A is a coherent set of frequencies if there exist a positive real number C and a compact subset K of G such that, for each trigonometric sum P(x) = xlen c r ~ ~ ( we x ) have
r.
(1) sup IPI G
< Csup IPI. K
If(1) holds we say that the pair (K, C) is suitable for A. Example: If G is compact, each subset A of has this ploperty. In the general case, each harmonious subset A of T has this property. But there seems to be no hope, even if A is relatively dense in of obtaining a characterization ofA as we did for harmonious sets.
r
r,
PROPOSITION 3 : LetA c I' be a coherent set of frequencies. There exists a neighborhood V of 0 in such that, if 2 EA, A' EA and 2 f: A', then 2' - A 4 v. The proof depends on the following lemma:
r
10.1. For each closed subset A of r , two Banach algebras A(A) and B(A) can be constructed: A(A) is the quotient algebra of the group algebra L1(G) by the closed ideal I(A) of L1(G) defined by f E I(A) if its Fourier transform vanishes on A ; B(A) is defined in the same way with the measure algebra M(G) in place of L1(G). We have the following surprising characterization of coherent sets of frequencies: A is a coherent set of frequencies if and only ifA is discrete and B(A) is the multiplier algebra of A(A). We first give some new definitions.
r,
DEFINITION 5 : Let E be a closed subset of the dual group of G. The Banach algebra A(E) is dejined by the following two conditions: (1) p, belongs to A(E) if there exists an f E L1(G) such that p, = f o n E; (2) llv/IA(E) = inf 11 f Ill, where the infimum is taken with respect to those f E L1(G), such that p, = .f on E. DEFINITION 6: Let E be a closed subset ofr. The Banach algebra B(E) is dejined by the following two conditions: (3) p, belongs to B(E) if there exists a bounded complex-Radon measure ,u E M(G) such that p, = , ii on E; (4) IIpIIBcE>= inf Ilpil, where llpll is the 'total variation' of p. DEFINITION 7: Let E be a closed subset of A P (G) is defined by
T.The subspace APE (G) of
116
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
(5) f E APE (G) if the spectrum of the almost-periodic function f is contained in E and the subspace L,"(G) is defned by (6) f E Lz(G) if the spectrum of the bounded Lebesgue-measurablefunction p is contained in E. Remarks: The Banach spaces APE (G) and B(E) can be put in duality. I f f E APE (G) is a finite trigonometric sum f(x) = CysE ayXy(x) and if p = ,L on E, we define n
117
(b) (a): The proof depends on the following construction of linear forms over the space APA (G). Let x E Hom (r,, T) be any homomorphism from the additive group I' (with the discrete topology) to T; for each f E A P (G), f(x) is defined by the following rule: iff is a finite trigonometric sum f(x) = zy,ayX, (x), f(x) is the corresponding ~ ~ m ~ ~ Kronecker's theorem shows that, on the finite spectrum A off, the complex numbers ~ ( y )y, EA, can be approximated by restrictions to A of continuous characters on T ; hence (f(x)I < sup If 1 and the linear form G
f +f(x) can be extended by continuity to the whole of AP (G). The following lemma will now be used:
We get I(f, p)l < Il f 11, llvllBcE,and, by Theorem I, the linear form f + (f, p) can be extended to the whole of APE (G).
10.2. Duality and coherent sets of frequencies It may be asked whether B(E) is the dual space of APE (G). The answer is surprising: THEOREM VI: Let G be a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group andA a closed subset of the dual group F. The following two properties of A are equivalent: (a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) each continuous linear form L on the space of all almost periodic functions P whose spectra lie in A can be written L(P) = f G P(x) dp (x).for a suitable complex valued bounded Radon measure p on G. Before proving Theorem VI some remarks should b: made. If for each positive 7 in 10, 1[ there exists a compact subset K of G such that the pair (K, 7) is suitable forA, then the dual space of APA(G) is isometric to B(A), as the following proof shows. In all other cases, the isomorphism between B(A) and the dual space of APn (G) is not an isometry. 10.3. Proof of Theorem VZ
A coherent set of frequenciesn is discrete in r;hence A is closed. (a) * (b) : Let (K, C) be suitable for A and let 8 be the closed subspace of %(K), whose elements are the restrictions g to K of all f in APA(G). A continuous linear form I on APA(G) defines a continuous linear form L on 6. The Hahn-Banach theorem shows that there is a measure p carried by K such that, for each f E APA(G), l(f) = f G f dp and (b) follows. The norm of p satisfies the inequality llpll < Clllll.
LEMMA 9: Let G be a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group, r the dual group andA a subset ofr. Assume thatA is not a coherent set of frequencies. Then for each positive E, there exist a sequence (Pk)k>Oof trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A and a x in Hom (T,, T) such that (a) sup IPkl = 1 ; G
(b) on each compact subset K of G, sup lPkl+ 0, as k + +a; K
(c) IPk(x)I > 1 - E for each k 2 0. Before proving the lemma, we show why it implies Theorem VI. Assume that the linear form f +f(x), defined on APA (G) by the element x of Hom (T,, T) found in Lemma 9, can be written f (x) = fGf ( - x) dp (x) with p E M(G). Replacing f by Pkand using Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem, we get f G P,(-x) dp (x) + 0, while IPk(x)I > 1 - &. This is impossible and Theorem VI is proved.
10.4. We return to the proof of Lemma 9. Let (K,),,, be an increasing sequence of compact subsets of G whose union is the whole group G. A sequence (Pk)k>Oof trigonometric sums on G whose frequencies belong to A and a sequence (xk)kgOof elements of G will be constructed by induction in such a way that sup lPk(= 1 G
(4.5)
~
~
118
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
We assume that x , , ..., x,, P,, ..., P, have been chosen and we now define x,,, and P,, , noting that the choice of x , and P, is easy. Since A is not a coherent set of frequencies, there exists a sequence ( Q J k a oof trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A such that sup IQ,J = 1 a r d sup lQ,l + 0 as k -> +a.The trigonometric sum
,
G
Kk
+ P, is an almost periodic function, as is evzry trigonoS, = P, + metric sum; so is Re [S,] and there exists a compact subset L , of G such that each translate s + L , contains an x satisfying Re [S,(x)] 3 sup Re [S,] - ~ 2 - ~ -3' k - F (2-I + + 2 - , + 2-k-2). G
Let m = m , be a sufficiently large integer that IQrn(x)I< l / ( k + 1 ) on K,,, - L,. Now regarding m as fixed, there exists an element s = s, in G such that IQm(s,)I > 1 We can multiply Q, by a constant complex number of absolute value 1 , which does not affect the other pro> 1 - d-,-'. NOWs, + Lk contains an perties of Q,, to get Re [Qm(sk)] element x k + , of G such that
119
11. Other definitions of coherent sets of frequencies
11.1. We recall that Hom (A,, T ) is the group of restrictions to A of all homomorphisms of the discretized group r i n t o the circle group T . Then thefollowing two properties of a closedsubsetA of r a r e equivalent: (a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) Hom (A,, T ) is contained in B(A). Let A be a coherent set of frequencies. Each x E Hom (A,, T ) defines a linear form f +f ( ~ )on APA (G) and there is a ,u E M(G) such that f01> = jGf ( - X ) dp ( x ); this implies &(A) = ~ ( 1for) each A in A. If A is not a coherent set of frequencies, Lemma 9 gives a x E Hom (A,, T ) , which is not in B(A). 11.2. Let A be a closed subset of r.We say that a function y : A + C is a multiplier of A(A) if for each f E A(A), yf (the usual product) also lies in A(A).
r,
Putting P,+,(x)
=
Q,, ( x - x,,,
THEOREM V I I : Ij2l is a discrete subset of the following two properties of A are equivalent: (a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) the multiplier space of A(A) is B(A). The proof of this result depends on the following interesting lemma:
+ s,), we have
and
The induction is thus complete. The inequalities (4.7) imply IPj(xk)l 2 1 - E for each k > 0 and each j less than k. Following Section 1 of Chapter 11, we regard G as a part of G" = Hom ( r d ,T ) ; let C , be the closure in G" of the tail-set {x,, x,, , .. .). Sii?ce G" is compact, there exists a 31 in G" belonging to all the C , , k > 0. Using the continuity of Pj for each fixed j, we get IP,(x)I 3 1 - F ; since x is independent of j, Lemma 9 is proved.
,
LEMMA 10: Let A be a discrete subset of a 1.c.a.grouprandlet f : A + C be afunction such that f(A) = 0 for all A in A with the exception of at most a cAf @)I,this supremum jinite number of A E A . Then Il f IIA(A) = sup being taken over all Jinite complex sequences (c,),,, such that P(x) = C n X A ( x ) satisjie~llPllrn < 1. Proof of Lemma 10: Let a = 11 f llAcA, and let b the right-hand side of the hoped-for equality. The inequality b < a is obvious. For each F > 0, there is an F in L1(G) such that llFlll < a F and P = f on A. Hence c ~ f (= 4 JG P( -x)F(x)dximpIie~ l & e ~ c ~( f4 < I1 PII, IIFII 1 < a + F. Thus b < a + E for all positive F , which grves b < a. We want to get the reverse inequality. Let E be any positive real number and g an element ofL1(G) with the following three properties: $(A) = 1 if A E A and f(A) # 0 , g has compact support and llgll < 1 F ([15],p. 53, Theorem 2.6.8). Let E be the finite set of all A in A for which $(A) Z 0. Theorem V I applied to the harmonious set E gives 11 f l l ~ ( ~<) b. This means that, for each positive E , there is an element ,u of M(G) such that ll,ull < b + F and
LA
+
,
+
121
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
,d = f on E. The convolution F = p * g belongs to L1(G); the norm
Proof: Let kj be an element of L1(G) such that kj = 1 on a neighbourhood of Ej and kJ = 0 on a neighbourhood of the union of the remaining E k , k # j , l
120
of F in L1(G) is less than (b + E) (1 + E) and f! = f on A. Hence a d (b + E) (1 + E ) for all positive E and Lemma 10 is proved. Now Theorem VII can be proved. The space of multipliers of A(A), for a discrete A, is exactly the dual space of APA (G) and our theorem is a corollary of Theorem VI. 12. Other relations between A(E), B(E) and L g
12.1. Theorem V I shows that B(E) is only exceptionally the dual space of APE(G). However, it is interesting to seek other relations of duality between the spaces A(E), B(E) and L;(G).
PROPOSITION 4: Let G be a 1.c.a. group,r the dual group and E, F two closed subsets of T such that E is contained in the interior of F For each f in L,"(G) and each p, in the restriction algebra B(F) a g in L g can be defined by 2 = g,? which furthermore satisJies llgll, d IIg, I 1 B ~ F )Ilf 11 ,. Proof: Let E be any positive real number. There exists a complex valued bounded Radon measure p on G such that ,d = g, on F and the total variation of p, llpll < (1 + E) 11~11~(~). Let g = f * p. This definition is independent of the choice o f p : if@ = B on F, then p * f = v * f since B is contained in the interior ofF. We get llgll d llpll Il f 11 ,d (1 E) Ilg, 11 s(~) (1 f 11,. Since g is independent of E > 0, Proposition 4 is proved.
+
COROLLARY 1: The notation is that of Proposition 4. Assume that E is compact. Then, for each f E LZ(G), there exists a complex valued bounded continuousfunction g on G such that f = g almost everywhere with respect to the Haar measure of G. Proof: There is an element k of L1(G) such that k = 1 on a neighborhood of E. Take g = f * k COROLLARY 2: The notation is that of corollary 1 and E is compact. For each f E L;(G) and each g, in B(F), a scalar product off and g, is given by f, g,> = j, f(-x) dp ( x ) , where ,d = g, on F.
<
3 : Let f be a complex-valued bounded continuousfunction on COROLLARY u Enof n disjoint compact subsets G whose spectrum is the union El u + .fn, where the fj are complexof r. Then f can be written f = f, + ualued bounded continuousfunctions on G and where the spectrum of euchfj , where C depends only on is contained in Ej. Moreover Il.fjl/,< C 11 f 11 , El, En. . . a ,
12.2. We have the following results on the algebras A(E) and BCE).
5 : If g, belongs to B(E) and has compact support, then g, PROPOSITION belongs to = IIvII B ~ E ) . and IIYIIA(E) Proof: The inequality I I v I I ~ ( ~ ) d I1911A(E) is immediate from the definition of these norms. To get the reverse inequality, let p, for each positive E, be a complex-valued bounded Radon measure on G such that fi = g, on E and llpll d (1 + E) Ilg,llscE).Let k be an element of L1(G) such that 11 k 11 d 1 + E and k = 1 on the support of g,. Then h = p * k belongs to L1(G), t%= g, on E and llhlll < (1 E ) IIg,llBcE). ~ Hence II~llacm< IIvIIB~E). PROPOSITION 6: The subalgebra A(E) of B(E) can be defined as the closure in B(E) of the subspace of compactly supported elements. Ifg, E A(E), then IIvIIA(E) = IblI B(E)Proof: The subset of all those f in L1(G) whose Fourier transforms have compact support is dense in L1(G) ([15], th 2.6.6, p. 51). Proposition 6 now follows immediately from Proposition 5.
+
13. Slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums 13.1. Intuitive motivation
Consider the motion of the earth around the sun; the position of the centre of gravity of the earth at time t is given by a continuous function g,: R + R3. To a first approximation, g, is a periodic function whose period T is one year and whose Fourier series is C?: a, exp 2kni (t/T). More precise observations show that the a, are not constants but functions of time whose periods are very great compared with T (secular perturbation). What is the quality of the approximation of these perturbed trigonometric sums y(t) = ak(t)exp2kni (t/T) by the corresponding periodic functions g, (to, t) = ak(t,)exp2kni(t/T); it is to be expectedthat the error term will be quite small in a neighbourhood of to. To state this problem in the context of general groups, the set ZT-' of frequencies used in the periodic case must be replaced by a coherent setA of frequencies.
x?:x?:
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
Surprisingly, in order to solve our problem, it is necessary to know the behaviour of p, at infinity; in the real case, an apriori estimate of the type Ip,(t)l < Cexp Itla, C > 0, 0 < ac < 1, is sufficient (Section 17) and, in the general case of 1.c.a. groups, it will be assumed that p, is bounded. If A is a coherent set of (real) frequencies and if ~ ( t = ) a,(t) exp 2niilt is a slowly perturbed trigonometric sum by which we mean that the spectrum of each a, lies in a small interval [ - c , E ] , where E depends only a,(to) exp 2niilt is a very good on A, it will be proved that p, (to, t) = approximation to p,(t). In fact Ip,(t) - p, (to, t)l < A It - tol sup (Ip,(x)
CAE,
CAE,,
R
where A depends only on A, E and a.
Let G be a 1.c.a. group, F the dual group and A a subset of l'.We are interested in slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums of the type f,(x) x,(x), where the sum is finite and the f, are functions with slow variations. To be more precise, the following definition will be needed: DEFINITION 8: Let G be a 1.c.a. group, K a compact subset of G and E a positive real number. A complex valued bounded continuousfunction f on G s) - f(x)l < 11,. is (K, &)-slowijfor each x in G andeach s in K, I f(x In other words, each s in K is an &-almostperiod off. The following proposition provides examples of (K, &)-slowfunctions:
+
PROPOSITION 7: Let G be a l.c.a, group, r the dual group, E a closed subset of 'l and 6 a real number in 10, l[. Then each s in G such that sup IxY(s)- 11 < 6 is a 26-almost-period of each compex-valued bounded Y EE
continuous function f on G whose spectrum lies in E. Before giving the proof, we show why Proposition 7 gives examples of (K, &)-slowfunctions. Let U be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in r such that sup Ixy(x) - 1I < s/2. Then each complex-valued bounded contigKxU
uous function f on G whose spectrum lies in U is (K, &)-slow. Now to the proof. Let ol > 0 be an arbitrary positive real number sufficiently small that 6 + ac < 1 and let U be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in r , small enough to satisfy sup IxY(s)- 11 < a , where s is fixed YEU
throughout the proof. Let F = E
+ U.
123
1::
As in Lemma 4, we construct a discrete measure o = dl,&-,,,on G d , ~ ,(ns) = xY(s)- 1 for each such that lloll < 2 (6 a ) and b(y) = y in F. At this point, the following lemma is useful:
+
C?;
LEMMA 11: The function A , f defined on G by A, f (x) = f (x + s) - f(x) is equal to f * o. Proof: The Fourier transforms of A f and f * o are respectively (xY(s) - 1)fand bf. Since b = 2, - 1 on a neighbourhood of the support of the distribution 3: we have the required equality. Returning to Proposition 7, we have l l Af 11, < lloll llf 11 < 2 (6 + a) I ] f ]Ico Since this inequality holds for each a > 0, we obtain IlA f 11 < 2611f 11 ., Iff, is defined on G byf,(x) = f(x - s), the spectrum o f f , lies in E and we can apply the preceding proof tof, instead off. We get Ilf, - f 11, < 2611 f 11, and Proposition 7 is proved. Slowfamilies: DEFINITION 9 :Let G be a 1.c.a. group, K a compact subset of G, and E a positive real number. We say that a family (f,),EA of complexvalued bounded continuous functions on G is a (K, &)-slowfamily if, for every family (cJrEA of complex numbers of which all but afinite number are 0, the finite sum c, f, is (K, &)-slow. Example : Let U be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in the dual group r such that sup IxY(x)- 11 < ~ / 2 Then . each family (f,),,, of complex-
CAEA
Kx U
valued bounded continuous functions whose spectra lie in U is a (K, s)slow family.
13.3. Approximation of slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums
A fundamental result can now be stated: THEOREM VIII: Let G be a 1.c.a.group, l' the dual group andA a subset The following two properties ofA are equivalent: (a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) There exist a compact subset K of G, a positive real number E and a constant C such that, for eachfinite (K, &)-slowfamily (fA),€, and each xo in G, the pure trigonometric sum f (x, , x) = fn(xo) XJX) is a good apfA(x)xI(x) proximation to the rlowly-perturbedtrigonometricsumf (x) =CnEA in the following sense:
of
r.
CnsA
124
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC
TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC
Before proving this result, some remarks should be made. A finite family (fn)rEAis a family all of whose terms are the zero-function with at most a finite number of exceptions; (4.8) means that the approximation off by f(xo, x) is good in the neighbourhood x, K of x, and the estimates given by (4.9) will play a fundamental role in the problem of spectral synthesis. Proof (a) => (b): Assume that the pair (K, c) is suitable for A, and let E so small that EC < 1. Let M = sup I f(x, xo)l over all x E G and x, E G. For each fixed u, x +f (x, u) is (K, &)-slow since the family (fn)AeAis (K, &)-slow;hence if x E y + K, I f(y, u) - f(x, u)l d EM. Applying this remark with y = x, and u = x, we get I f(x,, x) - f(x)l d EM whenever x E X, + K. Since the pair (K, c) is suitable forA, so is the pair (K + x,, c) and, for each x, fixed in G, we have sup I f(xo, x)l < c sup I f(x,, x)l <
+
XEG
c sup (f(x)( G
+
xexo K
+ CEMsince I f(xo, x)l d I f(x)l + I f(xo, x) - f(x)l.
Taking
thesupoverx,~G,wegetM< cIlfII, + c & M a n d Md c ( 1 -8~)-'IlfII,; (4.9) is satisfied if we take C = cll - EC. Substituting this estimate of M in ( f(x,, x) - f(x)l < EM, we get (4.8). (b) (a): IfA is not coherent, there exists a sequence (Pk)kSOof trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A such that 11 Pkllrn = 1 and Pk-, 0 uniformly on compact subsets of G. Let f be any (K, &)-slowfunction vanishing at infinity and such that f(0) = 1. For example, let U be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in such that sup Ix,(x) - 11 < 4 2 and put f = 9, where g belongs to L1(r), Kx U
g is carried by U and g(y) dy = 1. By Riemann-Lebesgue's theorem, f vanishes at infinity and Proposition 7 shows that f is (K, 8)-slow. Applying (4.9) with x, = 0 to the perturbed trigonometric sums fPk, we get 1 = IIPkllwd C 11 fPkllco + 0, as k -f +a.We thus have a contradiction and so A is a coherent set of frequencies.
13.4. Better results on the approximation of slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums Our next theorem is an improvement of Theorem VIII. The terminology of Theorem IX is the following: (a) G is a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group; (b) is the dual group;
r
TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
125
(c) A is a subset of l;' (d) U is a compact neighbourhood of 0 in r and for distinct 2 in A, the corresponding 1+ U are disjoint; (e) for each x in G, r(x) = sup Ix,(x) - 1I ; Yeu (f) by a suitable normalization of the metric on G, we may assume that r(x) d 1x1, where 1x1 is the distance from 0 to x. With this notation, we can state
THEOREM IX: The following two statements are equivalent: (a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) There exist a compact neighbourhood U of 0 in r and a positive constant C such that, for each x, in G and each perturbed trigonometric sum f = ~ r E A ~ for x n which the spectrum of everyfA is contained in U, the corresponding pure trigonometric sumf(xo ,x) = CnGA fA(xo)xn(x) satisjies the two relations
Proof: The implication (b) * (a) can be proved just as in TheoremVIII. If (a) is satisfied, let (K, c) be suitable for A and let E be a positive real number so small that sc < 1. Let U be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in such that sup Ix,(x) - 11 d 612. Proposition 7 now shows that
r
UxK
(fJAEA is a (K, &)-slow family and Theorem VIII gives (4.11) with C = (1 - &c)-l. We shall prove (4.10) using a constant D instead of C. We put a = r (x - x,). If a 2 1, there is nothing to prove: (4.11) implies I fx,(x) -f(x)l < ( C + 1) Ilfll, d DaIlfll,, where D = C + 1. If a < 1, we fn(u) ~ ~ ( x ) . define, for each fixed x in G, a function g on G by g(u) = Proposition 7, applied with s = x - x,, gives Ig(x) - g(xo)l d 2allgll , < 2Co1 11 f 11,; (4.10) is satisfied with C = max ((1 - EC)-' + 1 , 2 (1 - &c)-l).
CIEn
DEFINITION 10: Let G be a 1.c.a. group,A a subset of the dualgrouprand U a compact subset ofr. Thepair (A, U ) is a harmonic discretization ofA if, for distinct 1 in A, the corresponding 1 + U are disjoint and if the conclusion of Theorem IX holds. It will be now shown that each harmonic discretization ofA gives rise to an isomorphism between A (A + U) and A (A x U).
126
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
14. Coherent sets of frequencies and isomorphisms
14.1. Let G be a 1.c.a. group, F the dual group and A a uniformly discrete subset of T. This means that there is a compact neighbourhood U of 0 in 1"such that for different A in A, the corresponding A + U, i! EA are pairwise disjoint. There is thus a homeomorphism Hfrom the subsetA + U o f r o n t o the subset A x U of r2given by the rule H(A + t) = (A, t) if A EA, t E U. This homeomorphism defines an isometry 3 between V, (A x U) and %?,(A + U): for each f i n 'iP, (A x U), 3 ( f ) = f o H. We recall that A (A U) is the restriction algebra to A U of all Fourier transforms of elements of L1(G), that B (A + U) is the restriction algebra to A + U of all Fourier transforms of all complex-valued bounded Radon measures p in M(G) and that the corresponding notations are used for A x U, where G is replaced by G2.
+
+
THEOREM X: Let G be a I.c.a, group, r the dual group andA a subset of
r.Then the following three properties ofA are equivalent:
(a) A is a coherent set of frequencies; (b) A is uniformly discrete and there exists a compact neighbourhood U of 0 in r with thefollowingproperty: for each elementf of A (A x U),f o H belongs to A (A U), where H is the homeomorphism from A + U onto A x U dejined above; (c) there is a constant Csuch that,for eachf in A (A x U), 11f 0 HIIA(A+U) Q Cll f llAtAx v) and such that for each g in B (A x U), g o H belongs to B(A + U, and IIg HIIB(A+u) Q CllgllB(~xu).
+
14.2. To prove Theorem X, we need to introduce some spaces of testfunctions. The subspace d of L1(G) is defined by the condition that f E 6 if the Fourier transform f o f f is carried by a compact subset of Thc inversion theorem ([15], th. 1.5.1, p. 21) then shows that j"is the Fourier transform of f(j'(x) = f (- x)); hence f E A(G). It is well known that d is dense in L1(G) and it follows from the Hahe-Banach theorem that & is dense in %?,(G). The norm off in d will be sup If 1 = 11 f 11 m .
r.
G
If Q is an open subset of I', d ( 9 ) is the subspace of all f E I whose spectra are compact subsets of 9. PROPOSITION 8 : Let 9 be an open subset of T and E the closure of O. Let f be a complex-valued continuousfunction on E. Ifa positive number b can be found such that, for each a E &(O), ISEf(y) &Y) dyl Q bllallm, then f belongs to B(E) a n d 11 f (1 BtE) < b.
127
Let L be the linear form defined on 6(Q) by L(a) = jEf(y) &) dy. The metric form of the Hahn-Banach theorem shows that L can be extended to a linear form on V,(G) with the same norm. Hence there exists a complex-valued Radon measure p on G such that llpll Q b and L(a) = a(-x) dp (x) for all a e d(Q). The equalities jEf(Y) &) dy = jr & )I &) dy for each ol E 8(Q) and the continuity off imply fi = on Q; hence ,ii= f on E and Il f llB(E) < b.
I,
14.3. We return to the proof of Theorem X, (a) => (c): We retain the previous notation and introduce some new notation : (K, c) is suitable for A; 0 <eand~< c 1; V is an open neighbourhood of 0 i n r such that sup IxY(x)- 1I < 812; VxK U is the closure of V; d (A x V) is the normed space of all complex-valued bounded continuous functions ol on G x G, which can be written as finite sums a (x, y) = an(x) xn(y), where anE B(V) for each A EA. If g E B (A x U) and ol E 8 (A x v), we define (g, a) to be C2.n jr iY(y)g (1, Y) 4 ; d (A + V) is the space d(Q) for 0 = A + V; each element a E 6 (A V) can be written as a finite sum an(x)xA(x),where o r n ~ d ( Vfor ) each2in A; the correspondingelement of d (A x V) dejined byCnsAan(x)xn(y)will be called &. If g E B (A + U ) and a E & (A V), (g, a) = , j g(y) &) dy : this is a definition of the scalar product. To get (c), we begin with a g E B (A x U); Proposition 8 will be applied toprovethatgoH~B(A U).Foreacha~g(A V ) , ~ E ~ ( A V)X and Theorem IX gives llkllrn< CI1orllrn. We clearly have (g 0 H, a) = (g, G). Hence I (b): Trivial. (b) => (a) : Any restriction algebra is semi-simple. The general theory of Banach algebras ([I I], th. 4.1, p. 213; or [15], th. D5, p. 263) shows that the homomorphism f -t f 0 H from A (A x U) to A (A f U) is contin-
ILEA
+
xlEA
+
+
+
+
128
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
uous. Hence Il f 0 H l i ~ U,~ d~ Cll x f llAcA+u,. Again using the duality between &(A U) and B (A U) and between 8 (A x U) and B(A x U), we get the inequality l $ l < Cllall m . Theorem IX now shows that A is a coherent set of frequencies.
+
+
15. Improvement on the preceding results when A is harmonious 15.1. In the applications, Theorems IX and X are useless: they do not give any information about the size of the compact neighbourhood U of 0 in It would be convenient to take U to be the largest possible. We shall see that this is almost the case when A is an harmonious set. Before giving any precise result, Theorem VIII will be restated in the following way :
r.
r
PROPOSITION 9: Let G be a metrizable and separable I.c.a. group, the dual group andA c a coherent set of frequencies. There exist a compact neighbourhood U of 0 in r and a linear operator L, whose domain and range will be speczjied in a moment, such that (a) Iff is a complex-valued bounded continuous function on G whose spectrum lies in A U, g = L(f) is an almost-periodic function whose spectrum lies in A; (b) L is continuous: there is a constant C such that sup Jgl d C sup If 1
r
+
G
G
(c) Ig(x) -f(x)l d Clxl Ilf 11,; (d) For every 1 in A, the spectrum of g lies in (1) whenever the spectrum off lies in 1+ U; (e) There is a real continuousfunction OJ on G, vanishing at infinity, such that for eachf, llgll m G Ilwf ll m e Before proving Proposition 9, a remark should be made. Each coherent set of frequencies is uniformly discrete: there is a compact neighbourhood U of 0 in T such that for distinct 1in A, the corresponding 1 + U are disjoint. Each complex valued bounded continuous function f on G whose spectrum is a compact subset of A U can be written CAen f,(x) x,(x), where the spectrum of eachf,, 1EA, lies in U. To start with, we show that (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) hold for any complex valued bounded continuous function f on G whose spectra lie in A + U if they hold for slowly-perturbed finite trigonometric sums f,(x) x,(x) for which the spectrum of each& lies in U. Finally, (e) will be proved in this last case.
+
I,,
129
15.2. Reduction to slowly-perturbedfinite sums
Let (kj)j,l be a sequence of elements of L1(G) such that Ilkjll = 1, kj is compactly supported, and kj + 1 uniformly on each compact subset of ([15], th. 2.6.8, p. 53). Put f j = f * kj. Then (a) f j = f iXA;the sum is finite and the spectrum off j lies in U ; (b) llfillmd llf llm; (c) f i +f, as j + + co,uniformly on each compact subset of G. Therefore (wf-'), j 2 1, is a Cauchy sequence for the sup-norm over G and, if (e) holds for perturbed trigonometric sums, (gj),, is also a Cauchy sequence for the sup-norm over G. Hence gJ tends uniformly on G to an almost-periodic function g. We put g = L(f); (a) is satisfied and the verifications of (b) and (c) are trivial.
r
xien
15.3. The case of slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums and the conclusion of the proof of Proposition 9
Let V be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in T contained in the interior of U, where U is defined by Theorem IX, and let W be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in sufficiently small to satisfy V + W c U . Let a be any function in the test-class d introduced in Section 14 such hat a(0) = 1 and whose spectrum is contained in W.
r
LEMMA 12: For each element f of LW(G),the Fourier transform of the product af is the function ;I* f i n A(r). Proof: af belongs to L1(G) since a does, and the Fourier transform of af belongs to A(T). We put a = & and to compute the convolution of the distributionfwith a,we test on a function /I in A ( 0 . Then jr (f * a ) /I dy = Jr(& * P)fdy: &(y) = n(-y) and the equality is the definition of convolution. By the definition ofA j, (& * /3)fdy = f G a$f dx. Hence the Fourier transform of af is h * f. Returning to Proposition 9, let o(f) be the spectrum off. Then the specA trigonotrum of af is contained in o(f) + W. If f = ~ l E fnXlisaperturbed metric sum and if the spectrum ofeach f,iscontainedin V, ~f= CnsAafnxl is a perturbed trigonometric sum and the spectrum of each af, is contained in U. Theorem IX shows that the pure trigonometric sum g = afA(O)x, satisfies SUP lgl G C SUP laf l and Idx) (af ) (XIl f ~ ( 0 )xn(x) =
CAE,
C
G
G
< CJxl jlaf 11,. To get Ig(x) - f(x)( d Dlxl 11 f 11 m ,it suffices to show that la(x) - 11 < C,lxl. Since 2 has compact support, this last inequality is a corollary of Proposition 7.
130
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
15.4. A counterexample Even ifA is a set of integers and U = [O, I], it is hopelessly difficult to compute the supremum lo of positive 1 for which Theorem IX is true. This supremum can be different from the supremum I, of positive I for which the intervals [A,2 I] are pairwise disjoint. IfA is the set of all integers of the form Aj = IOj, j E Z and j # 2" for all n 2 0, together with all integers of the form AJ = 10 2" - 1, j = 2", then I, = 9 while the conclusion of Theorem IX is false with 1 = 1. To see why the conclusion of Theorem IX is false in this case, consider any continuous n / 5 periodic function f. The Fourier series off can be written f(x) xtz c(j) exp ilOjx and the spectrum off is contained in A + [0, 11. If part (b) of Theorem IX was valid, there would be a continuous 2n-periodic function g(x) with the following two properties: g(x) ~ ( jexp ) iAjx and Ilgll < Cll f 11 a . But f - g is the lacunary 0 42") (exp i 1 0 . 2 " ~ - exp i (10 2" - 1) x). By a classical result series on Sidon sequences (Chapter VI, Theorem 11), there is an absolute constant 6 such that 11f - gll > 6 ( I n a o lc(2")I). This would imply 8 Ic(2")I) < (c + 1) Il f lla for any n/5-periodic function. But any sequence (x,).,~ in lZis the sequence of Fourier coefficients 42") of a n/5periodic function ([24], th. 7.1, ch. XII).
+
-
xzs
En,
-
(En,,
131
(a) iff is a complex-valued bounded continuousfunction whose spectrum lies in A + E, g = L(f ) is an almost-periodicfunction whose spectrum lies inA F ; (b) sup lgl < C sup 1 f 1; moreover there is a real continuous function w
+
G
G
on G, vanishing at injinity, such that sup Igl G
(c) for each x in G, Ig(x) - f(x)l
< 1x1 sup bf I;
< sup lwf 1; G
< Clxl sup G If 1 ;moreover Ig(x) - f(x)l
G
(d) for each 2 in A, if the spectrum off lies in 2 + E, the spectrum of g lies in 2 + F. Before proving Theorem XI, a remark should be made: since F is finite, the almost-periodic functions whose spectra lie in A + F are in a class of almost-periodic function because A + F is harmonious. Roughly speaking, the aim of theorem XI is to replace a bad function f by a regular one g without serious modification of the spectrum.
15.6. Summary of the proof The idea of the proof is to consider T as a dense subgroup of the Bohr compactification f of and, using a partition of unity on 17 by means of the regular functions, to divide A into a finite number of pieces AT for which Proposition 9 applied to the pair (E, A,*) will be true. We recall that the Bohr compactification f of is the dual group of Gd, where Gd is G with the discrete topology; A(P) - is the Banach algebra of complex valued continuous functions y on whose Fourier series are absolutely convergent. A continuous homomorphism h : f with a dense range is defined by the following rule: for each y ET,h(y) is the character X, on G. Then, if y E y 0 h is an almost periodic function on I' whose Fourier series is absolutely convergent.
r
r
15.5. A fundamental theorem With a very slight modification of the range of the operator L, the preceding difficulty disappears completely. Roughly speaking, Theorem XI states that each slowly-perturbed f,(x) x,(x) can be approximated by a pure trigonotrigonometric sum P,(x) x,(x), where the frequencies of each trigonometric metric sum sum PAbelong to a fixed finite subset F of the compact set E containing the spectrum of each f,. (We have introduced new frequencies to get a better approximation; A is harmonious and no restrictions have to be made on E.)
FA,, Inon
r
THEOREM XI: Let G be a separable and metrizable 1.c.a. group, the dual group andA a harmonious subset of T. For each compact subset E of I', there exist aJinite subset F of E, a positive constant C and a linear operator L, whose domain and range will be specijied in a moment such that
r
r-t
~(0,
15.7. A set F , If A is harmonious in I',let M(E), for each positive E, be the relatively dense subset of G defined by sup Ixn(x) - 1I < E. Let A, be the set of all A
y in
r such that Ixy(x) - I I < 28 for each positive E and each x in M(E).
Then A, is harmonious by Theorem I of Chapter I1 and (E - E) n A, = F , is finite. It is clear that F , = - F , and 0 E F1.Finally let be the set of all y in I' such that IxY(x)- 1I d s for all positive E and each x in
132
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
M ( E ) ;A is harmonious by Theorem I of Chapter 11. The above definition of F , seems artificial but Fl plays a fundamental role when A is mapped into the Bohr compactification f of I'. Bohr compactijication, U, A*, U*. Let h : I'-* 1; be the homomorphic injection of I' in f and let U be the closure of h(A) in f. The inverse image under h of the compact subset U o f f is again an harmonious subset of I' contained in as the following observation shows: For eachpositive E , each t E M ( E )and each x E U , we have Ix(t) - 1 I < E. The inequalities Ix(t) - I I < E , where t runs over M ( E )define a closed subset o f f containing h ( ~and ) hence containing U. For each y in h-'(U) we have Jxy(t)- 11 < E ( t E M(E))and h-'(U) c A. Let V be the compact subset h(E) o f f . The following lemma shows that the number of decompositions of an element x of f as a sum 5 g, 5 E U , g E V is finite; the finite set concerned here is precisely F,.
Ix(t) - g(t)l < & (resp. Ix(t) - g(t)l < &) for each t in T . Finally let cc, be the set of all g in f such that Ir(t) - 1) < for all t E T. As x runs over U , the family consisting of the corresponding a, is an open covering of U. There exist an integer n and a finite covering of U by o , , ..., on, where oj = w, for x = xj E U, 1 < j < n. We define U* = U + h(Fl), Uj* = U* n w,*, where a,*= w,* for x = xj and o,*is a compact subset of f'. Finally let A,* be the set of all A in I' such that h(A) E Uj*.The set A,* is contained in A* and the union U AS contains A.
+
+
LEMMA 13: If an element x of 1; can be written x = 6 q = 5' + qf, where 5 and 5' belong to U and g and g' belong to V, then 6 - 5' = g' - g belongs to h(Fl). Proof: By the definition of V, we have g' - g = h(y),where y E E - E. On the other hand, for each t E M(E),1Qt) - 11 < E and I['(t) - 11 < s, which imply I([ - 5') ( t ) - 11 < 28. Then IxY(t)- 11 < 2s (t E M(E))and y E E - E show that y E F 1 , since this is the definition of F, . In what follows, the compact subset U* = U + h(Fl) plays an important role; h-l(U*) = h-l(U) + F, is contained in the harmonious set A* = A -t F , (Chapter 11, Section 3, Theorem 11).
l<j
LEMMA 14: For each j such that 1 < j < n, Proposition 9, applied to the pair (A,*, E l ) is true. Since Aj* is contained in A*, we have IxA(x) - 1I < for each jl in A: and each x in M*. On the other hand, let a, be an element ofAj*, fixed once and for all. For every x and x' in wf and every t in T , we have Ix(t) - xj(t)l < +i and Ix1(t)- xj(t)l < &and hence Ix(t) - ~ ' ( t )< l &. This implies Ix, ( A - aj) - 11 ,< $i for a112 in A,* and all t in T (we recall that for y in I' and t in G, x,(y) = xy(t)). Finally we have Ix, ( A - aj) - 1 ) < & for every x in T + M* and every A in A,*. Proposition 7 shows that each x in T + M* is an +almost period of each almost-periodic function whose spectrum lies in A,* - a j ; hence the pair ( K , is suitable for Aj* - a j . The argument of Theorem 1X then shows that ( E l ,Aj* - aj) is a harmonic discretization of A,* - a j ; hence ( E l ,A;) is a harmonic discretization ofA7 (1 < j < n),
y)
15.9. Functions y j , 1 15.8. A partition of A
Let El be a compact subset of I' whose interior contains E + F,. We shall divide the harmonious set A into a finite number of pieces, denoted by A,*, 1 < j ,< n, in such a way that Proposition 9 is true for the pair (A,*, El), where A,* and El take the places of A and U respectively in Proposition 9. Let K be a compact neighbourhood of 0 in G such that, for each x in K and each y in E l , Ix,(x) - 11 < Let M* be the relatively dense subset of G defined by the condition that, for each x in M* and each A in A*, jxn(x) - 11 < &, a r d let T be a finite subset of G such that T + K + M* = G. For each x in P, let w, (resp. w,*)be the set of all g in I' such that,
5.
133
<j < n
Let V be the compact subset h(E) of f , U j the closure of U n wj in f ; then U j is contained in U and each x in U j satisfies the inequalities 1%-t) - xj(t)l < A, t E T. Let Q j , 1 < j 5 n, be an open subset of containing the compact subset U j + V of and small enough to satisfy the following condition: for any k in (1, .. .,n), Qj does not intersect Q k if U j + V does not intersect U k + V. The family SZ,, 1 < j < n, is an open covering of the compact subset U + V of f'. Let y,, ..., y,, be n continuous functions on R, whose Fourier series are absolutely convergent and which satisfy the two conditions: (I) the support of y j is contained in Q j ; + yn = 1 on a neighbourhood of U + V. (2) y 1 + The regularity of the self-adjoint algebra enables us to obtain such partitions of unity.
r
A(O
r-
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC S U M S
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
We define pj = yj 0 h for each j in (1, . .., n). These pj are almostperiodic functions on f with absolutely convergent Fourier series; hence each g?, is the Fourier transform of a discrete bounded complex-valued measure oj on G. We have p1 + + p, = 1 on a neighbourhood of A + E and Wiener's theory (Chapter IV, Section 12) shows that each complex-valued bounded, continuous functionf on G whose spectrum lies inA+E,isasumf=f*o, +-..+f*o,.
Firstly, A - A* belongs to A* -Ag, which is harmonious, and to El - E; hence A - A* belongs to (El - E) n (A* - A*) which is a finite subset A of I'.We consider the translated sets E, of E by all a in A. For each s in E l , there exists an open neighbourhood J, of s small enough to satisfy the following conditions: for each LX in A, s belongs to E, if J, intersects E, and (J, - E) n (A* - A*) c A . We can find a finite covering of El by a finite number J, , . . ., J, of these J, corresponding to the elements sl , ..., s, of El.
134
0
.
.
LEMMA 15 : With the preceding notation, the spectrum of each f
1
< j < n, is contained in A: + El.
* aj,
The spectrum off * oj is the support of the Fourier transformfbj =fVj. To prove Lemma 15, it is sufficient to prove that if y belongs to A + E, which contains the support ofA and to the support of g?i, then y belongs t o n ) + El. The union U Uj is equal to Uand h (A + E) is contained in U + V. l$j$n
If we put x = h(y), we can find an integer k in (1, .. ., n} such that x E Uk + V. We can then write x = u + v, where u E Uk and v E V. Since y belongs to the support of y j , x belongs to the support of yj; hence x E Qj. If Uj + V does not intersect Uk + V, Qj does not intersect Uk + V; this is impossible since x belongs to these two subsets. Hence Uj + V intersects Uk + V. Lemma 13 shows that we can find elements 5 in Uj, 6' in Uk such that 6 - 6' E h(F1). Put u* = u + 5 - 5'. We shall prove that u* belongs to Uj*. Since u* belongs to U* = U + h(F1), it is sufficient to show that u* belongs to the closed set o) (U) = U* n oT and o) is defined like ojbut is 'three times larger'). But u and 6' belong to U,, and are therefore in the closure 13,of o k ;hence u - 5' is in - a, = I3 - ID.Sincel belongs to o j , u* belongs to o). Finally, by hypothesis, x belongs to h(r); so does each v in V = h(E) and u as 6 - E' are in h(I'). Hence the element u* of Uj* can be written u* = h(A*), where A* is in AT. Let us put 5' - 5 = h(f), f E F , , and v = h(s), s E E. The decomposition x = u* + 5' - l + v gives y = A* + f + s ; hence y belongs toll; + F, + E, which is contained inA7 + El.
15.10. Afinite set F The introduction of the finite set F and of a suitable partition of El allows to describe what happens if for some A* in A* and 2 in A, the translated set A* + El intersects 2 + E.
135
DEFINITION 11: With the preceding notation, F is the finite set of all dzflerences sk - a, 1 < k < q, a E A, which belong to E. We can state LEMMA 16: For each A* EA*, each k in (1, ..., q} and each A in A , if 2" + J, intersects A + E, then A* + skbelongs to A + F. We define elements C1, . .., [,of A(T)by the following two conditions: Cl + ... C, = 1 on a neighbourhood of El and the support of each Ck is contained in J,.
+
+
We define on the subset Aj* El of I',a complex-valued continuous function ZjPkby ZjVk(t)= Ck(s)if t = A* + s, where A* EA) and s E El. Theorem X shows that LEMMA 17: There is a complex-valued bounded Radon measure p j S k whose Fourier transform restricted toA7 + El is Zj,k. Operator L: Proposition 9 is true for the pair (AT, El). We can find a linear operator Lj,k, 1 < j < n, 1 < k < q, mapping complex-valued bounded continuous functions f on G whose spectrum lies in A) + J; (Jj, = El n J,) into almost-period functions Lj,,(f) whose spectra lie in A,* + sk;Lj,k has the following properties: (3) sup ILj,k(f < sup If 1 ; G
G
- f ( ~ > l< clxl Ilfllm; (5) if the spectrum off is contained in A* E l , A* E Aj*, the spectrum of Lj,k(f) is A* sk; (6) there is a real continuous function q,, on G vanishing at infinity such that IILj,k(f)II rn < I l o j , k f ll m . We now consider an f whose spectrum is contained in A + E. We define J;., 1 < j < n, by J;. = f * oj; the spectrum of fj is a subset of (4) I(Lj,k(f>>
+
+
136
137
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
PROBLEMS ON A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
A: + F, + E, which is contained in the interior of A,* + El. For this f,,, and hence reason we can define&,, to bef, * pjSk.We have f, =
(a) (b): If 8 is a Pisot number, A, is harmonious and Theorem XI1 is a weak version of theorem XI. (b) +-(a): The proof is based on the existence of a compact set E of real numbers with the following properties: (1) the vector space X generated by E over Q has Lebesgue measure 0; (2) 0 belongs to E; (3) there exists a complex valued continuous function pl on R vanishing at infinity, whose spectrum is contained in E and such that ~ ( 0 = ) 1. The existence of such a set will be proved in Chapter VIII, Section 10.
z
l
Ef,,,
f= where the sum is over all pairs ( j , k) such that 1 < j < n and l
16.2. Summary of the proof
Let Me be the set of all finite sums
C
pkOk,where pk E Z. Multiplying
k>O
E by a suitable real number if necessary, we can assume that 0 is the only element of Me lying in the vector space generated by E over Q. In this case the vector space of almost-periodic functions whose spectra lie in A + E has remarkable properties and (b) implies the conclusion of Proposition 9. We then use the existence of a continuous function on R, vanishing at infinity whose spectrum lies in E, to show that the validity of (b) implies that A, is a coherent set of frequencies. Hence 8 is a Pisot number.
+
16.3. Details of the proof
16. A new characterization of Pisot numbers
Let X be the vector space generated by E over Q. Reduction to the case Me nX = (0). Let Y be the set of all real numbers y such that yM, n X # (0). Then Y is contained in U 2-lX; since Me is
16.1. Let 8 be a real number greater than one and Ae the set of all finite sums &,ek, where &, = 0 or 1. It will be shown that Theorem XI applied to A, cannot hold if 8 is not a Pisot number.
zkTO
THEOREM XII: The following two properties of 8 are equivalent: (a) 8 is a Pisot number; (b) for each compact set E of real numbers there exist a constant C and a linear operator L, whose domain and range will be given in a moment, such that (1) iff is a complex-valued bounded continuousfunction whose spectrum lies in A, + E, g = L(f ) is an almost-periodicfunction whose spectrum lies in A, + E; moreover Ilgllm < Cll f / I m and g(0) = f(0); (2) if the spectrum off lies in 2 + E (2 EA), the spectrum of g also lies in 2 E.
+
AeMe
countable, Y has Lebesgue measure zero and so there is a real number y # 0 such that yM, n X = (0). If were place E by y - l E , then M, n X = (0) and the other properties of E are preserved. 16.4. Almost-periodicfunctions whose spectra lie in A,
The compact sets 2 + E, LEA, are pairwise disjoint since M, n X = (0). A trigonometric sum P whose frequencies belong to A + Ecan be written PAXI, where the spectrum of each PAis contained in E. For eachreal number x, the mapping H, from A + E to T defined by H, (A + t) = exp 27dixA is a weak character on A + E. Hence P(H,) is defined by
znen t
+E
138
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
znEA P,(O)~,(x)and IP(H,)I < 11 PI], .The trigonometric sum Q(x) P(HJ satisfies IIQII, < llPll ,and the linear mapping T defined by T ( P )
PROBLEMS O N A-PERIODIC TRIGONOMETRIC SUMS
139
=
Q can be extended to the space of all almost-periodic functions whose spectra lie in A E. =
+
16.5. Let y be the complex-valued continuous function on R vanishing at infinity, whose spectrum is contained in E, and such that q(0) = 1. We apply (b) to the perturbed trigonometric sum f = Py, where P is any trigonometric sum whose frequencies belong to A; we get an almost periodic function g with the following properties: c a x ~g, = ZAG, g,~,, where each ga is an almost-perio(i) if P = dic function whose spectrum lies in E; iii) g m = c,; ( W Ikll m < CIIPII ,. We now define Q to be T(g); then Q(x) = CnEA dAxn,d, = g,(O) and IIQII, < IIT(g)ll,. Then Q = P and we get IIPll, < CIIPyll,. Since p, vanishes at infinity on R, A is a coherent set of frequencies.
I,,,
17.2. We end this chapter by describing the connection between the local approximation property given by statement (3) of Theorem XIII and the arithmetical structure of A. Let 6' > 1 be a real number, A the set of all finite sums Ekek, E , = 0 or 1 , and A , the set of the 2k sums t j O J , cj = 0 or 1.
ZE-l
PROPOSITION 10: If 0 is not a Pisot number and E is a positive real number, statement (3) of Theorem XI11 does not hold for A. Proof: In fact we shall prove the stronger result that (3) fails in any neighbourhood of to. Let a : R -+ R be a continuous function, vanishing at infinity, not identically 0, such that a(0) = 0, and whose spectrum is contained in [ - E , E]. Let Pk(t) = 2-k exp 2 d t . Then sup R la(t)Pk(t)l + 0 as k
-+
-+
[ l , + co] be an even log-concave function such that +
* log w(x)
sup la(h) P, ( t
THEOREM XIII: Let w be as above. Then, for each coherent set of frequencies A there exist a positive E and a constant C > 0 such that (1) i f f : R -+ C is a continuous function which is 0 (w(t))at injinity and whose Fourier series is a,(t) exp 2 d t andif the spectrum of each a, is contained in [ - E , E ] ,then, for each real t o ,f ( t o , t ) = a,(to) exp 2 d t is almost periodic; (2) SUP lf(t0 t)l < C SUP If(x)/w ( x - toll ;
x,,,
2
R
(3) If(t0, t ) - f(t)l
R
< C It
+ h)] = a(h)
-+
0 as k +
+ h). If (3) were + co;
C-h,hl
if a(h) # 0 this cannot happen and, since a is an entire function, we can find such an h as close to 0 as we like.
dx
is finite. For instance, w(x) = exp lxla is such a function if a < 1.
xaen
+ co as was proved in Section 5.2. Let
for some h # 0. The corresponding f (0, t ) is a(h) P, ( t true for to = 0 on the interval [-h, h], we should get
17. Slowly-perturbed trigonometric sums in the real case
17.1. Let w : R
zkSO
- tol SUP lf(x)lw (x - toll. R
Proof: The Denjoy-Carleman's theorem ([I I], p. 114, th. 2.4) shows that for each positive E , there is a real continuous function a supported by [ - E , E ] ,whose integral is 1 and such that 2 = 0 (llw) at infinity. We now reproduce the proof of Proposition 9, to get Theorem XIII.
18. Notes The main result of this chapter was Theorem XI. In the real case, we considered the real line as a dense subgroup of a suitable compact group G in such a way that our discrete harmonious set A was contained in a thin compact subset of G . This idea has been used before by J. F. MCla in [65] and [66] to study the so-called 'interpolation sets for almost periodic functions'.
INTERLUDE
If G = R, r = R and A = Z, E(A) is the space of all continuous 1-periodic functions f : R -t C; E(A) is trivial on each compact subset V of 10, 1[. More interesting examples will be studied in Chapter V. If G = Q,, r = Q, and A is the subset of all mpn in Q, such that 0 < mpn < 1, where m and n are otherwise arbitrary rational integers, then E(A) is trivial on each compact subset V of Q, whose Haar measure is less than the measure of Z, (Theorem IX of Chapter V). Proof of (a) => (b); A is a relatively dense harmonious subset of r:for some compact subset K of r , A + K = r. Theorem I1 of Chapter IV shows that for each positive E there is a relatively dense set of &-almost periods for all f in E(A). The proof of the last statement of (b) is an easy adaptation of the proof of part (b) in Theorem IX of Chapter V. For this reason, the reader is referred to Chapter V, Section 8.7. Proof of (b) =. (a): The existence, for each positive s, of an a priori complete set M(E) of &-almostperiods for all f in E(A) implies that A is harmonious. To prove that A is relatively dense, from which (a) will follow, we use the following lemma :
INTERLUDE
One of the most fascinating problems in harmonic analysis is to find connections between the additive properties of a set A of frequencies and the functional properties of the corresponding space of almost periodic functions whose spectra are contained in A. ForA a finite set of real numbers independent over Q, we obtained the following connection in Chapter I: we can rapidly predict the size of trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A if and only if A is strongly independent over Z (Chapter I, Theorem IX). In the general context of 1.c.a. groups, we can also get striking results. We first recall some definitions: (1) A subset A of a 1.c.a. group G is discrete if each point 1 of A is isolated in A for the relative topology; (2) A subset A of G is relatively dense if there exists a compact subset K of G such that each translate of K intersects A ; (3) A set E of bounded continuous functionsf : G -+ C has a complete set of a priori &-almostperiods if there exists a relatively dense subset M(E) of G such that, for each z in M(E) and each f in E, sup f ( x + z) G - f ( x ) l Q E SUP If I ;
LEMMA 1 : For each n > 1, let A, be the set of a l l y in r whose distance from 0 exceeds n. Then for any h :I' -+ C in A(r), the norm of h in the restriction algebra A(A,) tends to 0. Proof: Obvious, since the compactly supported h in A(r) are dense in A(r). We return to the implication (b) (a). If E(A) is trivial on a compact neighbourhood V of 0 in G, a theorem of Banach applied to the surjective restriction operator T: E(A) -+ C(V) yields a constant C such that, for each complex valued continuous g, in C(V), there exists an f in E(A) such that sup If 1 Q C sup Ig,I and f lv = 9.
I
G
(4) A set E of bounded continuous functions f : G -+ C is locally trivial at 0 if there exists a compact neighbourhood V of 0 such that each continuous function g : V 4 C is the restriction to V of a function f in E. In this case we say that E is trivial on V. With these definitions we can state the following: THEOREM I: Let G be a metrizable and separable 1.c.a. group, I'the dual group, A a subset of I', and E(A) the space of all almost periodic functions f:G -+ C whose spectra lie in A. The following two properties are equivalent: (a) A is discrete, A is relatively dense in P and there is ajinite subset F of r such that A - A is contained in A F ; (b) for each positive s, there is a complete set of a priori s-almost periods for all f in E(A) and E(A) is locally trivial. Before giving the proof, some examples should be noted.
+
141
G
,'
V
It follows from duality that for each complex valued Radon measure p carried by V and each bounded complex valued Radon measure v, the equalities $(A) = $(A) for all 2 EA imply Ilpll < Cllvll. Let h be the Fourier-transform of an integrable function I, not identically zero, which is carried by V; then h E A(r). IfA is not relatively dense in G, there is for each n > 1, a yn in r whose &stance from A exceeds n. Let dp, = y,(x) I(x) dx. Lemma 1 shows that there is a sequence v, of complex Radon measures such that llvnll -+ 0 and ,il,(l)= Jn(2) for all A inA. But IIpnll = 111111and this contradicts llpnll Q Cllvnll.
SPECIAL SERIES
CHAPTER V
that, for every a
E 9'
10 SPECIAL T R I G O N O M E T R I C SERIES (COMPLEX METHODS)
(COMPLEX METHODS)
satisfying
+ 1x1)" y'k'(x)l < C,
0
< k < n,
(5.1)
we have IT(a)l < 1. The Fourier transformation a + & is an isomorphism of Y and the Fourier-transform of each T i n 9' is defined by the rule ( T , &) = (F, a ) . An element T of Y' is supported by [0, oo[ if for each a E Y which is 0 in a neighbourhood of [0, a [ , we have ( T , a ) = 0. From now on we shall c o n h e our attention to those T E Y' supported by [0, + a ] .
+
In the real and the p-adic case, precise and interesting results about coherent sets of frequencies need complex methods. In Section 1 we define the Laplace or the complex Fourier-transform of a distribution with compact support. The Paley-Wiener theorem gives precise information on the set of zeros of such a transform (Sections 2 and 3). In Section 9, we present the theory of mean-periodic functions on the line. Studying coherent sets of frequencies is equivalent to investigating the behaviour at infinity of all mean periodic functions whose spectrum is a given set of real numbers. Trigonometric series whose frequencies belong to the set of all entire parts of kB, where k 2 1 and 13 is an irrational number greater than one have quite fascinating properties which are studied in Section 6. But perhaps the most beautiful results concern the trigonometric series al exp 2ni2x, where 2 = mpn, defined on thep-adic field Q, by f ( x ) = CAE, for rational integers m and n such that 0 < mpn < 1. These series have almost all the properties of 2mperiodic functions on the line and other better ones (Section 8). The harmonious set A and its homothetical copies pkA, k 2 1 , are of outstanding importance in the atomization of distributions in Q,, just as arithmetic progressions are used to discretize problems on the real line.
143
+
1.2. The domain of dejnition of the Laplace transform
+
Let p = u iu be a complex number. The function t -+ e-"' does not belong to 9 , but i f a is an indefinitely diflerentiable function which is 1 on [- 1 , co[ and 0 on ] - oo, -21, then a ( t ) e-"' belongs to Y for each p E C such that u = Wep > 0. We can define ( T , e-"') to be ( T , a ( t ) e-P') whenever T is supported by [0, a [ . From now on, we write e-"' T ( t ) dt instead of ( T , e-"'). The Laplace transform can be defined on a larger space of distributions. For instance consider the function exp J7, t 2 0. For each p E C whose real part is positive, the integral j2 exp ( - p t &) dt converges and defines the Laplace transform of this function. Let 9 be the space of all complex valued indefinitely differentiable functions on the line with compact support. A distribution is a linear form T over 9 such that for each m Z 1 there is an integer n > 0 and a constant C > 0 with the property that for all y in 9 supported by [ - m , m ] the inequalities sup Ip(j)(t)J< C, 0 < j < n, imply IT(y)l < 1.
+
+
+
1-m,ml
If this is the case we write T E 9'. The domain of definition of the Laplace transform is the subspace 9of 9' consisting of all distributions T carried by [0, oo] such that, for each E > 0, e-et Tbelongs to 9'.
+
1. The Laplace transform 1.1. The space of tempered distributions
Following the notation of [21], Y is the Frechet space of all complex valued functions a on R all of whose derivatives, together with a itself, decay rapidly at infinity: for each j Z 0 and each k 2- 0, (1 Ixl)j y'k' ( x ) + 0 as 1x1 + + oo. The dual space Y' is the space of tempered distributions. For each T E Y' there is an integer n and a constant C > 0 such
+
142
1.3. Properties of the Laplace transform PROPOSITION 1 :For all T i n 9,theLaplace transform @(p)= :j e-"'T(t) dt is holomorphic in the open half-plane Wep > 0. Proof: Let 0 < E < Wep. Then e-pr = e-"e-'p-e'r , e-er T ( t ) E 9' and W e ( p - E ) > 0. The integral is thus well defined.
S E 9"; if S E ~we, apply the preceding argument to S ( t ) exp ( - s t / 2 ) with s/2 instead of E. The first part of Theorem I is thus proved. In the second half of Theorem I, the unknown distribution Twill be a limit of convolutions T * f as f runs over a sequence f , of indefinitely differentiable functions of the form f k ( t ) = k g ( k t ) , where g is supported by [O, 11 and j g(t) dt = 1. From now on, we write f instead off,. Let F(p) be the Laplace transform off. The Laplace transform of ~ k f is pkF(p). Now the Laplace transform of a complex valued continuous function carried by a compact subset of [0, + a [ is bounded. Hence 1pkF(p)l < c k .
To prove that @(p)is holomorphic, we apply the same trick and we are thereby reduced to examining only the case where T belongs to 9". If Wep, > 0, then with a defined as above, ~ ( t(exp ) ( - p t ) - exp (-pot)/ p - po tends to -ta ( t ) exp ( - p o t ) in the topology of 9'.Hence @(p)is differentiable over the field C at the point po and @'(p) is the Laplace transform of - t T (t). THEOREM I : Let T be a distribution carried by [0,+ co[ such that, for each positive E , e-,'T is a tempered distribution. Then the Laplace transform @(p)of T is a holomorphic function in the open halfplane with the following property: there is an integer n 2 0 such thatfor each positive s, we can find a constant C , such that (5.2) I@(p)l < C,lpln for Bep 2 s. Conversely each holomorphic function in the half-plane 9 e p > 0 satisfying (5.2) is the Laplace transform of a unique distribution T carried by [0,i-a[ such that e-" T belongs to 9" for each positive E. The proof of the first half of Theorem I begins with a lemma; here T is any distribution carried by [0, a[.
91ep20
The p~oduct@,(p) = F(p) @(p)has the following behaviour at infinity: for each positive E > 0 and each n > 0, Idil(p)l < C ( n , E ) IpI-" when Wep 2 E.
+
+
LEMMA 1: There exist an integer n >, 0, a continuous complex oalued function f carried by a compact subset of [0, + a [ and a distribution S carried by [l, + co [ such that T = D n ( f ) + S where Dn is the nth (distributional) derivative. Proof of the lemma: Let B be any indefinitely differentiable function with compact support, which is equal to 1 on a neighbourhood of [0,11. We write T = BT + ( 1 - B) T . The distribution /IT is carried by a compact set. Hence there exist an integer n 2 0 and a continuous function g such that g(t) = 0 if t < 0, g(t) = c if t >, to and PT = Dn(g).Let y be any indefinitely differentiable function with compact support, which is equal to 1 on a neighbourhood of [0,t o ] We define f = yg; then D n ( f ) = Dn(g) on a neighbourhood of [0,to] and T = D n ( f ) + S is the required decomposition of T. Proof of the first part of Theorem I: Let @, be the Laplace transform off and@, the Laplace transform of S. Then @, is an entire function ofp, bounded on Bep 2 0. The Laplace transform of D n ( f ) ispn@,(p)and satisfies (5.2). On the other hand, let a be an indefinitely differentiable function which is 0 if t < and 1 if t 2 2. Then for each s > 0 and each n 2 0, there is a constant c = c (n, E ) such that each function q ( t ) = ~ ( texp ) -pt (Wep >, E ) satisfies (5.1). This implies I<S, q)l < C, if
+
LEMMA 2 : For each real t , the integral ( 1 1 2 4 t): @, ( u iv) et("+'")dv T f ( t )exists and is independent of u > 0.This integral vanishes i f t < 0. Proof of the lemma: Let u, < u, be two such u. We apply Cauchy's theorem on the rectangle whose vertices are (u, , -L), (u, , -L), (u, ,L ) and ( u l , L). We get =
i
i StL@, (u,
+ iv) ef(u"i") dv - i j!,
Dl (u,
+ iv) e"U1'i"' dv
The behaviour of @, at infinity ensures that the last two integrals tend to 0 as L tends to infinity. I f t < 0 and u 2 1 , IJ+; @, (u + iv) et(u+iu)do] < C ( 2 , 1) j?," lu ivl-, dv, which tends obviously to 0 as u tends to + a .
+
LEMMA 3 : For eachjixed u > 0,e-'"Tf ( t ) E Y . The Laplace transform of T f is @, . Proof: The function e-'"Tf ( t ) is the inverse Fourier transform of @, ( u iv). To get estimates of the derivatives of @, , we apply Cauchy's formulas on the rectangle with vertices ( 4 2 , v/2), (3u / 2 , ~ / 2 )( ,3 ~ 1 23012) , and ( 4 2 , 3 ~ 1 2 ) :the inequalities I@, (u/2 iv)l < C'(u, n) Ivl-" and I@, ( 3 ~ 1 2 iu)l < CV(u,n) Ivl-" imply that, for each fixed u, each derivative of @, (u iv) with respect to v decays rapidly at infinity. Hence v -+ @, ( u iv) belongs to Y and taking the inverse Fourier transform,
+
+ + +
+
The Fourier-transform of edtUT f ( t )is ( u + iu); the Laplace transform of T , is therefore @, . We now replace f by f,(t) = k g ( k t ) and we write T k instead of Tf,. LEMMA 4: AS k tends to inJinity, T k tends to a distribution T carried by [O, + co [ in the sense that for each indeJinitely diferentiable function h with compact support, ( T k ,h ) + ( T , h ) as k -+ + co. Proof: Let E be any positive real number. The Fourier transform of e - , ' ~ , is @, ( E + iv) = @ ( E iv) yk( E + iv), where yk is the Laplace transform of k g (kt). We remark that lYkl < A throughout the halfplane Weu >/ 0 for some A independent of k and that Yk-+ 1 uniformly on compact subsets of this half-plane. The function eeth ( t ) is the Fourier transform of a function r(v) in Y . @ ( E + iv) Y k ( &+ iv)r(v)dv Hence ( T k , h ) = ( e - " ~ ~ eeth) ,, = + ST: @ ( E + iv) r(v) dv as k + co (we have I@ ( E iu)I lr(v)I dv < + co since @ grows slowly at infinity and r decays rapidly at infinity and Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem shows that the limit exists). If a distribution T is defined on R by the statement that the inverse Fourier transform of @ ( s + iv) is e-" T ( t ) , T would appear to depend on E. But the preceding argument gives, lim ( T k , h ) = ( T , h). Hence T k++m does not depend on E , Tis carried by [0, + oo [ and the Laplace transform of T is @.
+
+
(b) there exist an integer n 2 0 and a constant C such that IF (iy)l < C (1 lyl)". Conversely each entire function F(z) satisfying (a) and (b) is the Laplace transform of a distribution carried by [-I, I].
+
2.2. Proof of the first part of Theorem 11 If S is carried by [-I, I ] , we can find, for each positive E, two continuous functions f and g carried by [-I, I + E ] and an integer n 2 0 such that S = D n ( f ) + g. The proof is the same as that of Lemma 1. Let @(z) be the Laplace transform off, G that of g. Then F(z) = zn@( z ) + G(z). @(z) = j'_:,exp ( - z t ) f ( t ) dt implies I@(z)l < j'_:'exp ( - x t ) I f(t)l dt < C(E)exp (1 + E )1x1. The same inequality holds for G(z). Hence
+
2. The Paley-Wiener theorem
2.1. We list a number of corollaries of theorem I which are interesting in themselves. But first a definition is needed: 1: A complex valued.function f dejined in the complex plane DEFINITION is of exponential type I if, for each positive E , there exists a constant C(E) such that I f(z)l < C(s) exp [(I + E )lzl] for all z. A similar definition can be given for functions of a real variable. We say that f is of exponential type iff is of exponential type I for some I in 10, co [.
+
THEOREM 11: Let S be a distribution carried by [-I, I]. Then the Laplace transform F(z) of S is an entire function in the complex plane with the following two properties: (a) F is of exponential type I;
which implies (a) and (b). 2.3. To prove the converse, let F(z) be an entire function satisfying the inequality (5.3) for each positive E. Then exp [-(I + E )z ] F (z) is holomorphic in 9 e z > 0 and is bounded by C(E)(1 + IzIn). Theorem I shows that exp [-(I + E )z ]F ( z ) is the Laplace transform of a distribution T carried by [0, + co [. Hence F(z) is the Laplace transform of a distribution S carried by [- 1 - s, a[.In the same way, it can be proved that S is carried by ] - oo,I + E ] . The uniqueness of S shows that it is carried by
+
[-I,
4.
It remains to show that (a) and (b) imply (5.3). We use the following lemma of Phragmen-Lindelof : LEMMA 5: Let Y be a closed sector in the plane whose opening is less than n radians, and let f ( z ) be an holomorphic function on a neighbourhood of Y. I f f is of exponential type on Y and if( f(z)l < 1 on the frontier of Y, then ( f1 < 1 on the whole of Y. Proof: Since this statement is invariant under rotation, we can assume that Y is defined by -a < Arg z < a < 4 2 . Iff tends to 0 when z E Y and lz] -+ co, the maximum modulus principle gives I f(z)l < 1 for all z in Y. If f ( z ) does not tend to zero at infinity, we apply the preceding argument to f,(z) = exp (-EZ") f(z), where a > 1 and a a < 4 2 . We have lexp ( - E Z " ) ~= exp ( - E W e (za))< exp ( - s lzla cos aa). Hence I f,(z)l < 1 for each frontier point of Y andf , tends to zero when z E Yand lzI -, + co.
+
The preceding argument gives I fE(z)l < 1 for all positive E and all z in Y. Letting E tend to 0 , we get I f(z)l < 1. COROLLARY 1 : I f F is holomorphic in a neighbourhood of x 2 0,y 2 0 , i f F is of exponential type and ifJF(x)l < C exp Ix, IF (iy)l < C (1 (yl)", then (F ( x iy)l < C (1 Jzl)"exp lx. Proof: We apply Lemma 5 to f ( z ) = C-l ( z + i)-" F(z) exp -1z. The proof of Paley-Wiener's theorem is complete. We have proved the following improvement of Paley-Wiener's theorem. If F is an entire function of exponential type (not specified), if there exist an integer n 2 0 and a constant A such that IF (iy)l < A (1 Jyl)",and if for some positive I there is for each positive 8 a constant C , such that IF(x)J < C , exp (I + E ) 1x1, then F is the Laplace transform of a distribution carried by [-I, I].
+
+
n(r) = k nl(r). Once Theorem IS1 is proved for F , ,this relation at once gives the result for F. We apply Jensen's formula to F , to get that for each positive E and each R 2 1
+
+
+
Since this inequality holds for each positive E , Theorem I11 is proved. Remark: If n(r)/r tends to a limit D as r tends to infinity, so does R - l n(r)/r dr and Theorem 111 gives D < 1. In general, let D = l& n(r)/r. Then i E i R-l n(r)/r dr 2 D r-r + m
and Theorem 111 gives D
3. Repartition of roots of entire function of exponential type In all of what follows, F will be an entire function of exponential type I, so that for each positive E , there is a constant A(&) such that JF(z)l < A(&)exp (1 + E )(zI for any complex number z. Let a,, ...,a,, . . . be the sequence of all roots of F, ordered in such a way that la,l < la,+,l, and with each root occurring in the sequence (a,),, a number of times equal to its multiplicity.
,
DEFINITION 2: For each positiue real number r, n(r) is the number of roots of F in the closed disc lzl < r; alternatively, n(r) is the sup of n > 1 such that la,] < r. The function n(r) is defined on [0, +a[, is integervalued and is a step function. THEOREM 111: If E is an entire function of exponential type I, then lim sup R-I 1: n(r)/r dr < 1. We start with the well-known Jensen's formula: if F(z) is holomorphic on a neighbourhood of Jzl < R and if 0 < [all < la21 < ... < la,l is the sequence of roots of F, then dr o
r
=
S:'
2n
log IF ( ~ e ' ~do. )l
The proof is given in [16],th. 4.1, p. 181. We return to Theorem 111. I f F ( 0 ) = 0 , F(z) = zkF, (z),where F,(O)# 0 and if nl(r) is the number of roots of F , in the closed disc lzl < r, we have
r
o
Hence
< 1.
R-+m
,,,
COROLLARY 2: Let (A,)-, +, be an increasing sequence of real numbers such that lim I k / k = I / D exists. If 1 < n D , ecery distribution S Ikl-r+m
carried by [ - I , I ] whose Fourier transform canishes at all the A,, k is the zero distribution. Proof: Apply the Paley-Wiener theorem and Theorem 111.
E
Z
4. Bernstein's inequality THEOREM IV: Let g, be a complex valued bounded continuous function on the line whose spectrum1 Iies in [ - I , 11, or equivalently, a complex valued bounded continuous function on the line which is the restriction to R of an entire function of exponential type I. Then sup 19'1 < I sup Jq1. R
R
In particular for each pair of real numbers x' and xu, Ipl(x') - y(xV)l < 2 Ix" - x'l sup 191. R
Proof: The equivalence of the two definitions of is a consequence of Paley-Wiener's theorem. Let T / 4 be any real number greater than I and p ( t ) the T-periodic function defined by p(t) = 4T-'t if It( < T / 4 and p(t) = - 4 T - l t 2 if
+
In Sections 4 and 5, Fourier-transforms are defined by fix) =
e-lx'f(t)
dt to be
TI4 < t < 3T/4;p is the well-known sawtooth function of physics. Let q(t) = p ( t - T / 4 ) ;the function q is positive-definite and has an absolutely convergent Fourier series: q(t) = c, cos (2knt/T),ck 2 0, ck = 1. Hencep(t) = dk cxp (2knit/T),where Id,l = 1. I f o i s thediscrete measure dk6 ( x 2 k n T - l ) where 6 is the Dirac measure, the11b = p . Letg, be anycomplexvalucd boul:dedcontinuous functionon theline whose Fourier-transform S = is carried by [-I, I]. The Fourier-transform of y' is i t s ( t ) = i ( T / 4 ) p ( t )S(t). Hence g,' = i (T/4)a * g, and llg,'Il < (TI41 llall IIg,llm = (T/4) IIyllm. Since this inequality is true for each T / 4 > I, Bernstein's inequality is proved.
1,"
z?: +
x+:
x:
6
5. Other inequalities of Bernstein type THEOREM V: Let (Ak)- m < ,< + be an increasing sequence of real numbers such that lim (Aj+ - S ) / k = 1 ID uniformly over j E Z . For each
,
0 < A,,, < ( k + 1) L if k 2 0 and k L < A,,, < 0 if k < 0. Cantor's diagonal process yields an infinite increasing sequence m ( j ) of integers such that + A; for each k 2 0. For all k E Z , 0 < 6 < Am,,+ < L ; hence 0 < 6 < A;+, - A; < L and the set A' of all A;, - lm,k \ - co < k < + co is a regular set of real numbers. The preceding proof shows that if A has a realization A,, k E Z , such that lim (Aj+, - Aj)/k = 1/D uniformly over j E Z , so does k-+m
A': for each E > 0, there is an integer k ( ~ such ) that k 2 k ( ~implies ) (D-I - E ) k < Aj+, - Aj < (D-I + E ) k. But we can find an integer I depending only on m such that for each k in Z , A,,, = A,,, - x , . Hence for each j in Z , each m 2 1 and each k 2 k ( ~ )we , have (D-I - E ) k < - Am,j < (D-I E ) k . Passing to the limit, we get (D-I - E ) k < A;+, - AS < (D-I + E ) k for j~ Z and k 2 k ( ~ )which , is the required inequality.
+
k-+m
I < nD, there is a positive constant C such that for any complex valued bounded continuous function g, whose spectrum lies in [-I, I ] , we have ldAk)l. 191 < R
-m
5.2. To prove Theorem V, let E be the Banach space of complex valued continuously differentiable functions on [-21,211 and V the convex set of all distributions S carried by [-I, I ] whose Fourier-transforms 3 satisfy the inequality sup < 1. Then V is a compact subset of the dual space R
5.1. Proof of Theorem V Theorem V will be dednced from Corollary 1 of Theorem 111 and standard compactness arguments that we now describe. A set A of real numbers is called regular if there exists a 6 > 0 such that each interval of length 6 contains at most one point ofA and if there exists an L > 0 such that each interval of length L contains at least one point ofA. A realization cf A is a presentation of A as an increasing sequence A,, - co < k < co, of real numbers. We have 6 < A,,, - A, < L and all other realizations of A are of the form ,uk= A,-,, ( - a < k < + a ) A . sequence A,, m 2 1 , of regular sets of real numbers tends to a regular set A if there is a realization A,,,, - co < k < $ co of eachA, and a realization A,, - co < k < co, ofA such that A,,, + A, for each k . We do not require uniformity of convergence with respect to k .
+
+
LEMMA 6: Let A be a regular set of real numbers and x,, m 2 1, a sequence of real numbers. There exist a regular setAf of real numbers and a subsequence xk of x , such thatA - xh tends ton' when m tends to infinity. Proof: Let A,,, be a realization of A - x , such that, A,,, 2 0 for k 2 0 and A,,, < Ofork < 0. We haveil,,, < L,A,,-, 2 -Landhence
E* of E with respect to the weak-star topology a (E*, E). For each real t the mapping from Q to the complex field defined by S + $(t) is continuous. If a sequence (S,),, of distributions carried by [-I, I ] exists such that sup 131 , = 1 while sup lgm(Ak)l< llm, let x , be a real number
,
R
-m
+m
such that I~,(x,)I 2 5. Let T,, be the distribution e-'""" T ; T , belongs to V, J(T,, 1)1 2 4 and IF, (Ak - xm)l < l / k . We can find an increasing sequence m j of integers such thatA - x,(, +A' and Trncj) + T' as j tends to infinity. Bernstein's theorem shows that for any two real numbers x' and x" and any S i n Q, 1$(xr) - 3(x1')l < Ixr - xtll. Applying this inequality to X' = A; EA' and x" = A,,, E A - x,, whose limit is A;, we get, writing m instead of m j , pm(A;)-+ 0 as m + + co ; hence Pt(A;) = 0 for all k in Z . The set A' of all 31; has a uniform density D and D < nl. Corollary 2 implies T' = 0. This is impossible siwe I(T, 1)1 = lim I(Tm, 1)1 2 3. m-
+m
Hence Theorem V is proved. For a better result, the reader is referred to [54].
6. Irrational numbers and special trigonometric series
6.1. Let 8 be an irrational number > 1 and, for each positive integer k , let [Bk]be the integer m defined by 0 < Bk - m < 1 ; m is the integral part of 8k. We define A(8) to be the set of all [Bk],k E Z. DEFINITION 3 : For each irrational number 8 > 1 , g ( 8 ) is the Banach space of all complex valued continuous I-periodic functions whose spectra lie in the set A(B)of all in tegralparts [ k e ] ,k E Z. The Fourier series o f f is a, exp 2ni [kB]t.
1 :
THEOREM VI (properties of V ( B ) ): (1) g ( 8 ) is a closed, translation invariant space of I-periodic functions on the line; (2) i f O is any open subset of [0, 11 of Lebesgue measure greater than 118, eachfunction in g ( 8 ) is completely deJned by its values on 52, as thefollowing properties show: (b) i f f isp-times continuously diferentiable on O ,f isp times continuously diferentiable throughout the real line; (c) iff is analytic on 52, f is analytic on the real line; (3) i f K i s any compact subset of [0, 11 ofLebesgue measure less than 118, any complex valued continuousfunction on K is the restriction to K of some function in V(8). A p-adic version of Theorem VI will be given in Theorem IX. Theorem VI fails if 8 is rational.
finite union of intervals U whose Lebesgue measure is greater than 118. Once (a) is proved for U, it is proved for 52. Let M be the set of all integers m in Z such that h(m) E U . For any sequence ( c ~ ) ~ of , , complex numbers, we put
With this terminology we can state two lemmas:
7: For any complex valued continuous function f defined on T , LEMMA lim %l {f ( h ( j ) ) ; m < j < m k ) = ( 1 1 2 ~ ) f(eie) dB, uniformly over
+
k++m
m
Sin
Z. Since 11/2nS?f(eie) dB1 < Ilfll, and I%R{f(h(j));m < j < m k)l < 11f 11 , it suffices to consider the dense subspace of finite trigonometric sums; by linearity it is sufficient to examine the case where f(eie) = elpe, p E Z . In this case an easy computation gives the result. E
+
LEMMA 8: For any complex valued Riemann integrable function g on T the same result holds. Proof: By linearity we can confine our attention to real g. For each positive E , there are two continuous functions f l and f , on T such that fl < g < f2 and ( 1 1 2 4 j? (f2 - f l ) (eie)dB < E. Hence
6.2. Sketch of the proof of (a) The proof is based on the following remark: under the injective homomorphism h from Z to T defined by h ( j ) = exp 2nij8-17 the image of Z is a dense subgroup of T , and A(8) is mapped onto a dense subset of the arc I of T defined by the parametric representation z = exp -2nit, 0 < t < 118. Iff in a function defined on T whose spectrum lies in A(8) its composition with this homomorphism is a function g defined on Z whose spectrum lies in I and we are reduced to Theorem V. 6.3. A computation of densities
Before going into the details, some remarks should be made. An open subset O of [O,l] whose Lebesgue measure is greater than 110 contains a
But the two extreme terms of this inequality differ from (1 1222) t)? f(eie) d8 by an error term not exceeding E (Lemma 7). Hence lim %R { g (h(j)); m
< j < m + k ) = (1127~)
k-++oo
g(e'e) dB uniformly on m
E Z.
LEMMA 9: The uniform density of the set M of integers is equal to the Lebesgue measure of U. (Note that the Lebesgue measure of the whole of T is 1.) Proof: We apply Lemma 8 to the characteristic function of U.
6.4. Proof of (a) To prove (a) for all f in V(I3), it suffices to prove (a) for finite trigonometric sums P(t) = ck exp 27ci [kO] t. Moreover, each open subset Q of [O, 11whose measure is greater than 118 contains a finite union U of closed intervals, the sum of whose lengths is greater than 1/13. If we prove (a) for U instead of 52, the inequality with Q will hold a fortiori. Let h : Z + T be the homomorphism defined by h(j) = exp 2nijI9- l. The dual homomorphism h* : Z + T is also defined by h*(j) = exp 2nijI9-l. Since h*(Z) is a dense subgroup H of T, we have sup IP( = sup IPI C0,ll H and sup 1PI = sup ]PI. U
UnH
LetM be the set ofallintegersj~Zsuchthat h*(j)~Uandlet,ubethe measure carried byT and assigning the mass ckto the point exp -2niI9-'[ke]. An easy computation gives P(j) = P (h(*j)). To get (a), we have to prove that sup I,G(j)l $ C sup I$(j)l for all finite linear combinations of Z
M
Dirac measures concentrated in points of the form exp -2niI3-I Eke]. We now make the following crucial observation: let I be the arc of T defined by the parametric representation z = exp - 2nit, 0 < t 6 1/13. Then h(A) is contained in I; the image of the set A(I3) under the homomorphism h lies in an interval. Writing [kO] = k0 - r where 0 < r < 1, we get 8-I [ke] = - 0-lr (mod I), which proves our remark. Using the local inverse of the momomorphism t + 2nit, we now replace I by the interval J = [- (I/@, 01; ,u becomes a measure v carried by - J and all that remains is to show that sup le(t)l $ C sup IB(t)(. ZnZ
ZnM
Theorem V shows that to get this inequality, it suffices to show that 27cM is a regular set whose uniform density is greater than 23-218. Lemma 9 shows that this is the case and (a) is proved. LetQ be an open subset of [0, 11 of Lebesgue measure greater than 110. If a function in V(I9) is zero on Q, this function is zero everywhere. If two functions of V(I9) agree on Q, they are equal everywhere.
6.5. Proof of (b) and (c) Let f be a function of V(I9) continuously differentiable on an open subset Q of [0, 11 whose Lebesgue measure is greater than 110. Let U be a finite union of closed intervals contained in Q the sum of whose lengths is greater than 118. On U , the family of functions g (x) = t - I [f(x t)
+
- f(x)] of V(I9) tends uniformly to f '(x) as t tends to 0. Theorem VI, (a), implies uniform convergence over the whole of R ; hencef is continuously diffcrentiable throughout R. Similarly, iff is k times continuously differentiable on Q and iff belongs to V(I9), then f is k times continuously differentiable on R and sup ( f ( k ) ( R < A sup If (k'(,where A is independent of k > 0. B
Assume that f is analytic on 9 acd let U be as above. The inequalities If (k'(x)l $ Ckk! on U imply I f(k'(x)) $ ACkk! on the whole of R and f is analytic throughout R.
6.6. Two remarks Remark 1: For each open subset Q of [0, 11 whose Lebesgue measure is greater than 1/19, there is a constant C such that for any function f in V(@, J: lf(x)I2 dx G CJf2 If(x)12 dx. Proof of this remark: Let U be a finite union of closed intervals of [0, I] such that, for a positive E , U + [-E, E]is contained in Q, and such that the Lebesgue measure of U is greater than 118. Let g be any complex valued continuous function whose support lies in [ - E , E] and such that llgllz = (r-&lg(t)I2 dt)lI2 < 1. For each f in V(I9), the convolution product f * g lies in g(I9) and, by part (a) of Theorem VI, for each real x,
Taking the sup with respect to g, we obtain, for each real x,
and
Remark 2: For each open subset SZ of [0, 11 whose Lebesgue measure is greater than 118, there is a constant C such that for any complex valued Radon measure ,u whose spectrum lies in A(I9), Il,ull $ C JB dlpl (t). The proof of this second remark is similar to that of the preceding one : the set U and the positive real number E are defined as above, the test function g is any continuous complex valued function supported by
158
SPECIAL SERIES (COMPLEX
METHODS)
(b) iff E gAis p-times continuously diferentiable on K, then f is p-times continuously differentiable throughout the real line; (c) iff is analytic on a neighbourhood of K, f is analytic throughout the real line; (d) if K is a compact set of real numbers whose measure is less than l/la/3 - olbl, (a) and (b) are false. Before proving this theorem, some comments should be made. If E is any positive real number and K is the union of the two intervals I, = [0, (a/3- abl - s] acd .Ym = [m - E, m + E ] ,then, even if m is very large and the two intervals are very far from each other, the values off on K determinef completely. On the other hand the knowledge off on I,, is not sufficient to reveal any substantial information. The role played by the very small and distant interval Y mis indeed curious. The set A of all finite sums ,Qk, E~ = 0 or 1, 0 = (1 + 2/5)/2 can also be defined as the set of all positive real numbers m + no = 1, m E Z, n E Z such that - 1 < m n% < 0 where 8 = (1 - &)/2. In this case 3 J?/10. the critical measure 1/lap - abl is
Ek,,
+
++
7.2. Computations of densities
To obtain a better understanding of the number lllaj3 - abl, the following lemma will be useful: LEMMA 11 :Each intervalof realnumbers of length Tcontains T lap - olbl + o(T) points ofA; o(T)/T tends to 0 uniformly with respect to the position of the interval as T tends to infinity. To prove this lemma, we in fact consider a more general situation which is of interest in itself; the corresponding result will be proved for a large class of harmonious and relatively dense sets of real numbers. Definition of models: Let n be an integer greater than 1 ; U , a compact subset of Rn-l; a,, ...,a,, n real numbers linearly indeperder~tover Q ; I, the linear form defined over Rnby I (x, , ..., x,) = a,x, + . + n,,x,; L,, ..., L,-, , n - 1 other linear forms such that L,, ...,L,-, , I constitute a basis of the dual of Rn; (L: ,...,L,*) is the isomorphism of Rnwhich is the adjoint of the inverse of the isomorphism L of Rn defined by x + (L,(x), . ..,L,- ,(x), Ilx)),
X E R " : for each x and y in Rn, L:(x) L,(y) + + L,*_l(x)~,-l(y) L,*(x) I(y) = x . y. We assume that the coefficients of L,* are linearly independent over Q. Under these assumptions, we construct a set of real numbers which is called a model (Chapter 11, Section 6); A is the set of all real1 = a,k, + a,k, for all k = (k,, ..., k,) in Znsuch that the element (Ll(k), ..., L,- ,(k)) of Rn-I belongs to U.
+
+
7.3. A Poisson formula with remainder term for a model (computation of densities) In the following theorem U andA are defined just as above; E is any positive real number and U, is the set of all x in Rn-l whose distance from U does not exceed E . Finally A, is defined using L,, ...,L,-,, I and U,. THEOREM VIII: Assume that U is Riemann integrable, i.e. that the frontier of U has Lebesgue measure zero. For each positive E there exists a complex measure p e such that (1) sup j=+ldlp,l(t) < + a ; -m<x<+m
(2) the Fourier transform Sp, of p, is also a measure; Sp, is equal to (x - 1) + R,(x), where B(x) is the unit mass concentrated the sum in (0); (3) the remainder term R,(x) has the form '&sAs\A@(A)6 (x - 1) where 0 <&(A) < 1; (4) lim 1 / 2jz;: ~ d IR,(x)l + 0 as E + 0, uniformly over all real x.
CnEAB
T++m
This means that the Fourier transform of p, is the sum of unit masses concentrated in each point ofiltogether with an error term. This error term consists of positive masses, less than one, concentrated in points of Ae\A1. The mean value of this error term is arbitrarily small as E tends to zero. Now to the proof. We start by defining a function a which will be extended to the whole ofA, by the rule a(1) = 1 if A E A. Let p, be a Cm function on Rn-l, which is 1 on U and 0 outside U,. If 1= alk, + + ank, we put k = (k,,...,k,) E Z", &(A) = y(L1(k), ...,L,-,(k)) and p is a CMfunction defined on Rn by p(x) = p, (L1(x), ..., L,- ,(x)). A, &(A) B (X - 1) where B(x) is the unit mass concentrated in Let v = (0) and let us compute @. Iff is any test function in 9,we have
XI
A,\A is the complement of A in A,.
The function /3 (x, , ..., x,) f (a,x, + -.. + a,x,) decays rapidly at infinity over RE; its Fourier transform Q (x,, . .., x,) = (det L)-, @ (L: , ..,L,*- ,)f(~,*)also decays rapidly at infinity. At this stage, the well-known Poisson formula will be applied. If e : Rn-, C belongs to Y and if 6 (y, , ..., y,) = JRnexp -2ni (x, y, + .. xnyn)e (xl, .. .,x,) dxl dx,, then e(k) = &k). In our case this equality gives
.
xz,
+
xzn
The last equality follows from the observation that (gp,) * y is an almost periodic function whose Fourier coefficient for the frequency x is +(x)pA -4. Letting c tend to zero we get Lemma 12. Let V be the closure of U,\U. We have dens (A,\A) < (det L)-I meas (U,IU) and since the measure of the frontier of U is 0, lirn dens A,\A E'O
= 0. Since the masses of Re lie in ]O,l[ and are concentrated in points of
A,\A, (4) follows. COROLLARY 3 : If U is Riemann integrable, lim (1/2T) Card ([x - T, where p is the atomic measure assigning the mass (det L)-' L ),: (k,, ..., k,) to the point L,* (k,, ..., k,). We have
$J
(L: , ...,
x
+ TI n A,)
T-+m
= (det L)-l meas U, uniformly over all real x.
7.4. Proof of Theorem VZZ
where the latter sum is extended over all k in Zn such that L,*(k) belongs to [x, x 1). Let 0 be the characteristic function of [0, 11. Then
+
I:"
d Ip(t)l
(det L)-l
=
C (@I zn
(LT , ...,L L l ) 0 (L,* - x).
Since the linear forms L? , ...,L: form a basis of the dual space of Rn, there exists a E E Rn such that L,*(t) = ... = L,*_,(E) = 0 and L,*([) = x. Let w be the function defined on Rn by co = (det L)-I (L:, .. ., L,*-l) 0(L,*). With this notation d Jp(t)l = o (k - 6). Since w decays rapidly at infinity, we have sup w (k - 8 < + CYJ and hence
CZn
xzn
sup J?'
d Ip(t)l <
xsR
+ co.
CER~
We now have to prove (4). We need the following notion : for any compact subset V of Rn-l, let A, be defined by (L, , ..., L,-, , I ) and V. We define dens A, to be lim (2T)-l sup (Card [x - T, x + TI nA,). xeR
T*+m
LEMMA 12: dens A, < (det L) - meas V. Proof: Let y be any indefinitely differentiable function defined on R, whose support lies in [0, I] and such that ji y(t) dt = 1. We construct, using V, a measure p, just as we did with U. Then, since R, is a positive measure, (2) gives
-
dens A,
<
J
lirn -
'
~ - + + m2T
(Sp,) ,-T
* y dx = p,(O) , uniformly over x E R.
Let h be the homomorphism from R to T2 defined by h(t) = (exp 2niat, exp 2niPt). To prove (a), it is sufficient to verify (a) when f(t) is a finite sum a, exp 2ni1t since these sums are dense in V, with respect to the topology of uniform convergence over the whole of R. Such a sum can be written P o h, where P is defined on T2 = R2/Z2 by P (x, y) = C(rn,n)eT am., ~ X 2ni P (mx + ny). For all (x,, yo) in R2 and all real t, we have
xAEn
P (x,
+ at, yo + bt) = C
ah,, exp 2ni (am
+ bn) t = g(t),
(m.n)~r
where a&,, = a,,, exp 2ni (mx, + ny,). This function g(t) is the Fourier transform of a measure carried by [- 1, I]. Let h' :R -t T2 be the affine map defined by h'(t) = (exp 2ni (x, + at), exp 2ni (yo + bt)). Since bla is irrational, hl(R) is dense in T2. Let A' be the set of all real1 such that h'(1) E L = h(K); thenn' is a model whose uniform density is lap - abl meas K and hl(A') is dense in h(K). Theorem V gives sup Ig(t)l < A sup Ig(t)l = A sup IPI. Since ht(R) tsR ten' L is dense in T2, sup (g(t)l = sup IPI. Since h(R) is dense in T2, sup I f(t)l Tz
t ER
tsR
= sup ]PI; h restricted to K is a homeomorphism from K to L and this T2
implies sup 1 f 1 K
=
sup IP(.Hence sup I f(t)l L
~ E R
< A sup If 1 and TheoremVII K
is proved. Property (a) implies that, for each Riemann-integrable compact set K of real numbers whose measure exceeds l/lap - abl, there exists a constant C such that, for each complex-valued almost-periodic function f
whose frequencies belong to A,
8.3. Proof of (a)
Landau proved in [54], th. 2 p. 39, that this last property implies meas K 2 dens A. This is not the case here. Another method of proving this type of statements will be given in the p-adic case.
Replacing K by a smaller compact subset if necessary, we may assume that K i s a finite union of disjoint open balls B j , where an open ball of Q, is a coset of the form xZ, + y, x E Q,, y E Q,, and that the measure of K still exceeds 1. Let A' be the set of real numbers defined by the rule: A EA' if A E A, and furthermore if A, regarded as an element of Q,, belongs to K. LEMMA 13: A' can be ordered in such a way as to become an increasing sequence (A;)- ,,,, +, of real numbers such that lim - jl;)/k k+ + m = 1 /IKI uniformly over j E Z. Proof of Lemma 13: An open ball of Q, can always be written B = xZ, + y, where x = pJ, j E Z and y E A,. Then B n A, considered as a set of real numbers, is a two-way infinite arithmetic progression of common difference ]XI,' = IBI-l and uniform density IBI. Lemma 13 follows from this observation. We return to the proof of Theorem IX. Let P be any finite sum A ar exp 2nixA ( x E Q,) and p the corresponding trigonometric sum defined on R by p ( t ) = a* exp 2nitA. The frequencies of H belong to 10, l[. Since A, is dense in Q, and also in R, we have sup IP( = sup IPI
8. Special trigonometric series on p-adic fields
8.I. Let Q, be the p-adic field, Z, the subgroup of p-adic integers and A, the ring of elements mpn, m E Z, n E Z, of Q,. By an abuse of notation we shall identify A, with a subring of Q. L e t A be the subset of Q, consisting of all mpnin A, such that 0 < mpn< 1. By Hensel's decomposition, eachp-adic number x can be written uniquely as x = A + r, where A EA , r E Z,. Hence each coset x + Z,, x E Q,, of the compact group Z, meetsA in a single point. The Haar measure, denoted by dx, is normalized on Q, by IZ,I = 1. For each x in Q,, we define exp 2nix to be equal to exp 2 n d if A E A, and x - A E Z,. With this notation, each continuous character on Q, can be written in the form x -t exp 2nixy.
xlE =
sup
=
sup
8.2. W e denote by V A the Banach space of all complex-valued almostperiodic functions on Q,, whose spectra lie in A. The set of all finite sums P(x) = CleAa, exp 2niAx is a dense subspace of g,.
I
1
THEOREM IX: Let K be a Riemann integrable compact subset of Q,. (a) Ifthe Haar measure I K ( of K exceeds 1, there is a constant A such that or each f in V A , sup J f l 4 A sup 1 f l i QP
sup I
~ Similarly, I. asA'
A,
QD
n K is dense in K, sup IPI = sup /PI
R
K
A'
Since A' is regular and has uniform density IKI, Theorem V
A'
gives A sup If31 2 sup IP"I and the proof is complete. A'
R
8.4. Necessary andsufJicient conditions for sup If ( QP
< A sup ( f1 K
To prove (c), we first give the following characterization of compact subsets K of Q, such that sup If ( and sup If 1 are equivalent norms for funcK R tions f in %'A.
K
(b) If the Haar measure IK( of K is less than 1, each complex-valued continuous function deJned on K is the restriction to K of a function in V A . In particular, there i~ a non-zero function in V A , which vanishes identically on Ki (c) The subgroup Z, of Q,, whose Haar measure is exactly 1, does not satisfy the conclusion of (a). For a more precise result, the reader is referred to [89].
=
An
I
I
xleA
I
PROPOSITION 2: Let A = A, n 10, 1[, let K be a compact subset of Q,, let A' = A, n K considered as a set of real numbers and let A be a positive constant. The following two statements are equivalent: (a) for each almost periodic .function f : Q, + C whose frequencies lies inA,supIfl 6 AsupIfl; K
QP
(b) for each bounded continuousfunction g, : R 4 C whose spectrum lies in [O, 11, sup 191 < 4' sup 1 ~ 1 . R
A'
where z is the measure supported by A, aiid assigning the mass a(t) to each t in A,.
Assuming, for the moment, that Proposition 2 is proved, let us see why statement (c) of Theorem IX follows. If K = Z,, A' = Z and ~ ( x = ) exp 2nix - 1 is such that the spectrum of v lies in [0, 11 and q~= 0 on Z while sup (TI = 2. For this reason 2,
LEMMA 15: With the notation of Proposition 2, the following two statements are equivalent: (a) SUP If l < A SUP If I;
R
does not satisfy the conclusion of (a) in Theorem IX. In the same way, it can be shown that if Kis the union of a finite number of disjoint open balls of Q, and if IKI = 1, then K does not satisfy the conclusion of (a) in Theorem IX.
QP
8.5. Proof of Proposition 2
Enen
The interest of Proposition 2 is that it establishes an equivalence between properties of functions on the p-adic field and properties of functions on the real line. The proof of Proposition 2 depends on a series of lemmas:
LEMMA 14: Let a : R + R be the function defined by a(t)
=
K
(b) for each t in A,, there exists a complex Radon measure p, carried by K, whose norm does not exceed A and such that ,&(A)= exp 2ni1t for each 1in A. In the proof it suffices to confine attention to the dense subspace of finite trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A. (a) => (b): Let d be the vector space of all restrictions to K of finite trigonometric sums P(x) = Cn exp 2niilx; the norm of P in d is sup If 1. If (a) holds, we can define a linear form L, over d for each t in A, K
by L,( f ) = f(t); the norm of L, does not exceed A. By the metric form of the Hahn-Banach theorem, there is a complex Radon measure p, carried by Ksuch that L,( f ) = jK f dp, for eachf in 8;testing onf(x) = exp 2nixt we get (b). (b) => (a): Let P be any complex valued trigonometric sum whose frequencies lie in A. Then (b) gives P(t) = j, P(-x) dp, (x), which implies IP(t)l < A sup IP(. Since A, is dense in Q, we have sup (PI = sup \PI
sup (0, 1
- 12t - I(); a is the Fourier transform of the function b : R+ R dejined by b(x) = (exp inx) (1 - cos nx)/(n2x2).Let o be the atomic measure carried by A, and assigning to eachpoint t in A, the mass b(t). Then the Fourier transform of o, in the sense of distributions of Q,, is also an atomic measure t, carried by A and assigning to each 1in A the mass a(3L). Remark: The measure o is not bounded, but an elementary computation gives lo1 (x + Z,) = 1 for each x in Q,. Proof: Let D c Q, x R be the discrete and relatively dense subgroup of all pairs (t, t), t E A,. The annihilator of D is the discrete subgroup D' of Q, x R of all pairs (-t, t), t E A,. A class Y of test functions can be defined on Q, in the following way; f : Q, -t C belongs to Y if there exist n disjoint open balls B, , . .., B, and n complex numbers a,, ..., a, such that f restricted to Bj equals aj and f
K
< A sup ]PI.
QP
K
LEMMA 16: With the notation of Lemma 15,for each t in A,, let v, be the restriction of p, to A, and let Q, be the remainder term, i.e. Q, = p, - v,; then for each 1in A, &(A) = $,(A). Proof: Let o be the atomic measure carried by A, and defined as in Lemma 14. The convolution product p, * o is well defined since one of the two terms has compact support; testing on functions in Y , we see that the Fourier transform of p, * o is kt&,the product of a regular function with an atomic measure. If 1E A , the mass of P,b concentrated in 1is a@) exp 2ni1t, where a(1) denotes the value of a on 1considered as a real number, and if il @ A ,the mass of P,b concentrated in 1 is 0. Hence $,8 = a@) exp 2ni1t d(x - A), where d(x) is the unit mass concentrated in 0. Let st be the unit mass concentrated in t; then p, * o = st * o since these two measures have the same Fourier-transform. But p, * o = v, * o + Q, * o and v, * G is carried by the group A,, while Q, * o is carried by
n
equals 0 on Q,\U Bj. The class Y is invariant under Fourier transforms. 1
To compute the Fourier transform 8 of o, we consider the integral jQp$(x) do (x) = '&f(x) b(y), where the sum is over all pairs (x, y) E D. ~EQ~,YER. The Poisson formula ([7], Vol. 2, Ch. VIII, Section 31) gives
CAE,
I
SPECIAL SERIES (COMPLEX
the complement of A,. Since E, * o is also carried by A,, the only possibility is that s t * o = v, * o a ~ Qd, * o = 0. Lemma 16 is thus proved. Note that llvtll < llptll < A. Proof of Proposition 2: The implication (b) (a) has already been proved in Section 8.3. To get (a) (b), we apply Lemma 16: for each t E A,, there exists an atomic measure v, carried by A,, whose norm does not exceed A and such that 4,(1) = exp 2ni1t for each 1in A. Regarding A, as a dense subgroup of R, v, becomes an atomic measure 1,carried by A' and such that 1,(x) = exp 2nixt for each x in 10, 1[ n A,. Since [O, 1[ n A, is dense in [0, 11, we have &(x) = exp 2nixt for each x in [O, 11. Let p : R + C be any bounded function whose spectrum lies in [0, I]. If we can write F(t) = jRF(x) dAt (x) = F(x) Rf{x}, there is no more = sup JFI to prove. Since l\itll= Ex,,. 11,(x}I < A, we have sup
-
-
xXEAr
< A sup Iql. The following lemma concludes the proof:
R
*P
METHODS)
167
given complex-valued continuous g : Z, -+ C will be given by a convolution f = g * p (5.4) with a discrete Radon measure p carried by A , and satisfying
the Fourier transform v of p, in the sense of distributions, v = 3 , ~is a discrete measure carried by A(&)
(5.6)
and, if I is the characteristic function of Z, and 6(t) is the unit mass concentrated in 0 Z(t) dp (t) = 6(t). (5.7) Next, by a suitable partition of unity on K, we reduce the problem to the first case.
A'
8.7. Details of the proof: con,structionof p
LEMMA 17: Let Z be a compact interval of real numbers, ,u a complex bounded Radon measure on R whose Fourier transform vanishes on I, and g, a bounded complex continuousfunction on R whose spectrum lies in I. Then jR q(x) d , ( 4 = 0. In our context ,u is the difference between Rt and the unit mass concentrated in t. A dilation and a translation reduce the problem to the case where I = [-I, 11. We define yn, n 2 1, by pn(x) = p ((1 - lln) x); the spectrum of ynlies in [- 1 + lln, 1 - lln] a r d Proposition 4, Section 12, Chapter IV, gives JR FAX)dp (x) = 0. But IvnI < 11v11 and vn(x) + p(x) as n tends to infinity. Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem now gives JR F(x) dp (x) = 0. 8.6. Proof of part (b) of Theorem IX To start with, we show why the second part of (b) is a consequence of the first part. If lKl < 1 the union K' of K and of a point x in Q,, x E K, has the same property as K; hence the function which is 1 on x and 0 on K is the restriction to K' of a function in V Awhich vanishes on K without being identically 0. First of all, we shall prove (b) if K = Z, when A is replaced by the set A(&)of all x = mpnin Q, such that 0 < x < 1 + E. The extension f of the
Let a be a Cm real function on R carried by [0, 1 + E] and such that = 1identically. The Fourier transform a of d has the following properties: d belongs to the class Y of Schwartz, d(0) = 1 while d(j) = 0 for all j E Z, j # 0. We put b(x) = d(-x). Let p be the atomic measure carried by A, which assigns the mass b(t) to each point t in A,. As in Proposition 2, the Fourier-transform v of p , in the sense of distributions, is also an atomic measure, carried by A, n [0, 1 E]which assigns the mass a(t) to each point t of A,. Since Z, n A, = Z , the properties of b restricted to Z at once give (5.7). The estimates (5.5) follow from the following two observations: (a) (x + Z,) n A, is a translate of Z ; (b) owing to the rapid decay of b at infinity, sup Cj'=?, Jb( j + t)l ~ E R < +a. From (5.7) it is obvious that f = g on Z,.
xjEza (x -j )
+
8.8. Details of the proof: the partition of K Since ]Kl < 1 there there exist two integers m and n 2 1 such that K is m
contained in the union mp-" < 1.
U Bj of m open balls of measurep-" and suchthat 1
m
From now on we replace K by
U B,.
For each j, there is a function
1
~ ( x =) exp (2nip-"x)
- a,, which, restricted to B,, is 0 and which re-
stricted to each Bk, k # j, is a constant different from zero since each Bj is a translate of pnZp. Let 0 < E < 1 - mp-". For each continuous g : K + C, let gj be the restriction of g to Bj, and& the extension of gj to an almost periodic function whose spectrum lies in A, n [O, p-" + E];fj is given in terms of gj by a simple modification of (5.4), where Z, is replaced by B, = pnZp+ xj. ,, where dj is a constant such that on B,, We put f = dj& 1 = dj n k + j ~ l k . Then f equals& on each B,, f is almost-periodic and the spectrum off lies in A, n [O,p-" + E + (m - 1)p-"1 c A, n [0, l[. Note that the extension g -+ f from V(K) into VA is given by a continuous linear operator.
x'= nk,
8.9. How to discretize distributions on Q,? The extension operator defined in Section 8.6 can be used to atomize distributions taken in certain spaces that we now define. The notation is that of Sections 8.6 and 8.7. Let w : [0, + co[ + [I, + co[ be an increasing function and let LE(Q,) be the Banach space of all classes of measurable functions f : Q, + C such that for a constant C > 0, I f(x)l < Cw (1x1,) almost everywhere with respect to the Haar measure on Q,. We define Y(Q,) to be the vector space of all test functions g, : Q, + C which are compactly supported and locally constant. The Fourier-transform of such a g, also has these two properties. For any f E Lz(Q,), the Fourier transform S = ;Ff off, in the sense of distributions, is defined by
S(x) dx (b) for each t in A,, the mass ofL(S) concentrated in t is a(t) where a is defined as in Section 8.7; (c) the Fourier transforms of S and of L(S) coincide on Z,; (d) for a constant C > 0. (IL(S)II < CIISII, where the norms are computed in E, . In fact we put S = f E Lz, f = ( I f ) * p and L(S) = The terminology is that of Section 8.6 and the easy verifications of (a), (b), (c) and (d) are left to the reader. For each k 2 1 and each Radon measure p on Q,, let p k be the Radon measure p (pkx); if p is atomic and if the mass of p concentrated in x E Q, is a(x), p (pkx) is also atomic and the mass of concentrated ,ukin P - ~ X is a(x). Let I, be the characteristic function ~ f p - ~ Z , . A sequence L,, k 2 1, of linear atomizing operators can be found such that, for each S in Em,Lk(S) = S, is a nice sequence of approximations of S ; each S, is carried by the harmonious subset pkA, of Q, and this explains the role played by harmonious subsets of Q, in atomizing processes. If S E E,, S = where f E L,"(Q,). We define Skto be where
sf,
sf,
sf.
sfkk,
Then (5.5)-(5.7) imply that (a) S, is a measure carried by pkA,; (b) for each t in A,, the mass of L,(S) concentrated in pkt is a (pkt) jp.ct+zp, S(X)dx; (c) the Fourier-transform of S and of S, coincide on P-~Z,; (d) for a constant C independent of S and of k Z 1, llSkll < CllSll where the norms are computed in E, = OL,"; notice that pdkZPis an increasing sequence of open subgroups of Q, whose union is Q,.
9. Mean periodic functions Let Embe this Banach space of distributions; llSll is the norm of 3 in L3QP). A linear atomizing operator L can be constructed with the following properties: (a) for each distribution S in Em, L(S) is a measure carried by A, = A, n [O, 1 + E], where E > 0 isJixed from now on;
The theory of mean periodic functions provides a remarkable interpretation of coherent sets of frequencies: A is a coherent set of frequencies if and only if each mean periodic function whose spectrum lies in A is bounded or, equivalently, if and only if each mean periodic function whose spectrum lies in A is almost periodic. The exposition follows that of [47].
9.1. Engineers using Laplace transforms to solve linear differential equations of the type T * f = 0 where T is a derivation operator have noticed that this Laplace transform, originally defined in some right half plane, has a meromorphic extension F to the complex plane. Knowledge of the set (z,),, of poles of F and of the set P, {l/(z - 2,)) of principal parts of F at once gives the solution f as a finite sum Pk(t) exp z,t. Using the same idea, we study convolution equations of the type p * f = 0, where p is a given complex valued Radon measure carried by a compact interval [a, b] of the line and f is an unknown complex valued continuous function on the line. A solution of this equation is called a mean periodic function. The main theorem is the following: to get all solutions of p * f = 0 it is sufficient to consider all solutions f of the type P(t) exp At, where P is a polynomial and A a complex number, all finite sums of these particular solutions and all limits of such finite sums for the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of the line. Similar results can be found in 11601.
,
I,,
9.2. The space V(R)
From now on, a function will be a complex valued continuous function on the line, without any growth condition at infinity; V(R) is the linear space of all such functions. The topology of V(R) is that of uniform convergence on compact subsets of R. A measure will be a complex valued Radon measure carried by a compact subset of the line. The linear space of such measures will be denoted by ?JJlo(R).Then ?JJl,(R) is the dual space of Q(R). A mean periodic function f is defined by one of the two equivalent properties : (a) f belongs to Q(R) and the vector space spanned by all translates off is not dense in the whole of V(R); (b) f is a solution of a convolution equation p * f = 0, where p belongs to ?JJl,(R). From our point of view it is more exciting to start with such a convolution equation and to regard f as an unknown function.
9.3. The Laplace transform off Following the engineers, we solve p * f = 0 by taking the Laplace transform off. We shall prove that this Laplace transform has a meromorphic extension F to the complex plane. The determination of the poles of F and of the principal parts of F at these poles will give the approximation Pk(t) exp zkt. off by sums In defining the Laplace transform off, the first idea is to consider the integral J," f(t) exp -zt dt. This is not satisfactory since a mean periodic function can have a very rapid growth at infinity (Section 9.14). Furthermore this integral does not furnish the meromorphic extension. Our definition o f F is more unnatural: let f +(t) = f(t) if t 3 0, f += 0 if t < 0, f -(t) = f(t) if t < 0 and f -(t) = 0 if t 0. Consider the element g of V(R) defined by g = f * ,u = -f - * p. The first definition of g shows that g is supported by [a, +a[and the second one that g is supported by ] - co,b] when f is supported by [a, b]. Hence we can define the Laplace transform of g, G(z) = j,b g(t) exp (-zt) dt; G is an entire function of exponential type. Let M(z) = S,b exp (-zt) dp (t).
XkyO
+
DEFINITION 4: The Laplace transform of the mean periodic function f is the meromorphic function F(z) = G(z)/M(z). To prove the consistency of this definition, we show that F is independent of the choice of p such that f * ,u = 0. Iff * p' = 0, p' E ?JJlo(R),we define g' = f * p' = -f- * p' and we have g' * p = g * p'; hence G'(z) M(z) = G(z) M1(z)and F(z) = F1(z). Iff has a Laplace transform in the ordinary sense in g e z > x,, this f ) equals F on 9Zez > x, . Laplace transform 9( In fact +
G(z)
=
S:
=
J a exp
g(t) exp - tz dt
-zsdp(s)
=
S.
g(t) exp - tz dt
J o ft(u)exp
-zudu
9.4. Our program is to determine f by means of the set of poles of F. We need the following theorem:
X: If the Laplace transform F of the mean periodic function f THEOREM is an entire function in the complex plane, then f = F = 0. Before proving this theorem, we note the following: an entire function can be the Laplace transform of a complex valued continuous function on the line, but not of a mean periodic function (mean periodic functions are very special continuous functions on the line). 9.5. The proof of Theorem X depends on a series of easy lemmas and on a deeper proposition. LEMMA18 : Let f be a mean periodic function and o an element of n o @ ) . Then the Laplace transform of the mean periodic function f * o and the product of the Laplace transform o f f with jRexp -zt do ( t ) difer by an entire function. Proof: We have f+ * o = ( f * o)+ + r, where r is a compactly supported bounded function. Assume that f * p = 0 and put g = f + * p, h = ( f * o)+ + p. Then g * o = h r * p, which gives G(z)S(z) = H(z) + R(z) M(z), where R(z) = jRexp ( - z t ) r(t) dt is an entire function. The Laplace transform off is G(z)/M(z)and that off * o is G(z) S(z)/M(z) - R(z), which completes the proof.
+
LEMMA19: Let p be a complex valued Radon measure carried by [a,b] and A a complex number such that j : exp -It dp ( t ) = 0. Then there is a complex valued function m with bounded variation on [a, b] which is 0 outside [a, b] and such that, for each complex z f 1,
J
a
exp (- zt)m ( t ) dt = -J e x p - ~ t d p ( t ) . z-1 0
Proof: Replacing dp ( t ) by exp (-1t)dp (t),m(t) by exp (-1t)m ( t ) and z - 1 by Z, we can assume that 1 = 0. We simply take m(s) = y-, dp (t). From now on we shall write p~c,instead of m(t) dt. LEMMA 20: With the hypothesis of Lemma 19, let f be a mean periodic function, F the Lapluce transform o f f and1 a complex number which is not a pole of F. Then f * p = 0 implies f * p, = 0. Proof: As in the proof of Lemma 19, we may restrict our attention to the case 1 = 0. Then using the notation of Lemma 19,f + m has a distri-
butional derivative equal to f * p = 0. Hence the continuous function f * m is equal to a constant a. If a = 0, the lemma is proved; if a f 0 , the Laplace transform off * m is alz Lemma 18 shows that 0 is a pole of F, which by hypothesis is not the case. 3 : Let p be an N-times dzTerentiable function carried by PROPOSITION be the sequence of all zeros of the entire function [a, b],N 2 4. Let (Ak)kaO M(z) = j!: exp ( - z t ) p ( t ) dt. There exist an integer n 2 0 and a complex constant c such that
where p, is dejined as in Lemma 19 and where the series is uniformly convergent on [a,b]. Proof: The idea is to take Fourier transforms of the two sides of (5.9) and to establish convergence in L1 (- co, + co) for these Fourier-transforms. Returning to the original functions, we obtain uniform convergence. First of all, let us write down the Laplace transform of each side of (5.9). We obtain
But (5.10) is a consequence of Hadamard's factorization of entire functions of exponential type: ~ ( z=) C e c Z z n n ?(1 - ~ 1 1 ~ taking ) ; the logarithmic derivatives we get (5.10) with uniform convergence on compact subsets of C. In proving convergence in L1 (- co, + oo) of the restrictions to the imaginary axis, the following lemma will be useful: LEMMA 20 : Let
We have for a constant C and all real y, ly( 2 1 ,
The sequence of zeros of an entire function of exponential type satisfies
1: 11k1-2< + oo ([16],th. 8.2, p. 328) and we have N > 4 (the value o f N is given by the regularity of p). Hence Lemma 20 gives Proposition 3. To prove Lemma 20 we have to consider three cases:
(a) lz - 1,1 > litk1/2implies IXk(z)l < 2/21 IM(z)l 14k(-2by the second form of X,; (b) llk1/2 2 lz - Akl > 1 implies IXk(z)l < 21zI2 IM(z)l lAkl-2, since bl 2 I&1/2; (c) if lz - A,[ < 1 and lil,l 3 2, then (M(z)/(z - ilk)( < sup 12'-11=
2
IM(z')/(z' - A,)], since M(z)/(z - A,) is an entire functicn. Hence (M(z')I, where we have here lz' - A,[ 3 1 SUP IX,(z)[ < 2 12'-zl= 2
and lz/Akl < 2 Iz/Ak12by the assumptions on z and 1,.But from a direct evaluation of M(z) = J,b exp -ztp (t) dt, we obtain IM(z)l < ~ e ~ ' l " l / ( z ( ~ , where z = x + iy. Substituting this estimate in the inequalities obtained in (a), (b), (c) we get (5.11) with perhaps another constant C. Note, finally, that if ]jlkl < 2 and lz - a,/ < 11,1/2 we get lzl < 3 and there is nothing to prove. 9.6. Proof of Theorem XI Assume that the Laplace transform off is an entire function and that f * p = 0; convolving this equation with a regular compactly supported function, it may be assumed that p is N-times continuously differentiable. Let (A,),,, be the sequence of zeros of M(z) = JR exp (-zt) p(t) dt. , 0 for all k 2 0. Lemma 20 shows that f + p ~ = By the uniform convergence of (5.9), we get f * (tp) = 0. Iterating this, we obtain f * (Pp) = 0 for all polynomials P. Let to be a real number such that p(to) # 0. Then the Dirac mass E,, concentrated in to is the limit of a sequence P,p in the weak-star topology a (%,(R), %(R)). Passing to the limit, we get f * = 0 and f = 0. 9.7. THEOREM XI: Let p be a complex valued Radon measure carried by a compact set of real numbers. The set of all solutions off * p = 0, where f is a complex valued continuousfunction on the line, is given by the following set of rules: (a) all solutions h of h * p = 0 of the type h(t) = P(t) exp At, where P is a polynomial and 1a complex number must be found; Pk(t)exp 1,t of solutionsfound in (a) must be (b) allfinite sums g = written, (c) all limits f of convergent sequencesgj, j 1 of solutionsfound in (b) must be taken where the topology is that of uniform convergence on compact subsets of the line.
I,,
Before giving the proof, a remark should be made. The degree m of P and the complex number 1concerned in (a) can be found as follows: 1is a zero of the entire function M(z) = jg exp -zt dp (t) and m is the multiplicity of this zero.
9.8. Now to the proof. Let E be the space of all functions g defined in (b); E and the closure E of Eare translation invariant; B i s determined by the following rule : the function h belongs to E if, for each v E %,(R) whose Laplace transform N(z) at least vanishes whenever the Laplace transform M(z) of p vanishes, the convolution h * v is identically 0. We have to prove that f belongs to $ and to this end we show that k = f * v is identically 0. This is the case if the Laplace transform K(z) of k is an entire function (Theorem X). By Lemma 18, K(z) - F(z) N(z) is an entire function. But, by definition (Section 9.3) of F(z), F(z) M(z) is an entire function. Since N(z) vanishes at least whenever M(z) vanishes, N(z)/M(z) is also entire. Hence K(z) is entire, k = 0 and f E l?.
9.9. The spectrum and the Fourier series of a mean periodic function Let f be a mean periodic function, F the Laplace transform off, (zj),> the sequence of poles of F, Pj (l/(z - z,)) the principal part of the expansion of F in a neighbourhood of zj and mj the multiplicity of the pole zj or the degree of P,. DEFINITION 4: With the above notation, putting zj = 2niAj, we define the spectrum off to be set of all pairs (4, mi), j > 1. DEFINITION 5: The Fourier series off is the formal series exp 2ni1,t. The argument used in Section 9.8 gives the following result:
Pj(t)
XII: For the topology of uniform convergence on compact THEOREM subsets of R, each mean periodic function is a limit of jinite sums fk(t) = PjSk(t)exp 2ni;lJt. The degree of P,,, equals the degree mj of P,, and the coefficients of Pi,, tend to those of Pj as k -+ + co. To prove this last remark, the following lemma will be needed:
zja
LEMMA 21 : Let A be the spectrum of a mean periodic function f and (fi),,, a sequence of mean periodic functions whose spectra lie in A and
9.11. It remains to study sets of zeros of entire functions of exponential type having a slow growth on the real axis. For a precise statement of Beurling-Malliavin's theorem, a new definition will be needed.
which converges to f uniformly on each compact set of real numbers. Then the Laplace transforms Fj offj tend to the Laplace transform F o f f in the following sense: on each compact subset K of complex numbers not containing a pole of F, Fj tends uniformly to F and if 1 is a pole of F of order m , then 1 is apole of F j of order < m and the coefficients of the Taylor expansion of F j in a neighbourhood of 1 tend to those of F. Proof: Let p be an element of '2R0(R) such that f * p = 0 and let M(z) = 1exp (- zt) dp (t). Let g = f * p, gj = f: * p, G(z) = j exp (- z t ) g(t) dt, Gj(z)= j exp ( - z t ) g j ( t ) dt. Thenfj * p = 0 since the spectrum of f, is contained in that off. The Laplace transform off is G(z)/M(z)and that off, is Gj(z)/M(z).The supports of gj are contained in a fixed interval [a, b] and gj tends to g uniformly on [a, b]. Hence Gj(z)-, G(z) uniformly on compact subsets of C, and lemma 21 is proved.
,
+
x,>
9.10. How to construct mean periodic functions? Let A be a sequence of pairs (A,, m k ) k a where A, E C and m k E N. Is it possible to construct a mean periodic function whose spectrum is A? Beurling and Malliavin [30]give a complete answer to this question. We shall state the results. The problem can be divided into two parts.
XIII: There is a mean periodic function whose spectrum is A if THEOREM and only if there is an entire non zero function A(z) defined in the complex plane and satisfying A(A) = 0 for each 1 E Aand IA(x)l < C ( 1 1 ~ 1 for ) ~ suitable C > 0 and N 0 ( x E R)
+
IA(z)l < C exp llzl for suitable C > 0 and I > 0 ( z E C ) . Proof: The condition is necessary. I f f is mean periodic there is a con?plex measure p carried by some compact interval such that p * f = 0. By definition of the spectrum A(z) = jR exp (-2nizt) dp ( t ) vanishes on A. We define the complex Fourier transform of a compactly supported distribution S on the line to be A(z) = JR exp (-2nizt) S ( t ) dt. The condition is sufficient. By Paley-Wiener's theorem, A is the complex Fourier-transform of a distribution S carried by [-I, I]. Convolving S with a suitable test function pl in 9 , we may assume that S is an element of 9 , not equal to 0, whose complex Fourier transform vanishes on A. It remains to construct f as a series 2: aktmkexp 2niAkt ( A = (A,, mk),>J, where a, > 0 tends to zero rapidly enough to ensure uniform convergence on compact subsets of R. Hence f * S = 0 and f is a mean periodic function.
6: The mean period associatedwith a setA ofpairs(A,, m,),, DEFINITION (A, E C , mk 2 0 ) is the infimum p(A) of lengths of intervals [a, b] such that there exists a non-zero complex Radon measure ,u carried by [a, b] whose complex Fourier-transform1 vanishes on A. Remark 1 : I f [a, b] is an interval whose length is less than p(A), each complex valued continuous function defined on [a, b] is the limit of a sePk(t)exp 2niAkt, where dOPk< mk quence of finite sums Proof: Apply the Hahn-Banach theorem. Remark 2 : If [a, b] is an interval whose length is greater than p(A), each mean periodic function f whose spectrum lies in A and which vanishes on [a, b] vanishes on the whole real line. Proof: Let p be a measure carried by [a', b'], b' - a' < b - a, such that the complex Fourier-transform of p vanishes on A. The problem is clearly translation invariant and so we may assume that a = 0 Let f be defined by f + ( t ) = f ( t ) if t >, 0 and f + ( t )= 0 if t < 0. Sincef vanishes on [0, b] and since p is carried by [a', b'] whose length is less than b, f * p = f * ,u = 0. Using the definition of the Laplace transform F off, we get F = 0. Hence f = 0 by Theorem I. As a corollary we have that any mean periodic function whose spectrum lies in A is fully determined by its values on a compact subset depending only on A. It is interesting to compute the length of such an interval of defin~tion.Beurling and Malliavin's theorem gives the exact value of this length in terms of the exterior density of A, which we shall now define.
I
+
+
9.1 2. A density due to Beurling and Malliavin Let Q be a set of open intervals on the line (the notation o E 0 denotes intervals of this set), and let T(Q) be the union of all squares T ( w ) of R 2 one of whose diagonals is on w E Q : if x is the middle point of cu and 21 the J X - xl < 1. length of o, T ( o ) is defined by I YI A set 0 of intervals is said to be negligable if ( 1 + x2 + y2)-I dx dy < + co. (Note that for any set of open intervals, T(Q) is an open set of squares and is a measurable set.)
+
The complex Fourier-transform of ,u is 9: C -t C defined by P(z) = J: exp - 2nizt d~
w.
For example, if there is an I > 0 such that the lengths of the o E Dare all less than I, 9 is negligable. Roughly speaking, 2 ! is negligable means that it is improbable that 9 contains arbitrarily large intervals. A complex valued (not necessarily bounded) Radon measure p on the real line is said to be regular and has the density a if, for each positive E, the set 9,of all open intervals o of length lo1 such that llwl-l jm dp - a1 2 E is a negligable set of intervals. We then write a = A (dp). To each setA of pairs (A,, mk)kzl of real numbers together with multiplicities, we attach a positive measure dNAdefined by m, 6 (x - A,), where 6(x) is the unit mass concentrated in 0 and we assume that k -+ A, is an injective map.
C,,,
7 : The exterior density ofA, d,(A) is inf ( A (dv)) over regular DEFINITION positive measures dv such that dv 2 dNA. THEOREM XIV: With the above notation, (1) The set A of pairs (A,, m,),, is the set of frequencies of a mean periodic function f(t) on the line if and only ifd,(A) isfinite; (2) The mean period associated with A is d,(A). The proof of this result is deep and difficult. Since this theorem will not be used in the sequel, the reader is referred to [30]. An easy corollary can be given. We recall that a set A of real numbers is called regular if there exists a d > 0 such that each interval of length d contains at most one point o f A and a D > 0 such that each interval of length D contains at least one point ofA.
,
4: For a regular A, the mean period p(A) of A lies in the COROLLARY interual [ l / D , 1Id]. Proof: Consider R as the union of all intervals [kd, (k + 1) d[, k E Z and construct a measure dv as follows: if [kd, (k + 1) d[ n A = {A}, unit mass is concentrated in L and if [kd, (k + 1) d[ does not intersect A, unit mass is concentrated in kd. Hence dv 2-dNAand dv is regular and has the density lld. We thus obtain p(A) < lld. To get p(A) 2 1ID, we merely apply Theorem 111. 9.13. Mean periodic functions whose spectra are contained in a given A
From now on, A is assumed to be uniformly discrete, i.e. there exists a d > 0 such that each interval of length d contains at most one point ofA. We assume also that A does not present multiplicity (all m, = 0).
is then the Frechet space of all mean periodic functions whose spectra lie in A ; the topology V is that of uniform convergence on compact sets of real numbers. It is remarkable that the vector space of all mean periodic functions is not complete in the topology V ; the vector space of all mean periodic functions whose spectra are contained in a given A for whichp(A) < co is complete for %? since there exists a fixed measure ,u with compact support such that ,u * f = 0 for all such$
+
9.14. Behaviour at infinity
All f in V Aare fully determined by their values on any interval I whose 1 1exceeds p(A). The fundamental problem is now the following: length 1 is there a method of computing or estimating the values off outside I in terms of the values taken by f on I ? The answer is given by the following theorem:
+
XV: Let o : R -, [l, co [ be a function andA a regular set of THEOREM real numbers: each interval of length d contains at most one point ofA and each interval of length D contains at least one point of A. The following assertions are equivalent: (a) each mean periodic function f whose spectrum lies in A is 0 (o(t)) a s It( tends to in$nity; (b) there exist a constant C and a compact set K of real numbers such that, for each mean periodic function f whose spectrum lies in A and for all real t, If @)I < Cw (t) sup If I. K
Proof: Let ~?8be the Banach space of all complex valued continuous functions which are 0 ( ~ ( t ) as ) It( -t co.The norm of such an f in is sup Iw-lf 1. Let I: V A-+ LA? be the injection defined by (a). The topology
+
R
of W A is defined by the fundamental sequence of neighbourhoods of 0, V , = { f E V A: sup If 1 < 2-,}. The closed graph theorem shows that I C-f,kl
is continuous. Hence the inverse image under I of the unit ball of 9 contains a V , for sufficiently large k and this gives (b). The converse implication is trivial. Example: Let 8 > 2 be a real number and A, the set of all finite sums &,Ok,E , = 0 or 1. If 8 is a Pisot number, all mean periodic functions whose spectra lie in A, are almost periodic functions as we shall prove later. If 8 is not a Pisot number, mean periodic functions whose spectra lie in A, are known as soon as they are known on an arbitrarily small
interval [0, I] but it is impossible to give estimates for these functions in terms of their values on a compact set of real numbers. To substantiate these two remarks, two observations can be made: (a) if 8 > 2 each interval [x - T, x + TI of real numbers contains o(T) elements ofA and the little o is uniform with respect to x ; (b) there exists1 a sequence P,(t) of finite trigonometric sums whose frequencies belong to A such that P,(O) = sup IPk(t)l = 1 while P, tends R
uniformly to 0 on each compact set of real numbers not containing 0. Assertion (b) in Theorem XV cannot be true, since for s 4 K, t -+ P, (t - s) converges uniformly to 0 on K and takes the value 1 at s. THEOREM XVI: Let A be a regular set of real numbers. The following three assertions are equivalent: (a) each mean periodic function whose spectrum lies in A is bounded; (b) each mean periodic function whose spectrum lies in A is almost periodic; (c) A is a coherent set of frequencies. Proof: (a) * (c) by Theorem XV. Since trigonometric sums are dense in VA for the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets of real numbers (Theorem XII) and since by (c) this topology is equivalent to that of uniform convergence on the whole real line, each mean periodic function in VA is almost periodic. Hence (c) * (b). It is obvious that tb) =, (a).
Then A is the Fourier transform of a positive function b which is 0 ( r 2 ) as Proof of: rT
Let I > 0 be such that inf b(t)
> B > 0 (if E 6 1/4d, such an lexists).
c-1,ll
Then Parseval's equality gives l/b~11;= I&eA aAA(x - A)I2 dx = ll All: I r o n lan12.Hence 2 jk1 IP(t)I2 dt 6 11~112 laAI2.Since the space of trigonometric sums is translation-invariant, we get, for each k E Z, e2 jI::-f::: IP(t)12 dt 6 ~ ~ A I I : laAI2and adding a sufficiently large number of these relations we get (5.12). Proof of:
xleA
xAeA
c1AeA Z Ian126
-T
IP(t)12 dt.
:::
Eke,
(5.13)
2
We start as before with I ~ ~$ P =I I j$i+ b2(t) IP(t)I2 dt = /[A11 la,12. Since b(t) is ~(t-') as it1 + +a, 11b~11226 jTTb2(t) 1p(t)l2dt T-lC, @ ' , lai12 (using 5.12). Since b(t) 6 1/2d, we get I?, IP(t)12dt > 4d2 (llA112 - T I C 3 ) lanI2.If Tis large enough, (5.13) is proved. Notice that the L2 theory is easy and has a metric form while the L" theory (equivalence between sup If 1 and sup If I) is deep and is connected x A E A
+
rneA C-T,TI
R
with the arithmetical structure ofA.
9.15. The L2 theory We say that a set A of real numbers is uniformly discrete if there exists a d > 0 such that the distance between any two distinct points inA exceeds d. THEOREM XVII : There exist a T > 0 and