CAT HOLIC SENSAT IONALISM AND VICTORIAN LIT ER ATURE
LIVERPOOL ENGLISH TEXTS AND STUDIES, 49
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.ind...
128 downloads
1816 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CAT HOLIC SENSAT IONALISM AND VICTORIAN LIT ER ATURE
LIVERPOOL ENGLISH TEXTS AND STUDIES, 49
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd i
15/3/07 14:38:39
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd ii
15/3/07 14:38:39
CATHOLIC SENSATIONALISM AND VICTORIAN LITERATURE
MAUREEN MORAN
LIVERPOOL UNIVERSITY PRESS
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd iii
15/3/07 14:38:39
First published 2007 by Liverpool University Press 4 Cambridge Street Liverpool L69 7ZU Copyright © 2007 Maureen Moran The right of Maureen Moran to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication data A British Library CIP record is available ISBN 978-1-84631-070-6 cased
Typeset in Garamond Premier by Koinonia, Bury, Lancashire Printed and bound in the European Union by Biddles Ltd, King’s Lynn
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd iv
15/3/07 14:38:39
To my mother, Pat Moran, and in memory of my father, Frank Moran
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd v
15/3/07 14:38:39
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd vi
15/3/07 14:38:40
Contents
Acknowledgements Introduction
viii 1
1 Sensational Invasions: The Jesuit, the State and the Family Charles Kingsley’s Westward Ho! and Wilkie Collins’s The Black Robe
28
2 Nuns and Priests: Sensations of the Cloister Charlotte Brontë’s Villette and the Monologues of Robert Browning
77
3 Persecution and Martyrdom: The Law and the Body Grace Aguilar’s The Vale of Cedars, or The Martyr and George Eliot’s Romola
131
4 Feeling the Great Change: Conversion and the Authority of Affect Benjamin Disraeli’s Lothair, J. H. Shorthouse’s John Inglesant and Mary Ward’s Helbeck of Bannisdale 177 5 Art Catholicism and the New Catholic Baroque The Poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins and Francis Thompson
231
Epilogue Works Cited Index
284 292 311
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd vii
15/3/07 14:38:40
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank the Arts and Humanities Research Board (now the Arts and Humanities Research Council) for awarding me a Research Leave Grant which enabled me to complete this project. I appreciate the permission of Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Province of the Society of Jesus to quote from works in copyright by Gerard Manley Hopkins. I am grateful to Laurel Brake and Catherine Phillips for their belief in the book from the outset, to my Commissioning Editor, Anthony Cond, for his enthusiastic support, and to the anonymous readers of the manuscript for their perceptive comments and very helpful suggestions. I appreciate, too, the efforts of staff at the London Library and British Library to track down obscure material. John Aplin generously provided many tips on Thackeray, Pete Smith wittily shared all things Victorian, and the Medcroft Gardeners – Bryan, Henry, Mia and Victoria – offered insights, reminiscences and good cheer to further this book on its way. A very special thanks go to Linda Anderson who has assisted in countless ways throughout this research work, and especially by providing great encouragement, a razor-sharp brain, and an inexhaustible sense of humour. And, finally, my deepest thanks and loving gratitude to my parents – the wisest of guides, the keenest of supporters, and the very best of teachers.
LUP_Moran_00_Prelims.indd viii
15/3/07 14:38:40
1 Introduction 1550–15??
Faith of our Fathers! living still In spite of dungeon, fire and sword: Oh how our hearts beat high with joy Whene’er we hear that glorious word. Faith of our Fathers! Holy Faith! We will be true to thee till death. 1 — Father Frederick Faber, ‘Faith of our Fathers’ [Persecuted] by the sword, the gibbet, the rack, and the flames … men, women, and children were burned [by Catholics] before slow fires, pinched to death with red-hot tongs, starved, flayed alive, broken on the wheel, suffocated, drowned, subjected to all kinds of lingering agonies. 2 — Henry H. Bourn, Words of Warning respecting The Jesuits
This book is about an imaginary landscape: a sensationalized ‘geography’ of Roman Catholicism constructed and widely circulated in Victorian culture. This is a contentious space. It is the site of Protestant defensive battles and Catholic countercultural skirmishes over denominational authority in a society outwardly aligned with Christian principles but increasingly reliant on science and material evidence to validate ‘truth’. This terrain of extremes is characterized by linguistic extravagances and plots of crime and violence, of persecution and intrigue. Its signposts are images of confinement, torture and deviance. It is a world peopled by victims and oppressors, law-givers and rebels. Many Janus-faced creatures are found there, too – the brave who are also sinister, the respectable who harbour malign and secret intent. Embedded in discursive and non-discursive practices of all kinds – lectures, sermons, essays and journalism, prayers and hymns, travel journals, private correspondence and public declamations, canonical literary works and the penny pulps, cartoons and art reviews, architectural styles and liturgical rites, laws and parliamentary debates – the territory of Catholic sensationalism can be glimpsed in both the secular and religious domains
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 1
15/3/07 14:40:42
2
catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
that constitute nineteenth-century social experience. This book models the field, mapping its recurrent images, character types, narratives and aesthetic modes and demonstrating its persistence in imaginative writing throughout the Victorian period. As a distinctive literary practice, the sensationalizing of Catholicism both expresses and helps to shape perspectives on social reality. Responsive to the historical moment, it is inflected by different secular debates in the nineteenth century and is used in both conservative and radical contexts. These representations of excess, extremism and strangeness are diverse, appearing in a range of genres intended for different middle-class readerships from the ‘popular’ to the ‘intellectual’. However, the dominant effects of Catholic sensationalism are remarkably consistent. By interrogating Victorian myths of social freedom and harmony, it probes the individual’s control over an increasingly complex cultural milieu. In the multi-voiced religious culture of Victorian Britain, anti-Catholic mockery was a popular activity for politicians, historians and sages as well as churchmen. Cultural and social historians have tracked its deployment, suggesting its significance at national and regional levels for understanding the complex relationship between church and state at the time.3 Non-fiction and imaginative writing associated with overt prejudice against the Roman Catholic Church has also attracted recent scholarly interest for its importance in the formation of nineteenth-century Anglo-American national identities. In her informative study of anti-Catholicism in nineteenthcentury American literary and historical writing, Jenny Franchot shows how the rhetoric of religious prejudice performed a vital cultural role in the antebellum period, providing oppositional images against which an emergent Protestant middle-class identity could be asserted.4 More recently, Susan Griffin has built on this approach historically and geographically.5 By taking her study to the turn of the century, Griffin suggests that Protestant national, political and religious self-definition was a dynamic, fluid process, dependent on the flexible familiarity of anti-Catholic discourse. Juxtaposing American and British anti-Catholic novels, Griffin also reminds us of the transnational nature of anti-Catholic polemic. While each nation had its own national burdens – from the Empire to the impact of immigration on the nature of American citizenship – writing anti-Catholicism was a persistently popular way of writing ‘Protestant’ and of establishing the normative version of America and Britain. Catholic Sensationalism and Victorian Literature argues for a much broader cultural and social role for Catholicism in the Victorian project of self-formation and self-fashioning. I am concerned with a particular mode
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 2
15/3/07 14:40:42
introduction
3
through which Roman Catholicism was constructed in the period – that of sensationalism. The ‘sensationalizing’ of the Church of Rome dramatizes the many and interrelated understandings of ‘sensation’ that haunted the period: its indication of the mysterious connection between body, nerves and mind; its emphasis on extremes of emotion (and language); its association with the shocking, unorthodox and countercultural. Because of this multivalence, Catholic sensationalism is a particularly productive medium for the exploration of many secular and religious issues. It inhabits cultural domains far more diverse than those of nation and home, which to date have generally been the focus for scholars of the period. Through sensationalism, the wellknown plots, characters and motifs of Catholicism are rewritten by Victorians to explore gender, the body, artistic values, the workings of the mind and feelings. In its sensationalized form, Victorian Catholicism can signify difference that is menacing; but it can also entertain stimulating alternatives to the norms of home culture. Recognizing that these emotionally heightened articulations of Catholicism inflect all literary media of the period, this book ranges widely. It explores the phenomenon in poetry as well as novels. It seeks also to recover the mode’s meanings and significance as it appears in diverse genres and in texts drawn from both popular and elite culture. Most important of all is the recognition that this is not a discourse owned only by Protestants. While Catholic sensationalism draws on formulations from anti-Catholic rhetoric, it transcends simple denominational hostility. The epigrams that head this chapter echo each other in their emotive language of pathos, shock and triumphalism, as well as in their gruesome attention to persecution and bodily suffering. Yet one is by a mid-Victorian Catholic priest and the other from a Protestant polemical essay published late in the century. Victorian Catholics and Protestants (and those of no faith at all) appropriate the register, motifs and plots of Catholic sensationalism; and this book considers how writers of all persuasions exploit its many dimensions. My analysis concentrates on the literary side of this particular religious expression, establishing its dominant images, themes and stylistic strategies in poetic and fictional genres and showing their contribution to a wide range of cultural debates. This figuration of the Church of Rome, distinguished by extravagance and excess, proves a dynamic frame of reference for writers and readers from the beginning of the period to the turn of the century. Indeed, it is a key part of the religious ‘habitus’ of Victorians of all classes. The saturation of nineteenth-century culture by Christianity and its denominational variants makes religion always and everywhere a presence. In large
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 3
15/3/07 14:40:42
4
catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 6
part, many Victorian ‘systems of dispositions’, assumptions, beliefs and understandings about religious difference remain a hidden knowledge for twenty-first-century readers; but for Victorians, they were a rich imaginative resource that generated a range of possible subject positions and perceptions. A sensationalized version of Catholicism is an important part of that sensibility. As a grammar of the imagination, the sensational representation of Roman Catholicism constructs a social world through theological differences that are elided with contrasting cultural attitudes. It thus plays an important part in the articulation of the Victorian self-image. It serves as the ‘heretical’ foil against which orthodox middle-class beliefs and structures can be reaffirmed. Yet, as the place of opposition to the dominant Protestant home culture, Catholic sensationalism functions in a subversive way too. It expresses alternative models of self-fashioning and social relations, transgressive values and tastes already rooted in domestic ‘norms’. It can even mount critical resistance to the ideals that characterize the Victorian establishment ethos. The chapters that follow offer different perspectives on the functioning of this complex rhetoric in a range of literary works spanning the period. Under the guise of clear-cut denominational argument, these representations of countercultural extremism reveal ambivalence about the cherished values of public and private life. They encode uncertainties about the rights and roles of the nation-state and the family, as well as about gender divisions and destinies. They suggest the restrictions of respectability at the same time as they reflect on the power of the law, the body and the emotions over the individual subject. They even play a role in aesthetic battles about the relative worth of artistic form over function. Most significantly of all, Catholic sensationalism demonstrates the imprint of a major and persistent theme in the Victorian cultural imaginary: the conflict between powerful authorities, collective responsibility and individual self-realization. In diverse literary manifestations, sensational portrayals of Catholicism explore the possibility of balancing these competing forces through the structures of Victorian culture; but, paradoxically, they also expose doubts about the fitness of these structures for the purpose. Underpinning the Victorian discourse of Catholic sensationalism are historical events and artistic trends that help to account both for its formation and its persistent grip on the literary imagination. This particular construction of the alien Church of Rome bears the imprint of recurrent panics about the growing visibility and strength of the Catholic faith in Britain, the Gothic revival that recalled mediaeval Catholic roots (and abuses), and
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 4
15/3/07 14:40:43
introduction
5
the emergence of a sensational ‘style’ in fiction and ‘New Journalism’ that exposed the hidden treachery of crime, fraud and cultural subversion. At its base, undoubtedly, is the complex set of histories and myths about Roman Catholic designs on Great Britain that Victorians inherited. As Macaulay reminded his readers in 1848, through long experience of the Church of Rome, the English had by the 1680s formed ‘an indissoluble [mental] association … between Protestantism and civil freedom, between Popery and arbitrary power’.7 Suspicion of Catholics as creatures of divided loyalty – to King and to Pope – was well embedded in the national psyche from the late sixteenth century in ways that reinforced the Church of Rome as a dangerous religious and secular opponent. Catholic schemes against the crown, such as support for Mary Queen of Scots against Elizabeth I and the Gunpowder and Titus Oates plots, shaped a belief that the papacy continuously intrigued to control Protestant Britain by alliance with external enemies and domestic traitors. The faithful’s unquestioning obedience to an authoritarian papacy and the Vatican’s temporal as well as spiritual ambitions were fundamental to British representations of the wicked Roman Catholic Church. These stereotypes were magnified at times of social change and upheaval and were given particular prominence in narratives of cultural crisis. For example, public unrest of all kinds up to and including the nineteenth century was frequently attributed to secret Catholic machinations at work among the populace. In Victorian memory and experience, Catholicism seemed to stir up agitation within all denominational persuasions. The aggressive Protestant Association of the late eighteenth century, headed by Lord George Gordon, objected to the Catholic Relief Act, but a significant effect of the Association’s protests was to establish anti-Catholicism as a rallying point for general discontent in the populace. The Gordon Riots of 1780, when Catholic homes and embassy chapels in London were destroyed and prisons sacked, produced relatively scant sympathy for Catholic victims but ample fear of discord as an inevitable consequence of the Roman presence. Alternatively, in the mid-nineteenth century, the activities of the Irish Fenian Brotherhood seemed to link Catholics directly to civil rebellion, notwithstanding the Church’s formal opposition to this movement for Irish independence from Britain. Such instances of social disorder ensured the continued perception of Roman Catholics as a disquieting element within the state. Catholics were thought to provoke tension and bloodshed, disrupting social stability as either scapegoats or rebels. Even the Catholic Emancipation Act of 1829, which relieved most of the civil disabilities and restrictions on Catholic citizens, shows the high level
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 5
15/3/07 14:40:43
6
catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
of anxiety about the Catholic presence. Some supporters of this reform argued for freedom of conscience for all citizens without penalty. Yet, these civil liberties also imposed a subtle regulatory framework. Protection of the individual’s rights by the state came with a quid pro quo insistence on individual conformity with state law and communal values. Catholic loyalty and co-operation, so the reasoning went, could best be ensured by trust and full citizenship. For others, the Act was a pragmatic expedient for controlling a fraught political situation in Ireland where the unruly, subordinated Catholic majority was increasingly volatile. Nor did the Catholic Emancipation Act quiet Protestant nerves about Roman Catholic dependability and patriotism. With their allegiance to an alien (papal) crown and their ready submission to the overbearing authority of the Vatican, Catholics were still objects of suspicion. Jenny Franchot has drawn attention to the favourite disparaging ‘nicknames’ for Catholicism in the nineteenth century, such as ‘popery’, ‘Romanish’, and ‘Romish’.8 These commonplace epithets, which trope the religion in terms of its autocratic leadership and foreign location, give a good indication of the particular concerns that beset Protestant Victorians. Indeed, Catholicism in some quarters became generally synonymous with unwarranted state interference, as when opponents to the New Poor Law (1834) and the Public Health Act (1848) likened their drafter, Edwin Chadwick, to the Pope for his interventionist and centralizing policies.9 A number of spectacular events in the nineteenth century seemed to herald renewed attempts by the Church of Rome to appropriate British culture. At all social levels, sensitivity to Catholicism as an active force on British soil was revived. Given the dominance of Protestant voices in the country, it is not surprising that outrage and fear were prominent responses. Concern centred on the ease with which an alien religion could compromise an individual’s sense of public duty and undermine national institutions. However, public tension was also heightened by the sensationalist rhetoric used to denounce – or support – the Church of Rome. Emotive diction, melodramatic and morbid stories, and extravagant images of horror were employed by both sides in a shared paranoia about the role of Catholicism in British culture. The first – and in many ways the most lasting – trauma began in 1833 when a small group of influential Oxford Anglicans commenced publication of a series of Tracts for the Times. Their call for the doctrinal and devotional renewal of the Church of England, known as the Oxford (or Tractarian) Movement, sought to strengthen the spiritual authority of the established Protestant Church and secure it from improper state interference. In devel-
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 6
15/3/07 14:40:43
introduction
7
oping a theological framework, the Movement focused on the divine origins of Anglicanism by tracing its continuity from Christ’s foundation of Christianity through the Early (and therefore Catholic) Church. This insistence on the ‘Catholicity’ of the national Church by reference to the apostolic authority of the Church’s bishops created controversy. From the outset, some read the Movement as a symptom of ‘the dry-rot’ that would topple the Church of England into the ‘spiritual bondage’ of Roman superstition.10 When the most influential Tractarian, John Henry Newman, converted to Catholicism in 1845 together with other followers, alarm about the collapse of the Anglican Church into the arms of Rome became widespread. Suspected for some time of being a Catholic Trojan Horse, Newman, through his conversion, seemed to illustrate the insidious encroachment of Catholicism on the Protestant foundation of the British church and state. The shock of Newman’s change of faith was kept alive throughout the nineteenth century, revived for a new generation in 1864 when Charles Kingsley publicly attacked Newman’s integrity and the latter defended himself in his spirited autobiography, Apologia Pro Vita Sua. At the same time, pronouncements by senior Catholics encouraged the view that the Vatican schemed to regain possession of England through a project of mass conversion. In 1863, for example, Cardinal Henry Manning, himself a convert, proclaimed that ‘the Catholic Church goes forth once more to evangelise the English people’.11 The evidence of a steady leakage to Rome, including such prominent laypeople as the politician, the Marquess of Ripon, suggested that the Church’s plan was beginning to succeed, a matter routinely brought to the public’s attention by the press. In aesthetic terms, too, Catholicism retained a high and controversial profile as a seductive force. The craze for neo-mediaevalism and Pugin’s Gothic revival swept Catholic architecture and artistic culture into an idiom viewed as attractive, glamorous and fashionable. Nonetheless, when Anglo-Catholic Ritualists sought to promote the Catholicity of Anglicanism by the introduction of Roman liturgical practices, vestments, church decoration and devotional pieties from the late 1850s, prosecution through the Public Worship Regulation Act seemed to be a legitimate, if hyperbolic, response to a cultural threat. In 1850, a new outburst of anxiety about Catholic aspirations occurred when Pius IX re-established dioceses and the hierarchy of Catholic bishops in England for the first time since the seventeenth century. In his first pastoral letter to English Catholics, Cardinal-Archbishop Nicholas Wiseman, the new leader of the Catholic bishops, seemed to assert temporal as well as religious authority while predicting the speedy rise of Catholicism as the
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 7
15/3/07 14:40:43
8
catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
premier national faith: ‘behold the silver links of that chain which has connected their country [England] with the See of St Peter … changed into burnished gold’.12 The name chosen for his diocese – Westminster – was greeted with dismay; it seemed, symbolically, to snatch the heart of British governance for the seat of a foreign power. The press took up the ‘AntiPopery’ cry, representing this re-organization of Catholic administration in Britain as an overtly hostile act. The militaristic phrase coined to describe the restructuring – ‘Papal Aggression’ – reinforced the sense of political invasion. Although Catholics represented a tiny proportion of declared Christians in the 1851 religious census, the restoration of the Hierarchy was viewed as the preliminary to the imposition of a foreign yoke.13 In a parliamentary debate of 1851, for instance, Robert Inglis interpreted the Pope’s action as an attack on the Queen’s ‘Crown and dignity, on the independence of Her realms, on the integrity of Her Church, and on the faith and consciences of Her people’; as such, it endangered ‘the great body of the people of England’ and the rights for which they had fought.14 Even the Queen was purported to have asked, ‘[a]m I Queen of England or am I not?’15 Prime Minister Lord John Russell publicly expressed his opposition in inflammatory language that matched Wiseman’s own. He thunderously denounced this ‘pretension of supremacy over the realm of England … inconsistent with the Queen’s supremacy’ and an ‘insolent and insidious’ action.16 Feelings were so intense that Parliament quickly passed the Ecclesiastical Titles Bill to restrict the Catholic claim on diocesan names that challenged Anglican jurisdictions. That the civil law was invoked to police structures and naming in the religious domain shows the extent to which Catholicism was seen as a subversive cultural threat. Indeed, some politicians called for even more drastic measures to pull the tooth of the Catholic serpent. Throughout the 1860s and 1870s, specific Vatican pronouncements continued to provoke public hysteria about the malign intentions of Rome and its ‘hostility to the institutions most nearly identified with [British] national freedom, and our national faith’.17 The Syllabus of Errors attached to a papal encyclical in 1864 reiterated the Church’s condemnation of particular political philosophies and intellectual movements. Intended to re-assert the authority of the Pope against the Italian challenge to his temporal power, the Syllabus to Britons seemed an attack on religious and intellectual freedom and the complementary relationship between church and state that stabilized social life. The document’s rejection of naturalism, rationalism and political liberalism appeared to oppose the principles of a progressive Victorian Britain, with its growing confidence in the material
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 8
15/3/07 14:40:43
introduction
9
sciences and radical individualism. In 1870, public outcry also accompanied the first Vatican Council’s proclamation of papal primacy (in juridical matters) and papal infallibility (in the Pope’s teaching capacity). British Ultramontanists – Catholics who supported the strengthening of papal authority – strongly backed the pronouncement. However, Protestants, and even some liberal Catholics, including Newman, believed the doctrine symbolized the Vatican’s insensitivity to domestic governments and culture. It renewed debates about the trustworthy compliance of Catholics with civic regulation. It suggested Catholicism was on a par with all tyrannical regimes that suppressed individual reason and autonomous judgement. These events ensured that for many Victorians, Roman Catholicism presented an ideological danger, a cultural as well as a spiritual menace to be vigorously resisted. The Church of Rome had not quietly subsided into a backwater as an historical anachronism or the colourful backdrop for fantastic Gothic novels. Rome’s pro-active involvement in British cultural politics inflected a Victorian version of Roman Catholicism associated with apprehension and shock. This sensationalized representation occurred not only in religious polemics, but also in newspaper articles, serious essays and literary works as well as in visual depictions, including book illustrations and paintings. Catholics and Protestants alike generated narratives of the Church that focused on barbarism and cruelty of an excessive kind, the perpetrators of which depended on the writer’s denominational leanings. These strategies placed power relations at the centre of most Victorian depictions of Roman Catholicism. The role of institutions in regulating individual desire and the related themes of authority, duty and resistance are embodied in the plots of conversion, invasion and martyrdom that are typical of Catholic sensationalism from the late 1830s to 1900. For both Protestant and Catholic, this rhetoric fed communal paranoia by focusing on societies in which the innocent were suspected, threatened and persecuted by secretive, tyrannical powers. In these sensational representations of Catholicism, difference slides repeatedly into deviance. Disruptions of all kinds – social, emotional and sexual – cluster about the Roman Catholic Other as a major symbol of the culturally heretical in the Victorian imagination. Because of its association with social and spiritual waywardness, the rhetoric of Catholic sensationalism offers a means of expressing fears of social crisis and breakdown. When the Browning family clergyman observes ‘as an undoubted fact, that Roman Catholic and midnight assassin are synonymous terms’ or when, in 1868, a ‘member of the University of Oxford’ describes Roman Catholicism as ‘a
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 9
15/3/07 14:40:43
10 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature delusion of some fanatical brain’, they express disgust with a religion that appeals to the criminally inclined and the weak-minded.18 But they also embed Catholicism in a discourse of social decline today associated with the 19 sensation ‘genre’ of fiction that first appeared in the 1860s. In a flippant poem published in 1861, Punch facetiously dubbed the period the ‘age of Sensation’.20 The anonymous versifier no doubt hoped to appeal to readers bemused by the commercial wonder of the day: the best-selling sensation novel, typified by Wilkie Collins’s The Woman in White (1859–60) and Ellen (Mrs Henry) Wood’s East Lynne (1860–61). However, like the working-class Penny Dreadful and the popular mass culture journalism that developed in the period, this ‘new’ type of novel was just one manifestation of a significant nineteenth-century rhetorical practice. Victorians were clearly aware that sensationalism permeated ‘respectable’ and serious genres intended for the middle class, as well as less demanding entertainments for wider readerships. Punch’s ‘Sensation Sermons’ of 1867 mocked the religious use of lurid situations and extravagant language.21 In fact, reviewers concerned about the sensation fiction craze perceived the mode encroaching everywhere: Everything must now be sensational. Professor Kingsley sensationalizes History, and Mr. Wilkie Collins daily life. One set of writers wear the sensational buskin, another the sensational sock. Just as in the Middle Ages people were afflicted with the Dancing Mania and Lycanthropy, sometimes barking like dogs, and sometimes mewing like cats, so now we have a Sensational Mania. Just, too, as those diseases always occurred in seasons of dearth and poverty, and attacked only the poor, so does the Sensational Mania in Literature burst out only in times of mental poverty, and afflict only the most poverty-stricken minds. From an epidemic, however, it has lately changed into an endemic. Its virus is spreading in all directions, from the penny journal to the shilling magazine, and from the 22 shilling magazine to the thirty shillings volume.
Today, the term sensationalism is most readily associated with the genre of sensation fiction and the work of Collins, Wood, Braddon and Reade. However, as this book demonstrates through specific constructions of Catholicism, it was actually a major discursive phenomenon of the nineteenth century. As a powerful counterdiscourse set against and interacting with realism, sensationalism offers a distinctive mode of expression and interpretation, a way of ‘seeing’ that focuses attention on the ‘not perceived’, ‘not felt’, and ‘not said’ of commonplace experience. Violating the low-key, ‘transparent’ and naturalized codes of realist discourse, sensationalism proposes new, unsus-
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 10
15/3/07 14:40:44
introduction
11
pected readings of the ‘real’, accessible through extremes. Lurid spectacle and gruesome event, improbable connections and strange mysteries, hypocritical heroes and seemingly respectable villains, overblown language and fantastic images – all form part of the repertoire of sensationalism in its engagement with the unorthodox, the unexpected and even the unwholesome. Above all, with its thematics of secrecy and shocking disclosure, sensationalism reveals what mainstream culture normally discounts or occludes. Realism and sensationalism are opposed in terms of effect as well as content. Literary realism, with its emphasis on the gradual development of individual character through causal plots in recognizable environments, encourages considerable confidence in material appearances and social customs, in logic and reason, and in the ideologies of individual power and social progress to interpret everyday experience. It invites judicious assessment of dominant social and moral frameworks, rather than a radical overhaul. It participates in a larger project of social discipline and control by moderating and amplifying – but not undermining – generally accepted views of the contemporary world and individual subject positions within it. Because sensationalism challenges the proper and permissible in its style and topics, it has the potential to disturb – if not erase – aesthetic and social preconceptions and norms. Its narrative emphasis on surprising incident rather than character development, for example, predicates a social order resistant to shaping by individual will power and agency. Its preference for mystery and surprise challenges consensus about the supposedly stable and comprehensible social world. Locating the strange within the familiar, and the familiar within the strange, sensationalism cultivates shock, excitement, thrill and horror. Victorian readers believed its disturbing revelations stimulated ‘the nerves’, arousing ‘sensations’ largely associated with the body and the emotions. While realism ostensibly sets up its appeal to reason and ‘common sense’, sensationalism makes its overtures to the more unpredictable and ill-disciplined of the human faculties. Victorian sensationalism is thus, in its very practice, an innately rebellious medium. With psychological disturbance as one of its primary effects, it provides scope for disrupting complacency about accepted norms in private and public life. It challenges aesthetic standards by applying the techniques of mass literary culture to serious topics, encouraging somatic and psychological, rather than intellectual, responses.23 It challenges social and cultural standards by savouring the terror hidden in mundane ‘normality’, and by adopting scepticism about appearances and the impulse to exposé as central hermeneutic principles.24 Penetrating and transgressing the boundaries of
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 11
15/3/07 14:40:44
12 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature the ‘respectable’ at every level, it interrogates the illusions of convention and proposes a more ‘modern’ and authentic construction of truth, though this new vision can be disconcerting and unsettling. Victorian sensationalism has its roots in earlier forms. In its extreme, eccentric scenarios and language, it draws on the excess, extravagance and monstrosity of a Gothic register; in its sharp moral polarities and pathos, we can recognize the structures and emotional orientation of theatrical melodrama and the sentimental novels of the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Winifred Hughes has suggested that the Victorian return to these older romance forms in the sensation fiction of the 1860s marks novelists’ response to ‘a new situation for which they found realism inadequate’.25 As the examination of Catholic sensationalism will show, Hughes’s comment is also applicable to the mode in its broadest form. Sensationalism is distinctively Victorian in its construction and interpretation of a contemporary culture in flux and crisis. Victorian sensationalism imagines modernity as a site of conflict and upheaval. Reviewers of a sensation narrative, such as Mary Elizabeth Braddon’s Lady Audley’s Secret (1862), might have turned up their noses at its vulgarity, but they certainly read its codes as ‘a sign of the times – the evidence of a certain turn of thought and action, of an impatience of old restraints, and a craving for some fundamental change in the working of society’.26 Evading the structures of coherence, reconciliation and progress associated with the causal, closed plots and character development of realist discourse, sensationalism uses the hyperbolic, even the hysterical, to probe the gulf between idealized narratives of social relations and real practices and behaviour. Nothwithstanding its debt to earlier genres, this discourse is also distinctively Victorian in its preoccupation with the physical and the material, and in its engagement with the fragility of contemporary cultural formations and identities. For example, in Ann Radcliffe’s Gothic novel, The Italian, or The Confessional of the Black Penitents (1797), the sensational (Catholic) villain is a scheming monk (Schedoni) who represents the vestiges of a tyrannical feudal past. From the outset, his perspective is portrayed as outmoded and deviant when compared to the contemporary reader’s Enlightenment values. Unsurprisingly, he is vanquished by the ethical, social and political values of the modern benevolent state. However, rather than standing in opposition to the prevailing culture, the monsters of Victorian sensationalism are embedded within the middle-class domestic world. They are not curious remnants, but a present problem. Simultaneously alien and double, they oppose and replicate existing norms, and thus call them to account.
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 12
15/3/07 14:40:44
introduction
13
Additionally, as Mark M. Hennelly, Jr. suggests, Victorian sensationalism differs from sentimental and melodramatic forms of an earlier age in its complex intellectual and emotional engagement of the reader. 27 It replaces the passive, escapist comforts of the older genres with a somatic involvement – a physical frisson that moves the reader from shock to curiosity, and thence to the active decoding of a hidden truth. The heightened sensitivity to unknown possibilities which sensationalism thus encourages encapsulates the strange mix of fascination and anxiety with which Victorians confronted modernity. But it also underpins more significant cultural deconstruction. Ann Cvetkovich has argued that Victorian sensation narratives displace and obscure the real social threats to the individual. By treating the sensational as a sign of ‘something other than itself ’, they produce a mystery that can be resolved in emotional, rather than political, terms.28 However, the analysis of Catholic sensationalism illustrates that the mode, broadly conceived, actually has subversive ideological effects in the period. Obsessed always with hidden meanings suspensefully deferred, the sensational is a porous sign that accommodates debate about alterity of different kinds. Less a disguise than an indeterminate space, it expresses cultural contradictions and explores alternatives to existing models of selfhood and social relations. Although Catholicism per se is not a dominant theme of the best-selling sensation novel that flourished between the 1860s and 1890s, the genre and reactions to it exemplify the codes of sensationalism by which Catholicism is expressed, shaped and interpreted.29 In the first place, the mode asserts itself as culturally contemporary, rather than a pastiche of earlier writing, by updating the horrid plots and character types of such Gothic precursors as the fantasies of Radcliffe, Walpole and Lewis. As Nicholas Rance has argued with reference to Collins and his school, Victorian sensationalism mediates a Gothic sense of social crisis through a modern scepticism about supernatural assumptions and absolute moral schemas.30 The domestication of such Gothic clichés as oppressive labyrinthine spaces, exotic Continental locations, murderous assassins, and intricate, impenetrable plots also creates new meanings. Dark, claustrophobic enclosures – the monastic dungeon and the prison – are transformed into the familiar, protective institutions of British culture. In Victorian sensationalism, the home and the asylum are dangerous in their own right, inhabited by plausible malefactors intent on seizing wealth, property and even the identities of others. Villains are remodelled, too. In popular sensation novels like The Woman in White and Lady Audley’s Secret, the demonic Gothic evildoer becomes the ambivalent inhabitant of domestic culture, like the suave aristocratic émigré or the native-born
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 13
15/3/07 14:40:44
14 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature social climber. Capable of amazing disguise and deceit, their most dastardly crime is to shake belief in the security of ‘home’. The stranger can no longer be evaluated or ‘placed’ by good manners and social conformity, since these are easily faked. Catholic sensationalism demonstrates the same preoccupations, though its explicit use of religious materials more obviously exposes Gothic roots.31 The most lurid Victorian portrayals of Catholic convents and monasteries recall the evil, imprisoning cloisters of eighteenth-century romances, with priests and nuns cast as despots and slaves. These spaces are still scenes of confinement, but modernized, they also show the psychologically devastating effects of social regimentation, dullness and a loveless unproductive existence. Other Gothic echoes symbolize the foreign ‘trickiness’ and duplicity of Catholic behaviour, suggesting also that these qualities are now embedded in contemporary public and private life. Plots dependent on unexpected twists, surprising disguises and obscure motivations do just this, simultaneously connecting practitioners of this heretical faith to other marginalized groups that menace social equilibrium. The rewriting of Gothic features reveals the ‘truth’ of Catholicism as a ‘sensational’ social reality. The thematics of exposure, characteristic of Victorian literary sensationalism and a key feature in the 1860s sensation genre, also influences the depiction of the Church of Rome. Recurrent motifs of Catholic disguise and concealment underpin this theme. Combined with suspenseful plots about those with secret motives, they suggest the boldness with which the malign can capitalize on failing moral standards and the impotence of public institutions to protect the nation. Sexual transgressions, ‘invisible’ crimes including impersonation and fraud, and shadowy acts of violence, like murder and kidnapping, constitute one category of revelation, suggesting popery’s corruption. But Catholic writers exploit the rhetoric of exposure, too, uncovering equally unsuspected ‘secrets’: the anguish of a tormented, unworthy conscience, for example, or the spiritual merit of a broken body. Through disclosure of the hidden, sensationalism presents itself as a discourse of knowledge, revealing the truth about identity and values in contemporary society. When Henry James remarked that sensation novels dealt with ‘those most mysterious of mysteries, the mysteries which are at our own doors’,32 he could equally well have been describing sensational versions of Catholicism in the period. They too unearth the buried forces in middle-class culture that belie its orderly, progressive self-image. These representations speak of lost confidence in the moral authority and judgement of ‘proper’ individuals and ‘respected’ institutions.
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 14
15/3/07 14:40:44
introduction
15
The metaphors and linguistic register of sensationalism suggest a world that is unfathomable and unregulated. Eschewing the understated and referential codes of realism, sensationalism continuously heightens emotions by privileging the grotesque and the strange. Linguistic excesses typify the sensationalizing of Roman Catholicism in the period, not only to demonize the monstrosity of an unorthodox faith, but also to dramatize its devotee as exceeding the normal range of behaviours, be that through transcendent enthusiasm or overwrought fanaticism. Victorian Catholics and their detractors portray capitulation to the faith as highly charged, overwhelming in its irresistibility and intensity. Identified by their surrender to the ecstasy of exotic worship or the austere morbidity of ascetic mortifications and martyrdom, ‘sensationalized’ Catholics become a focus for the somatic and emotional anxieties that underpin other readings of literary sensationalism in the period. Indeed, the same terms used to represent ‘fanatical’ Catholicism appear in the reservations expressed by reviewers of sensation fiction in the 1860s. Both are linked in the Victorian imagination with irrationality and madness, with the capacity to ‘convuls[e] the soul’ through an appeal to the body.33 Just as Catholicism, in the minds of many Victorians, seemed to endanger social order and the moral health of individuals, so sensationalism seemed to undermine public taste and the mental equilibrium of a vast readership. Margaret Oliphant complained about the need of her age for a constant ‘supply of new shocks and wonders’ and for the ‘frequent and rapid recurrence of piquant situation and startling incident’.34 Like many of her contemporaries, she disparaged sensationalism because it aimed solely at ‘pure sensation, neither more nor less’. 35 Devoid of serious subject matter and moral judgement, such writing threatened bourgeois priorities with its anti-intellectualism and attack on traditional ideals. Even worse, it seemed to encourage a dangerous social volatility, whipping up uncontrollable ‘nerves’ and a frenzy of suspicion while pandering to prurient curiosity. As H. L. Mansel tartly noted, this was poisonous reading that carried ‘the whole nervous system by steam’ and set the reader’s ‘hair on end or his teeth on edge’.36 This emphasis on the physical reminds us that, for Victorians, the term ‘sensationalism’ had important connections with the ‘mental sciences’ and with theories about mental disturbance. Associationists, with their physiological approach to the mind, drew on knowledge of the senses, sensation, and the mechanics of perception and cognition to remodel the body–mind relationship as a continuum.37 Literary reviewers who disliked sensationalism could invoke science as proof of the connection between overstimulated nerves and
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 15
15/3/07 14:40:45
16 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature disordered minds. The eminent psychologist, Alexander Bain, for instance, argued that sensation – the transmission of nervous impulses – was ‘the very essence of cerebral action’.38 However, the connection between vibrating nerves and consciousness was a mysterious one. Victorian physiology had considerable difficulty shaping this linkage into a coherent narrative that accounted for extreme states of mind, irrational aberrations, delusions and hysteria. Consequently, as Jenny Bourne Taylor has shown, sensationalist psychology gave at least as much attention to controlling the deviances of irrationality as explicating them.39 From the 1840s to the 1880s, theories of moral management and self-regulation played a central role in the attempt to regulate the relationship between the conscious, willed self and mysterious disturbances hidden deep in the psyche. The ability to exercise self-control independently was seen as a fundamental distinction between the mentally ‘normal’ and the lunatic. Even those psychologists who saw that mental health was conditioned by inheritance, past experiences and the environment, nonetheless urged ‘a continued culture of the intellectual and moral faculties’ to aid self-formation.40 Whether to treat the insane by oppressive institutional supervision or by more humane methods that encouraged selfhelp and self-mastery was another matter of lively debate, largely because of uncertainty about the exact nature and cause of insanity. Catholic sensationalism shows the influence of such thinking in its treatment of the Church’s authoritarian ethos of control and discipline, and in its emphasis on faith as a non-rational experience, aroused by the body through sensuous ritual or the pains of ascetic practices. It presents an important means by which Victorians could think and speak about the appropriate balance between the will, the body and the emotions and the relative merits of institutional regulation and the culture of self-management. Identified with ‘something hot and strong’ in both subject matter and effects,41 sensationalism intersects with physiological psychology and Catholicism in the Victorian imagination to entwine spiritual, mental and aesthetic perils. Reviewers of sensation novels feared that these narratives would have an unwholesome effect on the mind, agitating and unsettling: ‘they deprave the taste … enfeeble rather than strengthen the intellect … stimulate the very feelings which they should have sought to repress’.42 By admitting readers to what Margaret Oliphant called a ‘confused moral world’, the mode itself constituted a countercultural threat to the character of the nation.43 It undermined the social body as well as the spiritual and psychological stability of individuals. Religious terminology was itself invoked to
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 16
15/3/07 14:40:45
introduction
17
emphasize these dangers. H. L. Mansel complained, for example, that sensation literature usurped the moral and spiritual authority rightfully belonging to the Protestant clergyman. Seizing ‘a portion of the preacher’s office’, these popular novels played ‘no inconsiderable part in moulding the minds and forming the habits and tastes of its generation’.44 Their ‘preaching to the nerves’ was a sign of social deterioration and a general lowering of standards in private and public life: works of this class manifest themselves as belonging, some more, some less, but all to some extent, to the morbid phenomena of literature – indications of a wide-spread corruption, of which they are in part both the effect and the cause; called into existence to supply the cravings of a diseased appetite, and contributing themselves to foster the disease, and to stimulate the want which they 45 supply.
An 1867 review similarly denounced sensationalism as ‘artistic atheism in its lowest phase’ because it erased traditional boundaries between right and wrong, encouraging sympathies that ‘tend to set us in active opposition to some conventional moral regards’.46 Sensational portrayals of the heretical Church of Rome in the period employed many of the themes and stylistic features which these reviewers suspected – and to similar effect. However, they more safely shunted cultural difference, contamination and decadence into an alien territory. Written and read as sensational, Roman Catholicism seemed a strange, oppositional force and a seductive spectacle. Presented as fantastic but real, a metaphor of the unorthodox, it functioned as a significant imaginary space embracing the unfamiliar, but also challenging the Victorian status quo. In Protestant Britain, the sensational depiction of Catholicism as hyperbolically different – and powerful by virtue of this difference – forms an important element in Victorian narratives of social identity. As this book illustrates, the main plots, character types and motifs of Catholic sensationalism constitute a unified rhetoric with three main effects. As signifier of the unconventional, it promotes dominant middle-class norms through comparison of these to the heretical denominational Other. Catholic sensationalism thus operates as a conservative ‘micro-mechanism of power’, to use Michel Foucault’s phrase.47 Norm-setting is accomplished by juxtaposing a scandalous Catholic culture and a sane, healthy British society identified primarily with its post-Reformation roots. The technique champions those beliefs and values that counteract Catholic ‘horrors’ and oppression. With its emphasis on papal tyranny, the imprisoning cloister and the Inquisitorial torturer, Catholic sensationalism demonstrates the dangers of an overbearing
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 17
15/3/07 14:40:45
18 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature external ‘management’ of the population. Shocking narratives of foreign authoritarianism give ‘spiritual’ legitimacy to Victorian middle-class ideals of individualism and entrepreneurship, of self-help and self-discipline. However, Catholic sensationalism also functions more ambivalently. It exposes heterodox disturbances lodged invisibly within British cultural formations, including nationhood and gender. The imagery and plots of subversion characteristic of the mode often suggest there is a symbiotic relationship between this foreign culture and British orthodoxy. A characteristic motif for the Catholic presence is the organism that invades and lives off its host: plague and contagion, for example, or secretly rooting ‘noxious weeds’, or the destructive, burrowing pest: ‘Roman Catholics like to work in subterranean chambers; century after century, acre after acre, throwing up a little mole-heap here and there just to let their friends above know that they are alive …’48 Such sensationalizing tropes construct Catholicism as a magnet for all that subverts society from within. When Walter Bagehot gives voice to his loathing of the Catholic ‘beast’, his racially inflected comments express a fear of social contamination as much as of denominational difference: ‘every sound mind would prefer a beloved child to produce a tail, a hide of hair, and a taste for nuts, in comparison with transubstantiation, wax-candles, and a belief in the glories of Mary’.49 This ridiculing conflation of Catholic ‘superstitions’ with the degeneration of the species is indicative of the metaphoric value of Catholic sensationalism as cultural shorthand for different kinds of irregularity. In this imaginary model of Catholicism, religious and secular discourses bleed into each other to express social disquiet about dissenters at the domestic margins. Thus, rebellious spinsters and effete men, class climbers and social impostors, aesthetes who proselytise on behalf of beautiful form, sensualists and hysterics, all have their place in the plots and archetypal characters of Catholic sensationalism. Finally, sensational representations of Catholicism subtly encode a masked version of middle-class Victorian Britain. The most morbid thrills of these extravagant constructions depend on a Catholicism that is not only alien but also uncannily double. In a sensational register, the Catholic menace mirrors the very culture it purportedly threatens. Its greed, cruelty, sexual desire and self-centred obsession shadily replicate the attitudes, aspirations and conduct of the establishment and magnify its failings. Such patterns fracture the reassuring narratives that sustain Victorian middle-class confidence. In the imaginative domain of Catholic sensationalism, values seen as core to British public and private life – self-sufficiency and duty, respect-
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 18
15/3/07 14:40:45
introduction
19
ability and advancement – frequently become the object of critique rather than the norm to be emulated. On the other hand, as sociologists like Chris Jenks have noted, ‘[e]very rule, limit, boundary or edge carries with it its own fracture, penetration or impulse to disobey’.50 The same is true of Catholic sensationalism in Victorian literature. The narrative patterns and images of this strange territory on occasion open a space of productive resistance in which alternative identities can be explored and mainstream beliefs deconstructed. For this reason, Catholic sensationalism can ultimately be read as the fantastic expression of the Victorian cultural unconscious, the displacement of inexpressible contradictions, uncertainties and desires. This literary modelling of Catholicism is a persistent phenomenon throughout the period. The authors and texts chosen for investigation demonstrate its range and diversity within middle-class Victorian Britain, from its opening years (with Aguilar’s The Vale of Cedars, or The Martyr) to the 1890s (with the work of Francis Thompson and Mary Ward). Catholic sensationalism is employed by male and female writers, and by those from a range of denominational backgrounds (and none): from the Broad Church Charles Kingsley to the Quaker-raised Joseph Shorthouse, from the Jewish Aguilar to the agnostic George Eliot, and of course, Roman Catholics themselves, including Hopkins and Thompson. As the selected texts illustrate, the dominant motifs of the mode are resilient. They surface in both Victorian poetry and fiction. They infiltrate a variety of genres appealing to a wide cross-section of middle-class readers of the period, from the sophisticated and serious to those who favoured mainstream and popular entertainment. Although inflected by different secular preoccupations at different moments, Catholic sensationalism is remarkably consistent in its themes, archetypal characters and effects, whether it occurs in lyrics or dramatic monologues; historical fiction or narratives with contemporary settings; romances of politics and philosophy or those of courtship and domesticity; in realist modes or fictions in a more light-hearted and extravagant register. The chapters which follow exploit this diversity in order to propose a typology for Catholic sensationalism and to explore its three-fold effects in imaginative literature of the period. Close readings of specific works, both popular and canonical, are contextualized through analysis of key character types, plots, and motifs that persist in this discourse throughout the nineteenth century: the Jesuit; the cloister; persecution and martyrdom; conversion; and worship, ritual and devotional practice. They show how Catholic sensationalism shapes the culture it articulates by revising and, at times, resisting specific assumptions and practices that underpin Victorian
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 19
15/3/07 14:40:45
20 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature cultural formations. This book also suggests that Catholic sensationalism is a fluid discourse, variously inflected by different nineteenth-century debates about art, empire, gender, the emotions, and the body. The chapters are organized to illustrate this interaction. Chapters 1, 2 and 3 examine the relationship of sensationalized representations of Catholicism to concerns about the delicate balance between the individual and cultural institutions (state, family, gender, law). Here, portrayals of an excessive, violent Catholicism function as ‘cultural metaphors’ for contemporary versions of selfhood. In this context, Catholic sensationalism dramatizes conflicts (and possible resolutions) between individual desire, duty to a higher authority, and responsibility for the public good. The last two chapters of the book concentrate primarily on writing of the 1880s and 1890s. They relate the sensationalizing of Catholicism to the growing Victorian interest in ‘interiority’ with reference to the emotions and the imagination. Chapter 1 focuses on the archetypal representative of Catholic Otherness: the scheming priest of the Society of Jesus. With their special pledge of loyalty to the Pope, their emphasis on intellectual achievement, and their dual roles as confessors to monarchs and aristocrats and as missionaries abroad, Jesuits have a significant place in the history of European power politics from the Counter-Reformation. In British culture from the Elizabethan period, the ‘Black Robe’ Jesuit has been demonized as a wily and treacherous enemy. Allied with national opponents like Spain, he threatens to pervert English Protestant destiny through the exertion of global control. The Order’s strict authoritative hierarchy and expectation of total obedience is also read as a sign of Catholic antipathy to freedom of conscience and individual rights. The chapter shows how the Victorian representation of the Jesuit through the rhetoric of sensationalism builds on this cultural myth to express contemporary concerns about the relationship between nationhood and subjecthood. Vilification of the Jesuit ostensibly makes the case for self-sufficiency and entrepreneurship as natural British attributes. But it also reveals uncertainty about the efficacy of these traits for ensuring a productive society at its macro (state) and micro (family) levels. The myth of the Jesuit takes on a distinctively Victorian self-consciousness about the fragility of national identity and health. Although written at different historical points of the period, Charles Kingsley’s patriotic historical novel, Westward Ho!, and Wilkie Collins’s sensation novel, The Black Robe, both use the plot of Jesuit invasion to reflect on the state of contemporary English culture and the possible illusions which sustain it. With the Jesuit bid for authority over the heart of the individual and the soul of the nation comes the unpalatable
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 20
15/3/07 14:40:46
introduction
21
discovery of moral hypocrisy and emotional impoverishment at the core of British society. In these exemplars of Catholic sensationalism, Victorian confidence in family and state emerges as a cultural fantasy itself, the projection of lack and insecurity. Chapter 2 is concerned broadly with social relations, focusing on representations of Catholicism that intersect with those codes of gender difference and respectability that convey status on the Victorian individual. In Catholic sensationalism, prurient representations of Catholic nuns and priests emphasize impropriety, hypocrisy and deviance. Behaviour in the cloister helps to define the anti-social and the transgressive with respect to gender roles and sexual conduct. However, these motifs of the culturally undesirable also dramatize new models for the gendered self. In Villette, Charlotte Brontë appropriates multiple readings of the Catholic convent circulating in the period to imagine a new type of female autonomy. Robert Browning exploits the contemporary relish for tales of Catholic clerical excess in his monologues about priests and monks. Through dubious churchmen, he lays bare the shadow side of masculine power and authority embodied in the reassuring Victorian images of the public man and the paterfamilias. For both Brontë and Browning, the devices of Catholic sensationalism facilitate the authors’ adoption of a culturally transgressive position. Only the unorthodox rebel can bypass the authority of convention to become a herald of social change. Chapter 3 explores the most lurid plot of Catholic sensationalism: that of bodily torment, persecution and martyrdom. The main literary focus of the chapter is on two novels that illustrate how ‘historicized’ versions of Catholic sensationalism are in dialogue with a self-conscious Victorian society. Both fictions capture a particular Victorian mood in their concern with communities in the midst of rapid change and social crisis. Horrific tales of Catholic persecution reveal uneasiness about the ways in which stability, conformity and cohesiveness might be maintained – or coerced – amidst political and intellectual turmoil. Spectacular cruelties by and to Catholics certainly express the struggle between personal conscience and institutional authority. Yet the ambivalent portrayal of Catholic victimizers and victims reveals early and mid-Victorian difficulties in reconciling two central ideologies of the time: that of individualism and that of social obligation and duty. Grace Aguilar and George Eliot remodel Catholic religious tyranny and suffering to examine what dedication and justice can mean in a competitive and individualistic society. In The Vale of Cedars, or The Martyr, Aguilar contrasts the dual heroics of resistance and of social obedience in a
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 21
15/3/07 14:40:46
22 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature novel about the Spanish Inquisition and the persecution of the Jews. George Eliot’s Romola also uses a Catholic historical setting – fifteenth-century Florence and the rise and fall of the Dominican preacher Savonarola – to reflect on the same tensions. The plot of persecution and martyrdom assesses several kinds of power relationships: that between body and soul, but also those between the individual subject and the various forces of law that seek to regulate and control. For Eliot, the persecuted body serves as a metaphor for a body politic that both deserves and does not merit its fate. For both authors, the martyred body is an ideologically bifurcated text in its own right; it speaks simultaneously of egotistical will power and humble selfabnegation. Works that draw on the plot of conversion are central to Chapter 4. The emotionalized discourse of Catholic sensationalism gives special scope for dramatizing and interpreting the complex effects of the feelings and unconscious impulses on personality and action. The secular cult of sympathy and the Evangelical belief in genuine religious experience as a matter of the heart are just two examples of the Victorian confidence in the ‘tender feelings’ as a reliable authority for moral decision-making. In the final decades of the century, however, the plot of Catholic conversion lends itself to revisions of the Victorian understanding of interiority. Because it emphasizes emotional manipulation and internal conflict, the sensationalized treatment of conversion transforms the familiar conflict between human desire and faith into a tale of self-betrayal and psychological damage. In Disraeli’s Lothair, Shorthouse’s John Inglesant and Ward’s Helbeck of Bannisdale, this plot encodes a shadow narrative about the potency of the buried life and its impact on adult subjectivity. The familiar conversion narrative of fervour and estrangement is adapted in ways that construct the modern subject as conflicted, alienated and abjected. Travel writing about the Continent as well as public religious ceremonies in Britain ensured many Victorians had at least a second-hand impression of the sumptuous and elaborate practices of Catholic devotional life. Chapter 5 examines Victorian responses to the aesthetic of sensation that informed these arts of worship. The sensationalizing of Catholic liturgy draws attention to its sensuous form and beautiful spectacle. Ritual is portrayed as extravagant and mysterious, particularly when contrasted to the low-key reserve of Anglican ceremony and the austerity of Dissenting faiths. However, these representations also reflect the struggle for aesthetic authority in nineteenth-century artistic discourses. Anticipating the anxieties about Aestheticism and art for art’s sake later in the century, the disapproval of Catholic devotional art in
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 22
15/3/07 14:40:46
introduction
23
the early and mid-Victorian period focuses on its irrational, immoral and decadent nature. It establishes both Catholic practices and the aesthetic of sensation as acts of cultural subversion. Certain non-Catholic and Catholic poets of the period take advantage of this heretical space, elaborating a revolutionary poetics modelled on Catholic devotional practice. Dante Gabriel Rossetti employs Catholic topics and images to announce a radical new aesthetic – art as the worship of beauty. He privileges sensuous form, evocative effects, and emotional responses as the essence of aesthetic experience and the source of its ‘truth’. Late Victorian Catholic poetry also makes specific connection to Catholic devotions and ritual practice. The work of Gerard Manley Hopkins and Francis Thompson bears the imprint of the transformation in Catholic worship and devotional writing that occurred in Victorian Britain. The ‘New Catholic Baroque’ embraces an aesthetic of sensuous spirituality, highly charged emotional states, and intimate selfexposure. In thematic and stylistic extravagance, the exhibitionist poetic practice of Hopkins and Thompson invokes this new style to express the ecstasy and pain of connection with the unfathomable Divine. In the Epilogue, I offer some brief reflections on the significance of Catholic sensationalism for an interpretation of the Victorian past. In its interweaving of secular and denominational anxieties, the sensational modelling of Roman Catholicism is central to the system of symbolic thinking that constructs Victorian cultural reality. Its recurrence in diverse literary manifestations from the beginning to the end of the era establishes the persistence of sensationalism as a major discursive practice in the period. Most importantly of all, perhaps, the study of Catholic sensationalism indicates the value of re-engaging with Victorian religious attitudes at the denominational level. Religious assumptions permeate nineteenth-century cultural formations of all kinds. Not only do they shape day-to-day conduct and personal destinies, but they also form a major part of the imaginative lexicon through which the period articulates and interprets itself to itself. Poised between story and history, the sensationalized treatment of Roman Catholicism is an important cultural trope for nineteenth-century writers and readers. For moderns, it reveals new continuities and connections within the vast Victorian project of personal and collective self-fashioning.
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 23
15/3/07 14:40:46
24 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
Notes 1 Frederick William Faber, ‘Faith of our Fathers’, in Hymns, 2nd edn (London: Burns & Oates, 1861), p. 265. 2 Henry H. Bourn, Words of Warning respecting The Jesuits, blasphemously called ‘The Society of Jesus’ (London: S. W. Patridge, n.d. [1890?]), p. 46. 3 The most comprehensive historical accounts of Catholicism in Victorian Britain focus on the denomination’s profile and development in England, a focus commensurate with the Victorian tendency to elide nationality (English) and citizenship (British). These include: George Andrew Beck, ed., The English Catholics 1850–1950: Essays to Commemorate the Centenary of the Restoration of the Hierarchy of England and Wales (London: Burns & Oates, 1950); John Bossy, The English Catholic Community 1570–1850 (London: Darton, Longman & Todd, 1975); Denis Gwyn, The Second Spring 1818–1852: A Study of the Catholic Revival in England (London: Burns & Oates, 1942); John Hickey, Urban Catholics: Urban Catholicism in England and Wales from 1829 to the Present Day (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1967); David Mathew, Catholicism in England: The Portrait of a Minority: Its Culture and Tradition, 3rd edn (London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1955); E. R. Norman, The English Catholic Church in the Nineteenth Century (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1984); E. R. Norman, Roman Catholicism in England: from the Elizabethan Settlement to the Second Vatican Council (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985); E. I. Watkin, Roman Catholicism in England from the Reformation to 1950 (London: Oxford University Press, 1957). Rich scholarly accounts of anti-Catholic fervour in the period also give valuable insights into the Victorian Catholic experience from a range of denominational perspectives. Of particular value in this respect are: E. R. Norman, Anti-Catholicism in Victorian England (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1968); D. G. Paz, Popular AntiCatholicism in Mid-Victorian England (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1992); John Wolffe, The Protestant Crusade in Great Britain: 1829–1860 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991). For general treatment of Victorian denominational history, Owen Chadwick’s The Victorian Church, 2 vols, 2nd edn (London: Adam & Charles Black, 1970), and Horton Davies’s Worship and Theology in England, vol. III, From Watts and Wesley to Maurice, 1690–1850; vol. IV, From Newman to Martineau, 1850–1900 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1961/2) remain central works for consultation. 4 Jenny Franchot, Roads to Rome: The Antebellum Protestant Encounter with Catholicism (London: University of California Press, 1994). 5 Susan M. Griffin, Anti-Catholicism in Nineteenth-Century Fiction, Cambridge Studies in American Literature and Culture No. 141 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004). 6 Pierre Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production: Essays on Art and Literature, ed. Randal Johnson (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1993), p. 71. 7 Thomas Babington Macaulay, The History of England: From the Accession of James II (1848; London: J. M. Dent, 1906), I, p. 359. For a recent historical account of the presumptions on which Macaulay’s readers would draw for their understanding of Catholicism, see Colin Haydon, ‘“I love my King and my Country, but a Roman Catholic I hate”: anticatholicism, xenophobia and national identity in eighteenth-century England’, in Protestantism and National Identity: Britain and Ireland, c.1650–c.1850, ed. Tony Claydon and Ian McBride (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988), pp. 33–52. The association
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 24
15/3/07 14:40:46
introduction
8 9
10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17
18
19
20 21
22 23
25
of Englishness with antipathy to Catholicism was certainly how Catholics perceived the position in the mid-nineteenth century. In 1851 a priest at St George’s (Roman Catholic) Cathedral in Southwark acknowledged the depth and longevity of the English hatred of his Church. He found it ‘a feeling that lies as deep as the gravel bottom over which London stands’ (quoted in Mary Chamberlain, ‘Growing up Catholic’, in Patriotism: The Making and Unmaking of British National Identity, vol. II, Minorities and Outsiders, ed. Raphael Samuel [London and New York: Routledge, 1989], p. 24). Franchot, Roads to Rome, p. xix. Lauren M. E. Goodlad, Victorian Literature and the Victorian State: Character and Governance in a Liberal Society (Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003), p. 4. Anon, ‘Domestic Jesuitism’, Fraser’s Magazine for Town and Country, XIX ( June 1839), pp. 677, 674. Henry Edward Manning, ‘The Work and the Wants of the Catholic Church in England’ [1863], in Miscellanies (London: Burns & Oates, 1877), I, p. 28. Nicholas Wiseman, ‘From out the Flaminian Gate of Rome’, The Times, 29 October 1850, p. 5. Out of a population of 17,927,609, Catholics numbered 383,630 to the Church of England’s 5,292,531 and the main Protestant Dissenting denominations 4,536,264 (Chadwick, The Victorian Church, I, pp. 363–65). In the next few decades, however, the Catholic population grew quickly, thanks to Irish immigration rather than mass conversion. By the end of the 1880s, the Catholic population in England and Wales numbered 1.25 million (Norman, Anti-Catholicism in Victorian England, p. 17). Norman, Anti-Catholicism in Victorian England, pp. 177, 182. Quoted in Norman, Anti-Catholicism in Victorian England, p. 56. Norman, Anti-Catholicism in Victorian England, p. 57. A Member of the University of Oxford, A Glance at the Intrigues of the Jesuits, and their Allies, for the Humiliation of England, and the Extinction of the Protestant Religion (Bristol: I. E. Chillcott, 1868), p. 12. Quoted in G. F. A. Best, ‘Popular Protestantism in Victorian Britain’, in Ideas and Institutions of Victorian Britain: Essays in Honour of George Kitson Clark, ed. Robert Robson (London: G. Bell & Sons, 1967), p. 115; Member of the University, Intrigues of the Jesuits, p. 12. See, for example, D. A. Miller, The Novel and the Police (Berkeley and London: University of California Press, 1988). Miller suggests that sensation novels demonstrate Victorian paranoia about the state of the modern world. Their plotting and rhetoric assume an audience familiar with a social environment ‘where suspicion and inquiry have already become everyday practices’ due to a sense of pervasive crime and violation (p. 157). Anon., ‘Sense v. Sensation’, Punch, XL (20 July 1861), p. 31. Elizabeth K. Helsinger, Robin Lauterbach Sheets and William Veeder, The Woman Question: Society and Literature in Britain and America 1837–1883, vol. III, Literary Issues (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1983), pp. 210–11. Anon., ‘Belles Lettres’, Westminster Review, XXX ( July 1866), pp. 269–70. For example, Deborah Wynne has identified the ‘Newgate’ crime novel, sensational newspaper reporting of crime, theatrical melodrama, penny dreadfuls and Gothic fiction as influences on Victorian literary sensationalism (The Sensation Novel and the Victorian Family Magazine [Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2001], p. 9). Ann Cvetkovich finds a
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 25
15/3/07 14:40:47
26 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
24
25 26 27 28 29
30 31
32 33 34 35 36 37
38 39
further gesture of disturbance in sensation fiction; it increases class anxiety by drawing its techniques from mass culture (Mixed Feelings: Feminism, Mass Culture, and Victorian Sensationalism [New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1992], pp. 15–17). Ann Cvetkovich takes up Paul Ricoeur’s ‘hermeneutics of suspicion’ to characterize the narrative impetus of sensation fiction ‘in which every fact that excites a sensation merits investigation’ (Mixed Feelings, p. 72). Equally important, however, is the dynamic of revelation or exposure of an unexpected ‘truth’ lying invisible below or alongside the ‘respectable’. Winifred Hughes, The Maniac in the Cellar: Sensation Novels of the 1860s (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980), p. 70. Anon., ‘Our Female Sensation Novelists’, Christian Remembrancer, n.s., XLVI, no. cxxi ( July-October 1864), 210. Mark M. Hennelly, Jr., ‘Reading Detection in The Woman in White’, Texas Studies in Literature and Language, 22 (1980), pp. 449–67. Cvetkovich, Mixed Feelings, pp. 84–85. Winifred Hughes’s The Maniac in the Cellar is an essential reference point for the historical contextualization and generic features of sensation fiction as a genre of the Victorian novel. A crisp survey of form, influences and handling of social and gender transgression in the genre can be found in Lyn Pykett’s The Sensation Novel: From ‘The Woman in White’ to ‘The Moonstone’ (Plymouth: Northcote House, 1994). Nicholas Rance, Wilkie Collins and Other Sensation Novelists: Walking the Moral Hospital (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1991), pp. 3–4. For a comprehensive account of Catholic elements in eighteenth- and early nineteenthcentury Gothic literature, see Sister Mary Muriel Tarr, Catholicism in Gothic Fiction: A Study of the Nature and Function of Catholic Materials in Gothic Fiction in England (1762–1820) (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 1946). Tarr’s survey of such topics as ‘monkish superstition’, ‘monastic gloom’ and ‘morbid devotions’ concludes that the Gothic use of Catholicism illustrates key eighteenth-century intellectual trends such as Deism, ‘Shaftesburian benevolence’, and the Burkean sublime (p. 122). Robert Mighall’s analysis of the Victorian Gothic briefly considers how the nineteenthcentury handled the earlier Gothic encoding of Catholicism as ‘reactionary’ against which the modern and the progressive can be contrasted (A Geography of Victorian Gothic Fiction: Mapping History’s Nightmares [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999], p. 6). Henry James, ‘Miss Braddon’, Nation, 9 November 1865, in Wilkie Collins: The Critical Heritage, ed. Norman Page (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1974), p. 122. [H. L. Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, Quarterly Review, 113, no. 226 (April 1863), p. 483. [Margaret Oliphant], ‘Sensation Novels’, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, XCI (May 1862), pp. 564, 568. [Oliphant], ‘Sensation Novels’, p. 572. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, p. 487. For a more detailed discussion of sensationalism and associationism, see Rick Rylance, Victorian Psychology and British Culture 1850–1880 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), pp. 59–65. Alexander Bain, The Senses and the Intellect, 1868; quoted in Rylance, Victorian Psychology, p. 172. Jenny Bourne Taylor, In the Secret Theatre of Home: Wilkie Collins, sensation narrative,
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 26
15/3/07 14:40:47
introduction
40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47
48
49 50
27
and nineteenth-century psychology (London and New York: Routledge, 1988), pp. 45– 46. Quoted in Jenny Bourne Taylor and Sally Shuttleworth, eds, Embodied Selves: An Anthology of Psychological Texts 1830–1890 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998), p. 280. For an overview of moral management debates, see pp. 227–30. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, p. 485. Anon., ‘Recent Novels: their Moral and Religious Teaching’, London Quarterly Review, XXVII (October 1866), p. 102. [Margaret Oliphant], ‘Novels’, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, XCIV (August 1863), p. 169. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, p. 482. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, pp. 482–83. H. A. Page [A. H. Japp], ‘The Morality of Art’, Contemporary Review, 5 (May-August 1867), p. 178. Michel Foucault, Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977, ed. Colin Gordon, trans. Colin Gordon et al. (New York and London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1980), p. 101. Thomas Lathbury, The State of Popery and Jesuitism in England; from the Reformation to the Period of the Roman Catholic Relief Bill in 1829: and the Charge of Novelty, Heresy, and Schism Against the Church of Rome Substantiated (London: John Leslie, 1838), p. 275; Rev. J[ohn] Cumming, The Pope, the Man of Sin: A Lecture Delivered on Tuesday, May 27th 1851 (London: Piper & Co. and John F. Shaw, 1851), p. 10. Walter Bagehot, ‘Edward Gibbon’ (1856), in The Collected Works of Walter Bagehot, ed. Norman St John-Stevas (London: The Economist, 1965), I, p. 363. Chris Jenks, Transgression (London: Routledge, 2003), p. 7.
LUP_Moran_01_Intro.indd 27
15/3/07 14:40:47
1 Sensational Invasions: The Jesuit, the State and the Family Charles Kingsley’s Westward Ho! and Wilkie Collins’s The Black Robe What is this alien on British soil? — R. W. Overbury, The Jesuits
1
Where is the Jesuit do you say? yea, where is he not? They multiply as maggots in May … 2 — R. J. M’Ghee, The Poor Gentleman of Liége ‘Jesuitism on the brain’ is a phenomenon not unknown both in our political and religious world … [a] psychological condition in itself. 3 — John Tulloch, ‘The Order of Jesuits’
In 1880, a priest took the pulpit in St Francis Xavier’s Roman Catholic church in Liverpool, looked carefully at the congregation, extended his hand theatrically, and proclaimed three times in a voice rising in sonority: ‘To hell with the Jesuits.’ After a measured pause to ensure maximum impact on the startled parishioners, he continued in a voice of quiet resignation: ‘Such is the cry today.’4 This sensational moment can still strike a modern reader, as it electrified Father Tom Burke’s listeners, through its shocking juxtaposition of the sacrilegious and the familiar. Like so many nineteenth-century representations of Catholicism, this episode has an uncanny resonance; it disconcerts precisely because it relocates a pervasive social attitude in an unfamiliar space. For his audience, Burke’s teasing performance dramatized Catholic identity in Victorian society at large. Whatever the law, adherents of the Church of Rome stood culturally apart, treated as marginal, alien and sinister. And to make this point, Burke drew on a cultural commonplace: the demonization of the Jesuit as the archetype of Catholic strangeness and wickedness. This chapter explores the meanings associated with lurid portrayals of the Jesuit order – the Society of Jesus – in nineteenth-century elite and popular culture. In Victorian history writing, religious tracts and fiction, lurid representations of the Jesuit have a significance that exceeds denominational
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 28
15/3/07 17:06:21
sensational invasions
29
differentiation. They show the complex cultural politics at work in the religious discourse of the day. Throughout the nineteenth century, both polemical writing and popular narratives employ the treacherous Jesuit to examine the formation and meaning of nationhood and inscribe a distinctively British model of social conduct.5 However, when the stock Jesuit villain is read through the discourse of sensationalism discussed in the Introduction, the character emerges as a repository of conflicting feelings about the nation’s collective self-image. Constructed as an aggressive invader from Catholic countries and as a secretive infiltrator of the British domestic scene, the Jesuit plays three distinct though contradictory roles in the Victorian cultural imaginary. He is simultaneously the dangerous alien, the arch-criminal within the British underworld, and the symbol of unresolved tensions embedded in Victorian models of social relations. This chapter begins with a wide-ranging examination of this triple ‘encoding’ in Catholic sensationalism in different works, and goes on to discuss its detailed operation in two novels of contrasting types: Charles Kingsley’s historical romance, Westward Ho! (1855), and Wilkie Collins’s sensation novel, The Black Robe (1880–81). At a time of cultural upheaval, transition and expansion, the crow-like ‘Black Robe’ signifies both social confidence and uncertainty. In each of his primary manifestations, the Jesuit offers particular perspectives on a modern British subjecthood which is both an idealised abstraction or ‘imagined community’ and a ‘performed’ behaviour. As representative of a despotic foreign religious culture, the Jesuit is a force to be opposed by a distinctive, unified national identity and purpose.6 Caricatured as dangerous outsider, he becomes the unacceptable Other against which a healthy British political and social character can be constructed and affirmed. However, the other two characterizations of the Jesuit are altogether more ambivalent. Through his incursions into British territory, he gives rise to more sobering reflections on national ill-health at the levels of home and state. The Jesuit succeeds in his countercultural schemes because of social division, weakness and venality. His bizarre and covert plots reveal a pervasive criminal substructure that underlies British society in public and private spheres. Finally, in particular versions of the wicked Jesuit tale, the actions of the Society of Jesus serve as symbolic parallel rather than contrast to the principles and operations of British secular institutions. As cultural metaphor, the figure of the invisible but ever-present Jesuit is a shadowy reminder of the hidden inconsistencies concealed by the idealized British character – upright, resilient and selfless, tolerant and committed to individual freedoms. Whether at the level of the state and empire in Westward Ho! or of the intimate family
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 29
15/3/07 17:06:22
30 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature in The Black Robe, the Victorian portrayal of the scheming Jesuit both asserts and deconstructs the myth of English liberal identity. From its foundation by Ignatius Loyola in 1540, the Society of Jesus had a distinctive Counter-Reformation commitment to support the papacy and to propagate the Catholic faith throughout the world by education, political influence and missionary work. In sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Reformation England, Jesuitism was viewed as the aggressive military arm of a Catholicism with global ambitions. The Society’s deep roots in mission fields that were potential English colonies, its intimate relation to papal temporal and spiritual power, and its influence at the Spanish and French courts all encouraged the vilification of the Jesuit in English narratives of national usurpation and revival. When Jesuit missionaries came to England in 1580, fears for English sovereignty coalesced around the Society. Jesuitism became a sign of spiritual and temporal invasion that would subvert not only the religious faith but also the civil allegiance of the English people. A ‘Jesuited’ country under the Society’s control would be ‘unEnglished . . . [its citizens] alienated from their nationality’.7 Similar fears are still alive in the polemics of the nineteenth century. Legislation to restore Catholic civil rights enshrines paranoia about the Society of Jesus, illustrating its deep hold on the English political and cultural consciousness. The Catholic Emancipation Act of 1829 reads the Jesuit ‘plot’ as a continual and pre-eminent danger to national traditions. While the new law seeks ‘the gradual suppression and final prohibition’ of Catholic religious communities in Great Britain, the Jesuits are the only order singled out by name for this policy of extinction.8 Members of the Society domiciled in England could stay and English Jesuits might return from abroad, but no other members of the Society could enter England unless under licence and then only for six months. The Society could not proselytize or admit new members to the order within the United Kingdom. These features of the legislation were not enforced, but anxiety about Jesuit ambition and power continued throughout the Victorian period. In 1893, for example, an Edinburgh audience was warned about new Jesuit schemes ‘for the conquest of the globe … [to] plant the foot of the pope on the neck of a prostrate mankind’.9 Victorians inherited – and developed – a belief that Jesuitism represented an international menace and, more particularly, an alien presence infesting the country, attacking the nation’s constitution and social stability, and requiring a clear framework for containment and control. While there is consistency from the sixteenth to the twentieth centuries
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 30
15/3/07 17:06:22
sensational invasions
31
in the characterization of the Jesuit as a dangerous enemy of England, the rhetorical strategies of sensationalism give a distinctively Victorian perspective to the reading of this ‘foreign’ Society. Although the Jesuit remains an alien figure, Victorian representations register alarm at his place in the domestic scene. No longer primarily an outside agent with diabolical powers in the black arts of political usurpation, the sensationalized Jesuit undermines middle-class British society from an integrated position within the community. His deceit subverts popular communal ideals, including belief in national progress and freedom, respect for individual rights and autonomy, and personal acceptance of responsibility expressed as self-control and dutifulness. Embedding the Jesuit in a web of verbal and narrative excess that provokes both outrage and shock, Victorian writing recasts him as an uncanny figure, terrifyingly strange and, at the same time, disturbingly familiar. Well before critics and readers gave a name to the ‘sensation’ novels of the 1860s, sensationalized narratives of Jesuit machinations occupy the same stylistic space. However, the parallels are unmistakable, and help to explain the contradictory meanings that accrued to the figure in the period. Margaret Maison, for example, has characterized the content and tone of popular Victorian religious novels with Jesuit themes as horrific in their ‘crudity, sadism, hysteria and blood-curdling violence’.10 Nineteenth-century definitions of sensation fiction single out the same semantic features. They routinely emphasize practices already commonplace in the Jesuit tale of insurrection and conversion: complex plots of ‘horror, excitement, and crime’ and duplicitous villains expert in ‘cheating, lying, swindling, stealing, forgery, dissipation, murder’.11 Even more significant for the reading of Victorian Jesuit fictions is the association of sensationalism with cultural abnormality and a certain un-Englishness. Contemporary reviews show how a sense of the foreign is embedded in the understanding of the sensation mode. Constructed as the act of the racial other, even its use is read as an exotic, if not shameful and disgusting, preference: ‘There is no accounting for tastes, blubber for the Esquimaux, half-hatched eggs for the Chinese, and Sensational novels for the English.’12 The sensation style is characterized as one of deviance, aberration and ‘strangeness’.13 Deemed ‘a plant of foreign growth’ out of step with ‘our rules of respectability’, sensationalism is understood by Victorian readers to oppose national standards of morality and conduct.14 In tone, content and effects, it speaks of aesthetic, not just cultural, difference. Whereas the English imagination is represented as distinctive ‘in its hard matter-of-fact sort of way, loving to grip everything with a firm hold,
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 31
15/3/07 17:06:22
32 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 15
and to spend its force … upon something craggy’, the imagination behind sensational discourse is viewed in pathological terms. It is ‘morbid’ in its taste for excitement and shock, irrational in its ‘preaching to the nerves’, and corrupt in its commercial pandering to the ‘cravings of a diseased appetite’ and to a ‘perverted and vitiated taste’.16 ‘Outlandish’ had long been a slang term for Roman Catholics in Britain, indicating their suspect status as outsiders.17 However, the Victorian adoption of the sensationalist register for the portrayal of Jesuits recasts their traditional religious-political danger into a threat to cultural sensibility. In Catholic sensationalism, aesthetics and denominational polemics intersect to inscribe a national identity appropriate to the challenges of nineteenth-century modernity. Associated with the foreign and deviant, sensationalism overtly presents the Jesuit as lying outside the boundaries of the ‘normal’. For a start, its use implies that realism, the discourse associated with rational thought and everyday life, is inadequate for portraying the unnatural deeds of these ruthless Catholic agents. Unexpurgated descriptions of Jesuit violence in Ireland are said to ‘surpass in horror and in cruelty the most thrilling incidents in any modern “sensation” novel’.18 Polemical fiction of the period works on the same assumption. Promotional blurbs for Catherine Sinclair’s anti-Jesuit novel, Beatrice; or, The Unknown Relatives (1852), take for granted that Jesuit behaviour is most appropriately described in terms of shock and excess. The narrative establishes clear denominational boundaries between two Scottish communities – one comprising generous and reasonable Protestants and the other, greedy and overbearing Catholics. However, the main plot dynamic centres on the struggle between the shipwrecked foundling-heroine Beatrice, and conniving, hypnotic Jesuits; they wish to keep her rightful inheritance in Catholic control. Enthusiastic readers justified the sensationalism of the novel by reference to its Catholic content. Commending ‘the high dramatic effect of many of its scenes’, its ‘intense and powerful’ character and its ‘thrilling interest’, they suggest that the novel’s improbabilities add verisimilitude, given ‘the insidious wiles of Romanism’ and ‘the many deceitful acts its votaries use to entrap the unsuspecting’.19 The more startling the disclosures of the novel, the more ‘intelligible as well as perfectly credible’ it becomes, since the world of the Jesuit agent is utterly alien in its wickedness. The arcane plots characteristic of sensationalism are another feature of nineteenth-century Jesuit tales that establish strangeness and cultural otherness. The Jesuit’s manipulation of bizarre and barely comprehensible entanglements is repeatedly invoked as a sign that he represents powers outside the boundaries of an ordered community where individuals have knowledge
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 32
15/3/07 17:06:22
sensational invasions
33
of their world, exercise control over it, and can expect to predict outcomes. For example, the narrator of Eugene Sue’s The Wandering Jew (1845), the popular prototype of nineteenth-century British and Continental antiJesuit fictions, 20 self-consciously draws attention to the florid complications of a plot centred on the just division of a massive inheritance and Society of Jesus scheming to appropriate the fortune. He attributes the mysteries, twists and suspense largely to secretive Jesuit intrigues, especially those of the evil Rodin: Trusting that the reader’s sympathy is with the old soldier thus left desolate, with Agricola in his prison, Adrienne in hers, the madhouse, and Rose and Blanche Simon in theirs, the nunnery; we hasten to assure him (or her, as the case might be), that not only will their future steps be traced, but the dark machinations of the Jesuits, and the thrilling scenes in which new characters will perform their varied parts, pervaded by the watching spirit of the Wandering Jew, will be 21 revealed in Part Second of this work …
Unlike the reviewers of Beatrice, Sue actually foregrounds the fictiveness of the text. The authorial intervention summarizes the now hackneyed Gothic elements that will, a decade or so later, become the stock machinery of the sensationalist shocker: female victimization and incarceration; the dark undercurrents of unnameable terror within respectable institutions; destructive intrigues; hidden identities; the race for an inheritance; and even the possibility of a supernatural agency. Yet, by reminding readers of the melodramatic staginess of the novel, Sue does more than scope the extraordinary extent of Jesuit malevolence. The passage also heightens the uncanny familiarity and unknowableness of this world in which agents of Rome plot against the vulnerable. Even experienced readers who recognize the narrative formulae cannot anticipate or fully understand the events of this nightmare environment. Individual characters have become the passive subjects of a fantastic script ‘written’ by alien forces. The handling of narrative enigma positions the reader, too, in a foreign narratological ‘culture’. Narrative authority and reliability – the basis of realist discourse – are compromised, because the structural requirement for continuous bafflement means the knowledgeable narrator withholds key information.22 Like the characters subjected to Jesuit malevolence, the perplexed observer of Jesuit schemes is disabled. This breach of the familiar ‘contract’ of good faith between author and reader is extended also to characterization, establishing Jesuit foreignness as a threat to recognizable and stable social identities. In The Wandering Jew, for example, Dagobert fails to develop as the unflappable and resourceful
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 33
15/3/07 17:06:22
34 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature stock ‘old soldier’ typical of adventure-romance. Instead, he is paralysed and demoralized by feelings of ‘a vast conspiracy, which surrounds and threatens us all’ (346). Jesuitism confounds his traditional heroic qualities: ‘I am not a coward – and yet I confess – yes, I confess it – these black robes frighten me –’ (346). This imaginative association of the alien Jesuit with impenetrable schemes, impairing individuals and the state, continues to be reproduced in the more extreme late Victorian and Edwardian accounts of Catholic difference. Walter Walsh’s alarmist The Jesuits in Great Britain pinpoints Jesuits as ‘secret wire-pullers’ (129) responsible for ‘many sensational events’ (vii) in the political and social history of the nation.23 In the discourse of Catholic sensationalism, familiar tropes of foreign wickedness are inflected by specific concerns of the historical moment. So, for example, at a time when a Victorian readership linked national identity to the power and authority of empire, Jesuit intrigues take on a breathtaking, international scale. In this rhetorical mode, the Jesuit has a global reach, disrupting social structures throughout the world with impunity because he is a master of disguise. In historical scholarship and polemical writing of the period, Jesuit viciousness is tracked – though only at second hand – through rumour and a trail of disasters. Past outrages laid at the door of the Society, such as the Gunpowder and Titus Oates Plots and the Great Fire of London, are replaced by contemporary events to update the Jesuit challenge to civil authority. The assassination of Abraham Lincoln, for instance, is said to be by a murderer who ‘was only a tool in the hands of the Jesuits’.24 Sensationalized, the Jesuits encapsulate the present danger to free and independent states. Uncannily, these mysterious ‘citizens of no country’25 have the capacity to be everywhere and nowhere, subverting national destiny and challenging the very concept of a secure, stable domestic culture. Fiction takes up this point through techniques that further emphasize the exotic cultural difference of the Jesuit enemy. Fanny Trollope’s novel, Father Eustace: A Tale of the Jesuits (1847), depicts their sly ubiquity by recalling the distant Continental dungeons and monasteries of an earlier literary tradition. The portrayal of Cuthbert Castle, with its hidden doors and secret passages, reconstructs the terrifying Gothic environment as an apt metaphor for the Jesuit ability to infiltrate secure places invisibly. Sensational language also defamiliarizes Jesuit plotting. The narrative traces a Jesuit conspiracy to defraud a family of its birthright. Using a disguised Jesuit to secure the love of the heroine, Juliana, the Society plans her conversion and the subsequent acquisition of her estate. Macabre images of monstrosity emphasize the horror of disrupting the natural line of inheritance. Each Jesuit seems to
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 34
15/3/07 17:06:22
sensational invasions
35
have ‘more eyes than are fabled in the head of a spider, and … weave[s] webs of more delicate and wide-spreading texture … than all the spiders in the world’.26 Trollope also foregrounds the Jesuit’s position as outcast by linking him figuratively to other ‘suspect’ groups alienated by their class and race, and thus incapable of rehabilitation. Jesuits are shown to prey on gullibility and superstition, as if by second nature, in order to further their designs. They are like ‘a party of gipsies dispersing themselves through a neighbourhood for the purpose of telling fortunes, they all gather something in the way of information, and then make common stock of it’ (III, 50). With the elision of religious and class difference, the Jesuit stranger comes to express the amorphous fears of a Victorian bourgeois establishment, suspicious of the concealed, hostile intentions of the ‘lower orders’. Different kinds of unnaturalness repeatedly suggest the Jesuit’s antipathy to the national or ‘home’ culture. As representative of a foreign faith, the familiar image of the Jesuit from Reformation times – the traitor and invader – is transformed through Victorian sensationalism into something physically and psychologically deviant and repugnant. Many works take their lead from Eugene Sue’s comparison of Jesuit practice to the perverse sadism of the Asian Thugs and Stranglers. In The Wandering Jew, the Jesuit, Rodin, is comfortable with these dangerous empire-builders who spread their cult of death wherever they can. The infidel himself sees the similarity between his unholy intentions and those of the Jesuit: ‘his religion, like mine, teaches to change life into nothingness’ (722). In British Protestant polemic, the alien nature of the Jesuit is reinforced by his dehumanization. The members of the Society of Jesus are ‘deadly vipers in [England’s] bosom … twisting their horrid coils around her’ or even an infestation, ‘spreading like locusts’ nationally and abroad.27 Like vampires, they can assume many plausible disguises and infect their enemies with a treacherous kiss, replacing the human with the diabolical. In Victorian sensationalism, the most traumatic powers of this Catholic Other are associated with the psychological oppression of weak and wellintentioned alike. The callous approach of Jesuits to authority and obedience within their own ranks becomes a warning for unsuspecting nations that fail to guard individual freedom and enterprise. Jesuits are fantastically imagined as automatons, subservient to the will of a Society which ‘prepares its agents for their work by first scooping clean out of their bosoms every atom of individual conscience’.28 The total self-annihilation required by the institution of its members – ‘a sort of holocaust’ of private will and judgement – transforms each individual into a mechanical tool, operating with the
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 35
15/3/07 17:06:23
36 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 29
‘noiseless smoothness’ of an insentient cog in a machine. Like the zombie of Gothic nightmare, the Jesuit is represented as enslaved to the Superior’s will and designs. Reduced to a ‘thoroughly translucent’ vessel or ‘panopticon’,30 each member is a hollow shell through which the Superior watches and discovers all. These tropes of bodily horror and morbidity encode Jesuitism (and, more broadly, Catholicism) as an institution of mental abjection. The Society’s stratagem of enforced psychological submission is compared to the monstrous maiming, even emasculation, of the physical body. Its rules, including unconditional obedience, are ‘deep cut upon the fleshly tablet of every Jesuit’s heart’, resulting in ‘a frame of mind that is dry, chilled and impoverished’.31 Without independence, personal character displays ‘stunted strength’ and ‘sterility’.32 For many Victorian writers steeped in the ideology of individualism, this process of exacting total obedience seems opposed to human nature and, therefore, like torture, when ‘[b]lood oozes from every vein – the sinews crack – the marrow of the bones drops from the fingers’ ends’.33 Even more unhealthy and degrading is the hint of erotic perversion ‘in the diseased prurience’ of Jesuit training with its voyeuristic surveillance and its appeal to the masochistic ‘fascination of submission’.34 These sensational tropes of abuse establish Jesuit authority as an alien concept that infects its adherents, ‘throw[ing] them into a syncope, out of which they should never once awake’.35 Such imagery of the body also constructs Jesuit spirituality as a sham, since it associates the Society with profane desires of the flesh and the world. In Catholic sensationalism, a fascination with physical excess is displaced onto the figure of the Jesuit as a sign of sexual perversity. His decadent interests imply the moral degeneracy of the entire Church of Rome. The wicked Rodin in Eugene Sue’s The Wandering Jew, for example, savours the connections between voluptuous love, horror and death. When he tells the gruesome story of a betrayed mistress who dies unshriven, his eyes ‘sparkle with diabolic fire’ as he describes the lover mourning the corpse: ‘In his delirium, he seized that fair, beloved head, to cover it with kisses. The head parted from the body, and remained in his hands!’ (744). Similar tropes describe Jesuit ambitions for financial and political power. Their mission activities are viewed as ‘essentially worldly and carnal … the wisdom by which they were guided was earthly, sensual, devilish’. 36 Jesuit objectives are unnatural because they disrupt the proper divisions between spiritual and secular authority. Sensationalizing Jesuitism in this fashion establishes two different norms for nineteenth-century readers. By encoding the horrors of Jesuitism as sensual perversity, Protestantism can claim the health of its attitudes to
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 36
15/3/07 17:06:23
sensational invasions
37
body and governance. Jesuit extremism – all pinched asceticism, despotic cruelty and voracious appetite – contrasts unfavourably with Protestant ideals expressed in terms of balance: a restrained acceptance of the body as God’s creation, and a commitment to individual freedom steadied by benign institutional oversight. In imaginative literature particularly, these representations of excess also hint at a darker, sublimated readerly taste and apprehensiveness. Spectacular cruelties certainly enable transgressive desires to be explored and expelled through the annihilation of the Jesuit villain. Indeed, the punishments of these wicked characters may be savoured as hideous extensions of their own vice, an ending more in keeping with an indifferent and ironic Nemesis than with a Christian God of compassion. In Fanny Trollope’s Father Eustace, the Superior General of the Jesuits, who invisibly masterminds the conspiracy against Richard de Morley’s Protestant heirs from afar, is himself secretly poisoned. The greedy and sensuous Sister Agatha, a ‘female Jesuit’ enlisted in the plot, falls ‘a victim to an abundant crop of walnuts, of which she had ever been extravagantly fond’ (III, 326). In Hawkstone: a tale of and for England in 184– (1845) by William Sewell, the subtle and treacherous Jesuit Pearce, who plots against the country by encouraging rebellion among the disaffected, receives an appropriate punishment for his schemes to revive ‘Popery’. The wily priest is inadvertently trapped in a secret passageway beneath the former Catholic Priory and is eaten alive by rats. His demise is graphically imagined in a way that eclipses his cowardice. Instead, the details reveal a fascination with the mutilation of sensitive flesh and with the body’s instinctive struggle to survive: All over the pavement were traces of blood, as if the wretched man had fled from place to place before his ferocious assailants; and there were marks of bloody hands upon the walls, on one place especially, were [sic] the stones were convulsively scrabbled over with gory fingers, and a spring was found … which had closed from the other side, and could not be opened. The extremities were wholly 37 gone. The vitals must have been attacked at last.
Such an anarchic vision of physical excess and disintegration seems out of key with the novel’s more explicit expression of confidence in the individual and the institution. It uncomfortably reminds readers that the unruly and fragile body cannot always be regulated and preserved through effort and will power. The dangerous threat to the nation cannot always be dispelled by the transparent process of law and the principles of justice and fair play. Ridiculing these sensational fantasies of bodily destruction as the vulgar stock-in-trade propaganda of the Jesuits themselves diffuses their most
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 37
15/3/07 17:06:23
38 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature disturbing implications for Victorian readers. Ironically, though Catholic sensationalism has its fair share of the popular, the suggestive and the indecorous, it also identifies taste as an important marker of national and individual normality. The sinister Black Robe easily entraps those unsophisticated minds enthused by mystery, adventure and romantic mayhem. In Sinclair’s Beatrice, Bessie McRonald, with her ‘too poetical and imaginative tendency’, is lured to apostasy and a Catholic convent by exciting stories of martyrdom and sacrifice.38 Masochism for her has its own glamour. She is seduced by the thought of heroic renunciation and comes to express her new Catholic principles in the violent, despotic vocabulary of her Jesuit mentors: ‘all on earth … must be crushed like a worm beneath my feet’ (II, 96). In this overwrought frame of mind, Bessie perversely treasures macabre gifts of dubious provenance: ‘a relic of decayed bone’, ‘an old tooth fit only for a charnel-house, some ancient iron instrument of torture, a lock of odd-looking red hair’ (II, 97). The off-hand tone not only suggests authorial scepticism about the origins of these tatty relics, but contempt for the sensibility that values them. William Thackeray accomplishes a similar deflation, though with less lurid detail, in Henry Esmond (1852), a Bildungsroman set in the reign of Queen Anne. For much of the novel, the eponymous hero is enmeshed in Catholic machinations to return a Jacobite to the throne. Most persuasive of all in winning the impressionable young protagonist’s loyalty to the cause are the sensational stories of swashbuckling adventure recounted by the Jesuit, Father Holt. The priest regularly excites Henry’s imagination with tales of the glories of his order, of its martyrs and heroes, of its brethren converting the heathen by myriads, traversing the desert, facing the stake, ruling the courts and councils or braving the tortures of kings; so that Harry Esmond thought that to belong to the Jesuits was the greatest prize of life and bravest end of ambition 39 – the greatest career here, and in heaven the surest reward …
Henry’s immaturity and insecurity help to justify – and excuse – his ready acceptance of these accounts. But Father Holt’s quiet advice that ‘he did well to meditate on these great things, and not to talk of them except under direction’ (33) subtly suggests to Victorian readers that even Catholics know their sensations cannot long bear the scrutiny of a mature Protestant intellect or the calm, reflective good sense which characterizes British identity. These examples also indicate how, in Victorian Jesuit fiction, sensational rhetoric operates to shape positive notions of nationhood as well as defining the boundaries of cultural difference. While the contrast of sensationalism to the discourses of realism and rationalism dramatizes the distinction between Catholic/foreign excess and Protestant/British moderation,
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 38
15/3/07 17:06:23
sensational invasions
39
humorous deflation encourages the reader to identify strongly with the satirist’s ‘superior’ values. An 1858 piece in Punch, for example, represents the national character as generously broad-minded when it describes Jesuit missionaries in Western Prussia as mad because they ‘rave’ and ‘howl’ against 40 ‘the idea of mutual toleration’. Victorian mockery of Jesuits conveys particular authority on the qualities of restraint and level-headedness, reading them as signs of truth-speaking and independence of mind. In contrast, as a raconteur of the sensational, the Jesuit is represented not only as a fantasist, but also as a liar and hypocrite. Thackeray’s benevolent Father Holt may tell tales of heroic martyrs who suffer stoically for their faith, but he coolly murders a Parliamentary soldier to save his own life. Even more damning is the Jesuit’s ineffectiveness. Thackeray turns Holt’s taste for sensational adventures against him in a way that makes Jesuit political machinations against the Protestant governance simply ridiculous. The priest’s elaborate attempts at espionage yield information that is never quite accurate. His conspiracies come to nothing. His final ignominious reduction snidely deflates the legendary Jesuit genius for disguise and infiltration. When Henry imagines the disgraced and disappointed Jesuit in America, the projection is not that of an adventurous missionary, but of a ludicrous buffoon languishing pointlessly in fancy dress. With ‘the hatchet and moccasins … attired in a blanket and war-paint, skulk[ing] about [as] a missionary amongst the Indians’, Holt is firmly unmasked and discredited as a foreign fake (553). Debunking the myth of Jesuit camouflage through absurdity, Thackeray authenticates a secular version of the British national character that is rational, transparent and matter of fact. Many Jesuit fictions of the period replicate this particular articulation of nationhood. George Stephen’s novel, The Jesuit at Cambridge (1847), for example, hinges on a Jesuit scheme to subvert the institutions that most clearly define British culture by inserting a disguised Catholic into Anglican orders. Written when the wound of Newman’s conversion was still raw, this antiTractarian narrative is informed by an urgent need to make clear boundaries between the Church of England and the Church of Rome. Stephen suggests that the distinction between Protestant and Catholic resides as much in intellectual and imaginative processes and aesthetic taste, as in specific doctrinal beliefs. He makes a contrast between the Protestant preference for ‘plain [and true] meaning’ deduced rationally from Scripture and the Jesuit appeal to religious feeling through some dubious tale of ‘miraculous agency’.41 The differentiation of the foreign Jesuit and the domestic Protestant opposes the ephemera of fancy and excitement to the solidity of material data rationally
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 39
15/3/07 17:06:24
40 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature assessed. While ‘[r]omance, and adventure, may produce an excitement that suspends appetite for awhile’ (II, 212), Stephen suggests that the spirit and affections are more appropriately nourished by reasoned reflection on biblical texts and verifiable documented evidence. Protestant polemicists use similar terms in their denunciation of Jesuit misinformation and fictitious ‘histories’ that delude the credulous. Indeed, the principles and techniques of realism provide the methodology for deconstructing the Society of Jesus. Only analytical investigation and a cool, detached voice can expose Jesuit tales ‘that deliberately countenance recourse to fabrication and forgery’.42 Principles of literary style are translated into features of the national character in the most shocking and melodramatic Jesuit tales of the period. In contrast to the alien ‘Jesuit’ style of lurid sensationalism, the conventions of realist practice are held to be synonymous with English native tradition and culture. The clarity and concrete specificity, respect for logic and plausibility, and the privileging of an innate ‘common sense’ associated with nineteenth-century realist discourse come to signify the best qualities of the English spirit. In Henry Esmond, for example, Thackeray mixes a calm, analytical and authoritative third-person narrative voice with the authenticity of first-person focalization to suggest that personal shrewdness and solid reasoning are the characteristics of Englishness. The feeble schemes of the Jesuits – like so many improbable melodramatic plots – ultimately find no favour with the native citizenry. People and Parliament have no ‘passion for intrigue, that love of secrecy, slander, and lying’ (222). The worst excesses of the Jesuits will inevitably provoke the English people to reassert their own identity as a nation: The moral of the Jesuits’ story I think as wholesome a one as ever was writ: the artfullest, the wisest, the most toilsome and dexterous plot-builders in the world – there always comes a day when the roused public indignation kicks their flimsy evidence down, and sends its cowardly enemies a-flying. (222)
Through cultural inheritance, Thackeray implies, English identity is shaped by principles of freedom, independence and honest-dealing – the very opposite of Catholic deviousness and authoritarian tyranny. The English national character – defined through the discourse of realism – emerges as the best defence against the Jesuit, a foreign interloper defined through sensational writing and sensational practices. Similarly, particular linguistic features of sensationalism enact national identity as well as cultural difference. Rhetorical method and register show that the distinction between the alien Jesuit and the native Englishman is based on contrasting attitudes to power, authority and control. In William
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 40
15/3/07 17:06:24
sensational invasions
41
Sewell’s Hawkstone, for example, the opposing argumentative strategies of the ruthless Jesuit, Pearce, and the noble Protestant hero, Ernest Villiers, inscribe middle-class ideologies of duty and respect as the epitome of English national character at its best. The Jesuit selects working-class co-conspirators who, like him, threaten the stability of the existing political structures. Restless, dissatisfied Chartists and violent outlaws are amenable to Pearce’s control. He builds on their disillusionment and anarchic passions through dissimulation and a cynical understanding of their faults and frustrations. As a result he can manipulate each agent with ease: ‘Having the key to his mind, Pearce knew how to rule it … by alternate confidence and mystery, by maintaining his own superiority, and at the same time flattering his tool with occasional panegyrics, and prospects of advancement to a still higher share in the great work before them …’ (II, 71). The Jesuit’s verbal strategies are appropriate to an underhanded and treacherous authoritarian. His language dissembles and confuses. He creates suspense to tempt his audience and keep it docile. Sudden destabilizing shifts of mood (from ‘confidence’ to ‘mystery’) and ‘prospects’ vaguely promised and endlessly deferred show his contempt for these feeble tools of his own superior will. His hypocrisy and insincerity are apparent in the narrator’s use of words like ‘flattery’ and the overblown ‘panegyrics’. While the worthy Villiers also displays significant rhetorical talents, his methods are described approvingly through the discourse of English middle-class gentility. Villiers’s ‘delicacy of feeling’ and ‘essential good nature’ (II, 81) are opposed to Pearce’s arrogant superiority. In keeping with his desire to improve his estate for the benefit of the people, he does not seek to ‘rule’ a mind or flatter with fake praise. Instead, he tactfully places ‘confidence’ in others and appeals to ‘the name and old associations of a gentleman’ (II, 81). Where Pearce tries to wrong-foot his subordinates by a shifty flux between revelation and secrecy, Villiers maintains a straightforward consistency, implying respect, if not equality, through the ‘openness and manliness of the communication’ (II, 81). A more complex illustration of the connections between narrative mode and national identity can be found in Beatrice. Here, style explicitly takes on the role of a conservative ideological apparatus, theorized by Michel Foucault as ‘“power through transparency” subjection by “illumination’.43 The contrast between sensational and realist idioms in the novel constructs the strangeness of the Gothic register as Jesuitical – unbalanced, idiosyncratic and alien. On the other hand, the novel’s realist elements, which emphasize disclosure, visibility and a shared viewpoint, promote a dutiful
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 41
15/3/07 17:06:24
42 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature citizenry by inscribing moderation and consensus as the healthy expression of native British culture. The bizarre images used to characterize the appearance of the sinister Father Eustace at his most despotic are drawn from the melodramatic register of Gothic excess. He is like ‘a perpendicular corpse … his whole figure crouching with assumed humility’ (II, 229). At other times, he resembles a threatening mesmerist: ‘there was an electric telegraph in his eye, which seemed always understood by his proselytes and obeyed’ (II, 227). Such sinister tropes place the Jesuit outside the boundaries of ‘real’ British life, isolating him as dead man or demonic spiritualist. Alternatively, in Sinclair’s characterization of the noble yeoman farmer Robert Carre, unadorned prose gives an everyday solidity to his uncomplicated independence and self-management – qualities equated with the British character in middle-class liberal ideology of the period.44 Like Villiers in Hawkstone, Carre is associated with the cultivation and shaping of the land for the benefit of the community as a whole. Because of this close connection to the soil, his dutiful temperament and generous commitment to the community at large can be read as typical of the nation’s ‘natural’ character. Carre’s moral attributes, signalled by his appearance, are conveyed through language that is, in effect, down to earth: simple and referential, rooted in the concrete, as unpretentious and open as the man himself. Unlike the pantomime appearance of the Jesuit villain, Carre’s ‘clear eye … open brow … native dignity … frank expression … [and] the free action of his finely-formed limbs’ (II, 229) encode an inherited tradition of honesty, straightforwardness and energetic self-control. By exploiting the discourses of realism, Sinclair can define Carre’s behaviour as an exemplary expression of an authentic national spirit. Moreover, his loyal service to the community implies that personal independence fits unproblematically with the hierarchical structures of deference and responsibility. The emphasis on the farmer’s heroic but unexceptional qualities and his positioning as microcosm of the nation dramatize what Mary Poovey has termed the distinctively Victorian ‘version of liberty – the freedom to be part of a social aggregate’.45 His eventual triumph demonstrates how the native combination of independent-mindedness and dutifulness are proof against the stealthy encroachment of a foreign sensibility like that of the Jesuits. Emphasis on Jesuit foreignness is not the only way in which Catholic sensationalism crystallizes debates about nationhood in the period. Many cultural historians have identified the importance of religious discourse, and most particularly that of Protestantism, to the definition of British character
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 42
15/3/07 17:06:24
sensational invasions
43
and destiny in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Central to this process is the notion of dispelling Catholic incursions onto British soil. For example, in the Glorious Revolution narrative of Catholic defeat and expulsion, Protestant rhetoric and the discourse of ‘civic humanism’ combine to portray British social structure as the sole guarantee of ‘civil and religious liberty, freedom of the press, the diffusion of knowledge and religious toleration’.46 By 1800, denominational allegiance is a well-established component of the modern myth of Britishness, of a ‘sense of [Britons’] place in history and a sense of worth’.47 However, Victorian paranoia about Jesuitism shows how this process of British self-formation took on renewed urgency in the nineteenth century. In the midst of vast social upheaval, a coherent concept of national identity becomes both less certain and more necessary. The sensationalized portrayal of Jesuit invasion provides a central motif through which new anxieties and confidence about the British character could simultaneously be explored and asserted. In Victorian histories, lectures, sermons, religious tracts, proselytizing pamphlets, reviews and novels, the Jesuit plot against the country is characterized as a secular danger as well as a religious menace. Insecurity is evident in generalized assertions about the Jesuits’ irrational but long-standing malevolence to Englishness itself: ‘If they hated England and Queen Elizabeth in the 16th century, they bear no less hate to England and Queen Victoria in the 19th. Let an opportunity present itself, and you shall see them again heading the rebellion, and preaching murder as the most meritorious of all actions.’48 The Victorian preoccupation with Jesuit antipathy to English culture and its political infrastructure shifts attention from religion to state. Conflating denominational and civil allegiance, it implies that even the secular dimensions of nationhood have a God-given legitimacy, and should be embraced with a sacred fervour lest ‘the liberties and freedom of England [be surrendered] to the papal power’.49 Sensationalized versions of Jesuitism in the period sustain this construction of patriotism by associating the Society with social destabilization and revolution. Jesuits are said to seek ‘to disturb the security of property, and to taint the character of the court’.50 They are ‘a corporation dangerous to the State’51 because they rival its control of financial wealth and political organization. Exaggerating Jesuit temporal ambitions in this way embeds Victorian notions of class difference into the construction of subjecthood. The general health of the country, which Jesuits endanger, is synonymous with middleclass social and economic structures. Once global superiority is integral to British middle-class affluence and commercial power, for instance, the Jesuit
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 43
15/3/07 17:06:24
44 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature invasion is redefined as one which attacks British imperial interests: ‘with its secret agencies spread abroad everywhere, with its multitude of unknown and pledged adherents in every class of society, it is a standing danger to the Empire’.52 Similarly, the Jesuit threat to the nation’s ‘political ascendancy and pre-eminence’ obliquely equates the ruling establishment with Britain’s renown throughout the world.53 A British and middle-class inflection is even given to the representation of the Jesuit as an enemy of culture, a view popularized in nineteenth-century French anti-clerical writing. Michelet and Quinet’s well known lecture series, Jesuits and Jesuitism, portrayed the Society of Jesus as an institution opposed to freedom in all its forms and spreading ‘the spirit of death … to politics, literature and art’.54 As the enemy of intellectual liberty, the demonic Jesuit is forced to bear the weight of European anxiety about modern processes of secularization and progress – and their vulnerability. The English variant on this theme shows how bourgeois interests coalesced quite early around scientific knowledge as the basis for worldly advance. The Jesuits invading the British nation stifle innovation and modernity by blocking the expansion of learning. Sensationalized as rigid and superstitious, Jesuits are deemed the natural opponents of any society ‘pushing discovery forward in all directions’.55 This distinctively Victorian conflation of middle-class interests with national identity is dramatized in the more sensational Jesuit novels. Jesuits are routinely involved with working-class and minority unrest that undermines the authority of public institutions and fractures family security. In The Jesuit at Cambridge, for example, ‘Jesuitical intrigue … cajolery, and intimidation, and corruption’ (II, 133) are part of a wider picture of popular ‘agitation’ and political pressure groups. William Sewell’s Hawkstone treats Jesuits, Fenians, Chartists, Socialists, and even Oxford Tractarians as part of the same anti-establishment movement which is fundamentally foreign and sensational in its appeal to ‘something exciting, fervent, enthusiastic, romantic, and picturesque – something unlike the common’ (II, 226). These radical desperadoes oppose the idealized self-image of the nation as peaceful and well regulated. Instead, they cultivate upheaval and disruption stimulated by the class envy and misery of a disaffected underclass. This ‘squalid, vitiated, turbulent population’ (I, 20) is prone to disorder, responding to any one of a number of ‘distracted political parties’ (I, 20) who promise an improvement in their condition and – even better – revenge against the economic tyrants who oppress them. In Sewell’s eyes, these masses are susceptible to Jesuit manipulation because they have lost any sense of collective identity and national pride. They are infected with ‘vice, intemperance,
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 44
15/3/07 17:06:25
sensational invasions
45
and ferocity’ (II, 108) because they are cut off from the guidance and support of legitimate, natural authority. From the beginning of the novel, he makes the point that, in the troubled industrial town of Hawkstone, no ‘man of birth, and property, and sound principles’ is present to keep order and ensure ‘unity of spirit … the bond of peace … righteousness of life’ (I, 20). No longer embedded in an organic community where a hierarchy of responsibilities ensures a cohesive system of respectful deference and benevolent patronage, the working class has been detached from the framework of middle- and upper-class governance that ensures a coherent and well-ordered society: ‘The population was a body without a head, – a mass of fermenting passions, sufferings, high stimulated desires, half-instructed reason, – with no power above them to control, to guide, to be the object of affection, to sympathize with them, or to awe them’ (I, 101). It is for these reasons that Jesuit fictions often market themselves as a public service. Because the Jesuit agent is a figure of difference against which a healthy national identity can be imagined and articulated, the details of his infiltration show the need for assertive measures to preserve cultural integrity and prevent social fragmentation and revolution. A telling comment used to advertise Beatrice, for example, presents the narrative as a rallying call to stamp out a pervasive social abuse: ‘[t]he work will be to Popery … what “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” has been to slavery’.56 Similarly, in the novel itself references to the recent Papal Aggression of 1850 urge collective vigilance to defend secular as well as religious freedoms and preserve the security of the state. ‘[T]he clandestine, the marvellous but imperceptible expansion of the Jesuits … while Protestants sleep on in a vague ignominious dream of safety’ (II, 39) is shown to undermine family life and parental authority. This domestic invasion is echoed at the level of the state in the restoration of the Catholic Hierarchy: ‘An Italian flag has been unfurled within the heart of our great metropolis, and bold defiance bid to our laws and religion; therefore all must now be actively true to the flag of old England’ (II, 37–38). The Jesuit plot to implant a foreign culture demands constant nourishment of patriotic fervour and confidence in the superiority of the British character. However, read through the encodings of sensationalism, representations of the Jesuit also show how Victorian culture nervously imagines a shadowy underside to its own national image of public order and private respectability. Jenny Bourne Taylor has noted that sensationalism creates a distinctive ‘strangeness within familiarity’, a disconcerting ‘sense of a weird and different world within the ordinary, everyday one’.57 The lurid portrayals of the Jesuit ‘anti-world’ within Britain evidence the same pattern. As well as
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 45
15/3/07 17:06:25
46 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature being an invader from without, the Jesuit is also the moral poison that can infect a culture from within. His presence discloses the flaws and tensions inherent in Victorian idealizations of the nation. As an instance of surreptitious wickedness, the Jesuit – everywhere suspected and nowhere certain – tropes the darker dimensions of a progressive and prosperous society where individuals and social groups are assumed to have stable, familiar and complementary identities and roles. In a variant on the earlier ‘Burkean Gothic’ with its ‘dissolution of boundaries that delimit the proper places of various stations of society’,58 Jesuit villains populate a world that is recognizably British, but seems beyond understanding and control in both public and private spheres. These Catholic agents exploit an anarchic environment where political and social structures can be overturned, where disguised and anonymous groups can audaciously gain control, and where the unwitting individual is repeatedly subject to confusion and exploitation. In his criminal activities particularly, the Jesuit challenges the version of national identity central to liberal middle-class thought: a community committed to principles of equality, freedom, humaneness and justice. The violent illegal undercurrent associated with the sensationalized narrative of Jesuit incursions is not, admittedly, entirely new, but represents a modernized perspective on the Society in nineteenth-century British culture. Seventeenth-century propaganda characterized Jesuits as sociopaths or amoral murderers, bent on destroying the religious establishment that safeguards the spiritual well being of the people. They send forth certain very audacious murderers who by poison may kill the principal doctors and teachers of the Evangelical and Calvinian Churches … infect[ing] dishes, salt cellars, basins, cauldrons and other vessels whatsoever appointed to daily use, that though they be twenty times wiped over and made clean, yet they 59 shall retain the force of most deadly and present poison.
Although the writer of this tract invests the Jesuit with a pseudo-magical power in his strange potions, the passage goes on to hint at more mundane reasons for his success as a criminal type. He dangerously unites knowledge, networks and disguise to escape detection and penetrate every level of society in every land. The nineteenth-century transformation of this myth refocuses on the secular encroachments of Jesuit villains. Their organisation is imagined as an intricate web that penetrates all social domains: they can be found ‘creeping and crawling about your hearth’60 and simultaneously drawing together rebellious political factions in the public arena. For Isaac Taylor, the Society of Jesus cleverly exploits social weaknesses to insinuate its criminal presence. Capitalizing on public uncertainty in a world where
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 46
15/3/07 17:06:25
sensational invasions
47
moral, material, ‘commercial, and fiscal’ spheres are arbitrarily subject to ‘abstruse and uncontrollable influences’, Jesuits deceitfully promise mystical solutions at the same time as imposing ‘an absolute despotism’.61 They contribute to cultural degeneration with their equivocation and hypocrisy, with their encouragement of sedition and class divisions, and with their fraudulent practices. For a polemicist like Taylor, their pollution of British culture can only be expressed in the outrageous language of sensational excess, the Victorian equivalent of the demonic discourse of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century denunciations of the Society. The Jesuits are like the flood of some ‘putrescent stream’, a ‘Ganges of pestilential filth … from the nether world’ (332).62 In sensational discourse, the Victorian panic about Jesuit invasion centres especially on criminal designs on private property. Jesuits’ ‘mental reservations’ and casuistry enable them to rationalize theft. Pilfering by servants is legitimized in Jesuit teaching as ‘clandestine compensation’, according to W. C. Cartwright.63 Such destruction of trust between employer and employee is paralleled by their meddling with basic property rights of the family. In many fictions, such as Beatrice and Father Eustace, Jesuits scheme to ensure personal estates and wealth come within control of the Society. In the political arena, they threaten the security of property by undercutting the laws and systems that protect it. Because they destabilize traditional bonds and social structures, their countercultural schemes also disrupt social harmony between classes. Jesuits are associated with levelling tendencies and with the hypocritical support of the downtrodden against the status quo. At the same time, they impose their own leadership in a grotesque parody of civic authority and obedience in a democratic system. They use ‘the rights and the privileges of freedom for the purpose of undermining political liberty, and of subverting the very foundations of civil government, and our Protestant constitution’.64 As an archetype of consummate trickery, the Jesuit operating within domestic culture most worryingly reveals the vulnerability of social institutions to fraud and deception. In the Victorian literary imagination, the lucrative criminality of the Jesuit routinely depends on his inconspicuous integration into everyday life. Newman mocks this fear as an ignorant Protestant caricature: ‘Nay, it is awful; they disguise themselves in a thousand shapes, as men of fashion, farmers, soldiers, labourers, butchers, and peddlers; they prowl about with handsome stocks, and stylish waistcoats, and gold chains about their persons, or in fustian jackets, as the case may be …’65 Even the anti-Catholic Punch turns its sarcasm, on occasion, against this fixation with finding secret Jesuits
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 47
15/3/07 17:06:25
48 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 66
in every nook and cranny. Nonetheless, there is a widespread belief that Jesuits had assimilated imperceptibly into the fabric of British social life.67 Most sensational Jesuit fictions sustain this suspicion of Jesuit false-seeming in which the disguised priest-on-the-run of Elizabethan propaganda has become an invisible malefactor defrauding the unsuspecting. Jesuit duplicity succeeds – or nearly so – because of gaps and erosions in social boundaries that the discourse of cohesive nationality normally works to play down. For example, the typical Jesuit villain has all the plausibility and good bearing of a middle-class English gentleman: ‘handsome, polite, courteous, pleasing in his manners’.68 Like the new white-collar criminals who exploit ‘urban chaos’ in Victorian popular fictions and journalism,69 Jesuit characters sidestep the accepted systems of classification that Victorians apply to place each other and to maintain a feeling of control over the social environment and social relations. In fact, the ubiquity and invisibility of Jesuit deceivers show how permeable these boundaries of categorization actually are. From the genteel to the barely respectable professions – no strata of society is imagined to be without its Jesuit spies and tools: ‘physicians, lawyers, fencing masters, hotelkeepers … servants, and policemen’.70 Particular anxiety is generated by the Jesuit infiltration of the working classes, who are assumed to be easily corruptible and unhelpfully entangled in middleclass life through trade and service industries. That a vast secret network of Jesuit sympathizers, including covert women devotees or Jesuitesses, could seem remotely probable to nineteenth-century polemicists, novelists and readers is an instructive sign of the times. Not only does it suggest a feeling that contemporary living requires continuous wariness and suspicion in the face of unspecified dangers, but it also expresses a collective disquiet with the alienating structures of a complex, modern industrial society. The undiscovered Jesuit, scheming discreetly, challenges confidence in a collective national purpose. Instead, his presence uncomfortably suggests the social fractures of modernity. He can work surreptitiously because Britons are now bound in a range of impersonal and unequal economic connections, motivated by worldly ambitions and greed, nurturing resentment rather than the spirit of duty and co-operation. Ultimately, sensational narratives of Jesuit invasion show that these villains take advantage of rather than initiate a perilous national condition. Three important features of Jesuit characterization ironically suggest why this is possible (and, perhaps, explain in part why the Jesuit exercises such persistent fascination for Victorians). In the first place, the Jesuit’s activities within the state and family are disconcertingly similar to the cultural
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 48
15/3/07 17:06:25
sensational invasions
49
practices of the world he would destroy. Even stripped of his disguise, he reveals qualities routinely promoted in Victorian secular ideologies as the sign of individual worth and respectability. Duty and deference, for example, are in practice duplicated in the Jesuit submission to authority. In one tract, the Jesuit ‘abdication of will and judgment’ to the Superior is a matter for censure, while ‘the cardinal virtue of obedience’ is simultaneously extolled as an essential adjunct to the (Protestant) ‘enthusiasm for liberty and … spontaneous virtue’.71 The dangerous constitution and regulations of the Jesuit Order are often ascribed to the single-minded, obsessive temperament of its Spanish founder, Ignatius Loyola. Yet the ‘independence and self-government’, ‘energetic temper’, and ‘power and unity of purpose’ that underpin his fiercely controlling personality72 are the very qualities deemed essential to the entrepreneurial energies of the British character. Although the Jesuit reliance on religious authority rather than personal judgement is rejected as tyrannical, Protestantism is portrayed as a desirable imposition which guarantees the temporal and spiritual well-being of the nation. ‘England herself, free, enlightened, religious England’ is civilized by the Protestant adherence to ‘the light of the Bible’.73 Such statements once again show the way religious difference operates in social formation. But these unresolved contradictions also suggest difficulties in the Victorian management of competing social ideals. Jesuit excess points up how awkwardly a commitment to individualism fits with the necessity of dutiful compliance within bounded social structures. Secondly, sensational narratives of Jesuit criminal scheming, like Beatrice and Hawkstone, give specificity to widespread Victorian fears of cultural degeneration brought about by the nation’s own moral failings and misdirections. In Beatrice, Jesuit cunning is effective because class divisions and antipathies have crystallized into a divided community with individuals jostling for status and control. Sinclair’s remedy is an idealized familial model of British society. Civil liberty and ‘our happy homes’ are coterminous with ‘the existence of British institutions, of moral worth, of natural conscience, of human virtue and human feelings’ (III, 290). Benevolent responsibility for those below and a humble deference to those above are invoked as the bland solution to an acid depiction of social fragmentation. The charitable and humane (Protestant) Lady Edith Tremorne gladly embraces the duties of her superior station. She selflessly cares for the villagers of Clanmarina, bringing physical succour and Bible instruction to the ‘honest-faced, openhearted peasantry’ (I, 143). This pattern of relations between rich and poor, well born and lower class, is entangled with notions of inherited Britishness
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 49
15/3/07 17:06:26
50 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature and coded as duty and sympathy. Once again, though, the ideal of national unity revealed in the downward gaze of the narrator rests on structures that echo the Jesuit system of control and submission. Lady Edith’s view of the family as a community in miniature, for example, is based on a paternalistic understanding of social relations. Parents must be ‘as monarchs, governing their children and servants with affection and authority’ (III, 157). The Catholic menace in Beatrice can only be vanquished if community leaders assume this ‘parental’ role of moral discipline, taking responsibility for the direction of the benighted lower classes. Sinclair’s solution to cultural instability ultimately advocates the very class stratifications the Jesuits presume to exploit. William Sewell’s analysis of Jesuit incursions in Hawkstone implicitly interrogates another potential weak point in the Victorian conceptualization of the national character: the investment in personal enterprise, self-help and advancement. Sewell indicated that he had intended the novel to show ‘something of the working of Jesuitism’; but he also saw the Jesuit dimension as sensational ornament – ‘excitement’ and ‘spice’ – for more earnest reflection on ‘some of the evils connected with our present manufacturing and political system’.74 The schemes of Jesuits and ruffians nearly succeed in the novel because the collective duties and responsibilities of good citizenship have been forgotten. Avarice and ambition gradually destroy harmony and social progress in the town. As a result, the language of freedom and personal independence so frequently used to characterize national identity and criticize popery’s plots is subordinated by the novelist. Too much talk of tolerance and liberalism encourages greed and restlessness. Rampant selfseeking undermines the peaceful order that should distinguish the British nation from its Catholic Continental Other. To resolve the conflict between the Victorian ideologies of liberal individualism and social duty, Sewell, like Sinclair, takes refuge in the discourse of authority and obedience normally associated with the despised Jesuit tradition. For Sewell, the established church and state shape and define national character. He demonstrates throughout the novel that the subordination of individual will to the designs of these powerful institutions is essential for society’s unity, as well as for spiritual and material progress. Leadership and submission to it are represented as obligations essential to cultural equilibrium. Just as the Church ‘demands not support, but obedience … recognising and submitting to its authority’, so the duty of a citizen is ‘not to cavil at or criticise the laws, but to acknowledge the authority of his lawful sovereign’ (II, 253, 376). Like Sinclair, Sewell enforces his link between authority,
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 50
15/3/07 17:06:26
sensational invasions
51
obedience and the formation of a mature identity for the nation by emphasizing the parallels between the state and the family. As Miriam Burstein has suggested, Protestantism frequently presents itself ‘as a family religion’ with ‘paternal authority … as a type of God’s authority itself ’.75 Hawkstone explicitly draws on this concept to create an image of national harmony that is at one and the same time both providentially ordered and reassuringly familiar. The relation between subject and sovereign is described, for example, in the terms of reciprocal responsibility and affection which bind child and father. The rhetoric of domestic affection also inculcates social discipline and compliance. A mature identity and stout conscience is best formed when children ‘respect’ their elders, are ‘grateful’ to them, ‘and do everything we bid them, for our sake’ (II, 30); such terminology also defines the behaviour of a patriotic subject in the public sphere. Control and regulation at national level are benignly naturalized by reference to the authority and obedience sustaining the home. However, the Jesuit intrusion into this family plot exposes the potential frailty of the well-ordered English nation. High standards of duty and obedience can be easily compromised in the interests of self-assertion and independence. Villiers’s haughty neglect of his cruel and fretful father in his dying months results in the forfeiture of his inheritance to scheming Jesuits. The subsequent loss of his own son, again as a result of Jesuit intrigue, seems to him ‘the punishment of Heaven to be sealed upon his own disobedience to his parent’ (II, 338). This failure to submit to authority in the name of independence becomes both a symptom of modern British selfishness and a means by which un-English Jesuitical forces can disrupt the stability of a family and the community which depends upon it. Disguise is the third feature of the sensationalized portrayal of the Jesuit that articulates doubts about the security of national identity. The idealized structure of authority and obedience promoted as the solution to British social decline depends on the legitimacy of claims to govern or to be part of that community which renders loyalty and service. Because the Jesuit shows how readily evil intentions can be masked by an assumed modesty and pleasant exterior, his portrayal highlights a major cultural dilemma: the extent to which any individual has the right to the character he or she professes. Adept at masquerade, the Jesuit reveals identity as performance, rather than essence. Although he replicates the behaviour of polite society, he clearly does not share British cultural purpose and national heritage. Instead, his hidden machinations problematize middle-class social mobility and material prosperity, illustrating how trust can be abused in an
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 51
15/3/07 17:06:26
52 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature increasingly fluid, anonymous and impersonal society. Many Jesuit intrigues demonstrate the impossibility of estimating an individual’s moral status and sincerity by relying on respectable appearances and the trappings of wealth. Fanny Trollope’s Father Eustace, for instance, uses Jesuit disguise to satirize the outward pretence that has supplanted more weighty signifiers of Englishness. Her conniving Jesuit and Jesuitess attend Church of England services and use middle-class dress and manners to cozen most of their acquaintances. Sister Agatha, arrayed as the elegant Mrs Vavasor, is immediately accepted by the gentry as one of their own because she ‘spoke with taste and feeling on the subject of horse-flesh’ (III, 34). Since she has the ‘decided appearance of fashion’, the wicked impersonator is naively respected as ‘a woman of discriminating taste and unerring judgement’ (III, 35). In a more serious vein, the distinction between false and true friends is central to George Stephen’s The Jesuit at Cambridge. The novel’s Jesuit plot hinges on multiple deceptions about identity. The sheltered, innocent Henry is slow to work out the Catholic roots of his best friend, Cyril Harrison. The alert reader steeped in anti-Jesuit discourse of the period would have little difficulty in decoding the many hints: the insinuating and deferential manner of Cyril’s father; the Mediterranean complexion and reserved manner of his wife; the family’s fervent attachment to pre-Reformation monastic institutions. Although these external signs might suggest to the suspicious that Mr Harrison is a Crypto-Jesuit, they do not disclose the nature of his audacious deception: that a Harrison son should be raised as a Catholic but, disguising this fact, be ordained and preach as a Protestant minister to undermine the established Church. In Catholic sensationalism, Jesuit disguise counterpoints Victorian narratives of self-formation, prompting questions about the meaning of ‘identity’ and the difficulty of distinguishing false English man or woman from true. As such, the motif provides an alternative perspective on the workings of middle-class theories of individualism with their high valuation of selffashioning and promise of social advancement. In narratives such as Jemima Luke’s The Female Jesuit (1851) and A Sequel to the Female Jesuit (1852), contemporary bourgeois life is portrayed explicitly as a place of danger as well as opportunity. Disguised as the autobiographical record of a traduced British family, these popular tales suggest that neither religious faith nor humane sympathy can preserve respectable households from the motiveless frauds of Marie L— G—. The impostor plays on the Jesuit fears of Mr L— and his family. She secures their friendship, shelter and financial support by presenting herself as a persecuted victim of the Society. On the basis of
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 52
15/3/07 17:06:26
sensational invasions
53
her intricately detailed tale of incarceration in a Jesuit-controlled convent and the (forged) correspondence from her Jesuit uncle, they treat her with affection and dutifully continue to harbour her, despite their gradual suspicion. Ironically, their native Protestant faith compounds the damage of their naivety, for ‘[t]hey regarded her as a child specially committed to their care by Providence, and not to be lightly cast off or too severely treated’.76 The Female Jesuit concludes with speculation about the origin of Marie’s schemes. They are tricky enough to be Jesuitical, and one theory put forward is that she is indeed an agent employed by the Society for reasons of its own. Her lying and facility with disguise, ‘the assumption of a character altogether the reverse of her own’ (431), and her indifference at having to escape to a foreign country seem proof enough. However, in A Sequel to The Female Jesuit, Jemima Luke traces the further deception, downfall and imprisonment of Marie, identifying a recurrent pattern of social fraud too intricate for even the devilishly efficient Jesuits to perpetrate. In fact, Marie directs her deceptions at Catholics and Protestants indiscriminately. Overall, the narrative, with its detailed analysis of the ways in which false identity can be maintained, highlights the corrosion of public and private life by deceit and hypocrisy. Since Marie’s dissimulation is ultimately without religious or political motivation, Luke falls back on morbid psychology to account for the young woman’s addiction to a kind of nineteenth-century identity-theft, ‘not only unchecked, but exulted and rioted in’.77 Indeed, Luke’s outline of pathological explanations, like ‘Simulative Hysteria’, suggests a world in which misrepresentation is sufficiently common to warrant scientific and medical study and categorization. Marie’s story may ‘act as a beacon-light to warn alike the trifler and the hypocrite’ (206); but in seeking ‘to put the public on its guard’ (2), Luke’s Jesuit paranoia reveals a nation suspiciously turning in on itself, convinced of the need for constant surveillance and control to police its own self-definition. Legitimate succession and inheritance – those principles essential for confirming identity of individual and state – are also shown to be vulnerable to perversion through the sensationalized representation of the Jesuit Other. In Father Eustace, for example, the ruthless Father Ambrose uses emotional blackmail and special drugs to force a dying man to change his will. He has no hesitation about plotting secretly to take ‘possession of what the laws of the land might oppose his taking openly’ (I, 24). In the discourse of Catholic sensationalism, the concept of the natural birthright serves also as an apt metaphor for those narratives of origin that define a nation and its culture. By exploiting typical sensation themes like misunderstandings and
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 53
15/3/07 17:06:26
54 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature mysteries about legitimate heirs, many Jesuit fictions show how the disruption of the process of inheritance endangers authentic national self-definition. In Beatrice, Henry Esmond and Hawkstone, for example, Jesuit threats to a specific legacy trope the difficulty of maintaining continuity in the transmission of the ‘wealth’ of cultural values. The appropriation of inheritance parallels the less tangible hijacking of traditional standards at the level of the home and the level of the state. The preface to Beatrice, for example, warns that Jesuit interventions erode family solidarity and the cultural cohesiveness based on it. To reinforce her point, Sinclair imagines a melodramatic scenario in which a Catholic convert would destroy his home and his life by ‘relinquishing his whole inheritance’ and forcing his mother and sisters to a convent in order to enter the priesthood (xiii). In the same novel, loyalty to inheritance means loyalty also to traditional values and responsibilities within the larger community. Sir Evan McAlpine treats his leadership of the clan as a role to be performed in ‘a spirit of generous self-sacrifi ce for the common good’ (I, 67). His commitment to the villagers increases their own self-esteem such that they, too, inherit and transmit the national spirit. They learn how to seize and make use of their native strength of character and selfsufficiency, for Sir Evan has a ‘humanizing influence on the most abject or uncultivated, in raising them to energetic efforts for themselves’ (I, 151). At one level, the relationship of heredity to personal and public benefit in these narratives of Jesuit trickery constructs a distinctive image of the resilient Victorian nation, uniting family and state within a network of cultural values passed from generation to generation. The individual’s right to freedom of conscience and plain truth-speaking consistent with Protestant principles, the family’s right to the unimpeded continuity of the estate, and the state’s right to flourish in concert with an independent, peaceful and dutiful citizenry are reinforced collectively as the British inheritance which Jesuits endanger. With their greedy materialism, dishonesty, tyranny and subservience, the Jesuits represent an exaggerated version of all that degrades contemporary culture. Foreign to the authentic British character, these modern tendencies should be expelled – like the Jesuits who symbolize them. However, not even idealized versions of the public and private national spirit can emerge intact after Jesuit ‘invasion’ into the narrative scene. It is largely through the handling of the sensationalized Jesuit Other, for example, that the Victorian myths of the state and of the family are deconstructed in Charles Kingsley’s Westward Ho! (1855) and Wilkie Collins’s The Black Robe (1880–81). On the face of it, Westward Ho! projects a romanticized version of Elizabethan imperialism as a way of reclaiming and reasserting a distinctive
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 54
15/3/07 17:06:27
sensational invasions
55
national character. Kingsley uses a range of narrative strategies to reassure his readers that the novel’s construction of British (in effect, English) identity is consistent and continuous with Victorian perspectives. Documents, correspondence, the representation of factual events like the Armada, and the interpolation of historical personages alongside fictional characters give an illusion of a ‘real’ past with which Kingsley’s readers could connect. Allusions to contemporary events – such as the Crimean War, or Papal Aggression, or even a troublesome Ireland – suggest that similar problems of loyalty, sound leadership and foreign powers challenge Elizabethan and Victorian Britons. Kingsley capitalizes on such historicism to make a number of different claims about Victorian society. On the one hand, he constructs a lost world of gallantry and economic and political success to point up the decline apparent in nineteenth-century culture. Traditions have been lost and inheritance neglected. The stately homes which once dominated the landscape of Devon have ‘long since passed into other hands, and fallen to decay’.78 On the other hand, Kingsley suggests that a moral inheritance has also been squandered. Despite the fondness of Elizabethan seafaring adventurers for ‘romance and superstition’, their innocence and heroism are preferable to the agnostic scepticism which informs the ‘hysterical’ Victorian infatuation with science, wealth and its own ‘refined and cultivated mind’ (404). Elizabethans are ‘noble’, and Victorians ‘prurient’ and dissolute by comparison. Kingsley’s explicit objective is to enable readers to recover that distinctive national character which in the past repelled foreign invaders and rivals, signified by the Hispaniolated Jesuit among others. It is not surprising that the novel was taken up as a patriotic propaganda text and distributed to troops in the Crimean War.79 Trading on the Armada as a central foundation myth of English nationhood, the confident authorial persona makes the case for what Raphael Samuel has termed ‘a national self-consciousness’.80 The same heroic concern for national glory and for the survival and dissemination of English culture which inspired the Elizabethan effort against Spain must be revived for the security and moral health of Victorian society in the 1850s: ‘[l]let us rather open our eyes, and see in these old English gallants our own ancestors, showing forth with the luxuriant wildness of youth all the virtues which still go to the making of a true Englishman’ (159). Kingsley goes on to highlight some of those traits which form ‘our own distinctive national character’ (160). In these remonstrations with the reader, his vocabulary reveals the extent to which, for Victorians, the concept of an inherited national identity is secular and expansionist. He focuses attention on those professions and institutions which ensure the prosperity and good order of
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 55
15/3/07 17:06:27
56 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature the state at home and in its dominions: ‘commercial and military daring’, ‘political astuteness’, ‘deep reverence for law’, and a ‘solemn sense of the great calling of the English nation’ (159-60). The religious inflection of this diction – with words like ‘reverence’, ‘solemn’, and ‘great calling’ – implies a divine hand in the formation of this national character. Moreover, the affective and intellectual characteristics which Kingsley appends to his list, like ‘tenderness and mercy’ and ‘teachableness and wide-heartedness’ (160), humanize and personalize this summation. Through his historical account of the origin of national qualities, Kingsley is able to gloss British imperialism as a largely beneficial cultural exchange whereby tolerant and open-minded Englishmen ‘profit by the wisdom and civilisation of all ages and of all lands, without prejudice to our own distinctive national character’ (160). In Westward Ho! the Jesuit menace is a spur to the formation of the strong English state and the modern post-Reformation English character. Jesuits are associated with Queen Elizabeth’s political enemies, such as Spain, who threaten English economic interests at home and in the New World as well as endangering the security of individuals. The alliance of alien religious and civil authorities to secure invasion, so important a feature of Victorian anti-Jesuit rhetoric, is vividly underlined by Kingsley’s homely picture of the Devon villagers celebrating the execution of Mary Queen of Scots. Described entirely in the present tense, the scene is given a contemporary immediacy. More importantly, it emphasizes the folly of separating denominational allegiance from political authority. The ‘hideous nightmare’ of a civil war, threatened by Mary’s Catholic supporters, dissolves in the fêtelike atmosphere of bells, bonfires and burning effigies of the pope, while the crowd drinks to the Protestant Queen. When Kingsley concludes, ‘[s]o perish all her enemies!’ (501), he reminds readers that Britishness entails a particular political and religious commitment. The Society of Jesus is also associated with ungodly persecution and enslavement of the innocent and defenceless. In the new colonies, Jesuits spread everywhere and impose a brutal regime on the Indian tribes: ‘military tyranny was superadded to monastic, and the Gospel preached with fire and sword, almost as shamelessly as by the first Conquistadores’ (435). In Ireland, they attack legitimate authority by fostering rebellion and disloyalty. Nor is the domain of family relationships and individual affections secure from their invasion. The ‘huge spider’s web of Jesuit intrigue’ (485) entangles the hero’s brother, Frank, and his beloved Rose in the Inquisition and death at the stake. Cannon Schmitt has associated the archetype of victimized womanhood with the construction of Englishness as a culture both threatened and
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 56
15/3/07 17:06:27
sensational invasions
57
81
avenging. In provoking manly Englishmen to attempt her rescue from the Spanish Don Guzman, Rose contributes to the reinvention of an English sensibility that favours the aggression and exclusivity, even xenophobia, appropriate to imperialism. But Kingsley’s narrative uses religious opposition to suggest that broad-mindedness also forms an essential part of English identity. It is the Catholic Other that oppresses all difference – denominational, national, cultural and racial. Though Christian, Frank and Rose are condemned by the Inquisitors, indistinguishable from the Jew and pagan black who die with them. The novel’s representation of Jesuits is one of the main structural mechanisms through which an idealized and timeless English character is fashioned. Kingsley displaces racial difference onto religious difference while maintaining the manichean economy central to imperialist discourse.82 He dramatizes all the usual accusations made against the Society of Jesus in Victorian sensationalism through a series of blatant binary oppositions. For each wicked Jesuit characteristic or practice, there is an equal and opposite quality or manner of conduct proposed as attractive, effective and naturally English. For example, cowardly Jesuit agent and novice, Eustace Leigh, spies and engages in petty cruelties, prurient voyeurism and spiteful treachery with horrific results for Frank and Rose. His cousin, the protagonist Amyas Leigh, is everything that Eustace is not: brave, open and forthright, courteous, tolerant, manly and heterosexual in his passions. Because the two young men are cousins, they are drawn to make their own enlightening assessments of each other, person-to-person and culture-to-culture. Eustace responds to Amyas with fear and envy. Amyas brushes Eustace aside with a confident straightforwardness. For him, Eustace, with his foolish schemes and fanatical supernaturalism, is ‘beneath argument’ and ‘a sort of harmless lunatic’ (53). As with other Jesuit narratives of the period, mocking ridicule is used in the assessment of Jesuit traits. As a kind of ‘aesthetic otherness’, derision is an effective strategy of marginalization. It deflates the status of an alien opponent, while it elevates the mocker to a position of superior disdain. Kingsley’s novel highlights the outrageous violence through which the Society of Jesus seeks to establish its power; but he also shows the institution is laughably inept and deluded. Because of his overly complicated intrigues and secrecy, the Jesuit consistently, ‘as is the wont of crooked spirits … only outwitted himself ’ (56). Kingsley uses farce to illustrate how Jesuit principles of authority and obedience are useless when translated into secular practice, especially when compared to English pragmatism and independence. For instance, the Society’s bureaucratic, hierarchical system of governance is
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 57
15/3/07 17:06:27
58 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature given a secular parallel in the command structure of the Spanish military. The Spanish troops are incapable of thinking for themselves. Like automatons – or clowns – they obey instructions blindly and to the letter with humiliating results: The company who were to turn the left flank walked manfully down into the sea, and never found out where they were going till they were knee-deep in water. The company who were to turn the right flank, bewildered by the utter darkness, turned their own flank so often, that tired of falling into rabbit-burrows and filling their mouths with sand, they halted and prayed to all the saints for a compass and lantern. (186)
On the other hand, the English fighting men demonstrate a workmanlike and intelligent response to each battle, even when outnumbered and their fighting ships outclassed. Daring, imagination and self-help characterize their battle style, reflecting the commitment to independent thought and industrious action which Kingsley associates with the emerging English state. In the novel ‘nation’ and ‘liberty’ become virtually interchangeable abstractions; both are given material presence by the effective repulsion of foreign invaders. The English ‘wield the swords of freemen in defence of a free land’ (534); and the narrator is quick to gloss such military skill with spiritual legitimation. Kingsley suggests that English initiative is spurred on by the need to protect ‘English soil’ from the contamination of Catholic persecution, keeping it ‘safe from rack and fagot’ (534). Yet these opportunistic and enterprising fighting methods are related as much to the burgeoning commercial spirit of Elizabethan England as to spiritual faith. Much like the English sailors’ defeat of the Armada, the Queen battles through to economic prosperity by a reliance on individual innovation rather than structured economic management. While not explicitly condoning piratical behaviour, she favours ‘the leaving as much as possible to private enterprise’ (525). By such descriptions, Kingsley implies the continuity of the national temperament and identity; Elizabethan economic principles are like an embryonic version of Victorian political economy with its commitment to a laissez-faire marketplace. Lest the narrative suggest that the English spirit is selfish and anarchic, constraints on freedom are identified throughout, primarily through reference to popular Victorian images of masculine collaboration and bonding. Kingsley links English camaraderie and chivalric self-sacrifice in battle to principles of compliance expressed as fraternal co-operation. Legitimate leaders are obeyed in a compact of mutual support. This requires stout
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 58
15/3/07 17:06:27
sensational invasions
59
discipline for both those who govern and those who submit to them. Those in authority guide; those who are led express respect and affection for their superiors. Drake trains Amyas in the ways of ‘a brave and virtuous captain’ (372) by insisting on the primacy of a homosocial community of feeling. The ideal military hero is not just physically adept and strategically talented. He must have an abundance of emotional sympathy that generates understanding and, where appropriate, forgiveness of his followers. Amyas is taught to ‘feel with and for his men, to make allowances for them’ (372). In return, the men who follow him express gratitude for his ‘works and ways, which [were] always those of a gentleman’ (388). In practice, of course, it implies a calculating approach to group dynamics that knows when to turn a blind eye; his men appreciate the fact that Amyas is no jealous prosecutor of the letter of the law, looking fanatically for every blemish. As fictional hero, he acts ever from the best motivation and imagines that others are equally pure-hearted: ‘[he] saw all you ought to see, and nought that you ought not’ (388). In Kingsley’s modelling of the national spirit, temporal and religious values are conflated. Secular rank implies decency of conduct which in turn designates spiritual standing. Englishmen, he asserts, are synonymous with ‘good men, good gentlemen’ and, as such, are also the epitome of ‘good Christians’. The rhetorical blend of religion and civic pride turns faith and patriotism to the service of the imperialist state, negating class divisions and enforcing obedience as the noble response to authority. Nonetheless, several characters in the novel also display traits which hint uneasily at a darker side to this paradigm of a valorous state. The text explicitly defines Englishness in opposition to many of the countercultural and anti-social qualities familiar from sensationalized anti-Jesuit discourse. Yet these antipathetic attitudes and practices are also woven into the characters and desires of the staunch English adventurers. As the Jesuits and Spanish brutally subdue the American natives in the name of good order, wealth and Catholicism, so the English fiercely and contemptuously suppress the Irish to preserve stable governance, property and Protestantism. Both English and Spanish justify their wars as crusades directed by God’s will, entwining political interests and denominational loyalties. In the New World, little distinguishes the Jesuit-Spanish and the English in their desire for gold, their rebellious adventurous spirit, and their appetite for global expansion and power. All vie for the same spoils and economic pre-eminence. While Spain intends to be ‘the mistress of the world’, England tries to ensure that ‘English commerce, under the genial sunshine of Elizabeth’s wise rule, was spreading and taking root’ (210). English ambitions are gracefully natural-
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 59
15/3/07 17:06:28
60 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature ized by Kingsley’s tropes, but, in the end, the objectives of conquest are the same. The most notable similarity between the Jesuit-Spanish and the English is in their shared attitudes to those who are excluded from power. By drawing attention to the oppressiveness and horror of any invasion of an-Other space and culture, the narrative contradicts the benign interpretations of English colonization expressed by the authorial persona. For example, the cruel and treacherous seduction of Rose by Don Guzman is initially represented as typical of the rampant immorality and acquisitiveness of the MediterraneanCatholic nature. Misled and traduced, Rose is humiliated in a way which suggests a foreign disrespect for the defenceless and innocent. Just as the Jesuit gulls the naive convert through sensational tales of martyrdom and hypocritical sympathy, so the Spaniard makes the English woman his trophy through the false enchantment of romantic adventure stories and insincere flattery. The perverse sadomasochism of the Jesuit also has its secular equivalent in Don Guzman’s lustful aggression. In direct contrast is the chaste, restrained passion of English gentlemen, like Frank and Amyas, who attempt to rescue Rose in an act of chivalric self-sacrifice. However, there are troubling assumptions underpinning even their conduct, which at first seems so noble an image of national identity. Rose’s hold on the sympathy of Amyas, Frank and the reader depends on the fact she marries Don Guzman and has not, therefore, offended against the middle-class conventions governing female sexuality and chastity. Whatever her innocence in the affair with the Spaniard, her continued ‘value’ as a heroine depends on strict conformity to a Victorian orthodoxy that endorses the legalized transfer of ownership of a woman from one man to another. The chivalric attitudes of Frank and Amyas, possible only because Rose is not a ‘ruined’ and fallen woman, reinforce a system in which female desires are silenced and sacrificed to fit economic structures and social propriety. Indeed, for the narrator and the characters, the finest confirmation of Rose’s status as an exemplary English woman is her brave and soundless performance during her persecution to the death by the Inquisition. The same pattern of disdain for difference can be seen in the treatment of the Central American natives. Amyas and his men are capable of contempt that echoes the attitudes of the high-handed Spanish and fanatical Jesuits and calls into question the association of English identity with tolerance, generosity and egalitarianism. The Spaniards enslave the Indians, Negroes and Zambos they defeat. Kingsley focuses graphically on their treatment of the defenceless, especially women, whose sanctified place in the English
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 60
15/3/07 17:06:28
sensational invasions
61
middle-class imagination is violated by Spanish-Catholic inhumanity. Old men, youths and ‘slender young girls, mothers with children running at their knee’ (435) are chained and whipped as they bear heavy burdens. At first, such brutality ratifies the distinction between the high moral principles of the English and the systematic tyranny of Catholic Europeans. The ambushed Englishmen who see the slaves are immediately horrified. Their indignation is represented as characteristic of the authentic English sensibility for it shows their ‘free and righteous hearts’ (435). Moral outrage is presented as the consequence of an inborn respect for ‘the instinct of freedom … [as] the righteous voice of God’. (435). However, the English also dehumanize the natives they encounter. When Amyas and his comrades wander in the Central American forests, they do not respond to the Indians in an even-handed way, but enforce English authority at all costs. They seek vengeance and retribution when threatened; benevolence comes only when they are obsequiously obeyed. Kingsley portrays the adventurers as if they were demi-gods in a new Garden of Eden, dispensing their abundant power arbitrarily but under guise of humane justice. They wander as ‘the lords of the forest and its beasts; terrible to all hostile Indians, but kindly, just, and generous to all who will deal faithfully with them’ (398). Amyas, of course, does not literally enchain native women. Nonetheless, he flays the heart of the passionate native, Ayacanora, and reduces her to an emotionally colonized receptacle of his power. She is described by him – with no apparent irony on the part of the narrator – as ‘a lovely toy’ (453) or a child. Indeed, the narrator even more explicitly subordinates Ayacanora by using tropes that emphasize her animal-like inferiority and the satisfaction she will obtain from unthinking obedience. She is represented as fawning around Amyas, ‘like a dog who has found her master’ (440). Against the grain of his explicit authorial commentary, Kingsley’s simile constructs Englishness as patriarchal and patronizing; it suggests simultaneously a belief in the unseemliness of a desiring woman and the deference to English superiority ‘naturally’ inherent in the savage breast. Ayacanora’s status in the text as a symbol of racial otherness also exposes the arrogance of her ‘civilizing’ conquerors. In Westward Ho! the Victorian project of defining national identity against the Jesuit Other actually exposes the moral murkiness of imperial discursive practices. Because the novel constructs Central American native culture using terms normally associated with dangerous Catholicism, there is an implication that the racially other should be eradicated or suppressed as a foreign menace. Ayacanora’s attempts in the forest to convince the Indian tribe that women and men can have
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 61
15/3/07 17:06:28
62 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature equality of public position are made to seem ridiculous. Her reverence for the tribe’s ‘holy trumpet’, an ancient though meaningless artefact, is overblown. In her regard for its ‘precious mystery’, she is as superstitious as the Jesuits with their saints’ relics. Ayacanora is also threatening because of her fanatical single-mindedness, another characteristic she shares with the sensationalized Jesuit in Victorian narratives. Her impulsive actions and bizarre machinations to gain possession of the trumpet are mocked through the hyperbolic rhetoric typically used to describe Jesuit plotting in polemical writing of the period. When she is disappointed, she is said to be in ‘torment’; she loses control in ‘a fresh explosion’ (441–42). She is unwomanly and ‘uncivilized’ in her disrespect as well as in her physical strength and violence. She shrewishly burns her Indian master’s hut and seizes the trumpet after she has given her tribal superior a sound thrashing. Amyas only partly comprehends her tale of these ‘Amazonian exploits’ (442), suggesting his lack of empathy for both her female ambition and her native culture. The novel remains unable to close the gap between the ideals of national identity (with its projection of openness, love of freedom and tolerance) and Englishness in its historical, colonizing practice. Read through the eyes of those disinherited by the English conquest of Central America, Englishness in the narrative resembles nothing so much as the Spanish pattern of brutal oppression and the Jesuitical pattern of intellectual tyranny against which it is normally differentiated. The point is reinforced by the transformation which occurs when Ayacanora’s English origins are discovered. Overnight, she begins to behave in ways appropriate to respectable middle-class English femininity. Her racial inferiority – confirmed by her earlier wild insistence on personal independence – is replaced by qualities which simply enact another position of subjugation, this time prescribed by gender. Instead of self-assertion and free expression, she gratefully cultivates ‘self-restraint’, ‘temperance’, ‘softness’ (497). Like a child, she meekly welcomes Amyas’s decision to pass her to his mother for shaping into a proper, dutiful Englishwoman. While Kingsley’s concept of national identity endorses belief in equality, personal freedom and sturdy independence, its operation with respect to those deemed inferior by religion, race or gender is one of tight control and dutiful repression. Thus, Ayacanora’s declaration of devoted love for Amyas after his blinding takes the form of abject subservience. She vows to love ‘like your slave, your dog!’ (590), an expression of loyalty which Amyas does not moderate, but for which he gives thanks to God. Despite Kingsley’s fervent belief that ‘our own distinctive national character’ (160) can be recovered and redefined for his age, Westward Ho!
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 62
15/3/07 17:06:28
sensational invasions
63
gradually exposes the contradictions underpinning concepts of British subjecthood in mid-Victorian imperial culture. Read through Catholic sensationalism, the problematics of the narrative become apparent. The novel’s central contrast between Protestant decency and Catholic venality exposes as many similarities as distinctions. The strong leadership, discipline, and deference that define Kingsley’s ideal English nation increasingly resemble the authoritarian oppressiveness and subjugation the novel associates with Catholic culture. Idealized principles of free enterprise and duty in practice replicate the infamous pattern of authority and obedience so castigated in anti-Jesuit rhetoric. The same patterns of control and subjugation emerge, too, in Kingsley’s representations of gender and racial relations. In constructing a version of English nationhood defined by freedom, determination, energy and self-confidence, Westward Ho! is increasingly unable to differentiate the alien Jesuit attitudes of Catholic sensationalism from Victorian middle-class culture. Similar fissures in the ideals of nationhood expressed through family life can be tracked in The Black Robe, Wilkie Collins’s sensational romance combining sexual secrets, guilt and Jesuit conversion intrigues. A complex and fast-moving plot focusing on inheritance, madness and misrepresentation draws attention to parallel themes of fakery and manipulation in matters of faith and matters of the heart. Indeed, many resemblances between these two domains are established. Throughout the novel, the Jesuit model of authority and obedience provides the pattern against which secular relationships, particularly those of love and marriage, are measured. Conspiracies and false positions are shown to be characteristic of the institutions of Catholicism and marriage. In both Catholic and family environments, control is exercised despotically on the weakly servile and the infatuated. As in Westward Ho! the threat of Jesuit infiltration in The Black Robe stimulates reflection on the current state of Englishness and contemporary culture. Kingsley yearned for a more outward-looking British character, energetically promoting national progress and expansion. He denounced mid-Victorian scepticism, materialism and passivity. However, writing in the late Victorian period, Collins suggests that a different kind of spiritual and emotional malaise runs through society and threatens national self-image. In The Black Robe, it is not foreign powers but weak individuals who undermine Englishness, especially as it is expressed through family values and behaviour. Even protagonists seem incapable of taking personal responsibility but instead exist as empty vessels, yearning for fulfilment from some external source. In this novel, Jesuit designs on Victorian family life expose the Victorian family
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 63
15/3/07 17:06:28
64 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature itself as a cultural fantasy, a projection of desire and insecurity, perhaps even of selfishness and greed. Father Benwell, the Jesuit in The Black Robe, is the catalyst whose schemes crystallize Collins’s critique of institutional venality and individual neediness. His characterization draws on the most common traits of the sensationalized Jesuit in Victorian writing. He is wholly untrustworthy and deceitful. Adept at casuistry and equivocation – though capable of speaking ‘the plain truth [when it] served his purpose’ (III, 87) – Father Benwell is a master of ‘moral disguises of all kinds’.83 He can switch from ‘pastoral simplicity’ to ‘fatherly interest and chastened admiration’ in a moment (I, 192, 161). Insincerity, secretiveness and discreet watchfulness enable him to uncover compromising information about his enemies, his dupes and his victims. When it suits, he accepts no responsibility for his vendettas or intrigues, falling back on a Jesuit model of obedience to his superiors and his faith: ‘I only did my duty as a priest’ (III, 263). In reality, he is a man who takes pride and pleasure in exercising authority and power. Not only has he great strength of will and tenacity, but he also has an implicit belief in his right to control others. Despite his worldly and cultivated manner, his ‘pleasant paternal smile’ and ‘remarkably light and easy step’, he is a demanding tyrant, with ‘the habit of command, and the capacity for insisting on his right to be obeyed’ (I, 119–21). Like most Jesuit villains, Father Benwell has property and wealth in mind as he shapes his schemes. His principal objective is the conversion of the nervous, sensitive Lewis Romayne and thus the acquisition of Romayne’s estate, Vange Abbey, formerly a pre-Reformation monastic institution. Benwell presents his intrigue to the honourable Jesuit, Arthur Penrose, as a fair reclamation of usurped property and an appropriate revisioning of national history: ‘We don’t mean to allow Henry the Eighth to have it all his own way for ever’ (I, 131). His argument cynically exploits the Victorian middle-class dependence on authentic origins and legitimate succession to guarantee identity. When he indicates that the estate should be restored as the rightful legacy of the Catholic Church, Benwell appeals to a revered secular principle of ownership and inheritance. But to achieve his ends, Benwell is prepared to violate this precept by blocking the estate’s transmission to Romayne’s heirs. Also behind his scheme is his desire for self-assertion, for the exercise of Jesuitical authority for the sake of it. His impatience on meeting problems – ‘What right has an obstacle to get in my way?’ (I, 142) – shows that the austerity and isolation of his calling are more than balanced by the risk and excitement of imposing his will on others.
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 64
15/3/07 17:06:28
sensational invasions
65
Father Benwell’s conspiracy to convert Romayne is explicitly paralleled by an equal and opposite conspiracy – to ensure Romayne marries. Lord Loring, Romayne’s friend, believes the owner of Vange Abbey is depressed by his solitude. He is unaware that Romayne’s moody frame of mind is due to a serious spiritual and psychological crisis arising from an illegal duel on the Continent in which Romayne killed a man. For a contemporary readership steeped in the legal journalism of the day, this violent act has already compromised the protagonist’s English heritage. By duelling – the practice of unrestrained, ‘impulsive and hot-blooded’ European foreigners – Romayne has departed from the emotional restraint routinely endorsed in Victorian courtrooms as a ‘sign of English “civilisation”’.84 His transgression of moral boundaries and accepted standards of national behaviour causes morbid guilt and deep despair. However, the unsubtle Loring misreads his friend’s suffering as the more conventional need for companionship of a female kind. In his relationship with Romayne, Loring is represented as a well meaning but shallow establishment figure. Fashionable attitudes to courtship and marriage are critiqued through Loring’s general approach to romance as a mere social and emotional diversion. His clichéd plan – ‘a sweet girl to tempt’ his friend and a ‘trap’ to bring them together (I, 95) – suggests the vapid approach of contemporary upper-class society to love and the formation of the family. It is a good indication, too, of the fragmentation and solipsism that haunt the modern individual. Even concerned friends are unable and unwilling to penetrate psychological barriers and share spiritual pain. Conversion and marriage are not simply drawn together as two parallel conspiracies. The threatening Jesuit plot to force a change of faith in order to gain an estate can be read as a displaced critique of the Victorian investment in marriage. Many similarities between the process of Jesuit conversion and the process of courtship nuance the treatment of marriage in the novel, encoding it as an institution of potential tyranny governed by commercial interest. Particularly at issue is the appropriation of an individual’s identity and property. In The Black Robe, a Jesuit and a woman struggle for authority over Romayne’s heart and fortune. The rivals in this battle are evenly matched, although Collins’s mocking descriptions of the forces of womankind massed against the Catholic clergy can undercut – as well as praise – female tough-mindedness in matters of love and romance. The guile of women in managing the intrigues of courtship, in covering awkward social moments, and in dissimulation generally, is set out in the same terms found in Victorian narratives about the Jesuit’s infiltration of the family unit through disguise, smoothness and manipulation. Lady Loring’s finesse in
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 65
15/3/07 17:06:29
66 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature plotting Romayne’s union with Stella Eyrecourt is apparent in her verbal thrusts and casuistry: ‘[w]ith a woman’s feline fineness of perception, in all cases of subterfuge and concealment, she picked a part of the truth out of the whole, and answered harmlessly without a moment’s hesitation’ (I, 117). Even Stella’s mother, a silly social gadabout, is every bit as cunning as Father Benwell. Given a fixed social idea, such as the need for a huge fashionable wedding, Mrs Eyrecourt displays all the tenacity of a fanatical Jesuit: ‘Mrs Eyrecourt’s capacity for holding to her own little ideas, and for persisting … in trying to insinuate those ideas into the minds of other persons, was a capacity which no resistance, short of absolute brutality, could overcome’ (II, 37). While this mocking caricature of the wilful society woman pokes fun at fashionable manners and social trivia, her besting of the tricky Father Benwell elsewhere has a more telling and serious purpose. It shows Mrs Eyrecourt has will power and intuitive shrewdness surpassing even that of the most ingenious Jesuit schemer. She quickly understands that Benwell’s interest in her daughter’s past is not benevolent. Controlled and self-disciplined when acting in her own interests, she ‘foiled him at every point’ (II, 108). Indeed, Father Benwell and Mrs Eyrecourt use similar strategies to get their way. Their dependence on an iron will, their cunning reserve, and their perceptive protection of their own self-interest and position, suggest a further disturbing parallel between an ambitious foreign religion and a selfish secular world. In both, the wielding of authority and the breaking down of personal defences are fair weapons. In a number of ways, the logic of the plot also seems to suggest there is little to choose emotionally or morally between the conspiracy to marry and the scheme to convert to Catholicism in a world of limited options. Both possibilities ostensibly offer Romayne the chance of making up for an undefined lack or emptiness in his life. Even before the duel, he articulates desires which he cannot look to himself to fulfil, referring to ‘the higher needs of human nature’, which Catholicism at least acknowledges (I, 12). He yearns, too, for a sense of community and connection with his ‘fellowcreatures’ in order to achieve calm. Whether these observations reflect noble sensitivities or personal inadequacies is a moot point. Romayne marries (and Stella encourages him to do so) because he hopes she will forgive his guilt and assuage his self-torment. As Father Benwell acutely observes when he learns of Romayne’s marriage, this is a union based on neediness rather than selfless passion: ‘I counted on Romayne’s weakness, and Miss Eyrecourt counted on Romayne’s weakness; and Miss Eyrecourt has won’ (II, 108).
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 66
15/3/07 17:06:29
sensational invasions
67
Almost as soon as the marriage begins, it is apparent that Stella’s victory is only temporary. Romayne is bored by his wife’s failure to provide intellectual stimulus and companionship. The narrative voice slides smoothly from Romayne’s petulant disappointment to a more generalized distinction between the ‘natural’ obedience and loyal support which a woman can offer her husband and the position of intellectual helpmate which is simply beyond her. Collins invokes the rhetoric of the angel in the house to expound on the wife’s duty to her husband: she must ‘love him, admire him, serve him, believe in him beyond all other men’ (II, 101). However, an ironically pointed question also shows how this ideological position takes no account of other differences in upbringing, education and experience which separate English woman and English man in marriage: ‘But where is the woman who can intimately associate herself with the hard brain-work of a man devoted to an absorbing intellectual pursuit?’ (II, 101). The effect of such authorial comment is to imply that marriage and family life can never fulfil the imagined projection of individual aspiration and desire. Nor can it fill the gap created by lost self-esteem and the failure to accept the moral consequences of personal actions. Romayne’s hallucinatory anxiety returns; Stella cannot take on herself or forgive his guilt for involvement in the death of another. Romayne’s morbidity and bitter disillusionment with marriage are matched by his disenchantment with conversion and Jesuitism. Vulnerable to Father Benwell’s insinuations about his wife, misled by Stella’s mistaken decision to hide a previous relationship, and persuaded by Jesuitical casuistry that his marriage is a sham, Romayne becomes a member of the Society and rises to a senior position in the hierarchy of the Church. But the romance of self-sacrifice for religion proves as delusory as Romayne’s hopes for marriage. His guilt is not assuaged but redoubles, erupting in strange fanatical sermons about the tortures of the damned. The Catholic faithful who hear him have long modulated austere piety into something altogether more fashionable and less exacting. Such direct meditations on sin, personal culpability and punishment now seem in disturbingly bad taste. Romayne’s graphic images of the tormented damned soul generate ‘hysterical shrieks’ from the female members of the congregation (III, 188) and cause even the reasonable, wellbalanced Winterfield to rush from the church in search of fresh air and a reviving bottle of champagne. In the end, Romayne finds his Church labours sterile and unsatisfying. His punishing physical mortifications, his loneliness and his guilt destroy him physically and mentally. Instead of flourishing, he inwardly dies, aging prematurely and making a ‘sad change for the worse’ (III, 232).
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 67
15/3/07 17:06:29
68 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature Romayne’s heart is only eased when he rebels against his intellectual and spiritual vanity, rejects the authority of the Society, and cunningly ensures his estate passes legitimately to Stella and their child. His final act seems to restore confidence in the role of the family and domestic life in the nourishment of the individual: ‘I know how I have erred – what I have lost. Wife and child. How poor and barren all the rest of it looks now’ (III, 247). When he re-establishes the continuity of his family line, he seems to achieve a peace which has hitherto eluded him. In his responsibility for others lies forgiveness. The hallucinatory voice of guilty accusation which has plagued him since the duel becomes ‘[h]ardly a whisper: my repentance is accepted, my release is coming’ (III, 248). The connection that Romayne seeks from the outset seems embodied in the loving, faithful wife at his deathbed and the child who inherits. The Jesuits appear, once again, to have supplied the ‘false’ principles and illusory promises against which the Victorian middleclass family can be asserted as the guarantor of personal and national good health. Critics have indeed tended to read the novel in this schematic way, accepting it simply affirms ‘normative Victorian domesticity’ against ‘Catholic misogyny’.85 However, the sensations of Catholicism reverberate in the bourgeois world of the novel in more ambiguous ways than binary interpretations suggest, indicating that the conventional portrait of marriage and the family at the end of the novel is something of a compromise. The novel actually has alternative stories to tell about domestic harmony and satisfactions. There are, for example, many more unhappy than happy families in Collins’s narrative. Married bliss exists primarily in the reader’s expectation and imagination. The relationship of Stella and Romayne ceases to be painful only at the moment of their final separation through death. Stella’s own family is a damaged one. Her aunt had become – through marriage – a fanatical and proselytizing convert to Catholicism. By the time the novel opens, she has seduced Stella’s sister into a convent, brought Stella’s father to an early death, and destroyed their family cohesion. The only happy member is the nun. Stella reveals her sister’s contentment lies in her severance of all familial connections: ‘she is so happily absorbed in her religious duties, that she has not the slightest wish to see her mother or me’ (II, 241). Similarly, the cultivated Winterfield’s improbable marriage to Emma, the circus horserider, illustrates the dangerous class mismatches arising from infatuation; passion alone cannot overcome individual vulnerabilities or weaknesses like Emma’s alcoholism. The mother of Romayne’s duelling victim lives through a marriage which is termed ‘a martyrdom!’ (I, 295), bearing with a coarse
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 68
15/3/07 17:06:29
sensational invasions
69
criminal husband, a mentally incapacitated child, and a gruelling enslavement to piecework in their Islington slum. Particularly for women, marriage and family life in the novel are shown to involve a loss of integrity. Collins’s version of the marriage market demands that women who seek husbands subordinate their own needs entirely; instead they must devote their energies to ingratiation and flattery. So great are the expectations of society concerning the English woman’s emotional attachments and romantic, maternal destiny that she can often retain selfrespect and social position only by resorting to lies and half-truths, whatever her innocence. As the narrator concludes, protecting her domestic interests within the family often puts a woman in a false position: ‘[e]ven in trifles, a woman’s nature is degraded by the falsities of language and manner which the artificial condition of modern society exacts from her’ (II, 220). Such universalizing commentary offers a strong counterpoint to the apparent endorsement of the ideal of family life in the conclusion. Maintaining a respectable domestic identity can involve as much self-delusion, irrationalism, fear and forcing of conscience as any Jesuit scheme of conversion. The most honourable characters in the novel are also the most unconventional with respect to their participation in the Victorian model of family life. Bernard Winterfield’s marital status throughout the novel goes through surprising fluctuations and twists. He assumes many roles: single, cultivated intellectual; jilted fiancé; near bigamist; unhappy, separated husband; finally, and most satisfactorily, contented widower. While his likely marriage to the widowed Stella is hinted at the end of the novel, the character of Winterfield is most admirable when he is part of a largely female domestic circle, in chaste, long-suffering attendance on Stella, her child, and Mrs Eyrecourt. Despite the difficulties of maintaining a brotherly, asexual role, he persists in self-discipline and loyal service to Stella’s needs rather than his own. Initially a man of a questionable past, his consistent attention to self-management and duty gradually reveals him as an admirable contrast to the self-occupied Romayne. Unnatural as this strange family might be, it allows Collins to endorse selfless values which his more orthodox family groups disdain in their rush for wealth, status and personal gratification. Even more sensational is Collins’s sympathetic portrayal of the Jesuit Arthur Penrose, who is both sexually and denominationally suspect. Through his priestly vow of chastity, Penrose stands outside all models of marriage and family life represented in the novel. Moreover, a delicate, effeminate sensitivity lies behind his devotion to Romayne.86 To Father Benwell, such feeling is what makes Penrose an inferior Jesuit tool; he remarks with pitying
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 69
15/3/07 17:06:29
70 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature contempt on ‘the weakness of my poor little Arthur’s character’ (I, 263). Conscientious, ‘gentle, self-distrustful, melancholy’, he retains an innocent sincerity which, the narrator warns, could ‘be perverted to dangerous uses in unscrupulous hands’ (I, 127). Certainly, Penrose’s love for the Protestant he has been ordered to convert can be read on top of his Jesuitism as yet another manifestation of an unnatural cultural identity. Yet this homosocial – or even homosexual – attachment is ennobled by the ‘intimate sympathy’ (I, 149) and pure disinterestedness which Romayne’s marriage lacks. In addition, Penrose maintains his sincerity and truthfulness. His affection for Romayne and his sense of honour force him to take difficult decisions against the interests of his Order: to plead Stella’s cause to her husband and to abandon the plan to convert Romayne. Penrose distinguishes himself in both consistency and courage in ways the novel’s protagonist, Romayne, never does. He manages what anti-Jesuit discourse normally suggests is impossible for members of the Society. He exercises personal authority in following his conscience and ignoring Father Benwell’s instructions. He then demonstrates obedience in taking responsibility for breaking his solemn Jesuit vow. He humbly accepts a perilous posting to a Central American mission. For all this, even Winterfield acknowledges he is ‘one of a company of heroes’ (III, 192). It would seem only outsiders can exercise true valour in Collins’s world of distorted and hollow family values. The characterization of Winterfield and Penrose suggests The Black Robe is, ultimately, a subversive text that interrogates the traditional image of the Victorian family. The repertoire of Catholic sensationalism is central to this radical strand, though Collins exploits its motifs and archetypal figures in unexpected ways. A Jesuit’s affection and sense of duty are shown to be more selfless than that of any married couples in the novel. The similarities between Jesuit schemers and marriage ‘brokers’ suggest courtship entails manipulation and coercion and marriage is motivated by acquisitiveness. Overall, the most contented characters are those who live apart from traditional families or in an unusual relationship to them, like Penrose and Winterfield, or even Stella’s sister, the nun. Heroism in The Black Robe certainly does not lie in conformity to social expectations and the established models of behaviour favoured by late Victorian bourgeois culture. Instead, as Winterfield and Penrose show, integrity depends on selflessness and the ability to take personal responsibility for decisions without self-pity. In this wider context, Romayne’s deathbed confession brings peace and indicates maturity, not because it endorses marriage and family over Jesuit tyranny, but because it signals his ability to face his own errors, accept their consequences, and
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 70
15/3/07 17:06:30
sensational invasions
71
forgive himself. Indeed, the destruction of the Jesuit will and the passing of his inheritance to his child allows Romayne to re-create a more innocent and noble self in the next generation. Sensational representations of Jesuits occupy an important place in the Victorian literary imagination. Jesuits enter numerous plots as the alien agents who endanger the health and stability of nation, family and individual. With their allegiance to a Continental Superior General and the Pope, they are troped as foreign invaders of the nation, threatening its political autonomy. Represented as the countercultural Other imperilling the secular state with their intrigues, violence and tyrannical principles, Jesuits enable the expression of nationhood through opposition. Against them, the native British character can be constructed as one dedicated to freedom of conscience and personal initiative. Moreover, the excesses of sensational Jesuit practice give impetus to this task of national self-definition. As the forces of misrepresentation, Jesuits undermine stable social structures, clouding judgement and eroding confidence in public and private domains, in the authority of the state and the family. They blur, confuse and disguise their own religious and secular identities, and thus impose an urgent need on nation and individual, on writer and reader, to separate the authentic and the false in matters of cultural definition. The terminology and thematics of this sensational discourse also have metaphoric purposes in many narratives. Jesuits serve as a type of all that is unhealthy and unnatural in contemporary social relations. Integrated secretly into society at all levels, their ability to scheme unnoticed and their promulgation of a despotic system of control and blind obedience signal at least the imminent danger, if not the presence, of cultural decline. Other paradigms for public institutions and personal relationships are articulated as a response to this Jesuit ‘invasion’. At the level of the state and the level of the family, an ideal chivalric fraternity based on legitimate leadership and loyalty emerges as the antidote to the ethical and social disintegration of Victorian society. Ideologies of sympathy, respect, and duty are promoted as the way to withstand – or mend – the worst failings of the modern nation which scheming, despotic Jesuits exploit. Yet, in a sensational mode, the Jesuit also functions more ambiguously. The clear differentiation between the Jesuit as foreign, invasive Other and the Briton as the natural inheritor of the values of freedom and righteousness is sometimes blurred by irony, paradox and contradiction. Wicked Jesuit principles and practices are mirrored, not supplanted, in the societies depicted in these Victorian fictions. Benign institutions that stand in opposi-
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 71
15/3/07 17:06:30
72 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature tion to the Jesuit and his allies are themselves shown to depend on structures of authority and compliance that, in practice at least, are similar to those of the despised Society of Jesus. The Jesuit reliance on subjugation and obedience is, on the one hand, treated with suspicion and disgust. Yet it is also re-articulated as an essential and natural characteristic of the free nation and blessed domestic circle, at least for the lesser orders. Women, workers and colonial natives are portrayed as attractive and sympathetic when they cheerfully embrace their subordination, empty their minds and surrender their wills to those with power over them. Whether located in the romanticized past or in the contemporary milieu of fashionable society, the melodramatic Jesuit villain is adept at mimicking a society that, like him, has two faces. Hidden in the most sensational Jesuit narratives are two images of the same culture: the idealized state and family sustained by the values of respectability and duty, work and responsibility, determination and enterprise; and a more disturbing vision of that society, one riven by narcissism, social hypocrisy, greed, materialism and inequalities of power. Repeatedly in Victorian Jesuit tales, the invasive Catholic Other slides worryingly and persistently into the complacent Us.
Notes 1 R. W. Overbury, The Jesuits (London: Houlston & Stoneman, 1846), p. 138. 2 R. J. M’Ghee, ed., ‘Preface and Notes’, in The Poor Gentlemen of Liége: being the History of the Jesuits in England and Ireland, for the Last Sixty Years, trans. M. Cretineau Joly (London: John F. Shaw, 1863), p. cxxi. 3 John Tulloch, ‘The Order of Jesuits’, Good Words, XVIII (1877), p. 689. 4 Christopher Devlin, ed., ‘Introduction’, in The Sermons and Devotional Writings of Gerard Manley Hopkins (London: Oxford University Press, 1959), p. 11. 5 As C. J. W.-L. Wee suggests, throughout the nineteenth century the discourse of nationhood frequently fails to distinguish among the multiple nationalities that constituted Great Britain. ‘British’ is often a synonym for ‘English’; this chapter reflects such elision in the discussion of patriotism and national spirit (‘’Christian Manliness and National Identity: The Problematic Construction of a Racially “Pure” Nation’, in Muscular Christianity: Embodying the Victorian Age, ed. Donald E. Hall [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994], p. 86). 6 Benedict Anderson’s Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (London and New York: Verso, 1991) is one of many recent works that draw on postcolonial theory to suggest the importance of the ‘other’ in the formation of national identity. Nationhood depends on boundaries ‘beyond which lie other nations’ (p. 7); defining borders forge feelings of kinship and exclusivity essential to a strong nation-state. Anderson’s theorizing of the nation as a kind of sacred cultural community
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 72
15/3/07 17:06:30
sensational invasions
7 8 9
10 11
12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19
20
73
is also helpful in accounting for the place of religious discourse in nationalism. The nation, he argues, becomes explicitly articulated as it replaces and defines itself against waning systems like those of religion or dynastic sovereignty. Arthur F. Marotti, Catholicism and Anti-Catholicism in Early Modern English Texts (London: Macmillan; New York: St Martin’s Press, 1999), p.15. Quoted in Francis Edwards, The Jesuits in England: From 1580 to the Present Day (Tunbridge Wells: Burns & Oates, 1985), p. 168. Lecture by William Paterson, 1893, quoted in Jonathan Wright, The Jesuits: Missions, Myths and Histories (London: HarperCollins, 2004), p. 227. Wright provides a good summary of the many accusations that have been levelled at the order from the sixteenth century, including sexual debauchery, avarice, cruelty and murder, political treachery, secrecy and disguise, equivocation and casuistry (pp. 126–49). Margaret M. Maison, Search Your Soul, Eustace: A Survey of the Religious Novel in the Victorian Age (London and New York: Sheed & Ward, 1961), p. 169. Anon., ‘The Popular Novels of the Year’, Fraser’s Magazine, LXVIII, no. 404 (August 1863), pp. 263, 255. H. L. Mansel even singles out such plot lines as ‘a priest persuading a dying man to sign a paper’ as a characteristic device ‘of the sensation kind (‘Sensation Novels’, p. 485). For discussion of how sensation fictions built on Gothic romance and narratives of ‘religious mystery’ in terms of plot, theme and reading strategies, see Patrick Brantlinger, ‘What Is “Sensational” about the “Sensation Novel”?’, Nineteenth-Century Fiction, 37, no. 1 ( June 1982), pp. 1–28, and Susan M. Griffin, ‘The Yellow Mask, the Black Robe, and the Woman in White: Wilkie Collins, Anti-Catholic Discourse, and the Sensation Novel’, Narrative, XII, no. 1 ( January 2004), pp. 55–73. Griffin is concerned with the plots, character types and images of anti-Catholic fictions as a framework for the writing and reading of sensation fiction, but does not pursue the ways in which sensationalized versions of religious discourse intersect with discourses of nationalism and patriotism in the period. Anon., ‘Belles Lettres’, p. 269. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, p. 503. An unsigned review in Reader, I (3 January 1863), pp.14–15; reprinted in Norman Page, ed., Wilkie Collins: The Critical Heritage (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1974), pp. 134–35. [ J. R. Wise], ‘Belles Lettres’, Westminster Review, n.s. XXXI ( January 1867), p. 262. [Mansel], ‘Sensation Novels’, pp. 482, 483; Anon., ‘Popular Novels of the Year’, p. 263. Linda Colley, Britons: Forging the Nation 1707–1837 (1992; London: Pimlico, 1994), p. 23. M’Ghee, ‘Preface and Notes’, p. cxxiv. Catherine Sinclair, Beatrice; or, The Unknown Relatives, 2nd edn (London: Simpkin, Marshall & Co., 1855), publicity testimonies from cover blurbs of this ‘Run and Read’ edition. Le Juif Errant, one of the best-selling anti-Jesuit novels of the nineteenth century, sold 120,000 copies upon publication in 1845 when it was also translated into English. Translations in German, Spanish and Italian also show the widespread European interest in its anti-clerical approach. In addition to its many reprints, Le Juif Errant was adapted for the stage in Paris and London. George Lander’s English stage version was still being reprinted in the 1880s. See J. C. H. Aveling, The Jesuits (London: Blond & Briggs, 1981), p. 23.
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 73
15/3/07 17:06:30
74 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 21 Eugene Sue, The Wandering Jew (1845; London: George Routledge, n.d.), p. 284. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 22 For Patrick Brantlinger, such perversion of narrative authority is a key feature of sensation fiction of the 1860s; see ‘What Is “Sensational”?’, p. 14. 23 Walter Walsh, The Jesuits in Great Britain: An Historical Inquiry into their Political Influence (London: George Routledge & Sons, 1903), pp. 129, vii. 24 Bourn, Words of Warning, p. 59. 25 Bourn, Words of Warning, p. 54. 26 Fanny Trollope, Father Eustace: A Tale of the Jesuits (London: Henry Colburn, 1847), I, p. 71. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 27 Member of the University, Intrigues of the Jesuits, pp. 5, 6. 28 Isaac Taylor, Loyola: and Jesuitism in its Rudiments (London: Longman, Brown, Green & Longmans, 1849), p. 310. 29 Taylor, Loyola, p. 242; [W. C. Cartwright]. ‘Jesuits: Der Jesuiten-Orden. by Dr. J. Huber, Berlin, 1873’, Quarterly Review, 137, no. 274 (October 1874), p. 287. 30 Taylor, Loyola, p. 310. 31 Taylor, Loyola, pp. 108, 154. 32 [W. C. Cartwright], ‘The Doctrines of the Jesuits’, Quarterly Review, 138, no. 275 ( January 1875), p. 105. 33 Taylor, Loyola, p. 298. 34 Taylor, Loyola, pp. 299, 317. 35 Overbury, The Jesuits, p. 38. 36 Overbury, The Jesuits, pp. 128, 148. 37 William Sewell, Hawkstone: A Tale of and for England in 184–. 2nd edn (London: John Murray, 1846), II, p. 422. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 38 Sinclair, Beatrice, or, The Unknown Relatives, 1st edn (London: Richard Bentley, 1852), I, p. 249. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 39 William Makepeace Thackeray, The History of Henry Esmond, Esq. Written by Himself Edited by William Makepeace Thackeray (1852; London: Thomas Nelson, n.d. [1904]), p. 32. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 40 Anon., ‘Jesuits’ Bark and Howl’, Punch, XXXV (4 September 1858), p. 100. 41 George Stephen, The Jesuit at Cambridge (London: Henry Colburn, 1847), II, p. 181. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 42 Cartwright, ‘Doctrines of the Jesuits’, p. 84. 43 Foucault, Power/Knowledge, p. 154. 44 See Robert Chambers’s comment in 1861: ‘In plain terms, on every man, no matter what his position, is imposed Individual Responsibility. …. from the power of universal selfmanagement and self-reliance … must ever spring the chief glory of a state.’ Quoted in Mary Poovey, Making a Social Body: British Cultural Formation 1830–1864 (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1995), p. 22. 45 Poovey, Making a Social Body, p. 109. 46 Tony Claydon and Ian McBride, ‘The trials of the chosen peoples: recent interpretations of protestantism and national identity in Britain and Ireland’, in Protestantism and National Identity: Britain and Ireland, c.1650–c.1850, ed. Tony Claydon and Ian McBride (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), p. 20. 47 Colley, Britons, p. 53. 48 G. B. Nicolini, History of the Jesuits: Their Origin, Progress, Doctrines, and Designs
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 74
15/3/07 17:06:30
sensational invasions
75
(London: Henry G. Bohn, 1854), p. 169. 49 Anon., ‘Domestic Jesuitism’, Fraser’s Magazine, p. 667. 50 Anon., The Jesuits Exposed, 2nd edn (London: Protestant Association/Seeley, 1839), p. 19. 51 [Cartwright], ‘The Jesuits’, p. 284. 52 Walsh, Jesuits in Great Britain, p. 347. 53 Member of the University, Intrigues of the Jesuits, p. 5. 54 M. J. Michelet and M. E. Quinet, Jesuits and Jesuitism, trans. G. H. Smith (1843; London: Whittaker & Co., n.d. [1846]), p. 3. 55 Taylor, Loyola, p. 154. 56 Sinclair, Beatrice, 2nd edn, quoted on the cover blurbs. 57 Taylor, Secret Theatre of Home, p. 7. 58 Tamar Heller, Dead Secrets: Wilkie Collins and the Female Gothic (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1992), pp. 14–15. 59 From Aphorisms, or certain selected points of the Doctrine of the Jesuits, 1609; quoted in Edwards, Jesuits in England, p. 23. 60 A Layman, The Jesuit Priest in the Family, the Church, and the Parish: In reply to a letter by W. H. Anderdon, Sometime Vicar of St Margaret’s Leicester – now Priest of Rome (London: Houston & Stoneman, 1852), p. 156. 61 Taylor, Loyola, pp. 321–22. 62 Taylor, Loyola, p. 332. 63 [Cartwright], ‘Doctrines of the Jesuits’, p. 78. 64 Charles Hastings Collette, A Jesuit Scheme for the Government of England and Ireland, Recommended by the Rev. R. F. Clarke, S.J., for adoption ‘should opportunity present itself,’ and exposed by Charles Hastings Collette. 2nd rev. edn (London: Charles Hastings Collette, n.d. [1898?]), p. 22. 65 John Henry Newman, Lectures on the Present Position of Catholics in England: Addressed to the Brothers of the Oratory (London: Burns & Lambert, 1851), p. 16. 66 See, for example, the lampoon of MP George Hammond Whalley’s self-defeating categorizations of Jesuits in high places: ‘Any M. P. who mentions the Pope, in praise or dispraise, is a Jesuit. Any M. P. who never mentions the Pope is the greatest Jesuit of all’ (Anon., ‘Ostensible Occupations of Jesuits’, Punch, LXIX (24 July 1875), p. 23). 67 The novelist William Sewell was convinced the local Ipswich butcher was a Jesuit in disguise. See Shirley Foster, ‘Two Against Rome: A Family Contribution to Victorian Anti-Catholic Fiction’, Durham University Journal, LXIX, n.s. 38, no. 2 ( June 1977), p. 256. 68 Nicolini, History of the Jesuits, p. 270. 69 Andrew Maunder and Grace Moore, eds, Victorian Crime, Madness and Sensation (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2004), p. 3. 70 Bourn, Words of Warning, p. 28. 71 Tulloch, ‘Order of Jesuits’, pp. 738–39, 742. 72 George H. Tragett, Notes on the History of the Jesuits (London: Bell & Daldy, 1865), p. 13; Taylor, Loyola, pp. 152, 178. 73 [Anon.], ‘A Sketch of Popery; extracted from “The Christian Lady’s Magazine’”, in Publications of the Protestant Association (London: Protestant Association/Seeley, 1839), p. 2. 74 Quoted in Foster, ‘Two against Rome’, p. 256. 75 Miriam Elizabeth Burstein, ‘Protestants against the Jewish and Catholic Family, c.1829
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 75
15/3/07 17:06:31
76 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature to c.1860’, Victorian Literature and Culture, 31, no. 1 (2003), p. 343. 76 Jemima Luke, The Female Jesuit; or, The Spy in the Family: A True Narrative of Recent Intrigues in a Protestant Household (London: Partridge & Oakey, 1851), p. 220. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 77 Mrs. S. [ Jemima] Luke, A Sequel to The Female Jesuit; Containing Her Previous History and Recent Discovery (London: Partridge & Oakey, 1852), p. 199. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 78 Charles Kingsley, Westward Ho! or, The Voyages and Adventures of Sir Amyas Leigh, Knight, of Burrough, in the County of Devon, in the Reign of Her Most Glorious Majesty Queen Elizabeth (1855; London: Macmillan, 1917), p. 248. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 79 Martin Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1980), p. 216. 80 Raphael Samuel (ed.), Patriotism: The Making and Unmaking of British National Identity, vol. I, History and Politics (London and New York: Routledge, 1989), p. lviii. 81 Cannon Schmitt, Alien Nation: Nineteenth-Century Gothic Fictions and English Nationality (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997), pp. 10–16. 82 Abdul R. JanMohamed argues: ‘This economy … is based on a transformation of racial difference into moral and even metaphysical difference.’ Kingsley’s treatment of Jesuits shows the way JanMohamed’s argument could be extended to include religious difference. See “The Economy of Manichean Allegory: the Function of Racial Difference in Colonialist Literature’, in ‘Race’, Writing, and Difference, ed. Henry Louis Gates, Jr. (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1986), p. 80. 83 Wilkie Collins, The Black Robe, 3 vols, 2nd edn (London: Chatto & Windus, 1881), III, p. 87; I, p. 192. Subsequent references to this edition are cited in the text. 84 Martin J. Wiener, ‘Homicide and “Englishness”: Criminal Justice and National Identity in Victorian England’, National Identities, VI, no. 3 (2004), p. 204. 85 Griffin, “The Yellow Mask’, pp. 62–64. 86 Tamara S. Wagner argues that Collins’s later sensitive and sentimental heroes indicate a ‘reaction to the more embarrassing and dangerous aspects of Victorian ideologies of energy, enterprise, and muscularity’, but her brief discussion of The Black Robe downplays the importance of Penrose for new definitions of heroism in a sceptical age. See ‘“Overpowering Vitality”: Nostalgia and Men of Sensibility in the Fiction of Wilkie Collins’, Modern Language Quarterly, 63, no. 4 (December 2002), pp. 474, 492.
LUP_Moran_02_Ch1.indd 76
15/3/07 17:06:31
2 Nuns and Priests: Sensations of the Cloister Charlotte Brontë’s Villette and the Monologues of Robert Browning
The popular demand is for the prodigious, the enormous, the abominable, the diabolical, the impossible. It must be shown that all priests are monsters of hypocrisy, that all nunneries are dens of infamy, that all Bishops are the embodied plenitude of savageness and perfidy. 1 — John Henry Newman, Lectures on the Present Position of Catholics I almost wish we were Papists, and had a convent to put her in to-morrow. 2 — Wilkie Collins, No Name Of monks and nuns with morbid cravings, With visions and ecstatic ravings … 3 — Eugene Lee Hamilton
In her memoirs of an Evangelical childhood, the Victorian poet, Eliza Keary, recalled a youthful fascination with stories about sinister Catholic convents. Both Eliza and her sister succumbed to the delicious frissons of ‘nun mania’ after reading Mrs Sherwood’s novel, The Nun (1833).4 Sherwood’s narrative makes much of the Catholic cloister as an institution that oppresses both the vulnerable (innocent girls) and the assertive (those with independent religious views). A sub-plot, for example, features Sister Agnes, who, obstinately Protestant in her religious tendencies, had ‘been hidden away in a cell underground, that she might not contaminate the sisterhood’.5 Deeply moved by this portrayal of Catholic violence to a defenceless creature, the Keary girls became convinced that some frightened novice was imprisoned in a subterranean passage under their house. They spread panic and terror among their school-friends, such that one poor girl ran home ‘almost raving about a nun, and a dungeon, and the priest’.6 Indeed, such nun mania was highly infectious in the nineteenth century. Priests, monks and nuns – and the cloistered life in particular – occupy a significant space in the Victorian literary imagination. Tortured nuns, immured nuns, escaped nuns, and rescued nuns as well as licentious chaplains and perverted monks are reconstituted from more exotic Gothic precursors to feature in all manner
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 77
15/3/07 17:09:29
78 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature of Victorian texts – from lurid journalism to scandalous autobiographies, from ‘penny bloods’ to mainstream literary works. This chapter explores the contribution of these sensational character types to the construction and interrogation of gender roles and the ideology of respectability in Victorian writing, with particular reference to Charlotte Brontë’s Villette (1853) and certain religious monologues by Robert Browning. Throughout the Victorian period, the Catholic cloister is invoked in secular as well as religious discussions concerning gender roles and social relations; and the spectacular claims often made about this life emphasize its transgressiveness. Driven by Protestant assumptions about the wicked Church of Rome, many portrayals of nuns and priests focus on their unnatural corrupt state as servants of unholy popery. With their secluded, spartan habitations and vows of chastity, poverty and obedience, nuns and priests oppose Victorian middle-class ideals concerning productive sexuality within marriage, prosperity, social status and individual autonomy. At their most sensational, the scandalous secrets, sexual perversities and authoritarian control of the cloister plot illustrate Catholic tyranny and vice. However, as archetypes against which more orthodox models of femininity and masculinity can be asserted, nuns and priests also offer lessons in ‘true’ and ‘false’ self-fashioning for a contemporary Protestant audience. The un-English space of the cloister provides images of the culturally undesirable, monstrous regiments of despotic or hysterical women, of lascivious, depraved and hypocritical priests. However, Catholic sensationalism also encodes the heterodox space of the cloister in more ambivalent ways. As this chapter shows, it is a contested site in the Victorian cultural imaginary. Because the Catholic consecrated life segregates the sexes, requires sexual abstinence, and insists on strictly regulated conduct, it has many points in common with the Victorian construction of separate domains for private and public experience, for feminine and masculine roles and behaviour. The association of this mainstream gender pattern with a foreign and false faith renders the Catholic cloister an uncanny and disruptive domain – and a potentially subversive one. Both familiar and strange, the cloister blurs the boundaries between horrid papist practices and the social roles and manners that define respectability within Victorian culture. Moreover, as a transgressive site, the cloistered space gives licence to imagine ‘heretical’ alternatives to accepted norms of personal identity and social aspirations. In their appropriation and revision of sensational cloister images and plots, both Brontë and Browning exploit their period’s fascination with the
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 78
15/3/07 17:09:29
sensations of the cloister
79
unorthodoxy of Catholic nuns and priests. In Villette, the adaptation of the popular convent exposé and the feminized convent space provides a new model of female autonomy that challenges marriage and domesticity as a woman’s sole destiny. Browning’s monologues about Catholic monks and priests are concerned with the masculine world of the public sphere where conduct is governed by cynical devotion to respectability, convention and social appearance. In his poetry, the lurid world of the greedy and sensual Catholic priesthood serves as a microcosm and critique of nineteenthcentury middle-class life and the hypocritical attitudes that motivate secular behaviour. Underpinning the work of both authors is a complex and shifting network of symbolic meanings associated with the enclosed religious life of the Catholic Church. The contradictions embedded in cloister images capture Victorian disquiet about gender politics and social relations in general. The cloister plot becomes a significant – and popular – means of exploring the gradual erosion of male and female gender boundaries and the changing balance of power between middle-class men and women. Sensational representations of nuns and priests also reflect the shifting ambitions and expectations of the bourgeoisie in more general terms. From sociological and economic discussions to the popular taste for paintings of convent life, nineteenth-century representations of the cloister resist and reinforce ideals of womanhood and masculinity and of social achievement and success. The complexity of Catholic cloister discourse is well illustrated by the multiplicity of readings attached to the figure of the nun in Victorian culture. Public concern about the social place of single women inflects the handling of this archetype of Catholic femininity. From the 1850s, an apparent surplus of unmarried women provoked disquiet. Denunciations of spinsterhood as an ‘unwholesome social state’ and an ‘evil and anomaly to be cured’ suggest the anxiety arising when many women could no longer be safely channelled into ‘completing, sweetening, and embellishing the existence of others’.7 These redundant single women seemed to imperil cultural assumptions about the feminine as a dependent and maternal identity. However, the debate also promoted an alternative view of women’s nature and its fulfilment. Activists like Dinah Mulock Craik and Florence Nightingale embraced a radical view of women’s nature and fulfilment, arguing that purposeful work was essential to female self-development: ‘the chief canker at the root of women’s lives is the want of something to do’.8 The unorthodox social project – to provide single women with a dignified ‘refuge and an occupation’9 – attracted some early feminists to a female space already deemed culturally heretical: the religious sisterhood.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 79
15/3/07 17:09:30
80 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature Anna Jameson, for example, suggested that the Catholic convent illustrated ‘a well-organised system of work for women’ that could be adapted to the national Protestant character and the ‘requirements of the age’.10 A sisterhood could acknowledge a ‘woman’s privilege to share in the communion of labour at her own free choice’ and train her to do so effectively.11 Admittedly, Jameson’s vision of a modern convent life seems scarcely radical to a presentday reader. She constructs her community in terms drawn from traditional Victorian ideals of femininity, so that there is a blurring of cloistered and secular domestic spaces. The sisters’ charitable endeavours with the poor, the fallen and the ignorant are consonant with the traditional understanding of women’s inclinations, with ‘the sympathies, the domestic instincts, the active administrative capabilities with which God has endowed them’.12 The regulation normally provided by the legal and cultural constraints of marriage and the family would, for Jameson, be replicated by the discipline of communal living. Like the traditional Victorian domestic environment, Jameson’s cloister would shape womanly aspirations and behaviour through a sympathetic support network and ‘the control of a high religious responsibility’.13 Nonetheless, by giving ‘domesticated’ respectability to a scheme that seems to challenge both gender and Protestant certainties of the day, Jameson’s proposal illustrates how the radical nature of the Catholic cloister could be used to imagine new alternatives to existing social structures. Certainly, in the prolonged Victorian debate about the Woman Question, the nature of a nun’s experience became a key means of portraying the advantages and disadvantages of an empowered, independent version of the feminine. The Anglican sisterhood, retaining Catholic features of separation, celibacy, collective discipline and spiritual dedication, was seen by many women as an opportunity rather than a threat. As Martha Vicinus has shown, convent life promised ‘adventure linked with duty’, providing respectable access to a public platform and exotic domains normally out of the reach of single women.14 Frances Power Cobbe, a Victorian feminist critical of religious sisterhoods in principle, admitted the attractions of such a life for an able single woman. It could be imagined as ‘a theatre whereon she may develop wonderful abilities for the government of the community and the direction of nobler enterprises … she may find a field wider than the private life of a woman can often supply’.15 The sisterhood movement thus challenged typical constructions of female identity as naturally dependent and relational. Women in a convent developed leadership and financial skills and deployed them in private and public spheres with a minimum of male oversight. Sisterhoods also challenged Victorian masculine ideologies of
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 80
15/3/07 17:09:30
sensations of the cloister
81
competition and self-assertion that underpinned commercial and imperial endeavours. They demonstrated how collaborative working ensured progress in noble enterprises of social welfare. Religious discourse was also involved in the rejection of these radical possibilities for female social access, self-determination and fulfilling work. Because of the cloister’s close association with the sensational depravity of the Church of Rome, anti-Catholic rhetoric was invoked to suggest the abnormality of a single woman’s life in a sisterhood (and, by implication, anywhere else). Even Protestant convents seemed to threaten the public good in their imitation of, as Bishop Wilberforce termed it ‘a semi-Romanist scheme, with its direction, with its development of self-consciousness and morbid religious affection, with its exaltation of the contemplative life, its perpetual Confession, and its unEnglish tone’.16 These denominationally inflected attacks served as a mechanism for controlling women’s maternal destiny and emotional capacity. By estranging the inhabitants of the ‘foreign’ cloister, marriage could be indirectly promoted and a single life denigrated. As one reviewer remarked, only ‘artificially excited religious emotion’ would attract someone to a sisterhood with its unwholesome Catholic undertones.17 By blending the sensational rhetoric of Catholic fanaticism and female hysteria, critics could represent attraction to this unmarried, active life as a pathological state. The same technique also undermined female intellectual ambition. The growing popularity of the convent as a life-choice was said by some to illustrate women’s inferior taste for the romantic and sentimental and their inability to cut rationally through surface appearance. A nun’s life is figured as ‘something fictitious’ with its ‘feigned parental relation between the superior and the sisters, [and] the self-humiliation where no real cause for humiliation exists’.18 Only a woman, it is implied, would be credulous enough to succumb to such nonsense. The danger of female self-will and determination is also an important undercurrent in the more sensational depictions of the cloister temptation. Women who decide to enter a sisterhood are denounced in language that is hyperbolic and overwrought. But the contradictory nature of these harangues actually exposes cultural panic about maintaining gender ideologies that are internally inconsistent. For some, a woman’s decision to honour her sense of vocation is sign of a misguided strength of will, a rebellion against family duty and parental authority.19 For others, the same single-mindedness is configured as weakness and immaturity, the mark of someone overly impressionable and with no will power at all. Because the mind of ‘a girl is plastic, & can be moulded by any one around her’, she can be enticed into ‘the
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 81
15/3/07 17:09:30
82 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature superstition, or the vice, which may be secretly practised within the convent walls’.20 Once she is inside, some argue, a woman’s rampant egotism will likely be unleashed by the cloistered regime. Tainted by Catholic arrogance and exclusivity, convent asceticism will foster ‘self-sufficiency and spiritual pride, while it engenders self-absorption, selfishness and want of feeling’.21 On the other hand, notwithstanding the general Victorian advocacy of dutiful obedience and respectable compliance in private and public life, convent experience is condemned because it actually obliterates independence. The Catholic tradition of enforced vows demands ‘the complete renunciation of will to another’.22 Such disparagement and promotion of female obedience and autonomy within the same discursive field suggest the instability of the cultural unconscious. Victorian portrayals of the Catholic nun show the difficulty of conceptualizing an ideal of womanhood in a Protestant patriarchy that invests equally in male authority, female submission, and individual freedom of conscience. Additional gender anxiety is apparent in the contradictory understanding of a nun’s liminal position between private and public spheres evidenced in the sisterhood debate. Nuns are represented as unpatriotic because they dedicate their lives to public service rather than the family. This viewpoint relies on the familiar association of the cloister with un-English Catholic roots. From the 1850s through the 1890s, repeated attempts to enforce the inspection of convents promote the view that these institutions have secret Catholic designs on British political and social life. Edward Harper, for example, called for the Government inspection of nunneries because they are sites ‘inside which the jurisdiction of the British Sovereign is not recognised, and where the rights of British subjects have ceased to exist’.23 However, it is the violation of gender expectations rather than denominational boundaries that seems to underpin the most insistent criticism. Nuns are said to undermine the order of the nation by rejecting their natural private role within the family and trespassing on the ‘masculine’ public domain. A meeting of bishops in 1895 looked aghast at ‘the growing independence and lawlessness’ of sisterhoods,24 implying their powerful impact and high visibility, but also their anarchic rebellion in operating outside an orderly system of male regulation. Through such representations of the transgressive, antisocial cloister, independent and self-directing women are implicitly displaced, shunted outside the nation and beyond frameworks of acceptable femininity and propriety. The sensations of the Catholic cloister also offered opportunities to explore – and police – erotic ideals and behaviour, as well as gender definitions.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 82
15/3/07 17:09:30
sensations of the cloister
83
Visual art that capitalized on the Victorian sisterhood debate illustrates how the portrayal of Catholic nuns simultaneously inscribed orthodoxy and permitted transgression with respect to female sexuality. As Susan P. Casteras’s study of Victorian paintings of nuns has demonstrated, the ‘partly sensational, partly sentimental’ visual images of the cloister are mainly about sex in their depiction of women pining away for lost or non-existent lovers.25 Further, such works, and reviewers’ responses to them, suggest these images carried inconsistent messages about the vulnerability of the female mind and body. Traditional theories about women’s emotional sensitivity and physical dependence are encapsulated in the favourite depiction of the calm, beautiful convent grounds. The enclosed space offers a necessary protection for women otherwise tempted, or driven, to waste themselves on unworthy men or styles of living. On the other hand, the cloister garden with its restricting walls is also an unhealthy site of repressed sexuality. Ironically surrounded by evidence of nature’s own fruitfulness in beautiful plants and flowers, the wan nun figure symbolizes the annihilation of woman’s natural reproductive capacity, her rejection of a normal maternal and domestic role. As one art critic put it, enforced celibacy leads to female de-naturing in depression, enfeeblement and death: ‘so much capability in giving and sharing delight, is immured alive … all is sadness’.26 However, the very representation of the mysterious convent world tropes a third interpretation of a woman’s physical presence – and this a more illicit and suggestive one. The viewer (or reader) is invited to adopt a scopophilic perspective, taking pleasure in gazing on the forbidden. The spectators’ penetration into the mysteries of a secret female space implies an alternative, sexualized femininity for imaginative contemplation. The figure of the nun becomes a religious displacement of (male) fantasies about the unattainable veiled virgin. These aesthetic products of nun mania collude with and challenge the secular fetishizing of virginity and associated versions of femininity. In the sensational discourse of the cloister, the chaste nun is an object of pity and titillation. Her prescribed celibacy ironically draws attention to woman’s sexual potential and presents it as both threatened and dangerously seductive. Beneath such ambivalence lies a deep-seated cultural uncertainty about whether the restraint of women is undesirable or necessary. These ambiguities are most visible in the literary modes of Catholic sensationalism where the cloister is shown to disrupt and pervert both gender and erotic norms. The excesses of Gothic horror and prurient anti-clerical revelations inflect Victorian non-fiction and imaginative writing about convents, foregrounding in particular the difficulties of self-formation in an
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 83
15/3/07 17:09:30
84 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature environment where powerful authorities command obedience. As Robert Miles has suggested, the Gothic designates Catholicism as the alien, abjected element of British cultural memory, ‘the embodiment of the “unclean” that ought to have been expelled from the Protestant political body’.27 Gothic constructions of the cloistered space, with their frightening dark rooms and enslaved or tyrannical inhabitants, serve as a microcosm of the corrupt power of the outmoded, feudal Roman Church. Transformed into a Victorian context, such horrific settings still present Catholicism as an alien presence, but the emphasis shifts from political structures and national identity to the ways in which strict external regulation deforms the individual. Self-control and self-determination are supplanted by institutional practices that crush the mind and spirit through impenetrable seclusion, secrecy and physical coercion. Many Victorian cloister narratives marry the claustrophobic convent space of Gothic writing to the lurid plotting of the fictionalized convent memoir, popularized in the eighteenth century by such novels as Diderot’s La Religieuse (The Nun) (1796). The convent exposé provides a repertoire of sensational events and behaviour that become commonplaces of Victorian cloister rhetoric, peppering polemical tracts as well as fiction and poetry. As a purported autobiography, the genre asserts an ‘eyewitness’ level of veracity in its accounts of the most intimate activities of nuns and priests – all crime, sex, violence and depravity. The plot of these voyeuristic shockers involves an exciting mix of seduction (into the convent), betrayal (of idealized hopes), escape (from the clutches of sexual perversity and torture), and dangerous revelation (of Catholic corruption via the memoir). Bizarre penances and humiliations, the debauching of novices, murder and infanticide, torture and solitary confinement are painstakingly itemized by a lucky narrator who has fled the convent and become an enlightened Protestant. The Awful Disclosures of The Hotel Dieu Nunnery of Montreal (1836), more popularly known as the Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, is the prototype of Victorian convent ‘memoirs’. Purporting to be the personal testimony of a nun’s experiences in a Canadian convent (though the book was actually written by a Protestant American clergyman), Maria Monk was an immediate bestseller in America and England and remained a prominent cultural referent throughout the period.28 Sensationalism is the dominant mode of the Victorian cloister exposé, and its thematics and register are apparent in writing for different class and denominational readerships. A popular topic of the penny press, convent scandals featured in alarmist denominational pamphlets emanating from
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 84
15/3/07 17:09:31
sensations of the cloister
85
both sides of the Atlantic. The Protestant-inflected American booklet, The Thrilling Mysteries of a Convent Revealed!, was equally matched in voyeuristic detail and shocking suggestiveness by anonymous British tracts, such as the Celibacy of Priests, Monks and Nuns and The Horrors of Roman Catholic Convents, Exposed in a True Heartrending Account of the Shocking Imprisonment & Sufferings of Sister Barbara, a Polish Carmelite Nun, who was walled up alive for twenty-one years in the cold dark cell of an infected Underground Dungeon! With an awful Description of her horrible condition when she was first discovered in her dismal, loathsome Den, and the fiendish treatment inflicted upon her by inhuman Priests, Lady Superioresses and Nuns, who styled themselves ‘Spiritual Wives’, and the ‘Brides of Heaven!’ 29 Catholic tracts offered equally hyperbolic rebuttals to set the record straight, such as Herbert Thurston’s ‘The Myth of the Walled-up Nun’ (1894), which responded directly, if belatedly, to the claims in Maria Monk. Romanticized fiction for a more sophisticated readership also adapted the cloister pattern of scandals revealed. Rebecca Reed’s Six Months in a Convent (1835), a ‘memoir’ contemporaneous with Maria Monk, details the boredom as well as the humiliations of convent life. Later cloister narratives, including Harriet Martineau’s ‘Sister Anna’s Probation’ (1862), Eliza Richardson’s The Veil Lifted: or, The Romance and Reality of Convent Life (1865), Julia McNair Wright’s Almost a Nun (1868), and Augusta Webster’s extended dramatic monologue, ‘Sister Annunciata’ (1866), focus on the psychological damage done to the female subject by the repression of the cloistered life. Even popular genres, like the mystery story and the ghost tale, exploit the uncanny potential of convent seclusion and secrecy.30 Whether suffering is physical, emotional or mental, these texts reproduce the plot of kidnap or seduction, debauchery, torture and escape as the authentic narrative of ‘unnatural nunnery practices’ in ways that outrage and titillate.31 In these sensational fictions, the pressure to deny individual needs and conform to the standards of the community is read as a degrading despotism. Paradoxically, in the convent exposé, the humble obedience and strict discipline encouraged in Victorian family and civic life legitimizes criminal strategies of control and repression. In Villette, Charlotte Brontë adapts the scandalous convent exposé of confinement and escape to explore the boundaries which normally demarcate Victorian constructions of gender and social relations. On the face of it, one might expect her to take up a traditional anti-cloister stance, rejecting the life of female separation and seclusion as a tyrannical imposition from Rome. In Brontë’s privately expressed views, she was certainly anti-Catholic. The familiar language of vehement Protestant polemics can be tracked in her
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 85
15/3/07 17:09:31
86 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 32
personal comments on the Church of Rome. In an 1842 letter, for example, she dismisses ‘Papistry’ as an infantilizing ‘feeble childish piece of humbug’ and ‘all the priests’ as ‘idiotic’ and ‘mercenary’.33 Her account of Cardinal Wiseman preaching in 1851 focuses on grotesque physicality to suggest spiritual corruption. Her caricatured description of his size and deportment implies unholy greed, sensuality, pride and fanaticism: He is a big portly man. … He has not merely a double but a treble and quadruple chin; he has a very large mouth with oily lips, and looks as if he would relish a good dinner with a bottle of wine after it. He came swimming into the room smiling, simpering, and bowing like a fat old lady, and sat down very demure in his chair, and looked the picture of a sleek hypocrite. … A bevy of inferior priests surrounded him, many of them very dark-looking and sinister men. The Cardinal spoke in a smooth whining manner, just like a canting Methodist preacher. The audience looked up to him as to a god. A spirit of the hottest zeal pervaded the 34 whole meeting.
Such hyperbolic contempt has been read by some, including Elizabeth Gaskell, as Brontë’s over-compensation for her own susceptibility to the imaginative attractions of Catholicism.35 And scholars have located the same hostility in Brontë’s fiction.36 Certainly, many narrative elements stress the emotional seductiveness of this foreign faith. For example, Lucy Snowe, the narrator of Villette, is sensitive to the bait of the ‘honied voice’, the ‘unction and balm’ of the Catholic tract passed to her by Paul.37 As one accustomed to police and repress her emotional needs, Lucy is particularly attuned to the lure of Catholicism for the lonely but noble spirit because ‘it sought to win the affectionate through their affections, the sympathizing through their sympathies’ (507). For female critics in particular, Catholicism in Brontë’s work also symbolizes a patriarchal culture of ‘male injustice’ demanding ‘the subjection of the self to a male authority’.38 In The Professor (1857), the Catholic schoolgirl Sylvie, destined for the convent, seems to have internalised her female victimhood at the hands of the patriarchal Church. She already typifies the disconsolate automatons to be found in the debunked religious communities of the convent exposé: weak health stunted her growth and chilled her spirits, and then, destined as she was for the cloister, her whole soul was warped to a conventual bias, and in the tame, trained subjection of her manner, one read that she had already prepared herself for her future course of life, by giving up her independence of thought and action into the hands of some despotic confessor. She permitted herself no original opinion, no preference of companion or employment; in everything she
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 86
15/3/07 17:09:31
sensations of the cloister
87
was guided by another. With a pale, passive, automaton air, she went about all 39 day long doing what she was bid …
Similarly, in Villette there are explicit denunciations of the ‘tyrant [Roman] “Church’ that insists on ‘servitude’ (514) and renunciation to further its ‘all-dominating eminence’ (515). For its ends, ‘women [are] most murderously sacrificed’ (515). The point is made visually in the same novel with the portrait of the nun, Justine Marie. To Lucy, the woman has been stripped of personality and energy through obedience to some overpowering force. The chaste creature, supposedly disappointed in love, seems enervated and crushed with her ‘weak frame, inactive passions, acquiescent habits’ (484). For these reasons, the Catholic dimension of Lucy Snowe’s experiences at Madame Beck’s school, which occupies the site of a former convent, is usually read as a traditional Protestant attack on the tyranny and seduction of popery with its ‘external authority and romantic spells’.40 But this is a limited view. Other comments in Brontë’s fiction and private correspondence gender Catholicism more ambivalently. Rather than treating it consistently as an extreme illustration of traditional male-authorized gender models (against which her female characters might rebel), Brontë at times links Rome to gender transgression. Sometimes, it is simply a snide way of further undermining celebrity Catholics. In her 1851 description of Wiseman’s sermon, for example, the Cardinal appears as the antithesis of conventional masculinity. A fussy, complacent ‘fat old lady’ surrounded by attentive and ‘sinister’ young male acolytes, he is sensationalized as sexually bizarre, if not perverse. More gender heresy is apparent in the Catholic world of The Professor. Here the criticism has an ambiguous effect, at least from a female perspective, since it aligns Catholicism with confident, feisty women. The (male) narrator castigates the discipline and doctrines of Rome for inculcating independent, impudent boldness in his female pupils. He dislikes their flirtatious ‘precocious impurity’, so inappropriate for girls who ‘belonged to what are called the respectable ranks of society’ (93). Indeed, he deems them ‘mentally depraved’ because they lack an air of graceful submission to the male gaze: ‘scarcely one of those girls having attained the age of fourteen could look a man in the face with modesty and propriety’ (93–94). Brontë’s Catholic sensationalism in Villette gives the novel a similarly unorthodox edge. Of course, critical attention has been given to Gothic remains that haunt the text, some associated with the cloistered space. Their traces create a narrative that is simultaneously realist and fantastic, both heimlich and unheimlich.41 Feminist critics have typically read the novel’s uncanny elements as signs of repression. Doubles (like Lucy and the ghostly
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 87
15/3/07 17:09:31
88 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature Nun), imagery of live burial and stirring corpses, coincidental meetings and ‘familiar’ strangers as well as a heightened sense of dreamlike confusion seem to arise from Lucy’s denial and displacement of her feelings; and, as Mary Jacobus has suggested, they express Brontë’s own sense of ‘the strangeness and arbitrariness of inner experience’ and the ‘incompatibility of the world of thought and the world of reality’.42 Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick similarly connects these phenomena to ‘uncertainty about where to place the perimeters of the self ’ or even how to represent the unspeakable reality of individual consciousness.43 However, reading Villette alongside other examples of Victorian ‘nunnery’ sensations gives a new insight into the novel as an uncanny fiction. Brontë’s use of the contemporary cloister exposé renders Catholicism itself uncannily double. Both mirror and other, its transgressive potential accommodates models of female subjectivity previously hidden or repressed. Rather than expressing indeterminacy and evasion, Brontë’s cloister adaptations critique orthodox concepts of gender difference in a way that activists like Anna Jameson would recognize. Indeed, Brontë’s case for female autonomy in psychological, social and artistic terms draws extensively on the central motifs of the cloister plot: the claustrophobic convent space, concealment and enigmatic events, cruel physical punishment and sinister surveillance. Victorian depictions of the Catholic convent enclosure characterize it as a place of incarceration, suffering and outrage, although it is not always clear whether the nun should be viewed as casualty or transgressor in this context. In Victorian popular culture, notions of cloister imprisonment are combined with suggestions of unhealthy desires. An advertisement for The Phantom Railway entices readers with the promise of ‘a capital illustration of a Nun in Chains’,44 an image that titillates through promises of illicit religion and bondage, and thus constructs woman both as victimized and depraved. In polemical writing, representations of the cloister space are scarcely less extreme. M. Hobart Seymour’s comparison of the Continental convent and the British prison suggests both are sites of oppressive control: ‘the same lofty walls, the same massive gates, the same barred windows, and the same grated openings; the same dull, sombre, cheerless aspect; the same uninviting, repelling, lifeless exterior; the same inaccessibility from without, the same precluded possibility of escape from within’.45 Seymour’s analogy sensationalizes the cloister as a threat because it separates women from the normal business of the home. This is like Rebecca Reed’s language in Six Months in a Convent; she claims that a Catholic nun is subject to ‘involuntary confinement for life, with no power to resist’.46
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 88
15/3/07 17:09:31
sensations of the cloister
89
While such imagery portrays the nun as an object of pity, it also serves more subtly to abject the whole religious community. By reason of their vows, the nuns have become pseudo-criminals without rights or identities to be acknowledged. They have forfeited their claim to respect by rejecting their domestic responsibilities and by surrendering their personal development to the control of dubious authoritarian figures. This paradoxical representation of nuns as both innocent and culpable is widespread in literary work of the period. Harriet Martineau, for example, uses her novella about a Catholic novice at the time of the English Reformation to discuss a woman’s right to access all domains of knowledge, including the political and theological. While the heroine is portrayed as a sympathetic, misguided victim, ‘Sister Anna’s Probation’ suggests nuns are guilty women for perpetuating female ignorance of public life in their convent world of high walls, ‘bolts and bars’.47 In Villette, Brontë ironically exploits such ambiguities, characterizing her cloistered Lucy Snowe as both victim of oppression and transgressor against supposedly normal models of femininity. By overtly aligning tyranny and repression with Catholic foreign principles, Brontë initially allows the reader to assume that freedom and independence lie with Protestant British culture. However, as critics like Rosemary Clark-Beattie suggest, English values inscribe a secular model of feminine selfhood that oppresses Lucy and ‘obliterates [her] from view’.48 Reading the novel in the light of the popular Victorian cloister exposé clarifies Brontë’s criticism of home culture. The enclosed religious environment damages when it replicates the ideology of a separate sphere (religious or secular) that limits and controls a woman’s independence. Even more unexpectedly, Villette capitalizes subversively on sensational associations of the convent space with transgression. In the novel, the handling of the ‘heretical’ convent demonstrates how the hidden single life can challenge gender expectations and express rebellion and resistance. In Brontë’s rewriting of the convent memoir, the cloister offers a chance to recast conventional destinies for women in the world beyond the enclosure. Madame Beck’s school for girls in Rue Fossette occupies grounds which were once reputedly those of a cloister; and, throughout the novel, Lucy Snowe refers to her environment as ‘our convent’ (175). Descriptions of the physical space of this ‘socializing’ educational institution echo the usual Victorian portrayal of the claustrophobic restriction of Catholic religious enclosures. As such, they suggest how the ‘finishing’ of young ladies for the marriage market has a depressing and deadening effect – at least in the eyes of the narrator. The school building, like any cloister in the popular
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 89
15/3/07 17:09:32
90 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature anti-Catholic literature of the day, seems imposing. The chapel is ‘long, low, gloomy’ (130); the dormitory – once nuns’ cells – is a foreign, queer space. The ‘conventual Rue Fossette’ (550) is strictly isolated in practice from the rest of the town with its promise of urban pleasures and freedom. School routine, like convent discipline, is characterized as ‘spiritual restraint’ with minds ‘reared in slavery’, the ‘chains [hidden] with flowers’ (195). Brontë uses the familiar rhetoric of convent imprisonment to emphasize the psychological pressures upon individuals in this cultural environment, too. Paul Emanuel, with his self-confessedly ‘monkish’ habits, describes himself as a ‘fettered’ man weighed down by family responsibility, religious conviction and conscientiousness (498, 500). Lucy’s loneliness is compared both to ‘conventual silence and stagnation’ and to ‘solitary confinement’ (265, 259). Her hopeless yearning for Dr John is likened to the emotional deprivation of a contemplative hermit in his cell. The school back garden is also a sign of poignant female isolation and living entombment, echoing popular Victorian readings of a convent’s walled enclosure. Designated a sacred female space (it is ‘sacrilege’ for men to be there after dark), it is neglected, overgrown and gloomy. This is a claustrophobic site, bordered by impersonal ‘windowless backs of houses’ (174) and forming a boundary beyond which the pupils are forbidden to go. Nonetheless, space can also be a site for creative thought and the display of interiority.49 By inflecting descriptions of the garden with other aspects of Victorian cloister discourse, Brontë creates a new vision of the potentiality of female separateness. Instead of seeing the garden as a sad reminder of a family world forsaken, of nature renounced or constrained, Lucy discovers in it a sign of her own characteristic individuality. Its seclusion speaks sympathetically to her sense of distinctiveness, ‘to such shades of peculiarity as were engrained in my nature’ (174). Rather than restricting her, the garden provides an outlet for action and creativity. Like other Victorian women attracted to a concept of sisterhood which redefines women’s capability, Lucy finds in her garden a chance for meaningful work. She is not a prisoner (demonstrating feminine compliance) but an organizer and cultivator (evidencing masculine energies and control). She assumes responsibility and directs herself in this task: ‘I made myself gardener’ (174). She expunges tradition, clearing ‘away the relics of past autumns’ (174); she appropriates a hidden rustic seat from which she can survey, know and control her territory. Imprisoning convent enclosures can debilitate if they mean isolation from purpose and activity. But, for some Victorian women, entrance into sisterhoods can also provide liberating opportunities for self-development and action. These multiple significations
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 90
15/3/07 17:09:32
sensations of the cloister
91
of the cloistered environment underpin and enrich the novel’s portrayal of female subjecthood. The convent setting of Madame Beck’s school takes up the familiar Protestant view of Catholic oppressiveness in new ways. It parallels the despotic Catholic control of the individual to the social shaping of young women for good marriages and respectable domesticity. As a place of unorthodox female separateness, the cloister environment of the novel also associates Lucy with the idea of an untraditional female life, one with radical potential for independence and agency. Many Victorian representations of the cloister gender it feminine in ways that correspond to patriarchal idealizations of woman’s separate sphere. It is domestic and familial (with ‘sisters’, ‘brothers’, Mother Superior, Father confessor). It is carefully protected from the worldly and competitive realm of masculine endeavour. In this place of piety and feeling, inhabitants are sexually chaste and innocent. Despite these attributes of female respectability, the convent in sensational writing of the period is re-imagined as an unnatural domain, all lack, absence and incompleteness. Portrayals of convent ‘abnormality’ expose a tension in Victorian responses to women’s erotic feelings and function. While sexual innocence is a required trait of respectable womanhood, so is sexual experience, provided it is channelled to childbearing in marriage. In his Daily Telegraph articles on London religious life, for example, C. Maurice Davies’s description of a nun’s profession of her vows highlights her violation of ‘natural’ expectations: ‘[t]here is to the ordinary secular mind something abhorrent in the idea of a young girl thus girding herself about “with narrowing nunnery walls;” and it may well be doubted whether the mind of England be not too large imbued with Protestantism ever to outgrow its objection in so far as the contemplative orders are concerned’.50 This critique, with its image of the woman’s physical body literally fortified and protected from penetration by convent walls, associates the imprisoning convent with a woman’s failure to realize her sexual potential (and civic duty) in marriage and reproduction. For Davies, ‘wifely, motherly work’ is woman’s God-given destiny.51 Nor is this a view expressed solely by Victorian men. In Almost a Nun, Julia McNair Wright also constructs the secluded feminine space of the cloister as unhealthy because it separates a woman from her capacities to flower, that is, to reproduce. Her morbid Sister Agnes is like a delicate greenhouse plant that becomes sickly and stunted when deprived of masculine support and the framework of motherhood: Sister Agnes was one of those clinging, faithful, true woman natures that are no more made for a life of seclusion and heart repression than is the fair, fragile
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 91
15/3/07 17:09:32
92 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature cypress vine to hold itself upright unaided amid sun and storm. In the gloom and chill of the cloister, this life, that might have borne rich and beauteous flower and fruit, faded away, a stinted, bleached and sickly thing, even in its utter loss and 52 desolation revealing what it might have been.
This image of the nun as a drooping, unsupported vine naturalizes the notion of a woman’s dependence on men. Wright’s extravagant language of melancholia, mental pathology and fanatical rigidity also suggests that women swing to extremes without the steadying and corrective influence of masculine leadership to teach self-control. Some of the nuns become shallow and mindless, ‘[w]ire-worked automata, puppets galvanized into motion’ (257). Others tyrannize under the hypocritical guise of female solidarity: ‘[v]igilant guardians, careful jailors, indeed, were the sisters’ (287). Such depictions of the convent as a claustrophobic prison inscribe dominant nineteenth-century ideologies of femininity in which a woman’s identity is best developed through the controlled framework of marriage and maternity. It is precisely this position that Brontë challenges in Villette by a neat transfer of a secluded nun’s abnormalities to the qualities of respectable femininity. In Brontë’s narrative, character distortion and weakness, repression and submission, normally the prerogative of morbid Catholic nuns, are associated with the representatives of conventional womanhood and marriage. When Paul directs Lucy’s attention to a series of paintings idealizing ‘La vie d’une femme’, Lucy responds with disgust, reading maternity as monstrosity in the portrait of the young mother, ‘hanging disconsolate over a clayey and puff y baby with a face like an unwholesome moon’ (277). Lucy castigates these women without substance in language usually reserved for the spectres of immured nuns; they are ‘cold and vapid as ghosts … bloodless, brainless nonentities’ (278). Doubling nun and the Victorian angel in the house, Brontë resists the usual equation of gender stereotypes with the individual female subject. The beautiful Polly, who makes the most respectable marriage in the novel, is also described in terms usually applied to the deranged unhappy nuns of many convent tales and pamphlets. She is like ‘some precocious fanatic or untimely saint’, a Catholic ‘enthusiast’ (69) with a monomaniacal desire for the unattainable male (in her case no Heavenly Bridegroom but her absent father or the teenaged John Bretton). For Lucy this is a lack borne of an unhealthy determination to possess through dependence. As a child, Polly is both tyrant and slave. She lies down at John’s feet like a dog. She tries to monopolize his attention. Her pleasure is totally relational, defined by
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 92
15/3/07 17:09:32
sensations of the cloister
93
his desire. When Polly grows into a well-bred young woman, she displays the same tendencies, though with greater finesse and decorum. She has no personality of her own except in relation to others: ‘She had different moods for different people. With her father she really was still a child or child-like … With Mrs. Bretton she was docile and reliant … With Graham she was shy’ (384). Polly’s deepest wish is egotistical – to be loved, rather than to love. But she fulfils her desire through subordinating, even annihilating, her uniqueness so that it is absorbed by the personality of her husband. In her idealized courtship and marriage, Polly replicates the dependency of nuns like Wright’s morbid Sister Agnes. Polly even sees herself as a delicate plant which needs ‘sun, due moisture, and safe protection, sheltered, fostered, taught, by my dear father; and now – now – another comes’ (466). Juxtaposed with this image, the convent-school garden of the novel, Lucy’s natural milieu, has more promising potential for self-development. Here the narrator is figuratively in control as cultivator, not dependent specimen. Throughout the novel, Brontë subverts the separate sphere model of gender relations by showing how traditional configurations of domesticity and marriage stifle self-assertion and self-expression. Nun-like seclusion forms an important part of this strategy as an alternate model for an independent woman. The women Lucy most admires are single, the widowed, financially acute and competent Mrs Bretton, and, even more significantly, the disabled Miss Marchmont, who lives a reclusive and celibate existence like a nun. She is a secular example of notorious convent asceticism in her physical and emotional deprivation, yet Lucy responds to her as daughter to mother. While this has been read as a sign of the narrator’s attraction to the inertia of quiescence and conformity,53 such a view takes insufficient account of the narrator’s description of her employer. Lucy is fascinated by the way in which Miss Marchmont’s interior strength and grandeur of personality belie her isolation and restricted material circumstances. Her delight is not only in Miss Marchmont’s affection but also in her independence, integrity and individualism. Despite her cloistered seclusion, she dramatizes what Rick Rylance has termed ‘the power and authority of exceptionality’.54 She becomes Lucy’s most trusted model for study and emulation in ‘the originality of her character’, ‘the steadiness of her virtues’, ‘the power of her passions’, ‘the truth of her feelings’ (97). In her sternness, fierce logic and attentive correction without humiliation, she prefigures Paul; and, in her stoic self-reliance, she is a shadowy anticipation of the mature narrator at the end of the novel. Brontë’s narrator also invests convent tropes and allusions with a sardonic wit, suggesting the benefits of inhabiting an outsider’s domain. It is not
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 93
15/3/07 17:09:32
94 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature surprising that Lucy foresees for herself only two possible destinies after her breakdown, both in their own way transgressive: as author of the ‘heretic narrative’ which becomes Villette, or as contemplative nun ‘counting my beads in the cell of a certain Carmelite convent’ (235). While these alternatives represent opposing denominational choices, they also signify two sides of the same coin of unconventional femininity for a Victorian readership. Lucy’s spiritual and intellectual inheritance lies with English Protestantism and middle-class beliefs. However, she asserts her right to a more untraditional life – not entrance to a sisterhood, but an equally rebellious future as an independent woman with the imaginative power to construct and reveal her identity in its telling. Indeed, the novel continuously exploits cloister allusions to foreground the potential of the single life for the (heretical) development and protection of female autonomy, and as an escape from imposed and limiting gender identities. By positioning her engaging and complex heroine in the heterodox, ‘foreign’ environment of the Catholic pseudo-convent, Brontë adopts a radical subject position from which to assess the roles and behaviours normally proposed for women. Her heroine is triply displaced and outcast – as Protestant in a Catholic culture, as English person in a foreign place, and as single woman in an environment where marriage is seen as the only natural female role. The separation of demi-convent seclusion helps her to interrogate the secular ideologies and practices of British culture that deform and stifle the female character and to propose unorthodox alternatives. Brontë adapts other dimensions of the popular cloister exposé with similar effects. The nineteenth-century fascination with the convent’s ‘secrecy, and mystery and concealment’55 shows how sensational Gothic plots of Catholic oppression are modulated to a domestic pitch in Victorian sensationalism. In popular stories about convents, the innocent Catholic novice is seduced and then controlled by the unknown and the enigmatic. Reserve and stealth are tools of physical and psychological control in these places. M. Hobart Seymour’s punning reference to the convent’s ‘veil of impenetrable mystery’56 locates tyranny even in the physical layout of the cloister space, for it obliterates the identity of individuals and hides violent persecution. Grates obscure nuns’ faces and voices; cellars and secret rooms stifle the sounds of immoral and criminal activities, ‘the groan of the persecuted victim, or the shriek of outraged purity’.57 In The Veil Lifted, Eliza Richardson uses lurid metaphors of physical brutality to express the psychological oppression of convent life, again insisting that the worst horrors are hidden. In the cloister, sensuous ritual and theatrical pomp disguise a perverse system that works
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 94
15/3/07 17:09:33
sensations of the cloister
95
upon the individual to ‘crush’ and ‘extinguish’ natural feelings and stimulate a masochistic devotion to ‘self-crucifixion’.58 Accounts of the convent space in the Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk use narrative style to enact the oppressive effects of concealment and mystery. The narrator’s detailed description of the convent interior confusingly mingles the mundane – ‘[a] large community-room, with plain benches fixed against the wall to sit’ – with the violent and horrific – ‘the next [room] is a small sitting-room, where a priest waits to baptize the infants previous to their murder’.59 Maria Monk’s simple, non-evaluative prose style suggests both the dispassionate objectivity of a good eyewitness and the emotional numbness of a vulnerable woman crushed by convent austerity, discipline and persecution. Even her detailed room-by-room description of the convent fails to give a sense of interpretive control that should come with the mapping of a secret place. Monk apologizes in advance for the inaccuracy of her account; some apartments were never seen, and the overall structure is confusing and disorienting because ‘the apartments and passages of that spacious building are numerous and various’ (50). Befuddlement is a common feature of the sensationalized convent exposé. The innocent novice cannot understand what is happening. Nuns are disoriented and then regimented into submission by carrying out orders or following rituals not fully comprehended. Even prayers seem confusing due to the use of Latin, a language Maria Monk, for example, admits, ‘I never understood a word of ’ (43). Enforced practice without understanding and enforced speech without meaning reduce a sense of personal judgement and authority. As Susan M. Griffin has suggested, the labyrinthine maze of Monk’s convent and her own confusion about it creates a ‘narrative mise en abyme, enmeshed in the density, intricacy and pervasiveness of popery’s plots’.60 In Villette, Brontë capitalizes on the reader’s association of the Catholic convent with mystery and obscurity to suggest the psychological alienation of her heroine in the modern world of male-female desire, pursuit and courtship. Initially, the standard Gothic theatrics of inexplicable and sinister events, like the appearance of the ghostly Nun or the removal and replacement of personal letters and effects, indicate Lucy’s general estrangement. Like Maria Monk and other victimized novices, she struggles to make sense of secrets beyond her understanding or control in this foreign environment with its incomprehensible language and strange religious customs. But Brontë also extends the enigmatic cloister image, transferring the reader’s expectation of confusing secret passages and rooms to the shadowy hidden depths of the psyche with its occluded motivations and unconscious desires.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 95
15/3/07 17:09:33
96 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature Lucy soon masters the language and absents herself from Catholic religious observance. But the real foreign space is other people, who are glimpsed only partially, if at all, by obscure tracks and traces, the sound of a footstep, a fluttering handkerchief, the scent of a cigar, a low murmur, a ‘shaken branch’ (182). Dr John, for example, remains for much of the novel, beyond ‘the compass of [Lucy’s] penetration’ (167). Madame Beck is more obviously duplicitous, hiding a hard, grim and ruthless determination under ‘a goodhumoured, easy grace’ (165–66) and a talent for casuistry. It is not until the concluding section of the narrative that Lucy understands her as a bitter rival for the hand of Paul. Most telling of all, Lucy herself emerges as a mysterious ghostly presence haunting the cloister of her own narrative and misread by most. She often describes herself as a shade, invisible to those around her. Others’ responses seem to confirm her assessment by allowing her no more individuality than might attend to a veiled nun. Dr John praises her as a meek creature, ‘inoffensive as a shadow’ (403); and, on another occasion in the garden, he irritably observes that ‘nobody will take notice of you: I should be seen’ (191). It is not until her flight and testimony that the oppressed nun of the Victorian convent exposé can shed light on the infantile or immoral practices concealed within the convent. Villette is Lucy’s enlightened testimony. She plays the role of the escaped nun by exposing hidden motivations and desires buried in the life of the demi-convent and by rejecting falsity for truth. Her narrative authority over secrets is often demonstrated, as in her eventual revelation of the ghostly tricks of de Hamal. Cynically using the disguise of piety (a nun’s habit), he turns the convent space into a place of seduction and sensuality in his pursuit of Ginevra. Lucy’s angry destruction of the costume is an act that signifies her rejection of false roles and convenient masks as much as her frustrated outburst from self-repression. Similarly, like the enlightened nun of the shocking cloister memoir who reveals the emptiness of Catholic faith, Lucy discloses the false creed of Dr John. In his case, secular beliefs take the place of Catholicism as the basis of superstitious devotion. He is misled by materialism, class prejudice and assumptions of male superiority and, as a consequence, misvalues female worth. As the narrator cynically surmises, Dr John’s economy of love is all economics: ‘[h]ad Lucy been intrinsically the same, but possessing the additional advantages of wealth and station, would your manner to her, your value for her have been quite what they actually were? … he was not the man who, in appreciating the gem, could forget its setting’ (401, 459). In her handling of this first-person revelation, Brontë further adapts the
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 96
15/3/07 17:09:33
sensations of the cloister
97
methodology and motifs of the sensational convent narrative to establish the rebellious and anti-conventional credentials of her heroine. Ironically, Lucy’s power as narrator ultimately demonstrates her authoritarian tyranny over the reader. In constructing a version of herself for public consumption, she proceeds like a despotic Abbess, employing techniques that disorient the reader by confusion and concealment. For example, she withholds key pieces of information, such as the family identity of Dr John or the intended recipient of her embroidered watchguard. In the context of the Victorian convent sensation, where blockage on the transparent exchange of information by a Mother Superior demonstrates Catholic tyranny, this narrative device for suspense takes on a new resonance. It establishes Brontë’s sensitivity to the problems of aesthetic representation, illustrating its incompleteness in scoping the complexity of a woman’s heart. It shows her understanding that the female subject can never be judged by appearances alone, but instead requires protection from a prying world that would intrude in order to control. Lucy’s narrative manipulation demonstrates a belief in her entitlement to the privacy essential to self-respect and dignity: The longer we live, the more our experience widens; the less prone are we to judge our neighbour’s conduct, to question the world’s wisdom: wherever an accumulation of small defences is found, whether surrounding the prude’s virtue or the man of the world’s respectability, there, be sure, it is needed. (395)
Finally, in a novel that critiques the subjection of individuals to imposed gender roles, this technique challenges traditional assumptions about the author’s own need to be subservient to established literary conventions. Lucy’s teasing command over narrative revelation resists the reader’s expectations of a comforting clarity. It prevents easy judgements about character behaviour and motivation that function in their own right as a kind of social control and gender inscription. Brontë also revises other motifs of Victorian cloister narratives that focus on the curtailment and repression of the individual. In the convent exposé, austere bodily restrictions and cruel punishments typify popery’s persecuting despotism. Maria Monk’s Awful Disclosures, for example, catalogues many kinds of abuse. Nuns are routinely starved, bound, gagged, hung upside down from the ceiling, forced to wear a poisoned cap that causes convulsions, condemned to solitary confinement, crushed to death between beds. But more generally, the language of physical torture and entombment is used metaphorically to suggest the living death of convent inhabitants and the ways in which extreme repression buries or ‘immures’ the self. For example,
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 97
15/3/07 17:09:33
98 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature Harriet Martineau uses imagery of self-entombment in ‘Sister Anna’s Probation’ to suggest the unnatural Catholic emphasis on subjugation of the flesh in order to perfect the spirit. After her profession, the heroine feels chilled, as if she ‘had indeed done with life’; her guilty longing to rebel and escape fills her with an annihilating ‘passion of self abasement’ (370). In Almost a Nun, Julia Wright likens the spiritual bondage of nineteenth-century Catholic nuns to ‘those who have been sealed up living in walls’ (293). Brontë uses exactly the same tropes to explore Lucy’s self-censorship in response to the restrictions imposed on her by social status and gender. The Rue Fossette school is reputedly haunted by the spectre of a Nun ‘buried alive, for some sin against her vow’ (172). Lucy sees this apparition at moments of emotional intensity, and the many references to her ‘buried life’ link her by analogy to the ghost. It is a connection that expresses the maiming effects of Victorian middle-class insistence on self-discipline, especially for women. Sally Shuttleworth has argued that Brontë’s Nun is one of a number of links in the novel between the practices of Catholicism and the Victorian psychiatric theories of mental alienation and moral management. The ability to exercise self-control was an important way in which Victorian medicine differentiated between the healthy and the neurotic, the sane and the lunatic, the mature matron and the hysterical girl. For Shuttleworth, images of oppressive popery in Villette signify the cruel tyranny of institutional authority, be that the regime of the asylum or the operations of the patriarchy on female sexuality. Loathing the aim of both Catholic Church and scientist to exercise ‘total dominion over the mind’, Lucy chooses instead to internalize social controls and regulate herself.61 But this is no solution. Lucy’s morbid dread of seeming too nervy and passionate shows the extent to which she unconsciously shares the cultural assumption that the construction of insanity ‘went hand in hand with that of femininity’.62 Her connection with a woman who has sinned against the regulations of her community suggests her guilty uneasiness, as if she too might expect punishment, as if her ‘mad’ desire for freedom and self-expression has offended the rules of her culture and exceeded what is permitted a ‘redundant’ Victorian spinster. Lucy’s cool remoteness can be seen as a disquieting – and not wholly effective – attempt at damage limitation. She escapes the censorious disapproval of others by overcompensation, brutally immuring her true feelings in response to limited secular possibilities: ‘I had feelings: passive as I lived, little as I spoke, cold as I looked, when I thought of past days, I could feel. About the present, it was better to be stoical: about the future – such a future as mine – to be dead’ (175). This excess of self-veiling, a grim parody of female
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 98
15/3/07 17:09:33
sensations of the cloister
99
reticence and demureness, undoubtedly causes further emotional damage. She is deeply depressed by her ‘despairing resignation’ (228), although she rationalizes it as a sensible response to limited emotional and economic opportunities, as important a competence as frugality. In fact, this masochistic restraint is as much a technique of psychological protection as a social necessity. Lucy repeatedly refuses to risk hope and connection, lest she expose her vulnerable need for affection: ‘no sooner did opportunity suddenly and fully arrive, than I evaded it, as I would have evaded the levelled shaft of mortality’ (477). Brontë evokes sympathy for these sexual and emotional inhibitions by drawing on contemporary scandals about convent frigidity, perversion and self-abuse. Lucy’s behaviour as a respectable unmarried woman who must deny sexual longing is likened to the abnormal mortifications of the Catholic cloister. Like the sad, wasted nun in many cloister exposés, she is tormented by unrequited love. The unhealthy nature of this self-repression is intimated by her burial of Dr John‘s letters. Gradually, the sexual desire and rejection she reads into these textual fragments are displaced onto morbid fantasies of corpses stirring in the grave: ‘[s]ometimes I thought the tomb unquiet, and dreamed strangely of disturbed earth, and of hair, still golden and living, obtruded through coffin-chinks’ (451). Sexual repression is further enmeshed in Catholic sensationalism through the tropes of physical mutilation that Lucy uses to express her desires and the need to crush them. While she delights in natural, stormy powers that carry her out of herself, she also punishes these cravings: too resistless was the delight of staying with the wild hour, black and full of thunder, pealing out such an ode as language never delivered to man – too terribly glorious, the spectacle of clouds, split and pierced by white and blinding bolts. I did long, achingly, then …This longing, and all of a similar kind, it was necessary to knock on the head … (176)
Lucy’s self-inflicted emotional asceticism, appropriate to a Victorian single woman, recalls the humiliating penances of the cloister tale – branding and whipping naked flesh, chewing glass to a fine powder, making the sign of the cross on the floor with the tongue – that simultaneously deny natural impulses, extinguish self-respect, and stimulate morbid self-consciousness. Other forces of social control that inhibit women in the novel are also inflected by sensational Victorian stories of the Catholic convent. In this discourse, the state and family spies of Gothic horrors are transformed into perverse religious chaperones who police the nuns at all times. Seymour, for example, highlights the many nooks, crannies and partitions which enable
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 99
15/3/07 17:09:34
100 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature ‘a watching nun’ to hide and thus ‘to observe and repeat’ private conversations.63 Maria Monk reports that a nun oversees the novices in their dormitory, adopting the secretive posture of a voyeur. Her partition contains ‘two holes, through which she could look out upon us whenever she pleased’ (21). Instead of exercising control as the perceiving subject with power to make sense of her world, the nun becomes the object of a sinister clerical gaze that distances her as Other and abjects her through humiliation. Such ocular supervision is matched by intrusion into the victim’s psyche through the practice of confession which reclassifies unauthorized thoughts and feelings as rebellious, disobedient and evil. In sensationalized versions of cloister experience, remorseless convent scrutiny inculcates a disposition of cowed obedience and self-doubt. For Eliza Richardson, the systematic, controlling invasion of personal space violates the essence of selfhood. The Veil Lifted charts how, in the convent, ‘every act and motion must be regulated only according to the will and pleasure of others … [the nun’s] very thoughts laid under interdict’ (28). Brontë takes up this motif, but is more ambivalent about the (im)propriety of reserve and surveillance. As in her adaptation of other elements of the Victorian cloister narrative, she embraces the familiar understanding of the convent space as a site of transgression – but to an unexpected end. Certainly, surveillance enables Madame Beck to tyrannize staff, subdue her students and keep tabs on her rival, Lucy. However, both Lucy and Paul exercise self-mastery and assert independence benignly through watching others. For Lucy, surveillance is most obviously a mechanism of self-defence. She persistently characterizes herself as one of life’s observers; fearing life’s uncertainties, she retreats from participation. Yet she also finds watching a source of power through knowledge and of pleasure through analysis and deduction. Lucy enjoys ‘examining, questioning, and forming conclusions’ (274). Unlike Madame Beck, she does not seek to suppress others through her secret discoveries. Instead, she pursues ‘a knowledge of my own’ (444) to develop personal, independent judgement; she gains the self-knowledge needed to face opponents on an equal footing. Her surveillance of Madame Beck’s surveillance gives her confidence to stand up to a petty tyrant: ‘she did not wear a woman’s aspect, but rather a man’s. Power of a particular kind strongly limned itself in all her traits, and that power was not my kind of power … I stood – not soothed, nor won, nor overwhelmed. It seemed as if a challenge of strength between opposing gifts was given’ (141). Madame Beck’s watchful authority is often gendered masculine in this way. It reminds a reader that her oversight of the female domain, like that
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 100
15/3/07 17:09:34
sensations of the cloister
101
of the most despotic Abbess of any convent tale, is patriarchal; it is more concerned with the restraint and control of women than with their protection. However, Lucy’s mastery through watching and understanding offers Brontë another model for authority. She reinscribes power, not as gendered, but in terms of the resisting, autonomous self, either male or female. When Lucy achieves great success in Paul’s play, she is dressed like a hermaphrodite – mixing her womanly garb with elements of a male costume. The fear she conquers in her hybrid performance is not that of social opinion; the crowd, she says, meant ‘nothing to me’ (209). Instead she learns not to fear ‘my own voice’ (209). She has power, not because she controls an audience or gains respectability by conforming to gender expectations. She gains strength because ‘I acted to please myself ’ (211). Paul is another careful watcher. He readily understands Lucy from the beginning, despite her habit of self-concealment: ‘he meant to see through me . . . a veil would be no veil for him’ (128). As a Catholic man and violator of the veil, Paul occupies a space normally held by the debauched convent confessor and spiritual director in narratives of cloistered tyranny and degradation. Indeed, by suggesting he invades Lucy’s innermost secret self – he ‘hungrily dived into me’ (201), Lucy observes – Brontë invites comparison between Paul and the smooth, grasping Père Silas. But careful distinctions are drawn between the intentions of the priest and those of the professor. Father Silas invades Lucy’s soul during her depressive breakdown. The confessional gives Lucy her first opportunity to voice that secret, tempestuous self which social roles and rhetoric officially silence. She initially finds comfort in ‘the mere pouring out of some portion of long accumulating, long pent-up pain into a vessel whence it could not be again diffused’ (234). However, she soon discovers that the priest neither respects her integrity nor values her individualism. The unctuous confessor watches and listens in order to subordinate Lucy, override her personal independence of mind, and convert her by appealing to her neediness. The relationship he tries to promote replicates that between Polly and Graham; it is a dynamic of possession through dependence and self-annihilation. When Lucy craves affection the priest offers compassion as a lure to intellectual and moral subjugation: ‘That priest had arms which could influence me; he was naturally kind, with a sentimental French kindness, to whose softness I knew myself not wholly impervious. … he would have shown me all that was tender, and comforting, and gentle, in the honest popish superstition’ (235). Alternatively Paul offers empathy and challenge, not calculating kindnesses. His connection with Lucy is based on an imaginative understanding
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 101
15/3/07 17:09:34
102 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature of her as a complete person with independence and autonomy, not an empty territory to be colonized. Like a discerning reader, he intuitively empathizes with her strengths, weaknesses and vulnerabilities; but he does not exploit such knowledge for purposes of judgement or possession. Rather, it enables him to appreciate and value Lucy’s distinctive separateness: he had the terrible unerring penetration of instinct, and pierced in its hidingplace the last lurking thought of the heart, and discerned under florid veilings the bare, barren places of the spirit: yes, and its perverted tendencies, and its hidden false curves. … No calamity so accursed but M. Emanuel could pity and forgive, if it were acknowledged candidly … (423–24)
Paul’s ultimate penetration of Lucy’s reserve becomes an oversight that is truly loving and protective of her individuality. ‘You need watching, and watching over,’ he assures Lucy (452). Here is possession based on a celebration of difference, not dependence. With his male energy and feminine tenderness, Paul, like Lucy in the play, exhibits a respect for personhood that moves beyond gendered dynamics of mastery and submission. He accepts and promotes Lucy as she is and as she desires to be, not as his Catholic and patriarchal culture would have her become. In the most sensational Victorian convent tales, the fortunate nuns are those who escape from victimization and slavery into the liberating enlightenment of Protestantism in the outside world. Brontë neatly echoes such a conclusion in the final stages of the courtship of Lucy and Paul to legitimize the radical notions of individualism the narrative promotes. Their relationship, with its promise of independent work in the public sphere, marks Lucy’s liberation from immurement in conventional gender roles and self-doubt. That it is a healthy escape, however it transgresses Victorian gender ideologies and the cult of the separate spheres, is triumphantly confirmed by Paul’s endorsement of her Protestantism. He does not just tolerate but appreciates this heretic faith because it is integral to Lucy: ‘I love Protestantism in you … it is the sole creed for “Lucy”’ (594–95). And he acknowledges the reciprocity of their partnership by retaining Catholicism as an essential element of his own free individualism. This is to be ‘honest … a freeman, and not a slave’ (595). Read in the context of sensational Victorian tales of the convent, Villette establishes the formation of female autonomy, not romance, as its strongest narrative line. Brontë writes both with and against the grain of cloister sensationalism to show how a Victorian woman might find redemption, not in a specific religious or social creed, but in belief in herself. She draws
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 102
15/3/07 17:09:34
sensations of the cloister
103
on an alternative Victorian version of convent life, the active sisterhood, to show how meaningful work provides escape for a woman from psychological and emotional restriction. Like Anna Jameson and Dinah Craik, Brontë suggests that ‘labour for independence’ (450) within a female community gives dignity, releases the imagination, and stimulates aspirations that Lucy can realize. As a teacher, Lucy is neither served nor subservient, but possesses the basis for realizing a selfhood constructed on her own terms. Establishing a school makes the most of her self-control and dignified reserve; it provides a vehicle for her intelligence and talents. The confidence she gains is essential to her relationship of mutual mastery with Paul and to her equanimity when that relationship is broken through death. Moreover, Brontë shows separation – the cloister-like seclusion from ‘natural’ female destiny – as central to the process of a woman’s growth. In a negative way, the petty authoritarian tyrannies and physical restrictions of the cloister, like Madame Beck’s school, reinforce the value of individualism by showing it threatened and at bay. However, this heretical, unconventional site also provides positive freedoms. Brontë rewrites the convent exposé to imagine radical female futures. Only here does Lucy begin to develop, freed from imposed gender and class expectations. To these she remains wholly opposed. If the demi-convent of Rue Fossette is outside Protestant denominational and British cultural boundaries, Lucy, by inhabiting a pseudocloister space, lies beyond the borderlines that define respectable femininity through marriage, money and social status. She learns to express a sense of self articulated solely in terms of resistance; as she says about Dr John: ‘He wanted always to give me a role not mine. Nature and I opposed him’ (404). Inhabiting this ‘other’ place becomes a symbol of vibrant female rebellion. Here, Lucy can, like the exponents of Victorian sisterhoods, define ‘other’ destinies, resisting cultural expectations, gaining confidence and competence, and entering the public domain as a purposeful individual to be respected. As Villette illustrates, Catholic sensationalism provides an uncanny counterpoint to Victorian arguments about the Woman Question. Functioning as Victorian culture’s mirror and contrast, fantasies of the convent are in ambivalent dialogue with contemporary models of female subjectivity, problematizing ideals of femininity and assessing alternative possibilities for women’s fulfilment. However, that is not the only intersection between Catholicism and debates about gendered social relations in the period. With its highly visible, authoritarian male hierarchy, the Church of Rome replicates the patriarchal structure of nineteenth-century middle-class society and the masculine voice of public culture. Representations of priestly
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 103
15/3/07 17:09:34
104 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature vice – like the scandals of the convent – perform a dual role, dramatizing the unacceptable, while suggesting uncomfortable parallels between Catholicism and Victorian social values and conduct. Robert Browning’s dramatic monologues featuring priests, monks and friars demonstrate how Catholic sensationalism operates as cultural critique. These poems recycle popular images of perverse Catholic masculinity and suggest that the same moral depravity and hypocrisy permeate Victorian public culture and secular institutions. In Browning’s work, priestly conduct mirrors a social world where propriety, respectability, and an eye to the main chance are cynically exploited to achieve domination. Many troublesome priests in the poems are isolated individuals, psychically disconnected, even absurd. The venal Catholic community represented by such men is a microcosm of any society where ideals of masculine chivalry and selfless duty have given way to the contradictory demands of competition and conformity. Overall, Browning’s representatives of the Catholic consecrated life dramatize a process of cultural deterioration and de-spiritualization. Specific references to Catholicism in Browning’s writings reveal some measure of broadmindedness, but generally scholars are agreed that he entertains a ‘bitter anti-Catholic prejudice’ directed especially at the Church’s ‘pride, corruption, casuistry, sensuality, and indifference to duty’.64 The poet’s extravagant depictions of the cloister or monastery as a hothouse of greed, hypocrisy and egotism are certainly much of a piece with the contemporary relish for details of priestly deviance.65 Victorian ‘No Popery’ journals piled on the epithets when denouncing Catholic clergy as lascivious sensualists or morbid fanatics: ‘There are two classes of Romish priest. … There is your sleek, oily, rollicking, leering, capon-lined emissary of Babylon, whose priestcraft is a mere trade; and there is your lean, intellectual, intense, credulous devotee.’66 The secular press was hardly less restrained. Middle-class newspapers as well as scandal sheets regularly reported legal cases involving nuns and priests in terms which took the immorality of Roman religious institutions for granted. Avarice was a popular subject dwelt on at length, with detailed reports of priests extorting money from sufferers on their deathbeds, from penitents in the confessional, and from heiresses forced into convents.67 Even more prominent was the interest in the sex lives of clergy and the association of the cloister with uncontrolled urges. Sensational discourse regularly linked lust and perversity to the Catholic priesthood, as is evident in W. A. Darby’s 1864 innuendo: ‘Why is a Convent of Monks always connected with a Nunnery and at no great distance from it?’68 Attacks on the Catholic priesthood proffered opportunities to revel in
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 104
15/3/07 17:09:35
sensations of the cloister
105
the details of sexual practices normally written out of literary culture. In a lecture on the pernicious Catholic cloister in 1852, the speaker advised the packed all-male audience that he would have to discuss conduct well outside the boundaries of respectability: ‘I am now obliged to read to you that which is filthy, revolting and disgusting; you have to hear that which is hideous, horrible and unnatural’.69 (The printed text of his lecture prudently omitted the details.) So deeply was the debauchery of Catholic clergy inscribed in Victorian cultural discourse that it became central to the defence of the convert-priest, John Henry Newman, in a notorious court action. Giacinto Achilli, a former monk and popular anti-Catholic lecturer in England, had been imprisoned by the Inquisition for heretical views, monastic disobedience and ‘gross immoralities’.70 When Newman repeated these charges in lectures and published them in 1851, Achilli sued for criminal libel. The trial catered for every sensational taste, particularly in the extended procession of defence witnesses attesting in graphic terms to Achilli’s sexual depravity (including rape, the hiring of a prostitute as a servant, and many examples of fornication and adultery). Without apparent irony, Newman’s defence counsel attacked Achilli’s reliability by recourse to all the standard Victorian prejudices against Catholic priests, though Newman was one himself: ‘For what is Achilli? … Is he not a subtle disputant, and an ingenious casuist? – brought up amidst Italian priests and monks, himself an Italian, a priest, a monk?’71 Victorian accounts of priestly immorality frequently focus on the abusive power structures within Catholic religious communities. Like the sensational representations of Jesuits in the period, denunciations of the cloister draw attention to the ways in which a social group can be perverted through blind, mechanical submission to authority. This theme, centred particularly on strategies for ordering hierarchical relationships, is apt for a culture struggling with the management of rapid social change; and its handling highlights problems which the nineteenth century perceived as especially ‘modern’. For example, the portrayal of the inhabitants of the cloister en masse expresses uneasiness about ceding too much authority to any subordinate group. The result can be unruliness and crime. The demonic nuns portrayed in Maria Monk’s Awful Disclosures are encouraged by priests to murder Sister Frances, mangling her body with relish and rallying ‘each other in the most unfeeling manner’ (83–84). The same cloister critiques also suggest how traditional masculine roles of leadership and service can become destructive. The stereotypical representation of despotic priests (and tyrannical, unfeminine abbesses) shows how the egotistical can pervert power to pursue gratifica-
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 105
15/3/07 17:09:35
106 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature tion and ride roughshod over spineless subordinates. A favoured trope is the comparison of the Catholic cloister to the outmoded feudal state. The meek, inexperienced nun becomes in effect ‘the serf of a Mother Abbess, a Bishop, and a Confessor, all acting in turn as her custodians and tyrants’.72 Transgressive Catholicism offers a safe environment for the exploration of this dark side of the masculine ideal. Browning’s The Ring and the Book (1868–69) explores masculinity and public life by embracing and re-writing the sensationalized representations of Catholic priests circulating in Victorian Britain. While some of the seventeenth-century priest-characters in the poem are indeed greedy, lecherous, self-seeking, manipulative hypocrites, certain clerical figures exemplify sound practice in government and social interaction. They offer persuasive leadership that maintains order and equality across civil and religious boundaries. The diverse aspirations and practices of different Catholic priests expressed in the monologues juxtapose contending versions of masculine conduct in the public sphere. At the same time, they define ideal and degraded patterns of social relations, justice and institutional power-broking that are recognizably contemporary and British. In Book X of the poem, for example, Browning presents a construct of Pope Innocent XII that is essentially heroic. The pontiff is supreme authority for he must balance the different perspectives on a murder case and provide a conclusive judgement on the guilt of the villain, Guido. Some critics characterize the Pope’s monologue as the voice of an enlightened Protestant masquerading under a pontifical tiara.73 There are indeed some grounds for this interpretation. The Pope seems un-Catholic in his suspicion of ‘the totalitarian character of any predetermining system’.74 He invokes Victorian anti-Catholic rhetoric to denounce smug friars and monks. He despises the cant and grotesque hagiographies that shore up their self-serving, exclusive ‘boundary-line / ’Twixt true and false religion and the world’.75 Overall, however, the Pope’s monologue is less concerned with denominational differences than with the exemplary qualities that can inspire a well-ordered society. As the final authoritative voice to decide on Guido’s fate, the Pope is sole arbiter of the claims of both civil law and the Church. Yet neither institution has his confidence. He rejects the slack tolerance of secular opinion that would, on balance, extend mercy to the middle-class murderer of a difficult wife. He is equally disinclined to take up the opinions of his friars and archbishops because they are primarily governed by selfish, worldly considerations. They conspicuously fail to act to save the abused victim, Pompilia, from her murdering husband. They collude in concealing civil crime and
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 106
15/3/07 17:09:35
sensations of the cloister
107
spiritual sin to uphold the economic thrust of the marriage contract and to preserve social appearances. Anti-conventional in his own reasoning, the Pope has respect only for the other romantic rebel in this familial tragedy – Caponsacchi, the priest who attempts to rescue Pompilia. It is by selflessly resisting frameworks of propriety and regulation that Caponsacchi reveals God’s truth and becomes an agent of His justice. He champions the socially disregarded, showing pity for the oppressed and ‘[h]elp for honour’s sake’ (X, l. 1551). To the gossips of secular Rome, Caponsacchi is at best a naive, at worst a lascivious, cleric, but to the Pope, he is a model of manly leadership in action. Caponsacchi intuitively perceives a new expression of God’s truth in the world, ‘[u]nrecognized yet, but perceptible’ (X, l. 1865). By defying the cant of respectability and the drive to self-advancement to help Pompilia, he redefines heroic masculinity. Browning uses rhetoric normally associated with the criticism of Catholic priests to represent two opposing responses to Caponsacchi – the contempt of the multitude and the admiration of the Pope. To some, Caponsacchi acts like a superstitious – even effeminate – Catholic martyr, blindly obedient to emotive zeal and extinct codes of self-sacrifice. He pointlessly risks life and reputation to aid another man’s wife. In this way, his conduct is also an affront to social order in which male control and possession are expected to be dominant. He dangerously disrupts an established principle of patriarchal social structure, the supposedly ‘natural’ authority of husband over spouse. On the other hand, the judicious Pope defines this priest’s masculinity in approving terms that dissociate it from the imperatives of the public sphere and notions of respectability. When Caponsacchi removes Pompilia from her abusive relationship despite social convention, he does indeed seem fanatically pious in a distinctively Catholic way: ‘[a]ll blindness, bravery and obedience!’ (X, l. 1555). However, this ‘blindness’ is caused by the brilliance of Divine enlightenment. The priest, argues the Pope, is ‘as a man would be inside the sun, / Delirious with the plenitude of light’ (X, ll. 1556–57). Caponsacchi’s obedience is redemptive precisely because it has nothing to do with masculine respect for power, possession and propriety. Instead, his actions stem from his imaginative sympathy with the Divine Plan. In this, he transcends gendered attitudes, prefiguring a new pattern of social behaviour that welds masculine energies to spiritual insight. As the Pope acknowledges, Caponsacchi’s pity for Pompilia – a potentially feminine response – prompts him to imitate the ultimate sacrifice of Christ, characterized in terms of masculine ‘strength’:
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 107
15/3/07 17:09:35
108 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature How can man love but what he yearns to help? And that which men think weakness within strength But angels know for strength and stronger yet – What were it else but the first things made new, But repetition of the miracle, The divine instance of self-sacrifice That never ends and aye begins for man? (X, ll. 1645–51)
Caponsacchi’s rebellion against clerical conformity to save a victimized woman modifies the aggressive and competitive dimension of mid-Victorian masculinity. He couples entrepreneurial ‘determination and skill’76 to the principle of selfless love that governs God’s relation to His creatures and should underpin creatures’ relations with each other. In The Ring and the Book, social relations in civil and religious communities demonstrably fail to live up to this principle. Most of the male characters evidence a lust for social status, money and sex that is associated in the popular Victorian imagination with the corrupt Continental and Catholic past. The scandalous sensuality, avarice and cruelty of many priests and nuns in the poem suggest most Catholic religious characters project the worst features of an amoral Churchbound culture. However, Browning also encourages the reader to discover disturbing parallels between this seventeenth-century world of the Church and contemporary England.77 For a start, he erodes the boundaries between the cultural imaginary of the past and contemporary beliefs and fears by articulating familiar complaints about Catholic priests in anachronistic, nineteenth-century terms. For example, the cynical priest, Paolo, explicitly dramatizes a common Victorian anxiety about the displacement of male authority through the intrusion of a Catholic confessor into the home.78 He sees women as bait by which power can be purchased or seized: ‘Mothers, wives and maids, / These be the tools wherewith priests manage men’ (IV, ll. 501–502). Connections are also clearly established between the worldly (Catholic) society of Rome and the creeping secularism and materialism of Victorian (Protestant) culture. The Pope, for instance, describes his society as one in which ‘the light from heaven [is] still more / And more encroached on by the light of earth’ (X, ll. 1811–12). Religious commitment has been displaced by self-aggrandizement which deadens the spirit. ‘Earthly incitements’ tempt ‘mankind [to] serve God / For man’s sole sake, not God’s and therefore man’s’ (X, ll. 1814– 15). Opportunities for social mobility, the assumption of disguised origins and identities, a vicious marriage market, and pervasive greed and lechery motivate many characters in The Ring and the Book. Using themes familiar to
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 108
15/3/07 17:09:35
sensations of the cloister
109
readers from Victorian sensation fiction and popular journalism, Browning creates a Roman culture which parallels the contemporary British urban scene at its worst. In this poem, seventeenth-century Catholic corruption is typical of any culture where conformity to expected social behaviours conceals voracious individual desire. This conflation in the poem of past and present, of Catholic and secular exposes the dubious foundation of those social institutions and practices in which Victorians placed their trust. Throughout the poem, for example, the destructiveness of marriage in a self-seeking world of malign masculine intentions is suggested by images and commentary that link it to suspect structures of Catholic domination and control. Pompilia experiences family life, whether as daughter or wife, as imprisonment typical of a Catholic convent. Her domestic environment is hemmed in by garden walls and ‘householdbars’ (III, l. 776). She is under observation at all times. Guido defends himself in his first monologue by describing his marriage as a commercial transaction that also mirrors the cloister hierarchy. He initially uses economic tropes to establish his rights over Pompilia as property – like buying a hawk that will render docile service. Yet it is quickly apparent that the dynamic of their relationship replicates the worst excesses of Catholic governance in its brutal enforcement of authority and obedience: The obligation I incurred was just To practise mastery, prove my mastership:– Pompilia’s duty was – submit herself, Afford me pleasure, perhaps cure my bile. (V, ll. 714–17)
The supposed sanctity of marriage is revealed as a sham. In practice, it is violent and abusive, and its horror is made manifest by explicit connection to the demonic priesthood of Rome: … yet priestliness Can find a parallel to the marriage-bond In its own blessed special ordinance Whereof indeed was marriage made the type … (V, ll. 722–27)
Social relations in both church and state are perverted by the same tyrannical values. Difficult monks and difficult wives require the same discipline in this Renaissance culture with its nineteenth-century undertones: ‘prescribe short chain and sharp scourge / Corrective of such peccant humours’ (V, ll. 739–40). Similarly, Browning problematizes Victorian middle-class social goals by exploiting various cloister stereotypes embedded in the nineteenth-century
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 109
15/3/07 17:09:35
110 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature cultural imagination. Grasping lascivious priests in The Ring and the Book may reinscribe comfortable denominational boundaries for a Protestant readership, but they also raise disturbing questions about the ultimate value of prosperity and social rank. The worship of both is shown to displace conscience. Guido’s slimy brother, Paolo, a ‘[s]mooth-mannered softspeeched sleek-cheeked’ priest (III, l. 251), is recognizable as an egregious nineteenth-century social climber. He is an adept and wily operator, exploiting his career (in the Church) to further his voracious ambition. He views marriage not as a sacrament but as a source of money and connections. Guido’s other priest-brother, Girolamo, exploits his ostensible respectability as priest and family member to make sexual advances to his sister-in-law. The Convertite nuns with whom Pompilia is lodged after leaving Guido show how easily women can collude in such masculine despotism under the guise of social propriety. When Pompilia is caught in her flight from Guido, the convent serves as an instrument of repressive social convenience. The relegation of Pompilia to the nuns offers her some measure of protection, but it is primarily a public appeasement of Guido’s male pride and a way of keeping a troublesome woman subdued. Similarly, Victorian fastidiousness about social appearances is mocked when Catholic clerics display the same tendency. Caponsacchi’s bishop easily deals with the young man’s scruples. Worldly insouciance characterizes the bishop as a social sophisticate, skilled at displaying the outward signs of pious austerity without experiencing any of its inconveniences: Qualmish of conscience? Thou ingenuous boy! Clear up the clouds and cast thy scruples far! I satisfy thee there’s an easier sense Wherein to take such vow than suits the first Rough rigid reading. … … Nobody wants you in these latter days To prop the Church by breaking your backbone … (VI, ll. 270–74, 287–88)
In a culture where ease and self-gratification take precedence, ideals of manly self-sacrifice are impossible to imagine. The gossips of Rome, circulating the usual prejudices about priestly lust, can only think that lechery motivates Caponsacchi. They pronounce him a debonair lover of Pompilia or even a dissolute frequenter of brothels because ‘vows can’t change nature, priests are only men, / And love likes stratagem and subterfuge’ (I, ll. 1049–50). Other Browning monologues employ a similar mirroring strategy. The sensational immoralities of Catholic religious men that figure in Victorian
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 110
15/3/07 17:09:36
sensations of the cloister
111
polemics are rehearsed in ways which give visibility to the insidious corruption embedded in sterile codes of social respectability. ‘Soliloquy of the Spanish Cloister’ (1842), for example, draws many of its details from familiar Protestant indictments of the celibate priestly life that leads to frustration and perversion. The dangers of cloistered denial are apparent in the identification of the speaker as both monk and madman, consumed with irrational hatred for his colleague, the mild Brother Lawrence. The stream of curses (‘Hell dry you up with its flames!’) and insults (‘you swine!’) together with the periodic break-down of language itself (‘Hy, Zy, Hine’) and even human speech (‘Gr-r-r’) suggest a mind out of control as well as a priest out of touch with Divine Love and charitable forbearance. In these terms, Catholicism is imagined as a pathological state, and the monastic cell not far removed from a room in the asylum. Curiously, though, this poetic voice is compelling as well as repellent, a paradoxical effect achieved by the dialogue between different versions of masculinity throughout the monologue. Compared to the pallid Brother Lawrence with his effeminate pastimes of tending plants, filling vases, picking fruit and attending prayers, the speaker displays all the traditional features associated with Victorian views of male energy. He is quick-minded and learned, sexually virile, and imaginatively creative in his increasingly fantastic schemes of revenge.79 Certainly, the juxtaposition of speaker and Lawrence suggests that the monastery is no place for manly men. The repressive regime of small-minded routines contorts male capacities into insane hatred. Such cloister damage is further troped in the metaphoric emasculation of the speaker’s grand designs. Despite his dynamic intensity, the only actual harm he does is the secret nipping-off of flower buds. Nonetheless, certain ambiguities give the poem a more complex network of possible meanings beyond the commonplace inscription of Catholic error. As a dramatic monologue, the poem forces the reader to adopt an indeterminate position of judgement. With its emphasis on the unwitting self-revelation of the speaker, the genre invites speculation about motivations the persona cannot directly acknowledge. In ‘Soliloquy of the Spanish Cloister’, the speaker’s arrogance, self-obsession and competitive hatred are made to seem delusional because his distorted assessment of reality is increasingly pushed to the fore. He projects his own unconscious fantasies and fears onto the world around him. His lust for the washerwomen becomes Lawrence’s lechery even though there is no concrete sign that the Brother’s ‘dead eye glow[s]’ (l. 30).80 He even imagines the possibility of a fearsome physical Satan who could be outwitted in a bid to damn Lawrence. With
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 111
15/3/07 17:09:36
112 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature the realization of the speaker’s skewed perception comes the implication that the unmasculine Brother Lawrence may be noble after all. Against the speaker’s reading of Lawrence’s failure can be set an alternative model of masculine probity and honourable conduct embodied in the simple Brother. Self-effacing modesty, humble love of God’s natural creation, and steady obedience to monastic rule can be deduced from the same material evidence the insane speaker uses to prove Lawrence’s inadequacy. Read in this way, a Catholic monastery might house both disturbed mind and saintly soul. The same interpretive ambiguity also connects cloister sensationalism to Victorian social manners in the poem. A nineteenth-century reader might begin by expecting that the speaker’s hatred is born of the unnatural frustrations of Catholic monkery. But Browning more explicitly attributes his fury to Lawrence’s sidestepping of proper appearances and codes of etiquette. Despite his own instinctive vulgarity (women squat; lips are ‘chaps’), the speaker professes his superiority and refinement through petty and arcane rituals. Like the biblical Pharisee, his piety depends on pretentious, empty ceremonies that touch neither heart nor soul: When he [Lawrence] finishes refection, Knife and fork he never lays Cross-wise, to my recollection, As do I, in Jesu’s praise. I, the Trinity illustrate, Drinking watered orange-pulp – In three sips the Arian frustrate; While he drains his at one gulp! (ll. 33–40)
A standard jibe at Catholic ritual elaborations is joined to the advocacy of plain, straightforward conduct, even if somewhat lacking in social niceties. It is the gentle, earthy simplicity of Brother Lawrence that becomes the touchstone of masculinity and morality in the poem. Insanity gradually becomes synonymous with phoney cant and a preoccupation with the empty respectability of appearances. Hypocrisy and respectability are also overt themes in ‘Bishop Blougram’s Apology’ (1855), a monologue that encourages the reader to draw parallels between the deceit of Catholic priests and the pretence of social ambitions. Set in 1850s England and taking the form of an extended interview between the Bishop and Gigadibs, an agnostic journalist, the poem broadens the familiar criticism of deceitful Catholic clergy into an appraisal of the Victorian preoccupation with social status. The monologue is, at one level, steeped in the public outrage occasioned by the restoration of the Catholic Hierarchy
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 112
15/3/07 17:09:36
sensations of the cloister
113
in 1850. Browning once admitted that the worldly, slippery Blougram was based on the new Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, Nicholas Wiseman, and that his subject was not ‘ungenerously’ treated.81 While the poet drew back from any suggestion that he was attacking Catholicism per se, readers of the day clearly understood the monologue in the context of Victorian anti-popery. When George Eliot praised the poem’s masterful revelation of complacent, ‘ingenious sophistry’,82 she implied that such intellectual dishonesty was hardly a surprise, given the Catholic speaker. To establish Blougram’s insincerity, Browning contrasts his speaker’s dazzling argumentative rhetoric with the bland, hazy and banal faith his argument is intended to sustain. For example, the Bishop develops an elaborate sea-faring metaphor to explain how institutionalized religious belief can be adapted for the progressive believer in a world which trusts only reason, material evidence and individual judgement. For him, worldly pragmatism is the solution. Like Caponsacchi’s Bishop, Blougram avoids the awkward trouble of transcendent ideals and absolutes. Truth becomes a matter of relativity, morality a matter of adroit negotiation of temporal circumstances. He prefers to focus on what is possible without having to sacrifice worldly dignity and success: The common problem, yours, mine, every one’s, Is … … finding first What may be, then find how to make it fair Up to our means … (ll. 87–91)
Resembling a man who can take only limited baggage on a sea voyage, Blougram’s believer must make the best of what he can accommodate and jettison everything that is inconvenient or does not fit his own view of what is comfortable. It is even sufficient to twist doubt into a belief of sorts; in this way, compelling modern philosophies of materialism and rationalism are scarcely troubled. ‘The grand Perhaps!’ (l. 190) makes God a possibility as much as a superstitious folly. Such deft rationalization directly connects the Bishop’s belief (such as it is) to his social position. His avowed faith, however hedged with qualifications, gives him a place in a powerful institution that provides everything he wants. Blougram’s desires are defined wholly in the worldly terms of a confident man of the establishment. He seeks – and has – material comfort (as gourmand and wine-lover), intellectual opportunities (to suit his scholarly and cultivated tastes), celebrity status (he plays a highly visible role in Church spectacles), and authority over the masses. That critics remain
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 113
15/3/07 17:09:36
114 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature divided about Browning’s fascination with some of Blougram’s arguments suggests the persuasiveness and ingenuity of this subtle character.83 However, when read in conjunction with the steady output of sensational Victorian revelations about the worldly acquisitiveness and duplicity of Roman clerics, the monologue shows the significant extent to which the poem exploits contemporary rhetoric about Catholic priests. Blougram’s adroit reasoning and argumentative skill can never be admirable, for they dramatize the prevalent view of Catholic clergy as arrogant, hypocritical and self-serving. The self-confidence and bravado that Blougram displays in the face of Gigadibs’s unspoken criticism represents him as the discredited agent of a heretic faith but also as an exemplary Victorian individualist. Browning’s portrait gives new meaning to the Victorian concept of the self-made man, ‘free to “select his own credo, construct his own opinions’.84 For all his protestations about loyalty to the Church, Blougram is essentially his own authority; his most deeply held belief is in himself. The bishop perceives the world solely in terms of his own yearnings; and his considerable talents are devoted to satisfying his appetites. Much of his monologue is given over to shaping other’s opinions (like those of Gigadibs) or to moulding circumstances (his metaphoric sea-cabin) to suit his own perspectives and reinforce his superiority. Indeed, one of the arguments for faith on which he places most weight is that it supplies his desires: ‘what I want, I have’; ‘I wish and get’ (ll. 540, 547). With this formulation of the Bishop’s sustaining principle, the monologue’s attack on Catholic hypocrisy broadens to connect with the midnineteenth-century debate about egotism and altruism in social relations.85 As Blougram demonstrates, when the advancement of the self has priority in a community, dishonourable self-seeking and hypocrisy seem inevitable. His love of control, demonized by its Catholic foundation, shows the repellent side of ethical frameworks predicated on radical individualism. Browning’s own highly individualistic violation of generic conventions through the addition of a coda is a strategy that shows again how unattractive features of Catholicism duplicate, and thus problematize, contemporary secular attitudes. In the body of the poem, the Bishop’s self-presentation has a cynical frankness that implies honesty. However qualified his faith, it seems the result of unromantic reflection and shrewd assessment of losses and gains. For this reason, his relaxed, confidential tone conveys some measure of personal authority to his claims. Yet the epilogue exposes this, too, as no more than a convenient disguise. Blougram has, all along, maintained social power and control over his listeners (and readers) through a careful attention to appearances and an artful hypocritical concealment:
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 114
15/3/07 17:09:36
sensations of the cloister
115
For Blougram, he believed, say, half he spoke.
… Some arbitrary accidental thoughts That crossed his mind, amusing because new, He chose to represent as fixtures there … (ll. 980, 984–86)
Browning’s unusual addition of this supplementary passage spoken by an omniscient commentator reveals the extent to which the skilled manipulator of social language and expectations can deceive. Even the usual codes of poetic form are insufficient for penetrating Blougram’s polished surfaces, because the concealment of truth is the truth of his moral character. Only a detached voice can confirm this. Insincerity is the mark of the man and, by association, of the Church whose authority and power he wields. At the same time, Blougram’s worldly rationalism and concern for status and respectability identify him as a caricature of the self-satisfied, self-fashioned public man of the Victorian middle class. His ambitions and rationalizations are inseparable from the cynicism, acquisitiveness and egotism that, for some Victorian intellectuals, seemed to taint mid-Victorian public life. Seen through the lens of Catholic failings, contemporary British culture privileges amoral self-seeking, which may well explain Gigadibs’s sudden departure for an Australian farm at the end of the interview. Browning also exploits the sensational association of sexual vice and Catholic priests to dissect the tyranny of conformity and hypocrisy in a materialistic culture obsessed with social appearances. ‘The Bishop Orders His Tomb at St. Praxed’s Church’ (1845) and ‘Fra Lippo Lippi’ (1855) tap a rich seam of imaginative writing on nuns and priests in ways that go beyond the scandal of Rome itself and satirize the false prudishness and affected piety that infect middle-class manners. The language of sexual excess, evasion and revelation found in the cloister exposé shows how easily codes of linguistic ‘propriety’ disguise, even rationalize, the sordid reality of lived experience. In Maria Monk’s Awful Disclosures, for example, the convent serves as a seraglio for the priests in an adjacent presbytery. Like an epidemic or plague, the men invade the body of the cloister from many doors and secret passages, at any hour of the day or night, under the pretext of religious duties. They spread infection as they go; both nuns and priests are riddled by venereal disease. In this predatory social model, fastidiousness about the sins of the flesh veils an inability to confront and deal with the power of sex. This sensational version of Catholicism suggests that external censorship of natural desires (rather than reliance on self-discipline) leads to moral blindness. The twisted logic of concealment even justifies murder and infanticide to hide the scandal of
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 115
15/3/07 17:09:37
116 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature uncontrolled male passion. Linguistic evasions in the convent exposé also show how the discourse of conventional orthodoxy can hide an infested world. Orgiastic priests and nuns use convolutions and silence to present warped and abusive relations as normal and natural. When the syphilitic clergy of the Awful Disclosures disappear for medical treatment, they are said to be on a ‘holy retreat’ (125). Even the testifying narrator is implicated in an evasion of the truth. For the sake of her own respectability in the eyes of her readers, her description of convent rapes is silenced by the euphemistic reference to ‘the practice of criminal intercourse’ (38). Browning’s use of this sensational ‘Catholic’ language of respectable impropriety in ‘The Bishop Orders His Tomb at St Praxed’s Church’ connects the Bishop’s Renaissance world to nineteenth-century narratives of Catholic vice. Like the revelatory convent memoir, this monologue foregrounds the way language functions as an ideological tool, recasting moral corruption as respectable behaviour. The Bishop’s deft handling of linguistic deflection paradoxically exposes his hidden unsavoury motivations in ways that have some relevance for a Victorian middle-class readership. Browning himself suggested the poem had contemporary cultural resonances at the time of composition; he anticipated a good reception for it in 1845 in the light of Tractarian controversy, ‘the Oxford business, and Camden Society and other embroilments’.86 Certainly, the Bishop’s deathbed memories would play well to a jittery audience hostile to the encroachments of Catholicism. His traits explicitly reinforce Victorian views of the priest of Rome as encapsulating the demonic inversion of ideal masculinity in his impiety, sexual transgression and greed. But even early readers of the poem saw that the monologue encompassed more than a simple denominational attack. In Modern Painters, John Ruskin praised the poem’s brilliant evocation of a whole culture in its religious and secular dimensions. He especially savoured its subtle interpretation ‘of the Renaissance spirit, – its worldliness, inconsistency, pride, hypocrisy, ignorance of itself, love of art, of luxury, and of good Latin’.87 In its exposure of the bishop’s corruption, the monologue shows how men gradually come to redefine their values in a materialistic, competitive society and how subtle semantic circumventions play an important part in this process. For the Bishop, identity exists purely in relation to his position in the social hierarchy. Neither personal conscience nor religious belief conveys self-worth. Instead, physical trappings and status ensure fame and prestige, the only terms in which this essentially worldly man can envisage survival after death. Through verbal strategies of exaggeration and evasion, the dying man works energetically to suppress whatever threatens his social superi-
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 116
15/3/07 17:09:37
sensations of the cloister
117
ority. While reminiscent of the rhetoric of clergy in the convent exposé, these linguistic habits also echo the familiar pieties of the Victorian middle classes. The Bishop conceals his anxieties beneath reassuring discourses of social respectability and family loyalty. It soon becomes apparent that the Bishop’s attitudes and speech mimic the social values and linguistic behaviours of nineteenth-century Britain. If Bishop Blougram can be said to represent a depressing example of Victorian masculinity enacting its public institutional role, the dying Bishop is the dark side of the Victorian paterfamilias. The latter’s linguistic evasions, substitutions and displacements reveal how hypocrisy and worldliness pollute traditional notions of the family as the foundation of social stability. In keeping with mid-Victorian understanding of the mechanisms of repression,88 his verbal processes conceal disturbing secrets about family relations through attention to outward form. At the same time, they expose feelings he is reluctant or unable to admit. For example, he gives the young men who gather at his deathbed a dual identity as ‘nephews’ and ‘sons mine’ (l. 3). The slide in terminology from the conventionally discreet term for priests’ bastards (nephews) to the biological fact (sons) establishes the Bishop’s history of sexual transgression. It suggests too that careful attention to respectable appearances is after all but a flimsy mechanism that can never fully rewrite the truth. Further linguistic trickery reveals that the Bishop treats fatherhood as a game of power, not responsibility. His open acknowledgement of his sons on his deathbed is not driven by love or even a sense of remorse, but by a desire to enforce obedience. The Bishop ‘orders’ his tomb by disclosing his specifications; but he also ‘orders’ it by attempting to impose his authority and will on others to create it. He appeals to the conventional notion of filial duty as well as to his sons’ greed to ensure they build his tomb as he directs. Their silent departure before the Bishop has finished his monologue suggests the emptiness of family relations based on economic interests rather than affection or loyalty. The young men stand by the bedside just long enough to be confident their father is truly dying and their inheritance is safe. While the Bishop sees this fact, he remains linguistically oblivious to it, reinterpreting their behaviour so that it fits into his own framework of conventional manners. At one point he rebukes them for ignoring him and his wishes: ‘For ye have stabbed me with ingratitude / To death’ (ll. 114–15). But in his final confused ramblings, he assumes the role of a kindly father taking leave of loving sons. Even though only their retreating backs are to be seen, he goes through the formalities, while stage-managing the physical props of his
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 117
15/3/07 17:09:37
118 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature dying: ‘Well, go! I bless ye. Fewer tapers there, / But in a row …’ (ll. 119–20). In a culture of hypocritical respectability, family relations are reduced to theatrical performance concealing tyranny and sullen acquisitiveness. The language with which the Bishop discloses his relationship to his mistress reveals the same corruption of family relations by worldly motivations. The prelate’s sexual activity, hidden by his vow of celibacy, is in keeping with the typical sensations of Protestant polemic popularized at the time. But Browning actually directs more attention to the Bishop’s attitudes to women than to his sins as a priest. The dying Bishop’s memories show his coldness. He recalls his lover purely in physical terms; she was ‘so fair’, ‘with her talking eyes’ (ll. 5, 94). Yet the same features also reveal the Bishop’s fear of female sexual power. His mistress is both possession and succubus, her eyes quick as a lizard, glittering ‘for my soul’ (l. 105). Moreover, in this worldly framework, the notions of desirable beauty and romantic attachment become evasive codes to conceal personal competitiveness. The Bishop’s mistress is really of value only because she establishes her lover’s manly dominance in the eyes of his rival, old Gandolf. Professional relationships in this acquisitive society fare no better, as evidenced by the Bishop’s obsession with Gandolf. The latter’s well-located, modest tomb suggests he was a humble man without conspicuous ostentation and respected by the Church. Nonetheless, like the mad monk’s characterization of mild Brother Lawrence in ‘Soliloquy of the Spanish Cloister’, the Bishop’s reconstruction of Gandolf is an imaginative projection of his own egotistical motivations and jealousy. He uses language that portrays Gandolf as a schemer, cozening the Bishop to ‘snatch’ the best tomb location and fantastically poised in death to savour the Bishop’s humiliation in the form of an inferior monument ‘which Gandolf from his tomb-top chuckles at!’ (l. 67). This displacement of Gandolf the man by Gandolf the stone effigy is a linguistic slip that once again tropes the Bishop’s identification of people with property. Such distorted values lie at the base of a metaphoric web that gradually consumes the whole poem. Scandalous images of sensuality and materialism obliterate the spiritual, and even, as E. Warwick Slinn has noted, ‘the discrimination and control’ associated with ‘aesthetic values’.89 Blasphemously, the Bishop merges a grand chunk of lapis lazuli, erotic desire, and idealized and spiritualized womanhood typified by the Virgin Mary. The stolen stone signifies for him the visual and tactile pleasures of the flesh, ‘[b]lue as a vein o’er the Madonna’s breast’ (l. 44). Another simile for the stone – ‘[b]ig as a Jew’s head cut off at the nape’ (l.43) – captures the dehumanizing effect of the Bishop’s greed through a display of casual brutal prejudice as
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 118
15/3/07 17:09:37
sensations of the cloister
119
easily found in nineteenth-century bigotry as in the Renaissance. The egotism that corrupts the Bishop’s social relations in public and private domains also taints his faith. Rather than attributing his unbelief to the false Roman creed, the poem emphasizes how the idolatrous worship of self-interest can corrupt spiritual understanding. The Bishop’s rhetorical excess reveals the unholy extent to which he consumes the entire reach of his imaginative vision. He describes his effigy for the tomb in terms which equate him with his Creator. He demands a pose normally reserved for the omnipotent Divinity: So, let the blue lump poise between my knees, Like God the Father’s globe on both his hands Ye worship in the Jesu Church so gay … (ll. 47–49)
Contrasts in diction and register similarly convey the stunted nature of the Bishop’s spirituality. When the cleric describes beautiful objects to convey his sensual delight in the physical, he is at no loss for words and images. Rich alliteration, sensuous detail and the multiple embedding of concrete images express his obsession with material experience. The marble for his tomb is both delicate and luscious, like ‘[p]each-blossom … the rare, the ripe’ (l. 29). His imagination richly conflates sounds, scent, taste, colour and movement simultaneously to portray it ‘[a]s fresh-poured red wine of a mighty pulse’ (l. 30). Yet when the Bishop attempts to delineate religious practice and belief, his language is crude and simplistic. Indeed, the terms of his description sound like those to be found in many Victorian anti-Catholic tracts. When the dying prelate speaks of Catholic ritual and dogma, he resembles any outspoken member of the Protestant establishment in Browning’s Britain. The prayers of the Mass are no more than ‘blessed mutter’ (l. 81), and Transubstantiation a blasphemous process by which ‘God [is] made and eaten all day long’ (l. 82). In the selfish society of the poem, social status and wealth are the worldly preoccupations that edge out spiritual values, even at the point of death. The Bishop’s vision of eternity has nothing to do with individual salvation, but everything to do with personal aggrandizement through pomp. The commodification of the soul may repress thoughts of eternity, but it returns uncannily in the Bishop’s unconscious linguistic confusions. For example, he constructs a life after death that is reassuringly physical but also totally self-defeating. As he lies on his deathbed he muddles his living presence with the effigy on his sepulchre ‘[w]hereon I am to lie till I must ask / “Do I live, am I dead?’ (ll. 112–23). His perception that there is little difference between
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 119
15/3/07 17:09:37
120 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature the two states is further dramatized by his attempt to shape his body into the form of the statue: ‘I fold my arms as if they clasped a crook, / And stretch my feet forth straight as stone can point …’ (ll. 87–88). This mimicry of a process of metamorphosis from life to stone vividly suggests the inert nature of his living heart and the spiritual blank which has been his life. The Bishop remains consistently unaware of this desiccated spiritual state. Obsessed with maintaining his veil of status and respectability, prosecuting to the end his competitive rivalry with Gandolf, he uses Christian rhetoric purely because the social occasion calls for its utterance. Language which might prompt a moment of self-revelation, like the opening reference to Ecclesiastes and the vanity of human wishes or the admission that ‘[e]vil and brief hath been my pilgrimage’ (l. 101), is stripped of its signifying potential. The emptiness of these pious platitudes is indicated by their textual isolation. They remain discrete phrases, disconnected from the Bishop’s central meditation on fame and material grandeur as the new eternity. Even the message the Bishop orders for his monument in ‘Latin pure, discreet’ (l. 98) is no call to repentance or memento mori. The Bishop’s imagined tomb – like any beautiful work of art – will speak to generations to come, but it has two stories to tell. On the one hand, for the Bishop it is set to become the conclusive utterance of his superior status and illustrious nature. On the other, its design and likely non-realization become, for the reader, a message about the ethical distortions inherent in a selfish and materialistic culture. The Bishop’s version goes nowhere. He speaks only to the mouldering corpse and silent effigy of his rival Gandolf. But to a community of Victorian readers, the poem suggests trenchant connections between the despised Catholic Other and any society that conceals the desire for selfgratification and domination beneath the cant of propriety and the respectability of appearances. Like the popular sensations about Catholic priests circulating in the middleclass Protestant culture of Victorian Britain, Browning’s monologues of the corrupt clergy of Rome emphasize their worldliness and hypocrisy. Wicked priests are especially repugnant in their cultivation of piety while indulging in vice and self-aggrandizement. However, Browning’s monologues also offer a masculine version of the scandalous Victorian cloister exposé that proposes an alternative vision of ‘spiritualized’ secularism. ‘Fra Lippo Lippi’ and the Caponsacchi soliloquy in The Ring and the Book each present the revelations of an admirable priest-monk who has left the Catholic religious enclosure. These characters, like the liberated nun figure of the convent memoir, use personal experience to explain the failures of monastic life.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 120
15/3/07 17:09:38
sensations of the cloister
121
Like their nun-parallel, they too are presented as admirable rebels against oppressive authority. While the nun who breaks free of the cloister advocates an enlightened Protestant faith as the guide to salvation, these men find redemption in free and honest expression and selfless action. This becomes the measure of Browning’s manly man: he is a living vehicle for truth and an agent for social change. Browning’s ‘Fra Lippo Lippi’, for example, uses the familiar cloister escape plot and its accompanying testimony to assert the heroism of defiance. By making the case for aesthetic rebellion, the speaker shows how a spineless respect for convention and conformity can be replaced by an honesty that is both energizing and inspirational. At the opening of the monologue, the friar, arrested after curfew, seems to conform to the standard Victorian portrayal of the debauched monk. Fra Lippo Lippi is full of improper energies, with his coarse oaths, knowledge of the seamy world of ‘sportive ladies’, crude jokes and irreverent, slangy speech. And yet, as the monologue develops, it clearly follows the pattern of the convent exposé. An enlightened and credible witness strips away cant to reveal the hypocrisy, sensuality and repression of the Catholic religious institution. When first taken into the monastery, Lippi learns that the friars might preach austerity and renunciation, but certainly do not expect to surrender their comforts, including … the good bellyful, The warm serge and the rope that goes all round, And day-long blessed idleness beside! (ll. 103–105)
Sensual gratification is everywhere apparent in Lippi’s monastic environment, just as in the overwrought descriptions of the monastery in Victorian Protestant propaganda – but so is censorship of the body. Clerical leaders evasively attempt to deny the centrality of the flesh to human experience, a point that the escaped Lippi is quick to mock. His Prior, like the Bishop at St Praxed’s Church, pays lip service to the transcendent soul but can conceive it only in material terms. His feeble theological understanding is exposed as laughably inadequate when he tries to regulate and constrain Fra Lippo Lippi’s attempts at religious art. The Prior has only contempt for Lippi’s realistic approach to biblical scenes and Christian legends because he cannot acknowledge the sanctity of the human body permeated by soul: Faces, arms, legs and bodies like the true As much as pea and pea! it’s devil’s-game! Your business is not to catch men with show, With homage to the perishable clay,
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 121
15/3/07 17:09:38
122 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature But lift them over it, ignore it all, Make them forget there’s such a thing as flesh. Your business is to paint the souls of men – Man’s soul, and it’s a fire, smoke … no, it’s not … It’s vapour done up like a new-born babe – (In that shape when you die it leaves your mouth) It’s … well, what matters talking, it’s the soul! Give us no more of body than shows soul! … Paint the soul, never mind the legs and arms! Rub all out, try at it a second time. Oh, that white smallish female with the breasts, She’s just my niece … (ll. 177–88, 193–96)
The Prior’s inability to express his own theory of religious art in concrete terms, his childish and clichéd images to invoke the soul, his ogling along the way of a female breast (which may, perversely, be that of a niece, illegitimate daughter or mistress), and his irritable petulance all combine to expose the falsity of any spiritual truth which separates humanity from the world of matter, action and desire. As fugitive from the cloister’s false understanding of art and spirit, Fra Lippo Lippi draws on his own perceptions to validate his discovery of the truth. In his resistance to the inhibitions of the monastic enclosure he, too, has pierced the veil that hides reality. What he uncovers through artistic practice is the real relationship between body, soul and God, the Divine Artist: If you get simple beauty and nought else, You get about the best thing God invents, – That’s somewhat. And you’ll find the soul you have missed, Within yourself when you return Him thanks. (ll. 217–20)
The soul is stimulated, not distracted, by expression of the individualistic, fluid material world. In the aesthetic response to a sensuous world, both artist and perceiver can make an imaginative leap of feeling and gain insight that is synonymous with true spirituality. Artistic creativity becomes both sign of the soul’s life and praise of God. Following the motifs of the cloister narrative, Fra Lippo Lippi has ‘escaped’ his order to testify to this new belief and his own discovery of a ‘personal religion’. However, for Lippi, this is a religion of art rather than Protestantism: ‘I’m my own master, paint now as I please – ‘ (l. 226). His artistic commissions for a wealthy patron in fact resemble the convent exposé itself. They
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 122
15/3/07 17:09:38
sensations of the cloister
123
express his independent insights, now unfettered by imposed regulations that simply enforce the power of past. For him, cloister repression is summed up by the Prior’s preference for old-fashioned religious art. Its formulae are the aesthetic equivalent of monastic routines, which express the Church’s corrupt gloss on the truth. To comply would be to expunge the soul’s independence and integrity – and thus to create a falsehood. Lippi therefore rejects the path taken by the reticent painter in Browning’s ‘Pictor Ignotus’ (1845). That unknown artist yearns for respectability and status, deciding this can be secured by reproducing conventional themes in a traditional manner. While he dreams of creating a new, more naturalistic, artistic style, he refuses to take the risk. It is easier to subjugate talent and vision to ‘[t]he sanctuary’s gloom’ (l. 63) than court possible ridicule for artistic rebellion. He therefore plays safe, repressing individuality by complying with outmoded, commonplace tastes. The result is inevitably a failure – the arid product of an atrophied imagination: My heart sinks, as monotonous I paint These endless cloisters and eternal aisles With the same series, Virgin, Babe, and Saint, With the same cold, calm, beautiful regard … (ll. 58–61)
Fra Lippo Lippi, on the other hand, offends the pious decorum of the status quo by rejecting conventional formulae and received styles. In an image that revises the typical stereotype of monastic greed, Browning imputes a voracious aesthetic appetite to his friar. His energy is focused on consuming the truth of God’s creation. To do so, he frankly acknowledges the value of the world and the flesh for the spirit: … This world’s no blot for us, Nor blank – it means intensely, and means good: To find its meaning is my meat and drink. (ll. 313–15)
This personal vision is the friar’s salvation; but his art also guides others, leading them to find a similar meaning and purpose that will liberate their imaginations. Lippi proposes a new basis for cultural renewal located in art. His aesthetic underpins delight in the material world with a selfless concern for truth, and its expression is for the good of all: … Art was given for that – God uses us to help each other so, Lending our minds out. (ll. 304–306)
The priest Caponsacchi in The Ring and the Book also journeys from clois-
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 123
15/3/07 17:09:38
124 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature tered delusion to free expression. Initially, Caponsacchi is represented as naive, falling in with the view of his fellow clerics that the Catholic priest is a modified version of the secular gentleman. He easily adopts the mask of the insidiously charming confessor recognizable from Catholic sensationalism. His ‘polished presence’, ‘genteel manner’, ‘wit / At will, and tact at every pore’ (VI, ll. 367–68) give him authority over the laity. However, his encounter with Pompilia is an epiphanic moment. Each comprehends the other through a gaze of equals that penetrates through body to soul. Independent of gendered, social or religious power, their intense connection goes beyond cultural roles and respectable reserve: … As I Recognized her, at potency of truth, So she, by the crystalline soul, knew me, Never mistook the signs. (VI, ll. 916–19)
Pompilia touches more than Caponsacchi’s manly chivalry, or his sensitivity to beauty, or his sensual desires, or even his pity for a friendless person in trouble. Her acknowledgement of his individual spiritual core is what transforms him. It by-passes his institutionalized role and the stereotypical expectations of conduct that it imposes. Her gaze frees him to know and value his own independence, integrity and moral responsibility: Pompilia spoke, and I at once received, Accepted my own fact, my miracle Self-authorized and self-explained, – she chose To summon me and signify her choice. (VI, ll. 903–906)
The consequences of this validation of individual worth are far removed from the egotism of Bishop Blougram or the dying Bishop of St Praxed’s church. Like the escaped nun figure, Caponsacchi feels compelled to bear witness to a divine mission. In obedience to God’s truth, he resists the duties of conformity imposed by the religious and civil authorities that control him. He willingly risks ostracism because, in order to rescue Pompilia, he must sacrifice his reputation within and outside his order. As in the cloister exposé, such flouting of decorum is represented as a selfless, dangerous act but also a sign of integrity: ‘There was no duty patent in the world / Like daring try be good and true myself ’ (VI, ll. 1800–801). Moreover, it promises to renew those who hear the testimony and are moved by it. Caponsacchi intimates that his statement at Guido’s trial will also affect society at large. Through him, the court will know the truth about innocence, honesty, cruelty and deception as he now does, and it will be brought to honour that
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 124
15/3/07 17:09:38
sensations of the cloister
125
truth in its judgements: Why, there’s a Judge weeping! Did not I say You were good and true at bottom? You see the truth – I am glad I helped you: she helped me just so. (VI, ll. 1864–66)
Imaginative empathy, self-knowledge and self-sacrificial action emerge as the guiding principles through which men might renew public life. The authority of convention and the lure of ego are displaced by a selfless independence. Rebellion against worldly values actually strengthens ties of sympathy and humane understanding. Victorian cloister sensations, with their images and plots of Catholic clerical corruption, interface with nineteenth-century anxieties about gender, social relations and the tension between independence and conformity in private and public life. Browning’s religious monologues draw extensively on the rich signifying potential of religious sensationalism in ways that move his characterizations beyond a simple critique of the Church of Rome. The familiar cloister motif of veiled evil becomes a strategy for exploring the psychological complexity of individual motivation. Characters’ techniques of evasion are not simply indicative of Catholic hypocrisy, but also of the general deceptiveness of verbal and visual signs of propriety. These monologues have a broader secular application as well. Catholic they may be, but Browning’s weak and wicked priests also dramatize the decadence of any culture with a cynical devotion to respectable appearances, prosperity and self-promotion. Their ‘foreign’ papist attitudes and behaviours mirror similar motivations and manners to be found in nineteenth-century Britain. Through these competitive, status-conscious and sensual men, Browning deconstructs paradigms of masculinity gaining currency in prosperous middle-class English culture. On the other hand, drawing on the familiar sensations of the cloister exposé, he uses the liberated priest figure to propose an alternative male subjectivity that functions benignly in the public sphere. Eschewing respectability and fleeing institutional conformity, these men show how to balance individual insight and collective responsibility, free expression and public service. Like Brontë’s Villette, Browning’s sensational monologues of the cloister become secular narratives about the dangerous impact of convention on an individual’s self-formation, on social relations in both private and public spheres, even on artistic production and interpretation. With their complex intertwining of the horrors of oppression and romances of rebellion and escape, Victorian literary imaginings of the cloister are spectacular examples of a pressing middle-class conundrum: the difficulty
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 125
15/3/07 17:09:38
126 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature of striking a sound balance between tyranny and control, between self-expression and disciplined restraint. In literal terms, the displacement of character – and reader – to the strange, secretive and entrapping world of the Catholic cloister demonstrates the impact of an isolated, superstitious environment on vulnerable individuals and the advantages of a healthy Protestant outlook. However, these representations of ‘heretical’ nuns and priests also challenge dominant social attitudes in Victorian Britain, exposing in particular the dangers of conformity. They express the inadequacy of prescribed gender roles, the danger of smothering erotic feeling, and the torture of constraining self and social relations within the straitjacket of institutional authority and respectable appearances. Ultimately, these shadowy sensations of the cloister play ambivalently against each other. In the strictly bounded and regulated convent space, heroic self-command and unnatural repression can, ironically, be mistaken for each other. In the cloister, selfless dedication to duty and the oppressive submission to external powers occupy common ground. Dignified privacy and duplicitous secrecy, brave resistance and reckless selfishness become increasingly difficult to distinguish. Embedded in these horrific tales of nuns and priests are the disruptive nightmares shaped by Victorian ideologies of gender, by the conflicting Victorian commitments to individualism and duty, by the urgent need to define respectability for a culture in social and spiritual transition. For all these reasons, in the end, the Roman cloister and the English hearth cast remarkably similar shadows.
Notes 1 Newman, Lectures, p. 134. 2 Wilkie Collins, No Name (1862; New York: Dover Publications, 1978), p. 54. 3 Quoted in Hoxie Neale Fairchild, Religious Trends in English Poetry, vol. IV, 1830–1880: Christianity and Romanticism in the Victorian Era (New York: Columbia University Press, 1957), p. 355. 4 Eliza Keary, Memoir of Annie Keary, 2nd edn (London: Macmillan, 1883), p. 32. 5 Keary, Memoir of Annie Keary, p. 28. 6 Keary, Memoir of Annie Keary, p. 34. 7 W. R. Greg, ‘Why Are Women Redundant?’, National Review, XIV, no. 28 (April 1862), pp. 436, 440. 8 Dinah Mulock Craik, A Woman’s Thoughts about Women, in Elaine Showalter, ed., Christina Rossetti: ‘Maude’; Dinah Mulock Craik: ‘On Sisterhoods,’ ‘A Woman’s Thoughts about Women’ (New York: New York University Press, 1995), pp. 64–65. See also Elaine Showalter, ‘Florence Nightingale’s Feminist Complaint: Women, Religion, and Suggestions for Thought’, Signs, 6, no. 3 (Spring 1981), pp. 395–412. 9 Craik, ‘On Sisterhoods’, pp. 47–48.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 126
15/3/07 17:09:39
sensations of the cloister
127
10 Anna Jameson, Sisters of Charity: Catholic and Protestant, Abroad and at Home (London: Longman, Brown, Green & Longmans, 1855), pp. 13, 15. 11 Jameson, Sisters of Charity, p. 11. 12 Jameson, Sisters of Charity, p. 10. 13 Jameson, Sisters of Charity, p. 94. 14 Martha Vicinus, Independent Women: Work and Community for Single Women 1850– 1920 (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1985), p. 48. 15 Frances Power Cobbe, Essays on the Pursuits of Women, 1863; quoted in Susan Mumm, Stolen Daughters, Virgin Mothers: Anglican Sisterhoods in Victorian Britain (London and New York: Leicester University Press, 1999), p. 63. 16 Quoted in Michael Hill, The Religious Order: A Study of Virtuoso Religion and Its Legitimation in the Nineteenth-Century Church of England (London: Heinemann, 1973), p. 182. 17 Anon., ‘The Service of the Poor’, Fraser’s Magazine, n.s., IV, no. 21 (September 1871), p. 374. 18 Anon., ‘Service of the Poor’, p. 374. 19 See, for example, Mumm, Stolen Daughters, Virgin Mothers, p. 176. John Scobell felt his daughter’s entrance into a convent against his wishes was a violation of his ‘family peace’ and a direct challenge to his ‘parental authority”.’ 20 M. Hobart Seymour, Convents or Nunneries: A Lecture in Reply to Cardinal Wiseman (London: Seeley, 1852), pp. 18, 19. 21 From a Protestant Alliance Tract, quoted in Hill, The Religious Order, p. 257. 22 Anon., ‘Two Views of the Convent Question’, Macmillan’s Magazine, XIX, no. 114 (April 1869), p. 542. 23 Edward Harper, The Papal Invasion of Jesuits, Monks and Nuns; with Twelve Reasons for the Government Inspection of Nunneries (London: John Harper, n.d.), p. 3. 24 Mumm, Stolen Daughters, Virgin Mothers, p. 141. 25 Susan P. Casteras, ‘Virgin Vows: The Early Victorian Artists’ Portrayal of Nuns and Novices’, Victorian Studies, 24, no. 2 (Winter 1981), p. 157. 26 From a review in Art Journal, 1852; quoted in Casteras, ‘Virgin Vows’, p. 174. 27 Robert Miles, ‘Abjection, Nationalism and the Gothic’, in The Gothic: Essays and Studies 2001, ed. Fred Botting (Cambridge: D. S. Brewer, 2001), p. 66. 28 Ray Allen Billington, The Protestant Crusade 1800–1860: A Study of the Origins of American Nativism (New York: Macmillan, 1938), pp. 101–102, 108. In 1851 Newman still felt the need to incorporate an extended denunciation of the Awful Disclosures as the vulgar outpourings of ‘a worthless stroller’ in his Lectures (p. 166). As late as 1894, Catholic Truth Society pamphlets dealt robustly with ‘slanders which are still industriously circulated’ about Catholic convents, including improbable stories of immured and escaped nuns and the dubious testimony of the unreliable Maria Monk (Some Protestant Fictions Exposed [London: Catholic Truth Society, 1894], p. iii). 29 While there are no publication details for The Horrors of Roman Catholic Convents, internal evidence suggests this penny pamphlet had an Irish origin. 30 See, for example: [William S. Hayward], ‘The Nun, the Will, and the Abbess’, in Revelations of a Lady Detective (London: George Vickers, 1864), and Elizabeth Gaskell, ‘The Poor Clare’ (1852), in Curious, If True: Strange Tales, ed. Jenny Uglow (London: Virago, 1995). 31 Anon., The Horrors of Roman Catholic Convents, Exposed in a True Heartrending Account
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 127
15/3/07 17:09:39
128 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature
32
33 34 35 36 37 38
39 40 41 42
43 44
45 46
47
48
of the Shocking Imprisonment & Sufferings of Sister Barbara, a Polish Carmelite Nun, who was walled up alive for twenty-one years in the cold dark cell of an infected Underground Dungeon! With an awful Description of her horrible condition when she was first discovered in her dismal, loathsome Den, and the fiendish treatment inflicted upon her by inhuman Priests, Lady Superioresses and Nuns, who styled themselves ‘Spiritual Wives,’ and the ‘Brides of Heaven!’ n.p., n.d. [1872?], p. 6. Marianne Thormählen, The Brontës and Religion (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999), p. 28. Rosemary Clark-Beattie argues that Brontë’s religious thinking reflects the theological positions and attitudes found in popular fiction of the day, although the specifics of her anti-Catholic reading remain uncertain (‘Fables of Rebellion: AntiCatholicism and the Structure of Villette’, ELH, 53, no. 4 (Winter 1986), p. 846). Quoted in Margot Peters, Unquiet Soul: A Biography of Charlotte Brontë (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1987), p. 109. Peters, Unquiet Soul, p. 334. Peters, Unquiet Soul, p. 334. See, for example, Thormählen, The Brontës and Religion, pp. 24–25. Charlotte Brontë, Villette, ed. Mark Lilly (1853; Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1979), p. 507. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. Sandra M. Gilbert and Susan Gubar, The Madwoman in the Attic: The Woman Writer and the Nineteenth-Century Literary Imagination (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1979), p. 426; Sally Shuttleworth, Charlotte Brontë and Victorian Psychology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), p. 226. Charlotte Brontë, The Professor (1857; London: Penguin, 1995), pp. 97–98. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. Michael E. Schiefelbein, The Lure of Babylon: Seven Protestant Novelists and Britain’s Roman Catholic Revival (Macon, GA: Mercer University Press, 2001), p. 142. Sigmund Freud, ‘The Uncanny’, in Literary Theory: An Anthology, ed. Julie Rivkin and Michael Ryan (Oxford: Blackwell, 1998), p. 154. Mary Jacobus, ‘The Buried Letter: Feminism and Romanticism in Villette’, in Women Writing and Writing About Women, ed. Mary Jacobus (London: Croom Helm; New York: Barnes & Noble, 1979), pp. 47, 52, 55. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, The Coherence of Gothic Conventions (New York and London: Methuen, 1980), p. 30. Quoted in John Shelton Reed, ‘A Female Movement”: The Feminization of NineteenthCentury Anglo-Catholicism’, Anglican and Episcopal History, LVII, no. 2 ( June 1988), p. 227. M. Hobart Seymour, Nunneries: A Lecture delivered at the Assembly Rooms, Bath, on Wednesday, April 21, 1852 (London: Seeleys, n.d.), p. 5. Rebecca Theresa Reed, Six Months in a Convent: The Narrative of Rebecca Theresa Reed, late inmate of the Ursuline Convent, Mount Benedict, Charlestown, Mass. (London: Thomas Ward & Co., 1835), pp. 84–85. Harriet Martineau, ‘Sister Anna’s Probation’, Once a Week, VI (22 March 1862), p. 338. Subsequent references to the weekly instalments which ran from 15 March–12 April are cited by page number parenthetically in the text. Clark-Beattie, ‘Fables of Rebellion’, p. 826. Kate Lawson similarly argues that Protestant Reason in the novel represses unconscious desire while Catholicism sublimates eroticism and refocuses it (‘Reading Desire: Villette as “Heretic Narrative’, English Studies in
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 128
15/3/07 17:09:39
sensations of the cloister
129
Canada, XVII (1 March 1991), pp. 59–60). 49 Liana F. Piehler, Spatial Dynamics and Female Development in Victorian Art and Novels: Creating a Woman’s Space (New York: Peter Lang, 2003), pp. 1, 43. 50 C. Maurice Davies, Unorthodox London: or Phases of Religious Life in the Metropolis (London: Tinsley Brothers, 1873), p. 414. 51 Davies, Unorthodox London, p. 421. 52 Julia McNair Wright, Almost a Nun (Philadelphia: Presbyterian Publication Committee, 1868), p. 247. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. 53 For example, see Karen Laurence, ‘The Cypher: Disclosure and Reticence in Villette’, Nineteenth-Century Literature, 42, no. 4 (March 1988), p. 459. 54 Rick Rylance, ‘Getting on”: Ideology, Personality and the Brontë Characters’, in The Cambridge Companion to the Brontës, ed. Heather Glen (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002), p. 164. 55 Seymour, Nunneries, p. 15. 56 Seymour, Nunneries, p. 14. 57 Seymour, Nunneries, p. 16. 58 Eliza Richardson, The Veil Lifted: or, The Romance and Reality of Convent Life (London: Morgan & Scott, n.d. [1865]), p. 13. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. 59 Maria Monk, Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, and the Startling Mysteries of a Convent Exposed! (1836; Philadelphia: Peterson, n.d.), pp. 51, 55. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. 60 Griffin, Anti-Catholicism, p. 32. 61 Shuttleworth, Charlotte Brontë and Victorian Psychology, p. 222. 62 Shuttleworth, Charlotte Brontë and Victorian Psychology, p. 232. 63 Seymour, Nunneries, p. 15. 64 Barbara Melchiori, ‘Browning in Italy’, in Robert Browning, ed. Isobel Armstrong (London: G. Bell & Sons, 1974), p. 174; Jacob Korg, Browning and Italy (Athens, OH: Ohio University Press, 1983), p. 132. 65 Andrew Tate suggests that Browning’s prejudice against Catholicism was in keeping with the general attitudes of his time (‘He Himself with His Human Air”: Browning Writes the “Body of Christ’, Nineteenth-Century Contexts, 25, no. 1 (March 2003), pp. 44–46). K. I. D. Maslen has established clear links between Browning’s treatment of Renaissance Catholicism and that of Macaulay (‘Browning and Macaulay’, Notes and Queries, 225 [1980], pp. 525–57). 66 Bulwark, I ( January 1852), p. 175, quoted in Paz, Popular Anti-Catholicism, p. 55. 67 Paz, Popular Anti-Catholicism, p. 13. 68 W. A. Darby, Monks and Nuns: A Lecture in Reply to Two Lectures by ‘Father Ignatius, O. S. B.,’ April 14, 1864 (Manchester: John Heywood, 1864), p. 41. 69 Seymour, Convents or Nunneries, p. 35. 70 Nicholas Wiseman, writing anonymously in the Dublin Review, 1850; quoted in Matthew C. Mirow, ‘Roman Catholicism on Trial in Victorian England: The Libel Case of John Henry Newman and Dr. Achilli’, Catholic Lawyer, 36, no. 4(1996), p. 405. 71 Quoted in Mirow, ‘Roman Catholicism on Trial’, p. 442. 72 Harper, Papal Invasion, p. 8. 73 Richard D. Altick and James F. Loucks, II, Browning’s Roman Murder Story: A Reading of ‘The Ring and the Book’ (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1968), p.
LUP_Moran_03_Ch2.indd 129
15/3/07 17:09:39
130 catholic sensationalism and victorian literature 68. 74 Herbert F. Tucker, Jr., Browning’s Beginnings: The Art of Disclosure (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1980), p. 187. 75 Robert Browning, The Ring and the Book (1868–69; New York: W. W. Norton, 1961), X, ll. 1569–70. Subsequent references are cited parenthetically in the text. 76 Leonore Davidoff and Catherine Hall, Family Fortunes: Men and Women of the English Middle Class: 1780–1850 (London: Hutchinson, 1987), p. 229. 77 The main parallel noted to date focuses on gender. See Susan Brown, ‘Pompilia: The Woman (in) Question’, Victorian Poetry, 34, no. 1 (Spring 1996), pp. 15–37. 78 This topic caused outrage throughout the 1850s and 1860s; see, for instance, John Echlin Armstrong, The Confessional: its wickedness (Brighton: Edward Verall, 1856). 79 For Daniel Karlin, these are the features of the rebellious Romantic artist; the speaker is alive to the world as the other shadowy monks are not (Browning’s Hatreds [Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993], pp. 77–78). 80 This poem, ‘The Bishop Orders His Tomb at St Praxed’s Church’ and ‘Pictor Ignotus’ from Robert Browning, Poems, Vol. 1 (London: Chapman & Hall, 1849). For ‘Bishop Blougram’s Apology’ and ‘Fra Lippo Lippi’, see Men and Women (London: Chapman & Hall, 1855). 81 Julia Markus, ‘Bishop Blougram and the Literary Men’, Victorian Studies, 21, no. 2 (Winter 1978), p. 194. 82 George Eliot, ‘Men and Women’, Westminster Review, 55 ( January 1856); reprinted in Browning: The Critical Heritage, ed. Boyd Litzinger and Donald Smalley (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1970), p. 176. 83 E. LeRoy Lawson, for instance, suggests Blougram and Browning share the same relativist starting point though they reach different conclusions about the ‘contingent character of faith’ in the nineteenth century (Very Sure of God: Religious Language in the Poetry of Robert Browning [Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press, 1974], pp. 115–16). 84 Edwin P. Hood, The Age and Its Architects: Ten Chapters on the English People, in Relation to the Times (1852), quoted in Walter Houghton, The Victorian Frame of Mind 1830–1870 (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1957), p. 96. 85 Stefan Collini offers a comprehensive analysis of the political and philos