This page intentionally left blank
An Introduction to Involutive Structures Detailing the main methods in the theory ...
26 downloads
1135 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
An Introduction to Involutive Structures Detailing the main methods in the theory of involutive systems of complex vector fields, this book examines the major results from the last 25 years in the subject. One of the key tools of the subject – the Baouendi–Treves approximation theorem – is proved for many function spaces. This in turn is applied to questions in partial differential equations and several complex variables. Many basic problems such as regularity, unique continuation and boundary behavior of the solutions are explored. The local solvability of systems of partial differential equations is studied in some detail. The book provides a solid background for beginners in the field and also contains a treatment of many recent results which will be of interest to researchers in the subject. Shi feraw Berha n u is a Professor of Mathematics at Temple University in the US. Pau lo D. Corda r o is a Professor of Mathematics in the Institute of Mathematics and Statistics at the University of São Paulo in Brazil. Jorge Hounie is a Professor of Mathematics at the Federal University of São Carlos in Brazil.
NEW MATHEMATICAL MONOGRAPHS Editorial Board Béla Bollobás William Fulton Frances Kirwan Peter Sarnak Barry Simon Burt Totaro For information about Cambridge University Press mathematics publications visit http://www.cambridge.org/mathematics
An Introduction to Involutive Structures SHIFERAW BERHANU Temple University PAULO D. CORDARO University of São Paulo JORGE HOUNIE Federal University of São Carlos
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521878579 © S. Berhanu, P. Cordaro and J. Hounie 2008 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2008
ISBN-13 978-0-511-38814-9
eBook (NetLibrary)
ISBN-13
hardback
978-0-521-87857-9
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
Preface I
page ix
Locally integrable structures I.1 Complex vector fields I.2 The algebraic structure of X I.3 Formally integrable structures I.4 Differential forms I.5 The Frobenius theorem I.6 Analytic structures I.7 The characteristic set I.8 Some special structures I.9 Locally integrable structures I.10 Local generators I.11 Local generators in analytic structures I.12 Integrability of complex and elliptic structures I.13 Elliptic structures in the real plane I.14 Compatible submanifolds I.15 Locally integrable CR structures I.16 A CR structure that is not locally integrable I.17 The Levi form on a formally integrable structure Appendix: Proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem Notes
II The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula II.1 The approximation theorem II.2 Distribution solutions II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces II.4 Applications Notes v
1 1 4 5 7 11 14 15 15 19 21 25 26 28 32 36 38 42 47 51 52 52 63 69 83 99
vi III
Contents Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation III.1 Sussmann’s orbits III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation III.3 The strong uniqueness property for locally integrable solutions III.4 Proof of Theorem III.3.15 III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions III.6 Real-analytic structures in the plane III.7 Further applications of Sussmann’s orbits Notes
IV Local IV.1 IV.2 IV.3 IV.4
solvability of vector fields Planar vector fields Solvability in C Vector fields in several variables Necessary conditions for local solvability Notes
V The FBI transform and some applications V.1 Certain submanifolds of hypoanalytic manifolds V.2 Microlocal analyticity and the FBI transform V.3 Microlocal smoothness V.4 Microlocal hypoanalyticity and the FBI transform V.5 Application of the FBI transform to the C wave front set of solutions of nonlinear PDEs V.6 Applications to edge-of-the-wedge theory V.7 Application to the F. and M. Riesz theorem Notes VI Some VI.1 VI.2 VI.3 VI.4
boundary properties of solutions Existence of a boundary value Pointwise convergence to the boundary value One-sided local solvability in the plane The H p property for vector fields Notes
VII The differential complex associated with a formally integrable structure VII.1 The exterior derivative VII.2 The local representation of the exterior derivative VII.3 The Poincaré Lemma VII.4 The differential complex associated with a formally integrable structure
101 101 108 120 126 132 140 146 147 149 150 176 184 199 214 218 218 226 236 239 243 254 263 270 271 271 281 286 289 307 308 308 309 311 311
Contents VII.5 VII.6 VII.7 VII.8 VII.9 VII.10 VII.11 VII.12 VII.13
Localization Germ solvability -cohomology and local solvability The Approximate Poincaré Lemma One-sided solvability Localization near a point at the boundary One-sided approximation A Mayer–Vietoris argument Local solvability versus local integrability Notes
vii 312 313 315 316 319 321 322 323 328 330
VIII Local solvability in locally integrable structures VIII.1 Local solvability in essentially real structures VIII.2 Local solvability in the analytic category VIII.3 Elliptic structures VIII.4 The Box operator associated with D VIII.5 The intersection number VIII.6 The intersection number under certain geometrical assumptions VIII.7 A necessary condition for one-sided solvability VIII.8 The sufficiency of condition 0 VIII.9 Proof of Proposition VIII.8.2 VIII.10 Solvability for corank one analytic structures Notes
331 332 332 333 337 340
Epilogue 1 The similarity principle and applications 2 Mizohata structures 3 Hypoanalytic structures 4 The local model for a hypoanalytic manifold 5 The sheaf of hyperfunction solutions on a hypoanalytic manifold
361 361 364 370 371
Appendix A Hardy space lemmas A.1 Multipliers in h1 A.2 Commutators A.3 Change of variables
374 374 376 378
Bibliography
381
Index
390
343 346 348 350 354 357
372
Preface
Since the first systematic exposition of the theory of involutive systems of vector fields ([T5]) was published almost 15 years ago, the subject has undergone considerable development and many new applications have been found. Systems of vector fields arise as a local basis of an involutive sub-bundle of the complexified tangent bundle CT . Involutivity of means that the commutation bracket of two smooth sections of must also be a section of . Examples of involutive structures include foliations, complex structures, and CR structures. In these examples, ∩ has constant rank. However, in recent work on integral geometry, natural examples of involutive structures have arisen for which the rank of ∩ changes from point to point ([BE], [BEGM], and [EG1]). In the works [BE] and [BEGM], the cohomology of involutive structures is a key ingredient. Examples of involutive structures where the rank of ∩ is not constant also arise naturally, for instance, on the tangent bundle of symmetric spaces (see [Sz] and the references therein) or in the study of the generalized similarity principle for the equation Lu = Au + Bu where L is a planar complex vector field not necessarily elliptic, which is intimately linked to the study of infinitesimal deformations of surfaces in R3 with non-negative curvature (see [Me3], [Me4], and the references therein). This book introduces the reader to a number of results on systems of vector fields with complex-valued coefficients defined on a smooth manifold . Most of the time, it will be assumed that the involutive structure is locally integrable. The latter means that the orthogonal of , which is a subbundle T of the complexified cotangent bundle CT ∗ , is locally generated by exact differentials. When is locally integrable, each point has a neighborhood U such that if L1 Ln are n smooth vector fields that form ix
x
Preface
a basis of over U , then we can find m = dim −n smooth, complex-valued functions Z1 Zm which are solutions of the equations Lj h = 0
1≤j≤n
(1)
and whose differentials are linearly independent over C at each point of U . The m functions Z = Z1 Zm are sometimes referred to as a complete set of first integrals in the neighborhood U . In 1981, in [BT1], Baouendi and Treves proved that in a locally integrable structure, each solution of (1) can be locally approximated by a sequence Pk Z where the Pk are holomorphic polynomials of m variables and Z = Z1 Zm is a complete set of first integrals. This approximation theorem has enabled several researchers to use the methods of complex analysis, harmonic analysis, and partial differential equations to study many problems on locally integrable structures. These problems include: the local and microlocal regularity of the solutions of (1); the determination of sets of uniqueness for solutions of (1); the solvability of the differential complex associated with the structure ; and many other properties of the solutions of (1). This book attempts to present a systematic treatment of some of these results in a way that is accessible to graduate students with a background in real analysis, one complex variable, and basic introductions to several complex variables and linear PDEs including the theory of distributions. Chapter I introduces the basic concepts in the theory of involutive and locally integrable structures. Special classes of involutive structures such as complex structures, CR structures, elliptic structures, and real analytic structures are identified and examples are provided. Useful local representations both for general involutive and locally integrable structures are also discussed. A proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem is presented in the appendix to Chapter I. Chapter II is devoted to the approximation theorem of Baouendi and Treves. It is shown that the approximation is valid in many function spaces used in analysis: the Lebesgue spaces Lp 1 ≤ p < ; Sobolev spaces; Hölder spaces; and localizable Hardy spaces hp 0 < p < . Applications to uniqueness in the Cauchy problem and extendability of CR functions are also included. Chapter III presents a variety of results on unique continuation for solutions and approximate solutions in a locally integrable structure . The orbits of Sussmann associated with the real parts RL of the smooth sections of play a crucial role in many problems, including the study of unique continuation and the chapter includes a discussion of some of the properties of these orbits. Chapter IV provides a detailed treatment of locally solvable vector fields. In the first part of the chapter, where the focus is on
Preface
xi
planar vector fields, the solvability condition of Nirenberg and Treves is discussed and a priori estimates are proved in Lp and in a mixed norm that involves the Hardy space h1 R. A duality argument is then used to derive local solvability results in Lp 1 < p < and in L R bmoR . The chapter also includes sections on the sufficiency and necessity of condition for local solvability in higher dimensions. The first part of Chapter V introduces certain submanifolds in an involutive structure which are important in the study of solutions. These submanifolds are generalizations of the totally real and generic CR submanifolds encountered in CR manifolds. The second part of the chapter introduces the FBI transform first in Rn and then in a locally integrable structure. The FBI transform is then applied to derive edge-of-thewedge type results. It is also applied to study the microlocal singularities of the solutions of a first-order nonlinear PDE and a generalization of the F. and M. Riesz theorem. Chapter VI studies some boundary properties of the solutions of locally integrable vector fields. These properties include the existence of a trace at the boundary, pointwise convergence of solutions to their boundary values, and the validity of Hardy space-like properties. Chapter VII describes the differential complex attached to a general involutive structure. An invariant definition of this complex is followed by a useful representation in appropriate coordinates. An approximate Poincaré Lemma for locally integrable structures is also proved in the chapter. Chapter VIII deals with the local solvability theory of the undetermined systems of partial differential equations naturally associated with a locally integrable structure, that is, the cohomology theory of its differential complex. Necessary and sufficient conditions are studied in some detail when the structure is analytic, or elliptic, or has corank one. Concerning the latter class, a thorough exposition of the geometric characterization of local solvability in degree one for real analytic structures is presented. Finally we conclude with an epilogue which summarizes some of the results obtained in recent years on diverse areas such as the similarity principle, Mizohata structures, and hyperfunction solutions in hypoanalytic manifolds. Two applications of the similarity principle are described. The first application concerns uniqueness in the Cauchy problem for a class of semilinear equations. The second application involves the theory of bending of surfaces. There are numerous interesting results on complex vector fields and involutive structures that have been obtained since the publication of [BT1] and which are not covered in this book. The authors have selected the material with which they have had first-hand experience. In the notes at the end of each chapter, we indicate some related works and provide additional references.
xii
Preface
The reader is referred to [BER] for a further reference on CR manifolds and to [T5] for additional topics on involutive structures. We are grateful to Elisandra Bär, Sagun Chanillo, Nicholas Hanges, Gustavo Hoepfner, and Gerson Petronilho for reading parts of the manuscript, pointing out errors and suggesting improvements. We are also grateful to Peter Thompson of Cambridge University Press for the expedience with which our book has been handled.
I Locally integrable structures
In this chapter we introduce the main concepts which will be studied throughout the book. In order to do so we recall some standard notions such as differentiable manifolds, vector fields, differential forms, etc., with the purpose mainly of laying down the basis for the presentation and to establish the notations. Nevertheless, we assume from the reader some familiarity with these concepts. In particular, we freely use some standard results on complex vector fields and complex differential forms on RN .
I.1 Complex vector fields Let be a Hausdorff topological space, with a countable basis of open sets. A differentiable structure over of dimension N is a collection of pairs = U x , where U ⊂ is a nonempty open set, x U −→ RN is a homeomorphism onto an open subset xU of RN and the following properties are satisfied: (1)
Ux∈
U = ; x x−1
(2) xU ∩ U −→ x U ∩ U is C for each pair U x, U x ∈ with U ∩ U = ∅; (3) is maximal with respect to (1) and (2), that is, if ∅ = V ⊂ is open and y V −→ yV is a homeomorphism over an open subset of RN such y x−1
that, for any U x ∈ with U ∩ V = ∅, the composition xU ∩ V −→ yU ∩ V is C , then V y ∈ . 1
2
Locally integrable structures
It is easy to see that given any family ∗ = U x as above satisfying (1) and (2) there is a unique differentiable structure over , of dimension N , such that ∗ ⊂ . Definition I.1.1. A differentiable manifold (or smooth manifold) of dimension N is a Hausdorff topological space , with a countable basis equipped with a differentiable structure of dimension N . If, in the above definitions, we replace C by real-analytic we obtain the concept of a real-analytic manifold of dimension N . We give some examples: (1) = RN , ∗ = RN identity map . (2) Let be a differentiable manifold of dimension N and let W ⊂ be open. Then over W is defined a natural differentiable structure of dimension N , which is given by W = W ∩ U x W ∩U U x ∈ W ∩ U = ∅ (3) Let f RN +1 → R be a C function. Let = x ∈ RN +1 fx = 0 and suppose that dfx = 0, ∀x ∈ . Then a natural differentiable structure of dimension N is defined over (as a consequence of the implicit function theorem). Notation. An element U x ∈ will be refered to as a local chart or as a local system of coordinates. If we write x = x1 xN then for p ∈ U its local coordinates (with respect to this given local chart) are given by x1 p xN p. From now on, unless otherwise stated, we shall fix a differentiable manifold (of dimension N ). We shall say that a function f → C is smooth if for every U x ∈ the composition f x−1 is C on xU.1 We shall denote by C the set of all smooth functions on . We observe that C is an algebra over C which contains, as an R-subalgebra, the set C R of all smooth functions on which are real-valued. Definition I.1.2. A (smooth) complex vector field over is a C-linear map L C −→ C 1
More generally, we say that a function f → C is C k (k ≥ 0) if for every U x ∈ the composition f x−1 is C k on xU.
I.1 Complex vector fields
3
which satisfies the Leibniz rule Lfg = fLg + gLf
f g ∈ C
(I.1)
We shall denote by X the set of all complex vector fields over . Proposition I.1.3. If L ∈ X and if f is constant then Lf = 0. We also have supp Lf ⊂ supp f
∀f ∈ C L ∈ X
(I.2)
Proof. For the first statement it suffices to show that L1 = 0 and this follows from (I.1) together with the fact that 12 = 1. We shall now prove (I.2); we must show that if f vanishes on an open set V ⊂ then the same is true for Lf . Let p ∈ V be arbitrary. We select a local chart U x with p ∈ U ⊂ V and take ∈ Cc xU such that xp = 1. Then the function g → R defined by the rule xq if q ∈ U gq = 0 if q ∈ U belongs to C R and vanishes on \V . In particular, f = 1 − gf and then Lfp = 1 − gpLfp + fpL1 − gp = 0 since gp = 1. A consequence of the preceding result is the possibility of defining the restriction of an element L ∈ X to an open subset W of . More precisely, there is a C-linear map X L −→ LW ∈ XW which turns the diagram L
C −→ C ↓ ↓ LW
C W −→ C W commutative (the vertical arrows denote the restriction map). Indeed, if p ∈ W and f ∈ C W we set LW fp = Lf˜ p
4
Locally integrable structures
where f˜ is any element in C which coincides with f in a neighborhood of p. Such a definition is meaningful according to Proposition I.1.3 and it is very easy to check that LW defines an element in XW. As usual we shall write L instead of LW , since the meaning will always be clear from the context.
I.2 The algebraic structure of X Given g ∈ C and L ∈ X we can define gL ∈ X by gLf = g · Lf
f ∈ C
Such external multiplication gives X the structure of a C -module. A very important (internal) operation in X is the so-called Lie bracket (or commutator) between two vector fields. Given L M ∈ X we define
L M f = L Mf − M Lf
f ∈ C
(I.3)
It is a simple verification to check that L M ∈ X. This bracket operation turns X into a Lie algebra2 over C. Let U x be a local chart in and let also L ∈ XU. We fix p ∈ U and write as before xq = x1 q xN q
q ∈ U
Next we take V ⊂ U open such that xV is an open ball centered at xp = a = a1 aN . Given f ∈ C U, write f ∗ = f x−1 . If x1 xN ∈ xV, the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus applied to the function t → f ∗ a1 + tx1 − a1 aN + txN − aN gives f ∗ x1 xN = f ∗ a1 aN +
N
hj x1 xN xj − aj
j=1
where hj ∈ C xV and hj a = f ∗ /xj a. If we further set gj = hj x ∈ C V, we obtain fq = fp +
N
gj qxj q − xj p
q ∈ V
(I.4)
j=1
2
Recall that a Lie algebra over C is a C-vector space E over which is defined a bilinear form E × E v w → v w which satisfies
u u = 0
u v w + v w u + w u v = 0
u v w ∈ E
I.3 Formally integrable structures
5
and consequently the Leibniz rule gives Lf p =
N
gj p Lxj p
(I.5)
j=1
Definition I.2.1. The C-linear map C U → C U given by f →
f ∗
x xj
defines an element in XU, which will be denoted by
. xj
Returning to the preceding argument and notation we can write f ∗ f p xp = gj p = hj xp = xj xj Inserting this in (I.5) gives Lfp =
N
Lxj p
j=1
xj
f p
since p was an arbitrary point taken in U we obtain the representation of L in the local coordinates x1 xN : L=
N
Lxj
j=1
xj
(I.6)
In particular this representation shows that the C U-module XU is free, with basis /x1 /xN . Observe that if M ∈ XU then the representation of L M in the local coordinates x1 xN is given by
L M =
N
xj
LMxj − MLxj
j=1
(I.7)
I.3 Formally integrable structures Denote by p the set of all pairs V f, where V is an open neighborhood of p and f ∈ C V. In p we introduce the following equivalence relation: V1 f1 ∼ V2 f2 if there is an open neighborhood V of p, V ⊂ V1 ∩ V2 , such that f1 and f2 agree on V . A germ of a C function at p is an element in the quotient space C p = p / ∼. We observe that C p is also a C-algebra. Given a C function f
6
Locally integrable structures
defined in an open neighborhood of p, the germ at p defined by f will be denoted by f . Notice that there is a natural C-algebra homomorphism C p → C defined by f → fp. Definition I.3.1. A complex tangent vector (to ) at p is a C-linear map v C p −→ C satisfying vf g = fpvg + gpvf
f g ∈ C p
(I.8)
The set of all complex tangent vectors at p, denoted by CTp , has a structure of a C-vector space and is called the complex tangent space to at p. If L ∈ X then Lp C p → C defined by Lp f = Lfp
f ∈ C p
belongs to CTp . Conversely, suppose that for each p ∈ an element vp ∈ CTp is given such that p → vp f ∈ C
∀f ∈ C
Then there is L ∈ X such that Lp = vp for all p ∈ . Suppose now that p ∈ U and that U x is a local chart. If v ∈ CTp then, according to (I.5), N N f f ∈ C p vf = gj pvxj = vxj x j p j=1 j=1 In particular we conclude that x p j = 1 N is a basis of CTp . j The complexified tangent bundle of is defined as the disjoint union CTp CT = p∈
We shall also need the notion of a complex vector sub-bundle of CT of rank n and corank N − n. By this we mean a disjoint union = p ⊂ CT p∈
satisfying the following conditions: (a) For each p ∈ , p is a vector subspace of CTp of dimension n. (b) Given p0 ∈ there are an open set U0 containing p0 and vector fields L1 Ln ∈ XU0 such that L1p Lnp span p for every p ∈ U0 . The vector space p is called the fiber of at p.
I.4 Differential forms
7
Given a complex vector sub-bundle of CT and an open subset W of , a section of over W is an element L of XW such that Lp ∈ p for all p ∈ W . We are now in a position to introduce our main object of study: Definition I.3.2. A formally integrable structure over is a complex vector sub-bundle of CT satisfying the involutive (or Frobenius) condition: • If W ⊂ is open and L M ∈ XW are sections of over W then L M is also a section of over W . The rank (resp. corank) of will be referred to as the rank (resp. corank) of the formally integrable structure . Let be a formally integrable structure over and fix p ∈ . There is a local chart U x with p ∈ U and vector fields L1 Ln ∈ XU such that L1q Lnq is a basis of q for every q ∈ U . If we write x = x1 xN and Lj =
N
ajk x
k=1
xk
then the matrix ajk has rank equal to n at every point; moreover, there are cjk ∈ C U, j k = 1 n, such that
Lj Lk =
n
cjk L
j k = 1 n
=1
Definition I.3.3. A (classical) solution for the formally integrable structure over is a C 1 -function u on such that Lu = 0 for every section L of defined in an open subset of . More generally, we can consider the concept of (weak) solutions for the formally integrable structure over : it suffices to consider u, in the preceding definition, belonging to the space of distributions on (we refer to [H2] for the theory of distributions on manifolds).
I.4 Differential forms We shall denote by N the dual of the C -module X and shall refer to its elements as differential forms over of degree one (or one-forms for short). In other words, a one-form on is a C -linear map X → C
8
Locally integrable structures
Let ∈ N, L ∈ X and suppose that L vanishes on an open subset V ⊂ . Then L also vanishes on V . Indeed, let p ∈ V and let g ∈ C R be equal to one at p and vanish on \V . Then L = 1 − gL and consequently L = 1 − gL vanishes at p. In fact, we have a more precise result: Lemma I.4.1. Let ∈ N, L ∈ X and suppose that Lp = 0. Then Lp = 0. Proof. By the preceding discussion it is clear that we can restrict a one-form on to an open set W ⊂ , that is, given ∈ N there is W ∈ NW which makes the diagram
X −→ C ↓ ↓ W
XW −→ C W commutative (the vertical arrows denote restriction homomorphisms). Let then U x be a local chart with p ∈ U . Then, if x = x1 xN we have by (I.6) N p = 0 Lp = U LU p = Lxj pU xj j=1 The proof of Lemma I.4.1 is complete. If we then define CTp∗ = dual of CTp to each ∈ N we can associate an element p ∈ CTp∗ by the formula p v = Lp where L ∈ X is such that Lp = v. As in the case for vector fields, we have a converse: if for every p ∈ an element p ∈ CTp∗ is given such that p → p Lp ∈ C
∀ L ∈ X
then there is ∈ N such that p = p , for every p ∈ . Proposition I.4.2. CTp∗ = p ∈ N . Proof. Let U x be a local chart with p ∈ U . Formula (I.6) allows one to define dxj ∈ NU, j = 1 N , by the rule
I.4 Differential forms dxj
xk
9
= jk
j k = 1 N
Hence, if ∈ NU we have =
N
j=1
xj
dxj
(I.9)
where /xj ∈ C U. If we now observe that dxj p ⊂ CTp∗ is the dual basis of /xj p ⊂ CTp then the conclusion will follow easily. Definition I.4.3. Given f ∈ C we define df ∈ N by the formula dfL = Lf
L ∈ X
(I.10)
From (I.9) we obtain the usual representation in local coordinates N N f dxj = dxj df = df x x j j j=1 j=1 We now introduce the complexified cotangent bundle of as being the disjoint union CT ∗ = CTp∗ p∈
As before we can also introduce the notion of a complex vector sub-bundle of CT ∗ of rank m as being a disjoint union p = p∈
where each p is a vector subspace of CTp∗ of dimension m, satisfying the following property: • Given p0 ∈ there are an open set U0 containing p0 and one-forms 1 m ∈ NU0 such that 1p mp span p for every p ∈ U0 . As before we shall refer to the space p as the fiber of at the point p. Proposition I.4.4. Let = ∪p∈ p be a complex vector sub-bundle of CT and set, for each p ∈ , p⊥ = ∈ CTp∗ = 0 on p Then ⊥ = ∪p∈ p⊥ is a complex vector sub-bundle of CT ∗ .
10
Locally integrable structures
Proof. Given p0 ∈ there is a local chart x = x1 xN
U0 x
with p0 ∈ U0 , and vector fields on U0 Lj =
N
ajk
k=1
xk
j = 1 n
such that L1p Lnp spans p for all p ∈ U0 . After a contraction of U0 around p0 and a relabeling of the indices we can assume that the matrix ajk jk=1n is invertible in U0 . Let bjk jk=1n be its inverse and set L#j =
n
bj L
j = 1 n
=1
Then L#1p L#np also spans p for all p ∈ U0 . Moreover, we have L#j =
m + cjk xj k=1 xn+k
j = 1 n
where cjk are smooth in U0 and m = N − n. Set = dxn+ −
n
c dx
= 1 m
=1
Then 1p mp are linearly independent for all p ∈ U0 and furthermore L#j = dxn+ L#j − cj = 0 Hence 1p mp is a basis for p⊥ for each p ∈ U0 . Remark I.4.5. It is clear that the preceding argument can be reversed. If ⊥ is a vector sub-bundle of CT ∗ then it follows that is a vector sub-bundle of . When is a formally integrable structure over of dimension N we shall always denote the sub-bundle ⊥ by T . We shall also always denote by n the rank of and by m the rank of T . In particular, n + m = N . We shall also use the standard notation: Tp = v ∈ CTp v is real Tp∗ = ∈ CTp∗ is real
I.5 The Frobenius theorem
11
T = Tp p∈
∗ T ∗ = Tp p∈
Given L ∈ X its (complex)-conjugate is the vector field L ∈ X defined by Lf = Lf
f ∈ C
In particular we shall say that L is a real vector field if L = L, that is, if LC R ⊂ C R. In the same way we can define the (complex)conjugate of an element in CTp . Given a subspace p ⊂ CTp we define p = v v ∈ p It is clear from the definitions that if is a complex vector sub-bundle of CT then the same is true for = ∪p∈ p . We shall refer to as the (complex)-conjugate of the sub-bundle . Analogous definitions and results can be introduced and obtained for CT ∗ and its fibers CTp∗ . It is also important to mention the equality ⊥
= ⊥ which is valid for every complex vector sub-bundle of CT.
I.5 The Frobenius theorem We start by considering a real vector field L=
N j=1
aj x
xj
defined in a neighborhood of the origin in RN . Assume that L = 0. Then it is possible to find local coordinates y1 y2 yN , defined near the origin, such that L= y1 The proof of this result is very simple and will be recalled here. We assume that a1 0 = 0 and solve, in some neighborhood of the origin, the following Cauchy problem: ⎧ ⎨ xj /y1 = aj x1 xN j = 1 N x 0 y2 yN = 0 ⎩ 1 xj 0 y2 yN = yj j = 2 N
12
Locally integrable structures
The fact that a1 0 = 0 implies that y1 yN → x1 xN is a smooth diffeomorphism at the origin and a simple computation shows our claim. The generalization of this result to a larger number of vector fields is the classical Frobenius theorem: Theorem I.5.1. Let L1 Ln be linearly independent, real vector fields defined in a neighborhood V of the origin in RN . Assume that the sub-bundle of CTV generated by L1 Ln is a formally integrable structure. Then there are local coordinates y1 y2 yN , defined near the origin, such that is generated by /y1 ,…, /yn . Proof. We shall proceed by induction on N . The case N = 1 is trivial. We then suppose that the result was proved for values < N . Applying the procedure described at the beginning of this section we can make a change of variables and assume that the given vector fields have the form: L1 =
N Lj = ajk j = 2 n x1 xk k=1
We then introduce a new set of generators for the bundle : L#1 = L1 L#j = Lj − aj1 L1 j = 2 n Notice that when j ≥ 2 the vector field L#j does not involve differentiation in the x1 -variable. Thus, in a neighborhood of the origin, we have
L#j L#k =
n
# Cjk L
j k = 2 n
=2
If we then consider, in a neighborhood W of the origin in RN −1 , the vector fields N ajk 0 x2 xN j = 2 n Mj = x k k=2 as well as the sub-bundle of CTW defined by them, we conclude the existence of a coordinate system y2 yN defined near the origin in RN −1 for which is spanned by /y2 /yn This argument has the following consequence: returning to the original coordinates x1 xN , the induction hypothesis allows us to assume from the beginning that ajk 0 x2 xN = 0
j = 2 n k > n
I.5 The Frobenius theorem
13
Now, the coefficient of /x in the commutator L#1 L#j is equal to aj /x1 . On the other hand,
L#1 L#j =
n
# 1 C1j L = C1j
=1
N n + C1j ak x1 =2 x k k=2
and thus n aj = C1j a x1 =2
= 2 N j = 2 n
Hence for each fixed the vector a2 an satisfies a linear system of ordinary differential equations with trivial initial condition. By the uniqueness theorem for such systems we conclude that aj = 0 if j = 2 n and > n. Thus we have n L#j = ajk j = 2 n x k k=2 which concludes the proof. We now discuss the holomorphic version of the Frobenius theorem. Write the complex coordinates in C as z1 z , where zj = xj + iyj , and identify C R2 by z = z1 z → x1 y1 x y Given an open set ⊂ C denote by the algebra of holomorphic functions on . An element L ∈ X is said to be a holomorphic vector field if given any f ∈ we have Lf ∈ and Lf = 0. Introducing the standard notation 1 1 = −i = +i zj 2 xj yj zj 2 xj yj it is clear that every vector field L ∈ X can be written as aj + bj L= zj zj j=1
(I.11)
where aj bj ∈ C ; (I.11) is then a holomorphic vector field if and only if bj = 0 and aj ∈ , j = 1 . We now state the holomorphic version of the Frobenius theorem, whose proof is the same as that of Theorem I.5.1, working now in the holomorphic category.
14
Locally integrable structures
Theorem I.5.2. Let L1 Ln be linearly independent, holomorphic vector fields defined in a neighborhood V of the origin in C . Assume that the subbundle of CTV generated by L1 Ln is a formally integrable structure. Then there are local holomorphic coordinates w1 w2 w , defined near the origin in C such that is generated by /w1 ,…, /wn .
I.6 Analytic structures Let be a real-analytic manifold, defined by the differentiable (real-analytic) structure = V x . A function f → C is real-analytic if for every V x ∈ the composition f x−1 is real-analytic on xV. Given U ⊂ an open set, we shall denote by U the space of real-analytic functions on U . An element L ∈ X is said to be a real-analytic vector field on if L U ⊂ U
∀U ⊂ open
If L is given in local coordinates as in (I.6) then L is real-analytic if and only if its coefficients Lxj , j = 1 N , are real-analytic functions. Analogously, we shall say that ∈ N is a real-analytic one-form on if L ∈ U for every U ⊂ open and every real-analytic vector field L. From such definitions it is clear that one can introduce the notions of complex analytic vector sub-bundles of CT and of CT ∗ ; in particular we can refer to the notion of an analytic formally integrable structure over . Remark I.6.1. Suppose that is now an open subset of RN and let L ∈ X be real-analytic. Write N L = aj x x j j=1 Let also u ∈ and take an open set C ⊂ CN , where the holomorphic coordinates are written as z1 zN , such that • C ∩ RN = ; • u, aj extend as holomorphic functions u˜ , a˜ j on C . Then ˜ u Lu = L˜ ˜ is the holomorphic vector field where L ˜= L
N j=1
a˜ j z
zj
(I.12)
1.8 Some special structures
15
I.7 The characteristic set Let ⊂ CT be a formally integrable structure over . The characteristic set of is the subset of T ∗ defined by (I.13) T 0 = T ∩ T ∗ We shall also write Tp0 = Tp ∩ Tp∗ if p ∈ . If we recall that the symbol of a vector field L ∈ X is the function L T ∗ → C
L = Lp
if ∈ Tp∗
then we see that ∈ Tp0 if and only if L = 0 for every section L of . Let U x, x = x1 xN be a local chart on . Take p ∈ U and ∈ Tp∗ . If we write = Nj=1 j dxjp (j ∈ R) and L = Nj=1 aj /xj then L =
N
aj pj
j=1
Thus, if Lj = Nk=1 ajk /xk are n linearly independent sections of over U we can describe T 0 ∩ T ∗ U by the system of equations N
ajk pk = 0
p ∈ U k ∈ R j = 1 n
k=1
Example I.7.1 (The Mizohata operator). If we write the coordinates in = R2 as x t then (I.14) M = − it ∈ XR2 t x is called the Mizohata vector field or Mizohata operator. We now describe the characteristic set of the formally integrable structure defined by M. From the equation − it = 0 we get 0 if t = 0 0 Txt = dxp ∈ R if p = x 0. This example in particular shows that T 0 is not, in general, a vector sub-bundle of T ∗ .
I.8 Some special structures Let be a formally integrable structure over . We shall say that defines • an elliptic structure if Tp0 = 0, ∀p ∈ ; • a complex structure if p ⊕ p = CTp , ∀p ∈ ;
16
Locally integrable structures
• a Cauchy–Riemann (CR) structure if p ∩ p = 0, ∀p ∈ ; • an essentially real structure if p = p , ∀p ∈ . Before we proceed further we state some easy consequences of the preceding definitions. Proposition I.8.1. Every essentially real structure is locally generated by real vector fields. Proof. Given p0 ∈ we take vector fields L1 Ln which generate in a neighborhood of p0 . By hypothesis the real vector fields Lj , Lj are also sections of . Moreover, span Lj p Lj p j = 1 n = p0 0
0
and consequently n of the tangent vectors Lj p Lj p are linearly 0 0 independent. Since this remains true in a neighborhood of p0 the result is proved. Next we recall a very elementary but useful result. Lemma I.8.2. If V is a vector subspace of CN = RN + iRN and if V 0 = V ∩ RN then V 0 ⊗R C V 0 + iV 0 = V ∩ V . Proof. We only verify the equality. If x y ∈ V 0 then x ± iy ∈ V and so V 0 + iV 0 ⊂ V ∩ V . For the reverse inclusion take z ∈ V ∩ V . Then z=
i 1 z + z − iz − iz ∈ V 0 + iV 0 2 2
As a consequence, given any formally integrable structure over we have
Tp0 ⊗R C Tp ∩ T p
∀p ∈
Since for a complex structure we also have
Tp ⊕ T p = CTp∗ we obtain:
∀p ∈
(I.15)
I.8 Some special structures
17
Corollary I.8.3. Every complex structure is elliptic. Unlike what happens with Mizohata structures we have: Proposition I.8.4. If defines a CR structure over then T 0 is a vector sub-bundle of T ∗ of rank d = N − 2n. Proof. If p ∩ p = 0, for all p ∈ , then = ⊕ = p ⊕ p p∈
is a vector sub-bundle of CT (of rank 2n) which defines an essentially real structure over . By Proposition I.4.4, ⊥ is a vector sub-bundle of ⊥ CT ∗ of rank d which of course satisfies p⊥ = p for all p ∈ . The same argument used in the proof of Proposition I.8.1 shows that ⊥ has local real generators. Since these generators span T 0 the proof is complete. In order to obtain appropriate local generators for a formally integrable structure we shall need an elementary result: Lemma I.8.5. Let V be a complex subspace of CN of dimension m. Let V0 = V ∩ RN , d = dimR V0 , = m − d. Let also V1 ⊂ CN be a subspace such that V0 ⊕ iV0 ⊕ V1 = V and take: 1 basis for V1
+1 m real basis for V0
If we write j = j + ij , j = 1 , then: 1 +1 m is a basis for V ;
(I.16)
1 m 1 is linearly independent over R
(I.17)
+ m ≤ N
(I.18)
Proof. Notice that (I.16) is trivial since +1 m is also a basis for V0 ⊕ iV0 . Next we notice that V ∩ V 1 = 0. Indeed, let z ∈ V ∩ V 1 . Then z ∈ V1 ⊂ V and consequently z z ∈ V0 , which gives z ∈ V0 ⊕ iV0 ∩ V1 = 0. Hence 1 1 +1 m is linearly independent. In particular, 2 +d = +m ≤ N and (I.17) holds. Given a formally integrable structure over and fixing p ∈ we shall apply Lemma I.8.5 with the choices V = Tp
V0 = Tp0
18
Locally integrable structures
If 1 +1 m is the basis given in (I.16) we first take a system of local coordinates x1 x y1 y s1 sd t1 tn vanishing at p such that, writing zj = xj + iyj we have dzj p = j dsk p = +k
j = 1 k = 1 d
Afterwards we take one-forms 1 1 d which spanT in a neighborhood of p and such that j p = dzj p
k p = dsk p
j = 1 k = 1 d
If L is a complex vector field on defined near p we can write it in the form L=
Aj
j
+ Bj + Ck + D zj zj sk t j k
If, furthermore, L is a section of we necessarily must have Aj = Ck = 0 at p for all j and k. Since + n = n, it follows that after a linear substitution we can find a set of local generators of the sub-bundle in a neighborhood of p of the form Lj = ˜ = L
d + ajj + bjk zj j =1 zj k=1 sk
d + a˜ j + b˜ k t j =1 zj k=1 sk
j = 1
(I.19)
= 1 n
(I.20)
where the coefficients ajj , a˜ j , bjk , b˜ k all vanish at p. We notice that the elliptic case corresponds to the situation when d = 0, the complex case to the one when d = n = 0, and the CR case to the one when n = 0. Next we introduce a generalization of the structure defined by the Mizohata operator (cf. Example I.7.1). Definition I.8.6. We shall say that a formally integrable structure over is a generalized Mizohata structure at p0 ∈ if p0 = p0 . Thus in the case of generalized Mizohata structures the coordinates vanishing at p0 can be taken as s1 sm t1 tn [d = m, n = n in this case] and is spanned by the vector fields L =
d + b˜ k s t t k=1 sk
= 1 n
I.9 Locally integrable structures
19
where bk = 0 at the origin for every k. Finally we recall the classical notion of the so-called CR functions: Definition I.8.7. Given a CR formally integrable structure over , any classical solution (for the formally integrable structure ) is called a CR function. Needless to add, we can also introduce the concept of CR distributions, etc.
I.9 Locally integrable structures A complex vector sub-bundle of CT, of rank n, is said to define a locally integrable structure if given an arbitrary point p0 ∈ there are an open neighborhood U0 of p0 and functions Z1 Zm ∈ C U0 , with m = N − n, such that span dZ1p dZmp = p⊥
∀p ∈ U0
(I.21)
If one observes that the differential of a smooth function g is a section of ⊥ if and only if Lg = 0 for every section of , it follows easily that every locally integrable structure satisfies the Frobenius condition. Hence, every locally integrable structure defines a formally integrable structure. We have: • The formally integrable structure is locally integrable if and only if, given p0 ∈ and vector fields L1 Ln which span in an open neighborhood U0 of p0 , there are an open neighborhood V0 ⊂ U0 of p0 and smooth functions Z1 Zm ∈ C V0 such that: dZ1 ∧ ∧ dZm = 0 Lj Zk = 0
in
V0
j = 1 n k = 1 m
Thus, checking local integrability is equivalent to looking for a maximal number of nontrivial solutions to the (in general overdetermined) homogeneous system defined by a fixed set of independent sections of . Theorem I.9.1. Every essentially real structure is locally integrable. Proof. By Frobenius Theorem I.5.1, in conjunction with Proposition I.8.1, given p ∈ we can find a local chart U x, x = x1 xN , with p ∈ U , such that j = 1 n xj
20
Locally integrable structures
are sections of over U . It suffices to take k = 1 m
Zk = xk+n
Theorem I.9.2. Every analytic formally integrable structure is locally integrable. Proof. We shall prove that if L1 Ln are linearly independent, realanalytic vector fields in an open ball B centered at the origin in RN such that n
L L =
C L
=1
where ∈ B, then we can find real-analytic functions Z1 Zm defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying C
Lj Z = 0
j = 1 n = 1 m dZ1 ∧ ∧ dZm = 0
We write Lj =
N
ajk
k=1
xk
and take an open, connected set U ⊂ CN such that U ∩ RN = B and such that there are a˜ jk , C˜ ∈ U satisfying a˜ jk = ajk C˜ = C
in B
Consider then the holomorphic vector fields in U : ˜j = L
N
a˜ jk
k=1
zk
By analytic continuation the coefficients of the holomorphic vector fields ˜ − ˜ L
L
n
˜ L C˜
=1
must vanish identically in U since they vanish on B and the former is connected. By the holomorphic version of the Frobenius theorem we can find holomorphic functions W1 Wm defined in an open neighborhood V ⊂ U of the origin in CN such that ˜ j W = 0 L
j = 1 n = 1 m
I.10 Local generators
21
dW1 ∧ ∧ dWm = 0 It suffices then to set Zk = Wk V ∩B in order to obtain the desired solutions (cf. (I.12)). Example I.9.3. For the Mizohata vector field (I.14) we have MZ = 0 in R2 , where Zx t = x + it2 /2. Notice that dZ = 0 everywhere.
I.10 Local generators In this section we shall construct appropriate local coordinates and local generators of the sub-bundle T when the structure is locally integrable. Once more we shall apply Lemma I.8.5. Let p ∈ and let also G1 Gm be smooth functions defined in a neighborhood of p such that dG1 dGm span T . As in Section I.8 we make the choices: V = Tp , V0 = Tp0 . If 1 +1 m is the basis given in (I.16) then we can find cjk ∈ GLm C such that m
cjk dGk p = j
j = 1
k=1 m
cjk dGk p = j
j = + 1 m
k=1
We then set Zj =
m
cjk Gk − Gk p
j = 1
k=1
W =
m
c+k Gk − Gk p
= 1 d
k=1
It is clear that dZ1 dZ dW1 dWd also span T in a neighborhood of p. If we further set xj = Zj yj = Zj s = W then (I.17) gives that dx1 dx dy1 dy ds1 dsd are linearly independent at p. We are now ready to state and prove the following important result:
22
Locally integrable structures
Theorem I.10.1. Let be a locally integrable structure defined on a manifold . Let p ∈ and d be the real dimension of Tp0 . Then there is a coordinate system vanishing at p, x1 x y1 y s1 sd t1 tn and smooth, real-valued functions 1 d defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying k 0 = 0 dk 0 = 0
k = 1 d
such that the differentials of the functions Zj x y = zj = xj + iyj
j = 1
Wk x y s t = sk + ik z s t
(I.22)
k = 1 d
(I.23)
span T in a neighborhood of the origin. In particular, we have + d = m, + n = n and also Tp0 = span ds1 0 dsd 0
(I.24)
Proof. The proof follows almost immediately from the preceding discussion: it suffices to take smooth, real-valued functions t1 tn defined near p and vanishing at p such that dx1 dx dy1 dy ds1 dsd dt1 dtn are linearly independent. Notice that dWk p = +k is real, from which we derive that dk = 0 at the origin. Since we have Wk 0 0 0 = kk sk
k k = 1 d
we can introduce, in a neighborhood of the origin in R2+d+n , the vector fields d kk z s t k = 1 d (I.25) Mk = s k k =1 characterized by the relations Mk Wk = kk
(I.26)
Consequently the vector fields Lj =
d k −i z s tMk zj k=1 zj
j = 1
(I.27)
I.10 Local generators
˜ = L
d k −i z s tMk t k=1 t
= 1 n
23
(I.28)
are linearly independent and satisfy ˜ Zj = L j Wk = L ˜ Wk = 0 L j Zj = L for all j j = 1 , = 1 n , and k = 1 d. Hence ˜ 1 L ˜ n span in a neighborhood of the origin. L1 L L
(I.29)
Notice that the one-forms dz1 dz dz1 dz dW1 dWd dt1 dtn
(I.30)
span CT ∗ near the origin. Moreover, the dual basis of (I.30) is given by ˜ 1 L ˜ n L1 L L1 L M1 Md L
(I.31)
where Lj =
d k −i z s tMk zj k=1 zj
j = 1
(I.32)
the vector fields (I.31) are pairwise commuting.
(I.33)
Finally we observe that
Indeed it suffices to notice that if P Q are any two of the vector fields (I.31) and if F is any one of the functions Zj Zj Wk t , the fact that (I.30) is dual to (I.31) gives dF P Q = P Q F = 0 from which we obtain that P Q = 0. In many cases we do not need the precise information provided by Theorem I.10.1 and the following particular case is enough: Corollary I.10.2. Same hypotheses as in Theorem I.10.1. Then there is a coordinate system vanishing at p, x1 xm t1 tn and smooth, real-valued 1 m defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying k 0 0 = 0
dx k 0 0 = 0
k = 1 m
such that the differentials of the functions Zk x t = xk + ik x t
span T in a neighborhood of the origin.
k = 1 m
(I.34)
24
Locally integrable structures
If we write Zx t = Z1 x t Zm x t then Zx 0 0 equals the identity m × m matrix. Hence we can introduce, in a neighborhood of the origin in RN , the vector fields Mk =
m
k x t
=1
x
k = 1 m
(I.35)
characterized by the relations Mk Z = k
(I.36)
Consequently the vector fields Lj =
m k −i x tMk tj k=1 tj
j = 1 n
(I.37)
are linearly independent and satisfy Lj Zk = 0, for j = 1 n, k = 1 m. The same argument as before gives: L1 Ln span in a neighborhood of the origin; L1 Ln M1 Mm are pairwise commuting and span CT RN in a neighborhood of the origin in RN .
(I.38) (I.39)
Let U be an open set of Rn and assume, given a smooth function ! U → Rm , !t = 1 t m t. We shall call a tube structure on Rm × U the locally integrable structure on Rm × U for which T is spanned by the differentials of the functions Zk = xk + ik t
k = 1 m
A tube structure has remarkably simple global generators. Indeed if we set, as usual, Z = Z1 Zm we have Zx x t = I, the identity m × m matrix, for every x t ∈ Rm × U . This gives Mk = /xk and consequently the vector fields (I.37) take the form Lj =
m k −i t tj xk k=1 tj
j = 1 n
Observe that these vector fields span on Rm × U .
(I.37 )
I.11 Local generators in analytic structures
25
I.11 Local generators in analytic structures When is real-analytic then the functions k in Corollary I.10.2 can be taken real-analytic. We keep the notation established in the preceding section and consider the equation Zx t − z = 0 for x t z ∈ Cm × Cn × Cm in a neighborhood of the origin. Since Z 0 0 = I x we can find, by the implicit function theorem, a holomorphic function x = Hz t = H1 z t Hm z t defined in a neighborhood of the origin in Cm × Cn satisfying H0 0 = 0
HZx t t = x
We set Zk# x t = Hk Zx t 0
k = 1 m
Then we also have Lj Zk# = 0 j = 1 n k = 1 m dZ1# ∧ ∧ dZm# = 0 Moreover, Zk# x 0 = xk for every k. Hence, if we consider the real-analytic diffeomorphism x t → X T = Z# x t t in these new variables we can write Zk# X T = Xk + i!k# X T where now we have !k# X 0 = 0 for every k. Summing up we can state: Corollary I.11.1. Let be a locally integrable real-analytic structure defined on a real-analytic manifold . Let p ∈ . Then there is a realanalytic coordinate system vanishing at p, x1 xm t1 tn and real-analytic, real-valued 1 m defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying k x 0 = 0
k = 1 m
such that the differentials of the functions Zk = xk + ik x t span T in a neighborhood of the origin.
k = 1 m
(I.40)
26
Locally integrable structures
Remark I.11.2. We point out that in the coordinates x t given by Corollary I.11.1 it is elementary to find the unique analytic solution u to the Cauchy problem: Lj u = 0 j = 1 n (I.41) ux 0 = hx where h is real-analytic. Indeed, ux t = hZ1# x t Zm# x t solves (I.41) and in order to see that this is the unique analytic solution it suffices to notice that if v is analytic, if vx 0 = 0, and if Lj v = 0 for every j then v must vanish identically since all its derivatives vanish at the origin. Uniqueness for the distribution solutions of (I.41) holds when the structure is only C . This, though, is a much deeper result and its discussion will be postponed to Chapter II.
I.12 Integrability of complex and elliptic structures The celebrated theorem of Newlander and Nirenberg ([NN]) states that every complex structure is locally integrable. We shall postpone the proof of this result to the appendix of this chapter and now we will apply it to prove the more general statement that in fact every elliptic structure is locally integrable. This result is due to L. Nirenberg. Theorem I.12.1. Let be an elliptic structure over a smooth manifold . Then is locally integrable.
Proof. By (I.15) we have Tp ∩ T p = 0 for every p ∈ and then Tp ⊕ T p T ⊕T = p∈
is a vector sub-bundle of CT ∗ of rank 2m. In particular, if n is the dimension of , we obtain that 2m ≤ n. Thus ⊥ ∩ = Tp ⊕ T p p ∩ p = p∈
p∈
is a vector sub-bundle of CT. By the argument that led to the proof of Proposition I.8.1 we see then that ∩ T = p ∩ Tp p∈
I.12 Integrability of complex and elliptic structures is a vector sub-bundle of T. Notice that n = dimR p ∩ Tp = n − 2m
27
p ∈
Let p0 ∈ be fixed. By the Frobenius Theorem I.5.1 we can find a coordinate system x1 x2m t1 tn around p0 such that ∩ T is generated near p0 by the vector fields j = 1 n tj Next we select m complex vector fields Lk =
2m
ak x t
=1
x
in such a way that L1 Lm /t1 /tn span in a neighborhood of p0 . After a linear substitution (as in the proof of Proposition I.4.4) we can assume that the vector fields Lk take the form Lk =
2m + b x t xk =m+1 k x
k = 1 m
Since is a formally integrable structure, we know /t Lk must be a linear combination of L1 Lm , /t1 /tn . Due to the special form of the vector fields Lk these brackets must vanish identically, that is: 2m bk x t = 0 x =m+1 t
∀ k
Consequently, the functions bk do not depend on t1 tn in a full neighborhood of p0 . Since, moreover, L1 Lm L1 Lm
t1 tn
span CT it follows that L1 Lm L1 Ln are linearly independent. We conclude then that L1 Lm define a complex structure (in the x-space) in a neighborhood of p0 . By the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem there are Z1 x Zm x with linearly independent differentials such that Lk Z = 0
k = 1 m
Since, moreover, Z = 0 tj the proof is complete.
= 1 m j = 1 n
28
Locally integrable structures
Theorem I.10.1 gives a particularly simple local representation for an elliptic structure. Let and be as in Theorem I.12.1 and fix p ∈ . With the notation as in Theorem I.10.1 we have d = 0, = m and thus there is a coordinate system x1 xm y1 ym t1 tn vanishing at p such that, setting zj = xj + iyj , the differentials dzj span T near p, and the vector fields /zk , /tj span near p. Notice also that n = 0 corresponds to the case when defines a complex structure.
I.13 Elliptic structures in the real plane In this section we depart a bit from the spirit we have adopted in the exposition up to now and make use of some standard results on Fourier analysis and pseudo-differential operators in order to study elliptic structures in twodimensional manifolds. The results contained here are not necessary for the comprehension of the remaining parts of the chapter and the section can be avoided in a first reading. If is an open subset of R2 any sub-bundle of CT of rank one defines a formally integrable structure over , for the involutive condition is automatically satisfied. Suppose that contains the origin and let L be a complex vector field that spans in a neighborhoord of 0. After division by a nonvanishing smooth factor it can be assumed that, in suitable coordinates x1 x2 , we can write L=
+ ax1 x2 x2 x1
As at the beginning of Section I.5 we can find a smooth diffeomorphism x t → x1 x2 , x2 = t, which reduces L to /t. Since also /x1 is a multiple of /x in these new variables, L can be written as a nonvanishing multiple of L• = + ibx t (I.42) t x where b is smooth and real-valued. Since both L and L• span in a neighborhood of the origin of R2 , there is no loss of generality in assuming that our original L takes the form (I.42). The structure is elliptic if and only if L and L are linearly independent at every point. This is equivalent to saying that the function b in (I.42) never vanishes (in the p.d.e. terminology, L is an elliptic operator). We shall now
I.13 Elliptic structures in the real plane
29
recall the standard elliptic estimates satisfied by L and its transpose t L in a neighborhood of the origin. Let L0 =
+ ib0 0 t x
(I.43)
If ∈ Cc R2 then taking Fourier transforms gives L0 = i − b0 0 Since b0 0 = 0 we have
2 + 2 ≤ max 1
1
i − b0 0 2 b0 02
and thus by Parseval’s formula we obtain, in Sobolev norms, 1 ≤ C L0 0 + 0 ∈ Cc R2
(I.44)
where for any real s we denote by s the norm in the Sobolev space L2s R2 (see Section II.3.2 for the definition of Sobolev norms). We select an open neighborhood of the origin U ⊂ such that bx t − b0 0 ≤ 1/2C for x t ∈ U . If ∈ Cc U then by (I.44) 1 ≤ C L0 + L − L0 0 + 0 = C L0 + bx t − b0 0 x 0 + 0 1 ≤ C L0 + 0 + 1 2 and thus 1 ≤ 2C L0 + 0 ∈ Cc U
(I.45)
Let now V ⊂⊂ U be an open set and let also ∈ Cc U be identically equal to one in V . We denote by " the operator ‘multiplication by ’ and by # the operator 1 − $1/2 . For a real number s and for ∈ Cc V, we obtain s+1 = #s "1 ≤ "#s 1 + C1 s since the commutator between #s and " has order s − 1. If we now apply (I.45) we obtain s+1 ≤ C2 L"#s 0 + "#s 0 + s ≤ C3 "#s L0 + s since both "#s and its commutator with L have order s. We then obtain: • For every V ⊂⊂ U open and every s ∈ R there is C • > 0 such that s+1 ≤ C • Ls + s ∈ Cc V
(I.46)
30
Locally integrable structures
2s+1 Proposition I.13.1. If u ∈ U and Lu ∈ L2s loc U then u ∈ Lloc U. In particular, if u ∈ U and Lu ∈ C U then u ∈ C U.
Proof. Let W ⊂⊂ V ⊂⊂ U be open sets and let ∈ Cc V be identically equal to one in W . Since there is ≤ s such that u ∈ L2 loc V it will suffice to show that u ∈ L2+1 , for iteration of the argument will give the result. Let B% = &% ∗ ·, where &% is the usual family of mollifiers in R2 . We have B% u → u in L2 as % → 0 and also %→0
LB% u = B% Lu + L B% u −→ Lu in L2 by Friedrich’s lemma, since Lu ∈ L2 . Thus, if take %n → 0 and if we apply (I.46) for s = and = B%m u − B%n u we conclude that B%n u is a Cauchy sequence in L2+1 . Hence u ∈ L2+1 and the proof is complete. We shall now derive from (I.45) an estimate for the transpose of L which will lead us to a solvability result. If we notice that t L = −L − ibx x t then from (I.45) we obtain, for some constant C > 0, 1 ≤ C t L0 + 0 ∈ Cc U
(I.47)
Now, it is elementary that 0 ≤ 2t 0
∈ Cc U
where = sup t x t ∈ U . Consequently, if we further contract U about the origin in order to achieve 2C ≤ 1/2, from (I.47) we finally obtain 0 ≤ 2C t L0 ∈ Cc U
(I.48)
Proposition I.13.2. For every f ∈ L2 U there is u ∈ L2 U such that Lu = f in U . Proof. Given f ∈ L2 U consider the functional t L → fx tx tdxdt
(I.49)
defined on t L ∈ Cc U , where the latter is considered as a subspace of L2 U. By (I.48) it follows that (I.49) is well-defined and continuous. By the Hahn–Banach theorem we extend (I.49) to a continuous functional on L2 U and by the Riesz representation theorem we find u ∈ L2 U such that g = gx tux tdxdt g ∈ L2 U
I.13 Elliptic structures in the real plane In particular, if ∈ Cc U t L =
31
fx tx tdxdt
which is precisely the meaning of the equality Lu = f in the weak sense. Corollary I.13.3. Let D ⊂⊂ U be an open disk centered at the origin. Then L C D = C D
(I.50)
Proof. Given f ∈ C D we extend it to an element f˜ ∈ Cc U and by Proposition I.13.2 we find u ∈ L2 U solving Lu = f˜ in U . Finally, by Proposition I.13.1, we have u ∈ C U and thus its restriction to D belongs to C D. Still under the assumption that L is elliptic we apply (I.50) in order to find v ∈ C D such that Lv = −ibx If we set ux t =
x
(I.51)
evx t dx
0
we get Lux t =
x
0
vt x tevx t dx + ibx tevxt
x
−ibvx − ibx x tevx t dx + ibx tevxt x = −i x bev x tdx + ibx tevxt =
0
0
= ib0 tev0t Then if we set Zx t = ux t − i
t
b0 t ev0t dt
(I.52)
0
we obtain LZ = 0
Zx = ev = 0
(I.53)
that is, our original elliptic structure is locally integrable. We have thus obtained a proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem in the particular case when N = 2. We emphasize for this situation the conclusion that we have reached at the end of Section I.12:
32
Locally integrable structures
Corollary I.13.4. If L is an elliptic operator in an open subset ⊂ R2 and if p ∈ then we can find local coordinates x y vanishing at p such that L can be written, in a neighborhood of p, as +i L = gx y x y where g never vanishes. Remark I.13.5. Our discussion indeed leads to a general criterion that characterizes when a rank one formally integrable structure ⊂ CT, ⊂ R2 open, is locally integrable. Suppose that is spanned, in a neighborhood of the origin, by the vector field (I.42). Proposition I.13.6. The following properties are equivalent: † there is Z ∈ C near the origin solving LZ = 0, Zx = 0; ‡ there is v ∈ C near the origin solving (I.51). Proof. We have already presented the argument that ‡ ⇒ †. For the reverse implication we notice that 0 = LZx = LZx + ibx Zx and consequently L logZx = Zx−1 LZx = −ibx
I.14 Compatible submanifolds Let be a smooth manifold. A subset of is called an embedded submanifold (or submanifold for short) of if there is r ∈ 0 1 N for which the following is true: • Given p0 ∈ arbitrary there is a local chart U0 x, with p0 ∈ U0 and x = x1 xN , such that U0 ∩ = q ∈ U0 xr+1 q = xr+1 p0 xN q = xN p0 When p0 runs over the pairs U0 x0 , where x0 = x1 U0 ∩ xr U0 ∩ make up a family ∗ that satisfies properties (1) and (2) of Section I.1 Hence is a smooth manifold of dimension r. We shall refer to the number N − r as the codimension of (in ).
I.14 Compatible submanifolds
33
Let p ∈ and denote by C p the space of germs of smooth functions on at p. It is clear that the restriction to defines a surjective homomorphism p which gives us then a natural injection o f C-algebras C p → C
'p CTp CTp
(I.54)
By transposition we thus obtain a surjection 'p ∗ CTp∗ −→ CTp∗
(I.55)
whose kernel will be denoted by CNp∗ . We shall sometimes refer to the disjoint union CNp∗ (I.56) CN ∗ = p∈
as the complex conormal bundle of in . Let now U ⊂ be open and let ∈ NU. Given L ∈ XU ∩ the map p → '∗p p Lp is easily seen to be smooth on U ∩ . By the discussion that precedes Proposition I.4.2, there is a form • ∈ NU ∩ such that •p = 'p ∗ p for every p ∈ U ∩ . We shall denote • by '∗ and shall refer to it as the pullback of to U ∩ . It is clear that '∗ is a homomorphism which is moreover surjective when U ∩ is closed in U . Observe also that '∗ df = df U ∩
f ∈ C U
(I.57)
Let now be a formally integrable structure over , with T = ⊥ , and let ⊂ be a submanifold. If p ∈ we set p (I.58) p = p ∩ CTp = p∈
With orthogonal now taken in the duality CTp CTp∗ we have 'p ∗ Tp = ⊥ p
(I.59)
since the left-hand side is the image of the composition 'p ∗
Tp CTp∗ −→ CTp∗ and consequently is equal to the orthogonal to the kernel of the composition CTp CTp −→ CTp /p
34
Locally integrable structures
Definition I.14.1. We shall say that is compatible with the formally integrable structure if defines a formally integrable structure over . When is compatible with then, according to our previous notation, ∗ T p = ⊥ p = 'p Tp (cf. (I.59)). The next result gives a very useful criterion: Proposition I.14.2. The submanifold is compatible with if (and only if) p → dim p is constant on .
(I.60)
Proof. We must prove that (I.60) implies that is a vector sub-bundle of which satisfies the Frobenius condition. First we observe that (I.60) and (I.59) give the existence of such that dim'p ∗ Tp = ∀p ∈
(I.61)
Let p0 ∈ and take 1 m ∈ NU0 , where U0 is an open subset of that contains p0 , such that 1 q m q span Tq for every q ∈ U0 . Select j1 j such that
∗ ' j1 p0 '∗ j p0 form a basis for 'p0 ∗ Tp 0 . Then
∗ ' j1 p '∗ j p will still be linearly independent when p belongs to an open neighborhood V0 of p0 in and consequently, thanks to (I.61), will form a basis to 'p ∗ Tp for all such p. By the remark that follows Proposition I.4.4 we conclude that is a vector sub-bundle of . To conclude the argument it suffices to observe that if U is an open subset of and if L M ∈ XU are such that Lp Mp ∈ CTp for every p ∈ U ∩ then L M p ∈ CTp also for every p ∈ U ∩ . This property will easily imply that satisfies the Frobenius condition. Proposition I.14.3. If is a locally integrable structure over and if is a submanifold of which is compatible with then is a locally integrable structure over . Proof. It follows from the proof of Proposition I.14.2 in conjunction with (I.57).
I.14 Compatible submanifolds
35
Example I.14.4. Generic submanifolds of complex space. As in Section I.5 we shall write the complex coordinates in C as z1 z , where zj = xj +iyj . If f is a smooth function on an open subset of C we shall write, as usual, f =
f dzj z j j=1
(I.62)
f =
f dzj z j j=1
(I.63)
Definition I.14.5. Let be a submanifold of C of codimension d. We shall say that is generic if given p0 ∈ there are an open neighborhood U0 of p0 in C and real-valued functions &1 &d ∈ C U0 such that ∩ U0 = z ∈ U &k z = 0 k = 1 d and &1 &d are linearly independent at each point of ∩ U0 . Notice that every one-codimensional submanifold of C is automatically generic. Denote by 01 the sub-bundle of CT C which defines the complex structure on C , that is, the sub-bundle spanned by the vector fields /zj , j = 1 . Proposition I.14.6. If is a generic submanifold of C of codimension d then is compatible with 01 . Moreover, 01 is a locally integrable, CR structure for which n and m satisfy: dim = 2n + d
m = = n + d
The sub-bundle T is spanned by the differentials of the restriction to of the complex coordinate functions on C . Proof. Let p ∈ . A vector j=1 aj /zj p belongs to CTp ∩ p01 if and only if & aj k p = 0 k = 1 d zj j=1 Since is generic it follows that dimC CTp ∩ p01 = − d
∀p ∈
By Propositions I.14.2 and I.14.3 we conclude that is compatible with 01 and that 01 is locally integrable. Moreover, since 01 p ∩ 01 p = 0 for every p ∈ C we obtain
36
Locally integrable structures 01 p ∩ 01 p = 0
∀p ∈
which shows that 01 defines a CR structure over . Finally, we have n = rank 01 = − d and thus dim = 2 − d = 2n + d and m = dim − n = n + d. The last statement follows immediately from the proof of Proposition I.14.2.
I.15 Locally integrable CR structures When defines a locally integrable CR structure over then, according to Proposition I.8.4, d = dim Tp0 = N − 2n, for all p ∈ . Using Theorem I.10.1 we obtain m = N − n = n + d, = m − d = n and n = N − 2 − d = 0. We summarize: • Given p ∈ there is a coordinate system vanishing at p, x1 xn y1 yn s1 sd and smooth, real-valued functions 1 d defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying k 0 = 0 dk 0 = 0
k = 1 d
(I.64)
such that the differentials of the functions Zj = xj + iyj
j = 1 n
Wk = sk + ik z s
k = 1 d
(I.65) (I.66)
span T in a neighborhood of the origin. Notice that is spanned, in a neighborhood of the origin, by the pairwise commuting vector fields (I.27), where = n and there is no t-variable. Suppose that = 1 d is defined in a neighborhood U of the origin in Cn × Rd . Then the map F U → Cn+d
Fz s = z s + iz s
(I.67)
has rank 2n + d and consequently FU is an embedded submanifold of Cn+d of dimension 2n + d (and of codimension d). Now we write the coordinates in Cn+d as z1 zn w1 wd where w = s + it, wj = sj + itj . Then FU is defined by the equations &k z w = k z s − tk = 0 k = 1 d
I.15 Locally integrable CR structures Since
37
&k 1 k + ik k = 1 d = w 2 s
we conclude, taking into account (I.64), that FU is generic if U is taken small enough so that z s ≤ 1 z s ∈ U (I.68) s 2 By Proposition I.14.6 the complex structure 01 on Cn+d defines a locally integrable CR structure FU on FU for which the sub-bundle T FU is spanned by the differentials of the restrictions of the functions z1 zn , w1 wd to FU. Since in the local coordinates z s we have zj F U = Zj z s
wk F U = Wk z s
(cf. (I.65), (I.66)), we can state: Proposition I.15.1. Every locally integrable CR structure can be locally realized as the CR structure induced by the complex structure on a generic submanifold of the complex space. Remark I.15.2. Let be a tube structure on Rm × U (cf. Section I.10). Thus U is an open subset of Rn and we assume given smooth, real-valued functions 1 m on U such that T is spanned by the differential of the functions Zk = xk + ik t, k = 1 m. Recall that is then spanned on Rm × U by the vector fields (I.37 ). Let us now assume that is also a CR structure. Let d = m − n be the rank of the characteristic set T 0 (cf. Proposition I.8.4). ∗ Since being CR demands that Txt + T xt = CTxt Rm × U for every m x t ∈ R × U , we must then have rank ! t = n
∀t ∈ U
where ! = 1 m . This implies that = !U is an embedded submanifold of Rm of dimension n and it is clear that can be realized as the CR structure induced by the complex structure on the generic submanifold Rm + i of Rm + iRm = Cm . One very important model of a CR structure is the Hans Lewy structure. We take as the space C × R, where the coordinates are written as z = x + iy and s, and consider the formally integrable structure spanned by the Hans Lewy vector field (or operator) L=
− iz z s
(I.69)
38
Locally integrable structures
Since L and L are linearly independent at every point it follows that defines a CR structure which is furthermore locally integrable, since the differential of the functions z and W = s + i z 2 span T on C × R. Notice also that the Hans Lewy structure can be globally realized as the CR structure induced on the hyperquadric Q = z w ∈ C2 w = s + it t = z 2 (I.70) by the complex structure on C2 . More generally, given %j ∈ −1 1 , j = 1 n, we can consider the CR structure on Cn × R spanned by the pairwise commuting vector fields Lj =
− i%j zj s zj
j = 1 n
(I.71)
Such a structure is also locally integrable for the differential of the functions z1 zn and W = s + iz, with z =
n
%j zj 2
j=1
span T on Cn × R.
I.16 A CR structure that is not locally integrable In this section we shall prove the following quite involved result: Proposition I.16.1. Let %1 = 1
%j = −1 j = 2 n
(I.72)
There is a smooth function gz s defined in an open neighborhood of the origin in Cn × R and vanishing to infinite order at z1 = 0, such that if we set L#j =
− i%j zj 1 + gz s zj s
j = 1 n
(I.73)
then the following is true: (a) the vector fields L#j are pairwise commuting; (b) if h is a C 1 function near the origin satisfying L#j h = 0 j = 1 n then h/s0 0 = 0. Before we embark on the proof we shall state and prove the important consequence of this result:
I.16 A CR structure that is not locally integrable
39
Corollary I.16.2. The vector fields (I.73) span a CR structure which is not locally integrable in any neighborhood of the origin. Indeed, first we notice that L#1 L#n L#1 L#n are linearly independent over which together with property (a) shows that (I.73) define a CR structure over . Now, given any smooth solution h to the system L#j h = 0
j = 1 n
(I.74)
we necessarily have h/zj 0 0 = 0 for all j = 1 n. By property (b) we then obtain dh = nj=1 aj dzj at the origin and hence any set h1 hn+1 of smooth solutions to (I.74) must have linearly dependent differentials at the origin. In particular, the CR structure defined by the vector fields (I.73) cannot be locally integrable. Proof of Proposition I.16.1. The first step in the proof is the construction of the function g. In the complex plane we denote the variable by w = s + it and consider a sequence of closed, disjoint disks Dj , all of them contained in the sector w s < t and such that Dj → 0 as j → . Let F ∈ C C R have support contained in the union of the disks Dj and satisfy Fw > 0 ∀w ∈ int Dj ∀j
(I.75)
As before we shall write Wz s = s + iz, with z = z1 2 − z2 2 − − zn 2
(I.76)
Lemma I.16.3. The function F W vanishes to infinite order at z1 = 0. Proof. Denote by H the Heaviside function. For every ∈ Z+ there is C > 0 such that
Fw ≤ C tHt Then
FWz s ≤ C zHz Since moreover zHz ≤ z1 2 , the lemma is proved. We then set gz s =
FWz s z1 − FWz s
(I.77)
40
Locally integrable structures
Since gz s =
FWz s 1 z1 1 − FWz s/z1
it follows from Lemma I.16.3 that g is smooth in an open neighborhood of the origin in Cn × R and that g vanishes to infinite order at z1 = 0. We shall now proceed to the proof of (a). We shall write L#j = Lj − i%j zj gz s
s
(cf. (I.76), (I.73)). Since Lj Lk = 0 and Lj zk = 0 for all j and k we obtain
L#j L#k = −i %k zk Lj g − %j zj Lk g s
(I.78)
Now Lj g =
z1 L F W z1 − F W2 j
and an easy computation making use of the chain rule gives Lj FWz s = −2i%j zj
F Wz s w
Hence from (I.78) we obtain −iz1 z1 − F W2 −2z1 = z1 − F W2
L#j L#k =
%k zk Lj F W − %j zj Lk F W s
= 0 %k zk %j zj − %j zj %k zk s
We now start to prove (b). For this we set (z s = hz 0 0 s and will show that (/s0 0 = 0. We assume that ( is C 1 in a set of the form V = z s ∈ C × R z < r s < and observe that L( − izfz s
( = 0 s
where L is the Hans Lewy operator given in (I.79) and fz s =
Fs + i z 2 z − Fs + i z 2
is smooth in V (contracting V if necessary).
(I.79)
I.16 A CR structure that is not locally integrable
41
Let U = w = s + it ∈ C s < 0 < t < r 2 and assume that Dj ⊂ U for all j. Define w ∈ U (I.80) Iw = √ (z sdz
z = t
By Stokes’ theorem we have Iw =
√
z ≤ t
2) ( z sdz ∧ dz = 2i z 0 0
√ t
( &ei s&d&d z
from where we obtain 2) ( √ I 1 ( w = i tei sd = z sdz √ t z 0
z = t z z Consequently,
I i 1 w = L(z sdz √ w 2 z = t z
(I.81)
(cf. (I.79)). From (I.79), (I.81) and from the fact that F is supported in the union of the disks Dj we conclude that I is a holomorphic function of w in the connected open set U \ ∪j Dj . Since, moreover, Iw → 0 when t → 0+ the Schwarz reflection principle implies that I vanishes identically in U \ ∪j Dj . In particular, I ≡0
on
Dj
∀j.
(I.82)
Next we consider, for each j, the map Dj × S 1 −→ R3
√ w → tei s
(I.83)
whose image defines a torus Tj ⊂ V . If we set u = ( dz ∧ dW (I.84) where W z s = s + i z 2 , we have Tj u = 0 for all j, as a consequence of (I.82). Consequently, du = 0 ∀j (I.85) Sj
where Sj is the solid torus whose boundary is equal to Tj . We shall now exploit property (I.85). Since dz dz dW are linearly independent we can write d( = Adz + Bdz + CdW
(I.86)
42
Locally integrable structures
where A, B and C are continuous functions. If we apply both sides of (I.86) to L we obtain that B = L(, since Lz = LW = 0. Hence, from (I.84) we obtain du = L(dz ∧ dz ∧ dW ( = izfz s dz ∧ dz ∧ ds s ( = −2zfz s dx ∧ dy ∧ ds s which in conjunction with (I.85) gives zfz s Sj
( dxdyds = 0 s
∀j
(I.87)
Now we observe that zfz s = Fs + i z 2 *z s, where * is smooth and satisfies *0 0 = 1. From (I.87) we conclude the existence of points Pj Qj ∈ Sj such that ( ( *Pj Pj = *Qj Qj = 0 s s for all j. It suffices to let j → to obtain that (/s0 0 = 0 and hence to conclude the proof of the proposition.
I.17 The Levi form on a formally integrable structure Let be a formally integrable structure over a smooth manifold and let ∈ Tp0 , = 0 be fixed (recall that in particular ∈ Tp∗ ⊂ CTp∗ ). We start with the following result: Lemma I.17.1. Let L and M be sections of in a neighborhood of p. If either Lp = 0 or Mp = 0 then L M p = 0. Proof. We take complex vector fields L1 Ln which span at each point in a neighborhood of p. Assume for instance that Mp = 0 (for the other case the argument is analogous). Then we can write M=
n j=1
gj Lj
I.17 The Levi form on a formally integrable structure
43
where gj are smooth functions and gj p = 0 for all j = 1 n. We have
L M =
n
Lgj Lj + gj L Lj j=1
and thus L M p = 0 since Lj p = 0 (because is real) and gj p = 0. From Lemma I.17.1 it follows that the following definition is meaningful: Definition I.17.2. The Levi form of the formally integrable structure at the characteristic point ∈ Tp0 , = 0 is the hermitian form on p defined by Lp v w =
1 L M p 2i
(I.88)
where L and M are smooth sections of defined in a neighborhood of p and satisfying Lp = v, Mp = w. Given a hermitian form H on a finite-dimensional complex vector space V , its main invariants are the subspaces V + , V − and V ⊥ of V , which give a decomposition V = V+ ⊕V− ⊕V⊥ and are characterized by: • v → Hv v is positive definite on V + ; • v → Hv v is negative definite on V − ; • V ⊥ = v ∈ V Hv w = 0 ∀w ∈ V . Thus H is itself positive definite (resp. positive negative) if V = V + (resp. V = V − ). More generally, H is said to be positive (resp. negative) if V − = 0 (resp. V + = 0 ). Also, H is said to be nondegenerate if V ⊥ = 0 . Finally, we recall that it is common to call the positive integer dim V + − dim V − the signature of H. Notice that the signature does not change after multiplication of H by a nonzero real number. A formally integrable structure over is nondegenerate if given any ∈ Tp0 , = 0 the Levi form Lp is a nondegenerate hermitian form. We now describe the Levi form for a formally integrable CR structure over . Let p ∈ , ∈ Tp0 , = 0. According to the results described in Section I.8 we can find a system of coordinates x1 xn y1 yn s1 sd
44
Locally integrable structures
vanishing at p and vector fields of the form Lj =
d d + ajj z s + bjk z s zj k=1 sk zj j =1
j = 1 n
with ajj 0 0 = bjk 0 0 = 0 for all j j k, which span in a neighborhood of the origin in R2n+d . Notice, moreover, that Tp0 is equal to the span of ds1 0 dsd 0 . of the Levi Write = 1 ds1 0 + + d dsd 0 and denote by Ajj the matrix
form Lp with respectto the basis /z1 p /zn p of p . Thus, by definition, Ajj = Lp /zj p /zj p and then 1 ds + + d dsd 0 Lj Lj p 2i 1 1 0 d
1 L b − Lj bjk 0 0 = 2i k=1 k j j k
Ajj =
that is
d bjk bj k 1 0 0 − 0 0 Ajj = zj 2i k=1 k zj
(I.89)
As an example, let us consider the CR structure defined by the vector fields L#j given by (I.73). In this case d = 1 and we take = ds 0 . We also have bj = −i%j zj 1 + gz s, where g vanishes to infinite order at z1 = 0. Then bj 0 0 = −i%j jj zj and (I.89) gives Ajj = diag %1 %n Thus, Corollary I.16.2 has provided an example of a nondegenerate CR structure, defined in a neighborhood of the origin in Cn × R, for which the signature of the Levi form at ds 0 ∈ T00 , = 0 is equal to n − 1. In connection with this example we mention the following deep result which gives a positive answer to the problem of local integrability (or local realizability, as we have seen in Proposition I.15.1) for certain classes of CR structures. It shows that the value of the signature of the Levi form plays a crucial role. Recall that by Proposition I.8.4 the characteristic set of a CR structure is a sub-bundle of the cotangent bundle. Theorem I.17.3. Let be a nondegenerate CR structure over a smooth manifold and assume that its characteristic set has rank equal to one. Let
I.17 The Levi form on a formally integrable structure
45
n denote the rank of (and thus the dimension of is equal to 2n + 1). Suppose that for some p ∈ the signature of the Levi form at ∈ Tp0 , = 0, is equal to n. If n ≥ 3 then is locally integrable in a neighborhood of p. Finally, we shall compute the expression of the matrix Ajj of the Levi form when is locally integrable and CR. Invoking the local coordinates described at the beginning of Section I.15, and in particular the functions (I.66) satisfying (I.64), we see that we can take the vector fields Lj in the form (cf. (I.27)) Lj =
d k z sMk −i zj k=1 zj
j = 1 n
where Mk =
d
kk z s
k =1
sk
k = 1 d
characterized by the relations Mk sk + ik = kk . In particular, (I.64) gives kk 0 0 = kk
(I.90)
According to our previous notation, we have ajj ≡ 0 for all j j and bjk = −i
d k zj k k k =1
Again by (I.64) and by (I.90) we have bjk 2 k 0 0 = −i 0 0 zj zj zj and then by (I.89) we obtain Ajj =
d k=1
k
2 k 0 0 zj zj
(I.91)
Example I.17.4. The following discussion justifies our terminology and makes a connection with the theory of several complex variables. Let U be an open subset of Cn+1 with a smooth boundary. Let & ∈ C Cn+1 R be such that U = z &z < 0 and that d& = 0 on U = z &z = 0 . We say that U satisfies the Levi condition at the point p ∈ U if the restriction of the hermitian form → to the space Tp = ∈ Cn+1
n+1
2 & pj k jk=1 zj zk
n+1
j=1 &/zj pj
= 0 is positive.
46
Locally integrable structures
The Levi condition is independent of the choice of the defining function &: it is also a holomorphic invariant. After a translation and a C-linear tranformation we can assume that 0 ∈ and that the tangent space to at the origin is given by the real-hyperplane w = 0, where now we are writing the complex coordinates as z1 zn w. We can also assume that the exterior normal to at the origin is the vector 0 0 −i ∈ Cn+1 . By the implicit function theorem we conclude the existence of a smooth, real-valued function satisfying 0 0 = 0, d0 0 = 0 such that & can be written, near the origin and in these new complex variables, as &z w = z w − w
(I.92)
Since then T0 = n+1 = 0 , the Levi condition at the origin can be written as: n 2 0 0j k ≥ 0 ∀ ∈ Cn (I.93) z z j k jk=1 The boundary of U is a one-codimensional submanifold of Cn+1 and consequently it is generic. The complex structure 01 of Cn+1 induces on U a CR structure 01 U and, according to the discussion in Section I.15, the differentials of the functions Z j = zj
j = 1 n Wz s = s + iz s
span T U near the origin [we are writing s = w and considering z s as local coordinates in U ]. From (I.91) we obtain the following equivalent statement to (I.93): the Levi form of the CR structure 01 U at the characteristic point ds 0 is positive. 10 To obtain an invariant 01 ⊥ statement let us first denote by T the orthog. Given an open set U with a smooth boundary U onal sub-bundle as above, and given p ∈ U , the map '∗p CTp∗ Cn+1 → CTp∗ U induces an isomorphism ∼
p Tp10 −→ Tp U Let ∈ Tp0 U, = 0. We shall say that is inward pointing if p−1 v > 0 for every v ∈ Tp Cn+1 which is inward pointing toward U . In the preceding set-up, when p = 0 and & is given by (I.92), then 0−1 ds 0 = dw 0 and then = ds 0 is inward pointing if and only if > 0. Summing up we can state:
Appendix: Proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem
47
Proposition I.17.5. Let U ⊂ Cn+1 be an open set with a smooth boundary. Then U satisfies the Levi condition at p ∈ U if and only if the Levi form associated with the CR structure U is positive at every ∈ Tp0 U, = 0 which is inward pointing.
Appendix: Proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem In this appendix we shall present an argument due to B. Malgrange ([Mal]) which leads to the proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem. We start by recalling some of the results we need from the theory of nonlinear elliptic equations. Let us consider then an overdetermined system of nonlinear partial differential equations ! x u" x1 u" u" = 0 ≤ M (I.94) where x varies in an open subset of RN , u" = u1 uq ∈ C M Rq ! = 1 p is smooth and real-valued and q ≤ p. The system (I.94) is elliptic at u" 0 ∈ C M Rq in if the linear differential operator v" →
d ! x u" 0 + "v x1 "u0 + "v "u0 + "v =0 d
(I.95)
is elliptic in the following sense: if × RN \0 → LRq Rp denotes the principal symbol of (I.95) then rank x = q
∀x ∈ × RN \0
We call I95 the linearization of (I.94) at u" 0 . Here is an important remark that will be quite important in what follows: if x0 ∈ and if v" →
d ! x0 u" 0 x0 + "v x1 "u0 x0 + x1 "v =0 d
(I.96)
is an elliptic linear system (with constant coefficients!) then (I.94) is elliptic at u" 0 in a neighborhood of x0 . Accordingly, we shall call (I.96) the linearization of (I.94) at u" 0 at the point x0 .
48
Locally integrable structures
The two main results that are essential for Malgrange’s argument are: • If u" is a C M -solution of (I.94), if (I.94) is elliptic at u" in the sense just defined, and if the function ! is real-analytic then u" is real-analytic. • Now assume that q = p and that (I.94) is elliptic at u" 0 ∈ C M Rq . Let x0 ∈ be such that ! x0 u" 0 x0 x1 u" 0 x0 u" 0 x0 = 0 Then there are %0 > 0, C > 0 and 0 < < 1 such that for every 0 < % ≤ %0 there is a smooth solution u" % to (I.94) on x − x0 < % satisfying the bounds
u" % x − u" 0 x ≤ C%M− + x − x0 < % ≤ M We now embark on the proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem. The starting point is the description of the special generators presented after Lemma I.8.5, particularly the vector fields given by (I.19), taking into account that when the structure is complex then d = n = 0. In other words, we can assume that our (complex) formally integrable structure is defined, in an open neighborhood of the origin in Cm , by the pairwise commuting vector fields Lj =
m + ajk z zj k=1 zk
j = 1 m
(I.97)
where ajk = 0 at the origin. For technical reasons, which are going to be clear in the argument, it is convenient to assume that ajk z = O z 2 , and this property can be achieved after performing a local diffeomorphism of the form z = z + Qz z, where Q is a homogeneous polynomial of degree two in z1 zm z1 zm chosen suitably. We leave the details of this (simple) computation to the reader. Malgrange’s key idea is to show the existence of a local diffeomorphism w = Hz, defined near the origin in Cm , such that, in the new variables w1 wm , the structure has a set of generators which have real-analytic coefficients. This implies the sought-for conclusion thanks to Theorem I.9.2. In order to shorten the notation and make the computations more apparent, we shall describe all the systems involved in vector and matrix notation. Thus we set ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ L1 z1 ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ z1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎥ ⎢ " L = ⎣ ⎦ = =⎢ ⎥ z ⎣ ⎦ z ⎣ ⎦ Lm z z m
m
Appendix: Proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem
49
and rewrite the system (I.97) as "= L
+ Az z z
where Az denotes the matrix ajk z . Let w = Hz be a local diffeomorphism near the origin in Cm satisfying Hz 0 is invertible.
(I.98)
Since + tHz = t Hz + tHz = t Hz w w z w w z a new set of generators for the structure is defined, in the new variables w1 wm , by the system "• = L
+ Bw w w
(I.99)
where Bw =
t
Hz + A tHz
−1
t Hz + A t Hz z=H −1 w
(I.100)
" • then a fortiori we must have If L•1 L•m denote the components of L
L•j L•k = 0
∀j k = 1 m j < k
Writing B = bjk this property is equivalent to m bj bk bk bj b w = 0 ∀j k j < k (I.101) − − − bjr w wj wk r=1 kr wr wr We emphasize: given any local diffeomorphism H satisfying (I.98) then equations (I.101) are satisfied by B = bjk defined by (I.100). The system (I.101) together with the additional equations m bjk j=1
wj
= 0
k = 1 m
(I.102)
make up a system of quasi-linear partial differential equations in the unknowns 2 bjk . Let us write V" = b11 b12 bmm−1 bmm ∈ R2m . Then systems (I.101) and (I.102) can be written as V" + +V" ," V" = 0
(I.103)
where is an elliptic linear operator with constant coefficients and + is a bilinear form in its arguments. It then follows that there is a small number > 0 such that if B0 ≤ then (I.101), (I.102) is elliptic at B in an open
50
Locally integrable structures
neighborhood of the origin. Hence any such B is a real-analytic function of w and the argument will be complete if we can show that a diffeomorphism H satisfying (I.98) can be chosen in such a way that B, defined by (I.100), is a solution of (I.102) satisfying B0 ≤ . We are left to solve the determined system m ! −1 t H z + A t H z t Hz + A t Hz = 0 k = 1 m (I.104) jk j=1 wj whose unknown is Hz Hz (we look at (I.104) as a determined system of 2m real equations). It is important to emphasize that these equations are now being considered in the z1 zm variables. Since Az = O z 2 it is easily seen that H0 z = z satisfies (I.104) at the origin. Furthermore, taking Hz = H0 z + Gz then for ∈ R, small we have −1 t H z + A t H z t Hz + A t Hz = A + t Gz + A F + O2 for some F smooth. Furthermore, since = t Hz−1 − t Hz−1 t H z w z w we obtain = + O wj zj Hence, using once more the fact that Az = O z 2 , we can easily conclude that the linearization of (I.104) at H0 at the origin can be identified, in a natural way, with the complex operator # " m m t t Gz j1 Gz jm G → j=1 zj j=1 zj # " m m 2 G1 2 Gm = j=1 zj zj j=1 zj zj which is clearly elliptic (in the usual sense). We conclude that there are %0 > 0, C > 0 and < 1 such that for every 0 < % ≤ %0 there is a smooth solution H% to (I.104) satisfying H% − H0 C 2 z
z ≤% ≤ C%2+
% ≤ %0
In particular, if % > 0 is small enough we can ensure that:
(I.105)
Notes
51
• H% is a local diffeomorphism near the origin satisfying (I.98); • B defined by (I.100) satisfies B0 ≤ . The proof is complete.
Notes The first treatment of formally and locally integrable structures as presented here appeared in [T4], the main point for this being the discovery of the Approximation Formula by M. S. Baouendi and F. Treves in 1981 ([BT1]); such structures were then studied extensively in [T5]. The pioneering work though seems to be the article by Andreotti-Hill ([AH1]), where the concept of what we now call a real-analytic locally integrable structure was introduced in its full generality. This introductory chapter contains mainly results that have already been presented in standard textbooks. We mention, for instance, the Frobenius theorem, whose proof was taken from L. Hörmander’s book [H4] and the integrability of elliptic vector fields in the plane, of which we give an almost self-contained proof, depending only on very simple facts concerning commutators of certain pseudo-differential operators that can be found, for instance, in [Fo]. As mentioned in the text, Theorem I.12.1 is due to L. Nirenberg ([N2]) and the proof we present was taken from [T5]. Proposition I.16.1 is a particular case of a more general result due to H. Jacobowitz and F. Treves ([JT1]). We also refer to [JT2] where the same authors study, via a category argument, the set of all formally integrable CR structures of rank n on an open subset of R2n+1 whose Levi form has, at each nonzero characteristic point, signature n − 1. Theorem I.17.3 was originally due to M. Kuranishi ([Ku1], [Ku2]) in the case n ≥ 4. Later, T. Akahori ([Ak]) presented an improvement to Kuranishi’s argument which allowed him to prove Theorem I.17.3 also for the case n = 3. The case n = 2 is still an open problem, whereas when n = 1 the conclusion is false, according to [N3] (see also Theorem I.12.1). A proof of Theorem I.17.3 can also be found in [W3]. Finally, Malgrange’s proof of the Newlander–Nirenberg theorem that we presented in the appendix was taken from [N1], where the use of a solvability result on elliptic determined systems of nonlinear partial differential equations makes the argument a bit simpler.
II The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
In this chapter we prove what is probably the most important single result in the theory of locally integrable structures. It states that in a small neighborhood of a given point of the domain of a locally integrable structure , any solution of the equation u = 0 may be approximated by polynomials in a set of a finite number of homogeneous solutions as soon as the solutions in that set are chosen with linearly independent differentials and the number of them is equal to the corank of . Such a set is called a complete set of first integrals of the locally integrable structure. The proof is relatively simple for classical solutions and depends on the construction of a suitable approximation of the identity modeled on the kernel of the heat equation as shown in Section II.1. The extension to distribution solutions is carried out in Section II.2. Section II.3 studies the convergence of the formula in some of the standard spaces used in analysis: Lebesgue spaces Lp , 1 ≤ p < ; Sobolev spaces; Hölder spaces; and (localizable) Hardy spaces hp , 0 < p < . The last section is devoted to applications.
II.1 The approximation theorem Since the approximation formula is of a local nature it will be enough to restrict our attention to a locally integrable structure defined in an open subset of RN over which ⊥ is spanned by the differentials dZ1 dZm of m smooth functions Zj ∈ C , j = 1 m, at every point of . Thus, if n is the rank of , we recall that N = n + m. Given a distribution u ∈ we say that u is a homogeneous solution of and write u = 0 if Lu = 0 52
on U
II.1 The approximation theorem
53
for every local section L of defined on an open subset U ⊂ . Simple examples of homogeneous solutions of are the constant functions and also the functions Z1 Zm , since LZj = #dZj L$ = 0 because dZj ∈ ⊥ , j = 1 m. By the Leibniz rule, any product of smooth homogeneous solutions is again a homogeneous solution, so a polynomial with constant coefficients in the m functions Zj , i.e., a function of the form PZ = c Z = 1 m ∈ Zm c ∈ C (II.1)
≤d
is also a homogeneous solution. The approximation theorem states that any distribution solution u of u = 0 is the weak limit of polynomial solutions such as (II.1). Theorem II.1.1. Let be a locally integrable structure on and assume that dZ1 dZm span ⊥ at every point of . Then, for any p ∈ , there exist two open sets U and W , with p ∈ U ⊂ U ⊂ W ⊂ , such that (i) every u ∈ W that satisfies u = 0 on W is the limit in U of a sequence of polynomial solutions Pj Z1 Zm : u = lim Pj Z in U j→
(ii) if u ∈ C k W the convergence holds in the topology of C k U, k = 0 1 2 . Some well-known approximation results in analysis are particular cases of Theorem II.1.1. Example II.1.2. Let be the locally integrable structure generated over an open set ⊂ C by the Cauchy–Riemann vector field 1 = +i z = x + iy 2 x y Then a distribution solution of u = 0 is just a holomorphic function and the theorem simply states that any holomorphic function can be locally approximated by polynomials in the complex variable z. Later we will give several applications of the approximation theorem but we wish to point out already one interesting consequence. Assume that two points p q ∈ U are such that Zp = Zq and let u ∈ C 0 satisfy u = 0. Then P Zp = P Zq for any polynomial P in m variables and, by the uniform approximation of u on U by polynomials in Z, it follows that up = uq. The fibers of Z in U are, by definition, the equivalence classes
54
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
of the equivalence relation defined by ‘p ∼ q if and only if Zp = Zq’. Thus, every solution u ∈ C 0 of u = 0 is constant on the fibers of Z. In particular, if the differentials of Z1# Zm# span ⊥ over it follows that Z# = Z1# Zm# is constant on the fibers of Z in U . Applying the theorem with Z# in the place of Z we may as well find a neighborhood U # ⊂ U of p such that Z is constant on the fibers of Z# in U # , which shows that the fibers of Z and the fibers of Z# on U # are identical. Thus, in the sense of germs of sets at p, the equivalence classes defined by Z and those defined by any other Z# = Z1# Zm# such that dZ1# dZm# generates ⊥ coincide. This independence of the particular choice of Z allows us to talk about the germs at p of the fibers of which are invariants of the structure. The fact that u is constant on the fibers of Z in U when u = 0, u ∈ C 0 , may be expressed by saying that there exists a function $ u ∈ C 0 ZU such that u =$ u Z. Thus, any continuous solution of u = 0 can be factored as the composition with Z of a continuous function defined on a subset of Cm . In general, the set ZU may be irregular but if it happens to be a submanifold of Cm , then $ u will satisfy in the weak sense the induced Cauchy–Riemann equations on ZU. Hence, at a conceptual level, the theorem links the study of solutions of u = 0 to solutions of the induced Cauchy–Riemann equations on certain sets of Cm . We will prove Theorem II.1.1 in several steps. The first step consists of taking convenient local coordinates in a neighborhood of p. Applying Corollary I.10.2, there exists a local coordinate system vanishing at p, x1 xm t1 tn and smooth, real-valued functions 1 m defined in a neighborhood of the origin and satisfying k 0 0 = 0
dx k 0 0 = 0
k = 1 m
such that the functions Zk , k = 1 m, may be written as Zk x t = xk + ik x t
k = 1 m
(II.2)
on a neighborhood of the origin. To do so we need to assume that the real parts of dZ1 dZm are linearly independent, for which we might have to replace Zj by iZj for some of the indexes j ∈ 1 m . Notice that this will not change the conclusion of the theorem. Thus, we may choose a number R such that if V = q
xq < R tq < R
II.1 The approximation theorem then (II.2) holds in a neighborhood of V and we may assume that j x t 1 < x t ∈ V 2 xk
55
(II.3)
where the double bar indicates the norm of the matrix x x t = j x t/xk as a linear operator in Rm . Modifying the functions k ’s off a neighborhood of V may assume without loss of generality that the functions k x t, k = 1 m, are defined throughout RN , have compact support and satisfy (II.3) everywhere, that is j x t 1 < x t ∈ RN (II.3 ) 2 xk Modifying also off a neighborhood of V we may assume as well that the differentials dZj , j = 1 m, given by (II.2), span ⊥ over RN . Of course, the new structure and the old one coincide on V so any conclusion we draw about the new on V will hold as well for the original . We will make use of the vector fields Lj , j = 1 n and Mk , k = 1 m entirely analogous to those introduced in Chapter I after Corollary I.10.2, with the only difference that here they are defined throughout RN . We recall from Chapter I that the vector fields Mk =
m
k x t
=1
x
k = 1 m
are characterized by the relations Mk Z = k
k = 1 m
and that the vector fields m k −i x tMk Lj = tj k=1 tj
j = 1 n
are linearly independent and satisfy Lj Zk = 0, for j = 1 n, k = 1 m. Hence, L1 Ln span at every point while the N = n + m vector fields L1 Ln M1 Mm are pairwise commuting and span CTp RN , p ∈ RN . Since dZ1 dZm dt1 dtn
span CT ∗ RN
the differential dw of a C 1 function wx t may be expressed in this basis. In fact, we have n m (II.4) dw = Lj w dtj + Mk w dZk j=1
k=1
56
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
which may be checked by observing that Lj Zk = 0 and Mk tj = 0 for 1 ≤ j ≤ n and 1 ≤ k ≤ m, while Lj tk = jk for 1 ≤ j k ≤ n and Mk Zj = jk for 1 ≤ j k ≤ m (jk = Kronecker delta). We now choose the open set W as any fixed neighborhood of V in . In proving the theorem we will assume initially that u is a smooth homogeneous solution of u = 0 defined in W with continuous derivatives of all orders, i.e., u ∈ C W satisfies on W the overdetermined system of equations ⎧ ⎪ L1 u = 0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨L u = 0 2 ⎪ ········· ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ Ln u = 0
(II.5)
Given such u we define a family of functions E u that depend on a real parameter , 0 < < , by means of the formula E ux t = /)m/2
Rm
e− Zxt−Zx 0 ux 0hx det Zx x 0 dx 2
which we now discuss. For = 1 m ∈ Cm we will use the notation
2 = 12 + · · · + m2 , which explains the meaning of Zx t − Zx 0 2 in the formula. The function hx ∈ Cc Rm satisfies hx = 0 for x ≥ R and hx = 1 in a neighborhood of x ≤ R/2 (recall that R was introduced right before (II.3) in the definition of the set V ). Note that since u is assumed to be defined in a neighborhood of V , the product ux 0hx is well-defined on Rm , compactly supported, and of class C . Since Z has m components we may regard Zx as the m × m matrix Zj /xk and denote by det Zx its determinant. Furthermore, since the exponential in the integrand is an entire function of Z1 Zm , the chain rule shows that it satisfies the homogenous system of equations (II.5) and the same holds for E ux t by differentiation under the integral sign. The second step of the proof will be to show that E ux t → ux t as → uniformly for x < R/4 and t < T < R if T is conveniently small. Once this is proved we may approximate in the 2 C topology the exponential e− (for fixed large ) by the partial sum of degree k, Pk , of its Taylor series on a fixed polydisk that contains the set √ Zx t − Zx 0 x x < R t < R , so replacing the exponential in the definition of E by Pk Zx t − Zx 0 we will find polynomials in Zx t that approximate E ux t in the C topology for x < R/4 and
t < T when k is large. Hence, from now on we fix our attention on the
II.1 The approximation theorem
57
convergence of E u → u. We consider the following modification of the operator E : 2 G ux t = /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx t ux thx det Zx x t dx Rm
Notice that in the trivial case in which the functions k , k = 1 m, vanish identically so Zx t = x and det Zx = 1, G is just the convolution of ux 0hx with a Gaussian in Rm , which is a well-known approximation of the identity as → . In general, the functions k do not vanish but they are relatively small because they vanish at the origin and (II.3 ) holds, so G is still an approximation of the identity. The idea is then to prove that G u → u and then estimate the difference R u = G u − E u using the fact that u = 0. Lemma II.1.3. Let B be an m × m matrix with real coefficients and norm B < 1 and set A = I + iB where I is the identity matrix. Then 2 det A e− Ax dx = ) m/2 Rm
Proof. We may write Ax 2 = t AAx · x (the dot indicates the standard inner 2 product in Rm and also its extension as a C-bilinear form to Cm ) so e− Ax = e−Cx·x where the matrix C = t AA has positive definite real part C = I − t BB because B < 1. It is then known that (see, e.g., [H2, page 85]) e−Cx·x dx = ) m/2 det C−1/2 Rm
where the branch of the square root is chosen so det C1/2 > 0 when C is real. Since det C = det A2 the proof is complete. Set hxux t det Zx x t = vx t. For x t fixed, the matrix Zx x t = I + ix x t satisfies the hypotheses of the lemma in view of (II.3 ). Thus, we may write 2 hxux t = ) −m/2 e− Zx xtx vx t dx Rm
Introducing the change of variables x → x + −1/2 x in the integral that defines G u we get −1/2 2 G ux t = ) −m/2 e− Zxt−Zx+ x t vx + −1/2 x t dx Rm
Then G ux t − hxux t = I + J
58
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
where I x t = ) −m/2
2
Rm
e− Zx xtx vx + −1/2 x t − vx t dx
and
J x t = ) −m/2
Rm
e− Zxt−Zx+
−1/2 x t 2
2 − e− Zx xtx vx + −1/2 x t dx 2
2
2
2
To estimate I we observe that e− Zx xtx = e− x + x xtx ≤ e−3 x /4 in view of (II.3 ). We also observe that ,x vx t is bounded in Rm × t ≤ R because v vanishes for large x, so the mean value theorem gives 2 e−3 x /4 x dx ≤ C −1/2
I x t ≤ C −1/2 Rm
showing that I x t → 0 as → uniformly on Rm × t ≤ R . To estimate −1/2 2 2 2 J we first observe that e− Zxt−Zx+ x t − e− Zx xtx ≤ 2e−3 x /4 , so −1/2 2 2
e− Zxt−Zx+ x t − e− Zx xtx dx
J x t ≤ C
x
+ C exp−K 2 /2 Thus, to show that J x t → 0 uniformly we need only estimate the integral on x < K for any large K. When x ≤ K and t ≤ R, the Leibniz quotient 1 = Zx t − Zx + −1/2 x t/ −1/2 converges to 2 = −Zx x tx uniformly in x as → in view of (II.3 ), which also implies that 1 2 ≥ 0 and 2 2 ≥ 0. Since e− is a Lipschitz function on ≥ 0 and 1 2 − 2 2 ≤ C −1/2 (note that 2 remains bounded as x t ∈ RN and
x ≤ K), we have
J x t ≤ CK m −1/2 + C exp−K 2 /2 which shows that J x t → 0 uniformly for x ∈ Rm and t ≤ R as → . Thus, G ux t → hxux t uniformly and the limit hxux t = ux t for x < R/2. We will now estimate the remainder R = G − E by means of Stokes’ theorem. The fact that u satisfies the system (II.5)—which was not used to prove that G u → hu—is essential at this point. For x t ∈ RN fixed consider the m-form on RN given by
x t = /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx t ux t hx dZx t = vx t dZx t
2
II.1 The approximation theorem where dZ = dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZm . Hence, we may write and E ux t = G ux t = Rm ×t
59
Rm ×0
observing that the pullback of dZx t to a slice t = c = const. is given by det Zx x c dx1 ∧ · · · ∧ dxm . Keeping in mind that vanishes identically for x > R and invoking Stokes’ theorem, we have d G ux t − E ux t = Rm × 0t
where 0 t denotes the segment joining the origin of Rn to the point t ∈ Rn . To compute d we will take advantage of expression (II.4). We have d = dv ∧ dZ so the only terms in (II.4) that matter here are those that do not contain dZj , j = 1 m , i.e., d = nj=1 Lj v dtj ∧ dZ. Since the exponential factor in v is an entire function of Z1 Zn , and thus satisfies (II.5) as well as u, we obtain n 2 R ux t = /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx t ux t Lj hx dtj ∧ dZx t m j=1 R × 0t
Assume now that x ≤ R/4 and t ≤ T , where T will be chosen momentarily. We wish to estimate the exponential factor
2 − x−x 2
e− Zxt−Zx t = e xt−x t 2
We have
x t − x t ≤ x t − x t + x t − x t 1 ≤ x − x + C t − t 2 1 ≤ x − x + CT 2 because t ∈ 0 t and t ≤ T . Hence, 1
x t − x t 2 ≤ x − x 2 + 2T 2 2 and
& − Zxt−Zx t 2 & &e & = e2T 2 − x−x 2 /2
where is a bound that depends only on and does not depend on u. Since Lj h vanishes for x ≤ R/2 we have that x ≥ R/2 in all integrands in the expression of R , so x − x ≥ R/4 and
R ux t ≤ Ce2T
2 −R2 /32
60
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
We may now choose T small enough so as to achieve R ux t ≤ Ce−R /33 . This proves that R ux t → 0 uniformly on U = x ≤ R/4 × t ≤ T . Summing up, we have found a neighborhood of the origin U such that for any C -solution u of (II.5) defined in W , E u → u uniformly on U , which partially proves part (i) of the theorem for very regular distributions. The third step is to prove part (ii) of the theorem for k = (the cases 1 ≤ k < will be proved later). The main tool is the use of commutation formulas for the vector fields Mk with G . 2
Lemma II.1.4. For u ∈ C 1 W and k = 1 m the following identity holds: Mk G ux t − G Mk ux t = Mk G ux t 2 = /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx t ux tMk hx det Zx x t dx Rm
(II.6)
Proof. By the symmetry in the variables x and x of the expression Zj x t − Zj x t we have
j = 1 m
jk = Mk x t Dx Zj x t − Zj x t
= −Mk x t Dx Zj x t − Zj x t
Thus, if F is an entire holomorphic function and we set fx x t = FZx t − Zx t we also have, by the chain rule, Mk x t Dx fx t t = −Mk x t Dx fx t t Applying this to F = e− we get, after differentiation under the integral sign that 2
Mk G ux t = −/)m/2 2 Mk x t Dx e− Zxt−Zx t ux thx dZx t Rm
where we have used the fact that the pullback to any slice t = const. of the m-form dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZn is given by det Zx x t dx . Next, using the ‘integration by parts’ formula Mk v w dZ = − v Mk w dZ (II.7) Rm
Rm
II.1 The approximation theorem
61
which is valid if v and w are of class C 1 and one of them has compact support, we get Mk G ux t = /)m/2 2 e− Zxt−Zx t Mk ux thx + ux tMk hx dZx t Rm
which proves (II.6). To complete the proof we show that (II.7) holds. Consider the exact m-form defined by ' k ∧ · · · ∧ dZm k = duv dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZ ' k ∧ · · · ∧ dZm = duv ∧ dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZ where the hat indicates that the factor dZk has been omitted. The pullback of k to the slice t × Rm is exact, so k = 0 (II.8) t ×Rm
Using (II.4) to compute duv and observing that the pullback to the slice of terms that contain a factor dtj vanish, we get k t ×Rm = −1k+1 vMk u + uMk v dZ t ×Rm so (II.8) implies (II.7). Next we prove for the Lj commutation formulas analogous to (II.6). We write Lj = =
m k −i x tMk tj k=1 tj m + jk tj k=1 xk
j = 1 n
We start with a technical lemma. Lemma II.1.5. m jk det Zx det Zx + ≡ 0 tj xk k=1
j = 1 n
(II.9)
Proof. Note that (II.9) says that the vector field det Zx Lj is divergence free, i.e., div det Zx Lj = 0, or that t Lj det Zx = 0 where t Lj is the transpose
62
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
of Lj . Take a test function vx t and consider the compactly supported exact form $ j ∧ · · · ∧ dtn j = d v dZ ∧ dt1 ∧ · · · ∧ dt $ j ∧ · · · ∧ dtn = dv ∧ dZ ∧ dt1 ∧ · · · ∧ dt = −1m+j−1 Lj v dZ ∧ dt = −1m+j−1 Lj v det Zx dx ∧ dt whose integral over RN vanishes, that is, Lj vdet Zx dxdt = v t Lj det Zx dxdt = 0 RN
RN
Since v is arbitrary, Lj det Zx ≡ 0 and (II.9) is proved. t
If g˜ t is a smooth function on Cm × Rn that is holomorphic with respect to and we set gx t = g˜ Zx t t we have, by the chain rule, that Lj gx t =
g˜ Zx t t tj
because Lj Zk = 0, k = 1 m. To take advantage of this fact we may write ˜ uZx t t, where G ux t = /)m/2 G 2 ˜ u t = G e− −Zx t ux thx det Zx x t dx Rm
so Lj G ux t = /)m/2
˜ u G Zx t t tj
To compute the right-hand side of the last identity we write e x t = 2 e− −Zx t , differentiate with respect to tj under the integral sign, and observe that det Zx e uh det Zx e uh = det Zx + e uh tj tj tj m = det Zx Lj e uh − det Zx jk e uh xk k=1 + e uh
det Zx tj
Note that the integral over Rm of the second term of the right-hand side may be written, after integration by parts, as m jk det Zx dx e uh x k k=1
II.2 Distribution solutions
63
so the integral of the second and third terms together yields " # m det Zx + jk det Zx dx = 0 e uh tj k=1 xk in view of (II.9). Since Lj e = 0, we also have that det Zx Lj e uh = det Zx e Lj uh + det Zx e uLj h. This shows that ˜ ˜ Lj u t + e x tuLj h det Zx x t dx G u t = G tj When = Zx t we obtain Lemma II.1.6. For u ∈ C 1 W and j = 1 m the following identity holds: Lj G ux t − G Lj ux t = Lj G ux t 2 e− Zxt−Zx t ux tLj hx det Zx x t dx = /)m/2 Rm
(II.10)
Let us assume now that u ∈ C W satisfies u = 0 and we wish to prove that E ux t → ux t in C U. We have already proved that G u → hu uniformly in t ≤ T × Rm . Since Lj Mk u = Mk Lj u = 0, 1 ≤ j ≤ n, 1 ≤ k ≤ m, Mk u is a smooth solution of the system, so we also have that G Mk u → hMk u uniformly on t ≤ T ×Rm . Now, the expression (II.6) of Mk G u is almost identical to that of G , the only difference being that h has been replaced by Mk h, so Mk G u → Mk hu. Restricting our attention to U where h = 1 and Mk h = 0, we conclude that Mk G u = G Mk u + Mk G u → Mk u uniformly on U as → . A similar conclusion can be obtained for Lj G u using (II.10) instead of (II.6), that is, Lj G u → Lj u uniformly on U . Since any first-order derivative D may expressed as a linear combination with smooth coefficients of the Mk ’s and the Lj ’s, we see that DG u → Du uniformly on U . This shows that G u → u in C 1 U. Of course, the argument can be iterated for higher-order derivatives to conclude that G u → u in C U.
II.2 Distribution solutions We continue the proof of Theorem II.1.1, keeping the notations of Section II.1. In order to extend the arguments of the previous section to a distribution u ∈ W such that u = 0—which is the fourth step of the proof of Theorem II.1.1—it is enough to check the following facts: (a) E u is well-defined for u ∈ W; (b) G u is well-defined for u ∈ W;
64
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
(c) G u → u in U as → for u ∈ W; (d) R u = G u − E u → 0 in U as → for u ∈ W. We start by observing that since u satisfies the system of equations (II.5) on a neighborhood of V , the wave front set WFu of u is contained in the characteristic set of and therefore does not intersect the set
x t < R = 0
x t 0 ∈ RN × RN
for some R > R. Thus, WFhu is contained in the same set and, in particular, the restriction of u to W belongs to C t ≤ R x < R On the connection between wave front sets and restrictions of distributions, we refer to [H2, chapter VIII]. Moreover, since V = x < R × t < R is relatively compact in W we may assume that t → u· t is a continuous function with values in the L2 based local Sobolev space L2s loc BR of order s, for all t ≤ R and some real s, where BR denotes the ball of radius R centered at the origin of Rm (for the definition of local Sobolev spaces see Section II.3.2 below). Thus, for any t ≤ R, the trace u· t is well-defined and belongs to L2s loc BR . Then, E ux t (resp. G ux t) is well-defined if we interpret the integral as duality between the distribution u· 0 and the test function 2 /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx 0 hx det Zx x 0 (resp. u· t and the test function 2 /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx t hx det Zx x t). This takes care of (a) and (b). To prove (d), it is convenient to express R u by a reinterpretation of the formula obtained for smooth u using Stokes’ theorem. We point out that the formula could also have been written as n rj x t t dtj (II.11) R ux t =
0t j=1
where rj x t t = /)m/2
Rm
e− Zxt−Zx t ux t Lj hx det Zx x t dx 2
(II.12) and 0 t denotes the straight segment joining 0 to t. In other words, by integrating first in x we may express the integral of an m + 1-form over the cell Rm × 0 t as the integral of a 1-form over the segment 0 t . In this form, Stokes’ theorem is just a restatement of the fundamental theorem of calculus for a 1-form. To prove this claim, write for fixed and 2 ˜ u t = e− −Zx t ux t hx det Zx x t dx gt = G Rm
II.2 Distribution solutions Then, gt − g0 =
65
n g t dtj
0t j=1 tj
(∗)
To compute the derivatives of g we write e x t = e− −Zx t , differentiate with respect to tj under the integral sign, and recall that 2
det Zx e uh det Zx e uh = det Zx + e uh tj tj tj m e uh = det Zx Lj e uh − det Zx jk xk k=1 + e uh
det Zx tj
a fact we already used in the proof of (II.10). Once again, the integral over Rm of the second term of the right-hand side may be written, after integrating by parts, as m jk det Zx dx e uh k=1 xk so the integral of the second and third terms together yields " # m det Zx + jk det Zx dx = 0 e uh tj k=1 xk in view of (II.9). Since Lj e u = 0, we also have that det Zx Lj e uh = det Zx e uLj h. This shows that g t = r˜j t tj where r˜j t =
Rm
(∗∗)
e− −Zx t ux t Lj hx det Zx x t dx 2
Hence, (∗) for = Zx t gives an alternative proof of the fact that R u = G u − E u as given by (II.11) and (II.12). Notice that (II.12) makes sense if u ∈ C t ≤ R x < R as soon as we change the integral symbol by the duality pairing between the distribution u· t and the appropriate test function; furthermore, R u = G u − E u is still given by (II.11) and (II.12) in the case of distribution solutions since (∗∗) is easily seen to remain valid in this case. Note also that R ux t is a smooth function of x t. We will prove a stronger form of (d).
66
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
Proposition II.2.1. Let u ∈ W satisfy the system (II.5). Then, R ux t → 0 in C U
(II.13)
Proof. We already saw that the exponential in (II.12) may be majorized by e−c for some positive constant c > 0 when x < R/4, x ≥ R/2, t < T and t ∈ 0 T . Let $x denote the Laplacian in Rm . For k ∈ Z+ we may write Lj hx ux t det Zx x t =(x 1 − $x k 1 − $x −k Lj hx ux t det Zx x t where (x is a cut-off function that vanishes for x ≤ R/4 such that (x Lj hx = Lj hx . Let us write vj x t = 1 − $x −k Lj hx ux t det Zx x t It follows that vj ∈ C 0 V for an appropriate choice of k and we may write, after an integration by parts, 2 rj x t t = /)m/2 vj x t 1 − $x k (x e− Zxt−Zx t dx Indeed, the convolution operator 1 − $−k fx =
1 ix· f d e 1 + 2 −k$ 2)m
f ∈ Rm
maps continuously L2s Rm onto L2s+2k Rm and the latter is contained in L Rm ∩ C 0 Rm if s + 2k > m/2 by Sobolev’s embedding theorem. Hence, rj x t t is continuous with respect to t and converges to 0 uniformly for x ≤ R/2 t ≤ t ≤ T , as → , since the derivatives in 1 − $x k produce powers of that are dominated by the exponential e−c . Hence, R ux t → 0 uniformly as → and it is easy to see, by differentiating (II.11), that the same holds for the derivatives of any order with respect to x and t of R ux t, as we wished to prove. Finally, it is enough to prove that (c) holds assuming that u ∈ C 0 t ≤ Let us start with the case k = 0. We assume R L2k loc BR for some integer k. 2 0 that u ∈ C t ≤ R Lloc BR (with R slightly larger that R) and we wish to prove that
G ux t − ux t 2 dx → 0 uniformly in t ≤ T
x ≤R/4
II.2 Distribution solutions
67
which certainly implies (c) in this case. Redefining u by zero off BR × Rn we may assume that ux t ∈ L2 Rm for each fixed t, t ≤ T . Using once more (II.3 ), we see that for any x x ∈ Rm and t ∈ Rn
Zx t − Zx t 2 = x − x 2 − x t − x t 2 ≥ 3/4 x − x 2 so the exponential inside the integral that defines G u has a bound 2 2
e− Zxt−Zx t ≤ e−3 x−x /4 . If we set F x = m/2 e−3 x /4 2
0 < <
we easily conclude for fixed t ≤ R that
G ux t ≤ C F ∗ u x t where the convolution is performed in the x variable and t plays the role of a parameter. Since F L1 = F1 L1 = C, Young’s inequality for convolution implies sup G u· tL2 Rm ≤ C sup u· tL2 Rm
t ≤T
(II.14)
t ≤T
On the other hand, we proved in Section II.1 that if u ∈ Cc V then G u → u uniformly in U = BR/4 × t < T , which implies convergence in the mixed norm space C 0 t ≤ T L2 BR/4 . So the operator G U convergesto the restriction operator u → u U , as → , on a dense subset of C 0 t ≤ because of T L2 BR and the family of operators G U is equicontinuous (II.14). Thus, G u U → u U in the whole space C 0 t ≤ T L2 BR . a cut-off Assume now that u ∈ C 0 t ≤ T L21 BR , R > R. Introducing function we may assume that u ∈ C 0 t ≤ T L21 Rm without modifying u for x < R. Thus, for t ≤ T fixed, we see that u, u/xk and u/tj are in L2 Rm for 1 ≤ k ≤ m, 1 ≤ j ≤ n. Since we are assuming that x t is compactly supported, the coefficients of Lj and Mk are bounded, with bounded derivatives. In particular, Lj u and Mk u are in L2 Rm for 1 ≤ k ≤ m, 1 ≤ j ≤ n, uniformly in t ≤ T . To obtain the convergence result for k = 1 we will be able to reason as with the case k = 0 as soon as we prove an estimate analogous to (II.14) for the L21 norm, i.e., sup G u· tL21 Rm ≤ C sup u· tL21 Rm
t ≤T
(II.15)
t
≤T
Any first-order derivative with respect to x is a linear combination with bounded coefficients of the Mk ’s, so it is enough to prove for t ≤ T , 1 ≤ k ≤ m, 1 ≤ j ≤ n, that
68
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula Mk G u· tL2 Rm ≤ C sup u· tL21 Rm
(II.16)
t ≤T
Writing Mk G = Mk G + G Mk we are led to estimate G Mk uL2 and Mk G uL2 . By (II.14) we have G Mk uL2 ≤ CMk uL2 ≤ C uL21 . Notice that an estimate like (II.14) holds as well with Mk G in the place of G because G and Mk G have very similar kernels, as (II.10) shows. Thus, Mk G uL2 ≤ CuL21 , which proves (II.16) and gives (II.15). This process can be continued to prove sup G u· tL2k Rm ≤ Ck sup u· tL2k Rm
t ≤T
t
≤T
k = 1 2
(II.17)
To deal with the case in which k is a negative integer, i.e., k = − k = −k, we consider a slight modification of G , namely, G ux = hxG ux. Of course, G u U = G u U because hx = 1 for x ≤ R/2, so this change will not affect our conclusions for x ≤ R/4. The advantage of considering G is that for fixed t it becomes a formally symmetric operator in the xvariables, as soon as we use the pairing given by the complex measure dZx t = det Zx x t dx. More precisely, for fixed t and v w ∈ Cc Rm we have #G v w$ = #v G w$ where we are using the notation #a b$ = axbx det Zx x t dx, when a b ∈ C Rm and one of them has compact support. Thus, G u· tL2k Rm ≤ C =C ≤C
sup
#G u· t w$
sup
#u· t G w$
sup
u· tL2k G wL2k
w∈Cc Rm wL2k ≤1 w∈Cc Rm wL2k ≤1 w∈Cc Rm wL2k ≤1
(II.18)
≤ Cu· tL2k where we have used (II.17) for the positive integer k in the last inequality. This extends (II.17) to all integers k ∈ Z, proving the equicontinuity of G in all spaces C 0 t ≤ T L2k BR , k ∈ Z, which together with the convergence of G u U to u U for the space of test functions Cc BR × t ≤ T which is dense in any C 0 t ≤ T L2k BR proves that G u → u in C 0 t ≤ T L2k BR/4 for any u ∈ C 0 t ≤ T L2k BR . This proves (c) and concludes the proof of part (i) of Theorem II.1.1.
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
69
To prove part (ii) of the theorem—this is the fifth and final step of the proof—using the same method of proof, it will be enough to prove the equicontinuity of G on the spaces C j t ≤ T Cbk Rm j k = 0 1 2 where Cbk Rm is the space of functions on Rm possessing continuous bounded derivatives of order ≤ k. For j k = 0 this is easily achieved by noting that
G ux t ≤ C F ∗ u x t ≤ C uC 0 t ≤T C 0 Rm b
For j k ≤ 1 one expresses the derivatives in terms of the vector fields Lj and Mk and reduces the equicontinuity for the norms of C j t ≤ T Cbk Rm to the case j = k = 0 by introduction of the commutators G Lj and G Mk , as was done before for Sobolev norms; iteration of this process gives the result for k = 2 3 This concludes the proof of Theorem II.1.1.
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces As proved in Proposition II.2.1, R u = G u − E u → 0 in C U, for any distribution u satisfying u = 0 in a larger open set V . This reduces the problem of the convergence E u → u in any space with coarser topology than C -topology to the convergence of G u → u in the same space. Now, as the reader probably noticed in the proof of Theorem II.1.1, the operator G is very close to convolution with a Gaussian in the x-variables with t playing the role of a parameter, and as such it is a very well-behaved approximation of the identity. Hence, loosely speaking, we may expect that the convergence G u → u on U holds in the topology of many functional spaces used in analysis, provided that u belongs to that space over the larger set V . In this section we deal with this question and the approach will always be the same: to prove convergence in a given space of distributions XU we will first prove the equicontinuity of G in the space XRN and then try to apply the standard fact that under the hypotheses of equicontinuity it is enough to check the convergence on a convenient dense subset of XV. Usually the dense subset will be the space of test functions * ∈ Cc V, for which we know that G * → * in C U . Thus, this approach works if (i) XV is a normal space of distributions (i.e., Cc V is dense in XV), and (ii) C U ⊂ XU with continuous inclusion. We have already applied this principle in the proof of Theorem II.1.1 with XV = C 0 t ≤ R L2k BR .
70
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
II.3.1 Convergence in L p The main result of this subsection is: Theorem II.3.1. Let be a locally integrable structure on and assume that dZ1 dZm span ⊥ at every point of . Then, for any z ∈ , there exist two open sets U and W , with z ∈ U ⊂ U ⊂ W ⊂ , such that for any u ∈ Lploc W, 1 ≤ p ≤ , satisfying u = 0, E ux t −→ ux t a.e. in U as → .
(II.19)
In case p is finite, i.e., 1 ≤ p < , we also have E ux t −→ ux t in Lp U as → .
(II.20)
In (II.19) and (II.20) we may replace the operator E by a convenient sequence of polynomials in Z, P Z1 Zm . In the proof of Theorem II.3.1 we may assume from the start by shrinking W that u ∈ Lp W and we will do so. We are also tacitly assuming that we are using special coordinates x t adapted to a given set of local generators dZ1 dZm of ⊥ with linearly independent real parts so that Z = x + ix t, where x t is smooth, real, has compact support and satisfies (II.3 ). Once the special coordinates x t are fixed, the operator E referred to in (II.19) and (II.20) is defined precisely as in the proof of Theorem II.1.1. We will also prove below theorems similar to Theorem II.3.1 for different norms and in all of them the first step will be to choose special local coordinates where Z has this special form where the operators E and G are defined and have good convergence properties. To avoid repetitions we will always assume that this step has already been carried out, even if not mentioned explicitly. According to the considerations made at the beginning of the section, we need only prove that G u −→ hu
in
Lp W
−→
u ∈ Lp W
(II.21)
For 1 ≤ p < , the space Cc0 W is dense in Lp W and (II.20) will be a consequence of G u −→ hu
uniformly
−→
u ∈ Cc0 W
(which we already know by Theorem II.1.1) and the uniform bound that we will prove later: G up ≤ Cup where p denotes the Lp -norm.
u ∈ Lp RN
> 0
(II.22)
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
71
Let us set W = Bx × Bt , where Bx = x < R and Bt = t < R . Let u ∈ Lp W and set ut x = ux t. Fubini’s theorem guarantees that ut is defined for a.e. t, it is measurable, and it belongs to Lp Bx . If, moreover, u satisfies u = 0, we know that u has a trace Tt u and Bt t → Tt u ∈ Bx is a smooth function. It will be useful to compare both types of restrictions of u to the slices t = const. Lemma II.3.2. If u ∈ Lp W 1 ≤ p ≤ , and u is a solution of the system (II.5) then Tt u = ut for a.e. t ∈ Bt . In particular, Tt u ∈ Lp Bx for a.e. t ∈ Bt . Proof. We take functions ∈ Cc Bx and * ∈ Cc Bt . We know that t → #Tt u $ is a C -function defined in Bt , t → #ut $ belongs to Lp Bt and ux tx dx *t dt #Tt u $*t dt = (II.23) = #ut $*t dt If we take *t = (j t −t0 , (j t = j n (jt, 0 ≤ ( ∈ Cc t ≤ 1 , (dt = 1, and let j → , the left-hand side of (II.23) converges for every t ∈ Bt to #Tt u $ while the right-hand side converges a.e. to #ut $. Hence, there is a null set N ⊂ Bt such that ∈ Cc
#Tt u $ = #ut $
t % N
If we apply the last identity to a dense sequence k ⊂ Cc Bx and set N = Nn we obtain that Tt u = ut as elements of Bx when t is not in the null set N . Remark II.3.3. One cannot expect in general that, under the conditions of Lemma II.3.2, Tt u ∈ Lp for all t. For instance, if = −1 1 × −1 1 ⊂ R2 , Z = x + it2 /2, L = t − itx is the Mizohata operator and ux t = 1/Zx t, it is simple to verify that u ∈ Lp for 1 ≤ p < 3/2, Lu = 0 in the sense of distributions and Tt u ∈ C −1 1 ⊂ L −1 1 ⊂ Lp −1 1 for t = 0 but for t = 0 we have T0 u = pv1/x − i)x % Lp −1 1. We now prove Theorem II.3.1. Consider the maximal operator associated with G u: G∗ ux t = sup G ux t ≥1
We claim that, for u ∈ L1 , there exists a constant C > 0 such that G∗ ux t ≤ CMhxTt ux
(II.24)
72
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
for any t such that Tt u ∈ L1 Bx . Here Mfx t = sup r>0
1
fx t dx
Bx r Bxr
is the Hardy–Littlewood maximal operator acting in the x-variable, Bx r is the ball of radius r centered at x, and Bx r denotes its Lebesgue measure. In fact, G ux t can be estimated by 2 2 /)m/2 e− x−x − xt−x t Tt ux
hx
detZx x t dx Rm
and this expression can be dominated by the maximal operator 2 sup F ∗ h Tt u det Zx = C sup m/2 e−3 x−x /4 ≥1
Rm
≥1
Tt ux
hx
det Zx x t dx where F x = C m/2 e−3 x
2 /4
and C is a constant. Hence, G∗ ux t ≤ sup F ∗ h Tt u detZx ≤ CMh·Tt u·x ≥1
The last inequality follows from the fact that F1 x = Ce−3 x /4 is radial decreasing and belongs to L1 Rm (see, for instance, [S1, page 62]). Thus, (II.24) is proved. If u ∈ Cc0 W, we know that G ux t → hxux t → uniformly. The standard properties of the maximal operator allow us to conclude that for any t ∈ Bt such that Tt ux ∈ L1 Bx there exists a subset Nt ⊂ Bx with
Nt = 0 such that 2
G ux t → hxux t
x % Nt
Hence, if we choose x t ∈ U such that Tt u ∈ L1 Bx and x % Nt , we get (recalling that R u → 0 uniformly in U ) E ux t → hxux t = ux t ae in U and therefore E ux t → ux t a.e. in U as we wished to prove. We now prove (II.22). We observe that
G ux t ≤ F ∗ h Tt u det Zx and then Young’s inequality for convolution implies G u· tLp dx ≤ F 1 h Tt u det Zx Lp dx ≤ CTt uLp dx
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
73
since the L1 norm of F does not depend on and h det Zx is bounded. Raising this inequality to the pth power and integrating with respect to t we obtain (II.22). Since G u → hu uniformly in W as → when u is continuous, the usual density argument shows that (II.21) holds for 1 ≤ p < . Thus, (II.19) and (II.20) have been proved. Finally, since E u can be approximated in C U by polynomials in Z for fixed , the proof is complete. It is obvious that (II.20) is, in general, false for p = because the uniform limit of a sequence of continuous functions, such as E ux t, is continuous. A simple consequence of Theorem II.3.1 is: Corollary II.3.4. Let be a locally integrable structure over a C manifold U and let u ∈ Lploc U, 1 ≤ p ≤ , v ∈ Lqloc U, 1/p + 1/q = 1, be solutions of the system (II.5). Then the product w = uv ∈ L1loc U also satisfies (II.5). Proof. By localization we may assume that U is the neighborhood where the conclusions of Theorem II.3.1 hold. Set u = E u, w = u v. Leibniz’s rule shows that w = 0, as u ∈ C U. By Theorem II.3.1 and Hölder’s inequality w → w in L1loc U, → , showing that w = 0 in the sense of distributions.
II.3.2 Convergence in Sobolev spaces In this subsection we prove Theorem II.3.5. Let be a locally integrable structure with first integrals Z1 Zm , defined in a neighborhood of the closure of W = Bx × Bt . There exists a neighborhood U ⊂ W of the origin such that for any u ∈ Lps loc W, 1 < p < , s ∈ R, satisfying u = 0, E ux t −→ ux t in Lps loc U
−→
(II.25)
As usual, we may replace the operator E in (II.25) by a convenient sequence of polynomials in Z, P Z1 Zm . We recall that for 1 ≤ p ≤ s ∈ R, Lps RN = f ∈ RN f ps = #s f p < where #s fx = −1 1 + 2 s/2 f x and denotes the Fourier transform in RN (#s is the Bessel potential and denotes the space of tempered distributions). For k ∈ Z+ and p in the range 1 < p < the space Lpk RN is exactly the subspace of the functions in Lp RN whose derivatives of
74
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
order ≤k in the sense of distributions belong to Lp RN . This space is equivalently normed by ([S1]) uLpk =
D up
(II.26)
≤k
The space Lps loc is the subspace of of the distributions u such that p N *u ∈ Ls R for all test functions * ∈ Cc , equipped with the locally convex topology given by the seminorms u → *ups , * ∈ Cc . Fix p ∈ 1 , s ∈ R and choose the open sets U and W as in Theorem II.1.1. The theorem will be proved if we show that
lim G v = h v
→
in
Lps W
∀v ∈ Cc W
(II.27)
and there exists a positive constant C such that G wps ≤ Cwps
∀w ∈ Lps RN
(II.28)
Indeed, (II.27) and (II.28) imply as usual, by density and triangular approximation, that G w − hwps → 0 as → for any w ∈ Lps RN ∩ W— where W denotes the space of distributions compactly supported in W —which implies that G w → w in the topology of Lps loc U. We know that for u ∈ Cc U, G u → u in C U, thus (II.27) is clearly true and we need only worry about proving (II.28), which we prove first for a positive integer s = k ∈ Z+ . The vector fields Lj and Mk form a basis of CT Rn and we may express the derivatives D in (II.26) in terms of the vector fields Lj , j = 1 n, Mk , k = 1 m. This gives G wLpk ≤ C
M 1 L2 G wp
(II.29)
1 + 2 ≤k
We write Lj G w = G Lj w + Lj G w Mk G w = G Mk w + Mk G w As shown in Lemmas II.1.4 and II.1.6, the operators Lj G and Mk G are given by the same expression as G with hx replaced respectively by Lj hx and Mk hx. Hence, the proof of Theorem II.3.1 gives bounds in Lp for the commutators that may be written as Lj G vp + Mk G vp ≤ Cvp
v ∈ Lp RN
(II.30)
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
75
Thus, for 1 ≤ j ≤ n, 1 ≤ k ≤ m, Lj G wp + Mk G wp ≤ CLj wp + Mk wp + wp ≤ Cwp1 + wp ≤ Cwp1
(II.31)
where we have used (II.22) to estimate G Lj w and G Mk w in the first inequality. Thus, combining (II.26) for u = G w and k = 1 with (II.31) we get (II.28) for k = 1. This reasoning can be iterated for any s = k ∈ Z+ and the theorem is proved for s ∈ Z+ . To prove (II.28) for nonintegral s > 0, we use interpolation of Sobolev spaces (on the subject of interpolation see, for instance, [C1] and [C2]). First we take k ∈ Z+ such that 0 < s < k. The operator G is of type p p 0 0 and also of type p p k k k ∈ Z+ , that is, it verifies G wp ≤ Cwp
w ∈ Cc RN
and G wpk ≤ Cwpk
w ∈ Cc RN
By complex interpolation we obtain that G is of type p p s s; that is, (II.28) holds for 0 < s < k and w ∈ Cc RN and by density it also holds for w ∈ Lps RN . Finally, to prove (II.28) for s < 0, we invoke a slight variation of the duality argument that was used to extend (II.18) from positive integers to negative integers: we consider the modification of G , G ux = hxG ux which is formally symmetric in the x-variables for fixed t for the pairing given by integration with respect to dZx t = det Zx x t dx and thus also symmetric in both variables x and t for the pairing given by integration with respect to dZx t ∧ dt = det Zx x t dxdt. Since this is a nonsingular continuous pairing for the spaces Lps RN and Lq−s RN , 1/p + 1/q = 1, it extends (II.28) to s < 0 as follows: G wLps RN ≤ C ≤C ≤C
sup *∈Cc RN *Lq ≤1 −s
sup *∈Cc RN *Lq ≤1 −s
sup *∈Cc RN *Lq ≤1 −s
#G w· t *$
#w G *$ wLps G *Lq−s
≤ Cs wLps RN
76
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
where in the last inequality we used (II.28) with q in the place of p and −s > 0 in the place of s. Thus, (II.28) is completely proved and the proof of Theorem II.3.5 is complete.
II.3.3 Convergence in Hölder spaces Let ⊂ R be an open, bounded, convex set. The Hölder space C is defined as N
C = u ∈ C k u < where u = u + u 0
u 0 = sup ux x∈
ux − uy
x − y xy∈
u = sup
0 < ≤ 1
x=y
u =
D u −k
k < ≤ k + 1
k ∈ Z+
u ∈ C k
≤k
The spaces C RN are defined similarly. The approximation theorem is: Theorem II.3.6. Let be a locally integrable structure with first integrals Z1 Zm , defined in a neighborhood of the closure of W = Bx × Bt . There exists a convex neighborhood U ⊂ of the origin such that for any u ∈ C W, > 0 satisfying u = 0 in a neighborhood of W and any 0 ≤ < E ux t −→ ux t in C U
−→
(II.32)
As usual, we may replace the operator E in (II.32) by a convenient sequence of polynomials in Z, P Z1 Zm . Proof. As always, since Cc W is dense in Cc W for the C norm, we need only prove G u −→ u
in
C W
u ∈ Cc W
and the inequality G u ≤ Cu
u ∈ Cc W
It is obvious that G u − u → 0 when → , u ∈ Cc W, because by Theorem II.1.1 G u → u, → in C k W for every positive integer k. We may assume without loss of generality, as we always do, that Zx t = x + ix t is defined and satisfies (II.3 ) throughout RN and reduces to
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
77
Zx t ≡ x for x t outside a compact set. We shall then prove G u ≤ Cu
u ∈ Cc RN
(II.33)
We assume first that 0 < < 1. It will be useful to use the following well-known characterization of C RN ([S2, page 256]): Lemma II.3.7. A function u belongs to C RN , 0 < < 1, if and only if there exist a sequence of functions uk ∈ C 1 RN , bounded and with bounded gradients, such that (i) uk L ≤ K 2−k , k = 0 1 (ii) ,uk L ≤ K 21−k , k = 0 1 N (iii) uz = k=0 uk z, z ∈ R . It also follows that the best constant K in (i) and (ii) above is proportional to u . Such a sequence is usually called a sequence of best approximation for u. We start by writing u = uk with uk a sequence of best approximation for u. Then, G u = G uk and we need to estimate the essential supremum of G uk and ,G uk . Taking account of (II.22) with p = and (i) of Lemma II.3.7 we derive G uk L ≤ Cuk L ≤ CK2−k
k ∈ Z+
(II.34)
In order to estimate ,G uk it is convenient to express any partial derivative in terms of the vector fields Lj and M , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, 1 ≤ ≤ m. Then, we are led to estimate Lj G uk , j = 1 n and M G uk , = 1 m. We may write Lj G uk = G Lj uk + Lj G uk and recall that Lj G uk L ≤ Cuk L which follows from (II.30) with p = . We get Lj G uk L ≤ CLj uk L + uk L ≤ C,uk L + uk L
j = 1 n
k = 1 2
Similar estimates are true for M G uk , = 1 m, k ∈ Z+ and we obtain ,G uk L ≤ Cuk L + ,uk L ≤ C K21−k
k ∈ Z+
(II.35)
Thus, (II.34), (II.35) and Lemma II.3.7 imply that (II.33) holds for 0 < < 1. Let us assume next that there is a positive integer k such that = k + , 0 < < 1 and we wish to estimate D G u ≤ C M 1 L2 G u G u ∼
≤k
1 + 2 ≤k
78
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
Using the commutation formulas of Lemmas II.1.4 and II.1.6 it is easy to prove (II.33) by induction on k, adapting the reasonings we used to deal with Sobolev norms of integral order in Section II.3.2; we leave the details to the reader. Finally, to prove (II.33) for = k = 1 2 , we observe that in this case u = uk ∼ uLk so (II.33) is a variation of the estimates already considered for Sobolev norms. This completes the proof of Theorem II.3.6.
It is not possible to take = in Theorem II.3.6, as we will see next. Example II.3.8. Consider in R2 , where we denote the coordinates by x t, the structure spanned by t with first integral Zx t = x and let 0 < ≤ 1. Consider a function ux ∈ Cc R2 independent of t (so it satisfies u = 0) such that ux = x for x ≤ 1. If wx t is of class C 1 in a neighborhood of the origin, we have for 0 < - < 1 sufficiently small,
u − w ≥
u- − w- 0 − u0 − w0 0 ≥ 1 − C-1− -
and the left-hand side is ≥ 1/2 for - small, showing that u cannot be approximated by continuously differentiable functions in the C topology.
II.3.4 Convergence in Hardy spaces We recall that the real Hardy space H p RN , 0 < p < , introduced by Stein and Weiss ([SW]), is equal to Lp RN for p > 1, is properly contained in L1 RN for p = 1, and is a space of not necessarily locally integrable distributions for 0 < p < 1. For p ≤ 1, H p RN is a substitute for Lp RN ([S2]), as the latter is not a space of distributions and has trivial dual if p < 1; even for p = 1, L1 RN does not behave as well as Lp RN , 1 < p < , for example on questions concerning the continuity of pseudo-differential operators. Let us choose a function ! ∈ RN , with !dz = 0 and write !- z = -−N !z/-, z ∈ RN , and M! fz = sup !- ∗ fz 0<-<
Then ([S2]) H p RN = f ∈ RN
M! f ∈ Lp RN
An obstacle to the localization of the elements of H p RN , 0 < p ≤ 1, is that *u may not belong to H p RN for * ∈ Cc RN and u ∈ H p RN . A way
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
79
around this is the definition of localizable Hardy spaces hp RN ([G],[S2]) by means of the truncated maximal function m! fz = sup !- ∗ fz 0<-≤1
h R = f ∈ RN p
N
m! f ∈ Lp RN
It turns out that if ! is replaced in the definition of hp RN by any other function ! ∈ R only required to satisfy ! = 0, this will not change the space hp RN . It is also known that the space hp RN is stable under multiplication by test functions and also that hp RN = Lp RN for 1 < p < . For 0 < p ≤ 1, which we henceforth assume, hp RN is a metric space with the distance df g = m! f − gzp dz. If ⊂ RN is an open set, the p is the subspace of of the distributions u such that space Hloc p *u ∈ h RN for all test functions * ∈ Cc . A sequence un converges p if *un → 0 in hp RN for every * ∈ Cc . We have to zero in Hloc Theorem II.3.9. Let be a locally integrable structure with first integrals Z1 Zm , defined in a neighborhood of the closure of W = Bx × Bt . There p W, exists a neighborhood U ⊂ W of the origin such that for any u ∈ Hloc 0 < p < , satisfying u = 0, p U E ux t −→ ux t in Hloc
−→
(II.36)
As usual, we may replace the operator E in (II.36) by a convenient sequence of polynomials in Z, P Z1 Zm . p Proof. Since Hloc W = Lploc W for p > 1, Theorem II.3.9 follows from Theorem II.3.1 for these values of p and it is enough to assume that 0 < p ≤ 1. p W and the theorem may The space Cc W is continuously included in Hloc be proved by showing once again that
lim G v = h v
→
in hp RN
∀v ∈ Cc W
(II.37)
G whp ≤ Cwhp ∀w ∈ hp RN (II.38) with the notation whp = m! wzp dz1/p , in spite of the fact that w → whp is not a norm for p < 1. To prove (II.37) and (II.38) we use the atomic decomposition of hp ([G],[S2]). An hp atom, p ≤ 1, is a bounded, compactly supported function az satisfying the following property: there exists a cube Q with sides parallel to the coordinate axes that contains the support of a and furthermore
80
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
(i) az ≤ Q −1/p , a.e., with Q denoting the Lebesgue measure of Q; (ii) z az dz = 0, ≤ N1/p − 1, if the side length of Q happens to be less than 1. Notice that if the support of a is contained in a cube Q such that (i) holds and the side of Q has length ≥ 1, then a is an atom, as condition (ii) is vacuous and only (i) is required in this case. As always, (II.37) follows from the convergence G v → v in Cc , v ∈ Cc . So, to prove Theorem II.3.9, we need only show (II.38) and the density of Cc RN in hp RN . To prove the density, it is enough to approximate hp atoms by smooth hp atoms in the hp norm. This is simply approximating a rough atom a by the convolution a- = a ∗ *- , where *- z = -−N *z/-, and * ∈ Cc RN has integral equal to 1. Then, a- satisfies the vanishing moments condition (ii) because a does and satisfies (i) for a cube Q slightly larger than the one that worked for a, if - > 0 is sufficiently small. Moreover, a- → a in the hp ‘norm’ as - → 0. To check the last fact use Hölder’s inequality to write m! a − a- zp dz ≤ Q 1−p/2 m! a − a- L2 ≤ C Q 1−p/2 Ma − a- L2 ≤ C Q 1−p/2 a − a- L2 where we have majorized the maximal function m! a − a- by the Hardy–Littlewood maximal function Ma − a- which is continuous in L2 . Any w ∈ hp can be written as a convergent series in hp , w = k k ak , where the ak are atoms and k are complex numbers such that k k p ∼ whp ([S2]) (since atoms may be approximated by smooth atoms we may even assume that ak ∈ Cc RN for all k). Then, to prove (II.38) it is enough to verify that there is a constant C > 0 such that for all hp atoms az (II.39) G aphp = m! G azp dz ≤ C ≥ 1 Indeed,
" m ! G
#p k ak
dz ≤
k
≤
#p
"
k m! G ak
k
k p
dz
m! G ak p dz
k
because p ≤ 1. We assume without loss of generality that ! ≥ 0 is supported in the unit ball (in fact, changing the function ! by any other function in RN
II.3 Convergence in standard functional spaces
81
with nonvanishing integral will produce an equivalent ‘norm’ in H p RN ). 2 We set Fx = e−3 x /4 , x ∈ Rm , F x = −m Fs/ and we check that by the estimates of Section II.3.1 (see (II.24)): x
!- ∗ G ax t ≤ C !- ∗ F ∗ ax t x
= C !- ∗ a ∗ F x t
= −1/2
x
where the symbol ∗ denotes convolution in the x-variable. Let Q = Q1 × Q2 , Q1 ⊂ Cm , Q2 ⊂ Cn , be a cube containing the support of a. Thus, invoking (i), we get m! G ax t ≤ C Q −1/p (Q2 t
(II.40)
Here and in the sequel, (A will denote the characteristic function of a measurm able set A. Let Q∗1 (resp. Q∗∗ 1 ) be the cube in R concentric with Q1 having twice (resp. four times) the side length. Then (II.40) shows that
m! G ax t p dx dt ≤ C (II.41) n Q∗∗ 1 ×R
with C > 0 independent of 0 < - ≤ 1, ≥ 1, az an atom. Thus, (II.39) will be proved as soon as we obtain x sup !- ∗ F ∗ ax t p dx dt ≤ C 0 < ≤ 1 (II.42) n Rm \Q∗∗ 1 ×R 0<-≤1
Assuming that !x t = !1 x!2 t, !1 and !2 supported in the unit ball of x x
Rm and Rn respectively, we are led to consider the convolution !-1 ∗ a ∗ F . In order to simplify the notation we simply write !-1 ∗ a ∗ F , letting t play the role of a parameter. Let us assume first that the side r of the cube Q is ≥ 1. Since !1 is supported in the unit ball, !-1 ∗ a = a- , 0 < - ≤ 1, is supported in Q∗1 . Therefore, if x % Q∗∗ 1 , letting x0 be the center of Q1 and CL = supx∈Rn x L Fx, we have & & & &
!-1 ∗ a ∗ F x t ≤ (Q2 t & a- y tF x − y dy& ( )
x − x0 −L ≤ CCL (Q2 t Q −1/p Q∗1 −m where we have used that x − x0 ∼ x − y for y ∈ Q∗1 and x % Q∗∗ 1 . Since ∗ m m L−m
Q1 = 2r ≤ 2 x − x0 and ≤ 1 if we take L > m, we obtain for a large integer d = L − m
!-1 ∗ a ∗ F x t ≤ C(Q2 t Q −1/p x − x0 −d
82
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
n Convolving with !-2 t gives, for x % Q∗∗ 1 and t ∈ R , x
t
!- ∗ F ∗ ax t ≤ C Q −1/p x − x0 −d !-2 ∗(Q2 t ≤ C Q −1/p x − x0 −d (Q∗2 t Choose d = m + 1. If we take the supremum in 0 < - ≤ 1, raise both sides to n the pth power and integrate in Rm \Q∗∗ 1 × R , we obtain (II.42), under the assumption r ≥ 1. Let us assume now that r < 1, so az satisfies the moment conditions (ii). It is clear that these properties are inherited by a- z, i.e., z a- z dz = 0,
≤ N1/p − 1. We start by writing Fx as a convergent series in Rm , Fx = k F k x with F 0 supported in the unit ball B = B0 1 and each F k supported in some ball of radius 1. We aim at proving (II.42) with F k in the place of F . Using the vanishing of the moments of a x a- ∗ Fk x t = (Q∗2 t ay t Gk - x − y dy = ay t Gk (II.43) - x − y − qx- y dy 1 k where Gk - = !- ∗ F and qx- y is the Taylor polynomial of degree d of the function y → Gk - x − y expanded about x0 and d is the integral part of N1/p − 1. The usual estimates for the remainder of the Taylor expansion imply that the integrand in (II.43) is ≤ C Q −1/p −d+1+m r d+1 . We assume first that k = 0 so F 0 is supported in the unit ball. Since x − x0 ≤ C x − y 0 when y ∈ Q∗1 and x % Q∗∗ 1 , x − y ≤ on the support of F x − y, and a is supported in the cube Q∗1 of measure 2rm it follows that for any 0 < % ≤ 1 and 0 < ≤ 1 d+m+1p r
a- ∗ F0 x t p ≤ C0 (Q2 t x % Q∗∗ 1
x − x0
which after integration gives sup !- ∗ F0 ∗ ax t p dx dt ≤ C0 n Rm \Q∗∗ 1 ×R 0<-≤1
(II.44)
On the other hand, the proof of (II.41) shows that sup !- ∗ F0 ∗ ax t p dx dt ≤ C0 n Q∗∗ 1 ×R 0<-≤1
which combined with (II.44) gives sup !- ∗ F0 ∗ ax t p dx dt ≤ 2C0 Rm ×Rn 0<-≤1
(II.45)
II.4 Applications
83
For other values of k we consider an appropriate translate F˜ k of F k so that F˜ k is supported in B0 1. If for any given we replace the atom a by a convenient translate a˜ , which of course is also an atom, we may write a- ∗ Fk = a˜ - ∗ F˜ k . Reasoning as before we get the analogue of (II.45): sup !- ∗ Fk ∗ ax t p dx dt ≤ Ck (II.46) Rm ×Rn 0<-≤1
The proof also shows that there is a continuous seminorm p in involving derivatives of order ≤ d + 1 such that Ck ≤ pF k and since the series F = k F k converges absolutely in we see that k Ck < . Estimates (II.46) imply (II.41) by subadditivity and the theorem is proved.
II.4 Applications In this section we discuss two typical applications of the Baouendi–Treves approximation formula. The first one deals with extensions of CR functions and the second with uniqueness of solutions of the equation u = 0 where is a locally integrable structure. The principle that governs the first application is conceptually very simple: suppose that we know that a sequence of polynomials P , ∈ Cm , converges uniformly in a compact set K ⊂ Cm , $ of K in Cm . then it converges uniformly in the holomorphic convex hull K We recall that * $= ∈ Cm P ≤ sup P K K
P∈
where denotes the space of polynomials in m complex variables. Since on a ball that contains K any entire function, that is any holomorphic function defined throughout Cm , can be uniformly approximated by the partial sums of its Taylor series, we also have $ = ∈ Cm K
f ≤ sup f
for all entire functions f
K
Let u ∈ C 0 W satisfy u = 0 on W and let K = ZV where V ⊂ U and U , W are the neighborhoods in the statement of Theorem II.1.1. We already u ∈ C 0 K because u is noticed that we may write u = $ u Z on V where $ $ defined constant on the fibers of Z in U . Now, we have a function U $ which clearly extends $ $ by U $ = lim→ P , ∈ K, u. Depending on K $ may have nonempty interior and on this open on the geometry of ZV , K $ set the extension U will be holomorphic because it is the uniform limits of polynomials in . Composition with Z gives the required extension. When u
84
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
is not continuous but, say, belongs to Lp , things are technically more involved but essentially the same principle works. This type of approach may also be seen at work in the following simple example. Consider the operator in R2 L=
− 3it2 t x
(a)
with first integral Zx t = x +it3 . Indeed, it is easily verified that LZ = 0 and clearly dZ never vanishes. The operator L has real analytic coefficients and is elliptic off the x-axis but is not elliptic at t = 0, nevertheless it shares with elliptic vector fields with real analytic coefficients the following regularity property: if u is a C 1 solution of Lu = 0, then u is real-analytic ([M]). This is also true for distribution solutions (thus, (a) is analytic hypoelliptic) but to keep matters simple let us restrict ourselves to classical solutions. To prove the claim, it will be enough to prove that u is real-analytic at any point x 0 of its domain, since for points x t with t = 0 this follows from ellipticity. Let us prove, for instance, that u is real-analytic at the origin in case it is defined in a neighborhood of the origin. By Theorem II.1.1 we may find > 0 such that for x ≤ and t ≤ the uniform limit ux t = lim → P x + it3 holds for a certain sequence of polynomials P , ∈ Z+ . This implies that the sequence P z = P x + iy is a Cauchy sequence in the space C 0 K where K = − × −3 3 . Hence, lim→ P z = $ uz is a continuous function on K which is a holomorphic function on − × −3 3 and we have that ux t = $ ux + it3 for x t ≤ . Since $ u is real-analytic in a neighborhood of the origin and so is Zx t = x + it3 , it follows that u is real-analytic in a neighborhood of the origin as we wished to prove.
II.4.1 Extendability of CR functions Consider the Heisenberg group Hn Cn × R = z s = z1 zn s with the group law
"
z s · w s = z + w s + s +
z ∈ Cn s ∈ R n
# zj w ¯j
j=1
Then Hn can be topologically identified with the boundary of the Siegel upper half-space Dn+1 = z1 zn+1 ∈ Cn+1
zn+1 >
n j=1
zj 2
II.4 Applications
85
via the map Z z1 zn t −→ z1 zn t + i z 2
(II.47)
This identification endows Hn with the CR structure transported from the boundary Dn+1 which possesses a standard CR structure as a smooth boundary of an open subset of Cn+1 induced by the anti-holomorphic differentiations. A function f ∈ C 1 Hn (or more generally a distribution) is a CR function (resp. CR distribution) if and only if it satisfies the overdetermined first-order linear system of equations ˜ jf = L
f f − izj = 0 ¯zj s
j = 1 n
(II.48)
˜ j are left-invariant under the action of Observe that the vector fields L n H . The components of the map (II.47), that is, the functions Z1 z s = z1 Zn z s = zn , Wz s = s + i z 2 satisfy (II.48) and it is of interest to determine which solutions of (II.48) may be expressed as the composition of the map (II.47) with a holomorphic function defined in Dn+1 and having a suitable trace in Dn+1 . It is known ([FS]) that a function f ∈ C 1 Hn is a CR n+1 function if and only if there exists a function F ∈ C 1 D which is holomorphic in Dn+1 and whose composition with the map (II.47) is equal to f . There is also a similar local result due to Hans Lewy ([L1]) which holds in the general set-up of CR structures of hypersurface type with nondegenerate Levi form which we now describe. Consider a hypersurface in Cn+1 with the CR structure induced by the standard anti-holomorphic differentiations of Cn+1 . We may assume that, in a suitable neighborhood of the origin in Cn+1 , is given by t = !z1 z2 zn s
zi ∈ C
s ∈ R
i = 1 n
where !z s =
n 2 ! 0 0zj z¯ k + O z 3 + s
z + s2 z ¯ z j k ij=1
Then is orthogonal to the differential of the functions Zj z s = zj
j = 1 n
z = z1 zn
Wz s = s + i!z s and generated by the vector fields Lj =
− i!z¯ j z s 1 + i!s z s −1 ¯zj s
j = 1 n
(II.49)
86
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
Using zj and w = s + it as a system of coordinates, the Levi form at 0 ds is represented by the matrix 2 ! 0 0 zk ¯zj The aforementioned result of Hans Lewy asserts that, when the Levi form of at 0 ds has a positive eigenvalue, there exists a neighborhood V of the origin in Cn+1 such that every continuous function satisfying Lj u = 0
(II.50)
in Z−1 ∩ V, Z = z1 zn s + i!z s, can written as u = F Z where F is a continuous function defined in z w ∈ V t ≥ !z s and holomorphic in V + = z w ∈ V t > !z s . We now return to the Heisenberg group Hn and recall that the (global) holomorphic Hardy space p Dn+1 , 0 < p < , is the set of functions F , holomorphic in Dn+1 , which satisfy
Fz s + i z 2 + & p dmz ds < sup 0<&< C×R
Here dm is the Lebesgue measure on Cn , ds is the Lebesgue measure on the real line and it turns out that the pullback of the product measure dm × ds is the Haar measure on Hn . If F ∈ p Dn+1 , F has a pointwise boundary value f at almost every point of Dn+1 given by the normal limit which exists also in Lp norm and, of course, f is a CR distribution. We now prove an analogue of Lewy’s local extension result within the framework of local Lp spaces, 1 ≤ p < . Theorem II.4.1. Let be a smooth hypersurface of Cn+1 passing through the origin and assume that the Levi form has a nonzero eigenvalue. Then, for any 1 ≤ p < and f ∈ Lploc which is a CR distribution in a neighborhood of the origin, there exists an open set V 0 of Cn+1 and a holomorphic function F in Lp V + (V + denotes the portion of V lying on the ‘convex’ side of ) such that f is the trace of F . Proof. In view of the hypothesis we may assume V + is given by t = zn+1 > !z s with !z s = z1 2 +
n j=2
%j zj 2 + O z 3 + s
z + s2
(II.51)
II.4 Applications
87
where each %j may assume the values +1, −1, or 0. We will assume initially that the remainder terms vanish identically because the proof is very simple in this case. Hence, we assume that !z s = !z = z1 2 +
n
%j zj 2
(model case)
j=2
Since f is a CR function, it follows that f Z satisfies the overdetermined system (II.50) where the vector fields Lj are given by (II.49). By Theorem II.3.1 there is a sequence of polynomials P Z, Z = z1 zn s + i!z s that converges to f Z in Lp norm in a neighborhood of the origin in Cnz × Rs . We may assume that the closure of the Cartesian product of √ the polydisk $0 2 a of radius 0 < a ≤ 1 times the interval −a a is contained in that neighborhood. Let us write z = z2 zn . Then, for each z and t fixed, the set z1
z1 z s + it ∈ V +
is a disk centered at the origin of radius Rz t = t − nj=2 %j zj 2 1/2 if n t − j=2 %j zj 2 ≥ 0 and empty if the latter quantity is negative. We will denote this (possibly empty) disk by Dz t. Given an entire function u defined on Cn+1 (actually we will only use that u is harmonic in the first variable), we wish to estimate the Lp norm of u on Va+ = z1 z s + it ∈ V +
zj ≤ a j = 2 n s t ≤ a
in terms of the Lp norm of the restriction of u to the boundary of V + . As the disks Dz r sweep V + , their boundaries sweep the boundary of V + , which suggests the use of Poisson’s formula. A change to polar coordinates rei in the variable x1 y1 allows us to express the integral a a I= ds dt dx dy
ux1 + iy1 z s t p dx1 dy1 −a
as I=
a
−a
ds
$ 0a
−a
a
−a
dt
$ 0a
dx dy
Dz t
2)
d 0
0
Rz t
urei z s t p rdr
It is a well-known consequence of Poisson’s formula and Young’s inequality for convolution that Rz t 2) Rz t2 2)
urei z s t p d rdr ≤
uRz tei z s t p d 2 0 0 0 A more geometric way of writing this inequality for any disk D is diam D
u p dA ≤
u p d (II.52) 4 D D
88
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
where dA is the element of area and d indicates arc length. Hence, a a Rz t2 2) I≤ ds dx dy dt
uRz tei z s t p d 2 −a z 0 $ 0a where, for a given z , z indicates the value of t below which the disk Dz t becomes empty (if this ever happens) or −a, whichever is larger. Now the substitution = Rz t in the integral with respect to t (so that t = ! z ) yields, assuming a is sufficiently small, 2) 2√a a ds dx dy √ 3 d
uei z s ! z p d I≤ $ 0a
−a
≤
−a
≤2
a
ds
$ 0a
dx dy
−2 a √ 2 a
√
−2 a
d
0
0
2)
uei z s ! z p d
u Z p dxdyds √ $02 a×−aa
Thus, we have proved that p dxdydsdt ≤ 2
u + Va
u Zz s p dxdyds √ $02 a×−aa
(II.53)
and applying this to u = P − P we conclude that the sequence P converges in Lp Va+ to a holomorphic function F that has a trace F/Va+ such that F/Va+ Z = f Z and this implies that F/Va+ = f , as we wished to prove (it follows from Cauchy’s formula that Lp -convergence implies local uniform convergence). To deal with a general ! given by (II.51) we may reason exactly in the same way, except that now the domains of C ˜ s t = z1 Dz
z1 z s + it ∈ V +
will no longer be round disks centered at the origin. However, they are simply connected and may be regarded as smooth perturbations of a disk Dz t of radius Rz t which can be mapped by a Riemann map z1 → .z1 z s t onto Dz t. Thus, we will be able to reason as in the proof of (II.52) as soon as we prove the following substitute for (II.52): ˜ s t
u p dA ≤ C diam Dz
u p d ˜ st Dz
˜ st Dz
where C > 0 is independent of z s t in a neighborhood of the origin and u ˜ s t and continuous in its closure. is any harmonic function defined in Dz To simplify the notation we omit any reference to the variables z s that play the role of parameters and write z = x + iy instead of z1 = x1 + y1 . Thus, we are led to consider the class % of smooth functions x y in R2 whose Taylor series at the origin is x y ∼ a + bx + cy + x2 + y2 + O z 3 , when
II.4 Applications
89
z → 0, where a + b + c < % and such that D x y ≤ C (here % > 0 is a conveniently chosen small number and C is a given fixed sequence of positive constants). We will need to study the sublevel sets in a fixed small neighborhood of the origin, ˜ Dt = z = x + iy
z < r x y < t
for an arbitrary ∈ % . Observe that any ∈ % has a small local minimum m at a point z0 = x0 y0 located close to the origin for small %. It follows that m + 2−1 z − z0 2 ≤ x y ≤ m + 2 z − z0 2 in a neighborhood of the origin and thus + √ ˜ Dz0 t/2 ⊂ Dm + t ⊂ Dz0 2t ˜ We see that Dm + t is empty for t ≤ 0 and contained between concentric √ disks of radius comparable to t if t is positive and small. Furthermore, ˜ the implicit function theorem shows that, in the latter case, Dm + t has a smooth boundary made up of a simple closed curve contained in the annulus t/2 < z − z0 2 < 2t. Lemma II.4.2. There exist t0 r0 > 0 such that for all 0 < t ≤ t0 and ∈ ˜ + t is a relatively compact simply connected open subset of the % , Dm disk D0 r0 . Furthermore, there exists C > 0 such that for every harmonic ˜ function u defined in a neighborhood of the closure of Dm + t and any 1 ≤ p < , the following a priori inequality holds: ˜
u p dA ≤ C diam Dm + t
u p d (II.54) ˜ Dm+t
˜ Dm+t
Proof. After a translation, we may assume that z0 = 0. For small t > 0, the level curve x y = m + t, which is implicitly given in polar coordinates by r 2 A + rBr = t where A = cos2 + 2 sin cos + sin2 and all derivatives of B with respect to x and y are bounded, may also be explicitly expressed by r = r t. Observe that if % is small, and are close to 1 and is close to zero. Implicit differentiation shows that r =
√ r rA + r 2 B = O t =− 2 2A + 3rB + r Br
t → 0
Differentiating further the expression above we conclude that the higher√ order derivatives r n , n = 1 2 , are also O t as t → 0. Consider a
90
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
√ ˜ ˜ dilation of Dm + t, t = 1/ tDm + t, whose boundary is given by √ √ −1/2 + O t. Observe that we also have Rt = r t/ t = A √ dn Rt /dn = dn A−1/2 /dn + O t for n ≥ 1. Since (II.54) is invariant under dilations of the domain, it will be enough to prove it for the dilate t that converges in C to the domain 0 with equation R < A−1/2 as t → 0. To do so it is enough to show that, for small t, the derivative Ft of the Riemann map Ft from t to the unit disk satisfies 1/C ≤ Ft ≤ C. Indeed, if u is harmonic in t and continuous up to the boundary, so will be v = u Ft−1 on the unit disk, and starting from (II.52) applied to v, the change of variables w = Ft z will give
u p dA ≤ C
u p d (II.55)
t
t
Notice that if we introduce the factor diam
√ side of √ t on the right-hand (II.55) the inequality remains valid because 2/ 2 ≤ diam t ≤ 2 2. Hence, the proof of (II.54) will be finished as soon as we prove Lemma II.4.3. There exist t0 > 0 and C > 0 such that for 0 ≤ t ≤ t0 the Riemann map Ft from t to the unit disk D satisfies 1/C ≤ Ft ≤ C. Proof. Let u be the solution of the Dirichlet problem ⎧ 2 2 ⎨$u = u + u = 0 on t x2 y2 ⎩ u t = uRt ei = logRt 0 ≤ ≤ 2)
(II.56)
Let v be the harmonic conjugate of u in t (say, normalized by v0 = 0) and set ft = u + iv. Then a Riemann map from t onto the unit disk D = D0 1 is (cf. the proof of theorem 3.3 in [F]) Ft z = ze−ft z Thus, Ft = e−ft z 1 − zft z and Ft = e−uz 1 − zft z which implies, by the maximum principle, that C −1 inf 1 − zft z ≤ Ft ≤ C sup 1 − zft z
t
t
with C > 0 independent of t, for small t. Indeed, logRt converges to −1/2 log A = −1/2 log cos2 + 2 sin cos + sin2 as t → 0 and the domain 0 is close to the unit disk for small %. Therefore, to conclude the proof, we need only show that ft ≤ 1/2 for small t and %. Since ft = ux − iuy we must show that the derivatives of u are uniformly small in t . The domains
t change with t and the analysis may be simplified by mapping t ∪ t
II.4 Applications
91
onto the fixed domain 0 ∪ o by a diffeomorphism (of manifolds with boundaries) !t such that all derivatives of !t and !t−1 are bounded uniformly with bounds that do not depend on t ∈ 0 t0 . Such !t are easily constructed. Then, Ut = u !t−1 is the solution of a Dirichlet problem on 0 with respect to an elliptic second-order differential operator Pt x y Dx Dy Ut = 0 and in particular satisfies the boundary condition Ut 0 = log !t−1 0 . The coefficients of Pt x y Dx Dy depend continuously on t ∈ 0 t0 as well as their derivatives. The usual regularity theory of smooth elliptic boundary value problems implies that there exists a positive integer N > 0 with the following property: given & > 0 there exists > 0 such that any function U that satisfies the equation Pt x y Dx Dy U = 0 for some t ∈ 0 t0 , and has in addition all tangential derivatives at the boundary bounded up to order N by , will satisfy the estimate ,Ux y ≤ &. Since 0 is close to the unit disk for small %, it follows that log !t−1 0 will have small tangential derivatives up to any fixed order, and thus Ut = u !t−1 will have uniformly small gradient. The chain rule now implies that u = U !t has small gradient, uniformly in x y ∈ t and t ∈ 0 t0 , proving that ft = ,u ≤ 1/2 for small t and %. Since Lemma II.4.3 implies (II.54), Lemma II.4.2 is proved. As we pointed out, the control of the Lp norm of u on the sublevel sets ˜ ˜ Dm + t in terms of the Lp norm of u on their boundaries Dm + t given by Lemma II.4.2 is all that is needed in order to extend the proof carried out in the model case to the general case. The proof of Theorem II.4.1 is then complete. Remark II.4.4. Stronger results than Theorem II.4.1 are known. In fact, it is possible to sweep V + with suitable translates of so that the Lp norm of the restriction of F to those translates is uniformly bounded ([Ro]). Theorem II.4.1 then follows from an application of Fubini’s theorem.
II.4.2 Propagation of zeros of homogeneous solutions Given a locally integrable structure in a manifold , and a solution u of u = 0 a natural question is: what additional conditions must the solution u satisfy in order to conclude that u vanishes identically? The local version of the question is: given p ∈ , and a neighborhood V of p, what conditions guarantee that there exists a neighborhood p ∈ U ⊂ V on which u vanishes identically? A natural additional condition would be to require that u vanish in some subset of V . In a small neighborhood of p, u = 0 may be expressed as an overdetermined system of equations (II.5). To get some insight, let
92
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
us consider the simplest case of a single vector field L = Ax + By , A +
B > 0, defined in an open set ⊂ R2 . Since the constant functions u = C always satisfy Lu = 0 it is apparent that some additional condition is needed; for instance, requiring that u vanishes at p certainly rules out the nonzero constants, but for most vector fields this is not enough (there exist, however, vector fields whose only homogeneous solutions are the constant functions [N1]). If L = is the Cauchy–Riemann operator of Example II.1.2, one could require that u vanishes at p to infinite order which would imply that u vanishes throughout any connected open set U that contains p. However, this condition will not be enough for the vector field L = x since a smooth function uy independent of x could vanish to infinite order at p and yet not vanish identically in any neighborhood U of p. A better condition for L = x would be then to require that u vanishes on the curve 0 = p1 y , p = p1 p2 . So requiring that u vanishes on 0, that is a submanifold of of codimension one, works for both and x but it does not work for y (show this). The main point is that y is tangent to p1 y while the two previous vector fields are transversal to any vertical line (for a complex vector field L = X + iY with real part X and imaginary part Y , L transversal to 0 means that at least one of the two vectors X and Y is transversal). This suggests that we should look at the case where u vanishes on a submanifold 0 of codimension one to which L is transversal. Note that if the structure of rank n = 1 generated by L is locally integrable, the corank m of L⊥ must be one, so we have N = 2, m = 1, and n = 1. Elaboration of this type of consideration for the case of a locally integrable structure of rank n and corank m defined in a manifold of dimension N = n + m leads to the following definition: Definition II.4.5. Let 0 ⊂ be an embedded submanifold. We say that 0 is maximally real with respect to if (i) the dimension of 0 is equal to m; (ii) for every p ∈ 0, any nonvanishing section L of defined in a neighborhood of p is transversal to 0 at p. If local coordinates x1 xm t1 tn vanishing at p are chosen according to Corollary I.10.2, then ⊥ is generated in a neighborhood of x = 0, t = 0, by dZ1 dZm , where Zj x t = xj +ij x t, j 0 0 = 0, j /xk 0 0 = 0, 1 ≤ j k ≤ m, and the vectors L1 Ln become Lj = /tj , j = 1 n at the origin. If 0 is maximally real, the vectors tj 0 are transversal to 0 at the origin, so by the implicit function theorem we may find locally defined functions j x such that 0 = x x , where x = 1 x n x. If
II.4 Applications
93
we perform the change of coordinates x = x, t = t − x the expression of Z in the new coordinates is Z x t = x + ix t + x = x + i x t and now 0 is given by t = 0. In other words, if 0 is maximally real, we may always assume that the set of coordinates x t of Corollary I.10.2 are such that not only Z has the form Zx t = x + i with real, 0 0 = 0, dx 0 0 = 0 but also that 0 is given locally by 0 = x 0 . In particular, if u is a distribution solution of u = 0 we may always consider its restriction to 0, u 0 , which is just the trace ux 0 which we have seen to exist from considerations on the wave front set of u. Theorem II.4.6. Let be a locally integrable structure on the manifold and let 0 ⊂ be an embedded submanifold maximally real with respect to . If u ∈ satisfies (i) u = 0 in ; (ii) u 0 = 0; then u vanishes identically in a neighborhood V of 0. Proof. It is enough to see that any point p ∈ 0 is contained in a neighborhood U on which u vanishes identically. According to our previous remarks, given p ∈ 0 we may assume that the special coordinates of Corollary I.10.2 that were used to prove Theorem II.1.1 are such that 0 is given by 0 = x 0 and p = 0 0. We may find open sets 0 ∈ U ⊂ W as in Theorem II.1.1 so that W is contained in the coordinate neighborhood and u is approximated in U by E u in the sense of U. However, the formula that defines E u right after (II.5) shows that E ux t = 0 because ux 0 vanishes on 0 ∩ W . Thus, u ≡ 0 on U . Corollary II.4.7. Let be a locally integrable structure on a manifold and let u ∈ satisfy u = 0 in . Let L be a local section of , let X = L. Assume that is an integral curve of X joining the points p and q ∈ . Then p ∈ supp u &⇒ q ∈ supp u. Proof. If X vanishes at p then p = q and there is nothing to prove. We may assume that 0 1 → is a nonconstant solution of s = X s, 0 ≤ s ≤ 1, with 0 = q and 1 = p, so X does not vanish in a neighborhood of . Denote by K = supp u the support of u and let us assume for the sake of a contradiction that p ∈ K and q % K. Replacing p by the first point s such that s ∈ K we may assume that p and q are as close as we wish and all points in between q and p are not in K. We may find a local set
94
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
of generators of , L = L1 L2 Ln such that in appropriate coordinates x t, x < 1, t < 2, that rectify the flow of X1 = X we have t1 m Xj = Lj = + jk tj k=1 xk
(i)
X1 = L1 =
j = 2 n
and p = 0 0; (ii) s = s − 1 0 0, q = 0 = −1 0 0; (iii) for some a > 0 the embedded closed m-ball given by x ≤ a, t = 0, t1 = −1 does not meet K (here t = t2 tn ). Since it is an embedded submanifold with boundary we may denote this m-ball as 00 ∪00 , where 00 is the corresponding open m-ball. Consider now the one-parameter family of embedded submanifolds 0 (without their boundaries) given by the equations t1 = − 1 −
x 2 a2
t2 = · · · = tn = 0
x < a
0 ≤ ≤ 1
Since 00 ∩ K = ∅ and 0 0 ∈ 01 ∩ K there is a largest 0 ∈ 0 1 such that 0 ∩ K = ∅ for 0 ≤ < 0 . Note that the submanifolds 0 are all maximally real with respect to . Indeed, the vector fields Xj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, are transversal to any 0 . This is clear for j ≥ 2 because 0 is contained in the slice t2 = · · · = tn = 0 and it is also obvious for j = 1 because /t1 is never tangent to 0 . Hence, the trace u 0 is well-defined and furthermore u 0 = 0 for 0 < < 0 and, since → u 0 depends continuously on , we conclude that u 0 = 0
(A)
00 ∩ K = ∅
(B)
0
We claim that Indeed, since dist00 K = 0, this is certainly true if we replace 00 by its closure 00 which amounts to adding to 00 its boundary points 00 . But, for any ∈ 0 1 , 0 is given by x = a, t1 = −1, t2 = · · · = tn = 0, so (iii) shows that 0 ∩ K = ∅. Hence, 00 ∩ K = 00 ∩ K = ∅. However, applying Theorem II.4.6 to 00 , (A) implies that u vanishes in a neighborhood of 00 in x < a, t < 2. This contradicts (B). Let be a manifold and consider a collection D = X of locally defined, smooth, real vector fields X. In Chapter III, the notion of orbit of D is
II.4 Applications
95
defined. Suppose now that is a locally integrable structure and we consider the collection D = L of all vector fields that are real parts of local sections of . In this case the orbits of D are simply called the orbits of . In the language of orbits, Corollary II.4.7 implies that if an orbit of intersects the support K of a solution u of the equation u = 0 it must be entirely contained in K. This is equivalent to saying that K is a union of orbits of . Thus, Corollary II.4.7 gives an alternative proof of Theorem III.2.1. The proof presented in Chapter III follows in a remarkable simple way—thanks to the use of a criterion of Bony about flow-invariant sets—from a related uniqueness result that we now describe. An embedded submanifold of of codimension 1 will be called a hypersurface. A hypersurface 0 ⊂ is noncharacteristic with respect to at p ∈ 0 if there exists a local section L of defined in a neighborhood of p that is transversal to 0 at p (which means, changing L by iL if necessary, that X = L is transversal to 0 at p). Notice that if u is a solution of u = 0 defined in a neighborhood U of p, the trace u 0∩U is defined because u satisfies the equation Lu = 0 for any local section of , so choosing L transversal to 0 we see that the wave front set of u does not contain 0’s conormal directions. Definition II.4.8. Let be a formally integrable structure in the manifold . We say that has the Uniqueness in the Cauchy Problem property for noncharacteristic hypersurfaces if and only if the following holds: for every hypersurface 0, every point p ∈ 0 such that 0 is noncharacteristic at p and every distribution solution u of u = 0 defined in a neighborhood U of p, u U ∩0 = 0 &⇒ u vanishes in a neighborhood of p. Corollary II.4.9. The Uniqueness in the Cauchy Problem property for noncharacteristic hypersurfaces holds for every locally integrable structure . Proof. Let 0 be a noncharacteristic hypersurface at p. As usual, we denote by N the dimension of the manifold , by n the rank of and set m = N − n. In appropriate local coordinates x t we may assume that ⊥ is generated by dZ1 dZm , Z = x + ix t, 0 0 = 0, dx 0 0 = 0, p = 0 0. Hence, is spanned at 0 0 by t1 tn and since is transversal to 0 at p = 0 0, the implicit function theorem gives a local representation of 0 as t1 = t1 t x, t = t2 tn , after renumbering the t-coordinates if necessary. Let 01 be given by t1 = t1 0 x, t = 0. Then, 01 is a maximally real submanifold contained in 0 that contains
96
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
p = 0 0. Consider now a neighborhood U of p = 0 0 and u ∈ U such that u = 0 and u U ∩0 = 0. Since 01 ⊂ 0 we also have that u U ∩01 = 0 and it follows from Theorem II.4.6 that u vanishes in a neighborhood of p. Example II.4.10. P. Cohen ([Co]) (see also [Zu] and the references therein) constructed smooth functions ux y and ax y defined on R2 such that u u + ax y = 0; y x (2) ux y = ax y = 0 for all y ≤ 0; (3) supp u = supp a = x y y ≥ 0 . (1) Lux y =
Thus, the formally integrable structure spanned by the vector field L fails to have the Uniqueness in the Cauchy Problem property for the noncharacteristic curve 0 = t = 0 and, by Corollary II.4.9, cannot be locally integrable in any open set that intersects the x-axis. The construction of ax y shows that ax y is real-analytic for y = 0, so for any point p = x y with y = 0 we may find a function Z defined in a neighborhood of p such that LZ = 0 and dZp = 0. On the other hand, if Z is a smooth function defined in a neighborhood of p = x 0 such that LZ = 0 we must have that dZp = 0, otherwise would be locally integrable in some open set that intersects the x-axis, a contradiction. A nonlocally integrable vector field was first exhibited by Nirenberg ([N1]) who used a completely different method to construct a vector field whose only homogeneous solutions are contant.
II.4.3 An extension In the applications to uniqueness we have seen so far, the ‘initial’ maximally real manifold t = 0 is in the interior of the domain where the solution u of u = 0 is defined. This is quite convenient because in this case the trace u· t exists and t → u· t is a continuous function of t valued in the space of distributions. However, in the study of one-sided Cauchy problems or boundary values of solutions, it is desirable to consider the case where the solution is not defined in a neighborhood of the ‘initial’ manifold. We will say that a set + ⊂ Rn \0 is a cone (or a cone with vertex at the origin to be explicit) if t ∈ + ⇐⇒ &t ∈ + ∀ 0 < & < . A set +T ⊂ Rn \0 , 0 < T , will be called a truncated cone if there exists a cone + such that +T = + ∩ t < T . An open truncated cone is a truncated cone which is an open set. Notice that the origin is in the closure of + and +T but it does not belong to them. A cone + is said to be a proper subcone of + if + ∩ x = 1 is a compact subset of +. This is, for instance, the case if + and + are circular cones with the same
II.4 Applications
97
axis and + has a smaller aperture than +. If + is a proper subcone of + and T < T we say that +T is a proper truncated subcone of the truncated cone +T . When n = 1, a truncated cone is an interval of the form 0 T or −T 0 or the union of both. If W ⊂ Rm is an open set and +T ⊂ Rn is an open truncated cone, the set W × +T ⊂ Rm × Rn is usually called a wedge with edge W . Consider a locally integrable structure of rank n in an N -manifold and assume that the standard coordinates x t used in the proof of Theorem II.1.1 had been chosen in a neighborhood of the origin. Let Bx ⊂ Rm , m = N −n, be a ball centered at the origin, +T ⊂ Rn a truncated open cone, and assume that u is a distribution satisfying the system (II.5) in Bx × +T . Under this circumstances we can assert that the trace u Bx ×t = Tt ux = ux t is defined and depends smoothly on t ∈ +T as a map valued in Bx , but ux 0 might not be defined. On the other hand, we may assume that limt→0 Tt u = bu exists in
Bx as t → 0. If n = N − m = 1, Bx × 0 divides = Bx × −T T into two components + = x t ∈ t > 0 and − = x t ∈ t < 0 and in this case we consider distributions u that satisfy the system (II.5) in + and such that limt(0 Tt u = bu exists. In other words, we assume that u ∈ C 0 +T ∪ 0 Bx (resp. u ∈ C 0 0 T Bx for n = 1). We see that E u can still be defined by 2 E ux t = /)m/2 e− Zxt−Zx 0 ux 0hx det Zx x 0 dx Rm
as soon as we interpret ux 0 as bux . For a given t ∈ +T and 0 < % < 1 consider R% ux t = G ux t − E% ux t where E% u is given by E% ux t = /)m/2
Rm
and G ux t = /)m/2
e− Zxt−Zx 0 ux %thx det Zx x 0 dx
2
Rm
e− Zxt−Zx t ux thx det Zx x t dx 2
As in the proof of Theorem II.1.1, the remainder R% u is given by m R% ux t = rj x t t dtj
%tt j=1
where rj x t t = /)m/2
Rm
e− Zxt−Zx t ux t Lj hx det Zx x t dx 2
98
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
Letting % → 0 we obtain R u = G u − E u with R given by R ux t = rj x t t = /)m/2
Rm
m
0t j=1
rj x t t dtj
e− Zxt−Zx t ux t Lj hx det Zx x t dx 2
The proof of Theorem II.1.1 now shows that there is a ball Bx = Bx 0 and proper subcone +& ⊂ +T such that R u → 0 uniformly in Bx × +& as → . Indeed, we can find a fixed k such that vj x t = 1 − $x −k Lj hx ux t detZx x t is continuous in Bx ×+& , since the distributions x→Lj hx ux t detZx x t lie in a bounded set of some Sobolev space when t ranges over a compact subset of +T ∪ 0 because u ∈ C 0 +T ∪ 0 Bx . Since the continuity of +T ∪ 0 t → Tt ux ∈ Bx implies the continuity of +T ∪ 0 t → Dx Tt ux = Tt Dx ux ∈ Bx and equation (II.5) allows us to express the derivatives of u with respect to t as a linear combination with smooth coefficients of derivatives of u with respect to x for t = 0, we conclude that actually u ∈ C +T ∪ 0 Bx . The derivatives of R u can be estimated in the same fashion and we obtain Corollary II.4.11. Let u ∈ C 0 +T ∪0 Bx (resp. u ∈ C 0 0 T Bx for n = 1) be a distribution satisfying the system (II.5) in = Bx × +T (resp. in + = Bx × 0 T for n = 1). There exist > 0, and a proper subcone +& ⊂ +T (resp. a number & > 0 for n = 1) such that for all multi-indexes n ∈ Zm + and ∈ Z+ Dx Dt R ux t −→ 0 uniformly on Bx 0 × +& ∪ 0 (resp. on Bx 0 × 0 & for n = 1). Corollary II.4.11 reduces the study of the approximation of u by E to the problem of approximating u by G u. As an illustration, we sketch the proof of a version of the approximation for wedges. Consider a wedge W = Bx × +T —where Bx ⊂ Rm is a ball centered at the origin and +T ⊂ Rn is an open truncated cone—and a locally integrable structure with first integrals Z1 = x1 + i1 x t Zm = xm + im x t, 0 0 = dx 0 0 = 0, defined in a neighborhood of the closure of W . Let u ∈ C 0 +T ∪ 0 Lploc Bx , 1 ≤ p < satisfy u = 0 and we wish to approximate u by polynomials in Z in the topology of C 0 +& ∪ 0 Lploc Bx , where +& is a proper subcone of + of height &, Bx ⊂ Bx is a ball of radius and & > 0 are small.
Notes
99
Shrinking Bx we may assume that u· t ∈ Lp and by Corollary II.4.11 it will be enough to approximate u by G u in the norm sup u· t − G u· tLp Rm t∈+T
By the proof of Theorem II.3.1 we know that the norm of G as an operator on Lp Rm (depending on t as a parameter) may be bounded by a constant independent of t ∈ +T . Thus, it is enough to check that G converges strongly to the identity on a dense subset of C 0 +T ∪ 0 Lp Bx . This is indeed the case, because if vx t is continuous and supported in +T ∪ 0 × Bx where Bx is a ball concentric with Bx and of smaller radius, we know by the proof of Theorem II.1.1 that G vx t → vx t uniformly on +T × Bx and this implies convergence in the norm of C 0 +T ∪ 0 Lp Bx . This proves Theorem II.4.12. Let be a locally integrable structure with first integrals Z1 Zm , defined in a neighborhood of the closure of W = Bx × +T . There exist a ball Bx ⊂ Bx and a proper truncated subcone +& of +T such that for any u ∈ C 0 +T ∪ 0 Lp Bx , 1 ≤ p < , satisfying u = 0 E ux t −→ ux t in C 0 +& ∪ 0 Lp Bx
−→
(II.57)
As usual, we may replace the operator E in (II.57) by a convenient sequence of polynomials in Z, P Z1 Zm .
Notes The approximation formula of Section II.1 for classical solutions was first proved by Baouendi and Treves in [BT1], building upon their previous work ([BT2]) that dealt with a corank one system of real-analytic vector fields. For distribution solutions, the proof in [BT1] relied on a local representation formula proved under a supplementary hypothesis on the locally integrable structure. This representation formula, which is of independent interest and states that any distribution solution u of u = 0 may be written as u = Px Dv, where v is a classical solution of v = 0 and Px D is a differential operator that commutes with the local generators Lj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, of . This representation formula was proved in general by Treves in [T4], who also stated and proved the approximation formula for distribution solutions in all generality. Metivier studied the case of a nonlinear first-order analytic single equation and proved an approximation formula for solutions of class C 2 , obtaining as a consequence uniqueness in the Cauchy problem ([Met]).
100
The Baouendi–Treves approximation formula
The convergence in Lp of the approximation formula for solutions in Lp is an unpublished observation of S. Chanillo and S. Berhanu; the proofs presented here for Lp as well as for other functional spaces follow [HMa1]. It was soon realized by researchers in several complex variables theory that the approximation formula, although formulated in the rather general context of locally integrable structures, could be applied with success to deal with classical questions and it was used early as a tool in the problem of extending CR functions ([BP],[W1], [BT3]) and other matters like the study of the Radó property for CR functions ([RS]) (see also [HT1] for the Radó property for solutions of locally solvable vector fields). Because the approximation is obtained through the operator E that depends linearly on the trace of the solution on a maximally real submanifold, it is hardly surprising that it would have consequences for uniqueness questions. One remarkable feature is that it applies directly to distribution solutions in sharp contrast with other methods, like Carleman’s estimates, which were devised to deal with functions rather than with less regular distributions. Before the definition of orbits by Sussmann in 1973 ([Su]), the propagation of zeros had been observed for some operators with real-analytic coefficients ([Z]) using as propagators Nagano’s leaves ([Na]), which coincide with Sussmann’s orbits in the real-analytic set-up. The theorem stating that the support of a solution is a union of Sussmann’s orbits was initially stated and proved in [T4]. Another early application to uniqueness is [BT4]. Nowadays, the use of the approximation formula is so standard that probably there is no point in keeping track of its use in the literature. Anyway, we mention [BH3] as a recent uniqueness result that takes advantage of the approximation formula. Another application outside the scope of the theory of holomorphic functions is its use in the study of removable singularities for solutions of locally solvable vector fields ([HT2], [HT3], [HT4]).
III Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
In this chapter we will present various results on unique continuation for solutions and approximate solutions of locally integrable structures. Our main focus will be on those results where Sussmann’s orbits have played a decisive role. We will begin with some general discussion of these orbits, taken mainly from [Su] and [BM].
III.1 Sussmann’s orbits Let be a C , paracompact manifold. Let D be a set of locally defined, smooth real vector fields. That is, each X in D is defined on some open subset of and it is smooth there. Assume that the union of the domains of the elements of D equals . We define an equivalence relation on as follows: two points p and q are related if there is a curve 0 T −→ such that (1) 0 = p, T = q; (2) there exist t0 = 0 < t1 < · · · < tn = T and vector fields Xi ∈ D (i = 1 n) such that for each i, the restriction ti−1 ti −→ is an integral curve of Xi or −Xi . The equivalence classes of this relation will be called the orbits of D. In [Su], Sussmann showed that these orbits can be equipped with a natural topology and differentiable structure which makes them immersed submanifolds of . We will next briefly describe the orbit topology and C structure (the reader is referred to [Su] and [BER] for more details). If X ∈ D is defined near p in , let !tX p denote the integral curve of X which at t = 0 equals p and is defined on a maximal interval. If Y = X1 Xm ∈ Dm (i.e., each Xi ∈ D), 101
102
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
s = t1 tm ∈ Rm , and p ∈ , we write X
X
X
!sY p = !t11 !t22 !tmm p and let Y denote the open subset of Rm × consisting of the points s p where !sY p is defined. For p ∈ and Y ∈ Dn , let !Y p denote the map s −→ !sY p, and let Y p be its domain. Note that Y p is a subset of Rn . Suppose that = x is an orbit of D through a point x. Observe that is the union of the sets !Y xY x, where Y ∈ Dn for n = 1 2 The orbit is topologized by giving it the strongest topology that makes all the !Y x continuous (for all n, and for all Y ∈ Dn ). Note that since each !Y x Y x −→ is continuous, it follows that the topology of is finer than the subspace topology. Equivalently, the inclusion map from into is continuous. As the examples below will show, in general, this inclusion won’t be a homeomorphism. For the independence of the topology of on the point x, we refer the reader to [Su, page 176]. We will briefly recall the differentiable structure on by describing the coordinate charts. Let +D be the smallest set of locally defined C vector fields on satisfying: (1) D ⊆ +D, and (2) for any p ∈ , Xp X ∈ +D is a subspace of Tp . to denote the smallest set of locally defined, smooth We will use +D vector fields which contains +D and is invariant under the group of local diffeomorphisms generated by +D. It is not hard to see that the dimension is constant as x varies in the orbit . Suppose now q ∈ . of the fibers +D x By lemmas 5.1 and 5.2 in [Su], there exist Y ∈ Dn for some n, q ∈ and s ∈ Y q such that !Y q s = q and the rank k of the differential of !Y q Y q −→ for at the point s is maximal, and that in fact, this rank equals dim +D x any x ∈ . By the rank theorem, we can find neighborhoods U of s in Rn , V of q in , diffeomorphisms F from U onto C n , G from V onto C N (N = dimension of ) such that G !Y q F −1 x1 xn = x1 xk 0 0 Here C l denotes the cube x1 xl ∈ Rl xi < 1
∀i
III.1 Sussmann’s orbits
103
Let # = !Y q U. # is an open subset of (see [Su]). Moreover, # is a submanifold of since G# = x1 xk 0 0 The differentiable structure on the orbit is defined by taking the pairs # G # as charts. One of the main results proved by Sussmann may be stated as follows: Theorem III.1.1 (Theorem 4.1 in [Su]). Let be a C manifold, and let D be a set of locally defined, smooth vector fields such that the union of the domains of the elements of D is . Then (1) If is an orbit of D then (with the topology described above) admits a unique differentiable structure such that is a submanifold of . (2) With the topology and differentiable structure as above, every orbit of D is a maximal integral submanifold of +D. We will next present several examples. Example III.1.2. Let be a manifold and suppose P is a sub-bundle of the tangent bundle T of dimension k. That is, for each x ∈ , the fiber Px is a k-dimensional subspace of Tx , and for each y ∈ , there exists a neighborhood U of y and smooth vector fields X 1 X 2 X k on U such that X j x 1 ≤ j ≤ k is a basis of Px for each x ∈ U . We assume that P is closed under Lie brackets. Then by the Frobenius theorem, the manifold is foliated by leaves each of which is an integral manifold of P. If we set D to be equal to the set of smooth local sections of P, then these leaves are precisely the orbits of D. Note that in this example, the orbits have the same dimension. Thus the concept of Sussmann’s orbits may be viewed as a generalization of Frobenius foliations. For a concrete example of this kind, consider the 2-torus T2 = S 1 × S 1 . Use the angles 1 2 as coordinates for points in T2 , so 1 and 2 are determined modulo integral multiples of 2). Pick two real numbers a and b, not both equal to zero, and consider the sub-bundle of the tangent bundle of T2 generated by the vector field L=a
+b 1 2
The orbits are the integral curves of L. If a and b are linearly dependent over the rational numbers, then each orbit is diffeomorphic to S 1 . In this case, an orbit is an embedded submanifold of T2 and so its orbit topology agrees with the induced subspace topology. If a and b are linearly independent over the
104
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
rational numbers, each orbit is diffeomorphic to the real line. In this case the orbits are dense in T2 , and hence are not embedded submanifolds. Example III.1.3. Let 1 = R2 and 2 = x ∈ 1 x <,1 . Let gt -∈ C R, g > 0 on (1, 2) and g ≡ 0 outside (1, 2). Let D = x gx1 x . 1 2 1 is the only orbit for D. However, if we consider D on 2 , the orbits are the horizontal segments in 2 . Notice also that the tangent space of the orbit 1 at points x1 x2 with x1 % 1 2 does not coincide with the fiber of the and gx1 . Lie algebra generated by x1 x2 , Example III.1.4. Consider the orbits of x x1 x in R2 . There are three 2 1 orbits: x1 > 0 , x1 < 0 , and x1 = 0 . Thus the dimension of orbits is not locally constant. In general, if dx = the dimension of the orbit through x, then dx is a lower semicontinuous function. Example III.1.5. The analytic case: suppose is a real-analytic manifold and D is a set of real-analytic vector fields on . Let D∗ be the smallest Lie algebra (under brackets) of real-analytic vector fields that contains D. It is well known (see [Su], for example) that if p ∈ , then there are a finite number of elements X1 Xk of D∗ such that every X ∈ D∗ can be expressed in a neighborhood of p as k
fj Xj
j=1
for some real-analytic functions fj . Moreover, in this case, if is an orbit of D and p ∈ , then its tangent space Tp = Dp∗ where Dp∗ = Xp X ∈ D∗ This makes it easier to compute the dimensions of orbits in the analytic case. The concept of orbits in the analytic case dates back to Nagano’s paper ([Na]). Orbits arise in a locally integrable structure by taking D as the collection of the real parts of smooth, local sections of . Below we will give an example of orbits arising from the CR structure of a hypersurface in C2 . More examples will be given in the rest of the sections. Example III.1.6. Let z = x + iy, w = s + it denote the variables in C2 and suppose g = gx y is a real-valued, real-analytic function defined on the plane such that
III.1 Sussmann’s orbits
105
(1) g0 0 = 0, gx y > 0 for x y = 0 0; and
,g 2 . (2) $g < 2 g Define &z w = s2 + t − gx y2 − gx y2 and let = z w ∈ C2 \0 &z w = 0 Notice that since d& = 0 on , is a real-analytic hypersurface. We consider the orbits arising from the CR structure of . Observe first that the complex line 0 = C\0 × 0 ⊂ . Since the bundle is tangent to 0, the bracket X Y of any two smooth sections X and Y of is also tangent to 0. Hence by the remarks in Example III.1.5, 0 is an orbit. We will next show that \0 is strictly pseudo-convex. For any a = a1 a2 ∈ C2 , we have ¯ #&a a$ = i w − wg ¯ z¯z a1 2 − gz a1 a¯ 2 + gz¯ a2 a¯ 1 + i a2 2 On the manifold , w ¯ + ig 2 = g 2 = 0 and so if for a = a1 a2 , #& a$ = 0 at a point of , then iw ¯ − wgz a1 a2 = w ¯ + ig It follows that if #& a$ = 0, then
2 gz 2 2 ¯ ¯ gz¯z − #&a a$ = i a1 w − w g
The latter, together with the assumptions on g, show that \0 is strictly pseudo-convex. Thus has one orbit of dimension 2, and all other orbits are of dimension 3. If we make a further assumption on g, say for example, gz z¯ = g z , then \0 is connected, and hence a single open orbit. When gx y = x2 + y2 , this example appeared in [BM]. Our next objective is to analyze the extent to which orbits behave like embedded submanifolds. We begin with: Lemma III.1.7. Let be an orbit through p0 of dimension k, dimension = n. Then there exists a local chart T × V * on about p0 with T and V neighborhoods of 0 in Rk and Rn−k respectively, such that ∩ *T × V = *T × P where P = v ∈ V *0 v ∈
106
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Proof. Let S be a submanifold of through p0 of dimension n − k such that Tp0 = Tp0 S + Tp0 where we view Tp0 as a subspace of Tp0 . Let X1 Xk be locally defined vector fields in $ + spanning Tp0 at p0 . After contracting S about p0 if necessary, we can find a neighborhood T of 0 in Rk and a neighborhood U of p0 in such that the map F T × S −→ U given by X
X
X
Ft1 tk p = !t11 !t22 !tkk p is a diffeomorphism. Suppose now that q ∈ ∩ U . Then q = Ft s for a unique t s ∈ T × S. Hence, FT × s ⊂ ∩ U Therefore, ∩ U = FT × P where P = ∩ S. After introducing a chart on S about p, we get the lemma. Observe that if an orbit is an embedded submanifold, then the sets T and V in Lemma III.1.7 can be chosen so that P is a single point. For a general orbit, we will next show that P can be chosen to be a countable set. This will follow from: Lemma III.1.8. The topology on an orbit is second countable. Proof. For p ∈ we will consider the charts T × V * of Lemma III.1.7. The discussion on the differentiable structure of shows that *T × V is an open set in . Since is second countable, the subspace topology on is second countable. Hence we can get a locally finite open cover for of the form Uj = *Tj × Vj j=1 Recall that for each j, ∩ *Tj × Vj = *Tj × Pj where Pj = v ∈ Vj *0 v ∈ If q ∈ Pj , we will call the set *T × q a slice of in Uj . Fix p0 ∈ Uj0 ∩ for some j0 , and hence p0 ∈ *Tj0 × p ⊆ for some p ∈ Vj0 . For every finite tuple i = i1 im , let Ai be the set of points x in such that x can be joined to p0 by a curve consisting of m pieces l where each l lies in Uil , l = 1 m. From the definition, it is clear that each Ai is a union of slices in Uim . The family Ai where i varies over all finite tuples of positive integers is a countable collection of open subsets of which form a
III.1 Sussmann’s orbits
107
basis for the topology of . Hence we only need to show that each Ai consists of a countable number of slices in Uim . We will do this by induction on m. When m = 1, Ai1 contains at most one slice. Suppose the result holds for all tuples j = i1 ik−1 of length k − 1. Then Aj is the union of countably many slices in Uik−1 . Fix a slice 0 in Aj . Since slices are open sets in , the intersection of 0 with each slice in Uik is an open set. Moreover, since the slices in Uik are pairwise disjoint, and 0 is homeomorphic to an open set in Rd , it follows that 0 can intersect only a countable number of slices in Uik . Thus each Ai is the union of a countable number of slices and therefore is second countable. The preceding lemma can be used to show that orbits possess properties not shared by a general immersed submanifold. To see one such property, call an immersed submanifold N of a manifold weakly embedded if whenever A is a manifold and f A −→ is smooth with fA ⊆ N then f A −→ N is smooth. This notion was introduced by Pradines in [Pr]. For an example of an immersed submanifold that is not weakly embedded, see remark 6.8 in [Boo]. Proposition III.1.9. An orbit in a manifold is weakly embedded. Proof. Suppose f A −→ is C and fA ⊆ . Let q ∈ A and p = fq. Let dim = k, dim = n, and suppose T × V * is a chart on about p as in Lemma III.1.7 with T and V cubes centered about 0 in Rk and Rn−k . Since f A −→ is C , we can choose a connected neighborhood W of q such that fW ⊆ *T × V Recall from Lemma III.1.7 and Lemma III.1.8 that ∩ *T × V = *T × v v∈P
where P ⊆ V is a countable set. The map * −1 f W −→ T × V is C and * −1 fW ⊆ v∈P T × v . Since W is connected, there exists a unique v ∈ P such that * −1 fW ⊆ T × v . Hence f W −→ *T × v ⊆ is C . Corollary III.1.10. If is an orbit of , then when topologized with its orbit topology, it has a unique differentiable structure that makes it an immersed submanifold of . Another property of orbits not shared by a general immersed submanifold concerns the propagation of embeddedness. More precisely, we have
108
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Proposition III.1.11. Let be an orbit in and suppose for a point p in , there is a neighborhood W in such that W ∩ is an embedded submanifold of W . Then is an embedded submanifold of . Proof. Let q ∈ and assume q = !tX p for some X ∈ + and t ∈ R. Set W = !tX W. Here we may assume W has been contracted enough to lie in the domain of the flow of !tX . Since !tX W −→ W is a diffeomorphism, the submanifold !tX W ∩ is an embedded submanifold of W . It is also easy to see that !tX W ∩ = W ∩ Hence is an embedded submanifold of . Corollary III.1.12. If an orbit is a closed subset of , then it is an embedded submanifold. Proof. Let p ∈ . Choose a chart T × V * about p as in Lemma III.1.7. If such a chart can be selected so that P is a finite subset of V , then by Proposition III.1.11, is embedded. Otherwise, such a selection is not possible for any point in . In particular, this means that for any v ∈ P , the point *0 v is an accumulation point of the set *0 × P . Hence v ∈ P is an accumulation point of P . Moreover, since is closed, P is a closed subset of V . It follows that P is a perfect set and hence it is uncountable. This gives rise to the pairwise disjoint, uncountable family of open subsets *T × v v ∈ P of , contradicting the second countability of .
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation This section discusses the relevance of orbits to a variety of global questions of unique continuation in involutive structures. Suppose is an involutive structure on for which uniqueness for solutions in the (noncharacteristic) Cauchy problem holds, i.e., every solution defined in a neighborhood of a noncharacteristic (with respect to ) hypersurface 0 and whose trace on 0 is zero vanishes in a neighborhood of 0. The uniqueness results of Chapter II show that an example of such a is provided by a locally integrable structure. Our first goal is to present another proof of Corollary II.4.7, which is a result on the propagation of the support of a solution along orbits. Special cases of this theorem were proved by several authors (see the notes). The result stated here is due to Treves ([T4]), but the proof is taken from [BM].
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation
109
Theorem III.2.1. Assume that is an involutive structure for which uniqueness in the Cauchy problem holds. If u is a solution, then the support of u is a union of orbits. Before we provide the proof, we will recall some definitions and results from a paper of Bony ([Bo]). Definition III.2.2. Let be an open subset of Rn and F a closed subset of . A vector v is said to be normal to F at x0 ∈ F if there is an open ball B ⊆ \F centered at x such that x0 ∈ B and v = x − x0 for some > 0. Remark III.2.3. By considering cones of varying apertures, it is easy to see that a closed set may have no normals or many normals at a boundary point. Definition III.2.4. Suppose is open in Rn and F ⊆ is closed. A vector field Xx is tangent to F if whenever v is normal to x0 in F , the vector Xx0 is orthogonal to v. In [Bo], Bony proved the following: Theorem III.2.5. Suppose is open in Rn and F a closed subset of . Let Xx be a Lipschitz vector field in which is tangent to F . If an integral curve of X intersects F at a point, then it is entirely contained in F . Proof of Theorem III.2.1. Let ) denote the projection map from T ∗ onto . Suppose u is a solution on and F denotes the support of u. Let = \F . Define NF to be the set of ∈ T ∗ \0 over points in F such that there exists f real-valued, smooth, defined near p = ) and such that fp = 0, dfp = and f ≤ 0 on F near p. Fix p ∈ F and suppose ∈ NF with ) = p. Suppose we show that for any X = L (for some smooth section L of ) defined near p, # X$ = 0. Then by Bony’s theorem, the integral curve of X through p will lie in F , thus proving the theorem. Let f be chosen as above with dfp = . Note that near p, the zero set of f is a smooth hypersurface, and u ≡ 0 on a side of this hypersurface. Since p ∈ F = supp u, by the uniqueness in the Cauchy problem, has to be characteristic to f = 0 at p. Hence, # X$ = 0. We note that if is an involutive structure for which uniqueness in the Cauchy problem is not valid, then the support of a solution may not be a union of orbits, as demonstrated by Cohen’s celebrated example ([Co]). Definition III.2.6. A formally integrable structure satisfies the global unique continuation property if every solution that vanishes on an open subset vanishes everywhere on .
110
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
According to Theorem III.2.1, global unique continuation holds in a locally integrable structure whenever is a single orbit for . However, global unique continuation may hold even when is not a single orbit, as shown by the structure on the 2-torus generated by a real vector field each of whose integral curves is dense. The obstruction to the validity of global unique continuation is the presence of proper, closed subsets of which are unions of orbits, since by Theorem III.2.1, such sets can potentially be the supports of solutions. We will refer to sets that are unions of orbits as invariant sets. In order to check the validity of global unique continuation, one needs to understand when a given proper, closed, invariant set equals the support of a solution. It turns out that in a general locally integrable structure, a proper, closed orbit may not be the support of a solution. This is illustrated by examples below. Some sufficient conditions for the existence of a solution supported on a proper, closed orbit were studied in the work [BM]. In particular, the following theorem was proved (see also Theorem III.2.12 below): Theorem III.2.7 (Theorem 5.8 in [BM].). Suppose is an orientable, connected analytic hypersurface in Cn . If is not Levi flat and has a codimension one orbit , then there is a solution supported on . Thus, on an analytic, non-Levi flat hypersurface in Cn , the global unique continuation property holds if and only if there is only one orbit. Example III.2.8. We consider real-analytic vector fields L in the plane that are rotation-invariant. That is, if is the bundle generated by L, then dR = for every rotation R (with angle ) of R2 . In polar coordinates, such an L takes the form (see [BMe]) L = gr rYr + iXr r X is even in r away from the Y zeros of Y and we may assume that X0 = Y0 = 1. The characteristic set 0 = XrY r = 0 is a union of circles centered at 0 and 0 % 0. Assume 0 = r = 1 . If L is of finite type at a point p in 0, then it is of the same type at every point p in 0 and in this case, has only one orbit. Suppose now L is of type at some and hence every point of 0. Then (see [BMe]) it can be shown that is generated by √ L= − −1rYr r where g, X, Y are real-analytic functions,
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation
111
where Yr = 1 − r 2 N hr, h is real-analytic, hr = 0, and h0 ∈ ±1 . Without loss of generality, assume h0 = 1. Then, has three orbits: r < 1 , r > 1 , and 0 = r = 1 . We consider next whether 0 can be the support of a distribution solution. When N ≥ 2, the distribution #u *r $ =
2) *1 d 0
is a solution supported on 0. Assume N = 1. In this case, such a u exists if and only if h1 is a rational number ([BMe]). Indeed, suppose Lu = 0 and u is supported on 0. Then there exist an integer k ≥ 0 and aj ∈ S 1 0 ≤ j ≤ k such that k
2)
#u *r $ =
m=0
am
0
r
m *1 d
Since L is in the tangential direction on 0, each aj ∈ C 0. Let *jn r = l fj r ein , where fj r is C and fj 1 = jl for 0 ≤ j ≤ k. Note that the transpose of L is given by t
Lw = −
w w + irYr + i2Yr + rY rw r
and so t
L*kn = iein rYrfk r + 2Yr + rY r − nfk
Moreover,
and
r
r
m rYrfk r r=1
=
0
m
kY 1
m=k
m
2Yr + rY r − nfk r r=1 =
0
Y 1 − n
m
Thus, we get: 0 = #Lu *kn $ = #ut L*kn $ 2) in = ak e d k + 1Y 1 − n
(III.1)
0
Since we may assume that ak does not vanish identically, there is an integer M for which
112
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
2) ak eiM d = 0
(III.2)
0
From (III.1) and (III.2) it follows that h1 =
−M ∈ Q and 2k + 1
ak = ce−iM for some c = 0. Conversely, suppose k ≥ 0 and M are integers satisfying 2k + 1h1 = −M We will seek a solution u of the form k
2)
#u *r $ =
m=0
0
bm r
m *1 d
Set bk = e−iM . Each bj can be determined from the equation #Lu *jM $ = 0. To see this, note that #Lu *k−1M $ = 0 is equivalent to ⎛ ⎞ 2) d k
rYfk−1 + rY + 2Y − Mfk−1 1 + ⎝ bk−1 eiM d⎠ 0 = 2) dr 0 k−1 d
rYfk−1 + rY + 2Y − Mfk−1 1 × dr
2) The coefficient of bk−1 eiM d in the latter equation is −2kh1 − M = 0
2h1 = 0, and hence we can get a constant ck−1 such that if we set bk−1 = ck−1 e−iM , then
#Lu *k−1M r $ = 0
In general, we can determine bl from #Lu *lM $ = 0. This leads to bl = cl e−iM for some constant cl since
d dr
l
rYfl + 2Y + rY − Mfl 1 = 2k − lh1 = 0
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation
113
Thus #Lu *jm $ = 0 for all m ∈ Z, and all j = 0 k. Since Lu is a distribution of order k, it follows that Lu = 0. Example III.2.9. (See [BM].) We denote the coordinates in R3 by x y s and we will write R3 = Rx × Ry × Rs . Let R −→ R be a smooth, 2)periodic function, ≥ 0 and not identically 0. Define L=
+ i + x sins = X + iY x y s
The coefficients of L are 2)-periodic and so L induces a vector field 2 L on T3 = S 1 × S 1 × S 1 . The involutive structure generated by 2 L is a Levi flat, locally integrable CR structure. We will show the following: (1) The orbits of 2 L through p1 = 1 1 1 and p2 = 1 1 −1 are compact but all other orbits are noncompact. (2) Depending on the value of 2) xdx 0
there may not be any solution supported on either of the compact orbits. (3) Global unique continuation is valid for continuous solutions. Let F R3 −→ T3 be given by Fx y s = eix eiy eis Consider the orbit 1 through the point p1 = 1 1 1. F0 0 0 = p1 and the orbit in R3 of X Y through 0 0 0 is Rx × Ry × 0 . Therefore, 1 = S 1 × S 1 × 1 . Likewise, for the point p2 = 1 1 −1, the orbit 2 = S 1 × S 1 × −1 . Consider now a typical point p = 1 1 eis0 for some 0 < s0 < ). If t = xt st is the integral curve of X with 0 = 0 s0 , we will see that the orbit through p is given by = eit eiy eist t y ∈ R Indeed, xt = t and s t = t sinst, s0 = s0 . If for some t0 , st0 = ), then the curves t and 1 t = t ) will both be integral curves of X passing through t0 ) at t = t0 . This implies that st ≡ ), contradicting the assumption that s0 = s0 < ). Likewise, st can never equal zero. Thus, 0 ≤ st ≤ ) and s t ≥ 0. Suppose lim st = a < )
t→
114
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Then s0 ≤ st ≤ a for all t ≥ 0. Therefore, s t ≥ ct for some c > 0, which in turn leads to lim st =
t→
Hence, lim st = )
t→
and by a similar reasoning, lim st = 0
t→−
Thus the closure of = ∪ 1 ∪ 2 . We consider now the question of existence of a solution supported on a compact orbit, say 1 . Since L is tangent to 1 and defines a complex structure there, any distribution solution u supported on this orbit has the form N ux y = ul x yl l=0
where the ul are C on S 1 × S 1 and 2) #k gx y s$ = 0
0
2)
sk gx y 0 dxdy
We have #Lk gx y s$ = #k t Lgx y s$ ) k ( 2) 2) g sin s + cos sg x y 0 dxdy x =− s s 0 0 k+1 2) 2) x
sin sg x y 0 dxdy =− s 0 0 k−l l k+1 2) 2) k + 1 cos s gx y 0 dxdy =− l s s 0 0 l=0 Thus, Lk = −k + 1xk − x
k−2 l=0
k + 1 k−l s cos s0l l
Let Mk = +i −k+1x, for k = 0 1 2 If vx y ∈ C S 1 ×S 1 , x y it follows that k−2 k + 1 k−l s cos s 0l Lvk = Mk vk − v l l=0
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation
115
Suppose now u=
N
uk x yk
k=0
is a solution. Then Lu =
N
Ml ul l −
l=0
N −2
N
l=0 k=l+2
Let 0 =
k+1 uk sk−l cos s 0l l
1 2) x dx 2) 0
and define 1 = − 0 . Since Lu = 0 and uN may be assumed nontrivial, we must have N + 10 ∈ Z. Thus if 0 is not a rational number, there are no solutions supported on the orbit 1 . If 0 is rational, with 0 = p/q where p and q are relatively prime, then N = q − 1 is the lowest possible transversal order of a nontrivial solution supported on 1 . This follows from the injectivity of Ml for l < N and the fact that MN has a nontrivial kernel. Since Ml is also surjective for l < N (as is easily seen using Fourier series), one can correct the ‘errors’ to obtain a solution u iteratively. Finally, we remark that there are solutions supported on the closure of any noncompact orbit. This will follow from Theorem III.2.12 as stated below, or can be constructed explicitly as in [BM]. Thus, global unique continuation is not valid for distribution solutions. However, it is valid for continuous solutions. We will now place these two examples in a more general context following [BM]. Given a locally integrable structure , let 0 be an orbit such that dim 0 < dim = m + n, where n is the rank of . Assume that 0 is an embedded submanifold of . Fix p ∈ 0 and let Z1 Zm be a complete set of first integrals defined in a neighborhood U in of p. Let L1 Ln be smooth, local generators of in U such that the brackets Li Lj = 0 for all i, j. Complete this to a basis L1 Ln M1 Mm of CT in U such that (1) Li Mk = 0, and (2) Mk Zi = ik . Let 1 n be smooth, exact one-forms in U such that 1 n dZ1 dZm
116
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
is a dual basis to L1 Ln M1 Mm . If 0 denotes the restriction of to 0, then 0 also has rank n. Hence if dim 0 = k + n, then after shrinking U about p, the restrictions of exactly k of Z1 Zm have linearly independent differentials along 0. Without loss of generality, assume that Z1 Zk have this latter property. It follows that Mk+1 Mm is a basis of the complexified normal bundle of 0 in U . Fix orientations in U and in U ∩ 0 so that distributions in U (resp. in U ∩ 0) may be viewed as acting on forms of top degree. We wish to describe all solutions in U that are supported on U ∩ 0. Let M = Mk+1 Mm . If u is any distribution in U that is supported on U ∩ 0, it is well known that there is an integer N and distributions u on U ∩ 0 for ≤ N , such that for any ∈ Cc U, #u M ∧ dZ $ #u ∧ dZ$ =
≤N
where = 1 ∧ · · · ∧ n , dZ = dZ1 ∧ dZm , dZ = dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZk and u = 0 for some , = N . Here and in what follows, by abusing notations, we are denoting by ∧ dZ the pullback to 0. Observe now that if h ∈ C 1 U, then dh =
m
Mi hdZi +
i=1
n
Lj hj
j=1
as can be seen by applying both sides of the equation to the basis L1 Ln M1 Mm Hence if h ∈ C U and ∈ Cc U, then #Lj h ∧ dZ$ = Lj h ∧ dZ U ˆ j ∧ · · · ∧ n ∧ dZ =−1j dh 1 ∧ · · · ∧ U − hLj ∧ dZ U = − hLj ∧ dZ U
= − #h Lj ∧ dZ$
∀j = 1 n
It follows that for the distribution u supported on U ∩ 0 as before, if ∈ Cc U, we have: #Lj u ∧ dZ$ = −#u Lj ∧ dZ$
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation =−
#u M Lj ∧ dZ $
117
∀j = 1 n
≤N
Assume now that u is also a solution. We will next show that each u is a solution of the induced structure 0 . Fix a point q ∈ U ∩ 0. The restrictions of Zl (l = k + 1 m) to 0 are solutions of 0 . By the Baouendi–Treves approximation theorem, for each such Zl , there is a sequence Pil i=1 of holomorphic polynomials such that Zl = lim Pil Z1 Zk i→
in C V ∩ 0 for some neighborhood V of q in . For each l = k + 1 m, define the sequence fil i=1 by fil = Zl − Pil Z1 Zk Each fil ∈ C V and for every l, lim fil = 0
i→
in C V ∩ 0. Let fi = fik+1 fim for i = 1 2 Fix a multi-index in Nm−k such that = N . For any ∈ Cc V and any j = 1 n, 0 = #Lj u fi ∧ dZ$ = −#u Lj fi ∧ dZ$ =− #u M Lj fi ∧ dZ $
≤N
=−
#u Lj M fi ∧ dZ $
≤N
=−
#Lj u M fi ∧ dZ $
≤N
= −#Lj u ∧ dZ $ + Ei since Ei −→ 0 on V ∩0 as i −→ and Ms fil = sl . Hence Lj u = 0 whenever
= N . Thus 0 = #Lj u * ∧ dZ$ = #Lj u M * ∧ dZ $
≤N −1
for any * ∈ Cc U. Plugging * = fi with = N − 1 and ∈ Cc V in these latter equations will likewise lead to Lj u = 0 whenever = N − 1
118
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Continuing this way, we conclude: Lj u = 0 ∀j ∀. Conversely, it is easy to see that if u has the form #u ∧ dZ$ = #u M ∧ dZ $
≤N
where each u is a solution of 0 and some u is nontrivial, then u is a solution in U supported on U ∩0. In particular, the distributions ( ∈ Nm−k ) defined by # ∧ dZ$ = M ∧ dZ 0
are solutions in U supported on U ∩ 0. Observe that = M 0 Heuristically speaking then, we may say that each solution u in U supported on U ∩ 0 can be expressed as u u=
≤N
where the u are solutions of 0 in U ∩ 0. The distribution 0 was introduced by Treves ([T5]). The existence of local solutions such as 0 supported on a nonopen orbit had previously been established by Baouendi and Rothschild in their proof of the necessity of Tumanov’s minimality condition for the holomorphic extension of CR functions into wedges (see Section III.3). We have proved: Theorem III.2.10. Let p ∈ 0, U , Z1 Zm 1 n and M = Mk+1 Mm be chosen as above. Then, u is a solution in U supported on U ∩ 0 if and only if u can be expressed as #u ∧ dZ$ = #u M ∧ dZ $
≤N
where the u are solutions of 0 and u is nontrivial for some = N . Suppose now u is a distribution supported on 0. In a chart U about p ∈ 0, write as before #u M ∧ dZ $ #u ∧ dZ$ =
≤N
Let N = Np be the minimum integer for which such a representation is possible. We will call Np the transversal order of u at p. When u is also a solution, we have:
III.2 Propagation of support and global unique continuation
119
Theorem III.2.11. If u is a solution supported on 0, the transversal order Np, p ∈ 0 is constant. Proof. Let p ∈ 0. Choose a chart U as before such that U ∩ 0 is connected and #u M ∧ dZ $ #u ∧ dZ$ =
≤N
where N = Np. Let 0 1 −→ 0 be an integral curve of X for some smooth section of such that 0 = p. We consider Nt for those t for which t ∈ U . In any neighborhood of such a t, u has the representation above. Moreover, if each u for = N vanishes in a neighborhood of such t, then since the u are solutions for 0 , by Theorem III.2.1 the u will vanish identically in a neighborhood of p in 0 (for = N ), leading to the contradiction that Np < N . Thus whenever t ∈ U , then Nt = Np. This argument shows that the set t ∈ 0 1 Nt = Np is both closed and open, and hence N1 = Np. Since any two points of 0 can be joined by a finite number of such ’s, the theorem follows. We will continue to assume that the orbit 0 is an embedded orbit. Let U be a covering of 0 by open sets in such that in each U we have a basis L1 Ln of , a basis L1 Ln M1 Mm of CTU , a dual basis 1 n dZ1 dZm where the i are exact and Z1 Zm is a complete set of first integrals. We will assume that the restrictions of Z1 Zk to U ∩0 form a complete set of first integrals for 0 . If u is a solution supported on 0 of transversal order zero, then we know that it is given by distributions u in U ∩ 0 in the sense that for any ∈ Cc U , #u dZ ∧ $ = #u dZ ∧ $ where in the right-hand side we mean the pullback of the form on 0. Let V = U ∩ 0 and whenever V ∩ V = ∅, let g ∈ C V ∩ V satisfy i∗ dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZk ∧ = g i∗ dZ1 ∧ · · · ∧ dZk ∧ where for a form in , i∗ denotes the pullback to 0. Note that the g are nonvanishing and on V ∩ V , g u = u . Therefore, 0 = Lj u = Lj g u . If Lj g is not zero on an open set, then u will be zero there. But then u will vanish on this open set and hence on 0, contradicting the nontriviality
120
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
of u. Hence the g are solutions on V ∩ V . Thus 0 is covered by V and whenever V ∩ V = ∅, we have a nonvanishing, smooth solution g V ∩ V −→ C It follows that we can construct a line bundle ) E −→ 0 having the g as transition functions. In particular, if 0 0 is a complex structure, the bundle E becomes a holomorphic line bundle and solutions of supported on 0 of transversal order zero correspond to nontrivial holomorphic sections of this bundle. In the situation where 0 is a Stein manifold, it is well known that a holomorphic bundle always has a nontrivial holomorphic section. In other words, we have: Theorem III.2.12. Suppose 0 is an embedded orbit of and 0 0 is a complex structure. If 0 is a Stein manifold, there are solutions supported on 0 of transversal order 0.
III.3 The strong uniqueness property for locally integrable solutions In this section we will consider locally integrable structures on an open domain in RN . The solutions we study will be assumed to be elements of the space L1loc of locally integrable functions with respect to Lebesgue measure. Definition III.3.1. The structure satisfies the strong uniqueness property if every solution u ∈ L1loc that is zero on a set of positive measure vanishes identically. Example III.3.2. Let be the structure generated by the Cauchy–Riemann 1 ≤ j ≤ n on a domain in Cn . Then satisfies the vector fields ¯zj strong uniqueness property. Example III.3.3. Let be the structure generated by a real-analytic vector field L on a domain in the plane. Assume that there is only one orbit. Then satisfies the strong uniqueness property. Indeed, suppose u ∈ L1loc , Lu = 0, and u vanishes on a set E of positive measure. Since there is only one orbit, it follows that there is an open set where L is elliptic and a subset E ⊆ of positive measure where u vanishes. By Corollary I.13.4, the ellipticity of L implies that locally, coordinates can be found in which L
III.3 Strong uniqueness for locally integrable solutions
121
becomes a nonvanishing multiple of the Cauchy–Riemann operator. Hence u vanishes on . By Theorem III.2.1, u has to vanish on . 1 ≤ j ≤ n on a xj domain ⊆ RN . It is easy to see that if n < N , will not satisfy the strong uniqueness property.
Example III.3.4. Let be the structure generated by
It turns out that orbits play a role in the validity of the strong uniqueness property. Before stating the main results, we need to introduce refinements of the concept of an orbit. Definition III.3.5. The bundle is called minimal at p ∈ if, given an open set p ∈ U ⊆ , there exists a smaller open set p ∈ U ⊆ U such that every point in U can be reached from p by a finite number of integral curves of sections of and each integral curve lies in U . Example III.3.6. If is real-analytic and has an open orbit , then is minimal at every p ∈ . In this case, we can take U = U . Example III.3.7. Let be the structure generated by the vector field L=
+ igx1 x1 x2
where g ∈ C R, g > 0 on 1 2 and g ≡ 0 outside 1 2. Observe that there is only one orbit in the plane. However, is minimal at a point p = x1 x2 if and only if x1 ∈ 1 2 . If is a real hypersurface in Cn with the standard CR structure which is a single orbit, it always has minimal points. This follows from the fact that if there are no minimal points in , then will be closed under Lie brackets leading to a Frobenius foliation of by orbits each of dimension 2n − 2. Each of these orbits is a complex hypersurface. Indeed, the CR bundle induces on each orbit a locally integrable structure that is CR and elliptic. By Theorem I.10.1, near each p ∈ , we can find coordinates x1 xm y1 ym (m = n − 1) such that the induced structure on is generated by z j = 1 m. In particular, any solution on is a holomorj phic function of the first integrals Z1 Zm Zj = xj + iyj . Going back to the complex coordinates z1 zn of Cn , it follows that the restriction to of one of these coordinates is a holomorphic function of the remaining coordinates. In other words, is a complex hypersurface—contradicting the fact that is a single orbit. However, there are CR manifolds in Cn consisting
122
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
of a single orbit with no minimal points. Examples of such are provided by the following, which appeared in [Jo1]: Example III.3.8. Let ⊆ C3 be given by = x1 + iy1 x2 + iy2 x3 + iy3 x1 = h1 x3 x2 = h2 x3 where h1 ≡ 0 for x3 ≥ − 21 and h1 is strictly convex for x3 < − 21 , h2 ≡ 0 for x3 ≤ 21 and h2 is strictly convex for x3 > 21 . is a CR submanifold of codimension 2. It consists of a single orbit but has no minimal points. The concept of minimality appeared in Tumanov’s theorem on the holomorphic extension of CR functions into wedges. Minimality is a necessary and sufficient geometric condition for the holomorphic extension of all CR functions into wedges. In [Tu1] Tumanov proved: Theorem III.3.9. Let be a generic CR submanifold of CN and p ∈ . If is minimal at p, then for every neighborhood U of p in there exists a wedge with edge centered at p such that every continuous CR function in U extends holomorphically to the wedge . Conversely, if is not minimal at p, Baouendi and Rothschild ([BR]) proved that there exists a continuous CR function defined in a neighborhood of p in which does not extend holomorphically to any wedge of edge centered at p. Tumanov’s original definition of minimality was stated differently. He called a CR submanifold of CN minimal at p if it contains no proper (i.e., of smaller dimension) CR submanifold of the same CR dimension through p. For the equivalence of the two definitions, we refer the reader to Marson’s paper ([Ma]). Definition III.3.10. Given an involutive structure on an open subset of RN , we say that an orbit is a.e. minimal if is minimal at p for almost every p ∈ in the sense of Lebesgue measure in RN . Note that if an orbit is a.e. minimal, then it is an open orbit. Example III.3.11. If is real-analytic and is an open orbit, then is a.e. minimal since is minimal at every p ∈ . Here is a simple example of an a.e. minimal orbit which is not minimal everywhere:
III.3 Strong uniqueness for locally integrable solutions
123
Example III.3.12. Let = R2 and be the structure generated by L=
+ ibx y x y
where bx y is smooth, real-valued, and b = 0 only on −1 1 × 0 . Then is minimal exactly at the points in \−1 1 × 0 . We can now state the main result on strong uniqueness: Theorem III.3.13. Let be a locally integrable structure defined on a connected open set in RN . Assume that = ∪ F where is an open a.e. minimal orbit of and F is a set of measure zero. Then any solution u ∈ L1loc that vanishes on a set of positive measure must vanish identically. Theorem III.3.13 was proved in [BH2]. According to the theorem, if satisfies the hypotheses, then almost every point p ∈ can be reached from a fixed point q ∈ by a piecewise smooth curve consisting of integral curves of smooth sections of . We may say that has an a.e. reachability property with respect to . Thus satisfies the a.e. reachability property if and only if admits a trivial decomposition, that is, if it can be expressed as the union of an open orbit and a set of measure zero. We note, however, that this a.e. reachability condition is not necessary for the conclusion of the theorem. For example, the structure generated on the 2-torus T2 by a real globally hypoelliptic vector field L has the strong uniqueness property although the torus does not admit a trivial decomposition. However, local a.e. reachability is necessary if the conclusion of Theorem III.3.13 is to hold on any base of connected neighborhoods of a given point. Indeed, we have the following [BH2] partial converse to Theorem III.3.13: Theorem III.3.14. Let be a sub-bundle of CT where ⊆ RN is open. Assume there is a base j j=1 of connected neighborhoods of p which do not admit a trivial decomposition. Then there is a base of connected neighborhoods Uk ⊆ k of p and nontrivial solutions uk ∈ L1 Uk for which the sets uk = 0 all have positive measure. We remark that in Theorem III.3.14, is not assumed to be locally integrable. It is not even assumed that it is involutive. Thus for analytic involutive structures (which are always locally integrable), Theorems III.3.13 and III.3.14 establish the local equivalence between a.e. reachability and the uniqueness property that local solutions are determined on sets of positive measure. We will prove Theorem III.3.13 in the important situation where is the tangential Cauchy–Riemann bundle of a CR manifold embedded in CN
124
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
(see Theorem III.3.15 below). In fact, by using Marson’s ([Ma]) trick of embedding a general locally integrable structure into a CR structure, one can deduce Theorem III.3.13 from Theorem III.3.15 (see [BH2] for the details). Theorem III.3.15 states that the strong uniqueness property that holomorphic functions have—that of being determined on any domain by their values on any subset of positive measure or, equivalently, that their zero sets have measure zero except in a trivial case—is inherited by their boundary values at the edge of the wedge where they are defined. In the particular classical case of a holomorphic function of one variable defined on a disk, this principle is well known and is attributed to Priwaloff and Riesz. Thus Theorem III.3.15 is, to a certain extent, a higher-dimensional version of the theorem of Priwaloff and Riesz. Theorem III.3.15. Let ⊆ CN be a generic CR manifold of codimension d (N = n + d). Assume that ⊆ CN is a wedge with edge . Suppose F is a holomorphic function of tempered growth on with distribution boundary value f ∈ L1loc . If f vanishes on a subset E of positive measure, then f ≡ 0 in a neighborhood of any Lebesgue density point of E. In the proof of Theorem III.3.15, we will use the following lemma where 0 is a smooth hypersurface in Cn , f is a CR function on 0, and f ∈ Lp 0 for some 1 ≤ p ≤ . Suppose also that f extends to a holomorphic function F on a side 0+ , that is, f is the boundary value of F in the distribution sense. Then we have: Lemma III.3.16. For any 0 ⊂⊂ 0, and a sufficiently small ball B in Cn containing zero, the restrictions of F to the hypersurfaces z ∈ B dist z 0 = t have uniformly bounded Lp norms. In particular, F ∈ Lp B ∩ 0+ . Proof. Without loss of generality, we may assume that 0 is part of the boundary of a bounded open set D with smooth boundary such that D ⊆ 0+ Let H be harmonic in D with boundary value f on 0 and 0 off 0. By the classical hp theory for harmonic functions, the restrictions Ht of H to the hypersurfaces St = z ∈ D dist z D = t (t small) are all in Lp and Ht Lp St ≤ f Lp 0 Moreover, it is well known that ‘dist z D’ can be replaced by any defining function for D. Since F is holomorphic in 0+ and has a boundary value on 0, there exist C k > 0 such that for any z ∈ D,
Fz ≤ C dist z 0−k This may require contracting 0. It follows that F has a boundary value which is a distribution on D. Let u = F − H
III.3 Strong uniqueness for locally integrable solutions
125
u is harmonic in D, has a distributional boundary value bu on D which is 0 on the piece 0. We wish to show u is smooth up to 0. Let Gx y be the Green’s function for D and Px y its Poisson kernel. We recall that Px y = −Ny Gx y for x ∈ D y ∈ D where Ny = the unit outer normal to D at y. Fix x ∈ D. The function y −→ Gx y is 0 on D and positive on D\x By Hopf’s lemma, Ny Gx y = 0 for all y ∈ D. Hence for % small enough, the open sets D% = y ∈ D Gx y > % 2% z y is the Green’s function for have smooth boundaries. Observe that if G D% , then 2% x y = Gx y − % G Hence the Poisson kernel P% z y for D% satisfies P% x y = −Ny% Gx y where Ny% is the unit outer normal to D% at y. We thus have ux = P% x yuy d% y D % −1 = P% x 1−1 % yu1% yJ% y dy D
where 1% D% −→ D is the normal projection map and J% is the Jacobian % + of 1−1 % . Since P% x y = −Ny Gx y as % −→ 0 , P% x 1−1 % yJ% y −→ Px y in C D. It follows that for any x ∈ D, ux = #bu Px $ This latter formula, together with the vanishing of bu on 0, tells us that u is C up to the boundary piece 0. Since F = H + u and H ∈ hp D the assertions of the theorem follow. Corollary III.3.17. [Nontangential Convergence] Let f and F be as in the lemma and D be as in the proof of the lemma. For > 1 and A ∈ 0, define + A = z ∈ D z − A < z where z = dist z D Then
126
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation lim
+ Az→A
Fz = fA
for almost all A in 0. Proof. Recall from the proof that F = H + u. Since u is smooth up to the piece 0 and bu vanishes on 0, limDz→A uz = 0 for all A ∈ 0. The corollary therefore follows from the fact that H ∈ hp D and that on 0, H = f .
III.4 Proof of Theorem III.3.15 To prove Theorem III.3.15, we may assume that 0 ∈ is a density point of E and that near 0 is defined by w = x y w, where z = x + iy ∈ Cn and w ∈ Cd N = n + d. The function is real-valued, smooth, 0 = 0, and d0 = 0. We may also assume that the wedge contains a wedge of the form z w w = s + ix y s + iv z < 2 s < 2 v < 2 v ∈ + for some open convex cone + ⊂ Rd and > 0. We may suppose that dx y s < 41 for x y s < 2. Without loss of generality, assume that + = v = v vd v < 2vd Let 2 + = y t ∈ Rn+d y t < td t = t td For y0 < , the set ˜ x y s t < y0 = x + iy0 + iy s + ix y0 s + it y t ∈ + is contained in the wedge . Indeed, this follows from the definitions of + and +˜ and the assumption on the norm of d. Observe that y0 is a wedge in CN with a maximally totally real edge y0 = x + iy0 s + ix y0 s x < s < Fix y0 , y0 < such that x s −→ fx y0 s is in L1 and the n + d-dimensional set y0 intersects E in a set of positive measure. Note that F is holomorphic and of tempered growth in the wedge y0 . Hence F has a distribution boundary value bF on y0 . We will eventually show that bF agrees with f on y0 for almost all y0 . Assuming this for
III.4 Proof of Theorem III.3.15
127
now, it is clear that Theorem III.3.15 would follow if we show that F ≡ 0 on y0 . This kind of reduction to a maximally totally real manifold also appears in the proof of theorem 7.2.6 in [BER]. We are thus led to consider a maximally totally real submanifold 0 of Cm given in a neighborhood U of 0 ∈ Cm by t = s
s ∈ U
where w = s + it are standard complex coordinates in Cm , is a smooth Rm -valued function defined near 0 ∈ Rm , and 0 = d0 = 0. We recall that a Cm -valued analytic disk is a map A $ → Cm of class C 1+ from the closed unit disk of the complex plane which is holomorphic on $ (here 0 < < 1 is fixed once from now on). An analytic disk A is said to be partially attached to 0 at p if (i) Aei ∈ 0 for ≤ )2 and (ii) A1 = p. The Banach space of Cm -valued analytic disks will be denoted by m . We recall theorem 7.4.12 of [BER] on the existence of analytic disks partially attached to 0: Theorem III.4.1 ([BER].). There exist a neighborhood U × V of the origin 0 0 ∈ Rm × Rm and a smooth map U × V s v → Asv ∈ m satisfying the following properties for all s v ∈ U × V : (i) Asv 1 = s + is; (ii) Asv ei ∈ 0 for ≤ )/2; (iii) (iv)
d Asv ei =0 = v + i s · v. d d Asv r r=1 = iv − s · v. dr
Notice that we have included (iv) here since it follows from (iii) and the Cauchy–Riemann equations satisfied by → Asv at = 1. The meaning of (i) and (ii) is that Asv is partially attached to 0 at p = s s and (iii) implies that we can choose a neighborhood U˜ ⊂ U of the origin and a small % > 0 such that for every p = s0 + is0 , s0 ∈ U˜ , the map 0 % × S m−1 0 %
−→ As0 ei ∈ 0
yields a C 1+ local system of polar coordinates centered at p on 0, where S m−1 0 % denotes the sphere of radius % centered at 0 ∈ Rm . In particular, given v0 ∈ Rm , v0 = %, and p1 = s1 + is1 , s1 ∈ U˜ , we may find s0 ∈ U and 0 ∈ 0 % such that p1 = As0 v0 ei0
128
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Assume that p1 is a density point of a measurable set E ⊆ 0 (in particular E has positive measure) and let U0 s0 and V0 v0 be open sets of diameter < %. Consider the set % 2 (E Asv ei d > 0 E % = s v ∈ U0 × S m−1 0 % ∩ V0 0
where (E denotes the characteristic function of E. We observe that we may assume without loss of generality that 2 E % has positive 2m − 1-dimensional measure. Indeed, the function −→ (E Asv ei ds dv
s−s <% 0
v−v0 <2%
is continuous and assumes a positive value at = 0 because Asv 1 = s + is. Hence, % i (E Asv e d ds dv > 0
s−s <% 0
v−v0 <2%
0
and writing v in polar coordinates we see that for some 0 < % < 2% our claim is true for 2 E % . We fix such an % > 0 and, dropping any reference to the dependence on % , simply write 2 E% = 2 E. Consider now the map U0 × S m−1 0 % ∩ V0 × 1 − % 1
s v r −→ Asv r ∈ Cm (III.3)
Taking account of (iv) we note that this map has rank 2m for small % > 0 and maps s × S m−1 0 % ∩ V0 × 1 − % 1 onto Bp \p , where Bp is a C 1+ differentiable m-ball that intersects 0 orthogonally at p = s + is. Indeed, the respective tangent spaces at p are Tp 0 = s + is + v + i s · v
Tp Bp = s + is + iv − s · v
v ∈ Rm
and
v ∈ R m
Since the map (III.3) is a local diffeomorphism, it takes 2 E onto a set of positive E . measure $ E which is contained in the union of the disks Asv s v ∈ 2 We could say that these disks are strongly attached to E in the sense that for any s v ∈ 2 E the set of boundary points Asv ei 0 < < % intersects E at a non-negligible set of values of . Consider now a holomorphic function F of slow growth defined in a wedge = 0 × + with edge 0 possessing a weak trace f ∈ Lp 0 and assume that f vanishes on E. Assume furthermore that v0 ∈ +. We will now sketch how we try to prove that F must vanish. First one proves that if % > 0 is small enough and s v ∈ 2 E the portion A%sv of the disk Asv described by the inequalities −% < < % and 1 − % < r < 1 is contained in
III.4 Proof of Theorem III.3.15
129
the wedge . Then the composition FAsv rei is defined for −% < < %, 1 − % < r < 1, is holomorphic and has a weak boundary value which, for a.e. s v ∈ 2 E, is given by—and the proof of this fact is our second step— fAsv ei . The third step is to prove that for a.e. s v, the restriction of f to the curve %/2 % → Asv ei is in Lp . Hence, by Corollary III.3.17 and the classical theorem of Priwaloff, the holomorphic function of one complex variable FAsv rei vanishes identically for −% < < %, 1 − % < r < 1, in particular for = 0. But we know that letting s v r vary on 2 E × 1 − % 1 and keeping = 0, the union of Asv rei covers $ E. Thus, F vanishes a.e. on $ E and so must vanish identically. The proof of the second step involves a discussion about the trace which will be developed next. We begin our considerations by looking at the simplest case of a holomorphic function of one complex variable Fx + iy defined for x < 1, 0 < y < 2 which satisfies the inequality
Fx + iy ≤ C log y
x < 1
0 < y < 2
(III.4)
We assume (III.4) for simplicity but the argument below can be iterated to handle the case Fx + iy ≤ C y −N . The standard manner of defining the weak trace f of F as an element of is through the formula (III.5) #f *$ = lim Fx + i- *x dx * ∈ Cc −1 1 -(0
In formula (III.5) we see that for each fixed x the argument of F describes a straight vertical segment - → x + i- that flows toward x as - → 0. We wish to see what happens if we change each vertical segment to a curve - → x + x - + i-. We will assume that −1 1 × 0 1 x - → is of class C 2 (we would need class C N +2 if we were assuming Fx +iy ≤ C y −N instead of (III.4)) and that x 0 = 0, x < 1. The latter assumption simply means that the curve - → x + x - + i- flows toward x as - → 0. Thus, j x 0 = 0 j = 0 1 2 (III.6) x We now define #2 f *$ = lim
-(0
Fx + x - + i- *x dx
* ∈ Cc −1 1
and wish to prove that f = 2 f . To that end we write 1 Fx + x - + i- = Fx + x - + i − i F x + x - + it dt -
It follows from (III.6) that if x belongs to a compact part of −1 1 and - is small, x x - < 1/2. We will assume for simplicity that x x - < 1/2 holds everywhere. Then
130
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Fx+x - + i- *x dx = Fx + x - + i*x dx 1 *x +i Fx + x - + it dt dx x 1 + x x - -
Letting - → 0 and taking account of (III.6), we obtain #f *$ = #2 f *$ as we wished. From now on we return to the general situation of a maximally totally real submanifold 0 of Cm and a holomorphic function F defined on a wedge = 0 × + and possessing a trace f ∈ Lp 0. We will now take advantage of two facts: (1) The formula #f *$ = lim
-→0
Fs + s - + is + -v0 + s - *s ds
is independent of the family of curves s - = s + s - -v0 + s - as long as all curves - → - s are contained in , they have the right number of bounded derivatives, and s 0 = s 0 = 0, s ∈ U (the assumptions imply that vo ∈ +). (2) The analytic disks described in theorem 7.4.12 of [BER] can be taken of class C k+ rather than C 1+ where k is a large positive integer. The first fact follows from proposition 7.2.22 in [BER]. The second fact is true because theorems 6.5.4 and 7.4.12 in [BER] are valid with the same proofs if the analytic disks are taken to be in C k for a fixed positive integer k. In the proof of theorem 7.4.12, the function h has to be modified so that one gets a C k extension. Set s = s1 sm−1 . We will assume without loss of generality that (i) For any % > 0 the set s
s < % and s 0 v0 ∈ 2 E
has positive measure. (ii) v0 = 0 0 a for some small a > 0. For s < %, < % consider the map s −→ As 0v0 ei
(III.7)
III.4 Proof of Theorem III.3.15
131
which for small % has an injective differential. We consider a family of curves p - defined by p = As 0v0 ei
p - = As 0v0 1 − -ei
Observe that p 0 = p and that we are implicitly using s as local coordinates. For small - the curves - → p - are contained in and it follows from our assumptions that for any test function * with small support around s = 0, #f *$ = lim Fp + p - + ip - *p ds -→0 = lim FAs 0v0 1 − -ei *s Js ds d -→0
Assuming that f ∈ Lp 0 and using Fubini’s theorem in the coordinates s , we see that for a.e. s < %, the function → As 0v0 ei is in Lp . Fixing such an s is equivalent to fixing an analytic disk with the property that the restriction of f to a portion of its boundary that is contained in 0 is in Lp . We now take test functions such that *J has separated variables, i.e., *s Js = *1 s *2 . Since F has tempered growth, so does the compose F As 0v0 and it follows that #f˜s *2 $ = lim FAs 0v0 1 − -ei *2 d -→0
defines a distribution in that depends continuously on s as a parameter (use the usual method to define the trace, integrating by parts with respect to ). We further have #f˜s *2 $*1 s ds = #f *$ We may now reason as in Lemma II.3.2 to conclude that for a.e. s , s < %, f˜s ∈ Lp −% % and f˜s = fs . If s is in the set (III.7) and f˜s = fs holds, then → FAs 0v0 has an Lp boundary value that vanishes on a set of positive measure which implies that → FAs 0v0 vanishes identically. We conclude that for a.e. s on the set (III.7), FAs 0v0 = 0, or equivalently, that the set E0 v0 = s
s < % such that F As 0v0 ≡ 0
has positive measure. A similar conclusion could have been reached for the set Esm v = s
s < % such that F As sm v ≡ 0
where sm is a small number and v − v0 is small. Thus, the set s v such that F Asv ≡ 0 has positive measure and so does the union of the corresponding partially attached disks.
132
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions In this and the following sections we will present uniqueness results for the approximate solutions of two structures: locally integrable structures in the plane defined by vector fields which are of a fixed finite type on their characteristic set and real-analytic structures with m = 1. The theorems were proved by Cordaro ([Cor2]). Suppose is a locally integrable structure defined on a manifold , dim = N = m + n, and the fiber dimension of over C equals n. By going to the quotient, the exterior derivative defines a differential operator d0
C → C CT ∗ /T where T = ⊥ . Equip the manifold C CT ∗ /T with a hermitian metric. Observe that a solution for the structure is a function or distribution u that satisfies d0 u = 0. If u ∈ L1loc , we will say that u is an approximate solution for the structure if the coefficients of d0 u are locally in L1 and given any p ∈ , there is a number M > 0 such that near p,
d0 u ≤ M u a.e. in U One way in which approximate solutions may arise is as follows: suppose F × C → C CT ∗ /T satisfies Fp z − Fp z ≤ M z − z and u and v are two C 1 solutions of the semilinear equation d0 wp = Fp wp Then the function u − v is an approximate solution for the structure . Recall next from Corollary I.10.2 that near a point in , coordinates x1 xm t1 tn for and local generators L1 Ln for can be chosen so that dtj Lk = jk j k = 1 n. With such a choice of coordinates and generators, we can identify the bundle C CT ∗ /T with the one spanned by the forms dt1 dtn and the operator d0 can be realized as Lu =
n
Lj u dtj
j=1
Before we discuss the uniqueness results, we will present a description of smooth, planar vector fields which have a uniform finite type on their characteristic set. Proposition III.5.1. Let L be a C nonvanishing vector field defined near the origin in R2 and let 0 denote its characteristic set. If L is of uniform finite type k on 0, then 0 is contained in a one-dimensional manifold. Moreover, if 0 is a one-dimensional manifold, then L is never tangent to 0.
III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions
133
Proof. We may choose coordinates x y near 0 so that L is a nonvanishing multiple of L = + ibx y y x with b real-valued and C near 0. Without loss of generality, let L = L . Then 0 = p bp = 0 The uniform type condition implies that j b ≡0 yj on 0 for j < k − 1 and k b = 0 yk on 0. Hence if fx y =
k−1 b x y yk−1
then 0 is contained in the manifold fx y = 0 which has a parametrization x yx for some smooth yx. Proposition III.5.2. Suppose L and 0 are as in Proposition III.5.1 and that 0 is a one-dimensional manifold. Assume L is locally integrable in a neighborhood of 0. Then we can find coordinates s t about 0 in which Zs t = s + is t is a first integral of L where s t is real-valued and s t = s + tk s t for some nonvanishing near 0. Proof. We first flatten 0 near the origin so that in coordinates x y, 0 = x 0 . By Proposition III.5.1, L is not tangent to 0 and so if Zx y is a first integral near the origin, then Zx 0 0 = 0. Assume Z0 0 = 0. Let s = Zx y and t = y. Then in s t coordinates, Z = s + is t and we may take
it L= − t 1 + is s
134
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
The finite type assumption then implies that s t = s + tk s t
0 = 0
for some smooth . Proposition III.5.3. Suppose L and 0 are as in Proposition III.5.2. If the uniform type k is even, then there are coordinates in which Zx y = x + iyk is a first integral. Proof. By Proposition III.5.2, we have a first integral Zs t = s + is t s t = s + tk s t
where 0 = 0
We may assume > 0 near the origin. For % small, let = ZD% 0 where D% 0 denotes the disk centered at 0 of radius %. Let be a smooth subdomain of such that 0 ∈ and the boundary part of near 0 is s s . By the Riemann mapping theorem, there exists a holomorphic function H which is a diffeomorphism up to such that H ⊂ x y y > 0 and Hs + is ∈ R. Let Ws t = H Zs t. Then LW = 0 and dW = 0 in a neighborhood of the origin. From the form of and the fact that H Zs 0 = 0, we have ˜ t H Zs t = tk s ˜ t k1 . It can where ˜ > 0 near the origin. Let x = H Zs t and y = ts easily be checked that these are coordinates near 0 and in these coordinates, Wx y = x + iyk is a first integral. Definition III.5.4. A locally integrable structure is called hypocomplex if every solution u is locally of the form H Z where H is holomorphic and Z = Z1 Zm is a complete set of first integrals. Proposition III.5.5. Suppose L and 0 are as in Proposition III.5.2. If k is odd, then there are coordinates x y in which Zx y = x + iyk is a first integral of L if and only if for any first integral W of L, there is a biholomorphism near 0 mapping W0 into the real axis.
III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions
135
Proof. Since k is odd, if we take the first integral Zs t = s + is t with s t = s + tk s t, 0 = 0 as in Proposition III.5.2, we see that L is hypocomplex. Therefore, to prove the necessity, we only need to do it for this first integral. Suppose then x y are coordinates in which x + iyk is a solution. Let F = U + iV denote this diffeomorphism and we may assume F0 = 0. Then F maps the characteristic set of L to that of − ikyk−1 y x and so Vs 0 = 0 for s near 0. Moreover, by the hypocomplexity of L, there is a holomorphic function H defined near the origin such that Us t + iVs tk = Hs + is t Since U + iV k and Z are homeomorphisms, H is a biholomorphism (near 0). We also have Hs + is = Us 0 ∈ R showing that HZ0 ⊆ R. Note also that from the equations Hs s = 0
and
dH0 = 0
we conclude that s is real-analytic. In the latter statement, we have assumed as we may that 0 = 0 and used the consequent fact that H 0 is real. Conversely, suppose H is a biholomorphism near 0 such that H Z0 ⊆ R where we take Zs t as before. Thus Hs + is ∈ R. Define Fs t = W −1 H Zs t, where Wx y = x + iyk . F is a homeomorphism and away from t = 0, it is a diffeomorphism. Since Fs t = H Zs t, Fs t is smooth. Next note that since H Zs t vanishes to order k at t = 0 and Fk = H Z, there is a nonvanishing smooth function gs t near the origin such that Fs t = gs tt The latter, together with the fact that H 0 ∈ R (we assume 0 = 0), implies that F is a diffeomorphism near the origin. Clearly, using F F as new coordinates, we get x + iyk as a first integral for L. Remark III.5.6. In Proposition III.5.5, whenZs t=s +is t with s t = s+itk s t, the proof shows that the two equivalent conditions are equivalent to the real-analyticity of s.
136
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Thus, we have: Corollary III.5.7. Suppose L and 0 are as in Proposition III.5.2 and L is real-analytic. Then there are real-analytic coordinates x y in which the function x + iyk is a first integral of L. In other words, when L is real-analytic and 0 is a manifold of dimension 1, up to a real-analytic local diffeomorphism (and up to a nonvanishing multiple), there is only one real-analytic vector field of uniform type k. The preceding corollary was also proved in [Me1]. Proposition III.5.5 can be generalized as follows: Proposition III.5.8. Suppose L1 and L2 are two vector fields of the same uniform odd type on their respective characteristic sets 01 and 02 . Then there exists a local diffeomorphism mapping the structure generated by L1 to the one generated by L2 if and only if for any first integrals Z1 and Z2 of L1 and L2 respectively, there exists a local biholomorphism mapping Z1 01 onto Z2 02 . The proof is similar to that of Proposition III.5.5. In Proposition III.5.2 and the subsequent discussion, we assumed that 0 is a one-dimensional manifold. However, in general, as the following examples show, 0 may not be one-dimensional. Example III.5.9. Let 1 be the structure in the plane defined by Z1 = x + ix2 y + y3 Then the characteristic set 01 = 0 0 and the type there is 3. Example III.5.10. Let 2 be the structure defined by Z2 = x + ix4 y + y3 Again the characteristic set 02 = 0 0 and the type is 3. We remark that in any neighborhood of the origin, the structures 1 and 2 are not equivalent. More generally, we have: Proposition III.5.11. Suppose L is elliptic except at the origin and is of finite type there. Then the type is odd. In particular, L is hypocomplex. + ibx y , with b real-valued. Then bp ≡ 0 if and y x only if p = 0. Hence b cannot change sign in any neighborhood of the origin. Proof. Write L =
III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions
137
It follows that the type at the origin is odd. Since b does not change sign, L is locally solvable (Theorem IV.1.6) and hence locally integrable. We are now ready to state and prove the key lemma from [Cor2] concerning approximate solutions: Lemma III.5.12. Let L be a locally integrable, planar vector field of uniform finite type on its characteristic set 0 which we assume is a one-dimensional manifold. Assume that u is a nontrivial approximate solution on a side of 0 and that u is continuous up to the boundary piece 0. Then the set p ∈ 0 up = 0 has zero measure with respect to arclength on 0. In view of the preceding propositions, Lemma III.5.12 will be a consequence of: Lemma III.5.13. Let L be locally integrable near the origin with a first integral Zx t = x + i!x t. Suppose that !t x t = ax ttk where k is a positive integer and a is never zero for x , t ≤ , > 0. Let u be a nontrivial function satisfying on x < , 0 < t < ,
Lux t ≤ M ux t and continuous up to t = 0. Then the set x x < ux 0 = 0 has zero Lebesgue measure. Proof. We may assume that ax t > 0 for every x t. The map x t → x !x t is a diffeomorphism from the region x < , 0 < t < onto the open set in the plane: = z = x + iy x < !x 0 < y < !x Denote by z → x .x y the inverse of this diffeomorphism and set vx y = ux .x y
x + iy ∈
By the chain rule, we have & & & v & v −1 & & & x + i y x y& ≤ K!t x .x y vx y
(III.8)
(III.9)
138
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Now we have for t ≥ 0 !x t − !x 0 = tk+1 Ax t where A > 0 for x ≤ , 0 ≤ t ≤ . Hence y − !x 0 = .x yk+1 Ax .x y
x + iy ∈
Since !t x t ≥ %tk
% > 0
we get
y − !x 0 !t x .x y ≥ %.x y = % Ax .x y
k/k+1
k
Consequently, (III.9) implies for x + iy ∈ : & & & & v v −k/k+1 & &
vx y & x + i y x y& ≤ K y − !x 0
(III.9 )
Observe that since x t → x !x t is also a homeomorphism from x < , 0 ≤ t < onto = z = x + iy x < !x 0 ≤ y < !x the function v is in fact continuous on . Fix 0 < < arbitrary. It suffices to show that the Lebesgue measure of the set x x < vx !x 0 = 0 is zero. Consider now a simply connected open subset U of that is bounded by a smooth Jordan curve for which there is a decomposition = 1 ∪ 2 with 1 = x + i!x 0 x ≤
2 ⊂
By the Riemann mapping theorem there is a biholomorphism = Gz from U onto the unit disk < 1. Since G is necessarily a smooth diffeomorphism from U onto ≤ 1, v = vG−1 will be continuous on ≤ 1 and will satisfy (III.9 ): & & & & v k & & ≤ K1 − − k+1
v < 1 & & ¯ The lemma now follows from Lemma III.5.14.
III.5 Uniqueness for approximate solutions
139
Lemma III.5.14. Let D be the unit disk in the complex z-plane and let v ∈ CD be not identically zero and satisfy & & & v & & z& ≤ K1 − z − vz z ∈ D (III.10) & ¯z & for some 0 ≤ < 1. Then the set ∈ T v = 0 has zero Lebesgue measure (here T denotes the boundary of D). Proof. The main step in the proof is to show the following property: 3 There is a solution S ∈ <1 C D of the equation S 1 v = in D satisfying ¯z v ¯z 2) sup
Srei d < r<1
(∗)
0
Let us show right away that (∗) implies the conclusion of Lemma III.5.14. Write v = expS h with h ∈ D. There is p ∈ Z+ such that v/zp is continuous in D and does not vanish at the origin. Moreover, (III.10) is satisfied when v/zp is substituted for v. Summing up, this argument shows that there is no loss of generality in assuming from the outset that v0 = 0. Applying Jensen’s inequality to the holomorphic function h gives, if r < 1, 1 2) 1 2) log v0 ≤ S0 − Srei d + log vrei d 2) 0 2) 0 and consequently (∗) implies log v0 ≤ C +
1 2) log vrei d 2) 0
(III.11)
where C > 0 is independent of r. A standard application of Fatou’s lemma in (III.11) shows that log− vei ∈ L1 T, whence the sought conclusion. We now proceed to the proof of (∗). To simplify the notation, we set F = vz¯ /v. We observe that there is p > 1 such that F ∈ Lp D (indeed it suffices to take 1 < p < 1/). We set 1 Fz Sz = dx dy ) D z−z Then S = F ¯z
140
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
moreover, since p > 1, it also follows (cf. [V], theorem 1.35) that S = 1F z where 1 denotes the singular integral operator 1 gz 1gz = − dx dy 2 ) D z − z Since 1 is a bounded linear operator in Lp D if 1 < p < (cf. [V], page 64) we obtain S ∈ Lp1 D. Since F ∈ L z < R for R < 1, any solution of the equation u/¯z = 3 F belongs to <1 C D. Hence (∗) will follow if we can establish the following property: 2)
Srei d < (III.12) sup 1/2≤r<1 0
We observe that /r = ei /z + e−i /¯z, / = irei /z − e−i /¯z from which we derive that r → Srei belongs to the Sobolev space L11 1/4 1 × 0 2) . Thus r → Srei is absolutely continuous for almost all . By first integrating on 1/2 r and afterwards on 0 2) we conclude that & 2) 1 && S 2) && 1 && 2) & i i & i & & & S
Sre d ≤ e & d + r e & dr d & & 2 r 0 0 0 1/2 for every r ∈ 1/2 1 , from which (III.12) follows. This completes the proof of Lemma III.5.14.
III.6 Real-analytic structures in the plane We will continue using the notation of the previous section and assume in addition that ! is real-analytic. If !t 0 0 = 0 then L is elliptic near the origin, and the results we will discuss are well known in this case. We next discuss the case when !t 0 0 = 0 but !t is not identically zero. We factor out !t x t = xl .x t, where . is real-analytic and .0 · does not vanish identically. Applying the Weierstrass preparation theorem to . allows us to describe the zero set 00 of the function !t as the zero set of x t → xl px t, where p is a distinguished polynomial in the t-variable with no multiple factors. Hence we can state: There is a disjoint decomposition 00 = F0 ∪ V1+ ∪ · · · ∪ V+ ∪ V1− ∪ · · · ∪ V−
(∗∗)
III.6 Real-analytic structures in the plane
141
in a small neighborhood of the origin x < %, t < %, where F0 is either 0 0 or is equal to the segment 0 × −% % (according to either l = 0 or l > 0), and each Vj+ (resp. Vk− ) is defined by an analytic graph x j x 0 < x < (resp. x k x − < x < 0 ), where 1 < 2 < · · · < (resp. 1 < 2 < · · · < ) and lim k x = lim+ j x = 0
x→0−
x→0
∀j k
As a consequence we observe that in a neighborhood of each point x0 t0 ∈ 00 \F0 we can write !t x t = t − gxk ax t, where k ≥ 1, a and g are real-analytic and a never vanishes. In what follows, for any set S and a number k, k S will denote the k-dimensional Hausdorff measure of S. We can now prove: Proposition III.6.1. Suppose that !t 0 0 = 0, !t ≡ 0. Let u be a nontrivial C 1 function defined for x < %, t < % and satisfying:
Lux t ≤ M ux t and denote its zero set by S. Then: (1) If u does not vanish identically on 0 < x < % t < % , then S ∩ x > 0 has a trivial one-dimensional Hausdorff measure (likewise for x < 0). (2) If F0 = 0 × −% %, then S ∩ F0 = ∅ ⇒ F0 ⊂ S. (3) If F0 = 0 0 and if u does not vanish identically then S has a trivial one-dimensional Hausdorff measure. Proof. Assume first that F0 = 0 × −% %. Then L = u/t over F0 (since Zt 0 t = i!t 0 t = 0), which gives & & & u & & 0 t& ≤ M u0 t & t & By Gronwall’s inequality, it follows that if u0 t0 = 0 for some t0 , then u0 t = 0 for all t. Now we consider the general case. Fix a point x0 t0 ∈ 00 \F0 and write !t x t = t − gxk ax t in a neighborhood of x0 t0 as before. After the change of variables x = x, t = t − gx, the analysis near x0 t0 reduces to the situation treated in Lemma III.5.13. In particular, we obtain that u cannot vanish identically in any component of the set W + = x t 0 < x < % t < % !t x t = 0 and also that the one-dimensional Hausdorff measure of S ∩ 00 \F0 is trivial. Since the vector field L defines a complex structure
142
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
on W + , it follows that the one-dimensional Hausdorff measure of S ∩ W + is also trivial. The proof of Proposition III.6.1 follows from these arguments. Corollary III.6.2. Suppose u is a C 1 -approximate solution defined for
x < % t < % and vanishing for t = 0. Then u vanishes identically. Proof. Consider the new C 1 -approximate solution u˜ defined as u for t > 0 and zero for t ≤ 0. If !t does not vanish identically, it follows from Proposition III.6.1 and the discussion that precedes it that u˜ vanishes identically. If however !t ≡ 0, then L = t and we reach the same conclusion by applying Gronwall’s inequality.
III.6.1 Real-analytic structures with m = 1 As a consequence of Corollary III.6.2 we obtain: Theorem III.6.3. Uniqueness in the Cauchy problem for C 1 -approximate solutions holds for real-analytic locally integrable structures with m = 1. Proof. Since this is a local statement we can work in local coordinates x t = x t1 tn centered at the origin for which there is a real-analytic, real-valued function !x t satisfying !0 0 = !x 0 0 = 0
(III.13)
such that, if Zx t = x + i!x t then the bundle is spanned by the linearly independent, pairwise commuting vector fields Ztj Lj = − j = 1 n (III.14) tj Zx x Let u be a C 1 -approximate solution defined for x < , t < :
Lu ≤ M u The conclusion will follow after we show that if u vanishes for t = 0 then u vanishes identically. Fix t0 , 0 < t0 < and define Z0 x s = Zx st0
x <
Consider also the vector field L0 =
Z − 0s s Z0x x
s < 1
III.6 Real-analytic structures in the plane
143
as well as the C 1 function u0 x s = ux st0 We have L0 u0 x s =
n Lj ux st0 t0j j=1
and thus
L0 u0 x s ≤ M u0 x s showing that u0 is a C 1 -approximate solution for the structure defined by L0 in x < , s < 1. Moreover, u0 vanishes for s = 0. Therefore, by Corollary III.6.2 and a standard propagation argument, u0 vanishes identically for x < s < 1. Hence ux t0 = 0 for all x < . Let be a real-analytic locally integrable structure over a connected, realanalytic manifold of dimension N . When m = 1 ( has then dimension n + 1) the orbits of the structure have either dimension n + 1 (open subsets of ) or dimension n. Introduce the projection over of the characteristic set of : 0 = p ∈ Tp ∩ Tp = 0 It is easy to see that 0 is an analytic subset of . Since is connected we either have dim 0 ≤ n or 0 = . Assume first that 0 = : in this case defines a real structure on in the sense that = C ⊗ 0 , where 0 is an involutive vector sub-bundle of T of rank n. The leaves of the foliation defined by 0 are precisely the n-dimensional (Nagano) leaves. Next suppose that the dimension of the analytic set 0 is ≤ n. On \0 the bundle defines an elliptic structure and every n-dimensional leaf is contained in 0; in particular, it follows that the union of all n-dimensional leaves is a set of n + 1-dimensional measure zero. We now prove: Theorem III.6.4. Let be a real-analytic locally integrable structure over a connected, real-analytic, n + 1-dimensional manifold with m = 1. Let u be a nontrivial C 1 -approximate solution on and let S denote its zero set. Then: (1) If is an n + 1-dimensional leaf, then either ∩ S = or n ∩ S = 0. (2) If S has nonempty intersection with some n-dimensional leaf , then ⊂ S.
144
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Proof. Suppose that 0 = . By the preceding discussion any point p ∈ is the center of a system of coordinates U x t1 tn over which is spanned by the vector fields /tj , j = 1 n. On U we have dt u ≤ M u and consequently if u0 0 = 0 then u0 t = 0 for all t thanks to Gronwall’s inequality. This argument also provides a proof of (2): if is an n-dimensional leaf then ⊂ CT and it defines a real structure over for which u is also a C 1 -approximate solution. Again Gronwall’s inequality gives S ∩ = ⇒ ⊂ S. Next we observe first that (1) is valid when n = 1. Indeed, let be a two-dimensional leaf on which u is not identically zero and p ∈ . Then p is the center of a system of coordinates x t as in Proposition III.6.1 for which there is Zx t = x + i!x t, whose differential spans T and !t ≡ 0. Either !t 0 0 = 0 or !t 0 0 = 0 and F0 = 0 0 . In any of these cases we obtain that the one-dimensional Hausdorff measure of the zero set of the restriction of u to a small neighborhood of p is trivial. Hence it remains to prove property (1) assuming that the full result has been proved for smaller values of n. Since any n + 1-dimensional leaf is a connected open subset of , we can assume that itself is a leaf. Decompose 0 into its regular and singular parts, 0 = 0r ∪ 0s . The dimension of 0s is ≤ n − 1 and then it follows that = \0s is open, connected, and that n 0s = 0. This observation allows us to assume from the outset that 0 is an embedded, real-analytic hypersurface of . Denote by ' CT ∗ 0 −→ CT ∗ 0 the pullback map, let = 'T 0 and 0∗ = p ∈ 0 dim p = 1 Since any component of 0 cannot be a leaf it follows that 0\0∗ is an analytic subset of 0 of dimension ≤ n − 1 and consequently has trivial n-dimensional Hausdorff measure. Any point p0 ∈ 0∗ is the center of a system of coordinates U0 x t1 tn for which all properties described at the beginning of the proof of Theorem III.6.3 hold and that U0 ∩ 0 = tn = 0 We make the following claim: () If v is a C 1 -approximate solution that vanishes on a nonempty open subset of , then v vanishes identically. Proof of (). Let pl be a sequence of points in , pl → p such that v vanishes identically in a neighborhood of each pl . If p % 0 then v vanishes identically
III.6 Real-analytic structures in the plane
145
near p since is an elliptic structure in \0. Suppose now that p ∈ 0 and take a coordinate system V y1 yn+1 , V = y < r , centered at p such that 0 ∩ V = y1 = 0 . Since is an elliptic structure in y ∈ V y1 = 0 and since pl ∈ V for some l it follows necessarily that v vanishes identically on one of the sides y1 > 0 or y1 < 0. Suppose that the first case occurs and take y∗ ∈ 0∗ ∩ V . By Theorem III.6.3 it follows that v vanishes identically in a full neighborhood of y∗ and consequently in the whole component y1 < 0. Since u is a C 1 -approximate solution on \0 with respect to an elliptic structure (with m = 1, = n − 1 according to the notation of Chapter I), which does not vanish identically on any component of \0, we have n S ∩ \0 = 0. Hence it suffices to show that n S ∩ 0∗ = 0 or, for that matter, that n S ∩ U0 ∩ 0 = 0
(III.15)
according to the preceding notation. The differential of Z tn =0 defines a locally integrable structure on U0 ∩ 0 with m = 1. Moreover, the restriction of u to U0 ∩ 0 is a C 1 -approximate solution for this structure, which is furthermore not identically zero on any n-dimensional leaf thanks to Theorem III.6.3 and (). If such a structure is not real, then (III.15) holds by the induction hypothesis. Suppose now that this structure is real, which is the same as saying that ! tn =0 depends only on x. Taking U0 ∩ 0 = x t x < t < Gronwall’s inequality gives S ∩ U0 ∩ 0 = x x < ux 0 0 = 0 × t t <
(III.16)
Since moreover !t is not identically zero, there is a line segment p through the origin in t-space such that ! restricted to − × p is not a function of x alone. This means that the differential of the restriction of Z defines a locally integrable structure on − × p which satisfies the hypothesis of Proposition III.6.1. The restriction of u to − × p is a C 1 -approximate solution and does not vanish on any nonempty open subset of − × p, once more thanks to Theorem III.6.3 and (). But then we can apply Proposition III.6.1 in order to infer that the Lebesgue measure of x x < ux 0 0 = 0 is zero, which according to (III.16) gives (III.15). The proof of Theorem III.6.4 is now complete. Corollary III.6.5. Let u be a C 1 -approximate solution on . Then d0 u/u which can be regarded as a section of CT ∗ /T with L coefficients, is d1 -closed.
146
Sussmann’s orbits and unique continuation
Proof. We can of course assume that u is not identically equal to zero. By [HaP] (corollary 2.4) in conjunction with Theorem III.6.4 (1) it follows that d1 d0 u/u = 0 on the union of all n + 1-dimensional leaves. Now let p be a point belonging to an n-dimensional leaf; we have to show that d1 d0 u/u = 0 in a neighborhood of p. We can find a coordinate system U x t1 tn centered at p, with U = x t x < t < such that T is