CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR and MATERIAL CULTURE in BRITAIN 1660–1760
LORNA WEATHERILL
CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR and MATERIAL CULTUR...
90 downloads
1947 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR and MATERIAL CULTURE in BRITAIN 1660–1760
LORNA WEATHERILL
CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR and MATERIAL CULTURE in BRITAIN 1660–1760 Second edition
London and New York
First edition published 1988 This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2003. Second edition published 1996 by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001 © 1988, 1996 Lorna Weatherill All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloging in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data Weatherill, Lorna. Consumer behaviour and material culture in Britain, 1660–1760/Lorna Weatherill. p. cm. Bibliography: p Includes index. 1. Consumers—Great Britain—History—17th century. 2. Consumers—Great Britain—History —18th century. 3. Great Britain—Economic conditions—17th century. 4. Great Britain— Economic conditions—18th century. 5. Great Britain—Social conditions—17th century. 6. Great Britain—Social conditions—18th century. I. Title. II. Title: Consumer behaviour and material culture in Britain, 1660–1760. HC260.C6W4 1988 306'. 3–dc 19 88–4033 ISBN 0-203-44229-6 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 0-203-75053-5 (Adobe eReader Format) ISBN 0-415-15184-8 (Print Edition)
For my children and my friends with love
CONTENTS
List of plates List of tables Preface Preface to the second edition 1 Introduction Part I THE NATION
23
2 Growth 3 Contrasting localities 4 The influence of towns
25 43 70
Part 2 THE HOUSEHOLD 5 6 7 8
viii ix xi xiii 1
Financing the household: income, wealth, and prices Financing the household: expenditure and priorities The domestic environment Ownership of goods, social status, and occupation
9 Conclusions and implications Appendix 1: Ways of using probate inventories Appendix 2: Occupations and status in inventories Notes Bibliography of contemporary sources Index
vii
91 93 112 137 166 191 201 208 215 240 244
PLATES
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Grace before a Meal, J.Van Aken, c. 1720 (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford) Claud and Peggy, David Allan, c. 1780s (National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh) Family at Tea, R.Colius, 1732 (Victoria and Albert Museum, London) Mid-eighteenth-century cutlery (photographs from the collection in Sheffield City Museum) Penny Wedding, David Allan, 1785 (National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh) Covent Garden, London, J.Van Aken, c. 1720 (Museum of London) Dixton Manor House, eighteenth-century British school (Art Gallery and Museum, Cheltenham) High Life Below Stairs, John Collett, c. 1750s (British Museum) Kitchen scene: women washing, Paul Sandby, 1765 (Royal Library, Windsor Castle) A kitchen at Steeple, Isle of Wight, anon., no date (Carisbrooke Castle, Isle of Wight) Making Pies, Paul Sandby, c. 1765 (Royal Library, Windsor Castle) A domestic scene by David Allan, c. 1780 (Glasgow Art Gallery and Museum) An English Family at Tea, J.Van Aken, c. 1720 (Tate Gallery, London)
viii
7 12 35 36 68 82 82 140 141 141 148 154 158
TABLES
2.1 2.2
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4 5.1
5.2
Frequencies of ownership of selected household goods in a sample of inventories from England, 1675–1725 26 Frequencies with which selected goods were recorded in a sample of inventories from the London Orphans’ Court, 1675–1725 27 Ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories from eight English regions, 1675–1725 44 Some characteristics of inventories from eight regions of England, 1675–1725 46 Changing ownership of selected goods in each of eight English regions, 1675–1725 49 Numbers of dealers in coffee and tea in the 1730s in the counties covered by the sample of inventories, population, and the frequency of ownership of utensils for hot drinks in 1725 62 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in towns and country areas in a sample of English inventories, 1675–1725 76 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in farmers’ and tradesmen’s inventories, in town and country, 1675–1725 78 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories in towns and country areas in eight regions of England, 1675–1725 80 Changing frequencies of ownership of selected goods in towns and country areas, 1675–1725 88 Percentages of a sample of inventories with selected household goods in wealth groups defined by the value of the inventory 107 Percentages of a sample of inventories with selected ix
x
TABLES
household goods divided according to the value of household goods 5.3 Ranges of values given to selected goods in inventories 6.1 Household and other expenditure of Richard Latham of Scarisbrick, Lancashire, 1724–1740 6.2 Household and other expenditure of Rachael Pengelly of Finchley, 1694–1708 6.3 Household and other expenditure of Sarah Fell of Swarthmoor Hall in 1675 and 1676 6.4 Household and personal expenditure in several households as a proportion of recorded annual expenses 7.1 Household activities: estimates of time spent doing them 8.1 A social-status hierarchy: frequencies of ownership of goods in a sample of inventories in England, 1675–1725 8.2 A consumption hierarchy: frequencies of ownership of goods in a sample of inventories in England, 1675–1725 8.3 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories in England, 1675–1725, subdivided by economic sector of occupations 8.4 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories in England, 1675–1725: selected occupations A2.1 Occupations and status in the sample of inventories A2.2 Some characteristics of inventories in ten social-status groups A2.3 Some characteristics of inventories in eight general occupational groups A2.4 Some characteristics of inventories in different economic sectors
108 110 116 124 129
133 143
168
184
186
188 209 212 213 214
PREFACE
The research upon which this book was based was undertaken as a project funded by the Economic and Social Research Council from 1981 to 1985, with the title ‘Consumer behaviour and material culture in Britain 1660–1760’. I am ever grateful to the Economic Affairs Committee for making it possible for me to undertake the work and travel. The research was done in many libraries and record offices, and I thank all the librarians and archivists who helped me to find what I needed; without them research would be impossible. The University of St Andrews generously gave me the facilities to work and to meet other scholars, and I am particularly grateful to have used St John’s House Centre for Advanced Historical Studies. I have also been helped by many people in practical, intellectual, and personal ways. Without Angie Lamb the computing would have been done in a very clumsy way. Pene Corfield and Peter Earle contributed insights into social s t r u c t u r e s a n d w e a l t h . Wi t h o u t M a r k O v e r t o n m y appreciation of inventories and of geographical regions would have been much less, and I have enjoyed my conversations with him. Many other people have talked to me about this or that aspect of the subject, or encouraged me in one way or another. Among them are John Hatcher, John Chartres, Helen Irwin, Roger Mason, John Styles, Pat Hudson, Kay Young, Sarah Bankes, Marine Berg, Tony Upton, David Gascoigne, Judith George, and Geoffrey Parker. Catherine King showed me the pitfalls of interpreting apparently realistic pictures, and without her I would never have unearthed so many. Without Keith Wrightson this would have been a much less xi
xii
PREFACE
interesting book, and I thank him for his time, patience, and perception in the knowledge that such debts can never properly be repaid. Nor can I properly thank Christopher Smout for encouraging me to see the importance of what I found and for a wider inspiration. Rhoda and Aidan Weatherill breathed life into the household. St Johns House, St Andrews
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
Many academic authors, in introducing a paperback edition some years after the original was published, are able to present further new work of their own. I cannot claim to do this for my personal and professional circumstances have changed since the book was written, although I have since published one substantial study on a related subject.1 However, I have deepened my understanding of methodologies through my recent career in a university computing service in which I give advice to scholars from all disciplines on research methods and especially on data and databases. The disadvantage of a change of career is that I had not fully kept up with historical debate since the late 1980s and had not even read my own book since I struggled over the copy editor’s comments. The advantage is that I came back to it afresh and I am glad to say that I still agree with the methods and the interpretations. So the purpose of this introduction is to update some of the methods and conclusions, and I begin with a review of new writing on some aspects of consumer behaviour. Second, there is a section on methodology and, third, without trying to rewrite the book, I look again at the role of wealth in determining material culture and behaviour.
Aspects of consumer behaviour The aspects of consumer behaviour covered in the book were reflections both of the subject itself and of intellectual and personal influences on me when I was writing it. First, I was interested in ‘demand’ for industrial goods which arose from earlier research on the pottery industry; this probably resulted in more economic xiii
xiv
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
history in the book than there would have been if I had written it afresh. Some of the old arguments seem, in retrospect, naïve. Why did we even debate the role of the home market when it was so obviously important? Second, I was influenced by the history of artefacts and by social history, the former through my dilettante interest in art, ceramics and archaeology, the latter through dissatisfaction with economic history. Third, and rather different, I was myself setting up a small household with an adult and two children, and was rather aware of household formation, consumption and how people express their social position through their domestic behaviour. My original purpose in doing the research and writing the book was a conviction that understanding life in households was crucial to understanding anything about their social and economic behaviour; I continue to think this is the case. Work published since 1988 has not superseded my research but rather enhances its conclusions, even where different approaches are notable. A more complete picture of consumer behaviour can be formed if the works by Shammas, Earle and Levine and Wrightson are read alongside this book, for they enlighten the way ahead in different ways.2 Shammas and myself take different approaches; hers is wide-ranging, both because she includes North America and consumption on clothing, food, housing and household goods; she takes a more directly economist’s approach to consumers; mine includes Scotland, looks at a narrower range of goods but is more eclectic in its range of explanation; my sample of inventories is more coherently selected and robust. The studies by Earle and Levine and Wrightson are not about consumption itself but are fine explorations of whole societies; their value in understanding consumer behaviour is that they enlighten the interplay between the material world and other aspects of life at different levels in society. The book edited by Brewer and Porter is a magnum opus containing papers from virtually all viewpoints, followed by two further substantial collections of papers that impact rather less on the main subject of this study, although they are of relevance to it. The range of subjects covered in these collections enable consumption to be seen in a wide theoretical and historical context.3 In addition, there have been studies of clothing, textiles and food, as well as of such things as education and ‘culture’; these are important in themselves and place the role of consumer durables in a more detailed context than was possible when this book was written.4
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
The book was never intended as a direct contribution to the study of the industrial revolution but the pre-industrial situation is relevant to an understanding of the later period. Revision and counter-revision continues and a balanced insight into these can be gained from Pat Hudson’s masterly overview which helps to place this study in a wider academic context.5 An even wider vision can be gained from seeing the eighteenth century as a distant mirror of current debates about political and economic change, and I am particularly gratified that my work should have made any contribution in this area.6 A number of things are worthy of comment in detail, beginning with mechanisms for change, and specifically ‘emulation’, and the depth of the market for consumer goods. A critique of the ideas of emulation is both implicit and explicit in recent work, which is a good thing and I am glad that these older ideas are not being repeated as universal truths because one of the things I aimed to do was to rethink these simplistic notions.7 was evidently puzzled by the urban dimension because I observed different patterns of ownership in towns than I had been led to believe from the literature. I continue to puzzle about this because work published since implies that towns were more important than I found them to be. The answer is probably that the use of terms such as ‘luxury’ trades and leisured classes and the observation of urban facilities such as assemblies, walks, coffee-houses, entertainment and the urban improvement does not necessarily measure the same thing as consumer durables in people’s homes: I am looking at different phenomena from those considered by the observers of town life.8 One of the main arguments implicit in this book is that material life is worthy of exploration and so it is gratifying to find that material life is being seen in the context of social relations in works that refer directly to ordinary domestic possessions within a much wider social, economic and political context. At the same time there are more sophisticated ways of looking at social structures than when I first wrote.9 There is also an appreciation of the importance of life-cycles in consumption, a factor of which I was aware but could not address directly using the main body of data, although household accounts touch on this.10 Likewise, work on individuals gives deeper insight into domestic behaviour and the use made of clothing and domestic utensils, especially when individuals can be seen within their social context.11 This book focuses on consumer durables and semi-durables but its
xv
xvi
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
conclusions are supported and enhanced by work on food consumption, clothing and textiles which gives a wider picture and covers the two most important groups of things on which money was spent.12 The assumption that men and women had different priorities is hardly a new discovery but I found Vickery’s article especially interesting in her observations of behaviour.13 On the supply side, further work on shops and the supply of goods supports what has long been suspected, namely that semidurables and other goods were available throughout the country by the late seventeenth century.14 There has not been further detailed work specifically on the chronology of the first half of the eighteenth century, but it is now accepted, as this book argues, that the economy was not then stagnant, especially in those sectors influenced by personal and household consumption.
Methods This was not an easy book to write, partly because of the multidimensional nature of ownership and consumption; partly because it was (and is) my view that there is more to consumption than economics. But there was a lack of theoretical perspectives on consumption, either with regard to the past or the present, which is why I looked to anthropology and archaeology for concepts about material possessions. The book depends on two kinds of research method: first, ownership of goods is presented as frequency tables which were derived from a computer database; second, I use a wide range of sources in the formation of qualitative judgements and interpretations. I take a kaleidoscopic approach, as in a multi-faceted mirror, reflecting different aspects of behaviour and I appreciate that other scholars might have collected and used the inventory data in a different way. It was my aim to collect the data in as robust a manner as possible. Inventories do have limitations which I took into account both in the manner of sampling and in analysis, as explained in the appendices. I decided simply to analyse whether or not a selection of items were recorded; this is a simplistic test of ownership but one that can be applied to most inventories.15 Tables are at the same time precise and imprecise; they invite explanation at the same time as they confound it. Using modern computer software (and perhaps greater expertise) would have allowed more sophisticated, quantitative questions to be asked.
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
Simply using a relational database I could easily tabulate differences between those who had an item and those who did not—something I did not think of doing at the time. Improved computing facilities mean that statistical tests on categorical data could be done in a manner not possible in the mid 1980s. If I were doing it again I would collect the data in a similar way but use multi-variate techniques to assess the probabilities that each variable influenced ownership. Using a computer package such as SAS would enable a formal assessment of the importance of different aspects of the problem.16 I do not believe that the overall conclusions would have been different from the informal judgements found throughout the study, but one aspect of consumption is developed below as an example.17 A central idea in my work is that observation of domestic behaviour can resolve some problems by looking at people’s lifestyles and experiences using historical sources. We cannot do anthropology on the past, but we have some descriptions and other evidence which can be used as a proxy for field observations and attitude surveys. This is why there are rather long descriptions of household tasks and attempts to probe the inner lives of households through their domestic activities. I still believe these are important methods and should not be rejected because they can appear to deal with trivia; indeed one of the best things I have read on women’s behaviour is based on similar themes, and autobiographies show a wider range of social motivation than normally appreciated.18 Observation in this sense is a powerful tool for looking at the past and for countering naïve assumptions about personal motivation and thus in arguing for a more critical approach to ideas of ‘emulation’, luxury and so on. If I were doing the work again I would be able to draw upon recent insights into qualitative methods and use computer software specifically developed for the analysis of unstructured text. 19 Formal qualitative methods have developed in the last five to ten years and are a growth area in social science research and methodology; they have the advantage of not imposing a spurious quantitative element in an analysis. For example, the qualitative data handling package called NUD.IST could have been helpful because it enables unstructured text to be linked and indexed; it also provides tools for exploring ideas and theories about the data. This would have required no less work or judgement but would rather have encouraged me to be more self-conscious about the approaches that I was using. I can envisage that such approaches would
xvii
xviii
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
improve formal methods used in historical studies where attitudes and opinions are sought amongst heterogeneous data.
The role of wealth I have singled out the role of wealth, and thus more broadly of economic influences on consumption, for further comment because I think there is an imbalance in this section of the book. I clearly take it for granted that income, stocks of goods and wealth were important determinants of material culture and thus ownership, and I deal with these aspects of the household economy at some length. Yet I have not acknowledged the implications of the crosstabulations according to the valuations of estates and household goods given in inventories and I have not acknowledged where ‘wealth’ might have been important. Shammas has used regression analysis and calculated that 60–70 per cent of the variation in the valuation of consumer goods could be attributed to wealth.20 I deliberately did not present results from multi-variate analysis for several reasons: one was that wealth and the totals given in an inventory are not the same thing; the totals may be seriously misleading because (as I argue in the book) they do not include debts owed by the deceased, which could be quite substantial. This being so I was reluctant to place too much weight on the figures even if they seem an attractive proxy for wealth. Second, I collected that data in a manner that meant that I could not use regression analysis for I recorded whether an item was present or not; I did this because it was a more robust way of collecting data. Shammas looked at the determinants of the value of various categories of goods and was thus able to use standard regression analysis. I needed more sophisticated approaches which were not readily available when I did the original research. Third, I was not seeking to offer a multi-variate explanation; I was interested in the nature of the influence of occupation, status, towns and so on in themselves and I was not so concerned about putting a numerical value to their importance as determinants. I was much more interested in the question of why people of apparently similar resources had dissimilar material lives. In asking this question at the level of the household my attention focused on aspects of material life other than income and expenditure. However, at the same time there is some justification in Shammas’ comment that it is impossible to know from my
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
tables whether greater incidence of ownership should be attributed to (for example) occupation or whether those occupations were just richer, or whether people in towns were just better off and there was nothing about town life in itself to encourage consumption. The argument could be enhanced by re-working some of the data but I do not believe that the thrust of the argument of this book is undermined by not attributing percentages to the possible factors. Also, there is already an in-depth account of economic factors in the book in the discussion of household expenditure and of income. The mean values of household goods were higher for those inventories where the goods were recorded than for those where they were not and this was true in all sub-divisions of the data. The only exceptions were the inventories of the clergy and professional groups, where the reverse was true just for earthenware and cutlery. This confirms that the economic influences should not be ignored in tracing the other factors.
Conclusion The book shows that important consumers were to be found amongst the middling sorts and that people were already conscious of their material life by the later seventeenth century. These are conclusions born out by the work of other scholars which has also enhanced appreciation of the financial, practical, symbolic, personal and other motives behind material life. It is not, and should not be, the last word on the subject. A really comprehensive survey of incomes into middling households is long overdue and could be done using widely scattered evidence and modern computer software designed for making qualitative links. More information on life-cycle consumption would be useful, although the best approaches would be labour intensive and only feasible as part of detailed work with outline life histories, purchase, inheritance and family formation. Household accounts shed light on many detailed aspects of consumption and we should know more about them, although they are an awkward source. Consumption should be taken as part of people’s lives and included alongside other matters connected with social well-being. Finally, I thank again all the people mentioned in the original Preface and add to them Brian Jones and Paul Salotti of Newcastle
xix
xx
PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION
Computing Service for allowing me some study-leave to read my book again and write this introduction. I am also indebted to Dr Chris Brunsden for showing me how to use SAS to do multivariate analysis on categorical data. And again to Chris Smout for keeping alive a glimmer of interest in history when I had gone over to technology. I reiterate the debt I owe to my friends and my children for their love and support over the years. Lorna Weatherill
Notes 1 LornaWeatherill, ed., The Account Book of Richard Latham, 1724– 1767, British Academy Records of Social and Economic History, New Series XV, (Oxford, 1990). 2 Peter Earle, The Making of the English Middle Class: Business, Society and Family Life in London, 1660–1730, (London, 1989). This uses the Orphans’ Court inventories in a different way from my use. David Levine and Keith Wrightson, The Making of an Industrial Society, (Oxford University Press, 1991). Carole Shammas, The Pre-industrial Consumer in England and America, (Oxford University Press, 1990); this book is a tour de force and adds considerably to our understanding of consumption. 3 John Brewer and Roy Porter, eds., Consumption and the World of Goods, (London 1993); John Brewer and Susan Staves, eds., Modern Conceptions of Property, (London, 1994); Ann Bermingham and John Brewer, eds., The Consumption of Culture, 1600–1800, (London), 1995. These are all major collections of papers although the first is the most relevant to the subject of this book. 4 Alex Gibson and Christopher Smout, Prices, Food and Wages in Scotland, 1550–1780, (Cambridge, 1995); Shammas, Consumers, pp. 96–100 and 225–290; Beverly Lemire, Fashions Favourite: The Cotton Trade and the Consumer in Britain, 1660–1800, Pasold Studies in Textile History, vol. 9, (London, 1992); Beverly Lemire, ‘“A Good Stock of Cloathes”: The Changing Market for Cotton Clothing in Britain, 1750–1800’, Textile History, vol. 22 (1991), 311–28. 5 Pat Hudson, The Industrial Revolution, (London, 1992). 6 Charles Saumarez Smith, ‘Made in England’, Royal Society of Arts Journal, CXLIII (1995) 31–7 7 These are summarised in Hudson, Industrial Revolution, pp. 173– 81. There is a good review in Jan de Vries, ‘Between purchasing power and the world of goods: understanding the household economy in early modern Europe’, Brewer and Porter, eds., Consumption, pp. 85–132. Ben Fine and Ellen Leopold, ‘Consumerism and the Industrial Revolution’, Social History, 15 (1990), 151–70 summarizes the debate. Emulation implies social mobility, a topic examined in autobiography in two articles that take these important sources of observation further than is normally the case. Michael Mascuch, ‘Social mobility and the middling selfidentity: the ethos of British autobiographers, 1600–1750’, Social History, 20 (1995), 45–61; Michael Mascuch, ‘Continuity and change in a patronage society: the social mobility of British autobiographers, 1600–1750’, Journal of Historical Sociology, 7 (1994) 177–97. A study of poverty is not within the direct scope of this book, but for insights into inter-generational change of status, see Barry Stapleton, ‘Inherited poverty and life-cycle poverty’, Social History, vol. 18 (1993), 339–55. On relief and mobility, see Levine and Wrighton, Industrial Society, pp. 295–344 and 354–59; also Gibson and Smout, Prices, Food and Wages, chapter 9.
xxi
xxii
NOTES 8 Peter Borsay, The English Urban Renaissance: Culture and Society in the Provincial Town, 1660–1770, (Oxford, 1989); A.Mclnnes, ‘The emergence of a leisure town, Shrewsbury 1660–1760’, Past and Present, 120 (1988), 53–87. 9 Social structures continue to be discussed, see Jonathon Barry and Christopher Brooks, eds., The Middling Sort of People: Culture, Society and Politics in England, 1550–1800, (London, 1994). Of greater importance to this study, ownership of goods and material life should be seen within the whole context of social relations, as in Levine and Wrightson, Industrial Society, pp. 231–41. At the other end of the social spectrum, see Earle, Middle Class, pp. 269– 90 and note that the influences on material life form a background to much of this study. 10 Life-cycle influences require further thought and research. Weatheril’s Latham Accounts illustrates this; both Levine and Wrightson and Earle are sensitive to its importance, as is an article about an individual consumer, Amanda Vickery, ‘Women and the world of goods: a Lancashire consumer and her possessions, 1751– 81’, Brewer and Porter, eds., Consumption, pp. 274–303. Autobiography is suggestive of the aims of the middling sorts and how they saw their life-cycles in general terms, see for a summary, Mascuch, ‘Social Mobility’. 11 Vickery, ‘A Lancashire consumer’; Anne Buck, ‘Buying clothes in Bedfordshire: customers and tradesmen, 1700–1800,’ in Harte, ed., Fabrics and Fashions, 211–37. These clearly refer to expenditure and attitudes ranging beyond the consumer durables examined in this book. 12 For food, see Gibson and Smout, Prices, Food and Wages in Scotland, pp. 225–60; Shammas, Pre-industrial Consumer, pp. 76–86. For textiles see Negley, Harte, ed., Fabrics and Fashions: Studies in the Economic and Social History of Dress, a special edition of Textile History, 22 (1991) 152–358; Lemire, The Cotton Trade; Shammas, Pre-industrial Consumer, pp. 96–100. 13 Vickery, ‘A Lancashire consumer’. 14 Shammas, Pre-industrial Consumer, pp. 225–290; Anne Buck, ‘Buying clothes in Bedfordshire: customers and tradesmen, 1700– 1800,’ in Harte, ed., Fabrics and Fashions, 211–37. 15 I developed a flat computer file in which the variables are recorded alongside the information about whether or not a particular item was present. The tables were formed by searching, using a database, for different combinations of variables and ownership. This is a conceptually simple technique with much use of pencil, paper and a hand calculator. I have since tried the data in a spreadsheet (which was not useful) and a relational database which uses similar methods as the original, except that codes could be easily looked up and spelt out. A relational database is one that handles one or more related tables; each subject is represented by one table. As this subject is conceptually one table, had I started with a relational database I might have handled the data in a different way but the results would have been the same.
NOTES 16 SAS is a statistical package widely used by researchers. See SAS Institute Inc., SAS Language Reference, (various versions, c. 1990 onwards according to version, Gary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.) 17 Shammas collected and analysed data in a different way. She used regression techniques because she collected values of the goods observed and looked in less detail at individual commodities. See Shammas p. 173 note 28 for a comment on my methods. Regression analysis, although a well respected technique for some purposes, was not applicable to this problem. 18 Vickery, ‘A Lancashire consumer’; Mascuch, ‘Social mobility’. 19 Martha S.Feldman, Strategies for Interpreting Qualitative Data, (London, 1995); Eba Weitzman and Matthew Miles, Computer Programs for Qualitative Data Analysis, (London, 1995); QSR NUD.IST stands for Non-numerical Unstructured Data Indexing Searching and Theorizing. It is distributed by Sage Publications, London. 20 Shammas has demonstrated the strength of the relationship between wealth and consumer goods, so for an economic account of similar data and a different approach, I recommend you to read her accounts of wealth—Shammas, pp. 100–12, especially table 4.11, pp. 169– 88, and tables 6.5 to 6.9
xxiii
1 INTRODUCTION
the middle state…was the best state in the world, the most suited to human happiness; not exposed to the miseries and hardships, the labour and sufferings of the mechanic part of mankind and not embarrassed with the pride, luxury, ambition and envy of the upper part of mankind. (Daniel Defoe, Robinson Crusoe, 1719) the Middling Class of People, which Class we know are vastly, I had almost said, infinitely superior, in number to the Great. (Josiah Wedgwood, 1772)1 This book is about consumption and consumer behaviour in the early modern period.2 It is hardly a new subject, for perceptive contemporaries puzzled over other people’s expenditure, accepting or rejecting new habits and new goods according to their preconceptions. Defoe, writing here from the viewpoint of consumers, makes the fundamental distinction between people who cannot afford to consume, those who consume too much, and those in the middle, of whom he approved. Wedgwood, from a manufacturer’s viewpoint, makes a similar distinction, but adding that those in the middle were a potentially large and attractive market. The interesting thing about these comments is that they both take it that upper, middle, and lower ranks could be distinguished on the basis of their consumption habits. Consumer behaviour does indeed imply a great deal more than whether or not some goods or services were available and used, which means that consumption cannot be discussed in isolation from other aspects of social and economic life. Historians have also puzzled over consumption, for it has long been recognized that increasing demand for a wide range 1
2
INTRODUCTION
of goods and clothing was as important in industrialization as the invention of new methods of production. Yet, although the importance of the subject can be simply stated in general terms and although it is evident that consumption habits were a fundamental part of life, answers to questions about who consumed what, where they did so, and why have not been firmly established. So it is the purpose of this book to present new evidence about consumers in the early modern period and to look at this evidence in new ways. The main question, underlying the whole of it, is whether people’s material lives reflected their social position. To discuss this, and to present different viewpoints on the processes involved, the argument is divided into two main sections. Part 1 deals with consumption at national, regional, and local levels. Part 2 looks more closely at household expenditure and behaviour before discussing the role of social position directly. This introduction explains the research methods and some of the concepts used, as well as outlining some approaches taken by previous writers.
New evidence: inventories The main framework of the book is based on new factual evidence from a comprehensive collection of probate inventories from eight parts of England.3 These listings of movable goods were made by neighbours shortly after a person’s death, and the executors or administrators of an estate were required to exhibit the inventory at the time of probate. They were commonly made throughout the seventeenth century and became rare only after the 1720s, although the precise date varies in different dioceses. In them are listed, sometimes in considerable detail, the farming, trade, and household goods of the deceased person, together with cash and debts due. They do not record debts owed or any real estate, so they do not give a complete account of the person’s wealth, although they normally give a full account of household contents. They also record other information, notably the date, the parish of residence, and the occupation or status. Each inventory contains some information about factors that may have influenced ownership, with the exception of age at death and details about the size and structure of die household. Thus it is possible to gain a considerable body of information from inventories about who exactly owned domestic goods, especially before 1725.
INTRODUCTION
Many goods are listed in the documents, and it simplifies the problem of data collection and analysis to select some of them for particular study. Two criteria were used to select about twenty items for special attention: they had to be reliably and consistently listed in the documents, and they had to be representative of other goods or of people’s domestic behaviour. They range from basic furniture and utensils (tables, pewter, and cooking pots) to newly available things like china. Many of them, like knives and forks or utensils for hot drinks, point towards gradual changes in eating and drinking habits. Some, such as books and clocks, show something of a household’s cultural interests and indicate contacts with a wider world. The main omission is that textiles are poorly listed, and clothing was not valued in a reliable way. The full list of goods is discussed in appendix 1, together with other observations about the way in which the data were collected. Ownership patterns of the selected goods can be analysed by cross-tabulating whether or not they were recorded in an inventory. There are a number of variables derived from the inventories themselves, and these form a framework for discussing the role of social status, occupation, wealth, place of residence, and change over time. That variations can be shown in all of these confirms that there were a large number of influences over ownership, and these are an important starting-point in discussing consumer behaviour. The validity of these observations rests on the way in which the inventories examined were selected and the extent to which they are a meaningful sample. There are many problems in selecting inventories in a comprehensive way; one of these is that they were not made on behalf of everyone who died, and they give their best results for the middle ranks, from the lesser gentry down to the lesser yeomen. They are extremely rare for labourers. The sample for this book amounted to almost 3,000 inventories, taken from eight parts of England (Kent, Hampshire, Cambridgeshire, the north-east, the north-west, Staffordshire, Cumbria, and London) in the middle year of each decade from 1675 to 1725. The documents were taken unseen from the boxes, and no bias due to this simple technique has been noted in analysing the data. Scottish testaments usually contain only partial lists of goods and credits so cannot be sampled in this way. At the same time, a sample of 300 for the same years was taken from the inventories of the Court of Orphans in the City of London, in order to include a wealthy group of consumers not
3
4
INTRODUCTION
covered in the main sample.4 The information from these is of particular value in enabling comparisons to be made between some very well-off merchants and tradesmen and those of modest means. For instance, the median value of the inventories of the sample from the Orphans’ Court was £2,034 (maximum £47,000), but for the probate sample it was £63 (maximum £4,132). These people more often owned all the goods listed than those in the main sample, as is demonstrated in chapter 2. Inventories are a familiar documentary source of information for scholars working on early modern England; they have been widely used in studies of agriculture, trades, towns, and other communities. There are also a few studies that focus on living standards, as well as several printed collections with introductory sections discussing housing, furnishings, and changing expectations.5 The sample used in this book, and the selection of goods for detailed examination, approaches the problem in a different way, for the documents have been taken from eight contrasting parts of the country, rather than from one area or community or occupational group. This means that the results are meaningful for much of the country, and comparisons can be made between different regions and between town and country.6
New evidence: diaries, household papers, and illustrations Diaries, accounts, and domestic manuals are gradually becoming more familiar to historians than formerly, especially to those interested in family life.7 They were made for many purposes and give a depth of detail not obtainable from inventories, and their range can be seen from the Bibliography. In this book I have used spiritual and personal diaries for their insight into daily routines and infrequent comments on material goods. Household accounts are much undervalued as a source for social history, although they are very rare and, for this reason, unrepresentative. They are often obscure in their meaning and time-consuming to analyse. Three full and interesting accounts have been used, especially in tracing household expenditure patterns in chapter 6. Like inventories, these sources of evidence about middleranking households are not unfamiliar to historians. The main problem in using them is that they originated from people’s inner needs to record experiences, feelings, or financial affairs, and the contents reflect individual idiosyncrasies as well as individual
INTRODUCTION
experiences. Their reasons for writing were not to tell us about domestic routines and consumption patterns, so there are many gaps and unanswerable questions. Yet they are as close as we can get to the inner lives of households, and I have drawn on them extensively for general insights as well as specific examples. Pictures, prints, and drawings of domestic interiors, especially British ones and especially those depicting interiors of middle rank, are potentially valuable in giving coherence to descriptions from written sources. They show ‘images’ of household activities, mealtimes, and leisure, and they confirm information from inventories and elsewhere. For instance, knives and forks were not used, interiors were bare, curtains were unusual, and so on. The best pictures are by Flemish and Dutch painters who visited England. However, great care is needed in using them because artists were concerned with images and ideas as well as with description. There was, it is true, a longstanding tradition of painting graphically, but how ‘real’ the reality is impossible to tell. Their importance is that they convey atmosphere and physical presence in a way that no written record can do. The same is true of the work of David Allan in Scotland in the late eighteenth century, although he was influenced by Italian styles.8
Interpretations: household consumption A new body of evidence about ownership patterns of household goods and the contexts in which they were bought and used is not, however, enough. It is also necessary to seek new ways of interpreting consumer behaviour in the early modern period. This can be difficult and uncertain because there are no obvious, accepted concepts that the historian (or anyone else) can readily use to analyse all aspects of the material side of people’s lives. One starting-point implicit throughout this study is that material goods were, as they still are, indicative of behaviour and attitudes. They had symbolic importance as well as physical attributes and practical uses.9 If this is taken into account, it is possible to move beyond whether or not something was recorded in a list to the meaning of ownership in social and other terms. At a simple level this is done by analysing the results from the sample of inventories, using cross-tabulations of social position or occupation. Even this shows complex patterns, but it is necessary to go further and examine the dynamics of ownership
5
6
INTRODUCTION
at the level of the ‘unit of consumption’, the household. Through exploring the organization of day-to-day life in households we can understand the specific practical and social situations with which consumption was associated. In turn, this leads to an appreciation of some of the mechanisms behind the spread of new goods throughout society from the perspective of the lives of the consumers themselves. From this point of view it is important to emphasize that the housholds of the middle ranks were organized on a scale that we would recognize. Most early modern households in England and Scotland had between four and seven people in them.10 There were no massive feasts, no accommodation problems for large numbers of servants, and no need for formal rules for good behaviour. This must be emphasized because many accounts of early modern households are based on evidence from large establishments.
Interpretations: the house as a physical environment In early modern houses, as now, space was used in coherent and socially meaningful ways. There is a great deal of evidence about buildings; indeed, there is almost too much, because studies of particular buildings tend to emphasize individual variation rather than general features.11 Inventories show that most households of middle rank had houses with between three and six rooms, although some of the farmhouses were very much larger.12 Houses surveyed in Gloucestershire were larger, probably because only the larger houses have survived; here most had eight to ten rooms.13 The most common arrangement was two or three rooms on a ground floor, with rooms over them. The groundfloor rooms were variously called parlour, hall, houseplace, and kitchen; the rooms above were normally called chambers.14 There were also outhouses for working tools and farming equipment. This meant that there were enough rooms for activities to be carried out in separate parts of the house, and this has significance for the ways in which space was used within the house. Houses also had movable goods which were, by our standards, sparse, although less so than they had been in the earlier part of the seventeenth century. There were increases in domestic utensils and furnishings by the early eighteenth century, and some houses had a wide variety of such things, but many did not. It is here that illustrations can help us to visualize how bare some interiors
INTRODUCTION
Plate 1 Grace before a Meal, J.Van Aken, c. 1720 (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford). The best and most realistic illustration of a middle-rank lifestyle.
could be. Paintings and engravings of domestic interiors show that tables were laid for meals in very simple ways, ornamentation was rare, curtains at windows were unusual, armchairs and carpets were confined to a very few houses, and there were
7
8
INTRODUCTION
generally few pieces of furniture. Van Aken’s Grace before a Meal is a good instance of an evocation of one corner of an English room. The bare floor and walls are immediately striking, as is the absence of curtains, ornaments, or wall hangings. In the sample of 3,000 inventories only a small proportion recorded window curtains (13 per cent), pictures (13 per cent), or decorative china (4 per cent). The wealthier London tradesmen more often had these things (81 per cent recorded window curtains and 41 per cent china), but these people were exceptional in that they were more likely than any others in England, apart from the wealthiest gentry, to own such new or decorative goods. So Van Aken does seem to be portraying a likeness that was not untypical of middleranking homes at the time. The picture shows very simple tableware, with no cutlery as we would use it and no table ornaments; this too was typical, in that knives and forks were recorded in only 4 per cent of the whole sample of inventories (14 per cent in London and 33 per cent in the London Orphans’ Court sample). The plates are of pewter, and this too would be expected, for china and earthenware plates were very unusual until the middle of the eighteenth century. The painting also illustrates that a living room of this kind was used for different purposes; in this case there is furniture for storage, a table set for a meal, and a spit for roasting over the fire. These and other aspects of domestic use of space are fully discussed in chapter 7, although they are implicit in the general approaches of the whole book. Differences between consumption of furnishings and consumption of clothing are also suggested by the fact that the clothing is more elaborate than the background, just as a higher proportion of expenditure was devoted to it, as is shown in chapter 6.
Interpretations: domestic space and social meaning There is no single analysis of relationships between material and social life, but there are several interrelated approaches that are suggestive of the social meanings of physical surroundings. Behind all of them is the assumption that buildings and interiors were constructed to convey social meanings as well as for practical purposes. Sometimes the symbolism is obvious, such as the wealth and power conveyed by the architecture of large country houses. More often, at a domestic level, the impact of a place or interior was more subtle and its meanings subconsciously achieved. This
INTRODUCTION
impact arose partly (as it still does) from the shared expectations and culture of the people using it. Material goods, such as furnishings, made physical and visible statements about accepted values and expected behaviour. They were used to draw lines in social relationships, at the same time as providing shelter and subsistence. The notion that the built environment and the domestic space had social meanings has been effectively explored by historians of nineteenth-century housing but has been less in evidence in the work of historians of the early modern period. Likewise, those studying the buildings have made more use of these ideas than historians of their contents.15 One useful way of interpreting behaviour and responses to the environment is to take specific account of how people endeavoured to present themselves to others in everyday situations, using ideas derived from studies of the present day.16 In order to foster particular images, people present themselves to others in ways that are analogous to actors’ methods of presenting themselves to an audience. Various techniques are used for fostering particular impressions, such as facial expression, tones of voice, clothing, and, of course, physical surroundings. This kind of ‘presentation of self’ does not apply in all situations and normally takes place at an automatic and subconscious level, but it is an everyday activity, both in the home and elsewhere. In putting forward these views, Goffman and, later, Portnoy have distinguished between use of space in different parts of the living area.17 When people are in the presence of others or when they are actively fostering their image, their behaviour is different from when they are doing essentially private things. Thus there are ‘front stages’, which are the settings of activities in which people present themselves to others, and can be likened to a theatrical stage. The appearance and ambiance of the ‘front stage’ affect the way in which individuals or households can present themselves. Likewise, the ‘back stage’ is analogous to the back stage of a theatre. Thus we can attempt to interpret the social roles of some possessions by observing use of space and assessing the values that were placed on activities from the point of view both of the kinds of goods that were found in different parts of the house and of the kinds of activities that took place there. That this is a useful approach is shown by the fact that some parts of houses were more valued than others. Rooms were used for different purposes because different values were attached to different parts of the living space. In both England and Scotland
9
10
INTRODUCTION
households had a general living room, which in England was variously called the houseplace, house, or hall.18 In the smaller houses this contained furniture and equipment for many household activities, such as tables, seating, cooking equipment, storage space, pewter, and miscellaneous other goods associated with daytime living. In England it was virtually unknown to have a bed in the main living room, although in Scotland enclosed and folding beds were normally to be found in the main living area. In England the main room sometimes had decorative things such as pictures, a looking glass, a clock, or books. A room used for many activities, such as that of Elizabeth Bullock of Wrockwardine in Shropshire (she was a spinster and schoolmistress), was only unusual in that she carried on her trade (schoolteaching), had a bed, and cooked in the same room. £ s d In the loft which was the place where shee kept schoole in one Truckelbed with the furniture thereunto. Itm In the same Roome one little table Three buffet stooles & a low ioyned stoole with a drawer Two Greene Chaires seven benches & four little stooles. Itm In the same Roome one brasse pot three little iron pots one very little kettle one boxe to hold salt a paire of bellowes one grate a paire of pothookes a paire of tounges a fire shouvl one plate to warme drinke before the fire a paire of Pot Geales and a ffrying pan.
1 0 0
010 0
1 0 0
She had a two-room dwelling, and the other room was ‘her lodging Chamber’, which was nicely furnished, with a bed (valued at £5, quite a high sum), tables, trunks, shelves, pewter, a looking glass, ‘three Jugs with blue spots’, linen and sheets (£5), cloth and clothes (£4. 6s. 8d.), and books (£1).19 In Scotland, even among the better-off tenants (roughly the equivalent of yeomen) room use was less specialized and houses were small, even in the mid-eighteenth century. A retrospective description of the farmers’ living conditions around 1765 mentions two rooms, the but (or kitchen) and the ben (or parlour). The kitchen was used for a large number of activities, much as the English houseplace was, but with some important differences:
INTRODUCTION
it was the general eating chamber, and one of the principal sleeping-rooms. Besides, it was the place where all the victuals were prepared: where they baked the bread, kirned the milk, washed the clothes and ironed them;…it was the general rendezvous of all the comers and gangers about the family.20 This in a room 14 by 16 feet and containing standing beds. The other room, the ben, was something like an English parlour, with the master’s bed and personal possessions, the Bible, linen, and food storage. In houses such as these the distinction between ‘front’ and ‘back’ becomes blurred, for there were no places devoted to specific activities, although the ben clearly served more private needs for some of the household members, while the but was more public.21 This kind of use of space is illustrated in Claud and Peggy by David Allan, which depicts various kinds of activity in a very small space. Rooms could be more specialized when the house was larger. The evidence from England is better here, and many inventories show that there were service areas, such as a kitchen, a dairy, or a buttery, for some of the messier activities. Chambers were common in all houses in England, where they were used for both sleeping and storage. In Scotland, houses larger than the ‘but and ben’ also contained separate rooms devoted to sleeping and storage. Chambers were normally sparsely furnished and, although some had decorative objects in them, they had the characteristics of ‘backstage’ areas. That the use of space in houses served social functions, and was subject to modification, can be seen from changes in room use. The most interesting change in England in the late seventeenth century was that the parlour, formerly a best bedroom with some seating and storage, became a best living room, containing decorative things and new types of furniture. These contrasting parlours of urban tradesmen illustrate the change. The first dates from 1674/5.22 £ s d In the Parlour A fether bedd bedsted and Furniture a Truckle bedd with Furniture a Chest Three Trunckes one Shelfe an old viol & a little range 4 0 0 The second, from 1717, illustrates how the parlour could be used in new ways, in this case as a room for meals, although sometimes they were furnished for other activities too.23
11
12
INTRODUCTION
Plate 2 Claud and Peggy, David Allan, c. 1780s (National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh). Many activities at the same time in one Scottish living room. There is an enclosed bed in the background. In the Parlour
£ s d In the Parlour 6 cane chaires 2 Elbow chaires One ovell Table 25 picktures great and small One tea Tabble 6 sawcers 6 cupps, two slopp basons one Tea pott One dish one cannister and stand one glass lanthorne 2 bird cages Window curtains and vallence one house Cloath
3 3 6
INTRODUCTION
Yet there was also continuity, for parlours like the first could be found well into the eighteenth century, as this example of 1748 shows.24 £ s d In the Parlour a Feather Bed, Bedsteads, Bolsters, sheets, Blanketts hangings & furniture 110 0 a Chest of drawes, one Ovall Table and Eight join’d Chairs 1 2 0 a Clock and Hanging Press 119 0 Whether they changed or not, the furniture, fittings, and utensils of a house made up the material culture of domestic life. This, in turn, was closely associated with the practical functions and social purposes of households. Relationships between ordinary activities, social mores and material life need to be explored in order that consumption, and specifically ownership, of household goods, can be properly placed within the contexts in which they were used. This means that it is essential to describe the numerous, time-consuming, and arduous activities necessarily undertaken in all households. These were central to the organization of space within the house, and only the larger houses had space devoted exclusively to things other than cookery, eating, cleaning, sleeping, and resting. This is the particular subject of chapter 7, but the observation that all domestic activities contributed towards the generation of the material environment is of central importance to the arguments in the book. If ownership patterns and consumer behaviour are to be understood in a social context, then patterns of household activities and their meanings need careful consideration.
Social status and occupation: the middle ranks There are several possible ways of defining the ‘middling’ parts of society in the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. For the purposes of this book, the middle ranks are taken to encompass people who were neither at the bottom (servants, labourers, and wage-earners) nor at the top (county gentry and aristocracy) of the social hierarchy as outlined by King and Massie.25 They therefore include the lesser gentry, professions, merchants,
13
14
INTRODUCTION
shopkeepers, farmers, yeomen, husbandmen, and craftsmen. About half the households in the country fell into these groups in the late seventeenth century (about 700,000 out of 1,400,000). In the mideighteenth century there may have been rather more than half in the middle ranks, Massie’s estimate suggesting about a million out of one and a half million. It is important to realize that the boundaries between the middle and lower ranks are not clear. Husbandmen, for instance, were sometimes barely able to maintain themselves and were quite unlike the better-off farmers or even craftsmen. In tracing their incomes and consumption, one must take into account the nuances of difference within occupations, a point developed more fully in chapters 5 and 8. In order to draw on as large a part of society as possible, and to remain sensitive to differences and complexities in occupation and status, I have taken as broad and pragmatic a definition as possible. The middle ranks were economically, socially, and politically important. Even in the seventeenth century the largest market for new and imported goods was among these consumers, and the wealthiest had an impressive range of household goods. They also made up the local social and political elites in villages and towns; many were enfranchised. The professions were of increasing importance, as were merchants and shopkeepers. Many were the forerunners of the nineteenth-century ‘middle classes’, a term already in use in the later eighteenth century. Some in the middle ranks had distinctly consumerist tastes and a need to assert their position in society in subtle ways. What is less obvious is that there were very many of modest means who sought to live ‘not exposed to the miseries and hardships…and not embarrassed with the pride, luxury, ambition and envy’.26
Consumption, luxury, and necessity Other concepts have been used to link consumption and social life. Much writing on living standards is based on an attempt to distinguish between expenditure that was, in some sense, essential to maintaining physical life, and other goods and services. Here the vocabulary of ‘necessity’ and ‘luxury’ is frequently deployed. The contrast has some point in enabling us to gauge what kinds of things were held to be important, but in practice it is not a sophisticated enough approach to enable us to understand the meanings of consumption, especially among the middle ranks.
INTRODUCTION
What were basic necessities? Did people die without them or were they just uncomfortable? It is hard to know how to define a necessity in our own culture; different people have different purposes for wanting to do so. It is harder still to do so in retrospect, but our views on the necessity for running water, sewage disposal, and central heating cannot usefully be translated into a critique of early modern consumption. But the distinction between ‘necessity’ and ‘luxury’ is one that has attracted historians, and we need to consider the meaning and impact of this well-known, if misleading, vocabulary.27 The meanings of these terms vary with circumstances: the word ‘luxury’ is normally used to convey the idea of consumption of costly and high-quality goods, food, or services; it can also carry some implicit judgement that luxuries are immoral. There is also an implied contrast with ‘necessity’, so that ‘luxury’ can also contain the meaning that ‘If it had been done without by an earlier age, it was unnecessary and therefore a luxury’.28 The word has also commonly meant something that is desirable but not indispensable, but possibly of higher quality and price than other goods of a similar nature: ‘all that assemblage which is rather intended to please the fancy, than obviate the real wants, and which is rather ornamental than useful’.29 The cultural aspect of luxuries is also recognized by their ability to mark the rank of the owner and thus communicate social position in a non-verbal way.30 This frequently used word is a shorthand for a number of social and economic ideas, and its use has a certain interest in showing how ownership of some goods could be seen in polemic terms, but it does not provide a firm basis for understanding consumer behaviour. Nor does it provide any means of identifying whether particular goods should be identified as ‘luxuries’ or not. It is equally difficult to pinpoint a ‘necessity’. In the late seventeenth century most household goods did not ‘obviate the real wants’ in the sense that some form of physical life could have been uncomfortably maintained without them. While it is amusing to speculate on the minimal food, clothing, and utensils needed for people to survive, it does not make sense to interpret behaviour in these terms, for this was already a society in which people expected to have a selection of domestic goods, although their homes seem sparsely furnished to modern eyes. So, while a ‘necessity’ could be defined as something necessary to maintain life, this is an abstract definition and not a meaningful startingpoint for discussing consumption. One reason for this is
15
16
INTRODUCTION
fundamental to the way in which social historians approach these matters, for people did not just have physical requirements; they valued the non-material aspects of their lives, such as reading, religion, family life, friends, gossip, and games; they were aware of many satisfactions in life. What people as individuals, or together as a society, felt was ‘necessary’ has also to be taken into account and can be understood only by observing their behaviour and priorities, as well as what they chose to own. The idea that there were classes of goods between ‘luxuries’ and ‘necessities’, usually referred to as ‘decencies’, modifies the stark contrasts in the vocabulary but does not remove the need to take account of the priorities shown within a society. These terms should be as carefully used as words about class. Consumption and society have also been linked in characterizations of the ‘consumer society’ or ‘consumerism’ in the eighteenth century. Accounts of the exuberant enjoyments, increasingly available as the century progressed, make compulsive reading, with amusing anecdotes about the consumerist pleasures of the wealthy, the excesses of those who strived to be fashionably dressed, and the attempts of tradesmen to satisfy this kind of demand.31 This social history of consumerism is confined to the wealthier tradesmen and the gentry, who had the time and resources for an increasing range of goods and services by the later eighteenth century. It is hard to see through this to other consumers, whose behaviour is difficult to dramatize, but whose experience was that of a larger proportion of the middle-ranking population. Excitement about new goods and services became much greater towards the end of the eighteenth century and, although fashion and enjoyment were clearly experienced in the late seventeenth century, the ‘consumerist’ approach is not so appropriately applied either to the earlier period or to the bulk of the middle ranks.
Consumption and economic change The main themes in this study are essentially social and cultural. These have not, however, been the approaches favoured by most writers about consumption. A very large amount written on this subject arises from attempts to explain industrialization in the second half of the eighteenth century,32 although there are also studies of the pre-industrial era that refer to consumption.33
INTRODUCTION
These works discuss the role of the home market and of demand, as opposed to production and overseas trade. Early writers, especially Gilboy in the 1930s, and later Eversley, outlined ideas and possibilities that still have not been properly tested and developed. To use Gilboy’s words: ‘Obviously the factory system with its complicated industrial mechanism cannot function profitably without a large and growing demand ready and willing to absorb its products as fast as they are produced…. Why…should the home population suddenly afford a market for a greater number of products?’34 Gilboy’s explanations were that there were increases in real incomes (by which she meant wages) and that new ‘wants’ were spread throughout the population partly as a result of inter-class competition and mobility. But, although she recognized the limitations of the evidence then available, she called for ‘continued investigation of demand in relation to the Industrial Revolution’. This has certainly been done in the half-century or so since she wrote, and no account of the economy in the eighteenth century is without a discussion of ‘demand’ in some form or other; but, as a recent survey puts it, ‘the study of the subject is still severely handicapped by the lack of adequate quantitative data’.35 There continues to be an uncertainty in the literature as to the importance of demand in economic change, and whether it came primarily from the home market or from exports.36 Eversley’s work is important here because it emphasizes the role of the middle ranks within the home market and thus the significance of the households that are the main subject of this book. Economic historians have also looked at consumption from the perspective of single industries, or even single businesses. Most business or industrial histories make some attempt to outline the markets for the products made, in order to provide a context for discussions of growth, business decisions, or the fortunes of individuals.37 These studies often point towards the industrial revolution, but they are normally based on well-documented accounts of particular parts of the economy that cover a longer time span than the late eighteenth century. Coleman’s study of the silk industry, at the beginning of his larger study of one company within it, exemplifies this, for here the focus is clearly on production, manufacturing techniques, and supplies of raw material, but the importance of a broader market for simple silks is recognized and production explained in terms of available markets.
17
18
INTRODUCTION
The meanings that the consumers themselves attached to silk, and any other implications of its use, go unremarked.38 In this, as in all studies of industrial change, the focus is on production, while the consumers themselves are taken for granted. Business decisions are seen as influencing the market and thus consumption, but the responses and choices made by consumers are not the central issue. This approach is found in a very large and distinguished body of writing on industrial change, although some recent writers have shown a greater sensitivity to the importance of understanding the people who bought things.39 On the other hand, there is a valuable sensitivity to the economic and other constraints on producers and a regard for the qualities of different kinds of products in these writings, which are also less limited chronologically to explaining the industrial revolution; they tend to trace developments as far back in time as documentary and other evidence allows, and especially into the late seventeenth century. Approaches to consumption by way of enquiries into increasing demand in the eighteenth century are, as already implied, beset with problems. The factual basis is extremely insecure at a national level. For instance, the production series for ‘home industries’ presented by Deane and Cole are narrowly based on a few products, namely soap, leather, candles, and beer. These were unfortunate enough to catch the eye of the eighteenthcentury excise, and as such were by no means representative of all, or even many, products for the home market.40 No domestic durables were included, although other studies have shown that these were liable to rapid change.41 The output of this narrow range of ‘home’ industries is shown as virtually static from 1700 to 1750 at a time when ‘export’ industries were estimated almost to have doubled. But there were some rapidly expanding trades at this time, making a hitherto unknown range of goods available to some of the population. There are also problems with chronology. Studying demand in the economy arose out of a longstanding desire to explain and understand the industrial revolution. This has meant that the late seventeenth and the early eighteenth centuries have been presented as a time when nothing much happened. Later developments in the structure of production, in imports of materials, and the output of many industries are seen as completely overshadowing the less dramatic changes of the earlier period. Likewise interest is strongest in those issues that seem to offer explanations for later
INTRODUCTION
growth. These essentially macro-economic approaches do not go very far in describing and explaining the processes of consumption because they are asking questions about economic transformation, statistical aggregation, and the causes of the industrial revolution. As an instance of this, it is notable that an economic study of brewing was published in 1959, but historians have only recently tried to put the consumption of ale in a social perspective through studies of inns and alehouses.42 So this kind of approach does not aim to illuminate the experiences of consumers themselves, and especially not consumers in the earlier part of the eighteenth century. Nevertheless, the chronology of change is important, and chapter 2 examines patterns of growth derived from the sample of probate inventories.
Consumption, wages, and living standards A further economic approach to consumption in the historical literature focuses on wages and living standards. This too arises from interest in economic growth and production, rather than from a concern for the behaviour of consumers themselves, but questions are sometimes posed about the expenditure patterns of individuals and their behaviour as consumers. For instance, A.H. John and others following him have argued that lower food prices between about 1730 and 1750 enabled wage-earners to have a small surplus to spend on domestic goods and clothing, thus stimulating innovation in industrial production in the early stages of economic growth. Eversley has argued that a similar momentum continued until 1780.43 These ideas have not gone unchallenged and are based on fragile evidence, but they exemplify the way in which writers have made broad generalizations about consumption habits and economic growth. Evidence from inventories about these issues is presented in chapter 8, and the conclusion that wage-earners were unlikely to have been important in consumption is stressed again in chapter 9. In a different context, assumptions have necessarily been made about consumption patterns of wage-earners when calculations are made for price series. Here consumption is seen in terms of a ‘basket of goods’ needed to define the weightings of price series. Any attempt to estimate ‘cost of living’ is based on assumptions about, or observations of, consumer behaviour, but the main
19
20
INTRODUCTION
problem with these studies in the early modern period is that the factual basis for many statements about living standards is founded on very little evidence about expenditure, and on too narrow an approach to income—problems that those who have done the calculations acknowledge more readily than those who have used the results.44 Recent research has adopted different viewpoints because it is apparent that living standards, incomes, and expenditure were too complex to be characterized by contrasts like wages/prices. The idea that people adopted complex strategies for survival, obtaining wages and incomes from many sources, enables us to understand individual behaviour in a less abstracted way, although it makes it harder to trace long-term changes in incomes.45 This book does not confront these issues directly because it concentrates on the middle ranks, rather than on wage-earners. It does, however, interpret incomes in terms of the various strategies for survival and shows that incomes were derived from many sources. The two chapters about the incomes and expenditure of middle-ranking households (chapters 5 and 6) are based on an analysis of household accounts and diaries. One suggestion about living standards has been that people copied one another for social reasons. Thus markets for industrial goods were able to develop in Britain because there was no legislation to prevent people owning what they wanted and copying the behaviour of the upper ranks. In theory people could dress how they liked and own what goods they liked and there were no institutional barriers to new goods being available to a large part of the population.46 This important observation about the relationship between social structure and production has been developed in a number of ways. One of these has been the idea that people readily copied one another in order to keep up appearances and to follow the lead of those of higher social status than themselves in the kinds of clothing and possessions that they owned. Perkin has especially noted the tendency for people to emulate those of higher rank; Hecht suggests that the employment of servants by the wealthier people in the population helped to spread new ideas and habits to the lower classes; McKendrick and Minchinton have argued that the pursuit of fashion, and the commercialization that went with it, broke down resistance to consumption and enabled a fully fledged consumer society to emerge at the end of the eighteenth century.47 These approaches to social relations and consumer behaviour are, however, limited to specific situations and groups of people; they do not provide a
INTRODUCTION
satisfactory framework for discussion of the experiences involved in consumption for the majority of people of middle rank. The cross-tabulations of ownership of goods from inventories in chapter 8 do show that there was a consumption hierarchy, with goods recorded in some groups more frequently than in others. This was not, however, the same as the social hierarchy.
The artefacts There is also a large amount written about the artefacts themselves, that is to say clothing, costume, domestic utensils, and furniture. Surviving artefacts are cared for in museums or collected privately, and this influences the works about them, for their main intention is to provide detailed guides, descriptions, and attributions. This fact, together with the nature of the surviving objects themselves, gives a quite different view of consumption.48 Pottery and porcelain, for instance, have generated an enormous collectors’ literature with fully researched discussions on all the collectable pottery available in the eighteenth century, but the focus tends to be on the most valuable pieces; there are even specialist journals.49 Likewise, the study and collection of furniture and costume has generated specialist collections in museums and a specialist literature.50 The intentions of those who study the objects themselves are so different from the intentions of economic and social historians that it takes considerable imagination to bridge the gap and see any relevance in this work for the study of consumption.51 Collectors are interested in the objects themselves, in their aesthetic qualities, origins, date, and sometimes monetary value, although there is some interest in the economic and social background to production and consumption. Thus there are some very good studies of makers, but the focus is usually on attribution of an object to a maker. On the other hand, economic and social historians tend to regard the objects as illustrative material for their studies and show a surprising disregard for the physical remains of the past. The main problem with the very large literature on the artefacts themselves is that the surviving pieces are those of the highest quality and greatest aesthetic appeal. It is impossible to analyse the style of pottery or furnishings found in a yeoman’s or tradesman’s house in the early eighteenth century from displays in even the most comprehensive collections, such as the primary
21
22
INTRODUCTION
galleries in the Victoria and Albert Museum in London. Likewise, galleries with reconstructed interiors, such as those at the Geffrye Museum in London, or at the Victoria and Albert Museum, show objects and interiors owned by the wealthier members of society. In the same way, the otherwise enlightening and interesting books on styles of furnishings in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries refer largely to the country houses of the gentry or to the large town houses of the well-to-do, not to the houses of the bulk of middle-ranking people.52 Studies of design and artefacts thus provide only a partial view of the goods themselves. Even so, there is much more here than most writers of general histories and students of consumption itself admit. That physical remains can be used to illuminate consumption is shown in Spufford’s study of the linen trade where she illustrates a few, rare examples of clothing worn by people in the lower parts of society.53 This book partly originated in these approaches, through an earlier attempt to explore consumption and production in the pottery industry.54 Looking at consumption from the perspective of particular goods, as well as looking at surviving examples, has a great deal of merit in it. But, from the point of view of consumers themselves, we need to know about their behaviour, the goods they owned, and their priorities. Ideally we require lists of the goods, clothing, and textiles owned by all households every few years, so that we could trace who owned what, and changes could be clearly documented. But historical evidence is rarely ideal, and this book makes the most of what is available in order to explore the motivation behind consumer behaviour. This begins, in the next chapter, with an outline of changing consumption after 1670.
Part 1
THE NATION
2 GROWTH
In travelling thro’ England…which way soever we look, we see something new. (Daniel Defoe, 1727)1 The purpose of this chapter is to set the scene by demonstrating that the ownership of domestic goods increased between 1675 and 1725. This establishes that the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries were marked by brisk changes, some based on industrial expansion, others on increasing imports of consumer items. These years used to be thought of as ones of restricted development, but it is now realized that there were growth areas as well as structural changes. The impression of stagnation is derived from figures from the excise records, but these are not representative of the economy as a whole.2 In the last fifteen years many more statistical series have become available, as well as an important study of the East India trade.3 One of the most important conclusions from the sample of inventories is that ownership of all household goods increased before 1725. This confirms the importance of the latter part of the seventeenth century and the early years of the eighteenth century. Table 2.1 shows the proportions of inventories in each decade in which the selected goods were recorded in the main sample. Table 2.2 shows the same information for the sample taken from the inventories of the London Orphans’ Court. Changes in consumer behaviour are clearly apparent; virtually all goods were recorded more frequently in 1725 than previously. In some cases, expansion in ownership was very dramatic. Clocks, for instance, were over three times more frequent by 1715 than they had been in 1685; in the wealthy households of the London freemen they 25
Sources and notes Main samnle: see aooendices 1 and 2 for the oriein of the samole and its limitations
Table 2.1 Frequencies of ownership of selected household goods in a sample of inventories from England, 1675–1725
Sources and notes London Orphan’s Court sample, City of London Record Office. See appendix 1 for comments on the sample.
Table 2.2 Frequencies with which selected goods were recorded in a sample of inventories from the London Orphans’ Court, 1675–1725
28
THE NATION
were already recorded in over a half in 1675, but increased until nine out often had them by 1715. The greatest expansion was in ownership of china and utensils for hot drinks in the freemen’s inventories; the latter were extremely rare, even in the 1690s, but were recorded in virtually all of these households by 1725. The period after 1670 was therefore one of changing consumption, and the changes in frequency with which goods were recorded in households offers the basis for a chronological framework within which other aspects of consumer behaviour can be seen.
Patterns of change There were three patterns of change in the frequencies with which items were recorded in both series of inventories. A few goods were well established in the 1670s; these are representative of basic furniture and utensils (pewter, tables, and cooking pots), many associated with ‘backstage’ activities. These also represent well-established aspects of the economy. Secondly, some goods were already in use in 1675 but were not common; these include books, silver, table linen, pewter dishes, pewter plates, looking glasses, and earthenware. They were mostly associated with ‘frontstage’ activities. Change here was often rapid. Lastly, there were some important new goods, some of which were virtually unknown in 1675, such as china and various equipment for the new hot drinks, tea, coffee, and chocolate. Others were extremely rare in 1675, including clocks, pictures, window curtains, and knives and forks. They too were ‘frontstage’ goods and were either decorative or associated with new mealtime behaviour. Ownership of them all expanded very rapidly. Established goods were found in most inventories in the first decade of the survey, together with many other basic items that have not been selected for particular study. They were not recorded in every inventory, but the tiny upward movement reflects growing ownership of commonplace goods. Each item had its own idiosyncrasies, and pewter is especially interesting, for it had declined slightly (4 per cent) in frequency by 1725. This is within the margins of error for the survey, but it is also in keeping with what we know about the development of pewter manufacture at this time, which reached its zenith in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries and was thereafter very gradually replaced by crockery and glass. The only sign of this replacement
GROWTH
by 1725 is in the Kent sample, where the frequency with which it was recorded was much lower (91 per cent) than it had been in 1705, when every inventory had had it. There were unusually high proportions of inventories with earthenware in this area, and earthenware plates and tablewares were often specified, also unusual at this date elsewhere. But this ‘replacement’ effect was mild, and pewter predominated for some time, gradually fading out in the later eighteenth century as crockery became standard. In the wealthier households of the Orphans’ Court inventories there were similar patterns of change for established goods, with high frequencies to begin with and slight growth by 1725. The main difference was that a wider range of goods was already well established in 1675, including many ‘frontstage’ goods. Looking glasses, for instance, were found in 86 per cent of Orphans’ Court inventories as early as 1685 and in virtually all of them by 1725. Ownership of established goods in inventories relates to those parts of the economy and society that had been functioning for some time and had relatively limited scope for expansion. Whether they can also be said to represent ‘traditional’ aspects of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century life is more difficult to say, for to observe that something was already there is not the same as to say that it had had long acceptance or was an underlying part of the structure of society. But it is clear that there were many wellestablished goods which represent less rapidly changing aspects of the economy and of consumers’ lives. It is also significant that these were either furniture or goods with functions in food preparation. There were more varied patterns of change among the things that were unusual in 1675. Some showed little or no increase; book ownership, for instance, changed very little in aggregate, although this was made up of substantial increases in London by 1725 (from 18 to 56 per cent) and other towns of all kinds (from 20 to 36 per cent) and decline in rural areas (from 18 to 13 per cent). Likewise, the frequencies with which silver was recorded declined slightly overall, resulting from a combination of mild decrease in some areas and mild increases elsewhere. Silver was more common in the London sample than elsewhere; in 1675, 48 per cent in London owned silver, but only 8 per cent in Carlisle and 9 per cent in the Cambridgeshire samples, while virtually all Orphans’ Court inventories recorded it. Influences on the ownership of silver were probably different from those on any
29
30
THE NATION
other item here, because it had an intrinsic value and fluctuations in ownership could have varied with family needs and prosperity. It could have represented the ‘traditional’ attitude of investing in things of known value rather than spending money on other goods of a more useful or decorative nature. If it did represent anything about attitudes, the patterns of change shown here do not suggest that these altered much in this period, and, if it is taken as a material which was acquired for its relatively high value, then hoarding of increased wealth is not apparent either. On the other hand, ownership of some goods (earthenware, pewter dishes, pewter plates, looking glasses) increased dramatically; the proportion of households with earthenware and looking glasses more than doubled between 1675 and 1725. Again there were considerable variations from place to place, both in the frequencies recorded at the beginning and in amounts of growth. In Lancashire, earthenware was recorded in most inventories (82 per cent) in 1675, with an unusual downward trend thereafter to 65 per cent in 1725. In Kent, it was recorded in only 38 per cent in 1675 but in most (88 per cent) of them by 1725. But the composite picture is of earthenware as a known, but not ubiquitous, item in 1675, ownership of which grew rapidly by 1725. In the Orphans’ Court inventories, earthenware was much more common to begin with and grew to being one of the most frequently recorded materials by 1725. Looking-glass ownership was similarly varied and complex. In some dioceses, looking glasses were virtually unrecorded in 1675 (Carlisle 3 per cent, Cambridgeshire 6 per cent, for instance), but were quite common in other areas (London 34 per cent, Kent 37 per cent), and they were already well established in the Orphans’ Court inventories. Growth did occur everywhere except in Carlisle and Staffordshire, while in the Orphans’ Court inventories they became, with the exception of tables, the most frequently recorded item by 1725. The evidence for pewter dishes and plates is less firmly based because of residual doubts (outlined in appendix 1) that they may have been seriously under-recorded in some places; but, if omissions were reasonably consistent in the five dioceses examined in table 2.1, then interesting patterns can be seen here too. Plates were smaller than dishes and were used by individuals rather than for eating in a communal way. The differences in shape and size can be seen from illustrations of mealtimes in chapter 7 and also from valuations, for dishes were normally valued at between one and two shillings; while plates were cheaper,
GROWTH
at about sixpence each—which is indicative of their smaller size. Rapid growth in ownership of pewter plates is therefore more important than it might seem because they are indicators, with many other goods, of changing behaviour at meals. The frequencies with which new goods were recorded changed extremely rapidly between 1700 and 1725. The Orphans’ Court inventories were slightly different, in that the only goods that were rare in 1675 were those that were entirely new, but these displayed exceptionally rapid expansion. Utensils for hot drinks were found in less than 10 per cent of the Orphans’ sample in 1695 but thirty years later were in virtually all of them. China similarly changed from being unknown in 1675 to being a normal part of household equipment by 1715. In the main sample there were important regional and other variations, and it is here that some of the influences over consumer behaviour and preferences stand but most clearly. The things that were already known in 1675, even if they were unusual, increased in frequency in all dioceses, although the places with fewest at the beginning usually had fewest at the end. Clock ownership was slightly different, in that Lancashire and London joined Kent as the areas with the highest proportions (about 50 per cent) with them. Clocks were also exceptional in that only a slightly lower proportion of households had them in rural than in urban areas, while ownership of the rest increased more in urban areas, with London predominating. In the Orphans’ Court inventories, ownership of these things grew more rapidly from a higher starting-point, with the result that clocks, pictures, and curtains were to be found in virtually every household by 1715, at a time when they continued to be very rare in some of the main sample. Ownership of completely new goods was more varied, for they were quite common in some places by 1725 but still virtually unknown in others. Thus china was not recorded in Staffordshire until 1725, whereas it first appeared in the Durham sample in 1685. Utensils for hot drinks, recorded in Kent in 1685, did not appear in the Cambridgeshire sample until 1725. This meant that growth was more concentrated in some areas than others; by 1725, 60 per cent of London inventories recorded utensils for hot drinks, whereas only 6 per cent of those in rural areas had them. China appeared in 35 per cent of the London sample but in only 4 per cent of rural areas by 1725. This kind of wide variation suggests that there were uneven economic, commercial, and social mechanisms at work which led to new goods being more readily available in some places than others. In this respect,
31
32
THE NATION
the Orphans’ Court inventories show just how fast new commodities could, in favourable circumstances, be adopted. Distinctions between new and established goods are useful in showing variety in patterns of change, although observation of increasing frequencies for new goods is implicit in this kind of evidence, for, although households contained many of them, I have chosen only a few that had little room for growth. What this does show is that changing ownership was based both on new commodities and on those that were already known, so expansion was not confined to new wants and behaviour, but it is notable that the most rapid growth took place in those goods used for entirely new purposes. Thus earthenware and china spread as utensils for hot drinks, whereas the use of new materials for tableware was a later development which took much longer to finalize. This confirms the need to examine carefully how goods were used and the roles that they fulfilled in the lives of the people who owned them.
Other kinds of change Whether particular items were present in households conveys a surprising amount about changing consumer preferences and the ownership of goods, but there were other changes too. Utensils and miscellaneous household goods changed in appearance and style, while households came to own more of them, so that the overall effect was of rooms which were less bare and more decorative, although the chronology of these changes is difficult to pinpoint. There were quality changes which are also hard to pinpoint because most of the furniture, china, teawares, pictures, and mirrors that have survived tend to be those of higher quality. Ordinary products have long since been discarded. Thus museum collections of china contain high-quality pieces, and discussions of domestic interiors tend to concentrate on the élite, as do the histories of furniture.4 It is not, of course, improper that museums should concentrate on artistic merit and design, but we should not assume that the items preserved in collections are representative of the whole of society. Likewise, the formalized interiors painted as backgrounds in the English conversation pieces of the 1740s depict idealized interiors of the gentry and others who were generally richer than the majority of the people covered by this study, and give a false picture of their environment.
GROWTH
The heavy architectural and artistic styles of the baroque and the lighter styles of the rococo were reflected in high-quality household goods and furniture, but these influenced fashionable style in London and had less impact on even the best locally made furniture in the provinces. As far as most middling households were concerned, these styles were of marginal relevance, for much furniture was very simply made and has not been thought worth keeping, so that any changes in appearance cannot be reconstructed. There was considerable continuity in the styles of some utensils; cooking pots and kettles, for instance, varied in shape but were basically the same in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries as they had been before and continued to be after. Some differences in furniture resulted in part from changes in the organization of the furniture-making trades, as well as in fashionable taste. In the seventeenth century, even in London, the joiner was the main woodworking craftsman, but the trade of cabinet-maker developed in the late seventeenth century in the London quality trade. Cabinet-makers made high-quality furniture, especially chests of drawers and tables. They also used new woods, such as walnut and mahogany, and new techniques, such as veneering, which resulted in lighter, more varied furniture. In addition, cane chairs became popular in the late seventeenth century, although they went out of fashion in the 1720s. Some of these new techniques, and the trade of cabinet-maker, spread to the provinces in the early eighteenth century, although furniture normally continued to be made locally by joiners. Many of the short-lived fashion changes were not relevant to the possessions of the middle ranks and especially not to the husbandmen or farmers who are the subject of much of this study. The pace of change in styles probably increased by the 1730s, when the value of designing properly for the high-class trades was appreciated, with the first pattern books dating from the 1750s (although fulltime designers were not known until the late eighteenth century).5 Some changes in modest households can be seen in contrasts between living rooms in the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. A farmer’s living room in 1676/7 had very sparse and basic furnishings.6 £ s d It in the dwelling howse one longe table 6 joyned stooles one Cubbord
33
34
THE NATION
£ s 3 Chaires one little table one fire grate fire showell & tonges one jack three spits prised at 3 0 It Brass pewter of all sorts prised at 5 0 It two Iron pots one dreping pan 2 frying pans & other Ware prised at 015 It Butter & Cheese hemp & flax prised 2 0
d 0 0 0 0
It in the plor one fether Bed and bedclothes boulster prised at 010 0 one chest & one table Boord & other things therein prised at 010 0 Later examples have a different feel about them.7 £ s d In the hall place one Clock & Case 1 large grate 2 Tables & 2 forms 8 Joyned Chaires. 1 warming pan, 1 dreeping pan one Northprospect of London In the little parlour 13 cane Chaires 1 oval Table 1 looking glass. 1 Day Table & some smal pictures
6 4 0
6 5 0
An unusually late example (1742) has an almost modern feel about it, although there are still relatively few pieces of furniture.8 In the Hall a Clock & Case A looking Glass A Writing Desk and Table & Stand A Doz of Sedge Chairs a grate In the Parlour A Corner Cupboard & China & a Tea Table An Oval Table a Tea Table a Card Table a dressing Table & a Hand Board twelve Cane Chairs
£ s 110 010 210 0 6 0 8
d 0 0 0 0 0
017 6 1 2 6 2 8 0
Utensils and other goods changed more rapidly in style than furniture because they were more readily replaced. Some changes were remarkable; earthenware, for instance, was transformed before 1750, with many new styles and finer shapes resulting in much wider variety of pieces with much more varied uses. Increasing availability of china also had a dramatic impact, although the shapes and styles of imported blue and white wares
GROWTH
Image rights not available
Plate 3 Family at Tea, R.Colius, 1732 (Victoria and Albert Museum, London). The teawares here were more lavish than those in most houses of middle rank, and few had such extensive collections of silver. The cups and saucers are typical of those imported from China and were among the most decorative of the new utensils.
for the middle market remained fairly standard during the eighteenth century. Some new items, like teawares or knives and forks, were different from anything previously available, so that their use modified the physical appearance of living spaces. Take, for instance, the differences between the appearances of meals and of tea-tables in contemporary painting, such as those by Van Aken and R.Colius. The tea-tables have decorated, blue and white utensils; the meals have less colour and less varied equipment, although the households portrayed at tea were probably of higher status than those shown in the meals. They illustrate the kinds of visual impact that the changing ownership of these utensils could have.
35
Plate 4 Mid-eighteenth-century cutlery (photographs from the collection in Sheffield City Museum). Another new commodity in the eighteenth century. Simple cutlery in museum collections dates from the middle of the eighteenth century when it was being more widely used than previously. The pair on the left have bone handles and date from the 1750s; maker Benjamin Middleton of Sheffield. The pair on the right have handles of horn and date from the 1780s; maker John Staniland of Sheffield.
GROWTH
Patterns after 1725 Can the same kinds of patterns and distinctions be made after 1725, when inventories become too rare to sample? Two examples illustrate that they can, at least until 1750. Imports of pictures showed little upward trend until the 1750s, but print production in England (especially in London) was increasing from the 1730s, and by 1760 there were very large numbers of engravers and print-sellers in London, as well as portrait and landscape painters.9 The output of pictures and prints increased from the 1740s, so that ownership of such things could have continued to grow as it had done earlier in the century, and there is no reason to suppose that the expansion in the numbers of households who owned them did not continue after 1725. The capacity of the pottery industry also represents some of the complexities in the patterns shown by this group of goods, for it did not expand very much overall between 1725 and 1745, but this was the result of a mild decline in the established branches of delft and coarse earthenware, and the growth of new types of pottery. Between about 1715 and 1750 the industry underwent major structural changes in location, techniques, and organization, which only manifested themselves in rapid expansion after 1745. Ownership of earthenware would have continued to expand in the same kind of way after 1725 for perhaps two decades, but after 1750 change would have been more rapid, as the capacity of the industry, and the range of products available, expanded more rapidly. Thus patterns of change in ownership shown by inventories could have continued in the same kind of way through the 1740s, but thereafter the mechanisms may well have been different, with new patterns about which we have no evidence comparable with that from inventories. The same kinds of conclusions are also true of new goods, for these continued to be distinguished by rapid expansion after 1725. The goods that had been new in the late seventeenth century were imported through the East India Company, and they all strongly suggest that the patterns that can be seen before 1725 continued but with more rapid change after 1750. Legally imported hot drinks, for instance, and especially tea, became much more common in the 1750s, and we would expect the utensils for these to be more common as well. Indeed, by the 1740s and 1750s tea was widely referred to as a normal part of the lifestyles of the middle ranks in society in all kinds of ways.
37
38
THE NATION
So what we see from the sample of inventories before 1725 is the beginning of the process by which a new item entered the diet of the middle ranks, a process which continued in the following decades. However, it certainly had not spread to the whole population by 1760.
Chronology of change, 1670–1760 Change was not equally spread over the decades covered by the inventory sample, for it was more apparent from 1685 to 1715 than before or after. Inventories record a particular item at one particular time; there is no information about how long the household had owned it and whether they had formerly got rid of things. In tracing the spread of household durables, it would be best to know when they were first purchased, but this cannot be deduced from inventories; nor is it possible to measure the likely time-lags between people acquiring things and their appearance in inventories. The implicit assumption here is that the behaviour of those who were about to die (and therefore leave inventories) was much the same as that of everyone else. Goods could certainly appear quickly in inventories, as the rapid increases in newly available china in the Orphans’ Court sample twenty years earlier than in the main sample shows. Ownership of most goods changed more slowly as a result of processes that took some time to work through, so that we must not necessarily expect close relationships between economic conditions (especially crises and annual trade fluctuations) and the patterns displayed in inventories. There is a reasonable similarity in some decades but in others there are surprises, such as the observation that the greatest change in ownership in both series of inventories occurred in the decade 1705–15, which does not fit with this as a decade of crisis, high prices, and disrupted trade. Likewise the last decade, 1715–25, was more prosperous in general but showed as little growth in ownership frequencies as the first decade of the sample. In the first decade after 1675, as table 2.1 illustrates, there was little change in the proportions of households owning the goods selected from the probate inventory sample, except for a few items in the Orphans’ Court sample (books, knives and forks, and pictures, together with pewter dishes and plates in the main sample). The decade was therefore one of continuity with the
GROWTH
past as it was in the economy as a whole. It followed a period of mixed fortunes, for there had been some years of acute crisis and misfortune in the 1660s, although by 1674 confidence had returned and the economy enjoyed a period of prosperity which lasted, with setbacks, into the 1690s. Yet the impact of the availability of new goods was not as yet apparent in the 1685 sample of inventories, except for a small increase in the ownership of china in the London Orphans’ Court inventories. There were signs of new developments in the economy, especially the imports of a wider range of goods, together with signs that these were influencing the behaviour of the wealthy commercial classes in London. In this way, developments in the economy as a whole ‘matched’ those suggested by the inventory sample, expressing basic continuity, with some slight changes. In the decade 1685–95 there was considerable economic advance in general, and here too developments in the economy ‘match’ those of the inventory sample, for there were increases in ownership of both new and established goods, with much more rapid change in the Orphans’ Court sample. Ownership of the established goods changed relatively little, but there were changes between 1685 and 1695 in the frequencies of things already known in households but not widely owned, both in the main sample and in the Orphans’ Court inventories. In particular, this was an important decade for the expansion in ownership of items that were to become very common by 1715 (looking glasses, earthenware, clocks, pictures, and curtains) in the Orphans’ Court inventories. The decade 1685–95 was characterized by considerable economic activity in general. The evidence from the inventories more or less coincides with that on the economy as a whole, with growth in ownership of known, but not widespread, items; the beginnings of growth in ownership of new goods; and very little change for established goods. From a chronological viewpoint, this must not be dated too precisely because there were many variations and there were time-lags that we cannot measure between general economic change and recorded changes in ownership of domestic durables in inventories. But the basic prosperity of the 1680s and 1690s was manifesting itself by 1695 in increasing frequency of ownership of most goods, new and known. From 1695 to 1705 the economy as a whole was more troubled and more liable to wide fluctuations and periodic crises, with greater or lesser influence depending on the part of the economy
39
40
THE NATION
examined. Bread prices in London, for instance, were high for the whole of the 1690s, although they reached unusually low levels in 1701 and 1702. Some of this variation is reflected in the inventories, for it was at this time that the new goods began, as yet unevenly, to establish themselves. Variation and unevenness can be seen in comparisons between the Orphans’ Court sample, measuring the most advanced aspects of ownership, and the rest. By 1705 many things which were as yet uncommon in the main sample had become standard household equipment in the Orphans’ Court sample (earthenware, looking glasses, pictures, clocks, books), and this alone identifies it as an important decade, although in the main sample itself expansion was at a lesser rate and, in some things, insignificant. Thus china and utensils for hot drinks increased dramatically in frequency in the Orphans’ Court inventories but had only just appeared in some parts of the main sample. The decade 1705–15 stands out as the one in which most change took place in both sets of inventories. Every item recorded some increase between 1705 and 1715, even the well-established ones and even those that expanded very little over the whole period 1675–1725. The previously known things, such as clocks, pictures, looking glasses, earthenware, and curtains, became much more common everywhere. New goods increased, and some became, by 1715, normal equipment in the London households represented by the Orphans’ Court inventories. Change was uneven in other ways, for growth was more rapid in some places than in others. In particular, all goods were more frequent in the London inventories by 1715 than elsewhere, although this had not previously been the case. It is as if these changes in ownership were exaggerating previously existing inequalities; issues such as the role of towns and the growth of London clearly warrant further consideration and are the subject of later chapters. Yet this decade of change was varied and troubled in the economy as a whole; it began in crisis, and recorded the highest bread and other prices (1709–10) of the period 1660–1760. There is no reason why ownership of household durables should not expand in conditions of economic fluctuation and variation of this kind, for there were growth areas in the economy which were, to some extent, aimed at household consumption. Furthermore, changing patterns of ownership were not related to the immediate ups and downs of the economy, and this decade was the culmination of a long period of gradual but varied economic change.
GROWTH
In the last decade before 1725 there was much less expansion in both series of inventories. Ownership of the well-established goods barely changed, which is not surprising, in that they were already very common by 1715, but there was even a very mild decline in pewter ownership. Some of the other things that had become more common by 1715 also appeared slightly less often, among them pictures and looking glasses. The only goods to be recorded more frequently were those associated with the East India trade, namely china and utensils for hot drinks, together with earthenware. On the other hand, and apparently in contrast, this was a more prosperous decade in the economy as a whole (except for the financial collapse of 1720–1), with low bread prices and increases in many series measuring trade and production. Tea and coffee imports increased very rapidly, while many other indicators, such as imports of china, pottery, printed goods, paper, and beer output, at least remained steady, and there were fewer violent fluctuations in annual trade. The differences in frequencies of ownership of goods between 1715 and 1725 seem out of keeping with some of the patterns for this decade in general and indicate that the influences over changes in the frequency of ownership of household goods were not necessarily immediate ones, and fluctuations in the economy could work in a number of directions. After 1725 similar mechanisms were at work until more rapid growth occurred in some sectors of the economy by the 1750s. In the economy as a whole the two decades after 1725 were not dissimilar to the ones before, in that there was both change and continuity, but without the intense crises of the earlier part of the century and with a steady decline in the prices of basic foodstuffs after 1730. This has led some historians to argue that these years were favourable for the consumer of household goods, utensils, and clothes. Likewise, historians have recognized the 1740s and 1750s as favourable to growth, with expansion of both overseas trade and population.
Conclusion: the environment for growth The evidence in this chapter demonstrates unequivocally that consumption of many household goods increased before 1725 and continued to do so afterwards. There were important changes in the late seventeenth century, especially in the increasing
41
42
THE NATION
availability of decorative goods for use at mealtimes. In some cases expansion was very rapid indeed, especially in the wealthier London households. This leads us to one of the themes in later chapters, namely the changes in domestic behaviour to accommodate these new goods. Were people’s social needs and aspirations influenced by increasing use of new tablewares like knives and forks? These questions are the specific subject of later chapters about household behaviour. Another question arising from the patterns of change in this chapter is whether the changes were evenly spread over the whole country or whether there were regional variations. It is to this problem that we now turn.
3 CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
a regional geography worthy of exploration did actually exist…. perhaps it still provides the only terms in which important problems in the empirical study of industrial as well as preindustrial societies can be expressed. (Langton, 1984)1 Britain was, for all its relatively small size, remarkably varied, with many distinctive economic and social landscapes, although it is in the nature of social history to be concerned with enduring aspects of human behaviour without much regard for geographical variations. The chapter draws on the differences in the ownership of goods recorded in eight contrasting parts of the country and explores their extent and meanings. There were very considerable variations in ownership of goods in the different parts of the country, as table 3.1 shows. They were more commonly recorded in some localities, although no one place was predominant for every commodity. The size of the variations was also large, for some goods were strongly concentrated in a few areas. There were even quite marked differences in ownership of staple goods; pewter, for instance, was recorded in nearly every inventory from Hampshire, Durham, and Kent, but in only four-fifths of those from northern Cumbria. Books were widely distributed, but, even so, they were three times as common in the London sample as in the north-east of England; clocks were five times as common in Lancashire as in Cumbria, Hampshire, and the north-west Midlands. The goods associated with ‘front’ activities showed the largest variations, with London, Kent, and the north-east normally, but not always, predominant, followed by Cambridgeshire and, for some items, Lancashire. 43
Notes See also table 3.2 1 1725 missing 2 Some goods (marked *) seem to have been badly listed in these areas. See also appendix 1 for details. 3 1715 and 1725 missing
Table 3.1 Ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories from eight English regions, 1675–1725
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
Overall the picture is one of some complexity, and table 3.1 does not display a clear hierarchy of regions. The substantial part of this chapter describes regional differences in patterns of ownership and also serves as an introduction to the origin of the sample of inventories. Attention is also focused on two other themes. One of these, the influence of internal trade and the convenience of local supplies, is explored with particular emphasis on the role of London as an entrepot. The other theme is that attitudes to consumption and material goods can usefully be examined at a regional level, for in some areas people may have preferred to spend their resources on special occasions rather than in acquiring household durables.
Regional differences Regional differences are not the same as local peculiarities, and differences between places are not necessarily suggestive of distinctive ‘regional’ behaviour or consciousness. A distinct geographical region is also more difficult to define than a town, especially since the geography of Britain was very varied.2 Administrative areas, such as dioceses or counties, often have some geographical validity, even if they overlap physical and other boundaries, and this is certainly true in the coverage of the sample. Whether they cover meaningful regions of the early modern period partly depends on how we wish to define a region. It is certainly very hard to divide the country into unambiguous areas that each displayed a sense of their own identity, especially at social levels below the gentry. But cultural or political regions, even if they could be identified from the limited evidence, would not necessarily be the appropriate unit to measure aspects of material life. Likewise, farming countries, characterized according to land use or vegetation and ultimately to the underlying geology, do provide a way of examining one aspect of the economy in an area, but such divisions do not coincide with other features, such as major towns or ports or mineral resources or transport facilities, all of which influenced consumption. At the same time, the area influenced by a county town or a regional capital, or the hinterland of a port, cannot be taken as a region without regard to the agricultural and other bases of local economic life.3 These variations can best be appreciated as a result of complex relationships, and the possibility of an underlying regional
45
Notes See also appendix 1, where full archive references are given. Mean values are a crude measure because the range of values is very large and the distribution skew.
Table 3.2 Some characteristics of inventories from eight regions of England, 1675–1725
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
geography behind differences shown in table 3.1 can be explored by looking at the economic and social characteristics of each area, alongside some features of the recorded ownership of goods there.4 Table 3.2 sets out some basic distinctions between the inventories from each area. There were obvious differences between the areas sampled: Cumbrian inventories were of lower value, the area was less urbanized, and there were more husbandmen and fewer tradesmen than elsewhere; the same was true of the north-west Midlands. But the mean values of inventories in Hampshire were higher (204) than elsewhere, whereas those in the north-east were much lower (99), although goods were usually more frequently recorded there.
London As London had a unique importance in the urban hierarchy, I shall begin there.5 As a geographical region the London area was the result of a long period of human activity and, by the late seventeenth century, covered the City, Westminster, adjoining parishes to the east and west, as well as Southwark to the south of the river Thames. It was a complex metropolis, which had widespread economic, social, and political influence on the rest of the country. At least one person in six had lived there at some time in their lives, and its population accounted for about a tenth of the population of England in 1700. Its primary economic role derived from its position as a major port, as a major centre of population, and as the financial, political, and commercial centre, but it was also an important manufacturing centre as well. The wealth and occupational structure were different from that of the country as a whole, with concentrations of professionals, the better-off tradesmen, shopkeepers, and small manufacturers as well as large merchants and manufacturers. There were conspicuously wealthy people living there, with as many as 5,000 gentry families commonly in residence, apart from visitors for the season or parliament or business. Its sophistication as a region can be seen in the specialized functions of different parts, with the port and small-scale manufacturing in the east, heavy industry to the south, and more spacious dwelling to the west, although the large developments of planned squares and town houses were not built until the first half of the eighteenth century. This means that the London region was one of great complexity, and there
47
48
THE NATION
are real problems in giving proper expression to the variety of experience to be found there. Indeed, the immense importance of London in English society is not fully apparent from this study, partly because of the nature and coverage of the sample of inventories, partly because of the nature of the subject itself. The particular problem with the evidence used in this study is the ‘match’ between the variety of occupations and wealth levels in London and the limited numbers of inventories surviving. The inventories used were those from the lower courts in the diocese of London, the archdeaconry of London, and the archdeaconry of Middlesex (used for 1685). The parishes covered are exclusively those in the east of the City, together with a few parishes outside the City limits, notably Whitechapel. The diocesan records do, however, have the advantage of giving evidence about the same kinds of people covered by the records of the provincial dioceses, namely the crafts- and tradespeople below the richer merchants, but above artisans and wage-earners, as well as a few farmers. In other words, it does not tell us everything about the ownership of goods in all parts of London, and it does not tell us anything about the luxury consumption of the rich and the greater gentry, whether they lived in London or whether they were visitors. But it does enable comparisons to be made between the middling trades in London and those elsewhere, and between people of roughly similar wealth—which is advantageous in many respects. In interpreting the evidence about the role of London from the sample of inventories these limitations have to be recalled. The inventories of middling to lower tradespeople are probably rather more representative of the whole of the London region than their relatively small numbers would suggest, for the occupational structure of the City and Westminster, at this level, was not greatly different from that of the sample. In the mideighteenth century the most important occupations in Westminster were those which occurred most often in inventories, namely victuallers, carpenters, chandlers, shoemakers, bakers, and butchers, although victuallers are probably over-represented and the port trades under stated. Furthermore, the Westminster inventories are similar to those from the City although they are not included in the sample. By contrast, the Orphans’ Court inventories, representing the wealthier freemen of the City, were much lengthier documents and do give the quite different impression of widespread ownership of many expensive household goods.
Notes The Number of inventaries for each year region is 65, except for London, 1695, where only 42 were available. See Appendix 1 for details. See also table 3.2. – = no data
Table 3.3 Changing ownership of selected goods in each of eight English regions, 1675–1725
50
THE NATION
The expectation from much writing about London is that it would clearly predominate in the ownership of goods. But, as table 3.1 shows, while many goods were more often recorded in the London sample than elsewhere, the differences were not large, and some goods were more often recorded elsewhere. The goods in which London predominated were all associated with ‘frontstage’ activities, such as new eating habits, new cooking techniques, new drinks, or domestic decoration. In some cases the concentration on London was marked: there were twice as many window curtains and three times as many saucepans as elsewhere, and the new, imported goods, such as china and the utensils for hot drinks, were strongly concentrated there. The evidence from the Orphans’ Court inventories shows that there were wealthier groups in London, who did more often own domestic durables. London was, however, more important by 1725 than it had been in the late seventeenth century. Ownership of goods expanded, as table 3.3 illustrates, more rapidly than elsewhere, so that, even if London was not clearly distinct from other regions at the start of the period, it was clearly so by the end. In book ownership, for instance, London had been fourth, but was clearly ahead by 1705; in ownership of pictures, London was third in 1675 but clearly ahead by 1705. And, of course, ownership of new, imported goods expanded here more rapidly than elsewhere. Just how quickly ownership could expand among the most favourably placed in the metropolis is shown by the growth in ownership recorded in the Orphans’ Court inventories. Here the new goods expanded from being virtually unknown in the 1670s to being virtually ubiquitous by 1725. This powerful growth was not confined to London, but it was an important feature of change in this region. How far growth and concentration in London were due to different attitudes and expectations is not easy to pinpoint with any certainty. The most obvious feature of London life in this respect was that the supply of most of the domestic goods was much easier here than in most other places. There were more shops, and people had already become used to the idea of looking in them for information about what was available. New goods could be seen and appreciated more readily than in most other places. So it is important that London was a great trading centre, with 80 per cent of English imports passing throught the port and with a monopoly of trade with the Far East. London also played a central role in the inland trades: both imported and
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
other goods were distributed to all parts of the country from London. The metropolis was, moreover, a centre for the manufacture of clocks, books, pictures, looking glasses, and earthenware. Ease of supply for the inhabitants of London could account for concentration in London inventories even at the level in society specifically examined here. London was not different in kind from other towns, but showed the same pattern in an exaggerated form.
The north-east Examination of the north-east of England certainly warns against assuming the predominance of London in every respect, for there were some interesting concentrations in the sample from this region.6 The north-east is one of the best-defined geographical regions of England, stretching from the river Tees in the south, and bordered by the Pennines in the west and the coast of Northumberland in the east. This region is covered by the diocese of Durham, which had jurisdiction over most of it but included a few upland parishes as well. Most of the inventories are from the coastal plain.7 The economy of the region was one of contrasts. Newcastle was in the vanguard of urban development, with a varied commercial and industrial basis, serving a large hinterland, and a centre for large-scale trade in coal, especially to London. Other towns in the area had similar functions on a smaller scale and, together with the county town of Durham, made a considerable urban concentration, which is given expression in the sample of inventories. On the other hand, the agricultural economy of the region as a whole was not well developed, and both the cultivated land and the grazing was often poor, even in the lowlands, although yields increased by the mid-eighteenth century. The upland and foothill farms concentrated on livestock, with crops grown for local and subsistence purposes. Holdings were small, but they were larger in the more arable lowlands, partly as a result of the actions of landlords. In southern Northumberland, for example, smaller holdings were grouped together as part of a reorganization of farming, for landlords did not allow small subsistence holdings to proliferate.8 Although the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries saw changes in farming and land ownership, especially in the
51
52
THE NATION
lowlands, these were not fully in evidence by the time of the last decade covered by the inventories (1705–15), and from the point of view of the contrasts between urban and rural it is an interesting area, for there were notable differences between the ownership patterns in the towns and elsewhere. Table 4.3 in chapter 4 shows this; clocks, for instance, were recorded in 21 per cent of the urban inventories (not much less than in London) but in only 7 per cent of rural ones. Likewise china was recorded in 15 per cent of urban inventories here (roughly the same as in London) but in only 3 per cent of rural ones. Here too, as in London, the proportions of inventories recording the goods were increasing, although less rapidly than in the capital. There is a certain regional unity which is explicable in terms of the constrasts between agrarian and commercial elements in the regional economy. The unifying feature of the area was the mining of coal—accounting for 40 per cent of national output in the late seventeenth century. Mining was expanding, and so too was the crucial trade in coal with London. Its importance is that there was a return trade in many household and consumer items, and this meant that such things were more readily available in this area than almost anywhere else in England. As Richard Pocock observed in a letter to his sister in 1760: ‘Besides the great trade in coal…they…import every thing for the use of Northumberland, Durham Westmoreland and part of Cumberland so that they have great shops of all kinds.’9 This was of very considerable importance in the dynamics behind regional differences in the ownership of goods and is a theme that will be developed later in this chapter. It is also important in characterizing the north-east as a region with very advanced aspects in its economy, especially in the towns, alongside rather backward rural elements. Table 4.3 shows that this aspect of the regional economy did influence rural as well as urban areas, but the proportions of rural inventories in which goods were recorded were somewhere between the better-developed rural economies of Kent and the more remote places in Cumbria and the north-west Midlands.
Kent East Kent did not have the same kind of regional identity as the north-east, for it was on the edge of the very mixed area of the
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
north downlands and the Weald. On the other hand, north Kent was separate from the inland forest areas and, being on the coast, was also closely influenced by the London food market. In this respect, the area covered by the diocese of Canterbury can be regarded as an entity in itself but not representative of the geographical region of south-east England. This, as I shall point out in discussing attitudes to material goods, is of some significance. The area relied on mixed farming and market gardening and was much influenced by selling produce in London.10 There were also considerable commercial, industrial, and craft developments in small towns and villages, but there were no major industrial areas based on mineral deposits or a coalfield. Rural and urban Kent as a whole was a wealthy area, with a partly landowning yeomanry and more substantial farmers and gentry than in other counties. There was a mixed occupational structure, with many shops and craftsmen, and this is reflected in the inventory sample. The area also had good communications with London, both by sea and by land, and here too there was a return trade with London in consumer items and household wares.11 The goods were more often recorded here than in many other places, and it was often second only to London. Table 4.3 in chapter 4 shows a major contrast with the north-east of England in that the distinctions between town and country were much less marked. Ownership of goods was more even between rural and urban areas, and ownership in the rural areas was often greater here than in other parts of the country. The regional economy was less clearly divided between an advanced urban sector and a less developed rural one. There was greater integration and similarity, with more village trades and a wider range of occupations. This too was, as table 3.3 illustrates, a growth area after 1705 for most goods, and especially the new ones. Overall it was a rather unusual area, having close links with London, an integrated urban/ rural pattern, and a mixed occupational structure. The north of Kent was particularly favourable, both in terms of the supply of goods and in having the kinds of people living there who were inclined to own household utensils.
Cambridgeshire Higher proportions of goods were often recorded in a third diocese from the east of England, Ely, which covered parts of two major
53
54
THE NATION
geographical regions, the fenlands to the north and the East Anglian heights to the south, although most of the diocese was within the county of Cambridgeshire.12 The county was an administrative unit and not typical of all of East Anglia, although it gives some expression to the diversity of this inland part. It was an extremely varied, but prosperous, agricultural area. After the draining of the south level of the fens in the 1650s, a wide variety of crops was possible, including hemp, flax, saffron, pulses, and grain, although the area remained liable to floods. At the same time a good deal of land remained unreclaimed and the mixed fenland economies based on grazing cattle, fishing, waterfowl, and gathering reeds continued. The inventories reflect great diversity of farming and land use, since many of them have evidence for more varied activities than in any other area examined, including small quantities of new crops, such as saffron, or water-based activities, or gardening, in addition to arable and pastoral husbandry; there were also more inventories of people called ‘labourer’ from this diocese than from any other. Much consumption here was rural, but the towns predominated for some new and decorative goods, especially knives and forks, saucepans, and pictures. There was also, as table 3.3 illustrates, some rapidly expanding ownership. There were very few clocks in the area in 1675, but by 1715 they were recorded in over a quarter of the inventories; similarly, from having very small proportions of looking glasses and pictures in 1675, ownership increased notably by 1725. This region did not rely on the London market in the same way as the two areas already discussed, for, while some of the local varied produce was sold there, there was not the same kind of bulky, water-born traffic with the possibility of a return trade in domestic goods. There were roads through the county, but communications were not particularly easy. This suggests that ownership was based on an adequate supply of goods, but more importantly on the wealth arising from agricultural improvements and diversification. The chronology of change, with expansion in ownership dating from the late seventeenth century, also points in this direction.
North-west England Lancastria formed a fairly compact physical unit to the west of the Pennines.13 The inventories cover the area which was to develop
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
into the industrial region of the north-west, for only Lancashire south of the river Ribble is included. The sample does not therefore represent the whole of Lancashire and the north-west in general, but covers the most advanced parts. This was a very varied area; the uplands of the Pennines, especially Rossendale, were difficult to cross and have remained relatively remote ever since, but there were also the major urban developments around Manchester and the developing port of Liverpool, as well as a major, if as yet underdeveloped, coalfield. In this respect it was similar to, if less developed than, the north-east. The soils of the lowlands did not give rise to affluent farming (the main crops were oats and barley) but the climate and soils were best suited to a pastoral economy, so there was sheep fattening and stock rearing. In general, holdings were small and the economies of individuals were based on a mixture of activities, including arable farming for local consumption. There were improvements in drainage in the Lancashire plain in the eighteenth century and production for urban markets as the towns grew. But the most important characteristic of the area was that it was developing as a textile-producing area, based on the domestic production of linen cloth and an increasing number of other things, such as clocks, glass, earthenware, and small metalwares. Industrial crafts were already of fundamental importance in the rural economies of south Lancashire, where there was, even in the seventeenth century, a certain unity in its occupational structure. So, like the north-east, it appears as a complex region, with growing towns but with more industrial occupations in the countryside than around Newcastle. The inventories reflect this occupational structure, for there are many rural craftsmen and small farmers among them. Ownership of goods here was generally lower than in areas already discussed, with a few important exceptions, which are in themselves indicative of the particular nature of the region and probably the whole of north-west England. Book ownership was relatively high, more so than in the north-east and even Cambridgeshire; this may have been associated with the high value that local religious dissent placed on reading the scriptures, resulting in higher general literacy. In this sense it is a reflection of regional values. Predominance of the area in the ownership of clocks and earthenware was more likely to have been associated with the fact that they were made locally and were therefore easily available. Since the supply of imported goods, or those made elsewhere, was limited, ownership of them here was less frequent.
55
56
THE NATION
There was some expansion at the end of the period, but there were some goods whose ownership did not increase as much here as elsewhere. Pictures, for instance, were found with about the same frequency at the beginning as at the end; earthenware even declined.
Hampshire Central southern England as a whole has a geographical unity largely based on the geological succession of limestones, clays, chalk, and sand that underlie it. It is, however, very varied in detail because of the numerous small-scale geological and topographical differences. The inventories cover the county of Hampshire together with the Isle of Wight. Here land use was very mixed, although much of the farming depended on wheat and barley, with sheep and domestic dairies. It was primarily an agricultural area, with numerous small market towns and craft trades serving the main farming function; there were three sizeable towns, but none was expanding or prosperous at this time.14 Hampshire was one of the most varied counties, and farming there was potentially less prosperous than further north in the region because much of the county was covered by infertile heaths and forests, notably the New Forest. But this county was typical of some of the others in the central south-west, for the geology, land form, and climate had much in common with all the counties to the west and with Sussex, although not the south-west peninsula. The inventories reflect the agricultural basis of the economy of the county, since there are many large and prosperous farmers among them, and the mean valuations of the whole inventory are substantially higher here than everywhere except Kent. Ownership of many of the household goods and utensils measured in this study was much lower here, in some cases (earthenware, clocks, pictures, and window curtains) among the lowest proportions in the whole survey. Furthermore, there was less growth in this region before 1705 than in any other, although the last two decades are not measured here—which is unfortunate, because there was considerable expansion in some other places in the two missing decades. This pattern is unexpected in that it was an apparently favoured region. Explanation is also complicated by the fact that the inventories did list some very expensive domestic goods, especially beds and furniture; they also
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
recorded the highest proportions of pewter. It is also less easy to argue that supply was inadequate, because Hampshire was quite near to London in the north and it had two major ports on its coast, which were connected to the capital by major roads. Earthenware was actually made in the north of the county but apparently was aimed at the London market.15 One possibility is that the economy of the whole region was influenced by the corn trade with London and was vulnerable to fluctuations in the price of corn, leaving even large farmers with few spare resources in cash for new consumer durables. In the 1680s cereal prices were especially low, and there were serious price fluctuations in the French wars. So, during the thirty or so years when ownership of goods was expanding in some parts of the country, in this apparently favoured area farmers did not have the money to buy utensils and consumables. But they did buy furniture, so it seems likely that, for some reason, utensils were less well regarded as household possessions here than elsewhere. Perhaps people’s attitudes and values were different from those elsewhere and decorative things were not so readily acquired and valued. Likewise, none of the towns was a dynamic centre of growth. This observation will be looked at again in greater detail later in this chapter, but it is also likely that other counties in the south were similar, especially those that were not on the inland waterways to London.
The north-west Midlands The north-west Midlands were different again, being an entirely land-locked area and covering a large part of the Midlands plain.16 It was a pastoral region, with concentration on dairying and rearing, and little attention paid to growing cereals for the market. There was less variety both of landscape and in farming, although there were some areas of specialized industrial activities. The inventory sample is drawn from northern Shropshire and Staffordshire, neither of which was a particularly favoured area for agriculture. Much of Staffordshire was seen as barren ground or heathland in the late seventeenth century, although there were some good pastures and forests. The majority of holdings were small, and there were no major urban areas within the scope of the sample. Industrial activity was increasing in the north-east Midlands in general, for there were three areas of domestic industry and other
57
58
THE NATION
kinds of developments, based on coalfields: in the rural areas to the south, ironwares were being made; to the north there was a growing pottery industry; and in Shropshire ironworking and other trades were already established on the coalfield.17 Yet the region as a whole was still dominated by farming, and the occupations in the sample of inventories reflect this. It was one of the least wealthy areas and was seventh in mean valuation of the whole inventory, reflecting the small size of many holdings. Lower proportions of all goods were recorded in the inventories, the new goods were almost unknown, decorative ones were very unusual, and clocks were rare. There was little growth, with the exceptions of saucepans and clocks, which meant that by the last couple of decades the frequencies in this region were often the lowest of any, even including the geographically remote Cumbria.
Cumbria Cumbria had a clear regional identity and covered an area stretching from Morecambe Bay to the Solway Firth and inland to the Vale of Eden in the east.18 There are many contrasting landscapes in the area, from the central mountains of the Lake District to the coastal plain and river valleys surrounding it. The agricultural environment was, however, limited to mixed farming on the coast and fell grazing and other pasture inland. There were profound weaknesses in the regional economy in the early seventeenth century, when there had been severe famines, but the worst problems had been modified by the later part of the century through agricultural diversification and incomes from non-agricultural sources. But, although famine did not recur, the area was known for the smallness of holdings and the poverty of the freeholders and tenants throughout the eighteenth century.19 The basic economy of the area, mixed farming for subsistence, was not transformed by the growth of industry, commerce, and trade in the Whitehaven area. It remained isolated, although some parts of the economy were altered by the increasing trade through Whitehaven with Ireland and the colonies, and with Scotland through Carlisle. The inventories were taken from the northern part of the region, and they represent the poorer and more remote areas, rather than the whole of Cumbria. They certainly show evidence for smallness of farms and low values of estates in comparison
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
with the other areas covered. The lowest frequencies were recorded for virtually every item examined; for instance, there were insignificant numbers of pictures in the rural areas and even the normally ubiquitous pewter was less often recorded here than anywhere else. There were also few towns apart from Carlisle, which was itself quite small as a regional centre, although goods were more often recorded here than elsewhere in the area. Like the north-east, there were very substantial differences between rural and urban areas: clocks were twice as common in towns as in the countryside; pictures were as common in towns as they were in other regions, but virtually unknown in the rural inventories. China was as frequent in the Cumbrian towns as anywhere else, but again virtually unknown in rural inventories. There was, however, more sign of expansion in this region than in the north-west Midlands, for the ownership of most goods increased by 1715, although the absolute levels remained lower than elsewhere. It contrasts with Hampshire in that it is easier to see that sheer lack of resources were responsible for fewer people owning the goods here.
Lowland Scotland Owing to different probate practices in Scotland, where most testaments have incomplete listings of household goods, 20 ownership patterns cannot be measured in a way that would be comparable to the method applied to the English regions. It is, however, possible to make some comparisons between Scotland and England in an informal way by using a few testaments, together with descriptions and memoirs. There are many pitfalls in doing this, not least the uncertainty in comparing English and Scottish social structures and the concentration in Scottish writing on the domestic behaviour of the upper ranks of society. Household size, structure, and function were not vastly different in Scotland, although houses were smaller, so there were nonethe-less, many similarities. One conclusion about the possible nature of consumption patterns in Scotland is possible. Lowland Scotland and Edinburgh would not, at least before 1725, emerge as one of the areas in which consumption of domestic durables was most important. Yet it would not be like the south of England, where the large farmers had very comfortably furnished houses. As will be shown
59
60
THE NATION
in chapter 8, the farmers had basic household equipment, but their houses were smaller, and they did not have many of the goods, such as crockery or cutlery, already quite common in parts of England. Nor did they have expensive furniture or much silver. The development of consumption in Scotland came rather later than the period covered by this book; before 1725 the Scottish economy was beginning to undergo changes that were not fully visible until later in the eighteenth century. In the late seventeenth century it was economically backward, and famine was experienced, even in the Lowlands and even among respectable tenants. It is in this context that limited consumption of domestic goods (and clothing) should be seen.
Contrasting consumption Ownership of goods was more likely in some regions than others. The metropolis stands out, followed by the north-east and Kent; these appear as the three most important areas. Cambridgeshire and north-west England were, however, important for some things, and the former is notable for some developments in rural areas. Goods were less frequently recorded in the north-west Midlands and Cumbria; in these areas there were some very sparsely furnished houses with low valuations. Lastly, in parts of the south, represented here by Hampshire, domestic durables were less often recorded, but inventories had relatively high values, and some of the houses were well provided with furniture and staple goods such as pewter. These are interesting patterns that encourage us to look at differences between different parts of the country. Many of the details also show that simplistic contrasts, such as those between north and south, agricultural and industrial, are not enough to explain the patterns. Does it help to try to understand the differences and similarities in terms of regional geography, allowing for the partial coverage of the survey evidence? This depends very much on how the impact of a ‘region’ on behaviour is seen. This can be looked at in four ways: the state of economic development in an area; diffusion from outside; the supply of goods; and regional differences in attitudes to consumption. The discussion of each region covered and Scotland shows that some aspects of the economy influenced ownership. In general, in inventories from those areas that were ‘backward’, especially Cumbria and the north-west Midlands, new and
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
decorative goods were less often recorded there. Likewise, Scotland’s economy was not developing rapidly at this time and there was still much subsistence agriculture and limited cash incomes. Inventories from areas with well-developed economies, like London and Kent, more often recorded a wide variety of goods. Yet, even as broad generalizations, these relationships do not explain all the patterns in the tables, and they do not necessarily explain the sparse goods found in Scotland, or why there were not more domestic durables in Hampshire, or why the north-east predominated.
Supply and trade The variations between some parts of the country have little to do with the inner workings of the regional economy, and this can be seen in the influence of the supply of goods, whether locally made or whether bought in from elsewhere. The regional differences in the proportions of inventories with the goods suggest that supply was important. Much is explained about regional differences if trading networks are taken into account. This is especially so of goods imported from the Far East, but is also true of goods made in the provinces and sold through London, and can be illustrated in three ways: first, by looking at the return trade in domestic and other goods to some areas that provided bulky goods to the London market; second, by examining the coincidence between ownership of utensils for hot drinks and the numbers of tea and coffee dealers in an area; and, third, by considering variations in local supplies of domestic goods. North-eastern England and Kent provided the London market with bulky goods, and the return shipping was used to carry many household and other items, whether produced in London or imported through the capital. This kind of trade accounts for similarities between these two otherwise distinct areas, as well as their predominance. The same kind of mechanism could have been at work in other places not covered by the sample of inventories; grain was traded in bulk down the Thames from Berkshire, Oxfordshire, and Wiltshire, and there may have been the same kind of return trade. There were certainly more tea and coffee dealers in these counties than in those where the bulky traffic was less in evidence, especially Dorset, Hampshire, and Sussex. This is only a partial explanation, for grain was taken
61
62
THE NATION Table 3.4 Numbers of dealers in coffee and tea in the 1730s in the counties covered by the sample of inventories, population, and the frequency of ownership of utensils for hot drinks in 1725
Notes and sources 1 Phyllis Deane and W.A.Cole, British Economic Growth, 1688–1959 (Cambridge, 1969), p. 103. These are unlikely to be totally accurate but they give a rough idea of the order of magnitude. 2 PRO, Excise and Treasury Letter-books, CUST/48/13, p. 206, dated 17 February 1737/8.
coastwise to London from these southern coastal counties; Sussex was a ‘maritime and corn county’, with flour and grain taken to London, although some carriage was overland. There was a return trade in coal, salt, and manufactured goods from London.21 Some coincidences between supply and ownership can be shown by comparing the ownership of utensils for hot drinks and the number of tea and coffee dealers in 1736/7.22 Table 3.4 does this, although it cannot take account of the sizes of the dealers’ businesses or whether they served a very wide area or not. A ranking of regions according to the percentages with utensils for hot drinks in 1725 is virtually the same as that for the ratio between dealers and population. Kent had by far the largest number of dealers, as well as the highest proportions of inventories with utensils for hot drinks in 1725, followed by Cambridgeshire and the north-east. On the other hand, the areas where utensils were uncommon by 1725 had fewer dealers relative to the population. It also shows the dominant position of London, where many of the dealers were undoubtedly redistributing tea and coffee to the provinces as well as selling in the capital.
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
As manufacturing became more specialized and concentrated, some items were more easily obtained in some areas. Earthenware, for instance, was made in south Lancashire, Liverpool, and Kent, and it was recorded there with greater frequency than elsewhere; however, it was also made in both north and south Staffordshire, but was not recorded there very often. Clocks were made in many places, but there was a concentration of makers in Lancashire and London—which explains their frequency thereand they were also more common in the places that traded with London.23 Pictures and prints were made in London and were also imported through the capital, so again the supply was concentrated, as was ownership. Some goods were more widely manufactured: pewter was made in many urban centres, and most furniture was put together locally; in these cases, both the supply and the distribution of ownership were more even.24 Change over time was also influenced by the same kinds of factors, and growth in ownership was more rapid in some regions than in others. The newer goods (notably china, utensils for hot drinks, looking glasses, and pictures) whose supply centred on London spread, and ownership of them increased by 1715, even in the least favoured places. Patterns of internal trade do, therefore, go some way towards showing why there were differences between the particular areas examined in this study. The networks of internal trade were part of an economic environment that extended beyond regional boundaries and, from that point of view, suggest that (while it is desirable to be aware of the distinctions between places) regional differences in themselves do not provide the only framework for discussing consumer behaviour.
Regions and attitudes Differences in attitudes to material goods, a further aspect of consumer behaviour, can be looked at in spatial, if not strictly regional terms. There is a possibility that people were more inclined to adopt new behaviour or new goods in some areas because they were more consumer-orientated. Some societies are known to have been resistant to adopting new goods, possibly because their resources were limited, but possibly because occasional conspicuous expenditure that had little influence on everyday household equipment or consumption was preferred.
63
64
THE NATION
This can be contrasted with a more ‘modern’ attitude to consumption, where people are prepared to own a wide variety of goods and use a wide range of services, rather than concentrate on a few symbolic or expensive occasions. Thus contrasts between ‘traditional’ and ‘modern’ can be made, constrasts that are not without foundation and meaning, especially in relation to some parts of some societies, like the Italian nobility or the Dutch peasantry.25 But such ideas need to be treated carefully in a commercialized society such as that of most of Britain by this time. So it is not valid to examine all communities in these terms. It is, however, difficult to find enough detail about this kind of attitude, for there is very little evidence on the subject. The diaries and memoranda used in this study often give graphic and detailed impressions of everyday routines, mealtimes, and eating habits, but they rarely make direct reference to material goods, and it is most unusual to find attitudes towards the acquisition of furniture and utensils spelt out, since such expectations were taken for granted. However, there is some evidence of a view that income had to be carefully managed and not squandered. Most of the quotations and sayings collected by Warley in the pages at the beginning and end of his account book are concerned with using money and time to best advantage and not getting into debt. Take, for instance, the caution, Climb not too high, lest thou fall: Creep not so low, as to be trampled on. This does not lead us to suppose that this affluent yeoman farmer would have approved of conspicuous consumption, any more than another entry, ‘’tis use that sanctifies expense’.26 But this kind of collection is unusual, and it is not possible to say from such comment whether there were different attitudes to material goods in different parts of the country. In most parts of England middle-ranking people do not seem to have wanted to spend a disproportionate amount of their resources on a few special occasions, such as funerals, weddings, and feasts, or on items of clothing. Thus Misson, in many ways a sympathetic observer of English life, reports of christenings: ‘The Custom here is not to make great feasts at the birth of their Children. They drink a glass of Wine, and eat a bit of a certain Cake, which is seldom made but upon the Occasions.’ He further remarks that ‘The English eat well, but are no great
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
Feasters’ and, of Presbyterian weddings, that they were ‘commonly very plain and very quiet’.27 Household routines were not systematically different in different parts of the country, although some of the details of what was eaten and how it was cooked did vary. The implication of this is that the ‘sober and industrious’ households of the middling ranks spent only modestly on family and other rituals. They did not behave in a manner characterized as typical of ‘traditional’ societies, where relatively large sums were spent on a feast or celebration and limitations in the availability of attractive consumer goods meant that people were unable to spend any surplus resources on them. It is therefore often taken as an essential step in the growth of a consumer-orientated society that people should devote resources to rather ordinary clothes and manufactured things, rather than to a few large-scale occasions or purchases. One way of discovering whether there were different perceptions in some regions is to look for any evidence for this kind of expenditure in some of them. The only evidence about celebrations in the diaries used here is from Sussex, an area represented by the inventory sample from Hampshire. Burrell’s diary shows that he received many presents during the year, mostly of game, food, and wine—evidently part of a mutual interchange with his neighbours. Christmas was celebrated on a large scale, and after 1691 he invited his humbler neighbours to dine at New Year; in that year he had thirty of them, with their wives. The implication is that hospitality continued on this scale every year until 1711, when he invited the humbler people to dine on Sundays in groups of two or three instead. The menus were lavish and the entertainment hospitable. He also spent a large sum, £35, on his sister’s funeral in 1708. This could partly have been a mark of his social position, for he was a lawyer, but, since he claimed his income at about £300 a year, he was not exceptionally wealthy, although well above most middle-ranking people. The diary does not give details of his regular domestic expenses or what kinds of furniture he had, so whether his hospitality was related to limited expenditure on domestic goods is not known. He mentioned the new hot drinks only twice, once as a gift and once when he drank chocolate in London.28 The other Sussex diarist, Marchant, also mentions a number of gifts and also feasted his workmen at Christmas; in 1727 he recorded that seven roasting pigs were used when ‘our workmen dined here as usual’. He also frequently gave and received mourning rings and gloves.29
65
66
THE NATION
This was not lavish expenditure, but there are no similar references in the diaries from other places, where Christmas often passed without notice and weddings, baptisms, and funerals were mentioned more as occasions for visits than for expenditure. Silver was the only household item selected here that might be considered as representative of ‘conspicuous’ consumption, and it was recorded in about a quarter of the inventories. Among the middle ranks it does not seem to have been used in a conspicuous way; households usually had a few pieces of useful silver, such as tankards, silver spoons, or porringers. The silver owned by Allen Wyat, glazier of Newmarket, in 1675 was typical; his household goods consisted of the usual furniture, bedding, and utensils, but he did have a clock.30 £ s d Item 3 silver boules 12 silver spoones 1 silver salt 2 silver wine cupps
1310 0
This does not suggest that silver was a ‘conspicuous’ possession, although it was much more frequently owned by those of highest status, the gentry (61 per cent), than by others. It was more often recorded in inventories of professional people (55 per cent) and dealing tradesmen (43 per cent) than in those of yeomen (13 per cent) and husbandmen (2 per cent). It was associated with wealth and was recorded in virtually every inventory (94 per cent) from the Orphans’ Court sample and in most inventories with a total valuation over £500. Yet it also seems to have been a staple, even traditional, material, for there was little change in the proportions of households owning it from 1675 to 1725, although rather more recorded it in 1715 than usual (29 per cent). It was also concentrated in the three most advanced areas (London 44 per cent, the northeast 34 per cent, Kent 41 per cent) and, with one exception, was recorded in about a tenth of inventories in other places. The exception was Hampshire (27 per cent), an area in which there is some other evidence that people might have used their resources for traditional things rather than consumer durables. They may also have invested in silver rather than in other items—which suggests that there were different attitudes in parts of the south. The evidence from Scotland is clearer, for here there is some commentary from the Lowlands suggestive of some kinds of ‘conspicuous’ expenditure. The writers of the later eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries who looked back over the changes in Scottish society make several comments about the importance that
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
was attached to feasting and to rather elaborate clothes. Dress, it was recalled, ‘was in general plain and frugal, but upon great occasions they scrupled no expense.’31 It was also remarked: ‘Then the heads were all dress’d in laces from Flanders;…the price of those was high, but two suit would serve for life.’32 And another writer observed: ‘The dress of both men and women alike in the middle and higher ranks exhibited by turns the extremes of gaudy ostentation and disgusting slovenliness.’33 This implies there was normal expenditure at a low level on consumer goods (in this case clothing), but combined with some apparently excessive expenditure for particular occasions. Such a contrast is also shown in these comments: In their general habits the husbandmen [the writer meant farmers here] of those days were a sober, a frugal, and an industrious race. Though not averse to indulge occasionally in convivial sociality with their friends and neighbours, yet the leading tendency of their minds was parsimony and thrift.34 Though our gentry lived plainly and frugally in common, yet upon certain occasions they wished to make a show…. It was at marriages, christenings, and burials, particularly the last, that country gentlemen were wont to exceed the bounds of moderation.35 Ramsey comments on the ‘old hospitality so much boasted of in Britain’, which involved eating a great deal of food and pressing guests to do the same, which became ‘troublesome and disgusting’.36 Here surplus was consumed in excessive food and drink on a few occasions, rather than on durable goods or even clothing, again characteristic of a ‘traditional’ attitude to consumption. All writers record that such behaviour had changed since the mid-eighteenth century; Somerville recorded that ‘A taste for amusements and festivities has rather declined, particularly among the middle and lower classes’; he specifically made the link between this and increased consumption of ordinary things, for he emphasizes that people were better fed, clothed, and housed than before.37 This too was characteristic of a society which valued some kinds of celebrations over domestic goods and even clothing. By the time these commentators wrote, tilings had changed, and people’s expectations were different. It is hard to be sure that they were not giving an exaggerated account, in order to stress improvements in Scottish society by emphasizing some oldfashioned aspects of its past.
67
68
THE NATION
The idea of conspicuous occasions was, however, evidently appealing to Scottish taste, for there are illustrations of wedding feasts and dancing. These too presented an image of what viewers wanted to believe about their society, rather than an accurate record of social mores, but perhaps this in itself suggests that certain kinds of apparently lavish expenditure were acceptable on some occasions. David Allan based his dancing figures in the Penny Wedding and other paintings on styles that he had seen and developed while he was in Italy, but his work, if not accurate in detail, serves to illustrate feasting and celebration as people wanted to see it, even in the late eighteenth century. The images in these illustrations and in the memoirs contrast with descriptions of English life, where there is not the same kind of interest in stressing lavish or conspicuous behaviour.
Plate 5 Penny Wedding, David Allan, 1785 (National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh). The style of the dancers was based on Allan’s Italian experience, but the scene as a whole gives an evocative impression of feasting, drinking, and celebration.
CONTRASTING LOCALITIES
There were considerable differences between different parts of the country. These are partly explicable in terms of an area’s general economic development, but the availability of new goods was uneven. Transport links with London were important in making goods available. So too was the extent of urbanization, and it is to this that we now turn in the next chapter.
69
4 THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
The towns are so many electric transformers. (Braudel)1 The role of the town must be severely curtailed. (Daunton)2 Towns are often taken to have played a crucial role in modifications to consumer behaviour throughout the preindustrial era, acting as ‘electric transformers’ on national or regional economies. 3 London has also been identified as a centre of consumption, and the growth of facilities in provincial spas and resorts has been taken as an indicator of changing consumption of material goods and leisure.4 Thus towns have been established as important elements, possibly even the most important element, in changing consumer tastes and behaviour. Even Daunton, in questioning the role of towns in economic change as a whole in the eighteenth century, confirms that they were the location of new consumption patters. 5 This chapter considers the influence of towns by making comparisons between goods recorded in urban and rural inventories and follows three interrelated but rather different themes. First, were towns different? Second, what was distinctive about town life? Third, it asks what part provincial towns played in expanding consumption and altering consumer behaviour, a question that is logically different from the first two in that it deals with changing patterns and diffusion, not with static comparisons.
70
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
Towns and culture Why were towns given a role in consumer behaviour distinct from that of the country? Towns were not just collections of buildings grouped together with populations of various sizes in them, providing various services. They were, and were felt to be, different kinds of communities: not only did they look and smell different, but people in them behaved differently and valued different things. They were seen at the time, as they have been since, as representing something distinctive about civilized human behaviour and experience. In the seventeenth century it was taken for granted that towns were not merely social and economic centres, but essential manifestations of political civilization and of a well-ordered state. That this was so can be seen from the confusion that visitors felt when they went to Virginia or Maryland, where there were no urban developments until much later. Settlement there was in widely dispersed plantations of various sizes, with the marketing, administrative, and other functions of towns also widely distributed. Social and commercial life functioned in an orderly and sophisticated way, but visitors, government officials, clergymen, and others condemned the lack of towns and villages as fundamentally detrimental to life and morals; it hindered the proper government, and it led to a fear that there could be a mass reversion to savagery, for it was thought that the very nature of man required settled communities, in which natural, sinful instincts could be controlled and civilized. Thus there were many comments on the ‘barbarism’ of scattered dwellings, and officials held that towns were desirable both for people’s behaviour and for trade.6 The attitudes expressed in this physical and cultural environment, different from Europe in many ways, are revealing, since they show that towns were believed at the time to have an important role in cultural experience and that an area lacking in them was seen as devoid of important elements of civilization. Town life has been seen as intrinsically different from life in the country; our image of urban life is that it was aesthetically, psychologically, and economically more advanced than life in the country. This does reflect contemporary perceptions and descriptions; the overall impression given by Defoe and Fiennes, for instance, is that towns were worth visiting, that something interesting would be seen in them, and that they were busy centres of local life.7 The plays and poetry of the period give an impression
71
72
THE NATION
of the sophistication of towns and their inhabitants, although they were written for an urban audience and it is easy to be overinfluenced by these accounts into thinking that they represented everyone’s views and experience.8 In addition, towns have often been seen as a vital force in breaking down ‘traditional’ patterns of behaviour and consumption and as the places in which new ideas and new ways of life are first introduced. For all these reasons we might expect differences in the material lives of townspeople and consequently different patterns of ownership in town and country. The sample of inventories was not stratified to include a balanced sample of urban inventories, but urban and rural probate practices were sufficiently similar for many urban inventories to have entered the selection along with those from villages and the countryside. The importance of towns is not unequivocal when the ownership of goods is taken as an indicator of consumer behaviour there. Table 4.1 gives the proportions of inventories in urban and rural places in which the goods were recorded, and it does show that higher proportions of inventories from towns recorded the goods. The apparently simple patterns of the table become more complex when it is evaluated in more detail. Interpretation of the patterns depends on what parts of town life are examined and how nearly the sample of inventories can be taken as representative of those parts of urban life in general. In particular, there is an obvious distinction between people’s domestic lives, with household goods and durables used within the home, and, on the other hand, life outside the home, where dress or community experiences were important. One problem in dealing with urban experience is that of deciding what kind of town to examine. By the late seventeenth century there was considerable diversity in town life, most notably between small markets and the great cities, or between the atmosphere of the developing industrial towns and the resort towns. Between such contrasting places we might expect as much diversity as between town and country. Urban networks and functions were becoming increasingly complex, and there was no neat urban hierarchy ranging from the prinvincial capitals down through market towns to lesser towns and villages. Comparisons with the countryside are also inhibited by the fact that small towns and large villages were not clearly distinct, although a higher density of dwellings and a mixed occupational structure usually distinguished a small town from a large village.
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
Complexity of function is usually associated with the size of population, although there is no absolute agreement about the minimum population necessary for urban functions and status. Gregory King included small settlements and assumed that the minimum size for market towns was about 500 people. There is much to be said for taking a contemporary view into account, and many places with some urban functions had quite small populations in the late seventeenth century. There were perhaps 500 market centres, with spheres of influence of only a few miles, with populations between about 500 and 1,500.9 These small places were local centres with craft and other tradespeople serving a restricted population, but they were distinct from the dispersed settlement in the countryside because the majority of people who lived in them did not farm the land, although some did. Their function was largely to provide services for the local population and to process and market agricultural products, so they were integrated into the local farming economy as an essential part of it. On the other hand, the more sophisticated economic and social characteristics of town life were not fully developed in settlements as small as this, and some urban historians have argued that the smaller places should not be taken into account in considering the extent of urbanization.10 There were only forty or fifty towns with populations between 2,000 and 5,000, and only twentyfour had populations over 5,000, so these were exceptional places in the English urban hierarchy; the seven towns with over 10,000 people were even more so. London towered over the rest with a population of about half a million in 1700, nineteen times as large as the next biggest city, Norwich. It contained a tenth of the population of England and accounted for two-thirds of the urban population in towns over 5,000 people. England had a relatively large urban population in 1700, although the exact proportion counted as urban depends on whether the smaller towns are included or not. In 1700 about 16 per cent of the population lived in towns with over 5,000 inhabitants and a further 7 per cent in the smaller towns.11 This means that between a quarter and a fifth of the population lived in urban communities of some kind, and of these between a third and a half lived in London. By 1750 towns had grown relative to the whole population, and by then over a quarter of the people lived in towns. This is a relatively high proportion, although not by the standards of present-day industrial countries.12 From the point of view of this study, there is advantage in taking as towns
73
74
THE NATION
any settlements with mixed and non-agrarian functions with over 500 inhabitants, for many places that served some urban functions had quite small populations in the late seventeenth century, but care is needed in specifying the kinds of town discussed and the types of urban experiences that might be specific to some kinds of town. This is true both when examining generalized comments based on travellers’ or visitors’ reports, and when matching the towns covered by the inventory sample with urban experience in general.
The urban inventories The sample of inventories encapsulates some elements of urban experience and has the advantage that comparisons can be made from the same kind of document. The proportions of urban inventories obtained is not out of keeping with the proportions of urban dwellers in the country as a whole, since 18 per cent of the inventories were from provincial towns and in only one diocese (Durham) was the proportion out of keeping, where it was rather high. Secondly, some recognition of the urban hierarchy is possible by dividing provincial towns according to whether they were regional or county centres, or whether they served less central functions or were very small in size. So inventories were coded according to the kind of community from which they came, based on the parish of residence. It is rarely possible to tell exactly where someone lived and impossible to distinguish village dwellers from those in dispersed farms and hamlets. The distinctions made here between rural and urban are therefore generalized, with an attempt to acknowledge different types of town by distinguishing major centres from other towns. This distinction is based on a combination of size and importance; Carlisle, for instance, was quite small, with about 3,000–4,000 people, but it was the economic and political centre for an extensive hinterland in Cumbria. The major towns are listed in the notes to table 4.1. These cover, and thus represent, large developing centres, such as Liverpool and Newcastle, as well as towns with less dynamic economies, like Shrewsbury and Winchester. The other towns include medium to small market towns and other small places with a variety of functions, but there are none from the developing spas and leisure centres. It is gratifying that a few errors in definition
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
would make little difference to the overall totals, because there are so few cases from each town. The sample from London does not cover the whole of the metropolis, for it is largely from the City parishes to the east, together with Whitechapel; it does not include Westminster, the West End, and the growing suburbs to the south; nor does it include the richest inhabitants. The London sample amounts to 11 per cent of the total, so is not out of keeping with the proportion of Londoners in the population as a whole, although this part of the sample does need to be treated with caution. The inventories of the London freemen from the Court of Orphans have also been used to illustrate comparisons between conclusions based on the main sample and those more relevant to the upper middle ranks, but the role of London as a region in its own right has already been considered in the previous chapter. The sample does not therefore cover all towns or even all towns in each of the dioceses examined, and it does not include all types of town, but it does give expression to experiences in many towns in many areas. The strength of the conclusions that can be drawn from it are greater than the coverage might at first suggest because they have not been selected from places where unusual facilities were becoming available. They draw upon evidence from ordinary towns and they are also comparable with the rural areas. This is important because much of the evidence quoted by urban historians in support of a view that town life encouraged consumption is drawn from visitors’ impressions or the behaviour of the gentry and aspiring gentry on holiday in Bath, Tunbridge Wells, and other resorts and spas.13 Such evidence refers to public occasions, rather than to household behaviour in many market towns, ports, or centres of commerce or manufacturing. There was more to town life than leisure and luxury, and the evidence from inventories has the advantage of drawing attention to this.
Comparisons between town and country Table 4.1 can now be looked at with some confidence that it provides grounds for comparisons between town and country and between major and other towns. The goods were generally more frequently recorded in urban inventories, but there are distinctions between different types of goods. There were few differences between the provincial towns and rural areas in the ownership of
75
Notes Definitions of town and country are discussed in the text. The major towns included are: Durham, Newcastle, Berwick, Carlisle, Southampton, Winchester, Canterbury, Cambridge, Shrewsbury, Liverpool, and Manchester. See chapter 1 and appendix 1 for a discussion of the sample.
Table 4.1 Frequencies oj’ ownership of selected goods in towns and country areas in a sample of English inventories, 1675–1725
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
staple goods, used alike for essential purposes in town and country. On the other hand, saucepans, associated with cookery on enclosed stoves, were four times as common in London as in other towns; they were twice as frequent in the provincial towns as they were in the countryside, where only about one in twenty households owned them. Earthenware, although used in farming as well as in households, was more common in London and provincial towns. Although people in towns are usually thought of as being more conscious of clock time and more literate, there were no significant differences between rural and provincial towns in ownership of clocks and books; however, the higher proportion in London inventories is in keeping with this view. The decorative and new goods were generally much more common in towns, and a few were virtually confined to them. Pictures and window curtains, both with largely decorative functions, were extremely scarce in rural areas but were quite common in London, with moderate frequency in provincial towns. Looking glasses were more widely distributed but they were found three times as frequently in London as in rural areas, and were twice as common in provincial towns. The indicators of new modes of eating and drinking were virtually unknown in the countryside and in the lesser towns, but were more common in the major centres and London. Taken together, the goods indicative of ‘frontstage’ activity were more common in towns than elsewhere, they were more common in the major centres than in the others, and they were more common in London than elsewhere. A hierarchy of place, from rural through provincial towns to London, is not unexpected in that towns have been associated with consumerism and with encouraging a demand for services and goods. On the other hand, it is unsatisfactory to leave it at that, for the urban hierarchy was more complex than the simple subdivisions in the tables allow, and we need further examination of the meanings of ownership of some of the goods in an urban context. What was it about the experience of living in a town that led to these kinds of differences? One possibility is that the differences shown in table 4.1 are reflections not of the experience of urban life but rather of the occupational structure of towns. All urban areas had more varied trades than rural ones, with concentrations of manufacturing, crafts, dealers, and services. We will see in chapter 8 that tradespeople, especially dealers and retailers, were more likely to own all kinds of goods than those in agricultural occupations and even than the lesser
77
Notes See table 4.1. Occupations are discussed in chapter 8 and appendix 2.
Table 4.2 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in farmers’ and tradesmen’s inventories, in town and country, 1675–1725
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
gentry. Table 4.2 cross-tabulates the proportions of inventories with the goods in a more complex way by distinguishing all trades from all farmers in each kind of place. There are two features showing that both occupation and locality influenced ownership. The influence of place can be seen by comparing the tradesmen in different kinds of places. Here the same kind of hierarchy can be seen, with tradesmen living in towns more likely to own most of the goods than tradesmen living in rural places. There were exceptions; clocks and books appeared as frequently in rural as in urban trade inventories. Some goods were as common in the rural trades as in the lesser towns, but were more common in major towns and London. The influence of occupation can be seen in outline by comparing trades and farmers in the different places, allowing for the small numbers of these in the major towns and London. Farmers in the urban parishes were more likely (again with the exception of clocks and books) to own the goods than the ones in the rural sample. The same proportions of farmers and tradesmen in the London area had pictures and china, whereas these were virtually unknown among farmers in the lesser towns and in rural places. Looking glasses occurred twice as frequently among farmers in the parishes of provincial towns as among those in rural places. It is the meanings of these patterns that are important, both in what they tell us about urban life and culture, and in what they reveal about the impetus behind consumer behaviour, changing or not. Urban areas could be integrated to a greater or lesser extent into the local and regional economies, and a further perspective on the likely importance of towns can be gained by observing the proportions of goods recorded in urban and rural inventories from the eight regions of the country from which the sample was taken. Table 4.3, which distinguishes urban from rural, shows that there were considerable differences between town and country in each region, as well as between the regions themselves. In particular, there were greater differences between town and country in some regions than in others, and this reflects the differences in regional development examined in the previous chapter.
Urban experience and material life Why should living in a town result in a greater likelihood of owning domestic goods? One explanation that has been found attractive
79
Note See table 4.1 and a discussion of regions in chapter 3, especially table 3.2.
Table 4.3 Frequencies of ownership of selected goods in a sample of inventories in towns and country areas in eight regions of England, 1675–1725
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
is that urban life and culture focused on display and on the concentration of leisure and other facilities for people to meet each other.14 Public and civic rituals certainly celebrated (in a number of symbolic ways) the life of the town as a unit and the political and social authority of its leaders. It is interesting to be able to show that urban community feeling was expressed in ways that distinguished one town from another and from the countryside, but it does not tell us why ownership of household goods should be different. Public occasions were public expressions of civic values, and did not influence private, household consumption and behaviour. There was more to individual consumption than social competition, fashion, and emulation, and there was more to individual consumption in towns than public competitive displays of personal wealth and status. Display of fine clothing in public places was not necessarily motivated in the same way as behaviour within the houses of middle-ranking people, and it is important not to conflate descriptions of entertainments with domestic material life and needs. Yet it is appropriate to enquire whether the experience of living in a town could have contributed to a greater tendency towards ownership of household goods. One possibility arising out of a central theme in this study is that personal and household behaviour influenced material life. Did something about the way people lived in towns lead them more frequently to own goods? Some of the goods most strongly associated with a concern for the ambiance of the domestic environment, especially pictures, looking glasses, and curtains, were certainly more common in towns. One aspect of the whole urban environment and of the psychology of living in towns, which could have influenced people’s attitudes towards their domestic movables, was that people lived there in closer proximity to one another than they did in villages or in dispersed settlements. Illustrations show visual images of this different density, and one of the Portsmouth area shows a compact town and open countryside. But would this have influenced what people did inside their homes? Dwellings were closer together, sometimes the buildings were built to accommodate more than one household, and buildings often abutted and were overlooked by other buildings.15 People are remarkably adaptable, but observations of modern communities have revealed that close proximity is stressful, even if the degree of overcrowding does not approach that in later tenements. In households that were not forced by poverty into overcrowding, one response to living near other people could have
81
82
THE NATION
Plate 6 Covent Garden, London, J. Van Aken, c.1720 (Museum of London). A town. A high density of people, market stalls, shops, and large buildings. Could these give a greater opportunity for consumption?
Plate 7 Dixton Manor House, eighteenth-century British school (Art Gallery and and Museum, Cheltenham). The countryside. A low density of people and fewer close daily contacts than in a town. Did this matter?
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
been a greater desire to look inwardly to the living space and to make this as aesthetically pleasing and comforting as possible through the addition of furnishings and goods. Window curtains, very strongly concentrated in towns, could be regarded as giving greater privacy to households living close to one another, as well as dampening noise and adding a softer texture to the décor of rooms. The new and decorative goods associated with eating and drinking were also markers of people’s concern that the material goods used in ‘frontstage’ activities should be attractive in appearance. Material goods could compensate for some of the inconveniences of town life. In some other ways, town life does not seem to have been markedly different. There is no evidence that the fundamental roles and activities of households were different in urban areas. The household still provided shelter, food, security, warmth, and a basis for full participation in a social life. The practical physical circumstances in which this happened were different, and there were more occasions when people met together, performing dayto-day activities, such as collecting water, buying bread or ale, or doing washing, than there were in the country. People did meet one another in the country; the difference lay in the numbers of people at an urban centre. The distinctions between town and country were not hard and fast, for a few country dwellers owned the new goods. Books and clocks were almost as common in rural areas and in some parts of the country they were more so. Likewise, there were many households with just basic utensils and furniture in both kinds of place. Three urban tradesmen’s inventories show this kind of variation. In the inventory of a potter in Burslem (a small industrial town of about 1,000 people) in 1714, basic equipment is listed, as well as decorative things:16 £ s d In the house place Eleven pewter dishes 2 dozen of plates 8 small dishes Two Little kettles, 2 potts one Warming pan one ffurnace one bakestone 9 small iron Things in the Chimney Place 15 white Earthen plates 2 small tables 6 chairs 2 spinning wheeles 3 looking glasses
110 0
1 2 0 015 0
For a weaver in Wellington in 1711 the inventory contains just ordinary furniture:17
83
84
THE NATION
£ s d In the Kitchen one ovall Table; one Short Skreene; one Grate, ffire Shovell Tongues other Iron ware; one old dishing bench & 3 pewter dishes & other old pewter & 3 old Segg Chaires; ffoure Stooles one warming pan Six Candlesticks 1 0 0 A blacksmith in a village (Dawley, Shropshire) in 1725 had very few domestic goods:18 £ s d In the Housplass It. one Tabell Bord and one form It. one Brass pan one Brass Keettell and a Brass pot It. one old Cohort It. Eight Small Poutter Disshess It. one larn pot and a Keettell It. one Geen [?] Cheers and other Lumber Goods
0 8 0 012 0 5 0 5 0 4 0 5
0 0 0 0 0
Furthermore, a distinctive urban domestic culture is not apparent in contemporary commentaries by the diarists and travellers. William Stout, for instance, lived in Lancaster from his teens, although his family were yeomen farmers. His values and daily behaviour do not seem different in kind from those of the other tradesmen diarists, who were less obviously urban. He certainly had his peculiarities, but these seem more a result of his own personality and experience than a reflection of ‘urban’ values. He did not approve of anything that seemed consumerist, especially in other people’s behaviour, and the values he expresses of hard work and sobriety would not have seemed out of place to people living in the country.
Supply and the inland trades There were other circumstances leading to some goods being common in towns. Many manufactured and most imported goods were more readily available in towns, for they often had markets and were at the nodes of transport networks. Images of town life often focus on the busy market, and even a rather pastoral scene of Henley-on-Thames shows the barges linking this area with
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
London. The marketing function of towns is the one characteristic of urban life that unequivocally distinguished town from country. Even the smallest towns were centres for the distribution of various kinds of goods. The retail and wholesale trades in consumer goods were not as sophisticated in the early eighteenth century as they were to become in the later part of the century, and this is one of the least-explored aspects of commercial change, partly because the evidence either does not exist at all or is very scattered. Studies of retail networks and itinerant dealers necessitate fitting together a complex jigsaw of scattered references. When this is done, it is apparent that there were coherent networks, flexible enough to expand and include new goods when necessary.19 They were also normally centred on towns and especially on the more important regional centres, where virtually every kind of household equipment and furniture was available, while many goods could easily be obtained in the smaller towns. In Cheshire, for instance, Chester was the largest town and had a market area that stretched beyond the county boundaries. It had shops able to supply many goods, and traders came from many parts of northern England and from London to display goods at the fair in the town. Travelling retailers also used inns. Other, smaller towns in the county had weekly markets, annual fairs, and a few shops.20 An engraving of the market square in St Andrews in the late eighteenth century presents an image of how a fair or market was seen as providing many kinds of goods. Urban dwellers, and especially those in the larger centres, had easier access to consumer durables, and especially to new goods, than people living outside the towns. In particular, townspeople could learn about new goods or appreciate the potential attractiveness of established things by seeing them at fairs or markets or in the shops where goods were displayed. This kind of mechanism had more to do with the towns’ role in the distributive trades and in the concentration of customers and facilities than with some abstract notion of consumerism inherent in the psychology of urban living. It is therefore worth exploring further. One of the problems in demonstrating relationships between the ease of supply and ownership of goods in towns is how to discover the distribution networks for domestic goods at this early date. Evidence from newspaper advertisements or trade directories are, for instance, extremely useful in enabling trading networks in particular commodities to be traced, but these sources are not
85
86
THE NATION
widely available before about 1750. However, patterns of trade in china, earthenware, and pictures illustrate how certain goods could be more readily available in some places than in others.21 The trade in chinaware is a useful measure of the influence of distribution networks on patterns of ownership.22 All of it was imported from the Far East before the 1740s, and it entered the British markets through auction sales at the East India Company’s warehouse in London. Here it was bought in large lots by specialist dealers, who came to be known as ‘chinamen’. These dealers, in turn, sold it to others, both in London and elsewhere; in so doing they played an important part in the development of the sales network in the trade. Chinese porcelain had long been imported in small amounts, but, owing to reorganization of the trade in China itself in the late seventeenth century, large quantities began to be imported in the 1680s; the import trade reached (with many annual fluctuations) a peak between the 1720s and 1740s. The main mechanism of distribution from London was for the chinamen to sell to wholesalers in the provincial centres, who resold to other dealers. Other dealers in London also bought from the chinamen, who also themselves had retail outlets in the City and West End. This means that stunningly attractive, decorated, useful china was available at modest cost in London and in certain provincial centres before it was widely known elsewhere. Inventories of shops selling glass and earthenware in Stamford (1721) and Abingdon (1696) show varied stocks of many kinds of pottery, but no significant amounts of chinaware.23 Details of the activities of the chinamen and dealers are obscured through lack of records, and only three of the forty-five merchants making purchases at the East India Company sales in the 1720s can be traced in other sources, two as chinamen in the 1730s and the other in a trading partnership with Ireland, having formerly been involved in making stonewares in Vauxhall and in an experimental factory in North Staffordshire.24 In Norwich, auction sales were held in inns in the early eighteenth century, and this was probably true of other centres. There were probably dealers in Liverpool, for Blundell was able to buy china there in 1719, having previously bought some from an itinerant dealer in 1710.25 By the 1760s, when the trade was much more clearly visible from many kinds of evidence, it is evident that the trade in china and earthenware was centred on London (where 153 dealers can be traced before 1780), but there were concentrations in Newcastle, Liverpool, and Bristol of twenty, twenty-eight, and thirty-two dealers
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
respectively. By this time there were dealers in most of the major and many of the minor provincial towns.26 Ownership patterns for china before 1725 are in keeping with a developing distribution network, centred on London and some main towns, but barely extended as yet to other places. Ownership was strongly concentrated in London, with fortyfour out of 109 references to it there. The next largest concentration was in north-east England, with twenty-eight references in towns and a further four in rural places. These followed trade routes, and in the north-east differences between town and country were more pronounced than in some other areas, notably Cambridgeshire and Kent. These reflect differences in economic development at a regional level. The importance of urban centres in the internal trading networks can also be seen by considering patterns of ownership in earthenware. China and earthenware were commercially different, for earthenware was made in many centres, such as London, Staffordshire, north Devon, Lancashire, Bristol, and parts of Yorkshire. There was a sophisticated distribution network, especially for decorated wares and the new stonewares. There were dealers in many places, and distribution was not centred on major towns or London. Ownership patterns too were less strongly concentrated on towns, although there were slight differences between rural areas and major urban centres. On this basis we might expect that new goods imported through London, such as hot drinks or pictures (many of which were imported), would be more strongly concentrated there, and in other towns, than items, like pewter, that were more widely available. Towns were important as centres of distribution, and this influenced the patterns of ownership of some goods with strongly concentrated sources of supply. It does not account for all the differences but was an important factor in some cases, as it was in the regional differences.
Diffusion from town to country If urban life gave opportunities for acquiring household goods— for whatever reason—did the process start there and diffuse into the countryside? Evidence from inventories and elsewhere shows differences between town and country, but it also shows that these were complex and were not great enough to suggest that towns
87
Notes See table 4.1. Changing ownership is discussed in chapter 2.
Table 4.4 Changing frequencies of ownership of selected goods in towns and country areas, 16751725
88 THE NATION
THE INFLUENCE OF TOWNS
were islands of active consumption surrounded by ‘traditional’ values in the countryside. On the other hand, table 4.4 shows changes in the frequencies with which some of the goods were recorded in the different kinds of places. This suggests that diffusion from town to country was taking place, especially for some of the newer goods. In most cases higher proportions of inventories recorded the goods in 1725 than previously, but the highest frequencies were in London or in major towns in 1715 and 1725. In some cases, such as utensils for hot drinks, this is a very clear pattern. Clocks and books show a more uneven pattern, and the established goods record smaller differences. This discussion shows that there was a closer integration of town and country than the polarity of the words suggests. From the practical point of view of how people acquired goods, visits to towns were frequent enough for country dwellers to see new things and buy them if they wanted to. Markets, shops, and fairs were visited regularly, even by those with few resources, or those living at a considerable distance from them. The diarists frequently refer to visits to towns in order to buy things; Rachael Pengelly made monthly visits to London, where she visited and bought clothes, groceries, and other things. This suggests that there could be close relationships between town and country and that the functions of towns as service and provisioning centres for a hinterland meant that goods were, if required, rapidly diffused to country dwellers. This returns the argument again to the nature of town life itself. Was there something particular about living in towns that led people to develop a slightly different material culture within their households? That there is not one answer is apparent from the scope of this chapter, and it is important to stress that the exact influence of life in towns on people’s behaviour and needs is elusive. It is one thing to feel that town life gave different opportunities; it is another to demonstrate exactly what was distinctive, especially since there was not one urban experience but many. The differences are best seen in terms of the more complex personal contacts possible in towns. People were liable to meet others and to learn about consumption and to have the opportunity to present themselves in a variety of different situations. This does not exclude the idea that some towns encouraged the display of wealth and status, but this was not the only motivation for owning household goods or decorating a living space. Thus the influence of towns can be seen in the same
89
90
THE NATION
kind of way as the influence of status: just as emulation and conspicuous consumption were not the prime movers behind the differences between people of different occupation and status, a desire to display wealth was not a prime mover behind urban domestic consumption. This evidence also supports the view that England was not a dual urban/rural economy, but that the towns and the countryside were integrated at many levels.27 However, this chapter focuses on the middle ranks in both town and country, and community of interest and behavioural similarities between tradespeople or farmers in the towns and country are more apparent than between wage-earners in agriculture and those in the urban trades. Perhaps the dualism was greater for those with few resources, and so this evidence about the middle ranks does not reveal everything about the influence of town life and its part in altering attitudes towards leisure and consumption at a lower level in society. In any case, it is also clear that the regional economy of the localities surrounding the towns was significant.
Part 2
THE HOUSEHOLD
5 FINANCING THE HOUSEHOLD: INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
A man he was to all the country dear, And passing rich at forty pounds a year. (Of the village preacher; Oliver Goldsmith, 1770)1 The final chapters take a different perspective on consumer behaviour, with the main focus on the economic and social behaviour in individual households. This enables us to examine what it was about everyday life that led to consumption of domestic goods. Consumption patterns are the aggregates of individual decisions, and the ‘unit of consumption’ was the household. It is therefore essential to have some perception of domestic behaviour to understand consumption, just as it is necessary to understand the firm in order to understand production. Four aspects of the relationships between domestic experience and consumer behaviour are outlined. First, the income of households is examined, for it was through their cash incomes that people were able to buy goods and services. Second, expenditure patterns are examined, since these give some indications of priorities and suggest that domestic goods were only one small part of the outgoings from middling households. Third, the social and expressive roles of households, and specifically the utilization of domestic space, are outlined by descriptions of the main activities of households. Finally, the relationships between ownership of selected goods and social position are discussed; in doing this the argument returns again to general problems about the relationships between economic change and social structures.
93
94
THE HOUSEHOLD
Household size and composition First of all we need to understand what households were like.2 They were of modest size: most early modern households in England and Scotland had between four and seven people living in them, and the houses for which there is evidence surviving contained between three and seven rooms. 3 In some places households were larger: the London listings of the 1690s record an average of as high as seven in one parish, whereas in Cambridge the average was four. Likewise the households of the middle ranks were larger than those of labourers: yeomen households in the English listings had an average of almost six people, but those of labourers had just over four; the same was true in Scotland.4 The shelter and nurture that these household gave was on a small scale in comparison with the establishments of the wealthy gentry. It is essential to emphasize this because many accounts of the domestic economy of early modern households are based on evidence from large establishments.5 On the other hand, the stress and impoverished material culture arising from one-room living does not apply to the majority of the middle-ranking households either. Life within the household was based on interactions between a small group of people who were well known to each other and who cared about each other, but each household was also a dynamic entity, with various phases in its life-cycle and many possibilities for change. Analysis of particular households and of the relationships that could arise when widows or widowers remarried show that these could become complex. The physical environment, especially in the established households that are the inevitable focus of historical study, had a certain continuity independent of the comings and goings of individual household members. All studies of household composition in England and Scotland show that most of them were headed by a married couple (70 per cent in the English listings) and most of the rest (18 per cent) by a widow or widower. Most had children (74 per cent), and just over a quarter had at least one living-in servant or apprentice. Yet there was plenty of scope, within this basic structure, for variation according to individual circumstances. Diaries enable the family lives of individuals to be traced; the household of Ralph Josselin, for instance, consisted of Josselin, his wife, a servant, and at least one child from 1642 to 1677. Ten children were born between 1642 and 1664, but only five lived in the household
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
at any time, and its maximum size was eight for a few years in the 1660s; with the departure of children, the household became smaller again and contained three adults after 1678. The diary does not say anything about the changing material life of the household, but it is evident that there were continuities, in that it stayed in the same place and retained the same functions, although there were changes in the numbers of people to be cared for.6 The same was true of the Lancashire yeoman, Richard Latham, who was far less well off than Josselin, and employed a servant only for a couple of months after each of his children were born. It is possible to trace some of the changes in consumer behaviour of this household through Latham’s carefully kept notebook of accounts; these show that expenditure on domestic durables, clothing, and books was greater at the beginning (before children) and at the end, when the children had grown up—an observation commented on more fully in chapter 6.7 There were other kinds of household. Those of unmarried men and women were more likely to change in composition than in size. Some instance of this is shown in two autobiographies of unmarried tradesmen, William Stout and James Fretwell. Unmarried men had the choice of ‘housekeeping’ for themselves, in the sense of having their own household with a housekeeper, but both Stout and Fretwell recorded that they were not comfortable living with servants—itself an interesting comment on their expectations of domestic life. They could board and lodge with someone else, to whom they made payments for a room and meals. Fretwell gave up housekeeping in 1735, ‘being weary of living with servants only since my sister left me’, but being a boarder was not always a good solution. Stout recorded of the few years (1735–9) in which he ‘gave over housekeeping and borded with my nephew’ that he ‘was not easy there’.8 The preferred solution was to have a female relative, preferably an unmarried sister, to keep house; Stout lived with his sister from 1691 until her death in 1725. After her death he normally lived with one or other of his nieces until they left to marry.
Incomes The financing of households of middle rank enables us to understand the economic basis of consumption, although less is known about the salaries and incomes of the middling ranks than
95
96
THE HOUSEHOLD
about wage rates. Income is obviously important to any understanding of the role of economic factors in consumer behaviour, for it was mainly through spending income that people could acquire consumer goods. Income and wealth are not the same thing, since wealth could take many forms not immediately relevant to the acquisition of household goods. In a later section of this chapter the wealth of the middling ranks is briefly discussed; it is demonstrated that inventories do give some measure of movable wealth and cross-tabulations show strong relationships between ownership of goods and the values of goods contained within inventories. This is followed by a discussion of another aspect of economic constraints on the ownership of goods, namely the prices of individual items. These were generally quite modest, and there is little evidence for price reductions at this time. This leads to expenditure patterns, which is the subject of the next chapter. Measurement of the incomes of the middle ranks presents considerable conceptual and methodological difficulties. It is best to take income to mean all kinds of input into households from all sources, whether formal cash payments, household labour, or informal rights and non-cash receipts. There is a serious lack of well-recorded evidence about incomes seen in this way, for, even if people kept accounts, they did not write down everything they received.9 Nor did they look at their composite income in the same way that we need to do in assessing the financial status of households, for garden produce, customary rights, and many things produced within the household were never (quite reasonably) valued by them in cash terms. Even cash incomes are hard to trace because the middling ranks did not receive regular sums in cash, so there is not even a source of evidence comparable to wage rates for labourers. The mixed nature of incomes causes very real difficulties in making generalizations about the sums of money that they might have had at their disposal.10 This is unfortunate, because it makes regional differences and differences between individuals difficult to quantify. The evidence does not show whether the incomes of people of middle rank were changing and whether they went up at the same time as increases in the ownership of goods. They were undoubtedly liable to short-term fluctuations, and people’s perceptions of them were liable to have constrained, or encouraged, expenditure. In examining the resources that went into households of middle rank we have to be aware that the situation was complex and the evidence sparce.
Figure 5.1 to illustrate the range os income available to household of middle rank
98
THE HOUSEHOLD
The range of incomes likely to have been received by clergy, tradesmen, and yeomen is illustrated in figure 5.1, which draws on a variety of evidence to show the range of values that household incomes had. This can be substantiated from a variety of scattered commentary about the behaviour of individuals and their expectations, which emphasizes that income was derived from various sources, in various ways. The continuous lines in figure 5.1 show estimates of ‘family’ (i.e. household) incomes made by King and Massie.11 There are many difficulties in interpreting, or even having much faith in, these calculations and the revisions of them that historians have suggested. In some ways they are vague, both in the annual totals suggested for the social and occupational subdivisions and in the fact that they do not give any indication of the complexity of the sources of incomes from fees, rents, investments, land, trade, and farming. Nor do the estimates link easily with other ways of seeing the social hierarchy. However, they do suggest orders of magnitude and the kinds of relationships that might be worth exploring further; they also have a certain internal consistency. Individual experiences, some of which are also shown in the diagram, could be anywhere within the suggested range, and even outside it. Figure 5.1 therefore gives a generalized overview of incomes and shows that they fell within the range £40 to £200 a year, and only the lesser gentry and the wealthier tradesmen received incomes of much over £200 a year. The overlaps in the incomes of yeomen, shopkeepers, and manufacturers are also worth noting, in view of the differences between their lifestyles and, as chapter 8 will show, ownership of household goods. The diagram suggests that the incomes of middle-ranking households were normally over £40 a year. There is some other evidence which supports a view that £40 a year from all sources was a minimum amount for maintaining a ‘middling’ lifestyle. Very ordinary yeomen were said to have incomes of £40 to £50 a year in the first half of the seventeenth century.12 Ralph Josselin commented in 1648 that his ecclesiastical income of about £50 a year was not adequate to maintain himself, his wife, three children, and a maid ‘in a very low manner’—which again points to a limit of around £40 for a smaller household.13 The recurrent theme in Adam Martindale’s autobiography is how to procure a basic income, especially after the loss of his living in 1662. He claimed to have ‘lived handsomly’ on an income from various sources which amounted to perhaps £60 a year not including produce
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
from his tenement.14 In the mid-seventeenth century £50 a year was thought capable of supporting a minister and his family.15 William Stout’s commentaries about his family’s finances and prospects are particularly revealing in indicating a lower boundary, because one of the themes in his autobiography is the problem of how people became established in farming or a trade and the need for hard work to do so. His comments, smug though they are on occasions, also point towards £40 to £50 a year as the kind of income that he, as a member of a yeoman/tradesman family, would expect if he was to support a household. His family farm was worth £40 a year. He offered to buy his nephew, John, an estate of £40 a year for farming; John refused and became a draper. His dealings with his nephew, William, are revealing in this context; after he took over Stout’s business he was not successful as a shopkeeper. Eventually, having subsidized him and paid off his debts, Stout made him an allowance of £40 a year to live on in 1739, which was increased to £50 in 1742. Stout comments (with some relish) that his nephew William’s family were able to ‘subsist’ on this with ‘great care’, a subsistence which included food, fuel, malt, meal, and clothing, but little beyond, as Stout put it, ‘plain fare’.16 A general ‘average’ household income does, of course, ignore annual and other fluctuations. Tradesmen or farmers could make net losses for some time without having to go out of business or even without recognizing that they were falling behind. Shopkeepers and traders are reported by Stout as having given up because the enterprise did not ‘answer’ after a few years, and Stout was especially keen on relating these incidents. Stout himself went for a number of years (1698–1704) without doing more than covering his household and personal expenses when he traded as an overseas merchant from Lancaster. From 1697 to 1703 he estimated that his estate ‘went down by £140’ (or 10 per cent), although it recovered rapidly when he took up dealing as a wholesale grocer.17 So that in any year, or even for several years, a household could receive less than usual and still be of middle rank. Several different occupational and status groups had incomes around the lower limits suggested in figure 5.1. This has importance for the study of expenditure and consumption patterns because the sources of these incomes were different; the lesser yeomen derived income largely from farming, including a large ‘subsistence’ or non-cash element which could not be used for
99
100
THE HOUSEHOLD
acquiring consumer goods. Some craftsmen, small manufacturers, and shopkeepers were also at the bottom end of the scale, although, since they received more of their income in cash, they had a choice about buying goods and clothing. The least wellpaid schoolmasters and clergy, especially if they had no income beyond their fees and stipends, were also at the bottom end of the scale, but professional families were usually better off because they received incomes from many different sources and did not rely on one salary or set of fees. Aside from annual fluctuations and individual variations there were two groups with incomes consistently below £40. The lowest estimate, apart from labourers and servants, was made by Massie for the husbandmen, although King had not distinguished different kinds of farmer. Massie was probably not considering the same people as those called ‘husbandmen’ in probate records, and he made little distinction between them and labourers in estimating income; but in any case this points towards a group of small farmers with fewer resources than yeomen. Understanding the position of the craft trades is crucial to appreciating the limits to the middle ranks, just as it is to appreciating their position in the status hierarchy. The crafts and manufactures were not clearly defined in King’s tables; they were probably underestimated by King and included several different kinds of people. There is considerable difficulty in defining these groups, since the terms used for many crafts could include people of different wealth and status, from manufacturers on a large scale to wage-earners. For example, the term ‘potter’ was used in many parts of the Midlands to denote several kinds of person, whose potential income, family connections, and life experience were radically different. A potter could be an employee, for potteries usually had several workers in them at this time.18 Such potters could earn as much as 10s. a week if they were in the skilled parts of the trade, such as throwing and turning. They probably worked most of the year, so their annual income could have been as much as 20, to which must be added food production and anything earned or produced by other members of the household. Such potters were not of middle rank but they were obviously better off than labourers and unskilled workers, also called ‘potters’ on occasions, who received lower wages of perhaps 6s. a week. Within the middle ranks were the small master potters, and some have left probate papers showing that they had estates comparable in size with those of yeoman; they sometimes had an
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
income from land ownership, either in rents or, more commonly, through farming it themselves, or keeping a few animals. They had possibly received an apprenticeship, and a retrospective estimate of the financing of a small pottery suggests that they got about £20 a year for their labour and a further £20 a year in profit if they were making ordinary earthenware. Finally, there were a few larger-scale manufacturers of earthen- and stonewares by the 1730s, especially in North Staffordshire, and there were a few large manufacturers of delftware in Bristol and London. These people had substantial investments in the fixed capital needed for a pottery of some size, as well as in circulating capital in the form of money owed to them by dealers. This could amount to several hundred pounds, and the scale of these enterprises suggests that these ‘potters’ were of higher status, with greater incomes than the others received.19 Even in the terminology of this one trade there were people called the same thing but with very different incomes. The same was true of other crafts; there were different kinds of weavers, from small independent masters to out-workers. Blacksmiths and ironworkers varied from owners of large wholesale concerns to workers in the iron trades; builders could be employees or substantial entrepreneurs—differences in scale that were reflected in different incomes. That this is less true of some trades like shoemakers, leather-workers, or brewers does not affect the overall conclusion that the craft trades could include people ranging from out-workers to substantial owners. Revisions to King’s and Massie’s statistics do try to take account of this in that the crafts and artisans are separated from the master manufacturers, but this can only be a crude way of acknowledging the variations within the same craft. Figure 5.1 also illustrates that the incomes of the better-off among the middling ranks were very much higher than £40, and, not surprisingly, much of the evidence about individuals falls within the upper part of the ranges of incomes. Many yeomen seem to have received up to £150 a year, although individual incomes are not easily traced.20 Professional people are better documented, and their incomes seem often to have exceeded £100 a year from different sources. Ralph Josselin’s income has been estimated at about £150–160 a year after 1660.21 Giles Moore valued the tithes of his living in Sussex at £131 a year, although he may not have collected the full sum. He also had £8 a year from the rent of a piece of land, as well as the produce of his
101
102
THE HOUSEHOLD
gardens and fishponds.22 William Stukeley reckoned his two livings in London were worth £150 together.23 The incomes of the other professions are not so fully listed because they were made up of many fees which are not recorded. James Yonge, who was a successful doctor, by the 1680s was getting a fairly high income from fees and other sources, although he had begun modestly in the 1660s. He numbered his patients at about 400 in 1703, but he evidently did not know what he had received in fees, for he never filled in the space in his diary saying how much they paid him. He did record £60–70 a year from being the surgeon in the docks in Plymouth, and he records getting £80 in a year from one family, so his total income was probably several hundred pounds a year. 24 Teaching was less remunerative, although it was often done alongside something else or by a young person just beginning to work. Martindale quotes 15s. a week as the usual rate for tutoring mathematics in a household of the gentry.25 Some shopkeepers could make a good living; Stout seems to have made, after his household expenses were covered, between £100 and £150 a year from 1690 to 1715, increasing to over £200 in the early 1720s, although he actually lost £300 between 1698 and 1705 when he traded as a merchant in Lancaster.26 The Pengelly household received at least £200 a year in the 1690s, and probably a lot more, because only the expenses of the household are documented.27 King estimated his own household expenses at £152 a year, but he does not include anything for rent and financial transactions of various kinds.28 More is known of the incomes of the lesser gentry, partly because they are better documented as a group and partly as a result of studies of gentry families in the mid-seventeenth century. In Lancashire most of them had incomes of less than £250 a year in the mid-seventeenth century, although the wealthy gentry households that are outside the scope of this study had very high incomes; in Lancashire 32 out of 774 identified gentry had over £1,000 a year. Individual experience here varied a lot, but the incomes of the gentry diarists used in this study were in the middle of the range. Timothy Burrell recorded his expenditure in 1686– 8 at around £300 a year. Sarah Fell’s accounts show expenditure of about £350 a year, but the income of the whole household was undoutedly greater.29
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
Sources of income Income was made up of a number of components from a number of different sources, some of which are very occasionally valued in money terms in the rare accounts of expenditure. The important distinction is between income received in cash, which could be spent on anything, and that which was less readily exchanged for goods and services. Concepts about occupation and work derived from a less flexible view of industrial societies should not be applied to the more fluid conditions of the early modern era. Most households produced some goods and food for their own use, and this is the most difficult part of household income to discover much about in detail, for garden produce, milk, hens, and so forth, are not valued in accounts and commentary. It is clear that most of the diarists had productive gardens with fruit and vegetables, as did Richard Latham, and these could have produced a large part of the non-staple food requirements of the household, whatever its status and occupation.30 Many farmers were able to retain some staple foods, but farms were not normally intending to be self-sufficient. The smaller farmers and husbandmen were likely to have derived a larger part of their needs from the farm, but even Latham bought a surpising amount of staple food, such as cheap cuts of meat, bread, and grain for bread. Thus households of middle rank, while not self-sufficient in food, could often produce a great deal themselves, and this gave them a certain independence from conditions elsewhere. The extent of this varied; town dwellers had less ready access to land and large gardens but more ready access to shops and markets. Similarly, some occupations, especially those with flexible work schedules like the clergy or doctors, were more suited to combination with other activities like gardening and farming. It was more difficult to combine farming with a craft or with dealing. Cash incomes were varied and complex, for one individual could receive fees, stipends, salaries, profits, rents, investments, gifts, and inheritance. It is rare to gain enough detail to reconstruct the proportions of income that came from each source, so that the one full attempt to do this for the Essex clergyman, Ralph Josselin, is all the more valuable. This shows that three components, which varied over his lifetime, were of greatest importance. After 1650 his annual income was about 150, with a peak in the 1650s of about 200 a year. Of this, 60 a year came from his ecclesiastical living, which rose to £80 a year after 1659.
103
104
THE HOUSEHOLD
In the 1650s he also got about 65 a year as the schoolmaster in Earls Colne. His third major source was from the rent, profits, and produce from land, which he gradually acquired after 1659, some with the salary from his teaching. From 1659 until his death in 1683 he received about £80 a year from it.31 Varied sources of income can be seen in a more general way in some other diaries, although these do not give enough detail for us to reconstruct the sums involved. Benjamin Rogers, for instance, nowhere says what he received, but it is clear from his diary that he farmed the glebe and ran a productive garden. He also did a considerable number of other things, such as making wills, giving advice, and acting as a doctor, for which he was presumably paid some fees; he also owned two houses in Bedford. Even so, having a large family, he once commented that he did not find his income adequate, had debts of 200 in 1729 and recorded resentment on 5 May 1732 that his mother did not leave him anything at her death, or only 20 which he claimed was his anyway.32 Others had less varied sources of income. Craftsmen, manufacturers, and dealers probably concentrated on their trade in order to survive, and many trades needed a great deal of commercial know-how or technical dexterity which were not readily combined with any other activity. In this respect, Stout seems representative of shopkeepers and wholesalers, and his experiences exemplify those of many other dealers and tradespeople. His main source of income was derived from running a shop (before 1698) and then a wholesale grocer’s and a shop after 1705, with a few intervening years in which he was a merchant and traded in other ways. His commentary suggests that he worked at these most of the time but he also did other things, although there is no indication of how much, if any, income he derived from them. He had a garden, and he gave legal and other advice to people, for which he could have been paid in some way. He also owned houses in Lancaster, and he may have had a small legacy from his family.33 His sister contributed to the shop by working in it and overseeing apprentices. Multiple occupations and varied sources of income were also possible for rural households, for there were different kinds of farming and a widening variety of crafts. In northern Cambridgeshire and the fens in general, for instance, the inventories show that income was to be derived from several sources, such as a cash crop like saffron or flax, from a smallholding, from spinning, or from activities such as that of
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
waterman. In the West Midlands and West Yorkshire the combination of iron or textile working and small-scale farming are well known, but the incomes derived from each component are not documented. Richard Latham likewise seems to have derived most of his income from the farm, but his family also spun flax, wool, and cotton.34 The income of the whole household was even more complex than that of its head, and this is extremely hard to trace because the work was often informally organized and casual. It is becoming clear from hints and references in many sources that the work of women and children could be significant, even if the sums involved were relatively small. Thus Martindale felt that ‘my wife being willing to keep a little stock of kine, as she had done formerly’ contributed markedly to the family’s economic security.35 Historians of women’s work have been especially interested in the informal work and incomes available to women and are gradually piecing together evidence that confirms that, although the main sources of income into a household derived from the occupation of the head of the household, the labour of women and children could give flexibility and contribute to the living standards of the whole.36 Latham’s accounts show that small sums could be involved in domestic handicrafts, and the small income derived from them could extend the range of goods, clothing, and food purchased. Here the patterns of expenditure became more varied in the 1730s when the household contained several daughters, and there is evidence for more activity in textile production than formerly. It is thus essential to take note of the income of the whole household, especially if some of it was received in cash.
Wealth and consumption The relationship between incomes and the ownership of goods cannot be derived from the probate inventory sample. On the basis of this discussion of the sources of income it can be suggested that people with a cash element in their incomes would be more likely to be able to buy a wider variety of household goods, and, from this point of view, it mattered whether income was from many sources and that some was available in cash. It is, however, possible to show relationships between the ownership of goods and the movable wealth of households, and it is to this that I now turn.
105
106
THE HOUSEHOLD
Wealth and income are not the same thing, although they are not unrelated. In this context, wealth can be taken to include all the accumulated resources of an individual or a household. It had two distinct components, akin to the capital employed in a manufacturing enterprise. Wealth was made up of fixed items like land and buildings, and movables of many kinds, including cash and credits. In addition, a useful distinction can be made between wealth that generated income or further wealth (such as rent from land or produce from agricultural equipment) and that which did not (such as dwelling houses, food, or consumer goods). Probate inventories list only movable goods, livestock, and debts owing to the deceased, so the total value gives only a partial account of an individual’s total accumulated resources. In particular, it omits real estate and debts owed by the deceased. In the case of traders receiving and granting credit (which was an acceptable and normal business practice at this time), the omission of their debts gives an inflated impression of their total ‘wealth’. Someone owning land or properties rather than movable goods appears to have had fewer resources than someone whose wealth consisted of movable goods or investments. People may have had access to vastly different resources during their lifetimes, although their movable estates were of similar value. As far as the use of probate inventories is concerned, it is virtually impossible to do anything about this because the relevant information is not normally recorded elsewhere.37 In addition, the total value of the inventory measures different kinds of things for different kinds of estates, and in particular the inventories of farmers and tradesmen did not record the same kinds of assets. Normally a farmer’s inventory listed a greater value in producer goods because the livestock, most of the crops, and any money owing for things sold were included. A tradesman’s did usually list producer goods, that is to say tools, materials, and stock, but these often had a low value relative to the income that was derived from them and they were less valuable than the farmer’s capital goods. As a result, inventories of tradesmen and farmers with the same total valuation show a different balance between the values of the goods recorded, and smaller proportions of farmers’ estates were recorded in household goods. The average total value of yeomen estates was 165, much the same as that of the dealers at 162, but the yeomen had lower valuations of their household goods, at 23 in comparison to 33 for the dealers. The mean value of household goods in yeomen’s inventories was one-seventh of the total value, but was one-fifth in all tradesmen’s inventories.
Sources and notes The sample is discussed in chapter 1 and appendix 1, where there are also details of the calculations and significance.
Table 5.1 Percentages of a sample of inventories with selected household goods in wealth groups defined by the value of the inventory
Sources and notes The sample is discussed in chapter 1 and appendix 1, where there are also details of the calculations and significance.
Table 5.2 Percentages of a sample of inventories with selected household goods divided according to the value of household goods
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
Table 5.1 shows the proportions of inventories in different ‘wealth’ groups, defined according to valuations derived from the whole inventory; table 5.2 shows the same information according to the value of household goods. In both, the goods were more likely to be recorded in inventories of higher value, and the relationship is stronger for household goods. These patterns are indicators of stocks of movable goods accumulated over a period of time, and the tables express relationships that cannot take account of many of the details of wealth, or of changing resources over a life cycle, although they do show that economic resources were important. The patterns in tables 5.1 and 5.2 show that higher proportions of inventories recorded goods in the groups with higher valuations. In every case there is a general tendency for ownership to increase as the recorded values become greater. The progression is also a fairly smooth one. There is more even distribution among the well-established goods, especially pewter, tables, and cooking pots, although the estates of lower value were less likely to own even these common goods. Clocks were individually expensive and barely occur at all in the inventories of lowest value. Of the other goods, only looking glasses and table linen were frequently recorded in the inventories with totals valued under 25 and the new goods were rare, occurring in few inventories with household goods valued at under 25, roughly the mean value for household goods in the sample as a whole.38
Costs and prices Another way of looking at ownership of goods in economic terms is to examine their costs and prices. There is scattered information on the values of individual goods in inventories as well as the prices paid in household accounts. Table 5.3 lists the ranges of values commonly assigned to the goods examined in detail. There is a reasonable consistency in the values given to most items, and for the purposes of suggesting orders of magnitude there is no need to be over-concerned about the criteria that appraisers used. (They were supposed to value at what they might reasonably expect to sell them for, rather than a new price.) There were no systematic changes in valuations within the sample, so the table covers all areas and dates of the survey. The values of the household goods have some bearing on the realtionships between wealth and ownership, and are also
109
110
THE HOUSEHOLD Table 5.3 Ranges of values given to selected goods in inventories
suggestive of the ways in which choices were made. Materials used for tableware and drinking vessels are instructive as examples here. Ownership of tableware, drinking vessels, and other utensils of different materials is illustrative of the complexities of relating prices to consumption in this period. Earthenware cost very much less per piece than pewter: typically an ordinary earthenware utensil that might be used at table cost about 2d., whereas pewter cost at least a shilling and normally 2–3s. for a dish and rather less for a plate. However, pewter was actually better value because it retained its monetary value, with old vessels valued at about twothirds of the new cost, and they could also be part exchanged for new.39 Secondly, pewter was not liable to break, and a potter suggested in the 1690s that if the price of delftware (a white decorated form of earthenware, with a very fragile surface) went up it would not sell: ‘other vessels of Pewter, Tin etc. would have been used, rather than Pots, because of their being very liable to break.’40 China was newly available in reasonable quantities in the early eighteenth century, and was most commonly used for new purposes, notably for hot drinks and for decoration, so it
INCOME, WEALTH, AND PRICES
was not in competition with pewter. At about 6d. a piece it was much more expensive than pewter because it was more fragile; although the initial price of pewter was greater, it wore well and retained part of its value. It was not until much later in the eighteenth century that earthenware became stronger and more aesthetically attractive than pewter, which was then gradually superseded by crockery as we know it. Even so, Cobbett was still fighting a rearguard action against crockery in the 1820s as being too costly for labourers’ families; he argued (somewhat unreasonably) that they would be best served by pewter because of its durability. Another problem in specifying economic relationships is that some of the relatively new goods, whose ownership was expanding markedly in the early eighteenth century, were not individually very costly. Pictures and prints, for instance, varied a great deal in price, but many were valued at less than a shilling each; small looking glasses were a few shillings each; a knife-and-fork set was about a shilling. The highest-quality pieces of these goods were more expensive, but what matters here is that they could be acquired for what seem to be fairly modest sums in comparison to the incomes of families of middle rank or even the total value of their household goods. This requires another way of looking at the domestic economy of middle-ranking households, namely their expenditure patterns on all kinds of goods and services, and this is the subject of the next chapter.
111
6 FINANCING THE HOUSEHOLD: EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
Look about your houses, in every degree: And as your Gettings are, so let your Spendings be. (Kentish yeoman in the 1760s)1
Expenditure patterns can tell many things about spending priorities and the contexts in which household durables were acquired. Household expenditure by people of middle rank is unfortunately difficult to trace and analyse, for comprehensive household accounts are rare, even for the more literate and selfaware professional people and the lesser gentry. Furthermore, those that do survive are extremely awkward to analyse because they contain so many detailed entries. They do, however, give a more eloquent view of the economic life of a household than can be seen by looking at income alone. They also enable us to place expenditure on household durables within the context of expenditures on many other things needed to maintain the household, for household goods were not the most expensive things bought and they were often acquired in an erratic and irregular way. In examining household expenditure patterns, we are getting close to consumption, as opposed to ownership. It is not possible to take account of enough households to enable the kinds of regional and other distinctions that have been made using inventories to be maintained. Instead, the accounts used here can be taken as exemplifying broad trends. Three accounts are used here in order to convey something of the many ways in which households could use their resources and spend their incomes. 2 These three are not necessarily representative of all households; they just happen to have survived. Their value is that they contain a great deal of detailed evidence 112
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
about the ways in which households were financed and goods acquired. They are, fortunately, from different types of household—one of a small farmer in a simple nuclear family in south Lancashire; one of a merchant’s wife (later a widow) in Finchley, near London; and the other of lesser gentry status in north Lancashire. Detailed breakdowns of expenditure from these accounts over a number of years are shown in tables 6.1 to 6.3. In conjunction with these, an analysis of expenditure by an aristrocratic family in Edinburgh and a budget by Gregory King of the costs of running his own household in London in the 1690s are outlined in table 6.4.3 The tables subdivide the expenditure of these households under headings that distinguish food, clothing, household maintenance, furnishings, miscellaneous spending, and financial affairs. This book focuses on furnishings and equipment, which normally amounted to only a few per cent of domestic spending. This chapter therefore places these things in the context of total expenditure, and thus of household consumption. In trying to observe people’s outgoings and expenditures from household accounts, there is a temptation to try to ask rather modern kinds of questions which would asume that all (or most) things that were used or eaten were bought with cash. This temptation is reinforced by King’s analysis of his own household, which is firmly based on the assumption of cash expenditures. There is also an opposite temptation to imagine that the households with which this study is primarily concerned dealt ‘in kind’ and that it is therefore not possible to know much about them and their outgoings. It may even be inappropriate to think in terms of ‘expenditure’ at all. These are important points about the meanings behind the documents, and there is no single answer to the issues that this raises. One approach lies in trying to be sensitive to the particular household economy represented by each account, and to take notice of this before endeavouring to answer wider questions about the proportions of expenditure on food, clothes, entertainment, and domestic goods. As has already been noted in discussing people’s incomes, the inputs into most households of middle rank were by no means simple and were not always in cash; the same is true of expenditure. In addition, the documents themselves are not always clear about the exact purpose of every payment; whether grain was for seed or for consumption; whether flax was to be spun for cloth and clothing for household use, or whether the yarn was to be sold (or both); whether a servant worked on the land or in the
113
114
THE HOUSEHOLD
house; whether milk was sold or consumed in the household. Thus our perfectly reasonable and proper desire for clear answers to questions about how much was spent on food or clothing is easily thwarted by the fact that the documents themselves are reflections of a complex domestic economy based on different kinds of input and output. In addition, there are obvious problems in knowing how accurately the account was kept, what was left out, and how to allow for this. As we do not know anything about what is not there, the discussion is based on what is in the accounts but with some regard to the possibility that explanations for curious patterns are due to omissions of various kinds. The rewards of observing expenditure from an individual account, as well as some of the problems of doing so, can clearly be seen from the account book of Richard Latham of Scarisbrick in Lancashire, which he began in the year of his marriage, 1724.
Richard Latham Richard Latham’s account book is unusually detailed, with sums recorded for many small items as well as a large payment of 40 for renewing his lease in 1728, a sum that was more than twice his normal annual expenditure. In table 6.1 each entry was categorized under headings which try to do justice to the complexity of his outgoings and to the fact that entries about his household and farm were made alongside one another, sometimes on the same line, even if each was valued separately.4 Typical of many entries are these from 1735:5 garden seeds. 5d: treakel. 4 1/2d: pease2d Plowing in midle filde ye 5 of April
s d 0 011½ 0 1 8
It is clear that some of the expenses must have generated income, although the accounts do not show this, for he does not note money that he received. Here he is recording the purchase of flax, but what happened to it is not noted, except that no payments are to be found for weaving or anything that might suggest that it was spun for use in the household. It is most likely to have been sold as yarn. s d for 2 stone of flax at Kirkam.l0s. dressing of it.6d. 14 pound to ye stone .ye 23 of November
010 6
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
This intermingling of expenses connected with household consumption and with production makes it meaningless to analyse Latham’s affairs in as simple terms as those that might be used for a household whose economy relied mainly on cash income and cash outgoings. So the table distinguishes expenditure associated with production from that associated with consumption, in so far as this is possible, for an unknown amount of the produce of the farm and garden were consumed by the household. There were also unpaid labour inputs by the household into brewing, making clothes, washing, and cleaning. The part played by each outgoing can best be seen by examining expenditure on different things separately, except for one general observation, which is that there were remarkable variations from year to year, quite apart from the evolution of the household from one containing a newly married couple without servants, to one with up to five children, still without servants, and indeed very little paid domestic help, except for washing, and household help when Nany Latham was giving birth to children and once when she was ill. The average expenditure shown in the table (excluding the first year because of unusual purchases of livestock, furniture, and utensils when the household was set up) on most items gives only a generalized impression of expenditure in any one year. Payments in connection with farming and livestock were as low as £1. 8s. 9d. and as high as £9. 4s. 8d., with a mean of £5. 2s. 4d. Equally, whereas about half as much was expended on average on food as on the farm and garden, in some years the differences were much greater and in others the amounts were similar. Household maintenance was the most steady, at about 12s. 5d. a year, but even here there were some years in which the sums were much lower. Expenditure on furniture and utensils was the most liable to wide fluctuations, with virtually no purchases made in many years, but with unusually large sums laid out in the first year. Such annual variations (unless they were the result of poor record-keeping, which is always possible and should not be over-looked, even though these accounts seem particularly detailed) may have been characteristic of a household of restricted means. Expenditure would be made on those things which were the most urgent in the circumstances of any one year, circumstances which the accounts do not enable us to reconstruct but which were related to many factors, such as harvests, illness, childbirth, the need to pay debts, to renew a lease, or to support additional people in a household. Thus it is notable that expenditure on food and clothes was lower
115
Notes All figures apart from the last column are amounts calculated to the nearest shilling. See also text and notes 2 and 3. * = amount less than 6d. - = no data
Source ‘Account book of Richard Latham of Scarisbrick, Lancashire, 1723–1767’, Lancashire Record Office, DP 385.
Table 6. 1 Household and other expenditure of Richard Latham of Sea risbrick, Lancashire, 1 724–1 740
Table 6. 1 Cont. Household and other expenditure of Richard Latham of Scarisbrick, Lancashire, 1 724–1 740
118
THE HOUSEHOLD
than usual for several years after the lease was renewed in 1728 and did not return to previous levels for five or six years. On the other hand, the years after about 1735, when the household seems to have done more spinning of cotton and flax, saw greater expenditure on furniture, equipment, books, and clothing. A household of this kind needed to be extremely sensitive to maintaining the balance between income and urgent outgoings in order to survive, as this one clearly did most successfully. The result was that in some years the balance between expenditure on different things varied markedly from ‘normal’. In most years, production and purchase of food accounted for a very high proportion of recorded expenditure, but we cannot know how much of the produce of the farm was sold because the accounts do not record receipts, though some of it undoubtedly was sold. Income was thus generated to pay for other things and also to pay off Latham’s lease and loans over a reasonable number of years. The farm was a mixed one; normally he kept about four cows with a pig and some hens, and these were numerous enough to have produced milk, milk products, and young animals beyond the needs of the small family and therefore to have generated income. He grew a remarkable variety of crops, to judge from the seeds purchased, including the staple grains, wheat and oats, potatoes, cabbages, peas, carrots, onions, clover, other garden vegetables, and fruit. Some could have been retained for household use and some sold, but the accounts do not say which. The farm and garden alone produced such a wide variety of food that, if it was eaten by the family in reasonable quantities, it amounted to a very adequate, mixed diet. Food was purchased as well as grown, and about the same was spent on staple foods as was spent on the farm or on the livestock separately, again with notable annual variations. The staple foods included bread, oatmeal, and cheap kinds of meat, notably the hearts and plucks of sheep and the heads of sheep and calves. A further few shillings a year were spent on sugar, dried fruit, pepper and spices, and these added variety to the diet that could have been had from the farm and garden alone. This shows that a farm, even if a wide variety of field and garden crops were grown and livestock kept, was not necessarily ‘self-sufficient’ in the sense that it produced all the food that was needed. Here meat and grains were purchased as well as things that could not be grown locally. This should be seen as adding variety and security to food supplies, rather than as making up deficiencies.6
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
Food was of central importance to such a household of small means, although this is rather difficult to demonstrate purely in terms of the proportions of expenditure devoted to food production and purchase. Table 6.1 shows that the proportions varied from year to year, but, even if we take the mean of the years after the first, the proportions also depend on whether the financial affairs of the household are included or not. As a proportion of expenditure on consumables, bought food accounted for 26 per cent of expenditure and all farming and food production (some of which was sold) for 46 per cent, making a total of 72 per cent. If the percentage is calculated on the basis of total outgoings, then only 17 per cent was spent on food and 30 per cent on food production, including that for market—a total of 47 per cent. Both are shown in the table for comparison with other accounts or budgets, but, either way, no other single kind of purchase was of such great importance. A second basic need, that for clothing, shoes, and other miscellaneous items of dress, is also listed in some detail in the accounts, and here too a distinction is apparent between purchases of wool, flax, and (after 1736) cotton on the one hand and other items of clothing and cloth on the other. The raw materials do not seem to have been purchased to make clothes for members of the household, for there are no records of payments for weaving, and they do not seem to have had a loom themselves. They bought flax in order to spin it into yarn for sale, so that purchases of raw materials, equipment for spinning, and several pairs of knitting needles were part of the productive activities of the household. Table 6.1 distinguishes these two kinds of purchase and shows that the production of yarn or knitted goods was variable and on a modest scale at less than 1 a year, although in the 1730s this accounted for about a tenth of outgoings. This does not mean that the cash income from this was unimportant to the household, especially since the work could have been done by the daughters, the eldest born in 1725. Clothing itself was the second largest single expenditure on the people in the household, and in some years its cost was similar to that of staple food. The purchase of clothing was very varied, and different things were acquired in different ways. The main garments were made up from cloth bought specially for particular items and made up by a tailor, who was paid at a daily rate. These kinds of entries are illustrated by this extract, from August 1737:
119
120
THE HOUSEHOLD
dicy new shoon.2d: & Ann. new shoon. cloath dicy 3qs. 1.7d: searg. Alice new gown 1 yard & h. lin & wool Ann & kerch. dicy new hatt. 11d: silk tape. 4 yards.8d: sop.Id. Taylors work, ye 16.17.18.19. of August bety.dicy.Rachael new clogs. 8d: bacon.4d
s d 3 3 1 9 5 5 1 8 4 0½ 1 0½
There are no references to yarn being woven, either in the household or by a weaver. Clogs were made up in a series of steps; the wooden soles were bought, someone was then paid to shape them, leather and nails were bought, and they were presumably made into clogs in the household. Some smaller or specialized things were bought ready-made, including aprons and scarves, shoes, stays, and hats. There was therefore a mixture of different ways of acquiring items of dress and of using household labour to make much, but not all, of what was needed—a characteristic pattern for purchases of clothes in other households.7 Heating (by coal and .peat bought a few times a year), lighting (by candle), and washing (soap, starch, and cleaning utensils bought frequently in small amounts) accounted for much less than was spent on food, but it was still an important part of the expenses of the household. These were important to the wellbeing and comfort of people living in the house, and expenditure on them was more regular than on some other things. On the other hand, furniture and utensils were not recorded regularly, and many years went by without any purchases recorded. In the first year of the accounts, the year in which Latham married and set up the household, the relatively large sum of £4.2s. was spent on utensils and furniture, but after this only a few shillings a year went to buy utensils such as cups, plates, and dairy equipment or to mend metalwares, and this gives the impression that the household did not seek to expand or improve its equipment, although the sums increased a little in the late 1730s. This was due to purchases of dairying vessels and to some replacements of basic equipment, such as a fire grate, rack, and pothook, costing 2s. 3d. in 1737. None of the new or unusual goods that have been observed from inventories were recorded, although a few books were bought, as in 1733:
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
spend 4d: salme book new & horn book 6d version by N. tate & brady
s d 010
There were also payments for the repair of a clock. There were a large number of very small payments for numerous other purposes, and these are shown separately in the table because they are indicative that even a household of rather small means had interests other than day-to-day physical survival and did maintain some contact with the outside world. As a proportion of total expenditure these were trivial, but they may well not have been trivial in relation to how the family behaved and saw itself. Thus a few shillings were spent on ‘school wages’ for sending children to school and on books for them in the 1730s. In 1735, ‘new teastament. l.ld.…for betty to learn in’, and in 1738, ‘new psalme book.l0d: & childs guide: l.ld’. Such purchases distinguished this from many illiterate households. A few pence were spent each year in travelling to the local market, in visits, and at the fair—as in 1740, ‘Nany going to her sister Alise ye 26 Feburary Id’. At the birth of each child, a midwife was paid and a payment made, usually to a relative, for someone to look after the house for a few weeks, as in 1731: the midwifs office at ye birth of ye child Ann Prescot ye 13 day of July. Margaret bigins …. wages for 3 weeks to Ann Culshow tenting my wife Ann my wife returning thanks after child bearing
s d 1 6 3 0 4 6 0 6
The other medical expenses were small, usually herbs, oils, or ‘physick’, but, while small, the sums spent were important at crucial times and therefore in prolonging the life of the household. In 1735: s d sirups of march malo 2 ounces.5d.…for fisick when nany my wife was ill ye 11 th day of november …. wages to bety Latham 1 week nany was lame
1 6 1 0
Likewise there were a few sums for special occasions, such as a funeral in 1735: ‘for funeral expenses for the child the 7 day of may £l 10s Od’.
121
122
THE HOUSEHOLD
The financial affairs of households are always the most obscurely documented and difficult to understand from accounts, but they were obviously crucial. The largest single payment, of 40, was for a new lease in 1728: £ s d Paid to Mr Scarisbrick ye 16 day of April 1728 in part for a new lease Paid the other part the 26 day of April for parchment writing ye lease giving possession 26th day of April
20 0 0 20 0 0 110 0
The accounts do not indicate how this was paid, but in every year there were payments for the ‘use’ of money as well as some large sums repaid to various individuals. It seems that part of the money for the lease was borrowed and repaid during the 1730s, mostly before 1735. But the accounts do not say for what purpose the money had been borrowed, and it is also likely that small sums were borrowed for other purchases and repaid quite quickly. However, repayments and interest accounted for a notable proportion of the annual cash expenditure of the household, and they were undoubtedly essential for family security and well-being. Overall, Latham’s accounts show a number of features of the way in which households were financed and the place of consumer goods in their expenditure patterns. One is the importance of financing the three basic needs of households—for food, clothes, and shelter—and these accounted for most of the cash recorded here. Among these payments are those for new foods, notably sugar. They also include payments for clothing in much larger amounts than those for household equipment. The second is that very little was spent on utensils after the household was initially equipped, and this is what might be expected. However, this should not lead us to conclude that such expenditure was not important, either to the household or an an indicator of the consumption of domestic equipment and furniture. Domestic utensils were accumulated and not immediately consumed like food, so the small sums spent in some years do not mean that they were not important. Likewise, while only minute sums were spent on many miscellaneous things, these were not as trivial as they might at first seem, for they enhanced the lives of people in the family. Something was spent on services, the fair, books, and education, all of which contributed towards a cultural life that involved contact with the world outside the household. This was,
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
of course, an unusual household in that the head of it kept such detailed accounts; it is difficult to know how typical it was of other small farming households, and we cannot say how other yeomen and tradesmen behaved on the basis of this set of accounts by themselves. It does, however, have certain things in common with other households and shows the importance of expenditure on growing and purchasing food, and in the provision of clothes and warmth.
Rachael Pengelly Can the same be said of other households? Let us look in detail at another, which was very different in its structure, age, wealth, and location. The accounts kept by Rachael Pengelly began two years before her husband’s death in January 1695/6 and continued until just before her own death in 1709. Changes in the size and especially in the structure of the household had some obvious influences over expenditure patterns, so table 6.2 (showing the same kind of information as given for Latham) is divided into three phases. From 1694 to 1696 it contained Rachael and her husband, Thomas (a merchant, according to the catalogue of the document in the British Museum), and two servants, together with some other people in the household for part of the time. Their son may have lived there at the beginning but was living in chambers in London by May 1696. Three other people, Cousin Dyer, her maid, and a Mr Clarke, also lived there for all or part of the time. In January 1695/6 Thomas Pengelly died, but Rachael’s mother then visited with her servant, and stayed until her death in December 1697, paying for her board. So in the first phase of the accounts the household was quite complex, with a married couple (then a widow), co-resident relatives, and servants; this kind of complexity was not uncommon. In the next three years the household continued in the same kind of way, with Rachael Pengelly at its head, although the boarders seem to have left. Betty Alldersey, who was Rachael’s sister’s daughter (probably in her teens), and whose father had died in January 1698/9, joined the household in 1699 and stayed until 1708; many payments in the accounts after 1700 were made on her behalf. The third phase, which continued until the accounts ended in 1709, began when, for some reason not apparent, there was some change in the way in which the household was financed. After 1700, quarterly payments were made to ‘Cousin Ottway’ of
123
Notes All figures are amounts calculated to the nearest shilling. - = no data. See also text and notes 2 and 3.
Source Rachael Pengelly, ‘Household accounts, 1693–1709’, BM Add. MS 32, 456.
Table 6.2 Household and other expenditure of Raphael Pengelly of Finchley, 1694–1708
Table 6.2 Cont. Household and other expenditure of Rachael Pengelly of Finchley, 1694–1708
126
THE HOUSEHOLD
about £1.10s., with a payment of £100 to him in 1701. After this many household items continued to be recorded, but no basic food like grains or meat; payments for heating, lighting, furniture, utensils, her servants, and personal things such as travel and clothing continued to be recorded. In this respect, the last nine years were different from the first six, and this is reflected in the patterns of household expenditure. As might be expected in a household which spent ten times as much, or more, in a year than Latham’s, the proportions spent on food were much lower, amounting to 30 per cent of total expenditure on consumer items, or 12 per cent if financial payments are taken into account. Food was, however, the most important single item. But, except for small amounts of tea and coffee, this larger and wealthier establishment did not buy different kinds of food from the type bought by Latham, although the quality was certainly higher. They even had a garden and kept a few livestock, and some of the milk and milk products were sold. After Thomas’s death about twice as much was spent on food, which then amounted to a higher proportion of consumer spending, at 49 per cent. The household seems to have reduced its own food production at the same time, for little was spent on the garden, and fewer animals were kept. In the last phase, much less was spent on food, especially on staple food, although brewing and purchases of sugar, dried fruit, and hot drinks continued. This is interesting in showing how the same household, under different circumstances, could record very different patterns of expenditure, even on such a major item as food. Expenditure on clothing was proportionately less important for most of the time than it was for Latham. The sums could be quite large: in 1695 damask for a mantua, silk, and lining cost 18s. 6d., with a further 5s. Od. to make it up. In 1693, 4 1/2 yards of cloth ‘for Tomme’ cost £4. Before Thomas’s death as much was spent on clothing as on heating, lighting, and washing, largely because the cloth and clothing bought was mainly for him. Thereafter less was usually spent on it in a year than on heating, lighting, and so on, and many purchases in the 1700s were for Betty. Running the household was proportionately more important than for the Lathams—not surprisingly, in view of its larger size and greater resources. Rachael Pengelly continued to spend similar sums on heating, lighting, cleaning, and washing for many years after her husband’s death, and the reasons for the reductions after 1705 are not immediately apparent.
EXPENDITURE AND PRIORITIES
Furniture and utensils were bought irregularly and in relatively small amounts, just as they were in Latham’s household. For many years after Thomas’s death only very minor purchases were made and things bought were normally replacements for ordinary utensils, even if they cost quite large sums, as in 1693 when a brass kettle cost £1. 10s. Od. and an iron one 5s. Od. Decorative items were rare. A few furnishings were bought in 1706–8, but the amounts never reached the sums spent in the first two years of the accounts. They included things like linen, white earthenware, brewing tubs, and a few cooking utensils. This is most important in showing, in conjunction with the irregularity in Latham’s accounts, that household durables and especially furniture were not necessarily (then as now) bought with any regularity, for they were relatively enduring and there was little need to do more than replace minor items for many years. The greater resources available to this household also meant that proportionately more was spent on servants, tips, and small payments for services of many kinds, as well as for travel and for the services of apothecary and doctors. One of the last entries is for 13s. for ‘my doctor for things he gave me to take’. Rachael herself went to London using a coach at the cost of around 3s. 6d. about every other month to visit relatives, to attend ‘the meeting’, and to go to the shops, where she bought groceries, clothes, and many miscellaneous personal items. Expenditure on books and papers ended with Thomas’s death, although small payments were recorded for ink and paper, and Rachel could write very clearly and kept her accounts for many years, so was clearly not illiterate. The largest payments recorded here are the sums of money paid to relatives and others for no stated purposes, and these represent aspects of the financial affairs of the household. Some could have been for money previously borrowed: thus she paid £87. 14s. and then £5 to Allwin ‘upon morguage’ in May 1694; she also recorded at the same time £100 as ‘money received and borrowed from my mother for repayment of Allwin’s morguage’. But it is rare for her to be so specific or for the sums to be so large, although as much as £100 a year could be spent in this way. The other rather odd set of payments are those to ‘Cousin Ottway’ for lodging, because they seem rather small for herself, her niece, and two servants at 30s. a quarter, although she did pay a lump sum of £100 to Ottway in 1701. Her accounts do record less food after this date, but the rest of her domestic payments continued.
127
128
THE HOUSEHOLD
Moreover, it was not unusual for single people and widows to board with others, or even to live separately and eat their meals with another household. These rather variable sums spent on essentially financial affairs stress again that a household’s expenditure cannot easily be distinguished from its productive function and from how it was financed. It is also notable that there are considerable similarities between these two rather different households, and I shall return to the significance of this after a brief review of a third household, that of Swarthmoor Hall in Furness for the years 1675 and 1676.
Sarah Fell The household account or, more accurately, the cash book kept by Sarah Fell relates to a complex set of family property and relationships. Sarah was the daughter of Margaret and Thomas Fell (d. 1658), who had six other daughters and a son (d. 1670). At the time of the accounts, Margaret had married again to George Fox, well known as a founder of the Society of Friends, and she continued to run Swarthmoor Hall, which she had inherited from her first marriage. She also had other property, including Marsh Grange where one of her married daughters, Mary Lower, lived. Four daughters had married and three were living at Swarthmoor, together with their mother, George Fox (from June 1675, when he was newly released from prison in Worcester), and three servants. It was one of the largest houses in the area, with thirteen hearths in 1673. The accounts are complex because they record many payments other than for the running of Swarthmoor. There are a few references to other properties, especially Marsh Grange; there are many purchases on behalf of the married sisters; there are a few for ironworking, amounting to £3. 10s. in 1676; there are some in connection with the Society of Friends; there are many letters which were probably received in this connection as well. At the same time, there seem to be gaps, so that there is one small reference to hops but none to the other materials used in brewing, apart from yeast, which can also be used for bread. Likewise, although this was a mixed farm, seeds were bought for the staple crops, but no bulls or cows were recorded; pasture was rented in 1675 but not in the next year. An additional factor is numerous sums varying from a few shillings to over £100 recorded as repayment of borrowed money, money lent (sometimes for
Notes All figures are amounts calculated to the nearest shilling. – = no data. See also text and notes 2 and 3.
Source The Household Account Book of Sarah Fell of Swarthmoor Hall, ed. N.Penney (Ca