ECOLOGICAL AQUACULTURE The Evolution of the Blue Revolution
ECOLOGICAL AQUACULTURE The Evolution of the Blue Revolutio...
178 downloads
2005 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ECOLOGICAL AQUACULTURE The Evolution of the Blue Revolution
ECOLOGICAL AQUACULTURE The Evolution of the Blue Revolution
ECOLOGICAL AQUACULTURE The Evolution of the Blue Revolution Edited by Barry A. Costa-Pierce
Rhode Island Sea Grant College Program Graduate School of Oceanography Department of Fisheries, Animal and Veterinary Science University of Rhode Island
# 2002 Blackwell Science Ltd, a Blackwell Publishing Company Editorial Offices: Osney Mead, Oxford OX2 0EL, UK Tel: +44 (0)1865 206206 Blackwell Science, Inc., 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148-5018, USA Tel: +1 781 388 8250 Iowa State Press, a Blackwell Publishing Company, 2121 State Avenue, Ames, Iowa 50014-8300, USA Tel: +1 515 292 0140 Blackwell Science Asia Pty, 54 University Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia Tel: +61 (0)3 9347 0300 Blackwell Wissenschafts Verlag, KurfuÈrstendamm 57, 10707 Berlin, Germany Tel: +49 (0)30 32 79 060 The right of the Author to be identified as the Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
First published 2002 by Blackwell Science Ltd Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Costa-Pierce, Barry A. Ecological aquaculture: the evolution of the blue revolution/Barry A. Costa-Pierce. p. cm Includes bibliographical references (p.). ISBN 0-632-04961-8 (alk. paper) 1. AquacultureÐEnvironmental aspects. 2. AquacultureÐEconomic aspects. I. Title. SH135 .C67 2002 338'71Ðdc21 2001043507 ISBN 0-632-04961-8 A Catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library Set in 10/13pt Times by DP Photosetting, Aylesbury, Bucks Printed and bound in Great Britain by MPG Books Ltd, Bodmin, Cornwall For further information on Blackwell Science, visit our website: www.blackwell-science.com
I dedicate this book to the memory of my beloved father, Edward A. Pierce Sr., who passed away while this book was being completed; to my mother, Thelma Pierce; and to my United Nations family ± Lily Mae Ho-Pierce, Lia Kaiulani Ho Costa-Pierce, Sierra Shaiming Ho Costa-Pierce ± and to the Elders of the Wampanoag Tribe of Massachusetts, USA.
Contents
List of Contributors Foreword Preface Acknowledgments Part 1
The Background of Ecological Aquaculture
1
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies Malcolm C.M. Beveridge and David C. Little
2
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii Barry A. Costa-Pierce
Part 2 3
4
The Methods of Ecological Aquaculture
ix x xii xv 1 3 30
45
Development and Application of Genetic Tags for Ecological Aquaculture Theresa M. Bert, Michael D. Tringali and Seifu Seyoum
47
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation: The Salmonid Case Study C.J. Bridger and Amber F. Garber
77
5
Farming Systems Research and Extension Methods for the Development of Sustainable Aquaculture Ecosystems Barry A. Costa-Pierce
103
6
A Market-driven, Social Ecological Approach to Planning for Sustainable Aquaculture: A Case Study of Tilapia in Fiji Barry A. Costa-Pierce
125
Part 3 7
The Context of Ecological Aquaculture
Village-based Aquaculture Ecosystems as a Model for Sustainable Aquaculture Development in Sub-Saharan Africa Randall E. Brummett and Barry A. Costa-Pierce
143 145
viii
Contents
8
Silvofisheries: Integrated Mangrove Forest Aquaculture Systems William J. FitzGerald, Jr
161
9
An Integrated Fish and Field Crop System for Arid Areas James E. Rakocy
263
10
Sustainability of Cage Aquaculture Ecosystems for Large-Scale Resettlement from Hydropower Dams: An Indonesian Case Study Barry A. Costa-Pierce
11
The Role of Aquaculture in the Restoration of Coastal Fisheries Mark A. Drawbridge
Part 4 12
Conclusion
Ecology as the Paradigm for the Future of Aquaculture Barry A. Costa-Pierce
Index
286 314
337 339 373
List of Contributors
Theresa M. Bert Florida Marine Research Institute,100 Eighth Avenue South, St. Petersburg, Fl 33701, USA Malcolm C.M. Beveridge FK9 4LA, Scotland
Institute of Aquaculture, University of Stirling, Stirling
Christopher J. Bridger College of Marine Sciences, University of Southern Mississippi, 703 East Beach Drive, Ocean Springs, MS 39564, USA Randall E. Brummett International Center for Living Aquatic Resources Management (ICLARM), BP 2008 (Messa), YaoundeÂ, Cameroon Barry A. Costa-Pierce Rhode Island Sea Grant College Program, Department of Fisheries, Animal and Veterinary Science, University of Rhode Island, Narragansett, RI 02882, USA Mark A. Drawbridge Hubbs-Sea World Research Institute, 2595 Ingraham Street, San Diego, CA 92109, USA William J. FitzGerald, Jr
PO Box 6997, Tamuning, Guam 96931
Amber F. Garber Department of Zoology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27695-7617, USA David C. Little Scotland
Institute of Aquaculture, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA,
James E. Rakocy University of the Virgin Islands, Agricultural Experiment Station, Kingshill, VI 00850, USA Seifu Seyoum Florida Marine Research Institute, 100 Eighth Avenue South, St. Petersburg, Fl 33701, USA Michael D. Tringali Florida Marine Research Institute, 100 Eighth Avenue South, St. Petersburg, Fl 33701, USA
Foreword
During the early years of the modern aquaculture era ± which I think of as starting in the 1960s ± practitioners of the art undoubtedly considered themselves to be strong environmentalists. Working with nature to produce food, bait, and ornamental species for the enjoyment of humans was the goal, but the practice involved establishing and maintaining the best possible conditions for production of the target species. Our understanding of pond dynamics, physiological requirements of culture species, and aquatic animal nutrition and disease were just a few among the many topics addressed by researchers. A tremendous amount of information on the relationships between aquatic organisms and their environment, e.g. ecology, was generated and continues to be generated by aquacultural researchers. Yet, by the mid-1980s, at least some forms of aquaculture were being branded as detrimental to the environment. It took a bit of time for the aquaculture community to become sufficiently introspective to recognize that, indeed, some of their practices had negatively impacted the environment. For at least the past decade, a considerable amount of time, money, and effort have been expended by the aquacultural community in addressing both real and perceived problems. The mantra of the aquacultural community became focused on sustainability. Many publications have appeared over that period which address the criticisms and relate how aquaculture has responded to them. Ecological Aquaculture takes a somewhat different approach in that it provides interesting insight into what we would now consider to be primitive culture systems and then ties those activities into modern aquaculture approaches. The book is edited and authored to a considerable degree by Barry Costa-Pierce who has been one of the leaders in the discussion of responsible and sustainable aquaculture development. A prolific author of often thought-provoking articles, he has assembled some of the other leading thinkers in the field to provide a pot-pourri of information spanning the spectrum from artisanal to high technology approaches to producing aquatic animals with an eye on maintaining balanced ecosystems. The approaches advocated in this volume represent the future of aquaculture around the world. Criticisms will continue to be lodged by opponents, but the fact is that if the demand for seafood is to be met in the future, a major source will have to be from aquaculture as capture fisheries are currently being exploited at or beyond maximum sustainable yields. Aquaculture often cannot be practiced without some
Foreword
xi
environmental impact, but that impact can be reduced, hopefully to insignificance, if the proper approaches are adopted. This book helps define those approaches. It should be required reading for anyone interested in producing aquatic organisms in an environmentally responsible manner; which means that it should be read by everyone involved in aquaculture. While the minds of the opposition may not be changed by volumes such as this, those members of society who are interested in the facts concerning how environmentally responsible aquaculture has been practiced in the past, how it is currently being practiced, and where it might be going in the future will find this book to be an excellent primer on the topic. Robert R. Stickney Director Texas Sea Grant College Program Texas A&M University College Station, Texas
Preface
`It is the arrogance of the rich to teach the virtue of poverty to the poor.' Dr P.M.S. Blackett, the late Nobel Prize-winning physicist `Don't underestimate the power of a small group to change the World. In fact, that's the only ones who ever have.' Dr Margaret Mead Ecological aquaculture is an integral part of our common planetary wisdom and cultural heritage, and is an essential part of our future evolution as a sophisticated species living in peace with the Earth's complex ecosystems. Traditional aquaculture systems are closely integrated with the management of indigenous land and water food production systems, and rely on intact natural ecosystems. Aquaculture ecosystems evolved as sophisticated forms of agriculture in areas of Asia, the Pacific and Europe where human populations overshot the carrying capacities of the traditional agro- and aquatic ecosystems to support these societies. Aquaculture evolved to take pressure off natural and cultivated land and water ecosystems and ecosystem services. In these `human ecosystems', aquaculture evolved as a part of ± not the dominating feature of ± the wonderful variety of aquatic life, and the evolutionary diversity of cultures that decided to undertake such an extraordinarily specialized art. `Blue revolutions' ± as the natural evolution of societies ± have been happening for over 2000 years. In this regard, the concept of `ecological aquaculture' is nothing new ± especially in Asia. In the West, however, the evolution of the `blue revolution', and avoiding the social and environmental blunders of the `green' one, are more recent. Development of an aquaculture ecosystems pedagogy and systems `mentality' began only in the late 1970s and 1980s (MacKay, 1983). The purpose of this book is to stimulate discussion among aquaculture's modern scientific, education, extension communities ± and the larger aquatic resource management community ± about the principles, practices, and policies needed to develop ecologically and socially sustainable aquaculture. It is one of the first primers on ideas of how we are to become twenty-first century stewards of the Earth's cultivated aquatic ecosystems using the singular unifying rubrics of ecological aquaculture and aquaculture ecosystems. However, serious students of aquaculture will recognize that many of the ideas conveyed in this book are nothing new, but have
Preface
xiii
been repackaged in a way to stimulate discussion on how the latest science and outreach advances can assist the evolution of aquaculture into the modern era. The authors of the chapters in this book demonstrate how aquaculture can be a valuable player in the evolution of planning for sustainable aquatic resource management in a more crowded, protein-hungry world. To meet the protein needs for 8 billion people, and at the same time protect the oceans and freshwater ecosystems of the Earth from the uncontrolled exploitation of hunting (capture fisheries), aquaculture must expand dramatically in the twenty-first century. To accomplish expansion, however, aquaculture must be planned as part of, not separate from, a comprehensive management strategy for the restoration of fisheries ecosystems. Fisheries legislation throughout the world, such as the US Magnuson-Stevenson Sustainable Fisheries Act, falls far short of this vision, completely ignoring aquaculture in the planning for sustainable capture fisheries. To accomplish major worldwide expansion, and to ensure its social acceptance, aquaculture needs family and community roots in addition to corporate ones. Thousands of new, ecologically and economically sustainable family farms and progressive start-up companies need to be developed in the twenty-first century. These farms will need to practice `input management', recycle water, nutrients and materials, and produce healthy, uncontaminated products without discharges. Farmers incorporating aquaculture into family farms and new companies will internalize, not externalize, plans for more efficient resource recycling and enhance natural ecosystem services as part of their business plans and economic projections ± not neglect their social and environmental responsibilities, as suggested in a classic volume by Ken Boulding some 40 years ago (Boulding, 1962). Aquaculture developments need greater planning in the larger regional and community contexts. In short, aquaculture must become less short-term and less production oriented, and become more ecologically, community, and culturally based. Such approaches make good business sense! If aquaculture doesn't evolve with an environmentally friendly/socially responsible pedagogy in nations where it is new, but evolves principally as a `corporate' undertaking, aquaculture will never bring its full potential benefits. Environmental regulations, management difficulties, and resource and social conflicts coming in the crowded twenty-first century will halt its progress. And it is certain that the public ± worldwide ± will not accept any new forms of food production that exploit people, cause environmental harm, or produce new sources of aquatic pollution. In short, the `blue revolution' will quickly go bust unless it `greens up'. I conclude this book with these concerns about the role of aquaculture in the twenty-first century, contending that aquaculture needs to return to its historical roots ± its ecosystem and community-based roots ± and that ecological aquaculture needs to become the basic level of analysis for development planning for aquaculture worldwide. We contend that in this century, ecological aquaculture needs to emerge as the dominant method not only for smallholder farms, but also for commercial aquaculture. In addition, ecological aquaculture scholarship needs to emerge as a `new' field of applied environmental scholarship throughout the world at the major land and sea universities to assist aquaculture's rapid transition to social and
xiv
Preface
environmental sustainability, and to integrate aquaculture into mainstream planning for sustainable fisheries and coastal zone management. By adopting ecological principles as the basis of development planning aquaculture will play an important role in creating new social constructs that tie together thousands of new, knowledge-based family farmers and companies, producing huge benefits to society. Management of these `ecotones' between society, natural ecosystems, and sustainable environmental development is the key to the future of sustainable, ecological aquaculture.
References Boulding, K. (1962) The Reconstruction of Economics. Science Editions, New York. MacKay, K. (1983) Ecological aquaculture, new approaches to aquaculture in North America. Journal of the World Mariculture Society, 14, 704±713.
Barry A. Costa-Pierce University of Rhode Island Narragansett, RI
Acknowledgments
Ideas for this book were planted in the late 1970s while I studied with Murray Bookchin (Bookchin, 1985) and Jim Nolfi at the Institute for Social Ecology, Goddard College in Plainfield, Vermont. Murray and Jim were early pioneers in the study of the social ecology of food systems, alternative energy and social strategies. In addition, I am forever grateful to my teachers, who have helped me (and many others) to formulate the ideas and create the inspiration needed to produce this book, especially: Joseph Kiefer, Roger Pullin, Ron Zweig, Daniel Pauly, John Lyle, Ian Smith, John Bardach, Rich Merrill, Ken MacKay, Ed Laws, Lee Swenson, E.F. Schumacher, Amory Lovins, Eugene Odum, David Brower, Page Nelson, Margaret Mead, Bill McLarney, and John Todd. Special thanks go to all the pioneers at the New Alchemy Institute and the Farallones Institute of the 1970s and 1980s. This book would not be possible without the stimulation from a host of aquatic friends who've been `swimming in these same blue waters' ± special people who have served as examples to me and countless others by dedicating their lives towards giving the next generation a rehabilitated blue-green planet ± Pete Bryant, Bob Stickney, Otto Soemarwoto, Orten Msiska, John Wagner, Randy Brummett, Dave Penn, Arlo Fast, Sutandar Zainal, Reg Noble, Pam Sager, Pepen Effendi, Gelar Wiraatmadja, Jean Davidson, Reg Noble, Joseph Ofori, Jay Maclean, Jim McVey, Gail Work, John Lyle, Glenn Jones, John Munro, Sarvahara Judd, Fredson Chikafumbwa, Chris Bridger, Earl Barnhart, Hilde Maingay Barnhart, Russell Cuhel, Dave Karl, Catalino de la Cruz, Joseph Weinstock, Dan Chodorkoff, Charles Woodard, Calley O'Neill, Dick Jacobs, Daniel Jamu, Don Heacock, Spencer Malecha, Rick Weisburd, Clive Lightfoot, Mark Prein, Jim Rakocy, Les Behrends, Bill Engler, and Anne van Dam. Special thanks to Kay Bruening for all her professional assistance in preparing the book for publication; and to the staff of the Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Consortium.
Reference Bookchin, M. (1985) The Ecology of Freedom. Cheshire Books, Palo Alto, CA.
Part 1
The Background of Ecological Aquaculture
Chapter 1
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies Malcolm C.M. Beveridge and David C. Little Institute of Aquaculture, University of Stirling The origins of aquaculture The origins of aquaculture are lost in history and little evidence remains to direct even a serious investigator of the subject. There are, after all, no aquaculturespecific artifacts to guide archaeologists. There is often little to distinguish abandoned ponds, even supposing we were able to find them, from dams of various types or from systems for producing inundated arable crops such as rice. Surface water would be stored to support communities or households in many cultures, and the predominant use for domestic/agricultural purposes may disguise a secondary role of holding or growing fish. Where rainfall is seasonal the focus of communities is around surface water bodies that may have originated as little more than natural depressions but became modified by the dependence these communities had on them. The presence of fish bones and shells in refuse heaps at early human settlements, or representations of fish on cooking pot shards, indicate only that the occupants ate these foods, not how they obtained them. The tools used in aquaculture are common to farmers and fisher folk, and remains of net-like materials or hooks tell us only about how fish met their fate, not whether they were caught from a river or from a fishpond. With few exceptions there is also no genetic record of domestication to draw upon, an important distinction between fish and livestock being that fish didn't need to be domesticated in the way livestock did in order to rear them in captivity. In this chapter, we examine what is known about the origins and development of aquaculture among traditional societies: who practiced it, and why, what distinguishes it from industrial and post-industrial aquaculture and its legacy. We briefly consider agriculture and current theories concerning its origins and development. We draw upon examples from traditional societies in four continents ± Africa, the Americas (with the exception of Hawaii, which is considered in detail in the following chapter), Asia and Europe ± and from various periods in history. Unfortunately, our review is not entirely balanced as there remain enormous gaps in knowledge. We begin with a consideration of what aquaculture is and how it differs from hunting.
4
Ecological Aquaculture
Aquaculture: some definitions It is important at the outset to be able to distinguish aquaculture from fisheries and agriculture. It may be differentiated from fishing because, as in agriculture, some measure of care or cultivation is involved. Reay's (1979) definition of aquaculture as `Man's attempt, through inputs of labour and energy, to improve the yield of useful aquatic organisms by deliberate manipulation of their rates of growth, mortality and reproduction' appeals from a biological perspective. However, it omits the other key component that distinguishes it from hunting: the concept of ownership or the extension of access and exploitation rights. The recently revised definition of aquaculture used by the UN Food and Agricultural Organization states that aquaculture is: `. . . the farming of aquatic organisms including crocodiles, amphibians, finfish, molluscs, crustaceans and plants, where farming refers to their rearing to their juvenile and/or adult phase under captive conditions. Aquaculture also encompasses individual, corporate or state ownership of the organism being reared and harvested . . .' (Rana, 1998). In this definition, both husbandry and ownership are seen as intrinsic. However, many traditional forms of aquaculture are based on the exploitation of multipurpose water bodies in which the organisms themselves are `common property', i.e. `owned' neither by an individual nor by some corporate body or the state. For present purposes we assume the key criteria distinguishing farming from hunting are that: there is some form of intervention(s) to increase yields; and l there is either ownership of stock or there are controls on access to and benefits accruing from the interventions (for parallels in agriculture see Bromley, 1992). l
Another key point in the FAO definition: end purpose is not at issue and fish owned and reared other than for food are regarded as the products of aquaculture. Nevertheless, as is discussed further below, differentiating between hunting and farming in the aquatic environment remains fraught with difficulties, in large measure because comparatively little effort has been expended on documenting and analyzing the range of methods used in exploitation of aquatic environments. A further set of definitions is necessary in order that we can compare aquaculture in traditional societies with contemporary practices from an ecological standpoint: these relate to resource use, or the differences between `intensive', `semi-intensive' and `extensive' aquaculture. According to Coche (1982), in extensive aquaculture the aquatic animals must rely solely on available natural food, such as plankton, detritus and seston. Semi-intensive aquaculture involves either fertilization to enhance the level of natural food in the systems and/or the use of supplementary feed. Such feeds are often low-protein (generally <20% DM), usually compounded from locally available plants or agricultural by-products, and complement the intake of natural
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
5
food which is higher in protein (Hepher, 1988). In intensive aquaculture, animals are almost exclusively reliant on an external supply of high-protein food (generally >20%), usually based on fishmeal and fish oil. These definitions broadly relate to use of environmental resources ± so-called `goods' ± although they ignore other resources such as land and water and seed. The intensity of production methods also has implications for use of environmental `services'; the more external food that is supplied per tonne production, the greater the wastes and the greater the demands on the environment to disperse and assimilate these wastes. However, the terminology is insufficiently well defined to be any more than a general guide. The term `semiintensive aquaculture', in particular, covers a huge diversity of aquaculture practices and ranges from minimal inputs to fairly substantial inputs of feed.
The origins of agriculture `People did not invent agriculture and shout for joy. They drifted or were forced into it, protesting all the way.' Tudge (1998) Neanderthals, Bandits and Farmers
Introduction The long accepted view of how and why agriculture began and spread has recently undergone some revision (Harris, 1996; Diamond, 1997; Tudge, 1998). While the established view remains that it started some 10 000 to 12 000 years ago, there is a growing recognition that different peoples adopted food production at different times. While some cultures, such as the Chinese, developed agriculture independently, others learned from neighbors or colonizers while a few, such as the Aboriginal Australians, appear never to have acquired agriculture at all (Flannery, 1994). The advantages of farming are readily apparent. Much plant and animal biomass is difficult or dangerous to harvest, labor intensive to prepare or of poor nutritional value. By farming, it is possible to select and grow crops and animals that give high nutritional returns per unit expenditure thereby increasing food supplies. Agriculture also generates food surpluses and food storage, prerequisites to the development of settled, politically centralized, socially stratified, economically complex and technologically innovative societies (Diamond, 1997). However, Tudge (1998) has recently argued that this view still underplays the importance of farming throughout much of our two-million-year history, especially from the late Paleolithic ± some 40 000 years ago ± onwards. He believes that a variety of `proto'-farming activities, a term coined to describe an ad hoc collection of activities that coaxed more food out of the environment, such as crop protection and game management, were part of the repertoire of responses to times when demands for wild foods outstripped supplies. Tudge also contends that when food supplies improved through upturns in abundance of game or more clement weather, or death or emigration of people, they returned to what they enjoyed best: hunting. His contention is that farming was hard work and to be avoided unless absolutely necessary.
6
Ecological Aquaculture
Although he makes little reference to farming prior to 12 000 years ago, Harris (1996) too believes in the concept of `proto-agriculture' and has elaborated an evolutionary classification of systems of plant and animal exploitation; a simplified, unified history of agriculture (Fig. 1.1a). There is much food for thought in these ideas and we believe that many of the concepts currently being considered by agricultural historians, especially with regard to terrestrial animal production, provide insights into aquaculture and into how it evolved and was practiced among traditional societies.
Fig. 1.1a An evolutionary classification of systems of animal exploitation (modified from Harris, 1996). Long seasonal migrations, examples including permanent winter settlements and summer migrations.
Aquaculture and `proto-aquaculture' Aquaculture too began in different societies, both agriculture- and fishing-based, and followed a pattern of development in many respects similar to that of agriculture. There is good evidence in aquaculture for Tudge's theory of people opting in and out of plant and animal cultivation according to their needs, although as we hope to show these needs were not always related to food. There is also evidence of `protoaquaculture', defined here as activities designed to extract more food from aquatic environments, such as: transplantation of fertilized eggs; entrapment of fish in areas where they could thrive and be harvested as required; l environmental enhancements, such as development of spawning areas, enhancement of food, exclusion of competitors or predators, etc.; l holding of fish and shellfish in systems ± ponds, cages, pens ± until they had increased in biomass or until their value had improved. l l
Each activity might on its own be considered as no more than stock enhancement and thus within the definition of what might be considered as managed fisheries. However, we apply the critical concept of control of access and benefits to draw a line between where managed fisheries end and proto-aquaculture begins. If the effect of such interventions increased supplies sufficiently to satisfy needs and to result in an equitable distribution of benefits, then it may have evolved no further. We propose that the relatively small degree of control over the life cycle of the animal and the low impact of the intervention on fish or shellfish production is used to distinguish proto-
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
7
aquaculture from aquaculture. The definition of proto-aquaculture is compatible with those of Coche (1982) regarding extensive, semi-intensive and intensive aquaculture and is further characterized by low consumption of energy (see above). The proposed definitions do not neatly distinguish fishing from fish farming, but perhaps this is only to be expected when dealing with something like the transition from hunting to farming. It also ignores some of the more contentious issues, such as ranching, a term used to describe the release of juveniles into the wild, only to be recaptured later as adults. However, it is useful in helping explain how aquaculture might have first developed. It is very much a working hypothesis and others with more detailed and accurate information, more insight and more time for reflection and debate will undoubtedly construct a better framework.
Proto-aquaculture and the origins and pattern of development of aquaculture Why might people in traditional societies have begun farming fish and shellfish? The answer, according to the agricultural historians, would be because it was necessary (Boserup, 1965). It is clear that aquaculture began in various parts of the world and at various points along the aquatic food supply line, between water and plate. The farming of fish and shellfish is by definition an activity of settled societies, originating among both fishing and wetland farming cultures as well as at points of trade. While we may surmise that conditions similar to those favouring the development of agriculture would have usually been necessary, i.e. that foraging and hunting (fishing) were insufficient to satisfy demands for fish, provision of food was not always the most important driver for the development of aquaculture. Stewart (1994) and others believe the importance of fish in early hunter±gatherer societies to have been underestimated. Rudimentary proto-aquaculture techniques would probably have evolved among such societies, although evidence is scant. Native North American peoples living on the Pacific seaboard are believed to have transplanted the eggs of spawning salmon in an attempt to improve fish survival and returns. Many proto-aquaculture activities relied on some sort of holding facility. The simplest to construct would have been earth ponds. In some parts of the world these would have been little more than mud walls constructed to temporarily hold water and fish following the seasonal flooding of a river. Such systems are still in use in some parts of the world today. The whedos or fish holes of Benin are one such example (see Welcomme, 1972, for details). The practice of communal construction of weirs on small rivers and streams in Asia to store water outside of the monsoons principally to ensure adequate irrigation for wet rice cultivation during lulls in the rains and allow early seed bed preparation is also common. Attempts to increase fish yields would have been a logical next step, by affording protection from predators and, perhaps, by feeding fish with household scraps or farm wastes (see Fig. 1.1b). Among fishing-based societies, a number of scenarios in which proto-fish or protoshellfish farming arose are readily envisaged: the short-term storage of catches until there were sufficient fish or shellfish to make the journey to market worthwhile; the transport of live fish to market; the holding of catches until prices improved. These
8
Ecological Aquaculture
Fig. 1.1b A scenario of how aquaculture may have evolved.
strategies are still seen among fisher folk today: modified traps, netted-off shallow areas of lakes, cages of the sort still seen in parts of Indonesia, traditional floating cages used in the Great Lake area of Cambodia (see Beveridge, 1996). If the theories of the agricultural historians hold true for aquaculture, then we can also expect to see aquaculture wax and wane as the result of changes in supply relative to demand for fish and shellfish.
Africa The earliest evidence of fish culture of sorts purportedly comes from ancient Egypt where fish often had a sacred as well as prosaic role in society. They were strongly associated with the cyclical life-giving forces of the Nile and the New Kingdom Egyptian view of the world, tilapia in particular being strongly linked to the goddess Hathor and the concept of rebirth (Desroches-Noblecourt, 1954). In his account of tilapia in ancient Egypt, Chimits (1957) reproduces a 4000-year-old bas relief figure from the tomb of Thebaine showing what appears to be an artificial, drainable pond being fished by a nobleman (Fig. 1.2). Many New Kingdom tomb scenes also show tomb owners sitting on chairs, fishing tilapias from their ponds, their wives standing behind and assisting with the catches. Although rod and line fishing is believed to have been common among all classes in Egypt at that time, the fishing activities of the
Fig. 1.2 Bas relief from the tomb of Thebaine, showing an Egyptian nobleman catching tilapia from an artificial pond (re-drawn from Chimits, 1957).
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
9
nobility were limited to their ponds. Their interest in fishing stemmed from religious rituals associated with death and rebirth and not with pleasure or sustenance (Desroches-Noblecourt, 1954; Brewer & Friedman, 1989). This was aquaculture at its most simple, more proto-aquaculture than aquaculture, involving little in the way of inputs or husbandry or pond management. Tilapia would have been transferred from nearby rivers to the ponds where they readily would have bred. While some food may have been provided, it is unlikely to have been important since production of fish for food was not the objective. It is believed that the practice persisted into the New Kingdom until the importance of rebirth in the world view of Egyptians waned. Although Brewer & Friedman (1989) detail many peculiar beliefs and taboos among the priesthood associated with fish, early travelers to Egypt confirm that fish was of tremendous importance in the Egyptian diet. The Roman traveler Diodorus Scullus is quoted as saying that `. . . the Nile contains every variety of fish and in numbers beyond belief: for it supplies the native not only with fish freshly caught but also yields an unfailing multitude for salting.' Herodotus, too, who traveled here some 2500 years ago, reported that `. . . all Egyptians in the Nile Delta possess a net with which, during the day, they fish. . . .' Given the fertility of the river, the abundance of fish and the skills of the fishermen, it is not surprising that these proto-aquaculture activities developed no further and indeed waned with the change in religious significance of fish. Its revival would have to wait several millennia until the early years of the present century.
Asia China and freshwater fish farming Although possibly pre-dated by events in Africa, Asia ± and China in particular ± is widely regarded as the cradle of aquaculture. The chronology is complicated, but is summarized in Tables 1.1 and 1.2. Many factors are thought to have constrained livestock development and predisposed China to develop aquaculture earlier than elsewhere in Asia. The wet rice agro-environment evolved relatively late in China's history, population pressure stimulating colonization of low-lying deltas. Such conditions would have both inhibited any development of mixed farming based on ruminant livestock and crops and supported fish culture and production of livestock such as pigs and poultry that thrived on rice by-products and water-based scavenging respectively. The process of agricultural evolution in southern China, from cropdominated to mixed farming (Grigg, 1974; Little & Edwards, 1997) was, therefore, molded by the limits and potentials of a flood-prone environment. Any diversification from a rice monoculture required a process of `ditching and diking' that produced deeper areas suitable for fish and higher dike areas for horticulture. Although areas of wet rice production were relatively sparsely populated until the Han dynasty (Grigg, 1974), the adoption of increasingly intensive, and irrigated, production in suitable areas prompted a rapid increase in population and demand for aquatic products that would also have been an important factor in stimulating aquaculture. With the development of ditch-dike systems, other crops such as beans, green vegetables and
10
Ecological Aquaculture
Table 1.1 Chronology of significant aquaculture developments in China, based on written records. Information derived from Lin (1991), Li (1994) and Yang (1994) Date (BP)*
Period
Event
2300
Zhou Dynasty
Publication of monograph by Fan Li, detailing design and layout of ponds, propagation, fry and fingerling production
2200±2100
Han Dynasty
Publication of You Hou Bin, detailing integration of fish with aquatic plant and vegetable production Development of cage, cove and pen culture
1975±1780 1380±1100
Culture of fish in rice paddies Tang Dynasty
1100
Development of polyculture Publication of Lin Biao Lu Yi by Liu Xun, detailing theory of mutualism in rice±fish culture Integration of fish and fruit production
1040±780
Song Dynasty
Increasing collection and distribution of wild fish fry for pond rearing
632±350
Ming Dynasty
The Complete Agricultural Art written by Xu Guangqi and Treatise on Fish Culture by Huang Shenchen detail extensive to intensive fish farming methods in Jiangxi Province, including rotation of fish with aquatic plant production; integration of fish with livestock and effects of manuring on pond fish production
500 360±90
Development of integrated mulberry±dike±fishpond production system Qing Dynasty
40
Detailed written accounts of fry production, sorting and transportation Widespread success in artificial propagation of carps
* BP = Before present.
Table 1.2 Schema showing the evolution of farming systems for livestock and fish. It illustrates the probable evolution of farming systems from traditional, crop-dominated systems (Settled Agricultural Phase I) through mixed farming in which the importance of livestock was enhanced through their integration with crops (Settled Agricultural Phase II), to industrial agriculture characterized by monoculture (Settled Agricultural Phase III). (From Little & Edwards, 1997.) Category System definition
Evolutionary stage/trend Traditional crop dominated
Mixed farming
Agro-industrial
Intensity level
Extensive
Semi-intensive
Intensive
Descriptor
Settled Agricultural Phase I
Settled Agricultural Phase II
Settled Agricultural Phase III
Livelihood
Part of a complex of activities
Specialized activity
Knowledge
Indigenous
Scientific
Resource use
Land, water*
Cash, fossil fuel energy intensive
Market
Rural, subsistence, local
Urban, cash, export
Cultured species
Polyculture
Monoculture
* Based on pond fish culture.
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
11
tobacco could also be grown alongside (Bray, 1984). As today, fish would have been a common component of seasonally inundating rice paddies. Given the lack of animals and the prevalence of wetlands it is thus not surprising that fish was a prominent component of the diet in many areas. The development of irrigation in China and elsewhere was driven by the fact that rice grows best when provided with water of the right quality and in the right quantity at the right time. While there is no neat chronology of evolution of irrigation systems in China, it is clear from the widespread existence of clay models of irrigated agriculture systems recovered from graves throughout southern China that by the Han Dynasty (2300±1700 BP) ponds were being widely employed for water storage (Bray, 1984; Li, 1994). To some this indicates the earliest that aquaculture might have been developed. In a single grave over 18 varieties of aquatic plants and animal, that are still used by the Chinese today, were found within an intact rice-field model. These included lotus flowers, seeds and leaves, water chestnuts, soft-shelled turtles (Trionyx sinensis), grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) and goldfish Carassius auratus (Guo, 1985, in Li, 1992). These areas of southern China had high densities of people culturally dependent on aquatic foods. As population densities increased, demand for fish and other aquatic foods would have increased and the practice of holding and growing fish would become increasingly attractive compared with reliance on increasingly exploited and inconsistent wild stocks. In the floodplains of China and elsewhere in Asia, soil is excavated to construct elevated, better-drained areas for establishing homesteads and raising crops. Although the resultant excavations may be referred to as fishponds by aquaculturists, farmers refer to them simply as ponds, an indication of their multipurpose nature. Others, however, including the Fisheries Society of China, refer to the short treatise published by the statesman Fan Li some 2500 years ago (2500 BP). It describes common carp (Cyprinus carpio) farming in sufficient detail to provide incontrovertible evidence that fish culture had developed well beyond a proto-aquaculture activity and that aquaculture was well established by this time (Li, 1994). The monograph details the design and layout of fishponds, carp breeding, and fry and fingerling rearing techniques. Fan Li's account is of `semi-intensive' monoculture of carp, although there remains some debate as to the species (see Balon, 1995). The integration of fish ± presumably carp ± culture with that of aquatic plants and vegetables is apparent from written records dating from 2200 to 2100 BP while written records of rice-fish culture date from the period 1975±1780 BP (Yang, 1994). Despite the long history of freshwater fish farming in China, there are few documentary accounts and details are fragmentary at best (see Table 1.1). According to Li (1994) fish culture expanded from rice paddies and ponds to lakes ± this implies the use of cages, pens and/or enclosures ± during the Han Dynasty (206 BC±AD 220). Provided herbivorous species were used, culture could have relied on semi-intensive or even extensive methods. If, however, omnivores were farmed, then there would have been a greater reliance on supplementary feed. There is strong evidence that small dams, constructed by farmers primarily for water storage purposes, were also used to produce lotuses, water chestnuts, fish and turtles (Bray, 1984). A milestone for aquaculture in China seems to have been reached at the beginning of the Tang
12
Ecological Aquaculture
Dynasty in AD 618 with the culture of combinations (polyculture) of carps (Ling, 1977; Li, 1994). However, while we might expect that this would have been promoted as a means of increasing yields from semi-intensively managed systems, historians claim polyculture to have been less due to an appreciation of ecology and the synergies of growing together species with complementary feeding habits than to the fact that the word for common carp in Chinese ± `Li' ± sounded the same as the emperor's surname. As a result, the catching, selling and eating of this species was banned for the next 300 years or so. Availability of suitable wild seed was critical to China's aquaculture development, and the same was true for Indian carp polyculture in the subcontinent and culture of Vietnamese silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys harmandi ), mud carp (Cirrhinus molitorella) and common carp (Cyprinus carpio) in the Red River Delta, Vietnam (Chevey & Lemasson, 1937). There is also evidence that there were traditional methods of producing seed that pre-date the now widespread use of hypophysation in hatcheries. Dry `bundhs', seasonal ponds that fill quickly at the time of the first rains, were used to stimulate spawning of Indian major carps in West Bengal over a hundred years ago (Sharma & Rana, 1986). Other key events in Chinese aquaculture include the gradual integration of fish ponds with various crop and livestock production systems (see Table 1.1), leading to what is widely regarded as the most complex integrated aquaculture system of all, the fishpond±dyke±mulberry system of Zhujiang, southern China (Ruddle & Zhong, 1988). The fishpond±dyke±mulberry system was strongly output orientated to meet both local demand for a variety of products ± live fish, fruit, etc. ± and distant markets for products such as silk. Until recent decades the yields of Chinese carp polycultures are likely to have remained low (<2 metric tons per hectare per year), however, and mainly dependent on feeding low nutrient, volunteer fodder to the grass carp. This situation, as indicated by the oft-quoted Chinese proverb `One grass carp feeds three other fish', reflects the paucity of, and competition for, nutrient inputs on traditional farms in southern China. The macrophagous grass carp, whose manure enhanced the productivity of food organisms for other fish species in the pond, filled a `niche' usually filled by ruminants, for such low value feed (Little & Edwards, 1997, 2000). Collectivization of agriculture in the 1950s saw great changes in the types of nutrient inputs, labour and markets available and a resultant increase in complexity of Chinese integrated aquaculture. The influence of China on aquaculture in the region has undoubtedly been great, but poorly studied. Chinese emigrants may have taken common carp Cyprinus carpio and techniques of fish farming with them first to Korea and then to Japan (Drews, 1951; Ling, 1977), from where McLarney (1984) believes the practice gradually spread to other parts of Southeast Asia. The culture of the exotic common carp with indigenous anabantids from swamps, such as giant gourami (Osphronemus gouramy), kissing gourami (Helostoma temmincki) and snakeskin gourami (Trichogaster pectoralis), and the riverine carp, silver barb (Barbodes gonionotus) and nilem (Osteochilus hasselti) in Indonesia, is believed to stem from their introduction by Chinese immigrants over two centuries ago (Edwards et al., 1997). Until recently, ethnic Chinese immigrants growing fish around urban centres imported Chinese carp in well-boats and, latterly, by air. Nevertheless, as we say above, the creation of exca-
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
13
vated areas in floodplains, and the presence of high densities of people used to exploiting aquatic foodstuffs are all the conditions necessary to initiate proto-aquaculture/aquaculture. There is evidence that away from the major floodplains wild stocks of aquatic animals are more prone to over-exploitation and that the stocking of juvenile and breeding wild fish was more likely to be a response to local fish shortages in these circumstances. The stocking and management of local common carp in ricefields in mountainous northern Laos and Vietnam (Chevey & Lemasson, 1937, Little & Pham, 1999) is an example. The accumulation of land and other resources by elites may also be a prerequisite to the development of aquaculture in agricultural societies. The construction of large ponds would require mobilization and organization of labor beyond the resources of poorer households. This perhaps explains the domination of large Hindu landowners in traditional aquaculture in Bengal (Lewis et al., 1996). There are almost certainly rich histories of aquaculture development in India, Indonesia and elsewhere. Unfortunately, these are much more poorly documented than in China (see Table 1.3 for summary chronology for Southeast Asia).
Mariculture Documentary evidence suggests that mariculture in Asia is less than 1000 years old. The culture of milkfish (Chanos chanos) in brackish water coastal ponds is believed to have developed in Java, Indonesia, some time between AD 1200 and 1400 under the influence of the Hindu rulers (Schuster, 1952). Convicts were apparently sent to the coastal fringes to work in the salt marshes and to guard coastal fires. They were forbidden to practice agriculture or trade and their conditions were so harsh that they are believed to have survived largely through damming of creeks and trapping of fish and crustaceans. Schuster (1952) believes coastal pond fish farming evolved among these `untouchable' fish-eating peoples from the seasonal flooding of salt ponds during the wet season. Mariculture developed independently in Japan during the Tokugawa era (1603± 1868) (Ling, 1977; McLarney, 1984). Some traditional forms of coastal mariculture, such as the use of barachois in Mauritius, are still practiced to a limited extent. Here, shallow lagoons, isolated from the sea by stone walls fitted with screens, are stocked with mullet (Mugil cephalus) or rabbit fish (Siganus sp.) fingerlings. Some oyster farming may also be practiced.
Europe Introduction Historical evidence suggests that mariculture in the Mediterranean pre-dates that in Asia by a millennium or so. The Etruscans practiced active management of coastal lagoons along the Adriatic and Tyrrhenian coasts in the fourth and fifth centuries BC. These proto-aquaculture activities evolved into what is generally known today as `vallicoltura', involving the installation of permanent or semi-permanent embankments to enclose the lagoons. Sluices were incorporated within the structures in order
14
Ecological Aquaculture
Table 1.3 Traditional and modified artisanal inland aquaculture systems in Southeast Asia. Historical is >100 years; recent is <100 years old. Improved implies benefits from scientifically derived knowledge. (Modified from Edwards et al., 1997.) Traditional Country/area
Culture facility
Historical
Brunei Cambodia Indonesia
Ponds Cages and pens Rice±fish Cages Ponds
+ + + +
Laos PDR Mountains Lowland Malaysia Myanmar Papua NG Philippines Singapore Thailand Vietnam Mountains Red River Delta Mekong Delta
Rice±fish Rice±fish Ponds Rice±fish Ponds Ponds Ponds Rice±fish Cages and pens Ponds Ponds Rice±fish Cages and pens Ponds Rice±fish Cages Ponds Ponds Rice±fish Cages Ponds Rice±fish Cages
+
+
+ + + + + +
Recent
Improved
+
+ + + +
+ + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + +
+
+ + +
+ +
+ + + + + + +
+ + + +
to trap fish inside the shallow, productive lagoon environment where they could be harvested when desired. This form of mariculture is still practiced to a limited extent around the Northern Adriatic, Tyrrhenian Sea, Sicily and Sardinia (Kirk, 1987; Ardizzone et al., 1988). Shellfish farming, involving the culture and relaying of oysters, was well established in the Adriatic 2100 to 2200 years before present (Balon, 1967b, in Balon, 1995), but probably pre-dates this by many hundreds of years. The Romans are documented as being among the first to build coastal aquaculture ponds, most likely before the end of the second century BC (2200 BP). In his Natural History (Vol. IX) written some hundred years later, Pliny the Elder notes that a certain Lucinus Murena had excavated substantial areas of fish ponds (piscinae) at Grotta Ferraia, close to the summer residence of Cicero. This idea was apparently adopted by other members of the nobility, partly for the purpose of holding live food fish, but also as a demonstration of wealth and status. Pliny the Elder also recounts that:
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
15
`. . . at Baculo in Baiae District, the pleader Hortensius had a fishpond containing a lamprey that he fell so deeply in love with that he is believed to have wept when it expired. At the same country house Drusus' wife Antonia adorned her favourite lamprey with earrings, and its reputation made some people extremely eager to visit Baculo.' Aquaculture perhaps, but scarcely for food! However, while these saltae or maritimae were built by the rich nobility primarily for spectacle, a practice that was widespread and persisted for several centuries, common people also built ponds (dulces) for food production for income generation (Kirk, 1987; Zeepvat, 1988). Both freshwater and saltwater ponds were built, the former being stocked with a variety of coarse fish and salmonids, the latter with eel, mullets, turbot and sea bass. According to Zeepvat, classical Roman literature gives the impression that the keeping of fish in artificial ponds was commonplace throughout the Mediterranean provinces of the Empire.
Continental Europe The common carp (Cyprinus carpio) was undoubtedly key to the development of aquaculture in continental Europe over much of the past two millennia. During the first and second centuries AD, Roman attempts to culture local fishes in piscinae on a significant scale to increase supplies of fresh fish failed and as a result the common carp from the Danube were imported (Balon, 1995). Gradually the practice of common carp culture developed by the Romans spread westwards, although it did not reach England until the late fourteenth century (Currie, 1991). The monasteries, the repository of knowledge throughout the Middle Ages, were undoubtedly important in the development of fish ± especially carp ± culture among the farming communities of central and Western Europe. There are several reasons for this. First, fish played an important symbolic role in early Christian motifs, fish representing Christian souls, and ponds of fish are common in mosaics decorating early Byzantine churches (Drewer, 1981). Second, a number of the Christian monastic orders, such as the Cistercians, were skilled agriculturists. The Cistercians also led in the development of fulling mills in which the processing of large quantities of wool took place. The requirements for waterwheels to drive the heavy timber and stone hammers that pounded the wool to clean and thicken it, in the mid-fourteenth century led to the construction of dams that were usually stocked with fish (Binnie, 1987). According to Binnie (1987), the Cistercians and other religious orders influenced the populace at large to adopt the practice of eating fish on Fridays and during Lent. The growing importance of fish and the preference for fresh rather than salted led to not only the royal and ecclesiastical establishments but also wealthy landowners to construct `stew' ponds. No single authoritative history of fish culture in Europe has yet been produced, the principal reason being the lack of study. Hoffman (1996), however, has marshaled current knowledge and understanding to give an excellent preliminary synthesis of pond fish culture. Hoffman associates the development of pond fish culture with
16
Ecological Aquaculture
environmental degradation and population growth that led to growing demand for freshwater fish. By the reign of Charlemagne (AD 768±814) carp culture was sufficiently important for the emperor to have issued edicts to tenant farmers regarding the maintenance and management of ponds, protection from poaching, the regulation of fishing and the sale of fish (Balon, 1995). By medieval times, fish had become an important staple in the diet (Hoffman, 1996). Initially, fishponds seem to have been built in Europe to ensure supplies of fish for the owner(s) and his/their dependents, especially during Lent when eating of meat was prohibited. Small fish were returned to the ponds to ensure continuity of production. Any surpluses tended to be used as gifts to cement social relations or for sale, although as Hoffman (1995) states, medieval fishponds were not managed to cater for what were undoubtedly considerable markets for fish for stocking and for consumption. A number of the medieval power dams, such as the Cistercian-owned Lucelle dam in northwestern Switzerland and the Bruna dam, Sienna, Italy, were also concurrently used for fish culture (Schnitter, 1994). The latter was owned by the State, which had a certain responsibility to ensure there was sufficient food for its populace and woe betide any that failed in this (Adams, 1984; Hoffmann, 1996). Economic growth during the fourteenth to sixteenth centuries promoted widespread development of fishponds throughout much of continental Europe (Adams, 1984; Schnitter, 1994) although for reasons given below not in England. Carp farming was very extensive and often practiced in modified floodplains difficult to exploit profitably except for pasture. In Hungary, for example, ponds were often located in areas of poor, unproductive soils that were likely to flood. The ponds ensured a continuous supply of food, particularly during times of war, feeding both rich and poor. In the Czech Republic, in the late fourteenth century there were 75 000 ha of ponds although production was very low, yielding 2250 mt of fish (Adamek & Kouril, 2000). Bohemia appears to have had the greatest concentration of ponds. During the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, some 700 ponds, totaling an area of 1800 km2, were built (Votruba, 1987). Ponds also flourished in the district of La Dombes, between Lyon and Bourg, France, for a period of several hundred years from the early Middle Ages, eventually covering an area of some 180 km2 (Sahrhage & Lundbeck, 1992). From the late sixteenth century onwards, pond fish farming in Germany and France fell into decline and did not begin to recover until the development of trout culture in the mid-nineteenth century. The causes were various. In Bohemia, they have been ascribed to over-production coupled with the pauperization of farmers that culminated in the Peasants' Wars of 1524 (Sahrhage & Lundbeck, 1992), while in the Czech Republic frequent wars and the development of agriculture were blamed (Adamek & Kouril, 2000). In France, the secularization of the church by Napoleon in 1803 is accorded some of the blame (Sahrhage & Lundbeck, 1992). The main reasons, however, were economic. Just as it had once proved highly profitable to convert farmland into fishponds, so the fortunes of fish culture turned full circle: increased profitability of other crops, coupled with State incentives to convert ponds into farmland, and a contracting market finished carp farming in many areas. The decline in the consumption of fish, a commodity always more expensive than meat, had
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
17
begun during the seventeenth century, first among the nobility and later among the middle classes.
England As in continental Europe, the Romans must be credited with the introduction of fish culture to England. At the time Zeepvat (1988) wrote his review, some dozen ponds, ranging in size from 30 m2 to 1770 m2, had been uncovered at Roman villas in southern England and there are undoubtedly more to be discovered. The earliest of the ponds dates from AD 65, the latest, at Bancroft, Buckinghamshire, from the first half of the fourth century AD. Many of the ponds were primarily ornamental in nature, while others were principally designed for bathing. However, many served a secondary purpose of production and storage of fish for the table and a few even are surmised to be primarily for food production: Zeepvat (1988) presents data from an excavation at Shakenoak, Oxfordshire, dating from the second century BC. Here a complex of ponds was uncovered in the 1970s, all of which seemed to have been purpose-built for fish production. One pond is surmised to have been a breeding pond, another a production pond, while a third is believed to have been used as a holding tank for fish awaiting shipment to market. The villas and their ponds were abandoned when the Romans left Britain in the fifth century AD. According to many historians, the greatest consumption of fish in medieval England was by the religious communities such as the Cistercians, in whose houses `meat and lard were never eaten . . . save for those seriously ill and by the hired workmen. The diet was therefore confined to bread, vegetables and dishes mainly from fish, flour, eggs and cheese, with honey as an exception. Throughout Lent and Advent and on certain vigils, eggs and cheese were banned, as were all kinds of imported spices' (Knowles, 1950). However, recent research by Currie (1989, 1991) has cast doubts on the traditional view that the monastic orders were primarily responsible for the development and dissemination of pond fish culture in England. There is much evidence to show that the ascendant Norman aristocracy built the first large-scale fish pond developments, primarily in order to cement their new-found status as landowners. There are records of fishponds from several areas of Norman England, dating back to the end of the eleventh century (Roberts, 1966; Stearne, 1971; McDonnell, 1981; Roberts, 1985; Binnie, 1987; Currie, 1991). In 1069 William the Conqueror, the French nobleman who had subjugated England only a few years before, ordered the River Foss at York to be dammed just above its confluence with the Ouse in order to protect his newly built castle, leading, incidentally, to the creation of a fishpond. Many more fishponds were built in England over the next two and a half centuries. Indeed, Roberts (1966) claims that `. . . fishponds were normal appurtenances to manors over much of lowland England during the middle ages . . .' and that `. . . few monastic establishments were without a supply of freshwater fish, frequently kept in ponds . . .' while `. . . fish production [was] on some scale from royal ponds during the thirteenth century'. By the late Middle Ages, there were at least 135 pond systems in Oxfordshire alone (Chambers & Gray, 1988). Other accounts highlight the role of royalty in pond fish production. Henry III
18
Ecological Aquaculture
(1216±72), for example, made numerous well documented gifts of live fish to his nobles, promoting the development of fishponds on the estates of the wealthy (McDonnell, 1981; Binnie, 1987). The ponds owned by the Cistercians, Augustinians and Gilbertines and other monastic orders were either granted by wealthy secular patrons in association with gifts of land or were built somewhat later during the medieval period and on a smaller scale. As mentioned above, fish were important in the early Christian church in both symbolic and practical terms. More than 100 fasting days per year were introduced, during which only cold-blooded animals such as fish and crustaceans could be eaten and even more elaborate rules regarding consumption of fish were followed by monastic orders (see Knowles, 1950). However, the idea that monastic fishponds provided much-needed fresh fish for the monastic orders during fasting days is rejected by Dyer (1988), Currie (1989) and others. They assert that cheap salted sea fish was eaten during periods of penance and cite contemporary records stating that fresh pond fish were to be kept for special occasions. The populace at large was rarely able to eat meat or fresh fish. Dyer (in Currie, 1991) states that fishponds were seen as bastions of privilege and often a focus of peasant discontent, such as during the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, in which the `stews of Southwark' were wrecked. The royal fishponds fell into decline during the period 1300±1480 due to the decline in the number of royal houses, the costs of pond maintenance and the relatively poor economic returns and because of the rising numbers of retail fishmongers (Stearne, 1988). With the dissolution of the monasteries in the sixteenth century, many monastic fishponds were abandoned, never to be productive again. In the latter part of the medieval period, a few wealthy freemen began to build ponds (Roberts, 1966; McDonnell, 1981; Currie, 1991). There is evidence that wealthy peasants owned ponds in the Forest of Arden, Warwickshire, for example, and that part of the produce was sold. Currie (1991) also cites evidence of fishmongers in mid-fourteenth century London feeding and keeping fish in ponds for sale. However, the practice could never be described as widespread. In post-medieval times, the keeping of common carp in ponds became popular for a while among land-owning nobility, the fish being used for both domestic consumption and sale (Currie, 1991). However, Taverner (1600), in his discourse on fish culture, mentions that fishpond keeping was no longer as popular as it once had been. In leasing estates to tenants, fishponds were often neglected. There was a decline in eating freshwater fish such as carp, bream and perch during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. According to Chambers & Gray (1988), the 1869 edition of the redoubtable Mrs Beeton's Book of Household Management states that freshwater fish are seldom purchased.
The Americas In pre-Hispanic Mexico the chinampas that developed and flourished in lakes Xochimilco and Texcoco in the Valley of Mexico under the Aztecs, represent only one of several integrated wetland agriculture/aquaculture systems (Coe, 1964). The term `chinampa' derives from the Nahuatl language and means `net of branches'. The
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
19
chinampas were created by cutting and piling turves on to the lake bottom around lake margins to form a patchwork of peninsulas and islands, each typically 100 m long by 5±10 m wide, interspersed by a grid-like pattern of canals. The key feature of the chinampas is that lake water could infiltrate the agricultural beds, maintaining a supply of water to the roots of the plants throughout the year. A wide range of crops was grown, including maize and tomatoes. Organically rich mud recovered from the canals would be piled on to the chinampas, thus maintaining fertility (Armillas, 1971). Although there have been many changes and much has been lost, the systems still exist and remain `the biologically richest agro-ecosystem . . . in which most of the flora is managed and used' (JimeÂnez-Osornio & Gomez-Pompa, 1991). Fish play no part in the present-day system, and although it is believed that they once did it is difficult to say how significant or to what extent fish production was deliberately enhanced. It is thought that fish were purposely trapped in the canals where they could readily be harvested as required, and that crop and vegetable by-products may have been used to enhance fish production. There were attempts to experiment with a more highly integrated form of chinampa-based aquaculture in Tabasco, Mexico, and in the Akanyaru marshlands of Rwanda in the 1980s, with mixed success (Micha & Chavez, 1997).
Fish farming methods Introduction Almost without exception, pre-twentieth century fish farming was of herbivorous/ omnivorous species such as carps and roach, milkfish, mullets and tilapias. Culture of piscivorous pike, as was practiced in Medieval European fishponds, was done in polyculture systems where the pike undoubtedly fed on smaller stocked carps and other coarse fishes. The monoculture of carnivorous salmonids was initiated in the nineteenth century as a response to the need to meet the growing demand of recreational fishing and to environmental degradation on the north Pacific coast of the Americas, and was limited to the production of juvenile stages for stocking. The culture of aquatic carnivores for the table had to wait until after the Second World War. Aquaculture for religious or for social status reasons aside, proto-aquaculture and aquaculture were about increasing fish and shellfish production. The fundamental principles involved can be derived from the figure of Pitcher & Hart (1982) for the factors that determine exploitable stock biomass (Fig. 1.3). To increase the harvestable yields from a stock, it is necessary to increase stock biomass (recruitment and growth) while minimizing losses through disease or predation. Stocking, increases in food supply, either through fertilization or provision of additional food, concern for animal welfare and exclusion of predators may all be employed in fish farming, although profitability is usually the ultimate criterion. Here we examine what was known about aquaculture methods among practitioners in traditional societies.
20
Ecological Aquaculture
Growth rate
Recruitment rate
Increase
Farmed stock biomass
Decrease
Harvesting mortality rate
Natural mortality rate
Fig. 1.3 Categories of factors governing exploitable farmed stock biomass (developed from Pitcher & Hart, 1982).
Broodstock management and spawning Early fish farming relied either on trapping or transplantation of wild fry (carp, milkfish, mullet, etc.) or on breeding and production of fish such as tilapia, roach, etc. within the production system. Accounts of catching and transportation of fry for stocking of fishponds are apparent from two written works dating from the early thirteenth century (Song Dynasty) in China (Li, 1994). How well did early fish farmers understand the life cycle and principles of farming fish? It is clear from the treatise on fish culture written by Fan Li some 2500 BP that the principles of carp breeding were well appreciated by that time in China (Li, 1994). McDonnell (1981) believes that in England the basic concepts behind holding fish in separate enclosures for store (`stews') and for breeding would have been familiar to medieval Cistercian sheep farmers, implying that in many of the larger fishpond systems there were separate breeding/fry rearing ponds and production ponds. Hoffman (1995) also cites evidence of separate carp fry rearing ponds or ditches associated with the ducal fishpond complex at LaperrieÁre-sur-SaoÃne, Burgundy, in the mid-fourteenth century. Most of the fish cultured in ponds in England at this time ± bream (Abramis brama), dace (Leuciscus leuciscus), perch (Perca fluviatilis), roach (Rutilus rutilus), tench (Tinca tinca) and pike (Esox lucius) ± (McDonnell, 1981) would have readily acclimatized to the muddy, stagnant pond environment, and, provided there were a few aquatic plants present, such fish would have happily bred. During harvest of medieval European fishponds, smaller fish were usually retained for restocking purposes (see Hoffman, 1995, for example). However, there is also extensive documentary evidence showing considerable and well organized movements of fish for stocking purposes (Roberts, 1966; McDonnell, 1981). Over a 20-year period, for example, parcels of fish, typically numbering 45 bream, 30 pike and larger numbers of smaller fish, were sent as gifts from the Royal Foss pond in York to stock the ponds of the Archbishop of York, the Fountains and Byland Abbeys in Yorkshire and, further afield, ponds belonging to the Earls of Cornwall and Lincoln (McDonnell, 1981; Binnie, 1987). The first carps kept in ponds in Roman and medieval continental Europe would have been wild Danube forms. Little is known about how these fish were propagated
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
21
or whether any selection took place. Although the first documentary accounts of common carp breeding in ponds did not appear until the thirteenth century, Balon (1995) asserts that breeding in captivity had occurred as early as in Roman times in Europe, albeit that spawning would probably have been a rather hit-or-miss affair. By the mid±late sixteenth century articles and even scientific investigations of carp production were being published. It is apparent from around this time that domesticated strains that differed in colour, shape and scale pattern from wild forms, were being produced. Balon (1995) believes domestication of the goldfish (Carassius auratus) in China preceded that of the common carp Cyprinus carpio in Europe, probably some decades earlier in the sixteenth century. Balon cites Chen (1952) in asserting that domestication in China resulted from the Buddhist belief that freeing a captive animal was an act of self-purification, and that the freeing of a rare, naturally occurring mutant form was a greater deed. `Ponds of mercy' were established at temples and the rich began to culture fish in jade jars, leading to inbreeding of aberrant forms ± trailing fins, bulging eyes and scale and pigment: a perverse form of selective breeding, in other words. The culture of koi carp in Japan some 200 years later may or may not have arisen from this practice (see Balon, 1995, for review). Today, the release of captive aquatic animals, especially fish and turtles, is still an everyday practice in many parts of Southeast Asia as is the husbanding of wild stocks in and around temple grounds. Protection and feeding fish in rivers and canals proximal to Buddhist temples and within temple ponds to make merit is widespread in Thailand, Laos and Cambodia. Such refuges may be an important part of conservation of wild stocks in areas with heavy exploitation and extensive water control.
Pond construction and management Much effort and expenditure often went into the construction and maintenance of ponds, as is particularly evident from European records. Medieval European fishponds varied in size from a few hundred square metres to more than 80 ha, and depths could be as much as 6±8 m. Most fishponds were formed by the damming of a stream in a valley, the dam wall being constructed from earth and stone and strengthened with wood. Early ponds tended to exploit the contours of the land; ponds built from the sixteenth century onwards were more likely to be linear in conformation, thereby facilitating netting (Chambers & Gray, 1988). Often the ponds were multipurpose; however, purpose-built fishponds were also constructed in close association with a millpond or moat surrounding a manor house or large farmhouse. Few of the ponds built in England during the early medieval period could be drained without creating a breach in the wall, and a simple overflow was usually all that was present to ensure that ponds did not burst their banks. Many of the ponds built in France, however, had deep drainage ditches fitted with wooden sluices that could be lifted, thereby allowing complete drainage of the ponds (Hoffman, 1995). Once built, ponds had to be maintained. Binnie (1987) asserts that silting was not a problem in medieval English fishponds and that pond catchments deliberately may not have been ploughed (i.e. used for crop culture) but instead were used for animal grazing. However, there are many contemporary written accounts of periodic
22
Ecological Aquaculture
de-silting. A detailed account at one such medieval pond is given by Roberts (1985). The Alresford fishpond, built around 1200, was an enormous structure (a magnum vivarium), covering some 80 ha. In the winter of 1252±53, after fish had first been transferred to a nearby stew pond, a breach was deliberately made in the 70-m long, 6-m high weir in order to allow the pond to drain. The following winter 122 labourers using 24 carts were employed to clean out the silt, the breach was mended and the pond was allowed to refill and was then restocked with 1072 roach, 603 bream, 229 perch and 115 pike. The factors that most often precipitated pond draining were deteriorations in stock `through disease or fouling of ponds' (Binnie, 1987). Although breaching of pond walls and de-silting were expensive, especially with such large ponds, the removal of silt was seen as essential in maintaining pond volume, and the practice of allowing pond soils to dry out seems to have long been recognized as important in maintaining productivity (Binnie, 1987). It is known that during dry fallowing periods, mineralization of sediment-bound nutrients occurs, resulting in renewed productivity once ponds are refilled. Such recycling of nutrients is further enhanced if grazing animals are allowed within these temporal pastures. There was also a tradition of inter-cropping in some parts of Europe. Taverner (1600) advised crops should be grown and cattle herded in fishponds during alternate dry years. According to Hoffman's account of the management of fishponds at LaperrieÁre-surSaoÃne, Burgundy, during the middle of the fourteenth century (Hoffman, 1995) draining and harvesting of ponds were often finished in time for planting of summer crops. During 1339±40 and 1350±51, extensive and costly repairs necessitated that the dry pond beds be farmed for a year, yielding crops of barley, oats and hemp. In central Europe the practice of rotations of 3 years of crops being followed by three fish crops was widely practiced (Wunder, 1949, in Hickling, 1962).
Feeding practices Technical literature related to feeding of fish is scant. Rumsey (1994) quotes mention by John Halver and Peter Milne and others of illustrations dating from more than three millennia of people feeding fish in impoundments. However, as still seen in some of the more extensive forms of aquaculture today, it is likely that the majority of the diet of fish grown in ponds and rice paddies would have been natural, principally plankton and benthic invertebrates and detritus. Natural productivity alone would have been able to sustain production of several hundred kilograms per hectare from monoculture. Production from polyculture, where synergistic feeding relationships are exploited, is likely to have been somewhat higher, although probably no more than 600±700 kg/ha/year, depending on the nature of the water body, proximity to human habitation and how nutrients drained into water bodies. Manuring has been widely used for centuries in Asia. In England too, Chambers & Gray (1988) cite evidence of human effluent being deliberately channeled in monastery fishponds during the later medieval period. Feeding was certainly known to the Chinese and to the Romans. However, Hickling (1971) and Currie (1991) believe that it would have been beneath the upper classes that owned fishponds in eleventh to thirteenth century England to try to increase revenues through feeding. But this was
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
23
certainly not the case with the aspiring lower orders who owned or leased fishponds for commerce and who did feed their fish. In many systems fish would also have been fed, most likely on wastes from the table and agricultural by-products and surpluses. Such practices would have been carried out on an experimental basis initially, but would have become accepted practice as yields were observed to increase. The integration of fish culture with agriculture in the pond±dyke system in southern China would have encouraged the use of such surpluses and wastes as fish food. Supplementary feeding would almost certainly have been necessary for fish reared in cages, there being insufficient plankton or seston available to sustain growth under most circumstances (see Beveridge, 1996, for review). With the development of salmonid farming in the nineteenth century, the use of animal protein such as oysters and horseflesh in diets became necessary (Maitland, 1887). Rumsey (1994) quotes anecdotal mention of fish feeds in books by Garlick, Norris and Stone published in North America during the latter half of the nineteenth century, although he says little detail is provided. Fish diet development started in earnest in the 1920s (Ellis, 1994; Rumsey, 1994). In Germany Schaeperclaus (1933) published a monograph on pond fish culture in which he discusses the inclusion of marine fish, meat and offal from warm-blooded animals, fish and shrimp flours and waste meals from oil extraction of soya, sunflower, etc., in trout diets. He also recommends the inclusion of 25% of beech or poplar sawdust as binder!
Discussion Despite the lack of serious archaeological or historical research there is sufficient evidence to conclude that the origins of aquaculture date back several ± possibly as many as five ± millennia. Early aquaculture ± proto-aquaculture as we have termed it here ± would probably have involved some simple form of intervention, such as transplantation of fertilized eggs or spawning fish or the enhancement of spawning grounds to increase production. Such actions would require that a claim to ownership or the control of access to and exploitation rights of stocks were established. A parallel development may have been the use of feed or shelter, probably first to attract fish in natural ecosystems and make them easier to exploit, before these aspects were incorporated into more formal culture systems. These forms of proto-aquaculture have parallels with the development of animal husbandry (see Fig. 1.1 and Table 1.2). The concept would have been readily understood, and perhaps informed from experience with livestock, and if inappropriate food were given it would have acted as a fertilizer, stimulating the productivity of the food web. As with agriculture, aquaculture would have to wait until the twentieth century for the arrival of inorganic fertilizers, but scientific inquiry into their use, and widespread adoption by fish farmers lags behind their use in terrestrial systems by several decades. Evidence suggests that captive breeding of fish and the management of ponds were later developments, as indicated in the aquaculture development scenario illustrated in Fig. 1.1b. Without control over propagation, selection for improved growth and disease resistance, let alone shape, colour, flesh quality or domestication, such a significant
24
Ecological Aquaculture
component of agricultural husbandry could not occur. In fact, the opposite may have happened. Although in certain contexts there would have been a large degree of passive selection for response to cultured environments, the practice of harvesting larger fish, leaving the smaller, slower-growing fish to serve as broodstock was, and still is, commonplace (see Silliman, 1975, for discussion). Removing the largest individual appears to be a common practice in the history of aquaculture the world over, perhaps illustrating residual close links to `hunting' and the role of raising fish in building social capital. That the fish thrived and grew often owed more to chance than to a profound understanding of how to satisfy the animals' needs; that had to wait until the development of the biological sciences in the nineteenth century. Proto-aquaculture activities have been recorded in many parts of the ancient world, including Egypt, China and Mexico. Why did aquaculture develop in some places rather than others, and what governed the methods of culture and the pattern of development? Fish has almost always been universally important in the Asian diet. Although extensive, China's coastline was small relative to the inland land mass. With its wetland-based agriculture and, from the Han Dynasty onwards, its high densities of aquatic food-eating people it had strong incentives to develop inland aquaculture and it is here that such advanced aquaculture methods as controlled spawning of fish, polyculture and integrated aquaculture first developed. By contrast, until recently in Japan and other countries with extensive coastlines, marine fish and shellfish resources were sufficient to supply their populations' needs. It should also be reiterated that religion, politics and power and social issues were sometimes more important in aquaculture development than increasing the supply of food or economic viability. In central and western Europe, for example, fish farming was primarily developed in the first instance by the monastic orders in order to ensure supplies of fish for days when eating of meat was forbidden. Subsequent pond aquaculture developments in continental Europe occurred in areas where soils were too poor to sustain agriculture (Hickling, 1962). In medieval England pond fish culture was also used by the arriviste Norman rulers to help consolidate political power. There are many parallels between the development of agriculture and aquaculture, with people opting in and out as the need for fish/food changed. However, unlike agriculture which has been the most important way of obtaining food on land for at least 10 000 years, aquaculture has until recently contributed little in real terms to world fish or shellfish production. Instead of evolving towards cultivation, hunter± gatherer methods of procuring food from the aquatic environment developed along a different path: by improvements in tracking methods and by increases in killing power. There are several reasons why the exploitation of food in terrestrial and aquatic environments did not develop in the same way. First, food in inland waters and in the sea has, until recently, been abundant. Changes in fishing grounds, increases in fishing pressure and development of fisheries technology were sufficient to meet demands and there was therefore little incentive to learn to farm. Moreover, the aquatic environment was hostile and something to be feared. It must have seemed impossible that a structure that could hold fish securely and withstand the forces of the tides and currents, waves and storms, could be built in the sea. There were other
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
25
technical problems, too, to overcome. While the breeding and husbandry of animals and the harvesting and planting of seeds was readily achieved on land, it has proved difficult to breed many aquatic species and to hatch the eggs and successfully rear the offspring. These problems in part stemmed from the fact that people were dealing with organisms that were very different from themselves and with an environment about which they were largely ignorant. It was not until the rise of the biological sciences in the nineteenth century that the mysteries surrounding the physiology and reproduction of aquatic animals and the role the environment played in controlling these processes began to be understood. These constraints were greater for coastal than inland environments, which may explain the earlier development of the latter. The environments for fish culture to develop were to some extent a consequence of the overall development of intensified floodplain agriculture in Asia. Like agriculture and fishing, aquaculture was shaped by changes in society ± wars and colonialism, politics and power, the waxing and waning of religions with their associated cults and schisms, the rise of science and industrialization (Tables 1.2, 1.3). However, it is not solely concerned with the production of food but has also played a role in a number of religions and in consolidating social position. The production of fish for religious purposes in ancient Egypt, Christian Europe and Buddhist Japan has contributed much to the development of aquaculture as a whole, especially with regard to selective breeding. Certain ironies are also apparent. Unlike hunting whose image is associated with nobility, fishing is often associated with poor people of low social standing (Sahrhage & Lundbeck, 1992). The construction of fishponds and the keeping of fish as in the Roman Empire and medieval England have long been associated with social position and would have required significant resources unavailable to ordinary people. Where demands for fish for religious or social purposes declined or the economics of production changed, as in ancient Egypt and in eighteenth century France, fish farming withered and died. Despite its ancient roots, however, fish and shellfish farming should be regarded as very much a post-Second World War phenomenon. Although locally important, in global terms farmed aquatic production prior to 1950 was insignificant. With the possible exception of China, few of today's important industries, particularly where mariculture is concerned, owe much to ancient traditions or technologies or have a history extending back more than 30 or 40 years. Even in China until recently farmed production was but a fraction of that from capture fisheries. Data assembled by Li (1994) and the FAO (Lu, 1992; Immink, 1997) show that the spectacular ± approximately 50-fold ± growth in cultured freshwater fish production has occurred since the founding of the People's Republic in 1949 as a result of political, economic, technical and demographic changes. Some 82 000 man-made water bodies have been constructed for hydropower, flood control and irrigation purposes, increasing the inland water surface area by 2.05 million ha (Lu, 1992). In the late 1950s the techniques for spawning Chinese carps were developed, freeing Chinese farmers from their reliance on wild-caught fry, while the development of the mixed economy some 20 years later has given further incentives to increase productivity. Elsewhere in Asia aquaculture was rare until recent decades. Huet's (1972) generalization that `In the
26
Ecological Aquaculture
Far East where all farmers are fish farmers and vice versa' was based on observations of a few clusters of activity around Bangkok and in West Java (Edwards et al., 1997). Edwards et al. estimate that probably far fewer than 10% of small-scale farms in the region culture fish and of those that do, most produce fewer fish than their resource base allows. And what is the legacy of traditional aquaculture? Much present day mariculture, particularly the intensive salmon and shrimp farming industries that have grown so rapidly during the past two decades, has a basis in industry. It has been technologyled and is heavily dependent upon the environment not only for the supply of essential resources such as food, but also to disperse and assimilate waste food, faeces, excreta and chemical residues (Beveridge et al., 1997). In parts of China traditional aquaculture practices are being abandoned in favour of intensification. Land prices are too high, water is in short supply, cheap feeds are becoming ever more easily available and there is a strong demand for fish from the increasingly affluent and urbanized population. Throughout Asia, the stigma associated with use of night soil in ponds has led to a decline in its use, compounded by increased mixing of human and industrial waste in urban sewage systems (P. Edwards, pers. comm.). However, for large areas of rural Asia, and elsewhere in the developing world, resource-intensive aquaculture is not, and is unlikely to be, a viable option. Trends to separate aquaculture from broader farming systems are largely commercially driven but are in conflict with longer term, and rational, practice. Just as industrial livestock production is now being challenged in Western Europe on public health, animal welfare and, most immediately, environmental grounds, we expect a similar fate for unsustainable aquaculture development.
Acknowledgments Colleagues James Muir, David Penman and Krishen Rana kindly helped with information and references. Last, but not least, we thank Dr Barry Costa-Pierce for his knowledge and enthusiasm on the subject of the ecology of aquaculture systems.
References Adamek, Z. & Kouril, J. (2000) A long aquaculture tradition in the Czech Republic. Aquaculture Europe, 25 (1), 20±23. Adams, N. (1984) Architecture for fish: the Sienese Dam on the Bruna River ± structures and designs, 1468±ca. 1530. Technology and Culture, 768±797. Ardizzone, G.D., Cataudella, S. & Rossi, R. (1988) Management of Coastal Lagoon Fisheries and Aquaculture in Italy. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper, 293. FAO, Rome. Armillas, P. (1971) Gardens on swamps. Science, 174, 653±661. Balon, E.K. (1995) Origin and domestication of the wild carp Cyprinus carpio: from Roman gourmets to the swimming flowers. Aquaculture, 129, 3±49. Beveridge, M.C.M. (1996) Cage Aquaculture, 2nd edn. Blackwell Science, Oxford.
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
27
Beveridge, M.C.M., Phillips, M.J. & Macintosh, D.C. (1997) Aquaculture and the environment: the supply and demand for environmental goods and services by Asian aquaculture and the implications for sustainability. Aquaculture Research, 28, 101±111. Binnie, G.M. (1987) Early Dam Builders in Britain. Thomas Telford, London. Boserup, E. (1965) The Conditions of Agricultural Growth. Allen & Unwin, London. Bray, F. (1984) Biology and Biological Technology. Part II: Agriculture. Science and Civilisation in China. Vol. VI (ed. J. Needham). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Brewer, D.J. & Friedman, R.F. (1989) Fish and Fishing in Ancient Egypt. Aris & Phillips, Warminster, UK. Bromley, D.W. (1992) Making the Commons Work. Theory, Practice and Policy. ICS Press, San Francisco. Chambers, R.A. & Gray, M. (1988) The excavation of fishponds. In: Medieval Fish, Fisheries and Fishponds in England (ed. M. Aston), pp. 113±128. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 182 (i). Chevey, P. & Lemasson, J. (1937) Contribution aÁ l'EÂtude des Poissons des Eaux Douces Tonkinoises. Institut OceÂanographic de I'Indochine. 33e Note. Gouvernement GeÂneÂral de L'Indochine, Hanoi. Chimits, P. (1957) Tilapia in ancient Egypt. FAO Fisheries Bulletin, 10, 211±215. Coche, A.G. (1982) Cage culture of Tilapias. In: Biology and Culture of Tilapias (eds R.S.V. Pullin & R.H. Lowe-McConnell), pp. 205±246. ICLARM, Manila, Philippines. Coe, M.D. (1964) The chinampas of Mexico. Scientific American, 211, 90±98. Currie, C.K. (1989) The function of fishponds in the monastic economy. In: The Archaeology of Rural Monasteries (eds R. Gilchrist & H. Mytum), pp. 147±172. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 203. Currie, C.K. (1991) The early history of the carp and its economic significance in England. Agricultural History Reviews, 11, 97±107. Desroches-Noblecourt, C. (1954) Poissons, tabous et transformations du mort. Nouvelles considerations sur les pelerinages aux villes saintes. Kemi, 13, 33±42. Diamond, J. (1997) Guns, Germs and Steel. A Short History of Everybody for the Last 13,000 Tears. Chatto & Windus, London. Drewer, L. (1981) Fishermen and fish pond: from the sea of sin to the living waters. Art Bulletin, 63, 533±547. Drews, R. (1951) The Cultivation of Food Fish in China and Japan: A Study Disclosing Contrasting National Patterns for Rearing Fish Consistent with the Differing Cultural Histories of China and Japan. PhD thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Dyer, C. (1988) The consumption of fish in medieval England. In: Medieval Fish, Fisheries and Fishponds in England (ed. M. Aston), pp. 27±38. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 182 (i). Edwards, P., Little, D.C. & Yakupitiyage, A. (1997) A comparison of traditional and modified inland artisanal aquaculture systems. Aquaculture Research, 28, 777±788. Ellis, J.N. (1994) In search of history: early days and trout feeds. Aquaculture Magazine, July/ August, 50±51, 54, 56±59. Flannery, T.F. (1994) The Future Eaters. Reed Books, Australia. Grigg, D.B. (1974) The Agricultural Systems of the World. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
28
Ecological Aquaculture
Harris, D.R. (Ed.) (1996) The Origins and Spread of Agriculture and Pastoralism in Eurasia. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington. Hepher, B. (1988) Nutrition of Pond Fishes. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Hickling, C.F. (1962) Fish Culture. Faber & Faber, London. Hickling, C.F. (1971) Prior More's fishponds. Medieval Archaeology, XV, 118±123. Hoffman, R.C. (1995) `Carpes pour le Duc . . . :' the operation of fishponds at LaperrieÁre-surSaoÃne, Burgundy, 1332±1352. Archaeofauna, 4, 33±45. Hoffman, R.C. (1996) Economic development and aquatic ecosystems in Medieval Europe. American Historical Reviews, 101, 630±669. Huet, M. (1972) Textbook of Fish Culture. Fishing News Books, Farnham, Surrey. Immink, A.J. (1997) World Aquaculture Production 1950±1983. Report for the FAO, Rome. Institute of Aquaculture, University of Stirling. JimeÂnez-Osornio, J.J. & Gomez-Pompa, A. (1991) Human role in shaping of the flora in a wetland community, the chinampa. Landscape and Urban Ecology, 20, 47±51. Kirk, R. (1987) A History of Marine Fish Culture in Europe and North America. Fishing News Books, Oxford. Knowles, D. (1950) The Monastic Order in England. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Lewis, D.J., Wood, G.D. & Gregory, R. (1996) Trading the Silver Seed. Intermediate Technology Development Group, London. Li, K.M. (1992) Rice±fish farming systems in China: past, present and future. In: Rice±Fish Research and Development in Asia (eds C. R. de la Cruz, C. Lightfoot, B.A. Costa-Pierce, V.R. Carangal & M.P. Bimbao), pp. 17±26. ICLARM Conference Proceedings 24, ICLARM, Manila. Li, S.F. (1994) Introduction: freshwater fish culture. In: Freshwater Fish Culture in China: Principles and Practice (eds S. Li & J. Mathias), pp. 1±25. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Lin, Z. (ed.) (1991) Pond Fisheries in China. Pergamon, London. Ling, S.W. (1977) Aquaculture in Southeast Asia. University of Washington Press, Seattle. Little, D.C. & Edwards, P. (1997) Contrasting strategies for inland fish and livestock production in Asia. In: Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition in Australia (eds J.L. Corbett, M. Choct, J.V. Nolan & J.B. Rowe), pp. 77±85. University of New England, Armadale, Australia. Little, D.C. & Edwards, P. (2002) Integrated Livestock ± Fish Farming Systems: the Asian Experience and its Relevance for Other Regions. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper. FAO, Rome (in press). Little, D.C. & Pham, T.A (1999) Common carp indigenous ricefield-based culture in Northern Vietnam. AARM Newsletter, 4 (3), 4±5. Lu, X. (1992) Fishery Management Approaches in Small Reservoirs in China. FAO Fisheries Circular 854. FAO, Rome. Maitland, J.R.G. (1887) The History of Howietoun. J.R. Guy, Stirling. McDonnell, J. (1981) Inland fisheries in medieval Yorkshire 1066±1300. Borthwick Papers, 60. University of York. McLarney, W. (1984) The Freshwater Aquaculture Book. Hartley & Marks, Point Roberts, Washington. Micha, J.-C. & Chavez, M. (1997). Development of agro-piscicultural ecosystems in tropical marshlands. In: Integrated Fish Farming (eds J.A. Mathias, A.T. Charles & H. Baotong), pp. 347±358. CRC Press, Boca Raton.
The History of Aquaculture in Traditional Societies
29
Pitcher, P.T.J. & Hart, P.J.B. (1982) Fisheries Ecology. Croom Helm, London. Rana, K.J. (1998) Recent developments in aquaculture statistics. Fishery and aquaculture statistics in Asia. In: Proceedings of the FAO/SEAFDEC Regional Workshop on Fishery Statistics. 19±21 August 1997, 11, 242±254. FAO, Rome. Reay, P.J. (1979) Aquaculture. Arnold, London. Roberts, B.K. (1966) Medieval fishponds. Amateur Historian, VII, 119±126. Roberts, E. (1985) Alresford Pond, a medieval canal reservoir: a tradition assessed. Proceedings of the Hampshire Field Club and Archaeological Society, 41, 127±138. Ruddle, K. & Zhong, G. (1988) Integrated Agriculture±Aquaculture in South China. The Dike± Pond System of the Zhujiang Delta. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Rumsey, G.L. (1994) History of early diet development in fish culture, 1000 BC to AD 1955. Progressive Fish-Culturist, 56, 1±6. Sahrhage, D. & Lundbeck, J. (1992) A History of Fishing. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Schaeperclaus, W. (1933) Lehrbuch der Teichwirtschaft. Paul Parey, Berlin. Schnitter, N.J. (1994) A History of Dams. A.A. Balkema, Rotterdam. Schuster, W.H. (1952) Fish Culture in Brackish-Water Ponds of Java. Indo-Pacific Fisheries Council Special Publication No. 1. FAO, Rome. Sharma, K.P. & Rana, R. (1986). Seasonal ponds ± a potential source of fish seed in Rajasthan, India. In: The First Asian Fisheries Forum (eds J.L. Maclean, L.B. Diizon & L.V. Hosillos), pp. 87±88. Asian Fisheries Society, Manila, Philippines. Silliman, R.P. (1975) Selective and unselective exploitation of experimental populations of T. mossambicus. Fisheries Bulletin, 73, 495±507. Stearne, J.M. (1971) The medieval fishponds of Northamptonshire. Northants Past and Present, IV (5), 299±310. Stearne, J.M. (1988) The royal fishponds of medieval England. In: Medieval Fish, Fisheries and Fishponds in England (ed. M. Aston), pp. 39±68. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 182 (i). Stewart, K.M. (1994) Early hominid utilization of fish resources and implications for seasonality and behaviour. Journal of Human Evolution, 27, 229±245. Taverner, J. (1600) Certaine Experiments Concerning Fish and Fruite. William Ponsonby, London. Tudge, C. (1998) Neanderthals, Bandits and Farmers. How Agriculture Really Began. Weidenfield & Nicolson, London. Votruba, L. (1987) Historissche Talsperren und Wasserseicher in der CSSR. Historische Talsperren, Band 1, pp. 401±406. K. Witter, Stuttgart. Welcomme, R.L. (1972) An evaluation of the acadja method of fishing as practiced in the coastal lagoons of Dahomey (West Africa). Journal of Fish Biology, 4, 39±55. Yang, H. (1994) Integrated fish farming. In: Freshwater Fish Culture in China: Principles and Practice (eds S. Li & J. Mathias), pp. 219±270. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Zeepvat, R.J. (1988) Fishponds in Roman Britain. In: Medieval Fish, Fisheries and Fishponds in England (ed. M. Aston), pp. 17±26. British Archaeological Reports, British Series, 182 (i).
Chapter 2
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii Barry A. Costa-Pierce Rhode Island Sea Grant College Program `The whole distance to the village of Whyeete is taken up with innumerable artificial fishponds extending a mile inland from shore, in these the fish taken by nets in the sea are put, and though most of the ponds are fresh water, yet the fish seem to thrive and fatten. . . . The ponds are several hundred in number and are the resort of ducks and other waterfowl' T. Bloxam, British naturalist on H.M.S. Blonde describing Waikiki in 1825 (Handy & Handy, 1972).
Introduction Beveridge & Little (Chapter 1, this volume) describe what is known about the origins of aquaculture in traditional societies in China, Egypt, Europe and the Americas. Most of these examples are inland, freshwater developments associated with rivers or other water courses indigenous to large continental land masses. The ancient mariculture systems of Hawaii are unique in that they connect an isolated island society with sophisticated ocean harvesting and integrated sea farming activities to an entire watershed management/food production system (the ahupua'a). Ancient Hawaiian mariculture systems are remarkable in terms of their diversity, distinctive management, and sheer extent of development, especially given the small size of Hawaii. Although the Hawaiian systems are relatively recent (only 1500±1800 years old) by Chinese and Egyptian standards, the evolution of ocean fishing to ranching and onwards to true ocean farming systems (mariculture) is notable. Evolution of such sophisticated farming systems may be a natural evolutionary part of societies whose population densities exceed the carrying capacity of natural ecosystems to support them. As a result, rapid evolution of new, innovative farming systems ± such as ecological aquaculture and mariculture systems ± occurred in Hawaii.
The social ecology of ancient Hawaii `The shores of Hawaii are by no means so well stocked with fish as those of the Society Islands . . . The industry of the Hawaiians in a great degree makes up for
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
31
the deficiency in fish, for they have numerous small lakes and ponds, frequently artificial, wherein they breed fish of various kinds and in tolerable abundance' (Ellis, 1826) The ancient Hawaiian fishponds were part of a large, integrated, and complex Hawaiian subsistence and barter economy that included agriculture, aquaculture, and animal rearing. The political aspects of this sociocultural system contributed greatly to the development of the expansive aquaculture±agriculture network. Hierarchical political control and redistribution of food was essential to the smooth functioning of the ancient integrated farming systems, because construction and management of the huge fishpond complexes required sizeable labor forces. Massive ponds such as the Kaloko pond in Kona, Hawaii, have a 229 m long wall about 2 m high that is 11 m thick at the base. This wall contains an estimated 150 000 m3 of rock and fill (Apple & Kikuchi, 1975). The Kuapa pond at Maunalua, Oahu, was reportedly built over several years by thousands of people who formed long human chains to transport rocks from the Ko'olau Mountains. Efforts of this magnitude obviously required tremendous social organization. Ancient Hawaii had highly stratified chiefdoms with a well defined class structure separating chiefs, advisors, stewards, and commoners. This organization was similar to that of the chiefdoms found in Tonga, Samoa and the Society Islands (Sahlins, 1958). Prior to 1848, all Hawaiian land ± its natural resources, fishponds, communal and spiritual centers ± were owned by the kings (ali'i). The kings would contract the bulk of the land and fishponds to subchiefs (konahiki), but keep sacred resources such as fishponds under their direct control. Couriers would transport from royal fishponds to the court plump fish in water-filled gourds or by hand (Rice, 1923). Subchiefs were granted large, wedge-shaped areas (ahupua'a) of the Hawaiian islands that encompassed the watersheds of entire valleys, stretching from the mountains to the sea (Lind, 1938). Ahupua'a were generally not physically demarcated in Hawaii. No evidence of erect stones marking individual land holdings, such as in Tahiti, have been found (Handy & Handy, 1972). It appears that the ahupua'a were mainly political subdivisions granted by the kings to the subchiefs to assure subsistence supplies of food, firewood, timber, thatch, and ornamentation. Handy & Handy (1972) have described a share-cropping arrangement between tenant families and the subchiefs that was `comprehensive and reciprocal in its benefits.' Within an ahupua'a, sections of land ('ili) were granted to individual extended families ('ohana) for cultivation. These land divisions within the ahupua'a carried individual titles. `It was said that in every community there were individuals who were well versed in the local lore of land boundaries, rights, and history' (Handy & Handy, 1972). All harvests from the fishponds were distributed in a politically institutionalized manner by the subchiefs to extended family groups and pond workers living in the ahupua'a. Kikuchi (1976) suggested that the fishponds were symbols of the chiefly right to conspicuous consumption and the exclusive ownership of the land and its resources, and that the fishponds were the subject of frequent inter- and intratribal conflicts.
32
Ecological Aquaculture
Kamakau (1976) argues, however, that the presence of the fishponds did not indicate any contempt on the part of the subchiefs for the local populace. He stated, `How could they have worked together in unity and made these walls if they had been frequently at war and in opposition against one another? If they did not eat the fruit of their efforts?' Indeed, a native Hawaiian, David Malo, wrote of a Big Island chief who was killed because of his cruel efforts to exploit his people when he ` made the people of Ka'u sweat and groan . . . [with] the building of heavy stone walls about several fishponds' (Malo, 1951). Contact with Europeans, which began in 1778, had dramatic effects on all levels of Hawaiian society. It destroyed the ancient religion and the chief's supernatural right to control all the land, its resources, and its people. The economy changed from the traditiona1 barter system to a monetary economy. Contact with foreigners brought new diseases, which led to the massive depopulation of Hawaii. The Hawaiian land decision of 1848 decision (known as the Great Mahele) allowed the purchase of crown lands by Hawaiian commoners and by foreigners. In many areas the largest purchase of these lands was by foreigners. Some of these purchased thousands of acres for $0.25±$0.50 per acre (Kelly, 1980). The Great Mahele was a pivotal point not only in Hawaiian history but also in the history of the integrated mariculture farming ecosystems. Decline of the fishpond complexes and Hawaiian integrated aquaculture ecosystems was rapid after the Great Mahele. Once the harvests from the lands and fishponds became economic entities with prices, their distribution tended no longer to follow either an institutionalized pattern of sharing (Handy & Handy, 1972) or exploitation of the commoners by the chiefs (Kikuchi, 1973), as before the Great Mahele. With the general demise of native Hawaiian society, the majority of Hawaiian integrated farming systems fell into disuse and disrepair. When Captain James Cook reached Hawaii in 1778, at least 360 fishponds existed. They produced an estimated 900 metric tons (mt) of fish/year (Costa-Pierce, 1987). Farber (1997) speculated there were as many as 488 ponds. According to the State of Hawaii, only 28 ponds were suitable for fish culture in 1977 (Madden & Paulsen, 1977). By 1985 only seven ponds were in commercial or subsistence use, producing an estimated 15 000±20 000 kg/year. However, accelerated community development efforts in the 1980±90s, especially on Molokai, which included studies, conferences, and formation of a fishpond task force, identified 31 ponds on Molokai alone that the Hawaiian community wanted to restore (Wyban, 1992; Farber, 1997).
Hawaiian integrated aquaculture ecosystems Four basic types of fishponds and one fish `trap' were known in ancient Hawaii and were integrated to various degrees with the staple carbohydrate crop of the Hawaiians, wetland taro (Colocasia esculenta). Ponds were fed with cut grass, mussels, clams, seaweeds, and taro leaf from adjacent agricultural or natural ecosystems (Wilder, 1923; Titcomb, 1952). In contrast to modern integrated aquaculture systems in Asia, Hawaiian fishponds did not receive fertilization from animal or human
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
33
wastes or kitchen refuse. Hawaiian chiefs prohibited such waste introductions (Kikuchi, 1976). The diversity, extent, and number of fishponds in Hawaii before contact with Europeans is impressive. The various fishponds spanned the natural salinity range of water. The four types of fishponds (Fig. 2.1) developed within the ahupua'a were: freshwater taro fishponds (loko i'a kalo) l other freshwater ponds (loko wai) l brackish water ponds (loko pu'uone) l seawater ponds (loko kuapa) l
Fig. 2.1 Four types of Hawaiian integrated aquaculture ecosystems developed in historical times: (a) lo'i were for the paddy culture of taro (Colocasia esculenta); and loko i'a kalo were taro patches modified to include aquaculture. These upland ponds are depicted in a valley with elevation contours indicated; (b) loko wai were artificial (and modified natural) freshwater lakes excavated for aquaculture; (c) loko pu'uone were brackishwater lakes separated from the sea by a pu'uone (a spit of land reinforced by mud, silt, and refuse) and connected to the sea by a ditch that had grates to trap and hold large fish; (d) loko kuapa were ponds built along the ocean shore usually on top of a reef flat with volcanic rock and/or coral rock to form a wall (kuapa). Controlled harvests were accomplished using a canal, net, and grate system. Modified from Kikuchi (1976).
34
Ecological Aquaculture
An additional type of pond (a fish trap) was known as loko `umeiki (Summers, 1964).
Freshwater taro fishpond ecosystems The taro fishponds (loko i'a kalo) were developed in the uplands to cultivate taro and simultaneously grow a limited range of euryhaline and freshwater fish, such as mullet (Mugil cephalus; ama 'ama), silver perch (Kuhlia sandwicensis; aholehole), and Hawaiian gobies (Eleotris sandwicensis and E. fusca; 'o'opu). Freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium sp.; opae) and green algae (Spirogyra sp. and Cladophora sp.; limu kalawai) were also grown. These integrated freshwater fishpond ecosystems probably arose originally from shallow ponds (lo'i) created by the diversion of stream runoff for the irrigation of wetland taro agriculture. Over time the Hawaiians added aquaculture to the design of these ponds. In addition, surplus fish from abundant sea harvests of milkfish (Chanos chanos), mullet and silver perch were put in shallow freshwater taro ponds located close to the sea. Fish also directly entered the taro patch-fishponds by migrating from the sea up the newly created artificial estuary. It is likely that the originators of the stocking practice observed that fish put temporarily in these freshwater ponds near the ocean not only survived the harsh transition in salinity from salt to fresh but also grew well. They also probably noticed that their taro grew more luxuriantly and had fewer pests, owing to the continual grazing and pruning activities of herbivorous and benthic-feeding fish such as milkfish and mullet. Taro was planted in mounds to leave channels for swimming fish to feed on the insects and ripe leaf stems of the taro (Kamakau, 1976).
Other freshwater pond ecosystems The second type of freshwater ponds, loko wai, were inland ponds or lakes typically excavated by hand from a natural depression, lake, or pool and supplied with water diverted by ditches from streams, rivers, or by natural groundwater springs or aquifers. Native species of freshwater prawn and Hawaiian gobies (Eleotris sandwicensis, E. fusca, and Gnatholepis anjernesis) and migrants from the sea that move into freshwater (mullet, milkfish, and silver perch) were stocked, grown, and harvested from these ponds. Milkfish were particularly abundant in these ponds, having been procured in shallow shoreline areas and carried long distances in large gourds filled with water (Beckley, 1883). These ponds were harvested by woven reed nets (hala) placed across a channel to capture the fish during their seaward spawning migrations, oftentimes during full moons in the spring.
Brackishwater pond ecosystems Brackishwater ponds, loko pu'uone, were coastal ponds excavated by hand from a natural body of water stranded by eustatic sea level changes (Kikuchi, 1976), or
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
35
formed by piling mud, sand, and coral to form earth embankments parallel to the coast (Fig. 2.1). A sand bar, coastal reef, or two adjacent edges of land masses isolated these ponds from the open sea. These loko pu'uone were connected to the ocean by a canal constructed so that seawater would enter the fishpond on a rising tide. Loko pu'uone usually had some freshwater inputs, either from springs, streams entering the pond, submarine groundwater discharges, or water percolating from adjacent aquifers. The combination of fresh- and saltwater produced a brackishwater environment that was very productive and very diverse in fish species that could acclimate to both fresh- and saltwater. Two types of loko pu'uone have been described, a commoner's pu'uone and a king's pu'uone (Handy & Handy, 1972), classified by their ownership and the effort and elaboration used in their construction.
Nearshore mariculture ecosystems The fourth type of fishpond, the seawater ponds, loko kuapa, were the ultimate aquaculture achievement of the native Hawaiians and a valuable contribution to native engineering and the evolution of subsistence food production. Mariculture, or the farming of euryhaline and marine aquatic animals in seawater, appears to have reached a sophisticated level in ancient Hawaii. Summers (1964) states that loko kuapa are found nowhere else in Polynesia. The main isolating feature of these ponds was a seawall (kuapa) constructed of coral or lava rock. Kikuchi (1973) noted that the lengths of 90 fishponds studied ranged from 46 to 1920 m, with the greatest frequency of lengths between 366 and 610 m, containing an average of 955 m3 of rocks and fill. Some of the stones used in the walls have been estimated to weigh as much as half a ton. On the island of Molokai, which has a protected, regular, shoal, southern coastline, more loko kuapa were constructed per area of land than anywhere else in Hawaii (Fig. 2.2). Large numbers of these ponds were also developed in the Kaneohe Bay, Waikiki,
Fig. 2.2 A map of the Hawaiian island of Molokai with its long, shoal, southern coastline. Darkened areas indicate the areas of some 28 marine fishponds (loko kuapa), Two brackish water ponds (loko pu'uone) are indicated by letters. Numbers refer to the location of fish traps (loko 'umeiki). Modified from Cobb (1902).
36
Ecological Aquaculture
and Pearl Harbor areas of Oahu (Fig. 2.3). In some of the Molokai ponds coralline algae, which secrete a natural cement, were used to strengthen the walls. Women and children gathered coralline algae from the sea for this purpose (Summers, 1964). Ponds on Molokai were built on a reef flat, with the walls extending in a semicircle from the shoreline. The ponds thereby contained all of the marine aquatic biota of the original reef environment. At least 22 species of marine life f1ourished in these ponds (Fig. 2.4).
Fig. 2.3 A map of the Pearl Harbor and Kalihi Basin areas of the island of Oahu, Hawaii. Darkened areas depict the locations of more than 30 loko wai, loko pu'uone and loko kuapa. Modified from McAllister (1933).
Loko kuapa had an additional feature that can only be described as an ancient ecological engineering marvel. Canals (auwai) were constructed into the walls of the ponds for the stocking, harvesting, and cleaning of the seawater ponds with minimal human effort. The canals connected the ponds directly to the sea and had, in the middle, a single, immovable grate (makaha) made of dense native woods (Fig. 2.5). These grates were constructed by vertically lashing solid timbers ('ohi'ia or lama) to two or three cross beams with ferns, so that the individual timbers were separated by approximately 0.5±2.0 cm wide spaces. As a result, only water and very small fish could pass freely in and out of the pond. The pond was therefore automatically stocked by normal recruitment of juvenile fish from the sea. The grates were fixed in the canal, and large fish trying to migrate to the sea to spawn were harvested by setting nets on the pond side of the grate, or by hand capture (Kamakau, 1976). Harvesting was attuned to the behavior of the fish. Loko kuapa were used to culture mainly two species of fish (milkfish and mullet). Both are sea spawners (catadromous). During spring moons in Hawaii, they return from their freshwater and brackishwater habitats to spawn in coastal seawater. Salmon, being anadromous fish, have an exactly opposite life cycle. During the migration periods the keepers of the fishpond (kia'i) would joyously watch hundreds of fish swim into
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
Fig. 2.4 The Hawaiian integrated aquaculture ecosystem spanned the entire normal salinity range of water, and comprised a continuum from agriculture to aquaculture. An impressive number of species were harvested from seawater fishponds and traps; the ponds enclosed a reef-flat environment and all of the reef-flat species. Modified from Kikuchi (1976).
37
38
Ecological Aquaculture
Fig. 2.5 Details of the sluice grate (makaha) that was permanently fixed in a canal (auwai o ka makaha) that connected the marine fishponds to the open sea. Nets were set on the pond side of the canal to capture fish gathering in the canal attempting to migrate to the sea. A single, immovable grate was used in the ancient design but was modified in recent times to have two grates on the ocean and pond sides of the canal. Modified from Apple & Kikuchi (1975).
the canal in a futile attempt to reach the sea. Nets set on the pond side of the makaha close off the migratory route. Later in Hawaiian history, the canals were modified to have one or two vertically movable makaha substituting for the set net and immovable makaha used earlier. With this modification, as the fish entered the canal and tried to migrate to the sea, the seaside makaha was lowered (or was permanently fixed) and the pond side makaha was raised and fish crowded into the harvest canal. The pond side makaha was then lowered, trapping the fish, which were simply netted out or hand harvested from the canal. The process was then repeated. Thus through the use of keen observational skills and knowledge of fish behavior, a method was devised of allowing the fish to harvest themselves!
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
39
`When the keeper of the pond wished to remove some fish, he would go to the makaha (grate) while the tide was coming . . . the keeper would dip his foot into the water at the makaha . . . and if the sea pressed in like a stream and felt warm, then he knew that the sluice would be full of fish. The fish would scent the fresh sea and long for it! I have seen them become like wild things. At a sluice where the fish had been treated like pet pigs, they would crowd to the makaha where the keepers felt of them with their hands and took whatever of them they wanted.' S.M. Kamakau, 9 December 1869. Translated from a Hawaiian Newspaper, Ke Au 'Oko'a (Kamakau, 1976) Over time the loko kuapa would become filled with sediments, either washed in during heavy rains or accumulated from the settling of particles in the water. In some of the larger ponds on Molokai that tended to become silted, the grates and canals were operated to clean the ponds, in a clever example of practical pond maintenance. In these cases, more than one canal was constructed in an orderly pattern in the pond walls, with grates set across from each other into the direction of the prevailing longshore current. On a rising tide the grate on the upstream end of the longshore current was opened. This washed the sediment accumulated at this upstream grate downstream toward the middle of the fishpond. On the next ebb tide this upstream grate was closed, and the downstream grate on the opposite side of the pond opened. The ebb tide therefore tended to pull the accumulated sediment from the middle of the pond toward the downstream grate. By a regular program of following the tidal cycle and opening and closing the proper grates the ponds could be effectively cleaned of sediment. In addition, if a pond was silted up after a particularly heavy rain, weighted bamboo rakes (kope 'ohe) were towed behind outrigger canoes to facilitate movement of the accumulated sediment out of the fishponds. Cordover (1970) discovered another type of seawater fishpond on Molokai with no grates. These ponds were stocked with fingerling mullet (Mugil cephalus) only once, and it was reported by Hawaiians that mullet spawned and grew there successfully. Hamre (1945) reported more of these types of ponds on Molokai prior to the 1946 tsunami. Although modern scientists have had great difficulty in spawning mullet in captivity (this has improved only recently), Phelps (1937) was assured by Hawaiian elders that mullet had indeed spawned regularly in these ponds. He states, `The Hawaiian knowledge of the natural history of fishes, in the old days, should not be underestimated' (Phelps, 1937).
Nearshore fish traps The last type of fishpond used by the Hawaiians, loko 'umeiki, was actually a trap rather than a pond (Fig. 2.5). Hawaiian fish traps are very similar to those in much of Oceania. Like loko kuapa, these traps were shoreline ponds with low, semicircular pond walls. However, unlike the loko kuapa, pond walls were partially or wholly submerged at high tide and contained numerous openings, or lanes, leading into or
40
Ecological Aquaculture
out of the trap. Most known loko 'umeiki were located on the island of Molokai, possibly owing to the favorable orientation of the island with regard to longshore currents. However, it is claimed that Pearl Harbor, on Oahu, had three or four of these types of traps and that one fish trap may have existed on land. These lanes connecting the traps with the ocean were used to catch fish migrating down the coastline, which were attracted to the surge of water at the lane entrances (Fig. 2.6). Fishermen simply set nets facing the sea across the opening of the lane to capture fish swimming into the trap on an incoming tide. When the tide reversed, fishermen faced their nets toward the traps, capturing fish as they swam out toward the sea. It was reported that the right to fish during different portions of the tidal cycle was divided among family groups.
Fig. 2.6 Plan of a fish trap (loko'umeiki) called Papa'ili'ili on the island of Molokai wedged between two marine fishponds (loko kuapa) (called Kaina'ohe and Keawanui). Details of three pond outlet canals (A,B,C) and one pond inlet canal (D) are shown. Note the enlarged wall sections on canals B, C, and D accommodating fishers. These areas indicate where nets were set to capture fish on rising (D) and falling (A,B,C) tides. Modified from Stokes (1909).
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
41
`Such was the case of Mikiawa Pond at Ka'amola, Molokai. When the tide was coming in, the people of Keawanui could use the lanes. When the sea ebbed, the fish belong to Ka'amola.' Timoteo Keaweiwi, 1853, Foreign Native Testimony Book 16, State of Hawaii Archives, Honolulu, Hawaii (Summers, 1964)
The context of the Hawaiian innovations in the evolution of mariculture ecosystems It is evident that the ancient Hawaiians supported a high population density by managing an ecologically complex integrated farming system that connected agricultural watershed ecosystems to nearshore mariculture/fisheries ecosystems ± the ahupua'a aquaculture ecosystem (Fig. 2.7). These historical developments are
Fig. 2.7 An idealized Hawaiian ahupua'a aquaculture ecosystem showing topographic placement of freshwater, brackishwater, and nearshore integrated aquaculture ecosystems on the landscape. Stars indicate placement of settlements. Hawaiian aquaculture ecosystems were diverse, unique, and well adapted to the wide range of natural environments and social structures present. Typical valley ecosystems of this type would be approximately 10 km from mountains to ocean and 10±20 km along the shoreline.
42
Ecological Aquaculture
remarkably similar in principle to integrated farming systems developed in ancient China and Egypt. Hawaiian society, like other ancient civilizations, was subject to droughts, climatic disruptions, natural disasters, and famines; it may have developed these integrated farming systems in response. The limited archeological and aquaculture research, as well as exploration in the Pacific Basin, allows no conclusions to be drawn either regarding the uniqueness of the Hawaiian integrated farming systems among the Pacific islands, as some have suggested (Summers, 1964; Kikuchi, 1973), or their possible relationships to Chinese or other Asian systems. The Hawaiians appear to be one of the originators of mariculture; there is no evidence of another ancient culture using oceanic resources in this manner (Costa-Pierce, 1987). Most of the previous work on early Hawaiian aquaculture focused on the marine fishponds. These studies concluded that the ponds were technologically primitive, ecologically inefficient, and unproductive in biomass per unit area when compared with Asian practices (Hiatt, 1947a, b; Kikuchi, 1973, 1976). But these earlier interpretations may be inappropriate in light of the total farming ecosystem, which spanned an extensive salinity range of water, encompassed entire valleys, and integrated watersheds and nearshore marine ecosystems in unique and possibly unprecedented ways.
References Apple, R.A. & Kikuchi, W.K. (1975) Ancient Hawaii Shore Zone Fishponds: An Evaluation of Survivors for Historical Preservation. National Park Service, Honolulu. Beckley, E.M. (1883) Hawaiian Fisheries and Methods of Fishing. Advertiser Stream Print, Honolulu. Cobb, J.N. (1902) Commercial fisheries of the Hawaiian Islands. US Fish Commission, 12, 383± 499. Cordover, J. (1970) Molokai fishponds: manmade ecosystems. In: Molokai Studies: Preliminary Research in Human Ecology (ed. H.T. Lewis), pp. 27±44. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu. Costa-Pierce, B. (1987) Aquaculture in ancient Hawaii. BioScience, 37, 320±331. Ellis, W. (1826) Journal of William Ellis. Notes from a Tour of Hawaii (Owhyhee) 1823. London. Farber, J. (1997) Ancient Hawaiian Fishponds. Neptune House Publications, Encinitas, CA. Hamre, C.J. (1945) A Survey of Nine Commercial Fishponds. Cooperative Fisheries Research Unit, University of Hawaii, Honolulu. Handy, E.S.C. & Handy, E.G. (1972) Native Planters in Old Hawaii. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Hiatt, R.W. (1947a) Food-chains and the food cycle in Hawaiian fish ponds ± Part I. The food and feeding habits of mullet (Mugil cephalus), milkfish (Chanos chanos), and the ten-pounder (Elops machnata). Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 74, 250±261. Hiatt, R.W. (1947b) Food-chains and the food cycle in Hawaiian fish ponds ± Part II. Biotic interactions. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 74, 262±280.
The Ahupua'a Aquaculture Ecosystems in Hawaii
43
Kamakau, S.M. (1976) The Works of the People of Old. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Kelly, M. (1980) Majestic Ka'u: Mo'olelo of Nine Ahupua'a. Report 80-2. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Kikuchi, W.K. (1973) Hawaiian aquacultural systems. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Arizona, Tucson. Kikuchi, W.K. (1976) Prehistoric Hawaiian fishponds. Science,193, 295±299. Lind, A.W. (1938) An Island Community, Ecological Succession in Hawaii. University of Chicago Press, Chicago. Madden, D. & Paulsen, C.L. (1977) The Potential for Mullet and Milkfish Culture in Hawaiian Fishponds. State of Hawaii Department of Planning and Economic Development, Honolulu. Malo, D. (1951) Hawaiian Antiquities (Mo'olelo Hawaii). Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. McAllister, J. (1933) Archaeology of Oahu. Bishop Museum Bulletin 104, Honolulu. Phelps, S. (1937) A Regional Study of Molokai. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Rice, W.H. (1923) Hawaiian Legends. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Sahlins, M.D. (1958) Social Stratification in Polynesia. University of Washington Press, Seattle. Stokes, J. (1909) Molokai Survey Field Notebook. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Summers, C.C. (1964) Hawaiian Fishponds. Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Titcomb, M. (1952) Native Use of Fish in Hawaii. Polynesian Society Press, Wellington, New Zealand. Wilder, G.P. (1923) The Taro, or Kalo, in Hawaii. University of Hawaii Extension Service, Honolulu. Wyban, C. (1992) Tide and Current: Fishponds of Hawai'i. University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu.
Part 2
The Methods of Ecological Aquaculture
Chapter 3
Development and Application of Genetic Tags for Ecological Aquaculture Theresa M. Bert, Michael D. Tringali and Seifu Seyoum Florida Marine Research Institute What is a genetic tag? The term `genetic tag' can refer to any DNA-based marker that can be used to identify individuals (Palsboll, 1999), parentage and family relationships (Garcia De Leon et al., 1995, 1998), members of populations (Moritz, 1994; Triantafyllidis et al., 1999), or even members of species (e.g. Bilodeau et al., 1999; MaKinster et al., 1999; Frischer et al., 2000). Two common uses of genetic tags are to identify specific wild individuals that may be present within groups of individuals (e.g. Paetkau & Strobeck, 1994; Richard et al., 1996) and to track released or escaped offspring of parents bred in captivity (e.g. Garcia De Leon et al., 1998; Hedrick et al., 2000). Ideally, the perfect genetic tag at the most precise level would allow discrimination of each individual in a group from every other individual. The recent, relatively inexpensive availability of DNA sequencing (the determination of the sequence of the nucleotides that comprise DNA) and the development of numerous ways to `look at' DNA have essentially opened the door for the discovery of all types of genetic tags. In many cases, genetic tags with the appropriate level of specificity can be developed in only a few weeks or months. Of course, the more that is known about the DNA of a species or group of species, the easier it usually is to develop a genetic tag, particularly a highly specific one. The use of genetic tags has enhanced our ability to understand contemporary patterns of genetic divergence within and among populations (e.g. Stepien, 1995, 1999); levels of gene flow (Taggart & Ferguson, 1986); many biological and life history characteristics of animals and plants valuable for both theoretical biology and conservation biology (e.g. Packer et al., 1991; Coltman et al., 1998); and the genetic effects of various types of captive breeding program, including aquaculture (e.g. ProdoÈhl et al., 1995), and accidental or purposeful release of captively bred individuals into wild environments (e.g. Mathias et al., 1985; Doyle et al., 1995; Tessier et al., 1997). Particularly the specific identification of individuals via genetic tags has enabled the estimation of parameters that are relevant for studying important ecological and conservation issues (Palsboll, 1999). Thus, the search for and development of genetic tags, particularly for threatened or managed species, is a field of intense activity and paramount importance. Genetic tags used for studies of organismal biology, population biology, ecology,
48
Ecological Aquaculture
evolutionary biology, conservation biology, or applied biology (including aquaculture) can be classified into two general categories: those that are produced by artificial (anthropogenic) selection and those that occur naturally. Selected genetic tags are those genetic alleles or traits that are rare in natural populations but specifically enhanced in cultured populations through a process of selective breeding (see Gharett & Seeb, 1990). Individuals that have a particular rare genotype at a specific gene locus (physical location within the genome) are sought after, brought into captivity, and bred. Subsequent generations of offspring then carry the selected rare allele in high frequencies (up to 100%, if each parent is bred to be homozygous for [i.e. to have identical forms of] the allele). These genetic tags allow cultured organisms to be identified if they are released or escape into wild environments containing a conspecific population in which the targeted allele is very low or absent (e.g. King et al., 1993). Naturally occurring genetic tags are usually composed of one or more segments of highly variable or hypervariable DNA. The advantage of finding this type of genetic tag is that no directed selection is involved in the development or use of the tag. Indeed, most types of DNA that are investigated for their potential as useful genetic tags are thought to be essentially free from selection. A naturally occurring genetic tag allows an individual to be identified in samples collected from a population because the individual's genotype is naturally unique. If individual identity is the objective of the search for a genetic tag, the tag must be so hypervariable that, essentially, every individual has a unique genotype. The discriminatory power of this tag is such that the probability of discerning each individual from another approaches 100%. A genetic tag of this specificity is usually termed a DNA fingerprint (Wright, 1993; O'Reilly & Wright, 1995) and might involve numerous loci.
Types of genetic tag Molecular identification of individuals or groups of individuals can be accomplished by directly looking at DNA sequence or some property of DNA (e.g. length, fragment pattern, mobility) or by looking at DNA products (e.g. the electromobility of alleles at allozyme loci, protein sequences). The choice of DNA tool to use depends on the ability to perform the laboratory analyses needed to find and resolve the DNA or its products and the specific level of discrimination required for the project at hand. For animal research, DNA markers can be developed from two basic types of DNA: nuclear (chromosomal) and mitochondrial (mtDNA). In general, any DNA segment that can be analyzed with reliable repeatability by the technique chosen by the researcher, for which the data can be clearly interpreted, and that possesses a high to hyper degree of variation is a suitable candidate for exploration as a genetic tag. For certain situations, a single segment of DNA serves adequately as the tag; in other cases, the level of discrimination needed may require the tag to be composed of several DNA segments and multiple types of DNA markers. Typical types of nuclear DNA explored for use in developing genetic tags include highly repetitive DNA such as minisatellite and microsatellite DNA, and
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
49
DNA with only moderate to low numbers of repeats, such as introns, genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), and anonymous single-copy, nuclear DNA (ascnDNA). Using certain techniques, even the entire nuclear genome can be used to generate a genetic tag. Minisatellite and microsatellite DNA are collectively known as VNTRs (DNA with variable numbers of tandem nucleotide repeats); microsatellites are also termed SSRs (simple sequence repeats), or STRs (simple tandem repeats). A review of VNTRmarker development and applications can be found in O'Connell & Dillon (1997). Briefly, mini- and microsatellites are regions of DNA composed of sequential repeats of short nucleotide sequences (e.g. AGCCTAGTAGCCTAGTAGCCTAGT . . . , or ACACAC . . .). The typical number of nucleotides in a single minisatellite repeat unit ranges from 10 to 100 base pairs (bp); the typical number in a single microsatellite repeat unit ranges between 2 and 5 bp (Dowling et al., 1996). Allelic polymorphism in mini- and microsatellite DNA is the product of variability in the number of repeated units of these short sequences and is manifested as DNA fragments of different lengths. Levels of polymorphism and numbers of alleles at VNTR loci are generally high within species or populations and may vary greatly among taxa. Minisatellites have an advantage of showing the highest degree of Mendelian polymorphism of all known loci. Thus, they are particularly useful for establishing pedigrees (Burke et al., 1996). Microsatellite loci are essentially replacing allozyme loci as the molecular tool of choice for many types of population genetics studies, including those for detection of interspecific hybridization, within- and between-population genetic diversity, relationships among individuals (including parentage), reproductive success (Bruford et al., 1996), and stock identification (Perez-Enriquez & Nobuhiko, 1999). Often, microsatellite regions are located in regions of DNA called introns. Introns are segments of genes that undergo DNA transcription but not translation. They are distributed throughout the nuclear genome and may be duplicated multiple times in different regions of the genome; each duplicated segment more or less undergoes an independent evolutionary pathway. Introns themselves can be highly variable and can be used as molecular markers. They are highly variable principally because they are non-coding regions of DNA; however, they are likely to be (and some evidence shows that they are) very much affected by selective forces because they are tightly linked to their associated exons (transcribed and translated segments of DNA). In some cases, balancing selection, which can facilitate the maintenance of polymorphisms in loci, has been proposed to account for the high level of genetic diversity in introns. For these reasons, and because a high degree of specificity is needed to identify individuals, several intron loci (hopefully from different linkage groups ± e.g. different chromosomes) used congruently, are usually needed for a valid study. MHC genes belong to a large `family' of functional genes that play critical roles in the immune response of vertebrates to foreign pathogens (Edwards & Potts, 1996). Certain classes of MHC genes have been recognized as being the most polymorphic of all known functional genes (see Hedrick, 1994); some loci contain as many as 100 alleles. There is an ongoing debate about the mechanisms of selection thought to maintain this incredible amount of diversity (e.g. Potts & Wakeland, 1990; Watkins et
50
Ecological Aquaculture
al., 1992). Regardless of the debate, these genes have proven to be useful in genetic surveys of vertebrate populations and in fingerprinting applications (see Edwards & Potts, 1996). For non-insect invertebrates, different hypervariable supergene families are known to occur, but these are not well characterized (Marchalonis & Schluter, 1990). AscnDNA is DNA that is arbitrarily chosen from anywhere in the genome and that has an unknown function. These fragments may be segments of coding regions or of non-coding regions of DNA. Thus, some fragments may be under selection whereas others may not. Thus, and for other reasons, the levels of variability in nucleotide sequence of this DNA vary greatly. Advantages to using ascnDNA fragments are that they are randomly chosen from throughout the entire nuclear genome and, overall, the fragments being assayed probably are not under direct selection pressure. AscnDNA fragment data has been used to determine levels of genetic diversity, various types of population genetic structure, and family relationships (see references in Karl, 1996). As genetic tags, ascnDNA fragments will probably be best utilized in combination with other types of DNA-based information. Mitochondrial DNA, which is extranuclear DNA that resides in the mitochondria of organisms, is composed almost exclusively of transfer RNA genes, ribosomal RNA genes, and genes that code for proteins. These genes are arranged in tandem in the circular mtDNA molecule. Unlike nuclear DNA, which undergoes genetic recombination during replication and is biparentally inherited, mtDNA does not undergo recombination and is effectively inherited without change from the mother to offspring (but see Zouros et al., 1994). Because of this unique inheritance pattern, the mtDNA molecule is frequently considered to be a single, linked genetic unit. Nevertheless, different mtDNA genes (e.g. those for cytochrome b and 16S rRNA) vary considerably in their rates of nucleotide substitution (reviewed in Palumbi, 1996, and Kocher & Stepien, 1996). On the average, the mtDNA genome is more variable than the majority of nuclear genes because of its mode of inheritance and because the rate of mutational error during the process of mtDNA replication is generally higher than that during nuclear DNA replication. Some mtDNA genes that have relatively high substitution rates can be used together in various ways to construct genetic tags (see Methods, below). One, usually hypervariable, non-coding region of mtDNA, the control region (called the D-loop in vertebrates and the A+T-rich region in noninsect invertebrates; Taberlet, 1996), is frequently used as a genetic tag (e.g. Stabile et al., 1996; Bentzen et al., 1997; Seyoum et al., 2000). Its overall substitution rate is among the highest known because, in addition to the factors cited above, it does not contain genes that are involved in the coding process. The ability to easily use the mtDNA control region as a genetic tag varies greatly among taxa because of differences among taxa in accessibility of the region and in its degree of variability. In vertebrates, the gene sequence in mtDNA is relatively constant among taxonomic groups (e.g. fish, mammals). Segments of the control region or the entire region can be accessed using standard, published primers (short segments of DNA that, after the mtDNA has been denatured, attach to segments of conserved mtDNA genes that flank the mtDNA region of interest [e.g. the control region] and, through the polymerase chain reaction [PCR], facilitate the synthesis of many copies
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
51
of that region). For example, the D-loop of many fish species can be accessed using primers published in the now classic paper by Kocher et al. (1989). However, in noninsect invertebrates that are commonly cultured (e.g. shrimp, bivalve mollusks), the A+T-rich region is not always in a fixed position relative to flanking conserved genes, and in some cases (e.g. certain bivalve species; Gjetvaj et al., 1992), it cannot be located by standard techniques. Thus, compared with vertebrates, relatively little is known about the levels of variability of this region in non-insect invertebrates. Even within taxonomic groups, levels of genetic variation in the control region differ greatly. For example, in some fish, segments of the D-loop are extremely hypervariable (see, for example, Seyoum et al., 2000), and relatively short segments (e.g. 450±600 bp) can serve alone as genetic tags for some needs in genetic monitoring of aquaculture activities. In contrast, in other fish species, the level of variability is comparatively low, possibly due to genetic bottlenecking or founder events in the recent past (see, for example, Wilson et al., 1997). Despite these shortcomings, the mtDNA control region is probably the segment of DNA most frequently used for differentiating intraspecific interbreeding populations (e.g. Taberlet, 1996). It also has great utility for examining maternal contribution to reproductive output, and, either alone or together with other types of DNA, for assessing effective population size (Tringali & Bert, in prep.). Nuclear DNA products such as proteins can be used as genetic tags, but because of the redundancy of the genetic code (see Hartl & Clark, 1997), the variation associated with these molecules is inherently less than that of the DNA that codes for these gene products. If protein sequences or allozyme alleles are used as genetic tags, batteries of these need to be used, and probably used in conjunction with other types of DNA markers. These types of markers are typically used to discriminate groups or organisms from each other (e.g. Taggart & Ferguson, 1984; Crozier & Moffett, 1995; Bert et al., 1996). Allozyme electrophoresis is the oldest widely used technique for assaying genetic variation at the molecular level. The widespread use of allozyme electrophoresis for theoretical and applied population-level studies began with the publication of Lewontin & Hubby's (1966) paper on genetic variation in Drosophila pseudoobscura. Allozyme electrophoresis has been used for numerous studies of phylogenetics, population genetic structure, interspecific hybridization, species identification, genetic stock identification, and studies that require genetic tags (e.g. Taggart & Ferguson, 1984, 1986; Nyman & Ring, 1989). For example, rare allozyme alleles have been used as selected genetic tags a number of times for stock enhancement (e.g. Murphy et al., 1983; Taggart & Ferguson, 1984, 1986; Knut et al., 1994). However, because in allozyme electrophoresis gene products, proteins, are assayed, the process is a very conservative estimate of genetic variation. Thus, the utility of allozyme electrophoresis as a natural genetic tag for identifying individuals or specific family lineages is limited to that of either a preliminary screening test or a secondary technique, to be used in conjunction with other, more sophisticated methods of analysis. Morphological tagging is the oldest method of demarcating cultured organisms. Morphological tags often represent phenotypic expressions of genetic traits. They have been used to distinguish hatchery-bred fish (e.g. cultured red sea bream (Pagrus
52
Ecological Aquaculture
major) in Japan; T.M. Bert, personal observation) and mollusks (e.g. color morphs of bay scallops (Argopecten irradians), Adamkewicz & Castagna, 1988; notata form of hard clams (Mercenaria mercenaria), Humphrey & Walker, 1982; Castagna & Manzi, 1989) from wild conspecific individuals. The advantage of morphological markers is that, if they are reliable (i.e. optimally controlled by a single locus and homozygous in the cultured population) and obvious, they allow the easy and unambiguous distinction of the marked individuals from all others. However, the potential drawbacks associated with using morphological tags are numerous. As with molecular tags, genetic selection for a phenotypic marker is unavoidable (in fact, it's the objective), and because several generations of offspring must usually be bred to render the marker homozygous in the cultured population, changes in genetic diversity are inevitable. The genes coding for the marker may be closely linked to genes at flanking or nearby polymorphic loci; the allele frequencies of those closely linked genes may be altered also because their alleles may be `carried' along with those of the marker genes during DNA recombination. Thus, selection on genes of unknown (and perhaps critical) function may occur. In addition, researchers cannot track offspring of cultured animals if the inheritance pattern of the phenotypic trait is not known. Specifically, hybrids are not identifiable if the alleles for the locus controlling the trait are not co-dominant and hybrids are not expressed as intermediates. Because the genetic basis of morphological tags is generally poorly understood and because the use of morphological tags almost invariably involves selection, they will not be further addressed here.
Methodologies for obtaining and utilizing genetic tags Thanks in large part to the Human Genome Project, a plethora of molecular techniques to identify DNA at various levels of precision have been developed in recent years. Many techniques used to analyze human DNA have also been used to search for and develop genetic tags. The following descriptions of the techniques and procedures are greatly simplified; for a more detailed explanation, the reader should consult the cited references. The most direct method for analyzing DNA is to determine its nucleotide sequence. DNA sequencing can be used to analyze any DNA segment, including the various types of highly variable DNA of interest in the context presented here (e.g. introns, ascnDNA, mtDNA control region). DNA sequencing offers the researcher an opportunity to directly observe individual nucleotide bases along a targeted region of DNA. The first step in this process is to find and isolate the segment of DNA that can serve as a candidate for a genetic tag. This step entails searching for hypervariable segments of either nuclear DNA or mtDNA, which is usually accomplished by cloning or by using primers. Cloning is a process in which a desired segment of DNA is isolated and inserted into the genome of a host organism (bacterium). Because bacteria multiply rapidly, the inserted segment of DNA is reproduced (cloned) in large quantities for genetic assay. A review of the various cloning techniques and applications may be found in Sambrook et al. (1989). Primers usually range from
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
53
about 20 to 35 nucleotides long. Pairs of primers are designed to be complementary to the two opposing strands of conserved (non-variable) regions of DNA that flank the region of interest (in this case, a hypervariable region). Many primers exist for all types of hypervariable DNA, both nuclear and mitochondrial, and their nucleotide sequences can be easily found in the scientific literature or via Genbank (http:// www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/irx/cgi-bin/genbank). Primers are often used for isolation of the target DNA, a process that involves the polymerase chain reaction (PCR; Saiki et al., 1989). PCR is a chemical process in which large quantities of identical copies of specific segments of DNA can be synthesized from limited and even somewhat degraded amounts of DNA. A review of the techniques, common protocols and primers used, and general applications may be found in Palumbi et al. (1991). The PCR product, which is composed of millions of copies of the desired segment of DNA along with the original (and much smaller) number of copies of all other DNA in the organism, is readily utilizable in direct DNA sequencing. Using cloned DNA or PCR products, DNA sequencing can be accomplished manually and visualized on acrylamide gels (Sanger et al., 1977; Craxton, 1991), or by using an automated DNA sequencing system. Often, preliminary sequencing is first performed on a few individuals (e.g. 10±20). This effort represents a developmental step in which `nested' primers are developed. These primers are obtained using DNA sequence segments that are interior to the segments to which the original primers attached. These specific primers are more custom-designed for the target species and are employed in subsequent, large-scale genetic assays (see, for example, Seyoum et al., 2000). Also, by first sequencing a small number of individuals, a researcher usually can form a preliminary opinion on the amount of nucleotide sequence variation that is contained in the specific DNA segment of interest and thereby evaluate the potential usefulness of that segment as a genetic tag. For surveys involving genetic tags, sequencing usually is the method of analysis used for hypervariable ascnDNA, introns, MHG genes, and the mtDNA control region. Because the sample sizes needed to ascertain the uniqueness of a genetic tag and to survey populations in which tagged individuals constitute some (possibly small) fraction of the population can be substantial (e.g. many hundreds of individuals), it may be beneficial to utilize one or more `short-cut' techniques that take advantage of such variation as the tertiary configuration of DNA or subtle differences in DNA charge that are associated with conformation of the DNA molecule and nucleotide base pairing. Several of these types of techniques are available; most are well summarized in Girman (1996). These techniques screen the DNA for sequence differences without the necessity of sequencing each individual. With these techniques, large numbers of individuals can be preliminarily screened and then only individuals of interest or uncertain genotypes sequenced. Among these techniques are singlestranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis, denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), and allele-specific oligonucleotide (ASO) hybridization. In aquaculture, these techniques are useful for determining and quantifying the parentage of hatchery broods. In SSCP analysis, short DNA fragments (100±300 bp provides the best resolution) are amplified by PCR and radiologically or chemically labeled for later visualization.
54
Ecological Aquaculture
The amplified DNA is then denatured (put through a process to separate the two sides of the DNA nucleotide ladder). Under specific conditions, the single-stranded DNA will then fold on to itself and assume a tertiary configuration that is characteristic of the particular base-pair sequence in the strand. Then the DNA is run through a polyacrylamide gel under a very specific and precise set of conditions. These conditions must be determined for each project and must be strictly adhered to in all SSCP procedures performed on all individuals that are analyzed to insure that each different single-stranded DNA nucleotide sequence always remains in its characteristic sequence-specific folded position. Ideally, the differences in folded positions among DNA nucleotide sequences cause each different sequence to migrate a unique distance through the gel. Thus, individuals with unique nucleotide sequences can be identified. The DNA of these individuals can be sequenced to confirm their uniqueness. The DGGE technique is highly sensitive to mutations in DNA sequence. In DGGE analysis, double-stranded, PCR-amplified DNA from different individuals is run through an acrylamide gel that has a gradient of denaturing chemicals (typically urea and formamide) within it. As the DNA runs through the gel matrix, it reaches an area in the gel where it begins to denature. This markedly slows the migration of the DNA through the gel. Ideally, DNA with different nucleotide sequences runs different distances through the gel. Single-nucleotide substitutions in the DNA of different individuals can be distinguished by these differences in migration distance from the original position of the DNA in the gel. To ascertain the nucleotide sequence of the target DNA segment for any individual, the DNA can be excised and extracted from the gel and then sequenced using standard techniques. A modification of the DGGE technique is temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE). In this technique, temperature, rather than chemicals, is used to generate the gradient in the gel. ASO hybridization can be used to determine the genotypes of many individuals quickly and inexpensively. The nucleotide sequence of a target DNA segment must be known for some reference individuals (e.g. broodstock individuals). In addition, each individual must possess at least one mutation in this segment of DNA that is unique compared to the other reference individuals. For each individual, an allele-specific probe (short segment of DNA with a nucleotide sequence that is complementary to a segment of the target DNA that contains the unique mutation) is created (this can be custom-ordered from a company specializing in such products). The target DNA of many individuals is annealed to filter paper. Under a specific temperature regime, the DNA is denatured and a probe for one specific mutation is applied; prior to applying the probe to the DNA affixed to the filter paper, the probe is labeled with a chemical that, later on in the process, will allow the probe to be visualized. If the conditions are correct, the probe will attach at the appropriate location on the filter paper only at sites where the DNA of individuals with precisely the complementary nucleotide sequence to the probe have been placed. Then, through a series of chemical reactions, the reconstituted probe is visualized. Because the probe is situated on the filter paper only at sites where the DNA of individuals that have the probe-specific mutation has been placed, those individuals can be identified. Kits are available for labeling the probe and detecting the labeled probe. The invention and affordability of DNA sequencing machines has facilitated the
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
55
generation of a veritable explosion of DNA sequence data for all types of research. For organismal biology, DNA sequencing data is fundamental to studies of phylogenetics, population genetics, conservation biology, and increasingly, fisheries biology (for stock identification) and aquaculture (for pedigree analysis). Review and applications can be found in Hillis et al. (1996), Kocher & Stepien (1996), and Smith & Wayne (1996). Examples abound in all journal series that publish articles on evolutionary biology, ecology, genetics, fisheries, and many other topics that deal with organismal biology. Microsatellite DNA loci are usually developed from genomic `libraries' of DNA fragments that are produced by treating total, purified DNA with restriction enzymes (enzymes that recognize specific DNA nucleotide sequence sites 4±6 nucleotide bases long, attach to the DNA at those locations, and sever the DNA at or near those locations). Libraries may be enriched for microsatellite-containing DNA fragments by a variety of means (see, for example, Bruford et al., 1996). The library is then checked for DNA fragments that contain microsatellite DNA regions by cloning. Next, bacterial clones having microsatellite DNAs are identified by hybridization (denaturing the target DNA and reconstituting with radio- or chemically labeled, synthesized, simple-sequence [e.g. CACACA . . . , ATTATT . . .] DNA) and sequencing. Specific primers are then developed for the cloned DNA fragments that contain microsatellites and are used in PCR reactions performed on the total DNA extracted from tissues or DNA-containing fluids obtained from individuals. The genotypes of the individuals are visualized by running the PCR products through an acrylamide gel electrophoresis system and staining the gel with an appropriate dye or stain or by using an automated DNA analyzer and an appropriate microsatellite DNA protocol based on fluorescent dye chemistry. Assays for microsatellite loci may be streamlined by `multiplexing' (see O'Reilly et al., 1996). In this procedure, two or more microsatellite loci can be co-amplified in a single PCR reaction and assayed during a single automated sequencing reaction. Like most allozyme loci (see below) and single-locus minisatellite loci, microsatellite loci usually have co-dominant alleles, which allow homozygous and heterozygous genotypes to be distinguished in individuals. These loci can usually be analyzed in accordance with the assumptions associated with Mendelian inheritance (e.g. Hardy±Weinberg genotype equilibrium assumptions; see Hartl & Clark, 1997). Minisatellites are generally assayed using restriction enzyme digestions of total DNA. The resulting mixtures of DNA fragments are separated according to their sizes (lengths) via gel electrophoresis. The minisatellite loci are detected by using one or more minisatellite-specific DNA probes (for detailed methodologies, see Jeffreys et al., 1985a, b, and Burke et al., 1996, and references therein). The raw data for individuals are often in the form of complex patterns (restriction fragment profiles) in which multiple loci are present. Thus, individual genotypes for particular loci are indistinguishable. However, because the minisatellite profiles are often individualspecific, they are highly useful for DNA fingerprinting and for determining parentage in individuals. Allele frequencies cannot be calculated and standard analyses of population genetic parameters (e.g. estimation of gene flow and effective population size) cannot be performed without making extensive simplifying assumptions (Burke
56
Ecological Aquaculture
et al., 1996), but measures of genetic similarity between individuals and within and between populations can be calculated based on `band-sharing' coefficients (Gilbert et al., 1990, 1991). In some cases, the analytical disadvantages of standard minisatellite assays have been overcome by the development of single-locus minisatellite markers (e.g. Bentzen et al., 1993). This usually requires cloning (Bentzen & Wright, 1993) during the initial period of marker development, which can be a time-consuming and expensive process. In general, VNTR markers have proven to be highly successful for understanding the genetic population structure within species (Bentzen et al., 1996; O'Connell et al., 1998; Ruzzante et al., 1998), gene flow (Ruzzante et al., 1996), the genetic basis of phenotypic traits (Garcia De Leon et al., 1998), and parentage determinations (O'Reilly et al., 1998; Colbourne et al., 1999). Most importantly for our purpose, they have proven their utility as genetic tags for use in ecology (Woods et al., 1999), conservation biology (Lehman et al., 1991; Wayne & Jenks, 1991; Avise, 1994), and applied biology (e.g. see review by O'Connell & Dillon, 1997), including aquaculture (Harris et al., 1991; Harris & Wright, 1995; McConnell et al., 1995; Morris et al., 1996). PCR primers for single-locus VNTR markers of many fish and shellfish species are available from the scientific literature (e.g. Bentzen et al., 1994; Takagi et al., 1996; O'Connell et al., 1998; Tassanakajon et al., 1998; Turner et al., 1998). As with any nuclear DNA marker, if a number of independent loci can be resolved for the species or population of interest, the probability that the genetic analyses are not strongly biased by undetected selection at any single locus is reduced. The advantages of VNTR markers are that they are highly polymorphic and generally provide information on both paternal and maternal contributions to offspring. When VNTR characters are co-dominant, they are amenable to many types of population genetic analyses (e.g. standard analyses of genetic variability; associations among populations, McConnell et al., 1997; gene flow, O'Connell et al., 1998; migration rate; and effective population size, Herbinger et al., 1997. In addition, co-dominant VNTR markers have been useful in statistical `assignment tests' in which individuals are assigned to their source populations on the basis of their genotypes (Paetkau et al., 1997). Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis is a technique that randomly surveys genetic variation in a targeted region of DNA (e.g. ascnDNA or a segment of mtDNA); or, in the case of mtDNA, the whole molecule may be assayed. Purified mtDNA, nuclear DNA, DNA PCR products, or total genomic DNA can be surveyed in this way. A number of restriction enzymes are used separately to cleave the DNA at their respective recognition sites, yielding for each restriction enzyme a reproducible array of variously sized DNA fragments for each individual assayed. The fragments are then separated according to size by gel electrophoresis. For each individual, the fragment pattern (composite of all of the variously sized DNA fragments) produced by each restriction enzyme is given a numerical or letter label. For each restriction enzyme, all individuals that produced the same fragment pattern are given the same label. The composite of the labels for all restriction enzymes is used to characterize the RFLP profile of each individual. Typically, only the restriction enzymes that produce fragment patterns that vary among individuals in the sample are included in the RFLP profile (see Sambrook et al., 1989, for methodological
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
57
details). Dozens of restriction enzymes are available for testing their ability to produce fragment patterns on the target species. Although RFLP analysis offers less resolving power than DNA sequencing, it remains a cost-effective alternative when large portions of a genome or large numbers of individuals need to be screened. Through RFLP analysis, nucleotide substitutions, large additions or deletions to the genome, or gene sequence rearrangements can be detected. RFLP analyses are typically performed on ascnDNA fragments and mtDNA (either segments composed of specific genes or the control region, or the entire molecule). The data generated are frequencies of specific RFLP patterns. By using multiple, hypervariable ascnDNA loci in RFLP analysis, individualspecific genetic tags may be obtained, but this may require considerable searching. The initial search for these fragments is performed by digesting total nuclear DNA with a restriction enzyme. Then a lengthy procedure (described in detail in Karl, 1996, and references therein) is performed, in which a recombinant nuclear DNA library is generated and screened for potential single-copy sequences. Sequence-specific primers are then designed for those sequences that are targeted for surveys of degree of polymorphism. These primers are used in PCRs; the RFLP analysis is applied to the PCR products and a number of restriction enzymes are used. A battery of those RFLPs that prove to be highly polymorphic may be used as a genetic tag. However, even when 4-bp restriction enzymes are used (these produce the most complex RFLPs), RFLP patterns usually exhibit insufficient polymorphism for use as genetic tags, at least when a tag that can discriminate among individuals is needed. In this case, nuclear DNA markers can be combined with mtDNA RFLP data to increase resolution. For aquatic organisms, RFLP studies have been used to resolve species relationships (phylogenetics; e.g. Ohland et al., 1995); identify species (e.g. Seyoum, 1990; Seyoum & Kornfield, 1992; Tringali et al., 1999a,b); determine genetic population structure of species for ecological/evolutionary studies (e.g. Triantafyllidis et al., 1999; Buonaccorsi et al., 2001); and identify fishery stocks (e.g. Bowen & Avise, 1990; Gold & Richardson, 1991, 1993; Gold et al., 1993, 1999; Tringali & Bert, 1996). RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA) fragments are molecular markers that are generated by the amplification of random DNA segments using single, 10-bp primers of arbitrary nucleotide sequences (Williams et al., 1990). As with ascnDNA techniques, RAPD markers are randomly drawn from throughout the nuclear genome. Theoretically the number of arbitrary 10-bp primers that can be generated is 410; thus, an enormous number of primers that can be used to generate different patterns of fragments for the DNA of a single individual are available. To generate the fragments, only one primer is used in a PCR in which either total genomic DNA (Williams et al., 1990) or pure mitochondrial DNA (Seyoum et al., in review) is the target DNA. Since the primer is short, there is a high probability that the DNA will have several to numerous priming sites on one strand of the double-stranded molecule and other priming sites in an inverted orientation on the complementary strand. Regions between pairs of these priming sites are amplified in the PCR of the target DNA. This produces several to numerous fragments of different sizes. The amplified DNA is then passed through an agarose gel under specific electrophoretic conditions for a defined period of time. The fragments separate according to their sizes. They are
58
Ecological Aquaculture
typically visualized by staining the gel with ethidium bromide. The pattern produced by the fragments is the RAPD profile of the organism for that particular primer. The pattern can be characteristic of species, populations, or individuals. RAPD genetic tags usually are composed of the profiles generated by several primers, used separately. At the highest degree of resolution, these profiles are specific to individuals. RAPD molecular markers can easily be obtained at low expense and they have advantages over other molecular markers in that RAPD analysis can be performed on a small quantity of template DNA and without prior DNA sequence information (Hadrys et al., 1992). However, great care must be taken to determine the ideal concentration, purity, and uniformity of reagents and conditions in the PCR. A slight change in any of these steps will usually lead to less resolution or different RAPD profiles. RAPDs have been used to analyze inter- and intraspecific population diversity (Dawson et al., 1993; Gibbs et al., 1994), distinguish species and subspecies in tilapia (Bardakci & Skibiniski, 1994), ascertain outcrossing in freshwater bryozoans (Jones et al., 1994), determine paternity and kinship relationships in conifers (Carlson et al., 1991), generate specific probes for taxonomic or RFLP analyses in soybeans (Williams et al., 1990), and develop genetic tags in mollusks (Seyoum et al., in review). Descriptions of the laboratory procedures and recipes for the stains needed to visualize allozyme loci can be found in Selander et al. (1971) and Richardson et al. (1986), and in the appropriate scientific literature that describes allozyme studies and was published in the 1970s and, to a lesser degree, the 1980s. In allozyme electrophoresis, tissues or cell-containing fluids (e.g. blood) are homogenized and placed in a semi-solid medium (e.g. hydrolyzed, cooked potato starch). The gel is placed in an assembly with an electrolyte solution and electricity is passed through it. Enzymatic and other proteins (representing `alleles') that have different electrophoretic mobilities travel different distances through the gel. The alleles of a gene coding for a particular protein are visualized by treating a slice of the gel with a staining solution specific to that enzyme. Both alleles of individuals that are homozygous at a specific enzyme locus travel the same distance in the gel, whereas different alleles travel different distances in heterozygous individuals. Thus, in a manner similar to that for single-locus minisatellite and microsatellite alleles, specific allozyme alleles can be identified and genotypes can be established based on the numbers and locations of the bands produced on the stained gels. However, an important difference is that the allozyme alleles (also commonly termed electromorphs) can actually be multiple, different genetic alleles that have the same electrophoretic mobility. Nevertheless, these alleles commonly conform to Hardy±Weinberg equilibrium assumptions and are thus treated as representatives of the genes that presumably code for those electromorphs. Similar to RFLP and VNTR analyses, the enzyme loci of interest are those that yield polymorphic banding patterns, and a battery of enzymes constitutes the allozyme genotype profile of an individual. Innumerable allozyme studies have been conducted during the past 30+ years. Allozymes have been used for studies in phylogenetics, population genetics, ecology, fisheries biology, conservation biology, and aquaculture genetics (see, for example, Ayala, 1977; Avise, 1994; Leberg, 1996, or Hartl & Clark, 1997, and references therein).
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
59
The analysis of all types of molecular data has now been made much easier by several different types of programs that are available through web sites and free through the internet. These programs are usually developed for particular analysis of DNA, RFLP, or microsatellite data. Thus the programs are usually incomplete in one type of analysis or another and the analyst needs to search through the various programs for one that contains the desired types of analyses. Currently, the focus in developing these programs apparently is to generate a program that has the capacity to deal with large data sets and perform all types of analyses. Nevertheless, at this time there is no single software program package that has the capacity to do all possible types of analyses on a particular molecular data set. Useful and comprehensive websites in existence at this time include the following: for population genetic data analysis, http://www.megasoftware.net/ and http://anthropologie.unige.ch/ arlequin; for 193 phylogenic programs, http://evolution.genetics.washington.edu/ phylip/software.html; and for 1100 molecular and biochemistry analysis entries applicable to Windows, Macintosh, Linux and Unix computers, http:// genamics.com/software/.
Uses of genetic tags for aquaculture Intensive aquaculture For aquaculture activities in which the intent is to contain the cultured organisms up to the time of harvest, the principal use of genetic tags is to identify individuals of interest for some specific reason. For example, genetic tags can be associated with and used to track lineages (family members) that have been bred for specific phenotypic, metabolic, or physiological traits. Rapid growth, metabolic efficiency, attractive coloration, high reproductive capacity, and high survival rates in the culture environment are characteristics that are commonly selected for and cultivated in aquaculture operations. These traits are at least partially under genetic control. Genetic tags enable the tracking of lineages with superior performance in these desired traits. Genetic markers linked to these traits, which are usually controlled by multiple quantitative trait loci (i.e. genes that have alleles with stepwise, measurable differences in their contributions to the trait), can be used to identify, inventory, or register strains that have these commercially valuable characteristics (e.g. Herbinger et al., 1995; Jackson et al., 1998; Sakamoto et al., 1999). Related to this use for genetic tags is the determination of heritability of these quantitative characteristics. Rarely are complex expressed traits controlled by single gene loci. Most physical, physiological, and biochemical attributes are the products of a number of genes acting in consort or in a complex cascade of interactions. The degree to which offspring inherit the desired characteristic can vary considerably among lineages, depending upon the specific alleles possessed by the parents for all of the genes that participate in the expression of the characteristic. Levels of heritability for important aquacultural performance traits are reviewed in Tave (1986). Genetic tags can be used in pedigree analysis as a proxy to track the presence of suites of genes manifested as the high performance of a specific trait that is the product of the
60
Ecological Aquaculture
interactions of numerous quantitative trait loci (Tanksley, 1993). For example, Danzmann et al. (1999) identified microsatellite markers linked to presumptive quantitative trait loci (QTL) for upper thermal tolerance, and Sakamoto et al. (1999) identified microsatellite markers linked to QTL for spawning seasonality in hatchery populations of rainbow trout. Microsatellite markers linked to QTL have also been used to determine if sufficient additive genetic variation exists to make it worthwhile for the aquaculturist to perform selective breeding for the desirable trait. Without multiple alleles in at least many of the loci involved in the genetic pathway leading to expression of the desired trait and variation in the singular and collective performance levels of those alleles, little change in the performance of the trait can be achieved (e.g. Moav & Wohlfarth, 1976). For example, Fishback et al. (2000) employed the microsatellite markers developed by Sakamoto et al. (1999) to show that there was insufficient additive genetic variation for further selective breeding for spawning seasonality in a hatchery group of summer-spawning rainbow trout. Because the heterozygosity of the marker loci was significantly higher in the group of spring spawners compared with the summer spawners, the authors posited that greater selective gains could be achieved by focusing on the spring group. When investigating the variation in trait performances that may be influenced by intrinsic factors (e.g. genetic or phenotypic) or extrinsic factors (e.g. water temperature, salinity or soluble chemical concentrations; food amounts, types or additives), the aquaculturist may want to set up an experimental array in which the factor(s) vary among treatments (e.g. among ponds, tanks, or cages) in graduated intervals or in a matrix. In this type of aquaculture, multiple members of several different lineages of the cultured species are placed into each treatment and their performances are tracked over time. If external tagging is impossible, impractical, or may interfere with the performance of individuals in the experiment, lineages can be tracked using genetic tags. Such tracking is particularly amenable to experimental aquaculture. For example, Herbinger et al. (1995) used microsatellite fingerprinting to show that paternal and maternal effects strongly affect offspring growth and survival in hatchery-bred and -reared rainbow trout. In that study, large and highly significant differences in growth were observed among the progeny of specific sires and dams. In contrast, significant differences in survival were observed among the progeny of specific dams but not among the progeny of specific sires; however, there was no correlation between progeny survival and particular dam attributes such as length, age at maturity, or egg size. Similarly, highly significant differences have been observed in progeny survival among dams in communally bred and reared red drum (Tringali & Bert, in prep.). In that study, large and significant differences in progeny survival, detected by mtDNA fingerprinting, accrued after the fourth week and prior to the twentieth week after hatching (i.e. after major morphological development but before complete development). Genetic tags serve another purpose useful to intensive aquaculture: lost or escaped cultured native species can be found or tracked and their escapement rates quantified if they are genetically tagged such that the cultured animals are differentiable from their wild counterparts (see, for example, Crozier, 1993; Clifford et al., 1997, 1998). One of the most environmentally problematic situations for aquaculturists is the
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
61
accidental or purposeful release of the cultured animals into the environment. Feral, cultured, native-species individuals can interbreed with wild conspecific individuals. As a group, feral, cultured individuals are usually depleted or differentiated in genetic diversity compared with the local wild population. Particularly if they have been derived from non-native broodstock, they can carry alleles that are not adapted to local environmental conditions. If the interbreeding is extensive and successful (i.e. numerous, reproductively active individuals in the subsequent generations contain genes derived from the feral, cultured individuals), the local or regional species gene pool can suffer several consequences: (1) at some or many polymorphic loci, alleles (particularly rare alleles) can be lost from the gene pool; (2) allele frequencies can be significantly shifted in the gene pool; and (3) maladapted alleles can be introduced into the gene pool. An extensive literature exists in which the negative consequences of a change in a species' genetic diversity resulting from interbreeding with feral cultured conspecifics are documented and the reasons for the predominance of negative consequences are postulated (Hindar et al., 1991; Ryman et al., 1995). Genetically tagging the cultured individuals would provide a mechanism for distinguishing those individuals from wild conspecifics in stocked populations and, if the specific genetic tags were developed for different aquaculture operations, for identifying the aquaculture facility from which they escaped or were released. Successful interbreeding can also occur between individuals of closely related species and between pure-species individuals and hybrids. Thus, cultured species or cultured hybrids between a native species and an alien species could interbreed with a native species. The consequence in these cases is contamination of the native pure-species gene pool from foreign genes. The problem is that, in any of these situations, the outcome and impact on native species is unknown, can be dramatic, and cannot be predicted with confidence, even from similar situations that have occurred elsewhere. Genetic tags that allow easy identification of these cultured individuals and permit tracking of the introgression of their genes into native populations are particularly important in these situations (see Costa-Pierce & Doyle, 1997). Genetic tagging could benefit both the aquaculturist and those interested in conservation of native gene pools. If loss of the aquacultured animals is unknown to the aquaculturist, it may be to his/her benefit to have this information and thereby take the steps necessary to prevent such losses in the future. Although feral, cultured, aquatic organisms cannot be gathered and placed again into captivity as can feral, ranched, terrestrial organisms, it may be possible to reduce the potential losses that the aquaculturist experiences and the impacts that result from the introduction of these animals into the environment if their rates of introduction and disperal can be monitored and controlled through the use of genetic tags. Finally, genetic tags are necessary for identification and verification of marketed seafood. Currently, forensic identification of aquaculture products is used principally to verify the identity of labeled products produced from wild fisheries (e.g. Kenchington et al., 1993; Baker & Palumbi, 1996; Birstein et al., 1998; Palumbi & Cipriano, 1998; Baker et al., 2000). A future use of genetic tags could be to discriminate between products produced by aquaculture and identical products produced by the harvest of
62
Ecological Aquaculture
wild animals or among identical products produced by different aquaculture operations.
Stock enhancement The purposeful addition of fish or aquatic invertebrates to a natural, conspecific population that has been depleted for some reason is variously termed stock enhancement or stock supplementation (See Drawbridge, Chapter 11). Regardless of the terminology, the objective is singular: to put individuals gathered from another location or spawned and reared to some specified size in a hatchery into an area where the native population has been greatly reduced due to anthropogenic influences or natural environmental changes. Related to this effort is stock restoration, in which wild or hatchery-reared organisms are placed into an area where the local, conspecific population has been extirpated. Stock enhancement and stock restoration are becoming increasingly popular as management tools for replenishing depleted fisheries. The genetic concerns associated with these efforts are complex, and somewhat different between stock enhancement and stock restoration. Here, we will deal with the use of genetic tags in stock enhancement. Bert et al. (in prep.) have developed a multifaceted, comprehensive program to monitor the genetic effects of stock enhancement. They use genetic tags as an integral component of this program. In stock enhancement programs, genetic tags can be used to perform the following tasks: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8)
(9)
(10)
track parentage and determine parental contribution in the hatchery; compare the genetic diversity of the cultured animals with that of the recipient wild population; estimate effective population size of the broodstock (and consequently of the broods); determine if genotype-specific selection is occurring in the hatchery or after release of the cultured animals; track dispersal and survival of the cultured animals after release; compare growth rates and other life history characteristics of the cultured animals after release with those of wild conspecifics in same cohort; determine the contribution of hatchery-derived animals to local and regional populations; track the level of interbreeding between wild individuals and released cultured animals (with some decay factor related to the inheritance pattern of the gene used); estimate the change in effective population size of the stocked population if interbreeding between the released, cultured animals and wild population occurs; and determine the rate of loss of physical tags.
Determining, in as much detail as possible, information about the actual contribution of each broodstock individual to the broods is a valuable exercise for the aquaculturist and any individuals interested in mimicking, in the hatchery, the genetic
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
63
diversity of the natural population. Because gene alleles are passed from the parents to their offspring essentially without mutation, a genetic tag that enables the researcher to distinguish each broodstock individual from all others can be used to identify the parentage of each brood individual (or a subsample of the brood). Thereby, the percentage of offspring that are derived from each parent can be calculated. In some breeding strategies used by aquaculturists, the broodstock individuals that actually contribute to the broods are unknown. Through the use of a genetic tag, not only can the contribution of each broodstock individual be estimated, but also the individuals that did not contribute to the brood can be identified. In some culture situations, the aquaculturist may choose to either reuse those individuals in other broodstock groups or to discard those individuals. Because numerous types of negative effects can result from decreases in genetic diversity, and because genetic diversity can be severely reduced in stocked populations if large numbers of cultured individuals interbreed with the recipient wild population, it is important to compare the genetic diversity of the cultured animals with that of the recipient wild population prior to release of the cultured animals. Breeding strategies can be devised, within the limits of the capabilities of the aquaculture facility, that produce broods in which the genetic diversity of the recipient wild population is mimicked as best as is possible. Some potential always exists for interbreeding between cultured animals and wild animals of the same or a closely related species in stocked population situations; thus, maintaining the wild-stock genetic diversity as well as possible is always a good precautionary measure. Effective population size (Ne) is a theoretical number generated through an equation that takes into consideration not only the number of broodstock in a population but also the relative contribution of each breeder to the next generation. (For a more complete description, see Sugg & Chesser, 1994, and references therein). Genetic diversity is directly related to broodstock size. Thus, small effective broodstock population sizes generate broods with small Nes and low genetic variation. If, in turn, those broods interbreed at high levels with the recipient wild population, the genetic variation of the stocked population can be greatly reduced, and the attendant concerns about the manifestations of reductions in the fitness and adaptive potential of the stocked population may need attention. When reproductive contributions are not systematically controlled (e.g. through strip-spawning or paired matings), genetic tags must be used to estimate the Ne of the broodstock, the broods, and the stocked population. Selection for particular genotypes can be very strong in aquaculture facilities (Kohanne & Parsons, 1988). The aquaculture environment is usually very different from the natural environment in which the species lives. Genotypes that may be adaptive in the habitats occupied by a species may be maladapted to the culture situation, and the reverse situation can occur. Thus, in a brood, many of the individuals that are ultimately released may be poorly adapted for life in the wild (e.g. Fleming & Einum, 1997). Survival, growth, or other important life-history components may be impaired, ultimately reducing the positive effects of the stock enhancement efforts. In addition, selection in the aquaculture environment can negatively impact the genetic diversity of the broods and reduce the brood Ne despite
64
Ecological Aquaculture
the best attempts to maintain the wild-population level of genetic diversity through the breeding strategy. By periodically assaying a sample of the broods and checking for directional changes in allele frequencies, genetic tags can be used to check for selection in the aquaculture environment over the time that the broods are reared in the aquaculture facility. Ideally, the aquaculturist or researcher can develop a genetic tag that will discriminate cultured animals (and, with some decay factor, their offspring) from wild conspecifics with a high degree of confidence. Then, by systematically sampling (often non-destructively, e.g. by taking fish fin-clips) individuals captured from the stocked population and identifying them as cultured or wild, a number of important lifehistory attributes can be assessed independently for the cultured animals (e.g. dispersal from the release site, survival over time) or compared between the cultured animals and their wild conspecifics (e.g. growth rates, size at reproduction). For example, both to the aquaculturist or scientist responsible for the stock enhancement program and to the funding source, an important question related to the stock enhancement effort is, `Are the cultured animals surviving after release?' Or, knowledge of whether or not the released, cultured animals integrate well into the recipient wild population and how far they disperse over time can be important when considering the genetic effects of the stock enhancement or planning future releases. The location of the release site, timing of the release, and size of individuals to be released can be important when considering the stock enhancement effort from an economic perspective. All of these factors should be optimized such that they yield the highest survival rates of the cultured animals after release and allow for good integration of the cultured and wild individuals. These are factors that can be tested in a preliminary phase of the stock enhancement effort; they can be determined by structured sampling of the stocked population periodically after release of the cultured animals and systematic assaying of the individuals collected to determine their origin (cultured or wild). Similarly, life-history characteristics important for survival of the cultured animals can be compared with those of their wild counterparts. For example, it may be important for released, cultured fish to maintain the same growth rate as conspecific wild fish of the same year class in order to avoid selective predation on the cultured fish or to insure that the cultured fish attain the same reproductive potential as that of the wild fish. The success of the stock enhancement endeavor may depend on the similarity of certain life-history characteristics between the released, cultured animals and wild conspecifics. Regardless of the objectives of the stock enhancement effort, the contribution of the hatchery-derived animals to the recipient population is important. The contribution can be defined as a percentage or as an absolute number of hatchery-derived animals that occur in a specific cohort. The time at which that assessment is made differs depending on those objectives. For example, in a put-and-take stock enhancement program, the objective may be to increase the harvestable component of the population. In that case, an assessment made after the animals reach legal harvestable size is the most important assessment for declaring the stock enhancement effort a success or failure. If the objective of the stock enhancement effort is to provide additional individuals to the reproductive population, an assessment made
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
65
after the animals attain reproductive maturity is the most important assessment. By coupling genetic tag identification of individuals captured from the stocked population with the appropriate life-history data, these types of question can be answered. If the objective of the stock enhancement program is to supplement the reproductively active component of the wild population, then the ultimate measure of success is the level of interbreeding between the enhancement animals and wild conspecifics. However, because an objective for a stock enhancement program is to release native species individuals into locations where the population is depleted compared with its former density, the potential for genetic alteration of the remnant wild population is high if both the ratio of released individuals to wild individuals and the rate of interbreeding between the wild individuals and released individuals are high. The alteration usually comes in the form of changes in the genetic diversity that negatively affect the stocked population. For example, the fitness of the population could be lowered because adaptations to local environments would break down via the introduction of maladapted `exotic' genes (outbreeding depression; Templeton, 1986). Genetic tags can assist with monitoring the rate of interbreeding between the wild stock and released animals (see, for example, Doyle et al., 1995; Tessier et al., 1997). Genetic tag identification can be coupled with age or size information to identify individuals that have a high likelihood of being progeny of hatchery-derived individuals. If the genetic tag is an mtDNA tag, all of the offspring of genetically tagged, released, cultured females (but not males) can be identified. Since males do not transmit their mtDNA to their offspring, the rate of identification decays by 50% with each subsequent generation (assuming that, collectively, the sex ratio of the progeny produced by the hatchery-derived animals each generation is 1:1). If the genetic tag is of nuclear DNA, all of the first-generation offspring can be identified. With subsequent generations, the inheritance patterns can become very complex and are dependent upon the composition of the genetic tag. If interbreeding is successful, almost invariably, the Ne of the stocked population will decrease over subsequent generations (see Tringali & Bert, 1998, and Bert & Tringali, in press). As mentioned above, this can potentially result in a suite of problems in fitness-related life history or morphological components that reduce the probability that the population will survive over ecological or evolutionary time periods. An objective of any stock enhancement program should be to minimize the probability of these types of problems by limiting the contribution of cultured animals to at or below percentages that will cause significant reductions in the stocked population Ne and, to the extent possible, insuring that the recipient wild population genetic diversity is mimicked in the cultured broods. Genetic tags can be used to estimate the Ne produced by a group of broodstock individuals and to estimate the Ne of the stocked population after interbreeding between the cultured animals and wild animals (see, for example, Waples & Do, 1994, for methods). Finally, some cultured animals (e.g. fish) are released at sizes sufficiently large to permit physical tagging of the individuals (e.g. using coded-wire tags or streamer tags). Some degree of tag loss always accompanies any type of physical tagging. Coupling a genetic tag with a physical tag insures that all released, cultured
66
Ecological Aquaculture
individuals are correctly identified when they are captured after release and, simultaneously, the rate of loss of the physical tags can be calculated.
Genetic tags and aquaculture ± the need and the future In the past 10 years, global production of farmed fish and invertebrates (principally shellfish) has more than doubled in both weight and value, and one-quarter of the fish and invertebrates consumed by humans worldwide is derived from aquacultured organisms (Naylor et al., 2000). As fisheries based on wild populations continue to decline (Botsford et al., 1997; Vitousek et al., 1997; Pauly et al., 1998) and as the growing human population searches for efficient and reliable ways to produce affordable, high quality food products, the prospect for continued and accelerated increase in aquaculture-for-food activities is high. Thus, aquaculture will continue to be one of the most rapidly growing sectors of the food production industry for the foreseeable future. In many countries, the culture of aquatic products (both marine and freshwater) is seen as a food production panacea for a rapidly growing population. Development of large scale and small scale operations for both intensive aquaculture and stock enhancement/restoration will at least be maintained at current levels, and will probably accelerate. Genetics is important to this industry, and in many ways and with continued development of the industry, the role of genetics will become increasingly important. Some aquaculturists conducting intensive commercial aquaculture select each succeeding generation of broodstock from the brood generated by the previous generation of broodstock individuals. This practice, although convenient and important when selecting for desirable traits such as elegant color, rapid growth, or high fecundity, can lead to a decrease in the fitness of the broods, principally due to alterations in the genetic diversity of the cultured animals over time (see, e.g. Bert & Tringali, in press). Tracking the genetic diversity of the broods over generations and determining parental contribution to each generation will allow the aquaculturist to determine whether it would be beneficial to introduce individuals from outside of the culture operation (i.e. individuals with `new' genotypes) into his/her broodstock in order to maintain an acceptable level of fitness in the cultured population over generations. Some aquaculturists conduct intensive aquaculture in areas where there is a chance that the cultured animals will escape and interbreed with local wild populations (e.g. open pen aquaculture in lakes, rivers, or the open ocean or facility-based aquaculture that uses flow-through water obtained from local streams, rivers, or estuaries). These aquaculturists may want or need to quantify the rate of escape, level and pattern of dispersal of the escaped individuals, and degree of interbreeding between wild populations and the escaped, cultured animals. The ability to distinguish cultured animals from their wild counterparts and to track the introgression of the genes of the cultured animals into wild populations is essential to this type of monitoring. Finally, the objective of stock enhancement or restoration activities is to produce animals that will be released into areas where the native conspecific population is depleted or extirpated. For many and varied reasons that are dependent on the
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
67
objectives of the activity, it is important to track the cultured individuals after their release and sometimes also to identify their progeny. Genetic monitoring is the only way to track the fate of cultured individuals that are released when they are too small to physically tag and it is the only way to estimate the reproductive contribution of the released, cultured animals. Even if the released individuals are physically tagged, using a genetic marker as a backup insures that the number of cultured animals identified is the maximum possible (physical tags always have a loss rate). Genetic tags are instrumental for all of these tracking and monitoring needs, and they can be retrieved non-destructively because any small amount of tissue ± fresh, preserved, or dried ± can yield DNA. The diversity in the types of genetic markers available, increasing ease of finding adequate markers and assaying large numbers of individuals, and decreasing cost of genetic monitoring make the inclusion of a genetic component in aquaculture operations feasible. The information provided to any individual or group interested in the outcome or impacts of the aquaculture operation (including the aquaculturist) through genetic monitoring based on genetic tags make the inclusion of a genetic component in aquaculture operations essential and indispensable. The future of aquaculture is inextricably linked to genetic tags and genetic monitoring.
Acknowledgments We thank Barry Costa-Pierce for inviting us to write this chapter and gratefully acknowledge Anne McMillen-Jackson and Brent Winner for valuable comments about the manuscript; Anne McMillen-Jackson and Bill Arnold for providing important references; and Kristine Johnston and the Florida Marine Research Institute editorial staff for their superb editorial assistance. This work was supported by funding from the Department of the Interior, US Fish and Wildlife Service, Federal Aid for Sport Fish Restoration Grant Number F-69 to T. M. Bert and M. D. Tringali and by the State of Florida.
References Adamkewicz, L. & Castagna, M. (1988) Genetics of shell color and pattern in the bay scallop Argopecten irradians. Journal of Heredity, 79, 14±17. Avise, J.C. (1994) Molecular Markers, Natural History and Evolution. Chapman & Hall, New York. Ayala, F.J. (1977) Molecular Evolution. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Baker, C.S. & Palumbi, S.R. (1996) Population structure, molecular systematics, and forensic identification of whales and dolphins. In: Conservation Genetics, Case Histories from Nature (eds J.C. Avise & J.L. Hamrick), pp. 10±42. Chapman & Hall, New York. Baker, C.S., Lento, G.M., Cipriano, F., Dalebout, M.L. & Palumbi, S.R. (2000) Scientific whaling: source of illegal products for market? Science, 290, 1695. Bardakci, F. & Skibinski, D.F. (1994) Application of the RAPD technique in tilapia fish: species and subspecies identification. Heredity, 73, 117±123.
68
Ecological Aquaculture
Bentzen, P., Taylor, E.B. & Wright, J.M. (1993) A novel synthetic probe for DNA fingerprinting salmonid fishes. Journal of Fish Biology, 43, 313±316. Bentzen, P. & Wright, J.M. (1993) Nucleotide sequence and evolutionary conservation of a minisatellite variable number tandem repeat cloned from Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar. Genome, 36, 271±277. Bentzen, P., Morris, D.B. & Wright, J.M. (1994) Development and use of variable number tandem repeat markers for population and aquacultural genetics of salmonids. NOAA Technical Memorandum. NMFS±NWFSC, 17, 87±90. Bentzen, P., Taggart, C., Ruzzante, D. & Cook, D. (1996) Microsatellite polymorphism and the population structure of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) in the Northwest Atlantic. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 53, 2706±2721. Bentzen, P., Wright, J.M., Bryden, L.T., Sargent, M. & Zwanenburg, K.C.T. (1997) Tandem repeat polymorphism and heteroplasmy in the mitochondrial control region of redfishes (Sebastes: Scorpaenidae). Journal of Heredity, 89, 1±7. Bert, T.M., McCarthy, K.J., Cruz Lopez, H. & Bogdanowicz, S. (1996) Character discriminatory power, character set congruence, and the classification of individuals from hybrid zones: an example using stone crabs (genus Menippe). Evolution, 50, 655±671. Bert, T.M. & Tringali, M.D. (in press) The effects of various aquacultural breeding strategies on the genetic diversity of successive broods. Jurnal Biosains (Malaysia). Bert, T.M., Tringali, M.D., Crawford, C. & Seyoum, S. (in preparation) A comprehensive genetic monitoring program for hatchery-based stock enhancement or restoration. In: Ecological and Genetic Implications of Aquaculture Activities (eds T.M. Bert & J. Nielsen), Kluwer Academic Publications, New York. Bilodeau, A.L., Lankford, W., Kim, T., Felder, D.L. & Neigel, J.E. (1999) An ultrasensitive method for detection of single crab larvae (Sesarma reticulatum) by PCR amplification of a highly repetitive DNA sequence. Molecular Ecology, 8, 683±684. Birstein, V.J., Doukakis, P., Sorkin, B. & DeSalle, R. (1998) Population aggregation analysis of three caviar-producing species of sturgeons and implications for species identification of black caviar. Conservation Biology, 12, 766±775. Botsford, L.W., Castilla, J.C. & Peerson, C.H. (1997) The management of fisheries and marine ecosystems. Science, 277, 500±515. Bowen, B.W. & Avise, J.C. (1990) Genetic structure of Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico populations of sea bass, menhaden, and sturgeon: influence of zoogeographic factors and lifehistory patterns. Marine Biology, 107, 371±381. Bruford, M.W., Chasman, D.J., Coote, T. et al. (1996) Microsatellites and their application to conservation genetics. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 278±297. Oxford University Press, New York. Buonaccorsi, V.P., Starkey, E. & Graves, J.E. (2001) Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA analysis of population subdivision among young-of-the-year Spanish mackerel (Somberomorus maculatus) from the western Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico. Marine Biology, 138, 37±45. Burke, T., Hanotte, O. & Van Pijlen, I. (1996) Minisatellite analysis in conservation genetics. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 298± 313. Oxford University Press, New York. Carlson, J.E., Tulsieram, L.K., Glaubitz, J.C., Luk, V.W.K., Kauffeldt, C. & Rutledge, R.
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
69
(1991) Segregation of random amplified DNA markers in F1 progeny of conifers. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 83, 194±200. Castagna, M. & Manzi, J.J. (1989) Clam culture in North America: hatchery production of nursery stock clams. In: Clam Mariculture in North America (eds J.J. Manzi & M. Castagna), pp. 111±126. Elsevier Press, New York. Clifford, S.L., McGinnity, P. & Ferguson, A. (1997) Genetic changes in an Atlantic salmon population resulting from escaped juvenile farm salmon. Journal of Fish Biology, 52, 118± 127. Clifford, S.L., McGinnity, P. & Ferguson, A. (1998) Genetic changes in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) populations of northwest Irish rivers resulting from escapes of adult farm salmon. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 55, 358±363. Colbourne, J.F., Neff, B.D., Wright, J.M. & Gross, M.R. (1999) DNA fingerprinting of bluegill sunfish (Lepomis macrochirus) using (GT)n microsatellites and its potential for assessment of the relative success of male reproductive strategies. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 53, 342±349. Coltman, D.W., Bowen, W.D. & Wright, J.M. (1998) Male mating success in an aquatically mating pinniped, the harbour seal (Phoca vitulina), determined by microsatellite DNA markers. Molecular Ecology, 7, 627±638. Costa-Pierce, B.A. & Doyle, R.W. (1997) Genetic identification and status of California regional strains in southern California. In: Tilapia Aquaculture in the Americas (eds B.A. Costa-Pierce & J. Rakocy), pp. 1±17. Louisiana World Aquaculture Society Books, Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Craxton, M. (1991) Linear amplification sequencing: a powerful method for sequencing DNA. Methods, 3, 20±24. Crozier, W.W. (1993) Evidence of genetic interaction between escaped farmed salmon and wild Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) in a Northern Irish river. Aquaculture, 113, 19±29. Crozier, W.W. & Moffett, I.J.J. (1995) Application of low frequency genetic marking at GPI-3 and MDH-B1, 2 loci to assess supplementary stocking of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L., in a Northern Irish stream. Fisheries Management and Ecology, 2, 27±36. Danzmann, R.G., Jackson, T.R. & Ferguson, M.M. (1999) Epistasis in allelic expression at upper temperature tolerance QTL in rainbow trout. Aquaculture, 173, 45±58. Dawson, I.K., Chalmers, K.J., Waugh, R. & Powell, W. (1993) Detection and analysis of genetic variation in Hordeum spontaneum populations from Israel using RAPD markers. Molecular Ecology, 2, 151±159. Dowling, T.E., Moritz, C., Palmer, J.D. & Riesenberg, L.H. (1996) Nucleic acids III: Analysis of fragments and restriction sites. In: Molecular Systematics, 2nd edn (eds D.M. Hillis, C. Moritz & B.K. Mable), pp. 249±320. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Doyle, R.W., Herbinger, C., Taggart, C. & Lochmann, S. (1995) Use of microsatellite DNA polymorphism to analyze genetic correlations between hatchery and natural fitness. In: Uses and Effects of Cultured Fishes in Aquatic Ecosystems (eds H.L.J. Schramm & R.G. Piper), pp. 205±211. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, Maryland. Edwards, S.V. & Potts, W.K. (1996) Polymorphism of genes in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC): implications for conservation genetics of vertebrates. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 214±237. Oxford University Press, New York.
70
Ecological Aquaculture
Fishback, A.G., Danzmann, R.G. & Ferguson, M.M. (2000) Microsatellite allelic heterogeneity among hatchery rainbow trout maturing in different seasons. Journal of Fish Biology, 57, 1367±1380. Fleming, I.A. & Einum, S. (1997) Experimental tests of genetic divergence of farmed from wild Atlantic salmon due to domestication. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 54, 1051±1063. Frischer, M.E., Danforth, J.M., Tyner, L.C., Leverone, J.R., Marelli, D.C., Arnold, W.S. & Blake, N.J. (2000) Development of an Argopecten-specific 18S rRNA targeted genetic probe. Marine Biotechnology, 2, 11±20. Garcia De Leon, F.J., Dallas, J.F., Chatain, B., Cannone, M., Versini, J.J. & Bonhomme, F. (1995) Development and use of microsatellite markers in sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax (Linnaeus, 1758) (Perciformes: Serranidae). Molecular Biology Biotechnology, 4, 62±68. Garcia De Leon, F.J., Canonne, M., Quillet, E., Bonhomme, F. & Chatain, B. (1998) The application of microsatellite markers to breeding programmes in the sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax. Aquaculture, 159, 303±316. Gharett, A.J. & Seeb, J.E. (1990) Practical and theoretical guidelines for genetically marking fish populations. American Fisheries Society Symposium, 7, 407±417. Gibbs, H.L., Prior, K.A. & Weatherhead, P.J. (1994) Genetic analysis of populations of threatened snake species using RAPD markers. Molecular Ecology, 3, 329±337. Gilbert, D.A., Lehman, N., O'Brien, S.J. & Wayne, R.K. (1990) Genetic fingerprinting reflects population differentiation in the California Channel Island fox. Nature, 344, 764±766. Gilbert, D.A., Packer, C., Pusey, A.E., Stephens, J.E. & O'Brien, S.J. (1991) Analytical DNA fingerprinting in lions: parentage, genetic diversity and kinship. Journal of Heredity, 82, 378± 386. Girman, D.J. (1996) The use of PCR-based single-stranded conformation polymorphism analysis (PCR-SSCP) in conservation genetics. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 167±182. Oxford University Press, New York. Gjetvaj, B., Cook, D. & Zouros, E. (1992) Repeated sequences and large-scale size variation of mitochondrial DNA: a common feature among scallops (Bivalvia: Pectinidae). Molecular Biology and Evolution, 9, 106±124. Gold, J.R. & Richardson, L.R. (1991) Genetic studies in marine fishes IV: An analysis of population structure in the red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) using mitochondrial DNA. Fisheries Research, 12, 213±241. Gold, J.R. & Richardson, L.R. (1993) Genetic distinctness of red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) from Mosquito Lagoon, eastern Florida. Fisheries Bulletin, 92, 58±66. Gold, J.R., Richardson, L.R., Furman, C. & King, T.L. (1993) Mitochondrial DNA differentiation and population structure in red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) from the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean. Marine Biology, 116, 175±185. Gold, J.R., Richardson, L.R. & Furman, C. (1999) Mitochondrial DNA diversity and population structure of spotted seatrout (Cynoscion nebulosus) in coastal waters of the southeastern United States. Gulf of Mexico Science, 1, 40±50. Hadrys, H., Balick, M. & Schierwater, B. (1992) Mini review ± applications of random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) in molecular ecology. Molecular Ecology, 1, 55±63. Harris, A., Bieger, S., Doyle, R. & Wright, J.M. (1991) DNA fingerprinting of tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus, and its application to aquaculture genetics. Aquaculture, 92, 57±163.
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
71
Harris, A. & Wright, J.M. (1995) Nucleotide sequence and genomic organization of chiclid fish minisatellites. Genome, 38, 177±84. Hartl, D.L. & Clark A.G. (1997) Principles of Population Genetics, 3rd edn. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Hedrick, P.W. (1994) Evolutionary genetics of the major histocompatibility complex. American Naturalist, 143, 945±964. Hedrick, P.W., Hedgecock, D., Hamelberg, S. & Croci, S.J. (2000) The impact of supplementation in winter-run Chinook salmon on effective population size. Journal of Heredity, 91, 112±116. Herbinger, C.M., Doyle, R., Pitman, E. et al. (1995) DNA fingerprint based analysis of paternal and maternal effects on offspring growth and survival in commercially reared rainbow trout. Aquaculture, 137, 245±256. Herbinger, C.M., Doyle, R., Taggart, C. et al. (1997) Family relationships and effective population size in a natural cohort of cod larvae. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science Supplement, 1, 11±18. Hillis, D.M., Mable, B.K, Larson, A., Davis, S.K. & Zimmer, E.A. (1996) Nucleic acids IV: Sequencing and cloning. In: Molecular Systematics, 2nd edn (eds D.M. Hillis, C. Moritz, & B.K. Mable), pp. 321±381. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Hindar, K., Ryman, N. & Utter, F. (1991) Genetic effects of cultured fishes on natural populations. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 48, 945±957. Humphrey, C.M. & Walker, R.L. (1982) The occurrence of Mercenaria mercenaria form notata in Georgia and South Carolina: calculation of phenotypic and genotypic frequencies. Malacologia, 23, 75±79. Jackson, T.R., Ferguson, M.M., Danzmann, R.G. et al. (1998) Identification of two QTL influencing upper temperature tolerance in three rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) halfsib families. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 129, 469±475. Jeffreys, A.J., Wilson, V. & Thein, S.L. (1985a) Hypervariable `minisatellite' regions in human DNA. Nature, 314, 67±73. Jeffreys, A.J., Wilson, V. & Thein, S.L. (1985b) Amplification of human minisatellites by the polymerase chain reaction: towards DNA fingerprinting of single cells. Nucleic Acids Research, 16, 10953±10971. Jones, C.S., Okamura, B. & Noble, L.R. (1994) Parent and larval RAPD fingerprints reveal outcrossing in freshwater bryozoans. Molecular Ecology, 3, 193±199. Karl, S. (1996) An application of anonymous nuclear loci to conservation biology. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 38±53. Oxford University Press, New York. Kenchington, E., Naidu, K., Roddick, D., Cook, D. & Zouros, E. (1993) Use of biochemical genetic markers to discriminate between adductor muscles of the sea scallop (Placopecten magellanicus) and the Iceland scallop (Chlamys islandica). Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science, 50, 1222±1228. King, T.L., Ward, R. & Blandon, I.R. (1993) Gene marking: a viable assessment method. Fisheries (Bethesda), 18, 4±5. Knut, J.E., Paulsen, O.I., Naevdal, G. & Thorkildsen, S. (1994) Genetic studies of cod, Gadus morhua L., in Masfjorden, western Norway: comparisons between the local stock and released, artificially reared cod. Aquaculture and Fisheries Management, 25, Suppl. 1, 77±91.
72
Ecological Aquaculture
Kocher, T. & Stepien, C. (Eds) (1996) Molecular Systematics of Fishes. Academic Press, San Diego. Kocher, T.D., Thomas, W.K., Meyer, A. et al. (1989) Dynamics of mitochondrial DNA evolution in animals: amplification and sequencing with conserved primers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 86, 6196±6200. Kohanne, M.J. & Parsons, P.A. (1988) Domestication: evolutionary change under stress. Evolutionary Biology, 23, 31±48. Leberg, P.L. (1996) Applications of allozyme electrophoresis in conservation biology. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 87±103. Oxford University Press, New York. Lehman, N., Eisenhawer, A., Hansen, K. et al. (1991) Introgression of coyote mitochondrial DNA into sympatric North American gray wolf populations. Evolution, 45, 114±119. Lewontin, R.C., & Hubby, J.L. (1966) A molecular approach to the study of genetic heterozygosity in natural populations. II. Amounts of variation and degree of heterozygosity in natural populations of Drosophila pseudoobscura. Genetics, 54, 595±609. MaKinster, J.G., Roberts, J.E., Felder, D.L., Chlan, C.A., Boudreaux, M. & Neigel, J.E. (1999) PCR amplification of a middle repetitive element detects larval stone crabs (Crustacea: Decapoda: Menippidae) in estuarine plankton samples. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 188, 161±168. Marchalonis, J.J. & Schluter, S. (1990) Origins of immunoglobulins and immune recognition molecules. Bioscience, 40, 758±768. Mathias, J.A., Babaluk, J.A. & Rowes, K.D. (1985) An analysis of the 1984 walleye, Stizostedion vitreum vitreum, run at Crean Lake in Prince Albert National Park, Saskatchewan, Canada, with reference to the impact of spawn-taking. Canadian Technical Report Fisheries and Aquatic Science, 1407, i±iv, 1±34. McConnell, S., Hamilton, L., Morris, D. et al. (1995) Isolation of salmonid microsatellite loci and their application to the population genetics of Canadian east coast stocks of Atlantic salmon. Aquaculture, 137, 19±30. McConnell, S., Ruzzante, D., O'Reilly, P.T., Hamilton, L. & Wright, J.M. (1997) Microsatellite loci reveal highly significant genetic differentiation between Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) populations from the East Coast of Canada. Molecular Ecology, 6, 1075±1089. Moav, R. & Wohlfarth, G.W. (1976) Two-way selection for growth rate in the common carp (Cyprinus carpio L.). Genetics, 82, 83±101. Moritz, C. (1994) Applications of mitochondrial DNA analysis in conservation: a critical review. Molecular Ecology, 3, 401±411. Morris, D., Richard, K. & Wright, J.M. (1996) Polymorphic microsatellites from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and their use for genetic study of salmonids. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 53, 120±126. Murphy, B.R., Nielsen, L.A. & Turner, B.J. (1983) Use of genetic tags to evaluate stocking success for reservoir walleyes, Stizostedion vitreum vitreum. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 112, 457±463. Naylor, R.L., Goldburg, R.J., Primavera, J.H., Kautsky, N., Beveridge, M.C.M., Clay, J., Folke, C., Lubchenco, J., Mooney, H. & Troell, M. (2000) Effect of aquaculture on world fish supplies. Nature, 405, 1017±1024. Nyman, L. & Ring, O. (1989) Effects of hatchery environment on three polymorphic loci in
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
73
Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus) species complex. Nordic Journal of Freshwater Research, 65, 34±43. O'Connell, M. & Dillon, M.C. (1997) Microsatellite DNA in fishes. In: Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries (eds G.R. Carvalho & T.J. Pitcher), pp. 331±363. Chapman & Hall, New York. O'Connell, M., Dillon, M.C., Wright, J.M., Bentzen, P., Merkouris, S. & Seeb, J. (1998) Genetic structuring among Alaska herring (Clupea pallasi) populations identified using microsatellite variability. Journal of Fish Biology, 53, 150±163. Ohland, D.P., Harley, E.H. & Best, P.B. (1995) Systematics of cetaceans using restriction site mapping of mitochondrial DNA. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 4, 10±19. O'Reilly, P., Hamilton, L., McConnell, S. & Wright, J.M. (1996) Rapid detection of genetic variation in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) by PCR multiplexing of dinucleotide and tetranucleotide microsatellites. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 53, 2292±2298. O'Reilly, P., Herbinger, C. & Wright, J.M. (1998) An analysis of parentage determination in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) using microsatellites. Animal Genetics, 29, 363±370. O'Reilly, P. & Wright, J.M. (1995) The evolving technology of DNA fingerprinting and its application to fisheries and aquaculture. Journal of Fish Biology, 47, 29±55. Packer, C., Gilbert, D.A., Pusey, A.E. & O'Brien, S.J. (1991) A molecular genetic analysis of kinship and cooperation in African lions. Nature, 351, 562±565. Paetkau, D. & Strobeck, C. (1994) Microsatellite analysis of genetic variation in black bear populations. Molecular Ecology, 3, 489±495. Paetkau, D., Waits, L.P., Clarkson, P.L., Craighead, L. & Strobeck, C. (1997) An empirical evaluation of genetic distance statistics using microsatellite data from bear (Ursidae) populations. Genetics, 147, 1943±1957. Palsboll, P.J. (1999) Genetic tagging: contemporary molecular ecology. Biological Journal of the Linnaean Society, 68, 3±22. Palumbi, S.R., Martin, A.P., Romano, S., McMillan, W.O., Stice, L. & Grabowski, G. (1991) The simple fool's guide to PCR. Special Publ., Dept. Zoology, University of Hawaii, Honolulu. Palumbi, S.R. (1996) Nucleic acids II: The polymerase chain reaction. In: Molecular Systematics, 2nd edn (eds D.M. Hillis, C. Moritz & B.K. Mable), pp. 205±247. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Palumbi, S.R. & Cipriano, F. (1998) Species identification using genetic tools: the value of nuclear and mitochondrial gene sequences in whale conservation. Journal of Heredity, 89, 459±464. Pauly, D., Christensen, V., Dalsgaard, J., Froese, R. & Torres, Jr, F. (1998) Fishing down marine food webs. Science, 279, 860±863. Perez-Enriquez, R. & Nobuhiko, T. (1999) Use of microsatellite DNA as genetic tags for the assessment of a stock enhancement program of red sea bream. Fisheries Science (Tokyo), 65, 374±379. Potts, W.K. & Wakeland, E.K. (1990) Evolution of diversity of the major histocompatibility complex. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 5, 181±187. ProdoÈhl, P.A., Taggart, J.B. & Ferguson, A. (1995) A panel of minisatellite (VNTR) DNA locus specific probes for potential application to problems in salmonid aquaculture. Aquaculture, 137, 87±97. Richard, K.R., Whitehead, H. & Wright, J.M. (1996) Polymorphic microsatellites from sperm
74
Ecological Aquaculture
whale and their use in genetic identification of individuals from naturally sloughed pieces of skin. Molecular Ecology, 5, 313±315. Richardson, B.J., Baverstock, P.R. & Adams, M. (1986) Allozyme Electrophoresis: A Handbook for Animal Systematics and Population Studies. Academic Press, Sydney. Ruzzante, D., Taggart, C.T. & Cook, D. (1996) Spatial and temporal variation in the genetic composition of larval cod (Gadus morhua) on the Scotian Shelf: cohort contribution and genetic stability. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 54, 2700±2708. Ruzzante, D., Taggart, C.T. & Cook, D. (1998) A nuclear DNA basis for shelf- and bank-scale population structure in NW Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) stocks: Labrador to Georges Banks. Molecular Ecology, 7, 1663±1680. Ryman, N., Utter, F. & Hindar, K. (1995) Introgression, supportive breeding, and genetic conservation. In: Population Management for Survival and Recovery: Analytical Methods and Strategies in Small Population Conservation (eds M. Gilpin & T. Foose), pp. 341±365. Columbia University Press, New York. Saiki, R.K., Walsh, P.S., Levenson, C.H. & Erlich, H.A. (1989) Genetic analysis of amplified DNA with immobilized sequence-specific oligonucleotide probes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 86, 6230±6234. Sakamoto, T., Danzmann, R.G., Okamoto, N., Ferguson, M.M. & Ihssen, P.E. (1999) Linkage analysis of quantitative trait loci associated with spawning time in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture, 173, 33±43. Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E.F. & Maniatis, T. (1989) Molecular Cloning: a Laboratory Manual, 2nd edn. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, New York. Sanger, F., Nicklon, S. & Coulson, A.R. (1977) DNA sequencing with chain termination inhibitors. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 74, 5463±5467. Selander, R.K., Smith, M.H., Yang, S.Y., Johnson, W.E. & Gentry, J.B. (1971) Biochemical polymorphism and systematics in the genus Peromyscus. I. Variation in the old-field mouse (Peromyscus polionotus). Studies in Genetics VI. University of Texas Publication, 7103, 49±90. Seyoum, S. (1990) Molecular identification of the tilapiine species introduced into Lake Langano, Ethiopia. SINET: Ethiopian Journal of Science, 14, 29±40. Seyoum, S. & Kornfield, I. (1992) Taxonomic notes on the Oreochromis niloticus subspeciescomplex (Pisces: Cichlidae), with a description of a new subspecies. Canadian Journal of Zoology, 70, 2161±2165. Seyoum, S., Bert, T.M., Wilbur, A., Arnold, W.S. & Crawford, C. (in review) Development, assessment, and application of a mitochondrial DNA genetic tag for the bay scallop (Argopecten irradians). Seyoum, S., Tringali, M.D., Bert, T.M., McElroy, D. & Stokes, R. (2000) An analysis of genetic population structure in red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) based on mtDNA control region sequences. Fisheries Bulletin, 98, 127±138. Smith, T.B. & Wayne, R.K. (1996) Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation. Oxford University Press, New York. Stabile, J., Waldman, J.R., Hart, J. & Wirgin, I. (1996) Stock structure and homing fidelity is high in Gulf of Mexico sturgeon (Acipenser oxyrinchus desotoi) based on restriction fragment length polymorphism and sequence analyses of mitochondrial DNA. Genetics, 144, 767±775. Stepien, C. (1995) Population genetic divergence and geographic patterns from DNA
Development and Application of Genetic Tags
75
sequences: examples from marine and freshwater fishes. American Fisheries Society Symposium, 17, 263±287. Stepien, C. (1999) Phylogeographical structure of the Dover sole (Microstomus pacificus): the larval retention hypothesis and genetic divergence along the deep continental slope of the northeastern Pacific Ocean. Molecular Biology, 8, 923±939. Sugg, D.W. & Chesser, R.K. (1994) Effective population sizes with multiple paternity. Genetics, 137, 1147±1155. Taberlet, P. (1996) The use of mitochondrial DNA control region sequencing in conservation genetics. In: Molecular Genetic Approaches in Conservation (eds T.B. Smith & R.K. Wayne), pp. 125±142. Oxford University Press, New York. Taggart, J.B. & Ferguson, A. (1984) An electrophoretically detectable genetic tag for hatcheryreared brown trout (Salmo trutta). Aquaculture, 41, 119±130. Taggart, J.B. & Ferguson, A. (1986) Electrophoretic evaluation of a supplemental stocking program for brown trout (Salmo trutta). Aquaculture and Fisheries Management, 17, 155±162. Takagi, M., Taniguchi, N., Cook, D. & Doyle, R. (1996) Isolation and characterization of microsatellite loci from red sea bream (Pagrus major) and detection in closely related species. Journal of the Japanese Society of Fisheries Science, 63, 199±204. Tanksley, S.D. (1993) Mapping polygenes. Annual Review of Genetics, 27, 205±233. Tassanakajon, A., Tiptawonnukul, A., Supankul, P. et al. (1998) Isolation and characterization of microsatellite markers in the black tiger prawn, Penaeus monodon. Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology, 7, 55±61. Tave, D. (1986) Genetics for Fish Hatchery Managers. AVI Publishing Company, Inc., Westport, Connecticut. Templeton, A.R. (1986) Coadaptation and outbreeding depression. In: Conservation Biology: the Science and Scarcity of Diversity (ed. M.E. SouleÂ), pp. 105±166. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Tessier, N.T., Bernatchez, L.B. & Wright, J.M. (1997) Population structure and impact of supportive breeding program inferred from mitochondrial DNA and microsatellite DNA analyses in sympatric landlocked Atlantic salmon populations (Salmo salar L.). Molecular Ecology, 6, 750±753. Triantafyllidis, A., Abatzopoulos, T.J. & Economidis, P.S. (1999) Genetic differentiation and phylogenetic relationships among Greek Silurus glanis and Silurus aristotelis (Pisces, Siluridae) populations, assessed by PCR±RFLP analysis of mitochondrial DNA segments. Heredity, 82, 503±509. Tringali, M.D. & Bert, T.M. (1996) The genetic stock structure of common snook (Centropomus undecimalis). Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 53, 974±984. Tringali, M.D. & Bert, T.M. (1998) Risk to effective population size should be an important consideration in fish stock-enhancement programs. Bulletin of Marine Science, 62, 641±659. Tringali, M.D. & Bert, T.M. (in prep.) Measuring gene correlation among F1 progeny in a complex system of captive breeding. Tringali, M.D., Bert, T.M. & Seyoum, S. (1999a) Genetic identification of Centropominae fishes. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 128, 446±458. Tringali, M.D., Bert, T.M., Seyoum, S., Bermingham, E. & Bartolacci, D. (1999b) Molecular phylogenetics and ecological diversification of the transisthmian fish genus Centropomus (Perciformes: Centropomidae). Molecular and Phylogenetic Evolution, 13, 193±207.
76
Ecological Aquaculture
Turner, T.F., Richardson, L.R. & Gold, J.R. (1998) Polymorphic microsatellite DNA markers in red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus). Molecular Ecology, 7, 1771±1788. Vitousek, P.M., Mooney, H.A., Lubchenco, J. & Meilillo, J.M. (1997) Human domination of earth's ecosystems. Science, 277, 494±499. Waples, R.S. & Do, C. (1994) Genetic risk associated with supplementation of Pacific salmonids: captive broodstock programs. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 51, 310±329. Watkins, D.I., McAdam, S.N. & Strang, L.X. (1992) New recombinant HLA-B alleles in a tribe of South American Amerindians indicate rapid evolution of MHC class I loci. Nature, 357, 329±333. Wayne, R.K. & Jenks, S.M. (1991) Mitochondrial DNA analysis implying extensive hybridization of the endangered red wolf Canis rufus. Nature, 351, 565±568. Williams, J.G.K., Kubelik, A.R., Livak, K.J., Rafalski, J.A. & Tingey, S.V. (1990) DNA polymorphisms amplified by arbitrary primers are useful genetic markers. Nucleic Acids Research, 18, 6531±6535. Wilson, R.R. Jr, Donaldson, K.A., Frischer, M.E. & Young, T.B. (1997) Mitochondrial DNA control region of common snook for use as a genetic tag. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 126, 594±606. Woods, J.G., Paetkau, D., Lewis, D., McLellan, B.N., Proctor, M. & Strobeck, C. (1999) Genetic tagging of free-ranging black and brown bears. Wildlife Society Bulletin, 27, 616± 627. Wright, J.M. (1993) DNA fingerprinting of fishes. In: The Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of Fishes (eds T. Mommsen & P.W. Hochachka), pp. 57±91. Elsevier Press, New York. Zouros, E., Ball, A.O., Saavedra, C. & Freeman, K. (1994) An unusual type of mitochondrial DNA inheritance in the blue mussel Mytilus. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, USA, 91, 7463±7467.
Chapter 4
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation: The Salmonid Case Study C.J. Bridger1 and Amber F. Garber2 1 College of Marine Sciences, University of Southern Mississippi 2 Department of Zoology, North Carolina State University Introduction Cultured fish occur in the wild from intentional release ± for stock enhancement and sea ranching purposes ± or escapees (individuals escaping to the wild from aquaculture grow-out facilities). Stock enhancement managers wish to supplement wild populations of a species for commercial and/or recreational fisheries, or to mitigate threats of biological extinction. Maintenance of wild genetic composition is a necessity in stock enhancement programs to minimize adverse genetic impacts to wild recipient populations, and is accomplished by utilizing an adequate number of local broodstock (donor spawning individuals) (Tringali & Bert, 1998; Tringali & Leber, 1999). To this end, aquaculture plays a vital role in the restoration of collapsing fisheries (Drawbridge, Chapter 11, this volume). In contrast to stock enhancement, most aquaculture species descend from long-term breeding programs selecting for economically important traits (e.g. rapid growth, late maturation, disease resistance, increased flesh quality, and improved survival within high density rearing environments) (Friars et al., 1996; Gjùen & Bentsen, 1997). Aquaculture net pens are frequently thought of as separate entities placed in the water by man. To the contrary, aquaculture facilities should be viewed in an holistic manner taking into account the role of the facilities as part of a complex ecosystem enhancing the form and function of the natural environment (Costa-Pierce & Bridger, in press). Each component of the `aquaculture ecosystem' must be evaluated on the basis of its sustainability; issues concerning escapees are one such component. Sustainability may be considered three-pronged ± social, economic and environmental ± all of which are very interrelated and require comparable attention for sustainable industry development and operation (Fig. 4.1). Aquaculture facilities are likely to lose domestic fish at some stage during production, especially with the utilization of sea cages. Aquaculture escapement may be classified as either chronic or acute. Chronic leakage is the slow, continuous loss of fish resulting from improper farm practices, small holes in the containment netting from general wear and tear, or localized, small scale predation. Rapid loss of fish due to storm damage or predation from destructive predators, such as seals or tuna, is considered acute escapement. Acute escapement may result in the loss of one to
78
Ecological Aquaculture
Economic sustainability
• Decrease economic loss associated with escapement Social sustainability Sustainable aquaculture
• Minimize impacts of escapees on wild fish stocks
• Decrease environmental group backlash • Decrease conflicts with wild fishers
Environmental sustainability
Fig. 4.1 Benefits of utilizing sustainable aquaculture practices by eliminating fish escapement from aquaculture facilities to the wild.
several cages of fish in a relatively short period of time and may be economically devastating to an aquaculture venture. To ensure social sustainability (and therefore general acceptance) of aquaculture, elimination of escapees to the environment will be required to decrease both public backlash and conflicts with wild fishers. Concerns of potential interactions between escapees and wild fish stocks are legitimate and require focused scientific research to decrease the impacts (disease, ecological and genetic) that escapees may have on wild stocks. Economic sustainability is of the greatest concern to the fish farmer, and is best attained by minimizing (or completely eliminating) revenue losses associated with escapement from cages. This chapter will focus on issues regarding escapees and environmental sustainability.
Occurrence of salmonid aquaculture escapees in the wild The salmonid aquaculture sector has received the most attention and has the highest public profile with regards to escapement from sea cages. Despite increased farm operator awareness and implementation of rigid industry Codes of Conduct and government regulations to mitigate farm fish loss, reports of high aquaculture escapement still occur (Table 4.1). Global occurrence of escapees in wild marine and freshwater fisheries is up to 48% of the total catch with a large proportion (up to 45%) of the sexually mature salmonids being escapees. Escapees can be differentiated from wild conspecifics (counterparts) by external appearance, presence of synthetic flesh colorants from salmonid farm feed, or genetic tags (Table 4.2).
Effects of domestication To increase profits, aquaculture operations selectively breed a fish strain for high growth rates in environments with no predatory stress, while using high density
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
79
Table 4.1 Occurrence of escapees in wild fisheries and freshwater systems throughout the world Locations
Occurrences of escapees
References
Norway
Escapees in 70% of monitored rivers with 15% of total samples in southern and 1% in northern Norway (greater salmon farming volume also in the south)
Gausen & Moen, 1991
29.1% of marine catch and 5.8% of freshwater catch in 1989
Lund et al., 1991
1 steelhead trout smolt captured migrating to sea
Jonsson et al., 1993
45% of female Atlantic salmon spawners
Sñgrov et al., 1997
22% of fishery in 1990
Webb & Youngson, 1992
After 1986, reared salmon detected frequently (ranged up to 38%) near salmon farms but irregularly (<0.5%) in distant rivers
Youngson et al., 1997
Iceland
30.1% in catch, almost all sexually mature
Gudjonsson, 1991
Faroe Islands
25±48% of fishery
Hansen et al., 1993
West Greenland
1.1% (1991) and 1.4% (1992) escapees in the wild fishery
Hansen et al., 1997
British Columbia
188 Atlantic salmon caught in freshwater from 1990 to 1995 with most displaying gonadal development and external coloration indicating sexual maturation
McKinnell et al., 1997
210 escaped Atlantic salmon adults captured in 29 streams in 1996
McKinnell & Thomson, 1997
20% of redds created by females of definite cultured origin
Carr et al., 1997
51.0±67.2% of smolts were juvenile escapees
Stokesbury & Lacroix, 1997
Scotland
New Brunswick
formulated feeds to yield a food conversion ratio close to 1:1 (i.e. 1 kg dry feed producing 1 kg of wet fish flesh). A large body of literature is available regarding the effects of domestication (process of adaptation to an artificial environment) on the genetics, behavior, morphology and physiology of fish species. We will outline some of the key concerns of domestication and also provide numerous studies that are contradictory, illustrating the complexity of fish behavior and problems associated with sweeping generalizations across species. Many of the examples provided discuss how escapees of hatchery origin may impact wild salmonid populations. Farmed Atlantic salmon, from the Norwegian salmon breeding program, have been selected for growth performance (body weight at slaughter), delayed sexual maturation, flesh color, body composition or fat content (total fat content and amount of fat tissue), and resistance against diseases (principally furunculosis and infectious salmon anaemia (ISA)) (Gjùen & Bentsen, 1997). A common assumption is that genetic variation may be lost in hatchery populations, using a small number of broodstock fish (Verspoor, 1988a). The Norwegian breeding program strives to maintain additive genetic variation through careful record keeping, use of pedigrees
80
Ecological Aquaculture
Table 4.2 Methods to identify and separate escapees and wild conspecifics Individuals identified
Methods of identification
References
Recently escaped individuals
Determine isomeric ratio of natural and synthetic astaxanthin present in muscle tissue
Lura & ékland, 1994
Recently escaped individuals
Carotenoid pigmentation
Craik & Harvey, 1987
Escapees of all ages
Scale characteristics associated with growth
Lund & Hansen, 1991; Hiilivirta et al., 1998
Juvenile escapees
Otolith analysis
Hindar & L'AbeÂe-Lund, 1992
Post-vaccinated individuals
Visual observation of postvaccination intra-abdominal adhesions
Lund et al., 1997
Adult escapees
Discriminate analysis based on fin size measurement as a result of fin erosion in captivity
Potter, 1987
Eggs and alevins from escapee females
Astaxanthin transferred from flesh to gonadal tissue thereby allowing use of isomeric ratio of natural and synthetic astaxanthin to determine parent origin
Lura & Sñgrov, 1991a
Escapees of all ages
Genetic tags
Crozier, 1993; Clifford et al., 1998a, b
(a genealogical tree using symbols to represent sex and presence of a desired trait), and rotating a large number of broodstock fish. Broodstock originates from diverse base populations and stocks are rotated between breeding stations on a regular basis (Gjùen & Bentsen, 1997). Selective breeding for desirable traits in a rather structured `aquaculture environment' may also inadvertently influence escapee behavior patterns (such as predator avoidance, aggression, habitat selection), morphology and physiology. Escapee survivorship and interactions with wild conspecifics may be impacted by selective breeding. Survival of hatchery salmonids in the wild tends to be less than that of wild salmonids (Reisenbichler & McIntyre, 1977; Fraser, 1981). Reduced survival could mitigate adverse effects to wild stocks. Time of escapement also influences survivorship. Escapee salmon smolts entering the wild in spring have higher survival rates than smolts escaping in autumn or winter (Hansen & Jonsson, 1989). Greater survival of hatchery coho salmon exists following release in an estuary as opposed to release within a river (Solazzi et al., 1991). Increased river mortality may be associated with suboptimal river position and decreased predator avoidance. Lower survival has also been attributed to improper spawning behavior (e.g. adequate redd digging and defending, reproductive timing) by domestic fish which, in turn, affects survival rates of newly hatched eggs. Berejikian et al. (1997) observed that merely captive-rearing fry (collecting wild individuals, raising them in artificial environments, and later
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
81
releasing them back to the river system for spawning) affected subsequent adult spawning behavior and success. Competitive inferiority of escapees is expected for adults during the spawning season. Hatchery coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) are competitively inferior to wild coho. Hatchery male coho have a 20% lower spawning success than hatchery females (Fleming & Gross, 1992, 1993). Hatchery males are considered less effective at accessing spawning opportunities. Hatchery females had poor site selection, inadequate redd preparation and unsuccessfully defended fertilized eggs (Fleming & Gross, 1993). Hatchery females also have an 8% lower fecundity than wild females (Fleming & Gross, 1992). In the wild, feeding is often limited (or postponed) due to the presence of predators. Selection for high growth rate in captivity (with ad libitum feeding and absence of predators) may inadvertently select for decreased predator avoidance and result in reduced escapee survival. Johnsson et al. (1996) observed reduction in predator avoidance by juvenile domestic brook trout, coupled with an increase in growth rate and food conversion ratio. Similar behavior has also been documented for domestic steelhead trout (Berejikian, 1995). Decreased predator avoidance could serve as a natural method to remove escapees from the wild. However, following escapee spawning in the wild, hybrid (domestic 6 wild) steelhead individuals also display decreased predator avoidance (Johnsson & Abrahams, 1991). Altered hybrid behavior could have negative implications to highly adapted wild salmonid populations. In contrast to these studies, Hvidsten & Lund (1988) observed similar predation rates on hatchery-reared and wild Atlantic salmon smolts. Feeding ad libitum combined with the high stocking densities experienced in artificial environments may affect the degree of aggression and schooling behavior expressed by escapees. Much debate exists, however, as to whether these behaviors will increase or decrease with domestication (reviewed by Ruzzante, 1994). Fenderson et al. (1968) for Atlantic salmon Salmo salar, Swain & Riddell (1990) for coho salmon, and Mesa (1991) for cutthroat trout Oncorhynchus clarki all provide evidence for elevated aggression in hatchery salmonids. Escapees may become more aggressive and display less schooling behavior in an attempt to increase their nearest neighbor distance (spatial distance between competing individuals for limited resources), thereby decreasing competition for limited food in the wild compared with captivity. Steelhead hatchery fry are more aggressive in situations with low population density and low food availability (Berejikian et al., 1996). Increased aggression may not be adequate to ensure escapee survival but may result in decreased predator avoidance. Wild conspecifics, accustomed to natural foraging and not hand-fed ad libitum, should perhaps outcompete escapees of the same size for limited food and habitat (Berejikian et al., 1996). However, owing to aquaculture trait selection for increased growth rate, seasons/habitats with adequate food supply effectively decreasing competition could provide the impetus for escapees to become larger than wild conspecifics during the same period of time. As expected, when given a size advantage, hatchery steelhead fry dominate wild fry (Berejikian et al., 1996). Artificial selection and productive `natural systems' that are underutilized could therefore favor escapees.
82
Ecological Aquaculture
Juvenile habitat selection and subsequent ability to defend a territory may be altered through domestication. Optimal stream position enhances survivorship and increases bioenergetic efficiency when fish remain in the stream area of least resistance. Suboptimal stream position results from losing dominance in confrontations between individuals for limited optimal space (Fausch, 1984). Hatchery-reared Atlantic salmon tend to maintain stream position at mid-water depth, between juvenile wild Atlantic salmon and brook trout (Dickson & MacCrimmon, 1982). Mid-water stream position will likely increase competition by overlapping juvenile habitat with both wild Atlantic salmon and native brook trout, and decrease escapee foraging success. Poor habitat selection may also be indicative of escapees lacking previous river experience, and occupying fast-flowing stream sections. Hatchery fish spend 43% of their time in riffles versus wild conspecifics spending only 29% in riffles (Mesa, 1991) and utilize physical stream structure less than wild fish (Bachman, 1984). Poor habitat selection may reduce escapee survivorship by providing an increased opportunity to be predated. Hatchery steelhead fry stay at the river water surface during daylight (Jonsson et al., 1993). Mid-water and surface stream position also increases risk of being swept downstream by rapid currents. Fast riffle position requires excessive energy expenditure to maintain river position, and subsequently results in smaller individuals that are subordinate to wild conspecifics. Subordinate individuals will, in turn, lose dominance and increase the likelihood of having to inhabit suboptimal pool and riffle position. Wild fish accurately time river migration with appropriate water flow regime. Following entry to the wild, escapees may be less morphologically adapted to local river systems and inferior to wild conspecifics. In addition, escapees have decreased morphological variation in comparison to wild conspecifics (Taylor, 1986). Decreased morphological variation may be the result of genetic homogeneity ± from using small numbers of broodstock and artificially selecting traits ± and/or the aquaculture growout environment with sufficient feed (Swain et al., 1991). Escapee morphometric changes are substantial following one generation in grow-out conditions, and become more prominent following selective breeding programs over numerous generations (Fleming et al., 1994). Although escapee spawning has been documented, decreased reproductive output may be anticipated owing to morphological deficiencies. Male hump height (Quinn & Foote, 1994), snout length (Fleming & Gross, 1994), and secondary coloration patterns (Hanson & Smith, 1967) all influence salmonid reproductive success. Obvious differences in phenotypic expression could result in lower reproductive output. Wild salmon have larger head dimensions, median fins and body depth than hatchery individuals (Swain et al., 1991; Fleming et al., 1994). Fins are frequently used in salmonid spawning behavior (e.g. female Atlantic salmon primarily use the caudal fin to build redds; Fleming et al., 1996), but fins may be eroded on escapees as a result of being held in net pens with high stocking density (Moring, 1982). Finally, successful escapee spawning with wild conspecifics could genetically alter the body morphology of wild populations (Riddell & Leggett, 1981; Taylor & McPhail, 1985). Hybrids (domestic 6 wild) could display changed phenotypic expression (alteration in body form) that may decrease reproductive success when compared with wild fish, resulting in long-term negative effects to wild populations.
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
83
Physiological differences between hatchery and wild fish have been attributed to selective breeding programs and artificial rearing environments. During excess confinement, comparable to aquaculture environments, wild trout express considerably higher concentrations of plasma cortisol than domestic individuals (Woodward & Strange, 1987). In the wild, physiological trait selection for increased aquaculture production may decrease escapee fitness. Farmed Atlantic salmon have lower swimming endurance than sea-ranched salmon during the peak spawning season (Thorstad et al., 1997). Reduced endurance may be the result of decreased swimming, foraging, and predator avoidance displayed in captivity. Both hatchery Atlantic salmon (Thorstad et al., 1997) and brook trout (Johnsson et al., 1996) have higher somatic fat contents than wild or hybrid (domestic 6 wild) individuals. Increased somatic fat content may further decrease swimming endurance. Domestication typically selects for increased growth rates. Domestic Atlantic salmon growth is twice the growth of wild conspecifics until smolting (Gjùen & Bentsen, 1997). This could result in larger spawner sizes (Reisenbichler & McIntyre, 1977), and increased food conversion efficiencies (Johnsson et al., 1996). Increased size renders an advantage to escapees when competing for optimal river position, spawning opportunities, and defending redds (assuming escapees receive adequate food and display appropriate spawning behavior).
Potential interactions of escapees with wild conspecifics Decline of wild fish stocks has become a global phenomenon. Observed declines have been associated with climate change, overfishing, and habitat destruction (Beamish et al., 1999; Clark et al., 1999). Some wild stocks are slow to recover, even following fishery closures (Hutchings, 2000). In addition to external pressures affecting wild salmonid stocks, stresses from aquaculture escapees are of concern. As an example, on November 13, 2000, `wild Atlantic salmon' was listed as an endangered species in several Maine rivers. In their decision to protect wild Atlantic salmon, the NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service and the US Fish and Wildlife Service cited diseases, interbreeding and competition from `escapee Atlantic salmon' as potential issues threatening recovery efforts of the wild stock. International symposia have been held to discuss issues regarding interactions between salmonid escapees and wild conspecifics (Hansen et al., 1991; Hutchinson, 1997). In addition, a thorough review of salmonid farming has been completed in British Columbia, Canada, evaluating numerous issues of public concern, including the impacts associated with escapees (Anonymous, 1997). In all cases, disease, ecological, and genetic interactions with wild conspecifics are of greatest concern (Fig. 4.2).
Disease interactions One frequent opposition to fish farming is that the opportunity for disease infection and transfer is increased in an aquaculture setting compared with wild stocks. Rearing
84
Ecological Aquaculture
Fig. 4.2 Escapee interactions ± disease, ecological, and genetic ± with wild salmonid populations and the environment.
conditions could raise the likelihood for opportunistic diseases and/or parasites owing to increased stocking density and associated stress. However, the same disease/parasite agents are present within wild salmonid stocks, as well as other marine fish species (Saunders, 1991; Kent et al., 1998). Apparent increases in diseases and parasites in fish farms may be misleading owing to rigorous observation and documentation in aquaculture that is absent for wild fisheries and stock surveys (McVicar, 1997). Infectious agents may be spread from wild stocks to cultured fish (and vice versa) through horizontal transmission (direct contact either via the water or escapees interacting with wild conspecifics) or vertical transmission (from infected wild broodstock or successful spawning of infected escapees). Both horizontal and vertical diseases require extensive contact for transmission. Therefore, it is possible that disease and parasite agents could be more likely transmitted through stock enhancement programs that promote extensive contact and spawning between hatchery-derived and wild fish to increase depleted wild populations. For example, spread of the monogenean parasite Gyrodactylus salaris has been correlated with the introduction of infected hatchery salmon to Norwegian rivers through stock enhancement programs. Numerous nearby rivers that have never been stocked but are in close proximity also have the parasite present. These fish likely originate from stocked parr migrating to neighboring streams (Johnsen & Jensen, 1986; Lund & Heggberget, 1992). Although stock enhancement programs are considered the primary cause of G. salaris in the wild, infected transport tanks, birds and escapees may also be additional sources of infection.
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
85
Some diseases of wild stocks ± such as enteric redmouth disease (Yersinia ruckeri) ± have been attributed to transmission of the pathogen from infected salmonid farms. However, no major outbreaks or clinical signs of the disease have been observed in wild fish (HaÊstein & Lindstad, 1991) that are likely serving as carriers of the pathogens. It may therefore be possible that the greatest risk of disease transfer exists from wild carriers to aquaculture stocks (Saunders, 1991). If suboptimal conditions exist for the cultured stock, the same opportunistic bacteria, not causing clinical signs of infection in wild fish, may result in a disease outbreak for cultured fish. To prevent opportunistic disease outbreaks, it is imperative that excellent husbandry practices be followed and optimal growing conditions maintained in culture environments. Following best management practices will decrease the opportunity for pathogen transmission and disease outbreak in aquaculture, which, in turn, would mitigate the opportunity for disease transmission to wild fish should escapement occur.
Ecological interactions Age, season, location of escapement, and juvenile experience influence movement patterns and upstream migration of escapees. Sutterlin et al. (1982) documented successful return of mature salmon to the smolt area of release after 13±25 months at sea. Decreased return can be expected for salmon escaping during winter. Up to 60% straying by salmon smolts released during the winter has been observed (Hansen & Jonsson, 1991). Rate of straying increases with distance between salmonid home-river location and escapement site (Heggberget et al., 1991). Increased straying will result in escapee adults entering rivers at random to spawn (Hansen et al., 1987). Haphazard river entry is permitted by escaped fish having no previous river experience offering discernible signposts (cues that allow return to a specific site) to follow during migration. Reduced homing precision to a river also exists for escapee steelhead trout adults (Jonsson et al., 1993). Juvenile river experience will impact escapee upstream migration behavior. Atlantic salmon will return to the river they left as juveniles, regardless of their genetic origin (Hansen & Jonsson, 1994). Hatchery smolts released in the mouth of a river (but without river experience) will return to that river as mature adults at the same time as wild conspecifics. However, hatchery adults enter the river later in the season illustrating the influence of river experience on behavior (Jonsson et al., 1990, 1991, 1994). Escaped farm salmon having no river experience will also delay river ascent compared with wild conspecifics (Eriksson & Eriksson, 1991; Gudjonsson, 1991; Lund et al., 1991; Heggberget et al., 1993). In contrast, hatchery smolts released within a river enter the river at the same time as wild conspecifics (Jonsson et al., 1994). These results illustrate the importance of river experience ± and aquaculture practices ± on timing of river ascent. Salmonid aquaculture industries typically raise early life stages either in tank facilities or ponds/lakes and transport (by truck) juveniles to an estuary without allowing river experience. Escapees would be expected to return to this estuary, assuming they are raised in the vicinity of the juvenile estuary, and enter rivers at a later time than wild conspecifics, having no signposts to continue the migration upstream.
86
Ecological Aquaculture
Once in a river, escapee and wild salmon have been observed together in spawning areas (ékland et al., 1995; Heggberget et al., 1996; Thorstad et al., 1998). Escapees of both sexes may spawn (apparently in equal numbers) with wild conspecifics (Lura & Sñgrov, 1991b; Webb et al., 1991). However, escapees tend to spawn later in the season (Webb et al., 1991). Having spawned later, escapees may dig redds in areas being used by wild salmon, decreasing wild salmon fitness (Webb et al., 1991). This would also indicate that escapee females with no river experience are able to locate suitable spawning areas and successfully dig redds, assuming fins are not eroded to prevent redd preparation. Youngson et al. (1993) indicated that Atlantic salmon escapees tended to hybridize with brown trout (Salmo trutta) more frequently than wild salmon. This may be attributed to overlapping habitat with brown trout and/or abnormal sexual behavior demonstrated by escapee female salmon decreasing spawning opportunities with wild salmon. Lura & Sñgrov (1993) observed escaped Atlantic salmon spawning earlier than native wild salmon in the River Vosso. Earlier spawning time overlapped with brown trout spawning. Escaped Atlantic salmon reproductive behavior could result in sterile progeny, negatively affecting the brown trout population (see `Genetic interactions' section). Additionally, earlier spawning will extend the growing season of hybrid (Atlantic salmon 6 brown trout) alevins. Assuming hybrids overlap juvenile habitat with wild Atlantic salmon, longer growing seasons will result in larger hybrid juveniles compared with wild salmon, and give a competitive and territorial advantage to hybrid progeny (Berejikian et al., 1996). Although successful spawning has been documented, escapee salmon are reproductively inferior to wild conspecifics. After entering a river to spawn, escapees remain in the river for a shorter period of time, with a notable percentage of both males and females leaving unspawned (Jonsson et al., 1990, 1991; ékland et al., 1995). Escapees in Norway move up- and downstream more often; are observed to be further up the river; and are more frequently injured during spawning than wild individuals (Jonsson et al., 1990, 1991; Heggberget et al., 1996; Thorstad et al., 1998). Increased movement and upstream distribution suggest escapees cannot locate `their' spawning area owing to the absence of juvenile river experience. Escapees tend to spawn in the lower reaches of northern Scottish rivers (Webb et al., 1991, 1993). Webb et al. (1991) noted that later escapee river entry compromised further river ascent owing to decreased water levels later in the season. Inferior escapee female spawning results from reduced spawning behavior, construction of fewer redds, and retention of more eggs than wild females (Fleming et al., 1996). Decreased fecundity and spawning behavior will result in less reproductive output from female escapees. Escapee males also display inappropriate courting behavior resulting in decreased success in entering redds to fertilize the eggs (Fleming et al., 1996). In North America, hatchery steelhead have reduced reproductive success in comparison with wild conspecifics (Chilcote et al., 1986; Leider et al., 1990). Predation and competition decrease the survivorship of offspring from hatchery steelhead. Owing to high mortality, hatchery steelhead contribution to the total population decreases from 85±87% at the egg stage to 42% at the adult stage (Leider et al., 1990).
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
87
Genetic interactions* Wild salmonid stocks are frequently thought of as being highly adapted to their native stream, existing in reproductively discrete populations (brook charr, Salvelinus fontinalis, Angers et al., 1995; Verspoor, 1997, for review; coho salmon, Small et al., 1998; chinook salmon, Oncorhynchus tshawytscha, Nelson et al., 2001). Localized populations may form demes (species population inhabiting a specific geographic location) that express traits (i.e. behavior, morphology, physiology) reflecting ambient environmental conditions within the home river system. Local adaptation is a process whereby the frequency of beneficial traits to enhance the survival and/or reproductive success of individuals expressing them increases through natural selection (Taylor, 1991). Adaptation of salmonids to specific river systems ensures optimal habitat utilization and spawning for the natural environment, but could be detrimental to the population in times of immense human-induced change to the local habitat (e.g. construction of dams and fish ladders, pollution). Escapee `exogenous' population genetic interactions with wild conspecific `indigenous' populations can be classified as direct or indirect (Krueger & May, 1991; Utter, 1998). Direct genetic effects result from introgression (defined here as the incorporation of genetic material from escapees into the gene pool of an indigenous (native) population following successful spawning between the two strains (interbreeding); also called introgressive hybridization) of escapees with wild conspecifics. Direct genetic effects can have negative or positive genetic implications on a highly adapted indigenous population depending on the degree of additional external pressures experienced by the population. Aquaculture breeding programs artificially select for traits that will be economically beneficial in the rearing environment, but not so in a natural system. Therefore, introgression may cause outbreeding depression resulting in the reduction of fitness (survivorship and transmission of genes) in the following generation. Introduction of exotic individuals to the wild gene pool can modify growth, survival, reproduction and behavior of the wild population (Utter, 1998). Einum & Fleming (1997) concluded hybrid salmonids (escapee 6 wild) are likely to be inferior to locally adapted wild individuals, but superior to escapee fish originating from a seventh-generation broodstock for aquaculture. Given intermediate performance, wild salmonids, adapted to the environment, will outcompete escapee and hybrid (escapee 6 wild) individuals. However, hybrids (escapee 6 wild) can replace indigenous wild populations (hybrid swarms; Utter, 1998), especially in regions having a small, locally adapted, indigenous salmonid population experiencing a large accidental escapement of cultured stock (escapees). After an escape of farmed Atlantic salmon, samples taken from a river in Northern Ireland indicated an allelic shift in 0+ age salmon toward the farmed strain with a loss of genetic diversity (using electrophoretic variation) occurring (Crozier, 1993). Using mitochondrial DNA and minisatellite markers, Clifford et al. (1998a, b) suggested escaped adult farmed Atlantic salmon were interbreeding with wild salmon in * See Bert et al., Chapter 3, this volume, for explanation of terminology not defined throughout this section.
88
Ecological Aquaculture
northwest Irish rivers. Escaped juvenile farmed Atlantic salmon had completed their life cycle; and, upon return to the river, escapees bred and interbred with the wild fish. The markers (genetic tags) used in these studies tracked escapee fish and not fitness of the hybrids. However, both studies indicated farmed salmon had a reduced genetic diversity compared with wild individuals. In the absence of other external pressures, hybrid individuals could have negative consequences to a wild population owing to decreased genetic variability and local adaptation. Numerous examples exist illustrating resistance differences of salmonids to various disease/parasitic agents (e.g. vibrio, Gjedrem & Aulstad, 1974; myxosporean parasite Ceratomyxa shasta, Hemmingsen et al., 1986; furunculosis, Bailey, 1987; monogenean Gyrodactylus salaris, Bakke et al., 1990). Disease-related genetic effects result following reproduction, altering the degree of pathogen resistance of local salmonid conspecifics. In such cases, intermediate susceptibility could result and serve as a method to select against hybrids in the wild (Hemmingsen et al., 1986). Of course, most aquaculture stocks are selected for disease resistance traits which could potentially be transmitted through introgression, with the creation of a hybrid (escapee 6 wild) strain having superior disease resistance compared with the original wild stock. Wild salmonid populations can be reduced by high fishing pressures, often artificially selecting for larger individuals, and human-induced environmental changes (e.g. pollution, dam construction). As a result, the reduced wild population can undergo inbreeding depression. Inbreeding depression is decreased fitness from crossing closely related individuals and subsequent reduction in traits (e.g. fertility, growth rate, disease resistance) necessary for survival. When considering the depleted numbers of wild salmonid stocks in some river systems and resultant inbreeding, introgression of escapee stocks could have positive effects on the wild population by increasing the overall genetic variability, adding new alleles to the population (Thorpe, 1991) to cope with the immense human-induced changes occurring. To prevent or relieve inbreeding depression, Wohlfarth (1986) suggested stocking programs should use crossbred fish (domestic strains 6 wild strains) to produce greater vitality (heterosis or hybrid vigor). Crossbreeds could have increased heterozygosity (allelic diversity) owing to crossing of two inbred lineages (in this case wild 6 domestic). Researchers stocking cutthroat trout (wild 6 domestic), brook trout (wild 6 domestic) and pink salmon (wild 6 wild) observed higher returns indicative of better survival, faster growth, or both (Wohlfarth, 1986). However, hybrid vigor may not be experienced by all species having exogenous alleles entering the gene pool (e.g. steelhead trout; Wohlfarth, 1986). A potential drawback of hybrid vigor is that, although improvement of hybrid (escapee 6 wild) strains may be evident, subsequent generations may be less fit. For long-term improvements, Wohlfarth (1986) suggested domesticated fish of one sex be stocked periodically to establish a stable resident population. Indirect genetic effects alter the genetic composition within or among a population without introgression (Utter, 1998). Some examples of indirect genetic effects are introduction of pathogens/parasites by resistant carriers, competitive displacement (for limited habitat or food), and non-introgressive hybridization (introgression that
Aquaculture Escapement, Implications and Mitigation
89
does not go beyond the first generation) (Krueger & May, 1991; Utter, 1998). Indirect genetic effects can cause a reduction in the number of wild individuals in the population which increases the rates of genetic drift (random fluctuations of gene frequencies in a population) and inbreeding (spawning of closely related individuals), artificially changing allele frequencies (Krueger & May, 1991). Non-introgressive hybridization is introgression that does not go beyond the first generation (Utter, 1998; classified as `infertile interspecific hybrid' direct genetic effect by Krueger & May (1991)). Non-introgressive hybridization occurs when escaped Atlantic salmon and wild brown trout interbreed (e.g. Verspoor, 1988b; de Leaniz & Verspoor, 1989; Youngson et al., 1993; Galbreath & Thorgaard, 1995). Hybrid offspring (F1, Atlantic salmon 6 brown trout) can produce viable F2 (hybrid 6 hybrid) and backcross (hybrid 6 parent) progeny (Verspoor, 1988b). However, viable Atlantic salmon 6 brown trout hybrids are functionally sterile owing to major karyotypic (chromosomal complement of ± in this case ± a species) differences between the species (Galbreath & Thorgaard, 1995). Non-introgressive hybridization can displace wild populations (e.g. brown trout) through ga