DEVELOPMENTS I N SEDIMENTOLOCY VOLUME I
DELTAIC A N D SHALLOW M A R I N E DEPOSITS
F U R T H E R TITLES I N T H I S ...
107 downloads
2704 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEVELOPMENTS I N SEDIMENTOLOCY VOLUME I
DELTAIC A N D SHALLOW M A R I N E DEPOSITS
F U R T H E R TITLES I N T H I S S E R I E S
G . C. A M S T U T Z , Editor
SEDIMENTOLOGY A N D ORE GENESIS A . H . B O U M A and A . B R O U W E R , Editors
TURBIDITES R . F. D I L L SUBMARINE EROSION
DEVELOPMENTS IN SEDIMENTOLOGY VOLUME I
DELTAIC AND SHALLOW MARINE DEPOSITS PROCEEDINGS OF THE SIXTH INTER NATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESS THE NETHERLANDS AND BELGIUM
-
I963
E D I T E D BY
L. M. J. U.
VAN
STRAATEN
Geology Department State University, Groningen The Netherlands
ELSEVlE R PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM
LONDON
1964
N E W YORK
ELSEVIER PUBLISHING COMPANY 335 JAN VAN GALENSTRAAT, P.O. BOX 211. AMSTERDAM
AMERICAN ELSEVIER PUBLISHING COMPANY, INC. 52 VANDERBILT AVENUE, N E W YORK 17, N.Y.
ELSEVIER PUBLISHING COMPANY LIMITED 12B, RIPPLESIDE COMMERCIAL ESTATE RIPPLE ROAD, BARKING, ESSEX
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER
63-16087
W l T H 162 ILLUSTRATIONS AND 24 TABLES
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED THIS BOOK OR ANY PART THEREOF MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, INCLUDING PHOTOSTATIC OR MICROFILM FORM, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
THE SIXTH INTERNATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESS THE NETHERLANDS AND BELGIUM, 1963
COMMITTEES
HONORARY COMMITTEE
Prof. Dr. D. J. Doeglas, Wageningen, Utrecht Prof. Dr. C. H. Edelman, Wageningen Prof. Dr. A. Hacquaert, Ghent Prof. Dr. Ph. H. Kuenen, Groningen
Ing. W. P. van Leckwijck, Brussels
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
Prof. Dr. R. Tavernier, Ghent, President Prof. Dr. A. J. Wiggers, Amsterdam, Vice-president Ing. M. K. Gulinck, Brussels, Secretary Dr. C. Kruit, Rijswijk, Secretary Dr. J. D. de Jong, Haarlem, Treasurer
Prof. Dr. M. Lecompte, Louvain, Member Prof. Dr. J. P. G. Michot, Litge, Member Prof. Dr. L. M. J. U. van Straaten, Groningen, Member
PREVIOUS INTERNATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESSES AND THEIR PROCEEDINGS
1. Belgium, 1946.
Ghent and Brussels. La GPologie des Terrains Rkents dans l’Ouest de I’Europe. Session extraordinaire des SOC. belges de CPologie. Hayez, Bruxelles, 495 pp.
2. France, 1949.
La Rochelle and Angouleme. S6dimentation et Quaternaire. Led Sam, Bordeaux, 321 pp.
3. The Netherlands, 1951. Groningen and Wageningen. Proceedings of the Third International Congress of Sedi-
mentofogy. Nijhoff, Den Haag, 332 pp. 4. Germany, 1954.
Gottingen. Geol. Rundschau, 1955, 43 (2): 307-599.
5. Switzerland, 1958.
Genkve and Lausanne. Eclogae Geol. Helv., 51 (3) : 485-1 177.
THE SIXTH INTERNATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESS THE NETHERLANDS AND BELGIUM, 1963 REPORT
MAY
2428.
FIELD TRIPS, HELD BEFORE SESSIONS (THE NETHERLANDS)
Fieldtrip A: Estuarine sedimentation in the southwestern Netherlands Leader: L. M. J. U. van Straaten. Number of participants: 77. Localities visited: ( I ) Shoal with megaripples in Westerschelde near Kruiningen. (2) Mud flat with ebb gullies near Bath. (3) Sand flat near Bergen op Zoom. (4) Salt marsh near Woensdrecht. (5) Excavation in estuarine series near Willemstad. FieldfripB: Coastal-plain sediments in North-Holland and former Zuiderzee area Leaders: J . D. de Jong and A. J. Wiggers. Number of participants: 114. Localities visited: ( I ) Excavation at Amsterdam, showing 10 m thick section through Holocene deposits, including Lower Peat, lagoon clay, tidal-channel, tidal-flat and salt-marsh deposits, Upper Peat and top clay layer. (2) North Sea beach at Zandvoort. (3) Excavation in dune deposits south of Zandvoort. (4) Several points in Oostelijk Flevoland polder (Zuiderzee area), showing deposits of lacustrine and lagoonal origin, with great variety of sedimentary structures.
MAY
29-30.
MEETING AT AMSTERDAM
The congress at Amsterdam was held in the “Instituut voor de Tropen” and was attended by 283 participants. It was opened by R. Tavernier, who, among other things, expressed the appreciation of the organizing committee for the help, received from several institutions, especially the ‘‘Koninklijke/Shell Exploratie en Productie Laboratorium” at Rijswijk, the Geological Survey at Haarlem, the “Rijkswaterstaat” at The Hague, and the Geology Departments of the Free University at Amsterdam and the State University at Groningen.
VIIT
THE SIXTH INTERNATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESS
F. P. Shepard (La Jolla), president of the International Association of Sedimentology, read an address on “Criteria in modern sediments, useful in recognizing ancient sedimentary environments”. Under chairmanship of J. Bourcart (France), W. P. van Leckwijck (Belgium), L. Trevisan (Italy) and E. Seibold [Germany), 17 speakers presented papers dealing with processes of recent sedimentation and erosion, and some other general topics, viz. Ph. H. Kuenen, P. McL. D. Duff, J. Ph. Mangin, H. Fuchtbauer, G. V. Chilingar, A. J. de Groot, E. T. Degens, A. Bersier, R. Goldring, D. J. Shearman, W. D. Briickner, J. R. Curray, J. H. Hoyt, D. G. Moore, A. Guilcher, D. J. J. Kinsman and A. J. Wells. I n addition, R. Goldring and F. E. J. Arbey read the papers by J. R. L. Allen and A. Rivitre resp., and J. E. Sanders presented a motion picture on sand transport and ripple formation in the laboratory and in natural rivers. On the evening of May 29, a reception was given to the congress members in the “Stedelijk Museum” by the municipality of Amsterdam, who also offered them a boat trip through the Amsterdam canals at the end of the following day. On the evening of May 30, the International Association of Sedimentology held a general assembly in the Physics Department of the Free University, where among other things, a British proposal was accepted to hold the next congress in Great Britain. A new council of the 1. A. S. was elected, composed as follows: President: J. H. Taylor (London); Vice-president: L. Trevisan [Pisa); General Secretary: D. J. Doeglas (Wageningen); Treasurer: A. H. Bouma (Utrecht); Members: K. Birkenmayer (Krakow), P. V. Dehadrai (Dehradun), 0. Riba ISaragosse), F. P. Shepard (La Jolla, Calif.); T. Sudo (Tokyo), J. J. Veevers (Canberra). During the meetings at Amsterdam, the participants had the opportunity to study a n exhibition of sedimentological work done in The Netherlands and Belgium. This exhibition was organized under direction of D . J. Doeglas.
MAY
31.
EXCURSION TO HARINGVLIET WORKS, SYMPOSIUM AT D E L ~AND EVENING SESSION AT ANTWERP
On their way from Amsterdam to Antwerp, most of those attending the congress visited a large excavation in the Haringvliet estuary under the direction of J. H. J. Terwindt. This excavation permits three-dimensional studies of the most recent estuarine deposits, the formation of which could be accurately dated by comparison of a long series of hydrographic maps. The other participants met in the Geology Department of the Technological University at Delft for a symposium on “Sedimentology and ore genesis” (total number of participants: 80), organized by Prof. Dr. G. C. Amstutz (Missouri, U.S.A.) and Prof. Dr. F. J. Faber (Delft). Fifteen papers were presented, which will be published in a separate volume, edited by G. C. Amstutz. On the evening of this day, a session was held in the “Nationaal Bouwcentrum” at Antwerp. Here, under chairmanship of D. S. Gorsline (U.S.A.), A. H. Bouma pre-
MEETINGS AND FIELDTRIPS
Y(
sented and explained a motion picture by R. F. Dill on sediment transport in the heads of submarine canyons.
JUNE
1.
MEETING AT ANTWERP
The last day of the congress was devoted to papers dealing especially with pre-Quaternary formations. Chairmen were: J. H. Taylor (England) and D. J. Doeglas [The Netherlands). The papers were presented by H. G. Reading, W. Zimmerle, P. Wurster, C. Pomerol, G. Kelling, T. R. Owen, R. H. Dott, A. Hallam and B. Mamet. In the closing session the organizers of the congress were thanked by J. H. Taylor (England), A. Bersier (Switzerland), H. Harder [Germany), L. Trevisan (Italy) and F. Macau Vilar (Spain). In the evening the congress had the opportunity to visit the Town Hall at Antwerp. June 2. During the morning of this day a number of participants visited the Hydraulics Laboratory at Borgerhout, near Antwerp.
JUNE
3-8.
FIELDTRIPS HELD AFTER SESSIONS (BELGIUM)
Fieldtrip C: Terrigenous sediments of the Lower Devonian. Rhythmic organogenic
Fieldtrip D: Fieldtrip E:
Fieldtrip F: Fieldtrip G:
and terrigenous sediments during the period of reef formation covering the Middle Devonian and Frasnian (Upper Devonian). Leader: M. Lecompte. Number of participants: 27. Idem. Number of participants: 16. The Namurian in the region of Andenne and Vist. Cyclic sedimentation. Arenaceous sediments of the Upper Devonian (Famennian) in the valley of the Hoyou. Arenaceous sediments with pseudonodules of the Lower Devonian of the Ardennes. Leaders: P. Macar, P. Michot and W. P. van Leckwijck. Number of participants: 20. Idem. Number of participants: 17. The Carboniferous limestone of the Meuse and Vesdre valleys. Rhythmic sedimentation, breccias, biostromes. Leaders: P. Michot, R. Conil, J. M. Graulich. Number of participants: 22.
X Fieldtrip I:
Fieldtrip J: Fieldtrip K:
Fieldirip M:
Fieldtrip N: Fieldtrip 0:
Fieldtrip P:
THE SIXTH JNTERNATIONAL SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CONGRESS
The Carboniferous limestone of Hainaut. Transition into the Namurian. Karst relief and infilling. Lacustrine and deltaic sediments of the Wealden. Shales and siltstones of the Cambro-Silurian of Brabant. Leaders: A. Delmer, R. Legrand, R. Marlikre and G. Mortelmans. Number of participants: 20. Idem. Number of participants: 12. Tertiary marine clayey deposits (Rupelian and Ypresian). Marine Eocene and Neogene sands. Continental sediments of the Pleistocene [loess, cover sands) in west BAgium. Leaders: R. Martchal and J. de Heinzelin. Number of participants: 18. Littoral arenaceous sediments of the Oligocene and the Eocene. Transition facies to continental deposits with slump phenomena. Fresh water deposits of the Oligocene. Leader: M. Gulinck. Number of participants: 14. Idem. Number of participants: 15. Pleistocene estuarine and river deposits. Cover sands, dunes and loess in the east of Belgium. Miocene sands and lignites. Lagoonal deposits of the Oligocene. Leader: F. Gullentops. Number of participants: 12. Idem. Number of uarticiuants: 8. 1 1
EDITORIAL
For various reasons, the committee organizing the Sixth International Sedimentological Congress had decided to focus attention on one central theme, viz. : Deltaic and shallow-marine deposits. The present Proceedings volume contains all papers (of participants) dealing with this topic, and submitted before the deadline, January 1, 1963. The papers had to be written in English, French or German. In several of the contributions in which authors, had written in a language not their own, the text was modified to a smaller or larger extent at the suggestion of the Editor. Though he believes that in some cases this has led to an improvement in the linguistic quality of these papers, he is aware that the result of his activities is still far from faultless. Two papers written in English were corrected by Prof. Dr. P. Allen (Reading), while Ing. W. P. van Leckwijck (Brussels) took care of a few contributions in the French language. The editor hereby expresses his sincere gratitude to these colleagues for their kind help. L. M. J. u. VAN STRAATEN
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS The Sixth International Sedimentological Congress. Committees
..............
Previous international sedimentological congresses and their proceedings
..........
V VI
The Sixth International Sedimentological Congress, The Netherlands and Belgium, 1963. Meetings and fieldtrips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .XI11
Editorial.. Contents
. ,
Presidential Address. Criteria in modem sediments useful in recognizing ancient sedimentary environments F. P. SHEPARD (La Jolla, Calif., U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sedimentation in the modem delta of the river Niger, West Africa J. R. L. ALLEN (Reading, Great Britain). . . . . . . . . . .
.............
Structure en creneaux et brkhe cyclopknne en milieu detritique-paralique A. BERSIER (Lausanne, Suisse) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.........
Specific features of deltaic deposits in coal-bearing and cupriferous formations L. N. BOTWNKINA and V. S.YABLOKOV (Moscow, U.S.S.R.) . . . . . . .
........
1 26 35 39
Devonian biostromes and bioherms of the southem Cantabrian Mountains, northwestern Spain A. BROUWER (Leyden, The Netherlands) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
48
Heavy mineral distribution on the continental shelf off Accra, Ghana, West Africa W. D. BRUCKNER and H. J. MORGAN (St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada) . . .
54
......
On shallow-water origin of phosphorite sediments G. I. BUSHINSKI (Moscow, U.S.S.R.)
.........................
62
Relationship between porosity, permeability and grain-size distribution of sands and sandstones G. V. C H I L I N G A R ( L O S Calif., A ~ ~ ~U.S.A.) ~~~, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
71
Holocene regressive littoral sand, Costa de Nayarit, Mexico J. R. CURRAY (La Jolla, Calif., U.S.A.) and D. G. MOORE (San Diego, Calif., U.S.A.)
76
....
u ber biogeochemische Umsetzungen im Friihstadium der Diagenese E. T. DECENS (Pasadena, Calif., U.S.A.).
.......................
83
Origin and transport of mud (fraction < 16 microns) in coastal waters from the Western Scheldt to the Danish frontier 93 A. J. DE GROOT(Groningen, The Netherlands) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Features in the heads of submarine canyons; narrative of underwater film R.F.DILL(SanDiego,Calif.,U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ancient deltaic sedimentation in eugeosynclinal belts R. H. Don JR. (Madison, Wisc., U.S.A.) . . . . .
.........
..................
101 105
Trend surface analysis of sedimentary features of the Modioluris Zone, east Pennine coalfield, England P. McL. D. DUFFand E. K. WALTON (Edinburgh, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 Thickness variations of the sandy Almere deposits (Holocene) in the former Zuiderzee area (The Netherlands) P. J. ENTE(Kampen, The Netherlands) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123
,'
Alreconnaissance survey of the environment of Recent carbonate sedimentation along the Trucial Coast, Persian Gulf G. EVANS, D. J. J. KINSMAN and D. J. SHEARMAN (London, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . 129
XIV
CONTENTS
Trace-fossils and the sedimentary surface in shallow-water marine sediments R. GOLDRING (Reading, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
136
Beach studies in west Florida, U.S.A. D. S. GORSLINE (Los Angeles, Calif., U.S.A.)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
144
La sidimentation sous-marine dam la partie orientale de la Rade de Brest, Bretagne A. GUILCHER (Pans, France) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
148
Liassic sedimentary cycles in western Europe and their relationship to changes in sea level A. HALLAM (Edinburgh, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
157
Lagoon sediments in Greenland K. HANSEN (Copenhagen, Denmark) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
165
Late Pleistocene and Recent sedimentation, central Georgia coast, U.S.A. (Golden, Colo., U.S.A.) and V. J. J. H. HOYT(Sapelo Island, Ga., U.S.A.), R. J. WEIMER HENRY JR.(Sapelo Island, Ga., U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 Sediment transport in part of the Lower Pennant Measures of South Wales G. KELLING (Swansea, Great Britain). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
177
The Recent carbonate sediments near Halat el Bahrani, Trucial Coast, Persian Gulf D. J. J. KINSMAN (London, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
185
Sedimentary facies in Bay of Fundy intertidal zone,Nova Scotia, Canada G. DE V. KLEIN[Philadelphia, Pa., U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
193
Aspects gdneraux de la ddimentation argileuse dans les facits littoraux du Paltoghe Nord Aquitain A. KLINGEBIEL et C. LATOUCHE (Talence, France). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 200 Pivotability studies of sand by a shape-sorter PH. H. KUENEN (Groningen, The Netherlands) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
207
Typical features of a fluviomarine offlap sequence R.LAGAAY and F. P. H. W. KOPSTEIN (Rijswijk, The Netherlands) . . . . . . . . . . . . 216 Rhaetic-Jurassic-Lower Cretaceous sediments from deep wells in North Jylland, Denmark G . LARSEN (Hellerup, Denmark) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
227
Reflexions sur la systtmatique et la g e n k des bassins de ddimentation N. LLOPIS LLADO (Madrid, Espagne) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
236
Sedimentology of beaches on the north coast of the Sea of Azov and I. N. REMIZOV (Moscow, U.S.S.R.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 245 N. V. LOGVINENKO Zur Gerollmorphornetrie von Transgressionskonglomeraten G. LUTTIC(Hannover, Deutschland) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
253
Sedimentary environments of the Weald Clay of southeastern England J . D. S. MACWUGALL and J. E. PRENTICE (London, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . 257 Sdlmentation des facies “marbres noirs” de la Belgique et du nord de la France B. MAMET (Bruxelles, Belgique) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
264
La dquence-unite et les dries kdirnentaires J. PH. MANGIN (Dijon, France) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
269
Sedimentary framework of the drowned Pleistocene delta of Rio Grande de Santiago, Nayarit. Mexico (La Jolla, Calif,. U.S.A.) . . . . 275 D. G. MOORE (SanDiego, Calif., U.S.A.) and J. R. CURRAY Die Korngrossenverteilung in den rezenten Sedimenten des Golfes von Neapel G MULLER (Tiibingen, Deutschland). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
282
xv
C0NTENTS
Unterschiede in den chemischen und physkalischen Eigenschaften von fluviatilen, brackischen und marinen Sedimenten W. MULLER (Hannover, Deutschland) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 293 The tectonic framework of Carboniferous sedimentation in South Wales T. R.OWEN(Swansea, Great Britain). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Frio sedimentation on the Rayne field of southwest Louisiana W. R.PAINE (Lafayette, La., U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . Shallow-water origin of Early Paleozoic oolitic iron ores J. P E T R ~ N(Praha, EK Czechoslavakia). . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
301
. . . . . . . . . . . .
308
................
3 19
Origine et conditions de sidimentation des depots sableux dans le Golfe bartonien du Bassin de Paris C. POMEROL (Paris, France) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 323 Couches intraformationnelles a galets primitivement mous dans I’Ordovicien moyen de la region de Caen J . P o ~ c ~ ~ ( C a e n , F r a n c.e ). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 330 Mesozoic and Cenozoic deltas of Tian-Shan and Pamir A. A. PHILLIPOV, A. A. BOGOIAVLENSKY and R. Y.MUZAV.I.POPOV,S. D. MACAROVA, PHAROVA (MOSCOW, U.S.S.R.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 336 A review of the factors affecting the sedimentation of the Millstone Grit (Namurian) in the Central Pennines H. G. READING (Oxford, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 340
Le Flysch: definition; depdt de faible profondeur? M. REcH-FROLLO (Toulouse, France). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
347
Contribution a l’etude de la skdimentologie des sediments carbonates A. RIVI~RE et S. VERNHET (Paris, France) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
356
The penecontemporaneous deformation of heavy mineral bands in the Torridonian sandstone of northwest Scotland R. C. SELLEY (London, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362
On the penecontemporaneous disturbance of bedding by “quicksand” movement in the Devonian rocks of North Devon D. J. SHEARMAN (London, Great Britain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368 Near-shore and shallow-water deposits of Aptian and Albian age in Moscow region U.S.S.R.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M.S.SHVETZOV(MOSCOW,
371
Primary structures in a part of the Nile delta sand beach S. M. SOLMAN (Cairo, Egypt) . . . . . . . . . . .
379
. . . .
Distribution and lateral variability of heavy minerals in the Annot Sandstones (Vicksburg, Miss., U.S.A.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. J. STANLEY
388
Traits particuliers mineralogiques-geochimiques de I’assise terrigtne carboniftre inferieur dans la region Ouralienne-Volgienne G. I. THEODOROVITCH, N. N. SOKOLOVA, E. D. ROSONOVA et M. V. BAGDASSAROVA (Moscou, U.R.S.S.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 399 Crittres de sensibilitt appliqds aux indices de forme des grains de sable v. TONNARD (Gernbloux, Belgique) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
410
Effect of the origin of the Lower Carboniferous clays in the western part of the Moscow Basin
on the alterations of their clay minerals M.F. VIKULOVA(MOSCOW, U.S.S.R.). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
417
XVI
CONTENTS
Present day precipitation of calcium carbonate in the Persian Gulf A . J . WELLSand L . V. ILLINC(Rijswijk, The Netherlands) . . . Delta sedimentation in the German Keuper Basin P. WURSTER (Hamburg. Germany) . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . 429
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Sedimentology of a Tertiary beach sand in the Subalpine Molasse Trough w. Z~MMERLE (Hamburg. Germany) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
436
. . . . . . . . . Index I. according to main topics of papers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
447
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
462
Index 11. according to main areas concerned
459
Presidential Address
CRITERIA I N MODERN SEDIMENTS USEFUL I N RECOGNIZING ANCIENT SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS' F R A N C I S P. S H E P A R D Scripps Institution
of OceanoLgraphy,University of California, La Jolla, CalF (U.S.A.)
INTRODUCTION
The great contributions of CAYEUX (1941) have been a major factor in recognizing the environments in which sediments were deposited. However, I can certainly agree with BROUWER(1962) that Cayeux was too pessimistic in saying that it is uniquely by the analysis of ancient sediments that we can get to understand the conditions in marine basins of the past. It is quite possible that some of these ancient deposits were formed under conditions that no longer exist, but it seems likely that our failure to find analogies between past and present is due largely to the sparcity of studies in modern sedimentary basins. Compared to the thousands of geologists who are investigating ancient sediments there are only a handful of us who have been studying the Recent although we now have many new recruits. It is said by some that the present is a poor time to learn about past sedimentary conditions because of the large amount of tectonic activity that has taken place in the Cenozoic and the broad emergence of the land masses in contrast to the extensive inland seas of the past. However, we still have extensive inland or at least partly landlocked seas, the study of which has only just been started. For example, there are the Gulf of Thailand, the South China Sea, the Yellow Sea, the Timor-Sahui shelf, the Java Sea, the vast embayments in the Arctic, the Caspian, the Black Sea, the Mediterranean, the North Sea, the Baltic, and the Persian Gulf. Need we name more? As a possible objection to the significance of this enumeration it could be pointed out that much of the area consists of relatively deep seas, whereas the seas of the past have been considered by most geologists as largely shallow. Yet that answer cannot be given with as much appeal since my old friend professor Kuenen and others have done so much to demonstrate that turbidity currents in deep water can produce most of the criteria that were used to diagnose shallow water conditions. Perhaps we have had many more deep water basins in the past than we now recognize. Furthermore, turbidity currents can carry shallow water fossils, including wood, out into the greatest of depths and are capable of transporting organisms with little or no signs of wear. Much of the work reported here was supported by grants from the American Petroleum Institute (A.P.I. 51) and from the Office of Naval Research under contract nonr 2216(01).
2
F. P. SHEPARD THOUSANDS 0 t Z O - - r 7 - r - - ' T X
[
5 000
OF
YEARS BEFORE T H E PRESENT 1
I
7
10.000
7
-
r
r
-
T
T
PRESENT
+
A+
+
-
I 15.000 i
I
,
20.0w I
I
x SEA
~-~
LEVEL
,'+A
~ - - ~.
I
lo
100-
:120LL
??
A
140-
w J
A
A
21
160-
d
180-
g
200-
A TEXAS
220-
a
A
!A
w
: x
240-
.
THE GEOERLAND5 EASTERN A R G E N T l M I p e o l l S W LOUISIANA CHENIERS X AUSTRALIA 0 FLORIDA d CEYLON 0 W MEXICO.OFF0ROAO COASTAL PLAIN
&
A
A
260 280 -
A 90
100
I10
380 5.0m
10.000
15,000
20.000
THOUSANDS OF YEARS BEFORE T H E PRESENT
Fig.1. Position of sea level during the past 20,OOO years indicated by "C dates of near sea level organisms and plants plotted against their depth below or above present sea level. All samples come from relatively stable areas. The samples from Australia that are above sea level are believed by recent investigators to represent kitchen middens and are therefore suspect.
Another objection to comparing ancient and present day environments is that the present is a time that is abnormal in that the sea level has been fluctuating rapidly over the past several hundred thousand years due to the alternate growth and dispersal of great ice sheets. As to how important this rapid fluctuation is in making the present an abnormal period depends on whether or not there have been as many up and down movements of the sea during the past few thousand years as claimed by a few geologists. For some years I have been accumulating 14Cdates that bear on this problem and as shown in the accompanying graph (Fig.1)I have come to the conclusion, along with most of the investigators of Holland and most Gulf Coast geologists, that the sea has been virtually at a standstill for the past 3,000 years and rose so slowly from about 6,000 to 3,000 years B.P. that it would not have differed very much from the slow sinking of sedimentary basins in the past. The hypothesis of a high sea level during the
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
3
climatic optimum, a few thousand years before the present, seems to be disappearing along with many other geological misinterpretations related to the sea. Recent investigations of what formerly seemed to be good evidence of uniformly elevated terraces
Fig.2. Box corer nioditied by A. H. Bouma from design by REINECK (1963). Noteconipass attachment for orienting sample. Structures are often well preserved in the box cores.
4
F. P. SHEPARD
have proved that these terraces are too old for a postglacial high stand and the terraces are far from uniform in height. Therefore, it now seems that there has been time for deposition to occur under the relatively stable conditions that existed during most of the past. Another difficulty in comparing recent and past sedimentation has been that modern sediments obtained by cores are too much disturbed to allow sedimentary structures to be found. This trouble has now been partially eliminated by the use of a large box sampler based on the system of a device of REINECK (1963) which has been redesigned by A. H. Bouma for use in all depths of water (Fig.2). With sections of these rectangular cores, X-ray photographs, and sedimentary peels, we have found cross-bedding, lamination, ripple marks, graded bedding, small folds, and reworking by organisms (Fig.3). Progress in understanding the conditions of sedimentation in the past has come from photographs of the ocean bottom. The finding of ripple marks on seamounts, in submarine canyons (Fig.4), and even in troughs at great ocean depths has helped us understand how completely wrong was the old idea that ripple marks are confined to shallow water deposits‘. Bottom photographs have also emphasized the importance of organisms in working over near surface sediments (Fig.5). The operations of SCUBA divers using Cousteau’s aqua-lung have revolutionized our ideas on submarine erosion and transportation. In the past the main emphasis in the recognition of environments has been on paleontology, the comparison of fossil habitats with those of the present day. This has, of course, been enormously helpful, but it can be deceptive. We have only to think of a few examples to illustrate this point. At present we have bears living from the Arctic to the equatorial regions. If only the polar bears had survived, is it not possible that bear skeletons in ancient deposits would be used as evidence for a cold climate? Coral reefs are generally considered as indicators of shallow and warm water, but, as TEICHERT (1958) and others have emphasized, ahermatypic coral reefs grow as far north as Norway and in water several hundred fathoms deep. Coal has generally been considered as developing in the tropics but the work on Arctic tundras has shown that certain types of coal could have developed equally well in cold climates. The very helpful criteria coming from depth zonation of foraminifera1 assemblages are used extensively in the interpretation of Tertiary sediments. However, it is not known to what extent the zonation is related to depth as a factor of pressure or to what extent to temperature that is not necessarily controlled by depth. BRADSHAW’S ( 196 1) controlled experiments in culturing Foraminifera at Scripps Institution may give some of the answers but work of this type is still in an early stage. Clearly we need to use evidence from the physical and chemical nature of sediments to supplement the faunal assemblages in diagnosing the ancient environments.
Actually, according to D. L. Inman (personal communication, 1963), certain types of ripples are definitely related to shallow water waves.
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
5
Fig.3. X-ray photograph of slice from box sample showing various structures. Sample is from Santa Maria Canyon, Baja California, in 335 m.
6
F. P. SHEPARD
Fig.4. Current ripple marks obtained by the writer from the floor of a Japanese submarinecanyon at a depth of 510 m. Photograph by an Edgerton underwater camera.
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
7
Fig.5. Showing the trails, burrows, and other disturbances of the bottom by organisms. Photo by an Edgerton underwater camera at a depth of 1,350 m. The disturbance of the sediment is caused by a smsll flat fish visible in picture (left center).
8
F. P. SHEPARD USEFUL METHODS FOR INTERPRETING THE PAST
During the course of some 40 years of sampling and studying recent sediments I have investigated a great many environments that have ranged all the way from beaches and coastal dunes out to the deep sea floor. Climatically these have ranged from glacial marginal to tropical. I n the course of this work I have been looking for criteria and methods for comparing ancient and modern sediments. During my direction of American Petroleum Institute Project 51 I had the cooperation of a considerable group of scientists with a variety of skills attacking this problem from samples collected in the northwest Gulf of Mexico (SHEPARD et al., 1960). The study of the faunas provedvery useful; Foraminifera, ostracods, and molluscan assemblages were all of help. Clay minerals gave some indications but were rather inconsistent so far as our work went. Size analysis along with sorting and skewness of sediments has given some idea of environmental control. Roundness of sand grains served to distinguish adjacent beaches and dunes and orientation of grains proved helpful in some environments. Sedimentary strilctures provided a helpful criterion, especially around river mouths. I have been particularly impressed with a method which I have called “coarse fraction analysis.” This consists of making counts of the constituents of the various sieve sizes of the sand and gravel fraction of a sediment. The types of constituents to be used should depend both on training of the operator and on the particular environment being studied. Such constituents as terrigenous including nonmicaceous light minerals, dark minerals, and micas can be separated easily and no great skill is required to count the benthonic and planktonic Foraminifera, the molluscan fragments, the echinoid fragments, the sponge spicuIes, etc. The ratio of abundance of these different groups has proved to be very helpful in interpreting environments. In fact, when we tested various methods on a series of samples with information on the environments withheld during the test, we found that we got the best scores by determinations based on the coarse fraction constituents. This test may apply only to Gulf Coast shallow water sediments but at least it shows that similar analyses of ancient sediments should be useful along with various other tests.
EXAMPLES OF CRITERIA COMING FROM MODERN SEDIMENT STUDIES
In order to illustrate the type of criteria which may come from sediment studies I should like to point to some results that my colleagues and I have had from our work. I do not mean to imply that these are by any means the only criteria that can be used but just wish to show how the studies of one small group of investigators have indicated the importance of modern sediments. Distinguishing dunes, beaches, and nearshore sediments During the course of the Gulf Coast studies we had the opportunity to compare the
9
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
sands from dunes, beaches, and nearshore environments. Later these comparisons were extended to coastal areas from various other parts of the world, with especial emphasis on the Hawaiian Islands. We found that where there were predominantly onshore winds we could distinguish about 95 % of the dune and beach sands because the former had greater roundness, higher silt content, and greater abundance of heavy minerals, especially of the easily recognized zircon crystals; whereas the latter had greater abundance of shells and mica (SHEPARDand YOUNG,1961). We could not find, however, any reason to believe that the skewness or kurtosis of the sands could be used to distinguish these environments as has been claimed by some investigators. As a criterion to separate beach from nearshore sands we found that outside fine sand beaches there was a fairly consistent increase of the very fine sand in the offshore samples along with the appearance of appreciable silt that is virtually missing in the beach sands (SHEPARD and MOORE,1955). Along the Gulf Coast sorting did not appear to differ much between beaches and nearshore sand but in the Hawaiian Islands where most sands are the remains of calcareous organisms, we found that sorting is rather consistently worse in the nearshore zone (Fig.6) (SHEPARDet al., 1962), and that the sediments are more negatively skewed nearshore because of the abundance of relatively large shell fragments and less erosion of the large Foraminifera. The well-known sedimentary structures of dunes and beaches can, of course, supplement these other criteria, but in our cores from drillings in the Gulf Coast area we
80
70
MORE PoSITI\
60 ,----o
\\ \
c JO
L--
In
\
\
----\\
I
a.
g40 e
m Y I
$
--
t -'O
MORE NEGAT
30
20
MEDIAN DIAMETERS
SKEWNESS
SORTING
I
f
10
0
Fig.6. Comparison of samples taken at berm crest, water line, and in shallow offshore zone along the beaches of the Hawaiian Islands. The number of comparisons and differences are indicated by the scale on the sides.
10 F. P. SHEPARD
C
3
.-C D
Ld
.-c
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
11
found very little bedding of any kind to help this interpretation. Whether or not these structures are found it seems likely that most continuous outcrops that traverse these three environments would have characteristics which should make it possible to find the boundaries between dune, beach, and nearshore. Distinguishing arid and humid lagoonal deposits from shallocc, shelf seditncnts The work along the coast of Texas provided some helpful criteria for the recognition of ancient lagoonal deposits and means of identifying the climatic conditions prevailing in the areas ( P A R K E R , 1960; PHLEGER, 1960; RUSNAK, 1960; SHEPARD and M O O R E , 1960). In addition to the distinguishing characteristics of the faunal assemblages the constituents of the coarse fraction and the physical characteristics of the sediments are important. Thus the bay muds differ from muds on the continental shelves in lacking the glauconite that is so common on the shelf. Almost all of the oyster reefs, especially those with Crassostrea virginica, are confined to the bays. Echinoid fragments are common in the shelf deposits and rare in the bays. The bay muds have at least as many Foraminifera as the shelf muds but consist largely of a few species in contrast to the numerous species of the shelf. At the lower end of the bays, especially near inlets, the sediments are commonly sandy clays or clayey sands with only small quantities of silt. Such sediments are very rare on the shelf. In the bays of humid areas the benthic faunas churn up the bottom in such a way as to eliminate most stratification except near stream mouths where the combination of fast deposition and low salinity with little bottom life results in the preservation of laminae. Most bay cores in central Texas lack any indication of stratification even in borings in which we have traced the bay sediments down to as much as 70 ft. below the bay floor (Fig.7a). On the other hand the cores in semiarid Laguna Madre of south Texas are mostly stratified (Fig.7b) because of the scarcity of the bottom sediment churning organisms. This in turn is due to a considerable extent to the covering of the bottom by algal mats that prevent oxygen from entering. In semiarid regions the sediments contain a considerable quantity of chemically precipitated lime. This may occur as thin lime coatings on sand grains or as oolites (RUSNAK, 1960). Locally, gypsum and anhydrite develop in the deposists of Laguna Madre. These chemical precipitates are missing in the more humid bays farther north. Relatively clean sand deposits are found over the part of the Laguna Madre adjacent to the sandy barrier island. These are derived from wind blown sand. This source is not nearly as important in the lagoons inside the barrier islands to the north because there the dunes are more anchored by vegetation. In the bay deposits marginal to the barrier islands in the humid areas sediments are much muddier and less well sorted. Distinguishing marine delta facies
In our studies of the shallow water sediments in the northwest Gulf of Mexico we were impressed by the fact that quantitatively the deposits forming around margins of
F. P. SHEPARD
Fig.8. Showing the growth of the Mississippi delta between 1859 and 1940. Much of the growth took place in a much shorter period. Water depths are given in feet. (Taken from maps and soundings by the U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey.)
deltas far exceed those of all other environments. This must also be true along most other coasts at the present time. Aside from catastrophic events such as large landslides it is only near the mouths of rivers that deposition is so fast that marked changes are indicated between successive surveys. Where human records go back for thousands of years, as in the Persian Gulf, we find that deltas have built forward for hundreds of miles. At the mouth of the Mississippi the far shorter records show an even more im-
13
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
pressive rate of sedimentation (Fig.8). Why, then, do we have so few descriptions of ancient deltaic deposits in geological literature? One answer could be that during the past the land areas were smaller in general and, therefore, delta formation was less important than it is today. Although this is probably true, there seem always to have been great shield areas with the rivers necessary to build deltas and according to paleogeographic maps the lands were sufficiently large to make delta building an active process. Furthermore, most of the seas were more protected by land barriers so that delta building should have been less hampered by the wave and current action that tend to disperse the sediment at present day stream mouths. An alternative explanation for the missing deltas may be that geologists have misinterpreted many ancient delta deposits. One reason that this may have been the case is that the typical textbook diagram of a delta (Fig.9) gives the impression that there are steeply dipping foreset beds lying between essentially horizontal bottomset and topset beds. The soundings outside the great deltas of the present day, however, show that the advancing slopes to which the name foreset bedding should be applied are almost universally very gentle. It is rare that they have inclinations of as much as 1" (SHEPARD, 1956, pp.2615-2620). If this were true also of most of the larger ancient deltas, it is easy to see how misinterpretations could have developed. The discordance in the dip of the foreset beds would be so slight that it would take a precise study before it could be recognized. Needed, therefore, are other criteria. The extensive work on the Mississippi delta (RUSSELL,1936; FISK,1944; FISKand MCFARLAN,1955; SHEPARD,1956, 1960; SCRUTON, 1960; LANKFORD and SHEPARD, 1960), on the Fraser delta (MATHEWS and SHEPARD. 1962), on the Rhone delta (VANANDEL,1955; KRUIT,1955; VANSTRAATEN, 1959), on the Orinoco delta (VANANDELand POSTMA,1954; NOTA,1958), and on the Volga delta (KLENOVA, 1956), to mention some recent studies, certainly have yielded sufficient information to provide the needed criteria. Much has been made of the socalled sand fingers of the Mississippi Passes lying between clay wedges of the interdistributary troughs (FISKand MCFARLAN, 1955). Theoretically such an arrangement should exist in deltas since the currents are, of course, stronger in the channels than in the overflow passageways and, hence, the sediments should be coarser. Unfortunately the very numerous cores and the shallow borings which we took in the Mississippi delta area during the American Petroleum Institute project failed to substantiate any marked differences in the sediments of these facies (SHEPARD and LANKFORD, 1959; SCRUTON, 1960). We found on the other hand that thick sand deposits coming from
w..:72c-.
+vcn
& -(
&.l'
rosstr BEOS
m s E r BEDS
OtSIRUClIONlL MPOSlIS
m i r o w BEDS
CROSS SECTION OF
I M BRlCAT ING
DELTAS
Fig.9. Typical delta profile with greatly exaggerated slope in foreset beds. (After SCRUTON, 1960.)
14
F. P. SHEPARD
the wells of the U. S. Army Engineers (KOLBand VAN LOPIK,1958; LANKFORD and SHEPARD, 1960) had characteristics that were indicative of stream channel point bars which are in a sense allied to the sand finger concept, although in the present stream channels they are discontinuous and bordered by mud deposits. Useful criteria for the marine facies of many deltas are the following: (I) Laminations (Fig.7~)consisting of very fine sand and silt alternating with silty clays. These are well developed on the delta front platforms around the Mississippi, Fraser, and Orinoco. (2) A coarse fraction in which Foraminifera and molluscs are scarce, but wood fibers are abundant and ostracods may be common. (3) Unusually large amounts of mica in the sediments because of the excessive mica transport by streams. (4) A very minor discordance between the well-laminated topset beds and generally unlaminated foreset beds. (5) Another minor discordance between the foreset beds and the equally unlaminated bottomset beds, the latter having a considerably greater quantity of Foraminifera and other organisms than found in the foresets. Transgressive deposits of the continental shelves One of the great problems confronting geologists has been to explain the wide extent of certain marine sand formations. At the present time sands are being deposited only rather near shorelines in the sea, and yet in the ancient sediments sand bodies of marine origin can be traced for hundreds of miles away from what is generally considered to be the direction of the shoreline. The study of continental shelf sediments has shown that sands are quite extensive on many shelves but these sands are ordinarily not contiguous to the shore and are likely to occur o n the outer shelf. An examination of the offshore sands (NOTA,1958; CURRAY,1960; NIINO and EMERY,1961) has shown that they are rather different in composition from sands found along the present shores, often being coarser and not infrequently more calcareous. They are clearly not being carried across the shelf from the lands at the present time, but are relict of a period of lower sea level. The finding of shallow water continental and lagoonal fossils in the sands confirms this assumption. In CURRAY’S (1960) study of the Texas shelf a considerable number of shells from the coarse sediments were collected and analyzed for age by 14C. The dates show that these deposits represent a transgressive series encroaching onto the lands as the sea rose after the last glacial stage. If a transgressing sea could produce widespread sand deposits off the Texas coast, it seems equally likely that many transgressions had the same effect in the past. When seas came in slowly across broad flat lands with gentle slopes, sand-carrying rivers should have provided sand deposits for deposition over the broad shallow water zones along the receding shore. Some of the faunas of the ancient marine sandstones suggest that the sands were
15
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
O-IOV.
OF TOTAL FORAMINIFERA
~ ' ' 10-~ 30% ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
73 0 - M %
PER CENT PLANKTONIC IN TOTAL
~~ ~
FORAMINIFERA
i
Fig.10. Map showing the general increase in planktonic Foraminifera in the total percentage of Foraminifera in crossing the continental shelf off the coast of Texas and southwestern Louisiana.
deposited far from the shore. This may mean, however, that the sands were reworked by waves and currents after the land had sunk, and the sands, although deposited near shore, were brought into an offshore zone by transgression without any appreciable covering because currents had inhibited deposition or because of scarcity of fine sediments in the overlying water. This is exactly what has happened along the Texas coast. A core we obtained in 80 m of water contained about 1 m of sand. All along the length of this sand there were Foraminifera characteristic of present day depths, but in addition there were macro-organisms of a shallow water facies (PARKER,1960). This mixture can be best interpreted as a shallow water sand low in Foraminifera that has been reworked under relatively deep water conditions, introducing the benthic Foraminifera of the present depth range. Distinguishing facies of the continental shelf
The study of the organisms of the continental shelf off the Gulf Coast of the United States has shown that it is possible to recognize assemblages of nearshore, inner shelf, and outer shelf (F. L. PARKER,1954; CURTIS,1960; R. H. PARKER, 1960; PHLEGER, 1960; LUDWICK and WALTON,1957). It is not only possible for an expert to distinguish these facies for the Gulf Coast, but rather easy for a geologist with a rudimentary knowledge of the difference between benthonic and planktonic Foraminifera to determine whether a sample is from the inner, intermediate, or outer shelf by the ratio of benthonic to planktonic that decreases outwardly (Fig.10). Also by finding the total per cent of Foraminifera in the coarse fraction similar results can be obtained since the Foraminifera also increase outwardly (CURRAY, 1960, fig. 12d). In some areas
16
F. P. SHEPARD
Fig.1 I . Showing the variation in sand content of a set of cores extending seaward from St. Joseph Island along the Texas Coast.
it was found that cores taken at successively greater distance from shore showed a rather constant decrease in sand lenses with increasing distances (Fig. 11). On the other hand little success has come from attempts to show a continuous decrease in the median diameters of the sediment with increasing distance from shore. The same is true of most other shelf areas of the world, although as EMERY ( I 952) has pointed out one of the reasons for the lack of outward decreasing grain-size is the presence of relict sediments on the outer and intermediate shelves. Distinguishing glacial marine from normal marine
The sediments in basins off many of the glaciated coasts of the world appear to have
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
17
characteristics which should make it possible to recognize the former existence of glaciers along the margins of ancient basins. The vast quantities of melting ice that existed along the coasts a few thousand years before the present resulted in the forming of icebergs that transported gravel, stones, and even boulders out to the basins. The forming of icebergs around the margin of Antarctica and Greenland at present is comparable to what existed more widely during the ice age. The present day bergs from Antarctica and Greenland are carrying away such quantities of coarse material that the sediments for hundreds of miles are influenced. For example, off the Grand Banks the slope sediments contain large quantities of rock fragments that may be partly residual from the Pleistocene but could be explained as well by the present day icebergs. Gravel and stones are found mixed with fine sediments in almost all samples from the Gulf of Maine (SHEPARD et al., 1934). Similar deposits arz reported from the Barents Sea (KLENOVA, 1960) and from the shelf off Norway (HOLTEDAHL, 1955). These anomalous sediments indicate that deposition has been rather slow since the last ice retreated from the coast. Otherwise the stones should be buried i n modern sediments. Probably the rivers in these areas still bring in a supply of rocks in ice flows during the spring, but it does not seem likely that these would be carried widely out over the continental shelves. In ancient sediments the finding of a considerable quantity of angular unweatherzd rock fragments scattered through fine-grained sediments is fairly good evidence of glacial marine origin. Other sources such as kelp, marine mammals, and mats of vegetation do not ordinarily transport morz than an occasional erratic to a basin, whereas icebergs bring great quantities of coarse dzbris. Iceberg stones are less likely to be rounded than stones introduced by marine mammals and are more likely to be of heterogeneous character than stones from the other sources since the continental glaciers have a larger source area. The presence of glacial striations, as reported by Holtedahl for the Norwegian shelf, would be confirmatory evidence. Recognition of deep water sands
The fine contributions made by Kuenen and his school of geology have led to the interpretation of turbidites, see list of references by KUENEN and HUMBERT (1964). This has explained the finding of deep water Foraminifera and other deep water organisms in sedimentary rocks associated with sand and gravel layers. The numerous findings of sand layers in cores from present-day deep water basins, troughs, and valleys are similarly intwpreted. Some authors, however, have begun explaining almost all marine sands as turbidites. For a complete understanding of the turbidite problem we need more study of the modern sediments as well as observations on turbidity currents in operation. To date they have been observed only in artificial lakes (GOULD,1951) where they are very slow moving and in Lake Geneva where slightly higher velocities are reported by DILL( 1964b). In recent years there have been rather extensive sampling operations
18
F. P. SHEPARD
along the California and lower California coast that have led to a considerable amount of information on the sand layers that are found in the slope valleys and on the fans as well as in the basins and troughs beyond (EMERY, 1960, pp.21&240; SHEPARD and EINSELE, 1962). Most recently with the help of the box sampler, A. H. Bouma, working with me off these same coasts, has obtained samples that are particularly helpful in interpreting the nature of deep sea sands. One thing which is becoming constantly more evident is that the sands that are carried to the deep basins and troughs move down the slopes along the axes of submarine valleys. Coring along slopes between valleys has almost universally failed to produce the alternating sand and mud layers that are typical of turbidites. On the other hand, most cores from submarine canyons have sand layers, particularly if the canyons extend in near to the shore. The studies of the stability of sediments carried on by MOORE(1961) and his associates at the San Diego Navy Electronics Laboratory, have shown that the sediments in the canyons are metastable and hence subject to sliding, whereas the slope sediments outside of canyons are in general stable. This discovery along with the finding that sand does move out along canyons implies that the basins of the past, into which turbidites were transported, also had submarine canyons of some sort to allow the transport. This in turn indicates that canyons of the sea floor are by no means a special feature of Pleistocene glacial stage origin. There is some disagreement on the definition that should be applied to graywackes, bLt I think that most geologists agree that graywackes are coarse sediments with a muddy matrix. There has been an attempt by some authors to explain graywackes as a product of turbidity currents and incidentally of deep water origin. We have analyzed inany deep water sands, both those obtained on Scripps Institution expeditions in the Pacific and many of the cores obtained by Lamont Geological Laboratory from the Atlantic (SHEPARD,1961). The result of these analyses has been that virtually all are fine to very fine sands, although a few have gravel and shells as wel! as coarse sand. Few samples of coarse sediment with a muddy matrix have been found. A core with gravel taken by Lamont from Hudson Canyon (shown to me by D. B. Ericson), proved to have the gravel embedded in a muddy matrix (Fig.12). Dredging along a channel in outer La Jolla Canyon showed that there were rounded claystone fragments, and R. F. Dill photographed some rounded boulders from the window of the bathyscaph “Trieste” while moving along the muddy floor in the same area (Fig. 13). Therefore, it may well be possible for coarse debris to be transported outward by some form of creep or mud flow along the canyons. This has long been recognized by Kuenen. Such an origin is suggested by the boulders found in a muddy matrix in the Plixene of the Ventura area of California (WINTERER and DURHAM, 1962, fig.63). It s e c n s likely, however, that at present most sands are being transported in a form that prevents the incorporation of coarse sand in a muddy matrix. This suggests that it is unwise to attribute graywackes to a turbidity current origin unless there is confirmatory evidence of another nature as Kuenen has found in some localities. The structures found by BOUMA(1962, fig.8) in his study of the French Alps have a characteristic alternation of graded sand covered by a laminated material of somewhat
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
19
finer grain-size and then by cross-bedded and ripple-marked fine sands in turn covered by mudstone. In one of the cores taken by the box corer in the outer La Jolla sub1 marine channel, Bouma found almost exactly this sequence (Fig. 14). Another: example, found by L. M. J. U. van Straaten (personal communication, 1963) is that
Fig.12. Pebbles embedded in muddy matrix found in core from the deep axis of Hudson Canyon. (Courtesy of D. B. Ericson, Lamont Geological Observatory.)
20
F. P. SHEPARD
Fig.13. Boulders photographed hy R. F. Dill from the port of the bathyscaph “Trieste” at 550 rn along the floor of La Jolla submarine channel outside the rock canyon. (Courtesy of Navy Electronics Laboratory.)
of a 17 cm thick graded turbidite layer from the small abyssal plain in the southeastern Adriatic. The structures in this bed are, from the base to the top: (a) horizontal laminations, (6) current ripple laminations, (c) convolute laminations, ( d )very fine horizontal laminations. This serves to show that the currents which emplaced the Alpine turbidites were probably similar in nature to the ones which have led to the deposits just mentioned. These certainly are remarkable examples of how the sediments of the past were laid down by processes still in operation at present. The recognition of ancient turbidites as noted by DOTT(1963) cannot be assured because of the presence of graywackes, graded bedding, or of sole marks and other similar criteria. All of them are developed as well or even better under other condi-
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
21
Fig.14. X-ray of box core taken in the f m channel off La Jolla Canyon at 1,028 m. The lower portion is a graded sand bed. This is covered by laminated sands including clay pebbles and the upper portion shows cross-bedding and ripple marks. The f o r e s t slopes, according to compass orientation, are down canyon. Cracks are due to disturbance in handling sediment slice. (Courtesy of A. H. Bouma 1
22
F. P. SHEPARD
tions. The repetition of relatively coarse graded beds with considerable fine intervening sediment and the presence of displaced and mixed faunas in the coarser sediments are apparently the most satisfactory indicators of turbidity current activity. I should like to emphasiz6the point that I have not tried to cover the entire field of comparison between ancient and modern sediments. Many important studies such as faunal assemblages, facies models, and mechanics and dynamics of sedimentation have not becn included, partly bxause of time limitations and partly because of my greater familiarity with the observational type of criteria. In conclusion I believe that one can now predict that acontinuation of studies along all of these fields should make it possible in the not distant future to determine the environments of deposition of virtually all sedimentary rocks that are not greatly altered by diagenesis.
SUMMARY
Evidence is presented favoring the hypothesis that “the present is the key to the past”. It is felt that the difficulties experienced by geologists in the use of modern sediments as a means of interpreting ancient sediments are due to the common lack of knowledge of sedimentary basins of the present day. Recent studies are rapidly filling in the gaps in this information. It is felt that there are plenty of present day basins in which this information is available and the sea level has been essentially constant for a long enough period to allow sediments of the various types to accumulate. Criteria that should be helpful in recognizing ancient environments have been gathered during the extensive operations conducted by the Scripps Institution of Oceanography along with many other organizations. In addition to faunal assemblages, criteria which have proved useful include the following: ( I ) Dune sands can usually be distinguished from adjacent beach sands by greater roundness, more heavy minerals, higher silt content, and smaller content of shells; along with the special aeolian type of cross-bedding. (2) Beach sands can be distinguished from adjacent shallow water formations by lower silt content and, as far as calcareous sands are concerned, by better sorting and less well-preserved fossils. ( 3 ) Lagoonal and estuarine deposits can often be distinguished from shallow shelf deposits by presence of abundant oysters, by scarcity or absence of glauconite and echinoids that are common on the shallow shelf, and by the finding of sandy clays low in silt that are rare on the shelf. (4) Marine delta facies can be recognized by the abundance of lamination, the scarcity of marine organisms along with an abundance of wood fibers, and in some cases by a very small discordance in dip between topset, foreset, and bottomset beds. (5) Extensive marine sand formations are often attributable to a transgressing sea with little deposition except along the advancing shoreline. (6) Glacial marginal deposits can be differentiated from normal marine deposits of
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
23
the same depth range by the presence of numerous scattered stones, mostly angular and often striated. (7) Deep water sands can be distinguished from those of shallow water by the repetition of numerous alternations between sand and mud, the sharp lower boundary of the sands, and the frequently graded nature of the sand beds. Here the help of paleontologists is particularly important since the deep sands often have mixed shallow and deep water Foraminifera. Differences in the ripple marks of shallow and deep water sands are also a promising approach to the problem.
REFERENCES
BOUMA, A. H., 1962. Sedimentology of some Flysch Deposits. A Graphic Approach to Furies Interpretation. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 168 pp. BRADSHAW, J. S . , 1961. Laboratory experiments on the ecology of Foraminifera. Contrib. Cushmon Found. Forum. Res., 12 (3) : 87-106. BROUWER, A,, 1962. Past and present in sedimentology. Sedimentology, 1 ( I ) : 2-6. CAYEUX, L., 1941. Causes ancienncs et Causes actuelles en Gkologie. Masson, Paris, 81 pp. CURRAY, J. R., 1960. Sediments and history of Holocene transgression, continental shelf, northwest F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent SediGulf of Mexico. In: F. P. SHEPARD, ments, Northwest Gulfof Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 221-266. CURTIS, D. M., 1960. Relation of environmental energy levels and ostracod biofacies in east Mississippi delta area, Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geolqyists, 44 (4) : 471494. DILL,R. F., 1964a. Features in the heads of submarine canyons; narrative of underwater film. In: L. M. J. U. VAN STRAATEN (Editor), Deltaic and Shallow Marine Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 101-104. DILL,R. F., 1964b. Submarine Erosion. Elsevier, Amsterdam. In preparation. DOIT JR., R. H., 1963. Dynamics of subaqueous gravity depositional processes. Bull. Am. Assor. Petrol. Geologists, 47 (1) : 104-128. EMERY, K. O., 1952. Continental shelf sediments of southern California. Bull. Geol. SOC.Am.. 63 : 1105-1 108. EMERY, K. O . , 1960. The Sea ofSouthern California.Wiley, New York, 366 pp. FISK,H. N., 1944. Geolqyical Invest4yation of the Alluvial Valley of the Lower Mississippi River. Miss. River Conunission, Vicksburg, 78 pp. FISK,H. N. and MCFARLAN JR., E., 1955. Late Quaternary deltaic deposits of the Mississippi River. In: A. POLDERVAART (Editor), Crust of the Earth - Geol. SOC.Am., Spec. Papers, 62 : 279-302. COULD,H. R., 1951. Some quantitative aspects of Lake Mead turbidity currents. In: J. L. HOUGH Editor), Turbidity Currents and the Transportation of Coarse Sediments to Deep Water -Soc. Eron. Paleontologists Mineralogists, Spec. Publ., 2 : 34-52. HOLTEDAHL.H., 1955. On the Norwegian continental terrace, primarily outside More-Romsdal: its geomorphology and sediments. With contributions on the Quaternary geology of the adjacent land and on the bottom deposits of the Norwegian Sea. Univ. Bergen, Arbok, Natunitenskap. Rekke, 14 : 209 pp. M. V. (Editor), 1956. Contemporary Sediments of the Caspian Sea. Acad. Sci., U.S.S.R. KLENOVA, Moscow, 303 pp. (Translated into English by Am. Geol. Inst., Washington, D. C.). KLENOVA, M. V., 1960. The Geolqyy of the Barents Sea (Russ.). Acad. of Sci., U.S.S.R., Moscow, 367 pp. English abstract in Marine Geology - Intern. Geol. Congr., 21 st., Copenhagen 1960, Repts. qf Soviet Geologists, 130 pp. KOLB,C. R. and VANLOPIK,J. R., 1958. Geology of the Mississippi River deltaic plain, southeastern Louisiana. U. S. Corps Engrs., Waterways Expt. Sta., Tech. Repts., 2 vols. : 3 4 8 3 and 3484. KRUIT, C., 1955. Sediments of the Rhdne Delta. I . Grain-size and Microfauna. Thesis, Rijksuniv. Groningen. Mouton, The Hague, 14 pp. - Verhandel. Ned. Geol. Miinbouwk. Gcnoot., 15 (3) : 357499. KUENEN, PH. H. and HUMBERT, F. L., 1964. Bibliography of turbidity currents and turbidites. In: A. H. BOUMA and A. BROUWER (Editors), Turbidites. Elsevier, Amsterdam, in press.
24
F. P. SHEPARD
LANKFORD, R. R. and SHEPARD, F. P., 1960. Facies interpretation in Mississippi delta borings. J. Geol., 68 (4) : 408426. LUDWICK, J. C. and WALTON, W. R., 1957. Shelf-edge, calcareous prominences in northeastern Gulf of Mexico. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. GeoloLyisrs,41 (9) : 2054-2101. W. H. and SHEPARD, F. P., 1962. Sedimentation of Fraser River delta, British Columbia. MATHEWS, Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists,46 (8) : 1416-1438. MOORE, D. G., 1961. Submarine slumps. J. Sediment. Petrol., 31 (3) : 343-357. N I I ~ OH. , and EMERY, K. 0..1961. Sediments of shallow portions of East China Sea and South China Sea. Bull. Ceol. Soc. Am., 72 : 731-762. NOTA,D. J. G., 1958. Sediments of the Western Giiiana Shelf- Reportsqfthc Orinoco Shelf Expedinon, 2 - Mededel. Landbouwhogeschool Wageniqpen, 58 (2) : 1-98. PARKER, F. L., 1954. Distribution of the Foraminifera in the northeastern Gulf of Mexico. Harvard Coll. Moseum C o n p . Zaol. Bull., I I 1 (10) : 453-588. PARKER, R. H., 1960. Ecolcgy and distributional patterns of marine macroinvertebrates, northern Gulf of Mexico. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL (Editors), Recent Sedinlents, Norrhuest Gu!fq/’Mexico. h i . Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 302-337. PHLEGER, F. B., 1960. Sedimentary patterns of microfaunas in northern Gulf of Mexico. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TI. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Cu!f of Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists. Tulsa, pp. 267-301. REINECK, H. E., 1963. Der Kastengreifer. Natur Museum, 93 : 65-68. RUSNAK, G. A,, 1960. Sediments of Leguna Madre. In: F. P.SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. V A N ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwesr Gulfof Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 153-196. RUSSELL, R. J . , 1936. Physiography of the Lower Mississippi River delta. Louisiana Geol. Surv., Geol. Bull., 8 : 3-199. SCRUTON, P. C., 1960. Delta building and the deltaic sequence. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL (Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Gulf of Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 82-102. SHEPARD, F. P., 1956. Marginal sediments of Mississippi delta. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 40 ( I 1 ) : 2537-2623. SHEPARD, F. P., 1960. Mississippi delta: marginal environments, sediments, and growth. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TI. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Gulf of Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 5 6 8 1 . SHEPARD, F. P., 1961. Deep sea sands. Intern. Geol. Coqgr., 21 st., Copenhagen 1960, Rept. Session, Norden, pp, 26-42. SHEPARD, F. P. and EINSELE, G., 1962. Sedimentation in San Diego Trough and contributing submarine canyons. Setfinientolqg, 1 (2) : 8 I- 133. SHEPARD, F. P. and LANKFORD, R. R., 1959. Scdinientary facies from shallow borings in Lower Mississippi delta. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Ceolqyists. 43 (9) : 2051-2067. SHEPARD, F. P. and MOORE, D. G., 1955. Central Texas coast sedimentation: characteristics of sedimentary environment, recent history, ar.d diagenesis. Biill. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 39 (8) : 1463- I 593. SHEPARD, F. P. and MOORE,D. G., 1960. Bays of central Texas coast. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Gulf of Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa. pp. 117-152. SHEPARD, F. P. and YOUNG, R., 1961. Distinguishing between beach and dune sands. J . Sediment. Petrol., 31 (2) : 19&214. SHEPARD, F. P., PHLEGER, F. B. and VAN ANDEL, TJ. H. (Editors), 1960. Recent Sediments, Northwest Gu!f qf Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, 394 pp. SHEPARD, F. P., TREFETHEN, J. M. and COHEE, G. V., 1934. Origin of Georges Bank. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am., 45 : 281-302. SHEPARD, F. P., MOBERLY JR., R., OOSTDAM, B. L. and VEEH,H. H., 1962. Beaches of ffawwii Abstract in Prqgr. Ann. Meeting Geol. Soc. Am., 1962 : 140-141A. TEICHERT, C., 1958. Cold- and deep-water coral banks. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geolocgists, 42 ( 5 ) : 1064- 1082. VANANDEL, TJ. H. and POSTMA, H., 1954. Recent Sediments of the Gulf of Paria - Reports of Orinoco ShelfExpedition 1. North-Holland, Amsterdam, 245 pp.
RECOGNIZING SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS
25
VAN STRAATEN, L. M. J. U., 1959. Littoral and submarine morphology of the RhBne delta. ln: R . J. RUSSELL (Editor), 2nd Coasrd Geography C o n ? ,Natl. Acad. Sci. Natl. Res. Council, Washington, D.C., pp. 233-264. WINTERER, E. L. and DURHAM, D. L., 1962. Geology of southeastern Ventura Basin, Los Angeles County, California. U.S. Geol. Surv., Profess. Papers, 334-H : 275-366.
SEDIMENTATION IN THE MODERN DELTA O F THE RIVER NIGER, WEST AFRICA I. R. L . A L L E N Sedinientology Research Laboratory, Geology Department, University of Reading, Reading (Great Britain)
INTRODUCTION
The Niger delta on the West African coast is the focus of drainage from a vast hinterland. It is a sandy delta of “classical” form merging westward with a beach barrierlagoon complex extending from the Lekki area to the River Volta (Fig. lc). The deposits top a thick pile of sediment, much of which is probably deltaic, accumulated from Cretaceous times onward in a downwarp athwart the continental margin (Fig. la). The delta has not previously been described sedimentologically, and this paper is written to outline for the first time salient characters of its depositional environments and lithofacies. Aspects of the delta are discussed by PUGH(1954), NEDECO(1954, 1959, 1961), and ALLENand WELLS(1962). The present study is based on observations made at more than 1,000 sample stations during a survey jointly organised and financed by Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij N.V. and The British Petroleum Company Limited; these companies are thanked for opportunities to study the Niger delta.
SEDIMENT SUPPLY AND DISPERSAL
Sediment entering the Niger delta area comes mostly from the coarsely crystalline basement complex and basement-derived Mesozoic-Tertiary sediments cropping o u t in the Niger and Benue drainage basins. The medium sand grade and finer material from the Niger Basin is characterised by hornblende, epidote, sillimanite, and zircon. Hornblende, epidote, zircon, and garnet typify the very coarse sand and finer debris from the Benue catchment, which for all its small size yields about 60% of the delta’s sand. Minor sediment contributions come from the Volta Basin via the coast, and from the basins of the Ogun, Oshun, and Cross Rivers. Epidote, hornblende, kyanite, and sillimanite mark the Volta’s contribution. NEDECO (1959, 1961) established that the yearly discharge of freshwater into the delta is about 200.109 nl3, of sand (< 0.1 mm) approximately l.106 m3, and of silt and clay ( < 0.1 mm) about 17-106m3. Patterns of dispersal in the delta area are shown in Fig.lb. Swift distributaries
b- DISPERSAL
RIVERS
/ 7
TIDAL CHANNELS LITTORAL CURRENTS
2
WAVE8 AND T I D A L
1
GUINEA
*/
CURRENTS
CURRENT
DEEP CURRENTS ( - 2 5 t m i l
-
0
SEA MILES 5 0
0
C-ENVIRONMENTS
n
KM
I W
d-GROSS LITHOLOGY
n
GRAIN SIZE
..." LIMIT MANGROVE SWAMP
/LIMIT
BEACH AND BEACH RIDGES
OF CLAYEY OF CLEAN
LIMIT OF VERY
SILT SILT FINE SAND
FINE GRNNED AND COARSER SAND
UNIFORM LAYERED UNIFORM
FINE oEw DEPOSITS COARSE
DEPOSITS
MIXED UNIFORM FINE AND LAYERED DEPOSITS MIXED UNIFORM COARSE NONDEPOSITIONAL
AREAS
1_] AN0
LAYERED DEPOSITS
Fig.1. Environmental and sedimentological features of the Niger delta area.
. . I
I
,
.
..
N
00
Fig. 2. Lithofacies based on core samples and grain size spectra of depositional environments in the Niger delta. Environments referred to in numbered columns: (1) floodplain; (2a) mangrove swamp; (2b) channel in mangrove swamp area; (3a) beach; (3b) channel in beach-ridge zone; (4) estuary; (5) river mouth bar; (6) delta platform; (7) prodelta slope; (8) open shelf; (9) continental slope; (10) non-depositional area. Sediment grades: vcs = very coarse sand; cs = coarse sand; rns = medium sand;,fs = fine sand; vfs = very fine sand; csi = clean silt; CIS = clayey silt; scl = silty clay;pd = plant debris. The cores shown in the lower part of the figure are about 0.075 natural size.
SEDIMENTATION IN THE MODERN NIGER DELTA
29
spread discharges radially but unequally through the delta proper from a centre near Aboh. The Nun exit passes to the sea about 26 % of the Niger’s freshwater discharge, and the Ramos and Forcados exits 29 and 15 % respectively; sediment discharges are correspondingly great. The remaining 30 % of the freshwater discharge divides between afurther 19 major exits. Once at sea sediment is dispersed by currents with directions parallel or at steep angles to the delta coast. Long swell waves from the south-southwest drive sand eastward along the beaches in the Lagos-Lekki area (barrier complex), northwestward in the western delta, and eastward in the eastern delta. Yearly drifts vary from 77,000 m3 in the central delta to 380,000 m3in the eastern and western sectors. Tidal currents disperse sediment at steep angles to the coast. They are strongest on the river mouth-bars, but still powerful enough to shift very fine sand or coarse silt into depths as great as about 20 fathoms. Doubtless rip currents also facilitate the transport of coarse scdiment from the littoral into deeper water. Parallel to the coast, silt and clay are dispersed inshore chiefly by strong, wave-generated, littoral currents and farther out by the slow west-east Guinea Current. According to BERRIT(1959). currents setting to the north or northwest operate on the continental shelf below 25 fathoms.
DEPOSITIONAL ENVIRONMENTS A N D LlTHOFAClES
Classification of the environments. Depositional environments in the Niger delta divide between terrestrial, transitional, and marine realms (Fig. Ic). The terrestrial realm is represented by the floodplain environment. The transitional realm includes the mangrove swamp, beach with beach-ridge, and estuarine environments. The marine realm divides into the river mouth-bar, delta platform, prodelta slope, opm shelf, continental slope, and non-depositional environments. Most of these are further divisible. Gross lithology of the delta. The delta sediments fine away from the dispersal centre near Aboh. Fig. Id shows the maximum distances from this centrz attained by sediments of different grades, using WENTWORTH’S (1922) classes for sand, and for finer material an arbitrary division into clean silt, clayey silt, and silty clay. Adapting MOOREand SCRUTON’S (1957) classification of bedding, the surface delta deposit (,< I m) is classified (Fig. Id) according to whether it is an essentially uniform one of fine sediment [silt, clayey silt, silty clay), an essentially uniform one of coarse sediment (sand, gravel), or a layered one of more or less closely interbedded fine and coarse sediments (e.g., silty clay and fine sand). This classification distinguishes between material deposited from suspended load, that deposited from bed load, and that deposited alternately from suspended load and bed load. Bed load deposition occurs chiefly in the terrestrial and transitional realms, while deposition from suspended load is most important in the marine realm. Variations in grain size and bedding over the delta are summarised in Fig.2 showing grain size spectra and lithofacies. Thus, away from the dispersal centre, the delta sediments become en mane better sorted as well as finer grained.
30
I. R. L. ALLEN
Reference should be made to Fig. 1 and 2 in following the descriptions of environments and lithofacies below. Floodplain environment. In this environment (8,400 kmz) sediment is erratically but persistently on the move. The meandering distributaries flow swiftly (50-1 20 cmlsec) over hummocky beds mostly of fine to medium sand. Typically, the channel-bed sands are cross-stratified and incorporate leaf or wood fragments, alternating very fine sand and clayey silt appearing locally. The point-bars are mostly of interbedded crossstratified and evenly stratified sand with some bands of clayey silt. During the March to November rains the distributaries top their banks to flood extensive backswamps. Levees of very fine sand with some clayey silt are built up, while in the backswamps accumulate close interbeds of plant debris, clayey silt, and very fine sand. Mangrove swamp environment. This is essentially a vegetated intertidal flat (9,000 km2) grading from the toe of the floodplain in the central delta but otherwise lapping onto pre-delta sediments. The swamps are crossed and connected to the sea by an intricate system of meandering creeks which feed with salt water and drain the inter-creek flats. Since the tidal capacity of the swamp is about 480.106 m3 (tidal range 1-2 m), the discharge from it of salt water vastly exceeds that of freshwater during each tidal cycle. The dominant plant is the red mangrove, a tree or shrub according to situation, its prop-root systems checking currents and trapping sediment. Quantities of the riverborne silt and clay flocculated in the brackish swamp water are deposited on the flats and creek point-bars as a black, organic-rich clayey silt. Sand remains largely on the creek beds, where it becomes unevenly interbedded with dark clayey silts and plant debris. Estuarine environment. The Calabar estuary (460 km2) is flanked by mud flats and mangrove swamps. Nowhere deeper than 5 fathoms and mostly shallower than 2.5 fathoms, the estuary bottom comprises large shoals elongated parallel to the tidal flows. Despite strong currents (up to 100 cmlsec) sand is in short supply, that drifting along the coast from the west toward the estuary becoming trapped on shoals at its western point. The estuary deposits are mostly interbedded dark gray clayey silts with plant debris, clean silts, and very fine to very coarse sands. Thick sands are restricted to the channels. Beach with beachridge environment. At the river exits sediment is sorted into coarse and fine fractions. Intense wave action drifts the coarse fraction away along the coast, sorting and rounding it further and building up continuous sand beach barriers between the river mouths. NEDECO (1954, 1961) report that the beach surfaces are gentle (gradients 1/50-1/100) and tolerably wide (50-200 m). Typically, the beaches are of clean, fine grained sand with gently inclined even laminae, but medium sand is present locally. Plant debris drifting from the river mouths often becomes buried in hollows on the beach surfaces under fresh sand influxes. Pavements of clay pebbles patchily cover beaches on eroding stretches of the coast. Back of the beach is a ridge from 1.5-3 m high followed inland by more ridges forming a zone a few hundred metres to I6 km wide (1,800 kmz). The densely forested ridges show an upper layer of leached sand with destroyed lamination, their freshwater trees contrasting sharply
SEDIMENTATION IN THE MODERN NIGER DELTA
31
on aerial photographs with the brackish-loving mangroves farther inland. Below root level even lamination is preserved. The ridges record earlier strand lines. River mouth bar environmenf. The river mouth-bars (1,600 km2) (PUCH, 1954; NEDECO,1961) are curved mounds of sediment lying out to sea just off the river exits. Each bar provides a shallow submerged connection between the beaches flanking the exit. The shape and character of each bar is a resolution of the local conflict between the drifting of sand by waves along the coast and the several discharges from the delta interior. Bar crests, swept by powerful waves and tidal currents, lie in depths generally less than 2 fathoms. They consist of clean, fine or medium sand with even lamination, cross-lamination, or cut-and-fill. Conditions are less extreme on the gently inclined bar flanks, where evenly laminated or cross-laminated, clean, very fine sand is found. Deeper still, near the toes of the bars (2.5-7 fathoms), are close interbeds of very fine sand, clean silt, and clayey silt with plant debris. Delta platform evironment. The delta platform (4,500 km2) is a gently inclined, terrace-like feature from 8-25 km across which extends from the beach to a break of slope between 4.5 and 10 fathoms. It is persistently but erratically supplied with suspended silt and clay by flows of turbid water emanating from the river exits and thereafter hugging the coast. Wave-generated and tidal currents are strong enough to move very fine sand and coarse silt across the platform from the vicinity of the beach. Inshore occurs evenly laminated or cross-laminated, fairly clean, very fine sand and coarse silt. Farther out on the platform is closely interbedded coarse silt and dark gray clayey silt with finely divided plant debris, thin bands of very fine sand appearing locally. Bioturbation structures and shell concentrations are common on the outer platform. Prodelta slope environment. This environment (7,800 km2) reaches from the delta platform to a depth of about 22 fathoms, where a thermocline separating two major water bodies intersects the sea bed (ALLENand WELLS,1962). The Guinea Current, the uppermost water body, drifts suspended silt and clay over the prodelta slope. Tidal and wave-generated currents, their strength diminishing with depth, are just competent to shift on the bottom whatever coarse silt or very fine sand attains the slope from nearer shore. Thus the shallower slope consists of thick layers of gray clayey silt and silty clay with plant debris interbedded with thin layers of evenly laminated or crosslaminated, clean, coarse silt and occasionally very fine sand. Bioturbation structures and shell pockets are plentiful. Farther out on the slope is bioturbated gray to greenish gray clayey silt. Open shelf environment. The open shelf (10,000 km2) is a smooth area extending from the 22 fathom line to the shelf break (42-108 fathoms). Tidal and wave-generated flows, unable to drag coarse bottom materials over the long haul from the coast, are competent to rework sand for short distances from non-depositional areas encompassed by the environment. Gentle currents steadily supply the open shelf with clay and silt. Grayish green silty clays devoid of lamination dominate the open shelf sediments, clayey silts being restricted to the central delta, and sand layers to the vicinity of non-depositional areas. Intense bioturbation points to the comparative slowness of deposition.
32
J. R. L. ALLEN
Continental slope environment. Conceivably deriving sediment from numerous sources, the continental slope environment (16,000 km2) is only known between the shelf break and 500 fathoms. The slope deposits are almost exclusively grayish green, intensely bioturbated, silty clays. At one station (253 fathoms) is a mass of shelly quartz sand, possibly slid from a non-depositional area at the shelf edge. Non-depositional environment. This term covers “outcrops” of quartz sand (5,100 km2)of Late Glacial to earlier Holocene age (JELCERSMA, 196 1) on which no significant deposition has occurred subsequently. The outcrops divide between a near-shore zone and a deeper one around the shelf edge. The shallower sands are typically clean and well sorted, being fine to very coarse grained, with plentiful abraded shell and rare glauconite. Minimum radiocarbon ages range from 3,380 150 to 1,190 k I50 years BP. Usually the deeper sands are muddy and rich in glauconite, shell, and foraminifera. They vary from coarse silt to coarse sand grade, showing abundant bioturbation structures. Minimum ages range from 12,250 240 to 10,750 f 250 years BP. Echograms show the exposed sands to be part of an otherwise deeply buried sheet which encompasses the entire continental shelf and probably reaches into the hinterland. Locally no thicker than 19 cm, the sheet rests disconformably on sediments of an earlier (?) delta.
COASTAL BARRIER COMPLEX
WEBB(1958) and HILLand WEBB(1958) briefly described beach barrier-lagoon complexes of the West African Coast. That complex lying immediately west of the Niger delta, and within the influence of the delta, embraces two large lagoons, Lekki Lagoon and Lagos Lagoon, both mostly shallower than 1.5 fathoms and divided from the sea by sandy beach-ridges. Direct connection with the sea is achieved at Lagos. Brackish water fills the lagoons in the dry season but during the rains is largely flushed out. Rivers building small deltas bring varied sediments to the lagoons. Organic-rich mud is accumulating in the deeper parts and clean, medium grained sand near the shores. Mangroves fringe the lagoons locally.
SEDIMENTARY FRAMEWORK A N D EVOLUTION
The stratigraphy of the Niger delta is as follows: younger suite - later Holocene older sands - Late Glacial-earlier Holocene pre-older sands - pre-Late Glacial The younger suite covers lithofacies in the floodplain, mangrove swamp, beach with beach-ridges, estuarine, delta platform, river mouth-bar, prodelta slope, open shelf, and continental slope environments. Older sands are exposed in the non-depositional areas, the pre-older sands lying immediately beneath them. Fig.3 amplifies this SUC-
33
SEDIMENTATION I N THE MODERN NIGER DELTA ONITSHA
NUN R
NEAR
BRASS R
5 T NICHOLAS R
BRASS
LEGEND
I__j
Den0 plotform foc,es
Prodelto slope f o c m
rj
B e a c h focles
BOoen
shelf focles
Mouth bar focies
Fig.3. Schematic facies relations in the Niger delta. a. Section along axis of delta. b. Section parallel to coast along beach-ridge zone.
cession by summarising facies distributions in the Niger delta as inferred from surface and subsurface (very scanty) data. Offshore and probably in coastal areas the delta mass commences with the sheet-like older sands analogous to the strand-plain deposits of the Mississippi and Rhbne deltas (FISKand MCFARLAN, 1955; SCRUTON,1960; KRUIT, 1955; VANSTRAATEN,1959, 1960). The floodplain facies grades seaward into sheet-like bodies of offshore silty clay and clayey silt, nearshore mixed clayey silt, clean silt and sand, clean littoral sand, and inland mixed swamp and channel-fill deposits. Thus the delta differs from the Mississippi bird-foot in framework in not having finger-like river sands (FISK,1961), but agrees essentially with other “classical” deltas like that of the RhBne (KRUIT,1955; VANSTRAATEN, 1959, 1960). The Niger delta evolved simply. After a low-stand of sea-level which brought the river mouths and strand line close to the edge of the continental shelf, the transgressing Late Glacial to earlier Holocene seas advanced inland to deposit the littoral older sands. Once sea level became stable the strand retreated seaward, carrying with it the several lithofacies of the younger suite. Thus in the Niger delta is recorded a transgression and subsequent regression of the sea in a subsiding region gathering sediment from a vast source area. Its deposits constitute a cyclothem: coarse grained littoral deposits at the base are succeeded by fine grained offshore sediments which grade upward into littoral sands and delta-top deposits.
SUMMARY
The cycle of deposits present in the modern Niger delta has been built up during a transgression of the sea (Late Glacial to earlier Holocene) and a subsequent regression (later Holocene). Quartz sands enriched with glauconite or shell debris were deposited at an advancing strand line during the transgression. The regression of the sea has been accompanied by the distribution, by wave and current action, of terrigenous sand, silt,
34
J . R. L. ALLEN
clay, and plant debris between the following principal environments: floodplain, mangrove swamp, estuary, beach with beach-ridges, river mouth bar, delta platform, prodelta slope, open shelf, and continental slope. The lithofacies deposited in these environments overlie the earlier transgressive sands.
REFERENCES
ALLEN,J. R. L. and WELLS,J. W., 1962. Holocene coral banks and subsidence in the Niger delta. J . Geol., 7 0 : 381-397. BERRIT,G. R., 1959. Rbultats scientifiques des campagnes de la “Calypso”: Golfe de Guinee. 11. Octanographie physique. Ann. Inst. OcPanop., Paris, 37 : 37-73. FISK. H. N., 1961. Bar-finger sands of Mississippi delta. In: J. A. PETERSON and J. C. OSMOND (Editors), Geometry of Sandstone Bodies.Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 29-52. FISK,H. N. and MCFARLAN, E., 1955. Late Quaternary deltaic deposits of the Mississippi River. In: A. POLDERVAART (Editor), The Crust of the Earth. - Geol. SOC.Am. Spec. Papers, 62 : 279-302. HILL, M. B. and WEBB,J. E., 1958. The ecology of Lagos Lagoon. 11. The topography and physical features of Lagos Harbour and Lagos Lagoon. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London, Ser. B, 241 : 319-333. JELGERSMA, S., 1961. Holocene sea level changes in The Netherlands. Mededel. Ceol. Sficht., Ser. c-VI, 7 : 1-101. KRUIT,C . , 1955. Sediments of the RhBne delta, I. Grain size and microfauna. VerhandeL Koninkl. Ned. Geol. Mijnbouwk. Genoot., Geol. Ser., 15 : 357-514. MOORE,D. G. and SCRUTON, P. C., 1957. Minor internal structures of some Recent unconsolidated sediments. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 41 : 2723-2751. NEDECO(Netherlands Engineering Consultants), 1954. Western Niger Delta, Report on Investigation. Nedeco, The Hague, 57 pp. NEDECO,1959. River Studies and Recommendations on Improvement of Niger and Benue. North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1,000 pp. 1961. The Waters ofthe Niger Delta. Nedeco, The Hague, 317 pp. NEDECO, PUCH,J. C., 1954. Sand movement in relation to wind direction as exemplified on the Nigerian coastline. Res. Notes Univ. Ibadan, Nigeria, 5 : 14 pp. SCRUTON, P. C., 1960. Delta building and the deltaic sequence. In: F. P. SHEPARD,F. B. PHLECER and TJ. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Nortliwest Guyof Mexico, 1951-58. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 82-102. VANSTRAATEN. L. M. J. U.. 1959. Littoral and submarine momholoev of the RhBne delta. In: R. J. L u, RUSSELL(Editor), Proc. 2nd. Coastal Geogruph. C o n ? , Louisiana State Univ. Baton Rouge, pp. 233-264.
VANSTRAATEN, L. M. J. U., 1960. Some recent advances in the study of deltaic sedimentation. Liverpool Manchester Geol. J . , 11 : 41 1 4 2 . WEBB,J. E., 1958. The ecology of Lagos Lagoon. I. The Lagoons of the Guinea coast. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London, Ser. B, 241 : 307-318. WENTWORTH, C . K., 1922. A scale of grade and class terms for clastic sediments. J . Geol., 30 : 377-392.
STRUCTURE E N CRENEAUX ET BRECHE CYCLOPGENNE EN MILIEU DfiTRITIQUE PARALIQUE ARNOLD BERSIER MusPe gPologique, Lausanne [Suisse)
Une paroi rocheuse d’une exceptionnelle grandeur a t t t rckemment dtgagte 8 Vennes, au nord de Lausanne (Suisse) pour le passage d’une autoroute dans une colline de molasse de 1’Aquitanien suptrieur. Des affleurements si vastes n’existent pas dans la nature, en raison de l’alttration rapide de cette roche. Celui-ci a mis en tvidence un exemple de b r k h e cyclopkenne de marne dans le grts, due ti une crtnelure d’trosion, qui depasse de beaucoup en &endue et signification les structures de ce genre, difficilement observables dans les petits affleurements ordinaires de ce facits. La paroi est taillte dans une masse de g r b q u i a I’apparence d’une couche unique. Prts du sommet apparait un alignement discontinu et crtnelt de plaques d’une marne gris-jaune, finement stratifite (Fig. I). Les fragments sont kpais de 0 , 3 4 6 m, longs de 1-3 m, laissant entre eux des intervalles de mCme ordre. Dans l’ensemble ce chapelet est horizontal, paralltle 8 la stratification gtntrale, mais les fragments sont plus ou moins inclines et certains sont tordus. Ces morceaux de marnes sont complttement enrobts par le grts. Au mur, au toit et de chaque cbtt, le mCme sable les entoure. C’est 18 le caracttre le plus tnigmatique de a
50 m
b
I----------
1
. . . _. . ._-. .- -. -.-.- .. . . ....... .. .. .. .. . . ..................... ......................
....i...... -A.
.... I
b
I 1
1
.:.c:. . . ..:. .:: .
10 m
2.5rn
. . . . . . . .1 . . . . . . . . . . . .
I
’ ..:+.:. ................................................. ........................
Fig.1. a. Ensemble de l’affleurement. b. Partie ouest de l’affleurement avec les crkneaux de mame, reliques de couche dtniveltes. c. Detail de I’affleurementA structure de brkhe marneuse cyclopkenne dam le gres, et cicatrice d’erosion dissimulk sable sur sable, mais jalonnk par des galets m o m
36
A. BERSIER
cette structure. A premiire vue ces gros blocs ont une apparence allochtone; leur transport n’ttant absolument pas de la compttence du courant transporteur du sable ambiant, quel pourrait Ctre l’agent de mise en place et de dissemination de cet alignement de blocs, intervenant brusquement en cours de stdimentation sableuse? Le mystkre est d’autant plus grand que ces blocs de marne ne forrnent pas seulement une ligne. Les travaux d’excavation de la paroi ont rtvtlt leur ttendue dans tous les sens. 11s sont disposts cornme des pavts largement espacts. Dtnivelts et souvent bascuIts, ils ne se superposent jamais. La gentse d’une telle structure sdimentaire, examinte en elle seule et dans son seul cadre immtdiat, resterait inexplicable, ou inciterait i irnaginer l’intervention de courants transporteurs d’une violence extraordinaire. Replacte au contraire dans le cadre gtiitral de la stdimentation molassique paralique, cette structure en crtneaux devient explicable par analogie avec d’autres formes stdimentaires du meme faciis. Elle n’en garde pas rnoins une originalitt et une signification qui mtritent inttrtt. I1 se peut que d’autres brtches cycloptennes - i tltments gigantesques - des pseudo-nodules de grande taille, des pseudo-concrttions, reltvent d’une origine semblable. Rappelons que cette format‘on molassique est constitute de couches de grbs (molasses a ciment calcaire, macignos h grain plus fin et A ciment argilo-calcaire), de marnes et argilites, tous ces ternies formant une gamme granulomttrique complkte. Ces couches sont assocites en groupes ou stquences cycliques: les cyclothkrnes, qui montrent une granodtcroissance progressive de bas en haut. Ces particularitts ont t t t dtcrites anttrieurement de faGon plus complkte (BERSIER,1958). Les sommets ou toits des cyclothtmes ont t t t frtquemnient dtcapts par une erosion prtctdant le dCpBt du sable de base du cyclothtme suivant. L‘trosion est bien apparente si le grts de base se superpose 2 une marne ou argilite, en moulant par ses indentations les ichancrures de cette dernikre. Si l’trosion a t t t plus profonde, entaillant jusqu’au corps sableux encore non consolid6 du cyclothtme prtctdent, la cicatrice est beaucoup rnoins visible: le sable dtpost aprts l’erosion se confond avec le sable attaqut par I’trosion. D a m la phase finale de l’trosion, quand le courant dirninuait et que le depBt s’amorcait, le m&me sable ttait arracht ou dtpost, selon d’infimes variations de compttence dtpendant de la rugositt du fond du chenal. Sable trodt et sable nouvellenient apportt se sont donc mClts alors en une m h e phase granulomttrique. Ce mimttisme a dissimult toute cicatrice, les deux bancs de grks sont coalescents et n’en sirnulent qu’un seul. Pourtant des cicatrices dissiniulees peuvent &tremises en evidence dans de semblables cas, soit par continuitt avec des traces lattrales d’trosion mieux marqutes sur des ttnioins marneux, soit par des difftrences de straticulation, soit surtout par des “galets mous” arrachts aux couches marneuses voisines. L’exanien minutieux de l’affleurement de Vennes rtvble la prtsmce de tels galets mous, souvent tcrasts, en chapelet entre les blocs de marne (Fig.lc). Ils soulignent les sillons d’trosion dans les intervalles. Les crtneaux apparaissent ainsi cornme des reliqiies d’une couche marneuse con-
STRUCTURE EN CRBNAUX ET
BRBCHE
CYCLOP~ENNE
37
Fig.2. Formation de la brkhe par erosion en cours de stdiniei Lation. a. Wash-out et attaque de la couche marneuse par ]’erosion. b. Morcellement de la couche par les chenaux. c. Affouillement du sable, basculernents et slumping. d. Enfouissement des blocs par reprise de la sedimentation sableuse.
tinue, entamke et dtcoupte par l’trosion. Aprks avoir rompu la carapace marneuse non encore lapidifiie, ? l’ttat i de vase compacte et probablement thixotropique, 1’61-0sion a affouillt plus facilement le sable sous-jacent encore meuble. Le sapement lateral sous les tables marneuses a provoqut leur tassement sur place, leur basculement avec ou sans translation. Des diplacements et basculements complexes ont pu ainsi se produire par ttapes successives. La mise en porte en faux des tronqons marneux plastiques a dtterniint des ecoulements ou slumpings de leurs tranches. No11 seulement les rnorceaux ont t t t denivelts, mais ils ont pris de ce fait des formes bizarres et contourntes. Une telle difference de rtsistance B I’trosion est conforme aux exptriences de HIULSTROM [ l939), dont les diagrammes devenus classiques montrent qu’un courant de I’ordre de 30 cm/sec peut eroder des grains de 0,l-1 mm de dianiktre (dimension de nos sables) sans Ctre capable d‘arracher des grains de 0,001-0,l mni (correspondant ii nos marnes) dont la cohesion acquise par compaction est plus tlevte que celle des sables. Des graphiques de cet auteur, on peut conclure que le vitesse des ourants trosifs des sables Ctait comprise entre 0,3 et 1 mjsec et qu’elle a dQ&tresuptrieure a ce dernier chiffre pour attaquer les marnes, cette dernikre donnte itant incertaine car i’action abrasive du sable sur les sediments fins a t t t vive. Le dipat des sables seuls a pu s’effectuer eiisuite avec des vitesses de courant s’abaissant B enviroii 5 cmlsec. L‘intervention de courants extraordinaires, B m&mede dtplacer des blocs, est superflue dans la genkse de cette structure. L’alternance des phases de skdimentation et
38
A. BERSIER
d’trosion, maintes fois manifestte dans ce milieu molassique paralique ii faibles variations du niveau de base, et command& par les divagations d’embouchures, est une cause suffisante. Elle suggtre de larges wash-outs par trosion en nappe au devant des embouchures mouvantes, distributrices des stdiments.
Une structure en crtneaux formte de fragments de marne dans un grts molassique aquitanien a CtC dtcouverte par la construction d’une autoroute au nord de Lausanne (Suisse). Les creneaux sont dtsalignts et simulent une br2che cycloptenne (brkhe A Cltments gtants). La genkse de cette structure est explicable par un tpisode d’trosion en cours de stdimentation, analogue a ceux que montre ordinairement cette formation dttritique cyclique en milieu paralique, constquences du dtplacement periodique des embouchures sur le delta. Le wash-out a segment6 la couche de marne, affouillt le sable inftrieur, et provoqut le basculement et le slumping des fragments de marne encore non consolidts. La skdimentation sableuse a repris ensuite. La cicatrice d’trosion invisible, sable sur sable, est soulignte par des galets mous.
SUMMARY
A structure of large, tilted blocks of marl, embedded in Aquitanian molasse sandstone was recently exposed during the construction of a through-way north of Lausanne, Switzerland. Together, the blocks form a breccia on a giant scale. Its origin may be explained by assuming an interlude of erosion, interrupting a depxitional period, such as have been found elsewhere in this cyclical, detrital formation of paralic facies, and which can be ascribed to periodic shifts of the river mouths in a delta. Wash-outs have cut through the marl layer into the underlying sand, after which the blocks of unconsolidated marl were undermined by lateral erosion of sand, became tilted and slid down sideways. Subsequently, deposition of new sand took place. The erosion surface, which is at most places invisible owing to its position between two sands of the same composition, is locally marked by small pebbles of marl.
BIBLIOGRAPHIE
BERSIER, A.. 1958. Sequences detritiques et divagations fluviales. E c l q p e Geol. Helv., 5 1 (3) : 842-853. HIULSTROM, F., 1939. Transportation of detritus by running water. In: P. D. TRASK (Editor), Recent Marine Sediments. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 5-3 1 .
SPECIFIC FEATURES O F DELTAIC DEPOSITS I N COAL-BEARING AND CUPRIFEROUS FORMATIONS L. N . B O T V I N K I N A
and v . s.
YABLOKOV
Geological Institute, Academy of Sciences, Moscow (U.S.S.R. )
INTRODUCTION
Deltaic deposits, as well as coastal-marine sediments, have been distinguished in fossil formations for quite some time. However, this has been done mostly by the place they occupy between typically marine and typically continental deposits. In this distinction the entire complex of deposits formed in deltaic environments has usually been considered as a whole. Yet, it mostly comprises strongly different facies. A major division can be made in continental deposits, formed on the landward side of the delta shoreline [river-, peat bog-, lake sediments etc.) and of marine sediments of the subaqueous parts, among which one may mention bands of various coastal-marine deposits. Detailed lithological researches carried out in recent years made it possible to establish textural, structural and other features characteristic for the (usually arenaceous) deposits of the submerged parts of the deltas and their differences as compared with other coastal-marine deposits. The established features permitted us to determine the deltaic origin of a number of sandstones in the coal measures of the Donetz Basin as well as in the series of cupriferous sandstones in the southern Urals and other areas (BOTVINKINA et al., 1956; ZHEMCHUZHNIKOV et al., 1959, 1960; BOTVINKINA et al., 1963; BOTVINKINA, 1963). With regard to the brief character of this communication these features are presented as a general result of all data obtained. They can be subdivided into two groups: (I) Features discernible directly in rock specimens or exposures, textural, structural (especially lamination), inclusions, etc. Features of this group are mostly similar in deltaic deposits of different sedimentary formations. (2) Specific features of the major structures of the deltas and their relations to the adjoining deposits. Here we see both similarities and differences, depending on the conditions under which the deltaic lenses have been formed in different environments.
LITHOLOGY AND STRUCTURES
Deposits of the (originally) submerged parts of the deltas are at most places repre-
40
L. N. BOTVINKINA AND V. S. YABLOKOV
sented by sandstones, mainly of medium grain. In some cases they are coarser and may pass into conglomerates, while in other cases they are of finer grain. The sorting of the grains varies; usually it is medium. They frequently contain pebbles and slightly rounded fragments of more fine-grained rocks (argillites, aleurolites), derived from underlying beds. It is interesting that the admixture of such fragments and pebbles often took place without a concomitant general coarsening of the enclosing arenaceous material. In this respect they differ from river deposits, where the appearance of pebble material is usually accompanied by a general coarsening of the sandstone. Sometimes a rhythmical sorting of grains is recorded in each oblique lamina, but it is expressed rather poorly and not so characteristic as in river deposits. Typical for deltaic formations is the presence of coarse-grained deposits in their middle part. Herein they differ from river sediments, where the lower part is generally the coarsest and usually marked by wash-out structures. A very characteristic feature of the delta deposits is their lamination (BOTVINKINA, 1962). In some cases these were formed under the influence of complicated hydrodynamic conditions in the basin near the estuarine parts of the rivers. Just in front of its mouth the flow of a river, in general, continues by inertia, but it spreads out, the velocity thereby becoming lower and lower the further it gets from the coastline. The influence of the normal marine currents and of the waves (swell) in the basin thereby becomes more pronounced. The flow of the river shows periodic increases (for instance during river floods) and decreases. It often happens that the main direction of outflow into the sea varies from one flood stage to the next one. As a result, the oblique sets of laminae in the arenaceous deposits of the submerged part of the delta shows a wide variation in orientation. In this manner a cross-laniination of large dimensions is produced. It is likely that the conditions in the investigated fossil deltas were of the above described type. The azimuths of the dip of the laminae in these sediments may vary within a range of approximately 180”. The angles of inclination of the laminae and the boundaries of sets of laminae show a strong variation. They fluctuate probably from 3 0 4 ” . A very characteristic feature is that the dip angle of the laminae increases within single sets. Along with large cross-laminated sets several tens of centimeters thick, there are also smaller sets (less than 10 cm in thickness). Cross-lamination can be manifest by minor changes of the granulometric coniposition of the laminae, as well as by the occurrence of various admixtures on or close to the planes of separation of the laminae. In coal measures these admixtures often consist of plant debris. In cupriferous formations the “lamination planes” are often marked by copper-containing minerals. In a number of cases one finds inclusions of relatively large, charred or mineralized vegetable remains. In the cupriferous formations of Priuralie they are associated with copper carbonates (malachite, azurite), which form incrustations and coatings on the surface of organic remains. No fauna has been found in the deposits of the submerged part of the deltas, neither in the coal-bearing, nor in the cupriferous ones. These deposits are characterized by the presence of various pebbles, which by their preferred orientation render the cross-
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF DELTAIC DEPOSlTS
41
lamination still more conspicuous. In the investigated cupriferous sediments, formed under conditions of arid climate, the place of such pebbles is often taken by carbonate and ferruginous concretions washed out from the underlying beds. Deltaic deposits of the cupriferous sandstone formations are also characterized by a more varied composition of pebbles than is usually found in marine sandstones of the same formation. Along with rounded fragments of adjacent and underlying beds of aleurolites and argillites, one here encounters also pebbles of many other rock types which cropped out in the source areas eroded by the rivers.
FACIES CHANGES AND RELATIONS TO UNDERLYING AND BORDERING FORMATIONS
The lower contact of the sandstones formed on the submerged parts of the deltas is usually sharp and often produced by erosion of the underlying sediments but it is more even than at the base of river channel deposits. The wash-outs become less distinct as one advances in the (original) seaward directions. A very typical feature of the deposits of the submerged part of the deltas is the combination of cross-laminations and beds with ripple-mark laminations and with coastal-marine laminations. These beds were, apparently, formed where the river flow became weaker or where its direction changed and waves and swell of the sea basin became a predominant hydrodynamic factor. Also characteristic are the ways in which the submerged delta deposits pass into adjacent sediments, both in horizontal and in vertical sense. Both the coal-bearing and cupriferous delta sediments are usually developed in the regressive series of facies in which a gradual change is found from deeper-basin types to more shallow-basin sediments and finally to continental deposits. The relations with other sediments depend to a large extent on the general environmental conditions during which these rocks were formed, but also on the position, which each point of deposition occupied in respect to the coast line. Obviously, the influence of littoral processes increases with decrease of the distance to the coast. In this direction the deposits of a submerged delta gradually acquire more features in common with those of typical alluvium (in other words continental river deposits). The further from the coast, the stronger the features of the newly formed sediment reflect the influence of the sea. The enclosing facies and, hence, the entire succession will, correspondingly, be of either more continental and littoral or of more marine character. As to the general environments, their influence is much more complicated. Delta formations originating in a humid climate, such as the coal measures in the Carboniferous depression of the Donetz Basin, are characterized by their superposition, often even with gradual transitions, on typically marine deposits. After deposition of a sufficiently thick (up to 15-20 m) sandy series, corresponding to the submerged part of the delta environment, the sediments gradually acquire morc and more features pointing to shallowing of the water. The final stage of complex deltaic deposition is usually represented by littoral (marine or lagoon) sediments of the swell-ripple zone, which
42
L. N. BOTVINKINA A N D
V. S.
YABLOKOV
originate under conditions of a very shallow sea. At higher levels these deposits change gradually into deposits of lagoons, lakes and land bogs, alternating sometimes with typical alluvium, the open sea environment having been replaced by the continental deltaic environment. Deltaic deposits described by us from the Upper Permian formations of the Suburalian depression also overlie basin deposits but usually with a sharp wash-out contact, which in the coal measures of the Donetz Basin has been recorded only in profiles near the original coast line. In Priuralie, on the other hand, the sediment composed of river borne material, deposited in the forelying sea, are of much smaller thickness (3-5 m). The sandstones of the submerged delta become more and more homogeneous and fine-grained as one moves upwards along the profile and change at the top again into basin deposits (though the depths of these basins apparently were very small). Thus, the succession here does not terminate with deposits of continental facies (Fig.4). On the contrary, these features indicate formation at a greater distance from the old coastline. An explanation of all these facts should, probably, be sought in the character of the general environment, and in the regime of the streams which created these deltas. In the Donetz Basin these latter were rather large rivers, emptying into a wide sea gulf. In Priuralie the streams werc much smaller, but more torrential. They poured periodically into shallow water areas, that were sometimes, perhaps, of the lacustrine type. Owing to their temporary high current velocities, they badly eroded previously deposited bottom sediments. The activity of these streams died down much faster than that of the rivers of the Donetz Basin and the original more or less quiet regime of sedimentation was re-established in the basins, their floor not having emerged above the water level.
EXAMPLE OF COAL MEASURE DELTA IN THE DONETZ BASIN
As a result of our regional and sectional researches (ZHEMCHUZNIKOV et al., 1959-1960;
BOTVINKINAet al., 1956) the relations between the deposits of the submerged part of the delta and the various other facies can be presented in much detail (Fig.], 2). On Fig. 1 we see how the area occupied by arenaceous sediments of the submerged part of the delta (having a rather complicated configuration) is bordered on two sides by arenaceous-aleuritic deposits of littoral shallow water and lacustrine facies and on the side of the open sea by aleuritic marine deposits. In a profile (Fig.2) the complicated relations are seen of the deltaic lens with the adjacent facies as traced in detail by a number of closely spaced bore holes. Laterally, delta deposits change quite distinctly into sandy deposits of spits, bay-bars and bars, or into stretches of littoral-marine sandstones extending along the coast line of the sea and barring the lagoon areas. Landwards they change into linearly extended sandstone bodies typically formed in rivers and orientated perpendicularly to the old coast line (Fig.3).
43
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF DELTAIC DEPOSLTS
2
A
z
4km
2
0
Fig.1. Areal relations of deposits of the submerged part of the delta with other deposits. Cycle Ii-L, of C! suite in Dolzhansk region of the Donetz Basin. Symbols: 1 = sandstones of the submerged part of the delta; 2 = arenaceous-aleuritic deposits of the swell-ripples zone of the tidal-lagoon coast; 3 = argillaceous-aleuritic and arenaceous deposits of coastal lakes; 4 = id., but more finegrained and with well preserved plant remzins; 5 = thin intercalations of aleurolites in the zone of swells of the littoral part of the sea. A-A = section line (seeFig.2). Circles = bore holes.
0
loo0
2000
3
4
3000
5
6
4000
8
5ow
9
10
7000
6000
11
12
13
8000
14
15
9000
10000
l l W m
16
Fig.2. Relations between the deposits of the submerged part of the delta with other deposits in a profile. Facies profile along the line A-A (see Fig.1) compiled by Botvinkina. Vertical lines = sections of bore holes. Brackets on the right give the boundaries of a cycle with coal seam 1: and limestone L,. T = transgressive part of the cycle. P = regressive part of the cycle. In this diagrdm the base of limestone L, is taken as a horizontal line. Symbols: 1 4 = marine deposits (I = limestone; 2 = calcareous argillite with marine fauna; 3 = argillite with msrine fauna; 4 = argillite and fine-grained aleurolite without fauns). 5 = argillite or fine-grained aleurolite with a brackish lagoon fauna. &8 = intercalation of aleurolites in the swell zone of the littoral part of the sea (6 = thin intercalation with a thickness of lamina of 1-2 mm; 7 = intercalation with a thickness of lamina up to 1-2 cm; 8 = thick intercalation with a thickness of lamina up to several tens of centimeters). 9 = arenaceous-aleuriticdeposits of thezone of swell ripples of the tidal-lagoon coast. 10 = arenaceous deposits of the submerged part of the delta (river miterial carried into the sea). 11-12 = lacustrine deposits (11 = aleurolites and sandstones with vegetable detritus; 12 = aleurolites and argillites with a well preserved flora). 13-16 = continental peat bog deposits (13 = mostly aleuritic deposits of swampy plains: “subsoil” of a coal seam; 14 = argillites and aleurolites with root remains: floor of a coal seam; 15 = coal argillites of silted peat bogs; 16 = coal seams, deposits of peat bogs).
44
L.
N.
BOTVINKlNA AND V. S . YABLOKOV
Fig.3. Transitions of arenaceous deposits of different facies. Paleogeographic map compiled for the H
end of the regressive part of the cycle with coal seam IS, suite Ci of the Donetz Basin. Compiled by Botvinkina. Symbols: 1 = bogged land; 2 = river sandstones; 3 = coast line; 4 = smdstones of the submerged part of the delta; 5 = sandstones of spits, bay-bars and bars; 6 = sandstones of bottom nisrine currents; 7 = arenaceous-aleuritic deposits in the zone of swell ripples of the lagoon-tidal coast; 8 = aleuritic deposits of the swell zone of the littoral part of the sea.
GENERAL CONCLUSIONS
Thus, on account of their position, the sandstones may be regarded with sufficient confidence as the deposits of the submerged part of the delta. For this reason we are justified in using the features of these deposits as indications of sediments of the submerged parts of deltas also in other cases. The generaUy recurrent complex of these features both structural-textural and generally geological, permitted to distinguish deltaic deposits in many sedimentary coal-bearing and variegated rock masses of the coal basins: Donetzk, Moscow, on Sakhalin Island, Udokansk, Dzhezkazgansk, in Priuralie, etc. (BOTVINKINA et al., 1956; BOTVINKINA, 1962; BOTVINKINA, 1963; BOTVINKINA et al., 1963; ZHEMCHUZKNIKOV et al., 1959-1960; BAKUNet al., 1958; SALNIKOV, 1960; SHULGA,1960; etc.). Both in coal-bearing and cupriferous paralic formations fossil deltaic deposits are characteristic for the regressive series of facies and develop mainly during the regressive stage of sedimentation cycles. This fully agrees with the concept formulated by SAMOILOV (1952) for recent deltas, that the sinking of the coast hinders, and that uplift favours the formation of deltas in general and of its submerged beds in particular. The possibility is not excluded that in a number of cases the lower horizons of deltaic deposits begin to get formed at the end of the transgressive stage. This happens
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF DELTAIC DEPOSITS I Scale (rn)
Lithological section
I1
4s
I11
Type of Genetic lamination type
12.
34.
567I..
.I
B9.
10 r 11 -
Fig.4. Section of littoral-marine deposits including the submergzd part of the delta in the Upper Permian rock rnxs of Priuralie. Symbols: I = Lithological designitions: 1 = pebbles; 2 = mediumgained sandstone; 3 = fine-grained sandstone; 4 = fine-grained smdstone with bands of aleurolites; 5 = coarse-grained aleurolite; 6 = thin intercalation of coarse-grained aleurolite with fine-grained aleurolite and argillite; 7 = argillite. I1 = Structures: 8-11 = lamination (8 = large criss-cross; 9 = cross wave-like; 10 = fine wave-like; 11 = horizontal); 12 = fracture cracks. 111 = Genetic types of deposits: 13 = deposits of the submerged part of the delta; 14 = deposits of the marginal part of the delta; 15 = marine deposits ofthe zone of swells; 16 = dzposits of shallow water parts, sometimes drying out; 17 = littoral-marine deposits; 18 = mzrine deposits.
when uplifts are alrzady taking place on the continent and abundant quantities of detrital material begin to be supplied to the basin by rivers. Thus, fossil deltaic deposits formed under differznt physico-geographical conditions have many specific features in common, which pxmit recognizing them everywhere, just as deposits of the submerged parts of deltas. However, despite their general similarity, there are also differznces, determined by climate, tectonic regime and general paleogeographic environments, peculiarities of the source arza and the character of the basin, in which the deposits of the submerged delta are being formed. The recognition of truly deltaic deposits in fossil sedimPnt&ryrock masses and their distinction from other littoral-marine deposits is of a very substantial practical importance, inasmuch as many deltaic arcas are the sites of concentration of useful minerals, which often decrease in abundance where the deltaic facies pass into facies of other types.
46
L. N. BOTVINKINA AND V. S. YABLOKOV SUMMARY
Detailed lithological researches have made it possible to establish typical features of arenaceous deposits, formed in the submerged parts of deltas and to determine their differences from other littoral-marine sediments. Deltaic sandstones are recognized in the coal measures of the Donetz Basin and in the rock mass of cupriferous sandstones of Priuralie, Dzhezkazgan and other areas. The paper discusses two groups of features of deltaic deposits. The first group consists of features observable directly in rock specimens or exposures: texture, structure (especially bedding), inclusions, organic remains, etc. Features of this group are generally alike in different deltaic deposits. More especially, it is possible to distinguish, on account of such features, the submerged parts of fossil deltas. The second group of features includes specific characteristics in the structure of the entirz formation of the submerged part of the delta and their relations with adjacent facies. Here we find both differences and similarities, depending on the formation conditions of the deltaic rock masses in various environments. The differences are determined by climate, tectonic regime, general paleogeographical environments, specific properties of the source areas and the character of the basin, in which the deposits of the submerged part of the delta are formed. Both in coal-bearing and in cupriferous paralic formations fossil deltaic deposits are mostly characteristic of the regressive series of facies. The establishment of truly deltaic deposits in fossil formations and their delineation against other littoral-marine deposits is of a substantial practical value inasmuch as deltaic deposits are often the sites of concentration of many useful minerals, which may decrease in abundance where the deltaic facies pass into other types of facies.
REFERENCES
BAKUN,N. N., V o L o D i N , R. N. and KRENDELEV, F. P., 1958. Main specific features in the geological structure of Udokansk deposits of cupriferous sandstones and the direction of its further prospecting. Izv. Vysshikh Uchebn. Zavedenii, Geol. i Razvedka, 5 : 61-83 (Russ.). BOTVINKINA, L. N., 1962. Bedding of sedimentary rocks. Tr. Geol. Inst., Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., 59 : 541 pp. (Russ.). BOTVINKINA, L. N., 1963. Some specific features in the genetic types of deposits and laws governing their stratification in paralic formations of various climatic areas. Tr. Geol. Inst., Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., 81 : 332-373 (Russ.). BOTVINKINA, L. N . , ZHEMCHUZHNIKOV, J. A., TIMOFUEV, P. P., FEOFILOVA, A. P. and YABLOKOV. V.S., 1956. Atlas of Lithogenetic Types of Middle Carboniferous Coal Measures of the Donetz Basin. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Moscow, 368 pp. (Russ.). BOTVINKINA, L. N., SELIVERSTOV, V. A., SOKOLOVA, T. N. and YABLOKOV, V. S., 1963. Some genetic types of Tatarsk red beds of the Orenburg Priuralic. Izv. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Ser. Geol., 5 : 47-66
(Russ.). SALNIKOV, B . A,, 1960. Strircture and Main Features of Coal Content of the Verkhnednisk Suite on the Western Coast of Sakhalin. Dissertation, 25 pp. (Russ.). SAMOILOV, I. V., 1952. River Mouths. Geografiz, 526 pp. (Russ.).
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF DELTAIC DEPOSITS
47
SHULGA,V. F., 1960. Conditions of Coal Measures Formation in Aleksinsk Regiotl of Moscow Coal Basin. Dissertation- Tr. Lab. Geol. qyliu, 6 : 398410 (Russ.). ZHEMCHUZHNIKOV, J. A,, YABLOKOV, V. S . , BOGOLJUBOVA, L. I., BOTVINKINA, L. N., FEOFILOVA, A. P., RITENBERG, M. I., TIMOFEJEV, P. P. and TIMOFWEVA, Z. V., 1959-1960. Structure and Accumulation Conditions of the main Coal Measures and Coal Seams of Middle Carboniferous A,pe in the Done/z Basin. 1-2. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R.,Moscow, 679 pp. (Russ.).
DEVONIAN BIOSTROMES AND BIOHERMS OF THE SOUTHERN CANTABRIAN MOUNTAINS, NORTHWESTERN SPAIN AART BROUWER
Department of Strat(@apliy and Paleontology, University of Leyden (The Netherlands)
INTRODUCTION
Along the southern slope of the Paleozoic part of the Cantabrian Mountains, the Devonian succession shows, over large areas, a remarkable uniform alternation of sandstones and shales on the one hand, and of limestones with dolomites on the other. Although local variations as to thickness and details of lithology do occur, the general succession remains essentially the same between the Valsurvio Dome in the east and the Luna River in the west, a distance of nearly 100 km. From a lithological point of view the sandstones are well sorted and consist of well rounded grains. Cross-stratifications, mud cracks, furrows and trails are common features of the sandstones or shales. The limestones are partly well bedded, finegrained, sometimes argillaceous limestones, partly typical biostromal limestones. From a paleontological point of view the whole succession is characterized by abundant remains of brachiopods, bryozoans, crinoids, stromatoporoids and corals. All features referred to are indicative of deposition in shallow water. In the northern part of the province of Palencia a different development of the Devonian succession has been discovered (BROUWER, 1963a, b), which differs lithologically as well as paleontologically from the succession referred to above. Its main elements are shales and fine-grained argillaceous limestones, whereas sandstones occur only in the lowermost and in the uppermost part of the succession. From a palaeontological point of view the differences are even more marked, ammonoids, tentaculites, pelecypods and conodonts being the most characteristic faunal groups. Generally this succession is much less fossiliferous. Tentatively it is suggested that this succession developed further away from the shore and possibly in somewhat deeper water.
FEATURES OF BIOSTROMES
Biostronies are of widespread occurrence in the Santa Lucia and the Portilla Limestone Formation (Fig.1). In the lower part of the Devonian biostronies are relatively rare. Only one biostrome is known so far in the La Vid Formation and a few others of small
W
EISW
ME
Fig. 1. Generalized lithostratigraphic section of the Devonian in the southern Cantabrian Mountains, east of Esla River. Bioherms of transition zone between Asturo-leonesian facies (left) and Palencian facies (right) indicated by oblique hatching. Data from KANIS(1956) (San Martin-Ventanilla area), KOOPMANS (1962) (Valsurvio dome), F. A. Sprenger van Eijk (unpubl.) (Esla area), J. F. Noorthoom van der Kruijff(unpub1.) (San Martin-Ventanilla area), P. A. C. de Ruiter (unpubl.) (Polentinos area) and the author's personal observations.
50
A. BROUWER
dimensions occur in its continuation towards the north in the Palencian facies. The most characteristic groups involved in biostrome formation are rugose and tabulate corals and stromatoporoids. Algal remains are of minor importance, but locally bryozoans and crinoids occur abundantly. The only one known biostrome of the La Vid Formation is near Colle. Its main constituents are branching Rugosa, of which several large specimens between 1 and 2 m in height are still in position of growth. Broken fragments of the same corals are the main constituent of the sediment, particularly in the upper part. The uppermost part of the biostrome consists of a bed of very large favositid colonies, up to 50 cm in diameter. Apparently this sudden faunal change has been caused by increased turbulence of the water. The biostrome seems a local feature as none of the other La Vid exposures, many of which have been studied in detail, showing any biostromal development. In the area of the Palencian facies the Lebanza Limestone Formation, which is chronologically the equivalent of the La Vid Formation, shows a few small biostromes built by massive stromatoporoids, by small favositids or by small branching Rugosa. It is, however, only in the Santa Lucia Formation that biostromal development starts on a much larger scale. Massive stromatoporoids and favositids are by far the most important biostromal elements. Sometimes they occur next to each other, both in position of growth, indicating that they may have lived together in the same habitat. In other places, however, large massive stromatoporoids predominate, or are even the only group present. Bituminous black shale intercalations between the biostromal limestones sometimes show many small colonies of favositids in living position, which is usually not their most stable position. At some levels branching forms, mainly corals, occur, but in general these are of much less importance. Crinoids and bryozoans are sometimes present abundantly, but rarely together with stromatoporoids or corals. Biostromes made upof the several groups referred to, repeatedly alternate in a vertical sense. Many of such biostromes can be traced laterally over several hundreds of meters, or even more, but the same sequence is never repeated in exactly the same way in the next outcrop. The vertical and the horizo~italdifferentiations suggest that the habitats preferred by the various groups of organisms were slightly, but distinctly, different. The deposition of the sands and shales of the Huergas Formation apparently brought the development of biostromes temporarily to an end. It was resumed, however, shortly after the deposition of the Portilla Limestone Formation had started. Usually this formation begins with thinly bedded limestones in which brachiopods and single corals abound. Thereupon biostromal development started anew, usually with a thin layer, 2&30 cm thick, of lamellar stromatoporoids. Contrary to the picture presented by the Santa Lucia biostromes, compound rugose corals are the dominant faunal element in nearly all Portilla biostromes. Branching corals and massive stromatoporoids are restricted to a few beds. Only in the higher parts of the Portilla Formation do tuberose or ramose Thamnopora become the dominant element.
DEVONIAN REEFS IN NORTHWESTERN SPAIN
51
As in the Santa Lucia Formation, the repeatedly alternating biostromal beds dominated by various groups suggest that the distribution of the organisms involved was controlled by minor, but nevertheless distinct changes in environmental conditions.
FEATURES OF BIOHERMS
I n view of the tremendous development of biostronies, the scarcity of bioherms is a noteworthy feature of the Devonian succession in the Cantabrian Mountains. A very few and small isolated bioherms occur in the Portilla Formation throughout the area. Less than ten of them are known so far. Their horizontal dimension is 25 m at most, their vertical dimensions never surpass 4 ni. They are dome-shaped structures, made up of massive, unbedded limestones in which few organic remains are visible to the naked eye. The massive biohermal limestone interfingers with the surrounding, normal, well bedded limestone. The interfingering shows dips which differ markedly from those of the surrounding sediments, suggesting that the structures once rose above the sea-bottom. Further evidence of this is brought forward by the slightly increased coinpaction of the underlying beds, caused by the extra weight of the bioherms. Typical screes of biohermal detritus are nowhere to be seen, and it is therefore improbable that the bioherms were reefs in the sense of wave-resistant structures. Microscopical investigation of the biohermal limestone suggests that massive stromatoporoids were of prime importance in building these structures. There is only one area which seems to have offered more favourable conditions for biohermal growth. It is situated in the northern part of the province of Palencia, east of Cervera de Pisuerga. Reef building started already in Lower Devonian time and continued until well into the Upper Devonian. Lamellar and massive stromatoporoids and massive and branching corals, both Tabulata and Rugosa, were important bioherm building organisms. Sedimentary features show that at least some of the bioherms were wave-resistant structures. Horizontally the biohermal limestone passes into biostromal limestones and fine-grained clastic sediments [shales and mudstones).
REGIONAL SETTING OF BIOSTROMAL AND BIOHERMAL DEVELOPMENT
In the southern part of the Cantabrian Mountains the impressive biostromal development of the Asturo-leonesean facies is now known to occur over 100 kin in an east-west direction. No doubt it continues even further through the arch of outcropping Devonian sediments. It re-occurs in the same facies along the Asturian coast ( R A D I G , 1961). Tn the eastern part of the southern limb the Asturo-leonesean facies passes rather abruptly into the distinctly different Palencian facies. The former represents a sublittoral evironment on a relatively stable shelf, characterized by an abundant benthonic fauna. The latter should rather be regarded as a less stable, or at least less regularly subsiding basin, derived during the greater part of its history from coarse detrital
52
A. BROUWER
material, and characterized by a fauna in which pelagic elements take a predominant position. The area of the Asturo-leonesian facies offered excellent conditions for a potentially reef-building fauna. The stable conditions prevailing throughout the greater part of the Devonian prevented the development of reef structures or even bioherms. This, however, does not imply that the biostromes developed exclusively in quiet water below the zone of wave turbulence. On the contrary, several features suggest that many biostromes developed in very shallow agitated water. In the area of the Palencian facies the water was probably too deep to allow the permanent establishment of potentially reef-building organisms. Only in Lower Devonian times did they temporarily get some foothold, but by that time the facies difference had not yet markedly developed, as is well evidenced, by lithological as well as palaeontological similarities between the La Vid and the Lebanza Formations. It now is of interest to note that the most prolific growth of bioherms took place exactly in the area where the Asturo-leonesean facies passes into the Palencian facies. This change in facies coincides with the northern border of the Leonides (DESITTER; 1962). The details of this transition are partly obscured by Carboniferous rocks, but it is clear enough that towards the Palencian facies the area of the Asturo-leonesean facies ends with a belt in which even more stable conditions prevailed than in the area of the Asturo-leonesean facies proper. That this belt stood as a submarine ridge, as has been suggested by KOOPMANS (l962), seems very doubtful, as neither the lithology nor the paleontological contents of the sediments in this belt favour such conditions. It seems rather a belt of intermittent, but on the whole smaller subsidence. On the outward side of this belt, towards the Palencian facies basin, water depth and subsidence offered the most favourable conditions for the development of bioherms.
SUMMARY
Extensive biostronial growths occur in the Santa Lucia and the Portilla Limestone Formations, resp. of Lower/Middle and Middle/Upper Devonian age, of the southern slope of the Cantabrian Mountains. Development of biostromes took place on a relatively stable shelf in a shallow sea. Uniform conditions prevailed over a large area. In northern Palencia this stable shelf facies passes rather abruptly into a less stable basin facies characterized by fine-grained sediments and a pelagic fauna. Bioherms occur at several stratigraphic levels in the transitional zone between the shelf and the basin facies.
REFERENCES
BROUWER. A., 1963a. Recherches stratigraphiques dans le Paltozoique des Montagnes cantabriques (Espagne nordouest). Leidse G o t . Mededef., in press.
DEVONIAN REEFS IN NORTHWESTERN SPAIN
53
BROUWER,A., 1963b. Deux types faciels dans le Dtvonien de la partie mtridionale des Montagnes cantabriques. Compt. Rend. la R6union Natl. Geol., Oviedo, 1962, in press. DESITTER, L. U.: 1962. The Hercynian orogenesis in northern Spain. In: K. CoE(Editor), Some Aspects of the VariscianFold Belt. Manchester Univ. Press, Manchester, pp. 1-18. KANIS, J., 1956. Geology of the Eastern Zone of the Sierra del Brezo (Palencia-Spain). Thesis, Univ. Leiden. Also published in Leidse Geol. Mededel., 21 (2) : 377-445. KOOPMANS,B. M., 1962. The Sedimentary and Structural History of the Valsurvio Dome, Cantabrian Mountains, Spain. Thesis, Univ. Leiden. Also published in Leidse Geol. Mededel., 26 : 121-232. RADIG,F., 1961. Zur Stratigraphie des Devons in Asturien (Nordspanien). Geol. Rundschau, 51: 249-267.
HEAVY MINERAL DISTRIBUTION ON THE CONTINENTAL SHELF O F F ACCRA, GHANA, WEST AFRICA
w.
D . BRUCKNER
and
H. J . MORGAN
Memorial University, St. John's, Newfoundland (Canada)
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this paper is to give a condensed account of results obtained by a quantitative study of the heavy minerals in samples from the recent sediment cover of the continental shelf off Accra, Ghana, on the northern side of the Gulf of Guinea. A more detailed report including further investigations may be published later.
ORIGIN OF SAMPLES, CHIEF STEPS OF THEIR STUDY, AND DATA OBTAINED
The samples used for this study were taken along a line extending from the beach a the lighthouse of Accra across the shelf to slightly beyond its outer edge (see Fig. I). Sample numbers (l-21), distances of the sampling locations from the shoreline (here defined as the foot of the beach slope barely exposed at low tide), and their elevations (above and below sea level) are listed in Fig.2. These 21 samples were first divided into grain size fractions by sieve and sedirnentation analysis, and the calcareous particles, chiefy of modern organic origin, were removed from each fraction by hand-picking and by means of dilute HC 1. Fig.2 shows the total size ranges thus determined, the quantitatively larger fractions indicating the frequency peaks, the maximum diameters of mineral grains or (non-calcareous) rock fragments, and the median diameters. The fractions (except the coarse ones and the finest) were then divided with bromoform into their light and heavy mineral components. The fractions so treated, and those of them quantitatively richest in heavies, are also marked in Fig.2. Representative portions of the heavy mineral concentrates were then mounted on slides and the relative abundances of the minerals determined under the microscop:. Of these mineral counts only those made of the fractions between the 45 and 100 p limits appeared to bs generally reliable for further evaluation. In order to reveal the chief trends of arzal mineral distribution as free as possible from vanations of subordinate or incidental nature, average mineral and mineral group percentages of the 45-100 p fractions were calculated for each sample and further combined to obtain average values for four sample groups which represent successive stretches of the sampling line across the shelf. Only these combined values are dealt with in this
HEAVY MINERALS ON THE CONTINENTAL SHELF OFF ACCRA
55
Fig.1. Sketch map of coastal zone at Accra, Ghana, showing sampling line across continental shelf and chief bedrock groups (the bedrock groups after BATES,1955). IA = Acidic gneisses and schists of Dahomeyan Group 1B = Basic gneisses (older( ?) Precambrian), 2 = Cape Coast granite complex (mid( ?)-Precambrian), 3 = Quartzites and phyllites of Togo Series (young( ?)-Precambrian), 4 = Sandstones and shales of Accraian Series (mid-Devonian).
1
paper. It was found useful for the interpretation of the laboratory results to prepare diagrams showing the distribution of certain mineral groups and of individual minerals within these groups, each on an appropriate scale, rather than only one table or diagram comprising all minerals on the same scale. Fig.3-7 with their legends should be self-explanatory in this respect. A few heavy minerals observed in many slides, but rare (apatite, clinozoisite, monazite, topaz, zoisite), have been omitted as well as biotite, muscovite, and chlorite whose ranges of specific gravity overlap that of bromoform. Early during the investigations it was found that the samples from the outer shelf (especially numbers 19 and 21) contained fragments of fairly well consolidated rock: fossiliferous sandy limestone and calcareous sandstone, which apparently outcrop locally on the shelf floor. These fragments are similar to certain types of beach rock associated with remnants of a slightly raised, subrecent shoreline along the West African coast (ANDERSON and BRUCKNER,1957). It seems therefore that they were, or are being, reworked from a fossil beach rock that was formed while sea level was much lower than today (Pleistocene?) and that has since been only partially covered by the sediments of the outer shelf. In order to test this assumption and to determine, if possible, the significance of reworking processes for the formation of the recent outer shelf sediments, two representative specimens of the rock fragments were selected, disintegrated by dissolving their calcareous matter in HCI, and then subjected to the
56
w. D. BRUCKNERAND H . J. MORGAN
-
! E
-
i E
rlancc? urnshahop
1
12
2
4
3
0.
4 5
6
i;
LOG
:.I m
' Z
iC-
rppror
+
-
125
9
250
10
1850
11
2750
12
4150
13
5500
14
7400
437
+ 0.3
-
100
107
1.5
40
I
490
3.0
0.1 0.0 ow Lids iea l e n l 20 - 0.5
8
j
/E: ;.Cj ! -.
-
912 1.3
210
1.5
227
3.5
1.1)
153
4.0
!,:
130
1 .o
- 4.5 - 9.5 - 12.0 - 16.5
- 22
2.5
70
0.7
56
1.1
52
0.11
52
0.7
41)
0.9
67
15
9200
- 31 - 35
0.6
LO
16
13000
-42
1 -4
62
17
15000
- 45
1.3
70
18
17000
2 .o
120
- 53 - 53
19
lS000
20
22000
- 60
21 -
27500
-90
2.1
2.5
150
1
135
-
220
~
Reworked
rock
fraaments
Fig.2. Diagram showing sample locations, grain size distributions (after removal of constituents soluble in dilute HCI), and sample fractions used for heavy mineral study. Solid lines include all size fractions present; stippled areas mark fractions compiising each more than 10 weight % of total sample. Broken lines include all fractions in which heavy mineral analysis was attempted; hachured, areus mark fractions containing more than 10 weight 76 of heavy minerals per fraction. (Line 14 max. mineral grain diameter, read 0.6.)
Sample groups comprising samples: 1-9 010
30
,.
10-13
16-17
22.23
18-21 010
70
Fig.3. Average weight percentages of light and heavy minerals respectively, calculated for groups fo samples from their 45-100 p fractions (all minerals = 100%).
HEAVY MINERALS ON THE CONTINENTAL SHELF OFF ACCRA
57
same procedure as the other samples. The results are shown in Fig.2-7 under the sample numbers 22 and 23.
INTERPRETATION SUGGESTED BY THE DATA
Fig.2 shows that the overall grain size distribution of the beach and inner shelf sediments changes fairly regularly: the beach sands become coarser downslope reflecting the increasing power of the breaking waves, and the inner shelf sands and silts become gradually finer with increasing distance from the coast, increasing water depth, and decreasing power of the undertow. On the outer shelf from sample 14 on, however, irregularities exist, double frequency peaks occur, and a general but somewhat irregular grain-size increase outwards is evident. The fact that the reworked rock fragments from the outer shelf are also rather coarse-grained (especially sample 23) suggests that most, if not all, of the coarser grains in the recent sediments of this area are derived from the underlying rock (the irregularities being probably due to its local variations), while only the finer and finest-grained material can have made the journey this far from the shore. The heavy mineral rich fractions marked in Fig.2 show a similar trend: progressively decreasing grain sizes from the shoreline outwards and additional frequency peaks in the coarser grades on the outer shelf. The relative enrichment of the heavies in the finest fractions of each sample can be ascribed to the lighter minerals of these grain size ranges having been winnowed away and carried farther out in considerable quantity. Among the diagrams giving the average mineral percentages of the 45-100 p fractions, the Fig.3, 5, 6, and 7 show again that the mineral distribution is fundamentally
S a m p l e groups comprising samples: 1-9
I I
10-13
14-17
22.23
(8-21
Opaque minerals
Fig.4. Average grain number percentages of opaque and non-opaque heavy minerals respectively, calculated for groups of samples from their 45-100 p fractions (all heavy minerals = 100%).
w. D.
58
BRUCKNERAND H. J . MORGAN
different on the inner and on the outer shelf. From the beach across the inner shelf the specifically heavier minerals generally give way progressively to the specifically lighter ones (Fig.3,5; zircon in Fig.6; staurolite, epidote and kyanite in Fig.7). On the outer shelf, however, the mineral distribution in the recent sediments is obviously governed, or at least strongly influenced, by supply from the underlying rock (shown particularly well in Fig.5 and 6, and for epidote, kyanite, and tourmaline in Fig.7). If the agreement of values is less good for the remaining minerals in Fig.7, and also for all
S a m p l e groups comprising sainples 1-9 010
.
-20 m L
\
0 1
*.
mw-10 G?
ZY %-:
14-17 2 2 , 2 3
10-13
\.
18-21 010
Non-opaque minerals o f specific gravities 3 - 4
"
80- 1
o n
"\ ---
-
/
.Li'rr=-.
90-2; 0
.
loo-= ,"
Non-opaque minerals o f soecific oravities L - 5
0
m
5:
\,-
Fig.5. Average grain number percentages of non-opaque minerals of specific gravities 4 5 and 3 4 respectively, calculated for groups of samples from their 45-100 p fractions (all non-opaque heavy minerals : 100%).
Sample groups comprising samples : 1-9
10-13
14-17
22.23
18-21
'lo 60
50
(0
LO
30
20
10 0
0
Fig.6. Average grain number percentages of individual non-opaque minerals of specificgravities 4-5, calculated for groups of samples from their 45-100 p fractions (all non-opaque minerals of specific gravities45 = 100%).
HEAVY MINERALS ON THE CONTINENTAL SHELF OFF ACCRA
59
heavies together in Fig.3, it has to be realised that the comparison of source rock and recent sediment is based on no more than two of the reworked rock fragments, whose average composition can only give an approximate picture of the gross averages of the reworked beds.
Sample groups comprising samples : 1-9
010
-40
(:I
-30
10-13
’
14-17
22.23
18-21
010
40.
A= E= K = P=
S=
Amphiboles Epidote Kyanite Pyroxenes Staurolite
30.
-
.2 0
20
-10
10 -
lo
0
1
Fig.7. Average grain number percentages of predominant individual non-opaque minerals of specific gravities 3 - 4 , calculated for groups of samples from their 45-100 p fractions (all non-opaque minerals of specific gravities 3 4 = 100%).
The largest discrepancy found concerns the opaque minerals (Fig.4). A search for its reason revealed that it was, most likely, introduced during the treatment of the samples with acid. A large proportion of the opaque minerals consists of more or less porous grains of limonite, which is moderately soluble in HCI. The reworked rock fragments had to be subjected to prolonged treatment with fairly concentrated acid in order to achieve their complete disintegration and therefore a fairly large amount of their limonitic grains was probably lost by solution. As the heavy mineral distribution discussed here includes the grains down to sizes of 45 p, it seems justified to assume that not only the coarser grains but also most of the finer-grained material on the outer shelf has its source in the underlying rock.
60
w. D. BRUCKNER AND H. J.
MORGAN
HEAVY MINERAL SOURCES ON THE COAST AND TRANSPORT DIRECTION OF THE COASTDERIVED GRAINS
As there are only minor streams in the coastal zone around Accra, which usually deposit their load in lagoons, the clastic material deposited on the beach and inner shelf is almost exclusively provided by wave erosion of the coastal cliffs, in which bedrock outcrops alternate with stretches exposing only the Quaternary mantle. Of the main bedrock groups (Fig.l), the clastic rocks of the Accraian series at Accra itself, and also those of the Togo series west of Accra, can probably be ruled out, such rocks being notoriously poor heavy mineral sources. The Cape Coast granite, with its nearest major outcrops as far as 40 km west of Accra, seems too distant; the same applies to other formations reaching the coast still farther west. The Dahomeyan group east of Accra, however, is known to be rich in the heavy minerals that predominate in the shelf sediments: In its acidic division bands of epidote-bearing hornblende schist and of tremolite-kyanite marble occur (west of Labadi); there are sequences of staurolite, kyanite, and garnet-bearing mica schists (in many outcrops between Accra and Tema), as well as granite gneisses from which the zircon could be derived. Around Kpone the basic division of the Dahomeyan, rich in hornblende, garnet, and pyroxenes reaches the shore. Rutile and tourmaline may be derived from quartz veins of the Dahomeyan belt. The most likely source of the haematite and limonite grains which predominate among the opaque minerals is the Quaternary mantle where these two minerals are common as ferruginous coatings, impregnations, concretions, and hardpans. In order to reach the beach and inner shelf at the sampling line off Accra, the Dahomeyan-derived heavy minerals must have travelled chiefly in a west to southwest direction. This is rather surprising as the prevalent current in the surface waters off Accra (the Guinea current) flows from west to east. However, the Benguela stream, opposite in direction, is known to replace the Guinea current at the coast of Ghana from time to time for periods of a few days (BUCHANAN,1958), and as it is colder than the latter it can perhaps be assumed that it penetrates under it onto the inner shelf more regularly than has so far been realised. If this were correct the distribution of the coast-derived heavies could be attributed chiefly to the joint action of the Benguela stream and the undertow.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Sampling on the shelf off Accra was done in 1955, 1957, and 1958, first by J. B. Buchanan, later on by W. D. Briickner together with Dr. D. T. Gauld, which all were members of the University College of Ghana at that time. The detailed study of the samples was begun in Ghana by J. B . Buchanan and W. D. Briickner. After 1958, it was carried on at the Memorial University of Newfoundland, where the major share of the laboratory work - including especially the mineralogical part - was taken
HEAVY MMERALS ON THE CONTINENTAL SHELF OFF ACCRA
61
over by H. J. Morgan, with D. Carmichael and J. M. Dawson assisting for some time. The figures of this paper were drawn by J. Drover. The authors wish to thank their colleagues for their help; the financial aid given by the University College of Ghana and by the National Research Council of Canada is also gratefully acknowledged.
SUMMARY
A quantitative study of the heavy minerals in sea bottom samples taken along a line across the continental shelf off Accra shows that their distribution on the inner shelf is governed by their specific gravities, the heavier minerals decreasing in quantity more rapidly outwards than the lighter ones, whereas their abundances on the outer shelf areclosely related to those of the underlying (Pleistocene?) rock, which has been amply reworked. The non-opaque heavies derived from the coast appear to indicate transportation in a west to southwest direction, opposite to the flow of the Guinea current which predominates at the surface of the sea.
REFERENCES
ANUERSON, M . M . and BRUCKNER, W. D., 1957. Note on raised shore-lines of the Gold Coast. In: J. D. CLARK(Editor), Third Pnn-Afi-[can Colyess on Prehistorv, Liviqpfone. 1955. Chatto and Windus, London, pp. 86-92. BATES,D. A , , 1955. Ceolqeicalniap ofthe Gold Coast, 1 : 1,OOO,OOO.Gold Coast Geol. Surv., Accra. BUCHANAN, J. B., 1958. The bottom fauna cornmunities across the continental shelf off Accra, Ghana (Gold Coast). Proc. Zool. Sor. London, 130 : 1-56.
ON SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN O F PHOSPHORITE SEDIMENTS G. I . BUSHINSKI
National Conitiiittee of Geologists in the U.S.S. R . , Moscow ( U . S . S .R . )
INTRODUCTION
Shallow marine formations containing phosphorites are of widespread distribution They are found for example in the Ordovician of Estonia, the Leningrad region and the southern part of the Siberian platform (phosphorites rich in shells), the Jurassic and Cretaceous of the Russian platform (nodular phosphorites with quartz and glauconite sand), Florida (conglomeratic phosphorites). the Eocene and Cretaceous of North Africa (rich zones of bedded phosphorites), the Permian of the western states of the U.S.A.,the Cambrian of Caratau (U.S.S.R.) and Cunian (China) and the Sinian of Tzin-Sian and Cayan (China). Almost the entire world production of marine phosphorite comes from shallow water deposits, the deep-sea ones being of no commercial value.
INDlCATIONS OF SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN
Indications of the shallow water origin of mcst phosphorite deposits are among others: the smooth, more or less worn condition, apparently due to rolling of phosphorite nodules and associated pebbles, the presence of sand grains of various origin and of arenaceous phosphorite material, the occurrence of angular and worn fragments of the shells and skeletoix of molluscs, brachiopods, sponges, Foraminifera and other marine organisms, the inclination of the bedding, the presence of thick-walled benthonic Foraminifera (in the phosphorite sands of Morocco), the alternation of phosphorite layers with shallow marine sands or pebbly sands, or their direct transition into one another, both in vertical and lateral directions. These characteristics, pointing to shallow water formation are typical not only for secondary, but also for primary, unreworked (rich) phosphorites. The primary origin of apparently shallow marine phosphorites is proved by the presence of phosphorite casts of mollusc shells of the same age as the phosphorite layer and also by the growth of oyster shells and worm tubes on phosphorite concretions. Furthermore, these shells and tubes often contain phosphorite, filling pseudomorphs testifying to the slow formation of the phosphate accumulation. Cross bedding in phosphorites has been observed in the Sinian deposit of Tzin-
SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN OF PHOSPHORITE SEDIMENTS
63
Fig.1.Cross lamination in phosphorites. At left: Deposit of Tzin-Sian, Sinian, Hubei, China. At right: Deposit of Janitas, Cambrian, Caratau range, Kazakhstan, U.S.S.R.
Sian in China and in the Cambrian deposit of the Caratau range in Kazakhstan (Fig. I). The layers may be inclined in one direction only, testifying to a constant current direction, or in different directions, proving the inconstancy of water movements. Inclined bedding is often found in shallow water, but it may appear at any depth where water currents exist. Definite signs pointing to the small depth of the sea are calcareous Algae or reef corals. Normally, however, neither the former nor the latter
Fig.2. Benthonic calcareous Algae in phosphorites. At left: Colleniu, deposit of Tzin-Sian. Sinian, Hubei, China. At right: Oncolithes, deposit of Janitas, Cambrian, Caratau range, Kazakhstan, U.S.S.R.
64
G . I. BUSHINSKI
are found in phosphorites. Yet, recently remnants of the calcareous reef building Algae Collenia and Oncolithes have been found in the phosphorite deposits of TzinSian and Caratau (Fig.2). Comparable Algae live at the present tim: in depths of 5-50 m, rarely up to 100 m. Hence, it may be concluded that the inclined bedding in the phosphorites discussed above was formed in shallow water. A no less important indication for the relatively small depths at which phosphate accumulation took place, is provided by the direct transition of many phosphorites into sand or pebbly sand deposits of doubtless shallow water origin. Thus the Sinian and Cambrian phosphorites of Asia are often interbedded with or covered by coarse detrital sediments or ore deposits and show traces of interruptions in the depositional process. The same has been observed in the Jurassic and Cretaceous phosphorites of the Russian platform, as well as in the Permian phosphorites of the U.S.A. Pebbles of various rocks may also form a strong indication for shallow water origin, but in bedded phosphorites they are comparatively rare. Rolled, worn grains of sand size, composed of phosphorite, which also point to small depths are found much more often. But it is not always possible to distinguish them from phosphate ovules or grains of other origin, either by their form or by their inner structure. A characteristic feature of many phosphate sand grains is that they are composed of an aggregate of minute oolites, which at the surface of the grains have been ground away by abrasion (Fig.3). Such sand grains are of common occurrence in all phosphorite layers of the Cunian deposit in China, and at Jani-tas and Cockjon in Caratau (U.S.S.R.). The shallow water facies, characteristic for most (rich) phosphorite deposits is also shown by the facies profile through the Caratau basin (Fig.4). I n the zone of very sha1low:water sediments as well as in the adjoining zones of somewhat greater depth
Fig.3. Phosphorite grains in bedded phosphorite of Caratau range: x 60.
65
SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN OF PHOSPHORITE SEDIMENTS
sw
NE Janytas
Akjar
Koksool
Fig.4. Facies profile of the Cambrian phosphate series ofthe Little Caratau range in the direction from shallow water zones (Cockjon, Jani-tas) to deeper-water zones (Ackjar, Cocksu). 1 = Dolomites; 2 = Chert, occasional spongolites; 3 = Phosphorite with oolites and phosphorite pebbles; 4 = Oolite phosphatic; 5 = Pellet phosphorite, sometimes with underdeveloped coating and rare oolites; 6 = Siliceous clay shales. Composed after the data of MENSIANHUA(1959).
(the Cockjon and Jani-tas deposits) oolites and pellets of phosphorites with phosphorite sand grains and granules are present throughout the layers. Phosphorite gravel is seldom met with. The phosphate grains usually show a thin coating of phosphate of a different nature. In the direction of originally deeper water the number of phosphorite sand grains, granules and oolites decreases, phosphate pellets with or without coating beginning to prevail instead. The dimensions of the phosphate pellets decrease from 0.3-1 mm to 0.1-0.2 mm. At the same time the phosphorite layer starts wedging out and lenses of dolomite and layers of siliceous-argillaceous shales appear. The thickness of the phosphorite bearing layers range from 20 m in Cockjon to 50 m in Akjar. Further to the northeast the abundance of phosphate pellets with coating and of phosphate oolites increases again. The siliceous rocks are here and there extremely rich in sponge spicules.
PHOSPHORUS SOURCE
When the rock sequences, not only of poor but also of rich phosphorite deposits are analyzed, the presence of quartz sandstone layers or of quartz sand admixtures form a conspicuous feature. This is the case, for example, in the Sinian deposits of Junhe. Kaian and the western Baikal territory, in the Cambrian deposits of Cunian and Karatau, the Permian deposits of the western states of the U.S.A., and i n the Jurassic, Cretaceous and Tertiary deposits of the Russian platform. This association can hardly be accidental. If we take into consideration that the seas in which the accumulation of phosphates took place were apparently bordered by lowland coasts, then involuntarily the question arises whether the land or the rivers flowing from it
66
G. 1. BUSHINSKI
were the direct source of the phosphates deposited in the sea. In order to check this idea we shall make an approximate calculation. The concentration of dissolved phosphate in river waters in the lower courses is on the average 5&80 mg P,O, per ms of water; upstream waters contain 150-200 mg P,O, per m3 of water, i.e., 2-3 times more. Rivers, however, also carry away a considerable quantity of phosphorus. Thus, for example, the Volga river brings into the Caspian Sea 6,000 tons of dissolved phosphate phosphorus yearly. If all that phosphorus should be precipitated during one million years, the result would be a layer of 40 billion tons, as calculated by 30% phosphorite. This would correspond already to a phosphate deposit comparable in size to that of the fossil basins. It is true that not all dissolved phosphate phosphorus necessarily falls out in phosphorite form, but if we take into consideration that the Volga brings twice as much dissolved and undissolved organic phosphorus and that the accumulation of phosphate may last several million years, then it comes close to the mentioned figure of 40 billion tons. Almost all dissolved phosphorus brought by the rivers into the sea is immediately assimilated by the plankton and deposited on the bottom, very little being carried away into the deeper parts of the basin. This means that a biological filtering of the phosphorus takes place. But in small depths where the motion of bottom waters is intensive enough, the phosphorus deposited under the influence of organisms returns again into circulation and may thereby be carried away far from the river mouths. Together with the phosphorus the rivers also bring much dissolved silica which is likewise assimilated by organisms, deposited on the sea floor and accumulated with the phosphorites in the form of siliceous sediments. The circumstance that quartz sandstones are often associated with phosphorites does not mean that the more there is of the former, the more there should also be of the latter. In fact, just the opposite is the case: where much quartz sandstone is found there are usually no phosphorites at all or they are few in number and thin. Obviously little sandy material reached the place of maximum phosphate accumulation. In order to provide in the mud on the sea floor a sufficiently high concentration of dissolved phosphates required for their precipitation as phosphorite, a rather plentiful rain of organic matter and a quick decomposition of it should take place. This is possible in the case of heightened phosphate concentration in the phytoplankton zone (the upper water layer 100-150 m thick, rarely up to 200 m) and of shallowness, so that there is no time for the sinking, dead organisms to become decomposed on their way to the bottom. The rate of decomposition of the organic matter is increased by high temperatures. Rich concentrations of dissolved phosphates, necessary for an intensive development of the organic life, may be caused by submarine hydrothermal sources, volcanic exhalations, upwelling of the sea water and by fluvial supply from the land. The production of organic life in areas of upwelling waters and i n estuaries may be of enormous importance. Hydrothermal and exhalational sources of phosphorus are of far smaller significance. Accordingly, their influence on the abundance of the plankton bio-mass is negligible and usually remains unnoticed, both in modern seas and in
SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN OF PHOSPHORITE SEDIMENTS
67
reservoirs of the geological past. The paleogeographical properties of basins containing phosphorite deposits renders it likely that rivers formed their most important phosphorus source.
PRECIPITATION FROM BOTTOM MUD SOLUTIONS
Almost all phosphorite layers consist of phosphate grains or pellets (mainly coprolites) and phosphate oolites. Their formation, as well as that of phosphorite nodules, took place in the mud on the sea bottom by processes of diagenesis. New studies of marine hydrochemistry lend much support to this view. According to data of BRUEVITCH and SAITZEVA ( I 958) the phosphate P content in near-bottom waters of shallow- and deep-water stations of the Bering Sea vary within the range of 0.080.13 mg/l, i.e., the extremes lie close t o each other. In shallow-water stations the mud solutions contain 2.50-7.48 nig P per 1, or 30-90 times more than in near-bottom waters. For the northern part of the Caspian Sea the corresponding excess equals 150 times. Together with the phosphorus the alcali reserve (alcalinity), ammoniac nitrogen and silica in bottom mud solutions from shallow-water stations are also much higher. In deep-water stations the phosphate content in mud solutions is only 2-3 times higher than in near-bottom waters. This happens because only stable organic matter reaches great depths. The latter decomposes very slowly, and therefore it changes the composition of mud solutions very little, causing only weak diagenetic processes. The strongest phosphate concentrations in marine environments are found in mud solutions of shallow-water zones. They are scores of times greater than the phosphate concentration in bottom waters. Therefore it is logical to suppose that the phosphate is not precipitated out of the basin water as KASAKOV(1937) considered, but out of the mud or ground water solution, though this is usually characterized by lower pH values (BUSHINSKI, 1954). The depths where the highest concentrations of dissolved phosphates in mud are found are within the range of about 30-200 m, which agrees with the depths of phosphorite formation deduced from the geological data of ARKHANGELSKI ( I 927), KASAKOV (1 937) and other geologists. Two circumstances determine these depth limits. The first is that the shallow water zones are connected with the greatest plankton bio-mass. The second being that in shallow-water the greatest quantity of dead plankton reaches the bottom. Mud solutions in hollows between shoals are especially rich in dissolved phosphates. The structural forms of phosphorite pellets, oolites and concretions are the result of a concentration of phosphate dispersed in deposits, dissolved or hard, but via the solution stage. Most pellets or ovules are phosphatised coprolites. Further phosphate concentration took place owing to repeated washing of the deposits by turbulent water. As a result fine clay, carbonate and silica particles were washed out and carried away into deeper parts of the basin, the phosphate pellets. oolites and concretions remaining in their place and forming phosphorite deposits.
68
G. I. BUSHINSKI
The accumulation of phosphorites in this way is possible only with alternating stages of quiet and rough water. During a stage of quiet water the remains of dead plankton sink to the bottom even on shoals, where as a result of their decomposition phosphorite pelIets, oolites and concretions are formed. In a stage of rough water or storms these structural elements are washed and fine admixtures are carried away. Traces of washing in the form of sand grains and pebbles are observed throughout all the rich and thick phosphorite deposits of Cunian and Caratau. Thus according to the biochemical hypothesis the concentration of phosphorus leading to the formation of phosphorites passed through the following five stages: (1) The influx of waters with a high phosphate content from rivers and possibly also from deeper parts of the sea, by currznts flowing upward into shallow areas with depths of about 30-200 m. (2) The concentration of dissolved phosphorus by organisms and its sinking to the sea floor after their death. (3) The concentration of phosphorus in mud solutions as a result of the decomposition of dead organisms on the sea bottom. On shoals, the deposition on the bottom of dead organisms and their decomposition took place only during conditions of calm weather. ( 4 ) The concentration of phosphates dispersed in mud with the formation of phosphate pellets, oolites, concretions, cement and various pseudomorphs. (5) The concentration of relatively coarse structural elements of the phosphorite, thus formed, owing to the washing out of fine admixtures by waves during stages of stormy weather. The interchange of periods with much and with little water turbulence could also be the result of tectonic elevations and lowerings of the bottom of the basin causing alternative shallowing and deepening of the water. Later concentrations or impoverishments of the phosphorites may take place by late-diagenetic, epigenetic and hypergenetic processes. The first, second and third of these stages are hypothetical, no direct indications having been found in the rocks. Many poor deposits, such as at Junhe, Tzin-Sian, Laibo, Emay, Belka and elsewhere, did not pass the fifth stage or it is only slightly expressed in them. The expounded biochemical hypothesis is still far from perfect. It does not go into the question of what peculiarities of the bacterial or biochemical processes in shallow water areas are responsible for the accumulation of phosphates at some places and the absence of accumulation at others. It may be supposed that for the genesis of phosphorites these processes are almost decisive, but their influence on the accumulation of phosphates in modern seas is still unstudied.
INFLUENCE OF ARID CLIMATE ON ACCUMULATION OF PHOSPHORITES
In the paleoclimatological respect it is interesting that large and rich phosphorite
SHALLOW WATER ORIGIN OF PHOSPHORITE SEDIMENTS
69
basins are situated in former arid zones. STRAKHOV (1962), who has discovered this relationship, explains it by the fact that the arid zone is characterized by strong and very constant trade-winds which cause upward flows or upwelling of waters bringing phosphates onto the continental shelves, and also by the fact that the seas of the arid zone are characterized by relatively high calcium concentrations, which stimulate the precipitation of phosphates. As we understand it, the influence of aridity on the accumulation of phosphates must lie primarily in the fact that few rivers flow here to the sea and, hence, little terrigenous material is supplied which could dilute the phosphorites. As far as appreciable quantities of phosphates were supplied by rivers, this material came from far upstream, from the humid zone. This is in agreement with the well-rounded, smooth and worn condition of the quartz sand grains and by the almost complete absence of admixture of unstable terrigenous minerals. A good example of this is supplied by the map of the Phosphoria formation deposits (MCKELVEY et al., 1959). It shows clearly the wedge of quartz sandstone, the material of which was brought from the north or northeast, i.e., from the humid to the arid zone. The phosphorites, together with silica rocks with sponge spicules are found in a zone extending from this wedge in seaward direction. Further to the south and southeast the phosphate-silica precipitations are replaced, first by dolomites, and then by red beds with gypsum and anhydrite, i.e., precipitations of a hypersaline basin.
SUMMARY
This paper presents evidence showing that among fossil marine phosphate deposits those formed in shallow water environment predominate. This predominance is i n agreement with analyses of the content of dissolved phosphate in the interstitial water of muds from the recent sea floor. In shallow water muds these contents are far higher than those in the seawater circulating directly over the bottom. The difference between the two is maximum at depths between 30 and 200 m. The phosphate is apparently precipitated from the bottom mud solutions. Further concentration may take place after deposition, both mechanically, by washing out of fine-grained clastic material, and chemically, by diagenetic processes.
REFERENCES
AKKHANGELSKI, A. D., 1927. Stratigraphy and g:ological conditions of formation of Russian phosphorites. In: M. M. TETIAEV (Editor), Phosphorites of the U.S.S.R.,pp. 13-21 (Russ.). S. V. and SAITZEVA, E. D., 1958. On the chemistry of the Bering Sea sediments. Papers BRUEVITCH, Inst. Oceanol., 26 : 8-108 (Russ.). BUSHINSKI, G. I., 1954. Lithology of’Cretaceous Deposits of the Dnieper-Donets Trough. Acad. Sci. U.S.S.R., 290 pp. (Russ.). KASAKOV,A. V., 1937. Phosphorite facies and phosphorite genesis. In: B. M. GIMELFARB (Editor), Geologic Investigations of Agronomic Ores of the U.S.S.R.O.N.T.I.,pp. 100-1 19 (Russ.).
70
G. I. BUSHINSKI
MCKELVEY, V. E. et al., 1959. The Phosphoria, Park City and Shedhorn formations in the western phosphate field. US.Geol. Surv., Profess. Papers, 313A : 1 4 . 1959. On the petrography of the Karatau Basin’s phosphorites. Trans. Acad. Sci. MENSIANHUA, U.S.S.R., 126 (6) : 13261330. (Russ.). STRAKHOV, N. M., 1962. Fundamentals of the Theory of Lithogenesis. 3 . Acad. Sci. U.S.S.R., 95 pp. (Russ.).
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN POROSITY, PERMEABILITY, AND GRAINSIZE DISTRIBUTION OF SANDS AND SANDSTONES GEORGE V. CHILINGAR
University of Southern California, Los Angeles, Car$ ( U . S . A . )
INTRODUCTLON A N D REVIEW OF LITERATURE
As pointed out by GRIFFITHS (1952a, 1952b, 1958), the definition of a specimen of sandstone in terms of petrographic properties may be presented as:
P = f (m,s, sh, o , p ) where P is some defining index expressed as a function (f) of the mineral composition (m),grain size (s), grain shape (sh), grain orientation (o), and grain packing @). In many instances, it is also very important to characterize a sandstone or a sand in terms of permeability and porosity (mass properties of rocks). Porosity can be easily related to petrography and in many reservoir sands porosity is related to permeability (exponential function). According to GRIFFITHS (1958, p. 1 9 , when permeability is plotted on a logarithmic scale and porosity on an arithmetic scale, a linear relationship emerges. This relationship, however, is not exact as can be seen from the scatter around the trend lines (GRIFFITHS, 1958, p. 16, fig. 1). According to KOTYAKHOV (1949, p.31) the average radius of pores, rc, can be expressed in terms of porosity and permeability by the following formula:
where m is the coefficient of porosity and k is the coefficient of permeability in c d . KOTYAKHOV (1949, p.32) also calculated that the effective diameter of grains, d,, is related to permeability and porosity as follows:
Both of these equations, however, seem to be oversimplified, because Kotyakhov apparently assumed that all grains are of spherical shape.
12
G . V. CHILINGAR
Some data on the relationship between porosity and permeability had been assembled by MUSKAT (1949 ,pp. 168-176). KHANIN(1956; see also CHILINGAR, 1957)conducted a comprehensive statistical study on relationship between the effective porosity and permeability, and found that the granulometric composition of sandstones has to be considered in order to establish correlation between these two variables. KHANIN (1958) also started to study relationship between the porosity and permeability of unconsolidated and weakly cemented sands (Fig. 1). Khanin prepared artificial sand packs with sands of known granulometric composition (at 0, 110, 190, 370 and 560 kg/cni2 compaction pressures) and determined their porosities and permeabilities. Although unconsolidated sands defy any accurate permeability measurement, the
$ 35
>;
e
8
30
25 200
5’
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Permeability, D
Fig.1. Relationship between porosity and permeability (to gas) of dry sand packs. I = < 0.1 mni in diameter; I1 = 0 . 1 4 . 2 5 mm in diameter; I11 = > 0.25 mm in diameter; IV = 50y0of sand is < 0.1 mrn, and 50% is 0 . 1 4 . 2 5 nim in diameter; V = 50% of sand is > 0.25 mrn, and 50% is < 0.1 mrn in diameter; VI = 50% of sand is 0.1-0.25 mm, and 50% is > 0.25 mni in diameter. (After KHANIN,1958,
fig. 1.)
graphs such as those presented in Fig. 1 will enable sedimentologists at least to estimate the permeability of sands of known porosity and grain size distribution.
EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES
Permeabilities were measured by air in a permeameter having a capillary-tube flowmeter. The measured values were corrected to infinite mean pressure from the data of HEIDet al. (1950). Their average correction for the appropriate permeability was applied to each sample. Bulk volumes were obtained with a pycnometer using mercury, whereas solid volumes were measured in an Oilwell research porosimeter (BEESON, 1950). It is a Boyle’s law instrument operated with helium. The samples used by the writer were ordinary bottom-hole, consolidated sandstone cores, which were thoroughly cleaned by solvent extraction and distillation and were dried in a vacuum oven for 24 hours at a temperature of 100°C. The porosity and permeability measurements were made on dry cores and on cores containing an irreducible minimum of interstitial formation water.
INTERRELATIONS BETWEEN SOME SANDSTONE PROPERTIES
73
Porosity. %
Fig.2. Relationship between porosity and permeability of very coarse-grained, coarse- and mediumgrained, silty and clayey sandstones.
The interstitial water content (irreducible minimum) was determined with an apparatus using principles of capillarity (BEESON,1953, p.21). Inasmuch as only the interstitial water content in the pendular region is desired, a single measurement may be made at a pressure sufficiently high to be on the nearly vertical portion of the water saturation ( S , )versus the capillary pressure (P,) curve (BEESON,1953, p.19). A generalized dispersion routine (KRUMBEIN and PETTIJOHN, 1938, pp.70-75) was used in the preparation of samples before determining the grain size distribution. The sandstones containing more than 5 0 x of 1-2 mm fraction were called very coarsegrained; 0.5-1 mm, coarse-grained; 0.254.5 mrn, medium-grained; and 0.1-0.25 mrn, fine-grained. Sandstones containing more than 10% of silt (< 0.1 mm) were called “silty”, whereas if clay content (< 0.004 mm) was in excess of 7 % the sandstones were called “clayey”. The latter value, however, is not final and is subject to changes with further research.
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
In Fig.2, the permeability was plotted on a logarithmic scale, whereas porosity was
74
G . V. CHILlNGAR
plotted on an arithmetic scale. As shown in this figure, when the grain size distribution is taken into consideration there is a correlation between the porosity and the permeability of cores containing an irreducible minimum of interstitial water. Such a correlation, however, does not seem to exist between the permeability and porosity of dried samples of sandstones, although in many instances these “dry” points do fall on proper curves in Fig.2. Apparently, on measuring the porosity of many dry cores, in addition to measuring the volume of the larger pores (through which the major part of the flow occurs) one also measures the pore volume of minute interstices and cracks which do not affect permeability. The scattering of points in Fig.2 shows, however, that variables other than porosity and grain size distribution influence permeability; and future experiments will be designed to study the effect of other petrographic properties. In the case of silty sandstones, there is a break in the porosity versus logarithm of permeability curve at about 100 md, whereas for coarse- and medium-grained sandstones the break occurs at about 1,000 md.
CONCLUSIONS
On considering grain size distribution, there is a correlation between the porosity and permeability of sandstones, containing an irreducible minimum of interstitial formation water, and unconsolidated sands. Considerable amount of research work, however, still remains to be done in this field.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The writer is greatly indebted to the following ex-petroleum engineering students (now petroleum engineers working for various oil companies) for their contribution to the present study: R. C. Main, Ali Sinnokrot, Myron Smith Jr., Bill Graham, Frank Lortscher and Edward Zinzer. The help extended by Dr. C. M. Beeson is also greatly appreciated.
SUMMARY
The porosity, permeability, and grain size distribution of 610 sandstone cores (dry and containing an irreducible minimum of interstitial water) from various parts of U. S. were determined by the writer and his students. Porosity (in %) was then plotted versus the logarithm of permeability (in md) separately for (a) very coarse-grained, (b) coarse- and medium-grained, (c) fine-grained, ( d ) silty, and (e) clayey sandstones. Correlation has been found to exist between the porosity and permeability of sandstone cores containing interstitial formation water.
INTERRELATIONS BETWEEN SOME SANDSTONE PROPERTIES
75
REFERENCES
BEESON,C. M., 1950. The Kobe porosimeter and the Oilwell porosimeter. Trans. A.I.M.E., 189 : 313-31 8. BEESON,C. M., 1953. Core Analysis Principles and Experiments. Univ. Southern Calif. Publ., Los Angeles, 55 pp. CHILINGAR, G. V., 1957. Khanin's classification of reservoir rocks. Compass, 34 (4) : 335-339. GRIFFITHS, J. C., 1952a. Grain size distribution and reservoir rock characteristics. Bid/. An?. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 36 : 205-229. GRIFFITHS, J. C., 1952b. Measurement of the properties of sediments (abstract). Bull. Ceol. SOC. Am., 63 : 1256. GRIFFITHS. J. C., 1958. Petrography and porosity of the Cow Run sand, St. Marys, West Virginia. J. Sediment. Petrol., 28 : 15-30. HEID,J. G., MCMAHON,J. J., NLELSEN, R. F. and YUSTER, S . T., 1950. Study of the permeability of rocks to homogeneous fluids. A.P.I. Drill. Prod. Pract., 1950 : 23&246. KHANIN,A. A., 1956. About classification of petroleum and natural gas reservoir rocks. Razvedka i Okhrana Nedr., 1 : 7-16. KHANIN,A. A., 1958. Toward question of determining reservoir properties of non-cemented sandstones. Tr. Vses. Nauchn. Issled. Inst. Khim. Pereraborki Gazov, 4 (12) : 8 pp. KOTYAKHOV, F. I., 1949. Interrelationship between major physical parameters of sandstones. Nefr. Khoz., 12 : 29-32. KRUMBEIN, W. C . and PETITJOHN,F. J., 1938. Manual of Sedimentary Petrography. AppletonCentury-Crofts, New York, 549 pp. MUSKAT,M., 1949. Physical Principles of Oil Production. McGraw-Hill, New York,922 pp.
HOLOCENE REGRESSIVE LITTORAL SAND, COSTA D E NAYARIT, MEXICO' JOSEPH R . CURRAY
and
D A V I D G. MOORE
Scripps Institiition of Oceanography, University of California, La Jolla, Calif.; U.S . Navy Electronics Laboratory, San Diego, CaliK ( U . S . A . )
INTRODUCTlON
The coastal plain and continental shelf of the west coast of mainland Mexico have been investigated as a part of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography project on the geology and oceanography of the Gulf of California. One of the areas of greatest geological interest is the area south of Mazatlan, Sinaloa, and north of San Blas, Nayarit, on the mainland side of the Gulf of California (Fig. 1). Both the coastal plain and the continental shelf in this region are dominated by the influence of the Rio Crande de Santiago, one of the major rivers of the west coast of Mexico, with lesser influence by the smaller adjacent rivers to the north and south. During Pleistocene periods of lower sea level, the Rio Crande built a complex delta system on the continental shelf, and in places prograded the edge of the shelf seaward into deeper water. The Holocene transgression moved the shoreline across the exposed upper surface of this delta complex to a position several kilometers inland of its present position. During the last few thousand years, the shoreline has regressed by deposition of a sheet-like body of littoral sand. This paper represents a progress report dealing with the general distribution of the sediments of the regressive sand body, its relationship to the underlying and overlying sediments, and the mechanism of deposition and regression at work along this coastline. The submerged Pleistocene delta complex of the adjacent continental shelf is the subject of another progress report (MOOREand CURRAY, 1963).
REGIONAL DESCRIPTION
The coastal plain (Fig. I ) consists of a low-lying marsh essentially at sea level, overlapping on the seaward-dipping flood plain surface of the Rio Grande de Santiago and the smaller adjacent rivers to the north and south. The coastal marsh exists mainly Contribution from the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, La Jolla, Calif.
I \ , I '
< \ '/ /
2
\
7 /
\
/
/.
Fig.1. Bathymetric and physiographic chart of the Costa de Nayarit continental shelf - coastal plain complex. Coastal plain consists of system of abandoned Holocene beach-dune ridges, shown diagrammatically, overlying pre-Holocene-transgressive alluvium, and in turn overlain in part by younger Holocene alluvium. Protuberance in continental shelf edge is Pleistocene delta system of Rio Crande de Santiago. (After MWREand CURRAY, 1963.)
78
J. R. CURRAY A N D D. G . MOORE
Fig.2. Oblique air views of abandoned Holocene beach-dune ridges during flood season. Average width of ridges shown is about 80 m. (Photos courtesy of F. B Phleger.) a. Landward half of strand plain of abandoned beach ridges covered with mangroves. b. Closer to ocean than upper photograph, showing discontinuity between adjacent sets of ridges. Younger ridges closer to ocean are built higher and closer together than older ridges, and coastline was I eoriented before formation of younger ridees.
REGRESSIVE LITTORAL S A N D OF COSTA DE N A Y A R I T
79
in the depressions between scores of parallel abandoned beach-dune ridges (Fig.2). This strand plain of abandoned beach ridges averages about 5 km in width for the entire 225 km distance from Mazatlan to San Blas, and about 10 km in width for the better developed cer,tral 130 km length. Maximum width from the present beach to the oldest ridge is 17 km. The upper surface of the strand plain is uniformly furrowed by the parallel ridges, which are typically spaced 30-200 ni apart. About 250 ridges can be counted in air photographs from one of the better developed parts of the plain 12 km wide, giving an average width of about 50 ni per ridge. Relief varies from less than I n i to a maximum of about 5 m above the surrounding level. Detailed leveling shows that the entire plain lies at about sea level. The sand body is continuous between the ridges and all the way across the strand plain (Fig.3). Some depressions between the ridges contain elongate surface lenses of modern alluvium, but sand is always encountered at depth under the alluvium. Some of the smaller rivers of the area discharge directly into the ocean, but others discharge into the tidal marsh between the sand ridges. Seasonal flooding accompanied by influx of alluvial muds is gradually prograding the river flood plains over the landward edge of the strand plain. Only the depressions between the ridges have been filled with modern alluvium in most of the area, but locally some of the older ridges near the landward edge of the plain have been completely buried. The continuous sand sheet overlies the pre-transgressive or Pleistocene flood plain deposits of the coalescing river system (Fig.3). This alluvial surface has been traced by drilling under the coastal strand plain, and it has been delineated in detail on the shallow continental shelf by acoustic reflection niethods (MOORE and CURRAY. 1963). The surface is irregular as a result of subaerial erosion, and sand-filled river channels
mPRE-TRANSGRE5SlVE (PL EIST OC EN E) A L L U V I U M
Fig.3. Diagrammatic cross section through coastal plain and inner continental shelf. Formation of ridges is by successive accretion of submerged longshore bars. During period of low waves, bar is built to surface and becomes new beach, thereby isolating former beach and creating a narrow lagoon. Lagoon is partially filled by washover and later covered with modern alluvium.
80
J. R. CURRAY A N D D. G. MOORE
have been detected both under the strand plain and at sea. Average slope of the irregular surface under the strand plain is about 1.3 m/km (7 ft./mile). Sands composing the strand plain are of fine grain and well sorted, with a high proportion of feldspar and volcanic rock fragments. The older alluvial deposits consist of alternating sandy muds and muddy sands, while the younger alluvium consists mainly of fine mud.
MECHANISM OF FORMATION OF SAND RIDGES
Each ridge was formed individually as a shoreline deposit; the oldest lie farthest from the ocean, and the youngest lie closest to the ocean. The present shoreline is analogous in most respects to each of the ridges at its time of formation. The mechanism of formation proposed for these features is that each ridge started as a submerged longshore bar in front of the existing beach. Laboratory wave tank experiments (MCKEEand STERRETT, 1961) and beach and wave studies (KEULEGAN, 1948; SHEPARD, 1950; D.L. Inman, personal communication, 1961) have shown that longshore bars form initially at the plunge point of breakers. With sufficiently high rate of supply of sand, and with conditions of low wave action, a bar can build to the surface. If this occurs during a high tide and if the low wave conditions persist through the low tide and several tidal cycles thereafter, the longshore bar in effect becomes the new beach, and the former beach is isolated. This process has apparently repeated itself cyclically since the time sea level came approximately to its present position. Cause for the periodicity might be fluctuation in the amount of sand supplied to the beach shoreface, fluctuation in wave and tidal conditions, or the process may occur under conditions of more or less uniform rate of supply and oceanographic conditions. The writers favor the latter explanation: that rate of supply and wave and tidal conditions were approximately uniform throughout the period of formation of the entire strand plain. After formation of each successive new beach ridge, the process started over again after a sufficient supply of sand was brought into the area either by longshore transport from the rivers, or bv reworking of older sediments on the shallow continental shelf. The shoreface was then built seaward to provide a base for the formation of a new longshore bar, and the new bar was built to above sea level. This in effect creates a self-regulating cyclic process, independent of external periodic influence. Age of the oldest abandoned beaches and development of the strand plain is not yet known. The only radiocarbon date available suggests that sea level came approximately to its present position 3,000-5,000 years ago. Assuming a uniform and regular rate of formation, an average of 12-20 years were required for the formation of each ridge. It is known, however, that long term periods of change of conditions and interruption of the regular sequence did occur, and the entire coastline was reoriented to produce discontinuities. (Fig.2b). Another major reorientation of the coastline may be occurring at the present day, because the coastline is locally eroding or trans-
REGRESSIVE LITTORAL SAND OF COSTA DE NAYARIT
81
gressing landward with consequent better development of the present beach ridge. The problems of ages of the ridges, rate of formation, and position of relative Late Holocene sea level in this area cannot be given final answers until further information has been acquired by radiocarbon dating.
SIGNIFICANCE OF REGRESSIVE SANDS
Factors controlling the processes of transgression and regression (CURKAY, 1963) are change of relative sea level and net rate of deposition or erosion along the shoreline. Inasmuch as a geological record is commonly preserved only under conditions of rising relative sea level (usually subsidence of the basin of deposition), the common alternation between transgression and regression is due to periodic pulsation of the rate of subsidence or periodic fluctuation of the rate of sediment supply. Holocene sediments of the Costa de Nayarit display a transgressive-regressive record. The transgression across the continental shelf occurred as a result of the very rapid rise of sea level following the Late Wisconsin (Wiirm 11) glaciation, interrupted by periods of delta advance or regression. With final slowing or cessation of the rise of sea level in the last few thousand years, deposition along the shoreline became dominant, and regression started by the process described. Regressive sands are well known from all geological ages and from all continents. The mechanism of the process of regression should be understood in order to interpret the deposits properly. The process described here is one possible mechanism. but perhaps not the only one. With long continued stillstand of sea level and continued high rate of supply of sand, this deposit could develop to dimensions comparable to those of ancient regressive sands. Alluvial deposition and marsh growth over the top of the sand body will complete the regressive aspect with peat or thin coal measures and an overlying continental shale body.
SUMMARY
The coastal plain of the mainland coast of west central Mexico consists of a strand plain marsh of about 250 parallel abandoned beach-dune ridges. The sand of the individual ridges coalesces to form a sheet sand with a furrowed upper surface. The sand overlies the pre-Holocene-traiisgression flood plain surface of the Rio Grande de Santiago and other small adjacent rivers. The sand is in turn partially covered, especially in the depressions between the ridges, with younger or modern Holocene alluvium. The mechanism of formation of the sand body has been regression after approximate stabilization of Holocene sea level by successive accretion of longshore bars in front of the existing beach. Each successive bar was built to sea level by the rapid supply of sand during periods of low wave intensity, and thereby became the new
82
J. R. CURRAY AND D. G . MOORE
beach. The former beach was isolated, and the newly-created lagoon behind the new beach was partially filled by sand. Regressive littoral sand bodies are common in ancient sediments. This is one possible mechanism for their formation. With long continued stillstand of sea level and abundant supply of sand, this deposit could grow to dimensions comparable to those of ancient deposits.
REFERENCES
CURRAY, J. R., 1963. Transgressions and regressions. In: Papers in Marine Geology, Shepard Cotiimemorative Volume. Macmillan, New York, in press. G. H., 1948. An experimental study of submarine sand bars. U.S . Beach Erosion Board KEULEGAN, Tech. Rept. 3: 40 pp. MCKEE,E. D. and STERREIT,T. S., 1961. Laboratory experiments on form and structure of longshore and J. C. OSMOND(Editor), Geometry qf Sandstone Bodies. bars and beaches. In: J. A. PETERSON Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists,Tulsa, pp. 13-28. J. R., 1963. Sedimentary framework of the drowned Pleistocene delta of MOORE,D. G. and CURRAY, Rio Grande de Santiago, Nayarit, Mexico. In: L. M. J. U. VAN STRAATEN (Editor), Delfoic and Shallow Marine Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 275-28 1. SHEPARD, F. P., 1950 Longshore-bars and longshdrktroughs. U. S . Beach Erosion Board Tech. Mem. 15: 32 pp.
UBER BIOGEOCHLMISCHE UMSETZUNGEN IM FRUHSTADIUM DER DIAGENESE’ EGON
T.
DEGENS
Cali‘jomia Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CalF (U.S.A.)
EINLEITUNG
Nur ein geringer Prozentsatz der im Verlauf geologischer Zeiten erzeugten organischen Substanzen hat sich abgelagert und ist in den Sedimenten erhalten geblieben. Der uberwiegende Teil ist als Nahrung biologisch verwertet worden oder aber wurde im Verlauf der Diagenese biogeochemisch umgesetzt. Bereits im Friihstadium der Diagenese vollziehen sich grundlegende Veranderungen in der biochemischen Struktur organischer Substanzen. Dieser erste Abschnitt der Diagenese, welcher den Zeitraum zwischen Absterben des Organismus und dem Ausklang rnikro-biologischer Tatigkeit im unverfestigten Sediment umfasst, modifiziert das organische Spektrum in grundlegender Weise. Unter dern Begriff “Friihdiagenese” fallen dabei alle biogeochemischen Vorgange, die sich wahrend Transport, Ablagerung und irn Bereich der ersten Sedimentmeter vollziehen. Die physikalisch-chemischen Reaktionen, die das organische Material irn weiteren Verlauf der Diagenese verandern, sind, gernessen an den friihdiagenetischen Prozessen, in ihrer Auswirkung n i!r minimal. Im wesentlichen handelt es sich dabei nur noch um eine langsame “Geochemische Reife” der primar oder friihdiagenetisch fixierten Anlagen. Kondensationen bzw. Polymerisationen, Inkohlungsprozesse, Anreicherung durch Migrationsvorgange und andere Phenomene mehr zahlen zu derartigen diagenetischen Maturationen. Was die Verteilung organischer SubstanZen in Oberflachenwassern und Sedimenten angeht, so sind wir relativ gut inforrniert hinsichtlich der absoluten Mengen (total organic matter), die in diesem oder jenem Wasser oder Gestein zu erwarten sind. Eine iibersichtliche Darstellung der in der Literatur vorliegenden Ergebnisse vermitteln die Arbeiten von GOLDBERG (1961), EMERY (1960) und HUNT(1962). Dagegen liegen nur wenige Angaben uber die Art und Verteilung biochemischer Molekiile in Sedimenten und Wassern vor. Folglich fehlen auch viele Voraussetzungen fur die genaue Auswertung und Deutung biogeochernischer Umsetzungen, die sich zweifelsohne im Verlauf der Diagenese am organischen Material vollzogen haben. Die wesentlichen Daten auf diesem Sektor der organischen Geochernie sind in den Arbeiten von VAL-
’ Contrib. no. 1116, Division of Geological Sciences.
84
E. T. DEGENS
LENTYNE (1957), ABELSON (1959), EMERY (1960), RITTENBERG et al. (1963) und DECENS et al. (1963a, b) zusammengefasst.
UBERBLICK
Nachvorsichtigen Schatzungen (HUNT,1962;WEEKS,1958) sind insgesamt 3,8 . IOI5 t organischer Substanz in Sedimenten fixiert; davon entfallen auf tonige Absatze 3,5 * 1515t ; der Rest ist an Sandsteine und Karbonate gebunden (0,3 1015 t). Die iiberwiegende Menge der im Sediment konservierten Biomasse ist dabeimit feinklastischen Flachmeerabsatzen assoziiert. Hier liegen die organischen Substanzen durchweg in fein verteilter Form vor und erreichen Konzentrationen, die sich im Mittel zwischen zwei und drei Prozent bewegen. Organische Konzentrate wie Kohle und Erdol sind mengenmassig demgegeniiber nur unbedeutend. So werden die Kohlenvorrate der Welt von verschiedenen Autoren mit 6 * 10l2 t angegeben, wahrend die des Erdols sogar nur 0,2 10I2 t betragen (WEEKS,1958; HUNT,1962). Mit andern Worten, das Verhaltnis KohleErdol zu feinverteilten organischen Substanzen liegt in der Grossenordnung von 1j500. Wegen ihres hohen Anteils an organischer Substanz in Verbindung mit der weiten geologischen Verbreitung kommt damit den feinklastischen Flachmeerabsatzen fur Untersuchungen auf dem Gebiete der organischen Geochemie besondere Bedeutung zu. Vide noch offenstehende Fragen von akademischen und praktischem Interesse konnen von hier aus rnoglicherweise ihre Antwort finden. Zwei der wichtigsten Fragen betreffen dabei die Evolution der organischen Materie und die Entstehung des Erdols. Um die eine oder andere der auftauchenden Fragen beantworten zu konnen, muss man zunachst einmal die wichtigsten diagenetischen Prozesse und ihre Auswirkung auf das biochemische Spektrum der Sedimente kennen, bevor sich weitreichende geologische Schliisse in dieser oder jenen Richtung ziehen lassen. So hat sich immer mehr herausgestellt, dass ohne eine zufriedenstellende Klarung der Vorgange in den ersten Sedimentmetern, Aussagen iiber fossile organische Spektren im Spekulativen stehen bleiben. Der in der klassischen Geologie allgemeingultige Satz, dass die Gegenwart der Schiissel zur Vergangenheit ist, hat seine tiefere Bedeutung auch fur das Gebiet der organischen Geochemie. Vom Verfasser und seinen Mitarbeitern wurden im Verlauf der letzten Jahre biogeochemische Untersuchungen an marinen Sedimenten und Meerwassern ausgefiihrt, welche die vorliegende Fragenstellung zum Thema hatten. Als Arbeitsgebiet wurden Sedimentationsbecken ausgesucht, die der Kuste Siidkaliforniens vorgelagert sind. Von allem, was wir iiber den geologisch-strukturellenAufbau dieser Becken wissen '(EMERY,1960), ahnelt er weitgehend dem fossiler Geosynklinalraume. Systematisch fentnommene Sedimentprofile aus reduzierendem und oxydierendem Milieu, sowie Wasserproben aus verschiedener Meerestiefe (0-4.000 m) wurden auf eine Reihe biochemischer Substanzen analysiert. Besonders eingehend untersucht wurden Eiweisse und Kohlenhydrate, wahrend die Untersuchungen auf Phenole, Indole, Fette,
-
-
BIOGEOCHEMISCHEUMSETZUNGEN IM FRUHSTADIUM DER DIAGENESE
85
Huminsauren und Nukleinsauren noch in ihren Anfangen stehen. Die ersten Ergebnisse aus diesen Studien sind im nachfolgenden Abschnitt kurt dargestellt. Die Untersuchungen wurden weitgehend ermoglicht durch die Unterstiitzung der National Science Foundation, der American Chemical Society (Petroleum Research Fund) und der American Association of Petroleum Geologists (Research Fund). Den genannten Organisationen sei hiermit gedankt.
DISKUSSION
Der Gehalt des Meerwassers an organischen Substanzen wird durch eine Reihe von Faktoren bestimmt, unter denen die geographische Lage (landfern-landnah), Meerestiefe, Wasserbewegung, Temperatur, und die Menge und Art geloster Nahrsubstanzen eine bedeutende Rolle spielen. Die Durchschnittswerte liegen zwischen 1 und 10 mg/l, doch sind wesentlich hohere Gehalte im kustennahen Flachmeerbereich zu finden (KREY,1961). Zu den wichtigsten organischen Substanzen des Ozeans zahlen neben Phytoplankton, Zooplankton und Tripton (particulate matter) auch die im Wasser gelosten organischen Stoffe. Die drei erstgenannten organischen Bestandteile gelten allgemein als die wichtigsten Lieferanten fur die organischen Substanzen, die in das marine Sediment eingehen, wahrend den gelosten Stoffen nur wenig Bedeutung in dieser Richtung beigemessen wird. Die organische Trockensubstanz des marin erzeugten Planktons besteht im wesentlichen aus Eiweiss, Kohlenhydraten und Fetten in einem durchschnittlichen Verhaltnis von etwa 50/30/20. Pigmente sind demgegeniiber quantitativ unbedeutend; die irn kontinentalen Pflanzenreich so dominierende biochemische Gruppe der Lignine fehlt im allgemeinen ganzlich. Das in Suspension befindliche organische Material (Detritus) wird in seiner Hauptmasse als abgestorbenes Plankton angesehen, welches sich in verschiedenen Stadien der Zersetzungbefindet. Die bei Stoffwechselumsetzungen und organischem Zerfall freiwerdenden Molekiile werden vom Meerwasser aufgenornmen und bilden einen wesentlichen Bestandteil der sich in Losung befindlichen organischen Stoffe. Der organische Detritus sinkt allmahlich zum Meeresboden und liefert das Ausgangsmaterial fur die sich im Sediment langsam konsolidierenden organischen Substanzen. Das ist in grossen Ziigen das Konzept iiber Herkunft, Chemismus und Diagenese organischer Substanzen wie wir es aus der Literatur kennen. Diese Vorstellung ist in vielen Punkten sicherlich richtig, in einigen jedoch bedarf sie entschieden einer Neuformulierung. Korrekt sind die Angaben iiber die biochemische Zusammensetzung des Planktons; die Ansichten iiber organische Sedimentation und Diagenese sind hingegen zum Teil revisionsbediirftig. Anhand der Verteilung von Aminosauren, Zucker, Phenolen und anderer biochernischer Substanzen im Meenvasser und rezenten marinen Sedimenten wird nachfolgend ein Konzept entwickelt, das Details iiber den Ablauf biogeochemischer Umset-
86
E. T. DEGENS
zungen im Friihstadium der Diagenxe vermittelt und ergaiizend Aussagen iiber Art und Ursprung organischer Substanzen in marinen Flachmeersedimenten zulasst. In Abb. 1 ist das Aminosaurespektrum von Plankton, Tripton, gelosten Substanzen und marinen Sedimenten dargestellt. Aus Vergleichsgrunden sind die Materialien dem gleichen Sedimentationsraum entnommen (offshore California). Zur besseren Ubersicht wurden die einzeliien Aminosauren gruppenweise zusammengefasst (basisch, sauer, neutral, aromatisch); wegen zu geringzr Konzentration blieben schwefelhaltige Aminosauren (Cystin, Methionin) unberucksichtigt.
lob
A ROM AT I SC H
SAUER
Phenylolonin
Fl Volln __
Plankton
NEUTRAL
Leucin und lsoleucin
0
Ozeon - qebunden
Threonin
m
Ozeonfrei
Prolin
0
Sediment
~~
Abb.1. Art und Verteilung von Aminosiuren in ( I ) Plankton, (2) Ozean, gebunden, (3) Ozean, frei und ( 4 ) rezentern Sediment (Mol. yo).
Aus der Art und Verteilung der Aminosauren lassen sich verschiedene Schliisse ziehen. Zunachst ergibt sich die interessante Tatsache, dass Substanzen, die dem Meerwasser nahezu oder vollig fehlen, im Sediment erheblich angereichert sind, doch auch eine Verarmung an bestimmten Aminosauren im Sediment und eine entsprechende Anreicherung im Ozean ist zu beobachten. Die biochemischen Wechselbeziehungen, welche sich daraus ergeben, lassen sich am besten anhand ausgesuchter Beispiele veranschaulichen:
BLOGEOCHEMISCHE UMSETZUNGEN IM FRUHSTADIUM DER DIAGENESE
87
Arginin, Ornithin und Asparaginsaure stehen durch den sogenannten “Harnstoff Zyklus” miteinander in Verbindung. In Anwesenheit von Arginase spaltet sich Arginin enzymatisch in Ornithin und Harnstoff auf. Die Armut des Ozeans an Arginin und sein Reichtum an Ornithin und Harnstoff (DEGENS et al., 1963a), mag so seine Erklarung finden. Andererseits lasst sich aus Ornithin und Asparaginsaure iiber verschedene Zwischenprodukte wie Citrullin, das Arginin biologisch erzeugen. Bakterien und andere im Sediment aktive Organismen scheinen demnach das im Meerwasser in freier Form vorliegende Ornithin zusammen mit der Asparaginsaure zu verwerten, wobei Arginin als Endprodukt auftritt. Wasserproben, die dem unmittelbaren Kontakt Ozean-Sediment entstammen (Wassertiefe 3.800 m), zeigen gegeniiber hohergelegenen Wassern [Wassertiefe 0-3.000 m) eine auffallige Verarmung an gelosten biochemischen Substanzen. Diese Beobachtung spricht dafiir, dass neben Ornithin rnoglicherweise auch andere freie Substanzen einigen Sedimentbewohnern als Nahrung dient. Besonders eindrucksvoll ist der Nachweis des im Sediment neugebildeten P-Alanins, einer Aminosaure, die sowohl dem Plankton als auch den iibrigen organischen Substanzen des Meerwassers fehlt. Das Auftreten von P-Alanin l a s t sich einmal durch eine metabolische Decarboxylierung von Asparaginsaure erklaren, zum andern sind Dipeptide wie Anserin und Carnosin bekannt, die P-Alanin als Baustein enthalten. Es lassen sich noch viele biochemische Mechanismen dieser Art aus dem Aminoslurespektrum ableiten (DEGENS et al., 1963a, b). Einzeln auf sie einzugehen ist aber im Rahrnen dieser Arbeit nicht moglich. Im Ganzen jedoch sprechen sie dafiir, dass das abgestorbene marine Plankton, welches den Meeresboden letztlich erreicht, von den Sedimentbewohnern nahezu vollkommen verspeist wird, wobei de novo Eiweisse anderartiger Arninosaure-Zusammensetzung erzeugt werden. Ein ahnliches Bild ergibt sich auch fur die Kohlenhydrate. Die im Meerwasser so reichlich vorhandene Glukose, Mannose und Galaktose wird im Sediment gewissermassen “biometasornatisch” nach Rhamnose, Arabinose, Xylose und Ribose verdrangt. Die im Sediment vorliegenden Zucker sind damit weitgehend in situ gebildet worden. Stellt man abschliessend eine Bilanz der Proteine und Kohlenhydrate auf, so ergibt sich die interessante Feststellung, dass die von Meeresorganismen im Ozean gebildeten Substanzen von den Sedimentbewohnern biologisch verwertet werden. Diese Umsetzungen erfolgen schneller und vollstandiger unter oxydierenden als unter reduzierenden Sedirnentationsbedingungen. Die Sedimentationsrate ist hierbei ebenfalls ein entscheidener Faktor: Die im Sediment neugebildeten Eiweisse und Kohlenhydrate haben wie das Plankton im Ozean nur eine kurze Existenzdauer. Als Beweis dafur sollen die biogeochemischen Analysen von RITTENBERG et al. (1963) dienen, die an Sedimenten der “Experimental Mohole” ausgefiihrt wurden. Das Mohole-Profil [ 170 m) urnfasst den stratigraphischen Zeitabschnitt vom Miozan bis zur Gegenwart. Bereits nach wenigen Metern Tiefe ist das Aminosaure-und Zuckerspektrum, wie es von den Sedimentbewohnern erzeugt wurde, ganzlich verandert. Auch mengenmassig gehen die Werte auf
88
E. T. DEGENS
das zehn- bis zwanzigfache zuriick. Hochst verwunderlich wirkt zunachst die Alinlichkeit mit dem biochemischen Spektrum des Triptons (particulate matter). Bevor eine Deutung dieses Phenomens iiberhaupt moglich ist, muss der biostrukturelle Aufbau der Materie im Wasser und Sediment bekannt sein. Es geht dabei ausschliesslich um die Frag:, ob die Aminosauren und Zucker in freier (molecular dispersed) oder gebundener Form in den verschiedenen Medien vorliegen. Im letzteren Fall ist auch die Bindungsart von Interesse. In rezenten Sedimenten liegt das Verhaltnis von freien zu gebundenen Substanzen in der Grossenordnung von 11250. Bei den gebundenen Substanzen der obersten Sedimentmeter handelt es sich in1 wesentlichen um Proteine, Peptide und Polysaccharide. Mit zunehmenden geologischen Alter werden diese weitgehend eliminiert. Die dem Sedinimt verbleibenden Zucker- und Aminosaurekomponenten sind entweder adsorptiv gebunden (z.B. an Tone oder Kerogen) oder aber liegen als nicht-eiweiss bzw. nicht-kohlenhydratartiger organischer Komplex vor (DEGENS et al., 1963a, b). Besonders b-fahigt zu einer derartigen Komplexbildung sind Humussubstanzen. Die Synthese von HLimin-Aminosaure Polymeren, die chemisch den Humusextrakten von Boden ahneln, ist SWABY (1956-1958) gelungen. Die organisshe Substanz der untersuchten Flachmeersedimente besteht aus 30-50 % sogenannter Huminsauren, wobei darunter die Substanzen verstanden werden, die sich mit 0.3 N NaOH aus dem Sediment extrahieren lassen (DEGENSund REUTER, 1962). Die isolierten Humusextrakte ergeben nach Hydrolyse mit 6 N HCI grossere Mengen u.a. an Arninosauren und Phenolen. Nach allem, was wir iiber Natur und Herkunft von Huminsauren wissen, kommen Ligninsubstanzen als ihr g:eigneteste Ausgangsmaterial in Betracht. Gleiches gilt auch fur viele Phenole, so wie sie in Boden, Sedimenten und Oberflachenwassern auftreten. Es s:i in diesem Zusammenhang erwahnt, dass das Phenolspektrum der untersuchten Sedim-nte und Wasser dem kontinentalen Boden vollig entspricht. Auch die aus terrestrischen und marinen Humusextrakten gewonnenen Phenolsauren unterscheiden sich biochemisch und damit faziell durch nichts voneinander (MORRISON,1958; DEGENS et al., 1963a, b). Es wurde anfangs erwahnt, dass Lignin am Aufbau mariner Organismen so gut wie nicht beteiligt ist. Die im Sediment nachgewiesenen Humusextrakte entstarnmen daher aller Voraussicht nach iiberwiegend dem Kontinent. Beriicksichtigt man zudem die Aminosaure- und Zuckerspektren in den Sedimentabschnitten unterhalb der Zone rnikrobiologischer Tatigkeit, so sprechen alle Anzeichen dafiir, dass die erhaltungsFahigen organischen Substanzen grosstenteils kontinentalen Ursprungs sind. Das terrestrische organische Material gelangt in die marinen Sedimentationsbecken entweder in geloster Form oder via Detritus, wobei besonders feinklastisches Material wie Tone als Tragersubstanzen fungieren konnen. Tone sind ausserdem befahigt, das sich in Losung befindliche organische Material adsorptiv aufzunehmen. Das im Meerwasser als Tripton vorliegende organische Material l h s t sich als eine komplexe Mischung zwischen marinen und terrestrischen biochemischen Substanzen auffassen. Eine mechanische Trennung beider Arten ist bisher nicht gelungen. Die
BIOGEOCHEMISCHEUMSETZUNGEN IM FRUHSTADIUM DER DIAGENESE
89
quantitativen Anteile lassen sich in etwa “biochemisch” abschatzen, kennt man die durchschnittliche Verteilung von Aminosauren in Boden und im Plankton. Tripton weist biochemisch starkere kontinentale als marine Ziige auf (70-90 %). Diese Ergebnisse werden weitgehend unterstiitzt durch Kohlenstoff-lsotopenanalysen. Bekanntlich liegt das 613C mariner Organismen zwischen -80 und -17, relativ zum PDB I Standard (CRAIG,1953, 1957)’. Fur terrestrisches Material liegen die Werte generell zwischen -20 und -30. Auf die biologischen und physikalischchemischen Fraktionierungsvorgange, welche diese Isotopenunterschiede zwischen marinen und terrestrischen Organismen hervorrufen, sol1 hier nicht naher eingegangen werden; Einzelheiten sind den Arbeiten von CRAIG(1953, 1957) und VOGEL(1959) zu entnehmen. Die aus dem Flachmeerbereich (San Diego Becken) isolierten Huminextrakte haben ein 613Cvon -22. Dieses Ergebnis stimmt mit dem ECKELMAN’S et al. (1962) uberein, die auf Grund umfangreicher Kohlenstoff-Tsotopenanalysenan rezentem und fossikrn organischen Material zu dem Schluss gelangten, dass die seit paliiozoischen Zeiten in marinen Geosynklinalraumen abgesetzten bzw. erhaltenen organischen Substanzen wahrscheinlich dem Kontinent entstammen. Damit ergeben sich vollig neue Aspekte f i r viele wissenschaftliche und angewandte Fragen in der Geologie. Beispielsweise finden - nimmt man fur Kohlenwasserstoffe ein terrestrisches Ausgangsmaterial an - die leichten Kohlenstoffisotopenwerte fur Petroleum ihre Erklarung (SILVERMAN und EPSTEIN,1958; ECKELMANN et al., 1962). Ob dabei die aus rezenten Sedimenten bekannten Kohlenwasserstoffe im C,,-,, Bereich (MEINSCHEIN, 1961) bereits in kontinentalen Boden entstanden sind oder aber in marinen Sedimenten aus terrestrischen organischen Substanzen im Verlauf der Diagenese hervorgegangen sind, ist dabei nur von sekundarem Interesse. Auch das oftmals sehr hohe 14C-Alter rezenter mariner Sedimente (EMERY,1960) ist moglicherweise durch eine Zumischung toter oder wenig I4C-aktiver terrigener Substanzen bedingt. Der hohe Gehalt an “Humus” in feinklastischen Flachmeerabsatzen in Verbindung mit seiner Kondensationsfahigkeit mit andern Substanzen wie Aminosauren, Zuckern, Nukleinsauren, Fettsauren, Phenolen u.a., dem relativ geringen Nahrwert und der oftmals sogar bakteriziden Wirkung, ein Ergebnis seines phenolischen Charakters, machen ihn zu dem gegebenen Ausgangsmaterial fur Kerogen. In diesem Zusammenhang werden auch die Beobachtungen von HUNT(1 962) und GEHMAN (1962) iiber die unterschiedliche Verteilung von organischen Substanzen in Schiefern und Karbonaten besser verstandlich. Rezente Tone und Kalke enthalten im Durchschnitt etwa ‘2-3 % organische Substanz. Wahrend in Schiefertonen dieser Wert beibehalten wird, betragt er in fossilen Kalksteinen und Dolomiten nur noch 0,1-O,3 %. Untersucht man daraufhin die Art der biochemischen Substanzen im rezenten Kalkmaterial, so stellt man fest, dass sie zu iiber 90 % aus Eiweiss und zu 5 % aus Kohlenhydraten bestehen; Pigmente und Huminsauren sind demgegenuber nur in Spuren vertreten. Protein- und Kohlenhydratsubstanzen sind dagegen in rezenten Tonen mit 613C ist die Abweichung des 13C/12CVerhaltnis in
o/Iw
relativ zu einern Standard.
90
E. T. DEGENS
weniger als 10 % a m Aufbau der organischen Materie beteiligt. Diese Tatsache, dass Humusstoffe den grossten Prozentsatz der organischen Substanzen in feinklastischen Sedimenten ausmachen, darf als der Crund angesehen werden, dass Tone ihren organischen Bestand wahrend der Diagenese zwar verandern aber doch weitgehend als solchen verhalten, wahrend Karbonatgesteine ihn in grosserem Umfang verlieren.
ZUSAMMENFASSUNG
Die wichtigsten Ergebnisse, die sich im Verlauf der biogeochemischen Untersuchungen an Wassern und Sedimenten siidkalifornischer Meeresbecken abgezeichnet haben, lassen sich wie folgt festhalten: (I) Die Verteilung van Aminosauren und Zuckern im marinen Plankton ist grundlegend verschieden von dem im ozeanischen Detritus und Flachmeersediment. (2) Die im Ozean gebildeten organischen Substanzen werden weitgehend von den Sedimentbewohnern konsumiert bzw. biochemisch umgesetzt. (3) Die im Sediment de novo erzeugte organische Substanz (Aminosauren und Kohlenhydrate) wird innerhalb der ersten Sedimentmeter biologisch verwertet. (4) Die nach Ausklang mikro-biologischer Tatigkeit demim Sediment verbleibenden Aminosauren und Zucker ahneln in ihrer Zusammensetzung weitgehend denen des ozeanischen Detritus, der seinerseits kontinentale Charakterziige aufweist. (5) Extrahierbare Humussubstanzen sind mit 30-50 % am Aufbau der organischen Fraktion mariner Flachmeersedimente beteiligt. Lignine kontinentaler Herkunft werden als ihr eigentliches Ausgangsmaterial angesehen. Melaninartige Produkte mariner Herkunft mogen zwar zur Huminsare-Fraktion der Sedimente beitragen, jedoch wird dieser Beitrag aus biogeochemischen Uberlegungen als relativ gering bet rac h tet . (6) Aminosauren, Phenole, Kohlenhydrate und andere biochemische Produkte sind chemosorptiv an die Humussubstanzen gebunden. Sie gehen miteinander moglicherweise spezifische Polymere ein von der Art, wie sie z.B. in Melanin oder Melanoidin Strukturen vorliegen. (7) Derartige Substanzen bilden ein potentielles Ausgangsmaterial fur Kerogen. (8) Das leichte Kohlenstoff-Isotopenverhaltnis der Humusfraktion in Verbindung mit seinem biochemischen Spektrum spricht fur seine iiberwiegend kontinentale Herkunft. (9) Das im marinen Milieu erzeugte organische Material (Plankton) ist reich an Nahrstoffen. Dies fiihrt dazu, dass viele Meeresorganismen und Sedimentbewohner weitgehend oder ausschliesslich von dem planktonischen Substrat leben. Terrestrischer Detritus ist demgegeniiber nahrstoffarm. Diese beiden Faktoren fiihren letzlich dazu, dass die marin erzeugten organischen Substanzen im Verlauf der friihen Diagenese bevorzugt abgebaut werden, wahrend ihre kontinentalen Vertreter dieses Stadium relativ unbeschadet iiberdauern. (10) Unterschiede im Totalgehalt organischer Substanzen zwischen fossilen Kar-
BIOCEOCHEMISCHE UMSETZUNGEN I M FRUHSTADIUM DER DIAGENESE
91
bonaten (niedrig) und Schiefertonen (hoch) sind biochemisch bedingt. Rezente Karbonate enthalten uberwiegend nahrstoffreiche und biologisch leicht zugangliche marin-gebildete Eiweisse, wahrend Tone vornehmlich nahrstoffarme terrigene Humussubstanzen fiihren.
SUMMARY
Organic substances in sea waters and recent marine sediments offshore California are significantly altered during the early stages of diagenesis. Kind and distribution pattern of biochemical materials such as amino acids, sugars, phenols, indoles, and humic acids are indicative of certain reaction mechanisms going on during transportation, deposition, and within recent sediments. They furtheron permit some statements as to the principal source of the organic matter in terms of marine versus continental.
LITERATUR
ABELSON, P. H., 1959. Geochemistry of organic substances. In: P. H. ABELSON (Editor), Researrhes in Geochemisfry.Wiley, New York, pp. 79-103. CRAIG,H., 1953. The geochemistry of the stable carbon isotopes. Ceochinr. Cosmochini. Acta, 3 : 53-92. CRAIG, H., 1957. Isotopic standards for carbon and oxygen and correction factors for inass-spectrometric analysis of carbon dioxide. Ceochini. Cosmochim. Acta, 12 : 133-149. DEGENS, E. T., REUTER, J. H. and SHAW,K. N. F., 1963a. Biochemical compounds in offshore California sediments and sea waters. Geochim. Cosmochirn. Acta, im Druck. DEGENS, E. T., EMERY, K. 0. and REUTER, J. H . , 1963b. Organic materials in Recent and ancient sediments. 111. Biochemical compounds in San Diego Trough, California. N e w s Jahrb. C ~ o l . Palaontol., Monatsh., 1963, im Druck. DEGENS, E. T. and REUTER, J. H., 1963. Analytical techniques in the field of organic geochemistry. Proc. Intern. C o t y r . Ocyanic Geochem., Milan, 1962, im Druck. ECKELMANN, W. R., BROEKER, W. S., WHITLOCK, D. V. and ALLSUP,J. R., 1962. Implications of carbon isotopic composition of total organic carbon of some recent sediments and ancient oils. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geolqyists., 46 : 699-704. EMERY, K. O., 1960. The Seaofsouthern California: A modern Habitat ofPetroleuni. Wiley, New York, 366 pp. GEHMAN JR., H. N., 1962. Organic matter in limestones. Ceochim. Cosmochini. Acfa,26 : 885-897. GOLDBERG, E. D., 1961. Marine geochemistry. Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem., 12 : 2 9 4 8 . HUNT,J. M., 1962. Geochemical data on organic matter in sediments. Proc. Intern. Sci. Oil Conf., Budapest, 1962, im Druck. KREY,J., 1961. The balance between living and dead matter in the oceans. Pitbl. An?. Assoc. Advari. Sci., 61 : 539-548. MEINSCHEIN, W. G., 1961. Significance of hydrocarbons in sediments and petroleum. Geochim. Cosniochim. Acta, 22 : 58-64. MORRISON, R. I., 1958. The alkaline nitrobenzene oxidation of soil organic matter. J . Soil Sci.. 2 : 13&140. RKITENBERC, S. C., EMERY, K. 0..HULSEMANN, J., DEGENS, E. T., FAY,R. C., REUTER. J . H.. GRADY, J. R., RICHARDSON, S. H. and BRAY.E. E., 1963. Biogeochemistry of sediments in Experimental Mohole. J. Sediment. Petrol., 33 (1). SILVERMAN, S. R. and EPSTEIN,S., 1958. Carbon isotopic compositions of petroleums and other sedimentary organic materials. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 42 : 998-1012.
92
E. T. DEGENS
SWABY, R., 1956-1958. Soil organic Matter. 8th, 9th, lOrh C.S.I.R.O., Annual Reports. Government Printers, Sydney, Australia. VALLENTYNE, J. R., 1957. The molecular nature of organic matter in lakes and oceans, with lesser reference to sewage and terrestrial soils. J . Fisheries Res. Board, Can., 14 : 33-82. VOGEL,J. C., 1959. Uber den Isotopengehalt des Kohlenstoffs in Siisswasserkalkablagerungen. Geochini. Cosmochini. Acra, 16 : 236-242. WEEKS, L. G.. 1958. Habitat of oil and some factors that control it. In: L. G. WEEKS(Editor), Habitat of Oil. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 1-61.
ORIGIN AND TRANSPORT OF MUD (FRACTION < 16 MICRONS) IN COASTAL WATERS FROM THE WESTERN SCHELDT T O THE DANISH FRONTIER A . J. D E G R O O T
Institute for Soil Fertility, Groningen (The Netherlands)
INTRODUCTION
The conclusions dealt with in this paper are partly based on analyses of bottom samples of newly deposited niuddy or clayey material (fractions < 16 p). The samples were taken from fresh, brackish and salt parts of estuaries, at different levels with regard to the water level and hence in different environments as to vegetation, groundwater conditions etc., and from similarly varied places on tidal flats and young salt marshes in and along the Dutch and German Wadden Sea. The analyses are compared with others from older marsh deposits, outside the dikes and in polders, that have been embanked within the last 100 years. In total, several thousands of analyses were carried out. No samples of sufficient size could be obtained from material suspended in the coastal waters. A detailed account of the investigations mentioned in the present paper can be found in the author’s thesis (DE GROOT, 1962).
THE MANGANESE SITUATION IN THE EXAMINED DEPOSlTS
A main division of the Mn compounds in the investigated sediments can be made into exchangeable Mn and higher oxides. The exchangeable Mn is bound as manganous ions to the soil colloids and is the most mobile form. The higher oxides form a sequence of compounds with varying reactivity. They can be distinguished by their oxidizing power with respect to reducing agents. The conversions between these Mn forms may be schematized as follows:
c
~- -
Mn2+ exchangeable
~
-
-
~-
~
~
~
~
MnO, --+ easiiy reducible
__
_
_
__
_
_
_
_
I ~
MnO, rather inert
The redox equilibrium between the exchangeable and easily reducible Mn is determined by the pH and the oxygen concentration in the sediment. The oxidation of bivalent Mn, as indicated above, can take place by purely chemical
_
-
~
94
A. J. DE CROOT
processes, at pH values above 4.9, whereas microbiological oxidation may occur at pH's ranging from 4.8 to 8.9. During transport in aerated river or sea water the mud cannot lose Mn, because the latter is almost exclusively present as insoluble higher oxides. Most of it is present in M n contents e x t r a p o l a t e d t o l 0 O 0 / o o f t h e f r a c t i o n <16microns
3 , 4 0 0 - p . p . m . of t o t a l 3,200
Mn
-
3,0002,8 00 2.600-
2.463
-
2,200.
2,0001.800 -
1.6 00 -
1.4001.2 00 1.000-
800600-
Ohof f r a c t l o n < 1 6 m i c r o n s
0
Sediments o f t h e Ems Sediments of t h e Flemish Banks
Fig.1. Linear relationship between Mn content and percentage of fractions
< 16 p.
ORIGIN AND TRANSPORT OF M U D IN COASTAL WATERS
95
the grain size fractions of 0-35 p, as coatings around clastic particles or attached to clay flakes or as individual particles. In connection with this preferred occurrence in the fine fractions, a linear relationship is found to exist between the contents of Mn (both total and reducible Mn) and the fraction < 16 p (in % of the CaC0,-free mineral constituents), at least as long as the origin of the sediments and the environment of deposition are the same. This relationship makes it possible to characterize a whole group of co-genetic sediments with different granulometric compositions by a single value. The value, chosen in the present study, is the Mn content (in p.p.m.) obtained by extrapolation of the relationship to 100 % of the fraction < 16 p (see Fig.1). After deposition, reduction can take place to a smaller or larger extent, depending on the redox potential of the environment, followed by loss of Mn by way of the exchangeable form. I n deposits of marshes and polders lying above the ground water table, this removal probably takes mainly place by drainage of percolating water. It is less obvious in what manner the Mn is carried off from sediments with very low redox potentials on mud flats. Possibly slow movements of the pore water, and diffusion of Mn ions are at least partly responsible. The degree and the velocity of this removal, in conditions of low redox potential, depends on the salt content, the salt ions dissolved i n the pore water tending to replace the Mn attached to the sediment particles. In fresh water environments the Mn content decreases only very slowly. Notwithstanding this loss of Mn, the relationship between Mn contents and percentages of the fraction < 16 p remains approximately linear, so that the characteristic values (for 100 % of the fraction < 16 p) can still be determined in the same way as for freshly deposited material. In areas with sediments coming from the same source, thesevalues are therefore more or less indicative of the degree of ageing. In general, salt marshes yield lower values than the forelying tidal flats, while the values for embanked polders are distinctly lower again than those for the marshes (see Fig.3-5).
CHOICE OF REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLES
For drawing conclusions about the origin and the direction of transport of mud on account of the Mn contents, only a part of the investigated samples could be used. For the tidal flats, the choice of these samples had to be limited to the most recently deposited material (not older than a few days), which was scraped from the surface with a knife. Even so it was found that some values were abnormally low, e.g., those obtained from muds that were deposited after heavy storms, during which much older material in the areas had been resuspended. In other cases the variation of the Mn contents was too large to allow calculation of a representative linear relationship from which a characteristic value could be extrapolated. This variation may probably be attributed t o the mixing of freshly supplied mud from the rivers or the sea, with various locally reworked older materials. In general, only the highest values in each area could be considered as significant in this respect.
96
A. J. DE GROOT ORIGIN AND TRANSPORT OF MUD
The origin of the mud deposits in Zeeland, investigated along the Western and Eastern Scheldt estuaries appears to be twofold. A minor part is supplied by the river Scheldt, the major part coming from the North Sea (Fig.3). The Scheldt river mud has the higher Mn content of the two. Its sedimentation is mainly confined to the eastern part of the Western Scheldt. The river influence decreases towards the west. Its relatively small importance is especially evident when the Mn contents in the muds of the Western and Eastern Scheldt are compared (Zuid Sloe > Noord Sloe; Kreekrakpolder > Hogerwaardpolder). The precise origin of the mud carried from the North Sea into these estuaries is not y:t certain. One possible source is the waters of the British Channel, entering the North Sea through the Straits of Dover. Another source, which has been suggested in the literature on this subject, could be the mud layers in, and in front of the mouth of the Western Scheldt (Flemish Banks and Wielingen), which have Mn contents lying not very far below those of the Zwarte Polder area, the Zuid Sloe and the Noord Sloe. However, the circumstance that their Mn contents (1092) are still rather high, notwithstanding the relatively high salinities of the water, may indicate that these mud
Fig.2. Water movements in the North Sea, according to KALLE(1937).
ORIGIN A N D TRANSPORT OF M U D IN COASTAL WATERS
97
T h e sedimentation a r e a of the southwestern Netherlands
p/ I.
"5 \
-
~~
o
5
k
m
layers are not old at all, but that they were deposited recently. Consequently, the material of the Flemish Banks and the Wielingen looks rather like another deposit of the same mud supplied via the Straits of Dover. By investigating the sediments of the fresh water tidal delta of the Biesbosch (Fig.2) it was found that little difference exists between the Mn contents of the mud supplied by the Rhine and those of the Meuse. Approximately the same values were obtained for the Haringvliet and the Brielse Gat, whereas in the Grevelingen the value is lower. The latter is probably the result of mixture with mud supplied from the south. The mud transported into the western Wadden Sea, and deposited along the shore of Friesland (Fig.4) has the same value. This inay point to a direct transport of material from the Rhine and the Meuse, along the coast of South and North Holland in northeasterly direction (2 on Fig.2), an interpretation which seems to be corroborated by analyses of mud in the harbour of IJmuiden. The lower Mn contents off the shore of Groningen inay be partly due to temporary deposition in the Wadden Sea, followed by further transport in eastward direction over the Wadden Sea flats. A similar decrease is found when the analyses of the young
98
A. J . DE CROOT .
!
I
The Dutch Wadden coast. t h e Dollard and t h e
'
.
. . .................. 2.
Leybocht
I
I
I
. . . .
/
. . . . . . . . .e;' . . . ... . . .. .. . .. .. . ..... .. . . . . . . . .
-d
. .
. ..:.
Friesland
5
0
I0
I5
20
25Lm
~
Fig.4. For explanation. see Fig.3.
polder deposits of Friesland and Groningen are compared with each other. The Mn contents of the mud carried seaward by the river Ems are considerably higher than those of the Meuse and Rhine sediments (Fig.4). Passing along the shores of the Dollard from the Enis mouth via the southern part to the Punt van Reide ( R ) , this influence is seen to diniinisli gradually. Except for the Punt van Reide itself. the Mn contents i n the Em-Dollard area are everywhere higher than those of comparable deposits in Friesland and northern Croningen, thus clearly showing the significance of the Ems for the sedimentation in the Dollard. The deposits of the reclaimed area of the Leybocht correspond, in Mn content, to the sediments (of comparable degrees of ageing) along the shore of Friesland, which may point to a common origin, viz. out of the North Sea. The mud deposited along the western shores of Schleswig Holstein (Fig.5) has a complex origin. Part of it comes from the Elbe and another part from the older Holocene marine clay beds. eroded on the shallow sea floor in front of Dithmarschen and North Friesland. Other sources may contribute to a smaller degree. The Elbe mud contains more Mn than any other mud investigated. The old clay layers on the sea floor i n front of the coast, on the other hand, have very low Mi1 contents (e.g., Nordstranddanim). The Mn values of the mud deposited at present along this coast therefore depend on the ratio of mixture of the two. The contribution of the Elbe component carried northwards with the sea currents (3 in Fig.2) decreases from the mouth of the Elbe via the Meldorfer Bay to the mouth of the Eider. However, further northward, along the Hindenburgdamm the Mn contents are again very high. The same variations are found in the young polders along this coast. In this connection it is interesting to observe that thc variations in Mn content in the sampled areasoutside the dikes are accompanied by similar changes i n the contents of organic matter. The highest values for organic material in this region were obtained in the deposits along the Elbe. Along the shores of the Meldorfer Bay and the mouth
99
ORIGIN AND TRANSPORT OF MUD IN COASTAL WATERS
of the Eider the contents are much lower (admixture of old marine material, poor in organic matter). The sediments at the Hindenbut-gdamm again show relatively high values. In conclusion it may be remarked that at most only a very subordinate part of the mud deposited along the continental coast can be supplied by the river Thames. This
7 Western coast
of S c h l e s w i q - H o l s t e i n
I I
DENMARK
FRIESLAND
dstranddornrn
1
Weser 0
5
10
15
20
25Lm
Fig.5. For explnnation, see Fig.3.
4'2 8 4
100
A. J. DE GROOT
appears from the low Mn contents of the Thames muds sampled along the shore of Essex. A significant transport of Thames mud across the sea is also unlikely on account of the water circulation in the North Sea (Fig.2). Owing to the flow of water through the Straits of Dover. the waters along the English coast in the vicinity of the mouth of the Thames are carried northeastward, towards the centre of the southern North Sea, rather than across this sea to the shores of Belgium and Holland.
SUMMARY
To determine the contents and character of manganese compounds in Holocene deposits [fractions < 16 p) along the North Sea coast of Holland and Germany, several thousands of analyses have been made. It was found, among other things, that the manganese content is very variable, owing to postdepositional migrations. When this influence is allowed for, regional differences appear to exist, which can be interpreted as the result of primary differences in Mn content of the source material. Using Mn as a tracer, the following conclusions can be drawn about the origin of the mud and the directions of transport along the coast: ( I ) The mud in the Eastern and Western Scheldt is supplied only for a small part by the river Scheldt. The river influence is strongest in the eastern part of the Western Scheldt. Most of the mud deposited in these two estuaries is brought in from the North Sea. Originally it probably comes from the British Channel. (2) The mud of the rivers Rhine and Meuse, which is not deposited in the estuaries, is carried in northeasterly direction. along the coast of South and North Holland and is partly deposited in the Wadden Sea. ( 3 ) Supply of mud by the river Ems is a n important factor for the sedimentation in the Dollard. The contribution of river material is seen to diminish when going along the Dollard shores from the mouth of the Ems via the southern part to the Punt van Reide. (4) Deposition along the western shores of Schleswig Holstein takes place under influence of the supply of mud by the river Elbe and by erosion of older Holocene deposits on the flats in front of the shores of Dithmarschen and North Friesland. ( 5 ) The supply of mud by the river Thames has no visible significance on the composition of the fine grained sediments along the coasts of the continent.
REFERENCES
DE GROOT, A. J., 1962. Mangaantoestand van Nederlandse en Duitse Holocene Seditiaienten it1 Vcrband met Slibtratisport en Bodenyenese. Thesis, Univ. of Utrecht, 205 pp. Also Verslag. Lundboitwk. Onderzoek., 69 (7) : 164pp. KALLE, K., 1937. Nahrstoffenuntersuchungenals hydrographischesHilfsmittel zur Untersuchungvon Wasserkorpern. Ann. Hydrograph. Maritini. Meteorol., 65 : 1-1 8.
FEATURES IN THE HEADS OF SUBMARINE CANYONS NARRATIVE OF UNDERWATER FILM ROBERT
F.
DILL
U S . Navy Electronics Laboratory, San Diqgo, CaliJ ( U . S . A . )
1NTRODUCTION
Geological observations to study the features present in the heads of submarine canyons have been made during the last five years by geologists wearing SCUBA (Self Contained Underwater Breathing Apparatus) equipment. Under-water shots have been made from which two motion pictures were put together. These films, shown at the sixth International Sedimentological Congress, deal with sedimentation and erosion phenomena in the heads of Scripps canyon near La Jolla (Calif., U.S.A.) and of Los Frailes and San Lucas Canyons on the east side of the southern tip of Baja California (Mexico). The Scripps Canyon is cut in Eocene sedimentary rocks, consisting of fine grained sandstones and shales, while the Mexican canyons are cut in hard granite. Notwithstanding the differences in material in which the canyons are cut, the sedimentation and erosion features show nearly complete similarities. In general, it can be said that these submarine canyons start close to the shore line with many small tributaries, with bowl-shaped heads, leading to the branches of the canyons. Sediment that is trapped in the bowl-shaped heads of the tributaries slumps down intermittently, causingerosion on the bedrock bottom and the sides of the tributaries and branches. Often an hourglass shape is the result of the erosion. The upper part of the tributary or branch has a rough surface with many forms of sessile life, while the wider bottom part has smoothed and polished surfaces with such features like truncated burrows, gouge marks, plucking scars, etc., which give evidence of submarine erosion.
SCRIPPS CANYON. CALIFORNIA, U.S.A.
The first sequence shows a diver inspecting one of the most active tributaries leading into the head of the Sumner Branch of Scripps Submarine Canyon. The depth of the water is 8Oft. (24 m). At the time of the photographs the sediment thickness was 21 ft. (6.4 m). The surface sediments in this area continually slump and creep down-canyon
102
R. F. DILL
at an average rate of 2 ft.jmonth at the surface, and approximately I ft./month at the base of the sediment-mat fill. I n areas of slowly moving sediment, erosional features are observed that can only be caused by submarine processes. Smooth polished rock surfaces, truncated burrows of marine organisms, overhanging walls, gougz marks. and plucking scars are some of the primary features giving evidence to this erosion. The second sequence i n Suniner Branch shows the nature o f the canyon at a depth of 100 ft. (30.5 m). The steep-to-overhanging rock walls arz unique to the submarine canyon and have no counterpart in the land canyons of the region. Beneath the haystack-like algal and sediment f i l l of this portion of the canyon the rock walls expand and have an hourglass profile. The surface of the contact zone between the fill and the rock walls is extremely smooth and polished. Material is continually being deposited in this area throughout the year. However, small slumps and slides arc often observed during storm periods which prevent the sediment slopes from exceeding 33-37', the angle of repose of the sediment f i l l in this area. This fill point is also reflected in the eroded rock walls and marks the boundary between active biological erosion and corrasion by the slowly moving sediment-mat. The third sequence shows the same area one month later. The marker stakes that were put in the sediment-mat a month before have moved and tipped down-slope. The surface J f the sediment-mat has a much higher algal content. Gas is bubbling from the fill and is most active between the rock wall-sediment fill contact and in areas of rzcent slump scars. The gas consists of methane and hydrogen sulfide derived from the breakdown of previously buried Algae and sea grasses. The high mica content in the water is shown by a sequence of photographs taken with an underwater light. The almost complete coverage of exposed rock surface by organisms is shown i n their natural color. The pictures were taken at a depth of 95 ft. (29 m) using high speed Ektachrome film and a 2,500 watt color corrected light. A well developed hanging valley enters Sumner Branch of Scripps Canyon at a depth of 55-73 ft. f17-22 m). Exceptionally well developed corrasional erosion features are found in this tributary that grade upward into an area where erosion is dominantly controlled by marine organisms. Observation over a five-year period has shown that the sediment fill of this area is confined to the areas where corrasion is evident. Marker stakes placed in the f i l l are slowly displaced down-slope by slow gravity creep and intermittent slumps. Sediments which slump rarely travel more than 25 ft. (7.6 m) before they reach a stable slope and compensate the stresses that lead to their instability. The inorganic portion of the sediment in this area is a fine sand with a high mica content. I n sttu porosities are between 50 and 55 7:. Relative densities are quite variable and range betwen 1.6-1.9 g/cm3.
BAJA CALIFORNIA. MEXICO
In this region of Baja California a number of large submarine canyons extend u p to
HEADS OF SUBMARINE CANYONS
103
within a short distance of the shoreline. They are cut in hard granite and, like Scripps
Canyon. have features that can only have been caused by submarine erosion. Three expeditions have been made to this region. The deeper portions of the canyons have ( 1963), and SHEPARD (1964). Their results have been studied by BWMAand SHEPARD been correlated with those of the present writer in the shallow nearshore heads of the canyons where diving techniques could be used to photograph and measure the processes active in depths down to 250 ft. (76 m). Two major areas have been studied in detail: (I) Los Frailes Canyon which lies approximately 45 miles northeast of the tip of Baja California, and (2) Sail Lucas Canyon which cuts into the very tip of Cape San Lucas, Mexico. In both areas, stakes were placed in the sediment. It has been observed, by following expeditions, that they move down-slope, and erosion features form by the corrasion of flowing sediment. A transition zone between organically caused surface roughness to an area of relatively smooth rocks has been found only in areas where flowing sand causes corrasion of the older rough surfaces. Niches or eroded “U-shaped” indentures i n the upper lips of the steep canyon walls are often observed where flowing sand falls into deeper portions of the canyon. Many of these niches develop bzlow hanging valleys which are common in most rock-walled submarine canyons.
RIVERS OF SAND, S A N V FALLS
One of the most spectacular submarine phenomena are the “rivers of sand” and “sand falls” that have bzen observed i n San Lucas Canyon. This process was first observed by the late Conrad Limbaugh. Janies Stuart, and Wheeler North i n 1959 durinp an et al., expedition to this area under the direction of Dr. F. P. Shepard (LIMBAUGH 1961). Similar sand flows. but on a much smaller scale, have been observed in other canyons but none can compare with those found at Cape San Lucas. The upper portion of the tributary, shown i n the motion picture, has a broad bowlshaped head. Sand flows slowly down this area during periods of storm when swell inducd currents cut back the beaches and shallow water fill that accumulates slowly during periods of quiescence. The average slope for the sediment fill when at rest is 30”. However, when flowing at a velocity of between 0.1-0.16 knots the slope will increase to as high as 37”. Sediments at rest can be artificially set in motion by diggin? away a part of the fill. Movement continues until a stable slope (approximately 30”) is again established. Velocity is accelerated around objects interfering with normal flow. ln areas of confinement flow has been observed to meander from one side ofthe channel to another. Streaks of dark sand develop where reduced sediment is brought to the surface by turbulence. Objects such as rocks up t G 6 inches (15 cm) in diameter have been observed to be carried by flowing sand. Divers have followed this type of flowing sand to depths of 250 ft. (76 m) and could at this depth see it continuing 011 into deeper water to a depth of at least 350 ft. (1 10 ni).
104
K. F. DILL
Spectacular sand falls develop where there are sharp drop-offs in the canyon’s axial profile. In these areas, the pulsation of the sand movement is readily apparent. In one of the fault controlled tributaries, fresh granite surfaces are exposed where the force of the falling sand has plucked and gouged weak and broken granite pieces from the face of the rock wall. Such surfaces are truly examples of contemporary submarine erosion.
SUMMARY
This paper deals with creep of sediment and rapid flow of sand over the steeply sloping floor of some submarine canyons off California and Baja California. The sediment motion apparently causes scour of the canyon floor and walls. The phenomena were directly observed and filmed by geologists diving in the upper parts of the canyons.
REFERENCES
BOUMA, A. H. and SHEPARD, F. P., 1963. Large rectangular cores from submarine canyons and sand valleys. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, in press. LIMBAUGH, C., NORTH,W. and STEWARD, J., 1961. Rivers of Sand (Underwater motion-picture report of submarine sand movement). Dept. of Oceanography, Scripps Institution of Oceanography, Univ. of Calif., San Diego, La Jolla, Calif. SHEPARD, F. P., 1964. Sea floor valleys of the Gulf of California. In: Marine Geology of the Gulfof California- Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Spec. Publ., in press.
ANCIENT DELTAIC SEDIMENTATION I N EUGEOSYNCLINAL BELTS’ ROBERT H . DOTT
JR.
University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisc. ( U . S . A . )
INTRODUCTION
Ancient eugeosynclinal belts containing important volumes of volcanic materials are typically regarded as sites of dominantly graded “graywacke” and mudstone deposition. Furthermore, many (if not most) of the sandy sequences are commonly interpreted as having been deposited in relatively deep, quiet marine water by turbidity currents -and doubtless much of it has been. Exceptions to this exist, however, and in significant volumes in most eugeosynclines. The general problem of characterization of geosynclinal sediments has been discussed by KAY(195 1) and VANANDEL(1958). The writer has discussed elsewhere (DOTT, 1961) a few examples of widely varied eugeosynclinal rock types, and several examples are summarized below for illustration. Many others exist, of course. Extensive marine carbonate rocks, including organic reefs, typify the far western North American Permo-Triassic as well as the famous east Alpine Triassic. Even relatively well sorted and pure (i.e., very mature) quartz arenites2 are very important in some areas, for example in the Ordovician of the central Nevada-Idaho eugeosynclinal belt described by KAY(1960), in the Middle Jurassic of central Oregon, and in scattered Mesozoic localities of the Antarctic (Palmer) Peninsula (HALPERN, 1963). Sedimentary environments in eugeosynclines have varied as much as petrographic sediment types. Thick non-marine volcanic and sedimentary sequences occur and are in striking contrast to the more familiar marine ones. A striking example is that of the central Chilean Andes where volcanism was extreme throughout Mesozoic and Cenozoic time. In the earlier Mesozoic, volcanic islands were surrounded by areas of marine deposition (MuRoz CHRISTI,1956). From medial Cretaceous to the present, this region has received enormously thick accumulations of entirely non-marine volcanic and interstratified sedimentary deposits. These possess Late Cretaceous and Tertiary floras and are typified by lavas with colummar jointing, agglomerates, flow breccias, slightly re-worked volcanic conglomerates, tuffs, and tuffaceous sandstones Investigations in Oregon and California are supported in part by funds supplied by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation. Investigations in Chile and Antarctica are supported by the National Science Foundation, Universidad de Chile and Empresa Nacional de Petroleo. Classification of sandstones in this paper employs the terminology of WILLIAM^ et al. (,1954) together with the maturity concepts of FOLK(1951).
106
R. H . DOTT J R .
and shales. This linear volcanic pile lies along the core of the Andean orogenic belt and appears to change along the same axis both north into Peru and south into southern Chile into much less volcanic, marine Cretaceous and Early Tertiary assemblages. Volcanism so exceeded the rate of subsidence in Chile that an unusually large volcanic land was built and persisted above sea level. Yet essential qualities of a eugeosyncline were retained, namely very thick accumulation of volcanic and sedimentary materials in a linear zone. The above examples are cited to indicate that sediment types, depositional mechanisms and environments have all been extremely variable in eugeosynclines. Dorninantly deep marine, shallow marine and even non-marine situations have existed simultaneously in different parts of the same belt and have also succeeded one another within many areas. And successions from deeply submerged to strongly emerged seem to be reversible. This may be influenced by eustatic sea level changes as well as local behavior. In the present paper special attention is devoted to examples of deltaic and littoral sediments in eugeosynclines. Examples discussed are from the Cordillera of the Americas.
OREGON AND CALIFORNIA, U.S.A.
L a t e Cretaceous, Cape Srbastiun urea. Oregon
The Klamath Province of southwestern Oregon and northwestern California contains a familiar type of eugeosynclinal assemblage, namely very immature “graywackes”, mudstone, bedded chert and pillow lavas of Jurassic age. Several intermittent orogenic pulses are recorded therein accompanied by severe faulting, regional metamorphism and emplacement of intermediate, mafic and ultramafic plutons. Very coarse, in part remarkably graded. conglomerates reflect vigorous elevation of irregular land masses i n Late Jurassic and Early Cretaceous. Temporary relative stability was achieved sonietime in the medial Cretaceous, with most of the Cordilleran region above sea level and with a general cessation of volcanism. During Late Cretaceous, local transgression occurred in response to eustatic rise of sea level or epeirogcnic crustal subsidence (or both). In marginal marine regions such as the Cape Sebastian area of the extreme southwestern coast of Oregon, moderately mature littoral sands (feldspathic quartz arenites) and gravels accumulated initially. These possess some medium-scale channeling. cross stratification, ripple niarks and scattered molluscs (Fig. I). They grade u p into a rhythmically alternating sequence of micaceous, less sorted fine sandstone (feldspathic quartz arenite and quartz wacke) and inudstone units. This sequence superficially resembles “turbidites”. but is essentially barren of graded bedding (DOTTand HOWARD. 1962). On the other hand, the thin, fine sandstone units have fine cross laminae throughout their total thickness. Current and load-formed sole markings are common. Mega- and microfossils are rare, but evidence of burrowing activity is abundant.
ANCIENT DELTAIC SEDlMENTATlON I N EUCEOSYNCLINAL BELTS
I07
Fig.1. Relationships of Late Cretaceous strata, Cape Sebastian area, southwestern Oregon, U.S.A. Lower littoral sandstones grade up to top-set deltaic mudstone and sandstone with probable local bar finger sand bodies.
Interstratified within the sandstone-mudstone sequence are many thicker, fine to medium, well sorted sand bodies with conspicuous current structures, chiefly fine cross-laminae, ripple bedding and prominent convolute laminae (Fig. I). However, parallel lamination is also very conspicuous. Grading is totally lacking. Coarse sandstone with larger cross strata and boulder conglomerate lenses characterize some of these masses. Abundant plant debris occurs in scattered laminae that locally are rich enough to be classed as thin, discontinuous coal seams. With exception of a few oyster shell fragments, fauna is totally lacking in these sandstone bodies. The basal sandstone sequence is interpreted as a littoral and near-littoral, very shallow, agitated marine assemblage. The mudstoiie~sandstonesequence is interpreted as representing a shallow (perhaps in part brackish) marine, top-set deltaic environment. Even lamination. abundant tractional current features, impoverished fauna but 1960). The thicker sandstone abundant plant detritus and mica suggest this (SHEPARD, masses within this sequence appear to represent bar finger sands (FISK,1961). They show little scouring at their bases, they are generally concordant, and at the top (and presumably laterally) are gradational with the dominant mudstone and thin, "dirtier" sandstone lithology. Good sorting, abundant fine current lamination. parallel laniination, plant debris, fine mica and lack of fauna also are consistent with this suggestion. Late Eocene, Coos Bql: area, Orqyon
Late Cretaceous stability was short-lived in southwest Oregon, for renewed volcanism, subsidence and transgression produced accumulation of very extensive submarine pillow lavas and Paleocene? to Early and Middle Eocene graded and non-graded
108
R. H. DOTT JR.
“graywackes” (lithic-volcanic wackes) and mudstones. North of the Klamath region, much of the sand was deposited by turbidity currents in relatively quiet, probably deep water (SNAVELY and WAGNER, 1962). General regression began in Late Eocene time, and littoral and deltaic facies shifted progressively northwestward from the Klamath upland. Great delta complexes developed at Coos Bay are characterized by large, prominent lenticular sandstone bodies with complexly channeled basal surfaces and containing angular chunks of contemporaneous, inter-channel laminated mudstones. Contorted stratification developed through gravity mass failures as the channels were cut. Contortion also is present within the channel-fill sands due to both current and gravity deformation of medium and large-scale cross-strata. Convolute lamination is present locally ( D o n and HOWARD, 1962). Current features abound in both topset and channel sediments, but parallel lamination is also very prominent in the very carbonaceous, micaceous and well sorted channel sands. Ripples, grooves, cross-stratification on all scales, contortions, and rolled-up sand balls are characteristic of the entire sequence. Compactional load structures, including sandstone dikes, are well developed as well. Important coal is associated with the higher sandstone bodies. These deposits are interpreted as delta distributary channels with top-set, laminated finer marine interdistributary sequences and, farther landward (south), non-marine inter-channel coal swamp deposits. Bar fingers have not been recognized. A complex delta plain was built of imbricated distributary sands, littoral bars, natural levees and coal swamp deposits that intertongued northward with marine top-set and fore-set deposits. Animal burrow features occur throughout much of the sequence. Foraminifera and some molluscs typify the interdistributary sediments, and sand-beach-dwelTABLE I SUMMARY OF MLNERALOGIC AND TEXTURAL DATA FOR TYPICAL EOCENE SANDSTONES, COOS BAY, OREGON, U.S.A. -
~~
Sample no. ~
~~~
55-1 3 55-14 59-16 59-2 1 59-24 59-25
~~
Qaartz
~~~
Feldspar
~
~
~
Volcanic rock fragments
~~~
Other
MI
r70
-
-
~~~
32“/0 55% 20 Yo 25 % 21 74
28 % 17% 27 % 27% 23
34% 17% 45 % 42 Yo 52%
6% 11% 8%
-
-
-
-
6% 4%
-
0.33m m 0.31 mm 0.12m m 0.36m m
-
1.12 I .03 1.24 1 .oo
_ _
ling molluscs and echinoderms (Dendraster) together with rill structures are found locally in littoral sandstone bodies. Two constructional phases followed by marine destructional phases can be tentatively recognized in the delta complex. Graded bedding is sparingly present in the initial fore-set deposits associated with the lowest channels. Apparently some turbidity current deposition occurred on the fore face and beyond the delta generated by mass failures of sediment as postulated by SHEPARD
ANCIENT DELTAIC SEDIMENTATION IN EUGEOSYNCLINAL BELTS
SUGGESTED
LATE
EOCENE
109
PALEOGEOGRAPHY
Fig.2. Hypothetical paleogeographic map of Oregon and Washington, U.S.A., during Late Eocene Littoral and deltaic environments are shown in relation to land areas and offshore volcanic islands Coos Bay, Oregon is located at the lower left (marked “Coaledo”); Cape Sebastian is farther south near the lower left corner.
(1955) on the Mississippi delta margin. Paleogeographic setting of the Eocene delta complex was rather unique. The Klamath upland with varied rocks lay to the south. Pillow lavas immediately underlie the deltaic sandstones (and may even be partially interstratified with them). Contem-
110
R. H. DOTT J R ,
poraneous volcanic islands existed offshore only 50 miles to the north (Fig.2). The sands of the complex, though mature texturally as to sorting and rounding i n keeping with a deltaic interpretation, are exceptionally immature inineralogically. Most are classed as lithic arenites with a high percentage of volcanic rock fragments (Table I). Associated mudstones contain overwhelming abundance of montmorillonoid minerals, apparently also reflecting an unusually volcanic-rich provenance.
Cretaceous to Holocene, Sacratncnto Vallej7,Culifnniia
During Cretaceous and Early Tertiary time, a long marine embayment occupied much of California. The Klamath highland separated it from the areas of marine deposition i n western Oregon discussed above. According to ANDERSON(1938), a Cretaceous delta-like complex was built at the northwestern end of this embayment and concentrations of sand i n the subsurface suggest at least one other possible deltaic mass on the northeast side. The northwestern example contains important conglomerate 1956) with, in tongues as well as very carbonaceous sandstone and shale (MURPHY, part, shallow marine faunas (ANDERSON, 1938). Transport of much if not most of the clastic sediments away from the postulated northern, coarsely clastic deltaic areas was southward along the Sacramento enibayment chiefly by mass flow and turbidity currents into presumably deeper water (CROWELL, 1957). Though there were marked oscillations of the strand, a gross southward (longitudinal) sedimentary filling and regression has characterized Late Cretaceous to Holocene time. Complex alluvial and deltaic deposits form the valley floor today and modern deltaic sedimentation continues i n northern San Francisco Bay.
SOUTHERN CHILE
At the southern end of the east flank of the Andean orogenic belt a thick sequence of well exposed. rhythmic flysch-like Cretaceous strata pass up into younger molasse-like sandstone and conglomerate with coal seams much like the Coos Bay sequence. Both suites have been likened to the pre-Alpine region (CECIONI, 1957; ZEIL,1958). Graded bedding is common in many repeated units i n the former. Grooves and flutes are common and indicate currents from north to south. Within the sequence are large, discontinuous masses of coarse conglomerate. some remarkably well graded, and a few masses of unsorted pebbly mudstone. Geologists of the Enipresa Nacional de Petroleo have shown (personal comniunication) that regional offlap occurred i n Late Cretaceous and Early Tertiary time along the geosynclinal axis from north to south as well as eastward. This carried the deltaic and littoral sedimentation gradually southward through this time interval, so that it arrived in the present Straits of Magellan area in the Oligocene.
ANCIENT DELTAlC SEDIMENTATION IN EUGEOSYNCLlNAL BELTS
Ill
CONCLUSIONS
Deltaic sediments, far from being oddities in eugeosynclinal belts, are very important i n many areas. Thoiigh they tend to be “young”, that is more or less syn-orogenic or post-orogenic, they can not be so interpreted rigidly i n any supposed “geosynclinal cycle”. Commonly flysch- and molasse-like deposits accumulated siniultaneo~islyi n adjacent areas. Whenever and wherever sufficient stability developed (even if only temporary) and rapid sedimentation prevailed, littoral and deltaic deposits soon formed and at any time in the history of a given region! Chief factors were local relations of rapidity of subsidence and of sediment in-put. Tt is important to note that the net upparent rate of subsidence may be complicated by external eustatic changes quite independent of the prevalent tectonic behaviour within the geosynclinal belt itself. Sediment in-put is in turn complexly related to topography, climate and source rock types, and modifications could be introduced by sediment basin morphology as this might influence current and wavc patterns. But, as deltas reflect abnornially rapid rates of sediment influx, they will apparently develop almost inevitably i n spite of all other circumstances if suficient detritus and run-off are available. It seems axiomatic that there must be many more ancient deltas preserved than have been recognized. Deltaic sediments of eugeosynclinal belts differ from more familiar ones chiefly i n possessing typically immature mineral suites, although those of the modern Mississippi delta are themselves surprisingly immature (VANANDEL.1960). This probably i n part reflects extensive Pleistocene glaciation in the upper Mississippi drainage basin, for sands of the sub-tropical Orinoco delta are slightly more mature mineralogically. The sediments of the ancient examples discussed above all average coarser than i n most large. moderii deltas. This is more a function of local geographic factors; wide variation i n median diameter of materials should be expected from delta to delta. Textural maturity, however, was attained and to essentially the same degree as i n modern ones. The high energy, equilibrium depositional systems characteristic of deltas have operated quite as effectively in eugeosynclinal belts as elsewhere i n spite of overall tectonic instability of such belts. KUENEN (1958) has suggested that geosynclinal filling requires more than just local (internal) island sources. In-put from large river systems draining relatively large parts of continental areas are also required, he feels. Patterns such as those discussed suggest that, at least in younger geologic time, large river systems such as envisioned by Kuenen have contributed a large share of sediments. The southwesterii Oregon Cretaceous and Eocene depositional patterns represent largely lateral “filling” seaward from the rising Cordillera. Patterns like that of the Sacramento Valley, California and southern Chile are virtually identical to that postulated long ago by STAMP (1922) and modified by TAINSH (1950) for the Late Tertiary of Burma. These involved strong longitudinal filling components along the orogenic axes. This pattern of growth or “accretion” along a mobile belt may be a far more important one than has been realized, as Kuenen suggested. On the other hand, such patterns are difficult indeed to discern - and test - in the older geosynclinal strata.
112
R. H. DOTT JR. SUMMARY
Deltaic sediments are more common in eugeosynclinal belts than literature would indicate. They differ from deltaic deposits elsewhere only in a tendency for less mineralogic maturity and slightly coarser detritus. Eocene deltaic sands at Coos Bay, Oregon possess high percentages of volcanic rock fragments, yet they are moderately well sorted and rounded. Associated shales contain chiefly montmorillonite. Deltas have formed, even in these tectonically unstable areas, when and wherever sufficient detritus and fluvial discharge were available so that rate of sedimentation could equal or exceed subsidence. When these conditions are met, deltas appear to form almost inevitably. The deltaic sediments discussed apparently were supplied by major rivers draining rather large land areas. In Oregon the net “filling” pattern was essentially lateral, i.e., seaward (westward) out from the flank of the Cordillera. But in the Cretaceous-Tertiary of northern California and southern Chile, like the Cenozoic of Burma, much of the deltaic “filling” was longitudinal or parallel to the orogenic axis. The latter may be a common pattern of geosynclinal “growth”, but its quantitative importance through geologic time is difficult to assesss.
REFERENCES
ANDERSON, F. M., 1938. Lower Cretaceous deposits in California and Oregon. Geol. SOC.Am., Spec. Papers, 16 : 339 pp. CECIONI, G., 1957. Cretaceous flysch and molasse in Departamento Ultima Esperanza, Magallanes Province, Chile. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 41 : 538-564. CROWELL, J. C., 1957. Origin of pebbly mudstone. &ill. Geol. SOC.Am., 68 : 993-1010. DOTTJR., R. H., 1961. Permo-Triassic diastrophism in the western Cordilleran region. Am. J. Sci., 259 : 561-582. D o n JR., R. H. and HOWARD,J. K., 1962. Convolute lamination in non-gradedsequences. J. Geol., 70 : 114-121. FISK,H. N., 1961. Bar-finger sands of Mississippi delta. In: J. A. PETERSON and J. C. OSMOND (Editors), Geometry of Sandstone Bodies. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 29-52. FOLK, R., 1951. Stages of textural maturity in sedimentary rocks. J. Sed. Petrol., 21 : 127-130. HALPERN, M., 1963. Cretaceous Sedimentation in Base O’Higgins Area of the Northwest Antarctic Peninsula. Ph. D. thesis, Univ. of Wisconsin, 97pp, (unpubl.). KAY,M., 1951. North American geosynclines. Geol. SOC.Am. Mem., 48 : 143 pp. KAY,M., 1960. Paleozoic continental margin in central Nevada, western United States. Intern. Geol. Cony-.,21st Copenhqen, 1960, Rept. Session, Norden, 12 : 94-103. KUENEN, PH. H., 1958. Problems concerning source and transportation of flysch sediments. Geol. Mijnhouw, 20 : 324-339. MuRoz CHRISTI,J., 1956. Chile. In: W. F. JENKS(Editor), HandOook of South American Geology - Geol. SOC.Am., Metn., 65 : 187-214. MURPHY, M. A,, 1956. Lower Cretaceous stratigraphic units of northern California. Bull. A m . Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 40 : 2098-21 19. SHEPARD. F. P.,1955. Delta-front valleys bordering Mississippi distributaries. Bull. Geol. SOC.Atn., 66 1489-1498. SHEPARD,F. P., 1960. Mississippi delta: marginal environments, sediments and growth. In: F. P. SHEPARD,F. B PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Gulf of Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 5 6 8 1 .
ANCIENT DELTAIC SEDIMENTATION IN EUGEOSYNCLLNAL BELTS
113
SNAVELY JR., P. D. and WAGNER, H. C., 1962. Tertiary geologic history of western Oregon and Washington (abstract). Progr. Ann. Meeting Ani. Assoc. Petrol. Geolqists, Sun Francisco, 1962 : 55. STAMP,L. D., 1922. An outline of the Tertiary geology of Burma. Geol. Mag., 59 : 481-501. TAINSH,H. R., 1950. Tertiary geology and principal oil fields of Buima. Bull. An]. Assoc. Petrol. Ceologisrs, 34 : 823-855. VANANDEL,TJ. H., 1958. Origin and classification of Cretaceous, Paleocene and Eocene sandstones of western Venezuela. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 42 : 7 3 6 7 6 3 . VANANDEL,TJ. H., 1960. Sources and dispersion of Holocene sediments, northern Gulf of Mexico. In: F. P. SHEPARD, F. B. PHLEGER and TJ. H. VAN ANDEL(Editors), Recent Sediments, Northwest Giiyof Mexico. Am. Assoc. Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, pp. 34-55. WILLIAMS, H., TURNER,F. J. and GILBERT,C. M., 1954. Petrography. Freeman, San Francisco, 406 pp. ZEIL,W., 1958. Sedimentation in der Magallanes-Geosynklinale mit besonderer Berucksichtigung des Flysches. Geol. Rimdscharr, 4 1 :4 2 5 4 3 .
TREND SURFACE ANALYSIS OF SEDIMENTARY FEATURES OF THE MODIOLARIS ZONE, EAST PENNINE COALFIELD, ENGLAND P.
M C L .D .
DUFF
and E . K .
WALTON
Grant Institiite of Geology, University of Edinburgh, Edinbuyh (Great Britain)
INTRODUCTION
In a previous paper we showed the results of a statistical study of the Coal Measure sediments of the East Pennine Coalfield (DUFFand WALTON,1962). The work was limited to the development of cycles of sedimentation, to their definition and significance in the area as a whole. In this paper we continue with the quantitative study of the sediments and are concerned with the areal variation and inter-relationships of czrtain characters or‘ the sediments. The variation is expressed in terms of partial trend surfaces (KRUMBEIN, 1959), and some attempt is made to assess the amount of data required to provide reliable estimates of the variation within the area. The investigation is restricted to the Modiolaris Zone (Lower Westphalian) because of our present lack of detailed information from the remaining part of the succession and because this is in the nature of a pilot study in the use of these techniques.
TREND SURFACE ANALYSIS
The areal variation of a sedinientary feature can be expressed in terms of a polynomial function based on the geographic co-ordinates ( U , V ) of the observation stations (GRANT,1957; KRUMBEIN, 1959; see also DAWSON and WHITTEN, 1962, for a useful summary of the basic principles). The complete trend of GRANT(1957) is the surface of “best fit” to a set of map data, and usually involves polynomial terms of high order. KRUMBEIN (1 959) and WHITTEN (1959) showed that partial trend surfaces containing linear, or linear plus quadratic‘ or linear plus quadratic plus cubic’ terms often demonstrated significant regional geological changes while the deviations (differences between the computed and the observed values) although including some local “noise” (due to faulty observation etc.) could also show important small-scale local geological effects. ALLENand KRUMBEIN [ 1962) have discussed this last point with regard to the mineralogical content of the Top Ashdown Pebble Bed. Subsequently referred to as quadratic and cubic surfaces.
TREND SURFACE ANALYSIS
:.-
- EAST
115
PENNINE COALRELD
U
.
Fig.]. The East Pennine Coalfield (exposed portion outlined) showing the main anticlines (based on EDWARDS, 1951, fig.39). Dashed lines are isopachs (in feet) of Modioluris Zone based on 129 localities (dots). Inset: Location of East Pennine Coalfield. (Structural features based on WILCOCKSEN, 1947 and EDWARDS, 1951.)
116
P. McL. D. DUFF AND E. K. WALTON
.............
. ..
,_.,
mL
..., .I.._
'.: s,
'..'._
a
U I
I
I
I
Fig.2. Partial trend surfaces and deviations. a. Pr. I: Thickness in feet: linear. b. Pr. I : Thickness in feet: linear plus quadratic. c. Pr. 11: Thickness in feet: linear. d. Pr. 11: Thickness in feet: linear plus quadratic. Zero deviation lines indicated with hatching open to negative areas. Localities for Pr. I1 indicated by dots in c. L = Leeds; D = Doncaster; S = Sheffield;W = Worksop; N = Nottingham. National Grid (10 km squares) indicated on margins. Full Grid Reference for the southwest comer of all maps is SK 400 300.
TRENDSURFACE ANALYSIS - EAST PENNINE COALFIELD
117
In this study the thickness of the Modiolaris Zone was obtained from 124 localities. Further information on number of cycles and sandstone thickness was available only from 29 of these localities. Two projects (Pr.) were therefore devised and the trend surfaces computed using the programme set up by Drs. W. C. Krumbein and C. Faulkner for the IBM 650 (London IBM Library Number 60704). In the first (Pr. I), partial trend surfaces for the thickness of the zone were obtained from the 124 localities. In the second jPr. 11) partial trend surfaces for the thickness were re-computed for comparative pusposes using only those 29 points for which additional information was available. The surfaces for other variables (sandstone thickness and number of cycles) were also computed on the basis of the 29 control points. Throughout the study the geographic coordinates were based on the National Grid.
THICKNESS
An isopacli map showing the thickness of the Modiolaris Zone represents the raw, untreated, data for this variable (Fig. I). The niap shows a simple decrease in thickness to the east i n conformity with the well known general thinning of the Coal Measures in that direction, together with some local variations. Our isopach map differs from that of ~ D W A R D S(1951, fig. 10) because of new borehole information and consequent improved correlation. As might be expected the partial trend surfaces reflect the easterly thinning. The linear surface (Fig.2a) strikes just east of north and accounts tor a large part of the variation in thickness (63.8 % of the sums of squares). The quadratic surface represents a better fit to the data (78.0% sums of squares) but the cubic surface (78.0% s.s.) is little better than the quadratic. Both quadratic and cubic surfaces have contours ruaning generally north-south but bulging convexly towards the east. These general trends are very reminiscent of those suggestcd by WILLS(1956. fig.3) i n his g?neral reconstruction of conditions i n Cornniunis and Modiolaris times (Wills’ Palstage 1 b). 1 he deviation maps (based on the differences between observed and computed values of thickness) for both the linear and the quadratic surfaces are broadly similar (Fig.2a. b). Areas of negative deviations (representing a deficiency of thickness conlpared with the general variation as indicated by the surfaces) occur to the north of Nottingham, east of Worksop and in a belt north of Doncaster. The partial trend surfaces (Pr. TI) deriked from the 29 localities (Fig.2c, d) are strikingly similar to those in Pr. I. The proportions of the sunis of squares accounted for by the surfaces are again significantly high (linear, 60.6%; quadratic, 78.5 %; cubic 79.4%) though again the cubic contribution is small. Compared with the surfaces in Pr. I the general decrease in thickness to the east is again evident and the quadratic and cubic surfaces are convex towards the east; the linear surface dips slightly more south of east. In deducing the general variation, if the 29 points rather than the 124 points had been used the error involved would be very small. The maximum error would occur in the southeast where there is a difference in the computed values of
118
P. M c L . D. DUFF AND E.
................... ............. .. ...'.L 'j
K. WALTON
I
'..
..... . .. . . . .... ...
.......
... .. ..__
I ...
;240L*/
2 0 ; 0
20
140
26 0
Sandstone thickness
'..
.:.. . .... .... .. ..._. ............
f
.1
i
40
p
400
900
Total
30
....'..
thlckners
....
w
u U 7-
U
C
d
9 00
400
Totol
thickness
Fig.3. Partial trend surfaces and deviations (ornament as in Fig.2). a. Pr. 11: No. of cycles: linear plus quadratic. b. Pr. 11: Sandstone thickness in feet: linear. c. Pr. 11: Sandstone thickness in feet: linear plus quadratic. d. Co-variation of sedimentary characters.
TREND SURFACE ANALYSIS - EAST PENNINE COALFIELD
119
50 ft. in 600 ft., an error of about 8 %. In the quadratic and cubic surfaces the discrep ancies between the two sets of results are never more than 4 %. It is clear that for most purposes the variation in thickness could have been determined using the smaller number of localities. A maximum error of 8 % would be involved in the use of the linear surface within the area but this would be confined to a small southerly portion. Any extrapolation eastwards on the basis of the 29 points would involve rather greater errors. The deviation maps (Fig.2c, d) differ rather markedly from those in Pr. I, but it is noteworthy that while the general form of the maps may not coincide, the negative areas north of Nottingham, in the Worksop area and north of Doncaster still persist.
NUMBER OF CYCLES
The figures used in this section are based on the number of seat-earths present, as described in our earlier work (DUFFand WALTON, 1962). The linear surface (not illustrated) is the same as that calculated for thickness in so far as the “18 cycles” contour coincides with the 600 ft. contour, the 21 with the 700 ft., etc. This is partly a reflection of the high degree of positive correlation ( r = 0.74) between the two variables as indicated in the scatter diagram (Fig.3a) though the precise co-incidence of the two surfaces is a chance feature. In any event the linear surface is a poor representation of the variability, accounting for only 29.9% of the sums of squares. The quadratic surface (Fig.3a) which accounts for 56.9% of the sums of squares is also similar to the surfaces of thickness but in the deviation maps the negative areas are somewhat displaced.
+
SANDSTONE THICKNESS
The partial trend surfaces for the thickness of sandstone show a decrease towards the southeast, the linear contours striking northeasterly (Fig.3b). The quadratic contours (Fig.3~)show a convexity towards the east only in the west of the area; in the southeast the direction of convexity is reversed. In both cases the proportion of the sums of squares accounted for by the surfaces is low [linear, 37.7%; quadratic, 42.7%), pointing to the greater variability of this parameter compared with the total thickness. This may be due in part to the fact that the proportion of sandstone in beds where it is interbanded with siltstone and/or mudstone was difficult to estimate from generalised written or graphic borehole logs. Local anomalies could also be caused by the development of thick masses of sandstone in restricted channels. Nevertheless, analysis of variance shows that while the cubic and quadratic components are weak the linear partial trend surface has a confidence level above 99 %. There is a positive correlation (r = 0.5) between sandstone thickness and total thickness of the zone (Fig.3d). Negative deviations occur near Nottingham, Worksop and Doncaster, as before,
+
120
P. McL. D. DUFF AND E. K . WALTON
but their shape and size are slightly different from those associated with the other surface (Fig.3b, c).
DlSCUSSlON
The thickness of a sedimentary succession is a function of regional subsidence and compactional effects. In so far as the compactional effects are dependent on the nature of the previously deposited sediments, in the Coal Measures they presumably reflect the distributary pattern of deltas or sub-deltas. The subsidence due to epeirogenic movements could be regional and the partial trend surfaces may, in the first instance, be taken to rcpreseiit these regional effects. On the other hand local diastrophic riiovements cannot be overlooked (e.g.. in the Scottish Carboniferous, GOODLET, 1957) and it is instructive to compare the deviation maps with the tectonic structures of an area in an attempt to determine how far local contemporary movements may have been important. When this is done (Fig.1, 2, 3) there seems to be little coincidence and this suggests that as far as pre-Permian structures are concerned local structural control during Modioluris times seems to have been very small. This is in contrast to WILCOCKSON’S (1947) conclusions rzgarding the sediments of the Sirnilis-PulcAru Zones, higher in the succession. But it is highly significant that Wilcockson himself suggested that the close relation between tectonic structures and thickness became less i n the lower part of his succession and that “ . . .the tectonic features were gradually coming into existenc: during Coal Measure times; early i n the period differential movements had hardly appeared”. Tf this is the case then the deviation maps may simply indicate local variations i n the sedimentary pattern. Over a period of time the positive deviations could indicate the more persistent paths of distributaries. Elongate maxima wo~ildindicate superposition of channels; point maxima would indicate the locus of intersection of “changing” distributary courses. Considering the generally assumed deltaic nature of the sedimentation it is likely that chance point maxima may be more usual than elongate maxima. The areas of positive deviation south of Nottingham, north of Worksop may be areas of heavier sand accumulation which was lacking in the areas of negative deviations. It is perhaps significant that though not coinciding precisely the deviation map of the sandstone thickness is similar to that of total thickness. More accurate data than presently available would be needed to establish these conjectures. The similarity between the partial trend surfaces of the number of cycles and the thickness and the high positive correlation of the two variables is an interesting 1950: WELLER, feature which has been commented on in similar successions (WANLESS, 1956; READ,1961). It is possible for the relative rates of sedimentation and subsidence to be such that the top of the sediments never reaches closely enough to water level to allow the establishment of a swamp. Under other conditions, and these must have obtained during Coal Measure times in the East Pennine area, sedimentation may be rapid enough to overtake subsidence and allow the establishment of a swamp.
TREND SURFACE ANALYSIS
- EAST PENNINE COALFIELD
121
Vegetation persists until regional subsidence overtakes peat accumulation and ininiersion occurs. The return of sediments brought about by distributary changes (MOORE, 1959) causes the basin to fill up again to sea level. The intercalation of cycles in regions of thicker sedimentation reflects then a critical balance between rates of subsidence and sedimentation. The general variation in sandstone thickness again illustrates the regional control of sand distribution. The degree of correlation between the sandstone thickness and the number of cycles is low (r = 0.3; Fig.3d) and not significant at conventional levels. This can be seen as the interaction of two opposing tendencies, as follows. Distribution of sandstone, like number of cycles, is controlled by regional subsidence and a high degree of positive correlation might be expected between the two variables. But this is offset by the fact that the sand distribution is controlled very closely by the distributary pattern and in the vicinity of the channel itself, so long as that channel persists the development of a number of cycles (which may be forming elsewhere on the delta) is prevented. This, together with the occurrelice of sandstone masses in washouts which may have destroyed one or more cycles, would lead to a negative correlation between the two characters. A preliminary study of this type can only hint at the ultimate usefulness of the technique of trend surface analysis. Although much remains t o be learned about the method, and especially about the geological meaning of the deviations, the results of the two computations of the partial trend surfaces of thickness give a striking illustration that the general variation in sedimentary characters may be obtained from very restricted data.
+
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
W e are indebted to the Chief Geologist, National Coal Board for access to the information on which this paper is based, and are particularly grateful to Messrs. R. E. Elliot and R. F. Goossens for providing that information and for their invaluable assistance i n problems of correlation. One of us (E.K.W.) was fortunate to have the opportunity of visiting Northwestern University and of being introduced to the technique of trend-surface analysis by Drs. W. C. Krunibein and E. H. T. Whitten. To them he would like to express his grateful thanks for their generous help. Dr. W. C. Krumbein also kindly read and criticised the manuscript. The cost of using an TBM Computer was met by a grant from the Carnegie Trust forAhe Universities of Scotland, which we gratefully acknowledge.
SUMMARY
The areal variation of the thickness of the sediments of the Motliolaris Zone of the
122
P. McL. D. DUFF AND E. K. WALTON
East Pennine Coalfield can be shown by trend surface analysis using relatively few control points. Partial trend surfaces of the number of cycles and the sandstone thickness are similar to those of the total thickness of the sediments and reflect the overall control of regional subsidence. Deviation m a p of thickness suggest no control, at the time of sedimentation, by local tectonic features. A high degree of positive correlation between total thickness and number of cycles is taken to indicate critical relations between rates of subsidence and sedimentation.
REFERENCES
ALLEN,P. and KRUMBEIN, W. C., 1962. Secondary trend components in the top Ashdown Pebble Bed: A case history. J. Geol., 70 : 507-538. K. R. and WHITTEN,E. H. T., 1962. The quantitative mineralogical composition and variaDAWSON, tion of the Lacorne, La Motte, and Preissac Granitic Complex, Quebec, Canada. J . Petrol., 3 : 1-37. DUFF,P. McL. D. and WALTON,E. K., 1962. Statistical basis for cyclothems: a quantitative study of the sedimentary succession in the East Pennine Coalfield. Sedimentology, 1 (4) 235-256. EDWARDS,W., 1951. The Concealed Coalfield of Yorkshire and Nottinghamshire. Geol. Surv. G I . Brit. Mem., 3rd Edn., 285 pp. GOODLET, G. A., 1957. Lithological variation in the Lower Limestone Group of the Midland Valley of Scotland. Bull. Geol. Sirrv. G I .Brit., 12 : 52-65. GRANT,F., 1957. A problem in the analysis of geo-physical data. Geophysics, 22 : 309-344. KRUMBEIN, W. C., 1959. Trend surface analysis of contour-type maps with irregular controlpoint spacing. J. Geophys. Res., 64 : 823-824. MOORE,D., 1959. Role of deltas in the formation of some British Lower Carboniferous cyclothems. J . Geol., 67 : 522-539. READ,W. A., 1961. Aberrant cyclic sedimentation in the Limestone Coal Group of the Stirling Coalfield. Trans. Eclinbirrgh Geol. SOC.,18 : 271-292. WANLESS, H. R., 1950. Late Palaeozoic cycles of sedimentation in the United States. Repts. 18th Intern. Geol. Congr., London, 4 : 17-28. WELLER,J. M., 1956. Argument for diastrophic control of late Palaeozoic cyclothems. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 40 : 17-50. WHI-ITEN,E. H. T., 1959. Composition trends in a granite: modal variation and ghost stratigraphy in part of the Donegal granite, Eire. J. Geophys. Res., 64 : 835-848. WILCOCKSON, W. H., 1947. Some variations in the Coal Measures of Yorks. Proc. Yorkshire Geol. SOC.,27 : 58-81. WILLS,L. J., 1956. Concealed Coalfields. Blackie, London, 208 pp.
THICKNESS VARIATIONS O F THE SANDY ALMERE DEPOSITS (HOLOCENE) I N THE FORMER ZUIDERZEE AREA (THE NETHERLANDS) P . J . ENTE
AcqriculturalResearch Department, Zuiderzee Polders Developnient Authority, Kampen (The Netherlands)
GEOLOGICAL OUTLINE
An extensive description of the Holocene development of the former Zuiderzee area has been given by PONSand WIGGERS(1959, 1960); see also WIGGERS(1955) and, (1947). MULLER and VANRAADSHOVEN Factors that have greatly influenced this development are: the surface relief of the Pleistocene, the relative rise of sea level and the alternation of periods of transgression and regression. The top of the Pleistocene forms a plain which slopes towards the west. In the centre of the area it is found at a depth of roughly 10 m below mean sea level. The plain is mainly formed by eolian “cover sands”. It has a relief caused by a braided-river system. At the transition from the Pleistocene to the Holocene dunes were formed along the channels of this system, the sand being derived from the streambeds. During the Atlantic substage of the Holocene era, the sea level rose from 17 m to 5 or 6 m below its present position. This hampered drainage and promoted the formation of peat (“Lower Peat”) along the eastern border of the sea. The marine (littoral) sediments of this age are known as “Deposits of Calais”. In the Atlantic the area of their deposition extended into the peat zone as far as the centre of the former Zuiderzee. Here the “Deposits of Calais” are called “Unio Clay”. Deposition continued into the Subboreal. The Unio Clay was deposited in a fresh to brackish environment with some tidal influence, the latter being responsible for a differentiation into levees and backswamps. After the deposition of the Unio Clay had ceased the levees and backswamps became covered with peat, which did not prevent some of the gullies remaining open. In these gullies and in streams in the peat landscape the “old detritus-gyttja” was formed, a sediment, partly composed of the remains of water flora and fauna and partly of detritus from the adjacent peat. Around 1650 B.C. the sea invaded the area again, causing considerable erosion. Deposition was mainly limited to the former drainage channels. Here, the “Cardium Clay” was formed. The latter represents the “Deposits of Duinkerken” of the western part of The Netherlands.
124
P. J. ENTE
Since the end of this transgression (before 1250 B.C.) a large part of the area remained open water, having a small connection in northerly direction with the sea. l n the lakes “young detritus-gyttja” was formed. After the beginning of the Christian era, the forementioned connection was enlarged and the Alinere beds were deposited. Much of the remaining peat was eroded and the older Almere deposits consist for a great part of the resulting detritus (“peat detritus” facies). Lateron more silty and sandy material was supplied from the north (sandy facies). The end of the Almere sedimentation may be put at about 1550 A.D. To complete the given outline it can be mentioned that since 1550 A.D. the Zuiderzee deposits were formed, in an environment with increased salinity. This ended in 1932 when the dam, separating the Zuiderzee from the North Sea, was closed. In the closed-off basin, now called IJsselmeer, local erosion and re-deposition caused the formation of the IJsselmeer deposits.
SEDIMENTATION AS RELATED TO DIFFERENTIAL COMPACTION OF THE SUBSTRATUM
The sandy facies of the Almere deposits shows, in many places, strong thickness variations over short distances. The examples of this phenomenon discussed in the present paper are situated in the northwestern part of the Eastern Flevoland polder. The upper side of these sandy Almere beds is very even and almost level. It slopes very gently (1 m in 5 km) towards the north, and is found at a depth of about 4.50 m below mean sea level. It is covered by about 40 cm of IJsselnieer and Zuiderzee deposits. In striking contrast to the evenness of the upper side, the lower side is strongly undulated. Consequently the thickness of the sandy facies varies greatly, that is, from a few decimetres to a few metres. The primary causes of this strong relief of the base of the Alinere deposits are the following two factors. The first one consists in the presence of numerous river bank dunes, rising to appreciable heights above the normal Pleistocene surface (Fig. I). The tops of many of these dunes almost reach to the upper side of the sandy facies.
-
q -
/
=
river bonkdunes
U”l0 cloy
Fig 1 . Distribution of Pleistocene liver bank dunes and Holocene Unio Clay (“Deposits of Calais”) within 1.5 rn below the surface of the Eastern Flevoland polder.
125
THICKNESS VARIATIONS OF DEPOSITS I N THE ZUIDERZEE AREA
Pleistocene
-
erOIl0”
rn below mean
wrfoce
Fi g2 Schematic geological profile from the northwesternpart of Eastern Flevoland.
The second factor is the relief of the top of the Unio Clay, due to its former gullies, levees and backswamps (Fig.2). At present in many places, the levee deposits attain almost the same level as the upper side of the Almere deposits, whereas the surface of the backswamp deposits lies 2 4 m lower. The former bottom of small gullies lies 1 or 2 m and the former bottom of large gullies several metres below the top of the levee deposits. Where they are well developed, the levees consist to a considerable depth of rather compact clay, whereas the clay of the backswamps (and of the small gullies) is soft. This can be demonstrated by the figures of the apparent specific gravity of both (Table Ia, b). It should be noted that the compactness of the levee deposits dates from the time of their formation. It can be explained by the higher position and consequently the better drainage during sedimentation, together with the evaporation of moisture from the soil, due to the climate and the vegetation at that time. As a result of this inherited compactness of the levee deposits the possible compaction of later date is negligible. However, the backswamp clays, the peat layer overlying the former backswamps and the filling material of the former gullies may have been compacted after their deposition. For, although for the backswamps the figures of the apparent specific gravity are already rather low, they were probably even lower at the time of deposition (see Table Ib, estimated original values). The “estimated original values” are based upon the relation A = 20 n ( L b H ) (cf. SMITS,1953; ZONNEVELD, 1960) and on the variation with depth of the factor n in this formula, according to R. J. de Glopper (personal communication, 1963). In this formula A stands for the water content of 100 g
+
+
126
P. J . ENTE
TABLE I SOIL ANALYSES D A T A ~~
~
~~
-~~
Esrini. w ( y . app. spec.
%
Orp. matter ”/,
Present app. spec. gravity
100-200 200-300 30&400 400-500 500-600
45 50 46 50 49
4 3 4 7 18
0.86 0.83 0.76 0.65 0.54
-
b. Backswamp Unio Clay
3O(k400 400-500 5 w 6 0 0
44 47 49
20 8 12
0.42 0.65 0.58
0.36 0.46 0.42
c. Old detritus-
45G500 5m600 6W700 700-800 800-850
29 24 27 22 21
33 33 36 38 42
0.31 0.36 0.32 0.32 0.31
0.24 0.25 0.23 0.24 0.23
Depth’
a. Levee Unio Clay
~
I
~~
~
~
~~~~
Clay
~~~
~~
graviiy
-
~
In centirnetres below the surface of the polder.
of dry sediment, L for the percentage of clay (particles < 2 p), H for the percentage of organic matter and h for the ratio between water-absorbing capacity of organic matter and of clay. The differences between the figures for the present apparent specific gravity and those inferred for the original situation correspond in this case to a compaction of more than one metre since the time the backswamp deposits were formed. The peat likewise shows low figures for the apparent specific gravity. Also here compaction is plausible, when these figures (0.214.27) are compared with those of non-compressed peat of other areas (0.09-0.13). The compaction may amount to the same value as the thickness of the layer. The “peat detritus” facies of the Almere deposits shows no difference in apparent specific gravity between samples from above the crzsts of the former levees and from above the former backswamps. Furthermore, the figures of samples from an area, where no sandy facies is present, are of the same magnitude. This means that the great differences in depth, of 2 m or more, at which the top of this layer is found, cannot be explained by compaction of the layer itself, but at best by compaction of the substratum. In the former gullies the figures for the apparent specific gravity of the old detritusgyttja are low (Table Ic). By comparing them with the estimated original values, it follows that the compaction, since the time of the deposition, may have been about 1.7 m. The “peat detritus” facies of the Almere deposits above the former gullies shows somewhat higher figures for the apparent specific gravity (0.67) than elsewhere in this area (0.57-0.60).
THICKNESS VARIATIONS OF DEPOSITS IN THE ZUIDERZEE AREA
127
Fig.3. Profile showing the different inclinations of the laminae of the sandy facies of the Almere deposits.
From the figures given for the estimated compaction of the beds underlying this “peat detritus” facies it appears possible that originally this formation had an almost horizontal position.
128
P. J. ENTE
In this connection it may be remarked that the lower and upper boundaries of the “peat detritus” facies are undoubtedly time boundaries. In the case of the lower side of the beds this is proven by the presence of a thin layer of sand, eroded from the top of a Pleistocene dune (Fig.2, right side). As for the upper boundary, it follows from the lithology of the Almere deposits themselves. If the “peat detritus” facies would be at least partly synchronous with the sandy facies, this would imply the very improbable situation of sedimentation of sand on the lower spots and of peat detritus and clayey material on the higher spots of the lake bottom of that time. In the foregoing it is made clear that the sedimentation of the sandy facies began on an almost level lake bottom, consisting of the “peat detritus” facies. Where sufficient sand was laid down, its load could cause an increased compaction of the underlying beds, thus leading to subsidence of the lake bottom. A depression was formed in which more sand was deposited, and so on. It follows that the horizontal variations in the amount of sand deposited in the lake, depended on the different degrees to which the substratum could be compacted. A last argument to prove this is found in the sandy facies itself. It contains a fine lamination with bands of peat detritus. At those places where the sandy facies becomes thicker, that is in the direction of a former backswamp or a former gully of the Unio Clay, these bands are seen to diverge at intermediate angles between the upper and lower boundaries of the sand (Fig.3). Accepting the idea of the originally horizontal position of each lamina at the time of its formation, the present inclinations of the deeper laminae imply compaction of the substratum during sedimentation of the sand.
SUMMARY
The thickness variations of the sandy facies of the Almere deposits are attributed to differential compaction (during their sedimentation) of the older, underlying beds. The amount of cornpaction is computed on the base of apparent densities, as measured today and inferred for the past. It is probable that the bases of both the lower and the upper division of the Almere deposits are time boundaries, which originally had subhorizontal positions.
REFERENCES
MULLER, J. en VANRAADSHOVEN, B., 1941. Het Holoceen in de Noordoostpolder. Tijdschr. Koninkl. Ned. Aardrijkskundig Cenoot., 64 : 153-185. PONS,L. J. en WIGGERS, A. J., 1959-1960. De Holocene wordingsgeschiedenis van Noord-Holland en het Zuiderzeegebied. Tijdschr. Koninkl. Ned. Aardrijkskirndig Genoot., 16 : 104-152, I1 : 3-51. SMITS,H., 1953. Over de Inklinkiq van Oostelijk Flevoland. Directie Wieringermeer, Kampen, 56 pp. WIGGERS, A. J., 1955. De Wording van het Noordoostpoldergebied. Thesis, Univ. of Amsterdam. Tjeenk Willink, Zwolle, 216 pp. I. S., 1960. De Brabantse Biesbosch. A study of Soil and Vegetation of a Freshwater Tidal ZONNEVELD, Delta. Thesis, Landbouw Hogeschool, Wageningen, 210 pp.
A RECONNAISSANCE SURVEY OF THE ENVIRONMENT OF RECENT CARBONATE SEDIMENTATION ALONG THE TRUCIAL COAST, PERSIAN GULF G . E V A N S , D. J. J. K I N S M A N ~ ~ ~ J . DS .H E A R M A N
Imperial College, London (Creut Brituin)
INTRODUCTION
The Persian Gulf is a relatively shallow sea being rarely deeper than 50 fathoms' (90 m). Communication with the Indian Ocean is through the Strait of Hormuz, which although narrow is not restricted by a submarine sill, as occurs for example at the southern end of the Red Sea. The deepest water lies, in fact, at its entrance. The Gulf is asymmetric in cross section with the deeper water axis lying close against the Persian shore, inland of which rise the Zagros Mountains. Along the southern or Arabian half of the Gulf the water is nowhere deeper than 20 fathoms (Fig. 1). EMERY ( I 956) made a description of the sediments and waters of the area, based on records and samples obtained by Royal Naval and United States Survey vessels. He showed that the area is one of carbonate sedimentation with appreciable amounts of terrigenous detritus occurring only around the Tigris-Euphrates delta at the head of the Gulf and along the Persian shore. HOUBOLT (1958) made a detailed study of the offshore sediments to the north and east of the Qatar Peninsula. The shallow water sediments were found to be essentially skeletal calcarenites and these pass laterally into calcilutites and marls towards the deeper water axis. The coastal lagoons of Qatar were investigated by BRAMKAMP and POWERS(1955) where they reported a series of carbonate and evaporitic sediments to be accumulating. SUCDEN(1963) studied the Recent sediments of the shallow Gulf of Salwa (to the west of the Qatar Peninsula) where he found a widespread development of aragonite muds, ooliths and pseudo-ooliths. He also made a regional survey of the variation in salinity, with particular reference to the remarkably high values occurring in the Gulf of Salwa and along the Trucial Coast, where salinities as much as 60 % above that of normal ocean water occur. He concluded that these high salinities had little effect on the diversity and abundance of the marine fauna. Recently, WELLSand his co-workers (1962) made the interesting discovery of the formation of Recent dolomite in the sediments of the higher parts of the tidal flats around the Qatar Peninsula and CURTISet al. (1963) All depths are expressed in fathoms below Admiralty Chart Datum (approximately Low Water Spring Tides).
130
G. EVANS, D. J . J . KINSMAN AND D. J . SHEARMAN
PERSIAN
GULF
/
TRUCIAL
COAST
Fig.1. Inset map of Persian Gulf showing broad bathymetry and asymmetric character in cross section. Map of Trucial Coast showing nearshore bathymetryand distribution of islands and ernbayments.
showed that both dolomite and anhydrite occur in the sediments of the Sabkha near Abu Dhabi. WELLSand ILLING(1963) have reported most interesting observations on the instantaneous precipitation ofcalcium carbonate in the waters of the southern Gulf. It was against the background of the work by Emery, Houbolt and Bramkamp and Powers, that the Departments of Geology, and Geophysics of the Imperial College of Science and Technology, London, initiated in 1961 a programme of research on the Recent sediments along the Trucial Coast. The nearshore zone above 5 fathoms (9 m) was found to be an area of carbonate sedimentation in which skeletal calcarenites, oolite sands and aragonite muds are being deposited, together with biohermal accumulations and accessory contributions from windblown materials. An evaporitic facies occurs immediately inland. The purpose of this paper is to describe the physiographic setting in which these various sediments occur, in the region between Ras Ghanadha in the northeast and Jabal Dhanna in the west, with more detailed reference to the area around Halat el Bahrani. The sediments of the latter area are described in the accompanying paper by KINSMAN (1963).
PHYSIOGRAPHY
The region consists of a broad coastal strip, up to 15 miles wide, of islands and penin-
ENVIRONMENT OF RECENT CARBONATE SEDIMENTATION IN THE PERSIAN GULF
131
sulas which enclose a series of large, shallow tidal embayments. In the west, the islands are joined by sandy shoals and are separated from the mainland by a long lagoon, Khor a1 Bazm, which is not completely closed at its eastern end (Fig.1). Apart from a few small channels which cut across this offshore barrier the main ebb tide drainage is westwards. In the east, however, the offshore islands are separated from each other by deep ebb channels which drain the large shallow embayments behind them (Fig. 1, 2, 3). Initially the small ebb channels have a dendritic pattern but these coalesce to form one or more major channels which then drain between the islands and across broad sub-aqueous deltas before reaching the open sea. The long profiles of the ebb channels are of particular interest. The channels deepen as they approach the gap between the islands, to depths of 5-7 fathoms, but shallow again, commonly to less than 1 fathom as they flow out across the seaward edge of the sub-aqueous deltas. In some places the channels lose their identity completely. The deltas are bounded seawards by the 1 fathom depth contour and shelve steeply at their outer edge to 3 fathoms. They are simple in form at the mouth of a single ebb channel, e.g., that northeast of Abu Dhabi island, or complex where more than one channel discharges between the islands, as for example the deltas northeast and southwest of Halat el Bahrani. They are being deflected partly southwestwards by the dominant wave approach which is largely controlled by the prevalent northwest or “Shamal” winds. The deltas probably have a complex origin, perhaps representing several stages of deposition separated by periods of elevation which may correlate with Pleistocene and post-Pleistocene sea-level changes. They are also in part erosional platforms cut into earlier Quaternary limestones on which the Recent sediments are accumulating. However, their general arcuate form and their close relationship to the present channel systems suggests that they are dominantly of tidal origin. The seaward islands are composed largely of unconsolidated Recent sediments. Limestones, probably Quaternary in age, underlie these desiments in some parts, and on the mainland often overlie older Tertiary deposits. This complex of lagoons, embayments and islands is bordered in some places on its landward margin by broad, low beach ridges and isolated hills of Tertiary and Quaternary sediments; in other places, extensive areas of intertidal flats, with wide stretches of Algae in some localities, occur along the inner coastline. Inland of the mainland coast is a wide flat sandy plain. often with a saline crust, the Sabkha. The Sabkha lies just above the level of high spring tides and may be up to 15 miles wide. It is bounded on its inland margins by low Tertiary hills capped occasionally by Quaternary limestone and often covered locally with a thin veneer of blown sand. In places a few, flat-topped, steep-sided, isolated hillocks, buttes, stand up from the Sabkha surface, surrounded by a fringe of blown desert sand. To the west the hills reach the coast and the Sabkha here occurs as isolated patches occupying the low ground. A detailed description of the area between Halat el Bahrani and Abu Dhabi will now be given; this area is fairly typical of the eastern part of the coastal region. The seaward facing coasts of these islands are aligned southwest to northeast and parallel the general coast trend. The beaches are fairly steep and are backed by large frontal
132
G . EVANS, D. J. J. KINSMAN AND D. J. SHEARMAN
Fig.2. Aerial mosaic of Abu Dhabi region. (Royal Air Force Photograph, Crown Copyright Reserved.)
ENVIRONMENT OF RECENT CARBONATE SEDIMENTATION I N THE PERSIAN GULF
133
Fig.3. Map showing salient features of area covered by aerial mosaic. Inset area is discussed by KINSMAN (1963).
134
G . EVANS, D. J. I. KINSMAN A N D D. J. SHEARMAN
dune ridges. The maximum tidal range is about 6 ft. but this may be increased during periods of strong northwesterly winds. The orientation of the beaches and the frontal dune ridges is a response to this onshore wind. The steep beach faces are characterised by the development of cusps and are fronted by a narrow low tide terrace. At the top of the beaches one or more berms are usually developed, often extensively colonised by the burrowing crab Ocypoda aegyptica. The berms are succeeded landwards by a wind stripped terrace. Low, hummocky, partly vegetated dunes lead inland from this upper terrace and merge into the frontal dune ridge which on Halat el Bahrani reaches 30 ft. in height and is the highest part of the island. Behind this ridge is an extensive flat, wind stripped area with a surface lag deposit of coarser debris; smaller dunes are present, especially near the inner southeastern corner of the island. In the southwest of Halat el Bahrani, however, behind the frontal dune ridge is a wide swampy area with a typical dendritic drainage pattern of creeks. This area is densely vegetated by Arthrocnemum glaucum. The sheltered inner coasts of Halat el Bahrani are characterised by a succession of spits. These are arranged en khelon and are all directed inwards toward the mainland. The tongues between the spits are colonised by large numbers of gastropods and crabs. Faecal pellets and trails cover much of the gastropod zone, which is inundated by every tide. The small burrowing crab Scopimera lives in the higher zone which is inundated only during high spring tides; the surface of this zone is covered by the burrowing pellets produced by Scopimrra, although these are destroyed whenever the zone is flooded. Wide cjab flats extend along most of these coasts, often landwards of the spit area. The gastropod flats become very extensive in the extreme southeast of the island. Further again southeast a n extensive area of tidal swamps is developed extending almost to the mainland coast. Between the deltas, directly fronting the islands are coral reefs, predominantly of Acropora with subordinate Platygyra and other massive corals. The main ebb channel flowing across the delta between Halet el Bahrani and Abu Dhabi bifurcates 3 miles from its mouth around the island of Jazirat el Ftaisi. This latter island is thus separated from the open sea by the wide shoal area of the delta and does not have the coastline typical of the more seaward islands. The shoal area enclosed by the main branches of the ebb channel is another area of coral growth. The coral here is diffuse and occurs in patches, whereas on the steep walls of the ebb channels the growth of the dominant coral, Acropora, is extremely prolific.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Grateful acknowledgement is made to D.S.I.R. for financing this project; to the Hydrographer of the Royal Navy, Captain and crew of H.M.S. Dalrymple for much assistance and co-operation; to the British Museum of Natural History for identification of fauna and flora; to Abu Dhabi Petroleum Co., and to Mrs. F. Kelk for assistance in the preparation of the figures.
ENVIRONMENT OF RECENT CARBONATE SEDIMENTATION IN THE PERSIAN GULF
135
SUMMARY
The physiographic setting of an area of Recent carbonate sedimentation along the Trucial Coast, Persian Gulf is described. Previous work on the sediments and waters of the Persian Gulf is briefly reviewed. The paper forms the background for the description of the sediments of part of the area discussed (see KINSMAN, 1963).
REFERENCES
BRAMKAMP, R. A. and POWERS, R. W., 1955. Two Persian Gulf lagoons. (Abstract). J. Sedinimt. Petrol., 25 : 139-140. CURTIS, R., EVANS, G., KINSMAN, D. J. J., SHEARMAN, D. J., 1963. Association of dolomite and anhydrite in the Recent sediments of the Persian Gulf. Nature, 197 (4868) : 679480. EMERY, K. O., 1956. Sediments and water of Persian Gulf. Bull. A m . Assoc. Petrol. Ceogists, 40 : 2354-2383.
HOUBOLT, J. J. H. C., 1957. Surface Sediments of the Persian Gulf near the Qatar Peninsula. Thesis, Univ. of Utrecht, Mouton, The Hague, 113 pp. KINSMAN, D. J. J., 1963. The Recent carbonate sediments near Halat el Bahrani, Trucial Coast, Persian Gulf. In: L. M. 5. U. VAN STRAATEN (Editor), Deltaic andShallow Marine Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 185-192 SUGDEN, W., 1963. 1. Some aspects of sedimentation in the Persian Gulf. 2. The hydrology of the Persian Gulf and its significance in respect to evaporite deposition. In press. WELLS,A. J., 1962. Recent dolomite in the Persian Gulf. Nature. 194 (4825) : 276275. WELLS,A. J. and ILLING,L. V., 1963. Present day precipitation of calcium carbonate in the Persian Gulf. In: L. M. J. U. VAN STRAATEN (Editor), Deltaic and Shallow Marine Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 429-435.
TRACE-FOSSILS AND THE SEDIMENTARY SURFACE IN SHALLOW-WATER MARINE SEDIMENTS R. GOLDRING
Department of Geology, University of Reading, Reading (Great Britain)
INTRODUCTION
In three papers, SEILACHER (1954, 1955, 1958) has distinguished two broad assemblages of trace-fossils (ichnofossils) in marine deposits. One may be associated with what are considered to be shallow-water sediments, and the other with what are considered to be relatively deeper-water sediments, in particular turbidites. In the broadest synonymy, one is associated with a flysch facies; the other with shallow marine facies. Few ichnogenera are common to both facies. The turbidite facies is characterised by a preponderance of grazing traces (Pascichnia), whilst resting traces (Cubichnia) and dwelling burrows (Domichnia) are rare or absent. The two latter are well represented in epicontinental sediments. Besides these two distinct trace-fossil assemblages, it is considered that the trace assemblages associated with shallow-water and shelf sediments may be usefully divided into two groups. Although the sedimentological characters of each are substantially distinct, a consideration of the trace assemblages may add useful information towards an appreciation of the sedimentary environment. In analysing epicontinental assemblages, Seilacher has drawn on such examples as the Mesozoic sandstones of Wiirttemberg and the Cambrian of the Salt Range, which include resting traces, often aligned, and trails made on, from, or very close to the sea floor. Migrating burrows constructed below the surface, such as Teichichnus, Ptiycodcs and Rhizocorallium, together with other feeding burrows, are also present. The sea floor must have been quite rapidly covered with accumulating sediment, for those traces, made close to it, to have been preserved. Seldom, if at all, was it subjected to any considerable penecontemporaneous erosion. Vertical repetitions of Asteriacites lumbricalis (SEILACHER 1953, p.100) in sandstone showing primary current lineation, indicate a fairly continuous accumulation of about 2 cm, and associated upward migrating (retrusive) Diplocraterion sp. of at least 15 cm. I n contrast, there are other sediments which, from their sedimentological characteristics and associated body-fossils, must also be considered as epicontinental and neritic. These rarely, if ever, yield any trace-fossil, in position of formation, that was made on or immediately below the sedimentary surface. This does not necessarily mean that such markings were not made in these sediments, but that if they were, then they were never fully preserved.
TRACE-FOSSILS A N D SEDIMENTARY SURFACE
137
CH 0NDR ITES
The trace-fossil Chondrites has been redescribed by SIMPSON(1957). It is known from the Ordovician to the Tertiary, and occurs in several types of preservation (Fig.1). With bed-junction preservation, a change in the nature of the sediment accumulating takes place, and the new sediment fills in the tunnel system excavated by the organism. The lithological change may be gradual, and without penecontemporaneous erosion. If there is no sedimentary change, only subsequent diagenetic differentiation between the sediment filling the tunnels and the matrix, will render them observable. Sharp changes in lithology, as, for instance, between a sandstone and a shale, may be associated with slight penecontemporaneous erosion removing portions of the proximal shafts, and give rise to concealed bed-junction preservation. Burial preservation is where the sediment surrounding the mucus-lined tubes has been winnowed away leaving a pile of Fucus-like strands, indicating definite penecontemporaneous erosion, and the removal of the sedimentary surface from which the tunnel system was initiated. In the latter two types, it is not however possible to measure the amount of erosion that has taken place. Bed-junction preservation and diagenetic preservation were noted by Simpson to occur abundantly i n the Lower Lias of the south coast of England, but burial preservation is absent. Burrowing pelecypods and Pinna in their attitude of growth, and Lima also in the growth position, with encrusting oysters on the posterior part of the shell (HALLAM,I960), also show the infrequency of penecontemporaneous erosion. In the Carboniferous limestone of the Bristol district, only a few examples of burial preservation have been found. Bed-junction preservation greatly predominates, such as cylinders of limestone piping downwards from a limestone into an argillaceous band, and vice versa, but diagenetic preservation is also present in the calcite-mudstone bands. In contrast, in the Upper Emsian Lynton Beds and the Givetian Ilfracombe Beds of southwest England, concealed bed-junction preservation predominates in the slate bands, and burial preservation is not infrequent. Penecontemporaneous erosion was of frequent occurrence. The Lynton Beds and the Ilfracombe Beds are neritic sediments, and both are conformably underlain by continental deposits. Other trace-fossils have not yet been described from the beds but, so far as the writer is aware, no exogenic forms occur. The type of preservation of Chondrites in these sediments contrasts sharply with that in the Dinantian, Lias, and elsewhere in the Mesozoic (SIMPSON, 1957, p.490).
THE UPPER DEVONIAN BAGGY BEDS
The Baggy Beds of southwest England stratigraphically lie in a conformable sequence between continental and neritic sediments. They almost completely lack surface-made traces and shallow burrowings are only locally abundant. DiplocrationJoyo,
138 R. GOLDRING
TRACE-FOSSILS A N D SEDIMENTARY SURFACE
139
a migratory U-burrow, vertical to the bedding, is the most common trace-fossil. It occurs in a banded lithology of fine-grained sandstone and mudstone; the laminae are from 0.1-1.0 cm thick. This lithology accounts for approximately 15-20% of the Baggy Beds (400 m). GOLDRING (1962) has interpreted the behaviour pattern of this species as a response to repeated phases of sedimentation and erosion. Both retrusive and protrusive forms are present. Only a few examples of what are considered to be the actual aperture to the burrow are known, and in the majority of specimens, which are retrusive forms, only a remnant of the original structure is preserved beneath a sandstone capped erosion surface. In spite of the overall accumulation of sediment, there must have been repeated phases of degradation of the sedimentary surface. The overall amount of erosion is not easy to determine, but was generally in the order of 5-10 cm for most specimens, whilst individual phases were probably less than 1 .O cm. I n nearly every case where the species occurs, erosion of sediment can be deduced, with at least twice the amount of sediment preserved having been originally deposited. Only organisms which were able to penetrate to a depth of 5-10 cni or more, were likely to leave any trace of their existeiice in the fossil record. The open U-tube Arenicolites curvatus is present in more massive sandstone. The tubes must have been frequently subjected to erosion, as fragments commonly occur in interbedded congloFig.1. The amount of sedimentation or erosion as indicated by the adjustment to depth and mode of preservation of various species. Heights of solid arrows show amount of sedimentation or erosion. ( I ) Movement pattern of burrowing pelecypod with single siphonal opening e.g., Mya (after REINECK. 1958). With stationary sedimentary surface (a) growing organism burrows deeper. With rapid sedimentation (b) organism migrates towards surface, leaving infilled burrow of same breadth as shell. With degradation of surface (c) organism migrates downwards, leaving burrow of same breadth as shell. (2) Movement pattein of polycheate worm, e.g., Nereis (after REINECK, 1958). Older colonised surface ( a ) is rapidly covered by sediment ( b and c) and during deposition of sediment, paths of escape are directly upwards. New colonisation surface (c) with irregular burrows. Burrows in ( a ) and ( c ) generally mucus lined; in (b) unlined. Similar pattern observed by author in sands of Bagshot Beds (Eocene) at Bramshill (SU 756610). (3) Movement pattern of organism dwelling in single tube, e.g.. Cerianthus (after SCHAFER, 1956). With sedimentation, the coral moves upwards leaving an infilled burrow. A similar pattern might be expected in traces attributed to Skolithos and Monocraterion. ( 4 ) Movement of Asteriocites lunibricolis (after SEILACHER, 1953): (a) with sedimentation the ophiuroid migrates upwards in stages (i-iii), and ( b ) combined plan of all impressions. ( 5 ) Preservation pattern of Chondrites (after SIMPSON, 1957). The tunnel system (a) is infilled (b) following a change in the type of sediment being deposited (bed-junction preservation). Slight degradation of the surface (c) removes the proximal shafts before further sediment, of a different type, accumulates (concealed bed-junction preservation). Renewed degradation of the surface winnows away the sediment, leaving the mucus-lined infilled tunnels as burial preservation (d). (6) Preservation pattern of Arenicolites curvatus (after GOLDRING, 1962). The sedimentary surface with the open U-tubes (a) has been degraded (b), the mucuscemented tube fragments accumulating in an intraformational conglomerate; sediment has filled the tubes in (b). (7) Movement pattern of Diplocration yoyo (after GOLDRING, 1962). In the Upper Devonian Baggy Beds of north Devon, this trace occurs in the various types shown in (F),where all have been truncated to a common erosion surface. It is considered that repeated phases of erosion and sedimentation led to the development of the various types. Stage (A), development of burrow ( I ) . With degradation of the surface, this tube migrates downwards, and at intervals, new tubes (2 and 3) are constructed ( E and C ) . Sedimentation follows (Dand E) but some of the tubes are abandoned. Stage ( F ) , all tubes are abandoned and erosion reduces them to a common base.
140
R . GOLDRING
merates. It is not possible to determine how much of the tubes were eroded, though there are fragments up to 5 cm in length. None of the body fossils (thick-shelled pelecypods and gastropods) occur in their growth position. It is interesting to attempt a determination of what the sedimentary surface must have often been like in Baggy times. From a freak preservation at one locality, it can be deduced that the sedimentary surface locally carried a prolific number of DFlocraterion. Judging from the large number of specimens of Lingula, frequently wellpreserved, lying on bedding surfaces elsewhere in the Baggy Beds, other sedimentary surfaces must often have been extensively burrowed by this brachiopod, though not to the depth to which Diplocraterion penetrated. There were probably also banks of the thick-shelled pelecypod Dolabra (Arcacea), none of which have been preserved, the specimens occurring only in cross-bedded sandstone units. If local areas were at times, quite highly populated with surface-dwelling and burrowing organisms, this would indicate (REINECK, 1958), so far as these areas are concerned, periods of only slight sedimentation and erosion. Such areas if they existed at the present day would likely be quite readily observable (e.g., tidal flats) in contrast with areas, such as channels where rapid changes may occur. Scarcely any surface that could represent such an area has been preserved.
AN INTERMEDIATE ASSEMBLAGE
The Baggy Beds and the basin facies of the Blue Lias, or the Lower Jurassic of Wiirttemberg, may be considered as the two extremes for the preservation of sedimentary surfaces. What might be considered as intermediate members, are sections of the Carboniferous of northern England and southern Scotland. There, although there is a good deal of evidence of penecontemporaneous erosion, nevertheless sedimentary surfaces with fossils in their growth positions, and surface-made traces, are not infrequently preserved. The upper part of the Carboniferous limestone and the succeeding Yoredales (Visean to Namurian), together with their Scottish equivalents, comprise repetitive successions of limestone, marine and non-marine shale, sandstone and occasional coals. In palaeoecological studies on the marine shales, CRAIG (1952, 1 9 5 4 , 1956) and FERGUSON (1962) have shown that, occasionally, surface-living organisms such as Productus concinnus and pectiniform pelecypods, and more frequently burrowers such as Lingula and Edrnondia, occur in their position of growth. However, sedimentary scour structures and the occurrence of concentrations of disarticulated and fragmentary shells, show that the sedimentary surface was always likely to be swept by currents. The trace-fossils associated with the series are not well documented, and have often been described merely as “fucoids”. DONALDSON and SIMPSON (1962) have described an association from the Visean (D) limestones of north Lancashire. Besides numerous surface-made, exogenic trails, one bed is covered by conical mounds of castings, Cliornatichnus, above vertical burrows, pushed to the surface by an unknown organism. Judging by the density of the castings (about
TRACE-FOSSILS A N D SEDIMENTARY SURFACE
141
30/m2), they must have been formed on a sedimentary surface of some duration. They were then rapidly covered, and no reworking took place. Spirophyton, Cock’s tail, markings may be connected with the castings, and there are also endogenic burrows, some attributable to Teichichnus and Chonrirites. Cauda-galli markings are common elsewhere in the series, and probably represent the central laminated trace of a sediment-eating organism, migrating through the sediment close to the sea-floor. A Corophium-like burrow with thick walls, near to Tisoa siphonalis MARCEL DE SERRES (BATHER1924), which extends about 5 cm into shale, is common at Earlsferry, Fife, in the Carboniferous Limestone Series. Footprints have been recorded from the Calciferous sandstone (SMITH,1891). In general, the faunal, algal and lithological association indicate a fairly shallow-water sedimentary environment for those parts of the cyclothems considered as marine.
CONCLUSIONS
These analyses, albeit brief, of trace-fossil assemblages formed in no great depth of water, lead to three main conclusions. Firstly, two distinct types of assemblages are represented, possibly the end members of a continuous series, (1) with surface or near-surface made traces, as well as traces made at greater depths, and (2) with only traces made some depth below the sedimen tary surface. Secondly, on the one hand, the frequent occurrence of abundant surface-made traces, or those made very close to the sedimentary surface, indicate fairly continuous sedimentation, and the preservation of nearly every sedimentary surface. On the other hand, the complete absence of these trace types, associated with frequent evidence of erosion, is testimony of discontinuous sedimentation. and the eventual preservation of only a fraction of the actual sediment deposited. REINECK (1960) has shown that only 1/lO,OOO-I/lOO,OOO part of the sediment deposited i n recent shallow water sediments in tidal seas, is actually fossilised. Similar conditions must have existed during the deposition of much of the Baggy Beds. Thirdly, the adjustments of certain organisms attempting to maintain a constant depth below the sedimentary surface, can be used to estimate the amount of sedimentation or erosion that has taken place. Also, the mode of preservation of others is an indication of this. REINECK (1 958) has shown the effect of slow and fast sedimentation and erosion on Mya, Nereis and other organisms in recent sediments. Vertical repetition of Asteriacites and retrusive Diylocraterion give an indicatioii of the amount of sedimentation. These and other examples are shown diagrammatically in the accompanying text-figure. The sedimentological causes for the division are probably complex. To permit continuous sedimentation with only limited penecontemporaneous erosion, the environment must have been under conditions leading t o continuous aggradation. If sediment accumulated beyond a certain rate, colonisation by burrowing organisms would be
142
R . GOLDRING
impossible, and most existing organisms would attempt t o migrate elsewhere (REINECK, 1958; MIDDLEMISS, 1962). Discontinuous sedimentation at the present day, is particularly well developed in the intertidal zone of continental shelves, and is a typical feature of prodelta sediments.
SUMMARY
Two distinct trace-fossil assemblages from shallow-water marine sediments are recognised: (a) with traces made on, or close to the sedimentary surface as well as those penetrating deeper, and (h) with only traces made well below the sedimentary surface. Whereas there is evidence for only limited penecontemporaneous erosion in sediments associated with the former type, there is evidence of considerable and frequent penecontemporaneous erosion associated with the latter. The amount of sedimentation and erosion can be estimated from the behaviour pattern and mode of preservation of certain trace-fossils.
REFERENCES
BATHER, F. A,, 1924. Tisoa siphonalis MARCEL DE SERRES, a supposed Liassic annelid. Naturalist, 1925 : 7-10. CRAIG,G. Y., 1952. A comparative study of the ecology and palaeoecology of Lingula. Trans. Edinbrrrgh Geol. SOC.,15 : 110-120. CRAIG,G . Y , 1954. The palaeoecology of the Top Hosie Shale (Lower Carboniferous) at a locality near Kilsyth Quart. J . Geol. SOC.London, 110 : 103-1 19. CRAIG,G. Y.,1956. The mode of life of certain Carboniferous animals from the west Kirkton Quarry, near Bathgate. Trans. Eilinbirrgh Gcol. Soc., 16 : 272-219. D. and SIMPSON, S., 1962. Choniatichtius. a new ichnogenus, and other trace-fossils of DONALDSON, Wegber Quariy. Liverpool Manrhester Geol. J., 3 : 73-81. FEROUSON, L., 1962. The palaeoecology of a Lower Carboniferous marine transgression. J. Paleontol., 36 : 1090-1101. GOLDRING, R., 1962. The trace fossils of the Baggy Beds (Upper Devonian) of North Devon, England. Paliiontol. Z., 36 : 232-257. HALLAM, A., 1960. A sedimentary and faunal study of the Blue Lias of Dorset and Glamorgan. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London, Ser. B, 243 : 1 4 . MIDDLEMISS, F. A,, 1962. Vermiform burrows and rate of sedimentation in the Lower Greensand. Geol. Mqy.. 99 : 3 3 4 0 . REINECK,H. E., 1958. Wuhlbau-Gefiige in Abhangigkeit von Sediment-Umlagerungen. Senckcviber,niana Lethaca, 39 : 1-23, 54-56. REINECK, H. E.. 1960 Uber Zeitliicken in rezenten Flachsee-Sedimenten. Geol. Rundschair,49 : 149-161. SCHAFER, W., 1956. Wirkungen der Benthos-Organismen auf den jungen Schichtverband. Srtickenbet-yiatia Lethaea, 37 : 183-263. SEILACHER, A., 1953. Studien zur Palichnologie. 11. Die fossilen Ruhespuren (Cubichnia). Neites Jahrb. Geol. Palaontol. Abhandl., 98 : 87-124. SEILACHER, A., 1954. Die geologische Bedeutung fossiler Lebensspuren. Z. Derrt. Grol. Ges., 105 : 2 14-227. SEILACHER, A,, 1955. Spuren und Fazies irn Unterkambrium. In: 0. SCHINDEWOLF und A. SEILACHER, BeitrLige zur Kenntnis des Kambriirrns in der Salt Range (Pakistan) - A k a d Wiss. Lit. Mainz Abhandl. Math. Nut. KI., 1955 : 313-399.
TRACE-FOSSILS A N D SEDIMENTARY SURFACE
143
SEILACHER, A., 1958. Zur okologischen Charakteristik von Flysch und Molasse. Eclogae Ceol. Helv., 51 : 1062-1078. SIMPSON, S., 1957. On the trace-fossil Clionrlrites. Quart. J . Geol. SOC.London, 112 : 475-500. SMITH,J., 1891. Note on the occurrence of footprints in the calciferous sandstone between West Kilbride and Fairlie. Trans. Geol. SOC.GlaTyow, 9 : 201-203.
BEACH STUDIES IN WEST FLORIDA, U.S.A.l D. S. CORSLINE
Department of Geolo,q, University of Southern Calfornia, Los Angeles, C a l f . ( U.S.A.)
INTRODUCTION
During the period from January to December, 1962, a series of fifteen beach stations distributed along the Florida Panhandle Coast were occupied monthly and profiles and other characteristics measured and recorded. The primary objective of the survey was to determine the magnitude of the seasonal variations of the beach dimensions and also to investigate the associated changes in the sediments and Foraminifera populations of the beach zone. This short report will note some of the initial conclusions based on the topographic and sedimentologic data. A more detailed paper is in preparation. Fig. 1 illustrates the station locations. This study was part of a larger study of bays of west Florida. I
ALA.
FLA
bJ\J1,
d
Fig.1. Locations of the fifteen beach profile stations. All stations were located on the open Gulf shore except S.J.P.C., Royal Bluff and East Point.
DISCUSSION
The data collected during the survey included detailed topographic profiles taken from fixed bench marks located well above the high water level and extended out beyond the surf zone. Profiles were determined using modified Jacob's staffs after a method desContribution no. 194 of the Florida State University, Oceanograc:,.c Institute.
145
BEACH STUDIES IN WEST FLORIDA
cribed by EMEKY(1961). Sediment samples were collected at intervals of one and onehalf meters on the first survey and then only a t the berm. swash line. mid breakerswash zone and beyond the surf on all subsequent profiles since these were found to be sufTicient to describe the character of the beach material. Water samples were collected for later analysis, temperatures of air and water, wind direction and velocity, biological samples of the swash line. wave period and height and wave direction were all measured and recorded. Sediment samples were analysed texturally using an Emery Settling Tube (EMERY,1938). Biological samples were stained with a protein specific dye (Rose Bengal) so as to mark living organisms. I n order to ascertain the representativeness of nlonthly profiles a series of profiles were measured at several test beaches at intervals of one hour. one to two days. one week and one month. These preliminary studies established that the monthly changes a r e a good sample of the important beach variations effected by changes i n tide and wave trains. TABLE I C F N F R A L SHORE CHARACTERISTICS
A rcrc!ycJ
Slclliulr
IllPUll
110.
iilttl
~-
o
Keaton Beach
I 2
Mashe Island Alligator Berch S.J.P.C. Royal Bluff East Point West Pass San Blas Beach Mexico Beach Panama City Grayron Beach Destin Beach Pensacola Reach Gulf Beach Gulf Shores
3
i 5
5 8 I2 14 I6
17 19 20 21
311.5 5!3.0 17!3.0 712.0 10:3.0 812.0 2514.0 231'4.0 2715.0 2716.0
3015.0 3015.0 3015.0 2415.0 35l5.0
5 10 30 10
2 2 8
20 15 50 35 40 45
3
50 60 75 45 65
~
30
-7
3 10 10 12 10 8 8 17
I5 17
-
100 80 60 35 85 40 60 40 50 35 50
0.28 0.36 0.33 0.27 0.27 0.44 0.31 0.32 0.42 0.30 0.36 0.29 0.43 0.44 P.75
See Fig.1. '?
Average of six months observations.
:' Mean sediment diameters of all samples collected at the swash line at each station Preliniinary examination of the data (Table I) indicates an expectable increase i n wave energy (in terms of wave heights) as the observer progresses from east to west. I n addition, the bay stations are all of the low energy type due to the protection from wave attack by the off<'- barrier islands. Maximum monthly profile changes occur region. Negligible changes are observed at Keaton Beach, at the western port;,
146
D. S. GORSLlNE
Mashe’s Island and the Apalachicola Bay stations (Fig. 1). PRICE’S (1954) original classification of the Big Bend region as a zero energy coast is confirmed. Net vertical changes in the zone of maximum variation range from no change to as much as two meters on the moderate energy beaches of the western sector. The size of the profile “envelopes” at each station are proportional to the much larger changes observed in a similarly executed study of the high energy beaches of the Pacific Coast Of the U.S. ([NGLE, 1962). Drift direction tabulations are surprising in that they are not mono-directional except at two stations (Royal Bluff and Mexico Beach) where offshore features screen out all but a small sector of possible wave approaches. The observations contrast with the evidence of general shoreline trends on aerial photographs and charts which seem to indicate dominant westerly construction in the vicinity of the station locations. There may be a roughly defined association of westerly drift directions and the highest waves and thus, the major long term shore trends may represent the effect of relatively short periods of strong wave action. The greatest fetch for wave generation is from the south and southwest. Sediments are essentially uniform i n character on the Florida beaches. Therefore, no marked changes in regional averages of mean diameter are observed (Table I). However, there appear to be real differences in individual sample profiles. These often show best sorting and markedly different mean diameters (as compared to berm and offshore) in the swash zone. At many beaches shells, shell fragments, drift wood, kelp and other debris accumulate in this zone. Maps of the wave front bearings at all stations for each month produce an interesting pattern. The area can be readily divided into a western and eastern sector west and east of Cape San Blas. Wave directions in each sector are always opposed either divergently or convergently and cross seas are always observed at Cape San Blas. This implies that either a topographic or meteorologic boundary is present. Since the Cape San Blas shoal is not sufficiently large to influence the patterns over such an extended region, it is suggested that the wave evidence is indicative of a meteorologic zonation. Cape San Blas Shoal may itself be a product of the converging seas. This boundary may also delineate sediment provinces but the gross similarity in the Florida shore sands prevents a clear conclusion on this point. A preliminary study of the heavy mineral assemblages of a few samples suggests that the western sands have appreciably smaller heavy mineral contents and also that the opaques (principally magnetite and 1960). ilmenite) are in much greater abundance in the heavy fraction (CARPENTER, More detailed studies are in progress. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The writer wishes to acknowledge the aid and financial support of the study by the Geography Branch of the Office of Naval Research. Much of the hard work of surveying was made possible by the devoted assistance of Messers Noel Plutchak, Robert Kunzler, Richard Evans, Ronald Kolpack, John Schnable, Richard Mitterer, Charles
BEACH STUDIES IN WEST FLORIDA
147
Early, Don Milligan, Vernon Finney and Charles Pflum. Mr. Plutchak and Mr. Kunzler did much of the sedimentologic analysis and Mr. Evans and Mr. Kunzle: also drafted most of the profiles. Salinities were measured by Miss Gloria Brown. Laboratory and field facilities were provided by the Oceanographic Institute and the Department of Geology of the Florida State University. Mr. Ronald Kolpack read the report manuscript and offered many useful criticisms. This study was supported by funds under contract nonr. 988 (07) with the Geography Branch, Office of Naval Research.
SUMMARY
Topographic profiles, sediment and water samples, and climatic data have been collected in a monthly schedule at fifteen stations distributed along the western Florida Panhandle coast during 1962. These observations and associated wave measurements have been studied to determine the magnitude of the beach variations associated with different energy ranges of wave attack. Preliminary conclusions are that the patterns show a direct relation between change i n beach profile versus increasing wave energy and further, that a regional climatic-oceanographic boundary can be defined on the basis of beach and wave data.
REFERENCES
CARPENTER, J. W.. 1960. Heavy Mineral Assemblavs in Florida Beach Sands. Unpubl. res. rept. Dept. of Geol., Florida State Univ.. Tallahassee, Fla., 12 pp. EMERY.K . 0.. 1938. A rapid method of mechanical analysis of sands. J . Sediiiient. Peirul., 8 : 105-1 I I . EMERY,K . 0.. 1961. A simple method of measuring beach profiles. Linxol. O c e a n q . , 6 : 90-93. INCLE JR., L. C., 1962. Tracing movement of beach sands by means of fluorescent dyed sand. Shore Beach, 30 (2) : 3 1-37. PRICE,W. A., 1954. Dynamic environments - reconnaissance mapping, geologic and geomorphic of the continental shelf of Gulf of Mexico. Trans. Gfibr. Coast Assoc. Geol. SOC.,4 : 75-107.
L A SEDIMENTAI'ION SOUS-MARINE DANS LA PARTIE ORlENI'ALE DE LA RADE DE BKEST, BRETAGNE
C O N D I T I O N SD E L A S ~ D I M E N T A T I O N
La Rade de Brest (Fig. I ) est une assez vaste ttendue d'eaux marines, qui ne communique avec I'Ocean que par u n goulet de 2 k n i de large et 50 ni de profondeur. Dans sa partie orientale. seule ttudiee ici, on distingue deux tltnieiits topographiques essentiels: ( I ) Des baiics, dont la profondeur n'atteint iiulle part 10 m sous les plus basses mers, et dont quelques parties tmergent aux grandes basses rners.
Fig.1. Topographic sous-marine de I'est d e la Rade de Brest. 6quidistance: 5 m (.sauf courbe de 3 m par endroits). Profondeurs en metres sous les plus basses mers.
(2) Deux valltes sous-marines encaisstes dans la partie axiale, q u i sont les prolongeinents des Rivikres de Chiteaulin et de Daoulas, ennoytes par la transgression flandrienne, et dont le goulet d'entrte de la rade est la partie aval; la profondeur dtpasse u n peu 30 rn dans I'ouest de la region ttudite. Dans la Baie de Daoulas, la vallte sousmarine nord a ktt cornblte par la stdimentation. La vallte de Chlteaulin est inter-
S~DIMENTATION SOUS-MARINE DANS LA R A D E IIE RREST
149
roinpue par u n seuil. la Traverse de I’H6pita1, q u i doit Ctre un ancien mtandre en majeure partie stdimentt: il en rtsulte i cet endroit u n decrochement dans la direction de la vallte. En outre, d a m I’Anse du Poulniic existent quatre valltes beaucoup rnoins profondes: l’une d’entre elks peut Etre u n autre mtandre de la vallte de Chiteaulin. recoupe par des processus Huviatiles avant la transgression; les trois autres sont vraisemblablement de petites valltes affluentes, beaucoup plus courtes, et moins profondes avant to u te sed i men t a t i on m ari nr: . Comine la houle du large ne penktre pas en Rade de Brest, ce milieu n’est atrecti que par des vngues nCes localenient, sur des fetches atteignant au maximum 24 kin. et gtneralement inferieurs: les vagiies ont donc une trts courte longueur d’onde et s’aniortissent tres rapidement en profondeur. Par contre, les courant.~de mur& sont notables, mais d’iniportance variable selon les lieux. D’apres les cartes de courants de surface d’heure en heure du Service Hydrographique francais. en vive eau rnoyenne (coefficient 100) ils atteignent jusqu’i I ,7 noeud dans I’axe de la vallte de Chiteaulin: I ,3 noeud sur le Banc de Skivieg; I ,O noeud dans le sudest de la Baie de Daoulas; 0.9 noeud dans I’Anse du Poulrnic; 0.8 noeud sur le Banc du Loc’h; 0,7 noeud sur le Banc du Poulmic. La Rade de Brest est u n milieu hybride, different d u milieu estuarien et du milieu bien ouvert sur le large, et participant des deux. C’est de Ih que dtcoulent les caracteres de sa sedimentation.
C A L C I M ~ T K IET E P ~ O G K A P H I DES E S~DIMENTS
Deux cent quinze tchantillons ont Ite draguts d a m I’aire ttudite, bord du petit bateau oclanographique “Kornog“, au moyen d’une drague Rallier du Raty. Les Fig. 2 et 3 permettent de voir quelle est la densitt des prtlkvements. Ceux-ci ont It6 faits dans toutes les positions topographiques, reptrtes au sondeur, sauf sur les hauts et al., 1957). d’estrans qui avaient d6jh ttt ttudits avant (GUILCHER La teneur en CaCO, de ces stdimelits est un premier caracttre trts important. On voit sur la Fig.2 que cette teneur est, en rnoyenne, trks tlevCe: dans I’irnmense ma,joritt des echantillons. elk dtpasse 20%. et il l u i arrive parfois d’exctder 80%. Pourtant, les roches de cette region, qui sont des schistes devoniens avec u n certain nonibre de filons basiques, sont trks gtntralement siliceuses: des gisements calcaires existent sur les bords de la rade, mais ils sont rares et trks peu ttendus. La forte teneur en calcaire provient donc presque uniquement de la fraction organogkne, et elk permet de mesurer la trks grande importance de cette fraction dans la skidimentation sous-marine. I1 y a cependant des difftrences dans les teneurs: les pourcentages depassant 50% se rencontrent dans la partienordouest et ouest, dans l’axe NE-SW de la Baie de Daoulas, et d a m la partie nordest (Traverse de I’H6pital et Banc de Gwaskellou). Au contrairte, les teneurs sont faibles d a m le sudouest (Anse du Poulmic), le sud (Banc du Loc’h), I’est (Landevennec), et d a m le nordouest et le sudest de la Baie de Daoulas.
150
A. GUILCHER
On a aussi determint, pour chaque echantillon, la teneur en Ca CO, de la fraction suplrieure a I mm, et de la fraction infkrieure a 60 p. Ces opkrations ont montre que, cornme en bien d'autres sediments marins, la teneur en calcaire varie en raison directe de la grosseur des particules. Au-dessus de 1 mm, les teneurs supirieures a 90% sont
Fig.2. Calcinittrie. Les chiffres donnent les pourcentages globaux de CaCO,,. Lirnite en trait plein: 50%; et de part et d'autre.
+
~
frequentes, et beaucoup plus gtneralisees dans I'espace. Au contraire, en-dessous de 60 p. les teneurs sont gentralement 10-30 %. Cette difitrence est essentielle; cependant, on remarquera que la fraction fine est loin, en general, d'Ctre complktenient dtnuie de calcaire: celui-ci y est seulement beaucoup moins abondant. Pour prtciser la nature des elements grossiers, I'exarnen macroscopique des echantillons a suggtrt la niithode suivante: on a procide, sur les tchantillons contenant une fraction sufisante entre I et 2 mni (c'est i dire, en fait, presque tous les echantillons). a un comptage du pourcentage des particules classtes en trois categories: Lithothamnium culcareum, appelt "maerl" en Bretagne; dtbris de coquilles; dtrnents minlraux. La Fig.3 donne le pourcentage des particules de Lithothamnium. Cette algue calcaire apparait comme ttant trks souvent prtdominante: c'est le cas le plus repandu sur les bancs, q u i sont un milieu extremement favorable, oh habituellement on recueille c6te B c6te du maerl vivant et du maerl mort. Cependant, dans la vallte sous-marine de Chiteaulin, la teneur en maerl devient le plus souvent faible ou trks faible. Nous attribuons ce fait ce que le maerl demande un bon kclairage pour vivre, et que la vallte est trop profonde pour qu'il y prospkre. Ceci implique que la sedimentation se fait sur les lieux de vie, donc que les transports de sediments sont faibles. Au contraire, les dtbris de coquilles sont extrCmement prtdominants dans la vallte sous-rnarine de Chiteaulin. Quant ri la fraction minerale a 1-2 mm, e l k est presque partout insigni-
S ~ D I M E N T A T I O NSOUS-MARINE DANS LA RADE DE BREST
151
-
Fig.3. Pourcentages de grains de rnaerl (Lithothamniuni ralcarrun~)dans la fraction 1-2 rnrn. Les tirets delimitent les vallees sous-marines de Chlteaulin et de Daoulas.
fiante: consistant en fragments de schistes ou plus rarement de mica et de quartz, ses pourcentages les plus frlquents vont de 0-3%, et ceux q u i dtpassent 10% sont trts rares. L’abondance du calcaire organogtne est a her au caracttre mixte de la Rade de Brest: dans les estuaires proprement dits, en effet, la fraction calcaire est en gentral trts inftrieure aux chiffres atteints ici. Comnie le calcaire organogkne est trts fragile, il peut paraitre ttonnant qu’il soit plus abondant aux grandes dimensions qu’aux petites: on peut prtsumer que le sediment subit une dtcalcification, qui soustrairait h mesure i la fraction fine ce qui devrait normalement lui revenir d’apports incessants de tests d’organismes.
A de rares exceptions prts, les stdiments de cette aire marine sont htttromttriques, contenant des particules de toutes tailles depuis celles inftrieures i 50 p jusqu‘aux graviers, en passarit par les sables. Le stdiment a gtntralenient une texture vaseuse comnie ceux des estuaires, mais il contient une fraction grossitre plus abondante que la moyenne des vases estuariennes. La encore apparait le caracttre mixte de la rade. On n’a pas fait la micro-granulomttrie de la fraction inftrieure a 50 p, mais on a tamist sous l’eau chaque tchantillon sur un tamis de 50 p, determint ainsi le pourcentage pondtral global de la fraction fine, et passt ensuite a sec la fraction de plus de 50 p dans une colonne de 9 tamis. On a ainsi pu dtterminer les principaux caracttres granulomitriques, et notamment les contrastes en fonction des situations topogra-
152
A . GUILCHER
phiques. Ces contrastes sont representis ici sous fornie de diagrammes triangulaires. la poudre et I'argile (silt and clay) etant grouptes ensemble, et les autres pointes des diagraninies etant attribuees au sable et au gravier. La Fig.4 donne la cle de la nomenclature, inspiree de celle de SHEPARD (1954).
sah!e
25
I
sable
50
75
Fig.4. Classification des categories diniensionnelles dans les diagramnies triangulaires. (d'Apres SHEPARD, 1954).
( / ) Sur la Fig.5 sont report& les points figuraiit les sediments des bancs du sud (Anse et Banc du Poiilniic, Banc du Loc'h, Banc Rouge), et de la Baie de Daoulas. Malgre une assez forte dispersion, on voit que ces points tendent ri se situer surtout dans les categories poudre sableuse et poudre graveleuse. et que mCme un certain argile. Ces sediments sont donc, comme on nombre sont d a m la categorie poudre
+
Fig.5. Granulometrie des sediments des bancs du sud et de la Baie dc Daoulas
S ~ D I M E N T A T L OSOUS-MARINE N D A N S LA RADE DE BREST
153
I'a dit, htttronittriques, A part trois ou quatre, mais, en gtneral, la fraction fine y est dominante ou tres dominante. (2) Sur la Fig. 6 sont figurts les points correspondant aux stdinients des bancs du nord (bancs de Skivieg, du Bendi, de Gwaskellou). Ici, la fraction fine n'est pas pre-
Fig.6. Granulometrie des sediiiients des bancs du nord, sauf la Baie de Daoulas.
dominante comme prtctdemment: les points sont groupts en grande niajorite dans la partiecentraledu diagramme, oh le gravier, le sable et la fraction poudre-argile sont tous prtsents en quantitts importantes et relativement tgales. Ce sont donc ceux des stdiments oh la dispersion granulomttrique est la plus grande, et ils sont nettement moins fins que ceux des bancs du sud et de la Baie de Daotilas. ( 3 ) Sur la Fig.7 sont indiquts, en cercles noirs, les points correspondant aux
Fig.7. Granulometrie des sediments des vallees sousmarines de Chiteaulin et de Daoulas. et de la Traverse de 1'88pital (cercles noirs), et des valltes sous-marines de I'Anse du Poulmic (croix).
154
A. GULLCHER
tchantillons des deux valltes sous-marines de Chlteaulin et de Daoulas, et ceux de la Traverse de I’Hbpital. Par rapport aux cattgories prtctdentes, ces points sont decalts vers les fractions sables et graviers: ils tendent ri se grouper dans la droite du cadre central. et dans le cadre du sable graveleux et du gravier sableux. Autrement dit, la fraction grossitre est encore plus importante que sur les bancs du nord. ( 4 ) Enfin, sur la Fig.7 tgalement, les croix indiquent les tchantillons des quatre petites vallees sous-marines peu profondes de I’.4nse du Poulmic. Ces stdiments sont complttement difftrents deceux des grandes valltes axiales: ce sont les plus fins de tous. Ces difftrences entre les cattgories de stdiments sont explicables par les courants de mar& (voir les vitesses de courants cittes plus haut). Les courants sont canalists surtout par la vallie sous-marine de Chlteaulin, et de Iri ils franchissent le barrage de la Traverse de I’H6pital. II est comprthensible que dans cette rtgion oh le courant est le plus fort, la fraction fine soit la moins abondante (Fig.7, cercles noirs). Sur les bancs du nord (Fig.6), le courant circule aussi assez vite. Au contraire, les bancs du sud sont abritts par la pointe de Peiin ar Vir qui dtvie le courant de flot vers le nord: I’Anse et le Banc du Poulmic et le Banc du Loc’h sont une aire i courants faibles, d’ou I’abondance des particules fines sur les baiics et dans les petites valltes peu profondes de cette rtgion (Figs. 7, croix). De m h e . la Baie de Daoulas est dans u n rentrant assez abritC (Fig.5). On remarquera d’autre part la correspondance entre les teneurs en calcaire relativement fortes et la stdimentation assez grossitre des bancs du nord, et la correspondance entre les teneurs en calcaire faibles et la skdinientation fine des bancs du sud et de la Baie de Daoulas (cf. Fig.2, 5 et 6). Ceci est une autre manitre d’exprimer le fait que plus les sediments sont grossiers, et plus ils sont calcaires. Enfin, un fait remarquable est la prtsence. en de trts nombreux tchantillons, de deux maxima granulomttriques distincts dans le gravier et dans le sable. Cette particularitt nous semble due a ce que le maerl est, par sa forme branchue et sa faible densitt, un mattrial trts particulier. q u i a ses rtgles propres de stdimentation (BERTHOIS et GUILCHER, 1959): il se melange aux particules d’autres origines en donnant un ensemble hybride. Et ce fait s’ajoute encore aux particularitis du milieu marin que nous ttudions ici.
REMERCIEMENTS
Ce travail rlsulte d’une recherche effectute ri bord du “Kornog”, puis au laboratoire de I’lnstitut de Gtographie de Paris, et i laquelle ont participt Mme Ters et M. Elhai, Maitres-assistants; Melle Pruleau, qui a rtcoltt les stdiments et a fait la plus grande partie des manipulations; Mesdames et Melles Kermarec, Malglaive, Paloque, Schiano, Sztokman, et MM. Ciblat, Leroi et Sztokman, ttudiants; M. Guez, Collaborateur technique; ainsi que l’tquipage du “Kornog”, MM. Le Lann, Kerros et H u h .
S~DIMENTATION SOUS-MARINE DANS LA RADE DE BREST
155
La partie orientale de la Rade de Brest comprend des bancs peu profonds (0-10 m). et des valltes sous-marines atteignant jusqu'h 30 m sous les plus basses mers. Les vagues y sont faibles, mais les courants de m a d e sont sensibles dans la partie axiale. Les stdiments sont trks calcaires, surtout dans leur fraction grossikre, beaucoup rnoins d a m leur fraction fine; le carbonate de calcium est fourni ii peu pres exclusivement par du Lithotiiamniwn cdrareum et pas des dtbris coquilliers; mais le premier est peu reprisente dans les valltes profondes, oh les conditions de vie ne lui sont pas favorables. Les elements noii organogenes sont t r b peu nombreux dans la fraction grossiere. Les stdiments sont htttrometriques, comprenant ii la fois des tltnients grossiers, moyens et fins. 11s presentent des differences locales, qui s'expliquent par la plus ou moins grande force des courants de maree: plus grossiers d a m les vallies sousmarines et dans le nord, ils sont plus fins d a m le sud. Ces sediments sont caracteristiques d'un niilieu d'eaux peu profondes intermidiaire entre les estuaires et les eaux ouvertes sur le large.
SUMMARY
The eastern part of the Rade de Brest comprises shoals (0-10 m depth) and submarine valleys, with maximum depths of 30 m below the level of the lowest tide. Wave action is of small intensity, but tidal currents reach high velocities, notably in the axial parts. The sediments are highly calcareous. The calcium carbonate, which is predominantly present in the coarse fraction, the fine fraction containing much less of it, is almost exclusively supplied by Lithothamnium calcareum and by shell debris. Little Litliothamnium material is found in the deep valleys where conditions are unfavourable for its growth. Inorganic elements are very scarce in the coarse fraction. The sediments show poor sorting of grain sizes, and contain elements of coarse, medium and fine size grades. They show local variations, which can be explained by differences in strength of the tidal currents: coarser material in the submarine valleys and in the north, and finer material in the south. The deposits are typical for a shallow water environment, intermediate between estuaries and the open sea.
BTBLlOGRAPHlE
BERTHOIS, L. et GUILCHER. A., 1959. Les Bancs de Saint-Marc et du Moulin-Blanc (Rade de Brest), et remarques sur la stdimentation du maerl (Lithnthunminrn culcurerm7). Cuhiers Oriunqy., 1 1 : 13-23, COLLIN. L., 1921. Geologie probable du fond de la Rade de Brest. Bull. Sor. Ciol. MinPrul. Bretape, 2 : 354-372. P., ANCRAND, J . P. et GALLOY, P., 1957. Les cordons littoraux de la Rade GUILCHER, A., VALLANTIN, de Brest. Bull. ComitP Ociunog. I?tudeles C&s, 9 : 21-54. GuiLcHm, A. et PRULEAU,M., 1962. Morphologie et skdimentologie sousmarines de la partie orientale de la Rade de Brest. Coni. Truv. Hisr. Sci., Bull. Sect. GPopruph., 75, sous presse.
156
A. GUILCHER
SHEPARD, F. P., 1954. Nomenclature based on sand-silt-clay ratios. J. Sediment. Petrol., 24 : 151-158. VACHW, A., 1919. La Rade de Brest et ses abords, essai d'interpretation morphogenique. Ann. Gdograph., 28 ; 177-207.
LIASSlC SEDIMENTARY CYCLES I N WESTERN EUROPE AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO CHANGES IN SEA LEVEL A. HALLAM
INTRODUCTION
One does not tiorinally associate the west European Lias with absorbing problems of cyclic sedimentation. Admittedly the development of cycles is neither so spectacular nor common as in, say, the Upper Carboniferous coal measures, but the Lias possesses the inconiparable advantage of a rich ammonite sequence, which allows for extremely refined correlation. This means that one can often compare sediiiientary environments over vast distances for very restricted intervals of time. and has led to results of considerable interest which could well have general application.
ERACHIOPODS. ROBUST P E L E C Y P O D S , ECHINODERM DEBRIS. REEF CORALS
INTERMEDIATE FAUNA
AMMONITES FRAGILE PELLCYPCDS
(1
C13y
Laminated shale
Fig.1. Diagrammatic illustration of a complete limestone-clay cycle of Kliipfelian type, and its equivalent in a sandstone-clay succession. The laminated shale and oolite are additions to Kliipfel's scheme.
158
A. HALLAM
The germinal idea i n the present work has been provided by the German geologist KLUPFEL ( I 9 17, 1920), whose study of the Lias of Lorraine shows an admirable combination of insight and meticulous observation. Kliipfel perceived a regular cyclic alternation in the limestone and clay succession of the Lias and Dogger. His complete cycle b-gitis with a clay containing a comparatively sparse fauna of ammonites and thin-shelled p-lecypods. This passes up gradually into more calcareous beds and eventually into a compact limestone with robust pelecypods, corals etc. At the top is a distinctive “Dachbank” or roofbed, which is capped by an erosion surface (Emersionsfliiche) marked by organic borings and incrustations. Slow deposition of the roofbed is signified by an abundance of phosphate and bone fragments, driftwood and shells. Directly above the roofbed there may be a layer of phosphatic nodules and incrusted pebbles, seemingly derived from the underlying limestone. The transition to clay of the overlying cycle is generally sudden (Fig.1). A sandy variant of the Kliipfelian cycle is also illustrated in Fig. 1. Kliipfel attributed the formation of his cyclic sequence to progressive shallowing of the sea followed by comparatively sudden deepening consequent upon regional epeirogenic movements of the sea floor, a seemingly plausible interpretation supported 1925; H E t D o R N , 1928; SOLL, 1957). In my own by other German geologists (FREBOLD, investigations on the Lias I have been intrigued to find cyclic sequences in Britain closely comparable with those described by K L U P F E L (1917) and have been led to pursue them laterally in the hope of learning more about the underlying mechanism.
LATERAL CHANGES OF FACIES
Any attempt to elucidate the problems of cyclic sedimentation by comparative study i n different regions obviously depends upon a thorough understanding of the variolrs environments of deposition. In the Lias of western Europe marine sedimcntation can be related to a series of basins and swells (Fig.2). Basins are regions of comparative downwarping characterised generally by thick, more or less uninterrupted clay sequences. Swells are topographic highs (either isolated marine shoals or land margins) over which sedimentation was slow. They are usually signified by thin calcareous or sandy deposits with frequent erosional breaks. The different environments of deposition may be treated in more detail with reference to the model illustrated in Fig.2a. Steady subsidence in the land-locked basin A ensures regular sedimentation in quiet water which, because of lack of renewal, is anaerobic below what is termed here the limit of oxygen availability. In consequence the sediments in the deepest parts of the basin lack a normal bottom fauna and are rich in bituminous matter, which marks out a very fine lamination probably annual in origin. Passing upslope towards the shallower reaches of the basin, but still below wave base, inorganic precipitation of calcium carbonate becomes increasingly important as terrigenous sedimentation declines and the waters become warmer, so that deposits become increasingly calcareous though remaining fine-grained. Benthonic organisms flourish above the limit of oxygen avail-
RELATION OF LIASSIC SEDIMENTARY CYCLES TO SEA LEVEL CHANGES
159
a
A
b
F i g 2 The effect of sea level changes on Liassic environments. Full explanation in text. Ornamentasea level: W.B. = wave base; L.O. V. = limit of oxygen availability. No tion as in Fig.1. S.L. quantitative significance is implied in the spacing of these three levels. 1
ability and destroy any lamination originally present. On the swell B, comparatively resistant to downwarping and isolated from substantial terrigenous influx by a zone of deeper water C,sedimentation is comparatively slight. Above wave base finer material is winnowed away, leaving little but ooliths and skeletal carbonate. The shallow near-shore basin C suffers less downwarping than A and never reaches the limit of oxygen availability. It is constantly fed by a rich supply of sediment from the land D, towards which the bottom deposits become increasingly silty and, above wave base, sandy. The sandy deposits are characteristically well sorted medium grained and cross-bedded, having been reworked from deltaic distributaries by tidal and longshore currents and waves. Though the basin is never deep the intense sedimentation from the
160
A. H A L L A M
neighbouring land ensures a high degree of dilution of precipitated calcium carbonate and calcareous muds rarely form. At certain times and places, for reasons still poorly understood, the seas may become enriched in iron, with the consequent formation of oolitic ironstones above and sideritic and chamositic niudstones below wave base instead of oolitic limestones and calcilutites respectively. I n off-shore waters the transition from shale to liniestone is nornially accomplished via an intermediate zone of alternating niarls and argillaceous calcilutites. These minor cycles are thought to be the combined result of minor oscillations of some primary factor (climate or depth of sea) and rhythmic segregation during early diagenesis. Most regional facies variations within the Lias can readily be accommodated within the framework of this model, which also provides the key to the understanding of cyclic variations in the vertical succession. It has been possible, by using these environmental criteria, to demonstrate that Kliipfelian cycles in Britain, Germany and northern France are the local expressions of extremely widespread and essentially synchronous variations i n depth of sea which seen1 to have been independent of a complex pattern of basinsand swells (HALLAM,1961). This fact suggests that the underlying control may have been the eustatic rise and fall of sea level rather than local epeirogenic movements.
EUSTATIC CONTROL
Let us return to Fig.2. Fig.2b illustrates the consequence of a eustatic rise while Fig. 3c shows a lowering of sea level. In the first case a transgression over the land will be accompanied bya shiftingof sedimentary zones so that deeper water facies will come to lie on shallower. Conversely a lowering of sea level will result i n a regression and a replacement of deeper by shallower water facies. accompanied perhaps by erosion over the emergent swells. This is all simple and obvious but it should be borne i n mind that the sedimentary changes will not be equally pronounced in all environments. As clays and niarls may be deposited over a considerable range i n depth a change i n sea level may have little to no effect on the sedimentation in a given locality. If a mud zone is brought above wave base for a brief period without the opportunity of further sedimentation the only record of the event may be a thin band of winnowed and disarticulated shells. High on a swell the only significant disturbance may be an erosional break within an otherwise uniform sequence of limestone. To prove beyond reasonable doubt the operation of eustatic control, it is necessary not merely to correlate likely changes of sea level in the same sense at particular!iorizoiis but also to relate them to major transgressions and regressions which affected different continents, so ruling out the possibility of local tectonic control. This is not an easy undertaking at present since we lack fine stratigraphic detail in most area< outside Europe. Furthermore, local epeirogenic movements can complicate the picture. and the evidence for transgressions over swells may often have been all but destroyed by peneconternporaneous erosion. There is an illuminating instance of this
RELATION OF LIASSIC SEDIMENTARY CYCLES TO SEA LEVEL CHANGES
161
near Caen in Normandy, where a Domerian succession rests upon the Palaeozoic massif, but pockets of shells within fissures on the old land surface are of Carixian age (RIOULT,1958), evidence that could easily have been missed in any but a meticulous survey . Nevertheless there is already good evidence in at least two cases of extensive marine transgressions coinciding with a change to deeper water facies within areas of marine deposition. Domerian-Toarcian The change from the Middle- to Upper Lias from Britain to Germany is perhaps the most striking in the whole of the Lower Jurassic, almost everywhere a series of shallow water sandstones, oolitic limestones and ironstones and shell limestones being directly succeeded by deeper water shales. Especially striking, the Falcifer Zone (Lower Toarcian) is represented over a vast area by finely laminated bituminous shales suggestive of deep water within an extensive land-locked sea. A change of this character is not confined to the northwestern and central part of the continent but extends southwards at least as far as the Jura Mountains (FRANK,1930) and the Aquitaine Basin (DUBAR,1925). Evidence of Lower Toarcian transgressions over old land masses and swells is present i n southwest England (KELLAWAY and WELCH,1948), the flanks of the Armorican Massif (BIGOT,1930; GABILLY, 1961) and possibly the old Vindelician Massif in Switzerland where, however, the oldest proved transgressive deposits (at Vattis) are of Bifrons age (TRUMPY,1949). At any rate the deposition of the Middle Lias of this region was followed by a period of widespread emergence (TRUMPY,1952). More significantly, there is transgressive Lower Toarcian in the Donetz Basin in Russia and over a huge region extending from Arabia to East Africa and Madagascar (ARKELL, 19%). In both areas the age of the oldest transgressive deposits corresponds with the probable time of deepest water (Falcifer Zone) in Europe. There was also an extensive Lower Toarcian transgression over the western and northern parts of the Canadian Shield, with the earliest deposits of Fulcifer or Bifrons age (FREBOLD, 1957, 1960). Sinmurian-Carisian Though the change is usually less striking than in the previous example there is evidence of the commencement of a new sedimentary cycle in many parts of northwestern Europe at the beginning of the Carixian or Lower Pliensbachian (HALLAM, 1961), as also in the Helvetic Alps (TRUMPY,1949). This coincides with the time (Jamesorzi Zone) of an extremely widespread transgression, over the old land mass that extended from southeastern England to the Ardennes (MELVILLE, 1961; HALLAM, 1961), northern Europe (TROEDSSON, 1951) and East Greenland (DONOVAN, 1957), apparently also in Basse Provence, Aquitaine and the Pyrenees (DUBAR, 1925; LECALVEZ and LEFAVRAISRAYMOND, 1961), where the early Carixian sea returned after extensive end-Sine-
162
A . HALLAM
muri..i:i emergence. The oldest dated rocks of the important transgression over the Arniorican Massif are dated as Zbes Zone (BIGOT, 1930) but the sea could well have started to advance in Jarnesoni Zone times. Altogether a total of eleven stratigraphic units corresponding locally with more or less complete Kliipfelian cycles has been recognised in northwestern Europe (HALLAM, 1961) but so far there is inadequate evidence to prove that these all signify the operation of eustatic movements, though the balance of probability favours this alternative. There are already quite reasonable grounds, however, for believing that widespread transgressions took place i n the Hettangian, Lower Sinemurian and Lower Domerian.
THE INFLUENCE OF REGIONAL EPEIROGENY
The eustatic changes themselves are doubtless the consequence of epeirogenic movements in both positive and negative senses in the ocean basins, but we have so far neglected the influence of local movements within Europe. It is generally accepted that while the basins have been subjected to more or less continued downwarping the intervening land masses have undergone periodic uplift. I n the first place this may help to explain the comparative constancy of palaeogeography throughout the Lias in Europe, with only limited transgressions for the most part because uplift of the land would act in opposition to rise of sea level. Secondly, it may help to account for the characteristic asymmetry of the sedimentary cycles. At first glance the abrupt transition at the top of a cycle from limestones and sandstones to clay suggests a comparatively sudden deepening of the sea following a gradual sliallowing. However, subsidence of the basins and their margins, where most of the deposition took place, would accentuate the change due to eustatic rise. Moreover, the concomitant retreat of shorelines would probably serve to reduce the supply of sediment from the land so that the early, transgressive phase of a cycle sho~ildnormally be signified by condensed beds (ALLEN, 1959). This seems frequently to be the case, with the base of a given cycle being marked by a layer of phosphatic nodules, glauconite and/or worn and broken shells (Fig.1). Hence the positive and negative movements of sea level may well have taken place at similar speeds. Intracontinental uplifts should have strictly local effects on the sedimentation in contrast to the more extensive though possibly milder results of eustatic movements. Thus regional uplift became important in Britain only towards the end of the Lias, as evidenced by the diachronous sand formations in the Upper Lias of southwestern England and the irregular and local pre-Bajocian warping and erosion in the Midlands and Yorkshire where several ammonite zones disappear below the Dogger within the distance of a few miles.
RELATION OF LIASSIC SEDIMENTARY CYCLES TO SEA LEVEL CHANGES
163
RELATIONSHIP WITH LIASSIC COAL MEASURE CYCLES
As the familiar Upper Carboniferous cyclothems have been related by several people
to eustatic movements (WELLS, 1961) considerable interest attaches to the presence of Rhaeto-Liassic coal measures in southern Sweden. TROEDSSON (1 95 1) has described a cyclic sequence of non-marine sandstones, clays and coals and partly marine or brackish water pelecypod beds embracing the Rhaetic (three cycles) and Hettangian (Helsingborg Stage - nine cycles). This pattern of sedimentation was brought to an end by a major marine transgression in the Lower Sinemurian, when the first ammonites entered the area. These ammonites include species of Arniorerus, Agussireras, Euagassiceras together with an arietitid probably related to Corotiiceras reynesi (SPATH), which indicate a lower Sernicostcitirrn Zone age. This is highly significant, since it corresponds precisely with a marine transgression across the North Sea, in western Scotland, and the beginning of a new marine sedinientary cycle elsewhere. This is unfortunately the only exact correlation that can be made with the marine successions in western Europe, but it is clear that Troedsson’s twelve cycles must iiiore or less correspond with only four of the cyclic units I have recognised. It seems to follow either that the coal measure cycles have been controlled by additional, minor Buctuatioiis of sea level or that they are at least partly the result of some local factor.
CORRELATION WITH FAUNAL CHANGE
That the Liassic cyclic boundaries correlate with important changes in the ammonite succession has long been recogiiised (KLUPFEL, I9 17; FREBOLD, 1924). Remarkably similar cycles in the Upper Jurassic and Cretaceous of Switzerland (FICHTER, 1934) are also related to faunal breaks. I have been able to extend these conclusions by demonstrating a detailed correlation overwide areas between sedimentary boundaries reflecting changes in depth of sea and evolutionary and migrational changes in ammonite genera through the whole of the Lias. The important eustatically controlled sedimentary changes discussed in this paper both correlate with significant changes in the fauna as a whole. It is especially interesting that the phase of widespread bathyal conditions i n the Lower Toarciaii corresponds with the disappearance (probably by extinction) of almost the whole invertebrate fauna, which was followed in the later Toarcian by a repopulation of species with Middle Jurassic affinities.
SUMMARY
Taking as a starting point a characteristic asymmetrical clay-limestone cycle widely developed in northwestern Europe the sedimentary evidence for periodic and extensive changes in depth of sea is outlined. A model of marine environments is developed and criteria for the recognition of eustatic changes proposed. Evidence is put forward to
164
A . HALLAM
suggest that on at least two occasions a widespread and essentially synchronous deepening of the sea in Europe coincided with an extensive marine transgression over several continents, indicating the operation of eustatic control. Discussion follows on the complicating effect of regional epeirogeny and an explanation of the asymmetry of the cycles is given in terms of the effect of this factor combined with variation in sediment supply controlled by changing sea level. The possible relationship with coal measure cycles in Sweden is briefly outlined and a correlation of the marine cycles with the invertebrate fauna noted. REFERENCES
ALLEN,P., 1959. The Wealden environment: Anglo-Paris Basin. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London, Ser. B, 242 : 283-346. ARKELL, W. J., 1956. Jurassic Geolo,ry ofthe World. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, London, 757 pp. BIGOT,A., 1930. Sketch of the geology of Lower Normandy. Proc. Geologists’ Assoc. Engl., 41 : 363-395. DONOVAN, D. T., 1957. The Jurassic and Cretaceous systems in eastern Greenland. Medd. Groenlnnd, 155 (4) : 214 pp. DUBAR, G., 1925. etudes sur le Lias des Pyrtntes franCaises. Mgm. Soc. GPol. Nord, 9 : 332 pp. FICHTER, H. J., 1934. Geologie der Bauen-Brisen-Kette an1 Vierwaldstattersee und die zyklische Gliederung der Kreideund des Malm der helvetischen Decken. Beitr. Geol. Karte Schweiz.69 : 128 pp. FRANK. M., 1930. Beitrage zur vergleichenden Stratigraphie und Bildungsgeschichte der Trias-LianSedimente im alpin-germanischen Grenzgebiet der Schweiz. NfwesJahrb. Mineral. Ceol. Paliiontol., Abt. B, 64 32-25, FREBOLD, H., 1924. Ammonitenzonen und Sediiiientationszyklen und ihre Beziehung zueinander. Zentr. Mineral. Grol. Puliiontol., 1924: 3 13-320. FREBOLD, H., 1925. Ueber cyklische Meerf,ssedirrrentotion.Leipzig. FREBOLD, H., 1957. The Jurassic Fernie Group in the Canadian Rocky Mountains and Foothills. Mem. Geol. Surv. Con., 287 : 197 pp. FREBOLD,H., 1960. The Jurassic faunas of the Canadian Arctic: Lower Jurassic and lowermost Middle Jurassic ammonites. Bull. Geol. Surv. Can.,59 : 33 pp. GABILLY, J., 1961. Stratigraphie et paltogtographie du Lias dans le detroit Poitevin. Dans: J. ROGER (,Rtdacterrr),Colloqire sur le Lias en France, ChambPry, 1960 - Cornpt. Rend. Soc. Savantes, 85 : 475486. HALLAM, A., 1961. Cyclothenis. transgressions and faunal change in the Lias of northwest Europe. Trans. Edinbiryh Geol. Soc., 18 : 125-174. HEIDORN,F., 1928. Paliogeographisch-tektonische Untersuchungen im Lias zeta von Nordwestdeutschland. N e w s Juhrb. Mineral. Geol. Palaontol., Abt. B, 59 : 117-244. KELLAWAY, G . A. and WELCH,F. B. A.. 1948. British Regional Geology: Bristol and Gloucester District., 2 ed. H. M. Stat. Office, London, 91 pp. KLUPFEL, W., 1917. Uber die Sedimente der Flachsee in1 Lothringer Jura. Ceol. Rundschau, 7 : 97-109. KLUPFEL, W., 1920. Der Lothringer Jura. I. Lias. Jahrb. Preuss. Ceol. Lanrlesanst., 39 : 165-372. LE CALVEZ,Y . et LEFAVRAIS-RAYMOND, A,, 1961. Le Charmouthien du Loth. Dans: J. ROGER Savantes, 85 :793-802. (Rtdacteur), ColloqiresrrrLiasc.nFrance, ChanrbPry,.l960- Compt. Rend. SOC. MELVILLE, R. V., 1961. In:Surnm. Pro$r. Geol. Surv. G t . Brit. 1960, p. 52. RIOULT,M., 1958. Le Lias de Feugerolles-sur-Orne (Calvados). Bull. Soc. Linnt;enne Normaiidie, 9 : 3540. SOLL,H.. 1957. Stratigraphie und Ammonitenfauna des mittleren und oberen Lias (Lotharingien) in Mittel-Wiirttemberg. G a l . Jahrb., 72 : 367426. G., 1951. On the Hoganas Series of Sweden. Lunds Univ. Arsskr., Avd. 2,47 : 268 pp. TROEDSSON, TRUMPY, R., 1949. Der Lias der Glarner Alpen. Denkschr. Schweiz. Naturforsch. Ges., 79 : 1-192. TRUMPY, R., 1952. Der Nordrand der Liasischen Tethys in den schweizer Alpen. Grol. Rundschau, 40 : 239-242. WELLS,A. J., 1961. Cyclic sedimentation: a review. Geol. Mag., 97 : 389403.
LAGOON SEDIMENTS IN GREENLAND K. HANSEN Gatnineltofiqyade 16,Copenhagen (Deriniark)
East of the village Godhavn on the south coast of the Island of Disco in North Creenland is a lagoon separated from the sea by a barrier beach of dark grey sand (Fig.]). The lagoon is 270 m long, 1 10 m wide, 1.5 m deep and has an area of 2.24 hectares. It is connected with the sea by a 100 m long channel. Two brooks enter the lagoon on the north coast. The eastern brook dries up during the summer, the other one has a very large discharge throughout the whole year (PORSILD,1925). The tide ruiis westward along the south coast of Disco, and shows a pronounced difference in amplitude of the two oscillations of each day. The amplitude of the large tide is 2.3 m at spring tide and 0.4 m at neap tide. The small tide has the more constant amplitude of 0.4 m (RIIS-CARSTENSEN, 1948). During winter the Disco Bay is covered with ice as far out as a line from Godhavn to Egedesminde. When the winter ice disappears (in the last part of May) a current system develops, running eastward along the south coast of the bay and westward along the south coast of Disco. The country north and west of the lagoon consists of gneissic rocks. East of the lagoon is a low plain, bounded on the north by a cliff of basalt-breccia. The barrier, a sand ridge 140 m wide and 3 m high and with a steep cliff against the sea, has a sparse vegetation of Psamma areriaria. Fig.2 and Table I show the granulometric composition of the sand from this barrier. TABLE I GRANULOMETRIC COMPOSITION OF T H E S A N D FROM THE BARRIER BEACH EAST OF GODHAVN ~
~
~~
~
~
~
Md
Analysis no.
IL ~
45 1
5 20
452 453
850 640
~
P
-
520 1300 lo00
~~
~~
~
~
Q,
Q3
%
so
IL ~~
~
~~
210 720 430
~-
1.29 1.30 1.54 -
0.94 0.39 1.05 ~~-
-
Sample 451 is from the outer part of the barrier, 452 from the tidal zone on the beach and 453 from the northern part of the barrier. The sediments are all well sorted, medium-coarse sand.
166
K. HANSEN
Fig.]. The lagoon east of Godhavn, Island of Disco. The contour lines for each 2 rn show, that the surrounding land rises steeply to the north and west. The black rectangle is the arctic station of the University of Copenhagen. The numbers 448464 correspond with the granulometric analysis.
Sample 451 has 847; of the grains in the fractions 25&-1,000 p, 453 is appreciably coarser, with 63 % of the material in the fractions 5W2,OOO p and all the sand from the beach is coarser than 500 p. The sand is black or dark grey and mainly composed of basaltic material, the remainder consisting mostly of grains of gneiss and of clear, colourless quartz. The grains > 0.5 mm are strongly rounded. I n the sand from the barrier only the grains < 0.125 mm have sharp edges, but in sample 452 sharp-edged grains up to a grain size of 0.4 mm are present. The barrier also contains fist sized pebbles of basaltic rocks. The western and the northern coasts are rocky and pebbly. In the southernmost part of the lagoon two banks are present, consisting of gravel and coarse sand. The
167
LAGOON SEDIMENTS IN GREENLAND
inner side of the barrier is fringed by a broad sand flat (Watt), which at some places is covered by a thin layer of mud. Farther out, the bottom consists of compact sand. In the deeper parts of the lagoon, however, the bottom is silty and muddy. The vegetation on the flat does not seem to play any part in the sedimentation processes. Fig.3 and Table I1 show the granulometric composition of the sediments from the flat and the bottom of the lagoon. Sample 448 is sand from the flat covered by 20 cin of water at low tide. It is of nearly the same type as the sand from the barrier, having 43.4 % in the fractions 500-1,000 p and 36 % in the fractions 3W500 p. The grains consist of gneiss and basalt and only those < 0.15 mni are sharp-edged. Samples 447,449 and 450 were taken from different parts of the muddy flat. They are all strongly sandy and may be characterised as silty, fine to medium sand. The sorting is not good. In fresh condition these samples are black and soft. After drying
Fig.2. Granulometric composition of the samples from the barrier beach.
Zoo0
1000
500
100
so
20
to
4//
Fig.3. Granulometric composition of the samples from the lagoon.
I68
K. HANSEN
they form small coherent lumps of a markedly fine sandy appearance and of a dirty grey colour. The fine fractions, < 63 p, are rich in diatom frustules. Sample 455 is from a special kind of sediment. In fresh state it is bluish-black, soft and soapy; dried, it forms dirty yellow, very light lumps which remind one of diatom earth. Further examination shows that the fine fractions, < 62 p, predominantly consist of diatom frustules and that there is no clay mineral material at all. The content of TABLE I1 GRANULOMETRIC COMPOSITION OF THE SEDlMENTS FROM THE LAGOON EAST OF GODHAVN
_ _-~
~
Analysis
Md
Q3
Q,
no.
!*
I*
EL
~~
447 448 449 450 455 464
140 510 230 440 11.5 12.5
160 725 500 725 36 34
so
62
4
o/ /I1
Yo
63.3 98.5 60.0 74.0 18.5 9.7
5.9
~
30 390 18 60 6 9
3.47 1.37 5.75 3.49 2.25 1.94
0.74 1.04 0.41 0.47 1.28 1.96
0.1 4.8 12.5 16.7
organic matter (loss of ignition) is 17.3 %, with 5.65 % C and 0.70 % N , which means that nearly the whole part of the fine fractions is organogenic. Sample 464 was taken in the middle of the lagoon at a depth of 1.30 m. In fresh condition it is soft and black,