Enterprise Interoperability IV
Keith Popplewell • Jenny Harding Raul Poler • Ricardo Chalmeta Editors
Enterprise Interoperability IV Making the Internet of the Future for the Future of Enterprise
123
Organiser
Promoter
Editors Professor Keith Popplewell Coventry University Future Manufacturing Applied Research Centre CV1 5FB Coventry UK
[email protected] Doctor Jenny Harding Loughborough University Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering Leicestershire LE11 3TU UK
[email protected]
Professor Raul Poler Polytechnic University of Valencia Research Centre on Production Management and Engineering EPSA Pza Ferrandiz y Carbonell, 2 03801 Alcoy Spain
[email protected] Doctor Ricardo Chalmeta Universidad Jaume I. Av Sos Banyant Grupo de Integración y Re-Ingeniería de Sistemas DLSI s/n 12071 Castellon Spain
[email protected]
ISBN 978-1-84996-256-8 e-ISBN 978-1-84996-257-5 DOI 10.1007/978-1-84996-257-5 Springer London Dordrecht Heidelberg New York British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Control Number: 2010923777 © Springer-Verlag London Limited 2010 Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing off the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence off a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions that may be made. Cover design: eStudioCalamar, Figueres/Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface Keith Popplewell1, Jenny Harding2, Raul Poler3, Ricardo Chalmeta4 1
2
3
4
Future Manufacturing Applied Research Centre, Coventry University CV1 5FB Coventry (United Kingdom) General Chairperson of I-ESA’10
[email protected] Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering Loughborough University Leicestershire LE11 3TU (United Kingdom) General co-Chairperson of I-ESA’10
[email protected] Research Centre on Production Management and Engineering Polytechnic University of Valencia EPSA. Pza Ferrandiz y Carbonell, 2, 03801 Alcoy (Spain) Chairperson of the I-ESA’10 International Programme Committee
[email protected] Grupo de Integración y Re-Ingeniería de Sistemas. DLSI. Universidad Jaume I. Av Sos Banyant s/n 12071 Castellon (Spain) co-Chairperson of the I-ESA’10 International Programme Committee
[email protected]
Enterprise Interoperability (EI) is the ability of an enterprise or more generally an organisation to work with other enterprises or organisations without special effort. The capability to interact and exchange information both internally and with external organisations (partners, suppliers, customers, citizens…) is a key issue in the economic and public sector. It is fundamental in order to produce goods and/or services quickly and at lower cost, while ensuring higher levels of quality, customisation, services and security. Today, Enterprises maximise flexibility and speed of response to changing external conditions. They develop knowledge of, and links with, other Enterprises or Organisations with which they can collaborate to provide the products and services that customers demand. The issue of interoperability within the Enterprise is therefore no longer limited to the interoperability between silos of systems within single companies, but has become one of interoperability throughout a Network of Enterprises. I-ESA’10 (Interoperability for Enterprise Software and Applications) is the sixth of a series of conferences, this time under the motto “Making the internet of the future for the future of enterprise”. As Europe and the world focus research on a Future Internet of Things, Services, Knowledge and People, the opportunities for enterprise collaboration are expanding. The focus of interoperability research and
vi
Preface
application is therefore on these opportunities and the new technologies and methodologies needed to exploit the Future Internet to the full. I-ESA’10 reports on current research in this field, as well as the underlying developments in enterprise interoperability which have been the foundation for this domain. The I-ESA’10 Conference was organized by Coventry University and the Virtual Laboratory for Enterprise Interoperability (INTEROP-VLab) and sponsored by the International Federation for Information Processing (IFIP). The world's leading researchers and practitioners in the area of Enterprise Integration from government, industry and academia have contributed to this book. As a result, Enterprise Interoperability IV is a unique anthology presenting visions, ideas, research results, industrial experiences and problems on business interoperability. This book is organized in seven parts addressing the major research in the scope of Interoperability for Enterprise Software and Applications: I II III IV V VI VII
Business Interoperability Enterprise Modeling for Enterprise Interoperability Semantics for Enterprise Interoperability Architectures and Frameworks for interoperability Platforms for Enterprise Interoperability Interoperability Scenarios and Case Studies Standards for Interoperability
Coventry Loughborough Alcoy Castellón April 2010
Keith Popplewell Jenny Harding Raul Poler Ricardo Chalmeta
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank all the authors, invited speakers, International Programme Committee members, International Senior Programme Committee members, Steering Committee members and participants of the conference that made this book a reality and the I-ESA’10 a success. We express our gratitude to all organizations which supported the I-ESA’10 preparation, especially the Virtual Laboratory for Enterprise Interoperability (INTEROP-VLab) and its UK Pole and the International Federation for Information Processing (IFIP). We are deeply thankful to the local organization support notably Joanna Sychta, Muqi Wulan, Mohammad Al-Awamleh and Shagloof Dahkil for their excellent work for the preparation and the management of the conference.
Contents
Part I Business Interoperability Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration Jean-Pierre Lorre, Yiannis Verginadis, Nikos Papageorgiou and Nicolas Salatge ......................................................................................................... 3 Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems Sundar Gopalakrishnan and Guttorm Sindre ......................................................... 13 Conceptual Framework for the Interoperability Requirements of Collaborative Planning Process María M.E. Alemany, Faustino Alarcón, Francisco C. Lario and Raul Poler ....... 25 Improving Interoperability using a UML Profile for Enterprise Modelling Reyes Grangel, Ricardo Chalmeta, Cristina Campos and Sergio Palomero ......... 35 Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds Nenad Ivezic, Jungyub Woo and Hyunbo Cho ....................................................... 47 Unified Reversible Life Cycle for Future Interoperable Enterprise Distributed Information Systems Zhiying Tu, Gregory Zacharewicz and David Chen ............................................... 57 Part II Enterprise Modeling for Enterprise Interoperability A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling Shang Gao and John Krogstie ................................................................................ 69
x
Contents
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using PiOCL Johan Ullberg, Ulrik Franke, Markus Buschle and Pontus Johnson ..................... 81 A UML-based System Integration Modeling Language for the Application System Design of Shipborne Combat System Fan Zhiqiang, Gao Hui, Shen Jufang and Zhang Li .............................................. 91 Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems Focusing on Data Storage System Guillaume Vicien, Yves Ducq and Bruno Vallespir .............................................. 101 GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable ESA Lanshun Nie, Xiaofei Xu, David Chen, Gregory Zacharewicz and Dechen Zhan......................................................................................................... 111 Model for Trans-sector Digital Interoperability António Madureira, Frank den Hartog, Eduardo Silva and Nico Baken ............. 123 Transformation from a Collaborative Process to Multiple Interoperability Processes Hui Liu and Jean-Pierre Bourey .......................................................................... 135 Part III Semantics for Enterprise Interoperability A Manufacturing Foundation Ontology for Product Life Cycle Interoperability Zahid Usman, Robert I.M. Young, Keith Case and Jenny A. Harding ................. 147 A Semantic Mediator for Data Integration in Autonomous Logistics Processes Karl Hribernik, Christoph Kramer, Carl Hans and Klaus-Dieter Thoben .......... 157 An Ontology Proposal for Resilient Multi-plant Networks Rubén Darío Franco, Guillermo Prats and Rubén de Juan-Marín ...................... 169 Collaboration Knowledge Ontologies to Support Knowledge Management and Sharing in Virtual Organisations Muqi Wulan, Xiaojun Dai and Keith Popplewell ................................................. 179 Mediation Information System Engineering for Interoperability Support in Crisis Management Sébastien Truptil, Frédérick Bénaben, Nicolas Salatgé, Chihab Hanachi, Vincent Chapurlat, Jean-Paul Pignon and Hervé Pingaud.................................. 187 Service Value Meta-Model: An Engineering Viewpoint Zhongjie Wang, Xiaofei Xu, Chao Ma and Alice Liu ........................................... 199
Contents
xi
Part IV Architectures and Frameworks for interoperability An Interoperable Enterprise Architecture to Support Decentralized Collaborative Planning Processes in Supply Chain Networks Jorge E. Hernández, Raul Poler and Josefa Mula ............................................... 213 Business Cooperation-oriented Heterogeneous System Integration Framework and its Implementation Yihua Ni, Yan Lu, Haibo Wang, Xinjian Gu and Zhengxiao Wang ...................... 225 Collaboration Knowledge Management and Sharing Services to Support a Virtual Organisation Muqi Wulan, Xiaojun Dai and Keith Popplewell ................................................. 235 Developing a Science Base for Enterprise Interoperability Yannis Charalabidis, Ricardo J. Goncalves and Keith Popplewell ..................... 245 From Pipes-and-Filters to Workflows Thorsten Scheibler, Dieter Roller and Frank Leymann ....................................... 255 Risk Sources Identification in Virtual Organisation Mohammad Alawamleh and Keith Popplewell..................................................... 265 Service-based Model for Enterprise Interoperability: Context-Driven Approach Alexander Smirnov, Tatiana Levashova and Nikolay Shilov ................................ 279 Transformation of UML Activity Diagram to YAWL Zhaogang Han, Li Zhang and Jimin Ling ............................................................ 289 Part V Platforms for Enterprise Interoperability Gap Analysis of Ontology Mapping Tools and Techniques Najam Anjum, Jenny Harding, Bob Young and Keith Case ................................. 303 Networked Enterprise Transformation and Resource Management in Future Internet Enabled Innovation Clouds Brian Elvesæter, Arne-Jørgen Berre, Henk de Man and Man-Sze Li................... 313 Opportunity Discovery Through Network Analysis Alessandro Cucchiarelli and Fulvio D’Antonio ................................................... 323 Reflections on Aspects of Enterprise Interoperability Jane Hall and Klaus-Peter Eckert ........................................................................ 331 Specification of SETU with WSMO Wout Hofman, Menno Holtkamp and Michael van Bekkum ................................. 341
xii
Contents
Part VI Interoperability Scenarios and Case Studies A Success Story: Manufacturing Execution System Implementation Albin Bajric, Kay Mertins, Markus Rabe and Frank-Walter Jaekel .................... 357 Enabling Proactive Behaviour of Future Project Managers Georgios Kapogiannis, Terrence Fernando, Mike Kagioglou, Gilles Gautier and Collin Piddington ................................................................................................. 367 Gaps to Fill Between Theoretical Interoperable Quality and Food Safety Environment and Enterprise Implementations David Martínez-Simarro, Jose Miguel Pinazo Sánchez and Raquel Almarcha Vela.......................................................................................... 377 How to Develop a Questionnaire in Order to Measure Interoperability Levels in Enterprises Noelia Palomares, Cristina Campos and Sergio Palomero ................................. 387 Knowledge Sharing and Communities of Practices for Intra-organizational Interoperability Philippe Rauffet, Catherine Da Cunha and Alain Bernard .................................. 397 Part VII Standards for Interoperability Aligning the UEML Ontology with SUMO Andreas L. Opdahl ............................................................................................... 409 Emerging Interoperability Directions in Electronic Government Yannis Charalabidis, Fenareti Lampathaki and Dimitris Askounis ..................... 419 Enterprise Collaboration Maturity Model (ECMM): Preliminary Definition and Future Challenges Juncal Alonso, Iker Martínez de Soria, Leire Orue-Echevarria and Mikel Vergara....................................................................................................... 429 Towards a Conceptualisation of Interoperability Requirements Sihem Mallek, Nicolas Daclin and Vincent Chapurlat ......................................... 439 Use Profile Management for Standard Conformant Customisation Arianna Brutti, Valentina Cerminara, Gianluca D’Agosta, Piero De Sabbata and Nicola Gessa......................................................................................................... 449 Index of Contributors ........................................................................................... 461
Part I
Business Interoperability
Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration Jean-Pierre Lorre1, Yiannis Verginadis2, Nikos Papageorgiou2 and Nicolas Salatge1 1 2
EBM WebSourcing, 4 rue Amélie, Toulouse, France Institute of Communications and Computer Systems, National Technical University of Athens, 9 Iroon Polytechniou Str., Athens, Greece
Abstract. Industrial enterprises realize that in order to function and survive in constantly changing grounds, they need to collaborate dynamically by forming network-based collaborative alliances of a temporary nature. During such collaborations, several segments of work can be often identified as recurring and be reused. The exploitation of this repetition is considered to be critical for these environments, so approaches that propose the use of Collaboration Patterns (CPats), seen as loose workflows of services, can be proven valuable. In this paper we present the use of CPats in virtual organizations that are executed in an ad hoc way. We propose a schema that combines the initiatives of CPats along with a dynamic service orchestration engine based on an autonomic framework called Fractal. Such approach allows reorganizing service workflow at run-time in order to take into account collaboration network plasticity. Keywords: Collaboration pattern, SOA, dynamic service orchestration, BPEL
1. Introduction Modern industrial enterprises as complex and dynamic management systems can be considered as a myriad of concurrent processes executed by a huge set of technological or human entities. In a competitive market environment, these enterprises cope with critical challenges, in order to survive, by trying to establish efficient collaborative mechanisms that may even span their intra-organizational frontiers. The basic motivation behind the necessity of collaborating network enterprises is the intention of exploiting new business opportunities, delivering superior quality products and services and at the same time keeping the production cost as low as possible [1] [2]. Enterprises often realize that the single enterprise model is no longer sufficient to cover all aspects of their needs and try to take part in enterprise collaborative formations referred to as virtual organizations (VOs) [3], [4], [5]. In a virtual
4
J.P. Lorre, Y. Verginadis, N. Papageorgiou and N. Salatge
organization, the participating firm is no longer a physical entity with a stable mission. Instead it is a dynamic entity systematically involved in temporary alliance via networks structures [6]. In such dynamic and virtual but legally consolidated schemas, the arising collaboration issues are considered to be of critical importance. In these challenging environments there is a need for adapting the ways of collaboration in order to reflect the current conditions. A way to address this challenge is by identifying and appropriately reusing Collaboration Patterns (CPats). CPats are segments of collaboration work, which can be identified as recurring and can be reused [7]. The reuse of CPats can constitute an advantage in collaborative environments such as VOs, as there is an increased need for modeling, executing, monitoring and supporting the dynamic nature of collaborations. The overall aim of using CPats is to enable adaptivity and ad hoc realization of collaborations with respect to changing circumstances. In the Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) context, executive forms of CPats is formalised in the BPEL (Business Process Execution Language from the OASIS standardisation body) orchestration language that describe how VOs partners collaborate thanks to a set of services. Consequently, in order to introduce ad hoc nature in terms of run-time collaboration we propose to use the Maestro dynamic orchestration engine that allows process instance re-organization. The main contributions of the paper are the following. First, the paper in section 2 introduces and presents the demanding nature of collaboration patterns along with the proposed use of Maestro for adequately supporting the ad hoc nature that the solution of CPats must present. In section 3 we focus on our CPat execution proposition that involves fractal-based “Maestro” engine for supporting ad hoc workflow executions. In section 4, we give an illustrative scenario of the execution aspects of a specific CPat. Finally, this paper concludes with the related work (section 5) and a discussion that concludes our research effort, in section 6.
2. Collaboration Patterns 2.1. The Demanding Nature of Collaboration Patterns The notion of collaboration involves the complex nature of vast number of processes that may span across organizational/geographical boundaries, through the World Wide Web. The need for coping with iterative problems or reusing iterative segments of collaboration processes (Collaboration Patterns) seems more imperative than ever before. In general, the participants of a collaboration process need to be collocated either physically or virtually in order to make a decision or work together. During such collaborations, recurring segments of solutions to problems or individual actions can be identified and introduced as CPats for future use [7]. These patterns can also be regarded as prescriptive, providing means for modeling collaborative tasks and protocols of cooperation [8], while they can guide
Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration
5
the configuration of Collaborative Working Environments to meet the requirements of the participants [9], [10]. Among the important elements that are needed for describing a CPat are the triggering mechanisms and the actual solution that they propose [7]. In terms of a system for handling knowledge based collaborations inside VOs, services may produce many events that might be relevant for other services. It is clear that all these influences, due to their ad-hoc nature, cannot be defined in advance explicitly, but they can be categorized and used as triggering mechanisms of recurring segments of collaborative work. In addition, a CPat determines the basic structure of the solution to a particular collaborative problem, while it does not always specify a fully detailed solution. A pattern provides a scheme for a generic solution to a family of problems, rather than a prefabricated module that can be used ‘as is’. The implementation of this schema must be done according to the specific needs of the design problem at hand. CPats are not only useful to users within the same domain as the pattern, but frequently a pattern is useful in other domains as well. As CPat execution we define first the retrieval and instantiation of the appropriate CPat for the collaboration situation (e.g., problem, preconditions, triggering mechanisms), [7] and second the execution of the CPat by the appropriate “execution engine” (e.g., workflow engine, groupware tool, human tasks, etc.). 2.2. SYNERGY Collaborative Framework CPats are used in the context of SYNERGY FP7 research project that defines a collaboration framework based on Service Oriented Architecture concepts. Even if it is not the aim of this paper to detail it, figure 1. depicts main building blocks. It consists of an Event Driven Architecture build on top of the Petals Enterprise Service Bus (ESB). Events are managed at the bus level while Complex Event Processing (CEP) engine allows identifying business events that match event patterns. CPats are triggered by those business events thanks to the CPat assistant which is in charge of selecting corresponding CPat from the CPat Knowledge Base CPat assistant also initializes the Ad-hoc workflow engine which is mainly in charge of executing the proposed by the CPats solution to collaborative problem. Collaboration Moderator Service is in charge of raising awareness of the priorities and requirements of other contributors while the Partner Knowledge Management Service (PKMS) provides effective mechanisms to manage and utilise all the knowledge in the SYNERGY Knowledge Bases.
6
J.P. Lorre, Y. Verginadis, N. Papageorgiou and N. Salatge
CPat editor
CEP editor
CPat Knowledge Base
Event Type Knowledge Base
CPat assistant
Collaboration Moderator Service
Partner Knowledge Management Service
CEP engine Ad-hoc workflow engine Event manager (pub/sub)
Enterprise Service Bus SYNERGY Portal
Fig. 1. SYNERGY technical architecture
2.3. Maestro Workflow Engine for Collaboration Patterns Ad-hoc workflow engine leverage the Maestro BPEL engine that takes into account dynamicity requirement stated previously. Maestro engine is an Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) component able to orchestrate services based on BPEL 2.0 language. An ESB is a standard-based integration platform that combines messaging, Web services, data transformation, and intelligent routing to reliably connect and coordinate the interaction of significant numbers of diverse services across extended enterprises with transactional integrity [11]. Once deployed, services are available inside the ESB or they can be exported outside the ESB. When the BPEL service receives a request, it starts a new instance of corresponding CPat solution. Maestro Engine is basically composed of two layered components (Figure 2): •
Maestro-core which is in charge of creating and executing abstract PetriNet instances (e.g an instance of process). These instances are composed of classical elements existing in Petri-Net framework (node, transition, etc.). Maestro-core is the basis for multiple process languages. Native support for any process language can be build on top of such Petri-Net Virtual Machine. The runtime behavior of each activity in the process graph is delegated to a dedicated API (Application Programming Interface). Each process language deals with specialization of a set of activity types. An activity implements the runtime behavior and corresponds to one activity type. So, building a process language on top of the Maestro-core is as easy as creating a set of activity implementations. Each activity is then inserted
Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration
•
7
in a node of the objects graph. This is realized by using the Maestro4BPEL interpreter as detailed below. Maestro4BPEL interpreter traduces the BPEL description (e.g. tag elements like <process/>,
etc.) into objects managed by Maestro-core (e.g. petri-net objects like process, node, transition). At the end of this step, an objects graph is built, which contains a set of nodes. Each node (except initial node and end nodes) is highly coupled with incoming and outgoing transitions. An execution object is also created. This object follows the step by step execution of objects graph. If a node has several outgoing transitions, the parent execution creates several child executions to follow each branch.
Fig. 2. Maestro Engine Framework
Dynamicity of BPEL process instances is obtained by basing Maestro-core on the Fractal component model, which means that each Petri-net node and transition has been reified into Fractal component. The Fractal component model [9], [12] is a programming-language-independent component model, which has been introduced for the construction of highly configurable software systems. The Fractal model combines ideas from three main sources: software architecture, distributed configurable systems, and reflective systems. From software architecture, Fractal inherits basic concepts for the modular construction of software systems, encapsulated components, and explicit connections between them. From reflective systems, Fractal inherits the idea that components can exhibit meta-level activities and reify through controller interfaces part of their internal structure. From configurable distributed systems, Fractal inherits explicit component connections across multiple address spaces, and the ability to define meta-level activities for runtime reconfiguration. 2.4. Related Work Within the domain of cross-organizational collaboration, patterns have been mainly used to facilitate the modeling and enactment of inter-organizational business processes [13]. In the domain of Communities of Practice (CoP) task patterns have
8
J.P. Lorre, Y. Verginadis, N. Papageorgiou and N. Salatge
been proposed, mainly in a theoretical level, to define which information patterns are to be created in particular steps of collaboration [14]. Collaboration Engineering (CE) is a research-based approach that aims to provide repeatable, tool-based processes, consisting of elementary items called thinkLets to model recurring collaborative tasks but from the point of view of a meeting facilitator [15]. Petri Nets have been used to model workflows for many years [16]. Others have proposed the π-calculus as a workflow model [17]. Control flow patterns [18] along with data flow [19] and resource patterns [20] have been proposed in order to assess the capabilities of the different workflow technologies, languages and models. To our opinion all of these approaches are too strict and not appropriate for collaborative processes which incorporate knowledge-based, and thus very difficult to prescribe, tasks. On the other hand, UAM method introduces activity patterns [21] in order to facilitate the reuse of ad-hoc collaborative activities and provides all the necessary underlying technologies to achieve that. Where it seems to be weak is in the modeling of complex, structured and event-based processes since the flow of the actions is modeled only as a list or a tree of activities with no constraints. Other approaches focus mainly in the extraction of patterns from collaborative systems with ad-hoc characteristics [22]. Our goal is to address the specificity frontier of collaboration support systems [23], i.e. to support a range of collaboration types, from fixed to ad-hoc. In this respect, our work extends research on activity patterns [21] and proposes CPats as a type of design patterns applicable on event-based systems [24].
3. Maestro Reorganisation Patterns As explained before, since Maestro-core is based on Fractal component model, it enables reconfiguration of running process instances. In this aim, Maestro-core provides a factory containing several reorganization patterns such as convert Flow to Sequence, convert If to Flow etc. Figure 3. depicts the logic and the component representation of the reorganization pattern used to convert flow control instruction into a sequence control instruction. In the component representation, each component is either a node with a functional behaviour like Flow, Sequence, Invoke, If, etc. or a transition with non-functional behaviours like log, persistence, etc. A node can have incoming or outgoing transitions, a parent node and child nodes. A Flow control instruction is represented in our component architecture by a component (or a node) with a Flow behaviour. This behaviour allows the execution in parallel of all child nodes of the flow component (node N2 and N3 on figure 3). All child nodes in the Flow control instruction are executed by a different thread. A Sequence control instruction is represented by a component with a Sequence behaviour. This behaviour allows the execution starting the first child node of the sequence component (node N2 on figure 2). All child nodes in the Sequence control instruction are executed in the creation order in the same thread.
Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration
9
The used algorithm to achieve the conversion of the flow control instruction into a sequence control instruction is straightforward (read the component representation from right to left): 1. Change the flow behavior of the component by the sequence behavior. Thus, instead of executing all child nodes of the component, only the first child node is executed. 2. Add a transition (T) between node N2 and node N3. Thus, when the activity of node N2 is finished, the node N3 is executed. When the node N3 is achieved, the sequence component activity is finished, so, the node N4 is started.
Figure 3. Reorganization patterns: Flow to Sequence
All these reorganization patterns are contained in the API of the Maestro factory. This factory can be used by the CPat run-time services to reorganize one or several running process instances.
4. Scenario In this section, we give an example of how we can use and execute CPats using the Maestro ad-hoc workflow engine for allowing the modification of the actions described by the CPat solution at the CPat instantiation phase (e.g., modify a sequence of actions from sequential to parallel, delete an action, add an new action etc.). The CPat of our example deals with the case in which a VO member decides to run and support a meeting after a project review has taken place. In the following table we present the specific CPat along with the most important aspects of its description.
10
J.P. Lorre, Y. Verginadis, N. Papageorgiou and N. Salatge Table 1.
CPat
Name:
Category:
Business Pattern
Problem:
Discuss the work progress and the results of a project review.
VO lifecycle phase:
Any
Pre-Conditions:
X (variable) number of VO members available
Triggers: Triggers of Exceptions: Roles: Input Information:
No.
CPat 1
(Meeting Organiser decides to schedule a meeting) AND (Project review completed) One or more VO members report unavailability at last moment (variable) VO Meeting Organiser, VO members / Meeting Participants Project’s DoW (Description of work), VO members’ contact details, EU guidelines, Review Report 1.
Solution:
Involves an action list: a. Meeting Organiser schedules the meeting (describe reason, propose date) b. Meeting Organiser selects meeting participants c. All meeting participants agree upon the meeting date and method (online or offline) d. Meeting Organiser prepares and sends a draft agenda. e. …
2.
Output Information:
Involves the usage of collaborative tools: ¾ engage with collaboration tool (e.g. www.doodle.ch) to find date based on collaborators’ availabilities ¾ virtual collaboration space… Meeting minutes document
Duration:
X (variable) Days
Exception:
Post- Conditions: Related CPats:
Meeting took place, Agreed meeting minutes stored in the system, Reason for having the meeting resolved CPat
The proposed CPat solution involves a set of actions to be undertaken by the VO meeting organizer and the VO members that will participate. We note that the CPat solution constitutes only a “possible” sequence of actions. CPat 1 involves the sequential execution of several actions. This structure is flexible to change when the CPat is being instantiated in order to satisfy the requirements of a particular situation. In our case, during instantiation phase, the VO meeting organizer decides that it would be much more appropriate to start CPat 1 by having action “d” executed in parallel with action “a”, instead of executing the several actions defined in the CPat solution in sequence. Maestro engine undertakes this flow transformation task by applying the “Sequence to Flow” reorganization pattern.
Ad-hoc Execution of Collaboration Patterns using Dynamic Orchestration
11
5. Conclusion This paper presents a framework for running ad-hoc collaborative patterns. Such patterns encapsulate reusable frames of collaboration activities. The approach uses a dynamic orchestration engine, Maestro, which leverages the Fractal component model in order to allow reorganization of flow in the proposed CPat solutions. Modification is managed by the collaboration pattern assistant [7] that triggers the need for reorganization and by Maestro-core that provides a library of reorganization algorithms. The virtual organizations as collaborative environments with increased needs can be favoured by the combined strength of collaboration Patterns and the dynamic nature of the Maestro engine. We believe that this proposal can cope with the critical challenges that a VO environment poses. Further work will be carried out in terms of implementing this framework into event driven environments for validating it across real case scenarios in VOs lifecycles. Our intention is to also use, test and validate CPats in an even broader environment, such as virtual breeding environments or in plain collaboration environments which are situated outside the borders of virtual organizations. Finally, we believe that it will be very interesting to examine ways to use CPats, in order to deal with unanticipated exceptions, that may occur in dynamic collaborative environments.
6. Acknowledgements This work has been partially funded by the European Commission regarding the project SYNERGY (Supporting highlY-adaptive Network Enterprise collaboration thRouGh semanticallY-enabled knowledge services), ICT No 63631. The authors would like to thank the project team for comments and suggestions.
7. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
Fox MS. Issues in enterprise modeling. Systems, Man and Cybernetics, 'Systems Engineering in the Service of Humans', Conference Proceedings, vol. 1, pp. 86-92, 1993. Matos C, Afsarmanesh H. Collaborative Networked Organization: A research agenda for emerging business models, Springer Press, 2004. Davidow WH and Malone MS. The Virtual Corporation. Harper-Collins, New York, 1992. Mowshowitz A. Virtual Organization. ACM 40, 9 (Sept. 1997), 30–37. Mowshowitz A. Virtual organization: A vision of management in the information age. Inf. Soc. 10 (1994), 267–288. Ahuja MK, Carley KM. Network Structure in Virtual Organizations, Organization Science, v.10 n.6, p.741-757, June 1999 Verginadis Y, Apostolou D, Papageorgiou N, Mentzas G. Collaboration Patterns in Event-Driven Environment for Virtual Organisations. Intelligent Event Processing –
12
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24]
J.P. Lorre, Y. Verginadis, N. Papageorgiou and N. Salatge Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AAAI) Spring Symposium 2009, Stanford, USA Molina, A. and Bell R. A Manufacturing Model representation of a flexible manufacturing facility. Journal of Engineering Manufacture: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers 213(B), 1999, pp. 225-246. Bruneton E., Coupaye T, Leclercq M., Quema,V. and Stefani JB. The Fractal Component Model and its Support in Java. Software - Practice and Experience 2006; 36:11-12. Slagter R, Biemans M. and Jones VM. Service Orchestration for Collaboration Patterns. Technical Report TR-CTIT-05-71, Centre for Telematics and Information Technology, University of Twente, Enschede, ISSN 1381-3625, 2005. Chappell D. Enterprise Service Bus: Theory in Practice, O'Reilly Media, 2004. Merle P., Stefani JB. A formal specification of the Fractal component model in Alloy. INRIA research report No 6721, 2008. Norta A., Hendrix M. and Grefen P. A Pattern-Knowledge Base Supported Establishment of Inter-organizational Business Processes. R. Meersman, Z. Tari, P. Herrero et al. (Eds.): OTM Workshops 2006, LNCS 4277, 2006, pp. 834–843. De Moor, A. Community Memory Activation with Collaboration Patterns. Proceedings of the 3rd International Community Informatics Conference (CIRN 2006) Prato Italy, pp. 1. Briggs, R. O. Collaboration Engineering with ThinkLets to Pursue Sustained Success with Group Support Systems. Journal of Management Information Systems, 19, 3164, 2003. van der Aalst, W. M. P. The Application of Petri Nets to Workflow Management. JOURNAL OF CIRCUITS SYSTEMS AND COMPUTERS, 8, 21-66, 1998. Puhlmann, F. & Weske, M. Using the pi-Calculus for Formalizing Workflow Patterns. LECTURE NOTES IN COMPUTER SCIENCE, 3649, 153, 2005. van der Aalst WMP, ter Hofstede AHM, Kiepuszewski B. and Barros AP. Workflow Patterns. Distributed and Parallel Databases, 14(3), 2003, pp. 5–51. Russell N, ter Hofstede AHM, Edmond D. and van der Aalst WMP. Workflow Data Patterns. Technical report, (FIT-TR-2004-01), 2004a. Russell N., ter Hofstede AHM, Edmond D. and van der Aalst WMP. Workflow Resource Patterns. BETA Working Paper Series, WP 127, Eindhoven University of Technology, 2004b. Moody P, Gruen D, Muller MJ, Tang J. and Moran TP. Business activities patterns: a new model for collaborative business applications. IBM Systems Journal 45(4), 2006, pp. 693-694. Biuk-Aghai R. Patterns of Virtual Collaboration in Online Collaboration Systems. Proceedings of the IASTED International Conference Knowledge Sharing and Collaborative Engineering, ACTA Press, 2004, pp. 57-62. Bernstein A. How Can Cooperative Work Tools Support Dynamic Group Processes? Bridging the Specificity Frontier, CSCW’00, Philadelphia, PA, 2000. Paschke A. Design Patterns for Complex Event Processing. 2nd International Conference on Distributed Event-Based Systems (DEBS'08), 2008.
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems Sundar Gopalakrishnan1 and Guttorm Sindre1 1
Department of Computer and Information Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Sem Sælands vei 7-9 , NO-7491 Trondheim Norway
Abstract. Model-based requirements specifications may be performed using a wide variety of notations, emphasizing different standards and information needs. Most of these notations have been developed with more traditional information systems development in mind, not specifically for mobile information systems. While many of the same modelling approaches will be relevant for mobile information systems, too, there are reasons to believe that the modelling needs in that domain might be somewhat different. In particular, the location and context of an information processing activity will be less fixed than for a desktop-based system, and this may also cause a bigger need for modeling this location and context. This paper explores some alternative notation variants for UML activity diagrams to address these needs. Some notations are proposed and compared, using a case study from the home care domain. Keywords: Requirements specifications, model-based, UML, use case diagrams, BPMN
1. Introduction A large number of diagrammatic modeling techniques have been used in information systems analysis and requirements engineering, such as goal modeling [1] conceptual modeling [10], and process modeling [4] including UML, use cases [11] and BPMN. For requirements specification [5] [6], there exist different diagrammatic modeling languages typically to address a lot of different aspects [7], such as • • •
WHAT (information is supposed to be handled by the system, e.g., in terms of classes and relationships) HOW (is the system going to solve its tasks, e.g., in terms of process models) WHEN (are tasks going to be performed, e.g., shown in more precise process models including timing)
S.Gopalakrishnan and G. Sindre
14
• •
WHY – in terms of goals or business rules WHO – in terms of agents / roles. Some languages typically combine WHY and WHO, such as i* or Kaos [3]
For mobile information systems another question emerges, namely WHERE? Most naively this can be considered in a purely geographical sense – where is a certain activity supposed to be performed or a certain service supposed to be offered? However, it can also be considered from a multi-channel [12] point of view – through which kind of equipment is the functionality going to be offered? [13] [14] Or from the point of view of the working context: In what situation is the user when needing the functionality, e.g., is it going to be used in a car, and is the car standing still or driving, and in the latter case: is it the person driving the car who actually needs to use the system at the same time? All this may have important bearings on the requirements and later design of the system, and would therefore be relevant to capture in early stage system models. This paper is organised with related works in section 1.2, proposed diagram notation in section 1.3 followed by evaluation in section 1.4, conclusion and with possible future work in section 1.5.
2. Related Works The Volere specification approach [8] provides a general template for all kind of requirements, but as mentioned earlier mobile requirements specification is unique and could not specify the “where” aspect. RE techniques mostly uses diagrams for requirements and visual notations play important role in all engineering disciplines. The works carried out in MPOWER project [17] uses UML notations in their home care system extensively and concludes UML profiles can be used as a mechanism for toolchains based on OMG’s Model Driven Architecture(MDA) and UML standards[16]. Larsson [7] proposes the three building blocks for knowing the processes list How, What and Why, adds Who for use oriented design approach and omitted the ‘Where’ concept. Veijalainen [15] mobile ontologies development identifies the ‘where’ aspect, but excludes the ‘what’ aspect.
3. Proposed Diagram Notation With the background of Home care system [9] case study, consider the simple UML [2] activity diagram in Fig. 1. A brief summary of home care system is given below: The shift leader is responsible for the work at the zone, answering to Trondheim municipality. Nurses typically have more somatic knowledge than the home care assistants, and are to support social needs. The home care assistants typically work more broadly work with personal care before lunch, and then with home care (i.e. practical tasks in the home). The diagram in Fig. 1 typically focuses on HOW the process is performed (the activity boxes and decision diamonds) and by WHOM (swimlanes, typically roles in the organization). WHAT could be included by rectangles representing information objects manipulated by the activities (not done here for the sake of
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems
15
simplicity). WHY is not so much included in this type of diagram, but could be addressed in another type of diagram, for instance a goal hierarchy. The WHERE dimension is typically not included in this type of diagram. Since the process is about home care and the loop indicates that the home care assistant is visiting multiple patients during the day, one could make the guess that the assistant might need to drive a car or use some other kind of transportation to get around to the various clients, but this is not explicit in the model. However, this could be interesting both for understanding the process and for discussing potential improvements. For instance, when it comes to understanding: -
Is the activity “Get preparatory information about patient” performed while in office (i.e., before going to see the patient), during transportation, or at the patient’s home? Similarly, is “Log info about visit” performed at the patient’s, upon returning to the car, or when returning to the office?
Fig. 1. Example UML activity diagram for a home care process
And, when it comes to possible improvement: -
Assuming the assistant currently returns to the office after each patient, which increases the drive time and makes for a less efficient process –
16
S.Gopalakrishnan and G. Sindre
-
-
how to distinguish this diagrammatically from the other alternative of only returning to the office after visiting all patients? Assuming that the assistant currently makes temporary logs on paper, which then have to be transcribed electronically after the visiting round – how to distinguish this from the practice of logging electronically while at the patient’s or in the car, using mobile equipment? Assuming that the shift leader wants more flexibility, e.g., dynamically reallocating patients between different assistants, either based on assistant capacity (for instance, one assistant might end up using extra time with one patient due to some complications, thus not having time for all patients on her list, while another assistant might have available capacity) or based on patient availability (e.g., one patient is not available for home care for a certain period of the day because she needs to go to the dentist or whatever, and therefore wants to be rescheduled). This could be achieved by communicating interactively with the assistants while they are on their rounds, but this would require the use of mobile equipment and necessary documentation about patients being available through that equipment, rather than assistants having received the needed documentation on paper prior to their rounds.
For both these main purposes (process comprehension and process improvement) it could be worthwhile to look into notations which explicitly show WHERE a task is performed, in what context, and with what equipment. Here we will explore various ways to do this: -
attempt A: using existing notation as-is, just adding some explanatory annotation attempt B: redefine the usage of swimlanes attempt C: using color or other notation to indicate WHERE-aspects
In Fig. 2 the first approach is illustrated. The diagram is largely the same as we just showed, only that some annotational boxes have been added where appropriate. Also, it is clearly shown where the activities of the home care assistant are performed and under what conditions. This would be important input to further requirements work, for instance knowing that preparatory info about the patient should be possible to acquire while driving the car, the system must be able to provide this info to the home care assistant as audio, either from mobile equipment or equipment belonging to the car, since if the assistant has to use his hands or eyes a lot to get the info, this could interfere with safe driving. A possible disadvantage of these annotations is that they might clutter up the diagram with a lot of extra nodes. In the next diagram another approach is shown, redefining the usage of swimlanes. Now, these are no longer used for indicating the organizational WHO but instead to show WHERE. For WHO, stick figures are used instead, since this is more consistent with some other diagram types in UML (e.g., use case diagrams). However, this diagram has another disadvantage, namely that a lot of edges are needed to indicate who performs which task, especially for the “Homecare assistant” who performs most of the tasks. Hence, Fig. 3 looks a lot messy and worse than Fig. 2 at this point. An attempt to mend it is shown in Fig. 4, where the parenthesis “all other activities” is added
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems
17
to the name of the Homecare assistant actor, so that the connecting lines can be dropped. In addition to the mentioned parenthesis, the stick figure for the HCA is also made bigger to indicate that this is the prime actor of the process. However, this would only work nicely if there is one particular actor who is responsible for most of the activities in a diagram. If there are several actors each responsible for a number of activities, it would be impossible to avoid the mess of a lot of edges.
Fig. 2. Home care example with annotations showing place and context
18
S.Gopalakrishnan and G. Sindre
Fig 3. Home care example with redefined swimlanes
Fig. 4. Attempt to improve on Fig. 3
Another idea could be the use of colour, such as in Fig. 5 (a).
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems
19
The disadvantage is that a colour legend has to be established, but if the same colours are then used consistently over a number of modelling projects, this will be a small investment, and gradually it might be less needed to have the legend visible in every diagram. Alternatively there might just be a link to the legend so that it could be accessed if needed. Another advantage of the color version, as illustrated in Fig 5 (b) is that if several process design alternatives are put side by side, it becomes very easy to quickly spot differences in planned locations of activities. The reader would see almost immediately that the only differences between the two diagrams is that the prep info and logging activities are performed in different places (car vs. office, car vs. patients’ home). This notation might therefore be particularly useful for easily discussing alternative process designs by means of location. Also, since the use of colors means that one avoids to add extra nodes (in contrary to the annotation variant) or extra edges (with the stick figure actor variant), diagram complexity is not so much increased here, except the reader must of course understand the usage of the colors. Alternatively patterns can be used instead of colours. It is of course possible to illustrate differences between process design alternatives by the other approaches, too. But for the annotation version Fig. 2 in particular this would be a lot more subtle, the differences only being shown as different texts within annotation rectangles, therefore needing close inspection of the model to be discovered by the user. Another possible advantage of color is if there are different options for how to perform an activity, e.g., if the worker has a personal choice whether to do the prep info activity in office or while driving the car. With the color approach, this could easily be shown by having two different colors inside the node for that particular process step, again easy for the reader to spot quickly and not increasing diagram complexity that much as shown in Fig.6.
5 (a)
5 (b) Fig 5. Example using color
20
S.Gopalakrishnan and G. Sindre
Fig. 6. Including an optional choice of location for a process step
4. Evaluation In this paper we used the home care system [9] at Trondheim city in Norway as a case study. The UML diagram notations presented in section 1.3 is based on a simple task in the complete home care system. It is regarded more important to understand alternate notations in view with mobile information systems than presenting the whole scenario of mobile care system. Before evaluation of these notations it is necessary to understand the some information about mobile care system at Trondheim [9]. The home care involves services being offered in the home of the customer, including practical help and home nursing care. In the ‘Mobile Care’-project, it is planned to better support the mobile aspects of the home care service by providing the employees continuous access to Gerica and other relevant systems from wherever they are using a PC/PDA-solution. This is seen in connection to the ‘Wireless Trondheim’-project, which is currently building a mobile broadband for Trondheim. In other parts of Trondheim, one so far has only UMTS or GPRS coverage (i.e. with lower bandwidth for data transfer). The 4 alternate process notations presented in section 1.3 just reflect the same task by home care assistant who visits patients according to the list given by shift leader. Using Gerica on PDA, the home care assistant logs the info about patients on the go intimating patient health status to the nurse at hospital receive further
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems
21
info about the logs. By Fig. 1 notations, these tasks performed can be understood but it lags the information where it is done. Also it hard to make dynamic log change for example the shift leader wants to prioritise patients schedule could not reflect in this notation. Fig. 1 notation is not reflecting the state of art use of mobile technologies in home care system. In Fig. 2, the notations are better than Fig. 1 comparatively to have where the tasks are carried out. At the cost of extra nodes in Fig. 2, where the activities and under what conditions has notified. But these extra nodes will be disadvantage if the same notation is used to represent entire home care system. The swim lanes and stick diagrams are representing where and who respectively in Fig. 3. This notation has a disadvantage of lot of edges on who performs the tasks can be overcome by assigning HCA to all other activities as in Fig. 4. Keeping a colour legend and assigning consistently through modelling project is performed by notation in Fig. 5. This notation seems to be simple and easy to perform a large project for example home care system provided a colour legend established and used consistently throughout the project. The same notation is improved in Fig. 6 showing optional choice of performing tasks. On using patterns instead of colour, certainly patterns have an advantage with respect to colour-blindness, on the other hand patterns might be slightly more difficult to distinguish quickly, especially if there are many locations/contexts that must be differentiated between so that one has to use many different patterns, which would make them more subtle and therefore require closer inspection of the model. With the annotation approach it could be described in text in the rectangle, e.g., “In office or while driving to patient’s home, according to worker’s preference” – easily understandable but needing closer inspection to spot. (and also causing annotation texts to be longer, which might mean that rectangles would have to be bigger, thereby cluttering up the diagram more, etc.). With the swimlane + stick figure approach, it gets very hard to illustrate such optional choices. Of course, an activity could be put on the boundary between two swimlanes, but this will only work if the alternative locations are actually on adjacent swimlanes. In other cases, one would simply have to put occurrences of the same activity step in several swimlanes and perhaps indicating the choice with a decision diamond, which would increase the diagram complexity quite a lot. Also, it might overload the decision diamond if this is used both for decisions concerning what to do, and decisions concerning where to do it. Table 1. Evaluation of proposed notations with simple and large models Notation
Trad. UML Annotated Loc.Swimlanes Loc.Swiml. with big actor colours Colours with optional choice
Min. deviation from standard Simple Large
Expressiveness
Intuitive / Easy to read Simple Large
Less Complexity
Simple
Large
Simple
Large
++ + -
++ + -
-+ +
-+ +
++ -
++ ---
++ + +
++ ---
-
-
+
+
-
--
+
-
-
-
++ ++
++ ++
+ +
+ +
++ ++
++ ++
S.Gopalakrishnan and G. Sindre
22
Table 2. Evaluation of proposed notations with SEQUAL framework Notation
Traditional UML Act. Diag. Annotated Location Swimlanes Loc. Swim. with big actor colours Colours with opt. choice
SEQUAL Framework on Language Quality Organizational Appropriateness
Domain Appropriateness
Comprehensibility Appropriateness
+ + + + ++ ++
+ + + + ++ ++
++ ++ + ++ ++
In Table 1, the proposed notations for small and large models are evaluated against four key features viz, minimal deviation from standard, expressiveness, intuitive/ easy to read and less complexity of models. In Table 2, by using SEQUAL framework, the notations are evaluated against its language quality viz, organizational, domain and comprehensibility appropriateness.
5. Conclusion and Future Work This paper analyse all the stated notations including the standard UML activity diagram and proposes alternate possible notations to specify mobile information systems. This specification analysis is performed with simple model in home care system starting with with UML activity diagram notation. The same is carried out with different alternate possible notations so that it can completely provide informations on what, who, how, why and where aspects and evaluated in the above section. Although to some extent it can be realised that some diagrams are better or worse than others, e.g., that Fig. 3 is a way too messy, empirical investigations are needed to make strong conclusions about what ideas are worth pursuing. Evaluation results are tabulated in Table 1 and 2 concluding colours and colours with optional choice have more positive features than other proposed notations. A wide range of different experiments can be envisioned where competing notations are compared to each other and the different notations would not have to be UML either, they could also be based on other modelling languages.
6. References [1] [2] [3]
Mylopoulos, J., Chung, L., and Tu, E., From Object-oriented to Goal-oriented Requirements Analysis Communications of the ACM. 1999,42(1): 31-37. Zhu, L. and I. Gorton, UML Profiles for Design Decisions and Non-Functional Requirements, in Proceedings of the Second Workshop on Sharing and Reusing architectural Knowledge Architecture, Rationale, and Design Intent. 2007, IEEE CS. Oliveira, A.d.P.A., et al., Integrating scenarios, i*, and AspectT in the context of multi-agent systems, in Proceedings of the 2006 conference of the Center for Advanced Studies on Collaborative research. 2006, ACM: Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Alternative Process Notations for Mobile Information Systems [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]
23
Pavlovski, C.J. and J. Zou, Non-functional requirements in business process modeling, in Proceedings of the fifth on Asia-Pacific conference on conceptual modelling - Volume 79. 2008, Australian Computer Society, Inc.: NSW, Australia. Ohnishi, A. Software requirements specification database based on requirements frame model in Requirements Engineering, Proc. of the 2nd Int. Conference on. 1996. Mujumdar, S., et al., A model-based design framework to achieve end-to-end QoS management, in Proceedings of the 43rd annual Southeast regional conference Volume 1. 2005, ACM: Kennesaw, Georgia. Larsson, A. V., Designing for use in a future Context – Five Case Studies in Retrospect, PhD thesis No:1034, 2003, Institute of Tech., Linkoping Univ., Sweden. URL: http://www.volere.co.uk/template.htm, accessed on 7th Dec 2009 URL: http://research.idi.ntnu.no/trimaks, accessed on 7th Dec 2009 Sølvberg, A., Data and what they refer to, in P.P.Chen et al. (eds.): Conceptual Modeling, 1999, pp.211-226, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer Verlag. Booch, G., Rumbaugh, J. & Jacobson, I., “The Unified Modeling Language: User Guide Addison-Wesley, 1999. URL: http://m3w.idi.ntnu.no/ accessed on 7th 2009 Gopalakrishnan, S. and Sindre, G., Taxonomy of Mobility-Related Requirements", IEEE CS(I-ESA'09), Beijing, China, 20-22 Apr, 2009. Gopalakrishnan, S. and Sindre, G., A Revised Taxonomy of Mobility-Related Requirements, In Proc. International Workshop on Management of Emerging Networks and Services (MENS'09), St.Petersburg, Russia, 12-14 Oct, 2009 Veijalainen, J., Developing Mobile Ontologies; who, why, where, and how? IEEE, 07. Moody,D.L., The “Physics” of Notations: Towards a Scientific Basis for Constructing Visual Notations in Software Engineering. IEEE Transanctions on Software Eng. 09. Walderhaug, S., Stav, E. and Marius Mikalsen, M., Experiences from Model-Driven Development of Homecare Services: UML Profiles and Domain Models, LNCS 2009.
Conceptual Framework for the Interoperability Requirements of Collaborative Planning Process1 María M.E. Alemany1, Faustino Alarcón1, Francisco C. Lario1, Raul Poler1 1
Research Centre on Production Management and Engineering (CIGIP), Polytechnic University of Valencia, Camino de Vera s/n, Valencia 46022, Spain
Abstract. In order to achieve the multiple benefits of the collaborative planning (CP) process in a supply network (SN) context, some interoperability-related obstacles should be saved. The design and characterization of the CP process is a critical time to identify not only the interoperability requirements (IR), but also the CP components they affect. This paper presents a conceptual framework for the simultaneous characterization of the CP process and the identification of the potential IR to be saved for implementing collaboration. This early IR identification can help define the interoperability problem space that is essential for the solution space definition, thus saving subsequent costs and efforts. Keywords: collaborative planning process, supply networks, conceptual framework, interoperability requirements
1. Introduction Collaborative Planning (CP) is defined as a joint decision-making process for aligning the plans of individual Supply Networks (SN) members for the purpose of achieving coordination (adapted from [1]). Coordination should be achieved between the plans of SN decision-makers at different temporal levels (temporal integration) and at the same temporal level (spatial integration). Different authors strength the importance of analysing the collaboration under a process perspective [2;3] and the necessity of making processes inter-operable to achieve the collaboration benefits [4]. [5] affirm that the first step to give solutions
1
This research has been partially carried out in the framework of a Subproject funded by the Science and Technology Ministry of the Spanish Government, entitled PSS-370500-20063 "SP3 Integración operativa de la Cadena de Suministro.", within the project PSE370500-2006-1.
26
MME Alemany, F Alarcón, F.C. Lario, and R. Poler
for making a process inter-operable is the identification of the interoperability requirements (IR). In this context, [6] propose a framework for the classification and a methodology for collection of the requirements for enterprise modelling interoperability. [7] propose a framework able to handle the diversity of collaborative processes based on different computational and communication requirements. [8] describe how to connect internal processes of two companies supported by the cross-organizational business process meta-model. [9] present a framework and general requirements for seamless interoperability in a collaborative network environment. Different tools, ICT platforms, reference models, frameworks [10;11] and its evaluation for interoperability have been proposed. However, up to our knowledge, there is no any conceptual framework for CP focusing on the process perspective and, additionally, addressing the interoperability issue. Though works have been identified that tackle with the interoperability issue, they are mainly focused on classifying the IR and analysing existing interoperability solutions much more than on reporting when? and where? the potential IR could appear along the process. Even more, there has not been found any work linking the IR with the specific CP process. Being identified this gap in the literature, this paper proposes a conceptual framework for the CP process characterization that allows the IR identification during the design of the CP process, in a structured way. The process design and analysis is a critical phase for the early IR identification and the latter search for interoperability solutions, thus saving later costs and efforts. The paper is structured as follows. The next section details the components of the CP conceptual framework and their relationship with the IR. The last section provides some conclusions relating the applicability and benefits of the proposal.
2. Description of the CF Components for the CP Process: Identification of IR The conceptual framework of this paper presents the same fundamental components as those proposed by [12], but with two main differences: 1) the contents of each element of the conceptual framework refer to the CP process and not to the Collaborative Order Promising Process, and 2) special attention has been paid to the IR in each element’s description. The IR are based on those proposed by [10; 9; 13] in a collaboration context and have been completed by the authors. These IR requirements have been classified using the interoperability levels (data, services, processes and business) proposed by INTEROP NoE for the enterprise interoperability framework [10]. A process will be defined when the answers to questions (a)-(g) are known (Table 1). The answer to each question corresponds with the characterization of a conceptual framework component which is described and linked with the IR in this section (Table 2).
Conceptual Framework for the IRs of Collaborative Planning Process
27
Table 1. Components of the conceptual framework THE PROCESS ITSELF
THE INFORMATION
(a) What activities are to be carried out? (b) Who is responsible, who has the authority to carry them out and with what? (c) When and how are they to be carried out?
EVALUATION ASPECTS
(d) The process inputs,
(f) The process objectives,
(e) The process outputs,
(g) The performance indicators
Table 2. Relationship among each CF component and the IR INTEROPERABILITY Levels of Interoperability
Interoperability Requirements
What activities?
PROCESS ITSELF
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS
Who and with what?
Process Inputs & Outputs
When and How?
EVALUATION ASPECTS (Ex ante) Objectives
(Ex post) Performance Indicators
Modes of decision-making [10] Alignment of conflicting objectives and goals Methods of work [10] Definition of domain of decisions and actions
BUSINESS
Agreement in responsibility and authority Learning Compatibility of organizational structure Integrated evaluation of inter-organizational activities and processes Base-detailed level of business representation [13] Definition and specification of the inter-organizational collaborative activities [10]
PROCESS
Business documents choreography [9] Definition of the interdependence information Achieve the roles/tasks fulfilment [9] Identification of potential activities to be automated
SERVICE
Linking applications and services addressing aspects related to interfaces, ICT platforms [9] Messaging (communication and message format) [9] Data integration [10] Information exchange [10] Semantics of the exchanged information [9] Format of the exchanged information [9] Information detail
DATA
Accessibility to reliable and real-time information [9] Update of information Management of the stored information [9] Security (confidentiality, authentication, non-repudiation) [9] Business documents formats and contents [9]
Tools and methods used in different companies in the four areas of interoperability concerns (data, services, processes, businesses) should be identified and compared, and their compatibility assessed. The answers to the questions of table 3 could be used as a validation principle for determining if an IR should (a “yes” answer) or not (a“no” answer) be omitted [14]. Table 3. IR validation principles [14] • •
CONCEPTUAL COMPATIBILITY
ORGANIZATIONAL COMPATIBILITY
TECHNOLOGICAL COMPABITIBILITY
Syntactic: is the information to be exchanged expressed with the same syntax? Semantic: does the information to be exchanged have the same meaning?
•
•
•
Persons: are authorities/ responsibilities clearly defined at both sides? Organization: are the organization structures compatible?
•
Platform: are the IT platform technologies compatible? Communications: do the partners use the same protocols of exchange?
28
MME Alemany, F Alarcón, F.C. Lario, and R. Poler
2.1. The Collaborative Planning Process What activities have to be carried out? The activities in such a process are dependent on the level of detail adopted for its representation and, therefore, the answer to the subsequent questions ((b)-(c)) is conditioned by the first question (a). Indeed, to achieve the inter-organizational IR integration process, the selection of a specific language for the business process description and the methods to link the disjointed view of the processes are essential, particularly in terms of the level of detail [13]. Therefore, to integrate the different planning sub-processes of each organization at the different CP temporal levels, we identified a base-detail level process representation that considers a base-activity as a set of activities for a specific temporal level of the CP process that: 1) has the same function, 2) has to be considered simultaneously (executed in the same planning period and at the same time point) given their strong interdependency and 3) has the same responsible party. In the following section we refer to the base-activity. The following main CP activities classification, based on the function performed, are proposed: • •
•
•
•
Initial and final activities: these activities determine when the process should be initiated and finalized, respectively. Planning activities: through their execution, a decision related to the SN Planning function is performed (i.e., to generate a production plan). To define them, the IR decision-making modes, the IR working methods, and the definition of the IR domain and decisions need to dealt with. Initial plan generation activities: these are in charge of generating an initial solution to start a negotiation process, should it exist. To define them, the IR decision-making modes, the IR working methods, and the definition of the IR domain and decisions need to be dealt with. Call activities: are in charge of making the execution of other activities possible. At the base-level business representation adopted, it usually links activities from the planning activities belonging to different responsible parties and/or organizations. They are essential in achieving all the IR related with messaging such as communication, message format, business document format, security, etc. Information Management Activities: they refer to those activities where either some type of information transformation, mainly due to spatial or temporal integration, or a calculus based on previous information, is made: o
spatial integration: at the same temporal level it would be necessary to pass information in the appropriate form to other SN members (e.g., to calculate the total requested supply quantity to each producer’s facility from the distributor’s distribution plan expressed as a vehicle and a facility).
o
temporal integration: as one moves down the decision-making temporal hierarchy, planning horizons shorten and the granularity of the information used increases in such a way as to permit the explicit representation and the timing of the key events [15]. Then, it would be necessary to
Conceptual Framework for the IRs of Collaborative Planning Process
29
aggregate/disaggregate the information relating to time, items and resources exchanged among the activities belonging to the different temporal levels. These types of activities are essential to solve the IR data integration, the semantics of the IR information exchanged, the availability of the IR information, and managing the IR information stored. •
Conditional activities: they check the accomplishment of certain conditions. Depending on whether these conditions have been achieved or not, the subsequent activities to be triggered differ. Conditional activities are essential for implementing the negotiation process and its finalization, and also for harmonizing the different decision-making modes and the IR working methods.
The above classification of activities could be useful for the definition and specification of inter-organizational IR collaborative activities. An interorganizational activity may be considered to link activities whose responsible party belongs to different organizations, and/or that the part of the physical SN under its control belongs to different organizations. Furthermore, the above classification linked with the answer to “with what?” can help in the identification of potential activities to become automated IR. Who is responsible to perform each activity and with what? Once the activities to be carried out in the CP process has been clarified: responsibility for their execution, authorizations and computer applications that could be of use in the decision-making process should all be defined. We distinguish four main categories of responsible parties (Table 4). A mediator is an additional SN member who controls the rules of the negotiation process, e.g., controlling the (timing of) interactions among members. A mediator may have the capability to evaluate the SN members’ plans, generate plans and present them to all the SN members for their evaluation, or propose the distribution of efficiency gains among SN members. For other activities than the planning type ones, another part or application will be defined as their responsible parties. The definition of responsibilities is strongly dependent on the SN organization and decision characteristics; however it is possible to provide some guidelines (Table 4). Table 4. Relationships among the different types of activities and those responsible RESPONSIBLE/ ACTIVITIES Planning Initial plan generation Call Information management Conditional
Planning decision-maker
Mediator
Another part
Application (automated)
At this point the compatibility of the IR organizational structures should be addressed. Furthermore, the definition of the responsible parties of the planning activities depends on the characteristics of the physical, decision and organization scope of these activities. The physical, decision and organization scope of each activity will allow the definition of the decisions and actions (IR) domain. The designation of responsibility for each activity will contribute to achieve the IR roles/tasks fulfillment. Furthermore, the specification of IR responsibility and
30
MME Alemany, F Alarcón, F.C. Lario, and R. Poler
authority is essential in defining IR security (confidentiality, authentication, non repudiation) and accessibility to IR information (authorization). Conditional activities require the IR related to negotiation specifications and collaborative agreement to have been previously defined. Therefore, the IR of available business documents for this type of activities has to be dealt with. Regarding the answer to the question with what?, it may be stated that planning activities and initial plan generation activities are usually supported by applications based on simulation, heuristic or mathematical programming models, which are partly automated because they require their responsible party’s validation. The remaining CP activities can be easily automated. Therefore in this step, not only the IR of linking applications and services addressing aspects related to interfaces, ICT platforms, exchange and accessibility, security and standards. but also those in relation to harmonizing the different IR decision-making modes and working methods will be addressed. When must CP activities be done? The execution of an activity depends on whether it is period-driven or eventdriven. Although planning activities are usually period-driven (i.e., executed at predefined time intervals, namely the re-planning period) due to temporal integration, they require a previous execution of the planning activities belonging to higher temporal levels that transmit them shared information. Furthermore, when negotiation takes place to achieve spatial integration, planning activities can be executed several times in the same re-planning period until the stopping negotiation criteria are achieved. Therefore, when negotiations among different planning activities take place their timing can be considered a mixture of perioddriven and event-driven activities. It is recommendable that all the planning activities belonging to the same temporal decision level present the same re-planning periods. Therefore, SN members must agree about the most suitable re-planning period for the CP process (IR decision-making modes and working methods). Every time an activity is performed, the information to be exchanged with other IR activities, accessibility to reliable and real-time IR information and IR information updating will be achieved. Finally, the timing of CP process activities is essential in specifying the sequence in which the business documents and information are exchanged in each inter-organizational activity (IR business documents choreography) and the instant when accurate information should be available (IR accessibility). 2.2. Information Requirements Information constitutes the input and output of the CP process. Additionally for the CP process, knowing the local or private information (i.e., not shared information with other activities), and the global or interdependent information (i.e., information shared with other activities) for each activity becomes specially relevant for defining collaboration. The local information of an activity always constitutes an information input or output of the whole process, while part of the global information can remain only as internal flow.
Conceptual Framework for the IRs of Collaborative Planning Process
31
The information to be exchanged among the different CP process activities constitutes one of the pillars for constructing links among inter-organizational subprocesses and requires the IR of the data level. So the first task in solving the IR related to the data level consists in identifying and defining this interdependent information. Furthermore, the information required and generated by an activity strongly depends on the previously specified IR modes and decision-aid tools for decision-making, the working methods employed and the definition of the IR decisions and actions domain. Therefore, there is a bi-directional relationship between these two last aspects that should be evaluated to adjust them both simultaneously. Identifying the required information for it to be shared can facilitate the later implementation of tightly coupled information technology and standards for information interchange. Furthermore, it is essential for establishing the following IR: communication, message format, business documents formats and contents, security, semantics of the information exchanged, managing the information stored, information availability, etc. Information Requirements for Planning and Initial Plan Generation Activities A planning activity attempts to obtain the value of its decision variables (output) that simultaneously optimize or achieve a satisfactory result of an objective/criteria (output) and respect the different limitations based on the available information (input). In table 5 a description of the input and output information of this planning activities is presented. Table 5. Input & output information of planning and initial plan generation activities INPUT INFORMATION Parameters or Data Local Parameters * Private attributes of the planning elements belonging to the system of the planning activity (e.g. costs, capacity, times, etc.) Interdependent Parameters *Shared attributes of the planning elements belonging to the system of the planning activity (e.g. demand forecasts). It is known as information sharing [8]. * Output information of other activities: ÆFrom planning activities: values of the decisions and/or criteria of its planning problem (interdependent decision variables and criteria). It is known as joint decisionmaking [8]. - Spatial integration - Temporal integration Æ From other planning activities
OUTPUT INFORMATION Tentative or Definitive Plan Local Decision Variables/Criteria * Private Decision Variable/Criteria: they are the decision variables/criteria values once executed the planning activity and solved the planning problem that are are not transmitted to other activities. Interdependence DecisionVariables/Criteria *Interdependent Decision Variable/ Criteria: they are those decision variables/criteria values which, in some way, are passed to other activities. This output data becomes input data for others activities, more specifically they become interdependent parameters of other planning activities. Æ Final Decision Variables/Criteria: their values cannot be changed under any condition during the negotiation process or, simply, because there is no negotiation. ÆNon-Final Decision Variables/ Criteria: their values can be modified during the negotiation process: -Temporal integration: disaggregation of decisions for being implemented(e.g. production volume of families should be disaggregated referred to articles) - Spatial integration: their values are adjusted before reaching the stopping criteria of the negotiation process (e.g. ordered/supplied quantities)
Input information of a planning activity refers to parameters and represents known characteristics or properties of SN entities (i.e., capacity of a facility, production cost of an item, etc.), or a relationship among them (processing times of an item on a facility). The interdependent parameters derived from the output decisions of other planning activities belonging to the upper temporal levels or the same temporal levels constitute the links for achieving temporal and spatial integration, respectively. The Output Information of a planning activity is usually integrated by the values of its decision variables and its criteria, and can be partly transmitted to
32
MME Alemany, F Alarcón, F.C. Lario, and R. Poler
other activities, thus becoming the input data (interdependence parameters) for those activities. Identifying the IR of update information is of special relevance to know whether the decision variables of an activity for each negotiation cycle are final or non final. The updating of non final decision variables has to be done for each negotiation cycle until the collaborative agreement specifications have been achieved. It is clear that the IR accessibility to interdependence information should be allowed for at least the responsible party of all the activities implied during the interaction cycle. Information requirements for Management Activities The input information for Management Activities relates with the level of the information detail required for the rest of activities, the format and the IR semantics. These activities collect the interdependence output information of other activities and transform it into the required format for the interdepence input information of other activities, thus achieving spatial and temporal integration. Information requirements for Conditional Activities Input information for conditional activities mainly consists in specifications regarding the collaborative agreement and output information (interdependence variables and/or criteria value) of other activities. Output contains information about whether a condition is accomplished, usually if the stopping negotiation criteria is reached. Depending on the result obtained, the subsequent sequence of activities to be triggered differs. 2.3. Evaluation Aspects Objectives (ex-ante evaluation) Objectives relate with the CP process goals. For collaborative processes, we can distinguish between the CP process objectives as a whole and the activity objectives. In this step, a consensus should be reached among the often conflicting IR objectives of the different SN members under the responsibility of different activities to achieve interoperability at the IR business level. •
•
The CP process objectives can be of three main types [1]. a) alignment of SN material flows, b) search for the SN optimum and c) search for a fair solution consisting in the evaluation of the SN solution as a whole with regard to the desired solution for each SN member. Objectives of activities depend on the type of activity being considered: Planning Activities and Initial Plan Generation Activities Objectives usually consist in simultaneously optimizing the local and interdependence criteria. If the responsible party is a mediator, the objectives of each SN member should be adequately integrated to accomplish the SN objectives as a whole. Conditional activity objectives relate with the accomplishment of a pre-defined criterion. The most usual criteria are the achievement of a pre-defined number of negotiation rounds, an aspiration deviation among the interdependence decision variables for the other SN members (e.g., ordered and supplied quantities), or/and the fairness evaluation of the SN members.
Conceptual Framework for the IRs of Collaborative Planning Process
33
Performance Indicators (ex-post evaluation) Performance indicators are essential to discover to what extent the established objectives are being fulfilled for each SN member and for the entire SN. The definition of the proper SN performance indicators and their threshold could allow the integrated evaluation of inter-organizational activities and IR processes. Once they have been defined, the information required to calculate them must be accessible and updated (accessibility to reliable and real-time IR information). The most usual CP process performance indicators relate to [16]: a) costs (inventory, production, warehousing and transportation costs), b) times (production operation and transport times), c) customer service level (stock out quantities and backorder quantities and d) volume flexibility.
3. Conclusions This paper presents a conceptual framework for simultaneously characterizing both the CP process and the potential IR to be saved for each component of the process. This research attempts to contribute in the alignment of the specific CP business process in the networked organizations, through guiding in the task of making the different SN planning sub-processes interoperable. Interoperability requires the identification of the shared elements and possible barriers between them [14] that is the main objective of this paper. In this sense, enterprise modelling can help identify the IRs trhough the modeling of interactions and information exchanges that occur in collaborations. The detection of IR can be used as a first step for models measuring interoperability through maturity models and other models [14] and determinining the impact of interoperability investments on business [17]. The latter selection of IRs to be solved should help achieve the optimal level of interoperability [18]. At this moment, the framework is being validated trough an application to a ceramic tile supply chain. Future research lines should be focus on a more exhaustive IR identification and the procurement of specific solutions for different IR supported by a methodology.
4. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
Stadtler H. (2009) A framework for collaborative planning and state-of-the-art, OR Spectrum 31 ( 1): 5-30 Osório A.L., Camarinha-Matos L.M. (2008) Distributed process execution in collaborative networks. Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing 24: 647– 655. Camarinha-Matos L.M., Afsarmanesh H., Galeano N., Molina A. (2009) Collaborative networked organizations – Concepts and practice in manufacturing enterprises. Computers & Industrial Engineering 57: 46–60. Xu H, Koh L, Parker D. (2009) Business processes inter-operation for supply network co-ordination. International Journal of Production Economics 122(1):188-99. Mykkänen, J.A; Tuomainen M.P. (2008) An evaluation and selection framework for interoperability standards, Information and Software Technology 50: 176–197.
34 [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
[15] [16] [17]
[18]
MME Alemany, F Alarcón, F.C. Lario, and R. Poler Ducq Y, Chen D, Vallespir B (2004) Interoperability in enterprise modelling: requirements and roadmap. Advanced Engineering Informatics 18(4):193-203. Osorio AL, Camarinha-Matos LM. (2008) Distributed process execution in collaborative networks. Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing 24(5):64755. ATHENA, , (2005) D.A2.2: Specification of a Cross-Organisational Business Process Model, Version 1.0", ATHENA IP, Deliverable D.A2.2. Chituc, C. M.; Azevedo, A.; Toscano, C. (2009) A framework proposal for seamless interoperability in a collaborative networked environment, Comput. Ind. 60(5): 317338. Chen D., Doumeingts G., Vernadat F. (2008) Architectures for enterprise integration and interoperability: Past, present and future, Comput. Ind. 59(7): 647-659 Chen D, Doumeingts G (2003): European initiatives to develop interoperability of enterprise-basic concepts, framework and roadmap, Annual Reviews in Control 27: 153–162. Alarcón F, Alemany MME, Ortiz A. (2009) Conceptual framework for the characterization of the order promising process in a collaborative selling network context. International Journal of Production Economics, 120(1):100-114. O'Brien W. J., Hammer J., Siddiqui M., Topsakal O. (2008) Challenges, approaches and architecture for distributed process integration in heterogeneous environments, Adv. Eng. Inform 22(1): 28-44. Chen D., Vallespir B., Daclin N. (2008) An Approach for Enterprise Interoperability Measurement. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Model Driven Information Systems Engineering: Enterprise, User and System Models (MoDISEEUS'08) Montpellier, France. 1-12 Muckstadt J. A., Murray D. H., Rappold J. A., Collins D. E (2001): Guidelines for Collaborative Supply Chain System Design and Operation, Inform. Syst. Front. 3 (4): 427-453. Beamon B. M., Chen V. C. P, (2001) Performance analysis of conjoined supply chains, Int. J. Prod. Res. 39 (14): 3195-3218. Lebreton, B., Legner, C. (2007) Interoperability Impact Assessment Model – Framework and Application. In Goncalves, R. J., Müller, J. P., Mertins, K., Zelm, M. (Eds.). Enterprise Interoperability II, Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Interoperability for Enterprise Software and Applications (I-ESA 2007), Berlin: Springer. 725–728. Legner C., Lebreton B. (2007) Business Interoperability Research: Present Achievements and Upcoming Challenges. Electronic Markets, 17(3): 176-186.
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profile for Enterprise Modelling Reyes Grangel1, Ricardo Chalmeta1, Cristina Campos1, Sergio Palomero1 1
Grupo de Investigación en Integración y Re-Ingeniería de Sistemas (IRIS), Dep. de Llenguatges i Sistemes Informàtics, Universitat Jaume I, 12071 Castelló, Spain
Abstract. Enterprise Modelling has been successfully used for modelling different enterprise dimensions such as business processes or organisation. However, some problems, like the lack of interoperability, are not solved in this context because the large number of different Enterprise Modelling Languages that exist make it difficult to exchange enterprise models performed by different enterprises. To solve this problem, in this paper we present a Framework that can be used to model enterprise dimensions, at the same time making interoperability between resulting models much easier to achieve. This Framework is based on UML using UML Profiles, and on the existing Enterprise Modelling metamodels proposed to solve interoperability problems. This paper provides a general description of the Framework that was implemented, as well as a detailed explanation of the UML Profile that was developed to represent one of the enterprise dimensions that can be modelled with the Framework, in particular the Organisational Structure of an enterprise. Keywords: Interoperability, Enterprise Modelling, Enterprise Modelling Language, UML, UML Profile, Organisational Structure
1. Introduction One of the main problems in Enterprise Modelling is the huge number of proprietary Enterprise Modelling Languages (EMLs) that exist, since interoperability problems increase among systems that use different EMLs when they want to exchange enterprise models [1-4]. Initiatives such as UEML1 [6-8]
1 Unified Enterprise Modelling Language first developed by the UEML Thematic Network [5] and then worked on by INTEROP NoE [3].
36
R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos and S. Palomero
and POP*2 [9, 10] provide common exchange formats to smooth the exchange of enterprise models in order to solve interoperability problems at Enterprise Modelling level. These two initiatives have been defined with the objective of making it easier to accomplish exchanges among enterprises that used different EMLs. For this reason, they propose common metamodels based on the main EMLs in which several enterprise dimensions, such as 'Process', 'Organisation', 'Product', etc. and the concepts related to each one of them are defined. MDA, on the other hand, is an emerging paradigm defined by the OMG. In this context, a lot of research work is being conducted in relation to PIM (Platform Independent Model) and PSM (Platform Specific Model), but the characterisation of CIM (Computation Independent Model) and the features that an enterprise model must satisfy in order to be considered a CIM and generate appropriate software is still in progress [11]. In fact, there exist several working groups inside the OMG3, which are working on this topic and whose main results (Business Motivation Model (BMM), Business Process Modeling Notation (BPMN), Semantics of Business Vocabulary and Business Rules (SBVR), etc.) highlight the interest of this topic. The objective of this paper is to present a Framework based on the Unified Modeling Language (UML) for modelling enterprises that takes these two contexts into account. In particular, one of the profiles of this Framework, the UML Profile for modelling the Organisational Structure of an enterprise, is detailed. The main reason why this is more than just another Enterprise Modelling Profile, that is different from the existing ones [12, 13] is that it is based on the accepted metamodels performed in UEML and POP*, in which interoperability problems have been solved. These proposals provide metamodels that make it easier to exchange of enterprise models between enterprises that use different EMLs. They do not, however, provide an implementation of these metamodels to be used for engineers to model enterprises directly. The UML Profiles developed inside the Framework presented in this paper are based on these metamodels and they can be used to model enterprises directly. Section 2 describes the main concepts related to UEML and POP* for modelling enterprises, especially organisational dimension, and different approaches that use UML for Enterprise Modelling. In Section 3, the Framework proposed based on UML for Enterprise Modelling is presented. Section 4 shows the detailed UML Profile for modelling Organisational Structure of an enterprise, and Section 5 outlines the conclusions and the main lessons learned for the application of the Framework.
2
Acronym of the different enterprise dimensions: Process, Organisation, Product, and so on (represented by a star), proposed by ATHENA IP [4]. 3 This is the Business Modeling & Integration Domain Task Force whose mission is to develop specifications of integrated models to support management of an enterprise.
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profiles for Enterprise Modelling
37
2. Enterprise Modelling 2.1. Using UEML and POP* In its latest version, UEML contains (1) a construct template, which provides a common structured format for describing modelling constructs; (2) a common ontology, to maintain the classes, properties, states and events used to describe modelling constructs; (3) the meta-metamodel, in which the top part is for managing the relationships between languages, their diagram types and their modelling constructs, the bottom part shows the structure of the common ontology, and the middle part is for breaking down modelling constructs and mapping them onto the common ontology [8, 14]. The UEML approach for describing modelling constructs is sufficiently powerful to support the integrated use of a broad variety of languages and models. However, the resulting theory and tools also need to be empirically validated and evaluated in real case studies [8, 14]. On the other hand, within its specification POP* also includes the POP* metamodel, which describes the set of basic modelling constructs that have been defined and their relationships, as well as some guidelines that describe the management and use of the POP* metamodel. A thorough explanation of the POP* metamodel and its corresponding methodology can be found in [9]. This work includes the description of the POP* metamodel with the dimensions that have been defined so far, i.e. Process, Organisation, Decision and Infrastructure. Organisation dimension expresses the formal and informal organisational structures of an enterprise, as well as the different stakeholders and relationships that form part of this organisation. The metamodel for the Organisation dimension proposes the following concepts with which to model this dimension: Organisation Unit, Organisation Role, Role (General Concept), Enterprise Object (General concepts), and Person. 2.2. Using UML The Unified Modeling Language (UML) has become a standard visual language for object-oriented modelling that has been successfully used for modelling information systems in very different domains [15]. However, UML is a generalpurpose modelling language that can also be useful for modelling other types of systems such as, for example, an enterprise [12, 13]. Other works, such as [16], point out the possibility of using UML as a language for Enterprise Modelling, although how and under which conditions this can be performed are explained in [17]. However, the benefits of model-driven approaches and the new UML2 specification provided by the OMG suggest the need to provide more practical examples for Enterprise Modelling with UML based on these recent works [18], and especially for Enterprise Knowledge Modelling.
38
R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos and S. Palomero
Furthermore, despite the fact that the weakness of the stereotype mechanism is pointed out in [17], the new UML2 specification [15] provides profiles that are more complete than those in version 1.5 [19]. It will therefore be possible to customise UML in a better way [20, 21]. Moreover, taking into account the number of diagrams provided in UML2 and the fact that the previous works use mainly 'Class Diagrams', it would be interesting to clarify exactly which UML2 diagrams are useful at the CIM level and then to specify which part of CIM models must be transformed into PIM models, since according to [22] there must surely be degrees of CIMness.
3. Conceptual Framework for Enterprise Knowledge Modelling The Framework for Enterprise Modelling presented in this paper is part of a bigger project dedicated to the development of Knowledge Management Systems (KMSs). The main results of this project are: (1) the KM-IRIS Methodology for the Implementation of KMSs [23]; and the proposal presented in this paper to model enterprises, the aim of which is to represent Enterprise Knowledge at the CIM level in order to obtain a graphical model called an Enterprise Knowledge Map [24]. Table 1. Proposal for Enterprise Knowledge Modeling Abstraction Level
Metamodel
UML Profile
Model
CIMKnowledge
Knowledge
UML Profile for KM
Knowledge
CIMBusiness
Organisation
UML Profile for GM UML Profile for OSM
Organisation
UML Profile for AM UML Profile for BRM UML Profile for SM
Structure
UML Profile for BM
Behaviour
Diagram Blocks Ontological Knowledge Goals Organisational Structure Analysis Business Rules Product Resource Process Service
In general terms, this proposal is based on MDA and defines a framework for developing conceptual models of KMSs at the CIM level. In other words, it allows enterprise knowledge to be modelled on the CIM level at two levels of abstraction, which are required due to the great complexity of this level (see Table 1.): • CIM-Knowledge: this corresponds to the top level of the model at the CIM level; the enterprise is represented from a holistic point of view, thus
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profiles for Enterprise Modelling
•
39
providing a general vision of the enterprise focused on representing enterprise knowledge that will later be detailed in a local way in successive lower levels. CIM-Business: here, the vision of enterprise knowledge is detailed by means of a representation of its business, according to three types of models, i.e. the Organisational Model, the Structure Model and the Behaviour Model.
The Framework (see Figure 1) also adheres to the following principles: (1) it is focused on Enterprise Modelling, since it takes into account enterprise dimensions and previous works leading to initiatives such as UEML and POP*; and (2) it is a user-oriented modelling framework, since it should be developed at the CIM level by domain experts. A summary of the Framework showing its levels of abstraction, metamodels and profiles, as well as the models and diagrams proposed for each level are shown in Table 1 [24].
Fig. 1. Models and diagrams defined within the Framework
4. Modelling Organisational Structure of an Enterprise The Framework for Enterprise Knowledge Modelling presented in this paper is capable of representing the Organisational Structure of an enterprise by means of different diagrams: • Blocks, Ontological and Knowledge Diagrams: these are able to represent the ontology defined for the human resources and the specific knowledge and instances defined for each category.
40
R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos and S. Palomero
•
Organisational Structure Diagram: this makes it possible to represent the organisation of the human resources in an enterprise, mainly by means of organisational units and the roles played by employees. • Resource Diagram: this makes it possible to model material and human resources. In this latter case, the diagram represents properties such as competencies, skills, knowledge, curriculum, and so on. This section shows an excerpt from the Framework in order to describe how Organisational Structure can be modelled in enterprises. It therefore shows an excerpt from the Organisation Metamodel and the UML Profile for OSM. 4.1. Organisational Structure Metamodel Figure 2 shows an excerpt from the Organisational Structure Metamodel. The constructs needed to represent human resources in an organisation in order to model Organisational Structure are as follows (see Fig. 2). • Enterprise: it represents any kind of organisation. This construct makes it possible to represent both an individual enterprise and an isolated entity (such as an extended or virtual enterprise) made up of different enterprises with distinct legal personalities. The following attributes are defined: - collaboration: it specifies the type of cooperation that enterprises maintain with other organisations in their environment. Its values can be any of those from the enumeration 'EnterpriseCollaborationType': single, extended or virtual. - legalStatus: it specifies the legal form that an enterprise has. - legalName: it indicates the legal name assigned to an enterprise. - cif: it specifies the fiscal identifier of an enterprise. • Unit: it represents each of the logical groups that exist in enterprises to implement their organisation, and may be one of the following types: department, organisational unit, section, and subsection. Furthermore, this construct makes it possible to design tree-shaped hierarchies that describe the organisational structure of enterprises. The following attributes are defined for this class: - type: it specifies the category the unit belongs to and may be one of the categories defined in the enumeration, 'UnitType': department, organisationalUnit, section or subsection. - isLeaf: it indicates whether a unit can no longer be broken down into another level, that is to say, if it is a leaf in the hierarchical tree that makes up organisational units. - connection: it indicates which of the two possible types of connection defined in the enumeration 'UnitConnectionType' (internal or external) exists among specific units in the organisation.
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profiles for Enterprise Modelling
-
41
location: it specifies the physical location of a unit.
Fig 2. An excerpt from the Organisational Structure Metamodel
•
•
• •
JobProfile: it represents a set of tasks that are related and require complementary and specific competences in order to be performed. The job profile defines the tasks and roles that should be performed by whoever has this job profile. The following attributes are defined for this class: - level: it indicates the hierarchical level on which the work position is defined, possible levels may be one from among the following defined by the enumeration 'LevelType': collaborative, strategic, tactic or operative. Employee: it represents the people that carry out a specific work in an enterprise, occupy a work position and have a specific role. The following attributes are defined for this class: - dni: it specifies the unique identifier of each employee. Role: it represents the attitudes and skills that are required for a particular job profile. Task: it represents the individual actions that are responsibility of a single individual and that are assigned to a particular job profile.
42
R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos and S. Palomero
4.2. Implementation of the Proposal From a technological point of view, this Proposal was implemented using the capacity of UML2 to extend a metamodel, that is to say, using a UML2 Profile. The UML2 Profile was defined for Enterprise Knowledge Modelling at the CIM level, following an MDA approach and the principles detailed above, and it was implemented using the IBM Rational Software Modeler [25]. The Profile provides the constructs needed to create the models proposed earlier (see Table 1). The 'UML Profile for OSM' (see Fig. 3) is one of the profiles of this Framework (see Table 1). It allows the organisational structure of an enterprise to be represented, showing the division of work carried out in departments, sections, subsections, etc. as well as the different profiles of jobs existing in enterprises, related employees, roles played by these employees and associated tasks.
Fig. 3. UML Profile for Organisational Structure Modelling
This profile makes it possible to develop the 'Organisational Structure Diagram' (one of the components of the 'Organisation Model') in order to represent the chart diagram of an enterprise. This diagram can include both the organisational units as the job profiles, roles and employees in each one of them. The main stereotypes of the 'UML Profile for OSM' that can be utilised to develop the Organisation Structure Diagram are shown in Table 2.
5. Conclusion The Framework outlined in this paper allows enterprises to be modelled using UML as EML. This Framework was applied in two real cases, an audit enterprise
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profiles for Enterprise Modelling
43
and a foundation, the results of which were used to improve iteratively the metamodels and the profiles presented in this paper. The proposal can be used to model any kind of enterprise, although as explained in the KM-IRIS Methodology [23] the first step is to define which kind of models are suitable bearing in mind the size of the enterprise, its strategic objectives, and so forth. Table 2. Stereotypes and icons that can be used within the 'Organisational Structure Diagram' Stereotype
Elements to model
<<Enterprise>>
Individual or collaborative enterprise
<>
Any of the organisational units of an enterprise, i.e. departments, organisational units, sections, subsections, etc.
<<JobProfile>>
Job profiles
<<Employee>>
Employees in the enterprise
<>
Employees' roles
<>
Tasks in a particular work place
Icon
<>
The main lessons learned is the difficulty involved in explaining the meaning of each concept proposed in the Framework to final users, since, in a similar way to UML, it is necessary to use diagrams to explain what each concept is and how it can be used to represent the particular case of an enterprise. For this reason, future work is centred on providing a number of templates that can guide the process of modelling and, on the other hand, on validating and improving the Framework with more real cases from different sectors and types of enterprises.
6. Acknowledgements This work was funded by DPI2006-14708 and the EC within the 6th FP, INTEROP NoE (IST-2003-508011 [3]).
44
R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos and S. Palomero
7. References [1] [2]
[3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
Chen, D., Doumeingts, G.: European initiatives to develop interoperability of enterprise applications–basic concepts, framework and roadmap. Annual Reviews in Control 27 (2003) 153–162 Doumeingts, G., Chen, D.: Interoperability development for enterprise applications and software. In Cunningham, P., Cunningham, M., Fatelnig, P., eds.: Building the Knowledge Economy: Issues, Applications, Case Studies. eBusiness, IOS Press Amsterdam (2003) INTEROP: Interoperability Research for Networked Enterprises Applications and Software NoE (IST-2003-508011). http://www.interop-noe.org (2010) ATHENA: Advanced Technologies for interoperability of Heterogeneous Enterprise Networks and their Applications IP (IST-2001-507849). http://www.athena-ip.org (2010) UEML: Unified Enterprise Modelling Language Themantic Network (IST-200134229). http://www.ueml.org (2010) UEML: Unified Enterprise Modelling Language Project (IST-2001-34229). http://www.ueml.org (2004) Deliverable 1.1. Berio, G., Opdahl, A., Anaya, V., Dassisti, M.: Deliverable DEM 1: UEML 2.1. Technical report, INTEROP-DEM (2005) Opdahl, A., Berio, G.: A Roadmap for UEML. In: Enterprise Interoperability. Springer-Verlag (2007) Ohren, O.P.: Deliverable DA1.3.1. Report on Methodology description and guidelines definition. Technical report, ATHENA Project (IST-2003-2004) (2005) Grangel, R., Chalmeta, R., Schuster, S., Peña, I.: Exchange of Business Process Models using the POP* Meta-model. In: Int. Workshop ENEI’2005. Vol. 3812/2005 of LNCS, Springer-Verlag (2005) Grangel, R., Chalmeta, R., Campos, C.: Enterprise Modelling, an overview focused on software generation. In Panetto, H., ed.: I-ESA Workshops of the INTEROP-ESA Int. Conf. EI2N, WSI, ISIDI and IEHENA 2005, Hermes Science Publishing (2005) Eriksson, H., Penker, M.: Business Modeling with UML: Business Patterns at Work. J. Wiley (2000) Marshall, C.: Enterprise Modeling with UML. Designing Successful Software Through Business Analysis. Addison Wesley (2000) Opdahl, A.: The UEML Approach to Modelling Construct Description. In: Enterprise Interoperability. Springer-Verlag (2007) OMG: UML 2.1.2 Superstructure. Object Management Group. version 2.1.2 formal/2007-11-04 edn. (2007) Panetto, H.: UML Semantics Representation of Enterprise Modelling Constructs. In: ICEIMT. (2002) 381–387 Berio, G., Petit, M.: Enterprise Modelling and the UML: (sometimes) a conflict without a case. In: Proc. of 10th ISPE International Conf. on Concurrent Engineering: Research and applications. (2003) 26–30 Grangel, R., Bourey, J.P., Chalmeta, R., Bigand, M.: UML for Enterprise Modelling: a Model-Driven Approach. In: I-ESA’06. (2006) OMG: OMG Unified Modeling Language Specification, version 1.5. Object Management Group. formal/03-03-01 edn. (2003)
Improving Interoperability using a UML Profiles for Enterprise Modelling
45
[20] Fuentes, L., Vallecillo, A., Troya, J.: Using UML Profiles for Documenting WebBased Application Frameworks. Annals of Software Engineering 13 (2002) 249–264 [21] Noran, O.: UML vs. IDEF: An Ontology-Oriented Comparative Study in View of Business Modelling. In: ICEIS (3). (2004) 674–682 [22] Berrisford, G.: Why IT veterans are sceptical about MDA. In: Second European Workshop on Model Driven Architecture (MDA) with an emphasis on Methodologies and Transformations, Kent, Computing Laboratory, University of Kent (2004) 125– 135 http://www.cs.kent.ac.uk/projects/kmf/mdaworkshop/submissions/Berrisford.pdf. [23] Chalmeta, R., Grangel, R.: Methodology for the Implementation of Knowledge Management Systems. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 59 (2008) 1–14 John Wiley & Sons. [24] Grangel, R., Chalmeta, R., Campos, C.: A Modelling Framework for Sharing Knowledge. In: Int. Conf. KES 2007. Vol 4693/2007 of LNAI, Springer-Verlag (2007) [25] IBM: IBM Rational Software Modeler Development Platform 6.0.1. http://www306.ibm.com/software/rational/ (2010)
Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds Nenad Ivezic1, Jungyub Woo1 and Hyunbo Cho2 1 2
National Institute of Standards and Technology, 100 Bureau Drive, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA Pohang University of Science and Technology, San 31, Hyoja, Pohang 790-784, Korea
Abstract. We introduce a novel Agile Test Framework (ATF) for eBusiness systems interoperability and conformance testing. Largely, existing test frameworks have been designed to only consider a limited collection of specific test requirements. This makes it difficult to apply these frameworks to other similar standards specifications and to support cooperative work in building distributed global test systems. ATF addresses the core issues found in these traditional testing frameworks to alleviate the resulting inefficiencies and lack-of-reuse problems that arise in the development of eBusiness test beds. Keywords: testing, eBusiness, interoperability, conformance, test framework, test bed, reusability
1. Introduction There exists an increasing need to build efficiently test beds in support of interoperable e-Business applications. For example, a recent international activity was completed under auspicies of the European Committee for Standardization (CEN) to perform a feasibility analysis of the Global Interoperability Test Bed (GITB) for eBusiness systems [1]. The goal of this activity was to establish a foundation for development of a common test framework (i.e., the GITB) for efficient development of global, distributed test beds for eBusiness. Specifically, the activity envisions and recommends development of a shared architecture for the test framework. The objective of this paper is to contribute to a basis for architectural development of the test frameworks that enable efficient building and re-use of test beds for interoperable eBusiness applications. Here, we introduce the Agile Test Framework (ATF) that represents a refinement of our lessons learned of developing test beds for e-Business systems over many years.
48
N. Ivezic, J. Woo, and H. Cho
The rest of the paper is organized as follows: first, we summarize findings of the feasibility analysis of the Global Interoperability Test Bed (GITB) for eBusiness systems. Then, we identify the issues that disqualify certain test frameworks from becoming a solid basis for the GITB. Next, we present design decisions that resolve the previous issues and describe the conceptual architecture for the proposed ATF framework. Finally, we summarize the findings in the paper.
2. Recommendations for the Global Interoperability Test Bed The following is a summary of the GITB project recommendations that directly impact the test framework architectural concerns [1]: • •
•
•
Promote the development of an integrated test framework which (1) does not hard-code a specific standard at any layer and (2) is capable of handling testing activities at all layers of the interoperability stack. Support the implementation of the test framework in a decentralized approach, as a network of multiple test beds and test services. The essential foundations are (1) a standardized testing framework (covering test execution and test case model), (2) a coherent architecture, (3) a common platform, and (4) access method. Also, the functional requirements should be implemented as plug-and-play components to leverage existing standards. In addition, emphasis needs to be given to non-functional capabilities, such as modularity and extensibility. Ensure that industry consortia and standard development organizations (SDOs) address the needs for testing as part of the standardization effort and to enable them to use the test framework. Specifically, in order to allow testing, standards specifications need to (1) complement narrative or semi-formal specifications by formal representations wherever possible; (2) define conformance criteria for compliance with the standard; and (3) comprise implementation guidelines and outline the testing approach and test cases. Conceive the GITB architecture as a set of test services, provided by several test service providers, which may be plugged in test infrastructure based on common interfaces. Focus on modularity and reusability of testing services and components. Provide for test services categorization in support of development of standardized interfaces.
Clearly, a foremost concern is that the test framework architecture promotes efficient development and reusability of testing facilities across different domains and different standards.
3. Issues with Test Frameworks Most existing test frameworks are limited in terms of reuse. Even new frameworks do not aim to maximize reuse of testing facilities and materials, although at least
Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds
49
one recent test framework has invested significant effort to address dynamic, configurable, and fully automated execution of conformance and interoperability test scenarios [2]. Most test frameworks are proposed with the purpose of meeting the requirements of testing for only a specific standard and a specific Test User’s usage. Therefore, their scope is generally narrow, and the provided functionalities cannot be applied easily to similar testing requirements in which, for example, a related standard specification is the subject of testing. For instance, the IIC test framework focuses on the ebMS (ebXML Messaging Specification) [3], the RossettaNet self-test toolkit only deals with the conformance test for RossettaNet PIP systems [4], and the WS-I tool only checks the data integrity of Web Service request/response messages [5]. That is, to test conformance with respect to each standard specification, development of different test frameworks was required such that the facile adaptation of the framework to related standard specifications was forbidden. For example, the IIC framework requires significant changes before it is applicable to related messaging standards, such as WS messaging. Even test frameworks, such as TTCN [6] and eTSM [7], that have been developed to overcome such a narrow scope of application, cannot effectively deal with new similar test requirements, because the test frameworks were not designed with sufficient modularity and extensibility.
Fig. 1. Activity Diagram for Standards-based Testing using Existing Test Frameworks
Figure 1. conceptually describes the typical usage of existing test frameworks – from test requirements to test bed execution. Once the Test User introduces their specific requirements for the intended usage of the standard specification of interest (e.g., by providing a specific business process or pattern of usage), the Test Case Developer composes test cases based on the grammar and structure of test case scripts designed for that particular test framework. At this time, the composed
50
N. Ivezic, J. Woo, and H. Cho
test case is machine-readable and tightly bound to the specific test requirements and specific test platform. By this we mean that the current test frameworks are designed for specific test requirements, specific user environments, and specific implemented testing tools – a specific test platform. The figure indicates this situation by situating the ‘Compose Executable Test Case’ and ‘Implement Test Bed’ activities within the Implementation Phase, supported by the Platform Specific Model (PSM). On the other hand, as shown on the right side of Figure 1, the Test Bed Architect extracts the test bed functional requirements from the Test User’s test requirements to implement a specific test bed based on these functional requirements. At the Execution Phase, the Specific Test Bed uses the Executable Test Cases and verifies the system under test. In summary, existing test frameworks have been designed to only consider a limited collection of specific test requirements, which makes it difficult to apply these frameworks to other standards specifications (regardless of similarity) or to support cooperative work in building distributed global test systems because of the following problems: •
Problem I. Test case dependency on the test bed and test case implementation decisions: The existing frameworks promote test case designs that depend on specific test bed design decisions. For example, a IIC test case cannot represent SUT activities during a test because the IIC test beds, which follow the IIC test framework specification, do not utilize information from the SUT activities (i.e., the test beds cannot control the SUT). This obviously prevents reuse of the test cases in situations in which new test beds are developed according to a common test framework but with different implementation decisions. In the IIC test framework case, new test beds, in which the test bed role changes (say, from a customer to a supplier), would not be able to reuse the previously developed test cases. Also, most test case designs are developed with consideration for specific test implementation requirements, such as a standard specification. For example WS-I tool’s test case cannot represent non-XML content as a test material, because it is designed only for XML-based web service testing. Therefore, the test case design does not support reusability, because application of the existing test case designs to other standards is often not feasible. Obviously, these two dependencies make test case development a time-consuming and costly process, because Test Case Developers are required to simultaneously consider both constraint types when developing test cases;
•
Problem II. Low configurability of test beds: Most test bed designs only consider a specific testing purpose and take into account specific test bed design decisions. It is, therefore, difficult to adopt one test bed to another, similar, testing situation. Such test beds cannot be re-configured and do not allow new components to be introduced in a pluggable manner to address new functional requirements; and
Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds
•
51
Problem III. Low modularity and extensibility of test cases: Most test cases contain both procedure and verification instructions for the data. However, the existing test framework designs do not treat the two types of information separately. Consequently, it is difficult to extract verification data from a test case in order to reuse a specific part of the test case in a related, similar, testing situation.
4. A Service Oriented Architecture for Agile Test Framework 4.1. Overall Approach Our purpose is to resolve the problems identified with the existing test frameworks by introducing new design decisions within a proposed test framework. Most existing test cases depend on both the specific test case implementation requirements and the test bed implementation (as described in Problem I). To resolve this problem, we remove the dependency of the test cases by introducing a two-layer test case design consisting of abstract and executable test case definitions. •
ATF_Design Decision I: Two-level test case design. The ATF test case structure consists of an abstract test case and an executable test case. The abstract test case is a human-readable, high level description of a test case. To enhance the reusability of the test case, an abstract test case does not contain specific implementation-level information. On the other hand, an executable test case is a machine-readable, low level description of a test case. The executable test case can be obtained by transformation from an abstract test case, when provided additional specific testing environment information (e.g., messaging protocol specification, a specific verification component, and a communication channel between the SUT and test bed). The existing test frameworks promote test case designs that are executable test cases. The addition of abstract test case descriptions is expected to have three benefits: 1) the abstract test case can be developed early in the design process without requirements for the test bed systems details, providing a clear specification of intent for the test case; 2) the abstract test case can be easily reused when similar test requirements arise, because it has no dependency on a specific test bed implementation; and 3) the abstract test case helps the testing user to understand the executable test case and its procedure and rules. That is, the abstract test case provides a kind of three-way bridge between the Standard Developer, who provides test requirements, the Testing User who verifies the system under test, and the Test Case Developer, who interprets the requirements to create the actual test case. Most existing test bed implementations cannot be re-configured to easily accommodate varying and dynamic functional requirements (as captured in Problem II). This low re-configurability problem makes a test bed difficult to reuse and adapt for new but related functional requirements. To resolve this
52
N. Ivezic, J. Woo, and H. Cho
problem, we propose the use of pluggable test components and infrastructure designs for the test bed implementation. •
ATF_Design Decision II: Pluggable test components and infrastructure designs. The ATF test bed execution model will consist of a test infrastructure with pluggable test components. The test infrastructure will allow assembly of the test components into the implementation of a desired testing service. The test infrastructure is independent of any specific standard and/or Test User’s environment. That is, it may be used for any type of testing without modification. In contrast, pluggable test components are designed and implemented by a test service provider to enable a specific function required for a specific standard and/or Test User’s environment. Normally, the test infrastructure would not provide the functions of the pluggable test component. • ATF_Design Decision III: Event-driven Test Execution design. In an ATF test bed, the pluggable test components are loosely coupled to the test infrastructure. Because it is impossible for the test infrastructure to control a potentially very large set of arbitrary pluggable test components, ATF relies on a generic transaction handler, instead of allowing direct interfacing between the test components. When a component attempts to interact with another component, it sends data to an event board instead of the target component. The event board stores the various types of interaction data as events so that every component can inquire and retrieve a specific event. All of the activities of the pluggable components and the test infrastructure are coordinated via events. When a Service Provider designs a pluggable test component, the design is registered with the Test Service Model Repository to be discovered and reused in similar testing situations. The pluggable test component is automatically deployed (configured) into the test infrastructure prior to a test execution. Introduction of the pluggable test component design anticipates three benefits: 1) the test infrastructure may be consistently reused for many types of testing, 2) the pluggable test components may be conditionally reused for the same testing requirements, and 3) automatic configuration makes the test bed more extensible and reusable. Most existing test cases are designed without separating the procedural definitions and verification rules (as captured in Problem III). This makes the test case virtually impossible to reuse and difficult to manage for large scale test suites (i.e., sets of test cases). To resolve this problem, we introduce two design decisions: •
ATF_Design Decision IV: Modular test case design. The abstract test case will consist of two design modules: assertion and procedure modules. Such a design yields an abstract test case which is not only easier to read but also easier to reuse, because the Test Bed Manager may reuse each module separately when the test case is adapted for different test requirements. In the executable test case, procedure and assertion content (scripts) will be separated for reuse in new executable test cases.
Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds
53
•
ATF_Design Decision V: Event-centric test case design. Every type of event - from low-level protocol signals (e.g. Acknowledgements) to business document receipts - may be captured by the event board and wrapped into a standard event envelope. Virtually all testing events are captured, stored, and may be used to trigger an arbitrary testing activity, such as a data extraction procedure or verification action. Because every assertion or procedure module in the test case contains triggering conditions, each module can be independently introduced and managed. By introducing a modular and event-centric design for test cases, we expect two benefits: 1) each module, either procedure or assertion, may be independently reused by another test case; and 2) because the test case module is not affected by other changes in the module, a Test Case Developer may easily manage large scale test suites.
Fig. 2. Procedure Architecture of the Agile Test Framework
4.2. Service Oriented Architecture for Agile Test Framework This section provides a high-level view of the ATF architecture and supported processes, as illustrated in Figure 2. Because the ATF architecture is designed according to the ATF design decisions discussed previously, Figure 2 illustrates the major differences between ATF and existing test frameworks, shown in Figure 1. First, the design phase (corresponding to Platform Independent Model (PIM)) is positioned between the conceptual and implementation phases. Actions in this phase are abstract and independent of a specific test bed implementation. The
54
N. Ivezic, J. Woo, and H. Cho
previous Test Bed Architect role now is broken into the three new roles: Test Service Provider, Test Bed Manager, and Test Framework Provider. The new roles and their activities reflect the drive towards greater modularity and reusability. Each test case has separate modules for verification rules and procedural data. The following are descriptions of the key processes supported by the ATF architecture: •
•
•
•
•
Analyze Test Requirements: The Test Case Developer investigates the requirements given by a standard specification and a specification for intended usage of the standard. He/she determines the functions that need to verify the identified Test User’s SUT. Compose Abstract Test Cases: An abstract test case consists of usage and assertion scripts. From the given test requirements, a collection of abstract test cases is developed (1) to represent the required scenarios as usage scripts that extract test items from the SUT, and (2) to provide predicates (i.e., true–false statements) as assertion scripts to determine whether the test item is true or false. The generated abstract test case is not machinereadable because it is generated without concern for a specific harness script. That is, an abstract test case does not describe a concrete test environment (e.g., message protocol) or specific configuration (i.e., included test components) for a specific test bed. Therefore, an abstract test case is independent of a specific test bed implementation and is a kind of meta-model for an executable test case. Compose Executable Test Cases: An executable test case consists of verification and procedure scripts. Such an executable test case is generated from a corresponding abstract test case after considering a specific test harness specification (or script). In other words, after the test environment and configuration information regarding the partner(s) and target SUT(s), pluggable test components to be used for the testing, protocol and schema to be used for business documents, etc., are decided and specified within the test harness script by the Test Bed Manager, the Test Case Developer may generate a machine-readable executable test case from an abstract test case. This test environment and configuration information is encoded as a harness script by the Test Bed Manager. The generated executable test case is registered into the test case repository. Analyze Functional Non-stationary Requirements: The Test Bed Manager investigates functional non-stationary requirements based on the test requirements. A non-stationary requirement is a specific test service requirement for a specific testing situation. That is, the test service is required for a testing scenario at hand but it may not be used in other testing situations without additional adaptation. Design and Register Pluggable Test Components: The pluggable test component provides a specific test service. A Test Service Provider designs the pluggable test component according to the standard specification and the interface specification for the pluggable test components. Once the pluggable test component is designed, it should be registered in a public
Towards Test Framework for Efficient and Reusable Global e-Business Test Beds
•
•
•
•
55
service registry. At that time, the Test Service Provider registers the information, such as technical capabilities, service interface, and index of service categorization, which are described in Section 5.4. Search and Select Pluggable Test Components: The Test Bed Manager searches for the relevant pluggable test components that are needed for the specific test bed. The Test Bed Manager decides the optimal set of pluggable test components among the alternative components. Generate Harness Script: The Test Bed Manager composes the harness script, which contains the test environment and configuration information describing the partner(s) and target SUT(s), pluggable test components to be used for the testing, the protocol and schema to be used for business documents, and other information necessary to assemble the required test bed. Implement Pluggable Test Component: The Test Service Provider implements and customizes a pluggable test component based on the pluggable test component design and specific interface requirements described in the harness script provided by the Test Bed Manager. Assemble Test Bed and Execute Test Case: A test bed is automatically configured on the basis of information contained in the harness script. That is, a test bed is assembled from the test infrastructure and the selected loosely coupled pluggable test components. Finally the test bed interprets and executes the executable test case to verify the system under test.
5. Conclusions In this paper, we have presented a novel Agile Test Framework (ATF) for B2B testing, which addresses the core issues found in traditional testing frameworks to alleviate the resulting inefficiencies and lack-of-reuse problems that arise in the development of B2B test beds. First, traditional test case designs rely on specific test bed and test case implementation decisions. In the ATF architecture, this issue is addressed by introducing the concept of an abstract test case, which insulates the test case specifications from the implementation details and from the specific testing platform decisions. The executable test cases are obtained by way of a transformation, only when the specific test bed configuration is specified. Second, traditional test execution models rely on specific testing requirements and do not consider the reuse of testing modules in similar situations. In the ATF architecture, the issue is addressed by introducing the concepts of test infrastructure, the pluggable test components, and event-driven execution. The test infrastructure contains readily reusable core functionalities that allow assembly of the test components into novel implementations of desired testing services. By way of event-driven execution, ATF provides a generic transaction handler, an event board, which coordinates and facilitates communication between the infrastructure and pluggable components. Third, traditional test case designs do not recognize and separate procedural and verification aspects of the test case, which makes test cases impossible to
56
N. Ivezic, J. Woo, and H. Cho
reuse. In the ATF architecture, the issue is addressed by introducing modular and event-centric test case design. The modular design separates two types of information: assertions and procedural information. The event-centric design allows assertion and procedure modules in the test case to contain triggering conditions, which allows each module to be independently managed and reused. Following these ATF architectural decisions, we are presently completing the necessary details for the test case design and execution model. The detailed design will be followed by a comparison of the proposed architecture with other existing test framework architectures. Our goal is to assure that the global, distributed eBusiness test beds are efficiently developed by reusing existing testing services while successfully addressing complex e-Business testing situations.
6. Disclaimer Certain commercial software products are identified in this paper. These products were used only for demonstration purposes. This use does not imply approval or endorsement by NIST, nor does it imply these products are necessarily the best available for the purpose.
7. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
GITB (Global eBusiness Interoperability Test Bed Methodologies), on line at www.ebusiness-testbed.eu, accessed December 2009. TestBATN – Testing Business, Application, Transport, and Network Layers Web Site, on line at www.srdc.com.tr/testBATN, accessed December 2009. IIC ("ebXML IIC Test Framework Version 1.0." OASIS), on line at http://www.oasisopen.org/committees/download.php/1990/ebXML-TestFramework-10.zip, accessed December 2009. RosettaNet (RosettaNet Ready Self-Test Kit (STK) User’s Guide Release Version 2.0.7). RosettaNet, 2004. WS-I tool site, on line at http://ws-i.org, accessed December 2009. TTCN-3 site, on line at http://www.ttcn-3.org, accessed December 2009. TaMIE Site, on line at http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/tamie, accessed December 2009.
Unified Reversible Life Cycle for Future Interoperable Enterprise Distributed Information Systems Zhiying Tu1, Gregory Zacharewicz1 , David Chen1 1
IMS-LAPS / GRAI, Université de Bordeaux – CNRS, 351, Cours de laLibération,33405, TALENCE cedex, France
Abstract. This paper aims at improving the re-implementation of existing information systems when they are called to be involved in a system of systems, i.e. a federation of enterprise information systems that interoperate. The idea is reusing the local experiences coming from the development of the original information system with the process of Model Discovery and Ontological approach. We give first, a review of ongoing researches on Enterprise Interoperability. The MDA can help to transform concepts and models from the conceptual level to the implementation. The HLA standard, initially designed for military M&S purpose, can be transposed for enterprise interoperability at the implementation level, reusing the years of experiences in distributed systems. From these postulates, we propose a MDA/HLA lifecycle to implement distributed enterprise models from the conceptual level of federated enterprise interoperability approach. In addition to this classical development, we propose a model reversal methodology to help re-implement the legacy information system, in order to achieve the interoperability with other systems. Keywords: Interoperabilitty, HLA, MDA, FEDEP, Information System
1. Introduction In the globalised economic context, the competitiveness of an enterprise depends not only on its internal productivity and performance, but also on its ability to collaborate with others. This necessity led to the development of a new concept called interoperability that allows improving collaborations between enterprises. No doubt, in such context where more and more networked enterprises are developed; enterprise interoperability is seen as a more suitable solution to total enterprise integration. Since the beginning of 2000, several European research projects have been launched to develop enterprise interoperability (IDEAS, ATHENA, INTEROP). Three main research themes or domains that address interoperability issues were identified, namely: (1) Enterprise modeling (EM) dealing with the representation
58
Z. Tu, G. Zacharewicz and D. Chen
of the inter-networked organization to establish interoperability requirements; (2) Architecture & Platform (A&P) defining the implementation solution to achieve interoperability; (3) Ontologies (ON) addressing the semantics necessary to assure interoperability. This paper intends to propose an improvement of the re-implementation of existing information systems when they are called to be involved in a system of systems. Compare to the traditional IS and Simulation development process, we involve the bottom-up process of Model Discovery and Ontological approach into our framework. In the framework, first, we align MDA and HLA to propose a lifecycle to implement distributed enterprise models from the conceptual level of federated enterprise interoperability approach. Besides that, a model reversal methodology is integrated with the MDA/HLA development lifecycle to assist reengineer the legacy information system, in order to achieve interoperability with other systems. The paper is structured as follows. We start out with a survey of related work in the area of HLA, MDA and their harmonization, as well as in the area of reengineering to model-driven architectures (section 2). Then, we describe our motivation of this work (section 3). After that, we explain two main parts of our methodology, alignment of MDA and HLA FEDEP (section 4) and Model Reversal (section 5).
2. IS and Simulation Development Life Cycle: State-of-the-Art 2.1. HLA The High Level Architecture (HLA) is a software architecture specification that defines how to create a global software execution composed of distributed simulations and software applications. This standard was originally introduced by the Defense Modeling and Simulation Office (DMSO) of the US Department Of Defense (DOD). The original goal was reuse and interoperability of military applications, simulations and sensors. In HLA, every participating application is called federate. A federate interacts with other federates within a HLA federation, which is in fact a group of federates. The HLA set of definitions brought about the creation of the standard 1.3 in 1996, which evolved to HLA 1516 in 2000 [1]. The interface specification of HLA describes how to communicate within the federation through the implementation of HLA specification: the Run Time Infrastructure (RTI). Federates interact using services proposed by the RTI. They can notably “Publish” to inform about an intention to send information to the federation and “Subscribe” to reflect some information created and updated by other federates. The information exchanged in HLA is represented in the form of classical object class oriented programming. The two kinds of object exchanged in HLA are Object Class and Interaction Class. Object class contains object-oriented data shared in the federation that persists during the run time; Interaction class data are just sent and
Unified Reversible Life Cycle
59
received information between federates. These objects are implemented within XML format. More details on RTI services and information distributed in HLA are presented in [1]. The FEDEP (Federation Development and Execution Process) describes a highlevel framework for the development and execution of HLA federation. FEDEP uses the seven-step process to guide the spiral development of the simulation system through phases of requirements, conceptual modelling, design, software development, integration, and execution [2]. 2.2. MDA The first methodology studied is Model Driven Architecture (MDA). This methodology defined and adopted by the Object Management Group (OMG) in 2001, (updated in [3]) is designed to promote the use of models and their transformations to consider and implement different systems. It is based on an architecture defining four levels, which goes from general considerations to specific ones. •
• • •
CIM Level (Computation Independent Model): focusing on the whole system and its environment. It is also named « domain model », it describes all work field models (functional, organisational, decisional, process…) of the system with an independent vision from implementation. PIM Level (Platform Independent Model): modelling the sub-set of the system that will be implemented. PSM Level (Platform Specific Model): that takes into account the specificities related to the development platform. Coding Level: The last level consists in coding enterprises applications (ESA: Enterprise Software Application).
To complete this description, a Platform Description Model used for the transformation between PIM level and PSM level is added to these four kinds of models corresponding to four abstraction levels. 2.3. MDA/HLA Harmonization In [4], Andreas Tolk mentions that while the HLA can help the MDA to improve in its principles concerning distributed simulation systems, the MDA can help the HLA implementers to improve their products based on the experiences of the OMG partners and the related software industry. Meanwhile, [4] proposes to consider five aspects for merge HLA and MDA together: Domain Facilities, Pervasive Services, RTI as Middleware, Federation Development Tools, and Data Engineering. A solution of applying MDA to HLA is proposed in [5]. In this methodology, the Component-based development (CBD) is underlined. The design goals and philosophy of CBD also share many similarities with the goals of HLA federate development, including the promotion of reuse and interoperability. However, HLA currently has no standardized development approach to CBD, known as a
60
Z. Tu, G. Zacharewicz and D. Chen
component model, analogous to the CORBA Component Model (CCM) or the Enterprise Java Bean (EJB) container. As a result, there is no commonality in design and implementation between federates, nor any formal way of separating and reusing the behavioural aspects of an HLA component. This results in an increase in development and maintenance costs, as well as impacting on the potential for reuse outside of the FOM for which the federate was built. As the result, they introduce SCM (simulation component model) into HLA (fig.1.). SCM is one potential candidate for the definition of a standardized model for component-based simulation development. This architecture employs a component model based on the OMG’s CCM, and describes how the separation of integration logic and simulation behaviour can be achieved for an HLA federate. This SCM development model also provides a commonality of design between federates, allowing them to access both HLA and extended CBD services (such as data transformation services between federates and the FOM) in a consistent manner.
Fig. 1. Simulation component model
2.4. MDA/FEDEP As mentioned in [6], FEDEP and MDA are successful within their particular community. FEDEP and MDA are separate, but alignable development life cycle. Each follows basic systems engineering process through analysis is done in the following areas: • • • •
Definition of requirements Definition of attributes and behaviors through a functional analysis of the requirements Expression of requirements, functions and analysis in narrative and graphical form Design of the ‘product’
Unified Reversible Life Cycle
61
Based on the FEDEP MDA alignment shown in fig. 2, [6] also proposes a development lifecycle as illustrated in fig. 3, which surrounds the testing phase, in order to implement the VV&A.
Fig. 2. FEDEP MDA alignment
Fig. 3. FEDEP MDA alignment based lifecycle
2.5. MDA-Based Reverse Engineering A framework to reverse engineering MDA models from object oriented code is presented in [7]. This framework is based on the integration of compiler techniques, metamodeling and formal specification and it also distinguishes three different abstraction levels linked to models, metamodels and formal specifications, as fig. 4 shows. In this framework, the model transformations are based on classical compiler construction techniques at model level. At the metamodel level, MOF metamodels are used to describe the transformations from model level. MOF metamodels describe families of ISMs, PSMs and PIMs. Every ISM, PSM and PIM conforms to a MOF metamodel. Metamodel transformations are specified as OCL contracts
62
Z. Tu, G. Zacharewicz and D. Chen
between a source metamodel and a target metamodel. MOF metamodels “control” the consistency of these transformations. The level of formal specification includes specifications of MOF metamodels and metamodel transformations in the metamodeling language NEREUS that can be used to connect them with different formal and programming languages The transformations are based on static and dynamic analysis at model level [7]. •
•
Static analysis extracts static information that describes the software structure reflected in the software documentation (e.g., the text of the source code). Static information can be extracted by using techniques and tools based on compiler techniques such as parsing and data flow algorithms. Dynamic analysis extracts dynamic analysis information, which describes the structure of the run-behavioral, by using debuggers, event recorders and general tracer tools. Dynamic analysis is based on an execution model including the following components: a set of objects, a set of attributes for each object, a location and value of an object type for each object, and a set of messages. Additionally, types such as Integer, String, Real and Boolean are available for describing types of attributes and parameters of methods or constructors.
Fig. 4. MDA-based reverse engineering framework
3. Studied Context A multiple agent/HLA enterprise interoperability methodology is proposed in [9]. It mentions several enterprises who all participate in a cooperative project, and they need to exchange various information any time, so the framework (fig. 5) defined in the methodology provides a platform based on HLA, where each enterprise plays as a federate and connect to each other.
Unified Reversible Life Cycle
63
Fig. 5. Interoperable System of Information-Systems
However, most of the enterprises will have their own IT system, and sometimes the cooperation among those companies won’t last permanently, some of them could join this group for a very short period time and then quit. Consequently it seems not adequat and luxurious to launch a totally new IT project for this short time cooperation. As the result, how to build the federate for each enterprise merits consideration. Refering to the existing methodologies mentioned in previous sections, we propose a new approach, as the fig. 6 shows, to solve this problem. This methodology will involve MDA&HLA FEDEP alignment in order to use both of their advantages to realize proper component reuse and rapid development. Besides that, in order to achieve a rapid federate development according to the legacy IT system, the model reverse engineering is integrated with this alignment.
4. Alignment of MDA and HLA FEDEP In this section, we propose a new development lifecycle to reconstruct HLA FEDEP and MDA, and generate a new five steps development framework (as shown in fig. 6). This new methodology aims to adopt the strong points from both HLA FEDEP and MDA while overcoming their weak points, then, to achieve proper component reuse and rapid development. Phase 1: Domain Requirment Definition The main task of this phase is to collect clear and enough requirements from customer in order to define the objective of the system, to describe the environment of the system, the senario of the system. At the same time, all these definition and description need to be reasonable, understandable for all the stakeholder. CIM of MDA has more similar task with Define Federation Objectives, Develop Federation scenario together in HLA FEDEP. As the result, we align them in this phase, to convert the user requirement, which is more textual based, into more visual model, such as UML use case to derive the federation requirement, etc.
64
Z. Tu, G. Zacharewicz and D. Chen
Fig. 6. IS and Simulation Devellopment Life Cycle
Phase 2: Domain Scenario Systematization The main task of this phase is to refine the domain scenario and business process defined in the first phase, to identify and describe the entities involved in the scenario and business process. And then, to define the relationships among entities and behaviors, events for each entity, etc. This phase integrates PIM in MDA, which describes the operation of system but doesn’t address the detail platform information yet, as well as steps of Perform Conceptual Analysis, Develop Federation Requirements and Select Federates in HLA FEDEP, which also define and select general participators of the federation, then describe their relationship, behaviours and event in general. Phase 3: System Model Specialization In this phase, according to the technique chosen and platform selected, the system needs to be refined, for instance, to refine federation and federate structure, to allocate functions and attributes, etc. Detailed design will carry out at this time. This phase integrates the following parts in MDA and FEDEP. PSM in MDA, which is in the form of software and hardware manuals or even in an architect’s head, will be based on detailed platform models, for example, models expressed in UML and OCL, or UML, and stored in a MOF compliant repository. The Prepare federation design, Prepare plan, Develop FOM, and Establish federation agreement in FEDEP will produce federate responsibilities, federation architecture, supporting tools, integration plan, VV&A plan, FOM, FED/FDD and time management, date management, distribution agreements, etc. Phase 4: System Implementation This phase’s task is to transfer the specific system model into code, to create the executable federation and runable federate.
Unified Reversible Life Cycle
65
At this level, MDA has various transformation techniques from model to code. In the FEDEP, Implement Federate designs will provide modified and/or new federates and supporting database. Implement Federation Infrastructure will provide implemented federation infrastructure and modified RTI initialization data. Plan Execution and Integrate Federation will provide execution environment description and integrated federation. Phase 5: Test Throughout the previous steps of the MDA and HLA FEDEP alignment process, testing is essential to ensure fidelity of the models. Testing phase includes the Test Federation, Execute Federation and Prepare Outputs, and Analyze Data and Evaluate Results in HLA FEDEP. Meanwhile, it will also refer to the outputs from the previos steps, such as the original user requirment in the first step, and federation test criteria from second phase.
5. Model Reversal This section describes a brand-new process of model reverse engineering with different senarios constraints (see fig. 6). The reverse process will re-characterize the legacy system in order to capitalize on the information and functions of the existing system, and make it easy for reusing in a new HLA compliant system. This methodology will assite to HLA FEDEP / MDA alignment mentioned in previous section, to fully achieve rapid development of federation and/or federate based on the legacy IT systems. We distiguish two kinds of reversal scenarios as following. 1. First, when an enterprise intents to start exchanging information in a new cooperative project with other enterprises. In that case, the HLA federation has not been created yet, so we propose to reverse the code of the legacy information systems to the first definition phase (domain requirment definition). Then from top to down, we generate the model for each phase, finally we produce a federation and federate rapid development template. 2. Second, if an enterprise intents to paticipate in a existing cooperative project and exchange data with other heterogeneous IS. Thus, we assume an HLA federation has already been created. Here, according to the HLA FEDEP, federate starts to be considered from the second step (Perform Conceptual Analysis) as the reversal scenario 2 shows in fig. 6. Therefore it is not necessary to reverse to the first phase, the reversal can stop at the second phase (Domain scenario systematization). One will only reuse the model of the existing federation to create the model for the federate related to the legacy system of the new participator. Finally, the model of the existing federation and the new federate model are used to generate the code template for the new federate for rapid development.
66
Z. Tu, G. Zacharewicz and D. Chen
6. Conclusion and Future Works Based on the state-of-the-art, we have proposed a new systematic methodology, which is a valuable outcome of the combination of HLA FEDEP & MDA alignment and Model reverse engineering. This methodology provides a new five steps process to develop models of simulation starting from conceptual enterprise models. In addition, it also bridges the gap from concepts to implementation in the field of enterprise modelling by offering a new standardised and reversible approach. This methodology seems promising regarding to real enterprise information system requirement of distribution, federated interoperability and agility of adapt to dynamic context. Compared with other techniques, which can solve the interoperability problem, such as SOA, our methodology is trying to provide a standard service API for all the participants, who can use this API to develop communication agent which adapts to the existing IT system without changing it. Up to now, this work is still in a research process. The methodology presented (each phase of HLA/MDA alignment and the model reversal process) still needs to be refined and detailed. A case study will allow testing the proposed approach in an industrial context.
7. References [1]
IEEE std 1516.2-2000. IEEE Standard for Modeling and Simulation (M&S) High Level Architecture (HLA) - Federate Interface Specification, Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers. [2] IEEE std 1516.3-2003. IEEE Standard for Modeling and Simulation (M&S) High Level Architecture (HLA) - Federation Development and Execution Process (FEDEP), The Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineer. [3] OMG, 2003. MDA Guide Version 1.0.1. Object Management Group, Document number: OMG / 20030601 Available from: www.omg.org/docs/-omg/03-06-01.pdf [accessed 15 June 2009] [4] Andreas T, (2002), Avoiding another Green Elephant—A Proposal for the Next Generation HLA based on the Model Driven Architecture. Proceedings of the 2002 Fall Simulation Interoperability Workshop: 02F-SIW-004 [5] Shawn P, (2003), The Next Step Applying the Model Driven Architecture to HLA. Proceedings of the 2003 Spring. Workshop: 03S-SIW -123 [6] Trbovich S, Reading R, (2005) Simulation and Software Development for Capabilities Based Warfare: An Analysis of Harmonized Systems Engineering Processes. Proceedings Spring Simulation Interoperability Workshop: 05S-SIW-106 [7] Favre L, Martinez L, Pereira C, (2008), MDA-Based Reverse Engineering of Object Oriented Code. SERA’08: 153-160 [8] Favre L, (2008), Formalizing MDA-based Reverse Engineering Processes. SERA’08: 153-160 [9] Zacharewicz G, Chen D, Vallespir B, (2008), HLA Supported, Federation Oriented Enterprise Interoperability, Application to Aerospace Enterprises. Proceedings of 2008 EURO International Simulation Multi-conference: 08E-SIW-074 [10] Meta Object Facility (MOF) Specification v1.4, OMG Document formal/02-04-03, http://www.omg.org/cgi-bin/apps/doc?formal/02-04-03.pdf
Part II
Enterprise Modeling for Enterprise Interoperability
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling Shang Gao1 and John Krogstie1 1
Department of Computer and Information Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Sem Sælands Vei 7-9, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
Abstract. In this paper, a meta-model for the business process characterizing model (BPCM) is defined. The defined meta-model, mainly capturing the syntax and semantics of the business process charactrizing model, is intended to guide the development of business process support systems. In addition, the relation between the SCOR model and the class process in the BPCM meta-model is addressed. Furthermore, the mapping from the BPCM meta-model to BPMN meta-model in a combined framework for developing business process support systems is depicted. Keywords: Meta-model, Business Process Characterizing Model (BPCM), Process Modelling, SCOR
1. Introduction The development of a business process support system is a complicated process that not only requires solving technical problems, but also needs taking the organizational problems related to the business domain into consideration. Different modelling techniques with various purposes and orientations, such as, agent-oriented modelling approach (i*[19]), and process-oriented modelling approach (BPMN [17]), have been proposed and used in developing business process support systems. These approaches have been successfully used in providing some key concepts which are essential to develop business process support systems. However, these modelling techniques often fail in the aspect of providing a modelling approach which can facilitate communications among business stakeholders. Therefore, a good understanding of business domain knowledge is a prerequisite to succeed in developing an effective business process support system. Some articles (e.g. [14] [19] [8]) have pointed out the importance of capturing organizational knowledge and requirements before process modeling design and requirements elicitation.
70
S. Gao and J. Krogstie
Further, with the growing interest in mobile commerce [16], there is an increasing need for methods and techniques that help in supporting process system development in mobile settings. Consequently, it makes the concept of context essential when designing and developing business process support systems, especially in mobile settings. Advanced business support systems are supposed to be able to support users according to the specific context environment. It is believed that there is a tight complementary relationship between activities in process models and context variables. And modelling context information is not a standalone task. It needs to be integrated with high level business modelling and analysis to design and elicit business process systems. Therefore, a new language needs to be developed to deal with the needs mentioned above. As illustrated in [7], one of the main ways of utilizing models is to describe some essential information of a business case informally in order to facilitate communications among stakeholders. In [9], by taking inspiration from this idea, we proposed the business process characterizing model (BPCM), which can be seen as an important early, business-oriented model in a modeling-based project. A BPCM model is characterized by its ability to address the key concepts (actor, goal, context, business domain, etc) involved in a business model development process. BPCM aims to provide an enhanced ability to understand and communicate business processes to all stakeholders involved in the development lifecycle. Such a model shows some essential elements of the business solution to be developed, anchored in business-oriented terminology. The main objective of this paper is to define a BPCM meta-model, mainly capturing the syntax and semantics of the BPCM, which is intended to ensure traceability among different models involved in the development of business process support systems through a combined framework [8]. A meta-model is a model which is used to specify certain features of a model. In this research work, the BPCM meta-model is used to describe the BPCM modelling constructs and relationships of the constructs. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 briefly describes BPCM. Section 3 defines a BPCM meta-model. In section 4, we illustrate the relation between the BPCM meta-model and the SCOR Model. Mapping from the BPCM meta-model to the BPMN meta-model is depicted in section 5. Finally, this paper is concluded in section 6.
2. Business Process Characterizing Model (BPCM) In the course of business process support system development, model developers focus on operational and procedural aspects of process systems, while various business stakeholders are more likely to express different concerns with regard to process models in terms of business oriented concepts. Most process modelling languages, like BPMN [18] or EPC [1], do not offer the necessary support mechanisms to express business oriented concerns in connection with process models. On the one hand, business stakeholders need a simplified model to express their concerns from the organizational perspective easily. On the other hand, process model developers would like to get the business
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling
71
process system specification in a better modelling language to ease their communications with business stakeholders. Successful business process support system requires the understanding of needs from various stakeholders involved in the business process. Therefore, in order to tackle these problems, we proposed a language for business process characterizing modelling in [9]. BPCM modelling aims to provide an enhanced ability to understand and communicate business processes to all stakeholders involved in the business process development project. The main objective is to assist both business stakeholders and model developers in the development lifecycle. Additionally, the BPCM model can be integrated into a combined framework for development of business process support systems [8], consisting of other modelling techniques, such as goal modelling and process modelling. Table 1 summarizes the general definition of the elements in a business process characterizing model. Table 1. Definition of the elements in BPCM
Element Process Resource Actor Context Business Domain Goal
Process Type
General Definition The business process people want to characterize. This element can be related to a common business process ontology such as SCOR [3]. This element is inspired by the resource concept in the REA framework [13]. This element can clearly address what are consumed and what are gained in a business process. This element describes the people and organizations with different roles involve in a business process. This element can illustrate who are important to which business process. It includes contextual characteristics in terms of locations and networks providing connections between the devices and others. This element classifies the business domain. We tend to link this element to the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS). This element can address what kinds of goals need to be fulfilled in the business process. The goals may be related to operational goals and strategical goals. Operational goals are related to hard-goals, usually covering functional requirements; while strategic goals are related to soft-goals, which set the basis for non-functional requirements. According to REA [11], REA does not model only exchanges but also conversions. Exchange and conversion can be seen as two typical process types.
In order to better illstruate BPCM modelling approach, a small example is provided in Table 2. In the realm of organizing conferences, the main actor is the organizational unit set up to organize the conference. This actor liaises with a number of other organizations to deliver the conference to the participants, for example: the conference proceeding is to be published by a professional publisher a couple of days before the conference. The reason to use a publisher is that having a renowned publication will attract more submissions.
72
S. Gao and J. Krogstie Table 2. BPCM model for producing conference proceedings BPCM Name
BPCM Elements
Publish proceedings with professional publisher
Process
Publish proceedings (ref to SCOR S3 Source Engineer-to-order Product (Proceedings)) Proceedings proposal (including previous acceptance rate for conference, acceptance rate of current conference, conference organizer) Organizing Committee, Publisher, Shipping company PC over LAN/WLAN, internet communication 561920 Convention and Trade Show Organizers 51113 Book Publishers (for publisher) Hard Goals: Proceedings physically delivered to conference organization a couple of days before conference starts(to be able to prepare delegate package) Soft goal: Minimize cost of proceedings Soft goal: Maximize the perceived status of publication Conversion (money for published proceeding)
Resource Actor Context Business Domain Goal
Process Type
Since some elements in the BPCM model refer to other ontologies or systems as presented in the Table 1, a brief description of those concepts and the motivation to incorporte those concepts is provided here. Concerning the element context, there is no universal or absolute definition for context. [5] describes context as “typically the location, identity, and state of people, groups and computational and physical objects”. Context is the reification of the environment, that is, whatever provides a surrounding in which the system operates. People can base their own perceptions or understanding to define context in different ways. In order to better design business process support system, it is crucial to collect and deliver contextual information in a better way. By including context element in a BPCM model, the correspondent business process support system is able to serve people better in mobile computing settings. Recently, W3C has released a draft version of the Delivery Context Ontology (DCO). This ontology constructed in OWL provides a model of characteristics of the environment in which a device interacts with the web or other services. In this research work, we incorporate some key entities of DCO into the element context of BPCM. Some other research work has also started addressing the relationship between context and system development at the requirement level. For instance, [2] investigates the relation between context and requirements at the beginning of goal oriented analysis, and [15] extends the application of the problem frames approach with context monitoring and switching problems. The SCOR model is developed by the supply chain council and aims to describe the operations of various supply chain constructs. It classifies the operations of supply chain as Plan, Source, Make, Deliver and Return. The main advantage of the SCOR model is to facilitate the knowledge sharing and cooperation among the various participants interested in that particular domain of knowledge. Moreover, having a set of standardized ontologies for the domain knowledge of business process support systems development will enhance the
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling
73
interoperability between the various process support systems. Integrating SCOR with the element process of BPCM for the development of business process support systems will result in a reusable, easy to integrate knowledge repository. REA [11] was originally conceived as a framework for accounting system, but it has subsequently broadened its scope and developed into an enterprise domain ontology. The duality of resource transfer is essential in commerce. It never happens that one agent simply gives away a resource to another without expecting another resource back as compensation. As illustrated in [8], the element resource of BPCM is important in identifying relevant tasks or activities for the construction of process models. For each resource in a BPCM, it should include a message flow which links two associated tasks in a BPMN process model, whereby the source of the message flow connected to the dependee’s task and the destination of the message flow connected to the depender’s task. Last but not least, the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) is a standard for the collection, tabulation, presentation, and analysis of statistical data describing the U.S. economy. NAICS is based on a production-oriented concept, meaning that it groups establishments into industries according to similarity in the processes used to produce goods or services. Each business process is labeled with a business domain. This is of help for model users to search or retrieve business processes within specific business domain.
3. BPCM Meta-model It is important to note that the BPCM model aims to be an easy to understand modeling language for all business stakeholders and model developers. Most process modeling languages (e.g. BPMN) do not offer the necessary mechanisms to include organizational or contextual concerns associated to a process model. What the BPCM modeling language distinguishes from them is to provide some constructs to tackle those concerns. The aim of this BPCM meta-model is to aid model developers with the various concerns from business stakeholders in designing the desired process models. The BPCM meta-model is described in Figure 1, which presents the major modeling concept and the relationships between them. UML class diagram is used to create the BPCM meta-model. The central class of the meta-model is process. One process may consists of zero or more sub process(es) by the representation of UML compositions. All other main classess can be associated with the central class process. Around the central class, business stakeholders could express different concerns, like required actors, required resources, contextual information, and so on. We use UML generalizations in case of elements extensions (e.g. context, process types). Then, process model developers can take these concerns into consideration when designing process models accordingly. The delivery context ontology mainly focuses on the following three entities: a). environment including information about the location and network, b). software describes whether the delivery context supports certain APIs, document formats, operating systems, etc, c). Hardware provides information about various hardware
74
S. Gao and J. Krogstie
capabilities including display, input, memory, etc. For the class context, we do not attempt to cover all entities above. We focus on two major aspects: location and network information. For example, a user using its device is connected to an information system through a wireless network or wired network. Mobile workers need to work in various locations (e.g. at home, in the office, on the way). Business process scenario itself is a complex, dynamic network that involves many business stakeholders. Integrating SCOR with the BPCM meta-model for the business process development process will facilitate knowledge sharing and communication among the various parties involved in the processes. As illustrated in Figure 1, we have incorporated process best practices, process levels from SCOR into the BPCM meta-model. The BPCM meta-model can also be transformed to OWL-based ontology. The ontology is built by defining classes, subclasses, properties, and instances which present the elements in BPCM meta-model. The BPCM ontology classes in the class browser is shown in Figure 2. The Ontologies is developed using Protégé software. Protégé is a free open-source software tool that was developed at Stanford University for building ontologies. Since the BPCM meta-model is centered with the class process, all other constructs are constructed relatively to process. The key role of the created ontology here is to form a repository to store various BPCM models. In this way, the existing BPCM models in an ontology repository may become reference models for various purposes. In addition, the ontology can also be seen as a reusable knowledge base for sharing and retrieving purposes in the future development. For instance, the class business domain can be used as a key for the querying purpose. Relevant information from similar areas can be retrieved by querying keywords of specific business domain.
Figure 1. BPCM Meta Model
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling
75
Figure 2. BPCM Ontology Classes
4. Relation Between SCOR and Process in BPCM Meta-model SCOR is a process reference model designed for effective communications among supply chain partners. SCOR integrates concepts of business processes, benchmarking, and best practices into a cross-functional framework. From business process reengineering perspective, the SCOR model builds a hierarchy of supply chain processes, which can be divided into three levels of details [3]: process type, process category, and process element. The process element level provides and documents enough details of process specifications, consisting of input and output parameters, process performance metrics, and best practices. Consequently, these detailed specifications can convey a better understanding of the relevant processes in BPCM which fits with the purpose of including BPCM model in the process support systems development lifecycle. The SCOR model does not follow any of the standardized or well structured business process modeling techniques such as BPMN or UML activity diagram. In contrast, the SCOR model provides the capability for business stakeholders to extract the existing supply chain knowledge, such as resources required for a specific process. In addition, the SCOR model also provides a mechanism for various users to reuse and share concepts and knowledge in a supply chain process. Having the SCOR model integrated with the BPCM meta-model for business process support systems development will result in a reusable, easy to integrate knowledge base. The SCOR model can be represented as a hierarchy of supply chain processes as depicted in the upper layer in Figure 3, where the level 1 and level 2 are for
76
S. Gao and J. Krogstie
representing more generic issues, such as planning and making, and the level 3 is for representing specific processes. Since the SCOR model is based on business process reengineering, this makes SCOR a process centric model. The processes in the SCOR model are the processes that are found in any supply chain. Concerning the relation between SCOR and the element process in the BPCM meta-model, each process element in the level 3 of the SCOR model can map to one process in the BPCM model as presented in Figure 3. This mapping aims to transform the detailed process element information in level 3 of the SCOR model to relevant elements in the BPCM meta-model. In addition, a process in a BPCM model may consist of several sub processes. The process elements information defined in the level 3 of the SCOR model might not be practical in terms of explicitly usefulness and utilization with respect to technical process models construction. However, having this information in place forms a good reusable knowledge base which facilitates communications between business stakeholders and model developers. Furthermore, the SCOR model makes sure that the relevant process elements in the level 3 from the organizational point of view are appropriately placed in the BPCM model in terms of various processes.
Figure 3. Relation between SCOR and Process in BPCM meta-model
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling
77
5. Mapping from BPCM Meta-model to BPMN Meta-model In this section, we illustrate the relation between the elements in the BPCM metamodel and the operational level process model in a combined framework [8] for development of business process support systems. In this combined framework, we consider a relatively informal model, more specifically BPCM here, which can ease the communication and cooperation between business stakeholders and technical model developers, as a starting point for developing a business process support system. In [12], they also argued that it is often beneficial to start a modeling-based project with an informal model and then develop the visual models. And then the BPCM models will be derived and developed into visual process models and executable models. Lastly, those models can be used as inputs for deriving a candidate IT system. The combined framework covering coarse grained business process characterizing modelling, and goal modelling and process modelling provides several benefits. It supports users to view the system from different perspectives. It also provides a mechanism for mapping of correspondences between meta-models of different models. Since BPMN has relatively higher expressiveness and ability to map directly to executable process languages such as business process execution language (BPEL) [10] and XPDL [6] compared to other process modeling notations, we select BPMN as the candidate notation for the operational level process model in the combined framework. Based on the BPCM meta-model proposed in section 3 and the BPMN 1.0 meta-model proposed by WSPER Group1, which is a class diagram that shows the elements of the BPMN language and their relationships, we analyze the mapping between those two models by considering Curtis framework on process modelling approach [4] which is based on four basic aspects: functional aspect, behavioral (control) aspect, organizational aspect, and informational aspect. BPCM: actor maps to BPMN: pool or lane, which covers organizational aspect. Likewise, BPCM: resource map to BPMN: data objects, which represents informational aspect. Concerning functional aspect, BPMN: task can be derived from BPCM: resource and actor in terms of complementary requirement table approach defined in [8]. The aspect which is least covered by the BPCM meta-model is the behaviroal (control) perspective for enacting business processes. The input and output parameters of the process element in the level 3 of the SCOR model may have implicitly effort on determining the order of activities and control flows. Refined BPCM meta-model with some extra SCOR properties and entities may help resolve this issue, which will result in better mappings between two metamodels. Further, we find that the traceability of the BPCM model to the BPMN model is improved in terms of the identified overlaps between two meta-models.
1
The BPMN meta-model is available at: http://www.ebpml.org/wsper/wsper/bpmn1.0.jpg
78
S. Gao and J. Krogstie
6. Conclusion In this paper, we describe a BPCM meta-model, which provides a foundation for building business process support systems. And the BPCM ontology classes on the type level are built. In addition, the relation between the SCOR model and the class process in the BPCM meta-model is addressed. Furthermore, the mapping from the BPCM meta-model to BPMN meta-model is depicted. However, it must be admitted that the usage and evaluation of the BPCM meta-model in the combined framework is currently quite limited since we have not tested it in some case studies. Future research will apply the BPCM meta-model and the combined framework in connection to supporting a loosely organized conference series.
7. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13] [14] [15]
Aalst, W.v.d.: Formalization and Verification of Event-driven Process Chains. Information and Software Technology. 41 (10), 639-650 (1999) Ali, R., Dalpiaz, F. and Giorgini, P.: A Goal Modeling Framework for Selfcontextualizable Software (eds.). 29, 326-338. LNBIP, Springer (2009) Council, S.-c. SCOR Model 8.0 Quick Reference Guide, (2006) Curtis, B., Kellner, M.I. and Over, J.: Process modeling. Commun. ACM. 35 (9), 7590 (1992) Dey, A.K., Abowd, G.D. and Salber, D.: A conceptual framework and a toolkit for supporting the rapid prototyping of context-aware applications. Human-Computer Interaction. 16 (2), 97-166 (2001) Fischer, L.: workflow handbook 2005. Workflow Management Coalition (WfMC) (2005) Fowler, M.: UML Distilled: A Brief Guide to the Standard Object Modeling Language. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (2003) Gao, S. and Krogstie, J.: A Combined Framework for Development of Business Process Support Systems. (eds.) The Practice of Enterprise Modeling. 39, 115-129. LNBIP, Springer (2009) Gao, S. and Krogstie, J.: Facilitating Business Process Development via a Process Characterizing Model. In: International Symposium on Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling 2008. IEEE CS (2008) Havey, M.: Essential Business Process Modeling. O'Reilly Media, CA (2005) Hruby, P.: Model-Driven Design Using Business Patterns. Springer-Verlag New York (2006) Maiden, N.A.M., Jones, S.V., Manning, S., et al.: Model-Driven Requirements Engineering: Synchronising Models in an Air Traffic Management Case Study. In: Persson, A. and Stirna, J. (eds.) CAISE 2004. LNCS vol. 3084, pp. 368-383. Springer, Heidelberg (2004) McCarthy, W.E.: The REA accounting model: a generalized framework for accounting systems in a shared data environment. 57, 554-578 (1982) Regev, G. and Wegmann, A. Defining Early IT System Requirements with Regulation Principles: The Lightswitch Approach Proceedings of the Requirements Engineering Conference, 12th IEEE International, IEEE Computer Society, (2004) Salifu, M., Yu, Y. and Nuseibeh, B.: Specifying Monitoring and Switching Problems in Context. In: RE 2007. IEEE CS Press (2007)
A Meta-model for a Language for Business Process Characterizing Modelling
79
[16] Siau, K., Lim, E.-P. and Shen, Z.: Mobile Commerce – Promises, Challenges, and. Research Agenda. Journal of Database Management. 12 (3), 4-13 (2001) [17] White, S.: Business Process Modeling Notation Version 1.0. Business Process Modeling Initiative (BPMI.org) (2004) [18] White, S.A. Introduction to BPMN, (2005) [19] Yu, E.: Modelling strategic relationships for process reengineering. PHD Thesis, University of Toronto (1996)
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using Pi-OCL Johan Ullberg1, Ulrik Franke1, Markus Buschle1 and Pontus Johnson1 1
Industrial Information and Control Systems, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Osquldas v. 12, SE-10044 Stockholm, Sweden
Abstract. Decision-making on enterprise-wide information system issues can be furthered by the use of models as advocated by the discipline of enterprise architecture. In order to provide decision-making support, enterprise architecture models should be amenable to analyses. This paper presents a software tool, currently under development, for interoperability analysis of enterprise architecture models. In particular, the ability to query models for structural information is the main focus of the paper. Both the tool architecture and its usage is described and exemplified. Keywords: Enterprise Architecture, Probabilistic Relational Models, Software tool, Interoperability
1. Introduction During the last decade, enterprise architecture has grown into an established approach for holistic management of information systems in an organization. Enterprise architecture is model-based, in the sense that diagrammatic descriptions of the systems and their environment constitute the core of the approach. A number of enterprise architecture initiatives have been proposed, such as The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF) [1], Enterprise Architecture Planning (EAP) [2], the Zachman Framework [3], and military architectural frameworks such as DoDAF [4] and NAF [5]. What constitutes a “good” enterprise architecture model has thus far not been clearly defined. The reason is that the “goodness” of a model is not an inherent property, but contingent on the purpose the model is intended to fill, i.e. what kind of analyses it will be subjected to. For instance, if one seeks to employ an enterprise architecture model for evaluating the performance of an information system, the information required from the model differs radically from the case when the model is used to evaluate system interoperability.
82
J. Ullberg, U. Franke, M. Buschle and P. Johnson
Enterprise architecture analysis is the application of property assessment criteria on enterprise architecture models. For instance, one investigated property might be the information security of a system and a criterion for assessment of this property might be “If the architectural model of the enterprise features a communication link with high availability, then this yields a higher level of interoperability than if the availability is low.” Criteria and properties such as these constitute the theory of the analysis and may be extracted from academic literature or from empirical measurements. This theory can be described using probabilistic relational models (PRMs) [6] which will be further detailed in section 1.3 Many interoperability concerns are related not only to various attributes of the architecture model but rather to the structure of the model, e.g. that two communicating actors need to share a language for their communication. With the actors and languages being entities in the metamodel, this property corresponds to ensuring that particular relationships exist in the architecture model instance. This paper presents a software tool under development for the analysis of enterprise architecture models. This tool extends previous versions of the tool [7][8] and the main contribution of this article is to illustrate how to query the architecture models for structural information such as the language compatibility as described above. This extension is based on the Object Constraint Language (OCL) [9] and is further detailed in section 1.3. The enterprise architecture frameworks described above generally suffer from the lack of methods for evaluating the architectures [10]. A number of enterprise architecture software tools are available on the market, including System Architect [11] and Aris [12]. Although some of these provide possibilities to sum costs or propagate the strategic value of a set of modeled objects, none have significant capabilities for system quality analysis in the sense of ISO-9126 [13], i.e. analysis of non-functional qualities such as reliability, maintainability, etc. However, various analysis methods and tools do exist within the software architecture community, including the Architecture Tradeoff Analysis Method (ATAM) [14] and Abd-Allah and Gacek [15]. In particular, various approaches such as LISI [16] and i-Score [17] have been suggested for assessing interoperability. However, these are generally not suitable in the enterprise architecture domain. Assessment Scoping
Evidence Collection Model Builder Function
Analysis Structural Analysis Function
provid ed by
Provid ed by 1..*
Provides 1 System
Administrat ed by 0..*
Administr ates 1
0 . . *
0.7 0.2 0.1 <Source id="Erik Johansson"/> <source id="Pontus Johnson"/>
Error locate with
System administrator
MTTF
Responsetime
MTTR
Repairtime
PRM
used by
Customer S upport : Funct ion
Fault Management : Function
provid ed by
Availiability
Availability
Uses 0 . . *
System Availiability
Calculation Function
Evidence.Interview.Juliet M e d i u m
provides administ r ated by
provides CRM Syst em : Syst em
Maintenance system : System
Availability
Availability
Reliability
Reliability
administr ates with
administrat es
Juliet : System administrat or Respons iveness Evidence. Document.Log H i g h
administ r ated by
Evidence. Document. M Log e d i u m
administrat es
Evidence.Observation. Juliet H i g h
Experience
Joseph : System adminis trator Responsiveness
Evidence.Observat ion.Joseph H i g h
Ex perience
Evidence.Interview.Juliet H i g h
E videnc e.I nterview.Joseph H i g h
Scenarios
Evidence
Instantiated PRM
Fig. 1. The process of enterprise architecture analysis with three main activities: (i) setting the goal, (ii) collecting evidence and (iii) performing the analysis
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using Pi-OCL
83
2. Process of Enterprise Architecture Analysis Enterprise architecture models have several purposes. Kurpjuweit and Winter [18] identify three distinct modeling purposes with regard to information systems, viz. (i) documentation and communication, (ii) analysis and explanation and (iii) design. The present article focuses on the analysis and explanation since this is necessary to make rational decisions about information systems. An analysiscentric process of enterprise architecture is illustrated in Fig. 1 above. In the first step, assessment scoping, the problem is described in terms of one or a set of potential future scenarios of the enterprise and in terms of the assessment criteria (the PRM in the figure) to be used for scenario evaluation. In the second step, the scenarios are detailed by a process of evidence collection, resulting in a model (instantiated PRMs, in the figure) for each scenario. In the final step, analysis, quantitative values of the models’ quality attributes are calculated, and the results are then visualized in the form of enterprise architecture diagrams. More concretely, assume that a decision maker in an electric utility is contemplating the changes related to the measurement of customer electricity consumption. The introduction of automatic meter reading would improve the quality of the billing process and allow the customers to get detailed information about their consumption. The question for the decision maker is whether this change is feasible or not. As mentioned, in the assessment scoping step, the decision maker identifies the available decision alternatives, i.e. the enterprise information system scenarios. Also in this step, the decision maker needs to decide on how to determine how this scenario should be evaluated, i.e. the assessment criteria, or the goal of the assessment. Oftentimes, several quality attributes are desirable, but we simplify the problem to the assessment of interoperability. During the next step, to identify the best alternative, the scenarios need to be detailed to facilitate an analysis of them. Much information about the involved systems and their organizational context may be required for a good understanding of their future interoperability. For instance, it is reasonable to believe that a reliable medium for passing messages would increase the probability that communication is successful. The availability of the message passing system is thus one factor that can affect the interoperability and should therefore be recorded in the scenario model. The decision maker needs to understand what information to gather, and also ensure that this information is indeed collected and modeled. When the decision alternatives are detailed, they can be analyzed with respect to the desirable property or properties. The pros and cons of the scenarios then need to be traded against each other in order determine which alternative should be preferred.
3. An Enterprise Architecture Analysis Formalism A probabilistic relational model (PRM) [6] specifies a template for a probability distribution over an architecture model. The template describes the metamodel M for the architecture model, and the probabilistic dependencies between attributes of
84
J. Ullberg, U. Franke, M. Buschle and P. Johnson
the architecture objects. A PRM, together with an instantiated architecture model I of specific objects and relations, defines a probability distribution over the attributes of the objects. The probability distribution can be used to infer the values of unknown attributes. This inference can also take into account evidence on the state of observed attributes. A PRM Π specifies a probability distribution over all instantiations I of the metamodel M. As a Bayesian network [6] it consists of a qualitative dependency structure, and associated quantitative parameters. The qualitative dependency structure is defined by associating attributes A of class X (A.X) with a set of parents Pa(X.A), where each parent is an attribute, either from the same class or another class in the metamodel related to X through the relationships of the metamodel. For example, the attribute satisfied of the class Communication Need may have as parent CommunicationNeed.associatedTo.communicatesOver.isAvailable, meaning that the probability that a certain communication need is satisfied depends on the probability that an appropriate message passing system is available. Note that a parent of an attribute may reference a set of attributes rather than a single one. In these cases, we let X.A depend probabilistically on an aggregated property over those attributes constructed using operations such and AND, OR, MEAN etc. Considering the quantitative part of the PRM, given a set of parents for an attribute, we can define a local probability model by associating a conditional probability distribution with the attribute, P(X.A |Pa(X.A)). For instance, P(CommunicationNeed.satisfied=True|MessagePassingSystem.isAvailable=False) =10% specifies the probability that communication need is satsified, given the availability of the message passing system. 3.1. Pi-OCL PRMs do not, however, provide any means to query the models for structural information such “as given two actors with a need to communicate, do these actors have a common language (modeled as a separate object)?” The Object Constraint Language (OCL) is a formal language used to describe constraints on UML models. Writing these types of constraints in natural language would lead to ambiguities. In order to resolve this, OCL provides a means to specify such constraints in a formal language without the need for extensive mathematical knowledge. OCL expressions typically specify invariant conditions that must hold for the system being modeled or queries over objects described in a model. [9] This ability to query models would be of great benefit to interoperability analysis. OCL is, however, a side effect free language, so that the application of an OCL statement cannot change the content of the model. Furthermore it is deterministic and thus incapable of allowing uncertainty in the analysis. This section briefly describes how these two aspects of OCL are addressed by the extension to probabilistic imperative OCL or Pi-OCL for short. For a more comprehensive treatment see [19]. For the language to become imperative, i.e. to be able to change the state of the model, the introduction of an assignment operator is necessary. Turning OCL into a probabilistic language also requires redefinition of all operations in OCL, which is accomplished through the mapping of each operation to a Bayesian network and then combining these networks into larger
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using Pi-OCL
85
networks corresponding to a complete Pi-OCL statement. For the sake of the analysis it is also necessary to introduce an existence attribute E in all classes and relationships corresponding to the probability that the class or relationship exists. Each expression views the model from the perspective of a context object C. The probability that an instantiated object O and its attributes O.A exist are thus not only dependent of O.E but also the existence of the relationships from the context object C to O. This context dependent existence is a key factor in the definition of all other OCL operations. To provide an example of how the operations are defined the following is a description of the equality operator 2 : . Since the original OCL equality operator is defined using the deterministic type Boolean, this operation needs to be refined. The probability that a given object o1 equals some other object o2, o1=o2 is calculated as follows: …
. , 0
…
.
Where … . , … . is the joint probability that there is a link from the context object to each of the objects o1 and o2 and id(object : OclAny) : Integer is a function that returns a unique identifier for each object. For a more comprehensive treatment of all of OCL statements in the Pi-OCL setting see [19]. The probability model of an attribute in a PRM expressed in terms of parent attributes can be replaced by Pi-OCL statements. Such statements allow not only attributes to constitute the parents of an attribute but also various aspects pertaining to the structure of the model. A PRM coupled with Pi-OCL statements thus constitutes a formal machinery for calculating the probabilities of various architecture instantiations. This allows us to infer the probability that a certain attribute assumes a specific value, given some (possibly incomplete) evidence of the rest of the architecture instantiation.
4. Design of the Tool Here a software tool supporting the enterprise architecture analysis process is outlined. The structural design of the tool is based upon the three basic processes illustrated in Fig. 1. Relating to the previous section, the first process step concerns the identification of the decision alternatives and the goals (assessment criteria). An example of a goal is to maximize the interoperability of an IT landscape. Goals are codified in a PRM, which also represents how various attributes and the structure of the model affect the goals (through the probability model and Pi-OCL statements). For instance, the PRM might state that the availability of the message passing system will affect the interoperability of the scenario. The Scenarios are not detailed in this step, but only given a name. In the second process step, the scenarios are elaborated. An example of a scenario might be to choose vendor X for the automatic meter reading system. In order to assess whether this is a better scenario than the one based on vendor Y,
86
J. Ullberg, U. Franke, M. Buschle and P. Johnson
more information is required. For instance we might need to detail the communication mediums employed by the respective vendors. Collected information on matters like these is called Evidence, and the process of evidence collection is supported by the tool. From the evidence, the Model Builder Function creates an instantiated PRM, which is a comprehensive enterprise architecture scenario model. The model thus typically contains instantiations of entities such as actor, message passing system, language, etc. Many times, the collected evidence will not be sufficient to allow full certainty of the values of entity attributes (for instance the attribute availability of the entity message passing system). They are therefore defined as random variables, allowing the representation of uncertainty. Recall that an important purpose of enterprise architecture models is to answer relevant questions, such as whether the interoperability of scenario A is higher than in scenario B. Oftentimes, it is not possible to directly collect information about properties such as interoperability, but it is possible to collect evidence pointing in a certain direction (e.g. information on the availability of the message passing system) and create models in which the structure of the model can be used for such evidence. Based on the created architecture model the structural analysis function use the Pi-OCL statements defined in the PRM to evaluate various structural concepts of the architecture. This is done by mapping the statements to Bayesian networks, evaluating these networks and writing the result back to attributes of the architecture model. Employing Bayesian theory once again, the Calculation Function calculates the values of those attributes that could not be credibly determined directly. The tool employs the collected evidence, the result of the structural analysis as well as the causal relationships specified in the PRM as input to these calculations. Central artifacts in enterprise architecture frameworks and tools are graphical models. The instantiated PRMs containing the enterprise architecture scenarios is therefore employed for displaying the results and the tool allows various views of the models. 4.1. Architecture of the Tool The tool is implemented in Java and uses a Model-View-Controller architecture, thus having these three main parts, illustrated in Fig. 2. The data model for PRMs and instantiated PRMs is specified in XSD files. The data binding tool Castor [20] allows simple marshalling and unmarshalling of XML models to and from java objects (the Model). The model elements are contained by the Widgets of the Net-Beans Visual Library that also update the view when the model changes. Model operations are controlled by a number of internal tools. This essentially corresponds to the functions of the design outlined above and a set of supporting tools. These internal tools, acting as controllers, provide uniform access to their functionality as they are all implemented in a common way, using the singleton pattern. One internal tool of particular interest here is the Pi-OCL evaluation tool that, based on the structure of the model, can perform various assessments of the
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using Pi-OCL
87
architecture. At the core of the tool is a Pi-OCL interpreter created using SableCC [21]. SableCC create an abstract syntax tree representation of Pi-OCL statements based on the grammar and provides a skeleton for traversal of the syntax tree using the visitor pattern. This skeleton is then refined to evaluate the result of the Pi-OCL statements. As this analysis is probabilistic each of the nodes in the abstract syntax tree are evaluated using Bayesian networks by employing the Smile library [22] for calculations. The results are then written back to attributes of the model. The view is implemented as a part of the JApplication framework. The view is in charge of handling all user interactions that are not concerned with the drag-anddrop modeling features of the scene. Several methods handle button and menu actions. Also, loading and saving tools are called by the view. Model
Controller
XSD PRM
Java PRM
XSD iPRM
Java iPRM
View
Fig. 2. High level architecture of the tool, illustrating the main components. "iPRM" is shorthand notation for instantiated PRM
5. Employing the Tool for Interoperability Analysis In this section a short example of the employment of the tool will be outlined. Interoperability is defined by IEEE as the ability of two or more systems or components to exchange information and use the information that has been exchanged [23]. This can be seen as a communication need and the interoperability analysis would correspond to ensuring that this need is satisfied. Consider the following metamodel for interoperability analysis where two or more Actors share a Communication Need. The actors communicate over a message passing system, e.g. the internet and encode the messages sent over the message passing system in a format, the language. On such a metamodel and interoperability definition the following very simple theory of interoperability can be expressed: 1) for interoperation to take place there need to be a path for message exchange between the actors of a communication need. 2) the actors must share at least one language for expressing their communication and finally 3) the message passing system
88
J. Ullberg, U. Franke, M. Buschle and P. Johnson
Fig. 3. A sample PRM for interoperability analysis detailing the important entities and relationships needed for the analysis
these actors use must be available This theory can be expressed as a PRM using the tool, cf. Fig. 3 where the abovementioned entities are modeled. The Communication Need class contains three attributes, the satisfied attribute corresponding to the goal of the analysis and two attributes corresponding to statement 1 and 2 of the theory. Since the third statement was concerned with the availability of the message passing system this is also included as an attribute of the message passing system class. Turning to the probability model of the PRM the first two statements in the theory are based on the structure of the architecture and can be expressed using with the following Pi-OCL statements: Context: CommunicationNeed self.pathExist := self.associatedTo->forAll(a1 : Actor, a2 : Actor | a1 <> a2 implies a1.communicatesOver.communicatesOver-1 -> exists(a2)) self.LanguageMatch := self.associatedTo->forAll(a1 : Actor, a2 : Actor | a1 <> a2 implies a1.uses -> exists(l:Language | a2.uses->exists(l)) As can be seen from these statements the result of the Pi-OCL evaluation is assigned to two of the attributes of the class communication need. These attribute need to be aggregated and combined with the third statement in the theory, that pertaining to the availability of the message passing system. This can be expressed in terms of parent attributes of CommunicationNeed.satisfied, the goal of the analysis. The parents of this attribute thus are: CommunicationNeed.pathExists, CommunicationNeed. languageMatch and CommunicationNeed.associatedTo. communicatesOver.isAvailable, see the solid arrows in the PRM of Fig. 2 . Turning to the quantitative part of the probability model the theory states that all these three criteria must be met for the communication need to be satisfied, an AND operation can thus be employed for aggregation.
A Tool for Interoperability Analysis of Enterprise Architecture Models using Pi-OCL
89
Fig. 4 depicts the concrete modeler where the architectural model is created based on the PRM. This means that specific instances of the abstract concepts are created to reflect the scenario at hand. By entering evidence on the states of the attributes and using the structural analysis function it is possible to use PRM inference rules to update the model to reflect the impact of the architecture and the evidence. The user can thus find updated probability distributions for all attributes in the model.
Fig. 4. An instatiated PRM for the modeled scenario
In this example we have a Communication Need get meter reading between the Actors Billing System and Meter Reading System. These are connected using a X.25 leased line of type message passing system. The meter reading system uses two languages, the common information model (CIM) and EDIEL whereas the billing system only use EDIEL Entering information regarding the availability, of the message passing system and running both the structural analysis and the inference will result in the prediction of a interoperability value for the modeled scenario.
6. Conclusions In this paper, a tool for analysis of enterprise architecture scenarios with a particular focus on interoperability assessments is outlined. The tool, currently under development, allows specification of the assessment theory in terms of a metamodel and a probability model encoded as a PRM with Pi-OCL statements. The Pi-OCL statements are used for structural analysis of the architecture. Based on the metamodel it is possible to model the architecture scenarios and using the theory assesses the interoperability of the scenario. Information system decision making is supported by allowing quantitative comparisons of the qualities, such as interoperability, of possible future scenarios of the enterprise information system and its context.
90
J. Ullberg, U. Franke, M. Buschle and P. Johnson
7. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
The Open Group. The Open Group Architecture Framework, Version 8, 2005 Spewak, S.H., Hill. S.C., Enterprise Architecture Planning. Developing a Blueprint for Data, Applications and Technology, John Wiley and Sons, 1992 Zachman, J., A framework for information systems architecture, IBM Systems Journal, 26(3), 1987 DoD Architecture Framework Working Group, “DoD Architecture Framework” Version 1.0, 2003 NAF, “NATO C3 Technical Architecture”, Volume 1-5, Version 7.0, Allied Data Publication 34, 2005 L. Getoor, N. Friedman, D. Koller, A. Pfeffer, and B. Taskar. Probabilistic relational models. MIT Press, 2007. Johnson, P., Johansson, E., Sommestad, T. Ullberg, J., A Tool for Enterprise Architecture Analysis, Proceedings of the 11th IEEE International Enterprise Computing Conference (EDOC 2007), 2007 Ekstedt, M. et al. A Tool for Enterprise Architecture Analysis of Maintainability, Proc. 13th European Conference on Software Maintenance and Reengineering, 2009 Object Management Group Object Constraint Language specification, version 2.0 formal/06-05-01, 2006 Chen, D. et al., Architecture for enterprise integration and interoperability: Past, present and future, Comput Industry (ind), 2008 IBM, Rational System Architect, http://www-01.ibm.com/software/awdtools/ systemarchitect/, accessed: Dec 2009 Scheer, A.-W., Business Process Engineering: Reference Models for Industrial Enterprises, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag, 1994 International Organization for Standardization/International Electrotechnical Commission, “International Standard ISO/IEC 9126-1: Software engineering – Product quality – Part 1: Quality model,” ISO/IEC, Tech. Rep., 2001. Clements, P., R. Kazman, M. Klein, “Evaluating Software Architectures: Methods and Case Studies”, Addison-Wesley, 2001 Gacek, C., “Detecting Architectural Mismatch During System Composition”, PhD. Thesis, University of Southern California, 1998 Kasunic, M., Anderson, W., “Measuring Systems Interoperability: Challenges and Opportunities” Technical Note, CMU/SEI-2004-TN-003, Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, 2004. Ford, T., Colombi, J., Graham, S., Jacques, D., “The Interoperability Score”, Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Conference on Systems Engineering Research, Hoboken, NJ, 2007 Kurpjuweit, S., Winter, R.: Viewpoint-based Meta Model Engineering. In Proceedings of Enterprise Modelling and Information Systems Architectures (EMISA 2007), Bonn, Gesellschaft für Informatik, Köllen, pp. 143-161, 2007 Franke U. et. al, π-OCL: A Language for Probabilistic Inference in Relational Models (2010) to be submitted ExoLab Group, The Castor Project, http://www.castor.org/ accessed Dec. 2009 Gagnon, É., SableCC, an Object-Oriented Compiler Framework, Master Thesis, McGill University Montreal, 1998 Decision Systems Laboratory of the University of Pittsburgh, SMILE, http://genie.sis.pitt.edu/ accessed Dec. 2009 IEEE, Standard Glossary of Software Engineering Terminology. Std 610.12-1990, The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, New York, 1990.
A UML-based System Integration Modeling Language for the Application System Design of Shipborne Combat System Fan Zhiqiang1, Gao Hui2, Shen Jufang1, Zhang Li1 1 2
Dept. of Computer Science and Technology, BeiHang University, Beijing, P.R.China Systems Engineering Research Institute, China State Shipbuilding Corporation, Beijing, P.R.China
Abstract. The Shipborne combat system (SCS) includes many application systems. The integration of application systems is necessary because they are distributed and need to interoperate with each other. For such integration, an integration model needs to be developed. Firstly, the integration framework of application systems of SCS is discussed, which involves three layers: data integration, function integration and workflow integration. Secondly, integration metamodel based on the framework is introduced. Data, application system, function, component, workflow and their relationships are explained in detail. Finally, a system integration modeling language for application system design (SIML4ASD) based on the metamodel is defined by extending UML using profile mechanism. SIML4ASD is easy to learn, use and understand for the system designers and can be used to describe integration models clearly and exactly in multi-view. Keywords: integration framework; integration metamodel; SIML4ASD; UML
1. Introduction The Shipborne Combat System (SCS) is a system of personnel, weapons and devices used to execute early-warning, tracking, communications, navigation, target identification, data processing, threaten assessment, and control various shipborne weapons against the enemy [1]. SCS includes hardware devices (e.g. computers and switch) and software systems (e.g. OS and database). As the software technology has become more and more mature, there are more and more application systems. These application systems are supporting the combat business, and play an important role in SCS. Application systems are distributed on different hardware devices and they work in collaboration to complete combat tasks. There is a need of interoperation among them. Therefore, the integration of application
92
F. Zhiqiang, G. Hui, S. Jufang and Z. Li
systems is very important in their design. Three characteristics of application systems should be considered: 1) there are large amount of data exchanges between application systems when they carry out a combat task collaboratively. 2) different application systems have different functions but some of them have several identical functions. Some times, the functions of system may be changed dynamically. Hence SCS is usually designed to consist of functional blocks and application system is the composition of those blocks. Functions are user-oriented and thus, do not fit to be used as system development guide. SCS is usually designed and developed using component-based technology. Functions are the composition of components. Therefore, for the system design and dynamic function change, the relationship between application system, function and component needs to be established; 3) in order to improve efficiency and achieve automation, part of or whole business processes are designed as workflow which is executed by application systems automatically. The actual activities of workflow are executed by components. Therefore, the relation of workflow and components needs to be established when designing a workflow. Besides that, the features of workflow in SCS should also be considered, e.g. some activities have time constraint and/or cannot be interrupted when being executed. Because of these three characteristics of SCS, application systems are usually integrated by three-layer (data layer, function layer and workflow layer) framework. Data, application system, function, component, workflow and the relationships between these layers need to be described clearly in integration model. However, existing modeling languages are not fully capable of describing the integration model. For example, IDEF can be used to describe system and function using IDEF0 [2], data using IDEF1X [3] and workflow using IDEF3 [4], but it cannot afford to describe the components. UML [5] can be used to describe workflow using activity diagram, data using class diagram and component using component diagram, but the consumption or production relationship between data and component cannot be established. Moreover, the features of SCS (e.g. time constraint) can not be reflected in the workflow model described using UML or IDEF. Thus a new system integration modeling language (SIML) for description of application system integration model and communication of designers is necessary.
2. Application System Integration: Framework and Layers Generally speaking, system integration can be divided into several layers. Deng [6] and Wang [7] proposed a three-layer integration framework of information system which consists of Network layer, Data Layer and Application Layer. Zhang [8] suggested a conceptual framework which consists of five layers, i.e. physical, data, application, business process/functionality and presentation. Edward and Jeffrey’s framework for business integration divided integration into two layer: system and organizational layer, and subdivided system integration into data, application and business process integration [9]. Giachetti gave a framework of enterprise information integration which involves network, data, application and process integration [10]. Drawing on these results, we propose a hierarchical integration
A UML-based System Integration Modeling
93
framework presented in Fig. 1 for the integration of application systems based on the three features mentioned in section I. Application System B
Workflow
Workflow Integration
Function
Function
Data
Data
Integration
Integration
Application System A
Fig. 1. A Integration Framework of Application Systems
Integration at Data Layer: the data layer lays a strong basis for the integration of application systems. Data integration virtually associates the data of different systems and provides the application system with data in a uniform format. Integration at Function Layer: the integration at this layer helps to understand the function of application system and the component realizing specific function. The function integration mainly aims at addressing the composition of components. Integration at Workflow Layer: workflow is the computerised facilitation or automation of a business process, in whole or part [11]. The integration of which asks for the cooperation of different application systems and their compliance with the workflow logic. The framework presents not only horizontal integration, but also vertical integration. Integration between data layer and function layer occurs when a component produces or consumes data. Integration between function layer and workflow layer happens when component executes activities of workflow.
3. Integration Metamodel of Application Systems The main elements involved in the integration framework are: data, application system, function, component and workflow. The conceptual model is showed in Fig. 2. Workflow consists of activities. Activity is executed by component with data consumption or production. Application system participating in the execution of workflow includes functions implemented by components. Based on the integration framework, detailed metamodel is introduced as follows. 3.1. Metamodel at Data Layer The main elements and relationship in the metamodel are descripted in Fig. 3. Data is composed by DataItem related with Type which can be generalized as ConstructedType, SimpleType and CollectionType. A SimpleType is a fixedlength type. CollectionType means a collecton of any type. ConstructedType refers to the type constructed by other types, and Data itself is a kind of ConstructedType.
94
F. Zhiqiang, G. Hui, S. Jufang and Z. Li
Data has zero or more DataInstance. The relationship between Data and DataInstance is Instantiation. The relationships of Data include Generatlization, Agregation and Composition with the same defination in UML [5]. DataDomain is the classification of Data. A Data can only be in one DataDomain.
Fig. 2. Conceputal Model of Application System Integration
3.2. Metamodel at Function Layer The model showed in Fig. 4 explains the relationships among Application System, Function, Component and Data. ApplicationSystem refers to the software system support combat business in SCS. Different ApplicationSystems may have serveral same Functions. Function is the decomposition of application system from users’ view. It cannot be used as system development guide, the application system is decomposed into components from the designers’ and developers’ view. Component only refers to single component instead of composed components since component composition is consider as Function in the metamodel. One Function can be implemented by one or more Component, and different Functions can be implemented by one Component. ComponentInstance and Interface related to component have the same symentics as in UML [5]. FunctionalConstraint and NonfunctionalConstraint are the text description of functional and nonfunctional requirements of AplicationSystem, Function or Component. The vertical integration relationship among data layer and function layer is reflected by the consumption or production relationship between Data and BasicElement which may be ApplicationSystem, Function or Component.
Fig. 3. Metamodel at Data Layer
Fig. 4. Metamodel at Function Layer
A UML-based System Integration Modeling
95
3.3. Metamodel at Workflow Layer The main elements of workflow in SCS are Activity, DataPool, ControlFlow, ObjectFlow and RealtimeConstraint as presented in Fig. 5a. Activity: ExecuteActivity is a action which is executed by only one component instance. The detailed SignActivity and LogicActivity are showed in Fig. 1.5c. AndSplitActivity splits a control flow into multiple concurrent control flows. OrSplitActivity splits a control flow into multiple control flows, and only one of them can be executed. AndJoinActivity is used to join multiple control flow as one control flow synchronously. OrJoinActivity joins multiple control flow as one control flow without synchronization. DataPool: Data in workflow is generalized as ApplicationData related to the business and ControlData used to make decision at OrSplitActivity. DataPool is the element storing and managing one or more kinds of application data instances. ControlFlow: ControlFlow connects two activities with zero or more kinds of control data and condition used for decision making at OrSplitActivity. ObjectFlow: ObjectFlow from DataPool to ExecutionActivity can be divided into two categories represented in Fig. 1.5b: ConsumeFlow and ReferenceFlow. ComsumeFlow means the objects stored in DataPool are comsumed. ReferenceFlow means the objects are just be used. RealtimeConstraint: In SCS, some activities, control flows and application data instances have time constraint represented by the RealtimeConstraint element. Li [12] has concluded six kinds of time constraints: delay constraint, flow delay, limited duration, deadline, time distance constraint and fixed-date. The delay constraint is suitable for the time constraint of workflow in SCS. Some activities and control flows can’t be interrupted which is represented by the Interrupt attribute. The SCondiction attribution of ExecutionActivity means the start condition of the activity. The vertical integration relationship of data layer and workflow layer is reflected by the relationships between Data and DataPool, ControlFlow and ObjectFlow. The relationships among Workflow and ApplicationSystem, ExecuteActivity and ComponentInstance reflect the integration relationship of function layer and workflow layer.
b. ObjectFlow, ControlFlow and Data
a. main elements of workflow
c. SignActivity and LogicActivity
Fig. 5. Metamodel at Workflow Layer
96
F. Zhiqiang, G. Hui, S. Jufang and Z. Li
4. UML Based System Integration Modeling Language For the description of integration model and the communication of designers, a modeling language is needed. In this section system integration modeling language for application system design (SIML4ASD) based on the metamodel is defined by extending UML2.0. 4.1. SIML4ASD SIML4ASD reuses part of elements of UML2.0 with the <<merge>> relationship, and then extends some elements of UML using profile mechanism. SIML4ASD divides elements into three packages which are data, function and workflow. Data Package: The elements in data package are ApplicationData, ControlData, DataInstance, DataDomain, Instantiation, Generalization, Composition, Aggregation and Class Diagram, where, the first three are the element extended from UML and the others are the elements of UML. Function Package: ApplicationSystem, Function, FunctionalConstraint, NonfunctionalConstraint, Component, ComponentInstance, Interface, Association, Realization, InterfaceRealization, Dependency, Component Diagram, UseCase Diagram, Component Diagram and Sequence Diagram are in function package, where, the first four are extended from UML, the others are the elements of UML. Association is connection from ApplicaitionSystem to Function. Realization is connection from Component to Function. InterfaceRealization and Dependency connect Component to required and provided Interface separately. Besides this, fucntion package imports data package, which means the elements in data package are included in fucntion package. Thus the Instantiation in data package can be used to connect Component to ComponentInstance. Workflow package: the elements in workflow package are Workflow, ExecutionActivity, DataPool, ObjectFlow, ReferenceFlow, ConsumeFlow, ControlFlow, ExceptionFlow, OrSplitActivity, OrJoinActivity, AndJoinActivity, AndSplitActivity, InitialActivity and FinalActivity. All of these are extended from UML. Workflow package imports the function package. The extended elements of SIML4ASD are listed in Table 1.1. The relationships among Application System, Function, Component, and Data are expressed by CDataType and PDataType attributes. The relationship between DataInstance and ObjectFlow/ControlFlow are expressed by the DataType attribute. These three attributes use “;” to split the different DataType. The relationship of ExecutionActivity and ComponentInstance are expressed by the ExeCmpt attribute recording the component name. The SCondtion attribute recording activity name is used to express the start condition of ExectutionActivity. Time constraint is expressed by the four attributes: minimum duration (Tmin), maximum duration (Tmax), actual duration (Trun) and time unit (Unit). 4.2. Multi-view Modeling of SIML4ASD Integration model involves many elements. It is hard to describe all elements in one view. Due to the difference of people’s concerns with integration model, it is
A UML-based System Integration Modeling
97
better to describe the model in multiple views. SIML4ASD has three views base on UML diagrams: data view, function view and workflow view. The Data and the relationship between Data can be described in data view using the class diagram. Function view has five sub-views. Application system view is used to describe the application systems and data exchange between them using component diagram. Application system function view is used to describe the function of each system using “use case” diagram. Component View can be used to describe a component and its interface using component diagram. The interaction of components can be expressed via component interaction view using sequence diagram. The function to component view is to describe the relationship of function and component, i.e. which function is implemented by which components. Workflow View is used to describe workflows by activity diagram. Table 1.1. Stereotype of SIML4ASD Modeling Concept / Stereotype / UML Element DataDomain / ASD_DD / Package ControlData / ASD_CD / Class DataInstance / ASD_DI / ClassInstance ApplicationSystem / ASD_AS / Component Function / ASD_F / UseCase Component / ASD_C / Component FunctionalConstraint / ASD_FC / Constaint NonfunctionalConstraint / ASD_NFC / Constaint Workflow / ASD_WF / Activity ExecutionActivity / ASD_EA / Action InitialActivity / ASD_IA / InitialNode FinalActivity / ASD_FA / ActivityFinalNode AndJoinActivity / ASD_AJA / JoinNode OrJoinActivity / ASD_OJA / MergeNode AndSplitActivity / ASD_ASA / ForkNode OrSplitActivity / ASD_OSA / DecisionNode ControlFlow / ASD_CF / ControlFlow ExceptionFlow / ASD_EF / ControlFlow DataPool / ASD_DP / DataStoreNode ObjectFlow / ASD_OF / ObjectFlow ReferenceFlow / ASD_OFR / ObjectFlow
Extended attributes
CDataType:string PDataType:string
Tmin:double Tmax:double Trun:double Unit:enum
DataType:string
ConsumeFlow / ASD_OFC / ObjectFlow ApplicationData / ASD_AD / Class ExecutionActivity / ASD_EA / Action ControlFlow / ASD_CF / ControlFlow
ExeCmpt:string SCondition:string DataType:string
98
F. Zhiqiang, G. Hui, S. Jufang and Z. Li
5. Related Work Since system integration involves many areas, there is no such language that is sufficient to describe all elements involved in system integration. Balasubramanian [13] and Shetty [14] , researcher of Institute for Software Integrated Systems of Vanderbilt University, provided SIML by composing two kind of Domain Specific Modeling Language respectively. The SIMLs provided by Balasubramanian and Shetty are used to describe the integration model of two kind of systems developed in different language and style. The integration of application systems involves three layers, i.e. data layer, function layer and workflow layer. The modeling languages studying data, function and workflow have made following progress. Data modeling: the metamodel is the core of a language. Currently, the wellknown data metamodel are CORBA [15], DDS [16], EXPRESS [17] and IDEF1X [3] data metamodel. CORBA supports fewer data types, especially the collection type. DDS provides richer data types that are closer to user. The UML profile for DDS is also released by OMG. The data types supported by EXPRESS are less than DDS. IDEF1X is a data modeling language used to develop semantic data model. DDS supports the most of data types among the four. It is the main reference of the metamodel at data layer. But the latter is more detailed than the former. Function modeling: the main function modeling methods are Functional Flow Block Diagram (FFBD) [18], Hierarchical Input Process Output (HIPO)[19], N2 Chart[20], Structured Analysis and Design Technique (SADT)[21], IDEF0[2] and UML[5]. Function modeling for the application system integration of SCS is aimed at describing application system, function, component and the relationships among them. These function modeling languages, unlike UML, cannot describe the components. But the relationship between functions and components are not defined in UML. Workflow modeling: there are mainly six workflow modeling methods: 1) Activity network diagram based modeling method [22]; 2) Petri Net based modeling method [23]; 3) State Diagram based modeling method [24]; 4) dialog model based modeling method [25]; 5) UML activity diagram based modeling method [5]; 6) IDEF3 based modeling method [4]. The methods based on Petri Net, UML activity diagram and IDEF are the most representative of the six methods above. The first is commonly used for workflow simulation and analysis due to Petri Net theory, but it’s hard to learn and understand. The latter two are used widely for workflow modeling because they are easy to learn and understand. But UML activity diagram is better than IDEF3 in expansibility and that activity diagrams are a recognized form of modeling real time systems [26]. Since model describing is the primary purpose of SIML4ASD, the method based on UML activity diagram is chosen. According to the survey above, the UML and IDEF are suitable for the integration modeling. Zhou [27] has used UML to describe the system integration model. Xiao [28] has used IDEF to describe the business integration model. Since the component needs to be described in integration model at function layer and IDEF does not support the requirement well, hence, the UML based system integration modeling language is defined for application system design of SCS.
A UML-based System Integration Modeling
99
6. Conclusion When designing application systems of SCS, the data exchange, function assignment and workflow must be described clearly. However, currently, there is no such modeling language to serve the purpose. Therefore, a research about the SIML for application system design of SCS is studied in this paper. There are three contributions of this paper: 1) an integration framework of application systems of SCS is proposed, which consists of data, function and workflow; 2) the integration metamodel, explaining the data, application system, function, component, workflow and their relationship for the first time, is introduced based on the framework; 3) a UML based SIML is defined, which is easy to learn, use and understand for the system designer. This work is meaningful for two reasons: 1) as the integration metamodel is defined and a UML based SIML4ASD is provided, system designers can describe the integration model of application systems easily and clearly in multi-view, which is helpful for communication of designers; 2) systems are usually evaluated after their design, and automatic evaluation methods are more and more mature in recent years. A clear and unambiguous definition of integration metamodel and SIML4ASD is the basis of automatic system evaluation. This paper is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No.60773155 and the National Grand Fundamental Research 973 Program of China under Grant No.2007CB310803.
7. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]
Mei Jiao, “Development Features and Prospects of Shipborne Combat System at Home and Abroad”, Ship Command and Control System, vol. 5, July 1996, pp. 817.(in chinese) Draft Federal Information Processing Standards Publication 183. INTEGRATION DEFINITION FOR FUNCTION MODELING (IDEF0). 1993 itl.nist.gov. Integration Definition for Information Modeling (IDEFIX). 21 Dec 1993. www.itl.nist.gov/fipspubs/idef1x.doc Richard J. Mayer et al. Information Integration for Concurrent Engineering (IICE): IDEF3 Process Description Capture Method Report. Logistics Research Division, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH 45433 OMG. OMG Unified Modeling Language (OMG UML), Superstructure, V2.1.2. http://www.omg.org/docs/formal/07-11-02.pdf Deng Su, Zhang Wei-Ming, Huang Hong-bin, Information System Integration Technology, 2nd ed., Publishing House of Electronics Industry: Beijing, 2004. (in chinese) Wang Hui-Bin, Wang Jin-Yin, Information System Integration and Fusion Technology and Its Application, National Defense Industry Press: Beijing, 2006, pp.21-75. (in chinese) Zhang Xiao-Juan, “System Integration in the Contemporary Business Information Systems-Framework,Implementation and Case Study”, 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing, Dalian. 2008. pp:1-6
100
F. Zhiqiang, G. Hui, S. Jufang and Z. Li
[9]
Edward A. Stohr, Jeffrey V. Nickerson, Enterprise Integration: Methods and Direction. Oxford University Press: New York, 2003, pp:227-251 Giachetti R.E., A Framework to Review the Information Integration of the Enterprise, International Journal of Production Research, 2004, Vol. 42, Iss. 6, pp.1147-1166. Workflow Management Coalition,The Workflow Reference Model-TC00-1003 v1.1. 1995. Li Hui-fang, Fan Yu-shun. "Overview on Managing Time in Workflow Systems", Journal of Software, vol 13(8), 2002, pp.1552-1558 (in chinese) Balasubramanian Krishnakumar, Schmidt Douglas C, Molnar Zoltan, Ledeczi Akos. Component-based System Integration via (Meta)Model Composi-tion. 14th Annual IEEE International Conference and Workshops on the Engineering of ComputerBased Systems, Tucson, AZ . 2007. pp: 93-102 Shetty S, Nordstrom S, Ahuja S, Di Yao, Bapty T, Neema S. Systems Integration of Large Scale Autonomic Systems using Multiple Domain Specific Modeling Languages. 12th IEEE International Conference and Workshops on the Engineering of Computer-Based Systems, 2005. pp: 481-489 OMG. Common Object Request Broker Architecture - for embedded. http://www.omg.org/cgi-bin/doc?ptc/2006-05-01.pdf OMG. Data-Distribution Service for Real-Time Systems, V1.2. http://www.omg.org/cgi-bin/doc?formal/07-01-01.pdf ISO 10303-11:2004 Industrial automation systems and integration -- Product data representation and exchange -- Part 11: Description methods: The EXPRESS language reference manual Function model. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Function_modeling#cite_note-11 Sandia National Laboratories. Sandia Software Guidelines Volume 5 Tools, Techniques,and Methodologies. 1992 .http://www.prod.sandia.gov/cgibin/techlib/access-control.pl/1985/852348.pdf NASA. Techniques of Functional Analysis. In: NASA Systems Engineering Handbook June 1995. p:142. John Mylopoulos. Conceptual Modelling III. Structured Analysis and Design Technique (SADT). Retrieved 21 Sep 2008. SADIQ S,ORLOWSKAM.On correctness issues in conceptual modeling of workflows[A].Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Information Systems[C].Cork,Ireland:Cork Publishing Ltd,1997. W.M.P.van derAalst.TheApplication of Petri Nets to Workflow Management.The
[10] [11] [12] [13]
[14]
[15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
Journal of Circuits,Systems and Computers,1998,8(1):21~66. [24] Georgakopolous D,Hornick M,ShethA.An overview of workflow management:from process modeling to workflow automation infrastruc-ture[J].Distributed and Parallel Database,1995,3(2):119~152. [25] Leymann F,Altenhuber W.Managing business processes as an information resource[J].IBM Systems Journal,1994,33(2):326~348. [26] Chang E, Gautama E, Dillon T S. Extended activity diagrams for adaptive workflow modelling[C]// Fourth IEEE International Symposium on Object-Oriented Real-Time Distributed Computing. Magdeburg, 2001: 413-419. [27] Yonghua Zhou, Yuliu Chen, Huapu Lu. UML-based Systems Integration Modeling Technique for the Design and Development of Intelligent Trans-portation Management System. IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics. 2004. pp: 6061 - 6066 [28] Xiao Yan-Ling, Xu Fu-Yuan, Hu Wen-Bo. Business Process Reengineering Based on IDEF Methods. Proceedings of the 2004 IEEE International Conference on Information Reuse and Integration. 2004. pp: 265 – 270
Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems Focusing on Data Storage System Guillaume Vicien1, Yves Ducq1, Bruno Vallespir1 1
IMS UMR 5218 CNRS, Dept LAPS / GRAI Group, 351, cours de la Libération, 33405 Talence Cedex – France
Abstract. Nowadays, performance improvement in order to reach the economic, technical and social objectives has become essential for all enterprises whose want to stay competitive. For this reason, enterprises should set up an executive information system which will give them their performance’s level at every moment through different performance indicators. The developement of those systems is long and difficult and different ineroperability problems can occur especially during the design of the data storage system. Those interoperability problems disturb the system and the agregation of the different performance indicators.This article aims in a first part to propose a framework for the design and implementation of the data storage system. In a second, we analyse the different possible architecture and make their comparison. Keywords: executive information system, performance indicators, interoperability
1. Introduction Ever since Jonhson and Kaplan published in 1987 their seminal book entitled “Relevant Lost – The rise and fall of management accounting” [1], performance measurement gained increasing popularity both in practice in the enterprises and in research [2]. Today, the enterprises have understood that they need performance measurement and performance management practices in order to be competitive and increase their development. In fact, managers are continually measuring or requesting measures and management could hardly exist nowadays without measurement [3]. To measure their performance, enterprises have to define a performance indicators system that allows to verify the accomplishment of organizational objectives and to help the managers to take the best decisions. To define this system, many methodologies have been developped since many years like the Balanced Score Card [4], Prism method [5] or ECOGRAI [6].
102
G. Vicien, Y. Ducq, B. Vallespir
When all the performance indicators are defined, the enterprise has to set up an executive information system that will be able to restore the indicators on different forms (dash boards, OLAP analysis, data mining...). Executive information system uses different computing tools like ETL (Extract, Transform and Load) and Data warehouse to aggregate, store and restore the different performance indicators. The first applications of computing tools to help managers to take decisions appear at the beginning of the 90’s and the development of data warehousing and OLAP technologies date of the middle of the 90’s [7, 8]. Nowadays, the Business Intelligence market that includes all the different computing tools is very developed and still developing very quickly. This article aims to show the importance in the choice of the structure and the modelling use for the data storage system of an executive information system in order to aggregate the different performance indicators without interoperability problems. This paper is composed of two parts. The first one begins with the presentation of executive information systems in order to introduce the different interoperability problems that can be found in those systems. The second one focuses on the data storage process proposing a framework for their design and comparing the different possible architectures.
2. Executive Information Systems Nowadays, executive information systems are common place in all sectors of industry and commerce and in all sized enterprises. Indeed, we observe for few years an increasing interest of the small and medium sized enterprises for executive information systems due to the price decrease of computing applications. However, we do not found methodology for the implementation of performance indicators system within executive information systems and we notice several failures in enterprises [9, 10]. 2.1. Critical Success Factors of Executive Information Systems Executive information system development and implementation, which usually tales around 6 and 12 months [11] is a risky task due to the fact that many elements take part in this process and are closely llinked to one another. The riks that something goes wrong are very high [12]. A study realized by Poon [13] have showed that failures occure in 70% of cases and could lead to the reliquishment of the project. Furthermore, human ressources are highly involved in this kind of project and they will be very important in its success. Indeed, they will have many responsibilities including selecting hardware and software, identifying information requirements, locating and accessing needed information, designing screens ans providing training [14]. It exists in the literature many articles that deal with executive information system success factors and the works of Salmeron [11] have been selected. These research work propose to established three categories to study the success keys: human
Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems
103
resources, technical and information resources and system operation. The study results are proposed in the table 1 below. Table 1. Keys to EIS success [11] Human resources
User’s interest 96.55 %
Competent and balanced EIS staff 65.52%
Executive sponsor’s support 62.07%
Technical and Information resources
Right information needs 96.55%
Suitable Soft/Hard 68.96%
Others 10.34%
System operation
Flexible and sensitive system 79.31%
Speedy development of a prototype 48.28%
Others 16%
Others 6.9%
Regarding this table we can conclude that there are three main keys success for executive information system. The first one, “user’s interest” requires enterprises to involve their employees from the beginning of the system design. The second one, “right information needs” is obvious if an EIS intends to satisfy the manager’s needs of information. The third one, “flexible and sensitive system” is inherent to the concept of executive information system and the final users would like to use a complexe, integrated and interoperable system that will evolve easily with their new expectations. 2.2. Executive Information System Process and Architecture Futher to the different keys success, we are going to see more in details the process and the architecture of executive information systems. 2.2.1 Process The executive information system is composed of three sub-processes. The first process “Data recovery” consits in the recovery of the operational data stored in the different operational data sources of the enterprise. This process is also composed of three sub-processes, extraction, transformation and loading. Extraction means the process that extracts data from enterprise operational data sources using adapters. Those adapters consult metadata to determine which data to extract, how and when. Transformation is the process which transforms the extracted data into a consistent format applying rules defined in the metadata repository. This process is also responsible for data validation and data accuracy. The process of load is responsible for loading the transformed data into data warehouse using target data adapters. Those adapters also consult metadata [18]. The second process “Indicators aggregation and storage” consists in the data storage and their processings in order to aggregate the different performance indicators. The data storage will also allow the historical management of the indicators and facilitate the information access.
104
G. Vicien, Y. Ducq, B. Vallespir
Finally, the third process “indicators restitution” allows final users to recover performance indicators on different forms. The more common widespread restitution forms are dashboards, OLAP analysis and datamining. Those restitution forms have to be developed according the final users expectations. 2.2.2 Architecture The executive information system process is supported by a specfic architecture composed of different computing applications, figure 1.
Fig 1. Executive information system architecture
This architecture is composed of three main parts according to the executive information system process. The first one “recovery” is composed of the different operational data stores and the ETL (Extract, Transform and Load) which will operate the data transfer until the data warehouse. The “storage” is composed of different elements which allow the storage of the data and the different performance indicators. We will see later in the article that the storage system could be different according to the enterprise expectations and those different architectures will be analysed. The “restitution” architecture is developed according to the final users expectations. Indeed, many computing tools are on the market and are used to propose different restitution modes. 2.3. Interoperability in Executive Information Systems Due to complex architecture of executive information systems, different interoperability problems could occur. We propose the enterprise interoperability framework developped by Chen [16] and proposed in figure 2., to caracterise the interoperability problems considered in these research works.
Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems
105
Fig 2. Enterprise interoperability framework
The research works presented in this paper are focused on the data barrier which is the most important to solve in the implementation of the executive information system (grey part). We have identified four major interoperability problems. For each problem, we will detect which solution has to be set up in order to solve this problem and position it in the framework. Interoperability problem 1: Data transfer between operational data sources and data warehouse. Enterprises use nowadays various operational computing tools and the ETL has to be able to transfer data between those different applications. ETL that we found on the market own different adapters that allow data transfer. If a specific adapter does not exist, it is possible to develop it but it is preferable for the enterprise to choose it ETL according to its operational data sources in order to avoid the development. We found the same kind of problem between ETL and data warehouse. Based on the previous description, this interoperability problem is then positioned in the framework as Data, C, Federated. Interoperability problem 2: When the data recovery process in launched, the ETL has to know which data does it have to recover? Where? When? Which processings have to be done? And Where the data has to be store? During recovery process design, it is necessary to specify all information about the operations which have to be realized on the data. To do so, it is necessary to develop a metadata repository where all those information will be stored. Furthermore, the setting of a metadata repository makes the system evolution easier because the possible evolutions will be recording directly in the metadata repository. This interoperability problem is positioned in the framework as Data, Conceptual, Unified. Interoperability problem 3: Data that have to be stored in the data warehouse come from different and heterogeneous operational data sources and semantic interoperability problems will certainly appear in the data warehouse. So it is necessary to define and adopt a common semantic for all the data that have to be stored in the data warehouse. This standardization of the data will be supported by a metadata repository. The interoperability problem is positioned in the framework as Data, Conceptual, Unified.
106
G. Vicien, Y. Ducq, B. Vallespir
Interoperability problem 4: the setting up of OLAP analysis forces the designer to use a particular modelling. Indeed, OLAP analysis require a snow flake modelling of the data. The data will be stored in two different kinds of tables: fact and dimension. The interoperability problem is classified in the framework as Data, Conceptual, Unified. In conclusion, we realize that most of interoperability problems that occur in executive information system can be solved using a unified approach. This result is consistent allowing that the goal of an executive information system is to centralize data extracted from various and heterogeneous data sources. Furthermore, all those interoperability problems could be identified and solved during the process design in order to avoid system failure.
3. Storage System In the previous section are presented interoperability problems in executive information system and in this section we are going to present our contribution on the data storage system. This section is composed of three parts. In a first time, we propose a framework for the setting up of the storage system. In a second part, we choose the architecture of the storage system which allows to avoid interoperability problems. Finally, in the third part, we propose a formalism in order to model the different elements of the architecture. 3.1. A Five Stage Framework It exits in the literature many articles that proposed a framework for the building of storage system [17, 18]. We propose to use a five stages framework. 3.1.1 Stage 1 – Business requirements The first stage consists in the recovery of the different requirements of the system final users. This part is one for the most important as mentionned in section 2.1. This step is generally realized thanks to interviews of the system final users and all information could be stored in specification sheet. It is necessary to make a specification sheet for each performance indicator. It allows to centralize information and find it easily. 3.1.2 Data sourcing When all information are recovered, it is necessary to be sure that all the data necessary to aggregate performance indicators are available and identify the different processings to make on data in order to store them in the data warehouse. In order to model the data recovery process, we suggest to use the model proposed in our previous works [19]. 3.1.3 Target architecture The choice of the architecture is very important and we found in the litterature different architectures. This step will be detailled in the next section.
Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems
107
3.1.4 Tool selection When the architecture is defined, designers have to chose the different tools which will compose the architecture. It will depend of the chosen architecture and final users requirements. Indeed, designers have to answer users requirements ensuring that chosen architecture will support the different computing applications. 3.1.5 Administration One of the commonly neglected issues is the administration of the data warehouse after its implementation. The appropriate technical resources mustbe assigned to monitor query load and performance, to handle dynamic changes to the data structures, and to ensure platform scalability with increased user demands. Generally, data warehousing projects use the prototype approach to development and the success of the prototype will determine the overall success of the project. 3.2. Data Storage Architecture The data warehousing architectures provides discussions and examples of a variety of architectures [20]. We found in the litterature four main architectures : independent data marts, data mart bus architecture with linked dimensional data marts, hub and spoke and centralized data warehouse. The hub and spoke architecture is considered as the most complete and we have chosen to use this architecture. This architecture will be detailled below. With this architecture, attention is focused on building a scalable and maintainable infrastructure. Data are stored in two different databases, the data warehouse and the data marts. The data warehouse stored all operational data extracted from data sources which are necessary for the aggregation of the different performance indicators. Dependant data marts are developed for departmental, functional area or specific purposes (e.g., data mining).In the data marts are only stored all the performance indicators and some atomic data for specific analysis (e.g., OLAP analysis). Data marts independence improves the rapidity of the system and furthermore it allows it to be more easily scalable and maintainable. However, this architecture owns two disadvantages. The first one is the cost of this system which is more expensive due to the data quantity to store which is more important. The second one is the difficulty of development. Indeed, two different modelling have to be used, one for the data warehouse and one for the data marts. When the architecture is chosen, it is necessary to realize the modelling of the data warehouse and the data marts. 3.3. Data Storage System Modelling As explained in the previous section, the data warehouse and the data marts have different objectives and so it is necessary to use a specific modelling for each one.
108
G. Vicien, Y. Ducq, B. Vallespir
3.3.1. Data warehouse modelling The goal of the data warehouse is to centralize all operational data extracted from the different data sources. The fist step of the data warehouse building is the creation of the metadata repository. The metadata repository will allow to solve the interoperability problem 3 definied in section 2.3 about the heterogeneous of the data. Designers have to develop a common format for data storage. This common format has to be develop according to the different information recovered about data in order to limit the number of processinds which have to be done on data during the extraction process. Then, it is necessary to model the data storage using the 3rd normal form of relational databases. The main interest of the 3rd normal form is to avoid data redundancy. The modelling is composed of two parts. The first allows consits in the definition of the different tables and the relations between the tables. This modelling has to be done using entity relation model. 3.3.2 Data marts modelling The modelling of the data marts is very important in order to avoid the interoperability problem 4 about the need for specific analysis or applications (e.g. OLAP analysis) to use a specific modelling. It is so important to have well defined the users requirements during the first stage of the framework. In order to allow the aggregation of the different performance indicators and give the final users the access to detailed data, it is necessary to organize the data in a star schema. Star schema is composed of two kings of tables and we have defined a formalism in order to model the different elements of the star schema. Fact tables allow to store the different measures of the fact and are composed of different elements: (1) Fact name, (2) Key name, (3) List of entry in dimensions and (4) Specific attributes of the fact. The fact table formalism is: Fact_name [(F), (Fact_Key), (Entries), (Dimensions)] Dimensions tables allow to do analysis of the fact according to the dimension and are also composed of different elements: (1) Dimension name, (2) Key name, (3) List of the different members of the dimension, for example the dimension Time could have for members: year, month, week and day, (4) Specific attributes of the dimension. The dimension table formalism is: Dimension_name [(D), (Dimension_key), (Members), (Attributes)] In order to illustrate the formalism, we are going to take the example of the performance indicator: number of stock shortages per item and product. Fact table: Stock_Shortages [(F), (Key_Stock_Shortage), (Key_Item, Key_Product, Key_Time), (Causes)]. Dimension tables: Items [(D), (Key_Item), (Item_Number), (Item_ Name)] Product [(D), (Key_Product), (Product_number), (Product_name)] Time [(D), (Key_Time), (Day, Week, Month, Year), ()] The figure 3 illustrates the star schema of the example.
Contribution to Interoperability of Executive Information Systems
109
Fig 3. Example of star schema
When all the star schema are finished for all the performance indicators which have to be agregated, it is necessary to find the different common dimensions in order to build the complete model of each data marts. The figure 4 shows a global star schema after the grooping of dimensions.
Figure 4. Global star schema
4. Conclusion This paper has allow to identify the different interoperability problems which can occur during the design of the data storage system of an executive information system. Thanks to their positionnement in the interoperability framework, the designers can identify them quickly and propose a solution. In the second part of this paper, the framework proposed for the data storage system permits to well identify the different steps of the design and the implementation of the system in order to assure the system success. Then, we have chosen to use the hub and spoke architecture and proposed a formalism to build the data storage elements model. Our future works, we will devoted on the restitution process and more particularly on the dashboards design. It will be interesting to design the dashboards using different concepts like decision centers or the coherence analysis developed by [21] in his previous works. Finally, we will have to apply those different results to a real case in order to verify their contributions and to adjust them according to the obtaining results.
110
G. Vicien, Y. Ducq, B. Vallespir
5. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
Johnson H. T., Kaplan R. S. (1987), Relevance Lost – The Rise and Fall of Management accounting, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. Bittici U., Garengo P., Dörfler V., Nudurupati S. (2009), Performance measurement: Questions for Tomorrow, APMS 2009 conference, Bordeaux, France. Lebas M. J. (1995), Performance measurement and performance management, Production Economics, Volume 41, pp. 23-35. Kaplan R. S., Norton D. P. (1996), The balanced scorecard, Harvard Business Press. Neely A., Adams C., Kennerley M. (2002), The performance prism, Prentice Hall. Bitton M. (1990), ECOGRAI : Méthode de conception et d’implantation de systèmes de mesure de performance pour organisations industrielles, Thèse de doctorat, Université Bordeaux 1. Haouet C. (2008), Informatique décisionnelle et management de la performance de l’entreprise, Cahier de recherche numéro 2008-01. Cody W. F., Kreulen J. T., Krishna V., Spangler W. S. (2002), The integration of business intelligence and knowledge management, IBM Systems journal, Volume 41, Number 4, pp 697-713. Nord J., Nord G. (1995), Executive information system: a study and comparative analysis, Information & Management, Volume 29, pp. 95-106. Rainer R. K., Watson H. J. (1995), The keys to executive information system success; Journal of Management Information Systems, Volume 12, pp. 83-98. Salmeron J. L. (2003), EIS success: keys and difficulties in major companies, Technovation, Volume 23, pp. 35-38. Rainer R. K., Watson H. J. (1995), The keys to executive information systems success, Journal of Management Information Systems, Volume 84. Poon P., Wagner C. (2001), Critical success factors revisited: success and failures cases of information systems for senior executive, Decision Support Systems, Volume 30, pp. 393-418. Watson H. J., Aronson J. E., Hamilton R. H., Iyer L., Nagasundaram M., Nemati H., Suleiman J. (1996a), Assessing EIS benefits: a survey of current practices, Journal of Information Technology Management. Zode M. (2007), The evolution of ETL, from hand-coded ETL to tool-based ETL, Cognizant Technology Solutions. Chen D. (2009), Framework for enterprise interoperability, CIGI 2009 Conference, Bagnères de Bigorre, France. Murtaza A. H. (1998), A Framework for Developing Enterprise Data Warehouses, Information Systems Management, Volume 15, pp. 21-26. Mollard D. (2006), Systèmes décisionnels et pilotage de la performance, Lavoisier. Vicien G., Ducq Y., Vallespir B. (2009), Contribution to Interoperability of Decision Support Systems focusing on the data recovery process, IESA 2009 Conference, Pékin, China. Watson H. J., Ariyachandra T. (2005), Data Warehouse Architectures: Factors in the Selection Decision and the Success of the Architectures, Report available on http://www.terry.uga.edu/~hwatson/DW_Architecture_Report.pdf. Ducq Y. (1999), Contribution à une méthodologie d’analyse de la cohérence des systèmes de production dans le cadre du modèle GRAI, Thèse de doctorat, Université Bordeaux 1.
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable ESA Lanshun Nie1, Xiaofei Xu1, David Chen2, Gregory Zacharewicz2, Dechen Zhan1 1 2
School of Computer Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, 150001 Harbin, China. IMS/LAPS/GRAI, University Bordeaux 1, 351 Cours de la Liberation, 33405 Talence Cedex, France.
Abstract. This paper presents GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture (MDI) which is developed based on MDA (Model Driven Architecture) of OMG and some initial works performed in INTEROP NoE. This MDI architecture aims at supporting the development of changeable on-demand and interoperable ESA (Enterprise Software Application). The architecture defined five modelling levels, i.e., Top CIM, Bottom CIM, Object oriented PIM, Pattern oriented PSM, and Component and configuration oriented CODE. This paper presents in detail core concepts and rational of each modeling level. An application example in nuclear equipment industry is outlined. Keywords: MDI, MDA, ESA, Interoperability, Architecture, Model transformation
1. Introduction Today, with the increasing pressure from competitive market, enterprises particularly SMEs are obliged to work in network in order to meet the changeable and customized demand. ESA (Enterprise Software Application) supporting the business should be adaptable and flexible to the business change. In such networking approach and with the development of the globalization of the economy, enterprises have to cooperate with partners such as material suppliers, service suppliers, distributor, retailer and public administration to provide highquality products and services to customers. In order to cooperate, it is required for enterprises to have capabilities of interoperability in the level of both business and IT/software systems, i.e. ESA. Changeable on-demand and interoperable ESA brings great challenge to software architecture, implementation, deployment, in a word, software development [1, 2]. This paper demontrates how MDI (Model Driven Interoperability) contribute to these developments.
112
L. S. Nie, X. F. Xu, D. Chen, G. Zacharewicz and D. C. Zhan
1.1. Problems and Research Objectives Code is the core artefact in traditional software development process. This process is usually very long, and the cost is usually very high. It is not rapid and adaptative enough to develop changeable on-demand interoperable ESA. Since years there is a shift from code-based software development to model-based software development. The most known approach is MDA (Model Driven Architecture)[3]. In the objective of tackling interoperability at each level of life cycle development, MDI (Model Driven Interoperability) architecture has been introduced by generalysing the steps of MDA. It deals with interoperabilty between ESAs during their respective developments. In this new methodology, conceptual models of enterprise interoperabilty are elaborated to facilitate the interoperablity at the coding level. Software development starts from business level where a Computing Independent Model (CIM) is elaborated and then transformed into executable ESA system by automatic/semi-automatic transformation and code generation tools. There are still some research questions due to the fact that MDA, and by heritage, MDI only defines the framework and some guiding rules, but not detailed method to follow, nor modelling languages. For example enterprise modelling techniques are not well considered at the CIM level. Should the CIM level be further divided in order to model both business and software requirements? The interoperability among adjacent levels is also not sufficiently studied. The research objective is to address the problems mentioned above through the elaboration of a Model Driven Interoperability Architecture (entitled GRAI-ICE MDI) taking into account the MDA and some initial works performed in INTEROP NoE. This MDI architecture aims at defining both the modelling levels of the architecture and model transformation method between adjacent levels. The proposed GRAI-ICE MDI will support the development of interoperable, configurable and executable next generation ESA. 1.2. Background and Related Works Model Driven Interoperability (MDI) architecture [2, 3] aims at decreasing the complexity and difficulty of interoperable software system development by decomposing complex, abstract system into multiple levels. The basic ideas are: (1) decoupling the requirement specification and function specification from implementation specification in specific platform; (2) establishing computation independent model (CIM) which describes business requirement, platform independent model (PIM) which describes design of software, and platform specific model (PSM) which describes implementation mechanism of system; (3) transformation and mapping from upper level model to lower level model, refining the model and automatically generating software from models [4,5]. It has been recommended for modelling using languages and technologies such as UML, MOF and CWM, and transforming models using technologies such as meta-model and pattern [6, 7]. However, MDI only defined some guiding rules, but not the details such as concrete modeling elements, modeling methodology and model transformation method [8]. Consequently, it is necessary to select or refine modeling method(s) and organize them consistently.
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable
113
Researchers have studied some most known existing modeling methodology, language and tools such as CIMOSA [9], GRAI [10] and IDEF[11]. UML (Unified Modeling Language) is the most widely used modeling language for software specification [11]. The former is suitable for business level, i.e. CIM level. The latter is suitable for software oriented modelling, i.e. PIM and PSM levels. However, there still exists a big semantic gap between them and no existing approach shows how to integrate them to a consistent architecture. Therefore, the question is still open on how to select, from the existing business modeling methods and software modeling methods, adequate formalisms, to refine, combine and integrate them into MDI architecture. Motivated by the requirement of developing changeable on-demand and interoperable ESA, and based on some existing modeling languages, a Model Driven Interoperability architecture, entitled GRAI-ICE MDI architecture, is proposed. GRAI refers to GRAI methodology and is used at CIM level to describe business user oriented requirements. ICE means Interoperable Configurable and Executable. This approach is based on some initial works performed in INTEROPNoE and further developed within the frame of INTEROP VLab through a research collaboration between University Bordeaux 1 (IMS/LAPS) and Harbin Institute of Technology (HIT) and also the company GFI.. It aims at defining concrete modelling elements (concepts) and relations among them at all levels of MDI architecture so that the model of ESA can be described precisely and consistently by these elements. This architecture supports model transformation top-down (CIM→PIM→PSM→CODE), and from code to system deployment. Also performed in INTEROP NoE, R. Grangel etc. proposed a similar MDI framework. They broke down CIM level into two sublevels, i.e. top-level CIM and bottom-level CIM. Besides this, their research work focus on transformation from top-level CIM model to bottom-level CIM model, with an example of transforming GRAI extended actigrams into UML activity diagrams[12,13]. 1.3. Purpose and Structure of the Paper The purpose of the paper is to present the preliminary research results on Model Driven Interoperability architecture for developing Interoperable ESA. In this paper focus is on the set of modelling methods and languages defined in MDI. The related transformation methods will be presented in a forthecoming paper. After the introduction given in section 1, the global GRAI-ICE MDI architecture is presented and explained in section 2. Then, section 3 to section 5 will explain the problems, target of modelling, core concepts and relations, as well as modelling methods used at the three main levels (CIM, PIM, and PSM). Section 6 presents the last level of the architecture (ESA component and system level) and outlines the principle of model transformation and supporting tools. An application case is discussed in section 7. Finally section 8 and 9 respectively conclude the paper and discuss on future perspectives.
114
L. S. Nie, X. F. Xu, D. Chen, G. Zacharewicz and D. C. Zhan
2. Overview of GRAI-ICE MDI Architecture GRAI-ICE MDI follows the basic structure of MDA proposed by OMG. It includes four modelling levels and one system level. It also includes transformation methods between these levels. The global view of GRAI-ICE MDI architecture is shown Fig.1. Note that CIM level is divided into two sub-levels: Top CIM (business oriented CIM) and Bottom CIM (ESA oriented CIM). Business Oriented CIM (GRAI*)
Decision Oriented
Business-oriented CIM Global Model Dec
Phy
Inf
AS-IS
Func
Org TO-BE 1
Models
ESA Oriented CIM For inter-op
TO-BE 2
Transform: Business CIM→ ESA CIM
Transform.
Process Oriented
ESA-oriented CIM Global Model GRAI ESA Decision Model
Function/Process View
UML+
Information View
GRAI TO-BE ESA
Organization View
ESA Model
Views Transform: CIM→ PIM
Transform.
ICE-PIM
Object Oriented
For inter-op
UML+
Transform: PI M→ PSM
Transform.
ICE-PSM For inter-op
Pattern Oriented
Static Confi. Model BC Model
XML+
Generator/Transform.
ESAComponent & System
Patterns Elements
EWF Model
ESA Implementation
Data Model (DB Schema)
Pattern based on framework Generator: PSM→ Code
Component & Configuration Oriented
Transf: PSM→ Confi.file
BC
Sys. Confi.
CC
Framework
Code/Conf. DB Table/View Generator/Transform.
Data Model (IDEF1X or E-R)
Role Model
Diagrams
Data Model (BO-R Model)
BO-Based Workflow Model
BO Model
Generator: PSM→ DB
EWF Confi..
DB Table/View
WF engi.
Platform(J2EE) Transform: CI M/PIM/PSM→ ESA Implementation ESA Implementation Specification ESA Manual
ESA Training
Global picture of GRAI-ICE Version: 1 (26-07-2006)
Fig. 1. GRAI-ICE MDI architecture
Top CIM, which is business oriented and based on GRAI methodology, is a set of models focusing on the description of decision making process, business process and physical product flow process. Bottom CIM, which is ESA oriented, extracts from Top CIM and describes more in detail business requirements which must be supported by ESA, i.e. function/process, information, organization and decision making structure. ICE-PIM is concerned with the object-oriented design of ESA. It focuses on identifying and describing business objects (BO). It includes BO model, BO-Based workflow model, role model, and data model.
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable
115
ICE-PSM, which describes the implementation of ESA, is pattern oriented and XML based. It includes business component (BC) model, static configuration model, executable workflow model and relational data model. ESA system is assembled by business components. It provides service to users by parsing the executable workflow model and scheduling function of business components supported by workflow engine.
3. TOP CIM and Bottom CIM There are two main modelling objectives at CIM level. On the one hand, CIM supports business process modeling, analysis, and optimization, with business people as the stakeholder. On the other hand, CIM also supports the modeling of ESA requirements, with business people and software developer as the stakeholders. Consequently the CIM level of GRAI-ICE MDI is further divided in two sub-levels: Top CIM (business oriented) and Bottom CIM (ESA oriented). Business oriented CIM aims at modeling three kinds of process (or flow). The first is physical process and physical product flow, which supports the analysis and optimization of the time, cost, quality and needed services. The second is business process and document flow, which supports managing, controlling and recording physical process. The third is decision process and order/plan flow which aims at controlling and coordinating physical process and resources. Besides, it is also necessary to describe enterprise organization and decision-making structure. The core modeling concepts/elements of business oriented CIM are: (1) Physical Product, (2) Information, (3) Function/Action, (4) Resource/Facility, (5) Organization, (6) QQV (Quality-Quantity-Value points): the point or the location where input, output or support should be measured, verified, recorded, controlled, processed, or reported, (7) Connection Sign. The models at business oriented CIM level are composed by these elements and their relations. The meta-model of business oriented CIM is shown Fig. 2.
Fig. 2. Metamodel of business oriented CIM
All elements can be further classified into sub-elements. For example, the element “Function/Action” is classified into “function”, “business action”, “decision action” and “physical action”. The element “Information” is classified into
116
L. S. Nie, X. F. Xu, D. Chen, G. Zacharewicz and D. C. Zhan
“document”, “order”, “event” and “report”. The view of CIM model can be exactly described by the combination of these elements and sub-class of them. GRAI-ICE CIM model is composed of three kinds of process diagram and some UML class diagram for information, organization, resource, etc. Physical process model describes the transformation and state transition of physical product in manufacturing. It includes six kinds of basic elements, i.e. product, action, order, resource, organization and QQV. Business process controlling/recording physical process describes the transformation and state transition of documents, such as receipts, orders, reports. It includes four kinds of basic elements, i.e. information/documents, order, action, and organization. Decision process model is based on GRID model of GRAI methodology. It has two dimensions. One is the decision level, for example strategic, tactics, operational levels. The other is the functions. The decision process model describes both the decision making process and the results which coordinate various functions and control other decision making processes. Information entities and the relations can be identified by analyzing the information flow embedded in business process to build information model. Also, organization model is also needed to construct at this level. Relation inside each kind of elements, such as information, organization, function, product, and resource, is described using UML class diagram. Analysis and simulation can be performed on business oriented CIM (AS-IS) of existing system. Then, by optimization and re-engineering, the TO-BE CIM can be obtained Business requirement for ESA is analyzed on the basis of TO-BE CIM. The result is ESA oriented CIM which focus on software requirement definition. For example, the physical process is not concerned since ESA does not control this process directly. We refine models extracted from TO-BE CIM and distinguish those activities (processes and information) which will be processed by machine or human with human-machine interaction. Due to the limited space, the specification of ESA oriented CIM is not described in detail in this paper.
4. ICE-PIM ICE-PIM is based on object-oriented approach, UML and workflow technology. The core concept BO is proposed for integrating both the process oriented model and object oriented software implementation. ICE-PIM is the bridge connecting business model and software implementation. At this level, information entities in the business process of CIM are abstracted and formalized as Business Objects (BO) describing the data structure, data dependency and relations. From the perspective of users, BO is an information entity with its state transitions and operations. From the perspective of software implementation, BO is an integrated object with unique identity, a lifecycle, several data sets and several operation sets. For example, the abstraction of a purchasing order is a BO. It provides a good basis for component-based software development. As mentioned above, CIM is more process oriented, in addition to
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable
117
BO, it is necessary to transform business process of CIM into workflow model. In other words, PIM mainly consists of business objects model and workflow model. The meta-model of ICE-PIM is shown in Fig. 3.
Fig. 3. Metamodel of GRAI-ICE PIM model
Based on the meta-model, the composition of PIM model is as following. Business object model describes BOs and relationship of BOs. BO integrated diagram describes the detail of BO in four dimensions. (1) BO Data diagram describes the relations among data sets in IDEF1x. (2) BO class diagram describes the DPR (controlling relation between operation and data set), the relations among OP (operation of BO) and activity AT (activity set of BO). (3) BO state diagram describes the state SS, transition ST, and the properties associated with lifecycle. (4) BO use case diagram describes the relation among roles and operations. Relations among several BOs are described by BO-R model in two levels. The first level, i.e. BO level, describes the data dependency relations among BOs, such as association and integration. The second level, i.e. entity-relation level, considers the data set inside BO as entity and then describes the relations among them. Workflow model describes the sequence of activities of one BO of multiple BOs. The business object model is the core of PIM level. Workflow model assembles BOs into process supporting business function. Data, operation and state of BO provide input, output and trigger event for workflow exectuion. Data model describes the data schema of all BOs and provides global business view for users.
118
L. S. Nie, X. F. Xu, D. Chen, G. Zacharewicz and D. C. Zhan
Role model defines the access to data and operation. ICE-PIM provides all essential design facets of ESA.
5. ICE-PSM On one hand, ICE-PSM follows and inherents the design information from ICEPIM level models and transforms them into platform specific implementation model. On the other hand, it is the basis for code generation. Software pattern and platform specification are two cornerstones for ICE-PSM. Business Component (BC) is a largest grained unit of software development, and is a realization body of Business Object (BO) which is the finest grained operation unit of business system. BC is an implementation and running pattern for business components and is the core modeling elements in ICE-PSM. It is based on software pattern and XML, and can be transformed to code by code generator. It is a link between business object model and ESA system. Because of limited space, meta-model of BC is omitted. The executable workflow model consists of workflow model of PIM level and implementation details based on schedule pattern. It is described by the language supported by workflow engine (e.g. business process modelling engine, state transition event driven engine…). The static configurable model (SCM) is extracted from the relation between business object and role model. Pattern based ICE-PSM formulizes the software implementation model, simplifies the development of complex ESA and supports industrialized component development. The use of XML provides standard data source for code generation, automatic system configuration and deployment, and interoperability.
6. Generation of Code: ESA Components and System In this level, PSM will be transformed into business components and ESA system. There are three phases for business component. The first is stem business component in software development phase. The properties related with roles and individuals are still in parameter. The second is reused business component in deployment phase. Variable properties of BC are finalized for special role/user. So, the BC in this state is role-related component. The third is individualized business component in running phase. The components show different interfaces and behaviors according to the configuration and requirement of users. By doing so, the requirement of flexibility is distributed in several phases and the difficulty of development is decreased. The ESA development is based on business components. Firstly, the business component models are transformed into stem business components by code generator. Then, they are assembled by workflow, association mechanism and extend mechanism into complete business process. The workflow engine will manage the execution by invoking the different implement BO in the right order. Verification of correctness can be done by running simulation using the workflow
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable
119
engine before execution. After that, they are configured and deployed based on the information of PSM.
7. An Application: Purchase Management The proposed architecture, methods, and associated tools and framework have been applied in ESA (Enterprise Resource Planning system) development in several Chinese enterprises. The time of development and deployment is shortened in more than 40%. The application in one of them, i.e. SHANDONG Nuclear Equipment Co. LTD, China is outlined below. Based on the GRAI-ICE MDI architecture, a set of tools have been developed. Firstly, a MOF, XML and Eclipse based extendable modeling tool supports defining modeling elements on demand and is used in modelling. A running framework has also been developed with a workflow engine inside for ESA. Some patterns in ESA have been extracted and formulized for business objects. XML and pattern based PSM model for BO is built. Based on pattern based PSM, we developed a PSM modeling tool and code generation tool, which support software developer for modeling PSM quickly, generate BC code, configure them and deploy them into the running framework. Fig. 4 (a) gives a segment of business process model at Top CIM level in purchase management domain. Fig. 4 (b) shows the BO-relation model at PIM level in the same domain.
Fig. 4. Example of CIM model and PIM model in purchase management domain
Fig. 5 (a) shows a segment of XML file, which is the PSM of purchase order BO. Fig. 5 (b) shows the running component of purchase order, which is generated from PSM model.
120
L. S. Nie, X. F. Xu, D. Chen, G. Zacharewicz and D. C. Zhan
Fig. 5. Example of PSM model and component of purchase order BO
8. Conclusions Changeability on-demand and interoperability are critical characteristics for ESA in today dynamical economical environment. A concrete and operable model driven interoperability architecture entitled GRAI-ICE MDI is proposed for developing ESA. It integrates both business modeling methods and software modeling methods, defines proper levels and transformation between models elaborated at these levels. The vertical transformation is developed straightforward along the thread “information entity→business object→business component model→stem business component→reused business component”. Dynamic component/service assembly based on workflow technology and variable business component gives good support to ESA assembly, configuration and deployment. The originality of the proposed approach is as following: (1) A nearly complete implementation of MDA/MDI is given in GRAI-ICE MDI, which appropriately integrates enterprise modelling, software modelling and software architecture. (2) The proposed architecture is interoperable, configurable and executable. (3) CIM is divided into business oriented CIM and ESA oriented CIM to capture both business and software requirements. (4) The proposed architecture and associated tools have been successfully applied in changeable on-demand and interoperable ESA development. Last but not least, the time of development and deploy has been greatly shortened.
9. Perspectives Considering the technical trend such as service computing and SaaS (Software as a Service), the GRAI-ICE MDI architecture should be adapted to service-oriented model-driven interoperable architecture. Business components will evolve to service components and ESA will evolve to service components composition.
GRAI-ICE Model Driven Interoperability Architecture for Developing Interoperable
121
More and more components and services are available on Internet. In order to incorporate, manage and reuse them in GRAI-ICE MDI architecture, it should not only be top-down, i.e. transformation and generation from business to IT, but also bottom-up, i.e. discovery, assembly and composition from existing IT elements to meet new business interoperability requirement[14]. Also, validation of the models by simulation can be envisaged. For now, GRAI-ICE MDI architecture focuses more on function requirement of ESA. However, non-function requirements such as confidentiality, security, timing, are crucial for run-time system. So, how to extend the proposed architecture to modeling non-function requirement and transform them into ESA is another important issue to consider in the future.
10. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13] [14]
C Pautasso, T Heinis, G Alonso. Autonomic resource provisioning for software business processes. Information and Software Technology, 49(1): 65-80(2007) J.P. Bourey, R. Grangel, G. Doumeingts and A.J. Berre, “Report on Model Driven Interoperability”, Deliverable DTG2.3, INTEROP NoE, , April 2007, pp. 91 OMG. MDA guide version 1.0.1. http://www.omg.com/.12th June 2003 J. Bezivin, O. Gerbe. Towards a precise definition of the OMG/MDA Framework. Automated Software Engineering.(ASE 2001). Proceedings. 16th Annual International Conference on 26-29 Nov. 2001:273 - 280 T. Meservy, K. D. Fenstermacher. Transforming software development: An MDA road map. Computer, 38(9): 52-58(2005) J. Bezivin. From object composition to model transformation with the MDA. Proceedings of the 39th International Conference and Exhibition on Technology of Object-Oriented Languages and Systems, Santa Barbara, August 350 (2001) R. Lemesle. Transformation rules base on meta- modeling. Enterprise Distributed Object Com- puting Workshop. EDOC'98. Proceedings. Second International,3-5 Nov. 113 – 122(1998) W. Tan, L. Ma, J. Li, Z. Xiao. Application MDA in a conception design environment. First International Multi-Symposiums on Computer and Computational Sciences, IMSCCS'06: 702-704(2006) K. Kosanke. CIMOSA--overview and status. Computers in Industry, 101-109(1995) D. Chen, B. Vallespir and G. Doumeingts. GRAI integrated methodology and its mapping onto generic enterprise reference architecture and methodology. Computers in Industry, 387-194(1997) D. Chen, G. Doumeingts, F. Vernadat. Architectures for Enterprise Integration and Interoperability: Past, Present and Future. International Journal of Computers In Industry, 59(5), May 2008. R. Grangel, R. Ben Salem, J. P. Bourey, N. Daclin, Y. Ducq. Transforming GRAI extended actigrams into UML activity diagrams: a first step to Model Driven Interoperability, I-ESA 2007, Funchal (Madeira Island), Portugal, March 28– 30, 2007. R. Grangel, R. Chalmeta, C. Campos, R. Sommar, J. P. Bourey. A proposal for goal modelling using a UML profile. I-ESA 2008, Berlin, Germany, March 26–28, 2008. G. Zacharewicz, D. Chen; B. Vallespir. Short-Lived Ontology Approach for Agent/HLA Federated Enterprise Interoperability, I-ESA