M.
A. KRASNOSEI/SKrI AND YA. B. RUTIOKII
vorond state University, Vorond'Institute of Oonstructional Engineering
CONVEX FUNCTIONS AND ORLICZ SPACES Translaled from the first Russian edition By
LEO F. B O RON
Direclor, Universal Om'respondence School of llfathematics
1961
P.
NOORDHOFF LTD. - GRONINGEN - THE NETHERLANDS
DEDICATION This translation is dedicated to Prof. Dr. M. A. Krasnosel'skii and to Prof. Dr. Ya. B. Rutickii. L. F. B.
Philadelphia 26, Pennsylvania, I96I.
Copyright I96I by P. Noordhoff, Ltd. Groningen; J This book or parts thereof may not be reproduced in written permission of the pubLishers. Printed in The Netherlands.
C O N T E N TS Page
IV X XI
DEDICATION . ANNOTATION FOREWORD . CHAPTER I
Special Classes ot Convex Functions § 1 . N-functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Convex functions ( I ) . Integral representation of a convex function (3) . Definition of an N-function (6) . Properties of N-functions (7) . Second definition of an N-function (9). Compo sition of N-functions ( 1 0) .
§ 2. Complementary N-function . . . . . . . . . .
11
Definition ( I I ) . The Young inequality ( 1 2) . Examples ( 1 3) . Inequality for complementary functions ( 1 4) .
§ 3. The comparison of N-functions . . . . . . . . .
14
Definition ( 1 4) . Equivalent N-functions ( 1 5) . Principal part of an N-function ( 1 6) . An equivalence criterion ( 1 7) . The existence of various classes (20) .
§ 4. The L1 2-condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23
Definition (23) . Tests for the Lh-condition (24) . The Lh-condition for the complement to an N-function (25) . Examples (27) .
§ 5. The L1 '-condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Definition (29). Sufficiency criteria for the satisfaction of the L1'-condition (3 1 ) . The LI'-condition for the complementary function (33) . Examples (33) .
§
6.
N-functions which increase more rapidly than power functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
29
35
The Lla-condition (35) . Approximations for the complementary function (36). The construction of N-functions which are equi valent to the complementary functions (37) . The composition of complementary functions (3 9) The Ll2-condition (40) . Properties of the complementary functions (44) . Test for the Ll2-condition for the complementary function (46) . Further discussion on the composition of N-functions (48) . .
§ 7. Concerning a class of N-functions . . . . . . . . . .
Formulation of the problem (52) . The class 9R (52) . The class 91 (55) . Theorem on the complementary function (58) .
52
VIII
CONTENTS
CHAPTER II
Orlicz SPaces Page
§ 8. Orlicz classes . . .
60
Definition (60) . The J ensen integral inequality (62) . The com parison of classes (63) . The structure of Orlicz classes (64) .
§ 9. The space LM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
67
The Orlicz norm (67) . Completeness (70) . Norm of the charac teristic function (72) . HOlder's inequality (72) . The case of the Lh-condition (75) . Mean convergence (75) . The Luxemburg norm (78) .
§ 1 0. The space EM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
80
§ 1 1 . Compactness criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
94
§ 1 2. Existence of a basis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
101
Definition (80) . The separability of E M (8 1 ) . Disposition of the class L M with respect to the space E M (82) . Necessary conditions for separability of an Orlicz space (85) . On the definition of the norm (86) . The absolute continuity of the norm (87) . Calculation of the norm (88) . Another formula for the norm (9 1 ) .
Vallee Poussin's theorem (94) . Steklov functions (95) . A. N. Kolmogorov's compactness criterion for the space E M (97) . A second criterion for compactness (98) . F. Riesz's criterion for compactness for the spaces E M (99) .
Transition to the space of functions defined on a closed interval ( 1 0 1 ) . Haar functions ( 1 03) . Basis in E M (lOS). Further remarks on the conditions for separability ( 1 07) .
§ 1 3. Spaces determined by distinct N-functions . . . . . .
1 10
Comparison of spaces ( 1 1 0) . An inequality for norms ( 1 1 2) . Concerning a criterion for convergence in norm ( 1 1 4) . The product of functions in Orlicz spaces ( 1 1 7) . Su fficient con ditions ( 1 20) .
§ 1 4. Linear functionals.
Linear functionals in L M ( 1 24) . General form of a linear function al on E M ( 1 28) . EN-weak convergence ( 1 30) . EN-weakly con tinuous linear functionals ( 1 33) . Norm of a functional and l!vll(N) ( 1 34) .
1 24
CHAPTER III
Operators in Orlicz SPaces § 1 5. Conditions for the continuity of linear integral operators 1 37 Formulation of the problem ( 1 37) . General theorem ( 1 38) . Existence of the function !l>(u) ( 1 38) . Concerning a property of N-functions which satisfy the .d'-condition ( 1 40) . Sufficient conditions for continuity ( 1 45) . On splitting a continuous operator ( 1 46) .
CONTENTS
§
1 6.
Conditions for the complete continuity of linear integral operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IX
Page
1 49
The case of continuous kernels ( 1 49) . Fundamental theorem ( 1 50) . Complete continuity and EN-weak convergence ( 1 52) . Zaanen 's theorem ( 1 55) . Comparison of conditions ( 1 60) . On splitting a completely continuous operator ( 1 64) . On operators of potential type ( 1 65) .
§ 1 7. Simplest nonlinear operator . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 67
The CaratModory condition ( 1 67) . Domain of definition of the operator f ( 1 67) . Theorems on continuity ( 1 69) . Boundedness of the operator f ( 1 72) . General form of the operator f ( 1 74) . Sufficient conditions for the continuity and boundedness of the operator f ( 1 74) . The operator f and EN-weak convergence ( 1 75) .
§ 1 8. Differentiability. Gradient of the norm . . . . . . . .
1 76
Differentiable functionals ( 1 76) . Measurability of the function O(x) ( 1 77). Functional for the operator f ( 1 78) . The linear operator f ( 1 78) . The Frechet derivative ( 1 79) . Special condition for differentiability ( 1 8 1 ) . Auxiliary lemma ( 1 86) . The Gateaux gradient ( 1 86) . Gradient of the Luxemburg norm ( 1 87) . Gradient of the Orlicz norm ( 1 89) .
CHAPTER IV
Nonlinear Integral Equations § 1 9. The P. S. Uryson operator . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 94
The P. S. Uryson operator ( 1 94) . Boundedness of the Uryson operator ( 1 96) . Transition to a simpler operator ( 1 97) . A second transition to a simpler operator ( 1 98) . A third transition to a simpler operator (200) . Fundamental theorem on the complete continuity of Uryson's operator (20 1 ) . The case of weak non linearities (203) . Hammerstein operators (207) .
§ 20. Some existence theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
208
Problems under consideration (208) . The existence of solutions (209) . Positive characteristic functions (2 1 3) . Characteristic functions of potential operators (2 1 4) . Theorem on branch points (2 1 6) .
SUMMARY OF FUNDAMENTAL RESULTS. BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTES LITERATURE. INDEX . . . . . . . .
217 230 239 248
ANN OTATION In the present book are discussed the theory of extensive classes of convex functions which play an important role in many branches of mathematics. The theory of Orlicz spaces (i. e. normed spaces of which the Lp spaces are a special case ) is developed in detail and applications are pointed out. The book is intended for mathematicians ( students in upper level courses, aspirants for the doctoral degree and scientific workers ) , who deal with functional analysis and its applications and also with various problems in the theory of functions.
FO R EW O R D The present monograph consists of four chapters. In the first of these chapters we study various classes of convex functions. The fundamental content of this chapter has been published, up to this time, only in various j ournal articles. It appears to the authors that the material in the first chapter is of interest independently of the remainder of the book inasmuch as convex functions are applied extensively in the most diversified branches of mathematics. In the second chapter, we discuss the general theory of Orlicz spaces-spaces which are the direct extensive generalization of Lp spaces . Here, we consider the usual problems of functional analysis with regard to applications to Orlicz spaces : completeness, separability conditions, the existence of a basis, equivalent normizations, com pactness conditions, properties of linear functions, and so on. It is made clear that Orlicz spaces are, in many cases, similar to Lp spaces. In the third chapter, we study operators and functionals defined on Orlicz spaces. The authors found it necessary to apply Orlicz spaces in the consideration of nonlinear integral equations of the form Atp(X)
J k(x, y)1 [tp(y)]dy, 1
=
o
where I(u) is a function which increases more rapidly than an arbitrary power function. The operator defined by the right member of this integral e quation does not operate in any of the Lp spaces. Therefore, the investigation of the indicated integral equations by the methods of nonlinear functional analysis turns out to be difficult . The results of the second and third chapters enable us to investigate wide classes of nonlinear equations . The fourth, and last, chapter of the book is devoted to the in vestigation of some nonlinear problems. The authors take i his opportunity to express their gratitude to G. E. � ilov whose many constructive criticisms were used in pre paring the present book.
CHAPTER I
S P E C I A L C L A S S E S O F C O N V EX F U N C T I O N S § 1 . N-functions
1 . Convex functions. A real-valued function M(u) of the real variable u is said to be convex if the inequality (1.1) is satisfied for all values of Ul and U 2 . We shall be interested only in continuous convex functions. Condition ( l . l) means that the midpoint of the chord connecting M (1.1)
Fig. 1 .
two points on the graph of the function M( u ) lies above the corre sponding point of the graph. It is geometrically clear (see Fig . 1 ) that every chord lies above the graph of the function, i.e. that the inequality M[IXU l + ( 1 - IX)U 2J � IXM(U l ) + ( 1 - IX) M(U 2 )
( 1 .2)
is satisfied for all IX (0 � IX � 1 ) . This inequality is called Jensen ' s inequality. Jensen's inequality can also be proved analytically .
CHAPTER I , § 1
2
In fact , let us assume that inequality ( 1 .2) is not satisfied for all oe in [0, 1]. Then the maximum value Mo of the continuous function !(oe)
=
M[oeul
+ ( 1 - oe)U2J - oeM(UI) - ( 1 -oe)M(U2)
on [0, I J will be positive: Mo> 0. We denote by oeo the least value of the argument for which !(oe) assumes the value Mo. Let � > ° be a number such that the segment [oeo -�, oeo + �J is contained in [0, 1 ] . Applying inequality ( 1 . 1 ) to the points =
u� u;
=
(oeo -�)UI + ( 1 - oeo + b)U2,
(oeo + �)UI + ( 1 - oeo -�)U2
and going over to the function !(tX), we obtain that !(tXo
)
"'::::
./
!(tXo - b) + !(tXo + �) 2
<
Mo ·
We have arrived at a contradiction which proves inequality ( 1 .2) . If UI oF U2, then equality is attained in ( 1 .2) either for tX ° and tX = 1 only or for all tX E [0, 1 ] . In fact, suppose equality is attained in ( 1 .2) for some tXo E (0, 1 ) . This means that !(tXo) 0. We shall show that in this case !(tX) ° for all tX E [0, 1 ] . It is eaosily verified that the continuous function ! (tX) is convex. Therefore it also satisfies Jensen's inequality. We assume that for some tXI E (0, 1) we have ! (tXI) < ° (by what we have already proved, ! (tX) cannot be positive) . We assume, for definiteness, that tXI < tXo. Since 1 - tXo tXo - tXI tXI + --I - tXI 1 - tXI ' =
=
=
tXo =
we have by Jensen's inequality that !(tXo)
�
tXo - tXI 1 -tXo ! ( I) !(tXI) 1 - tXI 1 -tXI
=
1 -tXo !(tXI) 1 - tXI
<
0,
which contradicts the assumption that !(tXo) = 0. Inequality ( 1 . 1 ) admits still another generalization: M
( UI+U2 + ··· +Un ) � -;;1 [M(UI) + M(U2) + ···+M(un)J n
( 1 .3)
for arbitrary Ul, U2, ... ,' Un. By successive application of ( 1 . 1 ) ,
CHAPTER
I, § 1
3
inequality ( 1 .3) is proved for all n of the form 2 k . The case of arbitrary n is more complicat ed. Let m be a number such that n + m 2k. Then
M
=
( UI + U2 + . . . + Un + mu* ) n+m
�
.
Settmg u*
1
n+m
�
[M(U I ) + M(U2) + . . . + M(un) + mM(u*) J .
= UI + U2 +n ... + Un , we obtam. ( 1 .3) .
We shall assume that U I � Ua � U 2 . Then
and, in virtue of inequality ( 1 .2) , we have that
from which it follows that
M(ua) - M(U I ) �-�
--�----�-
�
M(U 2 ) - M(U I ) �-�
--�----��
�
M(U 2 ) - M(ua) �-�
.
( 1 .4)
The inequalities obtained mean that the slope of the chord AB is less th� n the slope of the chord A C which, in turn, is less than the slope of the chord BC. 2. Integral LEMMA 1. 1.
representation of a convex function. A continuous convex function M(u) has, at every point, a right derivative p+(u) and a left derivative P_ (u) such that P_(u) � p+(u) . ( 1 .5) PROOF. In virtue of ( 1 . 4) , we have that
M(u) - M(u - h 2 ) h2
--�--��--�
�
M(u) - M(u - h I ) hI
�
1l·6)
4
CHAPTER
I, § I
It follows from these inequalities that the ratio
M(u) - M(u - h) h does not decrease as h -+ + 0 and, consequently , it has a limit P-(u) . Analogously, the ratio
M(u + h) - M(u) h does not increase as h -+ + 0 and has a limit p+(u) . Inequality ( 1 . 5) also follows from ( 1 . 6) . LEMMA 1 . 2. The right derivative p+ (u) of a continuous convex
function M(u) is a non-decreasing right-continuous function. PROOF . Let we have that
U l < U2.
+
Ul
h
Then, for sufficiently small positive h, - h and, in virtue of ( 1 .4) ,
< U2
Passing to the limit, we obtain ( 1 .7) From this inequality and ( 1 .5) it follows that ( 1 .8) The monotonicity of the function p+(u) is thus proved. As was shown in the course of the proof of Lemma 1 . 1 , for all h> 0, we have
p + (u) �
M(u + h) - M ( u) . h
Keeping h fixed and passing to the limit as u .
hm p+ (u) �
.......Uo +O
Uo
+ 0, we obtain
( o + uo -------
( 1 .9)
Mu
-+
h) - M( ) h
in virtue of the continuity of the function M(u) . The limit in the left member of this inequality exists in virtue of the monotonicity
CHAPTER
I, § 1
5
of the function p+(u) . Passing to the limit as h we obtain
�
+ 0 in p . 9) ,
U-'Uo+ O
On the other hand, p+ (u) � P+(uo) for u � Uo in virtue of which lim p+(u) � P+ (uo) .
Thus,
lim p+(u)
U-'Uo+ O
=
p+(uo) .
This equality does indeed mean that the function p+(u) is right-continuous. * REMARK. It can be proved analogously that the left derivative P-(u) is a non-decreasing left-continuous function. LEMMA 1 .3. A convex function M(u) is absolutely continuous
and satisfies the Lipschitz condition in every finite interval . PROOF. We consider any interval [a, bJ . Let a < U l < U 2 In virtue o f ( 1 .4) , w e have that M(U l ) - M(a) M(U 2 ) - M(Ul) M(b) - M(U 2 ) � . ------- � b - U2 Ul - a U 2 - Ul
<
b.
It follows from these inequalities that
p+(a)
�
M(U 2 ) - M(U l ) U 2 - Ul
�
P - (b) ,
i.e. that the quantity I {M(U 2 ) - M(Ul)}/(U2 - ul) 1 is bounded for all U l , U2 in the interval [a, bJ . *
=
THEOREM 1 . 1 . Every convex function M(u) which satisfies the condition M(a) 0 can be represented in the form
= f P(t) dt, U
M(u)
( 1 . 1 0)
a
where P (t) is a non-decreasing right-continuous function. PROOF. We note first of all that the function M(u) has a derivative almost everywhere. In fact , in virtue of ( 1 .7 ) and ( 1 . 5 ) ,
we have that
(1 . 1 1 )
for U 2 > U l . Since the function P - (u) is monotonic, it is continuous
6
CHAPTER I, § I
almost everywhere . Let U I be a point of continuity of the function P_ (u) . Passing to the limit in ( 1 . 1 1 ) as U 2 � U I , we obtain that P- (U I ) ?3 P + (U I ) ?3 P - (U I ) , i . e. P - (U I ) = P + (U I ) . Similarly, we have that M'(u) = P(u) = p + (u) almost every where . Since the function M(u) is absolutely continuous (in virtue of Lemma 1 .3) , it is the indefinite integral of its derivative (see, for example, NATANSON [ I ] ) . * p(t)
u
t
Fig. 2.
3. Definition of an N-function. A function M(u) is called an N-function if it admits of the representation
f pet) dt, l ui
M(u) =
( 1 . 1 2)
o
where the function P(t) is right-continuous for t ?3 0, positive for t > 0 and non-decreasing which satisfies the conditions
P (O) = 0, P (oo) = lim pet) =
00.
( 1 . 1 3)
t-->oo
Roughly speaking, the above conditions signify that the function
pet) must have a graph of the form shown in Fig . 2. The value of '
the N-function itself is the magnitude of the area of the corre sponding curvilinear trapezoid. For example, the functions M1 (u) = l u l lX/ex (ex> I ) , M2 (u) =e u ' - 1 are N-functions. For the first of these, P I (t) = M�(t) = tlX-1 and, • for the second, P 2 (t) = M;(t) = 2tet .
CHAPTER I , § 1
7
4. Properties of N-functions. It follows from representation ( I . I 2) that every N-function is even, continuous, assumes the value zero at the origin, and increases for positive values of the argument. N-functions are convex. In fact , if 0 � Ul < U2, then, in virtue of the monotonicity of the function P(t) , we have that M
( Ul : U2 )
f
(ul+ u.l/2 =
P(t) dt
�
o
J P (t) dt + t [ f u,
� o
=
t
P(t) dt +
U,
[ f P(t) dt + f P (t) dt]
J
u.
(u,+ u.l/2
=
P (t) dt
t[M(Ul)
]
=
+ M(U2)].
0
o
In the case of arbitrary Ut, U2, we have that M
( Ul : U2 )
Setting U2
=
M
( IUl : u21 )
�M
( lUll : IU21 )
= 0 in ( 1 . 2) , we obtain that M(IXUI) � IXM(Ul)
�
� t[M(Ul)
+ M(U2)].
(0 � IX � I ) .
( I . I 4)
The first of conditions ( I . 1 3) signifies that lim u-+O
M(u)
=
U
0.
( I . 15)
It follows from the second condition in ( 1 . 1 3) that lim U--+OO
M(u) U
=
00
smce, for U> 0, we have that
�
M U)
� f P(t) dt �� f P(t) dt � p (;) . u
u
=
o
u/2
( I . l 6)
CHAPTER I , § I
8
We note that for an N-function the equality sign can hold in ( 1 . 1 4) only in the case when ex 0, 1 or when U I = O. In fact, suppose U I #- 0 and that for some ex E (0, I ) the equality sign holds in ( 1 . 1 4) . Then, in virtue of what we said in subsection I, above, the equality sign holds in ( 1 . 1 4) for all ex E [0, I J . But then, for all ex E [0, I J , M(exU I ) /(exU I ) M(U I ) /U I . Passing to the limit as ex _ 0 in this equality, we obtain that lim M(exu I ) /(exu I ) M(U I) /U l , �O which contradicts ( 1 . 1 5) . Thus, =
=
=
M(exu)
<
exM(u)
(0
<
ex
<
I, U
=1=
0) .
( 1 . 1 7)
It follows from this inequality that the function M(u)/u is strictly increasing for positive values of u : - -- <
M(u') u'
--
M(u) U
(0
<
u'
<
u) .
( 1 . 1 8)
To prove this assertion, it suffices to set ex U' /u in ( 1 . 1 7) . The properties established describe sufficiently well the M(u) graph of an N-function (Fig. 3) . Property ( 1 . 1 5) signifies that the x-axis is tangent to the graph of the N-function at the origin. Properties ( I . 1 8) and ( 1 . 1 6) characterize the vari ation of the slope of the chord j oining the origin with a vari able point on the graph of the u N-function. The graph can contain salt uses and rectilinear Fig. 3 . segments. Salt uses correspond to points of discontinuity of the function P (t) and rectilinear segments correspond to its intervals of constancy. We denote by M- I (v) (0 � V < 00 ) the inverse function to the N-function M (u) considered for non-negative values of the argu ment . This function is convex since, in virtue of inequality ( 1 .2) , we have that M- I [exvi + ( I - ex)V 2J � exM- I (V I ) + ( I - ex)M- I (V 2 ) for V I , V 2 � O. =
9
CHAPTER I , § 1
The monotonicity of the right derivative P (u) of the N-function
M(u) implies the inequality M(u) + M(v)
f P(t) dt + f P (t) dt ::::;; f P(t) dt + + f P (t) dt f P(t) dt M( l u l +
=
lui
Iv l
l ui
0
0
o
lul+ Ivl
l u l + Ivl
=
l ui
=
0
Ivl ).
( 1 . 1 9)
Suppose a = M(u) , b = M(v) are arbitrary non-negative num bers. It then follows from ( 1 . 1 9) that
M- l (a + b)
�
M- l (a) + M l (b) . -
( 1 .20)
5. Second definition of an N-function. I t is sometimes expedient to use the following definition : a continuous convex function M(u) is called an N-function if it is even and satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 5) and ( 1 . 1 6) . We shall show that this definition is equivalent to that given above, in subsection 3. In the proof, we need only the fact that it follows from the second definition of an N-function that it is possible to represent it in the form ( 1 . 1 2) . In virtue of ( 1 . 1 5) , M(O) = O. Therefore, in virtue of the evenness of the function M(u) and Theorem 1 . 1 , it can be represented in the form
f P(t) dt, l ui
M(u)
=
o
where the function P(u) is non-decreasing for u > 0 and right continuous (i. e. the right derivative of the function M(u) ) . Since P(u) � M(u) /u for u > 0, we have that P(u) > 0 for u > 0 and , in virtue of ( 1 . 1 6) , limp(u) = 00. u---+oo
On the other hand, for u > 0,
M(2u)
=
f P(t) dt > f P (t) dt > uP(u) , 2u
2u
o
u
from which it follows that P( u ) < M(2u) /u. Therefore, in virtue of ( 1 . 1 5) , we have that P(O) = limp(u) = O. _0
CHAPTER I, § 1
10
Composition of N-functions . The composition [Ml(U)] M2 = M(u) of two N-functions M l(U) and M 2 (tt) is also an N-function. In fact, the function M (u) has (for u > 0) the right derivative P (u) P 2 [M1(u)]P l (U) , where Pl(U) , P 2 (tJ) are the right derivatives of the N-functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) . The function P(u) is right continuous, does not decrease, and satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 3) inasmuch as the functions P l (U) and P 2 (U) satisfy these conditions. The converse assertion is also true : every N-function 21£(u) IS the composition M(u) M 2 [M1 (u)] of two N-functions. If the N-function M l (tJ) is given, then the function M 2 (u) IS 6.
=
=
uniquely defined by the equality
( 1 .2 1 ) where Ml l (v) is the function inverse to M l (U) . Thus, to represent M(u) in the form of a composition, we must find an N-function M 1 (u) such that M 2 (u) M [M1I( l u l )] is also an N-function. Since, for u > 0, we have that
=
a necessary and sufficient condition that M 2 (U) be an N-function is that the function P (u)!h (u) be non-decreasing, right-continuous, and satisfy conditions ( 1 . 1 3) because the continuous function Ml l (v) is monotonic and tends to zero and to infinity together with v. Thus, if we find a non-decreasing right-continuous function Pl (U) , satisfying conditions ( 1 . 1 3) , such that the function P (U)!Pl(U) is also non-decreasing, right-continuous, and satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 3) , then the functions lui
M1(u)
= I Pl(t) dt o
=
and M 2 (u) , defined by equality ( 1 .2 1 ) , will be N-functions, where the equality M(lt) M 2 [M1 (u)] is valid. In particular, the function Pl (U) can be taken as the function
P l (U)
= [P(u)J"
(0
< EO <
1 ).
CHAPTER I , § 2
11
We note further that if the N-function is the composition
M 2 [M1(u)J of two N-functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) , then to each k> 0 there corresponds a constant Uo � 0 such that , for u � uo, we have M(u) > M 2 (ku) . § 2. Complementary N-function
1. Definition . Let P (t) be a function which is posItive for t > 0, right-continuous for t � 0, non-decreasing, and satisfying conditions (1.13). We define the function q(s) (s � 0) by the
equality
q(s)
=
sup t.
(2.1)
p(t),,;;;s
It is easily seen that the function q(s) possesses the same properties as the function P(t) : it is positive for s > 0, right-continuous for s � 0, non-decreasing, and satisfies the conditions =
q(O)
lim q(s)
0,
= 00 .
(2.2)
It follows directly from the definition of the function q�s) that we have the inequalities
q[P(t)J and, for
13
�
t,
P[q(s)J
�
s,
(2.3)
J � s.
(2.4)
> 0, that q[P (t)
-
I3
J � t,
P[q(s)
-
I3
If the function pet) is continuous and increases monotonically, then the function q(s) is the ordinary inverse function of pet) . In the general case, the function q(s) is called the right inverse of P(t) . The function pet) , in turn, is the right inverse of q(s) . Fig . 4 shows the graph of the function q(s) , the right inverse of the function P (t) , whose graph is shown in Fig. 2. The functions l ui
M(u)
=
J P(t) dt, f)
Ivl
N(v)
=
J q(s) ds o
are called mutually complementary N-functions.
CHAPTER I , § 2
12
Suppose q,(u) and P(v) are mutually complementary N-functions. There are situations when we must consider the N-fun ction (/J I (U) = a(/J(bu) (a, b > 0) . The N-function PI (v) which is comq(s)
(
, I
s
Fig. 4.
plementary to q, l (U) is defined by the equality P1 (v)
=
ap
( :b ) .
( 2.5)
In fact , the right derivative Pl (t) of the function (/J l (U) equals abP (bt) , where pet) is the right derivative of the N-function (/J(u) . From this it follows that q l (S) ( l /b) q(s/ab) and that
= f ql (s) ds =+ f q (:b ) dS = a f Ivl
P1 (v)
=
o
Ivl
o
Ivllab
q(s) ds,
o
which implies (2.5) .
2. The Young inequality. We shall use the line of reasoning usually utilized in the derivation of Holder's inequality. In Fig. 5, the areas T and 5 express the values of the N-functions M(u) and N (v) , respectively. It is geometrically clear that the following inequality holds : uv � T + 5 = M(u) + N (v) . In virtue of the fact that the functions M(u) and N (v) are even, the last inequality is valid for all u, v ; it is called Young ' s inequality. Thus, uv � M(u) + N(v) .
(2.6)
CHAPTER I, § 2
13
It is clear, from Fig. 5 again, that inequality (2.6) reduces to an equality when v = P ( l u l ) sgn u if u is given and when u = q( l v l ) sgn v if v is given. Thus,
l uI P( l u l ) = M (u) + N[P ( l u l ) ]
and
I v l q( l v l ) P(t), S v
=
M [q( l v l )] + N (v)
(2 .7 ) (2.8)
.
- - - - - - - ---- ---------- - -- - - - - --- - --- ---
S�(v)=-
u
t, q(s)
Fig. 5_
It follows from (2. 6) that N(v) ;;::: uv - M(u) . In virtue of (2.8) , this inequality goes over into an equality for u = q( l v l ) sgn v. Consequently,
N(v)
=
max [u l v l - M(u)] . u;;.o
(2.9)
Formula (2. 9) could have been taken as the definition of the N-function complementary to M(u) . It follows from Young's inequality that M -l (v)N- l (v) � 2v (v > 0) . On the other hand, it is clear from Fig. 5 that N[M(u) /u] < M(u) . It follows from this that , for M(u) = v, we have v < M- l (v)N -l (v) . Thus, for all v > 0, we have that
v
<
M -l (v)N- l (v) � 2v .
(2. 1 0)
3. Examples. As we have already pointed out , the function M 1 (u) = l uliX/ex (ex > 1 ) is an N-function. We shall compute the
CHAPTER I, § 3
14 P 1 (t) = M�(t) = tOl. - 1 . Therefore, q1 (S) I /a. + liP = I , and
complementary function to it. Clearly , for t> 0, we have that = SIl - l (s � 0) , where
N1(V)
=
Ivl
I q1(s) ds
o
=
v
I l ll p.
=
As a second example, we shall compute the N-function com plementary to the N-function M 2 (U) elul - l u i I . For this function, we have that P 2 (t) = M;(t) = et - I (t � 0) , from which it follows that q 2(S) = In (s + I ) (s � 0) and
N 2 (v)
=
Ivl
I q2 (s) ds
=
-
( I + Iv l ) In ( I + Iv l ) - Iv l .
(2. 1 1 )
o
We note that it is impossible in many cases to find an explicit formula for the complementary N-function. For example, if M(u) = eU' - I , then P(t) 2tet ' and we cannot express q(s) in the explicit form.
=
4. Inequality for complementary functions. THEOREM 2. 1 . Suppose that the inequality M1(u) � M 2 (u) is
satisfied for the N-functions M1 (U) and M 2 (U) when u � Uo. Then the inequality N 2 (v) � N1(v) holds for the complementary N-functions N1 (V) and N 2 (V) when v � Vo P 2 (UO) . PROOF. Suppose P 2 (U) is the right derivative of the N-function M 2 (u) . In virtue of the fact that the function q 2 (V) is monotone, the inequality q 2 (V) � Uo holds for v � Vo P 2(UO) . In virtue of (2.8) , we have q 2 (V) · V M 2 [q2 (V)] + N 2 (v) , and, =
=
=
in virtue of Young's inequality, we have so that
q2(V) ·V � M1[q 2 (V)] + N1(v) ,
M 2 [q2(V)] + N2( V) � M1[Q 2 (V)] + N1 (v) . Since M 2 [Q 2 (V)] � M 1 [Q 2 (V)] for v � Vo, we have N2 (v) � N1(v) .
*
§ 3. The comparison of N-functions
I . Definition. In the sequel, an essential role will be played by the "rapidity of growth" of the values of an N-function as
CHAPTER I , § 3
15
u
� 00 . I n this connection, i t is convenient to introduce the following notation. We shall write
Ml (u)
-<
M2(u) (3. 1 ) if there exist positive constants Uo and k such that Ml (u) � M 2 (ku) (u � uo) . ( 3.2 ) We shall say that the N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (U) are compa rable if one of the relations Ml (u) -< M 2 (u) or M 2 (U) -< Ml (u) holds. It is easily verified that Ml (U) -< M 2 (u) and M 2(u) -< Ma(u) implies that Ml(U) -< M 3(U) . A set of elements in which a relation of type (3. 1 ) , possessing the indicated property, is introduced, is called a partially ordered set . Thus, the N-functions form a set which is partially ordered relative to the symbol -< . The simplest example of N-functions, satisfying relation (3. 1 ) , juja1 , M 2 (U) juja2 (OCl ' OC 2 > I ) for are the functions Ml (u) <
=
=
=
We now consider the N-function M (u) ju j a(jln jujj + I ) (oc > I ) . It is clear that juja -< M(u) -< juja+e for arbitrary e > O.
OCl
OC2·
2. Equivalent N-functions. We shall say that the N-functions Ml (tt) and M 2 (u) are equivalent and write M l (u) '"" M 2 (u) if Ml (u) -< M 2 (u) and M 2 (u) -< Ml (U) .
Clearly, every N-function is equivalent to itself and if two N functions are equivalent to a third N-function, then they are equivalent . In virtue of this, the set of all N-functions is partitioned into classes of mutually equivalent functions. It follows from the definition that the N-functions Ml (u) and M2 (u) are equivalent if, and only if, there exist positive constants kl ' k2 and Uo such that
Ml (klU) � M 2 (U) � Ml (k 2U)
(u
�
uo) .
(3.3 )
From these inequalities, it follows, in particular, that the N function M (u) is equivalent to the N-function M(ku) for arbitrary k> o. It is also clear that the N-functions M (u) and Ml (u) satisfy ing the condition
.
11m are equivalent .
U-HXl
M(u) M leU)
--- =
a> 0
(3. 4)
16
CHAPTER
I, §
3
THEOREM 3. 1 . Suppose M leU) -< M 2 (U) . Then the corresponding complementary N-functions are connected by the relation N2(V) -< NI (V) . PROOF. By hypothesis, k,uo > 0 can be found such that
(3.5)
We set M(u) = M 2 (ku) . The function N (v) , which is com plementary to M(u) , equals N 2 (v/k) in virtue of (2.5) . Inequality (3.5) can be rewritten in the form M l(U) � M(u) (u � uo) . In virtue of Theorem 2. 1 , there exists a Vo > 0 such that N (v) � N I (V) (v � vo) from which it follows that N 2 (V) � N1 (kv) (v � vo/k) . * The next theorem follows directly from Theorem 3.1 . THEOREM 3.2. If the N-functions M I (U) and M 2 (U) are equivalent,
then the N-functions complementary to them, N I (v) and N 2 (v) , are also equivalent. Theorem 3.2 signifies that to a class of mutually equivalent N-functions there corresponds, in going over to the complementary functions, a class of N-functions which are also mutually equivalent . 3. Principal part of an N-function. A convex function Q(u) will be called the principal part (p.p.) of the N-function M(u) if Q (u) = M(u) for large values of the argument . THEOREM 3.3. Suppose the convex function Q (u) satisfies the
condition
lim u-+-oo
Q(u) U
(3.6)
= 00.
Then Q (u) is the principal part of some N-function M(u) . PROOF . It follows from condition (3. 6) that lim Q(u) =
00.
We
shall assume that Q (u) is convex and positive for u � Uo. In virtue of Theorem 1 . 1 , the function Q(u) admits of the representation
Q (u) =
f P(t) dt U
+ Q (uo) ,
Uo
where P (u) is a non-decreasing right-continuous function. This function satisfies the condition lim P(u) = 00 inasmuch as the
boundedness of the function P (u) , i.e. P(u) � b, would imply that
17
CHAPTER I , § 3
Q (u) � b(u - uo) + Q(uo) , which contradicts (3.6) . Without loss of generality, we may assume that P (u) is positive for u � Uo. Since P (u) increases indefinitely, there exists a U l � Uo + 1 such that P (U l ) > P (uo + 1 ) + Q (uo) . Then Q (Ul)
= f P(t) dt +
f P(t) dt + Q (uo) � Ul
Uo+ I
uo+ I
Uo
� P(uo + 1 ) + Q (uo) + P (U l ) (U l - Uo
-
1 ) � P(U l ) (Ul - uo) ,
from which it follows that IX = U lP (U l ) /Q(Ul) > 1 . We define the function M(u) by the equality
M(u)
=
\
Q(U l ) l u l a for l ui � U l , u� Q (u) for l ui � U l .
The function M(u) i s a n N-function inasmuch as its right derivative ,
ua- l for for is a function which is pos ltlve for u > 0, right-continuous for U � 0 , non-decreasing, and such that it satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 3) . * 4. A n equivalence criterion. A set F on the real line will be called a set of complete measure if the set of points not belonging to F has measure zero. We consider two N-functions, l ui
M l (U)
=
f Pl (t) dt,
M 2 (u) =
o
F
f P2(t) dt. l ui
(3.7)
o
LEMMA 3. 1 . Suppose there exist constants k, Uo > ° and a set of complete measure such that Pl (U) � P2(ku) (u � Uo, U E F) .
Then the N-functions
f Pl (t) dt and M2 (U) f P2(t) dt l ui
M l (U)
=
o
satisfy the relation M l (u) -< M 2 (U) . Convex functions
lui
=
o
CHAPTER I , § 3
18
PROOF. Integrating the inequality, given in the hypothesis of the lemma, between the limits from Uo to u, we obtain that
Without loss of generality, we may assume that k > 1 . In virtue of the fact that M l (U) increases indefinitely, a U l :> Uo can be found such that , for U :> U l , we have
Therefore, for U :> U l , M l (U) :s;; M 2 (ku) . * It follows from Lemma 3. 1 that M l (U) -< M 2 (U) if the inequality Pl[cxQ2(fJU)] < U holds for large u. LEMMA 3.2. Let lim u--;.oo ueF
P l (U) P 2 (U)
=
b > 0,
(3 8) .
where F is a set ot complete measure. Then Ml (U) "" M 2 (u) . PROOF. In virtue of (3.8) , there exists a Uo > 0 such that for U :> Uo, U E F, we have Pl (U) :s;; 2bP 2 (U) . Integrating the last inequality between the limits from Uo to u, we obtain from which it follows, in virtue of the fact that lim M 2 (U)
= 00,
that M l (U) :s;; (2b + I )M 2 (u) for large values of u. It follows from this inequality, in virtue of ( 1 .7) , that for large values of u, M l (U) :s;; M 2 [ (2b + l ) u] , i.e. that Ml (U) -< M 2 (u) . The relation M 2 (u) -< M l (u) is proved analogously. * Only the values of the functions Pl(U) and P 2 (U) for large values of the argument play a role in the conditions of Lemma 3.2. Here, as also in a number of other cases, when considering the right derivatives P (u) of the N-function M(u) , it is important to have a formula for the function P (u) only for large values of u. In this connection, we shall make use of the following definition: a function g; (u) is called the principal part (p.p.) of the function P(u) if g;(u) an d P (u) coincide for large values of the argument .
19
CHAPTER I, § 3
THEOREM 3.4. Suppose the N-functions (3.7) and the N-functions
N I (V) =
J ql (s) ds, Iv l
o
J q2 (s) ds, Iv l
N2 (V) =
0
complementary to them, are given. A ssume there exists a set F I complete measure such that
of
(3 .9)
PROOF. We introduce the notation q 2(V) = u . I n virtue of (2 . 3) ,
Then M I (V)
I"'-.J
M 2(V) .
P2[q2(V)] = P 2(U)
�
v
(3. 1 0)
and, in virtue of (2.4) ,
(3 . 1 1 )
for arbitrary s> o. We denote by F the subset of FI consisting of those points at which the functions P I (U) and P 2 (U) are continuous. Since every monotonic function has at most a denumerable number of points of discontinuity, we have that F is also a set of complete measure. It follows from (3. 1 0) that
P I (U) :s::: .P!J'!l P I [q 2(V)] P 2 (U) "'" v v
'
from which it follows, in virtue of (3.9) , that
P I (U) --- b 1·1m """ . P2(U) u-oo
(3. 1 2)
ueF,
It follows from (3. 1 1 ) that for all U E F ,
�(u) P2 (U)
=
lim e-> O
PI(U) P2(U - s)
�
P I [q 2(V )] j l (U) = v v
from which it follows, in virtue of (3. 9) , that · 11m
u-oo
ueF
PI (U) --7 P2(U)
b
.
(3. 1 3)
CHAPTER I, § 3
20 It follows from inequalities (3. 1 2) and (3. 1 3) that
l (U) P2(U)
lim ! U-'OO UEF
=
b.
The last inequality and Lemma 3.2 imply that M l (U) I"'-.J M2(U) . *
5. The existence at various classes. In connection with the
introduction of classes of equivalent N-functions, there arises the question of "how many" distinct classes of this sort are there? It is clear, for example, that the N-functions l u i IX belong to distinct classes for distinct 01: > 1 . The N-function M(u) ( 1 + l u I ) In ( 1 + + l u I ) - l ui satisfies the relation M(u) -< l ui IX (01: > I ) , but it is not equivalent to any of the N-functions l u l IX• Nor is the N-function M1 (u) el u l - l u i - I , which satisfies the relation l u l IX -< M1(u), equivalent to any of the N-functions l u l IX• Suppose, now, that =
=
J Pn(t) dt (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) l ui
Mn(u)
=
o
(3. 1 4)
is an arbitrary sequence of N-functions. We construct N-functions M (u) and (/> (u) such that
M n (u) -< M(u)
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . )
(3. 1 5)
and
(3. 1 6 ) (/>(u) -< M n (u) (n 1 , 2, . . . ) . Let P (t) = Pl (t) + P 2 (t) + . . . + Pn(t) for n - 1 :'( t < n. The function P (t) is right-continuous, monotonically increasing, and it satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 3) . In virtue of Lemma 3. 1 , the N-function =
J P(t) dt l ui
M(u) =
o
will satisfy relation (3. 1 5) . By what we have already proved, an N-function lJI(v) can be constructed satisfying the relations N n (v) -< lJI(v) , where the N n (v) are the complementary functions to the N-functions (3. 1 4) . I n virtue of Theorem 3. 1 . the complementary N-function (/>(u) to lJI(v) will satisfy conditions (3. 1 6) .
CHAPTER I , §
3
21
-
eM ( u) Suppose M(u) is an N-function. The function M1 (u) 1 is also an N-function. Clearly, M (u) -< M l (U) . It is clear that in the case when M(u) does not increase faster than a power function, M l (U) is not equivalent to M (u) . These functions are also not mutually equivalent for many other N-functions. However, there also exist N-functions M (u) such that eM ( u) - 1 ,...., M(u) (we leave it to the reader to construct an example!) . For an arbitrary N-function M (u), it is not difficult to construct N-functions Q(u) and R (u), which are not equivalent to M (u), such that Q (u) -< M(u) -< R(u) . For this purpose, it is sufficient to define the right derivative r(u) of the function R (u) by the equality r(u) np (nu) for n - 1 � u < n (n 1 , 2, . . . ) . The function Q(u) can be defined as the complementary function to the N-function lJf(v) which satisfies the conditions: N(v) -< lJf( v ) and lJf(v) is not equivalent to N (v) where N (v) is the complementary function to M(u) . It is easily seen that the functions Q (u) and R(u) thus con , structed possess the following property: to each n = 1 , 2, there exists a u: such that , for u > u:, we have =
=
=
,
Q(u)
<
M
(:)
...
<
M(nu)
<
R(u).
(3. 1 7)
In concluding this section, we shall show that to each N-function :l1(u) there corresponds an N-function 4>(u) such that neither the relation M(u) -< 4>(u) nor the relation 4>(u) -< M (u) holds. To this end, we first construct the N-functions Q(u) and R (u) which satisfy relations (3. 1 7) . Without loss of generality, we may assume that Q(u) < R(u) (u � uo), where Uo is a positive number. We shall now describe how the graph of the function 4>(u) is constructed (see Fig. 6) . We first set 4>(u) Q(u) for 0 � u � Uo. Next , we draw a straight line through the points with the coordinates {uo, Q (uo)} and {uo + 1 , R(uo + 1 )} . In virtue of property ( 1 . 1 6) , this straight line intersects the graph of the function Q (u) is still one more point whose abscissa will be denoted by U l . Through the points {Ul, Q (U l )} and {U l + 1 , R (UI + 1 )} we draw a new straight line until it intersects the graph of the function Q (u) ; the abscissa of the new point will be denoted by U 2 . Continuing this process, we obtain a polygonal arc connecting the points with the coordinates =
22
CHAPTER I , § 3
{uo, Q (uo)}, {U l' Q (U l )}, {U2, Q (U2)}, and so forth. This polygonal arc will then be the graph of the N-function tJ>(u) for u ;;;:: Uo . By construction, tJ>(u) possesses the following properties : and
tJ>(u n ) = Q(un)
( n = 1 , 2,
tJ> (un + 1 ) = R(un + 1 )
•
•
.
)
(3. 1 8)
(n = 1 , 2, . ) . .
.
(3. 1 9)
4>(u)
Fig. 6.
We now assume that tJ>(u) -< M(u) . Then k and u* > 0 can be found such that
tJ>(u) � M(ku) In virtue of (3. 1 7) ,
a
(u;;;:: u*) .
U n > u* can be found such that
(3.20)
M[k(u n + I ) J < R(un + 1 ) . Then, in virtue of (3. 1 9) ,
M[k (un + I ) J < tJ> (un + 1 ) , which contradicts (3.20) . It is proved analogously that the relation M (u) -< tJ>(u) does not hold. We leave it to the reader to prove that for an arbitrary sequence of N-functions M n (u) ( n 1 , 2, . . . ) there exist N-functions =
tJ>(u) and P(u) such that tJ>(u) -< M n (u) -< P(u) , where tJ>(u) and P(u) are equivalent to none of the functions M n(u) .
23
CHAPTER I , § 4 § 4. The .:1]-condition
I . Definition . We say that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition for large values of u if there exist constants k > 0, Uo � 0 such that
M(2u) ::( kM(u)
(u � uo) .
(4. 1 )
It is easily seen that we always have k > 2 inasmuch as, in virtue of ( l . lS) , M(2u) > 2M(u) for u =1= O. The LJ 2-condition is equivalent to the satisfaction of the inequality
M(lu) ::( k(l)M(u)
(4.2)
for large values of u, where 1 can be any number larger than unity . In fact, let 2 n � l. Then it follows from (4. 1 ) , with u � u o , that
M(lu) ::( M(2 nu) ::( k nM(u) = k(l)M(u) . Conversely, if 2 ::( I n , then it follows from (4.2) that M(2u) ::( M(l n u) ::( k n (l)M(u) .
The N-functions M(u) = a l u i <x (oc > I ) can serve as a simple example of functions satisfying the LJ 2-condition for all values of u inasmuch as M(2u) = a2<x l u l <x = 2<xM(u) . Clearly, the LJ 2-condition is satisfied for large values of u if
-.
hm ..-00
-
M(u)
<
(x) •
(4.3)
It is also easily seen that the fulfillment of the LJ 2 -condition for all u, i.e. the satisfaction of inequality (4. 1 ) for all u � 0, is equi valent to condition (4.3) and the condition lim
..- 0
�
M( U) M u)
<
(x) .
(4.4)
If M(u) satisfies the LJ 2-condition, then any N-function which is equivalent to M(u) also satisfies this condition. In fact , suppose M l (U) M(u) . This means that numbers oc < (3 and U l � 0 can be found such that M(oczt) ::( M l (U) ::( M({3u) (u � Ul) . Conse quently, for u � max {uo, Ul}, we have that '"'-J
M 1(2u) ::( M(2{3u) ::( k(2{3/oc)M(ocu) ::( k(2{3 /oc)M1 (u) .
CHAPTER I, § 4
24
We note that in every class of equivalent N-functions which satisfy the Ll 2 -condition, there are N-functions which satisfy inequality (4. 1 ) for all u. In fact, suppose M(u) satisfies inequality (4. 1 ) for u � Uo. As in the proof of Theorem 3.3, we define the N-function M l (U) by the equality
M(uo) l u l lX for l u i � UO, uti Ml (U) M(u) for l u i � uo, uoP(uo) JM(uo) > 1 . Then, for all u, we have =
where
ex =
(
(4.5)
M l (2u) � max {21X, k}M l(U) . 2. Tests for the Ll 2 -condition.
THEOREM 4. 1 . A necessary and sUlficient condition that the N
function M (u) satisfy the Ll 2 -condition is that there exist constants and Uo > 0 such that, for u � Uo, uP(u) < oc, M(u)
ex
(4.6)
where P (u) is the right derivative of the N-function M(u) . PROOF. Inasmuch as uP(u) is always > M(u) , oc > 1 . Suppose u � Uo. Then from (4.6) we obtain that 2u
I
u
P(t) --dt
2u
I
u
IX
dt - = oc ln 2 t
.
or, equivalently, that M(2u) < 2 M (u) . The sufficiency of the condition (4.6) is thus proved. Now, let M(2u) � kM(u) for u � Uo Then 2u
kM(u)
�
M(2u)
=
2u
I P(t) dt I P(t) dt
o
>
>
uP(u) ,
u
i.e. inequality (4.6) is satisfied for u � Uo. * It is clear from the proof that M (u) satisfies the Ll 2-condition for all u > 0 if inequality (4.6) is satisfied for all u > o. Theorem 4. 1 enables us to prove quite simply that N-functions M (u) which satisfy the Ll 2-condition do not increase more rapidly
25
CHAPTER I , § 4
than exponential functions. In fact , if the A 2-condition is satisfied, then it follows from (4.6) that
f
P(t) -dt
U
Uo
f -dtt ' U
Uo
i . e . that
M(u)
<
M(u o) Uo
uo<
(4.7)
for u � �t o . It is easily verified that an N-function M (u) satisfies the A 2condition if its right derivative P(u) satisfies the inequality
P(2u) .::;; IP(u)
(u
� �to ) ,
(4.8)
where 1 > 1 , U o � O. Inequality (4.8) is satisfied, in particular, if the function P(u) is convex downward for large values of the argument , i.e.
for large U l and U2.
3. The A 2 -condition for the complement to an N-function. We shall frequently be interested in the following question : Given an N-function N (v) , how can one determine directly whether or not the N-function M(u) complementary to it satisfies the A 2condition? THEOREM 4.2. A necessary and sufficient condition �hat the com plementary function M(u) to the N-function N(v) satisfy the A 2condition is that there exist constants 1 > 1 and V o � 0 such that 1 N (v) '::;;- N (l v) 21
(v � vo).
(4.9)
PROOF. Assume that condition (4.9) is satisfied. We set Nl (V ) { l j(2l)}N(lv) . In virtue of equality (2.5) , the complementary N-function M l (U) to N l (V) is defined by the equality M l (U) { l j(2l ) }M (2u ) . Inequality (4.9) can be written in the form N(v) '::;; N1 (v) . It follows from this, in virtue of Theorem 2. 1 , that =
=
=
26
CHAPTER I , § 4
M 1 (u) � M (u) or, equivalently, that M(2u) � 2lM(u) for large
values of the argument . I t is proved analogously that (4. 1 ) implies (4.9) . * If (4.9) is satisfied for all v > 0, then M(u) also satisfies the L1 2 -condition for all u. As was noted in the preceding subsection, an N-function satisfies the L1 2 -condition if its derivative is convex downward for large values of the argument . Manifestly, a function is convex downward if the function inverse to it is convex. Thus, the N-function M(u) satisfies the L12-condition if the N-function N(v) complementary to it has a convex derivative. To prove the next theorem, we shall need the following auxiliary assertion. LEMMA 4. 1 . Suppose the functions P(u) and q(v) are continuous. Then, a necessary and sufficient condition that inequalities (4. 6) be
satisfied is that the inequality
vq(v) N(v)
>
ex
ex
(4. 1 0)
- I
hold for large values of v . PROOF. We shall show, for example, that (4. 6) implies (4. 1 0) . I n virtue of (2.7) , we have that M(u) = uP(u) - N[P(u)] . There fore, it follows from (4. 6) that
uP(u) uP (u) - N[P (u)]
----:------ <
ex
(u;;?: uo) ,
from which it follows that
u,P(u) N[P(u)]
>
ex
ex
- I
(u;;?: uo).
(4. 1 1 )
If we set u q(v) in this inequality (in virtue of the continuity of the functions P (u) and q(v) we have P (u) = v) , then we obtain (4. 1 0) . It is proved analogously that (4.6) follows from (4. 1 0) . * N ow, the lemma just proved and Theorem 4. 1 imply Theorem 4.3. THEOREM 4.3. Suppose the N-function N(v) has, for large values of v, a monotonically increasing continuous derivative. Then the =
N-function M(u) complementary to it satisfies the L1 2 -condition if,
27
CHAPTER I , § 4
and only it, the inequality
vq(v) > ex 1 N(v)
{4. 1 2)
holds tor large values ot v, where ex 1 > I .
To prove this theorem, it suffices to note that the continuity of the function P (u) follows from the monotonicity of the function
q(v) .
As in the case of Theorem 4. 1 , the N-function M(u) satisfies the ,1 2 -condition for all u if inequality (4. 1 2) holds for all u > o. 4. Examples. As we have already remarked, the N-functions = a l u l 1¥ (ex > 1 ) satisfy the ,1 2 -condition for all values of u. As the next example, we consider the N-function
M(u)
M(u) = l u l 1¥( l ln l u l l + 1 ) .
(4. 1 3)
For this function, we have
uP(u) M(u) when u
>
ex + ex ln u + 1 ln u + 1
1 , from which it follows that
.
hm U-+OO
uP(u) M(u)
--
=
ex .
Therefore, in virtue of Theorem 4. 1 , the N-function (4. 1 3) satisfies the ,1 2 -condition for large values of u. A direct calculation shows that lim U-+OO
M(2u) M(u)
=
lim tH O
This means that conditions (4.3) signifies that the N-function (4. 1 3) all u. We shall leave it to the reader complementary to the N-function condition. The N-function
N(v)
=
M(2ul M (u)
=
21¥.
and (4.4) are satisfied. This satisfies the ,1 2 -condition for to show that the N-function (4. 1 3) also satisfies the ,1 2-
ell"' - I v l - 1
(4. 1 4)
does not satisfy the ,1 2-condition inasmuch as it increases more
28
CHAPTER I, § 4
rapidly than any exponential function. The derivative of the function N (v) is eV - 1 (v � 0) - it is convex. It follows from the remark made in the preceding subsection that the function M(u) complementary to N (v) satisfies the Ll 2-condition. It would not be difficult to verify that the function N (v ) satisfies condition (4.9) . The fact that the function M (u) complementary to the N function (4. 1 4) satisfies the Ll 2-condition can be verified directly since its expression in explicit form is known (see (2. 1 0) ) : M(u) = ( 1 + l u i ) In ( 1 + l u i ) - l u i . In this connection, it is easily seen that the Ll 2-condition is satisfied for all u. We now consider the N-function N (v) = e v' - 1 ,
(4 . 1 5 )
for which one cannot find the complementary function M(u) in the explicit form. However, one can also show for it that M(u) satisfies the Ll 2-condition for all values of the argument . To do this, we use Theorem 4.2. We note first of all that the function q;(t) = e 4 t - 4et + 3 increases monotonically for t > 0 since q;'(t) = 4et(e 3 t - 1 ) > o. • Consequently, for v > 0, we have that (e 4 V - 1 ) / 4 > e v' - 1 . The last inequality is condition ( 4.9) for the function (4. 1 5 ) for
1 = 2.
When considering the preceding "examples, the conj ecture could have been made that at least one of the two mutually comple mentary N-functions satisfies the Ll 2-condition. Moreover, the conj ecture could have been made that every N-function which increases less rapidly than a power function satisfies the Ll 2condition. We shall introduce an example which shows that both these conj ectures are incorrect . We shall construct an N-function M (u) by giving its derivative pet) by the equality
P(t) =
(t
if t E [0, 1 ) ,
k ! if t E [(k - l ) ! , k ! )
(k = 2, 3, . . . ) .
In order to prove that the N-function M(u )
lui
=
f P(t) dt does
o
not satisfy the Ll 2-condition it suffices to show that there exists
29
CHAPTER I , § 5
Let
U1l
U
n ---+ 00 such that M(2u n ) > nM(u n) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . = n ! (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . Then
a sequence of numbers
M(2u n ) >
(4. 1 6)
f P (t) dt > (n + I ) ! · n ! , 2n !
n!
and
n!
nM(u n) = n
f P(t) dt < n · n ! · n ! ,
o
from which (4 . 1 6 ) follows. It is clear that the function q(s) is defined by the equality
q(s) =
{s
if s E [0, 1 ) ,
(k - l ) ! if s E [(k - l ) !, k !)
(k = 2, 3, . . . ) .
We shall show that the N-function N ( v) =
Iv l
f q(s) ds does not
o
satisfy the L1 2 -condition either. To this end, we consider the sequence of numbers V n = n ! (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . Then
N(2v n ) >
f q(s) ds > n ! · n !, 2n !
n!
and n!
nN(v n) = n
f q(s) ds < n · n ! · (n - I ) ! = n ! · n ! ,
o
i.e. N(2v n ) > nN(v n ) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . In this connection, the function N (v) increases no more rapidly than v 2 j 2 since q(s) < s (s � 0) . § 5. The .1 ' -condition
1 . Definition . We say that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ '-condition if there exist positive constants c and Uo such that M(uv)
<
cM(u) M(v)
(u, v
�
uo) .
(5 . 1 )
30
CHAPTER I , § 5
LEMMA 5. 1 . If the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ '-condition, then it also satisfies the LJ 2-condition. PROOF. Let k = cM(uo + 2) . Then for u � Uo + 2 we have M(2u) � M[(uo + 2)u] � cM(uo + 2)M(u) = kM(u) . * Suppose the N-function M (u) satisfies the LJ '-condition and that the N-function M l (U) is equivalent to M(u) . We shall show that then M l (U) also satisfies the LJ '-condition, i.e. that satisfaction of the LJ ' -condition is a property of a class of mutually equivalent N-functions. Since M(u) ""' M1 (u) , there exist positive constants k l ' k 2 and U l such that (5.2) M(k lU) � M1 (u) � M(k 2U) (u � Ul) . I t is convenient to assume that k l < I , UO, U l , k 2 > I . In virtue of Lemma 5. 1 , k 3 > 0 and U 2 � 0 can be found such that
(
)
Vk 2 M -. - u � k 3M(U) �
(5.3)
Consequently, for u, v � max {uo, U l , u 2 jk 1}, we have
M1(uv) � M(k 2UV) < cM (Vk 2U)M(Vk 2V) � � ck�M(k l U)M(klV) � ck�M l(U)Ml(V) . We do not know whether or not there exists in each class of equivalent N-functions, satisfying the LJ '-condition, a function which satisfies this condition for all u, v. It is necessary to note that the class of N-functions which satisfy the LJ '-condition is already essentially the class of N-functions satisfying the LJ 2-condition. We consider, for example, the function M(u) u 2 j ln (e + l u I ) . It is an N-function inasmuch as its deriva tive p (u) = {2u (u + e) In (u + e) - u 2}j{(u + e) In 2 (u + e)} (u � 0) satisfies conditions ( 1 . 1 3) and increases monotonically. Only the last assertion is needed in the proof ; this follows from the fact that =
P ' (u)
=
(u
+
2 2 e) In 3 (u
+
e)
[ (U + e) 2 In2 (u + e)
- �� + � � � + � + � + >
2 2 (u + e) In 3 (u
+
e)
11 2 In (u 2
+
_
e)
]
>
[(u + e) I n ( t t + e) - u1 2 ,
"
�0
(u
>
0) .
31
CHAPTER I, § 5 The N-function M (u) satisfies the L1 2 -condition since
M (2u) M (u)
lim u->oo
=
4.
This function does not satisfy the L1 ' -condition since
M (u 2 ) = 00. M 2 (U)
.
hm u-+oo
I
2. Sufficiency criteria for the satisfaction of the L1 ' -condition. THEOREM 5. 1 . Suppose there exists a number Uo > such that
for every fixed u � Uo the function h(t) increase for t � Uo . Then the N-function
P(ut) jP(t) does not
=
f P(t) dt l ui
M(u)
=
o
satisfies the L1 ' -condition. PROOF. Let u, v � Uo. Then , by the condition of the theorem ,
we have that
P(ut) P (t)
,::;
---
P(uuo) P( Zfo)
(t
-=--:"'--'--,- --
�
uo) .
Vsing this inequality in the expressions
f P(t) dt
",1(ltv)
=
f P(ut) dt v
uv
= It
u
=
II
II
f P(ut) dt Uo
f P (ut) dt, u
+
u
II
Uo
we obtain that
P (uuo) M(uv) ,::; uuoP(uuo) + u P(uo) =
and, since
uuoP(uuo)
<
I f I
-110 -
UUO ·
UUo
P (t) dt
f P(t) dt v
o
uuoP(uuo) 1
� __
uo - I
=
M(v) ] [I + 1toP(uo)
uuo2
f
o
P(t) dt
=
M (UU 20 ) , uo - I
C HAPTER I , § 5
32 that �
M(uv)
M(uu5) Uo - 1
[1 +
M(v) uoP(uo)
J.
(5.4)
It follows from the last inequality that the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll 2 -condition. In fact , it follows from (5.4) , for u uo, that =
for v � vo, where Vo is a number such that M(vo) > uoP(uo) . In virtue of the Ll 2 -condition, a k > 0 can be found such that M(uu5) ,s;; kM(u) for u � Vo. Hence, it follows from (5.4) that
M(uv)
,s;;
2k M(u)M(v) (uo - l )uoP(uo)
(u, v
�
vol .
*
We shall now assume that the function Plt) is differentiable for large values of t. LEMMA 5.2. The function h(t) P(zd) jP (t) does not increase for fixed u � Uo > 1 for t � Uo if the function g(t) tp'(t) jP(t) does
=
=
not increase for t � uo.
PROOF. The function h (t) does not increase for t � Uo if, and only if, its derivative _
h' ( t ) -
uP' (ut)P (t) - P'(t)P(ut) P 2 (t)
is not positive for t � uo, i.e. if, and only if,
' (t) (ut)- � _ up=--P_ ----' ' -'--_ _ P(ut) "'" P(t)
•
The last inequality follows directly from the condition of the lemma. * This lemma and Theorem 5. 1 imply the next theorem . THEOREM 5 . 2. Suppose that for large values of t the function P(t)
is differentiable and that the function
tp' (t) g(t) = P(t)
( 5.5 )
33
CHAPTER I, § 5
does not increase . Then the N-function
f P (t) dt l ui
M (u)
=
o
satisfies the iJ ' -condition. 3. The iJ ' -condition for the complementary function . THEOREM 5.3. Suppose the derivative P(u) of the N-function M(u) is differentiable for u � Uo > 1 and that the function g(t) = tp' (t) /P(t) does not decrease for t � Uo. Then the N-function
f q(s) ds, Iv l
N(v)
=
o
which is complementary to the N-function M (u) , satisfies the iJ ' condition . PROOF. Since the function g(t) does not decrease, for sufficiently large t it assumes positive values. This means that for large values of the argument , we have P'(t) > 0, from which the differentiability of the function q(s) , the inverse of the function P(t) , follows. In view of Lemma 5.2, to prove the theorem, it suffices to show that an so > 1 can be found such that the function gl (S) = sq' (s)/q(s) does not increase for s � so. We set s = P(t) . Then, for t > to = max {uo, q( I )}, s > So = = P (to) > 1 , we have q' ( s) = I /P'(t) , gl (S)
=
sq'(s)
�
=
P (t) tp' (t)
= g(t)1 ,
and, since the function g(t) does not decrease, the function gl (S) does not increase. * In the next subsection, we shall isolate a special class of N functions whose complementary functions satisfy the iJ ' -condition.
4. Examples . If M l(U) = l u l l¥/ex (ex > 1 ) , then, obviously, M l(UV) = exM l (U)M l (V) for all u, v, i . e.. M l (U) satisfies the iJ '-
condition. A second example of an N-function which satisfies the iJ ' condition for all tt, v is given by the N-function
M 2 (u) Convex functions
= l u l l¥ ( l ln l u l l + 1 )
(ex
>
1). 3
34
CHAPTER I , § 5
= l uv l l¥ ( l ln l uv l l + I ) � � l u l l¥ I v l l¥ ( l ln l u l l + l In I v l l + I ) � � l u l l¥ ( l ln l u l l + 1 ) ' I v l l¥ ( l ln I v l l + I ) = M 2 (u)M 2 (V) .
In fact ,
M 2 (UV)
We now consider the N-function
Ma (u )
=
= (I + l u I ) In ( 1 + l u I ) - l u i .
The function Q(u) u I n u , which is convex for large values of u, satisfies condition (3.6) . In virtue of Theorem 3.3, the function Q(u) is the principal part of some N-function tP(u) : p.p. tP(u) Q (u) . The function tP(u) satisfies the J '-condition in virtue of Theorem 5.5 since for this function we have that
=
= In Int +t 1 = 1 + In1 t .
g(t)
-
The N-functions tP(u) and Ma(u) satisfy condition (3.4) and, consequently, they are equivalent . This means that the N-function Ma(u) also satisfies the J '-condition. It turns out that the N-function Ma(u) does not satisfy the J '-condition for all u, v. In fact , if there existed a constant e such that M (uv) � eM(u) M (v) for all u , v , then the values of the function t(u , v )
= M(u)M(v) = M(uv)
[( I + l u I ) In ( I + l u I ) - l u I J [ ( 1 + I v l ) In ( I + I v l ) - I v l ] ( 1 + l uv l ) In ( 1 + l uv l ) - l uv l
= n, =
would be bounded below by the positive number 1 Ie. But , if we set u 1 I Vn, then it is easily verified that v lim n---+ oo
t(n, �) = vn
o.
As the last example, we shall show that the J '-condition is satisfied by the N-functi6n N(v) which is complementary to the N-function ( I + l u l ) "/1n ( 1 + lul l I , M(u) =
-
which can be verified by making use of Theorem 5.3. For M(u) ,
35
CHAPTER I , § 6 the function
tp'(t) P(t)
[! vln ( 1 + t) - 1 +
1
] 1
+ T+t increases for large values of t since its derivative t [ 2 vln 3( 1 t) - 2 1n2(11 + t) ] + g ' (t) (1 + t) 2 + 1 + (1 + t) 2 [§. vln ( 1 + t) 1 + 2 1n ( I1 t) ] g(t)
=
=
2 1n (1
t)
=
-
is positive .
1.
+
2
§ 6. N-functions which increase more rapidly than power functions
The LJ a-condition . We shall say that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ a-condition if it is equivalent to the N-function the LJ a1 1� I M(u) . Since l u I M(u) is always > M(u) for u > condition signifies that for values of u greater than some uo,
1,
we have
l u I M(u) < M(ku) ,
1
(6. )
where k is some constant . If the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ a-condition, then, as can easily be seen, all N-functions which are equivalent to M(u) also satisfy this condition. The N-functions M(u) with principal parts eU, eU ' , u1nu, and so on, can serve as examples of N-functions which satisfy the LJ a condition inasmuch as condition (6. 1 ) is manifestly satisfied for them. The N-functions M (u) increase more rapidly than any power function in all the examples introduced above . This is not accidental, inasmuch as every N-function M(u) which satisfies the LJ a-condition increases more rapidly than any power, u n . In fact, in \· irtue of (6. 1 ), for u � uok n , we have that
( )
( )
> ... > M � M(u) > � M � > � ka k2 k k U un > Mn(n+ l l]/2 M k1t >
( )
M(uo)
Mn(n+ l l]/2
un .
CHAPTER I, § 6
36
However, not all N-functions which increase more rapidly than any power function satisfy the LI s-condition. For example, this condition is not satisfied by the N-function M(u) for which p.p. M(u) = U Vln u since for this N-function, we have that
M (k u) l u I M(u)
lim
for arbitrary k > o.
'U->oo
=
0
2. A pproximations for the complementary function . THEOREM 6. 1 . Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll s
condition. Then the N-function N(v) complementary to it satisfies the inequalities (6.2)
for large values of v, where M- l (V) is the function inverse to the function M(u) and k l . k2 (k1 � k2) are constants. PROOF. We shall first show that the N-function
M l (U)
lui
I M(t) dt
=
o
is equivalent to the N-function M(u) . In fact , by the condition of the theorem, for large u we have that u
M l (U)
=
I M(t) dt < uM(u) � M(ku) ,
o
where k is a constant. On the other hand, for u > 1 , we have
M 1 ( 2u)
=
2u
2u
I M(t) dt I M(t) dt > uM(u) > M(u) . >
o
u
Thus, Ml (U) M(u) . Therefore, the function N l (V) complementary to M l ( U) is also equivalent to N(v) . The function N l (V) is found directly : r-.J
r M-l (t) dt. Ivl
N1(v)
=
o
oJ
(6.3)
CHAPTER I , § 6
37
It follows from the last inequality that
N1 (v) < Iv I M- l ( l v l )
and
I M-l (t) dt > I M-l (t) dt > i�1 M- l ( I� I ) . I t' l
Iv l
Nl (V)
=
o
Ivl/2
Now (6.2) follows from the last inequalities and the fact that
N1(v)
�
N ( v) . *
We note that the left inequality in (6.2) is true for sufficiently large v for arbitrary function M(u) ( without the assumption about the L1 3-condition) with arbitrary constant k l < 1 . In fact , it follows from Young's inequality that for large v, we have
k l VM- l (k l V) � klN(v) + k�v < N(v) . 3. The construction of N-functions which are equivalent to the complementary functions. As we have already noted, the con struction of the complementary N-functions in the explicit form is possible only in rare cases. However, in applications, knowledge of exact formulas is not obligatory for the complementary function in many cases - it is sufficient to know the formula for some N function which is equivalent to the one sought . It turns out that for certain classes of N-functions formulas for N-functions equivalent to the complementary functions can be shown. A class of this sort is isolated with the aid of the L1 3-condition. The next theorem follows directly from Theorem 6. 1 . THEOREM 6.2. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the ,1 3-
=
condition and let the function Q (v) I v I M- l ( l v l ) be the principal part of an N-function 1fI(v) . Then 1fI(v) N(v) . In order that the function Q(v) be the principal part of an N function, it is sufficient that the function Q'(v) increases mono t onically to infinity as v ---? 00 Since Q' (v) M- l (v) + vIP[M- l (v)] for v > 0, we have that lim Q' (v) 00 In order that Q' (v) increase .
"...... 00
=
�
=
.
monotonically, it is sufficient that Q"(v) be a non-negative function for large values of v. The last condition is satisfied if
2P 2 (U) - M(u)P' (u) for large values of u.
� °
(6.4)
38
CHAPTER I , § 6
=
=
This inequality is satisfied, for example, for the N-functions
Ml (U) , M 2 (U) , Ma(u) , for which p.p. Ml (U) eU, p.p. M 2 (U) eU', and p.p. Ma(u) u1nu• Therefore, the N-functions complementary to them are equivalent , respectively, to the N-functions P'l(V) , P'2 (V) , P'a(v) for which
=
p.p. P'l (V)
= v In v, p.p. P'2 (V) = v Vln v,
p.p. P'a(v)
=
(6.5)
v 1 H 1 ! Y In vl.
We showed, above, that N-functions M(u) which satisfy the ,1 a-condition increase more rapidly than any power, l u l Gt (0.: > 1 ) . This means that M(u) > uGt/o.: (u � uo) , where Uo is a non-negative number. Then the inequality N (v) < vf3/fJ ( 1 /0.: + l /fJ 1 ) follows directly from Theorem 2. 1 . Thus, the N-function complementary to an N-function which satisfies the ,1 a-condition increases more slowly than any power, vf3 (fJ > 1 ) . For example, the functions (6.5) will be of this sort . In considering arbitrary N-functions which increase more slowly than an arbitrary power function, the conj ecture can be made that it is complementary to an N-function which satisfies the ,1 a-condition. This conj ecture can be verified in a number of cases. We shall consider, for example, the N-function N(v) for which the p.p. N (v) v (ln V) 2 . We represent it in the form
=
=
=
p.p. N (v)
=
vQ-l (v) .
Then Q (u) e Y u . Obviously, Q (u) is the principal part of an N function M l(U) which satisfies the ,1 a-condition. In virtue of Theorem 6.2, N (v) is equivalent to N1 (v) . The reasoning j ust carried out contains a general way of con structing N-functions which are equivalent to extensive classes of given N-functions, which increase more slowly than any power function. Suppose that such an N-function N (v) is given. We represent it in the form N (v) I v l Q - l ( l v l ) . If the function Q (u) turns out to be the principal part of the N-function M1 (u) which satisfies the ,1 a-condition, then, in virtue of Theorem 6.2, Ml (U) "" M(u) , where M(u) is the complementary N-function to N (v) . Another way of constructing an N-function equivalent to the complementary function to the N-function N(v) , which increases
=
39
CHAPTER I , § 6
more slowly than any power function vP ({3 > 1 ) is also possible. Let q(v ) = N' (v) , with the function q- l (u) = p.p. M 1 (u) , where Ml(U) is an N-function satisfying the L1 a-condition. Then, as was shown in the proof of Theorem 6. 1 , we have that lui
M l (U) ,....., M 2 (U)
= f M l (t) dt. o
This means that the N-functions N 1 (v) and N2 (V) which are com plementary respectively to M l (U) and M 2 (U) , where Ivl
N 2 (V)
=
f Ml l (s) ds,
o
are equivalent . Since for large values of v, we have that Ml l (v) = = q(v) , then N2 (v) ,....., N (v) from which it follows that M 2 (U) ,....., M(u) . Consequently, the N-function M l ( U ) will be the function, equivalent to M(u) , sought .
4. The composition of complementary functions. Let M(u) and Q(u) be N-functions. The N-functions M(u) and M[Q(u)] are never equivalent since, for arbitrary k > 0, we have that lim 'U--> oo
M[Q(u)] M (ku )
=
=.
This follows from the fact that , for sufficiently large u, we have Q(u) > nku, M (nku) > nM(ku) , where n is an arbitrary prescribed number, from which it follows that
M[Q (u)] M(ku)
> M(nku) M (ku)
> n.
The N-functions M(u) and Q[M(u)] can, however, be equivalent in certain cases. In this connection, if M l (U) ,....., M(u) and Ql(U) ,....., Q (u) , then the functions M l (U ) and Ql[M l (U)] are equi valent if, and only if, the N-functions M(u) and Q[M(u)] are equivalent . We make one further, obvious, observation : if M(u) ,....., Q[M(u)] , then M(u) ,....., Q[Q[ . . . Q[M(u)]] ] .
CHAPTER I , § 6
40
THEOREM 6.3. A necessary and sUfficient condition that the N-function M(u) satisfy the iJ a-condition is that the relation N[M(u)] "-' M(u) hold, where N(v) is the function complementary to M(u) . PROOF. Suppose M (u) satisfies the iJ a-condition. We shall prove that N l [M(u)] "-' M(u) , where N l (V) is the N-function defined by equality (6. 3) . Since N l (V) N(v) , this will prove the "-'
necessity of the condition of the theorem. By the definition of the function N 1 (v) , we have that
Nl (V) � I v I M- l ( l v l ) , from which it follows that N l[M(u)] � M(u)u � M (ku) , for large values of u, in virtue of the fact that l u I M(u) "-' M (u) . Nl [M (u)] > M(u) for large values of the argument . Thus, Nl[M(u)] > M (u) .
On the other hand, for arbitrary N-function N 1 (v) , we have
We now prove the sufficiency of the condition of the theorem. Suppose N[M(u)] "-' M (u) . This signifies that , for large values of the argument, we have N [M (u) � M(k lU) . Since, in virtue of Young's inequality, vM- l (v) � N(v) + v < 2N(v) for large values of the argument , we have that
uM(u) � 2N[M(u)] � 2M(k lU) < M(2klU)
for large values of u. Thus, the N-function M(u) satisfies the iJ a-condition. * Suppose M (u) and Q (u) are two N-functions, the first of which satisfies the iJ a-condition. We shall show that both compositions M[Q(u)] and Q [M(u)] also satisfy the iJ a-condition. This follows from the following chain of obvious inequalities which are valid for large values of the argument :
uM[Q (u)] � Q (u)M[Q(u)] � M[k Q(u)] � M[Q(ku)]
and
uQ[M(u)] � Q[uM(u)] � Q[M(ku)] .
5 . The iJ 2-condition. I n a number of cases, the functions M (u) and Q [M(u)] are also equivalent if, and only if, Q (v) is a function which increases "essentially" more rapidly than the complementary function N (v) to M(u) . In the sequel, we shall be interested in the case when Q (v) v2. =
CHAPTER I , § 6
41
We shall say that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition if M ( u) M 2 (u) , i.e. if there exists a k > I such that M 2 (U) � M(ku) t6.6) r-....J
for all sufficiently large values of u. It is easily seen that the N-function M(u ) satisfies the LJ 2 condition if M(u) MlX(U) for some oc > I . Conversely, if the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition, then M(u) > MlX(U) for arbitrary oc > I . It can be verified directly that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition if this condition is satisfied by any N-function which is equivalent to M(u) . 2 The N-functions with principal parts eU, e u , and so on, can serve as examples of functions which satisfy the LJ 2 -condition. If the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition, then it also satisfies the LJ 3-condition. In fact , the LJ 2 -condition implies the existence of a k > I such that M (ku) � M 2 (U) for large values of u, and since M(u) > u for large values of u we have that M(ku) > uM(u) , i .e. inequality (6. 1 ) is satisfied. But this means that the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 3-condition. However, the class of N-functions, satisfying the LJ 3-condition, is more extensive than the class of N-functions satisfying the LJ 2 -condition. For example, the N-function M (u) with the principal part u1n u satisfies the LJ 3-condition but it does not satisfy the LJ 2-condition since, for arbitrary k > 0, we have that r-....J
!�r:
U 2 1n u = (ku) ln ( ku ) 00.
We showed, above, that every N-function which satisfies the LJ 2-condition increases more slowly than any power function. This fact is not only true for N-functions. In fact , let f(x) be an arbitrary non-negative non-decreasing function which satisfies the inequality f(2u) � kf(u) for u � uo. Then it follows from 2 nuo < u � 2 n + 1 uo that k n < (u j uO) ln 2 k and
f(u) � k n + lf(uo) � kf(uo) (ujuo) ln 2 k .
We shall now consider a non-decreasing function f(u) which satisfies the inequality
2f(u)
<
f(ku)
(6.7)
42
CHAPTER I, § 6
for u � Uo. Clearly, k > I . Suppose k n uo < u � k n + l uO. Then
2n
and
�
{uj (kUO)}lllk 2
f(u) > f(k n uo) > 2 nf(uo)
�
f(uo) {uj(kuoWnk � .
Thus, (6.7) implies that
f(u) > ulX
(6.8 )
for large values of u, where oc < In k 2. LEMMA 6. 1 . Suppose the positive non-decreasing function Plu) is
greater than unity and satisfies the inequality P 2 (U) < P(ku)
(6.9)
for large values of the argument. Then there exists an that P (u) > eU'" for large values of u.
oc
> 0 such
PROOF. It follows from the condition of the lemma that the function f(u) = In P (u) satisfies inequality (6.7) . Therefore, it satisfies inequality (6.8) , i.e. In P (u) > ulX• * It follows from this lemma that every N-function, which satisfies the LJ 2 -condition, increases more rapidly than some function eU• for large values of the argument . THEOREM 6.4. Suppose the right derivative P(u) of the N-function M(u) satisfies condition (6.9) for u � Uo. Then M(u) satisfies the
LJ 2 -condition.
PROOF. In virtue of Lemma 6. 1 , we may assume that 2u for u � Uo. Therefore, for u � Uo, we have
<
P(ku)
2UP 2 (U) < 2uP(ku) < P 2 (ku) < P(k 2u) .
From this and the inequality M(u) < uP(u) , it follows that
M 2 (U)
=
2
I
U
o
M(t)P(t) dt � M 2 (UO)
+
2
I tp2 (t) dt u
<
Uo
I P(k2t) dt < M2 (UO) U
<
M 2 (UO) +
o
+
M(k 2u)
for u > Uo. For large values of u, M 2 (UO) < M(k 2u) . It therefore follows from the preceding inequality that M 2 (u) < 2M(k 2u) < M(2k 2 u) . *
43
CHAPTER I , § 6
As we have already remarked, an N-function which satisfies the LJ 2 -condition increases more rapidly than some function of the form eua ( ex > 0) . It turns out that the converse does not hold. We leave it to the reader to construct an example of an N-function which increases more rapidly than some function eU ' ( ex > 0) and satisfies neither the LJ 2 -condition nor the LJ a-condition. The following assertion yields a simple criterion that the N function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. Suppose an ex > 0 can be found such that the function In M(u) cp(u) = ---'-u'"
(6. 1 0)
does not decrease for values of u larger than some Uo. Then the N function M(u) satisfies the J 2 -condition. In fact , suppose u � Uo. Then M2 (u) = e 2 1n 1l:f(u) = e 2ua[ln 1l:f ( u ) /u"1 ::( e 2 u a[ln 1l:f ( 2 11 "u ) / 2 u "1 = M(2 1 / IXU) . Since, moreover, for sufficiently large values of u, M (u) < M 2 (U) , we have that M(u) ,....., M 2 (U) , which was to be proved. As we noted, both compositions M[Q(u)] and Q[M(u)] of the N-functions M(u) and Q (u) satisfy the J a-condition if the N-function M(u) satisfies this condition. We shall now assume that M(u) satisfies the J 2 -condition. Then M [Q (u)] also satisfies the J 2 -condition inasmuch as for large values of u we have
M 2 [Q(U)]
<
M[kQ(u)]
<
M[Q (ku)].
It turns out that the N-function Q[M(u)] , i n this connection, might not satisfy the J 2 -condition. Moreover, whatever the function M(u) , we can always construct a function Q (u) such that Q[M(u)] does not satisfy the LJ 2 -condition. Suppose 0 < Vo < < M(vo) < VI < M(V I ) < . . . < Vn < M(vn) < . . . . We define the N-function Q (u) by setting it equal to u 2 for 0 < u < M(vo) and defining it as the linear function Q (vn + 1 ) + kn[u - M(Vn - I ) J on every closed interval M(Vn - l ) ::( u ::( M(vn) . The angular coef ficients kn are chosen so that they increase - this guarantees the convexity of the function Q (u) . Furthermore, we shall require that these angular coefficients increase so rapidly that the inequality
CHAPTER I , § 6
44
is satisfied for all n. Then the N-function Q(u) will satisfy the inequalitites Q 2 (v n ) > Q[M(v n )] (n = 1 , 2 , . . . ) . We set V n = M(un) . Without loss of generality, it can be assumed that M(u n ) > nU n . Then it follows from the inequalities obtained that Q 2 [M(un)] > Q{M[M(un)]} > Q[M(nu n)] ' This means that the composition Q[M(u)] does not satisfy the L1 2 -condition. 6. Properties of the complementary functions. THEOREM 6.S. Suppose the N-function N(v) satisfies the .1 3-
condition. Then the N-function N(v) , complementary to M(u) , satisfies the L1 2 -condition. PROOF. Let k l and k 2 be the constants appearing in (6.2) . Since the function M- l (v) is convex and (2k 2 /k1) > 1 , we have that
(
) -
2k 2 2k 2 M- l (V) . M- l - V < kl kl Consequently, in virtue of (6 .2) , we have that
for large values of v, from which the assertion of the theorem does follow. THEOREM 6.6. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the .1 2-
condition. Then the N-function N(v) complementary to it satisfies the .1 ' -condition. PROOF. Since M(u) satisfies the L1 2 -condition, constants to, k can be found such that M (kt) � M 2 (t) for t � to. Without loss of generality, we may assume that to > 1 . Let t � s � to. Then M (kts) > M(kt) > M 2 (t) � M(t)M(s) . Set t ing t = M- l (u) , S = M- l (V) in the last inequality, we obtain that M- l (uv) � kM- l (U)M- l (v) for u, v � M (to) . Now u and v occur symmetrically in the last inequality therefore it is valid for all u, v � M(to) . Since the N-function M(u) satisfies the L1 2 -condition, it also satisfies the L1 3-condition. In virtue of (6.2) , a Uo � M(to) + 1 can be found such that k l uM- l (k1u) � N (u) � k 2 uM- l (k 2U) for It � Uo (or v � uo) , where k l and k 2 are certain const ants. Con-
4S
CHAPTER I , § 6 sequently, for u, v � uo, we have
N(uv) � k 2 uvM- l (k 2UV)
=
( 'Vk 2U) ( Vk 2V)M- l ( Vk 2UVk 2V) ,
from which it follows that
and, finally, that
N(uv) � kN{Vk 2 /(k l U)}N{Vk 2 /(klV)}. In virtue of the preceding theorem, the N-function N (v) satisfies the Ll 2-condition. It therefore follows from the last inequality that N(uv) � cN(u)N(v) for large values of u, v, where c is a certain constant. * THEOREM 6.7. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll 3-
condition. A necessary and sufficient condition that the complementary N-function N(v) to M(u) satisfy the LI '-condition is that the inequality (Muv)
�
M(rxu)M({Jv)
be satisfied for large values of u and
v,
(6. 1 1 )
where rx, (J are certain constants.
PROOF. Suppose condition (6. 1 1 ) is satisfied. Then the inequality
M- l (uv) � holds for large follows that
u,
M- l (u)M- l (v) rx{J
v. From this inequality and Theorem 6 . 2 it
and since, in virtue of Theorem 6.5, N (v) satisfies the Ll 2-condition, we have that N(uv) � cN(u)N(v) . This proves the sufficiency of condition (6. 1 1 ) . Let us assume that N(v) satisfies the LI '-condition. This signifies, in virtue of Theorem 6.2, that uvM - l (uv) � kuM- l (u)vM- l (v) for large values of u, v. It follows from this that M(kuv) � M(u)M(v) for large values of the argument. *
CHAPTER I , § 6
46
This theorem and Theorem 6.6 imply that inequality (6. 1 1 ) is satisfied for N-functions which satisfy the LJ 2 -condition. A much stronger assertion holds : if M (u) satisfies the LJ 2-condition, then a U o > ° can be found such that
M (uv) � M (u)M(v) (6. 1 2) for u, v � uo. As uo, we must take a number such that M 2 (U) :(:; M(uou) for u � U o . Then, for u � v � uo, we have that M (u)M(v) :(:; M 2 (u) :(:; M(uou) :(:; M (uv ) .
Condition (6. 1 1 ) is usually easily verified. Let us consider, for example, the N-function M(u) for which p.p. M (u) = u 1n u . It satisfies the LJ 2-condition. For it , condition (6. 11) signifies that for large u, v. 7 . Test for the LJ 2 -condition for the complementary function. In a number of cases. the occasion arises to study N-functions M (u) for which an explicit expression is not known, but a formula for the complementary function N(v) is given. The question arises (which was solved earlier in the study of other clas<;es of N-functions) of how to determine from the function N (v ) whether or not the com plementary function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. We first establish a lemma concerning arbitrary N-functions. Suppose c.P(u) is an N-function. In virtue of ( l . l 8) , the function c.P(u) /u increases monotonically for u > 0, where lim {c.P(u) /u} = ° and lim {c.P(u) /u} = = . Therefore, the function u->- O
o
is an N-function. LEMMA 6.2. c.P l ( U) c.P(u) . PROOF . Clearly, c.P 1 (u) :(:; c.P(u) . On the other hand, for u > 0, we have that f"oo.J
f
u
c.P1 (u) =
o
c.P {t) dt > t
f c.P;t) dt > c.P ( � ) . u
u/2
*
47
CHAPTER I , § 6
THEOREM 6.8. A necessary and sUfficient condition that the N function M (u) satisfy the LJ 2-condition is that the complementary N-function N (v) to it satisfy the inequality N (v) v
- -- <
N ( v';j k ------= -'-' v' v
(6. 1 3)
for large values of the argument, where k is some constant. Proof of necessity. Satisfaction of the LJ 2 -condition means that .11 2 (u) < M(klU) for large values of u. From this it follows that , for large values of the argument , we have (6. 1 4) where M-l (V) is the function inverse to M (u) . Since the function M(u) satisfies the LJ a-condition, we have, in virtue of Theorem 6. 1 , for large values of the argument , that (6. 1 5) N (v) < kavM- 1 (kav) .
and that
(6. 1 6)
In virtue of (6. 1 6) and (6. 1 4) , we have that
and, in virtue of (6. 1 5) , that N(v) v
-
<
klka . r;-N (k 2 V kav) . v' kav
-=
(6. 1 7)
In virtue of Theorem 6.5, the function N (v) satisfies the LJ 2 condition, i.e. N(k 2 v'ka v'-;;) < k4N ( v'-;;) for large values of the argument . Therefore, (6. 1 7) implies (6. 1 3) , where k = k1k4 v' ka. Proof of sufficiency. We consider the function r(v) = N (v) jv. In virtue of Lemma 6.2, the N-function Ivl
Nl( V ) =
f r(t) dt
o
is equivalent to the function N (v) . The N-function Ml (U) which
48
CHAPTER I , § 6
is complementary to N l ( V ) is computed directly :
= f r-1 (t) dt, l ui
M l (U)
o
where r- 1 (t) is the function which is the inverse to the monotonically increasing function r(t) . The N-function M l ( U) is equivalent to the N-function M (u) . In virtue of (6. 1 3) , for large values of the argument, we have that [r- 1 (u)J 2 < r-l (ku) . From this inequality and Theorem 6.4, it follows that the N-function M l (U) satisfies the L1 2-condition. This signifies that M(u) also satisfies this condition. * We note that k is always > 1 in condition (6. 1 3) inasmuch as for an arbitrary N-function, for v > 1 , we have that
Functions, which are complementary to those which satisfy the ,1 2 -condition, constitute a part of the class of N-functions which increase more slowly than an arbitrary power function I V [ IX (0( > 1 ) . Furthermore, it follows from Lemma 6. 1 , Theorem 2. 1 and Theorem 6. 1 that such N-functions satisfy the inequality N (v) < v Inti v (fJ > 0 ) for large values of the argument .
8. Further discussion on the composition of N-functions. In
the present subsection we shall establish some properties of the composition N l [N2 (V) ] of the N-functions N I (v) and N2 (v) which are complementary to the N-functions M 1 (u) and M2 (U) which satisfy the ,1 3-condition. We shall first prove an assertion which is valid for arbitrary N-functions. LEMMA 6.3. Suppose W l (V) and W2 (V) are two N-functions. Then the fttnction W(v) W l {V)W2('U) j [ V [ is also an N-function. PROOF. The function W(v) is even, non-negative and manifestly satisfies the conditions
=
lim V� O
W (v) V
= 0,
lim '!)--> oo
W(v) V
=
=
.
I n virtue of the second definition of an N-function (see p. 9) ,
CHAPTER I , § 6
49
it suffices to prove that tJ> (v) is a convex function, i.e. that
(6. 1 8) In virtue of ( 1 . 1 8) , the functions tJ> 1 (V) /V and tJ>2 (V) /V increase monotonically for positive values of v. Therefore, the function tJ> (v) also increases monotonically. Consequently, it suffices to prove inequality (6. 1 8) for positive VI and V 2 . Clearly,
inasmuch as both factors have the same sign. From this it follows that [tJ> I (VI) + tJ> 1 (V 2 ) ] [tJ>2 (VI) + tJ>2 (V 2 ) ] VI + V 2
���--�����--�� �
tJ> 1 (VI) tJ>2 (VI) tJ> 1 (V 2 ) tJ>2 (V 2 ) + VI V2
and, in virtue of the convexity of the N-functions tJ> 1 (V) and tJ>2 (V) , tJ>
( VI + V 2 ) = 2
�
2 VI + V 2
tJ> 1
1 2 (V I + V 2)
( VI
+ V2
2
) tJ>2 ( VI + V 2 ) 2
�
[ tJ> I (VI) + tJ> 1 (V 2 ) ] [ tJ>2 (VI) + tJ>2 (V 2 )] �
from which (6. 1 8) does indeed follow. * THEOREM 6.9. Suppose the N-functions M I (u) and M 2 (U) satisfy
the LJ s-condition and that M I (U) N I [N 2 (v)]
I"-.J
-<
M 2 (U) . Then
tJ> (v) =
NI (V)N 2 (V) Ivi
.
PROOF. We first note that the relation
.,
is valid for arbitrary N-functions NI (V) and N 2 (v) . In fact , in CO"v•
tunctiOKS
4
CH APTER I, § 6
50
virtue of ( 1 . 1 6) , the inequality N l (V) /V < N l [N2(V)] /N 2 (V) is valid for N 2 (V) > v, from which it follows that N l (V)N 2 (V)/V < N1[N 2 (v)] for these values of v. W e shall prove that, under t h e conditions o f the theorem, we have N1[N 2 (v)] -< N l (V)N 2 (V) / l v l . The relation M l (U) -< M 2 (U) signifies that Ml(U) :s;; M 2 (k lU) for large values of the argument , where k l is a number which can be assumed larger than unity. Therefore, M2 1 (V) :s;; klMl 1 (v) for large values of the argument . From this it follows that
(* )
The N-function M l (U) satisfies the L1 a-condition. Therefore, a k 2 > 1 can be found such that UM l(U) :s;; M1 (k 2 u) for large values of the argument . It then follows from the preceding in equality (*) that
VM2 1 (V)
:s;;
klMl[k 2Ml 1 (V)]
:s;;
M1[k l k 2M 1 1 (v)]
(6. 1 9)
for large values of the argument . Consequently,
Ml 1 [vM2 1 (V)] and
:s;;
klk 2Ml 1 (v)
In virtue of Theorem 6. 1 , constants ka found such that
N l (kav)
:s;;
vMl 1 (v)
N 2 ( kav) :s;; VM2 1 (V)
<
1 and k 4 > 1 can be
:s;;
Nl (k 4 V) ,
:s;;
N2 (k 4 V)
for large values of the argument . From these inequalities and (6.20) , it follows that
Nl[kaN 2 (kav)]
:s;;
k lk2
Nl (k 4 V)N 2 (k 4V) = k l k 2 k 4 tP(k 4V) V
for large values of the argument. It follows from this that
Nl[N 2 (k�v)] Thus, N 1 [N 2 (v)] -< tP(v) . *
:s;;
tP(klk 2 k�v) .
51
CHAPTER I , § 6
THEOREM 6. 1 0. Suppose M l (U) satisfies the J 2 -condition and that M2 (U) satisfies the J s-condition. Then the assertion of Theorem 6. 9:
PROOF. Since M 2(U) > U for large values of the argument, we have that vM2" l (V) < v 2 = Mi[Ml l (v)] for large v. The N-function M l (U) satisfies t h e J 2 -condition. This means that there exists a k l > 1 such that Mi(u) � M l (k l U) for large values of the argument . Therefore vM2" l � Ml[k l Ml l (V)] for large values of v. This inequality coincides with inequality (6. 1 9) . From it, as was also the case in the proof of the preceding theorem, it follows that N1 [N 2 (v)] -< (J)(v) . The relation (J)(v) -< N1[N 2 (V)] , as was pointed out above, is always valid. * The next theorem follows from Theorem 6. 1 0. THEOREM 6. 1 1 . If the N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (U) satisfy the
Nl[N2(V)] "" (J)(v)
=
N 1 (v)N 2(V) / l v l is valid.
J 2 -condition, then
Nl [N 2 (v)] "" N 2 [N1 (v)] "" (J)(v)
=
N l (V)N 2 (v) . Ivl
I t is not known whether it is sufficient in Theorem 6. 1 1 to require the satisfaction of a weaker J s-condition. As an example, we consider N-functions N l (V) and N 2 (V) such that p.p. N1 (v)
=
v In v, p.p. N 2 (v)
=
ve VIn 'll .
The function M l (U) satisfies the J 2-condition ; M 2 (U) satisfies the J s-condition but it does not satisfy the J 2 -condition. In this connection, M 2 (u) -< M l (U) inasmuch as N1 (v) -< N 2 (v) . In virtue of Theorem 6.9, we have that N 2 [N1 (v)] "" N1 (v)N 2 (v) / l v l and, in virtue of Theorem 6. 1 0, that Nl[N 2 (V)] "" N l (V)N 2 (V) / l v l . Thus, the assertion o f Theorem 6. 1 1 i s true i n this example although its conditions are not satisfied . Theorem 6. 1 1 is extended in a natural way by the following assertion : THEOREM 6. 1 2. Suppose the N-functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) satisfy
the J 2 -condition. Then the N-functions complementary to the N functions N1[N 2 (V)] and N 2 [Nl (V)] also satisfy the J 2-condition.
PROOF. In virtue of Theorem 6. 1 1 , it suffices to consider the N-function lJ'(u) which is complementary to the N-function
(J)(v)
=
N l (V)N 2 (V) . Ivl
52
CHAPTER I, § 7
In virtue of Theorem 6.8,
from which it follows, in virtue of Theorem 6.8 again, that P(u) satisfies the LJ 2-condition. * § 7. Concernin� a class of N-functions
1 . Formulation ot the problem. In the preceding section, we pointed out formulas for N-functions which are equivalent to the complementary functions to certain N-functions M(u) . In this connection, we succeeded in considering only those N-functions which either increase more rapidly than an arbitrary exponential function or more slowly than all exponential functions of the form u 1 +t ( 8 > 0) . To such N-functions there do not correspond functions M (u) for which p.p. M(u)
ulX =(In u) l' l (In In u) l" oc
. . . (In In . . . In u) l' n ,
(7. 1 )
where oc > I , Y l , Y2, . . . , Yn are arbitrary numbers. In the present section we study the special class of N-functions containing functions with principal parts of the form (7 . 1 ) . For functions in this class, one succeeds in effectively constructing N-functions equivalent to the complementary functions. For simplicity of discussion we assume that all N-functions considered in the present section have ordinary (and not only right) derivatives for large values of the argument .
2. The class
im.
Below, b y
KR ( U)
KR ( U) =
w e denote the function
ur ( u ) R (u) ,
(7.2)
where R (u) is a differentiable function and r (u) is it s derivative.
CHAPTER I , § 7
53
It is clear that the function KR(U ) is defined for those values of u for which r(u) exists and for which R (u) i= O. The following simplest properties of the function KR(U) are evident : KR1 ·R, (U) = KR1 (U ) + KR, (U) , (7.3)
KR1[R,] (U) = KRJR 2 (u) ] · KR, ( u) .
(7.4)
Both these formulas are valid for those values of U for which the expressions in the right members have meaning. We note that, for arbitrary differentiable N-function M (u) ,
KM (U) > 1 .
In fact, since P ( u) = M' (u) increases, we have that
uP(u) > M(u) =
(7.5)
lui
J P(t) dt,
o
from which (7.5) does indeed follow. We denote by we the class of those functions R (u) for which KR(U) is defined for all large u and lim KR(U)
=
O.
(7.6)
In virtue of (7.3) , whenever the class we contains the two functions R1(u) and R 2 (u) it also contains their product R 1 (u)R 2 (u) . It follows from this same property (7 .3) that Kl/R (U ) = - KR (U) , from which it in turn follows that the class we contains the function I /R(u) whenever it contains the function R (u) . In virtue of (7 . 4) , the superposition R1[R 2 (u)] belongs to we
if R 2 (u) E we, lim R 2 ( U ) = U-700
00,
and lim KR , (U) U-700
<
00.
I t follows from the properties of the class we described above that the functions (In ut', (In In ut ' , . . " (In In . . . In uyn belong to this class (where the Yi are arbitrary numbers) . Suppose s > 0 is given. Then for the function R(u) E we one can find a Uo such that l ur(u) jR(u) I < s (u ?: uo) , from which it follows that r(u) jR (u) < sju (u ?: uo) . Integrating the last inequality from Uo to u, we obtain In -- < s ln - .
I
R (u) R (Zfo)
I
u Uo
54
CHAPTER I , § 7
Consequently,
I R(u) 1 The relation
<
I R(uo) I
( :0 Y
(u
�
uo) .
(7 . 7)
lim --- = 00 ,
u R(u) I I
(7.8)
which will be of importance in the sequel, follows from (7.7) . LEMMA 7 . 1 . Let the function R(u) E im be positive for large values of u . Then, for arbitrary e > 0, the function uBR(u) increases
PROOF . It is sufficient to show that the function h(u) = uB/2R(u) has a positive derivative for large values of u. But this follows from (7 . 6) since
monotonically to infinity.
h ' (u) =
; U(B/2 ) - lR(u) + uB/2r(u)
=
u(e/2 ) - lR(u )
[ ; + KR(U) ] .
LEMMA 7 . 2. Suppose R(u) is a function from the class that the functions
u� oc
R (u) ,
vtJ PRtJ-l(v)
(
oc ,
P
> 1,
im
*
such
� + pI = 1 ) �
are the principal parts of the N-functions M(u) and Nl (V) , respectively . that the condition vtJ- l R RtJ- 1 (v) (7.9) lim =b>O R (v) v-+oo
A ssume
[
]
is satisfied . Then the N-function N l (V) is equivalent to the N-function N(v) which is complementary to the N-function M(u) . PROOF . We consider the functions
These functions increase monotonically to infinity for large values of u, v, in virtue of Lemma 7 . 1 . Therefore, each of them can be considered as the principal part of the derivatives of certain N functions M 2 (U) and N 3(v) .
CHAPTER I , § 7
55
A direct calculation shows that
1 P (U) = 1 + - KR (U) , IX P 2 (U)
--
q l (V)
--
qa(v)
f3 - 1
= 1 -
f3
KR(U)
for large u, where P(u ) = M ' ( u ) , ql (V) = N � (v) . From the last equalities and (7.6) . it follows that lim u-+oo
P (u) Q l (V) = lim P 2(U) 1)-+00 Q a (v)
=
1.
Therefore, in virtue of Lemma 3.2, we have
M(u) ,...., M 2 (u) , Since
we have, in virtue of (7.9) , that lim
P2[Qa (V)]
v
N 1 ( v) ,...., N a (v) .
(7. 1 0)
= b > 0,
and it follows from Theorems 3.4 and 3.2 that
(7. 1 1 ) where Ma (u) and N2 (V) are N-functions complementary to Na (v) and M2 (U) , respectively. It follows from (7. 1 0) and (7. 1 1 ) that M(u ) ,...., Ma(u) . This means that N(v) ,...., Na ( v) . It follows, again in virtue of (7. 1 0) , that N(v) ,...., N 1 (v) . *
3. The class m. By m we shall denote the class of functions which, for large values of the argument, are continuous , non negative and satisfy the conditions ll·m when
u->- oo
f[u + c5 (u)] --'--- = cons t an t > 0 f(u)
---
-- = d >
. c5( u) hm u u-+ oo
-
1.
( f E m)
(7 . 1 2)
(7 . 1 3 )
CHAPTER I , § 7
56
The functions lu i" for arbitrary y, In lui , and so on, can serve as examples of functions in the class m. For the first of these, we have that
f[u
lim U--'OO
+
� (u)] f(u)
=
lim u-oo
and for the second that
lim
f[u
u_oo
+
� (u) ] f(u)
=
lim u-oo
[
Mu) u
1 +
{I
In +
J" = ( 1 + d)"
l
[ I �] In u +
>
=
0
l.
When the function f(x) is in the class m, then l /f(u) is also in m ; if the two functions h (u) and f2 (U) are in the class m, then their product h (u)/2 (u) is also in m ; if lim f2 (U) = 00, then the superposition hC l2 (u)] is in m if the functions h (u) and l2 (u) are in m. In the proof, we need only the last assertion. Suppose the function � (u) satisfies condition (7. 1 3) and that lim u-oo
l2 [u + � (u)] =y> l2 (u)
o.
Then the function � l (U) , defined by the equality
� l[ l2 (u)]
=
l2 [u
+
� (u)] - f2 (U) ,
satisfies the condition
�l ( ) lim __V_ v 1)-+00
=
)] U,--� 1 [f---:-,- 2 (-'-clim _-f2 (U)
u-oo
=
y
_
1
>
-
from which it follows that lim u- oo
h {Mu + � (u) ]} h{l2 (u) + � l[l2 (u)] } = lim h[ f2 (U)] h[ f2 (U)] u-oo =
ll· m 1)-+00
h [v + � l (V ) ]
------'--
h (v)
=
I,
const ant > 0 .
This means that h[ f2 (U)] E m. I t follows from the properties of the class m described above that the function
f(u)
=
uY' (ln u)Y2 (ln In U) Y3 . . . (In In . . . In u)Yn,
(7. 1 4)
57
CHAPTER I , § 7
considered for large values of the argument, belongs to W . In (7. 1 4) , the Yi are arbitrary numbers. LEMMA 7.3. Functions jrom the class W which are monotonic
jor large values oj u possess the property that lim
In
j(u) = u
o.
(7 . 1 5)
PROOF. We tirst consider the case of an increasing function j(u) . It follows from (7 . 1 2) , if we set � (u) = u in this condition, that , for u, which are larger than some Uo > 0, we have : j( 2u) :(; kj(u) , where k is some positive number. Suppose 2 nuo < u < 2n + 1 uo. Then
( )
U In . 2 j(u) :(; j(2n + 1 uo) :(; kn + 1 j(uo) :(; kj (uo)2 n 1n • 2 :(; kj(uo) � .
Consequently, In j(u) :(; In [kj (uo)U- 1nk 2] + In k 2 · 1n u, from which (7 . 1 5) does indeed follow. Now suppose the function j(u) increases monotonically. Then the function h (u) = 1 /j( u) , which also belongs to the class W, increases monotonically. It follows from the assertion already proved for monotonically increa sing functions that In j(u) . In h (u) . hm = - hm = O. *
U
U- oo
u--+oo
U
We note that the function (7 . 1 4) is monotonic for large values of u - a fact which is easily verified. LEMMA 7 .4. Suppose the junction R(u) E m is representable in the jorm R(u) j(ln u) , where j(u) E W. Then jor oc > 1 , we have that
=
R lim 1'----+ 00
a-l [{ R�V) J } R( V )
= comtant > O.
PROOF. Let � (�t) = (oc - 2 )u - (oc - 1 ) In j(u) . In virtue of the preceding lemma, we have that lim u--+oo
� (u) = oc - 2 > - 1 -. 1,(,
CHAPTER I , § 7
58 Since R
{ [iM J } �-l
f[(rx - 1 ) ln v
R (v)
(rx. - 1 ) In R ( v)] f (In v) -
f[In
+ !5 (ln v) J f Un v )
v
we have that R ll' m �oo
{[ J } V R (v) R (v)
_
�- l
_ _
f [u + !5 ( J ll' m _____U_J_ u--+ oo
f(u )
=
const an t > 0 . *
4. Theorem on the complementary function. THEOREM 7 . 1 . Suppose R (u) belongs to the class m and that it is representable in the form R (u) = f (In u) , where f(u) is a monotonic function from the class in . Let an N-function M(u) be prescribed such that p . p. M(u) = (u�/rx)R (u) (rx > 1 ) . Finally, suppose the function (vtJ/{3)R l -tJ(v) ( l /rx + 1 /{3 = 1 ) is the principal part of
some N-function N l (V) . Then
(7 . 1 6) PROOF. It follows from Lemma 7 . 4 that condition (7 .9) is satisfied. Lemma 7.2 implies (7. 1 6) . * Let us turn to the consideration of the N-function M(u) pointed out at the beginning of this section :
p.p . M(u)
=
u� - (ln u) ", (1n ln u) "· · · · ( In In . . . In u r n rx
(7. 1 )
(where rx > 1 and the Yt are arbitrary numbers) . This function can be represented in the form p.p. M(u) ( u �/rx) f( ln u) , where f(u) is defined by formula (7 . 1 4) . Thus, the function M(u) satisfies the condition of Theorem 7. 1 . We set =
p.p. N l (V) =
vtJ
-
{3
[(In v )
-
'"
(In In v) - yo
•
•
•
(In In . . . In v ) - Yn] tJ- 1 (7. 1 7 )
59
CHAPTER I , § 7
Theorem 7 . 1 implies the next theorem. THEOREM 7 . 2. The N-function N l (V) with principal part (7 . 1 7)
is equivalent to the function complementary to the N-function M(u) with principal part (7 . 1 ) .
C H A P T E R II
ORLICZ SPACES § 8. Orlicz classes
I . Definition. In the remainder of this book, G will denote a bounded closed set in a finite-dimensional Euclidean space, on which we consider the usual Lebesgue measure. We note that the maj ority of the assertions and constructions introduced below also retain their validity for the case when we consider an abstract set with finite continuous measure (where by continuity of a measure we understand the existence of a subset A of every set B such that the measure of A equals half the measure of B) . Let M(u) be an N-function. We shall denote by L M (G) the class of those real-valued functions, defined on G, for which
p(u ; M) =
f U [u(x)] dx
<
=.
G
In this connection, functions which differ only on a set of measure zero will not be considered distinct . The notation p(u ; M) will be used frequently in the sequel. The classes L M (G) are called Orlicz classes. In situations where this cannot give rise to any misunderstanding, we shall write L M instead of LM(G) . All bounded functions, but not all summable functions, belong to the class LM. It is easily seen that every function in the class LM is summable. We note that every function u(x) which is summable on G belongs to some Orlicz class. To prove this assertion, we consider the sets Gn = G{n I � l u(x) I < n}. It is clear that -
� n mes Gn � f l u(x) l dx
n l As
IS
+ mes
G < =.
G
known, one can construct an indefinitely increasing se-
61
CHAPTER II, § 8 quence {a n} such that we also have 00
We set
pet) =
!
t
(8. 1 )
if 0 :s:;; t
an if
:s:;;
n
t
<
1,
<
n+ 1
(n = 1 , 2, . . . ) .
The function pet) possesses all the properties required in order that
M (u) =
lui
I P (t) dt
o
be an N-function. Since
M(n) =
I p et) dt :s:;; ann, n
o
we have, in virtue of (8. 1 ) , that
I M[u(x)J dx =1:1 I M[u(x)J dx :s:;;1:1M(n) mes Gn :s:;; Gn
G
00
n= 1 This means that u(x) E LM . The assertion j ust proved means that the space L of functions which are summable on G is the union of all the Orlicz classes. Further on, we shall use a stronger assertion. It turns out that for every summable function u(x) one can find an N-function Q(u) , satisfying the L1 '-condition, such that
I Q{Q[u(x)J} dx
G
< 00.
As we have already shown, there exists an N-function M(u)
CHAPTER II, § 8
62 such that
J M[u (x)] dx < =.
G
The function M(u) can be represented in the form of a composition, M(u) = Q l [Q 2 (U)] . We consider the N-function P (v) = ePd v) +P, (v) _ 1 ,
where P 1 (v) and P 2 (v) are N-functions which are complementary to Q l (U) and Q 2 (U) , respectively . The function P(v) satisfies the ,d 2 -condition, where P 1 (v) < P(v) , P 2 (v) < P(v) for large values of v. In virtue of Theorem 6.6, the N-function Q (u ) which is com plementary to P tv) satisfies the ,d '-condition and for large values of the argument , in virtue of Theorem 2. 1 , we have that Q (u) < Ql (U) , Q ( u ) < Q 2 (U) . Therefore
J Q{Q [(u)]} dx < a + J Q l{Q 2 [U(X)]} dx < =. G
G
1J ]
Let u ( x) E LM ; then the
2. The Jensen integral inequality. inequality
M
G
U(X) dX
mes G
J M[u(x)] dx
G_____ < _ �
mes G
( 8 .2 )
holds ; inequality (8.2) will be called the ] ensen integral inequality. We note that a more general relation is frequently called Jensen 's inequality (see, for example, ZIGMUND [ 1 J ) . We shall first consider the case when u (x) is a continuous function. Suppose e > 0 is an arbitrary prescribed number. The set G can be decomposed into n subsets Gi such that mes Gi = (mes G) jn (i = 1 " 2 . . . , n) ,
1M( J G
u(x)
mes G
J M[u(x)J dx
G
--'=-----
mes G
)
dX - M
-
n
� i=l
( .� U(Xi) �n ) 1 < e, t� l
M[ U(Xi )] < e, n
where Xi is some point in the set Gi. From the indicated inequalities
CHAPTER II, § 8
63
and ( 1 .3) , it follows that
M
(f G
u(x) dx
mes G
)
�M
1 + e � i�l(;l U (Xi) --;) n
�
M[
U (Xi) ]
n
+
f M[u(x)] dx mes G
G
e
�
+ 2e.
Hence, inequality (8.2) holds, inasmuch as e is arbitrary . Inequality (8.2) is obtained for the case of an arbitrary function in L M by passage to the limit, starting with this same inequality for continuous functions.
l(U)
3. The comparison ot classes. Orlicz classes L Ml and L M . which are determined by distinct N-functions M and M 2 (U) are, generally speaking, distinct . THEOREM 8. 1 . The inclusion
(8.3) holds it, and only it, there exist positive constants Uo and a such that (8.4) PROOF. The sufficiency of condition (8.4) is obvious : for an arbitrary function u(x) E L M1 , we have that
p(u ; M 2 )
=
f M2 [u(x)] dx
G
�
� M 2 (uo) mes G +
a
f M1[u (x)] dx
<
00 .
G
Let us assume that condition (8.4) is not satisfied. Then an indefinitely increasing sequence of numbers Un can be found such that M 2 (u n ) > 2 nM1 (u n ) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . (8. S ) We subdivide the set G into disj oint subsets G n such that mes G n
M1(Ul) mes G 2 nM1 (u n )
= ------
(n
=
I 2 . . .) "
,
CHAPTER I I , § 8
64 and we set
u(x)
=
I
Un for x E G n , o
00
for x E U G n .
n= l The function u(x) is in the class L M, since
I M1 [u(x)] dx =n�l I Ml[U(x)] dx n�l Ml (Un) mes G n =
Gn
G
=
but u(x) E L M. since, in virtue of (8.5) , we have that
I M2 [u(x)] dx
G
=
�
n l
I M2 [U(x)] dx n�l M2 (U n) mes Gn =
Gn
�
00
n= l
It follows from this theorem that two functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) determine the same Orlicz class if, and only if, there exist positive constants a, b and Uo such that (8.6) aM 2 (u) � Ml (U) � bM 2 (u) (u � uo) . 4. The structure of Orlicz classes. It follows from Jensen's inequality that the Orlicz class LM is a convex set : whenever the class LM contains the two functions U l(X) and U 2 (X) then it also contains the entire "segment " u /X(x) = ex:Ul (X) + ( I - ex:)U 2 (X) (0 � ex: � I ) . In fact, if U l(X) , U 2 (X) E LM then
p(u/X ; M)
=
I M[ex:U l (X)
G
,
+ (I
-
ex:)u 2 (x)] dx �
- ex:)p(U 2 ; M) < 00 . THEOREM 8.2. The class LM is a linear set if, and only if, the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. PROOF. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. Then for arbitrary l there exist constants k(l) and Uo such that M(lu) � k (l)M(u) for u � Uo. In virtue of Theorem 8. 1 , it follows from the last inequality that the function lu(x) belongs to the class LM whenever the function u(x) is in L M. �
ex:p(U l ; M)
+ (I
CHAPTER II, § 8
6S
Let U l (X) , U 2 (X) be in LM . Then, in virtue of what we ha:ve already proved and inequality ( 1 . 1 ) , we have that
f
M[ OCUI (x) + ,8u 2 (X)] dx :S;;
G
:S;; !
f M [2ocU l (X) ] dx + ! f M[2,8U2 (X) ] dx <
00
G
G
for arbitrary oc and ,8. This proves the sufficiency of the condition of the theorem. Now, assume that LM is a linear set. This signifies, in particular, that 2u(x) belongs to LM whenever u (x) E LM, i.e. that L M C L MI ' where the N-function M (2u) is denoted by M l (U) . In virtue of Theorem 8. 1 , it follows from the last inclusion that there exist constants a and Uo such that M 1 (u)
=
M(2u) :S;; aM(u) for U � Uo. *
We shall now consider in more detail the case when the N function M(u) does not satisfy the Li 2 -condition. Let u (x) E LM . The totality of functions u/1(x) = ,8u (x) (0 :S;; ,8 < 00) will be called the "ray" passing through u (x) . If the function u (x) is bounded, then it is clear that the entire "ray" u/1(x) belongs to L M • In virtue of Theorem 8.2, there also are functions for which part of the "ray" belongs to LM but the entire "ray" does not belong to this class. We denote by ,80 the number such that ,8u (x) E LM for ,8 < ,80 and ,8u (x) E LM for ,8 > ,80. The question arises whether or not the function ,8ou (x) belongs to the class. It turns out that · both cases are possible. Suppose the N-function M (u) does not satisfy the L1 2-condition. Then a monotonically increasing· 'sequence of numbers Un (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) , which tend to infinity, can be found such that M(U l ) > 1 and M
[ ( 1 + �) un] > 2nM (un)
(n
=
1 2 . . .). "
(8.7 )
Let Gn be disj oint subsets of G such that mes Gn = Convex functions
mes G n 2 M (un)
----
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . ) .
(8.8) 5
66
j
CHAPTER I I , § 8
We define the function u. (x) by means of the equalities
u (x) = •
(n
u n if x E G n 0
=
if x E nU G n.
1 , 2, . . . ) ,
00
�l
The function u. (x) belongs to LM since
p(U,. ; M)
=
f M[u,. (x)J dx � =n
f M[u. (x)] dx =
l
G
G.
00
n� l
= 1:
M(u n ) mes G n
<
00 .
In virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) , the functions fJu ,. (x) , with fJ < I , also belong to LM . We shall show that fJu,. (x) does not belong to LM when fJ is > 1 . In fact , for I + ( l in) < fJ, we have, in virtue of (8.7) and (8.8) , that
f M[fJu. (x)J dx
=
M[fJu nJ mes G n > >M
G.
[( + +) u1tJ mes Gn I
> mes G,
from which it follows that
p (fJu. ; M)
=
f M[fJu. (x)J dx � f M [fJu,. (x)J dx f M[fJu. (x) J dx =n
G
l
�
G.
;?
1+
( l / n )
fJ < I but fJu* (x) E LM for fJ
=
00 .
G.
We now construct a function u*(x) such that fJu*(x) E LM for ;? 1 . To this end, we set
u* (x)
=
)( I
1 +
0
+) un
if X E Gn if x E
n� l 00
(n
Gn.
=
1 , 2, . . . ) ,
CHAPTER
II, § 9
In virtue of (8 . 7) and (8.8) , we have, for (3 ;;:", I , that
p((3u* ; M)
=
f M[(3u*(x) ] dx
o
=
67
n�l f M[(3u*(x)] dx ;;:", On
But if (3 < I , then, for (3 [ 1 + ( l in)] < I , we have
f M[(3u* (x)] dx
=
On
[(
M (3 1 +
�) un] mes Gn m�: G , �
from which it follows that
p((3u* ; M) =
f M[(3u*(x)] dx n�l f M[(3u*(x)] dx
o
=
On
< 00.
§ 9. The space L�
I . The Orlicz norm. Suppose M (u) and N(u) are mutually complementary N-functions. We shall denote by LM(G) the totality of functions u(x) satisfying the condition
lu, v) =
f u(x)v(x) dx
o
<
00
for all v ex) E LN. In this connection, functions which differ only on a set of measure zero are not considered to be distinct - the same as was the case in the definition of Orlicz classes . We shall write LM instead of LM (G) in situations where this cannot give rise to any misunderstanding. It follows from the definition that LM is a linear set . In virtue of Young's inequality (2.6) , for every pair of functions u(x) E LM, v ex) E LM, we have that
(u, v)
=
f u(x)v(x) dx � p (u ;
o
from which it follows that LM e Lk
M) + p (v ; N) ,
(9 . 1 )
68
CHAPTER I I , § 9 THEOREM 9. 1 . Suppose u(x) E Lit . Then sup p(v ; N ) ';;; l
I (u, v) I
sup
=
p(v ; N ) ';;; l
I I u(x)v(x) dx I
<
00 .
G
PROOF. Let us assume that the assertion in the theorem is not true. Then one can find a function uo(x) E Lit and a sequence of functions v n (x) E LN, p(vn ; N) � I , such that
f uo(x)vn(x) dx
> 2n
(n
=
1 2 . . .) "
.
(9.2)
G
We can assume, without loss of generality, that all these functions are positive. We consider the increasing sequence of functions
It is easily seen that in virtue of the convexity of the N-function N(v) we have
p(gn ; N) �
n
�
k=l
p(Vk ; N)
<
1
and also, i n virtue o f (9.2) , that
f UO(x)gn(x) dx
�
n
(n = I , 2, . . . )
.
(9.3)
G
The monotonic sequence of functions g n (x) converges almost everywhere on G to the function
Since the sequence of functions N[g n (x)] also increases mono tonically, passing to the limit as n ---* 00 in the inequality
f N[gn(x)] dx < I ,
G
69
CHAPTER I I , § 9 we obtain, in virtue of Levi's theorem, that
f N[g(x)] dx
G
=
��
f N[gn(x)] dx
G
� I.
[For Levi's theorem, see NATANSON [ I ] . LEVI'S THEOREM. If a monotonically increasing sequence of measurable functions tpl (X) , tp 2 (X) , . . . converges almost everywhere on G to the function tp(X) , -
then ��
f tpn(x) dx
G
=
f tp(x) dx.]
G
Thus, the function g(x) is E LN. The monotonic sequence of summable functions uo(x)g n (x) (n = I , 2, . . . ) converges almost everywhere to the function uo(x)g(x) . Therefore, in virtue of the aforementioned Levi's theorem and (9.3) , we have that
f uo(x)g(x) dx
G
=
��
f UO(x)gn(x) dx
G
=
00 .
But this contradicts the fact that uo(x) E LM. * The assertion j ust proved allows us to introduce the Orlicz norm in the set LM with the aid of the following equality :
I l u li M = sup
p (v ; N ) <;; l
1 f u(x)v (x) dx I · G
(9.4)
It follows from the definition that the norm (9.4) satistiec; the usual axioms : I ) lI u l l M = 0 if, and only if, u(x) = 0 almost everywhere ; 2) I l ocu l l M = l oc l l i u llM ; 3) I l u I + u 2 1 1 M � I l u I llM + I l u 2 1 1 M . The set LM thus becomes a normed linear space which is called an Orlicz space. We note further one obvious property of the norm. If U I (X) , U 2 (X) E LM and I Ul (X) 1 � I U 2 (X) I almost everywhere on G, then
Il u I l lM � I l u 2 1 1 M.
As an example, we consider the case of the space LM determined by the N-function M(u) = l u l l¥/OC (oc > I ) . The N-function N(v) = I v l fJ/P ( I /oc + I /P = I ) will be complementary to it.
70
CHAPTER II. § 9
First assume that UI(X) E Lif and that
I l ul l l 1¥ =
( f l UI (X) I IX dX) 1 /" = 1 . o
(9.5)
I n virtue of the known Holder inequality, we have, for arbitrary function v(x) E LN satisfying the condition p (v ; N) ::;:;; 1 , that
If 0
UI (X) V (X) dx
so that
I ::;:;; ( f 0
I lu I l lM =
l UI (x) l 1¥ dx
sup p(v ; N)';;;; 1
If
y /" ( f Iv(x) l P dxy /fJ ::;:;; PI /fJ, 0
I
U l (X)V(X) dx ::;:;; PI /fJ.
o
(9.6)
On the other hand, for the function vo (x) = P 1 /fJ l ul (X) I 1¥-1 sgn Ul (X) , which satisfies the condition p (vo ; N) = I , we have that
f
o
UI (X) VO (x) dx = pl /fJ
f
G
I Ul (X) l 1¥ dx = PI /fJ.
From this and (9.6) it follows that
I l u I l l M = PI /fJ.
Suppose now that u (x) is an arbitrary function in Lif. Condition (9 . 5) is satisfied for the function UI(X) = u (x) / l lul I 1¥ . Therefore
I l u I I M = P l /fJ
( f I U (X) I 1¥ dXY ''' ·
(9.7)
o
Thus, the Orlicz norm defined in the space Lif differs from the usual norm in the space L1¥ by a constant multiplier.
2. Completeness . THEOREM 9.2. A n Orlicz space is complete. PROOF. Suppose the sequence of functions u n (x ) E Lif ( n = I , 2, . . . ) is convergent in itself, i . e . that lim l I un - uml lM = o .
n, �oo
(9.8)
This means that , for an arbitrary function v(x ) E LM which satisfies
CHAPTER II, § 9
71
the condition p(v ; N) � I , we have lim
n, '17l;-+OO
I l un(x) - um (x) I l v (x) I dx
= o.
G
It follows from the last relation that the sequence u n (x) (n = I , 2, . . . ) converges in measure. Then, it contains a sub sequence un. (x) (k = I , 2, . . . ) which converges almost every where to some function uo(x) . Let e > 0 be an arbitrary prescribed number. In virtue of (9.8) . a k (e) can be found such that for all k, k + P > k (e) , we have
I IUn.+� (x) - un. (x) I l v (x) dx I
<
e
(*)
G
for all v(x) E LN which satisfy the condition p(v ; N) � 1 . Passing to the limit in the inequality ( * ) as p - 00 , we obtain, in virtue of the Fatou theorem, that
I l uo(x) - un. (x) I l v(x) I dx � e
(* *)
G
for all v(x) E LN which satisfy the condition p(v ; N) � 1 . [For Fatou's theorem, see NATANSON [ 1 ] . FATOU'S THEOREM. -
If the sequence of non-negative measurable functions (P1(x) , tp 2 (X) , . . . converges almost everywhere on G to the function tp(x) , then
I tp(x) dx � s�p { I tpn(X) dX} .J G
G
It follows from inequality ( * * ) , firstly, that uo(x) -un. (x) E LM. Consequently, we also have uo(x) E LM ; secondly, it follows from ( * * ) that I l uo - un. I IM � e ,
i.e. that the subsequence un. (k = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges in norm to uo(x) . Since Un. (x) (k 1 , 2, . . . ) is a subsequence of a con vergent-in-itself sequence, the initial sequence u n (x) (n = I , 2, . . . ) also converges to the function uo(x) . * Thus, an Orlicz space is a Banach space. =
CHAPTER I I , § 9
72
3 . Norm of the characteristic function. The characteristic function of the set � C G will be denoted by K(X ; �) . Let v (x) be a function in LN such that p(v ; N) :::;:; 1 . Then, according to the Jensen integral inequality (8.2) , we have that
N
( me� � f V (X) dX) :::;:;
l me s �
f N[v(x)] dx :::;:;
�
me � ,
from which it follows that
f v(x) dx
:::;:; mes
�N- l
( mes1 � ) ,
(9.9)
where N-l (u) is the inverse function of N(v) . For the function vo(x) = N- l ( I /mes �) K (X ; �) , satisfying the condition p(vo ; N) = 1 , we have
f vo(x) dx
=
mes �N- l
�
( me� � ) .
(9. 1 0)
By the definition of the norm, we have that
IIK (X ; �) I I M
=
sup p (v ; M ) ,,;;; l
I f K(X ; �)v(x) dx I I f v(x) dx I '
=
G
=
sup p (v ; N ) ,,;;; l
�
from which, in virtue of (9.9) and (9. 1 0) , we obtain the formula for the norm of the characteristic function :
I I K(X ; �) I I M
=
mes �N-l
( mes1 � ) .
(9. 1 1 )
4. Holder ' s inequality. As we have already remarked, the class LM is contained in the space LM. In this connection, in virtue of (9. 1 ) , for every function u(x) E L M , we have that ' (9. 1 2) lIu l l M = sup I (u, v) 1 :::;:; p(u ; M) + 1 . p (v ; N ) ";;; l
73
CHAPTER II, § 9
N
LEMMA 9. 1 . Let P tu ) be the right-hand derivative of the -function � I . Then the function M(u) . Suppose u(x) E LM and that v (x) = P u x ) J) belongs to LN and � 1. PROOF . We shall first prove that for any function x) E LN
o
l Iu l MN) p{vo;
(l (
v(
if p (v; N) � I , l Ul M j ( x )v( x ) dx � II I I luI Mp (V; N) if p(v; N) I . (9. 1 3) The first inequality in (9 . 1 3) is obvious. To obtain the second, we notice it follows from ( I . I 7) with p (v ; N) I that v (x ] � N[v (x)] N[ p (v; N) p (v ; N) we have
u
>
G
>
)
•
so that we have
I N [ p (v;v (x)N) ] dx ...." p {V ; N) I N[V(X)]dX �
I
=
I.
G
G
Therefore
II u(x) p (vv(;xN) dx I l Iul M. )
�
G
from which the second inequality in (9 . 1 3) follows. Suppose � 1 . We set
I lu l iM
u n(x) =
1
I if l u (x ) I
u(x) if l u(x) � n, o
> n.
Since the functions u n (x) are bounded, we have that P ( l u n (x) J) E LN . We shall assume that the assertion in the lemma is not fulfilled. Then an no can be found such that
I N [P ( l u.... (x) J ) ] dx
> 1.
G
In virtue of (2 . 7) , we have that N [P ( l u n . (x) I ) ]
<
M [un . (x)J +
N [P ( l u n . ( x ) J ) ]
=
Iu n . (x ) P l u n .(x ) J ) .
I(
74
CHAPTER II, § 9
Integrating this inequality and making use of (9 . 1 3) , we obtain that
f N[P(l u n. (x) l ) ] dx < f l un. (x) I P ( l un. (x) l ) dx � G
G
I lun.I IM f N[P(l un.(x) I ) ]dx, which contradicts the inequality I l u n .I I M � I l u l i M � 1 . LEMMA 9 . 2. Suppose I l u l i M is � 1 . Then u(x ) E L M and p (u ; M) � I lu l I M. (9 . 1 4) PROOF . We set vo (x) = P ( l u (x ) I ) sgn u(x). In virtue of Lemma 9. 1 , we have that p (vo ; N) � 1 . Since, in virtue of (2 . 7) , u(x)vo(x) = M[u(x)] + N[vo tx)] , �
G
*
we have that
f M[u(x) ] dx � f M[u(x)]dx f N[vo(x)]dx = +
G
=
G
G
f utx)vo(x) dx � I lu l IM.
*
G
The following important inequality follows directly from this lemma :
U(X) ] dx � 1 . f M [-I lu l iM
( 9. 1 5
)
(9. 1 6
)
G
The inequality I f u(x)v(x) dx I � I lul iM I lv i N holds for any pair of functions u(x) E LM, v(x) E LN. PROOF . In virtue of (9. 1 5 ) , we have that p ( IV�N ; N) = f N [ I�:�� ] dx � 1 . THEOREM 9 . 3 .
G
G
CHAPTER I I , § 9
75
Therefore
I J u(x) G
v I l (x) iiN v
--
from which (9. 1 6) follows. * Inequality (9. 1 6) will be called
dx I ,::;;; l Iu l M,
Holder's inequality. 5. The case ot the LJ 2 -condition . It follows from inequality (9. 1 5) that the Orlicz space LM is the linear hull of the class LM. In this connection, in virtue of Theorem 8 . 2 , LM is a proper subset of LM if the N-function M(u) does not satisfy the LJ 2-condition. In virtue of this same theorem, LM coincides with LM if M(u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. 6. Mean convergence. We say that a sequence of functions un(x) E LM (n 1 , 2, . . ) is mean convergent to the function uo (x) E LM if lim M[un(x) - uotx)Jdx n---+oo J It follows from inequality (9. 1 4) that every sequence un(x) (n 1 , 2, . . . ) which converges in the norm of LM to some function uo(x) is also mean convergent to uo(x) . The converse, generally speaking, is not true. In fact , suppose the N-function M(u ) does not satisfy the LJ 2 -condition. Then there exists a monotonic in definitely increasing sequence of numbers Un such that M(2un) mes2n G M(un) (n 1 , 2, . . ) . In this connection, we can assume that M(U ) 1 . For each n, .we. . shall construct a system of disj oint setsl G�n) C G (k 1 , 2, , n) for which (k 1 2 n) =
.
=
o.
G
=
=
>
.
>
=
and we set
,
J
•
•
. ,
Uk if x E G(n) (k = 1 2 . . . n) , un(x) if x G�n). =
I
o
n
k
E U
k=l
"
,
=
,
76
CHAPTER II, § 9 Then
i .e. lim n--+ oo
f M[un{x)]dx
=
0,
. . . is from which it follows that the sequence = mean convergent to zero . If this sequence were also convergent to zero in norm, then, in virtue of (9. 1 4) , the inequality
!��
a
un(x) (n I, 2, )
f M[2un{x)] dx � !�� 1 2un i lM
0
=
a
would be satisfied whereas, at the same time, we have that
fM[2un(x) ] dx =k�l I M[2un{x)]dx ' k�lM{2Uk)
meas G�n) > 1 .
a ,en)
a
The contradiction thus arrived at shows that the sequence Un{X) (n = I, 2, . . . ) does not converge in norm. THEOREM 9.4. Let the N-function M(u) satisfy the ih-condition Then convergence in norm is equivalent to mean convergence. .
PROOF. In the proof, we need only the fact that mean con vergence implies convergence in norm. . . and Let = = 0,
un(x) E LM LM (n I, ) lim I M[un(x) - uo(x)] dx .
n-> oo
Let
E
= O.
(9 1 7 ) .
> 0 be an arbitrary prescribed number. Assume that a
I j2 k-1 Since the N-function M(u) satisfies the L h-condition, it follows from ( 9. 1 7 ) that ��� I M[2k (un(x) - uo(x))]dx <
E.
= O.
a
77
CHAPTER II, § 9
no be a natural number such that for n no we have f M[2k(un(x) - uo(x))]dx < 1 . Then, in virtue of (9. 1 2) , for n no, we have that [ [ 2k( U n - U O) [ [M � p(2k(un - uo) ; M) + I < 2, from which it follows that [ [ un - U O [[M < I j2k- 1 < Thus the sequence un(x) (n = I , 2, . . . ) converges in to uo(x). �
Let
G
�
e.
*
norm
We note that , in the sense of mean convergence, a set of bounded functions is everywhere dense in the class LM, i.e. for every function E LM we can construct a sequence of bounded functions such that
u(x)
un(x)
lim 1>-+00
J' M[un(x) - u(x)] dx =
G
o.
un(x) can, for example, be defined by the equalities un(x) { u(x) ifif [[ uu ((xx)) [I >� n.n, It follows from inequality (9. 2 ) that every set � of functions,
The functions
=
o
� e L M, which are bounded in the mean, i.e. which satisfy the condition
f M[u(x)]dx a (u(x) E �) , �
G
b (u(x)
b b(a)
will also be bounded in norm, [ [U [ [M � E ��) , where = depends only on the constant a . The converse, generally speaking, is not true simply because of the fact that not every function in LM belongs to LM. However, if the N-function satisfies the L h-condition, then the following assertion is valid : � C LM = LM, In fact , suppose l l [ [ M � a for all E �. Since satisfies the .1 2 condition, there exist constants and Uo such that � for � for all From this Then < +
M(u) every set which is bounded in norm, will also be bounded in the mean. u u(x) M(u) k M(au) kM(u) u Uo. M(au) M(auo) kM(u) u.
CHAPTER I I , § 9
78 inequality and (9 . 1 5) , it follows that
,
J M[u (x)] dx � M(auo) mes G + k J M [ U�) -J dx �
G
G
which was to be proved .
The Luxemburg norm.
� M(auo) mes G + k
=
b(a) ,
LM
7. The set can also be transformed into a Banach space with the aid of norms distinct from the norm introduced above . We shall consider one such norm which was studied in detail in LUXEMBURG [ I ] . Let
I l u l (M)
=
inf k,
(9 . 1 8)
where the infimum is taken over all k > 0 such that P
( : ; M ) J M [ U �) ] dx � I . =
(9. 1 9)
G
It follows from inequality (9. 1 5) that the inequality
(9.20) I l u l (M ) � I l u I M valid for every function u(x) E LM . We note that the infimum is attained in (9. I 8) for those functions u(x) for which I lu l (M) > This follows from inequality (9. I 9) , i n which (in virtue of Fatou's theorem) one can pass to the limit as k which limit tends from the right to I l u l I M . Thus, + the inequality ( u M ) f M [ U (X) ] dx � I (9.2 1 ) I l u ! I (M ) I l u l ! (M ) is
o.
�
00,
;
P
=
G
holds. It is quite easily seen that the equality sign occurs in (9.2 1 ) if the N-function satisfies the L1 2 -condition. But if this condition is not satisfied, then functions can be found such that M) < I . It is also easily seen that the equality
M(u)
p(u/ l u l (M) ;
(9.22) G
always implies that ko
=
I l u l ( M) .
CHAPTER II , § 9
79
I l u l (M )
We shall show that the norm satisfies the- usual axioms . 1 °. Inequality (9. 1 9) is satisfied for arbitrary if, and only if, = 0 if, and only if, = 0 almost everywhere. Therefore, = 0 almost everywhere. = follows from the obvious 2°. The equality relations
k
I l u l (M )
uu((x)x)
I lexu l (M)
=
I lexu l (M) l ex l l ul (M) inf k l ex l inf k l l ex l l u l (M) .
p(<
=
=
3° . The triangle inequality
I l u l + u 2 1 ( M) � I l u l l (M ) + I l u 2 1 ( M) is obvious in the case when the norm of one of the functions U l (X), U2 (X) is zero. If I lul l (M) > 0 and I lu2 1 (M) > 0, then, in virtue of ( 1 .2) , we have M [ I luUl ll((X)M) ++ UI lu2 2(X)1 (M) ] """"" I l ul l (MI lu) l+l (MI lu) 2 1 (M) M [ I luUlll(X)(M) ] l Iu2 1 (M) M [ U2 (X) ] + I lul l (M) + I lu2 1 (M) l Iu2 1 (M) and, in virtue of (9.2 1 ) , f M [ uUl (X) + U2 (X) ] dx � 1 , I l l l (M ) + I l u 2 1 ( M ) �
+
G
from which the triangle inequality does indeed follow . As an example, we shall find of the characteristic function of the set C G. If mes oF 0, then
I KC(X ; C) I (M) C (9 23 ) I K (X ; C) I (M) l ( 1 ) M- mes C inasmuch as ) f M [K(X; C)M-l ( me� C ] dx 1 . THEOREM 9.5. The unit sphere of the space LM with respect to the norm I lul (M) coincides with the set of functions u(x) E LM for which p (u; M) � 1 . Moreover, it follows from I lu l (M) � 1 thta p (u; M) � I lu l (M) and it follows from I lu l (M) > 1 that p(u; M) I lu l (M)· =
.
=
G
�
�
CHAPTER II, § 1 0
80
PROOF. Suppose I l u l l (M) :(; 1 . Then, in virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) and (9. 2 1 ) , we have that
J M [u (x)J dx J M [ I lulu(x)! (M) ] dx
1
I lul l (M)
:(;
G
G
:(; 1 ,
i.e. p (u ; M) :(; I lul l (M) . But if l Iu l l (M) > 1 , then, in virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) , we have that 1
l I u l l (M)
-
e
J M[u(x) J dx J M [ I l u l l u(M)(x) �
G
-
G
e
]
dx > 1
for all sufficiently small e > 0, from which it follows that p(u ; M) � I lu l l (M) inasmuch as e is arbitrary. * We shall show that the norms I l ul i M and I lul l (M) are equivalent : (9.24) We have already proved the first of these inequalities. The second follows from (9. 1 2) and (9.2 1 ) :
I
�
" U M)
1 f M
:(;
G
M
[ I I:I���) ] dx + 1
:(; 2 .
Still another formula for the definition of the Orlicz norm I lu liM follows from Theorem 9.5 :
I l u l iM
=
sup IIvll(N) ';; l
1f G
u (x)v(x) dx
I·
(9.25)
From (9.25) , there follow, in turn, inequalities which it is natural to call strengthened Holder inequalities :
1J
u(x)v(x) dx :(; I lul iM I lvl l (N)
1J
u (x)v(x ) dx :(; I lul l (M) I lv i iN
G
and
G
1
(u (x) E LM, v(x) E LN)
(9.26)
1
(u(x) E LM, v(x) E LN) .
(9.27)
§ 10. The space EM
1 . Definition . We shall denote the closure in LM of the set of bounded functions by EM .
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
81
As we have already noted, the set of bounded functions is everywhere dense in the Orlicz class LM in the sense of mean convergence. It follows from Theorem 9.4 that the set of bounded functions is everywhere dense in the Orlicz space L"M LM provided the Ll 2-condition is satisfied. Thus, if the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll 2-condition, then the spaces EM and L"M coincide. In the case when the N-function M (u) does not satisfy the Ll 2-condition, EM is a proper subset of L"M. This follows from the following inclusion :
=
( 1 0. 1 )
Ul (X) is a bounded function such that I luo - uIllM < !. Then, in We shall now prove this inclusion. Suppose uo (x) E EM and that
virtue of (9. 1 3) ,
f
M[2uo(x) -
2Ul (X)] dx
� 21 1uo - u I l l M
< 1.
-
a
This means that 2uo (x) 2U l (X) E LM . Since bounded functions belong to LM, it follows from the convexity of the set LM that the ![2uo (x) - 2Ul(X)] + ![2U l (X)] also belongs to LM. function uo (x)
=
2. The separability 01 EM. Suppose u (x) is a bounded function : lu(x) I � a. In virtue of Luzin's theorem, a sequence of continuous functions un (X) , l un (x) I � a, can be found such that the difference u (x) - un (x) is different from zero only on a set Gn C G whose measure is less than 1 In. Then, in virtue of formula (9. 1 1 ) , for the norm of the characteristic function we have
11$1
- un l lM
=
su p
p(v ; N ) « l
If a
� 2a sup
p(v ; N ) « l
f
an
=
I
[u (x) - un (x) ] v (x) dx �
2a mes GnN- l
I v (x) I dx
(
= 2a 1 1 K (x ; Gn) 1 1M = ) 2a N -l ' ) ,
1 mes Gn
from which it follows that lim Ilu - un l lM = O.
�
n
(n
n--+oo
r onuex functions
6
82
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
Thus, the '>et ot continuous functions is everywhere dense in the space EM. For every function u (x) , which is continuous on G, we can find a sequence of polynomials with rational coefficients which con verges uniformly to u (x) . It is easily seen that such a sequence also converges to u(x) with respect to the norm of any Orlicz space. Consequently, the countable set of polynomials with rational coefficients is everywhere dense in the space EM. Thus, the space E M is separable. 3. Disposition of the class LM with respect to the space EM. As we have already shown, EM e LM. We shall denote the totality of functions u(x) E L'M for which
d (u, EM)
=
inf I l u - w i lM < r
WEEM
by II(EM ; r) . The closure of II(EM ; r) will be denoted by ll(EM ; r) . The disposition of the class L M with respect to the space EM is sufficiently completely described by the following theorem (see Fig. 7) . o
o
o o
o
o
o
o
o o
o
o
0 o
o
o
0
o o
o
o
EM 0
0
0 0
0 0
0
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0
0
0
0
Fig. 7.
THEOREM 1 0. 1 . Suppose the N-function }\;I(u) does not satisfy the iJ 2 -condition. Then ( 1 0.2) In
this connection, II(EM ; 1 ) is a proper subset of LM and LM is a proper subset of ll(EM ; 1 ) .
CHAPTER II, § 1 0
83
PROOF. We shall first prove that every function uo(x) E EM is contained in LM together with an open spherical neighborhood of radius 1 . This will prove the first inclusion in ( 1 0.2) . Let u (x) E LM and I l u - O I IM < 1 . Then a number ex > 0 can be found such that l I u - uo l l M < 1 - ex . Since the set EM is linear, the function ( l /ex) uolx) is in EM and, in virtue of ( 1 0. 1 ) , we have that ( l /ex) uo(x) E LM. Since I I (u - uo) / ( I - ex ) I IM < 1 , we have, in virtue of (9. 1 4) , that {u (x) - uo (x)}/ ( 1 - ex ) E LM. It follows from the convexity of the set LM that the function
U
u(x)
=
(1
- ex
)
[ U (X )
- uo (x) I - ex
]+
ex
uo (x) ex
also belongs to LM. For the proof of the second inclusion in ( 1 0.2) , we shall show that every function u (x) E LM is at a distance not greater than unity from EM. In virtue of the absolute continuity of the integral, for arbitrary f > 0, a bounded function Ut(x) E EM can be found such that
f M[u(x) - ut(x)] dx < f.
Then, in virtue of inequality (9. 1 2) , I lu - ut l l < 1 + which it follows that G
d(u, EM) = inf l Iu - W I i M � I l u - ut l l < 1 + f .
f,
from
Since f is arbitrary, we have that d(u, EM) � 1 . It remains to prove that the inclusions ( 1 0.2) are proper . In subsection 4 of § 8 we constructed a function u. (x) E LM such that fJu .. (x) E LM for fJ � 1 and fJu (x) E LM for fJ > 1 . We shall show that u .. (x) E II(EM ; 1 ) . In fact, if d(u,. , EM) were less than unity, then a fJ > 1 could be found such that
d(fJu.. , EM) = inf I l fJu,. - W I i M weEM
=
fJ inf l Iu,. - wl l < I .
From this it would follow, in virtue of the first inclusion in ( 1 0.2) , that fJu,. (x) E LM contrary to the basic property of the function u .. (x) . It is thus proved that II (EM ; I ) is a proper subset of LM. In subsection 4 of § 8 we also constructed a function u* (x) E LM ::.uch that fJu* (x) E LM for fJ < 1 and fJu* (x) E LM for fJ � 1 . We
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
84
shall show that u*(x) E l1(EM ; 1 ) . This will complete the proof of the theorem. In fact , d(u*, EM) = 1 since otherwise a (J < 1 could be found such that d({Ju*, EM) > 1 from which it follows, in virtue of the second inclusion in ( 1 0.2) , that (Ju* (x) E L M contrary to the basic property of the function u*(x) . * The second part of the assertion of the theorem signifies that the class L M is neither an open set nor a closed set in the space L'M if the N-function M (u) does not satisfy the L h-condition. We suggest that the reader show in this connection that the set LM is not complete in the sense of mean convergence . The following assertion is implied by Theorem 8. 2 : if the N function M (u) does not satisfy the ,1 2-condition, then the set of bounded functions is nowhere dense in L'M inasmuch as all bounded functions are in E M . The space EM could have been defined as the maximal linear subspace of the space L'M which is contained in L M . This follows from the fact that u(x) E EM only in case AU (X) E L M for all values of A. We shall assume that u(x) E L'M and that
d (u, E M) = inf I l u - w ilM > O. Then the function u(x) can be approximated in the L'M norm by a bounded function to within d(u, EM) + e, where e is an arbitrary positive number. I t is convenient in a number of cases to select the approximating bounded functions in a special way. LEMMA 1 0. 1 . The equality lim I l u - un llM = d(u, EM)
n---> oo
1
holds for an arbitrary funcMan u(x) E L'M, where u(x) if l u (x) I � n, u n (x) = if l u (x) I > n. o PROOF. The functions l u(x) - un(x) I d o not increase a s n � 00 . Therefore their norms d o not increase and have a limit . Clearly, lim l I u - un llM ;;:: d(u, EM) .
n---> oo
It remains to prove the reverse inequality.
CHAPTER II, § 1 0 Let
e
85
be an arbitrary positive number and let
Then
d(rxu, EM)
=
inf
Therefore
I l rxu - w i lM = rx inf I lu - w i lM <
J M[rxu(x )Jdx
<
00 .
G
no can n :;::, no, J M[rxu(x) - rxun(x)Jdx < rxe, i. e. that from which it follows that I l rxu - rxun l M < 1 + I lu - un l M < (l/rx) + e < d(u, EM) + 3e, and, in virtue of the fact that e is arbitrary, that lim I l u - un l i M � d(u, EM) . 4. Necessary conditions for separability of an Orlicz space. As was shown above, the space EM is always separable. This means that the space LM = LM EM is also separable if the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll 2-condition. THEOREM 1 0.2. Suppose the N-function M(u) does not satisfy the Ll 2-condition. Then the space LM is not separable. PROOF. We shall assume that LM is separable and let un(x) (n = 1 , 2, . ) be a countable everywhere dense set in LM. In virtue of Luzin's theorem, a set G1 C G of measure zero can be found on which the functions un(x ) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) are continuous. We consider the space LM(G1) and denote the closure, in LM(G l ) , of the set of functions bounded on G l by E M (G1 ) . Then the functions wn(x) (n 1 , 2, . . . ), which are defined on G1 and coincide on this set with the corresponding functions un(x), belong to EM ( G1 ) . In virtue of Theorem 1 0. 1 , a function w(x) E LM(G1) can be In virtue of the absolute continuity of the integral, an be found such that , for we have
G
rxe,
*
=
.
=
.
CHAPTER II, § 1 0
86 found such that dew, EM(GI) ) > 1 . We set
={
u (x)
Then
=
I l u - u nl l M
sup p (v ; N ) "' l
If If
w(x) if x o
if x
p (v ; N ) "' l
E
GI, G"" GI.
I> I= (n = 1, 2,
[u(x) - u n (x) Jv(x) dx
o
> sup
E
[u (x) - u n (x) J v (x) dx
0,
I lw - wn l l M > 1 .
. . . ) is not dense This means that the sequence u n (x) in the space LM. We have thus arrived at a contradiction. *
the definition of the norm.
5. On
sup p(v ; N ) ", l veEN
If 0
1 :(;
u (x) v (x) dx
If
sup
0
p(v ; N ) ", l
Since EN C LN, we have that u (x) v (x) dx
1=
I l u l IM.
( 1 0.3)
Suppose 8 > 0 is an arbitrary prescribed number. Then a function vo{x) E LN can be found, satisfying the condition p (vo ; N) :(; I , such that
f
o
We set
> I l u I IM - 8.
u (x) vo (x) dx
v n (x)
={
vo (x) if I vo(x) I :(; n,
if Ivo(x) I >
0
n.
Clearly, v n (x) E EN and p (v n ; N) � p (vo ; N) :(; 1 (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . It follows from the absolute continuity of the integral that for sufficiently large
f
o
n,
u (x) v n (x) dx
Consequently, sup p (v ; N ) "' l veEN
If 0
>
f
0
u (x)vo (x) dx -
I f
u (x) v (x) dx >
0
8 > I lul i M - 28.
u(x) v n (x) dx ;;?: I lul iM - 28.
CHAPTER I I , §
10
87
(10.3)
The preceding inequality and yield, in view of the fact that 8 is arbitrary, a new representation for the norm in the space L*
M·
.
I lu l iM
sup
=
p (v ; N ) ';; l veEN
1 f u(x)v(x) dx I · G
(10. 4)
(10.4) u(x) 9.1, of the integrals f u(x)v(x) dx for all v(x) E EN implies that the functions u(x) belong to the space Lif. The modification of the proof of Theorem 9.1 consists in this that the functions vn(x) are selected from EN ; the function g(x) also belongs to EN since the series which defines this function converges in norm and EN is closed . 6. The absolute continuity of the norm. We shall say that the function u(x ) E Lif has an absolutely continuous norm if for every 8 > 0 one can find a c5 > 0 such that I UK (X; t9') I M sup 1 I u(x)v(x)dx 1 < 8 provided mes t9' < c5 (t9' C G ) . THEOREM 10. 3 . function u(x) E Lif has an absolutely continuous norm if, and only if, u(x) E EM. PROOF. Let u(x ) EE M . Suppose 8 > 0 is an arbitrarily prescribed number. We denote by U l (X) a bounded function, I U l (X) I a (x E G) , such that I lu - ulI l M < 8/2. Since the function vN- (1/v) increases monotonically for v 0, the equation c5N- l ( I/c5) 8/(2a) has the unique solution c5 > O. Suppose mes t9' c5 (t9' C G) . Then, in virtue of formula (9. 1 1), we have that I luK (X; t9') I M � I lu - uIl l M + a I K (x; t9') I M ::;:;; 1 ) � ac5N-l (�) 8 ::;:;; � + a mes t9'N - l ( 2 mes t9' 2 c5
We showed that formula defines a norm in an Orlicz space having assumed that E Lk. A line of reasoning, similar to that used in the proof of Theorem shows that the finiteness G
=
p(v ; N ) ';; l
If
A
<
<
�
=
::;:;;
for the norm of the characteristic function.
+
=
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
88
This proves the absolute continuity o f the norm of the function E EM. Now, suppose that the norm of the function E is absolutely continuous. We denote the set I � by Since the function is summable, we have that lim mes "'-
u(x)
u(x) Lif G{ l u (x) n} Gn. u(x) (G Gn) = 0, from which it follows, in virtue of the absolute continuity Thus, u(x), as the of the norm, that lim I l u - UK (X ; Gn) 1 M = n-+oo
O.
n-+oo
limit of a sequence of bounded functions, belongs to EM. * It follows from Theorem 1 0.3 that the space EM can be defined as the totality of all functions having absolutely continuous norm in It also follows from Theorem 1 0.3 that
Lif. all functions in the space LM have absolutely continuous norms if, and only if, the N-function M(u) satisfies the iJ 2-condition. 7 . Calculation of the norm. The usual formula I lul iM = P(V���';; l I J u(x)v(x) dx I G
does not allow us to actually carry out the computation of the norm. In this connection, the problem arises of expressing the norm in other forms. THEOREM 1 0.4. E
Let u(x) Lif and suppose there exists a positive number k* such that ( 1 0.5) J N[P(k* l u (x) I ) ]dx = 1 , where P(u) is the right derivative of the N-function M(u). Then ( 1 0.6) l Iul M = J P(k* l u (x) I ) l u (x) I dx. G
G
PROOF. In virtue of ( 1 0.5) , we have that
J P(k* l u (x) l ) l u (x) l dx
G
�
sup
p(v ; N)';; l
I J u(x)v(x)dx I I lul iM. =
G
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
89
On the other hand, in virtue of Young's inequality,
I lu l iM �k
sup
=
p(v ; N ) ';;; l
I J k*u(x)v(x) dx I �k ( J M[k*u(x)J dX) �
1 +
G
G
and, in virtue of ( 1 0.5) ,
I lu l iM �* ( J N[P(k* l u (x) I ) Jdx + J M[k*U(X)JdX) . �
G
G
Utilizing (2.7 ) , we obtain that
I lu l iM � �* J P(k* l u (x) I ) k* l u (x) 1 dx J P(k* l u (x) I ) l u (x) 1 dx. In seeking the number k*, equation ( 1 0. 5) can, in virtue of *
=
G
G
(2.7) , be written in the form
k* J l u (x) I P(k* l u (x) l ) dx - J M [k*u(x)Jdx G
=
1.
( 1 0.7
)
G
From this it is clear that to calculate the norm, making use of Theorem 1 0.4, one must know only the N-function and its derivative We note that the constant for which equality ( 1 0.5) is fulfilled, cannot always be found. For example, if the function is discontinuous, then it is impossible to find a number even for the characteristic function of the set G if N- l ( l /mes G) does not belong to the set of values of the function On the other hand, if the function has intervals of constancy, then the number is not uniquely defined. If the function is continuous, then the number can be found for any bounded function. This follows from the fact that the function
M(u)
P(u).
k*,
k*
P (u)
k* P(u)
P(u)
P(u).
k*
J ) =
(k J N[P(k l u (x) I ) J dx
J(=)
= =.
is defined for all
k
>
G
0 and it is continuous, with J (O)
=
0,
CHAPTER II, § 1 0
90
Further o n (in § 1 8, subsection 1 0) we shall show that the number k* can be found for any function u(x) E EM provided simply that the function P(u) is continuous. Formula ( 1 0.6) allows us to actually carry out the calculation of the norm with any degree of accuracy. This calculation reduces to the approximate solution of equation ( 1 0.5) with respect to k* and then to the calculation of the integral ( 1 0. 6) . We note that Theorem 1 0. 4 enables us, in the case of a continuous function P (u) , to obtain an already-known formula for the norm of the characteristic function. As an example, we shall compute the norm of the function u (x) = x in the space LM([O, 1 J ) , where M(u) = e l u l - l u i - I . Since, in this case, N[P (u)] = ueU - eU + I , equation ( 1 0.5) has the form
J {k*xek*Z - ek*x 1
o
+
I ) dx = I .
From this we obtain that k* is the positive root of the equation =
ek
2 2-k
.
( 1 0.8)
The value of the norm is determined by formula ( 1 0. 6) :
J (ek*X - I )x dx, 1
I lu l iM
=
o
from which it follows, in virtue of ( 1 0.8) , that
I l u l iM
=
I k*(2
_
I
k*) - 2" .
Equation ( 1 0.8) can be solved approximately (e.g. by a graphical method - as in Fig. 8) . It turns out that k* Po:::i 1 .587 . Thus I l u l i M Po:::i 1 .027. It is convenient to use Theorem 1 0. 4 in the calculation of the norms of bounded functions. We note that for an arbitrary function 1t (X) E LM one can construct a sequence of bounded functions u n (x)
91
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0 such that lim n--> oo
I lu n l M = I lu IM. The functions un (x) can be defined,
for instance, by the equalities
un(x) = 1 0u(x) ifit ll uu ((xx)) I >,,;;; n.n, I
( 1 0.9)
8 7
6 5
4
3
2
k
Fig. 8 .
Let lM ,,;;; can. . . be,,;;; Ifound lu l I M. such I luII I M ";;; I u2 1 M ,,;;; . . . ,,;;; I lu nlvo(x )
In fact , e > 0 be given number. Then a function that N) ,,;;; 1 and
p (vo ;
f l u(x)vo(x) dx > I lu l iM
G
I
-
e.
In virtue of Lebesgue's theorem on passage to the limit under the integral sign, we have that
f l un(x)vo(x) > l IuliM
G
I dx
-
e
n, i.e. lim I lun l M I lu l i M - We now have that lim I / u n l M l Iu l i M inasmuch as is arbitrary. 8 . A nother formula for the norm. Under the conditions of ?
for sufficiently large ?
e
e.
92
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
Theorem 1 0.4, we have that
I lu l iM = � ( I + f M[k*U(X) JdX) . G
On the other hand,
I lu l iM = �k
sup p(v ; N ) � l
I f ku(x)v(x) dx I :'( G
� (I + f M [kU(X)JdX) ( 1 0. 1 0) for arbitrary function u(x) E Livr and any k > O. Therefore, under �
G
the conditions of Theorem 1 0.4, we have that
I lu l iM = min �k (I + f M[kU(X)JdX) . G
k>O
It turns out that this formula can be generalized. THEOREM 1 0.5.
Let M{u) be an arbitrary N-function where u(x i E Livr. Then the formula (lO.I I) I lu l i M = inf �k (I + f M[kU(X1 JdX) is valid. PROOF. We shall first assume that the function P(u) is continuous. k>O
G
Then the norm of every bounded function can be defined by means of formulas ( 1 0.5) and ( 1 0. 6) . It has already been shown that in this case the norm is also defined by formula ( 1 0. 1 1 ) . Suppose the functions Let be an arbitrary function in are defined by formulas ( 1 0.9) and that
lt n(x)
where
u(x)
Livr.
I �t n I M = L ( I + f M[knUn(X)JdX) , G
f N[P(kn l u n(x) I ) J dx I. =
G
( 1 0. 1 2)
CHAPTER I I , § 1 0
93
It follows from the last equality that the In this connection,
kn kn (
1 1 __ < __ 1 +
kn do not increase.
f M[knUn(Xl ]dX) I lun l M I luI M. �
=
G
k*.
kn
Consequently, the sequence conv erges to some positive number Let 0 be a prescribed number. In virtue of ( 1 0. 1 2) , we have
e>
1 +
I M[knun(x)]dx kn l un l M < (k* + e) l Iu l M =
G
for sufficiently large n. Passing to the limit in this inequality (which can be done in virtue of Fatou's theorem) , we obtain that 1 +
f M[k*u(x)]dx I lu I M(k* + e), �
G
e is arbitrary, that �* (I + f M[k*U(X)]dX) � I lu I M.
and, in virtue of the fact that
G
Equality ( 1 0. 1 1 ) follows from this inequality and ( 1 0. 1 0) . We now liberate ourselves from the assumption on the continuity of Whatever the N-function one can easily construct an N-function with continuous derivative such that
P(u).
M(u), Ml (U) M(u) < Ml (U) < M((1 + e)U) (u > 0) .
It follows from these inequalities that Lit
=
( 1 0. 1 3)
Lit , and that
l I ul M � I lu ! IM, � ( I + e) I lu I M.
( 1 0. 1 4)
(A stronger proposition will be proved below in § 1 3, subsections 1 and 2.) It follows from these same inequalities ( 1 0. 1 3) that in f k>O
�k ( I + I M[kU(X)]dX) � inf �k ( I f M 1 [kU(X)]dX) � ' � (I + e) inf � (I + f M[kU(X)]dX) k G
+
k>O
k>O
G
G
CHAPTER I I , § I
94
I
from which it follows, by what has already been proved, that
-I I-- l u I lM, � inf �k ( 1 + J M[kU (X)JdX) I lu I M +
f
�
G
k>O
•.
From these inequalities and ( 1 0. 1 4) , it follows that
k ( I J M [kU(X)J dX) � (I + f) I lul IM. Since f is arbitrary, formula ( 1 0. 1 1 ) is valid for the function u(x). (I
I - l ul M
+ f) 2
__
� inf
k>O
+
�
G
*
§ 1 1 . Compactness criteria
I. Vallee Poussin's theorem.
We recall that a family 9C of functions has equi-absolutely continuous integrals if for arbitrary f > 0 an > 0 can be found such that for all functions in the family 9C we have
J 1
<
f
Iff
provided mes � < A general criterion for the equi-absolute continuity of the integrals of a family of functions is given by the following theorem. VALLEE POUSSIN'S THEOREM (d. , e.g. , NATANSON p. 1 59, American edition) . (0 � < 00)
h.
[I J, Let <1>(u) u be a monotonically increasing function which satisfies the condition . <1>(u) hm -- = oo. u Suppose, for the funciions
[ I
[1 (x) IJ dx A < (
G
'.R
�
00
CHAPTER I I , §
11
95
This straightforward theorem is proved in NATANSON [ 1 ] under somewhat more restrictive hypotheses. Every N-function satisfies the conditions of Vallee Poussin 's theorem. Therefore, if the family of functions � is contained in LM and
M(u)
p(u; M) J M [u(x) ] dx A (u(x) E �) , (1 1. 2) then the functions u(x) have equi-absolutely continuous integrals. Now, let M(u) and M l (U) be two N-functions for which . M(u) = 00. hm Ml (U) Then it follows from (1 1. 2 ) that the family of functions {Ml [U(X)]} has equi-absolutely continuous integrals on G. To prove this, it suffices to note that the function cJ> (u) = M[Ml (u)] satisfies the conditions of Vallee Poussin's theorem inasmuch as (u) lim M [Ml1(u)] lim M(v) 00. lim cJ> Ml (V) U U 2. Steklov functions. Let u(x) be a function which is summable on G. The function ur(x) = _mr1_ f �t(t) dt (x E G) , ( 1 1. 3) where Tr(x) is the n-dimensional sphere with radius r and center at the point x E G and mr is the volume of this sphere, is called a Steklov function. We set the function u(t) in integral (1 1. 3) equal to zero for t G. LEMMA 1 1.1. Suppose given a family of functions � C LM with uniformly bounded norms I lu l iM A , u (x) E �. Then the family �r of Steklov functions ur x), u(x) E �, is compact with respect to the �tniform norm (in the space( C of continuous functions on G) . PROOF. Since f M [ uA(x) ] dx f M [-Iulu(lx)iM ] dx 1 (1 1. 4) =
�
G
u_oo
�1 =
l
=
=
=
u-+oo
u-+oo
u-+ oo
T, (x)
E
�
G
�
G
�
96
CHAPTER I I , § 1 1
for u(x)
E
J U r (x) J
91, we have, in virtue of Young's inequality, that 1
:( __
mr
f J u(t) dt J
T, (x)
f mr
��
G
J u(1L dx :( A A :( - ( 1 + N ( I ) mes G) .
mr
Thus, the functions of the family 91 r are uniformly bounded. It follows from Vallee Poussin's theorem, in virtue of ( 1 1 .4) , that the functions of the family 91 have equi-absolutely continuous integrals, i.e. for given 8 > 0 an h > 0 can be found such that
f J u(xl J dx
( 1 1 .5)
8
for all functions in the family, provided mes Iff < h ( Iff C G) . We denote the set (Tr (x) U Tr (y) ) "'(Tr (x) n Tr (y) ) by Tx , y . Suppose that the volume of Tx , y is less than h for d(x, y) < 6. Then for all functions in the family 91r we have, in virtue of ( 1 1 .5) , that _ J ur (x) - U r (Y ) J � _ mr
f J u(t) J dt < _mB_r
1
Tx, lI
for d(x, y) < 6, from which it follows that the functions of the family 91r are equi-continuous. The assertion of the lemma now follows from Arzela's theorem. We shall use the following inequality in the sequel : ( 1 1 .6) To prove this inequality, we denote the sphere with radius r and center at the zero of the n-dimensional space by To. Then 1
J J UrJ J M :( __ mr
sup p(v ; N ) ";;; l
J
f J u(t)v(x) dtdx J
G T,(x)
mr
sup p(v ; N ) ";;; l
Interchanging the order of integration
=
f f J u(x
G
III
+ s) v(xl J ds dx.
T.
the last integral and
CHAPTER I I , § I I
97
bringing the supremum sign under the integral sign, we obtain that
I l url lM
:(
_1m_r f [
sup p(v ; N ) ';; l
+
]
S)V (X) l dX ds
G
T.
and, since u (t)
f l u(x
=
=
I l u (x
+
s) i l M ,
0 for t E G, we have
I l u (x + s) I I M = sup
p(v ; N ) ';; l
:(
f l u (x
G
+
sup p(v ; N ) ';; l
s) v (x) I dx �
f I U(t)V(t - S) l dt :( lluI IM. (1 1.7)
G
This completes the proof of inequality
(1 1.6).
3. A . N. Kolmogorov ' s compactness criterion for the space EM. THEOREM A family in of functions of the space EM is compact
1 1.1 .
if, and only if, the following conditions are satisfied : a) I l u l I M :( A , u(x) E in ; b) for arbitrary e > 0, a t5 > 0 can be found such that the con dition r < t5 implies that I l u - Urll M < e for all functions of the family in.
PROOF. The sufficiency of conditions a) and b) follows directly from Lemma and Frechet 's theorem since a set of functions which is compact in C is also compact in every Orlicz space. [FRECHET'S THEOREM : A set is compact if it can be approximated
1 1.1
arbitrarily closely by a compact set.]
Suppose in is a compact family of functions in EM. Then one can construct, for this family, an (e/3) -net consisting of continuous functions u(1) (x) , U( 2) (x) , . . . , u( n) (x) . The functions u(i ) (x) (i 1 , 2, . . . , n) may or may not belong to the family in. We denote by c the norm of the characteristic function K (X ; G) of the entire set G. Let r > 0 be a number such that for d(x, t) < r we have I U(i) (X) - U(i ) (t) I < e/ (3 c) (i = 1 , 2, . . . , n) . Then =
I U(ir ) (x) - u(i) (x) I
:(
_m1_r f l u(i) (t) - u(i) (x) I dt :( �e
3c
Co,wez JuncHons
(i = I 2 · · · , n) "
7
CHAPTER 11, § 1 1
98 and
( 1 1 .8) Suppose u (x) is an arbitrary function in in. A function u(io ) (x) can be found such that Il u - u(io ) I IM < 8/3. Then in virtue of ( 1 1 . 6) and ( 1 1 .8) , we have that
I l u - u rl lM � I l u - u(io ) I I M + I l u(io ) - u�io ) I I M + I l u�io ) - urll M � � 2 1 1 u - u( io) I I M + I l u( io ) - u�io) I I M < 8. The necessity of condition b) is thus proved. The necessity of condition a) is obvious. * In the case when the N-function M (u) satisfies the L1 2-condition, EM L M LM. Therefore, in the case when the L1 2-condition is satisfied, Theorem 1 1 . 1 yields a necessary and sufficient criterion for the compactness of a family of functions in LM. Since, in this case, convergence in norm is equivalent to mean convergence, the following theorem is valid. THEOREM 1 1 .2. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the .1 2=
=
condition. A necessary and sufficient condition that a family of functions in C LM LM be compact is that the followinR two con ditions be satisfied : =
a)
f M[u(x)] dx �
G
A,
u (x)
E
in ;
b) for arbitrary 8 > 0, a b > 0 can be found such that
f M[u(x) - ur (x)] dx < 8
G
for all functions in the family in, provided r < b. 4. A second criterion for compactness. We shall say that the family in of functions u(x) E LM have equi-absolutely continuous norms if for every 8 > 0 a b > 0 can be found such that I l u K (X ; 6") 11 M < 8 for all functions of the family in provided mes Iff < b. Clearly, in this case we have that in C EM . If in is a compact set in EM, then it can be shown, by means
of usual reasoning, that it has equi-absolutely continuous norms .
CHAPTER II, § 1 1 LEMMA 1 1 .2. A necessary and sufficient condition that a sequence of functions u n (x) E EM (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) , which converges in measure, converge in norm is that it have equi-absolutely continuous norms .
PROOF. The necessity of the condition follows from the fact that a convergent sequence is compact. We shall prove the sufficiency of the condition of the lemma . Suppose the 'sequence un(x) E EM ( n = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges in measure and has equi-absolutely continuous norms. Let I> > 0 be prescribed. We denote by tffm n the sets G{lu n (x) - um (X) I > 17}, where 17 = 1>/{3 mes GN l ( l /mes Gn. Let b > 0 be a number such that -
provided mes tff < b. Since the sequence u n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . ) converges in measure, an n o can be found such that mes tffmn < t5 for n, m > no . Then, for n, m > n o , we have that .
lI u n - umllM :( :( I I (u n - Um) K(X ; tffm n) I IM
+
I I (u n - Um) K (X ; G/tffm n ) I I M ::(
:( I I UmK(X ; tffm n ) 11 M + Il umK (X ; tffm n) I I M + 17 I I K(X ; G) I I M <
8.
This means that the sequence u n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges in LM. * THEOREM 1 1 .3. If the family in C EM has equi-absolutely con-
tinuous norms and is compact in the sense of convergence in measure, then the family in is compact in Lif.
PROOF. From each sequence of the family in we can select a subsequence which converges in measure. In virtue of Lemma 1 1 . 2, this subsequence converges with respect to the norm in Lif. * Verification of the second condition of the theorem on compact ness in the sense of convergence in measure usually reduces t o the proof o f the fact that the family in i s compact i n some Orlicz space which is distinct from Lif.
S. F. Riesz ' s criterion for compactness for the spaces EM. We shall give one more criterion for compactness of a family of functions in EM.
1 00
CHAPTER II, § 1 1
THEOREM 1 1 . 4. A family in of functions in the space EM is
compact if, and only if, the following two conditions are satisfied : a) I l u l i M � A , u (x) E in ; b) for arbitrary e > 0, a b > 0 can be found such that d(h, 0) < b implies that I l u(x + h) - u(x) I IM < e for all u(x) E in. PROOF. Suppose u (x) E in and that ur (x) is the corresponding
Steklov function. Then
1
l u(x) - ur (x) I � __ mr
J l u(x) - u(t) I dt,
from which it follows, for v (x) E LN , p(v ; N) � 1 , that
J l ur (x) - u(x) I v(x) dx
T,(x)
�r J [ J l u(t) - u(x) I dt] v(x) dx.
�
G
G
T,(x)
Interchanging the order of integration and making a change in variables, we obtain that
J l u (x) - ur (x) I v (x) dx
G
�
�
�r J [ J l u(x + s) - U(X) I V(X) dX] ds � To
1 � __
mr
G
J I lu(x + s) - u(x) I IM ds,
To
from which it follows that
Il u - u rl l M
=
sup p (v ; N ) � l
I J [u(x) - ur (x)] v (x) dx I J I lu(x + s) - u(x) I IM ds. � mr �
G
1 __
To
It follows from the last inequality that condition b) of Theorem 1 1 . 1 is satisfied provided condition b) of the present theorem is satisfied. Conditions a) of these theorems coincide. This completes the proof of the sufficiency of the conditions of the theorem.
CHAPTER II, § 1 2
101
We shall now prove the necessity of these conditions . Suppose 9'l is a compact family of functions in EM . Then, for this family, we can construct an (e/3) -net consisting of continuous functions u( I) (X) , U( 2) (X) , " ' , u( n ) (x) . We denote by c the norm of the charac teristic function of the entire set G in the space L!f . Let 15 > ° be a number such that
lu(i) (x + h) - U (i ) (x) I
<
e
-
3c
(i = 1 2 " ' , n) "
provided d(h, 0) < 15. It is then clear that e l I u(i ) (x + h) - u(i) (x) I IM � 3"
(i
=
1 , 2, " ' , n) .
( 1 1 . 9)
Let u(x) be an arbitrary function in 9'l . A U( io)(X) can be found such that I l u - u (io)II M < e/3. Then, in virtue of ( 1 1 . 9) and ( 1 1 . 7) , we have that
I l u(x + h) - u(x) I I M � I l u(x + h) - u(io)(X + h) I IM
+
+ I l u( io)(X + h) - u(io)(x) I IM + I l u(io)(X) - u(x) I I M
<
e.
The necessity of condition b) is thus proved. The necessity of condition a) is manifest . * § 12. Existence of a basis
1 . Transition to the space of functions defined on a closed interval .
Below, we shall consider Orlicz spaces of functions defined on a finite segment . This will not disturb the generality of the results . This follows from the fact that the space L!f(G) is linearly isometric to the space L!f([O, mes G] ) , i. e . there exists a linear one-to-one correspondence between the elements of the spaces L!f([O, mes G] ) and L!f (G) , under which norms are preserved. For the sake of simplicity of exposition, we shall show this here for the case when G is a bounded closed set situated in the plane with the cartesian coordinate system (GI, G2 ) . We enclose the set G in a square Bo : I GI I � b, I G 2 1 � b . We consider the sequence Tn of subdivisions of the square Bo into 4 n
CHAPTER I I , § 1 2
1 02 squares
B!
(k
=
I , 2, . . " 4 n ) by means of the straight lines
b . b . 1.0 1 t an d 0 2 = -81 = -1 n n 2 -1 2 -
(i, j
=
0, ± I , ± 2, " ' , ± 2 n - l ) .
I n the transition from the subdivision Tn t o the subdivision T n+ l , clearly, every square in the subdivision Tn subdivides into four equal squares in the subdivision T n+l (Fig. 9) . We shall construct a mapping of the set of squares of all sub divisions onto the totality of certain segments - subsegments of the segment 10 = [0, mes G] , in which the length of the segment I! - the image of the square B! - equals mes (G (\ B!) . Suppose the entire segment 10 corresponds to the square Bo. Let the segment [or;, P] C 10 correspond to some square B! in the subdivision Tn.
8, 2
822
82'
82
824
J
] 8I
2 8 ] 8 ]' 8 1] 8 ]4
Fig. 9.
We enumerate the four squares in the subdivision T n+ l which comprise B� as the quadrants are numbered in analytic geometry and we denote them by BI, BlI, BIll, BIV. The segment [or;, P] is sub divided by means of the points Y l. Y2 , ya , where or; � Y l � Y2 � ya � p, into four parts such that Y l - or; ya - Y2
BI ) , Y2 - Y l = mes (G (\ BlI ) , = mes (G (\ BIll) , P - ya = mes (G (\ BIV) . =
mes (G
(\
We correspond the segments [or;, rr] , [Y l, Y2] , [Y2 , ya] and [Y2 , with the squares BI, BlI, BIll and BIV, respectively.
PJ
1 03
CHAPTER I I , § 1 2
peG
Q
Gl
G
To every set we assign the set C 10 of points defined by the systems of contracting segments which correspond to systems of squares (i .e. subdivisions Tn) , which contract to the points of the set P. Under this mapping, the measure of sets is preserved (this becomes clear if we note that the image of the totality of all sides of the squares of all subdivisions Tn has measure zero) . the set of points x E any neighborhood of If we denote by which contains a part of positive measure of the set and which does not lie on the sides of the squares in the subdivision Tn, then mes = mes and the mapping a, constructed above, of the set onto the segment 10 will be one-to-one on The image of the set will be denoted by Since the functions belonging to an Orlicz space are defined to within a set of measure zero, we can assume that all of them are equal to zero on We correspond to each function the function u(t) , t E l 0, defined by u(x) E
G Gl
G
G,
Gl
Gl .
Ql.
G"'-.Gl .
LM(G)
_
u(t)
=
(U(X) °
for t
=
for t E
a(x ) E
Ql.
Ql,
This correspondence is manifestly linear. Inasmuch as the measure of sets is preserved under the mapping a, the functions in are mapped, with preservation of norm, into functions in the space mes It is also clear that the space maps, under this mapping, into the space mes
LM(G)
LM([O, GJ). 2.
E (G) EM ([O, GJ). M
Haar functions. The functions defined on the segment [0, 1 J by means o f the following formulas are called H aar functions :
2, ,/2n for - ,/2n for
and, further, for n
X�) (x)
=
=
°
1,
for ° :( x < l, for x = t, for t < x :( 1
k 1 , 2, . . . , 2 n, 2k n- 2 :( x < 2k n- 1 , 2 +1 2 +1 2k n- 1 < x 2kn ' 2 +1 "" 2 +l =
& ---
for the remaining values of x.
CHAPTER I I , § 1 2
1 04
We write the Haar functions X�k) (X) as a sequence in the order of increasing n, and for given n in the order of increasing k . The sequence thus obtained is denoted by lPi (X) (i = 1 , 2, . . . ) . This sequence of functions, as is easily seen, is orthogonal :
f lPi (X)lPi (x) dx 1
o
=
(jtj
=
!
0 if i =F j, . , . 1 If Z = J .
Since all Haar functions are bounded, the Fourier coefficients
f U(X) lPi (X) dx
( 1 2. 1 )
1
Ci
=
(i
o
=
1 , 2,
•
.
.
)
are defined for every summable function u(x) . We denote the operators Sm by means of the equality
Smu(x)
=
m
�
i= 1
(m
Ci lPi (X)
=
1 , 2,
•
•
.
).
We denote the points of discontinuity of the functions IP I (X) , 1P 2 (X) , " ' , IPm (x) to which the points 0 and 1 are added by a I , a2, " ' , a p arranged in increasing order. LEMMA 1 2. 1 . For as < x < asH, the value of the piecewise
constant function Smu(x) is defined by the equality Smu(x)
=
f u(x) dx. a. + 1
1
as + l - as
a,
PROOF. It follows directly from the definition of Haar functions that the function m
i= l
assumes, for as < x < asH, the following values :
Fm (x, y)
=
I
1
asH - as o
. If a s if y
< <
y < asH, as or asH < y
( this is verified most easily by induction on
m) .
Therefore, for
1 05
CHAPTER II, § 1 2 as <
x
Smu(x)
< aBH , =
we have that
i�l CPi (X) f U(Y) CPi (Y) dy f u(y)Fm (x, y) dy 1
1
=
0
o
=
3.
1 aB+l - as
=
f u(y) dy.
*
a.
B a sis in
EM. Let M(u) and N(v) be mutually comple
mentary N-functions. Suppose u(x) belongs to the space L M([ O, I J ) . From the Jensen integral inequality and Lemma 1 2. 1 , it follows that
M[Smu(x)J
=
M
[
1 as+l - as
f U(X) dX] �
a.
� for every
m
and
as
x<
<
as H ,
f M[u(x)J dx a.+l
---
as+ l - as
a,
which implies that
f M[Smu(x)J dx � f M[u(x)J dx a. + !
a,+1
and
a,
a,
I M[Smu(x)J dx � I M[u (x)J dx. 1
1
( 1 2.2)
0
o
If lI u llM � I , then, in virtue of (9. 1 3) , we have that
I M[u(x)J dx 1
o
� 1.
It therefore follows from inequalities ( 1 2.2) and (9 . 1 2) that
I M[Smu(x)J dx � 1 + I M[u(x)] dx � 2 1
1
I I Smu l lM � 1 +
o
0
CHAPTER II, § 1 2
1 06 for I l u l iM � 1 . Consequently,
I I Sml 1
=
(m
sup I I Smu l l M � 2
l IullM ';;; l
=
1 , 2, . . . ) .
Thus, the norms of the linear operators Sm , acting in the space LM ( [O , I J ) , are uniformly bounded . Now suppose the function u(x) is continuous. In virtue of Lemma 1 2. 1 , the sequence Smu(x) converges to u (x ) uniformly on the segment [0, I J if one discards from it the denumerable number of points of discontinuity of all Haar functions. Therefore the functions Smu (x ) also converge in norm to u (x) in any Orlicz space. So, the sequence of operators Sm ( m 1 , 2, . . . ) has uniformly bounded norms and converges strongly to the identity operator on a set of continuous functions which is dense in EM ([O, I J ) . In virtue of the known Banach-Steinhaus theorem, the operators Sm converge to the identity operator on all of E M ([O, I J ) . This means that the series =
00
( 1 2.3)
where the Ct are defined by equality ( 1 2. 1 ) , converges in LM to
u (x) for arbitrary function u(x) E EM ([O, I J ) . Thus the Haar functions 'Pi (x) (i 1 , 2 , . . . ) form a basis in EM ( [O, I J ) . I t is clear that the functions 'Pt (x /mes G ) (i = 1 , 2 , . . . ) , defined on the segment [0, mes GJ , form a basis in EM ([O, mes GJ ) . This fact =
and the line of reasoning followed in the first subsection of this section lead to the following assertion. THEOREM 1 2. 1 . A basis exists in the space EM (G) . It follows from this theorem that a basis exists for the entire space LM if the N-function M(u) satisfies the L1 2-condition inasmuch as EM = LM in this case. The Fourier coefficients ( 1 2. 1 ) are defined for all functions u (x) E LM ( [O, I J ) and not only for functions in EM ([O, I J ) . For those functions u (x) E LM ( [ O , I J ) for which series ( 1 2.3) converges, one could have defined an operator P by setting Pu(x)
=
00
� Ci'Pi (X) .
i�l
The operator P would b e an operator o f proj ection o n EM. It turns out that the set LM "'-E M contains no functions for which series ( 1 2.3) converges in LM-. In fact , suppose series ( 1 2.3) converges
1 07
CHAPTER II, § 1 2 for some function u(x) . We then set
g(x)
=
u(x) -
00
�
i� l
C i (j?t(X) .
All Fourier coefficients ( 1 2 . 1 ) for the function g(x) are equal to zero. In virtue of Theorem 1 2 . 1 , every function u(x) E EN([O, I J ) can be represented in the form of a series, v(x)
=
00
�
i=l
di (j?i (X) , which
converges i n LN([O, I J ) . This enables us to compute the norm of the function g(x) : in virtue of ( 1 0 . 4) , we have that
I f g(x)v(x) dx I
I l g i lM
=
sup
p(v ; N ) ';; l 0 v EEN
This means that g(x)
=
I � dt f g(x) (j?i (x) dx I 1
1
=
° and
sup p(v ; N ) ';; l vEEN
0
i�l
=
0.
u(x) E EM ([O, I J ) .
4 . Further remarks on the conditions lor separability . It was shown in the preceding section that the space Lid is not separable if the N-function M(u) does not satisfy the L1 2 -condition. This same
fact can be proved by effectively demonstrating a continuous totality of functions in the space Lid the mutual distances between which is greater than some fixed number. The reasoning of the first subsection permits us to limit ourselves to the construction of such a set in the space Lid( [O, I J ) . Suppose the N-function M(u) does not satisfy the L1 2-condition ; then a sequence of positive numbers Ul < U2 < . . . < Un < . . -+ = can be found such that M(2u) > 2 nM(u n ) (n 1 , 2, . . . ) . We construct on [0, 1 ) a sequence of disj oint segments t5n arranged in order of increasing indices - from left to right - whose lengths are determined by the equalities .
=
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . ) . 00
Such a construction is possible inasmuch as � mes t5 n < 1 . Suppose, n� l
00
furthermore, that unity is a limit point of U t5 n . n�l
1 08
j
CHAPTER II, § 1 2
We define a function u (x) on [0, I J by setting u (x) =
(n = 1 , 2, . . . ) ,
2Un for X E l5n o
.
00
for x E U I5 n. n= l
The function u (x) belongs t o LAt since !u (x) E L M :
J M[lu(x) J dx = } J M[lu (x)J dx n� M(un) mes I5 n 1
l
o
Suppose, for all 0 by the equality /Pl¥(X)
<
=
{
=
�
l
<
00 .
IX � I , that the functions /Pl¥ (X) are defined
u (x + 1 - IX ) for 0 � x � IX, u (x - IX ) for IX < X � 1 .
All these functions belong to LAt. We consider two functions /Pl¥(X) and /pfJ(X) , where IX < p. By construction, the function /PfJ(x) is bounded on the segment [0, IX] . Suppose l /pfJ(x) I = /pfJ(x) � A (0 � x � IX ) . Then a positive number 'YJ < IX can be found such that ( 1 2.4)
where Kl1(X) is the characteristic function of the segment [ IX - 'YJ, IX] . In fact , in virtue of formula (9. 1 1 ) , we have I I /pfJKl1 I IM � A l l Kl1 l lM = A 'YJN-1
(+)
<
!
for the norm of the characteristic function, for sufficiently small 'YJ. We shall estimate the norm of the function /Pl¥(X) Kl1 (X) from below. Clearly, this norm is equal to the norm of the function U(X) �l1 (X) , where �l1 (X) is the characteristic function of the segment [ 1 - 'YJ, I J . We consider the sets Fn = [ 1 - 'YJ, I J n ( U l5i ) n
i= l
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . ) .
The characteristic functions of these sets will be denoted by Kn(X) (n = I , 2, . . . ) . The function u (x) is bounded on each of the sets F n so that the functions vn (x) = P[u(X) Kn (X)] (n = 1 , 2, . . . )
1 09
CHAPTER I I , § 1 2
are also bounded and, a fortiori, belong to the class LN . In virtue of (2.7) , we have that
f
1
o
f M[u (x)] dx + f N[vn (x)] dx.
U(X) v n (x) dx =
1
F"
0
We shall show that
f
1
lim n->-oo
N[vn(x)] dx > 1 .
( 1 2.5)
o
In fact , if the inequality
f N [vn(x) ] dx � 1 1
o
were true for all n (n = 1 , 2, ) then the function U (X) l
.
.
,
f M[U(X) l
.
o
+
f
F"
N[ V n (X)] dX =
}
F"
�
sup p(v ; N )';;;; 1
f
1
o
f u (X) Vn (X) dx � 1
n ��t . .
0
U (X) v (X) dx = I l u l i M < 00,
which is a contradiction because
f M[U(X) l
1
=
o
0
f
M[u (x) ] dx =
1 - '1
-
0
1 10
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
In virtue of ( 1 2.5) , an
no
can be found such that
J N[vn.(x)] dx 1
= p
o
> I.
Then, in virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) , we have that
J N [ Vn�X) ] dx � I . 1
o
Thus, the following estimate is valid for II U I<1/ IIM :
I I U I<1jI l M
=
sup p(v ; N ) ";; l
=
J U (X)I<1j (X)V(X) dx 1
o
� 1
J U(X)I<1j(X) Vno (Xl dx 1
P
0
+ { J M[u(x)] dx + f N[Vn.(X)] dX} > 0
F"o
1.
=
( 1 2.6)
From this inequality and ( 1 2. 4) , it follows that
> 1 Thus, the functions !P£¥ (x) (0 < than t from one another.
oc
-
t
=
t·
� 1 ) are at a distance greater
§ 13. Spaces determined by distinct N-functions
1 . Comparison of spaces. Generally speaking, distinct N functions determine distinct Orlicz spaces. For example, the spaces L £¥ determined by the N-functions M (u) l u l £¥/oc are distinct for distinct oc > 1 . THEOREM 1 3. 1 . Let M l (U) and M 2 (U) be two N-functions. A necessary and sufficient condition that LM, be e LM, is that the relation M 2 (u) -< M 1 ( u) be satisfied, i.e. that there exist constants uo, k > 0 such that =
( 1 3. 1 )
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
111
PROOF. Let us assume that condition ( 1 3. 1 ) is not satisfied . Then an indefinitely increasing monotonic sequence of numbers Un (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) can be found such that M2 (un) > Ml (2 nnun) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . ( 1 3.2) In virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) , Ml (nUn) / (nun) � M l (2 nnun) / (2 nnun) , from which it follows that M l (2 nnun) � 2 nMl (nUn) . Combining the last inequality with ( 1 3.2) , we obtain that ( 1 3.3) Suppose Gl, G2,
•
•
•
are disj oint subsets of the set G for which (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . 00
Such sets can be constructed inasmuch as � mes Gn < mes G. n= l Now we consider the function u (x) defined by the equality u (x) =
l
(n = 1 , 2, . . . )
nun for x E Gn o
,
00
for x E U Gn. n= l
This function belongs to the space LAt , inasmuch as
J Ml[u(x)J dx = n�l J Ml[U(X) J dX · =n�lMl (nUn) mes Gn =
G
Gn
00 1 = M(Ul) mes G � n < 00. 2 n= l -
This function does not, however, belong to the space LAt . since, for all A � 1 , the functions ( I /A) u (x) do not belong to L M• • In fact, suppose m is an integer greater than A. Then, in virtue of ( 1 3.3) , we have that
00
� � 2 nMl (nun) mes Gn n=m
=
00.
CHAPTER II, § 1 3
1 12
This proves the necessity of condition ( 1 3. 1 ) . We shall now prove the sufficiency of this condition. Suppose condition ( 1 3. 1 ) is satisfied. Then the function u(x) belongs to the space LM,. This means that for some f-t > 0, f-tu(x) E LM" i.e. that
f M [,uu (x) ] dx <
G
1
We denote the set G{ l u (x) I ( 1 3. 1 ) , we have that
G
<
00 .
kuo/f-t} by Go . Then, in virtue of
G�Go
G.
:::;; M 2 (UO) mes Go
+
f Ml[,uU(x)] dx <
G
00.
This means that (f-t/k)u (x) E LM. from which it follows that
u (x) E LM •.
*
Let us recall that the N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (U) are said to be equivalent , Ml (U) '" M 2 (u) , if Ml(U) -< M 2 (U) and M 2 (u) -< -< M 1 (u) , i.e. if there exist positive constants k l ' k 2 and Uo such that Theorem 1 3. 1 implies the next theorem. THEOREM 1 3 .2. The spaces LM, and LM• consist of the same
functions if, and only if, the N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (u) are equivalent. This theorem is the basis for the introduction of the concept of equivalent N-functions . 2. A n inequality for norms. THEOREM 1 3.3. If LM, e LM., then there exists a constant q > 0
such that
( 1 3.5) PROOF. In virtue of Theorems 1 3. 1 and 3. 1 , LN. C LN, in which connection positive numbers k and vo can be found such that
1 13
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3 Nl (VJk) .:::;; N2 (V) , v � Vo. Then, for all v, we have that Nl Now suppose v (x) ( 1 3. 6) , we have that p
( � ) .:::;; Nl ( :0 ) + N2(V) . E
LN and p (v ; N 2) .:::;; 1 . Then, in virtue of
(� ) f [ r J f ; Nl =
G
Nl
( 1 3 . 6)
V )
+
G
dX ':::;; N l
(: ) O
mes G +
N2 [v (x)J dx .:::;; Nl
( � ) mes G + 1 = a.
We set q = ak. Then, in virtue of the last inequality and ( 1 . 1 7) , we have that p
(q ; ) f [ V
Nl =
G
]
1 v (x) Nl -;;k dx .:::;; --;;
f [
G
v (x) Nl -k
Relation ( 1 3.5) follows from the inequalities
I l u lI M. = sup
p(v ; N. ) ';;; l
1f
u (x) v (x) dx
G
.:::;; q
1
=
sup
q
p(v ; N. ) ';;; l
sup p(v ; N ) ';;; l
If G
1f
u (x)
G
u (x) w (x) dx
] dx .:::;; 1 .
I .:::;; I = l l l lM, *
V (x) q
dx
q u
.
It is easily seen that inequality ( 1 3.5) is satisfied with the constant q = 1 : I l u I I M. ':::;; I l u l I M" u (x) E L!t" if the inequality M2 (U) .:::;; Ml (U) is satisfied for all u . From Theorem 1 3.3, it follows, in particular, that the norms generated by equivalent N-functions Ml (U) and M2 (U) are equivalent : ( 1 3.7)
In the solution of many problems, one can therefore choose from the class of equivalent N-functions that one which, in virtue of any considerations, is the most convenient . Convex
I unctions
8
1 14
CHAPTER II, § 1 3
Let M(¥(u)
=
M(ocu) , oc > 0. Clearly M(¥(u) ,...., M(u) . The equality ( 1 3.8)
holds, for the proof of which it suffices to note that N(¥ (v) and
I l u l IM� = sup
p(v ; N � ) <;; l
I f u(x)v (x) dx I G
=
oc
=
sup
N
(:)
I f u(x)v(x) dx I v(x) dx I oc l l u l lM . I f u(x) -oc
sup
p(V/" ; N ) <;; l
p(V/" ; N ) <;; 1
=
G
=
=
G
3. Concerning a criterion for convergence in norm. We shall say that the N-fundion Ml(U) increases essentially more rapidly than the N-function M(u) if, for arbitrary A > 0, lim u---.. oo
M( AU) M 1 (u)
=
0.
( 1 3.9)
For example, the function l u l (¥ increases essentially more rapidly than the functions l u l P if oc > (3. It is also easily seen that the composition Ml (U) = M[Q (u)] of two N-fundions M(u) and Q(u) increases essentially more rapidly than the N-fundion M (u) . It is not difficult to see that M l (U) increases essentially more rapidly than M (u) i f , and only if, for every s > 0, M(u) < Ml(Sl�) for large values of the argument . LEMMA 1 3. 1 . If M 1 (u) increases essentially more rapidly than M(u) , then N(v) increases essentially more rapidly than N 1 (v) , where N (v) and N 1 (v) are functions complementary to the functions M ( u ) and M 1 (u) , respectively. PROOF. Let an arbitrarily small s > ° and any ft be prescribed. In virtue of ( 1 3 . 9) , the inequality M(l�/S) � M 1 (u/ft) is satisfied for large values of u. In virtue of Theorem 2. 1 and (2.5) , the inequality N1 (ftv) � N (sv) is satisfied for the complementary functions for larg e values of v, from which it follows, III virtue of ( 1 . 1 7) , that N l (ft V ) � sN(v) . This means that N 1 (ft V ) lim O. * ( 1 3 . 1 0) N (v) v---.. oo =
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
1 15
If Ml (U) increases essentially more rapidly than M(u) , then the inclusion ( 1 3. 1 1 ) holds. Since EM is the maximal linear subset of the class L M and LJ.t, is the linear hull of the class LM" it will suffice to show that , for arbitrary Il, the function Ilu(x) belongs to LM, if u(x) E LM,. The last assertion follows from the fact that, in virtue of ( 1 3. 9) . M(llu) � Ml (U) for large values of u . LEMMA 1 3.2. Suppose the N-function M1 (u) increases essentially
more rapidly than the N-function M (u) . Suppose also that the family of functions in is uniformly bounded in the space LJ.t, : I lu l lM , � a, u(x) E in. Then the family has equi-absolutely continuous norms in LJ.t. PROOF. Let e > 0 be an arbitrarily small prescribed number . We set ft = 2aj e. In virtue of ( 1 3. 1 0) and the de la Vallee Poussin theorem (see § 1 1 , subsection 1 ) , the functions N1[ftv(x) ] , where p(v ; N) � 1 , have equi-absolutely continuous integrals, i. e. a 15 > 0 can be found such that for all functions v (x) E LN, which satisfy the condition p (v ; N) � 1 , we have that
f N1[ftv(x)] dx
8
<
;
,
provided mes C < 15 (C C G) . Let u(x) E in and v(x) E L N, p(v ; N) � 1 . It then follows from Young's inequality that
I f u(x) v(x) dx I 8
�
f M1 [ U�) ] dx f N [ftV(X)] dx � +
8
8
1
� for mes C < 15 , which implies that
I l u K (X ; 6") I I M =
sup p(V ; N ) < l
I f u(x) v (x) dx I &
I : 1 M, �
+
e
for all functions u(x) E in provided mes C < 15 (C C G) . * The converse assertion also holds.
;<
e
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
1 16
LEMMA 1 3.3. Let M(u) -< Ml (U) . Suppose every set of functions bounded in Lid, has equi-absolutely continuous norms in Li.t. Then the N-function Ml (U) increases essentially more rapidly than M(u) . PROOF. Let us assume that M l (U) does not increase essentially more rapidly than M(u) . Then, in virtue of Lemma 1 3. 1 , the N function N(v) , complementary to the function M(u) , does not
increase essentially more rapidly than the complementary function N 1 (v) to Ml (U) . This means that an eo > 0 and a sequence of num bers Vn � 00 can be found such that N1 {v n) > N(eov n ) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . It follows from these inequalities that the inequalities =
( 1 3. 1 2) are valid for the numbers Wn = N1 (vn) . We shall denote by G n (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) those subsets of G for which mes G n = 1 JWn . Let
un (x)
=
I
Wn . If x E G n, 1 Nl (w n) o if x E G n.
Clearly, I l u nl lM, = 1 . Since mes G n
�
0, the relation lim Il u nl lM
=
0
n-+oo
must be satisfied in virtue of the condition of the lemma. This contradicts the following inequality, which is implied by ( 1 3. 1 2) :
N- l ( Wn ) Wn Gn) = ; K(X I IM I l u n l lM = I I Nl l (wn) Nl l (wn)
> eo ·
*
THEOREM 1 3.4 . Suppose the N-function Ml (U) increases essentially more rapidly than the function M (u) . Suppose also that the sequence u n (x) E LM, (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) is mean convergent to zero : lim n-+oo
f M1[un(x)J dx = O.
G
( 1 3. 1 3)
Then this sequence converges to zero with respect to the norm of the space Lid : lim I l u nl lM = O. n-+oo
PROOF. It follows from condition ( 1 3. 1 3) that the norms Il u nllM, (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) are uniformly bounded. In virtue of Lemma ( 1 3. 2) ,
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
1 17
the sequence u n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) has equi-absolutely continuous norms in L�. Since, in virtue of the same condition ( 1 3. 1 3) , the sequence u n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges in measure to zero, it converges, in virtue . of Lemma 1 1 .2, to zero with respect to the norm in L�. * 4. The product of functions in Orlicz spaces. Let u(x) E L�" w(x) E L�. Generally speaking, the product u(x) w (x) is not even a summable function. However, if the N-functions M l (U ) and l/J (u) are interrelated in a definite way, then the product u(x)w(x) may
turn out to be not only summable but it may also belong to a third Orlicz space L�., where M 2 (u) is defined by the functions M l (U) and l/J(u) . In the present subsection, we shall investigate a number of problems which arise in this connection. As the first example, we consider the case when L�, = Dx" L� = Dx A necessary condition that the product u(x)w (x) of the functions u(x) E La', and w (x) E LIX , be a summable function is, obviously, that the inequality I /IXl + I /IX2 :::;; 1 be satisfied. In this connection, u(x)w(x) belongs to all the Ly, where 1 :::;; Y :::;; :::;; IX I IX2/(IXl + IX2) . The verification of these evident facts is left to the reader. We proceed to the general case. LEMMA 1 3.4. Let u(x) be a function. Suppose u(x)w(x) E E for all functions w(x) E L�, where E is an Orlicz space L�. or the space L •.
of summable functions. Then there exists a constant k > 0 such that I l uw llE :::;; k l l w l l!ll · PROOF. The formula
Aw(x) = u(x)w (x) , w (x) E L�
defines an additive, homogeneous operator which acts from L� into E. We shall show that this operator is closed. [We recall that the operator A is said to be closed if I l wn - wo l l !ll --+ 0 and I I Awn - v i lE --+ 0 imply that v = Awo. ] In fact , let I l wn - wo ll!ll --+ 0 and I l uw n - v il E --+ O. Then the functions w n (x) converge in measure to wo(x) in virtue of which the functions u(x) w n (x) converge in measure to u(x)wo (x) . On the other hand, the functions u (x)wn(x) converge in measure to v (x) . It thus follows from this that v(x) = u(x)wo(x) almost everywhere. Since the closed operator A is defined on the entire Banach space L�, it is continuous. [Every
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
1 18
closed, additive, homogeneous operator A defined on a complete metric space is continuous (see, e.g . , HILLE [ 1 ] ) .] * LEMMA 1 3.5. Let u (x) w(x) E E for all functions u(x) E Lk" w(x) E L';p, where E is an Orlicz space Lk. or the. space L. Then there exists a constant k > 0 such that
( 1 3. 1 4 )
PROOF. As in the proof of the preceding lemma, we consider the linear operators A u w (x) = u(x) w(x) , w (x) E L';p, defined by the functions u(x) E Lk" I l u l I M, � 1 . The values of these operators on every fixed element w (x) E L';p are bounded since, in virtue of Lemma 1 3.4, the linear operator Bu(x) = u(x) w(x) , acting from LM, into E, is bounded. According to a known theorem (see, e . g . , BANACH [ 1 ] ) , the norms of the operators A u are uniformly bounded. Let I I A ul 1 � k. Then for arbitrary functions u (x) E Lk" w(x) E L';p, we have that
I l uw l lE
= I l l Iu�M1 w i lE l I u l l M,
=
I A I IU�M1 w liE l IullM, �
�
k I l u I I M, l l w I 14l . *
This lemma implies, in particular, the following assertion :
If the product u (x) v(x)w (x) is summable for any triple of functions u(x) E Lk" v (x) E Lk., w (x) E LM., then the following inequality holds :
I u(x) v(x)w (x) dx
G
�
k I l u II M, ll v I I M. ll w I I M.,
This inequality is a generalization of the known HOlder equality :
I u (x)v (x) w(x) dx k ( I l u (x) I IXl dX) ( I I v(x) locl dx) ( I I w(x) I dx )
lll
�
G
�
G
1 /",
G
1 /"2
G
OCI
1 /(%',
where 1 j(¥.l + 1 I(¥. 2 + 1 j(¥.3 � 1 . This assertion is valid for an arbitrary finite number of factors.
1 19
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
It is easily seen that the product u(x)w(x) will be summable for any functions u(x) E LM" w (x) E L� only in the case when lJI(u) -< M l (U) or, equivalently, when N l (u) -< C1>(u) . Here, as usual, lJI(u) , N l (U) denote the N-functions which are complementary to C1>(u) , M l (U) , respectively. We note that it is impossible to find an Orlicz space to which all the products u(x)w(x) belong if C1>(u) = Nl(U) . This follows from the following theorem. THEOREM 1 3.5 . Suppose u(x) w(x) belongs to some Orlicz space LM• for any pair of functions u(x) E LM" w (x) E L�. Then the N
function M l (U) increases essentially more rapidly than lJI(u) , or, equivalently, C1>(u) increases essentially more rapidly than N 1 (u) .
PROOF. In virtue of Lemma 1 3 . 3, it suffices to show that every bounded set of functions in LM, has equi-absolutely continuous norms in the space L 'Ip. Let T be a sphere of radius r in the space LM,. In virtue of Lemma 1 3.5, we have that I l uw l l M. � 2rk, u(x) E T, p(w ; C1» � 1 . It then follows from de la Vallee Poussin's theorem that the functions u(x)w (x) have equi-absolutely continuous integrals, i.e. to every e > 0 there corresponds a () > 0 such that
I I u(x)w(x) dx 1 < I I u(x)w(x) dx I
e for every
0,
inequality
0,
I I U (X) K(X ; G1) I I IJ1
<
=
e
G l C G, where mes G l
< I I u(x)w(x) dx I <
signifies that mes G l
sup p(w ;
0,
<
(). The
() implies that e. *
THEOREM 1 3. 6. If for every pair of functions u(x) E LM" w (x) E L�, the product u(x) w(x) belongs to some Orlicz space LM., then the N functions M l (U) and C1> (u) increase essentially more rapidly than the N-function M 2 (U) . PROOF. We shall prove the assertion of the theorem, for example, for the function M l (U) . Let G l C G and let K(X ; G 1 ) be the characteristic function of the set G l . Since K (X ; G l ) E L�, we have that U(X) K (X ; G l ) E LMz and, in virtue of Lemma 1 3.5 , that
I I U (X) K (X ; G l ) 1 1 M.
�
k l I u IlM, I 1 K I I
Suppose the family o f functions u(x) E LM, has bounded norms, lI u l lM, � a . Then, in virtue of the preceding inequality and formula
CHAPTER II, § 1 3
1 20 (9 . 1 1 ) , we have that
I l u(X) K(X ; G l ) I I M. � ak mes G 1 P- l ( l /mes G 1) ,
from which it follows that
lim
mes Gl-+ O
Il uK I I M. = 0, i . e. that the
functions u(x) have equi-absolutely continuous norms in LM •. *
5 . Sufficient conditions. We now point out some sufficient conditions for the product of two functions u(x) E LM" w(x) E L� to belong to an Orlicz space LM•. THEOREM 1 3.7. Suppose there exist two mutually complementary
N-functions R (u) and Q (u) such that the inequalities
( 1 3. 1 5)
and ( 1 3. 1 6)
are satisfied for u � Uo, where ex , f3 are certain constants. Then, for every pair of functions u(x) E LM" w (x) E L�, the product u(x)w(x) belongs to LM •. PROOF. In virtue of ( 1 3. 1 5) and ( 1 3. 1 6) , the inequalities
( 1 3. 1 7) and ( 1 3. 1 8) are satisfied for all values of the argument . Suppose v (x) E LN •. Then
f u(x)w (x)v (x) dx = exf3 l l u I IM, l l w ll!ll f ex u(x) I l u l I M,
G
G
w (x) v(X) dx . f3 ll w l l!ll
Applying Young's inequality twice to the last integral, we obtain that
I f u(x) w(x) v(x) dx I � exf3 llu I IM, l lw ll!ll { f M2 [R ( ex ;���, )] dx + f M2 [ Q ( f3���!Il )J dX + 2 f N2 [V(X)] dX} , G
G
+
G
G
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
121
and, in virtue of ( 1 3 . 1 7) and ( 1 3. 1 8) ,
IJ G
u(x) w (x) v (x) dx
I<
{
ocfJ I IU I IMJWI 1 4l M2[R (U O )] mes G +
+ M2[Q (UO) ] mes G + +
J
G
f./J
=
sup p(v ; N.) .;;; 1
IJ G
--
G
J dx + 2 J N2[V (X)] dX} < =. [�� I l w l l 41
Thus, u(x) w (x) E LM., with I luw l lM.
J MI [ I lUu(X)l lM, ] dx +
u (x) w (x) v (x) dx
G
1<
k l l u l l M, l l wl 1 4l ,
( 1 3. 1 9)
where k = ocfJ(4 + {M2[R (uo)] + M2[Q (UO)]} mes G) . * In particular, the assertion introduced above that under the condition I /OC I + l /oc2 1 the product u (x) w (x) belongs to all Ly, where 1 < I' < y o = OC I OC2/(OC I + OC2) , follows from this theorem. In fact, if M I (U) = l u l <X', f./J (u) = l u l <X2, M 2 (U) = l u l Yo, then the N-functions R (u) = M2" 1 [MI (U)] = l u l o,, /)'o and Q (u) = M2" l [f./J(U)] = = l u l « ' /)'o will be mutually complementary since YO/OCI + YO/OC2 = 1 . In the sequel, we shall be interested in the case when the N function MI (U) satisfies the LJ a-condition and M2 (U) = N I (U) . As is easily seen, in this case the assertion of Theorem 1 3.7 is satisfied if the inequality
<
( 1 3. 20) is valid for large values of u. In fact, in virtue of Theorem 6.3, we have that N I [M1 (U)] < < MI (ku) for large values of u, i.e. MI (u) < Nl 1 [MI (ku)] . Setting M I (U) = R (u) , N I (u) = Q (u) , we convince ourselves of the fact that the conditions of Theorem 1 3.7 are satisfied. It is also easily seen that in the case when the N-function M I (U) satisfies the LJ 2-condition and the N-function M 2 (U) the LJ 2-con dition, then the assertion of Theorem 1 3.7 is valid if the inequality ( 1 3.2 1 ) is satisfied for large values of the argument . To prove this, one must
CHAPTER I I , § 1 3
1 22
set R (u) = MI (U) , Q (u) = NI (U) and note that an N-function which satisfies the Ll 2-condition increases more slowly than some ex ponential function. If the N-function M2 (U) satisfies the LI '-condition, then another sufficient condition can be given, as follows. THEOREM 1 3. 8. Suppose the N-function M2 (U) satisfies the LI '
condition . Let the inequalities
( 1 3.22)
and ( 1 3.23)
be satisfied for u � uo, where R (u) and Q(u) are mutually comple mentary N-functions and ex , fJ are constants . Then, for every pair of functions u (x) E LM" w (x) E L�, the product u (x)w(x) belongs to LM •. PROOF. In virtue of ( 1 3.22) and ( 1 3.23) , the inequalities
( 1 3.24) and
Q [fJM2 (u) ] < Q({Juo) + C/J (u)
( 1 3 . 25)
are satisfied for all values of u. Since the N-function M2 (U) satisfies the LI '-condition, there exist constants a, a I , b l and C such that
for all u, w . Let v (x) E L N •. Then
f u(x) w (x) v (x) dx = l I u I lM, ll w l l41 f -u(x)
G
G
w(x) v (x) dx. I l u l I M, I l w l l 41 --
Applying the Young inequality to the last integral, we obtain that
I f u (x) w(x) v(x) dx I G
�
�
I l u I I M, ll w l l 41
{ f M2 [ U (X) G
]
w(x) -- dx + I l u l I M, I l w l l 41
--
f N2 [v(x) ] dx} .
G
1 23
CHAPTER II, § 1 3 In virtue of ( 1 3.26) , we have that
I M2 [ I luu (x)llM,
--
G
w (x) I I w lI 4l
--
] dx � a mes G + al I M2 [ U (X) ] dx + --
l I u llM,
G
Inequalities ( 1 3.22) and ( 1 3.23) imply that
M 2 (u) and
<
1
a l + - M I (U) a
for all u, where a I , fh are certain constants. Therefore,
I M2 [ l Iu(x) u l lM,
--
G
al
+a
w(x) I I w lI 4l
--
] dx � a mes G + a la I mes G +
U(X) J dx +' fhbl mes G + bl I (/J [ w (X) ] dx + I MI [ -l I u l lM, f3 I I W I I 4l -
G
--
G
In virtue of Young's inequality and inequalities ( 1 3.24) and ( 1 3. 25) ,
u (x) ] [ w(x) ] 1 [ u (x) ) I M2 [ -M2 -- dx � - { I R ( aM2 --J dx + af3 lI u l lM, l I u l lM, I I w l I 4l
G
G
+
1 I Q (f3M2 [ wI I w(x)lI 4l J) dX} � _ {CR(auo) + Q(f3uo)] mes G + af3
G
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
1 24
�
1
-
cx/J
{2 + [R (cxuo) + Q( /Juo}] mes G} .
Combining all the estimates obtained, we see that
J u(x) w(x)v(x) dx <
G
for all v (x) E LN. with
l I uw l lM. = sup
p(v ; NI) ';;; l
where
{
k= 1 +
00
I J u(x)w(x) v (x) dx I G
�
k ll u I I M, ll w l lQ) ,
2c + [a + CX l a l + /J I bl + CR(cxuo) + cx/J
-
( 1 3.27)
}
aI bI + CQ(/Juo) ] me as G + -;; + 73 . *
§ 14. Linear functionals
1 . Linear functionals in Lid. Suppose M(u) and N(v) are mutually complementary N-functions. Let v(x) be a fixed function in Lid. It follows from Holder's inequality (9. 1 6) that the linear functional I (u)
=
(u, v)
=
J u(x) v (x) dx, u(x) E LM,
G
( 1 4. 1 )
is defined on the entire space Lid . The inequality 1 1I1 1 � Il v i i N � 2 1 1 1 1 1 holds, where 1 1 I1 1 denotes the norm of the functional I (u) : 1 1 I1 1
=
sup l !ullM.;;; l
I I (u) l .
( 1 4.2)
1 25
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
2
The left inequality in ( 1 4. ) follows from the Holder inequality :
The right inequality in ( 1 4.2) follows from (9. 1 2) : =
1 2 1 11 .
I (u, v) l ::( sup I (u, v) = l Iul lM < 2 l We introduce the notation : k(v) = I l v I I N/ I III I . Then inequality ( 1 4.2) can be rewritten in the form 1 ::( k(v) The function k(v) was studied in detail by D. V. Salehov. The simplest properties of this function are given below. As an example, we shall compute the value of the function k(v) for the Orlicz spaces defined by the N-functions M (u) = l u l lX / ex (ex > 1 ) , i.e. for the case of the spaces LIX. We recall that for every function u(x) E LM we have I l v i iN
sup
p (u ; M ) <
::( 2.
I l u liM where l /ex + I /P
1 I1
=
sup
l I u l lM < 1
If G
=
=
ex 1 /<X PI /Il
{ f M[u (x) ] dxf /<x , G
1 . Therefore,
u(x) v (x) dx
I
=
sup
",l/ �lll / P{
I M[u(x)]dx}l/� < I
G
sup
If If
I M[u(x)] dx < 1
G
u(x) v (x) dx
G
G
I
u (x) v (x) dx
=
I
=
from which it follows that k(v) = ex l / <xp l /ll, v (x) E LN . The constant exi / "'p l /ll ( l / ex + l iP = 1 ) can assume any value in the interval ( 1 , Let M (u) and N (v) be arbitrary mutually complementary N-func tions. Let G 1 be a subset of G. We set v (x) = N- l ( l jmes G I ) K (X ; G 1 ) , where K(X ; GI) is the characteristic function of the set G1 . We shall show that
2J.
k (v)
=
mes GIM- I ( I /mes GI) N- I ( l jmes GI) .
( 1 4.3)
It follows from the formula for the norm of the characteristic
1 26
CHAPTER II, § 1 4
function that IlviiN equals the number appearing in the right member of formula ( 1 4. 3) . It therefore suffices to show that the norm of the linear functional ( 1 4. 1 ) , defined by the function v ) , equals unity . Since p (v ; N) = 1 , we have that
I I/I I = sup I (u , v) 1 � sup
{
sup
Ilul lM "';; l p(w ; N ) "';; l
I lullM ",;; l
On the other hand,
II/I I = sup I (u, v) I �
I (u,
w) l } =
(x
1.
( 1 1 K�x(x; ;:1)11)1M , v) = 1 .
This means that II/II = 1 , and formula ( 1 4.3) i s proved. Thus, the set of values of the function k (v) comprises at least the set of values of the function I lullM "';; l
fey)
M- 1 (y)N-1 (y) =
y
,
<
mes G
y <
=
.
D . V. Salehov showed that fey) = constant only in the case when M (u) k l u l 'X, IX > 1 . This result signifies that the function k (v) is constant only in the case of the spaces L iX . We shall prove this assertion for the simplest case - when fey) = 2, y � l imes G. We note first of all that the equality fey) = c implies the con tinuity of the right derivatives P (u) and q(u) of the N-functions M (u) and N (u) . In fact, it follows from the equality
=
M- 1 (y)N- 1 (y)
that
=
M- 1 (y) q[N- 1 (Y)]
cy,
1 � y < =, --mes G
N- 1 (y) c. + P [M1 (y)] =
Since the derivatives q (u) and P (u) have positive salt uses at their points of discontinuity, it follows from the last equality that q(Zt) and P (zt) are continuous. 2y In virtue of Young's Now let fey) = 2, i . e . , M- 1 (y) N- 1 (y) inequality, we always have that M- 1 (y)N- 1 (y) � 2y. We t h er e fo re have the case when the equality sign is attained in Young's in equality. In virtue of the continuity of the derivatives P (lt) and q(u) ,
= .
1 27
CHAPTER II, § 1 4
M- l (y) q[N-l (y)] l l (y)J. N- (y) P[MM-l(y)N-l(y) y 2y l 1 l M- (y)P[M- (y)] I jmes G. We set M- l (y) for all y u. Then P(u)jM(u) 2ju for u Uo M l ( l /mes G) . Integrating the equality P(u)/M(u) 2j u between the limits from Uo to l u i , we obtain that M(u) M(uo) Uo l u i , u Uo·
= the equality sign is attained if or, equivalently, = if Making use of the last equality and the relation = = 2 , we obtain that =
=
�
�
=
=
=
-
=
2
2
=
�
It follows from ( 1 4.2) that the space Llv can be considered as a linear subset of the space of functionals conj ugate to LM . In this connection, the norm of the space Llv is equivalent to the norm induced on LN as a subset of the space of functionals. Since the space LN is dense with respect to the Orlicz norm, it forms a closed subspace, LN, in the space of functionals, which, generally speaking, does not coincide with the space of functionals on LM, as is indicated by the following theorem. THEOREM 1 4. 1 . ( 1 4. 1 ) LM. PROOF. Let EM be a linear subspace of LM which is the closure in LM of a set of bounded functions. In virtue of Theorem 9.4 and ( 1 0. 1 ) , EM is a proper subset of LM. Let E LM�EM. We define a linear functional on LM by setting = 1 and = 0 for (x E EM, and then extending it by the Hahn Banach theorem, with preservation of norm, to all of LM (see BANACH [ I J ) . We assume that this functional l(u) is representable in theJform
Suppose the N-function M(u) does not satisfy is not the general form of a linear the iJ 2-condition. Then functional on u)
I(u)
I(u)
uo(x)
I(u)
=
f u (x)v (x) dx, u (x)
l(uo)
E LM,
G
where v(x) is some function. We form the following sequence of bounded functions :
v n (x)
=
{V(X) o
for I v(x) I :(; for I v(x) I >
n (n n.
=
1 , 2, .
. ), .
128
CHAPTER
II, § 14
I(u), we have that I Vn(X) V (X) dx = 0 (n = 1 2 . . . ) , from which it follows that the function vex) equals zero almost everywhere. But then we also have that I(uo) = 0 which contradicts the fact that I(uo) 1. 2. General form of a linear functional on EM. THEOREM 14. 2 . Formula (14.1), where vex) E LM, yields the general form of a linear functional on EM. By the construction of the functional
"
G
=
*
PROOF. We shall carry out the proof of this theorem by following the line of reasoning customary for such theorems. Let be a linear functional defined on EM. We define, on the totality of all measurable subsets eS' of the set G, a set function eS') ] , where (X eS') by means of the equality is the characteristic function of the set eS'. The additive function eS' is absolutely continuous inasmuch as, in virtue of we have that
I(u)
F(eS')
F(eS') I[K(x ;
K ;
=
F( ) (9.1 1), 1 ), [ F( eS') [ = [ I[K(X ; eS')] [ � [ [1[ [ mes eS'N- l ( mes eS'
from which it follows that
lim [ ( cf� O
F t&") [
=
O.
In virtue of the Radon-Nikodym theorem (d. HILLE function is representable in the form mes
F(t&")
F(t&") I v (x)dx, =
[1]), the ( 14. 4)
cf
vex)
where is a summable function on G. It follows from that the equality
( 14. 4)
I(u) I u(x)v(x) dx =
(14.5)
G
is also valid for every measurable function finite number of values.
u(x) which assumes a
CHAPTER I I , §
14
1 29
Let u(x) be an arbitrary function in LM . A sequence of bounded functions u n (x) (n = 2, . . . which converges almost everywhere to u(x) can be found such that I � l u(x) I almost everywhere so that I l un l l M � I l u lIM . The sequence of positive functions I also converges almost everywhere to the function In virtue of Fatou's theorem and we have that
)
1,
I U n(x)
I U n(x)v(X) (16. 5 ), l u (x)v(x)I . I f u(x)v(x) dx I � s�p { f l un(x)v (x) I dX} sup 1 / ( l un (x) I sgn v(x)) I � IIIII sup Il un l lM � 1 I/I I I I u liM < 00 This means that v(x) E LN. We denote the functional f u(x)v(x) dx, defined on LM, by 11 (u) : G
=
G
=
.
n
n
G
i I (u) =
(14. 5 ),
f u(x)v(x) dx.
G
In virtue of the continuous linear functionals I (u) and 1 1 (u) assume the same values on a set of bounded functions which is everywhere dense in EM . This signifies that they take on the same values on all of EM , i.e. formula is valid for all functions u(x) E EM . Distinct functions E LN, obviously, generate distinct functionals on EM . * We shall momentarily denote the norm of the functional considered only on EM , by 1 1/ 1 i I. For every s > 0 , a function u(x) E LM, I l u l iM = can be found such that
(14. 5 )
v(x)
(14.1),
1, f u(x)v (x) dx G
We set
for
I IIII
:(
n,
l u (x) I > l Iunl lM J ul M and un(x)
un (x) Clearly,
{ U(X) l u(x) J
�
Convex functions
=
�
0
for
n
E
-
s.
(n = I , 2, · · · ) . EM. It follows from the 9
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
1 30 absolute continuity of the integral that
I un (x)v (x) dx ;:?:: I u(x)v(x) dx
- E
G
G
for sufficiently large n, from which it follows that
1 111 1 1 ;:?:: I l u n l lM 1 11 1 1 1 ;:?::
I Un (X) V(X) dx ;:?:: I I II I
G
-
2e.
It follows from the inequality j ust obtained and the obvious relation 1 111 1 1 � I I II I that 1 111 i I = l ill i , i.e. that
I III I
=
sup I I (u) l .
( 1 4.6)
I luIlM";; l , u eEM
Equality ( 1 4.6) allows us to also use the same notation I I I I I when the functional ( 1 4. 1 ) is considered on all of Lit as when it is considered only on E M . If the N-function M (u) satisfies the Ll 2-condition, then EM coincides with Lit = L M . In this case, ( 1 4. 1 ) yields the general form of a linear functional on Lit. 3. EN-weak convergence. We shall say that the sequence u n (x) E Lit (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) EN-weakly convergent if the sequence
is
of numbers
I (un)
=
I un (x)v (x) dx
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . )
G
converges for every function v(x) E EN. The definition j ust introduced differs from the usual definition inasmuch as the functions v(x) E EN do not , generally speaking, define all linear functionals on Lit. This definition coincides with the usual definition if both N-functions M(u) and N (v) satisfy the Ll 2-condition. If we consider weak convergence in the space EN , then the definition introduced above coincides with the usual definition if the N-function N (v) satisfies the Ll 2-condition. In the general case, EN-weak convergence is weak convergence in the space Lit considered as the space of functionals on EN. I n fact, as was already shown, there exists a linear one-to-one
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
131
correspondence between the elements of this space of functionals and the elements of LM in which connection the norms of the corresponding elements are equivalent . Thus, to every EN-weakly convergent sequence of elements in LM there corresponds a weakly convergent sequence of linear functionals on EN . The following assertions follow from general theorems (see, e.g. , LYUSTERNIK and SOBOLEV [ I J ) . THEOREM 1 4.3. If the sequence of functions u n (x) E LM (n = =
1 , 2, . . . ) is EN-weakly convergent, then the norms l !u nl l M 1 , 2, . . . ) are uniformly bounded . THEOREM 1 4.4. Every space LM is EN-weakly complete in the sense that for every EN-weakly convergent sequence of functions u n (x) E LM (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) a unique function u(x) E LM can be found such that (n
=
!��
J un(x)v(x) dx J u(x)v(x) dx, v(x) =
G
G
E
EN .
Every space LM is EN-weakly compact, i . e . every bounded sequence contains an EN-weakly convergent subsequence .
We note that the EN-weak closure of the space EM in the space LM is the entire space LM. This follows from the fact that for every function u(x) E LM the sequence of bounded functons
u n (x)
=
( u(x) o
for l u(x) I � n, for l u(x) I > n
(n = 1 , 2 , . . . )
converges EN-weakly to u(x) inasmuch as
!��
J [u(x) - un(x)Jv (x) dx
G
=
0
for all v (x) E EN (and also for all v (x) E LN) . As was already shown (see p. 9 1 ) , the norms of the functions un(x) also converge to Ilul IM . Thus, the sequence u n(x) converges almost everywhere to u(x) , is EN-weakly convergent to u(x) , and I l u nl lM -+ I l u l IM . However, generally speaking, u n(x) does not con verge in norm to u (x) . Every sequence of functions which converges with respect to the norm in LM, obviously, is EN-weakly convergent . The converse,
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
1 32
of course, does not hold. We shall use the following obvious assertion in the sequel. THEOREM 1 4.5. If the sequence of functions un(x) E Lid ( n = = 1 , 2, . . . ) is EN-weakly convergent and compact in the sense
of convergence in norm in Lid, then it also converges in norm.
The following criterion for EN-weak convergence is sometimes convenient to use. THEOREM 1 4.6. Suppose the sequence u n (x) E Lid (n = 1 , 2, . . . )
converges in measure to the function u(x) with the norms I l un llM (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) uniformly bounded. Then u(x) E Lid and the sequence u n(x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) is EN-weakly convergent to u (x) . PROOF. In virtue of the fact that a sphere in Lid is EN-weakly compact, every sequence of functions in Lid which are bounded in norm contains an EN-weakly convergent subsequence. It is therefore sufficient in our case to show that for any subsequence u n .(x) which is EN-weakly convergent in Lid to uo(x) E Lid, we have uo(x) = u(x) . We denote by Km (X) the characteristic function of some fixed set of points on which l u(x) - uo(x) I � m, and the function sgn [u(x) - uo(x)] by vo(x) . Suppose 8 > 0 is prescribed. Since the functions uO(X) , u n.(x) (k = 1 , 2, . . . ) have, in virtue of the de la Vallee Poussin theorem (see § 1 1 , subsection 1 ) , equi-absolutely continuous integrals, a (j > 0 can be found such that
I l uo(x) l dx ; , I l un.(X) l dX ; <
<
(k - 1 , 2 . . . ) -
,
provided mes tff < (j (tff C G) . We shall assume that (j < 8/(5m) . It follows from the convergence in measure of the subsequence u n. (x) to the function u(x) and the EN-weak convergence of this sequence to the function uo(x) that there exists a ko such that , for k > ko,
I [Un.(X) - uo(x)]vo(X) Km(x) dx ; <
G
and mes G k < (j, where
Gk
=
G{ l un.(x) - u (X) I
�
8/(5 mes G)}.
CHAPTER II, § 1 4
1 33
Then, for k > ko, we have that
f l u(x) - uo(x) I Km(X) dx I f [un.(x) - uo(x)]Vo(X) Km(X) dx I + + f l u(x) - u n.(x) I dx + f I Un.(x) I dx + + f l uo(x) I dx + f l u(x) - uo(x) I Km(X) dx ::;:;;
0
o
<
<
Since
e
e
5
+
e
S mes G
mes (G"",G k )
e
e
+ - + - + m mes Gk 5
5
<
e.
is arbitrary, we have that
f l u(x) - uo(x) I Km(X) dx
=
0,
o
i.e. uo(x) u (x) almost everywhere. * 4. EN-weakly continuous linear functionals. We shall say that the linear functional l(u) is EN-weakly continuous on Lit if for every sequence u n (x) E Lit (n 1 , 2, . . . ) which is EN-weakly convergent to the element uo(x) E Lit the equality lim l(u n) l (uo) n---+ oo holds. It follows from this definition that functionals of the form ( 1 4. 1 ) , where v (x) E EN, are EN-weakly continuous. The converse assertion also holds. THEOREM 1 4.7 . Every EN-weakly continuous linear functional on Lit is representable in the form ( 1 4. 1 ) , where v (x) E EN. PROOF. We consider the space EN of functionals defined on the space EN. In virtue of Theorem 1 4.2 on the general form of a linear functional in EN, there exists a one-to-one correspondence, defined by the formula =
=
=
f(v)
=
f v(x)u(x) dx, u (x) E Lit, v(x) E EN,
o
( 1 4.7 )
between the functionals f E EN and the functions u (x) E Lit. In this connection, in virtue of the definition of EN-weak con vergence, to the sequence of functions u n(x) E Lit which is EN-
CHAPTER II, § 1 4
1 34
weakly convergent t o the function u(x) E LM there corresponds in one-to-one fashion a sequence of functionals
fn(v) =
f v(x)un(x) dx
G
which converges weakly to the functional
f(v) =
f v (x)u(x) dx.
G
Let lo(u) be an EN-weakly continuous functional defined on the space LM. We define a functional cP (f) , f E EN, on the space EN by means of the equality
cP (f) = lo (u) ,
( 1 4.8)
where u (x) E LM is the function corresponding to the functional f in virtue of the one-to-one correspondence established between the functionals on EN and the functions in the space LM. It is obvious that the EN-weak continuity of the functional lo(u) on LM implies the weak continuity of the functional cP (f) on EN. Since the space EN is separable, we have, in virtue of Banach's theorem on the general form of a weakly continuous functional in the conj ugate space, that there exists a function vo(x) E EN such that cP (f) = f(vo) for all f E EN, i.e.
lo(u) =
f vo(x)u(x) dx
G
for all u (x) E LM. [Banach's theorem (see BANACH [ I J ) asserts that if E is a separable space and tf.J (f) is a weakly continuous functional on the space E conjugate to E, then there exists an element Vo E E such that cP (f) = f(vo) for all f E E . * 5 . Norm of a functional and Il vl l (N) . If we consider the Luxem burg norm I l u l l (M) (see § 9, subsection 7) in the space LM, then the norm of every linear functional l(u) , which admits of an integral representation ( 1 4. 1 ) , is defined by the equality
J
1 11 1 1 (M) = sup
IlulkM, ';;;; l
I f u (x)v(x) dx I , G
and, in virtue of (9.25) , I l l l l(M) = I l v l l(N) .
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
1 35
The equality
I I III = Il v l l (N)
( 1 4. 9)
also holds, where I III I denotes the usual norm of the functional ( 1 4. 1 ) . This equality coincides with the equality
I l v l l (N) = sup
I lullM ';; l
1 f u(x) v(x) dx I ·
( 1 4. 1 0)
G
To prove ( 1 4. 1 0) , we note that (9.26) implies the inequality sup l Iul lM ';; l
I f u(x)v (x) dx I G
:::;;;
I l v ll (N) .
�
I l v ll (N) .
Thus, it will suffice to show that sup I lullM ';; l
1 f u(x) v (x) dx 1 G
( 1 4. 1 1 )
We denote by T the unit sphere I l v l l(N) :::;;; 1 considered as a subset of the space Ll of summable functions on G. The convex set T i s closed with respect to the norm i n Ll inas much as lim n--> oo
f I vn (x) - w(x) I dx =
G
0, v n (x) E T
implies that v n (x) converges in measure to w (x) , in which connection, in virtue of Fatou's theorem and (9 . 2 1 ) , we have that
f N[w(x)J dx
G
:::;;; s �p
f N[vn(x)J dx
G
:::;;; 1 .
Let vo(x) be a fixed non-zero function in the space LN. Clearly, the function ( 1 + e)vo(x) / l l vo ll (N) , where e > 0, is not in T. As we know (see BANACH [ 1 ] ) , a linear functional 1(v) , defined on Ll, can be constructed such that
[
1 ( 1 + e)
vo(x) Il vo l l (N)
]
> 1(v) ,
v (x) E T.
( 1 4. 1 2)
CHAPTER I I , § 1 4
1 36
The functional f(v) admits of the integral representation
f(v)
=
f v(x)h(x) dx, v (x) E L I,
G
where h(x) is an essentially bounded function (in this connection, see AHIEZER and GLAZMAN [ 1 J ) . It therefore follows from ( 1 4. 1 2) that 1 + s
I lvOII(N)
f vo(x)h(x) dx
G
and, in virtue of (9.25) ,
1 + s
( 1 + s) and, since
s
veT
f v(x)h(x) dx =
G
=
SUp I Ivl l(N) ';;; l
f I v(x) I Ih(x) dx
G
f vo(x)h(x) dx
�
I I h I lM
f vo(x) IIh(x)h l lM dx
�
I I vo l l (N) ,
I I vo I I (N) It follows that
� sup
G
G
is arbitrary, we have that
f vo(x) Ilh(x)hllM dx
G
Now, this inequality implies ( 1 4. 1 1 ) .
�
I I vo l l (N) .
.
I
C H A P T E R III
O P E R A T O R S IN O R L I C Z S P A C E S § 15. Conditions for the continuity of linear integral operators
I . Formulation of the problem. This entire chapter will be devoted to the study of linear operators A operating from one Orlicz space Lid, into another Orlicz space Lid• . We shall denote the class of linear operators operating from the space B l into the space B 2 by {B l -+ B 2}. The class of continuous operators will be denoted by {B l -+ B 2 ; c.} and the class of completely continuous operators will be denoted by {B l -+ B 2 ; compo c.}. Basically, we shall be interested in integral operators of the form Au(x)
=
f k (x, y)u(y) dy.
G
( 1 5. 1 )
The fundamental problem of the present section consists in elucidating the conditions under which the operator ( 1 5. 1 ) is continuous considered as an operator operating from Lid, into Lid., i .e. that it satisfies the condition
I I Au I IM. � I I A l l l l u l lM" where I I A I I is some number. We shall naturally search for in the various characteristics suitable such characteristic is Orlicz space, i.e. the finiteness
conditions for the continuity of A of the kernel k(x, y) . The most that the kernel belongs to some of the integral
f f P[exk(x, y)] dx dy
G G
for some ex. Below, we denote by G the topological product G X G equipped with the natural measure . By L M , LM, E M we will denote the corresponding class and spaces LM(G) , Lid (G) and E M (G) .
138
CHAPTER I I I , §
15
2 . General theorem. As usual, we shall denote by N l (V) and N 2 (V) the complementary functions to the given N-functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) . THEOREM Let !P(u) be an N-function such that for u(x) E L111,
15.1.
v(x) E LN. we have
w(x, y) = u (y)v(x) E L�,
with
15.2) ( 15. 3 ) (
where 1 is a constant. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) of the linear integral operator belongs to the space L rp , where P(v) is the comple mentary N-function to the N-function !P(u) . Then the operator belongs to {L111 --+ LM. ; c.}.
(15.1)
(15.1)
PROOF. In virtue of HOlder's inequality and for u(x) E L111, v(x) E LN., that
I Au(x)v (x) dx I I k(x, y) u(y)v(x) dx dy
o
=
0 0
(15. 3) we have,
�
from which it follows that the operator A acts from L111 into LM• . Since I l v i I N. � 2 for p(v ; N 2 ) :::;;; it follows from that
I I Au I IM. = sup
p (v ; N.) .;;; 1
1,
I I Au(x)v (x) dx I
(15. 4)
� 21 1 I k(x, Y ) I I � l l u I l Ml ·
(15. 5)
o
Thus, the operator A is bounded and, consequently, it is con tinuous. * From inequality we obtain an estimate for the norm of the operator A :
(15. 5 ),
I I A I I = sup I I Au I IM. � 21 1 I k(x, y) ll op .
( 1 5.6)
This estimate is, of course, too high. It can be sharpened in many cases. One way of sharpening the estimate of the norm of the operator A can be based on the application of the strengthened Holder inequality (9.26) .
3. Existence of the function !P(u) . The application of Theorem 15.1 requires knowledge of a function !P(u) for which conditions ( 1 5.2) and (15. 3 ) are satisfied.
CHAPTER III,
§ 15
1 39
LEMMA 1 5. 1 . Let tP (u) be defined as the complementary N-function to the N-function ( 1 5.7) Then conditions ( 1 5.2) and ( 1 5.3) are satisfied . PROOF. Let u(x) E Lid" v (x) E LN. . We shall first show that condition ( 1 5.2) is satisfied, i.e. that the function w(x, y) = u(y)v(x)
belongs to the space L�. Let g(x, y) E L IJI • Since
I I I w(x, y)g(x, y) dx dy I :;:;; (j
:::::: Il u llM, l l v I I N . "'"
1 dX dy, II I g(X, y) I lI ulu(IYI ) l llv(x) l v I I N. M,
(j
we have, in virtue of Young's inequality (2.6 ) , applied to the first of the two factors appearing under the integral sign in the right member, that
I I I w(x, y)g(x, y) dx dy I:;:;; (j
:;:;; I l u I IM, ll v I l N.
+
I v (x) I dx dy + { I I Nl[g(X, y)] -I l v i I N. (j
I v (x) I dX dY} . J II M1 [ � Il u l IM, I l v i I N. ()
Applying, once more, Young's inequality to the first term in the curly brackets, we obtain that
I I I w(x, y)g(x, y) dx dy I :;:;; :;:;; I I U I I M, I I V II N. { I I M 2 [Nl[g(X, y)]] dx dy + () + I I N 2 [ ��� ] dx dy + I M l [ I:�� ] dy I :���� dX} . , I . I (j
()
G
G
( 1 5.8)
CHAPTER III, § I S
1 40 Since
V(X) ] dx ::::;; I , J M J N2 [-I l v i I N. G
G
1
J dy -..::: [� I l u l I M,
� I
and the function v(x) is summable, it follows from ( 1 3.8) that
I J J w(x, y)g(x, y) dx dy I G
::::;;
{ J J P[g(x, y)] dx dy + I v(x) 1- } , ( 1 5.9) dX mes G + J
I l u I l M, l l v IIN. +
G
G
Il v i I N.
which implies ( 1 5.2) . In virtue of Young's inequality, we have that
+ M 2 ( 1 ) mes G
::::;;
I + M 2 ( 1 ) mes G .
Therefore, if p (g(x, y) ; P) ::::;; 1 , then it follows from ( 1 5.9) that
I l w(x, y) l l $ where
=
sup
p((J ; 'P)<;; 1 1 =
I J J w(x, y)g(x, y) dx dy I ::::;;lllu I IM. llv I lN., G
2 + mes G + M 2 ( 1 ) mes G.
*
( 1 5. 1 0)
The next lemma is proved in an analogous manner.
LEMMA 1 5.2. Let tP(u) be defined as the complementary N-function to the N-function ( 1 5. 1 1 ) Then conditions ( 1 5.2) and ( 1 5.3) are satisfied. Under the conditions of Lemma 1 5.2, the constant I is defined
by means of the equality 1 =
2 + mes G + N1 ( 1 ) mes G.
( 1 5. 1 2)
4. Concerning a property of N-functions which satisfy the LJ ' condition. In the investigation of linear integral operators, an important role is played by N-functions M(u) which are such that u(x) , v(x) E LM implies that u(y)v(x) E LM. In this subsection,
we elucidate what N-functions possess this property. Clearly, the N-functi ons M (u) k l u l lX ( ex > I ) possess the indicated property. =
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 5
141
LEMMA 1 5.3. Suppose u (x) , v (x) E Lll implies that the function w(x, y) = u(y) v(x) belongs to Lll. Then the N-function M (u) satisfies the LJ 2-condition . PROOF. Let us assume that the N-function M (u) does not satisfy the LJ 2-condition. Then a monotonic indefinitely increasing sequence of numbers U n, U n -+ 00 , can be found such that
(n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . ( 1 5. 1 3) We construct disj oint sets G n C G such that mes G n = M(2) · · mes Gj{2 nM(2 n )} (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) and disj oint sets rff n C G such that mes rff n = M(U l ) mes Gj{2 n M(u n)} (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) . M(2un)
We set
v(x) and
>
1-
u(x) = Then
I
2 2 nM(2 n )M(u n)
(n = 1 , 2, . . . )
2 n if x E G n o
00
if x E U G n
n= 1
Un if X E rff n o
,
(n
=
1 , 2, . . . )
00
if x E U rff n .
,
n= l
I M[v (x)] dx = n�l I M[v (x)] dx n�1M (2n ) mes G n
a
=
= M (2) mes G
Oft
I M[u(x)] dx n�l I M[u(x)] dx n�lM (Un) mes rffn =
=
G
=
On the other hand, for arbitrarily large k, we have that
II ()
M
[ U(y� (X) ] dx dy =
= � � M 00
00
i = 1 i= 1
� � II
i 1i 1
( -2i Uj ) mes G i mes rffj k
G.
�
Ifl
M
00 ,
=
= M(U l ) mes G
If.
<
<
[ U (Y� (X) ] dx dy =
00 .
CHAPTER III, § I S
1 42
where 2m-1 > k . I t follows from this, in virtue of ( 1 5 . 1 3) , that
f f M [ u(y�V(X) ] dx dy o
=
00 .
Thus, u (x) , v ex) E LM, whereas u(y)v(x) E LM. * THEOREM 1 5.2. A necessary and sufficient condition that for an arbitrary pair of functions u(x) , v ex) E LM the product w(x, y) = = u (y)v (x) belong to the space LM is that the N-function M(u) satisfy the Lt ' -condition . Proof of sulliciency. Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the Lt ' -condition, i.e. there exist positive constants Uo and C such that
M (uv)
�
CM(u)M(v)
(u, v
�
uo) .
( 1 5 . 1 4)
In virtue of Lemma 5 . 1 , the function M(u) satisfies the Lt 2-condition. Therefore LM = L M . Let u (x) , vex) E L M . We denote by G u (respectively G v ) the set G{ l u(x) I � uo} (respectively G{ l v (x) I � uo}) , where Uo is the number appearing in condition ( 1 5 . 1 4) . Then, in virtue of this condition, for x E G v , y E G u , we have that M[u(y)v(x)] � CM[u(y)]M[v(x)] . From this inequality and the obvious equality
f f M[u (y)v(x)] dx dy f f M[u(y) v (x)] dx dy + f f M[u(y)v(x)] dx dy + + f f M[u(y)v (x)] dx dy + f f M[u(y)v(x)] dx dy =
o
=
au a o
it follows that
f f M[u(y) v(x)] dx dy C f M[u(y)] dy f M[v(x)] dx + f M[uov (x)] dx + + f M[uou(y)] dy + M(u�) ( e G) , ( 1 5 . 1 5) �
(j
�
mes G
a
a
a
mes G
m s
a
2
1 43
CHAPTER III, § 1 5
and since uov (x) , uou(x) E LM , we have u(y)v(x) E LM = Lk Prool 01 necessity . Let the function w (x, y) = u(y)v (x) E Lif if u(x) , v ex) E Lif. In virtue of Lemma 1 5.3, the N-function M (u) satisfies the ,1 2-condition. Therefore Lif = L M . Let us assume that the N-function M (u) does not satisfy the ,1 ' -condition. Then monotonically indefinitely increasing sequences of positive numbers U n , Vn (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) can be found such that
M(u n v n ) > 2 2 n M(u n )M(v n )
(n = 1 , 2 , . . . )
We construct sets G n C G and tt n e G for which mes G n = with Gt
n
M( Vl ) mes G M(Ul) mes G , mes tt n = 2 nM( vn) 2 nM(u n )
j j
G, = 0, tti u(x)
-
and
vex) = Then
n
.
(n = 1 , 2 , . . . ) ,
tt,
= 0 (i =1= i) . We set Un if X E Gn ( n = 1 , 2, . . . ) , o
if X E U Gn 00
n= l
Vn if x E tt n o
if X E U tt n.
(n = I , 2, · · · ) ,
00
n= l
J M[u(x)] dx = n� l J M[u(x)] dx = n� lM (Un) mes Gn = G.
G
= M(U l ) mes G
and
J M[v(x) ] dx = n�l J M[v(x)] dx = n�lM(vn) mes
a
tt n
J J M[u(y)v(x)] dx dy = i�l i�l J J M[u(y)v (x)] dx dy = aj
<1,
< 00
=
= M(Vl) mes G
8.
On the other hand,
(j
( 1 5 . 1 6)
< 00 .
CHAPTER III, § 1 5
1 44 and, in virtue of ( 1 5 . 1 6) ,
f fM[U(y)V (X)] dX dY o
=
=.
Thus, u (x) E L M , V (X) E L M , and w (x, y) = u(y)v(x) E LM = LM. We have therefore arrived at a contradiction. * It follows from the theorem j ust proved that "u(x) E LM, v (x) E LM implies u(y)v (x) E LM" is not true for all N-functions (even those satisfying the Ll 2-condition) . LEMMA 1 5.4 . Suppose the N-function M(u) satisfies the Ll '
condition. Then a constant a > 0 can be found such that I l u(y)v(x) I IM � a ll u l l M l l v l lM
( 1 5 . 1 7)
for u(x) , v(x) E LM .
PROOF. Suppose M(uv) � CM(u)M(v) for u, v � Uo > 1 . In virtue of ( 1 5. 1 5) ,
(x) ] dX dY '"'" f f M [ uo li uu(y)v ll M . Uo ll v ll M &
o
�C
J dy f M [ � J dx + f M [� I l u l iM Il v i lM
G
+ mes G
G
v (X) ] dX} + M(u�) (mes G) 2, dy + f M [ ] { f [ Iu(y) u liM I l v i lM l G
M
G
and, since p (u/ l l u I IM ; M) � 1 , p(v/ l l vI IM ; M) � 1 , we have that
v(x) ] dx dy � C f f M [ Uo Iu(y) l u l i M · l l v l lM o
2
+
2 mes G + M (u�) (mes G) 2 .
Consequently,
u(y)v(x) I ] dx dy � � 1 + ffM [ I I u�u(y)v(x) u � lI u l l M l l v l l M l l u l lM l l v l l M Iu o
� 1 + C
+ 2 mes G + M (u�) (mes G) 2 .
CHAPTER III, § 1 5 Inequality ( 1 5. 1 7) ,
1 45 which
a = u � [ 1 + C + 2 mes G + M(u5) (mes G) 2] , III
( 1 5. 1 8)
follows from this. * Let Q(u) and R(u) be two N-functions. We recall that the relation Q(u) -< R(u) signifies the existence of positive constants k and Uo such that Q(u) ::( R(ku) (u � uo) . In virtue of Theorem 1 3. 1 , the relation Q(u) -< R (u) is equivalent to the inclusion L'R C L'Q. We also recall (d. Theorem 1 3.3) that the inclusion L'R C L'Q implies the existence of a constant q > 0 such that I l u l l Q ::( q l l u l l R (u ( x) E L 'H) . THEOREM 1 5.3. Suppose the N-function lP(u) satisfies the ,1 '
condition with
( 1 5 . 1 9)
Then conditions ( 1 5 . 2) and ( 1 5.3) are satisfied. PROOF. Let u(x) E Lu., v(x) E LN,. In virtue of ( 1 5. 1 9) , we have that u(x) E Lq" v (x) E L q, . Then , in virtue of Lemma 1 5 .4, w(x, y) = u(z) v(x) E Lq, and I l u (y) v(x) 1 1q, ::( a I l u l l q, I l v l l q,. It follows from ( 1 5. 1 9) that there exist constants ql and q 2 such that I l u l l q, ::( ql l l ttl lM. (u(x) E L uJ , I l v ll q, ::( q 2 11 v 11 N . (v (x) E LN,) . Therefore, I l u(y) v(x) 1 1 q, ::( I l l u IIM. l l v II N" where I = aqlq 2 . * 5. Sufficient conditions for continuity . THEOREM 1 5 . 4 ( FUNDAMENTAL THEOREM ON CONTINUITY ) . Let (/)(u) and lJI(v) be mutually complementary N-functions. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) of the linear integral operator ( 1 5 . 1 ) belongs to the space L'ip. Then the operator ( 1 5 . 1 ) belongs to {Lu. _ Lu, ; c .} if any one of the following conditions is satisfied : M 2 [N1 (v)] -< lJI(v) , a) ( 1 5 . 20) N1[M 2 (v)] -< lJI(v) ,
b) c)
the function lP(u) satisfies the ,1 '-condition and N l (V) -< lJI(v) , M 2 (v) -< lJI(v) .
( 1 5 .2 1 ) ( 1 5. 22)
PROOF. In virtue of Theorem 3. 1 , condition a) implies the condition of Lemma 1 5. 1 , condition b) implies the condition of Lemma 1 5.2, and condition c) implies the condition of Theorem 1 5.3. It is asserted in these lemmas and Theorem 1 5 .3 that the conditions of Theorem 1 5. 1 are satisfied and the proposition to be proved follows from the latter theorem. * Convex functions
IO
CHAPTER III, § 1 5
1 46
We note that the N-function P(v) appearing must satisfy the condition I v l lX -< P(v) ,
where
IX
m
condition c)
( 1 5.23)
> 1 . This follows from the obvious fact that condition
( 1 5.23) is satisfied by every N-function whose complementary
function satisfies the L h-condition. Conditions a) , b) , c) of Theorem 1 5.4 are not equivalent. There fore, e . g . , in the choice of the function P(v) satisfying either con dition ( 1 5.20 ) or ( 1 5.2 1 ) , it is natural to make clear at the start which of the compositions M 2 [N l (V)] and Nl[M 2 (V)] increases "the slower. " The conj ecture arises that to answer this question it is sufficient to know which of the two relations N l (U) -< M 2 (U) and M 2 (U) -< Nl (U) holds. But it turns out that this is not so. For example, for N l (U) = u 2 , M 2 (U) = e1ul - l u i - 1 we have that the relation N l (U) -< M 2 (U) holds. In this connection, the N-functions N1 [M 2 (V) ] and M 2 [Nl (V)] are not equivalent and inasmuch as N 1 [M 2 (v) ] "" M 2 (V) , Nl[M 2 (V)] -< M 2 [Nl (V)] M 2 [N l (V) ] "" e v' - 1 and, for arbitrary k > 0, we have that lim 1)--+ 00
Nl[M 2 (kv)] = o. M 2 [N l (V)]
The relation Nl (U) -< M 2 (U) is also true for the N-functions N 1 (u ) = e1ul - l u i - 1 and M 2 (U) = eU ' - 1 ; the N-functions N 1 [M 2 (V)] and M 2 [N l {V)] are again not equivalent - however, M 2 [Nl (V)] -< N 1 [M 2 (v)] since, for arbitrary k > 0, we have that . 11m 1)--+ 00
N l [M 2 (v)] = 00. M 2 [Nl (kv)]
A detailed comparison of conditions a) , b) and c) of Theorem
1 5.4 will be executed below. 6. On splitting a continuous operator. Let A be a positive
definite self-adj oint linear operator acting in the space L 2 of functions which are square-summable on G. As is known (see AHIEZER and GLAZMAN [ 1 ] ) , the operator A admits of the spectral decomposition
A=
f )' dEA 00
o
CHAPTER III , § 1 5
1 47
where EA is the spectral function of the operator A . The operator A 2 then admits of the spectral decomposition 00
In the case when the operator A is completely continuous, the spectral decomposition is replaced by the infinite series 00
( 1 5. 24)
i=1
where the e,,(x) are the characteristic functions o f the operator A corresponding to the non-zero characteristic numbers Ai . We denote the scalar product of the functions e(x) and
(e,
=
A 2
=
In this case,
J e (x)
G
00
�
i=1
A; (e, ,,
W e say that the operator B, acting from the Banach space E l into the Banach space E 2 with domain of definition D (B) , admits of a continuous extension ii, if ii E {E l -+ E 2 ; c.} and B
N-functions with N(u) -< u 2 -< M (u) . Suppose the operator A 2 (where A is a positive definite self-adjoint linear operator from {L 2 -+ L 2 ; c.}) admits of a continuous extension to the operator .1 2 E {EN -+ LM ; c.}. Then ..4 E {L 2 -+ LM ; c.}. PROOF. Let
� I I A2
l.e. ( 1 5.25)
L 2 is dense in EN since it contains all bounded functions. It therefore follows from ( 1 5 . 25) that the operator A admits of a continuous extension to all of EN. The extended operator will be
CHAPTER III,
1 48
§ 15
denoted by A l . The scalar product l(rp) = ( A 1rp, "P ) , where "P(x ) is a fixed element in L 2 , defines a continuous linear functional on EN. According to Theorem 1 4. 2 on the general form of a linear functional on EN, a function u(x) E LM can be found such that
l (rp) = (rp, u) =
I rp(x)u (x) dx.
G
We define the operator A ; by means of the equality
A ; "P(x) = u(x) .
In virtue of ( 1 0. 4) ,
I I A ; "P I I M =
sup p ( tp ; N ) ';; l tp(x)EEN
I ( A ; "P, rp ) l :S;;
sup I l tp 1 1 N ';; 2 tp(x)EEN
I ("P, A 1rp ) I :s;; 2 k l l"PI I L"
Consequently, the operator A ; belongs to {L 2 ---+ LM ; c.}. We shall show that A ; "P (x) = A "P(x) if "P (x) E L 2 . This follows from the fact that ( A ;"P' rp) = ("P, A 1rp ) = ("P, A rp ) = ( A "P' rp ) for arbitrary function rp(x) E L 2 . * The square root Ai of the operator A is defined as the operator whose square equals A . The operator A l has the spectral de composition 00
and, in the case of the completely continuous operator ( 1 5 . 24) , we have that
A lrp (X ) = � A.� (e i ' rp) e i (x) . 00
i=l
THEOREM 1 5. 6 . Suppose the positive definite self-adjoint operator A , which is continuous in L 2 , admits of a continuous extension to the operator .Ii E {EN ---+ LM ; c.}, where N(u) -< u 2 -< M(u) . Then
the operator A admits of the representation A = HH* ,
( 1 5 . 26)
where H E {L 2 ---+ LM ; c.} and H* is the operator in {EN ---+ L 2 ; c.} which is adjoint to H. [The operator H* is defined with the aid of the equality ( H* rp, "P ) = (rp, H"P) ("P( x) E L 2 , rp(x) E EN) .]
CHAPTER I I I, § 1 6
1 49
PROOF . We set H = Ai. In virtue of Theorem 1 5.5, H belongs to {L 2 � LM ; c.}. The operator HH* assumes the same values on L 2 as does the operator A inasmuch as (HH*cp, 'IjJ) = (H*cp, H*'IjJ) = = (Aicp, A!'IjJ) = (Acp, 'IjJ) for an arbitrary pair of functions cp(x) , 'IjJ (x) E L 2 . Therefore, the operator HH* is a continuous extension of the operator A to an operator in {EN � LM ; c.}.
Equality ( 1 5 . 26) follows from the fact that a continuous extension of the operator A is unique since L 2 is dense in EN with respect to the norm of the space EN. * The representation A = HH* will be called the splitting ot the operator A . § 1 6 . Conditions for the complete continuity o f linear integral operators 1 . The case ot continuous kernels . We now continue with the study of the linear integral operator A u(x)
=
f k(x, y)u (y) dy .
( 1 6. 1 )
G
In the present section, we shall study the problem of the con ditions for the complete continuity of the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) , i.e. the conditions under which the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) maps the unit sphere of the space LM , into a compact set in the space LM•. LEMMA 1 6. 1 . Suppose the kernel k(x, y) is continuous on C. Let
LM, and LM• be two arbitrary Orlicz spaces . Then the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to {LM, � EM. ; compo c.}. PROOF. In virtue of Theorem 1 5.4, the operator A belongs to {LM, � LM. ; c.}. Let T be the unit sphere of the space LM,. Since
f l u(x) I dx � I lu IIM, I[K (x ; G) l iN �
G
for u(x)
,
E
T, we have, for x E G, u(x)
I Au(x) I where K
=
=
I f k (x, y)u(y) dy I G
max Ik(x, y) 1 (x, y
E
mes G Mi l E
T, that
� K mes
G) .
G Mi l
( me� G )
( me� G ) ,
C HAPTER III,
1 50
§ 16
This means that the functions I Au(x) I (u(x) E T) are uniformly bounded. Let E > 0 be prescribed. We choose a lJ > 0 such that ]k(x l . y) - k(x 2 , y) 1 < E/[mes GM1 1 ( 1 /mes G)] for d(X I , X 2 ) < lJ, where d(X I , X 2 ) denotes the distance between the points Xl, X 2 E G. Then, with d(x l . X 2 ) < lJ , for an arbitrary function u(x) E T, we have, in virtue of the formula for the norm of the characteristic function of the set G in the space LN" that
I Au(Xl) - AU(X 2 ) I �
f I k(xl . y) - k(X2 , y) l I u(y) dy
G
I
�
The functions Au(x) (u(x) E T) are thus equi-continuous. In virtue of Arzela's theorem, the set AT is compact in the space C of functions which are continuous on G and, a fortiori, compact on an arbitrary Orlicz space. Since the functions Au(x) are continuous, they belong to EM,. *
2. Fundamental theorem . Conditions for the complete continuity
of operators of type ( 1 6. 1 ) can be obtained by making use of criteria for the compactness of a family of functions in Orlicz spaces. A simpler way consists in establishing the possibility of an arbitrarily close approximation of the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) by a known completely continuous operator. It is convenient to consider, as such approxi mating operators, also integral operators but with continuous kernels. In some cases, the conditions of Theorems 1 5. 1 and 1 5 . 4 are sufficient for the complete continuity of the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) . But it is unknown if they are sufficient in the general case. It turns out that the complete continuity of operator ( 1 6. 1 ) will be guaran teed if the condition k(x, y) E VI! in Theorems 1 5 . 1 and 1 5.4 is replaced by the more severe condition k(x, y) E E'l'. We shall prove this fact, which will be utilized in the sequel, from the corre sponding two assertions. THEOREM 1 6. 1 ( C ONCERNING SUFFICIENT CONDITIONS FOR COM PLETE CONTINUITY ) . Let <J>(u) and P(v) be mutually complementary
N-functions. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) of the linear integral operator
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
151
( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to the space E 'l' . Then each of the following conditions a) , b) , c) of Theorem 1 5.4 is sulficient for the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) to belong to {LM-. � EM, ; compo c.} : a) M 2 [N1(v)] -< lJI(v) ; b) N l[M 2 (V)] -< lJI(v) ; c) the function f/>(u) satisfies the t1 ' -condition and N l (V) -< lJI(v) ,
M2 (V) -< lJI(v) .
PROOF . Since k(x, y) E E'l', a sequence kn(x, y) (n = 1 , 2, . . . )
of continuous kernels can be constructed such that
I l k(x, y) - k n (x , y) I I 'l' < l in .
We shall denote the linear integral operators
Anu(x) =
I kn(x, y)u(y) dy
G
by A n . In virtue of Lemma 1 6. 1 , these operators act from LM-. into EM. and they are completely continuous. Under the conditions of the theorem j ust proved, the conditions of Theorem 1 5. 1 are also satisfied. Therefore, in virtue of ( 1 5 . 6) , we have that
I I A - A n l l � 2l l l k(x, y) - kn(x, y) I I 'l' < 2l/n
(n = 1 , 2, . . . ) .
This means that the operator A can be approximated arbitrarily closely in norm by a completely continuous operator with values in EM• . And this implies the assertion of the theorem. Theorem 1 6. 1 can be applied in two different variants . First , the problem can be posed on the properties of the function lJI(v) under which the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) acts from the given space LM, into the given space EM. and is completely continuous. In this case, the application of Theorem 1 6. 1 depends on the verification of the fact whether the kernel k(x, y) belongs to the space E'l', i .e. is the condition
I I lJI[Ak(x, y)] dx dy < G
satisfied for all A ?
<Xl
( 1 6.2)
CHAPTER III , § 1 6
1 52
If the N-function P(v) satisfies the Ll 2 -condition, then ( 1 6.2) is equivalent to the condition
I I P[k(x, y)] dx dy < (j
00.
( 1 6.3)
But if the N-function P(v) does not satisfy the Ll 2 -condition, then the verification of condition ( 1 6.2) becomes rather difficult. It is easily seen that ( 1 6.2) is satisfied if
I I P{Q[k(x, y)] } dx dy < (j
00 ,
( 1 6.4)
where Q (u) is an N-function. We also note that, under the conditions ( 1 6.2) , ( 1 6.3) and ( 1 6.4) , one can use, instead of the function P(v) , any other function R (v) which is the principal part of an N-function which is equivalent to P(v) . Second, the problem can be posed concerning finding N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (U) such that the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) with given kernel k(x, y) acts from LM, into EM. and is completely continuous. The N-functions Ml (U) and M 2 (U) are then chosen so that one of the conditions ( 1 5.20) , ( 1 5.2 1 ) and ( 1 5.22) is satisfied.
3. Complete continuity and EN-weak convergence. As is known, completely continuous linear operators acting from one Banach space into another transform a weakly convergent sequence of elements into a sequence which converges in norm. Since the class of EN-weakly convergent sequences in an Orlicz space is, generally speaking, more extensive than the class of sequences which converge weakly in the usual sense, supplementary conditions are required in order that a completely continuous linear operator acting from one Orlicz space LM, into another Orlicz space LM2 possess the analogous property with respect to EN-weak convergence. Here, we shall elucidate this problem for the linear integral operator ( 1 6. 1 ) . In this connection, we shall assume that the kernel k(x, y) of the operator A satisfies the following condition :
I I k(x, y)u(y)v (x) dx dy ()
<
00
( 1 6.5)
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
1 53
for an arbitrary pair of functions u(x) E LM., v (x) E LN •. In virtue of this condition, the operator A acts fro m Llt, into Llt. and the operator A*, defined by the equality
A*v (x) =
f k(y, x) v(y) dy,
( 1 6.6)
G
acts from LN, into LN" in which connection, the inequality
f Au(x)v (x) dx f u(y) A *v (y) dy =
G
( 1 6.7)
G
holds for an arbitrary pair of functions u(x) E LM" v(x) E LN•. LEMMA 1 6.2. A necessary and sufficient condition that the con
tinuous linear integral operator A with kernel k(x, y) , satisfying condition ( 1 6.5) , transform every EN, -weakly convergent sequence of functions in LM, into an EN. -weakly convergent sequence of functions in LM• is that the operator A* act from EN. into EN,. PROOF. The sufficiency of the condition of the lemma is evident inasmuch as, in virtue of equality ( 1 6.7) , the sequence of numbers I (Aun) =
f A nu(x) v (x) dx
G
converges for arbitrary function v (x) E E N. in virtue of the fact that A*v(x) E EN, . We shall now prove the necessity of the condition of the lemma. Suppose the continuous linear integral operator A transforms every EN,-weakly convergent sequence of functions in LM, into an EN.-weakly convergent sequence of functions in LM •. Let v(x) E EN, . Then the functional l(u) , defined on LMl by means of the equality
l(u) =
f Au (x)v (x) dx,
G
will be an EN.-weakly continuous functional on LMc In virtue of Theorem 1 4 . 7, this functional is representable in the form
l(u) =
where v* (x) E EN, .
f u(x)v*(x) dx,
G
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
1 54 Since, on the other hand, in virtue of ( 1 6.7) ,
f u(x)v*(x) dx f u(x) A*v (x) dx =
G
G
for arbitrary function u(x) E LM" we have that v* (x) A*v(x) for almost all x E G, i.e. that A*v(x) E EN,. * The following theorem can be easily obtained from this lemma. =
THEOREM 1 6.2. A necessary and sufficient condition that the completely continuous linear integral operator A with kernel k(x, y) , satisfying condition ( 1 6.5) , transform every EN, -weakly convergent sequence of functions in Llf, into a sequence of functions which converges with respect to the norm in LM. is that the operator A * act from EN. into EN,. PROOF. The necessity o f the condition o f t h e theorem follows,
in an obvious manner, from Lemma 1 6.2. The sufficiency follows from Lemma 1 6.2, Theorem 1 4.3 and Theorem 1 4.5. * We note that , under the conditions of Theorem 1 6. 1 on the complete con tinuity of the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) , condition ( 1 6.5) is satisfied and the operator A *, defined by equality ( 1 6 . 6) , acts from LN, into EN, (and, a fortiori, from EN. into EN,) . We shall prove the last assertion. Under the conditions of Theorem 1 6. 1 , conditions ( 1 5. 2) and ( 1 5 .3 ) are satisfied. Suppose v(x) E LN, and let e be an arbitrary positive number. Since the kernel k(x, y) , belonging to E'I', has an absolutely continuous norm in L t" a 15 > 0 can be found such that
mes S < 15 implies that I I k(x, Y ) K (X, y ; 2' ) 1 1 '1' < e /{2 1 I v I I N.t } (i C G) , where l is the constant in condition ( 1 5.3) . Let S C G, u(x) E LM1 . Then
f A*v(x)u(x) dx f f k(y, x)v(y)u(x) dx dy f f k(y, x)v(y)u(x) dx dy, =
8
8
=
G
=
where S S X G. Now let mes S < t5/mes G and p(u ; M) � I . Then mes S mes S mes G < 15, Il u l i M � 1 + p(u, M) � 2. Applying the Hol=
=
=
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
1 55
der inequality and ( 1 5.3) to the last integral, we obtain that
I f A *v (x)u(x) dx I
::s;
l l l k (x , Y) K(X, y ; ti) 1 I 'l' · 2 1 1 v 1 l N. <
e.
of
It follows from this that I I A *v (x) K(X ; t9') l iN, < e provided mes t9' < �/mes G. Thus, the function A *v (x) has in LN, an absolutely continuous norm and, consequently, it belongs to EN,. Thus, under the conditions of Theorem 1 6. 1 - without any other, supplementary, assumptions - the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) trans forms every EN,-weakly convergent sequence of functions into a sequence of functions which converges with respect to the norm in LM• . We note further that the assertion of Theorem 1 6.2 remains valid for abstract linear completely continuous operators A if the N-function Ml (U) satisfies the ,1 2 -condition and the operator A* is defined in the following way. Let v (x) E LN• . We consider the linear functional, defined, on LM, = EM" by means of the equality
l(u)
=
f Au(x)v (x) dx.
G
In virtue of Theorem 1 4.2, this functional can be represented in the form
l(u) =
f u(x)v*(x)dx,
G
where v* (x) E LN,. We set A *v (x) = v*(x) . Thus, the operator A* acts from LN. into LNt and ( 1 6.7) holds.
4. Zaanen ' s theorem.
LEMMA 1 6.3. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) satisfies either one of the following two conditions : a) for almost all x E G, the kernel k ( x, y) , as a function of y, belongs to the space LNt, where the function q;(x) = I l k (x, y) I IN , belongs to the space LM. ; b) for almost all Y E G, the kernel, as a function of x, belongs to the space LM., where the function P(y) = I Ik(x, y) I I M. belongs to the space LN,. Then the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to {LM, -+ LM. ; c.}. PROOF. Suppose the condition a) is satisfied. Then, m virtue
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
1 56 of Holder's inequality,
I f Au(x) v (x) dx I G
�
�
I I I k(x, y)u(y) dy I I V (X) I dx � l Iu llM1 I cp (x) I v(x) I dx
G
G
G
for arbitrary functions u(x) E LM" v (x) E LN. , from which it follows that
I I Au I iM. = sup
p(v ; N.) ';;; l
I I Au(x) v (x) dx I
� I lcpI l N. ll u I l M"
G
If condition b) is satisfied, then, interchanging the order of integration (which is possible on the basis of Fubini 's theorem) , we obtain that
I f Au(x)v (x) dx I I I I k(x, y)v (x) dx I I U(y) I dy �
G
G G
� I l v i I N.
I tp (y) l u(y) I dy
� �
I l v i l N. !ltpI I N, ll u I IM,
G
for arbitrary functions u(x) E Lk, v(x) E LN. , from which it follows that
: I Au I iM. = sup
p(v ; N.) .;;; l
I I Au(x) v(x) dx I I I Au(x) v(x) dx I G
�
�
.;;; 2
sup
' I v I IN •
G
� 2 1 I tp I I N, l l u I l M, . *
THEOREM 1 6.3. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) , as a function of y, belongs to EN, for almost all x E G, where the function cp (x) Then the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to = I I k(x, y) I I N , belongs to EM •. {LM, � EM. ; compo c.}. PROOF. In virtue of the preceding lemma, the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) =
acts from LM, into LM• and is continuous. It remains to show that this operator transforms the unit sphere T of the space Lk into a set of functions which is compact in EM•. In virtue of the EN,-weak compactness of the sphere T, it suffices to show that the operator A transforms an EN,-weakly convergent sequence of
1 57
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
functions on the sphere T into a sequence of functions in EM, which converges in norm. Suppose the sequence u n (x ) E T (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) is EN,-weakly convergent to the function uo (x) . In virtue of the condition of the theorem, the sequence of function'> A U n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges to the function Auo(x) almost everywhere and, conse quently, it converges to this function in measure. We shall show that the functions A u n (x) have equi-absolutely continuous norms in LM, . Let K (X ; rff ) be the characteristic function of the set rff C G, v (x) E L N, . Then
If
I
A U n (x) v �x) dx �
,ff
�
f I f ll(x,
8
G
y) 'u n(Y) dy
I I V (X) I dx f !p (x) I v (x) I dx, �
8
from which it follows that
x
Since the function !p (x) belongs to EM" it follows that the functions A u n ( ) have equi-absolutely continuous norms. In virtue of Lemma 1 1 .2, the sequence A u n ( x ) , which belongs to EM" converges in norm. * Theorem 1 6.3 can be augmented by the following assertion. THEOREM 1 6.4. Suppose the kernel k(x, y) , as a function of x, belongs to EM, for almost all y E G, where the function "P (y) y) I IM, belongs to EN, . Then the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to = {EM, ---+ EM, ; comp o c.}. PROOF. In virtue of Lemma 1 6.3, A E {LM-, ---+ LM , ; c.}. We consider the operator A* defined by means of equality ( 1 6.6) . In virtue of Theorem 1 6.3, the operator A * belongs to {LN . ---+ EN, ; compo c.} and transforms every EM.-weakly convergent sequence of functions in LN, into a sequence of functions in EN, which converges in norm. In virtue of Theorem 1 6.2, the operator A = (A*) * acts from EM, into EM• . In order to complete the proof, it remains to prove that the operator A transforms every EN,-weakly convergent sequence of functions from the unit sphere
I l k (x,
=
1 58
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
T of the space LM. into a sequence which converges with respect to the norm in LM • . Suppose the sequence of functions u n (x) E T (n 1 , 2, . . . ) is EN.-weakly convergent to the function uo(x) . It is easily seen that I l uo l lM . ::;;; 2. The sequence AUn (x) is EN.-weakly convergent to the function Auo(x) inasmuch as for every function u(x) E EN. we have, in virtue of equality ( 1 6 . 7) , that =
lim It-+OO
J A [u n (x) - uo(x)]v (x) dx =
G
=
lim n,->oo
I [u n (x) - uo(x)] A*v(x) dx = O.
G
Let e > 0 be given. We denote by A *Vl (x) , A *V 2 (X) , . . . , A *vs(x) a finite ( e /6) -net of the set {A *v} (p(v ; N 2 ) ::::;; 1 ) , which is compact in virtue of the complete continuity of the operator A*. Then, for every function v(x) E LN. (p(v ; N 2 ) ::::;; 1 ) we can find a function v i (V ) (x) such that I I A *v - A *v i (v ) II N 1 < e /6. Suppose the inequalities
I [un(x) - uo(x)] A *v,/ (x) dx < ;
G
(i = 1 , 2,
· · · , s
)
are satisfied for n � no . Then, for n � no, we have that
I I A [un(x) - uo(x)]v (x) dx I I [un(x) - uo(x)]A*v(x) dx I ::::;; p (v ; N. ) ';;; 1 I I I [un(x) - uo(X)]A*Vi(v) (x) dx I + p ( v; N. ) ';;; 1
I I Aun - Auo llMa = ::::;;
+
=
sup
p ( v ; N . ) ';;; 1
sup
sup
sup
p ( v ; N. ) .;;; 1
G
=
G
G
I l u n (x) - uo(x) IIA *v (x) - A *vi (V) (x) I dx <
G
i.e. the sequence Au n (x) converges in norm to Auo(x) . *
CHAPTER III,
§ 16
1 59
We note that the sufficiency of condition a) of Theorem 1 6. 1 can also be obtained as a consequence of Theorem 1 6.3 . In fact , suppose the kernel k(x, y) belongs to the space EMalN,] . Then, for arbitrary A > 0, we have that
f f M2{Nl[Ak(x, y)]} dx dy < (j
00.
( 1 6 .8 )
It follows from this that the conditions of Theorem 1 6.3 are satisfied. In fact, it follows from ( 1 6 . 8 ) that
f N1[Ak(x, y)] dx <
G
00
for arbitrary A > 0 and for almost all x E G. This means that for almost all x E G the kernel k(x, y) , as a function of y, belongs to the space EN,. I n virtue of (9. 1 2) , the estimate
q;(x) � 1 +
f Nl [k(x, y)] dy
G
is valid for the function q;(x) = Il k(x, y) I I N ,. In order to complete the proof of the theorem, it suffices to show that
f M2 [,uq; (x)] dx <
G
for arbitrary ,u > (2 mes G) - I . inasmuch as
00
This fact follows from t I 6.8)
f M2 [,uq;(x)] dx f M2 {,u + ,u f Nl [k(x, Y)] dY} dx { f N1[2,u Gk(x, y)] dX ) dx � � -!M2 (2,u) mes G + -! f M 2 �
G
G
� -!M 2 (2,u) mes G + +
1 2 mes G
G
G
�
G
mes
mes G
ff M2 {Nl [2,u mes Gk(x, y)]} dx dy < (j
00.
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
1 60
5 . Comparison 0/ conditions. As a first example, we shall consider the simplest case - when LlI , LlI. L 2 . In this case, conditions a) and b) of Theorem 1 6. 1 signify that the kernel k(x, y) must satisfy the relation =
=
f f k4 (x, y) dx dy <
00
f f k2 (X, y) dx dy <
00
G
.
But if we make use of condition c) , taking the function v 2 for the function P(v) , it turns out that the satisfaction of the relation ()
( 1 6.9)
L2.
is sufficient for the complete continuity of the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) in Condition ( 1 6.9) is less restrictive. We note that the known condition ( 1 6.9) is not necessary for the complete continuity of the linear integral operator in L 2 . It is clear that all the conditions, indicated above, for complete conti nuity in the case of arbitrary Orlicz spaces are only sufficient . As a second example, we note that it follows from this same condition c) of Theorem 1 6. 1 that the linear integral operator ( 1 6. 1 ) acts from L "' , into L "' . (CX1 > 1 , CX 2 > 1 ) and is completely continuous if the kernel k(x, y ) is p-th power summable on G with p equal to max {jh , CX 2}, where I /CX1 + l /fh = 1 . In order to obtain this known result (which, of course, is proved directly quite simply) , it suffices to set P(v) = I v l max{pl, "" } . e1 u l ( 1 + l u i ) In ( 1 + l u i ) - l u i , Now, let M 1 ( ) - l u i - 1 . In this case, N1 (u) M 2 (u) . From Theorem 1 6. 1 there follow three conditions which are sufficient that the operator ( 1 6. 1 ) act from Lk L M into E M. and be completely continuous. These conditions can be written in the form
U
M2 (U)
=
=
=
=
ff G
exp {exp l A.k (x, y) l } dx dy < 00
if we make use of conditions a) or b) , and in the form
ff ()
exp 1 A.k(x, y) l dx dy < 00
if we make use of condition c) , setting P(v)
=
( 1 6. 1 0)
M 2 (V) .
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
161
Thus, in this case also, condition c) turns out t o be less restrictive . The last example is an illustration of the following theorem (which follows directly from Theorem 1 6. 1 ) - this theorem will play an important role in the study of integral equations with essentially non-power non-linearities. THEOREM 1 6.5. Suppose M (u) and N (v) are mutually comple
mentary N-functions where N(v) satisfies the LJ '-condition. Let
f f M[Ak(x, y)] dxdy < G
00
for arbitrary A > o. Then the linear integral operator ( 1 6. 1 ) belongs to {LN -+ EM ; compo c. } . In the next example, we set M1 (u) = l u l IX/ae (ae > 1 ) , M 2 (U) = = e1ul - l u i - 1 . For the complete continuity of operator ( 1 6. 1 ) , it is sufficient : in virtue of condition a) that
ff G
exp I Ak(x, y) I P dx dy < 00
(� + �
= 1
)
for arbitrary A > 0, and in virtue of conditions b) or c) that
ff G
exp I Ak(x, y) I dxdy < 00
.
The second condition is, of course, less restrictive . We note, further, that it coincides with condition ( 1 6. 1 0) , which was obtained in the preceding example. This is not accidental since the following more general assertion holds. THEOREM 1 6.6. Let
( 1 6. 1 1 )
Then every linear operator in {Llr , -+ EM. ; compo c.} belongs to {L4> , -+ E� . ; compo c.}. PROOF. The fact that A E {L4> -+ E�.} follows from the inclusions L4> , C Llr" EM. C E�• . In virtue of Theorem 1 3.3 and ( 1 6. 1 1 ) , the inequalities lI u l lM, � q l l 1u l l�, (u(x) E L4> , ) and lI u l l �. � Q 2 I1 u I lM. (u(x) E Llr.) hold. Let T be a bounded set in L4> , . In virtue of the first of the above inequalities, T is also bounded in Llr, . Therefore, the set AT is compact in Llr •. In virtue of the second inequality, it is also compact in L4> • . * Convex junctions
II
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 6
1 62
I t follows from the preceding examples that condition c) is less restrictive, in a number of cases, than conditions a) and b) . We shall now give an example which shows that this is not always so. Let M l (U) = e1ul - l u i - 1 , M 2 (U ) = ( 1 + l u i ) In (1 + l u i ) - l u i . In this case, EM. = Lid. = LM •. It follows from conditions a) and b) of Theorem 1 6 . 1 that the operator ( 1 6 . 1 ) belongs to {Lid, -+ EM . ; compo c.} if the inequality
f f I k(x, (j
Y) I In 2 ( 1 + I k(x, y) I ) dx dy < =
( 1 6. 1 2)
is satisfied. Application of condition a) leads to the assumption that the kernel k (x, y) is summable with some power 01: > 1 , i.e . it leads to a more restrictive condition (see Remark, p. 1 46) . Summarizing everything stated above, we can formulate a rule for finding a function lJI(v) satisfying the conditions of Theorem 1 6. 1 . In this connection , we shall assume that any two N-functions q} l (U) and q} 2 (U) , which may be under consideration, are "compa rable, " i. e. that one of the relations : q} l (U) -< q} 2 (U) and q} 2 (U) -< q} l (U) is satisfied. In the first case, we shall say that q}l (U) is "smaller" than q} 2 (U) and in the second that q}l (U) is " larger" than q} 2 (U) . Let the spaces Lid, and Lid. be given. We consider the N-functions Ml (U) and N 2 (U) . If the "smaller" of them satisfies the LJ '-condition, then we shall consider the complementary N-function to it to be equal to lJI(v) . Obviously, in this case condition c) is satisfied which leads to the least (in comparison with conditions a) and b)) restrictions on the kernel k(x, y) . But if the "smaller" of the functions Ml (U) and N 2 (u) does not satisfy the LJ '-condition then two cases are possible : 1 . Both of the functions M1 (u) and N 2 (U) increase more rapidly than an arbitrary power l u l <% ( 01: > 1 ) . We shall assume that they satisfy the LJ 3-condition. Then the functions N l (V) and M 2 (v) increase less rapidly than any power I v l P ({J > 1 ) . Making use of condition a) or b) of Theorem 1 6. 1 and Theorem 6.9, we can set lJI(v) = N l (v) M 2 (v) / l v l which is equivalent , in this case, t.o one of the functions M 2 [N1 (v)] or N1[M 2 (v)] and is "smaller" than the other. It is easily seen that the function lJI(v) also increases less rapidly than any power of the form Iv l P ({J > 1 ) . But any function lJI(v) , which satisfies condition c) in virtue of the
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
1 63
remark on p. 1 46, increases more rapidly than some power function I v l fio ({Jo > 1 ) , which leads to a greater restriction on the kernel k(x, y) . 2. The " smaller" of the functions M 1 (u) and N 2 (u) does not satisfy the LI /-condition but it does not satisfy the LI s-condition either. In this case, we can make use of condition c) , taking as the function P(v) some N-function which is larger than N1 (v) and M 2 (v) but whose complementary function satisfies the LI -condition. One can also make use of conditions a) or b) , taking as the function P(v) the function M 2 [N l (V)] or N l [M 2 (V)] . In some cases, the first method leads to a lesser restriction with respect to the kernel k(x, y) and, in other cases, the second. We shall elucidate this by means of examples. Let M1 (u) = u 2 /2, M 2 (U) = u 2 ( l ln l u l l + 1 ) . In this case, the function N 2 (u) is equivalent to the N-function zf 2 /ln ( l u l + e) -< -< M l (U) and does not satisfy the LI /-condition. Making use of condition c) , setting P(v) I v l 2 + e, where e is a positive number, we arrive at the following restriction on the kernel k(x, y ) : I
=
I I I k(x, y) 1 2 + e dx dy < 00 (j
.
Application of condition a) or b) leads to the worse conditions :
I I I k(x, Y) 1 4 ln2 ( l k(x, y) 1 + l ) dx dy < 00 (]
or
I I I k(x, y) 1 4 ln ( l k(x, y) 1 + l ) dx dy < 00, (j
respectively. Now let M l (U) = elul - l u i - 1 , M 2 (u) = u 2 ( l ln lu l l + 1 ) . In this case, the N-function N 2 (Zf) is also "smaller" than M1 (u) and does not satisfy the LI /-condition. Application of condition a) leads to the following restriction on the kernel k(x, y) :
I I I k(x, Y) 1 2 1n3 ( l k(x, y) 1 + l ) dx dy < 00 ()
CHAPTER I I I, § 1 6
1 64
and application of condition b) leads t o the restriction
I I I k(x Y) 1 2 G
,
ln 2 ( l k(x , Y ) 1 + l ) dxdy <
=.
But to apply condition c) one must take as the function tP(u) , complementary to P(v) , a function which is "smaller" than u 2 /ln ( l u l + e) and which satisfies the LI '-condition. Such a function can be, for example, the function l u I 2 -., where 0 < e < 1 . But then the function P(v) will increase as I v 1 2+B1 (el > 0) which leads to a worse condition. 6 . On splitting a completely continuous operator. THEOREM 1 6.7. Let M(u) and N(u) be mutually complementary N-functions with N(u) -< u 2 -< M(u) . Suppose the operator A 2 (where A is a positive definite self-adjoint linear operator in {L 2 _ L 2 ; compo c. } ) admits of a continuous extension to the operator ..42 E {EN - Lif ; compo c. } . Then A E {L 2 - Lif ; compo c. } . PROOF. Since the conditions of Theorem 1 5.5 are satisfied, we have that A E {L 2 - Lif ; c. } . Let A l be the operator acting from EN into L 2 , introduced in the proof of Theorem 1 5.5. As was proved, A is the adj oint operator to A I. Therefore, to prove the complete continuity of the operator A, i t suffices to prove that the operator A l i s completely continuous. Let !p l (X} , !P 2 (X) , . . . be an EN-weakly convergent sequence of functions in L 2 . Then A 1 !Pt (x) = A!pt(x) and
I I A 1 ( !P n - !Pm) I J l.
=
(Ai {!P n - !Pm) , !pn - !Pm ) < < I I A 2 (!p I� - !Pm ) I I M I I !P n - !Pm I I N .
The first factor in the right member tends to zero since the operator A 2 is by assumption completely continuous and trans forms every EN-weakly convergent sequence of functions into a sequence whi ch converges with respect to the norm in Lif. The second factor in the right member is bounded. Consequently, the sequence A1 !P n (x) (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) converges in norm in L 2 . N ow let "1'1 (x) , "1' 2 (x) , . . . be an arbitrary sequence which con verges weakly in EN. Since L 2 is dense in EN, a sequence !p I (x) , !P 2 (X) , . . . can be found in L 2 such that I I V'n - !P n i l N - O. The sequence !P l (X) , !P 2 (X) , . . . is also weakly convergent . As was already
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
1 65
proved, the sequence AI !P n (x) converges in norm in L 2 . Therefore, the sequence AI1J' n (X) also converges in norm in L 2 inasmuch as
I I A1 (1J' n - 1J'm) l l L ' � I I A1 ( !P n - !Pm) ll L ' + + I I A1 ( !P n - 1J' n ) l l L ' + I I A1 (!Pm - 1J'm ) II L2 '
*
Following a line of reasoning analogous to that used in the proof of Theorem 1 5.6, we arrive at the following proposition. THEOREM 1 6.8. Suppose the positive definite self-adjoint completely
continuous linear operator A in L 2 admits of a continuous extension to an operator A E {EN _ LM ; compo c.}, where N(u) -< u 2 -< M(u) . Then the operator A splits, i.e. A = HH*, where H E {L 2 _ LM ; compo c.} and H* is the operator from {EN _ L 2 ; compo c.} which is adjoint to H. 7 . On operators of potential type. We shall assume that G is a closed bounded region (with a sufficiently smooth boundary) in n-dimensional space. An operator of potential type is a linear integral operator whose kernel is symmetric and satisfies the condition
a I k(x, y) 1 � ,r). ,
(x, Y E G) ,
( 1 6. 1 3)
where r is the distance between the points x and y. A detailed theory of operators of potential type is developed in S . SOBOLEV [ 1 ] in connection with embedding theorems. S . Sobolev and other authors showed that under definite relations among the numbers A, oc and the dimension n of the space, an operator of potential type acts from the space LOI into a definite space LOll or into the space C of continuous functions. In particular, for A = nj2, an operator of potential type acts, according to S. Sobolev's theorems, from the space L 2 into an arbitrary space LOll (OCI > 1 ) . Theorems on the splitting of linear operators enable one to strengthen this assertion. Let A be a linear integral operator acting in L 2 whose kernel satisfies condition ( 1 6. 1 3) in which A = nj2. Then the operator A 2 will also be a linear integral operator with kernel
k 2 (x, y)
=
I k(x, z) k(z, y) dz
G
.
CHAPTER III, § 1 6
1 66
A direct calculation, using condition ( 1 6. 1 3) , shows that ( 1 6. 1 4)
Consequently, k 2 (x y) E Lt" where P(u) = e1uI - l ui - 1 . In virtue of Theorem 1 5 .4, the operator A 2 , defined by the kernel k 2 (x, y) , acts from the space E� = L�, where
Theorem 1 5.5, we arrive at the conclusion that A E {L 2 � Lt, ; c.}. Let Pl (U) = l u l (e'U,H - I ) , where 0 < e < 1 . It is easily seen that P1 (u) satisfies the LJ 2 -condition. Therefore, the comple mentary function
f f Pl{l k2 (x, y) l l /(l-£) } dx dy o
<
00.
In virtue of Theorem 1 6. 1 , the operator .,4 2 acts from E�, = L� , into Lt" . Applying Theorem 1 6.7, we arrive at the conclusion that A E {V � Lt, , ; compo c.}. Thus, the following theorem is valid. THEOREM 1 6.9. Suppose the symmetric kernel k (x, y) satisfies the condition ( 1 6. 1 3) , where A = nj2. Then the linear integral operator A,
defined by the kernel k(x, y) . acts from V into Lt" where P(u) = = e1uI - l u i - I , and is continuous - and, as an operator acting from V into Lt" , where Pl (U) = l u i (e1ul' -' - 1 ) (0 < e < I ) , it is completely continuous. As is known, the Green function k(x, y) of the Laplace operator (in the case of homogeneous boundary conditions) for a four dimensional region satisfies the inequality I k (x, y) 1 � ajr2 . We find ourselves in a situation where the conditions of Theorem 1 6. 9 are satisfied. Consequently, the Green function in the case of a four-dimensional region gen erates a linear integral operator belonging to {L 2 � Lt, ; c.} and {L 2 � Lt, , ; compo c.}, where P(u) and P1 (u) are the N-functions defined above. We note one more fact. The Green function of the Laplace operator for a two-dimensional region satisfies the condition I k (x, y) I < b + c l In I r l l . It follows from Theorem 1 5. 6 that the linear operator A, defined by this Green's function, is splittable
CHAPTER III, § 1 7
1 67
in the sense that it is representable in the form A = HH*, where H E {V -+ Ly., ; c.} and H* is the operator in {Edl -+ V ; c.} which is adj oint to H. An analogous representation A = HH*, where H E {L 2 -+ Lir , ; compo c.}, H* E {EdI , -+ V ; compo c.}, follows from Theorem 1 6.8. In the last two assertions, the N-functions P(u) and Pl (U) are the functions indicated in the formula of Theorem 1 6.9. § 17. Simplest nonlinear operator 1 . The CaratModory condition. We say that the real-valued function f(x, u) of the two variables x E G, - = < u < =, satisfies the CaratModory condition if it is continuous in u for almost all x E G and measurable in x for every fixed u. The following theorem holds. THEOREM 1 7. 1 . A function f(x, u) satisfies the CaratModory condition if, and only if, to a prescribed e > 0 there corresponds
a closed set Go C G such that mes (G"'Go) < e and the function f(x, u) is continuous in aU variables on the set Go X ( - =, =) .
The sufficiency of the condition in the theorem is obvious. For a proof of the necessity, see KRASNOSEL'SKII and LADYZENSKII [ I J and KRASNOSEL'SKII [5J . We shall denote by f the operator defined on the set of real valued functions u(x) (x E G) by means of the equality
fu(x)
=
f[x, u(x) J .
( 1 7. 1 )
If the Caratheodory conditio ri is satisfied, then, in virtue of Theorem 1 7. 1 , the operator f transforms measurable functions into measurable functions - and it transforms sequences of functions which are convergent in measure into sequences of functions which are also convergent in measure. In the sequel, when we consider operators defined by formula ( 1 7. 1 ) , we shall always assume that the corresponding functions satisfy the Caratheodory condition . 2. Domain of definition of the operator J. We recall that JI(EM, r) denotes the totality of functions u(x) E LM for which d(u, EM) < r (see p. 82) . We shall denote the sphere of radius r and center at the point u of the Banach space E by T(u, r ; E) .
CHAPTER Ill, § 1 7
1 68
LEMMA 1 7 . 1 . Let h (x, 0)
=
(x E G) .
0
( 1 7 .2)
Suppose the operator h acts trom a sphere T(O, r ; L"M , ) into the space L"M. , the class LM. or EM • . Then the operator h acts trom II(EM" r) into the space L"M. , the class L M. or EM., respectively . It the operator h acts trom the sphere T(O, r ; EM,) into L"M. , L M. or EM. , then it acts trom aU ot EM, into L"M., L M. or EM. , respectively. PROOF . Let u(x) E II(EM " r) . In virtue of Lemma 1 0. 1 , a set Go C G can be found such that U(X) K(X ; Go) E EM, and I l uo l I M, < r, where uo(x) = U(X) K(X ; G""Go) . The function U(X) K(X ; Go) has an absolutely continuous norm . Therefore, the function u(x) can be written in the form U(X)
=
where I l u�II M, < r (i
uo(x) + Ul (X) + . . . + U k (X) ,
=
0, I , . . . , k) , and, for i ¥= /,
u,! (x)Uj(x)
=
0
(x E G) .
In virtue of ( 1 7.2) ,
hUi (X)huj(x) = 0
(x E G, i ¥= i) ,
( 1 7.3)
and
If hT(O, r ; L"M, ) C L"M . , then each of the terms in the right member of formula ( 1 7 . 4) is a function in L"M • . Therefore, hu(x) also belongs to L"M •. If hT(O, r ; L"M , ) e L M. , then, in virtue of ( 1 7.3) ,
f M[hu(x)] dx i�O f M[hui (X)] dx <
G
=
G
00 ,
i.e. hu(x) also belongs to LM• . If hT(O, r ; L"M, ) C EM. , then all the terms in the right member of ( 1 7 . 4) are functions in EM• . Therefore, hu(x) is also an element in EM • . Finally, if h is considered only on the functions in EM" then 149(X) = o. Therefore, hT(O, r ; EM,) C L"M. implies that all the
1 69
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 7
terms in the right member of ( 1 7 . 4) belong to Llr . and, conse quently, JIu(x) is also an element in Llr • . The remaining cases are considered analogously. * Let us now assume that the N-function M1 (U) satisfies the Ll 2 -condition. It then follows from Lemma 1 7 . 1 that the operator JI is defined on the entire space Llr, = LM, = EM, provided it is defined on any sphere of this space. The question naturally arises whether or not this fact holds in the case when M 1 (U) does not satisfy the Ll 2 -condition. It turns out that this is not so. In fact , if M l (U) does not satisfy the Ll 2 -condition, then the operator ( 1 7 .5) JIu(x) = M2" 1 {M1[U(X)]} acts from the unit sphere in the space Llr , into L M. since
f M2 [JIu(x)] dx f M1[u(x)] dx ::::;; Ilu l lM,
G
=
G
::::;; 1
for lI u l l M, ::::;; 1 . However, in an arbitrary sphere of radius r :::;;; 1 , a function u(x) can be found such that JIu(x) E L M •. To this end, it suffices to choose a function u(x) , with norm Il u ll M, < r, which does not belong to LM, . If the N-function M2 (U) satisfies the Ll 2 -condition, then the operator ( 1 7 .5) from the unit sphere of the space Llr, acts simul taneously into Llr. , LM. and EM. since Llr. = LM. = EM• . How ever, not all its values on a sphere of larger radius belong to Llr• . THEOREM 1 7.2. Suppose the operator f acts from a sphere
T((), r ; Llr,) into the space L M• or into the space EM• . Then the operator f acts from II(EM" r) into the space Llr. or into the space EM. , respectively . If the operator f acts from the sphere T((), r ; EM) into Llr. or into EM. , then it acts from all of EM , into Llr. or into EM. , respectively . PROOF. The function h (x, u) = f(x, u) - f(x, 0) satisfies con
JIu(x) = /I [x, u(x)] . This implies the assertion of the theorem. * 3. Theorems on continuity . A nonlinear operator B, acting from the Banach space E1 into the Banach space E 2 , is said to be continuous at the point Uo E E1 if lim I I Bu - Buo iI E . = o .
dition ( 1 7.2) . Therefore, Lemma 1 7. 1 can be applied to the operator
u eE, Ilu - uoI I E ,""' O
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 7
1 70
For nonlinear operators, in distinction from the case of linear operators, continuity at one point does not imply continuity at other points. In general, a nonlinear operator can be defined, as we saw in the example of the operator I, only on a part of the space E l. A nonlinear operator B is said to be bounded on the sphere T of the space E l if sup I I Bu I I E. < 00 . xeT
In distinction from linear operators, the concepts of boundedness and continuity are not connected with one another in the case of nonlinear operators : there exist discontinuous operators which are bounded and, conversely, there exist operators which are continuous on the entire space but which are not bounded on any spheres. In the sequel, we shall find the following assertion from KRASNO SEL'SKII [5] , pp. 3 1 , 35, 36, useful. LEMMA 1 7 .2. Suppose the operator g acts from the space L of
summable functions into the space L . Then the operator g is continuous and bounded with respect to the norm of the space L and the function g(x, u) satisfies the condition (x E G, - 00 < u < 00) ,
Ig(x, u) 1 � a(x) + b l u i
where a(x) E L and b is a positive number . THEOREM 1 7.3. If the operator I acts from II(EM" r) into EM" then I is continuous at every point of II(EM" r) . PROOF. We shall first assume that If) = f) and show that the operator I is continuous at the zero f) of the space LM, . If we assume the contrary, there exists a sequence ot funct i ons u (x) E LM, (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) such that l i m I l u l l M, = 0
whereas
n�oo
n
I I Iu I I M. > oc
n
(n = 1 , 2, . . . ) ,
n
( 1 7 . 6)
( 1 7.7)
where oc is some number . It follows from Lemma 9.2 and ( 1 7 . 6) that lim n-->-oo
f M [�ttn(x) ] dx = O. r
G
1
( 1 7.8)
171
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 7 I t follows from ( 1 7.7) that
I M2 [ � Jun(X) ] dx � " � Jun 1 M2 - 1
G
> I.
( 1 7 . 9)
Thus, if the operator J is discontinuous at zero, then there exists a sequence of functions u n (x) E LM, such that relations ( 1 7.8) and ( 1 7. 9) hold. We now consider the operator g defined by means of the formula
If u(x) is a summable function, then Ml l [u(x)] E LM,. In virtue of Theorem 1 0. 1 , Ml l [u(x)] E JI(EM" 3/2) . Therefore,
By the condition of the theorem, we have that
J
( ; M 1 1 [u(x)] ) E EM
•.
This means that gu(x) E L . In virtue of Lemma 1 7.2, the operator g, acting from L into L, is continuous at zero. It therefore must follow from ( 1 7.8) that
l��
I g {Ml [ � ]}
G
U n (X )
dX =
l��
I M2 [ � Jun(X) ] x
d = o.
G
We have thus arrived at a contradiction with ( 1 7.9) . This means that the operator J is continuous at the zero of the space LAt, if JO = O. We now proceed t o the consideration o f the general case : we shall show, without any additional assumptions, that the operator J is continuous at an arbitrary point uo(x) of the set JI(EM" r) . Let d = d (uo, EM , ) . Clearly, d < r. The continuity of the operator J at the point uo(x) is equivalent to the continuity of the operator /Iu(x) = J[uo(x) + u(x)] - Juo(x) at the zero of the space LM, . The operator /I acts from the sphere T(O, r - d ; LAt, ) into EM• . d ) into EM• . In virtue of Theorem 1 7.2, it acts from JI(EM" r
-
CHAPTER I I I § 1 7
1 72
Since hO 0 , we have, by what has already been proved, that the operator h is continuous at the zero of LM,. * We note that Theorem 1 7.3 yields a rough criterion for the continuity of the operator f. Even the continuity, for example, of the operator of the identity transformation (i.e. of the operator fu(x) u(x) ) in the spaces LM does not follow from it if M (u) does not satisfy the L1 2 -condition. If, under the conditions of Theorem 1 7 .3, the N-function M 2 (U) satisfies the L1 2 -condition, then this theorem signifies that the operator f is continuous if it acts into the space LM. = LM• = EM•. The question arises whether the operator f is always continuous if it acts from II(EM" r) into the space LM. when M 2 (U) does not satisfy the L1 2 -condition. It turns out that the operator f is not always continuous. Here is an example. Let =
=
( 1 7. 1 0) where M l eU) satisfies but M 2 (U) does not satisfy the L1 2 -condition. Clearly, the operator f acts from II(EM" I ) = L M , into LM•. Suppose v(x) belongs to LM• but that v ex) E EM• . Then, in virtue of Lemma 1 0. 1 , we have that lim I l v - v nl l M. = d(v, EM.) = d > 0,
where
vn(x)
=
{
vex) if I v (x) I o if I v (x) I
�
>
( 1 7. 1 1 )
n, n.
1 1 7 . 1 2)
The functions u n (x) = M l l {M 2 [V (X ) - Vll (x)]} belong to LM" with lim ft,-+OO
f Ml[Un (x)] dx
o
=
lim n�oo
f M [V
0
2 (X ) - vn(x)] dx
=
O.
Since, in L M" mean convergence implies convergence in norm, we have that lim I l u nllM, O. From this equality and ( 1 7 . 1 1 ) , =
n--.. oo
it follows that the operator f is discontinuous at the zero of the space LM, since fU n (x) = v ex) - v n (x) .
4. Boundedness 0/ the operator f. The boundedness of the set of values of the operator f on a sphere of the space LM, can be
1 73
CHAPTER III, § 1 7
proved under fewer restrictions that those under which the continui ty of the operator 1 was proved in Theorem 1 7.3. THEOREM 1 7.4. Suppose the operator 1 acts trom the sphere
T(O, r ; LM, ) into the class L M• . Then 1 is bounded on any sphere T(O, r l ; LM,) (rl < r) : sup 11 1u 1 1 M. < 00 .
I luIlM,
PROOF. In virtue of Lemma 1 7. 1 , the operator [fu(x) - 10]/2 acts from II(EM" r) into the class L M• . Therefore the operator
gv(x) = M2{t1(r l M1 1 [v (X)] ) - 110}
acts from L into L . For functions u (x) E T(O, r l ; LM,) we have that
f M [ --;-U(X);-] dx � l .
G
1
In virtue of Lemma 1 7.2,
i.e. sup Ilul l M, < T1
f M2[l1u(x) - 110] dx < 00
.
G
Consequently, sup IluIIM,
1 1 1u 1 1 M. � 1 1 10 11 M. + sup
IluIlM,
1 1 1u - 10 1 1 M. �
The question arises whether the operator 1 is bounded on spheres with larger radii. It turns out that this is not necessarily so. As an example, we consider again the operator ( 1 7 . 1 0) in which connection we shall assume that M1 (u) does not satisfy but M 2 (U) satisfies the .1 2-condition. The operator ( 1 7. 1 0) acts from the class LM, into L M• = EM, and, in virtue of Theorem 1 7.3, it is continuous on EM, . We shall show that the values of this operator 1 are not bounded on every sphere T(O, 1 + e ; EM,) ' where e is an arbitrary positive number.
1 74
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 7
Since M 2 (U) satisfies the L1 2 -condition, boundedness in norm is equivalent to boundedness in the mean. It therefore suffices to show that there exists a sequence of functions u n (x) E T((), 1 + e ; EM,) such that
( 1 7 . 1 3) The functions u n (x) are defined by equalities similar to ( 1 7. 1 2) where u (x) is a function not belonging to LM, such that I l u l I M, < 1 + e. The existence of the function u(x) follows from Theorem 1 0. 1 . If relation ( 1 7 . 1 3) were not satisfied for the functions u n (x) , then, in virtue of Fatou's theorem (see p. 7 1 ) , the function u(x) would belong to L M,. 5. General form of the operator J. THEOREM 1 7 .5. The operator f acts from the class LM, into the
class L M• if, and only if, M2[f(x, u)]
:s;;
a(x)
+
bM l (U)
(x E G, - 00 < u < 00) , ( 1 7. 1 4)
where a(x) E L, b � O . PROOF. If f acts from L M , into L M" then the operator gv(x) = = M2{j(M l 1 [v (x)J)} acts from L into L and, in virtue of Lemma 1 7.2, we have that . M2{t[x, Ml 1 (v)]} :s;; a(x) + b l v l . Setting v = M(u) in the last inequality, we obtain ( 1 7. 1 4) . The sufficiency
of condition ( 1 7 . 1 4) is obvious. * We now assume that condition ( 1 7. 1 4) is satisfied. Then, in virtue of ( 1 . 20) , we have that
I f(x, u) 1
:s;;
c(x)
+
b 1M2" 1 [M l (U)]
(x E G, - 00 < u < 00 ) , ( 1 7 . 1 5)
where c(x) = M2" l [a(x)] E LM, . Thus, condition ( 1 7 . 1 5) is necessary in order that the operator f act from LM, into LM,. In the case when the N-function M 2 (U) satisfies the L1 2 -condition, condition ( 1 7. 1 5) is at the same time a sufficient condition inasmuch as in this case ( 1 7 . 1 5) implies ( 1 7 . 1 4) . 6 . Sufficient conditions for the continuity and boundedness of the operator J. The assertions proved above imply the next theorem.
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 7
1 75
THEOREM 1 7 .6. Suppose the function f(x, u) satisfies the zn
equality
[
I f(x, u) 1 � c(x) + b 1M;; 1 M I (X E G, - =
<
u
( : )]
( 1 7 . 1 6)
< =) ,
where c(x) E L M2 , bi � 0, in which connection the N-function M2(U) satisfies the iJ 2-condition. Then the operator f acts from II(EM" r) into the space L'ivl , = EM2 , is continuous at all points of II(EM " r) , and is bounded on every sphere T((), r l ; LM.) (ri < r) . If the N-function M2(U) does not satisfy the iJ 2 -condition, then one must require, in order to have continuity of the operator f, that the set of its values belong to E M2 . Therefore , we must place more severe restrictions on the function f(x, u) . THEOREM 1 7 .7. Suppose the function f(x, u) satisfies the in equality ( 1 7. 1 7) I f ( x, u) I � b (x) + aQ- I M;; 1 M I
{
(x E G, - = < u
[ ( : )]}
<
=) ,
where b(x) E EM" Q (u) is an N-function, and a, r are positive numbers. Then the operator f acts from II(EM1, r) into EM2 , is continuous at all points of II(EM1 , r) , and is bounded on every sphere T((), r I ; LM.) (rr < r) . 7. The operator f and EN -weak convergence . We proved the continuity of the operator f under the assumption that it acts from the sphere T((), r ; LM.) into EM,. The boundedness of the operator f was established under weaker hypotheses. We shall show that the continuity of the operator f in some weakened sense can be proved under these weaker assumptions. THEOREM 1 7 .8. Suppose the operator f acts from the sphere T((), r ; LMJ into the class LM2 . Then this operator transforms an arbitrary sequence u n (x) E T((), r ; L'ivI.) , which converges in norm in the space LM I to the interior point uo(x) of this sphere, into the
sequence of functions fUn (x) which is EN 2 -weakly convergent in the space LM2 to the function fuo(x) . PROOF. Since the functions u n (x) converge in norm to the function uo(x) , they also converge to this function in measure .
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 76
Therefore, the sequence of functions JU n (x) also converges in norm to the function Juo(x) . Since the function u o (x) is an interior point of the sphere T((), r ; LM,) , we may assume, without loss of gener ality, that all u n ( x) E T((), r l ; LM,) , where r l < r. It follows from Theorem 1 7.4 that the norms of the functions JU n (x) are uniformly bounded. In virtue of Theorem 1 4.6, this sequence is EN-weakly convergent to the function Juo(x) . * § 18. Differentiability. Gradient of the norm
1 . Differentiable functionals. We shall consider real-valued functionals defined on Orlicz spaces LM (or on parts of these spaces) . We say that the functional F(u) is differentiable at the point uo (x) , which is an interior point of the domain of definition of this functional, if the increment of the functional can be written in the form F (uo + h) - F(uo) = l u o (h) + w (uo, h) , ( 1 8. 1 ) where l u o(h) is a linear functional on LM and the remainder w (uo, h) satisfies the condition lim IIhll� O
w (uo, h) ----'---'- - 0
I l h i lM
.
( 1 8.2)
The functional F(u) is differentiable on the set m if it is differ entiable at every point of m. The operator r which assigns the functional l u o to the element uo (x) E m is called the gradient of the functional F(u) . The gradient acts from the space LM into the conj ugate space. The space LN, where N (v) is the complementary function to M(u) , can be con sidered as a part of the conj ugate space. In the case when the gradient acts into LN, equality ( 1 8. 1 ) can be rewritten in the form
F(uo + h) - F(uo)
=
(ruo, h) + w (uo, h) ,
( 1 8.3)
where, as usual, the symbol (w, h) denotes the inner product :
(w, h)
=
f w(x)h(x) dx
G
(w(x) E LN, h(x) E LM) .
We shall retain the terminology gradient for the operator which assigns the function ruo (x) to the function uo (x) .
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 77
2. Measurability of the function O (x} . Suppose the function F(x, u} (x E G, 00 < u < oo ) satisfies the Caratheodory con ditions and has a continuous derivative with respect to u : F�(x, u) . Clearly, the function F�(x, u } also satisfies the Caratheodory -
conditions. Suppose u(x} is a measurable function on G. On the basis of th e mean-value theorem, there exists a function O (x} such that
F (x, u(x} } - F(x, O}
=
u(x}F�(x, O (x}u(x} } .
( 1 8.4)
Generally speaking, the function O(x} is not uniquely defined. We shall use the following assertion in the sequel. LEMMA 1 8. 1 . There exists a measurable function O(x) , satisfying
the inequalities
o
� O (x} � 1 ,
( 1 8.5)
for which equality ( 1 7. 2 1 ) is satisfied . PROOF. We define the function O (x} for all x E G as the minimum of those 0 E [0, I J for which the equality =
F(x, u(x}} - F(x, O}
u(x}F� (x, Ou(x} }
is satisfied. This minimum exists inasmuch as F�(x, u} is continuous with respect to u. Let [; > 0 be given. In virtue of Luzin's C-property and Theorem 1 7. 1 , a set GI C G can be found such that mes (G",GI) < [; and the functions F�(x, u} , F(x, O} , F(x, u} and u(x} are continuous in all variables simultaneously for x E GI, 00 < u < 00 Since [; is arbitrary, it will suffice to prove the measurability of O (x} on GI. Let Xo E G l , Xn E GI (n = 1 , 2, . . . ) and -
lim Xn
=
lim O(x n}
x,
�oo
n-+oo
=
.
00.
Passing to the limit in the equality
F(xn, u(xn}} - F(x n, O}
=
U(Xn) F� (xn, O(x n }u(xn} } ,
we obtain that
F(xo, u(xo} } - F(xo, O}
=
u(xo}F� (xo, Oou(xo} } .
The last equality implies that O (xo} � 00. This means that the function O (x} is lower semi-continuous on GI and, consequently, that it is measurable. * Co...es
'....clUJ"s
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 78
3 . Functional for the operator J. F 1 (u)
=
We now consider the functional
I dx I f(x, s) ds . u (x)
G
0
( 1 8. 6)
We shall be interested in the case when the functional Fl (U) is defined on a part of the space LM which is a part of the space L 2 . In this case, the N-function M (u) and the function N (v) comple mentary to it are connected by the relations N (u) -< u 2 -< M(u) . Since N (u) does not increase more rapidly than u 2 , it will satisfy the ,1 2 -condition in the fundamental cases. It is under this as sumption that the following theorem is proved. THEOREM 1 8. 1 . Let the operator J act from IJ(EM, r) into the space Liv = LN . Then the functional ( 1 8. 6) is defined and differ
entiable on IJ(E M , r) , in which connection its gradient is the operator J. PROOF. Let u(x) E IJ(EM" r) . In virtue of Lemma 1 8. 1 , a measurable function O (x) can be found, satisfying condition ( 1 8.S) , such that
Fl (U) I dx I f(x, s) ds I f[x, O (x)u (x)]u(x) dx. u(x)
=
=
G
G
O
Clearly, O(x) u(x) E IJ(E M, r) . Therefore, f[x, O (x)u(x)] E L N . Conse quently, J l (U) I � I I JOu l l N I l u l i M < 00, from which it follows that the functional l (U) is defined on IJ(EM, r) . In virtue of the same Lemma 1 8. 1 , to each function h (x) E LM such that I l h i l M < r - d(u, EM) there corresponds a measurable function O h (X) , satisfying condition ( 1 8. S ) , such that
F
F
J Fl (U + h) - Fl (U) - (Ju, h) I =
=
I I [I(x, u(x) + Oh(x)h(x) ) G
I
- f(x, u(x) )]h(x) dx �
,;;;; I I J(u + O hh) - Ju l i N I l h i I M . It follows from this inequality and the continuity of J (see Theorem 1 7 .3) that J is the gradient of the functional Fl (U) . * 4.
The linear operator J. The linear operator J: Ju(x)
=
a(x)u(x) ,
( 1 8.7)
CHAPTER I I I , § I B
179
where a(x) i s a fixed function, i s one o f the simplest forms o f the operators J. This operator was, in essence, already studied in §. 1 3 (subsections 4 and 5) . If the function a (x) is bounded, then, obviously, the operator f transforms every Orlicz space into itself and is a continuous operator. The next assertion follows from Theorem 1 3.7, Theorem 1 3.B and inequalities ( 1 3. 1 9) and ( 1 3.27) . THEOREM 1 B.2. Let a(x) E L�. A sufficient condition for the
operator ( l B.7) to act from LA!, into L1.t. and be continuous is that there exist mutually complementary N-functions R (u) and Q (u) such that or, if the N-function M2(u) satisfies the iJ '-condition, that R (u) < M I [M2" l (ocU)] , Q (u) < q>[M2" l (ocU)]
( l B.9)
for large values of the argument. Under these conditions, we have that I l au l lM. � k Il a l l � I l u I I M" where the constant k does not depend on the function u(x) . Under the conditions of this theorem, oc is a positive number. 5. The Frechet derivative. Suppose the nonlinear operator A acts from the Banach space E into the Banach space E1. We say that the linear operator B is the Frechet derivative of the operator A at the point Uo E E if A (uo + h) - Auo = Bh + w(uo, h) , where lim I lw (uo, h) I IEjl l h l lE = O. Ilhll.s-O
In this connection, the linear operator B also acts from the space E into the space E1. The expression Bh is called the Frechet differential. Operators which have a Frechet derivative are said to be differ entiable. If an operator is differentiable on some set then it obviously is continuous on this set . THEOREM 1 B.3. Suppose the function f(x, u) together with its
derivative f�(x, u) , which is continuous with respect to u, satisfy the CaratModory conditions. Suppose, further, that the operator f acts from some sphere T(uo, r ; L1.t, ) into the space L1.t. and that the operator JIu(x) = f� (x, u(x) )
( l B. 1 O)
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 80
acts from the sphere T(uo, r ; LM.) into the space L 'fr, and is continuous. Finally, let the functions M1 ( u) , M2(U) and $(u) satisfy one of the conditions ( 1 8.8) or ( 1 8. 9) . Then the operator f is Frichet-differentiable at every interior point of the sphere T ( uo, r ; LM.) , in which connection the Frechet differential Bh at the point u(x) E T is defined by means of the equality Bh(x) = iI u(x)h(x) , (h(x) E LMJ PROOF. In virtue of the mean-value theorem, we have that
f[x, u(x) + h(x)] - f [x, u(x)] - f� [x, u(x)]h(x) = = {t�[x, u(x) + O h(x)h(x)] - fJx, u ( x)] } h(x) ,
( 1 8. 1 1 )
where 0 � O h (X) � 1 , in which connection the function O h(X) can, in virtue of Lemma 1 8. 1 , be considered measurable. Let h(x) E LM , and suppose I l h iI M. is sufficiently small. Then the functions u(x) + h(x) and u(x) + O h (x)h(x) belong to the sphere T(uo, r ; LMJ, In virtue of Theorem 1 8.2, f�[x, u(x)]h(x) and the entire right member of equality ( 1 8. 1 1 ) belong to the space LM •. It follows from this same theorem that
From this, in virtue of the continuity of the operator iI , it follows that
I l f(u + h) - fu - iItt · h I I M, I l h iI M•
lim IlhllM.--> o
=
O.
*
As an example, we consider the operator fu(x) = eU(x ) . It follows from Theorem 1 7 . 6 that the operator f acts from the sphere T(O, t ; LM.) , where M1(u) = e1uI - I tt l 1 , into LM, = V. In virtue of Theorems 1 7. 2 and 1 7 .3, it acts from [[ ( EM" t ) into L 2 and is continuous. We shall show that this operator is differentiable and that its Frechet differential Bh(x) = iI u(x)h(x) at the point u(x) E [[ (EM. , t ) has the form Bh(x) = eU(X )h(x) . We apply Theorem 1 8.3, taking into consideration that $(u) = l u l 2 +/l, where 0 < P < { l jd (u , EM.)} 2. As T, we consider the sphere with center at the point u(x) and radius -
-
r
=
{ l j(2 + P)} - d(u, EMJ
The operator f acts
fro m the
sphere
T into L 2 smce
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
181
T C JI(EM" i) . The operator /Iu (x) eU(X ) acts from the sphere T((), 1 / (2 + (3) ; Li..c, ) into L� L 2 + fJ. It follows from Theorems 1 7 .2 and 1 7 .3 that it acts from JI(EM" 1 / (2 + (3) ) and, in pa rticular, from the sphere T into L� = L 2 + fJ and is continuous. =
=
In order to complete the proof, it suffices to verify that condition ( 1 8.8) is satisfied if we set R (u) M 1 (u) , Q (u) N1 (u) . As a second example, we consider the operators fu (x) sin u (x) , /Iu(x) cos u(x) . These operators act from an arbitrary Orlicz space Li..c , into every set E M, and, consequently, they belong to {LM, --+ Li..c , ; c.} . Let Li..c, C Li..c . . Then the operator Bh (x) = /Iu (x) . h (x) is the Frechet differential of the operator J. In the examples introduced above, the operator f was differ entiable at every point of some sphere T. This explains the simplicity of the proof of differentiability. It is quite easy to give examples of operators which are differentiable at one point of an Orlicz space but which are not differentiable on a set for which the given point is a limit point . For example, let =
=
=
=
fu (x)
=
sin (eU ' (X ) - 1 ) .
( 1 8. 1 2)
We shall consider f to be an operator in {L4 --+ L2} . At those points in which this operator is differentiable, its Frechet differential obviously has the form Bh(x) = 2u(x) eU ' (X ) cos (eu ' (X ) - 1 ) h (x) .
It is clear that the right member belongs to the space L2 only for certain functions u. (x) : for h(x) - 1 the right member does not belong to L2 for a set of functions u (x) which is everywhere dense in L4. It will be shown below that the operator ( 1 8. 1 2) is differentiable at the zero of the space L 4. 6. Special condition for differentiability . In this subsection, special condition for the differentiability of the operator f at one point of an Orlicz space will be given. We shall restrict our selves to a condition for the differentiability at the zero () of the space since the differentiability of the operator gu (x) g (x, u (x) ) at the point uo (x) is equivalent to differentiability at zero of the operator fu (x) g[x, uo (x) + u (x) ] . a
=
=
1 82
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
Below, we shall consider functions t(x, u) which satisfy con dition A) : A) The inequality
I t(x, u) - t(x, 0) - t� (x, O) u l � R ( l u l ) (X E G, - 00 < u < 00) ,
( 1 8. 1 3)
where R (u) is a continuous non-decreasing function such that R' (O) 0, holds, in which connection there exists an N-func tion P(u) which satisfies the J '-condition
R (O)
=
=
P(uv) � CP(u)P(v)
( 1 8. 1 4)
for all values of the argument , such that for sufficiently large values U l � UO, U 2 � Uo we have that U l < U2 implies ( 1 8. 1 5) where fl, v are positive constants. As the functions P(u) , it is most convenient to consider the functions P(u) Ite lT (r > 1 ) . Condition ( 1 8. 1 5) i s satisfied for such functions P(u) if R (u) is the principal part of an N-function satisfying the J 2 -condition. In fact , in this case, for large values of the argument , we have that urR(u) < R (vu) , where v is some constant . Therefore , for large values of U l and U 2 , it follows from Ul < U 2 that =
In the theorem to be proved below, the fundamental condition of the differentiability of the operator j, considered as an operator acting from Llt, into LM" will be based on inequality ( 1 8. 1 3) . A necessary condition for this inequality to guarantee the differ entiability of the operator j is , obviously, that lim IlhI I JI,-+ O
I IR ( l h(x) I ) I IM, I l h l lM,
=
O.
Considering the characteristic functions of sets whose measures
1 83
CHAPTER III, § 1 8
tend to zero as the functions h(x) , we arrive at the condition 1 1m ·
HOO
N 2- l ( V ) - 0, N i 1 (v)
( 1 8. 1 6)
where N l (V) and N 2 (V) are the complementary functions to M l (U) and M 2 (U) , since for the characteristic function K (X ) of the set G1 (mes G 1 = l /v) , we have that N:; l (V) I I R(K) I I M. = Rl I ) . Ni l (V) I I K I I M,
Let 13 > 0 be given. It follows from ( 1 8. 1 6) that N:; l (V) < I3Ni l (V) for large values of the argument . From this inequality, it follows, in turn, that the N-function N 2 (v) increases essentially more rapidly than the N-function N1 (v) . In virtue of Lemma 1 3. 1 , the N-function M 1 ( u ) increases essentially more rapidly than M 2 (u) , i.e. for arbitrary 13 > 0, the inequality M2 (U) < M1 (l3u) is satisfied for large values of the argument . A sufficient condition that this inequality be satisfied is that the functions M l (U) and M 2 (U) be connected by the relation ( 1 8. 1 7) where Q (u) is an N-function. In the sequel, we shall assume that condition ( 1 8. 1 7) is satisfied. In this connection, in virtue of Theorem 1 3.3, a constant q > 0 can be found such that ( 1 � . 1 8) We consider, further, the condition B) : B) The operator hh(x) f�(x, O)h(x) acts from LM , into LM• and is continuous. We note that , in virtue of ( 1 8. 1 7) , condition B) is always satisfied if the function a(x) = f�(x, 0) is bounded. If the function a (x) is not bounded, then a sufficient condition for condition B) to be satisfied is that the fUIlction a(x) belong to the space L�, where (/J(u) satisfies one of the conditions in Theorem 1 8.2. THEOREM 1 8.4. Suppose conditions A) , ( 1 8. 1 7) and B) are =
satisfied. Let
R (u ) :::::;; b + aM:; l [Ml (ku)]
(0 :::::;;
u
<
00) ,
( 1 8. 1 9)
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 84
where a , b , k > O . Let t(x , 0) E LM, . Then the operator f acts trom some neighborhood ot the zero () ot the space L'M, into the space LM. and has at the point () the Frechet ditferential Bh(x) hh(x) t� (x, O)h(x) . =
=
PROOF . In virtue of ( 1 8. 1 3) and ( 1 8. 1 9) , we have that
I t(x, u) 1 � I t(x , 0) 1 + l a(x)u l + b + aM2 1 [Ml (ku)] ( - 00 < U < 00) .
By hypothesis, t(x , 0) E LM •. In virtue of B) , a(x)u(x) E LM, for every u(x) E LM,. If I lullM, � 1 1k , then R ( l u(x) 1 ) E LM" in which connection we have that
I I R ( l u(x) I ) I IM.
=
2a
I �a R ( l u(x) I ) 1 M, { + f M2 [ �a R ( I U(X) I ) ] dX} �
� 2a 1
�
G
� 3a + aM 2
( : ) mes G
G
=
(3.
( 1 8.20)
Consequently, the operator f acts from the sphere T((), 1 1 k ; LM,) into the space LM, . To prove the differentiability of the operator f at the point () we must show that
I I R( l u(x) I ) I IM, I l u l lM ,
=
o.
( 1 8.2 1 )
Let e > 0 be given . Since R ' (0) = 0 , a C l > 0 can be found such that ( 1 8.22) R(lul) � e lui for l u i < Cl. To each function u(x) E Lid we assign the function u (x) defined by means of the equality
u(x) = _
{
U(X) if l u(x) I � Cl , o if l u(x) I > Cl.
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
1 85
In virtue of ( 1 8.22) and ( 1 8. 1 8) , we have that
I IR ( l u (x) I ) I I M. � e ll u l lM. � e l i u l lM. � eq l l u I I M"
( 1 8.23)
We can assume, without loss of generality, that the constant Uo appearing in condition A) is greater than C l . It follows from con dition A) that, for u ;;:,: Cl and y � Cl /UOV,
R (u) � R
( :: u) � #
and, in virtue of ( 1 8. 1 4) , that
R (u) � C#R Let lI u l lM1
R( l u(x)
< _
( ; ) P ( Uco; ) .
cl/ (uovk) . We set u(x) I ) � C#R
y
=
( 1 8. 24)
k il u l lM1 in ( 1 8.24) . Then
kuo I I u l l M1 I ( l u(x)k i lu-llMu(x) ) ), P( Cl 1
from which, in virtue of ( 1 8.20) , it follows that
I I R (u - u) I I M. � C#fJP
( kuo �� "M ) , l
and, since lim P(u) u = 0, we have that
/
M I I R"" u) I I� -"--- (u "'---- - ---=-- . = O . I I u l l M1
From the last relation and ( 1 8.23) it follows that
I I R(u ) 1 1 M. II u l lM1 +
+
11' m l IuIIM,-+O
) M. - --'I I R (u --, ,-- u 11--=I l u lI M ,
--
""" ./
eq.
Since e is arbitrary, equality ( 1 8. 2 1 ) is valid. * As an example, we consider operator ( 1 8. 1 2) as an operator in
{L 4 _ L 2} .
1 86
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
The function = sin - I ) satisfies inequality ( 1 8. 1 3) with the function R (u) = Therefore condition A) is satisfied in which we can set = and Since = Finally, condition ( 1 8. 1 7) is satisfied with the function = condition B) is satisfied inasmuch as 0) == ° in the case under consideration. The validity of condition ( 1 8. 1 9) is obvious. It thus follows from Theorem 1 8.4 that the operator ( 1 8. 1 2) in � is differentiable at the zero of the space
f(x, u) P(u)
(eU2 2 eu 2. u . M1(u) u4 M22 (u) u2 , Q(u) u . f�(x, =
{L4 L 2} fJ L4. 7. Auxiliary lemma. We shall need an operator defined by the function P(u), which is the derivative of an N-function M(u). LEMMA 1 8.2. Let M(u) and N(v) be mutually complementary N functions the second of which satisfies the J 2-condition. Suppose that the derivative P(u) of the function M(u) is continuous. Then the operator p, defined by means of the equality pu(x) P( l u (x) I ) , acts from JI(EM, 1 ) into L'N LN and is continuous. PROOF. In virtue of Lemma 9. 1 , the operator acts from T(fJ, 1 ; LM) into LN. It then follows from Theorem 1 7 . 2 that the operator p acts from JI(E M , 1 ) (and, by the same token, from EM) into LN. The continuity of the operator follows from Theorem 1 7.3. 8. The Gateaux gradient. We shall say that the functional F(u), defined on the Banach space E, is differentiable in the Gateaux sense, or Gateaux-differentiable, at the point u E E if, for arbitrary h E E, the function F(u + th) is differentiable with respect to t and the derivative of this function, for t 0, has the form d dt F(u + th) l t�o (v, h), where the element v from the conjugate space to the space E does not depend on h. The element v will be called the Gateaux gradient of the functional F(u) at the point u. The operator r, defined by the formula ru v on all elements at which F(u) is Gateaux-differ =
=
p
p
*
=
=
E
=
entiable, will also be called the Gateaux gradient . Clearly, the Gateaux gradient acts from E into the conj ugate space E. The following assertion holds (see, e.g. , VAIN BERG [ I J ) . LEMMA 1 8.3.
Suppose the functional F(u) is Gateaux-differentiable on some sphere T of the space E and that its Gateaux gradient is a continuous operator. Then the functional F(u) is differentiable in the
1 87
CHAPTER I I I , § 1 8
usual sense and its gradient (see subsection I ) coincides with the Gateaux gradient. PROOF. Let u