Creep-resistant steels
i WPNL2204
ii
Related titles: High-nitrogen steels and stainless steels (ISBN 978-1-84265-129-2) This authoritative book covers manufacturing methods for and the key properties of these important steels and their alloys. Electrochemistry in light water reactors (ISBN 978-1-84569-240-7) There has long been a need for effective methods of measuring corrosion within light water nuclear reactors. This important volume discusses key issues surrounding the development of high-temperature reference electrodes and other electrochemical techniques. Corrosion by carbon and nitrogen (ISBN 978-1-84569-232-2) Metal dusting is a form of corrosion involving the disintegration of metals and alloys into a dust of graphite and metal particles when exposed to a carburising atmosphere. This important book reviews the factors affecting metal dusting and how it can be prevented in sectors such as the chemical and petrochemical industries and in the direct reduction of iron ores. It also considers the related corrosion phenomena of carburisation and nitridation. Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing materials books, as well as materials books from Maney Publishing, can be obtained by: • visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com • contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext.130; address: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, England) If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail:
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in. Maney currently publishes 16 peer-reviewed materials science and engineering journals. For further information visit www.maney.co.uk/journals
WPNL2204
iii
Creep-resistant steels Edited by Fujio Abe, Torsten-Ulf Kern and R. Viswanathan
Woodhead Publishing and Maney Publishing on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals & Mining WPNL2204
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
WOODHEAD
PUBLISHING LIMITED
Cambridge England
WPNL2204
iv Woodhead Publishing Limited and Maney Publishing Limited on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals & Mining Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB21 6AH, England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2008, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © 2008, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-178-3 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-401-2 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4200-7088-0 CRC Press order number: WP7088 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt. Ltd. India Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, England
WPNL2204
v
Contents
Contributor contact details
xiii
Preface
xix
Part I General 1
Introduction
3
F. ABE, National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Japan
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
Definition of creep Creep and creep rate curves Creep rupture data Deformation mechanism map Fracture mechanism map References
3 3 7 9 11 14
2
The development of creep-resistant steels
15
K.-H. MAYER, ALSTOM Energie GmbH, Germany and F. MASUYAMA, Kyushu Institute of Technology, Japan
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
15 18 19 42
2.6 2.7
Introduction Requirements for heat-resistant steels Historical development of ferritic steels Historical development of austenitic steels Historical development of steel melting and of the purity of heat-resistant steels Summary References
3
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
78
64 67 70
G. MERCKLING, RTM BREDA Milano, Italy
3.1
Introduction
78
WPNL2204
vi
Contents
3.2 3.3 3.4
3.6 3.7
Specifications and standards The European Creep Collaborative Committee (ECCC) European Pressure Equipment Research Council (EPERC) The latest generation of CEN standards for creep-resistant steels Future trends References
95 150 151
4
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
155
3.5
81 85 92
F. MASUYAMA, Kyushu Institute of Technology, Japan
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7
Introduction Types of heat-resistant steels in Japan Specifications for high temperature tubing and piping steels Specifications for steam turbine steels Heat-resistant super alloys Summary References
155 155 158 169 169 169 173
5
Production of creep-resistant steels for turbines
174
Y. TANAKA, Japan Steel Works, Japan
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5
Introduction Overview of production technology of rotor shaft forgings for high temperature steam turbines Production and properties of turbine rotor forgings for high temperature applications Future trends References
174 175 192 207 212
Part II Behaviour of creep-resistant steels 6
Physical and elastic behaviour of creep-resistant steels 217 Y. YIN and R.G. FAULKNER, Loughborough University, UK
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7
Introduction 217 Elastic behaviour 219 Thermal properties of creep-resistant steels 225 Electrical resistivity and conductivity of creep-resistant steels 234 Implications for industries using creep-resistant steels 238 Future trends 239 References 239
WPNL2204
Contents
7
Diffusion behaviour of creep-resistant steels
vii
241
H. OIKAWA and Y. IIJIMA, Tohoku University, Japan
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 8
Introduction Diffusion and creep Diffusion characteristics Roles of atom/vacancy movement in creep Influence of some factors on creep through their effects on diffusion Diffusion data in iron and in some iron-base alloys Concluding remarks References Fundamental aspects of creep deformation and deformation mechanism map
241 241 243 248 250 255 260 263
265
K. MARUYAMA, Tohoku University, Japan
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8 8.9
Introduction Stress–strain response of materials Temperature and strain rate dependence of yield stress Deformation upon loading of creep test Creep behavior below and above athermal yield stress Change in creep behavior at athermal yield stress σa Deformation mechanism maps Concluding remarks References
265 265 267 269 270 271 275 278 278
9
Strengthening mechanisms in steel for creep and creep rupture
279
F. ABE, National Institute for Material Science (NIMS), Japan
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 10
Introduction Basic ways of strengthening steels at elevated temperature Strengthening mechanisms in modern creep-resistant steels Loss of strengthening mechanisms in 9–12Cr steels during long time periods Future trends References Precipitation during heat treatment and service: characterization, simulation and strength contribution
279 279 287 295 301 301
305
E. KOZESCHNIK and I. HOLZER, Graz University of Technology, Austria
10.1
Introduction
305
WPNL2204
viii
Contents
10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8 10.9
Microstructure analysis of the COST alloy CB8 Modelling precipitation in complex systems Computer simulation of the precipitate evolution in CB8 Microstructure–property relationships The back-stress concept Loss of precipitation strengthening during service of CB8 Summary and outlook References
306 312 315 320 322 324 325 326
11
Grain boundaries in creep-resistant steels
329
R.G. FAULKNER, Loughborough University, UK
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 12
Introduction Ferritic steels Austenitic steels Grain boundary properties and constitutive creep design equations Future trends References Fracture mechanism map and fundamental aspects of creep fracture
329 330 341 345 346 347
350
K. MARUYAMA, Tohoku University, Japan
12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
12.7 12.8 12.9 12.10
Introduction Fracture mechanisms and ductility of materials Stress and temperature dependence of rupture life Fracture mechanism maps Influence of fracture mechanism change on creep rupture strength Influence of microstructural degradation on creep rupture strength Change in creep rupture properties at athermal yield stress Multi-region analysis of creep rupture data Summary References
358 359 361 362 364
13
Mechanisms of creep deformation in steel
365
12.6
350 351 352 355 356
W. BLUM, University of Erlangen-Nuernberg, Germany
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4
Introduction Initial microstructure Creep at constant stress Transient response to stress changes
WPNL2204
365 366 368 370
Contents
13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11 13.12 14
Cyclic creep Microstructural interpretation of creep rate Dislocation models of creep In situ transition electron microscope observations of dislocation activity Discussion and outlook Acknowledgments References Appendix: Microstructural model Mikora Constitutive equations for creep curves and predicting service life
ix
374 375 385 389 393 395 395 401
403
S.R. HOLDSWORTH, EMPA – Materials Science & Technology, Switzerland
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7 14.8
Introduction Constitutive equations Constitutive equation selection Predicting service life Future trends Concluding remarks Nomenclature References
403 405 405 412 416 416 416 417
15
Creep strain analysis for steel
421
B. WILSHIRE and H. BURT, University of Wales Swansea, UK
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6
Introduction Creep-induced strain Patterns of creep strain accumulation Practical implications of creep strain analysis Future data analysis options References
421 422 427 433 441 442
16
Creep fatigue behaviour and crack growth of steels
446
C. BERGER, A. SCHOLZ, F. MUELLER and M. SCHWIENHEER, Darmstadt University of Technology, Germany
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6
Introduction Creep–fatigue experiments Stress–strain behaviour Creep–fatigue interaction, life estimation Multiaxial behaviour Creep and creep–fatigue crack behaviour
WPNL2204
446 447 449 449 456 459
x
Contents
16.7 16.8 16.9
Concluding remarks Acknowledgements References
468 469 469
17
Creep strength of welded joints of ferritic steels
472
H. CERJAK and P. MAYR, Graz University of Technology, Austria
17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7 17.8 18
Introduction Influence of weld thermal cycles on the microstructure of ferritic heat-resistant steels Weld metal development for creep-resistant steels Creep behaviour of welded joints Selected damage mechanism in creep-exposed welded joints Implications for industries using welded creep-resistant steels Future trends References
472
495 496 498
Fracture mechanics: understanding in microdimensions
504
474 482 483 484
M. TABUCHI, National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Japan
18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6
Introduction Non-linear fracture mechanics Effect of mechanical constraint Effect of microscopic fracture mechanisms Type IV creep crack growth in welded joints References
504 504 507 509 513 517
19
Mechanisms of oxidation and the influence of steam oxidation on service life of steam power plant components
519
P. J. ENNIS and W. J. QUADAKKERS, Forschungszentrum Juelich GmbH, Germany
19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6
Introduction Mechanisms of enhanced steam oxidation Steam oxidation rates Oxidation and service life Development of steam oxidation-resistant steels Outlook
WPNL2204
519 520 525 530 532 533
Contents
19.7 19.8
Sources of further information References
xi
534 534
Part III Applications 20
Alloy design philosophy of creep-resistant steels
539
M. IGARASHI, Sumitomo Metal Industries, Japan
20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4
Introduction Creep-resistant steels for particular components in power plants and the properties required Alloy design philosophies of creep-resistant steels References
539 539 541 570
21
Using creep-resistant steels in turbines
573
T.-U. KERN, Siemens AG Power Generation Group, Germany
21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 21.5 21.6
Introduction Implications for industries using creep-resistant steels Improving the performance and service life of steel components Next steps into the future Summary References
573 574 583 591 593 593
22
Using creep-resistant steels in nuclear reactors
597
S.K. ALBERT, Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research, India and S. SUNDARESAN, Maharaja Sayajirao University, Baroda, India
22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 22.5 22.6 22.7
Introduction Radiation damage Embrittlement caused by ageing Use of heat-resistant steels in major reactor types Fabrication and joining considerations Summary References
597 598 611 613 629 631 632
23
Creep damage – industry needs and future research and development
637
R. VISWANATHAN and R. TILLEY, Electric Power Research Institute, USA
23.1 23.2
Introduction Calculational methods for estimating damage
WPNL2204
637 638
xii
Contents
23.3 23.4 23.5 23.6 23.7
Non-destructive evaluation methods Accelerated destructive tests High temperature crack growth Future trends References
643 653 658 662 663
Index
667
WPNL2204
xiii
Contributor contact details
(* = main contact)
Editors
Chapter 1
Fujio Abe* Structural Metals Center, National Institute for Materials Science 1-2-1 Sengen Tsukuba 305-0047 Japan
Fujio Abe Structural Metals Center, National Institute for Materials Science 1-2-1 Sergen Tsukuba 305–0047 Japan
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
T.-U. Kern Siemens AG, Power Generation Group Dept. Materials Rheinstr. 100 D-45478 Muelheim Germany
Chapter 2 K.-H. Mayer* Am Kirchbühl 1 D-90592 Schwarzenbruck Germany
Email:
[email protected]
R. (Vis)Viswanathan Technical Executive Electric Power Research Institute 3420 Hillview Ave Palo Alto CA 94304 USA
Fujimitsu Masuyama Dept. Applied Science for Integrated System Engineering Kyushu Institute of Technology 1-1 Sensui-cho Tobata Kitakyushu 804-8550 Japan Email:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
WPNL2204
xiv
Contributor contact details
Chapter 3
Chapter 6
Gunther Merckling Via Po 84 20032 CORMANO MI Milano Italy
Y.F. Yin and R.G. Faulkner IPTME Loughborough University Ashby Road Loughborough LE11 3TU UK
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 4
Chapter 7
Fujimitsu Masuyama Dept. Applied Science for Integrated System Engineering Kyushu Institute of Technology 1-1 Sensui-cho Tobata Kitakyushu 804-8550 Japan
Hiroshi Oikawa* 2-2 Kagitori-3 Sendai 982-0804 Japan
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Yoshiaki Iijima 37-2 Kamo-1 Sendai 981-3122 Japan Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 5 Yasuhiko Tanaka The Japan Steel Works 4 Chatsu, Muroran, Hokkaido 051-8505 Japan
Chapter 8
Email:
[email protected]
Kouichi Maruyama Graduate School of Environmental Studies Tohoku University 6-6-02 Aobayama Aoba-ku Sendai 980-8579 Japan Email:
[email protected]
WPNL2204
Contributor contact details
xv
Chapter 9
Chapter 12
Fujio Abe Structural Metals Center, National Institute for Materials Science 1-2-1 Sergen Tsukuba 305–0047 Japan
Kouichi Maruyama Graduate School of Environmental Studies Tohoku University 6-6-02 Aobayama Aoba-ku Sendai 980-8579 Japan
Email:
[email protected] Email:
[email protected],jp
Chapter 10 Ernst Kozeschnik* and Ivan Holzer Institute for Materials Science, Welding and Forming Graz University of Technology Kopernikusgasse 24 A-8010 Austria Email:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Chapter 13 Wolfgang Blum Department of Materials Science Engineering Institute I: General Materials Properties WWI University of Erlangen-Nuernberg Martensstr. 5 91058 Erlangen Germany
Chapter 11 R.G. Faulkner IPTME Loughborough University Loughborough LE11 3TU UK Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 14 Stuart Holdsworth EMPA – Materials Science & Technology Überlandstrasse 129 CH-8600 Dübendorf Switzerland Email:
[email protected]
WPNL2204
xvi
Contributor contact details
Chapter 15
Chapter 18
B.Wilshire* and H. Burt Materials Research Centre School of Engineering University of Wales Swansea Singleton Park Swansea SA2 8PP UK
Masaaki Tabuchi Materials Reliability Centre National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS) 1-2-1 Sengen Tsukuba 305-0047 Japan
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 16
Chapter 19
Christina Berger*, Alfred Scholz, F. Mueller, Michael Schwienheer Institute for Materials Technology Darmstadt University of Technology Grafenstr 2 64283 Darmstadt Germany
P. J. Ennis and W. J. Quadakkers Forschungszentrum Juelich GmbH IEF-2 D 52425 Juelich Germany
Email:
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected]
Chapter 17 Horst Cerjak* and Peter Mayr Institute for Materials Science, Welding and Forming Graz University of Technology Kopernikusgasse 24 A-8010 Austria
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 20 M. Igarashi Corporate Research and Development Laboratories Sumitomo Metal Industries Ltd. 1-8 Fuso-cho Amagasaki Hyogo 660-0891 Japan Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected];
[email protected];
WPNL2204
Contributor contact details
xvii
Chapter 21
Chapter 23
T.-U. Kern Siemens AG Power Generation Group Dept. Materials Rheinstr. 100 D-45478 Muelheim Germany
R. (Vis) Viswanathan* and Richard Tilley Technical Executive Electric Power Research Institute 3420 Hillview Ave Palo Alto CA 94304 USA
Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 22 S. Sundaresan* L&T Visiting Welding Chair Dept. of Metallurgical Engineering Faculty of Technology and Engineering Maharaja Sayajirao University Kala Bhavan Baroda-390001 India S.K. Albert Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research Kalpakkam 603102 India Email:
[email protected] [email protected]
WPNL2204
xviii
WPNL2204
xix
Preface
Creep-resistant steel that can be used for a long time at elevated temperature is the key to the construction of thermal and nuclear power generation plants, chemical plants and petroleum plants. During the last decade, great progress has been made in developing creep-resistant steels of high strength and corrosion resistance at ever increasing temperatures and in evaluating the steels in terms of the weld characteristics, creep strength and corrosion resistance necessary for constructing plants. Although in the past the driving force for these developments has been primarily to achieve higher efficiencies, the focus has shifted more recently to the reduction of emissions of CO2, dioxins and other environmentally hazardous gases. In the field of thermal power generation, the maximum allowable temperature was about 565°C for conventional low alloy ferritic steels. However, progress in recent years has led to the development of high-strength 9–12% Chromium ferritic steels capable of operating in ultra super critical (USC) power plants at metal temperatures approaching up to 650°C. The creep strength of austenitic creep-resistant steels has been enhanced to enable operation up to temperatures of 675–700°C through the development of high Cr, high nickel steels. In the field of nuclear power, creep-resistant steels, which are excellent both in high-temperature creep strength and in irradiation resistance, have been developed for cladding tubes for 650°C fast breeder reactors. The temperature and pressure used were 454°C and 17 MPa, respectively in the early 1990s for hydrogen refining equipment in chemical plants, when reaction chambers were made of 2.25Cr–1Mo steel, but the subsequent development of high-strength 3Cr–1Mo–V steel and 2.25Cr– 1Mo–V steel raised the limiting temperature and pressure to 482°C and 24 MPa, respectively, by 1995. These figures are now about to reach 510°C and 24 MPa. For power generation from wastes, the development of austenitic creep-resistant steels that have high corrosion resistance enabled the boiler steam temperature to be raised from about 300°C in conventional plants up to about 500°C in more modern plants. In the automotive field, exhaust manifolds used to be made of cast iron to withstand exhaust heat. However, as the exhaust gas temperature rose with improved engine performance,
WPNL2204
xx
Preface
higher strength was required and so 18Cr–2Mo–Nb and other steels were developed, raising the exhaust gas temperature to 900°C or higher. Recent research on enhancing the creep strength of 9–12Cr steels for 650°C operation has revealed that the formation of even a partially weak microstructure near a grain boundary promotes local creep deformation and causes premature fracture. This suggests the importance of taking into account microstructural evolution phenomena during creep such as precipitation and coarsening of carbonitrides and intermetallic compounds, dynamic recovery and dynamic recrystallization, in the matrix as well as in the vicinity of grain boundaries. Recently, some high-strength 9–12Cr steels have been found to suffer premature loss of creep strength at 550°C or higher often after prolonged use up to relevant times. Therefore, efforts have been made to clarify the mechanisms of creep strength loss, using modern transmission electron microscopy studies. Extrapolation of short duration laboratory data using time–temperature parameter (TTP) methods, such as the Larson–Miller parameter, have been used widely in the past to predict long-term life. However, it has now become clear that conventional TTP methods tend to overpredict the long term strength because of microstructural degradation phenomena. To address this issue, new analysis techniques have been proposed taking the mechanisms of creep deformation and creep rupture into account. Welded structures made of ferritic creep-resistant steels used under high temperature and low stress (about 600°C and 100 MPa or less) are subject to premature brittle creep fracture by the so-called type IV fracture in the finegrained heat-affected zone (HAZ). Therefore, 9–12Cr steels are being investigated to clarify the mechanisms and the means of preventing this form of fracture. Operation of thick section components under thermally cyclic conditions further exacerbates the cracking problem by creep–fatigue interaction. Thus, as plant temperatures are raised to improve energy efficiency, it is becoming increasingly important to establish the foundation of creepresistant steels that can be used safely for a long time without showing deterioration of creep strength and creep ductility. The aim of this book is to consolidate and review the current state of knowledge of creep resistant steels, summarizing the information which is now scattered throughout voluminous scientific journals and a large number of proceedings of international conferences. Each chapter of the book has been written for engineers and researchers in particular by a world renowned expert in the field. Therefore, the book contains not only background on materials but also recent progress from an engineering and technology point of view. It also can be used as a reference source by graduate level students. It is hoped that the book will serve as an authoritative source of information relating to creep of steels. This book consists of three parts: a general Part I on specifications and
WPNL2204
Preface
xxi
manufacture, Part II on the behaviour of creep-resistant steels and Part III on specific applications. The introductory Part I includes the introductory description of creep and rupture (Chapter 1) and the historical development of creep-resistant steels (Chapter 2). Part I also includes the specifications of creep-resistant steels in Europe (Chapter 3) and in Japan (Chapter 4) and the production of creep-resistant steels for turbines (Chapter 5). Part II on the behaviour of creep-resistant steels covers physical and elastic behaviour (Chapter 6), diffusion behaviour (Chapter 7), fundamental aspects of creep deformation (Chapter 8), strengthening mechanisms (Chapter 9), precipitation (Chapter 10), grain boundaries (Chapter 11), fracture mechanisms and creep fracture (Chapter 12), mechanisms of creep deformation (Chapter 13), constitutive equations for creep curves and the prediction of service life (Chapter 14), creep strain analysis (Chapter 15), creep crack growth and creep-fatigue behaviour (Chapter 16), creep strength of welded joints (Chapter 17), fracture mechanics (Chapter 18), and oxidation and corrosion (Chapter 19). Part III on specific applications includes the alloy design philosophy behind creep-resistant steels (Chapter 20), creep-resistant steels in turbines (Chapter 21), creep-resistant steels in nuclear reactors (Chapter 22), and industry needs and future research trends in understanding creep damage (Chapter 23). We are grateful to all the contributors for their willing participation and for the cooperation they have extended to us in producing this book. We are also grateful to Mr Robert Sitton, Mr Ian Borthwick, Mrs Lynsey Gathercole and Ms Laura Bunney of Woodhead Publishing for their help in the publication of this book. F. Abe T.-U. Kern R. Viswanathan
WPNL2204
xxii
WPNL2204
Part I General
1 WPNL2204
2
Creep-resistant steels
WPNL2204
1 Introduction F . A B E, National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Japan
1.1
Definition of creep
Plastic deformation is irreversible and it consists of time-dependent and time-independent components. In general, creep refers to the time-dependent component of plastic deformation. This means that creep is a slow and continuous plastic deformation of materials over extended periods under load. Although creep can take place at all temperatures above absolute zero Kelvin, traditionally creep has been associated with time-dependent plastic deformation at elevated temperatures, often higher than roughly 0.4Tm, where Tm is the absolute melting temperature, because diffusion can assist creep at elevated temperatures. For detailed description of mechanical equation of state, creep behavior of metals and alloys, dislocation motion during creep, mechanisms of creep, creep damage and fracture, the reader is referred to standard text books on creep.1–6
1.2
Creep and creep rate curves
Creep tests can be conducted either at constant load or at constant stress. For experimental convenience, most frequently the creep tests of engineering steels are conducted at constant tensile load and at constant temperature. The test results can be plotted as creep curves, which represent graphically the time dependence of strain measured over a reference or gauge length. Figure 1.1 shows schematically three types of creep curves under constant tensile load and constant temperature conditions and also their creep rates ε˙ = dε/ dt, where ε is the strain and t the time, as a function of time. Textbooks on creep of metals and alloys generally describe that three stages of creep, consisting of primary or transient, secondary or steady-state and tertiary or acceleration creep that appear after instantaneous strain ε0 upon loading as shown in Fig. 1.1(a), when the test temperature is high enough or at a high homologous temperature. The homologous temperature is defined as the ratio T/Tm, where T is the test temperature in absolute Kelvin and Tm the 3 WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels εr
(d) (a) Three stages creep curve
ε2 ε1 ε0 Strain
t1
t2
tr
εr (b) Two stages creep curve
εm
log (strain rate or creep rate)
4
Steady-state creep rate
. εs
t1
t2
tr
(e)
Minimum creep rate
. εmin
ε0
tm
tr
tm
tr
(f)
(c) Logarithmic creep curve ε0 Time
Time
1.1 (a), (b) and (c) Creep curves of engineering steels under constant tensile load and constant temperature and (d), (e) and (f) their creep rate curves as a function of time.
absolute melting temperature. The instantaneous strain ε0 contains elastic strain and possibly plastic strain depending on the stress level. In the primary creep stage between ε0 and ε1, the creep rate, ε˙ , decreases with time, as shown in Fig. 1.1(d). The decreasing creep rate in the primary creep stage has been attributed to strain hardening or to a decrease in free or mobile dislocations. In the secondary creep stage between ε1 and ε2, the creep rate remains constant. This creep rate is designated as a steady-state creep rate, ε˙ s , which is given by ε˙ s = (ε2 – ε1)/(t2 – t1) and is commonly attributed to a state of balance between the rate of generation of dislocations contributing to hardening and the rate of recovery contributing to softening. At high homologous temperatures, creep mainly involves diffusion and hence the recovery rate is high enough to balance the strain hardening and results in the appearance of secondary or steady-state creep. In the tertiary creep stage, the creep rate increases with time until rupture at rupture time tr and rupture strain, εr. It should be remembered that under the constant tensile load, the stress continuously increases as creep proceeds or as cross-section decreases and a pronounced effect of increase in stress on the creep rate appears in the tertiary creep stage. Necking of the specimens before rupture causes a significant increase in stress. The increase in creep rate with time in the tertiary creep stage can follow from increasing stress or from microstructure evolution including
WPNL2204
Introduction
5
damage evolution taking place during creep. Microstructure evolution usually consists of dynamic recovery, dynamic recrystallization, coarsening of precipitates and other phenomena, which cause softening and result in a decrease in resistance to creep. Damage evolution includes the development of creep voids and cracks, often along grain boundaries. The extent and shape of the three creep stages described above can vary markedly depending on test conditions of stress and temperature, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.2, where the final point in each curve represents creep rupture. With increasing stress and temperature, the time to rupture and the extent of secondary creep usually decrease but the total elongation increases. Under certain conditions, the secondary or steady-state creep stage may be absent, so that immediately after the primary creep stage the tertiary creep stage begins at tm, as shown in Fig. 1.1(b) and 1.1(e). In this case, the minimum creep rate, ε˙ min , can be defined instead of the steady-stage creep rate, ε˙ s . Similar to the steady-stage creep rate, ε˙ s , the minimum creep rate, ε˙ min , can be explained by the process where hardening in the primary stage is balanced by softening in the tertiary stage. In many cases, there is substantially no steady-state stage in engineering creep-resistant steels and alloys. Many researchers have shown that there is an ever-evolving microstructure during creep for engineering creep-resistant steels and alloys. This suggests that there is no dynamic microstructural equilibrium in engineering creep-resistant steels and other alloys during creep, which characterizes steady-state creep of simple metals and alloys. Therefore, the term ‘minimum creep rate’ has been favored by engineers and researchers who are concerned with engineering creep-resistant steels and alloys. The stress dependence of minimum or steady-state creep rate is usually expressed by a power law as:
Strain
Arrows: increasing stress and temperature
Time
1.2 Schematic creep curves varying with stress and temperature.
WPNL2204
6
Creep-resistant steels
ε˙ min or ε˙ s = A σ n
[1.1]
A = A′ exp (– Qc/RT)
[1.2]
where n is the stress exponent, Qc the activation energy for creep, R the gas constant and T the absolute temperature. The parameter A′ includes microstructure parameters such as grain size and so on. Equation [1.1] is often referred to Norton’s law. It is well known that the minimum or steadystate creep rate is inversely proportional to the time to rupture tr as:
ε˙ min or ε˙ s = C /( t r ) m = A ′ σ n exp (– Qc / RT )
[1.3]
where C is a constant depending on total elongation during creep and m is a constant often nearly equal to 1. Equation [1.3] is often referred to as the Monkman–Grant relationship, which has been experimentally confirmed not only for simple metals and alloys but also for a number of engineering creepresistant steels and alloys. Equation [1.3] suggests that the minimum or steady-state creep rate and the time to rupture vary in a similar manner to stress and temperature. At low homologous temperatures, with T/Tm often less than roughly 0.3, where diffusion is not important, only the primary stage appears. Usually only limited strains well below 1% occur that do not lead to final rupture, as shown in Fig. 1.1(c) and 1.1(f). This deformation process is designated as logarithmic creep. Considerable efforts have been made to describe the creep curves, namely, the time dependence of creep strain. There are several model equations available for characterizing the primary, secondary and tertiary creep stage characteristics, ranging in complexity from simple phenomenological to physically based constitutive. Recent progress on the suitability of some of these to specific materials classes and analytical applications is reviewed by Holdsworth et al. [7]. Although Fig. 1.1 shows the idealized creep and creep rate curves, engineering creep-resistant steels sometimes exhibit complicated behavior, especially under low stress and long time conditions, reflecting complex microstructural evolution during creep. Complicated behavior is clearly demonstrated by creep rate curves rather than creep curves. Figure 1.3 shows an example of complicated creep rate curves of 1Cr–0.5Mo steel at 550°C.8 At high stresses above 108 MPa, the creep rate curves are relatively simple and consist of the primary and tertiary stages but there is no substantial steady-state stage, similar to Fig. 1.1(e). The shape of creep rate curve becomes gradually complicated with decreasing stress. At low stresses below 88 MPa, two minima appear in the creep rate curves. This suggests that new strengthening effects such as the precipitation of new phases seem to operate after an extended period, causing a decrease in creep rate again after an growing the previous acceleration creep. The subsequent loss of the existing
WPNL2204
Introduction
7
10–2 265MPa 10–3
216MPa 108MPa 88MPa 74MPa
Creep/h–1
10–4
61MPa 10
–5
10
–6
137MPa
10–7 10–8 10–1
53MPa
1Cr–0.5Mo steel (JIS STBA22) 550°C 100
101
102 103 Time/h
104
105
106
1.3 Creep rate versus time curves of 1Cr–0.5Mo steel at 550°C (823K).
strengthening effects by microstructural evolution such as the coarsening of new phases causes an increase in creep rate again after reaching a second minimum. Eventually the creep rate versus time curves exhibit oscillated shapes under low stress and long time conditions, reflecting complex microstructural evolution during creep. Similar oscillated shapes have sometimes been observed in other low alloyed steels. In fundamental investigations of creep, creep tests are often conducted at constant stress. The applied stress does not change during the creep test provided that the reduction in cross-sectional area is uniform along the whole gauge length. The stress can be kept constant during creep using proper loading mechanisms. When we need to avoid any influence of oxidation, creep tests are usually conducted in vacuum or in an inert atmosphere. Otherwise the influence of oxidation in reducing the cross-sectional area has to be considered, especially at higher temperatures and longer times for low alloyed steels.
1.3
Creep rupture data
Elevated-temperature components used under creep conditions are designed using allowable stress under creep conditions, which is usually determined on the basis of 100 000 h creep rupture strength at the operating temperature, and sometimes also for 200 000–300 000 h creep rupture strength. The 100 000 h creep rupture strength at a temperature T is defined as the stress at which creep rupture, the last point in Fig. 1.1(a) and (b), occurs at 100 000 h. Generally creep rupture data are represented in graphic form showing the
WPNL2204
8
Creep-resistant steels
relationship between the stress σ and the time to rupture tr. Figure 1.4 shows an example of creep rupture data for 1Cr–0.5Mo steel from the National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS) Creep Data Sheet.9 This figure contains 309 data points for 11 heats. The material specification defines the chemical composition, heat treatment conditions and so on. In terms of the chemical composition of 1Cr–0.5Mo steel (JIS STBA 22), the Cr concentration is specified as the range 0.80–1.25%, the concentration of Mo in the range 0.45–0.65%, and so on. Practically, the melting of steels causes a difference in the concentration of alloying elements, so that No. 1 ingot contains 1.0%Cr and 0.50%Mo, but No. 2 ingot contains 0.90%Cr and 0.60%Mo and so on, in which the two ingots satisfy the materials specification of 1Cr–0.5Mo steel (JIS STBA 22). Usually, such a small variation in chemical composition causes a difference in creep strength. The 100 000 h creep rupture strength is evaluated to be, for example, 61 MPa at 550°C. The creep rate curves shown in Fig. 1.3 were obtained for one heat of the 1Cr–0.5Mo steel shown in Fig. 1.4. The creep rupture data in Fig. 1.4 exhibit rather complicated curves showing inverse sigmoidal bending at intermediate stress levels of about 130 MPa. It should be noted that two minima appear in the creep rate curves at intermediate stress levels and below, while only one minimum appears at higher stress levels, Fig. 1.3. 500 500°C 550°C 600°C 650°C
400 300
Stress (MPa)
200
100
500°C
80 60 50 40
550°C
30 650°C
n = 309 20 10
102
103 104 Time to rupture (h)
600°C 105
1.4 Creep rupture data for 1Cr–0.5Mo steel at 500–650°C.
WPNL2204
106
Introduction
9
Recently, long-term creep rupture test data and creep strain data beyond 100 000 h have become available for a number of creep-resistant steels in several materials test institutions in the world, for example, in NIMS, Japan. For long-term creep and creep rupture data, the reader is referred to the NIMS Creep Data Sheets, for example.10 NIMS Creep Data Sheets contain a full set of data, such as creep rupture data, often exceeding 100 000 h, minimum creep rates, short-time tensile data, evaluation of short-time tensile strength and long-term creep rupture strength by curvilinear regression analysis and optical micrographs, together with the details of materials production procedures and chemical compositions. Microstructure Data Sheets, have also been published as the Metallographic Atlas of Long-Term Crept Materials,11 another series of NRIM Creep Data Sheets. The Metallographic Atlas not only contains series micrographs that show microstructural evolution during creep for up to 100 000 h, but that also show related data such as time–temperature–precipitation (TTP) diagrams, histograms describing the distributions of precipitates and creep-voids, and creep damage parameters, using specimens in the Creep Data Sheets. Furthermore, the Atlas of Creep Deformation Property12 was published as Creep Strain Data Sheets for Grade 91 steel (9Cr–1Mo–V–Nb), providing creep curves, creep rate curves and related data. As can be seen from Equation [1.3], stress and temperature are important variables that influence creep rate and time to rupture. In addition, creep and creep rupture properties are markedly affected by not only microstructure variables but also by external variables. The external variables include prestraining (cold-working), additional heat treatments, oxidation and corrosion, stress mode such as uniaxial or multiaxial loading, and superimposition of cyclic loading (creep–fatigue mode). High-temperature structure components in plants are usually used under the complicated conditions described above over long duration up to 300 000 h or longer.
1.4
Deformation mechanism map
Ashby13 proposed the concept of a deformation mechanism map, based on the assumption that all six deformation mechanisms concerned are mutually independent and operate in a parallel way. The six deformation mechanisms include (1) defect-less flow, (2) glide motion of dislocations, (3) dislocation creep, (4) volume diffusion flow, (5) grain boundary diffusion flow and (6) twinning. The twinning can supply only a limited amount of deformation and usually does not appear in the deformation mechanism map. It should be noted that Ashby considered steady-state flow only but no fracture. As illustrated schematically in Fig. 1.5, the deformation mechanism map is constructed with axes of normalized stress σ/G, where G is the shear modulus and T /Tm is the homologous temperature. The map is divided into fields. Within a
WPNL2204
10
Creep-resistant steels
Defect-free flow
Normalized stress, σ /G
10–1
Ideal strength Dislocation glide
10–3
Dislocation creep 10–2 Coble creep
10–5
Creep rate 10–8 10–10/S Nabarro creep
10–7 0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Homologous temperature, T / Tm
10–4
10–6 1.0
1.5 Schematic deformation mechanism map with contours of constant creep rate.
field, one mechanism is dominant, that is, it supplies a greater strain rate than any other mechanisms. The upper limit of the boundary is set by a theoretical or ideal strength of roughly G/20 to G/30. At stresses lower than the ideal strength, the deformation takes place by dislocation glide, as in short-time tensile tests. At stresses lower than yield stress, dislocation creep can take place with the aid of diffusion: probably dislocation core diffusion at low homologous temperatures and volume diffusion at high homologous temperatures. Sometimes the dislocation creep field is further divided into two fields: low- and high-temperature dislocation creep fields. At further low stresses, volume diffusion creep (Nabarro–Herring creep) and grain boundary diffusion creep (Coble creep) dominate. The boundaries between adjacent fields in the creep region indicate the conditions under which two mechanisms contribute equally to the overall creep rate. Using an appropriate constitutive equation for creep rates as functions of stress and temperature, we can calculate the creep rates and can draw the boundaries. This also allows us to plot the contours of constant creep rate onto the map, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.5. The locations of the boundaries between adjacent creep fields differ for different materials and also depend on microstructure valuables such as grain size. Experimentally, the deformation mechanism map can be constructed by the measurements of stress and temperature dependence of strain rates or creep rates caused by the individual mechanisms. It should be also noted that the time dependence is not included in the deformation mechanism map. As
WPNL2204
Introduction
11
already shown in Fig. 1.2, the creep rate of engineering creep-resistant steels varies in complex manner with time because of complicated microstructure evolution during creep exposure at elevated temperatures. Therefore, in the case of engineering creep-resistant steels, the deformation mechanism map can be applied to predict a dominant deformation mechanism at the beginning of creep under specific stress and temperature conditions.
1.5
Fracture mechanism map
Ashby14 also proposed the concept of fracture mechanism map for face centred cubic (fcc) metals and alloys with axes of normalized stress σ/G and homologous temperature T/Tm, which provides us with information about the dominant mechanism resulting in fracture in a shorter time than any other mechanisms. The fracture mechanism map is more important than the deformation mechanism map in practice, because the former relates to damage and fracture processes, which provide us with useful guidelines for assessment of damage evaluation and the remaining life estimation of components in plants. Because the minimum or steady-state creep rate and the time to rupture vary in a similar manner stress and temperature, as suggested by Eqn [1.3], approaches similar to those employed in the construction of a deformation mechanism map can be adopted for the construction of a fracture mechanism map. Figure 1.6 shows schematically the fracture mechanism map for fcc metals, where a cleavage fracture field does not appear. The ideal strength appears 10–1 Dynamic fracture
Normalized stress, σ / G
Ideal strength
Ductile fracture
10–3 Transgranular creep fracture
10–5 Intergranular creep fracture
10–7 0
Rupture 4
10 h
103 h
105 h rupture strength
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Homologous temperature, T / Tm
1.0
1.6 Schematic fracture mechanism map with contours of constant time to rupture for fcc metals.
WPNL2204
12
Creep-resistant steels
as the upper limiting fracture strength which will overcome interatomic forces in defect-free materials. At stresses lower than the ideal strength, fracture takes place in a ductile, transgranular way, designated ductile fracture, and often designated ductile transgranular fracture. In the creep regime, two fields of transgranular creep fracture and intergranular creep fracture appear at high and low stresses, respectively. At high temperature and relatively high strain rate, dynamic recrystallization can allow materials to deform extensively so that deformation becomes localized in a neck and failure eventually occurs by the specimen necking until the cross-sectional area has gone to zero, usually called the field of rupture. Because grain boundaries become highly mobile under conditions of dynamic recrystallization, the development of creep voids and cavities is suppressed. Figure 1.7 shows schematically the three fracture mechanisms in creep regime: intergranular creep fracture, transgranular creep fracture and rupture.14 Contours of constant time to rupture can be also plotted onto the map, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.6. Although the axes of most of the fracture mechanism maps are stress and temperature, axes of stress and time are also used. Figure 1.8(a) and 1.8(b) show examples of fracture mechanism maps for 1Cr–1Mo–0.25V steel for a turbine rotor, plotted for stress–time to rupture and for stress–temperature coordinate systems, respectively.15 In these figures, the stress–time to rupture plots and stress–temperature plots for constant times to rupture of 100–100 000 h are superimposed. It should be noted that the axes of stress and temperature but not those of normalized stress σ/G and homologous temperature T/Tm are used in these figures because the objective of constructing fracture mechanism maps is primarily for use in assessment of reliability, such as in the design and remaining life prediction of a steam turbine rotor. The intergranular creep fracture field is located in a long time-
Intergranular creep fracture (voids) (wedge cracks)
Growth of voids by power-law creep (transgranular) (intergranular)
Rupture due to dynamic recovery or recrystallization
(a)
(b)
(c)
1.7 Schematic drawing of three fracture mechanisms in a hightemperature creep regime.
WPNL2204
Introduction
600
Transgranular creep fracture
Stress (MPa)
400
500°C
525°C
625°C
550°C 575°C Intergranular creep fracture (cavitation)
100 675°C
600°C
Rupture (recrystallization) 102
650°C 103 104 Time to rupture (h)
600
105
Tensile
400
streng
th
Transgranular creep rupture 200
10 2
Ductility minimum 100
h
4
10
h
Intergranular creep fracture (cavitation)
10 3 h
e ur pt gth Ru ren st
Stress (MPa)
Ductility minimum
450°C
200
40
13
5
10
h
40 450
500
550 600 Temperature (°C)
Rupture (recrystallization) 650
1.8 Fracture mechanism maps for 1Cr–1Mo–0.25V steel, as functions of time to rupture and of temperature.
to-rupture region at 500–575°C. The rupture field appears at temperatures higher than 600°C. The region of practical importance for 1Cr–1Mo–0.25V steel turbine rotor in power plants is the low stress and long time-to-rupture region at temperatures of 550°C or lower, which belongs to the intergranular creep fracture field. This suggests that precise measurements of the development of creep voids at grain boundaries during creep contributes to the improvement in the reliability of the remaining life estimation.
WPNL2204
14
1.6
Creep-resistant steels
References
1. Finnie I. and Heller W. R., Creep of Engineering Materials, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1959. 2. Garofalo F., Fundamentals of Creep and Creep-Rupture in Metals, The Macmillan Company, New York, 1965. 3. Penny R. K. and Marriott D. L., Design for Creep, McGraw-Hill, London, 1971. 4. Evans R. W. and Wilshire B., Creep of Metals and Alloys, The Institute of Metals, London, 1985. 5. Cadek J., Creep in Metallic Materials, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988. 6. Viswanathan R., Damage Mechanisms and Life Assessment of High-Temperature Components, ASM International, Ohio, 1989. 7. Holdsworth S. R., Baker A., Gariboldi E., Holmstrom S., Klenk A., Merckling G., Sandstrom R., Schwienheer M. and Spigarelli S., ‘Factors influencing creep model equation selection’, Proceedings of ECCC Creep Conference, 12–14 September 2005, The Institute of Materials, London, UK, 2005, 380–393. 8. Kushima H., Kimura K., Abe F., Yagi K., Irie H., Maruyama K., ‘Effect of microstructural change on creep deformation behaviour and long-term creep strength of 1Cr–0.5Mo Steel’, Tetsu-to-Hagane, 2000, 86, 131–137. 9. NIMS (formerly NRIM) Creep Data Sheets No.1. Tokyo, Tsukuba, National Institute for Materials Science, 1996. 10. Series of NIMS (formerly NRIM) Creep Data Sheets No. 1–48. Tokyo, Tsukuba, National Institute for Materials Science, 2007. 11. Series of NIMS Metallographic Atlas of Long-Term Crept Materials No. M1-M6. Tokyo, Tsukuba, National Institute for Materials Science, 2007. 12. NIMS Atlas of Creep Deformation Property, No. D-1. Tokyo, Tsukuba, National Institute for Materials Science, 2007. 13. Ashby M. F., ‘A first report on deformation-mechanism maps’, Acta Metallurgica, 1972, 20, 887–897. 14. Ashby M. F., Gandhi C. and Taplin D. M. R., ‘Fracture-mechanism maps and their Construction for FCC Metals and Alloys’, Acta Metallurgica, 1979, 27, 699–729. 15. Shinya N., Kyono J. and Kushima H., ‘Creep fracture mechanism map and creep damage of Cr–Mo-V turbine rotor steel’, ISIJ International, 2006, 46, 1516–1522.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
15
2 The development of creep-resistant steels K.-H . M A Y E R , ALSTOM Energie GmbH, Germany and F . M A S U YA M A , Kyushu Institute of Technology, Japan
2.1
Introduction
The development of creep-resistant steels is a result of continuous technological progress throughout the 20th century. The urgent need to improve the creep strength of steels was based on endeavours by the power station industry to improve the thermal efficiency of steam power plant by raising the steam temperature and steam pressure in order to reduce the cost of fuel and reduce use of fuel resources. Since roughly 1900, as shown for instance by Fig. 2.1, the heat rate of thermal power plant in Germany has been reduced following a step-by-step increase in the steam parameters from 275°C/12 bar to 620°C/ 300 bar.1,2 A major contribution to the increase in power plant efficiency consisted of the development of heat-resistant steels with a higher creep strength at an acceptable creep ductility level (see for example Kallen).3 The significance of these material properties was not recognised until early damage was suffered by steam turbine bolts in the 1930s, which pointed to the fact that the strength of steels used in power stations operating at higher temperatures depends significantly on the creep behaviour of the material over the full period of operation.4 Based on this experience it was concluded that the strength values should no longer be determined in short-term tests,5,6 for example the ‘durability strength’ according to the DVM (Deutscher Verband fur Material prüfung) creep rate limit test. The procedure to be adopted should be to determine the fracture strength, the creep elongation and creep ductility of the heat-resistant steel in a creep test extending over a period of roughly 100 000 h (see for example Siebel).7 For the DVM creep rate limit test established in Germany in 1930, the ‘durability strength’ was defined to be the stress at the test temperature at which a creep rate of 10 × 10–4 %/h was reached between the 25th and 35th hour.5 Typical results of both tests, which were commenced at the end of the 1930s, are shown by Fig. 2.2. The tests were performed at 500°C on a steel containing 0.30%C–1.61%Cr– 1.28%Mo–0.10%V. The DVM creep rate limit test using smooth specimens 15 WPNL2204
16
Creep-resistant steels
40
Specific heat rate (kJ/kWh)
12 bar/275°C 30
15 bar/350°C
20
35 bar/450°C 100 bar/500°C 100 bar/540°C
10
With reheat (540/540°C) 0 1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950 1960 Year
1970
280 bar 580/600°C 300 bar 580/600°C
Supercritical (250 bar) 1980
1990
2000
2010
2.1 Heat rate of steam power plants in Germany as a function of steam parameters since the year 1900.
Creep rupture strength (MPa)
1000 500°C
600
Smooth specimens 400 313192 h 200 ‘Durability strength’ of DVM creep rate limit test carried out at about 1936
Notched specimens 294000 h
100 10–1
100
101
102 103 Time to rupture (h)
104
105
106
2.2 Creep rupture strength as a function of time to rupture and ‘durability strength’ of a 1.6%CrMoV steel at 500°C. Test steel: 0.30%C–1.6%Cr–1.3%Mo–0.1%V; heat treatment: 950°C/air + 680°C/air; tensile strength: 893 MPa.
and the creep rupture test using smooth and notched specimens (notch factor 4.3) are compared. Creep rupture tests were even continued up to roughly 300 000 h at the end of the 1970s.8 The ‘durability strength’ in the short-term test was determined at a strength level of 306 MPa. At this stress level, the rupture of the creep rupture tests was reached after about 3000 h, whereas the 100 000 h rupture strength of the smooth specimens lies at 190 MPa. The notched specimens stressed at the same level of 190 MPa failed after roughly 30 000 h, distinctly earlier than the smooth specimens owing to a significant notch-weakening
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
17
behaviour. It was also recognised that the tendency to notch-weakening behaviour of the steels was a wrong turn in the development of heat resistant steels on the basis of the DVM creep rate limit test, because the aim of raising the ‘durability strength’ of the heat-resistant steels as high as possible involves the risk of increasing the susceptibility of the steels to embrittlement. To provide a further example of the influence of creep processes on the strength of heat resistant steels, Fig. 2.3 demonstrates the dependence of the creep rupture strength and the strength for 1% creep strain on the test temperature and test period for a carbon steel and a 1%Cr–0.5%Mo steel in comparison with the 0.2% yield limit determined in the short-term tensile test (see for example Wellinger).9 In comparison with the 0.2% yield limit determined in the short-term tensile test, the 100 000 h creep rupture strength is lower for the carbon steel at higher than about 410°C and is also lower for the 1%Cr–0.5%Mo steel higher than about 480°C. The crossover temperatures between the results of the short-term tensile test and the creep strength values are distinctly lower if the 0.2% or the 1% permanent creep strain determined in the 100 000 h test are decisive for the design of power station components. Forming influences marking the development of heat resistant steels over the past 100 years are: long-term operational experience experience gained from long-term creep rupture tests improvements in melting technology systematic investigations into the influence of heat treatment on creep behaviour 300
0.2-Limit
Strength (MPa)
• • • •
1% Cr 0.5% Mo steel
200 100 000 h creep rupture 100
100 000 h 1%-creep strain
C steel
200
300 400 500 Test temperature (°C)
600
700
2.3 0.2-limit, 100 000 h creep rupture strength and 100 000 h 1%creep strength of a carbon steel and 1%Cr–0.5%Mo steel as a function of test temperature.
WPNL2204
18
• • • • •
• • • •
2.2
Creep-resistant steels
examination of the microstructure of specimens in the virgin condition following long-term thermal and creep loading systematic investigations into the influence of alloying elements computer-aided alloy design methods (e.g. Thermocalc, DICTRA) modelling of creep processes development of metallographic methods and equipment for the identification of precipitates (e.g. transmission electron microscopy (TEM), energy dispersive X-ray spectrometry (EDS), energy filtered transmission electron microscopy (EFTEM), atom probe field ion microscopy (APFIM), field emission Auger electron spectroscopy (FE-AES) and secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS). national and international joint research activities and research projects related to the development of advanced creep resistant steels and longterm tests under creep stress conditions7–16 testing of newly developed heat-resistant steels on the basis of large pilot components and welds fabricated under normal workshop conditions investigations into the oxidation behaviour of advanced heat-resistant steels in the laboratory and in test fields of steam power stations international exchange of experience at conferences and in workshops e.g. EPRI (Electric Power Research Institute USA), EPDC (Electric Power Development Center/Japan), COST (Community of Science and Technology of the European Communities), ECCC (European Creep Collaboration Committee), NIMS (National Institute for Materials Science/ Japan).
Requirements for heat-resistant steels
Heat-resistant steels for use in thermal power stations must be capable of satisfying the specific requirements established for dependable and economic operation. All phases of development and testing must therefore be specifically aligned to the following requirements: • • • • • • • •
high thermal efficiency operational capability in the medium and peak load ranges life expectancy of at least 200 000 h high availability long intervals between overhauls short overhaul periods short manufacturing times competitive production costs for the steam plant and electric power.
These requirements mean that the application of newly developed steels must not involve any additional risks, implying:
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
•
• • • •
19
that long time creep testing up to 100 000 h is needed to predict reliably the creep strength for 200 000 h (which means that the tests must be started with a large number of specimens, because at the outset of the tests a prediction cannot be made about the stress level which will be reached after a test period of 100 000 h. A long test period should also be scheduled if a research project is only due to last for 3–5 years); satisfactory oxidation resistance; high ductility of the steels under conditions of creep stressing; high fracture toughness of the steels in a new condition and following prolonged operational stressing; satisfactory production of the new steels in terms of melting, casting, forging, hot forming and welding.
2.3
Historical development of ferritic steels
2.3.1
Carbon steels
Up to the 1920s it was general practice to use non-alloyed steels for components in the steam admission zone exposed to maximum temperatures of 350°C and pressures of about 15 bar. The components were designed according to the material requirements established in a hot tensile test. In these short-term tests it was not possible to recognise that the elements N, Al and Mn exercised a major influence on the creep strength of carbon steels. Figure 2.3 has already shown the 0.2-limit and the creep rupture strength obtainable with present-day standard non-alloyed steels as a function of the test temperature in comparison with the 1%Cr–1%Mo steel.9
2.3.2
Low alloy steels
At the beginning of the 1920s, operation at steam temperatures of 450°C and pressures of 35 bar called for the development of low-alloyed heat-resistant steels. Developments were limited to individual steel works which at that time were not yet coordinated in joint research programmes. The steels were identified by the trade name of the steel works. The basic test in the development of low-alloyed steels was a hot tensile test which later on was followed by a short-term test, for example the DVM creep rate limit test in Germany.5 In the USA in 1933, a guideline was prepared between the ASME and ASTM for tests covering periods of 500–2000 h to determine the creep strain limits for a permanent creep strain of 0.01%, 0.1%, 1% and the ultimate rupture limit.6 The results were extrapolated at a double logarithmic scale on a straight line pattern up to 104 h and further up to 105 h. Based on the multiplicity of investigations of test steels carried out with different Mo, Cr, Ni, V, CrMo, CrV, MnSi, MoMnSi, CrSiMo, CrNiMo,
WPNL2204
20
Creep-resistant steels
CrMnV, CrMoV contents, worldwide developments in the manufacture of steam boilers and small forgings for steam turbines produced steels with chemical compositions of 0.15%C–0.3–0.5%Mo, 0.13%C–1%Cr–0.5%Mo17 and 0.10%C–2.25%Cr–1%Mo20 which are still in use today. In addition, in the 1950s, a MoV steel with a composition of 0.14%C–0.5%Mo–0.3%V with an even higher creep strength was developed in Europe for gas turbines and later also qualified in long-term creep tests for steam plants. In the field of turbine manufacturing since the 1950s a steel with a composition of approximately 0.25%C–1.25Cr–1%Mo–0.30%V is in use worldwide for turbine rotors, casings, bolts and small forgings. Systematic investigations into the creep strength of the steels developed in short-term tests between the 1920s and 1940s were followed in the 1950s by long-term creep tests.10–16 In Germany, for instance, a joint research project was established for this purpose in 1949 between steel and power plant manufacturers and plant operators.10 Long-term creep tests of individual melts have actually been performed by research bodies in Germany since the mid-1930s (see for example Diehl and Granacher).8 The activities of the individual national creep groups operating within Europe were coordinated in 1990 and culminated in the establishment of the European Creep Collaborative Committee (ECCC) in December 1991.11 Molybdenum was recognised as an important element for increasing high temperature strength. Mo steels developed in the USA and the UK are alloyed with a Mo-content of about 0.5%. The Mo-content of the steel developed in Germany is roughly 0.3% at a C-content of about 0.15%. Figure 2.4 illustrates the influence of molybdenum on the 100 000 h creep rupture strength at 450°C as opposed to an unalloyed steel with roughly 0.15%C.18 By the addition of approximately 0.5%Mo, the 100 000 h creep strength of the unalloyed steel of roughly 70 MPa is increased to about 260 MPa. The alloying effect of Mo is the result of solution hardening and Mo2C precipitation.9,18 A drawback of Mo alloying to over about 0.35% is a marked decline in ductility under creep stress conditions as well as graphite precipitation. Consequently, steels with an Mo-content of 0.5% should not be used in temperature environments over 400°C. However, the strengthincreasing effect of higher Mo contents, without an unacceptable decrease in ductility, can be utilised by the addition of Cr as in the case of the steels with a composition of 0.13%C–1%Cr–0.5%Mo and 0.10%C–2.25%Cr–1%Mo. Figure 2.5 shows the influence of Mo and Cr on the 100 000 h creep rupture strength of the three steels 0.3%Mo, 1%Cr–0.5%Mo and 2.25%Cr– 1%Mo at 500°C and 550°C.18 The highest creep rupture strength is already achieved by the 0.13%C–1%Cr–0.5%Mo steel at 500°C. At 550°C, subjected to an increase in the Mo and Cr-contents as in the case of the 0.10%C– 2.25%–Cr1%Mo steel, a further increase in the creep rupture strength is obtained. Microstructure investigations on the initial condition of the 0.13%C–
WPNL2204
100 000 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
The development of creep-resistant steels
21
300
200 450°C
100
C-steel
0.1
0.2
0.3 0.4 Mo content (mass%)
0.5
0.6
2.4 100 000 h creep rupture strength of a C-steel as a function of Mo content at 450°C.
1%Cr–0.5%Mo steel revealed M3C, M7C3 and M23C6 precipitations whereas for the 0.10%C–2.25%Cr–1%Mo steel Mo2C and M23C6 precipitations were found (see for example Florin).19 An excellent literature survey about the microstructure formation of the CrMo steels after heat treatment and long term creep is given by Orr et al.20 The 0.14%C–0.6%Mo–0.3%V steel, which in view of its higher creep rupture strength (Fig. 2.8) is given preference for live steam pipes and pipes with superheated steam, features higher strength than the 0.10%C–2.25%Cr– 1%Mo steel owing to finely distributed and thermally very stable V4C3 precipitation and Mo2C.19,21 A drawback for this steel is its tendency to type IV cracking in the intercritical area of the heat affected zone of welds (see for example Schüller et al).22 Amongst the numerous steel versions developed in the 1930s and 1940s for the manufacture of rotors, casings, valves and bolts for steam turbines, a 1%CrMoV steel has found worldwide acceptance which, depending on component size and the location of the site of development, is alloyed with a composition of roughly 0.20–0.30% C, 1–1.5% Cr, 0.70–1.25% Mo, 0.25– 0.35% V and 0.50–0.75% Ni.15,23,24 Figure 2.6 shows schematically the relationship of the 100 000 h creep rupture strength and the fracture toughness FATT50 as a function of the microstructure for the 1%CrMoV steel.26 The highest creep rupture strength of this steel type is achieved with an upper bainite structure.25 The disadvantage of the upper bainite structure is the lower toughness25 so that
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels 100 000 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
22
200 Steel Steel 1%Cr–0.5%Mo 2.25%Cr–1%Mo 500°C
160
120
80
Steel 0.3Mo
40
0.2
100 000h creep rupture strength (MPa)
500°C
0.4 0.6 0.8 Mo content (mass%)
1.0
200
160
Steel Steel 1%Cr–0.5%Mo 2.25%Cr–1%Mo 500°C
120
80
500°C Steel 0.3%Mo
40
0.5 1.0 1.5 Mo content (mass%)
2.0
2.5 100 000 h creep rupture strength of low alloyed steels as a function of Mo and Cr content at 500°C and 550°C.
the individual alloying elements of the steel as well as heat treatment must be aligned to the specific operational properties of the components.26 In some cases the procedure for turbine rotors is to adapt the heat treatment contour to the operational properties and/or to apply a method of spray hardening with different quenching rates for the specific regions of the components.26 Investigations into the microstructure in the initial state revealed V4C3, Mo2C and M23C6 (see for example Smith).27 With regard to the ductility and toughness of the 1%CrMoV steel, experience of operational stressed components has emphasised the significance of the austenitising and tempering temperature.28–32 Figure 2.7 illustrates the behaviour of smooth and notched specimens at
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
23
1200
Temperature (°C)
TTT-diagram 1%CrMoV steel
800 F 400
Perlite
B M
102 Martensite (M)
104 Time (s)
106
FATT
FATT
Creep strength
Long term creep strength
Upper Ferrite (F) Lower Bainite (B)
2.6 Creep rupture strength and toughness FATT of 1%CrMoV steel as a function of cooling rate after austenisation respectively for martensite, bainite and ferrite microstructures (schematic). TTT is the time temperature transformation.
500°C in a creep rupture test for two different heat treatment temperatures of two 1%CrMoV melts over test periods up to about 120 000 h.28 Austenitising at 1050°C in connection with a tempering temperature of 700°C was found to cause substantial notch weakening and very low ductility of the smooth specimens (case 17c). An acceptable deformation behaviour is obtained with an austenitising temperature of 980°C and tempering treatment at 670°C. A further disadvantage of heat treatment at an excessive austenitising temperature is the initiation of long-term embrittlement which results in a remarkable reduction of toughness at low temperatures. This loss of toughness has been
WPNL2204
500
24
17a: 0.19%C–1.32%Cr–1.05%Mo–0.54%V 980°C/oil + 2h 670°C/air
17c: 0.17%C–1.10%Cr–1.16%Mo–0.35%V 1050°C/oil + 3h 700°C/air
300 Smooth specimen
Notched specimen
200 500°C
100
Reduction of area (%)
Creep-resistant steels
Creep rupture strength (MPa)
Smooth specimen Notched specimen
400
500°C
102
103
104
105
102
103
104
105
102
103 104 Time to fracture (h)
105
102
103 104 Time to fracture (h)
105
100 80 60 40 20
2.7 Creep rupture strength of smooth and notched specimens of 1%CrMoV steels as a function of heat treatment and time to fracture at 500°C.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
25
105 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
the cause of brittle failure of turbine and valve bolts in the past.32,33 The long-term embrittlement also increases the risk of brittle failure of HP (high pressure) and IP (intermediate pressure) turbine rotors.34,35 In one investigated case, a FATT50 of 340°C was found after long-term service of a turbine rotor with a component temperature of about 380°C.36 However, in this connection, attention must be drawn to the fact that in accordance with technological progress in the early 1950s, the trace elements, owing to the melting process, were still at a relatively high level (e.g. phosphorus up to 0.028%). These high contents of trace elements also contributed to the embrittlement.36 Good long-term experience was gained in Germany with components of 0.20%C– 1%Cr–1%Mo–0.3%V steels in the mid-1950s when the austenitising temperature was limited to a maximum of 950°C and tempering treatment was fixed at 680–740°C. The maximum permissible tensile strength was specified at 835 MPa. Figure 2.8 provides an overview of the 100 000 h creep rupture strength as a function of the test temperature for the non-alloyed and low-alloyed heat-resistant steels currently established for the temperature range below about 565°C. Two new low-alloyed heat-resistant steels have been developed over the past 15–20 years predominantly for the manufacture of water walls for advanced steam power stations. The steels are named HCM2S (0.06%C– 2.25%Cr–2%Mo–1.6%W–0.25%V–0.05%Nb–0.02%N–0.003%B)37 and 7CrMoVTiB (0.07%C–2.4%Cr–1.0%Mo–0.25%V–0.07%Ti–0.01%N– 0.004%B).38 Both steels lend themselves well to welding and do not require post-weld heat treatment. Their creep rupture strengths in comparison with Steel (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f)
C 0.18 0.15 0.13 0.10 0.14 0.28
Cr – – 1.0 2.25 0.5 1.0
Mo – 0.3 0.5 1.0 0.6 1.0
V (mass%) – – – – 0.3 0.3
*Upper bainite
200
(f) 1%CrMoV* (e) 0.6%MoV 100
(b) 0.3%Mo (d) 2.25%CrMo
(a) C-steel
(c) 1%CrMo 0 450
500
550
600
Temperature (°C)
2.8 100 000 h creep rupture strength of a C-steel and low alloyed heat-resistant steels as a function of test temperature.
WPNL2204
26
Creep-resistant steels
the conventional used 0.15%C–0.5%Mo and 0.13%C–1%Cr–0.5%Mo steels are given in Fig. 2.9.
2.3.3
9–12%Cr steels
The development of heat-resistant 9–12%Cr steels was strongly motivated by two major events. During the 1950s it was the development of thermal power stations for public power supply, operating at steam temperatures ranging from 538°C to 566°C and during the 1980s the target was set to develop low-pollution power stations operating at steam admission temperatures of 600–650°C and supercritical pressures up to 350 bar. Figure 2.10 presents a summary of current national and international research projects in progress since the 1980s in Japan, USA and Europe. An overview of the historical development of heat-resistant ferritic– martensitic 9–12%Cr steels from the 1950s to the 1990s is given in the upper part of Fig. 2.11. The lower part shows recent values of the 100 000 h creep rupture strength at 600°C, extrapolated from long-term test data. Table 2.1 illustrates the chemical composition of the steels. As a rule, the steels are an onward development of steels already applied over extended periods of time by using the trial-and-error method. Development of 9–12% Cr steels for steam temperatures up to 620°C
105 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
The steel X22CrMoV 12 1 was developed in the 1950s for thin-walled and thick-walled power station components. Its creep strength is based on solution Steel (a) (b) (c) (d)
C 0.16 0.13 0.06 0.07
Cr – 1.0 2.25 2.4
Mo 0.3 0.5 0.2 1.0
W – – 1.6 –
V – – 0.25 0.25
Nb – – 0.05 –
Ti – – – 0.07
N – – 0.02 0.01
B (mass%) – – 0.003 0.004
200 (d) 7 CrMoVTiB 10 10 (c) HCM 2 S 100 (b) 1%CrMo
(a) 0.3%Mo
0 450
500
550
600
Temperature (°C)
2.9 100 000 h creep rupture strength of heat-resistant low alloyed steels used for water walls of steam plant boilers as a function of test temperature.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
27
International projects of advanced power plants
Japan R & D : DPDC Manufacturers, utilities, EPDC 1981–1991 316 Bar 566/566/566°C 314 Bar 593/593/593°C 343 Bar 649/593/593°C 50 MW pilot power plant
1989–1990 1991–1993 1994–2000 300 bar 630/630°C
USA
Europe
R & D : EPRI
Cost 50/501
Manufacturers Manufacturers. steelworks, Study 1978–1980 utilities and R & D institutes 310 Bar 566/566/566°C 1983–1997 310 Bar 593/593/593°C 300 bar 600/600/600°C 345 Bar 649/549/549°C 300 bar 600/620°C Steels and components for Boiler + Turbine EPRI-RP 1403-15 COST 522 300–900 MW R&D: 1986–1993 Steels and components for boiler + turbine (USA, Japan, Alstom+Man)
NRIM-STX 21Project: USC 650°C/350 bar boiler
EPRI-RP 1403-50 -WO9000-38
1997–2012
1990–1999
Thick wall boiler components
1998–2003 300 bar 620/650°C Steels and components for boiler + turbine
COST 536 2004–2008 300 bar max. 650°C Steels and components for boiler + turbine
Thick wall pipes: P 92 + P 122 (USA, Japan, UK + Denmark)
2.10 International research projects for the development of heatresistant steels for advanced steam power plants since 1978.
hardening and on the precipitation of M23C6 carbides. The steel has been applied successfully in power stations over several decades. The steels H46, FV448 and 56T5 (nos. 2 and 3 in Fig. 2.11) exhibit additional alloying of 0.30–0.45% Nb and roughly 0.05 N. The targeted increase in strength is obtained by secondary MX precipitations of the type VN and Nb (C,N). However, a distinct improvement in creep strength at 600°C, which is of primary interest for components for the aviation industry, is only obtainable in the short-term range. In view of the high Nb-content, these steel grades are only suitable for the manufacture of small-size components because the relatively high Nb-content results in pronounced segregations in ingots used in manufacturing thick-walled components. TAF steel (no. 4) developed in Japan by Fujita39 for small components is an onward development of European Nb-containing steels (no. 2: H46 and FV 448). In addition to an improved balance of the alloying elements–based on a very extensive investigation of the influence of all alloying elements on the creep strength – it also features a high boron contents up to 0.040%, which permits the steel only to be used for small components. According to Fujita’s investigations, boron stabilises the M23C6 carbides by forming M23 (C,B)6. At the end of 1999, Fujita40 gave a report on the actual results of creep tests on specimens of this steel which were carried out at 550°C up to about 70 000 h, at 600°C up to about 20 000 h and at 650°C up to about 125 000 h (Fig. 2.12). The results show that this steel has an extremely high
WPNL2204
28
Historical development 1 X 22 CrMo(W)V 12 1/rotors, casings, bolts, blades, pipes 2 H 46; FV 448/bolts, blades, gas turbine discs
France:
3 56 T 5/bolts, blades, Japan : 4 TAF/blades, small forgings
(1) Casing EPRI 1403–15 (2) Rotors and casings COST 501–2 Development for fast breeder
USA : 5 11% CrMoVNbN/rotors (GE) USA : 6 X 10 CrMoVNbN 9 1 (P 91)/pipes, pressure vessels, casings Japan : 7 + 8 HCM 12/Tubes; TMK1, TMK2/rotors Improved power plants (600 °C)
Cost 501 : 9 X 18 CrMoVNbB 9 1/rotors Cost 501 : 10 X 12 CrMoWVNbB 10 11/E911 Japan : 11 + 12 NF 616/HCM 12 A/pipes
1950
1960
1970
1980
100 000 h creep strength at 600°C
9
4
120
40
1950
MPa 160
TMK 1 + TMK 2
MPa
80
1990 Year
6 2,3
E911 5
11 12
8 7
10
1
1960
120 80 40
1970
1980
1990 Year
2.11 Overview of the historical development of heat-resistant 9–12% Cr steels within the time range 1950–1995 and the 100 000 h creep rupture strength of these steels at 600°C.
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
USA, Germ UK:
Table 2.1 Chemical composition and creep rupture strength at 600°C of the steels in Figure 2.11 (mass%) Country Steel
Chemical composition (weight%) C
X22CrMoV 12 1 H46 FV448 56T5 TAF 11%CrMoVNbN
1. 2.
France Japan USA
3. 4. 5.
USA Japan Japan
6. 7. 8.
Europe Europe
9. 10.
Japan Japan
11. 12.
Advanced steels P 91 HCM 12 TMK 1 TMK 2 X18CrMoVNbB 91 X12CrMoWVNbN E911 P92 P122
Japan Germany
13. 14.
HCM 2S 7CrMoTiB
Cr
Mo
0.22 0.16 0.13 0.19 0.18 0.18
12.0 11.5 10.5 11.0 10.5 10.5
1.0 0.65 0.75 0.80 1.5 1.0
0.50 0.70 0.70 0.40 0.05 0.70
0.10 0.10 0.14 0.14 0.18 0.12 0.11 0.07 0.10
9.0 12.0 10.3 10.5 9.5 10.3 9.0 9.0 11.0
<0.40
0.06 0.07
1.0 1.0 1.5 0.5 1.5 1.0 0.95 0.50 0.40 1.Cu 0.20 1.0
2.25 2.40
Ni
0.60 0.50 0.05 0.80 0.20 0.06 <0.40 – –
W
V
Nb
N
B
104 h
105 h
– – – – – –
0.30 0.30 0.15 0.20 0.20 0.20
– 0.30 0.45 0.45 0.15 0.08
– 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.01 0.06
– – – – 0.035 –
103 118 139 144 216 165
59 62 64 64 (150) (85)
– 1.0 – 1.8 – 0.80 1.0 1.8 2.0
0.22 0.25 0.17 0.17 0.25 0.18 0.20 0.20 0.22
0.08 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.08 0.05 0.06
0.05 0.03 0.04 0.04 0.01 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06
124
94 75 90 90 122 90 98 113 101
1.6 –
0.25 0.25
0.05 –
0.02 0.01
0.01 – – 0.003 0.003 0.003 0.004 0.07Ti
170 185 170 165 139 153 156
80 60
The development of creep-resistant steels
Basic steels Germany UK
Rupture strength at 600°C (MPa)
29
WPNL2204
30
Creep-resistant steels 500 550°C
400
Creep rupture strength (MPA)
300 600°C 200 650°C
100 80 700°C 60
40 30 100
1000
10 000 Time to fracture (h)
100 000
2.12 Creep rupture strength of the TAF steel (0.18%C–10.5%Cr– 1.5%Mo–0.2%V–0.15%Nb–0.035%B) as a function of temperature and time to fracture.
creep strength. Furthermore they demonstrate the creep strength potentials of ferritic–martensitic 9–11% Cr steels subject to optimum alloying. The rotor steel 11%CrMoVNbN (no. 5), patented in 1964 by the General Electric Company, USA, is also an onward development of the Nb alloyed steels no. 2.41 In particular, the Nb content was greatly reduced (0.08%) in order to prevent harmful segregation at the centre of a rotor. Furthermore, the alloying elements were balanced in order to avoid the formation of delta ferrite. The published creep strength of about 85–90 MPa for 600°C and 100 000 h was extrapolated on the basis of tests at 620°C up to times of 16 195 h duration.42 The steel referred to in the literature as mod. 9Cr1Mo or P91 (no. 6) is a steel of the newer generation. It was developed under a huge American national project in the late 1970s for manufacturing pipes and vessels for a fast breeder reactor. It is tough, readily weldable and, as shown by creep tests at 593°C up to about 80 000 h, has a high creep strength at 600°C and 100 000 h of about 94 MPa.43 In comparison with earlier steels it is characterised, for example, by a lower C content of only about 0.10% and a reduced Cr content of about 9%. This steel has meanwhile found wide application in all new Japanese and European power stations for the manufacture of pipes and small forgings. It is also used for the manufacture of valve chests and turbine casings.44,45 Steel HCM 12 (no. 7) is a newly developed Japanese 12% Cr steel with
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
31
0.10%C–1%Mo–1%W–0.25%V–0.05%Nb–0.03%N and a duplex structure of delta-ferrite and tempered martensite with improved weldability and creep strength.37,53 The stability of the creep strength of this steel has been obtained primarily by precipitation strengthening with very fine VN precipitates and high-temperature tempering at over 800°C.37 Experience with this steel has already been accumulated over a period of more than 20 years. The steel has been extensively used for superheater tubes in chemical recovery boilers exposed to severe high-temperature corrosion attack. The good resistance to corrosion is due to the high Cr-content of 12%. The Japanese rotor steels TMK 1 and TMK 2 (no. 8), developed in the 1980s, were based on the known properties of steels no. 1–6.46 Compared with the GE rotor steel (no. 5), the C content in particular was reduced and the sum total (C + N) was selected at around 0.17%. Based on the research work of Fujita,47 the Mo content was raised to 1.5% in TMK 1, whereas TMK 2 is additionally alloyed with about 1.8%W. The Mo content is simultaneously balanced to 0.50% in keeping with Fujita’s result that the highest solution hardening was obtained with (Mo + 0.5W) = 1.5%. Both rotor steels have been used for new power stations in Japan. Rotor steels nos. 9 and 10 are primarily the result of research work performed in the 1980s under the European cooperation programme COST 501.48 Steel no. 9 is a 9%CrMoVNb steel which is additionally alloyed with about 0.01% boron. It is an onward development of the TAF steel for large components with reduced contents of Cr, Nb and B and with an increase in V. Creep tests with specimens from a 900 mm diameter pilot rotor, which have so far reached about 100 000 h, indicate a probable creep rupture strength of about 120 MPa at 100 000 h and 600°C. Creep tests up to 94 000 h with specimens from a 600 mm diameter pilot rotor with a similar composition confirm this value. A larger pilot rotor with a diameter of about 1200 mm is under investigation. The creep strength of the steel X12CrMoWVNbN 10 1 1 (steel no. 10) containing 0.06%N instead of 0.01%B and only 1% Mo instead of 1.5% Mo and, in addition, 0.8% W, is about 20% lower, see Fig. 2.13. So far, the longest test period is about 100 000 h. This rotor steel has primarily been used for the new advanced European steam power plants. This steel type has also successfully been applied for many valve chests and turbine casings in the new plants. The pipe steel, E 911, developed under COST 501, features a somewhat comparable chemical composition. The Cr content was reduced to roughly 9%.49 The Ni content is also distinctly lower since because of the lower Cr content there is no risk of the occurrence of delta-ferrite. Based on results up to roughly 100 000 h, the creep rupture strength of this steel is estimated to be 98 MPa at 600°C and 100 000 h. Steel no. 11 is also based on the research work of Fujita. It is a 9% Cr pipe steel specifically alloyed with 0.10%C–1.8%W–0.5%Mo–0.2%V–0.06%Nb–
WPNL2204
105 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
32
Creep-resistant steels Steel (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
C 0.28 0.21 0.12 0.12 0.18
Cr 1.0 12.0 10.0 10.0 9.0
Mo 0.9 1.0 1.5 1.0 1.5
W – – – 1.0 –
V 0.30 0.30 0.20 0.20 0.25
Nb – – 0.05 0.05 0.05
N – – 0.05 0.05 0.02
B (weight%) – – – – 0.010
200 (c/d) X12CrMo(W)VNbN101(1)
(a) 1%CrMoV 100
(b) 12%CrMoV
(e) X18CrMoVNbB91 ca. 20°C ca. 70°C
0 500
550
600
650
Temperature (°C)
2.13 100 000 h creep rupture strength of steam turbine rotor steels as a function of test temperature.
0.05%N and about 0.003%B and tempered at about 750°C. It was developed in the second half of the 1980s under the designation NF 616 (P92).50 Based on creep tests up to about 100 000 h, the creep rupture strength is estimated to be 113 MPa at 600°C and 100 000 h.51 A similar pipe steel HCM 12A (P122), steel no. 12, has also been developed in Japan alloyed with a higher Cr content of 11% in order to improve oxidation resistance. About 1% copper has been added to reduce the tendency to deltaferrite formation caused by the higher Cr-content.52 The newest evaluation of the available results of long term creep tests led to an estimated creep rupture strength of 101MPa at 600°C and 100 000 h.53 Figure 2.14 compares the 100 000 h creep rupture strength versus the temperature for the new pipe steels. In addition to the pipe steel P91, all three pipe steels (E 911, NF 616 and HCM 12A) are in successful use for the new advanced steam power plants. Development of 10–11%Cr steels for steam turbines up to 650°C Based on the experience with the steels developed for temperatures up to 620°C, the alloying principles needed to obtain a further increase in the creep strength of 100 MPa for 100 000 h at the application temperature and to improve the resistance to oxidation are very similar in the Japanese and European research programmes: •
increase in Cr-content of 10–11% to improve the resistance to steam oxidation;
WPNL2204
105 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
The development of creep-resistant steels Steel (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
C 0.10 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.10
Cr 2.50 12.0 9.0 9.0 9.0
Mo 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.45
W – – – 1.0 1.8
V – 0.30 0.20 0.20 0.20
Nb – – 0.05 0.05 0.06
N – – 0.05 0.07 0.05
33
B (mass%) – – – – 0.002
200 (c) P91 (d) E911 (e) P92 (b) 12%CrMoV 100 (a) 2.25%CrMo 25°C 40°C 0 500
550
600
650
Temperature (°C)
2.14 100 000 h creep rupture strength of steam plant piping steels as a function of test temperature.
• • • • •
reduction in Si, Mn- and Ni-content to the lowest possible level to improve the creep strength; addition of 3–6% Co to reduce the diffusion rate and to prevent the formation of delta-ferrite; addition of 0.002–0.018% boron to stabilise the M23C6 carbides by forming M23(C,B)6; addition of 3%W (Japan) or 1.5%Mo (Europe) to improve the solution hardening and to stabilise the M23C6 and M23(C,B)6 carbides; study of the influence of C content on diffusion rate and on M23C6 precipitates.
Table 2.2 provides an overview of the chemical composition of Japanese and European test melts. None of the referenced analysis versions meets the needs for use at 650°C. A direct comparison of the creep strength of the tested versions is only possible in part because, as a rule, the results are only shown in the form of Larson and Miller diagrams. The investigations with the MTR and TOS/JSW test melts resulted in the development of rotor steels MTR 10 A and TOS 110 which were also tested in large pilot rotors.55,57 For these two steels a maximum application temperature of 630°C is given. By way of example, Fig. 2.15 shows the determined creep strength of the weakest version (FB6) and the strongest version (FB8) of the COST programme at 650°C in comparison with the master steel FB2.58,59 At test periods below 10 000 h, the test melts FB6 and FB8 undercut the creep strength curve of the 9% Cr master steel FB2 which is suitable for use up to about 625°C. The
WPNL2204
34
Table 2.2 Chemical composition of rotor test melts investigated in Europe and Japan (mass%) Type
Japan HR1200/20t ingot HR1200/80t ingot HR1200/C HR1200/D HR1200/E MTR various test melts MTR10A pilot rotor TOS/JSW test melts
TOS110 pilot rotor nominal
Si
Mn
Cr
Mo
W
Co
Ni
V
Nb
N
B
0.13
0.05
0.80
9.3
1.50
–
1.0
0.15
0.20
0.05
0.020
0.010
0.13 0.14 0.16 0.17 0.18 0.12 0.19
0.09 0.10 0.12 0.09 0.08 0.03 0.02
0.09 0.10 0.08 0.09 0.08 0.12 0.11
10.1 11.2 10.2 11.1 11.0 10.3 11.1
1.46 1.45 1.54 1.46 1.48 0.90 0.90
– – – – – 0.42 0.42
2.85 2.93 2.97 2.94 6.03 3.02 3.02
0.15 0.15 0.17 0.20 0.13 0.17 0.17
0.20 0.22 0.20 0.21 0.20 0.21 0.21
0.06 0.08 0.07 0.07 0.06 0.07 0.07
0.017 0.016 0.019 0.023 0.017 0.030 0.020
0.010 0.009 0.009 0.010 0.009 0.010 0.009
0.09 0.10 0.12 0.13 0.14 0.10– 0.12 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11
0.02 0.06 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.04– 0.10 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.08
0.50 0.46 0.50 0.18 0.15 0.06– 0.50 0.06 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.10
11.0 10.2 10.3 10.5 10.1 10.1– 11.6 10.2 10.3 10.2 10.2 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.2 10.2 10.0
0.23 0.14 0.16 0.14 0.18 0.33– 2.50 0.71 0.70 0.70 1.51 1.54 0.69 0.72 0.70 0.70 0.65
2.60 2.50 2.51 2.40 2.41 0– 1.96 1.76 1.80 1.76 – – 1.81 1.78 1.81 1.78 1.80
2.50 2.40 1.18 1.17 1.45 0– 6.0 3.7 3.02 2.98 2.95 2.98 2.95 2.97 2.97 2.97 3.0
0.51 0.25 0.04 0.11 0.18 0.02– 0.30 0.06 0.20 0.21 0.21 0.19 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.22 0.21 0.19 0.23 0.20 0.17– 0.21 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 – – 0.02
0.07 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.05– 0.06 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 – – 0.06 0.06 0.05
0.020 0.020 0.018 0.023 0.018 0.021– 0.076 0.029 0.018 0.020 0.018 0.018 0.022 0.019 0.019 0.020 0.020
0.018 0.013 0.011 0.011 0.011 0– 0.008 0.004 – 0.009 – 0.008 – 0.009 – 0.008 0.010
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
COST Programme Master steel: FB2 (625°C) Test Melts: FB5 FB6 FB7 FB8 FB9 FB10 FB11
C
The development of creep-resistant steels
35
Creep rupture strength (MPa)
200
650°C
FB2
100 80 FB6 60 FB8 40
100
Test temperature 650°C
1000 10 000 Time to fracture (h)
100 000
2.15 Creep rupture strength of the COST test steels FB2, FB6 and FB8 as a function of time to rupture at 650°C.
650°C creep strengths of the HR1200/20t ingot, the HR1200/80t ingot and the HR1200/C are shown in Fig. 2.16.60 After 10 000–20 000 h the HR1200/20t and the HR1200/80t versions (variants A and B) reveal a distinct reduction in creep rupture strength. Based on published test progress at 15 000 h, the long-term behaviour of the HR 1200/C version cannot be evaluated. However, the target of 100 MPa at 100 000 h will not be reached even after a further stable pattern of the creep rupture strength curve. According to the results of investigations into the microstructure of versions FB6 and FB8 of the COST programme, the marked decline in creep strength is mainly caused by precipitation of the Z-phase Cr2(Nb,V)2N2 which is formed at the expense of MX precipitations.54,61 A further striking fact is a remarkable coarsening of M23C6 precipitations and the Laves phase. A significant coarsening of the M23C6 precipitations and the Laves phase was also determined in investigations of versions HR1200/20t and HR1200/80t.60 This publication, however, does not provide any information on MX and Z-phase precipitations. It is significant when considering the interpretation of the investigation results into the microstructure of these rotor test melts that the long-term creep-stressed specimens of the thermally very stable steels TAF, B2 and FB2 revealed no Z-phase precipitations, but fine MX precipitations and only minor coarsening of the M23C6 precipitations.61,62 The influence of 8.56– 11.59%Cr on the creep strength at 650°C for a steel which in addition is alloyed with 0.10%C–3%W–3%Co–0.70%Mo–0.15%V–0.06%Nb–0.02%N– 0.01%B has been reported.63 Figure 2.17 presents an overview of the results. The summary includes details of the creep rupture time as a function of the
WPNL2204
36
Creep-resistant steels Test temperature 650°C
300 Ingot sizes: 20 t (A) 80 t (B) small (C) small (E)
Rupture strength (MPa)
200
A
100 80 60
40 30 100
C Si Mn Cr Mo Ni W V Nb N B Co Al
HR1200 variants B C
E new design 0.09 0.09 0.10 0.14 0.02 0.06 0.03 0.03 0.50 0.47 0.50 0.15 11.0 10.2 10.3 10.1 0.23 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.51 0.25 0.04 0.10 2.6 2.59 2.51 2.41 0.22 0.21 0.19 0.20 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.02 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.012 0.011 0.011 2.53 2.46 1.18 1.45 0.007 <0.005 0.005 0.001 1000
10 000 Time to fracture (h)
100 000
2.16 Creep rupture strength of the rotor test steels HR1200 (Variants A-B-C) as a function of time to rupture at 650°C.
Cr content and test stresses in the range 300–98 MPa. In the long-term range, that is, at lower test stresses, the alloying procedure with approximately 9%Cr exhibits the highest creep strength whereas in the short-term range the alloy with about 11.5%Cr reveals the highest creep strength. Investigations into the microstructure of the 157 MPa stressed creep specimens of the 9.5%Cr and 11.5%Cr versions showed the following results after creep rupture periods of 5289 h and 1928 h respectively. For the first set result the 11.5%Cr steel, the dislocation density decreased, subgrains were formed and only a minor fine Laves phase could be observed within the lath structure. For the second set result the 9.5%Cr steel on the other hand, the lath width remained narrow and the dislocation density was higher than for the 11.5% Cr steel and in addition, a significant amount of fine Laves phase had still been precipitated within the lath structure. The conclusion drawn was that the coarsening of precipitates, such as the Laves phase, was increased and that recovery of the microstructure could not be suppressed in the higher Cr steels. Development of 11% Cr steels for pipes and headers for 650°C steam plants Based on experience with the steels developed for temperatures up to 620°C, the alloying principles needed to obtain a further increase in the creep strength
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
37
Heat treatment 5 h 1070°C +20 570°C +20 h 680°C
98MPa
104 118MPa
137MPa Metallographic investigation
Time to rupture (h)
157MPa
103 177MPa
210MPa
240MPa 102
270MPa
101
300MPa 8
9
10 11 Cr content (%)
12
2.17 Creep rupture strength of 8.5–12%Cr–3.5%W–3%CoVNbB test steels as a function of Cr content, applied stress and time to fracture at 650°C.
to reach 100 MPa for 100 000 h at the application temperature and to improve the resistance to oxidation are similar in the research programmes undertaken in Japan and Europe:64–66 • • • •
increase in Cr-content to about 11% to improve the resistance to steam oxidation, addition of 1–3%Co to reduce the diffusion rate and to prevent the formation of delta-ferrite, addition of 0.003–0.012% boron to stabilise the M23C6 carbides by forming M23(C,B)6, addition of 0.3–3%W and/or 0.15–1.5%Mo (Europe) to improve solution hardening and to stabilise the M23C6 and M23(C,B)6 carbides,
WPNL2204
38
•
Creep-resistant steels
addition of 0.07%Ta and 0.04%Nd to improve the creep strength by fine and stable nitrides.
Table 2.3 provides an overview of the chemical composition of Japanese and European test melts. None of the referenced analysis versions meets the needs for use at 650°C. Figure 2.18 shows a comparison of the published results for steels VM12, NF12 and SAVE 12 with regard to the target creep strength at 650°C.67–69 The behaviour is comparable with the creep strength established for the rotor steels in Table 2.2, that is, with 10–11%Cr and Cocontents of roughly 3%. Results of the investigations into the microstructure have hitherto only been published for version NF12. After creep stressing for 15 000 h at 650°C it was similarly discovered that Z-phase precipitation took place at the expense of MX precipitation.70 Japanese NIMS research project STX 21 for the development of thicksection boiler components The Japanese research project STX 21, started in 1995,71 embraces a most comprehensive 15-year investigation into the influence of the alloying elements on the creep strength and oxidation resistance of the ferritic–martensitic steels in thick-section boiler components for advanced power stations. The systematic investigation into all relevant elements in regard to material property requirements for main steam pipes and headers covers: • • • • •
105 h creep rupture strength at 650°C oxidation resistance in steam weldability and creep rupture strength of welded joints thermal fatigue impact properties and hot workability.
Figure 2.19 demonstrates the design philosophy of a 9%Cr steel72 with the alloying partners W, Mo, Ni, Cu, Co, Si, V, Nb, Ta, C, N and B and their specific property profile. In addition, further analysis versions were tested. Table 2.4 provides an overview of investigated element variations within the project. Reports on test progress were issued on a regular basis at international conferences. The best version was established to be a steel with 0.08%C– 9%Cr–3%W–3%Co–0.20%V–0.05%Nb–0.008%N–0.014%B.73 It was found that the addition of boron at more than 0.01% to the 9%Cr steel remarkably improves the long-term creep strength. Boron stabilises the lath martensitic microstructure of 9%Cr–3%W–3%Co steels during creep deformation at 650°C through the stabilisation of M23C6 in the vicinity of prior austenite grain boundaries by an enrichement of boron in the M23C6 carbides. Further improvement of creep strength in this high boron-containing steel is accomplished by the addition of 0.008% nitrogen enhancing precipitation of fine MX. The steel also exhibits good creep–rupture ductility.
WPNL2204
Table 2.3 Chemical composition of pipes and header test melts investigated in Europe and Japan (mass%) Type
Si
Mn
Cr
Mo
W
Co
Ni
V
Nb
N
B
0.10 0.16 0.16
0.35 0.15 0.30
0.45 0.09 0.22
8.75 11.0 11.1
1.00 1.04 1.04
– 0.32 0.32
– 2.12 2.16
0.20 0.14 0.43
0.21 0.26 0.27
0.080 0.065 0.067
0.050 0.059 0.060
– 0.009 0.011
0.10 0.11 0.15
0.40 0.40 0.30
0.50 0.50 0.22
9.0 11.5 11.2
0.45 0.28 0.50
1.8 1.4 2.1
– 1.30 2.15
0.15 0.23 0.44
0.20 0.24 0.26
0.060 0.065 0.068
0.045 0.056 0.063
0.003 0.003 0.009
0.17 0.19 0.18
0.07 0.10 0.10
0.06 0.52 0.51
9.34 11.6 11.5
1.55 1.48 1.48
– – –
– – –
0.12 0.20 0.25
0.27 0.26 0.26
0.064 0.058 0.058
0.015 0.015 0.047
0.010 0.004 0.004
0.13 0.16 0.16 0.13 0.16 0.12
0.05 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.50
0.82 0.53 0.50 0.49 0.50 0.35
9.32 11.3 11.4 11.3 11.4 11.5
1.47 1.46 1.48 1.44 1.46 0.30
– – – – – 1.5
0.96 0.90 1.06 3.06 1.49 1.6
0.16 0.26 0.26 0.28 0.27 0.30
0.20 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.27 0.25
0.05 0.047 0.058 0.057 0.044 0.050
0.019 0.063 0.063 0.051 0.050 0.065
0.009 0.006 0.012 0.008 0.008 0.005
0.10 0.10
0.35 0.30
0.50 0.20
10.2 11.0
0.15 –
2.5 3.0
2.0 3.0
<0.10 <0.10
0.22 0.20
0.07 0.07
0.02 0.04
0.005 0.07Ta 0.04Nd
63
Japan Results of investigations of various test melts NF1265 SAVE 1265
39
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
COST programme Master steel P91: F1 F2 Master steel P 92: F F3 Master steel B2: A B Master steel FB2: C D E G Pilot pipes VM1264
C
Creep-resistant steels 300
Test temperature 650°C
200
Rupture strength (MPa)
40
SAVE12
NF12
100 80 VM12 60 P92 (mean ECCC) 40 30 100
1000
10 000 Time to fracture (h)
100 000
2.18 Creep rupture strength of piping test steels NF12, SAVE 12 and VM12 as a function of test time at 650°C in comparison to the behaviour of the 9% Cr piping steel P92.
Cr < 8
Cr = 9
Oxidation resistance decrease Addition of Si W + 2Mo < 2
W + 2Mo = 3
Ni = 0.5(Cu, Co)
Ni > 0.5(Cu, Co) Creep strength decrease Ac1 temperature decrease Additon of Ir, Rh, Pd
δ ferrite formation
Si < 0.3
W + 2Mo > 3 Toughness decrease
Creep strength decrease Ni = 0
Cr > 11 δ ferrite formation Addition of austenite stabilising elements
Si = 0.5
Oxidation resistance decrease Addition of Y
Si > 0.6 Carbide agglomeration Acceleration of Fe2W precipitaton
V, Nb, Ta V = 0.2, Nb = 0.05, Ta = 0.1–0.2 C, N, B
Fine dispersion of MC by TMCP Increase in MC volume fraction
C = 0.08–0.1, N = 0.03 –0.06, B = 0.005–0.008 Creep strength decrease
Carbide agglomeration Weldability decrease
2.19 NIMS alloy design philosophy of high Cr ferritic steels for 650°C ultrasupercritical (USC) boilers.
WPNL2204
Table 2.4 Chemical composition of test steels for pipes and boilers of the NIMS STX 21 project (mass%) C
Si
Mn
Cr
Mo
W
9CrW
0.10
0.30
0.50
9.0
–
9CrWMo
0.08
0.30
0.50
9.0
9CrWN
0.10
0.30
0.50
9.3
3 2.8 2.5 1.9 <0.01 –
– 1 2 4 0.003 0.10 0.33 0.62 1.54 3.3
9CrWB 9CrCoTiAl
0.08 0.10
0.30 0.01
0.50 0.01
9.0 9.0
– –
–0.01 0.30 0.50
<0.01
Var. 8.5 10
–
0.14
9–12Cr WSiTiY (Oxidation– tests)
V
Nb
N
Co
B
0.02
0.22
0.05
0.05
0.20
0.05
3.0
0.005
3.0 –
0.20 0.20
0.05 0.05
0.054 0.026 0.001 0.02 0.05
3.0 3.0
0+0.014
2.0
0.20
0.05
0.05
–
9CrWCoPd
0.08
0.80 1.0 0.30
9CrWVTa
0.10
0.30
ODS 10CrTiY2O3
0.065 –0.12
9 –13
–
2
ODS 12CrWY2O3
<0.05
12.3
–
0–3
0.014 (Ti+Al) Var. Ti 0
12 0.50
9.0
–
3.0
0.20
0.05
0.05
0.50
9.0
–
3.0
0.20
0.05
0.05
0.005
Var. Al 0.001
0.10
0.008
Y 2 O3 0.08 –0.35 Y 2 O3 0.24 –0.25
41
WPNL2204
0+3
0.05 0.10 0Pd 1Pd 3Pd Ta 0.02 Ti 0.12 +.22 Ti 0–0.39
Var.Y 0 0.05
The development of creep-resistant steels
Type
42
Creep-resistant steels
Figure 2.20 presents an overview of the influence of B and N on creep strength of 9Cr3W3CoVNbNB steel at 650°C in comparison with the TAF and P92 steels. The creep strength of the best 9%Cr version with 0.014%B and 0.008%N correlates in the long-term range with the creep strength of the TAF steel. Considering the results hitherto available, the authors of this publication conclude that, based on the present chemical composition, a 100 000 h creep strength of 100 MPa at 650°C is achievable. Protective Crrich scale is formed on the surface of 9%Cr by a combination of Si addition and pre-oxidation treatment in argon gas at 700°C for 20 h. This significantly improves oxidation resistance of 9%Cr steels at 650°C.74
2.4
Historical development of austenitic steels
2.4.1
History of austenitic steels
Nickel alloyed austenitic steel originated from 25%Ni–Fe alloy and 25%Ni– 5 to 8%Cr–Fe alloy melted by Krupp in Germany in 1893 and 1894, respectively.75 Krupp also produced 35%Ni–13 to 14%Cr–Fe and 25%Ni–8 to 15%Cr–Fe alloys for use in thermocouple sheaths and molten glass mould material in 1910.75 Krupp continued the development of a series of Ni–Cr– Fe steels and identified a martensitic 10%Cr–2%Ni steel and an austenitic Test temperature 650°C 300
Rupture strength (MPa)
200 TAF (Fujita)
100 80 9Cr3W3CoVNbB(NIMS) 60
40 30 100
0.0139B/0.0034N 0.0092B/0.0016N 0.0048B/0.0011N 0.0135B/0.0079N 0.0100B/0.0200N
1080/800°C 1050/790°C 1050/790°C 1150/770°C 1080/800°C 1000
10000 Time to fracture (h)
P92(ECCC)
100 000
2.20 Creep rupture strength of 9Cr3W3CoVNbB NIMS test steel as a function of B and N content, heat treatment and time to fracture in comparison to the behaviour of the 9% Cr piping steel P92 and the TAF steel.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
43
20%Cr–5%Ni steel in 1912 as stainless steels.76 The latter was designated as V2A in 1922 (V for Versuchstahl, respectively test steel, 2 as the development number, and A for austenitic) and served as an original austenitic steel for use after solution annealing for corrosion resistance in vessel piping, machinery, and so on in acid environments.77 Conventional 18%Cr–8%Ni austenitic steel originated from V2A in the mid-1920s, optimising the content of Cr and Ni to maximise the economical benefit by keeping the structure austenitic.78 Since these austenitic steels suffered severe intergranular corrosion in the weld heat affected zone, extensive investigation into the corrosion mechanism and improvement of the steels was carried out at Krupp around 1930. Consequently, stabilised austenitic steels were developed employing alloying elements Ti, V, Nb and Ta, as well as reducing the carbon content to a maximum of 0.07% and achieving a fine grained steel with finer distribution of chromium carbide.79 These steels are original versions of the conventional Type 321 and Type 347 steels. Type 316 originated from 18%Cr–8%Ni steel containing 3% molybdenum for use in ammonium chloride and sulphuric acid environments as a corrosion-resistant alloy. At that time (early 1930s), addition of the combination of Mo and Cu was found to deliver improved corrosion resistance against sulphuric acid and 18%Cr–8%Ni–2%Mo–2%Cu was thus developed by Krupp. From the viewpoint of better cold workability of austenitic steels, austenite forming elements such as Mn and Cu were increasingly used to develop several new steels, namely 19-9LW(19%Cr–9%Ni–1.25%Mo–1.25%W–NbTi), 199DX(19%Cr–9%Ni–1.5%Mo–1.2%W-Ti) and 17-14CuMo81 modified from Krupp V6A by Armco Steel in USA.80 These steels with stabilised austenitic structures exhibited not only corrosion resistance to sulphuric acid but also resistance to heat and creep. Figure 2.2182 shows the elevation of creep rupture strength of heat-resistant steels for boilers, viewed in terms of change in 100 000 h creep rupture strength at 600°C, for materials developed during the 20th century. After World War II, 18%Cr–8%Ni steels previously developed in Germany before the war were used for heat-resistant purposes as well as in chemical plants worldwide, thereby increasing the steam pressure and temperature of fossilfired power plants. Also, ultra-supercritical pressure power plants constructed in the late 1950s were realised by further applying these austenitic steels to thick walled components. For example, TP316H was used for boiler headers and steam piping and 17-14CuMo and TP321H for superheater and reheater tubes at Eddystone unit No. 1. Esshete 1250 (15%Cr-10%Ni-6%Mn1%MoVNbB)83 austenitic steel was also used for thick section components in the UK. In the 1950s high nickel Alloy800H was developed and put in service in the USA as a high strength and anti-corrosive steel substitutable for Nibased alloys. We must remember that these austenitic steels were basically
WPNL2204
44
Creep-resistant steels
NF709
105 h Creep rupture strength at 600°C (MPa)
200
RH3C AA-1 XA-704 Spr304H A-3 Next generaton 12Cr-WCoVNb
Stable austenitic 150
17-17CuMo E1250 800H
A-1 TP347HFG
HCM2S T24 (2Cr)
Meta-stable austenitic
50 Ferritic Ni-Cr 0 1900
Cr-Mo
1920
(2Cr) T22
3rd generation
NF616 HCM12A E911 HCM12 2nd generation T91
TP347H TP316H TP321H TP304H
100
SAVE25 HR6W
1st generation F-9 EM12 HCM9M HT9 HT91
410 T9 (9-12Cr)
1940
1960 Year
1980
2000
2020
2.21 Historical improvement in creep rupture strength of boiler steels.
developed for corrosion-resistant materials and unexpectedly showed good creep-resistant properties. From the perspective of the improved creep resistance of the 18%Cr–8%Ni system, austenitic steel alloy development studies started in the 1960s. Tempaloy A-184 was developed through the optimisation of carbon stabilising elements of Ti and Nb in 18%Cr–8%Ni steel in the early 1970s, followed by thermo-mechanically strengthened TP347H with finer grain structure developed in the early 1980s, designating TP347HFG85 for use in superheaters and reheaters as a steam oxidation-resistant and creepresistant material. Subsequently, several other 18%Cr–8%Ni austenitic steels with highly improved creep strength, such as Super304H,86 XA70487 and Tempaloy AA-188 were developed. Within the group of high Cr and high Ni austenitic steels, several new 20– 25%Cr austenitic steels with nitrogen and relatively lower Ni content were developed from the 1980s to the 1990s. As seen in Fig. 2.21 (for reference), the improved creep strength of ferritic steels is notable, along with the improvement of austenitic steels. Regarding ferritic steels, low alloy steels
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
45
or 9–12% Cr steels with about 40 MPa of 100 000 h creep rupture strength (half or less than that of 18%Cr–8%Ni steels) had been used for many years and the problem of cost increases existed because, especially in the case of superheater and reheater applications, there was an alloy ‘gap’ between the low alloy steels and the 18%Cr–8%Ni steels, arising as a result of temperature elevation. Accordingly, research work for high strength 9–12%Cr steels was initiated in order to fill this gap and 60 MPa class materials (first generation) were developed over the period from 1950 to 1970. Further efforts have been made and creep strength reached the 100 MPa class (second generation) in the 1980s, whereas the 130 MPa class (third generation) was achieved in the 1990s. Materials for 150 MPa at 600°C or 100 MPa at 650°C, as the next generation, are expected to emerge. In general, the outside diameter and wall thickness of pipes and tubes can be greatly reduced through elevation of creep rupture strength. Thermal stresses can accordingly be lowered and construction of fossil-fired power plants capable of load sliding operation under further elevated pressure and temperature steam conditions will be possible.
2.4.2
Alloy design of creep-resistant austenitic steels
Heat-resistant steels for practical application must be designed by taking their service conditions and environments into consideration and by examining their various properties.89 However when alloy design is performed based on modification of existing steels, both oxidation and corrosion resistance as well as their general material properties are expected to be nearly equivalent to those of the original materials. Hence, chemical compositions and heat treatment conditions are examined with particular consideration of creep strength improvement. Figure 2.2289 shows the concept of alloy design for heat-resistant austenitic steels to improve creep strength through the modification of existing steels. In the case of austenitic steels, chemical composition can be largely classified into the four categories shown in the figure, and solution strengthening and precipitation strengthening are designed specifically for each of these categories. 18%Cr–8%Ni steels based on Type 304 steels include Type 316 steels solution-strengthened through the addition of Mo, as well as Type 321 steels and Type 347 steels precipitation-strengthened through the addition of Ti or Nb. However, these materials were originally developed for chemical equipment as mentioned above, placing emphasis on corrosion resistance, but were not designed from the standpoint of creep strengthening. Accordingly, further enhancement of precipitation strengthening by means of ‘under-stabilising’90 C and/or composition design for improved creep strength is used. 15%Cr– 15%Ni or 21%Cr–30%Ni steels with a full austenitic phase structure are capable of high creep strength in the ‘as-is’ condition, although they are
WPNL2204
46
Austenitic steel
18%Cr-8%Ni
Precipitation strengthening
Type 316 (Mo)
Type 304
Stabilising
Under stabilising
Cr carbide Type 321 (Ti), TiC
Micro alloying of Nb, Ti, B
Type 347 (Nb), NbC
High strength 18%Cr-8%Ni steel
Lower (Ti + Nb)/C
Alloy design for creep
15%Cr-15%Ni (15%Cr-10%Ni)
Type 17-14CuMo
25%Cr-20%Ni
Type 310
21%Cr-32%Ni
Type alloy800H
2.22 General concept of alloy design for austenitic heat-resistant steels.
WPNL2204
Cu, Mo, W addition
Creep resisting steel
N addition
Creep/ corrosionresistant steel
Low-cost creep/ corrosionresistant steel
Creep-resistant steels
Solution strengthening
The development of creep-resistant steels
47
costly because of their high Ni content. Steels containing 20% and more Cr are likely to have excellent oxidation and corrosion resistance, but a costly Ni content of at least 30% is required to maintain a full austenitic structure. Nevertheless, low-cost, high-strength, highly corrosion-resistant austenitic steel can be designed by adding about 0.2% N to reduce the Ni content and by combining the strengthening mechanism as described above. The features of alloy design of austenitic heat-resistant steels are discussed below. As previously noted, ‘under-stabilising’ is a technique for improving the creep strength of 18%Cr–8%Ni steels. This method enhances creep strength through the improvement of precipitation morphology by fixing C in alloys and decreasing carbide forming elements such as Ti and Nb, which hinder Cr carbide formation, to the point where their contents are insufficient for C fixation. Figure 2.2390 shows this, and the peak point of the creep rupture strength against the ratio of (Ti + 0.5Nb)/C is at position far away from the peak point of conventional Type 321 or Type 347 steels, indicating that reducing additions of Ti and Nb relative to the C content can be useful. Figure 2.2486 shows the effect of the Cu and Nb additions on the creep rupture strength of 18%Cr–9%NiNbN steel and 18%Cr–9%NiCuN steel, respectively. Although Cu addition does not show a major change up to about 2%, a substantial enhancement in creep strength is observed owing to the very finely dispersed Cu-rich particle precipitates by means of Cu addition
105 h Creep rupture strength at 650°C (MPa)
130 120 110 100 90 80 70 321H 347H
60 50 40 30 0.01
0.01
0.1
0.1
0.5 1.0 (Ti + Nb)/C Atomic ratio 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 3.0 4.0 (Ti + 0.5Nb)/C Mass ratio
1.5
2.0
5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0
2.23 Effect of (Ti + Nb)/C ratio on creep rupture strength of 18Cr10NiNbTi steel.
WPNL2204
48
Creep-resistant steels 18Cr-9NiNbN
18Cr-9NiNuN
103
Time to rupture (h)
Time to rupture (h)
103
102
102 700°C 167MPa 137MPa
700°C/137MPa 750°C/108MPa 10 0
2
4
6
Cu (%)
10 0
0.2
750°C 137MPa 108MPa
0.4 0.6 Nb (%)
0.8
1.0
2.24 Effect of Cu and Nb on creep rupture strength of 18Cr–8Ni steels.
of about 3% or more. However, because the strength tends to be saturated, while a decline in creep rupture ductility can occur when the Cu addition exceeds 3%, the addition of Cu at 3% should be suitable. On the other hand, the effect of Nb addition on the creep rupture strength of 18%Cr–9%NiCu steel is significant when Nb content exceeds 0.2% and is saturated at a concentration of above 0.4%, which is not sufficient to stabilise the 0.08%C usually contained in 18%Cr–8%Ni H grade steels. This was mentioned above as an effect of under-stabilising on the creep strength enhancement. Super304H and other Cu-alloyed and under-stabilised steels were thus developed.
2.4.3
Development of austenitic heat-resistant steels
Austenitic steels for heat exchanger and boiler tube applications Chemical compositions of austenitic heat resistant steels for boiler applications are given in Table 2.5, with development progress in austenitic boiler steels presented in Fig. 2.25.91 Considering steels for boiler applications, various improvements have been made to enhance creep strength in the grade of 18%Cr–8%Ni system steel because this grade is used in the highest temperature region of superheater and reheater sections of boilers with conventional steam parameters. The steam oxidation resistance of some 18%Cr–8%Ni steels is also improved at their inner surface through finer grains. Furthermore, new austenitic steels with a Cr content of 20% or more have been developed for the purpose of improving creep strength and corrosion resistance.
WPNL2204
Table 2.5 Nominal chemical composition of austenitic steels for boilers Steels
18%Cr– 8%Ni
20%– 25%Cr
Si
Mn
Ni
Cr
Mo
W
V
Nb
Ti
B
Others – – – – – – 3.0Cu, 0.1N 0.2N 3.0Cu 3.0Cu 0.1N 0.1N – – – 0.2N 0.4Al 0.15N – 3.0Cu, 0.2N 3.0Cu, 0.2N 0.03Zr –
TP304H TP316H TP321H TP347H TP347HFG Tempaloy A-1 Super304H
18Cr–8Ni 16Cr–12NiMo 18Cr–10NiTi 18Cr–10NiNb 18Cr–10NiNb (FG) 18Cr–10NiNbTi 18Cr–9NiCuNbN
0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.12 0.10
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.2
1.6 1.6 1.6 1.6 1.6 1.6 0.8
8.0 12.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 9.0
18.0 16.0 18.0 18.0 18.0 18.0 18.0
– 2.5 – – – – –
– – – – – – –
– – – – – – –
– – – 0.80 0.80 0.10 0.4
– – 0.50 – – 0.08 –
– – – – – – –
XA704 Tempaloy AA-1 17–14CuMo 15–15N AN31 Esshete1250 12R72 TP310 HR3C Alloy 800H Tempaloy A-3 NF709 SAVE25
18Cr–9NiWVNb 18Cr–10NiCuTiNb 17Cr–14NiCuMoNbTi 15Cr–15NiMoWNbN 15Cr–13NiMoNbN 15Cr–10Ni6MnVNbTi 15Cr–10NiMoNbVB 25Cr–20Ni 25Cr–20NiNbN 21Cr–32NiTiAl 22Cr–15NiNbN 20Cr–25NiMoNbTi 22.5Cr–18.5NiWCuNbN
0.03 0.10 0.12 0.12 0.10 0.12 0.10 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.05 0.15 0.10
0.3 0.3 0.5 0.7 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.6 0.4 0.5 0.4 0.5 0.1
1.5 1.5 1.7 1.5 1.5 0.6 2.0 1.6 1.2 1.2 1.5 1.0 1.0
9.0 10.0 14.0 15.0 14.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 20.0 32.0 15.0 25.0 18.0
18.0 18.0 16.0 15.0 16.0 15.0 15.0 25.0 25.0 21.0 22.0 20.0 23.0
– – 2.0 1.5 1.5 1.0 1.0 – – – – 1.5 –
2.5 – – 1.5 – – – – – – – – 1.5
0.3 – – – 0.5 0.2 – – – – – – –
0.3 0.3 0.40 1.0 1.0 1.00 – – 0.45 – 0.70 0.20 0.45
– 0.2 0.30 – – 0.06 0.3 – – 0.50 – 0.10 –
– 0.02 0.008 – – – 0.006 – – – 0.002 – –
Sanicro25
22Cr–25NiWCuNbN
0.08
0.2
0.5
25.0
22.0
–
3.0
–
0.3
–
–
30Cr–50NiMoTiZr 23Cr–43NiWNbTi
0.06 0.08
0.3 0.4
0.2 1.2
50.0 43.0
30.0 23.0
2.0 –
– 6.0
– –
– 0.18
0.20 0.08
– 0.003
High Cr– CR30A High Ni HR6W
WPNL2204
49
C
The development of creep-resistant steels
15%Cr– 15%Ni–
Chemical composition (mass%)
(85)
(74)
20Cr-25NiMoNbTi
18Cr-9NiWVNb
18Cr-8Ni, C<0.08 (40–60)
(AISI 304) +Ti 18Cr-10NiTi (AISI 321) +Nb 18Cr-8Ni (AISI 302)
18Cr-10NiNb (AISI 347) +Mo 16Cr-12NiMo
H Grade 0.04 – 0.10C AISI AISI AISI AISI
304H 321H 347H 316H (75)
NF 709 (SUS310J2TB)
(53) 21Cr-32NiTiAl (Alloy 800H)
(66) 22Cr-15NiNbN
(ASME TP347HFG) Chemistry Optimization (58) 18Cr10NiNbTi Tempaloy A-1 (SUS321J1HTB) Cu Addition
(70)
18Cr9NiCuNbN
17Cr-14Ni CuMoNbTi
Tempaloy A-3 (SUS309J4HTB) Cu Addition (76) 18Cr10NiCuTiNb (89) 23Cr-43NiWNbTi
Tempaloy AA-1 ASME TP 321HCuCb SUS321J2HTB
HR6W
High Cr-High Ni
Super 304H
(AISI 316)
(73) 30Cr-50NiMoTiZr
ASME TP304CuCbN SUS304J1HTB
(91)
Cr30A
22Cr-25NiWCuCoNbN +Cr –Ni
Sanicro 25 (37) 22Cr-12Ni (AISI 309)
(90)
(65)
25Cr-20Ni (AISI 310)
25Cr-20NiNbN
23Cr-18.5NiWCuNbN
HR3C ASME TP310CbN SUS310J1TB
SAVE25 (SUS310J3TB)
( ) Designates 105 h Creep rupture strength (MPa) at 700°C.
2.25 Development progress of austentic boiler steels.
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
–C
XA704 (ASME TP347W) (SUS347 J1TB) Heat Treatment (58) 18Cr10NiNb
50
W Addition
The development of creep-resistant steels
51
18Cr–8Ni steels such as TP304H, TP321H, TP316H and TP347H grades are still used for fossil-fired power plants operating under conventional steam conditions. TP347H, which has the highest allowable stress among these four types, was improved in order to provide a fine-grained structure (grain size number 8 and finer) for steam oxidation resistance and creep strengthening, designated as TP347HFG by ASME. The effect of solution temperature on the creep rupture strength and grain size in thermo-mechanical processes is schematically illustrated in Fig. 2.26.85 This steel is highly effective in improving the reliability of superheater tubes, being applicable to ultrasuper critical pressure power plants up to 600°C class and already fully employed in the superheater tubes of a substantial number of these plants. Since the 15%Cr–15%Ni system steel is stable austenitic and high strengths in creep are likely to be obtained, their allowable stresses are very high. The mechanism of the strengthening of these steels is strong solution hardening by Mo and W, and precipitation hardening effects by inter-metallic compounds as well as by MC and M23C6 carbides make a contribution. Table 2.692 shows the nominal chemical compositions of typical elements forming intermetallic compounds and carbides, Nv – Nc (Nv – Nc is the excess electron vacancy number by PH ACOM which is defined in ASTM A567, v = vacancy, Developed TP347HFG Anneal
Temperature
Grain size, ASTM No.
10 8
NbC Resolved
Precipitated Cold drown
Solution treatments Fine graln
Cold crown
Solution treatments Coarce graln
6 4 2
Developed Conventional
120
105 h creep rupture strength (MPa)
Anneal NbC
650°C × 105 h
100 80
700°C × 105 h ASME A.S./0.67
60 ASME A.S./0.67
40
A.S.: Allowable stress 20 1100
1200 1300 Solution temperature (°C)
1400
2.26 Effect of solution temperature on creep rupture strength and grain size in a thermo-mechanical process.
WPNL2204
52
Creep-resistant steels
Table 2.6 Comparison of major alloying elements and schematic microstructures in 15Cr–15Ni austenitic steels Steel
Mo
W
Nb
Ti
Schematic microstructures NV – NC (700°C) after ageing at 700°C for 104 h
17–14CuMo
2.12
–
0.67
0.28
0.117
15–15N
1.58
1.49
1.07
–
0.096
(Nb, Ti)C NbC
AN31
1.53
–
1.07
–
0.162
Fe2Mo NbC
Esshete 1250
1.04
–
0.96
–
0.197
12R72
1.16
–
–
0.30
0.093
Fe2Mo
TiC M23C6
c = critical) values, and schematic microstructures. The creep rupture properties of five 15%Cr–15%Ni system steels are presented in Fig. 2.27.92 Among these alloys 17-14CuMo exhibits the highest creep rupture strength for the longest time and at the highest temperature. In Fig. 2.28, the allowable stresses for 18%Cr–8%Ni steels and for 17-14CuMo and Esshete1250 representing 15%Cr–15%Ni steels are compared. The allowable stress of Super304H is much higher than that of 17-14CuMo, which is thought to have the highest stress at temperatures up to 670°C among conventional materials. TP347HFG and Tempaloy A-1 also have allowable stresses higher than those of existing conventional steels. Because these steels have been developed on the basis of TP304H or TP321H, their cost effectiveness is excellent. They are also advantageous from the standpoint of resistance to steam oxidation owing to their fine grains. Although newly developed 20%–25%Cr austenitic steels and high Cr– high Ni austenitic steels such as CR30A93 and HR6W94 have excellent resistance to high temperature corrosion and steam oxidation compared to other austenitic steels, their drawback lies in the fact that they are too costly for their allowable stresses. However, as shown in Table 2.5, the materials developed in the 1980s, particularly N-alloyed 20%–25%Cr steel, have excellent high temperature strength as well as being relatively inexpensive. They are practically applied as high strength steels taking high temperature corrosion resistances into account. Allowable stresses for HR3C,95
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels 700°C
300
Stress (MPa)
53
200
100
17–14CuMo 15–15N AN31 Esshete 1250 12R72
70 102
103 Time to rupture (h)
104
700°C
300
Stress (MPa)
105
200
100 70
102
103 Time to rupture (h)
104
105
2.27 Comparison of creep rupture strength of 15Cr–15Ni austenitic steels.
NF70996 and Tempaloy A-397 are far higher than that of Alloy 800H, as shown in Fig. 2.29 and they can be used in higher steam conditions and in corrosive environments. As an example, Fig. 2.3095 shows the effect of the content of solute N on HR3C, with the changing Nb and Ni content in the alloy. Nitrogen as an alloying element acts as a creep strengthening agent in 25%Cr austenitic steel and the combination of 0.4%Nb and 20%Ni addition is an effective measure of the enhancement of creep strength. Alloy 800H has a stable austenite structure, stabilised by using a large addition of Ni, but high temperature strength is insufficient in relation to cost. Although there is currently no choice but to use austenitic steels for superheater and reheater tubes for ultra-supercritical pressure boilers, certain materials have already been developed that are sufficient to meet the steam conditions of 650°C class boiler superheater and reheater tubes, as noted previously. From the mid-1990s to date, materials taking cost effectiveness into consideration have also been developed. SAVE2598 and Sanicro2599 are
WPNL2204
54
Creep-resistant steels
150
TP
34
100 TP
31
FG 17
Te m 30
4H
o Te m
pa
lo
y
A-
1
1H
600 Temperature (°C)
pa
lo
y
AA
-1
0
550
uM
25
0 500
4C
E1
32
50
–1
6H
TP TP
4
7H
70
7H
A
TP34
X
Allowable stress (MPa)
Super 304H
650
700
2.28 Allowable stresses for 18Cr–8Ni and 15Cr–15Ni austenitic steels.
examples that use 0.25% addition of N to stabilise the austenitic structure based on HR3C, in addition to a small amount of Nb addition aimed at precipitation strengthening by means of ‘under-stabilising’. Furthermore, comprehensive strengthening techniques covering a wide range of temperatures have been employed by introducing the concept of Cu addition in Super304H and W addition in HR6W. Here, cost effectiveness has been secured by stabilising the austenitic structure through addition of N and Cu, while decreasing the Ni addition to 18% and reducing the Cr content to a level slightly below that of HR3C. As shown in Fig. 2.25, austenitic steels that have the highest creep rupture strength at 700°C are HR6W, SAVE25 and Sanicro25, exhibiting around 90 MPa at 100 000 h. Figures 2.3194 and 2.32100 show creep rupture strength in the temperature range 650–800°C. Stable creep rupture properties are confirmed in these figures. From the standpoint of realising 700°C class ultra-super critical pressure power plants, achievement of 100 MPa of 100 000 h creep rupture strength (70 MPa in allowable stress) is considered to be required, so that the limits for application of 18%Cr–8%Ni steels and 20–25%Cr austenitic steels with
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
55
NF709 HR
150
loy A -3
3C VE SA
Temp a
25 R6 W
Allowable stress (MPa)
H
Alloy 8 00H
100
CR
TP
50
0 500
550
31
30
A
0H
600 Temperature (°C)
650
700
2.29 Allowable stresses for 20–25Cr and high Cr–high Ni austenitic steels. 200
103 h Creep rupture strength (MPa)
180 160 140 120 100 80 700°C
60
750°C
Nb
Ni 20/23
40
17 0.4/0.5
20 0 0.05
20 23
0.10
0.15 0.20 Soluble N (%)
0.25
0.30
2.30 Effect of content of solute N and Nb and Ni on creep rupture strength of HR3C.
WPNL2204
56
Creep-resistant steels 400
650°C 700°C 750°C 800°C
300
Stress (MPa)
200
100
70 50 40 101
HR6W: 0.07C-23Cr-43Ni-6W-0.1Ti-0.2Nb
102
103 Time to rupture (h)
104
105
2.31 Creep rupture properties of HR6W.
500
650°C 700°C 750°C 800°C
Stress (MPa)
400 300
200 70 50 100
101
102 103 Time to rupture (h)
104
105
2.32 Creep rupture properties of SAVE25 steel.
the highest creep rupture strength in 350 bar plants would be approximately 660°C and 680°C, respectively, as shown in Fig. 2.33.91 In the accompanying figure, allowable stresses at higher temperatures for numerous austenitic steels developed to date are presented together with those for Ni-based alloys. However the allowable stresses in Ni-based alloys are not yet well established owing to insufficient databases and inaccuracy of predicted strength at 100 000 h. Reviewing the austenitic steels developed beyond the strength of conventional steels to date, materials can be classified in the strength levels as shown in Table 2.7 at a temperature of 700°C. Austenitic steels are graded
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
57
Table 2.7 Strength classification of austenitic steels 105 h creep rupture strength at 700°C (MPa)
Allowable stress (MPa)
Steels
Category
60
40
65
43
70
50
75 80, 85 90
53 55 60
TP347HFG Tempaloy A-1 HR3C NF709 Tampaloy A-3 Super304H XA704 Tempaloy AA-1 CR30A – HR6W SAVE25 Sanicro25
18Cr 18Cr 20/25Cr 20/25Cr 20/25Cr 18Cr 18Cr 18Cr High Cr – High Cr 20/25Cr 20/25Cr
in five levels except for the 80 MPa and 85 MPa classes in which strengths are separated in increments of 5 MPa. Table 2.891 lists austenitic steels and Ni-based alloys whose maximum application temperature is categorised by 620–660°C, 620–680°C and 680–770°C. The table also shows the ASME Code Case number assigned and applicable product forms, tubes and/or pipes. Austenitic steels for thick-section pipe and turbine component applications Thick section components in boilers consist of headers and steam piping and under conventional steam conditions, CrMo low alloy steel (for example, 2.25%Cr–1%Mo steel, 0.5%Cr–0.5%MoV steel or martensitic 12%Cr stainless steel X20CrMoV121)101 has been used extensively up to 566°C for many years. From 1989 onwards, P91102 has been selected for headers and piping operating up to 600°C and from the mid-1990s P92103 has also been employed for recently constructed 600°C class ultra-super critical power plants. However, under steam conditions above the temperature at which ferritic steels can be applied, generally above 620°C or 630°C, austenitic steels must presently be used from the standpoint of creep strength and oxidation resistance. Among austenitic steels, ASTM TP316 has actual application experience for the header and main steam piping in the Eddystone Station unit No. 1 in the USA under steam conditions of 350 bar and 650°C. Being an austenitic steel, this material has a low thermal conductivity meaning that thermal stresses will be higher than for ferritic steels. Further, as the high temperature properties of TP316 are greatly influenced by its chemical composition, its high temperature strength will be highly unstable if the chemical composition
WPNL2204
58
Trade designation
Nominal composition
ASME Code/ Code Case
Preferred application
Temperature of application (metal)/°C
Austenitic steels (18%Cr)
347HFG Super304H XA704 Temp. AA-1
18Cr–10Ni–Nb 18Cr–8Ni–Cu–Nb–N 18Cr–9Ni–W–V–Nb 18Cr–10Ni–Nb–Ti
2159 2328 2475 2512
T T T T
620–660
Austenitic steels
HR3C NF709 Temp. A-3 800HT SAVE25 Sanicro25 HR120 HR6W
25Cr–20Ni–Nb–N 20Cr–25Ni–Nb–Ti–N 22Cr–15Ni–N6–N 21Cr–32Ni–Al–Ti 23Cr–18Ni–W–Cu–Nb–N 23Cr–18.5Ni–W–Cu–Nb–N 25Cr–42Ni–N 23Cr–43Ni–6W–Nb–Ti
2115 2581 – 1325 – – – –
T T T T T T T P.T
620–680
Haynes230 Inco617 Inco625 Inco740 45TM
22Cr–5Co–3Fe–14W–2Mo–La 22Cr–13Co–9Mo–Al–Ti 22Cr–5Fe–9Mo–Nb–Al–Ti 25Cr–20Co–Mo–Nb–Al–Ti 27Cr–23Fe–2.75Si
2063 1956 1409 – 2188
P.T P.T P.T P.T P.T
680–770
(20–25%Cr)
Ni-base allows
T: superheater/reheater tubes, P: pipes and headers
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Table 2.8 Candidate alloys for USC power boilers
The development of creep-resistant steels
59
120
one
Inc
7 l 61
on el 74 0
E25
A-3 loy 0H 80 y
40
TP
31
63 c2
50
oni
60
Nim
lo
0S X
Su
Allowable stress (MPa)
Inc
SAV
pa
Al
70
Tem
80
30
25
90
es2
icro
100
Hyn
San
110
A 4
r3
70
pe 04
30
H
20
HR
HR 3C
NF7
10 0 600
Hast
650
700
750
09
elloy
800 850 Temperature (°C)
6W
XR 900
CR30
A Hast
elloy
950
X
1000
2.33 Comparison of maximum allowable stresses at high temperatures.
is not carefully optimised. This must be given special consideration because TP316 is very suitable for use in the heavy sectioned components operating at steam temperatures above the maximum limit for ferritic steels. In the case of TP316, the formation of the sigma phase can be suppressed in theory by having the Ni-valance (= 11.6 + Nieq – 1.35Creq, where Nieq = 0.5Mn + 30(C+N) + Ni, Creq = 1.5Si + Cr + Mo + 0.5 Nb) above 0.104 In practice, however, the sigma phase may precipitate after a long term of service causing a major drop in the creep rupture strength. Figure 2.34105 shows creep rupture test results for the main steam pipes produced at the end of the 1950s and used in the Eddystone No. 1 unit over a period of 130 250 h. It can be seen that a low Ni balance greatly reduces the creep rupture strength. The materials indicated as 17U and 17D in the graph were produced at the start of the 1980s using modern steel-making techniques to keep Ni balance high and were used for only 6000 h under the same conditions, with other samples showing high strength. Among the steels listed in Table 2.5, HR6W is being considered for thick section components of 700°C class ultra supercritical pressure power boilers, taking advantage of its very high creep rupture strength which is on a par with Ni-based alloys.
WPNL2204
60
Creep-resistant steels
400 Sample (Ni-bal.) 25U (2.134) 25D (2.126)
300
20D (–0.370) 20U (–0.367) 17D (1.536) 17U (1.339)
18D (1.195) 18U (2.306) 19D (0.425) 19U (0.045)
8D (–0.134) 8U (–1.167) 7D (–0.017) 7U (–0.961)
Stress (MPa)
200
100 NIMS data (ave.) 650°C
70
50 102
103 Time to rupture (h)
104
105
2.34 Creep rupture properties at 650°C for as-exposed TP316 steel.
A typical thick section component in a steam turbine is the rotor. For quite some time, 1%CrMoV steel and conventional 12%Cr steel have been used for steam temperatures of 566°C and below. The maximum use temperatures for these steels are considered to be 570°C and 590°C, respectively. 12%Cr steel, for which 1.5% W is added in substitution for the equivalent amount of Mo, can be used up to approximately 600°C, but higher temperatures require 12%Cr steel with the addition of W and Co. While the limit has not been clearly defined, safety considerations suggest a temperature of around 630°C. The arrival of ferritic steel that can withstand 650°C is awaited, but advanced materials development is needed since rotors require not only high-temperature strength but also good tensile strength and toughness. Austenitic steels such as Discaloy (13%Cr–25%Ni–3%MoAlTi) and A286 (15%Cr–26%Ni–1.5%MoAlTi) have demonstrated performance in Eddystone No. 1 unit at 650°C and 350 bar, and in a 50 MW demonstration plant in Wakamatsu, Japan also at 650°C. But temperatures over 700°C would require Ni-based alloys such as Inco617 (Ni–22%Cr–13%Co–9%MoAlTi) or Waspaloy (Ni–19%Cr–14%Co–4.5%MoAlTi), or Fe–Ni-based alloys with improved creep strength. From the perspective of practical application, fabricability would need to be improved to enable the manufacture of large components. Figure 2.35 presents the relationship between 100 000 h creep rupture strength and temperature for various materials based on the results of research to date. Along with consideration of Inco617, efforts are also being made worldwide to improve Inco706 (Ni–16%Cr–36%Fe–3%NbAlTi) and to develop alloys modifying the low thermal expansion Inver-type Ni alloy. Of these, LTES700 (Ni–12%Cr–18%MoAlTi)106 is an austenitic alloy featuring a low
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
61
105 h Creep rupture strength (MPa)
700 Refractaloy 26
500
300
Waspaloy
Inco617
400
12CrMoW 12CrWCo 12CrMoV
Inco706 LTES
Mod. A286 200 1CrMoV
100 70 450
500
550
600 Temperature (°C)
650
700
750
2.35 Comparison of 105 h creep rupture strength of turbine rotor alloys.
thermal expansion coefficient similar to ferritic steels and having strength equivalent to that of Refractaloy26 (Fe–18%Cr–38%Ni–20%Co–3%MoAlTi). Furthermore FENIX-700 (Ni–16%Cr–36%Fe–2%NbAlTi), 107 modified Inco706 and TOS-1X (Ni–23%Cr–10%Mo–15%CoAlTiB)108 have been developed aiming at 700°C class steam turbine rotor application. For temperatures above around 630°C, austenitic steels must be used because ferritic steels are presently not strong enough. The Discaloy used in Eddystone No. 1 unit weighed 1.6 tons and was made by melting at atmospheric pressure. However, rotors in 1000 MW class ultra supercritical pressure power plants will require a steel ingot weighing nearly 30 tons, and although it is possible to cast ingots of over 800 mm in diameter by the electro slag remelting (ESR) melting process, there will be a greater tendency for freckling to occur and this may impair the mechanical properties.109 Tests on a 1000 mm diameter A286 steel ingot with a rationalised chemical composition cast using large-size ESR equipment have shown that even if freckling occurs, it has no effect on high cycle fatigue or fracture toughness at room temperature, or on creep rupture strength, high or low cycle fatigue at high temperatures, although it may reduce tensile elongation at temperatures below 200°C.110 Ti and C contents influence freckling to the greatest extent and it has been reported that there was no freckling at all in a 1350 mm diameter ESR A286 steel ingot in which the Ti and C contents had been reduced to 1.13% and 0.02%, respectively. Although reducing the Ti content lowered the creep rupture strength of an A286 ingot, as shown in Fig. 2.36,110 for the level of reduction mentioned above, it satisfies the tensile property and creep rupture
WPNL2204
62
Creep-resistant steels
105 h Creep rupture strength at 650°C
160
100 kg ingot 2 ton ingot 16–19 ton ingot
150
140
130
120
110 0.9
1.0
1.2
1.4 Ti (mass%)
1.6
1.8
1.9
2.36 Effect of Ti content on 105 h creep rupture strength of A286 alloy at 650°C.
strength requirements for rotor material to be used at 650°C, with no reduction in creep notch strength. The Ti and C contents in A286 can also be reduced to 1.52–1.81% and 0.023–0.039%, respectively with no loss in toughness at 650°C confirming in theory the excellent suitability of the chemically improved A286 as a 650°C class rotor material. Austenitic steels for chemical plant applications The typical heat-resistant austenitic steels in chemical plants are used for reformer tubes in hydrogen treating equipment and for cracking tubes in ethylene polymerisation equipment in thermal cracking of naphtha at temperatures above about 800°C. In the case of high pressure equipment such as reformer tubes, higher creep rupture strength is required and anticarbonisation is also required for cracking tubes which are used at higher temperatures. Table 2.9111 shows the chemical composition of these austenitic tube materials for chemical plants made by centrifugal casting. The base alloy is HK40, 25%Cr–20%Ni with a high carbon content of 0.4%. The creep rupture strength has been improved through investigation into the effect of chemical elements. Nb and Ti are used to form eutectic carbide which strongly contributes to improved creep rupture strength, and W and Mo are used as solution strengthening elements in the austenitic matrix. In order to prevent the precipitation of the sigma phase and to stabilise the austenitic matrix as well as to improve anti-carbonisation, the Ni content is increased from 20% to 30–50%, and Si is added (also for the anti-carbonisation).
WPNL2204
Table 2.9 Nominal chemical composition of austenitic steels for chemical plants Steels
Cr–Ni– based
Mo addition
Co addition
C
Cr
Ni
Nb
Co
W
Mo
Ti
Others
0.40 0.43 0.45 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.50 0.50 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.50 0.15 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.40 0.45 0.40 0.50 0.50
25.0 23.5 25.0 25.0 25.0 27.0 25.0 24.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 24.0 25.0 22.0 25.0 25.0 28.0 33.0 25.0 28.0 22.0 25.0
20.0 22.5 20.0 35.0 35.0 29.0 20.0 24.0 35.0 35.0 20.0 20.0 23.0 35.0 30.0 35.0 35.0 48.0 50.0 45.0 48.0 30.0 35.0
– – – – – – – 1.5 1.5 1.0 0.2 0.6 0.7 0.7 1.2 – – – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – 3.0 5.0 13.0 15.0
– – – – – – – – – 1.5 – – – – – – 2.0 5.0 17.0 3.0 5.0 4.5 5.0
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – 1.2 – – – 3.0 – – –
– – – – – – 0.20 – – – 0.20 0.15 0.15 0.15 – – – – – – – – –
– – Si:2.0 – Si:2.0 – R.E.:0.3 – – Si:2.0 R.E. :0.3 – – – – – – – – – – – –
The development of creep-resistant steels
Ti addition Nb addition
HK-40 Mod. HK40 High Si-HK40 HP High Si-HP HO HiKa-1A IN-519 Manaurite 36 Manaurite 36XS Hika-1B BST Mod. BST HP-BST Manaurite 900 HOM MoRe-1 NA-22H MoRe-2 HOM-3 Super 22H Tenex Supertherm
Chemical composition (mass%)
63
WPNL2204
64
Creep-resistant steels
High temperature oxidation and corrosion resistance are improved by the addition of rare earth metal material. Figure 2.37112 demonstrates the creep rupture strength of these centrifugally cast austenitic steel tubes. The creep rupture strength of HK40 is lowest, while the other steels are substantially improved by alloy development. HP-BST whose chemistry is a nominal 0.5%C–25%Cr–35%NiNbTi exhibits the highest creep rupture strength. In the case of centrifugally cast tubes, small diameter sizes are difficult to produce and the extrusion process is also applied to produce tubes. However, the eutectic structure is decomposed by the extrusion process, resulting in a weakening of creep rupture strength. In this case, creep strength improvement by heat treatment is used in reforming the eutectic type carbide structures in the austenitic matrix.
2.5
Historical development of steel melting and of the purity of heat-resistant steels
The increasing demand of the steam plant manufacturer for turbine rotor forgings with improved cleanliness, soundness, higher ductility and toughness has mainly led to improvement in steelmaking processes for heat-resistant steels within the last century. Figure 2.38 gives a rough overview of the historical development of steelmaking processes throughout the 20th century and the achievable reduction in the phosphorus and sulphur contents as the main indicators of the effectiveness of these steelmaking processes.15,113–117 At the beginning of the last century only steels of the Thomas and open
50 40
1000°C Mod. BST
Stress (MPa)
30 HP-BST 20
10 IN519
102
103 104 Time to rupture (h)
Super them NA22H MoRe-1 Manaurite 36X HP HK40
105
2.37 Creep rupture strength of centrifugally casted tubes for chemical plants.
WPNL2204
Steel melting processes
(1) S < 0.075%/P < 0.10% (*) Oxidizing refining in EF
Electric-arc steel EF Thomas steel (1877) Basic open hearth steel (1964) BOH
1900
1920
(1) Max. P and S (%)
reladle
1940
1960 Year of application
1980
2000
P,S
0.02 P
P,S
P
P,S 0.01 P* P* Thomas steel
BOH
EF BOF Steel melting processes
S EF + ESR
S EF + AOD
WPNL2204
EF + LRF
65
2.38 Historical development of steel melting processess and their achievable P and S contents.
S
The development of creep-resistant steels
Ladle refining furnace LRF Vacuum induction melting VIM Vacuum arc remelting VAR Vacuum oxygen decarburization VOD Argon oxygen decarburization AOD Electric slag remelting ESR Vacuum carbon desoxydation VCD Vacuum degassing VAD (H2 <2ppm) Oxygen blown steel BOF
66
Creep-resistant steels
hearth processes, which possess high P and S contents were available. The electric-arc furnace steel, first introduced in 1908, provided very cost effective and much lower levels of P and S and better overall cleanliness but hydrogen flaking was still a problem of larger forgings. This problem was solved by the introduction of vacuum degassing introduced in the 1950s. The production of oxygen blown steels started in 1952. This basic oxygen steelmaking converter process, which works with a high amount of pig iron (nearly 70%), offers a very economic way to produce clean steels with lower P and S contents and with lower tramp elements, such as As, Sb and Sn, as long as cleaner pig iron is used. A further improvement in vacuum treatment was established in 1961 with the adoption of the vacuum carbon deoxidisation (VCD) process. VCD allows for the removal of oxygen through reaction with carbon to form CO as a gas which is then removed from the pouring stream by a vacuum system. This provided cleaner steels than the earlier practice in which oxygen was tied-up with solid deoxidants (Si, Al) which resulted in undesirable silicate and Al-oxide inclusions. Demands for cleaner and more uniform chemical homogenity were provided by the secondary remelting methods: electroslag-remelting (ESR) in the middle of the 1960s and vacuum-arc remelting (VAR) at the end of the 1960s. The advantage of the ESR process is also a low S content of about 0.002%. The VAR process provides no reduction of the trace elements but very low gas contents. Very effective secondary refining steelmaking processes are also the decarburisation technologies Argon-oxygen decarburisation (AOD) and vacuum-oxgen decarburisation (VOD) were introduced at the end of the 1960s. The advantages of the AOD process are lower S contents (about 0.002%) and lower N2 and H2 levels. Vacuum-induction melting (VIM) also provides very low gas contents. For this process very clean iron and alloy ores, selected scraps and very clean pig iron are used. The risk of shrinkages in the VIM ingot requires a remelting (ESR or VAR) after the VIM process. VIM+ESR is used, for example, for the Ni-alloys Inconel 617 and Inconel 625, but also for special steels, like 17-4PH. For the very high stressed Inconel 706 gas turbine discs, a triple melting of VIM+ESR+VAR is common. In the middle of the 1970s, very large forgings for nuclear and fossil fired plants with higher output demanded larger ingots. This challenge led to the development of ladle refining furnaces and subsequently commited the electricarc furnace only to the role of melting. With the developed ladle refining furnaces, various combinations of heating, degassing, desulphurising, dephosphorising and methods for inclusion shape control are possible in order to provide large forging with high quality.114 This ladle metallurgy allows delivery P and S contents in the range of about 0.002%. Low P and low Mn contents are also often made by oxidising refining processes in the electric furnace (see for example Azuma et al.)118 In addition to phosphorus, antimony, arsenic, tin and copper are elements which lead to embrittlement
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
67
in service and to lower creep strength in the heat-resistant steels. Each of these elements is non-oxidisable and therefore controlled through scrap selection for the electric-arc furnace melting process in order to avoid steel degradation. A further weakness in steelmaking practice in the past was the deoxidisation of the steels with aluminium. In consequence of the discovered negative influence of Al on creep strength and creep ductility in long term investigations, Al is nowadays limited to levels lower than 0.010%.
2.6
Summary
The development of creep-resistant steels is a result of continuous technological progress throughout the 20th century. The urgent need to improve the creep strength of steels was based on endeavours by the power station industry to improve the thermal efficiency of steam power plant by raising the steam temperature and steam pressure in order to reduce the cost of fuel and go easy on fuel resources. The major contribution to the increase in power plant efficiency consisted in the development of heat-resistant steels with a higher creep strength at an acceptable creep ductility level. The significance of these material properties was not recognised until early damage was suffered by steam turbine bolts in the 1930s, which pointed to the fact that the strength of steels used in power stations operating at higher temperatures depends significantly on the creep behaviour of the material over the full period of operation. Based on this experience, it was concluded that the strength values should no longer be determined in short-term tests but that a procedure should be adopted to determine the rupture strength, the creep strain and creep ductility of the heat-resistant steel in a creep test extending over a period of roughly 100 000 h. Based on the multiplicity of investigations of test steels carried out with different Mo, Cr, Ni, V, CrMo, CrV, MnSi, MoMnSi, CrSiMo, CrNiMo, CrMnV and CrMoV contents, worldwide developments in the manufacture of steam boilers and small forgings for steam turbines brought forth low alloyed steels with chemical compositions of 0.15%C–0.3% to 0.5%Mo, 0.13%C–1%Cr–0.5%Mo and 0.10%C–2.25%Cr–1%Mo which are still in use today. In addition, in the 1950s, a MoV steel with 0.14%C–0.5%Mo– 0.3%V with an even higher creep strength was developed in Europe for gas turbines and afterwards also qualified in long term creep tests for steam plants. In the field of turbine manufacture, a steel with approximately 0.25%C– 1.25Cr–1%Mo–0.30%V is in worldwide use for turbine rotors, casings, bolts and small forgings. The development of heat-resistant 9–12%Cr steels was strongly motivated by two major events: during the 1950s by the development of thermal power stations for public power supply operating at steam temperatures ranging from 538–566°C and during the 1980s by the target to develop low-pollution
WPNL2204
68
Creep-resistant steels
power stations operating at steam admission temperatures of 600–650°C with supercritical pressures up to 350 bar. The steel X22CrMoV 12 1 was developed in the 1950s for thin-walled and thick-walled power station components. Its creep strength is based on solution hardening and on the precipitation of M23C6 carbides. The steel has been applied successfully in power stations over several decades up to temperatures of about 566°C. The steel referred to in the literature as mod. 9Cr1Mo or P91, is a steel of the newer generation. It was developed under a huge USA project in the late 1970s for the manufacture of pipes and vessels for a fast breeder. This steel has meanwhile found wide application in all new Japanese and European power stations with steam temperatures up to 600°C for pipes and small forgings. It is also used for the manufacture of castings, like valve chests and turbine casings. The increase of creep strength in comparison to the 12%CrMoV steel is caused by 0.05%Nb and 0.05%N which form thermal stable VN and Nb(C, N) precipitates. A lower Cr content of about 9% also contributes to the higher creep strength. Similar creep strengths are exhibited by new steels developed for rotors, castings and pipes which are in addition alloyed with 1%W. A further increase of about 10% in creep strength reveals the steel type P92 which is in addition alloyed with about 0.003%B and has an increased W content of about 1.8%. Addition of boron gives thermally stabile M23(C,B)6 precipitates whereas the higher W content leads to a higher amount of the Laves phase. Higher B contents in the range of 0.010–0.014% give steels for rotors, casings and pipes which can be used up to temperatures of about 630°C. Further ferritic 9–10%Cr steels are under development for steam temperatures up to 650°C. A great challenge for the development of further improved 9–10%Cr heat-resistant steels is, first, the avoidance of the Z-phase precipitation Cr2(Nb,V)2N2 which precipitates at the expense of the MX particles, and second, the avoidance of BN and metallic borides which precipitate at the expense of M23(C,B)6 and VN. An important contribution to the development of advanced steam power plants was made in the last century with a continuous improvement in the melting technology which improved significantly the purity of the steels and the manufacturability of large heat-resistant steel components. Austenitic steel itself has originally been developed for chemical plant equipments used in various corrosion and oxidation environments. Economically to keep the structure austenitic, Cr and Ni contents were optimised at 18% and 8%, respectively (Type 304 steel) in the 1920s; later completely stabilised austenitic steels such as Types 321 and 347 steels were developed. Type 316 steel was also developed containing 3% Mo for use in ammonium chloride and sulphuric acid environments in 1930s. At the same time, the addition of combination of 2%Mo and 2%Cu to 18%Cr–8%Ni steel was found to provide excellent corrosion resistance against sulphuric acid.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
69
Fortunately the austenitic steels exhibit not only good corrosion resistance but also very high creep rupture strength, such as above 100 MPa of 100 000 h strength at 600°C for 18%Cr–8Ni% steels. The steam temperature of fossil power plant in the USA and Europe rose to around 538–566°C from the end of the 1940s to the beginning of the 1950s. The same situation reached Japan at the end of the 1950s. This meant that low alloyed Cr–Mo steels could no longer be used in boilers in superheater and reheater tubes whose metal temperature exceeded 580°C, from the view point of oxidation and corrosion as well as creep strength behaviour. Austenitic steels or high Cr ferritic steels needed to be used. Four types of 18%Cr– 8%Ni system austenitic steels could be used for such high temperature steam plants. Also, ultra-supercritical pressure power plants constructed in the latter half of the 1950s were made possible by further application of these austenitic steels to thick walled components. For example, TP316H was used for boiler headers and steam piping, 17%Cr–14%NiCuMoNbTi (categorised in the 15%Cr–15%Ni system austenitic steel), TP321H for superheater and reheater and Discaloy (13%Cr–25%Ni–3%MoAlTi) for a very high pressure turbine rotor at the Eddystone unit No. 1 of Philadelphia Electric operated at a temperature of 649°C in the 1960s. After 1980, numerous studies on the development of austenitic steels for use in power plants operating at temperatures above 650°C were started aiming at the enhancement of creep strength rather than using conventional austenitic steels originally developed for chemical applications. The alloy design concepts for austenitic steels were (1) enhanced precipitation strengthening by means of ‘under-stabilising’ C composition, (2) lowering the material cost by addition of N to reduce Ni content to maintain a full austenitic structure of high Cr above 20% containing steel, (3) utilisation of Cu and W for precipitation hardening and solution strengthening, and (4) precipitation hardening by inter-metallic compounds. Presently, the greatest 100 000 h creep rupture strengths at 700°C available are 70 MPa for 18%Cr– 8%Ni system steels and 90 MPa for 25%Cr austenitic steels. As 100 MPa is thought to be required for high-temperature and high-pressure power plants, the limits for application of 18%Cr–8%Ni system steels and 25%Cr austenitic steels in 350 bar pressure plants would be approximately 660°C and 680°C, respectively. For thick wall components experience of Type 316 steel is already available at the 650°C steam temperature. However, for temperatures above 650°C, development of new austenitic steels or improvement of Nibased alloy is needed. For steam turbine rotor applications, austenitic super alloys such as Dicaloy (13%Cr–25%Ni–3%MoAlTi) and A286 (15%Cr– 26%Ni–1.5%MoAlTi) have demonstrated a restricted performance at the 650°C level, but temperatures of 700°C and greater would require Ni-based alloys such as Inco617 (Ni–22%Cr–13%Co–9%MoAlTi) or Waspaloy (Ni19%Cr–14%Co–4.5%MoAlTi), or Fe–Ni based alloys with improved creep
WPNL2204
70
Creep-resistant steels
strength. The limit for austenitic steels is approximately 680°C for 350 bar pressure plants. On the other hand, Ni-based alloys can be applied at temperatures in excess of 680°C or 700°C, but the material cost is quite high compared with austenitic steels. In future, continued development is needed for austenitic steels that can be used at temperatures above 700°C aiming at the 100 000 h creep rupture strength of 100 MPa and greater at 700°C.
2.7
References
1 Schult H, ‘Grundlage der zukünftigen Entwicklung der Stromwirtschaft’, Kohle in der Elekrizitätswirtschaft Essen, 1952, 6–11. 2 Scarlin B, Alstom Switzerland, personal communication 2006. 3 Kallen H, ‘Der Werkstoff Stahl in der technischen Entwicklung der letzten 100 Jahre’, Stahl und Eisen, 1960, 80, 1864–1877. 4 Ruttmann W, ‘Untersuchungen an Schraubenbolzen’, Mitt. VGB, 1937, issue 65, 395–396. 5 Schmitz H, ‘Vereinheitlichung des Dauerstandversuches mit Stahl’, Stahl und Eisen, 1935, 1523–1534. 6 ASTM Tentative Standards, ASTM, Philadelphia, 1934, 1138–1156. 7 Siebel E, ‘Neuzeitliche Werkstoffprüfung im Hochdruckkessel’, Mitt. VGB, 1938, Issue 67, 74–79. 8 Diehl H and Granacher J, ‘Ergebnisse aus Zeitstandversuchen bei 500°C mit einer Beanspruchungsdauer bis über 300 000 h’, Arch. Eisenhüttenwesen, 1979, 50, (7), 299–303. 9 Wellinger K, ‘Beanspruchung und Werkstoffe’, VGB-Werkstofftagung, Essen, Germany, 1969, Tagungsband, 9–17. 10 Ewald J, Bendick W, Granacher J, Maile K, Melzer B, Mayer K H, Rhode W and Tolksdorf E, ‘50 Years of joint german activities in the area of creep resistant materials’, Proceedings of International Colloquium on the Occasion of the 50th Anniversary of the German Creep Committee, Düsseldorf, Germany, 25 November, 1999, 1–31. 11 Thornton D V, ‘UK power industry collaboration high temperature materials testing programme’, Proceedings of International Colloquium on the Occasion of the 50th Anniversary of the German Creep Committee, Düsseldorf, Germany, 25 November 1999, 32–37. 12 Masuyama F, ‘Industry view of creep study activities in Japan’, Proceedings of International Colloquium on the Occasion of the 50th Anniversary of the German Creep Committee, Düsseldorf, Germany, 25 November 1999, German Iron and Steel Institute, Düsseldorf 1999, 38–41. 13 Abe F, Irie H and Yagi K, ‘Recent activities in NRIM creep data sheet project’, Proceedings of International Colloquium on the Occasion of the 50th Anniversary of the German Creep Committee, Düsseldorf, Germany, 25 November 1999, 42–46. 14 Eberle F, ‘Einige Ergebnisse amerikanischer Langzeit-Standversuche an Röhrenstählen, ihre Berücksichtigung bei der Festlegung zulässiger Spannungen, International Meeting about Long Term Creep Tests’, 31.05./01.06.1957 Düsseldorf, Germany, Archiv für das Eisenhüttenwesen, 1957, 28, 702–706. 15 Curran R M, ‘The development of improved forgings for modern steam turbines’,
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
16
17 18 19 20
21
22
23
24 25
26
27 28 29
30
31
32
71
Proceedings of ASTM Symposium on Steel, Stainless Steel and Related Alloys, Williamsburg, VA, USA, 28–30 November 1984, ASTM Special Technical Publication 903, Code No. 04-903000-02, 9–32. Mitteilung der Schweizerischen Arbeitsgemeinschaft (BBC, Gebr. Sulzer, G. Fischer AG, Escher Wyss und von Roll); K.N. Melton et al, Zeitstanduntersuchungen an 21/4 Cr-1Mo-Stahlguss GS-18Cr Mo910, Material und Technik 1982/4, December 1982, 190–197. Baumann K and Gramberg U, ‘260 000 Stunden einer Löffler-Kesselanlage mit 130 bar und 510°C’, VGB Kraftwerkstechnik, 1977, 57, (10), 699–706. Fabritius H, Entwicklungsstand von warmfesten und korrosionsbeständigen Stählen für die Erdöl- und Erdgasindustrie, Mannesmannforschungsbericht, 1973, 610. Florin C, ‘Ferritische warmfeste Stähle’, in Werkstoffkunde der gebräuchlichen Stähle, Teil 2, Verlag Stahleisen, Düsseldorf 1977, 96–105. Orr J, Beckitt F R, Met A and Fawkes G D, ‘The physical metallurgy of chromium– molybdenum steels for fast reactor boilers’, Proceedings of BNES (British Nuclear Energy Society) Conference on Ferritic Steels for Fast Reactor Steam Generator, London, 1977. Foldyna F, Purmensky J, Prnka T and Kadulova M, ‘Einfluß des Molybdängehaltes auf die Zeitstandfestigkeit von Chrom-Molybdän-Vanadinstählen mit niedrigem Kohlenstoffgehalt’, Arch. Eisenhüttenwesen, 1971, 42, 927–932. Schüller H J, Hagn L, Woitscheck A, Kober A and Christian H, ‘Schweißnahtrisse in Formstücken an Heissdampfleitungen-Werkstoffuntersuchungen’, VGB-Konferenz Werkstoffe und Schweißtechnik im Kraftwerk, VGB Essen, Germany, 1973, 163– 194. Stahl-Eisen-Werkstoffblatt SEW 555, January 2001, Steels for Large Forgings for Components in turbine and generator installations, Verlag Stahleisen GmbH, Düsseldorf. EN 10269:1999, Steels and Nickel Alloys for Fasteners with Specific Elevated and/ or Low Temperature Properties, Beuth Verlag GmbH, Berlin, Germany, 1999. Norton F and Strang A, ‘Improvement of creep and rupture properties of large 1%CrMoV steam turbine forgings’, Journal Iron and Steel Institute, 1969, February, 193–203. Mayer K H and Rieß W, ‘The influences of the microstructure on the operational characteristics of steam turbine components subjected to high stresses’, VGB Kraftwerkstechnik, 1976, No 3, March, 138–142. Smith R, PhD Thesis, Sheffield University, 1959, cited in detail in Ref. 31. Thum A and Richard K, ‘Ergebnisse von Langzeit-Dauerstandversuchen bei 500°C’, Schweizer Archiv, 1953, 19, (8), 235–245. Schinn R, ‘Die deutsche Entwicklung von Schmiedstücken für Wellen von Turbogeneratoren’, VGB Technisch-wissenschaftlicher Bericht, Wärmekraftwerke VGB-TW503, VGB Essen Germany. Conrad J D and Mochel N L, ‘Operating experiences with high temperature steam turbine rotors and design improvements in rotor blade fastening’, Transactions ASME, 1958, 80, No 6 1210–1224, presented in Allentown,USA, 21–23 October 1957. Cress T, Zum Zeitstandverhalten warmfester Chrom-Molybdän-Vandin Stähle und deren Neigung zu verformungslosen Zeitstandbrüchen, Dissertation Techn. Hochschule Darmstadt, Germany, 1967. Ruttmann W, ‘Untersuchungen an Schraubenbolzen’, Mitt. VGB, 1937, issue 65, 395–396.
WPNL2204
72
Creep-resistant steels
33 VGB Guidelines for Bolts in the Range of High Temperatures, VGB-R 505M, 3rd edition, VGB Essen, Germany, 1977. 34 Kramer L D, Randolph D D and Weisz D A, ‘Analysis of the Tennessee Valley Authority Gallatin Union No 2 Turbine Rotor Burst’, Winter Meeting of ASME, New York, December 5–10, 1976, ASME New York NY, USA 1976. 35 Toughness of CrMoV-Steels for Steam Turbine Rotors, EPRI Special Report RD2357, April, 1982. 36 Viswanathan R and Gehl S, ‘Temper embrittlement of rotor steels’, Robert I. Jaffee Memorial Symposium on Clean materials technology, ASM/TMS Materials Week, 2–5 November 1992, Chicago, Illinois, USA, ASM International, Materials Park, Ohio 44073-0002, USA 1992. 37 Masuyama F, ‘Steam plant material development in Japan‘, 6th Liège COST Conference, Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 1998, Liège, Belgium, September 1998, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Germany 1998. 38 Husemann R U, ‘Werkstoffe und Werkstoffentwicklung für die Komponenten Membranwände und Überhitzerrohre für zukünftige Dampferzeuger’, Proceedings of TAM-Fachtagung Kohlekraftwerke im Jahre 2000/2015, 30–31 März Dresden, expert verlag Renningen-Malmsheim, Germany 1995. 39 Fujita T and Takahashi N, ‘The effects of boron on the long period creep rupture strength of the modified 12% chromium heat-resisting steel’, Transactions ISIJ, 1976, 16, 606–613. 40 Fujita T, ‘Twenty-first century electricity generation plants and materials’, Proceedings of International Workshop on Development of Advanced Heat Resisting Steels, Yokohama, Japan, 8 November, NIMS Tsukuba, Japan 1999. 41 Boyle C J and Newhouse D L, United States Patent 3, 139, 337, June, 1964. 42 Curran R M, ‘Progress in the development of large turbine rotor forgings’, Proceedings of the Fifth International Forgemasters Meeting, 6–9 May Terni, Italy, 1970. 43 Brinkmann C R, Gieseke B, Alexander J and Maziasz P J, ‘Modified 9Cr-1Mo Steel for Advanced Steam Generator Applications’, ASME/IEEE Power Generation Conference, 21–25 October, Boston, MA, USA, ASME/IEEE, ASME New York, NY, USA, 1991. 44 Mayer K H and Bakker W T, ‘New ferritic steels increase the thermal efficiency of steam turbines’, International Conference Joint Power Generation, Houston, Texas, USA, October 1996, ASME New York. 45 Thornton D V and Mayer K H, ‘New materials for advanced steam turbines’, Proceedings of the Fourth International Charles Parsons Conference, Advances in Turbine Materials, Design and Manufacturing, 4–6 November, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, Institute of Materials London, 1997. 46 Hizume A, Takeda Y, Yokota H, Takano Y, Suzuki A, Kinoshita S, Koono M and Tsuchiyama T, ‘The Probability of a new 12%Cr Rotor Steel applicable for Steam Temperature above 593°C’, Journal of Engineering Materials and Technology/ Transaction of ASME Chicago, USA, (109) 319–325, 1987. 47 Fujita T, Sato T and Takahashi N, ‘Effect of Mo and W on long term creep strength of 12%Cr heat-resisting steel containing V, Nb and B’, Transaction Iron and Steel Institute of Japan 1978 18, 115–124. 48 Berger C, Mayer K H, Scarlin B and Thornton D, ‘Improved ferritic rotor and cast steels for advanced steam power plants – a collaborate European effort in COST 501’, 4th International EPRI Conference on Improved Coal-Fired Plants, 1–4 March, Washington DC, USA, Electric Power Reseach Institute Palo Alto CA, 1993.
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
73
49 Orr J, Buchanan L W and Everson H‚ ‘The commercial development and evaluation of E 911, a strong 9%CrMoWVNbN steel for boiler tubes and headers’, International Conference Advanced Heat Resistant Steels for Power Generation, 27–29 April, San Sebastian, Spain, Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA, 1998. 50 Masumoto H, Sakakibara M, Takahashi T, Sakurai H and Fujita T, ‘Development of a 9%Cr–Mo–W steel for boiler tubes’, First International EPRI Conference on Improved Coal-Fired Plants, 19–21 November, Palo Alto/USA, Electric Power Research Institue Palo Alto CA, 1986. 51 Hald J, ‘ECCC E911-P92 assessment, ECCC Data Sheet’, published in September 2005 at the ECCC Creep Conference, 12–14 September, London, UK, ERA Technology Ltd, Leatherhead, Surrey KT22 7SA, 2005. 52 Iseda A, Sawaragi Y, Kato S and Masuyama F, ‘Development of a new 0.1C–11Cr– 2W–0.4Mo–1Cu steel for large diameter and thick wall pipe for boilers’, 5th International Conference on Creep of Materials, 18–21 May 1992, Lake Buena Vista, Florida, USA, ASM International, Materials Park, Ohio, 1992. 53 Kimura K, Assessment of Long-Term Creep Strength and Review of Allowable Stress for High Cr Ferritic Creep Resistant Steels, ASME PVP2005-71039, ASME New York NY, USA 2005 54 Strang A and Vodarek V, ‘Modelling and experimental verification of minor phase composition changes in creep resistant 12%CrMoVNb steels’, 5th International Charles Parsons Turbine Conference, Advanced Materials for 21st Century Turbines and Power Plants, 3–7 July 2000, Cambridge, UK, IOM Communication Ltd, London UK 2000. 55 Kagawa Y, Tamura F, Ishiyama O, Matsumoto O, Honjo T, Tsuchiyama T, Manabe Y, Kadoya Y, Magoshi R and Kawi H, ‘Development and manufacturing of the next generation of advanced 12%Cr steel rotor for 630°C steam temperature’, 14th International Forgemaster Meeting, Wiesbaden, Germany, September 3–8, German Iron and Steel Institute, Düsseldorf, Germany, 2000. 56 Azuma T, Miki K and Tanaka Y, ‘Effect of boron on microstructural change during creep deformation in 12%Cr heat resistant steel’, 3th EPRI Conference on Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants, Swansea, UK, April 2001, Electric Power Research Institue Palo Alto, CA. 57 Fukuda M, Tsuda Y,Yamashita K and Shinozaki Y, Takahashi, ‘Materials and design for advanced high temperature steam turbines’, 4th EPRI International Conference on Advanced in Material Technology for Fossil Power Plants, Hilton Oceanfront Resort, Hilton Head Island, SC, USA, October 25–28, 2004, Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA, 207–221. 58 Kern T U, Staubli M, Mayer K H, Donth B, Zeiler G and DiGianfrancesco A, ‘The European effort in development of new rotor materials – COST 536’, 8th Liège Conference on Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, 18–20 September, Liège, Belgium, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany, 2006. 59 Kern T U, Mayer K H, Berger C, Zies G and Schwienheer M, ‘Stand der Entwicklungsarbeiten in COST 522 für Hochtemperatur-Dampfturbinen 27’, Vortragsveranstaltung FVHT, 26 November, German Iron and Steel Institute, Düsseldorf, Germany, 2004. 60 Arai M, Doi H, Azuma T and Fuita T, ‘Development of high WCoB-containing 12Cr Rotor Steels for use at 650°C in USC Power Plants’, 15th International Forgemasters Meeting IFM 2003, Kobe, Japan, October 26–29, 2003, Steel Castings and Forgings Association of Japan, 261–268.
WPNL2204
74
Creep-resistant steels
61 Kauffmann F, Mayer K H, Straub S, Zies G, Scheu C, Willer D, Ruoff H and Maile K, ‘Characterization of the precipitates in modern boron containing 9–12%Cr steels developed in the frame of the COST program’, 8th Liège Conference on Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, 18–20 September, Liège, Belgium, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany, 2006. 62 Kager F, Böck N, Spiradek-Hahn K, Höfinger S, Brabetz M and Zeiler G, ‘Superior long-term creep behaviour and microstructure evolution of 9%Cr-steels with boron’, 8th Liège Conference on Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, 18–20 September, Liège, Belgium, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany, 2006. 63 Miki K, Azuma T and Ishiguro T, ‘Improvement of long term creep strength in high Cr heat resistant steel’, 15th International Forgemasters Meeting IFM 2003, Kobe, Japan, October 26–29, 2003, Steel Castings and Forgings Association of Japan, 269–275. 64 Scarlin B and Stamatelopoulos G N, ‘New boiler materials for advanced steam conditions’, Proceedings of the 7th Liège COST Conference on Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 2002, Part III, Liège Belgium, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany, 2002, 1091–1108. 65 Bendick W, Vaillant J C, Vandenberghe B and Lefebre Bo, ‘VM12 – a new 12%Cr steel for boiler tubes, headers and steam pipes in USC power plants’, ‘Development of a new 12%Cr-steel for tubes and pipes in power plants up to 650°C’, EPRI International Conference on Materials and Corrosion Experiences for Fossil Power Plants, 18–21 November, Wild Dunes Resort, Isle of Palms, SC, USA, Hilton Oceanfront Resort, Hilton Head Island, SC, USA, October 25–28, 2004, Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA, 2003. 66 Masuyama F, ‘Steam plant material development in Japan’, 6th Liège COST conference, Materials for advanced power engineering 1998, Conference proceedings III, Liège, Belgium, September 1998, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Germany, 1807. 67 Bendick W, ‘Neue Werkstoffentwicklung für moderne Hochleistungskraftwerke’, VGB Tagung Werkstoffe und Qualitätssicherung 2004, 10–11 März, 2004. 68 Blum R, Vanstone R W and Messlier-Gouze C, ‘Materials development for boilers and steam turbines operating at 700°C’, 4th EPRI International Conference on Advanced in Material Technology for Fossil Power Plants, Hilton Oceanfront Resort, Hilton Head Island, SC, USA, October 25–28, 2004, Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA, 118–138. 69 Masuyama F in Landolt–Boernstein, Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology, Group VIII, Vol. 2 Materials Subvol. B, Creep Properties of Heat Resistant Steels and Superalloys, ed by Yagi K, Merckling G, Kern T U, Irie H, Warlimont H, Springer Verlag, Berlin Germany 2004. 70 Danielsen H and Hald J, Z-phase in 9-12%Cr Steels, VÄRMEFORSK Service AB, Stockholm, Sweden, April 2004. 71 Sato A, ‘Research project on innovative steels in Japan’, International workshop on Innovative Structural Materials for Infrastructure in 21th Century, Tsukuba, NIMS Tsukuba, Japan, 12–13 January 2000. 72 Abe F, Igarashi M, Fujitsuna N and Muneki S, ‘Alloy design of advanced ferritic steels for 650°C USC boilers’, Conference on Advanced Heat Resistant Steels for Power Generation, 27–29 April San Sebastian, Spain, Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA, 1998. 73 Semba H and Abe F, ‘Development of creep resistant 9Cr-3W-3Co steel containing
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
74
75 76 77 78 79 80 81
82 83 84
85
86
87
88
89 90
75
high boron for USC boilers’, First International Conference Super-High Strength Steels, 2–4 November, Centro Sviluppo Metallurgia, Rome, Italy, 2005. Abe F, ‘High performance creep resistant steels for the 21st century power plants’, First International Conference Super-High Strength Steels, 2–4 November, Centro Sviluppo Metallurgia, Rome, Italy, 2005. Krainer H, ‘50 Jahre nichtrostender Stahl’, Stahl und Eisen, 1962, 82, 1527. Strauses B, ‘Non-rusting Cr-Ni steels’, Proceedings American Society Test Materials, 1924, 24, 208. Schottky H, ‘German version of birth of stainless steels’, Iron Age, 1929, December 5, 1512. Mitchel W M, ‘18-8 and related stainless steels’, Metals and Alloys, 1940, January, 14. Houdremont E and Schafmeister P, ‘Verhütung der Korrosion bei Stählen mit 18%Cr und 8%Ni’, Archiv. Eisenhuettenwesen, 1933, 7, 187. Suzuki T, Historical Invent of Stainless Steels (in Japanese), AGNE Technical Center, Tokyo, 2000, 110. Eberle F, Ely E G and Dillon J S, ‘Experimental superheater for steam at 2000Psi and 1250F – Progress report after 12 000 h of Operation’, Trans. ASME, 1956, 76, 665. Masuyama F, Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 1998, Part III, J. LecomteBeckers et al. (eds), Juelich GmbH, Forschungszentrum, Juelich, 1998, 1807. Murray J D, ‘Welding Trails on Esshete 1250’, Welding and Metal Fabrication, 1962, 9, 350. Minami Y, Kimura K and Tanimura M, ‘Creep rupture properties of 18%Cr-8%NiTi-Nb and Type 347H Austenitic Stainless Steels’, ASM International Conference New Development in Stainless Steel Technology, Detroit, Michigan, September 17– 21, ASM International, Materials Park, Ohio, 1984. Yoshikawa K, Fujikawa H, Teranishi H, Yuzawa H and Kubota M, ‘Fabrication and progress of corrosion-resistant TP347H stainless steel’, ASM Conference Coatings and Bimetallic for Aggressive Environments, ed. by R. D. Sission Jr.1985 99, ASM International, Materials Park, Ohio 44073 1984. Sawaragi Y, Ogawa K, Kan S, Natori A and Hirano S, ‘Development of the economical 18-8 Stainless Steel (SUPER 304) having elevated Temperature Strength for Fossil Power Boilers’, Sumitomo Search, 1992, 48, 50. Ishituka T and Mimura H, ‘Development of New 18Cr-9Ni austenitic stainless steel boiler tube’, 7th Liège COST Conference Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 2002, September 2002, Liège Belgium, J. Lecomte-Beckers et al. (eds), Juelich GmbH, Forschungszentrum, Juelich, 2002, 1321. Minami Y, Tohyama A and Hayakawa H, ‘Properties and experiences with a new austenitic stainless steel (Tempaloy AA-1) for Boiler Tube Application’, 7th Liège COST Conference Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 2002, September 2002, Liège Belgium, J. Lecomte-Beckers et al. (eds), Juelich GmbH, Forschungszentrum, Juelich, 2002, 1445. Masuyama F, ‘History of power plants and progress in heat resistant steels’, Transactions of Iron Steel Institute Japan, ISIJ International, 2001, 41, 612. Shinoda T and Tanaka R, ‘Role of carbide precipitations on creep rupture strength of austenitic stainless steels (in Japanese)’, Bulletin Japan Institute Metals, 1972, 11, 180.
WPNL2204
76
Creep-resistant steels
91 Masuyama F, ‘Advanced power plant development and material experiences in Japan’, 8th Liège conference on Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, J. Lecomte-Beckers et al. (eds), Juelich GmbH, Forschungszentrum, Juelich, 2006, Liège, Belgium, 175. 92 Sawaragi Y, ‘Elevated temperature strength and microstructure of several high strength austenitic steels’, JSPS, 123 Committee Report on Heat Resistant Metallic Material, 1985, 26, 369. 93 Tamura M, Yamaguchi N, Tanimura M and Murase S, ‘Processing alloys for the heat exchangers of advanced coal fired boilers’, 1985 Exposition and Symposium, Industrial Heat Exchanger Technology, Pittburgh, PA, 1985. 94 Sawaragi Y and Yoshikawa K, ‘High temperature strength and microstructure of high strength and corrosion resistant austenitic steel for boiler (in Japanese)’, Tetsuto-Hagane, 1986, 72, S672. 95 Sawaragi Y, Teranishi H, Makiura H, Miura M and Kubota M, ‘The development of HR3C steel with high elevated temperature strength and high corrosion resistance for boiler tubes (in Japanese)’, Sumitomo Metals, 1985, 37, 166. 96 Kikuchi M, Sakakibara M, Otoguro M, Mimura H, Araki S and Fujita T, ‘An austenitic heat resisting steel tube developed for advanced fossil-fired steam plants’, International Conference High Temperature Alloys, Petten, Netherlands, 1985. 97 Toyama A, Minami Y and Yamada T, ‘Effect of alloying elements on high temperature properties in an austenitic stainless steel containing high Cr (in Japanese)’, CAMPISIJ, 1988, 1, 928. 98 Semba H, Igarashi M and Sawaragi Y, ‘Development of 23Cr–18Ni–3Cu–1.5W– Nb–N Austenitic Steel for USC Boilers’, Proceedings International Conference Power Engineering–97, Volume 2, JSME, Tokyo, 1997, 125. 99 Rautio R and Bruce S, ‘Sandvik Sanicro 25, a new material for ultrasupercritical coal fired boiler’, Advances in Material Technology for Fossil Power Plants, R. Viswanathan et al. (eds), 2005, ASM International, Metals Park, OH, 274. 100 Masuyama F, in Landolt-Boernstein, Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology, Group VIII, Volume 2, Materials Subvolume B, Creep Properties of Heat Resistant Steels and Superalloys, Yagi K, Merckling G, Kern T U, Irie H, Warlimont H, Springer Verlag, Berlin Germany 2004. 101 Kalwa G, Haarmann K and Janssen J K, ‘Experiences with ferritic and martensitic steels tubes and piping in nuclear and non-nuclear applications’, Topical Conference Ferritic Alloys for Use in Nuclear Energy Technology, Metallurgical Society AIME, Snowbird, ed. by J W Davis and D J Michel, 1983. 102 Sikka V K, Ward C T and Thomas K C, ‘Modified 9Cr-1Mo Steel – An Improved Alloy for Steam Generator Application’, ASM International Conference Production, Fabrication, Properties and Applications of Ferritic Steels for High-Temperature Applications, Warrendale, PA, ASM International, Materials Park, Ohio, 1981. 103 Sakakibara M, Masumoto H, Ogawa T, Takahashi and Fujita T, ‘High Strength 9Cr0.5Mo-1.8W(NF616) Steel for Boiler Tube (in Japanese)’, Thermal and Nuclear Power, 1987, 38, 841. 104 DeLong W T, Ostrom G A, Szumachowski E R, ‘Mearsurement and Calculation of Ferrite in Stainless Steel Weld Metal’, Weld Journal, 1956, 35, 521S. 105 Masuyama F, Nishimura N, Haneda H, Ellis F V and DeLong J F, ‘Investigation of the Deterioration plus Restoration Behaviour of fourteen Heats of TP316 Stainless Steel removed from Eddystone Unit No 1 Main Steam Lines after 130 520 h
WPNL2204
The development of creep-resistant steels
106
107
108 109
110
111 112 113 114
115
116
117
118
77
Service’, Properties of Stainless Steels in Elevated Temperature Service, MPC-Vol. 26/PVP-Vol 32, 1987, 173. Yamamoto R, Kadoya Y, Ueta S, Nobe T, Magoshi R, Nishimoto S and Nakano T, ‘Development of wrought Ni-based Superalloy with low Thermal Expansion for 700°C Steam Turbines’, Advances in Material Technology for Fossil Power Plants, R. Viswanathan et al. (eds), 2005, ASM International, Metals Park, OH 623. Imano S, Doi H and Iijima E, ‘Modification of Ni-Fe base Superalloy for Steam Turbine Applications’, Advances in Material Technology for Fossil Power Plants, R. Viswanathan et al. (eds), 2005, ASM International, Metals Park, OH, 575. Imai K, private communication, 2006. Takeda Y and Masuyama F, ‘Heat Resistant Materials for Ultra Super Critical Power Plants (in Japanese)’, JSPS 123 Committee Report on Heat Resistant Metallic Material, 1987, 29, 399. Furuya K, Hizume A, Takeda Y, Fujikawa T, Fujita A, Kinoshita S, Kohono M, Honjo T and Suzuki A, ‘Austenitic Steel Rotor Forging for EPDC’s WAKAMATSU 50MW High Temperature Turbine Project’, Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. Improved CoalFired Power Plants, Palo Alto CA, USA 1989, Electric Power Research Institute, 1989, 59–1. Ohta S, ‘Heat Resistant Steels for Chemical Industries (in Japanese)’ JSPS 123 Committee Report on Heat Resistant Metallic Material, 1977, 18, 383. Koori M, Yosida T and Ohta S, ‘Analysis and Prevention of Failures in Steam Reforming Furnace (in Japanese)’, Kobe Steel Technical Bulletin, 1983, 33, 65. Weißbach W, Werkstoffkunde und Werkstoffprüfung, Vieweg & Sohn, Braunschweig/ Wiesbaden, Germany 1979. Bodnar R L and Cappepellini R F, ‘Effects of residual elements in heavy forgings, past, present, future’, Research Department Publication Bethlehem Steel Corporation, Bethlehem, PA, Philadelphia, USA, 1986. Schmollgruber F, Verfahrenswege zur Herstellung grosser Schmiedestücke und deren qualitative und wirtschaftliche Auswirkungen, Dissertation TH Aachen, February 1974. Nutting J and Viswanathan R, ‘Clean steel: superclean steel’, Conference on Clean Steel: Superclean Steel, Conference Proceedings, 6–7 March 1995, London, UK, 1995. Viswanathan R, ‘Clean steel technology’, Proceedings of the R.I. Jaffee Memorial Symposium, 2–5 November 1992, Chicago, Illinois, USA, ASM International, Materials Park Ohio, 1997. Azuma T, Tanaka Y, Ikeda Y and Yoshida H, ‘Production and properties of superclean 3.5%NiCrMoV rotor forgings for low pressure steam turbine’, Proceedings of the R.I. Jaffee Memorial Symposium, 2–5 November 1992, Chicago, Illinois, USA, 1992, ASM International, Materials Park Ohio, 213–220.
WPNL2204
78
Creep-resistant steels
3 Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe G . M E R C K L I N G, RTM BREDA Milano, Italy
3.1
Introduction
Creep problems with metallic materials emerged simultaneously in the USA and in Europe in the 1920s. In both cases, efforts to increase efficiency had led to higher service temperatures in pressure and other load-bearing systems. Unfortunately, on both sides of the Atlantic ignoring creep effects resulted in several casualties and in some cases severe injuries were sustained. As a consequence, researchers in the USA and the UK started to investigate the effect and the first publications describing creep appeared in the mid-1920s.1–3 The search for a simple answer to creep, encouraged by the decreasing strain rate of the primary creep stage, suggested to early researchers that there was a creep threshold stress, that is a stress level beyond which no creep, or at least no creep fracture, would occur. A particular testing type4 was created in Germany in the early 1930s. Criteria that helped identify ‘creep-resistant’ materials at a given temperature were defined by assuming that materials fulfilling these properties (creep strain rate lower than 10–3% h–1 between 25 and 35 h of testing and creep strain smaller than 0.2% in 45 h) would not fail and were applied extensively in parts of Europe. Again, it was casualties that proved this assumption wrong. It thus became apparent that expensive and difficult long-term creep investigations were needed to guarantee operational safety and plant reliability at high temperatures. All the major European countries developed activities to study, understand and predict creep strength and deformation behaviour. Building on efforts in the 1930s, research was re-activated after World War II and has continued ever since. Although aimed at the same target – for the best use of materials at the best safety levels with the available technology – different approaches to the investigation of creep were developed. Essentially three different directions were taken, although other interpretations and sub-fields grew with time: 78 WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
79
1. German industry developed a common effort approach from the outset, which, coordinated by an umbrella organisation, pooled experiences and data from most industrial companies, research and university institutions, including very long-term creep results. As a result, a huge number of steels were characterised, optimised and developed for application in creep regime, and creep strength data containing DIN standards were issued. From this activity, perhaps the only raw long-term creep data collation was published in 19695 (see also Table 3.1), and this formed the basis of the publicly available data pool throughout Europe for a long period. In parallel, technical rules for material properties, welding and component design were issued in the TRD and AD series. 2. In the United Kingdom, creep investigation efforts were more or less confined to big industrial companies operating independently, with less national coordination. Nevertheless, here also a large series of materials were developed on a company-to-company basis for use in creep regimes, accompanied by the related BS and PD standards and rules for creep strength data assessment, welding and component design. 3. A third approach was followed in the 1950s by some of the less industrialised countries, like Italy, who had fewer resources to develop their own materials and/or rules and so relied on external sources. Italian design and material standards in creep regimes were based on a unique mixture of European (German and British) and US research, assessed to suit the local circumstances. In these countries, US material nomenclature, design criteria and codes were used as widely as European specifications. Other countries, like Sweden and France, also developed a significant amount of technical documentation for material applications in creep regimes. Further developments followed the introduction of nuclear power to Europe, mainly concerning austenitic materials, nuclear pollution and the effects of irradiation. As this a very specialised area, the findings will not be discussed here, although it is acknowledged that nuclear research produced valuable data, some of which was made available for the development of new European Standards and joint assessment activities in the European Creep Collaborative Committee (ECCC) (see Section 3.2.5). With the introduction of the Common Market in Europe in the 1960s and the increasing importance of exports within and outside Europe, several panEuropean institutions began attempting to harmonise the various different standards. The European Carbon and Steel Collaboration programmes CECA/ ECSC6 had already begun this process in the 1950s and continued into the 1960s. Since 1971, most major work has been coordinated through the programmes of the organisation for European Cooperation in the field of Scientific and Technical Research (COST)7 and these have contributed
WPNL2204
80
Creep-resistant steels
significantly to innovation and the development and characterisation of new materials for high temperature applications, such as rotor steels, advanced piping materials, welding techniques, and so on. More focused front-line research has been concentrated in the EC funded Brite-Euram-Projects since the 1980s and technical, pre-competitive development of future technological solutions has been through various Thermie-Projects,8 which began in 1993. All these activities have helped European industry and research specialists to exchange their experience and knowledge and have encouraged the formation of a strong core of organisations collaborating while competing in the high temperature field. On the standards development side, right from the beginning the European Community tried to find common denominators for relevant technical issues that could be published as Euronorms (abbreviated as EU). However, the first series of Euronorms were not very well accepted, did not gain general application and made little difference to the use of independent national standards. The situation changed when the now European Union started to issue ‘directives’, which the member countries had agreed would become law and so would formalise voluntary industrial standardisation. For the high temperature sector, the relevant event was the publication in 1997 and mandatory introduction in 2002 of the Pressure Equipment Directive (PED) 97/23/EC,9 which required guarantees for the in-service performance of materials and, as a consequence, required harmonisation of the relevant EN standards. Although not dealing specifically with pressure vessels under a creep regime, the PED required a new series of standards harmonised at all levels for high-temperature materials, for which ‘European’ creep strength values were to be defined. The PED came from the European Committee for Standardisation (CEN) and its related technical committee, the European Committee for Iron and Steel Standards (ECISS) and, under the framework of the European Community funded research programmes, encouraged a large group of industries, research and inspection organisations to form: • •
the European Pressure Equipment Research Council (EPERC), which strongly contributed to implementation and clarification of the PED directive itself; and the European Collaborative Creep Committee (ECCC), which developed creep strength data for some of the materials under the new harmonised EN standards, using new data assessment approaches.
The following sections and tables will try to give a concentrated overview of the most relevant standard publications related to creep-resistant steels suitable for structural applications, beginning with the original national grades up to the current PED-harmonised standards.
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
3.2
Specifications and standards
3.2.1
Institutions, publishing rules and standards
81
Each European country publishes norms for voluntary industrial standardisation, which are issued by various organisations, as follows: • •
•
•
•
The national standardisation body (DIN in Germany, BS in the United Kingdom, AFNOR in France, UNI in Italy, etc.) is responsible for preparing and issuing voluntary industrial standardisation documents. Some of the national standardisation bodies, their sub-organisations or umbrella organisations also issue ‘second-level standardisation documents’, such as PD documents in the United Kingdom, SEP documents in Germany, and so on. Ad hoc industrial committees, in some cases affiliated to the national standardisation body, issue design codes for particular areas of technical interest. For example, for pressure application in creep regimes, design rules are issued by TRD and AD in Germany, CODAP in France, CTI with ANCC/ISPESL in Italy, and so on. Often these codes do not just specify a national standard for materials, but add additional prescriptions, controls or requirements. In some countries, inspection authorities have issued additional materialrelated specifications (e.g. the ‘Raccolta M/S’ of the Italian Authority ISPESL) or have required qualifications for suppliers of materials to be used in creep regime (e.g. VdTÜV-Richtlinien in Germany). A few major users or builders of equipment operating under creep regimes have developed design and material qualification guidelines (e.g. National Electricity Boards, refinery and petrochemical groups, turbine and boiler manufacturers, etc).
Since the PED Directive was issued in 1997, standards across Europe have tended towards unification. Standards issued by CEN, the European Standardisation Body, are jointly prepared by specialists from all CEN member countries and some which are not yet members, and are quickly substituted for the corresponding national standards. Under the CEN framework10 for steels ECISS11 is responsible for issuing harmonised standards. Experts from industry and research, delegated by national standards bodies, are recruited into Technical Committees and advisory organisations provide specific information as required, or, as is often the case, via their specialists being members of both the relevant CEN/ECISS Technical Committee issuing the standard and the advisory organisation (e.g. ECCC, EPERC, etc). The European Commission itself is ultimately in charge of defining EUwide regulations in the form of directives, with the objective of standardising approaches and methods, both technical and administrative, within the member countries to simplify and encourage transport, trade, exchange and
WPNL2204
82
Creep-resistant steels
implementation of goods. EU directives normally become law in all EU member countries within 12 to 18 months, superseding previous local legislation. Technical directives often call for common standardisation or refer directly to EN standards, significantly increasing the importance of CEN documents and their influence on industry and administration. For metallic materials used in creep regimes, the issue of the PED in 1997 followed by mandatory application starting in 2002 was a critical step.
3.2.2
The pressure equipment directive
The PED9 deals with all relevant safety issues in the design, manufacture and use of components designed to resist stresses induced mainly by pressure. The directive is aimed at simplifying intra-European trade and exchange of pressure handling equipment and harmonising safety prescriptions in order to allow intra-European exchangeability and serviceability of pressure devices. There are many types of boilers, pipelines, furnaces, heat exchangers, incinerators, chemical reactors, etc within Europe, and all have to conform to the directive. Explicitly excluded are all equipment regulated by other directives (e.g. pressure equipment for transportation on rail or road, ‘simple pressure equipment’, etc), and all types of rotating machines and motors (e.g. combustion engines, turbines and pumps, etc.). The PED is a general law (not a design code) and does not directly consider specific design and safety factors for components operating under creep regimes, although creep is mentioned and regarded as a non-negligible issue in designing. For dimensioning, including equipment operating in creep regime, PED allows the use of any internationally recognised standard and accepts fracture mechanics approaches and finite element simulation, but for materials, the rules are more strict: • • •
All materials must have a guaranteed minimum impact energy at the lowest possible service temperature that the equipment for which they are used may encounter under pressure, e.g. including hydraulic tests. All materials must demonstrate ‘sufficient’ ductility in service conditions to guarantee ‘leak before break’. Materials need to be selected from harmonised standards, i.e. material standards that in their intention and scope consider and include the safety criteria as set forth by the PED. This requirement strongly enhanced and accelerated the production of EN standards incorporating Europewide agreed strength values. If materials cannot be selected from EN standards (typically because they come under non-European design codes, e.g. where ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code or API standards are used), they must either pass a general acceptance procedure conducted by an accredited, notified body, or they must undergo a ‘particular material
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
•
83
appraisal’ to check their suitability for the application and their conformity to the PED safety criteria, on a case-by-case basis. A final, and in the creep regime very relevant, PED requirement is that all material producers involved in the production chain of a given component must declare and take responsibility that the material supplied (possibly with provisos relating to particular handling, assembly or design operations) is suitable for the intended application and its operating conditions. Alternatively, in a somewhat milder interpretation, producers must certify that the material is indeed fully compliant with the purchase specifications and the design-relevant material properties so that it can be guaranteed for safe service. For materials and welds in the creep regime this requires the material, shape, fitting and so on producer to guarantee: – – – –
long term strength of the base material long term strength of the construction welds long term strength of the assembly welds long-term strength of any repair (if allowed by the design code) of any of the items listed above.
The easiest way to comply is to select materials that conform with the harmonised standards, for which long-term strength values are indicated in the material norm. Materials subjected to the ‘particular material appraisal’ (typically ASTM or API grades, sometimes Japanese materials) have to demonstrate the points listed above, which can be achieved by testing the actual material or by presenting previous data for the same grade and producer. Owing to the expected long service duration of modern plants (generally 200 000–250 000 h, i.e. 25 to 35 years), these demonstrations often become extremely complex for welds, repairs and multiple repairs. Another route that is applied by some notified bodies and/or end user inspectorates is to qualify material producers as PED-compliant using stringent procedures when they first supply materials under the aegis of this notified body. This first-time qualification should include creep strength verification and demonstration through a reduced creep campaign, which, depending on the notified body/inspectorate, the type of material and the scope of supply, may include 2–3 isotherms made or composed from of three to five points each and durations of generally not less than 10 000 h, and often not less than 30 000 h.
3.2.3
Non PED creep applications
Equipment not subjected to PED regulations or the particular EU directives for dangerous goods and fluids, transportation or general safety in the work
WPNL2204
84
Creep-resistant steels
place, is built under the sole responsibility of its manufacturer. For high temperature applications, this is mainly the case for manufacturers of gas and steam turbines, compressors, pumps, geothermics, some types of welldrilling equipment, combustion engines, aircraft engine components and, in some cases, electrical or railway equipment. Creep data and strength determination in Europe in the past were strongly driven by turbine manufacturers. Based on their own large data collections, turbine manufacturers imposed creep testing and, less frequently, creep strength properties on components they bought from forges, steel works and foundries. Typical specifications included quite severe prescriptions and sometimes range limitations in chemical composition, stringent heat treatment details and control and mechanical testing, but generally only specifying ‘creep quality testing’ by means of one or a small group of short-term (24–100 h) stress rupture or time-to-rupture (see ASTM E292) tests. The turbine manufacturers themselves then often carried out large-scale, long-duration tests, so that the assessment of the creep properties of a single material batch was fully under their control.
3.2.4
European national standards reporting creep data
Before the era of CEN and the PED directive, creep rupture strengths were generally: • • •
assessed within the user companies (turbine and boiler manufacturers, or big end-users such as utilities, refineries and the chemical industry); supplied to support sales between companies (typically from steel maker or tube/pipe manufacturer to user); assessed by national associations (often under the control of a national electricity board acting as the main national customer).
Generally such assessments were not made available to the wider public and were confined to the members of the working group collating and preparing the strength values. In some cases, these were one-off activities, that is the collated or produced data were assessed by the working group and then disappeared into the databases of the companies. In other cases, fortunately, centralised databases were created which allowed data to be updated and strength values upgraded as the information available on creep expanded (for instance AGW within VDEh in Germany). National standardisation bodies made several attempts to include creep values into standards and rules, but their success was quite limited because long-term data were expensive to obtain and considered commercially sensitive, so they were often not made available to larger groups for common assessment. Nevertheless some of the older standards include creep strength information, sometimes as an informative appendix, sometimes as a true part of the standard.
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
85
Table 3.1 gives some of the older standards, now mainly discontinued, including creep strength information. Table 3.2 gives examples of creep data for tubes and pipes in the main steel grades included in the older standards. This table also shows the difficulties encountered in achieving common standardisation, because the correlation between steel grades of different countries is not always obvious and their application and heat treatment conditions are sometimes quite different. It is relatively obvious that in spite of the national preferences for using particular steel grades as recommended by national producers, the main national standards also include grades for ‘foreign’ materials, although sometimes with quite significant differences in guaranteed/expected creep strength values.
3.3
The European Creep Collaborative Committee (ECCC)
3.3.1
Motivation and history
With advancing integration within Europe, in 1991 a large number of industrial and research companies from the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, France, Denmark, Switzerland, Austria, The Netherlands and Belgium founded the European Creep Collaborative Committee (ECCC).12 The common purposes of this organisation were laid down in a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) that was jointly agreed, signed by all members and is still the foundation for cooperation. The MoU established that ECCC is a voluntary association of organisations representing their nations, led by industry, with the aim of improving, reinforcing and enhancing the position of European industry in the high temperature application market. The companies participating in ECCC cover the whole scope of industries and research organisations dealing with high temperature problems: steel makers, steel product manufacturers, boiler, turbine, plant and equipment builders, utilities and end users, inspection bodies, research institutes, technical universities, testing houses. Currently, the ECCC represent 14 nations, which include, besides those already mentioned above, Sweden, Finland, Portugal, Czech Republic and Slovakia. More than 50 organisations from the 14 countries contribute to ECCC activities. The MoU defines detailed targets to be addressed by ECCC to support European standardisation and research in creep. ECCC and its members: • • • • • •
collate, exchange and jointly assess creep data; support European standardisation; coordinate European creep data generation; develop common creep research and testing programmes; mutually exchange information on HT material development; and define common procedures for data generation and assessment.
WPNL2204
86
Table 3.1 Former national European Standards including creep strength values (examples) Nation
Title
Date of issue
Status
BS 1501
UK
1988/90
Discontinued
BS 1502
UK
1982
Discontinued
BS 1503
UK
1989
Discontinued
BS 1506
UK
1990
Discontinued
BS 3059-2
UK
1990
Discontinued
BS 3602
UK
1987
Discontinued
BS 3604
UK
1991
BS 3605 DIN 17175 DIN 17176
UK D D
1991 1979 1990
Current (only part 2 – welded tubes) Discontinued Discontinued Discontinued
DIN 17177
D
1979
Discontinued
DIN 17240 DIN 17245
D D
1976 1977
Discontinued Discontinued
DIN 17458
D
Plates, Specification for carbon, alloy and austenitic stainless steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Section and bars: Specification for carbon, alloy and austenitic stainless steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Forgings: Specification for carbon, alloy and austenitic stainless steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Bars for bolting: Specification for alloy and austenitic stainless steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Steel boiler and superheater tubes. Specification for carbon, alloy and austenitic stainless steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Specification for carbon steel pipes and tubes with specified room temperature properties for pressure purposes Steel pipes and tubes for pressure purposes: ferritic alloy steel with specified elevated temperature properties. Specification for longitudinally arc welded tubes Austenitic Stainless steel pipes and tubes for pressure purposes Nahtlose Rohre aus warmfesten Stählen; Technische Lieferbedingungen, Nahtlose kreisförmige Rohre aus druckwasserstoffbeständigen Stählen; Technische Lieferbedingungen Elektrisch pressgeschweißte Rohre aus warmfesten Stählen; Technische Lieferbedingungen Heat resisting and highly heat resisting materials for bolts and nuts Ferritic Steel Castings Creep Resistant at elevated Temperatures: technical Conditions for Delivery Seamless circular austenitic stainless steel tubes subject to special requirements: Technical delivery conditions
1985
Discontinued
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Designation
D
DIN 17460
D
DIN 17465 DIN 17470
D D
NF A36-209
F
NF A49-213 NF A49-215 NF A49-219 BS PD 6525 UNI 5462
F F F UK I
UNI 6904
I
UNI 7660
I
VDEh
D
Nahtlose kreisförmige Rohre aus hochwarmfesten austenitischen Stählen: Technische Lieferbedingungen Hochwarmfeste austenitische Stähle. Blech, kalt- und warmgewalztes Band, Stabstahl und Schmiedestücke Heat resistant steel castings: Technical conditions for delivery Heating conductor alloys : Technical delivery conditions for round and flat wire Produits Sidérurgiques : Tôles en aciers inoxydables austénitiques et austéno-ferritiques pour chaudières et appareils à pression
Elevated temperature properties for steels for pressure purposes Tubi di acciaio senza saldatura: Tubi per caldaie, per apparecchi, per tubazioni di impianti termici ad alte temperature ed alte pressioni – qualità, prescrizioni e prove Tubi senza saldatura di acciaio legato speciale inossidabile resistente alla corrosione e al calore. Prodotti finiti di acciaio fucinati, per recipienti a pressione. Qualità, prescrizioni e prove. Ergebnisse deutscher Langzeitversuche
1992
Discontinued
1992
Discontinued
1977 1984
Discontinued Current
1990
Discontinued
1990 1964
Discontinued Discontinued Discontinued Current Discontinued
1971
Discontinued
1977
Discontinued
1961
na
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
DIN 17459
87
WPNL2204
88
Table 3.2 Example of creep data availability in some national European Standards for carbon, low and high alloyed ferritic steels for boiler tubes and pipes (all mentioned national standards discontinued in the meantime) Heat
Treat- BS 3604
grade
ment
BS 3059-2
Designation
United Kingdom
NF A49-213,
France
DIN 17175
Germany
Creep rupture strength
215,219
Creep rupture strength
DIN 17176
Creep rupture strength
T range
Duration
(°C)
(h)
Designation
T range
Duration
(°C)
(h)
Designation
T range
Duration
(°C)
(h) 10k, 100k 200k 10k, 100k 200k
P235GH
N
33
350–500
100k
St35.8
380–480
P265GH 8 CrMo 4 5 8 CrMo 5 5 13 CrMo 4 5
N NT NT N
45
350–500
100k
St45.8
380–480
620–460
450–630
13 CrMo 4 5
NT
620–440
450–630
13 CrMo 5 5
NT
621
450–630
625
450–650
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k* 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k* 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k* 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
X 11 CrMo 5 A
X 11 CrMo 5 NT QT
TU 10CD5-05
500–575
10k, 100k
TU 13CD4-04
450–560
10k 100k
13 CrMo 4 4
450–570
10k, 100k 200k
TU Z12CD5-05 500–600
10k, 100k
12 CrMo 19 5 480–650
TU Z12CD5-05 500–600
10k, 100k
12 CrMo 19 5 350–650
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
WPNL2204
UNI 5462
Italy Ceep rupture strength
Designation
T range
Duration
(°C)
(h)
C14
390-520
100k
C18
390-520
100k
14 CrMo 3
450–600
100k
Creep-resistant steels
EN 10216 Material
16 Mo 3
N
11 CrMo 9 10 NT
243
450–550
622
460–610
TU 15 D3
450–550
10k, 100k
15 Mo 3
450–500
10k, 100k 200k
16Mo5
450–550
100k
TU 10CD9-10
500–625
10k, 100k
10 CrMo 9 10 450–600
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
12 CrMo 9 10
470–620
100k
480–580
10k, 100k, 200k
12CrMoV 6 2
11 CrMo 9 10 QT 12 CrMoV 6 2 NT
X 11 CrMo 9 1
X 11 CrMo 9 1
12 CrMo 9 10 400–520 660
A
NT
450–600
629
629–590
X 10 NT CrMoVNb9 1
‘T91’
490–690
X 20 CrMoNiV 11 1
NT
762
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
14 MoV 6 3
450–640 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
10k, 30k,
440–670 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
10k, 30k,
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k* 480–680 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
TU Z10CD VNb09-01
TU Z10CD09
TU Z10CD09
550–625
10k, 100k
X 12CrMo9 1 460–600
10k, 100k, 200k
450–675
10k, 100k
X 12CrMo9 1 400–650
10k, 100k, 200k, 10k, 100k
X 10CrMoVNb 91
10k, 30k, 12 1
470–650
X20 CrMoV 470–650 200k
X 10 CrMoNiVNb 91 10k, 100k CrMoNiV 11 1 1
X 20
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k* 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k*
89
WPNL2204
90
Creep-resistant steels
3.3.2
Organisation
Being a voluntary group, ECCC has no basic resources or funding to rely on. Nevertheless, there are several sources which, owing to the multi-national configuration of the ECCC, provide at least some limited support: • •
•
Over the last ten years, ECCC has run European Community funded projects.13–15 Under certain circumstances, ECCC or ECCC sponsored sub-groups have applied for and obtained European research projects, during which detailed problems identified through ECCC activities could be discussed, tested and satisfactorily solved. In some cases these SMT-Projects16,17 formed the basis for new European Standards (e.g. EN 10291 (creep testing) or 10319 (stress relaxation testing)). Each member nation contributes a balanced mixture of testing activity each year, so that testing resources are available each year for commonly agreed research programmes.
This strategy compensates for the recent reductions in national and EC research budgets and the loss of companies and related specialists dealing with high temperature resulting from globalisation. It has also allowed the ECCC to continue to contribute to debate on safety-related technical issues, which are becoming more and more stringent as requirements for reliability and foreseeability of component behaviour increase. Included in this are the new flexible service conditions, which introduce new hazards by pushing plants into not previously experienced operating conditions. The ECCC is led by a management committee, in which all member nations have a seat and a vote. Technical work is done in: • • • •
Working Group 1: Creep Data Assessment and Generation Procedures, in which specialists from all over Europe can take part Working Group 2: Results Dissemination and Exchange Forum18 Working Group 3: Creep Data Assessment, divided into sub-groups A (ferritic low and high alloyed steels), B (austenitic steels), C (nickel base alloys) and Working Group 4: Creep of Components and Features, which can both only be attended by specialists belonging to organisations that contribute to their country’s fee to the organisation.
3.3.3
ECCC’s contribution to standardisation
The ECCC WG3 subgroups were charged with producing the strength values to be proposed to the CEN Technical Committees working on the new European Standards in 1991/92. To comply with this task, the WG3 groups:
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
• • • • • •
91
identified the steel grades which were relevant to industry and should be considered for standardisation; collated raw creep data from all available, reliable sources in Europe (and in some cases, the world); assessed the credibility of the raw data collated; identified gaps within the available data; assessed creep rupture and creep strain strength values for the standardisation body; and promoted and led ECCC harmonised testing programmes relying – at least partially – on common testing resources. Since 1997, more than five million hours of stress rupture and creep rupture testing has been added to the collated data bases of most relevant steel grades (including X10CrMoVNNb 9 1 (grade 91), X 10 CrWMoVNb 9 2 (grade 92), X 19 CrWMoVNb9 1 1 (grade 911), X 6 NiCrMoTiBN 25 20 (grade 709), NiCr22Co12Mo (alloy 617), NiCr20TiAl (alloy 80A), 9%Cr welds, dissimilar welds (2,25%Cr to 9%Cr steels), aged materials (nickel base alloys), etc).
A strategically essential point in this was the need to establish: • • •
a modern system for collating and exchanging creep data in order to guarantee completeness of information and the fair involvement of all contributors; an objective system to judge and to guarantee quality of experimental data for old and future (including those jointly produced) creep tests; and a reliable, commonly agreed procedure on how to derive creep strength values from the large data population collated all over Europe.
A dedicated Working Group (WG1) was established to deal with this central problem and agreed in 1993/9419 on a common approach which was subsequently applied to all ECCC strength value determinations and was enhanced and enlarged several times up to 2005.20 Significant innovations included: • • •
a detailed written procedure by which the whole process, from setting up the detailed specifications of the material to be assessed for creep strength to the presentation of the results, is defined; defined criteria for evaluating statistical significance and material properties of a data set (Table 3; source: ECCC Recommendations, Reference 20; Vol 5 part Ia) and EN 12952-2 Annex B); strict requirements for strength assessment: – strength values for standards to be assessed by two independent assessors — whose results may not diverge by more than 10%,
WPNL2204
92
Creep-resistant steels
— who have to use at least one of the methods whose procedure is given in (Reference 20: Vol 5 part Ia – app. D); — both assessments to be positively verified by objective post assessment tests (Reference 20: Vol 5, References 21, 22), checking the strength prediction physical credibility, data description quality and repeatability/stability of extrapolation (see Chapter 14, Constitutive equations for creep curves and predicting service life). Owing to the time needed to prepare all these agreed guidelines, the very early data assessments recommended by ECCC did not completely follow the WG1 procedures, but since 1995 all creep strength values published by the ECCC have been validated by this approach. A first collation of creep strength values was presented in 1996,23 and an upgraded and enlarged version in 2005.24 Further upgrades and assessments on other grades are expected over the coming years. ECCC-recommended values have been made available to the relevant CEN Technical Committees and their sub-committees by common members, discussed and sometimes iteratively agreed. ECCC strength values formed the basis for a large part of the creep strength values included in the new EN standards.
3.3.4
ECCC’s future
In spite of the difficult funding situation in industrial research in Europe, ECCC will continue to support CEN in providing reliable creep strength values. In order to avoid duplication, to enhance the interaction with PED topics and to optimise available resources, ECCC will tighten its collaboration with the European Pressure Equipment Research Council (EPERC).
3.4
European Pressure Equipment Research Council (EPERC)
3.4.1
Motivation and history
The European Pressure Equipment Research Council (EPERC)25 was founded in the early 1990s and established officially in 1995 by a group of European industry and research organisations. It was set up to collaborate in harmonising and unifying European laws, regulations, codes and standards on all pressurebearing equipment, including those operating under high temperature and creep regimes. In 2005, EPERC became the EPERC-Technological Platform, in the light of the new EC Framework VII research funding strategy. According to the EPERC Member Agreement,25 the main objectives of EPERC are the establishment of: •
a European Network to support the pressure equipment industry and small and medium enterprises (SMEs), in particular;
WPNL2204
Table 3.3 Recommended data size requirements according to Reference 20, Vol. 5 part I Interim-minimum requirements
•
≥3 tests at each of ≥3 temperatures, at intervals of 50–100°C
Original (TM1)
For ≥6 casts, there should be tu(T, σ0) observations from: • ≥5 tests at each of ≥3 temperatures in the design application range at intervals of 25–50°C
䊐 – ≥3 tests per temperature (different σ0) with tu,max≥ 10 kh
TM2
TM3
For datasets with ≥300 observations, originating from ≥10 casts, at ≥5 temperatures covering the range TMAIN ± ≥50°C For ≥5 casts, there should be tu(T, σ0) observations from:
For datasets with ≥500 observations, originating from ≥20 casts, at ≥5 temperatures covering the range TMAIN ± ≥50°C For ≥5 casts, there should be tu(T, σ0) observations from:
•
•
䊐 – ≥4 tests per temperature (different σ0) with tu,max≥ 40 kh 䊐 – ≥1 test per temperature with tu,max≥ 40 kh
≥5 tests at each of ≥2 temperatures in the design application range at an interval(s) of 25–50°C 䊐 – ≥4 tests per temperature (different σ0) with tu,max ≤ 35 kh 䊐 – ≥1 test per temperature with tu,max≥ 35 kh
Predicted strength values determined from an Interim minimum dataset shall be regarded as tentative until the data requirements defined in one of the target-minimum columns are obtained
WPNL2204
䊐 – ≥4 tests per temperature (different σ0) with tu ≤ 35 kh 䊐 – ≥1 test per temperature with tu,max≥ 35 kh
93
tu,max is the longest test duration available, σ0 is the initial test stress, I is the temperature.
≥5 tests at ≥1 temperature(s) in the design application range (at intervals of 25–50°C)
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
For ≥3 casts, there should be tu(T, σ0) observations from:
Target-minimum requirements
94
• • • •
Creep-resistant steels
short- and long-term research priorities for the European pressure equipment industry; coordination of cooperative research in the domain of pressure equipment and identification of funding sources for this research; dissemination of research results to the European industry and standardisation bodies; and joint European attitudes to pressure equipment safety and reliability.
EPERC was particularly successful in interconnecting European cooperative research with current design needs, construction, inspection and in-service activities and especially in trying to harmonise contradictory European standards, rules and laws. For this purpose, EPERC was and probably will remain the major discussion forum and investigation coordinator providing technical and scientific depth to support the ‘New approach to Technical Harmonisation and Standards’, which will be the privileged means of complying with the ‘Essential Safety Requirements of the new Pressure Equipment Directive (PED 97/23/EC)’. Another important issue for EPERC is maintaining permanent contacts with standardisation bodies (CEN) and the relevant international organisations, PVRC (USA) and JPVRC (Japan), and so on. This cooperation is supported by a common Memorandum of Understanding (2001) and involves a strong interaction with all the committees and notified bodies’ umbrella organisations dealing with the Pressure Equipment Directive (PED 97/23/EC)9 and its amendments, guidelines and sometimes conflicting interpretations. Since 2002, EPERC has entered several new areas, including support for the new European Design Codes (EN 13445, EN 13480, families etc), also in the area of creep. In this context, EPERC and ECCC have collaborated and will develop an even closer relationship in the future.
3.4.2
Organisation
EPERC has relied on in-kind contributions and financial support via ECfunded projects. It is led by a steering committee in which national representatives from the countries with member organisations have a seat and a vote. The original EPERC structure can be found in Reference 25. The actual organisation of EPERC-TP is structured into five task groups, dealing with (i) Materials & fabrication, (ii) Design, (iii) Damage & rupture analysis, (iv) Operation, inspection, testing & maintenance, (v) Special and emerging issues, and Support to Standardisation.
3.4.3
EPERC’s contribution to creep-related standardisation
EPERC has collaborated on and influenced a huge number of standards and pre-standardisation projects in all areas related to pressure equipment. In the
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
95
high temperature area, essential contributions were made to the harmonisation of the non-destructive testing (NDT) codes and practices used for creepserviced component inspection, creep crack growth, minimum invasive testing (small punch) and the new philosophies founded on risk base analysis (RIMAP) and ‘fitness for service’ concepts (FITNET). Further EPERC contributions centred on the design codes and the related CEN TCs, especially for the new EN 13445 standards which include design issues in creep regime in Part 3. This particular project required information on parent material and weld creep strengths, hence the interaction with ECCC.
3.5
The latest generation of CEN standards for creep-resistant steels
3.5.1
General principle
The CEN10 standards are prepared by the relevant CEN Technical Committee and its sub-committees assisted, in some cases, by additional working groups. The new EN standards attempt to harmonise the often contrasting national norms and rules, focusing on those materials which are either present in most of the national standards, are not yet included in national standards but are of immediate technical interest, or are evidently commonly used throughout Europe. In some cases, similar grades codified in Partner National Standards can be grouped into one common type. In the case of standards related to creep, the framework covers revised methods for testing, specifications for steels, extensive use of creep strength data (although this is generally indicated as being informative), welds and – still mainly under development – design rules.
3.5.2
Material specifications
Table 3.4 includes an overview of the latest available CEN standards (up to November 2006, although several were expected in 2007) that relate to creep-resistant steels and reporting strength values. The materials included in these standards are listed in Tables 3.5 to 3.15, along with some information on the available creep strength values. A particular feature is the use of informative annexes reporting mean creep rupture strengths, which are determined from quality experimental data collations representing European and sometimes worldwide research. • •
Values marked * were obtained by extended extrapolation in time, i.e. by more than a factor of 3, beyond the scope of the available experimental data. Values in brackets ( ) were calculated by an extrapolation beyond 80% of the minimum stress of the experimental data set.
WPNL2204
96
Table 3.4 European specifications for creep-resistant steels Title
Date of issue
Status (Nov/2006)
EN10028-2
Flat products made of steels for pressure purposes – non-alloy and alloy steels with specified elevated temperature properties Flat products made of steels for pressure purposes – stainless steels Heat resisting steels and nickel alloys Technical delivery conditions for steel castings for pressure purposes – steel grades for use at room temperature and elevated temperatures Technical delivery conditions for steel castings for pressure purposes – austenitic and austeno-ferritic steel grades Seamless steel tubes for pressure purposes – Technical delivery conditions – Part 2: Non-alloy and alloy steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Seamless steel tubes for pressure purposes – Technical delivery conditions - Part 5: Stainless steel tubes Welded steel tubes for pressure purposes – Technical delivery conditions - Part 2: Electric welded non-alloy and alloy steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Welded steel tubes for pressure purposes – Technical delivery conditions - Part 5: Submerged arc welded non-alloy and alloy steel tubes with specified elevated temperature properties Welded steel tubes for pressure purposes – Technical delivery conditions – stainless steel tubes Steel forgings for pressure purposes – ferritic and martensitic steels with specified elevated temperature properties Steel forgings for pressure purposes – martensitic, austenitic and austeno-ferritic stainless steels Butt welding pipe fittings Steels and nickel alloys for fasteners with specified elevated and/or low temperature properties
2004
Current
2002 2001 1998
Current Current Current
1998
Current
2002
Current
2002
Current
2002
Current
2002
Current
2005
Current
2001
Current
2001
Current
1999 2001
Current Current
EN10028-7 EN10095 EN10213-2 EN10213-4 EN10216-2 EN10216-5 EN10217-2*
EN 10217-5*
EN10217-7* EN10222-2 EN10222-5 EN 10253* EN 10269
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Designation
EN 10295 EN 10302 EN 12952-2* EN 14532-2
Stainless steel bars for pressure purposes Hot rolled weldable steel bars for pressure purposes with specified elevated temperature properties Heat resistant steel castings Creep resistant steels, nickel and cobalt alloys Water tube boilers and auxiliary installations – Part 2: Materials for pressure parts of boilers and accessories Welding consumables: Test methods and quality requirements Part 2: Supplementary methods and conformity assessment of consumables for steel nickel and nickel-alloys
2003 2002
Current Current
2003 2002 2001
Current Current Current
2004
Current
* These standards do not include creep strength values themselves, but the materials included can be referred back to other standards in the table, where strength values are listed.
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
EN 10272* EN 10273
97
WPNL2204
98
Table 3.5 Chemical composition of carbon, low and high alloyed ferritic steels in European Standards Material grade
Gross chemical composition
GP240GH GP280GH P195 P235GH P245GH P250GH P265GH P280GH P295GH P305GH P355GH C7–C24 C35E 15 MnCrMoNiV 5 3 15 MnMoV 4 5 18 MnMo 4 5 20 Mn 5 20 MnMoNi 4 5 8 MoB 5 4 12 MoCrV 6 2 2 14 MoV 6 3 16 Mo 3 17 Mo 5 20 MnNb 6
N/ QT N–QT N N A, NT, QT N N N, NT, QT N N, NT, QT N N N, QT NT QT NT QT NT QT N QT N NT QT NT QT N, NT, QT N, NT, QT N
Concentration in mass% of the following elements C
Cr
Mo
Ni
V
0.18–0.23 0.18–0.25 <0.13 <0.16 0.08 –0.2 0.18–0.23 <0.2 0.08 –0.2 0.08–0.2 0.15–0.2 0.1–0.22 <0.24 0.32–0.39 <0.17 <0.18 <0.2 0.17–0.23 0.15–0.23 0.06 –0.1
– – <0.30 <0.30 – <0.30 <0.3 – <0.3
– – <0.08 <0.08 – – <0.08 – <0.08
– – <0.3 <0.3 – <0.3 <0.3 – <0.3
– – <0.02 <0.02 – <0.02 <0.02 – <0.02
<0.3 – <0.4 0.5–1 – <0.3 <0.4 <0.2 <0.2
<0.08 – <0.1 0.2–0.35 0.4–0.6 0.45–0.6 <0.1 0.45–0.6 0.4–0.5
<0.3 – <0.4 0.3–0.7 – <0.3 <0.4 0.4–0.8 –
<0.02 – – 0.05–0.1 0.04–0.08 – – <0.02 –
0.1–0.18 0.12–0.2
0.3–0.6 <0.3
0.5–0.7 0.25–0.35
– <0.3
0.22–0.28 –
<0.22
–
–
–
–
WPNL2204
Other
Mn 1–1.5 Mn 0.9–1.4 Mn 0.9–1.5 Mn 1–1.5 Mn 1–1.5 B 0.002–0.006
Mn 1–1.5; Nb 0.015–0.1 (Cr+Cu+Mo+Ni)>0.7
Creep-resistant steels
Heat treatment
QT NT NT IA NT QT NT NT NT QT NT N NT NT QT QT QT NT QT QT
21 25 40 40 40 42 15
CrMoV 5 7 CrMo 4 CrMo 5 6 CrMoV 4 6 CrMoV 4 6 CrMo 5 6 NiCuMoNb 5 6 4
X 3 CrAlTi 18 2
0.15–0.23 <0.15 0.08–0.14 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.10–0.15 0.10–0.15 0.09–0.17 0.1–0.15 0.08–0.18 0.08–0.18 <0.17 0.11–0.15 0.15–0.2 0.13–0.2 0.15–0.2 0.17–0.23 0.17–0.23 0.17–0.23
– 1–1.5 2.0–2.5 2–2.5 2–2.5 2–2.5 2.0–2.5 2.75–3.25 0.3–0.55 0.3–0.5 0.7–1.15 0.7–1.15 1–1.5 2–2.5 1–1.5 2–2.5 1.2–1.5 3–3.3 3.0–3.5 0.9–1.2
0.4–0.6 0.45–0.65 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.51–0.7 0.4–0.6 0.4–0.6 0.4–0.6 0.45–0.65 0.9–1.1 0.45–0.65 0.9–1.2 0.9–1.1 0.5–0.6 0.5–0.6 0.9–1.1
– <0.3 – – – – <0.3 <0.25 <0.22 – – – <0.3 <0.25 – – – – <0.3 <0.2
– – – – – – – 0.2–0.3 0.21–0.34 0.22–0.3 – – – 0.25–0.35 – – 0.2–0.3 0.45–0.55 0.45–0.55 0.6–0.8
QT QT NT QT NT QT NT QT
0.17–0.25 0.22–0.29 0.39–0.45 0.26–0.44
1.2–1.5 0.9–1.2 1.2–1.5 0.9–1.2
0.55–0.8 0.15–0.3 0.5–0.7 0.5–0.65
<0.6 – – –
0.2–0.35 – – 0.25–0.35
0.39–0.45 <0.17
1.2–1.5 <0.3
0.5–0.7 0.25–0.5
– 0.1–1.3
– –
A
<0.04
17.0–18.0
–
–
–
QT QT (!) QT QT
QT QT QT
QT
N 0.0015–0.016
Si 0.5–0.8
B 0.001–0.010; Ti 0.007–0.15
Cu 0.5–0.8; Nb 0.015–0.045 Si <1; Al 1.7–2.1; Ti 0.2+4*(C+N)– 0.8
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
G 20 Mo5 10 CrMo 5 5 10 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 12 CrMo 9 10 12 CrMoV 12 10 12 CrMoV 6 2 2 G 12 MoCrV 5 2 13 CrMo 4 5 13 CrMo 4 5 13 CrMoSi 5 5 13 CrMoV 9 10 G 17 CrMo 5 5 G 17 CrMo 9 10 G 17 CrMoV 5 10 20 CrMoV 13 5 20 CrMoV 13 5 5 20 CrMoVTiB 4 10
99
WPNL2204
100
Table 3.5 (Cont’d.) Material grade
Gross chemical composition Concentration in mass% of the following elements C
Cr
Mo
Ni
V
Other Nb 0.2–0.5;. W<0.7; B 0.005–0.015; Co 5–7 Si 0.7–1.4; Al 0.7–1.2 Si 0.7–1.4; Al 0.7–1.2 Si 0.7–1.4; Al 1.2–1.7 Si 0.5–1. Al 0.5–1 Nb 0.06–0.1
X 8 CrCoNiMo 10 6
QT
0.05–0.12
9.8 –11.2
0.5 –1
0.2–1.2
0.1–0.4
X X X X X X X X X X X X X
A A A A NT QT A NT1 NT2 IA A1 IA NT NT QT
<0.12 <0.12 <0.12 <0.12 0.08–0.12 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.08–0.15 0.09–0.13
12.0–14.0 17.0–19.0 23.0–26.0 6.0–8.0 8–9.5 4.0–6.0 4.0–6.0 4.0–6.0 4.0–6.0 8.0–10.0 8.0–10.0 8.0–10.0 8.5–9.5
– – – – 0.85–1.05 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1 0.9–1.1
– – – – <0.3 – – – – – – – 0.1–0.4
– – – – 0.18–0.25 – – – – – – – 0.18–0.25
X 11 CrWMoVNb 9 1
NT
0.07–0.13
8.5–9.5
0.3–0.6
<0.4
0.15–0.25
GX 12 CrMoVNbN 9 1
NT QT
0.1–0.14
8.0–9.5
0.85–1.05
<0.4
0.18–0.25
X 12 CrMo 5
NT QT
0.10–0.15
<4–6
0.45–0.65
<0.3
–
10 10 10 10 10 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11
CrAlSi 13 CrAlSi 18 CrAlSi 25 CrAlSi 7 CrMoVNb 9 1 CrMo 5 CrMo 5 CrMo 5 CrMo 5 CrMo 9 1 CrMo 9 1 CrMo 9 1 CrMoWVNb 9 1 1
WPNL2204
– – – W 0.9–1.1; Nb 0.06–0.1; N 0.05–0.09; B0.0005–0.005 W 1.5–2; Nb 0.04–0.09; N 0.03–0.07; B 0.001–0.006 Nb 0.06–0.1; N 0.03–0.07
Creep-resistant steels
Heat treatment
QT QT NT QT NT QT A A QT
0.08–0.15 0.12–0.19 <0.18 <0.18 <0.18 0.15–0.20 0.17–0.23
11–12.5 4–6 4.0–6.0 4–6 4–6 26.0–29.0 10–11.5
1.5 –2 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 0.45–0.65 – 0.5–0.8
2 –3.0 – – – – – 0.2–0.6
0.25–0.4 – – – – – 0.1–0.3
X 20 CrMoV 11 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 22 CrMoV 12 1 GX 23 CrMoV 12 1 GX 30 CrSi7 GX 40 CrSi 13 GX 40 CrSi 17 GX 40 CrSi 24 GX 40 CrSi 28 GX 130 CrSi 29 GX 160 CrSi 18
QT QT 700 QT800 QT QT A A A as cast as cast as cast as cast
0.17–0.23 0.17–0.24 0.17–0.24 0.18–0.24 0.2–0.26 0.2–0.35 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 1.2–1.4 1.4–1.8
10–12.5 11–12.5 11–12.5 11–12.5 11.3–12.2 6.0–8.0 12.0–14.0 16.0–19.0 23.0–26.0 27.0–30.0 27.0–30.0 17.0–19.0
0.8–1.2 0.8–1.2 0.8–1.2 0.8–1.2 1–1.2 <0.15 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5
0.3–0.8 0.3–0.8 0.3–0.8 0.3–0.8 <1.0 <0.5 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0 <1.0
0.2–0.35 0.2–0.35 0.2–0.35 0.25–0.35 0.25–0.35 – – – – – – –
Si <1. N 0.15–0.25 Nb 0.25–0.55; N 0.05–0.1 W 0.4–0.6 W 0.4–0.6
Si Si Si Si Si Si Si
1–2.5 1–2.5 1–2.5 1–2.5 1–2.5 1–2.5 1–2.5
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 12 CrNiMoV 12 3 GX 15 CrMo 5 X 15 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 18 CrN 28 X 19 CrMoNbVN 11 1
101
WPNL2204
Material grade
1% strain creep strength
T range (°C)
Heat-resisting steels and Ni alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
1% strain creep strength
T range (°C)
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Castings EN 10213-2 Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
GP240GH
400–500
GP280GH P195 P235GH
400–500
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k,
380–480
10k–100k
380–480
10k, 100k, 200k
P245GH P250GH P265GH
380–480
10k–100k
380–480
10k, 100k, 200k
P280GH P295GH
380–500
10k–100k
380–500
10k, 100k, 200k
P305GH P355GH
380–500
10k–100k
380–500
10k, 100k, 200k
Duration (h)
Duration (h)
C7–C24 C35E 15 MnCrMoNiV 53 15 MnMoV 4 5
WPNL2204
Duration (h)
Duration (h)
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-2
Product form
102
Table 3.6 Available creep data for carbon, low and high alloyed ferritic steels: plates; heat-resistant steels and Ni alloys; castings
18 MnMo 4 5 20 Mn 5 20 MnMoNi 4 5 8 MoB 5 4 12 MoCrV 6 2 2 14 MoV 6 3 16 Mo 3
10k–100k
425–525
10 k, 100k
Na
na
450–490
10 k, 100k
450–530
10k–100k
450–530
10k, 100k 200k
17 Mo 5 20 MnNb 6 G 20 Mo5 10 CrMo 5 5 10 CrMo 9 10
450–600
11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 12 CrMo 9 10 na 12 CrMoV na 12 10 12 CrMoV 6 2 2 G 12 MoCrV 5 2 13 CrMo 4 5 450–570 13 CrMo 4 5 13 CrMoSi 5 5 13 CrMoV 9 10 G 17 CrMo 5 5
450–570 na
10k–100k
450–600
10k, 100k 200k
na na
400–520 400–550
10k, 100k 10k, 100k
10k–100k
450–570
10k, 100k, 200k
100k na
450–570 400–550
100k 10k, 100k
10k, 100k, 200k
450–600
10k, 100k
400–550
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
400–600
WPNL2204
103
G 17 CrMo 9 10
400–550
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
425–525
104
Table 3.6 (Cont’d)
Material grade
1% strain creep strength
T range (°C) G 17 CrMoV 5 10 20 CrMoV 13 5 20 CrMoV 13 5 5 20 CrMoVTiB 4 10 21 CrMoV 5 7 25 CrMo 4 40 CrMo 5 6 40 CrMoV 4 6 40 CrMoV 4 6 42 CrMo 5 6 15 NiCuMoNb 400–500 564 X 3 CrAlTi 18 2
Duration (h)
10k, 100k
Heat-resisting steels and Ni alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
400–500
1% strain creep strength
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
10k, 100k 500–900
1k, 10k
500–900 1k, 10k, 100k
X 8 CrCoNiMo 10 6 X 10 CrAlSi 13
500–900
1k, 10k
X 10 CrAlSi 18
500–900
1k, 10k
500–900 1k, 10k, 100k 500–900 1k, 10k, 100k
WPNL2204
Castings EN 10213-2 Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
400–600
10k 100k 200k
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-2
Product form
X 10 CrAlSi 25
500–900
1k, 10k
X 10 CrAlSi 7
500–900
1k, 10k
na
500–670
10k, 100k, 200k
10k
460–625
10k
470–600
500–900
500–900 1k, 10k, 100k
105
X 19 CrMoNbV N 11 1 X 20 CrMoV 11 1
1k, 10k
10k 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 10 CrMoVNb na 91 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMoWV Nb 9 1 1 X 11 CrWMoVNb 91 GX 12 CrMoVN Nb 9 1 X 12 CrMo 5 460–625 X 12 CrNiMoV 12 3 GX 15 CrMo 5 X 15 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 18 CrN 28
500–900 1k, 10k, 100k 500–900 1k, 10k, 100k
WPNL2204
106
Table 3.6 (Cont’d)
Material grade
1% strain creep strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Heat-resisting steels and Ni alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
1% strain creep strength
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 22 CrMoV 12 1 GX 23 CrMoV 12 1 GX 30 CrSi7 GX 40 CrSi 13 GX 40 CrSi 17 GX 40 CrSi 24 GX 40 CrSi 28 GX 130 CrSi 29 GX 160 CrSi 18
WPNL2204
Duration (h)
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Castings EN 10213-2 Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
400–600
10k 100k 200k
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-2
Product form
Table 3.7 Available creep data for carbon, low and high alloyed ferritic steels; seamless tubes/pipes; forgings; bars for fasteners and bolts; bars Product form
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-2 Creep rupture strength
Forgings EN 10222-2 1% strain Creep strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Bars EN 10273 1% strain Creep strength
Creep rupture strength
GP240GH GP280GH P195 P235GH
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
400–500
10k 100k 200k 250k
P245GH P250GH P265GH P280GH P295GH P305GH P355GH C7–C24 C35E 15 MnCr
380–480
400–500
Duration (h)
10k–100k
T range (°C)
380–480
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
10k, 100k, 200k
10k 100k 200k 250k
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
380–480
10k– 100k
380–480
10k, 100k, 200k
380–480
10k– 100k 10k – 100k
380–480
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
380–480 380–480
10k–100k
380–480
380–480
10k–100k
380–480
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
na
na
400–500
10k, 100k, 200k
450–500
10k–100k
430–500
10k–100k
380–500 380–500 350–500
10k 100k 350–500
10k 100k
na
na
10k 100k 200k
WPNL2204
380–500
10k– 100k 10k– 100k
380–480
380–500 380–500
10k, 100k 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
107
MoNiV 5 3 15 MnMoV 4 5 18 MnMo 4 5 20 Mn 5 20 MnMoNi 4 5 8 MoB 5 4
T range (°C)
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
Material grade
108
Table 3.7 (Cont’d.) Product form
Creep rupture strength
Forgings EN 10222-2 1% strain Creep strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Bars EN 10273 1% strain Creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C) 12 MoCrV 6 2 2 14 MoV 6 3 450–600
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
10k, 100k, 480–600 200k, 250k 10k, 100k, 450–530 200k, 250k
10k 100k
450–600
10k–100k
450–530
10 k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
Duration (h)
16 Mo 3
450–550
17 Mo 5 20 MnNb 6
400–500
10k, 100k 200k* 250k*
G 20 Mo5 10 CrMo 5 5
450–600
10 CrMo 9 10
450–600
10k, 100k 200k, 250k 10k, 100k 200k, 250k
11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10
400–520
10k, 100k
450–600
10k–100k
450–600
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
450–530
10k – 100k
450–530
10k, 100k, 200k
450–600
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k, 200k
400–520
100k
10k, 100k, 200k
11 CrMo 9 10 12 CrMo 9 10 12 CrMoV 12 10 12 CrMoV 622 G 12 MoCrV 52
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-2
13 CrMo 4 5
450–600
450–570
10k–100k
450–570
10k, 100k, 200k
450–570
10k, 100k na
na
25 CrMo 4 40 CrMo 5 6 40 CrMoV 4 6
420–550
450– 600 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k 420–550 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k 420–550 10k, 100k
na
na
450–550
10k, 100k 200k
40 CrMoV 4 6 42 CrMo 5 6
na
na
450–550
10k, 100k, 200k
400–500
10k, 100k
500–650
10k, 100k 200k*
na
na
500–670
450–570
10k, 100k, 200k
10k, 100k, 200k
109
15 NiCuMoNb 564 X 3 CrAlTi 18 2 X 8 CrCoNiMo 10 6 X 10 CrAlSi 13 X 10 CrAlSi 18 X 10 CrAlSi 25 X 10 CrAlSi 7 X 10 CrMoV Nb 9 1 X 11 CrMo 5
420–550
10k 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
13 CrMo 4 5 13 CrMoSi 5 5 13 CrMoV 9 10 G 17 CrMo 5 5 G 17 CrMo 9 10 G 17 CrMoV 5 10 20 CrMoV 13 5 20 CrMoV 420–550 13 5 5 20 CrMoVTiB 4 10 21 CrMoV 5 7
10k, 100k, 200k 250k
WPNL2204
110
Table 3.7 (Cont’d.) Product form
Creep rupture strength
Forgings EN 10222-2 1% strain Creep strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Bars EN 10273 1% strain Creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
X 11 CrMo 5
450–600
X 11 CrMo 5
450–600
X 11 CrMo 5
450–630
10k, 100k 200k, 250k 10k, 100k 200k, 250k 10k, 100k 200k, 250k
X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMo 9 1
460–600 450–650
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
490–570
10k 100k 450–600
10k, 100k, 200k
10k, 100k 10k, 100k, 200k
X 11 CrMoWV Nb 9 1 1 X 11 CrWMoV Nb 9 1 GX 12 CrMo VNbN 9 1 X 12 CrMo 5 X 12 CrNiMoV 12 3 GX 15 CrMo 5 X 15 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1
T range (°C)
490–570
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k, 200k
WPNL2204
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
Creep-resistant steels
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-2
X 16 CrMo 5 1
10k 100k 200k
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k, 200k
470–650
10k 100k
480–630
10k, 100k, 200k
450–600
10k, 100k 450–600
10k, 100k, 200k
450–600
10k, 100k 450–600
10k, 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 18 CrN 28 X 19 CrMoN bVN 11 1 X 20 CrMoV 480–650 11 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 22 CrMoV 12 1 GX 23 CrMoV 12 1 GX 30 CrSi7 GX 40 CrSi 13 GX 40 CrSi 17 GX 40 CrSi 24 GX 40 CrSi 28 GX 130 CrSi 29 GX 160 CrSi 18
450–600
111
WPNL2204
112
Table 3.8 Available creep data for carbon, low and high alloyed ferritic steels: castings; creep-resistant steels; consumables; generic products Product form
1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302 Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Consumables EN 14532-2
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture
Generic ECCC Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
10k 100k 200k, 250k, 10k, 100k, 200k, 250k,
GP240GH GP280GH P195
x
400–500
P235GH
x
400–500
P245GH P250GH P265GH
x
400–500
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k,
P280GH P295GH P305GH P355GH
x
400–500
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k,
400–550
10k, 100k,
C7–C24 C35E 15 MnCrMo NiV 5 3 15 MnMoV 4 5 18 MnMo 4 5 20 Mn 5 20 MnMoNi 4 5 8 MoB 5 4
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Castings EN 10295
12 MoCrV 6 2 2 14 MoV 6 3 16 Mo 3
x
450–550
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k
17 Mo 5 20 MnNb 6 G 20 Mo5 10 CrMo 5 5 10 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10 11 CrMo 9 10
x
450–600
x
400–520
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k 10k, 100k
CrMo 9 10 CrMo 9 10 CrMoV 12 10 CrMoV 6 2 2
G 12 MoCrV 5 2 13 CrMo 4 5
x
13 CrMo 4 5 13 CrMoSi 5 5 13 CrMoV 9 10 G 17 CrMo 5 5 G 17 CrMo 9 10 G 17 CrMoV 5 10 20 CrMoV 13 5 20 CrMoV 13 5 5 20 CrMo VTiB 4 10 21 CrMoV 5 7
x xNotch
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k
450–600
10k, 100k, 200k, 250k
420–550
10k, 100k
450– 600
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k 10k, 30k, 100k 200k, (1%) 10k, 100k
420–550
25 CrMo 4
420–550
WPNL2204
113
475–600
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
11 12 12 12
x
114
Table 3.8 (Cont’d.) Product form
1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302 Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Consumables EN 14532-2
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture
Generic ECCC Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C)
T range (°C)
T range (°C)
T range (°C)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
42 CrMo 5 6
450–550
15 NiCuMo Nb 5 6 4 X 3 CrAlTi 18 2 X 8 CrCo NiMo 10 6 X 10 CrAlSi 13 X 10 CrAlSi 18 X 10 CrAlSi 25 X 10 CrAlSi 7 X 10 Cr
400–500
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k
500–670
10k, 30k,
450–630
100k, 200k, 10k, 100k, 200k, 250k
Duration (h)
Duration (h)
Duration (h)
Duration (h)
40 CrMo 5 6
x xNotch x x xNotch
40 CrMoV 4 6 40 CrMoV 4 6
470 –650
10k, 100k
MoVNb 9 1 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5 X 11 CrMo 5
500–600
10k, 100k
470 –650
10k, 100k, 200k
x
x x x
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Castings EN 10295
X 11 CrMo 9 1
450–640
X 11 CrMo 9 1 X 11 CrMo 9 1
x x 480–650
10k, (100k)
10k, 100k
520–650 470–620 450–600
X 12 CrNi
600–800 600–900
10k 100. 1k 10k
600–800
500–600
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k
450–600
470–650
10k, 100k
470–650
470–650
10k, 100k
470–650
450–600
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k
450–600
10k, 100k
100, 1k
x
480–650
10k, 30k, 100k, (200k) 10k, 30k, 100k, (200k) 10k, 30k, 100k, 200k, 10k, 100k, 200k 250k
10k, 100k, 200k
115
MoV 12 3 GX 15 CrMo 5 X 15 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 16 CrMo 5 1 X 18 CrN 28 X 19 CrMoN bVN 11 1 X 20 CrMoV 11 1 X 20 CrMoWV 12 1 X 20 CrMoWV 121 X 22 CrMoV 121 GX 23 Cr MoV 12 1 GX 30 CrSi7 GX 40 CrSi 13
480–650
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 11 CrMo WVNb 9 1 1 X 11 CrWMo VNb 9 1 GX 12 CrMo VNbN 9 1 X 12 CrMo 5
460–600 450–650 200k 520–650
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 10k, 100k,
WPNL2204
116
Product form
Castings EN 10295 1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302 Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Consumables EN 14532-2
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture
Generic ECCC Creep rupture strength
Material grade
GX GX GX GX GX
40 CrSi 17 40 CrSi 24 40 CrSi 28 130 CrSi 29 160 CrSi 18
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
600–900 600 –900 600–900 600–900 600–900
10k 10k 10k 10k 10k
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
600–900 800–900
100, 1k 100, 1k
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Duration or temperature in brackets ( ) represent strength values after extended extrapolation in stress. Duration or temperature with an asterisk * represent strength values after extended extrapolation in time. For steels assessed by ECCC the symbol (1%) means that a 1% strain creep strength assessment is also available. EN 14532-2 does not report strength data but does report assessed equations relating strength, duration and temperature. In the EN 14532-2 column, the remark ‘x notch’ means that an equation for creep notch rupture strength is also provided.
WPNL2204
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Creep-resistant steels
Table 3.8 (Cont’d.)
Table 3.9 Chemical composition of austenitic steels contained in European Specifications Material grade
Gross chemical composition Concentration in mass% of the following elements Mo
Ni
Ti
Other
X 2 CrNi 18 9 X 5 CrNi 18 10 GX 5 CrNi 19 10 X 6 CrNi 18 10 X 6 CrNi 23 13 X 6 CrNi 25 20 X 8 CrNi 25 21 X 12 CrNi 23 13 X 2 CrNiN 18 10 X 2 CrNiMo 17 12 2 X 3 CrNiMo 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiMo 17 12 2 GX 5 CrNiNb 19 11 GX 5 CrNiMo 19 11 2 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiMo 17 13 2 X 7 CrNiNb 18 10 X 7 CrNiTi 18 10
<0.03 <0.07 <0.07 0.04–0.08 0.04–0.08 0.04–0.08 <0.1 <0.15 < 0.03 < 0.03 <0.05 <0.07 <0.07 <0.07 <0.08 <0.08 <0.08 <0.08 0.04–0.08 0.04–0.10 0.04–0.08
17.5–19.5 17.5–19.5 18.0–20.0 17.0–19.0 22.0–24.0 24.0–26.0 24.0–26.0 22.0–24.0 17.5–19.5 16.5–18.5 16.5–18.5 16.5–18.5 18.0–20.0 18.0–20.0 17.0–19.0 17.0–19.0 17.0–19.0 17.0–19.0 16.5–18.5 17.0–19.0 17.0–19.0
– – – – – – – – – 2.0–2.5 2.5–3.0 2.0–2.5 – 2.0–2.5 – – – – 2.0–2.5 – –
8.0–10.0 8.0–10.5 8.0–11.0 8.0–11.0 12.0–15.0 19.0–22.0 19.0–22.0 12.0–14.0 8.5–11.5 10.0–13.0 10.5–13.0 10.0–13.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–12.0 12.0–14.0 9.0–12.0 9.0–13.0
– – – – – – – – –
N<0.11 N<0.11
X 8 CrNiTi 18 10 X 8 CrNiNb 19 11 X 8 CrNiNb 16 13
<0.1 0.06–0.1 0.04–0.1
17.0–19.0 17.0–20.0 15.0–17.0
– – –
9.0–12.0 9. 0– 13 12.0–14.0
WPNL2204
– – – – – – 5*C–0.7 5*C–0.7 – – 5*(C+N)– 0.8 5*C–0.8 – –
N 0.12–0.22 N <0.11 N <0.11 N <0.11 Nb 8*C–1.0 Nb 10*C–1.0 Nb 10*C–1.0
– Nb 10*C–1.2 N <0.11
Si <0.75; Nb 8*C–1 Nb 10*C–1.2
117
Cr
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
C
118
Table 3.9 (Cont’d.) Material grade
Gross chemical composition
C
Cr
Mo
Ni
Ti
Other
X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 A
0.08–0.16
20–22.5
2.5–3.5
19.0–21
–
X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 P
0.08–0.16
20–22.5
2.5–3.5
19.0–21
–
X 15 CrNiSi 20 12 X 15 CrNiSi 25 21 X 15 CrNiSi 25 4 A GX 25 CrNiSi 18 9 GX 25 CrNiSi 20 14 GX 40 CrNiSi 27 4 GX 40 CrNiSi 22 10 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 12 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 20 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 11 2 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 3 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiNbN 18 10 X 5 CrNiMoB 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiTiB 18 10 X 6 CrNiMoTi 17 12 2 X 6 CrNiMoB 17 12 2 X 8 CrNiMoNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiNbN 25 21 X 10 CrNiCuNb 18 10
<0.2 <0.2 0.1–0.2 0.15–0.35 0.15–0.35 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 <0.03 <0.03 <0.04
19–21 24.0–26.0 24.5–26.5 17–19 19–21 25–28 21–23 24–27 24–27 16.5–18.5 16.5–18.5 16.0–18.0
– – – <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 2.0–2.5 2.5–3.0 2.0–3.0
11.0–13.0 19.0–22.0 3.5–5.5 8.0–10.0 13–15 3.0–6.0 9.0–11.0 11.0–14.0 19.0–22.0 10.0–12.0 11.0–14.0 12.0–14.0
– – – – – – – – – – – –
Nb 0.75–1.25; W 2–3. Co 18.5–21 Nb 0.75–1.25; W 2–3. Co 18.5–21 Si 1.5–2.5; Si 1.5–2.5; Si 0.8–1.5 Si 0.5–2.5 Si 0.5–2.5 Si 1–2.5 Si 1–2.5 Si 1–2.5 Si 1–2.5 N 0.12–0.22 N 0.12–0.22 N 0.1–0.18; B 0.0015–0.005
0.04–0.08 <0.08 0.04–0.08 0.04–0.1 <0.1 0.07–0.13
17.0–19.0 16.5–18.5 16.5–18.5 15.5–17.5 23.0–27.0 17–19
– 2.0–2.5 2.0–2.5 1.6–2.0 – –
9.0–12.0 10.5–13.5 10.0–13.0 15.5–17.5 17.0–23.0 7.5–10.5
5*C–0.8 5*C– 0.7 – – – –
WPNL2204
B 0.0015–0.005 B 0.0015–0.005 Nb 10*C–1.2 Nb 0.2–0.6; N 0.15–0.35 Cu 2.5–3.5; Nb 0.3–0.6; N 0.05–0.12
Creep-resistant steels
Concentration in mass% of the following elements
15.5–17.5 24–26 23–25 16.0–18.0 15.5–17.5
– – <0.5 2.0–3.0 –
12.5–14.5 6.0–8.0 23.0– 25.0 12.0–14.0 15.5–17.5
0.4–0.7 – – – –
X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 WW X 6 CrNiMoTiB 17 13 A X 6 CrNiSiNCe 19 10
0.04–0.1
15.5–17.5
–
15.5–17.5
–
0.04–0.08 0.04–0.08
16–18 18–20
2–2.5 –
12.0–14.0 9.0– 11.0
5*C–0.8 –
X 7 CrNiMoBNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiMoVNb 16 13 X 9 CrNiSiNCe 21 11 2
0.04–0.1 0.04–0.1 0.05–0.12
15.5–17.5 15.5–17.5 20–22
1.6–2.0 1.1–1.5 –
15.5–17.5 12.5–14.5 10.0–12.0
– – –
0.07–0.15 0.07–0.13
15.5–17.5 14.0–16.0
– 0.8–1.2
12.5–14.5 9.0–11.0
0.4–0.7 –
X 10 NiCrSi 35 19 X 12 NiCrSi 35 16 GX 35 NiCrSi 25 21 GX 40 NiCrSi 35 17 GX 40 NiCrSi 38 19 GX 40 NiCrSi 35 26 GX 40 NiCrNb 45 35 GX 50 NiCrCo 20 20 20
<0.15 <0.15 0.2–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.35–0.45 0.35–0.65
17.0–20.0 15.0–17.0 19–23 16–18 18–21 24–27 32.5–37.5 19–22
– – <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 – 2.5–3.0
33–37 33–37 23.0–27.0 34–36 36–39 33–36 42–46 18–22
– – – – – – – –
X 5 NiCrAlTi 31 20 X 5 NiCrAlTi 31 20 (RA)
0.03–0.08 0.03–0.08
19.0–22.0 19.0–22.0
– –
30.0–32.5 30.0–32.5
0.2–0.5 0.2–0.5
X 10 CrNiMnNbV 15 10 6 1 X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 WW X 10 CrNiMoMnNbV B 15 10 1
WPNL2204
W 2.5–3; B 0.0015–0.006 Mn 8–10; N 0.2–0.4 Si 1–2.5. Nb 0.8–1.8 N 0.1–0.18; B 0.0015–0.005 Nb 10*C–1.2; W 2.5–3.5; N 0.06–0.14 Nb 10*C–1.2; W 2.5–3.5; N 0.06–0.14 B 0.0015–0.006 Si 1–2; N 0.12–0.2; Ce 0.03–0.08 B 0.05–0.1; Nb+Ta 10*C–1.2 Nb 10*C–1.2; V 0.6–0.85 Si 1.4–2.5;. N 0.12–0.2; Ce 0.03–0.08
W 2.5–3; B 0.0015–0.006 Mn 5.5–7; B 0.003–0.009; V 0.15–0.4; Nb 0.75–1.25; N<0.11 Si 1–2; Si 1–2; Si 1–2.0 Si 1–2.5 Si 1–2.5 Si 1–2.5 Si 1.5–2. Nb 1.5–2 Si<1:. Nb 0.75–1.25; Co 18.5–22, W 2–3 Al 0.2–0.5; Cu <0.5; Nb<0.1 Al 0.2–0.5; Cu <0.5; Nb<0.1
119
0.07–0.15 0.2–0.3 0.3–0.5 <0.04 0.04–0.1
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 A X 25 CrMnNiN 25 9 7 GX 40 CrNiSiNb 24 24 X 3 CrNiMoBN 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16
120
Table 3.9 (Cont’d.) Material grade
Gross chemical composition
C
Cr
Mo
Ni
Ti
Other
X 6 NiCrNbCe 32 27 X 8 NiCrAlTi 32 21
0.04–0.08 0.05–0.1
26–28 19.0–22.0
– –
31–33 30.0–34.0
– 0.25–0.65
X 8 NiCrAlTi 32 21 (RK)
0.05–0.1
19.0–22.0
–
30.0–34.0
0.25–0.65
X 10 NiCrAlTi 32 21 X 10 NiCrSiNb 35 22 GX 10 NiCrSiNb 32 20 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 35 18 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 38 19 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 35 26 GX 50 NiCrCoW 35 25 15 5 X 6 NiCrSiNCe 35 25
<0.12 <0.15 0.05–0.15 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.3–0.5 0.45–0.55
19.0–23.0 20–23 19–21 17–20 18–21 24–27 24–26
– – <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 <0.5 –
30–34 33–37 31–33 34–36 36–39 33–36 33–37
0.15–0.6 – – – – – –
Ce 0.05–0.1; Nb 0.6–1 Al 025–0.65; Cu<0.5; Co<0.5; Al+Ti<0.5 Al 0.25–0.65; Cu<0.5; Co<0.5; Al+Ti 0.85–1.2 Al 0.15–0.6 Si 1–2; Nb 1–1.5 Si 0.5–1.5; Nb 0.5–1.5 Si 1–2.5; Nb 1–1.8 Si 1–2.5; Nb 1.2–1.8 Si 1–2.5; Nb 0.8–1.8 Si 1–2. Co 14–16; W 4–6
0.04–0.08
24–26
–
34–36
–
X 2 NiCrMoNbBN 25 22
<0.04
21.5–23
1.0–2.0
22–28
<0.2
X 6 NiCrTiMoVB 25 15 2 X 8 NiCrMoNbBN 25 20
0.03–0.08 0.05–0.1
13.5–16.0 19–21
1.0–1.5 1.0–2.0
24.0–27.0 22–28
1.9–2.3 <0.2
WPNL2204
Si 1.2–2; N 0.12–0.2; Ce 0.03–0.08 Nb 0.1–0.4; B 0.002–0.01; N 0.1–0.25 B 0.003–0.01; V 0.1–0.5 Nb 0.1–0.4; B 0.002–0.01; N 0.1–0.25
Creep-resistant steels
Concentration in mass% of the following elements
Table 3.10 Available creep data for austenitic steels: plates; heat-resistant steels and Ni alloys; castings; seamless tubes/pipes Product form
Plates EN 10028-7 1% strain creep strength
X 2 CrNi 18 9 X 5 CrNi 18 10 GX 5 CrNi 19 10 X 6 CrNi 18 10
X 6 CrNi 23 13 X 6 CrNi 25 20
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
500–750
10k 100k
500–750
550–800
10k 100k
550–800 600–910
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k
1% strain creep strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
600–900
1k 10k
600–900
X 12 CrNi 23 13 X 2 CrNiN 18 10 X 2 CrNiMo 17 12 2 X 3 CrNiMo 17 13 3
600–900
1k 10k
600–900
1k, 10k, 100k 1k, 10k, 100k
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-5
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
500–700
10k, 100k,
(750)
200k
121
X 8 CrNi 25 21
Duration (h)
Castings EN 10213-4
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
Material grade
Heat-resisting steels and Ni-alloys EN 10095
WPNL2204
122
Table 3.10 (Cont’d.) Product form
1% strain creep strength
Heat-resisting steels and Ni-alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Castings EN 10213-4
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-5
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
X 5 CrNiMo 17 12 2 GX 5 CrNiNb 19 11 GX 5 CrNiMo 19 11 2 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiMo 17 13 2 X 7 CrNiNb 18 10 X 7 CrNiTi 18 10
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k
550–700
10k, 100k
T range (°C)
550–700
10k, 100k
540–700
10k, 100k, 200k* 10k, 100k
550–800
WPNL2204
Duration (h)
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-7
X 8 CrNiTi 18 10
580–750
10k, 100k
580–750
1k 10k
600–800
1k,10k, 100k
10k, 100k, 200k
580–750
600–800
1k 10k
600–900
600–1000 1k 10k
600– 1000 500–900
500–900
1k 10k
1k, 10k, 100k 1k, 10k, 100k 1k 10k
10k, 100k, 200k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe 123
X 8 CrNiNb 19 11 X 8 CrNiNb 16 13 X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 A X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 P X 15 CrNiSi 20 12 X 15 CrNiSi 25 21 X 15 CrNiSi 25 4 A GX 25 CrNiSi 18 9 GX 25 CrNiSi 20 14 GX 40 CrNiSi 27 4 GX 40 CrNiSi 22 10 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 12 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 20 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 11 2 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 13 3
600–800
WPNL2204
124
Table 3.10 (Cont’d.) Product form
1% strain creep strength
Heat-resisting steels and Ni-alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Castings EN 10213-4
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-5
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C) X 3 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiNbN 18 10 X 5 CrNiMoB 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiTiB 18 10 X 6 CrNiMoTi 17 12 2 X 6 CrNiMoB 17 12 2 X 8 CrNiMo Nb 16 16 X 8 CrNiNbN 25 21 X 10 CrNiCuNb 18 10 X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 A X 25 CrMnNiN 25 9 7
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k
T range (°C)
700–900
Duration (h)
1k, 10k
WPNL2204
T range (°C)
700–900
Duration (h)
1k, 10k
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k
580–750
10k, 100k, 200k
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-7
550–800
10k, 100k, 200k
600– (1000)
600– (1000)
600– (1000) 600–900
1k, 10k, 100k
1k, 10k, 100k
600– (1000)
600– (1000)
550–800
10k, 100k, (200k)
580–650
10k, 100k 200k
600–780
10k, 100k 200k, 250k*
1k, 10k, 100k
1k, 10k, 100k
1k 10k
600–900
1k, 10k
1k 10k 100k
600– 1000
1k, 10k, 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe 125
GX 40 CrNiSi Nb 24 24 X 3 CrNiMoBN 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 WW X 6 CrNiMoTiB 17 13 A X 6 CrNiSiNCe 19 10 X 7 CrNiMo BNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiMoV Nb 16 13 X 9 CrNiSiNCe 21 11 2 X 10 CrNiMn NbV 15 10 6 1 X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 WW X 10 CrNiMoMn NbVB 15 10 1 X 10 NiCr Si 35 19 X 12 NiCr Si 35 16 GX 35 NiCr Si 25 21 GX 40 NiCr Si 35 17
WPNL2204
126
Table 3.10 (Cont’d.) Product form
1% strain creep strength
Heat-resisting steels and Ni-alloys EN 10095
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Castings EN 10213-4
Seamless tubes/pipes EN 10216-5
Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C) GX 40 NiCr Si 38 19 GX 40 NiCr Si 35 26 GX 40 NiCr Nb 45 35 GX 50 NiCrCo 20 20 20 X 5 NiCr AlTi 31 20 X 5 NiCrAlTi 31 20 (RA) X 6 NiCrNb Ce 32 27 X 8 NiCr AlTi 32 21 X 8 NiCrAlTi 32 21 (RK) X 10 NiCr AlTi 32 21 X 10 NiCr SiNb 35 22
600–700 550–700
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
10k (100k) 10k (100k)
500–700
10k, 100k, (200k) 10k, 100k, (200k)
500–700
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
10k 100k
700– 1000
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
500–700 500–700 800– (1000)
700– 1000
Duration (h)
700– 1000
1k 10k
600 –900
600– (1000)
1k 10k
600–900
WPNL2204
10k, 100k (200k) 10k, 100k (200k)
10k, 100k
10k, 30k 100k, 200k
600–900
Duration (h)
1k, 10k, 100k 1k, 10k
10k, 100k (200k)
Creep-resistant steels
Plates EN 10028-7
600– 1000
1k, 10k 100k
600– 1000
1k, 10k 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
GX 10 NiCr SiNb 32 20 GX 40 NiCr SiNb 35 18 GX 40 NiCr SiNb 38 19 GX 40 NiCr SiNb 35 26 GX 50 NiCrCo W 35 25 15 5 X 6 NiCrS iNCe 35 25 X 2 NiCrMo NbBN 25 22 X 6 NiCrTiMoV B 25 15 2 X 8 NiCrMoNb BN 25 20
127
WPNL2204
128
Table 3.11 Available creep data for austenitic steels: forgings; bars for fasteners and bolts; castings; creep-resistant steels Product form
Creep rupture strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269 1% strain creep strength
Castings EN 10295
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
X 2 CrNi 18 9 X 5 CrNi 18 10 GX 5 CrNi 19 1 X 6 CrNi 18 10 X 6 CrNi 23 13 X 6 CrNi 25 20 X 8 CrNi 25 21 X 12 CrNi 23 13 X 2 CrNiN 18 10 X 2 CrNiMo 17 12 2 X 3 CrNiMo 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiMo 17 12 2 GX 5 CrNiNb 19 11 GX 5 CrNiMo 19 11 2 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1100
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700 550–700
10k, 100k 10k, 100k
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k
540–700
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
540–700
540–700 540–700
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k
T range (°C)
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
WPNL2204
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
Creep-resistant steels
Forgings EN 10222-5
10k 100k 200k
10k 100k 200k
580–750 550–850 550–850
600–900 10k
10k
600–900
600– 1000 600–900
10k
600–900
100, 1k
700– 1000 700– 1100
10k
700– 1000 700– 1100
100, 1k
600–900
10k
100, 1k
580– 750 550– 900 550– 900
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
129
10k 100k 200k 10k 100k 200k
10k
100, 1k
10k 100k 10k 100k 10k 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiTi 540–700 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiMo 17 13 2 X 7 CrNiNb 540–700 18 10 X 7 CrNiTi 18 10 X 8 CrNiTi 18 10 X 8 CrNiNb 19 11 X 8 CrNiNb 16 13 X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 A X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 P X 15 CrNiSi 20 12 X 15 CrNiSi 25 21 X 15 CrNiSi 25 4 A GX 25 CrNiSi 18 9 GX 25 CrNiSi 20 14 GX 40 CrNiSi 27 4 GX 40 CrNiSi 22 10 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 12 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 20 X 2 CrNiMoN 550–700 17 11 2 X 2 CrNiMoN 550–700 17 13 3
WPNL2204
130
Table 3.11 (Cont’d.) Product form
Creep rupture strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269 1% strain creep strength
Castings EN 10295
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
X 3 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiNbN 18 10 X 5 CrNiMoB 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiTiB 18 10 X 6 CrNiMo Ti 17 12 2 X 6 CrNiMo B 17 12 2 X 8 CrNiMo Nb 16 16 X 8 CrNiNb N 25 21 X 10 CrNiCu Nb 18 10 X 12 CrNiW TiB 16 13 A X 25 CrMn NiN 25 9 7 GX 40 Cr NiSiNb 24 24
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–800
10k, 100k, 200k
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
540–700
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
700– 1000
WPNL2204
Duration T range (h) (°C)
10k
700– 1100
Duration (h)
100, 1k
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
550–700
10k, 100k, 200k
550–850
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k, 200k
580–750
10k, 100k
580–750
600–750
10k, 100k
600–750
10k, 100k
Creep-resistant steels
Forgings EN 10222-5
X 10 CrNiMo
10k, 100k, 200k
550–800 580–750 (550)– 650 600–700
580–670
10k, 100k
580–670
550–650
10k, 100k,
10k, 580–750 100k 10k, 100k (550)– 650 10k, 100k 600–700
200k 10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 100k 10k, 100k
10k, 100k
10k, 100k, 200k
700– 1000 700– 1000 700– 1100 700– 1000 1000
WPNL2204
10k
800–1100 1k
10k
700–1100 100 1k
10k
700–1100 100 1k
580–650
10k, 100k 580– 650
10k, 100k, 200k
500–700
10k, 100k, 200k
10k, 100k, 200k
500– 700
10k 10k
900–1100 100 1k
131
MnNbVB 15 10 1 X 10 NiCrSi 35 19 X 12 NiCrSi 35 16 GX 35 NiCr Si 25 21 GX 40 NiCr Si 35 17 GX 40 NiCr Si 38 19 GX 40 NiCr Si 35 26 GX 40 NiCr Nb 45 35
550–800
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
X 3 CrNiMo BN 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiWN bN 16 16 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 WW X 6 CrNiMoTiB 17 13 A X 6 CrNiSi NCe 19 10 X 7 CrNiMo BNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiMo VNb 16 13 X 9 CrNiSi NCe 21 11 2 X 10 CrNiMn NbV 15 10 6 1 X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 WW
132
Table 3.11 (Cont’d.) Product form
Creep rupture strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269 1% strain creep strength
Castings EN 10295
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302
Creep rupture strength
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C) GX 50 NiCr Co 20 20 20 X 5 NiCr AlTi 31 20 X 5 NiCr AlTi 31 20 (RA) X 6 NiCr NbCe 32 27 X 8 NiCr AlTi 32 21 X 8 NiCr AlTi 32 21 (RK) X 10 NiCr AlTi 32 21 X 10 NiCr SiNb 35 22 GX 10 NiCr SiNb 32 20 GX 40 NiCr8 SiNb 35 1 GX 40 NiCr SiNb 38 19 GX 40 NiCr SiNb 35 26
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
900– 1100
10k
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration (h)
600–700
10k, (100k) 10k, (100k)
10k, 100k, (200k) 10k, 100k, (200k)
800–1000 100 1k
550–700
700– 1000
700– 1000
700– 1000 700– 1100
WPNL2204
10k
10k 10k
700– 1000 700– 1100 700–900 700–1 1100
100 1k 100 1k 100 1k 100 1k
500–700 500–700
10k, 100k 700– 1000
10k, 100k, (200k)
Creep-resistant steels
Forgings EN 10222-5
1000– 1100
500–650
10k, 100k
500–650
10k, 100k
10k
500–650
10k, 100k 500– 650
10k, 100k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
GX 50 NiCrCo W 35 25 15 5 X 6 NiCrSi NCe 35 25 X 2 NiCrMo NbBN 25 22 X 6 NiCrTiMo VB 25 15 2 X 8 NiCrMo NbBN 25 20
133
WPNL2204
134
Creep-resistant steels
Table 3.12 Available creep data for austenitic steels: consumables; generic products Product form
Consumables
Generic
EN 14532-2
ECCC
Material grade Creep rupture
X 2 CrNi 18 9 X 5 CrNi 18 10 GX 5 CrNi 19 10 X 6 CrNi 18 10 X 6 CrNi 23 13 X 6 CrNi 25 20 X 8 CrNi 25 21 X 12 CrNi 23 13 X 2 CrNiN 18 10 X 2 CrNiMo 17 12 2 X 3 CrNiMo 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiMo 17 12 2 GX 5 CrNiNb 19 11 GX 5 CrNiMo 19 11 2 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiNb 18 10 A1100
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
550–720
(10k)–(100k)
500–(750)
10k, 100k, 200k
600–910
10k, 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k
580–800 500–700
10k, 100k, 200k 10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
x
500–850
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
x
540–710
x
540–730
10k 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k 10k 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k 10k 100k 200k 10k 30k, 50k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k
x
X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1000 X 6 CrNiTi 18 10 A1100 X 6 CrNiMo 17 13 2 X 7 CrNiNb 18 10 X 7 CrNiTi 18 10 X 8 CrNiTi 18 10 X 8 CrNiNb 19 11 X 8 CrNiNb 16 13 X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 A X 12 CrCoNi 21 20 P X 15 CrNiSi 20 12 X 15 CrNiSi 25 21 X 15 CrNiSi 25 4 A GX 25 CrNiSi 18 9 GX 25 CrNiSi 20 14 GX 40 CrNiSi 27 4 GX 40 CrNiSi 22 10 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 12 GX 40 CrNiSi 25 20 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 11 2 X 2 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 3 CrNiMoN 17 13 3 X 5 CrNiNbN 18 10 X 5 CrNiMoB 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiTiB 18 10
Creep rupture strength
550–700 540–720
x (A1000) x (A1100)
x x x
WPNL2204
600–750 580–750
10k, 100k 10k, 100k, 200k (1%)
550–750
10k, 100k, 200k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe X 6 CrNiMoTi 17 12 2 X 6 CrNiMoB 17 12 2 X 8 CrNiMoNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiNbN 25 21 X 10 CrNiCuNb 18 10 X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 A X 25 CrMnNiN 25 9 7 GX 40 CrNiSiNb 24 24 X 3 CrNiMoBN 17 13 3 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 X 6 CrNiWNbN 16 16 WW X 6 CrNiMoTiB 17 13 A X 6 CrNiSiNCe 19 10 X 7 CrNiMoBNb 16 16 X 8 CrNiMoVNb 16 13 X 9 CrNiSiNCe 21 11 2 X 10 CrNiMnNbV 15 10 6 1 x X 12 CrNiWTiB 16 13 WW X 10 CrNiMoMnNbVB 15 10 1 x X 10 NiCrSi 35 19 X 12 NiCrSi 35 16 GX 35 NiCrSi 25 21 GX 40 NiCrSi 35 17 GX 40 NiCrSi 38 19 GX 40 NiCrSi 35 26 GX 40 NiCrNb 45 35 GX 50 NiCrCo 20 20 20 X 5 NiCrAlTi 31 20 x X 5 NiCrAlTi 31 20 (RA) X 6 NiCrNbCe 32 27 X 8 NiCrAlTi 32 21
X 8 NiCrAlTi 32 21 (RK)
X 10 NiCrAlTi 32 21 X 10 NiCrSiNb 35 22 GX 10 NiCrSiNb 32 20 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 35 18 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 38 19 GX 40 NiCrSiNb 35 26 GX 50 NiCrCoW 35 25 15 5 X 6 NiCrSiNCe 35 25 X 2 NiCrMoNbBN 25 22 X 6 NiCrTiMoVB 25 15 2 X 8 NiCrMoNbBN 25 20
135
580–820
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
580–770 600–750
10k, 30k, 100k 10k, 100k
550–800
10k, 100k, (200k)
550–1100
10k, 20k, 100k, 200k
600–790
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
500–700 500–700 580–950 550–1000
10k, 100k, (200k) 10k, 100k (200k) (10k–100k) 10k, 20k, 30k, 50k, 70k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k, 300k 10k, 20k, 30k, 50k, 70k, 100k, 150k, 200k, 250k, 300k (1%)
600–1000
600–820
10k, 30k, 100k
580–770
10k, 30k, 100k
Duration or temperature in brackets ( ) represent strength values after extended extrapolation in stress. Duration or temperature with an asterisk * represent strength values after extended extrapolation in time. For steels assessed by ECCC the symbol (1%) means that a 1% strain creep strength assessment is also available. EN 14532-2 does not report strength data but does report assessed equations relating strength, duration and temperature. In the EN 14532-2 column, the remark ‘x notch’, means that an equation for creep notch rupture strength is also provided.
WPNL2204
136
Table 3.13 Chemical analysis of nickel and cobalt base alloys contained in European Standards Gross chemical composition Heat
Concentration in mass% of the following elements
treatment
C
Cr
Co
Fe
Mo
Ni
G NiCr15 G NiCr28W G NiCr50Nb NiCo20Cr20MoTi
As cast As cast As cast P
0.35–0.65 0.35–0.55 <0.1 0.04–0.08
12.0–18.0 27–30 48–52 19–21
– – – 19–21
Balance Balance <1 <0.7
<1 <0.5 <0.5 5.6–6.1
58–66 47–50 Balance Balance
NiCr15Fe NiCr15Fe7TiAl
A AT P
0.05–0.1 <0.08
14–17 14–17
<1.5 <1
6.0–10.0 5.0–9.0
– –
Balance Balance
NiCr15Fe7TiAl
P 980
<0.08
14–17
<1
5.0–9.0
–
Balance
NiCr15Fe7TiAl
P 1170
<0.08
14–17
<1
5.0–9.0
–
Balance
NiCr19Fe19Nb5Mo3
P
0.02–0.08
17–21
<1
Balance
2.8–3.3
50–55
NiCr20Co13Mo4 Ti3Al
P
0.02–0.1
18–21
12.0–15
<2
3.5–5
Balance
NiCr20Co18Ti NiCr20Ti NiCr20TiAl
P AT AT P 2 stage
<0.13 0.08–0.15 0.04–0.1
18–21 18–21 18–21
15–21 <5 <1
<1.5 <5 <1.5
– – –
Balance Balance Balance
WPNL2204
Other
W 4–6 Nb 1–1.8. N<0.16 Al 0.3–0.6; Ti 1.9–2.4; B Al. Ti Al 0.4–1; Ti 2.25–2.75; Nb+Ta 0.7–1.2; Al 0.4–1; Ti 2.25–2.75; Nb+Ta 0.7–1.2; Al 0.4–1; Ti 2.25–2.75; Nb+Ta 0.7–1.2; Al 0.3–0.7; Nb+Ta 4.7–5.5; Ti 0.6–1.2; B 0.002–0.006 Al 1.2–1.6; Ti 2.8–3.3; B; Zr; Al 1–2; Ti 2–3; Zr; B Al; Ti 0.2–0.6; Al 1–1.8; B <0.008. Ti 1.8–2.7
Creep-resistant steels
Material grade
P 3 stage
0.04–0.1
18–21
<1
<1.5
–
Balance
NiCr22Fe18Mo NiCr22Mo9Nb
AT A
0.05–0.15 0.03–0.1
20.5–23 20–23
0.5–2.5 <1
17–20 <5
8.0– 10 8.0–10.0
Balance Balance
NiCr23Co12Mo
AT
0.05–0.1
20–23
11.0–14
<2
8.5–10
Balance
NiCr23Fe
AT
0.03–0.1
21–25
<1.5
<18
–
Balance
NiCr25Co20TiMo
P 1100
0.03–0.07
23–25
19–21
<1
1–2.0
Balance
NiCr25FeAlY
AT
0.15–0.25
24–26
–
8.0–11
–
Balance
NiCr26MoW NiCr28FeSiCe
AT AT
0.03–0.08 0.05–0.12
24–26 26–29
2.5–4 <1.5
Balance 21–25
2.5–4 –
44–47 Balance
NiCr29Fe CoCr20W15Ni G CoCr28
AT AT As cast
<0.05 0.05–0.15 0.05–0.25
27–31 19–21 27–30
– Balance 48–52
7.0–11 <3 Balance
– – <0.5
Balance 9.0–11 <4
Al 1–1.8; B <0.008. Ti 1.8–2.7 Al <0.5; B; W 0.2–1 Al <0.4; Nb+Ta 3.15–4.15 Al 0.7–1.4; Ti 02–0.6; B Al 1–1.7; Ti <0.4; B<0.006 Al 1.2–1.6; Nb+Ta 0.7–1.2; Ti 2.8–3.2; B 0.01–0.015; Zr 0.03–0.07; Ta Al 1.8–2.4; Ti 0.1–0.2; Y 0.05–0.12; Zr W 2.5–4 Ti <0.5; Si 2.5–3; Ce 0.03–0.09 Al <0.5 W 14–16 Nb <0.5
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
NiCr20TiAl
137
WPNL2204
138
Table 3.14 Available creep data for nickel and cobalt base alloys: heat-resistant steels and Ni alloys; bars for fasteners and bolts; castings Product form
Heat treatment
1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Bars for fasteners and bolting EN 10269 1% strain creep strength
Creep rupture strength
Castings EN 10295 Creep rupture strength
Creep rupture strength
Material grade
T range (°C) G NiCr15 G NiCr28W G NiCr50Nb NiCo20Cr 20MoTi NiCr15Fe
As cast As cast As cast P
NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr19Fe19 Nb5Mo3 NiCr20Co 13Mo4Ti3Al NiCr20Co18Ti NiCr20Ti
AT P P 980 P 1170 P
NiCr20TiAl
AT P 2 stage P 3 stage
NiCr20TiAl
A
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
Duration T range (h) (°C)
700–1100 10k 700–1000 10k
500–900
10k, 100k 600–1000 1k, 10k, 100k 500–800
10k 100k 500–800
10k 100k
500–800
10k 100k 500–800
10k 100k
P P AT
Duration T range (h) (°C)
600–1000 1k, 10k, 100k
WPNL2204
900–1000 800–1100 700–1100
Duration (h) 100. 1k 1k 100, 1k
Creep-resistant steels
Heat-resisting steels and Ni-alloys EN 10095
AT A AT AT
NiCr25Co 20TiMo NiCr25FeAlY NiCr26MoW NiCr28FeSiCe NiCr29Fe CoCr20W15Ni G CoCr28
P 1100 AT AT AT AT AT As cast
700–900
1k, 10k
600–1000 1k, 10k, 100k
700–1000 10k, 100k 700–1000 10k, 100k
700–1100 10k
900–1000
100, 1k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
NiCr22Fe18Mo NiCr22Mo9Nb NiCr23Co12Mo NiCr23Fe
139
WPNL2204
140
Table 3.15 Available creep data for nickel and cobalt base alloys: creep-resistant steels; generic products Product form
Heat treatment
G NiCr15 G NiCr28W G NiCr50Nb NiCo20Cr20MoTi NiCr15Fe NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr15Fe7TiAl NiCr19Fe19Nb5Mo3 NiCr20Co13Mo4Ti3Al NiCr20Co18Ti NiCr20Ti NiCr20TiAl NiCr20TiAl NiCr22Fe18Mo NiCr22Mo9Nb NiCr23Co12Mo NiCr23Fe NiCr25Co20TiMo NiCr25FeAlY NiCr26MoW NiCr28FeSiCe
As cast As cast As cast P A AT P P 980 P 1170 P P P AT AT P 2 stage P 3 stage AT A AT AT P 1100 AT AT AT
1% strain creep strength
Generic ECCC
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
500–900
10k, 100k
500–900
10k, 100k
650–800 500–800 500–800
10k, 100k 10k, 100k 10k, 100k
700–800
10k, 100k
650–800 500–800 500–800 650–800 550–800
10k, 10k, 10k, 10k, 10k,
500–800
10k, 100k
500–800
10k, 100k
600–1000
10k, 100k
550–1000
10k, 100k
650–1000
10k, 100k
580–1000
10k, 100k
600–(900) 650–1200 600–1050
10k, 100k 10k, 100k 10k, (100k)
550–900 650–1200 600–1000
10k, 100k 10k, 100k 10k, (100k)
WPNL2204
Creep rupture strength
T range (°C)
Duration (h)
600–900
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
450–670
10k, 30k, 100k, 200k
580–950
10k 30k 100k
100k 100k 100k 100k 100k
Creep-resistant steels
Material grade
Creep-resistant steels EN 10302
AT AT As cast
700–1050 700–1000
10k, 100k 10k, (100k)
700–1050 700–1000
10k, 100k 10k, (100k)
Duration or temperature in brackets ( ) represent strength values after extended extrapolation in stress. Duration or temperature with an asterisk * represent strength values after extended extrapolation in time. For steels assessed by ECCC the symbol (1%) means that a 1% strain creep strength assessment is also available. EN 14532-2 does not report strength data but does report assessed equations relating strength, duration and temperature. In the EN 14532-2 column, the remark ‘x notch’, means that an equation for creep notch rupture strength is also provided.
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
NiCr29Fe CoCr20W15Ni G CoCr28
141
WPNL2204
142
Creep-resistant steels
Although these marks provide obviously significant information, it is not clear how design should consider them with regard to safety factors, or how and if the marked strengths can be further extrapolated. The challenge to state guidelines on the handling of ‘different reliability’ strength values is a target of new design standards currently under development. In some cases, the standard also provides details about the scatter band of the data set used and the assessment method. If the standard data were assessed by ECCC, details of the data set, the collation specification (mechanical data, chemical composition, quantity and duration of tests, etc) and a straight equation for the chosen assessment (relating rupture time, temperature and strength) can be found in the ECCC Data Sheets.23,24 For bolting materials, stress relaxation may also become a design issue as well as the creep properties themselves. Therefore some relaxation properties have been collated and published, in EN 10269 and the ECCC Data Sheets.23,24 Table 3.16 gives an overview of available materials and the scope of relaxation strengths included.
3.5.3
Welding consumables and qualification
Welding consumables for creep-resistant steels are now classified, like all others, according to: • • • • •
EN 12070 (Welding consumables – Wire electrodes and wires and rods for arc welding of creep resisting steels – classification); EN 12072 (Welding consumables – Wire electrodes and wires and rods for arc welding of stainless and heat resisting steels – classification); EN 12536 (Welding consumables – Rods for gas welding of non-alloy and creep resisting steels – classification); EN 1599 (Welding consumables – Covered electrodes for manual arc welding of creep resisting steels – classification); or EN 1600 (Welding consumables – Covered electrodes for manual arc welding of stainless and heat resisting steels – classification).
The general welding procedure qualification comes under EN ISO 15613 or EN ISO 15614. The qualification of the consumables themselves is regulated by EN 14532 (Welding Consumables – Test methods and quality requirements) and a particular, creep-related ‘supplementary prescription’ is included in: EN 14532-2 (Welding Consumables – Test methods and quality requirements – Part 2: Supplementary methods and conformity assessment of consumables for steel, nickel and nickel alloys). Consumables intended for use in the creep regime, defined numerically by a temperature range for ferritic– martensitic, austenitic and nickel-base materials, shall be qualified for the maximum service temperature by comparison tests with a ‘sufficiently similar’ parent material: a stress rupture all weld material creep test series of at least
WPNL2204
Table 3.16 Relaxation strength in European Standards EN 10269
ECCC
Relaxation strength
Creep rupture strength
Heat treatment
C
Cr
Mo
Ni
V
42 CrMo 5 6 40 CrMoV 4 6 21CrMoV 5 7 20 CrMoVTiB 4 10
QT QT QT QT
0.39–0.45 0.26–0.44 0.17–0.25 0.17–0.23
1.2–1.5 0.9–1.2 1.2–1.5 0.9–1.2
0.5–0.7 0.5–0.65 0.55–0.8 0.9–1.1
– – <0.6 <0.2
– 0.25–0.35 0.2–0.35 0.6–0.8
X 22 CrMoV 12 1 X 19 CrMo NbVN 11 1
QT
0.18–0.24
11–12.5
0.8–1.2
0.3–0.8
0.25–0.35
QT
0.17–0.23
10–11.5
0.5–0.8
0.2–0.6
0.1–0.3
0.07–0.13
14.0–16.0 0.8–1.2
9.0–11.0
–
0.04–0.1
18–21
<1.5
–
X 10 CrNiMoMn NbVB 15 10 1
NiCr20TiAl
AT P 2 stage
<1
Other
Nb 0.25– 0.55; N 0.05–0.1 Mn 5.5–7; B 0.003– 0.009; V 0.15–0.4; Nb 0.75–1.25; N<0.11 Al 1–1.8; B <0.008. Ti 1.8–2.7
T range (°C)
Strain range (%)
Duration (h)
T range (°C)
350–500 400–500 300–540 B 0.001– 0.010; Ti 0.007– 0.15 400–580
0.15 0.15 0.2 400–600
1k, 10k, 30k 1k, 10k, 30k 1k, 10k, 30k 0.15
1k, 10k, 30k
0.2
1k, 10k
400–600
0.2
1k, 10k, 30k
550–700
0.15
10k
450–640 650–750
0.15 0.15– 0.2
1k, 10k, 30k 30k 1k, 10k
30k, 430–590
Strain Duration range (%) (h)
0.15
10k, 30k., 100k, 200k
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
Material grade
Gross chemical composition Concentration in mass% of the following elements
30k
143
WPNL2204
144
Creep-resistant steels
four tests has to be produced with the longest test not shorter than 10 000 h, one test above 1000 h and one between 50 and 250 h; tests shorter than 50 h are not considered. The regression line of this test series is then compared with the ±20% scatter band around the mean rupture strength lines of the reference parent material, for which EN 14532-2 Appendix E gives the equations based on Manson–Brown-parameter approaches following the discontinued ISO 6303 Appendix. The source of the coefficients to the equations is the British Guideline PD 6525. All weld material specimens – according to EN 14532-2 – are expected to fall within the scatter band of the matching parent material. If this is not the case, as is likely for longer testing times, detailed warnings about the longer or shorter duration have to be stated on the consumables qualification certificate. To date, EN 14532-2 is the only standard that includes creep strength equations. Some materials are marked with an ‘x’ in Tables 3.5 to 3.15 because the equation applicability is not just related to the temperature–duration plane.
3.5.4
Testing and testing standards
A side product of the ECCC WG1 Creep Data Generation and Assessment Procedures and of the EC-funded Standard Measurement and Testing (SMT) Projects conducted in the 1990s16,17 produced a group of testing procedures, which: • • •
harmonised the rules of the main National Standards (BS 3500, DIN 50118, NF A03-355, ASTM E139/E292, UNI 5111, etc); collated the results from the relevant SMT projects; and critically overviewed the creep testing procedures of 15 leading European labs, as laid down in Reference 19 and Reference 20: Vol 3 part I.
These recommendations were taken up by CEN/ECISS TC1 and became, with slight modifications, the standards: • • •
EN 10291:2000 (Metallic materials – Uniaxial creep testing in tension), which included stress-rupture, creep-rupture and creep testing with both interrupted and non-interrupted strain measurement; EN 10319:2003 (part 1) – 2006 (part 2) (Metallic materials – Tensile stress relaxation testing – Part 1: Procedure for testing machines and Part 2: Procedure for bolted joint models); CWA 15261-3:2005 (Measurement uncertainties in mechanical tests on metallic materials – Part 3: The evaluation of uncertainties in creep testing). This standard has the support and is based on the ground rules as established by the EC funded projects UNCERT and UNCERT-AM.26
EN 10291 is currently part of the discussions regarding revision of international standard ISO 204 (Metallic materials – Uninterrupted uniaxial
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
145
creep testing in tension – method of test). Creep testing on notched specimens has been proposed for inclusion according to the new ECCC-recommended notch geometry (Reference 19 and Reference 20: Vol. 3 part V; References 27, 28) and methods following the High Temperature Mechanical Testing Committee HTMTC Working Group on ‘Notch Creep Behaviour’.29,30 A particular testing technique (miniature specimen testing with the small punch method) is also under discussion in CEN WorkShop Agreement 21 (Small Punch Test Method for Metallic Materials) with the support of EPERC; the issuance of CWA 15627 concluded WS21’s work). Testing technique Compared to standards prepared elsewhere, the new European creep testing norms are based on the ECCC experience in refining testing requirements and some additional testing options. EN 10291 and EN 10319 were designed to best suit long duration tests, while realising that although most relevant to design and dimensioning, quality control laboratories would also use them for the more common short-duration stress rupture testing. •
Test methods and strain measurement: in Europe a large amount of the available long-term creep data was obtained in stress rupture tests, i.e. tests in which the specimen is held at constant temperature and load until fracture occurs. Such tests are often performed in multi-specimen testing machines, which may include up to ten strings each including ten or more specimens. Creep rupture testing, where creep strain is continuously measured during the test, is considered more expensive owing to the need to maintain thermal and electrical stability of the extensometer, or because ambient temperature must be controlled to reduce thermal drift in the transducers. It must be taken into account that during the initial stages of long- and medium-term creep rupture tests, elongations of a few micrometres must be measured, to keep uncertainty to a reasonable level. As a less expensive alternative,16 interrupted creep rupture tests are performed using techniques originally developed in the 1940s31 and improved in Germany in the 1980s.32 During these tests, the specimen is cooled, unloaded, its elongation measured, re-assembled, reloaded and re-heated at regular, generally logarithmically equi-spaced, time intervals. Although the ‘off line’ strain measurement, requires particular care and should be performed in a suitable metrological laboratory, the practical comparison of results achieved in a round robin test on BCR reference materials ‘Alloy 75’ (CRM 425, NiCr20Ti EN 10095) and ‘Durhete 1055’ (20 CrMoVTiB 4 10 EN 10269, 1%CrMoVTiB) showed,16 that interrupted and non-interrupted tests provide creep curves contained in the same scatter-band of approximately ±25% in strain
WPNL2204
146
•
•
Creep-resistant steels
around the mean line. Owing to these premises, EN 10291 and probably the future ISO 204 will regulate this alternative technique. Temperature: temperature stability is an essential parameter during longterm tests, and the main consideration here is distinction and consideration of the various factors contributing to thermal stability: EN 10291 defines temperature stability as the minimisation of the difference between true test temperature and specified test temperature, where these definitions account for all errors contained in the temperature measurement and regulation chain, i.e. regulation deviation plus random errors. Because of this, the allowable temperature differences are somewhat higher than, for instance, those in ASTM E139, where thermal stability has been considered equivalent to indicated temperature minus specified temperature, that is, to the regulation-induced deviations only. Another topic concerning thermal stability is the calibration of thermocouples, generally expensive PtRh–Pt thermocouples of type R, S or B, which unavoidably deteriorate during high temperature exposure owing to metallurgical instability.33 For long-duration tests, several calibration methods were compared and discussed34 and recommendations for both off-line and in situ calibration were stated (Reference 20: Vol 3 part I). Both of these consider the temperature range and gradient to which the thermocouple is exposed during its use, i.e. the depth to which the thermocouple is inserted into the testing furnace, which could be very high in multi-specimen machines where discarding the exposed thermocouple part may be very expensive. Data assessment is subdivided into two distinct steps: (i) Single test raw data assessment consists of transforming elongation time data into strain–time data by dividing elongation by the reference length, which, as a function of the test piece geometry, may be different from the cylindrical length because collars used for the extensometer fixation will contribute to the measured deformation. The reference length is therefore computed according to expected creep behaviour and the Norton stress exponent and may have to be re-assessed when the true results are obtained (Reference 20: Vol 3 part I Appendix 1). From the creep curve (strain versus time), initial plastic strain (if present) and times to specified plastic strains are collated, for which linear interpolation in a bi-logarithmic strain-time diagram appears to be best [20 Vol 3 Part I Appendix 1]. Small differences between interrupted and non-interrupted testing due to inelastic recovery may be negligible in most technical applications. (ii) Data assessment of an entire test programme is described in Chapter 6 by Holdsworth.
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
147
Testing programmes Setting up a testing programme for parent materials depends on what the data are needed for. In material quality assurance, single specimen tests with smooth or combined smooth-notched specimens are required. Production qualification tests generally require an isothermal approach including four to six specimens per temperature and a duration not shorter than 10 000 h, sometimes 30 000 h to meet the requirement to have an extrapolation factor below 3 when computing 100 000 h strengths. The ECCC approach to common testing programmes, intended to fill gaps identified in the currently available creep data population of a given material, also follows isothermal programme set-ups, for which durations of 1000, 3000, 10 000, 30 000 and 70 000 h are requested. To fully meet significance criteria suitable for standardisation, the data additionally have to meet the requirements listed in Table 3.3. In situations where creep properties must be verified in a relatively short period of time, such as during residual life assessment or, in some cases, particular material appraisal according to PED for non-harmonised materials, alternative methods are adopted, although these are generally not standardised and strongly based on the individual assessor’s experience. In such cases ‘iso-stress’, ‘MPC-Ω’ approaches35,36 or reduced test programmes which produce an estimate of a Larson–Miller master curve are used. The effectiveness and credibility of these tests, although in some cases clearly demonstrated, has proven to be strongly dependent on the assessor’s skill and experience with the testing procedure and the material tested (Reference 20: Vol 5 part III). Component creep tests In the past, a considerable number of near- and full-scale tests for components have been developed in Europe. As a consequence, procedures to test closeto-component specimens, generally tubes and pipes, have also been developed. Owing to the complexity of the testing devices and procedures, few testing facilities are available, although an impressive number of tests has been collated (Reference 20: Vol. 9 part III). In addition, codes of practice for tubular specimens under internal pressure and combined internal pressure and tension or torsion have been published.37,38 Relaxation testing The use of bolting at high temperature has to take into account the loss in pre-loading with time (relaxation) owing to creep effects under constant total strain. Various testing techniques have been proposed:
WPNL2204
148
•
Creep-resistant steels
Uniaxial relaxation testing, keeping a standard specimen under total strain control, i.e. keeping its elasto–plastic strain constant over time (generally to a value comparable to the pre-load of a bolt, ca. 0.1–0.5% strain). Two testing approaches are used: –
–
•
Isothermal relaxation: the specimen is heated to test temperature, and loaded to the foreseen strain, which is then kept constant, while the loss in stress over time is recorded. Severe technical testing issues need to be addressed during such tests,17 for instance closedloop testing systems proved to be very difficult to keep stable over long periods of time, when the stress decrease becomes small. Non-isothermal relaxation: in this case the specimen is loaded at room temperature with the required total strain and is then heated to the testing temperature.
Model bolt relaxation testing, developed and already standardised in Germany,39 consists of preloading a series of bolt-flange assemblies at room temperature and then tightening the screws to a known and controlled pre-load (generally measuring the bolt shaft strain using strain gauges). The assemblies are then put into a furnace and heated. One by one the bolt-flange assemblies are extracted at specified time intervals, cooled and loosened, using strain gauges to measure the remnant bolt pre-load.
A comparison of the two methods was conducted on a typical bolting steel (“X19” = X19CrMoNbVN 11 1 EN 10269, 11%CrMoNbNV) under the SMT project.17 Results showed that for long periods of time (ca. 10 000 h), the remnant stress measured using the two different methods are comparable. For both methods, detailed guidelines are found in ECCC Recommendations 2005, Vol 320 and in EN 10319, parts 1 and 2. Design standards At present there are no generally available European standards for design that directly address components which operate under European creep regimes. Nevertheless, considerable work is underway for the new standards EN 13445 part 3 (Unfired pressure vessels – Part 3: Design) and EN 13480 part 3 (Metallic industrial piping – Part 3 Design) and their various appendices. To be in line with PED, the new standards will, besides traditional creep design methods, also have to cover the dimensioning of welds, the use of finite element simulation techniques, the applicability of fracture mechanics and the consideration of statistics and/or risk-based methods (CEN Workshop 22 on FITNET and CEN Workshop 24 on Risk Based Inspection and Maintenance). The related CEN-TCs, EPERC-TP and ECCC are working towards compiling collations of reliable creep strength equations, weld creep strength reduction factors and other material related design features.
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
3.5.5
149
Specifications of creep-resistant steel users
The market for plant building in refineries, chemical plants and power units has changed since the publication of the PED with the breakup and privatisation of monolithic electricity boards and mergers/closures of big boilermakers. Plant building now tends to be in the hands of general engineering companies, which have significantly less skill and experience in handling creep problems and the materials suitable for such operating conditions. In addition, plant owners are asking for longer and longer service periods, so that creep strength values of 200 000 h or 250 000 h are no longer the exception. As a consequence, the plant builders’ specifications for creep-resistant steels tend to refer as far as possible to any available standards and they ask material, component fitting or spool suppliers to guarantee the values in accordance with PED and under all possible configurations during assembly and operation. Since long-term creep test results have up to now been collected and stored by specialist companies (boiler makers, turbine manufacturers, large furnace and reactor builders) rather than the material producers, negotiations to find a PED-conforming compromise are often very difficult. Even the specialist companies are often unable to provide experimental results for materials after complex forming and heat-treating operations (shapes, fittings, repaired castings, etc) or on welds after unusual heat treatments (for instance welds subjected to more than three post-weld heat treatments owing to repair or close assembly to manufacturing welds). As a consequence, the creep strength values of EN standards tend to become mandatory values in engineering companies’ specifications, sometimes lowered by a percentage apparently accounting for the usual ±20% scatter band in stress on rupture strength values. In most typical situations, where the material, component, fitting, spool or vessel manufacturer cannot comply with pre-existing data, ‘qualification’ creep test rows are requested, which, owing to the short time frame and the belief that ‘time–temperature parameter based’ extrapolations are safe, are generally reduced to a few tests below 1000 h, then grandly extrapolated to the required 200 000 h strengths. Validation procedures, like ECCC’s PATs (Reference 20: Vol 5), are generally unknown and not applied.
3.5.6
Residual life assessment
Residual life assessment, that is, activities to decide whether a given plant can be used beyond its original design life, is generally led by in-service inspection procedures, dictated by national rules and/or by more advanced systems like RBI (risk based inspection). Nevertheless, some national regulations require that design reviews are also conducted, during which past as well as future service is checked against the most credible available
WPNL2204
150
Creep-resistant steels
creep strength values. This requires on the one side sound assessment procedures, because residual life assessment tends to ask for very long durations, longer than available and possible tests, and on the other side the refined strength values published in the various documentation for the standards. Some guidelines on how to handle these particular needs were laid down in Reference 20, Vol 5 and are assessed in the CEN WorkShop Agreements 22 (FITNET – European Procedure for Fitness for Service) and 24 (Risk Based Inspection and Maintenance Procedures – RIMAP) and in the new Italian standard for residual life assessment, UNI 11096: 2004.
3.6
Future trends
The new concept of CEN standards, including creep strength values, and the new ECCC strength assessment procedure were a first step towards improving the reliability of creep strength and design values. Nevertheless, a huge amount of work is still to be done: •
• •
• •
•
New materials are continuously offered by leading companies with metallurgical skills, for instance the new 9–12%Cr steels and the new low-alloyed steels of 2.25%Cr type, as well as many new austenitic and nickel base grades. These materials need big duration tests and thorough assessment, but, since industrial users never have the time to wait for these results to come through, credible creep strength reference values at least are needed as soon as possible. The prescriptions of EN 12952-2 and ECCC (Reference 20: Vol 5 part I), along with the data requirements according to Table 3.3, make it clear that testing has to be taken further. Reliable assessments are only possible with very large, or at least strategically planned, Europe-wide coordinated test campaigns. ECCC and other bodies have also identified large gaps in the understanding of creep behaviour and data availability in consolidated materials, which urgently need to be filled. Some materials, obsolete or no longer used for their original applications, may suddenly find new users or applications (for instance alloy 617 for piping and forgings), so that data previously disregarded become relevant again and may need to be up-dated. Cast steel grades in general, with the exception of the 9–12%Cr steels, have not been a priority for assessment. A very particular area, mainly the concern of refineries and petrochemical plants, are the cast austenitic high-alloyed steels (i.e. G-X40CrNi25 20 or G-X40NiCr35 25, partially included in EN 10295) and their modifications based on mixtures of Co, W and Nb. These have not yet been considered in detail. CEN will review all standards on a five-to-ten year basis, so that creep strength values will be updated and upgraded in the light of on-going
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
151
tests and new high-priority materials (for instance grades 23 (10 CrWMoNbB 9 6), 24 (10 CrMoVTiB 10 10), 92 (X 10 CrWMoVNb 9 2), 911 (X 19 CrWMoVNb9 1 1), 709 (X 6 NiCrMoTiBN 25 20), etc). Some changes and refinements, particularly for those grades assessed without fully representative data sets or under reduced testing times (for instance grade 91, X 9 CrMoVNNb 9 1) will need to be upgraded in the published strength values. Besides the specifically material-related issues, there are other topics that will require strong collaboration between material specialists and designers, such as how to handle strength values of extended extrapolation, how to include time-dependent weld creep strength reduction factors, and so on. There is also an urgent need to harmonise the PED interpretation of creep handling in pressure vessel design, which, owing partly to a somewhat vague formulation, has led to radically different interpretations among the notified bodies. Agreement and reciprocal understanding is also desirable between the mandatory European PED and the forthcoming very advanced voluntary design codes (EN 13445, etc) and the well-established ASME, API and Japanese codes. Finally a few basic issues should also be addressed, including how to extrapolate from data sets of limited size or duration in the most reliable way and how to consider scatter or probabilistic effects for creep strength data assessments. These should be addressed by more basic research projects. In the past, Europe has shown that, despite the inherent difficulties, collaboration between different technical schools of thinking is possible and can lead to outstanding results. The next step is to include non-Europeans and to enlarge the multi-disciplinarity of the interacting specialists.
3.7
References
1 French, Tucker ‘Flow in a low-carbon steel at various temperatures’ NIST report T296, 1925; (re-published by Geil and Carwile, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) RP2329, 1952). 2 Pomp A. and Dahmen A., ‘Entwicklung eines abgekürzten Prüfverfahrens zur Ermittlung der Dauerstandfestigkeit von Stahl bei erhöhten Temperaturen’, Mitteilung a. d. Kaiser-Wilhelm-Institut für Eisenforschung zu Düsseldorf, Abhandlung 72–95 IX Band (1927), 33–52. 3 Parravano N. and Guzzoni G., ‘Prove statiche delle leghe ultraleggere’, La Metallurgia Italiana, 1930, XXII, 367 ff. 4 DIN 50 112 (DVM-Creep Test), ca. 1930. 5 German Iron and Steel Society (VDEh), Ergebnisse deutscher Standzeitversuche langer Dauer, in collaboration with the German Creep Resistant Steel Committee (AGW) and the Committee for High Temperature Engineering Materials, Verlag Eisen und Stahl, Düsseldorf, 1969.
WPNL2204
152
Creep-resistant steels
6 Former CECA/ECSC (European Carbon and Steel Collaboration): http:// cordis.europa.eu/ecsc-coal/home.html, and actual http://cordis.europa.eu/coal-steelrtd 7 COST website: www.cost.esf.org 8 Information on EC programme Joule–Thermie: http://erg.ucd.ie/ttp.html 9 Official PED-site http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/pressure_equipment/ped/index_en.html 10 European Standardisation Body: www.cenorm.be 11 European Committee for Iron and Steel Standardization ECISS: http://www.cenorm.be/ cenorm/aboutus/structure+/relations/workprogrammeeciss.asp 12 European Collaborative Creep Committee website: www.etd1.co.uk/eccc/ advancedcreep 13 EC funded Brite Euram Concerted Action, Creep –BE-5524, 1992–1996. 14 EC funded Thematic Network, BET2-0509 - Weldcreep, 1997–2001. 15 EC funded Framework V Thematic Network GTC2-2000-33051 Advanced Creep, 2001–2005. 16 EC funded Standard–Measurement and Testing Project MAT1-CT-940065, Development and Validation of a Code of Practice for a Low Cost Method of Strain Measurement from Interrupted Creep Testing, 1994–1998. 17 EC funded Standard–Measurement and Testing Project MAT1-CT-940078, Development of Standard European Methodology for Stress Relaxation Testing of Metals, 1994–1998. 18 International Conference on Creep & Fracture in High Temperature Components – Design and Life Assessment Issues, organized by ECCC, September 12–14, London, 2005. 19 ECCC Recommendations 1994, ERA Technology Ltd, Leatherhead. Volume 1 (issue 1) 1994: Creep Data Validation and Assessment Procedures – Overview, Holdsworth S.R. (ed.). Volume 2 (issue 2) 1994: Terms and Terminology for use with Stress Rupture, Creep and Stress Relaxation: Testing, Data Collation and Assessment, Orr J. (ed.). Volume 3 (issue 2) 1994: Recommendations for Data Acceptability Criteria for Creep, Creep Rupture, Stress Rupture and Stress Relaxation Data, Holdsworth S.R. and Granacher J. (eds). Volume 4 (issue 1) 1994: Guidance for the Exchange and Collation of Creep Rupture, Creep Strain–Time and Stress Relaxation Data for Assessment Purposes, Merckling G. & Bullough C.K. (eds). Volume 5 (issue 1) 1995: Guidance for the Assessment of Creep Rupture, Creep Strain snd Relaxation Data, Holdsworth S.R. (ed.). 20 ECCC Recommendations 2005, ETD Ltd, Leatherhead. Volume 1 (issue 6) 2005: Creep Data Validation and Assessment Procedures – Overview, Holdsworth S.R. (ed.). Volume 2, 2005: Terms and Terminology for use with Stress Rupture, Creep, Stress Relaxation, Creep Crack Initiation and Multi-Axial Creep: Testing, Data Collation and Assessment, Morris P., Orr J., Servetto C., Seliger P., Holdsworth S.R. and Brown T.B. (eds). (a) part I (issue 8): Parent Material, (b) part Iia (issue 2): Welding Processes and Weld Configurations, (c) part Iib (issue 2): Weld Creep Testing, (d) part III (issue 4): Post Exposure Material, (e) part IV (issue 2): Generation and assessment of creep crack initiation data, (f) part V (issue 1): Generation and assessment of multi-axial feature specimen and component data. Volume 3, 2005: Recommendations for Data Acceptability Criteria and Generation for Creep, Creep Rupture, Stress Rupture, Stress Relaxation, Creep Crack Initiation and Multi-Axial Creep Data, Holdsworth S.R., Granacher J., Klenk A., Buchmayr B., Gariboldi E., Brett S., Merckling G., Müller F., Gengenbach T., Dean D. and Brown T.B. (eds). (a)
WPNL2204
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Europe
21
22
23 24 25 26 27 28
29
30
153
part I (Issue 5): Generic recommendations , (b) part II (issue 3): Creep data for welds, (c) part III (issue 4): Creep testing of post exposure (ex-service) material, (d) part IV (issue 2): Creep crack initiation, (e) part V (issue 1): Multi-axial feature specimen and component test data. Volume 4, 2005: Guidance for the Exchange and Collation of Creep Rupture, Creep Strain–Time, Stress Relaxation, Creep Crack Initiation and Multi-Axial Creep Test Data for Assessment Purposes, Merckling G., Calvano F., Bullough C.K., Holdsworth S.R. and Tonti A. (eds). (a) part I (issue 6): Creep rupture, strain–time and relaxation data; (b) part II (issue 1) Creep crack initiation, (c) part III (tba); (d) part IV (issue 1): Creesty user manual. Volume 5, 2005, Guidance for the Assessment of Creep Rupture, Creep Strain and Stress Relaxation Data, Holdsworth S.R. and Merckling G., (eds). (a) Part Ia (issue 5): Full-size creep rupture data sets datasets, (b) Part Ib (issue 2): Creep strain and creep strength data, (c) Part Ic (issue 2): Full-size stress relaxation datasets, (d) Part Iia (issue 1): Sub-size datasets, (e) Part Iib (issue 1): Weld creep rupture datasets, (f) Part III (issue 2): Post exposure (ex-service) creep data. Volume 6, 2005 (issue 1): Residual Life Assessment and Microstructure, Concari S. (ed.). Volume 9, 2005: High Temperature Component Analysis, Patel R. (ed.). (a) part II (issue 1) Overview of assessment & design procedures, (b) part III (issue 1): Database of component tests and assessments. Holdsworth S.R., Orr J., Granacher J., Merckling G. and Bullogh C.K. on behalf of the ECCC-WG1, ‘European Creep Collaborative Committee activities on creep data generation and assessment methodologies’ in Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, D. Coutsouradis, F. Schubert, D.V. Thornton and J.H. Davidson (eds), Liege, 3–6 October 1994, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1994, 591–600. Merckling G. and Holdsworth S.R., ‘Long term creep rupture strength assessment: the development of the European Collaborative Creep Committee Post assessment tests’ , International Conference on Creep & Fracture in High Temperature Components – Design and Life Assessment Issues, September 12–14, London, 2005. ECCC Data Sheets, issue 1996. ERA Technology Publishers, 1996. ECCC Data Sheets, issue 2005. European Technology Development Publishers, 2005 European Pressure Equipment Research Council Web Site: www.mpa-lifetech.de/ eperctp/ EC-funded Thematic Network and CEN Workshop 11 “UNCERT-AM”: http:// www.mpa-lifetech.de/UNCERT-AM/HTML_Files/Main/UNCERTDefault.htm Morris P. and Granacher J., ECCC-Information Day, European Technology Development Ltd, Prague, 2001. Scholz A., Schwienheer M. and Morris P.F., ‘European notched testpiece for creep rupture testing’, in: Proceedings of the 21st Symposium of the German Iron & Steel Institute (VDEh) & German Society for Material Testing (DVM), Herausforderung durch den Industriellen Fortschritt, 4–5 December 2003, Buchholz W.O. and Geisler S. (eds), Bad Neuenahr, Verlag Stahleisen, Düsseldorf, 2003, 308–314. Webster G.A., Holdsworth S.R., Loveday M.S., Perrin I.J. and Purper H., A Code of Practice for Conducting Notched Bar Creep Rupture Test and the Interpretation of the Data, ESIS TC11, 1999. Webster G.A., Holdsworth S.R., Loveday M.S., Nikbin K., Perrin I.J., Purper H., Skelton R.P. and Spindler M.W., ‘A code of practice for conducting notched bar creep tests and for interpreting the data, issue 3’, Fatigue and Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures, 2004, 27 (4), 319–342.
WPNL2204
154
Creep-resistant steels
31 Matteoli L. and Andreini, B., ‘Le prove di scorimento interrotte. Influenza delle interruzioni di sollecitazione e di riscaldamento sulle proprietà di scorrimento’, La Metallurgia Italiana, 1947, XXXIX, 41. 32 Granacher J., Oehl M. and Preußler T., ‘Comparison of interrupted and uninterupted creep rupture test’, Steel Research, 1992, 63, 39–45. 33 Granacher J. and Scholz J., ‘Über die langzeitige Temperaturgenauigkeit von Zeitstandsprüfanlagen’, Materialprüf., 1973, 15, 116–123. 34 McCarthy P. and Loveday M.S. (eds), Proceeding of the Seminar on the Practicalities of Thermocouple Calibration and the Usage for Materials Testing, High Temperature Mechanical Testing Committee HTMTC, 16th December 1996. 35 Regis V., Livraghi M. and Di Pasquantonio F. Invecchiamento dei materiali per scorrimento viscoso, ENEL-CRTN, 1972. 36 Prager M., ‘Development of the MPC omega method for life assessment in the creep range’, J. Pressure Vessel. Technology, 1995, 117, 95. 37 How I.M., Browne R.J., Coleman M.C., Craig I.H., Ham M.W., Hurst R.C. and Meecham P.C., ‘A code of practice for internal pressure testing of tubular components at elevated temperatures’, in Proceedings of the HTMTC Symposium on Harmonised Testing Practice for High Temperature Materials, Loveday M.S. and Gibbons T.B. (eds), Ispra, Italy 18–19 October 1990, 363–400. 38 Rees D.W.A., Brown M.W., Hyde T., Lohn R.D., Morrison C.J. and Shammas M., ‘A code of practice for torsional creep testing of tubular testpieces at elevated temperatures’, in Proceedings of the HTMTC Symposium on Harmonised Testing Practice for High Temperature Materials, Loveday M.S. and Gibbons T.B. (eds), Ispra, Italy, 18–19 Octobers 1990, 331–361. 39 SEP 1260, Relaxationsversuch bei erhöhter Temperatur mit Schraubenverbindungsmodellen, VDEh, 1996.
WPNL2204
4 Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan F . M A S U YA M A, Kyushu Institute of Technology, Japan
4.1
Introduction
Creep-resistant steels have been widely used in structural components and machinery operated under high temperature and high pressure. There are many different types of heat-resistant steels, as the properties required vary according to application and these properties can generally be categorized into physical, chemical, mechanical, manufacturability and economical aspects. Chemical composition influences physical and chemical properties such as thermal conductivity, thermal expansion and high temperature corrosion/ oxidation resistance. Mechanical properties, including hardness, tensile, impact, creep and fatigue properties, depend on microstructures formed by heattreatment and chemical composition. The general specifications for heatresistant steels in Japan established JIS (Japanese Industrial Standards)1 and in METI (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry)2 Codes and JSME (Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers)3 Codes for power applications. This section reviews the status of specifications for heat-resistant steels in Japanese codes and standards.
4.2
Types of heat-resistant steels in Japan
Table 4.1 lists heat-resistant steels (SUH) and stainless steels (SUS) in JIS G4311 and G4312 for use under high temperature conditions, indicating their applications as well. In the case of ferritic steels, cooling in air from the annealing temperature of 780–880°C is necessary, since slow cooling at around 600°C causes material embrittlement owing to sigma phase precipitation. These steels can be used for heater boxes, burners and heater equipment operated up to 1100°C in air and gas containing sulphur. Martensitic steels are annealed in the temperature range of about 800–900°C, slow cooled at about 1000–1100°C, oil quenched and tempered at about 650–800°C, and then subjected to rapid cooling or air cooling. These steels are used for high temperature intake valves or turbine blades, applications that utilize their 155 WPNL2204
156
Table 4.1 Heat-resistant steels in JIS
Martensitic
Precipitation hardening Austenitic
Nominal composition (equivalent)
Applications
SUH 21 SUH 409 SUH 446 SUS 405 SUS 430 SUH 1 SUH 3 SUH 4 SUH 11 SUH 600 SUH 616 SUS 403 SUS 410 SUS 410J1 SUS 420J1 SUS 420J2 SUS 431 SUS 440A SUS 440B SUS 440C SUS 630 SUS 631 SUH 31 SUH 35 SUH 36 SUH 37
19Cr–3Al (18SR, JIS FCH2) 11Cr–Ti 25Cr–N–0.4C 13Cr–0.2Al–0.06C 18Cr-0.1C 9Cr–3Si–0.4C 11Cr–2Si–1Mo–0.4C 20Cr–1.5Ni–2Si–0.8C 9Cr–1.5Si–0.5 12Cr–0.6Mo–0.3V–0.5Nb–N–0.15C (H46) 12Cr–1Mo–1W–0.25C AlSl 422) 13Cr–low Si–0.1C 13Cr–0.5Mo–0.1C 13Cr–Mo–0.15C 13Cr–0.2C 13Cr–0.4C 16Cr–2Ni–0.15C 18Cr–0.5Mo–0.7C 18Cr–0.5Mo–0.85C 18Cr–0.5Mo–1C 17Cr–4Ni–4Cu–Nb–0.05 (17–4PH) 17Cr–7Ni–1Al–0.07C (17–7PH) 15Cr–14Ni–2Si–2.5W–0.4C 21Cr–4Ni–9Mn–0.45N–0.5C (21–4N) 21Cr–4Ni–9Mn–0.45N–0.5C–high S (21–4N) 21Cr–11Ni–0.25N–0.2N (21–11N)
SUH 38
20Cr–11Ni–2.3Mo–0.2P–0.3C–B (20–11P)
Heater, automobile exhaust gas cleaner Automobile exhaust gas cleaner, muffler Combustion chamber Combustion turbine compressor blade Furnace, bumer parts up to 900°C Diesel engine intake valve Valve, pre-combustion charier Inhale/exhaust valve, abrasion resistant parts Gas/diesel engine intake valve up to 750°C Steam turbine blade, disk, rotor, bolt Steam turbine blade, disk, rotor, bolt Steam turbine blade, nozzle High temperature oxidation resistant parts up to 800°C Steam turbine blade, high temp./press. components Steam turbine blade, valve stem, nozzle, pump shaft Piston ring, fuel injection nozzle, seat ring Shaft, bolt, spring Valve parts, ball valve Bearing, roller, valve parts Bearing, abrasion resistant parts Steam/combustion turbine blade High temp. spring, bellows Gas/diesel engine exhaust valve up to 1150°C Gas/diesel engine exhaust valve with high strength Gas/diesel engine exhaust valve with high strength Gas/diesel engine exhaust valve with oxidation resistance Gas/diesel engine exhaust valve, bolt
WPNL2204
Creep-resistant steels
Ferritic
Designation
SUH SUH SUH SUH SUH
309 310 330 660 661
SUS 304
22Cr–12Ni–0.2C 25Cr–20Ni–0.2C 15Cr–35Ni–0.1C 15Cr–25Ni–1.5Mo–0.5V–2Ti–Al–B (A286) 22Cr–20Ni–20Co–3Mo–2.5W–Nb–0.15N (LCN155) 18Cr–8Ni
SUS 309S SUS 310S SUS 316 SUS 317 SUS 321 SUS 347 SUSXM15J1
22Cr–12Ni–0.06C 25Cr–20Ni–0.06C 18Cr–12Ni–2.5Mo–0.06C 18Cr–12Ni–3.5Mo–0.06C 18Cr–8Ni–Ti–0.06C 18Cr–8Ni–Nb–0.06C 18Cr–13Ni–4Si (ASTM XM15)
Furnace, burner cyclically operated up to 980°C Furnace, burner cyclically operated up to 1035°C Furnace, oil cracking equipment Turbine rotor, bolt, shaft up to 700°C Turbine rotor, bolt, blade, shaft up to 750°C Cyclic heating equipment with oxidation resistance up to 870°C Furnace parts cyclically operated up to 980°C Furnace, automobile exhaust gas cleaner up to 1035°C Heat exchanger with high creep strength heat exchanger with high creep strength Welded parts for corrosion-resistant use at 400–900°C Parts for corrosion resistant use at 400–900°C Automobile exhaust gas cleaner
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
Austenitic
157
WPNL2204
158
Creep-resistant steels
superior oxidation-resistant and/or creep-resistant properties. Austenitic heatresistant steels listed in JIS G4311 and G4312 are for furnace equipment, heat exchangers and chemical plants taking advantage of their superior high temperature corrosion/oxidation resistance and creep resistance. Except for SUH35 to 38 and SUH660/661, which need to be age-hardened, austenitic steels are used as-solution annealed at about 1030–1200°C, followed by rapid cooling. For the aforementioned exceptional steels, aging treatments are applied at about 700–800°C after solution annealing.
4.3
Specifications for high temperature tubing and piping steels
Table 4.2 shows JIS and METI Code Specifications for high temperature tubing and piping steels. These tables include steel designation in the JIS and METI Code, minimum tensile and yield strengths, heat treatment conditions and application components in power boilers. However, several of these steels are not actually used in power boilers despite being listed in the codes and standards. The maximum usage temperature is determined by the designer, but the allowable stresses are listed in the METI Code up to the temperature indicated in the code for individual steels. The criteria for allowable stresses in the creep temperature range in the METI Code are stated as follows. The allowable tensile stress in the creep temperature range shall not exceed the minimum values given below: 1 2 3
average value of the stress by which creep rate of 0.01%/1000 h occurs at the relevant temperature; 67% of the average value of the stress by which rupture takes place in 100 000 h at the relevant temperature; 80% of the minimum value of the stress by which rupture takes place in 100 000 h at the relevant temperature.
On the other hand, the JSME Code recently changed the above criteria (2), substituting 67% with 100Favg% in accordance with the ASME criteria, where Favg is a multiplier applied to average stress for rupture in 100 000 h. At 815°C and below, Favg is 0.67. Above 815°C, it is determined from the slope of the log time-to-rupture versus log stress plot at 100 000 h, such that log Favg = 1/n, but it may not exceed 0.67. n is a negative number equal to δ log time-to-rupture divided by δ log stress at 100 000 h. METI Code materials are defined as KA-XXXX, with XXXX, taking on a JIS-like designation that has not yet been integrated into JIS and indicating power applications only. However, new steels recently developed in Japan for power boiler applications, such as high strength ferritic steels and austenitic steels, are included in the METI Code with the symbol ‘J’ followed by the development number in the designation. Tables 4.3 and 4.4 show the chemical compositions
WPNL2204
Table 4.2 JIS and METI Code specification for high temperature tubing and piping materials
KA-STB480
C-Steel
480
275
Ann. or nor.
Alloy steel tube for boiler & heat exchanger
STBA12
0.5Mo
380
205
STBA13 STBA20
0.5Mo 0.5Cr, 0.5Mo
410 410
205 205
STBA22
1Cr, 0.5Mo
410
205
STBA23
1.25Cr, 0.5Mo
410
205
Low temp. ann. isothermal ann., full ann. Nor. or nor. + temper Low Temp. ann. Iso-thermal ann. Full ann. or nor. + temper iso-thermal ann. full ann. or nor. + temper
STBA24 STBA25 STBA26
2.25Cr, 1Mo 5Cr, 0.5Mo 9Cr, 1Mo
410 410 410
205 205 205
JIS G 3462 (1988)
WPNL2204
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
Steam pipe
✓ ✓
159
C-steel tube for power METI Code
✓ ✓ ✓
SH/Rh header
No specification
Reheater
175 255 295
Superheater
340 410 510
Connect pipe
C-Steel C-Steel C-Steel
Applications
Header
Min. Heat treatment yield (MPa) Water wall
Min. tensile (MPa)
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
Part I C-steel tube for STB340 boiler & heat STB410 exchanger STB510 JIS G 3461 (1988)
Nominal composition (mass%)
Economizer
Designation
160
Table 4.2 Cont’d
2.25Cr, 1.6W 9Cr, 2Mo
510 510
400 295
KA-STBA28
9Cr, 1Mo, Nb, V
590
410
KA-STBA29
9Cr, 1.8W
620
440
SUS304TB SUS304HTB SUS304LTB SUS309TB SUS310TB SUS316TB SUS316HTB SUS316LTB SUS321TB
18Cr, 18Cr, 18Cr, 23Cr, 25Cr, 16Cr, 16Cr, 16Cr, 18Cr,
520 520 480 520 520 520 520 480 520
205 205 175 205 205 205 205 175 205
Part II Stainless steel tube for boiler & heat exchanger JIS G 3463 (1994)
8Ni 8Ni 8Ni, Low C 12Ni 20Ni 12Ni, 2Mo 12Ni, 2Mo 12Ni, 2Mo, Low C 10Ni, Ti
WPNL2204
1010°C 1040°C 1010°C 1030°C 1030°C 1010°C 1040°C 1010°C 920°C
Steam pipe
KA-STBA24J1 KA-STBA27
Nor. Ann. or nor. + temper Ann. or nor. + temper at min. 650°C Nor. + temper Nor. at min. 900°C+ temper at min. 700°C Nor. at min. 1040°C+ temper at min. 730°C Nor. at min. 1040°C+ temper et min. 730°C
SH/Rh header
255 205 205
Reheater
410 410 410
Superheater
1.25Cr, 0.3Cu 1Cr, 0.3Mo 2.25Cr, 1Mo
✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
Connect pipe
Alloy steel tube KA-STBA10 for power boiler KA-STBA21 METI Code KA-STBA24EG
Applications
Header
Min. Heat treatment yield (MPa) Economizer
Min. tensile (MPa)
Creep-resistant steels
Nominal composition (mass%)
Water wall
Designation
✓
✓
590 690 590 690
235 345 245 345
1040°C 1050°C 1050°C 1050°C
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
590 660 640 650
235 295 270 295
1120°C 1030°C 1100°C 1030°C
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
520
205
1100°C
✓
✓
520
205
SUS347TB SUS347HTB
18Cr, 10Ni, Nb 18Cr, 10Ni, Nb
520 520
205 205
SUS410TB SUS430TB
13Cr 16Cr
410 410
KA-SUS304J1HTB 18Cr, 9Ni, 3Cu, Nb, N KA-SUS309J1TB 24Cr, 15Ni, 1Mo, N KA-SUS309J2TB 22Cr, 14Ni, 1.5Mo, N KA-SUS309J3LTB 25Cr, 14Ni, 0.8Mo, N, 0.2Si KA-SUS309J4HTB 22Cr, 15Ni, Nb KA-SUS310J1TB 25Cr, 20Ni, Nb, V KA-SUS310J2TB 20Cr, 25Ni, 1.5Mo KA-SUS310J3TB 22.5Cr, 18.5Ni, 1.8W, 3Cu, 0.45Nb, 0.2N KA-SUS321J1HTB 18Cr, 10Ni, Ti, Nb
WPNL2204
161
✓
18Cr, 10Ni, Ti
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
Part III Stainless steel tube for power boiler METI Code
✓
205 245
1095°C for cold finished, 1050°C for hot finished 980°C 1095°C for cold finished, 1050°C for hot finished 700°C AC or FC 700°C AC or FC
SUS321HTB
162
Table 4.2 Continued Min. tensile (MPa)
Min. Heat treatment yield (MPa)
Superheater
Reheater
10Ni, 3Cu, Nb,
500
205
1160°C
✓
✓
10Ni, Nb 9Ni, V, W, Nb, N 1Mo, W, V, Nb 2W, 0.4Mo, V, Nb 2W, 0.4Mo, V, Nb
520 650 590 620 620
205 270 390 400 400
1150°C 1100°C Nor. + temper Nor. + temper Nor. + temper
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
C-steel C-steel C-steel
370 410 480
215 245 275
As rolled for hot finished low temp. ann. or nor. for cold finished
✓ ✓ ✓
✓ ✓ ✓
Part IV Alloy steel piping
STPA12
0.5Mo
380
205
✓
✓
STPA20
0.5Cr, 0.5Mo
410
205
✓
✓
STPA22 STPA23 STPA24
1Cr, 0.5Mo 1.25Cr, 0.5Mo 2.25Cr, 1Mo
410 410 410
205 205 205
Low temp. ann. isothermal ann. full ann. nor. or nor. + temper low temp. ann. isothermal ann. full ann. or nor. + temper Iso-thermal ann. full ann. or nor. + temper
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
JIS G 3458 (1988)
WPNL2204
Steam pipe
Connect pipe
Header
C-steel for high STPT370 temp. pipe JIS STPT410 G3456 (1988) STPT480
SH/Rh Header
KA-SUS321J2HTB 18Cr, Ti, B, N KA-SUSTP347HTB 18Cr, KA-SUS347J1TB 18Cr, KA-SUS410J2TB 12Cr, KA-SUS410J3TB 11Cr, KA-SUS410J3DTB 12Cr,
Water wall
Applications
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
Creep-resistant steels
Nominal composition (mass%)
Economizer
Designation
Part V Stainless steel piping JIS G 3459(1997)
5Cr, 0.5Mo 9Cr, 1Mo
410 410
205 205
KA-STPA21 KA-STPA24J1 KA-STPA27
1Cr, 0.3Mo 2.25Cr, 1.6W 9Cr, 2Mo
410 510 510
205 400 295
KA-STPA28
9Cr, 1Mo, Nb, V
590
410
KA-STPA29
9Cr, 1.8W
620
410
SUS304TP SUS304HTP SUS304LTP SUS309TP SUS310TP SUS316TP SUS316HTP SUS316LTP SUS321TP SUS321HTP
18Cr, 18Cr, 18Cr, 23Cr, 25Cr, 16Cr, 16Cr, 16Cr, 18Cr, 18Cr,
520 520 480 520 520 520 520 480 520 520
205 205 175 205 205 205 205 175 205 205
8Ni 8Ni 8Ni, Low C 12Ni 20Ni 12Ni, 2Mo 12Ni, 2Mo 12Ni, 2Mo, Low C 10Ni, Ti 10Ni, Nb
1010°C 1040°C 1010°C 1030°C 1030°C 1010°C 1040°C 1010°C 920°C 1095°C for cold finished, 1050°C for hot finished
✓
✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
163
WPNL2204
Ann. or Nor. + Temper Nor. + Temper Nor. at min. 900°C + temper at min. 700°C Nor. at min. 1040°C + temper at min. 730°C Nor. at min. 1040°C + temper at min. 730°C
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
Alloy steel power piping METI code
STPA25 STPA26
164
980°C 1095°C for cold finished, 1050°C for hot finished
Stainless steel power piping
KA-SUS410J3TP
11Cr, 2W, 0.4Mo, V, Nb
620
400
Nor. + temper
Ann = annealing, Nor = normalizing, Temper = tempering, AC = air cooling, FC = furnace cooling.
WPNL2204
Steam pipe
205 205
SH/Rh header
520 520
Reheater
18Cr, 10Ni, Nb 18Cr, 10Ni, Nb
Superheater
SUS347TP SUS347HTP
Applications Connect pipe
Min. Heat treatment yield (MPa) Header
Min. tensile (MPa)
Water wall
Nominal composition (mass%)
Economizer
Designation
✓
✓
Creep-resistant steels
Table 4.2 Continued
Table 4.3 Chemical compositions for ferritic boiler tubing steels Steels
Chemical composition (mass%) C
KA-STB510
≤ 0.25
≤ 0.35
KA-STB480
≤ 0.30
≤ 0.10
KA-STBA10
≤ 0.10
STBA12
STBA23
0.10 ~0.20 0.10 ~0.20 ≤ 0.15
0.20 ~0.80 0.10 ~0.50 ≤ 0.50
STBA24
≤ 0.15
0.50 ~1.00 ≤ 0.50
KA-STBA24E-G
≤ 0.15
≤ 0.50
0.04 ~0.10
≤ 0.50
STBA26
≤ 0.15
KA-STBA27
≤ 0.08
0.25 ~ 1.00 ≤ 0.50
KA-STBA28
0.08 ~0.12
KA-STBA21
KA-STBA24J1
9Cr
0.20~ 0.50
P
S
Ni
Cr
Mo
V
Nb
Al
N
W
B
0.30 ~0.80 1.00 ~1.50 0.29 ~1.06
≤ 0.035
≤ 0.035
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.035
≤ 0.035
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.048
≤ 0.058
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.80
≤ 0.025
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
0.30 ~0.80 0.30 ~0.60 0.30 ~0.60 0.30 ~0.60 0.30 ~0.60 0.10 ~0.60
≤ 0.035
0.015 ~0.030 ≤ 0.035
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.035
≤ 0.035
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.010
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
≤ 0.020
≤ 0.010
≤ 0.40
0.30 ~0.60 0.30 ~0.70 0.30 ~0.60
1.00 ~1.50 – 1.90 ~2.60 1.00 ~1.50 1.90 ~2.60 1.90 ~2.60 1.90 ~2.60
0.45 – ~0.65 0.87 ~ – 1.13 0.45 – ~0.65 0.87 – ~1.18 0.87 – ~1.18 0.05 0.20 ~0.30 ~0.30
8.00 ~10.00 8.00 ~10.00 8.00 ~9.50
0.90 – ~1.10 1.80 ~ – 2.20 0.85 ~ 0.18 1.05 ~0.25
WPNL2204
0.02 ~0.08
≤0.03
≤0.03
1.45 ~ 1.75
0.0006
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
0.06 ~0.10
≤0.04
0.030 ~0.070
165
≤ 0.35
Mn
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
≤ 0.32
C–Steel STB410
Low alloy steel
Si
166
Steels
Chemical composition (mass%) C
Mn
P
S
Ni
Cr
Mo
V
Nb
Al
N
W
B
0.030 ~0.070
1.50 ~2.00
0.001 ~0.005
0.07 ~0.13
≤ 0.50
0.30 ~0.60
≤ 0.020
≤ 0.010
≤ 0.40
8.00 ~9.50
0.03 ~ 0.60
0.15 ~0.25
0.04 ~0.09
≤0.04
KA-SUS410J2TB
≤ 0.14
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.030
–
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.020
≤ 0.010
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.70
≤ 0.020
≤ 0.010
≤ 0.50
0.20 ~0.30 0.15 ~0.30 0.15 ~0.30
0.04 ~0.10 0.04 ~0.10
≤0.04
≤ 0.50
0.80 ~1.20 0.25 ~0.60 0.25 ~0.60
≤0.04
0.07 ~0.14 0.07 ~0.14
11.00 ~13.00 10.00 ~11.50 11.51 ~ 12.50
≤0.20
KA-SUS410J3TB
0.30 ~0.70 ≤ 0.70
KA-STBA29
12Cr
Si
KASUS410J3DTB
WPNL2204
≤0.04
– 0.040 ~0.100 0.040 0.100
0.80 ~1.20 1.50 ~2.50 ~1.50 ~2.50
– 0.0005 ~0.005 0.0005 ~0.005
Creep-resistant steels
Table 4.3 Continued
Table 4.4 Chemical compositions for austenitic boiler tubing steels Steels
Chemical composition (mass%) C
SUS304HTB
~0.10 0.04 ~0.10 SUS347HTB 0.04 ~0.10 KA–SUS304J1HTB 0.07 ~0.13 KA–SUS309J1TB ≤ 0.06 SUS316HTB
Mn
P
S
KA–SUS309J4HTB
8.00 18.00 ~11.00 ~20.00 ≤0.75 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.030 9.00 17.00
≤0.75 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.030 ≤1.00 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.030 ≤0.30 ≤ 1.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.010 ≤1.50 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.030
≤ 0.04
≤1.00 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.030 ≤1.50 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.030
KA–SUS310J2TB
≤ 0.10
≤1.00 ≤ 1.50 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.010
0.05 ~0.12 KA–SUS321J1HTB 0.07 ~0.14
≤1.50 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.010 ≤1.00 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.030
~13.00 11.00 ~14.00 9.00 ~13.00 7.50 ~10.50 12.00 ~16.00 12.50 ~15.50 13.00 ~16.00 14.50 ~16.50 17.00 ~23.00 22.00 ~28.00 15.00 ~22.00 9.00 ~12.00
~20.00 16.00 ~18.00 17.00 ~20.00 17.00 ~19.00 23.00 ~26.00 21.00 ~23.00 23.00 ~26.00 21.00 ~23.00 23.00 ~27.00 19.00 ~23.00 21.00 ~24.00 17.50 ~19.50
Mo
V
Nb Al
N
Cu
W
B
Others
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Ta: 4 × C ~ 0.60
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Nb+Ta: 8 × C ~1.00 –
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.20
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 0.20
–
0.50 ~0.80 0.20 ~0.60 0.10 ~0.40 0.30 ~0.60 ≤ 0.40
2.00 ~3.00 – – 0.50 ~1.20 1.00 ~2.00 0.50 ~1.20 – – 1.00 ~2.00 – –
WPNL2204
0.30 ~0.60 –
0.05 ~0.12 0.25 ~0.40 0.10 ~0.25 0.25 ~0.40 0.10 ~0.20 0.15 ~0.35 0.10 ~0.25 0.15 ~0.30 –
2.50 ~3.50 –
≤ 0.006 –
0.002 ~0.010 2.00 0.80 – ~4.00 ~2.80 – – –
– – – – (Ti+Nb/2)C 2.0~4.0
167
KA–SUS310J1TB
0.03 ~0.10 ≤ 0.10
KA–SUS310J3TB
Cr
≤0.75 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.030
≤1.00 2.50 ≤0.030 ≤ 0.030 ~3.50 KA–SUS309J3LTB ≤ 0.025 ≤0.70 ≤ 2.00 ≤0.040 ≤ 0.030 KA–SUS309J2TB
Ni
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
SUS321HTB
0.04 ~0.10 0.04
Si
168
Steels
Chemical composition (mass%) C
KA–SUS321J2HTB
0.07 ~0.14 KA–SUS3TP347HTB 0.04 ~0.10 KA–SUS347J1TB ≤ 0.05
Si
Mn
P
≤ 1.00
≤ 2.00
≤0.040 ≤ 0.010
≤ 0.75
≤ 2.00
≤0.030 ≤ 0.030
≤ 1.00
≤ 2.00
≤0.040 ≤ 0.030
S
Ni
Cr
9.00 17.50 ~12.00 ~19.50 9.00 17.00 ~13.00 ~20.00 8.00 17.00 ~11.00 ~20.00
Mo V
Nb
Al
–
–
0.10 – 2.50 – ~0.45 ~3.50 8 X C% – – – ~1.00 0.25 0.10 – 1.50 ~0.50 ~0.25 – ~2.60
– –
WPNL2204
0.10 ~0.25 – –
– 0.20 ~0.50
N
Cu
W
B
Others
0.0010 (Ti+Nb/2)C ~0.0040 2.0~4.0 – – –
–
Creep-resistant steels
Table 4.4 Continued
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
169
of JIS and METI Code steel tubes used extensively in high temperature components such as economizers, water walls, superheaters and reheaters in Japanese power boilers. The heat treatment conditions and tensile requirements for these steels are indicated in Tables 4.2–4.4. The specific designations for product forms other than boiler tubing and piping are shown in comparison with ASME Code in Table 4.5 for recently developed high strength ferritic steels.
4.4
Specifications for steam turbine steels
Table 4.64 shows the chemical compositions for steam turbine steels used in Japanese power plants. Steels are classified for specific components such as blades and discs, rotors and casings. The rotor steels shown here are recently developed 12%Cr high strength materials, although CrMo/CrMoV rotor steel and casings are still generally used for conventional steam turbines. Specifications for these turbine steels are controlled by turbine manufactures individually and not by the regulatory specifications. The technical control of melting and refining is also very important for turbine steels, as well as heat treatment control in order to maintain appropriate mechanical (strength/ toughness) and creep/fatigue properties. Thus, the listed nominal chemical compositions and heat treatment conditions in the table are suggested as guidelines.
4.5
Heat-resistant super alloys
Table 4.7 shows the chemical compositions of heat-resistant alloys (known as super alloys) listed in JIS G4901 for bars and G4902 for plates. These alloys are designated similarly to NCF XXX, with the lower three columns of the unified numbering system (UNS) number or ASTM designation. These alloys are annealed or solution annealed, except several grades that are aged after solution annealing. JIS does not specify the recommended annealing or solution temperature and aging temperature, although tensile/yield strength, rupture elongation and hardness are specified. These alloys exhibit extremely high creep strength and high temperature corrosion/oxidation resistance compared with other steels.
4.6
Summary
Specifications for creep-resistant steels in Japan are well established in JIS for ordinary use including high temperature applications, with METI Codes and JSME Codes only for boiler and nuclear applications. These specifications show general recommendations and regulations for chemical compositions, heat treatment conditions, mechanical properties, and so on. Mechanical
WPNL2204
170
Steels (trade name) 2.25Cr
HCM2S HCM9M
9Cr
Mod.9Cr NF616 HCM12
12Cr
HCM12A
Code
Tube
Pipe
Plate
ASME METI ASME METI
SA-213 T23 KA-STBA24J1 – KA-STBA27
SA-335 P23 KA-STPA24J1 – KA-STPA27
SA-1017 Gr.23 KA-SCMV4J1 – –
SA-182 F23 KA-SFVAF22AJ1 – KA-SFVAF27
ASME METI ASME METI ASME METI
SA-213T91 KA-STBA28 SA-213T92 KA-STBA29 – KA-SUS410J2TB
SA-335P91 KA-STPA28 SA-336P92 KA-STPA29 – –
SA-387Gr.91 KA-SCMV28 – – – –
SA-182F91 KA-SFVAF28 SA-182F98 KA-SFVAF29 – –
ASME METI
SA-213T122 KA-SUS410J3TB KA-SUSF410J3DTB
SA-335P122 KA-SUS410J3DTP –
SA-1017Gr.122 KA-SUS410J3 –
SA-182F122 KA-SUS410J3 –
WPNL2204
Forgings
Creep-resistant steels
Table 4.5 Comparative code designations in METI Code and ASME for new ferritic boiler steels
Table 4.6 Chemical compositions and heat treatment for turbine steels Steels
Nominal chemical composition (mass%) —————————————————————————————————————— Ni
Cr
Mo
W
Co
V
Nb
B
N
Small H46 (12Cr–0.5MoVNbN) 0.15 components TAF (10.5Cr–1.5MoVNbB) 0.18 TAF650 0.11 (11Cr –2.6W–3CoVNbB) TOS203 0.11 (10.5Cr –2.5W–1CoVNbBRe)
0.40 0.30 0.01
0.60 0.50 0.50
– – –
12.0 10.5 11.0
0.5 1.5 0.2
– – 2.6
– – 3.0
0.30 0.20 0.20
0.25 0.15 0.08
– 0.030 0.015
0.050 0.015 0.020
1,150 –650 1,150 –700 1,100 –750
0.05
0.50
0.6
10.5
0.1
2.5
1.0
0.20
0.10
0.010
0.030
1,120 –680
Rotor
GE (10.5Cr–1MoVNbN) 0.18 TMK1 (10.3Cr–1.5MoVNbN) 0.14 HR1100 0.15 (10.3Cr–1.2Mo–0.3WNbN) TOS107 0.14 (10Cr–1Mo–1MVNbN) TMK2 0.14 (10.2Cr–0.5Mo 1.8WVNbN) TR1200 0.13 (11Cr–0.2W–2.5WVNbB) HT1200 0.11 (11Cr–2.6W–3CoNiVNbB) TOS110 (10Cr–0.7Mo– 0.11 1.8W –3CoVNbB)
0.30 0.05 0.03
0.60 0.50 0.60
0.6 0.6 0.6
10.5 10.3 10.3
1.0 1.5 1.2
– – 0.3
– – –
0.20 0.17 0.20
0.06 0.06 0.05
– – –
0.060 0.040 0.050
1,050 –620 1,100 –680 1,075 –660
0.05
0.60
0.7
10.0
1.0
1.0
–
0.20
0.07
–
0.050
1,050 –660
0.05
0.50
0.5
10.2
0.5
1.8
–
0.17
0.06
–
0.040
1,050 –700
0.05
0.50
0.8
11.0
0.2
2.5
–
0.20
0.08
–
0.050
1,050 –710
0.05
0.50
0.5
11.0
0.2
2.6
3.0
0.20
0.08
0.015
0.025
1,050 –720
0.08
0.10
0.2
10.0
0.7
1.8
3.0
0.20
0.05
0.010
0.020
1,070 –680
MJC12 (9.5Cr –1MoVNbN) 0.10 TOS302 0.12 (10Cr –1Mo–0.8WVNbN) TOS303 0.12 (10Cr–1.8W–3CoVNbB)
0.70 0.25
0.70 0.50
0.5 1.0
9.5 10.0
1.0 1.0
– 0.8
– –
0.15 0.20
0.06 0.10
– –
0.040 0.050
1,050 –710 1,050 –710
0.15
0.50
0.2
10.0
0.7
1.8
3.0
0.20
0.05
0.006
0.020
1,100 –730
Casing
WPNL2204
171
Mn
C
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
Si
Heat treatment Nor.-temper (°C)
172
Table 4.7 Chemical compositions of heat-resistant alloys (JIS G4901 and G 4902) Chemical composition (mass%) C
Si
Mn
P
S
NCF600
≤ 0.15
≤ 0.50
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
72.00~
NCF601
≤ 0.10
≤ 0.50
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
NCF625
≤ 0.10
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.015
≤ 0.015
58.00 ~63.00 58.00~
NCF690
≤ 0.05
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.50
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
58.00~
NCF718
≤ 0.08
≤ 0.35
≤ 0.35
≤ 0.015
≤ 0.015
NCF750
≤ 0.08
≤ 0.50
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
50.00 ~55.00 70.00~
NCF751
≤ 0.10
≤ 0.50
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
70.00~
NCF800
≤ 0.10
≤ 1.00
≤ 1.50
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
NCF800H
0.05 ~0.10 ≤ 0.05
≤ 1.00
≤ 1.50
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
≤ 0.50
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
≤ 1.00
≤ 1.00
≤ 0.030
≤ 0.015
NCF825 NCF80A
0.04 ~0.10
Ni
30.00 ~35.00 30.00 ~35.00 38.00 ~46.00 Bal.
Cr
Fe
14.00 ~17.00 21.00 ~25.00 20.00 ~23.00 27.00 ~31.00 17.00 ~21.00 14.00 ~17.00 14.00 ~17.00 19.00 ~23.00 19.00 ~23.00 19.50 ~23.50 19.50 ~23.50
6.00 ~10.00 Bal.
–
≤ 0.50
–
–
–
–
–
≤ 1.00
–
–
–
≤ 5.00
8.00 –10.00 –
–
1.00 ~1.70 ≤ 0.40
≤ 0.40
≤ 0.50
–
–
≤ 0.30
0.20 ~0.80 0.40 ~1.00 0.90 ~1.50 0.15 ~0.60 0.15 ~0.60 ≤ 0.20
Bal. = balance.
WPNL2204
7.00 ~11.00 Bal. 5.00 ~9.00 5.00 ~9.00 Bal. Bal. Bal. ≤ 1.50
Mo
2.80 ~3.30 –
Cu
≤ 0.50
–
≤ 0.50
–
≤ 0.75
–
≤ 0.75
2.50 ~3.50 –
1.50 ~3.00 ≤ 0.20
Al
1.00 ~1.80
Ti
Nb + Ta
0.65 ~1.15 2.25 ~2.75 2.00 ~2.60 0.15 ~0.60 0.15 ~0.60 0.60 ~1.20 1.80 ~2.70
B
3.15 ~4.15 –
–
4.75 ~5.50 0.70 ~1.20 0.70 ~1.20 –
≤0.006
–
– – –
–
–
–
–
–
–
Creep-resistant steels
Designation
Specifications for creep-resistant steels: Japan
173
properties, including hardness, tensile, impact, creep and fatigue properties, are strongly influenced by microstructures resulting from heat treatment and chemical composition. In the case of turbine steels, the steel manufacturing process is very important to achieve the desired properties and performance. In the case of boiler/piping and pressure vessel applications, allowable stresses are provided in the METI Codes and JSME Codes, which feature criteria similar to ASME for determination of the allowable stress values for temperatures. In the future, specifications for creep-resistant steels will be updated in accordance with codes and standards developed in other areas worldwide.
4.7 1 2 3 4
References
http://www.jsa.or.jp/default_english.asp http://www.meti.go.jp/english/index.html http://www.jsme.or.jp/English/ Masuyama F. ‘History of power plants and progress in heat resistant steels’, ISIJ International, 2001 41, 612–625.
WPNL2204
5 Production of creep-resistant steels for turbines Y. T A N A K A, Japan Steel Works, Japan
5.1
Introduction
Increases in steam temperature and pressure have made a large contribution to improvement in the efficiency of fossil power plants. The importance of the increase in efficiency is a stringent problem for CO2 reduction and conservation of resources. Realisation of advanced fossil power plants that incorporate advanced steam conditions depends on the development of advanced heat-resistant steels and of production technology for large turbine rotor forgings. So far, many advanced type high pressure (HP) turbines, intermediate pressure (IP) turbines and high pressure low pressure combination turbines (HLP) have been developed successfully and contribute to an increase in plant efficiency. These advanced turbines are realised through the application of state-of-the-art production technology developed together with cultivated widely used and conventional technologies over the years. Points for the production of high-performance and reliable turbine rotor forging can be summarized as follows. Production of high purity steels with minimized residual elements and freedom from non-metallic inclusions is important in the steelmaking process. Homogeneous ingots with minimal segregation, delta ferrite, non-metallic inclusions and porosities should be made with a homogeneous distribution of chemistry throughout the casting process. For each forging process, a sufficient forging effect at the centre of large diameter in the ingots and forging blocks needs to be attained to consolidate the porosities in the ingots and sufficient forging strain should be given to the ingots to eliminate the solidification structure (e.g. dendrite) and promote formation of equiaxed grain through dynamic recrystallization. In the heat treatment process, heat treatment effects need to be exerted to develop the required properties at the centre of the forging. A fine grain microstructure needs to be obtained to assure sufficient detectability of defects. In this chapter, the development of production technologies for turbine rotor forgings is reviewed and several key processes are introduced. In 174 WPNL2204
Production of creep-resistant steels for turbines
175
addition, the properties of forgings made from heat-resistant steels are introduced.
5.2
Overview of production technology of rotor shaft forgings for high temperature steam turbines
Figure 5.1 shows a schematic of the production process for large turbine rotor forgings. The detail of each process is essentially different depending on the designation of steels and the required properties of the rotor shaft. In this section, the facilities for the production and typical technologies are overviewed.
5.2.1
Steelmaking and casting process
Figure 5.2 shows the historical change in steelmaking methods and equipment in one company since 1950, as an example.1 Similar changes in facilities and production technologies have taken place in the majority of the forgemasters in the world. Turbine material used to be refined by open hearth furnaces and was cast in air. At that time, the absorption of hydrogen in steel was one of the most serious problems of the process since hydrogen causes defects such as flaking. Installation of vacuum degassing equipment like the Bochumer–Verein type was a solution for the degassing of hydrogen during casting. By use of vacuum degassing equipment, the basic open hearth furnace and the basic electric arc furnace (EAF), which tend to absorb hydrogen during refining but are superior in refining ability, were able to be used, leading to an improvement in the material properties. The efficiency of the vacuum degassing equipment has been improved to attain a higher vacuum. With the introduction of vacuum casting equipment, vacuum carbon deoxidization (VCD) technology has been successfully applied to steam turbine materials.2 With the increase in capacity of power plants, larger turbine rotor forgings were needed and new production technologies were developed. A pouring method using multiple furnaces was developed as the casting technology for such large forging. Ladle refining furnaces (LRF) were installed to keep steel molten after refining in an electric furnace. After that, several ladle refining furnaces were additionally installed and these make the production of ingots up to 600 tonnes possible using a fully ladle refined melt.3 On the other hand, an electroslag remelting (ESR) furnace was used for refining and casting of high quality steels. The capacity was enlarged to meet the demands of melting large high temperature turbines made from low alloy and high alloy steels. Vacuum induction melting (VIM) was also installed. The use of VIM for the production of rotor forging, however, is uncommon. Through
WPNL2204
176
Electric arc furnace
Press
Vacuum
Horizontal furnace
Vacuum
Steelmaking casting 1
2
Forging
3
Preliminary heat treatment
Vertical furnace Quenching
Rough machining
Vertical furnace Tempering
WQ Oil FC Quality heat treatment 5
4
FC Stress relieving Stress relieving
NDE, machining 6
7
5.1 Typical production process for large steam turbine forging.
WPNL2204
Shipping 8
Creep-resistant steels
Ladle refining furnace
Vacuum casting
Year
1950
55
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
Acid and basic open hearth furnace Electric furnace Ladle refining furnace
Melting and refining
Holding furnace
150 ton 130 ton
30 ton x2
20 ton ESR
150 ton x2 100 ton ESR 5 ton VIM
Bochumer–Verein type mould stream degassing Ingot making
Air casting Mechanical pump
Steam ejector (high vacuum) Multipouring
Maximum ingot weight
140 ton
220 ton
250 ton
Low Si-VCD
Prediction of segregation
Double degassing
500 ton
570 ton
600 ton
400 ton
WPNL2204
177
5.2 The history of the steelmaking and casting process: an example.
Production of creep-resistant steels for turbines
Basic open hearth furnace Electric furnace
178
Creep-resistant steels
the development of these facilities and production technologies, high performance and high reliability rotor forgings have been manufactured. Current steelmaking processes used in the production of high temperature steam turbine rotor forging are as follows. Basic electric arc furnace and ladle refining furnace Formerly, acid and/or basic open hearth furnaces were used for refining steels. Since the introduction of vacuum degassing facilities, basic electric arc furnaces have become the major equipment used in the melting and refining of turbine rotor steels. In this process, refining is performed by the double slag method. After melting the raw materials, oxidizing refining is effected by adding a basic oxidizing slag