Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page i
In the 60s, segregation and discrimination were no less a part of Aboriginal life than of the lives of black people in the Deep South. We needed a civil rights movement . . . and in Charlie Perkins and company, we got one. This book tells with verve the story of the Freedom Rides and the conscience-searing triumph they were. The characters are skilfully conjured in all their youth and idealism. Ann Curthoys tells the story with an insider’s eye and the passion of a true believer—and there is no other way to recount this moral victory and the lasting change it helped edge into being. Bob Carr, Premier of NSW
In the early 1960s, most Australians could affect ignorance or feel comfortable about the racism, discrimination and poverty affecting Aboriginal Australians. The Freedom Ride of 1965 marked the time when those who had been comfortable with what was happening were confronted with reality. It forced other Australians to look at the darker side of the past and the present. It helped develop a new generation of Aboriginal leaders. Jack Waterford, Editor-in-chief, The Canberra Times
The record of the students’ Freedom Ride in New South Wales is profound. Ann Curthoys has recounted the brave action of the students’ determination to break the barriers that divided black and white Australia. Meticulously researched, the author has provided a compelling work. Faith Bandler
This book is a revealing window into the courage, humanity and commitment of the participants. It again focuses the nation on the continuing need for organised political action to secure social justice and a just reconciliation. Robert Tickner, Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs 1990–96
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page ii
For my mother Barbara Lindsay Curthoys 1924–2000
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page iii
ANN CURTHOYS
FREEDOM RIDE a freedom rider remembers
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page iv
First published in 2002 Copyright © Ann Curthoys 2002 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10 per cent of this book, whichever is the greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act. Every effort has been made to contact the copyright holders of the photographs produced in this book. In the event where these efforts were unsuccessful, the copyright holders are asked to contact the publisher directly. Aboriginal readers are warned that this book contains the names and images of some Aboriginal people who have since died. Allen & Unwin 83 Alexander Street Crows Nest NSW 2065 Australia Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100 Fax: (61 2) 9906 2218 Email:
[email protected] Web: www.allenandunwin.com National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry: Curthoys, Ann. Freedom ride : a freedom rider remembers. ISBN 1 86448 922 7. 1. Curthoys, Ann, – Journeys. 2. Australia – History. I. Title. 994 Set in 10.5 pt Schneidler by Midland Typesetters Pty Ltd Maryborough, Victoria Printed in Australia by McPherson’s Printing Group 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page v
Contents List of illustrations
vi
Dramatis personae
x
Names Acknowledgements
xvi xviii
1.
Let’s have a Freedom Ride
2.
Getting ready
35
3.
On the way to Walgett
62
4.
High noon at Walgett
83
5.
Moree: Australia’s Little Rock?
114
6.
Clash at Moree
143
7.
‘Stirring up trouble’: The coastal towns
171
8.
Impact
210
9.
More Freedom Rides
240
Memory and meaning
274
10.
1
Epilogue: Whatever happened to . . .?
294
Select bibliography
313
A note on sources
317
Index
320
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page vi
Illustrations Page 6.
Page 7. Page 18. Page 26.
Page 49. Page 57. Page 95. Page 98. Page 99.
Page 111.
vi
Burning an imitation KKK cross at a student demonstration for US civil rights, Sydney, 6 May 1964 (Daily Telegraph, 7 May 1964). See note on page ix. A female student is arrested at a civil rights demonstration (Daily Telegraph, 7 May 1964). See note on page ix. Gary Williams and Charles Perkins on their first day as students at the University of Sydney, March 1963. Students demonstrate for Aboriginal rights during National Aborigines Week at Hyde Park and Parliament House, Sydney, 7 July 1964. Photographer: Michael Elton. John Powles, Charles Perkins, Pat Healy and Jim Spigelman plan the Freedom Ride (Sydney Morning Herald, 17 June 2000). Publicity notice for folk concert to raise money for the Freedom Ride, 21 January 1965. Machteld Hali draws the placard: ‘Good enough for Tobruk. Why not Walgett?’ Helen Gray, Machteld Hali, Norm McKay and Ann Curthoys hold banners outside Walgett RSL, 15 February 1965. Students demonstrate outside the Walgett RSL holding their banner, ‘Student Action for Aborigines’ and RSL worker offers drinks to the students (Sydney Morning Herald, 17 February 1965). ‘Nonsense! Of course you want a drink’. Cartoon by Molnar, Sydney Morning Herald, 17 February 1965. See note on page ix.
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page vii
Illustrations
vii
Page 129. Bob Brown, Freedom Ride supporter, standing outside his electrical goods store, Moree. Page 132. Ann Curthoys and Louise Higham interview Aboriginal residents at the Aborigines Welfare Board Station, Moree, 17 February 1965. Page 135. The students demonstrate outside the council chambers in Balo Street, Moree (Tribune, 24 February 1965). Page 138. Charles Perkins waits with children to enter the swimming pool, Moree, 17 February 1965 (Sydney Morning Herald, 24 February 1965). See note on page ix. Page 138. Charles Perkins with children in the Moree pool on Wednesday 17 February 1965 (Australian, 19 February 1965). Page 145. The bus stands outside the Hotel Boggabilla, where students rested before interviewing people at the Aboriginal Station. Page 152. Students greet Charles Perkins at Inverell airport. Page 154. Charles waits with children outside the Moree pool, 20 February 1965 (Daily Mirror, 22 February 1965). Page 156. Police attempt to keep the crowd away from the students at the Moree pool. Page 156. Charles Perkins is led away from the pool. (Daily Mirror, 22 February 1965). Page 157. Bob Gallagher is hit on the head with an egg at Moree (Australian, 22 February 1965). Page 163. The Daily Mirror’s full-page coverage of the demonstration at Moree pool, 22 February 1965. Page 166. Cartoonist Martin Sharp makes a harsh comment on the citizens of Moree (Australian, 22 February 1965). Page 168. ‘It’s not too cold for me—it’s too hot.’ Cartoon by Eyre Jnr, Sydney Morning Herald, 22 February 1965, satirising the Chief Secretary’s lack of response to the Freedom Ride. See note on page ix. Page 173. Charles Perkins, Gerry Mason, John Powles and Brian Aarons wait in Grafton for the replacement bus driver to arrive, Monday 22 February 1965 (Daily Examiner, 23 February 1965). Page 178. The students hold a watermelon eating competition while waiting in Grafton. See note on page ix. Page 182. Clarrie Combo, chairman of directors of the Aboriginal Cooperative at Cabbage Tree Island, discusses problems with the sugar
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page viii
viii
Freedom Ride
Page 187. Page 188.
Page 189. Page 192. Page 202.
Page 203.
Page 206. Page 207.
Page 208.
Page 225. Page 234. Page 242. Page 243. Page 246. Page 251.
Page 252. Page 255.
cane crop with Mr H. Jeffery, manager of the Cabbage Tree Island Reserve, Tuesday 23 February (Sydney Morning Herald, 24 February 1965). See note on page ix. Bruce Petty cartoon of the bus leaving Moree (Australian, 25 February 1965). George Bracken, Aboriginal former lightweight boxing champion, criticises the Freedom Ride (Daily Mirror, 22 February 1965). The students arrive in Bowraville. Brian Aarons and Gary Williams drink together in Bowraville Hotel (Sydney Morning Herald, 25 Feb 1965). See note on page ix. Charles Perkins is barred from taking a child into the McElhone olympic swimming pool, Kempsey (Sydney Morning Herald, 26 February 1965). Students outside Kempsey swimming pool hold placards protesting against exclusion of Aboriginal people from the pool (Macleay Argus, 27 February 1965). Wendy Golding’s photo of the students posed outside the bus. ‘He does not drink, hates crowded pools, likes to sit in front at the pictures. How can we desegregate him?’ Cartoon by Molnar (Sydney Morning Herald, 26 February 1965). See note on page ix. Ted Noffs welcomes back Charles Perkins at the University of Sydney on 26 February 1965. The Freedom Ride is over (Sydney Morning Herald, 27 February 1965). See note on page ix. The Student Action for Aborigines stall during the University of Sydney Orientation Week. See note on page ix. Students hold 100-hour vigil outside the NSW Liberal Party and Labor Party headquarters. Photographer: Bruce Adams. Members of SAFA visit Walgett in May and August 1965. Harry Hall’s place and members of Harry Hall’s family with two SAFA students, Walgett, 1965. The Luxury Theatre, Walgett, 1965. Marie Peters, Pattie Hall and Lorna Hall, participants in the demonstration to desegregate the Walgett Luxury Theatre on 7 August 1965. Harry Hall, Pattie Hall and Lorna Hall (Tribune, 18 August 1965). Ted Fields buys his ticket to the dress circle at the Luxury
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page ix
Illustrations
ix
Theatre, Walgett, Saturday 14 August 1965 (Tribune, 18 August 1965). Page 257. Walgett community members and students pose together for a group photo in August 1965. Page 265. A young Aboriginal man addresses a meeting near the Aboriginal reserve, Bowraville, 12 March 1966, while police watch. Page 267. Sue Johnston burns copies of the Aborigines Protection Act outside Parliament House, 13 July 1966 (Honi Soit, 20 July 1966). Note: Every effort has been made to contact the copyright holders of the photographs and illustrations produced on pages 6, 7, 111, 138, 156, 168, 178, 182, 192, 207, 208 and 225. As these efforts were unsuccessful, the copyright holders are asked to contact the publisher directly.
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page x
Dramatis personae The students Note: Ages are sometimes approximate, and both age and enrolment in university courses are for February 1965. Charles Perkins, 29, third-year Arts, Arrernte man, born in Alice Springs, former soccer player, Aboriginal activist Gary Williams, 19, third-year Arts, Gumbaynggir man from Nambucca Heads Aidan Foy, 19, third-year Medicine, member of the ALP Club Alan Outhred, 19, third-year Science, member of the Labour Club Alex Mills, 25, third-year Theology, member of the Liberal Club Ann Curthoys, 19, third-year Arts, member of the Labour Club Barry Corr, 18, second-year Arts Beth Hansen, 19, third-year Arts, member of the Humanist Society Bob Gallagher, 19, third-year Engineering, member of the Labour Club Brian Aarons, 19, third-year Science, member of the Labour Club Chris Page, 19, third-year Medicine Colin Bradford, 19, third-year Science, member of the Labour Club Darce Cassidy, 22, part-time third-year Arts, also ABC radio producer x
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xi
Dramatis personae
xi
David Pepper, 18, second-year Arts Derek Molloy, 19, third-year Arts Hall Greenland, 19, third-year Arts, member of the ALP Club Helen Gray, 19, second-year Arts Jim Spigelman, 19, third-year Arts, leader of the Fabian Society, breakaway group from the ALP Club John Butterworth, 20, third-year Science John Gowdie, University of New England, son of Presbyterian minister from Dubbo John Powles, 22, fifth-year Medicine, founder of the Sydney University Humanist Society, involved in Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament Judith Rich, 20, third-year Arts Louise Higham, 18, second-year Medicine, member of the Labour Club. Machteld Hali, 18, second-year Arts, born in Holland, raised in Indonesia Norm Mackay, 19, third-year Science, member of the Labour Club Paddy Dawson, 19, third-year Arts, member of the ALP Club Pat Healy, 20, third-year Arts, member of the Labour Club Ray Leppik, 22, postgraduate Science Rick Collins, 19, third-year Arts Robyn Iredale, 20, fourth-year Arts, in Geography Honours Sue Johnston, 20, fourth-year Arts, in History Honours Sue Reeves, 19, third-year Arts, member of Abschol Warwick Richards, 19, third-year Arts, member of the Student Christian Movement Wendy Golding, 17, second-year Arts
Also on the bus Gerry Mason, an older Aboriginal friend of Charles Perkins from Gerard government reserve in South Australia Bill Pakenham, from Punchbowl, driver of the bus until Grafton Ernie Albrecht, from Lugarno, driver of the bus from Grafton onwards
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xii
xii
Freedom Ride
Students on the follow-up trips Sue-Ann Loftus Owen Westcott, 18, second-year Arts Christine Jones
Aboriginal rights organisations and leaders AAF Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, a mixed-race organisation for Aboriginal rights founded by Pearl Gibbs and Faith Bandler in 1956. APA Aborigines Progressive Association, a largely Aboriginal organisation for Aboriginal rights, founded in January 1964, with Bert Groves, formerly president of the AAF, as president. The name had also been used by an earlier organisation in the 1930s. The Foundation The Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs, founded in 1964 to provide support for Sydney’s growing Aboriginal population. SAFA Student Action for Aborigines. Formed in 1964 at the University of Sydney to organise the Freedom Ride. Lasted until 1967. Abschol Organisation under the leadership of NUAUS, founded to raise funds for scholarships for Aboriginal university students; from 1965, supported political campaigns such as the Referendum. FCAA Federal Council for Aboriginal Advancement, founded in 1958. Changed its name in April 1964 to FCAATSI—Federal Council for the Advancement of Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders.
Aboriginal leaders based in Sydney Bert Groves, an Aboriginal man from the northwest of New South Wales, president of the AAF 1957–58, and of the APA 1964–? Charles (Chicka) Dixon, active in the APA and the Foundation Ray Peckham, Aboriginal man from northwestern New South Wales, now active in APA and the Waterside Workers’ Federation
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xiii
Dramatis personae
xiii
Non-Aboriginal activists Faith Bandler, founder and secretary of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship Allan Duncan, lecturer in Aboriginal adult education, member of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, and chairman of the Foundation’s Education Committee Jack Horner, secretary of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship
At the University of Sydney Michael Kirby, 25, Law, president of the SRC, student representative on the University Senate Ken Buckley, senior lecturer in Economic History, secretary of the Council for Civil Liberties Peter Westerway, executive producer of the investigative Channel 7 television program Seven Days, occasional lecturer in Government Tom Roper, 19, third-year Arts, member of SAFA, later director of Abschol David Ellyard, 19, Science, member of SAFA Eric Doldissen, 20, treasurer of SAFA
At the University of New South Wales Bill Ford, lecturer in the School of Economics, former Fulbright scholar in the United States, observer of Freedom Rides in Jackson, Mississippi in 1961
Walgett people Aboriginal Harry Hall, Gamilaraay, ex-shearer, worker at Walgett garage, leader of Aboriginal people in Walgett George Rose, Yuwaaliyaay, from Brewarrina, sergeant in army during World War II, shearer and member of the AWU, settled in Walgett in 1949, leading figure in Walgett APA Gladys Lake, leading figure in Walgett APA
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xiv
xiv
Freedom Ride
Ted Fields, leading figure in Walgett APA Pat Walford, woman in her twenties, outspoken resident Marie Peters, 18, resident Pattie Hall, daughter of Harry Hall Lorna Hall, niece of Harry Hall
Non-Aboriginal Alex Trevallion, Town Clerk Athol White, manager, Oasis Hotel-Motel Tom Hogan, manager, Walgett RSL Club James Conomos, owner, Luxury Theatre
Moree people Aboriginal Lyall Munro Snr, shearer and local Aboriginal leader Lyall Munro Jnr, 14, living on Mehi mission Zona Craigie, 8, resident of Thompson’s Row
Non-Aboriginal Alf Sadlier, Mayor in 1955 when resolution banning Aborigines from the local pool was passed William Tait, Deputy Mayor in 1955 Bill Lloyd, Mayor in 1965 Bob Brown, 29, owner/manager of an electrical business
Aboriginal people in other towns Ann Holten, 16, high school student, Bowraville Pastor Frank Roberts Jnr, Bundjalung leader, Lismore
The clergy Ted Noffs, Methodist pastor supportive of Aboriginal people, associate minister of the Central Methodist Mission in Sydney, co-founder of the Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xv
Dramatis personae
xv
Reverend Peter Dowe, the vicar at St Peter’s Church of England in Walgett Ted Ryan, Methodist minister, Moree
The journalists Bruce Maxwell, cadet reporter for the Sydney Morning Herald, travelled with the students Gerald Stone, migrated from the United States to Australia in 1962, reporter for the Daily Mirror and the Sunday Mirror, travelled with the students from Moree onwards Judith Rich, reporter for the Daily Telegraph from Moree onwards, also a student at the University of Sydney Peter Martin, reporter for Seven Days, Channel 7
Politicians and bureaucrats A.G. Kingsmill, chair of the Aborigines Welfare Board H.J. Green, Superintendent of the Aborigines Welfare Board Gus Kelly, Chief Secretary, responsible for Aboriginal welfare until 1 May 1965 Jack Renshaw, Premier of New South Wales until 1 May 1965, member for Castlereagh, the electorate in which Walgett was situated Eric Willis, Chief Secretary of New South Wales, 13 May 1965 to 19 June 1972 Bill Rigby, Labor MLA for Hurstville, one-time member of the AAF, one of the few supporters of Aboriginal rights in the New South Wales Parliament
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xvi
Names Aboriginal people a general term for the Indigenous people of Australia. The term ‘Aborigines’ was most commonly used in the 1960s, but is now less preferred. Indigenous the indigenous people of Australia and the Torres Strait Islands. Increasingly the preferred term by those whom it designates. Murris the term derived from local languages, meaning ‘our people’ or ‘us’, for Aboriginal people in southern Queensland and the central section of northern New South Wales. Kooris the equivalent term for Indigenous people in southern and eastern New South Wales. Kamilaraay a large language group in northern New South Wales; Walgett, Moree and Boggabilla lie in Kamilaraay country. Wiradjuri a large language group in western and southern New South Wales; Wellington is in Wiradjuri country. Bundjalung a large language group in far northeastern New South Wales; Lismore is in Bundjalung country. Gumbaynggirr the people of the east coast region near present-day Bowraville. Dhan-gadi, Ngaku and Ngumbar the people of the Macleay Valley, at the mouth of which lies Kempsey.
xvi
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xvii
xvii
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xviii
Acknowledgments From the moment I started writing a diary as a student on the Freedom Ride in February 1965, there was a possibility I might write this book. I did not, however, form a definite intention to write it until some time in 1988, the year in which Indigenous political protest so effectively deflected the Bicentennial celebrations towards a more reflective reconsideration of the meaning of Australian history. Perhaps I was moved to write it by Peter Read, who interviewed me in 1987 about the Freedom Ride for a chapter in his biography of Charles Perkins. In 1989 I applied for funding for the research from the Australian Research Council, stating in my application that the Freedom Ride was a ‘key event’ in the history of the relations between Aboriginal and other Australians. My book, I said, would assist the development of ‘a clearer understanding of the historical processes through which a strong Aboriginal political movement emerged in the 1960s’. I saw the Freedom Ride then—and still do—as ‘a jumpingoff point’ for investigating some large themes in the history of relations between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people in Australia. When the grant was awarded, I began serious work on the project in 1990, with the wonderful Kathy Moffatt as my research assistant. My original plan was to write the book during study leave in 1991. In April that year, John Docker and I retraced the itinerary of the Freedom Ride, interviewing many people and looking at the places that had witnessed these significant events two-and-a-half decades earlier. We travelled through the towns of Orange, Wellington, Dubbo, Gulargambone, xviii
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xix
Acknowledgments
xix
Walgett, Moree, Lismore, Bowraville and Kempsey, and interviewed people, both Indigenous and non-Indigenous, who had been involved. My having been a Freedom Rider led many Aboriginal people to speak to me who may not have done so otherwise, though most of those interviewed did not wish to speak into a tape-recorder. So I took extensive notes while we talked and then typed up my diary each evening. Later that year I wrote my first academic paper on the Freedom Ride project, and delivered it at the Sir Robert Menzies Centre for Australian Studies in London, and at the History Workshop conference in Oxford. What I learnt during 1991 was that the project had still a long way to go. I seemed to be endlessly diverted by the many and diverse activities of a busy senior academic in the 1990s—undergraduate teaching, graduate supervision, academic administration, consultancies, conferences, prize and grant committees, endless selection committees, committees of review, advisory committees, indeed academic committees of every imaginable kind. And there were still many intellectual lessons to learn. I found that I had to circle around my material before I could get directly to it. Through the 1990s I had a burst of writing activity on a wide range of issues, including national identity, the anti-war movement, the history of journalism, historical representation, second-wave feminism, Australian historiography, and colonialism and gender. But delaying me most of all was the realisation that I had still a great deal of research and thinking to do. I especially needed to interview the Freedom Riders themselves. After interviewing one of them, Beth Hansen, during my ‘retracing tour’ in 1991, I realised that I could not be the interviewer of the rest. Beth was, naturally, too aware that I had been there too, finding it difficult to tell me about things she thought I would already know, and feeling wrong-footed if I asked about details of events that I remembered or knew about and she didn’t. With the aid of a grant from the University of Technology, Sydney in 1993, I hired Inara Walden to do the oral history interviews for me. As a much younger person—Inara had not been born at the time of the Freedom Ride, to the amusement of many of her interviewees—I correctly judged that the Freedom Riders would feel bound to explain things to her that they would find odd telling me. In the interviews, we concentrated on asking about the Freedom Riders’ strongest impressions, and eliciting a lot more about who they were, their background, how they got involved, and what they had been doing since. I did a great deal of other research as well,
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xx
xx
Freedom Ride
especially at the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies library; I also placed a letter in the Sydney Morning Herald (which yielded few, but valuable, replies), and one way and another collected vast quantities of material. Early in 1995 I moved from UTS in Sydney to the Australian National University in Canberra. This meant more academic administration and new, very demanding, teaching commitments, so my work on this book was seriously interrupted for several years. In the long run, however, the change proved to be valuable, bringing me into intellectual contact with a new group of Indigenous and non-Indigenous people who were also engaged in rethinking Australian history. I taught units on Australian Aboriginal history for the first time, working with Indigenous teachers where I could, and forcing myself to gain a wider understanding of the history to which I was attempting to contribute, submitting my ideas to the unblinking stare and close scrutiny only undergraduates can give. With additional small ARC grants, I was able to hire Lani Russell and Ann Genovese to help with the final phases of research, in the National Library, the Australian Archives, the Mitchell Library and the New South Wales State Records Office. I gave papers on the progress of my research to the ‘Gender and National Identity’ symposium organised by the journal Gender and History at the Rockefeller Centre at Bellagio, Italy, and the conference ‘Suffrage and Beyond’ in Wellington, New Zealand. Closer to home, I spoke to the Royal Australian Historical Society and the Australian Historical Association conference in Perth in 1994, presented a seminar on Indigenous Citizenship under the auspices of the Reshaping Australian Institutions Project at ANU in 1996, spoke to the Australian Oral History Association conference in Alice Springs in 1997, and presented papers to the History Division seminar at the Research School of Social Sciences at ANU in 1997 and 2001 and at Macquarie University in 1998 and 2001. After such a long gestation, I have many people to thank. I sincerely thank the funding bodies that supported me—the Australian Research Council, the University of Technology, Sydney and the Australian National University. I especially thank the four research assistants who worked on this project at various times—Kathy Moffatt, Inara Walden, Ann Genovese and Lani Russell. All were brilliant researchers and wonderful to work with. Many of the Freedom Riders helped by consenting to interview, and by donating to me documentary material;
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xxi
Acknowledgments
xxi
particular thanks must go to Aidan Foy, Barry Corr, Bob Gallagher, Brian Aarons, Charles Perkins, Darce Cassidy, Jim Spigelman, Louise Higham, Patricia Healy, Warwick Richards and Wendy Watson-Ekstein. Indeed, I thank all those—Freedom Riders and others—listed in the note on sources, who gave Inara or me their time in interviews. I also thank Frances Peters-Little for reading and correcting the Walgett chapters, and drawing for me an illuminating if eccentric map of the town. Others who over the years lent me material, passed on ideas and contacts, or discussed my ideas with me, and whom I wish to thank, include Andrew Markus, Barry Higman, Bert Castellari, Carol Johnson, Catherine Hall, David McKnight, Fiona Paisley, Georgine Clarsens, Gordon Briscoe, Heather Goodall, Jack Horner, John Murphy, Judith Keene, Kate Evans, Ken Buckley, Lyndall Ryan, Marilyn Lake, Nic Peterson, Paula Hamilton, Peter Read, Susan Magarey, Terry Fox, Tim Rowse, Tom Griffiths and Vicki Grieves. Special thanks to Brian Aarons and Pat Healy for reading the whole manuscript, correcting errors and discussing ideas, and also to Bain Attwood for reading and commenting on the first half of the book. Above all I thank the people in the Freedom Ride towns who gave so unstintingly of their time when I visited them in 1991, especially Harry Hall, Phillip Hall, George Rose and Gladys Lake in Walgett; Lyall Munro Snr in Moree; Tess and Vic Brill in Lismore; Bob Perry in Bowraville; and Bob Brown (formerly of Moree) in Port Macquarie. I have tried out my ideas for this project a number of times, and wish to thank the organisers and audiences at those events. I also thank my students in my Australian Aboriginal history classes at ANU and my Writing History classes at UTS and ANU, and the Grade 6 class at Lyneham Primary School (1998) whose interest and challenging questions spurred me on. I wish to thank my publisher John Iremonger, for giving me that extra push when it started to seem as if this project would never be finished, and for supporting this book so wholeheartedly, even through his own serious illness. Warm thanks are also due to my production editor at Allen & Unwin, Alexandra Nahlous, for her efficiency and support. ‘Aboriginal Charter of Rights’, by Oodgeroo of the Noonuccal tribe from My People, third edition, The Jacaranda Press, 1990, is reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Australia. I thank Bruce Petty, Martin Sharp, Gary Williams, Darce Cassidy,
Freedom Ride Prelims 27/9/02 10:39 AM Page xxii
xxii
Freedom Ride
Wendy Watson-Ekstein, the Search Foundation, the State Library of New South Wales, the Daily Examiner, the Macleay Argus, Honi Soit, the Fairfax Photo Library and News Limited for permission to reproduce cartoons and photographs. Finally, a special thank you to my late mother, Barbara Curthoys, who first interested me in Aboriginal rights and gave me valuable documentary material. I also thank my son, Ned Curthoys, and father, Geoff Curthoys, for being so interested and reading the entire manuscript and my husband, John Docker, for making detailed comments on the entire manuscript and whose continuing intellectual and personal support is incalculable.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 1
1
Chapter
‘Let’s have a Freedom Ride’
Y
ou can always start earlier in the writing of history, but I begin this story with a student demonstration for civil rights in the centre of Sydney on 6 May 1964. Held just nine months before the Freedom Riders set out on their remarkable journey from the University of Sydney’s graceful neo-Oxfordian quadrangle to the race-inflected towns of northern New South Wales, this demonstration—surprisingly, perhaps—supported the civil rights not of Indigenous Australians, but of African Americans. Perhaps it wasn’t so surprising. In their concern for racism overseas, the students’ actions were not unusual. Eminent anthropologist Bill Stanner had written a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald only four days earlier referring to that ‘mountainous fact of Australian mentality: that we are angered only by very distant racial wrongs’. Racial inequality was often understood more easily elsewhere than at home—at least in the imagination. Opposition to South African apartheid, for example, was growing rapidly at this time. After some large campus meetings, and a demonstration of thousands of students in Martin Place in Sydney in reaction to the shootings in Sharpeville in March 1960, there had been a lull in activity, though the Students Representative Council at the University of Sydney held remembrances of the event each year. Unlike British Prime Minister Harold Macmillan, who saw the Sharpeville shootings as ‘the turning point in the history of race relations’, and who recognised a ‘wind of 1
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 2
2
Freedom Ride
change’ blowing through Africa, Prime Minister Menzies refused to protest officially against apartheid to the South African government. His refusal was taken to indicate tacit support and was roundly condemned by the Labor opposition. An anti-apartheid movement slowly developed which sought to pressure the Australian government into a stronger stand. Leading white anti-apartheid campaigner John Brink arrived from Pretoria in 1961, and became the focus of anti-apartheid activity in Sydney. In 1963, students at Melbourne and Monash Universities protested against apartheid in front of the South African stand at the International Trade Fair in Melbourne, while Queensland university students demonstrated against the gaoling without trial of black activists in South Africa. The cricket tour by the South Africans in the southern summer of 1963–64 was greeted by demonstrations of students, trade unionists and others at airports and cricket grounds during Test matches, though these were tiny compared with the massive demonstrations that greeted the South African (Springbok) footballers eight years later. As knowledge of apartheid grew, students began to campaign in earnest. The trial of Nelson Mandela and others in Pretoria was sympathetically covered in student newspapers. Their national body, the National Union of Australian University Students (NUAUS), agreed in February 1964 to institute an anti-apartheid campaign. It would seek cooperation with churches and trade unions to pressure the federal government into a stronger stand against South Africa in the United Nations, and to implement a boycott of South African goods. The May demonstration that I’ve taken as the beginning of my story was, however, advocating racial equality not in South Africa but in the United States. Australian interest in and knowledge of US civil rights had been greatly increased a year earlier by reports of police violence against thousands of African Americans conducting peaceful demonstrations in Birmingham, Alabama. On 12 April 1963, Martin Luther King and Reverend Ralph Abernathy had been gaoled for marching in Birmingham in support of civil rights. Four days later, King wrote his ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail’, a profound statement on the goals and tactics of the civil rights movement; it was to become something of a manifesto for the Australian Freedom Ride less than two years later. Once King was released, the civil rights campaign was stepped up, and now involved teenagers and even younger children on a large scale. In response, Birmingham’s Public Safety Commissioner, T. Eugene ‘Bull’ Connor—a white
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 3
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
3
supremacist who routinely used physical force against civil rights activists—attempted to stop the marches on 3 May using police dogs and fire hoses at high pressure. As historian Robert Weisbrot tells it: Using fire hoses at a pressure set to take off tree bark, they blasted adults and children, the jet streams ripping their clothes and leaving them bloodied on the ground. Police swung nightsticks into skulls indiscriminately, and attack dogs set loose among the panicked crowd sank their fangs into three fleeing children. In America, graphic images had not accompanied earlier protests; now newspapers carried photographs of huge, snarling dogs lunging at black women and children. The images of dogs biting peaceful protesters, and of fire hoses, batons and fists being used against people seeking equal treatment in schools, restaurants, theatres and other public places shocked many and led to an outpouring of support for the civil rights movement. The Australian urban press, especially the afternoon and Sunday tabloids, carried similar images. Brian Aarons, who was to become one of the Australian Freedom Riders, remembered the images and their importance many years later: I can remember that in the US, when the Civil Rights Movement was being built up, led by Martin Luther King, there was a particular incident . . . where a police chief called Bull Connor had loosed the police dogs onto civil rights demonstrators and there were dramatic photographs on the front page of the Sunday papers . . . And there was a policeman with a dog—an Alsatian or German Shepherd—on a leash and the dog is biting or going for a black demonstrator. Brian had a good memory. The Sun, a Sydney afternoon tabloid, carried on its front page on 4 May a graphic photo of a dog, held on a leash by a policeman, biting a young black activist. It accompanied a story headed ‘Wild Dogs Turned on Negroes. Many children among victims’. Other papers, like the Sun-Herald on 5 May, carried similar images and stories. The Daily Mirror sent a journalist to the United States specifically to cover the riots and their aftermath. ‘What an affront to human dignity,’ it editorialised, ‘that the Negro demonstrations should be met with such brutalities as turning fierce Alsatian dogs on children, knocking men,
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 4
4
Freedom Ride
women and children off their feet with water from fire hoses, and charging demonstrators with batons.’ Brian Aarons and some others in the Eureka Youth League bought about 100 copies of the Sun-Herald, and used the front page as a poster to call a protest meeting. The Birmingham events, involving over a hundred thousand protesters and nearly fifteen thousand arrests, finally convinced the US President, John Kennedy, that the federal administration needed to intervene. He introduced a Civil Rights Bill to make it illegal to discriminate against black people in employment and places of public accommodation, enabling the US federal government to compel local school districts to desegregate, and affirming the right to vote in national elections. Soon afterwards, the massive March on Washington, on 28 August 1963, attracted up to a quarter of a million people, providing the occasion for King’s moving ‘I have a Dream’ speech, followed by the memorable singing together of the movement’s anthem, ‘We Shall Overcome’. The civil rights movement was clearly gaining strength. Australians knew about the growing American movement not only from extensive press coverage, but also from television. Two years earlier, Four Corners had pioneered a new style of documentary on Australian television, and the ABC carried reports from the BBC as well. Robert Raymond, who had just arrived at Channel 9 from the ABC’s Four Corners, produced as one of his first programs for Nine ‘The Negro Revolution’, to coincide with the March on Washington. According to his memoirs, Out of the Box, he assembled from the United States Information Service library ‘a visual history of black America, going back to slavery and the Civil War’. It used interviews with notable black and white Americans and the Bob Dylan song ‘Blowin’ in the Wind’, sung by a new folk group, Peter, Paul and Mary, for its musical theme. The program, Raymond accurately recalled, went to air in prime time (9.35 p.m.), only a few hours after the March on Washington took place. After President Kennedy was assassinated on 22 November 1963, his replacement, President Lyndon Johnson—to the surprise of many—took up the cause and sought to push the Bill through Congress. It was always going to be tough getting it through the race-conservative Senate. For several months, Southern Senators tried to defeat the Bill by filibuster. It needed a two-thirds majority to close the debate; once the Bill was put, it would require only a simple majority. There was to be a crucial vote on procedure on 6 May.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 5
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
5
May 6 happened also to be Commem Day at the University of Sydney, an annual university holiday commemorating the founding of the university in 1850, and marked since 1896 by a procession through city streets and collection of money for good causes. That year the good cause was the ‘South African Committee for Higher Education’, an expression of growing student anti-apartheid sentiment. Commem Day was also traditionally a time for student pranks. In 1963, for example, a group of students had ‘invaded’ one of Sydney Harbour ’s islands, Pinchgut, so named for the hungry convicts who had been kept in isolation there over a century earlier. One of them, Darce Cassidy, was dressed as Fidel Castro. Soon to become one of the Freedom Riders, Darce was from a wealthy North Shore background, and by this time was a member of the leftleaning Sydney University ALP (Australian Labor Party) Club. Now, in 1964, Darce and the others in the ALP Club decided Commem Day provided an excellent opportunity for a more serious action: a student demonstration outside the US Consulate in support of American civil rights. A leaflet was distributed in the morning, urging students to join the demonstration that afternoon. It began: ‘Would you like to be jabbed by an electric cattle prod? To be set upon by an Alsatian police dog?’ and went on to ask whether its readers would like to be ‘clubbed, imprisoned, lynched, castrated or burnt? You wouldn’t? Then you’re lucky you’re not black. These are the methods used by the white supremacists in the American Deep South.’ Today, 6 May, the leaflet went on, was the last day the Civil Rights Bill could be passed. All over the United States, ‘people are demonstrating in support of the Bill, and we should support them’. The ALP Club’s plan proved successful. The usual Commem Day procession took place without incident in the late morning, on a mild autumn day, with student floats passing through the city and students collecting about £2000 for the South African Committee for Higher Education. But this was to prove no typical Commem Day; a new spirit of rebellion and political awareness was in the air. At around 1.30 p.m., a large crowd (the press estimated it at 2000) gathered outside the US Consulate. Some were robed as Ku Klux Klansmen and set fire to a 10-foot (3-metre) wooden cross they had erected in the centre of the roadway. Darce Cassidy had brought the cross: ‘I had the cross (an old wooden clothes line wrapped in cloth and soaked in petrol) in the back of my car. We took it to Wynyard Street, sat it upright in a garbage can weighed down with bricks, and set it alight.’ About 50 students sat down on
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 6
6
Freedom Ride
Image rights unavailable
Students set alight a mock Ku Klux Klan cross outside the US Consulate in Wynyard, Sydney, to symbolise white racist opposition to the Civil Rights Bill before the US Congress. Daily Telegraph, 7 May 1964.
the roadway in a peaceful protest, while the rest watched. I was there, a second-year student, one of the watchers—a little apprehensive, as I remember. I would have preferred us not to challenge the police in this way. The students chanted: ‘We want the Consul.’ Police began arresting those sitting down, while other students tried to free them. The tussle developed, as the Daily Telegraph put it the next day, ‘into an all-in brawl’ between police and students. Twice police called for reinforcements, and with vastly increased numbers order was restored by about 2.30 p.m. Around 50 students and a Channel 7 cameraman, Richard McNicoll, were arrested; later, those aged under 17 were allowed to go. Newspaper coverage tended to focus especially on the young women being manhandled by police. One of them was Arts student Pat Healy, later to be one of the Freedom Riders. When interviewed in 1994, she recalled that this had been a key moment in her involvement with leftwing student politics. Although she had come from a well-known political family, her grandfather being Jim Healy, the former communist leader of the powerful Waterside Workers’ Federation, until this moment she had not been politically inclined. She recalled:
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 7
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
7
I just thought it was a good idea. Despite the fact that I hadn’t been involved politically I guess my ideas had been very much formed by my family. And I’d gone along and unfortunately I got arrested . . . I just happened to be on the edge when the police were sort of pushing things through and I think I turned around and said to a big burly copper ‘Don’t push me’, being a very sort of brash type. And he sort of grabbed me and I struggled and subsequently got charged with assaulting said policeman which was really pretty ridiculous because at that stage I was about a size 8 in clothes, I was very very small, and this copper was about 6 ft tall [2 metres] and made about three of me. The next day, hundreds of students gathered at Central Court to hear the charges. Twenty-five students were formally charged, and all but one pleaded not guilty to their various charges of offensive behaviour, resisting arrest, using insulting words and obstructing police. Among them was another student who was later to join the Freedom Ride: John Powles, a fourth-year medical student. John was already a seasoned political activist, having helped establish the Humanist Society on campus, become a member of the Council of the New South Wales Humanist Society, and been involved in the university anti-nuclear movement. At the court, the ALP Club distributed a leaflet in support of the arrested students, saying ‘it is tragic that Australian students seeking to support the civil rights of others should have their own civil rights brutally abused’. Image rights unavailable The leaflet called on the unions to demand that the charges be withdrawn. The university’s Students Representative Council swung into action. Its president, Michael Kirby, also the student representative on the University Senate and later to become a High Court judge, called a A female student is arrested. meeting of all those arrested and Daily Telegraph, 7 May 1964.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 8
8
Freedom Ride
anyone who had witnessed or photographed the arrests to assist with legal representation. Ken Buckley, a senior lecturer in Economic History at the University of Sydney, and secretary of the recently formed Council for Civil Liberties, stressed the right of students to protest and not be pushed around by police. A few days later, Richard Walsh, better known for his editing of the controversial Oz Magazine at this time, edited a special supplement of the University of Sydney student newspaper Honi Soit on the arrests and the subsequent campaign in the students’ defence. The defence campaign was highly successful: of those whose charges were proceeded with, ten were acquitted outright, five had the offence proved but the charge dismissed under the First Offenders’ section of the Crimes Act, and just six were fined, of whom at least two had their appeals upheld. Meanwhile, in the United States itself, students were pleased to learn, the Senate voted on 10 June to close off the Southern filibuster, thus making way for the passing of the Bill a week later and its presidential signature on 2 July. The Commem Day protest raised not only the issue of the rights of protesters, but also some other very disturbing questions. Why, many people began to ask, were university students so prepared to demonstrate for civil rights in the United States, when they should be campaigning against racism in Australia itself? Brian Aarons remembers that ‘the point was made, both in private conversations I recall and also publicly, that all this was done for the rights of black people in America but nothing had been done about . . . you know, what were we doing about Aboriginal rights’. This was especially true of overseas newspaper comment, which was directed both at the notorious ‘White Australia’ immigration policy and the question of Aboriginal rights. The Ceylon Observer carried a commentary on 10 June headed ‘Strange Reactions’, which thought the students’ demonstration for US civil rights ‘must surely have brought guffaws and giggles from any who gave these reports a second glance’. It continued: For this is the one country into which no human being is permitted if the pigment of his skin has acquired even the slightest shade of colour—be it brown, yellow or black. We ‘coloured’ folk in Ceylon can even go to the U.S. and make it our home and be discriminated against, if we so choose. But Australia? Very definitely NO . . . These demonstrators . . . would have done well to look around their own
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 9
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
9
homeland and probe the complete LACK of coloured neighbours. If these demonstrators cared to look a little further and deeper, they would have come across as nauseating a form of social hypocrisy in their own backyards as that they were demonstrating against. I refer to the treatment of the Australian Aborigines. There was also commentary in the United States itself. The demonstration had been covered in the American press, the New York Times reporting on it on 7 May under the heading ‘Sydney Students Riot Against US: Battle Police at Consulate in Protest on Segregation’. The American Life magazine commented: ‘Students in Sydney have just rioted against racial prejudice—in the US! Conveniently overlooking the fact that Australia herself possesses some of the most stringent racial exclusion laws in the world.’ Honi Soit reprinted the Life comment, sent to it with a letter from Charlie Pyatt III, an African American in San Francisco. His letter, also published in Honi Soit, first thanked the students for their support: ‘News of your sympathy demonstration reaching our shores caused America to look with silent embarrassment (including Negroes)’, then mentioned the Life magazine comment, and went on to ask: ‘If you cannot deny this, and if your concern was sincere, profound and genuine, I ask you most humbly, most appreciatively, can you find the sympathy in your hearts and consciences to conduct PEACEFUL demonstrations against these laws in your own country?’ Within Australia, many people also commented that the students should have been protesting for the rights of Aboriginal people. One letter published in the Sydney Morning Herald on 11 May, from Mrs R. Schodde, was particularly telling. After noting that students had also held demonstrations against the visiting South African cricketers when they were on tour, she wrote: The motives behind these demonstrations may be admirable, but in the midst of their righteous indignation these students seem to have completely forgotten the plight of the Australian aboriginal. It is a relatively simple thing to join a crowd shouting slogans condemning discrimination in other countries and deluding themselves that they are championing the cause of coloured people. It is quite another thing to help our underprivileged aborigines in a constructive way . . . How many of Tuesday’s demonstrators have ever mixed with an aboriginal
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 10
10
Freedom Ride
socially? How many would invite an aboriginal to their homes? Or how many of those students would contemplate marrying an Australian of coloured blood? Only when all Australians stop treating the aboriginal as a second-class citizen and accept him into the white society without reservation can our student groups protest against racial discrimination in other countries without seeming hypocritical. Criticisms like these hit home. What, indeed, had the students been doing in support of the campaign for Aboriginal civil rights? For, though there was truth in the claim that white Australians were more likely to deplore racism abroad than at home, there was in fact an active Aboriginal rights campaign in existence. Politically diverse and multi-racial, it sought full citizenship for Aboriginal people, taking up a range of issues from around the country as they came to light, often in the less ‘settled’ regions of northern and western Australia. Key figures in these organisations were frequently Christians, anthropologists, or from the Left. Leading Christians in the Aboriginal movement included Charles Duguid, a Presbyterian minister in Adelaide known for his writing and activism on behalf of Aboriginal people, the Reverend Frank Engel, the secretary of Division of Mission of the Australian Council of Churches, and Barrie Pittock, a Quaker. Duguid’s book No Dying Race, published in 1964, became a key text for the growing Aboriginal movement. Both Engel and Pittock were becoming prominent advocates of Aboriginal land rights, influenced by travels and knowledge of the situation in the United States and New Zealand. Anthropologists like T.G.H. Strehlow, Donald Thompson and A.P. Elkin were also influential, in various ways given their very divergent politics. T.G.H. Strehlow’s book White and Dark Australians, his printed lecture ‘Assimilation Problems: The Aboriginal Viewpoint’, and Elkin’s books such as The Australian Aborigines: How to Understand Them (1938) and Aborigines and Citizenship (1960) were all part of the reading of concerned citizens in these years. Also important were the voices of a growing number of Left-liberal intellectuals, including historians like Brian Fitzpatrick, who included a chapter, ‘Disinherited Australians’, in his The Australian Commonwealth (1956), and Ken Inglis, who wrote a book on the case of Max Stuart (an Aboriginal man unfairly tried for murder) in 1962. In January 1962, Aboriginal Affairs, an independent and voluntary association to stimulate thoughts on subjects concerned with Aboriginal
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 11
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
11
welfare and advancement, was established in Melbourne. From April that year, it published a bi-monthly news-sheet, On Aboriginal Affairs, edited by Ian Spalding, which provided in-depth information and analysis on a regular basis. The Communist Party of Australia (CPA) was especially active on Aboriginal rights, its influence so great that it was beginning to cause concern in some circles. The Party had taken Aboriginal issues seriously since its inception in the early 1920s, and continued to do so through the succeeding decades. Before World War II, the communists had seen Aboriginal issues through the framework provided by the international communist body, the Comintern. This rested on a distinction between tribalised peoples, who were seen to have the rights of national minorities, and detribalised people, for whom equal citizenship rights were appropriate. This view was restated at its sixteenth congress in August 1951, under the heading ‘Safeguard the Native Races’. From 1954, however, influenced by a change in international communist policy, the CPA more or less abandoned its former distinction between tribal and detribalised peoples, and took up the Aboriginal cause with a new intensity. Communist policy now emphasised the exploitation of Aboriginal people as workers, and sought to establish the unity of all Aboriginal people in different parts of the country in a common struggle for full citizenship. Aboriginal matters were given high priority, with leader Sam Aarons calling for CPA members’ commitment in the Tribune, the party’s newspaper, on 19 January 1955. From then on, the communist press consistently gave a great deal of publicity to Aboriginal issues, publicising examples of prejudice, drawing attention to Aboriginal activism such as strikes and anti-eviction protests, and encouraging Aboriginal membership. The priority given to Aboriginal rights by the CPA flowed into the various organisations over which it had influence. One was the Union of Australian Women, a nationwide communist-led women’s organisation which from 1958 adopted and actively pursued the CPA interest in Aboriginal rights. It sought to include Aboriginal women in its own ranks, and had succeeded in doing so for some years, with prominent Aboriginal members including Pearl Gibbs and Dulcie Flower in Sydney, Gladys O’Shane in Townsville and Gladys Elphick in Adelaide, until it became clear that Aboriginal women preferred to form their own organisations. In unions with Communist Party leadership, support for Aboriginal rights
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 12
12
Freedom Ride
stepped up from the mid-1950s, notably in the Waterside Workers’ Federation, which attracted a number of Aboriginal members, the Sheetmetal Workers Union, led by long-time pro-Aboriginal campaigner Tom Wright, and the two building workers’ unions, which also had some Aboriginal members. New organisations developed in the 1950s focusing specifically on Aboriginal rights—or, as it was more commonly put at the time, advancement. In New South Wales, Aboriginal activism had a long history of opposition to the surveillance of the Aborigines Welfare Board and its predecessors. The Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship was formed in 1956 by Pearl Gibbs and Faith Bandler, and had a mixed Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal membership, many of its members being close to the Communist Party. One of its Aboriginal leaders, Bert Groves, left in 1958 and in January 1964 he was one of those who formed a new group, the Aborigines Progressive Association (APA), a title reviving that of an earlier organisation of the late 1930s. Unlike the Fellowship, the APA’s constitution ensured the dominance of Aboriginal people in the organisation (unless married to an Aboriginal person, others could only join if nominated by an Aboriginal person and accepted by a majority of members at a general meeting). There were mixed-race organisations also in other states and territories, notably the Coolbaroo League in Western Australia, the Council for Aboriginal Rights in Victoria, the Aborigines Advancement League in South Australia, and the Northern Territory Council for Aboriginal Rights. These organisations frequently drew attention to the situation of Aboriginal people by pointing out how far Australian practice diverged from the principles enunciated in the United Nations Declaration on Human Rights of 1948, which Australia had signed. A decade after the Declaration, Aboriginal rights remained extremely limited everywhere, with restrictions on freedom of movement, control of property and freedom of association with Europeans. Only if one had an ‘exemption certificate’ could equal rights be granted. In Queensland and Western Australia, there were government controls over marriage and Aboriginal people did not have the right to vote in elections. There were restrictions on the right to drink alcohol in all states except Victoria. Throughout the country, town councils and businesses practised various forms of exclusion of Aboriginal people from town amenities, and employment inequality was rife. Aboriginal people were moved on and off reserves
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 13
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
13
without reference to their basic right to freedom of movement. More starkly, in the outback regions of the country, Aboriginal people were exploited—sometimes brutally. In most parts of the country, authorities removed Aboriginal children from their families, from a strange mixture of genocidal intent (by which I mean a desire to ensure that Aboriginal identity was extinguished) and welfarist concern for neglected children. In 1957, veteran campaigner Mary Bennett’s book, Human Rights for Australian Aborigines, drew attention to these practices, and to how different they were from the UN principles which Australia itself had supported. Yet international censure and opprobium did not matter a great deal to state governments, whose focus was far more local. Aboriginal rights activists had been arguing since the 1930s that there would only be substantial gains when the Commonwealth government, more susceptible than state governments to international opinion, took responsibility. Commonwealth governments, however, left Aboriginal affairs largely to the states, and responded to pressure to take action by arguing that their hands were tied by the Constitution. There were two relevant clauses. Section 51 provided that the Parliament had the power to make laws with respect to ‘the people of any race, other than the aboriginal race in any State’, and section 127 excluded Aboriginal people from the census. When Jessie Street, well-known Australian feminist and supporter of human rights now living in London, returned to Australia in 1956–57 to investigate the situation for the British-based Anti-Slavery Society, she found governments citing the Constitution as the reason for Commonwealth inaction. She concluded that the Constitution must be changed to establish Commonwealth control, which she saw as essential for the framing of an appropriate national response to the UN Declaration, and to facilitate meeting Australia’s local and international obligations generally. Faith Bandler and others in the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship took up the idea, and a campaign for a Referendum for constitutional change began in earnest. Leaders of the state-based Aboriginal rights organisations around the country began to move for a national body to coordinate their campaign for constitutional change and for a new national government policy. The Federal Council for Aboriginal Advancement (FCAA) was accordingly formed in February 1958, and campaigned energetically on a wide range of issues.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 14
14
Freedom Ride
Accompanying the growing campaign domestically was an increased level of criticism internationally, just as the Aboriginal rights campaigners hoped and Australian governments feared. Australia was deeply concerned by attacks by Soviet leader Krushchev in the United Nations on its Aboriginal record. The meeting of the UN General Assembly on 13 October 1960 is often remembered as the occasion on which Krushchev pounded his desk with his fists and brandished a shoe to emphasise his objections to the rulings of the UN president. Yet it was also the occasion when the Assembly supported Krushchev’s motion to debate a declaration of independence for colonial peoples. Accusing Australia of having exterminated her Aboriginal population, Krushchev said: ‘Everyone knows in what way the aboriginal population of Australia was exterminated.’ With racial discrimination becoming an embarrassment internationally, the Commonwealth was forced to take some action, despite its supposed lack of relevant powers. In fact, the Commonwealth government had been attempting to develop some common policies and approaches through meetings of Commonwealth and state Ministers of Aboriginal Affairs, with a landmark meeting in 1937, followed by another in 1951. These did not provide for the citizenship rights and freedoms that many activists in the 1930s had wanted, but they did progressively develop policies of inclusion and assimilation rather than exclusion and segregation. A Commonwealth Parliamentary Select Committee to Enquire into Aboriginal Voting Rights was established in 1961; one of its members, Kim Beazley Snr, was to be profoundly influenced by its deliberations and remained a strong parliamentary voice for Aboriginal rights thereafter. As a result of the Select Committee’s report presented on 19 October 1961, the Commonwealth government removed discriminatory features from its own legislation—for example, extending the franchise to Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory in 1962, a move followed by both Queensland and Western Australia. Through all this, there was concern about communist influence in the expanding Aboriginal movement. The growing emphasis in the movement on autonomy rather than assimilation was interpreted in a detailed ASIO report in 1962 as the result of communist influence, in line as it was with international communist policy for minorities. At a meeting of the Trusteeship Council of the United Nations in June 1963, the Soviet delegate confronted the Australian delegate with section 127 of the Constitution as evidence of discrimination against Aborigines. Yet
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 15
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
15
unwelcome scrutiny was coming not only from the communist world. International pressure greatly intensified with the adoption on 20 November 1963 of the UN Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. It not only reaffirmed the principles contained in the UN Charter and the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, but also affirmed the necessity of ‘speedily eliminating such discrimination, in any form, throughout the world and of adopting national and international measures to that end’. Henceforth, governments were not only urged by the United Nations to cease all practice of racial discrimination themselves, but they were also expected to work to eliminate it from their society altogether. Senior public servants serving on an InterDepartmental Committee on Racial Discrimination, formed in response to the changing UN situation, secretly agreed in March 1964 that ‘there was an urgent need to remove, as far as practicable, instances of racial discrimination in Australia in order to ensure that Australia’s international reputation and influence are not to be seriously endangered’. Equally troubling for the Australian government was increased pressure from the International Labour Organisation (ILO). The payment of lower wages to Aboriginal pastoral workers was directly in contravention of ILO Convention 107 on the employment of Indigenous people, passed in 1957. The FCAA took this issue very seriously, with one of its leaders, a white Communist Party member named Shirley Andrews, compiling for its 1962 annual conference a detailed report revealing the widespread payment of low wages, especially in the pastoral industry in the Northern Territory, Queensland and Western Australia, and the restricted employment opportunities in Victoria and New South Wales. When the Australian delegation to an ILO conference in 1963 realised that the Aboriginal wages question might receive critical ILO scrutiny, the Australian Council of Trade Unions was galvanised into action, passing a resolution in favour of equal pay for Aboriginal pastoral workers at its Congress in September 1963. Soon after, the Equal Wages for Aborigines Committee of the FCAA headed by Andrews conducted a public campaign on the matter, widely distributing a pamphlet, The Facts on Wage Discrimination Against Aborigines. Kim Beazley Snr proposed in Parliament on 8 April 1964 that Aboriginal workers in the Northern Territory cattle industry be paid award (equal) wages, and a long and well-publicised debate ensued. The Referendum campaign was rapidly gaining ground. Beazley
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 16
16
Freedom Ride
initiated an urgency debate in the House of Representatives on 30 August 1962, calling for a Referendum on section 51. A public meeting in Sydney a few weeks later, on 6 October, launched a national petition, eventually taken with 40 000 signatures by an Aboriginal delegation to the Prime Minister.57 The Labor Party continued to campaign on the issue, with Arthur Calwell, the leader of the Labor opposition, moving unsuccessfully in the House of Representatives on 15 April 1964 for a Referendum to remove both racially discriminatory clauses from the constitution. Students were not quite yet part of this growing public protest and debate. When they protested publicly about racial policies within Australia itself, they had nearly always been concerned with immigration rather than Aboriginal policy. Several developments made them keenly aware of overseas opposition to the ‘White Australia’ policy. Student organisers attending overseas conferences found Australia’s reputation as a racist society deeply embarrassing. More importantly, on campuses around the country—especially at the universities of Melbourne, Sydney and Queensland—the considerable number of Asian students entering the universities under the Colombo Plan or privately put paid to older ideas about Asian intellectual inferiority, and facilitated feelings of friendship towards Asian people generally. At the newly opened Monash University, the first student demonstration in October 1961 was a picket, along with students from the University of Melbourne, of the West End Private Hotel in Melbourne for refusing board to three Nauruan women ‘simply on the grounds of colour ’. Students carried placards reading ‘Ban the White Australia Policy’ and ‘Racial discrimination is immoral’. Shortly afterwards, a meeting of about 800 students at the University of Melbourne formed Student Action, which mobilised hundreds of students in protest against the ‘White Australia’ policy during the federal election campaign of November 1961. Both Menzies and Calwell made angry attacks on the students, and Student Action became front-page news, attracting generally negative newspaper reports and editorial comment. Over the next two years, the student campaign against the ‘White Australia’ policy continued. Student Action groups appeared in Sydney and Brisbane in 1962. Sydney University students demonstrated outside the Immigration Department in Sydney in January that year in support of three Portuguese seamen threatened with deportation by the Menzies government; the day before, students from the University of Queensland had staged a similar demonstration outside the Immigration Department
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 17
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
17
offices in Brisbane. In April, more than 250 students at Melbourne and Monash Universities and at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology marched in protest at the action of the Immigration Department in deporting Mr Willie Wong; by September, Queensland students were picketing a hotel for its refusal to serve beer to an Indian and two African students. A key figure in the New South Wales branch of the Association for Immigration Reform was Ken Rivett, a lecturer at the University of New South Wales. The School of Economics at Rivett’s university had several active members of the association, including Bill Ford, soon to become a key figure in the Freedom Ride story. Darce Cassidy joined the committee of the association and began to write articles and speak to meetings about the need to abolish the ‘White Australia’ policy. The Students Representative Council at the University of Melbourne put pressure on the National Union of Australian University Students (NUAUS) to adopt a policy of clear opposition to the ‘White Australia’ policy. NUAUS agreed, after its own survey in 1963 of a random sample of its members in all ten universities and the university colleges in Townsville and Newcastle showed that almost 70 per cent of students nationwide favoured liberalisation of immigration policy, with Monash students being most in favour at 84 per cent and Townsville University College students least so, at 52 per cent. Very slowly, student interest in Aboriginal issues did develop, though less among the political radicals than among students simply interested in helping fund scholarships for Aboriginal people to attend university. In 1950 and again in 1951, NUAUS had urged the state governments that ‘greater educational facilities be made available for Aboriginals’. In 1952 it agreed to sponsor a scholarship scheme for Aboriginal students, providing an establishment grant of £1300 and requesting the Students Representative Councils in each university to set up local appeal committees, with Melbourne acting as a central organising committee. Jennifer Crew, director of the scheme in 1955, presented a complete report and wanted to broaden NUAUS’s Aboriginal policy beyond scholarships, but it refused. Plans for a scholarship scheme gradually became a reality: in 1957 Melbourne University agreed to act as trustee and the first two scholarships were awarded, though neither student graduated with a Bachelor’s degree. Abschol committees at a number of universities were formed, and raised funds through appeals to schools and private industry, button days, film showings and concerts. The University of Sydney made Abschol its
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 18
18
Freedom Ride
charity for its annual Commem Day collection in 1961. By August 1964, there were Abschol committees or directors in most universities, including the University of Sydney. Students in the Abschol branch at the University of Sydney raised money through an annual collection, and also through lunch-hour entertainment shows featuring artists such as Jimmy Little and Tony Morrison. In May 1964, at the time students were being criticised for doing so little for Aboriginal rights, Abschol was sponsoring a visit to the university of 42 Aboriginal children from the Sydney area. Abschol had little involvement in public political debate on the broader questions of Aboriginal rights. In 1963, however, with Margaret Valadian (an Aboriginal university student at the University of Queensland) as director, it persuaded NUAUS to agree to a motion requesting the state governments to take action to deal with problems preventing ‘Aborigines as a group from participating in or gaining benefit from education’. The following year, NUAUS passed a motion urging the Commonwealth government to call a Referendum to change the Constitution. These were still small steps, and on the whole NUAUS and Abschol remained aloof from the growing Aboriginal rights movement. Abschol was, however, starting to achieve its aims of assisting Aboriginal students to attend university. In 1963, scholarships were awarded to students of Aboriginal descent, at the Universities of Sydney (going to Charles Perkins and Gary Williams, both of whom enrolled in Arts) and Queensland (Margaret Valadian and Image rights unavailable Betty Anderson, both in Social Studies). It held a national conference in May 1963, and by mid-1964 its national funds exceeded £11 000. Charles and Gary’s presence at the University of Sydney was to change both them and the Gary Williams, left, and Charles Perkins, university forever. Gary, born in right, at the University of Sydney on their Mullumbimby in Bundjalung first day as students, March 1963. (Photo courtesy of Gary Williams) country (his father’s country),
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 19
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
19
grew up in Nambucca Heads, in Gumbaynggirr country (his mother’s country). His family, he told me in interview, had a history of resisting white authority, having opposed segregation of the picture theatre in the town, and fighting hard against children being taken away (and if they were taken and then made their way back, making sure they were not taken again). His schooling had been at the Aboriginal school on the reserve, then a convent school, from which he won a bursary to attend Woodlawn College in Lismore. After he completed the Leaving Certificate in 1962, he was welcomed at the start of the university year in 1963 at St John’s College, having just turned 17. Sydney for him was a much wider world than he had ever known, and through his uncle, Clive Williams, he met the growing network of Aboriginal activists. Charles Perkins, by contrast, was already an experienced political leader. His story has been told in detail a number of times, including his autobiography, A Bastard Like Me. This book is notable not only for the story it tells but also because, appearing in 1975, it was one of the first of a long line of such autobiographies, one of the main means by which Aboriginal people have communicated their individual and community experiences to a wider non-Aboriginal audience. Peter Read’s Charles Perkins: A Biography also tells his story well. Born in Alice Springs in the Northern Territory in 1936, of Arrernte and Kalkadoon descent, he had gone to school in Adelaide (‘I failed seven out of eight subjects in the final year at Technical School in Adelaide, so I was no academic giant’ he told me), played soccer for several English teams in 1957–59, and then became a noted public speaker for Aboriginal rights in Adelaide, being elected vicepresident of the FCAA in 1961. Charles came to Sydney in late 1961 or early 1962, where he played soccer for the Pan-Hellenic team, met a range of Aboriginal and nonAboriginal activists, and in particular struck up a friendship with Methodist minister Ted Noffs. Noffs’ first posting in 1951 had been as a Methodist pastor at the Far West mission at Wilcannia, where he had become close friends with many Aboriginal people, observed the dire conditions under which they lived, and developed respect for their spiritual beliefs. He had spent time in the late 1950s in Chicago, doing his Master’s degree in Theology, and had been influenced by racial politics there. On his return to Australia, he became associate minister of the Central Methodist Mission (CMM) in Sydney, and used its welfare agencies to assist the growing urban Aboriginal population in inner
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 20
20
Freedom Ride
Sydney. He wrote in The Methodist at this time: ‘One of the most explosive social questions facing Western society today is that of race.’ He outlined its importance in South Africa, the Deep South of the United States and in London, and reflected on the future of European relationships with the Aboriginal people of Australia. ‘Have we,’ he asked, ‘reached a point of no return so far as the building of a bridge between the cultures is concerned?’ His answer was no, given the emergence of Aboriginal–European committees throughout the nation ‘aimed at building new and better relations’. There was also, he thought, ‘a growing recognition throughout the country of the significance of the culture that the aborigine people represent’. He drew his readers’ attention to a new factor in Aboriginal affairs—the large numbers of Aboriginal people forsaking the fringe dwellings and reserves in country towns for the cities. The time had come, he said, to offer assistance, though ‘aid must never again be given patronisingly or in the form of welfare handouts’. Ted Noffs now arranged for Charles to speak at public meetings under the auspices of the CMM, and one of these speeches at the Lyceum Theatre was so successful that Noffs realised a new Aboriginal leader was emerging. He was also important in supporting Charles’s desire to go to university, encouraging him to study for his matriculation through the Metropolitan Business College. Charles did, and finally arrived at university in 1963 at the age of 27. Although he was not the only Aboriginal student, Gary Williams having started at the same time, he was to become the most visible on campus. When my research assistant, Inara Walden, interviewed Charles in November 1994, he told her: I was very pleased when I walked through the gates of Sydney University, and I thought ‘This is it’. I knew that something was going to happen as a consequence of me going through there, personally and in Aboriginal Affairs, because the fire in the belly was well and truly alight by then . . . and things were going to happen. I was going to make them happen. And I was very determined but I didn’t know what to do really, but the subjects I chose were really tuned into what I wanted to do later on, for example Anthropology I, II and III, Political Science I, II and III, the other two were Psychology and Social Theory or Sociology. So I was training for the future. In May 1964, Charles’s political activity was still more off campus
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 21
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
21
than on. He was closely involved in plans to provide some kind of welfare and social support for the growing number of Aboriginal people in Sydney, who had migrated to the city in search of work. By this time there were about 6000 Aboriginal people in Sydney, and public discussion of their needs was growing. The year before, on 3 May, the Labor Lord Mayor, Harry Jensen, had chaired a well-attended public meeting from which had emerged the Aboriginal Affairs Association, aiming to assist Sydney’s Aboriginal population. Its committee included Noffs as chair, Perkins and Ken Brindle (an influential Aboriginal Sydney man) as vicechairmen, and Bill Geddes, Professor of Anthropology at the University of Sydney, as treasurer. Geddes was a New Zealander who hoped to achieve some of the same closeness between the university and Indigenous students that he had witnessed in Auckland, and readily made the Department of Anthropology’s facilities available for the early meetings of the association. Just five weeks before the students’ May demonstration for US civil rights, a well-publicised general meeting of the association had been held in the Anthropology lecture room. The committee undertook fund-raising, found a property in lower George Street which would be suitable as a cultural, social and welfare assistance centre, and at a meeting on 1 July changed the name of the society to the Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs and agreed to purchase the building. Student protest meetings on Aboriginal issues were still rare. One of the first was at the University of Melbourne in mid-1963, when its ALP Club held a meeting on the proposals to disperse the Aboriginal community at Lake Tyers, the last remaining Aboriginal reserve in Victoria. Gordon Bryant, president of the Victorian Aborigines Advancement League, drew students’ attention to a range of injustices, such as the fact that Aborigines on the reserve could not be visited without the permission of the Aboriginal Welfare Board. Clyde Holding described the slum conditions, the low wages and the forcing of families away from the settlement. Pastor Doug Nichols, a Victorian man of Djadjawurung and Yorta Yorta descent, a preacher in the Church of Christ and noted Aboriginal political leader, also spoke, asking that Lake Tyers be retained. The national student body, NUAUS, began to take a much stronger and more openly political position on Aboriginal issues when Robert McDonald, who had been one of the leaders of Student Action in Sydney, became its president. At its Annual General Meeting in March 1964, just two months before the Wynyard demonstration, McDonald publicly
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 22
22
Freedom Ride
criticised the federal government’s refusal to guarantee its support for the rights of Northern Territory Aborigines, and ‘its unwillingness to take adequate steps towards elimination of discriminatory practices’. Noting the principles established by the United Nations, he urged the government to ‘make an immediate and unequivocal declaration of its support for what are basic human rights’. The meeting supported the ongoing campaign to eliminate the two discriminatory clauses in the Constitution, and ‘laid down a comprehensive program for student action on aboriginal affairs in 1964’. NUAUS sent two observers to the FCAA annual Easter conference in Canberra, to consider affiliation and to learn more about Aboriginal organisations and issues generally. Although NUAUS decided not to affiliate at this stage, the basis had been laid for new lines of communication between students and off-campus organisations for Aboriginal rights. Perhaps goaded into action by the criticisms of the May demonstration, members of the Labour Club at the University of Sydney urged the national conference of the Australian Student Labour Federation, the umbrella body for the Labour and ALP Clubs around the country, to organise a protest on ‘the treatment of Aborigines’ on National Aborigines Day in July 1964. This was a day that had begun in 1957 as a government attempt to publicise its assimilation policies, but had gradually been taken up as a focus for campaigning by Aboriginal rights organisations. By 1964, the day had extended to a National Aborigines Week. A fairly small demonstration was held in Melbourne, when about 200 students displayed placards and distributed leaflets headed ‘Australia’s Disgrace’, first in a march around a large city block and then on the steps of Parliament House. They moved to nearby gardens for a rally, addressed by the state leader of the opposition Mr Stoneham and Clyde Holding, the state ALP spokesman on Aboriginal affairs. A much larger demonstration was held at the same time at the University of Sydney. In June 1964, several students formed a committee called the ‘Sydney University Organising Committee for Action on Aboriginal Rights’ to organise action around National Aborigines Day on 8 July. The committee consisted of three students who were later to join the Freedom Ride—John Powles, Hall Greenland and myself (as treasurer)—plus the student and folk singer Jeannie Lewis and another student, Christopher Sweeney, who was active in the Civil Liberties Association; both Jeannie and Christopher had been arrested in the May
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 23
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
23
demonstration at Wynyard. Hall Greenland was a second-year Arts student and a member of the university’s ALP Club, while I, another second-year Arts student, was a member of the communist-influenced Labour Club. Louise Higham, a first-year medical student who was soon to become one of the Freedom Riders, was also involved in organising the demonstration as a member of the Labour Club. She wrote to the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, letting them know about the proposed demonstration on 8 July, and seeking information about reading material ‘we could sell on the bookstall the Labour Club will be opening in the near future’. This committee organised a public meeting and concert in Hyde Park, in the centre of the city, with substantial student support. Jeannie Lewis helped arrange the folk singers, Hall Greenland wrote on behalf of the ALP Club to the trade unions to raise funds for financial support, while I wrote on behalf of the committee to the university’s clubs and societies with the same request. I remember helping to write and produce the leaflet, a copy of which I still have. It was signed by the committee, and supported by a range of clubs and societies including Abschol, the ALP Club, the Anglican Society, the Civil Liberties Association, the Education Society, the Humanist Society, the Jewish Students Union, the Labour Club, the Newman Society, the Students’ Christian Movement, and the Students Representative Council. It was headed ‘Mass meeting today—Demonstration tomorrow’, and then ‘Poor bloody Abos!’ (What, quite, were we thinking?!) It went on: 150 years of persecution, extermination, indifference, prejudice, discrimination, paternalist ‘welfare’ policies and sheer neglect have left the original Australians as a depressed racial minority. This abhorent [sic] situation is ignored by a complacent society. The community’s conscience MUST be awakened by protest action. This has succeeded in the USA—it could do so here. The leaflet advertised a meeting at the university that day, 7 July, with speakers Senator Lionel Murphy, Ron Hancock (of the BWIU, a director of Tranby College and a former member of the FCAA) and the Reverend Alf Clint. Murphy, who nine years later became Attorney-General in the Whitlam Labor government of the 1970s, spoke of the Queensland Act that restricted Aboriginal people’s freedoms—in, for example, handling
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 24
24
Freedom Ride
their own money, choice of marriage partner, and deciding where to live. He drew attention to the discriminatory clause in the Constitution that meant Aborigines were not counted in the census, and the fact that the government had recently rejected Arthur Calwell’s attempt to have the offending clause removed. Ron Hancock outlined trade union support for Aboriginal people, mentioned the ACTU taking up the issue of Aboriginal wages the previous year, and drew attention to a recent incident in Walgett where two 9-year-old children had been locked up over night for taking two table tennis bats, two balls and a packet of crayons, an incident we return to in detail later in this story. The Reverend Alf Clint, an Anglican priest with strong socialist convictions who had first developed cooperative enterprises in Papua New Guinea and subsequently persuaded the Australian Board of Missions to support the development of cooperatives in Aboriginal communities, spoke about the success of the cooperative movement. The leaflet also advertised a peaceful demonstration for the following day at Parliament House. Students were urged to ‘make your placards (or “police-proof ” smocks) tonight’. The themes were to be:
Equal Rights here * End Legal and Social Discrimination now * Equal Opportunities for Aborigines * Education for Aborigines Students responded, with about 500 attending the rally-cum-concert in Hyde Park and the demonstration outside Parliament House, designed to give publicity to the legal and social discriminations against Aborigines. At the Hyde Park event, Gary Shearston sang a number of freedom songs from America, as well as songs written by the Aboriginal poet Kath Walker, later to be known as Oodgeroo. One song, I remember, was a musical rendition of her poem ‘Aboriginal Charter of Rights’, first presented to the 5th Annual General Meeting of FCAA in Adelaide held over Easter 1962. It went: We want hope, not racialism, Brotherhood, not ostracism, Black advance, not white ascendance: Make us equals, not dependents.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 25
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
We need help, not exploitation, We want freedom, not frustration; Not control, but self-reliance, Independence, not compliance, Not rebuff, but education, Self-respect, not resignation. Free us from a mean subjection, From a bureaucrat Protection. Let’s forget the old-time slavers: Give us fellowship, not favours; Encouragement, not prohibitions, Homes, not settlements and missions. We need love, not overlordship, Grip of hand, not whip-hand wardship; Opportunity that places White and black on equal basis. You dishearten, not defend us, Circumscribe, who should befriend us. Give us welcome, not aversion, Give us choice, not cold coercion, Status, not discrimination, Human rights, not segregation. You the law, like Roman Pontius, Make us proud, not colour-conscious; Give the deal you still deny us, Give goodwill, not bigot bias; Give ambition, not prevention, Confidence, not condescension; Give incentive, not restriction, Give us Christ, not crucifixion. Though baptized and blessed and Bibled We are still tabooed and libelled You devout Salvation-sellers, Make us neighbours, not fringe-dwellers; Make us mates, not poor relations, Citizens, not serfs on stations. Must we native Old Australians In our land rank as aliens?
25
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 26
26
Freedom Ride
Banish bans and conquer caste, Then we’ll win our own at last. Oodgeroo of the tribe Noonuccal Delegates from an International Student Seminar held the week before at the University of New South Wales attended. The seminar had been organised after Australia was rejected as a venue for the International Student Conference (ISC) because of its racist immigration and Aboriginal policies, with New Zealand chosen instead. Some of the ISC delegates were invited to Australia after the conference. From Malaysia, the United Arab Republic, Israel, Hong Kong and India, they spoke in support of any move to end racial discrimination in Australia. Charles Perkins also spoke, outlining numerous discriminations against Aborigines, including the fact that they were not counted in the census. ‘We rightly protest against the racial discrimination in South Africa and the USA,’ he said, ‘but we also have the same problem in Australia. We don’t want charity, just give us the freedom and opportunity to lift ourselves.’ Gary Williams again drew attention to the gaoling of the two 9-year-old Aboriginal boys at Walgett. As Honi Soit reported of the speeches by
Image rights unavailable
Students demonstrate for Aboriginal rights outside Parliament House, Macquarie Street, Sydney, 7 July 1964. (Photo by Michael Elton and reproduced with permission of the Australian Photographic Agency collection, State Library of New South Wales)
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 27
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
27
Charles and Gary: ‘Both speakers said Aborigines wanted to integrate into society, but not to be completely assimilated. They said that their people wanted to retain their culture etc. but to still live as ordinary citizens without discrimination.’ After the rally, the students moved from Hyde Park along Macquarie Street to state Parliament. They chanted slogans and sang songs, holding placards and banners depicting such themes as ‘End Discrimination Now’, ‘Civil Rights Now’, ‘Civil Rights for all Australians’, ‘Education for Aborigines’ and ‘You’re right if you’re white’. They distributed a pamphlet headed ‘Are You a Racialist?’ asking ‘Do you condone the existing discrimination against Aborigines?’ and drawing attention to the discriminatory clauses in the Constitution, the gross denial of civil rights in Western Australia and Queensland, and the fact that Aborigines had no land rights on their reserves. Even in New South Wales, where there was less legal discrimination, the pamphlet pointed out that there were examples of discrimination, including the locking up of the two Walgett children and the exclusion of Aborigines from the artesian baths and swimming pool— a popular tourist attraction—in Moree. The pamphlet concluded with the demand that: 1. The Commonwealth government remove Section 127 and the discriminatory words in Section 51 by holding a referendum at an early date. 2. The State governments abolish legal discrimination in their respective states. 3. The people of Australia do all they possibly can to end discrimination against Aborigines. The protest was notable for the lack of a police presence, its peaceful nature, and generally positive publicity. SRC president Michael Kirby said the demonstration aimed to draw parliamentary backbenchers’ attention to discriminatory clauses in the Australian Constitution, and to get the state government to support scholarships for Aboriginal students. After the meeting, I (as treasurer) wrote to various clubs and societies seeking financial contributions to offset the costs of the demonstration. Having achieved its immediate objective, this committee faded away, and a new organisation with a new leadership developed in its place. Although very active in the July demonstration, I was not involved in the developments and events of the next few months that I now relate.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 28
28
Freedom Ride
I’ve pondered possible reasons—personal, political, my studies—but in the end, I simply cannot remember why I vanish from this story until February 1965. After the National Aborigines Day demonstration, and the establishment of the foundation, Charles was beginning to look for a new way of organising student action for Aborigines. In later years, he was well aware of the importance of his presence to the development of Aboriginal politics on campus: ‘I played my part in terms of bringing the Aboriginal element into it.’ He met with several others to discuss the foundation of a more permanent student organisation for Aboriginal rights. One was Labour Club student Brian Aarons. It was a combination that might seem surprising, given Charles’s suspicion of communist influence in the Aboriginal movement, and Brian’s role as a communist student. It could not have happened at the University of Melbourne, where the communist students had been excluded from Student Action. Charles in fact seems to have been unaware of Brian’s communist connections, and the two got on very well; they joined up with several other students and staff to call a meeting at the university for 20 July to discuss what forms of action students could take in support of Aboriginal campaigns for equality. Also involved in calling the 20 July meeting were two of the academics at the University of Sydney. One was lecturer and Council for Civil Liberties secretary Ken Buckley; another was Peter Westerway, a lecturer in Government. Peter had a particular interest in politics and the media, and was much influenced in this by Henry Mayer, a pioneer of Australian media studies whose foundational text The Press in Australia appeared that same year. Although he had recently moved to the position of executive producer of the investigative Channel 7 television program Seven Days, Peter still maintained a teaching role at the university. He had a clear interest in covering Aboriginal issues on Seven Days, having aired a program called ‘The Australian Aboriginal and his Future’ on 9 July, during National Aborigines Week. This covered the issues and activities of Aboriginal people in Sydney, and also on Palm Island in Queensland. It explored the formation of the Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs, and included a panel discussion featuring Bill Geddes, Charles Perkins, Michael Sawtell—an 80-year-old former bushman who had been involved in Aboriginal rights organisations and the Aborigines Welfare Board—and Allan Duncan, an adult education teacher much involved with Aboriginal education. The other two names on the list of those calling the meeting
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 29
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
29
were Peter Martin, a reporter on Seven Days, and Kevin Martin from the Students Representative Council. These six collectively distributed a leaflet to 29 clubs and societies on campus. They explicitly addressed the troubling issues raised by the Commem Day demonstration: ‘This was fine as far as it went, but what now? How can we show our sympathy and support for our own coloured minority, the Aborigines?’ They asked all clubs and societies to ‘appoint two representatives of your club to attend a meeting in Gosper rooms 1 and 2, at 1 pm, to consider the matter’. At this point, the leaflet said, there was a range of options to consider: a) more demonstrations in the city; b) collections, voluntary labour, e.g. Abschol or the new Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs centre at Central; c) a long vac demonstration continued over 2–3 weeks, e.g. ‘freedom rider ’ buses in northern NSW and Queensland, and d)??? suggestions welcomed. The contact person was Peter Westerway. This was the first mention of a possible Freedom Ride in print. The idea of demonstrations or voluntary assistance was by now familiar, but how did the idea of ‘freedom rider’ buses get on to this list? It seems that Charles first pondered the idea of an Australian Freedom Ride after a conversation with Peter Westerway. Peter remembers his contact with Charles Perkins when he delivered a lecture in mid-1964 to a Government class at which Charles was present: It was in the Old Geology lecture theatre, one of those cantilevered lecture halls, and I was talking about politics and the media. I remember that the major point that I was making was that television was critical, and radio was now less important than it had been, and that if you wanted to do anything about television you had to be talking in terms of pictures. Without pictures it didn’t work. And that’s all I remember having said. The reason I remember it is that after the lecture was finished Charlie stayed behind and said to me what could he do about publicising the Aboriginal cause. And I remember we were sitting in the body of the lecture hall, not down at the lecture podium, and I repeated this stuff about pictures and said, ‘Look, television’s all about short grabs, you have to be able to
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 30
30
Freedom Ride
see interesting pictures or they won’t use it. They only use things which they have pictures to illustrate. Talking heads are dead on television.’ And we began to talk and I think I suggested about the Freedom Rides in the United States and the way in which that had been done. And as I was talking it occurred to me that there was no reason why you couldn’t do something similar in Australia and I said to him, ‘If you get together a group of people who will go on a bus ride around what has come to be called the Deep North of New South Wales, I suppose I’ll send a camera crew with you. And we’ll do a documentary and put it on Seven Days.’ The US Freedom Rides to which Peter Westerway drew Charles’s attention had occurred three years earlier, in the northern summer of 1961. Indeed, the term Freedom Ride is even older—having been used, for example, in Jamaica in 1957 to refer to a procession of 4000 city cyclists who rode miles through city streets and lanes in ‘joyful celebration’, as Public Opinion, the local newspaper, put it, of the removal of a tax on their bicycles. One cyclist carried a banner saying ‘freedom ride’, and the newspaper reporter, Jervis Anderson, took the word ‘freedom’ seriously: Like the cyclist whose bicycle was appropriately bannered, they were on a real ‘Freedom ride’, for like many of our forefathers who were born in shackles, many hundreds of them for the first time in their lives were going to be allowed to ride throughout Jamaica without having to pay for it. It seems likely that the term was around even earlier. The aim of the US Freedom Riders in 1961 had been very specific: to challenge segregation on interstate buses and in interstate bus terminals. The original thirteen Freedom Riders, seven black and six white, had gone in two buses from Washington to New Orleans via Alabama, and more buses had travelled soon after from Birmingham to New Orleans via Jackson, Mississippi. When they encountered racist violence at Anniston and Montgomery, Alabama, and at Jackson, Mississippi, the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) had organised buses of Freedom Riders from different parts of the country to converge on Jackson. More than 300 Freedom Riders had been arrested, and their cases were heard from August onwards. The Freedom Rides had provided dramatic headlines in several
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 31
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
31
ways: the joint action of black and white students; the racist violence they encountered; and their success in achieving their immediate aims. After the Freedom Rides, the Interstate Commerce Commission issued a regulation prohibiting segregated bus facilities. The commitment to a Civil Rights Bill, though, would have to await the shocking events in Alabama two years later. Australians knew of these Freedom Rides through the mass media— press, radio and television. The attacks in Anniston and Montgomery, Alabama and the violence and gaoling of Freedom Riders in Jackson were well covered. Newspaper reports emphasised the hostility of the whites, the Sydney Morning Herald reporting on 26 May 1961: ‘Highway patrolmen, troops in helicopters, National Guardsmen with fixed bayonets, and local police with savage dogs on leashes kept angry white crowds away from the “freedom riders” when they arrived from Alabama.’ Although the coverage was overwhelmed by the much more extensive coverage at the same time of one of Australia’s great murder mysteries—the Bogle– Chandler deaths on New Year’s Eve in 1960, and the inquest through May 1961—Australians did know about the US Freedom Riders and the violence they had encountered. They related the term Freedom Ride less to the specific idea of desegregating transport facilities than to the more general notion of a racially mixed group of students travelling by bus, confronting and drawing attention to segregationist practices so publicly that these practices had to end. The 20 July meeting attracted a dozen people, those present signing their names on a list. They were: Charles Perkins, Jim Spigelman, Brian Aarons, Colin Bradford, Robert Gallagher, John Powles, Beth Hansen, Eric Doldissen, Brian Jardine, Judith Mahony, John Russell and Bill Ford. The first seven of these later became Freedom Riders. We’ve already met Charles, Brian and John Powles. Jim Spigelman was an especially significant addition to the gradually forming group. The surviving written records reveal just how important his organising role was soon to become. He was a second-year student enrolled in Arts/Law, a member of the Labor Party and the university’s ALP Club. Beth Hansen, an Arts student, was a member of the Humanist Society and came along with her boyfriend John Powles; she was to become very important to the new organisation. Colin Bradford and Bob Gallagher were both friends of Brian’s in the Labour Club. The meeting canvassed several options for action, but it was soon
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 32
32
Freedom Ride
clear that a Freedom Ride on the American model was becoming the favoured plan. Bill Ford, a lecturer in the School of Economics at the University of New South Wales, spoke to the group about his experiences with Freedom Rides in the United States. He had won a Fulbright scholarship in the late 1950s and studied at the University of Illinois. Later, at the University of California in Los Angeles, where he worked as a research assistant at the Institute of Industrial Relations, he developed a close friendship with Bob Singleton, an African American who was a local leader of CORE and led the Freedom Ride from Los Angeles to Jackson, Mississippi in the summer of 1961. Bill remembers that ‘when they went off in the summer of ’61 and were gaoled, I flew to Jackson, to be with my friends at their arraignment. It was an incredible experience attending the mass meeting, the courtroom drama.’ Now he spoke to the meeting about the Freedom Rides in the United States, ideas of non-violent protest, and the possibility of doing something similar here. Ford had a history of interest in Aboriginal issues, having met Charles Duguid in Adelaide before he went to the United States. Beth Hansen says of this meeting: ‘The start of it for me was Bill Ford, and some blonde woman that was with him . . . She and or him had been to the States and had some connection with the Freedom Ride there, and they came out and gave a talk at one of the lunchtime meetings. That is my memory of where the idea started.’ A committee was formed, consisting of Charles Perkins, Jim Spigelman, Beth Hansen and Eric Doldissen (who did not, in the end, go on the Freedom Ride). Attracted to the idea of a Freedom Ride, and hoping for a larger attendance, the group called another meeting in the MacCallum Room for Friday, 31 July. Clubs and societies were again urged to send representatives. The group produced a leaflet reporting on the idea of a Freedom Ride, and the importance of publicity about discrimination against Aborigines: ‘While our initial impact on the country towns and aboriginal settlements is likely to be short lived and therefore possibly ineffective, it is hoped that student action of this kind will draw public attention to the problem.’ Publicity was the main focus, and the leaflet also announced that ‘Peter Westerway will be leaving the University soon to become Director of Public Affairs at ATN Channel 7. He would like to send a camera crew along with the bus to film a documentary for ATN.’ The meeting on 31 July was much larger. It seems to have been moved from the MacCallum Room to the much bigger Old Geology lecture
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 33
‘ L e t ’s h a v e a F r e e d o m R i d e ’
33
theatre. Again Bill Ford spoke about the American Freedom Rides and the possibility of doing something similar in Australia. Warwick Richards, a politically interested student in the Students’ Christian Movement, and later to become one of the Freedom Riders, remembers the meeting well. He was struck by the breadth of political views represented there: There was an intention to form an organisation that would be broadly representative of the different religious, political and philosophical points of view at the university. So each of the religious groups was invited to participate, all the political factions, sects and parties and a number of them did. Obviously the right wasn’t directly involved but the communists, the Labour Club, the various Trotskyite factions . . . there were a number of Jewish students who were involved, there were Christians . . . It was intended to unite students and essentially to combat racism and to right social wrongs. Pat Healy remembers it too: The things I remember were a large meeting in one of the large lecture theatres at Sydney U, that Bill Ford, who had been in the USA on— might have been a Fulbright scholarship or something like that—and he had been involved in the civil rights struggles. And he got very enthusiastic and very involved and he gave a talk about it. And I know that after that a lot of people were sort of saying: ‘We should do something like that in Australia.’ Brian Aarons remembers that: There was this very big meeting, it would have been probably 300, where a guy called Bill Ford who had recently come back from America . . . he spoke at this meeting and very sharply raised the question about—‘Well, you’re doing these things for the black movement in America, what about here?’ . . . I think he’d been deliberately invited by the organisers of the meeting to talk about how the civil rights movement worked, and out of that came the idea for a Freedom Ride. Charlie Perkins used to say to me for years afterward that just after that meeting—I think it was the same afternoon, or it may have been a day or two later—he and I and a fellow called Barry
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 34
34
Freedom Ride
Corr were talking about what had come up at the meeting and as I recall it Charlie said: ‘Well, are we going to organise a Freedom Ride?’ and we all said: ‘Well, yes we are, that’s what we’re going to do.’ The decision had been made. There would be a Freedom Ride.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 35
2
Chapter
Getting ready
O
n the evening of Friday, 12 February 1965 a white touring bus stood at the front of the University of Sydney’s historic main building. Begun in 1855 and completed in 1862, the large twostorey sandstone building had a good view over the city. Well-kept lawns swept down to busy Parramatta Road, the main artery to the suburbs of the west and beyond. Twenty-nine students waited with their bags and suitcases and rolled-up sleeping bags to get on board and start their journey. Second-year medical student Aidan Foy remembers that ‘there was some sort of banner at the front or along the side’, and photographs and film footage show a large banner inscribed ‘Student Action for Aborigines’ along the side of the bus. It did not say ‘Freedom Ride’, a term the students had come to see as somewhat patronising. They called it simply the ‘SAFA bus tour’. Only one of the students—Charles Perkins— was Aboriginal; a second, Gary Williams, would join later. There was also on the bus another Aboriginal man, Gerald (or Gerry) Mason, a lay preacher and an older friend of Perkins’s from Gerard government reserve in South Australia, one of the better-funded reserves in the country. Gerry was a gentle and rather conservative man who, it later emerged, had had no idea this bus tour had a political purpose. The composition of the group would change slightly as the tour went on, with five students joining later, one changing her status on the trip from ‘student’ to ‘journalist’, and three leaving before the end for a mixture of personal, work-related and political reasons. The students ranged in age from 35
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 36
36
Freedom Ride
18 to 29, with most about 19 years old. Of the 34, eleven—or about a third—were women, a gender ratio roughly reflecting that of the student population at the university as a whole at that time. There was a short farewell ceremony. Beth Hansen remembers the ‘send off, with Ted Noffs’s blessings, from the university grounds, Noffs on the steps of the bus’. I remember this too. Darce Cassidy, on tour not only as a student but also as a reporter for ABC radio, recorded the farewell. From this point until the major conflict in Moree, he recorded everything indefatigably. A program he made from the tapes still survives, providing us now with a remarkable record of the voices, ideas and people associated with the Freedom Ride. We can still hear Reverend Ted Noffs’ travellers’ prayer: Almighty God we thank thee that thou hast given us life and liberty in this great land Australia, and we ask now that thy blessing will rest upon these Australians as they journey out as they endeavour to bring reconciliation and healing among people who have been divided because of the colour of their skin . . . Give them travelling mercies and give them, we pray, that word that will be a word not only to the people of Australia, but perhaps a word to the people of the world of our concern and of our love for people no matter what the colour of their skin may be. So go with these young people we pray and bless them in all that they seek to do. And these things we ask in the name of Jesus Christ Our Lord. Amen. In retrospect, Noffs’s mention of ‘reconciliation’ and ‘healing’ is remarkable for prefiguring much subsequent politics on Aboriginal issues. Yet it is worth noting that, while the students appreciated this blessing and support, probably less than half were Christians; the rest were a mix of atheists, agnostics and Jews. As one of the atheists, I remember feeling distinctly uncomfortable. Aidan Foy, whose family was ‘traditional Irish, Labour, Catholic’, remembers that he’d ‘never actually heard a Protestant praying in public before, I remember that’. Then, on a quite different note, a group of visiting Black American folk song and dance performers from the ‘Go Tell it on the Mountain’ stage company sang songs in farewell. They were by no means the first African Americans to support the Aboriginal cause. Forty years earlier, a group of visiting Black American seamen had attended the Australian Aborigines Protection
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 37
Getting ready
37
Association conference in Sydney, and only four years before the Freedom Ride, in November 1960, Paul Robeson had visited Australia for an eightweek tour of Darwin, Brisbane, Melbourne, Adelaide, Perth and Sydney, as well as towns in New Zealand. His four concerts in the Sydney Town Hall, where he sang ‘folk songs of many countries, Negro Spirituals, popular songs’, had made a considerable impact, and he became— famously—the first performer at the half-built Sydney Opera House, singing to the building workers. He had supported the Aboriginal cause at a reception in his honour at Paddington Town Hall organised by the New South Wales Peace Committee and the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship; it was attended by 1500 people, of whom about 30 were Aboriginal. Listening to the recording today, it is hard not to be moved by these African American voices singing on a February summer evening in support of a Freedom Ride in Australia: We shall overcome, we shall overcome We shall overcome some day. Oh deep in my heart, I do believe That we shall overcome some day. And with that, soon after midnight, the bus with its load of students drove off into the night. It had been a hectic six months between the decision and the setting out. A new organisation had been formed, a constitution drawn up, publicity arranged, an itinerary worked out, and over 30 students attracted to and prepared for the trip. It was a remarkable feat for a group of people who were mostly still too young to vote. Yet they had a confidence distinctive to their generation—a sense of innovation and adventure. Only a few weeks before, the Rolling Stones had visited Sydney, and seven months earlier the Beatles had made their historic visit, rapturously received by youth all over the country. The music somehow expressed the mood of the age group and the time. This was a generation that produced a New Left beyond earlier Cold War certainties of either the self-congratulation of the ‘free world’ or the rigid authoritarianism of communism, interested in challenging consciousness as well as social structures and institutions, and as concerned with issues of ‘race’ (and within a few years ‘gender ’) as those of class. In the process of forming itself, this generation both inherited many loyalties, political and
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 38
38
Freedom Ride
religious, from their parents, yet in the end had a curious lack of respect for the authority or wisdom of their elders. They—we—were no longer to be dutiful sons and daughters. The large meeting on 31 July which resulted in the decision to hold a Freedom Ride had occurred shortly before the end of second term, and there was a lull in SAFA activity during the four-week vacation. In that time, however, student action on Aboriginal issues was greatly enhanced when NUAUS held an Aboriginal Affairs conference on 17, 18 and 19 August, using the broader term ‘Aboriginal Affairs’ to denote a new extension of its interest beyond the traditional concern with providing scholarships. Three of the scholarship students—Charles, Margaret Valadian and Betty Anderson—attended, along with 21 other students. Papers were delivered by three people experienced in Aboriginal activism—Alan Duncan on education, Shirley Andrews on legislation and Barry Christophers (another communist activist in the Aboriginal movement) on wages and employment. Over 100 motions were passed, including a suggestion for a tutorial scheme for Aboriginal students (such schemes became widespread in the 1980s and 1990s), the holding of work camps to build facilities or provide services requested by Aboriginal people themselves (these work camps became popular during the mid-1960s and later), support for the FCAATSI Referendum campaign to remove discriminatory clauses from the Constitution, more local control in Aboriginal communities, making Aboriginal people ‘aware of their rights as regards copyrighting of arts and artifacts, Aboriginal ritual and cultural activities in general’, and many other issues. Student interest in Aboriginal issues was rapidly rising. When third term started on 7 September, plans for a Freedom Ride went ahead. The name of the new organisation was settled—it would be Student Action for Aborigines (SAFA)—and a constitution was adopted at a meeting in the first week of the new term. The name was a clear derivation from the Student Action groups that had opposed the ‘White Australia’ policy a few years earlier. The objectives of Student Action for Aborigines, as stated in the constitution, were quite modest, and well within the equal rights perspective of the existing Aboriginal movement. They were: 1. to arouse public attention, especially within the University, to fundamental Aboriginal problems in health, education, housing, etc;
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 39
Getting ready
39
2. to break down social discrimination barriers to the extent possible by student action; and 3. to stimulate the interest of Aborigines in improving their situation within society. Office bearers were elected. Some continued from the meeting at the end of second term: Charles Perkins as chair; Jim Spigelman and Beth Hansen as co-secretaries; and Eric Doldissen as treasurer. Jim rapidly became a key figure in the organisation. Born in Sosnowiec, Poland on New Year’s Day in 1946, he had come to Australia with his family in 1949, and by this time his father owned a jewellery shop at Circular Quay. At Sydney Boys’ High School he had been disturbed by the lack of support for the Asian Colombo Plan students in contrast to that for an American exchange student, and had complained to the headmaster (‘that’s because of my Jewish background more than anything else . . . I’m sure it came from my Jewish background that racism had a very high salience’). To these four main office bearers were now added John Powles as vicepresident and Pat Healy as publicity officer. A committee of six was formed, with Colin Bradford, who had been at the initial meeting, one of its members. Colin had migrated from England with his parents—his father was a bricklayer and his mother a typist—when he was three years old, and he was now a second-year Science student, active in the Labour Club. Another member, Chris Page, would also go on the Freedom Ride. The son of a left-wing North Shore doctor, Chris was now a second-year medical student. Four members of the committee did not go on the Freedom Ride, including Margaret Hall and Anglican Society student David Sloper. One of the other committee members was David Ellyard, another Anglican and chair of the Students’ Camp Association, sponsored by the New South Wales Christian Youth Council, which had just organised the second annual camp for Aboriginal and European high school students in Lane Cove, Sydney. He was an important figure in SAFA, though he did not join the Freedom Ride. Now, with its name, constitution and structure in place, the new organisation went into full swing. SAFA’s first task was to agree that the Freedom Ride would indeed be a bus trip to racially discriminatory towns. Warwick Richards remembers ‘a number of meetings at the university that were planning it and there was a lot of discussion: “Should it be a bus or should we take cars?” and there were a number of people who had
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 40
40
Freedom Ride
various views about how that ought to be done.’ Its next task was to gather together enough students. Jim Spigelman wrote an article for Honi Soit on 24 September, describing the new organisation, its aims and its decision to conduct a ‘Freedom Ride’ in order to attract publicity, and asking any student sincerely interested in participating to give his or her name and address to SAFA. Publicity became a major activity of the new group, partly because that was a main aim of SAFA and partly to raise enough funds to hire a bus. In a leaflet distributed to the media on 14 September, SAFA announced its aim of arousing public attention to Aboriginal disadvantage, and its chosen method of a bus tour around country towns in northern New South Wales during February. In addition, the leaflet announced, students would undertake a social survey to back their protest with statistical information on housing, wages and so forth. While it is not clear just when and how the idea of a survey arose, it is likely that Pam Beasley, an anthropologist who conducted a survey of Sydney Aboriginal people for the Foundation, may have had an influence. The survey was strongly supported by Ted Noffs and the Christian clubs on campus, who were concerned that there was insufficient knowledge of actual conditions in country towns; Noffs may also have been a little apprehensive that radical action might have negative effects on the Aboriginal people in the targeted towns. The survey, the leaflet announced, would cover housing, education, health, employment, social welfare and racial attitudes among both Aborigines and whites. SAFA’s media release was effective. Three days later, the Sydney Sun carried a story, ‘A Bus Ride to Freedom’, which featured a photograph of Charles Perkins and reported that students ‘will go in mixed parties to hotels, picture shows, milk bars and swimming pools which, they believe, discriminate against aborigines. The Freedom Riders will then buy tickets, call for drinks or order meals for the whole party, aborigines as well as whites. Their plan is strictly non-violent.’ The Sydney Daily Mirror, the Australian and the Sunday Telegraph all picked up the story, while Eric Baume interviewed Charles Perkins on radio. There was some mixed response in letters to these newspapers, with one letter to the Sunday Telegraph suggesting that ‘Aboriginal people are quite happy with things as they are, the Freedom Ride would just stir up trouble’. As a result of this media coverage, Charles Perkins received supportive letters and some donations from individuals, like Dorothy May, who said,
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 41
Getting ready
41
‘I am with you all the way, though financially I cannot help much (encl. 10/-) I will help in any other way that I can . . . Here’s luck to your campaign.’ Mr T. Frawley congratulated SAFA for ‘taking the initiative in this very just and much needed movement and to wish you every success in your aims’. One letter from Boronia, Victoria, offered best wishes: ‘This action has long been needed to highlight the fact that we have racists in our country, who by intention or ignorance, are hampering the integration of Aborigines.’ The story was picked up interstate—for example, in the Hobart Mercury—leading Eleanor Brinton to write approvingly to Charles: ‘It is quite time somebody did something about race relations in this country. We do not have the problem in Tasmania as the first white settlers apparently shot most of the original inhabitants or drove them into the cold part of the country where they could not survive.’ Some of those already involved in Aboriginal rights issues were a little concerned at the announcement of a Freedom Ride. Ian Spalding, editor of On Aboriginal Affairs, sent a telegram to Jack Horner of the AAF on 18 September: ‘Please consider prevailing upon Charles Perkins have Freedom Riders survey discrimination scene before seeking notoriety and alternative deterrent stop force entrench difficulties some localities. Ian.’ He followed this with a letter on 30 September, saying that when he first heard of the move he was worried about it, since there was no way of knowing from the newspaper reports ‘how well considered the whole project was’. He applauded student interest in social discrimination, but was concerned that ‘the repercussions could be so great, damaging, and even ineffective unless made to fit the needs’. His own view was that discriminatory practices could be removed ‘by quite short and rational negotiation which leaves no bad odour’. Media stories of Aboriginal disadvantage and lack of basic civil and human rights continued to appear. The Australian on 30 September carried a feature story by Jock Marshall headed ‘Color Bar!’ which emphasised Australian governments’ poor record in Aboriginal affairs. A week later, the Australian published a letter from Jim in response to this story, which told its readers about the Freedom Ride, the survey, the interest television stations had expressed in covering the trip, and the fact that SAFA had received several donations in response to the Australian’s earlier article. The students were hoping, he said, for more donations towards the cost of chartering a bus. Jim’s letter generated another group of letters and
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 42
42
Freedom Ride
donations. Jean Culley, from Port Melbourne, wrote in support saying ‘to my mind this is a tremendously important task you have all set yourselves, and from my rather limited experiences of racial intolerance will need a good deal of courage and level headedness’, and enclosing a cheque for £5, a substantial sum. Marion Hellier wrote from Surfers’ Paradise, saying: ‘Such a “fresh” approach should do much towards awakening a lethargic public. The several worthwhile organizations who have been working to assist the Aborigines do not gain the all important publicity which this “freedom ride” should do. I wish your mission success and am enclosing a small donation.’ Margaret Langford wrote from Belfield, in Sydney, enclosing a cheque and expressing her doubts about the assimilation policy: I feel that the Aboriginals might be happier if they could evolve a way of life to suit themselves . . . I feel that they should be assisted to work out their own salvation independently of the white community. In the process, we might even learn to work out ours! I hope that your ‘freedom Ride’ will be successful: problems cannot be tackled until their precise nature and extent are revealed. Above all, I hope that the Aboriginals themselves will form an organisation to look after their own interests. The ideas behind the Freedom Ride continued to develop as the months of preparation went by. The common political philosophy binding this diverse group of students together was the idea of nonviolent direct action, its inspiration in a very direct sense the US civil rights movement. The SAFA publicity leaflet had been quite explicit: ‘Such student action has worked well in the USA, we have to make it work here.’ In his article in Honi Soit that same month, Jim Spigelman had said: ‘We intend to adopt appropriate methods of passive resistance.’ The notion of non-violent direct action, he explained, was modelled on the Student Non-Violent Co-ordinating Committee in the United States, which had ‘achieved so much in the Negro struggle for civil rights’. Another leaflet printed just before the bus set off said: ‘The team has been largely patterned on the concept of the Freedom Riders who were involved in programmes of integration in the United States.’ And indeed the tactic of non-violent action had good claims to effectiveness. Since the students’ demonstration in May, Congress had
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 43
Getting ready
43
passed the Civil Rights Act. It had not, however, ensured the right to vote, and in the months just passed—May to July—nearly one thousand volunteers had gone to Mississippi to participate in the ‘Freedom Summer’, designed to register blacks to vote and establish ‘Freedom Schools’ for black Americans. It is little wonder, then, that the Australian students were impressed by the idea of non-violent direct action as a means of pursuing a campaign for racial equality. It seemed to be working. Of all the American civil rights literature, the most influential by far on the Australian students was that written by Martin Luther King. SAFA was especially interested in his letter from Birmingham City Jail, and reprinted a condensed version from an American journal, The New Leader, which had published it in full on 24 June 1963. In the reprint, it became ‘Our Struggle’, and anyone going on the Freedom Ride was encouraged to read it. Aidan Foy remembers that ‘we all had a pamphlet, in advance, of Martin Luther King’s speech “Our Struggle”’. The organisers also encouraged the Freedom Riders to read the full text and ‘a vivid description of the events surrounding it’ in Martin Luther King’s latest book, Why We Can’t Wait, available from the Pocket Bookshop in Sydney. It would make ‘ideal light after-exam reading’. ‘Our Struggle’ makes fascinating reading today. Written on scraps of paper with a pen smuggled into King’s cell in Birmingham City Jail in Alabama in 1963, it was an impassioned response to criticism from churchmen who accused him of creating tension between blacks and whites. In this letter, King argues against gradualism and for immediate, direct, non-violent action. The purpose of direct action, he writes, is ‘to create a situation so crisis-packed that it will inevitably open the door to negotiation’. King goes on to say, in reply to clerical critics who said the time was not yet ripe for such radical action, that: Freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed. Frankly I have never yet engaged in a direct action movement that was ‘well timed’, according to the timetable of those who have not suffered unduly from the disease of segregation. For years now I have heard the word ‘Wait’. It rings in the ear of every Negro with a piercing familiarity. This ‘wait’ has almost always meant ‘never’ . . . I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negroes’ great stumbling block in the stride towards
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 44
44
Freedom Ride
freedom is not (the White Citizens’ ‘Counciler ’ or) the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to ‘order’ than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says ‘I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I can’t agree with your methods of direct action’; who paternalistically feels that he can set the timetable for another man’s freedom. Beth Hansen also remembered this pamphlet, and it made a lasting impression: There was the quote about how what was worse than the Ku Klux Klan sort of people were the white middle class, the ones who set a timetable on other people’s freedom. It’s just a quote that’s hung in there forever . . . the other Martin Luther King quote was ‘creating a constructive crisis’. King concluded his letter with these words: We will reach the goal of freedom in Birmingham and all over the nation, because the goal of America is freedom. Abused and scorned though we may be, our destiny is tied up with the destiny of America. One day the south will know that when these disinherited children of God sat down at lunch counters they were in reality standing up for the best in the American dream and the most sacred values in our Judeo–Christian heritage, and thus carrying our whole nation back to great wells of democracy which were dug deep by the founding fathers in the formulation of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. No black Australian—or indeed white Australian—had ever written quite like that, nor believed that the goal of Australia was freedom. Yet the sense of a contrast between conventional Australian notions of democracy, equality and fair play on the one hand and the continuing reality of racism on the other was sufficient for King’s oratory and ideas to have resonance in a country very different from his own. Jim Spigelman wanted to learn more about the US Freedom Rides of 1961—how they had been conducted, and what lessons the Australians
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 45
Getting ready
45
might learn from them. In December he wrote to the US Consulate in Sydney seeking the addresses of several American civil rights organisations—the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE), the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC), and the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee (SNCC). The consulate wrote back several days later with the first three addresses, but was unable to trace the address of SNCC. Jim wrote to all three, and received a reply from Bobbie Knable, the community relations officer for CORE, who replied rather briefly: The Freedom Rides in the southern part of the United States were made on public buses. The riders were both Negro and white. Their purpose was to show, by example, to what extent violence and intimidation were used to enforce local segregation laws. Somehow, Jim also found SNCC’s address, and received a reply on 16 January 1965, which was not especially helpful: ‘We do not have the specific kind of information available which you need.’ The SNCC people, however, did suggest that Jim read Jim Peck’s Freedom Ride, an eyewitness account, and that he look at some of the American periodicals of the time; they also enclosed a copy of their publication The Student Voice. I don’t know if Jim or the others did get hold of a copy of Peck’s Freedom Ride (it would not have been easy, as this was an American book and Australian book distribution was then closely tied to Britain), but if they had they would have read an exciting narrative of the quite dangerous 1961 Freedom Rides. Peck was one of the white Riders, who was subject to vicious attacks by white supremacists in Birmingham when a group of black and white students attempted to enter a whites-only waiting room at the bus station. A photo of his bandaged head appeared in newspapers and on television screens around the world, including in the Australian papers. His story was a warning, both that white desegregationists could be hated even more than their black counterparts, and that non-violence could be met with violence. SAFA also had access to some more direct information about the US Freedom Rides and civil rights movement. At the end of the year, it again invited Bill Ford to address it, as well as Sondra Silverman, a radical American then studying at the Australian National University for a doctoral thesis on political movements, comparing the US civil rights
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 46
46
Freedom Ride
movement, the British anti-nuclear movement and the Australian labour movement. The SAFA newsletter explained that ‘they were involved in the “Freedom Rides” in the USA and we look forward to further cooperation with them’. Bill and Sondra told the students about non-violent protest techniques, and gave them some American publications. While there is no record of what Sondra said that day, the thesis on which she was working distinguishes between ‘non-violent direct action’ and ‘passive resistance’. The former derived its ideas from Gandhi, and its essential element was its ‘refusal to sanction cooperation with what is regarded as evil’. It was more than a political tactic; it was a way of life— the continual pursuit of truth by non-violent means, having permanent regard for both ends and means. ‘Passive resistance’, on the other hand, derived from the early twentieth century British suffragettes, was purely a tactical weapon. In civil rights discourse, both in the United States and Australia, the terms were generally used interchangeably, and what was intended seems to have been something in between—that is, an ethically sustainable political tactic. In 1998, Bill Ford remembered very clearly a meeting at the Foundation before the Freedom Riders left, when ‘I was sharing my experiences with the group and The Bulletin wrote it up as a major feature’. It did indeed. Sam Lipski’s article ‘The Freedom Riders’ came out in The Bulletin on 20 February, when the Freedom Ride was in progress, but he had been researching the article for some weeks before. Lipski recorded Bill Ford as saying: Don’t any of you go into this tour with preconceived ideas about what you’re going to face. When the first Freedom Riders came down from California to the Deep South there were 3000 police and troops ready to greet them when the 13 of them got there. Now this isn’t going to happen here. Passive resistance works in some kinds of situations, but it doesn’t in others. Obviously it wouldn’t have done the Jews very much good against the Nazis. But it did work with Gandhi in India and it is working with students and Negroes in the Deep South. Bill Ford’s advice was very precise, and very much within the philosophy of ‘non-violent direct action’ and ‘passive resistance’. He told the SAFA group:
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 47
Getting ready
47
If you find a segregated swimming pool just go and stand out in front of it. Just stand there. Don’t go climbing over fences or trying to force your way in. The real key to this whole thing is to get some visual image across, to make certain that when you do something the Press, radio and television know about it. But if you go into a segregated bar and someone pushes someone else aside and a brawl starts—well, you’ve lost everything. You’ve got to have discipline. Don’t dissipate your energy demonstrating all over the place. Pick out one or two key centres and make sure you’ve got the camera on you. Remember a passive demonstration is the most effective. Any violence and you’ve defeated our own purpose. One of those at this meeting was Alex Mills, soon to be one of the Freedom Riders. He remembers that ‘that night there was a zing click click . . . I could see there was something valuable in this thing—the conditions for Aboriginal people were bad and this was an effective way of doing something about it.’ Alex was rather different from most of the other students. For one thing, he was from a country town, whereas most of the others were Sydney born and bred. He had gone to Orange High School, his father a carpenter and his mother a domestic worker before her marriage. Later, he became the leader of the Presbyterian Fellowship in Orange, and was at university studying Theology in order to become a Presbyterian minister. For another, he was a member of the Country Party, which meant his politics were more conservative than those of most of the other Freedom Riders. He had, however, got to know some of the others— Charles and Warwick Richards—the previous year when they had shared the same Social Theory I class. These three had formed a critical minority in the class. As Warwick, who joined SAFA early on, remembers it: I guess we were all there under the misapprehension from the student handbook that it had to do with, you know, political and social theories, but it was really social work for social workers . . . The main text was a dreadful book by Ben and Peters called Social Theory of the Democratic State, which was taught laboriously through most of the year, and this was an extremely conservative text with all the sort of welfarist implications. A small group of us including Charles and myself, we would sort of argue from one side of the room with the class and the lecturers about that.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 48
48
Freedom Ride
Little preparation was done during October and November, the examination period, but once exams were over, planning became intense. A newsletter, SAFA Talkabout, was devised to keep SAFA members informed and to call meetings. The first edition, in early December, reported that SAFA badges had been printed, called a committee meeting at Charles’s home in Forest Lodge on 14 December, and contained a slip at the bottom that asked students to indicate whether they intended to go on the trip. A letter signed by Charles, John Powles, Gary Williams, Paul Cohen and Ken Buckley was sent with explanatory material to academic staff members in the faculties of Arts, Law and Economics. A meeting on 21 December at the Foundation, which had opened at its premises at 812 George Street near Central Railway just a few days before, heard the Aboriginal leader of the Aborigines Progressive Association, Bert Groves, speak on the Aboriginal view of the trip, though what he said is not recorded. John Butterworth, a second-year Science student who was to become one of the Freedom Riders, agreed (along with another student, Des Moore) to seek further information from the Teachers’ Federation about education facilities in the towns to be visited. That very day, in fact, the federation had published its report on a survey it had conducted of Aboriginal pupils in New South Wales secondary schools, revealing serious educational disparity—not so much from differential education provision as from the deprived social and economic conditions in which pupils lived. The solutions were seen to be in Aboriginal employment, housing and special assistance. This report was widely disseminated and discussed, even reaching an international audience via the New York Times, to the consternation of officials in the Department of External Affairs. It was also agreed at this same SAFA meeting that the students needed to inform themselves as well as they could about conditions in rural New South Wales. Alan Duncan, Australia’s first full-time tutor for adult Aboriginal people after many years as a teacher in country schools, a member of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship and also chairman of the Foundation’s Education Committee, explained to the students about the location of Aborigines in settlements, reserves, towns and so on, while Pam Beasley spoke on the ‘anthropological aspects’. Intending Freedom Riders were asked to look at two articles just published on ‘assimilation versus integration’ in the Sydney Morning Herald on 14 and 16 December. Signed simply ‘a Staff Correspondent’, these articles noted the growing critique of assimilationist policies in many quarters. The second article
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 49
Getting ready
49
Image rights unavailable
From left to right: John Powles, Charles Perkins, Pat Healy and Jim Spigelman plan the Freedom Ride. (Photo courtesy of Fairfax Photo Library)
said assimilation meant nothing less than ‘the complete absorption of the aboriginal race by the white community’, and went on: ‘The aim, as it was in the ruthless days of exploitation, is that eventually the aborigines as a race will disappear.’ In support of this critique, it quoted Alan Duncan: ‘Aborigines are a proud people. They don’t want to lose their identity, become just like us. We’re kidding ourselves if we think we can change them, make them adopt our ways. For instance, aborigines have a very strong community feeling; they share everything . . . They don’t accept the individualism of white people.’ These articles prompted a correspondence to the Herald, leading it to comment in an editorial on 26 December that ‘there is a new and lively interest in New South Wales in aboriginal welfare. It seems to be a questing, deep-seated interest, concerned . . . with a systematic rethinking of policy.’ The editorial suggested that present assimilation policy should be abandoned for one of integration, which would mean the survival of Aborigines as a ‘separate and distinct segment of the Australian people’. Then there was the question of where to go. All indications were that the towns in the north of New South Wales had the most blatant discrimination, and SAFA had settled on this region as its focus back in September. The meeting of 21 December agreed on an itinerary: the bus
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 50
50
Freedom Ride
would go, as Jim Spigelman wrote to Jack Horner of the AboriginalAustralian Fellowship three days later, ‘from here to Dubbo, then north to Walgett, Moree, etc. then touching the Queensland border on our way to the coast and through Lismore, Kempsie [sic] etc’. Wellington, Gulargambone, Boggabilla, Tabulam, Bowraville and Taree had yet to be included. The students tried hard to learn as much as they could about conditions in the targeted towns. None of them, including Charles, had direct first-hand experience, for Charles was from central Australia and had now been living in cities for some years. He did, though, gain a good understanding of conditions generally from the Aboriginal people he met through his work at the Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs. Charles was exceptionally busy working at the Foundation during the summer vacation: Sam Lipski reported that, in his first eight weeks, ‘Perkins has had nearly 1000 interviews with job-seekers, with evicted families, abandoned children, people seeking information about social services, about education and many who come because they have nothing else to do’. An excellent opportunity to research the situation further in at least some of the towns—Walgett, Moree and Kempsey—came when Charles was invited to join an 1800-mile (2900-kilometre) light-plane tour through New South Wales in early January in the company of Ted Noffs, the Australian journalist Graham Williams and photographer Aubrey McCarthy. The group visited the southern town of Nowra, the western towns of Cowra and Wilcannia, the northwestern towns of Walgett, Moree and Armidale and the east coast town of Kempsey. The four newspaper stories by Williams were scathing in their condemnation of the racial inequality endemic in country towns. The first, on 4 January, focused on Aboriginal poverty in Wilcannia, and the second on racial discrimination in pools, hotels and cinemas in places like Moree, Walgett and Kempsey, concluding: ‘Racial discrimination is the result of deeprooted prejudice.’ The third focused on schooling conditions in Cowra, and the final article in the series discussed the assimilation and advancement leagues in Armidale, Kempsey and Nowra. Charles gave a talk about this trip to a general SAFA meeting on 13 January. This meeting also confirmed the timing of the Freedom Ride—the two weeks before Orientation Week, that is, the second half of February—and that the itinerary would be through the towns previously listed, adding Taree. There was a major discussion about whether the tour
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 51
Getting ready
51
would focus only on the survey, or on demonstrations as well. The notice for the meeting had said: ‘This general meeting is most critical and all members and others are requested to attend’, and indeed it was critical. The issue had become the nature of the tour itself. As Jim later wrote, the survey became for a while a ‘bone of contention’ between those who had come from the Christian societies—who favoured it—and those from the ALP Club—who accepted it ‘somewhat begrudgingly’. Colin Bradford remembers that ‘in the planning stages there was a real argument about whether we should be demonstrating at all, or whether we should be just getting factual information then coming back and doing something about it’. So great had this disagreement become that at one stage Jim wrote: ‘It was suggested that no demonstration should occur during the vacation and that only a social survey should be carried out.’ Colin remembered David Ellyard, in particular, ‘arguing that we should just have a fact-finding mission and not be demonstrating as well’. Charles himself seems to have briefly favoured the survey over the demonstrations, announcing in SAFA Talkabout (No. 3) in early January that at the General Meeting on 13 January he would ‘explain reasons why emphasis is now on the Social Survey aspect more so than the integrating of cafés, pool, etc’. The motion to focus only on the survey and to abandon demonstrations was, however, ‘overwhelmingly defeated’ by the General Meeting, and a compromise was reached. The Freedom Ride would give equal emphasis to both. Indeed, this was the view of a number of students in any case—especially those in the Labour Club who, as we shall see, were active in preparing the survey. In the end, Ted Noffs agreed to organise and direct the survey, and to oversee the processing of the results. The survey idea impressed the media. Sam Lipski, for example, noted that ‘they are obviously on the tour with a different expectation than American students. They are not going so much to right a social injustice, the form of which is clear and known, as to find out what form the problem takes.’ The Australian carried a story on 20 January which emphasised the survey and the role of Ted Noffs. Yet by and large the students seem to have constructed the survey themselves. It eventually had six parts, with a one-page sheet of questions for each. They were: Aboriginal Attitudes; European Attitudes; Living Conditions; Health; Occupations and Incomes; and Schooling and Education. Bob Gallagher remembers that a lot of time was spent in the committee meetings on
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 52
52
Freedom Ride
preparing the questionnaires. So too does Alan Outhred, who recalls that, on Colin’s suggestion, he had ‘participated in various working groups, for example, designing the surveys that we were going to do’. Alan, Bob and Colin were all friends. Bob was in the Labour Club; he was an Engineering student who had grown up in Ryde, his father an official in the Federated Engine Drivers’ and Firemen’s Association, and his mother a selfemployed dressmaker and occasional factory worker. Alan was another doctor’s son, his father at that time Chief Medical Officer for the Joint Coal Board with fairly radical political views. His mother was a strong supporter of Aboriginal rights and later a member of the Save Our Sons movement in opposition to Australia’s involvement in the war in Vietnam. The students sought assistance from academics in devising the questionnaires, with Jim Spigelman contacting several departments within the university. Tom Brennan, the head of the Social Work Department, gave a talk on doing a sociological survey, and how to interview people. Wendy remembers getting help in developing the questionnaire on ‘European Attitudes’: I was involved in that, being a Psych student and being interested in that, and there was a book, The Roots of Prejudice or something—from which I gained a lot about the dynamics behind prejudice and I remember going to—I think it was—the School of Clinical Psychology, there was somebody there who helped me put the questionnaire together . . . the questionnaires had to be written in a non-loaded fashion, so that we weren’t actually leading people to give an answer in one direction or another. Aidan Foy and John Powles devised the survey on Health, while Bob Gallagher rather ingeniously devised the one on Living Conditions which mainly focused on housing: As I say, I was the engineer and so there were a number of these survey questionnaires assembled and I constructed the one on the housing conditions, the condition of the houses. I got the . . . standard council planning regulations about light and ventilation, water, sewerage, electricity and sort of constructed a questionnaire around that.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 53
Getting ready
53
The survey not only received praise from the media, but it also assisted SAFA in its approach to the Aborigines Welfare Board for permission to enter the Aboriginal stations and reserves it controlled. The board by this time had been in existence for 25 years. It was the successor to the earlier Aborigines Protection Board, which had been established in 1883 when it became clear that the Aboriginal population would not disappear as had been generally thought during the ‘frontier’ period, and new policies of protection, surveillance and ‘improvement’ were put in place. The Protection Board had established a number of reserves throughout the colony specifically for Aboriginal use, and under the Aborigines Protection Act 1909 acquired much-increased powers over the Aboriginal peoples it controlled. For example, the board now had the power to break up those reserves where white farmers wanted the land, to concentrate large populations in others, and to move the people on and off reserves at will. It also intensified its program of removing Aboriginal children from their parents and placing them in institutions that trained them to become useful as labourers and domestic servants. After Aboriginal discontent rose to a peak in the late 1930s, and the system of surveillance and control seemed to be coming unstuck, the Aborigines Protection Board was abolished in 1939 and replaced by the Aborigines Welfare Board the following year. The new board was charged with the task of implementing the policy of assimilation, which meant trying to persuade and educate Aborigines to take their place as individuals or small families in white society. Its entire assimilation project was in direct conflict with the wishes of the vast majority of white townsfolk, who wanted Aboriginal people kept out of town, and opposed Aboriginal access to schools, clubs, picture theatres and swimming pools. They were especially opposed to the central plank in board policy: the relocation of individual Aboriginal families to houses in town, and many town councils refused the board permission to acquire land for this purpose within town boundaries. The result was that in 1965 few Aboriginal people actually lived in houses in town, and some of those who did had ceased to identify as Aboriginal. With a fast-growing Aboriginal population, the closure of some reserves and the inability to rent houses in town, an increasing number of Aboriginal people lived in unofficial shanty towns on unauthorised land, often now-disused common land on the edge of town, or along riverbanks. These shanty towns were usually without a clean water supply, proper sanitation, any form of electricity, proper roads, rubbish collection or other town services.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 54
54
Freedom Ride
On the other hand, the people there were more or less beyond board control, and often regarded themselves as having more autonomy and independence than those on the stations and reserves. Almost 7000 people did live on the stations and reserves run by the board. In these years, Aboriginal people often had to make a direct tradeoff between reasonable living conditions and freedom from surveillance and petty interference. Housing over 2600 people between them, the sixteen stations run by the board in 1964 usually had basic weatherboard houses, and facilities like a school, a recreation hall or a rudimentary medical centre. Each station had full-time white resident supervision, usually with a married couple in charge as manager and matron. The residents were employed in outside occupations, yet direct supervision of the people remained extensive. These sixteen stations were often referred to somewhat confusingly as ‘missions’, which they were not; they were government run and managed enclosed communities. Between the stations and the shanty towns, along the scale of Aboriginal options, lay the reserves, 42 of them, housing over 4000 people. These were also under board control, but were distinguished from the stations in not having a resident white manager. Their inhabitants were, however, supervised to some degree by a range of people—perhaps the teacher at the reserve school where there was one, or the local off-site board welfare officer, or—most frequently—the local police. The reserves also had a much lower level of housing and facilities than the stations. While they had some homes built by the board, they consisted mainly of makeshift homes built by the Aboriginal residents themselves from discarded materials. The Freedom Riders could visit the shanty towns and the towndwellers relatively easily, but they needed board permission to visit those who lived on stations and reserves. Requests for permission had to go to full meetings of the board, held once a month. In mid-January, Charles and Jim went to see the chair of the board, Mr A.G. Kingsmill, and soon afterwards, on 18 January, Charles wrote him a formal letter seeking permission to enter ‘all reserves, plus missions, and town homes of Aboriginal people’ on the planned route through Wellington, Dubbo, Walgett, Moree, the Queensland border, Lismore, and back to Sydney. The main object of the tour, he wrote, was the ‘comprehensive survey of Aboriginal life in the main towns visited’, under the direction of ‘the Rev. T.D. Noffs who did a similar survey in America’. He also mentioned
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 55
Getting ready
55
the more political purpose of the tour: ‘SAFA proposes also to integrate certain theatres, swimming pools, etc. which discriminate against Aboriginal people’, and pointed out that the ‘tactics will follow the pattern set by the Rev. Martin Luther King. It is passive non-violent action.’ He enclosed a copy of ‘Our Struggle’. Charles went on to reassure Kingsmill that the students ‘do not intend to create confusion or disturbances that will lead to violent action’. The board replied that it would consider his application at its next meeting on 16 February, three days after the tour had begun, and instructed its managers not to grant permission to the students to enter the stations and reserves until then. It also promised that as soon as the decision was made, telegrams would be sent to all the board’s officers en route. This meant the students would have to leave Sydney without the all-important permission, something which must have caused some concern to Charles, Jim and the others. However, they decided to go right ahead and hope for the best. The background research went on. Jim received a valuable letter from Jack Horner, the non-Aboriginal secretary of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship for eight years from 1958. Horner had written to SAFA in September when the original Freedom Ride publicity went out, offering to supply information and contacts if the students wanted it. Now, on 24 December, Jim took up the offer. After reading the fellowship’s Monthly Bulletin, he wrote to Horner ‘that you could be of great importance to our tour’. He outlined the itinerary and requested information on ‘instances of discrimination in this approximate area’, as well as names and addresses of people to contact in the towns. Horner’s reply on 19 January was long and informative. ‘I think,’ he wrote, ‘you will find that discrimination and prejudice are greatest where there are large concentrations of Aborigines, e.g. Kempsey district, Walgett, Woodenbong, and least where there are only small groups, e.g. Yamba, MacLean, Casino.’ He outlined some specific instances, as follows: Kempsey—Baths and Public halls. Kinchella Boys’ Home, from which many boys have absconded lately. We understand there is no longer an ‘Aboriginal ward’ at the hospital—but are Aborigines treated in exactly the same way as Europeans, or put on verandahs, etc.? Is Green Hills School (nominally a Public School) still used solely by aborigines, other parents preferring to pay bus fares to send their children into town?
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 56
56
Freedom Ride
Moree—We have heard that the school bus picks up Aboriginal children from the Station after it has delivered other children to school, and takes them home before school finishes, so that they lose up to an hour a day. Moree has a very bad name for discrimination generally— a sort of hard-core attitude, which should yield you a lot of material. Walgett—no doubt you have all the material on this town. We had correspondence with the manager (Mr White) of the Oasis HotelMotel, in which he admitted putting up a notice ‘Aborigines by invitation only’ . . . There are many issues worth taking up in places like Walgett, but it is essential to pick the unassailable ones, and to check carefully the facts given. Horner also enclosed a list of stations and reserves, with numbers of people living on each one, and people to contact in each town—school teachers, ministers of religion, Aboriginal leaders like Pearl Gibbs in Dubbo and Frank Roberts in Lismore, and other interested individuals. Horner’s letter went on to outline the AAF approach. It sought, he said, ‘to give Aborigines some say in their own affairs’. The Welfare Board, he wrote: gives no opportunity to assume responsibility, with stations under the control of a manager, who has wide powers, and the need to get his permission even to visit their families. There is no provision for a committee of residents to make their own decisions. There is little education, and most adult Aborigines are barely literate. The Board is so unpopular with Aborigines that they decline to get involved in its policies. Although Aborigines in NSW are eligible to vote in state and Federal elections, only a minority do so. His letter concluded with warm wishes: ‘We are convinced that this will be very valuable, and we wish you very well indeed.’ Jim replied gratefully five days later, seeking further information, which Horner helpfully supplied. Despite all their preparations, the students had in fact relatively little direct contact with Aboriginal people living in the towns to be visited. Charles was still seen by the Aboriginal people there as an outsider. Alan Duncan, who had very extensive contacts with people in these towns, recalled in 1994:
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 57
Getting ready
57
There was a little bit of a negative attitude, I suppose more apprehension than anything else, because [through] my work with Aboriginal communities, they as far as I’m aware, were not consulted very much at all. Now that’s not a criticism, it’s just a fact. And some of the older people there, Ella Simons for example at Taree, who was a matriarch there; I’m trying to remember Mary Dureaux at Kempsey, her attitude, I think it wasn’t quite as negative in a way as say Ella— but a lot of the older people on the Aboriginal stations were very apprehensive about what would happen (a) when the students arrived and (b) after they’d gone. This was really what the worry was, what was going to be the effect on the local community about people busting in, you know, stirring up a hornet’s nest and shooting off again, so that was the worry. At the same time as the students were researching the trip, they were also working hard to raise enough money to hire a bus. Beth Hansen organised the tenders, choosing Saint’s Bus Company (which still exists), which charged £460 after a £77 concession. The earlier publicity had attracted some donations, but they were nowhere near this amount. There were other ways of raising money, like the sale of Christmas cards with an Aboriginal motif, organised by Chris Page, which brought in £30. Several lunchtime folk concerts were held at the university during term time, raising £62, and a public folk concert, organised almost single-handedly by Pat Healy, netted £72. This concert was held in Paddington Town Hall on Thursday, 21 January, with non-Aboriginal folk singers Gary Shearston, Jeannie Lewis and Declan Affley and others, and Aboriginal singers Jenny Bush and Alan Moarywaalla. A good deal of the money for the bus tour in the end came from the students themselves. Student members of SAFA paid 2 shillings membership, and those going on the Freedom Ride had each to pay £10 to contribute to the cost of the bus and food. In the end, the £460 Publicity notice for folk needed for the bus came from the funds concert to raise money for raised by all these means, and additional the Freedom Ride.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 58
58
Freedom Ride
SAFA subscriptions levied after the bus returned. The main approach, though, was to keep costs down. SAFA looked for free accommodation in church halls and country showgrounds. Warwick Richards remembers that, because Charles had contacts with the Methodist church through Ted Noffs, he hoped that the Methodists ‘would provide a sort of a network of support’; this, he says, ‘was a bit controversial obviously’. Alex Mills remembers that he wanted the Presbyterians to be involved. When people at one SAFA meeting asked ‘How are we going to do the washing?’ and ‘How are we going to eat on this trip around?’, he thought: Well, why not do things like contacting a few of the Presbyterian churches around and ask some people to cook a bit of food for us, get a few things organised like that. That just sort of seemed a fairly reasonable thing to do, and I guess I was a few years older than a few other people who hadn’t had those experiences. So I somehow seemed to get involved in it as the quarter master or words to that effect . . . I know I ended up having a bit of an office—a phone and an office there in the Foundation for Aboriginal Affairs for the last few weeks doing something about organising. Pat Healy and Beth Hansen actually bought the food, though. Pat remembers going to ‘one of the big bulk food stores down in the Dixon St, Haymarket area’. In addition to Alex’s efforts with the Presbyterians, Jim Spigelman wrote many letters to churches, councils and agricultural societies. Showgrounds were offered at Lismore and Kempsey, and a National Fitness Hut in Warwick. Church halls were made available in many towns, and some of the letters of permission survive. In two of the most important towns, Walgett and Moree, church halls were made available for free. Reverend P.J. Dowe, the vicar at St Peter’s Church of England in Walgett, who will reappear in our story, wrote saying the students could stay in the hall on 14 and 15 February. Ted Ryan, of the Methodist parsonage in Moree, also wrote, saying ‘the Church hall would be available for your group as a dormitory’. He mentioned also that: ‘I wrote to Charles Perkins and volunteered to help in any way I could if he would let me know exactly what the team intends to do here and how I might assist. I have not received any information. Be assured of our cooperation.’
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 59
Getting ready
59
Jim also wrote to a number of unions seeking support and information. Though generally pro-Aboriginal at this time, especially after the ACTU policy of 1963, the unions contacted were not as enthusiastic as SAFA might have wished, largely because they seem to have feared that SAFA’s militant tactics might disturb their own longer-term strategies in support of Aboriginal demands. The Teachers’ Federation is an interesting example. It was to be expected that the federation would be helpful and supportive, given its strong commitment to the cause of Aboriginal education. Gloria Phelan, its research officer, replied to Jim’s letter offering her personal support and referring his request to the federation executive. However, when the letter finally came on 28 October from I.G. Lancaster, the general secretary, it was not the support SAFA expected: While the Federation agrees with the need to publicise cases of discrimination, it suggests that this type of action is premature at this moment, and may have an undesirable aftermath as far as the Aboriginal people themselves are concerned. You will appreciate, therefore, that the Federation cannot accede to your request at this juncture. The Australian Workers’ Union, New South Wales branch, wrote a fairly formal letter, advising Jim that ‘there are no legal discriminations concerning the employment of Aborigines in the State of NSW, all awards and acts of parliament give them equal rights’, and seeking information on any breaches of the law. Jim also wrote to the Liquor and Allied Trades Union, seeking support for SAFA’s plan to desegregate clubs and hotels. Aboriginal people had been barred by law for a century from drinking or buying alcohol (unless they had an exemption certificate); this did not actually prevent drinking, but it did make it more clandestine and expensive, and served to exclude Aboriginal people from public bars, clubs and other forms of sociality. After a campaign led by the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, the relevant section of the Aborigines Protection Act had been repealed in March 1963. There was now no legal basis for any refusal to serve liquor to Aborigines on the grounds of their race, though there was also no legislation as yet making it illegal to discriminate on the basis of race. Some publicans still refused to serve Aboriginal customers at all, or served them only in designated parts of their hotel. One challenge to this practice occurred with demonstrations in January 1964 of six Aboriginal people, along with
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 60
60
Freedom Ride
representatives of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, the New South Wales Council for Civil Liberties, a Mirror journalist, two Members of Parliament and Channel 7 at the Clifton Hotel in Redfern, fast becoming an area in which many Aboriginal people lived. The hotel had finally agreed to serve Aboriginal people on the same basis as others. Yet some city and many country hotels continued to segregate their customers. The union replied to Jim on 9 February rather cautiously: ‘We are prepared . . . to examine the merits of any particular instance and take any action deemed to be appropriate.’ Still searching for more information, Jim Spigelman also wrote in late January to church bodies which had had significant contact with Aboriginal people in the towns. Noel Flint, the pastor at the Church of Christ, Gilgandra, wrote suggesting the students visit the schools and dwellings in Gilgandra. He already knew something of the students’ plans, having met two of the students, one of them Chris Page, on a preliminary tour a week or two earlier. While little record of this trip remains, we do know that they visited Gilgandra, that their tour cost £13, and that they arrived back in Sydney only a few days before the bus left. The Reverend Flint now told Jim that ‘there is not much discrimination’ in Gilgandra, though ‘the Western Stores and Nelson’s timber yard require a guarantor before allowing credit’. He added the information that in nearby Gulargambone ‘they may go to the counter and be served but cannot sit at the table in the restaurant and there is a separate section in the theatre’. Gulargambone was added to the itinerary very late, and this letter may well have been the catalyst. At the end of January, the fourth edition of SAFA Talkabout informed everyone that an itinerary had been fixed and called a General Meeting for 4 February. This was the deadline for those intending to go to pay their £4 deposit. An itinerary was printed, showing that the bus would visit and survey ten towns—Wellington, Gulargambone, Walgett, Moree, Boggabilla, Tabulam, Lismore, Bowraville, Kempsey and Taree—with some other towns on the way as stopovers. The trip would cover a total distance of 1390 miles (over 2300 kilometres). Finally, everything had been done. On Friday, 12 February, the bus, the 29 students, some parents and well-wishers gathered at the university. I returned from my family home in Newcastle and joined the group of students waiting to leave. It was after midnight when we finally all boarded the bus and waved goodbye. Aidan Foy remembers us ‘all driving
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 61
Getting ready
61
off in the dark’. As the white bus slowly went down the hill and then out along Parramatta Road through Sydney’s western suburbs and along the Great Western Highway to the towns of the west and north, our thoughts began to turn to the unknown and possibly dangerous situation we were about to enter. Each of us had our own thoughts on the opportunities, pleasures, dangers and perils that might lie ahead. The American Freedom Rides had been attended by violence. Could anything similar occur in country Australia? Despite all the preparation, few of us had any real idea of what lay ahead.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 62
3
Chapter
On the way to Walgett
W
hile the students are chatting and gradually falling asleep on the bus in the early hours of the morning, let’s pause and learn more about those we’ve already met, and meet the rest. What did they have in common, and how did they differ? What were their family and class backgrounds, their political and religious beliefs, and their fields of study? For most of the journey, Charles Perkins was the only Aboriginal student. Gary Williams, though involved in SAFA, felt wary of going to places outside his own country. He joined the tour when it reached Bowraville. This nearly all-white composition marked the Australian Freedom Ride off from the American Rides that had inspired it. As Sam Lipski noted, on the American Freedom Rides, ‘the dynamism for the freedom riders was supplied largely by Negro university students themselves’. There are some other interesting features of the group. About two-thirds were from one faculty, the Faculty of Arts, and the rest were divided between Science (six undergraduates and one graduate), Medicine (four undergraduates) and Engineering (one). All but six were entering just their second or third year of university study. All but one—John Gowdie, whom we’ll meet shortly—were from the University of Sydney. There had been some talk in the preparation phase of students joining from universities in Tasmania, Victoria, Queensland and South Australia, but this idea seems to have faded. The class backgrounds of the students were extremely diverse. They 62
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 63
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
63
ranged from wealthy (Darce Cassidy) to solidly middle class (most of the others) to working class (Colin, Bob, Brian and Pat). Most were from Sydney, but several had grown up in country towns, including Alex in Orange, John Powles in Deniliquin and John Butterworth partly in Moree, while I had grown up in Broken Hill and Newcastle. Just over one-third of the students were from the organised Left. The largest group came from the Labour Club, some of whose members were in the Communist Party, or its youth organisation, the Eureka Youth League (EYL). Brian, Pat, Colin, Bob and Alan, who had been involved in the planning and preparation, were all in the Labour Club. Three more joined at this point. One was Norm Mackay, a second-year Science student along with Brian, Colin and Alan, and a close friend of Brian’s. His parents were both teachers and Communist Party members living near the Aarons family in Fairfield in the western suburbs of Sydney. Another was Louise Higham, a good friend of mine. Her father, like Alan’s and Chris Page’s, was a left-wing doctor and her mother a nurse and receptionist for the home-based practice. Both parents were Labor voters and atheists, with wide cultural interests. She was just about to enter her second year of Medicine, which she abandoned later and transferred to Arts. She was a member of the Folk Music Club, where she ‘received the powerful “Jim Crow must go” message of many of the songs in the concerts at the Wallace theatre’. I was the last in this group. I was about to enter the third year of an Arts degree, specialising in Modern History. My father was an academic scientist, a senior lecturer in Chemistry at the University of Newcastle, while my mother had just gone to the same university as a mature-age student to do an Arts degree, and was to become a psychologist on graduation. Both were committed communists, but it was my mother who introduced me to Aboriginal politics. She was involved not only through the Union of Australian Women, which strongly supported Aboriginal rights, but also in 1961 established, along with several others, the Newcastle Trades Hall Aboriginal Advancement Committee. This committee campaigned in support of a rent strike by the people at Purfleet mission station near Taree, a protest against the appalling state of housing and an incipient demand for land rights. As a result of my mother’s activism, Aboriginal people from Purfleet came to our home in Newcastle from time to time, and I gained in my teenage years some idea of Aboriginal conditions and political activism.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 64
64
Freedom Ride
Shortly before the Freedom Ride started, I had written an article, ‘The Fight for Aboriginal Rights’, for Left Forum, the extremely transient journal of the Labour Club. It indicates the strong influence of the Communist Party’s position on Aboriginal issues on my own thinking, namely the need for equality, and the importance of black and white people organising together for Aboriginal rights. It also reads now like the work of a History student. It began: Ever since the first European settlement of Australia in 1788 the Australian white population has degraded the Aboriginal population, originally by methods of shooting, poisoning, starvation, brutal seizure of land and destruction of the aboriginal social organisation, and later by the more ‘progressive’ policy of ‘Protection’. It went on to discuss the destruction of the population, and the limitations on Aboriginal people’s basic freedoms: ‘Innumerable instances of social discrimination exist all over Australia, whether in a place of leisure such as a hotel bar or a swimming pool, a place of work, or a place of social welfare such as a hospital or school.’ This history of destruction and discrimination existed, I argued, because the Aboriginal population ‘by its very existence constituted a threat to the European acquisition of the land’. In addition, ‘the new Australian settler, like his counterparts in Africa, Asia and America, used aborigines as a source of cheap labour’. I concluded with a call for racial equality and an end to legal and economic discrimination: ‘This can only be done through the development of a strong integration movement consisting of aboriginal and white Australians, which must aim firstly to secure those formal rights which are still not held by aborigines, and secondly to attack and destroy the discrimination and hostile racial attitudes now existing.’ With a quarter of the students connected to the Labour Club, the Eureka Youth League or the Communist Party, it is understandable that Charles and Jim were both concerned about the fact and the appearance of too many communists on the trip. The Bulletin had reported on the impending Freedom Ride several weeks earlier, offering cautious support but also warning of the dangers of communist influence. Whatever the number of communist students actually on the trip, there was always the danger that the Freedom Ride could be written off as a communist plot, given the general tendency to associate any radical cause with
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 65
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
65
communist influence and the strong actual association of communists with Aboriginal organisations at the time. As Sam Lipski accurately put it: ‘The Communist Party’s interest in Aborigines dates back to the party’s inception, and has changed as the international Communist line has changed. But at no time in its history has CPA interest in and work amongst Aborigines been more active than it is today.’ To counter charges of communist influence, Charles and Jim announced publicly that they would not allow a communist ‘stacking’ of the tour, and that they had discouraged members of the Eureka Youth League from enrolling. Whether the latter was literally true or not (and there is no evidence that it was), this announcement did effectively remove the question of communist influence from most coverage of the tour. In all its publicity, SAFA played down the fact that up to a quarter of the students were indeed associated either with the CPA, the EYL or the Labour Club. The students concerned also kept their political allegiances muted, for that was the approach of the time. The question was to reappear, though, as we shall see. There was a group of three students from the ALP Club, to become four when Hall Greenland joined the bus in Walgett. There would have been five, had not Jim Spigelman at the end of 1964 led a breakaway group which soon became the more centrist Fabian Society. The four had been involved in either the May 1964 demonstration for US civil rights, or the July rally and demonstration in Hyde Park, or in SAFA itself. Aidan Foy had been deeply involved in the organising phase, and now joined the Freedom Ride. He had arrived in Australia with his mother as an assisted immigrant from northern England in May 1962 (‘Australia being as far as my mother could possibly get from my father at the time’). His mother eventually became a schoolteacher ‘so that she could get a job to keep us because my father didn’t’. In his Labor-voting family, ‘people who voted for any other party were nearly as bad as Protestants but not quite as bad’. Aidan remembers that initially some of the students in the ALP Club had described SAFA as ‘a middle-class guilt, condescending organisation, we thought there were more important things at that stage. And then the bus tour idea started and suddenly everybody wanted to be part of it.’ At this point, Darce Cassidy, Paddy Dawson and Hall Greenland decided to come. Three of the four—Hall, Aidan and Darce—leant towards the Trotskyists in their political position, while Paddy, the son of a noteworthy academic at the university, Madge Dawson, was probably
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 66
66
Freedom Ride
more anarchist and libertarian in his politics than the rest of the group. Darce Cassidy’s position was a little unusual. As a full-time ABC employee and part-time student, he needed to get time off to join the Freedom Ride: I heard about the Freedom Ride on the grapevine, and asked the ABC for permission to cover it. Initially they said no. I had not been there long enough to have any annual leave, but had accrued three days off in lieu of overtime. Finally they agreed to let me have two days on duty, and three days’ leave. Together with the two weekends, this would give me nine days . . . My role became a bit ambiguous. I was still a student at Sydney University, and a financial member of SAFA. I was also an ABC journalist. The remaining students were from a wide variety of backgrounds, and had quite different reasons for joining in. Two, John Powles and Beth Hansen, came from the Humanist Society. Warwick Richards was in the Students’ Christian Movement. ‘I was the first member of the family to have gone to university. My parents left school at the age of 15 in both cases. My father was a bank officer and my mother was basically a house person who had various part-time jobs but never had a career of any sort.’ Sue Johnston, a History Honours student as I was, came from the very middle-class suburb of Beecroft, and was to become an important figure in SAFA during and after the tour. Her father was a solicitor with the NSW State Railways, dealing with workers’ compensation. Sue had become interested in Aboriginal issues through hearing Paul Robeson sing in Sydney four years earlier and through her university study of race relations in American history. Jim Spigelman was not the only student on the tour born overseas. Machteld Hali was born in Holland and grew up in Indonesia, before arriving in Australia to attend university. Wendy Golding was a secondyear Arts student whose Jewish parents had left Vienna after Hitler annexed Austria, going first to New Zealand and then in 1952 to Australia, with 5-year-old New Zealand-born Wendy. They came, she recalled, from a ‘very middle-class cosmopolitan rather sophisticated background’, and were ‘very small “l” liberal in their thinking’. She said later that ‘because I was very aware of the persecution of the Jews I guess I was very aware of injustice to any peoples anywhere on the basis of
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 67
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
67
creed, colour, race, religion—whatever it may be. So that’s probably what gave me a sensitivity to the Aboriginal issue.’ Two months after the Freedom Ride, she wrote in The Bridge, a Jewish magazine, that she had for a long time ‘shuddered at stories of Hitler’s regime and shaken my head about the American Negro situation’. The Freedom Ride offered her ‘the opportunity to put my fine words into action’. Judith Rich, who knew Charles from their Anthropology class, had a similar background to Wendy’s, though she was born in Australia. Her Jewish parents had also left Vienna in 1938 or 1939, and fled as refugees to Australia, where they met and married. She, too, had grown up with an interest in questions of race and racism. Some of the students, such as Alex Mills, came from politically conservative backgrounds. Robyn Iredale joined up because she was about to do an Honours thesis in Geography on rural–urban migration of Aborigines and her lecturer, Diana Howlett, had recommended she join the bus: ‘I was a bit apprehensive because I didn’t know any of the people.’ Robyn was from a large, conservative, religious family in West Ryde, her father an accountant at the Water Board for 43 years, her mother the organist at the Methodist church. She was, she says, ‘basically brought up anti-Aborigine, anti-anybody who was different, and we were even brought up antiCatholic, because that’s what Methodists were like . . . I went off to university and that changed me.’ Another, Derek Molloy, was an Arts student studying Anthropology who had been invited along by his friend, Alex Mills, just four days before the tour. From an Anglican background, his father was a lawyer who had earlier been involved in the Australian administration of Papua New Guinea, and his mother a nurse. He thought the Freedom Ride was to be a survey only, and was taken aback to find it also involved demonstrations against racial discrimination. There are nine students still to introduce. Four of them (John Gowdie, Hall Greenland, Barry Corr and David Pepper) joined later; we will meet them as they join the bus. Five of them, two women and three men, I have not been able to trace for this book. The women were Sue Reeves, a third-year Arts student involved in Abschol; and Helen Gray, a secondyear Arts student. The men were John Butterworth, a third-year Science student; Ray Leppik, a graduate Science student; and Rick Collins, a thirdyear Arts student.
O
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 68
68
Freedom Ride
The bus travelled through Sydney’s western suburbs, past Penrith and on to the Great Western Highway as it left the coastal plain and wound up through the Great Dividing Range. After passing through the cool mountain towns of Katoomba and Mt Victoria, the student bus travelled down the slopes to Lithgow and Bathurst, and then on to the Mitchell Highway to the inland town of Orange. A distance of 170 miles, or 280 kilometres, the trip probably took around five hours. The bus arrived at its first stop, Orange, before dawn on Saturday, 13 February. ‘I seem to remember we arrived at Orange in darkness,’ says Bob Gallagher. We went at 8.00 a.m. to the Presbyterian Church of St John’s, a very fine old church with a church hall next door, for breakfast. Pat Healy recalls: ‘Alex had arranged for us all to have breakfast in this large hall. That’s about all I remember. Staggering off the bus to have this wonderful breakfast that was all organised by these country ladies.’ Alex provides some more detail: I’d organised some people in the Presbyterian Church of St John’s there that I’d grown up in to get breakfast for the students, and organised for the Mayor of the town, who happened to be the president of the Labor Party, and the Deputy Mayor to come along and meet up with me . . . We probably had the [local] TV [station] along. I can’t remember, but anyway we got a little bit of hype there. And then I went off to see my cousin and came back late, held the bus up from making a start, so they went crook on me in Orange, which was right—they’re all rearing to go and here’s Millsie off visiting his cousin. At around 9.30 a.m. the bus left Orange, and went on to Wellington, arriving two hours later. Wellington, a pretty town at the junction of the Bell and Macquarie Rivers, had an interesting history. The Aboriginal people in the region were Wiradjuri, one of the most populous Aboriginal groups in New South Wales, who had first encountered Europeans in 1817. Europeans established sheep and cattle farming soon after, with the usual devastating effects on traditional sources of food supply. A prison farm was set up in 1823; when the soldiers and convicts left in 1830, the military buildings were given to the Church Missionary Society. With government funds, a mission was established under the leadership of the Reverend William Watson. The mission emphasised the education
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 69
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
69
and segregation of children away from their parents, and agriculture as the basis of civilisation. Aboriginal people were employed on the mission as shepherds, threshers, gardeners, ploughmen and draymen, and some had built and settled into huts. The whole enterprise, wrote social scientist Charles Rowley in The Destruction of Aboriginal Society, resembled a workhouse rather than a place of conversion to Christianity. The missionaries’ efforts were undermined by the contradictions their society presented to the people: ‘The gospel of love was being preached while white men were flogging each other and shooting black men.’ After the closure of the mission in 1843, the Aboriginal people in the Wellington region worked for pastoralists and other employers, and camped on the properties or on the edge of town. Gradually, they came more directly under the purview of the colonial and then state governments of New South Wales. By 1965, Wellington had both a board-managed station known as the Nanima reserve with its own school just out of town, and an Aboriginal shanty town on Crown land near the river. We could not visit the former, as the board had not yet met to consider our application to enter, and had in the interim instructed the manager to keep us out. When we arrived, the police warned us not to go there. Warwick Richards remembers the ‘circling policemen, who were sort of walking suspiciously around the bus’. Of necessity, therefore, our focus had to be the shanty town and the town itself, though there was no sign of Aboriginal families in town. We split up into a number of smaller groups, and I was in one of the groups that went to the shanty town. The idea was that we would conduct our survey, investigate claims of racial discrimination and, if we found any, make some kind of demonstration against them. We had little idea of what to expect. There were few if any contacts between the local Aboriginal community and us students, including Charles. As Rick Collins later remarked: ‘No one who was brought up in the city could’ve known what was going on out there, and we were just a bunch of green kids.’ In that situation, the survey could serve to emphasise, as Brian put it, that ‘we weren’t white students breezing in and kicking up a fuss about Aboriginal rights, we were going to try and talk to Aboriginal people and get their own version of their actual conditions’. Some of the students, however, were not very interested in the survey and thought we should focus on non-violent protests. Darce remembers:
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 70
70
Freedom Ride
I think there had been a good deal of debate on the bus, and before, about what we should be doing. Some were pushing the survey, saying that the important thing was gathering the facts. Others were saying that in a broad sense we knew the facts from investigations already carried out. We had a fair knowledge of what the world was like; our task was now to change it through some kind of confrontation. At Wellington, it seemed to me, the survey faction still held the upper hand. Only a few months earlier, Charles Rowley had investigated the situation in Wellington, along with many other towns, as part of his research into the status of Aboriginal people across Australia for the Social Science Research Council. The results of his research were not yet available, and were later published in Outcasts in White Australia, part of his influential trilogy that did so much in the 1970s to inspire non-Aboriginal people’s desire to understand. He had written to Mr H.S. Kitching, the Area Welfare Officer in Dubbo, who provided considerable information about the shanty town. Kitching told Rowley that there were 40 adults and 67 children, living in fourteen dwellings made mainly of scrap iron, and provided a list of the dwellings and their inhabitants, with a column denoting the ‘caste’ of each family—H.C. (half-caste), Q.C. (quartercaste), L.C. (lesser-caste, i.e. less than quarter-caste)—with L.C. the most commonly noted. He also pointed out the local council neither provided services (there was no water or sanitation service) nor control of the settlement, so the people were ‘free to live without restriction as to social standards or social behaviour’. That Saturday afternoon, we got out our survey forms, walked up to the tin shacks on the settlement, introduced ourselves to their residents and asked our questions. Looking back, there is something a little touching about this strange cross-cultural encounter. We were finally about to meet the people whose cause we hoped we understood and wanted to publicise. Would the questionnaires, so carefully prepared in Sydney, be useful or entirely inappropriate? The survey form I had that day was probably the one headed ‘Aboriginal Questionnaire’ and had a total of 29 questions. Some of these sought to elicit the ideas of Aboriginal people about their treatment (‘Are the white people giving the Aborigines a fair chance?’), their sense of worth (‘Are the Aboriginal people as good as the white people in every way?’),
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 71
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
71
ideas about committees to ‘deal with Aboriginal assimilation’, the Aborigines Welfare Board, experience in getting jobs, accessing health services, whether their situation had improved at all over the last twenty years, and their views about not being counted in the census. It also asked for opinions about not being accepted for the recently instituted national military service, an issue that had received some media attention during January 1965. One question was ‘Do you think that Aboriginal people are happier than white people?’, while others sought to elicit views on whether Aborigines should be on reserves or in towns, whether ‘the Aborigines should stand up for their rights or just accept the situation as it is?’, whether they should ‘preserve some of the old customs or adopt all the new ones?’, how Aboriginal people were discriminated against, and how ‘the Aboriginal situation could be helped’. Now, either totally or largely untrained as interviewers, we students walked around the settlement just outside Wellington, looking for Aboriginal people to interview. We got a tremendous shock. We really had no idea until this moment what it was we were protesting about. Here it was, the utmost poverty in our well-off First World industrialised country. Pat Healy remembers: ‘Wellington. Dry, dusty. And that’s where we first started to see the living conditions for Aboriginal people. I have a visual memory of Wellington more than anything else. I can just visualise these hot, dusty shacks. I don’t particularly remember what we did there.’ Soon after the Freedom Ride, she told an interviewer that her first reaction had been ‘complete numbness and shock. You know roughly before you go what you are going to face, but you simply don’t realise until you get there and see for yourself. Take the houses they live in. I could hardly believe it when I first saw it.’ I still remember Wellington clearly, for the poverty, and the feeling of trespass. That evening, perhaps realising that this was getting to be something serious and disturbing, I started to write a diary. The diary was written in a Croxley spiral notebook, and I have kept it all these years, through fifteen house moves. I remember writing it each night from then on, sometimes in rather poor light. I deliberately wrote it in a very matter-of-fact way, careful not to say anything that was embarrassing, should it be found and read by another student. There was no privacy on the bus, and the chances of having a diary read were potentially high. It does provide, however, a reminder of many of the details of the bus tour, and some idea of my own experience of it at the time. My first entry concerns our stay in Wellington:
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 72
72
Freedom Ride
Interviewed about ten tin shacks of people. Most of us found the questionnaires unsuitable. Houses of tin, mud floors, very overcrowded, kids had eye diseases, had to cart water (very unhealthy) from river. People fairly easy to talk to, kids quite friendly. General picture of extreme poverty but not a great deal of social discrimination. Got seven interviews on the settlement just outside the reserve, and two in the town. General picture of scarcity of jobs. Mainly garden work, which is very seasonal. Average of three months of year out of work. Some working on a dam nearby. Some did shearing jobs. Did not encounter or hear of any women with jobs at all. Did not seem to know much about social services. Thirteen of the completed survey forms for the ‘Aboriginal Questionnaire’ in Wellington survive, nine from women and four from men. Two of the women were named Ah See, possibly descendants of one of the Chinese families that had arrived in the region in the nineteenth century looking for gold, and owned and managed stores and market gardens for decades afterwards. It is difficult, now, to know what to make of these answers, and hard to tell what the students and the Aboriginal people of the settlement understood what each wanted of the other, or thought the other could do. While the respondents varied in their answers to the question ‘Are the white people giving the Aborigines a fair chance?’, all agreed ‘the Aborigines should stand up for their rights’ rather than ‘accept the situation as it is’. Only two thought Aboriginal people should ‘preserve some of the old customs’; the others agreed they should ‘adopt all the new ones’. All said Aboriginal people should live in the towns rather than on reserves. Clearly, the question of acquiring houses in town was uppermost in these answers; when asked how they thought ‘the Aboriginal situation could be helped’ or how the health standards of Aboriginal people could be raised, answers ranged from ‘better housing’, ‘build more homes’, ‘nice homes with water, etc.’ to ‘do away with missions and put Aborigines in towns, mixing’ and ‘put them in town’. When asked for examples of discrimination, the answers included ‘up to twelve months ago not allowed in pubs’, ‘Courthouse Hotel’, ‘hotels, shops’, ‘employment’, ‘putting them out of town’ and ‘won’t let them live in town even if can afford [it]’. While we had been interviewing people at the settlement, Jim and Charles and some of the others had been in town. They asked some local
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 73
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
73
Aboriginal people about which pubs discriminated against them, and went to the one named ‘The Courthouse’, which some Aboriginal people said refused to serve them. Jim started capturing the events of the Freedom Ride on super-8 film, to which he added a commentary in 1987. His film shows Darce interviewing an Aboriginal man, whom we then see outside the Courthouse Hotel, talking to Darce and Charles. It seems from my diary that this man was allowed in, but only because he was with the students: ‘The publican said he only prevented Aborigines from coming in “if they were disorderly”.’ Charles then went into the same hotel, and there was some discussion between the barmaid and the publican before they served him. When Darce interviewed him outside the hotel, Charles reported: Oh well the lady, the barmaid, asked me what I wanted and then went over, very reluctantly went over to the tap to serve me and then stopped serving, pouring out the beer, and went and asked the manager. The manager came over and had a conference and they both looked at me very slyly and then decided that I was a possibility, a doubtful case and so they decided to give me a glass of beer. Very reluctantly, after asking me twice, the manager himself that is. This meant that the students did not have direct evidence of racial discrimination in the hotel, making it difficult to demonstrate about the matter. Darce also interviewed the local Salvation Army officer, who said there was no discrimination in Wellington’s hotels, as did one of the drinkers he interviewed. He went with a team administering the ‘European Questionnaire’. This form asked people to agree or disagree with a range of questions, such as ‘The Aborigines are just as honest and public-spirited citizens as the Europeans. Do you agree?’, ‘The Aborigines are morally inferior to most other people. Do you agree?’, and ‘Does it worry you that the Aboriginal population is increasing at a rate about twice as fast as that of the European population?’ And so on, for seventeen questions, followed by four questions where respondents were to choose between two alternatives—for example, ‘Would you prefer Aborigines to live on the reserves or in the town?’ Finally, there were two open-ended questions, one asking ‘What sort of qualities would a “good” Aborigine have?’ and the other asking about the qualities of a ‘bad’ Aborigine.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 74
74
Freedom Ride
While these filled-in survey forms have not apparently survived, Darce did record an interview with some of the local white townsfolk. The theme in their comments was that Aboriginal people did not know the value of houses, money or education—though also, in one case, that ‘if they had the same chance as the whites, nobody really knows’. Darce also went with a group who spoke with the Anglican minister, Archdeacon Graham. He saw only one problem, that of ‘educating the Aboriginal so that they can be integrated into our community . . . They know so little about employer–employee relationships, about landlord and tenant relationships, and to my mind about personal hygiene. They need to be educated on those matters so they can take their place in the community.’ A child told Darce that Aboriginal children were her friends, though her mother would not allow Aboriginal children to play at her house, as ‘they make a mess of me dolls and that’. Aidan Foy and John Powles, meanwhile, had investigated the hospital. They probably took with them the Health survey that they had devised, of which no copy seems to have survived. Aidan remembers going to the tiny hospital ‘and the matron showing me the little black babies in the hospital, obviously keen to tell me how well they looked after them’. He also remembers interviewing a general practitioner. ‘The medical people interviewed by and large welcomed us. I think they thought they’d get some more resources if there was a bit of a fuss . . . We just marched in and asked matron to please answer some questions, and in every case that I can recall she did.’ There were three other questionnaires prepared by the students, which may have been used that day. In addition to those on attitudes and health, there was an ‘Occupations and Incomes’ survey, with ten questions about employment, including the nature of the employment, wages, training, locality, union membership and discrimination on the job, and seven questions about unemployment, concerning its duration, nature of the unemployed person’s training, union membership, social and unemployment benefits, and reasons for unemployment. The fifth questionnaire in the survey was on living conditions, and again, I have no copy. In view of the centrality of housing issues in Aboriginal politics at the time, this is rather a shame. The sixth, also seemingly lost, focused on schooling and education, and was designed to be put to school principals in each town. It asked about the number of Aboriginal students who completed primary school, the numbers in each class in high school,
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 75
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
75
non-attendance, the nature of and reasons for success and failure in exams, ideas about mixed versus segregated schools, curriculum, standards of homework, levels of acceptance and thoughts about employing Aboriginal teachers. Later in the afternoon, the students compared notes. They agreed that, although there was some evidence of racial discrimination, especially in the Courthouse Hotel, there was nothing substantial enough to justify a demonstration. Although Wellington may have had an assimilation organisation in the early 1960s (the board report said it did), there was no sign of it in 1965, and if there was one, it may have been largely or entirely white. In any case, the students had not made contact with politically active locals, and this was a major barrier to any further action. Many years later, Charles recalled that the students hadn’t been able to take the matter further partly because he, Charles, had in fact been served in the hotel and partly because: There weren’t enough Aboriginal people around to support us, and we wanted to get Aboriginal people to support the things we did. So after a while we decided to leave it at that and go on. We went on to the next town. There was discrimination in the pubs there, but it was more sophisticated, it wasn’t so blatant, and we wanted a clear-cut case of discrimination. And with that, at around 5.30 p.m., the bus left town for the nearby large town of Dubbo. We had been in Wellington for a total of five, perhaps six, hours. We were learning a lot, and indeed it could be argued that it was in Wellington that we started to become a group. Jim Spigelman later said: ‘At the outset we were not yet a unit—and didn’t become one till Wellington.’ The bus arrived in Dubbo an hour later. We all had dinner, went for a swim in the local council pool, and then walked to the Dubbo Hotel, where we noticed a sign above the doorway: ‘Aborigines not allowed in the Lounge without the Licensee’s permission.’ This same hotel had a large Aboriginal clientele in the public bar—in part because, as Charles Rowley later wrote, ‘that was where Aborigines had got their supplies when it was illegal to sell to them’. We didn’t do anything about it, but instead went to the Methodist church where we were to stay. Alex Mills remembers that the Methodist minister, John Mason, welcomed us, and
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 76
76
Freedom Ride
that he was ‘the guy who later became the leader of the Liberal Party’. That evening, Alex visited Jack Gowdie, the Presbyterian minister in Dubbo, and told him, his wife and his son John about the bus ride, and what it was about, as Alex understood it. John, a first-year student at the University of New England (UNE) in Armidale, and involved in its Society for Aboriginal Advancement, decided to join us. Gowdie had gone to school with Aboriginal children, and at UNE helped with a school support scheme for Aboriginal children. He had also been influenced by reading Charles Duguid’s No Dying Race, which began with a quote from John Ruskin he still remembered pretty accurately 30 years later: I saw an injustice done, and tried to remedy it. I heard a falsehood told, and was compelled to deny it. Nothing else was possible for me. I knew not what would come of my actions, or whether I was fit for them, but here was a lie, full set in front of me, and there was no way round it but over it. For us, Dubbo was simply an overnight stop, but in fact it was a place of some significance in Aboriginal Australian history. It had traditionally been an important camping area before European settlement, and continued as a centre of religious activity, with the Aborigines Inland Mission located there, and large religious gatherings being held there from time to time. It had been a centre of Aboriginal protest in 1938–39, when William Ferguson and Pearl Gibbs led one arm of the all-Aboriginal Aborigines Progressive Association (APA) seeking equal rights (the other arm of the organisation was based in Sydney, and led by Jack Patten). The all-Aboriginal political movement of the late 1930s is probably now best remembered for the ‘Day of Mourning’ it held on Australia Day, 26 January 1938, in protest at the triumphal sesquicentennial celebrations, emphasising that for Aboriginal people white settlement was not something to commemorate and celebrate. In rural New South Wales, the target of protest was the Aborigines Protection Board; Gibbs and Ferguson wanted nothing less than its abolition. In December 1938, a meeting of the APA at Talbragar, the riverside Aboriginal reserve 5 miles (8 kilometres) out of town, called for support for the agricultural development of Talbragar, Nanima and Burra Bee Dee reserve at Coonabarabran. The following year, the APA mounted a major campaign against the board for moving people around against their will, providing poor schooling,
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 77
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
77
denying social welfare benefits and removing children. A major conference of the APA in Dubbo over Easter 1939, with 60 Murris attending, criticised not only the board, but also the white towns for segregating schools and hospitals. The APA faded away during the war years. On Sunday, 14 February 1965, we were up by 6.30 a.m., and left with our new recruit, John Gowdie, on board at 9.15 a.m. There was as yet no newspaper or television coverage of the Freedom Ride, but someone must have had a radio, for we heard there was some local radio publicity about our presence in the area. The next stop was Gulargambone, not far from the Castlereagh River, in what had once been Kawambarai land, just north of Wiradjuri country. Just 30 miles (48 kilometres) from the slightly larger town of Gilgandra, it was—and remains—a very small town indeed. It had one hotel, one café, one grocery store and several hundred permanent residents. The white residents lived on one side of the Castlereagh River, and the Aboriginal people on the other. About 120 people lived on the reserve, less than a third of its population of five years before, and it was to halve its population again within three years of our visit. It was no wonder people were leaving: the reserve consisted of several shacks, with very few amenities such as electricity or sewerage, and had a rubbish tip and a sanitary depot about 150 metres from the houses. Three months later, Mrs Baxter, one of the residents, explained to a television reporter how the shacks were made: They buy their own tin; they buy their own piece of timber from the mill. Sometimes they make one-room places, sometimes they make two-room places, but they can never get enough tin or timber to make verandahs and bathrooms, or a washhouse or anything like that because the tin’s too dear for them and they’re only just working men. As in Wellington, Charles and the other Freedom Riders had little or no contact with the local Aboriginal people, so it was again a matter of conducting the survey. We had permission to visit the reserve, though only for an hour. Visiting the Gulargambone reserve was a sobering experience. Darce recorded an interview with Jim, who commented on the lack of normal facilities, the poor conditions of the houses and the proximity of the sewerage to the reserve. Jim’s film of Gulargambone
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 78
78
Freedom Ride
shows an unidentified Aboriginal man standing outside one of the houses, the camera panning to emphasise the makeshift corrugated iron roof. Charles told The Methodist a month later: ‘We found a reserve about 2 miles [3 kilometres] out of town. It was in a deplorable condition— sub-standard houses surrounded by barbed-wire fencing, not much water, no electricity. Fifty yards [metres] from the reserve was an open sewage pit the stench and flies from which came across the reserve causing a lot of diarrhoea, eye sore, skin sores, etc. among the people in the reserve.’ Jim later remembered it ‘mainly because the Aboriginal community was the other side of the town rubbish dump’. He was shocked by the conditions there: It was well out of the town, and it was very depressed, I mean just appalling conditions, and that would have been my first experience personally. I mean I’d heard and they’d sent pictures, but my first experience of Aboriginal living standards directly. That’s why I remember Gulargambone; I can’t remember what happened there. Everyone interviewed remembered it in much the same way. Not that everyone did remember Gulargambone—Charles, for instance, said to Inara in 1994: ‘I have no memories of Gulargambone’, and Norm McKay commented: ‘Gulargambone has sort of terrible memories for some reason but I can’t quite remember why.’ Many of the others, though, recall how shocked they were by what they saw. Warwick, for instance, said Gulargambone was the first place where the situation of Aboriginal people was really brought home to him: I remember—pretty sure it was Gulargambone—going to a mission. Some of the experiences that stand out from the Freedom Ride—a lot of it obviously at that distance of time is a series of impressions that meld together—but what was fairly striking was the stark images of deprivation that one got first hand in going into living conditions where there were, you know, houses with no doors and with no windows and cars with no wheels and no sanitation and no water, flies, rubbish, people cooking over fires, children obviously ill with running noses and flies in their eyes and all of those sort of things . . . I think the thing that struck me most were just those sort of very stark conditions that made quite an impact in terms of the
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 79
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
79
very abstract ideas of racism and deprivation that we had before we headed out. Alan Outhred has similar memories of recognising that the situation was far worse than we knew how to imagine: ‘Certainly, we knew we were going to strike conditions that were rough for the Aboriginal people we were visiting . . . but on the other hand to actually come and see—it certainly increased my understanding.’ For Pat Healy, it was ‘very hot . . . very hot and dry . . . There’s this sort of procession in my mind of huts and fibro houses and tin sheds and hot, dusty, flat, isolated living areas, with very primitive facilities. Blocks of toilets and showers and taps. Kids running around in the hot dust.’ Robyn Iredale says: ‘Well I’d never seen that sort of life before so I suppose I was shocked. But I’d read about it, I knew about it, but, yeah, I found it pretty disgusting that people lived like that. But it was taken for granted—I mean, nobody really questioned it too much in those days, you know, that was just the way Aborigines lived.’ I too remember a feeling of shock. My diary reminds me that I ‘spoke to Mr and Mrs Baxter—very old and very interesting’. I now have before me the form noting my interview with Mr Baxter that day. He agreed that Aboriginal people were as good as the white people in every way and should have more say in their affairs, and disagreed that the Welfare Board was doing a good job. He thought Aborigines should be on reserves, not in towns, and that they should stand up for their rights. I also noted in my diary that ‘Welfare board and police very much disliked’. Warwick remembers the people’s hatred of the police well: One thing that struck me when we were interviewing Aborigines on the trip, I think at Gulargambone . . . four Aborigines who were telling us about the police, and they were recently out of gaol and they told us that they were staying out of the town on the reserve, which was essentially controlled by the police. And the police would simply roll in, come through the door or the window, at any hour of the night. If there’s any kind of disturbance out there, the police would roll out and would know who the troublemakers were and would simply go and arrest people. So they could be in bed with their wife and the police would come and drag them out and thump them. And they got so sick of this that, even though they knew the consequences, every
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 80
80
Freedom Ride
now and again when they’d had a few drinks they’d decide they’d had enough, they’d wait behind the door until the police arrived and then they’d thump the Christ out of the police and go to gaol for six months after being beaten up in the police station. And they said it was worthwhile. The message Robyn Iredale received was the people’s hatred of the board. She spoke to another Mrs Baxter on the Gulargambone reserve (there were several Baxter families, and several Carrs), who said the ‘people on the Welfare Board [were there] to better [their] own ends’. Their conversation then turned—perhaps surprisingly, given the totally secular nature of our questions and concerns—to spirit beings. Robyn noted on the back of her survey form: Belief in Spirits. Little woman—see her dressed grey, or hear her—walks up flat. Once a week or once a month. See her come up to flat land to the fence— never hear her go . . . Mrs Baxter thinks it is the daughter she lost—same size. Son thinks it was a ghost. Robyn remembers this interview well: I’ve got a really interesting slide that I think is Gulargambone, where we went out to a reservation, and I remember talking to these Aboriginal people about spirits and the spirits of ancestors and so on, and I asked them could I take a photo of them standing in front of their little tin shed before I left. And when I got the photo developed, there looks like there’s another person there, and to me this was really strange because I’d had this conversation and then the photo comes back with an almost mystical other person in it. In the afternoon, we conducted our surveys in the town. Beth remembers Gulargambone as an ‘isolated one-horse town, three shops in the main street . . . The dryness and the dust.’ She remarked: ‘Don’t remember any connection with the Aboriginal people there. I remember eating in a café, and the high school, some connection there.’ For Aidan: ‘Gulargambone was sort of a novel experience. It was a funny little town. I’d never been in a place quite as wild as that.’ He also remembers going to
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 81
O n t h e w a y t o Wa l ge t t
81
the hospital: ‘I went to see the babies . . . and I think they were on the verandah off the one ward. There would have only been a tiny hospital there with a few beds.’ To put on a demonstration, we needed firm evidence of discrimination and support from the local Aboriginal community. It was soon clear we had the first. We quickly confirmed that only certain Aborigines were allowed in the hotel, none could get served in the one and only café, and blacks and whites sat separately in the picture theatre. One of the survey respondents reported that, in the café, Aboriginal people were ‘not allowed to sit down and have a meal’, and that they could not stay and drink in the hotel. Charles later told an interviewer that ‘in the café aborigines can stand up but they can’t sit down for any meals. The proprietor said that when he first came to the town he did allow aborigines to sit down for meals but the white people complained and wouldn’t do business with him. So now he won’t allow aborigines to sit down for meals.’ Another survey respondent, an 18-year-old, said the local constable ‘picked on’ the young men. Noreen Carr said that in the picture theatre you ‘can mix, but because of attitudes of whites don’t feel right so sit separately’. She also reported discrimination at ‘dances, work and school’; in the long run, she wanted homes in town. Darce recorded an interview with an Aboriginal man that confirmed these accounts: Cassidy: Can you go into the picture show in Gulargambone any time you want to? Man: Yes I can. Cassidy: And you sit anywhere you like? Man: Ah . . . no. Cassidy: Why’s that? Where do you have to sit? Man: Well it’s not so much that you’re made to, but there is a separate spot in the picture hall for the dark people . . . Cassidy: Now we’ve heard some stories about the café here. What goes on there, can you get a meal there? Man: Ah, no, you can’t get a meal there, but you can get anything else that you want there. It was crystal clear that racial discrimination was rife in Gulargambone, yet the leaders of the Freedom Ride agreed that this was not the place for a demonstration. We didn’t have local support and, perhaps even
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 82
82
Freedom Ride
more importantly, we didn’t have any media coverage or interest at this point. We would have been demonstrating with hardly an audience. We had to go to a bigger town. So, at around 4.00 p.m. we left Gulargambone and drove on to Walgett, arriving three hours later. Hopefully, in Walgett, we would meet up with the local Aboriginal people, confirm the existence of racial discrimination and, at last, demonstrate against it. We were itching for some action.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 83
4
Chapter
High noon at Walgett
T
he students desperately wanted media attention, and knew something more striking than an amateur survey was needed to get it. Walgett seemed especially promising for our purposes, given its reputation for racial discrimination and the presence of Aboriginal people who had already proven they were willing to speak out. The town seemed to be waiting for us, to test our mettle. The question was, were we up to the task? The Walgett township lies at the junction of the Barwon and Namoi Rivers, the natural boundaries for two traditional language groups—the Gamilaraay (in older texts rendered as Kamilaroi) and Yuwaaliyaay (Uralarai); other nearby groups included the Wayilwan (Wailwan). All are known as Murri, the name for Aboriginal people in a large region covering Queensland and northern and central New South Wales. Amongst the first Europeans to visit the area were Thomas Mitchell and his party in 1831. Frontier violence was rife in the 1830s and 1840s, reaching its peak in 1843 after the manager of the Gingie station on the Barwon River was killed. Pastoralists continued to press into the district, and direct conflict seems to have been over by 1855. The numbers of Aboriginal people in the district dropped rapidly in the wake of white settlement, partly as the result of violent conflict, but mostly from starvation and disease. Once direct conflict was over, the various Murri groups wanted to stay on their own land. Many began working on the pastoral stations, which were originally mainly cattle but later predominantly sheep. 83
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 84
84
Freedom Ride
Heather Goodall, in her book Invasion to Embassy, and John Ferry, in Walgett Before the Motor Car, tell some of the story of these survivors and fighters. Permanent camps were established at several sites near the town of Walgett itself, the most popular being at Namoi Bend, with many smaller camps on the stations. In 1895, the Aborigines Protection Board established a reserve at Gingie station 6 miles (10 kilometres) out of town in order to keep people away from Walgett and under board control. The people, however, refused to go there for several decades; Gingie station only became a reality when the board forcibly removed people from the Namoi Bend settlement to it in 1925. The camp at the Bend continued, however, and its population grew after 1936, when the board closed down the Angledool station, 60 miles (100 kilometres) to the north. Angledool had by this time become a problem station, with the demand for pastoral labour declining, poor housing and epidemic trachoma. On 26 May 1936, over 100 people were taken away by truck to Brewarrina, but over the next few months and years, many went on to Walgett and other towns. Angledool remains important in the memory of many Walgett people. As Frances Peters-Little, whose mother’s family is from Walgett, points out, many Walgett people have continued to identify with the Angledool mission, right up to the present. ‘Proclaiming Angledool as their site of Aboriginal heritage and culture,’ she writes, ‘their links to Angledool were perhaps strengthened by the terrifying events surrounding the night it was abandoned at midnight during winter in 1936 when families were split and forced on to the back of cattle trucks and transported to unknown destinations.’ Soon after the growth in its Aboriginal population as a result of the forced removal from Angledool, the Aboriginal political movement of the late 1930s came to Walgett. A public meeting in Walgett chaired by the Mayor, held on 20 February 1939, heard Bill Ferguson and Jack Kinchela of the Aborigines Progressive Association speak about the need for change, and passed a motion asking for Aboriginal representatives on the proposed new Welfare Board (a request which was granted). The Welfare Board carried on the plans of its predecessor for more control over the growing Aboriginal population at Walgett. The Gingie reserve was upgraded to a station, with a manager appointed in 1941, and became known as the Gingie mission. Despite somewhat better facilities than at the campsites, many people refused to move there, and continued to camp at the Bend. They could afford to do so: the war meant employment.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 85
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
85
When Marie Reay studied Aboriginal society in Walgett during World War II (one of the first anthropologists to study a ‘part-Aboriginal’ community), she found the Murris there much engaged in shearing and cutting scrub. Reay also found sharp racial segregation; racial intermixing was not possible, and any white people mixing with Aboriginal people were regarded as Aborigines, not whites. Most whites did not know Aboriginal people personally, and saw them in town brawling and drinking, regarding them as ‘unclean’. She reported that, though they failed to keep Murris out of town, the whites did keep places of entertainment segregated. After the war, the high demand for Aboriginal labour initially continued, with Welfare Board annual reports indicating 96 per cent male employment. From the 1950s, however, pastoral employment gradually decreased, and as a result the station camps gradually disappeared. The residents from nearby Dungalear pastoral camp, for example, moved into Walgett, though some people continued to work on the property during the 1950s. With the station camps disappearing, the population of Walgett continued to grow, with men living in or near town and working in a range of occupations on the nearby properties—as shearers, drovers, musterers and labourers. Others worked in blue-collar jobs for the council, the Department of Main Roads or on the railways. By the mid-1950s, the Walgett white townspeople were becoming alarmed at the rise in the Murri population, alleging that public drunkenness was driving whites out of the town. One of them, businessman Mr John Cooper, was quoted in the Sunday Telegraph on 25 August 1957 as saying the Aboriginal people in Walgett were drunken and lawless: ‘I’ll be packing up unless the Government does something about the aboriginal problem.’ Cooper told the Telegraph that the Aboriginal population had increased by 30 per cent in the last eighteen months, so that the numbers of Aborigines and whites were almost equal: ‘They seem to think they can come to Walgett, do as they like, and have no fear of reprisals.’ Cooper was quoted as saying the women would ‘make a play for any white man who looks as if he can afford to amuse them’. Cooper’s suggested solution was to appoint a welfare officer who could keep the people in check. In response to the Telegraph’s story, the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship sent a delegation consisting of its secretary, Irene McIlwraith, and Mrs Garland, wife of John Garland of the Amalgamated Engineering Union, a fellowship affiliated union, to Walgett to investigate. They stayed for four days, from 6–10 September, and talked to many people. As McIlwraith, a
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 86
86
Freedom Ride
refugee from Nazi Germany in the late 1930s, wrote to John Garland soon afterwards, they had walked ‘the length and width of Walgett on foot from dawn to dusk’. Their report provides an unusually detailed glimpse of race relations in a country town in the 1950s. On their return to Sydney, McIlwraith described rigorous segregation—separate church services, separate playgrounds at school, exclusion from hotels, separate seating in the picture theatre and separate living areas. The Anglican vicar, Reverend Hadlow, had tried to have mixed congregations, and had been prevented from doing so by the local whites. Living conditions were appalling: the Gingie mission still had no water supply other than the river, and no decent road into town, while the Namoi camp also had no water supply, no sanitation and no electricity. At Gingie, the station manager visited houses once a week, a much-resented imposition on people’s privacy. The local doctor was unsympathetic; McIlwraith’s report quoted him as saying that ‘they do not want to mix with us and I think the best would be if we had special towns for them, run by themselves, where they would not bother us and we would not bother them’. Walgett Aboriginal people, however, were not to be moved. They had retained something of their political radicalism from the pre-war period and wanted a better deal in town. As Mrs McIlwraith later wrote: ‘All the Aborigines we spoke to [in] Walgett said that what they wanted most was full citizenship rights.’ The two women called a meeting in the church hall on the Saturday evening, which about 40 Aboriginal people attended. They showed a film about the treatment of Aborigines at the Warburton reserve in Western Australia, and played a recorded speech by Bert Groves, a well-known figure in the region. They explained why they had come, and that the fellowship wanted the people of Walgett to know they had outside support. The Reverend Hadlow and Alec Trevallion, the Town Clerk, also spoke, and George Hill spoke on behalf of the Aboriginal people. He said: ‘I live on the Mission and I am an Aborigine. After serving six years with the Australian Army overseas, I came back to Walgett. When I went into the local hotel for a drink, I was rudely ordered out.’ Twenty-two Aboriginal people, along with Trevallion, Hadlow and John Cooper (now eager to distance himself from the comments attributed to him by the Telegraph), signed the fellowship petition requesting a change to the Constitution. When she returned, Irene McIlwraith did everything she could to alert Sydneysiders to the state of affairs in Walgett. Her letter
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 87
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
87
in the Sydney Morning Herald on 2 November drew readers’ attention to the ‘appalling conditions in Walgett’, with 400 people living in shanties on the riverbank, without electricity, gas or water, and Aboriginal women kept in a separate ward in the hospital, and men on one side of the male ward. The solution, many whites thought in the 1950s, was to house more Aboriginal people on the board’s stations. That way, they would be under surveillance, and cause less trouble in the towns. Their living conditions would also be better. A Herald editorial two days after McIlwraith’s letter recommended doubling the spending on Aboriginal housing, so that more Aboriginal people could be accommodated on the stations. Yet the funding for Aboriginal housing remained low, and towns like Walgett continued to witness a struggle by the whites to keep the Murris out of town. In 1958, young anthropologist Jeremy Beckett wrote in the Sydneybased discussion magazine, The Observer, that the Aboriginal population was growing and the problem of poor Aboriginal housing and social marginality could only get worse. Aboriginal people wanted to stay together; government policies meant the price they had to pay to do so was shocking housing conditions, and racial dislike and hostility from the whites. He ended his article with the prescient remark: ‘In a few years the country towns of the North and West are going to have a very ugly race problem on their hands.’ Walgett returned to the attention of the Sydney papers in 1960, as part of a Sydney Morning Herald series of feature articles called ‘Survey of Aboriginal Life’. The report on Walgett on 27 October emphasised the large number of Aboriginal child deaths in the area, and quoted the local Presbyterian minister, Reverend A.R. Ewin, who said ‘apathetic Government authorities and the public had shut their eyes to the tragedy’. The Town Clerk, Alec Trevallion, told the Herald ‘the commonwealth government will have to finance local authorities to handle the situation’, for example by funding the employment of ‘male and female social workers to teach the aborigines hygiene’. Some time after this, the riverbank settlement on the north side of the river was declared the Namoi reserve, in an attempt by the board to exert some control over conditions there. (Although gazetting new reserves was by this time against board policy— which was to locate people in houses in town—the refusal of councils to allow Aboriginal housing in town forced the board to create a number of reserves around this time, usually—like this one—comparatively small
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 88
88
Freedom Ride
and close to town.) The settlement on the south side, closer to town, had become known as Montkeila Bend. In Walgett, the council-owned swimming pool was open to all at the insistence of Trevallion, who seems to have been relatively sympathetic to Aboriginal people, at least by the standards of the time. But private enterprises like hotels, shops, cafés, cinemas and private clubs were another matter. After its 1957 visit, the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship continued to keep a watch on Walgett. One of its members, Barbara Gibbons, wrote to Jack Horner after her visit there in May 1964: ‘In Walgett, George and I noticed something I would like to draw the Fellowship’s attention to. The bar lounge of the “Oasis Hotel-Motel” had a notice on the door in very fancy lettering and incorrect spelling “Aborigines admitted only by invertation”.’ Horner showed the letter to David Tribe, a member of the fellowship who had been the schoolteacher at the Gingie mission school for some years until December 1963. Tribe confirmed the story, and told Horner of other instances of racial discrimination: the refusal of the Returned Servicemen’s League (RSL) Younger Set to admit Aboriginal people, and the exclusion of Aboriginal people from upstairs in the picture theatre. Horner hoped to set up an organising committee of the fellowship in Walgett itself. Meanwhile, he tried to act on the matter of discrimination through a flurry of letters. On 22 June he sent one to Athol White, the manager of the Oasis Hotel-Motel, asking him why the motel had a notice saying Aborigines could enter only by invitation, and another to several Aboriginal residents at the Gingie station, asking whether they wanted any action taken. There is no record of a reply from the latter, but White replied at length: ‘The policy of my hotel,’ he told Horner, ‘is to be of service to the majority of the people of the district, and to maintain a good standard of facilities for their enjoyment.’ Aborigines who behaved decently and who were dressed tidily ‘would be most welcome to enjoy these facilities’. However, the number of Aborigines answering this description ‘is very minute’. The notice, he said, ‘was to save embarrassment to the Aborigines, and also to ourselves, as having to constantly eject them because of their general behaviour and disgusting language is embarrassing to us, our patrons and must also be to them’. Yet, in the end, it was not the appalling housing conditions or racial discrimination in the hotel and the picture theatre that dramatically brought Walgett into public notice the year before the students arrived.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 89
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
89
It was the police and the courts. In June 1964, as the students had learned from speeches made at their meeting and rally in July, two 9-year-old Aboriginal boys were gaoled for two days and two nights in a police cell in Walgett for stealing from the Anglican church hall two table tennis bats and balls and crayons, together worth a total of 30 shillings ($3). The Sydney Sun featured the case as a page 1 story written within the tabloid tradition of ‘exposure journalism’, calling for sympathy with the boys and outrage at the authorities who had put them there. It also drew attention to the poor conditions under which Walgett’s Aboriginal population lived. The Sun story began: ‘Two weeping nineyear-old aboriginal children have been locked up for two days and nights in a police cell at Walgett. They cried continually during the night, prisoners who were in an adjoining cell told me yesterday.’ It went on to report that one white citizen had written to the editor saying: ‘I am ashamed of the society I live in. Townspeople can see the children in gaol with their little arms hanging through the bars.’ The two boys were Roy Hickey and Fred Morgan, who lived on the reserve on the outskirts of Walgett. During discussion with the magistrate the next day, one of the mothers agreed it would be better for the boys to be taken to a boys’ home: ‘We are desperately poor—it is so hard for coloured people to get work around here . . . Fred has no future around Walgett and that’s why I thought he would have a better chance in life if he went to a home for boys. But when I found out he was put in the town lockup I nearly collapsed.’ Jack Horner wrote directly about the matter to the Reverend P.J. Dowe, minister at St Peter’s Church of England, from which the bats and balls had been stolen. Dowe wrote a long letter in reply, worth quoting because he was soon to play an important role in the Freedom Ride story. He had agreed, you may remember, to accommodate the students in this same hall. Dowe had little sympathy for the two boys who had been gaoled for stealing toys from his church hall; indeed, it seems possible that complaints from the church had led to police involvement. He had even less for their mothers, commenting that the mother of one ‘has no concern for the boys at all’. He objected to Horner’s assumption that Aboriginal people in Walgett had a hard time: The dark people here have been well treated in this district (with some exceptions). That is why so many have come to this town. They are
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 90
90
Freedom Ride
accepted by most of the whites (again with some exceptions). They have the same opportunities as whites. There is no shortage of work. They are paid as well [as] or better than the whites. There appears to be plenty of money among them. The problems lay not with white racism, but with the Aboriginal people themselves: ‘We still have to tackle the basic problem of how to develop a sense of responsibility and the urge to take the possibilities before them, e.g. to develop skills and to use their money properly.’ Dowe went on: ‘They have had no end of gifts and “hand outs” and they are quite content to take all these, but it has only encouraged them to sit back and take things easy . . . There is a complete apathy and lack of concern to help themselves.’ Yet, if the Reverend Dowe had little sympathy for the boys, many others were moved by this story. Letters poured into the Sun, Charles Leon writing on behalf of the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship, saying ‘most people will share the indignation of the people of Walgett at the callousness that left two small Aboriginal boys in a police cell for two days and two nights, as part of their punishment for stealing some toys and crayons. The rest of their punishment is to be removed from their families and placed in a children’s home’. Several unions took up the case, writing to government agencies. In early July, a delegation of five men representing three unions visited the town to investigate the gaoling. Two of the five were Aboriginal—Alan Woods (from the Builders’ Labourers Federation (BLF), and also a member of the AboriginalAustralian Fellowship), and Jack Hassen (from the Waterside Workers’ Federation (WWF), and also former boxer—indeed, lightweight champion of Australia). The other three were Dick Prendergast (BLF), Jim Hill (Building Workers’ Industrial Union) and Jack Hartley (WWF). The visit was well publicised, with television and radio reports preceding the arrival of the delegation. The unionists met on 3 July with some local Murri activists who facilitated meetings with the two mothers and liaised between the delegation and the Aboriginal community. Two members of the community are especially important to our story. One was Harry Hall, a Gamilaraay man who in the 1960s lived at Montkeila Bend and was one of the town Aboriginal residents most accepted by white society in Walgett. He had been a shearer, then worked at the Walgett garage, and later for the
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 91
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
91
Department of Main Roads. Another was George Rose, one of the few remaining Yuwaaliyaay speakers, who had grown up in Brewarrina, joined the army late in the war, and settled in Walgett in 1949. In the army, where he had been a sergeant, he had experienced and enjoyed racial equality. His wife, Mavis, was also a strong community activist. Like Harry, George was a shearer and a member of the Australian Workers’ Union, and at this point, he was also a member of the Communist Party. The report written as a result of this visit went far beyond the original gaoling incident. It described the tin shanties, and reported first-hand accounts of the brutality and sadism of one particular policeman. Most importantly for our story, the delegation learnt of the exclusion of returned Aboriginal Diggers from the RSL Club, except sometimes on Anzac Day, and the sign ‘Aboriginals by invertation only’ at the Oasis Hotel-Motel. Two of their members interviewed the manager of the RSL Club, Tom Hogan, and an official, T. Quinlan, who agreed that returned Aboriginal Diggers were only admitted to the club on Anzac Day. ‘They denied,’ said the report, ‘that this was racial discrimination and said that they were only following past practices.’ The delegation also reported that ‘perhaps the most important event of our trip was a meeting of 100 Aborigines on the Sunday, who, after listening to our delegation, elected a committee to protect their interests’. This became the Walgett Aborigines Progressive Association (APA), loosely connected to the Aborigines Progressive Association formed by Bert Groves and others in Sydney some months earlier. It involved Harry Hall and George and Mavis Rose, and also Gladys Lake and Ted Fields. Harry Hall now became president of the newly formed APA, and remained so until 1973. There were also, Harry told me in 1991, some white people in the APA, especially Mrs Collins, who was a member for years, and whose son owned the garage that Harry used to work in. Back in Sydney, the New South Wales Labor Council adopted the trade union delegation’s recommendation that it seek a government investigation into the gaoling and the situation in Walgett more generally. A Labor government was in power, led by Jack Renshaw whose own electorate of Castlereagh included Walgett, but this by no means guaranteed government sympathy with the children and their families or a sympathetic hearing of the Labor Council delegation. While the Labor Council waited for an appointment with the Minister for Child Welfare, the Children’s Court in Sydney declared the children wards of the state
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 92
92
Freedom Ride
and decided they should go to a foster home. Delegates from the unions and the Labor Council finally met the Minister for Child Welfare in September, and another delegation from the Newcastle Trades Hall Council met him soon afterwards. The request to return the children to their parents was refused, the reason given being ‘bad housing’. The housing situation in Walgett was at crisis point by this time, with the Aboriginal population in Walgett nearing the 1000 mark, many of them living in the shanty town settlements along both sides of the Namoi River. There were different schools of thought on how to deal with the crisis. The Aborigines Welfare Board wanted to build ‘transitional housing’—that is, cheap, low-standard houses—on the Namoi reserve, in order to stretch its budget to supply the need. The shire council, which had been pressed by the Aboriginal-Australian Fellowship on the question of housing in mid-1964, strongly opposed the concept, wanting increased government funding for proper housing. Only four days before the students arrived, the council agreed to improve the housing, sanitation, drainage and access road for the Namoi reserve. Aware of only a fraction of this history and these debates, the students arrived in town just before 7.00 p.m. on a hot summer evening on 14 February. They settled into the St Peter’s hall and some went to the service that evening. Alex Mills remembers: ‘I did go to church in the Anglican church on the Sunday night and we actually sang the hymn . . . “Lord Jesus, There is No Room in My Heart for You”.’ Just across from the hall were the basketball courts, and some of the other students had a few games with the local Murri team, the Anglican Fellowship Basketball Team. One of its members was Phillip Hall, Harry’s son, and another was Bob Morgan, later to become a leading figure in Aboriginal education, but then a 14-year-old in Walgett. Bob recalls: ‘We were intrigued, I remember, about why would white fellas be coming—I remember as kids we had games of basketball.’ It must have been that evening, or perhaps it was on the bus trip into Walgett, that we agreed our target would be the RSL Club. A decisionmaking structure was emerging. Decisions over whether to demonstrate or not were made democratically by the whole group. There was also a tour ‘executive’, consisting of Charles, Jim and Pat, which represented the students to outside bodies, and which also was in charge of ‘discipline’— that is, ensuring that students who acted violently would be expelled from the tour. We also agreed that Charles would make all official press
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 93
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
93
statements, and in his absence either Jim or Pat would do so. The RSL, the whole group now agreed, was an ideal target for news-making. In a society where ex-servicemen were held in high esteem, and seen as embodying nationhood and national identity, racial discrimination against an ex-serviceman was easily ridiculed and attacked. Charles thought it was important that we had chosen an RSL Club, as he later recalled: To demonstrate outside the RSL, the great sacred cow at that time, you know, nobody criticises the RSL, they can do whatever they like . . . we decided that that would be the prime objective, to fly in the face of the most cherished institution in Australia, because they were very racist, and they were not only that they were arrogant, and they were self-centred and very discriminating and opinionated and everything else. Though the exclusion of Aboriginal ex-servicemen from the Walgett RSL Club was perhaps a small matter compared with the massive problems in housing, health and education confronting Aboriginal people at the time, it had great symbolic importance. For it was in the commemoration of war that Australian popular culture found its most profound sense of nationhood. This was as true in Walgett as everywhere else. From the 1920s, war memorials were erected in practically every country town; in Walgett, the war memorial was at the centre of the town, at the intersection of its two main streets, and the location of practically everything in town could be marked by its relation to the monument. Nationally, the RSL found itself in a contradictory situation in respect to Aboriginal ex-servicemen. On the one hand, it regarded the status of returned soldier as transcending all others, and had successfully pressed for Aboriginal ex-servicemen to be given the right to vote (granted in March 1949 by the Commonwealth Labor government for federal elections). On the other hand, it was a conservative organisation, and remained aloof from campaigns for full citizenship rights for Aboriginal people. It had no policy specifically preventing its clubs from excluding Aboriginal exservicemen from membership, leaving it to local clubs to determine their own policies. The Walgett club was thus free to exclude Aboriginal exservicemen from membership and use of the club, though local Murri activists like Harry Hall, George Rose and Ted Fields had been protesting about its exclusionary practices (and much else) for some years.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 94
94
Freedom Ride
Monday, 15 February 1965: My diary records that the next morning we were up at 7.00 a.m. and ‘heard announcement over radio that we intended to picket RSL at 12.00. All surprised that news had got out.’ The Reverend Dowe was not pleased at what he heard, and told us we couldn’t stay in the church hall if we carried out our plans to demonstrate. What should we do? We held a long and serious meeting. Here was the first chance to put the ideals of passive resistance into action, yet if we demonstrated where would we stay? After much discussion, we decided to go ahead anyway. Diary: Had meeting and decided to acquiesce in police demands only to point where acquiescence would break up demo. Then would passively resist. Also decided that anyone acting violently would be suspended immediately, and later subjected to general meeting at which it would be decided to send the person home or not. In deciding to go ahead, we had also, it seemed, called Dowe’s bluff. Seeing we had nowhere else to stay, Dowe reluctantly agreed that we could remain in the church hall. The Australian reported that ‘plans were being made for them to sleep in abandoned tram cars when they learned they would be allowed in the hall again’. Mr Dowe told the Australian he was strongly opposed to the picket of the club: ‘It is only stirring up racial feelings which don’t exist in the town . . . I thought they were coming to Walgett purely to study Aboriginal conditions.’ Quite a lot of time had been lost in discussion, and the demonstration was to begin at noon. We made placards, a process Jim Spigelman recorded on film. Aidan Foy remembers: ‘Wherever we stayed there was enough space to make all the placards because I do remember doing that.’ At this point, another student joined the bus, bringing our number up to 30—Hall Greenland, a member of the ALP Club, educated first at Fort Street Boys’ High School, now about to enter his third year in an Arts degree at Sydney University. He had been away on holidays on the north coast and caught a train down to join the bus. He later described himself as ‘a scholarship boy from a middle-class background’: his father was a plasterer, his mother a clerk. Some years before, his father had left, and ‘so we were a single-parent family . . . a working mother and three kids. We lived at Summer Hill and I suppose my mother classified herself as a revolutionary, libertarian, non-Stalinist
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 95
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
95
Image rights unavailable
Machteld Hali draws the placard asking, ‘Good enough for Tobruk. Why not Walgett?’. (Photo courtesy of the Tribune/Search Foundation)
socialist.’ Hall had already had some experience of Aboriginal shanty towns, when he visited Dareton, outside Griffith on the Murray River in the south of the state, in the summer of 1962–63 just before starting university. He told me: Being a good left-winger and occasionally seeing Aboriginals when I was on holidays up and down the coast, I knew that there was a certain amount of poverty and degradation about the way they lived. But then when I saw them living in this shanty town outside Griffith—with a single tap and of course their humpies—it did actually really shock me and brought home to me, the two or three months I lived in a country town, what their actual living conditions were like. I can remember going to a public meeting there about the fluoridation of water, and moving an amendment to the resolution at the public meeting in favour of fluoridation, that it be delayed until proper piped water and septic tanks and so on had been installed in the Aboriginal camp. That the municipal money that was going to be spent on fluoridation be redirected to that. And it was like a bloody lynch mob.
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 96
96
Freedom Ride
When asked why he joined the bus, he said he had ‘twin objectives’: ‘I was, I suppose, as much interested in the politics of it as in one of the women who was actually going on the bus. So I thought this was a good chance to actually meet her and get close to this particular woman.’ What most of the other students didn’t know was that Hall at the time had a ‘foster brother I suppose—for about five or six years at this time’, an Aboriginal youth from the Northern Territory named Maynard Burmester, who had been living at the factory where Hall’s mother worked, and then became part of the household. After the meeting, we separated out into groups and conducted our survey. Jack Horner ’s letter to Jim Spigelman just weeks before the Freedom Ride left Sydney had summarised the housing situation in Walgett tersely and accurately: ‘Walgett: 1. Reserve six miles out of town, Board houses. 2. Riverbank two miles out of town, bad conditions. 3. Camping grounds in town, shocking conditions.’ We did not have permission to visit the first of these, the Gingie mission with its board manager, where about 150 people lived, as the board still had to meet to consider our application. So one group went to the Namoi reserve while others went into town. I went to the reserve, where over 260 people lived, and we interviewed people for several hours. Diary: Most of the people I spoke to very shy and diffident, and said they were quite happy. Conditions very bad—had to use filthy water, tin shacks with mud floors, overcrowded. Eighteen of the survey forms filled in that day survive. One woman refused to answer questions because, as one of the students noted on the back of the form, ‘previous surveys had humiliated them through newspapers, radio, TV reports . . . and [they] did not see any results from surveys anyway’. This was possibly a reference to the intense media coverage of the previous year. From the others—mainly from women— some consistent themes came through: the desire for houses, perhaps in town, for a better water supply, and better medical services. Mrs Kennedy said Aboriginal people could not buy blocks of land, and mentioned the need for ‘better water instead of river water’, and proper sanitary arrangements. The people consistently reported on examples of racial discrimination in the town—exclusion from the Walgett RSL, the frock shop (Sheen’s, according to Phillip Hall 36 years later), upstairs in the cinema,
Freedom Ride Text Pgs 27/9/02 10:42 AM Page 97
H i g h n o o n a t Wa l ge t t
97
and the Oasis Hotel-Motel lounge. Mrs Fernando mentioned that, at the doctor’s, Aboriginal people were not treated until the Europeans had been seen to. One 16-year-old girl said Aboriginal people could not get jobs, the frock shop barred Aboriginal people, and the police were rough and tough, often putting the young men in gaol. Another group of students interviewed people in the town, both European and Aboriginal. Some Aboriginal people worked there, and some families—like the Peters family—now lived there. Aidan went to the local hospital, and also interviewed the town doctor, ‘who was disappointed because he’d hoped he’d be interviewed by an attractive female medical student and he was upset being confronted with me’. Alex Mills interviewed a young Murri man who worked as an assistant storeman at the shire council. He was willing, he said, to have his name submitted to the Walgett RSL together with other suitable Aboriginal applicants. Alex wrote on the back of the form that his neighbour reported that ‘he and his family are good neighbours’. Wherever we went, the story of racial discrimination was the same. Again and again we heard about the Oasis lounge, the frock shop and the cinema. Diary: Obviously considerable discrimination in the town . . .