Design and Use of Serious Games
International Series on
INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS, CONTROL, AND AUTOMATION: SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING VOLUME 37
Editor Professor S. G. Tzafestas, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Editorial Advisory Board Professor P. Antsaklis, University of Notre Dame, IN, U.S.A. Professor P. Borne, Ecole Centrale de Lille, France Professor D. G. Caldwell, University of Salford, U.K. Professor C. S. Chen, University of Akron, Ohio, U.S.A. Professor T. Fukuda, Nagoya University, Japan Professor F. Harashima, University of Tokyo, Japan Professor S. Monaco, University La Sapienza, Rome, Italy Professor G. Schmidt, Technical University of Munich, Germany Professor N. K. Sinha, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Professor D. Tabak, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, U.S.A. Professor K. Valavanis, University of Southern Louisiana, Lafayette, U.S.A. Professor S. G. Tzafestas, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
For other titles published in this series, go to www.springer.com/series/6259
Marja Kankaanranta • Pekka Neittaanmäki
Design and Use of Serious Games
Pekka Neittaanmäki University of Jyväskylä Dept. Mathematical Information Technology Fl-40351 Jyväskylä Finland
Marja Kankaanranta University of Jyväskylä Institute for Educational Research Fl-40014 Jyväskylä Finland
ISBN: 978-1-4020-9495-8
e-ISBN: 978-1-4020-9496-5
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008939845 © Springer Science+Business Media, B.V. 2009 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper 987654321 springer.com
Preface
During the last few years, a new area of creative media industry, namely Serious Games, has started to emerge around the world. The term serious games has become more popular for example in the fields of education, business, welfare and safety. Despite this, there has been no single definition of serious games. A key question, what the concept itself means, has stayed unsolved though most have agreed on a definition that serious games are games or game-like interactive systems developed with game technology and design principles for a primary purpose other than pure entertainment. In this book, serious games are understood as games which aim at providing an engaging, self-reinforcing context in which to motivate and educate the players. Serious games can be of any genre, use any game technology, and be developed for any platform. They can be entertaining, but usually they teach the user something. The central aim of serious games is to raise quality of life and well-being. As part of interactive media industry, the serious games field focuses on designing and using digital games for real-life purposes and for the everyday life of citizens in information societies. The field of serious games focuses on such areas as education, business, welfare, military, traffic, safety, travelling and tourism. This book focuses on the field of serious games from various aspects. The book contains 13 papers and four aspects of serious games: game production, learning, the social point of view, and technical applications. Part I is devoted to game production and it consists of four articles. The first article presents three approaches towards teaching game production. The second article describes the design and architecture of a cave based firefighter training game. The human-centered design process of a location-based sport game Fitness Adventure is presented in the third article. In the last article of this part, children’s involvement in the design of two game-based learning environments is discussed. Part II addresses topics related to learning: language learning and the use of commercial games in instruction. The first article presents a framework for development and analysis of an educational design for a platform used for teaching English as a foreign language in primary schools. The second article continues in the field of language learning. It discusses experiences from designing a role-playing game for language learning and explores competence requirements and cooperation required from the development team. The other two articles in this part strive to understand and look for the ways of using commercial games also for purposes of learning. In the third article, the attitudes and experiences of Finnish school teachers towards commercial educational games are portrayed. The fourth article examines introduction of social simulation videogame as an educational tool in classrooms. The focus is on the activities and conversations among teacher, children and researchers. v
vi
Preface
Part III is dedicated to the social point of view. This part consists of articles on playing together with the camera of a mobile device, social networks in gaming, and a multiplayer interface for a computer-augmented learning game. The first article presents an approach to a multiplayer mobile game. It discusses how an integrated camera would be used to support communication and collaboration in multiplayer mobile games. The second article considers social networks in gaming and describes a study on social networks built during the prerelease campaign of the AnimalClass game series. The last article of this part presents a multiplayer interface for a computer-augmented learning game. Part IV is devoted to technical applications of serious games – a driving game and a game-like tool for process simulation and analysis. Firstly, a noncommercial driving game which became a serious tool in the research of driver fatigue is presented. After that, the last article of the book introduces a game-like tool for visual process simulation and analysis. Material consists of selected papers or game presentations from Serious Games conference organized by Agora Game Laboratory of University of Jyväskylä in February 2008. Additional material has been included in order to broaden the scope of the volume. Special acknowledgements are due to Terhi Tuukkanen from University of Jyväskylä for her most constructive role in the various stages of this project. We would also like to express our gratitude to the reviewers of the papers, as well as all those involved in the publication process. Finally we want to thank Springer Publishing house for flexible and efficient collaboration. Jyväskylä, September 2008
Marja Kankaanranta Pekka Neittaanmäki
Contents
Part I Game Production Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production Tuomas Mäkilä, Harri Hakonen, Jouni Smed, Andy Best
3
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game Mikael Lebram, Per Backlund, Henrik Engström, Mikael Johannesson
19
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games: User’s Experiences of a Fitness Adventure Prototype Antti Väätänen, Jaana Leikas
33
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments: Cases Talarius and Virtual Peatland Tuula Nousiainen
49
Part II Learning Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning – a Framework for Development and Analysis Bente Meyer, Birgitte Holm Sørensen
69
Comptence Complexity and Obvious Learning: Experience from Developing a Language Learning Game Ellen Brox, Audun Heggelund, Gunn Evertsen
83
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers Towards Commercial Educational Games Minna Klemetti, Olli Taimisto, Paula Karppinen
97
Using Videogames as Educational Tools: Building Bridges Between Commercial and Serious Games Pilar Lacasa, Laura Méndez, Rut Martínez
vii
107
viii Contents
Part III Social Perspective Let’s Play Together with the Camera of Your Mobile Device Ekaterina Kuts, Carolina Islas-Sedano, Erkki Sutinen
127
AnimalClass: Social Networks in Gaming Harri Ketamo, Marko Suominen
143
Multiplayer Interface for a Computer-Augmented Learning Game Ari Putkonen, Markus Forstén
155
Part IV Technical Applications RACER: A Non-Commercial Driving Game which Became a Serious Tool in the Research of Driver Fatigue Narciso González, Igor Kalyakin, Heikki Lyytinen
171
VIPROSA – Game-like Tool for Visual Process Simulation and Analysis Tapani N. Liukkonen
185
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production Tuomas Mäkilä1, Harri Hakonen1, Jouni Smed1 and Andy Best2 1) Department of Information Technology, University of Turku; FI-20014 University of Turku, Finland
[email protected] 2) Digital Arts, Turku University of Applied Sciences; FI-20520 Turku, Finland
[email protected]
Abstract: Teaching game production benefits computer science and engineering students, because game applications are usually complex interactive real-time systems, which are non-trivial to implement. Moreover, game production has a multi-disciplinary nature, because – in addition to software development – a game production process can include areas such as commercialization issues, game design, graphics design and implementation, sound engineering, level design, and story design. This kind of project environment teaches the development team to work and communicate efficiently. Having organized a variety of game production project courses in the Department of Information Technology in the University of Turku the students have implemented complete computer games or game proto-types. Our focus has been on teaching game related algorithms, software technologies and software engineering aspects of game production. We have used three different teaching approaches to organize the courses: (1) the traditional home assignment model where the students take full responsibility of organizing the production, (2) research seminars where the teachers act as direct customers for the production, and (3) intensive courses where the teachers participate in the production as coaches and mentors. In this presentation, we describe the three different teaching approaches, present them as formal process models, and compare them to commercial game production processes. Additionally, we consider the multidisciplinary nature of game production and discuss how the issue can be taken into consideration in a study environment where the students are mainly technology oriented.
1 Introduction to Game Production This article discusses how game production can be used as a teaching tool in various different situations and what requirements different types of course set to the 3 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 3–18. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
4
T. Mäkilä et al.
production process. The article is based on the case studies of three different course types held by the authors. All have utilized game production as a teaching tool. The qualitative aspects of the cases are analyzed and compared. The goal of game production is to produce fully-working game products. Game production is a discipline that builds on the tradition and the methodologies of project management, software engineering and cultural productions. The game production life-cycle defines the basic activities which have to be accomplished before a game idea actualizes into a working game product. Although every game and every production team has its own ways of working, some generic models for game production life-cycle activities have been proposed (game production process, game production hand-book).
Fig. 1. Comparison between two game production models (Manninen et al. 2006) (Chandler 2006) and one software product development model (Hohmann 2003). The development phases are described on the upper half and more detailed production phase steps on the lower half.
If we compare game production models to the generic software product development model we find notable similarities (Figure 1). All models have a starting or a pre-production phase when a (game) product idea is defined and its feasibility is evaluated from the production and business viewpoint, a production phase when the actual product is developed, a quality assurance phase when the final quality of the product is tested, and a release phase when the project is wrapped up and the product is released to the customer. Manninen et al. (2006) address the postrelease activities, e.g. bug-fixes and user support, which are a natural part of the product life-cycle.
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
5
The development and production activities are also quite similar between the game production models and the software product development model. The multidisciplinary nature of game production forms the greatest difference. While the activities in the software product development model focus solely on the software development and testing, the game production activities include the cooperative work of artists, animators, game designers, level designers, musicians, and programmers. Although production modes and best practices exist, surprisingly many game production projects do not utilize well-known project management practices. Some of these productions still manage to be highly successful (Larsen 2002). This shows that there is not one right way to do or teach game production, but also that production training has its place.
2 Three Perspectives to Computer Games Computer game research and education includes three academic perspectives depicted in Figure 2. The Humanistic perspective is concerned with how a game affects and changes the users, gaming communities, other social networks, and society at large. The Business perspective is concerned with the economics around computer games. As an example, this includes issues of competing in the marketplace, productization, and investment strategies. The Construction perspective deals with the actual making of an executable computer game.
Fig. 2. Three perspectives that affect the game production process.
6
T. Mäkilä et al.
Although each of the perspectives provides essential topics for study, in this paper we focus on the construction perspective. In other words, our viewpoint is the constructional aspects of software development in the domain of computer games. This has four sub-perspectives: 1. Game design: What is the intended end-user experience and what game elements contribute to it? 2. Content creation: What are the entertainment artefacts and functionalities and how they are represented? 3. Game programming: How to implement the software mechanisms that serve the content creation so that the game design goals are achieved? 4. Software construction: How to weave the digital game components into the executable game? These perspectives target product design and development and they categorize the main artistic and technical concerns in the making of computer games. Let us consider how the perspectives relate to one another. Game design encapsulates the vision, intention, concept and theme of a game. For example, it includes activities for designing the back-stories, composing the opposing forces and major roles, and developing the synthetic participants, such as in-game characters, sidekicks, and deus ex machina. The game design is a creative process but it is governed by the rules of play, since we need an outcome that fulfils the definition of a game. Nowadays, there are high demands on the aesthetics, end-user experience, and re-playability of a game. To meet these challenges cost-effectively the game design is implemented on two fronts at the same time. Simply put, the intended features of the game can be divided into art and technology. The ‘art’ is entertainment content, which is run by the technology platform. The platform requires specialized programming effort in some form even if it is purchased. These two fronts require deep expertise, and thus they form their own profession. However, these areas of expertise are not disassociated in game development, instead, one of the key challenges is how to bring them together. In other words, when making a game we have to consider, for example, programming, 3-D modelling, and animation together. The game industry has pioneered finding practices and technologies for the interaction of many disciplines, such as computer science, art and design, business, management, and productization. One can argue that game development is an expertise area in itself that connects these disciplines. Software construction involves practices and tools for integrating the art and technology assets of the game into one executable system. This is an often complex technical process that is automatized as far as possible. Because all these perspectives are present at the same time in a game, they are often developed in parallel: at first the emphasis is on the game design and gradually, as the game attributes and features become fixed, the focus moves towards
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
7
content creation and software system issues. However, it is only seldom possible to stabilize and freeze the whole game design. Thus, there must be feedback activities that evaluate and control the possible changes to the game design. This uncertainty is intrinsic to software development and it arises from the digital nature of computer programs. Especially due to different cost structures, the making of software differs considerably from the manufacturing process for physical products. In this article we identify challenges and opportunities that lie in the teaching of game production. Then we go through three cases based on different course formats we have used to teach game production. After the presentation of each of the cases we summarize the lessons learned from the course types. Lastly, we conclude our article.
3 Teaching Game Production: Opportunities and Challenges Originally, the teaching of the game production process itself has not been our main goal in any of the courses we have taught. Our curriculum has included other game related issues, such as game algorithms, artificial intelligence, object programming patterns, interactive storytelling, game design, and co-operation between artists and programmers. Since our university does not have a degree program in making games our goal is to teach the students general skills within computer science and software engineering. Even so, we constantly end up with course formats where students go through the game production cycle. The reason is that using game production as an educational format creates several opportunities: •
• • •
•
Versatile but demarcated setting. From the teachers’ point of view a game can serve as a mixing pot for various study subjects within a curriculum. Also, the project-like form of instruction shows how to distinguish and intermix the essential activities and work products. Pragmatic teaching approach. It is easier for a student to understand advanced issues connected to the game content when the students actually make the games. Higher motivation. The students are motivated by real game development; simple tic-tac-toe assignments do not intrigue the students. Visible results. A working game demonstrates the acquired knowledge, e.g., have the students made rational decisions and have they fulfilled the given requirements and specifications. Also, in a game the user features are presented more visually than in the other kinds of software products. General applicability. We claim that computer game development is one of the most challenging software product domains, and thus students also learn beneficial practices used throughout the software industry (Hakonen 2006) and in the multimedia industry in general.
8
T. Mäkilä et al.
There are also several challenges in using game production as a teaching method: Sufficient multidisciplinary teaching skills. To facilitate this extrapolation, the teacher, or the group of teachers collectively, should have profound experience on the whole computer game domain, teaching methods, and project work. • Readiness to learn. The students participating in the game development courses must be proficient at their own field of study. The digital design and art students should have traditional visual art skills as well as experience with the software tools used for digital art creation. The software developers should master programming and information system design. However, they must also be able to apply the acquired knowledge in the game domain and be ready to work in teams and to quickly learn new work practices. • Uncertainty. It is not uncommon that in advanced education the resources are scarce, the working environment is volatile, and the planned results change over time. For this reason the students must be able to cope with uncertainty and to have confidence that the topics get more understandable later. • Controlled simplification. Over-simplification of complicated and intertwined topics can lead to misconceptions and conceptual distortions that ruin the learning experience. However, to keep the project feasible and manageable we have to reduce the requirements for the teaching. Apart from getting rid of irrelevant details, we recommend that the inherent complexity of the domain knowledge is preserved. We claim that injecting more assumptions, i.e. non-volatile requirements and forces, into real-world project carries out the actual simplification. •
When game production is taught within a concrete software development project we have to know how to actually configure the project. In general, the setting of the project configuration is as follows. Before starting the project the teacher must determine what are the educational goals to be demonstrated with respect to the actual real world issues. Next, the teacher establishes the perspectives from where the selected study topics are to be approached. Then, by using hands-on experience and imagination, the teacher collects the simplifying assumptions so that the project becomes feasible without loosing the intention and the central aspects of the real world work. In our case, we select and abstract topics within computer game development. For example, the goal can be an introduction to multiplayer gaming via a local area network (LAN) and the perspective can be a construction of communication technology. From this sub-domain we can select the topic, for example, the implementation of proper balance between consistency and responsiveness for a given game. To simplify the project, we can stipulate the LAN connections are slow and have narrow bandwidth, the self-steering software team is located into one room, and the customers only want to see the alpha-release of the game with just the placeholder graphics in place. Note that although the project can be configured to be simple, the inherent complexity can be kept: the project, product, and process issues can be presented together by adjusting their balance intentionally (Hakonen et al. 2008). Consequently, the students recognize all the key expertise fields and interest groups that are concerned with game production.
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
9
4 Case 1: Traditional Assignment Course In a traditional assignment course the students form a team and solve the given problem assignment as a homework exercise. The teachers observe and monitor the development but avoid partaking in the actual work. In the software development industry this kind of arrangement is called outsourcing, and the goal of the assignment is to implement a complete computer system. To concentrate the students’ effort on the relevant issues the teachers lecture the theory behind the selected study topics beforehand. Hence, the assignment should demonstrate the practical applications of those theories. Although the course concentrates on the production phase of a game project, the preceding phases must also be taken into account. To give the students grounding for ideas each student analyses individually some existing game that fits in with the course topics. Then each student writes a game treatment that suggests the main ideas and features for the new game. These game treatment documents form the basis from where the actual game concept is developed at the beginning of the production phase. To keep project management issues simple one team consisting of three to five students runs the game production lifecycle. If more students have enrolled for the course the same assignment is given for each of the teams.
Fig. 3. The main activities of the traditional assignment course.
10
T. Mäkilä et al.
The main activities of the course type are illustrated in Figure 3. The project work can be divided into three phases: inception, construction, and conclusion. At first in the inception, the teachers prepare the assignment and the theory lectures. This activity begins with selecting the study topics, outlining the game concept, and determining the results of the pre-production phase. These three work products determine the perspective and depth of the theory issues that are tackled in the project. Then, the project setting is introduced to the students in lectures where the theoretical backgrounds are taught. To support the game production aspect the lectures should include practical guidance for solving the most crucial problems. Whereas the lectures ascertain that the students’ starting levels match the pre-requirements, presentation of the actual assignment acts as a decision point where the students either commit themselves to or drop out of the course. The presentation of the assignment is one of the key activities for the successful execution of the assignment. The assignment milestones, communication mechanisms and practices between the teachers and the students, references to guidance and extra resources, and the grading principles should be written explicitly for the students. This focuses the students’ work on the assignment and they do not have to consider the organizational details of the assignment itself. An the beginning of the course the students are taught and prepared for the forthcoming teamwork. Especially if the students already have experience in teamwork and the assignment is extensive the teachers can advise how to divide the work into sub-teams. However, the main idea of a traditional assignment course is that the students organize their own work during the more elaborated design and creation of the game. The teachers’ role is not to control how the team operates, nor how the development conflicts become resolved, or what tactical decisions are made. Thus, this is the most demanding project course format we give to our students. The teachers act as outside customers and they follow the progress through the project milestones set in the assignment. As an example, a teacher assesses the feasibility of the work plans. The teachers also provide external support on request for the project, for example, by advising, guiding, and coaching in situations that stop the project. In extreme cases, the teachers can intervene and freeze the project until the problems are analyzed and further actions are found. It should be noted that the rationale for this kind of autonomous assignment is to teach tacit knowledge about software development in teams. For example, the students should find out themselves how to take responsibility, communicate, and share know-how. From our experience, if the students have sufficient base competence and the preceding activities are effective, they do not need extensive assistance to accomplish advanced results. As with the projects in general, the assignment has a strict deadline after which the students present the game, demonstrate its features and write a post-mortem document about the project. The writing of a post-mortem from a game project is a retrospective practice where the participants list and analyze the most influential successes and failures. In addition to ending discussions the post-mortem document sums up the tactical and strategic lessons learned and it provides the teachers
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
11
feedback from the inception and construction phases. Lastly, the teachers evaluate the results and grade the students on the team level. We prefer not to evaluate each student individually because a team should be seen as one development unit; the balancing and fairness issues must be considered during the project, not after it. In principle, a student can be expelled from a project but in our experience, situations have never escalated into this.
5 Case 2: Research Laboratory Course In a research laboratory course the students examine a scientific problem alongside the teachers, work on a practical solution to it, and report the results of the work to the whole class. Usually, the course is at an advanced level because it requires the participants to have pragmatic skills of collaboration and knowledge acquiring methods. In the software development industry similar work is carried out in customer-on-site projects. This course format has two goals. Firstly, the students learn about the newest scientific topics and they have hands-on training into scientific work. Secondly, the teachers, who are also researchers, benefit from fresh ideas and possibly new solutions to the research topic. In our case this kind of cooperation has often lead on to further studies and even to joint research. The latest instance of this course we held focused on software technologies, and especially, how certain object-oriented design patterns affect the software architecture of a multiplayer game. When the research question is a specific and mainly technical one the influence of the preceding and succeeding phases of the game project can be reduced. This lessens the risk of failure, although the outcome of the project tends to stay unpredictable until the deadline. However, this also poses an educational problem because we are leaving out real-world problems concerning, for example, the launching of the project. Fortunately, the problem has adequate solutions, and as an example, it is possible to organize a separate project course without a detailed construction phase. To keep project management as simple as possible one team includes five to seven students. If more students have enrolled for the course the same problem is given for each of the teams and the teams are encouraged to balance between cooperation and friendly competition on technical and content issues. Also, if the problem turns out to have many differentiating aspects the teams can share them. The main activities of the course type are depicted in Figure 4. The project work consists of three phases: inception, cooperative construction, and conclusion. In the inception, the teachers also conduct the whole preproduction phase. At first, the teachers prepare the assignment on their research questions and this activity determines the main concerns of the project. Then, to make the experiment repeatable and to have case setting the teachers design the game concept and features. The game design is used for constraining the general research question; the idea is to have a nontrivial case example that is feasible to solve with the given resources.
12
T. Mäkilä et al.
Fig. 4. The main activities of the research laboratory course.
The assignment and the game design are presented to the students after which they commit themselves to the course. Finally, the teachers guide the students to organize the teamwork, practices, methods, and development tools. Unlike in the traditional assignment course, the inception phase can be rather informal as the research problem is well-defined. The construction phase of the pre-made game design is realized in several iterations where the teachers and the students work alongside each other. The students make decisions and construct the game mainly at the operational and tactical levels. They are responsible for software and game level design, iteration planning, system and content development, and unit testing. To aid the construction the teachers can also operate at the tactical level but they should avoid affecting the results. Instead of giving ready solutions the teachers reveal on a need-to-know basis what aspects and alternatives the students should consider. In other words, the teachers act as on-site customers who are interested in outcomes, not means. This puts the students into a situation where they have to think out proper questions and possibly find out unforeseen answers. The teachers control the strategic work by organizing frequent follow-up meetings where they verify the progress, prioritize the game features, and guide the forthcoming tasks.
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
13
The construction phase has a strict deadline after which the project proceeds to the conclusion phase. At first, the students present the game, demonstrate its features, and discuss the project in retrospect. Unlike in the traditional assignment course the teachers should write the post-mortem document because they are more experienced in reflecting scientific issues. Then, the teachers evaluate the outcomes and grade the students. Although we consider the team as one, individual grading is also possible because the iteration work has been transparent and the game design is complex enough that it leads to clearly specialized and dedicated roles. Lastly, the teachers, preferably together with the students, analyze and report the scientific results. Often, this results in other research questions, study papers, and theses.
6 Case 3: Intensive Production Course In an intensive production course the students and the teachers work together as one team to produce a computer game that demonstrates both digital art and software technology. The production goal is to create a functional game prototype in a short period of time. The project proceeds in intensive workdays of six to eight hours at one site with inter-connected computers. In the software development industry this is called as customer-as-expert project. Due to intensiveness each participant must attend all the workdays to be at the team-mates’ disposal and to keep up with the project pace. The educational goal of the course is to encourage students having dissimilar backgrounds, i.e., digital art and software technology, to work together. Also, we foster mutual learning and extending understanding of the multidisciplinary nature of game development. The main focus of the course is collaboration between the different disciplines resulting in a working computer game. This approach gives us leeway to adjust what we want to emphasize in the course without changing its format. For example, if all the participants are already familiar with the development tools of their own expertise area and skilled in versioning tools, more content creation and technological challenges can be tackled in the course. On the other hand, it is possible to emphasize the challenges in multimedia design and art by selecting ready-made technology platforms with uncomplicated scripting languages. Thus, the teachers can put the students in such a situation where they keep motivated: the students have meaningful tasks from their own discipline, but at the same time they have to understand their impact on the whole. The latter is not possible without collaboration over discipline boundaries. As with the other course types, we prefer one-team co-located projects because we want simple communication practices. Because the project has many disciplines and the teachers also work as team members, each team has a number of members with various skill-sets. To keep the number of participants between ten and twenty the students apply to the course with curriculum vitae. This also allows the teachers to plan the course adjustments, possible sub-teams, and role descriptions beforehand. From these three course types this
14
T. Mäkilä et al.
one is the most challenging for the teachers because the schedule is tight, the workdays turn sporadically into chaos that must be managed, and in-advance and on-the-fly planning have to be balanced constantly. The main activities of this course type are presented in Figure 5. The project work has three phases: inception, continuous construction, and conclusion. In the beginning of the inception the teachers prepare a preliminary schema for the course assignment and setup the infrastructure for the project. For example, we have had an intensive production course for a non-violent shooter game and for a humorous point-and-click game. The actual game idea and design are still left open. The inception ends with assignment presentation where the students are introduced to the project topics and facilities. Because the students have passed the application process they are already committed to the course. The continuous construction begins with an open debate and brainstorming on the game ideas, their possibilities and the students’ interests in them. It is important that at this stage the students form a mental bond with the game, and thus, the teachers should act only as moderators. Then, the most promising ideas are refined and among them the core game idea is selected. The actual project work iterates
Fig. 5. The main activities of the intensive production course.
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
15
the idea into a computer game. The teachers take the responsibility for project management and product level quality assurance. Their first activity is to organize teamwork, practices, methods, and development tools. Then, they coach and guide the students, verify art assets and software quality, resolve workflow conflicts, and plan and prioritize the creation process. In other words, the teachers act as on-site customers who are experts on the disciplines and actively participate in the development of the game. The students are responsible for game design and its implementation with digital art and software technology. In other words, they have to make decisions on the game creation from the operational level up to the strategic level. For example, a level designer must look after the playability and immersion of the game. The most difficult problems arise from where the disciplines are bound tightly together into one. As with the other course types the construction phase has a deadline at which the conclusion phase begins. Despite the teachers participation in the project the students present the game in the final project meeting. The relaxed atmosphere fosters open retrospective discussions and the teachers can verify their understanding about the successes and failures before writing the post-mortem document. Finally, the teachers evaluate the results and grade the students. As in the traditional assignment course we prefer to evaluate only the team as one unit because in this kind of intensive project individual work is subject to circumstances.
7 Lessons Learned from Cases Previous chapters described the main activities of the three different teaching approaches and showed the differences between the approaches. In this chapter we define the common characteristics of three approaches and summarize the key lessons learned during the courses. Lesson 1: Game production provides a natural framework for project courses. Game production provides a suitable context for project oriented courses. This is because the assignment projects done in each approach are not mock-up projects which are constructed to suite the teaching needs. Instead, game production acts as a practical framework and the pedagogical elements are injected into that. This might explain why the students are motivated to pass these courses and feel that the course setting is rather realistic. Lesson 2: Larger team sizes have to be managed. Another characteristic of game production is that productions are usually self-organizing one team projects. This might make course organization and evaluation harder when the course size increases. We have found two methods to handle the problem: 1) Divide the students into smaller teams with their own responsibilities or 2) Divide the students into smaller teams and give the same production task to each. With the latter method it is surprising that the teams always end up with completely different results.
16
T. Mäkilä et al.
Lesson 3: Course formats do not restrict what kind of games can be developed. During the courses presented in the case study the students have produced a wide variety of different games from 2D real time strategy games to 3D shooters. It must been admitted that none of the games would have met modern commercial standards, but with further development some of the games would well be equal to modern shareware or independent games. Since the majority of the students have been computer science and engineering students, the emphasis of the game development has been on the technical issues of game production. Still, some of the games have also been visually appealing. During the courses some of the student groups have been experimenting with unorthodox game concepts. It can be said that the course formats presented do not set restrictions themselves on what kind of games can be produced. Of course, the timeframe of an average university course set certain limits on what can be done and how polished the resulting games will be. Lesson 4: The assignment format can be seen as easy for the teachers but there are pitfalls to look out for. For the teachers the project courses are basically easy because the students do most of the work. Of course, the preparation of the course and the assignment have to be done well so that students can focus on the assignment work itself. In the research lab and the intensive course approaches the preparation activities can be seen as a part of the pre-production of the game and therefore these preparations directly affect the end results of the course. The teachers have to follow the students work throughout the course and coach them as needed. The success of this task depends on the activity and skills of the students. Lesson 5: Pre-production and production steps were emphasized during the projects, but the whole production cycle was done. Although the main goal of our courses has been on teaching game production related issues, not game production itself, it is important to know which parts of game production the presented approaches teach. If we compare the workflow models of each teaching approach and generic game production models, we can see that the activities of the preproduction and production phases are emphasized. However, all the most characteristic activities of game production models are included in the course structures in one way or another. The only significant part that was missing from our courses was the business aspect of game production. It can be said that the basic activities of a non-commercial small scale game project are the same as the activities of a large scale commercial game project. Only the scale is different. Therefore the previously presented teaching approaches give students a good insight into actual game production. In addition to the production phases, the taught production disciplines are another important factor to be considered. As mentioned before, basically all activities of a game production have been done in a small scale during the courses and therefore all disciplines of game production are covered, from digital arts to software technologies. The emphasis between the disciplines is adjustable via the course objectives and needs. Alas, the teachers have to set the main focus of the course and understand that the student may not have excellent skills in each necessary discipline.
Three Approaches Towards Teaching Game Production
17
Lesson 6: Game production teaches skills that can be used outside the game production domain. Yet another issue to be considered is how well the skills learned using the presented approaches can be generalized outside the domain of game production. During a game production course, software engineering students can deepen their knowledge of the software engineering issues, since the game production process resembles the general software engineering process so much. The skills obtained are also applicable to other kinds of software projects besides game production. The multidisciplinary nature of game production teaches the software engineering students that during software projects there are lots of other things to be taken into consideration other than just programming the applications. The multidisciplinary nature also makes the game production project more challenging to manage but at the same time makes concepts like project roles and release integration more concrete for the students. From this perspective it can be said that game production assignments are good all-around project management and team work practice. The comparison done between the game production models and the software product development model in the introductory chapter reveals that game production is actually a product development process rather than just a software engineering or art production process. This means that the end result of the process is a complete package which can be more easily evaluated than an individual algorithm demo or a prototype application. At the same time the starting requirements have to be set more carefully and end-user needs have to be taken into consideration throughout the process. This finding might at least partially explain other lessons presented in this chapter.
8 Conclusions In the computer game industry a production project binds together many perspectives and disciplines by inventive balancing of conflicting interests. Because the balancing decisions culminate in the game product, game creation is a holistic process. In other words, it is not possible to isolate the disciplines such as digital art and software technology assets, project activities (e.g., requirement management, risk management, budgeting, resource allocation, prioritization, quality assurance, and motivation), productization, product line management (i.e., strategic business decisions on products), and marketing from each other without losing a realistic representation of the game development. However, due to time and budget limitations game creation education cannot take into account all of these perspectives at the same time. Instead of being content with mock-up projects where some of the production perspectives are just ignored, we have identified three project schemas used in the software development industry that also suit to student projects. The traditional assignment course emphasizes game production work, the research laboratory course
18
T. Mäkilä et al.
focuses on technological design and implementation of a game, and the intensive production course weight collaboration among selected game disciplines (in our case digital art and software technology). These three case schemas demonstrate that it is possible to arrange game projects for students that have both educational goals and reflect the projects in the software industry in general. There are game production models as well as general software product development models that support this observation. The successful injection of the educational goals into the game projects is also well-founded; the details are discussed in (Hakonen et al. 2008). The three game project schemas include much software technology work because computer games are always executable programs, and hence, the software platform runs the game content. We utilize this relationship to give the project adaptations concrete form and to determine the consequences. For example, there are tried practices for estimating how much time certain software implementation work takes. From a study topic aspect the reason is that we have wide know-how on how to implement the game technicalities (Smed and Hakonen 2006). However, it is a misconception to believe that the essence of a computer game comes from technological solutions. The game must have an intriguing end-user experience (entertainment, education, or of any other kind) that is only obtained by creative content and playability. Both the teachers and the students of the Digital Arts division lead the development on this front. To sum up, the teaching of game production requires that the teachers jointly understand the practicalities of the computer game domain, education methods, software development projects in general, and the ludic values of game playing. Thus they can provide the students with an enlightening experience of, not only game production, but also general software production and modern teamworking practices.
References Chandler, H. M. (2006). The Game Production Handbook. Game Development Series, Charles River Media. Hakonen, H. (2006). Game Industry versus Software Industry: Similarities and Differences. In A. Tuominen (Ed.), New Exploratory Technologies 2006 (pp. 124–132). Salo. Hakonen, H., Mäkilä, T., Smed, J., & Best, A. (2008). Learning to Make Computer Games: An Academic Approach. TUCS Technical Report 899, Turku Centre for Computer Science, Finland. Hohmann, L. (2003). Beyond Sofware Architecture – Creating and Sustaining Winning Solutions. Addison-Wesley Signature Series, Addison-Wesley Professional. Larsen, S. (2002). Playing the Game: Managing Computer Game Development. Technical Report International Edition. Version 1.1. Blackwood Interactive. Manninen, T., Kujanpää, T., Vallius, L., Korva, T., & Koskinen, P. (2006). Game Production Process – A Preliminary Study. Technical Report v1.0. Ludocraft/ELIAS-project. Smed, J. & Hakonen, H. (2006). Algorithms and Networking for Computer Games. UK, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game Mikael Lebram, Per Backlund, Henrik Engström and Mikael Johannesson University of Skövde, School of Humanities and informatics P.O. Box 408, SE-54128 Skövde, Sweden
[email protected]
Abstract: This paper presents the architecture of a game-based training simulator environment developed in collaboration with the Swedish Rescue Services Agency (SRSA). The learning objectives for the game relates to training of firefighters for Breathing Apparatus Entry, and in particular to develop systematic search strategies. The hardware and software system is based on off-the-shelf computer components in combination with tailor made units. The game has been developed as a Half-Life 2 mod – extended to be played in a cave using 5 standard gaming PCs in a local area network. The game environment is a cave where the player is surrounded by four 80” screens giving a 360 degree view of a virtual world. Each screen is projecting a fixed-angle view of the virtual world and the player’s orientation in the virtual world corresponds to her orientation in the real world. A novel interaction model has been developed for the game in order for it to be played in the cave. The player navigates and performs game actions using course body movements which are captured through a set of sensors.
1 Introduction Simulator training is becoming more and more common and is used in a number of situations. Recently, there is a movement towards utilizing computer games and computer game technology to achieve adequate functionality for, e.g., training (Zyda 2005; Squire and Jenkins 2003; LoPiccolo 2004; Backlund et al. 2006). This effort is commonly referred to as serious games (Serious Games Initiative 2007). Even though serious games may have many applications training is considered to be a major one. Consider the following usage scenario. Steve is in training to become a firefighter. He is just about to start a simulator training session. Wearing his boots, coat and air mask he enters the cave to meet his virtual instructor. Steve receives his mission via the air mask radio unit. He is instructed to search the premises and save all victims. The hallway is filled with thick smoke and Steven has to take a low position to see below it. From the crouching position he can orientate himself to see that there are three doors, one 19 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 19–31. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
20
M. Lebram et al.
on each wall, apart from the one he just entered. Remembering his tactics he chooses to open the first door on his right and enters the bathroom. Still crouching, he finds the room empty and checks that there is no one in the bathtub. Steve returns to the hallway and continues his search to the right to find the bedroom. The bed is on fire and he moves along the wall, searching behind furniture and in closets. He finds an unconscious man in the far end of the room and lowers the fogfighter nozzle to pick him up. Steve sees that the fire is increasing in strength and that his stamina is decreasing to a critical level. He has to get out quickly in order to gain health. The instructor asks him whether the search is completed. Steve remembers the third door and reenters the apartment. After the mission Steve enters the virtual debriefing room with an information board and an overview of the apartment. The assignment is evaluated and the areas covered by the search are highlighted. Steve gets feedback from the virtual instructor and the mission is summarized on the information board. In this paper we present the architecture and software solution for a game based firefighter simulator based on a commercial computer game and computer game technology. Our solution implements an advanced game based simulation, with a novel interaction mode, to be played on multiple screens (i.e. in a cave) which can be used for training and simulation. The utilization of standard off the shelf hardware has produced a cost-effective solution in a relatively short time. The game itself has been developed in close cooperation with the Swedish Rescue Services Agency in order to guarantee accurate content and relevant scenarios.
2 Background In this section we will introduce the central concepts of serious games and some applications to the subject area of firefighter training.
2.1 Serious Games Today, the term serious games is becoming more and more popular, see e.g. (Serious Games Initiative 2007; LoPiccolo 2004). The term itself is established, but there is no current singleton definition of the concept. Zyda (2005, 26) defines a serious game as: “a mental contest, played with a computer in accordance with specific rules, which uses entertainment to further government or corporate training, education, health, public policy, and strategic communication objectives.” Furthermore, Zyda (2005) argues that serious games have more than just story, art, and software. It is the addition of pedagogy (activities that educate or instruct, thereby imparting knowledge or skill) that makes games serious. However, he also stresses that pedagogy must be subordinate to story and that the entertainment component comes
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
21
first. In our work we define serious games as games that engage the user, and contribute to the achievement of a defined purpose other than pure entertainment (whether or not the user is consciously aware of it). A game’s purpose may be formulated by the game’s designer or by the user her/himself, which means that also a commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) game, used for non-entertainment purposes, may be considered a serious game. The desired purpose, i.e. a serious game, can be achieved through a spectrum ranging from the mere utilization of game technology for non-entertainment purposes to development of specifically designed games for some non-entertainment purpose or the use and/or adaptation of commercial games for non-entertainment purposes. We also propose that any combination of the above would constitute a feasible way to achieve the desired effect. Serious games can be applied to a broad spectrum of application areas, e.g. military, government, educational, corporate, and healthcare. A question of interest concerns the claimed positive effects of such games, or of applications from related and sometimes overlapping areas such as e-learning, edutainment, gamebased learning, and digital game-based learning. In addition to obvious advantages, like allowing learners to experience situations that are impossible in the real world for reasons of safety, cost, time, etc. (Corti 2006; Squire and Jenkins 2003), serious games, it is argued, can have positive impacts on the players’ development of certain skills. We also note that some of these positive effects of gaming are not necessarily associated with any specific training or information objectives. As discussed by Mitchell and Savill-Smith (2003) analytical and spatial skills, strategic skills and insight, learning and recollection capabilities, psychomotor skills, visual selective attention, etc. may be enhanced by playing computer games. Lager and Bremberg (2006) have summarized studies of the effects of playing computer games and indicate positive effects on motor and spatial skills. More specific positive impacts have been reported, e.g., by Enochsson et al. (2004), who found a positive correlation between experience in computer games and performance in endoscopic simulation by medical students. The better performance of gamers is attributed to their three-dimensional perception experience from computer gaming. The positive effects of games may hence be further utilized if we can identify the correct content and accurately exploit the user’s experience as a driving force for developing serious games. Swartout and van Lent (2003) identify the areas of experience-based systems and experience based education as potentially benefiting from such a game-based approach. The general idea is to influence users by exposing them to some type of experience. Even though gaming is not a replacement for simulation it may well serve as a complement in some regards (Sawyer 2005). In this sense we find the intersection between gaming and simulation to be an interesting one. The goal is hence to retain the immersion and motivating factors by means of a game element and to utilize computer game technology as a cost effective way to achieve the capacity of a mid range simulator (Lebram et al. 2006). In particular, game based training simulators (i.e. serious games) are feasible when training risky missions in inaccessible or dangerous environments.
22
M. Lebram et al.
2.2 Immersive Visualization There are several ways of visualizing virtual worlds in order to offer a more immersive experience to the viewer than can be achieved using ordinary computer displays. The choice of visualization system depends on in what purpose it shall be used and, what resources in terms of time, space and finances are available. 2.2.1 Head Mounted Displays The term HMD is used on a category of visualization systems which presents a virtual world directly in front of the viewer’s eyes, via one or two small displays. Used with a head tracking system the viewer is able to look at different parts of the world by turning his/her head. There are many different types of HMD:s in the market, for instance helmets, goggles, and lightweight glasses. There are also a number of features which may be supported by a HMD device, such as stereoscopic vision, semi transparent displays, et cetera. A common property of HMD:s is, however, relatively low resolution and a small field of view. 2.2.2 EVL CAVE A CAVE is an, usually super computer based, environment for visualization of, and interaction with virtual models and worlds. The first CAVE (CAVE Automatic Virtual Environment) was developed by Electronic Visualization Laboratory (1991). The purpose was to build a system for scientific visualization, with high demands on performance (Cruz-Neira et al. 1993). The original CAVE had three walls, consisting of screens for rear projection, and measures 2.5 × 2.5 × 2.5 meters. On the walls and the floor stereoscopic scenes are presented for a viewer, whose head movements are tracked in order to correct the projection in real time. The viewer is also able to interact with the virtual world, for instance by using a special glove. Several variations of CAVE have been built since 1991. One example is the six-sided VR-CUBE which was built at the Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm in 1998 (Center for Parallel Computers 1998). Here the viewer is completely surrounded by video and audio from the virtual world – in all directions.
2.3 Fire Fighter Training The Swedish Rescue Services Agency (SRSA) is the government authority responsible for the training of fire and rescue operatives. All municipal fire and
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
23
rescue services staff are trained and certified by the SRSA. Breathing Apparatus Entry (BAE) is one of the tasks a firefighter has to perform. It is of crucial importance that the firefighter can remain orientated with very limited or no vision in a building. Traditionally the firefighter students practice search methods with and without smoke in different physical buildings. Training is typically organized to start without smoke where students use a mask with translucent visor. This type of training is time consuming and requires flexible buildings. The optimal training for BAE search methods would be in an environment with a great number and types of buildings. Training would also be more efficient if students could practice individually yet with professional feedback and evaluation.
2.4 Virtual Environments for Fire Fighter Training As firefighters have to handle extreme tasks there is a continuous need to develop training programs to prepare for such tasks (Lasky 2004). There exist a number of reports of the use of virtual environments for firefighter training in the literature. Tate et al. (1997) present a study where a virtual environment training system was used to prepare shipboard firefighters for a mission. The virtual environment allowed users, equipped with a HMD device, to navigate in a 3D-model of the exUSS Shadwell fire research and test ship. A group of 12 trained firefighters participated in a study where their performance in a firefighting training mission was evaluated. Half the group was offered traditional mission preparation and the other half prepared using the virtual environment. The result of the evaluation showed that the second group had a better performance than the group using traditional preparation. In a different study, Julien and Shaw (2003) present a virtual firefighter command training environment which allows its users to inspect a house on fire and to command virtual firefighters. The fire is extinguished by issuing the correct sequence of commands to the firefighters. Perdigau et al. (2003) present an application for managing virtual reality scenarios and their main scenario is a Firefighter Training Simulation used for crisis situations training and understanding. There are also examples on commercial simulation software used for firefighter training. The tactical command trainer is a tool from VectorCommand Ltd. (2008) which allows users to train emergency management.
3 SIDH – The Game The main goal with SIDH was to develop a cave-based simulator game for training BAE. The project was carried out by expertise in game development and serious
24
M. Lebram et al.
games, in close cooperation with expertise in firefighter training from SRSA. The game is not intended to replace conventional training, but rather to be used as a complement with focus on search strategies and ability to orient in unknown premises. The game is to resemble real world BAE in as many aspects as possible. This means that the player’s task is to completely search different premises, with higher or lower complexity of the architecture, and rescue any persons inside. It should be possible to fill the premises with smoke, which, similar to real smoke, should be thinner close to the floor than close to the roof. The player should also be exposed to heat and physical and psychological stresses, which are characteristic parts of BAE. Furthermore, in respect of the educational purpose, it is crucial to record the player’s actions during a game session for later analysis. To reduce overhead time in the developing process, it was decided that the game was to be developed as a modification of a COTS game. In this way, the developers can focus on game content and specific features without first having to create an infrastructure from scratch. A feasibility study was committed in order to choose one of three common games - FarCry, Quake2 and Half-Life 2. All candidates were successfully modified to run in the cave environment. However, due to the realistic indoor environments and the ease of use of the level editor, Half-Life 2 was chosen as a platform for SIDH.
3.1 Cave Visualization The cave is constructed from standard consumer electronics components. The purpose is to create a flexible environment for 360 degrees visualizations of for example games and films. The four walls are each 160 cm wide and 210 cm high. The upper 120 cm of the walls consists of screens for rear projection. Each screen is projected by a standard LCD projector, connected to a PC (Figure 1). These computers are interconnected in an Ethernet network together with another computer which acts as a server. All five computers are standard gaming PC:s with regular graphics cards. The internal sound card of the server has been complemented with an external 5.1 sound card which delivers sound to four loudspeakers, one in each of the corners of the cave (Figure 1). Half-Life 2 is a multiplayer game which means that there is native network functionality for distributing information about the current state of the game objects. When playing a multiplayer game, one of the computers acts as a server responsible for controlling and synchronizing the progress of the game. When a server is running other computers in the network are able to connect and thereby become participating instances of the game running on the server. When playing SIDH in the cave, the actual game, i.e. the instance responsible for player input and game logic, is running on the server computer. The task of the
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
25
Fig. 1. Schematic view of the cave.
four client computers is to visualize the game running on the server, why the clients always have to be updated about the player’s position and the state of the world. To achieve this, a native multiplayer feature called spectator mode is used. The original purpose of this feature is to make it possible for connected, but nonparticipating, clients to automatically follow and observe an active player. In that manner, the instances of the game running on the cave computers are observers, following the player on the server and hence showing the same view as the server without actually interacting with the game. The screens of the cave are however not to be clones of the server screen. Instead they should present the world in four different directions, one direction for each screen, with the same origin as the server player. In the implementation, the game view is defined by a camera which acts as the eyes of the player (or the spectator). The position and orientation of this camera decides what is shown on the screen. By setting the orientation of a client’s camera to a certain fixed direction, the client view will always show the world from that angle, regardless of the player orientation. Each view is thus rotated 90 degrees with respect to the adjacent screens. To produce the final 360 degree projection in the cave, the FOV (field-of-view) for the cameras were adjusted to 90 degrees. This is important since two adjacent views will overlap with a greater FOV value, and with a lesser value all parts of the world will not be visible at the same time.
3.2 Interaction Model One of the goals with SIDH has been to make the player’s interaction with the game as natural as possible. The player has to be able to move and look around in
26
M. Lebram et al.
the virtual world, crouching as well as in a raised position. Moreover, it has to be possible to pick up and drop victims and control the game-flow. A problem about navigating in a cave environment is the lack of obvious directions in terms of forward, backward, left and right. Normally when playing a firstperson game, forward is defined by the center of the display, i.e. the direction in which the player is currently looking. Pressing the forward-key on the keyboard will always move the player in the desired direction since the world is rotating around the player and the keyboard. In the cave, on the other hand, it is not possible to use a single forward-key since the directions are fixed to the real world. Hence, in order to decide what direction is forward for a cave player it is necessary for the software to keep track of the player’s current orientation. In SIDH, this problem is solved by using a GameTrak, which is an USB-device working as a joystick with a string to pull as Z-axis. The GameTrak is placed centered in the top of the cave, top down, with the string attached to the fogfighter nozzle (Figure 2). In this way, the nozzle’s position in 3D-space can be calculated. Since there may be some discrepancy between the direction expected by the player and the calculated direction (due to player deviation from the center of the cave), the calculated forward direction is visualized as a marker on the screens. SIDH also calculates the nozzle’s distance to the floor in order to decide whether the player is crouching (to increase the sight in smoke-filled areas) or not. Since a low position is depending of the player’s height, the crouching threshold is dynamically adapted based on the highest nozzle position recorded during a mission. The information about the distance to the floor is also used to record so called markings. A marking is done by touching the floor with the nozzle, and is an action with different meanings in different phases of the game: • • • •
To start the game in the beginning of a level. To pick up found victims. To drop rescued victims. To confirm a completed search task.
One important aspect of the interaction model is to resemble some of the physical strain associated with BAE. This is done by using BAE gear inside the cave and by physical movement to navigate in the game. For the player to be able to move inside the cave, a device named Stepometer has been developed. The Stepometer is a gauge that allows the player to move forward in the game by walking or running on the spot. The device consists of two sensors which are attached to the player’s feet. Since the interaction is not depending on any fine motor activity at all, it is possible to let the SIDH player play the game using the same equipment as in BAE, i.e. coat, trousers, gloves, boots, helmet and air mask. Due to the look, feel and smell of the equipment this may be used to increase the player’s sense of realism. Since heat has a great influence on both physical and psychological stress during BAE, there was initially a discussion about placing infrared heaters on top of the
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
27
Fig. 2. The string of the GameTrak (top right) is attached to the fogfighter nozzle (bottom right). NB, only one of the GameTrak’s two controls is used.
cave. This would result in a realistic heat distribution which would force the player to crouch in order to decrease heat exposure. However, the computers and the projectors produced enough heat to make the room uncomfortably hot. This temperature and the fact that the equipment preserved the body heat (resulting from the player’s physical effort) led to the decision that adding more heat would be a disadvantage concerning the entertaining aspects of the game. The air mask (Figure 3) is equipped with a radio receiver through which instructions from the virtual instructor is presented. To avoid interfering with the radio frequencies used by SRSA, the original radio system is replaced by two budget walkie-talkies. The other walkie-talkie works as a transmitter, connected to the internal sound card of the server. A slight modification of the software makes it possible to direct the voice of the instructor to this sound card, while all other sound effects are played back in the regular sound system.
3.3 Level Design The levels for SIDH have been created in the Hammer world editor which is included in the Half Life 2 edition. The Hammer world editor is a powerful tool. Apart from facilities for easy creation and texturing of elementary building blocks such as walls, floors, roofs and ceilings the editor also gives access to a number of pre-fabricated models of humans, furniture and other furnishing items. The prefabricated items have facilitated development work by reducing the number of specific models necessary to create for SIDH. Furthermore, the editor supports the manipulation of light, sound, smoke and fire to alter environments.
28
M. Lebram et al.
Fig. 3. Air mask with radio unit.
The game flow is controlled by timers and triggers. Triggers are invisible objects which can be used to activate other objects or events such as, e.g., a fire to flare or a new level to start. As an example, a trigger may be activated when the player approaches it. All levels in the SIDH game must have a specific set up of triggers and timers to handle the game flow. Important elements to game functionality are recycled in all levels, thus reducing the over-head when creating new tracks. 13 different levels (Table 1) have been developed in close cooperation with the SRSA. There is also a tutorial in which the player gets to learn the game and the interaction mode and two bonus levels. The game covers a variety of flats, warehouses, shops and industry facilities to provide a relevant sample of environments for rescue personnel to train in. Each level provides new challenges with respect to size, complexity and smoke. The difficulty is also increased by shorter time limits and the degree of harm made to the player by smoke and fire. Furthermore, the game provides challenges in terms of unexpected situations, such as victims hidden in closets, and rooms difficult to locate. Other elements of stress are alarms, sirens, screaming victims and explosions. Each level starts with a female virtual instructor introducing the game task. The virtual instructor’s voice is personified by an instructor from the SRSA and the texture of the pre-fabricated models has been modified to resemble a real rescue personnel outfit. Each level ends in a debriefing room (Figure 4) where the player receives oral and visual feedback concerning his/her result. A level is completed when all rooms and areas have been scanned and all victims rescued within time limit and with preserved player stamina. If the result is unsatisfying, the virtual instructor will inform the player of this and the player gets a new chance. The number of trials on each level is maximized to three in order to expose the player to a variety of environments.
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
29
Table 1. The levels of the game and their learning objectives. Level
Description
Objective
0
Tutorial
To handle the interaction model and game goals
1
Two-room apartment
To get a first contact with the game
2
Club building
To realize that time is limited
3
Garage
To realize the advantage of crouching in smoke-filled areas
4
Bonus level
To get a break
5
One-room apartment
To look in closets
6
Youth hostel
To handle large number of rooms
7
Office space
To handle complex corridor architecture, closet
8
Grocery store
To handle areas divided by shelves
9
Three-room apartment
To handle heavy fire, closet and limited time
10
Large apartment
To handle extremely limited sight in complex architecture
11
Basement storage area
To handle fenced areas filled with junk
12
Four-room apartment
To handle doors at unexpected positions
13
Hotel corridor
To handle numerous identical doors
14
Butcher shop
To handle veiled areas
15
Bonus level
To finish the game
Fig. 4. The debriefing room. The board presents achieved score and an overview of the premises. The bright fields in the map represent areas visited by the player.
30
M. Lebram et al.
When a level is successfully completed the player will get a score based on the proportion of the facilities that has been searched, time spent on the task and whether it was the first, second or third trial. If the area covered by the search exceeds 90% the player will be awarded a star bonus which will also generate a bonus score on the following level.
4 Concluding Remarks The main contribution with the presented work is a training simulator developed with relatively simple means. SIDH is a cost effective immersive firefighter training game, which, according to personnel and students of SRSA, is entertaining as well as effective regarding learning of the intended tasks Backlund et al. (2007). We have demonstrated the feasibility and usefulness of an architecture for a game based immersive training simulator. The novel interaction mode adds to immersion by introducing physical aspects into the game. We have also shown that inherent game functionality can be used and extended to create a variety of levels with distinct learning goals. The source code has been modified to implement required features and the specialized game flow. An example of such a modification is the player’s health level, which is constantly decreasing when acting in smoke filled areas. Furthermore, specific logging functionality concerning the state and the activities of the player has been implemented in order to facilitate after action review. The modifications and amendments made to the original system serves as an illustration of the potential of game-based simulation. We have shown that this class of systems has a sufficient capacity to form basis for a training simulator. The success with SIDH is mainly depending on two factors – the close cooperation between SRSA and HIS and the utilization of common computer game technology. During the initial meetings the purpose of the game was discussed from different points of view. It was stated that even if it would be possible to simulate every aspect of a BAE operation, which would require a great amount of time and money, it would still be a simulation which cannot replace training in the real world. Hence, it was decided that the game should focus on search strategies and the ability to orient in unknown premises. These aspects were regarded as the ones which would gain the most from simulator training, due to the limited possibility of varying physical premises in the real world. Using Hammer world editor to create premises for SIDH, the architecture options are virtually unlimited. Acknowledgments: The authors would like to thank the personnel at the Swedish Rescue Services Agency (SRSA) for their advice on the subject matter. This work has been financed through the EU INTERREG IIIC DISTRICT project.
Design and Architecture of Sidh – a Cave Based Firefighter Training Game
31
References Backlund, P., Engström, H., & Johannesson, M. (2006). Computer gaming and driving education. Presented at the workshop Pedagogical Design of Educational Games affiliated to the 14th International Conference on Computers in Education (ICCE 2006). Beijing, China. Backlund, P., Engström, H., Hammar, C., Johannesson, M., & Lebram, M. (2007). Sidh – a Game Based Firefighter Training Simulation. Presented at the 11th International Conference Information Visualization (IV ’07). Zürich, Switzerland. Center for Parallel Computers. (1998). The PDC Cube. Royal Institute of Technology. http://www.pdc.kth.se/projects/vr-cube/. Accessed 7 February 2008. Corti, K. (2006). Games-based learning; a serious business application. White paper. The Serious Games Institute. http://www.pixelearning.com/serious_games-white_papers.htm. Accessed 8 February 2008. Cruz-Neira, C., Sandin, D., & DeFanti, T. (1993). Virtual Reality: The Design and Implementation of the CAVE. Presented at the SIGGRAPH 93 Computer Graphics Conference. ACM SIGGRAP,135-142. Electronic Visualization Laboratory. (1991). CAVE Automatic Virtual Environment. University of Illinois. http://www.evl.uic.edu/core.php?mod=4&type=1&indi=161. Accessed 7 February 2008. Enochsson, L., Isaksson, B., Tour, R., Kjellin, A., Hedman, L., Wredmark, T., & Tsai-Fellander, L. (2004). Visuospatial skills and computer game experience influence the performance of virtual endoscopy. Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, 8 (7), 874–880. Julien, T. U. S. & Shaw, C. D. (2003). Firefighter command training virtual environment. In Richard Tapia Celebration of Diversity In Computing. Proceedings of the 2003 Conference on Diversity in Computing (pp. 30–33). Atlanta, Georgia, USA: ACM. Lager, A. & Bremberg, S. (2005). Hälsoeffekter av tv- och datorspelande. En systematisk genomgång av vetenskapliga studier. Swedish National Institute of Public Health. Lasky, R. (2004). Firefighter survival training: from reactive to proactive. Fire Engineering, June, 117–119. Lebram, M., Engström, H., & Gustavsson, H. (2006). A driving simulator based on video game technology. Presented at SIGRAD 2006, Skövde, Sweden. LoPiccolo, P. (2004). Serious games. Computer Graphics World, 27(2). Mitchell, A. & Savill-Smith, C. (2003). The use of computer and video games for learning: A review of the literature. Learning and Skills Development Agency. Perdigau, P., Torguet, E. Sanza, C., & Jessel J.-P. (2003). A distributed virtual storytelling system for firefighters training. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Virtual Storytelling (pp. 227–230). November 2003, Toulouse, France. Sawyer, B. (2004). The serious games summit: emergent use of interactive games for solving problems is serious effort. Computers in Entertainment 2(1), 5. Serious Games Initiative. (2007). Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. http://www.seriousgames.org. Accessed 7 February 2008. Squire, K. & Jenkins, H. (2003). Harnessing the power of games in education. Insight, 3(1), 5–33. Swartout, W. & van Lent, M. (2003). Making a game of system design. Communications of the ACM, 46(7), 32–39. Tate, D. L., Sibert, L., & King, T. (1997). Virtual environments for shipboard firefighter training. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 17(6), 23–29. Vector Command Ltd. (2008). http://www.vectorcommand.com. Accessed 7 February 2008. Zyda, M. (2005). From visual simulation to virtual reality to games. Computer, 38(9), 25–32.
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games Users’ Experiences of a Fitness Adventure Prototype Antti Väätänen and Jaana Leikas VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland Tekniikankatu 1, Tampere, P.O. Box 1300, FI33101, VTT, Finland
[email protected]
Abstract: Nowadays, there are advantageous fitness gadgets and measurement systems available as well as specific fitness and GPS mobile phones on the market. This development process has enabled the advancement of new kind of game-like fitness concepts. This development means that the design requirements for new exercise gaming concepts become more challenging, and consequently, the challenges for the design thinking increase. This paper presents the design process of the Fitness Adventure prototype, based on Human-centred Design (HCD) with some new conceptual tools such as form of life, making the design of the contents of experiences easier. Based on the user feedback and results of the design process we give practical guidelines for the design of exergames. Before introducing the exergame design principles, a short overview of the history of fitness games is introduced.
1 Introduction to Game Production User experience design is a central challenge in developing serious games. Therefore we have to ask in solving concrete design tasks the reflective question what is the right form of design processes. Here, we are interested in designing a serious game for late middle aged people using human-centred design tradition. Especially, we are going to focus on designing a fitness game and therefore we logically call attention to the specific problems in designing such games. Because of currently prevailing styles of life overweight and the lack of exercise are becoming a common problem among all age groups in the Western countries. As commonly known, even a small amount of daily physical activity, such as half on hour of brisk walking, could help in losing weight and strengthen one’s physical health. Maintaining a good ability to walk is known to be as such probably one of the key issues in the prevention of mobility-related disability (Asikainen et al. 2006; Van Heuvelen 2000). Physical exercise affects also mental health (Ruoppila 2002). 33 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 33–47. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
34
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
It results in a feeling of well-being, with or without a relation to the characteristics of physical fitness, and increases social capabilities as well. Different levels of physical exercise can have remarkable effects on the functional physical capacity of the aging people. For example, the functionality of the cardiovascular system (the oxygen consumption) can be improved with the help of regular exercise. Moving from one place to another, e.g., running, cycling, and lifting and carrying loads can exceed oxygen consumption. Continued exercise has also proved to be an important means of preventing osteoporosis (Asikainen et al. 2006; Van Heuvelen 2000). In addition, receiving encouragement and support from a health care expert is known to be important for the aging persons. It has been suggested that physical activity counselling might increase the involvement in physical exercise (Rasinaho et al. 2006). Motivation plays a significant role in the exercise adherence. Rather than being a spontaneous behaviour carried out for fun and challenge, exercise is often accomplished for extrinsic reasons such as improved fitness or appearance (Ryan et al. 1997). However, such extrinsic motives often fail to sustain exercise activity over time. Also the intrinsic motivation (such as enjoyment and competence) remains a critical factor in sustained physical activity. In this respect, the exercise must be enjoyable and possibly even fun if the person is going to continue with it for any length of time. Although maintaining one’s physical condition and wellness at a good level when aging is important, there are not yet inspiring ways for middle-aged adults to keep fit. Solutions of ambient intelligence and mobile technology have now the potential to deliver motivating concepts for exercising and keeping fit. Exergames, in the sense of serious games with wireless sensor technology and mobile devices, can offer one solution to motivate people for keeping up a healthier life style. Nowadays, there are successful examples of new physical ways to play and approach the idea of gaming. The increasing popularity of fitness gadgets, GPS devices and phones with positioning features paves the way for mobile gaming, as well. These mobile and pervasive computing technologies were utilised in VTT’s Exergame project which focused on finding new motivating ways and playful contents for exercising (Lampila and Lähteenmäki 2006; Leikas and Lehto 2006; VTT 2008; Väätänen et al. 2007). In the Exergame, different game concepts were developed for different target groups. Based on the concept creation work, a Fitness Adventure game prototype was developed and evaluated with a group of middleaged Finnish persons. This paper presents design process of the Fitness Adventure prototype; the storyline, interaction methods, design process and user evaluations. Based on the results of this process we introduce user feedback of exergaming and give practical guidelines for the design of exergames. The paper also gives an overview of the history of exergames and introduces examples of specific games that are categorised into indoor and outdoor use.
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
35
2 Indoor and Outdoor Fitness Games Atari’s Project Puffer, which was launched in 1982, was the first credible step in developing exercise games and user interfaces for exertion gaming (Atari Gaming Headquarters – Atari Project Puffer Page). It was a combination of a video game and exercise cycle. Other examples of prototypes with an exercise cycle as a control device are the Peloton bicycling simulator by Bell Laboratories (Carraro et al. 1998) and the Virku – a Virtual Fitness Centre by VTT (Lainio et al. 2001; Mokka et al. 2003) (Figure 1). At the moment, few manufacturers develop exercise cycles, exercise steppers and rowing machines which are meant to be used as control devices in games (3D Innovations 2008; InterAction Laboratores Inc 2008). There are traditional dance games, such as Konami’s Dance Dance Revolution and the free Stepmania game, which offer easy ways for exercising with music (Konami Digital Entertainment 2008; Stepmania). Höysniemi (2006) has studied dance games and discovered that they are can be an enjoyable and motivating way for playing and exercising at the same time. In the long run, they can even lead to a better fitness level of the users. However, these games and controllers are primarily developed for home and indoor use and may thus restrict the movements of the player. Due to a simple user interface of these kinds of games, the game content is often rather limited. Sony’s EyeToy cameras and Nintendo’s Wii-controllers are all popular light control devices for games but not originally meant to be used as exercise equipment (Nintendo 2008; Sony Computer Entertainment Europe 2008). Now, with launching the Wii Fit, a pressure sensitive board and applications related to it, Nintendo has shown serious interest towards the development of workout solutions. Potential indoor and outdoor environments for pervasive games are playgrounds, schools, theme parks and shopping malls. The Lappset group company launched SmartUs interactive playground products in 2006 (Lappset group Ltd 2008). The development of SmartUs utilised partly results of the research of interactive environments carried out by VTT. The first steps of this research at VTT were taken in the Lumetila (Virtual Space – User Interfaces of the Future) project that generated game prototypes utilising pressure sensitive floor tiles (Leikas et al. 2003) (Figure 2). In Lumetila’s Lumepong the player controls a racquet by moving on the 4X4 meter floor area. In another prototype of Lumetila, called Nautilus, a group of players can control an imaginary diving bell with their position and movements on the floor tiles. Immersion into the underwater world was created with the help of a large screen, light effects, and a 3D sound system (Strömberg et al. 2002). In VTT’s ubiPlay project a game creator and a floor tile game system was further developed and studied (Mattila and Väätänen 2006) (Figure 3). The game creator is a tool for creating playful contents for interactive playgrounds.
36
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
Fig. 1. Example of an exercise cycle game: Virku – Virtual Fitness Centre User Interface.
Fig. 2. Example of floor tile system in the Lumetila project. (Graphical design: Tiina Kymäläinen, VTT).
Geocaching is a world wide and famous example of GPS solutions, but it is mainly focused in orienteering and doesn’t include real time interaction with GPS devices (Groundspeak Inc 2008a). Some tools for making GPS adventures and routes are available in the internet, e.g., EasyGPS and Wherigo are tools for creating interactive routes especially for GPS devices (EasyGPS; Groundspeak Inc 2008b). The applications can be used with GPS devices such as Magellan or Garmin by
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
37
Fig. 3. Example of floor tile system in the ubiPlay project. (Photo: Antti Väätänen, VTT).
using GPX (the GPS Exchange Format) which is an XML data format that enables downloading GPS data from the internet (TopoGrafix 2008). Traditional GPS devices have constraints on their multimedia feedback features. However, some of the newest devices have features for e.g. playing mp3 sounds. Only a few research studies have focused on GPS games designed especially for fitness purposes (IPerG – Integrated Project of Pervasive Games). E.g., MOPET and ‘Ere be dragons’, application examples of these studies, run only in a PC (Davis et al. 2006; Buttussi et al. 2006). Nokia has published an open source development platform MUPE (Multi-User Publishing Environment) (Nokia Corporation 2008. Mupe – Main: Mupe (Nokia Corporation 2008a; Suomela et al. 2004). It is a platform for context-aware applications development and it supports multi-user solutions and GPS features. In addition to game applications, different cell phone companies have developed new models with integrated GPS or sport performance measurements features such as step counters (Nokia Corporation 2008b, Nokia Corporation 2008c, Sony Ericsson 2008). Large clothing companies have their intelligent clothing versions which are connectable to e.g. cell phones, mp3 players and heart rate monitoring systems (Adidas Ag and Polar Electro Oy 2008; Apple Inc 2008; Halti Ltd 2008).
3 Fitness Adventure Prototype The Fitness Adventure is a location based game prototype developed in the Exergame project. It is an outdoor game that utilises Series 60 mobile phone platform (S60 Home 2008) and a Bluetooth GPS receiver. The game includes cartoon like dialogues between different characters in the game, and, based on the conversations between the actors, the player should decide to which direction (s)he should
38
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
be heading next in the game area (Figure 4). The game spots (overall 9 places) are different buildings or sightseeing places in the actual city district of Espoo. When the player enters to the spot that (s)he has selected, the GPS device recognises the player’s location and the game runs a scene that is related to the spot. Playing one game requires walking or running approximately 3 to 6 kilometres, depending on personal route selections. The game is not designed to measure physical performance or give feedback of the fitness level of the user. Its main purpose is to offer a new and joyful way to run or walk in different environments, thus motivating people to be more active and carry out outdoor exercise. In addition, it could be used to encourage the users to visit new surroundings and tourist attractions in a physically active way. The aim of frequent usage of the game is to increase the fitness level of the user in a long run. The game itself is a Java application and it reads signals from a Bluetooth GPS receiver with the help of Bluetooth bridge which communicates both with the game software and the GPS device. We used the Nokia N70 cell phone and the RoyalTek RBT2001, SIRF Star III Bluetooth receiver. The same setup was used in the user tests.
Fig. 4. Screenshots of Fitness Adventure. (Graphical design: Petri Ruutikainen, VTT).
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
39
4 Methodology 4.1 The Design Process and Study Procedure The development of new solutions has to be needs-driven and demand-driven. Instead of concentrating only on technology we have to study the culture that people live in and the needs that different user groups have. This information should be included in the concept design. Thus, the design process of the Fitness Adventure game was based on the Human-centred Design (HCD) approach (ISO 13407). It aims at creating useful and easy to use solutions by considering user backgrounds and needs, tasks, and usage environments, and iteratively evaluating the design outcomes together with end users. Adopting this approach it is possible to end up with products that will satisfy the users, and are successfully used. The HCD approach aims at understanding the needs of users early in the design process, providing guidance for designing the product, and assuring that the product will be accepted by the users. The process of Human-centred Design is composed of a number of key activities (ISO 13407): understanding and specifying the user requirements, understanding and specifying the context of use, iteration of design solutions, and evaluating the solutions with the users against requirements. The Fitness Adventure (FA) design ideas and later on the prototypes were discussed and evaluated with potential end users of the FA. Along with end users, the ideas were also discussed with fitness experts, in order to get information of the characteristics and usage motivations of different user segments of fitness services. The design of the FA prototype started with scenario work. This work was supported by a consumer study (see next chapter). Each member of the design team created scenarios of future exergaming solutions with the idea of bringing out vivid ways to combine new technology and exercising. Overall 14 scenarios were created. After that the scenarios were analysed by the project team and refined accordingly. Based on the refined scenarios, three different product concepts were created. They were called the Activator, the Location Adventures and the Fitness Club. The Activator and Fitness Club are Fitness tamagotchi -like concepts, where the player has a small fitness gadget that can be used as a part of the game. In the game, the player is offered to ‘earn’ extra features or extra points by carrying out activities such as jogging regularly in a game. The gadget can also remind the player if (s)he has not been active for a long time. In the Location Adventures – concept the game integrates the real environment and the game environment. The Fitness Adventure prototype was later developed based on the Location Adventure.
40
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
4.2 The Consumer Study A Consumer Study was carried out in order to examine the factors that affect willingness to use playful exercising solutions (Lampila and Lähteenmäki 2006). Also, the relationship between playing computer games and sports habits was studied. The data were collected with an inquiry in the internet and analysed based on the gender and age of the respondents1. Based on the results, active computer game playing doesn’t correlate with low physical activity. For young people, playing a game is normally a time consuming social event. Adults and elderly people are typical casual computer game players – they play shorter periods, less frequently, and usually do not take playing as a social event. On the other hand, middle aged and older people have more step counters and other health-related devices than the young. However, these pedometers and heart rate monitors are often popular gifts, and thus high device frequency does not necessarily correlate with the usage frequency.
4.3 The User Evaluations The created product concepts were evaluated with end users in focus groups in Spring 2006. The first focus group session was carried out at a sports institute in the city of Tampere. The aim of the focus group was to get feedback of the preliminary Exergame concepts as well as to find out how people in different age groups wish to exercise sports. Also, the subject of future sports favourites was discussed. We wanted also to gain user preferences of the potential usage of different activity sensors as well as the mobile device as a fitness device. The focus groups participants consisted of three students of sports education, a project manager and a communications and marketing assistant at the sports institute. The concepts were modified based on the feedback of this focus group. The next two focus group sessions were carried out at another sports institute in the city of Lahti and in a high school in Espoo. Also the aim of these focus groups was to evaluate the modified Exergame concepts. These focus groups participants consisted of 7 students of physical education and their teacher in Lahti, and 2 male and 10 female participants in Espoo (aged 14-15). The concepts were introduced and discussed with the participants who were encouraged to tell their opinions about the concepts and asked to give ideas about how to further develop them. Based on the feedback of these focus groups the concept was further developed: the storyboard was created, the game software together with Bluetooth connection
1
A total of 1489 respondents: adolescents (13 to 18 years old), young adults (19 to 30 years old), workage people (31 to 65 years old), and pensioners (66 to 75 years old).5
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
41
was finalised, and the game content including text, audio and pictures was implemented into the game application. The GPS coordinates were defined at the actual spots on the field. After that we were ready to start the user tests. The user tests were carried out in Autumn 2006. The aim of the tests was to analyse the usefulness and usability of Fitness Adventure application. Usefulness was observed in two dimensions: (i) how the game concept could offer new motivating contents for traditional outdoor activities and (ii) how e.g., occupational health service providers could support the usage of these kinds of solutions. The main usability issues were: (i) the user interface and interaction, (ii) context of use, (iii) reliability, and (iv) the game content. In addition, we asked the users’ opinions about supplying the GPS with complementary methods such as tag readers or visual codes for receiving information of the locations. 10 users (three men and seven women) participated in the evaluation. They were of the age 40-54, and had used the mobile phone at least for making calls and for text messaging. All users were also familiar with the game area to some extent. First, the users were asked to fill in a user background questionnaire of their mobile phone and internet usage, their experiences of mobile and internet games, their exercising habits and their experience of fitness games. Second, the game and user interface of it were introduced to the users. Then, an interview was carried out about the users’ experience and willingness for gaming and exercising. After that, the users started to play the game. The playing session took approximately one hour. The users were ordered to examine different spots of interest while running or walking in the area that was introduced in the game (Figure 5). They were expected to follow the game events in the mobile phone, read and listen to the dialogue in the story, and decide which routes to take. When they entered a right spot,
Fig. 5. Playing the game. (Photo: Jaana Leikas, VTT.).
42
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
the application announced about it with a sound and a vibration alert. If the users felt that they had got lost or if the application didn’t function as expected, they were able to phone one of the researchers nearby and ask for help. After the playing session the users filled in a questionnaire of the playing experience. It included questions of the willingness to play the game again, feelings after the game, impressions of the game as a whole, and desires for alternative interaction modes. After that, a semi structured group interview was carried out about the experiences that the users had of the FA game application. The whole test session took approximately one and a half hours.
5 Results The results indicate that the game succeeded in giving an alternative way for exercising. In addition to the fact that the game was seen as an enjoyable experience it was seen suitable for improving one’s physical condition. In this sense the idea of creating a motivating, new and an enjoyable exercise game was achieved well. This kind of a concept, where location information and an interesting story are combined together in a mobile game for running or walking through culturally interesting routes and places, clearly seems to offer added value for outdoor activities. The male participants felt that added information of the exercise session could motivate them. This information could include facts about how much exercise one had (e.g., distance), did one succeed in picking up the right routes, and what was the pulse during the game. The female participants did not appreciate this kind of statistical information of their fitness. Instead, they were enthusiastic in having social walks with friends when playing the game. The results of the questionnaire show that the FA game was considered as highly motivating and fun (Figure 6). On the other hand, the users felt that the content of the game was not rich enough and the game can thus be played only once or twice. There should be many optional sites along the route if the user is expected to walk or run through the route many times. This kind of game was seen profitable especially when a user wants to get to know a new environment, e.g. when travelling. Thus, different contents for different user groups would be useful. The game could, e.g., offer information about the nature of the area for nature tourists, and e.g., treasure hunt or detective adventures in a same environment for another user group. The game functioned well technically. The GPS system was reliable all the time and locating the user at the spot was found accurate enough in outdoor locations. The system was designed to recognise the players when they were within 20-30 meters distance of the defined spots, and the users were able to find most of the places easily. However, access to real-time location information should be an option in the game in order to give extra support for the user when needed.
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
43
Impressions of the game (N=10) motivating (1) - passivating (5) good for fitness (1) - not good for fitness (5) 1 useful (1) - useless (5)
2 3
safe (1) - risky (5)
4 5
new (1) - typical (5) Fun (1) - boring (5)
Fig. 6. Impressions of the Fitness Adventure game.
The users preferred the GPS recognition method when it was compared theoretically to the tag readers or visual codes, because using the GPS doesn’t require any extra input actions during the physical exercise. Also, the GPS device was small enough to carry along when running or walking. One hypothesis in the Exergame project was that the occupational health care service could have a suitable opportunity to wake up the person’s motivation and determination to start physical exercise with the help of a mobile application like FA. Individual counselling and training to use the application could be given e.g. during physical examination when lifestyle factors for health (such as diet, sleep and stress) are discussed in general. All users (except 2 men), felt that this kind of an application could motivate persons to exercise if it was suggested by the occupational health care personnel. 2 persons felt that they would let the occupational health care follow their exercise frequency, others felt that this would be too much controlling the employees. The application could also be loaded at the occupational health care office for free. Some users felt that if the application was given by the occupational health care it could motivate the persons to exercise sports.
6 Discussion Although the history of outdoor exergames is merely short, these games create a rapidly growing market potential. The step from indoor physical control devices and sensors towards mobile and outdoor fitness games has changed the nature of exergaming. Playful exercise solutions are more pervasive and versatile when considering interaction methods and the content of the applications. They focus on achieving inspiration for taking care of one’s fitness in a long term. The idea is not
44
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
only playing games and using new wireless technology, motion sensors, and positioning, but also a future way to do sports. Thus, the development of successful games calls for good practise examples and useful results of user experiences. As the outcome of different support activities depends highly on the person’s own motivation and willingness to take care of his/her health, people should be provided with tailored tools that motivate them to manage their own wellness. These tools can be developed with the help of mobile technology and provided with entertaining, informative, social and game-like aspects. Mobile phones are already our common everyday devices and thus form a suitable basis for these kinds of proactive guides for personal wellness management. In the Exergame project we designed and implemented a location based fitness game which utilises new GPS and cell phone technology. We feel that the HCD approach and the scenario work were fruitful and suitable for this kind of design. Thus, the model of the design process and the results of Exergame project could be utilized in other kinds of designs of playful fitness solutions, also. Based on the results of user evaluations, there are four principles to consider when developing exergaming solutions from the user point of view. The games should 1) be easy to use and include intuitive interaction methods, 2) support exercising by offering motivating and joyful ways for exercising sports, 3) include playful contents which take advantage from new user interfaces and game environments, and 4) offer statistics about the improvements of one’s physical condition when desired. There are certain practical factors that one could consider when designing and developing exergaming applications. First, when creating the storyline, the game should be connected to the real environment. Second, when designing GPS based games one should check the actual environment on the field and avoid places with high buildings, tunnels or other obstacles that might uncover GPS receiver signal. There could also be other disturbing factors or risks in the environment, such as construction works and heavy traffic routes. Third, the feasibility and functionality of the devices to be used in different conditions (indoor, outdoor, temperature, bad weather, etc.) should be examined. The user group of FA evaluations consisted of middle-aged persons who were rather inexperienced in mobile, video, and computer games. Despite of this the users managed to do well in the game and enjoy the physical exercise that at the same time came unobserved, as “into the bargain”. The users had a strong opinion that the Fitness Adventure story is playable only for once or twice. If the application is expected to be used for regular playing there should be new locations with several different stories included in it. When developing a game, it should be considered how the game would effect on the player’s personal motivational factors and external motivational issues: exercising and doing sports is not always competition: there are other issues, such as social networking, that would motivate the players more. Thus, e.g., positive and negative feedback with some kind of another form than traditional points and ranking is necessary. It is also good to design key features that would motivate
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
45
players. “Nice to try once” –solutions do not lure users in the long run. The Fitness Adventure prototype offers possibilities for creating new stories and outdoor game environments. An interesting view is that in the near future, the games could offer game creation tools for the users, so that the users could themselves create stories for different games. Taking into account the research character of the Exergame project, we were developing and evaluating a prototype, and thus have not much to say of the possible success of FA as a ready made product. In the user studies, we concentrated mainly on the usage qualities of the FA prototype. However, we are aware, that besides usefulness and usability, also other quality attributes that represent the underlying values, habits, assumptions and expectations of middle-aged and aging people have a great impact in the actual purchase decision (Leikas and Saariluoma 2008a). For example, it is commonly known that the everyday exercise should become a habit in order to be efficient. In order to succeed in fulfilling this need people long for professional help in terms of counselling and advice. The health care professionals should respond to this need. It is important also to notice that there were essential differences between female and male subjects in their interests. The male participants were focussed in their sports performance while the female participants emphasized cultural interests. This difference reflects differences in the male and female middle-aged people’s forms of life (Leikas and Saariluoma 2008a, b). This on its behalf illustrates how important it is for user experience designers to investigate the contents of the forms of life of different user segments.
References 3D Innovations. (2008). PCGameBike Home Page. http://www.pcgamerbike.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Adidas Ag & Polar Electro Oy. (2008). Adidas-Polar. http://www.adidas-polar.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Apple Inc. (2008). Apple – Nike + iPod. http://www.apple.com/ipod/nike/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Asikainen, T.-M., Suni, J. H., Pasanen, M. E., Oja, P., Rinne, M. B., Miilunpalo, S. I., Nygård, C.-H. A., & Vuori, I. M. (2006). Effect of brisk walking in 1 or 2 Daily bouts and moderate resistance training on lower-extremity muscle strength, balance, and walking performance in women who recently went through menopause: A Randomized, controlled trial. Physical Therapy, 86(7), 912–923. Atari Gaming Headquarters – Atari Project Puffer Page http://atarihq.com/othersec/puffer/ index.html. Accessed 19 September 2008. Buttussi, F., Chittaro, L., & Nadalutti, D. (2006). Bringing mobile guides and fitness activities together: a solution based on an embodied virtual trainer. In Proceedings of the 8th conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile Devices and Services (pp. 29–36). September 2006, Helsinki.
46
A. Väätänen and J. Leikas
Carraro, G. U., Cortes, M., Edmark, J. T., & Ensor, J. R. (1998). The peloton bicycling simulator. In Proceedings of the third symposium on Virtual reality modeling language (pp. 63–70). Monterey, California. EasyGPS. http://www.easygps.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Davis, S. B., Moar, M., Jacobs, R., Watkins, M., Riddoch, C., & Cooke, K. (2006). ‘Ere be Dragons: Heart and Health. Pergames’06 Third International Workshop on Pervasive Gaming Applications. Dublin, Ireland. Groundspeak Inc. (2008a). Geocaching – The Official Global GPS Cache Hunt Site. http://www.geocaching.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Groundspeak Inc. (2008b). Wherigo – Tools for creating GPS-enabled adventures. http://www.wherigo.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Halti Ltd. (2008). Halti Ai Jacket. http://www.halti.fi/dynamic/2/1372.html. Accessed 19 September 2008. Höysniemi, J. (2006). International Survey on the Dance Dance Revolution Game. Computers in Entertainment (CIE), 4(2). InterAction Laboratores Inc. (2008). Exerstation. http://www.ia-labs.com/ViewFitnessMarket.aspx? ID=13. Accessed 19 September 2008. IPerG – Integrated Project of Pervasive Games. http://www.pervasive-gaming.org/index.php. Accessed 19 September 2008. ISO 13407. (1999). Human-centred design processes for interactive systems. International standard. International Standardization Organization. Geneve. Konami Digital Entertainment. (2008). Dance Products. http://www.konami.com/Konami/ ctl3810/cp18756/cl0/Genre?attrib_search=Y&attrib_cnt=1&attrib_id_0=2340&attrib_value_0= Dance. Accessed 19 September 2008. Lainio, S., Väätänen, A., Välkkynen, P., Heinilä, J., Lakaniemi, S., & Mänttäri, A., Mäenpää, S. (2001). Virku – Virtual Fitness Centre. International Congress on Bridging Sport, Excercise and Lifestyle Activity for Health. February 2001, Lahti, Finland. Finnish Society for Research in Sports and Physical Education, 35–37. Lampila, P. & Lähteenmäki, L. (2006). Relationship of motives and attitudes towards new playful ways to exercise. 20th Annual Conference of the European Health Psychology Society. August and September 2006, Warsaw, Poland. Psychology & Health, 21(1), 87. Lappset group Ltd. (2008). SmartUs Playgrounds. http://www.smartus.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Leikas, J., Mattila, J., Cluitmans, L., & Urhemaa, T. (2003). IMS - Intuitive Movement Sensing Method. In Smart Objects Conference: Proceedings (pp. 200–203). May 2003, Grenoble. Leikas, J. & Lehto, R. (2006). Mobile Fitness Application for the Ageing Population. In Proceedings of the ASK-IT 2006 International Conference. October 2006, Nice, France, ASK-IT & European Commission. Leikas, J. & Saariluoma, P. (2008a). Older People’s Representations of ICT-Services: Female Cautiousness Effect. In Proceedings of Workshop on Cognition and the Web: Information Processing, Comprehension and Learning (pp. 97–100). April 2008, Granada, Spain. Leikas, J. & Saariluoma, P. (2008b). ‘Worth’ and mental contents in designing for ageing citizens’ form of life. Gerontechnology, forthcoming. Mattila J. & Väätänen A. (2006). UbiPlay: an interactive playground and visual programming tools for children. In Proceeding of the 2006 conference on Interaction design and children (pp. 129-136). June 2006, Tampere, Finland. Mokka, S., Väätänen, A., Heinilä, J., & Välkkynen, P. (2003). Fitness computer game with a bodily user interface. In Proceedings of Second international conference on Entertainment computing, ICEC. May 2003, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh, PA, USA. Nintendo. (2008). Wii at Nintendo. http://www.nintendo.com/wii. Accessed 19 September 2008. Nokia Corporation. (2008a). Mupe – Main: Mupe. http://www.mupe.net/. Accessed 19 September 2008.
Human-Centred Design and Exercise Games
47
Nokia Corporation. (2008b). Nokia Nseries N95. http://www.nseries.com/products/n95. Accessed 19 September 2008. Nokia Corporation. (2008c). Nokia Europe – Nokia 5500 Sport support. http://europe.nokia.com/ A4164325. Accessed 19 September 2008. Rasinaho, M., Hirvensalo, M., Leinonen, R., Lintunen, T., & Rantanen, T. (2006). Randomized controlled trial on the effect of physical activity counselling on physical activity among older people. 18th Nordic Congress of Gerontology (pp. 36). May 2006, Jyväskylä. Ruoppila, I. (2002). Psyykkisen toimintakyvyn tukeminen. In E. Heikkinen & M. Marin (Eds.), Vanhuuden voimavarat (pp. 119–150). Helsinki: Tammi. Ryan, R. M., Frederick, C. M., Lepes, D., Rubio, N., & Sheldon, K. M. (1997). Intrinsic Motivation and Exercise Adherence. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 28, 335–354. S60 Home. (2008). http://www.s60.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Sony Computer Entertainment Europe. (2008). EyeToy®: Kinetic. http://www.eyetoykinetic.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Sony Ericsson. (2008). Sony Ericsson – Mobile phones – Overview – W710i. http:// www.sonyericsson.com/cws/products/mobilephones/overview/w710i. Accessed 19 September 2008. Stepmania. http://www.stepmania.com/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Strömberg, H., Väätänen, A., & Räty, V.-P. (2002). A Group game played in interactive virtual space – Design and evaluation. In Proceedings of DIS2002: Designing Interactive Systems (pp. 56–63). June 2002, London. Suomela, R., Räsänen, E., Koivisto, A., & Mattila, J. (2004). Open-Source Game Development with the Multi-User Publishing Environment (MUPE) Application Platform. Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Entertainment Computing 2004. In M. Rauterberg (ed.), Lecture Notes in Computer Science 3166 (pp. 308–320). Springer. TopoGrafix. (2008). GPX: the GPS Exchange Format. http://www.topografix.com/gpx..asp. Accessed 19 September 2008. Van Heuvelen, M., Kempen, G., Brouwer, W., & De Greef, M. (2000). Physical fitness related to disability in older persons. International Journal of Experimental, Clinical and Behavioural Gerontology, 46(6), 2000. VTT. (2008). Exergame project. http://virtual.vtt.fi/exergame/. Accessed 19 September 2008. Väätänen, A., Leikas, J., Heino, I., Liikka, J., & Pihlajamaa, O. (2007). Fitness Adventure – location based fitness game. In Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on Pervasive Gaming Applications (pp. 107–113). June 2007, Salzburg, Austria. Aachen, Germany: Shaker Verlag Gmbh.
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments Cases Talarius and Virtual Peatland Tuula Nousiainen Agora Center, University of Jyväskylä P.O. Box 35, FI-40014 University of Jyväskylä, Finland
[email protected]
Abstract: This paper discusses the involvement of children in the design of two game-based learning environments, Talarius and Virtual Peatland. The aim of the study was to explore the experiences of both the children and the developers related to the children’s participation in the development process and on the participation activities employed in the projects. The first project, Talarius, indicated that while the children enjoyed the project as a whole, there were problems with providing them with a genuine feeling of ownership and with the children recognizing their contributions in the final outcome. Hence, the framework of user involvement that was used as the basis of the Talarius project was further expanded by bringing in principles and practices from other disciplines. This extended multidisciplinary framework was applied in the second project, Virtual Peatland. This did not eliminate all the problems with the children being able to track the evolution of the application from the initial ideas to the final outcome, but especially the inclusion of content creation activities was very important to the children as it made their creations directly visible and thereby promoted their feeling of contribution.
1 Introduction Child-centred perspectives have arisen as an emerging approach for addressing the relationship between children and technology in the field of human-computer interaction (HCI). Traditionally, much of the research regarding children and technology has focused on the impacts of technology on children and their learning, but in the recent years there has been growing interest in the roles of children in the design of software aimed for them, and a child-centred way of looking at technology design has been brought into discussion in an increasing amount (Bruckman and Bandlow 2003; Druin 2002). 49 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 49–66. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
50
T. Nousiainen
Children’s involvement in technology design is heavily based on the principles of user-centred design which is seen by many researchers as a successful approach in software design. The user-centred design cycle (ISO 13407, 1999) implies that users can have an active role in setting the goals, refining them iteratively, and evaluating the outcomes. However, in practice user-centred design often puts heavy emphasis on user testing in the later stages of the development, thereby placing the users in a position in which they are merely reactors to suggested solutions, not initiators of ideas (e.g., Scaife et al. 1997; Nesset and Large 2004). This leads to a question whether the input of users, adults and children alike, could be better valued by involving them in more varied ways (e.g., Nesset and Large 2004). This is emphasized especially in participatory design, a design philosophy based on the ideals of workplace democracy and empowerment. Moreover, it is worth looking outside the scope of software development techniques, especially when the participants are children. Approaches such as the sociological view of active citizenship related to the participation of children in the design of their school and living environments (e.g., Francis and Lorenzo 2002; Gallagher 2004; Johnson 2000; Kiili 2006), participative gaming culture and usercreated content (e.g., OECD 2007) and child-centred pedagogy (e.g. Chung and Walsh 2002; Clark 2005; Hujala 2002) have potential in providing new ways of looking at children’s involvement in technology design. This paper deals with the development projects of two game-based learning environments and the analysis of children’s involvement in them. In both projects, the children participated throughout the process, but the emphasis of the activities and the intensity of the collaboration differed between the projects. In the first project, the development process of a computer board-game design environment Talarius (Axén et al. 2004), the children provided ideas at the beginning of the project, but the main emphasis was on the testing of prototypes. Children’s experiences from this project led us to try a somewhat different approach in the other project, Virtuaalisuo (Virtual Peatland). In this project, in addition to shifting the focus onto the early stages of design, we also included content creation as one part of the approach, aiming to give the children more hands-on activities. In this paper, I will describe these approaches, examine their effects on how the children saw their roles in the projects, and discuss the general successfulness of the projects in terms of user involvement. Furthermore, I will take a look at learning from the participation in a technology development project. In Section 2, I briefly describe the process of studying the two development projects that were examined in this study. Section 3 presents the framework of user involvement which was used as the basis of the children’s involvement in the first project, Talarius. The Talarius project and the results obtained from studying the project are presented in Section 4. In Section 5, an extended, multidisciplinary version of the earlier framework is presented, and Section 6 discusses the Virtual Peatland project, in which this framework was applied. The paper concludes with a summary and discussion in Section 7.
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
51
2 Research Process The Talarius and Virtual Peatland projects were studied using the principles of case study research (Yin 1994) and development research (Richey et al. 2004; van den Akker 1999). Development research is employed in studies of educational interventions, addressing either the intervention itself, the process of developing it, or both (Richey et al. 2004; van den Akker 1999). The emphasis in this study was mainly on examining the development process. Experiences related to the development process were gathered both from the perspective of the children and that of the developers. The data consisted of development documents, outcomes of the design processes, interviews and questionnaires to the developers and the child participants, and observation of the design process documented in research journals. The data was analyzed using a framework consisting of several research questions as a basis of analysis. From the children’s point of view, the research questions were principally related to whether they felt that their ideas had had an effect on the final outcome, how they perceived their own expertise in the project, and how they experienced the participation activities in general. From the developers’ perspective, it was examined how they felt the children’s participation and ideas aided their work and affected their development decisions. Additionally, design session outcomes were compared to the final products in order to examine how the ideas provided by the children manifested in the final applications.
3 Children’s Involvement in the Design of Technology Principles and methods for bringing users into the design process of technological solutions have mainly been derived from the HCI perspective on user involvement. These approaches have, however, mostly been used in the development of productivity tools with adults. When it comes to designing educational or entertainment applications for children, a recently emerged perspective is child-computer interaction (CCI) which applies methods from user-centred and participatory approaches to this specific context (e.g., Read 2005). Moreover, the design of educational software has broadened the mere HCI perspective towards principles of pedagogical design: an approach referred to as learner-centred design (LCD) has been introduced as a way of bringing together the HCI point of view on the one hand and educational and developmental principles on the other (Good and Robertson 2006; Rode et al. 2003; Soloway et al. 1994; Soloway et al. 1996). Figure 1 illustrates the components of the traditional HCI view as well as the broadened child-focused view. Within the CCI/LCD viewpoint, various techniques have been developed by researchers for involving children in the development of applications aimed for
52
T. Nousiainen
Fig. 1. User involvement: Traditional HCI view and the expanded CCI/LCD view.
them: the focus has been especially on techniques supporting their involvement in the earliest phases of the design process. Several studies have employed requirements gathering techniques that have been specifically tailored to children, in order to provide an alternative for traditional interviewing. Such techniques include, for example, photo diaries (Oosterholt et al. 1996), the KidReporter technique in which children create ‘newspaper articles’ related to the themes of the application to be developed (Bekker et al. 2003), and the ‘Mission from Mars’ method entailing an innovative interview technique and enhanced with photo collage creation (Dindler et al. 2005; Verhaegh et al. 2006). Also, various creative techniques based on drawings (Bilal 2003; Scaife and Rogers 1999), storyboarding (Hall et al. 2004; Jones et al. 2003), and collaborative low-tech prototype creation (Druin 2002, 2005; Druin et al. 1999) have been used on order to gather more specific ideas related to the functionality and appearance of the application. The next section discusses the first case to be presented in the paper, namely the development of a game creation tool called Talarius. Children were involved at different phases of the development process, with the aim of employing principles and methods from the aforementioned framework.
4 Case I: The Development Project of Talarius The aim of the Talarius project was to develop a software tool with which children can both create and play educational games. The games that can be made and played with Talarius are typical board games where the players throw the dice and proceed accordingly along the path on the board, having to answer questions and complete different tasks on the way. The idea came from a teacher whose class had made
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
53
concrete board games in class in the previous school year. The teacher came up with an idea of making such games in a digital form, and this idea further extended into one of game-making software. Working in pairs or small groups, the children gather material relevant to the topic of their game (factual texts, images, sounds, videos). Based on this material, they create questions, design a game board, and play games created by their classmates. This paper deals with the development project of the pilot version of Talarius, which took place in the academic year 2003–2004.
4.1 The Process of Involvement The same class (23 children, ages 11-12) that made the original board games was the principal participant group in the project. The process of their involvement in the project was as follows. At the beginning of the project, the children were interviewed about their previously created board games. Later they made user interface drawings depicting either the game-making mode (see an example in Figure 2) or the game-playing mode of the application (Figure 3), and while they were drawing, they were informally interviewed regarding their wishes related to the functionality of the software. The use of low-tech materials in creating initial designs has been a commonly used method in user involvement both with adults and children, and applying a variant of such activities was seen as a feasible choice also in this project. The main benefit is that no technological skills are required, and therefore everyone has a similar possibility to participate (Bødker et al. 1993). Moreover, children are used to creating things using art supplies and materials, and this way they can also express themselves without needing to formulate their ideas verbally (e.g. Druin 1999, 2002; Druin et al. 1999). A significant drawback of using drawings as a design tool is, however, that children often pay a great deal of attention to small details in their drawings, overlooking the “big picture” and the functionality of the application (e.g. Scaife and Rogers 1999). Despite these potential problems, it was decided that user interface drawings be used in the project in order to allow the children to freely express their ideas. Based on the drawings and the interviews, the developers created several different user interface alternatives in the form of computer mock-ups representing different modes of the software, and the children evaluated and critiqued them. Later on in the project the children evaluated two different prototypes, the latter of which was evaluated by their parallel class as well. Computer mock-ups and prototypes are a core part of user-centred design (ISO 13407, 1999) in that they allow the users to give feedback on the outcomes of each development cycle. Moreover, they can bring the users into a more contributing role in the process, as it is possible to incorporate their suggestions quickly into the application in the next cycle (Rudd et al. 1996).
54
T. Nousiainen
Fig. 2. A user interface drawing representing the game creation mode.
Fig. 3. A user interface drawing representing the game playing mode.
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
55
The partner class also created contents (a series of questions) to be used as pilot content in the latter of the prototype testing sessions. In the vein of learner-centred design (LCD), the aim was to make the evaluation sessions to support rather than disrupt their normal school work (cf. Rode et al. 2003) – in other words, to ensure that the questions were suitable to the grade level and relevant in terms of the topics they were currently studying in class. At the end of the active development phase, there was an informal “launch session” in which the children got to see and use the finished pilot version. Finally there was one more session, in which the children gave feedback for future development and evaluated the sounds of the application. After the pilot version of the application was finished, the partner class continued to participate in the form of one field trial period in the school.
4.2 Results To the children, participation in a technology development project was an interesting experience. They reported having been motivated by being able to be involved in a real project and to have a role in the development of a real software application. As regards the particular participation activities used in the project, concrete activities – drawing and prototype testing – were preferred and seen as interesting. This notion was supported both by direct comments from the children in the interviews and questionnaires and by cues such as one boy specifically asking the developers in a later session whether the children’s drawings had been helpful to them. However, there were some significant challenges in the approach, most importantly related to the children’s feeling of ownership. Even though most of the children stated that they had been listened to, had a chance to participate actively, and been able to express their opinions, they had difficulties recognizing their contribution in the final product. Only a few of them felt that they had really had a say in the development of the application. Even though the children reported noticing, in general, that changes were made to the application after each time they gave feedback, individual students did not feel that their ideas “got through”. On a related note, they mainly appeared to consider their role in the project to be that of feedback providers. My own ideas haven’t really shown, [but] something has been done [to the application] anyway. (A child in the final questionnaire) Well, you know, if you want for example some [specific] intro music and some [others] want something else and there are more of them, so then they win, in a way, if there are more of those who said that. (A child in the final questionnaire)
For the developers, on the other hand, the children’s contribution was important in many aspects of the development work. They reported that the children’s ideas and feedback guided the development of the appearance, the functionality, and the
56
T. Nousiainen
usability of the application. Interestingly, an important issue mentioned by them was also the positive effect the close collaboration had on the developers’ work motivation. According to them, as they got to know the children they were working with, they wanted to do their best to make the outcome meet their expectations in order not to let them down. Additionally, the direct and immediate feedback they obtained from the children also serves as an extra motivator. Moreover, as the developers had little previous experience of designing applications for (or with) children, during the project they gained a great amount of new knowledge. They learned to understand what user involvement meant, gained knowledge about children as technology users, and obtained experience on technological skills. However, as the main challenge they mentioned time constraints. Intense user involvement required a great deal of time resources, and especially the scheduling of the activities to be carried out in the school presented a number of problems in the course of the project. In both phases, [our] work motivation has been excellent […]. The good motivation is possibly partially explained by the fact that [we] considered it an important task to make this application for the pupils of the partner class, and we did not want to disappoint them. All the members of the group have been very committed to the project work in both phases. (Developers’ phase report: Take-into-use and closing phases) According to the developer group, fitting schedules together, for example when planning dates for the user testing sessions, was one of the problems of the project. For instance, the evaluation of existing applications failed to be carried out because of time-related issues […]. (Research journal)
The process of the Talarius project roughly followed the UCD cycle (ISO 13407, 1999) and, moreover, attempts were made to direct the approach towards learnercentred design through taking the educational point of view into account. The process consisted of several iterations, each of which ended with an evaluation phase. The users were involved already when requirements were gathered, in the form of the UI drawings and the interviews, but all in all the emphasis was rather heavily on evaluation. As mentioned above, the children mainly saw themselves as providers of feedback, and their role as initiators of ideas was not recognized by them. This issue reflects the notion that the users’ role in UCD is often “too little, too late” (Scaife et al. 1997) and that the UCD process puts the users in a reacting role rather than an initiating one (Scaife et al. 1997; Nesset and Large 2004). In summary, although this structure was successful from the developers’ point of view, the process leading from ideas to the final outcome was not transparent enough for the children to be able to see their contributions. When the developers used and merged individual ideas they obtained, for example, from the children’s drawings, this manifested to the children as if their suggestions and ideas went into a “black box”, and when they came out of the “box” in the form of design solutions, they no longer recognized them as their own ideas. Although they did acknowledge that the prototype developed gradually, they could not see links between this development and their ideas, which caused them to lose their sense of ownership over the ideas and the outcomes. Such problems have been discovered in
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
57
projects carried out with younger, preschool-aged children (Guha et al. 2004; 2005), and the Talarius project seems to suggest that the same challenges exist also when working with older children. Guha et al. (2004; 2005) have suggested a way for addressing this problem – a technique called Mixing Ideas in which individual ideas are merged into collective ones. This technique, or a variant of it, is likely to be fruitful also with older children. It can also respond to another need, namely reducing the developers’ work load when it comes to analyzing design session outcomes. Another potential reason for the children not seeing their input in the outcome was that their contributions were not concrete enough. When they were evaluating the application, they were excited to see their own set of questions as pilot material in it, and some of the children even saw the question set as their principal contribution in the project. As mentioned above, the main goal of having children design a sample question set was to make the evaluation activities fit their school work in the best possible way, but the content creation was more important to the children than expected – it would seem that in order to feel ownership, children need to see their input very concretely. Hence it might be useful to take certain concrete content creation activities as a part of the participation process, if this is feasible considering the nature of the software being developed. In conclusion, it would look that there is a need to further expand the traditional UCD approach and the more pedagogically oriented LCD approach, and to look for additional ways of working with children in the design of technology in order to support their sense of contribution and ownership of the outcome. This matter will be discussed in the next section.
5 Broadening the Approach of Children’s Involvement In the previous section, the need to expand the approach of children’s involvement in technology design was recognized. The framework presented in Figure 1 is now used as a multidisciplinary basis onto which the extended framework will be built. There are approaches in e.g. educational sciences and sociology that particularly aim to enhance children’s empowerment and active participation, and these could lend something to technology design as well. Moreover, in the field of games, usergenerated content is a very prominent phenomenon today – and closely related to users’ desire to see their own concrete creations in the final outcome. Figure 4 represents this extended view to user involvement. In sociology and childhood studies, children’s active participation in the making of decisions concerning them has been studied mainly in the context of designing and living environments together with children (e.g. Francis and Lorenzo 2002; Gallagher 2004; Johnson 2000; Kiili 2006). In child-centered pedagogy, the aim is to emphasize such educational activities that originate from the child’s own world
58
T. Nousiainen
Fig. 4. Broadened view to user involvement.
of experience, taking their own culture and interests into account and allowing them to be actors in their environments instead of merely passively receiving instruction (Hujala 2002; Kinos 2001, 2002). Hence, involving children in the design of technological applications that are to be used as educational tools can be seen as one way of giving them a voice in issues that concern them and their learning. “Listening to children” (Clark 2005) is an active, two-way process that utilizes not only verbal interaction but other forms of expression as well. Finding appropriate methods to enable active participation is thus a key issue in establishing collaboration with children. Finally, game content creation has become all the more popular and widespread recently: members of different game-based virtual environments are provided with tools for creating various new game objects (OECD 2007, 16). However, currently the attention paid by developers to content creation only addresses games that are already released, in an attempt to explore and influence player behaviour (Sotamaa et al. 2005). As the Talarius project illustrated, however, there is also a link between user involvement in technology design and this type of voluntary active participation of the players. In other words, content creation can be a way of involving users in the development of technology, especially game-based learning environments.
6 Case II: The Development Project of Virtual Peatland The second case project discussed in this paper, Virtual Peatland, was based on the extended view presented above. In this project, the aim was to create a webbased learning environment about peatlands that includes text-based information
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
59
sections as well as interactive and game-like parts, aiming to educate especially young learners about peatland ecosystems, the use of peatlands, and other related themes. The project was carried out during the years 2005 and 2006. An elementary school class (approximately 25 children at a time, ages 11-12) participated in the process through various workshop sessions, each of which dealt with a specific aspect related to the structure of the learning environment or presentation forms to be used in it. The extended perspective above was used as a background for the process, with special emphasis on content creation activities.
6.1 The Process of Involvement The workshops started with an initial idea creation in the spring of 2005. For one term (autumn 2005) the activities were almost weekly: there were researcher-led design sessions approximately every other week, and in the alternating weeks the class worked on the tasks independently, continuing the activities that had been kicked off in the previous collaborative session or making preliminary preparations for the next session. At the later phases of the project, the collaborative sessions were less frequent and were carried out when each prototype was ready to be evaluated. In addition to the participation of the partner class, field trials were conducted with several other groups later, when the learning environment was finished. First, the children’s initial ideas were gathered into an idea map. As pointed out in the previous section, there was a need to introduce a technique that proceeds from individual to collective step by step. Guha et al. (2004; 2005) have addressed this need by developing a technique for merging drawings, but in the context of this project, idea-map creation was seen as a more feasible variant of this idea. This was due to the notion that at this point of the project, it was most important to collect ideas especially related to the content of the learning environment, and not yet so much on its appearance. The steps of the idea map creation process consisted of 1) creating individual lists of ideas, 2) group discussions and potential changes to the lists, 3) making one collective list with the whole class, and 4) compiling the idea map. These ideas were reviewed with the children later, and other, more concrete idea maps in the form of collages were created in small groups. In the collage creation, the aim was to find out which information presentation forms (e.g. crossword, quiz, info text, webcam) and peatland species (animals, plants, mushrooms) were especially interesting in the children’s opinion. Using paper snippets each of which represented either one species or one presentation form, the children made collages that expressed both the topics they would like to learn about and the ways in which they would like to learn about these topics. A collage technique was chosen in order to avoid some potential problems with drawings, such as putting too much effort and emphasis on secondary details at the expense of the main focus of the task (Scaife
60
T. Nousiainen
and Rogers 1999) and the issue with some children possibly being apprehensive about their drawing skills (Hart 1997, 162). Next, the children evaluated and critiqued a few existing websites in order to assess what works and what does not work on web-based learning environments, to discover new ideas for Virtual Peatland, and to clarify the concept of a web-based learning environment to the children. Gathering ideas by using existing technologies is a rather commonly used technique in user-centred design, aiming to uncover potential problems, user preferences, and ways of interacting with particular types of technology (e.g. Druin et al. 1999; Jones et al. 2003). These classroom sessions were followed by a slightly different activity, namely a peatland excursion where they took photographs of peatland nature and filmed video presentations of peatland plants to be included on the Virtual Peatland site. The topics of their video presentations were chosen by them based on the most frequently mentioned species in the collages. The following week, the children examined and discussed the pictures and video clips in class, and chose the best ones by voting. The best-voted photos and all video clips were included on the website; the video clips in a section called “Children’s Peatland”, and the photos as virtual postcards. The creation videos and pictures was one form of children’s content creation in the project, and in addition to these, they also created content in the form of quizzes and puzzles related to peatland nature. Similarly as the topics of the video clips, the topics and types of the quizzes were chosen based on items mentioned in the collages. The quizzes were implemented in the “Children’s Peatland” section as well. Additionally, the children worked on general game-related ideas for a few sessions. A brainstorming about game ideas was held, and drawings were made related to the game idea and game characters. Finally, the children evaluated the learning environment at different phases.
6.2 Results One principal difference between this project and the Talarius one was the inclusion of content creation activities which in this case consisted of making quizzes, taking photographs, and shooting video clips. Similar types of tasks – such as the photo diary and “newspaper article” techniques (Bekker et al. 2003; Oosterholt et al. 1996) – have been carried out in some technology development projects, but in these cases the aim has been to collect requirements with the aid of them, not content creation per se. Instead, content creation has only taken place when users produce something by using an application that enables the creation and sharing of contents of some type. In order to address the problems children have had with recognizing their input and feeling ownership over the outcomes, the children
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
61
were now given a possibility to make something concrete to be included in the application that was being developed. The results of the analysis of the interview and questionnaire data indicated that the content creation was very important to the children. Many children reported the content creation tasks, such as the quizzes and the video clips, to have been the most enjoyable, motivating and memorable activities in the project. Those quizzes were nice in that you could kind of really design them yourself. (A child in the final interview) [We could] again, just for fun, [go and] shoot those clips. (A child in the final interview)
The researchers who observed the project noted the children’s motivation as well. The children were particularly enthusiastic during the sessions when they were working on the contents they were producing. Moreover, as regards the creation of the quizzes, the class had taken the initiative and started preparing them already before the researcher-led session involving quiz-creation. The students, in general, appeared to work enthusiastically. They were motivated to find different plants and they observed the nature with interest. […] Watching the photos and the videos was very interesting to the children; it appeared that they were excited about seeing their own creations. (Field journal: the peatland excursion and reviewing its outcomes) Making quizzes was very interesting to the students, as they had independently been working on quizzes related to different topics. […] The students are especially interested in designing, such as the design of the quizzes. (Field journal: making the quizzes)
In addition to the content creation aspect, another difference in comparison with the Talarius project was the structure of the process. The workshops, each of which was aimed to build on the outcomes of previous ones, were intended to make the process more smooth and the evolution of the ideas more transparent to the children. On the most general level, the idea maps yielded ideas about what Virtual Peatland could include. These ideas were then taken onto a more detailed level by making collages and by evaluating existing websites. Next, in the content creation activities these ideas were made concrete in the form of quizzes, pictures, and video presentations. Despite these efforts, however, this project did not manage to fully avoid the aforementioned “black box” phenomenon, especially in terms of the activities that were related to the development of the game application to be included in Virtual Peatland. While the evolution of ideas came through in the process described above (from general ideas to more concrete ones and further to hands-on creations), the effects of their game-related ideas remained unclear to the children. There were several reasons for this, mainly boiling down to inadequacies in terms of coordination within the development group. One problem was the lack of sufficient game design and subject area expertise at the time when the participation activities were being planned, which led to the design session outcomes not fitting the needs of these fields as well as they could have, and to the game-related
62
T. Nousiainen
materials (e.g. the game drawing) made by the children being left aside for a large part. Moreover, the interaction between the children and the developers during the game development phase suffered from this stage of the project taking place in the summer when the school class was not available to give continuous feedback. One of the issues that were paid special attention in the Virtual Peatland project was what the children learned from participating in the project. Druin (1999) has presented areas of design-centered learning that have emerged in her projects. These areas include learning about the design process, respect for the design partners, group communication and collaboration, technology-related skills and knowledge, and content issues. In the Virtual Peatland project, the categories discovered were much alike these: 1) content-related issues, 2) design skills, 3) social skills, and 4) general learning skills. Firstly, content-related learning was in a big role because the application itself is, and thereby also the design activities were, strongly focused on one theme, i.e. peatlands. The children stated to have learned general factual knowledge about peatland nature especially due to searching information to serve as background material for their quizzes and video presentations. Moreover, some children mentioned learning “meta-knowledge” about peatlands; for example that peatlands are a versatile theme that is related to several school subjects, not only e.g. biology. I know where cranes winter, and that cottongrass belongs to the sedge family. And cottongrass grows in tufts. (A questionnaire response) Peatlands can be studied in many ways. Peatlands can be studied in many school subjects. (A questionnaire response)
The second category consists of design skills. They can be can be classified into design skills of a more general nature and skills related to more specific aspects of design. The former category includes, for example, learning more methodical and effective ways of working, while the latter deals with e.g. learning new ways of using techniques like collages and idea maps. I learned how to work together, how to make a website and how to work gradually. (A questionnaire response) [I have learned] how to develop characters and quizzes. (A questionnaire response)
Thirdly, social skills were important as group work was an integral part of most of the design sessions. The enhancement of the children’s social and communication skills in the course of the project is related to their readiness to voice their own opinions, to listen to others’ views, and to build on each others’ ideas. I learned to listen well and I came up with quite a lot of ideas. (A questionnaire response) I learned group work. Something about peatlands, and not to be nervous during presentations. (A questionnaire response) [I learned] that it’s fun to do things in groups, and that you learn and get more [out] of everything. (A questionnaire response)
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
63
The fourth category of learning deals with the development of the children’s general learning skills, such as searching information, comparing sources, and evaluating the reliability of the information found. These skills were needed epecially when the children were compiling their quizzes and preparing their video presentations. [I learned] that there are a lot of things with the aid of which you can find information about something, and that you can find a lot of information also on the Internet through search engines. (A questionnaire response) I can maybe make better texts now and I have learned to search for information too. (A questionnaire response)
To summarize the experiences obtained from the Virtual Peatland project, certain aspects of the project succeeded better than in the Talarius project – especially the importance of the content creation activities with regards to the children’s experience of ownership was clear. However, not all problems were avoided. Some of the challenges of the Talarius project manifested now as well – especially the “black box” phenomenon still transpired also in this project.
7 Conclusions and Discussion As a general conclusion from the two projects discussed in this paper, it can be said that the participation in a development process of a game-based learning environment was very motivating and enjoyable to the children as they obtained new kinds of experiences, whereas the principal problem was the feeling of ownership and contribution. Several lessons were learned based on the experiences obtained from the projects, and I will conclude by presenting some key issues that need to be considered in such projects in the future. Most of these are related to the participation activities, and making them better respond to the needs of the children and the developers alike. The project needs to include a variety of participation activities of different kinds in order to avoid the tasks to become boring to the children. Furthermore, there needs to be a balance between different activities in terms of several different dimensions such as the generality or specificity of the outcomes (e.g. initial idea creation vs. evaluation focused on specific issues), the tangibility or non-tangibility of the activities (hands-on techniques vs. interviews or brainstorming), and the creative or reactive nature of the tasks (i.e. making something from scratch vs. giving feedback on something that exists already). The inclusion of concrete content creation activities, the outcomes of which are directly visible Ensuring that the children see the links between their ideas and their implementation is another main issue. This presented problems in both of the projects. The “Mixing Ideas” technique developed by Guha et al. (2004; 2005) is a way of merging individual drawings gradually into a collective one. In the same vein, there is a need for a way of merging ideas from one session to another also when each session
64
T. Nousiainen
consists of a different type of activity, which can be even less straightforward than merging several items of one kind into one. A related point is the importance of talking with the children themselves about the interpretations and analyses made by the developers based on their creations – which should be obvious but is often disregarded due to tight schedules and other practical issues. One way of help the developers to find the most important ideas from children’s creations, for example, is to annotate the drawings (or other outcomes) according to the creator’s instructions (Hart 1997, 162–163). As stated above, a main reason for the children’s ideas not being adequately taken into account in the development of the Virtual Peatland game were problems with coordination within the developer group, mainly related to not having the expertise of all necessary perspectives available from the very beginning and failing to develop a common understanding of the way the project would be carried out. Despite respecting others’ views, the members failed to genuinely see outside their own areas of expertise. Therefore it is necessary to state the common principles explicitly and in as much detail as possible already when the process is being planned in order to ensure that everyone is committed to them. In the future, we will further explore and extend the multidisciplinary framework for involving children in the design of learning environments. Building on the experiences obtained from the projects discussed in this paper, we will aim to enhance the ways of children’s participation to better respond to the needs that were still inadequately addressed in these projects. Acknowledgments: Funding for the projects discussed in this paper has been provided by the National Technology Agency of Finland, the State Provincial Office of Western Finland, and the European Social Fund. The author would also like to thank all the children and their teachers as well as the development teams for collaboration.
References Axén, J., Härkönen, R., Kankaanranta, M., Nousiainen, T., Oinonen, A., Riekkola, R., & Ukkonen, M. (2004). Talarius – Lasten pelinsuunnitteluympäristöä kehittämässä. In M. Kankaanranta, P. Neittaanmäki & P. Häkkinen (Eds.), Digitaalisten pelien maailmoja. University of Jyväskylä. Bekker, M., Beusmans, J., Keyson, D., & Lloyd, P. (2003). KidReporter: a user requirements gathering technique for designing with children. Interacting with Computers, 15(2), 187–202. Bilal, D. (2003). Draw and tell: children as designers of web interfaces. In Proceedings of the 66th annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science & Technology (pp. 135–141). Long Beach, CA, USA. Bruckman, A. & Bandlow, A. (2003). HCI for kids. In J. Jacko & A. Sears (Eds.), The human-computer interaction handbook: Fundamentals, evolving Technologies, and emerging applications (pp. 428–440). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum. Bødker, S., Grønbæk, K., & Kyng, M. (1993). Cooperative design: techniques and experiences from the Scandinavian scene. In D. Schuler & A. Namioka (Eds.), Participatory design: principles and practices (pp. 157–175). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Children’s Involvement in the Design of Game-Based Learning Environments
65
Chung, S. & Walsh, D. J. (2000). Unpacking child-centredness: a history of meanings. Journal of Curriculum Studies 32(2), 215–234. Clark, A. (2005). Listening to and involving young children: a review of research and practice. Early Child Development and Care 175(6), 489–505. Dindler, C., Eriksson, E., Iversen, O. S., Lykke-Olesen, A., & Ludvigssen, M. (2005). Mission from Mars – a method for exploring user requirements from children in narrative space. In Proceedings of the 2005 conference on Interaction design and children (pp. 40–47). Boulder, Colorado, USA. Druin, A. (1999). Cooperative inquiry: developing new technologies for children with children. In Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems (pp. 592– 599). Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA. Druin, A. (2002). The role of children in the design of new technology. Behaviour & Information Technology 21(1), 1–25. Druin, A. (2005). What children can teach us: developing digital libraries for children with children. Library Quarterly 75(1), 20–41. Druin, A., Bederson, B., Boltman, A., Miura, A., Knotts-Callahan, D., & Platt, M. (1999). Children as our technology design partners. In A. Druin (Ed.), The design of children’s technology (pp. 51–72). San Francisco: Morgan Kaufmann. Francis, M. & Lorenzo, R. (2002). Seven realms of children’s participation. Journal of Environmental Psychology 22(1-2), 157–169. Gallagher, C. B. (2004). “Our town” – children as advocates for change in the city. Childhood 11(2), 251–262. Good, J. & Robertson, J. (2006) CARSS: A framework for learner-centred design with children. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education 16(4), 381–413. Guha, M. L., Druin, A., Chipman, G., Fails, J. A., Simms, S., & Farber, A. (2004). Mixing ideas: a new technique for working with young children as design partners. In Proceeding of the 2004 conference on Interaction design and children (pp. 35–42). College Park, Maryland, USA. Guha, M. L., Druin, A., Chipman, G., Fails, J. A., Simms, S., & Farber, A. (2005). Working with young children as technology design partners. Communications of the ACM 48(1), 39–42. Hall, L., Woods, S., Dautenhahn, K., & Sobreperez, P. (2004). Using storyboards to guide virtual world design. In Proceeding of the 2004 conference on Interaction design and children (pp. 125–126). College Park, Maryland, USA. Hart, R. A. (1997). Children’s participation: the theory and practice of involving young citizens in community development and environmental care. London: Earthscan Publications. Hujala, E. (2002). Uudistuva esiopetus. Oulu: Varhaiskasvatus 90 Oy. ISO 13407. (1999). Human-centred design processes for interactive systems. Geneve: International Organization for Standardization. Johnson, J. M. (2000). Learning as part of the design process. In J. Johnson: Design for learning: values, qualities and processes of enriching school landscapes. http://www.asla.org/latis1/ LATIS-Process.htm. Accessed October 2006. Jones, C., McIver, L., Gibson, L., & Gregor, P. (2003). Experiences obtained from designing with children (pp. 69–74). In Proceeding of the 2003 conference on Interaction design and children, Preston, UK. Kiili, J. (2006). Lasten osallistumisen voimavarat. Tutkimus Ipanoiden osallistumisesta. Jyväskylä Studies in Education, Psychology and Social Research 283. Kinos, J. (2004). Lapsilähtöinen varhaiskasvatus. In E. Hujala (Ed.), Puheenvuoroja lapsista ja varhaiskasvatuksesta. Oulu: Varhaiskasvatus 90 Oy. Kinos, J. (2002). Kohti lapsilähtöisen varhaiskasvatuksen teoriaa. Kasvatus 2/2002, 119–132. Nesset, V. & Large, A. (2004). Children in the information technology design process: a review of theories and their applications. Library & Information Science Research 26(2), 140–161. OECD. (2007). Participative web: user-created content. DSTI/ICCP/IE(2006)7/FINAL. http:// www.oecd.org/dataoecd/57/14/38393115.pdf. Accessed December 2007.
66
T. Nousiainen
Oosterholt, R., Kusano, M., & de Vries, G. (1996). Interaction design and human factors support in the development of personal communicator for children. In Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems (pp. 450–457). Vancouver, Canada. Read, J. (2005). The ABC of CCI (Child Computer Interaction). Interfaces 62, 8–9. Richey, R. C., Klein, J. D., & Nelson, W. A. (2004). Developmental research: studies of instructional design and development. In D. Jonassen (Ed.), Handbook of research for educational communications and technology (Second edition.) (pp. 1099–1130). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Rode, J. A., Stringer, M., Toye, E. F., Simpson, A. R., & Blackwell, A. F. (2003). Curriculumfocused design. In Proceeding of the 2003 conference on Interaction design and children (pp. 119–126). Preston, UK. Rudd, J., Stern, J., & Isensee, S. (1996). Low vs. high-fidelity prototyping debate. Interactions 3(1), 76–85. Scaife, M. & Rogers, Y. (1999). Kids as informants: Telling us what we didn’t know or confirming what we knew already? In A. Druin (Ed.), The Design of Children’s Technology (pp. 27–50). San Francisco: Morgan Kaufmann. Scaife, M., Rogers, Y., Aldrich, F., & Davies, M. (1997). Designing for or designing with? Informant design for interactive learning environments. In Proceedings of the ACM CHI ’97 Human Factors in Computing Systems Conference (pp. 343–350). Atlanta, Georgia, USA. Soloway, E., Gudzial, M., & Hay, K. E. (1994). Learner-centered design: the challenge for HCI in the 21st century. Interactions 1(2), 36–48. Soloway, E., Jackson, S. L., Klein, J., Quintana, C., Reed, J., Spitulnik, J., Stratford, S. J., Studer, S., Eng, J., & Scala, N. (1996). Learning theory in practice: case studies of learner-centered design. In Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems CHI’96 (pp. 189–196). Sotamaa, O., Ermi, L., Jäppinen, A., Laukkanen, T., Mäyrä, F., & Nummela, J. (2005). The role of players in game design: a methodological perspective. In Proceedings of the 6th DAC Conference – Digital Experience: Design, Aesthetics, Practice (pp. 34–42). Copenhagen, Denmark. van den Akker, J. (1999). Principles and methods of development research. In J. van den Akker, R. M. Branch, K. Gustafsson, N. Nieveen & T. Plomp (Eds.), Design approaches and tools in education and training (pp. 1–14). Dordrecht: Kluwer. Verhaegh, J., Soute, I., Kessels, A., & Markopoulos, P. (2006). On the design of Camelot, an outdoor game for children. In Proceeding of the 2006 conference on Interaction Design and Children (pp. 9–16). Tampere, Finland. Yin, R. K. (1994). Case study research: design and methods. (Second edition). Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning – a Framework for Development and Analysis Bente Meyer1 and Birgitte Holm Sørensen2 Department of Curriculum Studies, School of Education, Aarhus University 164 Tuborgvej, 2400 Copenhagen NV, Denmark 1)
[email protected], 2)
[email protected]
Abstract: In the paper we shall argue for the potential of serious games for teaching and learning languages online. The paper builds on data from a research project, Serious Games on a Global Market Place (2007–2010), in which an online gamebased platform for teaching and learning English (www.Mingoville.com) has been studied in the context of teaching and learning English in Danish primary schools. The initial research process – which was based on an analysis of the platform as well as interviews with platform developers – suggested that one of the challenges of developing a design for serious games in language education consists of renegotiating the serious games genre to balance drill-based exercises with contextualised simulations that involve fruitful thinking, real language interaction and student engagement. One hypothesis of the project is, following the initial research and drawing on previous research in the field, that the process of designing serious games for CALL may significantly benefit from involving children’s own experiences with using languages (primarily English) online for gaming and interacting. This to some extent involves transcending the dichotomy of ‘serious’ and ‘pleasurable’ learning found in the discourse on learning with games inside and outside schools.
1 Introduction In this paper we shall explore the complexity of a game-based design for learning focusing on language learning as a specific field of competence. Our focus will be on the analysis and development of an educational design for a platform used for teaching English as a foreign language in primary schools in Denmark, www.mingoville.com. The context of this analysis is a project in Serious Games on a Global Market Place (2007–10)1 in which academics work with companies 1
The project is funded by The Danish Council for Strategic Research under The Programme on Creativity, Innovation, New Production Forms and the Experience Economy 69
M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 69–82. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
70
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
to explore, build and implement game prototypes, using the products and experience of commercial game designers to develop knowledge about serious game challenges, educational design, and assessment with the aim of innovation. The aim of the paper will be to explore the challenges of designing and conceptualising game-based material for language learning in the context of this project. One aspect of these challenges will consist in studying the ways in which gaming is associated with ‘serious’ as well as ‘pleasurable’ learning, and with formal as well as informal learning. The paper will suggest ways of incorporating these perspectives into the educational design of game-based material for CALL.
2 Designing Serious Games for Language Learning – a Framework for Analysis Designing game-based material for learning may be understood as a process that involves three levels: a practice level, an organisation level and a theoretical reflection level (Dale 1989, 2000). Design as a concept can be defined as the plan or the model of what should be produced. According to Cobb et al. (2003) design experiments in learning involve both a pragmatic approach, understood as the “engineering” of specific forms of learning, and a theoretical approach, i.e. a study of the forms of learning used within the context in question. In the Serious Games project it is our aim to work respectively with engineering game-based language learning and with what Katrin Becker describes as “a reverse engineering process” (2007, 478), i.e. a process of uncovering instructional design principles in existing educational games. This double strategy of analysing existing games and generating theoretical concepts and practical methods for innovative product development, has provided a framework for the ways in which our research may potentially predict the benefits and learning outcomes of serious games locally as well as globally. In the project we use both platform analysis, classroom observations and interviews to study design principles and best practice for serious games design. In the first phase of our research, described below, we have been focusing on uncovering the learning content and theory, as well as the concept of gaming (including the role of players/learners and teachers) embedded in the Mingoville platform (Figure 1). The platform analysis has been supported by interviews with platform designers. Our theoretical framework is inspired by a wide range of research fields such as educational design theory, game and play theory, informal learning, anthropological studies in children’s cultures and CALL (Computer Assisted Language Learning). If we look at the educational use of games in general we see a number of game types that all affect the understanding and design of serious games. These educational uses of games can, we propose, be divided into three main categories.
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
71
Fig. 1. The Mingoville universe.
1) Edutainment and learning games. Edutainment can be described as the earliest example of a game-based learning type and can be understood broadly as a concept where entertainment is used to facilitate learning. Games of the edutainment type are generally designs to be used without teacher intervention. In addition to this edutainment may be associated with developmental and learning theories that do not correspond to contemporary ideas of learning and schooling (EgenfeldtNielsen 2005). 2) Research based educational games are made for educational use e.g. in schools and involve teacher intervention. In this category we place serious games. Serious games may be understood as the second generation of learning games in which educational design has been adjusted to the learning theories of modern schooling. In this context Katrin Becker claims that “games have the potential to offer an inquiry-based, constructivist approach that allows learners to engage with the material in an authentic, yet safe environment” (Becker 2007, 480). 3) Games for entertainment are not designed for educational use but are sometimes used in the educational system to facilitate learning in different subjects e.g. the games Civilization and SimCity which have been used to facilitate respectively history and social studies (Egenfeldt-Nielsen et al. 2008). In this paper we focus primarily on the relationship between the first two types of games, i.e. edutainment and serious games. In the case of Mingoville.com, the platform studied in the Serious Games on a Global Market Place project, the platform can generally be understood as gamebased material of the edutainment type in the sense that it combines entertainment
72
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
(‘fun’) and learning, as well as conceptualises play as an activity that teaches children something in order to convince parents and teachers that learning can be fun (Egenfeldt-Nielsen 2005; Sutton-Smith and Kelly-Byrne 1984; Johannesen 2006). In Mingoville children of 9-11 years meet the Pinkeltons, who are citizens of the simulated world Mingoville – a city inhabited by flamingos. The platform contains 10 Missions that take the learners through a variety of themes such as The Family, Colours and Clothes, Numbers and Letters. These are basic areas for vocabulary learning defined in the national curriculum for English. The Mingoville platform can be described not as a full game in itself, but rather as a web-based learning environment that capitalises on the mini-games and other entertainment activities that children engage in their spare time outside school. In addition to this the platform refers to school activities such as reading, listening and spelling.
3 Understanding Serious Games In the Serious Games on a Global Market Place project we understand serious games as digital games and equipment with an agenda of educational design and beyond entertainment (Meyer and Sørensen 2007). This approach is consistent with the argument, made by game theorist James Paul Gee that “Good commercial video games are by no means trivial phenomena. They are deep technologies for recruiting learning as a form of profound pleasure” (Gee 2003, 211). Gee’s contention addresses the fact, often discussed in educational game theory, that gaming is understood to be inimical to school culture as educational cultures rest on the “dominant cultural (op)positioning of play and education” (de Castell and Jenson 2003, 654). Consequently, play and gaming are understood to represent childish activities that are potentially disruptive and antithetical to schooling where ‘real’ and ‘serious’ learning is supposed to be the aim of the activities. Gaming is, as claimed by for instance de Castell and Jenson, a fundamentally unpopular culture in schools, a fact that influences teachers’ views on gaming as well as their practice (de Castell and Jenson 2003). One of the most significant aspects of studying serious games is then to ask the question of how games and play can be integrated into a culture of schooling that has traditionally been inimical or at best ambivalent about gaming as an educational activity. As suggested by Rieber (1996, 43) work is respectable, play is not which is why play and gaming are often confined to spaces outside the classroom. Baltra (1990, 446) similarly argues that “the game is over at school” as educational cultures often choose to stifle pupils’ engagement in gaming once they are past preschool learning. This emphasis on school cultures and their conceptual links with rational thinking and a ‘weberian’ work ethic (Fromme 2003) highlights the cultural aspects of serious game analysis and design, as serious games may aim to target the goals and ‘recognisable’ educational content of formal schooling – but are defined
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
73
by the leisure cultures that exist out of school. The apparently oppositional cultures of formal education and the ‘frivolous’ consumer cultures of gaming must consequently affect the design of serious games, specifically if the games in question have a commercial as well as an educational purpose. Games may have been reconceptualised as ‘serious’ by recent game theory (cf. Gee 2003), but they are also generally (still) associated with the ‘fun’ and pleasurable learning that allegedly engages learners (specifically children and young people) in meaningful practices where they may have a sense of their own value in and control over learning and interaction. As suggested by Kirriemur and McFarlane (2006) games can support children’s experimentation, exploration, imagination and role-play, and research repeatedly underlines that in gaming children “take on the role of teachers, providing advice, support, hints, tips and models of learning to other children”. Motivation must in continuation of this be seen as a central issue in understanding gaming as a ‘serious’ business, i.e. as being intrinsically motivating and pleasurable as well as enhancing performance. However, the use of games for motivational purposes alone may entice designers to conceptualise gaming as a form for facilitating and containing traditional learning rather than as an integrated model for meaningful performance and learning by doing. The consequences of this view is, according to de Castell and Jenson (2005, 18), that “learning is structurally posited as unpleasant and the challenge is to determine what forms of “sugar” are both most effective for learning and most rewarding for learners”. This ‘sugar-coating’ of learning with ‘fun’ may to some extent marginalise children’s engagement in gaming as part of a playful consumer culture. This perspective on motivation brings us back to the idea of edutainment, the idea that gaming is ‘fun’ and that the fun of gaming can facilitate learning in the sense that it affords positive feedback, pleasure and reward for persevering and studying. The implications of these aspects for analysing and developing the Mingoville platform will be discussed below.
4 Conceptualising the Design of Serious Games Through CALL Game theory conceptualises gaming in a number of ways that may be significant for language learning. As suggested above theories of serious games are contextualised by both formal and informal practices of learning and interacting. The informal practices of learning through gaming are highlighted by among others Gee who claims that “Learning in school could involve strong doctrine, values and identity, smart tools, distributed knowledge, well designed experience, guidance on how to build useful mental models or simulations and on how to evaluate their outcomes, performance before competence, competence that goes beyond verbal definitions and test taking (Shaffer, 2004). But, in reality, this is all very rare indeed in school, though common in good video games”. (Gee 2005, 222)
74
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
Others, such as Kurt Squire, argue that understanding how learning occurs through game play can be used to support learning in formal learning environments (Squire 2002). Most theorists agree, however, that engaging in game activity may potentially support pleasurable learning, learning by doing, and learning through collaboration (Kirriemur and McFarlane 2006). This indicates that there is a clash between cultures of schooling and informal learning environments that serious gaming may transcend, but which must also define how games can be received, used and assessed in formal learning contexts, and, consequently, how they can be designed for learning. In the analysis of Mingoville.com language learning has been understood to be a significant aspect of children’s engagement in games as a socially valued way of performing as language learning is involved in children’s use of games as a social practice primarily out of school (Meyer 2006; Sørensen 2002). When children play games in online environments they often emphasize interactivity, collaboration and individual action as significant practices. Interactivity is here understood in a broad perspective as communication patterns in conversation, consultation, transmission and registration (Jensen 2000). These understandings to some extent coincide with communicative approaches to language learning, i.e. the prioritisation of negotiation and communicative ability over for instance focus on form (Warschauer and Kern 2000; Warschauer and Healey 1998). In out of school contexts, children thus generally understand and use languages as a means for communication, information gathering and gaming, whereas in schools the understanding and use of languages is often understood to be a goal of the activities, i.e. an aspect of an intended learning process in which language may be understood as an internal system to be learned (Sørensen and Audon 2004; Meyer 2006; Warschauer 2004). As argued by Warschauer (2004, 23), interactivity and the fulfilment of a meaningful purpose for a real audience is a significant issue in using internet activities for language learning as “the purpose of studying English…becomes not just to acquire it as an internal system but to be able to use English to have a real impact on the world”. Though games and simulations have generally been part of language learning for decades (Crookall 2007; Li and Topolewski 2002) relatively little research has been made in the use of computer games to support language learning and instruction. In addition to this, game based learning through CALL (Computer Assisted Language Learning) has generally focused on university students ESL (English as a Second Language) learning rather than children’s learning (Crookall 2002). According to Ang and Zaphiris (2006) the lack of research in game based language learning is mainly due to the diversity and complexity of game material accessible which makes it difficult to assess the role of games in language education (Ang and Zaphiris 2006). Crookall and Oxford (1990, 7), on the contrary, argue, based on their interest in and experience with simulation and gaming in language learning that “simulation/gaming techniques are proving to be an extremely powerful means of helping people to acquire certain foreign or second language skills”, these skills being mainly communicative skills, understood broadly. Crookall
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
75
and Oxford are not specifically concerned with computer assisted gaming and simulation, however, in later work (for instance Crookall 2002) Crookall and others do acknowledge the significance of simulation and gaming activities for CALL. The relevance of these activities for language learning are primarily to create a language learning environment in which learning is focused on meaning rather than form, authentic communication is introduced into the classroom, low anxiety environments are created that motivate and engage learners, and situations are supported that make learners use language as a real communication tool (Baltra 1990; Li and Topolewsky 2002; Garcia-Carbonell et al. 2001). Game-based learning can thus contribute to communicative goals in language learning as in games and simulations students are “working with language not as an end in itself but as a medium to achieve a communicative goal” (Baltra 1990, 450).
4.1 Developing Enjoyable Games for Second Language Learning In our analysis of the Mingoville platform we have been inspired by research on the motivational aspects of gaming, as they have been discussed by Ang and Zaphiris (2006) on the subject of serious games for CALL, and by Malone (1981) and Malone and Lepper (1987) in their taxonomies of intrinsic motivations for learning. The motivational perspective on gaming for language learning have provided us with a theoretical framework for describing the concepts of the ‘fun’ and ‘the serious’ as they appear and take on meaning in the design principles of for instance the Mingoville platform. In addition to this we have drawn on earlier research done at the School of Education on children’s use of English when gaming in their spare time outside school. This research has shown that when games are used in the design of learning materials for CALL, children draw on their experiences with using English in gaming outside school. This may be significant for motivating children to learn languages as well as for language competence and performance. In their article on developing enjoyable second language learning software tools Ang and Zaphiris (2006) distinguish between an extrinsic and intrinsic design of learning games. These concepts build on the theory of motivation suggested by Malone (1981). The significance of Malone’s taxonomy for CALL is, according to Ang and Zaphiris (2006, 10) “that game design could be applied in language learning with two methods: the learning of the material as well as the learning of the game itself ”. In Ang and Zaphiris definition extrinsic games are games where language learning content is generally superimposed on the game itself, creating a split between the language learning content and the game setting. Extrinsic games are largely effective, Ang and Zaphiris claim, for motivating learners to engage with ‘boring’ and repetitive work such as drills and rote learning. The main function of the game setting in extrinsic game design is therefore motivational. The main feature of
76
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
intrinsic games is, on the contrary, that learning contexts and game narrative are seamlessly integrated, to create a complete learning situation. The focus of intrinsic games for language learning is therefore mainly learning the language while engaging actively with characters and narrative of the game. Narrative thus becomes an affordance for the exploration of for instance target language conversation or the cultural aspects of the target language. Following the analyses made by Malone and Ang and Zaphiris we can suggest that narratives and intrinsic motivation are crucial factors in the design of serious games for language learning. According to this argument, designers should first of all investigate what fantasy theme the target user is interested in. If the user does not like the fantasy theme the designer has chosen, it is likely that the design will be a failure. Secondly, the learning content should be part of the game design, and not presented as detached items of words or characters, i.e. the game design must be intrinsically motivating, not extrinsically motivating. Thirdly, the narrative should be able to stimulate the player to know what happens next, i.e. motivate through curiosity. Curiosity is, as suggested by Malone (1981) incited through among other things the twist of narrative plots. Finally, the learner’s control over the game and the learning tasks is crucial for the flow and acquisition of the learning content. In short, narrative is central to the integration and meaningful engagement with the educational content of the game.
4.2 Narrative and Intrinsic Motivation in Mingoville In Mingoville, a narrative framework is referred to in the use of themed platform missions that learners must engage with and complete in order to learn content such as English vocabulary and spelling. The missions of the platform generally consist of individual tasks, among them games, that children must solve or play to complete the individual missions. However, there is no consistent narrative structure in the platform that learners can engage in as the tasks are not explicitly integrated into a story. The mission is thus not a narrative quest, but a recognizable form – often used in games – that contains the thematic contents, drills and tasks of the platform. In addition to the missions a narrative framework is referred to in the use of avatars (flamingos/Mingos) that are central actors in the platform’s tasks and missions. The Mingoville universe and its characters provide the platform with fantasy themes that target the age group involved, i.e. primarily children aged 9-11. However, the fantasy theme is not explicitly integrated into a narrative structure, but provides the child with a recognisable environment in which the learning can take place. Finally, curiosity is not directly targeted through narrative, as there is no consistent narrative or twist of plot. Curiosity is incited through a number of mysteries or puzzles hinted at in the individual missions, for instance “Why isn’t Jeff ’s ice machine working?”, however, these are not central to the design of the missions.
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
77
In the following we shall develop our analysis on the basis of Ang and Zaphiris’ principles for the design of enjoyable games for second language learning.
4.3 Extrinsic and Intrinsic Game Design Mingoville.com is as an online platform based on the idea that children learn and are motivated by problem solving and game activities rather than traditional skillsbased and textbook based material focusing on reading, writing, spelling and listening. Mingoville therefore – as well as presenting itself as a ‘serious game’ – generally seeks to exploit the ‘fun-factor’ of gaming and is structured around themes and activities that cater to children’s desire to explore, interact and play games. In this sense the platform refers to the motivational aspects of gaming and digital media in general, as it intends to tap into the informal learning activities of children – activities that involve language production and communication in online environments. However, the platform also aims at communicating to parents, teachers and other potential users and investors that gaming is not only ‘fun’ but also ‘serious’ and that the ‘seriousness’ of games can support curriculum aims and goals. In this sense the platform builds on an educational design in which interfaces and tasks to some extent refer to children’s out of school gaming cultures but where the navigation, content and rhythm of learning to a large extent implicates school genres that focus on learning as a goal rather than as a means of engaging in the game. In this sense the design of the platform only to some extent succeeds in integrating the activities of learning and fun, i.e. the ‘serious’ and the ‘frivolous’. The fun and motivational aspects of gaming are generally highlighted by the designers of the platform, who are mainly software developers and game designers. Teachers and researchers have been involved in conceptualising and assessing the Mingoville game design but they have not been central to the process of platform design. On the issue of the out of school activities of children and the ways in which these have inspired the design of the platform, one designer claims that “we realised that they (i.e. the children) master modern technology, for instance mobiles and computers, quite well…a lot of the boys not only had quite a large vocabulary in English, but also a good pronunciation that derived from different kinds of computer games such as Counter Strike. Both sexes were very interested in song contexts and music videos …” (Johannesen 2006, 27, our translation). Another pointed out that “if we can manipulate or entice children into feeling that this is fun and exciting, it looks good, it is made for me, and it is about all these things that I am usually not allowed to do in school, well, then we have done well with the design” (our translation). The designers of the platform have thus been explicitly focused on gaming as an element in children’s out of school activities that involved the use of English as a foreign language. This focus involved the exploration and exploitation of the fantasy themes of children’s engagement in for instance Counter Strike (conceptualised as largely a boys’ activity) and singing
78
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
and engaging in music videos (conceptualised as a cross-gender activity) for the educational design of the platform. The fun of gaming in this sense works not as an integrated principle in the platform, but rather as “a FORM (actually more accurately as a disguise) to make learning more palatable” (de Castell and Jenson 2005, 18). This we argue, defines the platform as an extrinsic game design.
4.4 Learner Control and the Flow of Narrative The missions themselves contain a number of activities that aim at for instance vocabulary training, spelling, and word recognition. These are largely tasks where learners have no real control of the content, but must listen, fill in or spell preprepared words. One of the few exceptions to this rule is a karaoke game where children can listen to a song performed by one of the characters and record their own version(s) of the song which can then be sent to parents and friends or uploaded on the website (Figure 2).
Fig. 2. The karaoke game.
Navigation is another issue involved in analysing learner control in the platform. The integration of the fantasy themes and leisure activities of children into the platform design are part of an narrative setting or form that uses avatars (flamingos) to embody meaning and action and to conceptualise the users’ (expected) process of moving from one level of competence to the next. Navigation, in this connection, moves largely through a linear rhythm, prompting the user to progress from one window to the following through a “next” button. Navigation thus mimes the turning of a page rather than engaging the user in the general flow of narrative. This coincides with a common feature of the platform which is the remediation
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
79
of the book genre (Bolter and Grusin 1996) for instance through the use of book icons and pagination in “My book” and “Dictionary” and in the platform’s use of moving figures on a still background (Figure 3). Remediation is thus the feature that connects the platform with traditional media used in language education (primarily printed media), media that may serve to legitimize game-based material as part of language learning. The mixture of media and genre references (books, games, narratives, drills, song contests) therefore aim at situating the design in both formal and informal learning environments, i.e. at introducing the dynamics of game-based ‘fun’ learning into a formal learning environment that seems to base its understanding of learning largely on printed media and on curriculum-based tasks and drills. In terms of narrative and the flow of learning the focus on the fun of learning mentioned above implies that whereas narrative works as an explicit (though undeveloped) framework for interacting on the platform, there is no consistent connection between the narrative intent of the design (i.e. the Missions and the actions of the avatars) and the tasks and exercises that learners are expected to work on. Thus, the individual tasks are connected with the Missions largely in the sense that characters (avatars) and settings are recognizable as recurrent frameworks for the individual tasks. The narrative is therefore not, as recommended by Ang and Zaphiris, a flow in which the player may engage or even lose him- or herself, but rather a loose framework for a number of largely skill-based drills and exercises that entice learners into training curriculumbased skills. In this sense, the use of gaming in Mingoville can be characterised as consisting of “a structured series of puzzles or tasks embedded in a game or narrative structure with which they have only the most slender connection” (Ang and Zaphiris 2006, 10).
Fig. 3. Remediation of book genres.
80
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
The aim of the platform thus seems to be to motivate learners to engage in language learning partly through reference to children’s gaming cultures in informal settings, partly by situating language learning through gaming in a school context that is recognizable to parents, teachers, as well as children. In this context language learning becomes largely goal-orientated and gaming through narrative a motivational aspect, an incentive, to engaging in traditional educational tasks. However, it may be worth noting, as stated by Malone and Lepper (1987, 227) in relation to different contexts of instruction “that children chose the activity for roughly 50% more time when the material was presented as a game rather than a drill”. This indicates that user expectations and the role of the digital media are at least as significant for children’s motivation as the content and quality of the tasks. In the second phase of our research we shall study how learners actually interact and learn with Mingoville in the classroom, i.e. how gaming and the conceptual framework of the platform works in practice.
4.5 Designing and Developing Intrinsic Games for Language Learning – Implications for Further Work This paper has attempted to account for and discuss some of the challenges involved in designing and conceptualising serious games for language learning in a context where commercial and academic perspectives on serious gaming intersect. The theoretical point of departure for these reflections has been on the one hand a broad definition of educational design in relation to serious games research that includes goals and content as well as practice levels, organisation levels and levels of theoretical reflection. On the other hand the paper has thematised educational design in relation to formal and informal contexts of learning that involve children’s perceptions of and activities in online gaming. From a serious games perspective the game related practices of children in out of school contexts are pivotal points of interest for a consideration of how games may be transformed from an extrinsic design that involves drill- and task-based educational material to contextualised simulations, i.e. an intrinsic design, that involves fruitful thinking, real language interaction and learner engagement. The above described game-based concept for teaching English in primary school – Mingoville.com – has served as an example of how game-based prototypes for educational use can be assessed and developed with the aim of innovation. The quality of the platform is that it provides a multimedia environment in which gaming is central and which aims to tap into children’s experiences with using English for gaming out of school. Compared to existing educational material for language learning Mingoville is definitely innovative. However,– in spite of its awareness of and reference to children’s engagement in online game activities out of school – Mingoville.com is to large extent based on game models that cater to school based and school initiated learning. These
Designing Serious Games for Computer Assisted Language Learning
81
models generally dichotomise the ‘fun’ and ‘the serious’ as formal and informal processes of learning are conceptualised as being generally incompatible. In this sense Mingoville.com exists on a dialectical edge between existing ideas of gamebased material for language learning and broader concepts of the ways in which games are associated with and used for learning outside school. The challenge of developing this design will therefore consist of renegotiating the educational games genre for CALL through specifically the production and performance aspects of game material, i.e. the use of interactivity, collaboration and exploration based simulations that allow children to perform within their own categories of achievement. This renegotiation of form and content will involve a consideration of and reference to curriculum restraints, school cultures as well as market factors that define the local and global significance of game-based material for CALL.
References Ang, C. S. & Zaphiris, P. (2006). Developing Enjoyable Second Language Learning Software Tools: A Computer Game Paradigm. In P. Zaphiris (Ed.), User-Centered Computer Aided Language Learning. Information Science Publishing. Baltra, A. (1990). Language Learning Through Computer Adventure Games. Simulation & Gaming, 21 (4), 445–452. Becker, K. (2007). Digital game-based learning once removed: teaching teachers. British Journal of Educational Technology, 38(3), 478–488. Bolter, J. D. & Grusin, R. (1996). Remediation. Configurations, 4(3), 311–58. Cobb, P., Confrey, J., diSessa, A., Lehrer, R., Schable, L. (2003). Design Experiments in Educational Research. Educational Researcher, 32(1), 9–13. Crookall, D. & Oxford, R. L. (1990). Simulation, Gaming, and Language Learning. Newbury House Publishers. Crookall, D. (2002). Editorial: Simulation and computer-assisted language learning. Simulation and Gaming, 33(2), 137–138. Crookall, D. (2007). Editorial: Second language acquisition and simulation. Simulation & Gaming 38(1), 6–8. Dale, E. L. (2000). Professionalisering og læring i organisationer. In P. Andersen & P. Frederiksen (Ed.), Innovation, kompetence, læring. Frederiksberg: Dafolo. de Castell, S. & Jenson, J. (2003). OP-ED. Serious Play. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 35(6), 649–665. de Castell, S. & Jenson, J. (2005). Video games and Digital Game Play – The New Field of Educational Game Studies. Orbit, 35(2). Egenfeldt-Nielsen, S. (2005). Beyond Edutainment: Exploring the Educational Potential of Computer Games. IT-University Copenhagen. Egenfeldt-Nielsen, S., Smith, J. H., & Tosca, S. P. (2008). Understanding Video Games: The Essential Introduction. Routledge. Garcia-Carbonell, A., Rising, B., Montero, B., Watts, F. (2001). Simulation/gaming and the acquisition of communicative competence in another language. Simulation and Gaming, 32(4). Fromme, J. (2003). Computer games as a part of children’s culture. Games studies, 3(1). Gee, J. P. (2003). What Video Games have to Teach us about Learning and Literacy. New York: Palgrave/Macmillan.
82
B. Meyer and B.H. Sørensen
Gee, J. P. (2005). Pleasure, Learning, Video Games, and Life: the projective stance. E-Learning, 2(3), 211–223. Jensen, J. F. (2000). Interactivity – Tracking a new Concept. In P. A. Meyer (Ed.), Communication, Computer Media and the Internet: a Reader. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Johannesen, J. (2006). Mingoville.dk – et eksempel på sproglige muligheder inden for it. Sprogforum .Tidsskrift for sprog- og kulturpædagogik, 38. Kirriemur, J. & McFarlane, A. (2006). Literature Review in Games and Learning. Futurelab. Li, R.-C. & Topolewski, D. (2002). ZIP & TERRY: a new attempt at designing language learning simulation. Simulation and gaming 33(2). Malone, T. W. (1981). Toward a Theory of Intrinsically Motivating Instruction. Cognitive Science, 5(4), 333–369. Malone, T. W. & Lepper, M. R. (1987). Making Learning Fun: A Taxonomy of Intrinsic Motivations for Learning. In R. E. Snow & M. J. Farr (Eds.), Aptitute, Learning and Instruction: III. Conative and affective process analyses (pp. 223–253). Hilsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Meyer, B. (2006). Languages with ICTs – ICTs with Languages. In M. Buhl, B. Holm Sørensen, B. Meyer (Eds.), Medier og It – Læringspotentialer. Danish University of Education Press. Meyer, B. & Sørensen, B. H. (2007). Serious Games in language learning and teaching – a theoretical perspective. In Proceedings of the Third International Conference of the Digital Games Research Association. Tokyo, Japan. Rieber, L. P. (1996). Seriously Considering Play: Designing Interactive Learning Environments Based on the Blending of Microworlds, Simulations, and Games. Educational Technology Research & Development, 44(2). Shaffer, D. W. (2004). Pedagogical praxis: The professions as models for post-industrial education. Teachers College Record. Squire, K. (2004). Replaying history. Unpublished doctoral dissertation in the field of instructional technology. Indiana University. Squire, K. (2002). Cultural framing of computer/video games. Game Studies 2. Sutton-Smith, B. & Kelly-Byrne, D. (1984). The Idealization of Play. In P. K. Smith (Ed.), Play in Animals and Humans. Oxford: Basil Blackwell Inc. Sørensen, B. H. (2002). Børnenes nye læringsfærdigheder – didaktiske perspektiver. In B. H. Sørensen, C. Jessen, & B. R. Olesen (Ed.), Børn på nettet. Kommunikation og læring. København: Gads Forlag. Sørensen, B. H. & Audon, L. (2004). Nye Læringsformer og rum – digitale medier i vidensamfundets skole. Forskningsrapport. In B. H. Sørensen, C. Jessen & B. R. Olesen (Eds.), Børn på nettet. Kommunikation og læring. København: Gads Forlag. Warschauer, M. (2004). Technological change and the future of CALL. In Fotos & Browne (Eds.), New Perspectives on CALL for Second Language Classrooms. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Warschauer, M. & Healey, D. (1998). Computers and Language learning: an overview. Language Teaching, 31, 57–71. Warschauer, M. & Kern, R. (2000). Introduction. In Warschauer & Kern (Eds.), Network-based Language Teaching: Concepts and Practice. Cambridge UP.
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning Experience from Developing a Language Learning Game Ellen Brox, Audun Heggelund and Gunn Evertsen Northern Research Institute P.O. Box 6434, Tromso Science Park, N-9294 Tromso, Norway
[email protected]
Abstract: A computer role-playing game for language learning was created in a European project. The process was challenging with a multidisciplinary team from three countries who did not know each other well before the project started. Game designers, linguists, pedagogues and teachers have different approaches to how such an educational tool should function. The requirements for the game were scarce before the project started, so it was up to the team to agree on the game design and contents. We early realised that we had to work much more closely together than what is common in educational projects, so we used virtual meeting rooms extensively in addition to many physical meetings. One important conclusion regarding the process is that small prototypes should have been made very early to enhance the understanding and cooperation between the writers and designers and those responsible for the pedagogical contents. Designers and pedagogical personnel should also have had a much closer cooperation in the early phases to better integrate the learning material into the game story. This paper discusses how we worked together to get consensus about the game. We will also touch upon some of the technical difficulties we had trying to satisfy all our requirements with the chosen open source platforms. We also say a few words about the first reactions of the target group. The focus is however on the process of making educational games and what can be learnt from this experience.
1 Introduction A Nordic multi-disciplinary team just finalised a Socrates/Minerva project where a computer role-playing game for language learning was developed. The project was based on the need for better learning material for the Finnish language in
83 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 83–96. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
84
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
Norwegian and Swedish schools. It was planned in 2004, and at that time most of the educational role-playing games the participants had seen were simple games for social situations. Most of us had more or less experience with different types of entertainment games though. Making a computer game requires a real multi-disciplinary team consisting of game designers, writers, programmers, etc. In an educational game one also needs pedagogical competence and knowledge about the discipline covered by the educational game. In addition the end users should be heard. In our case we had pedagogues and language experts as well as teachers from both Norway and Sweden. With such a diverse team not only across disciplines but also across borders there are bound to be diverting opinions. Traditional language learning is a linear process where one grammatical theme comes before another. Games are often nonlinear, enabling the player to move around more or less freely and thus maybe encountering the language in the “wrong” order. This was a real challenge in our project in addition to the long distances between the participants. Our game is static, and can design-wise not compete with pure entertainment games. We were uncertain about how this would be received by the target group of children aged 12-15. Obvious learning versus a game where the learning is hidden was also an issue in the development team. Our pedagogues also meant that everybody likes to learn, so it should be acceptable to find for instance language exercises in the game scenes as long as they contribute to the game. The game is incorporated with a learning management system (LMS) giving both pupils and teachers the possibility to follow and evaluate the learning progress.
1.1 Background The lack of up-to-date educational material for pupils learning Finnish in Northern Norway and Sweden was the main reason behind our wish to make a computer role-playing game for language learning. We started to discuss the idea in the early spring of 2004, and at that time this was viewed as an innovative idea. Finnish is taught as a second or foreign language in several schools both in Northern Norway and Sweden. The native languages and culture of Norway and Sweden are fairly similar, meaning that pupils also more or less would have the same basis for learning the Finnish language. We therefore wanted a cross-border project, and the EU life-long learning Socrates/Minerva program was a suitable target for an application. This program would also enable us to have a focus on the teachers who were to use the game in their education of children. We managed to set up a team from Sweden, Finland and Norway that both had the required competence and were interested in considering new digitals tools for the classroom.
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
85
1.2 Competence Requirements and Cooperation The main goal of a game development team is to make an entertaining good-looking immersive game. Making an entertainment game requires close cooperation between the different skills of its creators as game design and development is a multidisciplinary task. Bateman (2007) mentions writer, producer, designer, programmer and artist. Educational games add an extra dimension requiring competence about the subject to be learnt as well as about the schools, the curriculum, didactics and the target group itself. Musicians, psychiatrist, etc. may also be useful in game development. Entertainment games may have a good story, and the players will learn something while playing, for instance strategy and co-operation or even something from the game contents. And of course many kids around the world learn a lot of English through game-play. It is thus possible to utilise many entertainment games for learning as well, however it is more challenging for teachers both to find good ways to use them and to assess what is being learnt since learning is not the main aim of commercial entertainment games. McFarlane et al. (2002) state that “The greatest obstacle to integrating games use into the curriculum is the mismatch between the skills and knowledge developed in games, and those recognised explicitly within the school system”. When it comes to educational games, the development team has to be extended to ensure that the games will be useful in school. In this respect teachers are very important. One of the recommendations found in “The games and learning” handbook from the Futurelab (Sandford 2005) is that “games designers should work closely with teachers from the beginning of the development process, to ensure that the end product is appropriate from a pedagogical and practical viewpoint”. These additional experts join the team with different main objectives for the game, and they don’t always agree with the previously mentioned goals. Of course the game should still be entertaining and immersive, but it also has to contain the information that is to be taught, and the tasks shall not be about killing monsters but about understanding a foreign language or solving a physical problem. Assessment of what is being learnt is also a challenge in any game, also educational ones.
2 The Game 2.1 Game Description A short description of the game itself is useful before discussing some of the challenges during the development process. Our game (Brox 2006) is story-based, and
86
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
we used results from an early survey when making the script. “Exiting” was the word we saw most often in the replies from pupils, so we tried to make a story that was exiting. It starts with an animation where the player sits on a train reading a letter from his/her grandfather in the small town of Melumäki somewhere in Finland. The grandfather has asked the player to come because strange things are happening. He also says that this may be the last time that they can go fishing together in the forest near grandfather’s house. When the player arrives grandfather is gone, and he/she realises that words are disappearing from the speech of the townspeople. The player must find out where grandfather is, and why are the words disappearing? Is there anything that can be done to change this? The game prototype is small (Figure 1). It only consists of 10 scenes, and four of them are open from the beginning. There are non-playing characters in several scenes, and the player will get useful information and maybe even items (such as keys) if they choose the right dialogues. Items and exercises can also be found in the scenes. More scenes are opened either through getting the right information, being in possession of the right item or even through gaining enough points. The game has a chat functions, and it is possible to chat with other player at any time. In some scenes it is also possible to see other players (for instance in a market place). According to Gee (2005) players can increase their competence by seeking advice from other players, and the chat is one way they can to this.
Fig. 1. A scene with the playing character (front right) and a non-playing character (back left). The latest chat is seen at the bottom of the game window as is the backpack that contains items gained.
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
87
The game exercises are in three levels, and the level is chosen before starting the game. Solving exercises is the task that gives the most points. The game user interface is in Finnish with information and dictionary translations in Swedish, Norwegian and English. It is static except for start and end animations, but the non-player characters’ dialogues are spoken as well as written. Throughout the game one finds language exercises that open in a separate window. They don’t have to be solved to be able to continue the game but some exercises should be solved to get enough points to reach the last part of the game. The contents of the exercises are connected to the scene contents, meaning that the exercises about nouns are found in the scene where a non-player character is losing nouns. The game is web-based so that no program has to be downloaded and installed.
2.2 Assessment of Learning and LMS Assessment of what is being learnt is important in the classroom. Digital tools, whether they are games or other tools will not be used if they are not of value in the learning situation. If all the players learn is how to click on the right dialogues to get to the end we have failed. For this reason we incorporated the game in an LMS (learning management system, Brox 2007). This is software for delivering, tracking and managing training. The students will typically be organised into classes with online learning content and forums for students and teachers. More and more schools use such learning environments to organise the work and to keep the study material and student progress and results in folders. We wanted both teachers and pupils to be able to assess the learning progress. The players first have to log into the LMS as themselves. No matter which nickname they choose to use in the game, all game results are stored in the players’ folders. Ideally the game should be integrated into the actual LMS that each school is using. However, the integration between the game and the LMS is so extensive that this was not achievable within the project’s budget. For this reason in the current version we have a specific game LMS where the players log into a designated class. We chose the open source LMS Moodle (www.moodle.com), both because we needed the code to be able to integrate the game platform into the LMS (login information, log from the game, exercises) and because the tool Hot Potatoes (http://hotpot.uvic.ca/) used for most exercises in the game already was integrated into Moodle (Figure 2). To enter the game in the LMS you have to choose a virtual classroom that contains the game. The organisation of the game classrooms is also a challenge; should there be one class for all players, one class for each school or one for each real class? Players can see one another in some scenes, and they can chat with all other players currently in the same game. Teachers can also see results of all players in
88
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
Fig. 2. The game window in Moodle. This player has three games running. All results will however bee stored in the player’s (Ellen Brox) folder. The classroom is called “SanatOn” which is also the name of the game.
their classroom. On one hand we want the pupils to meet pupils from other schools and maybe countries, on the other hand only the real teachers should be able to monitor the players’ results. Also the teachers might want to use the LMS for other language material as well, and not only this game. In the prototype there are separate classrooms for all the real schools that participated and one big test classroom for all other players. A combination of belonging to your own class and being able to play with pupils from other classes would have been nice. Then the teacher would only be able to see the results of their own pupils but the pupils would have the pleasure of meeting others in the game. Moodle does not have this feature but with more project resources this extension could have been added to the open source Moodle.
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
89
3 The Game Making Process 3.1 Our Team Socrates Minerva that was financing our project requires partners from at least three European countries. The idea about making a game came from Norway and was founded on the lack of up-to-date digital learning material for Finnish. Thus the initiative was Norwegian, and the technical developers as well as the responsible for the design and script were from Norway. The Finnish language experts were from Sweden, with didactical competence as well as knowledge about the curriculum. From Finland we had participants with artistic and game design competence. Finnish partners also developed a web-based course on ICT in language learning where the game played an important role. Teachers from Norway and Sweden participated. All together the core team of the project consisted of 11 people who worked closely together, and in addition teaches, students, pupils and other employers in the partner institutions assisted in the project. Thus in total we estimate that approximately 100 persons have either developed, tested or played the game in the project period. The teachers were a very important resource. They participated in the initial study as well as in the course where one assignment was to propose how one could use the game and it’s contents in language education. Of course they also participated in testing of the game and the learning material both with and without pupils. The main partners were the University of Umeå, Sweden, Palmenia Centre of Continuing Education at the University of Helsinki, Finland, Kotka and Kouvola departments, Northern Research Institute in Tromsø, Norway, the University of Applied Sciences in Kemi/Tornio, Finland and the County Governor of Troms, Norway.
3.2 How We Worked Game development requires teamwork, and we managed to work as a team across both disciplines and borders. Game design comprises everything that must be decided when converting a manuscript into a game story (Carr 2006). “The act of story creation is the most important creative task game writers face, as the story simultaneously makes up the bulk of the narrative and arranges all the game elements. … As such the game story needs to be crafted in careful collaboration with the rest of the team and the game designers in particular” (Bateman 2007). In our case, we also needed the consent of pedagogues, teachers and language experts.
90
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
The whole team was involved in discussing the manuscript, and important parts of the game were decided by consensus. More or less creative ideas came from everyone while the development team provided a cooling effect when the ideas would demand development efforts beyond the project’s means. Since this was a learning game, the pedagogical contents and planned levels within the game should also have been designed from the start. Unfortunately, we spent so much time achieving consensus on the main story line in the manuscript that there was little time left for making a thorough design before implementing the game. A more stepwise approach with an early prototype just showing a few scenes and game elements would probably have been a better approach. We would then have been able to demonstrate the capabilities of the different elements (Kirjavainen 2005). This would have helped the pedagogical team to see where best to add learning contents. Probably it would also have helped the writers of the main story to relate it to the actual game elements. Teamwork requires regular contact and we had numerous both physical and virtual meetings. Since most of us did not know each other before the project started, we needed to meet physically several times to get acquainted. Altogether we had 30 meetings including workshops and a seminar during the 2 years the project lasted. 16 of those were via Internet. In addition there were several work group meetings and extensive e-mail contact. We also had a common archive reachable by Internet so that the last version of material always was available for everyone, and it was easy to share material. We started the project with a tutorial about games to get a common idea about what we were going to make, and we also had seminars and workshops where we both discussed language learning and educational games. Initially we had planned several rounds with pilot group testing. We were however delayed because it took a very long time until we had decided upon an end to the game that everyone found satisfactory. For this reason it was mainly the project members who testes the game until very near the end of the project. Preliminary versions were however tried in the course, and we also had a workshop with teachers to get their reactions on the language contents and the exercises. ICT students in Finland also tested the game for errors before it was finished. In the following we will discuss some of the issues that had to be agreed upon to be able to finalise the project.
3.3 Game Versus Educational Tool As mentioned earlier, an educational game often has a different overall goal than a pure entertainment game, and there might be a conflict between the entertainment value and the learning outcome. We also realised that the experience and expectations of the two groups – the game designers and technical developers versus the educational team – were different. It seems that the “gamers” envisaged an
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
91
entertaining and exiting role-playing game with embedded learning whereas the educational team envisaged an educational game-based tool with exercises. Earlier in this paper we touched upon the fact that one often learns from entertainment games. Many games are for instance in a correct historical setting, thus giving the player knowledge about this epoch. It is a fact that playing MMORPGs gives strategic skills as well as skills in planning, cooperation and sometimes even leadership. The main language of most big games is English, and players with other mother tongues will soon learn some English. However, it is not always easy to assess the learning outcome, and how do we know that all the contents in a commercial historical game is correct, even though some of it is? And even if players learn English by communicating in online role-playing games it is not necessarily correct English. The conversations might be between non-native speakers learning each other’s mistakes instead of proper English. We also often find that a certain game slang is used that is not considered correct English in the real world – and certainly not in the classroom. The technical personnel in the project had studied the The Futurelab Handbook (Sandford 2005), and learnt that current game developments try to blend hard educational work into the act of playing a game. They describe “the pitfall of earlier learning games, such as those which only offer a period of play once a multiple choice question, a mathematical equation, or a spelling test have been completed” and “Learning should be integrated with game-play, rather than dividing the game content between ‘learning’ and ‘fun’. It should not be assumed that compromises can be made with fun purely because the game is designed to be educational”. On the other side, one also has to consider where the game-play is taking place. The handbook from Learning lab also states that a computer game does not necessarily have to be the latest, cutting edge edition since it is not competing against other games but against a whiteboard. “In a formal environment a game looks very different from in the living room.” (Sandford 2005). In our project we chose to make a game with many exercises, but none of them are mandatory and it is easy to leave an exercise at any time. However a certain amount of points are required to play the game through to the end, and points are best earned by solving exercises. The dialogues are an important part of the game, and selecting the best (most polite and at the same time showing that the question is understood) both gives the most clues and points.
3.4 Language Learning in a Non-linear Game One of the main areas of dispute in the project was the order of exercises and language material. In school language is taught in a certain order with present before past, and simple grammatical forms before more complex ones. The game designers on the other hand insisted on a non-linear game with hidden exercises and items.
92
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
Searching for game elements, including exercises is one of the aspects that make the game fun, the game designers claim. The partner in charge of the language material did not like the idea of a nonlinear game where dialogues and exercises could be stumbled upon in almost any order. Since we chose to make a non-linear game you can pass through the first couple of scenes before you start a dialogue with a character or find and open an exercise. Gros (2003) says that the digital generation is familiar with non-linear means of learning, and that children and adolescents are introduced to a form of organising information that is totally different from that used in writing. Also Prensky (2001) states that the students of today are no longer the people the educational system was designed to teach. “They prefer random access and they prefer games to ‘serious’ work”. The current version of the game is quite small, and it does not take long to play. This means that the players normally will play through at least most of the game in one round. Thus they should also have encountered most of the grammatical problems found in the exercises before they start to play the game. Based on this fact the order should no longer be of such significance. Also it is not necessary to solve any particular exercise to get through the game. The exercises are also found in the encapsulating learning management system together with a document stating the best order to use them in the classroom education outside of the game.
3.5 Suitability for Schools In entertainment videogames and role-playing games characters are often stereotypes, as stated by The Futurelab handbook (Sandford 2005): “Gender, nationality and racial difference are often misrepresented in games, where, for example, often females are ‘sexy’, often heroes are white, male Western, and other racial groups represented by negative stereotypes.” In games made for school education one has to tread carefully. Not only should we avoid the stereotypes mentioned, but also more subtle pitfalls must be eluded. We had long discussions about the reason behind the disappearing words. Many ideas ranging from the basis of the story line to the description of the characters were rejected during the writing process. We, the makers of the game, knew that gnomes stood behind the word disappearance and that it was some human activity in Melumäki they did not like. This could however not be something that made Finland appear like a bad country where such things could happen. We also wanted to place the game in a real Finnish town, but this was also rejected because we would not want this town to be viewed as worse than other Finnish towns. We had to be careful about how we described the non-playing characters as well. Some phrases were re-written many times to ensure they could not be interpreted
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
93
as ridiculing certain habits or traits. “She liked to follow the latest fashion and wore Burburry” was not accepted, neither was a statement about one wearing glasses. It is allowed to say that people are different and maybe behave odd sometimes, but making such remarks could make it sound negative. And there really is nothing odd about wearing glasses. Another consideration is of course that both the storyline and difficulty level shall suit the target group. The difficulty level not only applies to the language but also the game-play. The youngest children who tried the game found the introduction a bit sinister, which we found very encouraging. A bigger challenge was that the knowledge level of the Finnish language is substantially different between Norwegian and Swedish pupils who are entitled to Finnish. The Norwegian children can choose to learn Finnish without any prior knowledge whereas the Swedish pupils must have some basic competence, and thus the Swedish children might be younger when they master Finnish well enough to play.
3.6 Technical Challenges The technical team started with a requirements document based on the project description and preliminary discussions in the project team. The resources were scarce so we were looking for an existing open source game engine with interface and multiplayer features that could be integrated into an LMS. We also decided to make a web-based game to make it more accessible. There were some heavy opponents for using Flash for the entire game, but the development team did not at the moment have enough Flash skills. They were also afraid that it would require too much development resources and that it would be difficult to make a multiplayer game. They had found the open source platform DimensioneX (http://www.dimensionex.net/) that could be used. The appearance of this platform was however not what we wanted, and both the experienced players and designers reacted negatively to the user interface. After both discussions and a workshop the designers outlined a new user interface that was integrated on top of the platform using Ajax techniques. It is also possible to integrate modules made in Flash into the new user interface, so both the start and end animations and a puzzle in the game are in Flash. The game is entirely web-based. The main reason behind this decision is to make sure that as many schools as possible should be able to use it. Schools normally don’t allow installation of software, and they also have firewalls that can cause problems. The drawback with this approach is that it makes the game slow, since graphics and sound has to be loaded while playing. Particularly the transition between the game engine and the Hot Potatoes exercises take time. We also see that if the connection is slow, the entire game gets a hang-up so that it cannot be played.
94
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
4 The First User Reactions on the Game Two small groups of pupils aged 10-15 met to play the game at the very end of the project. The testing was not systematic, and of course the sample is so small that it does not have any statistic significance whatsoever. The trials could however give us some indication about whether we were on to something or the game was a total failure, and we had a small feedback form that we asked the test players to fill out. The first group of pupils was delivered on the doorstep of our research institute. These players were followed up by the development team – the only project participants who didn’t understand Finnish at all. They were placed in separate rooms. One of the kids had Finnish parents and spoke Finnish well whereas the others had started learning Finnish in school. They attacked the game very differently. The Finnish speaking kid was the youngest, but he understood the texts and helped the others after a couple of hours with game-play. He really worked with the texts and exercises, and one (for him) rather difficult exercise nearly drove him mad, but he didn’t give up. One kid used the dictionary extensively, and she also managed to understand the texts and find out how to proceed through hard work. The last example is the kid who knew the least Finnish, but who probably was the most experienced gamer. He quickly found out how to play, and also how to get enough points to go to the last part of the game by simple repetition. Except for this last example the others searched the game for exercises since they realised that this was the best way to get points. After about three hours they were finished, and some gathered around a computer to study the logs that they had found in the LMS. The second group was together with two Finnish teachers, and all of them were bilingual. They were sitting together in a lab outside their own schools. After four hours of game-playing the teacher literally had to drag them from the computers to reach a bus back to school. The only exception was a 16 years old boy who was significantly older than the rest (who were 11-12). He had the air of not belonging to the group from the very start, and he did not put any effort into playing the game, although he did mention there was not enough action. He also left after a short while. The rest of this group of kids searched the game for exercises and items. They also tried different levels of exercises. It seems like this last group had a bigger profit from the game than the first. There were three big differences between the two groups, and we don’t yet know what was the most significant; the presence of the teachers, the language knowledge or that they were sitting together in the same room. The test players mainly gave positive feedback on both the story and the layout. Some complained that the game was too short and they would have liked more scenes. The players in the small test groups did not use the chat function to discuss the game-play but they did try it out to contact each other. In these first tests we only wanted to test the game’s playability; that is weather the kids in the target group managed to play through all of the game and understood
Competence Complexity and Obvious Learning
95
the contents and that they found it fun to play. We did nothing to assess what they might have learnt, and we observed the playing with as little interference as possible.
5 Conclusions The conclusions will be given on three themes: • • •
The game itself The process of making a game How to play the game.
The small tests we had of the game, were encouraging. The players liked the game, but they found it a bit slow at times and some also complained that it was too small. The game is also rather slow, and when the bandwidth is too narrow it is not possible to play the game at all. Therefore it would have been nice with a downloadable version. It seems that the current version is best suited for the bilingual pupils since some of the dialogues are pretty complex. The end exercise is also a bit tricky and should be redesigned. Game design and development really requires teamwork, and this is not made easier when the participants are in different countries, and the communication is in a foreign language. This is however a common problem, and we started the project with a tutorial and discussion about games and learning games. It turned out that this was not enough to create a common platform. We had several discussions and professional disputes, but we managed to maintain the respect for each other’s field and ended up as a team that worked well together and who dared to express their opinion. However, the game designers and educators should have worked more closely together from the beginning, and small fast prototyping would probably have helped us reach a common understanding earlier. We should also have spent even more time in the beginning of the project to establish a common understanding. Small demos would most likely have helped. The small lab trials that we had also indicated that the environment in which the game is played makes a difference but we have not had the chance to look into that more closely. We did not have the trials in the classroom but took the children out of the school and placed them in a different environment. It also seems to be of importance whether there is a teacher present or not, and whether the game is played alone or in a group. It would be very nice to be able to evaluate the game properly looking at all these factors and also include gender; do boys and girls react differently to the game: do they play in different ways and do they learn the same? The main contribution to the area of educational game development is the integration of the game into an LMS and thus enabling logging of the progress and achievements in the pupils’ folders no matter how they choose to log into the game itself (name and gender). The game should one common place.
96
E. Brox, A. Heggelund and G. Evertsen
The team behind the game are now looking for further funding to be able to perform a more thorough evaluation that will direct the further development of the game. This further development address known weaknesses and take the evaluation results into consideration.
References Bateman, C. (2007). Game Writing, Narrative skills for Videogames. Boston, USA: Thomson Learning Inc, Charles River Media. Brox, E., Evertsen, G., Heggelund, A., Andreassen, M. (2006). Language learning through digital role-playing games. Report from an on going project, 5th European Conference on e-learning, Academic Conferences Limited (pp. 54–60). Brox.E., Evertsen, G., Heggelund, A., Bertling, B., Mokko, T., Tapiovaara, K., Lausas, P. (2007). Computer role-playing game integrated in a learning environment. In Proceeding at Inted 2007 – International Technology. Education and Development conference. Carr, D., Buckingham, D., Burn, A., Scott, G. (2006). Computer Games: text, narrative and play, Polity Press, UK. http://www.polity.co.uk. Gee, J. P. (2005). The Classroom of Popular Culture. What video games can teach us about making students want to learn, Harvard Educational letter. http://www.edletter.org/. Gros, B. (2003). The impact of digital games in education. First Monday, 8(7). Kirjavainen, A., Nousiainen, T., Kankaanranta, M. (2005). Prototyping in Educational Game Design. CHI’06, April 2005, Montréal, Québec, Canada. McFarlane A., Sparrowhawk, A., Heald Y. (2002). Report on the educational use of games, an exploration by TEEM on the contribution which games can make to the educational process. TEEM. http://www.teem.org.uk/publications. Prensky, M. (2001). Digital Natives, Digital immigrants, from On the Horizon. NCB University Press, 9(5). http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/. Sandford, R. & Williamson, B. (2005). Games and Leaning, A handbook from Futurelab. Bristol, United Kingdom. http://www.futurelab.org.uk/.
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers Towards Commercial Educational Games Minna Klemetti, Olli Taimisto and Paula Karppinen Happywise Ltd Kansankatu 47 A, 90100 Oulu, Finland
[email protected]
Abstract: E-learning and educational software have since long been accepted as tools for teaching and learning. Even though games as such have been used in learning through ages, digital serious games, however, are still in the beginning of the process as the entire field is only emerging. The focus of this paper is to analyze opinions, experiences and attitudes of Finnish school teachers regarding digital educational/learning games, especially when they are equated with other commercial material for teaching. The conclusions are based on the material collected in three occasions during the year 2007. Surveys were used to collect information from about 400 teachers, some of whom were also interviewed. Most of the teachers who participated in the surveys work in comprehensive school (grades 1-9) in which the students are aged from 7 to 16. The study was based on the needs of a game developer company HappyWise Ltd. The surveys and interviews were conducted in order to direct the development process of Growwwings.net – Sustainable development learning game, in its pre-marketing phase.
1 Introduction E-learning and educational software have since long been accepted as tools for teaching and learning (The Finnish National Board of Education 2004). Even though games as such have been used in learning through ages, digital serious games, however, are still in the beginning of the process as the entire field is only emerging. Also the amount of research has grown significantly during the past decade. All around the world a growing number of seminars and conferences are arranged. The focus of this paper is to analyze the opinions, experiences and attitudes of Finnish school teachers regarding digital learning games especially when they are equated with other commercial material for teaching. Educational or learning games are treated as a sub-category of the vast field of serious games according to the Serious Games Taxonomy (Sawyer and Smith 2008). The effectiveness of different 97 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 97–105. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
98
M. Klemetti, O. Taimisto and P. Karppinen
types of educational games or their comparison to other learning material is not discussed in this paper. The empirical study presented in this paper was conducted as three surveys during 2007. The results consist of the opinions and attitudes of Finnish school teachers towards commercial educational games. The study was based on the needs of a game developer company HappyWise Ltd, and its purpose was to direct product development plans.
2 Opportunities and Background of the Use of Serious Games There are significant opportunities as well as challenges for the use of serious games in schools. The common understanding among researchers and industry alike seems to be that serious games have great potential of becoming more and more influential in many walks of life in the future (Manninen 2006; Sawyer 2007). Need for lifelong learning, exponential growth in the amount of information and the complex interdependencies on phenomena of today’s world require new methods for more efficient learning. At the same time the games industry is in strong and steady growth (PricewaterhouseCoopers 2007; Eskelinen 2005, 24-25) and games keep on attracting new types of players. Also people, who have played since their childhood, still keep on playing and are also searching for new types of games. According to the Entertainment Software Association (ESA) survey in 2007 the average game player is 33 years old. 38% of all game players are women. Playing games is a popular pastime, 49% of game players say that they play games online one or more hours per week. (Entertainment Software Association 2007) The increased awareness of the potential of serious games creates demand which may also lead to springing up of new companies specializing in serious games development. Information about the attitudes of potential customers towards serious games is vital for anyone developing serious games on commercial basis.
3 Challenges for the Use of Serious Games Since serious games are seen as such a potential area, why haven’t they made the breakthrough already a long time ago? May be the most common explanation is found in the organizational culture in schools as it changes slowly and the effective use of new methods takes time (e.g., Harju 2004). Other factors may include for example the availability of enabling technology in schools, the fact that online learning games are perceived to be free of charge, insufficient content and other hindrances in integrating games in teaching (e.g., Federation of American Scientists 2006).
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers
99
Some stronger opinions against learning games gathered by Kangas in 2003 included the following: The game content is daunting and games are a waste of time. Games and the internet offer false information that children and teenagers can’t distinguish from the truth. • E-learning and virtual learning environments are a dead duck. • •
Even though most of these comments apply to internet, IT and games generally, they are worth of noticing simply as they exist.
4 Empirical Study The empirical study discussed in this paper was conducted in order to direct the product development plans of a game developer company. The study affected especially the development process of Growwwings.net – Sustainable development learning game.
4.1 The Background of the Study In this paper the opinions, experiences and attitudes of Finnish school teachers regarding digital learning games are analyzed basing on surveys conducted in 2007. The material was collected in three occasions during the first half of 2007 in Finland; Educa 2007 the educational sector’s professional event in Helsinki, ITK 2007 – Interactive Technology in Education conference in Hämeenlinna, and an e-mail survey regarding a new game concept and its pricing. The surveys were based on information that was gathered from preliminary interviews conducted in 2006. Altogether 400 teachers participated in the surveys, 291 (73%) of whom worked in comprehensive school (grades 1-9) in which the students are aged from 7 to 16 (Table 1). Table 1. Statistics of the surveys. Survey
Survey participants
number of participants working in comprehensive school (grades 1-9)
228
170
ITK 2007
78
27
e-mail survey1
94
94
400
291
Educa 2007
Total
1
E-mail survey was sent to total of 600 teachers working in comprehensive schools in May 2007. Response percentage was 15.7.
100
M. Klemetti, O. Taimisto and P. Karppinen
The surveys and interviews were conducted in order to direct the development process of Growwwings.net – Sustainable development learning game, in its premarketing phase. The purpose of the surveys was to find out both factual and attitudinal information about digital learning material and they consisted of both selections and open questions. In the following statistics only the replies of comprehensive school teachers are considered.
4.2 Statistics and Observations The factual part of the surveys dealt with the use of educational software generally, the current use of learning games in schools and the subjects in which learning games and educational software are used (Figure 1). The attitudinal part dealt with the willingness and readiness to use learning games in own teaching, opinions about the motivating effects of learning games, and the feedback on a new game concept and its pricing. 17 % 83 %
Uses educational software Doesn't use educational software Fig. 1. Statistics of educational software usage among teachers (n = 291).
According to the survey 83 % (241) of the respondents in comprehensive schools use educational software at school. 82% (238) of the teachers responded that they use learning games. It turned out that many teachers still consider learning games mainly as traditional games such as card or board games, as the amount decreased to 65% when the question emphasized digital learning games. Most often learning games and educational software are used in mathematics (31%) and Finnish language (27%) as presented in Figure 2. Digital learning material is also commonly used in natural sciences (20%) and foreign languages (19%). Since comprehensive digital learning games are not readily available for most subjects at school, teachers sometimes include some internet based free mini games in their classes. This may explain the relatively high percentage of digital learning game users.
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers
101
3% 19% 20%
Mathematics Natural sciences others
31% 27%
Finnish language Foreign languages
Fig. 2. Usage of learning games and educational software in different subjects (n = 232).
Almost all of the respondents (92%, 268) said that they could use learning games in their teaching. The opinion of 99% (288) of the teachers was that learning games would motivate their students in learning. Obviously teachers find learning games or at least the idea of them useful. Naturally it is possible that teachers who did not have even a slight interest towards digital learning material did not participate in the surveys. Considering the answers as a whole however it seems that the respondents represent a relatively good sample of Finnish school teachers. Generally the respondents emphasized that students like doing things on computers and games bring a welcome change to studying at school. However, even though games may help in understanding things, so far students have found most games interesting only for a short period of time. This also indicates that the games are concise and don’t offer much of a challenge to the learner: “So far learning games haven’t managed to interest students for long. In that sense it’s good if new ideas come to the market.”
A significant problem with increasing the use of learning games in teaching seemed to be the lack of resources, especially the amount of money for new learning material. In addition, in their own words teachers are not able to use the school computers in teaching as often as they would like to due to the inadequate number of computers at schools. There are variations between schools in the number of students per computer however, the average being 7-8 (Lehto 2007). The opinion of the teachers calls for solutions that enable the teacher to show the game on one computer for example via a video projector during the lesson. “The price is a significant factor.” “Shouldn’t be expensive for schools.”
The surveys also revealed some factors that teachers especially look for in learning games. The games should be very easy to use, yet versatile and challenging. They
102
M. Klemetti, O. Taimisto and P. Karppinen
should provide enough material for several lessons, but they also should be able to be played in periods of single or double lessons. It is also hoped that the games are visually attractive, and at best they should include some positive social aspect. “There has to be enough material.” “The game works best if there are enough interesting things for several game sessions.” “Should be able to be played in one lesson.”
Many teachers also emphasized that they should be able to know how the students are doing in the game, and in some way be in charge of the situation. In addition, using a game in teaching should not increase the workload of the teacher.
4.3 Empirical Conclusions According to the surveys most of the teachers use some type of educational software in their teaching. Almost as many teachers have used and are willing to continue using learning games, even though some of them first think of traditional games instead of digital ones when speaking about learning games. It can be seen that the use of educational software (not especially educational games) is concentrated on subjects like mathematics and languages. The proportion of these classes at school is relatively high, digital learning material is widely available on the market, and schools have been willing to invest in it in addition to text books. Learning games are however seen as free resources since they are perceived as too concise and the themes not important or versatile enough to be invested in. Until recently this has been mostly true too. From the content point of view teachers emphasized themes that fit in the curriculum to make it easier to integrate games in teaching. The attitudes of teachers towards learning games is very positive, and teachers clearly see the potential of games in getting better learning results by better motivation.
5 Final Conclusions The potential of serious games as motivational tools for learning will most likely increasingly influence the organizational culture of schools. The conducted surveys show that there don’t seem to be remarkable hindrances for the acceptance of serious games as such in the attitudes of teachers. There are however several other factors to consider when developing commercial learning games for schools. Approving or even interested attitude towards serious games might not necessarily lead to effective use of games in teaching.
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers
103
5.1 Observed Challenges Schools often have to strongly prioritize all purchases, and learning games are at this point often seen as additional material only. There continues to be preference for printed materials, and the content of most learning games is seen inadequate in supporting the curriculum. Learning games are perceived as free resources on the internet that are used to enliven the lessons from time to time. So far many learning games available have been mini games made by some interest groups or for promotional purposes. Wider themes are often covered by games developed by universities and research units this leading to games being experimental in nature, and free of charge due to the public funding. Neither ensures that the learning games necessarily suit the curriculum. In addition it’s not the purpose of research units to maintain, and market the developed games to a wide audience. Teachers also reported lack of time or energy to get familiar with new learning material and to start using it, which is in accordance with the notion of slowly changing organizational culture in schools. The practical problem of inadequate amount of computers in some schools does not encourage familiarizing oneself with new digital learning material.
5.2 Implications of the Study One method of easing the access of learning games into effective use in schools could be developing games about wide and important themes within the curriculum. They still probably wouldn’t replace text books but it would be more reasonable for schools to consider purchasing digital material of this type. So far schools haven’t been used to paying for digital learning games, but they are used to paying for other types of educational software as it has been available much longer. In addition the internet is becoming increasingly important distribution channel also for educational material, including digital material with valuable content comparable to text books. The accordance to a specific curriculum however causes, at least partly, the problem of having to localize the game to fit the curriculum in each country if the game is intended for international markets. The learning games should also be designed to have good usability and be very easy to use in classroom context. In addition they shouldn’t increase the workload of teachers. The younger generations of teachers who are already used to computers and games, will probably affect the organizational culture in schools regarding the role of digital learning material. According to the Finnish National Board of Education representative Ella Kiesi (Lehto 2007) the number of students per computer shouldn’t be so much of a problem
104
M. Klemetti, O. Taimisto and P. Karppinen
in Finland anymore. The opinions of the teachers in the conducted surveys were mostly contradictory to this. On the other hand only now serious games are starting to be developed by game developers in addition to pedagogical experts. This brings the integral elements of game development in serious games and may make the games of the future increasingly engaging as well as visually attractive. Yet another interesting aspect is user created content that also may be integrated in learning games. According to these results of the empirical study, Growwwings.net – Sustainable development learning game was designed to be extensive in content, fit the national curriculum and easy to use in classrooms during lessons. Teachers are also able to monitor the progress of their students within the game. As a final conclusion, as the growing interest in gaming and familiarity of e-learning solutions are combined, soon the time could be right for commercial educational games also in schools.
5.3 Future Avenues for Research The study was conducted in Finland among Finnish school teachers. It would be interesting however to expand the research to other Nordic Countries and analyze the variations between countries. It may be that mostly IT-oriented teachers took part in the survey, but already among these respondents there were replies indicating that the teacher was in no way interested in IT as such and yet the attitude towards learning games was positive. In addition it would be useful to compare the results of the study with participant observation in classrooms and see how the attitudes appear in practice when using learning games. Also a similar survey study could be conducted in 2-3 years time to see if the organizational culture and attitudes regarding digital learning material has changed.
References Entertainment Software Association. (2007). Game Player Data. Entertainment Software Association. http://www.theesa.com/facts/gamer_data.php. Accessed 27 February 2008. Eskelinen, M. (2005). Pelit ja pelitutkimus luovassa taloudessa. Sitran raportteja 51. Helsinki: Sitra. Federation of American Scientists. (2006). Summit on Educational Games. Federation of American Scientists. Harju, M. (2004). Digitaalisten oppimispalveluiden hankinta ja käyttö sekä niitä tukevat palvelut. Espoo: Culminatum. Kangas, S. (2003). Hyödyllistä pelaamista. Opetuspelit ja muut *tainmentit. Presented at the ITK conference, Hämeenlinna, Finland.
The Attitudes of Finnish School Teachers
105
Lehto, T. (2007). Ficom ja opetushallitus toivovat lisää koneita. Koulut uhkaavat jäädä jälkeen tietotekniikassa. Tietokone. http://www.tietokone.fi/uutta/uutinen.asp?news_id=31797&tyyppi=1. Accessed 26 February 2008. Manninen, T. (2006). Virtuaalipelit nuorten tulevaisuuden oppimisympäristönä. Presented at the Oppimisympäristöjä kehittämässä seminar, Oulu, Finland. PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2007). Global Entertainment and Media Outlook 2007–2011 (Video games section). PricewaterhouseCoopers. Sawyer, B. (2007). Serious Games: What you don’t know. Presented at the Nordic Game Conference, Malmö, Sweden. Sawyer, B., & Smith, P. (2008). Serious Games Taxonomy. Presented at the Game Developers Conference, San Francisco, Kalifornia, USA. The Finnish National Board of Education. (2004). National Curriculum for Comprehensive Schools. Helsinki: The Finnish National Board of Education.
Using Videogames as Educational Tools: Building Bridges Between Commercial and Serious Games Pilar Lacasa1, Laura Méndez2 and Rut Martínez3 1) University of Alcala, 28801 Alcalá de Henares, Spain
[email protected] 2) Facultad de Psicología – UNED, Juan del Rosal, Ciudad Universitaria, 28040 Madrid, Despacho 1.70, Spain 3) University of Alcalá, 28801 Alcalá de Henares, Spain
[email protected]
Abstract: This paper describes how a social simulation videogame (The Sims 2 Pets) was introduced into the classroom as a educational tool, and discusses the activities and conversations of the children, teachers and researchers involved. This study adopts a qualitative analytical perspective based on narrative and ethnographic approaches and discourse analysis. Sixteen seven- to eight-year old children participated in the study. All the video recordings were segmented using Nudist 8.0 and Atlas.ti. The analysis allows us to delimit different phases according to the strategies that children and adults used to approach the game in the classroom context. Our results show the strategies used by the adult to guide the children through a deductive reasoning process.
1 Why Commercial Videogames with Serious Educational Purposes? Introducing commercial videogames into the classroom helps us to think about why and how cultural objects designed for fun rather than for educational purposes can be used to improve digital literacies at school. This paper addresses this question by focusing on how these games involve certain representations of the world that raise new challenges when the relationships that children and adults establish between real and virtual universes are analyzed. Education relates to learning and specifically to the acquisition of certain skills that help people to be part of their social and cultural worlds, by understanding and also transforming them. Behind these abilities there lies an ability to represent virtual and real worlds by means of various codes, for example oral, written or audio-visual discourses; nowadays, these are present not just in traditional media 107 M. Kankaanranta and P. Neittaanmäki (eds.), Design and Use of Serious Games, 107–123. © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2009
108
P. Lacasa, L. Méndez and R. Martínez
but also in digital screams. The school needs to reflect on how digital universes involve young people and children’s life in order to develop new forms of literacy (Gee 2007). Moreover, considering simulation as “an operating representation of central features of reality” (Eddington et al. 1982, 10; in Salen and Zimmerman 2004, 423), we relate digital literacy to the ability to make meaning of the simulated world that appears on the screen. But education cannot be completely identified with learning. People learn to utilize certain technologies by being educated to use them in social and cultural contexts which defined how these tools are utilized in everyday life and especially in communication situations with specific purposes. Education, in contrast to learning, implies the presence of shared goals that lead human activities in a certain direction defined by the most expert members of the community (Willoughby and Wood 2008). These goals relate to specific models for understanding the world, and involve mental representations that assign meaning to human activities merged with the social and cultural situations of those in which they are generated. Within this general framework, videogames can turn into an educational instrument because they engage with symbolic reconstructions of the world. Adopting this perspective we consider commercial videogames as a “purposeful, goaloriented, rule-based activity that the players perceive as fun”. (Klopfer 2008) and we wonder how using them as educational tools is somehow different than providing “serious games” for teachers and children. One of the clearest differences is that commercial videogames are present in children’s everyday life. Previous studies have shown that they can be a valuable tool to establish bridges between what happens inside and outside the classroom. Some other reasons can be considered in relation to this. First, they motivate children and young people, because videogames are “fun” and learners associate the games that they play outside the school with pleasant moments. Second, they require the use of a set of cognitive and social skills that are implemented when they are consciously approached; a set of metacognitive activities can thus be developed around them that would be difficult without adult support present in the classroom. Third, playing commercial videogames, as well as serious games, involves the ability to communicate and the use of multiple discourses that children use outside the school; in this perspective, the main difference between commercial and serious games is that the content of these discourses has meaning in very different contexts. Finally, even though commercial videogames are usually very far from the content of the traditional classroom curriculum, they open the door to suggestions for activities oriented to developing not merely the passive transmission of information but a process of knowledge construction. This paper presents some of the results of a project carried out in collaboration with teachers to explore how commercial video games can be used in elementary classrooms. During the school year we have been working in two different schools from an ethnographic perspective. Participants were the teachers and three class
Using Videogames as Educational Tools
109
groups of children aged between 8 and 11. Five workshops were organized, each one based on a different video game. Three types of game were selected, each of which required different skills and introduced the children to different world representations: a) sports (for example, NBA Live 2007), which opened the possibility of approaching rules from a double perspective; the rules of the game as it is played in the real world and the videogame’s specific rules; b) adventure, related to the Harry Potter franchise, since these offered a vision of the world that centered predominantly on the concepts of magic and fantasy; c) social simulation; in our case, the Sims. With these three types of game we aimed to offer different representations of the virtual world and to examine how children and adults establish relationships between real and virtual worlds. The project had two general goals that we will consider in order to present the specific questions which we will deal with on these pages. First, the project examined how various commercial video games can be turned into educational instruments. From this perspective we will explore some of the results by focusing on the process that took place in the classroom when we worked with a social simulation such as the SIMS in a workshop; we will see several phases during which the children, their teacher and the research team approach social worlds in both real and virtual reality. We will show the process by which children generated metacognitive processes supported by the teacher, and established relationships between simulated persons and the spaces they inhabit. Secondly we focus on the conversations that took place during one session, in order to show the relationships that the videogame enables to be established between the children and the adults. The restrictions imposed by the rules of the game in order to develop specific social models are also considered, and we explore the strategies of the children and the adults who support the children when they talk, play and think together during the game. In order to define this goal we consider how The Sims relates to specific models of western society that could support reflective processes related to the way in which people organize their lives in specific spaces and according to social rules.
2 Building Bridges between the School and Everyday Life Why should we wish to bring social simulation games into the classroom? Because they offer multiple representations of the real world in an interactive form. Moreover, this interaction involves specific processes of thinking that are present in many situations in the everyday life of children. Our theoretical framework settles into a double axis that brings us into a certain social context and the specific processes of thought that can develop when such a game, in this case the Sims 2 Pets, comes to the classroom.
110
P. Lacasa, L. Méndez and R. Martínez
2.1 The Outside World as a Model when Playing the Sims Pets Following Gee (2003), we assume that a cultural universe involves images, history, principles or metaphors that capture what a particular group finds “normal” or “typical” with respect to a given phenomenon. These cultural universes capture only a partial view of reality; i.e. a specific perspective. Adopting a similar view, Frasca focuses on The Sims from an ideological and social perspective. His approach is of interest to us right from his point of departure: “The Sims represents a breakthrough in videogame design. For the first time, a best-selling game is not about trolls and wizards. This simulation is about regular people – known as Sims – in everyday situations in an American, suburban environment. In my opinion the Sims’ biggest achievement was that it fully opened the Pandora’s box of simulating human life. Although structurally The Sims is similar to other resource management simulations, the fact that it portrays people, and not aliens, results in players asking questions about the game’s ideology” (Frasca 2004, 91).
The Sims is a model of real life in the US and possibly other Western societies. According to Frasca, in the social universe of The Sims, the player can control the character in a different way to that in other traditional games where the player “is” the character but his activities are much more closely controlled by the rules of the game. In any case, Frasca considers that The Sims’ characters are rather limited in the possibilities that the game offers to define them. For example, the most important decisions that the player can take refer to the characters’ clothes and other physical dimensions, but not to personal traits affecting their behavior. Continuing our examination of the contributions of this author, we wonder how the players reconstruct the social model presented in the Sims and to what extent this model orients his or her actions in the game. The educational value of this question is related to the fact that it enables children and young people to construct representations of the social reality in which they live, and to be critically aware of the above-mentioned models.
2.2 New Models of Narratives In the previous paragraph we pointed out that The Sims’ approach to specific forms of social reality reflects the fact that they are present in a virtual world, leading us to explore how these models are developed, depending on the game mechanics and the designers’ approach to the world. In that context, Jenkins refers to this game as an example of those that offer a new model for constructing narratives that express specific models of the world and the activities that its characters perform in it.
Using Videogames as Educational Tools
111
Referring to simulating characters on The Sims, he writes: “(…)Wright frequently describes The Sims as a sandbox or dolls’ house game, suggesting that it should be understood as a kind of authoring environment within which players can define their own goals and write their own stories (…) Wright has created a world ripe with narrative possibilities, where each design decision has been made with an eye towards increasing the prospects of interpersonal romance or conflict. (…). Yet, let us now understand the designers’ contribution. The characters have a will of their own, not always submitting easily to the player’s control, as when a depressed protagonist refuses to seek employment, preferring to spend hour upon hour soaking in the bath or moping on the front porch” (Jenkins 2006, 684).
According to Jenkins, both the possibilities and the limitations imposed by the game are important. Players can define their characters by choosing from among several possibilities, often projecting their own desires, frustrations and hopes. In previous studies, we have seen that players enjoy the Sims because they can control what people do on the screen, while they cannot control what other people do in real life (Lacasa et al. 2008). Moreover, we need to remember that these characters act according to a well-defined set of possibilities; for example if we focus on The Sims Pets, important differences are found in what the characters can do, even based on the interface we are using. For example, PlayStation 2 gives gamers many more possibilities to define their preferred environment and the people who inhabit it.
3 Approaching to the Classroom: Action Research and Ethnography In order to analyze how a simulation game, The Sims Pets 2, can contribute to the development of digital literacies, as related to the interpretation of the game universe in a multimedia educational setting, we worked from an ethnographic and action research perspective. Our analyses are rooted in a sociolinguistic approach. In the project we acted as participant observers. Sixteen children between 7 and 8 years of age (seven boys and nine girls), their teacher and the research team participated in the workshop. All the children were highly motivated and interested in the games, although there were wide differences among them in terms of their expertise as gamers. The teacher was a young woman with at least ten years of experience. Although she was not an expert in the use of technology she wished to offer her students the new possibilities opened up by it. She was extremely cooperative with the research team and we worked well together; it is important to point out that when games and consoles were being used in the classroom or specific activities involving playing were designed, control of the classroom was passed to the research team. The roles of the members of the research team were clearly defined for the children, who regarded all of us as “the videogames teachers”; at least three people were always present during the sessions.
112
P. Lacasa, L. Méndez and R. Martínez
As games we work with The Sims Pets 2, using both PlayStation 2 y Nintendo DS. Because we have worked in other classrooms with the same games using just one platform