Energy Efficiency and Climate Change
ii ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Energy Efficiency and Climate Change Con...
103 downloads
1361 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Energy Efficiency and Climate Change
ii ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Energy Efficiency and Climate Change Conserving Power for a Sustainable Future
B. Sudhakara Reddy Gaudenz B. Assenza Dora Assenza Franziska Hasselmann
Copyright © B. Sudhakara Reddy, Gaudenz B. Assenza, Dora Assenza and Franziska Hasselmann, 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. First published in 2009 by SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd B1/I-1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area Mathura Road, New Delhi 110044, India www.sagepub.in SAGE Publications Inc 2455 Teller Road Thousand Oaks, California 91320, USA SAGE Publications Ltd 1 Oliver’s Yard 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP, United Kingdom SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd 33 Pekin Street #02-01 Far East Square Singapore 048763 Published by Vivek Mehra for SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd, typeset in 10/12 pt Adobe Garamond by Star Compugraphics Private Limited, Delhi and printed at Chaman Enterprises, New Delhi. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Energy efficiency and climate change: conserving power for a sustainable future/ B. Sudhakara Reddy … [et al.]. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Energy conservation. 2. Energy policy. 3. Climatic changes—Prevention. I. Sudhakara Reddy, B. TJ163. 3E4365
363. 738’746—dc22
2009
2009032025
ISBN: 978-81-321-0228-1 (HB) The SAGE Team: Elina Majumdar, Manali Das, Anju Saxena and Trinankur Banerjee
Contents
List of Tables List of Figures List of Boxes Preface 1
Energy, Economy and the Environment: An Introduction
2
Climate Debate
vi vii ix x 1 31
3 Win-Win Climate Policy
56
4
76
Fundamentals of Energy Efficiency
5 The Benefits and Drawbacks of Energy Efficiency
113
6 The Concept of Barriers and Drivers and its Application to Energy Efficiency
150
7
Energy Efficiency and International Environmental Law
183
8
Commercializing Clean Energy Technologies
214
9
Financing Energy Efficiency in Transition Economies
239
10 The Role of Institutions in Promoting Energy Efficiency
272
Epilogue: Road to a Sustainable Future: A Systematic Understanding of Energy Efficiency and Climate Change 305 Consolidated Bibliography About the Authors Index
319 341 343
List of Tables
2.1 2.2 4.1 4.2 4.3 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 6.1 7.1 8.1 9.1 10.1
Great weather disasters, 1950–2001 Projected climate change impacts compared to other environmental problems Functions of the actors in energy efficiency Overview of factors fostering the implementation of EE programmes Features of the energy sector relevant to policy Positive aspects of energy efficiency History of corporate environmentalism Potential savings due to increase in supply-side efficiency Potential savings due to increase in demand-side efficiency Potential savings due to other options Employment benefits in EU countries due to energy efficiency Energy-efficient homes vs. typical homes Energy efficiency projects Externalities of energy efficiency Variables in the causal model (examples) Emissions reduction obligation under Annex B to Kyoto Protocol Technology commercialization model Regional allocation of concessional flows, 1990–1999 Components of a sound performance analysis
45 48 97 101 103 115 124 125 126 128 132 135 138 145 172 198 222 246 281
List of Figures
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 3.1 3.2 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4A.1 4A.2
5.1 5.2 6.1 6.2
Energy outlook in 2030 World energy investment, 2005–2030 Fuel share in energy investment requirements, 2005–2030 Share of energy investment of different countries and groups, 2005–2030 Trends in economic and insured losses, 1950–2004 Trend in annual frequency of great natural catastrophes, 1950–2004 Per capita CO2 emissions by Annex 1 and non-Annex 1 countries Recommendations to financial institutions and governments Fisher’s time-preference theory of interest Cost-benefit of a cleaner technology project Characterization of energy efficiency potential Technology choices for private sector investment in energy efficiency Inter-relationships among actors Actors’ perspectives Actor–factor influence state diagram Research environments Comparison of energy and entropy flows of (a) electric furnace and (b) heat pump World-wide averages of second-law efficiencies for the generation and transformation of electricity into energy services Methodology of selecting projects Benefits to various stakeholders—Local and global Schematic representation of profitability barriers Schematic representation of feasibility barriers
6 9 10 11 46 47 52 54 60 73 84 91 94 95 98 105 108
110 140 141 159 160
viii ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
6.3 6.4 6.5 7.1 8.1 8.2 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 10.1 10.2
Targeting micro, meso and macro barriers Structure of causal model Causal linkages The CDM project cycle The chain from basic research to commercialization Technology diffusion curve Net long-term flows to developing countries, 1995–2004 Sources of risk in energy efficiency investments Role of local financial institutions Role of ESCOs The functions of ESCO International ESCO and local partner Financing channels Pre-offer financial analysis Institutions involved in energy efficiency Roles of utilities
163 166 171 207 218 220 245 248 250 251 252 253 262 264 275 277
List of Boxes
1.1 4.1 4.2 5.1 5.2 5.3 6.1 7.1 8.1 8.2 9.1
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4
Flow-on benefits to promote energy efficient practices Key reasons for advocating EE Ingredients of the techno-economic model of change Energy efficiency and the indoor environment Benefits of EE for business establishments Trade-off between a technology and service—An example The case of Hungary Standardized procedures for small-scale energy-efficiency projects proposed by the CDM Executive Board Luz International Limited—A failure story Case: The commercialization of the Internet ‘Securitizing’ the savings stream, developing financial structures and credit enhancements to support EE project loans Performance evaluation Performance description Performance prediction Performance prescription
24 81 89 116 122 136 181 209 226 235
249 284 285 285 285
Preface
Arising from the ashes of the Second World War, the industrialized countries embarked on an epoch of unprecedented growth and stability, but seem to have ignored emergencies, the predominant pattern being to live as if there was no tomorrow. Individuals, companies and nations borrowed with abandon, not realizing how overuse of energy, over-consumption of goods and resources and lack of ecological stewardship will destabilize the very fundamentals of prosperity in the future. In pursuit of development, industrialized nations exploited natural resources unhindered. And today, it’s the turn of the nature to react to its over-exploitation in the form of devastating changes in the climate. The developing countries that have very limited role in destroying the nature are caught in a great dilemma. With high vulnerability neither these countries can ignore climate change nor can they withstand its devastating changes. While struggling to meet the basic needs of their people, these countries are in a catch-22 situation (spurging is not an option). This book attempts to answer this dilemma of developing countries through sustainable marketbased energy-efficiency (EE) solutions. This book discusses the factor of energy, which drives all economies. Energy and development are correlated and the causation is both ways. More efficient energy use enhances production, promotes economic development and improves the standard of living. Energy is closely linked to economic opportunity, security and empowerment. Energy services are essential to both social and economic development and wider access to them is critical in achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and thereby assist in sustainable human development. The future of energy seems uncertain. At the beginning of the 20th century, nuclear energy was unheard of. Today, the world abounds in nuclear reactors. Similarly, even to imagine the kind of life possible without petroleum products is extremely frightening. Although previous concerns about global energy scarcity have proved unfounded, there is a fierce debate
PREFACE
xi
whether the peak of oil utilization has already been reached, or whether oil extraction will still increase for years or perhaps even decades. Fossil fuels may never be fully exhausted, but their quality and accessibility are declining, and their end is most likely to be caused by demand constraints rather than resource limitations. After the reckless use of this scarce resource, modern society is now struggling to identify new energy resources. Global warming, acid rain, radioactive waste and other issues increasingly influence energy policies in the new world. The challenges of resource scarcity and environmental sustainability, have made the future of energy policy a hot topic among policy makers and academics. Understanding energy demand and how efficient use of energy is used is of interest to policy makers as both aspects influence economic development, environment and sustainability. Researchers and policy makers have turned their attention to the more efficient utilization of existing energy supplies to help meet society’s energy needs. Depending on the system and user investigated, it may be more economical to make efficient use of existing energy resources and reduce waste rather than develop new energy supplies to meet growing energy demand. EE investments can have broader societal benefits in addition to reduced energy costs. More efficient utilization of energy often leads to improved productivity and competitiveness in business and helps avoid or reduce environmental impacts associated with the extraction, delivery and combustion of fossil fuels. Yet, policies or programmes to increase EE often face daunting institutional, behavioural, financial and cultural barriers to their adoption. The global financial crisis and global warming arose from the same unsustainable economic policies, which aimed to maximize short-term growth at the expense of long-term development. This book shows that economic growth is not necessarily incompatible with sustainable development. The question is not whether growth or the environment is more important, but how the economy can become environmentally and socially sustainable. The volume shows that the real choice facing policy makers is between sustainable forms of economic development and unsustainable ones. It provides a systematic framework for students, policy makers, academics and others interested in the efficient utilization of energy. Chapter 1 of the volume introduces the key issues to be addressed in the subsequent discussions, that is, the interrelations among the environment, economy and energy (the three ‘Es’). The next two chapters deal with the ‘great climate debate’ and discuss clashing positions represented by sceptics and supporters of action on climate change. The discussion focuses on
xii
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
market-based measures as a means to increase the win-win opportunities and to attract investors to invest in climate change mitigation. Chapter 4 provides an overview of the fundamentals of EE. Chapters 5 and 6 develop a new systematic classification and explanation of benefits and drawbacks to EE. The topic of EE is approached with the aim of understanding the barriers to and the drivers for EE investments. The chapters try to identify (a) the drivers and barriers that affect the success or failure of EE investments and (b) the institutions that are responsible for the emergence of these barriers and drivers. This taxonomy aims to synthesize ideas from three broad perspectives, namely, micro (project/end user), meso (organization) and macro (state, market and civil society). Chapter 7 looks at the relationship between international environmental law and EE. A detailed treatment of the prerequisites for adopting a private sector-driven ‘business model’ approach for the successful diffusion of sustainable energy technologies (SETs) is presented in Chapter 8. Emphasis is laid on the mobilization of private capital and the commercialization of energy-efficient technologies (EETs). This private sector perspective is critical to reduce the burden on state budgets, which are creaking under the weight of numerous demands of urgent nature. This is expected to integrate the processes of market transformation and entrepreneurship development with innovative regulatory, marketing, financing, incentive and intermediary mechanisms. Chapter 9 discusses the linkages between EE and the financing mechanism. It shows how to tap the dynamism, innovation and power of markets for promoting EE and environmental concerns. It helps institutions that are involved in EE to identify and assess promising market opportunities, find local partners that are critical for success, package projects to make them attractive to lenders and investors and find sources of financing. Chapter 10 discusses the lessons of experience of institutions in supporting energy-efficient technologies. The emphasis is on analyzing the performance of organizations, particularly multilateral institutions (MIs) in promoting EETs. Many policies adopted in response to the global financial crisis are of a short-term nature, based on saving dirty industries with low or no profitability, while neglecting opportunities in EE, clean energy and intelligent resource management. The advantage of the EE approach is that it looks at real needs and at real human development. It provides value for money, for consumers, businesses and governments. For several decades, EE has been a growth industry creating new jobs at an ever-faster rate. Nevertheless, many governments, firms and consumers neglected the energy savings potential due to a complex web of barriers. These barriers are discussed here. The volume examines the approaches around the world that succeeded and failed, and draws lessons about the way to proceed.
PREFACE
xiii
In energy and environmental policy, the choice is between continuing the status quo, with most resources invested into fossil fuels, or promoting new forms of energy, especially renewable energy (megawatts) and EE (negawatts). To achieve win-win outcomes, which combine positive economic and environmental effects, policy makers can choose among a range of instruments, such as emissions trading, taxes, subsidies, command and control instruments, information mechanisms and voluntary mechanisms. This book explores public policy and technologies from the perspective of current political, economic and cultural realities as well as likely future trends. It argues that governments and firms can prosper and strengthen their security by investing in the growing green world market, securing patents for green technologies and adopting climate change measures that overall create more jobs than they destroy. We are indebted to the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research, Mumbai, India, and the collaborating universities, in particular Palacky University in Olomouc (Czech Republic) and the Catholic University of Ružomberok (Slovakia), including the faculty and staff of the respective organizations for their support of our efforts in writing this book and for providing all the necessary facilities that we all, too often, take for granted. There are some people who are mentors. The influence of the late Prof. Amulya K. N. Reddy (research supervisor of the first author) on the work described here is extremely significant. Prof. Reddy, a pioneer in the field, first introduced the first author to the issue of EE on which he had been engaged for some 20 years. For this, he is deeply indebted to him. There are others who provided important ideas. They include Dr. Eric Ferguson, The Netherlands; Dr. P. Balachandra, Department of Management Studies, Indian Institute of Science; Mr. K. Sreenivasa Rao, assistant editor, Journal of the Indian Institute of Science (JIISc), Bangalore, India and Mr. Hippu Salk Kristle Nathan (IGIDR, Mumbai) who have contributed to this book through technical and philosophical discussions of different parts of it. We offer them our sincere gratitude. The assistance of Tatyana Golubenko and the comments of Beatrice Maalouf in developing an early partial draft are gratefully acknowledged. We would like to thank Thomson Publishing Service, UK and Elsevier Science Publisher, UK, for permission to reproduce published material in Chapter 4 and Chapter 5. We thank Ms. Manali Das, Ms. Elina Majumdar and Ms. Meena Chakravorty and others at SAGE publications, New Delhi, for excellent handling of the publication of this volume. Last and most of all, BSR offers a special word of thanks to his wife, Lalitha, and sons, Sandeep and Siddarth, for the loving family environment
xiv
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
that afforded him the tranquillity and peace of mind that made the writing possible. It is a pleasure to acknowledge their contribution and to thank them for it.
B. Sudhakara Reddy Gaudenz B. Assenza Dora Assenza Franziska Hasselmann
1 Energy, Economy and the Environment An Introduction
Energy development is a barometer of economic progress. The substitution of energy for human power in the performance of agriculture, industry and domestic services has contributed to the process of economic growth. The increased availability of energy services stimulates economic activity along different stages of the development process. Economic development accelerates when a society uses energy in new forms, adaptable to a range of needs based on its social and cultural characteristics. Understanding energy demand and how efficiently energy is used is of interest for policy makers as both aspects influence economic development, environment and sustainability. Throughout history and across the globe, energy utilization has followed a highly uneven process and has demonstrated dramatic variations in energy sources, use and growth rates. For example, in 2000, an average member of the American economy used hundred times more energy than his counterpart in Bangladesh. While in some countries, the per capita energy consumption is increasing rapidly, in others it has shown a decrease.1 In developing countries, fuel wood stoves can be found alongside nuclear reactors. Likewise, space vehicles coexist with bullock carts. 1
McNeill et al. 2001.
2
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The world’s future energy path is uncertain. At the beginning of the 20th century, nuclear energy was unheard of, but, today, more than 400 nuclear power plants are in operation worldwide. Similarly, the present-day society cannot imagine life without petroleum products and electricity. However, the environmental implications of increased fossil fuel use and the risk of climate change in particular, will place limits on the use of fossil fuel resources. The progressive exhaustion of the easily accessible supplies will cause significant price increases by the turn of this century. The magnitude and speed of climate change is likely to be significant, but not completely certain. Increased greenhouse gas (GHG) concentrations are very likely to raise the Earth’s average temperature, influence precipitation and some storm patterns as well as raise sea levels.2 However, the amount and speed of future climate changes will ultimately depend on: whether GHGs and aerosol concentrations increase, stay the same or decrease; how strongly the features of the climate (for example, temperature, precipitation and sea level) respond to changes in GHG and aerosol concentrations; and how much the climate varies as a result of natural influences (for example, from volcanic activity and changes in the sun’s intensity) and its internal variability (referring to random changes in the circulation of the atmosphere and oceans).3 The fact is that the 10 warmest years in the instrumented temperature record (1861—the present day) have all occurred since 1990.4 However, the likelihood of deleterious impacts, as well as the cost and difficulty of adaptation, are expected to increase with magnitude and speed of the global climate change.5 The speed at which climate change is occurring and the uncertainty of the exact nature or timing of the impacts mean that a flexible and responsive approach to climate preparation will be needed.6 Faced with these challenges of climate change, economic development and sustainability, the future of energy and environmental policies have been a hot topic among policy makers and academics. Debates continue on the best energy source, with considerations of availability and cost of the resource, efficiency of production, public safety and health. Policy makers grapple with these decisions as well as with the consequences of use of different energy sources. Environmental concerns about global warming, acid rain, radioactive waste and other issues influence energy policies around the world. Understanding energy use in our society means understanding resources, their limitations and the environmental consequences of their use. 2
IPCC 2007d. EPA n.d. 4 Forestry Commission 2005. 5 Stern 2007. 6 CCIG 2008; IPCC 2007a. 3
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
3
Increasingly, researchers and policy makers have begun to focus on the more efficient utilization of existing energy supplies to help meet society’s energy needs. Depending on the system and user investigated it may be more economical to make efficient use of the existing energy resources and to reduce waste rather than to develop new energy supplies to meet growing energy demand. Energy efficiency (EE) has broader societal benefits in addition to reduced energy costs. More efficient utilization of energy often leads to improved productivity and competitiveness in business and helps avoid or reduce environmental impacts associated with development, combustion and delivery of fossil fuels. Yet, policies or programmes to increase EE often face daunting institutional, behavioural, financial and cultural barriers to their adoption. Consequently, researchers and policy makers are often confronted with an ‘energy efficiency gap’7 between the potential for energy savings and what is being realized in practice. The aim of this book is to provide a systematic framework for students, policy makers, academics and others interested in the efficient utilization of energy. The topic of EE is approached with the aim of understanding the barriers to and the drivers for EE investments. Particular emphasis is laid on the mobilization of private capital and the commercialization of energyefficient technologies (EETs). This private sector perspective is critical in order to reduce the burden on state budgets, which are creaking under the weight of enormous public expenses. Also, a business perspective on EE is necessary to tap the dynamism, innovation and power of markets for promoting environmental concerns. The environmental implications of EE investments as potential drivers for improved efficiency are a key focus of this book. The goal is to disseminate information on the development of policy instruments for promoting EE investments that can begin to bridge the gap between EE potential and practice. An attempt has been made in this volume to include the whole gamut of issues related to EE, development and environment. The introductory chapter ventures into the world of energy and EE by providing background, as well as context. Historically, supporters of energy efficiency defended the need for rational use of energy primarily on the basis of economic efficiency. However, the emergence of evidence of energy use contributing to climate change reinforces the case for EE. Chapter 2 on the great climate debate presents an independent assessment of the global level arguments both in favour and against climate change in terms of its causes, outcomes, policy initiatives, mitigation and adaptation methodologies. Chapter 3 examines a 7
Koopmans and te Velde 2001.
4
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
climate policy, which encourages win-win situations for both the environment and the economy. EE alternatives are considered as win-win opportunities for greenhouse gas mitigation. To familiarize the readers with the fundamentals of EE, Chapter 4 deals with the concept and unravels the complex linkages in terms of technology, policy, stakeholders and politics. A critical evaluation of energy efficiency is presented in Chapter 5 through an assessment of the benefits and drawbacks of adopting EETs and approaches. This assessment is made from the perspective of all stakeholders, namely, government, consumers, society, business, and so on. If the benefits of adopting EE are enormous, then, naturally, one is tempted to ask why this is not happening. In attempting to resolve this issue, Chapter 6 presents the theory behind the barriers that prevent and the drivers that promote the adoption of EE measures. In addition, a theoretical framework is provided to causally relate EE investments and existence of barriers. Chapter 7 pre-sents a discussion on the implications of international laws on climate change, environmental pollution, intellectual property rights, and so on, in the commercialization of EE. The benefits of EE cannot be realized until a large-scale diffusion of efficient technologies takes place. However, this can happen only if EE attains commercial status and spreads without any programmatic support. Chapter 8 discusses these aspects and presents a collaborative approach to achieve the goal of commercialization of EETs. A critical evaluation of financial mechanism is presented in Chapter 9 through an assessment of methods, channels and approaches in financing EE. Chapter 10 presents the role of multilateral institutions in promoting the adoption of EE measures.
1.1 Powering the World Economy In ancient times, human beings had a modest need for energy. They relied mainly on the energy from animal strength to do work. Humans first learned to control fire around one million BC and since then have used fire to cook food and to warm their shelters.8 There were water mills, wind mills and also solar energy for drying of foods. About 1000 BC, the Chinese discovered coal and started using it as a fuel, primarily for heating. Before the advent of coal, many regions experienced fuel crises due to the depletion of wood resources. The extraction and burning of coal made it possible to produce energy on a large scale and supply power to a growing economy. 8
Mitchem 1994.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
5
The invention of the steam engine in the 18th century, which has the capacity to convert heat from the combustion of coal and other fuels into mechanical energy, opened up new possibilities. The first steam engines were inefficient and wasted more than 99 per cent of energy, but by 1900, they had become 30 times more efficient than their predecessors. On top of this, steam engines, unlike watermills and windmills, could be set up anywhere, even on ships or railroad locomotives. The portability of the steam engine created a positive feedback loop, in that it enabled the transport of coal on a massive scale, providing fuel for more steam engines. Industrialization in the 19th century rested on this fact. World coal production, about 10 million tons in the year 1800, shot up 100-fold by the year 1900. Rough calculations suggest that the world in the 20th century used 10 times the energy used in the thousand years before A.D 1900.9 By the year 2030, it is predicted that energy consumption will increase by 52 per cent compared to energy demand in 2006 under a business as usual scenario.10 The Asian region will account for almost 40 per cent of that growth. Energy consumption in developing countries, particularly in China and India, has increased significantly in recent years. The share of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) nations in world energy demand is expected to fall from 56 per cent in 2006 to 47 per cent in 2030, while that of the Asian region, excluding Japan, will rise from 26 to 27 per cent (Figure 1.1). An increase is foreseen in the ratio for natural gas in the energy resources from 23 per cent in 2000 to 28 per cent in 2030, while the share of oil and coal will decrease proportionately. Notwithstanding these variations in the above ratios, consumption of fuels will increase due to a rise in the overall energy demand. The consumption of oil, coal and natural gas in the Asian region is expected to rise from 2000 through 2030 by 38, 79 and 19 per cent, respectively. It is estimated that by 2030 China’s dependency on oil will be about 30 per cent. However, if the world moves away from coal due to considerations for the environment and human health, there will be an increase in oil consumption in Asia and in the corresponding ratio too. Energy in central and eastern Europe during the socialist era was provided by coal, the most monolithic of the fuel mixes. For instance, Poland relied on coal for close to 70 per cent of its primary energy and 95 per cent of its electricity supply in 2005.11 Lithuania, Bulgaria, Slovakia and Hungary 9
McNeill et al. 2001. IEA 2008a. 11 Ibid. 10
6
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 1.1 Energy Outlook in 2030
Source: IEA 2006a.
ranked among the top 10 world-wide in terms of reliance on nuclear energy for electricity supply. For instance, Lithuania produced 85.6 per cent of electricity from nuclear energy in 1995.12 Another key characteristic of the energy supply of central European countries and the Soviet Republics was that they relied heavily on energy imports from Russia. Energy was one of the leashes through which Russia kept its republics and the satellite countries of CEE (Central and Eastern European) dependent, in accordance with the provisions of the Yalta Treaty since 1945. Large imports of natural gas, electricity, oil, nuclear fuel and other primary energy carriers built the basis of CEE energy supply. One of the positive legacies of the Soviet era for the CEE region is the high share of natural gas in the fuel mix, and the relatively well-developed infrastructure for natural gas. Since Russia is endowed with the lion’s share of the world’s natural gas reserves, it relies heavily on natural gas as a primary energy source. Furthermore, it has developed an extensive pipeline network 12
IEA 2008a.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
7
to provide central European economies with natural gas. This has resulted in a high dependence on natural gas in these countries. The share of natural gas in Hungary’s energy supply presently exceeds 40 per cent, whilst more than 60 per cent of all Hungarian households are supplied with natural gas.13 Other countries in the region also rely largely on natural gas in their total primary energy supply, such as Ukraine (42.9 per cent), Romania (37.7 per cent) and Czechoslovakia (19.9 per cent).14 Since natural gas is the least polluting of the fossil fuels and emits only half as much carbon to the atmosphere per unit of energy as coal, this had a positive impact on the overall environmental performance of the energy sectors of these economies. While the reliance on natural gas was desirable from an environmental perspective in the short term, after the fall of the Soviet era, it raised concerns of national sovereignty in several CEE countries and in the former Soviet republics. Since diversifying the import sources of natural gas is burdensome due to the costly and time-consuming pipeline construction, fuel diversification emerged instead on the top of the energy policy agenda of several CEE countries as a tool to promote energy security. Natural gas, however, remains an important fuel in the CEE region. The energy industry was the largest polluter of the CEE region at the end of the socialist era. According to Kramer, the communists claimed that ‘(…) environmental pollution is the price that has to be paid for industrial development and the development of civilization’,15 Baker and Jehlicˇka illustrate further the attitude of the communists. They argued that environmental problems arising from industrial production were only temporary and would be solved in the near future through scientific and technological advances.16 In the so-called ‘Black Triangle’, which was an area of heavy industry and coal mining in Poland, Czechoslovakia and East Germany, acid rain has turned many square miles of forests into a moonscape. In the Orlické hory mountains, over two-thirds of the trees were dead by 1989, and even worse was the situation in the Krušné hory mountains and the Jizerské hory mountains.17 In this region, carbon emissions per unit of economic output were among the highest in the world; several times higher than those in OECD countries.
13
MOL 2001. IEA 2006a. 15 Kramer 1983, 204. 16 Baker and Jehlicˇka 1998, 7. 17 See Carter 1993, 72–73. 14
8
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
However, at the root of all environmental damages related to the energy sector was the wasteful production and use of energy in the CEE region. While quality of life was significantly lagging behind that in OECD countries, the levels of energy consumption per capita were comparable to those in the most developed economies. In 1989, a Russian citizen 18 consumed more energy than a citizen of any EC country, while he or she enjoyed only a fraction of the wealth of an EC citizen. As a result, environmental emissions per capita and per gross domestic product (GDP) were also high compared to the low standards of living. Thus, at the root of the energy-related environmental damages was the inefficiency of the energy chain, which is often characterized by energy intensity indicators such as total per capita energy supply (TPES)/GDP. The stage is set for intense competition for resources among countries seeking to secure their energy supply by diversifying sources and areas of origin. According to projections of the World Energy Council, the fuels most widely used today—coal, oil and natural gas—will still account for 19 two-thirds of primary energy even beyond six decades from now. Currently, coal is both cheap and abundant. Likewise, oil supplies are still high and new oil deposits are being discovered. Natural gas is the cleanest fossil fuel today but the transportation infrastructure is not very well developed in developing and transition countries. However, there is the option of reducing the use of fossil energy to counter their environmental implications. This can be done through EE measures and substitution of alternative energy sources, such as solar, wind, geothermal, modern biomass and traditional hydropower generation. According to the World Bank’s estimates, renewable energy could potentially provide up to 50 per cent of all energy by the middle of the 21st century, ‘(… ) given appropriate enabling policies and 20 new technology developments’. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates, the world’s increasing demand for energy will require a total investment of USD 20 trillion (value in 2005 dollars) by 2030 out of which about USD 11 trillion would be needed in the global electricity sector alone. Worldwide, the race is on to increase exploitation of existing oil fields and to find new ones. Capital expenditure in the oil industry amounts to just over
18
Certainly the citizens did not directly consume all this energy, but their per capita share of the national primary energy consumption was very high. 19 WEC 2006. 20 World Bank 2000, 23.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
9
one-fifth of the total energy investment. Projected oil development programmes in North America will require a total investment of USD 856 billion over 2005. In order to restore Iraqi oil production to the 1990 levels, some USD 5 billion will be needed over the next six years and, in a rapid growth scenario, production could reach 5.4 mb/d by 2030 at a cost of USD 54 billion. China will need a total of USD 7 trillion investments, which is 18 per cent of the total investment (Figure 1.2). Figure 1.2 World Energy Investment, 2005–2030
Source: IEA 2006a. Notes: E&D = Exploration and Development; T&D = Transmission and Distribution; LNG = Liquified Natural Gas.
The IEA states that a total investment of USD 20 trillion is required by the global oil and gas industry to keep pace with the anticipated demand over the next 30 years, of which about USD 700 billion is needed to support the Middle East oil sector. Oil from the Persian Gulf region will play an increasingly important role in the world economy. The uncertainty surrounding the developments in Iraq is a cause for concern. Investment in the global natural gas industry will average USD 157 billion a year over the next two decades to meet a near doubling in demand and to provide around 300 billion cubic metres of new gas production. Global investments in Russia’s energy sector are projected to exceed USD 195 billion by 2030. Peak investment would come in 2010 for prospecting
10
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
new oil fields and gas reserves, maintaining old ones and improving the infrastructure for transporting oil. According to the IEA, the total level of investment in oil transportation will increase six-fold by 2030. Russia is poised to become one of the leading exporters of oil and gas by 2030, gaining an important niche in many markets, including Asia (Figure 1.3). Figure 1.3 Fuel Share in Energy Investment Requirements, 2005–2030
Source: IEA 2006a.
According to IEA, world-wide electricity demand will double in the next three decades, with an average annual increase of 3.2 per cent. To meet this growing demand, the world would further need around 5,100 GW electricity generating capacity by 2030, and about half of that needs to be built in Asia. Europe would need to invest about USD 1.7 trillion on power plants, transmission and distribution to meet an increasing demand for electricity and maintain the current capacity. Germany alone anticipates a new capacity of around 40,000 MW in electricity production in the coming decades, which corresponds roughly to 60 large-scale power plants (Figure 1.4).
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
11
Figure 1.4 Share of Energy Investment of Different Countries and Groups, 2005–2030
Source: IEA 2006a.
Due to limited state budgets, financing for necessary energy sector investments in transition economies and developing countries will pose the greatest challenge in the decades ahead. Developing countries will account for over half of the total investments over the next 20 years, or USD 10.5 trillion, with transition economies accounting for USD 1.85 trillion. Brazil’s energy sector will need investments of USD 250 billion to meet the country’s electricity demand in the next 20 years. More than USD one trillion will need to be spent on China’s transmission and distribution networks—an amount equivalent to 2.1 per cent of China’s annual GDP. India will need an investment close to USD 100 billion in electric and oil sectors. Notwithstanding the projected rate of investment for new electricity supplies, an estimated 1.4 billion people, mostly in Africa and South Asia, will still remain without electricity connection. The underlying assumption of this overview, is in no way, that the firm predictions of various agencies such as the IEA can neither be influenced nor be avoided. It is our firm belief that policies do have the required leverage to influence the energy path. A significant reduction of energy consumption levels can be achieved if we promote such policies. Therefore, the issue is the need for a shift in paradigm—from policies which increase energy consumption to those that help to reduce it.
12
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
1.2 The Geopolitics of Energy In the new millennium, new realities affecting the energy industry are constantly emerging not only because of events in the Middle East but also because of the environmental impacts of energy consumption and concerns about global sustainability. A strong interaction exists among energy, economics, technology, geopolitics and sustainability. The challenge for policy makers is to secure the long-term energy future without destroying the environmental systems that support the human race. It would be short-sighted of countries to focus only on their own energy security without due regard for the geopolitical and environmental risks and impacts. The invasion of Iraq in 2003 was seen by many as an expression of the mindset that oil equals security. According to these theorists, the geopolitical strategy of the United States (US) is based on the perceived need to maintain access to oil reserves not only in the Persian Gulf but also around the world. It is a common truism that all politics, including that of energy, is local. Yet the source of energy is global. That means that global energy supplies are potentially vulnerable to any disruptive event, anywhere, anytime. Vulnerability is ever present, regardless of the degree of dependence on imported oil. The national security of a country must be viewed as a question, not just of military hardware, but also of economic vulnerability, which is linked to the dependence on energy. This dependence has been amply demonstrated during the first oil crisis of 1973 when the price of crude oil increased four-fold. By 1973, according to some experts, oil had become the main source of energy of industrial economies around the world. Never before had industrial countries been so dependent on oil exporting countries. Seeing through this dependency, some Arab countries started considering the use of oil as a weapon to achieve their economic and political objectives. When Israel attacked the Golan Heights in 1973, the Arab countries agreed to an oil embargo. The economies of many developing countries were shattered due to supply restrictions and price increases. Unless the energy resources are diversified and used far more efficiently, many of the oil importing countries will remain vulnerable to the tempestuousness of the politics of oil. Access to Middle East oil and gas is likely to remain a major factor of international political relations. The challenges of energy security and sustainability are daunting and require a paradigm shift to reduce energy consumption levels. This calls
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
13
for a much bolder approach, involving a combination of policy proposals and technologically feasible ideas, significant public investment in efficient systems, and stronger support for renewable energy resources as well as other alternative sources of energy.
1.3 The Energy–Environment Nexus—The Climate Change Energy is closely linked with key contemporary global challenges the world faces—social development and poverty alleviation, environmental degradation and climate change—and is therefore a defining issue of our time. Climate change is especially of concern to the energy sector, since the use of energy accounts for about 60 per cent of greenhouse gas emissions. But above all, it is a global concern because without new policy action, we run the risk of irreversibly altering the environmental basis for sustained economic prosperity. Climate change will impact our health, our security and our economies. The damage could be large and irreversible. The costs are also likely to be unevenly distributed, with poorer economies and households incurring greater losses. This is one of the many facets of the problem that complicates the international response to the challenge of climate change. In recent years, there has been a growing concern about global warming due to increased concentration of heat trapping gases in the atmosphere. As a result of burning coal, oil and other fossil fuels, large amounts of carbon dioxide (CO2) and sulphur dioxide (SO2) have been released into the atmosphere.21 Since the beginning of industrial revolution, the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide has increased by nearly 30 per cent, methane has more than doubled, and nitrous oxide has risen by about 15 per cent. These increases have enhanced the heat trapping capability of the earth’s atmosphere. Many scientists see links to global warming.22 Since the end of the 19th century, the global mean temperature of the earth surface has increased from 0.5°F to 1.0°F.23 21 SO2 is responsible for acid rain and the pollution of soil and water, forest and biological resources. CO2 is the main GHG responsible for climate change. 22 Common air pollutants such as sulphate aerosols cool the atmosphere by reflecting light back into space; however, sulphates are relatively short-lived in the atmosphere and vary regionally. 23 EPA , n.d.
14 ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
GHG emissions occur naturally but they can also be attributed to a number of human activities, namely, energy production and utilization, industrial processes, deforestation and agricultural practices. Of these, energy production and use account for nearly 50 per cent of the human caused increase in greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Deforestation and agriculture together contribute about 25 per cent whereas industry is responsible for the remaining 25 per cent.24 While the great majority of GHGs such as water vapour occur naturally, scientists have linked the observed increase in greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to human activities. Developing countries, which were low-emitting countries until the 1970s, have become the fastest growing sources of GHG emissions, mainly due to economic growth. In 1950, North America and western Europe together accounted for 68 per cent of total emissions while in 2006 they represented only 40 per cent of the total. In contrast, the share of developing countries increased from 7 to 35 per cent of the world total.25 Since energy production and use is the single most important source of GHG emissions and coal demand is dominant in several key developing countries in Asia,26 the energy as well as environmental policies in these countries will strongly influence global environment in the future. As the exhaustion of fossil fuels and the environmental damage caused by pollutants of fossil fuel combustion became notable, energy experts began to seek alternative sources of energy. Some of the energy sources that are becoming popular are solar, wind, hydroelectric, biomass and geothermal energy. Many of them have been developed nearly a century ago. There are many reasons for the slow diffusion of these technologies. Whereas for solar radiation, the low energy density is a barrier for wind and hydro, it is their local availability and intermittent nature. Hydro is constrained by environmental concerns and low world availability while geothermal is mainly a local source with a low world maximum and technological problem like corrosion. Biomass competes with food and fodder crops, has low efficiency and high logistic costs. Nuclear energy is widely used today. Its efficiency in producing energy is attractive, but the risk of accidents and the disposal of radioactive waste are key concerns. A far more important issue 24
WRI 2003. WEC 2006. 26 Domestically produced coal is the predominant source of generating electricity. The quality of this coal is very poor (calorific value=2800 kcal/kg which is 40 per cent less than that is being produced in countries like USA). Hence, CO2 emissions from coal plants is higher in the Asia-Pacific region. 25
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
15
is proliferation. Every nuclear plant produces plutonium, which can be reprocessed into fissile material for nuclear weapons relatively easily. Considering all these constraints, a very good alternative that is economically beneficial and environmentally sound is the efficient utilization of energy resources. By reducing the need to supply more energy inputs to the system, EE creates economic and environmental benefits. Until now, EE has not been sufficiently marketed this way. However, EE is not a magic bullet, but an essential part of any solution. It does not make the approaches to balancing the energy markets superfluous.
1.4 Energy Efficiency—The Other Paradigm Need for Energy Efficiency The thinking in developing countries and transition economies on energy production and utilization is mostly on the pattern prevailing in Europe and North America. Many countries adapted a nearly identical path of large scale, supply-side-oriented energy development. However, despite decades of adherence to this path, these countries have not met even the basic energy needs of the majority of their people. In such circumstances, a different paradigm of energy development needs to be developed. This approach goes beyond the traditional supply side one, using energy as a catalytic force to bring about both social and economic development. This type of development embraces the following principles: (a) development oriented, (b) service based, (c) endogenous, (d ) self-reliant, (e) environmentally 27 sound and ( f ) socially acceptable. To achieve these goals, an efficient utilization of resources is necessary. This is a holistic view of how to provide the energy need of all without destroying ecological balance. This approach is not merely looking for consumption growth, but for consumer value and human development. The paradigm with emphasis on EE could be turned into an engine of 28 growth that truly enhances livelihood levels of people at the lowest end of the economic ladder. The driving concern of this paradigm has been 27
Goldemberg et al. 1988. There is no intrinsic coupling between the EE approach and the livelihood levels of people or a catalytic force to social development. However, it fits well into such a development model. 28
16
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
that the human dimensions of energy are as important as the technological. This approach is rooted in the conviction that energy needs cannot be met in isolation from other human problems. The emphasis must be on energy services—not merely on energy consumption or supply as an end in itself. The focus has to be on energy services that improve the Human Development Index directly, such as cooking, safe water, lighting, transportation, as well as 29 indirectly via employment and income generation. These needs have to be met through a combination of means using renewable resources, efficiency improvements and new technologies that can improve economic activities and at the same time reduce the risk of environmental degradation. Although the 1990s saw a re-emergence of EE as an important policy goal, the relentless growth of economic activity and population still dominated the public agenda, causing a multiple increase in aggregate demand for energy resources. An increasing share of energy consumption is attributable to developing countries, including such densely populated countries as India and China.30 If we project these trends into the future, the world could experience a shortage of finite and non-renewable fossil fuels by the first half of the 21st century. The energy sources that have sustained the civilized society for so long—fossil fuels—are becoming increasingly scarce. A much debated question is—what will happen when deposits run out? Judging by today’s level of energy consumption and technological possibilities, the world’s coal deposits may last a few centuries, natural gas for about 70 years and oil for more than 40 years.31 However, there is also an option of exploring other possibilities. There is a possibility of secondary and tertiary recovery, which can vastly increase oil recovery from oilfields. There are gigantic supplies of methane in geo-pressurized zones and clathrates. There are also tar sands, oil shales and deep-in-site gasification of fossil fuels. The mineral deposits may never be fully depleted if technological progress and changing energy structures make fossil fuels obsolete before the stocks run out. One should also take into account the self-regulation of the oil industry: if there are only 40 years of assured reserves, there will be a cut down on exploration, and so less new reserves will be found. Thus, the main question may not be about the time of depletion of coal, oil, and gas stocks, but about when these energy sources will be substituted by a combination of alternative energy
29
Reddy 2002. ESCAP 2008. 31 Torkunov 2001. 30
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
17
sources, efficient technologies, lightweight materials and other advanced technologies. An energy revolution driven by concerns about economics, sustainable development, and energy security has been called for by many experts since 1970. However, only in recent times the installation of EETs has become an urgent task for industrial organizations and governments alike. In many countries this process has barely begun because of the absence of technological know-how and political will. The reasons for not promoting EE may become quite sensible, if one takes election within the next few years as the main government perspective and shareholder value as those of energy companies. There is neither political will nor industrial initiatives to develop technologies and know-how, that cannot be sold on a large scale. However, for those who want to take long-term responsibility, and to look for the future of humanity, these short-term optimizations are not sufficient. Even three decades after the first oil crisis the vast potential for EE and savings still remains to be harnessed. To achieve the goal of energy security and sustainability, the involvement of various stakeholders such as end users and many intermediate and down-stream institutions in setting up integrated energy systems is essential. This requires long-term planning, stable government and managerial skills. Usually an EE approach is not always the cheaper option. The advantages accrue over the much longer term: lesser dependency on foreign energy imports or local fossil resources; lower impact on the environment, and so on. But those advantages do not help the short-term development. On the contrary, the classical supply side approach is more flexible with standard equipment and widely-known technologies. Hence it is important that we should be much more careful in designing the EE system. To succeed in this approach, there is an urgent need for a paradigm shift in policies to support EE and renewable energy initiatives aided by appropriate incentives, standards and investments geared towards spurring private investment. This shift in energy policy should be rapid and sustained if it is not to run out of steam and give way to the previous status quo.32 In the following sections, each of these factors will be considered in more detail.
32 The evolution of human needs and the services that require energy, such as lighting, cooking, transport, or motive power have to be analyzed along with demographic and social trends. For a sustainable energy strategy, policy and planning should be thought of as part of a global policy involving land use, infrastructure, urbanization, lifestyles and region.
18
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The Economics of Energy Efficiency Generally the term EE is defined in a technical sense and relates a given level of service to a given level of input. To put it differently, an increase in EE occurs when either energy inputs are reduced for a given level of service or service is increased or enhanced for a given level of input. To be energy efficient per se is to provide services with an energy input that is small relative to a fixed standard or normal input. It is important to note that EE should not be regarded as an end in itself. It is a means to conserve natural resources, to reduce environmental degradation and to save money. It is true that EE helps to reduce GHG emissions. However, there is a debate about both its cost effectiveness and the policies that should be pursued to enhance EE.33 Improvements in EE will require active intervention in markets to overcome barriers and to stimulate drivers (see Chapter 6 on drivers and barriers). On the other hand, some argue that market barriers to the penetration of EETs do not represent real market failures that reduce economic efficiency. Under certain conditions, such as wrong choice of technology, expensive policy incentives, inefficient implementation, there can be trade-offs between economic efficiency and EE, even though these goals should go hand-in-hand logically. The balance of evidence supports the view that there is not always a ‘free lunch’ in EE. Nonetheless, a case can be made for the existence of certain inefficiencies in energy technology markets, thus raising the possibility of win-win EE enhancements. These issues are discussed in more detail in Chapters 3, 6 and 9. The cost effectiveness of an efficiency measure varies, depending on who evaluates the investment and which costs and benefits are considered. For example, from a business perspective, the only relevant costs and benefits are those borne by the energy user. These include expenditures on equipment, installation as well as operation and maintenance costs. The benefits include energy cost savings plus enhanced labour productivity, environmental compliance or product quality. These are the traditional accounting costs and benefits that affect the industry directly. From a societal viewpoint, there is a wider range of relevant costs and benefits. These include monetary, health and environmental costs and benefits that accrue to society. Certain societal benefits, such as reduced local air pollution or diminished threat for climate change are external to the market and are difficult to quantify. Moreover, they accrue to society at large, not directly to the particular party 33
See for example, Newell 2000.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
19
implementing efficiency measures. So it is important to analyze who bears the costs and who gets the benefits. Not until every actor has a positive cost-benefit perception will they participate and the EE system will take off. The EE approach can be termed as tightly coupled. The key economic question that will determine the pace of the widely anticipated energy revolution is the cost of improving EE relative to various forms of energy generation, such as for instance the cost of extracting fossil fuel and providing services through renewable energy sources. The fundamentals of EE are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4. It is worth discussing three fundamental relationships here: z
z
z
With increasing costs of energy generation, the adoption of EETs will become a viable alternative. Since the contribution of renewable energy sources is marginal to the total energy mix the main economic driver for EE remains the utilization of fossil fuels. The more expensive the extraction of these fuels, the more attractive is the reduction in their use through efficiency measures. With increasing volatility of energy prices, many countries become vulnerable to such volatility. While the high and volatile oil prices may reduce economic growth in developed economies, they can trigger prolonged economic crisis in developing countries in the form of increasing budget deficits, trade imbalances, increased unemployment and impoverishment. Under these circumstances, the option of efficient utilization of energy becomes an attractive proposition. With increasing stability and soundness of economic policies and overall macroeconomic conditions, the probability of increasing EE will be higher. It is generally postulated that macroeconomic conditions matter less with regard to EE area because EE projects are more of a short-term proposition than fossil fuel or nuclear power projects. However, traditional energy investments tend to be large and long term, and hence the political and economic stability of the country is particularly important.
Energy Efficiency and Climate Change In recent years, the main focus of the global environment has been on global warming and the related policy responses. The exploitation of fossil fuels not only has contributed to human well-being, but has also led to increasing
20
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
environmental pressure on the earth. Currently, climate change induced by humans is one of the most important environmental problems related to the use of fossil fuels. The emission of CO2, the most important of the greenhouse gases, is a direct result of the combustion of fossil fuels. One policy response of particular interest is EE. This can be used to reduce the level of CO2 in the atmosphere by reducing the amount of fossil fuels combusted and therefore the amount of CO2 released. Together with renewable energy, transportation and forestry projects, EE is widely viewed as one of the most accessible and cost-effective opportunities to mitigate climate change. The potential scale of efforts to improve efficiency levels depends on the outcome of a global negotiation process, in which governments meet regularly to discuss issues concerning climate change. Many proposals have been discussed but there is still uncertainty regarding the implementation of policy measures, particularly at the international level. This uncertainty has so far stemmed the flow of public and private capital into climate-friendly technologies. As a result, the boom in EE activities has not materialized so far, despite the recognized potential for cost-effective projects.
1.5 Energy for a Sustainable Future The term sustainable was popularized in 1987 by the World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED), a body that became known as the Brundtland Commission.34 The concept of sustainable development has come to embody a holistic vision of societal change, including political, economic and cultural.35 The strength of the concept is that it reflects widely shared concerns about the state of the world, and that it provides a common umbrella to numerous measures aimed at improving this state.36 Sustainable development integrates the concept of nature with society and
34
The body became known as the Brundtland Commission after its leader, Gro Harlem Brundtland, who was the prime minister of Norway at that time. 35 The state of the world and the instruments for promoting sustainable development are subject of numerous publications. Some of the best known are: (a) FAO 2000, (b) Lester R. Brown et al. 2000, (c) Renner and Sampat 2002, (d) UNEP 2001, (e) UNDP 2002 (f ) UNICEF 2003, (g) World Bank 2002a and (h) WRI 2003. 36 A limitation of the concept is its operationality. As it is all-embracing countless controversies about the state of the world and what measures should be taken to improve its state exist.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
21
its three fundamental constituent parts: politics, economics and culture. Nature provides the sources of energy, which in turn enable development. Oil, a non-renewable energy source, is the outcome of prehistoric fossil disintegration and compression. A significant amount of economic activity revolves around naturally extracted forms of renewable and non-renewable forms of natural resources such as forests and coal. These factors of production and consumption form the environmental constraints for economic progress, and define the environmental aspects of sustainable development.
Politics Can we possibly meet the energy requirements of nine billion people with a prosperous lifestyle? It is feasible to solve this problem. Yet, action on this front has been anaemic. Private investment in research has declined because sufficient incentives for invention are lacking. An increase in the price of fuels to reflect the environmental and security costs associated with each might be a solution. This solution conflicts with the policy demand to keep prices low. In many countries, a mixture of incentives and regulations for automobiles and appliances has been created in the past few decades, which help reduce emission levels. However, these are often offset by production as well as supply subsidies that keep prices artificially low. Since the full cost of energy consumption is not reflected in market prices, private incentives for innovation in EE and energy supplies are well below optimum. The case in point is the abandonment of research on coal gasification (or petroleum from coal) as it is more expensive than petroleum products.
Economics Economic activities not only include wealth and prosperity in a financial sense but also the provision or protection of qualitative features, such as environmental amenities and quality of life. Some of these qualitative features can be provided by economic activities. Equally important is the challenge to prevent the economy from creating excessive externalities and damaging the quality of life. The Human Development Index and similar alternatives to the indicator of GDP attempt to capture a broader dimension of development. As the Brundtland report definition mentions, sustainable development is future oriented in its outlook and hence imposes a responsibility on today’s generations. Environmental responsibility and social equity are key dimensions. One should also explore a concept that includes a negative term for environmental losses due to economic growth
22
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
such as ‘Green Domestic Product (Green DP)’.37 Presently, the apparent gains in traditional GDP have been offset by significant losses in Green DP for a long time. If governments aim for growth, the direction of economic policies has to be changed totally. Around 2004, the Chinese government made an attempt to reflect whole cost accounting or environmental accounting in their country’s GDP. The effect lowered the country’s GDP so much that it was considered ‘politically unacceptable’. This is not to say that it should not be done but just that in the current global context it is political suicide for a country to implement it. So we have a case of environmental correctness in opposition to political expediency.
Culture An interesting aspect of the definition of the sustainable development is the attention given to local cultures and community-based decision making, a strategy that renders sustainable development less technocratic. Resource management approaches to sustainable development is a new class version of managerialism that functionally serves to globalize and perpetuate the techno-managerial elite’s control over everyday life. With increasing attention to issues of societal embedding and culture in the energy transition (for example, from use of biofuels to LPG) this situation may change, but it probably will remain problematic.
Energy for Sustainable Development Energy is the key driver of global economic development. However, a question may arise: Is the prevailing pattern of energy use and the economic development sustainable? A cursory glance at the global energy scene reveals a wide gap between actual and desired goals. To remember, the World Commission on Environment and Development defines sustainable development as something, which aims at promoting harmony among human beings and between humanity and nature.38 Further, the Commission defines sustainable energy development as meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Energy use is also related to social development in terms of improvement in quality of life, education, employment or poverty alleviation. 37 38
Hueting 1991. Brundtland 1987.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
23
Overall, to be sustainable the production and use of energy should conform to the following yardsticks—economic feasibility, social acceptability, environmental soundness and resource conservation. The World Energy Council (WEC)39 has set three principles for the sustainable development of energy—it must be accessible, available and acceptable. Accessibility to modern energy means that energy must be available at prices that are both affordable and sustainable. Then they are low enough for the poorest people, but still support the financial ability of utilities to maintain and develop their energy services by reflecting the real costs of energy production and distribution. Availability relates to long-term continuity of energy supply as well as to short-term quality of service because energy shortages are disruptive for economic development. This implies that the right energy mix relies on a well diversified portfolio of domestic or imported or regionally traded fuels and sources of energy. Acceptability is an issue for both traditional and modern energy. It covers many issues, such as deforestation, land degradation or soil acidification at the regional level, indoor or local pollution, GHG emissions and climate change, nuclear security, waste management and proliferation; and the possible negative impact of large dams or large scale modern biomass developments.
1.6 Understanding Trade-offs for a Successful Energy Policy Existing technologies and approaches can deliver significant gains in EE. However, to date, there has only been limited success in terms of adopting these technologies and approaches by industries and domestic markets. This is because, there is a general belief that inefficient practices are primarily caused by social, economic, informational and institutional actions working against a shift to more energy efficient practices. For example, there is a general acknowledgement of the fact that there are potential gains in areas other than those that directly benefit from improved energy management, but there is a limited understanding of the nature and extent of these ‘flowon’ benefits. In formulating energy policy, government agencies need to understand how to use these flow-on benefits to promote a wider adoption of energy efficient practices (Box 1.1). This requires identifying and quantifying the barriers and drivers in terms of factors such as economic growth, environment, employment and regional development. 39
WEC 2003.
24 ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE Box 1.1 Flow-on Benefits to Promote Energy Efficient Practices How do you take a 29-year old office building from a 1-star to a 4-star rating under the Australian Building Greenhouse Rating (ABGR) scheme? It has been achieved by ‘looking for better ways of doing things’. The results have been startling, with the Council’s overall electricity bill slashed from USD 1 million in 1995 to around USD 550,000 per year. This equates to greenhouse gas savings of approximately 1,303 tons, equivalent to taking 289 cars permanently off the road. The Council’s administration building alone has reduced energy costs from USD 168,000 in 1995 to USD 65,000 in 2003. If the Council had not implemented energy savings, the 2003 energy bill would have been USD 1.2 million. Installing a USD 68 movement detector in the administration building toilets has achieved a 98 per cent saving in lighting energy use. Investing USD 72,000 in power factor correction in the administration centre, art gallery and city hall has achieved savings of USD 36,000 a year by improving the building’s power factor and reducing peak demand energy load. This eliminates the electricity supplier’s penalty for poor power factor. A USD 52,000 office lighting retrofit, which replaced the inefficient control gear in 1,200 twin 4018-watt fluorescent fittings with Gold Energy low loss ballasts and single triphosphor lamps, has achieved a 47 per cent reduction in office lighting energy use and a more uniform lighting output. An added benefit of installing triphosphor lamps has been the reduced loads on the air conditioning system due to reduced lighting heat. Plus, the lamps are now changed every five years instead of every two, reducing maintenance costs. The Council also controls the 2.4kW auto boiling units and chilled water drinking fountains so that they only operate when someone turns on the lights in a particular area. This reduces the operating time by 70 per cent and greenhouse pollution by 63 tons per annum. In the underground car park, the 29.5 kW exhaust fans operated for 18 hours a day, five days a week. By installing a Variable Speed Drive (VSD) and carbon monoxide sensors at a cost of USD 35,000, the energy usage and resultant greenhouse gas emissions dropped by 89 per cent. The project had a simple payback period of 3.2 years and cut emissions by 115 tons per annum. The windows in the administration building were replaced with double-glazed smart reflector glass, which reduced the internal surface temperature of the glass by 10 degrees Celsius in summer. Many of the changes have flow-on benefits such as reduced maintenance and a better working environment. The air conditioning system was modified to include an ecocycle, which now allows the building to automatically draw on 100 per cent outside air for almost half of the year, and has resulted in a more comfortable environment. The new Building Management System (Box 1.1 Continued )
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
25
(Box 1.1 Continued ) determines when to introduce outside air. The consumption has been reduced from 2000 to 250 kWhr a day when 100 per cent fresh air is utilized. With the savings, it was possible to replace the air filtration system, which is now four times as efficient and a much better level of air quality is being enjoyed. The installation of VSDs on the main air handling fans has resulted in a significant reduction in noise levels, again adding to a better work environment. Source: Australian Building Green Rating Scheme 2001 (www.abgr.com.au)
A broader development-oriented approach is possible only if various stakeholders, namely, politicians, planners, equipment manufacturers, financial institutions and researchers begin, without delay, to channel the available human, technical and financial resources into the mass production and marketing of energy-efficient and environment-friendly technologies. This path bears the potential of providing employment opportunities, as these technologies are labour intensive. The implementation of such a system requires the reorientation of energy planning and the priorities of governments and utilities, a multiplying of research efforts for clean, renewable energy systems, and changing the mindset of consumers. Efficiency measures are, on an average, less capital-intensive per kilowatt than supply side options. Although many are aware of this truism, the knowledge about who can and should do what is lacking. Research is needed to underpin the development of national and regional strategies that will lead to greater adoption of both existing and new technologies and approaches for increasing EE. Such research will need to go further than simply identifying and describing the barriers. It will need to develop a fundamental understanding of the characteristics of these barriers so that government policy and planning agencies can design effective strategies for the implementation of solutions. It may involve the development and assessment of policies, which have the potential to promote new markets for energy-efficient practices, products or services. Further research should aim at identifying business models for commercialization of efficient technologies. The commercialization of EETs is of direct and immediate relevance to the development of government policies to promote EE government actions have the potential to facilitate a positive response by firms and businesses. Science and technology support will need to demonstrate how their proposed research will make a strategic contribution to the development of a policy that promotes uptake of energy-efficient practice by industry
26
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
and the markets. Linkages and alignment to existing policy research, and even support from the private sector may need to be developed as part of formulating a proposal. Such linkages would need to be identified clearly. It should also become clear how the research project will build on previous or current research efforts, or how it will fill gaps in national and international research findings. Project proposals should provide evidence of strategic partnerships that ensure the implementation of energy efficiency projects. The key to a successful energy policy is to achieve: z
z
Greater efficiency in energy use by consumers, due to better management of existing equipment and buildings, switching to low carbon fuels such as natural gas; New investment in plants for low carbon generation in the future; public investment geared at stimulating private investments in new technologies and infrastructure which can transform the underlying demand for services, such as transport, power, shelter, and comfort, into less intensive demands for energy. The cost of reducing emission trends varies where there are many alternatives. Many demand policies have long lead times as consumers are needed to take a new investment. Also, habits as well as institutions have high inertia.
In the light of competing claims on scarce public funds, governments and multilateral institutions are unlikely to make up for the bulk part of this gap (between need and availability of funds) through massive investments. A significant proportion of capital must come from the private sector. Even if sufficient public capital is available, it could be argued that government investment is less effective as far as the stimulation of EE is concerned than measures that create the framework conditions, which favour private sector activities in EE. In other words, governments may be more effective if they shift their emphasis from direct financing of EE to: (a) overcoming the barriers that prevent the commercialization process and (b) stimulating the drivers that promote the commercialization process. These barriers and drivers vary with each actor in the system. If each actor, such as the public, the private, the local, national and multilateral is motivated, then the whole process starts. In recent years, a number of trends have accelerated the commercialization of EETs. These trends can be referred to as drivers and include factors such as high prices for fossil fuels, technological innovation, increasing economies of scale, rising environmental awareness, growing
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
27
recognition of EE as a source of profit rather than cost, increasing investments of firms in this sector, and the prospect of stronger measures being introduced in the coming years at the national, regional and international levels in order to mitigate global warming. Any action to reinforce these drivers is likely to boost the commercialization trend.
1.7 The Role of Multilateral Institutions In order to understand the role of multilateral institutions (MIs) in financing efficiency improvements and the mitigation of environmental degradation, we need to take a glimpse at some of the international instruments put into place for tackling these issues, namely, the 1992 Rio Earth Summit and the Agenda 21, and the United Nations (UN) Millennium Declaration in September 2000. Of the many items in the Rio agenda, those relevant to this section are the financing of the development process and its derivative—the involvement of a wider number of stakeholders. In 1992, it became evident that Overseas Development Assistance (ODA) programmes were no longer sufficient to stimulate external financing in middle-and low-income countries particularly in debt-ridden sub-Saharan Africa, despite the commitment made by the developing world to devote 0.7 per cent of their gross national product (GNP) to ODA. Although the June 2001 UN Summit on Finance for Development reiterated much of the items already touched upon in Rio, it is clear that the world has become more conscious of the fact that the involvement of various stakeholders such as planners, consultants and academics from government, development agencies, private companies and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) is essential in achieving sustainable development. These actors tend to link up if they think they have something to offer and to gain. However, it is only when they clearly see a common interest that they will commit themselves substantially to a partnership by contributing material or intellectual resources. The objectives of the partners may be very different, but there can be a common interest and objectives shared by the partners. For example, a public–private partnerships (PPPs)40 is a promising option for meeting EE research needs because they tie research closely to users’ needs, provide opportunities to improve efficiency and can augment investments in research. This type of 40 The PPP is an agreement between the public and the private sector to assume coresponsibility and often co-ownership for service provision.
28
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
partnership can at best develop in a network of institutions whose activities in the energy chain are integrated. This is not the same as a privatization agreement, wherein a corporation takes full responsibility for specific services. Rather, a partnership combines the advantages of the corporate sector’s dynamism, access to finances, knowledge of emerging technologies, managerial efficiency and entrepreneurial spirit—with the job generation and service delivery concerns of the public sector and local residents. Another mechanism is the UN Millennium Declaration of September 2000. The quote below taken from this historic Declaration codifies the multiple level role of international stakeholders in future development of the world. We resolve . . . to ensure greater policy coherence and to improve better cooperation between the UN, its agencies, the Bretton Woods institutions and the World Trade Organisation (WTO), as well as other multi-lateral bodies, with a view to achieving a fully co-ordinated approach to the problems of peace and development.41
Summarizing the diverse activities of MIs, one may identify five strands of activities: z
z
z z
z
Designing and implementing projects, which already have an economic and environmental rationale today, and which would receive an additional boost if emission reduction credits were available and tradable; Financing such projects and mobilizing cofinancing from public and private sources; Project brokering, facilitation and other intermediary mechanisms; Advising governments on the legal, policy regulatory changes required for greater EE and climate change mitigation and Providing technical assistance, research and training services.
Many multilateral institutions have a stake in the EE and climate arena. The UN administers the negotiations through its Climate Change Secretariat in Bonn, Germany. Various UN agencies develop projects related to climate change. The World Bank Group develops and cofinances projects and positions itself as a facilitator through initiatives like the Prototype Carbon Fund or Biocarbon Fund. The European Union (EU) funds climate projects and, unlike the other two multilateral groups, in addition has real leverage on the negotiation process as it represents a powerful group of countries. 41
Earth Summit 2001.
ENERGY, ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
29
The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) has a small but growing portfolio of climate change projects, in particular in the area of EE. Regardless of the performance of multilateral institutions, without increased pressure from the business community and civil society organizations, there is a low probability that flexible mechanisms (such as Clean Development Mechanism [CDM]) will be implemented on a global level in the near future. Factors such as lack of scientific consensus regarding the design of these mechanisms as well as worries about economic impacts suggest that the adoption and implementation of a climate regime may be further delayed. With these delays, it seems likely that many countries will miss the Kyoto Targets agreed upon in 1997. Despite the delays and setbacks, however, the policy debate shows no sign of abating, and there are still efforts to find consensus on the modalities of a global carbon trading system. On the national and international levels, there is a trend toward experimenting with flexible mechanisms. Corporate efforts to establish trading schemes and other responses to climate change are likely to continue regardless of the near-term negotiation outcomes. Likewise, an increasing number of governments support trial schemes in their home countries to test the feasibility of trading schemes and to gauge the support of participants and stakeholders for such instruments. Through trial and error, these corporate and government programmes provide the experience necessary to make carbon trading feasible on a larger scale. In many countries, including China, India and Japan, policy initiatives are gradually establishing a legal and regulatory basis for trading greenhouse gas reduction credits. At the same time, new technologies are entering the marketplace, and existing ones are becoming better and cheaper. Taken together, increasing prevalence of corporate initiatives, technological advances and regulatory changes add up to a dynamic environment, to which institutions involved in EE and climate change mitigation must constantly adjust.
1.8 Post Script Regarding the principles of sustainable development, creating an energy system and making it acceptable to all is of paramount importance. This creates a huge ethical problem. A rich person in a developed country can complain bitterly about the way poor countries are allowing their environment to be destroyed by economic development. On the contrary, a poor
30
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
person in a developing country, ever doubtful about getting food, health care and education, would leap with joy at any improvement in the situation, and would not care for any environmental damage unless it affects his livelihood. How do we balance the short-term benefits to the population with the long-term interests of preserving the environment? And who do we think are the decision makers? Do the poor get a democratic vote? Do the rich and powerful decide? Another issue is the role of policies and political will. If EE policies are promoted, they will have a significant impact on energy growth and thereby on economic development. There can also be disastrous policies—a war can destroy the entire energy infrastructure thereby reducing energy use. The question therefore is: how much leverage can we give to constructive policies, say to avoid climate change? This is neither a technical issue nor an economic analysis, but one of analysis of the exercise of political power. How can governmental policies influence EE directions? These are the issues that need to be discussed and debated. The advantage of the EE approach is that it looks at real needs and at real human development. It aims for a useful value for the consumer. An EE approach can fit into the ‘livelihood’ approach. However, the reverse may not be true. For this we have to analyze dispassionately where the good niches exist and where the obstacles lie, both technically and institutionally. We need to study EE approaches around the world that have succeeded and failed, and to draw lessons from those about the way to proceed.
2 Climate Debate
For more than two decades, scientific and political communities have debated whether and how to act on climate change. This chapter synthesizes these long standing debates in two sections. The first section provides an overview of the development of international climate policy. The second section discusses clashing positions represented by sceptics and supporters of action on climate change.
2.1 Introduction At the beginning of the 21st century, the dispute on climate change continues to be hotly contested, but much of the disagreement has shifted from the scientific certainty of climate change to identifying appropriate policy responses. While most scientists agree that there is a significant human influence on the climate, a handful continues to insist that the observed warming is not a trend into the future, but merely a sign of natural climate variability. The debate centres on the causes and consequences of climate change, and what, if anything, should be done to mitigate the emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs). At least three general policy responses can be distinguished: The first response is focused intervention to minimize the negative impacts on the environment. An important consideration is to ‘avoid cures that may be worse than the disease’. The second response is adaptation, which some economists prefer because the measures would be taken in the future and
32
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
their discounted present cost is lower. This policy is controversial, however, because it does not prevent or mitigate climate change. The third type of policy response is prevention. This is promoted mainly by environmentalists, and requires immediate investments to prevent future damages.1 In the debate on climate change mitigation, we can distinguish two main groups, which may be referred to as sceptics and supporters. While the sceptics generally do not want to take action or want to postpone measures on climate change, the supporters claim that action is needed now. The categorization into two groups is simplified because there is quite significant variation within these broad camps.2 Before the clashing positions on climate change are introduced, the emerging political environment is outlined.
2.2 A Brief History of Climate Policy The question of how climate change might affect human activities appeared on the international agenda in 1979 at the World Climate Conference (WCC).3 The conference issued a declaration calling on the world’s governments ‘(…) to foresee and prevent potential man-made changes in 1
Schneider and Rickel 2002. It can be argued that it is problematic to use the categorization of sceptics and supporters because it is too difficult to capture the complexity of the issue and the diversity of viewpoints by categorizing the debate into two camps. This caveat is important, but it is equally valid to argue that even very differentiated views on climate change will ultimately have to decide upon basic dualistic questions that divide sceptics and supporters, such as whether climate change is influenced by human activities (yes/no), whether climate change will have serious impacts in the future (yes/no), whether governments shall spend money on avoiding climate change (yes/no), and so on. The answers to such questions determine which basic category the respondent belongs to, which still allows for the fact that there can be significant variation within each category. 3 The term ‘climate change’ is preferable to ‘global warming’. The latter refers to the observed heating of the earth’s atmosphere; whereas ‘climate change’ refers to a broader set of alterations in climate patterns, which include warming as well as cooling trends and other meteorological changes. Although some of the changes could be explained as natural climate variability, there is an increasing scientific consensus that climate change in recent history has been increasingly caused by human activities, including the burning of fossil fuels, deforestation and industrial activities such as cement production. These and other anthropogenic activities result in the emissions of GHGs, including carbon dioxide (CO2), chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) and water vapour. Of these gases, carbon dioxide accounts for more than 90 per cent of GHG emissions. About three quarters of annual CO2 emissions result from burning fossil fuels including coal, oil and natural gas (IEA 1997a). 2
CLIMATE DEBATE
33
climate that might be adverse to the well-being of humanity.’4 Following this conference, it took many years with further meetings and initiatives before the international community was able to agree on initial steps to deal with the problem.5 In 1988, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) established the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) with the mandate ‘(…) to assess on a comprehensive, objective, open and transparent basis the scientific, technical and socio-economic information relevant to understanding the scientific basis of risk of human-induced climate change, its potential impacts and options for adaptation and mitigation’.6 The IPCC is a scientific body that includes 2,500 scientists, including eight Nobel laureates. Since its establishment, the Panel released four Assessment Reports in 1990, 1995, 2001 and 2007 (released recently), which summarized the state of scientific knowledge available at that time. These reports formulated a consensus opinion while pointing to areas that are uncertain or controversial and needed further research. In its First Assessment Report released in 1990, the Panel expressed concerns about the growing evidence of a human impact on climate change.7 The report was influential for the development of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), which was adopted at the Earth Summit in 1992.8 In this non-binding document, 154 countries, plus the European Community, agreed on the ‘(…) stabilization of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system’.9 To achieve this goal, the countries were divided into two groups: the developed (Annex I) countries were encouraged to cut their emissions of GHGs back to the 1990 levels, while the remaining countries did not have to commit to such reductions, following a principle of ‘(…) common but differentiated 4
UNEP and UNFCCC 2002, Information Sheet 17. According to UNEP and UNFCCC (2002), the key events were the Villach Conference (October 1985), the Toronto Conference (June 1988), the Ottawa Conference (February 1989), the Tata Conference (February 1989), the Hague Conference (March 1989), the Noordwijk Ministerial Conference (November 1989), the Cairo Compact (December 1989), the Bergen Conference (May 1990) and the Second World Climate Conference (November 1990). 6 IPCC 2003, 2007c. 7 Houghton et al. 1990. 8 The Convention entered into force on 21 March 1994, 90 days after the receipt of the 50th instrument of ratification (see UNEP and UNFCCC 2002). An international convention must be ratified by national parliaments in order to be valid under national law. 9 UNFCCC, Article 2. 5
34
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
responsibilities (…)’.10 In practice, differentiated responsibilities meant that developed countries were obliged to assume leadership in efforts to mitigate climate change.11 Another significant tenet in the UNFCCC is the precautionary principle.12 Article 3 of the Convention describes the notion as follows: ‘Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason for postponing such measures.’13 Science may never be able to predict exactly what will happen and where, but it can ‘(…) provide scenarios and assess the probabilities and consequences of various plausible alternatives.’14 According to the precautionary principle, policy decisions must be made under uncertainty when there is a risk of catastrophic damage. Also, the precautionary principle suggests that many segments of the private sector may be better off if serious costs are avoided by adopting precautionary measures. According to Franklin Nutter, the president of the Reinsurance Association of America, ‘The insurance business is first in line to be affected by climate change. It is clear that global warming could bankrupt the industry.’15 The development of the UNFCCC and other international environmental treaties was accompanied by the establishment of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) as a joint venture of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), (UNEP) and the World Bank. For the past 12 years, the GEF has been one of the main sources of international funding for clean energy and other measures to address climate change. The GEF does not implement environmental projects itself, but it provides grants and concessional funds for projects. Apart from climate change, the GEF also funds projects in areas, such as biological diversity, international waters and the depletion of the ozone layer. The purpose of the GEF is to fund reduction and adaptation measures both in countries in transition and in developing countries.16 According to Martinot and McDoom: GEF climate change projects represent an emerging body of experimental, caseoriented information on innovative approaches to promoting energy efficiency 10
UNFCCC, Article 3 This is the first of five guiding principles laid down in Article 3 of the UNFCCC. 12 The precautionary principle is also discussed in Section 12.2.2. 13 UNFCCC, Article 3 14 Schneider and Rickel 2002. 15 Innovest 2002a, 15. 16 Martinot and McDoom 2000, 16. 11
CLIMATE DEBATE
35
and renewable energy technologies in developing countries and countries in transition. Although much project information exists in published and electronic form, no systematic review of these projects exists.17
Since its establishment in 1991, GEF has allocated more than USD 4 billion in grants and mobilized a further USD 12 billion in co-financing. So far, more than 1,000 projects have been supported by the GEF in transition economies and in developing countries. The GEF is supported by a large number of governments, which replenish the funds every three to four years. At the latest replenishment in August 2002, almost USD 3 billion were pledged to finance GEF activities until 2006.18 Although USD 3 billion is a significant sum, it translates to less than USD 1 billion a year, which is spread across many countries and multiple environmental problems. To assess the level of funding, compare USD 1 billion, for example, to USD 80 billion provided by the US Congress in March 2003 as a first instalment for the war in Iraq. In light of the scale and severity of global environmental problems, GEF funds by themselves cannot make a major difference. Since it is unlikely that governments will dramatically increase their allocations for the global environment in the foreseeable future, greater priority must be placed on devising ways to mobilize private capital to complement public funding. A strong regulatory framework can help increase private financing of sustainable development by providing clear signals and by reducing regulatory uncertainty. However, it appears that the current frameworks are woefully inadequate. Although 186 countries have so far ratified the UNFCCC19 since its adoption in 1992, the goal of limiting emissions in 2,000 to the 1990 levels was not achieved, mainly because the Convention was not binding. At the Rio meeting, a process was put in place to strengthen the regime over time. The participants agreed that the supreme decision making body of the UNFCCC and the Conference of the Parties (COP) would meet regularly to discuss further steps to mitigate climate change. At its first session, which took place in Berlin in 1995, the COP concluded that the 1992 UNFCC commitments were insufficient and that there was a need to establish compulsory targets. In December 1995, just in time for COP2, the IPCC released its ‘Second Assessment Report’, which was written and reviewed by about 2,000 scientists. The report reaffirmed that ‘(…) the
17
Martinot and McDoom 2000, 12. GEF n.d. 19 UNFCCC 2003. 18
36
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
balance of evidence suggests that there is a discernible human influence on the global climate’. The report also noted ‘(…) the availability of the socalled no-regrets options and other cost-effective strategies for combating climate change’.20 The confirmation of the evidence on climate change galvanized policy 21 makers into action. The Kyoto Protocol was adopted on 11 December 1997 at the COP3. The Protocol for the first time set legally binding emission targets for a group of countries listed in Annex I. In Article 3 of the Protocol, Annex I countries committed to reduce their emissions of GHGs by at least 5 per cent below the 1990 level by the years 2008–2012.22 Individual commitments differ from this guideline in both directions. The 5 per cent group target would be achieved through the following cuts: z
z
z
Eight per cent by Switzerland, most Central and Eastern European states, and the European Union (EU). The EU will meet its group target by distributing different rates among its member states; Seven per cent by the US which in 2001 withdrew from the Kyoto Protocol; and Six per cent by Canada, Hungary, Japan and Poland.
In contrast, Russia, New Zealand and Ukraine are to stabilize their emissions, while Norway may increase emissions by up to 1 per cent, Australia by up to 8 per cent, and Iceland by up to 10 per cent.23 The Kyoto Protocol focuses on six GHGs: carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs) and sulphur hexafluoride (SF6). These gases are to be combined in a basket, with reductions in each gas translated into CO2 equivalents that are then added up to produce a single figure.24 According to Article 25 of the Kyoto Protocol, the agreement becomes valid:
20
UNEP and UNFCCC 2002, Information Sheet 17. The full name is The Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. 22 Emission reductions need not be achieved by a fixed year, but the average of the committed five-year period will determine whether the Kyoto targets are achieved. 23 A list of reduction commitments of the parties can be found in Annex B to the Kyoto Protocol. 24 The concept Global Warming Potential (GWP) is used to calculate CO2 equivalents according to the IPCC methodology (see IPCC 1995). 21
CLIMATE DEBATE
37
(…) on the ninetieth day after the date on which not less than 55 Parties to the Convention, incorporating Annex I Parties, which account for at least 55 per cent of the total carbon dioxide emissions for 1990 from that group, have deposited their instruments of ratification, acceptance, approval or accession.25
In March 2001, the United States, which represents about one quarter of global carbon dioxide emissions, withdrew from the Protocol. As of April 2003, 84 Parties had signed and 106 Parties had ratified or acceded to the Kyoto Protocol. This meant that the Protocol has 43.9 per cent in disposition. With the United States’ withdrawal, Russia’s ratification became pivotal for reaching the 55 per cent threshold for bringing the Protocol into force. The ‘Third Assessment Report’, which was published in 2001, reported the findings from three task forces: Working Group I dealt with the evidence on climate change, Working Group II focused on possible consequences and Working Group III examined mitigation options. The models of Working Group I found that in the course of the 20th century ‘globally averaged surface temperatures’ have risen 0.6°C, with a margin of error of ± 0.2°C. According to the IPCC Special Report on Emission Scenarios (SRES), the globally averaged surface air temperature is projected to increase between 1.4°C and 5.8°C by 2100 relative to the 1990 levels.26 The Working Group II identified different scenarios for the potential consequences that could follow from the range of projected increases in temperature. It also presented the consensus of the group as to their level of confidence with its predictions. The Working Group II confirmed that overall harmful impacts of climate change are likely to overshadow positive impacts. One prediction is that, as a result of the melting of the polar icecaps, the volume of the world’s oceans will increase, probably somewhere between 0.09 and 0.88 metres by 2100. The result could be coastal flooding that may dislocate up to several hundred million people world-wide. Other possible consequences of climate change include more frequent and extreme weather-related events, such as heat waves, droughts, fires, floods and storms, which could damage economies and result in negative impacts on human health. The scientists in Working Group II notes that a rise: (…) in the frequency or intensity of heat waves will increase the risk of mortality and morbidity, principally in older age groups and the urban poor 25 26
UNFCC 2003. IPCC 2001b, 2007c.
38
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE (high confidence) (…). Any regional increases in climate extremes (storms, floods, cyclones, and so on) associated with climate change would cause physical damage, population displacement, and adverse effects on food production, freshwater availability and quality, and would increase the risks of infectious disease epidemics, particularly in developing countries (very high confidence/ well established).27
While shifting climate zones could exacerbate food shortages, climate change could also bring localized benefits to some regions, for example, the potential to grow wheat in Siberia. Alexander Bedritski and Yuri Israel, climate scientists in Russia, argue that a warming trend would be beneficial for their country. According to their model, Russia will enjoy high yields of potatoes and grains and thus the nation’s welfare will be increased.28 Working Group III, which assesses various climate change mitigation options, concluded that a wide range of policy instruments should be considered in order to stimulate participation of various stakeholders in climate change mitigation. Firms and financial institutions are among the main stakeholders to be targeted by policy measures. The IPCC experts believe that a broad selection of instruments enlarges the number of noregrets options and help to fit policies to short-, medium- and long-term goals.29 The Working Group estimated that about half of the total GHG emissions reductions attained by 2020 could be profitable, based on discount rates ranging from 5 to 12 per cent, which are in line with public sector discount rates.30 At the same time, they note that ‘Private internal rates of return vary greatly, and are often significantly higher, affecting the rate of adoption of these technologies by private entities.’31 The third volume of the fourth assessment report of the IPCC has been approved on 4 May 2007. According to the report, between 1970 and 2004, global emissions of CO2, CH4, N2O, HFCs, PFCs and SF6, weighted by their GWP, have increased by 70 per cent, from 28.7 to 49 Gigatons of carbon dioxide equivalents. The largest growth in global GHG emissions has come from the energy supply sector (an increase of 145 per cent); transport, 120 per cent; industry 65 per cent; and land use; land use change and forestry 40 per cent. A range of policies, including those on climate 27
IPCC 2001c. (chapter 2.2.2, page 2). Brown 2003. 29 IPCC 1995. 30 As we will note in the next chapter, public sector discount rates are controversial in the climate area. 31 IPCC 2001a, 2007b. 28
CLIMATE DEBATE
39
change, energy security, and sustainable development, have been effective in reducing GHG emissions in different sectors and in many countries. The scale of such measures, however, has not yet been large enough to counteract the global growth in emissions. The report,32 which is a consensus document put together by 600 scientists and agreed by representatives of 113 countries, predicts continued warming of 0.2 °C per decade for the coming few decades. Over the 21st century it predicts a range of 1.1–2.9 °C warming in a scenario with low emissions of greenhouse gases, and 2.4–6.4 °C in a high-emissions scenario. The warming is expected to be the greatest over land, and the chance of heat wave increasing in frequency is greater than 90 per cent.33 The IPCC suggested enhancing the consideration of cross cutting issues, to involve more scientists from developing nations and economies in transition and to use more un-English literature. The IPCC also recommended developing better interactions with industrial and NGO sectors to help mobilize private capital for climate change mitigation in furtherance of the IGCC and Kyoto Protocol goals of achieving cost-effective emissions reductions.
2.3 Clashing Positions on Climate Change Sceptics The sceptics include, at one extreme, those who see climate change as a hoax inflated by media and who maintain that the only sensible solution is to do nothing. According to the supporters they misjudge the risks of climate change by making selective use of evidence. Backed by the fossil fuel lobby and its allies in the media, they endeavour to deflect attention from the emerging consensus in the scientific community. However, not all sceptics can be described as extreme and not everyone serves as a mouthpiece for the fossil fuel lobby. There are other groups of sceptics who do not discount the possibility of serious consequences of climate change, but who also believe that the cost of taking action now is higher than that of not taking action. One prominent sceptic, Wilfred Beckerman, expressed this position 32
The report provides an overall scientific view on climate change that integrates and synthesizes information from the three volumes around six topic areas that include: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability and mitigation of climate change. 33 IPCC 2007b.
40
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
when he claimed that ‘Global warming is no cause for alarm or dramatic action. If dramatic action were taken, the effects on human welfare would be horrendous—even more horrendous perhaps than the effects of global 34 warming itself.’ In 1995, the Leipzig Declaration on Global Climate Change was signed by about one hundred scientists, stating that ‘Costly actions undertaken to reduce greenhouse emissions are not justified by the available scientific evidence.’35 Since climate modelling is not always precise, sceptics argue that it cannot serve as a basis for strong policy measures. John Christy, a professor of atmospheric science at the University of Alabama, notes that ‘Reports are filled with ifs, maybes and coulds’. What we do know is that 36 the climate varies naturally.’ Often the disbelief in climate science is rooted within a scepticism of the environmental movement—a reaction against inroads made by environmental ideas into mainstream policy. Mary Hager describes the lingering doubts about the conventional wisdom among those individuals who disagree with the general scientific consensus about the environment: What if global warming does not loom on the horizon, or if seasonal stratospheric ozone layer depletion is part of a natural cycle and not the creation of human created chemicals? What if pesticides really promote a more abundant and varied food supply for the world without causing cancer and ail in children? Or if hazards from abandoned wastes have been blown out of proportion?37
While a group of sceptics claim that global warming merely is a figment of imagination, more moderate groups recognize that there has been a warming trend and that this trend is likely to continue into the future. Some sceptics acknowledge that, based on the cumulative evidence, there could be serious consequences in the long run. Still, they argue that 34 Beckerman 1996. Wilfred Beckerman has been one of the favourite targets of environmentalists ever since he published the book Two Cheers for the Affluent Society: A Spirited Defence of Economic Growth (1974) in response to Donella Meadows et al., The Limits to Growth (1972) and other early environmental literature. 35 Smith 1997, 2. The Leipzig Declaration has been discounted by the fact that only a few signatories are considered respected scientists in the field (Jensen 1998). Given that hundreds of scientists work on every IPCC Assessment Report, and those contributions from sceptics are welcome, the results of these reports are generally more trusted than findings produced by individuals or relatively small groups, especially those whose objectivity is questioned because of conflicts of interest (EMS 2003). 36 GCC 2001. 37 Hager 1993, 10.
CLIMATE DEBATE
41
predictions about future warming and the consequences associated with climate change are often exaggerated, and that the GHG theory is not the only plausible explanation of observed warming trends. For example, James Hansen, Makiko Sato and Reto Ruedy argue that too much emphasis has been placed on carbon dioxide, but they do not discount the possibility of CO2 being an important contributing cause to climate change.38 More the research conducted, the easier it becomes to support any position with evidence. Sceptics can point to an increasing number of studies on global warming that are inconclusive, while avoiding or disparaging conclusive studies. The moderates within the spectrum of sceptics are careful not to dismiss well-established facts, so as not to lose credibility. However, they emphasize evidence that undermines the impetus for policy action, and they point to real or perceived weaknesses in the research of their opponents. The European Science and Environment Forum for instance states that ‘Solar output and sunspot activity could well have played a major role in climate change as observed over the last century’,39 adding that there is a lack of ‘(…) firm geological evidence to support global warming’.40 Another sceptic, Patrick Michaels, explains the extremely hot summer of 1998 as ‘(…) the result of a strong El Nino superimposed on a decade in which temperature continues to reflect a warming that largely took place in the first half of this century’.41 In a congressional testimony, Michaels argued that future warming would be ‘(…) relatively modest (…)’42 and that forecasts of future impacts on ‘(…) ecosystems, health and the economy are based on old models which are in error’.43 Academic sceptics are supported by activists in anti-environmental groups. Jim Baca describes the movement ‘People for the West!’ whose members are engaged in grassroots mobilization by going door to door with petitions in rural and minority communities in the United States, by calling people, and by writing letters.44 According to Michael Bruner and Max Oelschlaeger, sceptics are successful due to ‘(…) their ability to articulate persuasive rationales through slogans, myths and narratives’.45 These narratives are disseminated through friendly media. Eileen Claussen, president of the Pew Center, a climate change research institute, argues that 38
Hansen et al. 2000. Landscheidt 2003. 40 Greenpeace n.d. 41 Michaels 1998, 1. 42 Michaels 1995. 43 Ibid. 44 Baca 1995, 54. 45 Bruner and Oelschlaeger 1994, 379. 39
42
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
the Wall Street Journal is an influential source of such myths. To illustrate her point, Claussen cites following from the Wall Street Journal:46 Why require the nations of this planet to spend the hundreds of billions of dollars necessary to reduce carbon dioxide and other emissions when we don’t even know if the earth’s climate is getting permanently hotter or if that temperature change is caused by human activity or if that change is even dangerous?
In the United States, many sceptics, including the members of antienvironmental movements, are closely linked to the Republican Party, which increased their rhetoric and activism after the elections in 1994.47 Enraged by the signature of the Kyoto Protocol in December 1997, the conservative networks within the Republican Party engineered a withdrawal from the Protocol in 2001. President George W. Bush, who is ideologically close to these groups, preferred to face the wrath of the international community rather than to act against his own sources of support. In the words of one prominent sceptic, Charlie Coon, The President was right to let the international community know that the United States would be walking away from the Kyoto Protocol and to direct his Cabinet Secretaries to conduct a thorough review of climate change policies. Other countries should follow the President’s lead and refuse to ratify it. To do otherwise is short-sighted and, in the long run, will prove to be both environmentally and economically damaging.48
Sceptics and supporters base their arguments on different estimates of the cost of compliance with the Kyoto Protocol. Sceptics point to pessimistic scenarios, such as one developed by the Energy Information Administration (EIA), which showed that it would cost the United States 4.2 per cent of GDP to comply with Kyoto. Supporters cite more optimistic scenarios such as one conducted by the Council of Economic Advisers, which predicted that it would cost 1 per cent of GDP. 49 Sceptics suggest postponing action until there is greater certainty about the causes and consequences of climate change. They argue that it makes no sense to rush for ‘short-term’ Kyoto targets, and that it is better to wait until the market itself will force out carbon-intensive fossil fuels and will favour the use of more environmentally 46
Claussen 2002. Tokar 1995, 152. 48 Coon 2001b, 9–10. 49 For a comprehensive discussion on economic dimensions of climate change, see Tietenberg (1996). 47
CLIMATE DEBATE
43
friendly fuels and energy-efficient technologies.50 Some scientists insist on letting the process of GHG emissions stabilization last for about 100 years. In their opinion such an approach will not harm the US and the global economy and will bring environmental benefits.51 Sceptics and lobbyists who strive to prevent action on climate change further are supported by groups in academia and by think tanks such as the Cato Institute, the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute. Together with lobby organizations such as the Global Climate Coalition (GCC), this network develops the intellectual foundation for antienvironmentalism, and the justification for advising against ‘premature’ and ‘imprudent’ action.52 Resistance also comes from powerful industrial leaders and government officials, including cabinet level members in the Bush Administration with links to the fossil fuel industry such as Vice President Richard Cheney and Secretary of Defence Donald Rumsfeld. Much is at stake. A transition to renewable forms of energy and greater energy efficiency would make industries and markets react. The countries of OPEC (Organisation for Petroleum Exporting Countries) stand to lose most from the commercialization of clean energy technologies.53 Apart from a loss of revenue due to expanding alternative energy markets, the Kyoto sanctioning mechanisms for non-compliance could lead to a welfare decrease in the OPEC region.54 To prevent this, influential personalities such as Donald Pearlman, former official in the Reagan and Bush administration and Brian P. Flannery, Exxon, have been working to protect OPEC interests.55 Most scientists prefer to stay out of the politically charged ‘Greenhouse Wars’,56 which are less about science than about the quest for economic power. But it is difficult to avoid getting drawn into the battle. Many sceptics and supporters appear comfortable in the dual role of scientists and advocates. The main problem, however, is of economic nature. Scientists are dependent on research funds, and not all funding is free of political and economical interests.57 They realize that unless they become effective advocates, they can easily be ‘(…) over-ruled by the other stakeholders’.58 50
See Van Doren 1999. Walker et al. 1996. 52 The Global Climate Coalition (GCC) was one of the most outspoken and confrontational industry groups in the United States battling reductions in GHG emissions. 53 Yeh 1997. 54 Hagem et al. 2003. 55 EMS 2003. 56 Pearce 1997. 57 See for example Gelbspan 1995 and Collier 1997. 58 Greenpeace n.d. 51
44
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Supporters Many supporters of action on climate change agree with sceptics that the climate is influenced by multiple contributing factors, including natural causes. Without adopting a mono-causal point of view, many supporters nonetheless argue that the theory of human influence on the climate is well established. They also believe that many consequences of climate change, although not certain, are documented so well already that it would be irresponsible to wait for action. Hence the main issue for supporters is not whether to do something about climate change, but what to do about the problem. The debate centres on the effectiveness, cost and ethical appropriateness of various courses of action.59 While some supporters favour command and control mechanisms, such as regulated limits on GHG emissions, others would like to rely on economic instruments, such as for instance carbon taxes and market-based mechanisms such as emission trading. There is much debate on the role of the private sector in problem solving. Some believe that the private sector is crucial for any solution, while others question the motives of private actors. Many supporters agree that civil society should play a role in problem solving as well. And some argue that lasting solutions to environmental problems require more fundamental transformation, including changes in economic structures, the media and education.60 While some pessimists claim that it is already too late to take effective action on climate change, the majority argues that it is not too late to mitigate future damages. Supporters believe that if nothing is done, serious consequences are unavoidable, including rising sea levels, more extreme weather events, disruption of agriculture and impaired health. All of this could lead to major reductions in economic well-being and quality of life.61 To support their call for action, supporters refer to evidence of serious impacts. A report prepared by Innovest for the UNEP shows that banks, insurances and other businesses have already incurred significant losses due to climate change, and that these losses are likely to multiply if global warming is left unchecked. The report notes that global economic damages associated 59 For an interesting debate on ethics, see Michael Sandel’s editorial It’s Immoral to Buy the Right to Pollute, which was published in the New York Times on 15 December 1997 following the signature of the Kyoto Protocol, including the replies from Robert Stavins, Steven Shavell, Sanford Gains and Eric Maskin published on 17 December 1997. 60 For an analysis of the differing views on climate action and the Kyoto Protocol, see Jacoby et al. 1998. 61 See IPCC 2001c.
CLIMATE DEBATE
45
with natural catastrophes have approximately doubled every 10 years, reaching almost USD 1 trillion in the course of the past 15 years. Annual weather-related disasters have quadrupled compared to 40 years ago; and insurance payouts have increased by a factor of 11, rising to an average of USD 10 billion annually during the 1990s. If we extrapolate these trends into the future, yearly losses will increase to almost USD 150 billion in the next decade.62 Table 2.1 lists the number of great weather-related disasters and the increase of economic and insured losses in the period from 1950 until 2001. Figure 2.1 illustrates the steeply increasing cost curve, which is believed to be at least partly related to climate change. The figure depicts the economic and insured losses and some of the projections and risks associated with climate change and their impacts on the ecosystem and human activity. However, care should be taken to correctly estimate the rate and scale of these losses since it may result in either too little attention and significant human costs or too much cost for unneeded preventative measures. Figure 2.2 shows the trend in annual frequency of great natural catastrophes between 1950 and 2004. It enables to understand the type of hazard and estimate the number of people that might suffer consequences. The results can be used to determine options for reducing or eliminating risks. Based on the numbers as shown in Table 2.2 pessimists among the supporters claim that the reduction of greenhouse gases will not always bring the intended results. For example, there may be little improvement with regard to the decline of forest areas or the number of malaria incidences, which are key areas of concern in relation to anthropogenic warming.63 However, the possibility of reducing GHC emissions not leading to rapid results cannot be used as an argument for doing nothing. The key issue Table 2.1 Great Weather Disasters, 1950–2001 Year 1950–59 1960–69 1970–79 1980–89 1990–99 Last 10 years: 1992–2001 Source: Innovest 2002a, 7. 62 63
Innovest 2002a, 6. Dorf 2001, 468.
Number
Economic losses
13 16 29 44 72 64
41.2 54.1 79.4 126.1 425.4 362.0
Insured losses – 7.2 11.5 23.0 98.9 79.3
Source: Munich Re 2004.
Figure 2.1 Trends in Economic and Insured Losses, 1950–2004 46 ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Source: Munich Re 2004.
Figure 2.2 Trend in Annual Frequency of Great Natural Catastrophes, 1950–2004
CLIMATE DEBATE 47
2060 for baseline. > 2100 for climate change
2050 2060 2100 2060 2100 2060 or 2100
Agricultural production
Global forest area Malaria incidence
Decrease 25–30 (+) %, relative to 1990 500 million 500 million Varies Varies Not applicable
Must increase 83%, relative to 1990
Baseline (includes impacts of environmental problems other than climate change)
64
Impacts of climate change, on top of the baseline Net global production would change –2.4% to +1.1%; but could substantially redistribute production from developing to developed countries Reduced loss of global forest area 25 to 40 million additional cases 50 to 80 million additional cases < 25 cm < 50 cm Unknown whether magnitudes or frequencies of occurrence will increase or decrease
Reprinted from Dorf 2001, 468 with permission from Elsevier Science and Cambridge University Press.
Sources: Dorf 2001, 468, referring to Goklany 1998, 2000 and IPCC 1996.64
Extreme weather events
Sea level rise
Year
Climate-sensitive sector/indicator
Impact/effect
Table 2.2 Projected Climate Change Impacts Compared to Other Environmental Problems
48 ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATE DEBATE
49
is the uncertainty about the absorption capacity of ecological systems and the threshold at which such systems collapse. Richard Dorf argues that ‘(…) climate change on top of the other environmental problems may be the straw that breaks the camel’s back, particularly with respect to forests, ecosystems, and biodiversity, which suggests that immediate action ought to be taken to curtail GHG emissions’.65 If one compares the arguments of sceptics with those of supporters, one finds little common ground. In what follows, five issues will be analyzed to show how supporters differ from sceptics. Two further issues, the cost of climate change mitigation and the choice of discount rate, are discussed in the next chapter.
Scientific Knowledge In general, sceptics and supporters agree that there is a need for more knowledge on climate change, but they disagree on how much certainty has been achieved already, and how much is needed. Supporters believe that there is a sufficient basis of established facts to justify measures on climate change now. George Marshall argues that waiting for a complete scientific understanding will not be accepted as an excuse by future generations affected by global warming. Moreover, he states that ‘(…) there is far more certainty about climate change than there is about many other aspects of science on which policy decisions are routinely made’.66 Sceptics and supporters concur on the need to improve models designed to predict the course and consequences of climate change.
Alternative Explanations of Climate Change Supporters are not convinced about most alternative explanations of observed warming trends forwarded by sceptics. For example, supporters argue that there are not sufficient data to support the conclusion that the warming is due to sunspot activity, since satellite monitoring of the sun started not until the late 1970s.67 They also point out that the warming cannot be explained by the theory of long-run fluctuations, as going by this theory, the world would currently be in a cooling phase. They recall that in the 1970s, some scientists were concerned about the prospect of global cooling. 65
Ibid., 469–70. Marshall 2006. 67 Collier 1997. 66
50
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The Precautionary Principle Supporters advocate the application of the precautionary principle. This principle is considered necessary for environmental and health damage prevention in a forward-looking society. The precautionary principle was first applied in Germany in the 1970s. Later on, it was incorporated into international agreements, including the Bergen Declaration on Sustainable Development and the UNFCCC. In January 1998, the Wingspread Conference on the precautionary principle concluded that ‘(…) if a practice seems likely to harm the environment, even if proof of harm is not definitive, actions should be taken to eliminate or control the practice’.68 In the words of Raffensperger and Tickner, the precautionary principle is ‘(…) a tool with ethical power and scientific rigor’.69 One way to motivate ‘(…) the public and policy-makers to take preventative action in the face of possible climate change’ is to raise public awareness of health impacts’.70 According to Innovest, precaution is one of three fundamental principles, on which the evolving international policy framework should be based.71 A message for the industrial and the financial sector is that destructive impacts of climate change can have global implications and can affect any area of business activity. While four out of five business leaders from the top 500 companies are aware of financial risks caused by climate change, only two out of five are taking relevant steps to hedge possible threats and to make use of potential opportunities.72 The main areas of business involvement are emission trading mechanisms and greater investments in clean power technology. In this respect, a wide array of actions is developed specifically for policy makers, market regulators, commercial bank managers and other key decision makers.73 The main recommendations can be summed up as follows:
Trade-offs Many supporters are willing to countenance tradeoffs between a better environment and health on one side and wealth on the other side. Some 68
Maret 2000. Raffensperger and Tickner 1999. 70 Long and Iles 1997, 45. 71 Innovest 2002a. 72 Innovest 2003. 73 Innovest 2002b. 69
CLIMATE DEBATE
51
supporters believe that developing countries need to make trade-offs between growth and a cleaner environment. Others believe that developing countries have an opportunity to leapfrog developed countries in terms of adopting cleaner technologies as a basis for development. The notion of leapfrogging over old technologies may be the best way to make action on climate change palatable to developing countries. These countries are and will remain concerned primarily about economic growth. As Thomas Schelling wrote, ‘The Chinese, Indonesians or Bangladeshis are not going to divert resources from their own development to reduce the greenhouse effect.’74
Benefits of Climate Change Supporters and sceptics agree about localized benefits and that some regions may become richer due to increased yield of crops. Nevertheless, they are not convinced that these benefits will outweigh the costs for any country, and much less for the world as a whole. Ute Collier writes that some agricultural plants, such as wheat, rice and soy beans, the so-called C3 plants, can be shown to thrive on greater concentrations of CO2 in laboratory experiments. She cautions, however, that: (…) levels of temperature and precipitation are also crucial and combined effects may be negative in some areas. Also, some important crop plants (C4 species, such as maize, sorghum and sugar cane) are less responsive to higher CO2 levels and are likely to suffer from water shortages and increased soil parching in a warmer climate.75
As regards the perspective of growing wheat in Siberia, a recent report by scientists from Moscow State University, the Russian Academy of Science and Kassel University in Germany highlights the weaknesses and omissions that produced such a promising forecast for Russia. The report indicates that warming in Russia is likely to bring droughts and bad harvests to 15 southern and western regions, which used to be the country’s granary. Some regions will suffer from flooding, while others will experience shortages of water. Some 77 million people may be negatively affected by 2020, and this number is forecast to increase to 141 million by 2070.76 74
Schelling 1997, 8. Collier 1997. 76 Brown 2003. 75
52
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Climate Realists Between climate change supporters and sceptics, there has been a tiny minority of analysts who are convinced of the urgency of the problem while remaining profoundly sceptical of the proposed solutions. Most of them are from developing countries and their voices have largely gone unheard. The data about emissions show (Figure 2.3) that developed countries (Annex 1) emit far more than that of developing countries (non-Annex 1). Global emissions, on per capita emissions, increased from 0.01 metric tons in 1800 to 1.2 tons in 2005. Average per capita emissions were 8.4 tons of carbon dioxide in the EU-15 and 19.7 tons in USA. Despite their faster growth in emissions, developing countries such as those from Asia still emit a lot fewer emissions (on a per capita basis) than countries from Europe and North America. Per capita emissions from China were 2.6 tons and for Figure 2.3 Per capita CO2 Emissions by Annex 1 and Non-Annex 1 Countries
Source: Dawson and Spannagle 2009.
CLIMATE DEBATE
53
India the figure was 1.0 tons. By 2050, emissions will start stabilizing for both Annex 1 as well as for non-Annex 1 countries.77 For the developing countries, climate change issues are not the main concern when compared with problems, such as poverty, natural resource management, energy and livelihood needs. From their perspective, development should come first, that is, one should start from a sustainable development perspective, which prioritizes poverty reduction and equity. The challenge for such a type of development is the practical question of choosing sustainable pathways that provide food and energy security, employment opportunities and at the same time minimize environmental impacts.78 Hence, a less-polarized way of meeting the challenges of climate change is to build policies upon development priorities that are vitally important to developing countries. Such an approach views the risks of climate change not as a burden to be avoided, but as a side-benefit of sustainable development. And this could then lead to an alternative strategy for establishing cooperation between developing and developed nations. Such a strategy should involve efficient utilization of natural resources, increase in service levels, lower spending by the consumer on resource-related expenditure reduction and also reduction in air pollution levels (Figure 2.4).
2.4 Conclusion The term climate refers to the aggregate of all weather appearances over a period of time. It is widely agreed that the climate is changing but its future trajectory and impacts on the environment and society remain uncertain.79 There can be little doubt ‘(…) that man is capable of influencing the climate through human activities of many different kinds’.80 Although a matter of some debate with regard to data reliability, the curve of the global mean temperature has been rising since 1861 and although no single explanation for global warming can be given, the greenhouse effect is a plausible one. This effect is attributed to the greenhouse gases CO2, CH4, N2, O, O3 and FCCs.81 The clash between sceptics and supporters is likely to endure, and may even become more pitched as the stakes on climate change are raised. 77
IPCC 2007a. Bradley et al. 2005. 79 Heal and Kriström 2002, 3; Santamouris 2001, 22. 80 Santamouris 2001, 19. 81 Ibid. 78
54
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 2.4 Recommendations to Financial Institutions and Governments
Source: Adapted from Innovest 2002b, 37–43.
The expansion of scientific knowledge is unlikely to end the debate, as each side will get more data to confirm their case. Sceptics will continue to assail supporters for blending science with environmental activism, and supporters
CLIMATE DEBATE
55
will maintain their doubts about the scientific credibility of sceptics because of their links to economic interests. Regardless of who is right in this debate, each side is valuable to the other. A vocal group of contrarians is necessary to achieve scientific progress, since it forces supporters to improve their science and vice versa. It is necessary to point out the flaws in assumptions, logic, and method, and to propose counterarguments for every argument. The problem is not the scientific controversy, but the way in which science is used by economic and political interests, and the risk of scientists becoming pawns in a high stakes political game.
3 Win-Win Climate Policy
Climate change mitigation is related to costs. This chapter develops an outline of a win-win-oriented climate policy. As an introduction to the problem, the debate on abatement of costs is reviewed first. The discount rate partly influences how much money is spent on climate change mitigation. Therefore, this chapter discusses the question: ‘What discount rate should be applied for problems that are likely to peak in the medium to long-term future?’ The third section examines whether climate protection can yield benefits both for the environment and economy, thereby providing win-win opportunities. The last section discusses market-based measures as a means to increase the take up of win-win opportunities and to attract profit-minded investors for climate change mitigation.
3.1 Introduction A key issue in the debate on climate change is how much it will cost to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emission levels. In contrast to the ‘no-rush’ approach advocated by sceptics, supporters believe that the cost of delay is much higher than the cost of immediate action.1 When it comes to detailed calculations of the cost of climate change mitigation, sceptics sometimes use worst case assumptions, which partially 1
UNEP and UNFCCC 2002, Information Sheet 24.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 57
or completely exclude the use of market-based mechanisms and ‘no-regrets’ options. Supporters believe that there are significant opportunities in almost every country to achieve climate change mitigation at a zero or negative net economic cost. As Innovest argues in its report for the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP): (…) the right blend of policies, if skilfully introduced, can substantially reduce the direct and indirect costs of mitigation and perhaps even produce a net economic benefit. Cost benefit analyses of climate change mitigation often omit the fact that mitigation aims at preventing damages caused by climate change. If the cost of damages were taken into account, the estimates would look quite different.2
Indeed, the calculation of climate change mitigation costs depends largely on the assumptions underlying it. Many climate–economy models are based on the assumption that all profitable energy savings have already been bought, and therefore, greater energy savings will be worth purchasing only at higher energy prices. Using this as a starting point, computer models are developed to calculate the value of the energy tax needed based on historic elasticities, the subsequent negative effects on the economy and the cost of climate change mitigation. As Amory Lovins argues, climate models ‘(…) find carbon abatement to be costly because that is what they assume’.3 Climate models also tend to assume that the public sector will invest directly in greenhouse gas reduction, thus neglecting that the government may focus on mobilizing private capital instead. In doing the latter, major cost savings could be realized. However, it is difficult to say exactly how much money could be saved because there is little historical experience apart from Public–Private Partnership (PPP) programmes, which did not focus on climate change. Lovins further cites ‘(…) a heavily peer-reviewed five-Labs study (…)’,4 which demonstrated that it is possible to freeze US carbon emissions in 2010 at the 1990 levels at (…) net economic costs—under a range of assumptions and alternative methods of cost analysis—[that] will be near or below zero’. This can be achieved through a combination of energy efficiency, renewable energy and other low carbon options and would reduce the carbon intensity of the economy at an average rate of 2.5 per cent per year.5 Assuming this is 2
Innovest 2007a. Another difficulty consists in valuing natural assets. Lovins 2008. 4 Ibid. 5 McKinsey Global Institute 2007. 3
58
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
correct, it suggests that accelerating sustainable energy development can be consistent with maintaining national and corporate competitiveness. Lovins points out that several Nobel prize winners in economics and 2,600 of their peers agreed that ‘(…) policy options exist that would slow climate change without harming American living standards, and these measures may in fact improve US productivity in the longer run’. These arguments have not significantly influenced the policies of President George W. Bush so far, who seems to believe that action on climate change is very costly. This contrasts with the position taken by the Clinton Administration, where Vice President Gore6 was a strong proponent of early action on climate change. The spectrum of scenarios presenting costs for global climate change abatement ranging from billions to net negative costs illustrate that costs are uncertain and difficult to calculate accurately. Based on figures from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), an International Energy Agency (IEA) report claims that ‘(…) the potential for realizable noregret, cost-effective energy saving is very uncertain. Current estimates by IPCC suggest a range of 10–30 per cent gains on baseline trends over the next two to three decades’.7
3.2 The Choice of Discount Rate There are three types of capital investments: Those that have a net economic cost, those that are costless and those that yield a profit. Mobilizing private capital is not different: it can be costly, costless or profitable. How much money should be invested in climate change mitigation or in mobilizing private capital for climate change mitigation partly depends on the discount rate. Discounting converts the (full) values of the impacts that occur at different points of time into common units, for example, translating the costs of future climate change damages into ‘(…) equivalent values in today’s monetary units’.8 The application of discounting in environmental policy has long been controversial.9 In the climate area, the basic fault line runs between the
6
Gore was awarded Noble Prize (along with IPCC) in 2007. IEA 2006a. 8 Goulder and Stavins 2002, 674. 9 Weitzman 1994. 7
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 59
sceptics who want to apply a similar discount rate as in any standard public investment decision, and the supporters who prefer to use a low or zero discount rate. Applying a discount rate means that damages, which are expected to occur in the long-term future have a very low present value, even if a reduced discount rate of 3 or 4 per cent is applied. Since the costs associated with climate change may peak in 50, 100, or more years, the discount rate methodology tells us to pay very little now to avert these damages.10 The higher the discount rate, the lower the investments we are willing to make today. William Cline argues that people ‘(…) who prefer discount rates of 10 per cent can (…) dismiss global warming 100 years from now, because however catastrophic it might be, it is worth only a few dollars today to try to avert it’.11 A lack of willingness to pay for climate change mitigation is particularly problematic if it turns out that climate change impacts are cataclysmic, matching or exceeding worst case scenarios. The report of the IPCC confirmed the possibility of ‘discontinuity scenarios’,12 in which GHG emissions shoot above an upper limit, leading to further disasters. According to Innovest, ‘The experience of the insurance industry shows that even small changes (<10 per cent) in event severity can generate multiple increases in damage.’13 The discount rate is controversial because it means to place a greater value on current relative to future lives.14 Nobel Prize winner economist James Tobin believes that in the long term discount rates should not be used, since their use ‘(…) reflects the impatience of those on the globe who would like their goodies now’.15
10 The question for economists is not only to estimate the cost of future damages, but also how much the gains from, for example, saved species are worth. The benefits could be vaccines, or just the enjoyment of the existence of the species (Goulder and Stavins 2002, 674). As David Pearce said, ‘A first step should be to improve the measurement of the value people put on the environment (…). Put a proper value on an environmental “good”, and the balance between costs and benefits will start to look greener’ (Heathfield and Russell 1992, 412, quoting an unpublished lecture by Pearce). 11 To ‘justify an aggressive and expensive effort to slow global warming’, Cline suggests a discount rate of 2 per cent (see Stokes 1992, 124–25). 12 IPCC 2001b. 13 Innovest 2002a, 7. 14 See Weiss 1990, for a proposal of how to protect the interests of future generations. 15 Stokes 1992, 124–25.
60
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The use of discount rates is based on Irving Fisher’s time-preference theory of interest shows the preference for today’s relative to tomorrow’s consumption (Figure 3.1). According to Fisher, the interest rate is determined by impatience and technological progress. The indifference curves U1, U2 and U3 represent the level of impatience about tomorrow’s consumption of society or an individual. The production possibility frontier (PPF) demonstrates the possibility to transfer today’s consumption into consumption of tomorrow. E is the equilibrium, in which satisfaction is maximized. The slopes of PPF and U2 in E are equal to minus (1 + r), with ‘r’ representing the real interest rate. The slopes express how much of the future goods are equivalent to today’s goods. The assumption is that economic subjects are not willing to sacrifice today’s consumption without getting any benefit for it. They favour today’s consumption over tomorrow’s consumption and want to be paid for waiting. Figure 3.1 Fisher’s Time-preference Theory of Interest
Source: Adapted from Samuelson and Nordhaus 1989, 387.
How much the choice of discount rate matters for the design of policy was illustrated by a study undertaken by William Nordhaus. Using the example of a tax on GHGs, he sought to determine an efficient policy response to climate change. In his ‘maximum damage’ scenario, a discount rate of 4 per cent suggests that an efficient level of the tax is USD 2.44 per ton of carbon, and the result would be a less than 5 per cent decrease in
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 61
emissions compared to business as usual. A discount rate of zero, however, suggests an efficient tax of USD 65.94 per ton of carbon, which would lower emissions by one-third.16
3.3 ‘No-regrets’ and ‘Win-win’ Opportunities Already in 1992, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) encouraged the use of cost-effective mechanisms for tackling climate change. This principle was reaffirmed later in the Kyoto Protocol. The principle of cost effectiveness influences (a) the type of project and (b) the type of policy instruments. This section focuses on types of projects, whereas the next one discusses policy instruments. No-regrets options have the potential to be welcomed by both, sceptics and supporters as they provide the dual benefit of climate change mitigation and economic improvement. The concept of no-regrets can be considered as synonym for the concept of win-win. There are two types of no-regrets, respectively win-win outcomes: z
z
16
The first type—economic win-win—is achieved when a problem is mitigated at a negative net economic cost, thus leading to a win for problem solving and a win for the economy. The second type— financial win-win—is achieved when a problem is mitigated at a profit (negative net financial cost), thus leading to a win for problem solving and a win for the particular investor, company or industry.17
Nordhaus 1991. Among financial win-win opportunities, we must distinguish between immediate and delayed financial win-win opportunities. Immediate win-win opportunities yield a direct profit on a project, whereas delayed financial win-win opportunities improve corporate profits/competitiveness over time. Michael Porter, a professor at the Harvard Business School, popularized the notion of delayed win-win opportunities (although he uses a different terminology). Porter argued that a well-designed environmental regulation improves corporate competitiveness over time by prodding firms to invest in more efficient technologies that not only improve environmental performance but also lower costs and improve the bottom line (Porter and van der Linde 1995). 17
62
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The distinction between economic and financial cost is important because the number of measures that are economically viable is probably higher than the number of measures that are financially profitable. This is because in a detailed economic analysis, externalities are taken into account, whereas in a financial analysis they are not. Few doubts that there are the proverbial USD 100 bills waiting to be picked up from the street, but the question is whether there are sufficient viable business propositions to make it worthwhile for businesses to alter their course and start systematically searching for win-win opportunities. The essence of the theory of private capital mobilization (PCM) is that win-win opportunities can be created.18 In other words, if there are too few USD 100 bills on the street, it is possible to print them. Where there are such bills, but barriers too to get hold of them, it is possible to reduce, remove, or overcome these barriers. The key is to focus on those win-win opportunities that require only a small subsidy or intervention and that create large external benefits. If we want to get businesses and financial institutions to be active participants in solving problems, it is not sufficient to demonstrate that their participation will be good for the economy or the society as a whole. But we also have to show that it will improve their balance sheets as well. If financial win-win situations can be created by mobilizing private capital, it is possible to strengthen the case against the argument that companies cannot afford to take environmental action. There is another way to conceptualize the win-win issue by using a stakeholder perspective. From a narrow view of this approach, win-win outcomes are achieved if the participant benefits from a particular project. From a broader view, win-win outcomes are related to the distribution of benefits to all stakeholders, also to those that are not directly involved within a project. In an ideal scenario, the government will achieve its policy goals, such as for instance reducing public expenditures, improving the environment or protecting disadvantaged social groups. Firms and financial institutions will achieve their business objectives, such as for instance making profits and improving their reputation. The civil society organizations will attain their aims, such as for instance improving the environment, ensuring democratic legitimacy and preventing corruption. A win-win solution means achieving those par-ticular goals the stakeholders define for themselves.
18
See Assenza 2005.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 63
There are GHG reduction measures at zero or negative net economic cost, which are good for the economy. However, it is a matter of disagreement how many opportunities are available, and what percentage of an environmental target can be achieved with no-regrets and win-win options. Supporters of action on climate change insist that there are plenty of noregrets opportunities, and that climate change can be mitigated in a costeffective way without undermining prosperity. Economic win-win situations contain activities that lead to positive environmental and developmental change. They do not involve significant trade-offs between the environment and the economy. Economic effects, thereby, can have many different meanings such as GDP, number of jobs created, consumer benefits, business competitiveness or average industry performance, and each researcher will have his or her own preference. Financial win-win opportunities combine profit and sustainability. In this way, win-win opportunities overcome asymmetrical interests that have often prevented effective problem solving. It is worth distinguishing between real win-win arrangements that involve a net positive pay-off for all stakeholders, and relative win-win arrangements, where some parties may have to pay something, but not as much as under alternative arrangements. The latter is the case when car manufacturers facing a costly carbon tax see a requirement to increase the sales of clean cars. Furthermore, it is useful to distinguish between win-win opportunities, which are exploited and those which are latent. The first type are win-win opportunities, which do not require any intervention from governments, multilateral institutions (MIs) or other parties because the private sector is aware of them and is already exploiting them. As they are privately financed without special incentives, there is no need to mobilize private capital. The second type of win-win opportunities are latent ones. Those may or may not be known to the private sector, and require a stimulus or some other form of intervention. The intervention may be regulatory, informational, financial or a combination of these. The intervention may be economywide—affecting all firms and financial institutions, sector-wide or targeted at particular companies and individuals. Any win–lose situation can be turned into a win-win situation by compensating the losers. An important question is how many latent win-win opportunities exist.19 There is much debate and uncertainty in estimating win-win options. 19
While there is no reliable data to quantify the amount of win-win opportunities in either category, it is analytically pertinent to draw the boundaries around the term ‘win-win’. A project can be considered win-win even if there are cheaper alternatives, that is, if opportunities
64
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
For instance, a report by the IEA notes that the potential for realisable noregret, cost-effective energy savings is very uncertain. Current estimates by the IPCC suggest a range of 10–30 per cent gains on baseline trends over the next two to three decades.20 In the future, the driving force regarding the promotion of sustainable energy may shift increasingly from regulation to opportunity. While for a long time businesses adopted strategies of avoidance and outright resistance, in recent years an increasing number of businesses have begun to explore the profit potential of clean energy technologies. Oil giants redefined themselves as energy companies and, together with a host of engineering and technology companies, increased their exposure to clean energy technology. The more win-win opportunities exist, the cheaper it is to mitigate climate change. In fact, as long as win-win opportunities are exploited, mitigating climate change is economically and financially viable. However, although win-win opportunities are profitable, this does not necessarily mean that they are privately financed and that there is no need to mobilize private capital. Due to a variety of barriers, the private sector cannot take advantage of all profit opportunities. Since it is unlikely that all profit opportunities have been recognized and exploited, traditional policy options and marketbased measures can enable profit-minded investors to take advantage of environmental business opportunities. If win-win opportunities are sizeable, the question is how to realize them cost effectively and make them commercially self-sustaining over time. This question merits further attention by policy makers and the business community. In the absence of demonstrated linkages between different sectors, the technology options are given a superficial treatment by policy makers. To illustrate an example, access to electricity and subsidized kerosene is justified from the perspective of reduced forest loss. Reduced expenditure on health and retention of a healthy and productive community is seldom quantified. Policy makers would provide increased budgets for rural health care without considering a complementary budget for the diffusion of renewable energy technologies or electrification programmes. This does not demonstrate poor performance on the part of exist, which yield greater net economic/financial benefits relative to cost. For example, if a government provides a grant to a renewable energy power plant, the project may be considered ‘win-win’, as long as the project is financially profitable and the grant is lower than (a) the cost of subsidies given to generate an equivalent amount of electricity using conventional power technologies or (b) the avoided costs of environmental and health damage. If ‘win-win’ projects included only those that are least costly, there would be considerably fewer win-win opportunities, as only the best projects would qualify. 20 IPCC 2007f.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 65
policy makers but highlights the need for a pool of skills and resources for assisting policy makers in justifying decisions taken in the process of planning rural development.21
3.4 Market-based Climate Policy All environmental policy instruments, including traditional command and control mechanisms, such as performance standards and economic instruments, such as taxes and subsidies can have an impact on private investment decisions. However, market-based measures have the greatest potential to attract profit-minded investors for climate change mitigation. The main idea of market-based mechanisms is to solve environmental problems in an economically efficient way by sending appropriate price signals to private investors to internalize the societal costs of their business decisions and to provide an economic incentive for firms to reduce those costs. Marked-based measures are sometimes favoured due to ideological reasons; for example, the belief that the government is not capable of or efficient in providing solutions.22 However, markets require clear price signals and a legal framework. Therefore, market-based measures necessarily imply a role for the government. They would not thrive in an environment, entirely free of regulation, where the government does not provide clear rules and frameworking conditions.23 Warwick McKibbin and Peter Wilcoxen argue that mitigation policies, which do not minimize cost, are doomed to failure. For example, they propose coal market reform through reducing coal subsidies and trade barriers as a solution that will generate both economic and environmental benefits. According to their calculations, if western Europe and Japan would remove their coal production subsidies and import restrictions, OECD GHG emissions would decrease by 13 per cent and global emissions by 5 per cent by 2005.24 Whilst price reform of this kind may disadvantage fossil fuel industries, the renewable energy sector can anticipate inflows of capital that would otherwise go to carbon-intensive industries. Apart from subsidy reform, trading emissions may be an instrument with the greatest potential in terms of climate change mitigation. The first 21
IISD 2003. Anderson and Leal 2001. 23 Stavins 1989. 24 McKibbin and Wilcoxen 2002. 22
66
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
emission trading schemes were developed in the United States.25 The most well-known programme is the sulphur dioxide trading scheme established at the beginning of the 1990s to tackle acid rain. This system enables firms to buy and sell rights to emit sulphur dioxide in a manner equivalent to buying and selling currencies in a foreign exchange market. The fact that it combines both environmental and economic benefits makes it attractive as a model for carbon trading systems. High penalties have prevented sources from violating the cap level—the maximum amount of allowable emissions. Indeed, since the acid rain programme commenced in 1995 sources included into the scheme comply with their caps at lower costs than predicted at the time the programme was implemented. (Emissions trading is an administrative approach used to control pollution by providing economic incentives for achieving reductions in the emissions of pollutants. It is sometimes called cap and trade.) The experience has shown that the programme can ensure emission reductions at the least cost to society. This outcome should make it attractive even in the eyes of those who tend not to trust in market solutions. The programme is successful as the trade is beneficial for both buyers and sellers. Sources that have a high cost of abatement can buy additional allowances at a lower price whilst sources that are able to reduce emissions below their cap are rewarded for better environmental performance by selling their extra allowances and making a profit. The total cost of reducing emissions through trading is smaller than that of other policy mechanisms. For instance, it was calculated that the Danish goal of 21 per cent and the European Union (EU) goal of 8 per cent of GHG abatement would be achieved at nine and 24 times the cost, respectively, by using taxation policy than with the use of emission trading.26 With regard to pollution permit trading, there is a clear incentive for decreasing emissions because there is a monetary value attached to allowances. Emission trading systems stimulate research and development, as the business sector can anticipate profitable emissions abatement. Furthermore, emission trading systems provide high flexibility in choosing which type of emission reduction—including investment into abatement technology, fuel switch, energy efficiency measures or utilization of renewable energy sources—is most suitable. In contrast, command and control approaches 25 See Hahn’s classic article ‘Economic Prescriptions for Environmental Problems: How the Patient Followed the Doctor’s Orders’ (1989) for a review of early efforts to achieve emission trading and emissions charges in the US and Europe. 26 Svendsen and Vesterdal 2003.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 67
that, for example, specify the types of pollution control devices to be installed do not provide the same degree of flexibility.27 In 2008, a new scheme came into operation, which promises to become the largest emission trading market in the world. The EU’s Emission Trading Scheme (ETS) would be applicable not only in the EU, but also in accession countries and the countries of the European Economic Area (EEA). The ETS is designed to contribute to the greenhouse gas reduction commitments under the Kyoto Protocol. The first emission trades have already been agreed to, indicating the interest of private sector actors. For example, Shell Trading will sell a considerable number of allowances to Nuon during the first compliance year.28 Several challenges in developing EU-wide emission trading remain to be addressed, including the harmonization of fragmented national markets, the possibility of interaction between parties covered by the EU scheme with other Kyoto parties on the base of bilateral agreements and building up links with project-based Kyoto mechanisms. There are voices advising against the use of credits from Joint Implementation (JI) and Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) in the ETS. In its letter to the European Commission dated 28 February 2003, the Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe expressed its reservations and demanded to ‘Keep the emission trading scheme as a domestic measure for cutting industry emissions!’29 The Network argued that some of these projects are non-additional and even environmentally destructive.30 Two EU countries, Denmark and the UK, have established national carbon emission schemes, already. Lessons learned from the Danish experience indicate that the level of CO2 emissions remains almost the same as in the baseline year. Therefore, Denmark is aware of the difficulty in meeting emission reduction goals with the help of measures, which are used only nationally. Denmark is ready to buy emission credits from other countries, which are below their Kyoto targets. The country is likely to become an active participant in the EU-wide emission trading scheme, as well as in other international schemes and projects aimed at GHG reduction. A study undertaken by Enviros Consulting, which evaluated the UK carbon trading programme, concluded that the scheme provided local companies with the necessary experience to enter the EU-wide emission trading 27
US EPA 2002. Shell International Limited 2003. 29 CAN 2003. 30 Ibid. 28
68
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
system and other international carbon markets. At the same time, the study questions the effectiveness of the programme in decreasing UK carbon emissions. However, the authors of the study hope that as the scheme matures it will contribute to the UK Kyoto target more significantly. To improve the operation of the programme, Enviros Consulting recommends changing voluntary enforcement mechanisms into mandatory ones.31 Another major instrument for climate change mitigation is environmental taxation. Several industrialized countries introduced taxes on the carbon content of oil, coal, and gas. This measure is designed to cut the use of carbon-intensive fuels and increase the use of cleaner energy, thereby decreasing GHG emissions. In comparison to environmental taxes, emission trading may be more effective in terms of reaching an emission target, since it sets a strict emission goal. On the other hand, a tax may provide more up front certainty as to the cost of the programme, and it can be used in market segments where the establishment of an emission trading scheme is impractical or unwieldy. A mix of emission trading and environmental taxes may be the most effective approach in many countries. The former instrument is better applicable to large polluters, while the latter better suits small polluters.32 If an emission trading system is implemented at an international level, it could create strong demand for investment projects designed to reduce GHG emissions. Private capital could be mobilized through this mechanism because GHG reduction projects would yield credits that can be sold in the market. Firms that are able to reduce GHGs at a price below the trading price can make a profit out of mitigating climate change. In this way, climate change could become the basis for a growing sector of business activity, ultimately developing into a major economic driving force in the coming decades. Specialists from Natsource, DZ Bank and other organizations involved in climate change mitigation see a big advantage of a carbon market in that it will enable ‘(…) bringing future revenues from forward GHG contracts to the beginning of the project, rather than payments at the back end’. In their view it will help to get ‘(…) lots of projects off the ground because of the ability to accelerate cash flow in projects where cash is required in the early stages’.33 There are also critical voices concerning emission trading schemes.34 For example, Martin Tampier argues that the renewable energy sector will 31
Enviros Consultancy 2003. Svendsen and Vesterdal 2003. 33 Innovest 2002b, 28. 34 Victor 1991, for a critical perspective on market-based mechanisms. 32
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 69
not be able to benefit from the ETS since renewables will not be covered. The only possibility for them to get involved is to offer renewable energy to those who might wish to substitute for fossil fuel generation. Moreover, for many firms, paying the non-compliance penalty might be cheaper than reducing their emissions. A low penalty would encourage many firms to prefer non-compliance rather than investing in more expensive clean technologies. Further, an emission trading scheme may not, in itself, be sufficient to achieve broader policy objectives, such as renewable energy development. It is not clear if emission trading will help renewables to cover the gap between production costs and electricity prices, and thereby, to become more competitive with conventional fuels. However, the future may bring a decrease of renewable energy prices and at the same time an increase in the prices for emission credits and energy from fossil fuels.35 Currently, energy efficiency projects may be better suited to take advantage of emission trading, while renewables could benefit from JI. However, this assumption should be subject to further research. The Transnational Institute states that JI and the CDM favour implementation of large scale renewable energy projects since small ones have more difficulties in measuring and identifying energy production. According to Bachram et al., ‘This undermines diversity and innovation in the renewable energy sector as a whole.’36 In terms of actual policy developments currently under implementation, the development of a GHG trading system would be an essential component of a reform of incentive structures. If the effectiveness of such a system is not whittled down in negotiation, and if compromise does not result in the lowest common denominator, GHG trading has the potential to mobilize large sums of private capital, especially if combined with carbon taxes and other policy instruments. The question is how to bring these ideas into practice. In order to make GHG markets operate efficiently, the main tasks include producing demand, enhancing buyer confidence in pricing, bringing greater liquidity to the GHG market, overcoming the short-term cash flow problems and creating larger economies of scale.37 The main task for private investors is to incorporate the effects of GHG regulations and carbon price sensitivities into the analysis of project economics.38 The interest among investors will increase if it can be shown that technologies become cheaper as a result of commercialization and that GHG emission markets offer opportunities to create profits from project 35
Tampier 2003. Bachram et al. 2003, 22. 37 Innovest 2002b. 38 Ibid. 36
70
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
cash flows and advisory fees. The alternative to voluntary action on climate change is higher taxes and stricter environmental regulations, as well as higher indirect costs due to environmental and health damages, which ultimately are paid by households and firms. An important advantage of GHG trading is that it includes incentives based on self-interest, such as for instance, direct profit opportunities for firms, which can reduce pollution at less than the trading price. Thus, GHG trading is not favoured by arguments about enlightened self-interest, although these arguments may be important to long-term profits and business competitiveness. Market-based mechanisms should not be treated as a panacea for solving environmental problems, since there are cases, which require complementary mechanisms, including economic instruments and command-andcontrol approaches. However, market-based provisions should be further investigated and exploited when they offer advantages. The US sulphur trading programme has shown that market-based approaches can be costeffective in mobilizing private capital for clean technologies, which gives ground for optimism concerning carbon trading schemes. Using a mix of measures, climate change mitigation policy can provide a stimulus for speeding up the commercialization of clean energy technologies.39
3.5 Integrating Climate Policies with Development Priorities As climate change negotiations advance, it is becoming increasingly clear that there is a greater need to shift the focus on developing countries since the international negotiations have not adequately addressed their priorities for sustainable development, support for adaptation activities, aid assistance and technology transfer. This is because affordable and accessible modern energy services along with poverty reduction are essential to achieve sustainable development. Lack of access to these services adversely affects public health, constrains educational opportunities and impedes human development and well-being of nearly 1.6 billion people in developing countries. However, the proponents of climate change argue that affordable energy—in the form that is currently available—is also the cause of climate change. Hence, it is important to integrate development policies with
39
See Chapter 9 (this volume) for an analysis of commercialization.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 71
that of climate change, which means reconciling development and climate priorities. This means that countries must improve the prospects of integrating climate policy into development considerations, and vice versa. The key is to identify such sustainable development policies and measures (SDPAM) and promote them. The concept of SDPAM has been explored in the research community, including detailed case studies of policies in several developing countries.40 Winkler et al. put forward this approach mentioning that the policies and measures that are firmly within the national sustainable development priorities of the host country should be integrated into climate policies.41 However, a great deal of work remains to be done to explore the operational implications of this approach as part of an international policy framework. Bradley et al. have suggested that the use of SDPAM in developing countries gives an automatic recognition to climate policy, facilitates sharing of knowledge and expertise across borders, involves actual engagement in climate mitigation efforts rather than just providing lip service, and promotes both development and climate goals.42 The benefits that accrue to the society (economic, social, environmental, public health, and so on) independent of any direct benefits from mitigating climate change can be referred to as ‘co-benefits’. The IPCC Third Assessment Report on Mitigation differentiates ‘co-benefits’ as benefits intended as the primary objective of certain actions or policies from those that are secondary or incidental to it, which are named simply as ‘ancillary benefits’ for developing countries.43 The literature shows that several countries have already demonstrated the benefits (reduced poverty, increased employment opportunities, improvements in health, energy and food security and infrastructure) of an integrated approach.44 For example, the alcohol fuel programme in Brazil has provided significant economic and environmental benefits along with employment opportunities for hundreds of thousands of poor smallholder families (900,000 relatively well-paid jobs were created) in the Brazilian northern and north-eastern regions. The programme has helped to reduce its dependency on oil import; between 1975 and 2002, in terms of foreign
40 Bradley et al. 2005; Dubash and Bradley 2005; Moreira et al. 2005; Mwakasonda and Winkler 2005; Winkler et al. 2002 and Wei-Shiuen and Schipper 2005. 41 Winkler et al. 2002. 42 Bradley et al. 2005. 43 IPCC 2001a. 44 O’Brien et al. 2008; Ribeiro and Abreu, 2008.
72
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
exchange savings, the programme has saved about USD 52 billion (January 2003 USD). It has also considerably reduced local air pollution in the cities.45 According to a study by Dubash and Bradley,46 the rural electrification programme in India can have significant local as well as global benefits. The study suggests that there are significant climate benefits to off-grid renewable energy that have not been explored in recent planning initiatives. The recent study by the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and Clear Air Initiative (CAI-Asia)47 identified a menu of short- to long-term transport policy interventions, which can bring about the most reduction in CO2 emissions in the transport sector. The proposed measures include interventions in vehicle fuel efficiency, transport demand management, transport and land use planning and biofuels. These measures reduce total fuel consumption significantly and land-use planning contributes to more reduction in CO2 emissions. China’s CDM is an example of similar success. World Bank-led study on the CDM market potential suggests that China will capture about 50 per cent of the world’s CDM market in 2010.48 China’s growing belief that CDM would play an important role in future global efforts to mitigate climate change has led China to gradually recognize the importance of capacity building at national, local and enterprise levels to ensure that China is well positioned to take advantage of CDM opportunities. This is in line with rules and modalities the UNFCCC have agreed upon to make the CDM fully operational. The CDM will channel private sector investment into emissions abatement projects in developing countries. In this way, it will promote sustainable development in these countries while offering industrialized governments credits against their Kyoto targets.49 A pledge-based approach by countries with bilateral and multilateral funding can bring in more success.50 A potentially important network is the CAN, which the UNEP is currently in the process of establishing in consultation with various stakeholders, including the governments of China, Indonesia and Pakistan. The objective of this network is to facilitate a more effective participation of Asian governments in climate-related negotiations. Although the planning for the network as far as known now is 45
Kok et al. 2008. Dubash and Bradley 2005. 47 ADB 2006. 48 World Bank 2004. 49 Zhang 2006. 50 Bradley et al. 2005. 46
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 73
not specifically focused on co-benefits, it is clear that the establishment of the first formal climate network incorporating governments in Asia offers strong possibilities to integrate the co-benefits approach. However, there are certain trade-offs between certain aspects of development and addressing climate change, for example, food security versus energy security. Promoting large-scale bioenergy production is a prime example of a policy where trade-offs between food security, biodiversity and climate change have to be made. In terms of costs and benefits, one has to weigh higher costs of clean energy systems against social and economic benefits. This requires collaboration on multiple levels and from various perspectives. Greater effort needs to go into generating ideas from within developing countries and sharing them with the international community. The driving forces for the promotion of a sustainable energy path may shift increasingly from regulation to opportunity. While for a long time businesses adopted strategies of avoidance and outright resistance, in recent years an increasing number of them have begun to explore the profit potential of clean energy technologies (Figure 3.2). Figure 3.2 Cost-benefit of a Cleaner Technology Project
Source: Authors.
In short, economic prosperity, human development and environmental benefits should move hand-in-hand. Conversely, high-energy use places an enormous burden on long-term economic development and poses critical problems to improving living standards, particularly those from the developing countries. Inefficient technologies become a drain on factories,
74
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
machinery and resources, affecting competitiveness. Hence, it is important to invest in the efficiency of the energy supply systems and reduce losses on the demand side. However, it is a matter of disagreement how many opportunities are available, and what percentage of an environmental target can be achieved with efficient technologies and win-win options. Nonetheless, it can be safely argued that there are plenty of these no-regrets opportunities, and that development can be achieved through these options and climate change can be mitigated in a cost-effective way without undermining prosperity.51
3.6 Conclusion Given the uncertainties about the costs of reducing GHGs, the best way to proceed may be the introduction of more flexibility into international trading programmes for carbon credits. While there are important implementation issues regarding the design and monitoring of such programmes that must be addressed, a well-planned emission trading system could succeed in getting governments to start moving towards climate protection, despite or because of worries about high climate change mitigation costs. If such systems are implemented, they are likely to create strong demand for investment projects designed to reduce GHG emissions. Private capital would be mobilized because GHG reduction projects would yield credits that can be sold in the market. The adoption of flexible mechanisms may well be the key to increased spending on environmental technologies, including energy efficiency and renewable energy. Whether the flexible mechanisms are effective or not depends on their design, implementation and the behaviour of participants within the regime. Nobody can predict how international action on climate change will evolve in the coming years and decades. After a boost through the adoption of the Kyoto Protocol in December 1997, international climate change negotiations have, at least temporarily, lost their momentum in two key areas. First, ratification has been slow and contentious, and second, there has been a lack of consensus on the modalities for implementing the so called flexible mechanisms—JI, the CDM and Emission Trading. If a climate regime is to be effective, it needs to give each actor incentives to participate in real emission reduction. Climate change negotiations so 51
Innovest 2002a; Pew Center 2001.
WIN-WIN CLIMATE POLICY 75
far, have brought forward many good proposals to this effect. But there were counterproductive dynamics too driven by certain parties to the Kyoto Protocol, which have tried to use the climate negotiations as a means of attracting money from other participating countries. One example of this poker game has been exhibited by Russia in the question of ratifying the Kyoto Protocol. The climate negotiations will succeed only if sufficient numbers of players are driven by a problem solving attitude, and if there are countries or groups of countries willing to take a leadership role to push the process forward. In the absence of leadership, even well intentioned players remain uncoordinated, which increases the transaction costs and timeframe both of the negotiations, as well as of the pilot projects carried out for mitigating climate change. A Republican administration could, but does not want to, assume a leadership position in global environmental governance, and in the near future is unlikely to provide acceptable alternatives to the international community. The EU, another major player, is still too fragmented. Nevertheless, with the absence of America, the EU is the only powerful block able to retake the leadership.52 If new impetus is to be expected, it might come from the business community, as corporations and financial institutions, especially the insurance industry, have begun to adopt the view that climate change needs to be considered in terms of threats and opportunities.53 Still, actions from the private sector depend on the speed and efficiency of national governments. Due to their ability to change the incentive structures of the market, governments still hold the key to the feasibility and profitability of climate change mitigation measures. So far, the private sector has been waiting for policy signals, while governments have been waiting for greater private sector interest. It will be interesting to see which side will make the first move.
52 In October 1996, for example, the EU argued for quantified and binding reductions in a position paper presented to the FCCC executive secretary. One year later, this argument became the essence of the Kyoto Protocol. 53 MIs are also important actors, although they often reflect the consensus or conflict of their owners (the governments) and therefore cannot be quite as independent as global businesses and financial institutions. However, multilateral institutions are important sources of funding climate change mitigation projects, and they could play important roles as facilitators, catalysts and brokers in a climate regime.
4 Fundamentals of Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency (EE) is widely viewed as an important element of economic and environmental policy. However, there is little agreement on specific EE goals and the strategies to attain them. The lack of consensus stems from the fact that there are differing views about the meaning of EE and the means of implementing it. How much one will actually benefit from EE depends on how one approaches the issue. Also, the success in EE improvements depends on how well various actors help each other, and how well their actions are integrated. The present chapter aims to explain the nature and purpose of EE as well as its relation to various actors of the society and the environment. The chapter also presents a short overview of the current debate on EE in which the EE gap and the rebound effects are the main constitutes.
4.1 Introduction It is hardly an exaggeration to say that with increasing affluence, energy has moved into the very centre of public concern. As populations expand and strive for better standards of living, per capita energy consumption rises, leading to an accelerated depletion of finite resources. It is not surprising that those who speak of conservation have been ridiculed for years as impractical and opponents of development. However, in recent years, there seems to be a widespread realization about the limits to energy consumption growth
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
77
and the need for an efficient utilization of energy. Most importantly, there has been a shift away from thinking about EE and economic prosperity as mutually exclusive policy goals. This situation, we believe, begins with the understanding of the concept of EE. Energy is not an end in itself, but a means of providing services like illumination, space heating or conveyance. However, much of the information required to deal effectively with these issues is not readily available to end users and decision makers. So, it is true that even at this late date in the history of world energy, policy makers have no comprehensive plan of the design to describe, let alone correct, various dimensions of the energy system. The concept of energy efficiency varies depending on the person who is defining it. Economists, politicians and sociologists have very different views of EE. Often, the concept of EE is defined either in a technical sense or in a more broad and subjective sense. People with a social view of EE might consider energy savings to be a gain in welfare, while those with a more technical view of efficiency would classify the savings as resources saved. Many a times, the term ‘energy efficiency’ is used to describe what actually can be termed as energy conservation. In general, EE describes the relation of an activity or service and the energy used for this purpose.1 The precise definition of EE varies according to its field of application. The different meanings of efficiency in economy, ecology and technology contribute to this diversity. In their taxonomy of efficiency terms, Diekman et al. distinguish nine definitions and areas of application.2 An economic approach to EE, for instance, aims at the optimal resource allocation and minimal overall costs. EE in a more subjective sense may refer to the relative thrift or extravagance with which energy inputs are used to provide services such as powering a vehicle, firing a boiler, cooling an office or lighting a house. EE can be an economic concept—similar to that of productivity, a political concept—the result of EE policy, as well as a sociological concept—reflecting lifestyles of different groups. Hence, while trying to define EE, there is no single commonly accepted definition. It can be safely argued that an increase in EE is when either energy inputs are reduced for a given level of service or there is an increase or enhancement of services for a given level of input. To be energy efficient 1 The use of energy or an energy-related service is inter-related with a variety of influences: structure of the economy, state of technology, culture and lifestyle, geography, climate, consumer preferences and prices. 2 Diekman et al. 1999, 18. See further Brookes 2000.
78
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
per se is to provide services with an energy input that is small relative to a fixed standard or normal input. However, in a narrow sense, EE indicators refer to technology and EE relates to the amount of energy needed to provide a service, which is defined as output of a technical facility or system.3 Investments in EE mean an improvement in the delivery of energy services, for example, in the sense that less energy brings the same end result. EE is a means to conserve natural resources, reduce environmental degradation, and—not least—to save money. It is true that EE helps to reduce Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions. However, there is an intense debate about both its cost effectiveness and the policies that should be pursued to enhance EE.4 Improvements in EE will require active intervention in markets to overcome barriers and to stimulate drivers (see Chapter 6 [this volume] on drivers and barriers). On the other hand some argue that market barriers to the penetration of EE technologies do not represent real market failures that reduce economic efficiency. There are trade-offs between economic efficiency and EE. It is possible to get more of the latter, but sometimes only at the cost of less of the former. Although energy and technology markets certainly are not perfect as all markets in practice, the balance of evidence supports the view that there is less of a ‘free lunch’ in EE than many have suggested. Nonetheless, a case can be made for the existence of certain inefficiencies in energy technology markets, thus raising the possibility of win-win energy efficiency enhancements.
4.2 Rationale for EE Intervention Nearly all devices and systems are less energy efficient in practice than their maximum efficiency in theory. There is always potential for improvement. Thus, few things are truly energy efficient. A device or system can only be more or less energy efficient than the alternatives at a given time, in a given situation. Thus, the technical potential can be defined as the achievable savings resulting from the maximum EE improvement available at a given time, regardless of cost considerations. Market potential is the saving that can be expected to be realized in practice. It reflects what is seen to be technically and financially viable by the consumers. Financial potential is the saving that can be achieved by optimizing the costs and achieving the 3 4
Diekman et al.1999, 25. See also Birol and Keppler 2000. Newell 2000.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
79
best resource utilization. It reflects the viewpoint of organizations. Economic potential is the saving that can be achieved at a net positive economic effect to society as a whole. Here, multiple economic actors are included and externalities are taken into consideration. An example would be the societal investment in EE to reduce growth in electricity demand. This might be less expensive than building a new power plant. These varying definitions point out the importance of various actors in determining potential energy savings. The size of the EE potential is not stable, but varies according to different sectors, energy prices and technological developments. The estimates of energy demand reduction through efficiency improvements are based on assumptions about technical factors, equipment costs, expected rates of market penetration, consumer behaviour and policy measures. When considering the potential for improvement, it is important to distinguish between the potential technological savings and actual ones. Often it is assumed that consumers behave in an economically rational way in view of a cost effective EE measure. However, the evaluation of the cost effectiveness of an EE measure depends largely on the discount rate used, though there is no agreement on what represents an appropriate discount rate. In some cases the discount rates applied to EE improvements are the same as those used by utilities for energy supply investments. In some cases, premiums are included to take into account resource depletion, energy security, environmental and other considerations in order to create ‘societal cost effectiveness’ measures. Most consumers make investment decisions without direct reference to discount rates and discounted capital flows. Even in business or industrial organizations, where investments are more likely to be evaluated in terms of rates of return or payback period, more stringent investment criteria are applied sometimes to EE investments than to production investments. Many EE measures that would be paid back in two years or less still do not appear financially attractive for many industrial organizations. For most firms, energy is not a major cost category. Hence, EE often is a minor consideration and it is expected that the costs have to be paid back at a rapid rate. Product characteristics are more important for individual consumers, as are productivity considerations for industrial consumers of which efficiency is only one component. In addition, investments in EE are subject to fluctuations with energy prices. Information on the performance of EE investments is often difficult to acquire. They are perceived as having a higher risk than many other business operations.
80
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
These issues contribute to the problem of identifying a single, absolute cost effective potential. In practice, customers do not normally base their choices on formal economic calculations, but on considerations of comfort, quality and availability. Nevertheless a calculation of cost effectiveness gives valuable information about how well resources are used, and if their usage can be improved. The cost effectiveness of an efficiency measure depends on the costs and benefits considered. For example, from a business perspective, the costs and benefits which are relevant are those borne by the energy user. These include the expenditures for equipment, installation as well as operation and maintenance costs. The benefits include energy cost savings, enhanced labour productivity, environmental compliance or product quality. These are the traditional accounting costs and benefits that affect the industry directly. From a societal point of view there is a wider range of costs and benefits, which are relevant. These include monetary, health and environmental costs and benefits that accrue to society. Certain societal benefits, such as reduced local air pollution or diminished threat for climate change are external to the market and are difficult to quantify. Moreover, they accrue to society at large, not to the particular party implementing the efficiency measure. A sustainable energy policy will reduce these pressures by promoting EE. Also, the need to become more energy efficient will stimulate technological innovation by creating markets for more efficient, more advanced products and services. This will create more jobs dedicated to the research and development of energy efficient products, energy advice and saving services, for example, in energy distribution companies. EE, in short, is an untapped source of wealth creation. Investing in EE will prove to be a profoundly wise way to spend public and private money. While EE is an important objective in itself, promoting EE is also an essential part of an effective strategy to combat climate change. It is estimated that, by using the most advanced technologies, a CO2 reduction of about 50 per cent is possible until the year 2050.5 Energy efficiency, therefore, is a goldmine for CO2 reduction and should not be overlooked in aiming for the Kyoto targets and beyond. As Box 4.1 reveals, increasing EE fulfils multiple objectives.
5
Martinot and McDoom 2000.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
81
Box 4.1 Key Reasons for Advocating EE
Market Failures Payback gap—consumers face higher interest rate than producers. Differences of prices from marginal cost—with franchised monopolies or regulatory oversight, prices rarely reflect marginal cost. Risk sheltering of the utility—monopoly franchise or regulatory oversight shield utility from risk. Rate of return regulation—leads to an incentive to over invest. Externalities—externalities are not seen by market actors. Lack of information—consumers do not choose EE technologies because of lack of knowledge. High transaction costs—consumers miss opportunities because of high transaction costs. Disconnected decision makers or tenant/landlord relationships—consumers may not be able to influence EE decisions. This occurs, such as for instance, when one party, the landlord pays for the equipment while the other party, the tenant, pays the energy bill.
Other Reasons Ensuring adequate energy supply. Maintaining consumer price stability. Promoting greater equity with respect to energy cost burdens. Source: Adapted from Romeo Pacudan 2002.
4.3 The Energy Efficiency Debate There has been a long running debate between energy economists and energy analysts about various aspects of energy efficiency. One aspect is the rebound effect. Although definitions vary, this effect describes the following linkage: the efficient use of energy leads to an increase in the use of energy. This may offset the savings in energy use achieved by the EE improvement partly.6 The theory of the rebound effect is rooted in the neoclassical 6 Compare with Schipper 2000. This effect is also known as Khazzoom-Brookes postulate. Brookes advanced the argument (Laitner 2000, 471). For a recent history of the rebound effect see Schipper 2000.
82
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
economic theory. The extent of the rebound effect depends on the price elasticity of demand. Therefore, the assumption of rational decision making is the precondition for an explanation of this effect.7 It is suggested that in practice the rebound effect is not high enough to subtract the potential contributions of EE to the reduction of carbon emissions or the justification of EE policies.8 Nonetheless, some implications for policy follow from this. Energy-efficient technologies (EETs) may need to be reinforced by market instruments. A continued measurement and explaining effort should be put on to the rebound effect as economies are complex and changing.9 Henry Saunders argues that ‘(…) energy efficiency gains can increase energy consumption by two means: by making energy appear effectively cheaper than other inputs; and by increasing economic growth, which pulls up energy use’.10 The debate grew more intense in the 21st century, spurred by concerns about global warming. The argument for EE, however, is independent of environmental concerns. The market failure that distorts energy use is the under-pricing of energy by regulators. Deregulation, therefore, is preferable with regard to EE as utilities are forced to reduce energy prices. Another aspect to which contributions to the EE debate can be associated is what one describes as a matter of governmental intervention. Gunn who investigated the paradigms of EE stated that it is important to recognize that the primary debate is over the optimal level of governmental intervention in energy markets rather than over the optimal level of EE.11 There are many forms of government intervention, such as subsidies and taxes, special purpose loans, and facilitation like information systems, wellstructured markets or approved suppliers. Further, there are guarantees for specific risks, or offering insurance, and the arrangement of objective non-partisan product information, like energy labelling. The justification and degree of governmental intervention is a matter of debate in the international literature. Barriers which are attributed to market failures make governmental intervention necessary and justifiable and a large body of
7
Berkhout et al. 2000. Berkhout et al. 2000; Greening et al. 2000; Laitner 2000; Schipper 2000. According to Schipper micro rebound effects for the energy end use might depending on initial costs, income and energy price range from 10–40 per cent (Schipper 2000). 9 Brännlund et al. 2004. 10 Saunders 1992. 11 Gunn 1997. 8
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
83
international literature relates barriers to market failures.12 However, others claim that only few market failures can be defined as such.13 Haugland, Bergesen and Roland argue that most barriers merely reflect ‘(…) unaccounted (transaction) costs or simply result from the consumer’s liberty to choose freely his/her convenience and service levels and willingness to accept a higher energy bill for their personal taste or lifestyle’.14 Therefore, governmental intervention might be questionable.15 A large body of international literature puts effort into an empirical approach to this question with different objects of investigations and findings. Governmental stimulation of the implementation of new technology by promoting associated research and development was found to be counterproductive. Although it leads to technological progress, it may hinder corporate investments in new technology. Firms may favour to wait for the next generation of technological developments.16 In the case of restructuring electricity market, pro-interventionists ask whether the market alone is able to overcome EE barriers. It is argued that governmental support in promoting EE and load management can be advantageous.17 Further, an evaluation of US energy labelling programmes led Banerjee and Solomon to the conclusion that, ‘(…) government support is the most critical factor for the success of a labelling program’.18 Altogether, the challenge of reconciling government and free market contributions with regard to the energy market and EE remains. With regard to EE potential, a distinction has to be made between: (a) the economists’ potential: achievable by removing market failures, (b) the technologists’ potential: achievable by the additional removal of non-market/ market barriers and (c) the hypothetical potential: achievable through the
12
Helm 2002. In general, the definition of market failures depends partly on the societal goals which are seen as important within a society (for example, equity). The free market system may fail to achieve these goals. Economists have identified a number of market failures which partly explain this: externalities, lack of information, uncertainty, the existence of public goods or the time which is needed to response to a changing environment (Sloman and Sutcliffe 2000). 13 Gunn 1997. 14 Haugland et al. 1998, 47. 15 For a general discussion on benefits and drawbacks of free markets and government intervention see Sloman and Sutcliffe 2000. 16 Van Soest and Bulte 2001. 17 Vine et al. 2003. 18 Banerjee and Solomon 2003, 121.
84
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
additional elimination of market failures in fuel and electricity markets.19 This framework is summarized in Figure 4.1. Figure 4.1 Characterization of Energy Efficiency Potential
Source: Jaffe Stavins 1994.
4.4 Understanding the ‘Energy Efficiency Gap’ The question being asked very often is why consumers and firms do not invest in cost-effective energy efficiency opportunities. Partly, the answer is that consumers and firms discount future savings of energy efficiency
19
Jaffe Stavins 1994.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
85
investments at rates well in excess of market rates for borrowings or savings. This pattern is referred to as the ‘energy efficiency gap’.20 To understand the EE gap, it is essential to study (a) the characteristics of markets for energyefficient technologies (EETs), (b) the nature of institutional energy-related decision making and (c) the nature of an individual consumer’s energyrelated decision making.
Markets Manufacturers, builders, designers and suppliers all face market-related barriers that inhibit the adoption of EETs. These barriers include organizational inertia, reluctance to change design and production cycles or the inability of a company to capture all the benefits of Research and Development (R&D) investments as competitors can copy products and services.
Institutions In large institutions, factors involved in decisions concerning EE investments include inconsistent application of budgeting procedures, predominance of payback period, split incentives, moderate transaction costs facing certain EE project proposals, effective communication for management of the results of EE programmes, and as far as firms with on site generation are concerned particular incentive problems.
Individual Consumers Factors influencing consumers in investing in EE include transaction costs on consumer decision making, the tendency of consumers to overemphasize initial appliance cost at the expense of future benefits, a lack of interest and the uncertainty about future benefits from efficiency investments. Even if all the energy saving potential could be tapped through EE, the payback gap would persist. Often, cost-effective energy saving options is not chosen. One reason is that many factors which are not directly quantifiable costs, such as the purchasing price, the maintenance cost, or energy costs, affect consumer decisions. Moreover, individuals and organizations do not
20
Reddy 2003.
86
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
invest in EE because of a lack of information and awareness, a lack of technical personnel, a lack of investment funds, uncertainty about energy prices, uncertainty about equipment performance and social pressure. They also are discouraged by problems concerning the equipment supply infrastructure, and split incentives. In the energy sector there are areas where investment is low or misplaced from the EE point of view. For example, investment in new power plants may be avoided when a lower expenditure can be incurred in existing plants through the replacement of existing inefficient technologies with efficient ones. An energy system can meet new demand either by adding more supply capacity or by reducing the additional demand. Good economics suggests that the least cost option should be chosen. The dilemma is that different actors make the choice: it is the company on the supply side and the consumer on the demand side. They have different perspectives on their choices. In contrast to consumers, suppliers have more opportunities to obtain information and to spread their risks. In some cases, they even have a dominant position in the market or enjoy a monopoly position. Energy use is just one component of the desired service for a consumer. Investments may be made at lowest first cost without due consideration to life cycle costs. This problem is known as the ‘payback gap’.21 The investment behaviour of firms, which is unsatisfying with regard to EE, cannot be explained by barriers such as organizational failure or ignorance, solely.22 On the contrary, it may be an expression of rationality not to invest in a technology that seems to be economically beneficial according to a net present value approach. This is explained, inter alia, by the uncertainty of future technological progress and the irreversibility of investments in new technology.23 Many analysts claim that an ‘energy efficiency gap’ exists between the most EETs available at some point in time and those that are actually in use. However, the extent to which these technologies reduce energy use through improved EE remains open to debate. To estimate the actual potential one has to distinguish first between EE and economic efficiency.
21
Geller and Nadel 1994. Wells and Hoffman (2000) point out that organizational structure create a fundamental barrier to corporate investment in energy efficiency. In most American firms, energy functions are managed by cost centres which operate at a two-year payback rule. 23 Van Soest and Bulte 2001. 22
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
87
Consider two air conditioners that are identical except that one has a higher EE and, as a result, is more costly to manufacture because high efficiency units require more cooling coils, larger evaporators, larger condensers as well as a greater research and development effort. On the other hand, using an engineering-economic model, the technologists define optimal EE by minimizing the total purchase and operating costs of an investment, where energy-operating costs are discounted at an appropriate discount rate. However, this approach does not describe all the issues that can influence EE investment decisions accurately. These issues relate to the fact that the weight given to different investment criteria by purchasers varies considerably. Investment criteria thereby are the purchaser’s discount rate, the investment lifetime, the price of energy, the purchase price and other costs. The magnitude of this ‘option-to-wait’ effect24 depends on projectspecific factors, such as the degree of energy price volatility, the degree of uncertainty with regard to investment costs and how fast energy and conservation technology prices change over time. Requiring consumers to purchase appliances with a higher level of efficiency based on a simplistic analysis could, in effect, impose extra costs on consumers.25 The result might be a higher level of EE, but a decrease in economic efficiency, as consumers could be forced to bear costs that they would have otherwise avoided. This gap suggests a role for policy measures focused on stimulating innovation and investments in EE improvement. Such policies would include the acceleration of technology development and demonstration, the stimulation of product demand through procurement activities, the application of efficiency standards, the influence of consumers’ energy-using behaviour, the organization of competitions between manufacturers for the most efficient products and the finding of ways to create markets for energy savings. Proponents of the EE gap suggest the consideration of alternative theories to gain new insights into the existence of this gap. Thompson, for
24 The techno-economic analysis does not account for changes over time in the savings that purchasers might enjoy from an extra investment in EE, which depends on trends and uncertainties in the prices of energy and conservation technologies. When making investments that can be delayed, such as the purchase of air-conditioning equipment, the presence of this uncertainty can lead to a higher investment-hurdle rate which is referred to as ‘option-to-wait’ effect. 25 Newell 2000.
88
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
instance, points out that a single cost-benefit approach to EE investments which merely tests whether an investment in EE is financed by its associated fuel savings may lead to an undervaluing of EE improvements. The author argues that in many cases the consumer will benefit from an increase in utility and comfort, even if the efficiency measure is not suggested by a simple cost-benefit test.26 A major issue that deserves to be mentioned explicitly here is that of risk. Let us assume that a consumer would like to insulate his house, but is afraid that his house may react to the injection of insulating material into the cavity wall by creating points where moisture can penetrate the wall. That would cause enormous costs of repair. That risk is not covered by any guarantee of insurance. It can act as a major deterrent to having the insulation put in. Even worse are the risks one does not know. Such risk issues, especially small chances of large liabilities, need to be covered by some form of insurance or guarantee, or the investor will not be able to follow the financially most favourable option. Another major issue is that of transaction costs and other frictions. Eric Ferguson points out that, in Yemen, bakeries use extremely inefficient ‘tannur’ stoves to bake bread. Better stoves could be developed. However, even if these stoves would save 50 per cent of the energy, the cost of energy is less than 10 per cent of the sales price of the bread. So the baker is not likely to go through the trouble of installing an improved ‘tannur’ stove, by spending about 5 per cent of his total turnover, and taking a risk if the technology goes wrong. He has far more urgent things to take care of. Technologies that are embedded well ‘have low transaction costs’. EE is not yet embedded well within society, and hence the transaction costs, in terms of time and effort, are high. Another risk is the credibility of the supplier of the EE technology. If problems arise, the investor faces the problem, not the supplier, unless there is a warranty attached to the technology and the supplier has the necessary financial reserves to back up the warranty. One approach which belongs to the aspect of theory, modelling and system boundary is the modelling of consumer behaviour. Opponents to the existence of an EE gap criticize the assumed rational consumer behaviour: If a consumer is informed appropriately and if the energy saving measure is
26 Thompson 2002. Clinch and Healey (2001) present a template for a comprehensive costbenefit analysis of domestic energy conservation programmes by including components such as health benefits and comfort benefits. See further Goodacre et al. 2002.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
89
cost effective, then the consumer will adopt it, due to his rational decision making. Box 4.2 shows assumptions of the so-called techno-economic model of change. Box 4.2 Ingredients of the Techno-economic Model of Change Decisions are made by relatively autonomous individuals—that is, people are free to make energy efficient decisions if they choose so; People do not make energy efficient decisions for many reasons: because they do not know-how to, they are not aware of the benefits, there is a price distortion in the market or there is a misalignment of interests; Once individuals are personally convinced that they have the necessary information, and they receive the correct pricing or regulatory signals, they will adopt proven and cost effective energy saving technologies. Source: Based on Guy and Shove 2000: 59.27
4.5 Energy Efficiency: A Technological Perspective Technological innovation is a key factor in microeconomic explanations of consumer behaviour. Technological change may be interpreted as sociotechnical innovation. The need or demand for clean clothes, as for instance, was satisfied by hand washing years ago, but is satisfied by automatic washing machines today. Technology mediates psychological needs and demand for products.28 Technology also plays a role in market models. Technological progress and technological advance are crucial in Schumpeter’s model of dynamic competition. In his market model, competition over innovations in products and processes is central. Innovations by advances in technological knowledge as well as cost reductions by new technology and economies of scale are necessary for firms to stay in the market.29 From this perspective, economically beneficial EETs may be interpreted as a source of competitive advantage. Technology is even conceptualized as a component of models
27
With permission from Thomson Publishing Services, UK. Wheelock 2000. 29 Brown 2000. 28
90
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
of capitalism. Improving the productivity of natural resources by changes in production process and technology is one of the four major shifts suggested by Lovins to achieve natural capitalism.30 The potential for EETs is quite large. In industry, electric motors offer the best opportunity to effect major saving potential. Replacing existing motor systems, which include inefficient motors, pumps, compressors or blowers with efficient ones can save electricity by 15–20 per cent. Also for an application, involving variable speed conditions, savings can be achieved by using electronic adjustable speed drives (ASDs), which control the speed of the motor depending on the process requirement. The ASDs can reduce electricity consumption by 15–20 per cent. After motors, lighting system represents another advance in providing significant conservation potential. Lighting innovations like the compact fluorescent tubes, electronic ballasts, advanced luminaries, reflectors or optical sensors can save electricity up to 60 per cent of the existing consumption levels. Other efficient technologies include waste heat recovery systems using absorption chillers, thermal cold storage for air conditioning, cogeneration of heat and electricity or efficient process technologies. The reason why the consumer can reduce energy consumption is very simple. Virtually, every technology, at present, uses far more energy than the minimum required by thermodynamic laws which specify the minimum amount of energy required to do the work. According to the European Commission, the ‘(…) average equipment used in the household sector in European Union (EU) countries is 50 per cent less efficient than the best equipment currently sold’.31 Some of the most common technology choices for private sector investment in EE are shown in Figure 4.2.32
4.6 Actors in the Field of Energy Efficiency There is a growing recognition that the usual investment decisions, such as payback period, rate of return on investment or net present value, do not account adequately for actual business behaviour. Technical solutions given in Figure 4.2 are not likely to succeed unless there is an interface between
30
Lovins et al. 2000. EC 2000, 142. 32 Technical experts at the World Bank Group and the Global Environment Facility 1997 (interviews). 31
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
91
Figure 4.2 Technology Choices for Private Sector Investment in Energy Efficiency
Source: Authors. Note: ∗ District heating is a system for distributing heat generated in a centralized location for residential and commercial heating requirements such as water heating.
92
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
various actors in the field of EE. Conventional energy programmes consist of only two main participants— suppliers and consumers. In contrast, the EE system consists of many actors, such as the equipment manufacturer, financial institutions, or non-governmental organizations (NGOs). If EE programmes are to be accepted widely, all of these parties should work together. Each actor relates to many other actors, experiences constraints and stimuli, has abilities and weaknesses, and holds rights, responsibilities and obligations. A series of decisions is the result. All the actors, and their decisions, describe the whole socio-technical structure and the processes that occur. Different categories of actors play various roles in the diffusion of EETs services to the consumers. These actors, such as, households, industries, commercial consumers, utilities, equipment manufacturers, planners, and so on, play a role in shaping the technology diffusion. The actors have interdependent influence. Each actor experiences constraints and stimuli; has abilities and weaknesses; and holds rights, responsibilities and obligations. All these lead to a series of decisions. A brief description of the role played by each of the major actors is given in the following sections:
Public Policy Institutions Public policy shaping institutions influence the EET market indirectly through taxes and subsidies. Taxes have a negative influence and subsidies a positive influence. Policy makers as actors of energy consumption work alongside those who frame policies pertaining to economics, technology and social welfare. The role of policy makers is to address the most pressing technology challenges facing the nation, including enhancing the efficiency of energy use. Sound energy policy requires more than a political balancing of popular interests. Because of the technological complexity of the national energy system, policy must also be consistent with technical and economic analyses.
Technology/Equipment Manufacturers In the chain of actors involved in the use of energy carriers, equipment manufacturers play an important role in optimizing fuel utilization. This is because they are the ones who supply energy-using devices. Their efficiency determines the benefits to various stakeholders. But households may not be
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
93
interested in efficiency per se. What they are interested in, is the cost, that is, the ratio of investment to useful energy. This is not related to ‘efficiency’. There are many technologies that are highly efficient, but many households do not adopt them because they are prohibitively expensive. At the other end of the scale, if a manufacturer develops a technology (say solar water heater) with an efficiency of only 5 per cent, but is still cheap for the energy it supplies, it can be an excellent solution, as the ‘fuel’ is free, and the households do not care if there is fuel wastage. Hence, the equipment manufacturer indirectly plays an important role in the fuel choice.
NGOs and Others NGOs have their own influence on the technology choice which is varied and distinct from other actors. For example, there are several NGOs who are active in countries like India in the field of renewable energy. They help lowincome households to obtain renewable energy technologies like biogas plants.
Consumers Consumers play an important role in the choice of technology and are the main actors. From the perspective of the consumers, the technology choice depends mainly on the annual energy budgets coupled with the availability of a particular technology. The costs of energy utilizing devices like stoves or water heaters also have an impact. Thus, the consumer makes a choice based on the desires and priorities, especially the financial resources and related constraints. However, there are other external actors who influence the choice. For example, the subsidies provided by the government have a positive role in the selection and use of a particular technology. Consumers as final end uses influence his or her decisions, influenced by almost all other actors.
Inter-relationships among Various Actors Actors do not act independently since several actors have similar goal, that is, to supply energy to consumers in a cost-effective manner. The interrelationship among the actors may be analyzed by using a diagram. Figure 4.3 shows the government at the highest level connected to energy suppliers who in turn are inter-related to the consumer through intermediaries. If we
94
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 4.3 Inter-relationships among Actors
Source: Authors.
want to change the existing system, we have to redesign the relationships among different actors and also introduce new actors. There is also a need for feedback mechanism from the consumers to the energy suppliers or the government.
Actor Analysis All the actors, and their decisions, describe the whole socio-technical structure and the processes that occur.33 Here we propose to classify actors into various levels, micro, meso, macro and meta. Micro level actors are those that influence at the lowest level, for example, at the consumer level. Meso level actors are those at the intermediate level, that is, in the supply stage. The macro level actors are at a higher level: state and central government, and the meta level actors are at the highest level, namely, international level. Here we develop a model which shows how various actors at the finance (meta), policy (macro), organizational (meso) and consumer (micro) levels influence EE. Modelling helps in identifying the causality as well as its intensity. Each actor in the field of EE has a specific function and responsibility. However, even without being an active performer, everyone can benefit 33
Reddy and Srinivas 2009.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
95
from the positive externalities of EE. The EE process needs cooperation and common achievement to be completed. Therefore, in order to promote EE-directed decisions, the government needs to establish structures which favour EE-directed decisions. Figure 4.4 illustrates actors in the field of EE from ‘macro’, ‘meso’, ‘meta’, and ‘micro’perspectives. Figure 4.4 Actors’ Perspectives
Source: Authors.
Level of Actors
Actors at the Micro Level The first ‘actor’ to look at is the consumer whose technology choices depend on the income, needs, prices, costs and availability of equipment and fuel, on the ‘status value’ of energy sources (‘for example, Liquefied petroleum gas [LPG] is more modern’) and on other factors. If we can find out the intensity of these choice factors it would help in predicting future behaviour. There are also NGOs who try to help the consumer in providing information about various energy technologies, availability, costs and benefits. To design better programmes, they are the persons/consumers to address (information, training, support by specialists, and so on).
96
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Actors at the Meso Level Organizations, such as utilities, energy development agencies, service companies, and so on are the actors at the meso level. These actors are the ‘intermediaries’, who trade in technologies/services. They play a major role in demonstrating energy savings through efficient systems. They gain from such campaigns and also contribute to creating awareness on EE.
Actors at the Macro Level These actors relate to the ‘higher-level’ institutions (state/market/civil society) that determine the setting under which the lower levels have to operate. These are the public utilities, which supply energy to consumers. There are also institutions (at national and state levels) that regulate tax and subsidies. Macro level actors are important because they have direct influence on the consumers.
Actors at the Meta Level These actors relate to the ‘highest-level’ institutions (World Bank/Asian Development Bank [ADB], Global Environment Facility [GEF], and so on) that help in obtaining finances to implement EE policies. These actors are very important since they have significant influence on the policy makers. Functions of actors in EE is shown in Table 4.1 along with their influencing variables.
Influence of Actors and Factors Technology choice analysis is facilitated by a state diagram depicting the influence of various factors and the corresponding actors. Figure 4.5 describes the Actor–Factor Influence Linkage state. Different types of actors, level of influence (low or high), and so on, are depicted. Household budget directly influences the fuel choice, whereas availability and price influence it indirectly. Policy makers have a great influence directly as well as indirectly. Actually the nature of influence can be graded, as low, medium or high. Here we take a descriptive approach.
Macro
Macro
Macro
Meso
Meso
Meso
Meta Meso
Micro
Micro
Governments
Energy supply agencies (Utilities)
Multilateral institutions
EE agencies
Business and industry enterprises
Equipment manufacturers
Financial institutions
Non-governmental organizations
Consumers
Source: Reddy and Srinivas 2009.
Level
Actors Establish legal and institutional frameworks; Integrate EE in decision making processes; Support administrative efforts to enhance EE; Provide transparent evaluations to learn and to guide. Improve energy services—supply, transmission and distribution; Propagate EE technologies; Change consumption patterns. Develop supporting instruments for monitoring and evaluation; Support mutual interest by adapting routines and instruments; Serve as a forum to disseminate results; Act as a clearing house to establish collaborative actions. Collect and propagate information about activities, experiences, programmes and projects; Develop and implement EE programmes. Disseminate the results achieved; Appeal to members to apply EE measures; Negotiate with partners involved in terms of achieving EE targets. Provide a whole range of devices—mechanical and electrical equipment—to the consumers; Cooperate on developing and later promoting EE technologies; Convince consumers to consider life cycle costs. Help to finance EE programmes; Cooperate with other agencies to implement common projects; Implement programmes and projects actively. Publicize best practice; Network to make use of the latest experiences in research, both in technology and applications. Collect appropriate information; Choice of technology.
Functions
Table 4.1 Functions of the Actors in Energy Efficiency
98
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 4.5 Actor–Factor Influence State Diagram
Source: Authors.
On one side we have the actors, such as policy makers, supply agents, and so on, classified into macro, meso and micro actors. A list of factors influencing the technology choice through the actors is shown against them—namely, budget, price of energy, and so on. The connecting linkages between the actors and factors show the actors’ role on the influencing factor. For example, subsidy and taxes have an influence through the policy makers. Similarly price and availability are the influencing factors through subsidy agents. Multiple linkages are possible since an agent may influence through several factors. Likewise, a factor may be influenced by many agents. In order to indicate the level of influence a weightage may be assigned to each linkage. Here three levels of influence are used: high, moderate and weak influence, indicated by red, blue and green lines. Such a state diagram can be useful to analyze the technology choice and the role of actors. Now, the objective of the analysis being to find out the optimal way to enable technology choice by consumers, we can suggest modifications to the linkages and their weightages or levels of influence. These should be based on the observations of the data available as tabulated in the previous sections. As an example, the household budget deters the low-income household to use LPG for cooking. So the state transition diagram may be modified to enhance the role of financial institutions by providing loans
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
99
at affordable rates to purchase LPG stoves. So this can be represented by a green to blue shift of weightage. Also new actors like entrepreneurs, NGOs, and so on, can be brought in to facilitate the transition. It is necessary to include extra slots for actors that may be influential in the future. Similarly, there may be factors that will become important in the future. Modification of state diagram is an effective way for effective fuel choice changes. The analytical approach presented above has the advantage of mathematical treatment. This can be implemented by introducing mathematical variable and functions representing the linkages. Also, the functional form may be chosen according to the corresponding weightages. The methodology of implementation consists of a list of all linkages that are modified. There are several possible state transitions as discussed further. Policy makers have a direct strong influence on the subsidy and a strong indirect influence on the price. Sometimes actors influence the factors whereas many times the factors are the main influence on actors. For example, external factors like the situation in oil importing countries influences public institutions/policy makers who in turn influence the availability. So Figure 4.5 also depicts the influence of external factors on the availability of resources. Most factors are inter-influential directly, which is shown by direct linkages. Thus, the representation can be used to analyze household fuel choice. The classification of actors into micro, meso, macro and meta greatly facilitates the analysis of role of actors. For example, household and supply intermediateries that are micro level actors influence directly, though aspects are different. They may be treated and analyzed similarly. In the next section, actor–factor linkages are analyzed using the state-diagram approach. For convenience, the inter-linkages discussed in this section are not considered explicitly.
Role of Actors: Needs and Priorities In order to achieve the goal of optimal stable state of actor influence leading to the highest level in the comfort ladder, their needs and priorities need to be analyzed accurately. First and the most important step is substituting inefficient technologies with efficient ones. As basic energy needs are met, consumer priorities shift to other, often higher quality services. Consumers can climb the technology ladder quickly due to shifts in technologies. This leads to an increasing stress on cleanliness, for environmental and health reasons on the one hand and the growing value placed on flexibility, saving time and avoiding disruptions on the other.
100
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
While implementing EE programmes, one has to take human behaviour into consideration. Although there are technologically feasible and economically meaningful potentials for reducing energy consumption levels, the number of measures that is implemented is very small. This is due to the ‘implementation gap’ which means relating existing potentials to real world implementation. Barriers for the implementation of these measures are not only the political and economical setting, such as for instance the externalization of environmental costs, but also the behaviour of actors and decision makers. Actually, the implementation of energy efficiency measures can be considered as an ongoing social process involving the interaction of different actors inside and outside organizations. The process comprises different stages: an initial stage of motivation or willingness to act, several steps of problem solving and a final stage, where continuation is possible on the basis of the experiences made by the different actors. As shown in Table 4.2, the process of implementation can be described as a spiralling process of learning by individuals and organizations.34 The process of implementation is not straightforward, following a rational plan, but tends to be incomplete and full of unexpected side effects. Plateaus, stops and fall backs to earlier stages are possible. The complexity of the process reveals itself if one tries to relate the various factors exactly to energy efficiency measures. Thus, all the factors listed below and the associated activities lead to a best performing organization with regard to energy use.
4.7 Energy Efficiency Policies Energy efficiency policies usually consist of instruments of governmental intervention into the energy market. These instruments aim to overcome barriers to investment in EE improvements. Although there are some standard policy measures for governmental intervention in markets, such as taxes, subsidies, laws, regulations and provision of information or provision of services, their application varies according to each sector, taking into account their different characteristics. Table 4.3 gives an overview of further policy-relevant features of energy sectors. The choice of applied policy instrument is not only a matter of rational and techno-economic consideration, but is strongly dependent on 34
Friedemann and Andreas 1997.
Programme funding
Marketing
Preparation for action
Participation
Innovative actions
Motivation
Risk assumption
Learning from experience Cost reduction Programme expenditure
Networking Test
Sense of mastery Social pressure Models and experiences Analyses
Commitment
Experiences and models
Social influence
Motives
Factors
Processes
(Table 4.2 Continued)
Innovative actions by stakeholders are important with regard to improving the image of the programme. Material incentives are seen as most effective while non-material ones are effective as supplementary elements. Social norms are influential as negative incentives, such as public pressure, while positive social incentives, such as rewards seem to work. Previous experience of an organization, as well as successful models and reports provided by organizations are helpful. Committed actors in the organization foster decisions, which are economically and environmentally sound. The willingness to overcome obstacles is decisive. Withstanding the pressure fostered from outside the organization. Distribute successful models and experience reports within the organization. Analyze the techno-economic baseline, one’s own skills and competencies as well as those of target groups. Create an early and broadly based cooperation with local actors. Make a test run of the EE programme (not only for monitoring the programme technically but also for commercial purposes). Orientation to exemplary precursor programmes. Dispelling the factors that hinder in target group, such as environmental and social costs. Reduction of programme expenditure by following routine activities, standardization and free provision of third party services. Risk assumption by suitable persons or institutions in the case of necessary pre-financing.
Actions
Table 4.2 Overview of Factors Fostering the Implementation of EE Programmes
Personal relevance
Source: Authors.
Feedback
Positive relations Publicity
Interaction
Measurement Process evaluation and corrections Keeping attention Motivation
Evaluation mechanism Monitoring
Social comparison
Face-to-face communication Opinion leaders
Feedback of intermediate results keeps the programme in people’s minds. Besides keeping attention and signalling the progress, feedback can generate community spirit and a feeling of belonging. It engenders further motivation to participate. Look at feedback as a precondition for generating a process of dialogue and interactive exchange between actors and participants. Feedback provides positive effect on the programme organizers (image, customer ties). Good contact with the local press is important for the mediation of feedback to the public.
Pay attention to local networks, clarity and real world practicality of the information and message conveyed. Communicate a wide variety of advantages of participating in the programme, taking aspects of economic efficiency into account. Use the word of mouth and personal discussions to step up knowledge of the programme. Secure participation of multipliers and opinion leaders, particularly with regional networks, and institutions without vested interests. Prompting processes of social comparison (neighbourhood, municipal district, etc.) and competition. Ongoing programme monitoring and evaluation is a precondition for systematic further development and organic integration into existing structures. Developing suitable standards and measuring instruments and indicators at the planning stage. Enable corrections in the course of the programme by means of process evaluation.
High effort
Public relations and information strategy
Advantages
Actions Find sources in addition to public budgets, e.g., via contributions, donations, participation fees, etc. High intensity of promotion and appropriate provision of funds.
Factors Additional sources
Processes
(Table 4.2 Continued )
10–50 years
> 30 years
> 10–15 years
> 50 years
Residential and commercial For example, buildings, appliances or office equipment
Gas, oil and power production
Industry For example, industrial equipment
Transport For example, infrastructure
35
Government and private sector actors at the local, regional and national levels. High complexity as local decisions have implications for national policy.
Relatively small number of decision makers, strongly driven by bottom line.
Small number of large players, sometimes government owned or regulated.
Large number of decision makers, such as individual consumer, contractors or financial institutions.
Key decision maker
Regulatory and social instruments; building energy efficiency standards, technical assistance, audits, fiscal incentives for improving thermal efficiency and labelling. Electricity and gas market liberalization and deregulation, subsidy reform, falling prices, natural gas gaining market share in power sector or shift in policies for environment. Voluntary approaches, search for eco-efficient materials and energy intensity improvements, some regulatory mechanisms which are widely exempted from environmental tax instruments. Limited climate policy initiatives, some regulatory reforms, land use and community planning interacting with national policy.
Main policy developments related to climate change
Based on OECD 1999c, 2003. National Climate Policies and the Kyoto Protocol, p. 37, with permission from OECD.
Source: Based on OECD 2003.35
Capital stock turnover
Sector
Table 4.3 Features of the Energy Sector Relevant to Policy
104
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
various actors.36 Most authors support the view that each policy instrument is linked to its own political economy and is distinct according to certain criteria of political choices, such as its degree of state intervention or the number of administrative and institutional resources needed.37 Labels and standards are examples of instruments which are widely used, especially to improve the EE of home appliances and office equipment—a sector of fast growing energy use.38 Labels inform about the energy use or EE of a certain product,39 while standards regulate minimum efficiency or maximum energy use levels for products in a mandatory way. The EU, for instance, applies labels on cloth dryers and washers, cloth washer-dryers, dishwashers and lamps as well as labels and standards on refrigerators and freezers. An outcome of the EU labelling programme was an improvement in EE of 6 per cent (from 2000 to 2004).40 Research and development (R&D) in EETs, such as low carbon fuels, advanced solar photo-voltaic technologies, is seen as long-term effort to reduce energy consumption levels. However, energy-related R&D carried out in an organized way by different actors and institutions, such as corporations, financial institutions or universities frequently does not achieve the expected short-term results. To help remedy this, the industry should play a key role in the development and implementation of new technologies. An efficient and productive approach to energy-related R&D requires the collaborative efforts of the government, industry and other organizations. There are two issues worth mentioning that highlight the complexity of the linkage between EE, R&D and policy. These are the concept of EE and the research environments which are interdependent. Different structures of interaction influence research priorities and the conceptualization of EE.41 Figure 4.6 gives an example of two possible research environments. These correlate with a certain degree of involvement of actors as far as the formulation of research schemes is concerned. Within the
36 OECD/IEA 2000; Varone and Aebischer 2001. In Varone and Aebischer (2001) a detailed empirical and comparative study of the applied policy instruments in the area of household appliances and office equipment in Canada, Denmark, United States, Sweden and Switzerland from 1973 to 1996 is given. OECD/IEA (2000) provides an overview over current labels and standards programmes in IEA countries. 37 Varone and Aebischer 2001, 617. 38 According to IEA 2006b, labels are used in 37 and standards in 34 countries. 39 Labels comprise different varieties, such as ‘comparison labels’ or ‘endorsement labels’ (OECD/IEA, 2000, 10). A famous example is the US Energy Star programme. 40 IEA 2006b. 41 Guy and Shove 2000.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
105
‘close communities’42 model, research schemes are negotiated informally among all actors. In contrast, within the ‘coordinated contractors’43 model, research schemes respond mainly to policy, whereas industry is not involved directly.44 This may have an impact on research objectives. Research management and funding further influences the range of disciplines considered and may hinder or enable opportunities for effective interdisciplinary inquiry.45 In the ‘close communities’ model, the disciplinary boundaries within which the energy problem is positioned were found to be relatively flexible, whereas in the ‘coordinated contractor’ model a more technical perspective dominates.46 Also the scientific institutions and research organizations should be seen as more or less impartial policy advisors and play an important role in reducing global environmental risks.47 Figure 4.6 Research Environments
Source: Guy and Shove 2000, 21ff.48
4.8 Conclusion The EE concept shifts the focus from energy generation to energy service. It provides a fertile ground for cost-effective technologies and managerial options in reducing energy consumption levels and thereby the environmental degradation. These EE programmes are appropriate where the efficiency of the device, especially the process is low and the energy 42
Ibid., 30. Ibid. 44 Guy and Shove 2000. 45 Lutzenhiser and Shove 1999. 46 Guy and Shove 2000. 47 Boehmer-Christiansen 2000. 48 Reprinted from Guy and Shove 2000, 21, 25 with permission from Thomson Publishing Services, UK. 43
106
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
intensities are high. These programmes should be developed on a long-term perspective of providing the right incentives to customers regarding the real cost of energy resources rather than short-term, rationing-oriented programmes. EE policies and programmes should be integrated with overall energy planning. The task of an EE programme is to create incentives for each actor to move towards reducing energy consumption levels. That is where one needs the actor-oriented approach. No institution should have a special and dominant status. However, at the same time, it seems fair to argue that without strong, forward looking, gradually introduced, and long-term signals by the government, other actors are unlikely to move forward decisively, even though in many countries other actors are actually the primary driving force for policy change. With regard to climate change issues, EE will be just one of many approaches, and probably not the principal one. We can discover that the Kyoto regime proposal which can probably be considered deceased fails to address some of the major actors effectively, and creates major new barriers and frictions. However, despite this situation we should use energy more efficiently in future than we are using it today. Therefore, the concern is not about whether to implement EE programmes or not, but when, how, where and how fast?
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
107
Appendix Concepts of Technological Efficiency49 A.1 Introduction While many people are familiar with the concept of first law efficiency, the notion of second law efficiency, suggested by Nakicenovic50 as an interesting, often more adequate definition of EE, is rather unknown. Here, we explain the concept of second law or entropy efficiency with a stylized example. The comparison of this concept to the notion of first law or energetic efficiency indicates that estimates about current efficiency improvement potentials depend heavily upon the efficiency concept employed. Moreover, we explain why prevailing energy efficiencies are grossly overestimated when measured in terms of first law efficiencies. High figures that are commonly reported for the first law efficiencies of current technologies lead to the impression that efficiency improvement potentials are almost exhausted. These high figures represent negative signals and, therefore, serious barriers on the route to a sustainable economic development via the accomplishment of high efficiency standards. In fact, the world-wide average of the second law efficiency of electricity consumption, for example, is estimated by Gilli et al. to be lower than 6 per cent.51 Thus, efficiency improvements appear to be promising52 and might be an important part of a broader strategy to restructure energy systems with respect to a sustainable economic development.
A.2 The Concepts of First and Second Law Efficiency The basic difference between both concepts is that while first law efficiency solely relates to the specific technology applied in order to satisfy certain tasks, for example, illumination and space heating, the concept of second law efficiency takes into account both the actual technology employed and the technology that would theoretically be the best for the same task. Our following example on whether to heat a house with either electric furnaces or heat pumps illustrates the difference between these two concepts. 49
This appendix is prepared by Manuel Frondel and Dirk Rubbelke. Nakicenovic 1996. 51 Gilli 1995. 52 See also Frondel et al. 2002. 50
108
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
Consider a house that shall be heated up to the temperature of Tin = 21°C, while the outside temperature remains Tout = 1°C. Among a great variety of technologies available for this task, heating with furnaces is one of the methods mostly used, whereas heat pumps are rarely employed. When, for instance, an electric furnace is used, electric energy is transformed into heat. In practice, a part of the electric energy provided by a power plant cannot be transformed into the desired heat. That means, depending upon the furnace, more or less of the electric energy is wasted. The concept of first law efficiency measures the ratio of the minimum energy per time, such as for instance, the minimum power that is theoretically required to the power that is actually necessary to maintain a constant temperature with this electric furnace:
ε1 =
Pmin (electric furnace) Pactual (electric furnace)
(1)
The power that is actually necessary, Pactual (electric furnace), may be split into two parts: the minimum power Pmin (electric furnace) that is necessarily required and an amount of power that is wasted. Only if no power is wasted the first law efficiency will amount to 100 per cent. An ideally working furnace is an example. In practice, however, ε1 is smaller than 100 per cent. Typically, first law efficiencies of electric furnaces are in the range of 70 to 80 per cent, with best performing electric furnaces operating with efficiencies greater than 90 per cent. For the sake of simplicity, we assume that our electric furnace is perfect in terms of first law efficiencies: ε1 = 100 per cent. In this case, the minimum electric power is required to maintain the temperature level Tin (Figure A4.1), because the electric power Pel delivered is transformed completely into heat power, Pheat. Moreover, an . entropy flux S is produced by the furnace, providing the heat service ultimately desired. Due to imperfect insulation, the entropy flux produced is exported gradually, requiring a permanent heating. This heat or entropy production is similar to the Figure A4.1 Comparison of Energy and Entropy Flows of (a) Electric Furnace and (b) Heat Pump
Source: Reynolds and Lunnas 1978.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
109
entropy-producing rubbing of hands in order to warm them. A person who rubs his/her hands on a cold winter day experiences what entropy production is. Unlike an ideal electric furnace, a heat pump ideally does not produce entropy. Rather, the heat pump merely imports entropy from outside the house. Yet, without a heat pump, entropy, especially heat, would not flow from the lower temperature Tout to the higher temperature Tin by itself. By itself entropy, especially heat, flows from higher to lower temperatures. This is the reason why a heat pump is indispensable for delivering the heat power desired. As do electric furnaces, heat pumps run on electricity. Recall that, in our example, the heat pump is assumed to work ideally, that is, its first law efficiency equals 100 per cent. In other words, the electric power which is necessary for heating the house with a perfect heat pump equals precisely the minimum electric energy. Hence, both the ideal electric furnace and the ideal heat pump work equally well in terms of first law efficiency. Nevertheless, the furnace technology is inferior to that of the heat pump. For Tin = 21°C = 294 K and Tout = 1°C = 274 K, we obtain from the laws of physics.53 ⋅
Pel (heat pump) (Tin − Tout ) ⋅ S 20 K = = = 0.073 ⋅ Pel (furnace) 294 K T ⋅S
(2)
in
The minimum electric power required by the heat pump is lower than 8 per cent of the electric power required by the furnace for the same amount of heat power desired. Theoretically, a heat pump is the best technology. It needs only a minimum amount of electric power for the task of space heating because the heat pump imports almost all the heat from outdoors. On the other hand, an electric furnace is the worst technology. It requires the maximum amount of electric power for the same task, as no heat is imported at all (see Figure A4.1). Rather, the entire heat is produced inside. Inspired by equation (4.2) Nakicenovic54 as well as Frondel and Rubbelke55 define second law efficiency as the ratio of minimum power required by the theoretically best technology to the minimum power necessary for the technology actually employed in order to achieve the same task:56
ε2 =
Pmin (theoretically best technology ) . Pmin (actually applied tecchnology)
(3)
By definition, second law efficiency refers to both the technology actually employed and to the technology that would, at least theoretically, be the best. By contrast, first law efficiency relates only to the technology actually employed. 53
See Frondel and Rubbelke 2002, 290 and Figure 1. Nakicenovic 1996. 55 Frondel and Rubbelke 2002. 56 Nakicenovic (1996, 81) define second law efficiency as the ratio of theoretical minimum energy consumption for a particular task to the actual energy consumption for the same task. 54
110
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
The miserable second law efficiency performance of electric furnaces reflects the poor match of the technology employed and the purpose for which energy is used: Heating with the help of electricity is a sin in terms of entropy because electricity has to be generated with some effort and is accompanied by a production of entropy in the form of waste heat. The high-quality energy in the form of electricity is misused for heating purposes, producing entropy in the form of heat once again, albeit desired now. With respect to entropy considerations, it would be better to use gas and to produce entropy in the form of desired heat only once. As far as first law efficiencies are concerned; such questions are not an issue. No alternatives, exclusively the technology actually employed, are taken into account. From this limited point of view and given the high first law efficiencies with which electric energy is transformed into the desired heat, heating with electricity seems to be a big deal. However, the fact that the second law efficiency is lower than 8 per cent in this example stresses the mismatch of the application of high-quality energy for low-quality energy services.
A.3 Real World Second Law Efficiencies Second law efficiencies as low as in our stylized example are far from being unrealistic. The second law efficiency of overall electricity consumption, for example, is estimated by Gilli et al. to be lower than 6 per cent on a world-wide average.57 In contrast to low second law efficiencies, however, commonly high first law efficiencies support the impression that further efficiency improvements are hardly possible. Moreover, while our example merely focuses on the efficiency with which space heating is accomplished by final energy in the form of electricity, we have to take into account that electricity must be produced out of primary energy. Figure A4.2 World-wide Averages of Second-law Efficiencies for the Generation and Transformation of Electricity into Energy Services
Source: Frondel and Rubbelke 2002.
57
Gilli et al. 1995.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
111
In Figure A4.2, efficiency considerations are extended to the complete generation and transformation chain, starting with primary energy and ending with the supply of the desired energy service. Figure A4.2 displays world-wide averages of second law efficiencies appraised by Gilli et al.58 for each conversion step. While primary energy carriers like coal, gas, and oil are transformed into final energy in the shape of electricity with rather high second law efficiencies –ε2 is about 72 per cent, including distribution losses, the least efficient part of the chain is the end use of electricity by consumers. Electricity is converted into useful energy, such as for instance for heating purposes, by consumption technologies, such as electric furnaces, with a second law efficiency whose world-wide average is estimated to be as low as 14 per cent.59 At a first glance, it looks like the final step. However, an energy service, such as heating a house, would require less useful energy if the house had better insulation. For such reasons, a final, artificial conversion step from useful energy to the ultimately desired energy service is introduced by Gilli et al.60 for which these authors appraise a second law efficiency of about 40 per cent. Hence, according to Gilli et al.61 the second law efficiency of electricity consumption is only about 5.6 per cent on an average, world-wide. This percentage suggests that there is a potential for efficiency improvements in the consumer’s sphere that is much higher than the potential in the producer’s sphere. Overall, the world-wide average of the entropy efficiency of all steps that are necessary to provide an energy service with the help of electricity is as low as 4 per cent. Low estimates of world-wide averages of second law efficiencies for the generation and transformation of electricity into energy services provided by Gilli et al.62 support our example, which indicates that much more efficient technologies than those currently applied might be available. Above all, ‘(…) end-use devices are on average the least efficient components of the energy system’.63 This result promises a higher potential for efficiency improvements in electricity consumption than in electricity generation. But how can we explain that the most efficient technologies are not implemented? Economic reasons, such as high time preference rates of consumers still prevent highly efficient consumption technologies, such as power-saving light bulbs, from being the current technical standard, although these technologies offer long run economic advantages for consumers.64 Prohibitively high information costs for consumers, partially caused by the common impression of high first law efficiencies, are but one example of those reasons and market failures. These problems could be solved by information programmes, energy contracting and demand-side management.
58
Gilli et al. 1995. Ibid. 60 Ibid. 61 Ibid. 62 Ibid. 63 Nakicenovic 1996, 18. 64 Ekins 1995. 59
112
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
A.4 Conclusion In this contribution, we have illustrated the concept of second law efficiency with a stylized example. We have highlighted that technological efficiency potentials are, by far, not exhausted. This result contradicts common impressions of high technological efficiencies that are based on the concept of first law efficiency. The discrepancy is a consequence of the major distinction between both concepts. While first law efficiencies solely refer to the single technology actually applied for a special task, the concept of second law efficiency takes into account the purpose for which energy is required and relates two technologies to each other: the technology actually employed and the optimal technology for the same purpose. Space heating, for example, can be achieved more efficiently—in terms of second law efficiencies—and perhaps less expensively—in terms of marginal cost—on the basis of gas such as for instance, rather than by high-quality energy in the form of electricity. The concept of second law efficiency particularly emphasizes the mismatch of applying high-quality energy for low-quality energy services, such as space heating. In sum, with respect to both a sustainable economic development and an economically more efficient use of energy, it would be desirable in many situations if agents were better informed and took account of the purposes for which energy is required. However, although the potential for efficiency improvements seems to be substantial when technological efficiency is measured by the concept of second law efficiency, technological progress is only a necessary, yet not sufficient, condition for reducing pollutant emissions. The question is whether the rates of efficiency improvements will be higher than the world’s increasing rates of energy requirements. It is the level of real energy prices—which is partially affected by energy taxes— that will determine the answer to this question. Increasing energy prices may induce income and substitution effects that possibly dampen the future world-wide rise of energy demand. Moreover, a rise in energy prices may stimulate R&D, environmental innovation and demand-side management. Finally, higher prices might enhance the efficiency level of, specifically, consumption technologies.
5 The Benefits and Drawbacks of Energy Efficiency
The aim of this chapter is to discuss the methods of assessing the advantages and drawbacks of energy-efficient technologies (EET) as well as projects. It is a proven fact that in specific situations and well-chosen energy efficiency (EE) proposals, benefits significantly outweigh drawbacks. However, it is important to mention the perceived and actual disadvantages and complications. In the present chapter, both these aspects are discussed from the perspective of the governments, businesses establishments and households. As the scope of investigation is a global one and the resulting drawbacks as well as benefits emerge out of a specific situation, this chapter should be understood as giving directions of thought rather than empirical evidence. The purpose of this chapter is to help the reader decide which EE programmes would give positive effects, and which would not, based on which he can learn to discriminate between alternative EE proposals.
5.1 Introduction Energy efficiency improvements have multiple advantages, such as the efficient utilization of natural resources, reduction in air pollution levels and lower spending by the consumer on energy-related expenditure. Investments in EE result in long-term benefits, such as reduced energy consumption, local environmental enhancement and overall economic development. Energy use has environmental impacts, regardless of the source or mechanism.
114
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
For example, hydroelectric projects affect their local ecological systems and displace long-standing social systems. Fossil fuel power creates pollution in the extraction, transportation and combustion of its raw materials. The long-term storage of the waste products of the nuclear power industry is an issue yet to be resolved. Cost-effective energy efficiency is the ultimate multi-pollutant reduction strategy. Many win-win opportunities for EET exist, which can provide benefits in terms of the following dimensions: domestic and global, environmental and economic, as well as benefits for multiple stakeholders in society. There are ways to ensure benefits for all parties, including the government, companies and consumers. Sectors for EE include industries, commercial establishments, households, municipal buildings, as well as transportation and agriculture. The industry category includes such heavy energy users like cement, aluminium, glass, chemicals, and pulp and paper. EE applies to various human activities like private, public or industrial. Each such activity has an actor who is carrying it out. One actor produces energy, another supplies technology while other actors market or use the technology or make policy decisions. If the central actor wants to introduce EE, he or she needs to contact the other actors to succeed. Many a time, the projects may fail even if the technology is valid and, conversely, may succeed even if the technology is not a sensible one.1 There are three consequences of these developments in EE. First, the EETs will make industries more efficient by improving the productivity of labour, leading to higher growth rates for many economies. Second, these new technologies require less electricity, petroleum products and gas as their fuel. The global demand for these carriers, then, will be less than it would have been without the technologies. Third, the efficient technologies afford business firms the opportunity to become global, moving their operations from one country to another on the basis of local economic and political considerations. As a result of these developments, policy makers should focus attention on the EE.
5.2 Benefits of Energy Efficiency The short- and long-term benefits of EE are given in Table 5.1. In households, improving the efficiency of energy use resulting in reduced energy requirement to provide a given amount of lighting, cooking, heating and other services is equivalent to an increase in income on account of 1
Dr Eric Ferguson 2003 (personal communication).
THE BENEFITS AND DRAWBACKS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
115
Table 5.1 Positive Aspects of Energy Efficiency Short-term benefits
Long-term benefits
Reduces load, peak demand and energy use
Less oil wells, refineries, forests, land, water, etc. Less subject to security risks and interruptions Creates jobs and improves the economy Less subject to market and fuel price volatility Improve economic development Less transport (fuels to the energy generating places) Less health impacts Reduced environmental impacts (a) Local pollutants (b) Global pollutants (c) Water use Increases energy security
Reduces market prices for all consumers Often less costly and more cost effective Less subject to market and fuel price volatility No transportation and distribution costs Short gestation periods Fuel is saved Plantations are saved
Reduces local pollutants Improved quality of service Source: Authors.
reduced expenditure. In the long run, households enjoy the benefit of lower expenditures on energy, while increasing their comfort and well-being. For commercial and industrial sectors, using energy more efficiently reduces the cost of producing goods and services. This in turn can translate into lower production costs, higher output and more profits in the short term. The lower product price results in increased sales. This means that these sectors employ more workers to satisfy the increased demand for their products. The increased employment, of course, improves the performance of the local economy. The governments can also benefit from energy efficiency improvements as government-owned buildings can use less electricity, oil, gas and water. They can also use less electricity for street lighting. The local transport system that uses petrol and diesel fuel will save significant amounts of money if EETs are used. Similarly, reducing congestion and other measures can have a marked impact on local environmental conditions if a community currently relies on automobiles for local transportation. Global environmental conditions can improve to the extent that local energy efficiency improvements will reduce consumption of energy sources that produce greenhouse gases (GHGs). There is also an opportunity cost involved in the increase of EE. The increase in the efficiency results in reducing the resource utilization. The governments can use these resources to reduce taxes or increase spending on other goods and services. Local and
116
ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
global environmental conditions can improve if households, business enterprises and governments use energy more efficiently. EE programmes have widespread and diverse environmental impacts that go beyond GHG impacts. The environmental benefits associated with EE programmes can be just as important as the global warming benefits. Potential environmental impacts that need to be considered are presented in Box 5.1. Direct and indirect programme impacts need to be examined, as well as ‘avoided negative environmental impacts’ (for example, the deferral of the construction of a new power plant). Both gross and net impacts need to be evaluated. Box 5.1 Energy Efficiency and the Indoor Environment In developing countries, fuels are often burned in inefficient stoves, with inadequate or in many cases non-existent chimneys. The resulting indoor air pollution exposes families to particulates, carbon monoxide and other products of combustion. The costs of the failure to recognize the energy development linkage is evident in the nations’ health statistics. Studies indicate high risk, such as acute respiratory infections (ARI), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), lung cancer and also tuberculosis (TB), asthma and blindness. In India, conservative estimates indicate that some 400–550 thousand premature deaths can be attributed annually to the use of biomass fuels in these population groups. Using a disability-adjusted lost life-year approach, the total is 4–6 per cent of the Indian national burden of disease, placing indoor air pollution as a major risk factor in the country. In a more recent study, respiratory diseases across all age groups cost the South African Department of Health USD 75 million in treatment costs alone. In addition to these costs, there are productivity and quality of life losses which are more difficult to quantify, but could conceivably add up to tens of millions of dollars equivalent per year. Substituting efficient fuel wood stoves in place of inefficient stoves or shifting from fuel wood to LPG can solve these problems. Source: Reddy and Srinivas 2009.
5.3 Energy Efficiency—Actors’ Perspectives EE programmes provide economic, environmental and social benefits for two reasons. First, the persistence of GHG reductions and the sustainability of EE programmes depend on individuals and local organizations that help support a programme during its lifetime. Both direct and indirect programme benefits will influence the motivation and commitment of programme participants. Hence, focusing only on environmental impacts
THE BENEFITS AND DRAWBACKS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY
117
would present a misleading picture of what is needed in making a programme successful or making its environmental benefits sustainable. Second, the diverse group of stakeholders (for example, government officials, project managers, non-profit organizations, community groups, project participants and international policy makers) are interested in, or involved in, EE programmes and are concerned about their multiple impacts. Looking at the perspectives of various actors should help to improve the credibility of the programme (by showing stakeholders that these impacts have, at least, been considered) as well as facilitate the review of EE programmes.
Governmental Perspective This perspective looks at the net costs of the EE project as a resource option based on the total costs to the government and the customer. Energy efficiency issues that also need to be looked at from the government perspective include national development goals, social equity, national priorities, selfreliance, energy security, policy making as well as institution forming. Energy inefficiency plagues almost all of the developing countries that face energy shortages. The process of reforms that are taking place in many developing countries emphasizes appropriate pricing and efficiency in the use of resources, including energy resources. Programmes to promote energy efficiency and incentives to adopt efficiency improving measures play an important role. A significant benefit from improved energy efficiency is the reduction in GHG emissions and a well practiced concept to facilitate parts of the Kyoto Protocol (1997) and further governmental agreements concerning environmental issues.2 Studies carried out at the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research (IGIDR), Bombay, India, reveal that the power sector is responsible for the highest direct CO2 emissions in India, followed by iron and steel, road and