Bauhaus Construct
Reconsidering the status and meaning of Bauhaus objects in relation to the multiple re-tellings of t...
284 downloads
3723 Views
71MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bauhaus Construct
Reconsidering the status and meaning of Bauhaus objects in relation to the multiple re-tellings of the school’s history, this volume positions art objects of the Bauhaus within the theoretical, artistic, historical, and cultural concerns in which they were produced and received. Collectively, its essays take into account the primacy of cultural objects in fashioning a critical history of the school. Featuring contributions from leading scholars in the history of art, architecture, and design, this volume offers an entirely new treatment of the Bauhaus, introducing new archival research and innovative methodologies which reveal how histories of the school have been constructed. Its essays demonstrate how Bauhaus objects are central to the discourse on the school and its key figures, including Paul Klee, Walter Gropius, and László Moholy-Nagy, and address the implications this has had on our understanding of the Bauhaus and modernism more generally. Issues such as art and design pedagogy, the practice of photo graphy, copyright law, and critical theory are brought into focus in relation to understandings of the iconic design school. At its core, the volume takes into account the inherent pliability of the Bauhaus and its continued relevance. An important resource for anyone studying the Bauhaus, modern art and design. Jeffrey Saletnik is Lecturer and Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of Art History and Archeology at Columbia University. Recently he was a fellow of the Berlin Program for Advanced German and European Studies at the Freie Universität Berlin. Robin Schuldenfrei is Junior Professor of Art History at Humboldt University, Berlin and Assistant Professor of Art History at the University of Illinois–Chicago.
Bauhaus Construct Fashioning Identity, Discourse and Modernism
Edited by Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
First published 2009 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2010. To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk. Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business © 2009 selection and editorial matter, Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei; individual chapters, the contributors All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. Every effort has been made to contact copyright-holders. Please advise the publisher of any errors or omissions, and these will be corrected in subsequent editions. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Bauhaus Construct : fashioning identity, discourse and modernism / edited by Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Bauhaus. 2. Art, German—20th century. 3. Design—Germany— History—20th century. 4. Avant-garde (Aesthetics)—Germany— History—20th century. I. Saletnik, Jeffrey. II. Schuldenfrei, Robin. N332.G33B4262 2010 709.04—dc22 ISBN 0-203-86867-6 Master e-book ISBN ISBN10: 0-415-77835-2 (hbk) ISBN10: 0-415-77836-0 (pbk) ISBN10: 0-203-86867-6 (ebk) ISBN13: 978-0-415-77835-0 (hbk) ISBN13: 978-0-415-77836-7 (pbk) ISBN13: 978-0-203-86867-6 (ebk)
2009014700
Contents Notes on Contributors
vii
Acknowledgments
ix
Introduction Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
1
Part 1: Agents
11
1 The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar: From the Street to the Wall to the Radio to the Memoir Karen Koehler
13
2 The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object Robin Schuldenfrei
37
3 The Disappearing Bauhaus: Architecture and its Public in the Early Federal Republic Frederic J. Schwartz
61
4 Pedagogic Objects: Josef Albers, Greenbergian Modernism, and the Bauhaus in America Jeffrey Saletnik
83
Part 2: Transference
103
5 A Refuge for Script: Paul Klee’s “Square Pictures” Annie Bourneuf
105
6 Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs Laura Muir
125
7 Excavating Surface: On the Repair and Revision of László Moholy-Nagy’s Z VII (1926) Joyce Tsai 8 Picturing Sculpture: Object, Image and Archive Paul Paret
142 163
v
Contents
Part 3: Object Identity 9 Designing Men: New Visions of Masculinity in the Photomontages of Herbert Bayer, Marcel Breuer, and László Moholy-Nagy Elizabeth Otto
181
183
10 The Bauhaus Object between Authorship and Anonymity Magdalena Droste
205
11 The Identity of Design as Intellectual Property T’ai Smith
226
Coda
245
247
Bauhaus Endgame: Ambiguity, Anxiety, and Discomfort Alina Payne
Illustration Credits
267
Index
271
vi
Contributors Annie Bourneuf is a Ph.D. candidate at Princeton University and a Dedalus Foundation Dissertation Fellow, at work on a dissertation on Paul Klee’s art of the late 1910s. Her forthcoming publications include essays on Walter Benjamin and on Gunta Stölzl. Magdalena Droste has been Chair in Art History at the Technische Universität Cottbus, Germany since 1997. From 1980 to 1997 she worked as a curator at the Bauhaus-Archiv/Museum für Gestaltung. She is the author of two books on the Bauhaus which have been translated into more than ten languages. Karen Koehler is Associate Professor of Architectural History at Hampshire College. She has published on Walter Gropius, the Bauhaus, and connections between architecture, critical theory, and pictures. Her book on the Bauhaus for Phaidon Press is forthcoming in 2010. Laura Muir is Assistant Curator of the Harvard Art Museum/Busch- Reisinger Museum, Cambridge, MA. She organized the 2001 exhibition Dancing on the Roof: Photography and the Bauhaus (1923–29) at the Metropolitan Museum of Art and is currently preparing the first exhibition devoted to Lyonel Feininger’s photographic work. Elizabeth Otto is an Assistant Professor of Art History and Visual Studies at the State University of New York at Buffalo. Her current research focuses on the gendered valences of represented bodily fragmentation in multiple media of later nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Germany. Paul Paret is Assistant Professor of Art History at The University of Utah in Salt Lake City. He received his Ph.D. from Princeton University’s Department of Art and Archaeology. Alina Payne is Professor at Harvard University and holds the Max Planck/ Alexander von Humboldt Prize, 2006. She is the author of several books and edited volumes, including Objects, Ornament and Culture: Modern Architecture and the Rise of a Theory of Objects (forthcoming). vii
Contributors
Jeffrey Saletnik is Lecturer and Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of Art History and Archeology at Columbia University. Recently he was a fellow of the Berlin Program for Advanced German and European Studies at the Freie Universität Berlin. He earned his Ph.D. at The University of Chicago. Robin Schuldenfrei is Junior Professor of Art History at Humboldt University, Berlin and Assistant Professor of Art History at the University of Illinois-Chicago. She received her Ph.D. from the Graduate School of Design, Harvard University. Frederic J. Schwartz teaches history of art and architecture at University College London. He is the author of Blind Spots: Critical Theory and the History of Art in Twentieth-Century Germany (2005) and The Werkbund: Design Theory and Mass Culture Before the First World War (1996). T’ai Smith is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Art History, Theory and Criticism at Maryland Institute College of Art. She is completing a book on the Bauhaus weaving workshop, gender, and the concept of the medium. Recently, she has begun writing on pseudonyms, anonymity, and intellectual property in modern and contemporary art and design. Joyce Tsai is currently a Predoctoral Fellow at the Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, where she is completing her dissertation, László Moholy-Nagy: Painting after Photography. She is a doctoral candidate at The Johns Hopkins University in the Humanities Center and the History of Art Department.
viii
Acknowledgments Many of the essays in this volume were first presented in March 2008 as part of “Bauhaus Palimpsest: the Object of Discourse,” a symposium funded by the Harvard Art Museum’s M. Victor Leventritt Fund. The editors co-organized this symposium with Peter Nisbet, Daimler-Benz Curator of the Busch-Reisinger Museum and Senior Lecturer in History of Art and Architecture at Harvard University. They would like to thank Thomas Lentz, Richard Benefield, Janet Sartor, and especially Peter Nisbet for their generous support at the onset of this project. The editors also would like to express their gratitude for the encouragement and efforts of Barry Bergdoll, Sabine Hartmann, Charles W. Haxthausen, Andres Lepik, Toshiko Mori, and Alina Payne, as well as John Ackerman and Dawna Schuld, both of whom offered sensitive and insightful suggestions throughout the preparation of the manuscript. At Routledge, they thank Francesca Ford and Georgina Johnson-Cook for their guidance and expertise regarding the editing, production, and design of this volume. Finally, they thank the authors for their diligence and for their dedication to this project.
ix
Introduction Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
Among the dozens of photographs taken by Lucia Moholy of the Bauhaus school building, masters’ houses, and director’s house, few are as thought-provoking and evocative as her photograph of a typewriter on a desk in Walter and Ise Gropius’s Dessau living room (Figure 0.1). Other
0.1 Lucia Moholy, Typewriter on desk in Walter Gropius’s house at the Bauhaus, Dessau, 1926, gelatin silver print, printed c. 1950, 14.9 × 11.4 cm 1
Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
photographs admirably capture work and life at the school: straightforward documentary images of the Bauhaus with its flat roof and horizontal ribbon windows, its environs not yet paved and landscaped; images of the masters’ dwellings nestled in a pine grove; photographs of the school’s interior and living quarters, with custom-designed fixtures and furnishings; and straightforward sachlich (objective) images of Bauhaus products set against plain backgrounds, such as Marcel Breuer’s chairs and Josef Hartwig’s chess sets. In another vein, there are also the iconic images of Wassily and Nina Kandinsky sitting starchily at their dining room table, and Walter and Ise Gropius in their living room, he in formal evening clothes including a bow tie. Although photography was a key mode of Bauhaus investigations, it has been not highly valued or interrogated by scholars until recently—yet photography reveals much about the school and its protagonists’ self-representation. What differentiates Lucia Moholy’s image of Gropius’s desktop and typewriter from other images of the Bauhaus is the particular attention paid in it to this one spot and set of objects within a wider object-filled environment. Unlike the subjects of her other photographs, this typewriter was not, of course, produced at the Bauhaus. Rather, Moholy depicts an object that, in a sense, produced the Bauhaus. With this and other typewriters, much of the institutional history of the Bauhaus came into being. It was an industrious object, a means for communication and asserting expertise. The construction of the Bauhaus as concept is akin to a palimp sest, having been repeatedly and at times strategically erased and rewritten. On these terms, the Bauhaus can be viewed as a document that reveals both shifting origins and subsequent revisions. In its many iterations, the Bauhaus has been beset by the weight of competing nationalisms, socio-political change, discourses of modernism, and ensuing reactions to them. Its legacy reveals changing attitudes about art-making, pedagogy, production, and authorship. This volume examines how objects produced at the school both reflected and constructed the myriad—and at times conflicting—narratives of the Bauhaus and its discursive practices, in the period of their inception and subsequently in other contexts. In the essays that follow, Bauhaus objects are viewed both as critical repositories that unlock specific pasts in specific moments and as discursively pliable. The status of the object continues to be theorized and questioned by scholars: in terms of its relation to ideas and ideology, its place in subject/object relationships, an object’s “being in the world,” and the relationship between the object and its material qualities.1 The Bauhaus presents an important locus through which to assess these and other larger issues. Bauhaus objects have often been cast as representatives
2
Introduction
of certain well-established expectations that have been joined to the early twentieth-century tradition of the modern. This volume attempts to look afresh at ways in which these objects were agents for change—and, accordingly, themselves changeable—in their own time and in the histories that issued from them and reshaped them in turn. To that end, the essays presented here shed new light on the design school’s complex history and the historical, theoretical, and political forces that molded it. They also offer insight into individual creative practices. Despite the visual suggestiveness of machine-like impersonality, Bauhaus objects are far from being anonymous. This volume therefore interrogates their relationship to identity, whether of their makers or in the fashioning of the history of the Bauhaus. It submits for renewed consideration the question of how Bauhaus objects—“Bauhaus objects” being defined in the broadest sense— maintain their relevance over the course of changing critical values. Lucia Moholy’s photograph which has the typewriter as its object is a reminder of the importance of writing and theoretical discussions at the Bauhaus. It gestures towards the idea that discourse was a primary focus of Bauhaus work. Typewriting, as a symbolic system and means for the communication of authority, can be seen as a crucial tool for conveying the ideas and larger project that the Bauhaus represented.2 Waves of written public relations campaigns were launched, especially in times of crisis—the archives are replete with letters to key cultural and political figures as the school was forced into survival mode time and time again. Before its doors were shut for the final time in Germany, its history was already being written. And in the postwar era, various protagonists strove to mold the Bauhaus’s legacy in alignment with political and social goals, an ongoing discourse that was never fixed to a certain period. Certainly the Bauhaus protagonists unabashedly took the liberty of rewriting their own history of the school, in subtle and not so subtle ways—thereby maintaining a powerful hold on it. In the written paradigm, for example, Hannes Meyer, who realized many of Gropius’s stated goals, is barely a footnote, and Gropius the perennial hero. Several authors in this volume address the stakes of strategic repositionings which were instigated by Bauhaus figures. This is an ongoing phenomenon, in which the continuing theoretical and critical reception of the Bauhaus, as construct, is as useful as an understanding of the school in its original context, if not more so. In the first part of this volume, authors address how Bauhaus masters and Bauhaus objects themselves served as agents for the school throughout its immediate, postwar, cold war, and international incarnations. Karen Koehler explores how Walter Gropius continually returned to the original Bauhaus manifesto document, a “moving object” he employed
3
Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
to recast the school in the postwar era. She notes the manipulative and intentional falsifications of memory—for polemic or for profit—stemming from memory’s multiple forms, and myriad responses to the experience of exile and displacement. Robin Schuldenfrei argues that Bauhaus protag onists were willing to call into question the status of the objects the Bauhaus produced—to sacrifice their “aura” and status as “art” in order to achieve their mass reproduction, as would have been necessary to realize the Bauhaus’s stated social goals; yet, in practice the Bauhaus was unable to do so, given qualities inherent in the objects it produced. Frederic J. Schwartz uses postwar critical positions articulated by Theodor W. Adorno and Ernst Bloch to show how the Bauhaus, as a historical legacy in the context of the young German Federal Republic, was a fraught element in discussions of the built environment. The Bauhaus, he argues, seemed to hinder postwar architectural discussions as much as it served to frame them. Jeffrey Saletnik posits that Bauhaus objects were ill received in an American context because they were “pedagogical” by nature and thus possessed an agency out of step with an emphasis upon disinterested viewing in art critical discourse at the time. He points to how the omission of Bauhaus practice from critical discourse was as significant as Gropius’s overarching—perhaps even overbearing—presence in the casting of the Bauhaus in America. These essays explore how the Bauhaus articulated its aims and controlled its public image. They also bring to the fore the agency of ideas in shaping the Bauhaus’s reception over time and consequently defining attitudes about it. Upon first glance, Moholy’s photograph is an object-filled image, in which the tactile qualities of the typewriter underscore the tactile aspects of the other objects on display, namely the Gropius-designed double desk with its overemphasized wood graining and the reflective surface qualities of the Marianne Brandt-designed desk light. And yet, in Typewriter there is no indication of work; rather, the typewriter is shown inactive and in isolation. Significantly, this typewriter did not belong to Walter Gropius, but rather to Ise Gropius. As Ise Gropius wrote to her husband two years before this photograph was taken, “[A typewriter] is a divine device and must be one of our next procurements.”3 Typewriters generally signaled a new role for women in the workplace, made tantalizingly real by Siegfried Kracauer’s evocation of a new variety of office girl trained to type to the ever-swifter beat of a gramophone.4 But especially at the Bauhaus, the manufacture of documents was also the manufacture of doctrine. Ise Gropius’s role therein was essential. As Ise Gropius recalls of her initial time in the Bauhaus orbit, “In those first months my personal contact with the school was light. I did not enter any of the workshops, as my talents lay in the literary field which
4
Introduction
made me a natural collaborator for the endless output of statements, articles and reports that were required of my husband. The fact that I was able to type proved a godsend, and for most of our married life my little typewriter was a steady companion.”5 She noted in a letter to Walter Gropius’s mother in May of 1925 that she was kept so busy attending to Bauhaus business that she had trouble keeping up with her personal correspondence.6 Much of what we know about the Bauhaus is largely that which those who sat before these machines have allowed us to read, and through which, to follow Friedrich Kittler, we hear the filtered voices of the past.7 Beyond the formal properties of the image and its contents, then, Typewriter allows a reading in which Ise Gropius’s role in fashioning the Bauhaus may be brought to the fore. Although she was a public figure, her role remained largely anonymous—yet, when viewed as existing between the message and the machine, Ise Gropius can be seen as an intendant. In an act of transference, she can be understood as transmitting order at the Bauhaus. Essays in the second part of this volume explore innovative, unexpected, and often quite personal instances of transference taking place at the Bauhaus through various close readings of its objects. Annie Bourneuf uses Paul Klee’s “Square Pictures” to examine Klee’s response to the changing parameters of reading culture. By considering the transformations of the book and the page proposed at the school, this essay addresses a perennial question of the relation of Klee’s art to its Bauhaus context. In doing so, Bourneuf illustrates a transference from reading to seeing in the context of a new text-saturated environment where writing was reconceived in relation to other surfaces. Laura Muir explores the private, contemplative nature of Lyonel Feininger’s little-known Bauhaus photographic endeavors. She demonstrates how Feininger used photography in an engaging praxis that led to new directions in his painting practice and, in turn, how his painting affected his photography. Joyce Tsai, in her examination of László Moholy-Nagy’s Z VII, shows the previously unacknowledged degree to which painting practice informed Moholy-Nagy’s interests in effects of light and transformative vision, demonstrating his use of the painted surface as a means through which problems in new media could be worked out. Paul Paret reconsiders a documentary photograph of the Bauhaus sculpture workshop as a “modernist object.” He then highlights transitions from the three-dimensional practice of sculpture to the later twodimensional practice of the workshop, and its metamorphosis into advertising and display. These authors excavate layers of meaning associated with lesser-known Bauhaus objects and show how understudied evidence, such as personal and documentary photographs, broaden understanding of the
5
Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
school, its masters, and the complex functioning of its objects. In these essays, concepts and perspectives are transferred, allowing for new readings and connections, often transliterated between media. They give rise to new productive ambiguities regarding the status of Bauhaus objects. Objects were essential to the construction of individual, critical, and collective identity at the Bauhaus, both as tools and as indices. Often they have multiple identities and iterations: Typewriter, for instance, exists as a glass plate negative from 1926, as an original print from the same year, and as a second print Gropius had made in the early 1950s. This photograph and, more importantly, the negative from which it was printed were the subjects of heated accusations and disagreements about authorship and copyright. In 1954, Lucia Moholy wrote Gropius to ask for his assistance in locating her collection of negatives, which she believed had been lost during World War II. Gropius’s reply is worth quoting at length: Regarding the Bauhaus photos, you obviously have forgotten what happened; long years ago in Berlin, you gave all these negatives to me. I have carefully kept them, had copies made of all of them and have given a full set of copies to the BuschReisinger Museum at Harvard which has built up a special Bauhaus Department which is steadily growing. I have promised them the original negatives with your name attached as soon as I do not need them any more myself. Both Ise and myself remember this clearly. You will imagine that these photos are extremely useful to me and that I have continuously made use of them; so I hope you will not deprive me of them. Wouldn’t it be sufficient if I sent you contact prints of the negatives? There are a great many, but I certainly understand that you want to make use of them yourself. Anyhow it will be a relief for you to know that they are in existence and in good shape. I have never left them out of hand.8 Moholy’s lengthy response in which she accused Gropius of depriving her of her negatives, her “most valued possessions,” was the opening salvo in a protracted battle. She wrote Gropius: I have no doubt that my negatives have been extremely useful to you, and I gather from what you say that you have had copies made of all of them, have continuously made use of them and presumably frequently published and publicly shown them. Moreover, you have, equally without my consent, given a whole
6
Introduction
0.2 Left: Lucia Moholy, Bauhaus masters’ housing, MoholyNagy’s studio window, c. 1926 (verso), 17.2 × 23 cm Right: Lucia Moholy, Bauhaus masters’ housing, Moholy-Nagy’s studio window, c. 1926, gelatin silver print 17.2 × 23 cm
set of copies to the Busch-Reisinger Museum to help them build up a special department. Do you realize what this means to me? … But this is not all. I am appalled to hear that you have promised the museum the original negatives, my negatives, with “my name attached” as if I were long dead—your only stipulation being that you do not need them any more yourself! How can you do such a thing?9 Negatives were returned to Moholy in 1957 and Gropius, for his part, remained adamant that he had done nothing untoward.10 Yet on the verso of some of the original prints given by Moholy to Gropius in 1926, one finds stamped in German: “Photo Lucia Moholy—Dessau, reproduction forbidden without permission.”11 On at least one print “reproduction forbidden without permission” has been crossed out and Gropius’s own stamp has been added, indicating his custody of the photograph (Figure 0.2). This incident between Moholy and Gropius points to conflicting opinions about authorship both at the Bauhaus and thereafter. In the third part of this volume, concerning object identity, questions of the authorship of objects come to the fore. Whereas objects might be prioritized—especially under the directorship of Gropius—as property of “the Bauhaus,” other members claimed and employed them as their individual artistic or material output. Elizabeth Otto emphasizes how the new practice of photomontage was integral to the exploration of masculinity at the Bauhaus through her analysis of montaged gifts exchanged between Bauhäusler (members of the Bauhaus). Drawing upon Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of habitus, Magdalena Droste explores the public and private strategies through which Marcel Breuer, Herbert Bayer, and Marianne Brandt sought to assert and articulate individual authorship at the Bauhaus. T’ai Smith uses a new framework to address the question of object identity at the Bauhaus, namely the legal protection of work through patents, a 7
Jeffrey Saletnik and Robin Schuldenfrei
practice intended to secure—through intellectual property—both authorship and identity. These essays complicate notions of identity which were directly and indirectly related to much discourse and activity surrounding the school—by viewing its practitioners and their objects as both singular and inextricably tied to the Bauhaus collective. As the multiple readings of Typewriter and the essays in this volume indicate, Bauhaus objects can be deployed to re-present numerous tropes through which to reexamine the Bauhaus and the work of those associated with it: the use of technology and machines at the school, photography as an important praxis of Bauhaus members, the idealization of mass production, the implications of making objects by or for one gender, and the connection between process and end-product at the school. In this context, Bauhaus objects are distinctive—pedagogic object, modernist object, consumer object, productive object—and can be employed to address the relationships through which they acquired their meaning for the variable and contested history of the Bauhaus, such as those between objects and text, between objects and protagonists, or between objects and collective identities. Whether material or discursive objects, they can be seen as both revealing and concealing the Bauhaus’s literal and figurative constructs.
Notes 1 See, for instance, Bill Brown, ed., Things (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2004), especially the introduction “Thing Theory”; and Fiona Candlin and Rainford Guins, eds, The Object Reader (London and New York: Routledge, 2009). 2 See Friedrich A. Kittler’s description of “the language of the typewriter” in his Gramophone, Film, Typewriter, trans. Geoffrey Winthrop-Young and Michael Wutz (1986; Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1999), 15–16. 3 Ise Gropius to Walter Gropius, 1 October 1924, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. “[A typewriter] ist eine göttliche Einrichtung und muss eins unserer nächsten Anschaffungsobjekte werden!” Unless otherwise noted, translations are the author’s own. 4 Siegfried Kracauer, The Salaried Masses: Duty and Distraction in Weimar Germany, trans. Quintin Hoare (1930; London: Verso, 1998), 43. 5 Ise Gropius, Diary, 31–2, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. This passage is from a c. 1968 explanatory text by Ise Gropius that accompanied the diary to the archive. 6 Letter, Ise Gropius to Manon Gropius [Walter Gropius’s mother], May 1925, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 7 See “Introduction,” in Kittler, Gramophone, Film, Typewriter, 1–19. Kittler argues that typewriting standardized writing in a manner that separated body and hand from the act of writing and, by extension, from traces of individuality: “Typewriters do not store individuals” (14). 8 Walter Gropius to Lucia Moholy, 25 February 1954, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 9 Lucia Moholy to Walter Gropius, 20 March 1954, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 10 Ise Gropius replied to Moholy’s second letter regarding the negatives, “Walter does not
8
Introduction
intend to answer your letter of March 20 [1954] himself because of the insulting insinuations it contains.” The Gropiuses laid blame upon Moholy for any miscommunication about the negatives, noting that they would have returned the negatives to her had she ever asked for them. Indeed, at the end of the letter they offered to have them packed and shipped to her at their expense. Ise Gropius to Lucia Moholy, 3 April 1954, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. Moholy consulted several lawyers about her rights both to the negatives and to compensation for reproductions without her permission. Bulcraig & Davis Solicitors advised her that, “if the photographs were taken for valuable consideration [payment], the customer can use the prints for any purpose he wishes without the permission of the photographer. The photographer only had the right to the property of the negatives.” Bulcraig & Davis Solicitors to Lucia Moholy, 23 November 1954, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 11 “Foto Lucia Moholy-Dessau, Ohne Erlaubnis, Reproduktion verboten.”
9
Part 1 Agents
Chapter 1
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar From the Street to the Wall to the Radio to the Memoir Karen Koehler This essay will investigate the strange and complex history of the Bauhaus Manifesto—a small, ephemeral document that has functioned as a symbol of the institution for ninety years. A four-paged broadsheet with a woodcut on the cover, the Manifesto has been misidentified, blown out of proportion, and seen as both a seditious and an innocuous piece of paper. From the beginning the Manifesto was problematic, and confusions have persisted through the cold war to the present. In order to unpack this complicated ambivalence, it is important to explore the Manifesto as both a material object and a mode of address—as a woodcut of a fractured and fragmented Cathedral, and as a pedagogical and political treatise that Walter Gropius continued to return to throughout his life (Figure 1.1). As the founder of the Bauhaus, Gropius is the one figure most associated with the school, and although he was replaced as director in 1928 by Hannes Meyer, and later by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, Gropius had a clear interest in controlling how the Bauhaus program was historically positioned, and therefore he continued to redraft the history of the school throughout his life. As a German émigré and later as a German-American emissary, he was also compelled to rewrite his own biography. This revisionist project (both that of Gropius and that of current scholarship) makes it clear that one must always be on the alert to scrutinize Bauhaus facts and fictions, as well as to acknowledge the interstices between the two. To that end, this essay considers the Bauhaus Manifesto as a moving object, emerging and (re)emerging at a series of extremely potent 13
Karen Koehler
historical junctures: 1919, 1923, 1938, 1944, 1947, and 1957. However, it is important to view these sightings as more than a mere chronology, and instead as part of a mutable historical and theoretical dialogue in which these later versions of the Manifesto—both visual and textual—were always operating with a memory of the previous one.
1.1 Lyonel Feininger, Cover of the “Bauhaus Proclamation,” 1919, woodcut printed in black ink on green wove paper, 117⁄8 × 75⁄16 in 14
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
Working through the Past Any work of art history is one of reconstruction. At our best, we examine the layered lives of objects, and consider successive and diverse historical moments with precision: we analyze materials formally, and as social, political, economic, and cultural constructs. If we see the work of art as the product of a specific historical moment (that is to say, situated synchronically) then its continued life is nonetheless based in some measure on its autonomy and authenticity—its diachronic perpetuation as a work of art, worthy of our attention and capable of acquiring new meaning. Yet, the specific history of the Manifesto—and of Bauhaus historiography, generally—challenge us to do more: to work creatively with the dialectical notion that art is both tied to and separate from its social construct. In part, this is because the story of the Bauhaus is inextricably fused with the complicated function that history and memory play for Germany. In part, it is because the Bauhaus itself presented us with an imperfect paradigm—as a real school made up of classrooms, teachers and students, yet also as an idea, as something timeless and without physical substance. Is it possible to situate specific Bauhaus things in this highly charged conglomerate of realities and abstractions? Certain critical theorists, themselves part of Germany’s historical trajectory in the twentieth century, offer fertile methodologies. A specialized interpretation of dialecticism, drawn from Theodor Adorno’s Aesthetic Theory, is perhaps a methodology that can be applied to, yet is also determined by, the Manifesto itself.1 The process of uncovering the strata of Bauhaus objects, what the editors of this book refer to as a “Bauhaus palimpsest,” is akin to Adorno’s questioning of “origins”—of the impulse to “trace” aesthetic forms as a reinforcement of their autonomous stature.2 It is tempting to view a Bauhaus palimpsest as something made of subsequent historical or interpretive layers, or as passive forms, that one could simply excavate to reveal an original meaning made at the moment of conception—what Adorno refers to as “sedimented content.”3 It is important to search for historic specificity, and to situate works of art as truthfully as possible into their original context. But Adorno’s dialectic challenges us to do more than that. Works of art exist as suspended moments, according to Adorno; yet the meaning of any individual work of art, and moreover of the concept of “art” itself, is located in an evolving constellation of elements. Art’s essence cannot be deduced from the original, Adorno warns us, “as if the first work were a foundation from which everything that followed were constructed and would collapse if shaken.”4 Aesthetic forms can be traced back to their origins (in this case, to Berlin in 1919), but the idea of a pure artistic essence
15
Karen Koehler
is still in opposition to itself, that is, to its historically positioned original. Furthermore, the dialectic here is legitimized, for Adorno, only by what art became with regard to what it wanted to become.5 What did the Bauhaus Manifesto become with regard to what it wanted to become? It is tempting to conclude that the closing of the Bauhaus by the National Socialists, the diplomatic moves of Gropius, and the postmodernist discrediting of any perceived Bauhaus utopia all lead to the conclusion that the Manifesto (and its author) was a failure. However, what if it is ultimately the wanting to become something, the declaration, which mattered? According to Adorno, “Artworks recuperate, neutralized, what was once literally and directly experienced in life… Artworks do not lie, [they] do not feign the literalness that speaks out of them.”6 Furthermore, if the processes of layered historicity, of the critical reconstruction of artworks, are viewed as a form of remembering—and if those works are in fact German artworks made in the Weimar period, viewed through the lens of World War II and the cold war—then it is essential that we as writers and as historians recognize that we are knowingly raising the specter of Vergangenheitsbewältigung, of the loaded postwar practice of “working through the past.”7 Evidence suggests that Gropius surely needed to.
The Bauhaus Manifesto, 1919 In 1919, in the immediate aftermath of the revolutionary end to World War I and the subsequent civil war between the Spartacists and the Reformists, the newly formed Bauhaus in Weimar issued its Manifesto, the Programm des Staatlichen Bauhauses in Weimar. On the first page is a proclamation, in which Gropius wrote of a need to bring an end to the class distinctions that existed between the handcrafts and the fine arts, and asked all artists to join him in creating the complete building: The ultimate aim of all visual arts is the complete building! To embellish buildings was once the noblest function of the fine arts. They were the indispensable components of great architecture. Today the arts exist in isolation, from which they can be rescued through the conscious, cooperative effort of all craftsmen … Architects, sculptors, painters, we must all return to the crafts!… Let us then create a new guild of craftsmen without the class distinctions that raise an arrogant barrier between craftsman and artist! Together let us desire, conceive, and create the new structure of the future, which will embrace architecture and sculpture and painting in one unity and which will one day rise 16
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
toward heaven from the hands of a million workers like the crystal symbol of a new faith.8 This twentieth-century version of a broadsheet was illustrated by Lyonel Feininger, whose woodcut of a faceted, fragmented Cathedral on the title page was a visualization of the ideas expressed within the text—an illustration of the “crystal symbol of a new faith.” Yet it was, as well, a historically charged image—an architectural symbol of the Germanic past that had been faceted and fragmented. Gropius and Feininger chose to construct a symbol, part rubble, part crystal, that was meant to be an inspiration to young artists to build a new Germany out of the refractory bits and pieces of Germany’s past—to build a cathedral of the future. The Cathedral is symbolically perhaps the single most important image for the early years of the school, yet the Manifesto was first and foremost a pamphlet, a genre of printed material that played a crucial political role in 1918–1919. There are two known versions. In the first preliminary design, which was not published and distributed, the woodcut appears with the words “Staatliches Bauhaus in Weimar” printed below (Figure 1.2). In the second print—widely distributed to art schools, magazines, and newspapers—the cathedral is much larger, covering the entire paper, and there is no wording on the cover at all (Figure 1.1). Most importantly, the treatment of the building has changed considerably—the cubofuturist fragmentation is much more insistent and all-encompassing. In the preliminary design, the use of space around the image sets it apart, while including the title, the name of the school, immediately below the image suggests that it represents the actual building where the Bauhaus was to be housed, or perhaps the type of structure the school would design. In the published print the framing device is removed, and the cathedral becomes a metaphor rather than a representation. Throughout the Revolution the streets were covered with posters. Leaflets were being passed out on every street corner, and newspapers published special editions to inform their readers of the constantly changing political situation. Programs and manifestos blanketed Berlin in particular—some of them put out by artists’ groups such as the Novembergruppe and the Arbeitsrat für Kunst, others by political factions.9 The German Revolution was initially free of bloodshed, but full of pamphleteering and printing. However, by the winter of 1918–1919, political events had taken a turn. Civil war broke out between the socialist factions that had overthrown the Kaiser only months before. At one point in the street fighting, the radicals occupied the Vorwärts building—where the Social Democrats were printing their materials, and now the stacked-up piles
17
Karen Koehler
of printed matter took on another role: that of the barricade. When the Revolution was first taking place, documents show that the question of how best to use leafleting was under discussion by all the different political factions, and when Feininger and Gropius issued the Bauhaus Manifesto in April 1919,
1.2 Lyonel Feininger, Preliminary design for Bauhaus Manifesto, 1919, woodcut with letterpress on green paper, 129⁄16 × 15½ in 18
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
they directly engaged themselves and the Bauhaus in this war of printers’ ink, for it was in Berlin, not in Weimar, that Gropius issued the Manifesto. In these various pamphlets and leaflets, the writers speak of a future society that will grow from the chaos of the postwar situation, and change social relationships—the type of architectural vision that Gropius wrote about in the Bauhaus Manifesto, and the type of architectural vision that Feininger sought to express, thematically and stylistically, in his Cathedral woodcut. If one reaches back to see the preliminary design as an underlayer for the Manifesto, it is possible to make use of Jacques Derrida’s study of memory and repression in Freud, and to use Derrida’s description of the Wunderblock, the Mystic, or Magic, Writing Pad. This well-known toy allows children to make a drawing with a stylus on a thin piece of plastic or vellum, placed on top of a waxy, darkened or carbonized pad underneath; when the child pulls up the top layer, the image is erased, although remnants of the original forms are sometimes visible on the pad beneath.10 Like the traces left on the Magic Pad, Feininger’s original design is embedded in the Manifesto, but no longer seen. In his hundreds of drawings of German churches from the war years, some straightforward, others abstracted, one can see him working through a language of fragmentation, and these sketches lend credence to this Derridean concept, of churches embedded beneath churches. These images function like unseen underdrawings, informing the Manifesto, its meanings, and its presentation each and every time it is reproduced or reinterpreted. Furthermore, in this study of Freud, Derrida explores the idea of the “breach,” what he calls the “tracing of a trail.”11 For Freud, via Derrida, a “tracing” happens when one follows a memory (both neurologically and metaphorically) and then breaks away from the memory’s path, because of barriers or obstacles. In this breakage, for Derrida, all memory becomes a form of resistance, whether or not it is ultimately erased. The idea of the breach is a useful tool to discuss how Bauhaus objects operate over time; precisely because this process works through a series of particular historical moments where memory and resistance (political and biographical) have pronounced agency.
The Cathedral of Socialism, 1923 When the Bauhaus opened in the spring of 1919, the sphere of activity moved from the streets of Berlin to the classroom in Weimar. The making of street literature was replaced by an emphasis on private work. Yet, both the language and the format of the Manifesto continued to resonate. From the very beginning conservative, nationalist groups attacked the Bauhaus, for both its modern art and its leftist ideologies. The school was attacked on racial, political, and aesthetic grounds, called internationalist, Spartacist, Jewish, 19
Karen Koehler
and anti-German, and blamed for nothing less than the disintegration of German culture. Pamphleteering played a role in these charges of “cultural bolshevism”: the presence at the Bauhaus of an Arbeitsrat für Kunst leaflet was offered as evidence of the Bauhaus as a Spartacist outpost.12 Under pressure from state authorities, the Bauhaus mounted their exhibition “Art and Technology: A New Unity” and the Manifesto again emerged. Before the exhibition opened, Oskar Schlemmer, director of the Bauhaus Theatre, prepared at Gropius’s request a pamphlet for the exhibition. Included was a section that referred to the Bauhaus as a “cathedral of socialism.”13 “The Bauhaus,” Schlemmer wrote, “founded after the catastrophe of the war, in the chaos of the revolution… is becoming the rallying point for all those who, with faith in the future and willingness to storm the heavens, wish to build the cathedral of socialism.”14 That he would identify the school in this way, just as they were working to undo the charges brought against them, is somewhat astounding. He goes on: “The triumphs of industry and technology before the war and the orgies in the name of destruction during it, called to life that impassioned romanticism that was a flaming protest against the materialism and the mechanization of art and life. The misery of the time was also a spiritual anguish.”15 As they prepared for the exhibition, from 1922 to 1923, there were charges and countercharges between Gropius and a faction of the staff, including Schlemmer’s brother Carl. The controversy concluded with a series of firings and ultimately a libel suit filed by Gropius. According to Elaine Hochman, there were also behind-the-scenes allegiances being formed by the Bauhaus with leftist political factions in the state government.16 It is unclear what Oskar Schlemmer’s motives were in 1923, and the sentiments are particularly confusing in that Gropius was trying to move the public perception of the Bauhaus into a new direction—a collaboration between art and technology, based on the design of prototypes for mass production. Schlemmer wrote: “It is in pictures, and always in pictures, where the decisive values take refuge,” and he goes on to rail against the “speed and supertension of commercialism.” It is a strange and ambiguous treatise that concludes: …we can do no more than to ponder the total plan, lay the foundations, and prepare the building stones. But We exist! We have the will! We are producing!17 Gropius retrieved as many of the leaflets as he could and destroyed them, although a few complete copies made their way to the
20
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
1.3 Oskar Schlemmer, Erste BauhausAustellung in Weimar, 1923, letterpress on paper, 8 × 1113⁄16 in
public.18 The final pamphlet that was released for the exhibition was printed without Schlemmer’s text (Figure 1.3). Yet, in the eyes of the rightist state authorities and the rabid opposition groups, the Bauhaus had made an admission simply by using the phrase “cathedral of socialism”; and the Manifesto has continued to be confused with this unfortunate sound bite to this day.19 In a more immediate context, it is clear that the episode had a resonance for Schlemmer. Four years later he wrote of the episode in his diary, and complained that it was “meaningless and malicious to lift the sentence from context and present it as the manifesto of the Bauhaus.” He goes on to defend his wording: didn’t the majority of the German people want to build the Cathedral of Socialism in 1918? Weren’t the revolution and the constitutional democracy launched in the name of a people’s state? And what is a people’s state other than socialism? Furthermore: does socialism necessarily imply the Social Democrats or the Communist Party? Isn’t socialism a concept, an ethic, not limited to any specific party?20 As we know, the Bauhaus moved from Weimar to Dessau in 1925. New buildings promised new beginnings, yet the charges of cultural bolshevism followed the school amid a darkening political climate. By 1928, Gropius had resigned and when the National Socialists took over the Dessau government in 1932, they closed the Bauhaus. After opening briefly in Berlin, the Bauhaus was shut down again, following a sham search for subversive pamphlets in 1933.21 21
Karen Koehler
The Museum of Modern Art in New York, 1938 In 1934, Gropius left Germany for England and then emigrated to the United States in 1937, when he was invited to lead the architecture program at Harvard. Precisely at the moment when he came to the United States, the House Un-American Activities Committee began to monitor the movements of communists, socialists, and foreigners in the United States, while extremists like the radio evangelist Father Coughlin found an audience for his message of anti-Semitism, and the pro-Nazi organization of German immigrants, the German-American Bund, marched openly at rallies throughout the USA. In 1938, the Austrian Anschluss and Kristallnacht took place and the importation of thousands of Jews to concentration camps had begun. The Museum of Modern Art in New York mounted an exhibition entitled “The Bauhaus, 1919–1928” in 1938, an exhibition of the work of German artists, many who had been declared degenerate, Marxist, communist, Jewish, and bolshevist by Hitler in the infamous Degenerate Art exhibition in Munich the previous year.22 As a result, antiGerman propaganda was everywhere, although officially the United States was still seeking a diplomatic solution to German aggression. These exigencies of international relations in the years preceding the outbreak of World War II prescribed the display of the objects and the catalogue description of them. According to Alfred Barr, director of the museum, “As we could have guessed, we have reports that the exhibition is considered Jewish.”23 He wanted to make a statement about why the Nazis persecuted the Bauhaus, and to state how many Jews were on the faculty. Barr proposed writing a statement that “although the Bauhaus welcomed Jewish students, there were no Jews on its faculty (or only two Jews) or whatever.”24 Gropius refused to allow such a statement to be written. While Barr feared the response of his American critics, Gropius was keenly aware of his position as a German in this country on the eve of the war. Originally scheduled to open in the spring, the exhibition was postponed due to difficulties bringing objects out of Germany, and fear of political retribution for those Bauhaus teachers, students, and defenders living under the Nazis. Due to the challenges of shipping work, the exhibition was largely a display of paintings and other objects already in the collection of the museum or the artists themselves, supplemented to a large extent by photographs of objects. The Bauhaus graphic artist Herbert Bayer and his wife were able to courier some work, and used the exhibition as a means to procure the unfortunately elusive American visa.25 One of the many visual translations in this exhibition, the
22
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
1.4 Installation view of the exhibition, “Bauhaus: 1919–1928,” The Museum of Modern Art, New York, 7 December 1938 through 30 January 1939 (IN82.7)
Bauhaus Manifesto was represented by an enlarged photograph, hung on the wall as if it were a painting, roughly ten times the size of the original leaflet (Figure 1.4). Besides completely distorting the scale and format of the Manifesto, the preliminary design was blown up, not the more final version that was actually distributed in 1919. In a strange deviation of Walter Benjamin’s argument that mass-produced objects are devoid of the aura of the original, the Bauhaus Manifesto—a broadsheet originally printed in multiple versions and distributed to newspapers and former art schools— was made into a mechanically reproduced photograph, yet shown as if it were an original object. The catalogue reproduced the same preliminary design, and as a consequence, for many years, surveys of modern art and architecture, as well as some more specialized studies of the Bauhaus continued to illustrate the wrong image—and this is representative of the many historiographic ramifications of the 1938 exhibition and catalogue. Even the exclamation points that are part of the original German were removed from the text of the Manifesto in the catalogue. The stridency of the Manifesto is tamed: no longer a piece of street literature, no longer a cubistic woodcut, less of a call to action. In the 1930s and 1940s there were over one hundred articles written by and about Gropius in English-language scholarly and professional 23
Karen Koehler
journals; publications such as Architectural Forum, Architectural Review, Architectural Record, and Pencil Points included articles by and about the architect, while magazines such as Country Life, Industrial Arts, and The Educator’s Yearbook also published his work. There was press coverage about his arrival in the United States, his job at Harvard, and his projects. The contents of these articles and reviews are exceptionally diverse, ranging from theoretical treatises and long biographical histories to brief, principally illustrated notices about his projects. Again and again and again he tells the story of the Bauhaus, while carefully sidestepping issues of socialist politics or Nazi persecution. The political situation loomed in the background of many of these articles, either implicitly or explicitly. For most of the war years, Gropius never directly engaged in a discussion of his position as an enemy alien, and rightly so. His essays remain passionate about the Bauhaus, yet his politics are like an erased text. There has been a breach.
America, the Haven, 1944 In 1944, Gropius makes an about-face, and allows a propagandistic radio play about him, America, the Haven, to be made for the United States War Information Bureau. A typescript of the play tells the fabricated tale of Gropius on a train, reminiscing about his days in Germany, while a lonesome train whistle wails in the background.26 Written by Jay Bennett, and lasting about fifteen minutes, the radio play starts with these words from an announcer: Along with other democratic lands, America has been a traditional haven for the dispossessed. And with the last decade, a newly dispossessed have sought refuge here and in other free countries. They are men and women whose only crime was the incorruptibility of their minds. Here in America they guard the culture of their homelands, a culture that is their people’s past and their hope for the future and today we should like to tell you about such a man. The eminent architect and industrial designer … Doctor Walter Gropius.27 The narrator speaks softly, as he describes Gropius beginning his exilic life: “The train has crossed the border. Germany was behind him … He sat close to the window—his wife silent behind him … The sun was hot and strong in the sky … and yet he felt cold.” A voice speaks: “My heart, my heart is mournful, yet joyously sounds the May.”28 “The words of Heine kept repeating themselves in his mind,” the narrator 24
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
continues, “My heart, my heart is mournful.” As the sound of the train whistle starts again in the distance, the narrator’s voice comes back: “Walter Gropius, architect. Born in the happy year of 1883, died in this blank year of 1934, died in that split second of time when the train crossed the border … carrying him into exile. … Died? He smiled grimly at the thought. No, he was very much alive. Alive in the past … and alive in the present because of the past. For out of the past he felt would come the inspiration and courage to carry on. He must find it. Otherwise this train he was on was a train to nowhere.”29 Gropius begins to reminisce in order to find a pattern to his life, so that he could “see his life not as a series of isolated achievements, but as a complete ordered whole.”30 The play goes on to tell the story of when Walter told his father he wanted to be an architect, because “to build is a happy thing. … To build for his fellow man.” Next we hear of an exchange between Gropius and the night watchman at the Fagus building (a factory he designed in 1911–1913) as the sound of crickets is heard in the background. The watchman wants Gropius to know how much he loves the building, because: “It’s like you were to say to people: Here is a good place where men and machines get together. … Here is a place where there is peace and happiness, and the good feelings that comes from sweating on something that is useful.” The script then turns to the creation of the Bauhaus, and a series of harsh voices come in: “Your architecture is oriental!” “You are a profaner of German culture!” “You are teaching architectural socialism!”31 According to the narrator, Gropius’s “hands clenched” when he heard the words “architectural socialism.”32 Soon the setting moves back to Gropius sitting on the train, the music is becoming louder in the background, and he is telling his wife that they will live, and they will return. “I am an exile,” he confesses to his wife, “and yet I shall live. I will continue with my work. … For there is a trust placed in me. A cultural trust. And I shall keep it.”33 The play concludes with Gropius planning for “when the world will be at peace again … when the world will begin its great task of building anew.”34
25
Karen Koehler
We know from the exchanges between Gropius and the Agency that this story, geared towards German working-class soldiers, was recognized by all of the authors as a work of fiction and of propaganda. According to a letter from Leon Meadow, Chief of the Special Features Section of the Radio Program of the Office of War Information, clearly written in response to a former protest by Gropius: I should have taken the opportunity then to present somewhat more specifically the details of time and place concerning the use of this script. Without such information, you are necessarily compelled to form your judgment somewhat out of context. It is planned to use this material as part of a series at a time when various liberated areas have been restored to some comparative degree of normalcy. I agree that the broadcasting of such a show in the immediate future would meet with unfavorable reaction from listeners still very much concerned with the brutal exigencies of war time conditions. At a later period, however, it is felt here that our basic cultural story interests can be projected plausibly and dramatically with materials such as the radio show. It would have been our desire ordinarily to do such a show as this in a half-hour period. But programming needs … demand that we limit ourselves almost completely to fifteen minute periods. And whereas, in a half-hour show, we certainly would have devoted more time to material of a factual nature, a fifteen minute program demands a rather different approach in order to hold the listeners’ attention. It must use a dramatic device—and within the framework of such a device—attempt at least to project a feeling of the whole truth, if not all the facts themselves.35 Mr. Meadow went on to say that “certainly out of the wealth of materials with which you supplied Mr. Bennett, more facts and less sentiment could have gone into this script.”36 He then asked for a small statement on the current state of architecture. Gropius replied with a list of small editorial changes and included his statement as a one-page enclosure. His 1944 “manifesto” echoed yet clearly diverged from his 1919 text, in both tone and content: For contemporary architecture has struck roots at last. After three decades of rejuvenation in trial and error its scope has gradually widened out into the vast problem of replanning man’s physical surroundings as fully integrated entities. … Foreshadowing a new society with a collective conscience, architecture
26
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
emerges from a period of spiritual impoverishment as a new social art. Visions of that new world begin to crystallize. Gropius concluded that science will bring in a new architectural language, which “by its veracity and realism … will safeguard this new and bold architectural spirit.”37 It is unclear exactly how this statement was to make its way into the radio program, or if it was simply an appeasement to Gropius. By the 1940s, the radio has joined the pamphlet as a form of manifesto-making: sound has become the counterpart of image. For example, in a pamphlet called “The Unconquered People,” about European resistance movements, made by the Office of War Information for American audiences in 1942, the author tells us that radios are “Verboten” (Figure 1.5). Yet, “regardless of the consequences, people of the occupied
1.5 Edmund Duffy, Cover illustration, The Unconquered People, 1943 27
Karen Koehler
countries continue to listen to short-wave broadcasts from the Allies. A deep hunger for truth draws them to these voices from the free world. This is a struggle of ears,” the ears of the resistance listening to the broadcast, and those of the Gestapo listening-in to catch them.38 It is unclear if the radio play about Gropius was ever produced by the Office of War Information, or ever played to a retreating German infantry or liberated populace. It is challenging to know how to position this strange piece of propaganda. Is it capitulation, self-preservation, opportunism, or naivety? What we do know is that there are multiple forms of memory, and myriad responses to the experience of exile and displacement. Between the extremes of acute trauma and forgetting as a form of psychic survival, and of manipulative and intentional falsifications of memory for polemic or for profit, there are untold stratifications. There is no question that Gropius had a comfortable position at Harvard, and one can argue over whether he was an exile or an émigré.39 Gropius was an enemy alien until 1944, the year of the radio play, at which point he became an American citizen. As Kentgens-Craig has shown, there are tragicomic FBI files, in which anonymous neighbors refer to Gropius as a spy, storing weapons in the basement of his house. There are also letters to the US Department of Justice, indicating that Gropius was required to file his itinerary every time he left Cambridge.40 Even after the war, by which point Gropius was a US citizen, he was not allowed to contribute to the design of the United Nations complex in New York, because Germany was not a member of the UN.41 To paraphrase Adorno, the radio story may be a conscious fiction, but it does not lie about its context in 1944. The narrator tells us that Gropius helped save German culture by leaving—and we see here the future set-up: after the war, the United States would control the national discourse in Germany by controlling the mnemonic devices. Furthermore, although he left Europe, Gropius would want to be considered part of the resistance.
Apollo in the Democracy, 1947–1957 A decade later, in 1957, in a defeated and divided Germany, Gropius gave a speech in Hamburg (when he won the Goethepreis) about the role of the architect as an “Apollo in the Democracy.”42 Is this new call to action a nostalgic homecoming, the product of a clever adman working with the State Department, or an authentic belief in the power of architecture? “My theme,” he begins, “concerns itself with the creation of beauty and with the measure of its reverberations in the democratic society.” By the word “democracy” he means: 28
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
neither the antique Greek form of government which rested upon the power of a comparatively small elite group of free citizens over a solid foundation of slave labor, nor do I mean the politically stressed European, American or Russian special forms of present democracy … the form of life which, without political identification, is slowly spreading over the whole world, establishing itself upon the foundation of increasing industrialization, growing communication and information services, and the broad admission of the masses to higher education and the right to vote. What is the relationship of this form of life to art and architecture today. 43 Clearly Gropius is here referencing the concept of “the civil society,” an idea that had begun to gain great currency in Germany in the postwar period. The desire was to make sense of German actions during the war, by seeing the Holocaust as a rupture of civilization, a failure not of the Germans but of humanity. By seeing the Holocaust as a bureaucratically organized and industrially realized form of mass extermination, it was therefore a failure of civilization, not of the individual. If Nazism existed below the purview of the state, than this same kind of self-realization can also exist in the alternative, as a democratic self-organization of citizens. In 1957 Gropius saw a different villain than the “hierarchy of class distinctions” that he targeted in 1919. The danger lies in the “triumphal march of the sciences.” It is this that “has crowded out the magical in our lives—the poet and the prophet have become the stepchildren of the over-practical man of purpose, who, blinded by the success of mechanized civilization, shuts himself off.” “We live in a world of ‘unending transformation’ ” Gropius stated, and “the human heart has not been able to cope with this tempo.” Society was in a state of balance just a few generations ago, and art and architecture developed slowly and organically as different branches of culture. Then with the beginning of the age of science and the development of the machine, the old social forms crumbled. Gropius put it simply: “The tools of civilization outgrew us.”44 In the context of the competing discourse in Germany in the years after World War II and the Occupation of Germany by the United States and the Allies, it becomes clear that Gropius was taking up a position here. Gropius can be seen as aligning himself with the charge that Nazism was a social deviance—and the product of what was called “the special path,” the result of Germany’s particular history (that of late industrialization and statehood). “Modern man” he wrote, “leans mechanistically on quantity instead of quality and serves utilitarian ends instead of building
29
Karen Koehler
up a new faith.”45 The phrase “building up a faith” echoed the Manifesto, yet it is no longer a crystal symbol, forged from the hands of a million workers that Gropius imagined; it is no longer art in unity with technology as it was redefined in 1923, or art asserting its authenticity. There was still a want of spiritual satisfaction; but for Gropius in 1957 art was now in conflict with science: “No society of the past ever found its significant expression without the participation of its artists: cultural problems cannot be solved by intellectual processes or political actions alone. I am speaking here of the great problem of reawakening in every individual the lost ability to create and understand form.”46 Like the Manifesto, his speech in Hamburg in 1957 is a call to action—but he was not speaking in a revolutionary tone; his new role was that of the diplomat. The way to create change, Gropius stated, was through education. We must learn to go beyond the individual to the “suprapersonal” and learn to work collaboratively—to create, he wrote, total works of architecture that embraced the entire environment from the simplest utensil to the complicated city, searching after new truths in cooperation with other like-minded artists.47 Again, he drew attention to the operations of a civil society. But did Gropius really ask us to join him? When he first gave this speech, Gropius was being honored for his work as an architect and an educator. Did he, in fact, reject the very idea of a collaborative society, and want us to see him as a hero who saved German culture by going into exile? It was not Gropius’s first postwar homecoming. In 1947 he was appointed by the US Department of the Army to serve as a consultant for planning the reconstruction of Germany. Returning to Germany for the first time since his exile, reporting to the American Military Governor of Germany, Gropius wrote to his wife that “Berlin is a has been! A desecrated corpse! … the people bent down, bitter, hopeless.”48 After his tour of the country, Gropius reported that he felt that simply to rebuild would not be enough—that there had to be an overall effort to remake Germany economically, physically, and emotionally. “Apollo in the Democracy” is closely tied to this immediate postwar period, particularly to the controlled, imposed memories that are part of what came to be known as “re-education.”49 Re-education was a catchall phrase for the Occupation in general, the idea that the entire country of Germany had to be forced to think differently. According to official US proclamations, “German education must be so organized … so as to establish an affirmative program of reorientation designed to encourage the development of democratic ideas and institutions … The reconstruction of the cultural life of Germany must be in large measure the work of the Germans themselves and must be fostered,
30
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
not only on a regional but also on a national scale.”50 It was thought that this would be done by leaders in education, art, and professional organizations who would be persons concerned with the “reorientation of [the] German people towards peace and democracy … Whenever possible, preference shall be given to persons who have demonstrated their opposition to Nazism.” 51 The stated goal of the occupying Allies (although perhaps not their practice) was to “encourage humanitarian feelings, [and] freedom of thought and expression … to aid the German people … to redirect their own social institutions and to revive the values of German culture.”52 In keeping with Thomas Mann’s famous postwar claim that there were two Germanys, the Allies wanted to promote the idea of Germany as a cultural entity, not a political one. In this, Germany could be rebuilt and recuperated as a cultural state, yet humiliated and incapacitated as a political one.53 Many other postwar intellectuals promoted re-education along these lines. In 1946 historian Friedrich Meinecke called for the creation of “Goethe communities” that would be organized, if at all possible, in churches.54 In these communities, readings of poetry and music would revive Germany’s tradition of humanism in the spirit of Goethe’s and Schil ler’s Weimar. Also in 1946, the philosopher Karl Jaspers directly addressed the question of collective guilt, and insisted that Germany must acknowledge and incorporate its guilt into any future German culture, within a new civil society. Jaspers believed that the university as an institution could recreate a dialogue between the sciences and the spirit, between science and the humanities. For Jaspers, “science without wisdom is meaningless, wisdom without science is unreal.”55 When Gropius spoke of the Apollo, it was ten years later, in 1957, and he was receiving one of many awards from various German state and local governments. His lectures in Germany in the 1950s drew thousands; he was treated as someone who saved German architectural culture by going into exile. It was, in fact, his Americanization that allowed him to be seen so reverently in Germany at this time. He was completely free from any possible charges of collaboration with the Nazis, something that many German architects could not claim. Gropius was at this time surely straddling two worlds (European and American) and two generations (prewar and postwar). Germany in 1957 was a country on the mend; West Germany was experiencing a period of rapid growth, but it was still a world divided. There were significant tensions between Germany and the different powers controlling different geographical spheres—the European, American, and Russian—precisely those “democracies” that Gropius referred to in his opening passage. He claimed that these nations are equally in crisis,
31
Karen Koehler
unable to recognize beauty. Yet he also mentioned them all, in Germany, in 1957. It is impossible to know what he meant precisely in doing this; yet it is surely significant that he did. Was Gropius the diplomat strategically acknowledging that they all had power in Germany? Or, was he somehow chastising them all? In the 1950s, there was an ongoing struggle in western Europe between Communism and anti-communism. Although many did not join official Communist parties, and many others changed course when the full extent of Stalin’s purges became publicized, there was a fascination among European intellectuals with working-class issues and left-wing politics, and this struggle spilled into both political and intellectual spheres. To answer this, cultural and artistic organizations in Europe and in the US worked to counter Marxist intellectuals. The first Congress for Cultural Freedom was held in Berlin in 1950, eventually growing to open up offices in 35 countries worldwide—although attention was focused on France, Italy, and Germany. The Congress was publicly underwritten by the Ford Foundation, and covertly underwritten by the CIA. In the 1950s, the US Information Agency had taken over the propaganda campaign in Europe, eventually employing 13,000 people and spending $129 million on the battle for sympathies of the intelligentsia.56 Although surely an oversimplification, Tony Judt writes that many Europeans after the war saw the world in terms of binary oppositions: black vs. white, good vs. evil, freedom vs. slavery, workers vs. aristocrats, fascist vs. communist, fascist vs. democratic.57 The most important designation was resistance vs. collaboration. The old Europe had been discredited; unquestioning belief in the good of humankind had been destroyed. When Adorno claimed that “To write poetry after Auschwitz was barbaric” he was, in fact, not calling for the end of art but calling for a reevaluation of aesthetic value in a postwar world.58 In “Apollo in the Democracy,” Gropius dismissed the antique Greek form of government, where a small elite group of free citizens existed on a foundation of slave labor. He also rejected the “stressed European, American or Russian … forms of democracy” and called instead for a new “form of life which, without political identification … [was] spreading over the whole world, establishing itself upon the foundation of increasing industrialization, growing communication and information services.”59 Gropius was attempting to position his comments somewhere within this intellectual divide. When he spoke of a lost sense of balance and unity, and decried that civilized man had lost his totality, he was, perhaps, recognizing and engaging in this ideological debate, albeit with a kind of duplicity. As the savior of German architectural culture, he can ally himself with the heroic resistance. But as the American statesman, he avoids the implications
32
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
of Communist sympathies, so closely allied with much of the European resistance movements. Gropius’s “Apollo” speech was published first in a new art magazine, Zodiac, in 1957. The text was published again in 1968, the year before his death, as the lead piece in a collection of his writings, which taken together make a kind of essayistic memoir. The book appeared with the subtitle: “The Cultural Obligation of the Architect,” as if to echo Jean-Paul Sartre’s existentialist call for commitment.60 Art was not to be just beautiful, or just activist, entirely independent or wholly assigned to a social context and function. Art affirmed its aesthetic autonomy through its negation: as a consequence of its social purpose. As Gropius nostalgically stated, he wanted his writings to represent a commentary on what he calls the incessant search to create an architectural environment for twentieth-century man … Only when we intrinsically learn to see things in their broader context, only when we have a sensitivity to the beautiful awakened in all of us, will the chain reaction necessary for the betterment of our world take place … That which is useful furthers itself, for the many produce it, and no one can do without it … the beautiful must be furthered, for few create it, and many need it.61 Do we collectively help build a better world, like his million workers of 1919, or do we appreciate the beauty of others who do it? Gropius’s program for postwar reconstruction has moved from a call for collective creative action at the end of World War I to a desire for a sensitive kind of viewing at the end of World War II. He shifted the mode of address from the world of the political to the world of the cultural; he recognized the two Germanys and chose where and how to re-educate. Yet, despite the repositioning of the audience, the Adornian dialectic has remained true: in “Apollo” and in the Manifesto, from postwar to postwar, we see a tension between the authentic and the contingent, between the layers of history and the need to erase them in response to immediate needs. By placing his Apollo into the context of détente it is evident that the rubble of the Bauhaus Manifesto was simultaneously celebrated and camouflaged in this postwar treatise.
33
Karen Koehler
Acknowledgments I want to thank the editors Robin Schuldenfrei and Jeffrey Saletnik for their thoughtful contributions to this essay, as well as my colleagues Monique Roelofs and Barton Byg for their suggestions to look to Adorno and Derrida to unravel the layers of the Manifesto.
Notes 1 Theodor Adorno, Aesthetic Theory, ed. Gretel Adorno and Rolf Tiedemann, trans. Robert Hullot-Kentor (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1997). For extended studies of the relationship between the critical theory of the Frankfurt School and modern architecture, see, for example, Hilde Heynen, Architecture and Modernity: A Critique (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1999) and Frederic J. Schwartz, Blind Spots: Critical Theory and the History of Art in Twentieth-Century Germany (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2005). 2 Adorno, Aesthetic Theory, 2–5. 3 Ibid., 5. 4 Ibid., 2. 5 Ibid., 3. 6 Ibid., 5. 7 Adorno, “The Meaning of Working Through the Past,” in Can One Live After Auschwitz? A Philosophical Reader, ed. Rolf Tiedeman (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2003), 4–18. The debate over Vergangenheitsbewältigung has been a volatile topic since the end of the war, and continues to this day; the literature on the topic is vast. See, for example, Norbert Frei, Vergangenheitspolitik. Die Anfänge der Bundesrepublik und die NS-Vergangenheit (Munich: C.H. Beck, 1996); Jeffrey Herf, Divided Memory: The Nazi Past in the Two Germanys (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1997); Charles Maier, The Unmasterable Past: History, Holocaust, and German National Identity (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1988). 8 Walter Gropius, “Programm des Staatlichen Bauhauses in Weimar,” 1919, in Hans Maria Wingler, The Bauhaus: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago, trans. Wolfgang Jabs and Basil Gilbert (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1969). 9 Katherine Ida Rigby, An Alle Künstler! War Revolution Weimar (San Diego: San Diego University Press, 1983); Joan Weinstein, The End of Expressionism: Art and the November Revolution in Germany, 1918–1919 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990). For contemporaneous studies see: Oscar Gehrig, Plakatkunst und Revolution (Berlin: Wasmuth, 1919); Adolf Behne, Paul Landau and Herbert Löwing, Das politische Plakat (Charlottenburg: Verlag “Das Plakat,” 1919). 10 Jacques Derrida, “Freud and the Scene of Writing,” in Writing and Difference, trans. Alan Bass (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1978), 199. 11 Ibid., 200. 12 Ministry of Culture in Weimar, “Results of the Investigation Concerning the Staatliche Bauhaus in Weimar,” Supplement to the “Dispute over the Staatliche Bauhaus,” Weimar, 1920, in Hans Maria Wingler, The Bauhaus: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago, ed. Joseph Stein, trans. Wolfgang Jabs and Basil Gilbert (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1976), 42. 13 For a discussion of how the concept of the Gesamtkunstwerk in the 1919 Manifesto was transformed by the 1923 exhibition, see Eva Forgács, Bauhaus Idea and Bauhaus Politics, trans. John Bákti (Budapest: Central European Press, 1995), 98–117. For other documents related to the exhibition, see Wingler, Bauhaus, 64–8, and Frank Whitford, ed., The Bauhaus Masters and Students by Themselves (Woodstock, NY: Overlook Press, 1993), 141–57.
34
The Bauhaus Manifesto Postwar to Postwar
14 Oskar Schlemmer, “The Staatliche Bauhaus in Weimar, Manifesto from the Publicity Pamphlet ‘The First Bauhaus Exhibition in Weimar July to September 1923’,” in Wingler, Bauhaus, 65–6. 15 Ibid. 16 See Elaine Hochman, Bauhaus: Crucible of Modernism (New York: Fromm International, 1997), 147–51. Unfortunately, this book does not reference original documents. 17 Oskar Schlemmer, “Staatliche Bauhaus.” 18 Reginald Isaacs, Walter Gropius (Boston: Bullfinch, 1991), 102; Wingler, Bauhaus, 65. 19 See, for example, Deborah Wye, Artists and Prints: Masterworks from The Museum of Modern Art (New York: Museum of Modern Art, 2004), 67. 20 Oskar Schlemmer, The Letters and Diaries of Oskar Schlemmer, ed. Tut Schlemmer, trans. Krishna Winston (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1972), 200. 21 See Hans Kessler, “Letter to his mother, Berlin April 14, 1933,” in Whitford, Bauhaus Masters, 302. 22 Artists from the “Communist Bauhaus” were prominently featured in the Degenerate Art exhibition. See Stephanie Barron, ed., Degenerate Art: The Fate of the Avant-Garde in Nazi Germany (Los Angeles: Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 1990), 49–80. 23 Alfred Barr to Walter Gropius, 10 December 1938, Exhibition File “The Bauhaus 1919–1928,” Exhibition no. 82, Department of Registration, Museum of Modern Art, New York, NY. 24 Ibid. For a more detailed discussion of the 1938 exhibition, see Karen Koehler, “The Bauhaus 1919–1928: Gropius in Exile and the Museum of Modern Art, 1938,” in Art, Culture, and Media Under the Third Reich, ed. Richard Etlin (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002), 287–315. 25 See Arthur A. Cohen, Herbert Bayer (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1984), 41–2. 26 Walter Gropius Archive, Houghton Manuscript Library, Harvard University, by permission of Houghton Library, Harvard University (hereafter WGA), bMSGer 208 (1654): item 1, letter from US Office of War Information, 1944, including mimeograph copy of the radio script America, The Haven #5; item 2, letter to Office of War Information, 1944, with enclosure. 27 “America, the Haven,” bMSGer 208 (1654) in WGA. 28 Ibid. 29 Ibid. 30 Ibid. 31 Ibid. 32 Ibid. 33 Ibid. 34 Ibid. 35 Leon Meadow to Walter Gropius, 10 May 1944, bMSGer 208 (1654) in WGA. 36 Ibid. 37 Walter Gropius to Leon Meadow, 16 June 1944 (carbon copy with enclosure), bMSGer 208 (1654) in WGA. This is essentially the same statement that he also wrote for an exhibition, America Builds, in 1944, bMSGer 208 (65), WGA. 38 United States Office of War Information, The Unconquered People (Washington, DC: OWI, 1942), 7. For more on the use of radio as wartime propaganda, see Lawrence Soley, Radio Warfare: OSS and CIA Subversive Propaganda (New York: Praeger, 1989); Allan M. Winkler, The Politics of Propaganda: The Office of War Information 1942–1945 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1978); Holly Cowan Shulman, The Voice of American Propaganda and Democracy 1941–1945 (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1990). 39 See Peter Hahn, “Bauhaus and Exile: Bauhaus Architects and Designers between the Old World and the New,” and Kathleen James, “Changing the Agenda from German Modernism
35
Karen Koehler
to U.S. Internationalism,” in Exiles and Emigrés: The Flight of European Artists from Hitler, ed. Stephanie Barron (Los Angeles: Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 1997), 211–24, 235–52. 40 Margret Kentgens-Craig, The Bauhaus and America (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1999), 238–40. For examples of correspondence between Gropius and the State Department, see bMSGer (1652), WGA. 41 Eric Mumford, The CIAM Discourse on Urbanism 1928–1960 (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2000), 160. 42 Isaacs, Walter Gropius, 280–1. 43 Gropius, “Apollo in the Democracy,” [1957] bMSGer (230), WGA. First published in Zodiac 1 (October 1957): 9–14; later, Gropius dates the speech to 1956, in his collected essays Apollo in the Democracy (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1968), 3–14. 44 Gropius, Apollo in the Democracy (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1968), 5. 45 Ibid. 46 Ibid., 8. 47 Ibid., 9. 48 Isaacs, Walter Gropius, 259. 49 Jaimey Fisher, Disciplining Germany: Youth, Reeducation, and Reconstruction after the Second World War (Detroit: Wayne State Press, 2007); Konrad H. Jarausch, Recivilizing Germans 1945–1995, trans. Brandon Hunziker (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2006); Jeffrey K. Olick, In the House of the Hangman: The Agonies of German Defeat, 1943–49 (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 2005). 50 “Military Government Regulations, Aim of Education” (March 1947) in United States Department of State, Germany 1947–49: The Story in Documents (Washington, DC: Library of Congress, 1950), 541–2. 51 “Visits of German Nationals to the United States and of Persons from the United States to Germany: Policy Statement” (October, 1946), ibid., 611–12. 52 Ibid., 614. 53 Thomas Mann, Germany and the Germans (Washington, DC: Library of Congress, 1945). 54 Friedrich Meinecke, The German Catastrophe, trans. Sidney Fay (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1950). 55 Fisher, Disciplining Germany, 146. 56 Tony Judt, Postwar: A History of Europe Since 1945 (New York: Penguin, 2005), 222–3. 57 Ibid., 197–225. 58 Adorno, “Cultural Criticism and Society” (1949), in Adorno, Can One Live After Auschwitz?, 162. 59 Gropius, Apollo in the Democracy, 3. 60 Jean-Paul Sartre, What is Literature?, trans. Bernard Frechtman (New York: Philosophical Library, 1949). 61 Gropius, Apollo in the Democracy, vii.
36
Chapter 2
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object Robin Schuldenfrei
Objects produced at the Bauhaus occupy an uneasy juncture between the canonical history of modern art and architecture, period culture, and issues such as the production and consumption of modernism.1 In 1923, Walter Gropius articulated the aims of the Bauhaus with the proclamation, “art and technology—a new unity,” which advanced the use of new materials, more stripped-down forms, and a spare, functional aesthetic. His successor Hannes Meyer pronounced instead: “people’s needs instead of luxury needs”
2.1 Otto Rittweger and Wolfgang Tümpel, Stands with Tea Infusers, 1924, German silver (Photograph by Lucia Moholy, 1925, printed c. 1950), gelatin silver print 37
Robin Schuldenfrei
(Volksbedarf statt Luxusbedarf)—but would he have been moved to make such a declaration if Gropius had successfully carried out his stated aims? The failure of Gropius’s Bauhaus to merge art and technology—to move from the production of individual, luxury objects to mass reproduction—is the subject of this essay. To be discussed are the objects produced under Gropius from 1923 to 1928, the period of his overtures to industry. This repertoire of specialized objects—including silver and ebony tea services, modern chess sets, and children’s toys, to name just a few canonical works—represents a paradigmatic example by which to examine the relationship between modernism’s discourse and its material results. Expensive in their day, original Bauhaus products are now art objects displayed in museum vitrines as individual works of art. Often hailed for the mythic merging of forward-thinking ideas and modern production techniques, they are asked to illustrate modernism’s unflinching belief in the powers of industry. And they are presented as objects of discourse, the material evidence of a series of debates on handcraftsmanship, machine production, and taste. This essay considers and contextualizes the ways in which the Bauhaus produced its modern objects and the extent to which, despite its egalitarian ideals, the school ultimately spoke to—and designed for—an elite. The products of the Bauhaus, ostensibly intended for mass production, were expensive, difficult to fabricate, and never sold on a widespread basis, reflecting the economic realities of producing and purchasing modern objects. Essential to this discussion is the problem of reproduction itself. Engaging Walter Benjamin’s essay “The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility,” this chapter will recognize that, ideologically, the Bauhaus protagonists were willing to call the status of the objects the Bauhaus produced into question—to sacrifice their “aura” and status as “art” in order to achieve their mass reproduction; yet, in practice the Bauhaus was unable to do so.2 This failure was due to the limits to the reproducibility of Bauhaus objects—themselves a product of their place in the Weimar social order that they also sought to transform.
Luxury Objects Upon first glance the small teapot designed and executed in 1924 by Marianne Brandt at the Bauhaus evinces all of the concepts that modernism proclaimed—Sachlichkeit, functionality, hygiene, and the use of modern materials and construction methods (Figure 2.2).3 To all appearances it is a thoroughly modern object. Surface decoration has been eschewed in favor of pared-down, machine-like geometrical shapes that form the round lid, the semicircular handle, and the crossed base. But although it suggests machine production, it was laboriously hand-wrought in the Bauhaus 38
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
2.2 Marianne Brandt, Tea Infuser and Strainer, 1924, silver, Katalog der Muster, Bauhaus GmbH, 1925, photomechanical print in black and orange inks on white paper (Graphic design by Herbert Bayer)
workshop at great cost. This diminutive pot’s handle and knob are ebony, and it was only available in silver when ordered through the Bauhaus GmbH catalogue.4 Out of the numerous objects designed at the school, its presence among the other twelve products selected in 1925–1926 for inclusion in the product catalogue suggests that it was deemed representative of the Bauhaus. Yet, it could not be inexpensively mass-produced in these materials, nor was it intended to be; as the catalogue notes, it featured “exacting handcraftsmanship.” In any case, its smooth form and the meticulous joins of its body to its spout and base lacked the surface ornamentation that hid imperfections that occurred in cheaply produced factory goods of this period, resulting in an object that would have been very difficult to industrially fabricate with precision. Thus, it could be serially produced by hand in the metal workshop in limited quantities, but it was not—in form, material, or price—suitable for mass reproduction. It was, in short, a luxury object in need of an elite consumer—and not only one who could afford it, but one who understood both its modern form and its underlying ideas.5 Bauhaus goods were also highly legible expressions of affluence. 39
Robin Schuldenfrei
Though the Bauhaus proposed to utilize industry to make goods that even the masses could afford, it played to a privileged audience—especially members of the industrial and educated upper middle class (respectively the Wirtschaftsbürgertum and Bildungsbürgertum). Despite the rise of German industrialism, accompanied by the ascent of technical firms such as AEG, Siemens, and numerous smaller rivals, the objects produced by the Bauhaus were not items associated with the machine age, such as advanced electrical goods. Equally revealing, the school’s products did not advocate an entirely new way of living, unlike designs of its contemporaries, such as Grete Lihotzky’s mass-produced Frankfurt Kitchen of 1926 (a minuscule modern kitchen designed for maximum efficiency which limited the number of steps needed to perform tasks, following the scientific principles of Frederick Winslow Taylor) or Hannes Meyer’s Coop-Zimmer (a radically pared-down single room supplied with standard elements to meet the absolute minimum needs for dwelling; see Figure 12.4, page 256). Gropius’s stated aims for the workshops, from about 1923 onwards, reiterated the Bauhaus’s desire to develop “standard types for all practical commodities of everyday use.”6 And yet, given this charge, why were there no Bauhaus forks, an ordinary product that could be easily molded or stamped out in large quantities at low cost? Instead the school remained committed to producing the types of traditional, conventional objects—chess sets, teapots, tea services, tea containers, ashtrays, and armchairs—that already had a place in upper-class homes (Figure 2.3).
2.3 Bauhaus vitrine, Ausstellung Europäisches Kunstgewerbe, 1927, GrassiMuseum, Leipzig 40
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
2.4 Above: Wilhelm Wagenfeld (designer; executed by Josef Knau), Kugelförmige Kannen (Sphereshaped jugs), 1924, silver-plated brass, German silver lids and hinges (Photograph by Lucia Moholy, 1924, printed c. 1950) Below: German Werkbund (designer unknown), Warenbuch silver jugs, c. 1915
Bauhaus objects employed a stripped-down vocabulary of forms while reducing applied ornament; the result was an object that was modern and yet familiar.7 One can see this process at work in Wilhelm Wagenfeld’s 1924 Bauhaus design for a set of small, sphere-shaped jugs, which rework some Werkbund Warenbuch-endorsed silver versions available at least as early as 1915 (Figure 2.4).8 The earlier jugs featured delicate, reedcovered handles and a hand-hammered arts and crafts finish; the Bauhaus counterparts were simplified and more geometric but had the same general form and function. Material costs were reduced in the Bauhaus versions by employing silver-plated brass and German silver—which, tellingly, maintained the appearance of real silver.9 But older, luxurious materials such as silver and ebony also remained part of the Bauhaus repertoire throughout the 1920s. A Bauhaus egg cooker from 1926 had an ebony handle, for example. A number of objects, such as Brandt’s teapot (ME 8) and tea service with water pot (ME 24), were advertised in silver, obviously a luxury material (Figures 2.2, 2.5). Already expensive because they were
41
Robin Schuldenfrei
2.5 Marianne Brandt, Tea service with Water pot, 1924, silver with ebony handles, Katalog der Muster, Bauhaus GmbH, 1925, photomechanical print in black and orange inks on white paper (Graphic design by Herbert Bayer)
handmade, objects in finer materials raised costs significantly, allowing quality to take precedence over the goods’ accessibility to a broader public. In other words, the Bauhaus did not reinvent products, but simply introduced known objects in new “modern” forms and occasionally new materials. It did not wish to alienate its potential consumers with modernism, but rather to accommodate their perceived needs and already articulated desires for a certain repertoire of goods, which were then given a modernist treatment. Under Gropius, even through the late 1920s, the school introduced very little that was unfamiliar, and relied on established, traditional luxury objects prevalent in the upper echelons of culture. Rather than overwhelm its audience with wholly new ideas and goods, the Bauhaus created its new market through consensualist means, remaining committed to designing the types of weighty, representative objects that the bourgeoisie might be enticed to buy. In doing so, the Bauhaus appealed to what Benjamin described as the authority of traditional art objects, that is, the authority that they retained through their relationship to a tradition and in the context of established social rituals. Traditional Kunstgewerbe (decorative arts) objects such as the tea service with its array of accoutrements (tea infuser, water pot, creamer, sugar bowl) maintained this autonomous authority through their role in the customs that guided patterns of life in bourgeois homes. These social rituals continued to maintain a distance between the object and its user—the aura, the “unique apparition of a distance, however near it may
42
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
be”—that sustained traditional authority.10 Technological reproducibility, on the other hand, “emancipates the work of art from its parasitic subservience to ritual.”11 For the Bauhaus to have engaged in successful mass reproduction of standard objects of everyday use, it would have been necessary that objects—rather than shoring up their withering aura through an appeal to tradition—instead be produced in such a manner that they successfully reached the masses. Bauhaus goods were also prohibitively expensive. To put their prices in perspective, it is important to note that the average income for a working-class (Arbeiter) family in 1927 was about 64 Marks per week and for a white-collar (Angestellten) family, around 91 Marks per week.12 Marcel Breuer’s “Wassily” chair, not in leather but merely in fabric, cost 60 Marks, around a week’s worth of wages for a worker.13 The silver Bauhaus cookie tin (Keksdose) cost 160 Marks, the teapot cost 90 Marks, and the five-piece tea service in German silver cost 180 Marks, three times a worker’s weekly wage (Figures 2.3, 2.5). As Bauhaus artist Otto Rittweger noted in 1926: “Today it is more difficult than ever for the vast majority of people who would like to possess such a [Bauhaus] service to actually afford one.”14 Comparatively, a non-Bauhaus, generic nickeled coffee set cost only 10 Marks. Bauhaus objects were not consumed by the masses; in 1925, even if they could have afforded a Bauhaus lamp, 81 percent of the inhabitants in Berlin’s working-class areas lived without electricity.15 Indeed, the start-up costs of mass production or the high projected sale prices often kept goods from ever being produced. On several occasions, Gropius commented that the costs for producing the objects were higher than what the market could bear and that the selling price of Bauhaus goods was artificially high in order to meet costs associated with balancing the Bauhaus budget and the purchase of raw materials in small quantities rather than in bulk.16 Objects from the metal workshop were especially unaffordable as both labor and material costs were high, but goods from the other workshops were also costly, and it was often the more expensive objects that were promoted. For example, there were two categories of Bauhaus chess sets: the standard version “intended for use” (Gebrauchsspiel), and the “luxury” version (Luxusspiel), which was made by hand or in small batches, using rare and costly types of wood.17 While the standard wood chess set was priced at 51 Marks, the walnut version cost 155 Marks.18 The Luxusspiel was marketed early on through a series of postcards, two of which featured the word Luxus prominently in the advertising copy (Figure 2.6). Gropius had to contend with the accusation that the products of the Bauhaus were simply another form of expensive, artistic luxury
43
Robin Schuldenfrei
2.6 Postcard advertising Josef Hartwig’s Bauhaus chess set, 1924, lithograph (Graphic design by Joost Schmidt)
similar to the output of other schools of arts and crafts (Kunstgewerbe).19 He was careful to articulate that the Bauhaus was involved in creating artistic objects within the present economic paradigm, but asserted early on that its work was not involved in “artistic luxury affairs” (künstlerische Luxus angelegenheit).20 László Moholy-Nagy, around 1928, conceived of a dialogue between a “well-meaning critic” of the Bauhaus and a “representative of the Bauhaus.” In it, the critic charges that Bauhaus objects have become luxury objects, accessible only to a few.21 To this, the representative of the Bauhaus replies that during the initial phases the objects were so expensive that only a few wealthy people were able to buy them, but that the luxury product itself was merely an intermediate link in the development towards becoming an object of everyday use.22 This intriguing line of reasoning— that the objects were part of an evolution from luxury to accessibility—does not appear to have gained wider currency. During Gropius’s tenure, a tension existed between concurrent realities: the production of serial objects by hand, the ideal of the prototype, and the desire for mass production. By never fully reaching the mass production stage, because of their cost and nature, the Bauhaus’s products ultimately remained luxury objects. Following Benjamin’s formulation, the very act of the mass reproduction and dissemination of Bauhaus goods—rather than small, serialized production of multiple copies made by hand—would have allowed them to be brought out of the rarified realm of luxury and tradition: It might be stated as a general formula that the technology of reproduction detaches the reproduced object from the sphere of tradition. By replicating the work many times over, it substitutes a mass existence for a unique existence. And in permitting
44
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
the reproduction to reach the recipient in his or her own situation, it actualizes that which is reproduced.23 The cost and exclusivity of Bauhaus objects were related to the fact that they were turned out in small batches, mainly to fill specific commissions, in a workshop system. As Benjamin observes, In principle, the work of art has always been reproducible. Objects made by humans could always be copied by humans. Replicas were made by pupils in practicing for their craft, by masters in disseminating their works, and, finally, by third parties in pursuit of profit. But the technological reproduction of artworks is something new.24 At the Bauhaus, the move to technological reproduction would have had to entail the object’s overcoming of its tradition-grounded formal qualities so as to be determined instead by its inherent reproducibility; in Benjamin’s words, “the work reproduced becomes the reproduction of a work designed for reproducibility.”25 Thus in terms of the Bauhaus project, the fact that Bauhaus objects were visually modern was less important than the fact that they were never reproduced in any significant numbers.
Bauhaus Modern on Display In addition to the school building in Dessau, which not only housed the school but showcased its ideas, the nearby houses of the school’s masters were on view and played a very public role in setting the context for Bauhaus objects, eliciting interest in the media and the public alike (Figure 2.7). Like the Bauhaus objects, Gropius’s director’s house and the three double masters’ houses advertise an aesthetic of mass reproducibility but in fact are also an example of limited serial production. It is not insignificant that their inhabitants often referred to them as “villas”; they represented a rarified form of dwelling and were meant to function as lived-in showpieces for the school’s theories and ideals, allowing the Bauhaus to exhibit the products of its workshops in an instructive and architecturally appropriate domestic setting. Ise Gropius’s diary charts an unending stream of important visitors representing an elevated, educated segment of the population—from trade organizations and cultural groups to politicians, modern architects, artists, cultural critics, period intellectuals, and professors.26 Even a year after they had been completed, there seemed to be no indication that interest in the houses was waning, as Lyonel Feininger wrote exasperatedly to his wife in the fall of 1927: “What is going on here is beyond
45
Robin Schuldenfrei
2.7 Above: Walter Gropius (Architect), Bauhaus Masters’ Housing, Interior of Moholy-Nagy House, Dessau, 1925–1926, gelatin silver print (Photograph by Lucia Moholy, c. 1925) Below: Tea corner in the Gropius House, Dessau, 1925–1926, gelatin silver print (Photograph by Lucia Moholy, 1926)
belief and almost beyond endurance. Crowds of idlers slowly amble along Burgkühnauer Allee, from morning to night, goggling at our houses, not to speak of trespassing in our gardens to stare in the windows.”27 According to Dessau Mayor Fritz Hesse, between 1927 and 1930 the Bauhaus buildings received over 20,000 visitors.28 This indicates that their modern design and contents were not quickly assimilated into the general culture but remained objects of fascination. The director’s house, in particular, functioned as an “exhibition house,” playing a very public role. As Feininger wrote to his wife, “Gropius’s house, of course, is miraculous. The furniture and the entire setup are intended as representative.”29 The house boasted an appliance-filled kitchen with labor-saving conveniences, such as an automatic soap-infused sprayer for the dishes, an early clothes washer, and a centrifuge dryer. But these devices were for the hired help, an expected domestic arrangement 46
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
for a couple of their social standing. Period films celebrating the house depict a uniformed maid at work while Ise Gropius drinks tea with friends in the living room “tea corner” (Figure 2.7). Serviced by hot and cold running water and an electric tea kettle, it aptly illustrates the merging of bourgeois habits and precious objects with modern technology and convenience, with little pretense towards universal application. The dining room featured Bauhaus furniture made out of costly nickel-plated tubular steel, an adjustable plate warmer, and other electrical appliances that could be plugged in directly to the floor outlets conveniently placed in the center of the room, adjacent to the table. A fan installed in the living room was connected to the central heating system behind the wall, so that warmed, but fresh, air could be brought in during the winter. Gropius’s 1930 book Bauhausbauten Dessau acknowledged that this feature, like many others in the house, was an extravagance, and predicted that “today a lot still functions as luxury, that will be the norm the day after tomorrow!”30 At a time when modern architects looked to mass production for interior fittings, and when massproduced, plain porcelain sinks were readily available, Gropius’s bathroom featured a luxurious richly marble-veined double sink, flanked by glass-lined walls. The Bauhausbauten book erased the marble veining from the sink to make it appear more industrial and less luxurious. Perhaps tellingly, Gropius employed a chauffeur and his house was the only one with a garage. Generally, the house was not portrayed for what it really was—a prohibitively expensive design for the powerful director of the Bauhaus.
Productive Operations As early as April 1922 and continuing into 1923, the Bauhaus masters and Gropius had discussed the necessity of organizing the workshops into a productive operation (Produktiv-Betrieb), and indicated that they viewed the school itself as a locus of productive operations (Produktiv-Apparat).31 Gropius envisioned products from Bauhaus prototypes, reproduced via methods of standardization and large-scale sales as the only way that goods could be offered at a reasonable price.32 The Bauhaus’s embrace of an industrial means of production was the result of external political and economic as well as internal pressures. This proposed shift in the activities and overall orientation of the workshops, clearly articulated by Gropius, was founded on an astonishingly immodest premise: to sway the industrial powers of 1920s Germany.33 Although factory production was the stated desire after 1923, throughout the entire history of the school, small orders were filled for specific patrons in response to requests via correspondence and personal 47
Robin Schuldenfrei
visits to the Bauhaus.34 From small objects to furnishings for entire apartments, original pieces were produced, not just in the Weimar period as might be expected, when original crafts were the mainstay, but throughout the Dessau period too.35 Students were expected to spend a specific number of hours in their chosen workshop with a portion of that time devoted to formal instruction and the acquisition of technical skills, but orders for Bauhaus goods also had to be filled. A general lack of production capacity in the workshops due to labor, financial, and materials shortages, meant that orders were constantly delayed or only partially supplied. In 1924 the Bauhaus manager Emil Lange wrote Gropius a long letter containing recommendations for making the workshops economically sound.36 Lange does not suggest reviewing the overall design process, the internal production costs, or whether the products were appealing to potential buyers; to the contrary, he expresses frustration with the caprice of buyers and the unpredictability in their ordering patterns, apparently showing little acumen about the market and tools of selling. This lack of attunement to consumer desire was a continual problem. But more importantly, the Bauhaus continued to be oriented toward workshop production rather than to what successful mass reproduction would have had to entail. During 1924 and 1925 the Bauhaus took important measures to shore up its finances and implemented some basic operations to organize its fairly autonomous workshops into a more comprehensive entity for the purposes of selling designs. The first mention of a “Bauhaus-AG” appears in conjunction with the possible uses of profits from the school’s 1923 exhibition.37 In January 1924, Gropius began lengthy proceedings with the government over the founding of a separate Bauhaus company, the Bauhaus GmbH.38 In a long meeting on 18 February 1924 Gropius laid out plans for an economically feasible Bauhaus corporation, discussing its relationship to the workshops, provisions for student employment, and payment— either by piecework or wages.39 At this stage, the general plan was not to outsource production to other companies, but rather to internally organize the labor and productivity of the workshops according to what Gropius called the “free market” (freie Wirtschaft). An agreement template was drawn up that gave the Bauhaus GmbH the rights to all objects made at the school and stipulated that the designer was not to make similar objects on his own.40 In return, the company would pay for every approved design and give the designer up to 30 percent of the resulting profits.41 The company hired a business manager, Walter Haas, to act as a conduit between the Bauhaus and industry, to market the prototypes designed in the workshops, and to oversee the reproduction of objects. The Bauhaus printed up stationery and invoices for the GmbH, which was legally a separate entity.
48
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
Under the aegis of the Bauhaus GmbH, the school began to organize its products into one comprehensive sales catalogue, known as the Katalog der Muster.42 There are two versions. A single sheet, probably designed by Moholy-Nagy, appeared with just four selected products, perhaps those viewed as most marketable. A multi-page, orange and black version, designed by Herbert Bayer with photographs by Lucia Moholy, appeared in November of 1925 (Figures 2.2, 2.5). This catalogue was a loose-leaf booklet, organized by workshop, in which each product or product group could be removed and function as a stand-alone information sheet. A separate price list, which could be periodically updated, possibly accompanied it. The objects could be ordered individually from the Bauhaus GmbH, although the hope was for mass production through the company itself. Presented as single objects on individual leaflets, the products in the Katalog der Muster are not offered as part of a comprehensive Bauhaus collection, in that the objects are organized by workshop rather than by use or intended room. The images project the clean, clutter-free ideal of modernism, but the design also reflects the straightforwardness of standard product catalogues of the period. There is a careful estrangement of the objects from their surroundings. The images, through their coldness and detachment, highlight the alluring, surface qualities of the individual objects rather than their potential for use. Whereas in an earlier period the workshops had been guided by an ideal of working in tandem to create an integrated interior—as took place in the 1920 Sommerfeld House or the Haus am Horn exhibition house in 1923—the Katalog der Muster represents a shift to the pursuit of the single object, or type-object, for wider production. As Gropius stated unequivocally, the workshops’ mandate was to create standard types for practical commodities. Yet the objects selected for the catalogue represent some of the school’s most elite objects and arguably many of its least practical ones—a full silver tea service, the tea container and tea balls, the chess set, and several ashtrays which, among other objects, would not have been easily stamped out or otherwise mass-produced by machine. Furthermore, several designs note “most exacting” (genaueste) or “finest handcraftsmanship” (feinste Handarbeit), calling into question whether some of the objects in the catalogue were ever intended for mass production. The “Inventory of Work and Ownership Rights of the Workshops,” made prior to the move to Dessau, serves as a good indication of what the Bauhaus had produced by April of 1925, and lists the objects that it theoretically could have selected from when assembling the Katalog der Muster.43 Simpler, arguably more easily mass-producible objects on the 49
Robin Schuldenfrei
list, such as tablecloths, pillows, scarves, or drapes being produced in the weaving workshop, are notably absent from the catalogue. Another method by which the Bauhaus sought to draw German industrialists to its goods was through participation in trade shows, especially the twice-yearly Leipzig Trade Fair, at which the school exhibited objects regularly from 1924 to 1931, selling goods and taking orders to be filled by the workshops.44 As with the Katalog der Muster, the Leipzig activities underscore the ambiguity of the Bauhaus’s program: the products represented elite, one-off goods to be sold for profit as well as prototypes intended for mass production. In 1927, four years after Gropius’s turn to industry, the Bauhaus was selected to represent Germany at the Ausstellung Europäisches Kunstgewerbe (European Applied Arts Exhibition), held in conjunction with the regular Leipzig fair (Figure 2.3). Chosen not as a producer of modern, rational goods intended for industry but rather for their fine craftsmanship, the handmade, luxurious nature of the goods comes to the fore. Bauhaus objects, including a hammered, silver-lined fish poaching dish, were put on display in the same room as Meissen porcelain and other expensive goods made in Germany. This conjunction illustrates the Bauhaus’s difficult position of trying to be modern while existing within the context of Kunstgewerbe, the applied arts, with the skilled training in the traditional crafts that it required. The workshops continued to occupy an unclear position between their role as producers of the unique art object and as designers of prototypes for mass reproduction. Although industrial production and the formation of an alliance between the Bauhaus and industry was a carefully articulated goal, even an underlying principle, which Gropius reiterated in speeches and writings and which is implied in the “industrial” aesthetics of the objects, there is little evidence beyond the Katalog der Muster and trade fair exhibitions that clear steps toward the formalization of relations with industry were taken.45 As years passed, the situation began to appear dire, as MoholyNagy admitted in 1928: “Designs for vessels and appliances, with which we have been occupied for years, have so far not been sold to industry.”46 Outside visitors, such as art theorist Rudolf Arnheim, similarly noted: “Certainly the Bauhaus has not yet come so far as to be able to supply industry with conclusively standard patterns.”47 A contract finally materialized in 1927 with the metalworks factory Paul Stotz AG of Stuttgart to manufacture and distribute the glass lamp, although it was not fulfilled.48 Later, relations with the manufacturers Körting & Mathiesen and Schwintzer & Gräff brought lighting to the market in significant numbers for the first time in the Bauhaus’s history.49 In the end, only four workshops were ever able to deliver models to industry—carpentry, weaving, metal, and wall
50
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
painting—and Gropius’s ideal of working closely with manufacturers never materialized.50 Only three firms began negotiations during his tenure; the rest came during that of his successors, mainly Hannes Meyer. Practically speaking, Bauhaus objects were not mass-produced in any number, nor picked up by industry in general. It is important to differentiate between objects that were genuinely mass-reproducible and the visual propagation of an idea of modern, reproducible products. This idea of paring objects down to their essences appealed to students and masters at the Bauhaus as a visual and conceptual task—though outside the school the objects met with limited success. Bauhaus objects did not transform function but rather attempted to distill the object’s essential function, as in the visually pared-down tea extraction pot which was refined until it poured well (Figure 2.2). Yet, designed to make a very strong cup of tea, its contents needed to be diluted with hot water from yet another vessel—resulting in the proliferation, rather than reduction, of household objects. What remained important to the Bauhaus, if not the consuming public, was the aesthetic of simple, machine-like forms, the elevation of function, and the idea of mass reproduction. Buyers, in any case, were skeptical. Even though Gropius stressed that the Bauhaus workshops were addressing the “necessities of life of the majority of people” and viewed the home and its furnishings as “mass consumer goods,” and though the school wanted to limit designs to “characteristic, primary forms and colors, readily accessible to everyone,” the masses themselves did not embrace the modern goods.51 Convincing them to value a teapot’s severe reduction in form and decoration for its attendant Bauhaus ideology was arguably as much of a hindrance as its price tag. These objects were not received with wide enthusiasm outside an elite of left-wing artistic and intellectual circles, the members of which understood the principles of the school and its objects, or what was sometimes termed the “Intellektuell-Sachliches”—even among those who could afford them.52 A list of workshop commissions completed in 1926 notes mainly avant-garde art galleries as patrons.53 Photographs of industrialists’ interiors, for example, reveal homes amply laden with modern paintings and sculpture yet virtually no modern design objects. Surprisingly, modern interiors, such as those by Marcel Breuer, do not feature Bauhaus objects on their tables or shelves with any frequency either.54 It is very difficult, outside of its own buildings and photographs, to find the products of the Bauhaus in domestic settings. As Grete Lihotzky, in her important 1927 essay “Rationalization in the Household,” ends her devastating critique: “Years of effort on the part of the German Werkbund and individual architects, countless articles and lectures demanding clarity,
51
Robin Schuldenfrei
simplicity, and efficiency in furnishings, as well as a turn away from the traditional kitsch of the last fifty years, have had almost no effect whatsoever.”55 Other sources, too, indicate that Bauhaus objects were estranged from public taste; according to a critic for the Frankfurter Zeitung the Bauhaus was “even further from the general taste of the public than the Werkbund.”56 The legacy of the Bauhaus’s products lies more with an idea and a few canonical objects than with any widespread material reality or mass adoption of modern objects.
Production/Reproduction How then should these issues of production figure in the assessment of the Bauhaus’s significance? Should the Bauhaus be viewed as an entity that failed to produce objects that buyers wanted to consume or that manufacturers wanted to produce? Should Bauhaus objects be understood as unique, authentic works of art—which may be their historical fate, judging by their scarcity and their status in art museums today? Walter Benjamin’s postulation that “what withers in the age of the technological reproducibility of the work of art is the latter’s aura” is useful for reflecting on the status of these objects within the conditions of production of their time.57 The status of art and art objects, including objects intended for use, in such an age was precisely the question that Gropius faced at the Bauhaus. As proclaimed by his slogan “art and technology—a new unity,” his emphasis was on both art and technology, and specifically their relation to each other. The nineteenth-century heritage of Kunstgewerbe and its postWorld War I revival shaped the school’s earliest incarnation, which explicitly attempted to recover that heritage via the high-quality art object of the craftsman. This heritage continued to shape subsequent activities at the school, although Gropius carefully sought to elude what he termed “dilettantism of the handicrafts” (kunstgewerblichen Dilettantismus).58 Simultaneously he worked to counter the “ersatz” and low-quality products of an industrializing Germany. The potential for degradation of Bauhaus designs through the reproduction process was of continual concern to Gropius, who offered the reassurance that a decline in the quality of the product’s material and construction, as a result of mechanical reproduction, would be countered by all available means.59 Gropius thus sought to mass-produce well-designed objects by industrial methods without ever wholly freeing the school from the Kunstgewerbe legacy of the design of the singular work of art produced in small numbers. According to Benjamin’s theory, given the reality of small batches in the workshops, these objects would 52
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
have safeguarded their own, autonomous authority, grounded in tradition, and resisted being taken up and appropriated by the masses. However, a loss of aura and authority would necessarily have resulted if the Bauhaus had succeeded in factory mass reproduction. These issues of production and reproduction of art, architecture, and objects were a subject of period concern among theorists and critics, such as Benjamin and the architectural critic Adolf Behne, artists such as Moholy-Nagy, and architects such as Gropius.60 Each had different, specific ideas, but the terms and the overarching concern—the relationship of the authentic art object to the modern means of production—formed an important commonality of period discourse. In his 1917 essay, “The Reproductive Age” (Das reproduktive Zeitalter), Behne argued that, unlike with earlier authentic artworks, technological reproduction caused the essential effect—Wirkung—of the original to be lost, and yet the aesthetic values of the work of art were transferred to the reproductive process itself.61 Moholy-Nagy’s 1922 essay “Production-Reproduction” went further, specifying the goal of making reproductive processes useful for creative activities.62 Benjamin identified the loss of authenticity and aura and the turn to mass reproduction as inevitable consequences of the modern transformation in conditions of production, which nonetheless bore great artistic and political potential, while Moholy-Nagy, and the Bauhaus generally, actively endorsed mass reproduction as an art practice. Perhaps the Bauhaus should be assessed in terms not of production, but of reproduction—the stage at which it failed most visibly to realize its aims.63 As Gropius shifted the emphasis of the Bauhaus towards mass reproduction, along with other basic operations he instituted, he was reacting not to a change in the availability of industrial technology, but rather to a change in ideas about process. In an attempt to broaden consumption, the Bauhaus needed to move from concentrating on production (where it arguably did well, generating many functionally and aesthetically successful designs in a relatively short period of time) to reproduction. As this examination has shown, reproduction, as both a practical process and a theoretical construct, is precisely where a material and economic failure took place; at the same time, theoretical signification can be read from this historical episode. In evaluating the Bauhaus, it is the emphasis laid on the process of reproduction that is important and imbued with social significance in the context of the period. As K. Michael Hays has pointed out, Benjamin’s analysis reveals that as one approaches those mediums that are inherently multiple and reproducible, not only does the authenticity of the object, its here and now, lose its value as a repository of meaning, but also the
53
Robin Schuldenfrei
reproductive technique as procedure takes on the features of a system of signification. Meaning arises from the multiple forces of social practice rather than the formal qualities of the auratic art object.64 Thus the potential significance of the Bauhaus project under Gropius lies less in the objects themselves that were produced than in the Bauhaus’s grappling with the problem of reproducibility. The members of the Bauhaus saw their larger project not just as art practice but as a part of social practice, as MoholyNagy wrote: “We hope that from the inspirations of the Bauhaus, such results will come forth as will be useful to a new social order.”65 This social function, for Benjamin and for the Bauhaus, occurred when the art object was reproduced in such a way that what it would lose in aura it would make up for by reaching society at large, becoming available for its use. For Benjamin, the social function of art was revolutionized as soon as the criterion of authenticity ceased to be applicable to artistic production.66 The actual objects designed by the Bauhaus, however, were not consonant with what was needed to achieve its goals for reproduction, as their elite qualities stymied the social project. In their relationship to society, the object-types the Bauhaus produced—such as silver tea services—were insufficient; their luxury character limited their reproducibility, perhaps equally as much as their costly fabrication and materials. As a result of this disjunction, Bauhaus objects can be read as material indices of the social problematic of mass reproducibility. Benjamin pinpoints the transformation that occurs in the modern age from the autonomous authority of the art object itself to its social determination by its inherent technological reproducibility. That Gropius’s Bauhaus embraced mass reproduction as a system and a goal is meaningful even if it was unable to realize this goal to any significant, material degree. As Josef Albers noted, “The greatest success of the Bauhaus was to win over and interest industry. We realized this aim only to a small degree.”67 Indeed, the idea of a relationship with industry remained the Bauhaus’s greatest achievement, even if it was hardly realized. The Bauhaus inserted itself into this system of signification through the ideal of reproduction, and it was willing to sacrifice the auratic or authentic qualities of its objects to do so. An essential legacy of Bauhaus objects is the mythical aspiration of good design for the masses, achieved through an alignment with industrial production. And meaning can be derived from this ideal even if it never occurred at the level of actual Bauhaus products. Through their very failure as objects of reproduction and mass consumption, the products of the Bauhaus paradoxically retained both their authenticity and their aura, for, in an age of mechanical reproduction—that is, of the definitive withering of aura—an individual Bauhaus object, such
54
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
as a Brandt teapot, remains a work of art. To acknowledge this by conceding these objects’ elite, luxury status, however, calls into question the received, mythological account of the Bauhaus’s contribution to the trajectory of modernism. It also re-poses the question of what designing objects for mass reproduction—and socially transformative use by society, by the masses—might entail.
Acknowledgments This essay has benefited from thoughtful suggestions by John Ackerman, Annie Bourneuf, Charles W. Haxthausen, Jennifer Hock, and Klaus Weber, whom I would like to thank. I also thank Peter Nisbet and Laura Muir at the Busch-Reisinger Museum, Harvard University, and Sabine Hartmann at the Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin.
Notes 1 For related discussion of these concerns, see especially Frederic J. Schwartz, “Utopia for Sale: The Bauhaus and Weimar Germany’s Consumer Culture,” in Bauhaus Culture: From Weimar to the Cold War, ed. Kathleen James-Chakraborty (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2006), 115–38; and Anna Rowland, “Business Management at the Weimar Bauhaus,” Journal of Design History 1, no. 3–4 (1988), 153–75. 2 Walter Benjamin, “The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility,” in Walter Benjamin: Selected Writings, ed. Howard Eiland and Michael W. Jennings, vol. 3, 1935–1938 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 2002), 101–36. Benjamin composed this essay in the autumn of 1935; the version used here is the 1936 second version which the editors note represents the form in which Benjamin originally wished to see the work published. A third, revised version remained unfinished at Benjamin’s death and was published posthumously. See also Benjamin, The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility, and Other Writings on Media, ed. Michael W. Jennings, Brigid Doherty, and Thomas Y. Levin (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 2008). When Benjamin makes his famous proclamation, “What withers in the age of the technological reproducibility of the work of art is the latter’s aura,” he immediately follows it with: “This process is symptomatic; its significance extends far beyond the realm of art” (emphasis added, 104). He begins his essay, in a similar vein, with Marx, noting that it “has taken more than half a century for the change in the conditions of production to be manifested in all areas of culture” (emphasis added, 101). In the essay, Benjamin largely discusses this process as it manifests itself in images and film. However it is clear throughout that the significance of the phenomena he explicates is not limited to these areas of culture alone; Benjamin also specifically addresses architecture, literature, medicine, music, and coins. Moreover, Benjamin uses a number of different terms to refer to his subject, not only “artwork” (Kunstwerk), but also object of art (Gegenstand der Kunst), object (Objekt), thing (Sache), all of which have been predominantly translated as “artwork,” perhaps contributing to a common perception that Benjamin is only talking about the visual arts. The distinct importance of architecture at a late stage in Benjamin’s discussion—which brings it into particular proximity with film and makes “the laws of its reception … the most instructive” in relation to new forms of mass participation in art—lies in the fact that buildings are received in a twofold manner: by perception and by use (120). The significance of
55
Robin Schuldenfrei
Benjamin’s essay for understanding the problem of the reproducibility of Bauhaus objects will hang precisely on the potential for technologically reproducible objects to make themselves available for mass use. On production and reproduction in architecture and art, see Beatriz Colomina, ed., Architectureproduction (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1988), especially K. Michael Hays, “Reproduction and Negation: The Cognitive Project of the Avant-Garde,” 153–79; Charles W. Haxthausen, “Reproduction/Repetition: Walter Benjamin/Carl Einstein,” October 107, no. 47 (winter, 2004): 47–74; Esther Leslie, “Walter Benjamin: Traces of Craft,” Journal of Design History 11, no. 1 (1998): 5–13; and Andrew Benjamin, ed., Walter Benjamin and Art (London: Continuum, 2005). For contacts between Walter Benjamin and Moholy-Nagy during the latter’s years at the Bauhaus—and Moholy-Nagy’s influence upon Benjamin—see “Walter Benjamin and the Avant-Garde,” in Frederic J. Schwartz, Blind Spots: Critical Theory and the History of Art in Twentieth-Century Germany (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2005), especially pp. 42–50. In other writings Benjamin devotes sustained attention to domestic objects as part of the same constellation of themes also found in the “Work of Art” essay. See, for example, “Louis-Philippe, or the Interior,” section 4, “Paris, Capital of the Nineteenth Century,” in Walter Benjamin: Selected Writings, ed. Howard Eiland and Michael W. Jennings, vol. 3, 38–9, and June 8 entry in “May–June 1931,” in Walter Benjamin: Selected Writings, ed. Michael W. Jennings, Howard Eiland, and Gary Smith, vol. 2, 1927–1934 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 1999), 479–80. 3 Sachlichkeit presents difficulties in translation; it could be translated as “factualness” or “objectiveness.” As Rosemarie Bletter has pointed out, the term simultaneously suggests the “world of real objects” and that of “conceptual rationalism.” See Bletter, introduction to Adolf Behne, The Modern Functional Building (Santa Monica: The Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1996), 48. 4 A nearly identical version, MT 49, was available from the Bauhaus in brass or red brass with a silver-plated interior and a silver strainer, but it was not among the chosen objects featured in the Katalog der Muster. Klaus Weber, curator at the Bauhaus-Archiv/Museum für Gestaltung, notes that there are presently only seven known period examples of this teapot. Correspondence with author, 9 March 2009. 5 This was also the case for the other objects featured in the Bauhaus catalogue, as well as for the overwhelming majority of the products of the Bauhaus in this period. 6 Walter Gropius, “Bauhaus Produktion,” Qualität 4, no. 7–8 (Juli/August 1925): 130. Translation from a nearly identical version of the essay in Hans Maria Wingler, The Bauhaus: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago, ed. Joseph Stein, trans. Wolfgang Jabs and Basil Gilbert (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1976), 110. Gropius continued to recall this purpose long after leaving: “The creation of standard types for the articles of daily use was their main concern. These workshops were essentially laboratories in which the models for such products were carefully evolved and constantly improved.” Walter Gropius, “Education Toward Creative Design,” American Architect and Architecture (May 1937): 28. 7 For invaluable research on the entire span of production in the Bauhaus’s metal workshops and their main artisans, see Klaus Weber, ed., Die Metallwerkstatt am Bauhaus (Berlin: Kupfergraben Verlagsgesellschaft, 1992). 8 The 1915 Werkbund Book of Wares (Warenbuch) was a selection of domestic German goods that met the Werkbund’s design standards. See Heide Rezepa-Zabel, Deutsches Warenbuch Reprint und Dokumentation: Gediegenes Gerät fürs Haus (Berlin: Dietrich Reimer, 2005). 9 German silver, or Neusilber, as it was called in German, had the appearance of silver but was a surrogate made of an alloy of copper, zinc, and nickel. 10 Benjamin, “Work of Art,” 104–6.
56
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
11 Benjamin, “Work of Art,” 106. 12 Die Lebenshaltung von 2,000 Arbeiter-, Angestellten-, und Beamten-Haushaltungen: Erhebungen von Wirtschaftsrechnungen im Deutschen Reich von Jahre 1927–1928, Einzelschriften zur Statistik des deutschen Reichs, no. 22 (Berlin: R. Hobbing, 1932). Specific industries paid significantly less; for example, a male spinner in the textile industry earned 44 Marks per week in 1927, while a female spinner earned 28 Marks per week and unskilled workers earned even less. Statistischen Reichsamt, Statistisches Jahrbuch für das Deutsche Reich (Berlin: Verlag von Reimar Hobbing, 1930). For the day-to-day struggle on this wage, see Deutscher Textilarbeiterverband, ed., Mein Arbeitstag, Mein Wochenende. 150 Berichte von Textilarbeiterinnen (Berlin: Textilpraxis Verlag, 1930), 187–9; and “Die Misere des ‘neuen Mittelstands’,” Die Weltbühne 24, no. 4 (22 January 1929): 130–4. 13 Standard-möbel catalogue, 1927, n.p., Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 14 Otto Rittweger, Vivos Voco 5, no. 8–9 (1926): 293–4; translated in Posthumous Works Designed While Living: Metallwerkstatt Bauhaus 20’s/90’s, ed. Bruno Pedretti (Milan: Electa, 1995), 34–5. 15 Die Grundstücks- und Wohnungsaufnahme sowie die Volks-, Berufs- und Betriebszahlung in Berlin im Jahre 1925 (Berlin, 1928), table 8; quoted in Nicholas Bullock, “First the Kitchen: Then the Façade,” Journal of Design History 1, no. 3–4 (1988): 188. 16 For example, see Dr Necker and Walter Gropius, “Bericht über die wirtschaftlichen Aussichten des Bauhauses,” 19 October 1924, typed manuscript, pp. 1–2, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 17 Anne Bobzin and Klaus Weber, Das Bauhaus-Schachspiel von Josef Hartwig (Berlin: Bauhaus-Archiv, 2006), 17–21. 18 Ausstellung “Die Form,” 1924, exhibition checklist with prices, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 19 For example, the Czech architect and critic Karel Teige chastised the Bauhaus early on for its emphasis on the crafts: “Today, the crafts are nothing but a luxury, supported by the bourgeoisie with their individualism and snobbery and their purely decorative point of view.” Karel Teige, Stavba (1924); translated in Bauhaus, 1919–1928, ed. Herbert Bayer, Walter Gropius, and Ise Gropius (New York: Museum of Modern Art, 1938; reprint, Boston: Charles T. Branford Co., 1952), 91. 20 Walter Gropius, Weimar, to Staatsminister Greil, 11 November 1922, p. 2, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. Unless otherwise noted, translations are the author’s own. 21 László Moholy-Nagy (presumed), “Dialogue between a Well-meaning Critic and a Representative of the Bauhaus, Weimar-Dessau,” c. 1928; translated in Krisztina Passuth, MoholyNagy (London: Thames and Hudson, 1985), 400. The identity of the author of this document has not been conclusively established; the document is in the possession of Moholy-Nagy’s daughter, Hattula Moholy-Nagy and presumed to be written by Moholy-Nagy. 22 Ibid., 401. 23 Benjamin, “Work of Art,” 104. 24 Ibid., 102. 25 Ibid., 106. 26 Ise Gropius, Diary, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 27 Lyonel Feininger, Dessau, to Julia Feininger, 2 October 1927, Houghton Library, Harvard University, Cambridge; translated in Lyonel Feininger, Lyonel Feininger, ed. June L. Ness (New York: Praeger, 1974), 158. 28 Fritz Hesse, Von der Residenz zur Bauhausstadt (Hannover: Schmorl & von Seefeld, 1963), 238. 29 Lyonel Feininger, Dessau, to Julia Feininger, 6 August 1926, Houghton Library; translated in Feininger, Feininger, 152. 30 Walter Gropius, Bauhausbauten Dessau (München: A. Langen, 1930), 112. 31 Protokoll, Sitzung der Meister und Werkstättenleiter des Staatlichen Bauhauses, 7 April 1922, Weimar, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin; Protokoll des Bauhausrates, 22 October 1923, in Die
57
Robin Schuldenfrei
Meisterratsprotokolle des Staatlichen Bauhauses Weimar 1919 bis 1925, ed. Volker Wahl (Weimar: Verlag Hermann Böhlaus Nachfolger, 2001), 319. “Produktiv-Betrieb” can also be translated as “productive company,” but it is not clear from the original context if a company is specifically meant at this early date. 32 Gropius, “Bauhaus Produktion,” 135; translated in Wingler, Bauhaus, 110. 33 Walter Gropius, “Education Toward Creative Design,” American Architect and Architecture 150 (May 1937): 28. Although this was written years later, it succinctly captures the direction of this period: “The aim of this training was to produce designers who were able, by their intimate knowledge of material and working processes to influence the industrial production of our time.” 34 Word of mouth and personal recommendation between customers accounted for much of this small-scale work, such as a request for a silver tea caddy from Herr Architekt Bernard in December of 1924 and an order from Herr Regierungsrat Döpel in January 1925 for a silver pin “like the one the metal workshop had made for the kindergarten teachers.” Rowland, “Business Management,” 154. 35 The archives of the Stiftung Bauhaus Dessau hold original records, including letters, bills of sale, and drawings of commissions. Notable Dessau commissions include Erich Dieckmann’s work for Hinnerk and Lou Scheper in 1925, which included chairs, stools, tables, desks, cupboards, and bookshelves; Dieckmann’s designs for the home of Pauline Schwickert; and Breuer’s furniture and kitchen cabinetry for the Wohnung Ludwig Grote at the Palais Reina in Dessau of 1927. For a full range of rare photographs of interiors, see Christian Wolsdorff, Bauhaus-Möbel: eine Legende wird besichtigt/Bauhaus Furniture: A Legend Reviewed (Berlin: Bauhaus-Archiv, 2002). 36 Emil Lange to Gropius, Weimar, 16 February 1924, typescript, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. 37 Protokoll, Formenmeister-Besprechung, 18 October 1923, in Wahl, Meisterratsprotokolle, 319. Originally the minutes were written with “GmbH,” which was then struck out and replaced with “AG,” possibly indicating some question of what designation the company should have. AG, for Aktiengesellschaft, is a public limited company, while GmbH, or Gesell schaft mit beschränkter Haftung, represents a limited liability company. 38 Wahl, Meisterratsprotokolle, 520–1. 39 Protokoll der Sitzung des Bauhausrates, 18 February 1924, 20 February 1924, in Wahl, Meisterratsprotokolle, 323–4. The meeting lasted 3½ hours. 40 Vertrag zwischen dem Bauhaus und Bauhausangehörigen, n.d., typescript, p. 1 verso, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. Several designers, when they left the Bauhaus, continued to fill orders for their designs personally, notably Josef Hartwig, who continued to produce his famous chess set. This document was designed to prevent this in the future. 41 Protokoll der Sitzung des Bauhausrates, 18 February 1924, 20 February 1924, Thüringisches Hauptstaatsarchiv Weimar. The “Work Plan of the Metal Workshop” (c. 1925–1926) also codifies payment, noting that either a single-payment compensation or royalties will be paid for models used in series production. Translated in Wingler, Bauhaus, 111. 42 This small catalogue lacks a formal name in the literature, and even the Bauhaus Archive has not reached a consensus on what to call it. In the Bauhaus exhibition and accompanying catalogue, Das A und O des Bauhauses: Bauhauswerbung: Schriftbilder, Drucksachen, Ausstellungsdesign, Ute Brüning refers to it as the “Katalog der Muster,” while Klaus Weber in Die Metallwerkstatt am Bauhaus refers to it as the “Musterkatalog der Bauhausprodukte.” In the period, the journal Bauhaus referred to a page from it as a “prospectus page” (Prospektseite) of the Bauhaus GmbH. Bauhaus, no. 1 (1926): 6. Because the title page of the loose-leaf sheets that make up the catalogue states, “Katalog der Muster,” that title will be used here. In English it has been translated as “Catalog of Designs” (Schwartz, “Utopia for Sale,” 124) and “Bauhaus Sample Catalog” (collection accession file, Harvard Art Museum/Busch-Reisinger Museum).
58
The Irreproducibility of the Bauhaus Object
43 Reproduced in Wingler, Bauhaus, 98–101. 44 For more on the role of trade shows in the display and sale of Bauhaus objects in the Weimar period, as well as efforts by the Bauhaus to bring early goods to market, see Rowland, “Business Management,” especially pp. 163–7. 45 The basic plan of the Bauhaus to produce machine prototypes rather than the standard fare of a regular school of applied art was also reported in countless newspaper articles. For a typical example, see Dr Grote, “Das Weimarer Bauhaus und seine Aufgaben in Dessau,” Anhaltische Rundschau, 11 March 1925: 1. 46 László Moholy-Nagy, “Eine bedeutsame Aussprache: Konferenz der Vertreter des Bauhauses Dessau und des Edelmetallgewerbes am 9. März 1928 in Leipzig,” Deutsche Goldschmiede-Zeitung, no. 13 (1928): 123. 47 Rudolf Arnheim, “Das Bauhaus in Dessau,” Die Weltbühne 23, no. 22 (31 May 1927): 921; translated in The Weimar Republic Sourcebook, ed. Anton Kaes, Martin Jay, and Edward Dimendberg (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994), 451. 48 Bauhaus, no. 4 (1927): 5. It was also reported that a related catalogue was in production. However, this relationship appears to have been short-lived, as the lamp division folded, causing the Bauhaus to begin anew in the search for a manufacturer. See Ise Gropius, Diary, 30 November 1927, 205–6. 49 A new contract for lighting came through in February of 1928, as noted in Ise Gropius’s diary (10 February 1928, 224). In the July 1928 issue, Bauhaus announced that both lighting companies Körting & Mathiesen and Schwintzer & Gräff were producing Bauhaus designs. See “Industrie und Bauhaus,” Bauhaus, no. 2–3 (1928): 33. For a full account of the Bauhaus’s relationship with Körting & Mathiesen and the line of modern lighting produced by the company from Bauhaus prototypes, see Justus Binroth et al., Bauhausleuchten? Kandemlicht! Die Zusammenarbeit des Bauhauses mit der Leipziger Firma Kandem/Bauhaus Lighting? Kandem Light! The Collaboration of the Bauhaus with the Leipzig Company Kandem (Leipzig: Grassi Museum, Museum für Kunsthandwerk Leipzig; Stuttgart: Arnoldsche Art Publishers, 2002). This arrangement, while fulfilling Gropius’s aims for the school, did so in an anonymous manner, because except for one mention in 1931, Körting & Mathiesen did not acknowledge the association of its Kandem line with the Bauhaus until its 75th anniversary, in 1964; see Ulrich Krüger, “Leutzsch Lighting: On the Collaboration of Körting & Mathiesen AG in Leipzig-Leutzsch with the Bauhaus in Dessau,” in Binroth, Bauhausleuchten?, 11. 50 Christian Wolsdorff, “Bauhaus-Produkte: Zusammenarbeit mit der Industrie,” in Bauhaus Berlin: Auflösung Dessau 1932, Schließung Berlin 1933, Bauhäusler und Drittes Reich, ed. Peter Hahn (Weingarten: Kunstverlag Weingarten, 1985), 183. The pottery workshop also began to make contacts with—and supply models to—industry (porcelain and stoneware) but did not accompany the Bauhaus to Dessau, and ceased to exist. 51 Gropius, “Bauhaus Produktion,” 130; translated in Wingler, Bauhaus, 110. 52 Like Sachlichkeit, “Intellektuell-Sachliches” presents difficulties in translation; it could be translated as “intellectual factualness” or “intellectual objectiveness.” 53 Bauhaus, no. 1 (1926): 3. 54 Among the hundreds of photographs of Berlin interiors, both known and anonymous dwellings, at the Bildarchiv Preußischer Kulturbesitz in Berlin, there are relatively few modern interiors, and in these interiors, Bauhaus domestic objects are in scant evidence, while Breuer’s tubular steel chairs and Bauhaus furniture are fairly common. For example, the Breuer-designed apartment interior for Edwin Piscator, 1927, featured Bauhaus furniture and lighting fixtures but not its other products. 55 Grete Lihotzky, “Rationalisierung im Haushalt,” Das neue Frankfurt, no. 5 (1926–1927): 120; translated in Kaes, Jay, and Dimendberg, Weimar Republic Sourcebook, 463. 56 Fritz Wichert, “Ein Haus, das Sehnsucht weckt,” Frankfurter Zeitung, 10 October 1923.
59
Robin Schuldenfrei
57 Benjamin, “Work of Art,” 104. 58 Gropius, “Bauhaus Produktion,” 135–6; translated in Wingler, Bauhaus, 110. 59 Ibid., 136. 60 Benjamin was a member of artistic and architectural circles in Berlin and was certainly conversant with key concepts of the day. He was part of a group that met often at Hans Richter’s house, which included Raoul Hausmann, Tristan Tzara, Frederich Kiesler, and Hans (Jean) Arp, which would launch the magazine G in 1923, led by Richter, Lissitzky, Van Doesburg, and Mies. 61 Arnd Bohm, “Artful Reproduction: Benjamin’s Appropriation of Adolf Behne’s ‘Das reproduktive Zeitalter’ in the Kunstwerk-Essay,” The Germanic Review 68, no. 4 (1993): 149. Cf. Adolf Behne, “Das reproduktive Zeitalter,” Marsyas (1917): 219–25. 62 Moholy-Nagy, “Production-Reproduction,” De Stijl, no. 7 (1922): 97–101; translated in Passuth, Moholy-Nagy, 289. 63 The slippage in this essay between the terms “mass production” and (mass) “reproduction” reflects this problem: to speak of mass production is really to speak of mass reproduction— as Benjamin’s essay illuminates—but the standard usage of the former term highlights the tendency to conceive it in the terms of production alone. 64 Hays, “Reproduction and Negation,” 163. Emphasis original. 65 Moholy-Nagy, “Dialogue”; translated in Passuth, Moholy-Nagy, 400. 66 Benjamin, “Work of Art,” 106. 67 Josef Albers, “Thirteen years at the Bauhaus,” in Bauhaus and Bauhaus People, ed. Eckhard Neumann (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1970), 171.
60
Chapter 3
The Disappearing Bauhaus Architecture and its Public in the Early Federal Republic Frederic J. Schwartz Keetenheuve saw in his mind’s eye the miner arriving home at the new estate that the committee had discussed, that they had calculated, that they had legislated. … The miner entered the minimum number of square meters that the experts had allotted to him. … They were overcome by tedium, a silent tedium that sometimes manifested itself in violence, in suicide, in seemingly inexplicable family conflict, but it was simply the incessant noise of the estate, the proximity to so many others, the disgust at the odors of the kitchens and the toilets. Wolfgang Koeppen, The Hothouse (1953)1 On 23 October 1965, Theodor W. Adorno and Ernst Bloch spoke as invited guests at the Deutscher Werkbund’s conference, that year on the topic of “Education through Form.” In his address, titled “Functionalism Today,” Adorno struck a deeply critical note: “The deep unease the style of the German reconstruction instills in me, who is no less subjected to it than an expert, moves me to ask about its cause.”2 Among other examples Adorno was referring, no doubt, to his own place of work: the new building for the Frankfurt Institute for Social Research, designed by Alois Giefer and Hermann Mäckler and finished in 1951. His conclusion: “There’s nothing so bleak as the mediocre modernism of the German reconstruction. A critical analysis of it by an expert in the field is needed.”3 Bloch was no less critical: in his lecture on “Education, Engineering Form, Ornament” he wrote
61
Frederic J. Schwartz
3.1 Alois Giefer and Hermann Mäckler, Institute for Social Research, Frankfurt am Main, 1950–1951
of the contemporary “termite existence in box houses … Forms are no longer differentiated humanely … all are rendered uniform in the domineering form of the glass box.”4 Both point a finger at the Bauhaus. The presence of Adorno and Bloch at the Werkbund’s conference has been interpreted by historians as symptomatic of a larger turn against the architecture of the postwar West German reconstruction (Wiederaufbau) and the legacy of the Bauhaus. A closer look at these texts and the context in which they were presented, however, suggests a far more complex, and far more interesting, situation. The argument presented here will have two parts. First, I will suggest that Adorno and Bloch articulated positions that in fact failed to resonate with their audience—though not because of the prestige of the institution they criticized. For despite the prestige of the Bauhaus and the hegemony of functionalism in the architectural profession—this is the second part of the argument—I will try to show that the Bauhaus, as a historical legacy and as a trope for an acceptable German architecture, was always a problematic element in the public discussions of the built environment in the young Federal Republic. As a historical reference point it seems the Bauhaus often generated irritation, contradiction and friction after the war, even among those now considered “modernists.” In other words, the Bauhaus seemed to interfere with postwar architectural discussions as much as it served to organize them. In looking at not only Bloch and Adorno but also the interventions of other prominent intellectuals in discussions of design, this essay
62
The Disappearing Bauhaus
will trace the shifting debates in philosophy, sociology and psychology about the reconstruction of Germany and the changing way the built environment could effectively be discussed as political matter. It will also focus on the discursive resistances in this process—resistances that were often due to anxieties about the complicity of architecture as a practice, a profession, and a discourse during the years of dictatorship and war. The aim is not simply a reception history of the Bauhaus and the “functionalist” position in the third quarter of the twentieth century, but rather to develop a different way of understanding the political stakes of architecture in postwar West Germany. At issue are the attempts to find adequate objects of discourse that allowed for matters of concern to a later architectural culture to be identified, elaborated, and analyzed. The vicissitudes of the Bauhaus as a legacy reveal much about the development of a postwar public sphere and the (always problematic) attempts to make issues of architecture and design the site of the public production of knowledge. They were talking about homes for mine workers now, about new settlements near the slag heaps, and an expert had calculated how many square meters each occupant needed, and a second expert had determined how cheaply the walls could be made. Korodin [from the CDU] owned stock in the mining company. The workers dug out the coal, and somehow their labours appeared in Korodin’s bank account.5 What is notable about Bloch’s address is its grand historical sweep. Bloch traces the emergence of what he calls the present “latecapitalist rat-race and alienation,” the general “train-station character of our existence.”6 It is a well-known tale. He starts with the way ornament was implicated in the class dynamic of the Gründerzeit or Gilded Age, where the petty bourgeoisie and the parvenus imitated the ruling class; he sees in the work of Adolf Loos a valid critique of the abuse of architectural form, a critique that was “partially indebted to socialism,” but one that stayed in the realm of style.7 The asceticism of “functional form” (Zweckform) became a style itself, one that lost its connection to its moral and political origins and itself became a brand new, functional fig leaf for social relations that had hardly changed. He pleads for a renewal of ornament—not of the rote figures of traditional decoration but as “formative fantasy” (bildende Phantasie). This fantasy could be reunited with the undeniable fantasy behind modern technology, a sublation of different aspects of modernity that could lead to a built environment, and a social order, that would be more humane. It is an extraordinary essay—“grand Bloch music” is what Adorno called his friend’s philosophy—but what chord, one might ask,
63
Frederic J. Schwartz
would Bloch have struck with this audience?8 References to the present are vague and unspecific; and the reference points of his account were very old indeed. To say “we are still stuck … in the Gründerzeit” was to make a valid point, but it is hard to imagine that many of his listeners had this period in recent memory.9 The bases of Bloch’s history were the architectural fashions (Stilmoden), the search for a true style, the breakthrough of Kandinsky and the Blaue Reiter, Adolf Loos and Paul Scheerbart, all matters more than a half-century old. And though postwar architects were keen to reestablish connections with prewar history, Bloch goes back to the time before World War I. Indeed, much of his argument, and many of his formulations, had already appeared in the first edition of his Spirit of Utopia (Geist der Utopie) from 1918. Bloch does not address the specificity of the fifteen-year-old Federal Republic and its culture. For all the actuality of Bloch as a father-figure for the new left, this must have sounded like a dusty history lesson. In any case, his address seems to have had few echoes in later architectural discussions. Adorno’s “Functionalism Today” is the more ambitious contribution to the conference; as an intellectual performance, it is a tour de force. Adorno excuses himself for going beyond his own métier, that of music; but he claims a direct kinship with the Sachlichkeit of the Bauhaus and the Werkbund through his involvement with Schoenberg and the Second Viennese School of music. He begins by breaking down the distinction between ornament and function by drawing it through a historical dialectic. Function, he says, is not only external but is first and foremost a matter of immanent, artistic function, within the logic of the work itself. And what was once functional can become, internally, unnecessary, superfluous, indeed ornamental, when its logic is no longer necessary to internal coherence. The functional and the functionless are historically intertwined. He seems here to allude to Semper when he writes of ornament as “scars of superseded modes of production”; the nonfunctional here is given a new valence as the “sublimation” of function.10 Nor is the inherent functionlessness of the autonomous work of art in modernity in any way “ornamental,” itself being a silent protest against the lowest common denominator of function as domination—of nature, of classes, of humans. Adorno continues to break down distinctions and interweave them anew. Function is not always technical, but also social. Rationality would include them; any other sort of “function” is an illusion. And yet society itself is irrational, though not in a way that can be corrected by the narrowly conceived instrumental rationality around which the problematic of architecture has come, he says, to turn. Functionalism represents the worst of both worlds: having become degraded to a “style” as consistent
64
The Disappearing Bauhaus
and false as any previous one; and in its narrow attention to purpose, it has become something “monotonous, meager, narrowly practical.”11 Functional form has transformed dialectically from rational to utterly irrational. The supposed opposition of technique and fantasy, discipline and freedom, is similarly collapsed. To fulfill a function without reducing the subject to a function of it, any design must focus on the surplus, the Mehr, must go beyond function, material, and technique: “Fantasy means: innervating this ‘more.’ ”12 An object, free and for the free subject, comes from the process of “finding an answer to the wordless question that material and forms pose in the mute language of the thing.”13 As ever, Adorno circles around the unnamable, the utopian, a truth just beyond reach and even more beyond words. As long as the object is bound by the petrified logic of the commodity, its abstraction, any uses it serves can never escape the system based on domination. The only hope is fantasy, the nonuseful, or the useful for uses not yet named, one that can reveal other functions and make objects human. But the current state is far from this; Adorno sees no easy solution: “[N]othing is so aesthetically unbearable as the present form of Function, enslaved to its opposite and deformed by it to the core.”14 There is much more to be said about this essay. What is relevant here is again the problem of anachronism. While claiming to react to the “Wiederaufbaustil,” his reference points are Loos, the Jugendstil, the Bauhaus. These were history (the only contemporary architect mentioned by name is Hans Scharoun). If Bloch’s account has what could be called a historic center of gravity of perhaps 1910, Adorno’s does not extend much beyond 1930; what he speaks about was hardly “Functionalism Today.” And furthermore, what he offers is hardly an adequate analysis of the architecture of the earlier “New Building” (Neues Bauen): Adorno’s critique would apply to a very small sector of the architecture of the heroic days of functionalism; it is in fact a mere caricature of it. The caricature of functionalism, of the Bauhaus style, and the criticism of contemporary architecture by means of it was a sensitive issue, a sore point for architects of the postwar period. When, for example, the sociologist and long-time friend of the Werkbund Alfred Weber inadvertently touched this raw nerve, he was quickly put in his place. The occasion was the second of the prominent Darmstadt Colloquia, one organized largely by Werkbund members on the topic of “Man and Space.” Weber attacked the assumptions of architecture as living machine, disparaging it as “applied hygiene,” as polemically uninviting, purely intellectual; he attacked its limited palate of “damned white,” what he characterized as its disingenuous claims for purity, and its putative intention of being nothing more than “functional building.” He made exception only for Otto Bartning’s postwar churches,
65
Frederic J. Schwartz
dismissing the rest of the architecture as he did the new plans for the United Nations headquarters in New York, as “upright cigar boxes.”15 Weber was very nearly shouted down.16 A representative of the younger generation, Hermann Mäckler, returned the attack: “Herr Professor Weber really doesn’t know … much about what’s been built in the last few years. … What he’s attacking is the form and color of the twenties.” He put paid similarly to characterizations of contemporary architectural space as “hard,” “crystalline” or “cool.”17 Weber backed down, but the problem here was not simply a misunderstanding of modern and contemporary architecture. In fact, this well-intentioned and relatively well-informed sociologist reveals something very important about the architecture of the Wiederaufbau. The issue was not one of practice, of style or form. What the incident suggests is that there was no stable discourse by which to discuss and debate the built environment as a matter of public concern, a discourse like the one that had earlier centered on the Bauhaus. We find many examples of this problem, and the most prominent one concerns precisely the Bauhaus. It was Rudolf Schwarz, one of the most talented and articulate architects of the period, who sank into the quicksand of this shifting and unstable discursive terrain, sparking a thoroughly unproductive controversy, the so-called “Bauhaus Debate.”18 In 1953, Schwarz attacked the legacy of the school, seeing the strict formal guidelines and method he associated with it as a form of “anti-intellectual terrorism,” one he found as dictatorial as the strictures of the “thousandyear Reich.”19 Now at one level this makes no sense at all: an architect who worked in the modernist mode attacked what had emerged as the very image of modernism. It reeked of personal rancor, but was not. In fact, his attack was less on the architectural practice of the school than the way it set the terms of architectural debate: he criticizes not so much the Bauhaus per se as what he called “the Bauhaus literati.”20 His objection was that architects were forced not to design, but to speak, in a certain way: not in “German, but in the jargon of the Communist International.”21 The Bauhäusler “didn’t want a dialog, but a dictatorship.”22 We should attend carefully to the title of his article, a quote from Goethe: “Make things, Artist, don’t talk” (Bilde Künstler, rede nicht). It is unfortunate that he did not follow his own advice; as it transpired, any attack on the legacy of the Bauhaus was, at the time, impossible. The Bauhaus had come to stand synechdochically for much that had been demonized during the years of fascism and war. But it is important that Schwarz’s concerns were not stylistic but about the terms of architectural debate, the way architecture would be discussed. The fact that
66
The Disappearing Bauhaus
talking was a problem is clear sign of the instability of the discursive conditions, the inability of architects and commentators to find clear reference points, a set of concepts agreed upon, a way of making architecture understandable, part of public discussion, an area that could be discussed by nonexperts. Now there were clear and identifiable discourses of architecture at the time. Modernism and the Bauhaus were assimilated into a cold-war ideology and cultural politics that promoted figures such as Walter Gropius as democratic, Western, and free; and many of the discussions referred to here are suffused with this cold-war rhetoric.23 It has also been established how architects compromised by successful careers in the Third Reich managed to reposition themselves, institutionally and discursively, as experts with specialized knowledge devoid of politics and ideology who were exclusively qualified to make valid statements about cities and their reconstruction, buildings and their forms.24 But beyond these institutions, governmental and professional, with their specific and overlapping protocols for sense and legitimacy, there were other reasons to talk. For architecture to be discussed by an informed public, for it to be an area of life over which a public could form opinions, which they could influence and integrate into their experience, there similarly needed to be a stable set of terms on which all could agree. Like all other matters of general concern, architecture needs to be the site of a public production of knowledge and politics; and we have clear indications that this could not happen in the early years of the Federal Republic. And this perhaps explains the despair of Wolfgang Koeppen’s fictional SPD parliamentarian Keetenheuve from The Hothouse (Das Treibhaus), his novel of Bonn in the early years of the Federal Republic. The issues Keetenheuven raises, registering so quickly the tremors of contemporary architectural politics, are urgent but irreducible to common denominators, inassimilable to the new, shifting, and suspect language of bourgeois democracy, opaque to history but devoid of any convincing vision of the future. They accepted the proposals of the experts; they approved the minimum expenditure, the minimum number of square meters, the minimum dwelling.25 Back to the Bauhaus, to “functionalism,” to the caricatures of Weber, Adorno, even Bloch, caricatures that were clearly inadequate but remarkably stubborn and persistent. The point that needs to be made here is that the caricature was not entirely incorrect but represents one form in which architecture could be represented in public. “Bauhaus
67
Frederic J. Schwartz
Functionalism” was a myth—unnuanced and largely incorrect—but the myth as a historical fact had a profound reality. Indeed, one could describe “functionalism” not as a style, an approach, even a stable or identifiable practice of architecture, but as a specific historical way in which architecture found a place in knowledge, politics and public discussion. I have traced elsewhere the way architecture before World War I was a stable object of discourse, one fit into a totality defined as culture, one spoken about by a subject who saw himself as bourgeois, as a consumer and not a producer, one who sought access to a totality defined as culture.26 The terms now seem odd and foreign, but they allowed the experience of a specific public to be described and analyzed at a high level; they enabled both debate and consensus. The public discourse was one that included prominent economists, sociologists and politicians; its site was cultural reviews and writings on architecture addressed to a public, such as the important yearbooks (Jahrbücher) published by the Deutscher Werkbund. In these, the objects of discussion concerned less statics and plumbing than “spirit,” “style,” “types,” and “culture.” We find later examples of writing of this kind, but, as a discourse conferring legitimacy and existing in symbiosis with professional and bureaucratic institutions, it died with the Wilhelmine period. Though there were certainly institutional, educational and bureaucratic continuities with the postwar period, this way of speaking disappeared as an effective public language. A period of instability followed. Certain architects in the late 1910s and early 1920s retreated into small magazines with a limited circulation, discussions that were considerably less public. The objects of knowledge were also unstable: was it a new man? a new culture? socialism?27 As young architects became successful and gained bureaucratic positions, their language turned to matters that were measurable and quantifiable. These matters were always important for architects, but now they became the public face of the avant-garde. It was a positivist discourse that developed at the same time as the professionalization of the avantgarde and the development of the international lobbying organization Congrès International d’Architecture Moderne (CIAM). The language of planned economies, of statistical matters of living standards and physical requirements, all this now served as the public (and not merely bureaucratic or professional) terms of architecture. Though there were strong reactions against this discursive formation at the time, prominent members of a generation found that it served them well to confer legitimacy—served, in other words, as a form of self-representation. This convergence of architectural idiom and public face,
68
The Disappearing Bauhaus
3.2 Hans Leistikow, Color lithograph poster for the CIAM/Werkbund exhibition Die Wohnung für das Existenzminimum, showing plan of a two-storey house in the Siedlung Praunheim, Frankfurt am Main
temporary and shaky though it was, was an important achievement. But it had an afterlife in defining the Bauhaus and the Neues Bauen, as a style and a set of personnel for many years. Thus Adorno’s elision of the Existenzminimum (“minimum dwelling” or “subsistence living,” the subject of the second congress of the CIAM in Frankfurt, 1929) and functionalism: Practical form can only lead to freedom if it sheds this fundamental barbarism, if it ceases to subject the human, whose needs 69
Frederic J. Schwartz
it is meant to serve, to the sadistic jabs of the sharp edges, the meanly calculated rooms, staircases and so on. Nearly every consumer has felt painfully for himself the impracticality of the ruthlessly practical.28 Yes, this was a caricature; but Adorno’s elision of functionalism and positivist planning was a response to the carefully crafted discursive position of architecture in the second half of the 1920s, to the way it found a convincing and seemingly lasting place in knowledge, politics and public discussion. He thought he could see right through the whole thing: it was full of poison and microbes. How were these settlements any different from the National Socialist settlements for the large families they wanted, or from the SA and SS colonies, only cheaper, smaller, grimmer and shabbier? And when you looked at the blueprints, it was the same Nazi style they were still building in, and when you looked at the names of the architects, it was the Nazi architects who were still building.29 Such a self-evident way of relating practice to a public was always embattled, but it simply did not exist after the Second World War. Consider the situation around 1950. When Hans Schwippert presented his project for a high school at the Darmstadt Colloquium (Darmstädter Gespräch) in 1951, we see this uneasy relation of form to language. The architecture is, we would say, International Style; others would have said “functionalist” or “Bauhaus.” It is an unornamented architecture of flat roofs, clearly exposed
70
3.3 Hans Schwippert, Project for a high school in Darmstadt, 1951. From Bartning, Mensch und Raum
The Disappearing Bauhaus
grid of the reinforced concrete frame, and nonhierarchical repeated modules, a logical rectangle around two courtyards. He contrasts his “massive form” (große Form) with Scharoun’s “loose form” (Auflösung) for another school project, bringing in the terms Auflockerung (loosening or dispersal) and Gliederung (structure) that would inform architectural discussions, but the rest of his description sounds very strange. The rhetoric is not cold and technical, but refers to the “creative community” he tries to create with his design; he tries to create here an “inner community of togetherness.” This is not an education machine, but instead a “monastery” that will create a union of “the teachers, the school, the whole.”30 On the same occasion, Franz Schuster—like Schwippert, later to build at the 1957 Interbau building exhibition in the Berlin Hansaviertel—presented a functionalist design for a kindergarten. The day before, he had framed his contribution to the “Man and Space” discussions in tones pathetic and expressionist. The times, he wrote, “will recreate the ties to those nearest to us, to the Volk, to the community, to humanity, to the unnamable, which will help us overcome the hopeless isolation and the homelessness of man.”31 In 1948, Schuster had published his The Style of our Time (Der Stil unserer Zeit), where he wrote about architecture using the well-worn figure of the symphony: Those who have particular abilities must not stifle the others, or annihilate them … What each of these talented individuals brings … is not a credit to him alone. It is one’s own choice to sit at the drafting table. What we achieve will follow a plan that arises out of the strictest order and rules. Like the most free of all arts, music, the model for all others, the work of the individual will fall in line with the meaning of the whole.32 When Schuster quoted from his own book, the response included some applause but even more nervousness and interruptions. The closeness of his rhetoric to that of the Third Reich obviously made his audience nervous. Whatever the architect’s designs, whatever his politics, this was obviously not an effective way of discussing architectural concerns in public. To get a sense of how architectural discussions developed, we need to look briefly at specifically public representations and debates: the famous Darmstadt Colloquia, with prominent intellectuals, that were broadcast live and published in full; publications of the Werkbund and their conferences, which were widely reported in the press; the sort of radio discussions that later appeared in book form; and other publicistic interventions.
71
Frederic J. Schwartz
The first Darmstadt Colloquium, on “The Image of Man in our Time,” did not thematize architecture per se but is important because of the controversy surrounding the keynote speaker, the art historian Hans Sedlmayr.33 Sedlmayr had been a convinced National Socialist and had criticized modernist art from this perspective during the regime (though, to be fair, he had taken modernism far more seriously than most of his persuasion). After the war, his position did not change in content—his talk in Darmstadt was on “The Dangers of Modern Art”—but the terms on which his argument was based were now explicitly Christian, in particular Catholic. But this change of reference points did not work; his criticisms, when they began uncomfortably to echo the Nazi demonization of modernism as “degenerate,” prompted whistles, heckling and calls of “Heil Hitler!”. The abstract artist Willi Baumeister fanned the flames by laconically claiming to have nothing against “former [Nazi] party members.” The event was a fiasco, and this despite the fact that many shared Sedlmayr’s position, and indeed his dubious past.34 To prevent such incidents, later colloquia were chaired with iron discipline (so much so that it was joked that they had become “Darmstadt Monologs”). But it was clear that new languages had to be found; neither those of the right nor those of the left seemed to work, and it was clear that history had be negotiated with considerable care. This was no mere matter of etiquette or rhetoric. Instead it seems that the conceptual figures and detours involved with the avoidance of history would come to be constitutive to the possibilities of thought for several years, and occasionally in productive ways. The next colloquium in Darmstadt, in 1951, was on architecture; called “Man and Space,” it was organized by the Werkbund and accompanied by a major exhibition. The keynote address was by Martin Heidegger; this was where he first presented his important work “Building Thinking Dwelling.” Heidegger’s point is well known: that in Germanic languages the word Bauen emerges, etymologically, from the word for dwelling. His conclusions are also familiar: 1. 2. 3.
Building is really dwelling. Dwelling is the manner in which mortals are on the earth. Building as dwelling unfolds into the building that cultivates growing things and the building that erects buildings.35
This is not the place to delve into Heidegger’s philosophy of Dasein, or, as Adorno puts it, his “jargon of authenticity.”36 What should be clear, though, is that as a contribution to discussions of the built environment in 1951, this is an extraordinary intervention. Indeed Heidegger refers to the
72
The Disappearing Bauhaus
context of contemporary architecture: Wohnen or dwelling, he says, does not simply mean that we have accommodation. In today’s housing shortage even this much is reassuring and to the good; residential buildings do indeed provide shelter; the accommodation today may even be well planned, easy to keep, attractively cheap, open to air, light, and sun, but—does this housing in itself hold any guarantee that dwelling occurs in them?37 And later: What is the state of dwelling in our precarious age? On all sides we hear talk about the housing shortage, and with good reason … We try to fill the need by providing housing, by promoting the building of housing, through regulation of the architectural industry. But: However hard and bitter, however hampering and threatening the lack of housing remains, the real plight of dwelling does not lie in the mere lack of housing. The real plight of dwelling is indeed older than the two world wars with their destruction. … The real plight of dwelling lies in this, that mortals ever search anew for the nature of dwelling, that they must ever learn to dwell. What if man’s homelessness consisted in this, that man still does not even think of the real plight of dwelling as the plight? Yet as soon as man gives thought to his homelessness, it is a misery no longer. Rightly considered and kept well in mind, it is the sole summons that calls mortals into their dwelling.38 For someone whose past bore remarkable similarities to Sedlmayr’s, such seemingly reassuring words sound disingenuous indeed. Only one member of the audience—Dolf Sternberger—saw fit to invoke the realities of the “the deportations, the resettlements, the refugees in their camps, the expulsions and the displaced persons.”39 But drawing such a grand arc over the horrendous realities of the immediate past of so many millions did not, apparently, seem offensive. Even Hans Schwippert fell into the metaphysical vocabulary by which architecture was now discussed, speaking immediately after Heidegger not of the needs of housing but biblically of the “commandment to build” (Gebot des Bauens).40 Hans Scharoun too was deeply affected.41 (This was only a year after the Sedlmayr debacle; it is indicative of the momentum that rehabilitation and restoration had achieved in the Western zones.)
73
Frederic J. Schwartz
Heidegger’s address to the architects is emblematic in three ways of architectural discussions for the decade and a half before Adorno and Bloch addressed a similar audience. First, as we have seen, history and its specificities had no place in these discussions. It is in fact notable how few references there are to particular buildings of the past; and this is in stark contrast to architectural discussions before and after World War I. And as history disappeared as a basis for these discussions, its place was taken by anthropology. Ambitious statements about the nature of an undifferentiated and generalized human being replaced references to historical, political, economic and social specificities. When history was invoked, it was the history of the species, not of a war-torn Europe. José Ortega y Gasset also spoke at the Man and Space colloquium, on “The Myth of Man Behind Technology.”42 It is not the horizon of war and destruction that situates his discussion of technology, but the necessity of technique for a man situated as a vulnerable species in a hostile nature. Man is referred to as a biologically disadvantaged species (Mängelwesen), echoing the philosophical anthropology of Arnold Gehlen and Helmuth Plessner and biologists such as Alfred Portmann.43 Indeed, if there is a defining characteristic of the discussions of architecture and design in the 1950s, it is that the subject is not style and culture, as it was before World War I, and not social housing, as in the 1920s, but man in an abstract, or at least ahistorical, sense. Speaking on “The Tasks of the Werkbund” at the yearly meeting of the group in 1953, the architect Heinrich Lauterbach declared the aim to be the “continued attempt of each of us to achieve the human integration of the things around us into a proper form” and the overcoming of the present “unintegrated reality of man.”44 These habits of thought even characterize the writings that emerged from the Hochschule für Gestaltung in Ulm, otherwise known for a more hard-nosed approach to technology. Speaking before the Werkbund in 1956, Ulm docent and philosopher Max Bense, who helped introduce cybernetics and information technology to the increasingly technocratic Ulm, situates his approach within these coordinates: The premises for an understanding of the position of man in the civilization and culture of the technical world are to be found in the scientific principles of modern anthropology—that in his evolution, man emerged from the originally closed functional circuit of animal instinct and security and began to develop an open functional system of information and therefore a lack of security.45 The second important shift signaled by Heidegger resonates in
74
The Disappearing Bauhaus
3.4 Reyner Banham and Martin Heidegger at the Hochschule für Gestaltung, Ulm, in 1959
these passages: it is the movement of the centre of gravity from building (Bauen) or form-giving (Gestaltung) to its phenomenological counterpart, dwelling or Wohnen. We can describe this as a sort of centrifugal conception of an object into a larger world, or a building considered not in terms of the qualities of the object but its creation of an environment. “Man and Space” came to be the rubric not for discussions of the practical essentials of living but for anthropological, poetic or phenomenological explorations by the likes of Otto Friedrich Bollnow, student of Heidegger and, according to Adorno, a jargonist of authenticity.46 But we should not simply dismiss this tendency. The reversal of container and contained, the necessity to think the one in terms of the other, became a basic trope of design discourse in a thoroughly productive way. Its repetition is noteworthy. “Thinking about design,” wrote Wilhelm Wagenfeld in an article in Werk und Zeit of 1957 … is less a matter of the object itself than its purpose and function, less about the form than the space encompassed by it. It’s not the handle of a teapot that is important, but the hand that grasps it; it’s not the glass that closes the circle it draws us into, but rather the wine that we’re drinking.47 This was not just a commonplace, but a pivot or fulcrum of the kind of thought that emerged under the discursive constraints of the time. Listen to two statements by Schwippert. In the first, he echoes Heidegger and stays within the limits of his thought, limits masked by the timeless and mysteriously resonant grammar of the intransitive verb: We made a good drinking glass. With this glass we wanted to help people lead a better, more beautiful life. But then … we began to fancy that we not only could improve people’s lives
75
Frederic J. Schwartz
with the help of this glass, but that the glass itself had the power to improve the people. A fallacy … We need to grasp the human situation and return to the original humility of our task. But what happened? Well, we made good glasses … but we no longer know the secret of drinking. Much good housing has been built and furnished, but we no longer know what dwelling is.48 The second continues with the image now so familiar to us but reveals the extraordinary, indeed constitutive potential of the trope of reversal introduced by Heidegger: In fifty years we’ve managed to make quite respectable drinking glasses… But in the meantime two things have happened. First, we’ve forgotten … how to appreciate what’s inside; and second, the wine’s got worse and worse, and we can no longer drink the water. … What good is the glass now? We’ve often wondered … if we should be speaking about using, and not making. In the end it’s probably the case that culture is determined by the manner of consuming as much as by the manner of producing, and that this use needs a sort of education that is utterly lost under the terror or hurried innovation and the goading of aesthetic novelty.49 We could put it this way: if an anthropology of design was, in some ways, a response to the problems of a sociology and a history of it, when the limits of anthropology were reached, the path seemed to lead quite quickly to a politics. The cramped and contorted thought of Heidegger, which turned the material social world inside out into meta physics, provided the impetus to address what he had so fastidiously avoided. Heidegger had identified a problem—dwelling—but could not conceive the tools by which to analyze it. By 1959, and with increasing speed thereafter, those engaged in architectural debates filled in the gaps. The problem, they said quite straightforwardly, was the restorative capitalism of the West German economic miracle, the ugly economy of the young Federal Republic. It was an important committee, it had important questions to discuss, it was supposed to build homes for the people (den Menschen). But how complicated that was! … questions of the War Compensation Act, of the availability of capital, of tax legislation were to be borne in mind, the effect on interest rates had to be considered, the accommodation of displaced persons, the 76
The Disappearing Bauhaus
allowance for bomb victims, the rights of property owners, the care of the crippled, the laws of the Federal states and those of the cities might be infringed upon, and how could the poor be provided for if no one was willing to make any sacrifices, how could one expropriate anything when the Constitution explicitly affirmed private ownership? 50 The sudden political turn of the formative trope of postwar architectural discourse is extraordinary. Things began in the Werkbund, with the 1959 Werkbund congress on the destruction of the countryside (Die große Landzerstörung) which identified the problems of city planning in the laws about land ownership. The freedom to dispose of land in one’s possession was an untouchable aspect of the capitalist mirror West Germany held up to its communist counterpart; but it led to land speculation, the draining of the cities and the inability to plan them properly, to rising housing costs and the commodification of domestic space. It seems that the Heideggerian trope encouraged a thoroughgoing social and phenomenological analysis of the once reified categories of design or building by means of the problem of dwelling. Public discussions of architecture now bore titles such as The Art of Being at Home (Die Kunst zu Hause zu sein), with contributions by such figures as the new Werkbund coordinator, the sociologist Hans Paul Bahrdt, Ernst Bloch, and Alexander Mitscherlich, whose essay was titled, more clearly, “On the Impossibility of Being at Home.”51 Mitscherlich’s crucial pamphlet Our Inhospitable Cities (Die Unwirtlichkeit unserer Städte) now focused not on what architects could or should do, or what they had done wrong, but instead on what they could not do under the present social system.52 In his contribution to a symposium with the Adornian title Damaged Life (Das beschädigte Leben), the young Ulrich Conrads explicitly invoked Heidegger in turning to consider the material and political conditions of contemporary architecture, conditions of “unreason.”53 This was again a turn to a public, to what they might have hoped represented the public sphere. Architects had not only found a stable public discourse, a set of concepts and objects by which citizens could make sense of the built environment and conceive solutions to problems identified, but they understood their work as precisely public relations work. Die Kunst zu Hause zu sein was, like many other anthologies, published in the wake of the public broadcast of the contributions, in this case over the Hessisches Rundfunk. Mitscherlich, Bahrdt, Ulrich Conrads and others joined in issuing the Bochum Declaration (Bochumer Erklärung), which they presented to the opposition Social Democratic Party (SPD).54 And the
77
Frederic J. Schwartz
3.5 Ulrich Conrads (?) speaking at the Bochumer Erklärung, 16 September 1965. Willy Brandt is seated in the first row, third from left. From Hammer, Die Bochumer Erklärung
architects turned now explicitly against earlier strategies in which architects claimed expert professional knowledge. In Werk und Zeit we read of the “danger that these questions will be judged by the politicians and bureaucrats as to be a matter for the relevant experts … We think it is worth trying to present the issue of the destruction of the countryside as a matter that transcends professional expertise, as an issue of fundamental importance in a broad cultural and political circles.”55 It was thus an extraordinary moment in 1965, when Adorno and Bloch addressed the Werkbund; indeed it was less than six weeks after the Bochumer Erklärung, and five weeks after the bitter parliamentary election lost by the SPD. Adorno and Bloch spoke about objects, not the environment around; they spoke about history, not the demands of the present; they expressed “unease,” not rage; they called for the experts instead of sending them away; they offered philosophy and not politics. They would have sounded, I think, very anachronistic indeed. We could end by trying to characterize this moment, by trying to understand what seems to have been the shared fate of architecture and philosophy. In architecture, the famous glass ran over as the whole dialectic of object and contents seemed to challenge the very existence of its institutional forms. For a brief moment, objects evaporated as process came to the fore; the centripetal concerns of the object, of design, seemed less urgent than the centrifugal consideration of the world around it. The traditional expert knowledge of the architect and designer looked superseded. It was a moment when a renegotiation of architecture as practice, as knowledge, and its relation to society seemed possible. The Werkbund seemed on the verge of dissolution. In 1969 it changed the subtitle of its organ, Werk und Zeit, from Monthly Journal of the German Werkbund (Monatszeitung des Deutschen Werkbunds) to Monthly Journal of Environmental Design (Monatszeitung für Umweltgestaltung).56 The organizational form seemed to have been burst, from architecture to the world. In 1971, the older generation no longer felt it could tolerate the direction in which
78
The Disappearing Bauhaus
3.6 (left and right) Walter Gropius and protesting students at the Bauhaus exhibition, Stuttgart, 1968
the Werkbund was going; Hans Schwippert, Hans Schmitt-Rost, Wend Fischer, and Richard Scherpe left the journal.57 Perhaps the limits of architecture were coming into view. But architecture continued. For a moment, the Werkbund and the legacy of the Bauhaus seemed redundant, but they lived on, we could say, because the moment to realize their goals was missed. The social organization of knowledge, building and politics were strong enough to resist their complete reorganization, or new ones could not be conceived. The logic and momentum of discourse ran up against the dead weight of institutions. At this point, the Bauhaus reappeared as just such dead weight. When a depoliticized version of the school was presented in a massive fiftieth anniversary exhibition in Stuttgart, students of the sinking Ulm Hochschule für Gestaltung nearby called for the demands of the present to take precedence over the celebration of a closed history. Gropius appeared, expressing solidarity but warning the students not to allow politics to take over the now shrinking concerns of the object. Architecture and revolution were again shown to be mutually exclusive. And this moment, undefined and frightening, when much balanced on the edge of a knife, turned into the beginning of postmodernism, instead of any of the other beginnings it could have been. The goal of the Bauhaus—the attempt to reorganize life, with all its political resonances, to reconfigure the relation of objects to practice—stayed put in the past, as a figure of the alternative to a history clearly gone wrong. Or it remained in the future. For what it is worth, even on the left this seemed prudent. Habermas rejected the “left fascism” of Rudi Dutschke for rational debate.58 And Adorno too. It is the introduction to his Negative Dialectics to which I have alluded: “Philosophy, which once seemed obsolete, lives on because the moment to realize it was missed.”59 When confronted with his own students who sought to realize his teachings but threatened to unleash energies of revolt that he had seen, in his own lifetime, so horribly abused, he clearly felt the moment had already
79
Frederic J. Schwartz
3.7 Max Scheler, Removal of protesting students from the Institute for Social Research, Frankfurt, 1969
been missed or had not yet arrived. On 31 January 1969, he found his own workplace, Hermann Mäckler and Alois Giefer’s Institute for Social Research, overflowing with the messy and ill-thought-through energies of revolt in the form of 76 protesting students who refused to leave.60 Though Adorno cared little for the building, he felt it needed to be emptied. He called in the police, and he stayed with philosophy.
Notes 1 Wolfgang Koeppen, Das Treibhaus (1953; Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 2000), 123. 2 Theodor W. Adorno, “Funktionalismus heute,” in Ohne Leitbild: Parva Aesthetica (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1967), 104. A translation of Adorno’s essay by Jane O. Newman and John H. Smith appears in Oppositions no. 17 (Summer 1979): 31–41 and is reprinted in Neil Leach, ed., Rethinking Architecture: A Reader in Cultural Theory (London: Routledge, 1997), 6–19. I have used my own translations here. 3 Adorno, “Funktionalismus heute,” 114. 4 Bloch, “Bildung, Ingenieurform, Ornament,” Werk und Zeit 14, no. 11/12 (1965): 2. Bloch’s essay, translated by Newman and Smith, similarly appears in Oppositions no. 17 (Summer 1979), 45–51, and in Leach, Rethinking Architecture, 43–50; again, translations here are my own. 5 Koeppen, Das Treibhaus, 122. 6 Bloch, “Bildung, Ingenieurform, Ornament,” 3. 7 Ibid., 2. 8 Theodor W. Adorno, “Große Blochmusik,” Neue Deutsche Hefte 69 (1960/61): 14–26.
80
The Disappearing Bauhaus
9 Bloch, “Bildung, Ingenieurform, Ornament,” 2. 10 Adorno, “Funktionalismus heute,” 107. 11 Ibid., 114. 12 Ibid., 118. 13 Ibid. 14 Ibid., 124. 15 Otto Bartning, ed., Mensch und Raum: Darmstädter Gespräch 1951 (Darmstadt: Neue Darmstädter Verlagsanstalt, 1952), 96–7. 16 The published protocols record some “applause” but far more “laughter,” “whistles,” “objections,” and statements of “Get out! Stop!” Ibid., 97. 17 Ibid., 97–8. 18 On the “Bauhaus-Debatte,” see Paul Betts, The Authority of Everyday Objects: A Cultural History of West German Industrial Design (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2004), 85; Greg Castillo, “The Bauhaus in Cold War Germany,” in Bauhaus Culture: From Weimar to the Cold War, ed. Kathleen James-Chakraborty (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2006), 188–9; Ulrich Conrads, Magdalena Droste, Winfried Nerdinger and Hilde Strohl, eds, Die Bauhaus-Debatte 1953: Dokumente einer verdrängten Kontroverse (Braunschweig: Vieweg, 1994); and Wolfgang Pehnt, Rudolf Schwarz 1897–1961: Architekt einer anderen Moderne (Ostfildern: Hatje, 1997), 137–42. 19 Rudolf Schwarz, “ ‘Bilde Künstler, rede nicht’: Eine (weitere) Betrachtung zum Thema Bauen und Schreiben,” Baukunst und Werkform 6, no. 1 (January 1953), 9–17, reprinted in Die Bauhaus-Debatte 1953, 34–47, here page 35. 20 Die Bauhaus-Debatte 1953, 35. 21 Ibid., 46. 22 Ibid., 45. 23 See Paul Betts, “The Bauhaus as Cold War Legend: West German Modernism Revisited,” German Politics and Society 14, no. 2 (1996): 75–100; Betts, The Authority of Everyday Objects; and Castillo, “The Bauhaus in Cold War Germany.” 24 See Werner Durth’s magisterial Deutsche Architekten: Biographische Verflechtungen, 1900– 1970 (Braunschweig: Vieweg, 1986). 25 Koeppen, Das Treibhaus, 124. 26 In The Werkbund: Design Theory and Mass Culture Before the First World War (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1996). 27 See my “Form follows Fetish: Adolf Behne and the Problem of Sachlichkeit,” Oxford Art Journal 21, no. 2 (1998): 72–6. 28 Adorno, “Funktionalismus heute,” 110–11. 29 Koeppen, Das Treibhaus, 125. 30 Bartning, Mensch und Raum, 173–81. 31 Ibid., 120. 32 Ibid., 123. 33 On Sedlmayr, see Norbert Schneider, “Hans Sedlmayr (1896–1984),” in Altmeister moderner Kunstgeschichte, ed. H. Dilly (Berlin: Reimer, 1990), 267–88. 34 Hans Gerhard Evers, ed., Das Menschenbild in unserer Zeit: Darmstädter Gespräch 1950 (Darmstadt: Neue Darmstädter Verlagsanstalt, 1950), 59, 135. 35 Martin Heidegger, “Bauen Wohnen Denken,” in Mensch und Raum, 74; “Building Dwelling Thinking,” in Heidegger, Poetry, Language, Thought, trans. A. Hofstadter (New York: Harper & Row, 1971), 148. Karsten Harries discusses Heidegger’s paper in the context of the Darmstädter Gespräch in The Ethical Function of Architecture (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1997), 152–66. 36 Theodor W. Adorno, The Jargon of Authenticity, trans. K. Tarnowski and F. Will (1964; London:
81
Frederic J. Schwartz
Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1973). Despite Adorno’s rejection of Heidegger’s Seinsphilosophie, it overlaps frequently with aspects of Adorno’s own: see Silke Kapp, “Asyl für Obdachlose, oder Zwischen Frankfurter Küche und Frankfurter Schule,” Zeitschrift für kritische Theorie no. 18/19 (2004). 37 Bartning, Mensch und Raum, 72; Heidegger, Poetry, Language, Thought, 145–6 (translation modified). 38 Bartning, Mensch und Raum, 84; Heidegger, Poetry, Language, Thought, 161 (translation modified). 39 Bartning, Mensch und Raum, 126. 40 Ibid., 86. 41 A brief but balanced discussion of Scharoun’s interest in Heidegger’s thought appears in Peter Blundell Jones, Hans Scharoun (London: Phaidon, 1995), 136. See also J. Christoph Bürkle, Hans Scharoun (Zürich: Artemis, 1993), 96. 42 Bartning, Mensch und Raum, 111–17. 43 Ibid., 114. 44 Heinrich Lauterbach, “Über die Aufgabe des Werkbundes,” in Zwischen Kunst und Industrie: Der Deutsche Werkbund, ed. Wend Fischer (München: Die Neue Sammlung, 1975), 413–14. 45 Max Bense, “Kunst in künstlicher Welt,” Werk und Zeit 5, no. 11 (1956): 3. 46 Otto Friedrich Bollnow, Mensch und Raum (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1963). Bollnow is mentioned often in Adorno’s Jargon der Eigentlichkeit. 47 Wilhelm Wagenfeld, “Industriemesse contra Museum,” Werk und Zeit 6, no. 6 (1957), repr. in Fischer, Zwischen Kunst und Industrie, 436–37. 48 Hans Schwippert, “Warum Werkbund?,” Werk und Zeit 5, no. 5 (1956), repr. in Fischer, Zwischen Kunst und Industrie, 428. 49 Hans Schwippert, Begrüßung und Einführung zur Tagung “Die große Landzerstörung,” Werk und Zeit 8, no. 12 (1959): 1, repr. in Fischer, Zwischen Kunst und Industrie, 447. 50 Koeppen, Das Treibhaus, 120. 51 Gert Kalow, ed., Die Kunst zu Hause zu sein. Eine Senderreihe des hessischen Rundfunks (München: Piper, 1965), 147–61. 52 Alexander Mitscherlich, Die Unwirtlichkeit unserer Städte: Anstiftung zum Unfrieden (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1965). 53 Ulrich Conrads, “Städtebau zwischen Unvernunft und Hoffnung,” in Das beschädigte Leben: Diagnose und Therapie in einer Welt unabsehbarer Veränderungen, ed. A. Mitscherlich (Grenzach: Hoffmann-La Roche, 1969), 148. 54 Konrad Jule Hammer, ed., Die Bochumer Erklärung 16. September 1965 (Berlin: Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands, 1965). 55 Walter Rossow, “Die ‘Landzerstörung’ und der Werkbund,” Werk und Zeit 11, no. 3 (1962): 3. 56 Werk und Zeit 18, no. 7 (1969): 1. 57 “Veränderungen in der Herausgeberschaft und in der Redaktion,” Werk und Zeit 20, no. 7 (1991): 1. 58 Rolf Wiggershaus, Die Frankfurter Schule, 3. Aufl. (München: dtv, 1991), 687. 59 Theodor W. Adorno, Negative Dialectics, trans. E. B. Ashton (1966; London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1973), 3. 60 Wiggershaus, Die Frankfurter Schule, 702; Stefan Müller-Doohm, Adorno. Eine Biographie (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 2003), 705–6.
82
Chapter 4
Pedagogic Objects Josef Albers, Greenbergian Modernism, and the Bauhaus in America Jeffrey Saletnik
To reject mechanical or habitual application is to promote inductive studies recognizing practice before theory, trial and error before insight. In short, we believe in learning by experience, which naturally lasts longer than anything learned by reading or hearing only. Josef Albers1 As a teacher, Josef Albers encouraged a relational approach to material that prioritized active engagement with matter through comparative and counterintuitive applications: he stressed “observing eyes, flexible minds, and skilled hands.”2 Such activity starkly contrasts with conceptions that one’s medium possesses inherent qualities, the properties of which it is the task of the artist to elucidate. The sensory-integrated practices of Bauhaus preliminary instruction, although still essential to the training of artists and designers, were denuded of value in their American context due in part to the specialized tendencies that came to dominate American art criticism following World War II. The prioritization of medium specificity common in Greenbergian art criticism posited an autonomous art object incongruent with attitudes about the functioning of creative media as propagated by Albers. Albers advanced a mode of material inquiry in his practice that viewed matter as potential; significantly, he encouraged the creation of objects that functioned pedagogically insofar as their materiality made connections beyond the work itself. As had been the case at the
83
Jeffrey Saletnik
Bauhaus, Albers gave precedence to process. This was cultivated through the methods and practices of preliminary instruction, to which Albers had been exposed as a student and which he was later responsible for teaching at the Bauhaus, and which he introduced at several institutions in the United States, including Black Mountain College and Yale University.3 This essay situates Albers’s practice—and, by extension, attitudes about the functioning of objects held at the Bauhaus—in the context of key art critical values in mid-twentieth-century America, in particular those of Clement Greenberg. In comparing Albers’s critical reception to that of Barnett Newman and Hans Hofmann, it highlights not only differences in terms of how Albers and his American contemporaries were understood through a Greenbergian lens, but also how Albers’s Bauhausindebted approach to the medium and the object were supplanted by a formalist agenda to which neither he nor the Bauhaus adhered. This displacement becomes evident when one examines the inductive practices which Albers employed in the classroom and through which he expressed attitudes about the object as demonstration piece. At stake is a fundamental difference between disinterested and engaged viewing, but also a theoretical elision of practice by “medium,” which undermines the role of the Bauhaus in twentieth-century American art. As arguably the most potent voice writing about art in mid-twentieth-century America, Greenberg is unique: his criticism holds a discursive weight with which historians and critics still contend. Greenbergian notions of meaningful art practice—and responses to them—have contributed significantly to perceptions of what it means to have been a modern artist in America. Thus, while objects created by Bauhaus artists attracted some critical attention, the Bauhaus prioritization of practical experiment was largely discounted. When we consider the consequences of excluding Bauhaus practices in art critical discourse, it becomes evident that this omission was historically as significant as Walter Gropius’s overarching—perhaps even overbearing—presence in the casting of the Bauhaus in America. The effects of discursive omission also lay bare the degree to which art critical values and structures are inherently exclusionary, in particular with regard to expectations about the function of art objects, art viewing, and art making. Greenberg seldom chose to write about Albers and other Bauhaus artists and designers, a fact that is significant to the history of the school’s American reception since the art critic considered the Bauhaus— and much so-called German art—to be outside parlance on meaningful art practice. As he wrote, it was Kandinsky’s “bad luck” to have come to French modernism having “had to go through German modernism first.”4 Indeed, the Bauhaus and individuals associated with it were subjects of lesser
84
Pedagogic Objects
critical importance in mid-twentieth-century American criticism, an absence noted by Greenberg’s foe, Harold Rosenberg, who lamented that “the twentieth century is rich in personages—the Bauhaus masters, Gertrude Stein— whose creations are rarely looked at or read.”5 More than mere antipathy toward German art, however, Bauhaus-indebted approaches to making and viewing were out of step with Greenbergian formalist values. The disinterested relationship between work and viewer implicit in Greenberg’s criticism as well as his advocacy for self-reflexive relationships between surface and support foreclosed the practice of many Bauhaus masters and students from his modernist discourse. Many Bauhaus objects required an active and engaged viewer and, in some instances, a user. And under Albers’s tutelage in particular, students were presented with the medium as a means for exploration, the boundaries of which were to be investigated toward productive ends.6 In contrast, Greenberg deemed artistic practice as a quest for discovering what was “unique in the nature of [an art’s] medium” as representing the “proper area of competence of each art.”7 To assert that the terms of Greenbergian modernism contributed to the obfuscation of the Bauhaus is meant not as a value judgment nor to claim that Greenberg’s was the only significant voice writing on art at the time, nor to oversimplify the context in which Bauhaus ideas were introduced in America. Indeed, rebuking Greenberg has been quite commonplace since the late 1960s and 1970s.8 The art criticism of Rosenberg and Meyer Schapiro was similarly influential in mid-twentieth-century America and contributed to the school’s art critical reception.9 For instance, the Bauhaus was implicated in Schapiro’s view that the “taste for industry, technology and science” in the 1920s led to an art of “coolness and mechanical control” that now seemed “less interesting and even distasteful” in light of the “artist’s active presence” upon the surfaces of contemporary abstract painting.10 And significantly, an array of forces including political attitudes toward Germany immediately preceding and during World War II, cold war anxieties about socialism, and hostility to so-called modern architecture and design guided how the Bauhaus was received in the United States.11 It is productive to isolate Greenberg in both this nexus and that of mid-twentieth-century art criticism because many of the terms that were characteristic of his criticism were similarly key concerns at the Bauhaus; the medium and materiality were essential to the pedagogic program at the design school. Yet the kinds of questions the critic asked of art were antithetical to Bauhaus practice. When Greenberg did mention the Bauhaus he invoked the word Bauhaus as value-laden catchall for “hardness,” “flat silhouettes,” and “firm contours” or—much in keeping with the neo-Kantian tenor of
85
Jeffrey Saletnik
4.1 Josef Albers Variant/Adobe, Red Front, 1947, oil on Masonite®, 22 x 26 in
his criticism—objected to the notion that there was some larger content or purpose for work either produced at the school or in its wake. About Albers’s exhibitions at the Egan and Janis galleries in 1949 he wrote: Alas, Albers must be accounted another victim of Bauhaus modernism, with its doctrinism [and] its inability to rise above merely decorative motifs. It is a shame, for an original gift is present in this case that is much superior to all that. One has to regret that Albers has so rarely allowed the warmth and true plastic feeling we see in his color to dissolve the ruled rectangles in which all these potential virtues are imprisoned.12 When writing about Barnett Newman in 1952, however, the critic assumed a quite different stance, claiming that Newman’s “emphasis is predomin antly on color, which in his case is sensuous without being soft, and his effect is usually much warmer and more painterly” than what one expects given the geometry of his work. He continued, claiming, “Newman does not intend to startle or shock,” ultimately stating that in “the presence of these canvases one realizes immediately [my emphasis] that he is faced by major art.”13 At the Egan and Janis exhibitions Albers displayed a range of works made between the 1920s and late 1940s. Among the more recent of these, Greenberg would have seen paintings similar to Variant/Adobe, Red Front (Figure 4.1).14 The artist’s surfaces are not as rigid as Greenberg suggests. Albers’s asymmetrically arranged planes of color appear to penetrate one another, so as to obfuscate the points at which they intersect. This is not unlike what one observes in Newman’s Adam (Figure 4.2), as its bands of color move beyond the bounds of the artist’s characteristic, linear “zip.” In both paintings, one observes the transmutation of boundaries where colors meet. In the case of Albers’s work, this is achieved through the positioning and combination of color: although difficult to ascertain in 86
Pedagogic Objects
black-and-white reproduction, colors often appear to be layered upon one another or transparent, yet are not; one color seems to be more saturated than another, yet the two are actually the same tone. Although Greenberg objected to the work as “merely decorative” and saw its geometry as threatening to the modernist program, Albers used this structure to demonstrate the interaction of color as relational. This interaction only became apparent upon prolonged viewing and, significantly, found meaning when one turned one’s gaze away from the painting, newly aware of the interaction of color in one’s daily experience. Newman, in contrast, aspired to achieve the sublime, specifically directing the viewer to engage his work at a close distance, so that one might be enveloped by the canvas.15 As he posted in the Betty Parsons Gallery upon the exhibition of (the then untitled) Adam and other work in 1951, “there is a tendency to look at large
4.2 Barnett Newman Adam, 1951–1952, oil on canvas, 96 x 80 in 87
Jeffrey Saletnik
pictures from a distance. The large pictures in this exhibition are intended to be seen from a short distance.”16 Greenberg had no truck with Albers’s work insomuch as his practice itself was pedagogic and thus didactic. His frustration with Albers, however, had little to do with the artist’s teaching per se and everything to do with his art. In contrast, the critic’s overall attitude was favorable with regard to the work of Hans Hofmann, whom he acknowledged as “probably the most important art teacher of our time.”17 Greenberg’s focus remained the surface of Hofmann’s painting; as the critic wrote, “His painting is all painting; none of it publicity, mode, or literature.”18 He praised Hofmann because the artist’s views about art were in keeping with his own; indeed, they influenced his criticism.19 The artist included the following statement—replete with what would come to be known as Greenbergian language—in the 1937–1938 brochure for the Hans Hofmann School of Fine Arts: the organic elements of painting are the flatness of the surface used and its plastic medium, color. the pictorial development which retains the character of these elements in an equilibrium of volume and forces produces the plastic effect of “pictorial space.” “realistic space,” that of optical illusion, is contrary in its character to an instinctive use of the medium.20 Hofmann and Albers differ in terms of the intentionality of their objects: the work of the former is self-referential, whereas the work of the latter imposes itself upon the viewer—it expects that we see differently, not that we revel in its painterly effects per se. This, in part, is why Greenberg would be drawn to Hofmann, yet cast Albers as “doctrinaire.” Greenberg saw no place for pedagogic objects meant to draw one’s attention to the act of viewing, as did those produced by Albers and others affiliated with the Bauhaus.21 Rather, Greenberg saw it as his role to guide viewing habits; to serve both the artist-conduit and the disinterested viewer. Albers rendered instability, a perceptually shifting surface through his choice of color and proportion; if not these colors in this combination one would not experience the same visual effect.22 Like Variant/ Adobe, Red Front, Albers’s Homage to the Square, Black Setting (Figure 4.3) demonstrates the interaction of color. Albers shows how this combin ation of color creates a pulsating visual effect, as a white square appears to move to the fore, only seemingly to recede when overtaken by a cyan square before moving to the fore once again. The work exhibits an unresolvable relationship in which color remains in flux, highlighting that what one actually sees is light rather than surface. In contrast and much to 88
Pedagogic Objects
4.3 Josef Albers, Homage to the Square, Black Setting, 1951, oil on Masonite®, 32 × 32 in
Greenberg’s pleasure, Hofmann utilized the properties of painting to enliven the medium, not to educate the viewer. In Hofmann’s Goliath (Figure 4.4), his so-called “push-pull” technique creates a sense of depth without employing illusion; red, yellow, and blue quadrangles appear to float above
4.4 Hans Hofmann, Goliath, 1960, oil on canvas, 841⁄8 × 60 in 89
Jeffrey Saletnik
the surface. An array of multi-colored, brushy gestures—rendered on the same, flat picture plane—create dimension and depth. Albers does not attempt to deny that his surfaces are painted; the marks of his hand are evident. And insomuch as one looks at Hofmann’s painting, one also perceives it. But there is both an immediacy and a stasis to Hofmann’s floating quadrangles quite dissimilar to Homage to the Square, Black Setting. Unlike Albers’s play with the process of perception, Hofmann’s painting addresses problems particular to painting and is testament to the artist’s facility in manipulating material in accordance with the “plastic medium” of color and the “flatness of the surface.”23 Just as Greenberg was by no means the only art critical voice in mid-century America, Albers was not the only target of this vein of criticism. Albers’s practice, however, is an effective means of introducing a larger problem regarding the reception of the Bauhaus in America. In holding up the Bauhaus and American modernism, the Albers–Greenberg dynamic reveals a disconnection between Bauhaus-indebted practices and American art critical values. In a purely formal sense, eschewing narrative and mimesis in favor of the plastic qualities of two- and three-dimensional visual objects themselves—as could be said about the appearance of many Bauhaus objects, such as Marianne Brandt’s Tea Infuser and Strainer (Figure 2.2, page 39)—seems in keeping with Greenberg’s views insofar as they are indebted to European modernist traditions. Brandt’s design consists of a combination of basic geometric forms, and its visual vocabulary is unador ned. Indeed, artist-designers affiliated with the Bauhaus were likely among the unnamed “purists” to whom Greenberg made reference when he called for literature to be expunged from visual art so as to quell the dominance of narrative, which forced the nonliterary arts to “deny their own nature.”24 But while Greenberg acknowledged the “Dutch and Germans” as among those responsible for realizing the full potential of “abstract purism,” he also blamed them for consolidating it into “a school, dogma and credo,” claiming that they sterilized the expressive factors of abstraction as a result.25 For Greenberg, the powerful expressiveness of abstraction (to invoke Charles Harrison) was the formal system itself.26 Art was impotent: neither utopian nor dystopian, apolitical, and certainly lacking function. Both Bauhaus-indebted instructional methods and Greenbergian modernism involve the search for essential elements and emphasize structural and material coherence. Yet Greenberg implies that the inherent physical properties of the artistic medium should help define how artists use their material in accordance, for instance, with the flatness of the painting surface—Jackson Pollock’s splatter and Helen Frankenthaler’s stains
90
Pedagogic Objects
correspond to the “nature” of painting.27 Thus, the medium is granted a kind of agency, such that it guides the artist in the creative act. Although a Bauhaus-indebted approach to material and materiality encourages stud ents to seek answers to design problems from and through an exploration of material properties, the individual, by contrast, possesses the agency to employ this knowledge to numerous ends. The “nature” of the material world does not prescribe, but rather informs its use. Yet due to the predominance of Greenberg’s critical voice, Bauhaus practices often have been received through a Greenbergian lens. Contemporary critiques of Bauhaus-indebted teaching strategies frequently invoke the terms that Greenberg brought to the forefront of mid-twentieth-century art critical discourse. It has been common to proclaim that the “medium-centered” teaching methods of the Bauhaus are obsolete, as has Thierry de Duve, who stated that teaching at the Bauhaus was “based on the reduction of practice to the fundamental elements of a syntax immanent to the medium” and if its methods function in light of contemporary mixed-media, conceptual art practice, they do so “in spite of themselves.” 28 According to de Duve’s view, and in keeping with Rosalind Krauss’s more general assertion that contemporary artists work in a “postmedium” condition,29 artists are no longer bound to the confines of the medium, notwithstanding the question of whether they ever were. The critical negation of Bauhaus instructional methods in the United States, as perpetuated by Greenbergian criteria, serves as testament to the pervas iveness of the critic’s views. But more, and likely much to Albers’s dismay, the degree to which the Bauhaus was caught in a web of responses to Greenbergian discursive structures—despite never having been embraced therein—also speaks to the degree to which the language of criticism guides understandings of practice.
Learning by Induction Although Greenberg would cast the school generically as a style, visual unity was not a Bauhaus priority; rather, the Bauhaus emphasized the activities of art making and approached the medium as an active tool— as praxis. By categorizing Bauhaus objects according to a priori aesthetic criteria, Greenbergian medium specificity overlooks the role of objects as essential to Bauhaus practice, as means to an end rather than an end themselves. In contrast to the critic’s deductive reasoning, Albers saw meaning as induced through practice. At the Bauhaus, Black Mountain College, and Yale University his instruction was productive; it was about complicating understanding rather than reduction and refinement, and his teaching 91
Jeffrey Saletnik
methods were geared toward general design principles, such as (and notably for Albers) color interaction, which he understood as a means of visual organization. Albers would describe his instructional approach as that of creating “visual empathy” through which one gained “the ability to read the meaning of form and order” and to “articulate” this knowledge in terms of the “conditions of formulation.”30 At the Bauhaus, he made reference to his method as induktives Lernverfahren (and as “inductive studies” in America), a movement from detailed study to general principles. 31 Thus, the acquisition of basic skills was first sought in isolation from their application, with the understanding that the individual parts (i.e. the building blocks of design) precede their combination and the formation of a whole. Accordingly, Albers’s pedagogic emphasis lay in practical, concrete exercises; in “learning through conscious practice.”32 Yet his classroom was a forum for active demonstration, not free experimentation. This activity of building up from basic knowledge runs in opposition to a Greenbergian approach based in overarching fundamental principles. The attention Albers paid to perceptual fundamentals was in keeping with the goals of preliminary instruction under his predecessors at the Bauhaus, Johannes Itten and László Moholy-Nagy, yet his approach diverged from Itten’s emphasis upon the body as site for sensory stimulus and Moholy-Nagy’s prioritization of sensory communication.33 Albers encouraged students to investigate the properties of material in his material study (Werklehre) so as to explore their structural potential, which—in light of the increasingly prevalent rhetoric of industry at the Bauhaus—was tethered to the creation of “commercial form” and the “union of purpose and material.”34 His approach to the medium was pragmatic, as were his teaching methods. Albers’s students were encouraged to investigate material by subverting expectations—to demonstrate potential, rather than to define function. At the Bauhaus, he chose to focus primarily upon two- and threedimensional studies in material, which he separated into the categories: “Material” studies, which involved “construction” and “Materie” exercises (also known as matière and the term used henceforth), which involved “combination.”35 In the first of these methods, material studies, students were charged to construct structures with a single material, such as corrugated cardboard, metal sheets, wire, glass, and plastic. Among the most common assignments—one that remains a mainstay in many art and design curricula—were paper studies in which students were to explore the properties of paper, only allowed to cut or fold it so as to create forms that highlighted the material’s structural possibilities (Figure 4.5).36 About these exercises and Albers’s teaching generally Hannes Beckmann recalled:
92
Pedagogic Objects
4.5 Albers and students manipulating a sheet of paper at Black Mountain College in 1946
I remember vividly the first day of the [Preliminary Course]. Josef Albers entered the room, carrying with him a bunch of newspapers. … “Ladies and gentlemen [Albers said], we are poor, not rich. We can’t afford to waste materials or time. … All art starts with a material, and therefore we have first to investigate what our material can do. So, at the beginning we will experiment without aiming at making a product. At the moment we prefer cleverness to beauty. … Our studies should lead to constructive thinking. … I want you now to take the newspapers … and try to make something out of them that is more than you have now. I want you to respect the material and use it in a way that makes sense—preserve its inherent characteristics. If you can do without tools like knives and scissors, and without glue, [all] the better.”37 Results varied considerably and, according to Beckmann, the student who simply folded the paper such that it could stand on its side was singled out, for he demonstrated how paper—a pliable material—could be made stiff.38 He had enabled one to see the material differently. The relational aspect of Albers’s instruction was expressed most explicitly in the second of these methods, matière exercises. Albers often had students make lists of contrasts such as dark/light, warm/cold, soft/hard and would then ask that they formulate associations between these terms and material qualities generally or charge them to demonstrate contrasting relationships in advanced exercises: for instance, the creation of positive 93
Jeffrey Saletnik
and negative space using a single material.39 Matière involved the combination of material available in the Bauhaus workshops: strips of cellophane, wire mesh, fabric, nails, and thus purposeful rather than found matter. Students were to demonstrate comparative qualities—elastic/stiff, planar/ linear, straight/bent—and categorize material according to Struktur, Faktur, and Textur.40 Like material studies, matière were meant to enable new ways of seeing and observation through one’s active engagement with the material world. The exercises were a means of determining, as Albers wrote: … which formal qualities predominate today—harmony or balance, rhythm or scale, geometric or arithmetic proportion, symmetry or asymmetry, rosette or row—and in conjunction with that, what holds more interest—complicated or elementary form, multiplicity or simplicity, composition or construction, mysticism or hygiene, volume or line, beauty or prudence, ancestral portraits or toilets.41 The activity of making matière was distinct from the act of discussing what trends could be identified among them. They were at once a means of material understanding, yet also a platform for exchange: they were intended to be didactic objects. Albers’s stated goals for his Werklehre were to provide students with an overview of many materials and a feeling for design concerns; to encourage economy, responsibility, discipline, and criticism through independent discovery; and to determine with which material they might like to work as they continued their studies.42 The means were as signific ant as these ends. Albers included a discussion of “methode” among his course outline, lectured on the topic of “creative education,” and published “Werklicher Formunterricht,” an essay in which he laid out his views on education as a balance of discipline and freedom, experimentation, and the encouragement of controlled mistakes.43 The dialectics of education— literally the process of drawing out, rather than imposing information and knowledge—became even more pronounced in the radically new context of Black Mountain College, where the importance of facilitating exchange among students was essential to the collaborative nature of the institution and its educational program. Unlike the Bauhaus, Black Mountain offered students a largely self-directed education in literature, music, visual art, the sciences, and other disciplines under the rubric of general education. Although Albers seldom engaged the nonvisual overtly in his teaching at the Bauhaus—as did Itten and Moholy-Nagy—he was adamant that the essential principles of material and design could be applied across disciplines. Unlike Greenberg’s modernism, with its emphasis upon
94
Pedagogic Objects
differences between the arts, Albers’s pedagogical method stressed common principles that united the arts and encouraged that learning take place through “parallelism” rather than “separatism.” In reference to the curri culum at Black Mountain he wrote: To speak in professional terms: We should discover for instance that music, too, has to do with proportion and the values of line and volume; also that literature can be static and dynamic, and can have staccatos and crescendos, and poems can have color; that the play on the stage has not only dramatic climax but also an optical and an acoustical one; that there are musical qualities in all art—that every work of art is built (composed), has order, consciously or unconsciously.44 This was more than mere rhetoric at the college; students were asked to address the interpenetration of the arts in their examinations. One of ten required questions on the “Qualifying Examination” in 1948—when Albers was college rector—was: “Discuss the interrelationships of painting, musical composition and architectural structure. Choose your examples and compare them.”45 It is taken as given that interrelationships exist and merely left to the student to articulate them. Although oriented toward visual understanding, Albers’s instruction at the college addressed widely applicable fundamental principles: proportion, line, volume, and color as well as static and dynamic form. His students—many of whom took his courses as part of their general education—were to apply these principles to their own work and in their own fields of study as they saw fit. This is not to say that Albers did not recognize differences among creative media. In a lecture on abstract art given soon after his arrival in the United States he used medium-based qualities to indicate “a development toward the pure arts,” the aims of which were that music be “primarily a combination of tones,” painting be “a combination of colors,” and dance be a “combination of movements.”46 But he continued: Let us say this in artistic terms: we want more Composition Combination Construction Dynamic and static Weight and qualities Rhythm and balance And so on.
95
Jeffrey Saletnik
Although here Albers maintains a distinction between the temporal and visual arts, he did not value the formal qualities of tone, color, and movement per se, as did Greenberg. Rather, his aim in making these remarks was to advocate how abstraction was implicit to life itself. He stated, “A life is more than nature, so is art more than life. Because art is spirit—that means an essential seeing—instead of imitation we need translation.”47 Indeed, Albers did not seek to prescribe the conditions of visual experience or aspire—as did Kandinsky, Mondrian, and others for whom “essential seeing” was key—to craft wholly abstract vocabularies of visual form. Rather, his teaching demonstrated the terms of translation by prioritizing process over form. Albers’s curricular aspirations remained consistent, regardless of the course in question. An undated synopsis of the curriculum for the 1948–1949 academic term at Black Mountain includes detailed descriptions of his drawing and painting courses, which were taught throughout the year, as well as courses in basic design, color, and structural sculpture, taught alternating every other semester.48 Six statements as to how art courses relate to the college curriculum precede the descriptions of the goals for each course. The courses are open to “artists and non-artists.” They are not “directly concerned with self expression or completed work,” but rather they are laboratory classes that aim “first at observation and articulation, that is, conscious seeing,” and emphasize the “control of means, hand, [and] tools,” as well as the collaborative, comparative nature of peer review and critique as fostering “self-criticism and judgment.”49 His final statement addressed the concept of art as a course of study: “Art here means more a process and way of living than a product or its production. Art as an educational means aims at an intensive use of our senses and a broader and deeper vision of our self and of the world.”50 Although adamant that no finished work was made in his classroom, the exercises produced in his courses were highly valued, so much so that they were routinely displayed as part of senior exhibitions, and thus the demonstration of one’s process was tantamount to finished products made outside the classroom. Color instruction, for which Albers is perhaps most widely known, exemplified how the emphasis on perceptual estrangement in his teaching was meant to bring hierarchies of visual order to consciousness.51 In the course students used foliage, paper, and other materials available to them in their studies; they did not mix pigments to create a new, composite color, and thus his color instruction was a comparative rather than an additive process (Figure 4.6). Exercises were meant to attune students to perceptual phenomena and, by extension, the
96
Pedagogic Objects
4.6 Albers and students in the Color Course at Yale University in 1952
interaction of color as relational and unfixed. As was so in his other courses, students employed a process of trial and error, often placing countless pieces of “Color-aid” paper in combination with one another until arriving at the desired, at times unexpected visual effect. They would manipulate color so as to create a sense of volume or weight, various surface and optical effects such as the illusion of fluted edges, the appearance of transparency, or the optical effect of one color assuming the qualities of another. Indeed, Albers desired to achieve these same effects in his own painting practice (Figures 4.1 and 4.3), in which he emphasized perceptual exchange between colors in lieu of establishing conceptual unity. Indeed, the inductive studies Albers employed in his teaching were quite opposed to Greenberg’s modernism: they were meant to be non-mediumspecific, purposeful, and largely self-determined. And, significantly, objects produced in Albers’s courses were intended to be didactic; they functioned as demonstration pieces, as did Albers’s own work. The discourse in which Greenberg established himself was specifically one of writing about viewing, predicated upon a language of formalist abstraction as tethered to the structural properties of the medium and its specializing effects. In a sense Greenberg was a teacher;52 the critic directed his reader in how to see—and evaluate—works of art.53 Although he believed that aesthetic experience was intuitive, Greenberg saw the critic’s role as that of inviting “the reader to look at works of art [so as] to see if he agrees with the critic.”54 At the Bauhaus, seeing was integral to
97
Jeffrey Saletnik
preliminary instruction, yet Bauhaus pedagogic methods and practices cast vision as but one of many senses at the service of making. For Greenberg, the maker’s goal was to capitalize on the characteristic qualities inherent in the medium with which he worked, as if he were in service to a tradition of painting or sculpture. Albers encouraged the crafting of an apparatus that drew attention away from the physical object and the subversion of perceptual expectations as a means of design innovation. The competing applications of (Platonic) idealized seeing as facilitated by Greenberg and the propagation of an (Aristotelian) embodied vision at the Bauhaus have distinct genealogies, yet the former often has superseded the latter in art critical discourse. This was especially the case as the Bauhaus was received in an American context, where Bauhaus objects and practices came into contact with the terms of Greenbergian formalism and medium fixation.
Acknowledgments This essay was assisted by a grant from the Berlin Program for Advanced German and European Studies with funds provided by the Freie Universität Berlin. I would like to thank Brenda Danilo witz and Jessica Csoma at The Josef and Anni Albers Foundation, as well as Dawna Schuld and Christa Robbins.
Notes 1 Josef Albers, Search Versus Re-Search (Hartford, CT: Trinity College Press, 1969), 13. 2 Ibid., 36. 3 After receiving his teaching certification in primary education, Albers taught primary school between 1908 and 1913. From 1913 to 1915 he studied at the Königliche Kunstschule in Berlin, from which he received certification as an art teacher. He later attended the Kunstgewerbeschule in Essen and Königliche Bayerische Akademie der Bildenden Kunst in Munich before enrolling at the Bauhaus in 1920, where he attended Johannes Itten’s Preliminary Course and participated in the stained-glass workshop. In 1923 he began teaching material study (Werk lehre), an aspect of preliminary instruction, assuming full responsibility for preliminary instruction from 1928 to 1933. Upon his emigration to the United States, Albers taught at Black Mountain College from 1933 to 1949 and at Yale University from 1950 to 1960. He served as visiting or guest instructor at many institutions, including the Cincinnati Art Academy, Pratt Institute, Graduate School of Design at Harvard University, University of Oregon, Syracuse University, and the University of South Florida. He also lectured extensively throughout the Americas. See Frederick A. Horowitz and Brenda Danilowitz, Josef Albers: To Open Eyes (London: Phaidon, 2006) for a comprehensive study of Albers’s teaching of design, drawing, color, and painting at the Bauhaus, Black Mountain College, and Yale University. 4 See Clement Greenberg, “Kandinsky,” in Art and Culture: Critical Essays (Boston: Beacon Press, 1961), 111–14. Greenberg did devote considerable and attention to the work of Wassily Kandinsky and Paul Klee. 5 Harold Rosenberg, “Thoughts in Off Season,” in Art on the Edge: Creators and Situations (New York: Macmillan, 1971), 247.
98
Pedagogic Objects
6 T’ai Smith addresses concepts of the medium held in the weaving workshop in context of intellectual debates in Germany, through which “weaving as medium” was formulated. See Weaving Work at the Bauhaus: The Gendering and Engendering of a Medium, 1919–1937 (Ph.D. diss., University of Rochester, 2006). 7 Greenberg claimed that “each art” had to “use the characteristic of [its] discipline to criticize the discipline itself, not in order to subvert it but in order to entrench it more firmly in its area of competence.” See Clement Greenberg, “Modernist Painting,” in Clement Greenberg: the Collected Essays and Criticism, ed. John O’Brian, vol. 4 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 85–93. 8 Among Greenberg’s notable detractors have been Leo Steinberg, Lucy Lippard, Rosalind Krauss, and T. J. Clark. More recently in Clement Greenberg Between the Lines, trans. Brian Holmes (Paris: Éditions Dis Voir, 1996), Thierry de Duve has suggested that the time for responses to Greenberg has passed and that there exists a need for a reappraisal of the critic. Caroline A. Jones investigates the fashioning of Greenberg’s unique subjectivity in her Eyesight Alone: Clement Greenberg’s Modernism and the Bureaucratization of the Senses (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005). 9 Harold Rosenberg wrote of the Bauhaus in terms of collage as outgrowth of preliminary instruction, one of few critics to note how Bauhaus-indebted pedagogic methods were of import beyond the classroom. See “Collage: Philosophy of Put-Togetherness,” in Rosenberg, Art on the Edge, 173–80. 10 See Meyer Schapiro, “Recent Abstract Painting,” in Modern Art: 19th & 20th Centuries (New York: George Braziller, 1978), 213–32. 11 In The Bauhaus and America: First Contacts, 1919–1936 (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1999), Margret Kentgens-Craig discusses the formation of the International Style as among the factors that led to the suppression of the Bauhaus Weltanschauung. Karen Koehler investigates how the 1938 Bauhaus 1919–1928 exhibition at The Museum of Modern Art “negotiated events of world history” through the “self-imposed censorship” of its organizers, including Walter Gropius and Herbert Bayer in “The Bauhaus, 1919–1928: Gropius in Exile and the Museum of Modern Art, N.Y., 1938,” in Art, Culture, and Media Under the Third Reich, ed. Richard A. Eltin (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002), 287–315. See also Gabriele Diana Grawe, Call for Action: Mitglieder des Bauhauses in Nordamerika (Weimar: Verlag und Databank für Geisteswissenschaften, 2002). 12 Clement Greenberg, “Review of exhibitions of Adolf Gottlieb, Jackson Pollock, and Josef Albers,” in Clement Greenberg: the Collected Essays and Criticism, vol. 2, ed. John O’Brian (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 285. 13 Clement Greenberg, “Feeling Is All,” reprinted as “Partisan Review ‘Art Chronicle’, 1952,” in Art and Culture: Critical Essays (Boston: Beacon Press, 1961), 150. Greenberg writes: “even if his pictures do consist of only one or two (sometimes more) rectilinear and parallel bands of color against a flat field.” His mention of “shock” is likely a direct reference to critical writings on Newman that pre-dated Greenberg’s essay. See Melissa Ho, “Chron ology,” in Barnett Newman, ed. Ann Temkin (Philadelphia: Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2002), 325. 14 Albers showed work made between the 1920s and late 1940s at the Egan exhibition, entitled “Paintings in Black Grey White.” The exhibition at the Janis Gallery, “Paintings titled Variants,” comprised more recent work. Albers did not begin to make his iconic Homage to the Square paintings until 1950. 15 As Newman wrote about his painting, “The image we produce is the self-evident one of revelation, real and concrete, that can be understood by anyone who will look at it without the nostalgic lens of history.” See Barnett Newman, “The Sublime is Now,” Tiger’s Eye 1,
99
Jeffrey Saletnik
no. 6. (December 1948): 51–3, reprinted in Charles Harrison and Paul Wood, Art in Theory: 1900–1990 (Oxford: Blackwell, 1992), 574. 16 See Ann Temkin, “Barnett Newman on Exhibition,” in Temkin, Barnett Newman, 41. 17 Among Hofmann’s students were Red Grooms, Helen Frankenthaler, Lee Krasner, Joan Mitchell, and Louise Nevelson. Albers’s students included Robert Rauschenberg, Eva Hesse, and Richard Serra. 18 Clement Greenberg, “Review of an Exhibition of Hans Hofmann and a Reconsideration of Mondrian’s Theories,” The Nation 7 (April 1945), in Clement Greenberg: the Collected Essays and Criticism, vol. 2, ed. John O’Brian (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 18. 19 Greenberg wrote, “Hoffman [sic] has not yet published his views, but they have already directly and indirectly influenced many, including this writer—who owes more to the initial illumination received from Hofmann’s lectures than to any other source.” Ibid. 20 Punctuation is Hofmann’s. “Brochure, Hans Hofmann School of Fine Arts, New York, 1937– 38,” in Cynthia Goodman, Hans Hofmann (New York: Whitney Museum of Art, 1990), 164–5. 21 One could, for instance, make a similar claim about the practice of László Moholy-Nagy, in particular his interest in light. 22 So important were the precise colors and proportions used to Albers, he would often list the pigments as well as their manufacturer on the verso of his paintings. 23 For Greenberg, “[Hofmann] … grasped the issues at stake better than did Roger Fry and better than Mondrian, Kandinsky, Lhote, Ozenfant, and all the others who have tried to ‘explicate’ the recent revolution in painting.” Greenberg, “Review of an Exhibition,” 18. 24 See Clement Greenberg, “Towards a Newer Laocoon,” in Clement Greenberg: the Collected Essays and Criticism, vol. 1, ed. John O’Brian (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 23–37. 25 Ibid. 26 See Charles Harrison, Essays on Art and Language (Oxford: Blackwell, 1991), among other texts. 27 In a 1964 catalogue essay for an exhibition Greenberg curated, “Post Painterly Abstraction,” he discussed some of the exhibiting artists as reacting against painterly abstraction, claiming: “Their reaction against it does not constitute a return to the past, a going back to where Synthetic Cubism or geometrical painting left off. … They are included [in the exhibition] because they have won their “hardness” from the “softness” of Painterly Abstraction; they have not inherited it from Mondrian, the Bauhaus, Suprematism, or anything else that came before.” Clement Greenberg, “Post Painterly Abstraction,” in Clement Greenberg: the Collected Essays and Criticism, vol. 4, ed. John O’Brian (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 192. 28 Thierry de Duve, “When Form Has Become Attitude – And Beyond,” in The Artist and the Academy: Issues in Fine Art Education and the Wider Cultural Context, ed. Stephen Foster and Nicholas de Ville (Southampton, UK: John Hansard Gallery, 1994), 31. 29 See Rosalind Krauss, A Voyage on the North Sea: Art in the Age of the Post-Medium Condition (London: Thames & Hudson, 1999). 30 Albers, Search Versus Re-Search, 10. 31 “Werklehre Albers” (1927). The Josef and Anni Albers Foundation, Bethany, CT. Albers continues to note that this was achieved through communal critique of one’s work (gemeinsame kritik der arbeiten). See also Albers, Search Versus Re-Search, 13. 32 John Dewey’s “learning by doing” approach to instruction as tethered directly to activity was known to Albers—especially subsequent to his emigration—and became essential to his conception of education. See John Dewey, Art and Experience (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1934) and Josef Albers, “Art as Experience,” Progressive Education, 12 (October 1935): 391–3. 33 For an extensive analysis of teaching practice at the Bauhaus, including that of Johannes
100
Pedagogic Objects
Itten, László Moholy-Nagy, and Josef Albers, see Rainer K. Wick, Teaching at the Bauhaus (Ostfildern-Ruit: Hatje Cantz, 2000). 34 Undated translation/notes based upon Albers’s essay “Werklicher Formunterricht,” Black Mountain College Records, 1933–1956, North Carolina State Archives, Raleigh, NC. 35 I focus on Albers’s three-dimensional studies here. Albers’s two-dimensional course assignments enabled students to explore visual relationships through drawing and collage studies. One such study was known as a “reordering” exercise, in which familiar material, such as pages from the newspaper, were cut into strips and rearranged as collage to achieve various optical effects. Like Moholy-Nagy, he also used photographic techniques in his instruction. See Horowitz and Danilowitz, Josef Albers, 112–22. 36 About the study depicted in Figure 4.5, Albers remarked: “[This photograph] shows a mutual and manual examination of a volume-space study, more specifically a ‘structural organization’ study. A multi-sided pyramid is formed by folding a single, undivided sheet of paper. The problem is to determine the proper relationship of the cut bottom edge to both the plane basis of the plywood board and the varying angulature of the pyramid’s slopes.” Albers, Search Versus Re-Search, 82–3. 37 Hannes Beckmann, “Formative Years,” in Bauhaus and Bauhaus People, ed. Eckhard Neumann (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1970), 196. 38 Ibid. 39 Rainer K. Wick has shown that Albers’s contrast exercises were largely indebted to Itten’s employment of similar methods at the Bauhaus. See Wick, Teaching at the Bauhaus. See also Rolf Bothe, Peter Hahn and Hans Christoph von Tavel, eds, Das frühe Bauhaus und Johannes Itten (Ostfildern-Ruit: Verlag Gerd Hatje, 1994). 40 László Moholy-Nagy also had students organize arrays of matter in elaborate tactile charts, and analyze materials according to categories. Struktur was the internal composition of a material (its physical consistency), Textur corresponded to the material’s outward appearance (the visible surface), and Faktur or “surface aspect” was the perceptible result or effect of man’s treatment of a material (the maker’s manipulation and markings). Among the categories, the latter was most significant as it related to how one would use material to achieve a desired sensory result. See László Moholy-Nagy, The New Vision (New York: George Wittenborn, Inc., 1947). Albers, however, claimed that Moholy-Nagy failed to acknowledge his role in establishing this categorization system, which the latter claimed as his own. See Horowitz and Danilowitz, Josef Albers, 255, note 69. 41 Josef Albers, “Werklicher Formunterricht,” Bauhaus 2, no. 2/3 (1928): 3–7, in Hans Maria Wingler, The Bauhaus: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago, ed. Joseph Stein, trans. Wolfgang Jabs and Basil Gilbert (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1976), 142. 42 “Werklehre Albers” (1927). Albers clearly lays out the theme (thema) of the course, his method (methode) to achieve it, and his course goals (ziel) in this document. 43 Albers presented a lecture at the Sixth International Congress for Drawing, Art Education, and Applied Art in Prague, 1928. See note 41. 44 Albers, “Art as Experience,” 391. 45 “Qualifying Examination, First Day, March 4, 1948, 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.” The Josef and Anni Albers Foundation, Bethany, CT. 46 “ ‘Abstract Art,’ Speech made in Asheville, NC, by J. Albers, August 1935.” Josef Albers Papers. Manuscripts and Archives, Yale University Library, New Haven, CT. 47 Ibid. 48 “Art Courses,” undated typescript for 1948–1949 courses at Black Mountain College. The Josef and Anni Albers Foundation, Bethany, CT. At Yale University Albers taught only a color and a drawing course. 49 Ibid.
101
Jeffrey Saletnik
50 Ibid. 51 Albers published his canonic Interaction of Color as a boxed set with 80 color folios and commentary in 1963 (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1963) and a smaller version of the work in 1971 (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1971), which has seen several revisions and reprintings, most recently in 2006. 52 I use teacher intentionally to distinguish Greenberg from Albers, an educator who, in keeping with the definition of the term, facilitated a “process of rearing” as opposed to the directedness and presumed instructional authority of teaching. 53 This was evident in Greenberg’s teaching. The critic taught “The Development of Modernist Painting,” “Sculpture from Their Origins to the Present Time,” and a course on criticism and Kant’s Critique of Aesthetic Judgment at Black Mountain in summer 1950. Albers had left the college in 1949 and thus did not come in contact with the critic directly. See Mary Emma Harris, The Arts at Black Mountain College (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1987). 54 Clement Greenberg in conversation with Karlheinz Lüdeking, “Clement Greenberg: Modernism or Barbarism,” in Clement Greenberg: Late Writings, ed. Robert C. Morgan (Minnea polis: University of Minnesota Press, 2003), 217.
102
Part 2 Transference
Chapter 5
A Refuge for Script Paul Klee’s “Square Pictures” Annie Bourneuf
Painting as Page It has often been said that Paul Klee’s paintings are more like pages from a book than like other paintings.1 This is the analogy Clement Greenberg uses to talk about how different Klee’s work is from Picasso’s. Picasso’s paintings “move about in actual physical space”—”take place among other events and other objects”—whereas “Klee’s live in a more fictive medium and require of the spectator a greater dislocation, a greater shift.”2 Picasso’s painting is architectural, monumental, public; Klee’s is the opposite: “Klee’s private lyricism is more sympathetic to those who live in industrial countries … where the scope of art is essentially private.”3 Summing up these differences, Greenberg writes: “The difference is that [Picasso] sees the picture as a wall, while Klee sees it as a page.”4 The same analogy appears in one of the best more recent accounts of Klee’s painting—Joseph Leo Koerner’s essay, “Paul Klee and the Image of the Book.”5 For Koerner, it is not simply that Klee sees the picture as a page, but that Klee figures the picture as a page in order to investigate the book as a metaphor and as an object in crisis in modern culture. Modern culture, writes Koerner, is the crisis of the book, which, “no longer … capable of holding the totality which is its claim … becomes an object among other objects, mute and material.”6 Koerner sees this crisis as registered above all in the way Klee’s painting deploys the material “thingness” of the book and of writing.7 The line of inquiry Koerner opens up, considering Klee’s paintings as sustaining a dialogue with the book both as a metaphor and a particular kind of material object, is of great importance for the analysis of Klee’s art:
105
Annie Bourneuf
Klee does indeed figure his paintings as pages to speak to a crisis of the book in modern culture.8 But his engagement with the book might best be probed if we look more closely at how his contemporaries and colleagues spoke of the problematic situation of the book at the time. What neither Greenberg nor Koerner mention is that both book and page were under a great deal of pressure at the Bauhaus, where Klee taught for a full decade, from 1921 to 1931, while making many of the paintings they describe as page-like.9 Proposals for the transformation of reading and writing circulated at the Bauhaus that would either displace or fundamentally alter the page as Klee’s art would appear to conceive it. The book was no longer necessarily seen as the chief and characteristic home of the printed page; attention shifted to unbound, ephemeral forms of printed matter—the poster, the brochure, the newspaper, the magazine. Nor was the printed page necessarily seen as the chief and characteristic home of writing. Writing was reconceived in relation to other surfaces: film screen, shop sign, neon light, and, indeed, the wall—the countermodel, according to Greenberg, to Klee’s painting-as-page. The typographical avant-garde aimed to remake reading into a public, collective activity, into something very different from the silent absorption of solitary individual readers, their noses in their books. They asked whether writing were necessarily a matter of horizontal lines of letters to be read left to right, top to bottom—and, going still further, whether writing might become no longer a matter of letters at all, but of photographs and pictographs, potentially accessible to all rather than only to those literate in the language of a given text. In short, the page was called into question at the Bauhaus, both as a surface for writing, for conventional symbols to be read in a particular and codified order, and as a space, discontinuous with its surroundings, for private contemplative reading. A future was imagined in which the page would no longer have those qualities for the sake of which Klee seems to adopt it as a model for his painting. By considering the transformations of the book and the page proposed at the Bauhaus, this essay attempts to bring the perennial question of the relation of Klee’s art to its Bauhaus context into sharper focus.
Picture-writing “Everything indicates that the book in [its] traditional form is nearing its end,” wrote Walter Benjamin in One-Way Street, his 1928 booklet of his “aphorisms, jokes, dreams.”10 Benjamin devotes a long section of his own pointedly untraditional book to speaking of the crisis of the book and his 106
A Refuge for Script
utopian predictions of a future for writing outside its bounds. Benjamin describes the mass media—advertising, newspapers, and film—as saturating everyday urban life with a writing outside the book that interferes with the modern subject’s vision in such a way as to diminish his or her ability to enter the book: “[B]efore a contemporary finds his way clear to opening a book, his eyes have been exposed to such a blizzard of changing, colorful, conflicting letters that the chances of his penetrating the archaic stillness of the book are slight.”11 When “script (Schrift)—having found, in the book, a refuge in which it can lead an autonomous existence—is pitilessly dragged out into the street,” its character changes, writes Benjamin. In film and advertising, writing loses its autonomy. The bodily orientation of reader to text changes; readers hold books horizontally before them, but newspapers vertically— and “film and advertising force the printed word entirely into the dictatorial perpendicular.” Writing gains a new “picture-like-ness” (Bildlichkeit), a new visualness, which Benjamin predicts will soon lead to a new “picture- writing” (Bilderschrift). Benjamin implies that this picture-writing’s audience will be the collective, not the individual. Benjamin’s speculations on the situation of writing in the 1920s are particularly pertinent to Klee’s art, both because his great interest in Klee is closely bound up with his interest in the potential picture-like-ness of writing and because his thinking in One-Way Street responds to the publications of Klee’s Bauhaus colleague László Moholy-Nagy on the future of writing.12 Even before Walter Gropius appointed Moholy-Nagy as master of the preliminary course (Vorkurs) in the spring of 1923, the book was already an object of concern at the Bauhaus. Both Johannes Itten, the previous master of the Vorkurs, and Lothar Schreyer, master of the theater workshop until 1923, produced printed works that played with the picturelike-ness of written words.13 When Klee began teaching at the Bauhaus in 1921, he was to lecture on design theory (Gestaltungslehre) and, fittingly, to take over the bookbinding workshop. This workshop was discontinued in 1922, due to both personal friction between Klee and the workshop master and the difficulty of fitting bookbinding into any program of modernization.14 But it was only when Moholy-Nagy came in 1923 that a radical transformation of writing and the book was theorized at the Bauhaus. Soon after his arrival, in the first book he designed—the catalogue accompanying the school’s exhibition in the summer of 1923—MoholyNagy published a short article on the “New Typography.”15 In this article, Moholy-Nagy announces that his “New Typography” aims not merely to make texts in the existing language visually clearer and more penetrating.
107
Annie Bourneuf
Instead, he writes, the new typography will eventually lead to a whole “new typographic language.” As we can see both in programmatic statements about the New Typography and in the printed matter Moholy-Nagy, Herbert Bayer, and others produced according to their principles, the Bauhaus project of reforming typography was ambitious.16 The “New Typography” aimed to pave the way towards a new language, a new pictographic writing for collective reading.17 Even what may now appear as the merely modish mannerisms of Bauhaus typography are attempts to reimagine reading and writing—for instance, Moholy-Nagy writes about the use of all-lower-case type as bridging the chasm between writing and speech, which knows no distinction between upper and lower case.18 Moholy-Nagy’s Painting, Photography, Film (1925; revised edition 1927), the eighth volume in the series of Bauhaus Books published by the school, is an attempt to show what the book of the future would be like—the book transformed by its incorporation of photography and of the effects of advertising and film into something very different from the sheltering “refuge” for the autonomy of script that is the traditional book.19 Johannes Molzahn, summing up the aims of the New Typography, proclaimed: “Stop reading! Look!”20 Much of this typography, preparing for the picture-writing to come, aimed to make reading more like looking—moving away from the old typography’s scripting of the reader’s gaze, left to right and top to bottom, away from the arbitrariness of the letters of the alphabet, towards a new “reading” that would be as free, natural, and universal as vision was understood to be. As we will see, some of Klee’s paintings of this period may be understood as, in part, a highly ambivalent response to this project: some push in the opposite direction, pushing seeing towards a temporal “reading” of signs in a definite, scripted order.
The Letter in the Square In 1923, concurrent with Moholy-Nagy’s statement on the New Typography, Klee initiated his series of what are known as his “square pictures,” all-over grids of colored rectangles. The first one he registered in his oeuvre catalogue (Figure 5.1) sets out the rules of the series.21 The painting, a smallish piece of paper, is coated with black paint against which the colored squares covering the surface glow. The grid functions as a “mapping of the space inside the frame onto itself”: the painting’s rectangular center, made of smaller units and brighter colors than the rest, reads as a painting within a painting.22 This inside area is visibly more tightly structured; its squares of color are arranged according to a reversed mirroring pattern with but one 108
A Refuge for Script
deviation, at the very center of the canvas, whereas the outside, framing area, organized by a simpler symmetry, includes many more deviations. These paintings seem to speak of nothing outside themselves, of their patterned relations among their parts. But they precipitate out of Klee’s own probing of the problem of “picture-writing” back in the mid1910s—concerns perhaps reactivated in 1923 by Moholy-Nagy’s use of the concept of “picture-writing.” As we will see, both Moholy-Nagy and Klee see what Moholy-Nagy calls “primeval picture-writing” (urzeitlichen Bildschriften) as the original form of writing, and reject yet preserve aspects of it in their very different sublations of the hieroglyph.23 Seeing Klee’s Bauhaus-era work in relation to the New Typography brings out important
5.1 Paul Klee, freundlicher Blick (1923/54), oil on paper on cardboard 31.7 × 22.2 cm Private collection 109
Annie Bourneuf
aspects of his concern with linear, temporal viewing, with the “movement” that is the central motif of his teaching and concern of his paintings during those years. This essay does not argue that the square pictures are a direct response to Moholy-Nagy’s 1923 text—the chronology is unclear and Klee, unsurprisingly, wrote nothing about his views on the New Typography.24 Yet Moholy-Nagy’s text can illuminate what is at stake in these paintings. In his 1923 statement, Moholy-Nagy speaks of the changes the New Typography will bring about—exactness of communication, collective rather than individual reception, the full incorporation of photography— by sketching a historical development from “primeval picture-writing” to present-day alphabetic writing and beyond to the “new typographic language.” Moholy-Nagy compares the photographs that will be integral to this new language to hieroglyphs, “the unexact primeval picture-writing of the Egyptians” (die unexakte Urbildschrift der Ägypter); but, writes Moholy-Nagy, while each reader interpreted the old hieroglyphs differently, according to “tradition and personal aptitude,” the photographs of the new language will enable entirely exact expression, substituting for those “still individually interpretable concepts and expressions” remaining in presentday language.25 Klee’s square pictures of 1923 also work out of the hieroglyph, but in a very different way. As vertically oriented all-over grids of colored rectangles stretched tightly over the surface, they take up the compositional form of his solution to the problem of “picture-writing” five years earlier. In 1916, Klee began making what he called “watercolored writing” or, later, “color-writing”—watercolors organized around lines of verse, in which the armature of the letters delineates areas to be “colored in” with watercolor (Figure 5.2).26 The first were built around excerpts of German translations of Chinese poems; his initial conception of the series revolved around the fantasy of the Chinese character as a true pictogram, melding the symbolic and iconic, seen as much as read.27 This fantasy of the Chinese character is based on the German Romantic theory of the hieroglyph as a primeval union of picture and writing, an inexhaustible fount of meaning, resistant to any final reading, untranslatable.28 The translations Klee used came from Hans Heilmann’s 1905 anthology, which began with a lengthy prefatory lament about the utter failure of the translations to approach the hieroglyphic multivalence of the Chinese character, which is, wrote Heilmann, drawing and writing at once.29 This conception of an original unity of writing and drawing, lost in the Latin alphabet but preserved in Chinese, was important for Klee, who spoke of “the prehistoric times of peoples, when writing and drawing still coincided.”30 This appears to have
110
A Refuge for Script
5.2 Paul Klee, Hoch und stralend steht der Mond. Ich habe meine Lampe ausgeblasen, und tausend Gedanken erheben sich von meines Herzensgrund. Meine Augen strömen über von Tränen (1916/20), watercolor and pen on paper on cardboard (a) 2.7 × 23.8 cm (b) 7.7 × 23.8 cm, Sammlung Ernst und Hildy Beyeler, Basel
been the impetus for his color-writings, attempts to improve Heilmann’s translations by using color to incorporate something of the iconicity of the Chinese poems as described in the preface. In 1918, however, Klee’s conception of these works shifted. No longer projecting pictogrammatic reconciliation onto another language, Klee’s watercolor Once emerged from the gray of night … (Figure 5.3) instead uses the rectangular units of a modular grid to mediate between writing and painting. Importantly, this painting is not based on any of Heilmann’s translations, but on a poem of Klee’s own composition. And it no longer attempts to unite writing and painting on the level of mode of signification. Instead, it takes up the material and procedural similarities between painting and writing, comparing the colored square to the letter as discrete units that make meaning only in relation to others. The resulting grid of colors and letters of Once emerged is, then, antithetical to the earlier color-writings. Rather than depicting a hieroglyphic unity of word and picture, this watercolor throws the difference between words and pictures back upon the viewer. The very similarity of reading writing and looking at a picture makes it impossible for the viewer to simultaneously read the poem as a poem and view the painting as a painting. Reading and looking oscillate back and forth through a figure– ground reversal—either the scaffolding of the letters or the colors spanning it come to the fore. Moholy-Nagy’s 1923 article warns specifically against typefaces that force letters into “a predetermined form such as the square”—precisely
111
Annie Bourneuf
5.3 Paul Klee, Einst dem Grau der Nacht enttaucht ... (1918/17), watercolor, pen and pencil on paper on cardboard 22.6 × 15.8 cm, Zentrum Paul Klee, Bern
the means by which Klee mediates between the letters of the words and the structure of the picture.31 Moholy-Nagy’s warning comes in the context of a more general point: “Readability—the message must never suffer under an aesthetic assumed a priori.” Indeed, Once emerged sets up a conflict between readability and the viewing of the watercolor as an aesthetic whole. We might see Klee’s square pictures as returning to the grid of colored squares of Once emerged to go much farther in this direction.32 112
A Refuge for Script
In the square pictures, readability suffers to such a degree under an a priori aesthetic that there is, so to speak, no message to be read in them at all.
“The eye follows paths established for it” Despite their relation to the text-grid of Once emerged, it may seem perverse to think of the square pictures as either readable or unreadable, so often has the grid in early-twentieth-century painting been seen as a “barrier … between the arts of vision and those of language.”33 But one of Klee’s very first square pictures, Centrifugal Memorial Page (1923) (Figure 5.4), strongly suggests that readability and unreadability are at stake in these pictures. Jürgen Glaesemer and Eva-Maria Triska’s standard accounts of the square pictures explain them by connecting them to Klee’s theoretical writings; indeed, Triska writes about them as exemplifying the close connection between Klee’s painting and the body of theory he developed while teaching at the Bauhaus. The very convincing connections Glaesemer and Triska draw are indispensable but also insufficient, for they make Klee’s paintings and writings into a closed circuit. According to these accounts, the square pictures are to be understood in terms of the color “movements” Klee described in his Bauhaus lectures and in the second of the Bauhaus Books that Moholy-Nagy designed, Klee’s Pedagogical Sketchbook (1925), which was based on his lectures.34 In 1921, Klee developed a series of layered watercolor gradations that he saw in terms of such movement; the square pictures attempt to create similar “color-movements,” but using oils, which, because of their relative opacity, require a very different approach.35 In the square pictures, Klee spreads, as it were, the layers of the watercolors over the surface—the one-square-beside-the-other of these paintings substitutes for the one-layer-on-top-of-the-other of the watercolors.36 The relations between the colors are understood as establishing vectors—dark to light, cool to warm—of just the kind Klee describes in his lectures and his Pedagogical Sketchbook.37 These paths are usually echoed by those generated by the coded reversals and mirroring devices he elaborated in his pedagogical writings (Figure 5.5).38 Together, these systematic relations between the colored squares of the grid lay down tracks for the viewer’s gaze, like the watercolor gradations or the graphic lines that Klee describes as movements for the viewer to retrace.39 As Klee writes in the Pedagogical Sketchbook: The work … is, in terms of production as well as reception: movement. … In terms of reception, this is due to the limitation
113
Annie Bourneuf
5.4 Paul Klee, centrifugales Gedenkblatt (1923/171), watercolor on primed paper on cardboard, 54.7 × 41.7 cm, Museum Ludwig, Köln, Leihgabe Sammlung Ludwig
114
A Refuge for Script
of the perceiving eye. The limitation of the eye is the impossibility of seeing even a surface of quite small dimensions sharply at the same time. The eye must graze away [abgrasen] the surface, grazing away and sharpening one part after the other. … The eye follows the paths established for it in the work.40 These accounts interpret Klee’s square pictures as laying down paths for the eye in this sense, by means of the color relations between the squares. Yve-Alain Bois has called Klee’s concern that the viewer’s eye follow the artwork’s “paths,” his linear, temporal model of reception, “dogmatic, authoritarian.”41 Commenting on the passage just cited, Bois writes that Klee does not even seem to trust his own model of viewing, for his paintings attempt to force it: using devices such as arrows and color
5.5 Paul Klee, Specielle Ordnung. Umkehrungen, Spiegelungen, Pedagogical Estate (Special Order), colored pencil and pencil on paper 33 × 21 cm, Zentrum Paul Klee, Bern, PN 30M60/68 115
Annie Bourneuf
gradations, Klee “tells you where to look, and in what order.”42 By drawing our attention to Klee’s controlling shepherding of the gaze, Bois puts us in a position to ask a question that drops out in accounts that explain Klee’s painting in terms of his own theoretical writings: Why is Klee so invested in this model of looking as sequential “grazing,” one part after the other? It is significant that in an earlier version of this analogy, from his lecture notes, Klee writes that the eye “like a grazing animal, feels the surface, not only from top to bottom, but also from left to right.”43 Once emerged and the Centrifugal Memorial Page both suggest that Klee’s notion of “grazing,” his scripting of the viewer’s gaze, is modeled on reading.
A Memorial Page The reversed mirroring pattern and the emphasis on the painting’s central rectangle place the Centrifugal Memorial Page in the square pictures series. But this Memorial Page (Gedenkblatt), unlike the other square pictures, is readable in places.44 Nested in its center are the lower-case letters “ei,” written in a handmade imitation of a printed typeface—which might be read as a word fragment, sound notation, or an all-lower-case Ei (egg). Then, in two twinned yellow squares of the periphery, two names are written less tidily: “PAUL ERNST” (Klee’s given names) and “ANNA WENNE.”45 Then, almost entirely unreadable, there are the dark horizontal lines of newsprint, for, as Klee’s title reinforces again, the page is quite literally the basis of this square picture. Only short phrases show through, here and there—Liküre hochwertig! (“High-quality liqueurs!”), Haut- und Geschlechtsleiden (“skin and venereal diseases”). To make this Memorial Page, Klee took a page of a broadsheet newspaper and made it very difficult to read, turning it upside-down and painting it over, first with chalk ground and then translucent watercolor. The unreadable newspaper’s organization provides the underlying matrix for the colored squares, the boundaries of which follow, in many places, the visible, if illegible, horizontals of the text and verticals separating the columns. The painting compares the “paths” established by the pattern of squares—indeed a centrifugal spiraling out from the center—to the highly codified “paths” newspaper layout provides for its readers, guiding them along by cues such as the size and typeface of headlines, the downward movement of columns, conventions correlating a story’s importance to its position on the page, along with the basic left-toright and top-to-bottom of European languages. The painting’s interest in reading as a convention-governed movement of the gaze, as a model for what Klee appears to conceive as the similar but more flexible movements of looking at a picture, comes out 116
A Refuge for Script
5.6 Paul Klee, Schaufenster für Damenunterkleidung (1922/125), watercolor and pen on paper on cardboard 41.9 × 27 cm, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, The Berggruen Klee Collection
most clearly in the peculiar name Anna Wenne. This name—apparently Klee’s invention—appears in one other place in his work, a watercolor of the previous year called Display Window for Ladies’ Underclothing (Figure 5.6). Anna Wenne’s name is written, like a proprietor’s, across this painting that calls itself a Display Window, a showcase for goods for sale and a surface for writing out on the street. The legibility of Anna Wenne’s
117
Annie Bourneuf
name would suffer less than most from one condition of writing on a shop window—that it may be viewed from inside the store, reversed. The reversability of Anna Wenne’s name—two palindromes (“ANNA” and “ENNE”) separated by the optical palindrome of the symmetrical letter W in the middle—outdoes even that of Anna Blume, Kurt Schwitters’ imaginary muse, whose palindromic qualities he celebrates in his famous poem of 1919.46 Anna Wenne similarly invites readers to read her backwards and forwards, and thereby to reflect on reading as a movement, with a direction. Her name asks in miniature what the Centrifugal Memorial Page urges as a whole: that the movement of reading be considered as a model for the kind of movement for which Klee wants his paintings to make paths. This painting takes up newspaper reading as a model for the kind of sequential looking that the square pictures as a group solicit—a kind of looking-as-reading. Klee’s square pictures of 1923 and the next few years might be viewed, then, as so many “memorial pages”—as memorials not only in the form of pages, but memorials to the page. They may be seen as a highly ambivalent response to reimaginings of reading at the Bauhaus that put a tremendous amount of pressure on the autonomy and privacy of the page of the book, which had long served as Klee’s model for the autonomy and privacy of his paintings. In a passage about the precarious situation of the autonomous object in Painting, Photography, Film, Moholy-Nagy takes the book as the exemplar of such autonomy, speaking of “the controversial easel painting or separate optical structure (in the sense that a book is an autonomous structure with a justification for existence independent of nature or architecture).”47 Based on the Old Typography’s grid of text, the grids of Klee’s square pictures test the easel painting as a place for a sequential looking that is like reading, and, by extension, as a refuge for private contemplation, understood as less and less possible in relation to script in books.
Acknowledgments I wish above all to thank Brigid Doherty for her acute comments and patient criticism. This essay benefited greatly from the insights and encouragement of Noam M. Elcott, Charles W. Haxthausen, Jennifer King, Benjamin Lytal, and Joyce Tsai. I am very grateful as well for the help of Christine Hopfengart, Fabienne Eggelhöfer, Heidi Frautschi, Marianne Keller, and Eva Wiederkehr Sladeczek at the Zentrum Paul Klee, Bern, and of Julia Friedrich at the Museum Ludwig, Cologne. A Fulbright–Institute of International Education/Swiss Government grant supported me while I researched and wrote this essay.
118
A Refuge for Script
Notes 1 Indeed, through Klee’s own classification of his work, this analogy has entered the apparatus of Klee scholarship. Klee compared his works to pages in the very categories he used to classify his work in the oeuvre catalogue in which he inventoried his production from 1911 on. From 1932 on, he does away entirely with the categories of watercolor and drawing and speaks instead, idiosyncratically, of colored or uncolored Blätter—pages, leaves, or sheets. Eva Wiederkehr Sladeczek, “Der handschriftliche Œuvre-Katalog von Paul Klee,” in Paul Klee: Kunst und Karriere. Beiträge des Internationalen Symposiums in Bern, ed. Oskar Bätschmann and Josef Helfenstein (Bern: Stämpfli, 2000), 150. When the Paul Klee-Stiftung, founded in 1947 (seven years after Klee’s death), inventoried its holdings, it borrowed from the language of Klee’s own oeuvre catalogue by dividing Klee’s work up into drawings, farbige Blätter (usually translated as “colored sheets”), and paintings. See Jürgen Glaesemer’s foreword to his catalogue, Paul Klee: Die farbigen Werke im Kunstmuseum Bern. Gemälde, farbige Blätter, Hinterglasbilder und Plastiken (Bern: Kornfeld und Cie, 1976), 8. While it is not uncommon in German to refer to works of graphic art as graphische Blätter, Klee’s insistence on referring to his watercolors as Blätter is unusual. 2 Clement Greenberg, untitled essay in Five Essays on Paul Klee, ed. Merle Armitage (New York: Duell Sloan and Pearce, 1950), 49, and “Art Chronicle: On Paul Klee (1870–1940),” in Greenberg: Collected Essays and Criticism, ed. John O’Brian, vol. 1 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1986), 71. The four other essays collected in Armitage’s volume were written by Howard Devree, Nancy Wilson Ross, James Johnson Sweeney, and Armitage himself. “Art Chronicle: On Paul Klee (1870–1940)”—Greenberg’s first essay on a single artist—was originally published in the Partisan Review, May–June 1941. I am grateful to Charles W. Haxthausen for pointing out the importance of these texts and showing me his fascinating essay, “Ad Marginem? Klee und die amerikanische Kunstgeschichtsschreibung,” forthcoming in Paul Klee et la France, ed. Gregor Wedekind (Paris: Éditions de la maison des sciences de l’homme, 2009). 3 Greenberg, Five Essays, 52–3. Haxthausen argues that not only did Klee, like all the painters on the faculty, continue to paint “private” easel paintings at the Bauhaus, but he painted easel paintings that were “parodies of murals” (such as his Wandbild aus dem Tempel der Sehnsucht “dorthin” [1922/30] and Wandbild [1924/128])—parodies of the hopes that many at the Bauhaus attached to murals as a way for painting, integrated into architecture, to regain a public function. One might thus see the “privacy” of Klee’s art not as simply detached from this project of restoring public function to painting, but as a critical response to it. Haxthausen, “Between Representation and Parody: Klee’s ‘Auratic’ Pictures,” The Study of Art History 1, no. 3 (2001): 19–21. 4 Greenberg, Five Essays, 52. 5 See also Foucault’s argument that Klee’s art abolishes one of the foundational principles of Western painting since the Renaissance, “the separation between plastic representation (which implies resemblance) and linguistic reference (which excludes it),” in part by making the space of his pictures “simultaneously page and canvas,” in his book on Magritte, This Is Not a Pipe, trans. James Harkness (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1973), 32–3. For a critique of both Koerner’s and Foucault’s interpretations of Klee’s work, see Regine Prange, “Das utopische Kalligram: Klees ‘Zeichen’ und der Surrealismus,” in Paul Klee: Kunst und Karriere, 206–10. Prange claims that Koerner’s essay suppresses “modernity and its rupture with classical artistic pictorial representation” to maintain the possibility of iconological interpretation, falling into the trap of Klee’s own metaphorics of what she calls “the utopian calligram” (207): Koerner is, she argues, caught up in “[t]he neoromantic totality concepts of modernity,” which, following from Friedrich Schlegel’s idea of the hieroglyph,
119
Annie Bourneuf
attempt to shore up classical pictorial representation (225). I would argue that a strong account of Klee’s work must engage with his metaphorics, his “primitivist iconography” (225), and that Koerner’s essay does so in exemplary fashion. 6 Joseph Leo Koerner, “Paul Klee and the Image of the Book,” in Rainer Crone and Joseph Leo Koerner, Paul Klee: Legends of the Sign (New York: Columbia University Press, 1991), 48–49, 53. 7 Ibid., 55. 8 Among a very large number of possible examples, see, for instance, Concentrierter Roman (1916/74), Inschrift (1918/207), the two versions of Er küsse mich mit seines Mundes Kuss (1921/142 and 1921/179), Buchstabenbild (1924/116), Zerstörtes Aegypten (1924/178), Ein Blatt aus dem Städtebuch (1928/46), Offenes Buch (1930/99), Abstracte Schrift (1931/284), Pflanzen-Schriftbild (1932/61), and Bilderbuch (1937/140), as well as the other works discussed by Koerner. 9 This pressure was not only a Bauhaus phenomenon; avant-garde typographers outside the school shared the concerns described. For an overview of the frequent discussions in Weimar Germany about a much broader “book crisis,” see the first chapter of Gideon Reuveni’s Reading Germany: Literature and Consumer Culture in Germany before 1933 (Oxford: Berghahn, 2006). 10 Benjamin, One-Way Street, in Walter Benjamin: Selected Writings, ed. Marcus Bullock and Michael W. Jennings, vol. 1, 1913–1926 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 1996), 456–7; Walter Benjamin: Gesammelte Schriften, ed. Rolf Tiedemann and Hermann Schweppenhäuser, vol. 4, ed. Tillman Rexroth (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1991), 102–4. All subsequent Benjamin citations in the text are taken from this short section of One-Way Street, titled “Attested Auditor of Books.” See Benjamin’s description of One-Way Street in his letter to Gershom Scholem of 22 December 1924, Walter Benjamin: Briefe, ed. Gershom Scholem and Theodor Adorno, vol. 1 (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1966), 367. In the first section of One-Way Street, Benjamin states that “[s]ignificant literary effectiveness” will result from the cultivation of “inconspicuous forms” such as “leaflets, brochures, newspaper articles, and posters,” rather than “the pretentious, universal gesture of the book” (Selected Writings, 444; Gesammelte Schriften, 85). For an illuminating discussion of how One-Way Street positions itself as one of these “inconspicuous forms,” and of how Benjamin took up the theories of Moholy-Nagy and other New Typographers regarding the future of reading, see Frederic J. Schwartz, “The Eye of the Expert: Walter Benjamin and the Avant Garde,” Art History 24, no. 3 (June 2001): 402–12. Benjamin’s interest in the material makeup of texts long predates his involvement with the typographical avant-garde. Scholem, speaking of the 1918–1919 period when he and Benjamin were living in Switzerland, remembered that “[t]he enthusiasm with which [Benjamin] was capable of discussing bindings, paper, and typefaces in those years frequently got on my nerves” (Walter Benjamin: The Story of a Friendship [Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1981], 71.) 11 Benjamin, One-Way Street, in Selected Writings, 456. 12 I discuss Benjamin’s interest in Klee’s work in a forthcoming article in Grey Room, “ ‘Radically Uncolorful Painting’: Walter Benjamin and the Problem of Cubism” and in my Ph.D. dissertation in progress on Klee’s work of the late 1910s. 13 For instance, Itten, “Analysen alter Meister,” in Utopia: Dokumente der Wirklichkeit, ed. Bruno Adler (Weimar: Utopia Verlag, 1921), or Lothar Schreyer, Kreuzigung. Spielgang. Werk VI (Hamburg: Kampfbühne, 1920). See the excellent catalogue, Ute Brüning, ed., Das A und O des Bauhauses. Bauhauswerbung: Schriftbilder, Drucksachen, Ausstellungsdesign, (Berlin: Bauhaus-Archiv, 1995). 14 See Klee’s letters to his wife of 14 and 19 April 1921 on the bookbinding workshop, in Klee, Briefe an die Familie 1893–1940, ed. Felix Klee, vol. 2 (Cologne: DuMont, 1979), 974–5. 15 Moholy-Nagy’s one-page article, “Die neue Typographie,” was originally published in
120
A Refuge for Script
Staatliches Bauhaus in Weimar, 1919–23 (Weimar and Munich: Bauhausverlag, 1923). It is reproduced in facsimile in Bauhaus. Drucksachen, Typografie, Reklame, ed. Gerd Fleischmann (Stuttgart: Oktagon, 1995), 14; an English translation is available in Moholy-Nagy, ed. Richard Kostelanetz (London: Penguin Press, 1971), 75. 16 Besides Das A und O des Bauhauses and Bauhaus, see “Typographie in der Reklame-Werkstatt,” in bauhaus utopien. Arbeiten auf Papier, ed. Wulf Herzogenrath (Cologne: Edition Cantz, 1988), 103–16, and Ute Brüning, “Die Druck- und Reklamewerkstatt: Von Typographie zur Werbung,” in Experiment Bauhaus (Berlin: Bauhaus-Archiv, 1988). 17 Otto Neurath’s “picture statistics,” which he presented to an enthusiastic audience of Bauhäusler in 1929, surely represent the most ambitious attempt to devise such a new pictographic writing for collective reading during the 1920s. See Peter Galison, “Aufbau/Bauhaus: Logical Positivism and Architectural Modernism,” Critical Inquiry 16, no. 4 (Summer 1990): 709–52; Robin Kinross, “Otto Neurath et la communication visuelle,” in Le Cercle de Vienne: doctrines et controverses, ed. Jan Sebestik and Antonia Soulez (Paris: Klincksiek, 1986), 271–88; Friedrich Stadler, ed., Arbeiterbildung in der Zwischenkriegszeit Otto Neurath–Gerd Arntz (Vienna: Österreichisches Gesellschafts- und Wirtschaftsmuseum, 1982); and Lynette Roth, Painting as a Weapon: Progressive Cologne 1920–33: Seiwert–Hoerle–Arntz (Cologne: Walther König, 2008). See also Constanze Hofstaetter, Karl Peter Röhl und die Moderne (Petersberg: Imhof, 2007), on the pictograms devised in the late 1920s by the Bauhäusler Karl Peter Röhl. 18 Moholy-Nagy, “bauhaus und typografie,” in Hans M. Wingler, Das Bauhaus, 1919–1933: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin (Bramsche: Gebr. Rasch, 1962), 124; originally published in the Anhaltische Rundschau (Dessau), 14 September 1925. 19 See Brigid Doherty’s analysis in “Photography, Typography, and the Modernization of Reading,” in A New History of German Literature, ed. David E. Wellbery (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 2004), 733–8. 20 Johannes Molzahn, “Nicht mehr lesen! Sehen!,” Das Kunstblatt 12 (1928): 78–82, translation in Weimar Republic Sourcebook, ed. Anton Kaes, Martin Jay, and Edward Dimendberg (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994), 648–9. Molzahn emphasizes the complete incorporation of photography into the illustrated magazines and newspapers of the future. 21 Besides freundlicher Blick (1923/54), the “square pictures” of 1923 include Harmonie blau–orange (1923/58), Architektur (1923/62), Statisch-Dynamische Steigerung (1923/67), Bildarchitectur rot gelb blau (1923/80), Buntes Beet (1923/109), centrifugales Gedenkblatt (1923/171), and Harmonie aus Vierecken mit Rot, Gelb, Blau, Weiss, und Schwarz (1923/238); Klee continued the series through the 1920s and beyond. Klee did not use the term Quadratbild for these works in his oeuvre catalogue—when he did not simply note the materials and format used, he referred to them as Tafelbilder, Ölgemälde or, in the case of the centrifugales Gedenkblatt, “grosses Aquarell.” See Paul Klee Foundation, ed., Paul Klee: catalogue raisonné, vol. 4 (London: Thames and Hudson, 1998–2004). The standard accounts of these works are Jürgen Glaesemer, Die farbigen Werke im Kunstmuseum Bern, 177–82, Eva-Maria Triska, “Die Quadratbilder Paul Klees—ein Beispiel für das Verhältnis seiner Theorie zu seinem Werk,” in Paul Klee. Das Werk der Jahre 1919–1933 (Cologne: Kunsthalle Köln, 1979), 45–78, and Triska, “Die Quadratbilder Paul Klees” (Ph.D. diss., University of Vienna, 1980). See also K. Porter Aichele, “Paul Klee’s ‘Rhythmisches’: A Recapitulation of the Bauhaus Years,” Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte 57, no. 1 (1994): 75–89, and Christian Rümelin’s discussion in Paul Klee: Leben und Werk, (Munich: Beck, 2004), 78–82. Will Groh mann called these works Klee’s “magic squares,” opening up the important questions of the relation of these paintings to the use of “magic squares” in musical composition; see Grohmann, Paul Klee (New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1955), 213–21, and Nancy Perloff, “Klee
121
Annie Bourneuf
and Webern: Speculations on Modernist Theories of Composition,” The Musical Quarterly 69, no. 2 (Spring 1983): 180–208. 22 See Rosalind Krauss on “centripetal” readings of the grid structures of modernist painting, “Grids,” October 9 (Summer 1979): 60–2. She does not mention Klee in the article. 23 Moholy-Nagy, “Die neue Typographie.” 24 Klee makes no explicit references in his letters or other writings to the New Typography— nor to many other subjects of heated discussion at the Bauhaus. It was his habit to stand apart from such debates; see Georg Muche’s description of Klee’s aloofness in Erinner ungen an Paul Klee, ed. Ludwig Grote (Munich: Prestel, 1959), 44. Hence his reputation as the “Bauhaus Buddha,” as in Ernst Kállai’s 1929 caricature. 25 In the 1910s and 1920s, many commentators spoke of the proliferation of images brought about by the technological media, in the illustrated press, advertising, and, above all, film, as the return of hieroglyphic writing. As Miriam Hansen writes, “The comparison between cinema and hieroglyphics appears rather early and frequently in discourse on film throughout the silent era … In most commentaries … the comparison between cinema and hieroglyphics is celebratory, if not apologetic; the underlying concept of hieroglyphics is one of a language of mystical correspondence and visual self-evidence, reincarnated in the new universal language of film.” Hansen, “Mass Culture as Hieroglyphic Writing: Adorno, Derrida, Kracauer,” New German Critique 56, Special Issue on Theodor W. Adorno (Spring–Summer 1992): 58. The American poet Vachel Lindsay, in his Art of the Moving Picture (New York: Macmillan, 1915), compared the new visual forms of the American mass media to Egyptian hieroglyphs: “American civilization grows more hieroglyphic every day. The cartoons of Darling, the advertisements in the back of the magazines and on the bill-boards and in the street cars, the acres of photographs in the Sunday newspapers, make us into a hieroglyphic civilization far nearer to Egypt than to England.” Cited in Miriam Hansen, Babel and Babylon: Spectatorship in American Silent Film (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1991), 77–8. As Hansen points out in “Mass Culture as Hieroglyphic Writing,” the metaphor of the hieroglyph was also used by the avant-garde to theorize montage; for instance, in “Beyond the Shot” (1929), Sergei Eisenstein recounts the legendary history of the Chinese character, which he terms the ieroglif (hieroglyph), from the origin of representational characters to their combination into compound symbols, which he identifies with filmic montage. The Eisenstein Reader, ed. Richard Taylor, trans. Richard Taylor and William Powell (London: British Film Institute, 1998), 82–3. 26 Klee designated several of the six 1916 watercolors which he based on excerpts of Chinese poems in translation as “watercolored writing” (Aquarellierte Schrift) in his oeuvre catalogue; see Paul Klee: catalogue raisonné, vol. 2. All six of the watercolors were shown at Klee’s February 1917 exhibition at Der Sturm gallery, Klee’s breakthrough to critical acclaim. On 13 February 1918, Klee wrote in a letter to his mother that he will “also make attempts with writing (color-writing)” (auch mit Schrift Versuche machen (Farbenschrift)), probably referring to his watercolor Once emerged from the grey of night. Klee, Briefe an die Familie, vol. 2, 905. Klee’s term, Farbenschrift, would seem most obviously to imply a writing, a script, made of color, but Schrift can also mean writing in the sense of treatise or work. Thus, for instance, in a letter to Goethe on 20 March 1806, the composer Karl Friedrich Zelter referred to Goethe’s Farbenlehre (then in preparation) as the Farbenschrift. Klee, who was fascinated by the Farbenlehre, had in his library the complete published correspondence between Goethe and Zelter; he may well have understood his Farbenschrift as a sort of Farbenlehre, a theory or doctrine of color in the form of color-writing. The very idea of a color-writing in a strong sense, in which color would signify as writing, has the potential to upset writing as a system. It is interesting in this context to look at the writings of Ferdinand de Saussure, Klee’s compatriot and near-contemporary, on the necessary and absolute insignificance for
122
A Refuge for Script
writing as a system of its material mode of production, including its color: “the means of the sign’s production is completely irrelevant, because it does not affect the system. … Whether I write letters in black or white … is of no importance for their signification,” Cours de linguistique générale (Paris: Payot, 1962), 165–6. 27 Klee was far from alone among his German-speaking contemporaries in drawing on such translations of Chinese poetry; Kafka wrote enthusiastically to Max Brod about Heilmann’s translations in 1920, Webern set a poem of Wang Seng Yu’s to music in 1914, and Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde was based on another set of German translations of Chinese poems. The interest in Chinese characters, in particular, may be traced back to Leibniz’s interest in them as a possible model for a characteristica universalis, a universal ideographic language. The early-twentieth-century surge of interest in translations of Chinese literature and in the problems attending such translations was not at all confined to the German-speaking world—Apollinaire, Pound, and others were involved with the subject. “The concept of Chinese writing,” writes Jacques Derrida, “thus functioned as a sort of European hallucination … this functioning obeyed a rigorous necessity,” Of Grammatology, trans. Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1998), 80; see chapter 3, “Of Grammatology as a Positive Science.” 28 See Steven C. Schaber, “Novalis’ Theory of the Work of Art as Hieroglyph,” Germanic Review 48 (1973): 35–43; Liselotte Dieckmann, “The Metaphor of Hieroglyphics in German Romanticism,” Comparative Literature 7, no. 4 (Autumn 1955): 306–12; and Dieckmann, Hieroglyphics: The History of a Literary Symbol (St. Louis, MO: Washington University Press, 1970). 29 Heilmann, Chinesische Lyrik vom 12. Jahrhundert v. Chr. bis zur Gegenwart (Munich: Piper, 1905). “The ideographic pictures of the writing address themselves to the eye,” writes Heilmann, “even before they become words. … Once they have become words, however, they do not cease but rather truly first begin to have a painterly effect” (xxxiii). 30 Klee, Beiträge zur bildnerischen Formlehre, vol. 2, Anhang zum faksimilierten Originalmanuskript, Transkription und Einleitung von Glaesemer (Basel and Stuttgart: Schwabe, 1979), 15. Unless otherwise noted, all translations are my own. 31 Many did attempt, during the early years at the Bauhaus, to create typefaces based on the square and other elementary geometric forms; see Robin Kinross, “Das Bauhaus im Kontext der Neuen Typographie,” in Brüning, Das A und O des Bauhauses, 9, and Ute Brüning, “Kalligraphie und Konstruktion,” ibid., 35. See Moholy-Nagy’s later, more measured words on such attempts in “Zeitgemäße Typografie. Ziele, Praxis, Kritik” (1926), in Fleischmann, Bauhaus, 19. 32 Koerner also suggests that the square pictures might be seen as precipitating out from Once emerged, describing them as “painting at its furthest remove from any narrative or illustrative elements, and yet the grid that makes up Once emerged suggests that what might now be abstract once (einst) was more bookish,” 65. 33 Krauss, “Grids,” 50. 34 See Klee, Pädagogisches Skizzenbuch, originally published as volume 2 of the series of bauhausbücher, available in a facsimile edition (Berlin: Gebr. Mann, 2003), 48–51. The very form of the Pädagogisches Skizzenbuch represents a collaboration between Klee and MoholyNagy, who designed the book. 35 As Glaesemer writes, “For instance, the technique of layering glazes to make color gradations can only be applied to a very limited degree in oil painting. Without much success he attempted … to extend this transparent way of painting to opaque paints by mixing the techniques of watercolor and oil painting,” until Klee arrived at the very different solution the square pictures offered to the problem of creating color-movements (Die farbigen Werke, 177–8). 36 Glaesemer writes that Klee’s “attempts to put progressive color-movements to use in oil
123
Annie Bourneuf
painting as well led finally, as if of their own accord, to the genre of ‘square pictures’,“ ibid., 178. Glaesemer lays out with exemplary clarity the relation between the layered watercolor technique Klee developed in 1921 and his theoretical writings (ibid., 167–70), as well as that between the layered watercolors and the square pictures (177–80). See also Triska, “Die Quadratbilder Paul Klees,” 49, 62–3. 37 Besides the already cited pages of the Pädagogisches Skizzenbuch, see also Klee’s teaching notes or “Pedagogical Estate” (the Pädagogischer Nachlass in the collection of the Zentrum Paul Klee, Bern), such as PN 26, M45, 45–7, and the illustration in Glaesemer, 167. 38 See PN 30, M60/68 and 71, reproduced in Paul Klee: Die Kunst des Sichtbarmachens. Materialien zu Klees Unterricht am Bauhaus, ed. Michael Baumgartner and Christine Flechtner (Bern: Benteli, 2000), 78–9. See also Susanne Friedli, “Specielle Ordnung (PN 30 M60),” in the same catalogue, 69–74. 39 Klee, Pädagogisches Skizzenbuch, 6–8. Klee, Schriften: Rezensionen und Aufsätze, ed. Christian Geelhaar (Cologne: DuMont, 1976), 172–3. 40 Klee, Pädagogisches Skizzenbuch, 23. 41 Yve-Alain Bois, “ ‘Der liebe Gott steckt im Detail’: Reading Twombly,” in Abstraction, Gesture, Écriture: Paintings from the Daros Collection (Zurich: Scalo, 1999), 64–5. 42 Ibid. 43 Klee, Beiträge, 98. Also suggestive in this respect is the word Klee wrote in pencil at the top of Once emerged, along the uppermost of the ruled lines he drew on the cardboard mount for the inscription of the title: Bahn (track, path). 44 Klee made a number of works between 1917 and 1924 which he termed memorial pages (Gedenkblätter) or commemorative sheets (Erinnerungsblätter), such as Erinnerungsblatt an eine Empfängnis (1918/75), Gedenkblatt mit dem eisernen Kreuz (1918/125), and Gedenkblatt (an Gersthofen) (1918/196); as Otto Karl Werckmeister has pointed out, these works may be connected to the mass-produced Gedenkblätter, “picture prints with a framed blank space in which to inscribe the name of a soldier killed in action, which army authorities sent as formal notifications to his relatives.” Werckmeister, The Making of Paul Klee’s Career 1914–1920 (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1989), 139. Other artists working in Germany during the war and its aftermath, from Käthe Kollwitz to George Grosz, also drew upon the Gedenkblatt in a wide variety of ways. Perhaps particularly pertinent to Klee’s Centrifugal Memorial Page as a memorial to reading is the Berlin Dadaist Johannes Baader’s collage with photomontage Gutenberggedenkblatt (1919), also known as the Ehrenporträt von Charlie Chaplin. 45 Richard Verdi, Klee and Nature (New York: Rizzoli, 1985), 206. 46 “Weißt Du es Anna, weißt Du es schon,/Man kann Dich auch von hinten lesen … Du bist von hinten, wie von vorne:/A—N—N—A,” writes Schwitters in “An Anna Blume.” Schwitters, Das literarische Werk, ed. Friedhelm Lach, vol. 1 (Cologne: DuMont, 1973), 58–9. On the relation between Anna Wenne and Anna Blume, see Paul Bauschatz’s insightful article, “Paul Klee’s Anna Wenne and the Work of Art,” Art History 19, no. 1 (March 1996): 86–92. 47 Moholy-Nagy, Painting, Photography, Film, trans. J. Seligman (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1969), 16. Malerei, Fotografie, Film (1927 edition), facsimile republication (Mainz: Florian Kupferberg, 1967), 14.
124
Chapter 6
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs Laura Muir
If the Bauhaus has proved an unwieldy historical subject, the role of photography at the school is perhaps even harder to pin down because of its unofficial status and the variety of modes in which it was practiced. Although there was no formal workshop devoted to photography before 1929, the innovative explorations of the many Bauhaus artists who experimented with the medium during the 1920s constitute one of the most vital episodes in the history of photography.1 As objects, the photographs themselves are similarly elusive, neither adhering to a single “Bauhaus style” nor representing the type of functional object typically associated with the established workshops. Created free from the requirements of any formal course, but deeply inspired by the school’s spirit of artistic innovation and fascination with technology, the photographs are among the most powerful expressions of the whole Bauhaus experiment. Photography’s rise in popularity at the school coincided with the arrival in 1923 of the young constructivist artist László Moholy-Nagy, whose own photographic experiments and writings on art and technology exemplified the new direction in which Walter Gropius hoped to take the school. For the older painters on the faculty who had helped Gropius to shape the initial course of the Bauhaus, this development, which threatened to dramatically reduce their role at the school, was deeply unsettling.2 One painter voiced his concerns in a 1925 letter in which he comments on an article Moholy-Nagy had recently published: “Nothing but optics, mechanics, taking the ‘old’ painting out of service … he talks of movies … projections, and movement, and even of mechanically produced ‘optical 125
Laura Muir
slides’ … but why attach the name of art to this mechanization of all visual things …?”3 Within a few years of writing these words, Lyonel Feininger experienced a surprising change of heart. By 1928 the 58-year-old painter was himself pursuing photography as an important mode of artistic expression. Despite his initial skepticism, Feininger enthusiastically embraced the technical complexities of this “mechanical” medium, investigating them through an array of experimental techniques. In the fall of 1928 and spring of 1929, Feininger photographed the Bauhaus and its environs in all weather conditions and often at night before retreating to the darkroom to continue his explorations with the enlarger and through negative printing. Shared only with family and a few trusted friends, this intriguing body of work has remained largely unknown and has never been fully explored.4 A study of it reveals that Feininger’s quiet pursuit of photography played a surprisingly important role in his creative life during this period. Fein inger found in photography an invigorating and artistically liberating activity that, in turn, inspired him to explore new directions in his painting practice. His approach to photography drew inspiration from his experience as both painter and printmaker as well as from the dazzling photographic techniques promoted by Moholy-Nagy and practiced by many of the other amateur photographers at the Bauhaus. In contrast to their characteristically lighthearted images, Feininger’s photographs are mostly uninhabited, contemplative, and dreamlike, revealing an unfamiliar and intensely personal view of the Bauhaus while reflecting his enchantment with the unique possibilities of a new medium. When Gropius invited Feininger to join the Bauhaus in 1919 as his first faculty appointment, the painter was considered to be one of the most important modern artists in Germany. After beginning his career as a cartoonist in the 1890s, the American-born artist had gone on to achieve considerable fame for his luminous cubist-inspired paintings of German towns and churches and, shortly before coming to the school, for his work in the medium of woodcut. At the Weimar Bauhaus, Feininger became head of the printing and graphics workshop and directed the publication of the Bauhaus print portfolios. He also continued to exhibit and sell his work, achieving a degree of financial security over the next few years that no longer made it necessary for him to teach.5 When the school moved to Dessau, Gropius arranged for Feininger to retain the title of Bauhaus Master but without teaching obligations. In July 1926 Feininger moved into No. 3 Burgkühnauer Allee, half of one of the two-family masters’ houses designed by Gropius, the other half of which was occupied by MoholyNagy and his wife Lucia Moholy.
126
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
By the time Moholy-Nagy and the Feiningers became neighbors, the young Hungarian artist’s influence at the school had grown considerably. In addition to promoting an interest in technology through his teaching of the preliminary course and direction of the metal workshop, he was exerting tremendous influence through his extracurricular experiments with photography and theoretical writings about the medium. He encouraged artists to think of photography not simply as a means of reproducing and recording, but as a way of producing entirely new art.6 He argued that phot ography had the power to provoke a fresh rapport with the visual world— a “new vision”—by rendering the familiar unfamiliar through unexpected viewpoints, extreme close-ups, radical cropping, negative printing, and the photogram technique, all of which he demonstrated in his seminal Painting, Photography, Film, published as the eighth Bauhaus Book in 1925.7 Photography also became the focus of intense interest for many other Bauhaus artists. Inspired by Moholy-Nagy’s experiments, as well as the striking imagery of the new illustrated newspapers and avant-garde film, students and teachers alike used it to document their daily lives and conduct a variety of innovative experiments. One of the most exceptional of these amateur talents was Lux Feininger, Lyonel’s youngest son. A student at the Dessau Bauhaus from 1926 to 1932, Lux spent his free time playing in the school’s jazz band and roaming the campus with his camera, recording exuberant views of student life. Lyonel’s eldest son, Andreas, who was living at home while studying architecture at the Anhaltischen Bauschule in the nearby town of Zerbst and later while working for an architectural firm in Dessau, also took up the camera during this period and would go on to pursue photography as a career. In 1927 he built a darkroom in the basement of their house and became particularly interested in darkroom manipulations.8 Lyonel’s middle son, Laurence, took up the camera around this time as well. In a June 1928 letter to Alfred Barr, Feininger reported: “All three boys are good amateurs with the camera and of course do their own developing and printing, on which so much depends.”9 Feininger followed his sons’ photographic activities with great interest, and their enthusiasm undoubtedly contributed to his own shift in attitude toward the medium. Lux Feininger recalls that his father “got turned on to [photography] by my brother and myself. Our photographing rather copiously gave him somehow the idea he would like to do it too … I was merely doing my own photography and he was very interested, constantly wanted to see what I had done and he began …”10 Feininger’s feelings about Moholy-Nagy had also warmed in the intervening years as a personal relationship developed. Upon learning of his colleague’s departure from the school in June 1928, Feininger wrote to his wife Julia:
127
Laura Muir
That is really a gap that will not be filled easily. … All the many people that were welcomed next door at No. 2 with hearty cheers! The friendly and powerful voice of Moholy that pierced through the wall between our studios during his conferences! He cared about the exchange and circulation of Bauhaus ideas and was the most amiable and helpful, and most vital person.11 By the fall of 1928 Feininger had acquired a camera (the “beloved” Voigtländer Bergheil, which took 4.5 × 6 cm glass-plate negatives) and began making a series of photographs around the neighborhood at night.12 On 31 October 1928, he wrote to Julia about a recent outing: At nightfall I set out with my camera firmly attached to the tripod and made about 12 exposures of night scenes with lanterns and lighted windows. Dessau has changed countenance for me since I have been prowling about a good deal with the camera, intensely observing.13 The intriguing detail that Feininger’s first serious foray into photography took place at night might in part be explained by the fact that during the day he painted, leaving evenings free for him to draw, make prints, or pursue other artistic activities that did not require natural light.14 While practical necessity may have played a part, photographing after dark was in fact perfectly suited to the solitary and private nature of Feininger’s project. Unlike most of the other amateur photographers at the school, who were interested in recording their fellow students and their high-spirited activities during the daylight hours, Feininger, who was now relatively estranged from the daily life of the Bauhaus, preferred to find his subjects in the evening when the streets were deserted. At night, he could also engage in this activity without drawing attention to himself. The fact that during this initial period Feininger did not venture much beyond the street where the masters’ houses were located also suggests the kind of circumspection with which he approached his work with photography. Feininger may also have been inspired by other contemporary artistic explorations of the night. Night imagery and the effects of artific ial lights were a source of intense fascination for the modernist architects, painters, filmmakers, and photographers of the period. In spite of the technical challenges it posed (focus, exposure times), night photo graphy become increasingly popular in the 1920s as urban electrification became more widespread. It was also among the techniques that MoholyNagy promoted in his 1925 Bauhaus Book, Painting, Photography, Film, with which Feininger was certainly familiar. The examples Moholy-Nagy
128
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
reproduced record urban settings with streaming headlights captured by long exposures and the exaggerated reflections of streetlamps in puddles and on wet pavement.15 While these photographs use the stark contrasts of the night to evoke the dynamism and energy of the modern city with its cars, trams, and illuminated signage, Feininger’s photographs emphasize the stillness and ambiguities of the night, qualities that had attracted him to the subject long before he ever took up the camera. A small charcoal drawing from 1906 depicting a dark deserted street illuminated by a single streetlamp reveals his early interest in the theme while looking ahead to his photographs along the empty Burgkühnauer Allee.16 In one particularly haunting image from this series he 6.1 Lyonel Feininger, Untitled (Night View of Trees and Streetlamp, Burgkühnauer Allee, Dessau), 1928, gelatin silver print, 17.7 × 23.7cm
explores the atmospheric effects of street lights on a foggy November evening (Figure 6.1). By concealing his light source behind a tree, he avoided the technical problem of halation, a flaring caused from the light reflecting back from the negative’s emulsion support.17 This strategy enabled him to capture the ghostly effects of the light radiating through the damp air as well as the slim silhouettes of the trees in the foreground, recalling Caspar David Friedrich’s atmospheric night scenes in which figures and trees are often silhouetted against the light of a softly glowing
129
Laura Muir
moon.18 Feininger has often been discussed as an heir to the Romantic tradition in German painting, particularly in connection to his seascapes and depictions of Gothic architecture,19 but the affinity between his night photographs and the pensive nocturnal scenes of the German Romantic painters is also worth noting. Despite the modernity of his medium, setting, and source of illumination, Feininger’s photographs are permeated by the same misty air, contemplative mood, and mysterious quality of light. In contrast to more contemporaneous preoccupations with the night by artists such as George Grosz, Ludwig Meidner, and Otto Dix who stressed its negative, threatening, and chaotic aspects in works addressing societal ills and anxieties,20 Feininger’s work echoes the Romantics’ positive attitude toward the night.21 He sought to convey its tranquillity and the way it transformed his everyday surroundings into something alluringly unfamiliar— a quality the Romantics described as the “estrangement effect.”22 In this respect, Feininger’s photographs are perhaps most closely aligned with the night explorations of the French surrealists, anticipating the uncanny and enigmatic photographs that Brassaï would make, beginning in 1929, of deserted Parisian parks and streets during the course of his own nocturnal wanderings.23 The themes of light and photography are brought together in another photograph from this series, in which Feininger records the brightly lit window of Moholy-Nagy’s former studio (Figure 6.2). Made several months after his neighbor’s departure, the quotation marks Fein inger inscribed around the words “Moholy’s Atelierfenster” in the title indicate that, although Josef and Anni Albers now occupied this half of the masters’ house, it was still powerfully associated with the previous resident.24 The warm glow emanating from the studio suggests both the presence of the artist as well as human creativity. The large lighted window also suggests the materials and processes of photography. The window panes evoke the rectangular glass-plate negatives that Fein inger was using in his camera, and the creative moment when they are exposed to light to record an image. Feininger’s elegant meditation on the absence of his former colleague and the medium with which he was so closely associated might also be seen as an innovative kind of portrait and perhaps as an acknowledgment of the fact that it was only after Moholy-Nagy’s departure that Feininger was able to embark on his own experiments with photography. The defamiliarizing and bold graphic effects that attracted Fein inger to night photography also drew him to the technique of negative printing. Moholy-Nagy had praised the technique’s transformative effects in his essay “Photography is Creation with Light,” which Feininger would
130
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
likely have seen when it appeared in early 1928 in an issue of the Bauhaus magazine with one of Moholy-Nagy’s own photographs illustrating the technique.25 Later that year, perhaps working in the darkroom alongside his son Andreas, who was also experimenting with the technique, Feininger began to produce his own negative images, printing standard negatives onto diapositive plates from which enlargements could be made.26 Twice removed from the reality of the daytime, his negative image of one of the masters’ houses (Figure 6.3) reverses the already distorted tonalities of the night view.27 The sky becomes light and the brightly lit studio window
6.2 Lyonel Feininger, “Moholy’s Studio Window” around 10 p.m., 1928, gelatin silver print, 17.8 × 12.8 cm 131
Laura Muir
becomes a nebulous black mass, while the darkened stairwell window is transformed into a delicate trellis of glowing lines. Negative printing also served as a new means of exploring some of the effects that had fascinated Feininger a decade earlier during his intense engagement with the woodcut—a medium, like photography, that Feininger was drawn to for its flexibility, expressivity, and possibilities for experimentation.28 Both techniques emphasized bold forms, stark contrasts between black and white, and the play of positive–negative effects. Both required the creation of a matrix from which a print was made, and both involved an inversion of that image. While the “negative” image carved into the woodblock remained an invisible part of the process, the negative print made it visible. In his woodcuts Feininger would frequently pair corresponding areas of black and white, evoking light and shadow as well as the negative–positive transformation of the woodblock process (see, for example, his treatment of the spaces around the cathedral’s doors and buttresses and in the sky above in his 1919 print for the cover of the Bauhaus proclamation (Figure 1.1, page 14). With its total reversal of tonalities, the negative print allowed Feininger to take the graphic, abstract, and disorienting effects of the woodcut a step further in images
132
6.3 Lyonel Feininger, Untitled (Negative Image of a Master’s House, Burgkühnauer Allee, Dessau), 1928–1929, gelatin silver print, 17.7 × 23.8 cm
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
6.4 Lyonel Feininger, Bauhaus, 26 March 1929, gelatin silver print, 17.9 × 24 cm
that were perhaps all the more satisfying for having been extracted from the real world. On 22 March 1929, after several months of actively photographing, Feininger finally approached Gropius’s Bauhaus building as a subject. The evening before, he had been photographing at the Dessau railway station and written to his wife Julia that the night had been “magically beautiful,” the moon “high up in the sky … almost full, in a haze. …”29 On his way home Feininger probably would have passed by the northeastern side of the Bauhaus building, and perhaps the sight of it in the moonlight inspired him to return the following evening with his tripod and a fresh supply of negatives.30 Four nights later he embarked on a more extensive campaign. Starting at dusk and working into the night, he circled the campus, photo graphing the building from all directions, this time getting much closer and shooting from unusual angles. When he photographed the east side of the studio building, for example, he positioned his camera near one corner and angled it upward in order to achieve a dramatic worm’s-eye view and dia gonal composition that accentuates the geometry of the building and the way its distinctive balconies are illuminated from below (Figure 6.4). Feininger gave about a dozen of these views to Gropius, who 133
Laura Muir
had left the Bauhaus and moved to Berlin in 1928. Gropius, who was in the process of collecting images for his Bauhaus Buildings Dessau, published in 1930 as the twelfth Bauhaus Book, selected two of Feininger’s photographs for the volume (Figure 6.4 and a vertical image depicting the south side of the studio building).31 Among the only night views in the book, Fein inger’s pictures are juxtaposed with daytime images of the same subject by the Bauhaus photographer Erich Consemüller and the Moscow-based photographer Wutke.32 These pairings underscore the fact that most of the photographs of the building from this period were made during the daytime and focus either on student life or the way the architecture gleamed in the sunlight. A growing interest in photographing modernist architecture after dark is reflected in only one other set of images in the book, by an unidentified photographer, in which every light is ablaze.33 An accompanying caption notes how well the night illumination reveals the building’s construction. Feininger, however, used the night to create a more personal and expressive portrait of the Bauhaus. He was less interested in recording the details of the architecture than he was in conveying a mood. In his night photographs the famous glass walls and windows are randomly lit, emphasizing less the structure of the building than the individuals and their activities taking place within it, while accentuating his own position outside of it. Gropius’s book also reproduces many photographs of the Bauhaus that he commissioned from Lucia Moholy.34 Certainly aware of her project, Feininger sought to accomplish something quite different. Photographing the building on his own initiative and after Gropius’s departure, Feininger’s pictures of the former director’s achievement are more contemplative than celebratory. The twilight softens the hard geometry of the architecture and transforms the Bauhaus into a serene, dreamlike world— a fantasy that belies the reality of the turbulent period that ensued after Gropius’s departure in 1928 and during the controversial directorship of Hannes Meyer. In 1929 Feininger painted a view of a modern apartment building at dusk (Lighted Windows I), its dark rectangular mass pierced by brightly lit windows, one shining upward like a beacon into a delicate blue-green sky.35 It is likely that this is the small night picture “composed after a photo graph” that Julia Feininger refers to in a letter she wrote to her husband on 17 May 1929.36 Although one of Feininger’s night views of the Bauhaus probably did not serve as a study for this work, the theme of a modern building illuminated by randomly lit windows and the still, quiet mood of the painting are strikingly similar. The fact that Feininger was drawing inspiration from his work with photography is not at all surprising. Upon making his earliest photographs, he had declared “Dessau has changed
134
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
countenance for me”37 and a few months later he asserted that “photography has taken the way I see to a new level …”38 He believed that the camera helped him to see the world with fresh eyes, revealing subjects that had previously gone unnoticed and proposing new ways of approaching them, which naturally led him to consider how it might enhance his painting practice. Later that spring, after receiving a commission to paint a view of the city of Halle, Feininger began photographing its architectural landmarks with the specific intention of using the photographs as studies for paintings. After amassing a group of negatives, he wrote to Julia: “I shall have about 100 enlargements to make! Not a bad result of my endeavors in Halle. I find I can paint very well after compositions from photos. I shall have splendid material for important new paintings.”39 About a month prior to leaving for Halle, in the late afternoon of 1 April 1929, Feininger pointed his camera out his studio window in order to photograph a stand of pine trees in his front lawn.40 Feininger had been struck by the graphic potential of these trees upon arriving in Dessau in 1926, writing to Julia about how pleasantly situated the masters’ houses were in a “sun-filtered pine wood” and remarked on the “rhythm of the slender upright stems.”41 The camera proved an ideal means by which to capture this temporary convergence of trees and light and the remarkable warp-and-weft-like pattern it created. His bird’s-eye view enabled him to record the trees’ long shadows on the ground while flattening the space and giving the image a slightly vertiginous quality. In one photograph from this series (Figure 6.5) he introduces a third element: the narrow trapezoidal band of the front walk, interrupting the vertical and horizontal lines with a bold diagonal, which further emphasizes the abstract geometry of the scene. If Feininger’s painting Lighted Windows I was composed after a photograph, we might consider the possibility that this photograph was inspired by a painting. The diagonal path through the woods, overhead viewpoint, and complex network of lines in the photograph are also present in Feininger’s 1915 painting Avenue of Trees (Figure 6.6), which hung in the living room of his master’s house.42 Feininger would have seen it every day and perhaps recognized elements of it in the view outside his studio window, finding in nature the kind of precise linearity that he used in his paintings in order to transform the real world into a more abstract version of itself. In returning to the real world with this photograph, Feininger retained the geometry and formal rigor of the painting, but replaced its crystalline coolness with the new elements of airy space and warm natural light. By early May 1929 Feininger was in Halle and beginning
135
Laura Muir
preparations for his new painting commission. On 16 May he wrote to Alfred Barr: I have been taking photos of the principal sites. … When I have copies I must send you some views. … I am very much wedded to my little camera, and having begun very late in life to photograph and to do my own chemical work, I am all the more intensely devoted to the process. I enclose a few enlarged copies of various subjects taken in Dessau [three night views and one negative print], hoping they will interest you.43 During Barr and Jere Abbott’s visit to the Bauhaus in December 1927 and in subsequent correspondence, both men had been enthusiastic about Lux’s photography.44 It was perhaps this show of interest that encouraged Feininger to send each of them a sampling of his own work.45 Despite this openness to sharing his photographs with people he respected, Fein inger did not pursue more public exposure for it. His photographic work was essentially a private endeavor, and it was the private nature of the project—working alone at night, in the darkroom, and in cold and damp weather—that gave him such freedom to experiment. Because it was not
136
6.5 Lyonel Feininger, Untitled (Trees and Shadows, Burgkühnauer Allee, Dessau), 1 April 1929, gelatin silver print, 17.7 × 23.7 cm
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
6.6 Lyonel Feininger, Avenue of Trees, 1915, oil on canvas, 80.5 × 100.5 cm
his primary work or source of income, it was also never a source of the pressure and depressions that painting sometimes caused him. Instead it became a kind of stimulating, almost therapeutic activity that he turned to when he was unable to paint. In October 1928 Feininger wrote to Julia: “I mainly have been out with my small camera, which has been the most bearable of activities. … I have made some progress on my music, but not with painting—my vitality is too low for that.”46 A few days later he writes that he has been photographing again and “while out walking my jittery spirits are calmed and I am restored enough to make a start at painting. I see now that to paint is still better than to take photographs – but the latter is also stimulating in a way of its own.”47 The push and pull that Feininger experienced between painting and photography had a counterpart in his wife’s determined promotion of his career as a painter and her uneasiness about his attachment to the camera. Feininger’s slightly awkward assurance that “to paint is still better than to take photographs” was less a reflection of his own feelings than an attempt to allay her concerns. Lux Feininger recalls that his mother was “almost morbidly sensitive to any public references of linking Feininger’s art 137
Laura Muir
to photographs. My father was unwilling to cause her discomfort and thus kept pretty quiet about his activities along those lines.”48 The publication of his photographs in Gropius’s Bauhaus Buildings Dessau was an exceptional occurrence and his work, unlike that of his sons’, was never included in any of the period’s many publications or exhibitions devoted to avant-garde photography. It is possible that Feininger, who printed his photographs with great care, signing, dating, and titling many of them like any other work of art, might have pursued this if not for the obstacle presented by his wife’s intense disapproval. In deference to her wishes, he kept his photographic work to himself, and, as a result, it has remained virtually unknown.49 Feininger’s photographs are curious Bauhaus objects. Although he employed the same experimental techniques associated with “Bauhaus photography,” his subjects existed for the most part outside of the school and its bustling activity. When he photographed the building, it was after dark when the campus was deserted. Instead of playful and spirited, his images are introspective and otherworldly. These photographs, however, probably would never have come into being if the medium had not become the focus of such concentrated interest at the school and within Feininger’s own household. They also provide insight into Moholy-Nagy’s influence, exemplifying not only the techniques he promoted, but also, and perhaps most significantly, his belief that photography represented a new way of seeing and experiencing the world. For the painter who took up the camera late in life, photography provided not only artistic stimulation but also a new sense of vitality. The irony of Feininger’s devotion to a medium that was widely seen to have displaced painting is complicated by his ongoing commitment to painting and the fact that his work with photography seems in fact to have energized and enriched that practice at a critical moment. The story of Feininger’s photographs is inseparable from his experience as an artist at the Bauhaus and the story of the school itself. The photographs are the product of an institution and individual in transition, reflecting Feininger’s anxieties about how the Bauhaus was changing, how he fit in, and were ultimately, perhaps, a means of reconciling his artistic vision with the new order.
Notes 1 For an overview of this subject, see Jeannine Fiedler, ed., Photography at the Bauhaus (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1990). 2 For a discussion of this transitional moment, see Rose-Carol Washton Long, “From Metaphysics to Material Culture: Painting and Photography at the Bauhaus,” in Bauhaus Culture: From Weimar to the Cold War, ed. Kathleen James-Chakraborty (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2006), 43–62.
138
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
3 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 9 March 1925, Lyonel Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (1986), Houghton Library, Harvard University. 4 Sixteen of Feininger’s Bauhaus photographs are part of the Walter Gropius bequest at the Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin. Almost all of his other surviving photographs, some 500 vintage prints, are in the collection of Harvard University’s Houghton Library, along with his papers. Feininger’s negatives (glass-plate and film) as well as a collection of his slides (c. 18,000 objects in total), made during the course of what became an almost thirty-year engagement with the medium, are part of the Lyonel Feininger Archive at the Harvard Art Museum/Busch-Reisinger Museum, which also contains paintings, watercolors, finished drawings, and over 5,000 sketches by the artist. Although a handful of Feininger’s photographs have appeared in various publications devoted to his work, they have been used primarily as illustrations in chronologies or as comparatives to his paintings. The only photographs to have been extensively reproduced are those that Feininger made in the city of Halle between 1929 and 1931 as a means of selecting motifs and as studies for a painting commission. These photographs are thoughtfully discussed in connection with Feininger’s Halle painting series in Wolfgang Büche’s Lyonel Feininger: Halle-Bilder, Die Natur-Notizen (Leipzig: Beck & Eggeling Kunstverlag, 2000) and Lyonel Feininger: Die Halle-Bilder (Munich: Prestel-Verlag, 1991), which includes a brief essay (pp. 90–5) in which Andreas Hünecke discusses the photographs as works of art in their own right while acknowledging that the subject of Feininger as a photographer is still an open field for discovery. 5 Ulrich Luckhardt, Lyonel Feininger (Munich: Prestel-Verlag, 1989), 41. 6 László Moholy-Nagy, “Production-Reproduction,” (De Stijl, 1922). Reprinted in Christopher Phillips, ed., Photography in the Modern Era: European Documents and Critical Writings, 1913–1940 (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1989), 79–82. 7 László Moholy-Nagy, Malerei, Photographie, Film (Munich: Albert Langen Verlag, 1925). 8 T. Lux Feininger, “Lyonel Feininger’s Photography,” unpublished ms, 1995, 1, Lyonel Fein inger Archive, Harvard Art Museum/Busch-Reisinger Museum; T. Lux Feininger, interview by the author, Cambridge, MA, 24 May 2000. 9 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Alfred Barr, 30 June 1928, Alfred H. Barr, Jr. Papers, 3a.A.[8]. The Museum of Modern Art Archives, New York. 10 T. Lux Feininger, interview by the author, Cambridge, MA, 10 March 2003. Feininger wrote about his sons’ various photographic activities and successes in several letters. See, for example: Lyonel Feininger, letter to Alfred Barr, 30 June 1928, Barr Papers, 3a.A.[8]. MoMA Archives, New York, and Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 29 September 1927, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2088), Houghton Library. 11 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 29 June 1928, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2112), Houghton Library. 12 T. Lux Feininger, interview by the author, Cambridge, MA, 10 March 2003. 13 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 31 October 1928. Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2147), Houghton Library. 14 “… I can keep on working for 8 to 9 hours now, painting during the day, in the evening by artificial light I am either drawing or printing or doing some other thing to further me …,” 4 March 1925. Leona E. Prasse, Lyonel Feininger. A Definitive Catalogue of his Graphic Work: Etchings, Lithographs, Woodcuts (Cleveland: Cleveland Museum of Art, 1972), 32. 15 Moholy-Nagy, Malerei, Photographie, Film, 53, 121. 16 See Lyonel Feininger, Untitled (Houses and Streetlamp), 15 January 1906, charcoal on paper, Busch-Reisinger Museum, BR63.5425. 17 Feininger eventually was able to overcome this challenge after a great deal of experiment ation with various “anti-halatic” negatives, which allowed him to record the streetlamps
139
Laura Muir
while controlling the enchanting coronas they created. T. Lux Feininger, “Lyonel Feininger’s Photography,” 1, Feininger Archive, Busch-Reisinger Museum. 18 See, for example, Friedrich’s painting Two Men Contemplating the Moon, c. 1830. Reproduced in Sabine Rewald, Caspar David Friedrich: Moonwatchers (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2001), 35. 19 Carla Schulz-Hoffmann, “Kunst ohne Eigenschaften? Lyonel Feininger und die Romantik,” in Lyonel Feininger von Gelmeroda nach Manhattan: Retrospektive der Gemälde, ed. Roland März (Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, 1998), 321. 20 See Stephanie Rosenthal, “Grossstadtnächte grell geschminkt,” in Die Nacht, ed. Stephanie Rosenthal et al. (Munich: Haus der Kunst, 1998), 135–152. 21 Roger Cardinal, “Night and Dreams,” in The Romantic Spirit in German Art 1790–1990, ed. Keith Hartley (London: Hayward Gallery, South Bank Centre, 1994), 191. 22 Rewald, Caspar David Friedrich: Moonwatchers, 11. 23 Anne Tucker, Brassaï: The Eye of Paris (Houston: The Museum of Fine Arts, 1999), 28. Brassaï’s night photographs achieved widespread fame in 1932 when they were published in his book Paris de Nuit. 24 In 1928 Josef Albers also took up photography and made use of the darkroom with which the Moholys had equipped the house. Albers sought advice from Lux Feininger on how to operate his new 35 mm Leica camera and made some portrait photographs of Lyonel Feininger on the roof of their two-family masters’ house. Whether Lyonel shared his own photographic activities with his new neighbor, however, is unknown. Karen Haas, “More than Meets the Eye: Josef Albers and Photography,” in Josef Albers in Black and White, ed. Karen Haas (Boston: Boston University Art Gallery), 11. 25 László Moholy-Nagy, “Fotografie ist Lichtgestaltung” in Bauhaus 2 (1928): 6. 26 Although Feininger was a self-taught photographer, it is possible that Andreas, the expert technician in the family, occasionally may have advised his father on certain darkroom techniques, including negative printing. T. Lux Feininger, interview by the author, 10 March 2003. 27 For a positive print of this night view see Lyonel Feininger, Burgkühnauer Allee 4 around 10 p.m., 1928, gelatin silver print, Bauhaus-Archiv, Berlin, 6326/2. 28 Prasse, Lyonel Feininger. A Definitive Catalogue of his Graphic Work, 31. 29 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 22 March 1929, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2153), Houghton Library. 30 The path of the moon as it traveled across the sky (visible in Feininger’s negatives but cropped out of his prints) reveals an exposure time of several minutes. See Lyonel Feininger, Untitled (Night View of the Bauhaus Building, Dessau), 22 March 1929, glass-plate negative, and Untitled (Night View of the Bauhaus Building, Dessau), 22 March 1929, gelatin silver print, Busch-Reisinger Museum, BRLF.28.11, BR60.36.2. 31 These photographs are now part of the Gropius collections at the Bauhaus-Archiv in Berlin. Although Feininger may have given the photographs to Gropius simply out of friendship, he may also have known that Gropius was in the process of gathering images for his book, possibly through his son Lux whose photographs also appear in the volume. 32 Walter Gropius, Bauhausbauten Dessau (Munich: Albert Langen Verlag, 1930), 40–3. 33 See Gropius, Bauhausbauten Dessau, 58–59. For a discussion of the period’s fascination with illuminated architecture see Dietrich Neumann, “Lichtarchitektur and the Avant-Garde,” in Architecture of the Night: The Illuminated Building, ed. Dietrich Neumann (Munich: Prestel Verlag, 2002), 36–51. 34 One of the only professionally-trained photographers at the school, Lucia Moholy was liked and admired by both Lyonel and Lux Feininger. T. Lux Feininger, interview by the author, 10 March 2003.
140
Lyonel Feininger’s Bauhaus Photographs
35 Reproduced in Hans Hess, Lyonel Feininger (New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc., 1961), cat. no. 314. 36 Andreas Hüneke, catalogue entry for Beleuchtete Häuser-Zeile I, 1929, in Lyonel Feininger von Gelmeroda nach Manhattan, 162. 37 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 31 October 1928, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2147), Houghton Library. 38 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 21 May 1929, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2164), Houghton Library. 39 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 13 May 1929, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2161), Houghton Library. 40 Feininger wrote on the box containing his glass-plate negatives for these photographs: “Dessau: From My Studio Window.” A typewritten label on the same box reads: “schattenaufnahmen II” (shadow photographs), box for BRLF.30.1-14, Feininger Archive, BuschReisinger Museum. 41 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 4 August 1926, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2051), Houghton Library. 42 In a 1927–8 photograph by Andreas Feininger the painting is visible on the west side of the room. Drawing inspiration from this earlier work would have been in keeping with Fein inger’s practice of occasionally basing paintings on sketches made years earlier. 43 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Alfred Barr, 16 May 1929, Barr Papers, 3a.A.[8]. MoMA Archives, NY. 44 Lux Feininger’s photographs are mentioned in the following letters: Jere Abbott, letter to Lyonel Feininger, 20 December 1927; Alfred Barr, letter to Julia Feininger, 18 December 1927; and Alfred Barr, letter to Lyonel Feininger, 22 April 1928, 12 May 1928, and 11 June 1928, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2), (15), (18), (19), (20), Houghton Library. 45 The photographs Feininger sent to Barr on 16 May 1929, are in the Archives (Alfred H. Barr, Jr. Papers) and Photography Department at MoMA. The photographs he gave to Abbott are in the Smith College Museum of Art. 46 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 27 October 1928, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2145), Houghton Library. 47 Lyonel Feininger, letter to Julia Feininger, 31 October 1928, Feininger Papers, bMSGer 146.1 (2147), Houghton Library. 48 T. Lux Feininger, letter to the author, 11 February 2008; T. Lux Feininger, interviews by the author, Cambridge, MA, 2 February 2006 and 13 June 2007. 49 What Feininger did do, however, was preserve the work, saving almost 500 vintage photographs and around 18,000 negatives and slides. After both his parents died, Lux Fein inger gave these collections to Harvard University’s Houghton Library and Busch-Reisinger Museum (see note 4).
141
Chapter 7
Excavating Surface On the Repair and Revision of László Moholy-Nagy’s Z VII (1926) Joyce Tsai
The paintings of László Moholy-Nagy have hardly ever attracted the kind of attention his other works have garnered. He secured his reputation as an artist less on the strength of his paintings and more on the theoretical ingenuity of his various experimental projects. He ordered enamel panels from a sign factory and exhibited them as EM1, EM2, and EM3 at a show of his paintings at the Galerie der Sturm in 1924.1 Derived from the German word for enamel, Emaille, the title emulated the language of industrial production, mimicking its seemingly anonymous and systematic logic. The critic Adolf Behne argues in an article from 1924 that these works, in their radically reduced aesthetic vocabulary, suggest a future when art would no longer remain the domain of the privileged but would become accessible to all. Anyone, Behne muses, might one day be able to place a telephone call to order paintings as durable as street signs, factory direct.2 MoholyNagy integrated this imaginative scenario in his retrospective account of the works’ origin twenty years after the fact, an account which inaugurated their more common name, the Telephone Pictures.3 At the Bauhaus, where Moholy-Nagy taught from 1923 to 1928, he flaunted his enthusiasm for photography and was seen by his fellow masters as an enemy of painting.4 He declared on several occasions, most notably in Painting, Photography, Film (1925), that in the face of new technologically sophisticated media, and of photography especially, painting cannot help but become an anachronism.5 In these years, he would claim that not only was painting doomed to obsolescence but art, narrowly understood as an autonomous realm of 142
Excavating Surface
creative activity, must too be abandoned.6 Moholy-Nagy would stop painting altogether in 1928 in order to focus on developing new technologies that would enable artists to work with the possibilities of light. Given the trajectory of his artistic career of the 1920s, it is clear why his contemporaries and more recent scholars have viewed MoholyNagy as an artist for whom painting was nothing more than a dusty historical relic, to be replaced with new media commensurate with the demands of the modern industrial world. This narrative of Moholy-Nagy’s artistic career has been shaped by the perception that his artistic project moved from a preoccupation with painting in pigment to painting in pure light, following a progressive arc of technologically-mediated dematerialization.7 Over the course of the 1920s, it would seem that Moholy-Nagy grew ever more impatient with the intractable limitations of easel painting—its messy materiality, its static nature, its problematic surface prone to damage and to the vicissitudes of the hand. Looking at an oil painting such as Z VII (1926), a work which hangs in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, this teleology appears to ring true (Figure 7.1). The surface of the painting has a provisional, slapdash feel to it. An imprecisely spaced pencil grid has been inscribed on the surface of a gray plane. Along points of intersection, uneven dabs of blue paint have been applied (Figure 7.1a). The expanse of haphazardly applied blue dots cannot help but foreground the imprecision of the hand and underscore the tedious temporality of this manual work. Unlike enamel, its uneven surface, pockmarked by years of abrasions and losses, speaks to the material fragility of painting. Patches of mismatched pigment betray several campaigns of repair and restoration, some of which are documented in the provenance (Figure 7.1b).8 Even if we try to imagine away these smaller blemishes, there is one area of damage we cannot overlook. A section of the circle is distended, swollen like a scar marking an old wound (Figure 7.1c). A photograph of the back of the canvas shows that the fabric itself had been rent and a white paste had been applied to it, perhaps to seal or to stabilize the rip.9 And that bulge in the circle, struggling to conceal the tear in the canvas, highlights how unwieldy thick, gooey paint is, how it impedes the production of immaterial effects. Z VII seems to testify, point for point, the reasons why Moholy-Nagy would eventually abandon painting in 1928. After all, why paint, when factories could theoretically produce pictures impervious to damage by executing them on cheap, durable, industrial supports? Why paint, when the camera captures the world with such breathtaking facility and speed? Why paint, when light could be made to dance on walls with the right technology? However, Moholy-Nagy returned to painting in 1930, after two
143
Joyce Tsai
7.1d Detail: center dark red square. These drying cracks result from the application of multiple layers of paint without each drying thoroughly.
7.1b Detail: lower right edge of canvas, revealing provenancedocumented repairs. 144
7.1c Detail: gray circle with patched tear
7.1a Detail: inside of lower parallelogram with dots overlaid on a penciled grid. Traces of bloodred visible as the faint outline of black here along the edges of the plane.
Excavating Surface
7.1 László Moholy-Nagy, Z VII, 1926, oil on canvas, 95.3 × 76.2 cm (37½ × 30 in)
145
Joyce Tsai
enormously productive years curating photography shows, designing stage sets, and promoting emerging media through his publications and editorial contributions. He began to paint once more after he achieved his long-standing dream to produce a kinetic light display machine. This is a fact that disrupts the familiar narrative of Moholy-Nagy as the consummate artist-turned-engineer, rejecting the brush in favor of the machine; abandoning painting in favor of photography. Moholy-Nagy’s concomitant investment in painting and in new technological media has baffled generations of critics and scholars. It has been seen as an inconsistency in his thought—or, worse, as a retreat from the radical positions he took in the 1920s.10 Even in the early 1930s, Moholy-Nagy understood and anticipated the perceived discrepancy between his stated project of the 1920s and his artistic practice of the 1930s. Writing in October 1934 to his second wife, Sibyl, after seeing an exhibition of his work in Utrecht, he laments, there are so few people who really can grasp [my paintings] in their reality and because they don’t know anything about the effort put into their making and nothing about the overarching problems [gesamtproblematik] with which these paintings engage … a gallerist in utrecht told me that because of my photograms, the newspaper there sent a photography expert to the exhibition who didn’t have the slightest idea as to how to begin dealing with the paintings.11 The reception of his Utrecht show underscored the extent to which the reputation Moholy-Nagy cultivated over the course of the 1920s overshadowed any reception of his paintings. He realized that his paintings appeared to his public to be incommensurate with his aesthetic project altogether. Z VII has largely eluded critical attention. It was in a private collection until 2007 and had been shown only in a handful of small exhibitions over the past few decades, probably in no small part because of its problematic condition.12 However, as this study will show, this particular painting, precisely because of its damage, undergoes a number of transformations and comes to assume an extremely important place in MoholyNagy’s thinking about the interrelatedness of different media. In 1934, in the same month he expressed his frustration with the reception of his paintings in Utrecht, he began work on a retrospective monograph, a spec ial issue of the journal Telehor, which offered an overview of his artistic career. Incorporating a selection of his theoretical writings and a range of illustrations of his painting, photography, film, and sculpture, MoholyNagy saw the publication as an opportunity to describe the relationships among these different practices, to offer an overview of what he called
146
Excavating Surface
his gesamtproblematik. Serving as the cover image for this publication is a color reproduction of Z VII in its repaired state but shown horizontally, rotated 90 degrees clockwise from its original vertical orientation (Figure 7.2). It will emerge that sedimented on the surface of Z VII are the traces of Moholy-Nagy’s struggle to clarify the place of painting in his artistic project. Z VII is a curious hybrid, at once representative of his work from the 1920s and wholly anomalous. Judging from its title and composition, it is absolutely a work of the 1920s. The composition Z VII is similar to a picture such as A XX (1924), which is structured by the presence of a dominant circle underpinning a complex of suspended planes (Figure 7.3).13 However, the use of color and the achieved surface on Z VII is completely foreign to Moholy-Nagy’s paintings of the 1920s. In paintings of the period, his compositions provide the scaffolding for his exploration of effects of translucency, transparency, and luminosity. The colors, often within a restricted chromatic range, are all deployed to produce the illusion of an architectonic structure hovering in an infinite space or to render in paint the
7.2 László MoholyNagy, ZVII, 1926, as published in Telehor 1:1–2 (1936): cover 147
Joyce Tsai
effect of overlapping shafts of light. Z VII feels comparatively obstinate in its refusal to achieve the effects so prevalent in his paintings of that time (Figure 7.1). Unlike the smooth, delicate surfaces of his works of the 1920s, which sought to suppress the traces of the hand—of obvious brushwork— Z VII is a painting with several rapid shifts in facture, moving jarringly, for instance, from the heavy impasto of the gray disc to the thinly rendered expanse of brilliant red constituting the plane jutting below the circle, running vertically down the center of the picture. The vertical strip of uninterrupted, viscid white cuts partially into the right side of that red plane and conjoins it to a pane of pink. The opacity of that white strip repudiates what should read structurally as a convincing area of translucent overlap. That impervious white disrupts the coherence of the central structure. Here, the planes start feeling like discrete shapes, ratcheted together to constitute a compact, almost sculptural figure. There is evidence to suggest that the differences between Z VII and Moholy-Nagy’s paintings from the 1920s emerged as a result of repair. Z VII, as noted above, suffered a trauma to the canvas. A tear, several
7.3 László MoholyNagy, A XX, 1924, captioned as A2, 1926 in Telehor 1:1–2 (1936): 53 148
Excavating Surface
centimeters long, was roughly patched. The swell in the circle marks the area where the application of thick viscous paint attempts to conceal the rip—paint distributed across the circle with broad, unbroken strokes applied with a stiff-bristled brush (Figure 7.1c). If this were simply a matter of patching up a tear, we would expect to see a more localized instance of stitching and not this kind of vigorous, if not obsessive, repainting pursued in the whole of that sector. The dramatic nature of the intervention suggests that Moholy-Nagy repaired this bit of damage with his own hand. This is an interpretation borne out by the fact that the paint and technique used to fix this bit of damage is quite different from those deployed in the areas repaired in documented, posthumous campaigns of restoration. According to curatorial files that detail the provenance, Z VII’s dimensions were expanded by about a half a centimeter to fit a frame bought for it by the collector in 1991. The paint used to fill in the newly exposed edges of the expanded picture is discernible, for the color has shifted over the last few years and no longer matches the painting itself. Under ultraviolet light, the difference between the original paints and those used in restoration is even more evident (Figure 7.4).14 The restoration paints fluoresce a dirty yellow, which appears in the black-and-white illustration in this volume as
7.4 László MoholyNagy, Z VII, 1926, pre-treatment photograph (under UV light) 149
Joyce Tsai
a haze along the perimeter of the canvas, intruding too in isolated cloudy patches in the lower right quadrant, and at the halo emitting from the lower outer circumference of the gray circle. By contrast, the tear with its surrounding areas within the circle fluoresces a streaky lilac, its striations integrated, even if unevenly, into the structure of the brushwork spread across the gray sector. Unlike other areas of subsequent conservation treatment where repairs and restoration are identifiable as discrete patches, this entire section of the circle was treated with a continuous, highly impastoed coat of paint. There is ample evidence that Moholy-Nagy cleaned and restored many of his own works throughout his life, especially in his years in exile during the 1930s in the Netherlands, London, and Chicago.15 However, in this instance, Moholy-Nagy’s intervention cannot be characterized as an act aimed at conserving the original painting. The gray circle was not restored but repainted; it appears that other portions of the canvas were too. The opacity of the thick, slick, cold gray paint constituting the ground for the network of hastily applied blue dots seeks to deny the existence of another color underneath it. However, abrasion has excavated the blood red that the layer of gray was supposed to suppress, a red that also peeks out along the outer borders of that plane. In the reproduction in this volume, that red reads like the barest traces of a black outline at the edges of the dotted plane (Figure 7.1a). The relief-like black, the hard, glossy, beige planes at the painting’s corners, and the central dark red square all share in an insistent opacity. That central red square puckers from the application of impatient layers of paint atop one another without allowing each to dry thoroughly (Figure 7.1d). The impulse to apply coat after coat of opaque paint to the canvas appears to have been motivated by the repair of the picture, coming about as if to balance the thickly plastered surface burying that long lesion in the circle. No exact date can be given for the changes made to Z VII. However, the repaired painting, given a new patchwork coat of colors, gains a special significance by 1936. Z VII graces the cover of Telehor, a journal publication that also served as one of the few retrospective monographs published during Moholy-Nagy’s lifetime (Figure 7.2). The project came out of an invitation extended by the Czech architect František Kalivoda, who asked Moholy-Nagy to organize a show of his art in Brno, in then Czechoslovakia, and to submit a selection of reproductions of his work and writings.16 Moholy-Nagy was in the process of writing his introductory essay, an open letter, for the publication in the same month he wrote his wife about his alarming encounter in Utrecht with the puzzled photography expert who could not grasp his paintings.17
150
Excavating Surface
Kalivoda envisioned Telehor as a forum to explore new international developments in visual art. The internationalism of its ambition is evident from the fact that all of the texts—Sigfried Giedion’s introduction, Moholy-Nagy’s writings, and Kalivoda’s postscript—were all translated from their German original and published in their entirety in the same volume in French, English, and Czech. As Kalivoda underscores in his postscript, Telehor was not intended to be a monographic series. Rather, he hoped to produce thematically-oriented issues that would address crucial problems facing contemporary artists. He maintains that the singular focus on Moholy-Nagy’s work is justified by the fact that his oeuvre comprises several different media and practices all engaged with the problem of light, which Kalivoda calls the “decisive artistic problem of the next few decades, if not centuries.”18 For Kalivoda, the importance of light cannot be overstated, for it is the condition of possibility for any vision. The introduction of electric light led to commercial uses in the metropolis, demonstrating the efficacy of this new technology. Kalivoda argues that Moholy-Nagy’s work offers a glimpse into how light technologies might one day be developed to help cultivate a politically progressive vision.19 The one work by Moholy-Nagy that most obviously addresses the aims stated by Kalivoda is his Light Prop for an Electrical Stage (Lichtrequisit einer elektrischen Bühne, �������������������������������������� 1930), which was unveiled at the Werkbund Exhibition in Paris in 1930 (Figure 7.5).20 The Light Prop was shown in that context as a prototype for further industrial development. It represented the culmination of a dream for Moholy-Nagy, the fulfillment of his desire to break free of the limitations of easel painting. With the invention of this machine, the generation of light, color and spatial effects need no longer be restricted to the illusions produced within a single painting. Moholy-Nagy could manipulate pure luminous color through the complex interaction of the light generated by electric bulbs and reflected dynamically off the machine’s rotating polished surfaces. The machine was destined for the stage, a space far more expansive and inclusive than the picture gallery. Rather than a discrete picture for the single viewer who might pause and contemplate it, Moholy-Nagy’s Light Prop promised to reach a broader audience, perhaps even a mass audience ready to respond to the new effects it could generate by immersing them in a new environment. Moholy-Nagy’s preoccupation with this project is rooted in his long-standing belief that the task of the artist under modernity is not to produce individual autonomous works of art but to transform human vision. At stake in transforming vision is the conceit that a social and political revolution cannot come by simply supplying the masses with the correct political message. Instead, what is necessary is the fundamental reconfiguration of
151
Joyce Tsai
how an individual perceives the world, which would analogously transform how he comports himself towards it.21 To reconfigure perception, the artist must mobilize all that science and industry have to offer, and use technology as a catalyst in this process. Kalivoda’s postscript echoes these commitments in his description of the urgency of Moholy-Nagy’s artistic project. Curiously, where Kalivoda’s postscript emphasizes the future potential of Moholy-Nagy’s projects, Moholy-Nagy’s introductory text for the volume, an open letter addressing the editor’s questions written in
7.5 László MoholyNagy, Das Lichtrequisit, 1922–1930, as published in Telehor 1:1–2 (1936): 81 152
Excavating Surface
1934, orients itself to the past. This is perhaps not altogether strange, as part of what the publication aims to do is to offer an overview of MoholyNagy’s work. However, the text Moholy-Nagy pens is strangely defensive in its tone. It opens, dear kalivoda, you are surprised that i am again arranging a growing number of exhibitions of both my earlier and more recent work. it is true that for a number of years i had ceased to exhibit, or even to paint. i felt that it was senseless to employ means that i could only regard as out of date and insufficient for the new requirements of art at a time when new technical media were still waiting to be explored.22 Later in the same text, he writes, you are acquainted with my light requisits and my “lightplay black-white-grey.” It took a great deal of work to assemble all this material, and yet it was only a very modest beginning, an almost negligible step forward. nor was i able fully to carry out my experiments even within this limited sphere. you have every right to ask, why i gave in, why i am painting and exhibiting pictures, after once having recognized what were the real tasks confronting the “painter” of today.23 The tone of his letter throughout is striking. We should bear in mind that this publication was Moholy-Nagy’s first retrospective monograph, and Kalivoda, the editor, touted him as one of the most important avant-garde artists of his generation.24 One would expect, under these circumstances, something more celebratory, or at least a more neutrally descriptive account of his career than a text that underscores the failure to achieve his own stated aims. Moholy-Nagy’s letter opens with the admission that his abandonment of painting and pursuit of projects such as the Light Prop at the end of the 1920s amounted to little more than “a very modest beginning, an almost negligible step forward.” He describes the possibilities and potential of “orchestrated symphonies of light,” “light frescoes,” and the illumination of the night sky with monumental “architecture[s] of light.”25 With regard to these projects, which he would never realize, he writes, it is an irrefutable fact that the material dependence of the artist on capital, industry and working equipment presents an
153
Joyce Tsai
insurmountable obstacle today to the successful creation of a true architecture of light. … while possession of a few brushes and tubes of color enables the painter in his studio to be a sovereign creator, the designer of light displays is only too often the slave of technical and other material factors, a mere pawn in the hands of chance patrons.26 Moholy-Nagy offers a sober description of the limitations that technologically-mediated art poses by virtue of its technical and capital demands. These lines were written in the midst of a global economic crisis, at a moment when Moholy-Nagy’s practical hopes of finding the resources to advance his ambitious projects had already been dashed. The Light Prop was built by a licensed mechanic, designed by an architect, and funded by the German industrial conglomerate Allgemeine Elektrizitäts-Gesellschaft (AEG). It offered a model for bringing art into a collaborative relationship with technology and industry. However, the actual prototype produced was never a fully functional machine. It was extremely fragile and unstable. Its creaky gears got stuck, parts came dislodged, and its primitive motor failed upon multiple occasions.27 Nonetheless, Moholy-Nagy hoped that his project to bring into being a workable light machine for the stage would find investors, but no one came forward to fund additional research or development. Plans to showcase the Light Prop at a “Contemporary Room” (Raum der Gegenwart), which Moholy-Nagy conceived as a pendant to El Lissitzky’s “Abstract Cabinet” in Hannover, fell through for lack of funds.28 Discernible in Moholy-Nagy’s open letter is his reluctant acknowledgment that the transformation of human vision by way of technology has inherent limits. Such a transformation called for capital and expertise he could never amass on his own. He understood that to pursue such means would demand compromises he was unwilling to make. It would force him to become nothing more than “a mere pawn in the hands of chance patrons.”29 At stake in his return to painting is a desire to carve out a space to explore the possibilities of creating “new vision” without obliging him to accumulate resources his more technologically ambitious projects required. In a sense, he saw that painting could become technological media’s surrogate because it need not be chained to means necessary to execute the kinds of projects he dreamed of pursuing in the 1920s. Despite the fact the Light Prop was never further developed, Moholy-Nagy remained preoccupied with this work for the rest of his life, transporting the unwieldy machine to his various stations of exile.30 It is also reproduced in Telehor several times as photographs, sketches, and
154
Excavating Surface
film stills.31 This preoccupation with the Light Prop is also evident in the kinds of effects he sought to achieve in his paintings of the 1930s. During the early years of that decade, Moholy-Nagy wrote with much pleasure about his new paintings to his colleagues and friends, including the likes of Franz Roh, art historian and theorist of photography. In March 1934, Moholy-Nagy writes, i’ve been painting a few very nice paintings on highly polished sheets of silberit [a type of aluminum]. an interesting effect: the colored planes float in an abstract space that is constituted only through reflections and mirroring.32 In the 1930s, Moholy-Nagy explored painting both on canvas and on new synthetic and metallic supports he bought with the little money he had or salvaged from his freelance commercial exhibition design projects. He moved away entirely from the architectonic compositions of the 1920s, opting instead for free-floating shapes against fathomless grounds with barely visible lines, sometimes incised on those supports, to tether those figures to one another. One example of this kind of painting can be seen in his Construction AL 6 (1933–1934), from exactly the moment Moholy-Nagy writes to Roh (Figure 7.6).33 It is also one of the eight paintings reproduced in color along with Z VII in Telehor. Here, Moholy-Nagy worked on an aluminum plate with five identically sized cut-out circular holes. This plate is secured with brackets, which hold it in front of a painted wooden plank. The holes in the painting provide areas where real shadows are cast, where light qualities shift with the changes in the surrounding. And although the painting cannot move, Moholy-Nagy activated the polished metal surface through the application of patiently engraved lines and circles in the metal. This carefully and deliberately scratched surface invites the viewer to move in order to catch the light, glinting off at different angles from the painting. There are no obvious affinities between Z VII and AL 6. One is executed on canvas, the other on aluminum, and they do not share much by way of their composition. But the two paintings are linked by their preoccupation with the Light Prop. Seen in relation to the machine, Z VII’s anomalies begin to make sense (Figures 7.1, 7.5). The blue dots spread across the parallelogram bear a likeness to the perforations on a metal plate caught against a dark shadowed ground, akin to the variously perfor ated panels that comprise the body of the Light Prop or the kinds of metal sheets he affixed to his paintings of the 1930s. And the circle, which was so obsessively repainted with layers of thick, gray paint, starts to feel like a textured metal disc. It is rendered as if in movement, partially enshrouded in shadow and partially caught behind translucent planes. The planes
155
Joyce Tsai
coalesce, not into an architectonic structure, but into a near-hallucinogenic vision of what a levitating light machine of the future might look like, freed of sticky gears and unreliable engines. What this painting makes present is not what the Light Prop is, but what it might become. Kalivoda writes in his postscript for Telehor that the journal seeks to introduce Moholy-Nagy’s work because it shows future potential of “light as an artistic medium” through the exploration of new “technical possibilities.”34 As much as Kalivoda understands painting to be a part of Moholy-Nagy’s project, he sees it as merely provisional. He writes, in our opinion the painters of today have an important educational responsibility: for painting proper is a training both for the artist and for the public. yet it can be no more than a transitional phase, leading to new and higher forms of expression.35 It is then all the more striking that what graces the cover of Telehor is not a picture of the Light Prop, arguably Moholy-Nagy’s most famous
7.6 László MoholyNagy, AL6, 1932, as published in Telehor 1:1–2 (1936): 68 156
Excavating Surface
contribution to the exploration of light technology, but a painting worked in a medium which Kalivoda describes as “transitional” (Figure 7.2). Although this painting bears affinities to the Light Prop, publishing the reproduction horizontally disrupts its direct association with Moholy-Nagy’s light machine. Turned on its side, the planes expand laterally, the sculptural quality so palpable in its vertical orientation disperses. If we examine a photograph of the painting’s verso, it turns out that the vertical orientation was perhaps rejected. The instructions given on the reverse to hang the painting vertically are given as “OBEN” and “HAUT,” which correspond linguistically to the German and French contexts where Moholy-Nagy showed his works until the mid-1930s. The arrow pointing in that direction was crossed out with double Xs. The arrows for the horizontal hanging are accompanied with the English word “TOP.”36 It uses the language of Moholy-Nagy’s exile in London and of his adopted home of Chicago, where he died in 1946 just a month after becoming an American citizen. Moholy-Nagy decided upon this orientation certainly by 1936, when Z VII was shown at the London Gallery, hung horizontally as on the cover of Telehor.37 This reorientation is significant, for it captures Moholy-Nagy’s growing reservations about the actual potential of the Light Prop by the mid-1930s, reservations he expressed in his own introductory text to Telehor. The Light Prop was supposed to integrate industry, technology, and art together for the progressive transformation of vision, but it also became an emblem for the impossibility of that project. For Moholy-Nagy, it represented something of an impasse, “nothing more than a very modest beginning, an almost negligible step forward.”38 The rotation of the canvas might be seen, then, as an attempt to conceal that painting’s relationship to the problematic legacy of the Light Prop. However, in another sense, Moholy-Nagy might have discovered another way to express the fusion of art and technology in the service of “new vision.” To publish the painting on the cover of Telehor horizontally and in full color, he marshals yet another technology to redeem his vision. In the remaining pages, it will emerge that color photography comes to serve as a means to recuperate Moholy-Nagy’s projects of the past.39 The year Telehor is published, Moholy-Nagy writes in a letter to his friend and fellow painter Paul Citroën: i’ve incidentally recently been on a very good painting streak. i’ve been painting for a few months now with real courage and excitement. mainly i’ve been working out paintings on rhodoid, a kind of celluloid … it’s been great fun … i think one more step and i’ve figured out a new way to put color film on a new path.40
157
Joyce Tsai
The stakes of being on a good painting streak have to do with MoholyNagy’s desire to work out the possibilities of new materials. But in the same paragraph, while still talking about painting, Moholy-Nagy ends by expressing his hope that he is close to finding a “new path” for color film, that is, color photography. This is a medium that Moholy-Nagy was deeply invested in already in the mid-1930s, having experimented beginning in 1934 with the Dufaycolor process and later with Vivex while in London.41 Z VII, in its horizontal orientation, reproduced in full color on the cover of Telehor, is not merely an illustration. In a sense, the particular limitations of color reproduction have come to save the painting, to smooth out the obvious areas of damage and to reconfigure the odd spatial relationships within the picture. The thick opaque whites, in part because the print is tinged with yellow throughout, take on an airier quality on the cover. That warm tone in the reproduction helps shift the spatial relations within the picture, opening them up. The yellow plane, jutting out towards the lower right, which once registered like an orphaned extension, reads like a luminous plane of pure, golden light emitting forth from the complex. By rotating the painting and by exploiting a burgeoning technology and embracing its limitations, Moholy-Nagy found a way to mobilize the new medium of color reproduction and color photography to articulate a vision that could not have existed otherwise. It is through this process of experimentation that Moholy-Nagy begins to paint towards color photography. There is something overdetermined about Z VII’s place on the cover of Telehor, a volume which seeks to provide a summary of an artistic project. Because of Z VII’s repair, its repainting, and its transfiguration through color photography, it offers the accrued history of Moholy-Nagy’s hopes and disappointments. Sedimented on the surface of this painting are the traces of a struggle to render visible the possibilities and limitations of his gesamtproblematik. The Light Prop would never be put into production but still continued to serve Moholy-Nagy as a constant touchstone for his subsequent work. The gash in Z VII led to repairs that transformed it not only into a painting of the 1930s, but also a painting that guides MoholyNagy’s forays into color photography. And the limitations of color reproductive technologies cast Z VII in yet another light, lending it a kind of luminous dynamism unavailable to the painting’s patchwork surface.42
Acknowledgments This project began in 2005 when Jeffrey Weiss and Leah Dickerman encouraged me to work on Z VII at the National Gallery of Art. I am indebted to Jay Krueger, whose patient, constant guidance in reading material condition helped to shape my interpretation throughout. I had the opportunity to present this material at the Zimmerli Museum, College of William and Mary,
158
Excavating Surface
and Safra Colloquy (CASVA) thanks to the invitations of Oliver A. I. Botar and Andres Zervigon, Charles Palermo, and Nancy Troy respectively. This essay has benefited from the thoughtful suggestions and comments of my advisors Michael Fried and Kathryn Tuma, as well as Annie Bourneuf, Gülru Çakmak, Marc Gotlieb, Ashley E. Jones, Kate Markoski, Bibiana Obler, Lynette Roth, and Matthew Witkovsky.
Notes 1 The enamel paintings, EM1, EM2, and EM3, are listed in the catalog of the Sturm exhibition from 1924. Galerie der Sturm, Moholy-Nagy, Hugo Scheiber, Gewebe aus Alt-Peru, SturmGesamtschau (Berlin: Der Sturm, 1924). Exhibition installation photograph of the Sturm exhibition can be found in Krisztina Passuth, Moholy-Nagy (London: Thames and Hudson, 1985), plate 236. 2 Adolf Behne, “Snob und Anti-Snob,” Die Weltbühne 20 (1924): 235–6. Behne’s suggestion that Moholy-Nagy’s reduced aesthetic vocabulary lends itself particularly well to the production of art by industrial means, perhaps even mediated by telephonic transmission, provokes a number of ironic remarks. The editors at Das Kunstblatt ridiculed the seeming enthusiasm with which Moholy-Nagy, Behne, and the Bauhaus, which at that moment was located in Weimar, embraced the unity of art and technology. The editors portray them as such vitriolic enemies of any work of art produced by hand that they would dismiss even the lyric of Homer and Goethe in favor of poetry composed on the typewriter. “Bemerkungen,” Das Kunstblatt 7, no. 3 (1924): 96. The fantasy of artistic production by telephonic correspondence is parodized in Hans Arp and El Lissitzky’s The Isms of Art, where they write, “Now the production of works of art is judiciously so facilitated and simplified that nobody can do better than order his works by telephone from his bed, by a common painter.” El Lissitzky and Hans Arp, Die Kunstismen; Les Ismes de l’Art; The Isms of Art (Munich and Leipzig: Eugen Rentsch Verlag, 1925), ix–x. 3 László Moholy-Nagy, “Abstract of an Artist,” in The New Vision, 1928 and Abstract of an Artist, trans. Daphne Hoffmann, 4th rev. edn (New York: Wittenborn, Schultz, 1947), 79. “Abstract of an Artist” was written in 1944 in English. This notion that Moholy-Nagy made the enamels by phone has had a powerful hold on the imagination. Despite the fact that during his lifetime these works were only referred to by their title EM1, EM2, EM3 as Enamel Paintings or as Enamel Pictures, they are now more commonly known as Telephone Pictures. 4 Oskar Schlemmer to Otto Meyer, December 1925, in Oskar Schlemmer, Diaries and Correspondences, ed. Tut Schlemmer, trans. Krishna Winston (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1972), 183–4. Conversation with László Moholy-Nagy as recounted by Ise Gropius, Diary, 6 November 1925, 93, Bauhaus Archiv, Berlin. 5 László Moholy-Nagy, Malerei, Photographie, Film (Munich: Albert Langen, 1925), 5, 37. 6 Ibid., 13. 7 Moholy-Nagy invokes this development in a number of his publications, beginning already in the 1925 edition of Malerei, Photographie, Film, where he discusses the potential that new technologies offer in shifting the exploration of color effects to the manipulation of pure color itself. Further underscoring the sense of a progressive development towards the manipulation of pure light as a medium is the title of the first section of the book: “Von der Pigmentmalerei bis zum reflektorischen geworfenen Lichtspiel.” Malerei, Photographie, Film, 6–7. However, despite how polemical his claims might appear, he never explicitly argues in his writings that painting understood generally (Malerei as opposed to Tafelbild) would be rendered wholly obsolete. This is an aspect of his thinking that is often suppressed in the
159
Joyce Tsai
reception of Moholy-Nagy’s work. One striking example of this is in Christopher Phillips’s indispensable anthology of key avant-garde sources in the history of photography. Introducing a lively debate on the relationship between painting and photography involving Erno˝ [Ernst] Kállai in the pages of the journal i.10, for which Moholy-Nagy served as photography and film editor, Phillips writes, “[Moholy-Nagy] accuses Kallai of a veiled attempt to rescue the craft of painting, which Moholy regards as obsolete in a machine age. Moholy insists that facture remains an important part of the photographic image, too—no longer in the form of ‘coarse-grained pigment,’ but as an increasingly sophisticated manipulation of light and shade, a true ‘facture of light.’” Christopher Phillips, ed., Photography in the Modern Era: European Documents and Critical Writings, 1913–1940 (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1989), 94. Moholy-Nagy’s claims about painting in the text Phillips examines are far more nuanced in the German original. There, Moholy-Nagy critiques Kállai for wanting to preserve “representational painting” (darstellerischen Malerei). The text is not, as Phillips suggests, an attack on the practice of painting as such. Moholy-Nagy, “Diskussion über Ernst Kallai’s Artikel ‘Malerei und Fotografie,’ ” i.10 1, no. 6 (1927): 233–4. The translation of Moholy-Nagy’s text published in Phillips’s anthology also excises an entire paragraph on painting without providing any indication of this in the text. “Response by László MoholyNagy,” trans. Harvey L. Mendelsohn, in Photography in the Modern Era, 102. 8 László Moholy-Nagy, Z VII (1926), gift of Richard Zeisler, National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. The relevant documents pertaining to condition and treatment are as follows: Rose Fried Gallery, invoice, 29 April 1960; Julius Lowy Frame and Restoring Company, Inc., invoice, 19 April 1990; object file for László Moholy-Nagy, Z VII (1926), Department of Modern and Contemporary Art, National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC (hereafter “object file for Z VII”). 9 Photograph of the reverse of Z VII, object file for Z VII. 10 Two authors who have addressed the seeming incommensurability of Moholy-Nagy’s commitment to painting and photography are Andreas Haus and Eleanor M. Hight. Hight describes Moholy-Nagy’s return to painting as follows: “Curiously, one of the many irreconcilable inconsistencies in Moholy’s work involves his own identity as an artist. From the time he left Berlin he seems to have preferred painting over photography. Even though his writings on painting were few, we can sense an underlying desire on his part to be seen first and foremost as a serious painter … [E]ven his descriptions of photography and film as ‘painting with light’ demonstrate his inability to reconcile his theory, in which film media dominate, with his desire to be known as a painter.” Eleanor M. Hight, Picturing Modernism: Moholy-Nagy and Photography in Weimar Germany (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1995), 212–13. Writing in 1978, at a moment when there was a resurgence of interest in Moholy-Nagy’s photography, Andreas Haus offers an account that seeks to acknowledge the fact that the artist considered himself a painter. Nonetheless, he notes “Moholy the painter was never considered as particularly important in the historical development of painting. In exhibitions and museums his works rarely radiate the brilliance and intensity of a Lissitzky, Mondrian or Malevich.” Andreas Haus, Moholy Nagy: Photographs and Photograms, trans. Frederic Samson (New York: Pantheon Books, 1980), 8. This perception resonates with the reception of Moholy-Nagy’s work seen in exhibition reviews from his own contemporaries as well as those written in recent decades. See Willi Wolfradt, “Berliner Austellungen,” Der Cicerone, 16 no. 4 (1924): 191–2; “Wertheim Gallery,” The Times, 2 January 1937: section 2, 8; Jerrold Lanes, “Exhibition at Guggenheim Museum,” Artforum 8 (1970): 81; Roberta Smith, “On the Paths of Two Giants, Voyagers in Modernism,” New York Times, 3 November 2006: section E.2, 30. 11 László Moholy-Nagy to Sibyl Moholy-Nagy, 9 October 1934, reel 951, page 148, Archives of American Art, Washington, DC. Orthography Moholy-Nagy’s, translations by author unless otherwise noted. Here is the quote in full: “meine bilder – die sah ich jetzt in utrecht – sind noch gar nicht austellungsreif. sie können nur unter der behutsamsten privatpflege
160
Excavating Surface
existieren und nur etwas von ihren werten abgeben. eine ganze ausstellung ist zu viel. es gibt noch kaum leute, die sie in ihrer wirklichkeit fassen können und weil man nicht von der mühe des entstehens und nichts von der gesamtproblematik dieser bilder überhaupt weiss, erscheinen sie dem austellungsbetrachter wahrscheinlich eintönig, einander zu ähnlich. und ich wünschte, dass der zuschauer selbst mit jedem auch bei mir und für mich gewachsenen bild weiter wachse, heute ist er weit noch [?]. trotzdem will ich die nächste zeit nicht verstreichen lassen, ich stelle aus, wo man mir gelegenheit dazu bietet. ich muss es tun, weil die leute überhaupt nicht wissen, dass ich maler bin. so erhalte mir den kunsthändler in utrecht, dass auf grund meiner fotogramms von der dortigen zeitung ein referent für fotografie zur ausstellung geschickt würde, der mit den bildern überhaupt nichts anzufangen wüsste.” 12 Z VII was included at an exhibition at Mount Holyoke College in 1971; an exhibition in 1979 at the Annely Juda Fine Art Gallery in London; and an exhibition of works from the permanent collection in 1985 at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. See Joyce C. Tsai, unpublished report, 29 June 2005, object file for Z VII. 13 László Moholy-Nagy, A XX (1924), Centre Georges Pompidou, Paris. 14 Pre-treatment photograph of Z VII under UV light (August 2007), National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. 15 Sibyl Moholy-Nagy to Lucia Moholy, 15 November 1947. Bauhaus Archiv, Berlin. 16 Moholy-Nagy alerts Franz Roh in April 1934 to a Czech invitation to produce a special issue featuring his work. Moholy-Nagy to Franz Roh, 23 April 1934. Special Collections, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles. 17 His wife begins work editing his open letter to Kalivoda in October 1934. Sibyl Moholy-Nagy to László Moholy-Nagy, 17 October 1934, reel 951, pp. 155–6, Archives of American Art, Washington, DC. 18 Fr. Kalivoda, “Postscript,” trans. F. D. Klingender, Telehor 1, no. 1–2 (1936): 45. 19 Ibid., 46. 20 To explain the purpose and the possible application of his Light Prop, Moholy published an illustrated essay in the journal of the Werkbund. László Moholy-Nagy, “Lichtrequisit einer elektrischen Bühne,” Die Form: Zeitschrift für gestaltende Arbeit 5, no. 11/12 (1930): 297–9. 21 Moholy’s long-standing commitment to such a project is evident in his early writings, expressed most explicitly in the following: László Moholy-Nagy, “Az új tartalom és az új forma problémájáról,” Akasztott Ember no. 3–4 (1922): 3, translation from Passuth, MoholyNagy, 286–8. 22 L. Moholy-Nagy, “Dear Kalivoda,” trans. F. D. Klingender, Telehor 1 no. 1–2 (1936): 30. 23 Ibid. 24 Kalivoda, “Postscript,” 46. 25 Moholy-Nagy, “Dear Kalivoda,” 30. 26 Ibid., 31. 27 The original Light Prop is in the collection of the Busch-Reisinger Museum, which has had a number of persistent problems with the work’s condition. For an account of its inherent design flaws, see memo from Arthur Beal to Miss Mongan, cc: Prof. Kuhn, Harry Berg, Larry Doherty, 20 May 1969, object file for László Moholy-Nagy. Light Prop for an Electric Stage (Light-Space Modulator), Busch-Reisinger Museum, Cambridge, MA. 28 See correspondences on the “Raum der Gegenwart” in the Alexander Dorner Papers, Sprengel Museum, Hannover. 29 Moholy-Nagy, “Dear Kalivoda,” 31. 30 Of the Light Prop, Moholy’s second wife writes, “I would come to consider the light-display machine the problem child of my household because it refused to pass custom authorities in the normal way. When it finally came to rest in Chicago it had been declared a mixing
161
Joyce Tsai
machine, a fountain, a display rack for various metal alloys and a robot, and it had caused me more trouble than a dozen children.” Sibyl Moholy-Nagy, Experiment in Totality, 1st edn (New York: Harper, 1950), 67. 31 The Light Prop was reproduced in Telehor 1 no. 1–2 (1936): 80–3. 32 László Moholy-Nagy to Franz Roh, 23 March 1934. Franz Roh Papers, Getty Special Collections, Getty Research Center, Los Angeles. 33 László Moholy-Nagy, Construction AL6 (1933–1934), Instituto Valenciano de Arte Moderno (IVAM), Generalitat Valenciana, Valencia. 34 Kalivoda, “Postscript,” 46. 35 Ibid. 36 Photograph of the reverse of Z VII, object file for Z VII. Thanks to Miles Chappell and Harry Cooper who encouraged me to attend to the peculiarities of the inscriptions on the reverse of this painting. 37 Exhibition photograph of Z VII at the London Gallery in 1936 in Sibyl Moholy-Nagy, Experiments in Totality, 2nd edn (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1969), 135. 38 Moholy-Nagy, “Dear Kalivoda,” 31. 39 Thanks to Graham Bader for helping me articulate the significance of the rotation of the picture. 40 László Moholy-Nagy to Paul Citroën, 16 June 1936, Bauhaus Archiv, Berlin. Here is the complete quote in the original, orthography Moholy-Nagy’s:“ich bin übrigens in einer sehr güten malsträhne. ich male seit einigen monaten richtig mit mut und begeisterung. hauptsächlich [?] bilder auf rhodoid (eine art zelluloid) und ich vertoniere sie um schatten und farbeneffekte zu bekommen. es macht einen ungeheuren spass, und das [?] entwickelt zu einem netten früher unbekannten ausdruck. ich würde dir mal alles gerne erklaeren, ich glaube 1 schritt weiter und ich habe den farben film auf neuen wegen.” 41 Jeannine Fiedler, “Moholy-Nagy’s Color Camera Works, a Pioneer of Color Photography,” in Color in Transparency: Photographic Experiments in Color, 1934–1946, ed. Jeannine Fiedler and Hattula Moholy-Nagy (Göttingen: Steidl, 2006), 20. 42 Much of the argument of this essay has relied on an interpretation of color in this painting and attends to how its color reproduction fundamentally transforms its internal dynamics. The illustrations for this article are published in black-and-white, which poses unavoidable problems for the interpretation put forward. However, it also illustrates the profound ways in which reproductive technologies irrevocably alter how we perceive a composition. Publishing the color images of this painting—as painting and as 1936 color reproduction—in blackand-white exaggerates the depth of the composition because the resulting images translate subtle shifts in tonality and hue into light–dark relationships. In an imperfectly analogous manner, the limitations of color reproduction transform the perception of the painting’s composition because of the specific ways in which the colors are rendered on the cover of Telehor. This study has attempted to show that it is in his willingness to explore this gap or, rather, the interstices among various media that Moholy-Nagy makes his most profound contributions.
162
Chapter 8
Picturing Sculpture Object, Image and Archive Paul Paret
One of the noticeable tics in Bauhaus scholarship has been the obsessive categorization of the school’s institutional history according to changes in its leadership, teaching staff, and program. There are competing accounts of the three stages, or the five stages, or sometimes the eight stages of Bauhaus development, each with detailed argumentation and supporting evidence.1 The cue for this art historical fetish for organizing, writing and rewriting the Bauhaus might be traced to the school itself, which from the outset trumpeted its own organizational and pedagogical structure, and then almost immediately proceeded to alter it in a continuous series of programmatic shifts and key personnel changes. A provocative model for thinking about the progression of the Bauhaus, its workshops and the individual objects produced can be found, surprisingly, at the historical end of modernism in the serial practices of conceptual art, such as Sol LeWitt’s 1974 Variations on Incomplete Open Cubes (Figure 8.1). A work in which “the idea becomes a machine that makes the art,” Incomplete Open Cubes elaborates the possible variations of a single object, an incomplete cube.2 The parameters LeWitt set for the project included the requirement that each variant have at least one strut on each axis (height, length, width), so that the simplest variants have three parts and then become increasingly complex as additional struts are added up to the final, single, eleven-part variation. Another parameter called on the variations to be non-identical, which meant LeWitt could not simply rotate a given incomplete cube so that it appears different and then designate it as a new variant. Determining which cubes were truly 163
Paul Paret
non-identical turned out to be particularly tricky. Oscillating between the logical simplicity of its premise and the obsessive, even irrational, complexity of its realization, Variations on Incomplete Open Cubes is a project that locates meaning not only in the elaborate process of unfolding the ultimate number of nonidentical variations of an incomplete open cube (the answer turns out to be 122), but also, unexpectedly, in the visually dazzling possibilities of their representation: as schematic drawings, miniature models, large-scale objects, photographs, an artist’s book, in isolation, in subgroups, collectively and so on.3 LeWitt’s combination of logical analysis and obsessive reworking provides an illuminating model for considering the Bauhaus and its histories. Could we, as part of an absurdist modernist game, discern and map out all the non-identical variations of Bauhaus directors, workshops and faculty like the three required axial struts of Incomplete Open Cubes? Like LeWitt’s basic cube, the Bauhaus is something seemingly familiar and well understood, which when questioned and interrogated may unravel and multiply into an unknown number of new or little-considered possibilities.
164
8.1 Sol LeWitt, Incomplete Open Cubes, 1974, painted wood structure, gelatin silver prints, and drawings on paper, 12 × 120 × 216 in
Picturing Sculpture
If nothing else, LeWitt’s project points to the complexities that can be generated by a simple object. This essay examines such a single, seemingly straightforward object from the history of the Bauhaus: an anonymous photograph of the stone sculpture workshop first published in the catalogue of the 1923 Bauhaus exhibition in Weimar (Figure 8.2).4 Familiar to scholars and students of the Bauhaus, yet little examined, this photograph does not present a palimpsest of accrued narratives over time, or twists and turns of historical reception. Rather, this photograph has been consistently understood as an illustration of the stone sculpture workshop and document of the objects
8.2 Bauhaus stone sculpture workshop, Weimar, 1923
pictured in it. Beginning with the catalogue of the landmark Bauhaus exhib ition at the Museum of Modern Art, New York, in 1938, the photograph of the stone sculpture workshop has been reproduced as stock image with little or no comment in dozens, if not hundreds, of Bauhaus books and catalogues as a visual supplement and archival witness testifying to the workshop’s existence.5 To the extent that this photograph has been interpreted at all, it has been for its documentary information about the specific sculptures depicted, most of which no longer survive.6 What follows here instead is
165
Paul Paret
an exploration of the 1923 workshop photograph for its discursive as well as documentary operations. Strikingly attuned to the discourses of modernism, this seemingly marginal photograph reframes the program and problems of Bauhaus sculpture and suggests new interpretations of some of the individual objects it presents. Reconsidered as a modernist object with a complex and deliberate visual logic, this archival image generates multiple meanings and narratives, not just of the Bauhaus, its objects and histories, but of modernist visuality, media specificity and the vexing status of sculpture in modernity.
The 1923 Workshop Photograph and the Problem of Sculpture The photograph of the stone sculpture workshop has its origins in the book produced for the 1923 Bauhaus exhibition in Weimar. Designed by László Moholy-Nagy, who had come to the Bauhaus earlier that year, Staatliches Bauhaus Weimar 1919–1923 includes brief sections for each of the workshops, which begin with a photograph of the workshop space itself, followed by images of individual objects by students and apprentices.7 As is the case with the other workshop images included in the catalogue, the photographer of the stone sculpture workshop remains unknown. Yet its selection for inclusion—likely the decision of Moholy-Nagy as the book’s designer and Schlemmer as the head of the workshop—makes it more than an arbitrary snapshot. Presented as an informal cross section of the stone sculpture workshop and its activities, the photograph’s array of figurative and abstract objects in plaster and stone cleverly stages the workshop’s internal debates and the troubled status of sculpture at the Bauhaus.8 Beginning with the two objects that frame the image—Kurt Schwerdtfeger’s Architectural Sculpture on the left and Oskar Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure (Free Sculpture G) on the right—the photograph maps the competing tendencies within the workshop between abstraction and figuration, as well as between architectural and free-standing sculpture. These sculptures mark a basic difference between the teaching of Johannes Itten, who headed the stone sculpture workshop from 1920 to 1922 and emphasized contrasts of form and texture, and Schlemmer’s lifelong commitment to the human figure.9 Moreover, these two framing sculptures delineate intersecting figurative and abstract axes across the image. The corner of Schwerdtfeger’s Architectural Sculpture points diagonally toward the abstract objects clustered in the back right of the image, while the shoulder of Schlemmer’s sculpture draws our eye across the room toward his 166
Picturing Sculpture
tall figurative relief in the back left. Near the center of the room, marking the intersection of these diagonals, Otto Werner’s four-sided (and identically titled) Architectural Sculpture presents itself alternately as figurative and abstract, an attempted synthesis of these competing visual modes. Through its title Werner’s sculpture also declares the founding ambition for the Bauhaus to reunify the arts and crafts under architecture. Sculpture was not to exist independently as autonomous art, something Walter Gropius had disparaged in the Bauhaus manifesto as “salon art” that had lost its “architectonic spirit.”10 Rather, like other Bauhaus workshops, the stone sculpture workshop had been established with the idea that it would contribute to larger architectural projects. The hoped-for commissions, however, did not materialize. As Schlemmer reported during a faculty meeting in December 1922, the sculpture workshops were held back by a “lack of applied commissions”; Gropius also complained about the stone and wood sculpture workshops, noting in October 1923 that “up to now little has been achieved there.”11 The largest commission for the stone sculpture workshop was the 1922 Monument to the March Dead, a memorial for Weimar residents killed during the 1920 Kapp Putsch, designed by Gropius and carried out by the master craftsman Josef Hartwig and students in the stone sculpture workshop.12 Much of the workshop’s activity, however, merely supported other areas of the Bauhaus, such as producing plaster models for the ceramics and theater workshops—including the large oblong object behind the table in the back room of the workshop photograph, part of a stage prop for Lothar Schreyer’s 1923 Moon Play—as well as plaster architectural models for Gropius’ private commissions.13 The two works in the photograph titled Architectural Sculpture by Schwerdtfeger and Werner reflect the frustrated ambition of architectural collaboration at the early Bauhaus. Not related to any commission, both sculptures were made for the journeyman’s exam required of each Bauhaus student following a three-year apprenticeship in one of the workshops. The act of naming alone, however, secures neither an “architectural” function nor meaning for these sculptures, which remain independent modernist objects, demonstration pieces intended for no particular site or architectural project. In spite of their titles and the rhetoric of the Bauhaus program, these objects are disconnected from any rooted function and exemplify the homeless condition of autonomous modern sculpture, the “salon art” that Gropius had hoped the Bauhaus would overcome.14 If these objects cannot easily live up to the claims and aspirations of their titles, the workshop space itself might be reimagined as their aesthetic fulfillment. It becomes one of the tasks of the photograph to forge the disparate objects of the stone sculpture workshop into a more
167
Paul Paret
coherent program of Bauhaus modernism. It does so not by privileging the individual objects depicted, but paradoxically by obscuring and effacing them, undermining their autonomy and reframing them within a fantasy of architectural totality. Almost all of the sculptures in the photograph are partly obstructed by other objects or cropped by the edges of the image. This fragmented view of the objects conveys a somewhat clichéd sense of a busy, crowded, workshop space. The center of the image is left largely open and the sculptures distributed to the sides. With the objects partially eclipsed and pushed to the periphery, the various sculptural facets and planes do not remain distinct in the photograph, but rather merge and blend with the walls and windows of the architectural space they fill. The tight sequencing of overlapping sculptures and reliefs, coming in from both the left and right edges of the image, defines and articulates the space of the workshop to such an extent that the sculptures seem to constitute the architecture rather than merely inhabiting it. Even those few objects that are not obscured, most notably Werner’s Architectural Sculpture in the center right of the image, have an adjacency to other objects that works against their status as freestanding autonomous objects. In this way, the workshop photograph provides a counter- narrative to the autonomous modernism embodied in so many of the actual sculptures. Rather than privileging individual objects, the photograph fragments the sculptures within a dense network of overlapping forms and facets, and recasts them in an approximation of the collaborative architectural totality that the workshop desired, but had yet to realize.
Architectural Reliefs and the 1923 Exhibition When the workshop photograph was taken, in the spring or early summer of 1923, Schlemmer was intensely engaged in questions of architectural sculpture. Although Gropius had for some time been reorienting the Bauhaus toward the design of marketable objects and the imperatives of industrial production—a program he encapsulated during the 1923 exhibition with the pronouncement “art and technology: a new unity”— Schlemmer continued to embrace, more completely and for longer than any of his Bauhaus colleagues, the ideal of synthesizing painting, sculpture and architecture. The 1923 exhibition provided a major opportunity for Schlemmer to demonstrate the possibilities of architectural reliefs and give purpose to the sculpture workshops. The previous fall he had remarked with a cautious optimism that “the trouble [for the stone and wood sculpture 168
Picturing Sculpture
workshops] is that big commissions are lacking. Perhaps the exhibition will offer them—but only perhaps!”15 Given the task of redesigning the entrances and hallways of the Bauhaus buildings for the exhibition, Schlemmer wrote of the need “to raise painting and sculpture to the functions that they had in the great ages: part of architecture as space and wall-creation.”16 Echoing Schlemmer, Gropius clarified the intentions of the reliefs for the vestibule of the Art School building by explaining that “the wall panels will be sculpturally organized [plastisch gestaltet] and specifically so that they do not represent some kind of Renaissance-like inserted panels, but rather take on a functional significance for the entire space.”17 The results of these plans were Schlemmer’s elaborate series of figurative reliefs and murals in the stairwell and hallways of the workshop building, now known as the Van de Velde building, and Joost Schmidt’s abstract geometric relief panels in the vestibule of the main Bauhaus building, the Art School building. Schlemmer’s and Schmidt’s reliefs were met with decidedly mixed reviews. Rejected as applied decoration by such important critics as Adolf Behne, an early supporter of the Bauhaus, who, like Gropius, came to advocate a more rigorously functionalist design, these works failed to engender continued interest in architectural sculpture at the Bauhaus.18 Schlemmer too, despite the enormous energy he had put into his reliefs and murals, referred privately to the “relative disappointment” of this work.19 Indeed, the reliefs by Schlemmer and Schmidt were the last attempt by the sculpture workshop at architectural reliefs, which would have no place in the new Bauhaus building in Dessau. Evidence of these projects is visible in the workshop photograph, which continues to be a useful source of archival information, particularly because both sets of works were later destroyed.20 Schlemmer’s tall figurative relief in the back left of the photograph is the mold for one of his reliefs in the workshop building. The small relief just below it and to the right is likely a study for Schmidt’s reliefs in the vestibule of the Art School building. More than a record of these lost objects, however, the workshop photograph also speaks to the aesthetic and programmatic ambitions of Schlemmer’s and Schmidt’s architectural reliefs. Defining the space of the workshop through the dense patterning of overlapping sculptural forms and facets, the photograph in fact comes closer to Schlemmer’s rhetoric of sculpture being “part of architecture and wall creation” than do his reliefs. Similarly, the photograph’s creation of an architectural space transformed by sculpture echoes Gropius’ hope that Schmidt’s reliefs result in “not some kind of Renaissance-like inserted panels” (which, although abstract, is precisely what they were) “but rather take
169
Paul Paret
on a functional significance for the entire space.” If the reliefs themselves were a disappointment, it is again the workshop photograph that succeeds in representing the programmatic ambitions of architectural sculpture at the 1923 exhibition. So far this essay has addressed the 1923 workshop photograph largely in terms of the relationship of sculpture to architecture and the changing program of Bauhaus modernism. Yet, in addition to these struggles over the function of modernist sculpture, there are other crucial ways in which to understand this photograph. For one thing, the image’s radical cropping can suggest significant reinterpretations of the individual objects it depicts. Moreover, the photograph’s obstruction of sight lines and overlapping of objects call attention to the physical, three-dimensional character of sculpture and the aesthetic and conceptual stakes of its photographic mediation. It is to these questions that we will now turn.
Oskar Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure The photograph of the stone sculpture workshop can be considered almost as a group portrait, with the sculptures and objects acting as the mechanomorphic analogues of the absent masters and students. Presiding over this group is Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure (Figure 8.3).21 Often interpreted in terms of antique statuary and Schlemmer’s ideas on three-dimensional sculpture, Abstract Figure’s precise geometries and mechanical rigidity have made it nearly emblematic of rationalist modernism in the 1920s, a classicizing ideal of machine-age beauty.22 Yet the workshop photograph, certainly among the first commentaries on the sculpture, disrupts any sense of classical equipoise by cropping and slicing Schlemmer’s figure on three sides, and thereby suggests a very different way of thinking about this object. In part because of its enlarged foreground position, Abstract Figure is most radically and violently affected by the photograph’s cropping and fragmenting. Not only does the workshop photograph split Schlemmer’s figure down the middle, in the top right corner it also sections out a quadrant from the nested geometry of the figure’s head and helmet. The violation of the sculpture—sliced and bisected by the camera—calls attention to an aspect of the sculpture that has been overlooked: namely that Abstract Figure may be less a classically balanced figure of equipoise than a wounded body with prosthetic replacements, and a defensive armor protecting it from future damage. As suggested by the photograph, Abstract Figure reveals its almost schizophrenic pose in its awkward combination of severe machined and soft biomorphic forms. One shoulder extends powerfully from the 170
Picturing Sculpture
figure in a broad sweeping curve, while the other is abruptly cut off. Round, bulbous forms contrast with sharply edged, planar surfaces, and two metal poles serve as prosthetic limbs to connect the body to its oversized base, itself a combination of abrupt angles and sweeping curves. This combination presents a confusion of subject positions that mix signs of man with machine, authority with vulnerability, and solidity and wholeness with a damaged and surgically invaded body. In this sense Abstract Figure is emblematic of many of the contradictions of Bauhaus modernism. Both protected and devoured by the more rationalized machine aesthetic that would mark the Bauhaus in the coming years, Schlemmer’s sculpture enacts what Hal Foster has called “the double logic of the technological prosthesis that governed the machinic imaginary of high modernism: the machine as a castrative trauma and as a phallic shield against such trauma.”23 If Schlemmer’s figure is an icon of machine-age beauty, then it is one that has as much in common with depictions of mangled World War I veterans (such as Ernst Ludwig Kirchner’s Self-Portrait as a Soldier or George Grosz’s Republican Automatons) as it does with the utopian geometries of international constructivism.24 The radical cropping of the workshop photograph dislodges Schlemmer’s figure from its classical precedents and reframes it within a different modernist discourse. But it is not only the cropping that is relevant here. The workshop photograph further reinforces and elaborates the idea of Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure as damaged and wounded by pairing it with the rough-hewn verso of Kurt Schwerdtfeger’s marble Torso, which emerges just behind Schlemmer’s figure. The dark, jagged materiality of Schwerdtfeger’s figure resonates not only as a textural and tonal contrast with Schlemmer’s smooth white surfaces, but also now as guts and innards, turning Schwerdtfeger’s Torso into a grotesquely flayed doppelgänger of Schlemmer’s cleanly machined forms.
The Space of Modernism Like the photograph’s cropping of objects and obstruction of sight lines, this doubling, the figuring of recto and verso between Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure and Schwerdtfeger’s Torso, calls attention to the three-dimensional character of sculpture as a physical object and the potential problems of representing it from a single viewpoint. Beyond the workshop photograph, Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure appears a second time in the 1923 exhibition catalogue’s section on “independent paintings and sculptures,” where it is pictured both in wide profile from the side and in a narrow view looking 171
Paul Paret
straight up the severed arm.25 A slightly later photograph of Abstract Figure, one that Moholy-Nagy included in his 1929 book Von Material zu Architektur (translated in 1932 as The New Vision) incorporates these two views, plus a third more distant profile from the back (Figure 8.3). Rather than the nightmarish doppelgänger evoked by the raw verso of Schwerdtfeger’s Torso, these views of Abstract Figure are presented as a spatially choreographed montage that, echoing the tradition of the Three Graces, constructs a rationalized, composite knowledge of the complete figure. These two- and three-part views of Schlemmer’s sculpture highlight the object’s three-dimensionality and its changing profiles. Addressing this issue in a brief manuscript from January 1924, Schlemmer states: The essence of sculpture must of course be illustrated by means of three-dimensional sculpture, the purest form. … It cannot be grasped in any given moment; rather it reveals itself in a temporal succession of vantage points and views. Since a piece of sculpture does not yield a total impression from one angle, the spectator is obliged to move, and only by walking around and adding up his impressions does he eventually grasp the sculpture. Thus any piece of plastic art which does not offer the viewer a series of surprises as he walks around it, but merely repeats one segment … has no validity as sculpture.26
8.3 Three views of Oskar Schlemmer, Abstract Figure (Free Sculpture G), 1923. From László MoholyNagy, The New Vision (New York: Brewer, Warren and Putnam, 1932) 172
Picturing Sculpture
Schlemmer’s Abstract Figure is generally regarded as exemplifying these ideals based on its changing profiles and asymmetry, as well as the simple fact that it was completed only a half-year earlier.27 Yet it is hard to say that these separate views offer any real “series of surprises.” Each view of Abstract Figure, in fact, logically implies the other and a single view provides near-total knowledge of the overall form. (It takes the abrupt cropping of the workshop photograph to rupture this coherence.) Schlemmer’s text, hardly radical, is among the many responses by early-twentieth-century artists and critics to the widely influential “concept of relief” advanced by the sculptor Adolf von Hildebrand at the turn of the century.28 In his treatise The Problem of Form in the Fine Arts, first published in 1893, Hildebrand argued that sculpture, although three-dimensional, achieves its artistic value through the visual impression of form rather than through the physical or tactile status of the object itself. “Only when [a three-dimensional figure] works as a plane, although still cubic,” he insisted, “does it acquire artistic form, that is, only then does it mean something to the visual imagination.”29 While Schlemmer’s text advocates sculpture that produces a “series of surprises” as the viewer is “obliged to move” around the object, his Abstract Figure works differently. To a great extent it is consistent with Hildebrand’s dictum about successful sculpture, regardless of the number of different vantage points: There will always be one view that presents and unites the whole plastic nature of the figure as a coherent surface impression, analogous to painting or relief. It signifies the actual visual notion that underlies the sculptural representation and to which the other views are subordinate or seen as a necessary consequence of the main view.30 Within the photograph of the Bauhaus stone sculpture workshop, it is not Schlemmer’s figure but rather Werner’s Architectural Sculpture, with its four distinct carved sides, none of which logically or visually imply the other, which actually counters Hildebrand’s “concept of relief.” An extended discussion of Hildebrand is outside the scope of this essay, but it is worth noting that The Problem of Form belongs to the elaborate art historical discourse opposing classicism and the Baroque, and pictorial versus spatial conceptions of art.31 For Hildebrand the “concept of relief” was a way of establishing and ensuring a clear separation of the ordered aesthetic space of art from the real space of objects and things. At stake in such a distinction was not just the understanding of antiquity and the history of art, but a profound fear and distrust of the material and
173
Paul Paret
spectacular forms of contemporary popular culture, including photography as well as such phenomena as waxworks and panoramas.32 The separation of the aesthetic space of art from the real space of things is a core issue for modernist sculpture theory, and central to the complex relationship of sculpture and photography in the 1920s.33 It is noteworthy that unlike the communal space of the workshop photograph, the composite photograph of Abstract Figure in three views isolates the sculpture within a completely abstracted black space that removes the figure from any material surroundings and suspends it within an idealized space of modernist autonomy. This exemplifies one of the many ways that photography, through simple acts of lighting and cropping, could eliminate the external context and provide an abstracted visual field to explore forms and volumes freed from tectonic forces of mass, material and, by implication, architecture. An interest in dematerializing the concrete physicality of sculpture and attempting to overcome its non-transcendent materiality is present in a great deal of modernist sculpture in the 1920s and the photography that engages it ambitiously. The central chapter of MoholyNagy’s The New Vision, “Volume (sculpture),” for instance, describes the development of sculpture in terms of the “the path from material-volume to virtual volume and from tactual grasp to visual, relative grasp.”34 (Such ideas are not unrelated to Hildebrand’s relief theory.) In the Bauhaus sculpture workshop by the late 1920s, now under the direction of Schmidt, photography would come to play a central role in the workshop’s perceptual and kinetic experiments with form and volume. The photographic results of these experiments were used to represent the workshop in Bauhaus exhibitions such as the 1929–1930 Bauhaus Wanderschau. An installation photograph of the exhibition shows objects from other workshops displayed on walls and in vitrines, while a long panel labelled “sculpture department” (plastische Abteilung) presents a series of photographic experiments with the creation and perception of volume (Figure 8.4). Not illustrations or stand-ins for an absent object, these photographs are the sculptural objects. The closely allied workings of sculpture and photography also certainly involve the reproducibility of their processes. In the 1923 workshop photograph the reproductive processes of casting and mold-making are evident in Schlemmer’s tall relief in the back left, which is the mold for one of the reliefs he would create in the workshop building. The workshop photograph itself is known almost exclusively as a rephotographed image taken from its initial publication in the 1923 exhibition catalogue.35 Indeed it is in large part due to this logic of the copy that photography and sculpture
174
Picturing Sculpture
8.4 Installation photograph (detail) from the BauhausWanderschau in the Kunstgewerbemuseum, Zurich, 1930
have such a densely intertwined and still largely unwritten history within modernist art.36 A final point about the 1923 workshop photograph is its plunging perspectival composition, which casts the sculptures to the sides and punctures straight through the two rooms of the workshop into the outdoor space beyond. This pictorial structure can be compared with a very different image from the sculpture workshop published in the journal Bauhaus in the fall of 1928 (Figure 8.5). Identified as having been made in the sculpture workshop (renamed die plastische Werkstatt in 1925), this is not a studio view, but rather a mock-urban landscape filled with illuminated signs, mechanical devices, advertising kiosks and window displays. These objects bear very little relation to the conventional materials, genres, and modes depicted in the 1923 photograph. In place of the conventional materials of plaster and stone are now photography and photomontage; the genres of statuary and relief have been replaced by illuminated advertisements and kinetic devices; and instead of the interior space of the 1923 workshop, this image addresses, as the caption states, the urban spectacle of “the square, the street, the shop-window as advertising theater.” 175
Paul Paret
The two images mark very different moments of the Bauhaus in terms of the conception of modernity and the practice of sculpture. Yet, as radically different as the two images may be, they share a strikingly similar pictorial structure: a tightly framed perspectival construction that organizes the seemingly casually arranged objects into the same rational, geometric space of Bauhaus modernism. This is true to such a degree that the two images could be overlaid almost seamlessly onto one another. The individual sculptures, objects and advertisements become interchangeable elements that fill identical compositional roles regardless of which picture they inhabit. While the materials, practices and ambitions of the Bauhaus sculpture program have changed dramatically in the five years between the two images, their pictorial order or scopic regime has remained largely unchanged. The comparison finally may remind us how carefully staged the 1923 workshop photograph is and that the many programmatic changes at the Bauhaus involved continuity as often as they did transformation. All of these different readings of the 1923 photograph, and presumably others as well, derive from playing the photograph (its information, rhetoric, medium) against the larger idea of the Bauhaus and modernism (their histories, practices and legacies). This image, perhaps like many others, has been lingering on the periphery, continually reproduced in 176
8.5 Heinz Loew and Franz Ehrlich, Studies for Electric Advertising (the square, the street, the shop-window as advertising theater), 1928. From Bauhaus 2, no. 4 (1928): 7
Picturing Sculpture
the Bauhaus literature with little thought given to its operations, logic or meaning. That seems also the case with the sculpture workshop in general, which existed throughout the history of the Bauhaus but never had a stable or even coherent position within the school’s program and pedagogy. The sculpture workshops remain just about the only area of the Bauhaus not to have been the subject of an extensive exhibition or historical reconstruction. This essay ultimately asks whether the anonymous photograph, a piece of Bauhaus ephemera, may be both marginalia and an autonomous object, a modernist machine with i