This page intentionally left blank
Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics Fundamentals and Large-Scale Circulation Fl...
463 downloads
1848 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics Fundamentals and Large-Scale Circulation Fluid dynamics is fundamental to our understanding of the atmosphere and oceans. Although many of the same principles of fluid dynamics apply to both the atmosphere and oceans, textbooks on the topic have tended to concentrate on either the atmosphere or the ocean, or on the theory of geophysical fluid dynamics (GFD). However, there is much to be said for a unified discussion, and this major new textbook provides a comprehensive, coherent treatment of all these topics. It is based on course notes that the author has developed over a number of years at Princeton and the University of California. The first part of the book provides an introduction to the fundamentals of geophysical fluid dynamics, including discussions of rotation and stratification, the role of vorticity and potential vorticity, and scaling and approximations. The second part of the book discusses baroclinic and barotropic instabilities, wave–mean flow interactions and turbulence. The third and fourth parts discuss the general circulation of the atmosphere and ocean. Student problems and exercises, as well as bibliographic and historical notes, are included at the end of each chapter. Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics: Fundamentals and Large-Scale Circulation will prove to be an invaluable graduate textbook on advanced courses in GFD, meteorology, atmospheric science, and oceanography, and will also be an excellent review volume for researchers. Additional resources are available at www.cambridge.org/9780521849692 Geoffrey K. Vallis is a senior scientist and professor in the Program in Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences and NOAA’s Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory at Princeton University. He is also an associate faculty member at the Program in Applied and Computational Mathematics, and a former professor at the University of California, Santa Cruz. Until recently he was editor of the Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences. His research interests include the general circulation of the ocean and atmosphere, turbulence theory, and climate dynamics. He has taught a wide range of topics at Princeton and the University of California, and he has published extensively in both the oceanographic and meteorological literature.
Pre-publication praise for Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics “Geoff Vallis’ Atmosphere and Ocean Dynamics will become the standard text on modern largescale atmosphere and ocean dynamics. It covers the field from the equations of motion to modern developments such as wave–mean flow interaction theory and theories for the global-scale circulations of atmospheres and oceans. There is no book of comparable comprehensiveness, spanning the needs of beginning graduate students and researchers alike.” Tapio Schneider, California Institute of Technology “This clearly written, self-contained new book is a modern treatment of atmospheric and oceanic dynamics. The book starts from classical concepts in fluid dynamics and thermodynamics and takes the reader to the frontier of current research. This is an accessible textbook for beginning students in meteorology, oceanography and climate sciences. Mature researchers will welcome this work as a stimulating resource. This is also the only textbook on geophysical fluid dynamics with a comprehensive collection of problems; these cement the material and expand it to a more advanced level. Highly recommended!” Paola Cessi, Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, San Diego “Vallis provides a cohesive view of GFD that smoothly blends classic results with modern interpretations. The book strikes an ideal balance between mathematical rigor and physical intuition, and between atmosphere- and ocean-relevant applications. The use of a hierarchy of models is particularly welcome. Each physical phenomenon is modeled with the right degree of complexity, and the reader is introduced to the value of the hierarchy at an early stage. Well-designed homework problems spanning a broad range of difficulty make the book very appropriate for use in introductory courses in GFD.” Adam Sobel, Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University “I have adopted this text for my course in Atmosphere–Ocean Dynamics because the ideas are clearly presented and up-to-date. The text provides the flexibility for the instructor to choose among a variety of paths that take the student from the foundations of the subject to current research topics. For me as a researcher, the text is satisfying because it presents a unified view of the ideas that underlie the modern theory of large scale atmospheric and oceanic circulations.” Paul J. Kushner, University of Toronto “The large-scale circulation in the atmosphere–ocean system is maintained by small-scale turbulent motions that interact with large-scale radiative processes. The first half of the book introduces the basic theories of large-scale atmosphere–ocean flows and of small-scale turbulent motions. In the second half, the two theories are brought together to explain how the interactions of motions on different scales maintain the global-scale climate. The emphasis on turbulent motions and their effect on larger scales makes this book a gem in the GFD literature. Finally, we have a textbook that is up to date with our current understanding of the climate system.” Raffaele Ferrari, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
ATMOSPHERIC AND OCEANIC FLUID DYNAMICS Fundamentals and Large-scale Circulation GEOFFREY K. VALLIS Princeton University, New Jersey
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521849692 © G. Vallis 2006 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2006 eBook (EBL) ISBN-13 978-0-511-34879-2 ISBN-10 0-511-34879-7 eBook (EBL) hardback ISBN-13 978-0-521-84969-2 hardback ISBN-10 0-521-84969-1
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
To my parents, Jim and Doreen Vallis.
Contents
An asterisk indicates more advanced material that may be omitted on a first reading. A dagger indicates material that is still a topic of research or that is not settled.
Preface
page xix
Notation
Part I 1
xxiv
FUNDAMENTALS OF GEOPHYSICAL FLUID DYNAMICS Equations of Motion
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4 1.5
1.6
1 3
Time Derivatives for Fluids 1.1.1 Field and material viewpoints 1.1.2 The material derivative of a fluid property 1.1.3 Material derivative of a volume The Mass Continuity Equation 1.2.1 An Eulerian derivation 1.2.2 Mass continuity via the material derivative 1.2.3 A general continuity equation The Momentum Equation 1.3.1 Advection 1.3.2 The pressure force 1.3.3 Viscosity and diffusion 1.3.4 Hydrostatic balance The Equation of State Thermodynamic Relations 1.5.1 A few fundamentals 1.5.2 Various thermodynamic relations Thermodynamic Equations for Fluids vii
3 3 4 6 7 7 9 11 11 12 12 13 13 14 16 16 18 22
viii
Contents 1.6.1 Thermodynamic equation for an ideal gas 1.6.2 * Thermodynamic equation for liquids 1.7 * More Thermodynamics of Liquids 1.7.1 Potential temperature, potential density and entropy 1.7.2 * Thermodynamic properties of seawater 1.8 Sound Waves 1.9 Compressible and Incompressible Flow 1.9.1 Constant density fluids 1.9.2 Incompressible flows 1.10 The Energy Budget 1.10.1 Constant density fluid 1.10.2 Variable density fluids 1.10.3 Viscous effects 1.11 An Introduction to Non-Dimensionalization and Scaling 1.11.1 The Reynolds number
2
Effects of Rotation and Stratification 2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
Equations in a Rotating Frame 2.1.1 Rate of change of a vector 2.1.2 Velocity and acceleration in a rotating frame 2.1.3 Momentum equation in a rotating frame 2.1.4 Mass and tracer conservation in a rotating frame Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates 2.2.1 * The centrifugal force and spherical coordinates 2.2.2 Some identities in spherical coordinates 2.2.3 Equations of motion 2.2.4 The primitive equations 2.2.5 Primitive equations in vector form 2.2.6 The vector invariant form of the momentum equation 2.2.7 Angular momentum Cartesian Approximations: The Tangent Plane 2.3.1 The f-plane 2.3.2 The beta-plane approximation The Boussinesq Approximation 2.4.1 Variation of density in the ocean 2.4.2 The Boussinesq equations 2.4.3 Energetics of the Boussinesq system The Anelastic Approximation 2.5.1 Preliminaries 2.5.2 The momentum equation 2.5.3 Mass conservation 2.5.4 Thermodynamic equation 2.5.5 * Energetics of the anelastic equations Changing Vertical Coordinate 2.6.1 General relations 2.6.2 Pressure coordinates
23 26 31 31 33 37 38 38 39 40 40 42 43 43 44
51 51 52 53 54 54 55 55 57 60 61 62 63 64 66 66 67 67 68 68 72 73 73 74 75 76 76 77 77 78
Contents
ix
2.6.3 Log-pressure coordinates Scaling for Hydrostatic Balance 2.7.1 Preliminaries 2.7.2 Scaling and the aspect ratio 2.7.3 * Effects of stratification on hydrostatic balance 2.7.4 Hydrostasy in the ocean and atmosphere 2.8 Geostrophic and Thermal Wind Balance 2.8.1 The Rossby number 2.8.2 Geostrophic balance 2.8.3 Taylor–Proudman effect 2.8.4 Thermal wind balance 2.8.5 * Effects of rotation on hydrostatic balance 2.9 Static Instability and the Parcel Method 2.9.1 A simple special case: a density-conserving fluid 2.9.2 The general case: using potential density 2.9.3 Lapse rates in dry and moist atmospheres 2.10 Gravity Waves 2.10.1 Gravity waves and convection in a Boussinesq fluid 2.11 * Acoustic-Gravity Waves in an Ideal Gas 2.11.1 Interpretation 2.12 The Ekman Layer 2.12.1 Equations of motion and scaling 2.12.2 Integral properties of the Ekman layer 2.12.3 Explicit solutions. I: a bottom boundary layer 2.12.4 Explicit solutions. II: the upper ocean 2.12.5 Observations of the Ekman layer 2.12.6 * Frictional parameterization of the Ekman layer
80 80 80 81 82 84 85 85 86 88 89 91 91 92 93 95 98 98 100 101 104 105 107 109 112 113 114
Shallow Water Systems and Isentropic Coordinates
123
2.7
3 3.1
3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6
3.7
Dynamics of a Single, Shallow Layer 3.1.1 Momentum equations 3.1.2 Mass continuity equation 3.1.3 A rigid lid 3.1.4 Stretching and the vertical velocity 3.1.5 Analogy with compressible flow Reduced Gravity Equations 3.2.1 Pressure gradient in the active layer Multi-Layer Shallow Water Equations 3.3.1 Reduced-gravity multi-layer equation Geostrophic Balance and Thermal wind Form Drag Conservation Properties of Shallow Water Systems 3.6.1 Potential vorticity: a material invariant 3.6.2 Energy conservation: an integral invariant Shallow Water Waves 3.7.1 Non-rotating shallow water waves
123 124 125 127 128 129 129 130 131 133 134 135 136 136 139 140 140
x
Contents 3.7.2 Rotating shallow water (Poincaré) waves 3.7.3 Kelvin waves 3.8 Geostrophic Adjustment 3.8.1 Non-rotating flow 3.8.2 Rotating flow 3.8.3 * Energetics of adjustment 3.8.4 * General initial conditions 3.8.5 A variational perspective 3.9 Isentropic Coordinates 3.9.1 A hydrostatic Boussinesq fluid 3.9.2 A hydrostatic ideal gas 3.9.3 * Analogy to shallow water equations 3.10 Available Potential Energy 3.10.1 A Boussinesq fluid 3.10.2 An ideal gas 3.10.3 Use, interpretation, and the atmosphere and ocean
4
Vorticity and Potential Vorticity 4.1
4.2 4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
Vorticity and Circulation 4.1.1 Preliminaries 4.1.2 Simple axisymmetric examples The Vorticity Equation 4.2.1 Two-dimensional flow Vorticity and Circulation Theorems 4.3.1 The ‘frozen-in’ property of vorticity 4.3.2 Kelvin’s circulation theorem 4.3.3 Baroclinic flow and the solenoidal term 4.3.4 Circulation in a rotating frame 4.3.5 The circulation theorem for hydrostatic flow Vorticity Equation in a Rotating Frame 4.4.1 The circulation theorem and the beta effect 4.4.2 The vertical component of the vorticity equation Potential Vorticity Conservation 4.5.1 PV conservation from the circulation theorem 4.5.2 PV conservation from the frozen-in property 4.5.3 PV conservation: an algebraic derivation 4.5.4 Effects of salinity and moisture 4.5.5 Effects of rotation, and summary remarks * Potential Vorticity in the Shallow Water System 4.6.1 Using Kelvin’s theorem 4.6.2 Using an appropriate scalar field Potential Vorticity in Approximate, Stratified Models 4.7.1 The Boussinesq equations 4.7.2 The hydrostatic equations 4.7.3 Potential vorticity on isentropic surfaces * The Impermeability of Isentropes to Potential Vorticity
141 143 144 145 146 148 149 151 152 152 153 154 155 156 158 159
163 163 163 164 165 167 168 168 171 173 173 174 175 175 176 178 178 180 182 183 183 184 184 185 186 186 187 187 188
Contents
xi 4.8.1
5
Interpretation and application
190
Simplified Equations for Ocean and Atmosphere
197
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6
5.7
5.8
Part II
6
Geostrophic Scaling 5.1.1 Scaling in the shallow water equations 5.1.2 Geostrophic scaling in the stratified equations The Planetary-Geostrophic Equations 5.2.1 Using the shallow water equations 5.2.2 Planetary-geostrophic equations for stratified flow The Shallow Water Quasi-Geostrophic Equations 5.3.1 Single-layer shallow water quasi-geostrophic equations 5.3.2 Two-layer and multi-layer quasi-geostrophic systems 5.3.3 † Non-asymptotic and intermediate models The Continuously Stratified Quasi-Geostrophic System 5.4.1 Scaling and assumptions 5.4.2 Asymptotics 5.4.3 Buoyancy advection at the surface 5.4.4 Quasi-geostrophy in pressure coordinates 5.4.5 The two-level quasi-geostrophic system * Quasi-geostrophy and Ertel Potential Vorticity 5.5.1 * Using height coordinates 5.5.2 Using isentropic coordinates * Energetics of Quasi-Geostrophy 5.6.1 Conversion between APE and KE 5.6.2 Energetics of two-layer flows 5.6.3 Enstrophy conservation Rossby Waves 5.7.1 Waves in a single layer 5.7.2 Rossby waves in two layers * Rossby Waves in Stratified Quasi-Geostrophic Flow 5.8.1 Setting up the problem 5.8.2 Wave motion Appendix: Wave Kinematics, Group Velocity and Phase Speed 5.A.1 Kinematics and definitions 5.A.2 Wave propagation 5.A.3 Meaning of group velocity
198 198 200 203 203 205 207 207 211 214 215 215 216 219 220 221 224 224 225 226 227 228 229 229 229 232 234 234 235 236 236 237 239
INSTABILITIES, WAVE–MEAN FLOW INTERACTION AND TURBULENCE
245
Barotropic and Baroclinic Instability 6.1 6.2
Kelvin–Helmholtz Instability Instability of Parallel Shear Flow 6.2.1 Piecewise linear flows
247 248 250 251
xii
Contents
6.3
6.4
6.5
6.6
6.7
6.8 6.9
7
6.2.2 Kelvin–Helmholtz instability, revisited 6.2.3 Edge waves 6.2.4 Interacting edge waves producing instability Necessary Conditions for Instability 6.3.1 Rayleigh’s criterion 6.3.2 Fjørtoft’s criterion Baroclinic Instability 6.4.1 A physical picture 6.4.2 Linearized quasi-geostrophic equations 6.4.3 Necessary conditions for baroclinic instability The Eady Problem 6.5.1 The linearized problem 6.5.2 Atmospheric and oceanic parameters Two-Layer Baroclinic Instability 6.6.1 Posing the problem 6.6.2 The solution An Informal View of the Mechanism of Baroclinic Instability 6.7.1 The two-layer model 6.7.2 Interacting edge waves in the Eady problem * The Energetics of Linear Baroclinic Instability * Beta, Shear and Stratification in a Continuous Model 6.9.1 Scaling arguments for growth rates, scales and depth 6.9.2 Some numerical calculations
Wave–Mean Flow Interaction 7.1 7.2
7.3
7.4
7.5
7.6
Quasi-geostrophic Preliminaries 7.1.1 Potential vorticity flux in the linear equations The Eliassen–Palm Flux 7.2.1 The Eliassen–Palm relation 7.2.2 The group velocity property 7.2.3 * The orthogonality of modes The Transformed Eulerian Mean 7.3.1 Quasi-geostrophic form 7.3.2 The TEM in isentropic coordinates 7.3.3 Residual and thickness-weighted circulation 7.3.4 * The TEM in the primitive equations The Non-acceleration Result 7.4.1 A derivation from the potential vorticity equation 7.4.2 Using TEM to give the non-acceleration result 7.4.3 The EP flux and form drag Influence of Eddies on the Mean Flow in the Eady Problem 7.5.1 Formulation 7.5.2 Solution 7.5.3 The two-level problem * Necessary Conditions for Instability 7.6.1 Stability conditions from pseudomomentum conservation
253 254 254 258 258 260 261 261 263 264 265 266 268 271 271 272 277 278 280 282 284 285 287
295 296 297 298 299 300 302 304 304 306 307 309 314 314 316 317 319 319 321 324 324 325
Contents
7.7
8
7.6.2 * Necessary 7.7.1 7.7.2 7.7.3
xiii Inclusion of boundary terms Conditions for Instability: Use of Pseudoenergy Two-dimensional flow * Stratified quasi-geostrophic flow * Applications to baroclinic instability
Basic Theory of Incompressible Turbulence 8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
8.5
9
The Fundamental Problem of Turbulence 8.1.1 The closure problem 8.1.2 Triad interactions in turbulence The Kolmogorov Theory 8.2.1 The physical picture 8.2.2 Inertial-range theory 8.2.3 * Another expression of the inertial-range scaling argument 8.2.4 A final note on our assumptions Two-Dimensional Turbulence 8.3.1 Energy and enstrophy transfer 8.3.2 Inertial ranges in two-dimensional turbulence 8.3.3 † More about the phenomenology 8.3.4 Numerical illustrations Predictability of Turbulence 8.4.1 Low-dimensional chaos and unpredictability 8.4.2 * Predictability of a turbulent flow 8.4.3 Implications and weather predictability * Spectra of Passive Tracers 8.5.1 Examples of tracer spectra
Geostrophic Turbulence and Baroclinic Eddies 9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
Effects of Differential Rotation 9.1.1 The wave–turbulence cross-over 9.1.2 Generation of zonal flows and jets 9.1.3 † Joint effect of β and friction Stratified Geostrophic Turbulence 9.2.1 An analogue to two-dimensional flow 9.2.2 Two-layer geostrophic turbulence 9.2.3 Phenomenology of two-layer turbulence † A Scaling Theory for Geostrophic Turbulence 9.3.1 Preliminaries 9.3.2 Scaling properties 9.3.3 The halting scale and the β-effect † Phenomenology of Baroclinic Eddies in the Atmosphere and Ocean 9.4.1 The magnitude and scale of baroclinic eddies 9.4.2 Baroclinic eddies and their lifecycle in the atmosphere 9.4.3 Baroclinic eddies and their lifecycle in the ocean
325 327 327 330 331
337 338 338 339 341 341 342 348 349 349 351 354 357 360 361 362 363 365 366 367
377 377 378 380 382 384 384 385 388 391 392 393 395 395 396 397 400
xiv
10
Contents
Turbulent Diffusion and Eddy Transport 10.1 Diffusive Transport 10.1.1 An explicit example 10.2 Turbulent Diffusion 10.2.1 Simple theory 10.2.2 * An anisotropic generalization 10.2.3 Discussion 10.3 Two-Particle Diffusivity 10.3.1 Large particle separation 10.3.2 Separation within the inertial range 10.4 Mixing Length Theory 10.4.1 Requirements for turbulent diffusion 10.4.2 A macroscopic perspective 10.5 Homogenization of a Scalar that is Advected and Diffused 10.5.1 Non-existence of extrema 10.5.2 Homogenization in two-dimensional flow 10.6 † Transport by Baroclinic Eddies 10.6.1 Symmetric and antisymmetric diffusivity tensors 10.6.2 * Diffusion with the symmetric tensor 10.6.3 * The skew flux 10.6.4 The story so far 10.7 † Eddy Diffusion in the Atmosphere and Ocean 10.7.1 Preliminaries 10.7.2 Magnitude of the eddy diffusivity 10.7.3 * Structure: the symmetric transport tensor 10.7.4 * Structure: the antisymmetric transport tensor 10.7.5 Examples 10.8 † Thickness Diffusion 10.8.1 Equations of motion 10.8.2 Diffusive thickness transport 10.9 † Eddy Transport and the Transformed Eulerian Mean 10.9.1 Potential vorticity diffusion
Part III 11
LARGE-SCALE ATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION
The Overturning Circulation: Hadley and Ferrel Cells 11.1 Basic Features of the Atmosphere 11.1.1 The radiative equilibrium distribution 11.1.2 Observed wind and temperature fields 11.1.3 Meridional overturning circulation 11.1.4 Summary 11.2 A Steady Model of the Hadley Cell 11.2.1 Assumptions 11.2.2 Dynamics
407 408 409 409 409 413 415 415 416 417 419 421 422 423 423 424 425 426 426 427 429 430 430 430 432 435 437 440 440 442 443 443
449 451 452 452 453 456 457 457 457 458
Contents
11.3
11.4 11.5
11.6 11.7
12
11.2.3 Thermodynamics 11.2.4 Zonal wind 11.2.5 Properties of solution 11.2.6 Strength of the circulation 11.2.7 † Effects of moisture 11.2.8 The radiative equilibrium solution A Shallow Water Model of the Hadley Cell 11.3.1 Momentum balance 11.3.2 Thermodynamic balance † Asymmetry Around the Equator Eddies, Viscosity and the Hadley Cell 11.5.1 Qualitative considerations 11.5.2 An idealized eddy-driven model The Hadley Cell: Summary and Numerical Solutions The Ferrel Cell
Zonally Averaged Mid-Latitude Atmospheric Circulation 12.1 Surface Westerlies and the Maintenance of a Barotropic Jet 12.1.1 Observations and motivation 12.1.2 The mechanism of jet production 12.1.3 A numerical example 12.2 Layered Models of the Mid-latitude Circulation 12.2.1 A single-layer model 12.2.2 A two-layer model 12.2.3 Dynamics of the two-layer model 12.3 † Eddy Fluxes and an Example of a Closed Model 12.3.1 Equations for a closed model 12.3.2 * Eddy fluxes and necessary conditions for instability 12.4 A Stratified Model and the Real Atmosphere 12.4.1 Potential vorticity and its fluxes 12.4.2 Overturning circulation 12.5 † The Tropopause and the Stratification of the Atmosphere 12.5.1 A radiative–convective model 12.5.2 Radiative and dynamical constraints 12.6 † Baroclinic eddies and Potential Vorticity Transport 12.6.1 A linear argument 12.6.2 Mixing potential vorticity and baroclinic adjustment 12.6.3 Diffusive transport of potential vorticity 12.7 † Extratropical Convection and the Ventilated Troposphere Appendix: TEM for the Primitive Equations in Spherical Coordinates
13
Planetary Waves and the Stratosphere 13.1 Forced and Stationary Rossby Waves 13.1.1 A simple one-layer case 13.1.2 Application to Earth’s atmosphere
xv 460 462 463 464 465 466 468 468 468 469 473 473 474 477 480
485 486 486 487 495 496 497 503 507 513 513 514 516 516 522 522 526 528 529 530 530 532 534 536
541 542 542 543
xvi
Contents
13.2
13.3
13.4
13.5
Part IV 14
13.1.3 * One-dimensional Rossby wave trains 13.1.4 The adequacy of linear theory * Meridional Propagation and Dispersion 13.2.1 Ray tracing 13.2.2 Rossby waves and Rossby rays 13.2.3 Application to an idealized atmosphere * Vertical Propagation of Rossby Waves in a Stratified Medium 13.3.1 Model formulation 13.3.2 Model solution 13.3.3 Properties of the solution * Effects of Thermal Forcing 13.4.1 Thermodynamic balances 13.4.2 Properties of the solution 13.4.3 Numerical solutions Stratospheric Dynamics 13.5.1 A descriptive overview 13.5.2 † Dynamics of the overturning circulation 13.5.3 † The polar vortex and the quasi-horizontal circulation
LARGE-SCALE OCEANIC CIRCULATION
Wind-Driven Gyres 14.1 The Depth Integrated Wind-Driven Circulation 14.1.1 The Stommel model 14.1.2 Alternative formulations 14.1.3 Approximate solution of Stommel model 14.2 Using Viscosity Instead of Drag 14.3 Zonal Boundary Layers 14.4 * The Nonlinear Problem 14.4.1 A perturbative approach 14.4.2 A numerical approach 14.5 * Inertial Solutions 14.5.1 Roles of friction and inertia 14.5.2 Attempting an inertial western boundary solution 14.5.3 A fully inertial approach: the Fofonoff model 14.6 Topographic Effects on Western Boundary Currents 14.6.1 Homogeneous model 14.6.2 Advective dynamics 14.6.3 Bottom pressure stress and form drag 14.7 * Vertical Structure of the Wind-Driven Circulation 14.7.1 A two-layer quasi-geostrophic Model 14.7.2 The functional relationship between ψ and q 14.8 * A Model with Continuous Stratification 14.8.1 Depth of the wind’s influence 14.8.2 The complete solution
545 548 549 549 550 553 554 554 555 559 560 561 562 563 566 566 569 575
581 583 585 586 587 589 593 597 599 600 600 601 603 604 606 608 608 609 611 613 613 616 619 619 620
Contents
xvii
15
627
The Buoyancy-Driven Ocean Circulation 15.1 Sideways Convection 15.1.1 Two-dimensional convection 15.1.2 † Phenomenology of the overturning circulation 15.2 The Maintenance of Sideways Convection 15.2.1 The energy budget 15.2.2 Conditions for maintaining a thermally-driven circulation 15.2.3 Surface fluxes and non-turbulent flow at small diffusivities 15.2.4 The importance of mechanical forcing 15.3 Simple Box Models 15.3.1 A two-box model 15.3.2 * More boxes 15.4 A Laboratory Model of the Abyssal Circulation 15.4.1 Set-up of the laboratory model 15.4.2 Dynamics of flow in the tank 15.5 A Model for Oceanic Abyssal Flow 15.5.1 Completing the solution 15.5.2 Application to the ocean 15.5.3 A two-hemisphere model 15.6 * A Shallow Water Model of the Abyssal Flow 15.6.1 Potential vorticity and poleward interior flow 15.6.2 The solution 15.7 Scaling for the Buoyancy-Driven Circulation 15.7.1 Summary remarks on the Stommel–Arons model
16
629 630 633 634 635 635 637 639 640 640 644 646 646 647 650 652 653 655 656 657 658 659 661
The Wind- and Buoyancy-Driven Ocean Circulation
667
16.1 The Main Thermocline: an Introduction 16.1.1 A simple kinematic model 16.2 Scaling and Simple Dynamics of the Main Thermocline 16.2.1 An advective scale 16.2.2 A diffusive scale 16.2.3 Summary of the physical picture 16.3 The Internal Thermocline 16.3.1 The M equation 16.3.2 * Boundary-layer analysis 16.4 The Ventilated Thermocline 16.4.1 A reduced gravity, single-layer model 16.4.2 A two-layer model 16.4.3 The shadow zone 16.4.4 † The western pool 16.5 † A Model of Deep Wind-Driven Overturning 16.5.1 A single-hemisphere model 16.5.2 A cross-equatorial wind-driven deep circulation 16.6 † Flow in a Channel and the Antarctic Circumpolar Current 16.6.1 Steady and eddying flow
667 668 670 671 672 673 674 674 676 681 682 683 686 688 691 693 697 700 701
xviii
Contents 16.6.2 Vertically integrated momentum balance 16.6.3 Form drag and baroclinic eddies 16.6.4 † An idealized adiabatic model 16.6.5 Form stress and Ekman stress at the ocean bottom 16.6.6 Differences between gyres and channels Appendix: Miscellaneous Relationships in a Layered Model 16.A.1 Hydrostatic balance 16.A.2 Geostrophic and thermal wind balance 16.A.3 Explicit cases
702 703 708 709 710 710 711 711 712
References
717
Index
738
We must be ignorant of much, if we would know anything. Cardinal John Newman (1801–1890).
Preface
T
on the fluid dynamics of the atmosphere and ocean, with an emphasis on the fundamentals and on the large-scale circulation, the latter meaning flows from the scale of the first deformation radius (a few tens of kilometres in the ocean, several hundred kilometres in the atmosphere) to the global scale. The book is primarily a textbook; it is designed to be accessible to students and could be used as a text for graduate courses. It may be also useful as an introduction to the field for scientists in other areas and as a reference for researchers in the field, and some aspects of the book have the flavour of a research monograph. Atmospheric and oceanic fluid dynamics (AOFD) is fascinating field, and simultaneously both pure and applied. It is a pure field because it is intimately tied to some of the most fundamental and unsolved problems in fluid dynamics — problems in turbulence and wave– mean flow interaction, problems in chaos and predictability, and problems in the general circulation itself. Yet it is applied because the climate and weather so profoundly affect the human condition, and so a great deal of effort goes into making predictions — indeed the practice of weather forecasting is a remarkable example of a successful applied science, in spite of the natural limitations to predictability that are now reasonably well understood. The field is plainly important, for we live in the atmosphere and the ocean covers about two-thirds of the Earth. It is also very broad, encompassing such diverse topics as the general circulation, gyres, boundary layers, waves, convection and turbulence. My goal in this book is present a coherent selection of these topics, concentrating on the foundations but without shying away from the boundaries of active areas of research — for a book that limits itself to what is absolutely settled would, I think, be rather dry, a quality best reserved for martinis and humour. AOFD is closely related to the field of geophysical fluid dynamics (GFD). The latter can be, depending on one’s point of view, both a larger and a smaller field than the former. It is larger because GFD, in its broadest meaning, includes not just the fluid dynamics of the Earth’s atmosphere and ocean, but also the fluid dynamics of such things as the Earth’s interior, volcanoes, lava flows and planetary atmospheres; it is the fluid mechanics of all HIS IS A BOOK
xix
xx
Preface
things geophysical. But at the same time the appellation ‘GFD’ implies a certain austerity, and the subject is often seen as the one that provides the fundamental principles and language for understanding geophysical flows without being suffocated by the overwhelming detail of the real world. In this book we are guided by the ascetic spirit of GFD, and my hope is that the reader will gain a solid grounding in the fundamentals, motivated by and with an appreciation for the problems of the real world. The book is an outgrowth of various courses that I have taught over the years, mainly at Princeton University but also at the University of California and at summer schools or similar in Boulder and Kyoto. There are four parts to the book: fundamentals of geophysical fluid dynamics; instabilities, wave–mean flow interaction and turbulence; atmospheric circulation; and ocean circulation. Each corresponds, very roughly, to a one-term graduate course, although parts could also be used for undergraduates. Limitations enforced both by the need to keep the book coherent and focused, and my own expertise or (especially) lack thereof, naturally limit the choice of topics. In particular the chapters on the circulation focus on the steady and statistically steady large-scale circulation and perforce a number of important topics are omitted — tropical and equatorial dynamics, many of the effects of moisture on atmospheric circulation, the spin-up of the ocean circulation, atmospheric and oceanic tides, the quasi-biennial oscillation, and so on. I have however — and at no extra charge, mind you — discussed the large-scale circulation of both atmosphere and ocean. The similarities and differences between the two systems are, I believe, so instructive that even if one’s interest is solely in one, there is much to be gained by studying the other. The references at the end of the book are representative and not exhaustive, and almost certainly disproportionately represent articles written in English and those with which I happen to be familiar. For the benefit of the reader interested in exploring the development of the subject I have included references to a number of historical articles, even when the presentation given does not draw from them. If there are other references that are particularly relevant I trust the reader will inform me. I have tried to keep the overall treatment of topics as straightforward and as clear as I know how. In particular, I have tried to be as explicit as possible in my explanations, even at the risk of descending from pedagogy into pedantry. Relatedly, there is a certain amount of repetition between sections, and this serves both to emphasize the important things and to keep chapters reasonably self-contained. The chapters are of course intellectually linked, for example, heat transport in the atmosphere depends on baroclinic instability, but hopefully the reader already familiar with the latter will be able to read about the former without too much cross-referencing. The treatment generally is fairly physical and phenomenological, and rigour in the mathematical sense is absent; I treat the derivatives of integrals and of infinitesimal quantities rather informally, for example. The figures (many in colour) may all be downloaded from the CUP web site associated with this book. An asterisk, *, next to a section heading means that the section may be omitted on first reading; although normally uncontroversial, it may contain advanced material that is not essential for subsequent sections. A dagger, †, next to a section heading means that the section discusses topics of research. Very roughly speaking, one might interpret as asterisk as indicating there is advanced manipulation of the equations, whereas a dagger might indicate there is approximation of the equations, or an interpretation that is not universally regarded as settled; caveat emptor. There is some arbitrariness in such markings, especially where the section deals with a well understood model of a poorly understood
Preface
xxi
reality. Sections so-marked may be regarded as providing an introduction to the literature, rather than a complete or finished treatment, and the section may also require knowledge of material that appears later in the book. If the asterisk or dagger is applied to a section it applies to all the subsections within, and if a dagger or asterisk appears within a section that is already marked, the warning is even more emphatic. Reading the endnotes at the end of each chapter is not needed in order to follow the arguments in the main text. Problems marked with black diamonds may, like similarly marked ski-slopes, be difficult, and I do not know the solutions to all of them. Good answers to some of them may be publishable and I would appreciate hearing about any such work. I would also appreciate any comments on the material presented in the text. Qui docet discit. Finally, I should say that this book owes its existence in part to my own hubris and selfishness: hubris to think that others might wish to read what I have written, and selfishness because the enjoyable task of writing such a book masquerades as work.
Summary of Contents The chapters within each part, and the sections within each chapter, form logical units, and do not necessarily directly correspond to a single lecture or set number of lectures. Part I. Fundamentals of geophysical fluid dynamics Chapter 1 is a brief introduction to fluid dynamics and the basic equations of motion, assuming no prior knowledge of the field. Readers with prior knowledge of fluid dynamics might skim it lightly, concentrating on those aspects unique to the atmosphere or ocean. Chapter 2 introduces the effects of stratification and rotation, these being the two main effects that most differentiate AOFD from other branches of fluid dynamics. Fundamental topics such as the primitive equations, the Boussinesq equations, and Ekman layers are introduced here, and these form the foundation for the rest of the book. Chapter 3 focuses on the shallow water equations. Many of the principles of geophysical fluid dynamics have their simplest expression in the shallow water equations, because the effects of stratification are either eliminated or much simplified. The equations thus provide a relatively gentle introduction to the field. Chapter 4 discusses vorticity and potential vorticity. Potential vorticity plays an especially important role in large-scale, rotating and stratified flows, and its conservation provides the basis for the equation sets of chapter 5. Chapter 5 derives simplified equation sets for large-scale flows, in particular the quasigeostrophic and planetary-geostrophic equation sets, and introduces a simple application, Rossby waves. Much of our theoretical understanding of the large-scale circulation has arisen through the use of these equations. Part II. Instabilities, wave–mean flow interaction and turbulence Chapter 6 covers barotropic and baroclinic instability, the latter being the instability that gives rise to weather — and therefore being, perhaps, the form of hydrodynamic instability that most affects the human condition. Chapter 7 provides an introduction to the important topic, albeit one that is regarded as difficult, of wave–mean flow interaction. That is, how do the waves and instabilities affect the mean flow in which they propagate?
xxii
Preface
Chapter 8 and 9 are on the statistical theory of turbulence. Chapter 8 introduces the basic concepts of two- and three-dimensional turbulence, and chapter 9 applies similar ideas to geostrophic turbulence. Chapter 10 discusses turbulent diffusion — a hoary subject, both used and abused, yet one that plays a central role in our thinking about the transport properties of eddies in the atmosphere and ocean. Part III. Large-scale atmospheric circulation Chapter 11 is mostly concerned with the dynamics of the Hadley Cell, and, rather descriptively, with the Ferrel Cell. Chapter 12 addresses the mid-latitude circulation. The goal of this chapter is to provide the basis of an understanding of such topics as the surface westerly winds, the dynamics of the Ferrel Cell, the stratification of the atmosphere and the height of the tropopause. These are still active topics of research, so we cannot always be definitive, although many of the underlying principles are now established, and our discussion emphasizes the fundamentals that have, I think, permanent value. Chapter 13 discusses stationary waves in the atmosphere, mainly produced by the interaction of the zonal wind with mountains and land–sea temperature contrasts. It also discusses the vertical propagation of Rossby waves, and how these induce a stratospheric circulation. Part IV. Large-scale oceanic circulation Chapter 14 discusses the wind-driven circulation, in particular the ocean gyres, either ignoring buoyancy effects or assuming that buoyancy forcing acts primarily to set up a stratification that can be taken as a given. Chaper 15 discusses the buoyancy-driven circulation, largely neglecting the effects of wind forcing. Chapter 16 addresses the combined effects of wind and buoyancy forcing in setting up the stratification and in driving both the predominantly horizontal gyral circulation and the overturning circulation. As with many sections of Part III, many of these topics are still being actively researched, although, again, many of the underlying principles have, I think, now been established and have permanent value.
Acknowledgements This book would not have been possible without the input, criticism, encouragement and advice of a large number of people, from students to senior scientists. Students at Princeton University, New York University, Columbia University, California Institute of Technology, MIT and the University of Toronto have used earlier versions of the text in various courses, and I am grateful for the feedback received from the instructors and students about what works and what doesn’t, as well as for numerous detailed comments. Parts of the first few chapters and many of the problems draw on notes prepared over the years for a graduate class at Princeton University taught by Steve Garner, Isaac Held, Yoshio Kurihara, Paul Kushner and me. Steve Garner has been notably generous with his time and ideas with respect to this material. I would like to thank following individuals for providing comments on the text or for
Preface
xxiii
conversational input: Alistair Adcroft, Brian Arbic, Roger Berlind, Pavel Berloff, Thomas Birner, Paola Cessi, Sorin Codoban, Agatha de Boer, Roland de Szoeke, Raffaele Ferrari, Baylor Fox-Kemper, Dargan Frierson, Steve Griffies, Brian Hoskins, Huei-Ping Huang, Chris Hughes, Kosuke Ito and his fellow students in Kyoto, Laura Jackson, Martin Juckes, Allan Kaufman, Samar Khatiwhala, Andrew Kositsky, Paul Kushner, Joe LaCasce, Trevor McDougall, Paul O’Gorman, Tim Palmer, David Pearson, Lorenzo Polvani, Cathy Raphael, Adam Scaife, John Scinocca, Rob Scott, Tiffany Shaw, Sabrina Speich, Robbie Toggweiler, Yue-Kin Tsang, Ross Tulloch, Eli Tziperman, Jacques Vanneste, Chris Walker, Ric Williams, Michal Ziemiánski and Pablo Zurita-Gotor. Some of the above provided detailed comments on several sections or chapters, and I am very grateful to them; a number of other people provided figures and these are acknowledged where they appear. Anders Persson and Roger Samelson provided a number of useful historical remarks and interpretations, and Michael McIntyre (see also McIntyre 1997) emphasized the importance of being as explicit as possible in my explanations. I am particularly indebted to Tapio Schneider, Adam Sobel, Jürgen Theiss and Andy White who read and gave detailed comments on many chapters of text, to Isaac Held for many conversations over the years on all aspects of atmospheric and oceanic fluid dynamics, to Shafer Smith for both comments and code, to Ed Gerber for several calculations and figures, and to Bill Young for very useful input on thermodynamics and the Boussinesq equations. I would also like to thank Matt Lloyd of CUP for his encouragement, my copy-editor, Louise Staples, for her light but careful touch, and Anna Valerio for efficient secretarial assistance. Needless to say, I take full responsibility for the errors, both scientific and presentational, that undoubtedly remain. My first exposure to the field came as a graduate student in the fecund atmosphere of Atmospheric Physics Group at Imperial College in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and I’d like to thank everyone who was there at that time. You know who you are. I would also like to thank everyone at the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboaratory (GFDL) and in Princeton University’s Atmospheric and Oceanic Science program for creating the pleasant and stimulating work environment that made it possible to write this book. I am grateful to the staff and scientists at the Plymouth Marine Laboratory and the U. K. Meteorological Office for their hospitality during a sabbatical visit. Finally, I would like to thank the National Science Foundation and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration for providing financial support over the years, and Bess for support of a much greater kind. Note on second printing I have taken advantage the opportunity afforded by a second printing of this book to correct a number of typographic errors and make a number of small corrections to the text throughout. The pagination and equation numbering are mostly unaltered, although some microtypographic improvements have changed some of the line breaks. I am grateful to many readers who have sent in comments and corrections, and I would particularly like to acknowledge Roger Berlind for his exceptionally detailed and perceptive comments on the entire book. Additional resources, including downloadable figures and solutions to many of the end-of-chapter exercises, are available at www.vallisbook.org and www.cambridge.org/9780521849692.
xxiv
Notation
NOTATION The list below contains only the more important variables, or instances of non-obvious notation. Distinct meanings are separated with a semi-colon. Variables are normally set in italics, constants (e.g, π) in roman (i.e., upright), differential operators in roman, vectors in bold, and tensors in bold sans serif. Thus, vector variables are in bold italics, vector constants (e.g., unit vectors) in bold roman, and tensor variables are in bold slanting sans serif. Physical units are set in roman. A subscript denotes a derivative only if the subscript is a coordinate, such as x , y , z or t ; a subscript 0 generally denotes a constant reference value (e.g., ρ0 ). The components of a vector are denoted by superscripts. Variable
Description
b cg cp cv cs f , f0 g, g h i, j, k i i k kd Ld L, H m M N p Pr q Q ˙ Q
Buoyancy, −gδρ/ρ0 or gδθ/θ. y Group velocity, (cgx , cg , cgz ). Phase speed; heat capacity at constant pressure. Heat capacity constant volume. Sound speed. Coriolis parameter, and its reference value. Vector acceleration due to gravity, magnitude of g . Layer thickness (in shallow water equations). Unit vectors in (x, y, z) directions. An integer index. Square root of −1. Wave vector, with components (k, l, m) or (kx , ky , kz ). Wave number corresponding to deformation radius. Deformation radius. Horizontal length scale, vertical (height) scale. Angular momentum about the Earth’s axis of rotation. Montgomery function, M = cp T + Φ . Buoyancy, or Brunt–Väisälä, frequency. Pressure. Prandtl ratio, f0 /N . Quasi-geostrophic potential vorticity. Potential vorticity (in particular Ertel PV). Rate of heating. Rayleigh number. Real part of expression. Reynolds number, UL/ν . Rossby number, U/f L. Salinity; source term on right-hand side of an evolution equation. Solenoidal term, solenoidal vector. Temperature. Time. Two-dimensional (horizontal) velocity, (u, v). Three-dimensional velocity, (u, v, z). Cartesian coordinates, usually in zonal, meridional and vertical directions. Log-pressure, −H log p/pR . Usually, H = 7.5 km and pR = 105 Pa.
Ra Re Re Ro S So , So T t u v x, y, z Z
Notation
xxv
Variable
Description
A α β βT , βS
ε η F γ Γ κ K Λ µ ν v φ Φ Π ω Ω, Ω ψ ρ ρθ σ τ τ τ θ ϑ, λ ζ ∂a ∂b c ∂a ∂b
Wave activity. Inverse density, or specific volume; aspect ratio. Rate of change of f with latitude, ∂ f /∂y . Coefficient of expansion with respect to temperature, salinity. Generic small parameter (epsilon). Cascade or dissipation rate of energy (varepsilon). Specific entropy; perturbation height; enstrophy cascade or dissipation rate. Eliassen Palm flux, (F y , F z ). Vorticity gradient, β − uyy ; the ratio cp /cv . Lapse rate. Diffusivity; the ratio R/cp . Kolmogorov or Kolmogorov-like constant. Shear, e.g., ∂ U/∂z . Viscosity. Kinematic viscosity, µ/ρ . Meridional component of velocity. Pressure divided by density, p/ρ ; passive tracer. Geopotential, usually gz. Exner function, Π = cp T /θ = cp (p/pR )R/cp . Vorticity. Rotation rate of Earth and associated vector. Streamfunction. Density. Potential density. Layer thickness, ∂ z/∂θ ; Prandtl number ν/κ ; measure of density, ρ − 1000. Stress vector, often wind stress. /ρ . Kinematic stress, τ Zonal component or magnitude of wind stress; eddy turnover time. Potential temperature. Latitude, longitude. Vertical component of vorticity.
∇a
Gradient operator at constant value of coordinate a, e.g., ∇z = i ∂x + j ∂y .
∇a ·
Divergence operator at constant value of coordinate a, e.g., ∇z · = (i ∂x + j ∂y )·.
∇⊥
Perpendicular gradient, ∇⊥ φ ≡ k × ∇φ.
curlz
Vertical component of ∇× operator, curlz A = k · ∇ × A = ∂x Ay − ∂y Ax .
a=c
D Dt Dg Dt D3 D2 , Dt Dt
Derivative of a with respect to b at constant c . Derivative of a with respect to b evaluated at a = c .
Material derivative (generic). Material derivative using geostrophic velocity, for example ∂ /∂t + ug · ∇. Material derivative in three dimensions and in two dimensions, for example
∂ /∂t + v · ∇ and ∂ /∂t + u · ∇ respectively.
Part I
FUNDAMENTALS OF GEOPHYSICAL FLUID DYNAMICS
Are you sitting comfortably? Then I’ll begin. Julia Lang, Listen With Mother, BBC radio program, 1950–1982.
CHAPTER
ONE
Equations of Motion
T
establishes the fundamental governing equations of motion for a fluid, with particular attention to the fluids of the Earth’s atmosphere and ocean. Our approach in many places is quite informal, and the interested reader may consult the references given for more detail. HIS CHAPTER
1.1 TIME DERIVATIVES FOR FLUIDS The equations of motion of fluid mechanics differ from those of rigid-body mechanics because fluids form a continuum, and because fluids flow and deform. Thus, even though both classical solid and fluid media are governed by the same relatively simple physical laws (Newton’s laws and the laws of thermodynamics), the expression of these laws differs between the two. To determine the equations of motion for fluids we must clearly establish what the time derivative of some property of a fluid actually means, and that is the subject of this section.
1.1.1 Field and material viewpoints In solid-body mechanics one is normally concerned with the position and momentum of identifiable objects — the angular velocity of a spinning top or the motions of the planets around the Sun are two well-worn examples. The position and velocity of a particular object is then computed as a function of time by formulating equations of the form d xi = F ({xi }, t), dt 3
(1.1)
4
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
where {xi } is the set of positions and velocities of all the interacting objects and the operator F on the right-hand side is formulated using Newton’s laws of motion. For example, two massive point objects interacting via their gravitational field obey d ri = vi , dt
Gmj d vi ri,j , = dt (ri − rj )2
i = 1, 2; j = 3 − i.
(1.2)
We thereby predict the positions, ri , and velocities, vi , of the objects given their masses, mi , and the gravitational constant G, and where ri,j is a unit vector directed from ri to rj . In fluid dynamics such a procedure would lead to an analysis of fluid motions in terms of the positions and momenta of different fluid parcels, each identified by some label, which might simply be their position at an initial time. We call this a material point of view, because we are concerned with identifiable pieces of material; it is also sometimes called a Lagrangian view, after J.-L. Lagrange. The procedure is perfectly acceptable in principle, and if followed would provide a complete description of the fluid dynamical system. However, from a practical point of view it is much more than we need, and it would be extremely complicated to implement. Instead, for most problems we would like to know what the values of velocity, density and so on are at fixed points in space as time passes. (A weather forecast we might care about tells us how warm it will be where we live, and if we are given that we do not particularly care where a fluid parcel comes from, or where it subsequently goes.) Since the fluid is a continuum, this knowledge is equivalent to knowing how the fields of the dynamical variables evolve in space and time, and this is often known as the field or Eulerian viewpoint, after L. Euler.1 Thus, whereas in the material view we consider the time evolution of identifiable fluid elements, in the field view we consider the time evolution of the fluid field from a particular frame of reference. That is, we seek evolution equations of the general form ∂ ϕ(x, y, z, t) = G(ϕ, x, y, z, t), (1.3) ∂t where the field ϕ(x, y, z, t) represents all the dynamical variables (velocity, density, temperature, etc.) and G is some operator to be determined from Newton’s laws of motion and appropriate thermodynamic laws. Although the field viewpoint will often turn out to be the most practically useful, the material description is invaluable both in deriving the equations and in the subsequent insight it frequently provides. This is because the important quantities from a fundamental point of view are often those which are associated with a given fluid element: it is these which directly enter Newton’s laws of motion and the thermodynamic equations. It is thus important to have a relationship between the rate of change of quantities associated with a given fluid element and the local rate of change of a field. The material or advective derivative provides this relationship.
1.1.2 The material derivative of a fluid property A fluid element is an infinitesimal, indivisible, piece of fluid — effectively a very small fluid parcel of fixed mass. The material derivative is the rate of change of a property (such as temperature or momentum) of a particular fluid element or finite mass; that is to say, it is the total time derivative of a property of a piece of fluid. It is also known as the ‘substantive derivative’ (the derivative associated with a parcel of fluid substance),
1.1 Time Derivatives for Fluids
5
the ‘advective derivative’ (because the fluid property is being advected), the ‘convective derivative’ (convection is a slightly old-fashioned name for advection, still used in some fields), or the ‘Lagrangian derivative’. Let us suppose that a fluid is characterized by a (given) velocity field v(x, t), which determines its velocity throughout. Let us also suppose that it has another property φ, and let us seek an expression for the rate of change of φ of a fluid element. Since φ is changing in time and in space we use the chain rule,
δφ =
∂φ ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ δt + δx + δy + δz = δt + δx · ∇φ. ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ∂t
(1.4)
This is true in general for any δt , δx , etc. The total time derivative is then dφ ∂φ dx = + · ∇φ. dt ∂t dt
(1.5)
If this equation is to represent a material derivative we must identify the time derivative in the second term on the right-hand side with the rate of change of position of a fluid element, namely its velocity. Hence, the material derivative of the property φ is dφ ∂φ = + v · ∇φ. dt ∂t
(1.6)
The right-hand side expresses the material derivative in terms of the local rate of change of φ plus a contribution arising from the spatial variation of φ, experienced only as the fluid parcel moves. Because the material derivative is so common, and to distinguish it from other derivatives, we denote it by the operator D/Dt . Thus, the material derivative of the field φ is Dφ ∂φ = + (v · ∇)φ . Dt ∂t
(1.7)
The brackets in the last term of this equation are helpful in reminding us that (v · ∇) is an operator acting on φ. Material derivative of vector field The material derivative may act on a vector field b, in which case
∂b Db = + (v · ∇)b. Dt ∂t
(1.8)
Db ∂b ∂b ∂b ∂b = +u +v +w , Dt ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z
(1.9)
In Cartesian coordinates this is
and for a particular component of b,
∂ bx ∂ bx ∂ bx ∂ bx Dbx = +u +v +w , Dt ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z
(1.10)
or, in Cartesian tensor notation, Dbi ∂bi ∂ bi ∂ bi = + vj + v j ∂j bi . = Dt ∂t ∂xj ∂t
(1.11)
6
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
where the subscripts denote the Cartesian components and repeated indices are summed. In coordinate systems other than Cartesian the advective derivative of a vector is not simply the sum of the advective derivative of its components, because the coordinate vectors change direction with position; this will be important when we deal with spherical coordinates. Finally, we note that the advective derivative of the position of a fluid element, r say, is its velocity, and this may easily be checked by explicitly evaluating Dr/Dt .
1.1.3 Material derivative of a volume The volume that a given, unchanging, mass of fluid occupies is deformed and advected by the fluid motion, and there is no particular reason why it should remain constant. Indeed, the volume will change as a result of the movement of each element of its bounding material surface, and will in general change if there is a non-zero normal component of the velocity at the fluid surface. That is, if the volume of some fluid is dV , then D dV = v · dS, (1.12) Dt V S where the subscript V indicates that the integral is a definite integral over some finite volume V , although the limits of the integral will be functions of time if the volume is changing. The integral on the right-hand side is over the closed surface, S , bounding the volume. Although intuitively apparent (to some), this expression may be derived more formally using Leibnitz’s formula for the rate of change of an integral whose limits are changing (problem 1.2). Using the divergence theorem on the right-hand side, (1.12) becomes D dV = ∇ · v dV . (1.13) Dt V V The rate of change of the volume of an infinitesimal fluid element of volume ∆V is obtained by taking the limit of this expression as the volume tends to zero, giving lim
∆V →0
1 D∆V = ∇ · v. ∆V Dt
(1.14)
We will often write such expressions informally as D∆V = ∆V ∇ · v, Dt
(1.15)
with the limit implied. Consider now the material derivative of some fluid property, ξ say, multiplied by the volume of a fluid element, ∆V . Such a derivative arises when ξ is the amount per unit volume of ξ -substance — it might, for example, be mass density or the amount of a dye per unit volume. Then we have D∆V Dξ D (ξ∆V ) = ξ + ∆V . Dt Dt Dt
(1.16)
Dξ D (ξ∆V ) = ∆V ξ∇ · v + , Dt Dt
(1.17)
Using (1.15) this becomes
1.2 The Mass Continuity Equation
7
and the analogous result for a finite fluid volume is just D Dt
V
ξ dV =
V
ξ∇ · v +
Dξ Dt
dV .
(1.18)
This expression is to be contrasted with the Eulerian derivative for which the volume, and so the limits of integration, are fixed and we have d dt
V
ξ dV =
V
∂ξ dV . ∂t
(1.19)
Now consider the material derivative of a fluid property ϕ multiplied by the mass of a fluid element, ρ∆V , where ρ is the fluid density. Such a derivative arises when ϕ is the amount of ϕ-substance per unit mass (note, for example, that the momentum of a fluid element is ρv∆V ). The material derivative of ϕρ∆V is given by Dϕ D D (ϕρ∆V ) = ρ∆V +ϕ (ρ∆V ) Dt Dt Dt
(1.20)
But ρ∆V is just the mass of the fluid element, and that is constant — that is how a fluid element is defined. Thus the second term on the right-hand side vanishes and Dϕ D (ϕρ∆V ) = ρ∆V Dt Dt
and
D Dt
V
ϕρ dV =
ρ V
Dϕ dV , Dt
(1.21a,b)
where (1.21b) applies to a finite volume. That expression may also be derived more formally using Leibnitz’s formula for the material derivative of an integral, and the result also holds when ϕ is a vector. The result is quite different from the corresponding Eulerian derivative, in which the volume is kept fixed; in that case we have: d dt
V
ϕρ dV =
V
∂ (ϕρ) dV . ∂t
(1.22)
Various material and Eulerian derivatives are summarized in the shaded box on the following page.
1.2 THE MASS CONTINUITY EQUATION In classical mechanics mass is absolutely conserved, and in solid-body mechanics we normally do not need an explicit equation of mass conservation. However, in fluid mechanics fluid flows into and away from regions, and fluid density may change, and an equation that explicitly accounts for the flow of mass is one of the ‘equations of motion’ of the fluid.
1.2.1 An Eulerian derivation We will first derive the mass conservation equation from an Eulerian point of view; that is to say, our reference frame is fixed in space and the fluid flows through it.
8
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Material and Eulerian Derivatives The material derivative of a scalar (φ) and a vector (b) field are given by: Db ∂b = + (v · ∇)b. Dt ∂t
∂φ Dφ = + v · ∇φ, Dt ∂t
(D.1)
Various material derivatives of integrals are: D Dt
V
φ dV =
V
∂φ Dφ + φ∇ · v dV = + ∇ · (φv) dV , Dt ∂t V D dV = ∇ · v dV , Dt V V Dφ D ρφ dV = ρ dV . Dt V Dt V
(D.2) (D.3) (D.4)
These formulae also hold if φ is a vector. The Eulerian derivative of an integral is: d dt
V
φ dV =
V
∂φ dV , ∂t
(D.5)
so that d dt
V
dV = 0
and
d dt
V
ρφ dV =
V
∂ ρφ dV . ∂t
(D.6)
Cartesian derivation Consider an infinitesimal rectangular parallelepiped (i.e., a cuboid) control volume, ∆V = ∆x∆y∆z that is fixed in space, as in Fig. 1.1. Fluid moves into or out of the volume through its surface, including through its faces in the y –z plane of area ∆A = ∆y∆z at coordinates x and x + ∆x . The accumulation of fluid within the control volume due to motion in the x -direction is evidently ∂ (ρu) ∆y∆z[(ρu)(x, y, z) − (ρu)(x + ∆x, y, z)] = − ∆x ∆y ∆z. (1.23) ∂x x,y,z To this must be added the effects of motion in the y - and z-directions, namely ∂ (ρw) ∂ (ρv) + ∆x ∆y ∆z. − ∂y ∂z
(1.24)
This net accumulation of fluid must be accompanied by a corresponding increase of fluid mass within the control volume. This is
∂ ∂ρ , (density × volume) = ∆x ∆y ∆z ∂t ∂t
(1.25)
because the volume is constant. Thus, because mass is conserved, (1.23), (1.24) and (1.25) give
∂ (ρu) ∂ (ρv) ∂ (ρw) ∂ρ + + + = 0. ∆x ∆y ∆z (1.26) ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z
1.2 The Mass Continuity Equation
9
∂ (ρu) ρu + ∆x ∆y ∆z ∂x
ρu ∆y ∆z
z y x
x + ∆x
x
Fig. 1.1 Mass conservation in an Eulerian cuboid control volume.
Because the control volume is arbitrary the quantity in square brackets must be zero and we have the mass continuity equation:
∂ρ + ∇ · (ρv) = 0. ∂t
(1.27)
Vector derivation Consider an arbitrary control volume V bounded by a surface S , fixed in space, with by convention the direction of S being toward the outside of V , as in Fig. 1.2. The rate of fluid loss due to flow through the closed surface S is then given by fluid loss = ρv · dS = ∇ · (ρv) dV , (1.28) S
V
using the divergence theorem. This must be balanced by a change in the mass M of the fluid within the control volume, which, since its volume is fixed, implies a density change. That is dM d ∂ρ fluid loss = − =− ρ dV = − dV . (1.29) dt dt V V ∂t Equating (1.28) and (1.29) yields V
∂ρ + ∇ · (ρv) dV = 0. ∂t
(1.30)
Because the volume is arbitrary, the integrand must vanish and we recover (1.27).
1.2.2 Mass continuity via the material derivative We now derive the mass continuity equation (1.27) from a material perspective. This is the most fundamental approach of all since the principle of mass conservation states simply that the mass of a given element of fluid is, by definition of the element, constant. Thus, consider a small mass of fluid of density ρ and volume ∆V . Then conservation of mass may be represented by D (ρ∆V ) = 0. (1.31) Dt
10
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Fig. 1.2 Mass conservation in an arbitrary Eulerian control volume V bounded by a surThe mass gain, face S . V (∂ ρ/∂t ) dV is equal to the mass flowing into the vol ume, − S (ρv) · dS = − V ∇ · (ρv) dV .
Both the density and the volume of the parcel may change, so
∆V
Dρ D∆V +ρ = ∆V Dt Dt
Dρ + ρ∇ · v Dt
= 0,
(1.32)
where the second expression follows using (1.15). Since the volume element is arbitrary, the term in brackets must vanish and Dρ + ρ∇ · v = 0. Dt
(1.33)
After expansion of the first term this becomes identical to (1.27). This result may be derived more formally by rewriting (1.31) as the integral expression D Dt
V
ρ d V = 0.
(1.34)
Expanding the derivative using (1.18) gives D Dt
V
ρ dV =
V
Dρ + ρ∇ · v Dt
d V = 0.
(1.35)
Because the volume over which the integral is taken is arbitrary the integrand itself must vanish and we recover (1.33). Summarizing, equivalent partial differential equation representing conservation of mass are: Dρ + ρ∇ · v = 0, Dt
∂ρ + ∇ · (ρv) = 0 . ∂t
(1.36a,b)
1.3 The Momentum Equation
11
1.2.3 A general continuity equation The derivation of continuity equation for a general scalar property of a fluid is similar to that for density, except that there may be an external source or sink, and potentially a means of transferring the property from one location to another than by fluid motion, for example by diffusion. If ξ is the amount of some property of the fluid per unit volume (which we will call the concentration of the property), and if the net effect per unit volume of all non-conservative processes is denoted by Qv [ξ], then the continuity equation for concentration may be written: D (ξ∆V ) = Qv [ξ]∆V . Dt
(1.37)
Expanding the left-hand side and using (1.15) we obtain Dξ + ξ∇ · v = Qv [ξ], Dt
(1.38)
∂ξ + ∇ · (ξv) = Qv [ξ]. ∂t
(1.39)
or equivalently
If we are interested in a tracer that is normally measured per unit mass of fluid (which is typical when considering thermodynamic quantities) then the conservation equation would be written D (ϕρ∆V ) = Qm [ϕ]ρ∆V , (1.40) Dt where ϕ is the tracer mixing ratio — that is, the amount of tracer per unit fluid mass — and Qm [ϕ] represents non-conservative sources per unit mass. Then, since ρ∆V is constant we obtain Dϕ = Qm [ϕ]. (1.41) Dt The source term Qm [ϕ] is evidently equal to the rate of change of ϕ of a fluid element. ˙ , so that When this is so, we write it simply as ϕ Dϕ ˙ = ϕ. Dt
(1.42)
˙ = 0 is said to be materially conserved. If a tracer is materially A tracer obeying (1.42) with ϕ conserved except for the effects of non-conservative sources then it is sometimes said to be ‘semi-materially conserved’ or ‘adiabatically conserved’.
1.3 THE MOMENTUM EQUATION The momentum equation is a partial differential equation that describes how the velocity or momentum of a fluid responds to internal and imposed forces. We will derive it using material methods and informally deducing the terms representing the pressure, gravitational and viscous forces.
12
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
1.3.1 Advection Let m(x, y, z, t) be the momentum-density field (momentum per unit volume) of the fluid. Thus, m = ρv and the total momentum of a volume of fluid is given by the volume integral V m dV . Now, for a fluid the rate of change of a momentum of an identifiable fluid mass is given by the material derivative, and by Newton’s second law this is equal to the force acting on it. Thus, D ρv dV = F dV , (1.43) Dt V V where F is the force per unit volume. Now, using (1.21b) (with ϕ replaced by v ) to transform the left-hand side of (1.43), we obtain Dv − F d V = 0. ρ (1.44) Dt V Because the volume is arbitrary the integrand itself must vanish and we obtain
ρ
Dv = F, Dt
or
F ∂v + (v · ∇)v = , ∂t ρ
(1.45a,b)
having used (1.8) to expand the material derivative. We have thus obtained an expression for how a fluid accelerates if subject to known forces. These forces are however not all external to the fluid itself; a stress arises from the direct contact between one fluid parcel and another, giving rise to pressure and viscous forces, sometimes referred to as contact forces. Because a complete treatment of these would be very lengthy, and is available elsewhere, we treat both of these very informally and intuitively.
1.3.2 The pressure force Within or at the boundary of a fluid the pressure is the normal force per unit area due to the collective action of molecular motion. Thus dFp = −p dS,
(1.46)
where p is the pressure, Fp is the pressure force and dS an infinitesimal surface element. If we grant ourselves this intuitive notion, it is a simple matter to assess the influence of pressure on a fluid, for the pressure force on a volume of fluid is the integral of the pressure over the its boundary and so
Fp = −
p dS.
(1.47)
S
The minus sign arises because the pressure force is directed inwards, whereas S is a vector normal to the surface and directed outwards. Applying a form of the divergence theorem to the right-hand side gives
Fp = −
V
∇p dV ,
(1.48)
where the volume V is bounded by the surface S . The pressure force per unit volume, Fp , is therefore just −∇p , and inserting this into (1.45b) we obtain
∂v ∇p + (v · ∇)v = − + F , ∂t ρ where F , equal to (F − Fp )/ρ , represents viscous and body forces, per unit mass.
(1.49)
1.3 The Momentum Equation
Air Water Mercury
µ ( kg m−1 s−1 ) 1.8 × 10−5 1.1 × 10−3 1.6 × 10−3
13
ν ( m2 s−1 ) 1.5 × 10−5 1.1 × 10−6 1.2 × 10−7
Table 1.1 Experimental values of viscosity for air, water and mercury at room temperature and pressure.
1.3.3 Viscosity and diffusion Viscosity, like pressure, is a force due to the internal motion of molecules. The effects of viscosity are apparent in many situations — the flow of treacle or volcanic lava are obvious examples. In other situations, for example large-scale flow the atmosphere, viscosity is to a first approximation negligible. However, for a constant density fluid viscosity is the only way that energy may be removed from the fluid, so that if energy is being added in some way viscosity must ultimately become important if the fluid is to reach an equilibrium where energy input equals energy dissipation. When tea is stirred in a cup, it is viscous effects that cause the fluid to eventually stop spinning after we have removed our spoon. A number of textbooks2 show that, for most Newtonian fluids, the viscous force per unit volume is approximately equal to µ∇2 v , where µ is the viscosity. Although not exact, this is an extremely good approximation for most liquids and gases. With this term, the momentum equation becomes,
∂v 1 + (v · ∇)v = − ∇p + ν∇2 v + Fb ∂t ρ
(1.50)
where ν ≡ µ/ρ is the kinematic viscosity, and Fb represents any body forces (per unit mass) such as gravity, g . For gases, dimensional arguments suggest that the magnitude of ν should be given by
ν ∼ mean free path × mean molecular velocity,
(1.51)
which for a typical molecular velocity of 300 m s−1 and a mean free path of 7 × 10−8 m gives the not unreasonable estimate of 2.1 × 10−5 m2 s−1 , within a factor of two of the experimental value (Table 1.1). Interestingly, the kinematic viscosity is less for water and mercury than it is for air.
1.3.4 Hydrostatic balance The vertical component — the component parallel to the gravitational force, g — of the momentum equation is Dw 1 ∂p =− − g, (1.52) Dt ρ ∂z where w is the vertical component of the velocity and g = −g k. If the fluid is static the gravitational term is balanced by the pressure term and we have
∂p = −ρg, ∂z
(1.53)
14
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
and this relation is known as hydrostatic balance, or hydrostasy. It is clear in this case that the pressure at a point is given by the weight of the fluid above it, provided p = 0 at the top of the fluid. It might also appear that (1.53) would be a good approximation to (1.52) provided vertical accelerations, Dw/Dt , are small compared to gravity, which is nearly always the case in the atmosphere and ocean. While this statement is true if we need only a reasonable approximate value of the pressure at a point or in a column, the satisfaction of this condition is not sufficient to ensure that (1.53) provides an accurate enough pressure to determine the horizontal pressure gradients responsible for producing motion. We return to this point in section 2.7.
1.4 THE EQUATION OF STATE In three dimensions the momentum and continuity equations provide four equations, but contain five unknowns — three components of velocity, density and pressure. Obviously other equations are needed, and an equation of state is an expression that diagnostically relates the various thermodynamic variables to each other. The conventional equation of state (also called the thermal equation of state) is an expression that relates temperature, pressure, composition (the mass fraction of the various constituents) and density, and we may write it, rather generally, as p = p(ρ, T , µn ), (1.54) where µn is mass fraction of the nth constituent. An equation of this form is not the most fundamental equation of state from a thermodynamic perspective, an issue we visit later, but it connects readily measurable quantities. For an ideal gas (and the air in the Earth’s atmosphere is very close to ideal) the conventional equation of state is p = ρRT , (1.55) where R is the gas constant for the gas in question and T is temperature. (R is related to the universal gas constant Ru by R = Ru /m, where m is the mean molecular weight of the constituents of the gas. Also, R = nk, where k is Boltzmann’s constant and n is the number of molecules per unit mass.) For dry air, R = 287 J kg−1 K−1 . Air has virtually constant composition except for variations in water vapour content. A measure of this is the water vapour mixing ratio, w = ρw /ρd where ρw and ρd are the densities of water vapour and dry air, respectively, and in the atmosphere w varies between 0 and 0.03. This variation makes the gas constant in the equation of state a weak function of the water vapour mixing ratio; that is, p = ρReff T where Reff = Rd (1 + wRv /Rd )/(1 + w) where Rd and Rv are the gas constants of dry air and water vapour. Since w ∼ 0.01 the variation of Reff is quite small and is often ignored, especially in theoretical studies.3 For a liquid such as seawater no simple expression akin to (1.55) is easily derivable, and semi-empirical equations are usually resorted to. For pure water in a laboratory setting a reasonable approximation of the equation of state is ρ = ρ0 [1 − βT (T − T0 )], where βT is a thermal expansion coefficient and ρ0 and T0 are constants. In the ocean the density is also significantly affected by pressure and dissolved salts: seawater is a solution of many ions in water — chloride (≈ 1.9% by weight) sodium (1%), sulfate (0.26%), magnesium (0.13%) and so on, with a total average concentration of about 35‰ (ppt, or parts per thousand). The ratios of the fractions of these salts are more-or-less constant throughout the ocean, and
1.4 The Equation of State
15
their total concentration may be parameterized by a single measure, the salinity, S . Given this, the density of seawater is a function of three variables — pressure, temperature, and salinity — and we may write the conventional equation of state as
α = α(T , S, p),
(1.56)
where α = 1/ρ is the specific volume, or inverse density. For small variations around a reference value we have
∂α ∂α ∂α dT + dS + dp = α(βT dT − βS dS − βp dp), (1.57) dα = ∂T S,p ∂S T ,p ∂p T ,S where the rightmost expression serves to define the thermal expansion coefficient βT , the saline contraction coefficient βS , and the compressibility coefficient (or inverse bulk modulus) βp . In general these quantities are not constants, but for small variations around a reference state they may be treated as such and we have α = α0 1 + βT (T − T0 ) − βS (S − S0 ) − βp (p − p0 ) . (1.58) Typical values of these parameters, with variations typically encountered through the ocean, are: βT ≈ 2 (±1.5) × 10−4 K−1 (values increase with both temperature and pressure), βS ≈ 7.6 (±0.2) × 10−4 ppt−1 , βp ≈ 4.1 (±0.5) × 10−10 Pa−1 . Since the variations around the mean density are small (1.58) implies that ρ = ρ0 1 − βT (T − T0 ) + βS (S − S0 ) + βp (p − p0 ) . (1.59) A linear equation of state for seawater is emphatically not accurate enough for quantitative oceanography; the β parameters in (1.58) themselves vary with pressure, temperature and (more weakly) salinity so introducing nonlinearities to the equation. The most important of these are captured by an equation of state of the form β∗ α = α0 1 + βT (1 + γ ∗ p)(T − T0 ) + T (T − T0 )2 − βS (S − S0 ) − βp (p − p0 ) . (1.60) 2 ∗ ∗ The starred constants β∗ T and γ capture the leading nonlinearities: γ is the thermobaric parameter, which determines the extent to which the thermal expansion depends on pressure, and β∗ T is the second thermal expansion coefficient. Even this equation of state has quantitative deficiencies and more complicated semi-empirical formulae are often used if high accuracy is needed.4 An illustration of the variation of density of seawater with temperature, salinity and pressure is illustrated in Fig. 1.3, which uses an accurate, semi-empirical equation of state. More discussion is to be found in section 1.7.2. Clearly, the equation of state introduces, in general, a sixth unknown, temperature, and we will have to introduce another physical principle — the first law of thermodynamics or the principle of energy conservation — to obtain a complete set of equations. However, if the equation of state were such that it linked only density and pressure, without introducing another variable, then the equations would be complete; the simplest case of all is a constant density fluid for which the equation of state is just ρ = constant. A fluid for which the density is a function of pressure alone is called a barotropic fluid; otherwise, it is a baroclinic fluid. (In this context, ‘barotropic’ is a shortening of the original phrase ‘auto-barotropic’.) Equations of state of the form p = Cρ γ , where γ is a constant, are sometimes called ‘polytropic’.
16
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion 30
30
Temperature
22
38 24
20
20
40 42
26 10
44
10
28
46 30
0 32
34
36
48
0 38
32
Salinity
34
36
38
Salinity
Fig. 1.3 A temperature–salinity diagram for seawater, calculated using an accurate empirical equation of state. Contours are (density − 1000) kg m−3 , and the temperature is potential temperature, which in the deep ocean may be less than in situ temperature by a degree or so (see Fig. 1.4). Left panel: at sea-level (p = 105 Pa = 1000 mb). Right panel: at p = 4 × 107 Pa, a depth of about 4 km. Note that in both cases the contours are slightly convex.
1.5 THERMODYNAMIC RELATIONS In this section we review a few aspects of thermodynamics. We provide neither a complete nor an a priori development of the subject; rather, we focus on aspects that are particularly relevant to fluid dynamics, and that are needed to derive a ‘thermodynamic equation’ for fluids.5 Readers whose interest is solely in an ideal gas or a simple Boussinesq fluid may skim this section, and then refer back to it as needed.
1.5.1 A few fundamentals A fundamental postulate of thermodynamics is that the internal energy of a system in equilibrium is a function of its extensive properties volume, entropy, and the mass of its various constituents. (Extensive means that the property value is proportional to the amount of material present, as opposed to an intensive property such as temperature.) For our purposes it is more convenient to divide all of these quantities by the mass of fluid present, so expressing the internal energy per unit mass, I , as a function of the specific volume α = ρ −1 , the specific entropy η, and the mass fractions of its various components. Our interest is in two-component fluids (dry air and water vapour, or water and salinity) so that we may parameterize the composition by a single parameter, S . Thus we have
I = I(α, η, S) ,
(1.61a)
η = η(I, α, S) .
(1.61b)
or an equivalent equation for entropy,
Given the functional forms on the right-hand sides, either of these expressions constitutes a complete description of the macroscopic state of a system in equilibrium, and we call them
1.5 Thermodynamic Relations
17
the fundamental equation of state. The conventional equation of state can be derived from (1.61), but not vice versa. The first differential of (1.61a) gives, formally,
dI =
∂I ∂α
η,S
dα +
∂I ∂η
dη +
α,S
∂I ∂S
dS.
(1.62)
α,η
We will now ascribe physical meaning to these differentials. Conservation of energy states that the internal energy of a body may change because of work done by or on it, or because of a heat input, or because of a change in its chemical composition. We write this as dI = d–Q − d–W + d–C ,
(1.63)
where d–W is the work done by the body, d–Q is the heat input to the body, and d–C accounts for the change in internal energy caused by a change in its chemical composition (e.g., its salinity, or water vapour content), sometimes called the ‘chemical work’. The quantities on the right-hand side are imperfect differentials or infinitesimals: Q, W and C are not functions of the state of a body, and the internal energy cannot be regarded as the sum of a ‘heat’ and a ‘work’. We should think of heat and work as having meaning only as fluxes of energy, or rates of energy input, and not as amounts of energy; their sum changes the internal energy of a body, which is a function of its state. Equation (1.63) is sometimes called ‘the first law of thermodynamics’. Let us consider the causes of variations of the quantities on the right-hand side. Heat Input: Thermodynamics provides a relationship between the heat input and the change in the entropy of a body, namely that in an (infinitesimal) quasi-static or reversible process, with constant composition,
T dη = d–Q,
(1.64)
where η is the specific entropy of the body. The entropy is a function of the state of a body and is, by definition, an adiabatic invariant. As we are dealing with the amount of a quantity per unit mass, η is the specific entropy, although we will often refer to it just as the entropy. We may regard (1.63) as defining the heat input, d–Q, by way of a statement of conservation of energy, and (1.64) then says that there is a function of state, the entropy, that changes by an amount equal to the heat input divided by the temperature.6 Work done: The work done by a body is equal to the pressure times the change in its volume. Thus, per unit mass, we have d–W = p dα, (1.65) where α = 1/ρ is the specific volume of the fluid and p is the pressure. Composition: The change in internal energy due to changes in composition is given by d–C = µ dS,
(1.66)
where µ is the chemical potential of the solution. In the ocean compositional changes
18
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion (i.e., changes in salinity) arise through precipitation and evaporation at the surface, and molecular diffusion. When salinity does so change, the internal energy of a fluid parcel changes by (1.66), but in practice this change is usually small compared to other changes in internal energy. The most important effect of salinity is that it changes the density of seawater. In the atmosphere the composition of a parcel of air primarily mainly varies according to the amount of water vapour and liquid water in it; these variations cause corresponding changes in internal energy, but in the absence of phase-changes the internal energy variations are slight. The most important effect of water vapour is that when condensation or evaporation occurs, heat is released (or required) that provides an entropy source in (1.64).
Collecting equations (1.63) – (1.66) together we have dI = T dη − p dα + µ dS .
(1.67)
We refer to this as the fundamental thermodynamic relation. The fundamental equation of state, (1.61), describes the properties of a particular fluid, and the fundamental relation, (1.67), is a statement of the conservation of energy. Much of classical thermodynamics follows from these two expressions.
1.5.2 Various thermodynamic relations From (1.62) and (1.67) it follows that
∂I ∂I T = , p=− , ∂η α,S ∂α η,S
µ=
∂I ∂S
.
(1.68a,b,c)
η,α
These may be regarded as the defining relations for these variables; because of the connection between (1.63) and (1.67) these are not just formal definitions, and the pressure and temperature so defined are indeed related to our intuitive concepts of these variables and to the motion of the fluid molecules. Note that if we write dη = it is also clear that ∂η p=T , ∂α I,S
1 p µ dI + dα − dS, T T T
T −1 =
∂η ∂I
(1.69)
µ = −T
, α,S
∂η ∂S
.
(1.70a,b,c)
I,α
In the derivations below, we will, unless noted, suppose that the composition of a fluid parcel is fixed, and drop the suffix S on partial derivatives unless ambiguity might arise. Because the right-hand side of (1.67) is equal to an exact differential, the second derivatives are independent of the order of differentiation. That is,
∂2I ∂2I = ∂η ∂α ∂α ∂η and therefore, using (1.68)
∂T ∂α
η
=−
∂p ∂η
(1.71)
. α
(1.72)
1.5 Thermodynamic Relations
19
This is one of the Maxwell relations, which are a collection of four similar relations that follow directly from the fundamental thermodynamic relation (1.67) and simple relations between second derivatives. A couple of others will be useful. Define the enthalpy of a fluid by
h ≡ I + pα
(1.73)
then, for a parcel of constant composition, (1.67) becomes dh = T dη + α dp.
(1.74)
But h is a function only of η and p so that in general
dh =
∂h ∂η
dη +
p
∂h ∂p
dp.
(1.75)
η
Comparing the last two equations we have
T =
∂h ∂η
α=
and p
∂h ∂p
.
(1.76)
η
Noting that
∂2h ∂2h = ∂η ∂p ∂p ∂η we evidently must have
∂T ∂p
=
η
∂α ∂η
(1.77)
,
(1.78)
p
and this is our second Maxwell relation. To obtain the third, we write dI = T dη − p dα = d(T η) − η dT − d(pα) + α dp,
(1.79)
dG = −η dT + α dp,
(1.80)
or where G ≡ I − T η + pα is the Gibbs function (or ‘Gibbs free energy’ or ‘Gibbs potential’). Now, formally, we have
∂G ∂G dG = dT + dp. (1.81) ∂T p ∂p T Comparing the last two equations we see that η = −(∂ G/∂T )p and α = (∂ G/∂p)T . Furthermore, because ∂2G ∂2G = (1.82) ∂p ∂T ∂T ∂p we have our third Maxwell equation,
∂η ∂p
=−
T
∂α ∂T
. p
(1.83)
20
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Maxwell’s Relations The four Maxwell equations are:
∂T ∂α ∂η ∂p
η
T
=−
∂p ∂η
∂α =− ∂T
These imply:
∂(T , η) ≡ ∂(p, α)
∂T ∂p
α
, p
∂η ∂α
∂α , ∂η p η ∂η ∂p = . ∂α T ∂T α
,
∂T ∂p
−
=
∂T ∂α
∂η ∂p
(M.1)
= 0.
(M.2)
The fourth Maxwell equation, whose derivation is left to the reader (make use of the Helmholtz free energy, F ≡ I − T η), is
∂η ∂α
T
=
∂p ∂T
,
(1.84)
α
and all four Maxwell equations are summarized in the box above. All of them follow from the fundamental thermodynamic relation, (1.67), which is the real silver hammer of thermodynamics. Fundamental equation of state The fundamental equation of state (1.61) gives complete information about a fluid in thermodynamic equilibrium, and given this we can obtain expressions for the temperature, pressure and chemical potential using (1.68). These are also equations of state; however, each of them, taken individually, contains less information than the fundamental equation because a derivative has been taken. Equivalent to the fundamental equation of state are, using (1.74), an expression for the enthalpy as a function of its natural variables pressure, entropy and composition, or, using (1.80) the Gibbs function as a function of pressure, temperature and composition. Of these, the Gibbs function is the most practically useful because the pressure, temperature and composition may all be measured in the laboratory. Given the fundamental equation of state, the thermodynamic state of a body is fully specified by a knowledge of any two of p, ρ, T , η and I , plus its composition. The conventional equation of state, (1.54), is obtained by using (1.61a) to eliminate entropy from (1.68a) and (1.68b). One simple fundamental equation of state is to take the internal energy to be a function of density and not entropy; that is, I = I(α). Bodies with such a property are called homentropic. Using (1.68), temperature and chemical potential have no role in the fluid dynamics and the density is a function of pressure alone — the defining property of a barotropic fluid. Neither water nor air are, in general, homentropic but under some circumstances the flow may be adiabatic and p = p(ρ) (problem 1.10). In an ideal gas the molecules do not interact except by elastic collisions, and the volume of the molecules is presumed to be negligible compared to the total volume they occupy.
1.5 Thermodynamic Relations
21
The internal energy of the gas then depends only on temperature, and not on density. A simple ideal gas is an ideal gas for which the heat capacity is constant, so that
I = cT ,
(1.85)
where c is a constant. Using this and the conventional ideal gas equation, p = ρRT (where R is also constant), along with the fundamental thermodynamic relation (1.67), we can infer the fundamental equation of state; however, we will defer that until we discuss potential temperature in section 1.6.1. A general ideal gas also obeys p = ρRT , but it has heat capacities that may be a function of temperature (but only of temperature — see problem 1.12). Internal energy and specific heats We can obtain some useful relations between the internal energy and specific heat capacities, and some useful estimates of their values, by some simple manipulations of the fundamental thermodynamic relation. Assuming that the composition of the fluid is constant (1.67) is
T dη = dI + p dα,
(1.86)
so that, taking I to be a function of α and T , ∂I ∂I T dη = dT + + p dα. ∂T α ∂α T
(1.87)
From this, we see that the heat capacity at constant volume (i.e., constant α) cv is given by ∂η ∂I cv ≡ T = . (1.88) ∂T α ∂T α Thus, c in (1.85) is equal to cv . Similarly, using (1.74) we have
T dη = dh − α dp =
∂h ∂T
p
dT +
∂h ∂p
The heat capacity at constant pressure, cp , is then given by ∂η ∂h cp ≡ T = . ∂T p ∂T p
− α dp.
(1.89)
(1.90)
For later use, we define the ratios γ ≡ cp /cv and κ ≡ R/cp . For an ideal gas h = I + RT = T (cv + R). But cp = (∂ h/∂t )p , and hence cp = cv + R , and (γ − 1)/γ = κ . Statistical mechanics tells us that for a simple ideal gas the internal energy is equal to kT /2 per molecule, or RT /2 per unit mass, for each excited degree of freedom, where k is the Boltzmann constant and R the gas constant. The diatomic molecules N2 and O2 that comprise most of our atmosphere have two rotational and three translational degrees of freedom, so that I ≈ 5RT /2, and so cv ≈ 5R/2 and cp ≈ 7R/2, both being constants. These are in fact very good approximations to the measured values for the Earth’s atmosphere, and give cp ≈ 103 J kg−1 K−1 . The internal energy is simply cv T and the enthalpy is cp T . For a liquid, especially one like seawater that contains dissolved salts, no such simple relations are possible: the heat capacities are functions of the state of the fluid, and the internal energy is a function of pressure (or density) as well as temperature.
22
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
1.6 THERMODYNAMIC EQUATIONS FOR FLUIDS The thermodynamic relations — for example (1.67) — apply to identifiable bodies or systems; thus, the heat input affects the fluid parcel to which it is applied, and we can apply the material derivative to the above thermodynamic relations to obtain equations of motion for a moving fluid. But in doing so we make two assumptions. (i) That locally the fluid is in thermodynamic equilibrium. This means that, although the thermodynamic quantities like temperature, pressure and density vary in space and time, locally they are related by the thermodynamic relations such as the equation of state and Maxwell’s relations. (ii) That macroscopic fluid motions are reversible and so not entropy producing. Thus, such effects as the viscous dissipation of energy, radiation, and conduction may produce entropy whereas the macroscopic fluid motion itself does not. The first point requires that the temperature variation on the macroscopic scales must be slow enough that there can exist a volume that is small compared to the scale of macroscopic variations, so that temperature is effectively constant within it, but that is also sufficiently large to contain enough molecules so that macroscopic variables such as temperature have a proper meaning. Now from (1.63) conservation of energy for a infinitesimal fluid parcel may be written as dI = −p dα + d–QT
(1.91)
where p dα is the work done by the parcel and d–QT is the total energy input to the parcel, including the contributions from a thermal flux and from changes in composition. Given the first assumption above, we may form the material derivative of (1.91) to obtain DI Dα ˙T +p =Q Dt Dt
(1.92)
˙ T is the rate of total energy input, per unit mass, with (as for d–QT ) possible where Q contributions from thermal fluxes (including radiative heating, thermal diffusion and heat generated by viscous damping) and from diffusive fluxes of composition. (In general, both the thermal flux and the composition flux depend on the gradients of both temperature and composition, although in many circumstances the thermal flux is approximately determined by the temperature gradient, and the compositional flux by the gradient of composition.) Using the mass continuity equation in the form Dα/Dt = α∇ · v , we write (1.92) as DI ˙T + pα∇ · v = Q Dt
.
(1.93)
This is the internal energy equation for a fluid. ˙ T contains, in general, energy fluxes due to changes in composition, we need Because Q to know that composition. The composition of a fluid parcel is a carried with it as it moves, and changes only if there non-conservative sources and sinks, such as diffusive fluxes. Thus, and analogously to (1.42), the evolution of composition is determined by DS ˙ = S, Dt
(1.94)
1.6 Thermodynamic Equations for Fluids
23
where S˙ represents all the non-conservative terms. Rather than use an internal energy equation, we may use the fundamental thermodynamic relation to infer an evolution equation for entropy. Thus, forming the material derivative from (1.67) and using (1.93) and (1.94), we obtain the entropy equation 1 ˙ 1 ˙ Dη µ˙ = Q S ≡ Q, T − Dt T T T
(1.95)
˙ is the heating rate per unit mass. (This equation could have been equivalently where Q derived, by forming the material derivative of (1.64), along with assumption (ii) above.) It is important to realize that the entropy equation is not independent of the internal energy equation, but may be derived from it. The two equations are equivalently connected via the equation of state: if we use the internal energy equation we can in principle then calculate the entropy using the equation of state in the form η = η(I, α, S), or if we use the entropy equation we can then calculate the internal energy using I = I(η, α, S). Indeed, the internal energy equation and the entropy equation are both commonly referred to as ‘the thermodynamic equation’. In multi-component fluids irreversible diffusive processes provide a source of entropy, and the use of the internal energy equation is often more straightforward than the use of an entropy equation.7 Given evolution equations for composition and internal energy or entropy, and given the fundamental equation of state, we have, in principle, a complete set of equations for a fluid, as summarized in the shaded box on the following page. In practice, this form of the equations is not the most useful because, especially for liquids, the equation of state cannot be written in a simple and useful form that allows pressure and temperature to be diagnosed. Happily, for an ideal gas the equation of state does allow such a diagnosis, as we now discover.
1.6.1 Thermodynamic equation for an ideal gas For a dry ideal gas the internal energy is a function of temperature only and dI = cv dT (also see problems 1.12 and 1.14). The first law of thermodynamics becomes d–Q = cv dT + p dα
or
d–Q = cp dT − α dp,
(1.96a,b)
where the second expression is derived using α = RT /p and cp − cv = R . Forming the material derivative of the above gives two forms of the internal energy equation:
cv
DT Dα ˙ +p =Q Dt Dt
or
cp
DT RT Dp ˙ − = Q. Dt p Dt
(1.97a,b)
Using the mass continuity equation, (1.97a) may be written as
cv
DT ˙ + pα∇ · v = Q. Dt
(1.98)
Alternatively, using the ideal gas equation, we may eliminate T in favour of p and α and obtain Dp ˙ ρR . + γp∇ · v = Q (1.99) Dt cv
24
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Fundamental Equations of Motion of a Fluid The following constitutes, in principle, a complete set of equations for an inviscid fluid ˙ and whose composition, S , changes at a rate S˙. heated at a rate Q Evolution equations for velocity, density and composition: Dv 1 = − ∇p, Dt ρ
Dρ + ρ∇ · v = 0, Dt
DS ˙ = S. Dt
(F.1)
Internal energy equation or entropy equation:
p DI ˙T , − ∇·v =Q Dt ρ
Dη 1 ˙ = Q. Dt T
(F.2)
˙ + µ S˙ is the total rate of energy input. ˙T = Q where Q Fundamental equation of state:
I = I(ρ, S, η).
(F.3)
Diagnostic equations for temperature and pressure:
T =
∂I ∂η
, α,S
∂I p=− ∂α
.
(F.4)
η,S
The Earth’s atmosphere also contains water vapour with mixing ratio w , and an evolution equation for it takes the form Dw ˙ = w, (1.100) Dt ˙ represents the effects of condensation and evaporation. (An equation for liquid where w water may also be needed if cloudiness is to be modelled.) The main thermodynamic effect of water vapour occurs when water vapour condenses, or liquid water evaporates, and latent ˙ = −Lc w ˙ plus heat is released; this heating appears in thermodynamic equation, with Q other effects, where Lc is the latent heat of condensation. Potential temperature, potential density and entropy We can use entropy instead of temperature for our thermodynamic equation, and this corresponds to using (1.95) instead of (1.93). This is effectively equivalent to deriving and using the fundamental equation of state for an ideal gas, although it turns out to be convenient to express entropy in terms of a temperature-like quantity. To proceed, we first note that when a fluid parcel changes pressure adiabatically, it will expand or contract and, using (1.96b), its temperature change is determined by
cp dT = α dp.
(1.101)
As this temperature change is not caused by diabatic effects (e.g., heating), it is useful to define a temperature-like quantity that changes only if diabatic effects are present. To this
1.6 Thermodynamic Equations for Fluids
25
end, we define the potential temperature, θ , to be the temperature that a fluid would have if moved adiabatically (and, in general, at constant composition) to some reference pressure (often taken to be 1000 hPa, which is close to the pressure at the Earth’s surface). Thus, in adiabatic flow the potential temperature of a fluid parcel is conserved, essentially by definition, and Dθ (1.102) = 0. Dt For this equation to be useful we must be able to relate θ to the other thermodynamic variables. For an ideal gas we use (1.96b) and the equation of state to write the fundamental thermodynamic relation as dη = cp d ln T − R d ln p. (1.103) The definition of potential temperature then implies that
θ T
cp d ln T −
pR p
R d ln p = 0,
(1.104)
which, for constant cp and R , may be solved to give
θ=T
pR p
κ (1.105)
where pR is the reference pressure and κ = R/cp . Note that as a consequence of its definition the potential temperature is related to entropy by dη = cp d ln θ (1.106) and, if cp is constant,
η = cp ln θ.
(1.107)
Equation (1.106) is in fact a general expression for the potential temperature of a fluid parcel (see section 1.7.1), but (1.107) applies only if cp is constant, as it is, to a good approximation, in the Earth’s atmosphere. Forming the material derivative of (1.107) and using (1.95) we obtain
cp
Dθ θ ˙ = Q , Dt T
(1.108)
with θ given by (1.105). Equations (1.98), (1.99) and (1.108) are all equivalent forms of the thermodynamic equation for an ideal gas. The potential density, ρθ , is the density that a fluid parcel would have if moved adiabatically and at constant composition to a reference pressure, pR . If the equation of state is written as ρ = f (p, T ) then the potential density is just
ρθ = f (pR , θ). For an ideal gas we therefore have
ρθ =
pR ; Rθ
(1.109)
(1.110)
26
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
that is, potential density is proportional to the inverse of potential temperature. We may also write (1.110) as
1/γ pR ρθ = ρ . (1.111) p Finally, for later use we note that for small variations around a reference state manipulation of the ideal gas equation gives
δT δp δρ δθ 1 δp = −κ = − . θ T p γ p ρ
(1.112)
* The fundamental equation of state for an ideal gas Equations (1.107) and (1.105) are closely related to the fundamental equation of state, and using I = cv T and the equation of state p = ρRT , we can express the entropy explicitly in terms of the density and the internal energy, to wit
η = cv ln I − R ln ρ + constant .
(1.113)
This is the fundamental equation of state for a simple ideal gas. If we were to begin with this, we could straightforwardly derive all the thermodynamic quantities of interest for a simple ideal gas: for example, using (1.70a) we immediately recover P = ρRT , and from (1.70b) we obtain I = cv T . Indeed, (1.113) could be used to define a simple ideal gas, but such an a priori definition may seem a little unmotivated. Of course the heat capacities must still be determined by experiment or by a kinetic theory — they are not given by the thermodynamics, and (1.113) holds only if they are constant.
1.6.2 * Thermodynamic equation for liquids For a liquid such as seawater no simple exact equation of state exists. Thus, although (1.95) holds in general, an expression relating entropy to the other thermodynamic variables is still needed. For quantitative modelling and observational work such an equation of state must be accurate, but this entails a complicated, nonlinear expression that is, to most eyes, uninformative. On the other hand, for most theoretical work and for idealized models a simplified equation of state that captures the main qualitative effects will suffice. It is informative to proceed heuristically, and to begin with the entropy equation and make simplifications to it. I. Entropy equation using pressure and density If we regard η as a function of pressure and density (and salinity if appropriate) we obtain
∂η ∂η ∂η T dη = T dρ + T dp + T dS ∂ρ p,S ∂p ρ,S ∂S ρ,p
∂η ∂η ∂η ∂ρ =T dρ − T dp + T dS. (1.114) ∂ρ p,S ∂ρ p,S ∂p η,S ∂S ρ,p From this, and using (1.95) and (1.94), we obtain for a moving fluid
∂η ∂η Dρ Dp ∂ρ ˙ − T ∂η ˙ −T =Q T S. ∂ρ p,S Dt ∂ρ p,S ∂p η,S Dt ∂S ρ,p
(1.115)
1.6 Thermodynamic Equations for Fluids
27
But (∂ p/∂ρ)η,S = cs2 where cs is the speed of sound (see section 1.8). This is a measurable quantity in a fluid, and often nearly constant, and so useful to keep in an equation. Then the thermodynamic equation may be written in the form Dρ 1 Dp − 2 = Q[ρ] , Dt cs Dt
(1.116)
˙ − (∂ ρ/∂S )ρ,p S˙ represents the effects of entropy and salinity where Q[ρ] ≡ (∂ ρ/∂η)p,S Q/T source terms. This form of the thermodynamic equation is valid for both liquids and gases. Approximations using pressure and density The speed of sound in a fluid is related to its compressibility — the less compressible the fluid, the greater the sound speed (section 1.8). In a liquid, sound speed is often sufficiently high that the second term in (1.116) can be neglected, and the thermodynamic equation takes the simple form: Dρ = Q[ρ]. (1.117) Dt This equation is a very good approximation for many laboratory fluids. Note that this equation is a thermodynamic equation, arising from the principle of conservation of energy for a liquid. It is a very different equation from the mass conservation equation, which for compressible fluids is also an evolution equation for density. In the ocean the enormous pressures resulting from columns of seawater kilometres deep mean that although the second term in (1.116) may be small, it is not negligible, and a better approximation results if we suppose that the pressure is given by the weight of the fluid above it — the hydrostatic approximation. In this case dp = −ρg dz and (1.116) becomes ρg Dz Dρ + 2 = Q[ρ]. (1.118) Dt cs Dt In the second term the height field varies much more than the density field, so a good approximation is to replace ρ by a constant, ρ0 , in this term only. Taking the speed of sound also to be constant gives
ρ0 z D ρ+ (1.119) = Q[ρ], Dt Hρ where
Hρ = cs2 /g
(1.120) −1
is the density scale height of the ocean. In water, cs ≈ 1500 m s so that Hρ ≈ 200 km. The quantity in brackets on the left-hand side of (1.119) is (in this approximation) the potential density, this being the density that a parcel would have if moved adiabatically and with constant composition to the reference height z = 0. The adiabatic lapse rate of density is the rate at which the density of a parcel changes when undergoing an adiabatic displacement. From (1.119) it is approximately ∂ρ ρ0 g − ≈ 2 ≈ 5 (kg m−3 )/km, (1.121) ∂z η cs so that if a parcel is moved adiabatically from the surface to the deep ocean (5 km depth, say) its density will increase by about 25 kg m−3 , a fractional change of about 1/40 or 2.5%.
28
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
II. Entropy equation using pressure and temperature Taking entropy to be a function of pressure and temperature (and salinity if appropriate) we have
∂η ∂η ∂η T dη = T dT + T dp + T dS ∂T p,S ∂p T ,S ∂S T ,p
∂η ∂η = cp dT + T dp + T dS. (1.122) ∂p T ,S ∂S T ,p For a moving fluid, and using (1.95) and (1.94), this implies,
Dp T ∂η DT + = Q[T ], Dt cp ∂p T ,S Dt
(1.123)
˙ p − T cp−1 S(∂ ˙ η/∂S ). Now substitute the Maxwell relation (1.83) in the where Q[T ] ≡ Q/c form
1 ∂ρ ∂η = 2 (1.124) ∂p T ρ ∂T p to give DT T + Dt cp ρ 2 or, equivalently,
T DT − Dt cp
∂ρ ∂T
∂α ∂T
p
p
Dp = Q[T ], Dt
Dp = Q[T ]. Dt
(1.125a)
(1.125b)
The density and temperature are related through a measurable coefficient of thermal expansion βT where ∂ρ = −βT ρ. (1.126) ∂T p Equation (1.125) then becomes
βT T Dp DT − = Q[T ] . Dt cp ρ Dt
(1.127)
This form of the thermodynamic equation is valid for both liquids and gases, and in an ideal gas βT = 1/T . Approximations using pressure and temperature Liquids are characterized by a small coefficient of thermal expansion, and it is sometimes acceptable in laboratory fluids to neglect the second term on the left-hand side of (1.127). We then obtain an equation analogous to (1.117), namely DT = Q[T ]. Dt
(1.128)
This approximation relies on the smallness of the coefficient of thermal expansion. A better approximation is to again suppose that the pressure in (1.127) varies according only to the weight of the fluid above it. Then dp = −ρg dz and (1.127) becomes 1 DT βT g Dz Q[T ] + = . T Dt cp Dt T
(1.129)
1.6 Thermodynamic Equations for Fluids
29
For small variations of T , and if βT is nearly constant, this simplifies to D T0 z = Q[T ], T+ Dt HT
(1.130)
where
cp (1.131) βT g is the temperature scale height of the fluid. The quantity T + T0 z/HT is (in this approximation) the potential temperature, θ , so called because it is the temperature that a fluid at a depth z would have if moved adiabatically to a reference depth, here taken as z = 0. The temperature changes because of the work done by or on the fluid parcel as it expands or is compressed. That is, βT gT0 θ≈T + z. (1.132) cp HT =
In seawater the expansion coefficient βT and cp are functions of pressure and (1.132) is not good enough for quantitative calculations. With the approximate values for the ocean of βT ≈ 2 × 10−4 K−1 and cp ≈ 4 × 103 J kg−1 K−1 we obtain HT ≈ 2000 km. The adiabatic lapse rate of temperature is the rate at which the temperature of a parcel changes in the vertical when undergoing an adiabatic displacement. From (1.129) it is ∂T T gβT Γad = − = . (1.133) ∂z η cp In general it is a function of temperature, salinity and pressure, but it is a calculable quantity if βT is known. With the oceanic values above, it is approximately 0.15 K km−1 . Equation (1.133) is not accurate enough for quantitative oceanography because the expansion coefficient is a function of pressure; nor is it a good measure of stability, because of the effects of salt. It is noteworthy that the scale heights given by (1.120) and (1.131) differ so much. The first is due to the compressibility of seawater [and so related to cs2 , or βp in (1.59)] whereas the second is due to the change of density with temperature [βT in (1.59)], and is the distance over which the the difference between temperature and potential temperature changes by an amount equal to the temperature itself (i.e., by about 273 K). The two heights differ so much because the value of the thermal expansion coefficient is not directly tied to the compressibility — for example, fresh water at 4° C has a zero thermal expansion, and so would have an infinite temperature scale height, but its compressibility differs little from water at 20° C. In the atmosphere the ideal gas relationship gives βT = 1/T and so
Γad =
g , cp
(1.134)
which is approximately 10 K km−1 . The only approximation involved in deriving this is the use of the hydrostatic relationship. III. Entropy equation using density and temperature Taking entropy to be a function of density and temperature (and salinity if appropriate) we have ∂η ∂η ∂η T dη = T dT + T dα + T dS ∂T α,S ∂α T ,S ∂S T ,α
30
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Forms of the Thermodynamic Equation General form Dα DI ˙T +p =Q Dt Dt
or
DI ˙T , + pα∇ · v = Q Dt
(T.1a,b)
˙ T is the rate of energy input, per unit mass. Equivalently, where I is the internal energy and Q we may may use an entropy or potential temperature equation, Dη 1 ˙ = Q Dt T
or
cp
D ln θ 1 ˙ ≈ Q, Dt T
(T.2a,b)
˙ is the heating rate. For a fluid where η is the entropy, θ is the potential temperature, and Q parcel of constant composition, cp d ln θ = dη. Entropy or potential temperature must then be related to the other thermodynamic variables via an equation of state. [Equation (T.2b) is exactly true in the absence of compositional changes.] Ideal gas For an ideal gas dI = cv dT , and the adiabatic thermodynamic equation may be written in the following equivalent, exact, forms: DT Dp −α = 0, Dt Dt DT + pα∇ · v = 0, cv Dt
cp
Dp + γp∇ · v = 0, Dt Dθ = 0, Dt
(T.3)
where θ = T (pR /p)κ . The two expressions on the second line are usually the most useful in modelling and theoretical work. Liquids For liquids we may usefully write the adiabatic thermodynamic entropy equation as a conservation equation for potential temperature θ or potential density ρpot . For example: Dθ = 0, Dt Dρpot Dt
= 0,
⎧ ⎨T θ≈ ⎩T + (βT gz/cp ) ⎧ ⎨ρ ρpot ≈ ⎩ρ + (ρ0 gz/c 2 ) s
(approximately) (with some thermal expansion), (very approximately) (with some compression).
(T.4a)
(T.4b)
Unlike (T.3), these are not equivalent forms. More accurate semi-empirical expressions that may also include saline effects must be used for quantitative applications. In principle, an internal energy equation may then be constructed using the equation of state; an oft-used alternative is to employ the Boussinesq approximation (discussed in section 2.4), which avoids consideration of internal energy.
1.7 * More Thermodynamics of Liquids
= cv dT + T
31
∂η ∂α
T ,S
dα + T
∂η ∂S
dS.
(1.135)
T ,α
For a moving fluid this implies, DT T + Dt cv
∂η ∂α
T ,S
Dα ], = Q[T Dt
(1.136)
˙ v − T cv−1 S(∂ ˙ η/∂S ). ] ≡ Q/c where Q[T For an ideal gas, and using (1.84) (one of Maxwell’s relations), (1.136) may be written as
cv
DT Dα ˙ +p = Q, Dt Dt
(1.137)
so recovering the internal energy equation (1.97a). On the other hand, for a liquid of nearly constant density, the second term on the left-hand side of (1.136) is small, and also cp ≈ cv , ]. and we have to a first approximation DT /Dt = Q[T Various forms of the thermodynamic equation are summarized on page 30, and the complete equations of motion for a fluid are summarized on page 32. Also, note that for an ideal gas (1.116) and (1.127) are exactly equivalent to (1.98) or (1.99) (problem 1.11).
1.7 * MORE THERMODYNAMICS OF LIQUIDS 1.7.1 Potential temperature, potential density and entropy For an ideal gas we were able to derive a simple thermodynamic equation for a single variable, potential temperature, which in turn could be simply related to the temperature and pressure and that was, furthermore, closely related to entropy. Potential temperature is, in fact, closely related to entropy for more general fluids, as we now see. Potential temperature The potential temperature is defined as the temperature that a parcel would have if moved adiabatically to a given reference pressure pR , often taken as 105 Pa (or 1000 hPa, or 1000 mb, approximately the pressure at the sea-surface). Thus it may be calculated, at least in principle, by the integral
θ(S, T , p, pR ) = T +
pR p
Γad (S, T , p) dp,
(1.138)
= (∂ T /∂p)η . Such integrals may be hard to calculate, and if we know the equation where Γad of state in the form η = η(S, T , p) then we can calculate potential temperature more directly because, by definition, potential temperature satisfies
η(S, T , p) = η(S, θ, pR ).
(1.139)
Solving this for θ gives, in principle, θ = θ(η, S, pR ) = θ(T , S, p). For a parcel of constant composition, changes in entropy are directly related to changes in potential temperature because, from the right-hand side of (1.139), dη =
∂ η(S, θ, pR ) dθ. ∂θ
(1.140)
32
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
The Equations of Motion of a Fluid For dry air, or for a salt-free liquid, the equations of motion may be written as follows: The mass continuity equation:
∂ρ + ∇ · (ρv) = 0. ∂t
(EOM.1)
If density is constant this reduces to ∇ · v = 0. The momentum equation: Dv ∇p =− + ν∇2 v + F, Dt ρ
(EOM.2)
where F represents the effects of body forces such as gravity and ν is the kinematic viscosity. If density is constant, or pressure is given as a function of density alone (e.g., p = Cρ γ ), then (EOM.1) and (EOM.2) form a complete system. The thermodynamic equation: DI p ˙ + ∇ · v = Q, Dt ρ
or
1 Dθ = Dt cp
θ T
˙ Q,
˙ represents diabatic sources such as heating and diffusion. where Q An equation of state: p = f (I, ρ) or p = g(θ, ρ)
(EOM.3)
(EOM.4)
where f and g are given functions. For example, for an ideal gas, p = ρRI/cv and p = pR (T /θ)1/κ where T = p/ρR . The equations describing fluid motion are called the Euler equations if the viscous term is omitted, and the Navier–Stokes equations if viscosity is included.8 Sometimes these appellations are taken to mean only the momentum and mass conservation equations, and sometimes the Euler equations are restricted to a fluid of constant density.
Thus, if a fluid parcel moves adiabatically and at constant composition then dη = 0 and dθ = 0. Furthermore, if we express entropy as a function of temperature and pressure then
∂η ∂η ∂η T dη = T dT + T dp = cp dT + T dp, (1.141) ∂T pS ∂p T S ∂p T S using the definition of cp . If we evaluate this expression at the reference pressure, where T = θ and dp = 0, then we have θ dη = cp (pR , θ) dθ , and therefore dη = cp (pR , θ)
dθ θ
,
(1.142)
and dη/dθ = cp (pR , θ)/θ . In the special case of constant cp integration yields
η = cp ln θ + constant,
(1.143)
1.7 * More Thermodynamics of Liquids
33
as for a simple ideal gas (1.107). Given (1.142), the thermodynamic equation can be written, for a field of constant composition,
cp
θ ˙ Dθ = Q, Dt T
(1.144)
where the right-hand side represents heating. If composition is not constant, the right-hand side should also include any saline source terms and saline diffusion; however, such terms usually have a very small effect in the ocean. We can use (1.144) as a thermodynamic equation instead of (1.95), although we must now relate θ instead of η to the other state variables via an equation of state. The notion of potential temperature is useful because it is connected to the actual temperature, with which we are familiar; roughly speaking, potential temperature is temperature plus a correction for the effects of compressibility. Entropy, on the other hand, may seem alien and unnecessarily exotic. However, the use of potential temperature brings no simplification to the equations of motion beyond that already afforded by the use of entropy as a thermodynamic variable. Indeed, for fluids of variable composition, the evolution equation for potential temperature is more complicated than that for entropy.9 Potential density Potential density, ρθ , is the density that a parcel would have if it were moved adiabatically and with fixed composition to a given reference pressure, pR , that is often, but not always, taken as 105 Pa, or 1 bar. If the equation of state is of the form ρ = ρ(S, T , p) then by definition we have ρθ = ρ(S, θ, pR ). (1.145) For a parcel moving adiabatically (i.e., fixed salinity and potential temperature) its potential density is therefore conserved. For an ideal gas (1.145) gives ρθ = pR /(Rθ) [as in (1.110)] and potential density provides no more information than potential temperature. However, in the oceans potential density accounts for the effect of salinity on density and so is a much better measure of the static stability of a column of water than density itself. An approximate expression for ρθ is given by (1.119). Because density is so nearly constant in the ocean, it is common to subtract the amount 1000 kg m−3 before quoting its value, and depending on whether we are referring to in situ density or the potential density the results are called σT (‘sigma-tee’) or σθ (‘sigma-theta’) respectively. Thus,
σT = ρ(p, T , S) − 1000,
σθ = ρ(pR , θ, S) − 1000.
(1.146a,b)
If the potential density is referenced to a particular level, this is denoted by a subscript on the σ . Thus, σ2 is the potential density referenced to 200 bars of pressure, or about 2 kilometres depth.
1.7.2 * Thermodynamic properties of seawater In this section we illustrate how the thermodynamic variables for seawater — the conventional equation of state, an expression for potential temperature, and so on — can be obtained directly from the fundamental equation of state. Writing the fundamental equation
34
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
in the form I = I(η, S, α) is not practically useful, because the variables are not easily measured in the laboratory. However, if we cast the fundamental equation in terms of the Gibbs function, G = I − T η + pα, then dG = −η dT + α dp + µ dS and the independent variables are the familiar and measurable (T , S, p). Oceanographers go to great lengths to obtain an accurate equation of state and other physical properties of seawater, and we noted in section 1.4 that seawater has some nonlinear properties that, although small, are nevertheless important. A Gibbs function that accurately reproduces these properties is very complicated, but we can write down a model Gibbs function that, although not highly accurate except for small variations around a reference state, does capture and display the most important properties with a certain degree of economy and transparency.10 The function is G = G0 − η0 (T − T0 ) + µ0 (S − S0 ) − cp0 T ln(T /T0 ) − 1 1 + β∗ S (S − S0 ) βP + α0 (p − p0 ) 1 + βT (T − T0 ) − βS (S − S0 ) − (p − p0 ) 2 ∗ ∗ βT γ β + (p − p0 )(T − T0 ) + T (T − T0 )2 . (1.147) 2 2 In this equation the variables are G, T , S and p . The parameters [which all have subscripts or stars, with the starred parameters giving rise to nonlinear effects; refer also to (1.60)] are all constants that could in principle be determined in the laboratory with the help of the derived quantities like heat capacity, and their approximate values are given in Table 1.2. We will take p0 = 0 and βp = α0 /cs20 , where cs 0 is a reference sound speed. From (1.147) we may derive the following quantities of interest. The conventional or thermal equation of state, α = (∂ G/∂p)T ,p :
β∗ α = α0 1 + βT (1 + γ ∗ p)(T − T0 ) + T (T − T0 )2 − βS (S − S0 ) − βp p . 2
(1.148)
The entropy, η = −(∂ G/∂T )p,S :
η = η0 + cp0 ln
T ∗p ∗ 1 + β∗ (S − S ) − α p β + β γ + β (T − T ) . 0 0 T T 0 T S T0 2
The heat capacity, cp = T (∂ η/∂T )P : ∗ cp = cp0 1 + β∗ S (S − S0 ) − α0 pβT T .
(1.149)
(1.150)
This is to a first approximation constant, varying mildly with salinity and more weakly with temperature and pressure. T = α−1 (∂ α/∂T )S,p : The thermal expansion coefficient, β
T = (α0 /α) βT + βT γ ∗ p + β∗ (T − T0 ) , β T where α is given by (1.148). The adiabatic lapse rate, Γ = (∂ T /∂p)η . Using (1.141) gives
∂T T ∂α T Γ = = = α0 [βT (1 + γ ∗ p) + β∗ T (T − T0 )]. ∂p η cp ∂T p,S cp where cp is given by (1.150).
(1.151)
(1.152)
1.7 * More Thermodynamics of Liquids
35
Parameter
Description
Value
ρ0 α0 T0 S0 cs 0 βT β∗ T βS βp γ∗ cp0 β∗ S
Reference Density Reference Specific Volume Reference temperature Reference salinity Reference sound speed First thermal expansion coefficient Second thermal expansion coefficient Haline contraction coefficient Compressibility coefficient (= α0 /cs20 ) Thermobaric parameter (≈ γ ∗ ) Specific heat capacity at constant pressure Haline heat capacity coefficient
1.027 × 103 kg m−3 −1 9.738 × 10−4 m3 kg 283 K 35 psu ≈ 35‰ 1490 m s−1 1.67 × 10−4 K−1 1.00 × 10−5 K−2 0.78 × 10−3 psu−1 −1 4.39 × 10−10 m s2 kg −1 −8 1.1 × 10 Pa −1 3986 J kg K−1 −3 1.5 × 10 psu−1
Table 1.2 Various thermodynamic and equation-of-state parameters for seawater, which may be used in the equations of state (1.60) and (1.147). The ’psu’, or practical salinity unit, is approximately one part per thousand.
38
34
S 400
200
0.6
L 9.6
1 9.8
10
Potential Temperature
32
0
10
20
400
30
Temperature
Fig. 1.4 Examples of the variation of potential temperature of seawater with pressure, temperature and salinity. Left panel: the sloping lines show potential temperature as a function of pressure at fixed salinity (S = 35 psu) and temperature (10.14° C). The solid line is computed using an accurate, empirical equation of state, the almostcoincident dashed line uses the simpler expression (1.153) and the dotted line (labelled L) uses the linear expression (1.154c). The near vertical solid line, labelled S, shows the variation of potential temperature with salinity at fixed temperature and pressure. Right panel: Contours of the difference between temperature and potential temperature, (T − θ ) in the pressure–temperature plane, for S = 35 psu. The solid lines use an accurate empirical formula, and the dashed lines use (1.153). The simpler equation can be improved locally, but not globally, by tuning the coefficients. (100 bars of pressure (107 Pa or 10 MPa) is approximately 1 km depth.)
Pressure (bars)
0.2
36
200
9.4
0
Salinity
Pressure (bars)
0
36
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
Potential temperature and a simplified equation of state for numerical models An expression for the potential temperature, θ , may be obtained by solving (1.139) for θ . In general, such an equation must be solved numerically, but for our equation of state, using (1.149) and taking pR = 0, we find
θ = T exp −
β∗ 1 ∗ α 0 βT p T 1 + γ p + (T − T ) . 0 cp 2 βT
(1.153)
where cp = cp0 1 + β∗ S (S − S0 ) . Equation (1.153) is a relationship between T , θ and p analogous to (1.105) for an ideal gas. The exponent itself is small, the second and third terms in square brackets are small compared to unity, the deviations of both T and θ from T0 are also presumed to be small, and cp is nearly constant. Taking advantage of all of this enables (1.153) to be rewritten, with increasing levels of approximation, as
T 0 α 0 βT 1 ∗ α 0 β∗ α 0 β∗ T T T ≈ p 1 + γ p + T0 p + θ 1 + T0 p cp 0 2 cp 0 cp0
1 α 0 β∗ T 0 α 0 βT T ≈ p 1 + γ ∗ p + θ 1 + T0 p cp 0 2 cp 0
≈
T 0 α 0 βT p + θ , cp 0
(1.154a) (1.154b) (1.154c)
where T = T − T0 and θ = θ − T0 . The last of the three, (1.154c), holds for a linear equation of state, and is useful for calculating approximate differences between temperature and potential temperature; making use of the hydrostatic approximation reveals that it is essentially the same as (1.132). Plots of the difference between temperature and potential temperature, using both a highly accurate empirical equation of state and using the simplified equation, (1.153), are given in Fig. 1.4, and some examples of the density variation of seawater are given in Fig. 1.5. Numerical ocean models often use potential temperature as a thermodynamic variable. We then require an equation of state that gives density in terms of potential temperature, pressure, and salinity. Using (1.154b) in the equation of state (1.148) we find that
α ≈ α0
α0 p 1 ∗ 2 ∗ 1 − 2 + βT (1 + γ p)θ + βT θ − βS (S − S0 ) , 2 cs 0
(1.155)
−2 −2 2 −2 ∗ ∗ ∗ differ by where γ ∗ = γ ∗ + T0 β∗ T α0 /cp 0 ≈ γ and cs 0 = cs 0 − βT T0 /cp ≈ cs 0 (γ and γ a few percent, and cs2 and cs2 differ by only a few parts in a thousand). We may approximate (1.155) further by using the hydrostatic pressure instead of the actual pressure; thus, letting p = −g(z − z0 )/α0 where z0 is the nominal value of z at which p = 0, we obtain
α ≈ α0
g(z − z0 ) β∗ T 2 ∗ g(z − z0 ) 1+ θ + + βT 1 − γ θ − βS (S − S0 ) . α0 2 cs20
(1.156)
Using z instead of p in the equation of state entails a slight loss of accuracy, but is necessary to ensure that the Boussinesq equations maintain good conservation properties, as discussed in sections 2.4 and 4.7.1.
1.8 Sound Waves
37
(a)
(b) 50
40
Density
Density
50
S = 35, p = 5 × 107 S = 35, p = 105
30
θ = 5, p = 5 × 107 θ = 13, p = 105
30
20 10
0
10
Temperature
20
20 32
30
(c)
34
Salt
36
38
(d)
50
0.4
S = 35, θ = 13 S = 35, θ = 30
0.3
40
βT × 103
Density
40
30
0.2
0.1
S = 35, p = 5 × 107 S = 35, p = 105
20
0
1
2
3
Pressure
4
5 x 10
7
0 10
0
10
Temperature
20
30
Fig. 1.5 Examples of the variation of density of seawater (minus 1000 kg m−3 ) with (a) potential temperature (° C); (b) salt (psu); and (c) pressure (Pa), for seawater. Panel (d), T = −ρ −1 (∂ ρ/∂T )p,S K−1 , for each of the shows the thermal expansion coefficient, β two curves in panel (a).
1.8 SOUND WAVES Full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. William Shakespeare, Macbeth, c. 1606.
We now consider, rather briefly, one of the most common phenomena in fluid dynamics, yet one which is in most circumstances relatively unimportant for geophysical fluid dynamics — sound waves. Their unimportance stems from the fact that the pressure disturbance produced by sound waves is a tiny fraction of the ambient pressure and too small to affect the circulation. For example, the ambient surface pressure in the atmosphere is about 105 Pa and variations due to large-scale weather phenomena are about 103 Pa or larger, whereas sound waves of 70 dB (i.e., a loud conversation) produce pressure variations of about 0.06 Pa. (1 dB = 20 log10 (p/pr ) where pr = 2 × 10−5 Pa.) The smallness of the disturbance produced by sound waves justifies a linearization of the equations of motion about a spatially uniform basic state that is a time-independent solution to the equations of motion. Thus, we write v = v0 + v , ρ = ρ0 + ρ (where a subscript 0 denotes a basic state and a prime denotes a perturbation) and so on, substitute in the
38
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
equations of motion, and neglect terms involving products of primed quantities. By choice of our reference frame we will simplify matters further by setting v0 = 0. The linearized momentum and mass conservation equations are then, respectively,
ρ0
∂ v = −∇p , ∂t
∂ ρ = −ρ0 ∇ · v . ∂t
(1.157a,b)
(Note that these linear equations do not in themselves determine the magnitude of the disturbance.) Now, sound waves are largely adiabatic. Thus, dp = dt
∂p ∂ρ
η
dρ , dt
(1.158)
where (∂ p/∂ρ)η is the derivative at constant entropy, whose particular form is given by the equation of state for the fluid at hand. Then, from (1.157) and (1.158) we obtain a single equation for pressure, ∂ 2 p = cs2 ∇2 p , (1.159) ∂t 2 where cs2 = (∂ p/∂ρ)η . Equation (1.159) is the classical wave equation; solutions propagate at a speed cs , which may be identified as the speed of sound. For adiabatic flow in an ideal gas, manipulation of the equation of state leads to p = Cρ γ , where γ = cp /cv , whence cs2 = γp/ρ = γRT . Values of γ typically range from 5/3 for a monatomic gas to 7/5 for a diatomic gas and so for air, which is almost entirely diatomic, we find cs ≈ 350 m s−1 at 300 K. In seawater no such theoretical approximation is easily available, but measurements show that cs ≈ 1500 m s−1 .
1.9 COMPRESSIBLE AND INCOMPRESSIBLE FLOW Although there are probably no fluids of truly constant density, in many cases the density of a fluid will vary so little that it is a very good approximation to consider the density effectively constant in the mass conservation equation. The fluid is then said to be incompressible. For example, in the Earth’s oceans the density varies by less that 5%, even though the pressure at the ocean bottom, a few kilometres below the surface, is several hundred times the atmospheric pressure at the surface. Let us first consider how the mass conservation equation simplifies when density is truly constant, and then consider conditions under which treating density as constant is a good approximation.
1.9.1 Constant density fluids If a fluid is strictly of constant density then the mass continuity equation, (1.36) (i.e., Dρ/Dt + ρ∇ · v = 0), simplifies easily by neglecting all derivatives of density yielding
∇·v =0 .
(1.160)
The prognostic equation (1.36) has become a diagnostic equation (1.160), or a constraint to be satisfied by the velocity. A consequence of (1.160) is that the volume of each material
1.9 Compressible and Incompressible Flow
39
fluid element remains constant. To see this recall the expression for the conservation of mass in the form D (ρ∆V ) = 0. (1.161) Dt If ρ is constant this reduces to an expression for volume conservation, D∆V /Dt = 0, whence (1.160) is recovered because D∆V /Dt = ∆V ∇ · v .
1.9.2 Incompressible flows An incompressible fluid is one in which the density of a given fluid element does not change. Thus, in the mass continuity equation, (1.36a), the material derivative of density is neglected and we recover (1.160). In reality no fluid is truly incompressible and for (1.160) to approximately hold we just require that
∂w Dρ ∂u ∂ v ρ + ; (1.162) + Dt ∂x ∂y ∂z that is, the material derivative of density is much smaller than the individual terms constituting the divergence. As working definition we say that in an incompressible fluid, density changes are so small that they have a negligible effect on the mass balance. We do not need to assume that the densities of differing fluid elements are similar to each other, but in the ocean (and in most liquids) variations in density, δρ , are in fact everywhere small compared to the mean density, ρ0 . A sufficient condition for incompressibility, then, is that
δρ 1. ρ0
(1.163)
Note that the fact that ∇ · v = 0 does not imply that we may independently use Dρ/Dt = 0. Indeed for a liquid with an equation of state ρ = ρ0 (1 − βT (T − T0 )) and a thermodynamic ˙ we have equation cp DT /Dt = Q β T ρ0 ˙ Dρ =− Q. (1.164) Dt cp Furthermore, incompressibility does not necessarily imply the neglect of density variations in the momentum equation — it is only in the mass continuity equation that density variations are neglected. Some conditions for incompressibility The conditions under which incompressibility is a good approximation to the full mass continuity equation depend not only on the physical nature of the fluid but also on the flow itself. The condition that density is largely unaffected by pressure gives one necessary condition for the legitimate use of (1.160), as follows. First assume adiabatic flow, and omit the gravitational term. Then
∂p d ρ dρ dp = = cs2 (1.165) dt ∂ρ η dt dt so that the density and pressure variations of a fluid parcel are related by
δp ∼ cs2 δρ.
(1.166)
40
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
From the momentum equation we estimate
U2 1 δp , ∼ L L ρ0
(1.167)
where U and L are typical velocities and lengths and where ρ0 is a representative value of the density. Using (1.166) and (1.167) gives U 2 ∼ cs2 δρ/ρ0 . The incompressibility condition (1.163) then becomes U2 1. (1.168) cs2 That is, for a flow to be incompressible the fluid velocities must be less than the speed of sound; that is, the Mach number, M ≡ U/cs , must be small. In the Earth’s atmosphere it is apparent that density changes with height. To estimate how much density does change, let us first assume hydrostatic balance and an ideal gas, so that 1 ∂p = −g. (1.169) ρ ∂z If (for simplicity) we also assume that atmosphere is isothermal then
∂p = ∂z
∂p ∂ρ
T
∂ρ ∂ρ = RT0 . ∂z ∂z
(1.170)
Using (1.169) and (1.170) gives
ρ = ρ0 exp(−z/Hρ ),
(1.171)
where Hρ = RT0 /g is the (density) scale height of the atmosphere. It is easy to see that density changes are negligible only if we concern ourselves with motion less than the scale height, so this is another necessary condition for incompressibility. In the atmosphere, although the Mach number is small for most flows, vertical displacements often exceed the scale height and the flow cannot then be considered incompressible. In the ocean density changes from all causes are small and in most circumstances the ocean may be considered to contain an incompressible fluid. We return to this in the next chapter when we consider the Boussinesq equations.
1.10 THE ENERGY BUDGET The total energy of a fluid includes the kinetic, potential and internal energies. Both fluid flow and pressure forces will, in general, move energy from place to place, but we nevertheless expect energy to be conserved in an enclosed volume. Let us now consider what form energy conservation takes in a fluid.
1.10.1 Constant density fluid For a constant density fluid the momentum equation and the mass continuity equation ∇ · v = 0, are sufficient to completely determine the evolution of a system. The momentum equation is Dv = −∇ (φ + Φ) + ν∇2 v, (1.172) Dt
1.10 The Energy Budget
41
where φ = p/ρ0 and Φ is the potential for any conservative force per unit mass (e.g., gz for a uniform gravitational field). We can rewrite the advective term on the left-hand side using the identity, (v · ∇)v = −v × ω + ∇(v 2 /2), (1.173) where ω ≡ ∇ × v is the vorticity, discussed more in later chapters. Then, omitting viscosity, we have ∂v + ω × v = −∇B, (1.174) ∂t where B = (φ + Φ + v 2 /2) is the Bernoulli function for constant density flow. Consider for a moment steady flows (∂ v/∂t = 0). Streamlines are, by definition, parallel to v everywhere, and the vector v × ω is everywhere orthogonal to the streamlines, so that taking the dot product of the steady version of (1.174) with v gives v · ∇B = 0. That is, for steady flows the Bernoulli function is constant along a streamline, and DB/Dt = 0. Reverting back to the time-varying case, take the dot product with v and include the density to yield 1 ∂ ρ0 v 2 + ρ0 v · (ω × v) = −ρ0 v · ∇B (1.175) 2 ∂t The second term on the left-hand side vanishes identically. Defining the kinetic energy density K , or energy per unit volume, by K = ρ0 v 2 /2, (1.175) becomes an expression for the rate of change of K , ∂K + ∇ · (ρ0 vB) = 0. (1.176) ∂t Because Φ is time-independent this may be written ∂ 1 2 1 2 ρ0 v +Φ + ∇ · ρ0 v v +Φ+φ = 0. ∂t 2 2
(1.177)
or
∂E + ∇ · [v(E + p)] = 0. (1.178) ∂t where E = K + ρ0 Φ is the total energy density (i.e, the total energy per unit volume). This has the form of a general conservation equation in which a local change in a quantity is balanced by the divergence of its flux. However, the energy flux, v(ρ0 v 2 /2 + ρ0 Φ + ρ0 φ), is not simply the velocity times the energy density ρ0 (v 2 /2 + Φ); there is an additional term, vp , that represents the energy transfer occurring when work is done by the fluid against the pressure force. Now consider a volume through which there is no mass flux, for example a domain bounded by rigid walls. The rate of change of energy within that volume is then given by the integral of (1.175) dK d ≡ dt dt
V
K dV = −
V
∇ · (ρ0 vB) dV = −
S
ρ0 Bv · dS = 0,
(1.179)
is the total kinetic energy. Thus, the total using the divergence theorem, and where K kinetic energy within the volume is conserved. Note that for a constant density fluid the gravitational potential energy, P, is given by ρ0 gz dV , (1.180) P = V
42
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
which is a constant, not affected by a rearrangement of the fluid. Thus, in a constant density fluid there is no exchange between kinetic energy and potential energy and the kinetic energy itself is conserved.
1.10.2 Variable density fluids We start with the momentum equation
ρ
Dv = −∇p − ρ∇Φ, Dt
(1.181)
and take its dot product with v to obtain an equation for the evolution of kinetic energy, 1 Dv 2 ρ = −v · ∇p − ρv · ∇Φ = −∇ · (pv) + p∇ · v − ρv · ∇Φ. 2 Dt
(1.182)
The internal energy equation for adiabatic flow is
ρ
DI = −p∇ · v. Dt
(1.183)
Finally, and somewhat trivially, the potential energy density obeys
ρ
DΦ = ρv · ∇Φ. Dt
Adding (1.182), (1.183) and (1.184) we obtain D 1 2 ρ v + I + Φ = −∇ · (pv), Dt 2
(1.184)
(1.185)
which, on expanding the material derivative and using the mass conservation equation, becomes ∂ 1 2 1 2 v +I+Φ + ∇ · ρv v + I + Φ + p/ρ = 0. (1.186) ρ ∂t 2 2 This may be written
∂E + ∇ · v(E + p) = 0 , ∂t
(1.187)
where E = ρ(v 2 /2 + I + Φ) is the total energy per unit volume of the fluid. This is the energy equation for an unforced, inviscid and adiabatic, compressible fluid. Just as for the constant density case, the energy flux contains the term pv that represents the work done against pressure and, again, the second term vanishes when integrated over a closed domain with rigid boundaries, implying that the total energy is conserved. However, there can now be an exchange of energy between kinetic, potential and internal components. The quantity σ = I + pα + Φ = h + Φ is sometimes referred to as the dry static energy. However, it is not a component of the globally conserved total energy; the conserved energy contains only the quantity I + Φ plus the kinetic energy, and it is only the flux of static energy that affects the energetics. For an ideal gas we have σ = cv T + RT + Φ = cp T + Φ , and if the potential is caused by a uniform gravitational field then σ = cp T + gz. One other important point to note is that is it the divergent term, ∇ · v , that connects the kinetic energy equation, (1.182), and the internal energy equation, (1.183). In an incompressible fluid this term is absent, and the internal energy is divorced from the other components of energy. This consideration will be important when we consider the Boussinesq equations in section 2.4.
1.11 An Introduction to Non-Dimensionalization and Scaling
43
Bernoulli’s theorem For steady flow ∂ []/∂t = 0 and ∇ · ρv = 0 so that (1.186) may be written v · ∇B = 0 where B is the Bernoulli function given by 1 2 1 2 B= v + I + Φ + p/ρ = v +h+Φ , (1.188) 2 2 and h is the enthalpy. Thus, for steady flow only, DB = v · ∇B = 0, Dt
(1.189)
and the Bernoulli function is a constant along streamline; this result is commonly known as Bernoulli’s theorem.11 For an ideal gas in a constant gravitation field B = v 2 /2 + cp T + gz. For adiabatic flow we also have Dθ/Dt = 0. Thus, steady flow is both along surfaces of constant θ and along surfaces of constant B , and the vector
l = ∇θ × ∇B
(1.190)
is parallel to streamlines. A related result for unsteady flow is given in section 4.8.
1.10.3 Viscous effects We might expect that viscosity will always act to reduce the kinetic energy of a flow, and we will demonstrate this for a constant density fluid. Retaining the viscous term in (1.172), the energy equation becomes d d E ≡ dt dt
V
E dV = µ
V
v · ∇ 2 v dV .
(1.191)
The right-hand side is negative definite. To see this we use the vector identity
∇ × (∇ × v) = ∇(∇ · v) − ∇2 v,
(1.192)
and because ∇ · v = 0 we have ∇2 v = −∇ × ω, where ω ≡ ∇ × v . Thus, d E = −µ dt
V
v · (∇ × ω) dV = −µ
V
ω · (∇ × v) dV = −µ
ω2 d V ,
(1.193)
V
after integrating by parts, providing v × ω vanishes at the boundary. Thus, viscosity acts to extract kinetic energy from the flow. The loss of kinetic energy reappears as an irreversible warming of the fluid (‘Joule heating’), and the total energy of the fluid is conserved, but this effect plays no role in a constant density fluid. The effect is normally locally small, at least in the Earth’s oceans and atmosphere, although it is sometimes included in comprehensive General Circulation Models (GCMs).
1.11 AN INTRODUCTION TO NON-DIMENSIONALIZATION AND SCALING The units we use to measure length, velocity and so on are irrelevant to the dynamics, and not necessarily the most appropriate units for a given problem. Rather, it is convenient
44
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
to express the equations of motion, so far as is possible, in so-called ‘non-dimensional’ variables, by which we mean expressing every variable (such as velocity) as the ratio of its value to some reference value. For velocity the reference could, for example, be the speed of of light — but this would not be very helpful for fluid dynamical problems in the Earth’s atmosphere or oceans! Rather, we should choose the reference value as a natural one for a given flow, in order that, so far as possible, the non-dimensional variables are order-unity quantities, and doing this is called scaling the equations. Evidently, there is no reference velocity that is universally appropriate, and much of the art of fluid dynamics lies in choosing sensible scaling factors for the problem at hand. Non-dimensionalization plays an important role in fluid dynamics, and we introduce it here with a simple example.
1.11.1 The Reynolds number Consider the constant-density momentum equation in Cartesian coordinates. If a typical velocity is U , a typical length is L, a typical time scale is T , and a typical value of the pressure deviation is Φ , then the approximate sizes of the various terms in the momentum equation are given by
∂v + (v · ∇)v = −∇φ + ν∇2 v (1.194a) ∂t Φ U U U2 ∼ ν 2. (1.194b) T L L L The ratio of the inertial terms to the viscous terms is (U 2 /L) (νU/L2 ) = UL/ν , and this is the Reynolds number.12 More formally, we can non-dimensionalize the momentum equation by writing = v
v , U
= x
x , L
t =
t , T
= φ, φ Φ
(1.195)
where the terms with hats on are non-dimensional values of the variables and the capitalized quantities are known as scaling values, and these are the approximate magnitudes of the variables. We choose the non-dimensionalization so that the non-dimensional variables are of order unity. Thus, for example, we choose U so that u = O(U), where this should be taken to mean that the magnitude of the variable u is approximately U , or that u ∼ U , and we say that ‘u scales like U ’. [This O() notation differs from the conventional mathematical meaning of ‘order’, in which a = O( α ) represents a limit in which a/ α → constant as
→ 0.] Thus, if there are well-defined length and velocity scales in the problem, the non = O(1), and similarly for the other dimensional variables are of order unity; that is, u variables. Because there are no external forces in this problem, appropriate scaling values for time and pressure are L Φ = U 2. T = , (1.196) U Substituting (1.195) and (1.196) into the momentum equation we obtain
U2 L
∂v · ∇)v + (v ∂ t
=−
U 2 νU 2 ∇φ + 2 ∇ v, L L
(1.197)
Notes and Problems
45
where we use the convention that when ∇ operates on a non-dimensional variable it is a non-dimensional operator. Equation (1.197) simplifies to
∂v + 1 ∇2 v, · ∇)v = −∇φ + (v Re ∂t
(1.198)
where Re ≡
UL ν
(1.199)
is, again, the Reynolds number. If we have chosen our length and velocity scales sensibly — that is, if we have scaled them properly — each variable in (1.198) is order unity, with the viscous term being multiplied by the parameter 1/Re. There are two important conclusions: (i) The ratio of the importance of the inertial terms to the viscous terms is given by the Reynolds number, defined by (1.199). In the absence of other forces, such as those due to gravity and rotation, the Reynolds number is the only non-dimensional parameter explicitly appearing in the momentum equation. Hence its value, along with the boundary conditions, controls the behaviour of the system. (ii) More generally, by scaling the equations of motion appropriately the parameters determining the behaviour of the system become explicit. Scaling the equations is intelligent non-dimensionalization.
Notes 1 Joseph-Louis Lagrange (1736–1813) was a Franco-Italian, born and raised in Turin who then lived and worked mainly in Germany and France. He made notable contributions in analysis, number theory and mechanics and was recognized as one of the greatest mathematicians of the eighteenth century. He laid the foundations of the calculus of variations (to wit, the ‘Lagrange multiplier’) and first formulated the principle of least action, and his treatise Mécanique Analytique (1788) provides a unified analytic framework (it contains no diagrams, a feature emulated in Whittaker’s Treatise on Analytical Dynamics, 1927) for all Newtonian mechanics. Leonard Euler (1707–1783), a Swiss mathematician who lived and worked for extended periods in Berlin and St. Petersburg, made important contributions in many areas of mathematics and mechanics, including the analytical treatment of algebra, the theory of equations, calculus, number theory and classical mechanics. He was the first to establish the form of the equations of motion of fluid mechanics, writing down both the field description of fluids and what we now call the material or advective derivative. Truesdell (1954) points out that ‘Eulerian’ and ‘Lagrangian’, especially the latter, are inappropriate eponyms. The so-called Eulerian description was introduced by d’Alembert in 1749 and generalized by Euler in 1752, and the so-called Lagrangian description was introduced by Euler in 1759. The modern confusion evidently stems from a monograph by Dirichlet in 1860 that credits Euler in 1757 and Lagrange in 1788 for the respective methods. Clifford Truesdell (1919–2000) was a remarkable figure himself, known both for his own contributions to many areas of continuum mechanics and for his scholarly investigations on the history of mathematics and science; he also had a trenchant and at times pungent writing style. See Ball & James (2002) for more details.
46
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion 2 For example Batchelor (1967). 3 Rd and Rv are related by the molecular weights of water and dry air, Mv and Md , so that α ≡ Rd /Rv = Mv /Md = 0.62. Rather than allowing the gas constant to vary, meteorologists sometimes incorporate the variation of humidity into the definition of temperature, so that instead of p = ρReff T we use p = ρRd Tv , so defining the ‘virtual temperature’, Tv . It is easy to show that Tv ≈ [1 + w(α−1 − 1)]T . Atmospheric GCMs often use a virtual temperature. 4 The form of (1.60) was suggested by de Szoeke (2004). Accurate semi-empirical formulae are available from Mellor (1991), Jackett & McDougall (1995), Wright (1997) and (with particular attention to high accuracy) McDougall et al. (2002). The formulae of McDougall et al. are derived from the Gibbs function of Feistel & Hagen (1995); see Feistel (2003) for an updated version. The so-called ‘international equation of state of seawater’ (UNECSO 1981) is an empirical equation that fits measurements to an accuracy of order 10−5 (see Fofonoff 1985); however, it is hard to compute and the Feistel-Hagen formulation is as accurate, or more so, and more consistent. Wright’s formulae are used for Fig. 1.3 and Fig. 1.5. A formula of Bryden (1973) is used for Fig. 1.4. 5 For a development of thermodynamics from its fundamentals see, e.g., Callen (1985). 6 See Reif (1965) for more discussion. 7 Landau & Lifshitz (1987) have a longer discussion (their chapter 6), and also approach the energy equation in a different way. 8 Claude-Louis-Marie-Henri Navier (1785–1836) was a French civil engineer, professor at the École Polytechnique and later at the École des Ponts et Chaussée. He was a expert in road and bridge building (he developed the theory of suspension bridges) and, relatedly, made lasting theoretical contributions to the theory of elasticity, being the first to publish a set of general equations for the dynamics of an elastic solid. In fluid mechanics, he laid down the now-called Navier–Stokes equations, including the viscous terms, in 1822. George Gabriel Stokes (1819–1903). Irish born (in Skreen, County Sligo), he was a professor of mathematics at Cambridge from 1849 until his retirement. As well as having a role in the development of fluid mechanics, especially through his considerations of viscous effects, Stokes worked on the dynamics of elasticity, fluorescence, the wave theory of light, and was (rather ill-advisedly in hindsight) a proponent of the idea of an ether permeating all space. 9 Nevertheless, potential temperature and salinity are used as prognostic thermodynamic variables in many numerical ocean models. McDougall (2003) advocates using ‘potential enthalpy’ as a thermodynamic variable, because of its conservative properties and because it is a useful measure of heat content, suitably interpreted. 10 Drawing from de Szoeke (2004) and Young (2006). See also endnote 4 above. The accuracy of (1.147) with respect to saline variations could be further improved by adding small terms proportional to T S ln S and T S . 11 Bernoulli’s theorem was developed mainly by Daniel Bernoulli (1700–1782). It was based on earlier work on the conservation of energy that Daniel had done with his father, Johann Bernoulli (1667–1748), and so perhaps should be known as Bernoullis’ theorem. The two men fell out when Daniel was a young man, probably because of Johann’s jealousy of Daniel’s abilities, and subsequently had a very strained relationship. The Bernoulli family produced several (at least eight) talented mathematicians over three generations in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and is often regarded as the most mathematically distinguished family of all time. 12 Osborne Reynolds (1842–1912) was an Irish born (Belfast) physicist who was professor of
Notes and Problems
47
engineering at Manchester University from 1868–1905. His early work was in electricity and magnetism, but he is now most famous for his work in hydrodynamics. The ‘Reynolds number’, which determines the ratio of inertial to viscous forces, and the ‘Reynolds stress’, which is the stress on the mean flow due to the fluctuating components, are both named after him. He was also one of the first scientists to think about the concept of group velocity.
Further reading There are numerous books on hydrodynamics, some of them being: Lamb, H., 1932. Hydrodynamics, 6th edn. This is a classic text in the subject, although its notation is now too dated to make it really useful as an introduction. Another very well-known text is: Batchelor, G. K. 1967. An Introduction to Fluid Dynamics. Contains a very useful discussion of the fundamentals of fluid mechanics and a detailed derivation of the equations of motion. Two other useful references are: Tritton, D. J., 1988. Physical Fluid Dynamics, 2nd edn. Kundu, P. & Cohen, I.M. 2002. Fluid Mechanics. Both are introductions written at the advanced undergraduate/beginning graduate level, and are easier-going than Batchelor. Kundu and Cohen’s book has more material on geophysical fluid dynamics. There are also numerous books on thermodynamics, two clear and useful ones being: Reif, F., 1965. Fundamentals of Statistical and Thermal Physics, Callen, H. B., 1985. Thermodynamics and an Introduction to Thermostatistics. Reif’s book has become something of a classic, and Callen provides a rather more axiomatic approach. Thermodynamic effects in fluids are discussed by: Landau, L. D. & Lifshitz, E. M. 1987. Fluid Mechanics. Salmon, R., 1998. Lectures on Geophysical Fluid Dynamics. Salmon emphasizes the fundamentals, and Landau and Lifshitz provide a discussion of fluids with more than one component.
Problems It is by the solution of problems that the investigator tests the temper of his steel; he finds new methods and new outlooks, and gains a wider and freer horizon. David Hilbert (1862–1943), on presenting the Hilbert Problems.
1.1 For an infinitesimal volume, informally show that Dϕ D (ρϕ∆V ) = ρ∆V , Dt Dt
(P1.1)
where ϕ is some (differentiable) property of the fluid. Hence informally deduce that D Dt
V
ρϕ dV =
ρ V
Dϕ dV . Dt
(P1.2)
48
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion
1.2 Show that the derivative of an integral is given by d dt
x2 (t) x1 (t)
ϕ(x, t) dx =
x2 x1
∂ϕ d x2 d x1 ϕ(x2 , t) − ϕ(x1 , t). dx + ∂t dt dt
(P1.3)
By generalizing to three dimensions show that the material derivative of an integral of a fluid property is given by ∂ϕ ∂ϕ D + ∇ · (vϕ) dV , ϕ(x, t) dV = dV + ϕv · dS = (P1.4) Dt V ∂t V ∂t S V where the surface integral ( S ) is over the surface bounding the volume V . Hence deduce that D Dϕ ρϕ dV = ρ dV . (P1.5) Dt V Dt V 1.3 Why is there no diffusion term in the mass continuity equation? Suppose that a fluid contains a binary mixture of dry air and water vapour. Show that the change in mass of a parcel of air due to the diffusion of water vapour is exactly balanced by the diffusion of dry air in the opposite direction. 1.4 By invoking Galilean invariance we can often choose, without loss of generality, the basic state for problems in sound waves to be such that u0 ≡ 0. The perturbation velocity is then certainly larger than the basic state velocity. How can we then justify ignoring the nonlinear term in the perturbation equation, as the term u ∂ u /∂x is certainly no smaller than the linear term u0 ∂ u /∂x ? 1.5 What amplitude of sound wave is required for the nonlinear terms to become important? Is this achieved at a rock concert (120 dB), or near a jet aircraft that is taking off (160 dB)? 1.6 Using the observed value of molecular diffusion of heat in water, estimate how long it would take for a temperature anomaly to mix from the top of the ocean to the bottom, assuming that molecular diffusion alone is responsible. Comment on whether you think the real ocean has reached equilibrium after the last ice age (which ended about 12 000 years ago). 1.7 Consider the following flow:
u = Γ z, v = V sin[k(x − ct)] , where Γ , V , k and c are positive constants. (This is similar to the flow in the mid-latitude troposphere — an eastward flow increasing with height, with a transverse wave superimposed.) Suppose that Γ z > c for the region of interest. Consider particles located along the y = 0 axis at t = 0, and compute their position at some later time t . Compare this with the streamfunction for the flow at the same time. (Hint: show that the meridional particle displacement is η = ψ/(u − c), where ψ is the streamfunction and u and c are parameters.) 1.8 Consider the two-dimensional flow: u = A(y) sin ωt, v = A(y) cos ωt. The time-mean of this at a fixed point flow is zero. If A is independent of y , then fluid parcels move clockwise in a circle. What is its radius? If A does depend on y , find an approximate expression for the average drift of a particle, lim
t→∞
x(a, t) t
where a is a particle label and A is suitably ‘small’. Be precise about what small means. 1.9 (a) Suppose that a sealed, insulated container consists of two compartments, and that one of them is filled with an ideal gas and the other is a vacuum. The partition separating the compartments is removed. How does the temperature of the gas change? (Answer:
Notes and Problems
49
it stays the same. Explain.) Obtain an expression for the final potential temperature, in terms of the initial temperature of the gas and the volumes of the two compartments. Reconcile your answers with the first law of thermodynamics for an ideal gas, that dθ d–Q = T dη = cp = dI + d–W = cv dT + p dα. θ
(P1.6)
(b) A dry parcel that is ascending adiabatically through the atmosphere will generally cool as it moves to lower pressure and expands, and its potential temperature stays the same. How can this be consistent with your answer to part (a)? 1.10 Show that adiabatic flow in an ideal gas satisfies pρ −γ = constant, where γ = cp /cv . 1.11 (a) Show that for an ideal gas (1.116) is equivalent to (1.99). You may use the Maxwell relation (∂ α/∂η)p = (∂ T /∂p)η . (b) Show that for an ideal gas (1.127) is equivalent to (1.98). 1.12 Show that it follows directly from the equation of state, P = RT /α, that the internal energy of an ideal gas is a function of temperature only. Solution: from (1.87) and p = RT /α we have dη =
1 T
∂I ∂T
But, mathematically,
α
dT +
1 T
∂I ∂α
T
+
R dα. α
∂η ∂η dT + dα. ∂T α ∂α T Equating the coefficients of dT and dα in these two expressions gives R 1 ∂I 1 ∂I ∂η ∂η = and = + . ∂T α T ∂T α ∂α T T ∂α T α
(P1.7)
dη =
(P1.8)
(P1.9)
Noting that ∂ 2 η/(∂α∂T ) = ∂ 2 η/(∂T ∂α) we obtain
∂2I 1 ∂2I = − ∂α∂T ∂T ∂α T
∂I ∂α
.
(P1.10)
T
Thus, (∂ I/∂α)T = 0. Because, in general, the internal energy may be considered either a function of temperature and density or temperature and pressure, this proves that for an ideal gas the internal energy is a function only of temperature. 1.13 Show that it follows directly from the equation of state P = RT /α, that for an ideal gas the heat capacity at constant volume, cv , is, at most, a function of temperature. 1.14 Show that for an ideal gas
T dη = cv dT + p dα. (P1.11) and that its internal energy is given by I = cv dT . Solution: let us regard η as a function of T and α, where α is the specific volume 1/ρ . Then ∂η ∂η T dη = T dT + T dα ∂T α ∂α T ∂η = cv dT + T dα (P1.12) ∂α T by definition of cv . For an ideal gas the internal energy is a function of temperature alone (problem 1.12), so that using (1.70) the pressure of a fluid p = T (∂ η/∂α)I = T (∂ η/∂α)T and (P1.12) becomes T dη = cv dT + p dα (P1.13)
50
Chapter 1. Equations of Motion But, in general, the fundamental thermodynamic relation is
T dη = dI + p dα.
(P1.14)
The terms on the right-hand side of (P1.13) are identifiable as the change in the internal energy and the work done on a fluid, and so dI = cv dT . The heat capacity need not necessarily be constant, although for air it very nearly is, but it must be a function of temperature only. 1.15 (a) Beginning with the expression for potential temperature for a simple ideal gas, θ = T (pR /p)κ , where κ = R/cp , show that dθ = (θ/T )(dT − (α/cp ) dp),
(P1.15)
and that the first law of thermodynamics may be written as d–Q = T dη = cp (T /θ)dθ.
(P1.16)
(b) Verify that dη = cp (pR , θ)dθ/θ , for a fluid parcel of constant composition that obeys (1.147). 1.16 Obtain an expression for the Gibbs function of a simple ideal gas, in terms of pressure and temperature. 1.17 From (1.113) derive the conventional equation of state for an ideal gas, and obtain expressions for the heat capacities. 1.18 A parcel of water is added to the ocean surface that is denser than any water in the ocean. Suppose the parcel sinks adiabatically to the ocean bottom. Estimate the change in temperature that the parcel undergoes, being explicit about the assumptions you make. 1.19 Consider an ocean at rest with known vertical profiles of potential temperature and salinity, θ(z) and S(z). Suppose that we also know the equation of state in the form ρ = ρ(θ, S, p). Obtain an expression for the buoyancy frequency. Check your expression by substituting the equation of state for an ideal gas and recovering a known expression for the buoyancy frequency. 1.20 Consider a liquid, sitting in a container, with a free surface at the top (at z = H ). The liquid obeys the equation of state ρ = ρ0 [1 − βT (T − T0 )], and its internal energy, I , is given by I = cp T . Suppose that the fluid is heated, and its temperature rises uniformly by ∆T , and the free surface rises by a small amount ∆H . Obtain an expression for the ratio of the change in internal energy to the change in gravitational potential energy (GPE) of the ocean, and show that it is related to the scale height (1.131). If global warming increases the ocean temperature by 4 K, what is the ratio of the change of GPE to the change of I ? Estimate also the average rise in sea level due to thermal expansion. Partial solution: the change in internal energy and in GPE are
∆I = cp ρ1 H1 (T2 − T1 ),
∆GPE = ρ1 gH1 (H2 − H1 )/2 = ρ1 gH1 βT H1 (T2 − T1 )/2.
(P1.17)
(Derive these. Use mass conservation where necessary. The subscripts 1 and 2 denote initial and final states.) Hence ∆GPE/∆I = gβT H1 /2cp . 1.21 Obtain an expression, in terms of temperature and pressure, for the potential temperature of a van der Waals gas, with equation of state (p + a/α2 )(α − b) = RT , where a and b are constants. Show that it reduces to the expression for an ideal gas in the limit a → 0, b → 0.
If a body is moving in any direction, there is a force, arising from the Earth’s rotation, which always deflects it to the right in the northern hemisphere, and to the left in the southern. William Ferrel, The influence of the Earth’s rotation upon the relative motion of bodies near its surface, 1858.
CHAPTER
TWO
Effects of Rotation and Stratification
T
are shallow layers of fluid on a sphere in that their thickness or depth is much less than their horizontal extent. Furthermore, their motion is strongly influenced by two effects: rotation and stratification, the latter meaning that there is a mean vertical gradient of (potential) density that is often large compared with the horizontal gradient. Here we consider how the equations of motion are affected by these effects. First, we consider some elementary effects of rotation on a fluid and derive the Coriolis and centrifugal forces, and then we write down the equations of motion appropriate for motion on a sphere. Then we discuss some approximations to the equations of motion that are appropriate for large-scale flow in the ocean and atmosphere, in particular the hydrostatic and geostrophic approximations. Following this we discuss gravity waves, a particular kind of wave motion that is enabled by the presence of stratification, and finally we talk about how rotation leads to the production of certain types of boundary layers — Ekman layers — in rotating fluids. HE ATMOSPHERE AND OCEAN
2.1 THE EQUATIONS OF MOTION IN A ROTATING FRAME OF REFERENCE Newton’s second law of motion, that the acceleration on a body is proportional to the imposed force divided by the body’s mass, applies in so-called inertial frames of reference. The Earth rotates with a period of almost 24 hours (23h 56m) relative to the distant stars, and the surface of the Earth manifestly is not, in that sense, an inertial frame. Nevertheless, because the surface of the Earth is moving (in fact at speeds of up to a few hundreds of metres per second) it is very convenient to describe the flow relative to the Earth’s surface, rather than in some inertial frame. This necessitates recasting the equations into a form that is appropriate for a rotating frame of reference, and that is the subject of this section.
51
52
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
Ω
Fig. 2.1 A vector C rotating at an angular velocity Ω. It appears to be a constant vector in the rotating frame, whereas in the inertial frame it evolves according to (d C/dt )I = Ω×C .
Ω×C
C⊥ m
C ϑ λ
2.1.1 Rate of change of a vector Consider first a vector C of constant length rotating relative to an inertial frame at a constant angular velocity Ω. Then, in a frame rotating with that same angular velocity it appears stationary and constant. If in a small interval of time δt the vector C rotates through a small angle δλ then the change in C , as perceived in the inertial frame, is given by (see Fig. 2.1)
δC = |C| cos ϑ δλ m,
(2.1)
where the vector m is the unit vector in the direction of change of C , which is perpendicular to both C and Ω. But the rate of change of the angle λ is just, by definition, the angular velocity so that δλ = |Ω|δt and
m δt = Ω × C δt. δC = |C||Ω| sin ϑ
(2.2)
= (π/2 − ϑ) is the angle between using the definition of the vector cross product, where ϑ Ω and C . Thus dC = Ω × C, (2.3) dt I where the left-hand side is the rate of change of C as perceived in the inertial frame. Now consider a vector B that changes in the inertial frame. In a small time δt the change in B as seen in the rotating frame is related to the change seen in the inertial frame by (δB)I = (δB)R + (δB)rot ,
(2.4)
where the terms are, respectively, the change seen in the inertial frame, the change due to the vector itself changing as measured in the rotating frame, and the change due to the rotation. Using (2.2) (δB)rot = Ω × B δt , and so the rates of change of the vector B in the inertial and rotating frames are related by
dB dt
I
=
dB dt
R
+Ω×B .
(2.5)
2.1 Equations in a Rotating Frame
53
This relation applies to a vector B that, as measured at any one time, is the same in both inertial and rotating frames.
2.1.2 Velocity and acceleration in a rotating frame The velocity of a body is not measured to be the same in the inertial and rotating frames, so care must be taken when applying (2.5) to velocity. First apply (2.5) to r , the position of a particle to obtain dr dr = +Ω×r (2.6) dt I dt R or
vI = vR + Ω × r.
(2.7)
We refer to vR and vI as the relative and inertial velocity, respectively, and (2.7) relates the two. Apply (2.5) again, this time to the velocity vR to give
or, using (2.7)
or
d vI dt
Then, noting that
=
I
d (vI − Ω × r) dt
I
d vR dt
=
dr dt
d vR dt
I
I
R
=
=
R
+ Ω × vR +
dr dt
+ Ω × vR ,
dvR dt
dvR dt
(2.8)
R
+ Ω × vR ,
dΩ ×r +Ω× dt
(2.9)
dr dt
.
(2.10)
I
R
+ Ω × r = (vR + Ω × r),
(2.11)
and assuming that the rate of rotation is constant, (2.10) becomes
d vR dt
R
=
dvI dt
I
− 2Ω × vR − Ω × (Ω × r).
(2.12)
This equation may be interpreted as follows. The term on the left-hand side is the rate of change of the relative velocity as measured in the rotating frame. The first term on the right-hand side is the rate of change of the inertial velocity as measured in the inertial frame (or, loosely, the inertial acceleration). Thus, by Newton’s second law, it is equal to the force on a fluid parcel divided by its mass. The second and third terms on the right-hand side (including the minus signs) are the Coriolis force and the centrifugal force per unit mass. Neither of these are true forces — they may be thought of as quasi-forces (i.e., ‘as if’ forces); that is, when a body is observed from a rotating frame it seems to behave as if unseen forces are present that affect its motion. If (2.12) is written, as is common, with the terms +2Ω × vr and +Ω × (Ω × r) on the left-hand side then these terms should be referred to as the Coriolis and centrifugal accelerations.1
54
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
Centrifugal force If r⊥ is the perpendicular distance from the axis of rotation (see Fig. 2.1 and substitute r for C ), then, because Ω is perpendicular to r⊥ , Ω × r = Ω × r⊥ . Then, using the vector identity Ω × (Ω × r⊥ ) = (Ω · r⊥ )Ω − (Ω · Ω)r⊥ and noting that the first term is zero, we see that the centrifugal force per unit mass is just given by
Fce = −Ω × (Ω × r) = Ω 2 r⊥ .
(2.13)
This may usefully be written as the gradient of a scalar potential,
Fce = −∇Φce .
(2.14)
where Φce = −(Ω 2 r⊥2 )/2 = −(Ω × r⊥ )2 /2. Coriolis force The Coriolis force per unit mass is:
FCo = −2Ω × vR .
(2.15)
It plays a central role in much of geophysical fluid dynamics and will be considered extensively later on. For now, we just note three basic properties. (i) There is no Coriolis force on bodies that are stationary in the rotating frame. (ii) The Coriolis force acts to deflect moving bodies at right angles to their direction of travel. (iii) The Coriolis force does no work on a body because it is perpendicular to the velocity, and so vR · (Ω × vR ) = 0.
2.1.3 Momentum equation in a rotating frame Since (2.12) simply relates the accelerations of a particle in the inertial and rotating frames, then in the rotating frame of reference the momentum equation may be written Dv 1 + 2Ω × v = − ∇p − ∇Φ, Dt ρ
(2.16)
incorporating the centrifugal term into the potential, Φ . We have dropped the subscript R ; henceforth, unless we need to be explicit, all velocities without a subscript will be considered to be relative to the rotating frame.
2.1.4 Mass and tracer conservation in a rotating frame Let φ be a scalar field that, in the inertial frame, obeys Dφ + φ∇ · vI = 0. Dt
(2.17)
Now, observers in both the rotating and inertial frame measure the same value of φ. Further, Dφ/Dt is simply the rate of change of φ associated with a material parcel, and therefore is reference frame invariant. Thus, Dφ Dφ = , (2.18) Dt R Dt I
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates
55
where (Dφ/Dt)R = (∂ φ/∂t )R + vR · ∇φ and (Dφ/Dt)I = (∂ φ/∂t )I + vI · ∇φ and the local temporal derivatives (∂ φ/∂t )R and (∂ φ/∂t )I are evaluated at fixed locations in the rotating and inertial frames, respectively. Further, since v = vI − Ω × r , we have that
∇ · vI = ∇ · (vI − Ω × r) = ∇ · vR
(2.19)
since ∇ · (Ω × r) = 0. Thus, using (2.18) and (2.19), (2.17) is equivalent to Dφ + φ∇ · v = 0, Dt
(2.20)
where all observables are measured in the rotating frame. Thus, the equation for the evolution of a scalar whose measured value is the same in rotating and inertial frames is unaltered by the presence of rotation. In particular, the mass conservation equation is unaltered by the presence of rotation. Although we have taken (2.18) as true a priori, the individual components of the material derivative differ in the rotating and inertial frames. In particular ∂φ ∂φ = − (Ω × r) · ∇φ (2.21) ∂t I ∂t R because Ω × r is the velocity, in the inertial frame, of a uniformly rotating body. Similarly,
vI · ∇φ = (vR + Ω × r) · ∇φ.
(2.22)
Adding the last two equations reprises and confirms (2.18).
2.2 EQUATIONS OF MOTION IN SPHERICAL COORDINATES The Earth is very nearly spherical and it might appear obvious that we should cast our equations in spherical coordinates. Although this does turn out to be true, the presence of a centrifugal force causes some complications which we must first discuss. The reader who is willing ab initio to treat the Earth as a perfect sphere and to neglect the horizontal component of the centrifugal force may skip the next section.
2.2.1 * The centrifugal force and spherical coordinates The centrifugal force is a potential force, like gravity, and so we may therefore define an ‘effective gravity’ equal to the sum of the true, or Newtonian, gravity and the centrifugal force. The Newtonian gravitational force is directed approximately toward the centre of the Earth, with small deviations due mainly to the Earth’s oblateness. The line of action of the effective gravity will in general differ slightly from this, and therefore have a component in the ‘horizontal’ plane, that is the plane perpendicular to the radial direction. The magnitude of the centrifugal force is Ω 2 r⊥ , and so the effective gravity is given by
g ≡ geff = ggrav + Ω 2 r⊥ ,
(2.23)
where ggrav is the Newtonian gravitational force due to the gravitational attraction of the Earth and r⊥ is normal to the rotation vector (in the direction C in Fig. 2.2), with r⊥ = r cos ϑ.
56
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
ghoriz ≠ 0
g
g ghoriz = 0
Fig. 2.2 Left: directions of forces and coordinates in true spherical geometry. g is the effective gravity (including the centrifugal force, C ) and its horizontal component is evidently non-zero. Right: a modified coordinate system, in which the vertical direction is defined by the direction of g , and so the horizontal component of g is identically zero. The dashed line schematically indicates a surface of constant geopotential. The differences between the direction of g and the direction of the radial coordinate, and between the sphere and the geopotential surface, are much exaggerated and in reality are similar to the thickness of the lines themselves.
Both gravity and centrifugal force are potential forces and therefore we may define the geopotential, Φ , such that g = −∇Φ. (2.24) Surfaces of constant Φ are not quite spherical because r⊥ , and hence the centrifugal force, vary with latitude (Fig. 2.2); this has certain ramifications, as we now discuss. The components of the centrifugal force parallel and perpendicular to the radial direction are Ω 2 r cos2 ϑ and Ω 2 r cos ϑ sin ϑ. Newtonian gravity is much larger than either of these, and at the Earth’s surface the ratio of centrifugal to gravitational terms is approximately, and no more than,
α≈
(7.27 × 10−5 )2 × 6.4 × 106 Ω2a ≈ ≈ 3 × 10−3 . g 10
(2.25)
(Note that at the equator and pole the horizontal component of the centrifugal force is zero and the effective gravity is aligned with Newtonian gravity.) The angle between g and the line to the centre of the Earth is given by a similar expression and so is also small, typically around 3×10−3 radians. However, the horizontal component of the centrifugal force is still large compared to the Coriolis force, their ratio in mid-latitudes being given by
Ωa Ω 2 a cos ϑ sin ϑ horizontal centrifugal force ≈ ≈ 10, ≈ Coriolis force 2Ωu 4|u|
(2.26)
using u = 10 m s−1 . The centrifugal term therefore dominates over the Coriolis term, and
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates
57
is largely balanced by a pressure gradient force. Thus, if we adhered to true spherical coordinates, both the horizontal and radial components of the momentum equation would be dominated by a static balance between a pressure gradient and gravity or centrifugal terms. Although in principle there is nothing wrong with writing the equations this way, it obscures the dynamical balances involving the Coriolis force and pressure that determine the large-scale horizontal flow. A way around this problem is to use the direction of the geopotential force to define the vertical direction, and then for all geometric purposes to regard the surfaces of constant Φ as if they were true spheres.2 The horizontal component of effective gravity is then identically zero, and we have traded a potentially large dynamical error for a very small geometric error. In fact, over time, the Earth has developed an equatorial bulge to compensate for and neutralize the centrifugal force, so that the effective gravity does act in a direction virtually normal to the Earth’s surface; that is, the surface of the Earth is an oblate spheroid of nearly constant geopotential. The geopotential Φ is then a function of the vertical coordinate alone, and for many purposes we can just take Φ = gz; that is, the direction normal to geopotential surfaces, the local vertical, is, in this approximation, taken to be the direction of increasing r in spherical coordinates. It is because the oblateness is very small (the polar diameter is about 12 714 km, whereas the equatorial diameter is about 12 756 km) that using spherical coordinates is a very accurate way to map the spheroid, and if the angle between effective gravity and a natural direction of the coordinate system were not small then more heroic measures would be called for. If the solid Earth did not bulge at the equator, the behaviour of the atmosphere and ocean would differ significantly from that of the present system. For example, the surface of the ocean is nearly a geopotential surface, and if the solid Earth were exactly spherical then the ocean would perforce become much deeper at low latitudes and the ocean basins would dry out completely at high latitudes. We could still choose to use the spherical coordinate system discussed above to describe the dynamics, but the shape of the surface of the solid Earth would have to be represented by a topography, with the topographic height increasing monotonically polewards nearly everywhere.
2.2.2 Some identities in spherical coordinates The location of a point is given by the coordinates (λ, ϑ, r ) where λ is the angular distance eastwards (i.e., longitude), ϑ is angular distance polewards (i.e., latitude) and r is the radial distance from the centre of the Earth — see Fig. 2.3. (In some other fields of study co-latitude is used as a spherical coordinate.) If a is the radius of the Earth, then we also define z = r − a. At a given location we may also define the Cartesian increments (δx, δy, δz) = (r cos ϑδλ, r δϑ, δr ). For a scalar quantity φ the material derivative in spherical coordinates is
∂φ u v ∂φ ∂φ ∂φ Dφ = + + +w , Dt ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r ∂ϑ ∂r
(2.27)
where the velocity components corresponding to the coordinates (λ, ϑ, r ) are
Dλ Dϑ Dr ,r , (u, v, w) ≡ r cos ϑ . Dt Dt Dt
(2.28)
58
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
Fig. 2.3 The spherical coordinate system. The orthogonal unit vectors i, j and k point in the direction of increasing longitude λ, latitude ϑ, and altitude z. Locally, one may apply a Cartesian system with variables x , y and z measuring distances along i, j and k.
That is, u is the zonal velocity, v is the meridional velocity and w is the vertical velocity. If we define (i, j, k) to be the unit vectors in the direction of increasing (λ, ϑ, r ) then
v = iu + jv + kw.
(2.29)
Note also that Dr /Dt = Dz/Dt . The divergence of a vector B = i B λ + j B ϑ + k B r is
∇·B=
1 cos ϑ
1 ∂ Bλ 1 ∂ cos ϑ ∂ 2 r + (B ϑ cos ϑ) + (r B ) . r ∂λ r ∂ϑ r 2 ∂r
(2.30)
The vector gradient of a scalar is:
∇φ = i
∂φ ∂φ 1 1 ∂φ +j +k . r cos ϑ ∂λ r ∂ϑ ∂r
(2.31)
The Laplacian of a scalar is:
∇2 φ ≡ ∇ · ∇φ =
1 r 2 cos ϑ
∂ 1 ∂2φ + cos ϑ ∂λ2 ∂ϑ
∂φ ∂ ∂φ cos ϑ + cos ϑ r2 . ∂ϑ ∂r ∂r
(2.32)
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates The curl of a vector is: 1 curl B = ∇ × B = 2 r cos ϑ
i r cos ϑ ∂ /∂λ λ B r cos ϑ
59
jr ∂ /∂ϑ Bϑ r
k ∂ /∂r Br
.
(2.33)
The vector Laplacian ∇2 B (used for example when calculating viscous terms in the momentum equation) may be obtained from the vector identity:
∇2 B = ∇(∇ · B) − ∇ × (∇ × B).
(2.34)
Only in Cartesian coordinates does this take the simple form:
∇2 B =
∂2B ∂2B ∂2B + + . 2 2 ∂x ∂y ∂z2
(2.35)
The expansion in spherical coordinates is, to most eyes, rather uninformative. Rate of change of unit vectors In spherical coordinates the defining unit vectors are i, the unit vector pointing eastwards, parallel to a line of latitude; j is the unit vector pointing polewards, parallel to a meridian; and k, the unit vector pointing radially outward. The directions of these vectors change with location, and in fact this is the case in nearly all coordinate systems, with the notable exception of the Cartesian one, and thus their material derivative is not zero. One way to evaluate this is to consider geometrically how the coordinate axes change with position. Another way, and the way that we shall proceed, is to first obtain the effective rotation rate Ωflow , relative to the Earth, of a unit vector as it moves with the flow, and then apply (2.3). Specifically, let the fluid velocity be v = (u, v, w). The meridional component, v , produces a displacement r δϑ = vδt , and this gives rise a local effective vector rotation rate around the local zonal axis of −(v/r )i, the minus sign arising because a displacement in the direction of the north pole is produced by negative rotational displacement around the i axis. Similarly, the zonal component, u, produces a displacement δλr cos ϑ = uδt and so an effective rotation rate, about the Earth’s rotation axis, of u/(r cos ϑ). Now, a rotation around the Earth’s rotation axis may be written as (see Fig. 2.4)
Ω = Ω(j cos ϑ + k sin ϑ).
(2.36)
If the scalar rotation rate is not Ω but is u/(r cos ϑ), then the vector rotation rate is
u u u tan ϑ (j cos ϑ + k sin ϑ) = j + k . r cos ϑ r r
(2.37)
Thus, the total rotation rate of a vector that moves with the flow is
Ωflow = −i
v u u tan ϑ +j +k . r r r
(2.38)
Applying (2.3) to (2.38), we find Di u = Ωflow × i = (j sin ϑ − k cos ϑ), Dt r cos ϑ Dj u v = Ωflow × j = −i tan ϑ − k , Dt r r Dk u v = Ωflow × k = i + j . Dt r r
(2.39a) (2.39b) (2.39c)
60
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
(a)
Ω
Ωy
Ωz
(b)
Ω = Ωz k
k k
Fig. 2.4 (a) On the sphere the rotation vector Ω can be decomposed into two components, one in the local vertical and one in the local horizontal, pointing toward the pole. That is, Ω = Ωy j + Ωz k where Ωy = Ω cos ϑ and Ωz = Ω sin ϑ. In geophysical fluid dynamics, the rotation vector in the local vertical is often the more important component in the horizontal momentum equations. On a rotating disk, (b), the rotation vector Ω is parallel to the local vertical k.
2.2.3 Equations of motion Mass Conservation and Thermodynamic Equation The mass conservation equation, (1.36a), expanded in spherical co-odinates, is
u v ∂ρ ∂ρ ∂ρ ∂ρ + + +w ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r ∂ϑ ∂r ∂ 1 ∂ ∂u ρ + (v cos ϑ) + (wr 2 cos ϑ) = 0. + r cos ϑ ∂λ ∂ϑ r ∂r
(2.40)
Equivalently, using the form (1.36b), this is
∂ρ 1 1 1 ∂ ∂ (uρ) ∂ + + (vρ cos ϑ) + 2 (r 2 wρ) = 0. ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r cos ϑ ∂ϑ r ∂r
(2.41)
The thermodynamic equation, (1.108), is a tracer advection equation. Thus, using (2.27), its (adiabatic) spherical coordinate form is Dθ ∂θ u v ∂θ ∂θ ∂θ = + + +w = 0, Dt ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r ∂ϑ ∂r
(2.42)
and similarly for tracers such as water vapour or salt. Momentum Equation Recall that the inviscid momentum equation is: Dv 1 + 2Ω × v = − ∇p − ∇Φ, Dt ρ
(2.43)
where Φ is the geopotential. In spherical coordinates the directions of the coordinate axes change with position and so the component expansion of (2.43) is Du Dv Dw Di Dj Dk Dv = +v +w i+ j+ k+u Dt Dt Dt Dt Dt Dt Dt
(2.44a)
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates
=
Du Dv Dw i+ j+ k + Ωflow × v, Dt Dt Dt
61 (2.44b)
using (2.39). Using either (2.44a) and the expressions for the rates of change of the unit vectors given in (2.39), or (2.44b) and the expression for Ωflow given in (2.38), (2.44) becomes
Du Dv uv tan ϑ uw u2 tan ϑ vw Dv =i − + +j + + Dt Dt r r Dt r r
(2.45) 2 2 Dw u +v +k − . Dt r Using the definition of a 2Ω × v =
vector cross product the Coriolis term is: i j k 0 2Ω cos ϑ 2Ω sin ϑ u v w
= i (2Ωw cos ϑ − 2Ωv sin ϑ) + j 2Ωu sin ϑ − k 2Ωu cos ϑ.
(2.46)
Using (2.45) and (2.46), and the gradient operator given by (2.31), the momentum equation (2.43) becomes: u 1 ∂p Du − 2Ω + , (2.47a) (v sin ϑ − w cos ϑ) = − Dt r cos ϑ ρr cos ϑ ∂λ wv u 1 ∂p Dv + + 2Ω + , (2.47b) u sin ϑ = − Dt r r cos ϑ ρr ∂ϑ Dw 1 ∂p u2 + v 2 − − 2Ωu cos ϑ = − − g. Dt r ρ ∂r
(2.47c)
The terms involving Ω are called Coriolis terms, and the quadratic terms on the left-hand sides involving 1/r are often called metric terms.
2.2.4 The primitive equations The so-called primitive equations of motion are simplifications of the above equations frequently used in atmospheric and oceanic modelling.3 Three related approximations are involved. (i) The hydrostatic approximation. In the vertical momentum equation the gravitational term is assumed to be balanced by the pressure gradient term, so that
∂p = −ρg. ∂z
(2.48)
The advection of vertical velocity, the Coriolis terms, and the metric term (u2 + v 2 )/r are all neglected. (ii) The shallow-fluid approximation. We write r = a + z where the constant a is the radius of the Earth and z increases in the radial direction. The coordinate r is then replaced by a except where it used as the differentiating argument. Thus, for example, 1 ∂ (r 2 w) ∂w → . r2 ∂r ∂z
(2.49)
62
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
(iii) The traditional approximation. Coriolis terms in the horizontal momentum equations involving the vertical velocity, and the still smaller metric terms uw/r and vw/r , are neglected. The second and third of these approximations should be taken, or not, together, the underlying reason being that they both relate to the presumed small aspect ratio of the motion, so the approximations succeed or fail together. If we make one approximation but not the other then we are being asymptotically inconsistent, and angular momentum and energy conservation are not assured (see section 2.2.7 and problem 2.13). The hydrostatic approximation also depends on the small aspect ratio of the flow, but in a slightly different way. For large-scale flow in the terrestrial atmosphere and ocean all three approximations are in fact all very accurate approximations. We defer a more complete treatment until section 2.7, in part because a treatment of the hydrostatic approximation is done most easily in the context of the Boussinesq equations, derived in section 2.4. Making these approximations, the momentum equations become
uv 1 ∂p Du − 2Ω sin ϑv − , tan ϑ = − Dt a aρ cos ϑ ∂λ Dv 1 ∂p u2 tan ϑ + 2Ω sin ϑu + =− , Dt a ρa ∂ϑ 1 ∂p − g, 0=− ρ ∂z where D = Dt
∂ u ∂ v ∂ ∂ + + +w ∂t a cos ϑ ∂λ a ∂ϑ ∂z
(2.50a) (2.50b) (2.50c)
.
(2.51)
We note the ubiquity of the factor 2Ω sin ϑ, and take the opportunity to define the Coriolis parameter, f ≡ 2Ω sin ϑ. The corresponding mass conservation equation for a shallow fluid layer is:
u v ∂ρ ∂ρ ∂ρ ∂ρ + + +w ∂t a cos ϑ ∂λ a ∂ϑ ∂z ∂w 1 1 ∂u ∂ +ρ + = 0, (v cos ϑ) + a cos ϑ ∂λ a cos ϑ ∂ϑ ∂z
(2.52)
∂ρ 1 1 ∂ (uρ) ∂ ∂ (wρ) + + (vρ cos ϑ) + = 0. ∂t a cos ϑ ∂λ a cos ϑ ∂ϑ ∂z
(2.53)
or equivalently,
2.2.5 Primitive equations in vector form The primitive equations may be written in a compact vector form provided we make a slight reinterpretation of the material derivative of the coordinate axes. Let u = ui + v j + 0 k be the horizontal velocity. The primitive equations (2.50a) and (2.50b) may be written as 1 Du + f × u = − ∇z p, Dt ρ
(2.54)
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates
63
where f = f k = 2Ω sin ϑk and ∇z p = [(a cos ϑ)−1 ∂ p/∂λ, a−1 ∂ p/∂ϑ], the gradient operator at constant z. In (2.54) the material derivative of the horizontal velocity is given by Di Dj Du Dv Du (2.55) =i +j +u +v , Dt Dt Dt Dt Dt where instead of (2.39) we have Di flow × i = j u tan ϑ , =Ω Dt a Dj u flow × j = −i tan ϑ , =Ω Dt a
(2.56a) (2.56b)
flow = ku tan ϑ/a [which is the vertical component of (2.38), with r replaced by a.]. where Ω The advection of the horizontal wind u is still by the three-dimensional velocity v . The vertical momentum equation is the hydrostatic equation, (2.50c), and the mass conservation equation is ∂ρ Dρ + ρ∇ · v = 0 + ∇ · (ρv) = 0, or (2.57) Dt ∂t where D/Dt on a scalar is given by (2.51), and the second expression is written out in full in (2.53).
2.2.6 The vector invariant form of the momentum equation The ‘vector invariant’ form of the momentum equation is so-called because it appears to take the same form in all coordinate systems — there is no advective derivative of the coordinate system to worry about. With the aid of the identity (v · ∇)v = −v × ω + ∇(v 2 /2), where ω ≡ ∇ × v is the relative vorticity, the three-dimensional momentum equation may be written: ∂v 1 1 + (2Ω + ω) × v = − ∇p − ∇v 2 + g. (2.58) ∂t ρ 2 In spherical coordinates the relative vorticity is given by: i r cos ϑ jr k 1 ∂ /∂ϑ ∂ /∂r ∂ /∂λ ω = ∇×v = 2 r cos ϑ ur cos ϑ rv w ∂ (r v) ∂w 1 ∂w 1 − −j =i r ∂ϑ ∂r r cos ϑ ∂λ ∂v ∂ 1 − (u cos ϑ) . +k r cos ϑ ∂λ ∂ϑ
∂ − (ur cos ϑ) ∂r
(2.59)
Making the traditional and shallow fluid approximations, the horizontal components of (2.58) may be written
∂u 1 1 ∂u + (f + kζ) × u + w = − ∇z p − ∇u2 , ∂t ∂z ρ 2
(2.60)
where u = (u, v, 0), f = k 2Ω sin ϑ, ∇z is the horizontal gradient operator (the gradient at a constant value of z), and using (2.59), ζ is given by
ζ=
u 1 1 1 1 ∂u ∂v ∂ ∂v − (u cos ϑ) = − + tan ϑ. a cos ϑ ∂λ a cos ϑ ∂ϑ a cos ϑ ∂λ a ∂ϑ a
(2.61)
64
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
The separate components of the momentum equation are given by:
∂u ∂u 1 1 ∂p 1 ∂ u2 − (f + ζ)v + w =− + , ∂t ∂z aρ cos ϑ ρ ∂λ 2 ∂λ and
∂v 1 ∂v + (f + ζ)u + w =− ∂t ∂z a
1 ∂p 1 ∂ u2 + ρ ∂ϑ 2 ∂ϑ
(2.62)
.
(2.63)
Related expressions are given in problem 2.3, and we treat vorticity at greater length in chapter 4.
2.2.7 Angular momentum The zonal momentum equation can be usefully expressed as a statement about axial angular momentum; that is, angular momentum about the rotation axis. The zonal angular momentum per unit mass is the component of angular momentum in the direction of the axis of rotation and it is given by, without making any shallow atmosphere approximation,
m = (u + Ωr cos ϑ)r cos ϑ.
(2.64)
The evolution equation for this quantity follows from the zonal momentum equation and has the simple form 1 ∂p Dm (2.65) =− , Dt ρ ∂λ where the material derivative is
∂ u v ∂ ∂ ∂ D = + + +w . Dt ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r ∂ϑ ∂r
(2.66)
Using the mass continuity equation, (2.65) can be written as
∂p Dρm + ρm∇ · v = − Dt ∂λ
(2.67)
or
∂p ∂ ∂ ρm 1 1 ∂ (ρum) ∂ + + (ρvm cos ϑ) + (ρmw) = − . ∂t r cos ϑ ∂λ r cos ϑ ∂ϑ ∂z ∂λ
(2.68)
This is an angular momentum conservation equation. If the fluid is confined to a shallow layer near the surface of a sphere, then we may replace r , the radial coordinate, by a, the radius of the sphere, in the definition of m, and ≡ (u + Ωa cos ϑ)a cos ϑ. Then (2.65) is replaced by we define m
1 ∂p Dm =− , Dt ρ ∂λ
(2.69)
where now
D ∂ u v ∂ ∂ ∂ = + + +w . Dt ∂t a cos ϑ ∂λ a ∂ϑ ∂z Using mass continuity, (2.69) may be written as
∂ ρm 1 ∂p u v ∂m ∂m ∂m + + +w =− , ∂t a cos ϑ ∂λ a ∂ϑ ∂z ρ ∂λ
(2.70)
(2.71)
which is the appropriate angular momentum conservation equation for a shallow atmosphere.
2.2 Equations of Motion in Spherical Coordinates
65
* From angular momentum to the spherical component equations An alternative way of deriving the three components of the momentum equation in spherical polar coordinates is to begin with (2.65) and the principle of conservation of energy. That is, we take the equations for conservation of angular momentum and energy as true a priori and demand that the forms of the momentum equation be constructed to satisfy these. Expanding the material derivative in (2.65), noting that Dr /Dt = w and Dcos ϑ/Dt = −(v/r ) sin ϑ, immediately gives (2.47a). Multiplication by u then yields
u
Du u2 w u ∂p u2 v tan ϑ − 2Ωuv sin ϑ + 2Ωuw cos ϑ − + =− . Dt r r ρr cos ϑ ∂λ
(2.72)
Now suppose that the meridional and vertical momentum equations are of the form 1 ∂p Dv + Coriolis and metric terms = − Dt ρr ∂ϑ 1 ∂p Dw + Coriolis and metric terms = − , Dt ρ ∂r
(2.73a) (2.73b)
but that we do not know what form the Coriolis and metric terms take. To determine that form, construct the kinetic energy equation by multiplying (2.73) by v and w , respectively. Now, the metric terms must vanish when we sum the resulting equations along with (2.72), so that (2.73a) must contain the Coriolis term 2Ωu sin ϑ as well as the metric term u2 tan ϑ/r , and (2.73b) must contain the term −2Ωu cos φ as well as the metric term u2 /r . But if (2.73b) contains the term u2 /r it must also contain the term v 2 /r by isotropy, and therefore (2.73a) must also contain the term vw/r . In this way, (2.47) is precisely reproduced, although the sceptic might argue that the uniqueness of the form has not been demonstrated. A particular advantage of this approach arises in determining the appropriate momentum equations that conserve angular momentum and energy in the shallow-fluid approximation. We begin with (2.69) and expand to obtain (2.50a). Multiplying by u gives
u
u2 v tan ϑ Du u ∂p − 2Ωuv sin ϑ − =− . Dt a ρa cos ϑ ∂λ
(2.74)
To ensure energy conservation, the meridional momentum equation must contain the Coriolis term 2Ωu sin ϑ and the metric term u2 tan ϑ/a, but the vertical momentum equation must have neither of the metric terms appearing in (2.47c). Thus we deduce the following equations:
u tan ϑ 1 ∂p Du − 2Ω sin ϑ + , v=− Dt a ρa cos ϑ ∂λ u tan ϑ 1 ∂p Dv + 2Ω sin ϑ + , u=− Dt a ρa ∂ϑ 1 ∂ρ Dw =− − g. Dt ρ ∂r
(2.75a) (2.75b) (2.75c)
This equation set, when used in conjunction with the thermodynamic and mass continuity equations, conserves appropriate forms of angular momentum and energy. In the hydrostatic approximation the material derivative of w in (2.75c) is additionally neglected. Thus, the hydrostatic approximation is mathematically and physically consistent with the shallow-fluid
66
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
approximation, but it is an additional approximation with slightly different requirements that one may choose, rather than being required, to make. From an asymptotic perspective, the difference lies in the small parameter necessary for either approximation to hold, namely:
shallow fluid and traditional approximations: small aspect ratio for hydrostatic approximation:
H 1, a H 1, α≡ L γ≡
(2.76a) (2.76b)
where L is the horizontal scale of the motion and a is the radius of the Earth. For hemispheric or global scale phenomena L ∼ a and the two approximations coincide. (Requirement (2.76b) for the hydrostatic approximation is derived in section 2.7.)
2.3 CARTESIAN APPROXIMATIONS: THE TANGENT PLANE 2.3.1 The f-plane Although the rotation of the Earth is central for many dynamical phenomena, the sphericity of the Earth is not always so. This is especially true for phenomena on a scale somewhat smaller than global where the use of spherical coordinates becomes awkward, and it is more convenient to use a locally Cartesian representation of the equations. Referring to Fig. 2.4 we will define a plane tangent to the surface of the Earth at a latitude ϑ0 , and then use a Cartesian coordinate system (x, y, z) to describe motion on that plane. For small excursions on the plane, (x, y, z) ≈ (aλ cos ϑ0 , a(ϑ − ϑ0 ), z). Consistently, the velocity is v = (u, v, w), so that u,v and w are the components of the velocity in the tangent plane, in approximately in the east–west, north–south and vertical directions, respectively. The momentum equations for flow in this plane are then
∂u 1 + (v · ∇)u + 2(Ω y w − Ω z v) = − ∂t ρ ∂v 1 + (v · ∇)v + 2(Ω z u − Ω x w) = − ∂t ρ ∂w 1 + (v · ∇)w + 2(Ω x v − Ω y u) = − ∂t ρ
∂p , ∂x ∂p , ∂y ∂p − g, ∂z
(2.77a) (2.77b) (2.77c)
where the rotation vector Ω = Ω x i + Ω y j + Ω z k and Ω x = 0, Ω y = Ω cos ϑ0 and Ω z = Ω sin ϑ0 . If we make the traditional approximation, and so ignore the components of Ω not in the direction of the local vertical, then 1 Du − f0 v = − Dt ρ 1 Dv + f0 u = − Dt ρ Dw 1 =− Dt ρ
∂p , ∂x ∂p , ∂y ∂p − g. ∂z
(2.78a) (2.78b) (2.78c)
where f0 = 2Ω z = 2Ω sin ϑ0 . Defining the horizontal velocity vector u = (u, v, 0), the first two equations may also be written as 1 Du + f0 × u = − ∇z p, Dt ρ
(2.79)
2.4 The Boussinesq Approximation
67
where Du/Dt = ∂ u/∂t + v · ∇u, f0 = 2Ω sin ϑ0 k = f0 k, and k is the direction perpendicular to the plane (it does not change its orientation with latitude). These equations are, evidently, exactly the same as the momentum equations in a system in which the rotation vector is aligned with the local vertical, as illustrated in the right-hand panel in Fig. 2.4 (on page 60). They will describe flow on the surface of a rotating sphere to a good approximation provided the flow is of limited latitudinal extent so that the effects of sphericity are unimportant; we have made what is known as the f -plane approximation since the Coriolis parameter is a constant. We may in addition make the hydrostatic approximation, in which case (2.78c) becomes the familiar ∂ p/∂z = −ρg .
2.3.2 The beta-plane approximation The magnitude of the vertical component of rotation varies with latitude, and this has important dynamical consequences. We can approximate this effect by allowing the effective rotation vector to vary. Thus, noting that, for small variations in latitude,
f = 2Ω sin ϑ ≈ 2Ω sin ϑ0 + 2Ω(ϑ − ϑ0 ) cos ϑ0 ,
(2.80)
then on the tangent plane we may mimic this by allowing the Coriolis parameter to vary as
f = f0 + βy ,
(2.81)
where f0 = 2Ω sin ϑ0 and β = ∂ f /∂y = (2Ω cos ϑ0 )/a. This important approximation is known as the beta-plane, or β-plane, approximation; it captures the the most important dynamical effects of sphericity, without the complicating geometric effects, which are not essential to describe many phenomena. The momentum equations (2.78) are unaltered except that f0 is replaced by f0 + βy to represent a varying Coriolis parameter. Thus, sphericity combined with rotation is dynamically equivalent to a differentially rotating system. For future reference, we write down the β-plane horizontal momentum equations: Du 1 + f × u = − ∇z p, Dt ρ
(2.82)
In component form this equation becomes where f = (f0 + βy)k. 1 ∂p Du − fv = − , Dt ρ ∂x
Dv 1 ∂p + fu = − . Dt ρ ∂y
(2.83a,b)
The mass conservation, thermodynamic and hydrostatic equations in the β-plane approximation are the same as the usual Cartesian, f -plane, forms of those equations.
2.4 EQUATIONS FOR A STRATIFIED OCEAN: THE BOUSSINESQ APPROXIMATION The density variations in the ocean are quite small compared to the mean density, and we may exploit this to derive somewhat simpler but still quite accurate equations of motion. Let us first examine how much density does vary in the ocean.
68
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
2.4.1 Variation of density in the ocean The variations of density in the ocean are due to three effects: the compression of water by pressure (which we denote as ∆p ρ ), the thermal expansion of water if its temperature changes (∆T ρ ), and the haline contraction if its salinity changes (∆S ρ ). How big are these? An appropriate equation of state to approximately evaluate these effects is the linear one
p ρ = ρ0 1 − βT (T − T0 ) + βS (S − S0 ) + (2.84) , ρ0 cs2 where βT ≈ 2 × 10−4 K−1 , βS ≈ 10−3 psu−1 and cs ≈ 1500 m s−1 (see the table on page 35). The three effects may then be evaluated as follows. Pressure compressibility. We have ∆p ρ ≈ ∆p/cs2 ≈ ρ0 gH/cs2 . where H is the depth and the pressure change is quite accurately evaluated using the hydrostatic approximation. Thus, |∆p ρ| gH 1 if 1, (2.85) ρ0 cs2 or if H cs2 /g . The quantity cs2 /g ≈ 200 km is the density scale height of the ocean. Thus, the pressure at the bottom of the ocean (say H = 10 km in the deep trenches), enormous as it is, is insufficient to compress the water enough to make a significant change in its density. Changes in density due to dynamical variations of pressure are small if the Mach number is small, and this is also the case. Thermal expansion. We have ∆T ρ ≈ −βT ρ0 ∆T and therefore
|∆T ρ| 1 ρ0
if
βT ∆T 1.
(2.86)
For ∆T = 20 K, βT ∆T ≈ 4 × 10−3 , and evidently we would require temperature 1 differences of order β− T , or 5000 K to obtain order one variations in density. Saline contraction. We have ∆S ρ ≈ βS ρ0 ∆S and therefore
|∆S ρ| 1 ρ0
if
βS ∆S 1.
(2.87)
As changes in salinity in the ocean rarely exceed 5 psu, for which βS ∆S = 5 × 10−3 , the fractional change in the density of seawater is correspondingly very small. Evidently, fractional density changes in the ocean are very small.
2.4.2 The Boussinesq equations The Boussinesq equations are a set of equations that exploit the smallness of density variations in many liquids.4 To set notation we write
ρ = ρ0 + δρ(x, y, z, t)
(2.88a)
= ρ0 + ρ(z) + ρ (x, y, z, t)
(2.88b)
= ρ(z) + ρ (x, y, z, t),
(2.88c)
2.4 The Boussinesq Approximation
69
where ρ0 is a constant and we assume that
|ρ |, |δρ| ρ0 . |ρ|,
(2.89)
, but this is often the case in the ocean. To obtain the We need not assume that |ρ | |ρ| Boussinesq equations we will just use (2.88a), but (2.88c) will be useful for the anelastic equations considered later. Associated with the reference density is a reference pressure that is defined to be in hydrostatic balance with it. That is, p = p0 (z) + δp(x, y, z, t)
= p(z) + p (x, y, z, t),
(2.90a) (2.90b)
and where |δp| p0 , |p | p d p0 ≡ −gρ0 , dz
dp ≡ −g ρ. dz
(2.91a,b)
if |ρ| ρ0 . Note that ∇z p = ∇z p = ∇z δp and that p0 ≈ p Momentum equations To obtain the Boussinesq equations we use ρ = ρ0 +δρ , and assume δρ/ρ0 is small. Without approximation, the momentum equation can be written as
(ρ0 + δρ)
Dv + 2Ω × v Dt
= −∇δp −
∂ p0 k − g(ρ0 + δρ)k, ∂z
and using (2.91a) this becomes, again without approximation, Dv (ρ0 + δρ) + 2Ω × v = −∇δp − gδρ k. Dt
(2.92)
(2.93)
If density variations are small this becomes Dv + 2Ω × v = −∇φ + bk , Dt
(2.94)
where φ = δp/ρ0 and b = −g δρ/ρ0 is the buoyancy. Note that we should not and do not neglect the term g δρ , for there is no reason to believe it to be small (δρ may be small, but g is big). Equation (2.94) is the momentum equation in the Boussinesq approximation, and it is common to say that the Boussinesq approximation ignores all variations of density of a fluid in the momentum equation, except when associated with the gravitational term. For most large-scale motions in the ocean the deviation pressure and density fields are also approximately in hydrostatic balance, and in that case the vertical component of (2.94) becomes ∂φ = b. (2.95) ∂z A condition for (2.95) to hold is that vertical accelerations are small compared to g δρ/ρ0 , and not compared to the acceleration due to gravity itself. For more discussion of this point, see section 2.7.
70
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
Mass Conservation The unapproximated mass conservation equation is Dδρ + (ρ0 + δρ)∇ · v = 0. Dt
(2.96)
Provided that time scales advectively — that is to say that D/Dt scales in the same way as v · ∇ — then we may approximate this equation by
∇·v =0 ,
(2.97)
which is the same as that for a constant density fluid. This absolutely does not allow one to go back and use (2.96) to say that Dδρ/Dt = 0; the evolution of density is given by the thermodynamic equation in conjunction with an equation of state, and this should not be confused with the mass conservation equation. Note also that in eliminating the time-derivative of density we eliminate the possibility of sound waves. Thermodynamic equation and equation of state The Boussinesq equations are closed by the addition of an equation of state, a thermodynamic equation and, as appropriate, a salinity equation. Neglecting salinity for the moment, a useful starting point is to write the thermodynamic equation, (1.116), as
˙ 1 Dp Q Dρ ˙ ρ 0 βT − 2 = ≈ −Q (2.98) Dt (∂ η/∂ρ)p T cp cs D t using (∂ η/∂ρ)p = (∂ η/∂T )p (∂ T /∂ρ)p ≈ cp /(T ρ0 βT ). Given the expansions (2.88a) and (2.90a), (2.98) can be written to a good approximation as
ρ 0 βT 1 Dp0 Dδρ ˙ − 2 = −Q (2.99) , Dt cp cs D t or, using (2.91a), D Dt
ρ 0 βT ρ0 g ˙ δρ + 2 z = −Q , cp cs
(2.100)
as in (1.119). The severest approximation to this is to neglect the second term in brackets on the left-hand side, and noting that b = −gδρ/ρ0 we obtain Db ˙ , =b Dt
(2.101)
˙ = gβT Q/c ˙ p . The momentum equation (2.94), mass continuity equation (2.97) where b and thermodynamic equation (2.101) then form a closed set, called the simple Boussinesq equations. A somewhat more accurate approach is to include the compressibility of the fluid that is due to the hydrostatic pressure. From (2.100), the potential density is given by δρpot = δρ + ρ0 gz/cs2 , and so the potential buoyancy, that is the buoyancy based on potential density, is given by δρpot ρ0 gz z g δρ + =b−g bσ ≡ −g =− , (2.102) ρ0 ρ0 Hρ cs2
2.4 The Boussinesq Approximation
71
where Hρ = cs2 /g . The thermodynamic equation, (2.100), may then be written Dbσ ˙σ , =b Dt
(2.103)
˙ . Buoyancy itself is obtained from bσ by the ‘equation of state’, b = bσ +gz/Hρ . ˙σ = b where b In many applications we may need to use a still more accurate equation of state. In that case (and see section 1.6.2) we replace (2.101) by the thermodynamic equations Dθ ˙ = θ, Dt
DS = S˙ , Dt
(2.104a,b)
where θ is the potential temperature and S is salinity, along with an equation of state. The equation of state has the general form b = b(θ, S, p), but to be consistent with the level of approximation in the other Boussinesq equations we replace p by the hydrostatic pressure calculated with the reference density, that is by −ρ0 gz, and the equation of state then takes the general form
b = b(θ, S, z) .
(2.105)
An example of (2.105) is (1.156), taken with the definition of buoyancy b = −gδρ/ρ0 . The closed set of equations (2.94), (2.97), (2.104) and (2.105) are the general Boussinesq equations. Using an accurate equation of state and the Boussinesq approximation is the procedure used in many comprehensive ocean general circulation models. The Boussinesq equations, which with the hydrostatic and traditional approximations are often considered to be the oceanic primitive equations, are summarized in the shaded box on the next page.
* Mean stratification and the buoyancy frequency The processes that cause density to vary in the vertical often differ from those that cause it + to vary in the horizontal. For this reason it is sometimes useful to write ρ = ρ0 + ρ(z) 0 and b ≡ −gρ /ρ0 . Using the hydrostatic equation ρ (x, y, z, t) and define b(z) ≡ −g ρ/ρ to evaluate pressure, the thermodynamic equation (2.98) becomes, to a good approximation, Db + N 2 w = 0, Dt
(2.106)
where D/Dt remains a three-dimensional operator and
2
N (z) =
db g2 − 2 dz cs
=
σ db , dz
(2.107)
σ = b − gz/Hρ . The quantity N 2 is a measure of the mean stratification of the fluid, where b and is equal to the vertical gradient of the mean potential buoyancy. N is known as the buoyancy frequency, something we return to in section 2.9. Equations (2.106) and (2.107) also hold in the simple Boussinesq equations, but with cs2 = ∞.
72
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
Summary of Boussinesq Equations The simple Boussinesq equations are, for an inviscid fluid: Dv + f × v = −∇φ + bk, Dt ∇ · v = 0,
momentum equations: mass conservation:
Db ˙ = b. Dt
buoyancy equation:
(B.1) (B.2) (B.3)
A more general form replaces the buoyancy equation by: Dθ ˙ = θ, Dt DS ˙ = S, Dt b = b(θ, S, φ).
thermodynamic equation: salinity equation: equation of state:
(B.4) (B.5) (B.6)
Energy conservation is only assured if b = b(θ, S, z).
2.4.3 Energetics of the Boussinesq system In a uniform gravitational field but with no other forcing or dissipation, we write the simple Boussinesq equations as Dv + 2Ω × v = bk − ∇φ, Dt
∇ · v = 0,
Db = 0. Dt
(2.108a,b,c)
From (2.108a) and (2.108b) the kinetic energy density evolution (cf. section 1.10) is given by 1 Dv 2 = bw − ∇ · (φv), 2 Dt
(2.109)
where the constant reference density ρ0 is omitted. Let us now define the potential Φ ≡ −z, so that ∇Φ = −k and DΦ = ∇ · (vΦ) = −w, (2.110) Dt and using this and (2.108c) gives D (bΦ) = −wb. Dt
(2.111)
Adding (2.111) to (2.109) and expanding the material derivative gives
∂ ∂t
1 2 1 2 v + bΦ + ∇ · v v + bΦ + φ = 0. 2 2
(2.112)
This constitutes an energy equation for the Boussinesq system, and may be compared to (1.186). (Also see problem 2.14.) The energy density (divided by ρ0 ) is just v 2 /2 + bΦ . What does the term bΦ represent? Its integral, multiplied by ρ0 , is the potential energy of the
2.5 The Anelastic Approximation
73
flow minus that of the basic state, or g(ρ − ρ0 )z dz. If there were a heating term on the right-hand side of (2.108c) this would directly provide a source of potential energy, rather than internal energy as in the compressible system. Because the fluid is incompressible, there is no conversion from kinetic and potential energy into internal energy. * Energetics with a general equation of state Now consider the energetics of the general Boussinesq equations. Suppose first that we allow the equation of state to be a function of pressure; the equations are motion are then (2.108) except that (2.108c) is replaced by Dθ = 0, Dt
DS = 0, Dt
b = b(θ, S, φ).
(2.113a,b,c)
A little algebraic experimentation will reveal that no energy conservation law of the form (2.112) generally exists for this system! The problem arises because, by requiring the fluid to be incompressible, we eliminate the proper conversion of internal energy to kinetic energy. However, if we use the approximation b = b(θ, S, z), the system does conserve an energy, as we now show.5 Define the potential, Π , as the integral of b at constant potential temperature and salinity; that is z
Π(θ, S, z) ≡ −
b dz ,
(2.114)
a
where a is any constant, so that ∂ Π/∂z = −b. Taking the material derivative of the left-hand side gives DΠ ∂Π ∂Π ∂Π Dθ DS Dz = + + = −bw, (2.115) Dt ∂θ S,z Dt ∂S θ,z Dt ∂z θ,S Dt using (2.113a,b). Combining (2.115) and (2.109) gives
∂ ∂t
1 2 1 2 v +Π +∇· v v +Π +φ = 0. 2 2
(2.116)
Thus, energetic consistency is maintained with an arbitrary equation of state, provided the pressure is replaced by a function of z. If b is not an explicit function of z in the equation of state, the conservation law is identical to (2.112).
2.5 EQUATIONS FOR A STRATIFIED ATMOSPHERE: THE ANELASTIC APPROXIMATION 2.5.1 Preliminaries In the atmosphere the density varies significantly, especially in the vertical. However deviations of both ρ and p from a statically balanced state are often quite small, and the relative vertical variation of potential temperature is also small. We can usefully exploit these observations to give a somewhat simplified set of equations, useful both for theoretical and numerical analyses because sound waves are eliminated by way of an ‘anelastic’ approximation.6 To begin we set
ρ = ρ(z) + δρ(x, y, z, t),
p = p(z) + δp(x, y, z, t),
(2.117a,b)
74
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
such that and we define p where we assume that |δρ| |ρ| ∂p ≡ −g ρ(z). ∂z
(2.118)
The notation is similar to that for the Boussinesq case except that, importantly, the density basic state is now a (given) function of vertical coordinate. As with the Boussinesq case, the idea is to ignore dynamic variations of density (i.e., of δρ ) except where associated with gravity. First recall a couple of ideal gas relationships involving potential temperature, θ , and entropy s (divided by cp , so s ≡ log θ ), namely
s ≡ log θ = log T −
R 1 log p = log p − log ρ, cp γ
(2.119)
where γ = cp /cv , implying
δs =
δρ 1 1 δp 1 δp δρ − . δθ = − ≈ ρ θ γ p ρ γ p
(2.120)
− log ρ then Further, if s ≡ γ −1 log p g ρ 1 dp 1 d ρ 1 d ρ d s = − =− − . dz dz γp γp ρ dz ρ dz
(2.121)
In the atmosphere, the left-hand side is, typically, much smaller than either of the two terms on the right-hand side.
2.5.2 The momentum equation The exact inviscid horizontal momentum equation is Du + f × u = −∇z δp. (ρ + ρ ) Dt
(2.122)
Neglecting ρ where it appears with ρ leads to Du + f × u = −∇z φ, Dt
(2.123)
where φ = δp/ρ, and this is similar to the corresponding equation in the Boussinesq approximation. The vertical component of the inviscid momentum equation is, without approximation,
(ρ + δρ)
Dw ∂p ∂ δp ∂ δp =− − − g ρ − gδρ = − − gδρ. Dt ∂z ∂z ∂z
using (2.118). Neglecting δρ on the left-hand side we obtain
Dw δρ δp δρ 1 ∂ δp ∂ δp ∂ ρ =− −g −g =− − 2 . Dt ∂z ρ ∂z ρ ρ ρ ∂z ρ
(2.124)
(2.125)
This is not a useful form for a gaseous atmosphere, since the variation of the mean density cannot be ignored. However, we may eliminate δρ in favour of δs using (2.120) to give
Dw ∂ δp g δp δp ∂ ρ = gδs − , (2.126) − − 2 Dt ∂z γ p ρ ρ ∂z
2.5 The Anelastic Approximation
75
and using (2.121) gives
∂ Dw = gδs − Dt ∂z
δp ρ
+
d s δp . dz ρ
(2.127)
What have these manipulations gained us? Two things: (i) The gravitational term now involves δs rather than δρ which enables a more direct connection with the thermodynamic equation. (ii) The potential temperature scale height (∼ 100 km) in the atmosphere is much larger than the density scale height (∼ 10 km), and so the last term in (2.127) is small. The second item thus suggests that we choose our reference state to be one of constant potential temperature (see also problem 2.19). The term ds/dz then vanishes and the vertical momentum equation becomes
∂φ Dw = gδs − Dt ∂z
,
(2.128)
where φ = δp/ρ and δs = δθ/θ0 , where θ0 is a constant. If we define a buoyancy by ba ≡ gδs = gδθ/θ0 , then (2.123) and (2.128) have the same form as the Boussinesq momentum equations, but with a slightly different definition of buoyancy.
2.5.3 Mass conservation Using (2.117a) the mass conservation equation may be written, without approximation, as
∂ δρ + ∇ · [(ρ + δρ)v] = 0. ∂t
(2.129)
We neglect δρ where it appears with ρ in the divergence term. Further, the local time derivative will be small if time itself is scaled advectively (i.e., T ∼ L/U and sound waves do not dominate), giving 1 ∂ (ρw) = 0. ∇·u+ (2.130) ρ ∂z It is here that the eponymous ‘anelastic approximation’ arises: the elastic compressibility of the fluid is neglected, and this serves to eliminate sound waves. For reference, in spherical coordinates the equation is
1 1 ∂ (w ρ) ∂u ∂ 1 + (v cos ϑ) + = 0. a cos ϑ ∂λ a cos ϑ ∂ϑ ρ ∂z
(2.131)
In an ideal gas, the choice of constant potential temperature determines how the reference density ρ varies with height. In some circumstances it is convenient to let ρ be a constant, ρ0 (effectively choosing a different equation of state), in which case the anelastic equations become identical to the Boussinesq equations, albeit with the buoyancy interpreted in terms of potential temperature in the former and density in the latter. Because of their similarity, the Boussinesq and anelastic approximations are sometimes referred to as the strong and weak Boussinesq approximations, respectively.
76
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
2.5.4 Thermodynamic equation The thermodynamic equation for an ideal gas may be written ˙ D ln θ Q . = Dt T cp
(2.132)
+ δθ , where θ is constant, and the thermodynamic equation In the anelastic equations, θ = θ is θ ˙ Dδs = Q. (2.133) Dt T cp Summarizing, the complete set of anelastic equations, with rotation but with no dissipation or diabatic terms, is Dv + 2Ω × v = kba − ∇φ Dt Dba , =0 Dt =0 ∇ · (ρv)
(2.134a,b,c)
. The main difference between the anelastic and Boussinesq where ba = gδs = gδθ/θ sets of equations is in the mass continuity equation, and when ρ = ρ0 = constant the two equation sets are formally identical. However, whereas the Boussinesq approximation is a very good one for ocean dynamics, the anelastic approximation is much less so for largescale atmosphere flow: the constancy of the reference potential temperature state is not a particularly good approximation, and the deviations in density from its reference profile are not especially small, leading to inaccuracies in the momentum equation. Nevertheless, the anelastic equations have been used very productively in limited area ‘large-eddy simulations’ where one does not wish to make the hydrostatic approximation but where sound waves are unimportant.7 The equations also provide a good jumping-off point for theoretical studies and for the still simpler models of chapter 5.
2.5.5 * Energetics of the anelastic equations Conservation of energy follows in much the same way as for the Boussinesq equations, to obtain except that ρ enters. Take the dot product of (2.134a) with ρv
ρ
D Dt
1 2 v 2
+ ba ρw. = −∇ · (φρv)
(2.135)
Now, define a potential Φ(z) such that ∇Φ = −k, and so
ρ
DΦ = −w ρ. Dt
(2.136)
Combining this with the thermodynamic equation (2.134b) gives
ρ
D(ba Φ) = −wba ρ. Dt
(2.137)
2.6 Changing Vertical Coordinate
77
Adding this to (2.135) gives
ρ
D Dt
1 2 v + ba Φ = −∇ · (φρv), 2
or, expanding the material derivative, ∂ 1 2 1 2 v + ba Φ + ∇ · ρv v + ba Φ + φ = 0. ρ ∂t 2 2 This equation has the form
∂E + ∇ · v(E + ρφ) = 0, ∂t
(2.138)
(2.139)
(2.140)
2 /2 + ba Φ) is the energy density of the flow. This is a consistent energetic where E = ρ(v equation for the system, and when integrated over a closed domain the total energy is a Φ, evidently conserved. The total energy density comprises the kinetic energy and a term ρb which is analogous to the potential energy of a simple Boussinesq system. However, it is not exactly equal to potential energy because ba is the buoyancy based on potential temperature, not density; rather, the term combines contributions from both the internal energy and the potential energy into an enthalpy-like quantity.
2.6 CHANGING VERTICAL COORDINATE Although using z as a vertical coordinate is a natural choice given our Cartesian worldview, it is not the only option, nor is it always the most useful one. Any variable that has a one-to-one correspondence with z in the vertical, so any variable that varies monotonically with z, could be used; pressure and, perhaps surprisingly, entropy, are common choices. In the atmosphere pressure almost always falls monotonically with height, and using it instead of z provides a useful simplification of the mass conservation and geostrophic relations, as well as a more direct connection with observations, which are often taken at fixed values of pressure. (In the ocean pressure coordinates are essentially almost the same as height coordinates, because density is almost constant.) Entropy seems an exotic vertical coordinate, but it is very useful in adiabatic flow and we consider it in chapter 3.
2.6.1 General relations First consider a general vertical coordinate, ξ . Any variable Ψ that is a function of the coordinates (x, y, z, t) may be expressed instead in terms of (x, y, ξ, t) by considering z to be function of the independent variables (x, y, ξ, t); that is, we let Ψ (x, y, ξ, t) = Ψ (x, y, z(x, y, ξ, t), t). Derivatives with respect to z and ξ are related by
∂Ψ ∂z ∂Ψ = ∂ξ ∂z ∂ξ
and
∂Ψ ∂ξ ∂Ψ = . ∂z ∂ξ ∂z
(2.141a,b)
Horizontal derivatives in the two coordinate systems are related by the chain rule, ∂Ψ ∂Ψ ∂z ∂ Ψ , = + (2.142) ∂x ξ ∂x z ∂x ξ ∂z and similarly for time.
78
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
The material derivative in ξ coordinates may be derived by transforming the original expression in z coordinates using the chain rule, but because (x, y, t, ξ) are independent coordinates, and noting that the ‘vertical velocity’ in ξ coordinates is just ξ˙ (i.e., Dξ/Dt , just as the vertical velocity in z coordinates is w = Dz/Dt ), we can write down
∂Ψ ∂Ψ DΨ + u · ∇ξ Ψ + ξ˙ = , Dt ∂t x,y,ξ ∂ξ
(2.143)
where ∇ξ is the gradient operator at constant ξ . The operator D/Dt is physically the same in z or ξ coordinates because it is the total derivative of some property of a fluid parcel, and this is independent of the coordinate system. However, the individual terms within it will differ between coordinate systems.
2.6.2 Pressure coordinates Let us now transform the ideal gas primitive equations from height coordinates to pressure coordinates, (x, y, p, t). In z coordinates the equations are
∂p 1 Du + f × u = − ∇p, = −ρg, Dt ρ ∂z Dρ Dθ = 0, + ρ∇ · v = 0, Dt Dt
(2.144a) (2.144b)
R/cp , and pR is the reference pressure. These are where p = ρRT and θ = T pR /p respectively the horizontal momentum, hydrostatic, thermodynamic and mass continuity equations. The analogue of the vertical velocity is ω ≡ Dp/Dt , and the advective derivative itself is given by ∂ ∂ D = + u · ∇p + ω . (2.145) Dt ∂t ∂p To obtain an expression for the pressure force, now let ξ = p in (2.142) and apply the relationship to p itself to give
0=
∂p ∂x
z
+
∂z ∂x
p
∂p , ∂z
(2.146)
,
(2.147)
which, using the hydrostatic relationship, gives
∂p ∂x
z
=ρ
∂Φ ∂x
p
where Φ = gz is the geopotential. Thus, the horizontal pressure force in the momentum equations is 1 ∇z p = ∇p Φ, (2.148) ρ where the subscripts on the gradient operator indicate that the horizontal derivatives are taken at constant z or constant p . Also, from (2.144a), the hydrostatic equation is just
∂Φ = −α. ∂p
(2.149)
2.6 Changing Vertical Coordinate
79
The mass conservation equation simplifies attractively in pressure coordinates, if the hydrostatic approximation is used. Recall that the mass conservation equation can be derived from the material form D (ρ δV ) = 0, (2.150) Dt where δV = δx δy δz is a volume element. But by the hydrostatic relationship ρδz = (1/g)δp and thus D (δx δy δp) = 0. (2.151) Dt This is completely analogous to the expression for the material conservation of volume in an incompressible fluid, (1.15). Thus, without further ado, we write the mass conservation in pressure coordinates as ∂ω = 0, ∇p · u + (2.152) ∂p where the horizontal derivative is taken at constant pressure. The primitive equations in pressure coordinates, equivalent to (2.144) in height coordinates, are thus:
∂Φ Du + f × u = −∇p Φ, = −α Dt ∂p , Dθ ∂ω = 0, =0 ∇p · u + Dt ∂p
(2.153)
where D/Dt is given by (2.145). The equation set is completed with the addition of the ideal gas equation and the definition of potential temperature. These equations are isomorphic to the hydrostatic general Boussinesq equations (see the shaded box on page 72) with z ↔ −p , w ↔ −ω, φ ↔ Φ , b ↔ α, and an equation of state b = b(θ, z) ↔ α = α(θ, p). In an ideal gas, for example, α = (θR/pR )(pR /p)1/γ . The main practical difficulty with the pressure-coordinate equations is the lower boundary condition. Using ∂z ∂z Dz = + u · ∇p z + ω , w≡ (2.154) Dt ∂t ∂p and (2.149), the boundary condition of w = 0 at z = zs becomes
∂Φ + u · ∇p Φ − αω = 0 ∂t
(2.155)
at p(x, y, zs , t). In theoretical studies, it is common to assume that the lower boundary is in fact a constant pressure surface and simply assume that ω = 0, or sometimes the condition ω = −α−1 ∂ Φ/∂t is used. For realistic studies (with general circulation models, say) the fact that the level z = 0 is not a coordinate surface must be properly accounted for. For this reason, and especially if the lower boundary is uneven because of the presence of topography, so-called sigma coordinates are sometimes used, in which the vertical coordinate is chosen so that the lower boundary is a coordinate surface. Sigma coordinates may use height itself as a vertical measure (typical in oceanic applications) or use pressure (typical in atmospheric applications). In the latter case the vertical coordinate is σ = p/ps where ps (x, y, t) is the surface pressure. The difficulty of applying (2.155) is replaced by a prognostic equation for the surface pressure, derived from the mass conservation equation (problem 2.24).
80
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
2.6.3 Log-pressure coordinates A variant of pressure coordinates is log-pressure coordinates, in which the vertical coordinate is Z = −H ln(p/pR ) where pR is a reference pressure (say 1000 mb) and H is a constant (for example the scale height RTs /g ) so that Z has units of length. (Uppercase letters are conventionally used for some variables in log-pressure coordinates, and these are not to be confused with scaling parameters.) The ‘vertical velocity’ for the system is now
W ≡
DZ , Dt
(2.156)
and the advective derivative is
∂ ∂ D ≡ + u · ∇p + W . Dt ∂t ∂Z
(2.157)
It is straightforward to show (problem 2.25) that the primitive equations of motion in these coordinates are:
RT ∂Φ Du + f × u = −∇Z Φ, = , Dt ∂Z H Dθ ∂v ∂W W ∂u = 0, + + − = 0. Dt ∂x ∂y ∂Z H
(2.158a) (2.158b)
The last equation may be written ∇Z · u + ρR−1 ∂ (ρR W )/∂z = 0, where ρR = exp(−z/H), so giving a form similar to the mass conservation equation in the anelastic equations. Note that integrating the hydrostatic equation between two pressure levels gives, with Φ = gz,
z(p2 ) − z(p1 ) =
R g
p2 T d ln p.
(2.159)
p1
Thus, the thickness of the layer is proportional to the average temperature of the layer.
2.7 SCALING FOR HYDROSTATIC BALANCE In this section we consider one of the most fundamental balances in geophysical fluid dynamics, hydrostatic balance, and in the next section we consider another fundamental balance, geostrophic balance. The corresponding states, hydrostasy and geostrophy, are not exactly realized, but their approximate satisfaction has profound consequences on the behaviour of the atmosphere and ocean. We first encountered hydrostatic balance in section 1.3.4; we now look in more detail at the conditions required for it to hold.
2.7.1 Preliminaries Consider the relative sizes of terms in (2.77c):
1 ∂p UW W2 W + g. + + + ΩU ∼ ρ ∂z T L H
(2.160)
For most large-scale motion in the atmosphere and ocean the terms on the right-hand side are orders of magnitude larger than those on the left, and therefore must be approximately
2.7 Scaling for Hydrostatic Balance
81
equal. Explicitly, suppose W ∼ 1 cm s−1 , L ∼ 105 m, H ∼ 103 m, U ∼ 10 m s−1 , T = L/U . Then by substituting into (2.160) it seems that the pressure term is the only one which could balance the gravitational term, and we are led to approximate (2.77c) by,
∂p = −ρg. ∂z
(2.161)
This equation, which is a vertical momentum equation, is known as hydrostatic balance. However, (2.161) is not always a useful equation! Let us suppose that the density is a constant, ρ0 . We can then write the pressure as
p(x, y, z, t) = p0 (z) + p (x, y, z, t),
(2.162)
where
∂ p0 ≡ −ρ0 g. (2.163) ∂z That is, p0 and ρ0 are in hydrostatic balance. The inviscid vertical momentum equation becomes, without approximation, 1 ∂ p Dw =− . Dt ρ0 ∂z
(2.164)
Thus, for constant density fluids, the gravitational term has no dynamical effect: there is no buoyancy force, and the pressure term in the horizontal momentum equations can be replaced by p . Hydrostatic balance, and in particular (2.163), is certainly not an appropriate vertical momentum equation in this case. If the fluid is stratified, we should therefore subtract off the hydrostatic pressure associated with the mean density before we can determine whether hydrostasy is a useful dynamical approximation, accurate enough to determine the horizontal pressure gradients. This is automatic in the Boussinesq equations, where the vertical momentum equation is
∂φ Dw =− + b, Dt ∂z
(2.165)
and the hydrostatic balance of the basic state is already subtracted out. In the more general equation, 1 ∂p Dw =− − g, (2.166) Dt ρ ∂z we need to compare the advective term on the left-hand side with the pressure variations arising from horizontal flow in order to determine whether hydrostasy is an appropriate vertical momentum equation. Nevertheless, if we only need to determine the pressure for use in an equation of state then we simply need to compare the sizes of the dynamical terms in (2.77c) with g itself, in order to determine whether a hydrostatic approximation will suffice.
2.7.2 Scaling and the aspect ratio In a Boussinesq fluid we write the horizontal and vertical momentum equations as Du + f × u = −∇φ, Dt
∂φ Dw =− − b. Dt ∂z
(2.167a,b)
82
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
With f = 0, (2.167a) implies the scaling
φ ∼ U 2.
(2.168)
If we use mass conservation, ∇z · u + ∂ w/∂z = 0, to scale vertical velocity then
w∼W =
H U = αU, L
(2.169)
where α ≡ H/L is the aspect ratio. The advective terms in the vertical momentum equation all scale as UW U 2H Dw ∼ = . (2.170) Dt L L2 Using (2.168) and (2.170) the ratio of the advective term to the pressure gradient term in the vertical momentum equations then scales as
U 2 H/L2 |Dw/Dt| ∼ ∼ |∂ φ/∂z| U 2 /H
H L
2 .
(2.171)
Thus, the condition for hydrostasy, that |Dw/Dt|/|∂ φ/∂z| 1, is:
α2 ≡
H L
2 1 .
(2.172)
The advective term in the vertical momentum may then be neglected. Thus, hydrostatic balance is a small aspect ratio approximation. We can obtain the same result more formally by non-dimensionalizing the momentum equations. Using uppercase symbols to denote scaling values we write
y), (x, y) = L(x, t = T t =
z = H z,
L t, U
u = U u,
= U 2 φ, φ = Φφ
= w = Ww = b = Bb
HU , w L
U2 b, H
(2.173)
where the hatted variables are non-dimensional and the scaling for w is suggested by the mass conservation equation, ∇z · u + ∂ w/∂z = 0. Substituting (2.173) into (2.167) (with f = 0) gives us the non-dimensional equations
Du = −∇φ, Dt
α2
Dw ∂φ − b, =− ∂ z Dt
(2.174a,b)
/∂ x + v∂ /∂ y +w ∂ /∂ z and we use the convention that when where D/Dt = ∂ /∂ t + u∂ ∇ operates on non-dimensional quantities the operator itself is non-dimensional. From (2.174b) it is clear that hydrostatic balance pertains when α2 1.
2.7.3 * Effects of stratification on hydrostatic balance To include the effects of stratification we need to involve the thermodynamic equation, so let us first write down the complete set of non-rotating dimensional equations: Du = −∇z φ, Dt
∂φ Dw =− + b , Dt ∂z
(2.175a,b)
2.7 Scaling for Hydrostatic Balance
83
Db + wN 2 = 0, Dt
∇ · v = 0.
(2.176a,b)
dz ; this We have written, without approximation, b = b (x, y, z, t) + b(z) , with N 2 = d b/ separation is useful because the horizontal and vertical buoyancy variations may scale in different ways, and often N 2 may be regarded as given. (We have also redefined φ by .) We non-dimensionalize subtracting off a static component in hydrostatic balance with b (2.176) by first writing y), (x, y) = L(x, t = T t =
L t, U
u = U u,
z = H z,
= b = ∆bb
φ = U 2 φ,
=
w = Ww U 2 b, H
HU , w L
(2.177)
2 2 , N2 = N N
where is, for the moment, undetermined, N is a representative, constant, value of the buoyancy frequency and ∆b scales only the horizontal buoyancy variations. Substituting (2.177) into (2.175) and (2.176) gives
Du = −∇z φ, Dt
α2
∂φ Dw =− +b Dt ∂ z
Db 2 = 0, + wN 2 t D N H U2 2
+
∇·u
∂w = 0. ∂ z
(2.178a,b)
(2.179a,b)
· ∇z + ∂ /∂ z . To obtain a non-trivial balance in (2.179a) we where now D/Dt = ∂ /∂ t + u 2 choose = U 2 /(N H 2 ) ≡ Fr 2 , where Fr is the Froude number, a measure of the stratification of the flow. The vertical velocity then scales as W =
Fr U H L
(2.180)
and if the flow is highly stratified the vertical velocity will be even smaller than a pure aspect ratio scaling might suggest. (There must, therefore, be some cancellation in horizontal divergence in the mass continuity equation; that is, |∇z · u| U /L.) With this choice of
the non-dimensional Boussinesq equations may be written:
Du = −∇z φ, Dt Db 2 = 0, N +w Dt
Fr 2 α2
Dw ∂φ +b =− ∂ z Dt
+ Fr 2 ∇·u
∂w = 0. ∂ z
(2.181a,b)
(2.182a,b)
The non-dimensional parameters in the system are the aspect ratio and the Froude number , but by construction this is just an order one function of z). From (2.181b) (in addition to N condition for hydrostatic balance to hold is evidently that Fr 2 α2 1 ,
(2.183)
so generalizing the aspect ratio condition (2.172) to a stratified fluid. Because Fr is a measure of stratification, (2.183) formalizes our intuitive expectation that the more stratified a fluid
84
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
the more vertical motion is suppressed and therefore the more likely hydrostatic balance is 2 to hold. Also note that (2.183) is equivalent to U 2 /(L2 N ) 1. Suppose we solve the hydrostatic equations; that is, we omit the advective derivative in the vertical momentum equation, and by numerical integration we obtain u, w and b. This flow is the solution of the non-hydrostatic equations in the small aspect ratio limit. The solution never violates the scaling assumptions, even if w seems large, because we can always rescale the variables in order that condition (2.183) is satisfied. Why bother with any of this scaling? Why not just say that hydrostatic balance holds when |Dw/Dt| |∂ φ/∂z|? One reason is that we do not have a good idea of the value of w from direct measurements, and it may change significantly in different oceanic and atmospheric parameter regimes. On the other hand the Froude number and the aspect ratio are familiar non-dimensional parameters with a wide applicability in other contexts, and which we can control in a laboratory setting or estimate in the ocean or atmosphere. Still, in scaling theory it is common that ascertaining which parameters are to be regarded as given and which should be derived is a choice, rather than being set a priori.
2.7.4 Hydrostasy in the ocean and atmosphere Is the hydrostatic approximation in fact a good one in the ocean and atmosphere? In the ocean For the large-scale ocean circulation, let N ∼ 10−2 s−1 , U ∼ 0.1 m s−1 and H ∼ 1 km. Then Fr = U /(NH) ∼ 10−2 1. Thus, Fr 2 α2 1 even for unit aspect-ratio motion. In fact, for larger scale flow the aspect ratio is also small; for basin-scale flow L ∼ 106 m and Fr 2 α2 ∼ 0.012 × 0.0012 = 10−10 and hydrostatic balance is an extremely good approximation. For intense convection, for example in the Labrador Sea, the hydrostatic approximation may be less appropriate, because the intense descending plumes may have an aspect ratio (H/L) of one or greater and the stratification is very weak. The hydrostatic condition then often becomes the requirement that the Froude number is small. Representative orders of magnitude are U ∼ W ∼ 0.1 m s−1 , H ∼ 1 km and N ∼ 10−3 s−1 to 10−4 s−1 . For these values Fr ranges between 0.1 and 1, and at the upper end of this range hydrostatic balance is violated. In the atmosphere Over much of the troposphere N ∼ 10−2 s−1 so that with U = 10 m s−1 and H = 1 km we find Fr ∼ 1. Hydrostasy is then maintained because the aspect ratio H/L is much less than unity. For larger scale synoptic activity a larger vertical scale is appropriate, and with H = 10 km both the Froude number and the aspect ratio are much smaller than one; indeed with L = 1000 km we find Fr 2 α2 ∼ 0.12 × 0.12 = 10−4 and the flow is hydrostatic to a very good approximation indeed. However, for smaller scale atmospheric motions associated with fronts and, especially, convection, there can be little expectation that hydrostatic balance will be a good approximation. For large-scale flows in both atmosphere and ocean, the conceptual simplifications afforded by the hydrostatic approximation can hardly be overemphasized.
2.8 Geostrophic and Thermal Wind Balance
Variable
Scaling symbol
(x, y) t (u, v)
L T U Ro
85
Meaning
Atmos. value
Ocean value
Horizontal length scale Time scale Horizontal velocity Rossby number, U/f L
106 m 1 day (105 s) 10 m s−1 0.1
105 m 10 days (106 s) 0.1 m s−1 0.01
Table 2.1 Scales of large-scale flow in atmosphere and ocean. The choices given are representative of large-scale eddying motion in both systems.
2.8 GEOSTROPHIC AND THERMAL WIND BALANCE We now consider the dominant dynamical balance in the horizontal components of the momentum equation. In the horizontal plane (meaning along geopotential surfaces) we find that the Coriolis term is much larger than the advective terms and the dominant balance is between it and the horizontal pressure force. This balance is called geostrophic balance, and it occurs when the Rossby number is small, as we now investigate.
2.8.1 The Rossby number The Rossby number characterizes the importance of rotation in a fluid.8 It is, essentially, the ratio of the magnitude of the relative acceleration to the Coriolis acceleration, and it is of fundamental importance in geophysical fluid dynamics. It arises from a simple scaling of the horizontal momentum equation, namely
∂u 1 +(v · ∇)u + f × u = − ∇z p, ∂t ρ U 2 /L
fU
(2.184a) (2.184b)
where U is the approximate magnitude of the horizontal velocity and L is a typical length scale over which that velocity varies. (We assume that W /H U /L, so that vertical advection does not dominate the advection.) The ratio of the sizes of the advective and Coriolis terms is defined to be the Rossby number,
Ro ≡
U . fL
(2.185)
If the Rossby number is small then rotation effects are important, and as the values in Table 2.1 indicate this is the case for large-scale flow in both ocean and atmosphere. Another intuitive way to think about the Rossby number is in terms of time scales. The Rossby number based on a time scale is RoT ≡
1 , fT
(2.186)
86
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
where T is a time scale associated with the dynamics at hand. If the time scale is an advective one, meaning that T ∼ L/U , then this definition is equivalent to (2.185). Now, f = 2Ω sin ϑ, where Ω is the angular velocity of the rotating frame and equal to 2π/Tp where Tp is the period of rotation (24 hours). Thus, RoT =
Tp 4πT sin ϑ
=
Ti , T
(2.187)
where Ti = 1/f is the ‘inertial time scale’, about three hours in mid-latitudes. Thus, for phenomena with time scales much longer than this, such as the motion of the Gulf Stream or a mid-latitude atmospheric weather system, the effects of the Earth’s rotation can be expected to be important, whereas a short-lived phenomena, such as a cumulus cloud or tornado, may be oblivious to such rotation. The expressions (2.185) and (2.186) are, of course, just approximate measures of the importance of rotation.
2.8.2 Geostrophic balance If the Rossby number is sufficiently small in (2.184a) then the rotation term will dominate the nonlinear advection term, and if the time period of the motion scales advectively then the rotation term also dominates the local time derivative. The only term that can then balance the rotation term is the pressure term, and therefore we must have 1 f × u ≈ − ∇z p, ρ
(2.188)
or, in Cartesian component form
fu ≈ −
1 ∂p , ρ ∂y
fv ≈
1 ∂p . ρ ∂x
(2.189)
This balance is known as geostrophic balance, and its consequences are profound, giving geophysical fluid dynamics a special place in the broader field of fluid dynamics. We define the geostrophic velocity by
f ug ≡ −
1 ∂p , ρ ∂y
f vg ≡
1 ∂p ρ ∂x
,
(2.190)
and for low Rossby number flow u ≈ ug and v ≈ vg . In spherical coordinates the geostrophic velocity is
f ug = −
1 ∂p , ρa ∂ϑ
f vg =
1 ∂p , aρ cos ϑ ∂λ
(2.191)
where f = 2Ω sin ϑ. Geostrophic balance has a number of immediate ramifications:
Geostrophic flow is parallel to lines of constant pressure (isobars). If f > 0 the flow is anticlockwise round a region of low pressure and clockwise around a region of high pressure (see Fig. 2.5).
2.8 Geostrophic and Thermal Wind Balance
87
Fig. 2.5 Schematic of geostrophic flow with a positive value of the Coriolis parameter f . Flow is parallel to the lines of constant pressure (isobars). Cyclonic flow is anticlockwise around a low pressure region and anticyclonic flow is clockwise around a high. If f were negative, as in the Southern Hemisphere, (anti)cyclonic flow would be (anti)clockwise.
If the Coriolis force is constant and if the density does not vary in the horizontal the geostrophic flow is horizontally non-divergent and ∇z · u g =
∂ ug ∂ vg + =0 . ∂x ∂y
(2.192)
We may define the geostrophic streamfunction, ψ, by
ψ≡ whence
ug = −
p , f0 ρ 0
∂ψ , ∂y
vg =
(2.193)
∂ψ . ∂x
(2.194)
The vertical component of vorticity, ζ , is then given by
ζ =k·∇×v =
∂u ∂v − = ∇2z ψ. ∂x ∂y
(2.195)
If the Coriolis parameter is not constant, then cross-differentiating (2.190) gives, for constant density geostrophic flow, vg
∂f + f ∇ z · u g = 0, ∂y
(2.196)
which implies, using mass continuity,
βvg = f
∂w . ∂z
(2.197)
88
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification where β ≡ ∂ f /∂y = 2Ω cos ϑ/a. This geostrophic vorticity balance is sometimes known as ‘Sverdrup balance’, although the latter expression is better restricted to the case when the vertical velocity results from external agents, and specifically a wind stress, as considered in chapter 14.
2.8.3 Taylor–Proudman effect If β = 0, then (2.197) implies that the vertical velocity is not a function of height. In fact, in that case none of the components of velocity vary with height if density is also constant. To show this, in the limit of zero Rossby number we first write the three-dimensional momentum equation as f0 × v = −∇φ − ∇χ, (2.198) where f0 = 2Ω = 2Ω k, φ = p/ρ0 , and ∇χ represents other potential forces. If χ = gz then the vertical component of this equation represents hydrostatic balance, and the horizontal components represent geostrophic balance. On taking the curl of this equation, the terms on the right-hand side vanish and the left-hand side becomes
(f0 · ∇)v − f0 ∇ · v − (v · ∇)f0 + v∇ · f0 = 0.
(2.199)
But ∇ · v = 0 by mass conservation, and because f0 is constant both ∇ · f0 and (v · ∇)f0 vanish. Thus (f0 · ∇)v = 0, (2.200) which, since f0 = f0 k, implies f0 ∂ v/∂z = 0, and in particular we have
∂u = 0, ∂z
∂v = 0, ∂z
∂w = 0. ∂z
(2.201)
A different presentation of this argument proceeds as follows. If the flow is exactly in geostrophic and hydrostatic balance then
v=
1 ∂φ , f0 ∂x
u=−
1 ∂φ , f0 ∂y
∂φ = −g. ∂z
(2.202a,b,c)
Differentiating (2.202a,b) with respect to z, and using (2.202c) yields
−1 ∂ g ∂v = = 0, ∂z f0 ∂x
∂u 1 ∂g = = 0. ∂z f0 ∂y
(2.203)
Noting that the geostrophic velocities are horizontally non-divergent (∇z · u = 0), and using mass continuity then gives ∂ w/∂z = 0, as before. If there is a solid horizontal boundary anywhere in the fluid, for example at the surface, then w = 0 at that surface and thus w = 0 everywhere. Hence the motion occurs in planes that lie perpendicular to the axis of rotation, and the flow is effectively two dimensional. This result is known as the Taylor–Proudman effect, namely that for constant density flow in geostrophic and hydrostatic balance the vertical derivatives of the horizontal and the vertical velocities are zero.9 At zero Rossby number, if the vertical velocity is zero somewhere in the flow, it is zero everywhere in that vertical column; furthermore, the horizontal flow has no vertical shear, and the fluid moves like a slab. The effects of rotation have provided a stiffening of the fluid in the vertical.
2.8 Geostrophic and Thermal Wind Balance
89
In neither the atmosphere nor the ocean do we observe precisely such vertically coherent flow, mainly because of the effects of stratification. However, it is typical of geophysical fluid dynamics that the assumptions underlying a derivation are not fully satisfied, yet there are manifestations of it in real flow. Thus, one might have naïvely expected, because ∂ w/∂z = −∇z · u, that the scales of the various variables would be related by W /H ∼ U /L. However, if the flow is rapidly rotating we expect that the horizontal flow will be in near geostrophic balance and therefore nearly divergence free; thus ∇z · u U /L, and W HU /L.
2.8.4 Thermal wind balance Thermal wind balance arises by combining the geostrophic and hydrostatic approximations, and this is most easily done in the context of the anelastic (or Boussinesq) equations, or in pressure coordinates. For the anelastic equations, geostrophic balance may be written
−f vg = −
∂φ 1 ∂φ =− , ∂x a cos ϑ ∂λ
f ug = −
∂φ 1 ∂φ =− . ∂y a ∂ϑ
(2.204a,b)
Combining these relations with hydrostatic balance, ∂ φ/∂z = b, gives
∂ vg 1 ∂b ∂b =− =− ∂z ∂x a cos λ ∂λ ∂ ug ∂b 1 ∂b f =− =− ∂z ∂y a ∂ϑ
−f
.
(2.205a,b)
These equations represent thermal wind balance, and the vertical derivative of the geostrophic wind is the ‘thermal wind’. Eq. (2.205b) may be written in terms of the zonal angular momentum as ∂ mg a ∂b =− , (2.206) ∂z 2Ω tan ϑ ∂y where mg = (ug + Ωa cos ϑ)a cos ϑ. Potentially more accurate than geostrophic balance is the so-called cyclostrophic or gradient-wind balance, which retains a centrifugal term in the momentum equation. Thus, we omit only the material derivative in the meridional momentum equation (2.50b) and obtain 2uΩ sin ϑ +
u2 ∂φ 1 ∂φ =− . tan ϑ ≈ − a ∂y a ∂ϑ
(2.207)
For large-scale flow this only differs significantly from geostrophic balance very close to the equator. Combining cyclostrophic and hydrostatic balance gives a modified thermal wind relation, and this takes a simple form when expressed in terms of angular momentum, namely ∂ m2 a3 cos3 ϑ ∂ b ≈− . (2.208) ∂z sin ϑ ∂y If the density or buoyancy is constant then there is no shear and (2.205) or (2.208) give the Taylor–Proudman result. But suppose that the temperature falls in the poleward direction. Then thermal wind balance implies that the (eastward) wind will increase with height — just as is observed in the atmosphere! In general, a vertical shear of the horizontal wind is associated with a horizontal temperature gradient, and this is one of the most simple and far-reaching effects in geophysical fluid dynamics. The underlying physical mechanism is illustrated in Fig. 2.6.
90
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
-
Fig. 2.6 The mechanism of thermal wind. A cold fluid is denser than a warm fluid, so by hydrostasy the vertical pressure gradient is greater where the fluid is cold. Thus, the pressure gradients form as shown, where ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ mean relative to the average at that height. The horizontal pressure gradients are balanced by the Coriolis force, producing (for f > 0) the horizontal winds shown (⊗ into the paper, and out of the paper). Only the wind shear is given by the thermal wind.
Pressure coordinates In pressure coordinates geostrophic balance is just
f × ug = −∇p Φ,
(2.209)
where Φ is the geopotential and ∇p is the gradient operator taken at constant pressure. If f if constant, it follows from (2.209) that the geostrophic wind is non-divergent on pressure surfaces. Taking the vertical derivative of (2.209) (that is, its derivative with respect to p ) and using the hydrostatic equation, ∂ Φ/∂p = −α, gives the thermal wind equation
f×
∂ ug R = ∇p α = ∇p T , ∂p p
(2.210)
where the last equality follows using the ideal gas equation and because the horizontal derivative is at constant pressure. In component form this is
−f
∂ vg R ∂T = , ∂p p ∂x
f
∂ ug R ∂T = . ∂p p ∂y
(2.211)
In log-pressure coordinates, with Z = −H ln(p/pR ), thermal wind is
f×
∂ ug R = − ∇Z T . ∂Z H
(2.212)
The physical meaning in all these cases is the same: a horizontal temperature gradient, or a temperature gradient along an isobaric surface, is accompanied by a vertical shear of the horizontal wind.
2.9 Static Instability and the Parcel Method
91
2.8.5 * Effects of rotation on hydrostatic balance Because rotation inhibits vertical motion, we might expect it to affect the requirements for hydrostasy. The simplest setting in which to see this is the rotating Boussinesq equations, (2.167). Let us non-dimensionalize these by writing
y), (x, y) = L(x, w=
u = U u,
z = H z,
βHU HU w =β , w f0 L
t = T t =
= f0 U Lφ, φ = Φφ
U t, L
= b = Bb
f = f0 f, f0 uL b, H
(2.213)
≡ βL/f0 . (If f is constant, then f is a unit vector in the vertical direction.) These where β relations are the same as (2.173), except for the scaling for w , which is suggested by (2.197), and the scaling for φ and b , which are suggested by geostrophic and thermal wind balance. Substituting into (2.167) we obtain the following scaled momentum equations:
Ro
Du = −∇φ, + f × u Dt
∂φ . 2 Dw −b Ro βα =− ∂z Dt
(2.214a,b)
/∂ z and Ro = U/(f0 L). There are two notable aspects to · ∇z + β∂ Here, D/Dt = ∂ /∂ t + u these equations. First and most obviously, when Ro 1, (2.214a) reduces to geostrophic . Second, the material derivative in (2.214b) is multiplied by three balance, f × u = −∇φ non-dimensional parameters, and we can understand the appearance of each as follows. (i) The aspect ratio dependence (α2 ) arises in the same way as for non-rotating flows — that is, because of the presence of w and z in the vertical momentum equation as opposed to (u, v) and (x, y) in the horizontal equations. (ii) The Rossby number dependence (Ro) arises because in rotating flow the pressure gradient is balanced by the Coriolis force, which is Rossby number larger than the advective terms. arises because in rotating flow w is smaller than u by β times the aspect (iii) The factor β ratio.
2 is very small for large-scale flow; the reader is invited to calculate The factor Ro βα representative values. Evidently, a rapidly rotating fluid is more likely to be in hydrostatic balance than a non-rotating fluid, other conditions being equal. The combined effects of rotation and stratification are, not surprisingly, quite subtle and we leave that topic for chapter 5.
2.9 STATIC INSTABILITY AND THE PARCEL METHOD In this and the next couple of sections we consider how a fluid might oscillate if it were perturbed away from a resting state. Our focus is on vertical displacements, and the restoring force is gravity, and we will neglect the effects of rotation, and indeed initially we will neglect horizontal motion entirely. Given that, the simplest and most direct way to approach the problem is to consider from first principles the pressure and gravitational forces on a displaced parcel. To this end, consider a fluid initially at rest in a constant gravitational field, and therefore in hydrostatic balance. Suppose that a small parcel of the
92
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
fluid is adiabatically displaced upwards by the small distance δz, without altering the overall pressure field; that is, the fluid parcel instantly assumes the pressure of its environment. If after the displacement the parcel is lighter than its environment, it will accelerate upwards, because the upward pressure gradient force is now greater than the downward gravity force on the parcel; that is, the parcel is buoyant (a manifestation of Archimedes’ principle) and the fluid is statically unstable. If on the other hand the fluid parcel finds itself heavier than its surroundings, the downward gravitational force will be greater than the upward pressure force and the fluid will sink back towards its original position and an oscillatory motion will develop. Such an equilibrium is statically stable. Using such simple ‘parcel’ arguments we will now develop criteria for the stability of the environmental profile.
2.9.1 A simple special case: a density-conserving fluid Consider first the simple case of an incompressible fluid in which the density of the displaced parcel is conserved, that is Dρ/Dt = 0 (and refer to Fig. 2.7 setting ρθ = ρ ). If the environmental profile is ρ(z) and the density of the parcel is ρ then a parcel displaced from a level z [where its density is ρ(z) ] to a level z + δz [where the density of the parcel is still ] will find that its density then differs from its surroundings by the amount ρ(z)
+ δz) = ρ(z) + δz) = − δρ = ρ(z + δz) − ρ(z − ρ(z
∂ ρ δz. ∂z
(2.215)
The parcel will be heavier than its surroundings, and therefore the parcel displacement will < 0. Similarly, it will be unstable if ∂ ρ/∂z > 0. The upward force (per be stable, if ∂ ρ/∂z unit volume) on the displaced parcel is given by
F = −gδρ = g
∂ ρ δz, ∂z
(2.216)
and thus Newton’s second law implies that the motion of the parcel is determined by
ρ(z)
∂ 2 δz ∂ ρ δz, =g 2 ∂t ∂z
(2.217)
or
∂ 2 δz g ∂ ρ δz = −N 2 δz, = ∂t 2 ρ ∂z
(2.218)
where
N2 = −
g ∂ ρ ρ ∂z
(2.219)
is the buoyancy frequency, or the Brunt–Väisälä frequency, for this problem. If N 2 > 0 then a parcel displaced upward is heavier than its surroundings, and thus experiences a restoring force; the density profile is said to be stable and N is the frequency at which the fluid parcel oscillates. If N 2 < 0, the density profile is unstable and the parcel continues to ascend and convection ensues. In liquids it is often a good approximation to replace ρ by ρ0 in the denominator of (2.219).
2.9 Static Instability and the Parcel Method
93
Fig. 2.7 A parcel is adiabatically displaced upward from level z to z + δz, preserving its potential density, which it takes from the environment at level z. If z + δz is the reference level, the potential density there is equal to the actual density. The parcel’s stability is determined by the difference between its density and the environmental density [see (2.220)]; if the difference is positive the displacement is stable, and conversely.
2.9.2 The general case: using potential density More generally, in an adiabatic displacement it is potential density, ρθ , and not density itself that is materially conserved. Consider a parcel that is displaced adiabatically a vertical distance from z to z + δz; the parcel preserves its potential density, and let us use the pressure at level z + δz as the reference level. The in situ density of the parcel at z + δz, namely ρ(z + δz), is then equal to its potential density ρθ (z + δz) and, because ρθ is conserved, this is equal to the potential density of the environment at z, ρθ (z). The difference in in situ density between the parcel and the environment at z + δz, δρ , is thus equal to the difference between the potential density of the environment at z and at z + δz. Putting this together (and see Fig. 2.7) we have
+ δz) = ρθ (z + δz) − ρθ (z + δz) δρ = ρ(z + δz) − ρ(z = ρθ (z) − ρθ (z + δz) = ρθ (z) − ρθ (z + δz), and therefore
δρ = −
∂ ρθ δz, ∂z
(2.220)
(2.221)
where the derivative on the right-hand side is the environmental gradient of potential density. If the right-hand side is positive, the parcel is heavier than its surroundings and the displacement is stable. Thus, the conditions for stability are:
∂ ρθ <0 ∂z . ∂ ρθ >0 ∂z
stability : instability :
(2.222a,b)
That is, the stability of a parcel of fluid is determined by the gradient of the locally-referenced potential density. The equation of motion of the fluid parcel is
g ∂ 2 δz = ∂t 2 ρ
∂ ρθ ∂z
δz = −N 2 δz,
(2.223)
94
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
where, noting that ρ(z) = ρθ (z) to within O(δz),
g N =− ρθ 2
∂ ρθ ∂z
.
(2.224)
This is a general expression for the buoyancy frequency, true in both liquids and gases. It is important to realize that the quantity ρθ is the locally-referenced potential density of the environment, as will become more clear below. An ideal gas In the atmosphere potential density is related to potential temperature by ρθ = pR /(θR). Using this in (2.224) gives
g ∂ θ N2 = , (2.225) θ ∂z
refers to the environmental profile of potential temperature. The reference value where θ pR does not appear, and we are free to choose this value arbitrarily — the surface pressure is a common choice. The conditions for stability, (2.222), then correspond to N 2 > 0 for stability and N 2 < 0 for instability. In the troposphere (the lowest several kilometres of the atmosphere) the average N is about 0.01 s−1 , with a corresponding period, (2π/N), of about 10 minutes. In the stratosphere (which lies above the troposphere) N 2 is a few times higher than this. A liquid ocean No simple, accurate, analytic expression is available for computing static stability in the ocean. If the ocean had no salt, then the potential density referenced to the surface would generally be a measure of the sign of stability of a fluid column, if not of the buoyancy frequency. However, in the presence of salinity, the surface-referenced potential density is not necessarily even a measure of the sign of stability, because the coefficients of compressibility βT and βS vary in different ways with pressure. To see this, suppose two neighbouring fluid elements at the surface have the same potential density, but different salinities and temperatures, and displace them both adiabatically to the deep ocean. Although their potential densities (referenced to the surface) are still equal, we can say little about their actual densities, and hence their stability relative to each other, without doing a detailed calculation because they will each have been compressed by different amounts. It is the profile of the locally-referenced potential density that determines the stability. An approximate expression for stability that is sometimes useful arises by noting that in an adiabatic displacement 1 δρθ = δρ − 2 δp = 0. (2.226) cs If the fluid is hydrostatic δp = −ρgδz so that if a parcel is displaced adiabatically its density changes according to ∂ρ ρg =− 2. (2.227) ∂z ρθ cs
2.9 Static Instability and the Parcel Method
95
If a parcel is displaced a distance δz upwards then the density difference between it and its new surroundings is
δρ = −
∂ρ ∂z
ρθ
−
∂ ρ ∂z
δz =
ρg + cs2
∂ ρ ∂z
δz,
(2.228)
where the tilde again denotes the environmental field. It follows that the stratification is given by
g 1 ∂ ρ 2 N = −g + . (2.229) ρ ∂z cs2 This expression holds for both liquids and gases, and for ideal gases it is precisely the same as (2.225) (problem 2.9). In liquids, a good approximation is to use a reference value ρ0 for the undifferentiated density in the denominator, whence (2.229) becomes equal to the Boussinesq expression (2.107). Typical values of N in the upper ocean where the density is changing most rapidly (i.e., in the pycnocline — ‘pycno’ for density, ‘cline’ for changing) are about 0.01 s−1 , falling to 0.001 s−1 in the more homogeneous abyssal ocean. These frequencies correspond to periods of about 10 and 100 minutes, respectively. * Cabbeling Cabbeling is an instability that arises because of the nonlinear equation of state of seawater. From Fig. 1.3 we see that the contours are slightly convex, bowing upwards, especially in the plot at sea level. Suppose we mix two parcels of water, each with the same density (σθ = 28, say), but with different initial values of temperature and salinity. Then the resulting parcel of water will have a temperature and a salinity equal to the average of the two parcels, but its density will be higher than either of the two original parcels. In the appropriate circumstances such mixing may thus lead to a convective instability; this may, for example, be an important source of ‘bottom water’ formation in the Weddell Sea, off Antarctica.10
2.9.3 Lapse rates in dry and moist atmospheres A dry ideal gas The negative of the rate of change of the temperature in the vertical is known as the temperature lapse rate, or often just the lapse rate, and the lapse rate corresponding to ∂ θ/∂z = 0 is called the dry adiabatic lapse rate and denoted Γd . Using θ = T (p0 /p)R/cp and ∂ p/∂z = −ρg we find that the lapse rate and the potential temperature lapse rate are related by T ∂θ g ∂T = − , (2.230) ∂z θ ∂z cp so that the dry adiabatic lapse rate is given by
Γd =
g , cp
(2.231)
as in fact we derived in (1.134). (We use the subscript d, for dry, to differentiate it from the moist lapse rate considered below.) The conditions for static stability corresponding to
96
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
(2.222) are thus: stability : instability :
∂ θ > 0; ∂z ∂ θ < 0; ∂z
or or
∂ T < Γd ∂z , ∂ T − > Γd ∂z −
(2.232a,b)
where a tilde indicates that the values are those of the environment. The atmosphere is in fact generally stable by this criterion: the observed lapse rate, corresponding to an observed buoyancy frequency of about 10−2 s−1 , is often about 7 K km−1 , whereas a dry adiabatic lapse rate is about 10 K km−1 . Why the discrepancy? One reason, particularly important in the tropics, is that the atmosphere contains water vapour. * Effects of water vapour on the lapse rate of an ideal gas The amount of water vapour that can be contained in a given volume is an increasing function of temperature (with the presence or otherwise of dry air in that volume being largely irrelevant). Thus, if a parcel of water vapour is cooled, it will eventually become saturated and water vapour will condense into liquid water. A measure of the amount of water vapour in a unit volume is its partial pressure, and the partial pressure of water vapour at saturation, es , is given by the Clausius–Clapeyron equation,
L c es d es = , dT Rv T 2
(2.233)
where Lc is the latent heat of condensation or vapourization (per unit mass) and Rv is the gas constant for water vapour. If a parcel rises adiabatically it will cool, and at some height (known as the ‘lifting condensation level’, a function of its initial temperature and humidity only) the parcel will become saturated and any further ascent will cause the water vapour to condense. The ensuing condensational heating causes the temperature and buoyancy of the parcel to increase; the parcel thus rises further, causing more water vapour to condense, and so on, and the consequence of this is that an environmental profile that is stable if the air is dry may be unstable if saturated. Let us now derive an expression for the lapse rate of a saturated parcel that is ascending adiabatically apart from the affects of condensation. Let w denote the mass of water vapour per unit mass of dry air, the mixing ratio, and let ws be the saturation mixing ratio. (ws = αes /(p − es ) ≈ αw es /p where αw = 0.62, the ratio of the mass of a water molecule to one of dry air.) The diabatic heating associated with condensation is then given by D ws , Qcond = −Lc (2.234) Dt so that the thermodynamic equation is D ln θ L c D ws =− , Dt T Dt
(2.235)
Lc Dws D ln T D ln P −R =− . Dt Dt T Dt
(2.236)
cp or, in terms of p and and T
cp
2.9 Static Instability and the Parcel Method
97
If these material derivatives are due to the parcel ascent then
R d ln p L c d ws d ln T − =− , dz cp dz T cp dz
(2.237)
and using the hydrostatic relationship and the fact that ws is a function of T and p we obtain
∂ws dT dT Lc g ∂ws =− ρg . (2.238) + − dz cp cp ∂T p dz ∂p T Solving for d T /dz , the lapse rate, Γs , of an ascending saturated parcel is given by
Γs = −
dT g 1 − ρLc (∂ ws /∂p)T g 1 + Lc ws /(RT ) . ≈ = dz cp 1 + (Lc /cp )(∂ ws /∂T )p cp 1 + L2c ws /(cp RT 2 )
(2.239)
where the last near equality follows with use of the Clausius–Clapeyron relation. The quantity Γs is variously called the pseudoadiabatic or moist adiabatic or saturated adiabatic lapse rate. Because g/cp is the dry adiabatic lapse rate Γd , Γs < Γd , and values of Γs are typically around 6 K km−1 in the lower atmosphere; however, dws /dT is an increasing function of T so that Γs decreases with increasing temperature and can be as low as 3.5 K km−1 . For a saturated parcel, the stability conditions analogous to (2.232) are
∂ T < Γs , ∂z ∂ T > Γs . − ∂z −
stability : instability :
(2.240a) (2.240b)
where T is the environmental temperature. The observed environmental profile in convecting situations is often a combination of the dry adiabatic and moist adiabatic profiles: an unsaturated parcel that is is unstable by the dry criterion will rise and cool following a dry adiabat, Γd , until it becomes saturated at the lifting condensation level, above which it will rise following a saturation adiabat, Γs . Such convection will proceed until the atmospheric column is stable and, especially in low latitudes, the lapse rate of the atmosphere is largely determined by such convective processes. * Equivalent potential temperature Suppose that all the moisture in a parcel of air condenses, and that all the heat released goes into heating the parcel. The equivalent potential temperature, θeq is the potential temperature that the parcel then achieves. We may obtain an approximate analytic expression for it by noting that the first law of thermodynamics, d–Q = T dη, then implies, by definition of potential temperature,
−Lc dw = cp T d ln θ,
(2.241)
where dw is the change in water vapour mixing ratio, so that a reduction of w via condensation leads to heating. Integrating gives, by definition of equivalent potential temperature,
0 −
w
Lc w dw = cp T
θeq d ln θ, θ
(2.242)
98
Chapter 2. Effects of Rotation and Stratification
and so, if T and Lc are assumed to be constant,
θeq = θ exp
Lc w cp T
.
(2.243)
The equivalent potential temperature so defined is approximately conserved during condensation, the approximation arising going from (2.242) to (2.243). It is a useful expression for diagnostic purposes, and in constructing theories of convection, but it is not accurate enough to use as a prognostic variable in a putatively realistic numerical model. The ‘equivalent temperature’ may be defined in terms of the equivalent potential temperature by
Teq ≡ θeq
p pR
κ .
(2.244)
2.10 GRAVITY WAVES The parcel approach to oscillations and stability, while simple and direct, is divorced from the fluid-dynamical equations of motion, making it hard to include other effects such as rotation, or to explore the effects of possible differences between the hydrostatic and nonhydrostatic cases. To remedy this, we now use the equations of motion to analyse the motion resulting from a small disturbance.
2.10.1 Gravity waves and convection in a Boussinesq fluid Let us consider a Boussinesq fluid, initially at rest, in which the buoyancy varies linearly with height and the buoyancy frequency, N , is a constant. Linearizing the equations of motion about this basic state gives the linear momentum equations,
∂ φ ∂ u =− , ∂t ∂x
∂ w ∂ φ =− + b , ∂t ∂z
(2.245a,b)
the mass continuity and thermodynamic equations,
∂ w ∂ u + = 0, ∂x ∂z
∂ b + w N 2 = 0, ∂t
(2.246a,b)
where for simplicity we assume that the flow is a function only of x and z. A little algebra gives a single equation for w ,
∂2 ∂2 + 2 ∂x ∂z2
∂2 ∂2 + N2 2 ∂t ∂x 2
w = 0.
(2.247)
Seeking solutions of the form w = Re W exp[i(kx + mz − ωt)] (where Re denotes the real part) yields the dispersion relationship for gravity waves:
ω2 =
k2 N 2 + m2
k2
.
(2.248)
2.10 Gravity Waves
99
Scaled Frequency (t/N)
1
Fig. 2.8 Scaled frequency, ω/N , plotted as a function of scaled horizontal wavenumber, k/m, using the full dispersion relation of (2.248) (solid line, asymptoting to unit value for large k/m) and with the hydrostatic dispersion relation (2.252) (dashed line, tending to ∞ for large k/m).
0.5
0 0
1
2
3
4
Scaled wavenumber (k/m)
The frequency (see Fig. 2.8) is thus always less than N , approaching N for small horizontal scales, k m. If we neglect pressure perturbations, as in the parcel argument, then the two equations, ∂ b ∂ w = b , + w N 2 = 0, (2.249) ∂t ∂t form a closed set, and give ω2 = N 2 . If the basic state density increases with height then N 2 < 0 and we expect this state to be unstable. Indeed, the disturbance grows exponentially according to exp(σ t) where
σ = iω =
(k2
±kN , + m 2 ) 1/ 2
(2.250)
2 = −N 2 . Most convective activity in the ocean and atmosphere is, ultimately, where N related to an instability of this form, although of course there are many complicating issues — water vapour in the atmosphere, salt in the ocean, the effects of rotation and so forth. Hydrostatic gravity waves and convection Let us now