British Government and the Constitution Like the immensely successful previous edition of this highly respected work, t...
668 downloads
1197 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
British Government and the Constitution Like the immensely successful previous edition of this highly respected work, this seventh edition of British Government and the Constitution has been jointly prepared by Colin Turpin and Adam Tomkins. The book has been thoroughly updated. It takes fully into account constitutional developments under the Coalition Government and examines the most recent case law of the Supreme Court, the European Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights. While it includes extensive material and commentary on contemporary constitutional practice, Turpin and Tomkins is a book that covers the historical traditions and the continuity of the British constitution as well as the current tide of change. Designed principally for law students, the book includes substantial extracts from parliamentary and other political sources, as well as from legislation and case law. As such it is also ideal for politics and government students. With its fresh design the book provides a full yet accessible account of the British constitution at a fascinating moment in its ongoing development. â•… From Public Law’s review of the 6th edition: ‘Turpin and Tomkins provide a guide that is both immensely detailed and admirably clear [but they also] … aid the reader who is looking for more depth. In this, British Government and the Constitution has always been immensely useful … Turpin and Tomkins have produced a textbook … which is masterly in its treatment of a convoluted and evolutionary area of cross-disciplinary impact. It should be essential reading for students of constitutional law, and a valuable resource for those looking to think about the British constitution in more depth. Law and politics are never more intertwined than when investigating the constitution, and it is a measure of the mastery of both by the authors that the two fade in and out without undue confusion. Any reader looking for the British constitution, how it works and where it does not, will find no better introduction than British Government and the Constitution.’ Colin Turpin is a Fellow of Clare College and Reader Emeritus in Public Law at the University of Cambridge. Adam Tomkins is the John Millar Professor of Public Law at the University of Glasgow. Regular updates and occasional commentary on topics covered in this book are available via www.adamtomkins.net.
The Law in Context Series Editors: William Twining (University College London), Christopher McCrudden (Lincoln College, Oxford) and Bronwen Morgan (University of Bristol) Since 1970 the Law in Context series has been in the forefront of the movement to broaden the study of law. It has been a vehicle for the publication of innovative scholarly books that treat law and legal phenomena critically in their social, political and economic contexts from a variety of perspectives. The series particularly aims to publish scholarly legal writing that brings fresh perspectives to bear on new and existing areas of law taught in universities. A contextual approach involves treating legal subjects broadly, using materials from other social sciences, and from any other discipline that helps to explain the operation in practice of the subject under discussion. It is hoped that this orientation is at once more stimulating and more realistic than the bare exposition of legal rules. The series includes original books that have a different emphasis from traditional legal textbooks, while maintaining the same high standards of scholarship. They are written primarily for undergraduate and graduate students of law and of other disciplines, but most also appeal to a wider readership. In the past, most books in the series have focused on English law, but recent publications include books on European law, globalisation, transnational legal processes, and comparative law. Books in the Series Anderson, Schum & Twining: Analysis of Evidence Ashworth: Sentencing and Criminal Justice Barton & Douglas: Law and Parenthood Beecher-Monas: Evaluating Scientific Evidence: An Interdisciplinary Framework for Intellectual Due Process Bell: French Legal Cultures Bercusson: European Labour Law Birkinshaw: European Public Law Birkinshaw: Freedom of Information: The Law, the Practice and the Ideal Cane: Atiyah’s Accidents, Compensation and the Law Clarke & Kohler: Property Law: Commentary and Materials Collins: The Law of Contract Cowan: Housing Law Cranston: Legal Foundations of the Welfare State Dauvergne: Making People Illegal: What Globalisation Means for Immigration and Law Davies: Perspectives on Labour Law Dembour: Who Believes in Human Rights?: The European Convention in Question de Sousa Santos: Toward a New Legal Common Sense Diduck: Law’s Families Fortin: Children’s Rights and the Developing Law Glover-Thomas: Reconstructing Mental Health Law and Policy
Goldman: Globalisation and the Western Legal Tradition: Recurring Patterns of Law and Authority Gobert & Punch: Rethinking Corporate Crime Harlow & Rawlings: Law and Administration Harris: An Introduction to Law Harris, Campbell & Halson: Remedies in Contract and Tort Harvey: Seeking Asylum in the UK: Problems and Prospects Hervey & McHale: Health Law and the European Union Holder & Lee: Environmental Protection, Law and Policy Kostakopoulou: The Future Governance of Citizenship Lewis: Choice and the Legal Order: Rising above Politics Likosky: Law, Infrastructure and Human Rights Likosky: Transnational Legal Processes Maughan & Webb: Lawyering Skills and the Legal Process McGlynn: Families and the European Union: Law, Politics and Pluralism Moffat: Trusts Law: Text and Materials Monti: EC Competition Law Morgan & Yeung: An Introduction to Law and Regulation: Text and Materials Norrie: Crime, Reason and History O’Dair: Legal Ethics Oliver: Common Values and the Public–Private Divide Oliver & Drewry: The Law and Parliament Picciotto: International Business Taxation Reed: Internet Law: Text and Materials Richardson: Law, Process and Custody Roberts & Palmer: Dispute Processes: ADR and the Primary Forms of Decision-Making Rowbottom: Democracy Distorted: Wealth, Influence and Democratic Politics Scott & Black: Cranston’s Consumers and the Law Seneviratne: Ombudsmen: Public Services and Administrative Justice Stapleton: Product Liability Stewart: Gender, Law and Justice in a Global Market Tamanaha: Law as a Means to an End: Threat to the Rule of Law Turpin & Tomkins: British Government and the Constitution: Text and Materials Twining: General Jurisprudence: Understanding Law from a Global Perspective Twining: Globalisation and Legal Theory Twining: Human Rights, Southern Voices: Francis Deng, Abdullahi An-Na’im, Yash Ghai and Upendra Baxi Twining: Rethinking Evidence Twining & Miers: How to Do Things with Rules Ward: A Critical Introduction to European Law Ward: Law, Text, Terror Ward: Shakespeare and Legal Imagination Wells & Quick: Lacey, Wells and Quick: Reconstructing Criminal Law Zander: Cases and Materials on the English Legal System Zander: The Law-Making Process
British Government and the Constitution Text and Materials Seventh edition
C olin T urpin Fellow of Clare College and Reader Emeritus in Public Law University of Cambridge
A dam T omkins John Millar Professor of Public Law University of Glasgow
cambridge university press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Tokyo, Mexico City Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521185110 © Colin Turpin and Adam Tomkins 2011 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published by Weidenfeld & Nicholson 1985 Second edition published by Northwestern University Press 1991 Third edition published by Butterworths 1995 Fourth edition published by Butterworths 1999 Fifth edition published by Butterworths 2002 Sixth edition published by Cambridge University Press 2007 Seventh edition published by Cambridge University Press 2012 Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data ISBN 978-0-521-18511-0â•… paperback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
‘Government without a Constitution is power without a right’ Thomas Paine, Rights of Man (1792)
To Monique, our sons and grandchildren CCT To Lauren, Oliver, Leo, Phoebe and Jasper AT
Contents
Preface
xv
Acknowledgements
xix
Abbreviations
xxi
Table of Cases
xxiii
Table of Statutes
xliii
Table of European Treaties
lv
Part I Constitution, state and beyond 1
2
The British constitutional order
3
1 Nature of the British constitution
3
6
(a) Fundamentals, fluidity and safeguards
2 The constitution, the state and the nation
10
3 Constitutional law beyond the state
19
4 Constitutional reform
24
(a) An outline
24
(b) Evaluation
35
The ideas of the constitution
48
1 Democracy and the constitution
49
(a) Representative democracy
50
(b) Participatory democracy
53
(c) Democracy and accountability
55
2 Parliamentary sovereignty
58
(a) Diceyan orthodoxy
61
(b) Territorial extent of sovereignty: post-colonial independence
66
(c) Continuing sovereignty and the ‘new view’
71
(d) Sovereignty re-appraised: three contemporary challenges
79
(e) Conclusions
95
�x
Contents
3
4
3 The rule of law
96
(a) Government under law
98
(b) Equality before the law
112
(c) Discretion and the rule of law
117
(d) The rule of law: wider conceptions?
122
(e) The rule of law and parliamentary sovereignty
126
4 Separation of powers
126
(a) A political ideal or a legal principle?
130
(b) The courts in the constitution: judicial review and judicial law-making
136
(c) Judicial independence and the position of the Lord Chancellor
139
(d) The courts and Parliament
150
(e) Parliament and the executive
157
Constitutional sources
160
1 Legal rules
160
(a) Statute
161
(b) Subordinate legislation
168
(c) Common law
172
2 Conventions
182
(a) How do conventions arise?
189
(b) Doubtful conventions
192
(c) Conventions and laws
195
(d) Patriation of the Canadian constitution: a case study
199
Devolution and the structure of the UK
210
1 The United Kingdom as a Union State
210
(a) Federalism
211
(b) Devolution
216
2 Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
221
(a) Scotland
222
(b) Wales
245
(c) Northern Ireland
253
3 Local government
266
(a) Structure of local government
267
(b) Functions and powers
271
(c) Central–local government relations
275
�xi
Contents
5
The European dimensions
277
1 The European Convention on Human Rights
277
(a) The ECtHR and its impact on British constitutional law
279
(b) Domestic influence of the ECHR
283
2 The European Union
288
(a) Nature and development of the EU
288
(b) Institutional structure and law-making powers
297
(c) Principles of European law: supremacy, direct and indirect effect, state liability and fundamental rights 315
(d) EU law in the UK
335
Part II Government 6
7
Crown and government
365
1 The Crown
365
368
(a) Privileges and immunities of the Crown
2 Monarchy and the prerogative
377
(a) Appointment of the Prime Minister
379
(b) Dismissal of ministers
383
(c) Dissolution of Parliament
384
(d) Royal assent to legislation
385
3 Central government
386
(a) Ministers
386
(b) The Prime Minister
408
(c) The Cabinet
415
(d) Ministerial committees of the Cabinet
424
(e) Government departments
427
(f) Arm’s length bodies
431
(g) The civil service
439
The powers of government
450
1 Executive power
451
2 The government’s powers
455
(a) Parliamentary legislation
456
(b) Delegated legislation
468
(c) Prerogative legislation
483
(d) Executive powers
485
�xii
Contents
(e) Administrative rule-making (quasi-legislation)
496
(f) Guidance and codes of practice
503
(g) Voluntary agreement and self-regulation
508
Part III Accountability 8
9
10
Parties, groups and the people
517
1 The people in the constitution
517
2 Elections
519
(a) Review of constituency boundaries
521
(b) Fairness of the contest
523
(c) The electoral system
533
3 The people and government
543
544
(a) Referendums
4 Political parties and pressure groups
548
5 Open government
556
559
(a) Freedom of information
Parliament and the responsibility of government
566
1 Introduction: responsible government
566
2 Individual ministerial responsibility
573
(a) A convention of resignation?
576
(b) Responsibility of civil servants
586
3 The power of Parliament
591
(a) Opposition
594
(b) Backbenchers
602
(c) The House
607
4 Control and scrutiny
608
(a) Policy and administration
610
(b) Legislation
636
(c) Finance
644
5 The House of Lords
649
656
(a) Reform
The courts: judicial review and liability
661
1 Nature and foundations of judicial review
661
2 Grounds of review
668
�xiii
Contents
(a) Illegality
669
(b) Irrationality
677
(c) Proportionality
685
(d) Procedural impropriety and unfairness
695
3 Scope and limits of judicial review
710
(a) Scope of judicial review
710
(b) Standing
711
(c) Ouster clauses
714
(d) Judicial review of prerogative powers
716
4 Conclusion: the advance of judicial review
720
5 Liability of the Crown
723
(a) Contractual liability
725
(b) Tortious liability
727
(c) Liability in restitution
729
6 Liability of public authorities
731
(a) Contractual liability
731
(b) Tortious liability
732
Part IV Liberty 11
Liberty and the constitution
743
1 Sources of protection
744
(a) Common law
744
(b) Statute
748
(c) Statutory interpretation
749
(d) Delegated legislation
751
2 Liberty and the HRA
752
(a) The Convention rights
752
(b) Convention rights and national security: a case study
771
3 Freedom of expression
789
(a) Freedom of expression and democracy
790
(b) The ‘Spycatcher’ cases
794
(c) Freedom of expression as a common law ‘constitutional right’
797
(d) Freedom of expression and statute
800
(e) Freedom of expression and the HRA
803
(f) Conflict of rights
810
�xiv
Contents
4 Freedom of assembly
815
(a) Common law: the classic authorities
817
(b) Common law preventive powers and breach of the peace
823
(c) Freedom of assembly as a ‘constitutional right’
832
(d) Statutory restrictions on freedom of assembly
833
Preface
This book is concerned with the organisation, powers and accountability of government in the British constitution. It has been written from a lawyer’s perspective, modified by an awareness that the British constitution is far from being exclusively the handiwork of lawyers. Judges and other practitioners of the discipline of law have made a notable contribution to it, but so have political actors, controversialists of many hues, party organisations, peers, rebels in and out of Parliament and the legions of special interests. Yet lawyers sometimes pretend that the constitution is theirs, teaching and writing about it in myopic isolation. We have written this book in the conviction that the law student will arrive at an incomplete and fragmentary view of the constitution unless encouraged to take account of ideas, practices and relationships that occur outside the strict limits of the law of the constitution. The law student has much to learn from writers and practitioners in politics, government and public administration, just as students of these subjects can enrich their studies by learning something of the values, constraints and possibilities of the law. If asked a question, say, about the power of Parliament, a lawyer and a political scientist may give very different answers. But they are describing the same institution, and for a full understanding of its place in the constitution each of them needs to take the other’s perspective into account. We have set out in this book to present essential features of British government and the constitution in a way that offers a wider range of views to students of law and, we hope, also to students of politics and government. The materials in the book are taken not only from law reports, statutes and legal works but from a variety of official and unofficial publications, and from the writings of political scientists, parliamentarians and other commentators on the constitution and the practice of government. We have tried in this way to show the variegated texture of a constitution which consists not only of rules – legal, quasi-legal and customary or conventional – but of ideas, habits of mind and shared understandings: a constitution continually re-shaped in the daily practice of politics and administration as well as by the deliberate law-making of legislators and judges.
�xvi
Preface
The student of the British constitution soon finds that there are present in it two opposite principles: a principle of change and a principle of continuity. Until quite recent times, studies of the constitution generally over-emphasised the latter principle, presenting the constitution as something stately and settled, secure in its foundations, strong in its continuity and consistent in its slow evolution. By contrast, a good deal of the more recent literature focuses overly on the changing constitution at the expense of the continuing, the historical and the traditional. For all the reform we have seen to the British constitution in the last thirty years or so, there is much that remains of the old order (see further chapter 1). The ‘venerable constitution’ is still, in all sorts of respects, an apt description. What is needed – and what we hope we have provided here – is a balanced account that addresses both the elements of change and continuity that we find at the heart of the British constitution today. This edition – the second to have been jointly prepared by Colin Turpin and Adam Tomkins – adopts the same basic structure as the previous edition. The book is divided into four parts. Part I (chapters 1–5) deals with the fundamental ideas that govern the constitution (democracy, sovereignty, the rule of law and so forth) and with the multiplicity of sources, both domestic and European, that now contribute to it. In this Part, too, readers will find consideration of constitutional reform and of the structures of devolution that have transformed British government, at least in some parts of the UK, since 1998. Part II (chapters 6–7) is concerned with central government, with its institutions, personnel and powers. Part III (chapters 8–10) focuses on the various ways in which British government is subject to forms of accountability. In this Part we consider, in turn, the relative roles of the people, of Parliament and of the courts of law in this regard. When we come to the courts (in chapter 10), both the law of judicial review and the principles of liability are discussed. Part IV (chapter 11) considers the extent to which, and the means by which, the British constitution seeks to secure a degree of personal liberty. This is an element of the constitution that has been sorely tested in recent years in the face of a series of apparent threats to national and international security. We consider in some detail the ways in which British constitutional law has responded to this challenge. As we shall see, allegations of the implication of British officials in the despicable practice of torture have severely tested a number of our constitutional principles and institutions. Colin Turpin gives especial thanks to Monique for her constant encouragement and practical help with work on the book. Once again he is grateful to the Master and Fellows of Clare College for collective, friendly stimulus and to the students whose enthusiasm, alertness and scepticism make the whole enterprise of teaching and writing about law exciting and worthwhile. Adam Tomkins thanks Maria Fletcher for comments on chapter 5 and Harith Canna for assistance with chapter 8. Much more than mere thanks are owed to Lauren Apfel for her support and forbearance whilst this edition was in preparation.
�xvii
Preface
Adam Tomkins is a legal adviser to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Constitution. His contribution to this book is made purely in a personal capacity: nothing in this book is to be taken to represent the view of any member, official or committee of the House of Lords unless the contrary is clear in the text. We would both like to acknowledge the pleasure it has again been to work with our publishers at Cambridge University Press. We have endeavoured to state the legal and constitutional position as at February 2011, although we have been able to take into account subsequent developments in one or two instances. Developments occurring after this date are outlined, along with occasional commentary on constitutional matters, at www.adamtomkins.net. Links to other resources are also available via this website. Colin Turpin Adam Tomkins February 2011
Acknowledgements
Every attempt has been made to secure permission to reproduce copyright material in this title and grateful acknowledgement is made to the authors and publishers of all reproduced material. In particular, the publishers would like to acknowledge the following for granting permission to reproduce material from the sources set out below: Robert Blackburn and Andrew Kennon (eds), Griffith & Ryle on Parliament: Functions, Practice and Procedures (2nd edition 2003), pp 409–411. Reprinted with permission by Sweet & Maxwell. Rodney Brazier, The constitution in the new politics (1978) PL 117, pp 117–20. Reprinted with permission by Sweet & Maxwell. Rodney Brazier, Constitutional Practice p 296, (1988). Reprinted with permission by Oxford University Press. Vernon Bogdanor, The Monarchy and the Constitution (1997), pp 61–2, 63. Reprinted with permission by Oxford University Press. Ronald Butt, The Power of Parliament (2nd edition 1969), pp 317–8. Reprinted with permission by Margaret Butt. Nick Cohen, ‘Without Prejudice: Return of the H-Block’, Observer, 18 November 2001. © Guardian News and Media Ltd 2001. Reprinted with permission. Bernard Crick, The Reform of Parliament (revised 2nd edition 1970), pp 79–81. Reprinted with permission by Weidenfeld and Nicolson, a division of The Orion Publishing Group. SE Finer, ‘The Individual Responsibility of Ministers’ (1956) 34 Pub Adm 377 at 393–4. Reprinted with permission by Blackwell Publishing. JAG Griffith, ‘The Place of Parliament in the Legislative Process’ (1951) 14 MLR 279 at pp 287–8. Reprinted with permission by Blackwell Publishing.
�xx
Acknowledgements
Harris v Minister of the Interior 1952 (2) SA 428 (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of South Africa). Reprinted with permission by Juta & Company, Cape Town. HLA Hart, The Concept of Law, 2nd edition (1994), pp 149–50. Reprinted with permission by Oxford University Press. Kavanagh and Butler, General Election figures of 2005, (2005). Reprinted with permission by Palgrave Macmillan. Robert Leach in Maurice Mullard, Policy-making in Britain, pp 34–5. © Taylor & Francis 2005. Reproduced by permission of Taylor & Francis Books UK. Lord Lester and Lydia Clapinska, ‘Human Rights and the British Constitution’, in Jowell and Oliver (eds), The Changing Constitution 5th edition (2004), pp 67–9. Reprinted with permission by Oxford University Press. Martin Loughlin, ‘The Underside of the Law: Judicial Review and the Prison Disciplinary System’ (1993) 46 CLP 23, 25–6. Reprinted with permission by Martin Loughlin and Oxford University Press. Martin Loughlin, Sword and Scales (2000), pp 141–5. Reprinted with permission by Hart Publishing. MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396 (Court of Session) Scottish Council of Law Reporting. Reproduced from Session Cases® by permission of the Scottish Council of Law Reporting, all rights reserved. Ralph Miliband, The State in Capitalist Society (1969), pp 49–54. Reprinted with permission by Merlin Press. Philip Norton, The House of Commons and the Constitution: The Challenges of the 1970s (1981) 34 Parliamentary Affairs 253, 254–5, 266–7. Reprinted with permission by Oxford University Press. Frederick Schauer, Free Speech (1982). Reprinted with permission by Cambridge University Press. HWR Wade, The Basis of Legal Sovereignty (1995) CLJ 172, pp187–9. Reprinted with permission by John Bell, editor of The Cambridge Law Journal. Patrick Weller, ‘Cabinet government: an elusive ideal?’ (2003) 81 Pub Adm 701, 703–4, 716. Reprinted with permission by Blackwell Publishing. All public sector information has been licenced under the Open Government Licence v1.0
Abbreviations
ACAS AFSJ AMS AV BJ Pol S CFSP CLJ CLP Cm Cmd CML Rev Cmnd COREPER Crim LR DUP EC ECB ECHR ECtHR ECJ EEC EHRLR EL Rev EP EU FPTP GCHQ HC HC Deb HL HL Deb HRA ICLQ
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service area of freedom, security and justice additional member system alternative vote British Journal of Political Science common foreign and security policy Cambridge Law Journal Current Legal Problems Command Paper (1986–present) Command Paper (1919–56) Common Market Law Review Command Paper (1956–86) Committee of Permanent Representatives Criminal Law Review Democratic Unionist Party European Community European Central Bank European Convention on Human Rights European Court of Human Rights European Court of Justice European Economic Community European Human Rights Law Review European Law Review European Parliament European Union first past the post Government Communications Headquarters House of Commons Paper House of Commons Debates House of Lords Paper House of Lords Debates Human Rights Act 1998 International and Comparative Law Quarterly
�xxii
Abbreviations
IPPR JCHR JHA JLS JMC JR LQR LS MEP MLR MP MSP NDPB NEDC NILQ NLJ OJLS Parl Aff PL PPB Pol Q PR Pub Adm QMV Quango SDLP SIAC SNP Stat LR STV TEU TFEU UNSCR UUP
Institute for Public Policy Research Joint Committee on Human Rights justice and home affairs Journal of Law and Society Joint Ministerial Committee Judicial Review Law Quarterly Review Legal Studies Member of the European Parliament Modern Law Review Member of Parliament Member of the Scottish Parliament non-departmental public body National Economic Development Council Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly New Law Journal Oxford Journal of Legal Studies Parliamentary Affairs Public Law party political broadcast Political Quarterly proportional representation Public Administration qualified majority voting quasi-autonomous non-governmental organisation Social Democratic and Labour Party Special Immigration Appeals Commission Scottish National Party Statute Law Review single transferable vote Treaty on European Union Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union United Nations Security Council Resolution Ulster Unionist Party
Table of Cases
A v B [2009] UKSC 12, [2010] 2 AC 1.............................................................................. 716 A v Head Teacher and Governors of Lord Grey School [2004] EWCA Civ 382, [2004] 4 All ER 628............................................................................... 11 A v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] UKHL 56, [2005] 2 AC 68..................................................... 7, 14, 693, 772, 778–83, 788 A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (No 2) [2005] UKHL 71, [2006] 2 AC 221................................................................................ 747 A v United Kingdom (1998) 27 EHRR 611...................................................................... 759 A v United Kingdom (2009) 49 EHRR 29......................... 14, 279, 704, 767, 768, 785, 788 Abbasi v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2002] EWCA Civ 1598............................................................................................................... 136 Accession to the ECHR, Opinion 2/94 [1996] ECR I-1759............................................ 327 Adams v Naylor [1946] AC 543......................................................................................... 727 Adams v Scottish Ministers 2004 SC 665.......................................................... 235, 236, 238 Adegbenro v Akintola [1963] AC 614............................................................................... 383 Agricultural Training Board v Aylesbury Mushrooms Ltd [1972] 1 WLR 190.......... 475 Ahmed v United Kingdom (1998) 29 EHRR 1................................................................ 444 Ahmed and others v HM Treasury [2010] UKSC 2, [2010] 2 WLR 378.......................................................... 169, 170, 480, 669, 722, 751, 789 Air Canada v Secretary of State for Trade (No 2) [1983] 2 AC 394.............................. 176 Airedale NHS Trust v Bland [1993] AC 789.................................................................... 138 Albert v Lavin [1982] AC 546..................................................................................... 823, 826 Albert (Prince) v Strange (1849) 1 H & TW 1................................................................. 178 Ali v Birmingham City Council [2010] UKSC 8, [2010] 2 AC 39................................. 699 Al-Khawaja v United Kingdom (2009) 49 EHRR 1................................................ 768, 769 Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato v Simmenthal SpA, Case 106/77 [1978] ECR 629........................................................................... 316–18, 323 Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 2 AC 147............................................................................................. 438, 466, 669, 714–16 Anns v Merton London Borough Council [1978] AC 728............................................. 738 Appleby v United Kingdom (2003) 37 EHRR 38............................................................ 837 Argyll (Duchess of) v Duke of Argyll [1967] Ch 302...................................................... 178 Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd [2002] UKHL 29, [2002] 1 WLR 2033.... 803 Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corpn [1948] 1 KB 223................ 662, 676–8, 681, 685, 692, 693, 707, 708, 732, 745, 778, 799
�xxiv
Table of Cases Aston Cantlow Parochial Church Council v Wallbank [2003] UKHL 37, [2004] 1 AC 546............................................................................................ 763 Attorney General v Blake [1998] Ch 439.......................................................................... 389 Attorney General v De Keyser’s Royal Hotel Ltd [1920] AC 508............ 493–4, 495, 496 Attorney General v English [1983] 1 AC 116........................................................... 800, 801 Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd [1987] 1 WLR 1248............ 285, 795, 797 Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd [1992] 1 WLR 874.............................. 801 Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd (No 2) [1990] 1 AC 109................................................................................ 14, 285, 793, 796, 797 Attorney General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752........... 176–82, 198, 199, 390, 794 Attorney General v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1987] QB 1.................................... 800 Attorney General v Newspaper Publishing plc [1988] Ch 333.............................. 390, 795 Attorney General v Times Newspapers Ltd [1974] AC 273................................... 282, 797 Attorney General v Times Newspapers Ltd [1992] 1 AC 191........................................ 795 Attorney General v Wilts United Dairies Ltd (1921) 37 TLR 884 (CA); affirmed (1922) 38 TLR 781 (HL)............................................... 162, 163 Attorney General (ex rel McWhirter) v Independent Broadcasting Authority [1973] QB 629........................................................................ 533 Attorney General for Canada v Attorney General for Ontario [1937] AC 326........... 335 Attorney General for Canada v Hallet & Carey Ltd [1952] AC 427..................... 479, 488 Attorney General for Hong Kong v Ng Yuen Shiu [1983] 2 AC 629........................... 502 Attorney General for New South Wales v Trethowan [1932] AC 526, (1931) 44 CLR 394........................................................................................ 77, 79 Austin v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [2009] UKHL 5, [2009] 1 AC 564............................................................................... 827–31, 834 AXA General Insurance, Petitioners [2010] CSOH 2, 2010 SLT 179; [2011] CSIH 31, 2011 SLT 439..................................................... 236, 237 Ayr Harbour Trustees v Oswald (1883) 8 App Cas 623................................................. 731 Bainbridge v Postmaster-General [1906] 1 KB 178......................................................... 368 Bakker v Austria (2003) 39 EHRR 548.............................................................................. 701 Bank Mellat v HM Treasury [2010] EWCA Civ 483, [2010] 3 WLR 1090.................. 767 Bank Mellat v HM Treasury [2011] EWCA Civ 1........................................................... 690 Bank Melli Iran v Council, Case T-390/08 [2009] ECR II-3967.................................... 335 Barrett v Enfield LBC [2001] 2 AC 550......................................................................... 732–5 Bates v Lord Hailsham [1972] 1 WLR 1373..................................................................... 478 BBC v Johns [1965] Ch 32.................................................................................................. 366 BBC v Sugar [2009] UKHL 9, [2009] 1 WLR 430............................................................ 563 BBC v Sugar (No 2) [2010] EWCA Civ 715, [2010] 1 WLR 2278................................. 563 Beatty v Gillbanks (1882) 9 QBD 308.......................................................................... 817–22 Beggs v Scottish Ministers 2005 SC 342 (CSIH); [2007] UKHL 3, [2007] 1 WLR 455.............................................................................. 376 Begum (Runa) v Tower Hamlets LBC [2003] UKHL 5, [2003] 2 AC 430.............................................................................................. 135, 698–702 Belfast City Council v Miss Behavin’ [2007] UKHL 19, [2007] 1 WLR 1240............................................................................... 690, 691 Belfast Corpn v OD Cars Ltd [1960] AC 490................................................................... 175
�xxv
Table of Cases Belgian Linguistic Case (No 2) (1968) 1 EHRR 252........................................................ 757 Bellinger v Bellinger [2003] 2 AC 467............................................................................. 82–4 Bibby v Chief Constable of Essex (2000) 164 JP 297....................................................... 823 Bishop of Natal, Re (1864) 3 Moo PCCNS 115................................................................ 485 Blackburn v Attorney General [1971] 1 WLR 1037.......................................... 68, 492, 716 Black-Clawson International Ltd v Papierwerke Waldhof-Aschaffenburg AG [1975] AC 591............................................................... 154 Blair v Lochaber District Council 1995 SLT 407............................................................. 711 Boddington v British Transport Police [1999] 2 AC 143...................... 110, 174, 665, 668 Bonham’s Case (1610) 8 Co Rep 114................................................................................... 74 Bowles v Bank of England [1913] 1 Ch 57.......................................................................... 62 Bowman v United Kingdom (1998) 26 EHRR 1.............................................................. 525 Brannigan and McBride v United Kingdom (1993) 17 EHRR 539............................... 281 Brasserie du Pêcheur v Germany, Case C-46/93 [1996] ECR I–1029........................... 324 Brazil v Chief Constable of Surrey [1983] 1 WLR 1155.................................................. 173 Bribery Comr v Ranasinghe [1965] AC 172....................................................................... 77 Brind v United Kingdom 77-A DR 42 (1994).................................................................. 799 British Airways Board v Laker Airways Ltd [1984] QB 142........................................... 139 British Coal Corpn v R [1935] AC 500................................................................................ 68 British Medical Association v Greater Glasgow Health Board [1989] AC 1211......... 376 British Oxygen Co Ltd v Board of Trade [1971] AC 610............................... 171, 496, 677 British Railways Board v Herrington [1972] AC 877...................................................... 136 British Railways Board v Pickin [1974] AC 765......................................... 63, 65, 66, 69, 94 Broadmoor Special Hospital Authority v Robinson [2000] QB 775............................. 713 Brogan v United Kingdom (1998) 11 EHRR 117............................................................ 281 Bromley LBC v Greater London Council [1983] 1 AC 768................................... 273, 274 Bropho v State of Western Australia (1990) 171 CLR 1................................................. 371 Brown v Stott [2003] 1 AC 681........................................................................................... 756 Bugdaycay v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1987] AC 514......... 682, 683 Bulmer v Bollinger [1974] Ch 401..................................................................... 320, 338, 340 Burmah Oil Co Ltd v Bank of England [1980] AC 1090................................................ 558 Burmah Oil Co Ltd v Lord Advocate [1965] AC 75............................... 110, 111, 494, 749 Bushell v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] 1 AC 75........................ 486, 703 Cabinet Office v Information Commissioner, Information Tribunal Appeal No EA/2008/0024 and EA/2008/0029, 27 January 2009............................... 563 Cadder v HM Advocate [2010] UKSC 43, 2010 SLT 1125..................................... 746, 769 Camelot Group plc v Centaur Communications Ltd [1999] QB 124........................... 803 Campbell v MGN Ltd [2004] UKHL 22, [2004] 2 AC 457..................................... 766, 770 Campbell and Cosans v United Kingdom (1982) 4 EHRR 293..................................... 765 Canon Selwyn, ex p (1872) 36 JP 54.................................................................................. 253 Caparo Industries v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605............................................................... 733 Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560.......................... 485–6, 677 Case of Proclamations (1611) 12 Co Rep 74............................................................ 483, 717 Central Control Board v Cannon Brewery Co Ltd [1919] AC 744............................... 750 Chagos Islanders v Attorney General [2004] EWCA Civ 997....................................... 117 Chahal v United Kingdom (1996) 23 EHRR 413............................................. 775, 778, 780
�xxvi
Table of Cases Chandler v DPP [1964] AC 763..................................................................... 12, 13, 136, 716 Chassagnou v France (2000) 29 EHRR 615........................................................................ 52 Cheney v Conn [1968] 1 All ER 779.................................................................................... 61 Chester v Bateson [1920] 1 KB 829 (DC)......................................................................... 165 Chief Constable of North Wales Police v Evans [1982] 1 WLR 1155........................... 662 Christians against Racism and Fascism v United Kingdom (1980) 21 DR 138.......... 835 Christie v Leachinsky [1947] AC 573................................................................................ 748 CILFIT v Ministry of Health, Case 283/81 [1982] ECR 3415........................................ 308 City of Chicago Tribune Co (1923) 139 NE 86................................................................ 792 City of Edinburgh DC v Secretary of State for Scotland 1985 SC 261.......................... 669 Coleshill and District Investment Co Ltd v Minister of Housing and Local Government [1969] 2 All ER 525........................................................................ 506 Collins v Hertfordshire County Council [1947] KB 598................................................ 728 Commission v France, Case C-304/02 [2005] ECR I-6263............................................ 302 Commission of the European Communities v United Kingdom, Case 246/89R [1989] ECR 3125..................................................................................... 349 Common Services Agency v Scottish Information Commissioner [2008] UKHL 47, [2008] 1 WLR 1550............................................... 563 Congreve v Home Office [1976] QB 629.......................................................................... 163 Conway v Rimmer [1968] AC 910..................................................................................... 373 Cooper v Attorney General [2010] EWCA Civ 464........................................................ 325 Cooper v Wandsworth Board of Works (1863) 14 CBNS 180.............................. 175, 699 Corporate Officer of the House of Commons v Information Commissioner [2008] EWHC 1084 (Admin), [2009] 3 All ER 403......................... 564 Costa v ENEL, Case 6/64 [1964] ECR 585............................................. 79, 315–7, 323, 328 Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Servce [1985] AC 374................................. 136, 360, 440, 668, 678, 695, 707, 716–20, 722, 775 CPC Group v Qatari Diar Real Estate [2010] EWHC 1535 (Ch).................................. 379 Crédit Suisse v Allerdale Borough Council [1997] QB 306.................................... 712, 731 CREEDNZ Inc v Governor General [1981] 1 NZLR 172............................................... 676 Crocket v Tantallon Golf Club 2005 SLT 663.................................................................. 711 Crown Lands Commissioners v Page [1960] 2 QB 274.................................................. 727 Cullen v Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary [2003] UKHL 39, [2003] 1 WLR 1763.......................................................................... 765 Customs and Excise Comrs v ApS Samex [1983] 1 All ER 1042................................... 309 Customs and Excise Comrs v Cure & Deeley Ltd [1962] 1 QB 340.............................. 479 D v National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children [1978] AC 171.......... 12 Davidson v Scottish Ministers 2002 SC 205 (IH); [2005] UKHL 74, 2006 SLT 110, 2006 SC (HL) 41................................. 117, 163, 376, 724, 725 Daymond v South West Water Authority [1976] AC 609............................................. 664 De Falco v Crawley Borough Council [1980] QB 460.................................................... 504 De Freitas v Permanent Secretary of Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries, Land and Housing [1999] 1 AC 69...................................................... 688, 690 Defrenne v Sabena, Case 43/75 [1976] ECR 455............................................................. 320 Denning v Secretary of State for India (1920) 37 TLR 138............................................ 440 Derbyshire County Council v Times Newspapers [1992] QB 770 (CA); [1993] AC 534 (HL)................................................... 285, 746, 791–3, 797
�xxvii
Table of Cases Deutsche Morgan Grenfell v Inland Revenue Commissioners [2006] UKHL 49, [2007] 1 AC 558........................................................................ 376, 730 Dimes v Grand Junction Canal Proprietors (1852) 3 HLC 759..................................... 695 Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562............................................................................. 137 Doorson v Netherlands (1996) 22 EHRR 330.................................................................. 768 Doughty v Rolls Royce [1992] 1 CMLR 1045................................................................... 322 Douglas v Hello! Ltd [2001] QB 967................................................................................. 811 Douglas v Hello! Ltd [2005] EWCA Civ 593, [2005] QB 125........................................ 766 DPP v Bhagwan [1972] AC 60........................................................................................... 750 DPP v Haw [2007] EWHC 1931 (Admin), [2008] 1 WLR 379..................................... 486 DPP v Jones [1999] 2 AC 240............................................................................. 833, 836, 837 Dr Bentley’s case (1723) 1 Stra 557.................................................................................... 174 Duke v GEC Reliance [1988] AC 618............................................................................ 356–8 Duncan v Jones [1936] 1 KB 218........................................................ 173, 747, 819–22, 832 Dunn v R [1896] 1 QB 116.................................................................................................. 440 Duport Steels Ltd v Sirs [1980] 1 WLR 142.................................................................. 151–3 E v Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary [2008] UKHL 66, [2009] 1 AC 536............................................................................................ 762 E (A Child), Re [2008] UKHL 66, [2009] 1 AC 536............................................ 555–6, 840 Eba v Advocate General for Scotland [2010] CSIH 78................................................... 711 Edinburgh and Dalkeith Railway Co v Wauchope (1842) 8 Cl & Fin 710..................................................................................................................... 62, 64, 65 Ellen Street Estates Ltd v Minister of Health [1934] 1 KB 590........................................ 77 EN (Serbia) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2009] EWCA Civ 630, [2010] 3 WLR 182............................................................................... 483 Entick v Carrington (1765) 19 St Tr 1029............................................. 11, 99–102, 495 744 Eshugbayi Eleko v Government of Nigeria [1931] AC 662................................................ 8 European Parliament v Council, Case C-540/03 [2006] ECR I-5769........................... 326 Evans v Information Commissioner (Judgment of the Upper Tribunal pending)............................................................................................... 199 Faccini Dori v Recreb, Case C-91/92 [1994] ECR I-3325............................................... 321 Factortame, See R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Farhi Saeed Bin Mohammed v Barack Obama (Civil Action No 05-1347 (GK)) 19 November 2009, District Ct for DC......................................................................... 375 Farley v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2006] 1 WLR 1817...................... 716 Findlay, Re [1985] AC 318.......................................................................................... 676, 677 Fitzpatrick v Sterling Housing Association [2001] 1 AC 27............................................ 83 Foster v British Gas [1991] 2 AC 306.................................................................................. 12 Foster v British Gas, Case C-188/89 [1990] ECR I-3313................................................ 321 Fothergill v Monarch Airlines Ltd [1981] AC 251.......................................................... 123 Francis v Yiewsley and West Drayton Urban District Council [1963] 2 QB 133....... 173 Francovich and Bonifaci v Italy, Joined Cases C-6 and 9/90 [1991] ECR I-5357........................................................................................................ 296, 323, 324 Fraser v Evans [1969] 1 QB 349......................................................................................... 178 Fraser v MacCorquodale 1992 SLT 229............................................................................ 227 Furniss v Dawson [1984] AC 474...................................................................................... 137
�xxviii
Table of Cases G (Adopton: Unmarried Couple), Re [2008] UKHL 38, [2009] 1 AC 173.................. 693 Gentle v Prime Minister [2008] UKHL 20, [2008] 1 AC 1356....................................... 758 Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza [2004] UKHL 30, [2004] 2 AC 557............................. 83, 766 Gibson v Lord Advocate 1975 SLT 134......................................................................... 225–7 Gillan v United Kingdom (2010) 50 EHRR 45....................................... 121, 124, 279, 788 Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority [1986] AC 112................................................................................... 508 Glasgow Corpn v Central Land Board 1956 SC (HL) 1.................................................... 14 Godden v Hales (1686) 11 St Tr 1165 (KB)........................................................................ 71 Golden Chemical Products Ltd, Re [1976] Ch 300......................................................... 486 Golder v United Kingdom (1975) 1 EHRR 524....................................................... 134, 281 Goodwin v United Kingdom (1996) 22 EHRR 123................................................. 802, 803 Gorringe v Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council [2004] 1 WLR 1057.............. 732 Greene v Secretary of State for Home Affairs [1942] AC 284........................................ 774 Greens & MT v United Kingdom [2010] ECHR 1826 (23 November 2010)............... 283 Griffin v South West Water Services [1995] IRLR 15..................................................... 322 Grzelczyk, Case C-184/99 [2001] ECR I-6193................................................................. 328 Hales v R (1918) 34 TLR 589.............................................................................................. 440 Hall and others v Mayor of London [2010] EWCA Civ 817.................................... 837–40 Hamilton v Al Fayed [2001] 1 AC 395.............................................................................. 163 Handyside v United Kingdom (1976) 1 EHRR 737........................................................ 826 Harding v Wealands [2006] UKHL 32, [2007] 2 AC 1................................................... 466 Hardy v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1964] 2 QB 745.......................................................... 509 Harris v Minister of the Interior 1952 (2) SA 428......................................................... 75–7 Hashman v United Kingdom (2000) 30 EHRR 241........................................................ 824 Hatton v United Kingdom (2003) 37 EHRR 28............................................................... 692 Hazell v Hammersmith and Fulham LBC [1992] 1 AC 1............................................... 273 Hector v A-G of Antigua and Barbuda [1990] 2 AC 312............................................... 792 Hedley Byrne & Co v Heller & Partners [1964] AC 465................................................. 729 Helow v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] UKHL 62, 2009 SC (HL) 1.............................................................................................. 695 Hill v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire [1990] 1 WLR 946...................................... 749 Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [1989] AC 53........................................ 734, 735 Hirst v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire (1986) 85 Cr App Rep 143....................... 832 Hirst v United Kingdom (No 2) (2006) 42 EHRR 41........................................ 80, 283, 288 HM Advocate v McLean [2009] HCJAC 97, 2010 SLT 73............................................. 769 HM Treasury v Information Commissioner [2009] EWHC 1811 (Admin), [2010] 2 WLR 931.................................................................................................... 199, 563 Holden v Chief Constable of Lancashire [1987] QB 380................................................ 736 Home Office v Dorset Yacht Co Ltd [1970] AC 1004..................................... 729, 732, 734 Huang v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2007] UKHL 11, [2007] 2 AC 167....................................................................................................... 691, 693 Hubbard v Pitt [1976] QB 142............................................................................ 744, 832, 836 Imperial Tobacco Ltd, Petitioner [2010] CSOH 134, 2010 SLT 1023................... 238, 239 Imutran Ltd v Uncaged Campaigns Ltd [2001] 2 All ER 385........................................ 811 Internationale Handelsgesellschaft, Case 11/70 [1970] ECR 1125........................ 316, 326
�xxix
Table of Cases International Transport Roth v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] EWCA Civ 158, [2003] QB 728................................................................... 87, 693 IRC v National Federation of Self-Employed and Small Businesses [1982] AC 617.................................................................................................................. 712 IRC v Rossminster Ltd [1980] AC 952.............................................................................. 100 Ireland v United Kingdom (1978) 2 EHRR 25......................................................... 103, 759 Jackson v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56, [2006] 1 AC 262, HL; on appeal from [2005] EWCA Civ 126, [2005] QB 579.................. 64–6, 78, 91–94, 354, 520, 651 Jain v Trent Strategic Health Authority [2009] UKHL 4, [2009] 1 AC 853................. 737 Jameel v Wall Street Journal Europe [2006] UKHL 44, [2007] 1 AC 359.................... 794 Jenkins v Attorney-General (1971) 115 Sol Jo 674.......................................................... 492 Joyce v DPP [1946] AC 347.................................................................................................. 70 Kadi v Commission, Case T-85/09, 30 September 2010................................................. 335 Kadi v Council, Case T-315/01 [2005] ECR II-3649....................................................... 332 Kadi and Al Barakaat v Council, Joined Cases C-402/05 P and C-415/05 P [2008] ECR I-6351.......................................................................... 332–5, 788 Kaur v Lord Advocate 1980 SC 319................................................................................... 284 Kavanagh v Hiscock [1974] QB 600.................................................................................. 820 Khawaja v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1984] AC 74........................... 8 Klass v Germany (1978) 2 EHRR 214................................................................................ 757 Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council [1999] 2 AC 349................................... 138 Köbler v Austria, Case C-224/01 [2003] ECR I-10239.................................................... 325 Kremzow, Case C-299/95 [1997] ECR I-2629.................................................................. 326 Kuddus v Chief Constable of Leicestershire [2001] UKHL 29, [2002] 2 AC 122............................................................................................ 736 Laker Airways Ltd v Department of Trade [1977] QB 643............................................ 503 Lambeth London Borough Council v Ireneschild [2007] EWCA Civ 234.................. 504 Lam Chi-ming v R [1991] 2 AC 212.................................................................................. 746 Laughland v Wansborough Paper Co Ltd 1921 1 SLT 341............................................ 227 Lauri v Renad [1892] 3 Ch 402........................................................................................... 123 Lavender (H) & Son Ltd v Minister of Housing and Local Government [1970] 1 WLR 1231........................................................................ 677 Lawal v Northern Spirit Ltd [2003] UKHL 35, [2004] 1 All ER 187............................. 174 Leach v Money (1765) 3 Burr 1692.................................................................................... 783 Le Compte, Van Leuven and De Meyere v Belgium (1981) 4 EHRR 1........................ 701 Lee v Bude and Torrington Junction Rly Co (1871) LR 6 CP 576...................... 62, 64, 65 Leech v Deputy Governor of Parkhurst Prison [1988] AC 533..................................... 175 Lewis v Attorney General of Jamaica [2001] 2 AC 50..................................................... 720 Lindley v Rutter [1981] QB 128......................................................................................... 173 Litster v Forth Dry Dock and Engineering [1990] 1 AC 546......................................... 359 Liversidge v Anderson [1942] AC 206......................................................... 747, 773–5, 789 Lloyd v McMahon [1987] 1 AC 625.................................................................................. 703 Lochner v New York 198 US 45 (1905)............................................................................... 46 L’Office Cherifien des Phosphates v Yamashita-Shinnihon Steamship Co Ltd [1994] 1 AC 486............................................................................... 123
�xxx
Table of Cases London United Investments plc, Re [1992] Ch 578........................................................ 749 Lonrho plc v Tebbit [1991] 4 All ER 973.......................................................................... 729 Lord Advocate v Dumbarton District Council 1988 SLT 546 (IH), [1990] 2 AC 580....................................................................................................... 371, 723 Lord Advocate v Scotsman Publications Ltd [1990] 1 AC 812...................................... 797 M v Home Office [1994] 1 AC 377............................ 113–17, 176, 349, 367, 583, 724, 725 McCall v Poulton [2009] 1 CMLR 45................................................................................ 322 McCartan Turkington Breen v Times Newspapers Ltd [2001] 2 AC 277.................... 790 Macarthys Ltd v Smith [1979] 3 All ER 325......................................................... 344–7, 355 Macarthys Ltd v Smith [1981] QB 180.............................................................................. 347 Macarthys Ltd v Smith, Case 129/79 [1980] ECR 1275.................................................. 347 MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396.......................................................... 60, 223–7 McDonald v Secretary of State for Scotland 1994 SC 234.............................................. 724 McE v Prison Service of Northern Ireland [2009] UKHL 15, [2009] 1 AC 908......................................................................................................... 81, 112 McEldowney v Forde [1971] AC 632................................................................................ 256 McGonnell v United Kingdom (2000) 30 EHRR 289............................................. 140, 150 Macgregor v Lord Advocate 1921 SC 847................................................................ 723, 727 Mackenzie v Stewart (1752) 9 Mor Dic 7443..................................................................... 63 McKerr, Re [2004] UKHL 12, [2004] 1 WLR 807........................................................... 175 McKerr v United Kingdom (2002) 34 EHRR 553........................................................... 103 McLeod v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1994] 4 All ER 553............................ 823 McLeod v United Kingdom (1999) 27 EHRR 493................................................... 823, 824 McLoughlin v O’Brian [1983] 1 AC 410........................................................................... 138 Madras Electric Supply Corpn Ltd v Boarland [1955] AC 667..................................... 369 Madzimbamuto v Lardner-Burke [1969] 1 AC 645.......................................... 70, 197, 198 Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1979] Ch 344................ 11, 101–103, 744 Malone v United Kingdom (1984) 7 EHRR 14................................................ 102, 282, 499 Manchester City Council v Pinnock [2010] UKSC 45, [2010] 2 WLR 1441......... 769–71 Manuel v Attorney General [1983] Ch 77.............................................................. 61, 68, 95 Marcic v Thames Water Utilities Ltd [2003] UKHL 66, [2004] 2 AC 42..................... 736 Marleasing v La Comercial Internacionale de Alimentacion, Case C-106/89 [1990] ECR I-4135................................................................ 322, 356, 359 Marshall v Southampton and SW Hampshire Area Health Authority, Case 152/84 [1986] ECR 723.................................................................................. 321, 356 Martin v HM Advocate [2010] UKSC 10, 2010 SC (UKSC) 40..................... 229, 238, 239 Martinez Sala, Case C-85/96 [1998] ECR I-2691............................................................. 328 Matthews v Ministry of Defence [2003] UKHL 4, [2003] 1 AC 1163............... 134–6, 377 Merkur Island Shipping Corpn v Laughton [1983] 2 AC 570............................... 467, 468 Merricks v Heathcoat-Amory [1995] Ch 567.................................................................. 725 Mitchell v Glasgow City Council [2009] UKHL 11, [2009] 1 AC 874...................................................................................... 732, 735, 737, 758 Molyneaux, Ex p [1986] 1 WLR 331.......................................................................... 258, 492 Moss v McLachlan [1985] IRLR 76.......................................................... 173, 820, 824, 825 Murphy v Brentwood District Council [1991] 1 AC 398............................................... 738 Murray v Express Newspapers [2008] EWCA Civ 446, [2009] Ch 481................ 766, 770 Murray v Rogers 1992 SLT 221.......................................................................................... 227
�xxxi
Table of Cases N v United Kingdom (2008) 47 EHRR 39........................................................................ 762 N v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] UKHL 31, [2005] 2 AC 296............................................................................................................... 762 Nadarajah v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] EWCA Civ 1363............................................................................................... 502, 709, 710 Ndlwana v Hofmeyr 1937 AD 229....................................................................................... 68 Netherlands v Parliament and Council (‘Biotechnology Directive’), Case C-377/98 [2001] ECR I-7079................................................................................ 296 Newbury DC v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] AC 578....................... 505 New York Times Co v Sullivan (1964) 376 US 254......................................................... 792 Nicol (D & J) v Trustees of the Harbour of Dundee 1915 SC (HL) 7........................... 714 Nottinghamshire County Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1986] AC 240.......................................................................................... 681 NUT v St Mary’s Church of England Junior School [1997] 3 CMLR 630......................................................................................................................... 322 Observer and Guardian v United Kingdom (1991) 14 EHRR 153........................................................................................... 282, 283, 797, 797 O’Byrne v Aventis Pasteur [2008] UKHL 34, [2010] 1 WLR 1412............................... 308 Odelola v Home Secretary [2009] UKHL 25.................................................................... 171 Office of Government Commerce v Information Commissioner [2008] EWHC 774 (Admin)....................................................................................................... 155 Officer L, Re [2007] UKHL 36, [2007] 1 WLR 2135........................................................ 758 O’Kelly v Harvey (1883) 10 LR Ir 285............................................................................... 819 O’Reilly v Mackman [1983] 2 AC 237....................................................................... 667, 746 O’Rourke v Camden London Borough Council [1988] AC 188................................... 736 O’Rourke v United Kingdom, Application No 39022/97, unreported, 26 June 2001................................................................................................ 760 Osman v United Kingdom (1998) EHRR 245.................................................. 734, 735, 758 Padfield v Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food [1968] AC 997.................................................................................................. 488, 671–3, 676, 722 Parliament v Council and Commission, Cases C-317/04 and C-318/04 [2006] ECR I-4721.......................................................................................... 304 People’s Mojehadin Organisation of Iran v Council, Case T-256/07 [2008] ECR II-3019............................................................................... 335 Pepper v Hart [1993] AC 593............................................................................. 154, 163, 466 Percy v DPP [1995] 1 WLR 1382....................................................................................... 824 Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777............................................................................................ 137 Phelps v Hillingdon LBC [2001] 2 AC 619............................................................... 732, 736 Phillips v Eyre (1870) LR 6 QB 1........................................................................................ 123 Pickstone v Freemans [1989] AC 66.............................................................................. 357–9 Piddington v Bates [1961] 1 WLR 162...................................................................... 173, 820 Plattform Ärzte für das Leben v Austria (1988) 13 EHRR 204...................................... 833 Plaumann v Commission, Case 25/62 [1963] ECR 95.................................................... 306 Porter v Magill [2001] UKHL 67, [2002] 2 AC 357................................ 174, 670, 695, 696 Post Office v Estuary Radio Ltd [1968] 2 QB 740............................................................ 483 Prebble v Television New Zealand Ltd [1995] 1 AC 321........................................ 156, 163
�xxxii
Table of Cases Prescott v Birmingham Corpn [1955] Ch 210................................................................. 273 Pretty v United Kingdom (2002) 35 EHRR 1........................................................... 759, 761 Pringle, Petitioner 1991 SLT 330....................................................................................... 227 Prohibitions del Roy (1607) 12 Co Rep 63....................................................................... 717 Province of Bombay v Municipal Corpn of the City of Bombay [1947] AC 58 (PC).................................................................................................................. 370–71 Publico Ministero v Ratti, Case 148/78 [1979] ECR 1629.............................................. 321 Pyx Granite Co Ltd v Ministry of Housing and Local Government [1960] AC 260....................................................................................................................... 173, 174 Quigly v Chief Land Registrar [1993] 1 WLR 1435......................................................... 662 R v A (No 2) [2001] UKHL 25, [2002] 1 AC 45............................................. 82, 83, 85, 692 R v Advertising Standards Authority Ltd, ex p Vernons Organisation Ltd [1992] 1 WLR 1289.......................................................................................................... 797 R v Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council, ex p Hook [1976] 1 WLR 1052........... 686 R v BBC, ex p Lavelle [1983] 1 WLR 23............................................................................ 711 R v BBC and ITC, ex p Referendum Party [1997] COD 459......................................... 533 R v Board of Inland Revenue, ex p MFK Underwriting Agents [1990] 1 WLR 1545.......................................................................................................... 705 R v Board of Visitors of HM Prison the Maze, ex p Hone [1988] 1 AC 379............... 703 R v Boundary Commission for England, ex p Foot [1983] QB 600.............................. 522 R v Bow Street Metropolitan Stipendiary Magistrates, ex p Pinochet Ugarte (No 2) [2000] 1 AC 119.............................................................................. 174, 695 R v Bradley [2005] EWCA Crim 20, [2005] 1 Cr App R 397......................................... 465 R v Brent LBC, ex p Awua [1996] AC 55.......................................................................... 504 R v British Coal Corpn, ex p Vardy [1993] ICR 720............................................... 681, 706 R v Brown [1994] 1 WLR 1599........................................................................................... 136 R v Cambridge Health Authority, ex p B [1995] 1 WLR 898................................. 663, 681 R v Chaytor and others [2010] EWCA Crim 1910, [2010] 2 Cr App R 34; affirmed [2010] UKSC 52, [2010] 3 WLR 1707........................................... 163, 164, 564 R v Chief Constable of Devon and Cornwall Police, ex p CEGB [1982] QB 458............................................................................................................................... 823 R v Chief Constable of South Wales, ex p Merrick [1994] 1 WLR 663........................ 746 R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Trader’s Ferry Ltd [1999] 2 AC 418............................................. 360, 679, 686, 821, 833 R v Chief Immigration Officer, Gatwick, ex p Kharrazi [1980] 1 WLR 1396.............. 502 R v Chief Immigration Officer, Heathrow, ex p Salamat Bibi [1976] 1 WLR 979...... 501 R v Chief Metropolitan Stipendiary Magistrate, ex p Choudhury [1991] 1 QB 429............................................................................................................................... 284 R v Cornwall County Council, ex p Huntington [1994] 1 All ER 694.......................... 715 R v Coventry City Council, ex p Phoenix Aviation [1995] 3 All ER 37........................ 674 R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board, ex p Lain [1967] 2 QB 864............. 502, 716 R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board, ex p Schofield [1971] 1 WLR 926......... 438 R v Director of Serious Fraud Office, ex p Smith [1993] AC 1...................................... 746 R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club, ex p Aga Khan [1993] 1 WLR 909........................................................................................................................... 711
�xxxiii
Table of Cases R v DPP, ex p Duckenfield [1999] 2 All ER 873............................................................... 506 R v DPP, ex p Kebilene [2000] 2 AC 326.......................................................................... 692 R v Ealing LBC, ex p Times Newspapers Ltd (1986) 85 LGR 316......................... 670, 671 R v Felixstowe Justices, ex p Leigh [1987] QB 582.......................................................... 713 R v G [2009] UKHL 13, [2010] 1 AC 43........................................................................... 751 R v Gaming Board, ex p Benaim and Khaida [1970] 2 QB 417............................. 438, 704 R v Goldstein [1983] 1 All ER 434..................................................................................... 343 R v Grant [2005] EWCA Crim 1089................................................................................. 109 R v H [2004] UKHL 3, [2004] 2 AC 134........................................................................... 373 R v Halliday, ex p Zadig [1917] AC 260................................................. 11, 773–5, 783, 789 R v Hallstrom, ex p W [1986] QB 1090............................................................................. 750 R v Henn [1978] 1 WLR 1031 (CA), [1981] AC 850 (ECJ and HL)...................... 308, 343 R v HM Treasury, ex p British Telecommunications plc, Case C-392/93 [1996] ECR I-1631........................................................................................................... 325 R v HM Treasury, ex p Smedley [1985] QB 657...................................................... 155, 712 R v Horncastle [2009] UKSC 14, [2010] 2 WLR 47................................................... 768–70 R v Horseferry Road Magistrates’ Court, ex p Bennett [1994] 1 AC 42............... 108, 109 R v Horseferry Road Magistrates’ Court, ex p Bennett (No 4) [1995] 1 Cr App Rep 147................................................................................................................ 109 R v Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, ex p Blood [1999] Fam 151.... 438 R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, ex p Manshoora Begum [1986] Imm AR 385..................................................................................................................... 502 R v IRC, ex p Preston [1983] 2 All ER 300; [1985] AC 835.................................... 725, 726 R v Jones [2006] UKHL 16, [2007] 1 AC 136................................................................... 556 R v Khan [1997] AC 558..................................................................................................... 105 R v Keogh [2007] EWCA Crim 528, [2007] 1 WLR 1500...................................... 751, 804 R v Lewisham LBC, ex p Shell UK Ltd [1988] 1 All ER 938................................... 671, 731 R v Local Commissioner for Administration, ex p Eastleigh Borough Council [1988] QB 855................................................................................... 630 R v Local Commissioner for Administration, ex p Liverpool City Council [2001] 1 All ER 462.......................................................................................................... 630 R v Londonderry Justices (1891) 28 LR Ir 440................................................................. 818 R v Loosely [2001] UKHL 53, [2001] 1 WLR 2060......................................................... 107 R v Lord President of the Privy Council, ex p Page [1993] AC 682...................... 665, 669 R v Lord Saville of Newdigate, ex p A [2000] 1 WLR 1855............................................ 746 R v Lyons [2002] UKHL 44, [2003] 1 AC 976.................................................................... 61 R v McIlkenny [1992] 2 All ER 417........................................................................... 104, 143 R v Metropolitan Police Commissioner, ex p Blackburn (No 2) [1968] 2 QB 150............................................................................................................................... 797 R v Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, ex p Hamble [1995] 2 All ER 714......................................................................................................................... 361 R v Ministry of Defence, ex p Smith [1996] QB 517.................. 678, 681–5, 689, 692, 745 R v Norfolk County Council Social Services Department, ex p M [1989] QB 619............................................................................................................................... 700 R v North and East Devon Area Health Authority, ex p Coughlan [2001] QB 213........................................................................................ 361, 679, 704, 707–10, 722 R v North Derbyshire Health Authority, ex p Fisher (1997) 10 Admin LR 27........... 504
�xxxiv
Table of Cases R v North West Lancashire Health Authority, ex p A [2000] 1 WLR 977................... 680 R v Paddington Valuation Office, ex p Peachey Property Corpn [1966] 1 QB 380....................................................................................................................... 712, 713 R v Panel on Takeovers and Mergers, ex p Datafin plc [1987] QB 815................ 510, 710 R v Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, ex p Balchin [1996] EWHC Admin 152.............................................................................................. 630 R v Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, ex p Balchin (No 2) [1999] EWHC Admin 484, (1999) 2 LGLR 87............................................................ 631 R v Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, ex p Dyer [1994] 1 WLR 621........................................................................................................................... 631 R v Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, ex p Al Fayed [1998] 1 WLR 669................................................................................... 155 R v Parole Board, ex p Wilson [1992] QB 740................................................................. 438 R v Police Complaints Board, ex p Madden [1983] 1 WLR 447............................ 504, 506 R v Ponting [1985] Crim LR 318.......................................................................................... 13 R v Post Office, ex p Association of Scientific, Technical and Managerial Staffs [1981] 1 All ER 139.......................................................................... 476 R v R (Rape: Marital Exemption) [1992] 1 AC 599................................................. 138, 139 R v Radio Authority, ex p Bull [1998] QB 294................................................................. 438 R v Samuel [1988] QB 615.................................................................................................. 746 R v Secretary of State for Defence, ex p Sancto (1992) 5 Admin LR 673..................... 558 R v Secretary of State for Education and Employment, ex p Begbie [2000] 1 WLR 1115................................................................................................................. 171, 682 R v Secretary of State for Employment, ex p Equal Opportunities Commission [1995] 1 AC 1.................................................................................... 351, 713 R v Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, ex p World Development Movement [1995] 1 WLR 386................................................................................ 670, 713 R v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex p Everett [1989] QB 811............................................................................. 492, 499, 719 R v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex p Indian Association of Alberta [1982] QB 892..................................................... 368 R v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex p Quark Fishing Ltd [2005] UKHL 57, [2006] 1 AC 529................................ 66, 368 R v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex p Rees-Mogg [1994] QB 552..................................................................................... 712 R v Secretary of State for Health, ex p British American Tobacco, Case C-491/01 [2002] ECR I-11453.............................................................................. 297 R v Secretary of State for Health, ex p Imperial Tobacco Ltd [2001] 1 WLR 127........................................................................................................................... 308 R v Secretary of State for Health, ex p Pfizer Ltd [1999] Lloyd’s Rep Med 289........... 508 R v Secretary of State for Health, ex p United States Tobacco International [1992] QB 353.......................................................................................... 477 R v Secretary of State for Social Services, ex p Association of Metropolitan Authorities [1986] 1 WLR 1........................................................................................... 476 R v Secretary of State for Social Services, ex p Camden LBC [1987] 1 WLR 819........ 481 R v Secretary of State for Social Services, ex p Stitt (1999) 3 Admin LR 169............... 505 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Greenwich LBC [1989] COD 530........................................................................................................................... 508
�xxxv
Table of Cases R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Hammersmith and Fulham London Borough Council [1991] 1 AC 521.................................... 61, 681, 682 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Kirkstall Valley Campaign [1996] 3 All ER 304....................................................................................... 696 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Lancashire County Council [1994] 4 All ER 165........................................................................................... 504 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Ostler [1977] QB 122....................... 715 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Rose Theatre Trust Co [1990] 1 QB 504............................................................................................................... 713 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, ex p Spath Holme Ltd [2001] 2 AC 349........................................................ 124, 466, 642 R v Secretary of State for the Environment, ex p Tower Hamlets LBC [1993] QB 632............................................................................................................................... 504 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Abdi [1996] 1 WLR 298........ 747 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Akhtar [1981] 1 QB 46.............. 8 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Bentley [1994] QB 349.......... 719 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Brind [1991] 1 AC 696................................................................. 284–6, 678, 683, 686, 798, 799 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Cheblak [1991] 1 WLR 890................................................................................... 704, 776, 777, 789 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Choudhary [1978] 1 WLR 1177.............................................................................................................. 8 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Doody [1994] 1 AC 531............................................................................................... 119, 486, 703 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Fayed [1998] 1 WLR 763............................................................................................................ 714 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Fire Brigades Union [1995] 2 AC 513.......................... 135, 158, 464, 494, 676, 721 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Hargreaves [1997] 1 WLR 906............................................................... 360, 707, 708 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Hosenball [1977] 1 WLR 766................................................ 501, 704, 775, 776, 789 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Khan [1984] 1 WLR 1337....................................................................................... 502 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Leech (No 2) [1994] QB 198.................................................................. 174, 745, 746 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Northumbria Police Authority [1989] QB 26.................................................. 494–5 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Oladehinde [1991] 1 AC 254.................................................................................. 486 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Phansopkar [1976] QB 606.................................................................................... 164 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Pierson [1998] AC 539..................................................... 119–21, 175, 354, 502, 699 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Simms [2000] 2 AC 115.................. 81, 167, 169, 174, 282, 354, 745, 749, 790, 798 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Stafford [1999] 2 AC 38.......................................................................................... 132
�xxxvi
Table of Cases R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Swati [1986] 1 WLR 477......................................................................................... 747 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Venables [1998] AC 407................................................................................. 121, 131 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Yousaf [2000] 3 All ER 649......................................................................................................................... 121 R v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, ex p Lonrho plc [1989] 1 WLR 525........................................................................................................................... 673 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (1989) 2 CMLR 353......................................................................................................................... 348 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd [1990] 2 AC 85................................................................................ 113, 115, 348, 376, 725 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd, Case C-213/89 [1990] ECR 1-2433................................................................ 349, 350, 725 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (No 2) [1991] 1 AC 603.......................................................................................... 91, 349–55, 725 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (No 3), Case C-48/93 [1996] ECR I-1029.................................................................................. 324 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (No 3), Case C-221/89 [1992] QB 680........................................................................................ 351 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (No 5) [2000] 1 AC 524....................................................................................................................... 325, 351 R v Shayler [2002] UKHL 11, [2003] 1 AC 247............................................... 557, 558, 803 R v Sheer Metalcraft Ltd [1954] 1 QB 586........................................................................ 479 R v Somerset County Council, ex p Fewings [1995] 1 All ER 513, [1995] 1 WLR 1037......................................................................................................................... 102 R v Tower Hamlets LBC, ex p Chetnik Developments Ltd [1988] AC 858................. 671 R v Tronoh Mines Ltd [1952] 1 All ER 697...................................................................... 526 R v Wandsworth LBC, ex p Beckwith [1996] 1 WLR 60................................................ 506 R v Z [2005] UKHL 35, [2005] 2 AC 645.......................................................................... 750 R (A) v Lord Saville of Newdigate [2001] EWCA Civ 2048, [2002] 1 WLR 1249......................................................................................................................... 758 R (Alconbury) v Secretary of State for the Environment [2001] UKHL 23, [2003] 2 AC 295.......................................... 135, 496, 690, 693, 697, 698, 702 R (Al Jedda) v Secretary of State for Defence [2007] UKHL 58, [2008] 1 AC 332............................................................................................................... 788 R (Ali Zaki Mousa) v Secretary of State for Defence [2010] EWHC 3304 (Admin)............................................................................................. 107, 758 R (Al-Sweady) v Secretary of State for Defence [2009] EWHC 2387 (Admin), [2010] HRLR 2................................................................ 104, 375 R (Amin) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] UKHL 51, [2004] 1 AC 653............................................................................................ 758 R (Anderson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] UKHL 46, [2003] 1 AC 837..................................................................... 82–4, 132–4, 136 R (Animal Defenders International) v Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport [2008] UKHL 15, [2008] 1 AC 1312.............. 533, 693, 767, 791, 810 R (Anufrijeva) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] UKHL 36, [2004] 1 AC 604............................................................................................ 124
�xxxvii
Table of Cases R (Asif Javed) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] QB 129............................................................................................................................... 681 R (Association of British Civilian Internees Far East Region) v Secretary of State for Defence [2003] QB 1397............................................................................. 690 R (Axon) v Secretary of State for Health [2006] EWHC 37 (Admin), [2006] QB 539................................................................................................................... 508 R (Bancoult) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2001] QB 1067...................................................................................... 66, 164, 169 R (Bancoult) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (No 2) [2008] UKHL 61, [2009] 1 AC 453............................................ 59, 66, 81, 165, 168–70, 485, 709, 720, 722, 751, 789 R (Bapio Action Limited) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] UKHL 27, [2008] 1 AC 1003..................... 368, 504, 709 R (Begum) v Headteacher and Governors of Denbigh High School [2006] UKHL 15, [2007] 1 AC 100............................. 690, 691, 839 R (Bhatt Murphy) v Independent Assessor [2008] EWCA Civ 755..................... 502, 710 R (Binyam Mohamed) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (No 1) [2008] EWHC 2048 (Admin), [2009] 1 WLR 2579........................... 106 R (Binyam Mohamed) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (No 4) [2009] EWHC 152 (Admin), [2009] 1 WLR 2653..................... 106, 374 R (Binyam Mohamed) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (No 5) [2009] EWHC 2549 (Admin), [2009] 1 WLR 2653........................... 106 R (Binyam Mohamed) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2010] EWCA Civ 65, [2011] QB 218............................. 106, 373, 375, 558, 693 R (Binyam Mohamed) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2010] EWCA Civ 158, [2010] 3 WLR 554...................................................... 106 R (Boyle) v Haverhill Pub Watch [2009] EWHC 2441 (Admin).................................. 711 R (Bradley) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2008] EWCA Civ 36, [2009] QB 114................................................................................................................... 633 R (Breckland DC) v Boundary Committee [2009] EWCA Civ 239.............................. 704 R (Brooke) v Parole Board [2008] EWCA Civ 29, [2008] 3 All ER 289....................... 438 R (Bulger) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] 3 All ER 449......... 713 R (C) v Secretary of State for Justice [2008] EWCA Civ 882, [2009] QB 657....................................................................................................................... 477, 478 R (Cala Homes) v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2010] EWHC 2866 (Admin)....................................................... 673 R (Cala Homes) v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2011] EWCA Civ 639................................................................... 674 R (Cart) v Upper Tribunal [2009] EWHC 3052 (Admin); [2010] EWCA Civ 859......................................................................................................... 711, 714 R (Corner House Research) v Director of the Serious Fraud Office [2008] EWHC 714 (Admin); [2008] UKHL 60, [2009] 1 AC 756, [2008] 4 All ER 927........................................................... 16, 110, 391, 674, 675, 722, 788 R (Countryside Alliance) v Attorney General [2007] UKHL 52, [2008] 1 AC 719....................................................................................................................... 308, 693 R (Crompton) v Wiltshire Primary Care Trust [2009] EWHC 1824 (Admin)........... 705 R (Daly) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] UKHL 26, [2001] 2 AC 532................................................................................ 282, 360, 687–90, 722
�xxxviii
Table of Cases R (Eisai) v National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence [2008] EWCA Civ 438................................................................................................................. 704 R (Equitable Members Action Group) v HM Treasury [2009] EWHC 2495 (Admin)..................................................................................................... 634 R (Evans) v Secretary of State for Defence [2010] EWHC 1445 (Admin)................... 107 R (F and Thompson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2010] UKSC 17, [2010] 2 WLR 992............................................................................. 148 R (Farrakhan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] EWCA Civ 606, [2002] QB 1391................................................................... 693–5 R (Gillan) v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [2006] UKHL 12, [2006] 2 AC 307.............................................................................. 81, 122, 788 R (Greenfield) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] 1 WLR 673............................................................................................................ 765 R (Greenpeace) v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [2007] EWHC 311 (Admin), [2007] Env LR 29.................................................. 704, 705 R (Hammond) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] UKHL 69, [2006] 1 AC 603................................................................................ 134 R (Hasan) v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [2008] EWCA Civ 1312, [2009] 3 All ER 539........................................................................... 703 R (Haw) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] EWCA Civ 532, [2006] QB 780..................................................................................... 750 R (Hooper) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2005] UKHL 29, 1 WLR 1681........................................................................................... 492, 762 R (Karas) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] EWHC 747 (Admin)....................................................................................................... 104 R (Kay) v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [2008] UKHL 69, [2008] 1 WLR 2723.......................................................................................................... 834 R (Kehoe) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2005] UKHL 48, [2006] 1 AC 42.............................................................................................. 135 R (Laporte) v Chief Constable of Gloucestershire [2006] UKHL 55, [2007] 2 AC 105....................................................................... 798, 823–7, 839 R (Lewis) v Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council [2008] EWCA Civ 746, [2009] 1 WLR 83................................................................................. 696 R (Limbuela) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] UKHL 66, [2006] 1 AC 396...................................................................................... 758–61 R (Middleton) v West Somerset Coroner [2004] UKHL 10, [2004] 2 AC 182............................................................................................................................... 758 R (Morgan Grenfell & Co Ltd) v Special Commissioner of Income Tax [2002] UKHL 21, [2003] 1 AC 563.......................................................... 750 R (Moos and McClure) v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [2011] EWHC 957 (Admin)....................................................................................................... 831 R (Niazi) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] EWCA Civ 755................................................................................................................. 710 R (Noone) v Governor of HMP Drake Hall [2010] UKSC 30, [2010] 1 WLR 1743......................................................................................................................... 124 R (Pretty) v DPP [2001] UKHL 61, [2002] 1 AC 800...................................................... 757 R (Prolife Alliance) v BBC [2003] UKHL 23, [2004] 1 AC 185.............. 533, 692, 805–10
�xxxix
Table of Cases R (Purdy) v Director of Public Prosecutions [2009] UKHL 45, [2010] 1 AC 345............................................................................................................................... 122 R (Q) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] EWCA Civ 364, [2004] QB 36.............................................................. 148, 757, 760, 761 R (Raissi) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] EWCA Civ 72, [2008] QB 836....................................................................................... 502 R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Primary Care Trust [2006] EWCA Civ 392, [2006] 1 WLR 2649..................................................................... 679, 680 R (Rusbridger) v Attorney General [2003] UKHL 38, [2004] 1 AC 357............................................................................................................................... 804 R (Sainsbury’s) v Wolverhampton City Council [2010] UKSC 20, [2010] 2 WLR 1173.......................................................................................................... 675 R (SB) v Headteacher and Governors of Denbigh High School, See R (Begum) v Headteacher and Governors of Denbigh High School R (Shrewsbury & Atcham BC) v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2008] EWCA Civ 148, [2008] 3 All ER 548...................... 103, 492 R (Singh) v Chief Constable of West Midlands Police [2006] EWCA Civ 1118, [2006] 1 WLR 3374........................................................................... 841 R (Southall) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2003] EWCA Civ 1002...................................................................................... 198 R (St Helens BC) v Manchester PCT [2008] EWCA Civ 931........................................ 663 R (Synthon) v Licensing Authority of the Department of Health, Case C-452/06 [2008] ECR I-7681................................................................................ 325 R (T) v Secretary of State for the Home Department 7 CCLR 53................................. 761 R (Ullah) v Special Adjudicator [2004] UKHL 26, [2004] 2 AC 323........................................................................ 687, 688, 766, 767, 769–71 R (Wagstaff) v Secretary of State for Health [2001] 1 WLR 292.................................... 681 R (Weaver) v London and Quadrant Housing Trust [2009] EWCA Civ 587, [2010] 1 WLR 363............................................................................... 764 R (Wheeler) v Office of the Prime Minister [2008] EWHC 1409 (Admin)........................................................................ 154–6, 705, 713, 722 R (Woolas) v Parliamentary Election Court [2010] EWHC 3169 (Admin)............................................................................................. 523, 711 R (Wright) v Secretary of State for Health [2009] UKHL 3, [2009] 1 AC 739.............................................................................................................. 700–703, 738 R (Zardasht) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] EWHC 91 (Admin)......................................................................................................... 761 Rajput v Immigration Appeal Tribunal [1989] Imm AR 350........................................ 747 Rantzen v Mirror Group Newspapers [1994] QB 670.................................................... 284 Rape Crisis Centre v Secretary of State for the Home Department 2000 SC 527................................................................................................................................ 714 Ratti, 148/78 [1979] ECR 1629 See Publico Ministero v Ratti, Case Raymond v Honey [1983] 1 AC 1...................................................................................... 174 RB (Algeria) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2009] UKHL 10, [2010] 2 AC 110............................................................................................ 788 Rederiaktiebolaget Amphitrite v the King [1921] 3 KB 500...................................... 726–7 Redmond-Bate v DPP [2000] HRLR 249......................................... 173, 752, 821, 822, 833
�xl
Table of Cases Reference re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada (1981) 125 DLR (3d) 1........................................................................................................ 199, 205, 206 Reyners v Belgium, Case 2/74 [1974] ECR 631................................................................ 320 Reynolds v Times Newspapers Ltd [2001] 2 AC 127...................................................... 793 Rice v Connolly [1966] 2 QB 414....................................................................................... 746 Ridge v Baldwin [1964] AC 40........................................................................................... 700 Roberts v Parole Board [2005] UKHL 45, [2005] 2 AC 738........................................... 767 Robertson v Minister of Pensions [1949] 1 KB 227................................................ 368, 726 Robinson v Secretary of State for Northern Ireland [2002] UKHL 32...................................................................................................... 88–91, 167, 354 Rogers v Home Secretary [1973] AC 388......................................................................... 373 Rookes v Barnard [1964] AC 1129.................................................................................... 736 Rothwell v Chemical and Insulating Co Ltd [2007] UKHL 39, [2008] 1 AC 281............................................................................................................................... 236 Royal College of Nursing of the United Kingdom v Department of Health and Social Security [1981] AC 800................................................................... 507 Royster v Cavey [1947] KB 204.......................................................................................... 727 Russell, Re Earl [1901] AC 446............................................................................................. 70 Rutili, Case 36/75 [1975] ECR 1219.................................................................................. 326 S, Re [2002] 2 AC 291........................................................................................................ 82–4 Saadi v Italy (2009) 49 EHRR 30........................................................................................ 780 Salih v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] EWHC 2273 (Admin)..................................................................................................... 123 Salomon v Customs and Excise Comrs [1967] 2 QB 116............................................... 284 Sanders v Chichester [1995] 03 LS Gaz R 37.................................................................... 533 S and Marper v United Kingdom (2009) 48 EHRR 50........................................... 283, 473 Saunders v United Kingdom (1996) 23 EHRR 313......................................................... 746 Savage v South Essex Partnership NHS Trust [2008] UKHL 74, [2009] 1 AC 681............................................................................................................................... 758 S-C (Mental Patient: Habeas Corpus), Re [1996] QB 599.............................................. 164 Schmidt v Secretary of State for Home Affairs [1969] 2 Ch 149................................... 705 Scottish National Party, Petitioners [2010] CSOH 56............................................ 532, 533 Scottish Old People’s Welfare Council, Petitioner 1987 SLT 179................................. 714 Secretary of State for Defence v Guardian Newspapers Ltd [1985] AC 339........ 744, 801 Secretary of State for Education and Science v Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council [1977] AC 1014................................................................................. 276 Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs v Downs [2009] EWCA Civ 664................................................................................................................. 455 Secretary of State for the Home Department v AF [2009] UKHL 28, [2009] 3 WLR 74, [2010] 2 AC 269................................ 86, 110, 704, 767, 768, 770, 785 Secretary of State for the Home Department v AP [2010] UKSC 24, [2010] 3 WLR 51........................................................................................................ 86, 786 Secretary of State for the Home Department v JJ [2007] UKHL 45, [2008] 1 AC 385........................................................................................... 85, 86, 787, 787 Secretary of State for the Home Department v MB [2007] UKHL 46, [2008] 1 AC 440.......................................................................... 85, 86, 767, 768, 785, 788
�xli
Table of Cases Secretary of State for the Home Department v Pankina [2010] EWCA Civ 719, [2010] 3 WLR 1526.............................................. 170–72, 468, 497, 501 Secretary of State for the Home Department v Rehman [2001] UKHL 47, [2003] 1 AC 153............................................................. 15, 777, 778, 781, 783 Shaw v DPP [1962] AC 220................................................................................................ 138 Silver v United Kingdom (1983) 5 EHRR 347................................................................. 826 Siskina, The [1979] AC 210................................................................................................. 343 Smith v Chief Constable of Sussex [2008] UKHL 50, [2009] 1 AC 225....... 735, 736, 739 Smith v Donnelly 2001 SLT 1007....................................................................................... 823 Smith v Smith [2004] EWCA Civ 1318, [2005] 1 WLR 1318........................................ 465 Smith and Grady v United Kingdom (1999) 29 EHRR 493............................... 685–7, 689 Somersett v Stuart (1772) 20 St Tr 1.................................................................................. 783 Somerville v Scottish Ministers [2006] CSIH 52, 2007 SC 140...................................... 690 Sporrong v Sweden (1982) 5 EHRR 35............................................................................. 757 Stafford v United Kingdom (2002) 35 EHRR 32..................................................... 132, 133 Starrs v Ruxton 2000 SLT 42.............................................................................................. 144 Steel v United Kingdom (1998) 28 EHRR 603................................................................. 824 Stewart v Henry 1989 SLT (Sh Ct) 34................................................................................ 227 Stoke-on-Trent City Council v B & Q plc [1991] Ch 48................................................. 356 Stovin v Wise [1996] AC 923.............................................................................................. 732 Sunday Times v United Kingdom (1979) 2 EHRR 245......... 124, 282, 282, 757, 797, 800 Sunday Times v United Kingdom (No 2) (1991) 14 EHRR 229.......................................................................................................................... 282 T, Petitioner 1997 SLT 724................................................................................................. 284 Tamlin v Hannaford [1950] 1 KB 18................................................................................. 376 Tariq v Home Office [2010] EWCA Civ 462, [2010] ICR 1034..................................... 767 Taylor v New Zealand Poultry Board [1984] 1 NZLR 394............................................... 87 Tesco Stores Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment [1995] 1 WLR 759........... 676 Terry (Previously ‘LNS) v Persons Unknown [2010] EWHC 119 (QB), [2010] EMLR 16............................................................................................................... 815 Thoburn v Sunderland City Council [2002] EWHC 195, [2003] QB 151.................................................................................. 80, 91, 166, 167, 336, 353, 745 Thomas v Sawkins [1935] 2 KB 249................................................................... 173, 823, 824 Three Rivers District Council v Bank of England (No 3) [2003] 2 AC 1...................... 736 Tovey v Ministry of Justice [2011] EWHC 271 (QB)...................................................... 283 Town Investments Ltd v Department of the Environment [1978] AC 359..................................................................... 115, 366–8, 387 Traghetti del Mediterraneo v Italy, Case 173/03 [2006] ECR I-5177........................... 325 Trawnik v Lennox [1985] 1 WLR 532............................................................................... 728 TV Vest v Norway (2009) 48 EHRR 51............................................................................. 533 University of Oxford v Broughton [2006] EWCA Civ 1305.......................................... 842 UPA v Council, Case C-50/00 P [2002] ECR I-6677....................................................... 306 Van Colle v Chief Constable of Hertfordshire [2008] UKHL 50, [2009] 1 AC 225.......................................................................................... 735–7, 739, 758
�xlii
Table of Cases V and T v United Kingdom (1999) 30 EHRR 121................................................... 131, 759 Van Duyn v Home Office, Case 41/74 [1974] ECR 1337............................... 320, 321, 345 Van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratie der Belastingen, Case 26/62 [1963] ECR 1................................................................... 79, 318–20, 323, 328 Vauxhall Estates Ltd v Liverpool Corpn [1932] 1 KB 733................................................ 78 Venables v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2001] Fam 430..................... 758, 766, 811–13 Von Colson and Kamann v Land-Nordrhein-Westfalen, Case 14/83 [1984] ECR 1891..................................................................... 296, 322, 356–8 Waddington v Miah [1974] 1 WLR 683............................................................ 123, 284, 750 Walumba Lumba v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2011] UKSC 12............................................................................................... 124, 497, 500 Ward v James [1966] 1 QB 273.............................................................................................. 7 Watkins v Home Office [2006] UKHL 17, [2006] 2 AC 395.......................... 737, 745, 746 Watkins v Woolas [2010] EWHC 2702 (QB).................................................................. 523 Watt v Lord Advocate 1977 SLT 130, 1979 SLT 137....................................................... 669 Webb v EMO Air Cargo [1993] 1 WLR 49....................................................................... 359 Webb v EMO Air Cargo, Case C-32/93 [1994] ECR I-3567.......................................... 359 Webb v EMO Air Cargo (No 2) [1995] 1 WLR 1454...................................................... 359 Welch v United Kingdom (1995) 20 EHRR 247.............................................................. 123 West v Secretary of State for Scotland 1992 SC 385........................................................ 710 Westminster Bank v Minister of Housing and Local Government [1971] AC 508.................................................................................................................. 664 Whaley v Watson 2000 SC 340.......................................................................... 234, 235, 238 Wheeler v Leicester City Council [1985] AC 1054.................................................. 671, 797 WH Smith Do-It-All v Peterborough City Council [1991] 1 QB 304.......................... 343 Wicks v Firth [1983] 2 AC 214........................................................................................... 506 Williams v Home Office (No 2) [1981] 1 All ER 1211.................................................... 163 Wilson v First County Trust [2003] UKHL 40, [2004] 1 AC 816................................. 466 Wilson v Independent Broadcasting Authority 1979 SC 351........................................ 533 Wilson v Independent Broadcasting Authority (No 2) 1988 SLT 276......................... 533 Wilson v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [2003] UKHL 40, [2004] 1 AC 816............................................................................................................... 135 Wise v Dunning [1902] 1 KB 167...................................................................... 819, 821, 822 Wiseman v Borneman [1971] AC 297.............................................................................. 175 Woolwich Equitable Building Society v IRC [1993] AC 70............................ 137, 729–30 Wynne v United Kingdom (1994) 19 EHRR 333.................................................... 132, 133 X v Bedfordshire County Council [1995] 2 AC 633.................................................... 732–5 X Ltd v Morgan-Grampian Ltd [1991] 1 AC 1................................................ 154, 802, 803 Yarl’s Wood Immigration Ltd v Bedfordshire Police Authority [2008] EWHC 2207 (Comm)..................................................................................................... 467 YL v Birmingham City Council [2007] UKHL 27, [2008] 1 AC 95.............................. 764 Z v United Kingdom (2002) 34 EHRR 3........................................................................... 734 Zalewska v Department for Social Development [2008] UKHL 67, [2008] 1 WLR 2602.......................................................................................................... 360 Zamir v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1980] AC 930............................. 8
Table of Statutes
Abortion Act 1967......................... 507, 553 s 1........................................................ 507 Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act 1919.......... 77 s 7(1)..................................................... 77 Act of Settlement 1701. 36, 74, 142–4, 162 Act of Union 1536................................. 245 Act of Union (Ireland) Act 1800......... 253 Adoption Act 1976 s 56...................................................... 498 Agricultural Marketing Act 1958........ 672 Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986......................................... 119 s 5........................................................ 119 Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003 s 30...................................................... 841 Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004...................... 841 Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001....... 7, 27, 287, 462, 771, 772, 782–4 Part 4 (ss 21–36)...... 772, 779, 780, 783, 784 s 23........................................................... 7 s 122.................................................... 783 Appellate Jurisdiction Act 1876.......... 150 Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc) Act 2004...................... 27, 87, 716 Australia Act 1986 s 1.......................................................... 71 Autism Act 2009............................ 553, 603
Bail, Judicial Appointments etc (Scotland) Act 2000...................... 144 Bank of England Act 1998.................... 625 Bill of Rights 1689........... 5, 36, 74, 162–6, 354, 814 art 9.............. 64, 154, 163, 164, 800, 814 Boundary Commission Act 1992........ 521 Bribery Act 2010.................................... 626 British Nationality Act 1981................ 221 s 6(1)................................................... 497 s 44(2)................................................. 714 Sch 1.................................................... 497 British North America Act 1867................. 199, 200 British North America (No 2) Act 1949............ 200 British Railways Act 1968................. 63, 64 s 18.................................................. 63, 64 Broadcasting Act 1981 s 29(3)................................................. 799 Broadcasting Act 1990.......................... 531 s 6(1)(a).............................................. 805 Building Act 1984 s 14(3)................................................. 476 Canada Act 1982............................... 68–71 s 2.......................................................... 71 Caravan Sites Act 1968......................... 465 Care Standards Act 2000.............. 701, 703 Charities Act 2006................................. 511 Children and Young Persons Act 1933 s 25(1)................................................. 498 Child Support Act 1991........ 463, 465, 472
�xliv
BritishofGovernment Table Statutes and the Constitution: Text and Materials City of Bombay Municipal Act 1888......................................... 370 Civil Authorities (Special Powers) Act (Northern Ireland) 1922....... 255 Civil Aviation Act 1971........................ 503 s 3........................................................ 503 s 3(2)................................................... 503 Civil Contingencies Act 2004.......... 27, 463, 473, 496, 749 Coal Industry Nationalisation Act 1946 s 46(1)................................................. 706 Colonial Laws Validity Act 1865..... 75, 76 Commissioner for Older People (Wales) Act 2006.......................... 250 Commonwealth Immigrants Act 1962......................................... 600 Communications Act 2003......................... 530, 531, 533 ss 319–21............................................ 532 Community Care and Health Act 2002......................................... 467 Companies Act 2006............................. 510 Constitutional Reform Act 2005....... 26, 27, 141–3, 146, 151, 161, 392 s 1.......................................................... 97 s 3........................................................ 388 s 3(1), (5), (6)..................................... 143 s 4........................................................ 144 s 5(1)................................................... 144 ss 10, 11, 17........................................ 144 s 33...................................................... 142 s 63...................................................... 147 ss 63–107............................................ 146 s 64...................................................... 147 s 108(2)–(7)........................................ 145 ss 108–21............................................ 144 s 115.................................................... 144 s 133.................................................... 142 Sch 12.................................................. 147 Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010...... 27–30, 161, 168, 186, 196, 439, 441, 447, 448, 458, 483, 489, 541, 587, 640 Part 1 (ss 1–19) s 1(2)................................................... 483 s 3........................................................ 440
s 3(4)................................................... 483 s 3(6)................................................... 440 s 5(1)................................................... 441 s 5(2), (3)............................................ 442 s 6........................................................ 442 s 6(6), (7)............................................ 442 s 7(4)............................................... 4, 442 s 7(5)................................................... 447 s 8(1), (5), (8)..................................... 447 s 9........................................................ 443 s 10(2)................................................. 440 s 16...................................................... 448 Part 2 (ss 20–25)........................ 196, 490 Consumer Protection Act 1987 s 10...................................................... 477 s 11(5)................................................. 477 Contempt of Court Act 1981...... 282, 283, 800, 801 s 2........................................................ 800 s 2(2)................................... 282, 797, 800 s 5................................................ 800, 801 s 10..................................... 744, 801–803 Continental Shelf Act 1964.................... 70 Copyright (Visually Impaired Persons) Act 2002....... 553 Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007... 376 s 11(1)................................................. 376 Sch 1.................................................... 376 Corrupt and Illegal Practices Prevention Act 1883..................... 524 Counter-terrorism Act 2008................ 462 Countryside Act 1968 s 11...................................................... 488 Crime and Disorder Act 1998....... 27, 749 Crime and Security Act 2010............... 283 ss 14–16.............................................. 473 Crimes (Sentences) Act 1997 s 29...................................................... 132 Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act 2008.................. 769 Criminal Justice Act 1988........ 7, 158, 494 Criminal Justice Act 1991.................... 282 s 35...................................................... 119 s 35(2)......................................... 120, 121 Criminal Justice Act 2003............ 7, 119, 134, 465, 769
�xlv
Table Abbreviations of Statutes Criminal Justice and Courts Services Act 2000 s 60...................................................... 131 Criminal Justice and Police Act 2001. 287 s 42...................................................... 842 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994......... 7, 161, 749, 835 ss 34–9................................................ 746 ss 68, 70.............................................. 835 s 80...................................................... 465 Criminal Justice (Terrorism and Conspiracy) Act 1998........... 462 Criminal Proceedings etc (Reform) (Scotland) Act 2007 s 45...................................................... 238 Crown Proceedings Act 1947... 5, 112, 114, 115, 117, 161, 723, 724, 728 s 1........................................................ 725 s 2(1)................................................... 728 s 2(1)(a).............................................. 728 s 2(2), (6)............................................ 728 s 10.............................................. 134, 377 s 13...................................................... 724 s 17...................................................... 114 s 21..................... 113, 114, 376, 724, 725 s 21(1)................................................. 724 s 21(2)................................. 114, 348, 725 s 25...................................................... 724 s 38(2)................................................. 728 s 40(2)(b)............................................ 728 s 40(3)................................................. 728 s 40(2)(f)............................................. 369 Crown Proceedings (Armed Forces) Act 1987................... 134, 377 Crown Suits (Scotland) Act 1857........ 724 Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) (Scotland) Act 2009.............. 236, 237 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991............... 465–6 Data Protection Act 1998..... 342, 563, 748 Defamation Act 1996 s 13...................................................... 163 Sch 1.................................................... 814 Defence Act 1842.......................... 493, 494 Defence of the Realm Act 1914 s 1........................................................ 773
Deregulation and Contracting Out Act 1994........................................ 129, 473 Part 2................................................... 512 s 69...................................................... 677 s 72...................................................... 631 Disability Discrimination Act 1995................................. 553, 603 Drug Trafficking Offences Act 1986... 123 Education Act 1980 s 8........................................................ 506 Education Act 1996 s 548.................................................... 653 Education Act 2002............................... 249 Education (No 2) Act 1986.................. 282 s 47...................................................... 653 Education Reform Act 1988................ 463 Electoral Administration Act 2006................................. 529, 533 Electoral Registration Act 2006........... 520 Electronic Communications Act 2000 Part 1................................................... 511 Emergency Powers (Defence) Act 1939 s 1........................................................ 774 s 1(2)................................................... 774 Employment Act 1980.......................... 467 s 17...................................................... 468 s 17(6)................................................. 468 Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978............ 351 Employment Rights Act 1996.............. 371 s 191............................................ 371, 440 Enterprise Act 2002............................... 287 s 8........................................................ 510 Environment Act 1995 s 4........................................................ 505 Environmental Protection Act 1990 s 159.................................................... 372 s 159(2)............................................... 373 Environment and Safety Information Act 1988.................. 553 Equality Act 2006.................................. 287 Equality Act 2010... 40, 287, 373, 440, 748 Equal Pay Act 1970..... 342, 344, 345, 346, 357, 358, 748 s 1........................................................ 344 s 1(2)(a)(i).......................................... 346
�xlvi
BritishofGovernment Table Statutes and the Constitution: Text and Materials Equitable Life (Payments) Act 2010... 634 European Communities Act 1972... 5, 35, 79, 80, 86, 129, 161, 166, 170, 263, 336, 339–44, 347, 350, 352, 354, 355, 358 s 2........................................................ 339 s 2(1). 225, 226, 340, 341, 344, 345, 347 s 2(2)................................... 166, 342, 354 s 2(4)..... 341–5, 347, 352, 354, 357, 358 s 3........................................................ 340 s 3(1)........................................... 340, 341 ss 4–12................................................ 340 s 9(1)................................................... 340 Sch 2.................................................... 342 para 2(2)................................................. 482 European Communities (Amendment) Act 1986............... 336 European Communities (Amendment) Act 1993............... 336 European Communities (Amendment) Act 1998............... 336 European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002............... 336 European Parliamentary Elections Act 1999.......... 65, 302, 303, 543, 651 European Parliamentary Elections Act 2002................................. 303, 543 European Union (Amendment) Act 2008................................. 154, 336 s 2(1)................................................... 340 s 2(2)(a).............................................. 340 s 6................................................ 336, 337 Sch 1.................................................... 340 Export Control Act 2002...................... 480 Extradition Act 2003....................... 27, 287 Fair Employment (Northern Ireland) Act 1989.......................... 259 Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003......................................... 603 Finance Act 1964..................................... 61 Financial Services Act 1986................. 510 Financial Services and Markets Act 2000................................. 463, 510 Flags and Emblems (Display) Act (Northern Ireland) 1954.............. 259 Food Standards Act 1999..................... 553
Freedom of Information Act 2000..... 25, 29, 40, 186, 199, 500, 553, 560–65, 613, 622, 662, 748 s 2........................................................ 562 s 4................................................ 437, 560 s 5........................................................ 560 s 35(1)(c)............................................ 199 s 35(4)................................................. 562 s 53...................................................... 563 Sch 1............................................ 437, 560 Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002........ 40, 560, 748 Government of Ireland Act 1914................................... 91, 651 Government of Ireland Act 1920......................... 213, 254, 255 Government of Wales Act 1998. 25, 166, 219, 246, 247, 249, 250, 252 ss 1, 22................................................. 247 Sch 2.................................................... 247 Government of Wales Act 2006.......... 219, 220, 250–52, 271 s 5........................................................ 385 s 7........................................................ 250 ss 45–8................................................ 250 ss 46, 47.............................................. 382 ss 49, 56–8.......................................... 250 ss 80, 81.............................................. 252 s 93...................................................... 251 s 94.............................................. 251, 252 s 95.............................................. 170, 251 ss 96–98.............................................. 251 s 99.............................................. 251, 252 s 100.................................................... 251 s 101............................................ 251, 252 s 102.................................................... 251 ss 103, 104.................................. 252, 546 s 105–16.............................................. 252 Sch 5...................................... 170, 250–52 Sch 7.................................................... 252 Government Trading Funds Act 1973............................. 439 Greater London Authority Act 1999................................... 25, 270 s 384.................................................... 838
� xlvii
Abbreviations Table of Statutes Greater London Authority (Referendum) Act 1998......................................... 546 Green Energy (Definition and Promotion) Act 2009................... 603 Habeas Corpus Act 1679...................... 162 Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 Part I................................................... 372 s 48...................................................... 372 Health and Social Care Act 2008 s 145.................................................... 764 Health (Wales) Act 2003...................... 249 Highways Act 1980 s 137............................................ 832, 836 Honours (Prevention of Abuses) Act 1925......................................... 529 House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975 s 1(1)(b).............................................. 443 s 2(1)................................................... 392 House of Commons (Redistribution of Seats) Act 1979......................... 258 House of Lords Act 1999................... 25, 193, 194, 658 Housing Act 1925.................................... 77 Housing Act 1985 s 32...................................................... 670 Housing Act 1988.................................... 83 Housing Act 1996 s 182(1)............................................... 504 Housing (Scotland) Act 2001.............. 467 Human Rights Act 1998...... 25, 27, 31, 33, 40, 43, 47, 74, 81–3, 86, 92, 93, 101, 102, 129, 133, 134, 149, 161–3, 166, 174, 232, 263, 265, 281, 283–8, 308, 354, 377, 558, 681, 685, 687, 697, 699, 700, 708, 713, 722, 738, 743–6, 748, 749, 752, 757, 762–4, 770–3, 777, 778, 780, 789, 797, 799, 803, 804, 810 s 1................................................ 752, 780 s 1(1), (2)............................................ 779 s 2................................. 286, 687, 766–71 s 2(1)................................................... 687 s 3.................... 82–5, 285, 322, 356, 749, 766, 800, 787 s 3(1)..................................... 82, 285, 833
s 3(2)(c).............................................. 762 s 4............................. 82–5, 285, 749, 800 s 4(6)................................................... 762 s 4(6)(a)........................................ 82, 285 s 6........................................ 286, 438, 764 s 6(1). 757, 759, 761, 762, 763, 765, 799 s 6(2)........................................... 762, 808 s 6(2)(a), (b)....................................... 762 s 6(3)................................... 763, 764, 767 s 6(3)(a).............................................. 765 s 6(3)(b)...................................... 763, 764 s 6(5)................................................... 763 s 6(6)................................................... 757 s 7................................................ 764, 765 s 7(1)........................................... 713, 763 s 7(7)........................................... 763, 765 s 8................................................ 361, 765 s 10.............................................. 286, 482 s 12...................................................... 811 s 12(3), (4).......................................... 811 s 19.............................................. 286, 287 Sch 1............................................ 752, 756 Sch 2.................................................... 482 Hunting Act 2004............. 65, 66, 91, 308, 551, 651 Identity Cards Act 2006.......................... 33 Identity Documents Act 2010....... 33, 749 Immigration Act 1971...... 8, 164, 171, 500 s 3(2)........................................... 170, 500 s 3(5)................................................... 776 s 33(5)................................................. 494 Sch 2, para 16..................................... 744 Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 s 95...................................... 758, 760, 761 s 97(2)................................................. 488 Import, Export and Customs Powers (Defence) Act 1939......... 607 s 1........................................................ 480 Industrial Development Act 1982 s 1(3)................................................... 478 s 7........................................................ 487 Industrial Relations Act 1971.............. 465 Inquiries Act 2005................................. 103 s 10...................................................... 150 Intelligence Services Act 1994..... 161, 627 ss 5, 6................................................... 105
�xlviii
Table of Statutes s 6(1)................................................... 486 s 7........................................................ 105 Interception of Communications Act 1985......................... 102, 282, 499 s 5........................................................ 499 Interpretation Act 1978 s 5........................................................ 388 Sch 1.................................................... 388 Iran (Temporary Powers) Act 1980.... 607 Ireland Act 1949.................................... 254 Irish Church Act 1869.......................... 253 Irish Free State (Agreement) Act 1922......................................... 253 Irish Free State (Consequential Provisions) Act 1922.................... 253 Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922......................................... 253 Judiciary and Courts (Scotland) Act 2008......................................... 147 Justices of the Peace Act 1361.............. 823 Labour Exchanges Act 1909................. 451 Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998............ 511 Legal Aid Act 1988................................ 463 Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006................... 26, 130, 474, 643 ss 1, 2, 15, 18...................................... 483 Licensing Act 2003................................ 467 Life Peerages Act 1958.......................... 658 Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009......................................... 673 s 55(2)................................................. 376 s 79(6)................................................. 673 Local Governance (Scotland) Act 2004......................................... 271 Local Government Act 1888................ 268 Local Government Act 1894................ 268 Local Government Act 1972................ 268 s 111.................................................... 273 s 111(1)............................................... 731 s 135.................................................... 731 s 135(4)............................................... 731 Local Government Act 1974................ 274 Local Government Act 1985........ 269, 653
Local Government Act 1988 s 17...................................................... 731 s 28...................................................... 654 Local Government Act 1992................ 269 Local Government Act 1999................ 276 Local Government Act 2000.......................... 25, 270, 273, 544 s 2........................................................ 273 Local Government Act 2003................ 276 Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007......................................... 270 Local Government (Boundaries) (Northern Ireland) Act 2008....... 271 Local Government (Contracts) Act 1997......................................... 731 Local Government Finance Act 1988......................................... 465 Local Government (Northern Ireland) Act 1972......................................... 271 Local Government (Scotland) Act 1994......................................... 271 Local Government (Wales) Act 1994................................. 245, 271 London Government Act 1899........... 268 London Government Act 1963........... 268 Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 s 115.................................................... 823 Magna Carta............ 5, 36, 162, 164–6, 354 Chapter 29.......................................... 165 Marine and Coastal Access Act 2009......................................... 251 Matrimonial Causes Act 1973............... 82 Medicines Act 1968............................... 475 s 129(6)............................................... 475 Mental Health Act 1983....................... 282 ss 2, 3, 4............................................... 744 Merchant Shipping Act 1988................ 348, 349, 351, 352 Part II.......................................... 348, 349 Merchant Shipping (Registration etc) Act 1993 s 3........................................................ 351 Ministerial and other Salaries Act 1975................... 196, 392 s 1(1)(b).............................................. 595
xlix
Table  of Statutes s 2(1)–(3)............................................ 596 Sch 1.................................................... 416 Sch 2.................................................... 595 Ministers of the Crown Act 1975......................... 168, 387, 427 National Assistance Act 1948 s 21...................................................... 764 National Audit Act 1983...................... 649 ss 6, 7, 9............................................... 437 National Health Service Act 1977 s 2........................................................ 681 National Health Service (Amendment) Act 1986............... 603 National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990......... 272 s 60...................................................... 372 National Insurance Act 1911............... 451 Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 s 55.............................................. 758, 761 s 55(1)......................................... 760, 761 s 55(5)(a).................................... 759, 761 s 84(1)......................................... 171, 501 National Lottery etc Act 1993.............. 165 NHS Redress Act 2006 s 17...................................................... 250 NHS Reform and Healthcare Professions Act 2002.................... 249 Northern Ireland Act 1920.................. 221 Northern Ireland Act 1974.................. 257 Northern Ireland Act 1982.................. 257 Northern Ireland Act 1998............. 25, 88–90, 219, 220, 261–3, 265 s 1(1), (2)............................................ 254 s 3........................................................ 261 s 4(5)................................................... 263 s 5(6)................................................... 264 s 6(2)................................................... 263 ss 7, 8................................................... 263 s 9........................................................ 264 s 10.............................................. 263, 264 ss 11, 12.............................................. 264 ss 14, 15.............................................. 263 s 16.................................................. 88, 90 s 16(1), (3)............................................ 88
ss 18, 19.............................................. 264 s 28A................................................... 398 ss 29, 30.............................................. 264 s 32........................................................ 90 s 32(3)............................................. 88–90 ss 33, 34.............................................. 541 s 69(1)................................................. 265 s 85...................................................... 264 Schs 2, 3...................................... 262, 263 Schs 4, 10............................................ 264 Northern Ireland Assembly Act 1973......................................... 257 Northern Ireland (Border Poll) Act 1972................................. 256, 545 Northern Ireland Constitution Act 1973......................... 257, 262, 265 Northern Ireland (Elections) Act 1998................................. 261, 541 Northern Ireland (Entry to Negotiations, etc) Act 1996......... 259 s 4........................................................ 260 Northern Ireland (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2006.................... 264 Northern Ireland (Sentences) Act 1998......................................... 750 Northern Ireland (St Andrews Agreement) Act 2006................... 262 Northern Ireland (Temporary Provisions) Act 1972............ 214, 256 Nursery Education and Grant-Maintained Schools Act 1996......................................... 455 Obscene Publications Act 1959......................................... 800 Official Secrets Act 1911......................... 12 s 1.......................................................... 12 s 2................................................ 389, 557 s 2(1)..................................................... 13 Official Secrets Act 1989......... 35, 567, 603, 749, 751, 800, 803 s 1........................................................ 803 s 4(3)(a).............................................. 197 Old Age Pensions Act 1908................. 451 Overseas Development and Co-operation Act 1980................ 670
�l
Table of Statutes Parliament Act 1911.... 5, 65, 91, 161, 183, 452, 462, 651 s 2(1)............................................. 66, 520 s 7................................................ 384, 520 Parliament Act 1949............. 5, 65, 66, 91–4, 161, 462, 651 Parliamentary and Health Service Commissioner Act 1987 Sch 1.................................................... 438 Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967..................... 5, 161, 628, 629 s 5................................................ 631, 636 s 5(1)................................................... 629 s 10(3)............................................. 631–4 s 12(3)................................................. 629 Sch 2.................................................... 629 Sch 3.................................................... 631 Parliamentary Constituencies Act 1986......................................... 521 Sch 2 r 1(4)........................................................ 258 Parliamentary Papers Act 1840........... 814 s 3........................................................ 814 Parliamentary Standards Act 2009............................... 29, 30, 41 Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Act 2011....... 34, 245, 521, 522, 606, 655 Peerage Act 1963................................... 228 Planning Act 2008......................... 371, 372 s 226.................................................... 372 Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004........................ 371 Police Act 1964 s 4........................................................ 496 s 4(4)........................................... 494, 495 s 41...................................................... 495 Police Act 1996...................................... 161 Police Act 1997...................................... 161 Part 3 (ss 91–108).............................. 105 s 91(1)................................................. 408 Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984........................... 35, 161, 748 s 1........................................................ 122 s 28...................................................... 748 s 54...................................................... 173
s 58(1)................................................. 746 s 67(11)............................................... 505 Police Reform Act 2002.................. 57, 161 Political Parties and Elections Act 2009................................. 521, 527 s 21...................................................... 525 Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000...... 27, 526–9, 547, 545 Part II (ss 22–40)............................... 533 s 101(4)............................................... 156 s 104.................................................... 548 s 144.................................................... 531 Pollution Prevention and Control Act 1999.......................... 463 Post Office Act 1969.............................. 102 Prevention of Terrorism Act 1984................................. 281, 282 Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005....... 7, 27, 85, 462, 467, 772, 784, 786 s 1(4)................................................... 784 s 2(1)................................................... 784 ss 4, 5................................................... 744 Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1989.................... 222 Prison Act 1952..................... 163, 282, 798 Private Security Industry Act 2001..... 511 Protection from Abuse (Scotland) Act 2001...................... 467 Protection from Harassment Act 1997......................................... 842 Protection of Children Act 1978......... 553 Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002......................... 235, 236, 551 Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998......................... 444, 603, 800 Public Libraries and Museums Act 1964................................. 670, 671 s 7................................................ 670, 671 Public Order Act 1936.................. 161, 835 Public Order Act 1986. 35, 161, 749, 800, 833, 834, 841, 842 ss 1–5.................................................. 841 ss 11, 12...................................... 833, 834 s 13...................................... 819, 833, 834
li
Table  of Statutes s 14.............................................. 833, 834 s 14A........................................... 835, 836 Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998......................................... 840 s 2(1)(b).............................................. 840 s 11...................................................... 840 Public Services Ombudsman (Wales) Act 2005.................. 274, 635 Public Service Vehicles (Concessions) Act 1955............... 274 Race Relations Act 1965....................... 748 Race Relations Act 1968....................... 748 Referendum Act 1975........................... 545 Referendums (Scotland and Wales) Act 1997.................... 219, 546 Regional Development Agencies Act 1998.......................... 25 Registered Homes Act 1984 Part II.................................................. 737 Registration of Political Parties Act 1998......................................... 533 Regulation of Care Act 2001................ 467 Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000......... 27, 102, 282, 481, 499, 749 s 5........................................................ 499 s 7(1)................................................... 486 s 8(6)................................................... 486 Part 2 (ss 26–48)................................ 105 ss 28, 29.............................................. 481 s 30...................................................... 481 s 30(7)................................................. 481 s 57(1)................................................. 408 s 59(1)................................................. 408 s 65...................................................... 715 s 67(7)................................................. 715 s 67(8)................................................. 716 s 72...................................................... 505 Sch 1.................................................... 481 Regulatory Reform Act 2001......................... 129, 473, 474 Rent Act 1977........................................... 83 s 13...................................................... 371 Sch 1, para 2................................... 83, 84 Representation of the People Act 1832...... 50, 127, 166, 219, 256, 383, 748 Representation of the People Act 1867......................... 166, 571, 748
Representation of the People Act 1884........................... 50, 166, 748 Representation of the People Act 1918............................. 50, 51, 748 Representation of the People Act 1928............................. 50, 51, 748 Representation of the People Act 1948........................................... 51 Representation of the People Act 1949......................................... 526 Representation of the People Act 1983......................... 520, 525, 748 ss 73–76ZA......................................... 525 s 75.............................................. 525, 526 s 75(1)................................................. 531 s 93(1)................................................. 531 ss 106, 120, 123.................................. 523 Sch 1 rr 1, 3....................................................... 195 r 9(1)........................................................ 524 r 53(4)...................................................... 524 Representation of the People Act 1985................................. 520, 521 Representation of the People Act 2000......................................... 520 Restrictive Trade Practices Act 1976.. 510 Restrictive Trade Practices (Stock Exchange) Act 1984...................... 510 Royal Titles Act 1953............ 223, 224, 226 Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006........................... 701 School Standards and Framework Act 1998 s 92...................................................... 506 Scotland Act 1978.......................... 217, 221 Scotland Act 1998................. 25, 34, 59, 91, 93, 166, 220, 229–34, 238, 239, 241, 243, 247, 252, 262, 264, 271, 276, 285 s 3........................................................ 385 s 28(2)................................................. 233 s 28(7)........................................... 93, 241 s 29...................................... 231, 232, 237 s 29(1)......................................... 234, 236 s 29(2)................................................. 237 s 29(2)(d)............................................ 764 s 29(3)................................................. 211 s 30...................................................... 232 s 30(2)................................................. 170
�lii
Table of Statutes s 31(1), (2).......................................... 233 s 32(3)(a)............................................ 233 s 33...................................................... 233 s 35...................................................... 240 s 36...................................................... 233 s 36(4)................................................. 233 s 37...................................................... 229 s 40...................................................... 235 ss 45, 46.............................................. 382 s 53...................................................... 240 s 57(2)......................................... 240, 764 ss 58, 63.............................................. 240 s 86...................................................... 242 s 87...................................................... 241 s 95.............................................. 142, 232 s 99...................................................... 239 s 106.................................................... 240 s 107.................................................... 241 Sch 4 para 2(3)................................................. 238 Sch 5........................... 231, 232, 238, 240 para 4....................................................... 232 para 7(2)(b)............................................ 240 Scottish Parliament (Constituencies) Act 2004........... 230 Scottish Public Services Ombudsman Act 2002......... 274, 635 Security Service Act 1989..................... 161 Security Service Act 1996..................... 101 Senior Courts Act 1981 s 11(3)................................................. 142 s 31(3)................................................. 712 Separate Representation of Voters Act 1951 (South Africa)........... 75, 76 Septennial Act 1715.............................. 384 Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005........ 27, 749, 842 ss 125–7.............................................. 842 s 145.................................................... 842 Sex Discrimination Act 1975........ 344, 356, 357, 359, 748 s 8................................................ 344, 346 Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 2000........................... 65, 651, 654 Social Security Act 1986....................... 463 Social Security Act 1988....................... 505
South Africa Act 1909................. 75, 76, 77 s 35.................................................. 75, 76 s 35(1)............................................. 75, 76 s 152................................................ 75, 76 Southern Rhodesia Act 1965............... 197 Special Immigration Appeals Commission Act 1997.................. 282 Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1993........... 228 Statute Law Revision (Scotland) Act 1964...................... 228 Statute of Westminster 1931..... 67–69, 75, 76, 80, 162, 199, 200, 202, 203 Preamble.............................. 67, 200, 208 s 2................................................ 200, 202 s 2(1)..................................................... 76 s 4..................................... 67–69, 71, 200 s 7.............................................. 69, 201–4 s 7(1), (3)............................................ 200 Statutory Instruments Act 1946......................... 474, 475, 479 s 1........................................................ 474 s 1(1), (2)............................................ 475 s 2(1)................................................... 479 s 3(2)................................................... 479 s 4(1)................................................... 480 s 5........................................................ 642 Stock Transfer Act 1982 s 2(4)................................................... 480 Taxes Management Act 1970.............. 100 Television Act 1954............................... 552 Territorial Sea Act 1987........................ 484 Terrorism Act 2000......... 27, 122, 222, 281, 751, 771 ss 3, 11................................................. 750 s 41...................................................... 744 ss 44–7................................ 121, 122, 788 Sch 2.................................................... 750 Terrorism Act 2006................. 27, 462, 772 ss 1, 23................................................. 772 Terrorist Asset-Freezing etc Act 2010......................................... 170 Theft Act 1968 s 17.............................................. 163, 564 Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Act 2002..................... 509 Tobacco and Primary Medical
liii
Table  of Statutes Services (Scotland) Act 2010....... 238 Town and Country Planning Act 1990......................................... 674 s 70...................................................... 676 s 70(1)................................................. 505 Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974................ 152, 467 s 13(1)................................................. 152 s 17(1), (2).......................................... 154 Trade Union and Labour Relations (Amendment) Act 1976....... 152, 467 Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 s 203.................................................... 504 s 204(2)............................................... 505 s 207(3)....................................... 504, 505 Transport Act 1985 ss 93–105............................................ 274 Transport Act 2000............................... 481 s 160(1), (2)........................................ 481 Transport (London) Act 1969............. 274 Transport (Scotland) Act 2001............ 467 Treason Felony Act 1848...................... 804 s 3........................................................ 804 Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007................................. 668, 711 Triennial Act 1694................................ 183 Union with England Act 1707..... 60, 161, 222–4, 227, 229, 253 art 1............................................. 223, 224 art 18............................................... 225–7 art 19................................................... 225 art 22........................................... 227, 228 Union with Ireland Act 1800....... 161, 253
Union with Scotland Act 1706..... 60, 161, 162, 166, 222–4, 227, 229, 253 art 1............................................. 223, 224 arts 18, 19........................................... 225 art 22........................................... 227, 228 United Nations Act 1946.............. 169, 170 s 1........................................................ 169 Universities (Scotland) Act 1853........ 223 Universities (Scotland) Act 1932........ 223 Unsolicited Goods and Services Act 1971.......................... 553 Vaccine Damage Payments Act 1979. 552 War Crimes Act 1991..................... 65, 651 War Damage Act 1965......................... 111 s 1........................................................ 111 Water Act 1973 s 30...................................................... 664 Water Act 2003 s 34(1)................................................. 376 Weights and Measures Act 1985......................... 166, 353, 354 Welsh Church Act 1914................. 91, 651 Welsh Language Act 1993.................... 245 Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981......................................... 715 s 53...................................................... 715 Sch 15.................................................. 715 para 12..................................................... 715 para 12(3)............................................... 715 Zimbabwe Act 1979 s 1(2)..................................................... 67
Table of European Treaties
Amsterdam Treaty (1997)............................ 290, 291, 293, 294, 336 Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union........................................ 291, 293, 326–31 Title I (arts 1–5) art 1..................................................... 331 Title II (arts 6–19)............................. 331 arts 13, 14........................................... 331 Title III (arts 20–26) art 20................................................... 331 art 24................................................... 327 art 25........................................... 327, 331 Title IV (arts 27–38)................. 327, 331 art 28................................................... 327 art 29................................................... 331 art 30................................................... 331 art 31(2).............................................. 331 art 32(1).............................................. 331 arts 34, 35, 37..................................... 327 art 38........................................... 327, 331 Title V (arts 39–46)........................... 327 art 41................................................... 327 Title VII (arts 51–54)........................ 327 art 51............................................... 327–9 art 51(2).............................................. 328 art 52(1)...................................... 330, 331 art 52(3).............................................. 327 art 53(5).............................................. 330 European Convention on Human Rights 1950............................................................. 4, 25, 80–2, 84–6, 92–4, 102, 134, 140, 231, 232, 235, 237, 238, 240, 263, 265, 277, 278, 280–86, 288, 291, 308, 326, 327, 330, 331, 360, 685, 687, 688,
690–92, 697, 698, 701, 709, 713, 736, 737, 743, 746, 756–9, 762–6, 770–72, 799, 800, 808, 810, 812, 826, 827, 830, 831 art 2............ 735, 752, 756, 758, 812, 831 art 2(2)................................................ 756 art 3.... 163, 752, 756, 758–62, 765, 772, 778, 780, 812 art 4..................................................... 752 art 4(1)................................................ 756 art 5.. 753, 772, 779, 780, 783, 784, 786, 788, 827, 830, 831 art 5(1)............. 7, 132, 756, 824, 829–31 art 5(1)(c)........................................... 829 art 5(3)................................................ 281 art 5(4)................................ 132, 767, 775 art 6.. 151, 373, 697–702, 734, 735, 738, 753, 756, 765, 767, 768, 772 art 6(1). 131, 133–5, 140, 144, 174, 281, 377, 697, 699, 701–703 art 7..................................... 123, 754, 756 art 7(2)................................................ 756 art 8. 83, 102, 122, 149, 283, 473, 685–7, 689, 708, 754, 757, 766, 772, 788, 811–3, 824 art 8(1)................................................ 281 art 8(2)................................ 236, 687, 811 art 9............................ 687, 690, 754, 757 art 10. 374, 525, 526, 533, 681, 687, 691, 755, 757, 772, 791, 797, 799, 802–4, 806, 808–11, 824, 826, 827, 837–9 art 10(1).............................................. 838 art 10(2).... 800, 803, 808, 809, 811, 812, 825, 826, 830, 838 art 11. 687, 755, 757, 772, 826, 827, 833,
�lvi
BritishofGovernment Table European Treaties and the Constitution: Text and Materials 837–9 art 11(1).............................................. 838 art 11(2).... 757, 825, 826, 833, 835, 837, 838 art 12................................................... 755 art 13.................. 285, 685, 687, 735, 780 art 14............ 83, 755, 758, 779, 780, 783 art 15................................ 7, 281, 779–81 art 15(1)...................................... 780, 782 art 15(2).............................................. 780 art 34........................................... 763, 765 Protocol 1 art 1 738, 755 para 2 236 art 2 756 art 3 283, 756
Protocol 11......................................... 278 Protocol 13, art 1............................... 756 Protocol 14................................. 278, 279 Lisbon Treaty................................................. 154, 289–300, 302, 310, 312, 314, 318, 326, 336, 338, 340, 706, 713 Protocol No 30............................ 328–30 art 1 328 art 2 329
Nice Treaty (2001)........................................ 290, 291, 294, 326, 336 Single European Act (1986)......................... 290, 294, 298, 302, 336 Treaty on European Union (TEU) (references to the Treaty pre-Lisbon are indicated in italics)........................................... 289, 290, 291, 292, 293, 294, 299, 301, 309, 328, 336, 545, 546, 604, 712 art 1..................................................... 294 art 2............................................. 292, 294 art 3............................................. 289, 292 art 4......................................... 292, 295–7 art 4(3)................................................ 323 art 5......................................... 292, 295–7 art 5(3)........................................ 296, 297 art 6................................ 292, 297, 326–9 art 6(1)................................................ 327 arts 9–12............................................. 292 art 13................................................... 297 art 14................................................... 302 art 15................................................... 298 art 16(4), (8)....................................... 299
art 17................................................... 300 art 17(4), (7), (8)................................ 300 art 19................................................... 305 arts 21–46........................................... 292 art 24................................................... 312 art 25................................................... 312 art 48................................................... 292 art 48(2)–(5)...................................... 336 art 48(6)...................................... 336, 337 art 48(7).............................................. 336 Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) (Formerly EC Treaty (Treaty of Rome) references to which are in italics).............................. 290–4, 305–7, 311, 315, 316, 319, 320, 323, 324, 334–6, 340, 344–7, 349, 350, 356–8, 546 ex art 10 EC........................................ 296 art 18 (ex 12/6).................................. 292 arts 20–25 (ex 17–22/8–8e)............. 293 Part 3 (arts 26–197).................. 292, 336 art 30 (ex 25/12)........................ 318, 319 art 34 (ex 28/30)........................ 308, 360 art 36 (ex 30/36)................................ 308 art 49 (ex 43/52)................................ 351 art 75 (ex 60/73g).............................. 332 art 108 (ex 88/93).............................. 301 art 115 (ex 94/100)............................ 311 art 157 (ex 141/119).... 293, 294, 344–7, 351, 357, 358 art 226 (ex 193/138c)........................ 303 art 228 (ex 195/138e)........................ 310 art 234 (ex 201/144).................. 300, 303 Part 6 (arts 223–334)........................ 293 art 252 (ex 222/166).......................... 304 art 253 (ex 223/167).......................... 304 art 254 (ex 224/168).......................... 305 art 258 (ex 226/169). 301, 302, 305, 349, 355 art 259 (ex 227/170).......................... 305 art 260 (ex 228/171).................. 302, 355 art 263 (ex 230/173). 303, 305, 306, 310, 332 art 265 (ex 232/175).......................... 305 art 267 (ex 234/177). 293, 305, 307, 319, 320, 346–8 art 275......................................... 305, 312
�lvii
Table of European Treaties art 286 (ex 247/188b)........................ 310 art 287 (ex 248/188c)........................ 310 art 288 (ex 249/189). 310, 312, 320, 324, 357 art 289................................................. 312 art 290................................................. 301 art 294 (ex 251/189b)........................ 313 art 305 (ex 263/198a)........................ 310
art 306 (ex 264/198b)........................ 310 art 307 (ex 265/198c)........................ 310 art 314 (ex 272/203).......................... 303 art 346 (ex 296/223).......................... 512 art 352 (ex 308/235).................. 296, 314 Protocol Nos 1, 2....................... 293, 296 Protocol Nos 21, 30.......................... 293
Part I
Constitution, state and beyond
1
The British constitutional order
Contents 1 Nature of the British constitution (a) Fundamentals, fluidity and safeguards 2 The constitution, the state and the nation 3 Constitutional law beyond the state 4 Constitutional reform (a) An outline (b) Evaluation
1╇ Nature of the British constitution Almost every country in the world has a written constitution which is a declaration of the country’s supreme law. All other laws and all the institutions of such a state are subordinate to the written constitution, which is intended to be an enduring statement of fundamental principles. The absence of this kind of supreme instrument in the governmental system of the United Kingdom is unusual, leaving many observers to wonder where our constitution is to be found, and indeed whether we have one at all. What, then, do we mean when we speak of the British constitution? Plainly there exists a body of rules that govern the political system, the exercise of public authority, and the relations between the citizen and the state. The fact that the main rules of these kinds are not set out in a single, formal document does make for some difficulty in describing our constitution, although even in a country with a written constitution we soon discover that not all the arrangements for its government are to be found there: many elements of the constitution will have to be looked for elsewhere than in the primary document labelled ‘the Constitution’. (The formal constitution may even be misleading, for we are warned by a Frenchman, Léon Duguit, that ‘the facts are stronger than constitutions’ and by an American, Roscoe Pound, that the ‘law in books’ is not necessarily the same as the ‘law in action’.) But at all events a written constitution is a place where a start can be made. Lacking this, how do we set about describing the British constitution?
�4
British Government and the Constitution
We might begin in a specific way by taking note of particular rules and practices that are observed in the working of the political system – for example, the rule that the civil service is politically objective and impartial (Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, section 7(4)) – or the practice by which ministers answer Questions in the House of Commons. Rules and practices such as these, relating to the government of the country, are of great number and variety: if it were possible to make a complete statement of them, this could no doubt be presented as a formal description of the British constitution. (It would include much that elsewhere would be put into a written constitution and much more that would be left out.) We should then have the material for a definition of the British constitution, which might run Â�something like this: a body of rules, conventions and practices which describe, regulate or qualify the organisation, powers and operation of government and the relations between persons and public authorities.
But such a definition, even if formally adequate, would fail to reveal some important features of the constitution. Shifting our point of view slightly, we might think next of the institutions and offices which constitute the machinery of British government. An institutional description of the constitution would include Parliament, the government and the courts, the monarchy and the civil service, devolved assemblies and administrations in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and such offices as those of the Parliamentary Ombudsman, the Comptroller and Auditor General, and the Director of Public Prosecutions. Of course these institutions and offices are themselves to be explained by reference to rules and practices which constitute them or define their powers and activity. But we do not think of them simply as bundles of rules. Rather, they have what might be described as their own reality and momentum – often loaded with history and tradition – in what is sometimes called ‘the living constitution’. Reflecting further on the constitution, there would come to mind certain ideas, doctrines or organising principles which have influenced or inspired the rules and practices of the constitution, or which express essential features of our institutions of government or of relations between them. There can be no true understanding of the British constitution without an appreciation of the role within it of such commanding principles as those of democracy, parliamentary sovereignty, the rule of law, the separation of powers and ministerial responsibility (on each of which, see chapter 2). We also have to think of the ways these various institutions and ideas are now required to operate in the context of globalisation and of the rise to prominence of international and supranational organisations such as the Council of Europe, with its influential European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR),
�5
The British constitutional order
and the European Union (EU), with its vast and continually growing body of EU law (on both of which, see chapter 5). Until now we have spoken rather loosely of ‘rules and practices’ of the constitution, and we need to be more definite. The legal rules that make up part of the constitution are either statutory rules or rules of common law. Many of the more important practices of the constitution also have the character of rules and, like legal rules, may give rise to obligations and entitlements. These nonlegal rules are called conventions. (The nature of conventions and their relation to law is one of the fundamental problems of the constitution and is more fully explored in chapter 3.) As already indicated, the attempt might be made to enumerate all the rules relating to the system of government in a comprehensive statement of the contents of the British constitution (although it would not remain up to date for long). A problem that would arise in doing this would be that of deciding whether rules were sufficiently connected with the machinery of government to count as part of the constitution. Should the statement include the rules and practices relating to the control of immigration, or the organisation of the armed forces, or the administration of social security? This sort of question would have to be answered rather arbitrarily, for there are no natural boundaries of the system of government or of the constitution. As S Finer, V Bogdanor and B Rudden have commented (Comparing Constitutions (1995), p 40), the British constitution is ‘indeterminate, indistinct and unentrenched’. Moreover, much of it would remain so even if it were codified. Unsurprisingly, no comprehensive list or statement of the kind under consideration has been attempted, but Albert Blaustein and Gisbert Flanz (eds), Constitutions of the Countries of the World, offered a list of constitutional statutes of the UK which (in 1992) named over 300 statutes, ranging from Magna Carta in 1215 and the 1689 Bill of Rights to more recent statutes such as the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, the Crown Proceedings Act 1947, the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 and the European Communities Act 1972. The 2009 edition of Blackstone’s Statutes in Public Law and Human Rights includes extracts from 110 statutes, of which only 28 were passed before 1975. The UK is said to have an ancient constitution, but if fully three-quarters of its statutes on constitutional law date from only the last 35 years, perhaps this is not the case. Whether any of this is a reliable indication of how much the British constitution has changed in recent times is a matter we shall consider later in this chapter. A comprehensive list of constitutional rules would not tell us what is distinctive in the British constitution or what is of especial value. For the constitution is not mere machinery for the exercise of public power, but establishes an order by which public power is itself to be constrained. Some constitutional rules express social or political values that are thought important to preserve, or that help to maintain a balance between different institutions of government, or safeguard
�6
British Government and the Constitution
minorities or protect individual rights. These rules, we may say, have ‘something fundamental’ about them and are distinguishable from much that is circumstantial, temporary, simply convenient or merely mechanical in the constitution. This distinction, however, is not straightforward. There is often disagreement about what is vital in the constitution and what is inessential. It is easy to fall into a very conservative way of regarding the constitution and to categorise what is old and traditional in our rules and practices as necessarily to be cherished and preserved, although no longer conformable to a changed society, a transformed public consciousness and new conceptions of justice and morality. There is a contrary tendency to view the whole constitution in an instrumental way, holding all its rules to be equally malleable or dispensable in the interest of immediate political ends or administrative convenience. Profound changes in society and politics in the past century created stresses in Britain’s historical constitution, but a lack of consensus, together with official inertia or satisfaction with the status quo, for a long time inhibited thoroughgoing constitutional reform. The response to revealed defects was to adjust or tinker with the constitutional mechanism, sometimes without due deliberation or debate, rather than to redesign the system. Towards the close of the twentieth century questions were increasingly raised about the suitability of the constitution to the political realities of the post-industrial, multi-racial, multi-party, relatively non-deferential and egalitarian (if still unequal) society which Britain had become. We find Samuel Beer observing that ‘the new stress on participant attitudes and behaviour collides with values anciently embedded in the political system’ (Britain Against Itself (1982), p 112). Constitutional rules which had seemed deeply rooted were coming under critical scrutiny – for example, the electoral system, rules for maintaining governmental secrecy, and the law and conventions which regulate the working of Parliament. Government was seen to be over-centralised and insufficiently controlled. In response to such criticisms and dissatisfactions, the Blair Government, taking office in 1997, launched an ambitious – but not comprehensive – project of constitutional reform, which we consider in the final section of this chapter. In their own ways the Brown Government (2007–10) and the Coalition Government (2010 to date) each continued to place questions of constitutional reform prominently on their political and legislative agendas, as we shall see in more detail later in this chapter. The still uncompleted reform project has given a renewed impetus to constitutional debate and it is timely for us to ask what in the British constitution has outlived its usefulness, what needs reform and what expresses fundamental values that it is important to maintain and strengthen?
(a)╇ Fundamentals, fluidity and safeguards It may be expected that Parliament, the government and the courts should have a particular concern for rules that reflect fundamental values, upholding
�7
The British constitutional order
them against prejudice or transient passions and departing from them only on the strength of open and principled argument. Unfortunately this expectation is sometimes disappointed: we identified a particularly disturbing example of this in our preface. The abrogation by Parliament of long-established rules that may be deemed fundamental is not always supported by full investigation or convincing justification. This criticism has been made, for instance, of the abolition by the Criminal Justice Act 1988 of the defendant’s right of peremptory challenge of jurors and also of the abolition by the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 of an accused person’s ‘right of silence’, which had ‘stood out as one of the proudest boasts of Britain’s commitment to civil liberties’ (Geoffrey Robertson, Freedom, the Individual and the Law (7th edn 1993), p 32). Proposed legislation to restrict the right to trial by jury – regarded by Lord Denning as ‘the bulwark of our liberties’ (Ward v James [1966] 1 QB 273, 295) – attracted similar criticism, and the Government was compelled to make significant concessions to overcome opposition in the House of Lords and secure the enactment of the Criminal Justice Act 2003. By the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001 Parliament authorised the indefinite detention without trial of non-British nationals who were suspected of being international terrorists. To forestall challenges to the adoption of this power, the Government derogated from Article 5(1) of the ECHR (the right to liberty and security of person). Derogation is allowed by the Convention (Article 15) if strictly necessary in the event of a ‘public emergency threatening the life of the nation’. In A v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] UKHL 56, [2005] 2 AC 68, it was held by the House of Lords that the Government’s derogation on this ground went beyond what was strictly necessary and was unlawful. It was further held that section 23 of the Act, the provision for detention, was incompatible with Article 5(1) of the Convention. The case resulted in Parliament re-legislating, replacing the scheme of indefinite detention without trial with a system of ‘control orders’, themselves deeply controversial from a human rights point of view (see the Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005). (These matters are more fully considered in chapter 11.) Judicial decisions, too, may undo what had been thought fundamental. Here follows an example of judicial subversion of a fundamental rule – although happily it was only a temporary aberration, and after a time the rule was restored. The writ of habeas corpus (meaning ‘thou shall have the body brought into court’), for securing a judicial inquiry into the legality of a person’s detention, has its origin in early common law and a series of Habeas Corpus Acts. The efficacy of the writ of habeas corpus will often depend in practice on the onus of proof, and the courts established the rule that the custodian must prove, to the satisfaction of the court, the circumstances alleged to justify the detention. This rule, in assuring effective protection of the right of the individual to
�8
British Government and the Constitution
Â� personal freedom, certainly has the appearance of ‘something fundamental’: it was expressed as follows by Lord Atkin in Eshugbayi Eleko v Government of Nigeria [1931] AC 662, 670: In accordance with British jurisprudence no member of the executive can interfere with the liberty or property of a British subject except on the condition that he can support the legality of his action before a court of justice.
However, in a number of cases arising under the Immigration Act 1971 the courts reversed the rule as to onus of proof in habeas corpus proceedings, holding that the onus was on the applicant to establish that his or her detention was unlawful. It was further held that this onus could be discharged only by showing that the immigration authority – the immigration officer or the Secretary of State – had no reasonable grounds for reaching the conclusions on which the detention was based. (See R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Choudhary [1978] 1 WLR 1177 and Zamir v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1980] AC 930.) The effect of these rulings was, as Templeman LJ observed in R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Akhtar [1981] QB 46, 52, to deny ‘the effective recourse of an individual to the courts which administer justice in this country’. Must we not say of this judicial deviation, in which the courts overturned the rule of the Habeas Corpus Acts and robbed the individual of an effective remedy for unlawful detention, that it violated fundamental constitutional principle? In Khawaja v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1984] AC 74, the House of Lords restored the true principle, holding that the burden of proof rested on the custodian and that the issue was not whether there were reasonable grounds for the decision to detain, but whether the detention could be justified in law. To whom are we to look for the defence of what is fundamental in the constitution – for the preservation of ‘constitutionalism’? In the first place, the courts have a cardinal role to play in upholding fundamental principle, although, as we have just seen, they have themselves the capability to reinterpret or displace constitutional rules, which itself calls for vigilance: quis custodiet ipsos custodes? (who will guard the guardians?). We rely upon the courts to maintain fundamental legal rules against excessive zeal or malpractice of administrators and others who exercise public power, but their role as constitutional guardians is necessarily limited. They are restricted, as regards legislation, by the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty (see chapter 2); and they work within a tradition (itself resting on a fundamental idea of the constitution) of judicial restraint, for they are, after all, unelected, largely unaccountable and not especially qualified to resolve issues of political judgment and policy. In recent years the courts have, however, found a new boldness in developing the principles of judicial review, and an eminent constitutional lawyer declares that they have brought about a ‘renaissance of administrative
�9
The British constitutional order
law’ in asserting their power to control public authorities (Sir William Wade, Constitutional Fundamentals (rev edn 1989), ch 5). The balance between a proper judicial restraint and a legitimate judicial activism remains a critical feature of the constitution. (See further chapters 10 and 11.) Secondly, we depend on the political actors themselves to observe the ‘rules of the game’: ministers, civil servants and parliamentarians operate in a framework of generally well-understood procedures which are designed to make the governmental machine work not merely efficiently but with respect for fundamentals. A veteran parliamentarian showed an awareness of this in remarking: ‘We have no constitution in this country: we have only procedure – hence its importance’ (Mr St John-Stevas, HC Deb vol 991, col 721, 30 October 1980). Procedures, it is true, may not hold up in a time of crisis. Admitting this, JW Gough nevertheless asked whether, in ‘a time of crisis or of embittered emotions’, we should be ‘any safer with laws, even with fundamental laws and a written constitution’ (Fundamental Law in English Constitutional History (1955), p 212). The observance of procedures is checked in certain respects by parliamentary select committees – such as the Public Accounts Committee and the Select Committee on Standards and Privileges in the House of Commons and the Constitution Committee in the House of Lords – and by the Comptroller and Auditor General, the Committee on Standards in Public Life, the Parliamentary Ombudsman and the Commissioner for Public Appointments. (See further chapter 9.) Thirdly, and in the last resort, we depend on the force of public opinion, pronounced in the general verdicts of elections and expressed in more specific ways through the media, political parties, public protest and private interest groups and organisations of many kinds. A valuable role is performed by those organisations, such as Liberty (the National Council for Civil Liberties), that exist for the purpose of defending individual rights. (See further chapter 8.) Part of the problem, perhaps, is a lack of certainty about what truly is fundamental to our constitutional order. We may wish to claim that trial by jury, the right to silence or habeas corpus are fundamental values inherent in the constitutional order, but on what basis can such a claim actually be grounded, beyond one’s own desire? How can an argument be made, either legally or politically, that this value or that right is so fundamental to our sense of constitutionalism, whatever that may mean, that it should remain untouched by legislative amendment or judicial re-interpretation? As we have already mentioned, and we as we shall see further below, the British constitution has been subject to considerable and significant reform in recent years. Much of the reform is, in our view, both welcome and overdue. But the current climate of reform poses in stark form the question of whether there is anything that ought to lie beyond the reformers’ reach. Is anything sacred, or is the entirety of the British constitution ‘up for grabs’? (For an intriguing analysis,
�10
British Government and the Constitution
see Murkens, ‘The quest for constitutionalism in UK public law discourse’ (2009) 29 OJLS 427.) Sir John Baker (a Cambridge law professor), reflecting on these questions in an absorbing analysis, warns that the government ‘constantly tinkering with constitutional arrangements as a routine exercise of power and without regard to the consequences’, even if many of the changes are themselves desirable, may lead to ‘the dismal reflection that we no longer have a constitution, in the sense of a set of conventions which set the bounds of executive power and keep the government within those bounds’ (Sir John Baker, ‘Our unwritten constitution’ (2010) 167 Proc Brit Acad 91, 117). If the government no longer exercises constitutional self-restraint, then to whom must we turn for safeguards? Sir John’s answer is a traditional one in the British context: this is Parliament’s role, he argues, and, in particular, it is the role of select committees (‘one of the most fruitful reforms of the last thirty years’) and of the House of Lords (which has ‘become the principal defender of constitutional liberties, and arguably the more significant legislative chamber, albeit at the cost of endangering its own existence’). A written constitution might help, he argues (p 108), although it would not necessarily do so: In practice the true function of a written constitution is not so much to improve the clarity of the rules as to empower the highest court to strike down legislation according to its own interpretation of the words. The question is therefore whether the time has come to transfer more power to the judges, on the footing that the political constitution has broken down beyond repair. This is far from straightforward, since we cannot assume that the traditional juristic standards of the judiciary will be maintained once they have a political role.
The ongoing tensions (or, if you prefer, the balance) between the parliamentary aspects of our constitution and its judicial aspects is one of the central themes of contemporary constitutional debate in Britain, and we shall touch on it throughout this book.
2╇ The constitution, the state and the nation Definitions of the constitution often focus on the concept of the state and its organs. For example, Hood Phillips and Jackson’s Constitutional and Administrative Law (8th edn 2001), p 5, defines a constitution as: the system of laws, customs and conventions which define the composition and powers of organs of the state, and regulate the relations of the various state organs to one another and to the private citizen.
Regarded from the perspective of international law the UK is undoubtedly a state, but our constitutional system has been constructed largely without the use of the concept of the state. In Britain there is no legal entity called
�11
The British constitutional order
‘the state’ in which powers are vested or to which allegiance or other duties are owed. The non-admission of the idea of the state helps to explain the tardy and partial development in Britain of a system of public law. As Kenneth Dyson remarks (The State Tradition in Western Europe (1980), p 117), there was ‘no conception of the state to which principles and rules could be attributed’ and ordinary private law occupied much of the field in which relations between public officers and private citizens were conducted (among many examples, see Entick v Carrington (1765) 19 St Tr 1029 and Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1979] Ch 344, both considered in chapter 2). For issues savouring more of policy than of property, the courts were inclined to assign to Parliament the function of controlling governmental action (a classic example is R v Halliday, ex p Zadig [1917] AC 260). It has been said, too, that the absence of a concept of the state has frustrated ‘the development of a rationallegal theory of the constitution’ and has excluded from our constitutional culture ‘the notion of an authority higher than the government of the day’ (P Madgwick and D Woodhouse, The Law and Politics of the Constitution of the United Kingdom (1995), p 75; see further Mitchell, ‘The causes and effects of the absence of a system of public law in the United Kingdom’ [1965] PL 95 and Laborde, ‘The concept of the state in British and French political thought’ (2000) 48 Pol Stud 540). The written constitutions of many countries are founded on the idea of the state as expressing the whole political organisation of the people. We find, for instance, the following provisions in the Constitution of Ireland of 1937.
The Constitution of Ireland Article 4. The name of the State is Éire, or, in the English language, Ireland. Article 5. Ireland is a sovereign, independent, democratic state. Article 6. (1) All powers of government, legislative, executive and judicial, derive, under God, from the people, whose right it is to designate the rulers of the State .â•›.â•›. (2) These powers of government are exercisable only by or on the authority of the organs of State established by this Constitution. Article 9. (2) Fidelity to the nation and loyalty to the State are fundamental political duties of all citizens.
A number of the fundamental rights defined by the Irish Constitution are expressed in terms of guarantees or obligations assumed by the state. For instance, the state ‘guarantees liberty for the exercise’ inter alia of ‘The right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions’ (Article 40(6)(1)). The idea of the state is familiar enough in English political thought, and even lawyers have to deal with such expressions as ‘offences against the state’, ‘act of state’ and the ‘interests of the state’. On the other hand, as Sedley LJ remarked in A v Head Teacher and Governors of Lord Grey School [2004] EWCA Civ 382, [2004] 4 All ER 628, [3], ‘the law of England and Wales does not know the state
�12
British Government and the Constitution
as a legal entity’. Accordingly, there is no single legal definition of the state for all purposes and the courts have had to decide, in various contexts, whether a particular public body is an organ of the state. In D v National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children [1978] AC 171, it was argued that the NSPCC, a voluntary charity incorporated by royal charter and authorised by statute to bring care proceedings for the protection of children, was not part of ‘the state’ and accordingly could not rely on ‘public interest immunity’ (a prerogative immunity of the Crown’s) as justifying its refusal to disclose the identity of its informants. Lord Simon of Glaisdale disposed of this argument in the following words (pp 235–6): ‘[T]he state’ cannot on any sensible political theory be restricted to the Crown and the departments of central government (which are, indeed, part of the Crown in constitutional law). The state is the whole organisation of the body politic for supreme civil rule and government – the whole political organisation which is the basis of civil government. As such it certainly extends to local – and, as I think, also statutory – bodies in so far as they are exercising autonomous rule.
(See further on Crown prerogatives chapters 6 and 7.) In Foster v British Gas [1991] 2 AC 306 the House of Lords, applying criteria laid down by the European Court of Justice (ECJ), ruled that the British Gas Corporation (a nationalised industry, the predecessor of British Gas plc) was sufficiently identified with the state (it had been set up by the state with special powers to provide a public service under the control of the Secretary of State) to be bound by the terms of an EC Directive addressed to the UK and other Member States of the EU (see further chapter 5). The phrase ‘the interests of the state’ occurs in the Official Secrets Act 1911 and was considered in the following case.
Chandler v Director of Public Prosecutions [1964] AC 763 (HL) The appellants had attempted to enter and immobilise an airfield, which was a ‘prohibited place’ within the meaning of the Official Secrets Act 1911, as a demonstration of opposition to nuclear weapons. They were charged with conspiracy to commit a breach of section 1 of the Act, which makes it an offence to enter any prohibited place ‘for any purpose prejudicial to the safety or interests of the State’. It was argued for the appellants that what they had intended to do was not in fact prejudicial to the safety or interests of the state, and further that it was their purpose to benefit and not to harm the state. Counsel argued also that the word ‘State’ in the Act meant the inhabitants of the country and not the organs of government. Lord Reid: .â•›.â•›. Next comes the question of what is meant by the safety or interests of the State. ‘State’ is not an easy word. It does not mean the Government or the Executive. ‘L’Etat c’est moi’ was a shrewd remark, but can hardly have been intended as a definition even in
�13
The British constitutional order the France of the time. And I do not think that it means, as counsel argued, the individuals who inhabit these islands. The statute cannot be referring to the interests of all those individuals because they may differ and the interests of the majority are not necessarily the same as the interests of the State. Again we have seen only too clearly in some other countries what can happen if you personify and almost deify the State. Perhaps the country or the realm are as good synonyms as one can find and I would be prepared to accept the organised community as coming as near to a definition as one can get.
Lord Hodson also took the state to mean ‘the organised community’ (p 801). Lord Devlin: .â•›.â•›. What is meant by ‘the State’? Is it the same thing as what I have just called ‘the country’? Mr Foster, for the appellants, submits that it means the inhabitants of a particular geographical area. I doubt if it ever has as wide a meaning as that. I agree that in an appropriate context the safety and interests of the State might mean simply the public or national safety and interests. But the more precise use of the word ‘State’, the use to be expected in a legal context, and the one which I am quite satisfied .â•›.â•›. was intended in this statute, is to denote the organs of government of a national community. In the United Kingdom, in relation at any rate to the armed forces and to the defence of the realm, that organ is the Crown.
In the view of all their Lordships, the interests of the state were in this matter identical with those of the Crown or at all events were determined by the Crown – in effect, by the government of the day. Lord Pearce, for example, said (p 813): In such a context the interests of the State must in my judgment mean the interests of the State according to the policies laid down for it by its recognised organs of government and authority.
Consequently it could not be argued that the military dispositions decided upon by the government were not in the interests of the state. The arguments for the appellants having failed in this and other respects, their convictions were confirmed. (See further Thompson [1963] PL 201.) In R v Ponting [1985] Crim LR 318, McCowan J, in directing the jury on the meaning of ‘the interest of the State’ in section 2(1) (since repealed) of the Official Secrets Act 1911, followed Lord Pearce in saying that the expression meant the policies of the state laid down for it by the recognised organs of government and authority. This ruling neutralised Ponting’s argument, in defenÂ� ding a charge of disclosure of official information in breach of section 2(1), that he had acted in the interest of the state as an institution distinct from the government of the day. (The jury nevertheless acquitted Ponting in a verdict welcomed by many observers, including Lord Denning: see HL Deb vol 461, col 563, 20 March 1985. On the Ponting case, see further N MacCormick, Questioning Sovereignty (1999), ch 3.)
�14
British Government and the Constitution
If the interests of the state and of the government are in law to be considered the same, the possibility remains that those interests may differ from what is in the real interest of the community as a whole. This was perceived by Lord Radcliffe, when he said, in Glasgow Corpn v Central Land Board 1956 SC (HL) 1, 18–19, that ‘The interests of government .â•›.â•›. do not exhaust the public interest’. That the interests of the government may have to yield to the wider public interest is clearly shown by the ‘Spycatcher’ case, Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd (No 2) [1990] 1 AC 109, where the desire of Mrs Thatcher’s Government to ban the publication of the memoirs of a former Security Service (MI5) officer, Peter Wright, was weighed against the broader public interests of freedom of expression and open government. These latter interests were (eventually) held to prevail over the declared interest of the government of the day (see further chapter 11). It might make for a better understanding of constitutional relationships if we had a coherent concept of the state, clearly distinguished from those who exercise power within it. Who speaks for (or represents) the national interest and, indeed, whether there even exists in our constitutional law a conception of the national interest which is any higher (or any deeper) than the political interest of the government of the day are matters which continue to cause trouble. The ‘national interest’ is as confused and as under-developed a notion in British constitutional law as is the state. As we saw earlier in this chapter, among the questions for the House of Lords in A v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] UKHL 56, [2005] 2 AC 68 was whether (as the Government claimed) there was a ‘public emergency threatening the life of the nation’. Their Lordships ruled 8-1 that there was, a verdict subsequently endorsed (17-0) by the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) (in A v United Kingdom (2009) 49 EHRR 29). The sole dissentient on this point was Lord Hoffmann (at [91]–[96]), who took the words ‘threatening the life of the nation’ to require something more than ‘threatening the lives of some of those who live in the nation’: What is meant by ‘threatening the life of the nation’? The ‘nation’ is a social organism, living in its territory (in this case, the United Kingdom) under its own form of government and subject to a system of laws which expresses its own political and moral values. When one speaks of a threat to the ‘life’ of the nation, the word life is being used in a metaphorical sense. The life of the nation is not coterminous with the lives of its people. The nation, its institutions and values, endure through generations. In many important respects, England is the same nation as it was at the time of the first Elizabeth or the Glorious Revolution. The Armada threatened to destroy the life of the nation, not by loss of life in battle, but by subjecting English institutions to the rule of Spain and the Inquisition. The same was true of the threat posed to the United Kingdom by Nazi Germany in the Second World War. This country, more than any other in the world, has an unbroken history of living for centuries under institutions and in accordance with values which show a recognisable continuity .â•›.â•›.
�15
The British constitutional order The Home Secretary has adduced evidence .â•›.â•›. to show the existence of a threat of serious terrorist outrages .â•›.â•›. But the question is whether such a threat is a threat to the life of the nation. The [government’s] submissions .â•›.â•›. treated a threat of serious physical damage and loss of life as necessarily involving a threat to the life of the nation. But in my opinion this shows a misunderstanding of what is meant by ‘threatening the life of the nation’. Of course the government has a duty to protect the lives and property of its citizens. But that is a duty which it owes all the time and which it must discharge without destroying our constitutional freedoms. There may be some nations too fragile or fissiparous to withstand a serious act of violence. But that is not the case in the United Kingdom .â•›.â•›. This is a nation which has been tested in adversity, which has survived physical destruction and catastrophic loss of life. I do not underestimate the ability of fanatical groups of terrorists to kill and destroy, but they do not threaten the life of the nation. Whether we would survive Hitler hung in the balance, but there is no doubt that we shall survive Al Qaida. The Spanish people have not said that what happened in Madrid, hideous crime as it was, threatened the life of their nation. Their legendary pride would not allow it. Terrorist violence, serious as it is, does not threaten our institutions of government or our existence as a civil community.
None of the other judges hearing the appeal took this approach. Lord Bingham ruled that the court should defer to the Government on the point, stating that ‘great weight should be given’ to the Home Secretary and his colleagues on the question ‘because they were called on to exercise a preeminently political judgment’ (at [29]). Lord Hope agreed, ruling that ‘the questions whether there is an emergency and whether it threatens the life of the nation are pre-eminently for the executive and Parliament. The judgment that has to be formed on these issues lies outside the expertise of the courts’ (at [116]). Similar views were expressed by the other Law Lords hearing the appeal (see, eg, Baroness Hale at [226]). The Grand Chamber of the ECtHR agreed with these views, stating that ‘while it is striking that the United Kingdom was the only Convention State to have lodged a derogation in response to the danger from Al Qaida .â•›.â•›. the Court accepts that it was for each government, as the guardian of their own people’s safety, to make their own assessment on the basis of the facts known to them. Weight must, therefore, attach to judgment of the United Kingdom’s executive and Parliament on this question’ (at [180]). While this does not suggest that there can be no circumstances in which a court may overturn the judgment of the government that there is a ‘public emergency threatening the life of the nation’, it is clear that the government will have to have done something outrageous – taken leave of its senses, perhaps – before a court will intervene (see further chapters 10 and 11). Other recent cases in which the courts have struggled with concepts of the national interest or with the question of who, constitutionally, speaks for the national interest include Secretary of State for the Home Department v Rehman [2001] UKHL 47, [2003] 1 AC 153, in which the House of Lords unanimously
�16
British Government and the Constitution
ruled that it was lawful for the Secretary of State to deport an individual from the UK on the basis that he was a threat to national security even where he was a threat not directly to the security of the UK but to the security of a foreign country, thus appearing to merge ‘national security’ and ‘international security’ together. In R (Corner House Research) v Director of the Serious Fraud Office [2008] UKHL 60, [2009] 1 AC 756 the Director of the Serious Fraud Office discontinued a criminal investigation into British Aerospace (BAe) which concerned a lucrative arms deal that BAe had secured with Saudi Arabia. He had been prevailed upon to do so by ministers and diplomats on the basis that the investigation, if taken further, would threaten future Saudi provision of intelligence to the UK. This, it was feared, would be so contrary to British national security that it would jeopardise ‘British lives on British streets’. The Divisional Court held that it was a monstrous breach of the rule of law for an independent prosecutor to have yielded to such political and diplomatic threats (see [2008] EWHC 714 (Admin), [2008] 4 All ER 927). The House of Lords swiftly overruled the lower court, unanimously holding that the Director of the Serious Fraud Office had not acted unlawfully. The case throws into sharp relief ongoing tensions as to what is in the national interest, and who decides this (we return to the Corner House case in chapter 2). Yet a further complication arises when it is remembered that not all those in the UK would equate ‘the national interest’ with ‘the British national interest’. The Scottish National Party, for example, are strongly of the view that the national interest north of the border means the Scottish national interest. Some parties in Wales and Northern Ireland take similar views. These issues have not yet troubled the courts, although there is no guarantee that they will not do so soon. Whether either the courts or any other players on the constitutional stage possess the conceptual apparatus that may one day be necessary to disentangle the ideas of ‘government’, ‘state’ and ‘nation’ must, on the present state of the authorities, be doubted. To date such disentangling has not proven necessary and, for the time being, we continue to muddle along – for the most part unaware even that we are in a muddle in the first place. Legal argument about the nature of the state and its relation to the government is sometimes rather narrow and may cause us to lose sight of wider political realities. These receive their due in the following passage.
Ralph Miliband, The State in Capitalist Society (1969), pp€49–54 There is one preliminary problem about the state which is very seldom considered, yet which requires attention if the discussion of its nature and role is to be properly focused. This is the fact that ‘the state’ is not a thing, that it does not, as such, exist. What ‘the state’ stands for is a number of particular institutions which, together, constitute its reality, and which interact as parts of what may be called the state system. The point is by no means academic. For the treatment of one part of the state – usually the government – as the state itself introduces a major element of confusion in the
�17
The British constitutional order discussion of the nature and incidence of state power; and that confusion can have large political consequences. Thus, if it is believed that the government is in fact the state, it may also be believed that the assumption of governmental power is equivalent to the acquisition of state power. Such a belief, resting as it does on vast assumptions about the nature of state power, is fraught with great risks and disappointments. To understand the nature of state power, it is necessary first of all to distinguish, and then to relate, the various elements which make up the state system. It is not very surprising that government and state should often appear as synonymous for it is the government which speaks on the state’s behalf. It was the state to which Weber was referring when he said, in a famous phrase, that, in order to be, it must ‘successfully claim the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory’. But ‘the state’ cannot claim anything: only the government of the day, or its duly empowered agents, can. Men, it is often said, give their allegiance not to the government of the day but to the state. But the state, from this point of view, is a nebulous entity; and while men€may€choose to give their allegiance to it, it is to the government that they are required to give their obedience. A defiance of its orders is a defiance of the state, in whose name the government alone may speak and for whose actions it must assume ultimate responsibility. This, however, does not mean that the government is necessarily strong, either in relation to other elements of the state system or to forces outside it. On the contrary, it may be very weak, and provide a mere façade for one or other of these other elements and forces. In other words, the fact that the government does speak in the name of the state and is formally invested with state power, does not mean that it effectively controls that power. How far governments do control it is one of the major questions to be determined. A second element of the state system which requires investigation is the administrative one, which now extends far beyond the traditional bureaucracy of the state, and which encompasses a large variety of bodies, often related to particular ministerial departments, or enjoying a greater or lesser degree of autonomy – public corporations, central banks, regulatory commissions, etc – and concerned with the management of the economic, social, cultural and other activities in which the state is now directly or indirectly involved. The extraordinary growth of this administrative and bureaucratic element in all societies, including advanced capitalist ones, is of course one of the most obvious features of contemporary life; and the relation of its leading members to the government and to society is also crucial to the determination of the role of the state. Formally, officialdom is at the service of the political executive, its obedient instrument, the tool of its will. In actual fact it is nothing of the kind. Everywhere and inevitably, the administrative process is also part of the political process; administration is always political as well as executive, at least at the levels where policy-making is relevant, that is to say in the upper layers of administrative life. .â•›.â•›. Officials and administrators cannot divest themselves of all ideological clothing in the advice which they tender to their political masters, or in the independent decisions which they are in a position to take. The power which top civil servants and other state administrators possess no doubt varies from country to country, from department to department, and from individual to individual. But nowhere do these men not contribute directly and appreciably to the exercise of state power. .â•›.â•›.
�18
British Government and the Constitution Some of these considerations apply to all other elements of the state system. They apply for instance to a third such element, namely the military, to which may, for present purposes, be added the paramilitary, security and police forces of the state, and which together form that branch of it mainly concerned with the ‘management of violence’. In most capitalist countries, this coercive apparatus constitutes a vast, sprawling and resourceful establishment, whose professional leaders are men of high status and great influence, inside the state system and in society .â•›.â•›. Whatever may be the case in practice, the formal constitutional position of the administrative and coercive elements is to serve the state by serving the government of the day. In contrast, it is not at all the formal constitutional duty of judges, at least in Western-type political systems, to serve the purposes of their governments. They are constitutionally independent of the political executive and protected from it by security of tenure and other guarantees. Indeed, the concept of judicial independence is deemed to entail not merely the freedom of judges from responsibility to the political executive, but their active duty to protect the citizen against the political executive or its agents, and to act, in the state’s encounter with members of society, as the defenders of the latters’ rights and liberties .â•›.â•›. But in any case, the judiciary is an integral part of the state system, which affects, often profoundly, the exercise of state power. So too, to a greater or lesser degree, does a fifth element of the state system, namely the various units of sub-central government. In one of its aspects, sub-central government constitutes an extension of central government and administration, the latter’s antennae or tentacles. In some political systems it has indeed practically no other function. In the countries of advanced capitalism, on the other hand, sub-central government is rather more than an administrative device. In addition to being agents of the state these units of government have also traditionally performed another function. They have not only been the channels of communication and administration from the centre to the periphery, but also the voice of the periphery, or of particular interests at the periphery; they have been a means of overcoming local particularities, but also platforms for their expression, instruments of central control and obstacles to it. For all the centralisation of power, which is a major feature of government in these countries, sub-central organs of government, notably in federal systems such as that of the United States, have remained power structures in their own right, and therefore able to affect very markedly the lives of the populations they have governed. Much the same point may be made about the representative assemblies of advanced capitalism. Now more than ever their life revolves around the government; and even where, as in the United States, they are formally independent organs of constitutional and political power, their relationship with the political executive cannot be a purely critical or obstructive one. That relationship is one of conflict and cooperation. Nor is this a matter of division between a pro-government side and an anti-government one. Both sides reflect this duality. For opposition parties cannot be wholly uncooperative. Merely by taking part in the work of the legislature, they help the government’s business. .â•›.â•›. As for government parties, they are seldom if ever single-minded in their support of the political executive and altogether subservient to it. They include people who, by virtue of their position and influence, must be persuaded, cajoled, threatened or bought off.
�19
The British constitutional order It is in the constitutionally-sanctioned performance of this cooperative and critical function that legislative assemblies have a share in the exercise of state power. That share is rather less extensive and exalted than is often claimed for these bodies. But .â•›.â•›. it is not, even in an epoch of executive dominance, an unimportant one. These are the institutions – the government, the administration, the military and the police, the judicial branch, sub-central government and parliamentary assemblies – which make up ‘the state’, and whose interrelationship shapes the form of the state system. It is these institutions in which ‘state power’ lies, and it is through them that this power is wielded in its different manifestations by the people who occupy the leading positions in each of these institutions – presidents, prime ministers and their ministerial colleagues; high civil servants and other state administrators; top military men; judges of the higher courts; some at least of the leading members of parliamentary assemblies, though these are often the same men as the senior members of the political executive; and, a long way behind, particularly in unitary states, the political and administrative leaders of sub-central units of the state. These are the people who constitute what may be described as the state elite.
No matter how centralised government in the UK may be (and, even after devolution, British government remains remarkably centralised) it would be misleading, as Miliband shows, simply to identify central government with the state (see further Loughlin, ‘The state, the Crown and the law’, in M Sunkin and S Payne (eds), The Nature of the Crown (1999)).
3╇ Constitutional law beyond the state A number of commentators have in recent years argued that the traditional focus in constitutional studies (both legal and political) on the state is no longer appropriate or that, at the least, such a focus needs now to be supplemented with additional perspectives. Gavin Anderson, for example, urges that we need to do no less than to ‘reconfigure our understandings of constitutional law and constitutional rights according to .â•›.â•›. [a new] paradigm that enables us to understand better, and respond to, the challenges facing constitutionalism in an age of globalization’ (Constitutional Rights after Globalization (2005), p 3). The state, it is claimed, is coming under pressure both internally and externally. On the one hand, the devolutionary forces of regionalism and localism are investing sites of constitutional authority within the state with increasing power. In the UK, for example, we can no longer understand the fullness of our constitutional arrangements if we confine our attention to matters in London, Westminster and Whitehall. The Scottish Parliament at Holyrood and the National Assembly for Wales at Cardiff Bay are essential institutions not only if you are studying British constitutional law in Scotland or Wales but so, too, if you are studying it in England. On the other hand, the forces of globalisation (in the economic, political, social, cultural and legal spheres) and the rise to constitutional prominence of both international and supranational organisations such as the World Trade Organization, the United Nations (UN), the
�20
British Government and the Constitution
Council of Europe and the EU (among a number of others) also require us to shift our gaze beyond national borders. To this end recent years have seen a voluminous literature with such suggestive titles as J Camilleri and J Falk, The End of Sovereignty? (1992), S Sassen, Losing Control? Sovereignty in an Age of Globalization (1996) and S Strange, The Retreat of the State (1996), while a number of EU lawyers have written articles that talk of such things as ‘postnational constitutionalism’ and the need to find ‘constitutional substitutes’ (see, eg, Shaw (1999) 6 JEPP 579; and Chalmers (2000) 27 JLS 178). Two different sets of claims are made in this literature. The first, more moderate, claim is that even if the state continues to be the primary site of constitutional authority, the way in which it operates is now conditioned by both sub-state and super-state forces. The second, bolder, claim is that, in some senses at least, the state is no longer the primary site of constitutional authority and has been replaced in that regard by a combination of sub-state and superstate forces. The following extract surveys the issues.
Martin Loughlin, Sword and Scales (2000), pp€141–5 The nation-state is a relatively modern phenomenon. Its emergence has been traced to the period after the Treaty of Westphalia of 1648, an era in which the western world was divided into more clearly delineated jurisdictions and the modern map of Europe began to take shape. But the idea of the nation-state which emerged in modern European history is not one in which a close congruence between ethnicity and the structure of government has been forged. Given the circumstances in which states have been formed, such congruency is almost never realized. Rather, nation-states are best viewed as ‘imagined communities’ [Benedict Anderson] or ‘groups which will themselves to persist’ [Ernest Gellner]. They exist despite differences of race and language, and largely because they are united by ‘common sympathies’ [JS Mill] or a history of common suffering .â•›.â•›. This is what might be called a civic conception of the nation-state. The French, for instance, constitute a nation-state, whether their ancestors were Gauls, Bretons, Normans, Franks, Romans or whatever. Similarly, the English, Irish, Scots and Welsh – notwithstanding their ethnic differences – have been forged into the nation-state of the United Kingdom. In this civic conception, the nation-state can be seen as a device through which class, ethnic and religious tensions within a defined Â� territorial unit can be managed. These nation-states present themselves as independent units in the international arena. From .â•›.â•›. the mid-eighteenth century, it has generally been accepted that the fundamental principle of international law is that of the formal equality of states, a principle which in turn yields those of independence and territorial integrity. These principles of the independence, equality and territorial integrity of sovereign states form the basis for the conduct of international relations .â•›.â•›. [C]ertain structural changes are occurring in the international arena which appear to challenge the traditional role of the nation-state in political and economic affairs. These structural changes involve the twin processes of integration and fragmentation. Although these
�21
The British constitutional order processes seem to be pulling in opposite directions, both present threats to the position of the nation-state as the predominant actor in .â•›.â•›. political affairs. The process of integration is the result of the global impact of economic and technological change. The world which we inhabit is now genuinely global. It has been noted, for example, that today even illiterate labourers working in the deepest recesses of tropical rain forests understand that their livelihoods are not determined by forces operating at the level of their localities or even within the territorial borders of their states, but by the vagaries of world markets and the habits, tastes and capacities of consumers in distant countries. But this observation now applies not only to the cocoa labourers of Ghana but also to workers in the semi-conductor plants of Scotland and north-east England. With the emergence of global markets we see the growth in scale and power of transnational corporations and also the establishment of a variety of international organizations trying to respond to the regulatory issues which are presented. This process of world-wide economic integration necessitates a reconfiguration of the international political arena. The process of fragmentation is, to some extent, a by-product of economic and political integration. With the growth of world markets, for example, the trend has been towards the regionalization of economies, and some of these regional entities (e.g., Singapore/Indonesia or Vancouver/Seattle) have become linked primarily to the global economy rather than to their host nation-states. In response to these economic trends, which have contributed to the resurgence of issues of ethnic identity, more extensive powers of government have been given to regional bodies within the nation-state. This has occurred throughout Europe, notably in the autonomous regions of Spain and the Länder of Germany and as the recent establishment of a Welsh Assembly and a Scottish Parliament indicates, this process has also affected governmental arrangements within the United Kingdom .â•›.â•›. Fragmentation undermines the traditional structures of the nation-state and has prompted the reconfiguration of the national political system. Such contemporary trends of integration and fragmentation are commonly viewed as responses to one powerful phenomenon€– Â�globalization. Since the end of the Second World War, there has been a spectacular growth in transnational investment, production and trade. In turn, this has led to the establishment of global financial markets as the major US, European and Japanese banks have become locked into an international circuit regulating the flow of capital. The major transnational corporations which have emerged now account for a large proportion of the world’s production and these corporations, able to disperse their centres of production, are no longer bounded by the territories of any particular State. Many of these changes have been driven by technological development. A revolution has occurred in transportation and communications systems and, in conjunction with the microchip revolution and the digitalization of information, this has had a profound impact on economic activity. Production is now much less tied to specific localities; enterprises increasingly possess the capacity to shift capital and labour at low cost and high speed. Money is now able to circulate around the world through invisible networks, in vast quantities and at high velocity. These developments – universalized communication, supersonic transportation, hi-tech weaponry and the like – have presented a series of serious challenges to the nation-state. The success of the modern State over the last two hundred years has been
�22
British Government and the Constitution based mainly on its ability to promote economic well-being, to maintain physical security and to foster a distinctive cultural identity of its citizens. Yet it is precisely these claims which are now being undermined by [the forces of globalisation].
Having surveyed the issues, Loughlin’s verdict is that, powerful as the simultaneously integrationist and fragmentary forces of globalisation may be, the state will survive them, and will survive them intact (pp 145–6): Globalization has created a world of greater interdependence. Nevertheless, although the phenomenon seems to undermine the power of the nation-state, it is unlikely to lead to its demise. Indeed, there seems little doubt but that the modern State will remain the primary form of political organization for the foreseeable future .â•›.â•›. The State is still the principal agency for managing the economy and promoting the welfare of its citizens. The critical point for our purposes is that, as a result of structural changes, the State must acknowledge that, to be effective, it must be prepared to work with other powerful agencies. To be successful, the State must be able to harness the immense power now located in private corporations and it must also work in tandem with a range of supra-national governmental bodies. The State, in short, is obliged to share power.
Loughlin’s analysis is supported by Helen Thompson, who comes to a similar conclusion: (‘The modern state and its adversaries’ (2006) 41 Gov and Opp 23, 26, emphasis in the original): [F]or the modern state to be heading towards crisis, or significant long-term change, at least one of three things would have to be true: first, consent to particular and reasonably longestablished sites of authoritative rule is breaking down either through large-scale resistance to the rule of law, or through the rejection of the rules of rule of such a state by a significant section of the political community constituted by it, and those who command the state’s power cannot contain such developments; secondly, previously capable states are unable to command coercive power against those over whom they rule and against their external enemies; thirdly, the laws and demands of international institutions and organizations have enforceable claims against historically sovereign states.
In a compelling overview, Thompson argues that while each of these three phenomena has occurred at least somewhere in the world in recent times, there is no overall pattern that may be attributable to overarching forces of globalisation. She argues, for example, that the ‘most crucial coercive powers that states enjoy are to tax and to command military forces’ and that the evidence ‘does not suggest that states are actually taxing less than they did .â•›.â•›. Neither can it be plausibly claimed that the coercive power of well-established states to tax is diminishing .â•›.â•›. [and] Even more clearly, the ability of previously capable states to mobilize armed force has been unimpaired by the end of the Cold War’ (pp 30–3). While she concedes that not all states today ‘enjoy the same degree of external sovereignty as they did at the end of the 1970s’ (p 34):
�23
The British constitutional order such intervention in the internal affairs of nominally sovereign states does not represent a move beyond Westphalia. In the spirit of Westphalia, powerful states have long tried to curtail the activities of other states as states.
According to Thompson, and contrary to popular myth, the Peace of Westphalia (1648) ‘did not result in external state sovereignty against all other states’. Rather, it ‘legitimized the sovereignty of powerful modern states and the right of those states to impose limits on the statehood of defeated and aspiring states. It defined an external world in which sovereignty depended on power and in which distinctions were made between strong and weak states’ (pp 25–6). Seen in this light, the policies of contemporary institutions such as the World Bank and the IMF, where tough conditions are imposed on states in the developing world, conditions that increasingly speak to constitutional values such as ‘good governance’, ‘accountability’ and ‘transparency’, are not so much a break from the Westphalia model as its continuation by new means: ‘An international economy in which indebted states find that richer states succeed in controlling their economic decision-making and the parameters of their internal politics is repeating past history’ (p 36). Thompson’s conclusions are as follows (pp 39–40): Whilst the internal authority of some poorer states has certainly buckled under the pressure of economic liberalization, it is the external sovereignty of many poor and small states that has diminished most significantly, leaving them unable to resist the demands of other states and international institutions without inviting their own destruction. This is not because of anything that can sensibly be called ‘globalization’. Neither does it mean that the modern state is heading towards a general crisis. Rather it suggests that the number of modern states that can lay claim to effective external sovereignty is diminishing towards the numbers seen in the more distant past. We are returning to some aspects of an older political world in which empire – the rule of a state over territory where it does not, at least at the moment of subjugation, recognize the subjects as its own – was central to the language and practice of politics. The modern state and empire have long been historical bedfellows.
In a lengthy and thoughtful analysis Neil Walker examines a variety of critiques of modern constitutionalism, including those associated with globalisation and post-nationalism. He suggests (as does Gavin Anderson, Constitutional Rights after Globalization (2005)) that what is needed to account for constitutionalism in today’s world is a developed sense of ‘constitutional pluralism’ (‘The idea of constitutional pluralism’ (2002) 65 MLR 317). Walker says, first, that any successful notion of constitutionalism must (p 334): continue to take the state seriously as a significant host to constitutional discourse. Even those who would most urgently contend that constitutionalism has to encompass post-national trends or that constitutionalism is an increasing irrelevance or obstacle to
�24
British Government and the Constitution understanding or steering forms of social and political organisation, would hardly deny the state its place in the constitutional scheme.
He goes on to suggest, however, that: almost equally uncontroversially, a revised conception of constitutionalism should of course then also be open to the discovery of meaningful constitutional discourse and processes in non-state sites .╛.╛. Even for those who are most sceptical or pessimistic about the viability of constitutionalism beyond the state, their position is based either upon an incapacity to imagine the form in which such post-state constitutionalism might be effectively articulated and institutionalised or upon an unwillingness to concede that the time is yet ripe for such an enterprise, rather than upon a refusal in principle to contemplate that a constitutional steering mechanism, or its functional equivalent, might be appropriate for significant � circuits of transnational power.
Be this as it may, in this book we focus in most of our chapters on British constitutional law and practice, albeit that we aim to explain and demonstrate how the British constitution accommodates – sometimes relatively smoothly, but sometimes not – sites of constitutional authority both within the UK (see especially chapter 4) and beyond its borders (see especially chapter 5). In this, perhaps it may be said that we are siding with John Dunn’s judgment (in The Cunning of Unreason (2000), p 66) that, in the UK at least, ‘Only massive selective inattention could stop anyone recognizing that states today remain (as they have been for some time) the principal institutional site of political experience’.
4╇ Constitutional reform In recent years the United Kingdom has been ‘going through a period of profound constitutional change’ (D Oliver, Constitutional Reform in the United Kingdom (2003), p v). The changes are regarded by some commentators to amount to no less than a ‘new British constitution’ (V Bogdanor, The New British Constitution (2009), p x). We would not go so far. Indeed, as we shall show later in this section, there is a very great deal of the ‘old’ constitution that remains. This said, however, there should be no doubting the significance of the reforms which have occurred in recent years and, indeed, which remain ongoing. In the pages that follow we first set out what the main reforms have been, before offering some commentary on how they might best be understood.
(a)╇ An outline The Blair Governments (1997–2007) The ‘New Labour’ Government that took office in Britain in 1997 did so on a series of manifesto commitments to reform aspects of the constitution. In
�25
The British constitutional order
particular, it undertook as follows: to modernise the composition of the House of Lords and the procedures of the House of Commons; to enact freedom of information legislation designed to lead to more open government; to devolve power to Scotland and Wales; to reform local government; to establish a directly elected ‘strategic authority’ and mayor for London; to strengthen regional government in England; to enact human rights enforceable in UK courts; and to continue to work on a bipartisan basis for sustained peace and reform in Northern Ireland (Labour Party manifesto, Because Britain Deserves Better (1997), pp 32–5). The 1997–2001 Parliament passed legislation or introduced other measures in fulfilment of each of the Labour Party’s manifesto pledges on constitutional reform. Thus, the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) incorporated most of the substantive provisions of the ECHR (1950) into domestic law; the Scotland Act 1998 and the Government of Wales Act 1998 devolved power to Scotland and Wales; the ‘Good Friday’ or ‘Belfast’ Agreement led to the enactment of the Northern Ireland Act 1998, under which power was devolved to Northern Ireland; the House of Lords Act 1999 removed most of the hereditary peers from the House of Lords; a Freedom of Information Act was passed in 2000; the Greater London Authority Act 1999 created a mayor and a Greater London Authority for the nation’s capital; the Local Government Act 2000 sought to give a new lease of life to local democracy; and the Regional Development Agencies Act 1998 made provision, albeit modest, for the development of aspects of economic policy on a regional basis. Meanwhile, a newly established Modernisation Committee of the House of Commons considered an array of ways in which Commons procedure could be modernised. A number of these policies had been relatively newly adopted by the Labour Party, whose traditional hostility to a Bill of Rights, for example, had been founded on a fear that a conservative judiciary would use its provisions to defeat progressive or socialist legislation (see J Griffith, The Politics of the Judiciary (5th edn 1997) and K Ewing and C Gearty, Freedom under Thatcher (1990), ch 8). Others were more firmly established. Most of these policies had long been advocated by pressure groups campaigning for constitutional reform (Charter 88, for example, or Liberty (the National Council for Civil Liberties), or the Campaign for Freedom of Information) and several of them had been subjected to detailed analysis by think tanks such as the Institute for Public Policy Research and the Constitution Unit. The latter, in partiÂ�cular, published a series of detailed reports on how to make devolution work, which, along with the groundbreaking work of the Scottish Constitutional Convention (on which, see chapter 4), greatly contributed to the way in which the new Labour Government was able to ‘hit the ground running’ and to embark on its most ambitious constitutional reforms early in its first term. After 2001 the pace of change – especially of legislative change – slowed somewhat, although 2005 saw the enactment of the (slightly misleadingly
�26
British Government and the Constitution
named) Constitutional Reform Act, which substantially reformed the powers and responsibilities of the Lord Chancellor and the judicial appointments process for England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and provided for the creation of a new Supreme Court to replace the appellate committee of the House of Lords and the judicial committee of the Privy Council. (The UK Supreme Court commenced its work in 2009.) Also important in this period was the Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006, which concerns the relationship between the government’s and Parliament’s law-making powers. An important difference between the reforms before and after the 2001 election concerned the process by which they were introduced. A notable feature of the 1997–2001 reforms, especially so given the magnitude of the reforms legislated for, was the smoothness of their implementation. Projects such as devolution or the incorporation of fundamental rights are considerable endeavours. Yet they were each legislated for and implemented with efficiency and apparent ease of effort – at least in part explained by the years of careful thought and planning that had been devoted to these issues by think tanks and pressure groups while Labour was in Opposition. The measure which became the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, by contrast, was born of blunder. In June 2003 the Prime Minister announced a Cabinet reshuffle, one element of which was that the Lord Chancellor and his Department would cease to exist, to be replaced by a Secretary of State of (and Department for) Constitutional Affairs. Only afterwards did it apparently occur to the Prime Minister and the Cabinet Office that the position of Lord Chancellor was a statutory one and that it could therefore be abolished only by an Act of Parliament (the Prime Minister can effect ‘machinery of government’ changes through announcing them himself but cannot amend or repeal legislation; ordinarily only an Act of Parliament can amend or repeal legislation). As the Cabinet Secretary later told the House of Lords Constitution Committee, ‘it was a complete mess-up’ (see House of Lords Constitution Committee, The Cabinet Office and the Centre of Government, 4th report of 2009–10, HL 30, para 193). A fresh Lord Chancellor had therefore to be appointed (Lord Falconer); he steered the required legislation through Parliament, the result being the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. The Constitution Committee was damning in its criticism of this sorry episode, which, it said (at [208]–[210]): involved wholly inadequate consultation both within Government (the Lord Chancellor [Lord Irvine of Lairg] was not consulted before decisions were taken) and outside Government (in particular, the failure to consult the senior judiciary). There was no justification for the failure to consult on these important reforms .â•›.â•›. [T]he scale of the constitutional changes involved, and the content of the necessary legislation, were not properly appreciated. This problem could not have arisen but for the fact that the Lord Chancellor and the senior judiciary were not consulted. Consultation on important constitutional reform is essential to good government.
�27
The British constitutional order
(For further criticism of the process of constitutional reform under Labour, see Baker, ‘Our unwritten constitution’ (2010) 167 Proc Brit Acad 91 and M Flinders, Delegated Governance and the British State (2008).) The measures outlined above are the main reforms of the constitution during the years of the Blair Governments, but they are far from the only measures to have affected aspects of our constitutional law. The period 1997–2007 witnessed significant legislative change in several other areas that touch upon constitutional law and practice. The funding and conduct of political parties was (partially) reformed by the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000; human rights and civil liberties were substantially affected by such legislation as the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, the Extradition Act 2003, the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants) Act 2004 and the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005, among several others; and the period saw a raft of counter-terrorism legislation, including the Terrorism Act 2000, the Antiterrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001, the Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005 and the Terrorism Act 2006; see also in this regard the Civil Contingencies Act 2004. (This legislation and the various matters it concerns are considered throughout this book: the HRA is considered in chapters 2, 10 and 11; the devolution legislation is considered in chapter 4, as is reform of local government; reforms to Parliament are considered in chapter 9; the Constitutional Reform Act is considered in chapter 2; and aspects of the counter-terrorism legislation are considered in chapter 11.)
The Brown Government (2007–10) The story of constitutional reform during Gordon Brown’s time as Prime Minister is an astonishing one and makes for a sobering case study of the gulf in British government between rhetoric and reality or, from a different point of view, of how little government can be expected to deliver, no matter how grand its aspirations. It started in the opening week of Mr Brown’s premiership, no less, as the most ambitious and exciting programme of reform ever seen in the modern era; it ended with a relative mouse of a measure, the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, in which only a fraction of the programme set out in the summer of 2007 was realised. The main events in the story are as follows: (a) the publication of a Green Paper (a Government consultation document) in July 2007, within a week of Mr Brown becoming Prime Minister, The Governance of Britain (Cm 7170); (b) the simultaneous publication in March 2008 of a White Paper (a Government policy document), The Governance of Britain: Constitutional Renewal (Cm 7342) and of a Draft Constitutional Renewal Bill (the Draft Bill was thoroughly scrutinised by a parliamentary Joint Committee on the Draft Constitutional Renewal Bill: see that Committee’s 1st report of 2007–08, HL 166, HC 551, July 2008); (c) the introduction more than a year later of the
�28
British Government and the Constitution
Government’s Constitutional Reform and Governance Bill; (d) the enactment in the mad rush immediately before the general election of 2010 of some, but far from all, of the provisions contained in the Bill, in the form of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010. Each of these events will be discussed in turn. The Governance of Britain Green Paper was cast in broad and grand terms, and sought to limit the powers of the executive, to make the executive more accountable, to re-invigorate British democracy and to review the relationship between the individual and the state. Moreover, it did so by framing the debate in historical terms, giving the strong impression that what the Government had in mind would in the future come to be compared with the great constitutional re-settlements of the seventeenth century. The grand historical narrative which the Green Paper expressly sought to buy into was one in which constitutional power is re-balanced between Parliament and the Government, giving ‘Parliament more ability to hold the Government to account’ (para 10). The Green Paper stated that ‘power remains too centralised and too concentrated in government’ and that ‘it is not sufficiently clear what power government should and should not have’ (para 7). To address these matters, the Green Paper suggested that all the Government’s powers should be placed on a statutory footing and should be ‘brought under stronger parliamentary scrutiny and control’ (para 24). Reforms to Parliament were also suggested: the House of Lords should become ‘substantially or wholly’ elected (para 137), the House of Commons should be ‘revitalised’ (para 139) and new forms of ‘direct democracy’ should be encouraged. A new Bill of Rights and Duties was proposed. All of this, it was thought, would have the potential to lead at least to a new ‘concordat between the executive and Parliament’ or, perhaps, even to a written constitution (para 212). (See further Le Sueur, ‘Gordon Brown’s new constitutional settlement’ [2008] PL 21.) The Draft Constitutional Renewal Bill and the accompanying White Paper of eight months later brought forward only a few of these proposals. The Draft Bill contained provisions: (a) to repeal restrictions enacted in 2005 on protest in the vicinity of Parliament; (b) to place the Attorney General on a statutory footing; (c) to make minor amendments to judicial appointments; (d) to place onto a statutory footing Parliament’s conventional powers with regard to the ratification of treaties; and (e) to place the civil service on a statutory basis for the first time. The very large gulf between the promise of the Green Paper and the provisions of the Draft Bill was obvious to everyone. Whatever the merits of the individual reforms provided for by the Draft Bill, its contents could hardly be described as ‘constitutional renewal’! In addition to the measures contained in the Draft Bill, the accompanying White Paper dealt with three further matters. It proposed a new parliamentary resolution requiring the Government to seek Parliament’s approval of a decision to send Her Majesty’s armed forces into conflict overseas; it announced that the rules concerning the flying of the Union flag from Government buildings had been liberalised;
�29
The British constitutional order
and it announced the Government’s intention to make a number of changes to the way the Intelligence and Security Committee is appointed and operates (this is the committee which oversees the UK’s security and secret intelligence services: MI5 (the Security Service), MI6 (the Secret Intelligence Service) and Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ)). The Constitutional Reform and Governance Bill was long delayed, not being published until July 2009 (fifteen months after the Draft Bill and twelve months after the Joint Committee’s report on the Draft Bill). No reason for this delay was given. The Bill included provisions on four of the five areas covered in the Draft Bill: the provisions on the Attorney General were dropped, while provisions on the civil service, on the ratification of treaties, on demonstrations in the vicinity of Parliament and on judicial appointments remained. Added to the Bill were provisions on a variety of matters not included in the Draft Bill. Some of these were minor and need not detain us. But of note were provisions concerning membership of the House of Lords. These were tidying-up measures, falling a long way short of the stated ideal of the ‘substantially or wholly’ elected House referred to the in the Governance of Britain Green Paper. It was proposed that the 92 remaining hereditary peers should no longer be replaced, one by one, such that the number of remaining hereditaries would instead dwindle over time rather than being kept at 92. Further clauses provided for the expulsion, suspension or resignation of members from the House of Lords. As the Bill progressed though its legislative stages in the House of Commons, a considerable number of provisions were added to it by way of Government amendments. Fresh clauses were added on the conduct of referendums; clauses were also added that would have established a nationwide referendum to be held on whether the electoral system for the House of Commons should be changed from first-past-the-post to the alternative vote system (‘AV’ – see further on this below); clauses were introduced that substantially amended the Parliamentary Standards Act 2009; new provisions were added concerning the tax status of MPs and members of the House of Lords; and an amendment to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 was also introduced at a late stage in the Bill’s passage through the Commons. The Bill as amended was eventually passed by the Commons and was sent to the House of Lords in March 2010. Parliament was dissolved early the following month, as a general election had been called for 6 May 2010. Thus, what had started out in the summer of 2007 as such a grand ‘renewal’ of Britain’s constitution had been reduced to an omnibus Bill of constitutional miscellany, much delayed, much amended and, now, much rushed. The House of Lords had time to hold a second reading debate on the Bill (that is, a debate on its general principles) but detailed consideration of its many and various provisions proved impossible, owing to time having run out. In the event the Bill went into what is called the ‘wash-up’, the curious and frenetic few days in the dying days of a Parliament in which the political parties engage in crude
�30
British Government and the Constitution
horse-trading, Â�deciding behind closed doors which provisions from which Bills before Parliament will be allowed to pass into law. The House of Lords Constitution Committee was far from alone in expressing its dismay, sadness and, indeed, anger that such were the depths to which Labour’s once-Â�cherished plans for constitutional reform had fallen. ‘This is no way to undertake the task of constitutional reform’, it flatly stated, in a damning verdict that was echoed on all sides of the House (see House of Lords Constitution Committee, Constitutional Reform and Governance Bill, 11th report of 2009–10, HL 98, para 47; and HL Deb vol 718, cols 958–1056, 24 March 2010). The enactment that came out of the wash-up contains only about half of the provisions that had found their way into the Bill by the time it had arrived in the Lords: thus, the principal provisions of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 place the civil service on a statutory footing; provide for Parliament to approve (or, as the case may be, not to approve) treaties ratified by ministers; make substantial amendments to the Parliamentary Standards Act 2009; and impose new requirements on the tax status of MPs and members of the House of Lords. One of the main themes of the Governance of Britain Green Paper was that the non-statutory (or prerogative) powers of the Government should either be placed on a legislative footing or, at least, made subject to greater parliamentary oversight. The Constitutional Reform and Governance Act achieves this for two such powers: the constitutional position of civil servants is now governed by statute (rather than, as formerly, under the prerogative) and powers to ratify treaties are now, as a matter of statute, subject to parliamentary scrutiny (the ratification of treaties is a prerogative power). But the vast bulk of the Government’s prerogative powers remain unaffected, despite the promises of the 2007 Green Paper. Even the war powers resolution, also promised by the 2008 White Paper, did not materialise. To take two further examples, in The Governance of Britain Green Paper the Government stated that, before seeking a dissolution of Parliament, the Prime Minister should be required to seek the approval of the House of Commons. It also stated that it should be for a majority of MPs, rather than (as now) for the government, to request any recall of Parliament during a recess. Both of these reform ideas were passed for consideration to the House of Commons Modernisation Committee, chaired by the Leader of the House of Commons (a Cabinet minister; in the relevant period this was Harriet Harman MP). This was for the reason, presumably, that they could be effected through a change to the Standing Orders of the Houses of Parliament and would not require legislation. The Modernisation Committee issued a call for evidence in the autumn of 2007 but then appears simply to have ceased to meet. No reasons for this were given and the reforms as to dissolution and recall suggested in the Governance of Britain Green Paper disappeared alongside the Modernisation Committee’s demise (see Blackburn, ‘The prerogative power of dissolution of Parliament: law, practice and reform’ [2009] PL 766). It Â�encapsulated the fate of constitutional reform under Gordon Brown.
�31
The British constitutional order
The Coalition Government (2010 to date) Both parties in the Coalition Government that took office following the 2010 general election went into that election committed to a series of constitutional reforms. While full-scale constitutional reform is a policy most often associated with the Liberal Democrats, David Cameron’s Conservative Party had by 2010 also pledged itself to a variety of reforms. Among the Liberal Democrats’ priorities were: a proportionate system of voting to replace the first-past-thepost system used for elections to the House of Commons; the introduction of fixed-term parliaments; an elected House of Lords; a written constitution; and a Freedom Bill designed to roll back the incursions into civil liberties witnessed under previous governments. Conservative policies included the following: to reduce by 10 per cent the size of the House of Commons; to establish a system of ‘English votes for English laws’, meaning that only MPs representing constituencies in England would be permitted to vote on measures affecting only England; the repeal of the Human Rights Act and its replacement with a British Bill of Rights; a Referendum Bill, requiring a referendum to be held before the UK could ratify any future EU treaty; and a Sovereignty Bill, re-affirming the supremacy of Parliament. The Coalition Government’s Programme for Government, published in May 2010, set out a series of policies which sought to combine aspects of these ideas. On ‘political reform’, the Government stated as follows: The Government believes that our political system is broken. We urgently need fundamental political reform, including a referendum on electoral reform, much greater co-operation across party lines, and changes to our political system to make it far more transparent and accountable. • We will establish five-year fixed-term Parliaments. We will put a binding motion before the House of Commons stating that the next general election will be held on the first Thursday of May 2015. Following this motion, we will legislate to make provision for fixed-term Parliaments of five years. This legislation will also provide for dissolution if 55% or more of the House votes in favour. • We will bring forward a Referendum Bill on electoral reform, which includes provision for the introduction of the Alternative Vote in the event of a positive result in the referendum, as well as for the creation of fewer and more equal sized constituencies. We will whip both Parliamentary parties in both Houses to support a simple majority referendum on the Alternative Vote, without prejudice to the positions parties will take during such a referendum. • We will bring forward early legislation to introduce a power of recall, allowing voters to force a by-election where an MP is found to have engaged in serious wrongdoing and having had a petition calling for a by-election signed by 10% of his or her constituents. • We will establish a committee to bring forward proposals for a wholly or mainly elected upper chamber on the basis of proportional representation. The committee will come forward with a draft motion by December 2010. It is likely that this will advocate single
�32
British Government and the Constitution long terms of office. It is also likely that there will be a grandfathering system for current Peers. In the interim, Lords appointments will be made with the objective of creating a second chamber that is reflective of the share of the vote secured by the political parties in the last general election. • We will bring forward the proposals of the Wright Committee for reform to the House of Commons in full [see further on this below] – starting with the proposed committee for management of backbench business. A House Business Committee, to consider government business, will be established by the third year of the Parliament .â•›.â•›. • We will establish a commission to consider the ‘West Lothian question’ .â•›.â•›. • We will cut the perks and bureaucracy associated with Parliament .â•›.â•›. • We will ensure that any petition that secures 100,000 signatures will be eligible for formal debate in Parliament. The petition with the most signatures will enable members of the public to table a bill eligible to be voted on in Parliament. • We will introduce a new ‘public reading stage’ for bills to give the public an opportunity to comment on proposed legislation online, and a dedicated ‘public reading day’ within a bill’s committee stage where those comments will be debated by the committee scrutinising the bill .â•›.â•›.
Also worth noting here is what the Coalition’s Programme for Government stated about civil liberties: We will be strong in defence of freedom. The Government believes that the British state has become too authoritarian, and that over the past decade it has abused and eroded fundamental human freedoms and historic civil liberties. We need to restore the rights of individuals in the face of encroaching state power, in keeping with Britain’s tradition of freedom and fairness. • We will implement a full programme of measures to reverse the substantial erosion of civil liberties and roll back state intrusion. • We will introduce a Freedom Bill. • We will scrap the ID card scheme, the National Identity register and the ContactPoint database, and halt the next generation of biometric passports. • We will outlaw the finger-printing of children at school without parental permission. • We will extend the scope of the Freedom of Information Act to provide greater transpaÂ� rency .â•›.â•›. • We will protect historic freedoms through the defence of trial by jury. • We will restore rights to non-violent protest. • We will review libel laws to protect freedom of speech. • We will introduce safeguards against the misuse of anti-terrorism legislation. • We will further regulate CCTV. • We will end the storage of internet and email records without good reason. • We will introduce a new mechanism to prevent the proliferation of unnecessary new criminal offences.
�33
The British constitutional order • We will establish a Commission to investigate the creation of a British Bill of Rights that incorporates and builds on all our obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights, ensures that these rights continue to be enshrined in British law, and protects and extends British liberties. We will seek to promote a better understanding of the true scope of these obligations and liberties.
It is immediately obvious that this is a potentially far-reaching and ambitious programme of reform. Some of it takes further aspects of constitutional reform adopted under Labour (most notably with regard to devolution, which we consider in detail in chapter 4). Some of it keeps under consideration aspects of constitutional reform which had become stalled under Labour (eg, the ideas for a partially/substantially/wholly elected House of Lords and the issues surrounding the replacement of the Human Rights Act with a British Bill of Rights). Some of it sets out to reverse aspects of Labour policy (especially as regards civil liberties). And some of it is new, introducing aspects of constitutional reform that had not featured on Labour’s agenda (such as the introduction of fixed-term parliaments). A comprehensive analysis was produced with remarkable speed by the Constitution Unit: see R Hazell, The Conservative-Liberal Democrat Agenda for Constitutional and Political Reform (2010), available from the Constitution Unit website. The first Bills published in pursuit of this agenda were the Identity Documents Bill, the Fixed-term Parliaments Bill and the Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill. The Identity Documents Act 2010 repealed the Identity Cards Act 2006, thereby abolishing the scheme for identity cards introduced by the Labour Government, and required the Secretary of State to destroy all data contained in the National Identity Register. The Fixed-term Parliaments Bill will set the date for the next and for successive general elections, fixing the parliamentary term for Westminster at five years, the next scheduled election therefore being due in May 2015. Provision is made for an earlier election to take place if the House of Commons passes a motion of no confidence in the Government and if no other Government can be formed within 14 days. Provision is also made for an earlier election to take place if the House of Commons, by a two-thirds majority, passes a motion to that effect. (In this respect the Bill as introduced is different from the Programme for Government (above), which had suggested a 55 per cent threshold for such a vote.) If enacted, the Bill will abolish the Crown prerogative of dissolution and, more importantly perhaps, will abolish the power previously vested by constitutional convention in the Prime Minister to choose the timing of the next general election. Among the issues which immediately sparked controversy are: the proposed length of the fixed term (five years rather than four) and the two-thirds rule. The Bill was subjected to detailed and, in several respects, critical scrutiny by the House of Lords Constitution Committee in that committee’s 8th report of 2010–11, HL 69.
�34
British Government and the Constitution
The Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Act 2011 provided for a referendum to be held in May 2011 on whether the system for elections to the House of Commons should be changed from first-past-the-post to the AV system (the different voting systems are explained in chapter 8). In the event the option of moving to AV was comprehensively defeated. It also provides for the size of the House of Commons to be reduced from its present 650 seats to 600 seats. Under the Act, the Boundary Commissions, the public bodies responsible for drawing up parliamentary constituencies, are required to report their recommendations as to the re-drawn constituencies by October 2013, with a view to the scheduled 2015 general election being conducted on the basis of the new constituencies. The main controversy concerning this Act is the speed with which the Boundary Commissions are expected to work: their reviews of parliamentary constituencies are complex, politically sensitive and frequently contested. Considerable care will have to be taken to avoid any suspicion or allegation of bias, unfairness or gerrymandering. The measure was strongly criticised both by the House of Commons Political and Constitutional Reform Committee (3rd report of 2010–11, HC 437) and by the House of Lords Constitution Committee (7th report of 2010–11, HL 58). Other Bills affecting aspects of constitutional reform to have been introduced by the Coalition Government in its first parliamentary session are the Public Bodies Bill (containing extraordinary ministerial powers to order the abolition, merger or modification of very large numbers of public bodies); the Scotland Bill (amending the Scotland Act 1998 and altering arrangements for Scottish devolution, on which see chapter 4); the European Union Bill (requiring a referendum to be held before certain powers can transferred from the UK to the EU, and seeking to re-assert the sovereignty of Parliament, on which see chapter 5); and the Protection of Freedoms Bill (amending certain aspects of the law relating to civil liberties). Several features of these Bills have proved to be immensely controversial: see, eg, the report of the House of Lords Constitution Committee on the Public Bodies Bill (6th report of 2010–11, HL 51) and the reports of the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee on the European Union Bill (10th and 15th reports of 2010–11, HC 633 and HC 682). A Draft House of Lords Reform Bill was published in May 2011. Progress of these various measures will be tracked on www.adamtomkins.net.
Constitutional reform before 1997 Despite all this activity, two points must be emphasised. The first is that what is listed above cannot be taken to be a complete or even a particularly coherent project of overall constitutional reform; the second is that it is not to be implied that the constitution was somehow static or unreformed in the years before 1997. To expand on each of these points, taking them in reverse order: the Conservative Governments of 1970–74 and 1979–97 (under
�35
The British constitutional order
Prime Ministers Edward Heath, Margaret Thatcher and John Major) were not uniformly or Â�dogmatically conservative regarding the constitution. On the contrary, significant constitutional reforms took place during this time. It was under Edward Heath, for example, that the UK acceded to the Treaties establishing the European Communities (see the European Communities Act 1972). There has arguably not been a measure as reforming of the British constitution as has the UK’s membership of the EU for more than a century. As we shall see in detail in chapter 5, membership of the EU has had a profound impact on our constitutional arrangements, principles and understandings. From Mrs Thatcher’s time in office, three sets of constitutional changes stand out: her reforms to the civil service (especially the establishment within the civil service of ‘next steps’ or executive agencies: see chapter 6); the way in which her Government’s extensive programme of privatisation was accompanied by a novel system of regulation; and her Government’s record on civil liberties, which saw both significant legislation (such as the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, the Public Order Act 1986 and the Official Secrets Act 1989) and internationally renowned activity in the form of the Government’s engagement in litigation (most notoriously, but not only, in the ‘Spycatcher’ affair (above, p 14). (For a forthright overview, see K Ewing and C Gearty, Freedom under Thatcher (1990)).
(b)╇ Evaluation A new constitution? Labour’s programme of reform has been said to amount to ‘a new constitutional settlement, which will be looked back on as the major achievement of the new Blair Government’ (R Hazell (ed), Constitutional Futures (1999), p 1). Vernon Bogdanor (Professor of Government at Oxford) claims that the changes witnessed since 1997 cannot ‘be understood in evolutionary terms’ and that ‘they represent nothing less than a revolution in our constitutional affairs, a radical discontinuity from what has happened before’ (V Bogdanor, The New British Constitution (2009), p 276). These, with respect, are surely over-statements. Whether constitutional reform will in the future be regarded as the major achievement of the Blair Government is not for us to judge. What we can say is that, no matter how significant the various reforms, they do not amount to ‘a new constitutional settlement’. On the contrary, there is a good deal of the present constitution that continues to operate much as it has for decades. Professor Bogdanor’s argument is that whereas the ‘old’ British constitution was concerned principally with facilitating the exercise of power at the centre, the ‘new’ constitution is concerned with dispersing that power among a variety of elites. The power traditionally concentrated in Westminster and Whitehall has been devolved downwards (to Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and
�36
British Government and the Constitution
London), it has been surrendered upwards (to supranational bodies such as the EU), it has been made newly subject to judicial endorsement (in the courts of law) and it has dispersed even within Westminster – from Commons to Lords – as the Upper House has increased in its assertiveness and levels of activity since its membership was reformed in 1999. Even if the endpoint of the new constitution has not yet been reached (‘it is as yet incomplete and its final outlines are .â•›.â•›. only partially discernible’, Bogdanor writes: p xi), even if grave uncertainty remains over a number of its key ingredients (especially so with regard to the future of the House of Lords and of local government) and even if we cannot yet definitively say what has replaced it, the old constitution, Bogdanor flatly insists, ‘no longer exists’ (p xiii). While there is much of value in Bogdanor’s analysis, we cannot agree with his conclusions. In the excitement of the early years of the Blair Government’s reforms, it was easy, perhaps, to get carried away. In the introduction to their edited collection of essays, Constitutional Reform (1999), Robert Blackburn and Raymond Plant stated, for example, that ‘taken as a whole, the parameters and range of subjects affected [by the Government’s plans in the field of constitutional reform] cover virtually the entire terrain of our constitutional structure’ (p 1). This was never the case. The ‘Westminster model’ is still intact. Britain remains a constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy with a bicameral legislature; the Prime Minister and the Cabinet continue to be constitutionally accountable for their policies and decisions to Parliament; and the judiciary continues to be independent, even if its constitutional powers have grown since 1972 (and again since 1997). There are significant aspects of the British constitution that remain largely untouched by the post-1997 reforms. These include the monarchy, most of the Crown’s prerogative powers, the structure of government and the relationship between ministers and civil servants (see chapters 6 and 7); rule- and lawmaking by the government – delegated legislation and suchlike (see chapter 7); the UK’s relationship with the EU, and the impact of EU law on the constitution (see chapter 5); and the relationship between the House of Commons and the House of Lords, which has not been substantially altered since 1911. The great constitutional statutes of the past continue since 1997 as they did before to shape the constitutional order of today: Magna Carta, the Bill of Rights 1689, the Act of Settlement 1701 and so on. As we shall see throughout this book, were we to confine our attention to events and laws that occurred or have been passed only since 1997, it would result in our having an extremely odd – and untenable – view of the constitution. It is essential that students and scholars of the constitution grasp the venerable and the continuing, as well as the new and the changing, elements of our constitutional order. To privilege either over the other would be a serious error. (For recent literature that explains aspects of the importance of the past to an understanding of the contemporary constitution, see J Allison, The English Historical Constitution (2007); R van Caenegem, An Historical Introduction to
�37
The British constitutional order
Western Constitutional Law (1995); A Tomkins, Our Republican Constitution (2005), ch 3; and E Wicks, The Evolution of a Constitution (2006).) A different view is put forward by another Professor of Government, Anthony King. In The British Constitution (2007), Professor King argues, as does Vernon Bogdanor, that the ‘old’ constitution has been replaced by a new one. But this is about the limit of their agreement. Whereas Bogdanor sees a logic to the new constitution (a logic of the dispersal of power), in King’s analysis what we now have is merely ‘a mess’ (The British Constitution, p 345): ‘some of the changes were intended, some were unintended, some were intended but had unintended consequences, and some were undoubtedly intended, but not as part of any scheme of constitutional change’, he says (p 349). Furthermore, King argues that the great changes to the constitution have taken place over a 40-year period and that these changes ‘go far wider than anything initiated by the post-1997 Labour government’ (p 345). The three key changes, in King’s view, have been: (1) the UK’s accession to the EU, which, he says, has ‘substantially increas[ed] the role played by the judiciary’ (p 346); (2) the fact that ‘the judges have further augmented their role all by themselves’ (ibid); and (3) the fact that local government has been all but destroyed – it has become a ‘ghost’, he says (p 151). (On the increased constitutional role of the judiciary in Britain, see further below; on local Â�government, see chapter 4.) A sober assessment of the constitutional reforms seen since 1997 is offered in a series of papers by the political scientist Matthew Flinders. In a compelling analysis, he divides Labour’s period in office into five phases, as follows: activity (1997–2001); fatigue (2001–05); anomie (2005–07); optimism (2007–09); and timidity (2009–10). Our own, perhaps less kind, assessment runs like this: activity (1997–2002); blunder (2003–05); withdrawal (2005–07); rhetorical revival (2007); and crushing disappointment (2008–10). Flinders relies on a large body of research in political science to argue that real success in constitutional reform requires the presence of three variables: first, there must be public pressure for change; secondly, there must be a constitutional entrepreneur strategically located within government with the capacity to drive reform forward; and, thirdly, there needs to be some sort of critical moment (even a crisis) of sufficient magnitude to induce a broad ideational shift among the political elite (Flinders, ‘Bagehot smiling: Gordon Brown’s “new constitution” and the revolution that did not happen’ (2010) 81 Pol Q 57, p 62). Applying these variables to Labour’s time in office, he comes to a conclusion rather different from that preferred by commentators such as Bogdanor and King: The period 1997–2009 was undoubtedly a critical period in British constitutional history. A new government was elected into office after 18 years of Conservative government on the basis of a commitment to democratic change that can be framed as one of ‘aversive constitutionalism’ (that is, a critique of the past that is used to construct and promote a quite different constitutional order). And yet .â•›.â•›. ironically the underlying principle of New Labour’s constitutional
�38
British Government and the Constitution statecraft has been a commitment to maintaining the core power-hoarding components of the Westminster model (that is, a simple plurality electoral system, executive dominance within the Palace of Westminster, and executive vetos and opt-outs in relation to other measures) .â•›.â•›. Labour ministers never operated within a political context in which there was visible and significant public pressure for change. This reflected three interrelated aspects of British constitutional development: the capacity of the existing constitutional system to avoid crises by evolving to mitigate social pressures; the failure of pro-reform groups .â•›.â•›. to either orchestrate a social movement for change or convince the two main political parties of the substance of their arguments; and the relative disinterest of the British public in constitutional matters. Numerous public opinion polls reveal that when offered a portfolio of contemporary issues (crime, health policy, immigration, etc) the public will consistently place democratic renewal at the bottom of the list .â•›.â•›. [A further feature was] the absence of a constitutional entrepreneur. Tony Blair was never a wholehearted supporter of radical reform. Many of the most far-reaching measures passed during 1997–2001 were carried through on the momentum of John Smith’s legacy rather than on Blair’s personal commitment. Gordon Brown’s capacity to emerge as a constitutional entrepreneur was reduced by his personal indecisiveness over specific measures (for example, for a written constitution but against electoral reform) and the existence of many anti-reform Cabinet members .â•›.â•›. [Neither has there been] a broader ideational shift among the political elite in favour of change. Both the Labour party and the Conservative party remain, at root, committed to the precepts of a power-hoarding constitution .â•›.â•›. Yet what is arguably most clear about the future trajectory of British democracy is that it is likely to be unstable: the constitution is in a transitional stage and the next government (post-2010) will have no choice but to make a number of difficult decisions regarding institutional dynamics .â•›.â•›. and ‘unfinished business’ .â•›.â•›.
Flinders endorses the point made above that continuity is as much a theme of the contemporary British constitution as is change. (See also Flinders, ‘Charter 88, New Labour and constitutional anomie’ (2009) 62 Parl Aff 645; Flinders, ‘Constitutional anomie: patterns of democracy and “The Governance of Britain”’ (2009) 44 Gov and Opp 385; and Tomkins, ‘Constitutionalism’, in M Flinders, A Gamble, C Hay and M Kenny (eds), Oxford Handbook of British Politics (2009), ch 14.)
No overall agenda? The coherence of constitutional reform It would be better, then, to think in terms of discrete constitutional reforms (in the plural) rather than of a single programme of constitutional reform. As Dawn Oliver suggests (in Constitutional Reform in the United Kingdom (2003), p 3): there has been no master plan .â•›.â•›. No coherent ‘vision’ of democracy or citizenship or good governance or constitutionalism has informed the various actors who have brought about the changes .â•›.â•›. The reforms have often been introduced as pragmatic responses to political pressures and perceived problems, on an ad hoc, incremental basis.
�39
The British constitutional order
The closest we have come to a ‘master plan’ was undoubtedly Gordon Brown’s Green Paper, The Governance of Britain (2007), but we saw above what happened to that. In The Politics of the British Constitution ((1999), ch 4) Michael Foley chronicles how the leading advocates for each of the major planks of constitutional reform in the late 1990s were different from one another. Those pushing for a Bill of Rights were not the same as those who desired to see Scottish devolution. Those campaigning for greater freedom of information were not the same as those who advocated reform of Parliament, and so forth. But it was not only the identity of the campaigners that was different: the methods they used, the reasons they set out and the eagerness of the Labour Party to accept the argument varied across each of the main areas of constitutional reform. It is well known, for example, that the Labour Party was already committed to Scottish devolution before Tony Blair become its leader (in 1994, following the sudden death of John Smith) and that Mr Blair, while not himself free of reservations about the desirability and attractiveness of Scottish devolution, felt that this was one policy that he could not safely unpick – especially, perhaps, while he was doing battle with his party over ‘Clause IV’, the now-removed provision of the Labour Party’s constitution that committed it to public ownership (see further Walker, ‘Constitutional reform in a cold climate’, in A Tomkins (ed), Devolution and the British Constitution (1998), ch 5 and N Johnson, Reshaping the British Constitution (2004)). Nonetheless, it may be that a number of themes can be said to run through the various post-1997 reforms. In her thoughtful account of constitutional reform, Dawn Oliver locates three such themes at its core: democracy, citizenship and good governance (Constitutional Reform in the United Kingdom (2003), esp chs 2, 3 and 19). A number of constitutional reforms touch on aspects of democracy. Electoral reform and reforms to the composition of the House of Lords may enhance representative democracy, while devolution and greater freedom of information may help to develop opportunities to participate more effectively in government (on democracy and the constitution, see further chapter 2). While the first-past-the-post electoral system continues to be used for elections to the House of Commons, it is no longer the only electoral system used in the UK: elements of systems of ‘proportional representation’ are used for elections to the Scottish Parliament, to the Welsh Assembly and to the European Parliament (see further chapter 8). In 1997 the Government appointed an independent commission (under the chairmanship of Lord Jenkins) to review the voting system for the House of Commons (see Cm 4090, discussed in chapter 8), but its recommendations were not carried forward, and this was an aspect of constitutional reform that stalled relatively soon in the lifetime of the Blair Government. The Coalition Government’s referendum on AV has been considered above. Citizenship – or, at least, a certain liberal conception of citizenship – may be said to have been enhanced through the enactment of provisions that confer
�40
British Government and the Constitution
new constitutional rights on individuals (and corporations). The HRA and the Freedom of Information Act 2000 may be said to be important in this regard (see too, in Scotland, the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, which in some respects is stronger than the Westminster Act). (For a critical appraisal of the ‘thinness’ of the human-rights-based, liberal conception of citizenship, see Bellamy, ‘Constitutive citizenship versus constitutional rights’, in T Campbell, K Ewing and A Tomkins (eds), Sceptical Essays on Human Rights (2001), ch 2; for a more positive appraisal, see D Oliver, Constitutional Reform in the United Kingdom (2003), ch 6). Britain’s post-1997 rights legislation has strongly privileged civil and political rights over economic and social rights, an ‘imbalance’ that has been condemned by writers such as Ewing (‘Social rights and constitutional law’ [1999] PL 104; see also C Fabre, Social Rights under the Constitution: Government and the Decent Life (2000)). The rights which are incorporated into UK law by the HRA comprise the following: the right to life; freedom from torture, inhuman or degrading treatment; freedom from slavery or servitude; the right to liberty and to security of the person; the right to a fair trial; freedom from retroactive criminal law; the right to respect for private and family life; freedom of thought, conscience and religion; freedom of expression; freedom of peaceful assembly and association; the right to marry; freedom from discrimination; the right to peaceful enjoyment of property; the right to education; the right to free elections; and freedom from the death penalty. Social and economic rights, such as the right to work, the right to a decent wage, the right to social security or other welfare provision, the right to adequate health care and the right to housing, are not included, although it may be that the rights and duties codified (and to some extent enhanced) under the Equality Act 2010 may in time take on a constitutional significance in this regard. ‘Good governance’, says Oliver (above, p 47), comprises the following values: ‘openness and transparency’; ‘appropriate mechanisms of accountability’ (whether ‘political, legal, public or auditing’); ‘appropriate provisions to maximise the effectiveness of government’; ‘encouragement for public participation’; and ‘constitutional arrangements’ that promote ‘legitimacy’, ‘trustworthiness’, ‘reliability’, an ‘absence of corruption’ and ‘respect for human rights’. This is a far-reaching list and it is not clear that all of these objectives can simultaneously be achieved. Some would argue, for example, that accountability or enhanced public participation may in some instances make government less effective, not more so. Others would object that this is simply a wish-list, fine for the ivory tower but impractical – implausible even – as a basis for the conduct of the sometimes necessarily dirty business of government. Can an effective national security policy, for example, successfully be run on the basis solely of the values listed here? That said, it is clear that perceived deficiencies in the decision-making processes of government motivated a number of arguments for constitutional reform. The issues are perceptively analysed
�41
The British constitutional order
in C Foster and F Plowden, The State Under Stress (1996); see also C Foster, British Government in Crisis (2005).
The revival of Parliament? It may be claimed that a further theme underpinning constitutional reform – ideally, if not always in practice – is that of the revival of Parliament. The House of Commons reformed a number of its more archaic working practices (eg, in allowing some bills to be carried over from one session to the next, instead of having to be started afresh: a reform mainly of benefit to the government). Acting on recommendations from its Modernisation Committee for strengthening the scrutiny of legislation and extending opportunities for debate, the Commons introduced procedures for the regular programming of bills and for debates to be held in the ‘parallel chamber’ of Westminster Hall. Reforms such as these helped to make the House more effective, but critics continued to argue that more radical change was needed for the House to secure the full accountability of government. We saw above how the Modernisation Committee, in contrast to its earlier enthusiasm for reform, simply sat on (and thereby quashed) a number of reform ideas put forward in the 2007 Governance of Britain Green Paper, ideas which would have further contributed to a revival of Parliament. The year 2009 was a disastrous one for Parliament, and for the House of Commons in particular, as the ‘MPs’ expenses scandal’ became the dominant political story of the year. Flinders summarises what happened (‘Bagehot smiling: Gordon Brown’s “new constitution” and the revolution that did not happen’ (2010) 81 Pol Q 57, p 59): In May 2009 the Telegraph newspaper published extensive details of how MPs had utilised the expenses regime over recent years. This created a widespread sense of public anger as, day after day, more revelations were revealed about the manner in which MPs had apparently abused the Additional Members Allowance to make significant personal financial gains .â•›.â•›. [I]t led to the forced resignation of the Speaker of the House of Commons and several ministers, the de-selection or early retirement of a significant number of MPs, the voluntary repayment of over £700,000 by MPs, a palpable feeling of crisis within the Palace of Westminster .â•›.â•›., the election of a new ‘clean break’ Speaker, police investigations and an Inland Revenue inquiry, and an almost frenzied media and public debate about the failings of British democracy and the need for far-reaching reforms.
The Government’s reaction to the expenses scandal – more accurately, the allowances scandal – was the Parliamentary Standards Act 2009, which created a new body, the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA), to oversee a revised regime of MPs’ pay, allowances and expenses arrangements. The scandal was also at least partly responsible for an unprecedented turnover of MPs at the 2010 election: 149 sitting MPs retired at the election and 227
�42
British Government and the Constitution
of the MPs elected in 2010 entered Parliament in that year for the first time (ie, 35 per cent of MPs were entirely new to the House). (See further Kelso, ‘Parliament on its knees: MPs’ expenses and the crisis of transparency at Westminster’ (2009) 80 Pol Q 329 and Leyland, ‘Freedom of information and the 2009 parliamentary expenses scandal’ [2009] PL 675.) Another response to the scandal was the establishment in the summer of 2009 of an all-party House of Commons Reform Committee. Under the chairmanship of the much-respected senior Labour backbencher Tony Wright MP (who had for several years chaired the Public Administration Select Committee), the Committee published an important report, Rebuilding the House (1st report of 2009–10, HC 1117). The Wright Committee made a series of recommendations designed to enhance the power and the position of the House of Commons (and especially of backbench MPs) over the government of the day. It recommended that the chairs and members of select committees should be elected by the House as a whole rather than appointed by the party Whips (select committees, in the main, scrutinise the actions, policies and decisions of government departments: they are principally concerned with Parliament’s scrutiny or accountability functions rather than with its legislative functions: see further chapter 9). Select committees are appointed for the duration of a Parliament at the beginning of its term (ie, following a general election). In 2010 the chairs and members of the Commons’ select committees were indeed elected, for the first time, in accordance with the Â�recommendations of the Wright Committee. The Wright Committee also recommended that the House of Commons should take greater ownership over its own agenda. At present, the bulk of Commons time is controlled by the Government, albeit that a limited amount of time is set aside for backbench or Opposition debates. The Wright Committee recommended the establishment of a new elected Backbench Committee, which would have the task of coordinating, alongside the Government’s business managers, the Commons’ time and agenda. These recommendations have not yet been implemented but, as we saw above, the Coalition Government undertook in its Programme for Government to ‘bring forward the proposals of the Wright Committee for reform to the House of Commons in full – starting with the proposed committee for management of backbench business. A House Business Committee, to consider government business, will be established by the third year of the Parliament’. (Cf HC Deb vol 506, col 1099, 4 March 2010; for further comment, see the Editorial (co-authored by Tony Wright), ‘Reforming Parliament (again)’ (2010) 81 Pol Q 163.) As for the House of Lords, since the partial reform to its membership in 1999 it has grown in assertiveness and effectiveness as it performs the functions of a revising chamber. Among the issues for which the Upper House has had a particular regard in recent years is the constitution; it has also been vocal (more so on several occasions than the Commons) in its defence of civil liberties. Yet a very big question mark continues to hang over the House of Lords. Plainly
�43
The British constitutional order
it is not a democratic chamber. No-one is elected to it by the public at large. Members of the House of Lords are appointed. Accordingly, we must pose the question of whether the House of Lords is as impressive and effective an institution because it is unelected or despite the fact that it is unelected. Could a way be found to bring democracy to the Upper House without jeopardising the undoubtedly high quality of its work? Sir John Baker’s view is that the future of the House of Lords is ‘the paramount constitutional concern today’ (‘Our unwritten constitution’ (2010) 167 Proc Brit Acad 91, p 113). It is difficult to disagree. (See further Russell, ‘House of Lords reform: are we nearly there yet?’ (2009) 80 Pol Q 119; Lipsey, ‘What the House of Lords is really for?’ (2009) 80 Pol Q 400; and Lord Bingham, ‘The House of Lords: its future’ [2010] PL 261.)
Towards juristocracy? Finally on this topic of the themes of constitutional reform, it is frequently claimed that a key idea underpinning a number of the post-1997 reforms has been significantly and substantially to enhance the constitutional power and authority of the judiciary, to such an extent that it is now to the courts (rather than to Parliament) that we should look to take the lead responsibility in seeking to hold government to account. As Robert Hazell has claimed, ‘the judges would not admit it, but they have emerged immensely stronger’ (‘The continuing dynamism of constitutional reform’ (2007) 60 Parl Aff 3, p 17). Regardless of whether we should express the position in terms as bold as these, what is clear – to opponents and supporters of enhanced judicial power alike – is that the constitutional power and authority of the courts has increased markedly in recent years (and not only since 1997). While reforms such as the HRA may not by themselves have caused the growth in judicial power, they have certainly made a significant contribution to it. Indeed, Vernon Bogdanor goes so far as to claim that the HRA is ‘the cornerstone of the new constitution’ (The New British Constitution (2009), p xiii). (These matters are considered further throughout this book: see, in particular, chapters 2, 10 and 11.) The UK is far from alone in having recently witnessed constitutional changes the effect of which is to enhance the power of the courts. In a compelling analysis Ran Hirschl has documented similar moves in a variety of common law jurisdictions: namely Canada, Israel, New Zealand and South Africa (see Towards Juristocracy: The Origins and Consequences of the New Constitutionalism (2004)). In the UK, while the influence of comparable common law jurisdictions has played its role, the greater pressures and influences have come from Europe – that is, both from the ECtHR and from the law of the EU, as shaped and developed by the ECJ (see further chapter 5). (For an informed exchange of views on the ‘juridification’ of the British constitution, see Bevir, ‘The Westminster Model, governance and judicial reform’ (2008) 61 Parl Aff 559, Masterman, ‘Labour’s “juridification” of the constitution’ (2009) 62 Parl Aff 476, Bevir’s response to Masterman at (2009) 62 Parl Aff 493 and Masterman’s further response at (2009) 62 Parl Aff 499.)
�44
British Government and the Constitution
A written constitution? Most of the rules of our constitution do, of course, exist in written form somewhere. Lord Scarman has said that ‘today our constitution is not “unwritten” but hidden and difficult to find’ (Why Britain Needs a Written Constitution (1992), p 4). Besides the great number of statutes that may be labelled as ‘constitutional’, the written sources of our constitution include law reports as the repository of many common law or judge-made rules affecting constitutional powers and relationships. In addition, as we shall see, some constitutional conventions have been put on written record in the interests of clarity and for the avoidance of doubt. There are also many informal but authoritative codes, memoranda, notices and other documents produced within government which direct the behaviour of ministers or officials and can be seen as belonging to the written part of our constitution, even though they do not have the status of law. Some of these documents are of great importance to the way in which government operates and some of the rules and procedures which they contain might be included in a written constitution, if we had one. As it is, documents of these kinds are easily overlooked in any attempt to enumerate the sources or written elements of the constitution. Among the more important of them are the Civil Service Code (rules of conduct for civil servants); the Ministerial Code; the so-called ‘Osmotherly Rules’, Departmental Evidence and Response to Select Committees; and Government Accounting (Treasury guidance on the financial procedures and responsibilities of government departments). In the 1970s a written constitution, as a remedy for the perceived ills of the body politic, was urged by, among others, Hood Phillips (‘Need for a written constitution’, in WJ Stankiewicz (ed), British Government in an Era of Reform (1976)) and Lord Hailsham (Elective Dictatorship (1976), pp 12–14). Arguments for a written constitution were renewed in the 1990s and significant contributions to the debate were made by the publication of three draft constitutions for the UK: the ‘MacDonald Constitution’, drawn up by John MacDonald QC and published in a Liberal Democrat paper (We, The People (1990)); Tony Benn’s Commonwealth of Britain Bill, presented to the House of Commons in May 1991; and The Constitution of the United Kingdom, published by the Institute for Public Policy Research in 1991. (These essays in constitution-making are analysed by Oliver, ‘Written constitutions: principles and problems’ (1992) 45 Parl Aff 135; see also Cornford, ‘On writing a constitution’ (1991) 44 Parl Aff 558; and Brazier, ‘Enacting a constitution’ (1992) 13 Stat LR 104.) The MPs’ expenses scandal of 2009, combined with disquiet on a number of fronts about the process by which constitutional reform had been undertaken since 2001, and augmented in some quarters by concern as to the negative impact on civil liberties of a number of government policies, led in 2008–10 to fresh calls to consider enacting a written constitution. We saw above the powerfully expressed views of Sir John Baker in this regard (above p 10), but perhaps the most sustained plea that an earnest and urgent debate be
�45
The British constitutional order
Â� commenced as to a new written constitution came from Richard Gordon QC, a leading public law barrister at the English bar. In his Repairing British Politics: A Blueprint for Constitutional Change (2010), Gordon set out an argument as to why a written constitution might be required at this point in Britain’s history and followed this with a draft constitutional text which, he claimed, was based on the ‘central principle’ of seeking to ‘reflect as strongly as possible a representative democracy’ (p 29). Gordon’s constitution would create a ‘sovereign, democratic, secular state with power conferred by the people’; the constitution would be the supreme law, thereby replacing the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty with a doctrine of constitutional supremacy; the Upper House of Parliament (renamed the Senate) would be 70 per cent elected and 30 per cent appointed; the monarchy would remain but its powers would be defined and limited by the constitution; and the Supreme Court’s powers would grow yet further, as it would have the power to strike down laws which it held to be in violation of the constitution. Richard Gordon’s constitution was very much a lawyer’s constitution, giving extensive powers to courts and seeking to use law to curtail political institutions. It was also a curiously Anglocentric constitution, which said precious little about the position of Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. (See also Barber, ‘Against a written constitution’ [2008] PL 11; Bogdanor and Vogenauer, ‘Enacting a British constitution: some problems’ [2008] PL 38; and Beatson, ‘Reforming an unwritten constitution’ (2010) 126 LQR 48.) The Coalition Government was asked in Parliament in June 2010 whether it had plans to bring forward proposals for the adoption of a codified constitution for the UK. The Minister for Political and Constitutional Reform (Mr Mark Harper MP) replied that the Government currently had no such plans (HC Deb vol 511, col 519w, 17 June 2010). In the course of his answer the minister stated that: the British constitution is not, as it is in many countries, codified in a single document, although much of it is already written. It is made up of a complex web of statutes, conventions, and a corpus of common and other law. It is also informed by an interweaving of history and more modern democratic principles.
The arguments for a written constitution deserve serious consideration. There is a case for giving to our most highly valued constitutional principles the special status and authority that would result from their embodiment in a constitution which was intended to endure. A more complete separation of powers might be instituted in the written constitution, reducing the power of the executive to control and direct the workings of Parliament. The relations between the countries and regions of the UK could be put on a firmer and clearer basis, possibly on a federal plan. The status of local government could be confirmed and protected, preventing the sort of erosion of its independence that occurred under the Thatcher Governments (see chapter 4). The
�46
British Government and the Constitution
fluidity and uncertainty of some of our most important conventions might be corrected by putting them into writing. The constitution would rest upon the authority not of Parliament but of the people: a referendum could be held to approve it and be required for its amendment. If these arguments are weighty, there is much to be said on the other side. The security that can be given to leading principles and fundamental rights by an entrenched written constitution should not be exaggerated. Certainly the constitution could be made difficult to amend – if not, much of the point of having a written constitution would be lost – but this might work as a brake on the necessary adaptation of the constitution to social change. Sir Stephen Sedley aptly remarks (in Lord Nolan and Sir Stephen Sedley, The Making and Remaking of the British Constitution, The Radcliffe Lectures (1997), p 88) that a written constitution: has to be negotiated with and by an infinite range of interests and viewpoints, among whom there will be the winners and losers dictated by the balance of power at the moment of enactment. Simply to put in writing our arrangements for the distribution and exercise of state power at a point of history where no comprehensive new consensus has emerged is to risk consolidating state power wherever it happens at that moment to reside.
Compare the following comments by Andrew Gamble (in I Holliday, A Gamble and G Parry (eds), Fundamentals in British Politics (1999), p 26): For its proponents the great virtue of the British state as a liberal state lies precisely in its undefined character, because it is this which gives it its flexibility and pragmatism, its ability to respond to new interests and demands and, by making timely concessions and accommodations, to preserve its essential institutional core intact .â•›.â•›. The danger of any kind of codified constitution from this perspective is that it locks in a particular set of arrangements which may be the best available at that time, but may later be judged inappropriate and then may be very difficult to change.
Ours has traditionally been a political constitution, in which change is directed and conflicts are largely resolved through the political process (see Griffith, ‘The political constitution’ (1979) 42 MLR 1). When a written constitution is in place, arguments about its effect are conducted in legal terms, as an exercise in interpretation, and are displaced from the political forum into the courts. As Ian Holliday remarks (in G Parry and M Moran (eds), Democracy and Democratization (1994), p 253), ‘juridification of politics is one of the major problems created by a written constitution’: much power and much trust are given to judges. The role which they may assume is exemplified by the history of the US Supreme Court. Rights guaranteed by the United States Constitution were in the years 1880–1930 used by Supreme Court justices, imbued with ideas of laissez-faire capitalism, as weapons against progressive social welfare legislation. (See, eg, Lochner v New York 198 US 45 (1905),
�47
The British constitutional order
in which the US Supreme Court held that a statute limiting employment in bakeries to sixty hours a week and ten hours a day was invalid as an arbitrary interference with the freedom to contract guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution.) Again, the New Deal programme, undertaken by President Roosevelt to counter the results of economic depression, was substantially nullified by Supreme Court decisions in the years 1934 to 1936. In its active phases the Supreme Court has been the source of far-reaching judicial legislation, whether of a conservative or a liberal tendency, and has had a substantial influence on social and political affairs in the US. This is the kind of role that our courts might be given by a written constitution. As we saw above, it may be that we are already taking that course, with the enhanced constitutional adjudication entrusted to our courts by the HRA and the devolution legislation. Perhaps it is becoming true here, as in the US, that the constitution ‘is whatever the judges say it is’ (Sedley, ‘The sound of silence: constitutional law without a constitution’ (1994) 110 LQR 270, p 277). Perhaps we are moving from a political constitution to a law-based or perhaps even a judge-based constitution. In the chapters that follow, we will come back to this question many times. (On constitutional reform, see further D Oliver, Constitutional Reform in the United Kingdom (2003); N Johnson, Reshaping the British Constitution (2004); A King, The British Constitution (2007); V Bogdanor, The New British Constitution (2009); R Gordon, Repairing British Politics: A Blueprint for Constitutional Change (2010); R Hazell, The Conservative-Liberal Democrat Agenda for Constitutional and Political Reform (2010); and I McLean, What’s Wrong with the British Constitution? (2010).)
2
The ideas of the constitution
Contents 1 Democracy and the constitution (a) Representative democracy (b) Participatory democracy (c) Democracy and accountability 2 Parliamentary sovereignty (a) Diceyan orthodoxy (b) Territorial extent of sovereignty: post-colonial independence (c) Continuing sovereignty and the ‘new view’ (d) Sovereignty re-appraised: three contemporary challenges (e) Conclusions 3 The rule of law (a) Government under law (b) Equality before the law (c) Discretion and the rule of law (d) The rule of law: wider conceptions? (e) The rule of law and parliamentary sovereignty 4 Separation of powers (a) A political ideal or a legal principle? (b) The courts in the constitution: judicial review and judicial law-making (c) Judicial independence and the position of the Lord Chancellor (d) The courts and Parliament (e) Parliament and the executive ‘Successful constitutions and institutions’, says Ian Gilmour (Inside Right: A Study of Conservatism (1978), p 70), ‘are not mere pieces of machinery. If they work, it is because of the ideas and beliefs of those who try to work them.’ The British constitution, having evolved over centuries, does not embody any single constitutional theory. It is the product of a long period of kingly rule, parliamentary struggle, revolution, many concessions and compromises, a
49
The ideas of the constitution
slow growth of custom, the making and breaking and alteration of many laws. Although we lack a general theory of the constitution, there has come down to us an idea of constitutionalism – of a constitutional order which acknowledges the necessary power of government while placing conditions and limits upon its exercise. The British version of constitutionalism has been shaped by a number of leading ideas or principles: some of these have crystallised as rules or doctrines of the constitution; others have influenced constitutional thought or have gained currency as explanations or justifications of particular features of the constitution. In this chapter we shall consider some of these commanding ideas or doctrines and their place in the modern constitution. We start with democracy and then move on to consider the sovereignty of Parliament, the rule of law and the separation of powers. It will appear that, at times, there is a conflict, or tension, between these ideas; between democracy, for instance, and parliamentary sovereignty, or between sovereignty and the rule of law. A good deal of contemporary constitutional analysis is concerned with how such conflicts, or tensions, should be resolved and worked out. (For an engaging critique, see Murkens, ‘The quest for constitutionalism in UK public law discourse’ (2009) 29 OJLS 427.)
1╇ Democracy and the constitution Democracy is not to be taken for granted. Neither is its contemporary acceptance as the only form of government able to claim legitimacy to rule. As John Dunn asks in his account of the history of democracy, Setting the People Free: The Story of Democracy (2005), pp 13, 15: Why does democracy loom so large today? Why should it hold such sway over the political speech of the modern world? What does its recent prominence really mean? When Britain and America set out to bury Baghdad in its own rubble, why was it in the name of democracy of all words in which they claimed to do so? Is its novel dominance in fact illusory: a sustained exercise in fraud or an index of utter confusion? Or does it mark a huge moral and political advance, which only needs to cover the whole world, and be made a little more real, for history to come to a reassuring end? Why should it be the case that, for the first time in the history of our still conspicuously multi-lingual species, there is for the present a single world-wide name of the legitimate basis of political authority?
Democracy came late to the British constitution. Much of our constitutional architecture was constructed at a time when to accuse someone of harbouring democratic sympathies was a grave political insult. This is not to say that democracy came late to Britain in comparison with other countries. But it is to say that several key elements of the British constitution predate the emergence of democracy as an accepted form of government. Anthony King puts the point well (The British Constitution (2007), p 249):
50
British Government and the Constitution The United Kingdom was a monarchy before it became a constitutional monarchy. It was a constitutional monarchy before it became a system of government built around ministers of the Crown. It was a system of government built around ministers of the Crown before it became a parliamentary system. And it was a parliamentary system before it became a parliamentary democracy. Democracy .â•›.â•›. was a novel feature grafted on to a pre-existing constitutional structure.
Nonetheless, democracy deserves to be treated as the first of our constitutional themes since the working assumption of all the principal actors on the constitutional stage, even those who (like the monarch and the House of Lords) are not themselves democratically elected, is that Britain is, and ought to consider itself as, a modern democracy. Even if the assumption is sometimes misplaced or over-stated, it is impossible to understand the way the contemporary British constitution works without taking on board this basic working assumption. Equally, however, like all assumptions, it is rebuttable. On no account could today’s British constitutional order accurately be described as entirely or unambiguously democratic. (Valuable introductions to the idea of democracy abound. Among the better ones, see R Dahl, On Democracy (1998) and B Crick, Democracy: A Very Short Introduction (2002).)
(a)╇ Representative democracy Democracy may be said to have two main elements: representation and participation. As to the first, since the achievement of universal suffrage with the enactment of the Representation of the People Acts 1918 and 1928 it can be claimed that the British constitution has embodied the principle of representative democracy, at least as far as elections to the House of Commons are concerned. As it is from the House of