Fundamentals
of Ceramic Powder Processing and Synthesis
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Fundamentals of Ceramic...
76 downloads
1423 Views
34MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Fundamentals
of Ceramic Powder Processing and Synthesis
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Fundamentals of Ceramic Powder Processing and Synthesis Terry A. Ring Department of Chemical and Fuels Engineering and
Department of Materials Science and Engineering University of Utah Salt Lake City, Utah
?P A c a d e m i c Press San Diego New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
Photo taken from Millot, G., La Science 20, 61-73 (1979). Please see Chapter 1 for more information.
This book is printed on acid-free paper. ( ~
Copyright 9 1996 by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. A c a d e m i c Press, Inc. A Division of Harcourt Brace & Company 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495
United Kingdom Edition published by Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NW1 7DX Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Ring, Terry. Fundamentals of ceramic powder processing and synthesis / by Terry Ring. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 0-12-588930-5 (alk. paper) 1. Ceramic powders. I. Title TP815.R56 1995 95-15418 666--dc20 CIP
PRINTED IN THEUNITED STATES OF AMERICA 96 97 98 99 00 01 MM 9 8 7 6 5
4
3
2
1
To Susan's understanding
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents
Preface xxi
I
INTRODUCTION HISTORY, RAW MATERIALS, CERAMIC POWDER CHARACTERIZATION 1.1 General Concepts of Ceramic Powder Processing References 6
1
4
Ceramic P o w d e r Processing History a n d Discussion of N a t u r a l R a w Materials 1.1 Objectives 7 1.2 Historical Perspective 8 1.3 Raw Materials 27 1.3.1 Natural Raw Materials 27 1.3.2 Synthetic Raw Materials 34 1.4 Selecting a Raw Material 40 1.5 Summary 41 References 41
2
Ceramic Powder Characterization 2.1 Objectives 43 2.2 Introduction 43
vii
viii
Contents
2.3 Powder Sampling 44 2.3.1 Sampling Accuracy 44 2.3.2 Two-Component Sampling Accuracy 45 2.3.3 Sampling Methods 46 2.3.4 Golden Rules of Sampling 46 2.4 Particle Size 48 2.4.1 Statistical Diameters 48 2.4.2 Mean Particle Size 52 2.4.3 Size Distribution Accuracy 55 2.5 Particle Morphology 56 2.5.1 Shape Factors 57 2.5.2 Shape Analysis 59 2.5.3 Fractal Shapes 60 2.5.4 Internal Porosity 62 2.6 Powder Density 63 2.7 SurfaceArea 64 2.7.1 First Layer Adsorption~Langmuir Adsorption 64 2.7.2 Multilayer Adsorption~BET Adsorption 65 2.8 Particle Size Distributions 66 2.8.1 Normal Distribution 68 2.8.2 Log-Normal Distribution 69 2.8.3 Rosin-Rammler Distribution 72 2.9 Comparison of Two-Powder Size Distributions 73 Problem 2.5. Comparison of Two Size Distributions 74 2.10 Blending Powder Samples 75 Problem 2.6. Mixing Two Log-Normal Size Distributions 76 2.11 Summary 78 Problems 78 References 79
H 3
CERAMIC POWDER SYNTHESIS The Population Balance 3.1 Objectives 85 3.2 Microscopic Population Balance 86 3.3 Macroscopic Population Balance 87 Problem 3.1. Constant Stirred Tank Crystallizer 88
Contents
ix
3.4 Population Balances Where Length, Area, and Volume Are Conserved 89 3.4.1 Conservation of Length in the Batch Grinding of Fibers 89 3.5 Population Balances on a Mass Basis 91 3.5.1 Population Balances on a Discrete Mass Basis 91 3.5.2 Population Balances on a Cumulative Mass Basis 92 3.6 Summary 93 3.6.1 Microdistributed Population Balance 93 3.6.2 Macrodistributed Population Balance 93 3.6.3 List of Symbols 93 References 94
4
Comminution a n d Classification of Ceramic Powders 4.1 Objectives 95 4.2 Comminution 96 4.2.1 ComminutionEquipment 96 4.2.2 Energy Required for Size Reduction 101 4.2.3 Comminution Efficiency 102 4.2.4 Population Balance Models for Comminution Mills 103 4.2.5 Array Formulation of Comminution 110 4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders 115 4.3.1 Dry Classification Equipment 115 4.3.2 Classifier Fundamentals 117 4.3.3 Size Selectivity, Recovery, and Yield 123 4.3.4 Classifier Efficiency 124 4.3.5 Wet Classification Equipment 127 4.4 Comminution and Classification Circuits 129 4.5 Summary 135 Problems 136 References 136
5
Ceramic P o w d e r Synthesis with Solid Phase R e a c t a n t 5.1 Objectives 139 5.2 Introduction 140 5.3 Thermodynamics of Fluid-Solid Reactions
141
X
Contents
5.4 Oxidation Reactions 144 Problem 5.1. Free Energy of Oxidation 145 5.5 Reduction Reactions 147 5.6 Nitridation Reactions 148 5.7 Thermodynamics of Multiple Reaction Systems 148 Problem 5.2. What Is the Reaction Product When A1 Metal Is Exposed to Air at 800~ 149 5.8 Liquid-Solid Reactions 151 5.9 Fluid-Solid Reaction Kinetics 151 5.9.1 Shrinking Sphere Model 157 5.9.2 Comparison with Kinetic Models 158 5.9.3 Kinetic Models Where Nucleation and Growth Are Combined 161 5.10 Fluid-Solid Reactors 162 Problem 5.3. Conversion of a Size Mixture of Ceramic Powders 165 5.11 Solid-Solid Reactions 166 5.11.1 Vaporization of One Solid Reactant 167 5.11.2 Solid-Solid Interdiffusion 170 5.12 Summary 176 Problems 177 References 178
6
Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation 6.1 Objectives 179 6.2 Introduction 180 6.3 Nucleation Kinetics 183 6.3.1 Homogeneous Nucleation 183 6.3.2 Heterogeneous Nucleation 189 6.3.3 Secondary Nucleation 192 6.4 Growth Kinetics 193 6.4.1 Stages of Crystal Growth 196 6.4.2 Diffusion Controlled Growth 196 6.4.3 Surface Nucleation of Steps 202 6.4.4 Two-Dimensional Growth of Surface Nuclei 203 6.4.5 Screw Disclocation Growth 204 6.4.6 Summary of Growth Rates 208 6.5 Crystal Shape 210 6.5.1 Equilibrium Shape 210
Contents
6.5.2 Kinetic Shape 212 6.5.3 Aggregate Shape 214 6.5.4 Crystal Habit Modification by Impurities 216 6.6 Size Distribution Effects--Population Balance and Precipitator Design 220 6.6.1 Continuous Stirred Tank Reactor 220 6.6.2 Batch Precipitation 226 6.6.3 Effect of Aggregation on the Particle Size Distribution 229 6.7 Coprecipitation of Ceramic Powders 244 6.7.1 True Coprecipitation 244 6.7.2 Simultaneous Precipitation and Coaggregation 246 6.8 Summary 249 Problems 249 References 250
7
P o w d e r Synthesis with Gas Phase R e a c t a n t s 7.1 Objectives 255 7.2 Introduction 256 7.3 Gas Phase Reactions 260 7.3.1 Flame 260 7.3.2 Furnace Decomposition 262 7.3.3 Plasma 262 7.3.4 Laser 262 7.4 Reaction Kinetics 263 7.4.1 Combination Reactions 265 7.4.2 Thermal Decomposition Reactions 267 7.4.3 Laser Reactions 268 7.4.4 Plasma Reactions 269 7.4.5 Complex Reaction Mechanisms 269 7.5 Homogeneous Nucleation 270 7.6 Collisional Growth Theory 275 7.7 Population Balance for Gas Phase Synthesis 278 7.8 Dispersion Model for Gas Synthesis Reactors 280 7.8.1 Single-Point Nucleation 284 7.8.2 Multipoint Nucleation 285 7.9 Population Balance with Aggregation 289 7.9.1 Rapid Flocculation Theory 290 7.9.2 A Physical Constraint on the Population Balance 292 7.9.3 Other Numerical Models 295
xi
xii
Contents
7.10 Quenching the Aggregation 296 7.10.1 Heat Transfer Quench 298 7.10.2 Gas Mixing Quench 300 7.11 Particle Shape 301 7.12 Summary 303 Problems 303 References 304
8
Other Ceramic Powder Fabrication Processes 8.1 Objectives 307 8.2 Spray Drying 307 8.2.1 Atomization 309 8.2.2 Droplet Drying 315 8.2.3 Gas-Droplet Mixing 327 8.2.4 Spray Dryer Design 330 8.3 Spray Roasting 331 8.4 Metal Organic Decomposition for Ceramic Films 335 8.5 Freeze Drying 336 8.5.1 Problem: Freezing Time for a Drop 338 8.6 Sol-Gel Synthesis 340 8.6.1 Precursor Solution Chemistry 343 8.6.2 Film Formation 347 8.6.3 Gel Drying 349 8.6.4 Thermal Decomposition of Gels 350 8.6.5 Gel Sintering 350 8.7 Melt Solidification 351 8.8 Summary 353 Problems 353 References 354
III 9
CERAMIC P A S T E F O R M A T I O N - MISE-EN PATE Wetting, Deagglomeration, and Adsorption 9.1 Objectives 359 9.2 Wetting of a Powder by a Liquid 360 Problem 9.1. Spreading H20 on SiO2 364
Contents
9.3 9.4
9.5 9.6
10
xiii
9.2.1 Smooth versus Rough Surfaces 366 Problem 9.2. Wetting of a Rough Solid Surface 368 9.2.2 Partial Wetting of a Solid 368 9.2.3 Internal Wetting 368 9.2.4 Heat of Wetting 370 Problem 9.3. Solvent Selection 373 Deagglomeration 374 9.3.1 Ultrasonification 375 Adsorption onto Powder Surfaces 379 9.4.1 Gibb's Adsorption Isotherm for the Liquid-Vapor Interface 380 9.4.2 Adsorption Isotherms for the Solid-Liquid Interface 382 9.4.3 Binary Solvent Adsorption 384 9.4.4 Adsorption of Ions 386 Problem 9.4. Surface Change 394 9.4.5 Adsorption of Ionic Surfactants 398 9.4.6 Adsorption of Polymers 403 9.4.7 Selection of a Surfactant 410 Chemical Stability of a Powder in a Solvent 414 9.5.1 Stability in Water 414 Summary 416 Problems 417 References 418
Colloid Stability of Ceramic Suspensions 10.1 Objectives 421 10.2 Introduction 421 10.3 Interaction Energy and Colloid Stability 422 10.3.1 van der Waals Attractive Interaction Energy 422 Problem 10.1. H a m a k e r Constant 427 10.3.2 Electrostatic Repulsion 428 10.3.3 Steric Repulsion 445 10.3.4 Total Interaction Energy 466 10.4 Kinetics of Coagulation and Flocculation 467 10.4.1 Doublet Formation 467 Problem 10.2. Determine the Half-Life for Doublet Formation for Various Initial Number Densities of Particles in Water 467
xiv
Contents
10.4.2 Growth and Structure of Large Aggregate Clusters 475 10.4.3 Shear Aggregation 486 Problem 10.3. Critical Size for Shear Aggression 487 10.5 Colloid Stability in Ceramic Systems 488 10.6 Summary 489 Problems 489 References 491
11
Colloidal Properties of Ceramic Suspensions 11.1 Objectives 495 11.2 Introduction 496 11.3 Sedimentation 497 Problem 11.1. Terminal Settling Velocity 499 11.3.1 Nonspherical Particle Settling 500 11.3.2 Hindered Settling 500 Problem 11.2. Hindered Settling Velocity 502 11.3.3 Centrifugal Sedimentation 503 11.3.4 Sedimentation Potential 503 11.4 Brownian Diffusion 504 11.4.1 Nonspherical Particle Diffusion 504 11.4.2 Fick's Laws for Diffusion 505 11.4.3 Equilibrium between Sedimentation and Diffusion 505 Problem 11.3. Sedimentation Equilibrium 506 11.4.4 Rotational Diffusion 506 11.5 Solution and Suspension Colligative Properties 509 11.5.1 Osmotic Pressure of Electrolyte Solutions 511 11.5.2 Osmotic Pressure of Polymer Solutions 512 11.5.3 Osmotic Pressure of the Double Layer in a Colloidal Suspension 513 11.6 Ordered Suspensions 516 11.6.1 Osmotic Pressure (and Other Thermodynamic Properties) of a Ceramic Suspension 517
Contents
11.6.2 Measurement of Ordered Array Structure 526 11.6.3 Defects in Ordered Arrays 527 11.6.4 Processing Effects on Order Domain Size 529 11.6.5 Measurement of Ordered Domain Size by Light Diffraction 530 11.6.6 Effect of Ordering and Domain Size on Ceramic Processing 531 11.7 Summary 532 Problems 532 References 533
IV 12
G R E E N B OD Y F O R M A T I O N - MISE-EN FORME Mechanical Properties of Dry Ceramic Powders and Wet Ceramic Suspensions 12.1 Objectives 541 12.2 Introduction 542 12.3 Equations of Motion 543 12.3.1 Continuity Equation 543 12.3.2 Momentum Balance 544 12.3.3 Constitutive Equations for Dry Powders 545 12.3.4 Constitutive Equations for Fluids 545 12.4 Ceramic Suspension Rheology 550 12.4.1 Dilute Suspension Viscosity 551 12.4.2 Rheology of Concentrated Ceramic Systems 562 Problem 12.1. Hard Sphere Stress-Strain Curve 569 12.4.3 Ceramic Paste Rheology 585 12.5 Mechanical Properties of Dry Ceramic Powders 590 12.5.1 Coefficient of Pressure at Rest 592 12.5.2 Compact Body 594 12.5.3 Plastic Body 595
XV
xvi
Contents
12.5.4 Yield Criteria for Packings 596 12.5.5 The Coulomb Yield Criterion 597 12.5.6 Yield Behavior of Powders at Low Pressures 599 12.6 Summary 602 Problems 603 References 605
13
Ceramic Green Body Formation 13.1 Objectives 609 13.2 Introduction 610 13.3 Green Body Formation with Ceramic Suspensions 612 13.3.1 Slip Casting 613 13.3.2 Filter Pressing 618 13.3.3 Tape Casting 620 13.3.4 Sedimentation Casting and Centrifugal Casting 629 13.3.5 Electrodeposition 636 13.3.6 Dip Coating 638 13.4 Extrustion and Injection Molding of Ceramic Pastes 643 13.4.1 Flow in the Extruder 644 13.4.2 Flow in the Extrusion Die 646 13.4.3 Flow into the Injection Molding Die 651 13.5 Green Body Formation with Dry Powders--Dry Pressing 653 13.5.1 Tapped Density 654 13.5.2 DiePressing 656 13.5.3 Stress Distribution in the Ceramic Compact 661 13.5.4 Deformation of Visco-Elastic Solids and Fluids 667 13.5.5 Die Ejection and Breakage 667 13.5.6 Isostatic Pressing 671 13.5.7 Green Machining 673 13.6 Green Body Characterization 674 13.7 Summary 675 Problems 675 References 677
oo
Contents
XVll
V
PRESINTERING HEAT TREATMENTS OF DRYING A N D B I N D E R B URNO UT
14
Green Body Drying 14.1 Objectives 683 14.2 Introduction 683 14.2.1 Heat Transfer 686 14.2.2 Mass Transfer 687 14.2.3 Flow of Liquid in the Pores 689 14.2.4 Drying Shrinkage 690 14.2.5 Drying Induced Stresses 691 14.3 Sphere and Cylinder Drying 693 14.3.1 Boundary Layer Heat and Mass Transfer Giving the Drying Rate for the Constant Rate Period 693 14.3.2 Shrinkage during the Constant Rate Period 695 14.3.3 Diffusion and Heat Conduction in the Porous Network Giving the Drying Rate for the Falling Rate Period 698 Problem 14.1. Drying Time Calculation 700 14.3.4 Cylinder Drying 702 14.4 Drying of Flat Plates 703 14.5 Warping and Cracking during Drying 705 14.5.1 Thermal Stresses Induced during Drying 708 Problem 14.2. Temperature Difference Induced Tensile Stress 712 14.5.2 Flow Stresses during Drying 713 14.5.3 Capillary Stresses 716 14.6 Characterization of Ceramic Green Bodies 718 14.6.1 Green Density 719 14.6.2 Uniformity of Microstructure Mixedness 719 14.6.3 Green Body Strength 721 14.7 Summary 726 Problems 726 References 727
xviii
15
Contents
Binder Burnout 15.1 Objectives 729 15.2 Introduction 730 15.2.1 Heat Transfer 731 15.2.2 Mass Transfer 732 15.3 Thermal Degradation of Polymers 733 15.3.1 Reaction Kinetics 737 15.3.2 Polymer Residues and Volatiles 738 15.4 Oxidative Polymer Degradation 738 15.4.1 Reaction Kinetics 749 15.4.2 Polymer Residues and Volatiles 750 15.5 Kinetics of Binder Burnout 752 15.5.1 Kinetics of Binder Oxidation 755 15.5.2 Kinetics of Volatiles Loss 758 Problem 15.1. 760 15.5.3 Kinetics of Binder Pyrolysis without Oxygen 761 15.5.4 Kinetics of Carbon Removal 762 Problem 15.2. 765 15.6 Stresses Induced during Binder Burnout 767 15.6.1 Thermal Stresses Induced during Binder Burnout 768 15.6.2 Stresses Due to Volatile Flow 770 15.7 Summary 771 Problems 772 References 775
VI 16
SINTERING AND FINISHING Sintering 16.1 Objectives 781 16.2 Introduction 782 16.3 Solid State Sintering Mechanisms 785 16.3.1 Driving Force for Sintering 786 16.3.2 Sintering Kinetics by Stage 788 16.3.3 Effect of Green Density of Sintering Kinetics 811
Contents
16.4
16.5
16.6 16.7 16.8
17
16.3.4 Effect of Particle Size Distribution on Sintering Kinetics 812 16.3.5 The Effect of Fractal Aggregates on Sintering Kinetics 817 Grain Growth 824 16.4.1 Normal Grain Growth 827 16.4.2 Abnormal Grain Growth 840 ReactiveSintering 844 16.5.1 Sintering wtih a Liquid Phase 844 16.5.2 Solid State Reactive Sintering 860 16.5.3 Gas-Solid Reactive Sintering 861 Pressure Sintering 864 Cool Down after Sintering 867 Summary 869 Problems 869 References 871
Finishing 17.1 Objectives 875 17.2 Introduction 875 17.3 Ceramic Machining 876 17.3.1 Effect of Machining on Ceramic Strength 877 17.3.2 Effect of Grinding Direction on Ceramic Strength 878 17.3.3 Effect of Ceramic Microstructure on Strength 879 17.3.4 Grinding and Machining Parameters 880 17.4 Coating and Glazing 882 17.5 Quality Assurance Testing 883 17.5.1 Proof Testing 884 17.6 Nondestructive Testing 886 17.7 Summary 888 References 889
Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix
A B C D E F
Ceramic Properties 891 Gamma Function 893 Normal Probability Function t Test 901 Reduction Potentials 903 Thermodynamic Data 905
895
xix
XX
Contents
Appendix G Summary of Differential Operations Involving the V-Operator in Rectangular Coordinates (x, y, z) 915 Appendix H Summary of Differential Operations Involving the V-Operator in Cylindrical Coordinates (r, 0, z) 917 Appendix I Summary of Differential Operations Involving the V-Operator in Spherical Coordinates (r, 0, d~) 919 Appendix J Liquid Surface Tensions 921 Appendix K Drago E and C Parameters 925 Appendix L Hildebrand Solubility Parameter and Hydrogen Bond Index 929 Appendix M Hydrated Cation Radii 935 Index 937
Preface
In the past 15 years ceramic powder processing and synthesis have undergone a transformation. Scientific and engineering methods have been applied in this field at a much higher level than ever before, allowing much greater control of properties than could be achieved previously. Ceramic systems are not simple and therefore these scientific and engineering methods had to achieve sufficient sophistication to be adaptable to this field. We now have many examples of the application of these scientific and engineering methods to ceramics. As a result these first examples can be explained to students of ceramics, who with this knowledge, can continue this evolution of sophistication in the fundamentals of ceramic powder processing and synthesis. This book was written in an attempt to do just that. The organization of this book is explained in the introduction. Basically, it is organized like a ceramic manufacturing facility starting with raw materials and ending with sintering and finishing. Various chapters contain problems within the text for illustration. At the end of each chapter, additional problems allow the reader to go into greater depth using the material presented in the chapter. These problems are not necessarily easy but the reader's efforts to resolve them will result in much greater knowledge of the material covered in the chapters. Finally, I acknowledge the help of others in writing this book. Many long nights over a period of more than six years were spent writing this book and my family has suffered as a result. This book is dedicated to my understanding wife, Susan. Many people have helped me with concepts and ideas. Professor Alain Mocellain critiqued the outline of this book and made many useful suggestions. Dr. Paul Bowen, Dr. xxi
xxii
Preface
Dennis Gallagher, Dr. Jacques Lemaitre, and the LTP-EPFL students performed the very important task of proofreading the manuscript. Dr. Bowen provided gentle guidance in areas where rewriting was required. Academic Press provided a long list of anonymous reviewers, one for each chapter; I am indebted to them for many helpful suggestions. Elizabeth Burdet worked diligently to minimize the other work in my laboratory so that sufficient time was available to write this book. Silvia Yvette helped with typing the first draft of this manuscript, Wilma Bunners made many of the more complex drawings found in the text, and my wife, Susan, read each chapter for English corrections. Many thanks to all.
Terry A. Ring
PART
I I N T R OD UC TION: HISTORY, RAW MATERIALS, CERAMIC POWDER CHARACTERIZATION
Many options are to be considered in organizing a book on the fundamentals of ceramic powder processing. One could organize a book along phenomenological lines (e.g., similar thermodynamics and reaction or diffusion kinetics) or along material classifications lines (e.g., oxides, carbides, and nitrides) or along material properties lines (e.g., structural ceramics and electronic ceramics). After considering the many possibilities, this book has been organized as if the reader were following a ceramic process in a factory from powder to final finished piece. Ceramic powder processing can take two traditional routes: one is a wet powder processing route, where the powder is mixed in the liquid and cast into the green body before firing; the second is a dry ceramic powder processing route, which consists of pressing the dry powder (with binder) into the green body and then firing. Both of these processing routes are shown in the Figure 1.1. This is the flow sheet for the computer controlled tile making facility for the ' INAX Corporation in Japan. Here they use these two routes, a wet paste-extrusion route and a dry-pressing route, to make ceramic tiles. These processing routes are also used for modern ceramics such as tiles for the space shuttle's surface and electronic BaTiO3 capacitors. In this figure one sees all the steps that go into making ceramics, starting with grinding the ceramic powders to develop a very fine particle-size distribution (the grinding circuits contain classification and recycle loops). This is
2
Part I
Introduction
followed by putting the ceramic powder into liquid form, adding different additives to adsorb to the particle surface and prevent coagulation of the particles, as well as to adjust the rheology of the paste and provide a binder of the particles after consolidation. The paste is then dewatered to the best consistency for extrusion into the desired shape. The resulting green bodies are dried very slowly, then subject to binder burn-out treatment at higher temperatures followed by sintering. During sintering, pores are removed from the ceramic body, leaving behind a fully dense piece which must then be finished in some way (e.g., applying a glaze or grinding to size). This constitutes the wet route as shown in Figure 1.1. The outline of this book follows that sequence of events very closely. As a result we have the following parts of this book:
F I G U R E 1.1
Ceramictile manufacturingprocess. Photo courtesyof Inax Corp., Japan.
Part I Introduction
3
Part I. Introduction: History, Raw Materials, Ceramic Powder Characterization Part II. Ceramic Powder Synthesis Part III. Ceramic Paste Formation: Mise-en Pdte Part IV. Green Body Formation: Mise-en Forme Part V. Presintering Heat Treatments of Drying and Binder Burnout Part VI. Sintering and Finishing The parts are further broken down into chapters discussing the chemical, physical, and engineering fundamentals of each step of the process. The other route for ceramic manufacturing, starting with dry powders and pressing them with a polymer or binder, is discussed in this book in the different sections. This route will have in common with the wet processing methods the steps of powder synthesis and ceramic green body formation, binder burn-out, sintering, and finishing; thus, the reader interested in the dry powder processing route can follow this processing sequence by stepping over various materials which are not of interest. For the students particularly interested in ceramic part manufacture, Part II of this book, discussing ceramic powder synthesis, would be of less interest. As a result the student can start with the part three after reading the introductory chapters in Part I on raw materials and ceramic powder characterization. Each chapter is broken into sections with the first section always stating the objectives of the chapter, and the last section always providing a summary of the chapter. In the text, problems are worked to elucidate the points discussed. Finally at the end of each chapter there are unworked problems that the students can do for homework. The book attempts to provide a large list of references for specific concepts and ideas presented elsewhere, and we hope that the reader will refer to these references for the derivation of specific equations not presented. This book is highly mathematical in comparison with other texts in the field, because this field should be much more quantitative than heretofore presented. With these mathematics, the field of ceramic powder processing can become more quantitative in the future.
4
Part I Introduction
1.1 G E N E R A L C O N C E P T S POWDER PROCESSING
OF C E R A M I C
Several general ideas are associated with ceramic powder processing. These general ideas have been generated after many years of research and have resulted in a philosophy of ceramic powder processing. The first idea is that uniformity in the microstructure of a single phase ceramic is better for electrical and mechanical properties. This idea is based on the Griffith fracture theory for ceramics, where the strength of the ceramic is related to the largest flaw size. With a bigger flaw size, weaker single phase ceramics result. Uniformity is also important for electrical ceramics. For example, the final grain size distribution of BaTiO3 should be uniform to have the highest dielectric constant for ceramic capacitors or the highest piezoelectric coupling constants for actuators. In the case of the capacitor, the grains should be uniformly small; and in the case of the actuator, they should be uniformly large to achieve the orthorhombic crystal structure necessary for piezoelectricity, which is prevented for grains less than 1 micron in size for pure BaTiQ. The idea of uniformity remains for both large and small grains in the case of electrical properties. This is sometimes difficult when cannibalistic grain growth occurs during sintering, leading to a bimodal grain size distribution. For this reason, dopants are used to prevent cannibalistic grain growth. Another idea is that the microstructural inhomogeneities that occur in casting a green body remain (or even get larger) during drying, binder burn-out, and sintering. Therefore, to obtain the best uniformity the casting process must be performed very carefully with suspensions that contain no bubbles or large pieces of polymers. In addition, the uniformity produced in the green body should not be destroyed by rough handling. In the case of drying and binder burn-out, huge volumes of gas, many thousands of times that of the green body itself, must leave the green body. This process puts tensile stress on the green body which can cause cracks. To prevent these cracks, drying and binder burnout conditions which are very slow are desirable. Uniformity is also extended from the green body casting down to the ceramic suspension utilized for casting. In this case uniformity of the particles used is important because larger and smaller particles segregate into different parts of the mold during casting of monophase ceramics, leading to
1.1 General Concepts of Ceramic Powder Processing
5
nonuniformity. This is the same reason why stable colloidal suspensions are used for casting to prevent packing inhomogeneities caused by aggregates. With composite ceramics which consist of two or more different phases, uniform mixing in the suspension is also important. This may be impossible if the two powders utilized have either different densities or different particle-size distributions or both. For this reason, the suspension is often flocculated with polymers so that the well-mixed nature of a suspension is preserved in the flocs..These flocs, with their inhomogeneous packing of particles, are then broken into homogeneous green bodies by pressing at high pressure. The last general concept of ceramic powder processing is that smaller powders sinter to give smaller grains that give a stronger ceramic piece. This idea is again based on the Griffith fracture theory for ceramics, where the strength of the ceramic is related to the largest flaw size. Assuming homogeneity, a smaller grain size will result in a smaller flaw size, leading to a stronger ceramic. The sintering times tl and t2 for two powders with the same chemistry but different particles sizes rl and r2 is given by Herring's scaling law [1]:
t2 = [r2/rl]ntl where n is a constant depending on the sintering mechanism. In the case of volume diffusion, n = 3. From the Herring scaling law, we see that, as the mean particle size is decreased, the time needed to sinter a ceramic piece is decreased. These general concepts will play an important role in the selection of a process for the manufacture of a particular ceramic part and as a result these general concepts will be encountered again and again throughout this book.
Reference 1. Herring, C., J. Appl. Phys. 21, 301 (1950).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1
Ceramic Powder Processing History and Discussion of ~~atural Raw ?daterials
1.1 O B J E C T I V E S This chapter will give the reader a historical perspective of the field of ceramic powder processing. This field has a long and rich history which in many ways is impossible to trace because it goes back to before writing. Nonetheless, there is a rich archaeological record of ceramic articles produced by different technologies from which we can learn a great deal. In addition, this chapter presents the raw materials used for ceramic manufacture both historically and in the present day. Finally an overview of the organization of this book is presented. This book is organized like a ceramic factory, with powder synthesis and preparation first followed by paste preparation, forming, drying, binder burnout, and sintering.
7
8
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
1.2 H I S T O R I C A L P E R S P E C T I V E The first ceramic objects in the archaeological record are fired clay figures appearing about 22,000 B.C. [1]. These figures were probably n a t u r a l clay pieces shaped by h a n d into a h u m a n o i d form, allowed to dry, and placed in a fire. This art form gradually became used for more practical objects such as bowls and storage vessels on a m u c h larger scale. This larger scale of production became an integral part of the Chinese villages about 6000 B.C., where the ceramic kiln played a central role [17]. As a result, the f u n d a m e n t a l s of ceramic powder processing, the title of this book, have been practiced for over eight millennia [1 ]. A highly developed ceramic technology was in place for e a r t h e n w a r e like t h a t shown in Figures 1.1 [2] and 1.2 [2] well before the Bronze Age (about 4000 B.C. [3]), at a time when silkworm cultivation was also invented. These red pottery vases have a complex shape and are painted with black o r n a m e n t a l patterns. Figure 1.2 was excavated at Pan-p'o,
FIGURE 1.1 Red pottery vase with a contracted waist, a black design on a red base
that covers the earthen ware (brown). It was excavated at Lan-chou, Kansu, in 1958, and is 18.3 cm in height, from the third millenium B.C. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
1.2 Historical Perspective
9
Yang-shao bowl excavated in 1954-57 at Pan-p'o, Shensi, made of red pottery painted with black (carbon) triangles over a slip of white clay, 12.7 cm in height, from the fifth or fourth B.C.Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
FIGURE 1.2
Shensi, China* with other objects t h a t date it to 5000 B.C. or 4000 B.C. The gloss of the paint results from b u r n i s h i n g the clay before firing. The deep red color suggests the use of a clay (i.e., kaoline, an aluminosilicate mineral) containing hematite, a red iron oxide. This pottery was fired in a kiln of a relatively advanced design, capable of t e m p e r a t u r e s up to about 1000~ because only at t e m p e r a t u r e s above 900~ does kaolinite sinter to reasonable s t r e n g t h [4,5]. By 3000 or 2000 B.C., a b u r n i s h e d black pottery was produced as shown in Figure 1.3 [6]. This type of pottery, excavated at Wei-fang, S h a n t u n g , China, is either entirely black or has a black surface with a grey core. Analysis of the polished surface shows t h a t it has only a higher concentration of carbon t h a n at the core. Much debate has centered on how this polished surface was achieved. But, due to the presence of carbon in the clay body, the kiln design m u s t have been sufficiently advanced to give a reducing atmosphere. This pottery is similar to the present day S a n t a Clara pottery produced by the Indians in the s o u t h w e s t e r n USA. * Note that all Chinese names have been romanized by the Wade-Giles system.
10
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.3
Tall beaker, tou, excavated in 1960 at Weifang, Shantung. It is of burnished black pottery, 16.1 cm in height, and from the third or second millenium B.C. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
The first archaeological record of bronze production in China comes from an Erlitou Culture (1700 B.C.) site in Henan, Shanxi, China [6]. Bronze is an alloy of copper and tin (although in ancient China, lead was also frequently used). The earliest known Chinese bronze object is shown in Figure 1.4, which has 92% copper and 7% tin. This wine cup displays the basic metalworking features of the Chinese Bronze Age, which are sharply different from Near Eastern and Western traditions. This alloy is not an accident but a deliberate choice and indicates that a complex metallurgical infrastructure was in place to mine the ores of both metals and then smelt each ore to its respective metals.
1.2 Historical Perspective
11
FIGURE 1.4 Wine cup with tripod feet, of bronze, from the seventeenth century B.C. (one of the earliest so far known). Taken from "Treasures from the Bronze Age of China" [6].
Most important, this bronze vessel has seams which show it to have been cast from a mold made in four separated sections. This wine cup required a complex ceramic mold, which sets the early Chinese bronze technology apart from the lost-wax process used in the West. The production of bronze is a major undertaking. Sources of copper and tin must be located and protected. The ore must be mined and the metal removed. In the case of copper, this is difficult because copper accounts for only a small fraction of the volume of the ore. In ancient China, the ores seems to have been crushed, liberated, separated, and smelted at the mines and then transported to communities for casting. The melting of large quantities of metal, primarily copper, Tm = 1085~ required elaborate kilns and huge fires of high intensity; skills that had developed out of the ceramic tradition. Casting required controlled cooling of the metal to avoid holes and cracks in the finished object; skills which also relied on the precise fitting ceramic molds. During the Shang Dynasty (1600 to 1027 B.C.), when writing was first developed, bronze metallurgy developed into a highly skilled technology. Shang bronze molds where made from loess, the wind-blown ochrecolored soil that covers much of the landscape of northern China. Loess is rich in micas, fine quartz, sodium feldspar, and alkaline minerals
12
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.5 (a) Diagram showing how early Chinese bronzes were formed: (1) the model, (2) the sections of the mold, and (3) schematic of completed vessel.
[3]. The natural clay content (mostly illite) in loess ranges between 10 and 20%, which is enough to give it plasticity when mixed with water [3]. The unique property of loess as a ceramic molding material is that it does not shrink much as it is dried and fired [3] to 900~ Also, it is porous after firing, allowing the bronze to degas into the mold during solidification. By the Warring States Period (475 to 221 B.C.), there is evidence of the prolific use of ceramic multipart piece molds shown in Figure 1.5 in the direct casting of bronze vessels and weapons. In the Shang Dynasty, the first example of pottery covered with a high-fired feldspathic glaze [2] was observed. The body of this vase, shown in Figure 1.6, is of near stoneware hardness. The glaze, requiring kiln temperatures of 1200~ is spread uniformly over the whole body. This glaze technology then disappears from the archaeological record until the late fourth or early third century B.C. China's first emperor, Ch'in Shih Huang Ti, in about 221 B.C. united the various warring states of China by providing a uniform code of law, standards of currency, written language, and weights and measures
1.2 Historical Perspective
F I G U R E 1.5
13
(b) Actual completed vessel. Taken from "Treasures from the Bronze Age
of China" [6].
and completed the separate ramparts of the Great Wall of China, some 1000 km long, as protection from northern invaders. During his reign, ceramic and bronze arts were also practiced to perfection. In his mausoleum 7000 life size terracotta soldiers (one shown in Figure 1.7) and horses made of fired loess were discovered. On the eve of the Western Han Dynasty (206 B.C. to 8 A.D.), low-fired lead-fluxed glaze made its first appearance. This is the predecessor to the "polychrome" lead glasses of the Sui (581 to 618 A.D.) and T'ang Dynasties (618 to 906 A.D.). The colors of the lead glazes (i.e., brown, yellow, green, and blue) were produced by adding refined metal ores to the glaze mixture. A three-colored T'ang Dynasty vase, shown in Figure 1.8, is an example of this technology. These glazes were generally
14
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.6 Glazed pottery vase of high fired stoneware hardness, excavated in 1965 at Ming-Kung-lu, Cheng-chou, Honan. It is covered with a high-fried feldspatic glaze, 28.2 cm in height, and from the sixteenth or fifteenth century B.C. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
applied over a slip of white clay. During the T'ang Dynasty, the feldspathic glazes evolved into what is to become a long tradition of white porcelaneous ware like that shown in Figure 1.9. This glaze required firing at 1300~ This body has a glassy phase, filling the pores, giving a nonporous fired body. For this development, purified raw materials had to be used with a specific narrow range of chemical composition. This glaze was further refined into the subtle celedon green prolific in the Sung Dynasty (960 to 1279 A.D.). At this point the Chinese ceramics had reached one of its technological objectives, which was a porcelain
1.2 Historical Perspective
15
Life-sizefigure of a terracotta military commander in the mausoleum of the first emperor of China. Taken from "Treasures from the Bronze Age of China" [6].
FIGURE 1.7
body fused with a glossy, translucent green glaze that r u n g when struck and looked like jade. With the porcelaneous ware of the Yuan Dynasty (1271 to 1368 A.D.) underglaze painting of cobalt blue (cobalt oxide fired to give cobalt silicate, which is blue [7]) and copper red (copper oxide fired to give metallic copper, which is red [7]), present in the delicate
Tang Dynasty covered bowl, with lead glaze in green, brown, and yellow, excavated in 1958 at Loyang, Honan, 21 cm in height, from the first half of the 800s A.D. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
F I G U R E 1.8
White porcelaneous bowl, clear glazed with applied medallions, excavated in 1956 at Han-sen-chai, Near Sian, Shensi, 23 cm height, from the T'ang dynasty 667 A.D. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
F I G U R E 1.9
1.2 Historical Perspective
17
leaf and floral motifs of the vase with cover shown in Figure 1.10, indicate a new technological level of excellence. This was to be exploited in the Ming D y n a s t y (1368 to 1644 A.D.) and transferred to Europe to become the Meisen and Delft pottery of the early 18th century. Control of the a t m o s p h e r e during firing of these glazes (i.e., reducing conditions) was necessary to give the desired blue or red color and not simply black. The glazing technology culminated in the polychrome overglaze paints of the Ch'ing D y n a s t y (1644 to 1911 A.D.), Figure 1.11 [8].
White porcelain vase and cover with underglaze decoration of incised dragons and blue glaze waves, excavated in 1964 in Pao-ting, Hopei, 51.5 cm height, from the Yuan dynasty, late 14th century A.D. Taken from "The Genius of China" [2].
F I G U R E 1.10
18
Chapter 1 Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.11 Polychrome glazed vase decorated with flowers and insects in a peach branch, 51.4 cm height, from the Ch'ing dynasty, with a Ch'ien Lung mark, 1736-95. Taken from "A Handbook of Chinese Ceramics" [8].
Ceramic powder processing technology is discussed in the T'ao Shuo [9]. This text describes how kaolin raw materials had to be found and ground to the desirable size distribution. After grinding, the earth was washed and purified. This was done by mixing it with water in a large
1.2 Historical Perspective
1
earthen ware jar and stirring the mixture until all the organic impurities had floated to the top and were poured off. The resulting paste was next passed through a fine horsehair sieve and then into a bag made of two thicknesses of finely woven silk. Afterward, the paste was poured into several earthenware vessels, so that the excess water could run off. The paste was then allowed to sediment. The settled paste was further dewatered by wrapping it in a fine cotton cloth, and placing it in a bottomless wooden box resting on dry earthenware bricks. More bricks were piled on top of the cotton bag of paste to press and absorb more of the water, using both hydrostatic and osmotic pressure. When free of excess water, the paste was thrown on large stone slabs and turned over and over until it was ductile. The paste was worked into the green body shape by various techniques: coiled and layered by hand, thrown on a potter's wheel, slip cast or pressed into molds, or stamped. The green body was then dried slowly, so as not to crack it, and fired in a wood-burning kiln under oxidizing conditions at more than 900~ A stunning example of this type of technology are the 7000 life-size terracotta statues, each with a different face, of the army of the First Emperor of China, Emperor Ch'in (221 to 207 B.C.), at his grave site in Xian, China (see Figure 1.7). Historians believe there is an official document describing this ceramic powder processing technology that was among the official documents of the Ch'Hi state incorporated in 140 B.C. Indeed, updated copies of the Chou Li, an early encyclopedia of art and technology, shows wood block prints of the various processing steps. The wood block prints shown here are from "T'ao Shuo," Description of Pottery [9], in six books by Chu Yen. This work describes 20 woodblock prints dating from 1743 with T'ang Ying, director of the Imperial Factory at Ching-t~, narrating a description of each print. Several of these woodblock prints are reproduced in Figures 1.12 and 1.13 showing green bodyt shaping methods, decorating, and firing in a wood-burning kiln. Closely interacting with this earthenware technology were developments in metallurgy. Some of the metallurgical operations are described in the T'ien Kung K'ai Wu published in 1637 A.D. from which Figures 1.14 and 1.15 come [10]. Much of the glaze technology that sealed the outside of the porous earthenware structure and gave the body color and texture was a result of ceramic alloying of metal oxides, which were made available by metallurgical operations. The lead oxide flux glazes of the Han Dynasty (202 B.C. to 220 A.D.) and the T'ang Dynasty (618 to 906 A.D.) funeral ware were refined to give colors that t Unfired ceramic body. Green due to color of purified kaolin when wet. Also from the Chinese word Qing with the definitions (1) fresh and (2) green.
20
FIGURE 1.12
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
Woodblock prints of the stamping of a pattern on (a) and the firing of a "dragon kiln" with several chambers (b). named because they snaked their way at a constant gradient up the Taken from T'ien Kun K'ai Wu, 1637 print from "Description of Porcelain" [9].
the surface of a bowl These kilns were so contours of a hillside. Chinese Pottery and
included white, amber, yellow, green, and violet blue with a minutely cracked texture, analogous to the lead oxide glazes used today. The colors were obtained by adding refined metal oxides to the basic glaze formula and controlling the oxidizing or reducing conditions in the kiln. This history of ceramic powder processing technology is only a brief description of the events in China. In fact, other parts of the world also contributed to the technological developments of ceramic powder processing. Table 1.1 lists the roots of the ceramic technologies throughout the world. Egypt played an important part in the development of faience about 4000 B.C. and glass making about 1500 B.C. In the 9th
1.2 Historical Perspective
FIGURE 1.12
21
(Continued)
century Baghdad played a role in developing tin glaze ware, to cite some examples. One of the most interesting developments is that of porcelain manufacture [11]. Crude porcelain was first made during the T'ang dynasty in China (618 to 908 A.D.). This technology was carefully guarded by the Chinese but finally spread to Korea by the ll00s and to Japan by the 1600s. Marco Polo and other Western travelers described the Chinese porcelain to the Italian ruling class upon their return from the Far East, and they started importing pieces. Under royal patronage, alchemists tried to discover how the material could be manufactured, but without chemical analytical methods success came only from trial and error. In 1575, under the sponsorship of de Medicis in Florence, soft paste porcelain was developed, a mixture of clay and ground glass, fired at 1200~ The French also produced soft paste porcelain at Rouen and St. Cloud in the 1600s. Later in the 1600s, this technology spread
22
Chapter I
Ceramic .Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.13 Woodblock prints of painting the ceramicware with cobalt underglaze patterns (a) and using a wheel for painting a circle on the rim of a bowl (a). In (b), two men are dipping the painted ware into a great bowl of glaze prior to firing. Taken from T'ien Kun K'ai Wu, 1637. Print from "Description of Chinese Pottery and Porcelain" [9].
to other parts of France (Chantilly, Mennecy, Vincennes, and Sevres) and to England (Chelsea, Bow, and Derby) in the mid-1700s. The secret of true porcelain was not rediscovered in Europe until 1707 by von Tschirnhaus (a mathematician) and B~ttger (a kidnapped alchemist), who were "employed" by Augustus the Strong of Saxony. Augustus the Strong's fascination with collecting Oriental porcelain nearly bankrupted his kingdom. Using the crude scientific analysis of BOttger, Tschirnhaus recognized that true porcelain must be a mixture of natural materials and not ground glass as in soft paste porcelain. They ordered samples of clay from various parts of the kingdom and finally substituted ground feldspar for ground glass of the soft paste with a natural kaolin clay. Tschirnhaus and B~ttger established a true porcelain factory at Meissen near Dresden. The first major sales from this
1.2 Historical Perspective
F I G U R E 1.13
23
(Continued)
factory took place at the Leipzig Fair in 1713. This technology spread quickly across Europe, fueled by the demand of the new fad of drinking tea, coffee, and chocolate. Throughout this history the purity of the raw materials has been of the utmost importance. In ancient China the purification of raw materials was practiced for 8000 years with the use of purified white clay as a wash coat under designs. Ground feldspar of a closely controlled chemical composition was used for the very first glaze of the Shang Dynasty. During the Bronze Age, ceramic raw materials were first synthesized (e.g., lead oxide used for the basic glaze formula). In modern times, ceramic powder raw materials are still purified and synthesized by separate processes (e.g., Bayer process alumina, flame synthesis of titania, dead-burned magnesia) so that their purity is better controlled. This attention to raw material purity coupled with attention to the
24
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.14 Distillation of mercury in a retort, from T'ien Kun K'ai Wu, 1637. Re-
printed by permission of the publishers from "Science in Traditional China" [10], copyright 9 1981 by the Chinese University of Hong Kong. details of each process step are important attributes of the development of ceramic powder processing. In this brief overview of the first recorded ceramic powder processing, we find all of the attributes of this technology still with us today; for example, raw materials selection, grinding, size classification, raw material purification and blending, paste preparation, dewatering, green body formation, drying, and firing. In this regard ceramic powder processing is a very old art. Yet, in the last 10 years, enormous development has taken place in the scientific understanding of this very old art. Currently now that the speed with which these new developments emerge appears to be slowing down, it is time to reflect on what has been accomplished and where we stand scientifically. This book will give the state of the art of ceramic powder processing in the early 1990s. We should keep in mind that this field is still progressing and this book, like the official documents of the Ch'hi state incorporated
Liquidation process for the separation of silver from copper by lead, which is later cupelled, from T'ien Kun K'ai Wu, 1637. Reprinted by permission of the publishers from "Science in Traditional China" [10], copyright 9 1981 by the Chinese University of Hong Kong.
F I G U R E 1.15
TABLE 1.1
Outline of Ceramic History Showing the Main Lines of Technological Development
Prehistory of Ceramics -22,000 B.C. earliest known fired clay figures -8,000 B.C. fired earthenware vessels in Near East -6,000 B.C. slip coatings and clays prepared by decanting suspensions, ochre red and black decoration, manganese and spinel black pigments, control of oxidation, reduction during firing, impressed designs, rouletting, incised decoration, coil and slab construction, burnishing, joining paddle and anvil shaping, carving, and trimming -4,000 B.C. Egyptian faience 4,000-3,500 B.C. wheel throwing, earthenware molds, craft shops - 1 6 0 0 B.C. vapor glazing, prefritted glazes, lead glazes - 1 5 0 0 B.C. glass making, alkaline glazes - 1 0 0 0 B.C. glazed stoneware in China - 7 0 0 B.C. Greek black and red wares
Developments toward particular ceramic products Soft-paste porcelain
900s clay quartz ware in Egypt 1200s enameled minai ware 1400s white tile 1500s Isnik tile blue on white wares 1575-1587 Medici porcelain 1600s Gombroon ware 1695 soft paste porcelain at St. Cloud 1742 soft paste porcelain at Chelsea 1796 Spode's English bone china 1857 Beleek frit porcelain
Hard-paste porcelain 206 B.C.-221 A.D. (Han Dynasty in China) White porcelain 618-906 (Tang Dynasty in China) extensive porcelain exports to Europe 960-1279 (Sung Dynasty in China) celadon and J u n ware, cobalt blue and white porcelain 1368-1644 (Ming Dynasty in China) blue and white, reduced copper red and white porcelain extensively exported to Europe 1600s Arita ware 1600s Bottinger porcelain 1700s fine white semivitrous ware in England 1800s Parian porcelain
Tin-glazed ware
Jasperware
Stoneware 6000 B.C. earthenware 600 B.C. terracotta in Greece
900s tin-glazed ware in Baghd a d - l u s t e r painting 1300s majolica ware in Spain and Italy 1500s polychrome painting 1600s paintings of history and stories 1700s faience in Europe 1700s blue and white Delftware 1900s hand-crafted tin glaze ware
1400s German stoneware, salt glazing 1400s English sipware 1600s fine terracotta 1700s turning by steam engine 1700s basalite cane ware 1764 Wedgewood jasperware
1400s German stoneware, salt glaze, English slipware 1600s fine terracotta 1800s engine turning 1900s hand-crafted stoneware
1.3 Raw Materials
27
140 B.C., is only a description of the state of the art. Many problems have yet to be solved before ceramic powder processing can be developed into a mature field for all ceramics. Part of the reason for constant technological evolution is that this field will never be c o m p l e t e n n e w ceramic compositions are always being developed (i.e., high temperature superconductors, piezoelectrics, varistors). In this regard ceramic powder processing will never be without challenging frontiers.
1.3 R A W M A T E R I A L S Since the Bronze Age both natural ceramic raw materials and synthetic raw materials have been used. Today synthetic raw materials are referred to as industrial minerals or specialty chemicals. Natural raw materials are those to which only physical separations are performed (e.g., clay soils from which organic raw materials are floated, feldspar rock ground to a particular size distribution). With this classification, a description of common ceramic raw materials will be given in the next part of this chapter.
1.3.1 N a t u r a l R a w M a t e r i a l s
1.3.1.1 Clays Clays were probably the first ceramic raw materials. Clay minerals are fine-particle hydrous aluminum silicates, like those shown in Figure 1.16 [12], which develop plasticity when mixed with water. They have a wide range of chemical and physical characteristics but the common attribute of a crystalline layer structure consisting of electrically neutral aluminosilicate layers as shown in Figure 1.17. The platelike morphology gives easy cleavage, which leads to a fine particle size and a narrow particle-size distribution and allows the particles to easily move over one another. Clays perform two important functions in ceramic bodies. First, the plasticity of clay suspensions is basic to many of the forming processes commonly used to fabricate ceramic bodies; the ability of clay-water suspensions to be dewatered to give a shape with strength during drying and firing is unique. Second, clays fuse over a temperature range, depending on composition, that can be economically attained, to become dense and strong without losing their shape. The most common clay minerals of interest to ceramists are based on the kaolin structure, A12(Si2Os)(OH)4. (The term kaolin comes for the name, Kao Ling, of a mountainous district, 20 miles northeast of Chingtechen, China, famous during the Tang and Sung Dynasties as a strong hold for outlaws [7]). The reason why kaolin is such a useful
28
FIGURE 1.16
Chapter 1 Ceramic Powder Processing History
Photomicrograph of kaolinite platelets, A12Si20~(OH)4. From Millot [12].
FIGURE 1.17 A platelet of kaolinite consists of a tetrahedral layers and octahedral layers superimposed. The summits of the tetrahedral layer and octahedral layers form a plane of oxygen atoms. The distance between the two units is 7/k. From Millot [12].
1.3 Raw Materials
~
~0
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.18 Commoncompositions in the ternary system MgO-A1203-SiO2.Taken from Kingeryet al. [13], reprinted with permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 9 1976,
New York. raw material is that above 500~ the crystallization of water evolves. Then it decomposes at 980~ to form fine-grained mullite, A16Si2013, in a silica matrix. F u r t h e r heating of kaolin gives rise to a growth of mullite crystals, crystallization of the silica matrix as cristobalite, and formation of a eutectic liquid at 1595~ as shown in the phase diagram in Figure 1.18 [13]. Reasonable strengths of the sintered kaolin ceramics can be obtained on firing between 900 and 1000~ where one can observe the viscous sintering [4,5] of the kaolin polymorphs produced above 900~ Common natural impurities (i.e., MgO, CaO, Na20, K20) in kaolin act as mineralizers, which promote the crystallization of different mineral phases and enhance strength in this temperature range [5]. Other clay minerals important in ceramics (and their chemical formulas) are Kaolinite Halloysite
Ale(Si2Os)(OH)4 A12(Si2Os)(OH)42H20
1.3 Raw Materials Pyrophyllite Montmorillonite Mica Illite
31
A12(Si2Os)2(OH) 2 All.67Nao.33Mgo.33(Si2Os)2(OH)2 A12K(Sil.sAlo.5Os)2(OH)2
A12_xMgxKl_x_y(Si1.5_yAlo.5ยง
These minerals have different stacking of the silica and alumina layers, as well as, incorporating metal hydrates of Na, K, Mg, A1, or Fe between the silica and alumina layers. Clay minerals can also be characterized according to their morphological features including crystal habit (i.e., plates, rods, or rolled-up platelets) stacked in either a house of cards or blocklike aggregates giving a particle-size distribution. 1.3.1.2 Talc A related natural raw material is talc, a hydrous magnesium silicate with a layer structure similar to clay minerals [14]. Talc has the chemical formula Mg3(Si2Os)2(OH)2 and is used as a raw material for making tile, dinnerware, and electronic components. Talc decomposes to give a mixture of fine-grained protoenstatite crystals, MgSiO3, in a silica matrix at 1000~ Further heating leads to crystal growth of enstatite (MgO 9SiO2), which has a high thermal expansion coefficient. A liquid is formed at 1547~ At this temperature almost all of the talc melts because its composition is not far from the eutectic composition in the MgO-SiQ system (Figure 1.18). Reasonable sintered strengths can be obtained when talc is sintered at 1000~ The high thermal expansion coefficient of enstatite is used in glaze formulations to put the glaze into compression after firing, which prevents crazing. In some cases, saponite a hydrous magnesium aluminum silicate is used in place of talc because saponite is cheaper than talc. 1.3.1.3 F e l d s p a r Feldspar is an anhydrous aluminosilicate containing K, Na, or Ca. The value of feldspar in ceramics is due to it being an inexpensive and water insoluble source of alkali. The major minerals of interest in this area are orthoclase, K(A1Si3)Os albite Na(A1Si3)Os, and anorthite Ca(A12Si2)Os. These minerals are widely abundant in nature. Feldspars are a major constituent of igneous rocks (e.g., granite contains about 60% feldspar). These minerals are used as a flux which forms a glass phase in either the ceramic body or the glaze. Figure 1.19 [15] shows the phase diagram for the ternary system K20-A1203-SiO2. In this phase diagram orthoclase (potassium feldspar) is shown to give a near eutectic composition which melts between 800 and 1000~ Feldspar provides alumina and alkali for the glass batch that is used for bottles, fiber glass, and television picture tubes. Feldspar is also the most widely used fluxing agent for ceramics and can be found in formulation for both bodies and glazes, as well as enamels.
32
Chapter 1 Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.19 Common compositions in the ternary system K20-A1203-SiO2 from Schairer and Bowen [15].
1.3.1.4 Silica
Silica is both abundant and widespread in the earth's crust. In addition, it is one of the purest of the abundant minerals. The most commonly used forms of natural silica are quartz, cristobalite, diatomite. Quartz is the most common form of silica, which in natural form can have very large crystals > 10 cm with very high purity. Common sand is high in quartz. Silica sand shows sharply angular fragments of quartz [14]. It is an important constituent of igneous rocks such as granite and diorite. It is also found in most metamorphic rocks, constituting a major portion of sandstone. Quartz as a pure form is often found in veins in other rocks. Diatomite consists of the skeletons of diatoms, an ancient microbe about 10 ftm in diameter, see Figure 1.20. This material is widely found in bogs throughout the world, however, large deposits of diatomite are rather rare. Diatomite is used in insulating bodies to give pores smaller than the mean free path of air and for catalysts to provide a controlled microporous diffusion pathway. Silica is a very important raw material for ceramics. Its extensive use is due to its hardness, high melting point, low cost, and ability to form glass. Silica
1.3 R a w Materials
F I G U R E 1.20
33
Silica, Si02, diatom skeleton, from a Cellite Corporation | advertisement.
is used in a ceramic body like aggregate is used in concrete: to provide a solid mass around which the glass phase can be used to bind the body together.
1.3.1.5 Wollastonite Another source of water insoluble calcium is wollastonite (CaO 9 SiO2). Wollastonite is found in either a pure form or in association with garnet or calcite and dolomite. The impure wollastonite deposits must be beneficiated by optical sorting, high intensity magnetic separation, or froth flotation. In glazes, wollastonite may be used as a substitute for calcite, which reduces the volatiles and increases the gloss and texture of the glaze. Wollastonite deposits are known for their low iron content, which gives a glaze with an excellent fired color. In enamels, wollastonite acts as a n a t u r a l frit to reduce gas evolution. It is also
34
Chapter 1 Ceramic Powder Processing History
used in ultralow ceramic insulating bodies and as an auxiliary flux in electrical insulators. 1.3.1.6 A l u m i n u m M i n e r a l s
Corundum (A1203) in its impure form is also known as emery, a common abrasive. Natural corundum has sharp highly angular particles [14]. Sillimanite minerals with the theoretical composition A12SiO5 are also a source of alumina for refractories. They include alusite, sillimanite, and kayanite, which are common metamorphic minerals found in slates and schists. Alusite is the aluminosilicate mineral which is stable at low pressure and low temperature. Sillimanite is stable at high temperature, and kayanite is stable at high pressure. Kayanite (A1203 9SiO2) is commonly used for mullite (3A1203 92SIO2) refractories and porcelain sparkplug insulators and has prismatic crystals with steplike fracture surfaces. 1.3.1.7 L i t h i u m M i n e r a l s
The important lithium minerals are spodumene (Li2A12Si4012), lepidolite (LiKA12F2Si3Og), amblygonite (Li2F2A12P2Os), and petalite (LiA1 Si4010). Spodumene has prismatic and lath-shaped crystals. In a few cases, it is used in glaze formulations in a ground form; in other cases, a lithium salt is extracted and used in a pure form in glass, glazes, and acid resistant enamels. Lithium minerals are most often used as network modifiers in glass to increase melting efficiency and lower the thermal expansion coefficient of the glass, which increases durability. 1.3.1.8 F l u o r i n e M i n e r a l s
For ceramic use, the most important mineral containing fluorine is fluorite (CaF2) which occurs in fluorspar. Natural deposits have a purity of 90-98% with silica as the principal impurity. Fluorite mineral powders have angular surfaces which result from cleavage and conchoidal fracture of the mineral [14]. Fluorspar is used in many forms of optical glass of low index of refraction and in enamels.
1.3.2 Synthetic R a w Materials Synthetic raw materials are those produced by the chemical treatment of natural raw materials or by the chemical transformation of synthetic materials. 1.3.2.1 T r a n s f o r m e d N a t u r a l R a w Materials M a g n e s i t e and Calcite Magnesite is the mineral form of magnesium carbonate which has particles composed of aggregates of wellcrystallized 1 t~m rhombohedra, many of which are in parallel align-
1.3 Raw Materials
35
ment [14]. It is often associated with calcite (CaCO3), which is a mineral with well-defined rhomboidal or prismatic crystals [14]. The mixture of magnesium and calcium carbonate is the mineral dolomite [14]. Dolomite particles are rounded agglomerates composed of rhombohedral subunits. Magnesite, calcite, and dolomite can be calcined to drive off the CO2, leaving the respective metal oxides. Magnesite is used for refractories because it has one of the highest fusion points known (2800~ and is resistive to many metal slags. Calcite is used in ceramics, as well as ground limestone in glazes, enamels, and glass. Another source of calcium in ceramics is calcined gypsum a natural hydrous calcium sulfate mineral. Calcium and magnesium are network modifiers in glass, which improve the glass's resistance to chemical attack.
Barium Minerals Barite (BaSO4)and witherite (BaCO3) are commonly used to supply barium in ceramic formulations. Purified barium carbonate, made by dissolution and reprecipitation, is used most frequently in ceramic processes and as fluxing compounds in the glazes, glass, and enamels of electronic ceramics and in heavy clay products to prevent scumming. The use of these minerals have the drawback that upon heating they give off gas, which can cause cracks. L e a d M i n e r a l s The most common lead-containing mineral is galena (PbS) followed by anglesite (PbSO4) and cerussite (PbCO3). The two latter minerals result from the weathering of galena. The occurrence of galena deposits is unexpectedly high and spread throughout the world. Galena is roasted in air to give lead oxide. Red lead (Pb304) and white lead (PbCO3 9Pb(OH)2) are commonly used as a basic flux. From the point of view of health, the lead should be reacted with silica to give insoluble PbSi205 . Lead is used in "crystal" stemwear, electrical glass for lighting and television picture tubes, and radiation-absorbing glass and in sanitary ware for enamels and glazes.
1.3.2.2 Synthetic Raw Materials--Specialty Chemicals Alumina Alumina used in ceramics today is commonly obtained via the Bayer process. The Bayer process starts with gibbsite (A1203 9 3H20), which is a common soil mineral often found in association with hematite (Fe203). This raw material is leached with sodium hydroxide at high temperature and pressure and separated from the hematite which is insoluble. The resulting sodium aluminate solution is then allowed to precipitate gibbsite. This purified gibbsite is calcined to give alumina, A1203, which contains both well-formed hexagonal crystals and rounded agglomerated masses attached to the surfaces of the hexagonal surfaces [14]. Another synthesis method for alumina is to mix the sodium aluminate solution with an acid to lower its pH and thereby
36
Chapter 1 Ceramic Powder Processing History
FIGURE 1.21 Pseudo-boehmite gel produced by precipitation of alumina by acid-base neutralization. Versal | a Kaiser Aluminum Corp. product. Photo courtesy Ron Rigge.
precipitate a microcrystalline boehmite, which forms gel agglomerates similar to those shown in Figure 1.21. Aluminas are commonly used as catalytic substrates and as silicon chip substrates, as well as additives to glass. High-alumina ceramics are used as refractories for ladle metallurgy. C h r o m i a Chromite C r 2 F e O 4 is the most commonly used chromium-containing mineral for ceramic formulations. This mineral has a spinel crystal structure, where the iron may be replaced by magnesium and aluminum. Chromite is used in ceramics largely as a refractory in the form of burned and chemically bonded bricks. For this purpose, a low-silica material is desired. When low silica is desired, chromic oxide is extracted from chromite by dissolution in acid, removal of the iron impurity by liquid-liquid extraction, and precipitation of the hydroxide, which is subsequently calcined to the oxide. Chromic oxide is used as a color additive to glazes and enamels and in ferrite production to give magnetic materials.
M a g n e s i a Magnesia (MgO) is produced from seawater or brine. In one process, the chloride brine is sprayed into a reactor where hot gasses convert the MgC12 solution to MgO and HC1. The MgO is slurried
1.3 Raw Materials
37
with water, which reacts to form Mg(OH)2. The Mg(OH)2 is washed, thickened, filtered, and then calcined to produce magnesia. Magnesia produced in this way is composed of agglomerates of well crystallized 1 ~m platelets [14]. In another process, the magnesium chloride brine is reacted with strong base to precipitate Mg(OH)2, which is washed, thickened, filtered, and then calcined to produce magnesia. With increasing calcination time and temperature, the MgO crystallites increase in size. Magnesia calcined at <900~ has a relatively high chemical reactivity and is a useful industrial chemical. Dead-burned magnesia calcined at >1400~ has a low chemical reactivity and is used exclusively in refractories because it has a high resistance to basic metallurgical slags.
Soda Ash, Caustic Soda In the Solvay process, soda ash is produced by reaction of salt (NaC1) with limestone (CaCO3) to produce soda ash and a calcium chloride salt solution. Ammonia enters the reaction process at various steps but is not consumed. Caustic soda is produced by electrolysis of NaC1 brine solutions, giving C12 gas and Na metal, which forms an amalgam with the Hg of the cathode. The amalgam is decomposed using water to form a sodium hydroxide solution, which is concentrated and precipitated to give anhydrous caustic soda. The glass container and flat glass industries use an extensive quantity of both soda ash (NaCO3) and caustic soda (NaOH) as a network modifier to decrease the working temperature of the glass. T i t a n i a Pigment grade titania is produced by the oxidation of titanium tetrachloride. Titanium tetrachloride is produced by the chlorination and selective distillation of ilmenite (FeTiO2) ore. The powder produced by the oxidation process consists of spherical particles (0.2-0.3 ~m in diameter [14]. Titania's high refractive index of 2.5 and its narrow submicron size distribution makes it a very good white pigment in glass and glaze. Zinc Oxide Zinc oxide has a specific gravity of 5.6, sublimes at 1800~ is photoconductive, insoluble in water, soluble in strong alkali solutions, and in acid solutions. It is produced by one of two processes. One process vaporizes zinc metal and burns the vapor in air to give a fine spherical zinc oxide particles [14]. In the other process, the mineral form of zinc sulphide is roasted with carbon to reduce the ore to zinc metal, which in turn vaporizes to give a gas which is burned in air. Zinc oxide powder is used in the manufacture of glass, glazes, porcelain enamels, varistors, and magnetic ferrites. In glass, glazes, and enamels, zinc oxide offers great fluxing power, reduction of expansion, prevention of cracking and crazing, and enhanced gloss and whiteness.
38
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
Zirconia Common zirconium-containing minerals include baddeleyite (ZrO2) and zircon (ZrSiO4). Most of the zirconium-containing materials used in ceramics are extracted from zircon sands. This extraction is performed by chlorination of the silicious raw material and distillation of the mixed metal chloride gases. The separated zirconium chloride is then mixed with water and precipitated as the hydroxide or the hydroxychloride. Upon calcination, both the hydroxide and the hydroxychloride decompose to zirconium oxide. Calcined zirconia particles are composed of 0.1 t~m granules agglomerated into rounded ~20 t~m particles [14]. Zirconium produced in this way has 4% halfnia in it. To remove the halfnia, a liquid-liquid extraction must be performed on the zirconium chloride solution before precipitation. Zirconium oxide is used as an opacifier in glazes and enamels or as a refractory after fusion with lime, which acts as a stabilizer of the crystal phases present. Mixed with yittria the tetragonal phase of zirconia is stabilized, which transforms to monoclonic undergoing a 15% volume change, allowing ceramics to be transformation toughened by the presence of this phase. S i l i c o n Carbide The Acheson process is used to produce large quantities of SiC. This process carbothermically reduces SiO2 to give SiC and CO(g) in a resistance furnace. In 36 hr at 2400~ the chemical reaction is complete. The SiC produced is 1 to 5 mm crystals of a-SiC and must be ground to the desirable particle size distribution. Lowpurity silicon carbide is used in abrasive and refractory applications. High-purity silicon carbide is used for reaction bonded ceramics that require strength at high temperatures, high thermal conductivity, high thermal shock resistance, and a low thermal expansion coefficient. For the manufacture of high-performance ceramics by sintering or hot pressing, other methods of powder synthesis are used. Such processes include plasma-arc synthesis, batch reaction of silica and carbon in CO or inert gas, decomposition of polycarbosilanes, and chemical vapor decomposition. In addition, SiC whiskers are manufactured by the carburization of molten silicon. These single crystal whiskers are used in ceramic matrix composites. Other Metal C a r b i d e s A host of other metal carbides are used in ceramic formulations. These include TaC, TiC, Cr3C2, VC, Mo2C, B4C, WC, and ZrC. These metal carbide powders are produced by carbothermal reduction of the relevant metal oxide or reaction of the relevant metal with carbon in CO or an inert atmosphere. These metal carbides are used as abrasives and in high-temperature wear applications. S i l i c o n N i t r i d e Silicon nitride is a synthetic raw material which is synthesized by various high-temperature reactions between 1000
1.3 Raw Materials
39
and 1600~ The three most important methods of silicon nitride powder synthesis are 9 reacting silicon metal powder with nitrogen 9 reacting silica, nitrogen, and carbon 9 reacting chlorosilanes with a gas containing nitrogen (e.g., ammonia). Silicon nitride whiskers are also produced by variations of processing conditions in these synthesis methods. Silicon nitride is used for toolbits for cutting cast iron and other high-temperature wear parts including burner nozzels. O t h e r Metal N i t r i d e s Many other metal nitrides are used in ceramic formulations. These include A1N, TiN, VN, and BN. These metal nitride powders are produced by carbothermal reduction of the relevant metal oxide in a nitrogen-containing atmosphere or reaction of the relevant metal with a nitrogen-containing reducing atmosphere. These metal nitrides are used as abrasives and in high-temperature wear applications. B o r i d e s Metal borides form another important class of ceramic powders, which include TiB2, BC, W2B, and MoB. Borides have metallic characteristics, with high electrical conductivity and positive coefficient of electrical resistivity. They are produced either by reaction of the relevant metal with boron at a suitable temperature, usually in the range of 1100-2000~ or by reaction of a mixture of the relevant metal oxide and boron oxide with aluminium, magnesium, carbon, boron, or boron carbide followed by purification. Borides are used for electrically heated boats for aluminum evaporation and sliding electrical contacts, as well as abrasives and wear parts, including sandblast nozzels, seals, and ceramic armor plates. TiB 2 has been investigated for use as a nonconsumable replacement for the consumable graphite anode in the electrolytic reduction of alumina to aluminum metal. O t h e r R a w M a t e r i a l s This list of ceramic raw materials is by no means complete. A myriad of other raw materials are presently being used in ceramic formulations. New raw materials are being developed all the time to fulfill the need for better material properties and tailor ceramic powder properties to meet different ceramic processes. The tailoring of ceramic powders usually involves altering particle morphology or particles size distribution for use in a new ceramic powder process. Such new ceramic materials include metal silicides (e.g., NbSi2, V3Si, WSi2, and MoSi2) and metal sulphides (e.g., CdS2). These materials are synthesized in various ways by small-scale batch methods and are used for highly specific applications.
40
Chapter I
Ceramic Powder Processing History
1.4 S E L E C T I N G A R A W M A T E R I A L To select a ceramic raw material, it is necessary to know the final material properties demanded of the ceramic product and the ceramic process by which it will be fabricated. With the physical property information, it is possible to develop a list of raw materials that, after high temperature fabrication, will give the desired chemical formulation. This list of raw materials will next have to be considered in light of a particular ceramic process to be used, which may include, for example, powder mixing, slurry formation, slip casting, drying, binder burn-out, and reactive sintering. To prevent segregation in the ceramic green body, raw materials with similar particle morphology and size distributions should be used. Thus, the different raw materials necessary for the process must be compared to one another for particle size and shape compatibility. Sometimes surface chemistry compatibility is also important. The particle morphology and particle size distribution of a particular raw material depends on the method of powder synthesis. The fundamental principles of many of these powder synthesis methods will be discussed in the balance of this book to explain the reasons for the various particle morphologies and particle size distributions observed in natural and synthetic raw materials. These powder characteristics influence in what ceramic processes these powders can be used. For the simple case of the processing a single ceramic powder, what
FIGURE 1.22 Micrograph of silicon nitride powder, SN-E10, from UBE Industries, Ltd. [16] with sedigraph size distributions for various grades of this powder with 3 m2/ gm (E03), 5 m2/gm (E05), and 10 m2/gm (El0).
References
41
type of powder should be chosen? Reflecting on the "General Concepts of Ceramic Powder Processing" discussed in the introduction to this chapter, a ceramic powder with high chemical purity and a uniform size distribution and particle morphology is the best choice. Only synthetic ceramic powders provide these characteristics. A good example of such a powder is shown in Figure 1.22. Here a silicon nitride powder with a >97% s-phase purity and a narrow size distribution of spherical particles is shown. Various grades of this powder corresponding to different particle size distributions are commercially available from UBE Industries, Ltd. [16].
1.5 SUMMARY This chapter has reviewed the field of ceramic powder processing from a historical perspective. In addition, it has catalogued the various ceramic powder raw materials used to produce ceramics.
References 1. Smith, B., and Weng, W.-Go, "China--A History in Art," Gemini Smith Inc. Book. Doubleday, New York, 1972. 2. "The Genius of China," an exhibition of the archaeological finds of the People's Republic of China held by the Royal Academy, London 29 September 1973 to 23 January 1974. 3. Wood, N., New Sci. February, pp. 50-53 (1989). 4. Lemaitre, J., and Delmon, B., Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull. 59(2), 235 (1980). 5. Lemaitre, J., and Delmon, B., J. Mater. Sci. 12, 2056-2065 (1977). 6. "Treasures from the Bronze Age of China," an exhibit from the People's Republic of China, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Ballantine Books, New York. 7. Brankston, A. D., "Early Ming Wares of Chingtechen," p. 64. Vetch and Lee Ltd., Hong Kong, 1938. 8. Valenstein, S. G., "Handbook of Chinese Ceramics." Weidenfeld & Nicholson, London, 1989. 9. Bushell, S. W., "Description of Chinese Pottery and Porcelain" (translation of "T'ao Shuo"). Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford, 1977. 10. Needham, J., "Science in Traditional China." Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA, 1981. 11. Anderson, K. J., M R S Bull., July, pp. 71-72 (1990). 12. Millot, G., La Science 20, 61-73 (1979). 13. Kingery, W. D., Bowen, H. K., and Ulhmann, D. R., "Introduction to Ceramics," 2nd ed. Wiley (Interscience), New York, 1976. 14. McCrone, W. C., and Delly, J. G., "The Particle Atlas." Ann Arbor Sci. Publ., Ann Arbor, MI. 15. Schairer, J. F., and Bowen, N. L., Am. J. Sci. 245, 199 (1947). 16. UBE Industries, Ltd., Ceramic Div., Tokyo Head Office, ARK MORI Building, 1232, Akasaka 1-chome, Minato-ku, Tokyo, 107 Japan. 17. Hobson, R. L., "Chinese Pottery and Porcelain." Dover, New York, 1976.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
2.1 O B J E C T I V E S To characterize a ceramic powder, a representative sample must be taken. Methods of sampling and their errors therefore are discussed. Powder characteristics, including shape, size, size distribution, pore size distribution, density, and specific surface area, are discussed. Emphasis is placed on particle size distribution, using log-normal distributions, because of its importance in ceramic powder processing. A quantitative method for the comparison of two particle size distributions is presented, in addition to equations describing the blending of several powders to reach a particular size distribution.
2.2 I2VTROD UCTION In all ceramic raw materials, both natural and synthetic, a powder with a particular chemical formula is the primary objective. Chemical
43
44
Chapter 2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
analysis of ceramic powders is performed by many techniques from X-ray fluorescence spectrometry and atomic absorption spectrometry to the wet chemical methods of titration. All of these techniques are subjects unto themselves, covered by other books and not be discussed further here. After satisfying this primary objective of chemical purity, other powder characteristics are important to optimize the powder to the requirements of the ceramic process in which it will be used. The diversity of these production methods calls for the choice of ceramic powders to be based on different characteristics. Beyond chemical purity, the most important characteristics for subsequent ceramic processing are particle morphology, particle size distribution, and surface chemistry. The surface chemistry of ceramic powders is extremely important for wet and dry processing methods and will be discussed in detail in a separate chapter. The characteristics of ceramic powders corresponding to their size and shape are discussed in this chapter. An excellent book that treats particle size measurement is one by Allen [1], from which many concepts used in this chapter are taken.
2.3 POWDER SAMPLING Before any characteristics of a powder can be measured it is imperative to have a representative sample of the powder. This problem can be viewed in its true magnitude by considering that several tons of material will be analyzed on the basis of less than 1 gm of material. The ultimate that may be obtained in a representative sample is called the perfect sample; the difference between this perfect sample and the bulk can be established by a statistical method, described in the following problem.
2.3.1 Sampling Accuracy P r o b l e m 2.1. D e t e r m i n e t h e S a m p l i n g E r r o r
A glaze formulation has poor color when a finely ground silica powder has a fraction of iron impurities larger than 50 ppm by weight. Let us assume that a 10 gm sample is taken from a 10,000 kg batch. In this 10 gm sample, we find 40 ppm iron particles greater than 44 ftm by sieving. The maximum sampling error, E, can be expressed as [1]
E-- +20i _ ~
(2.1)
2.3 Powder Sampling
45
where (r~ is the standard deviation intrinsic in the sample due to the sampling of 10 gm from a 10,000 kg batch and P is the weight fraction of material greater than 44/xm measured in the sample. The standard deviation due to sampling is determined by [1]
~ =[
W-~
( s)112
. (Pw~ + ( 1 - P)w2) . 1-- Wbb
(2.2)
where Ws and Wb are the weight of the sample and the bulk, respectively; w~ and w2 are the weights of individual grains, the metal impurity particles 1 assumed to be the density of iron with a diameter of 44 txm and 2 assumed to be silica 0.5 txm in diameter. In this example, P = 40 x 10 -6, Ws = 10 -2 kg, Wb = 10,000 kg, Wl = 3.5 x 10 -1~ kg, and w2 = 1.7 x 10 - ~ kg, giving a value of cri = 2.37 x 10 -7 and an error of 1.19%. In addition to the error caused by using a small sample, we have the error in our analytical technique. For our example, when multiple iron impurity measurements were made on the same sample, the standard deviation of the impurities was ___4 ppm with a m e a n value of 40 ppm as before. This 10% analysis error will have an effect on the total error since the total standard deviation o't is O.t
=
(0.2 + ~'nJ __2,1/2
(2.3)
where (rn is the standard deviation of the analysis technique (i.e., 4 โข 10 -s for this example). Accounting for the error in our analysis in this problem, we find a total error (using equation (2.1) with (rt replacing (r~) is 20.0%. The analysis error (rn is, therefore, the most significant error in this example.
2.3.2 Two-Component Sampling Accuracy Any powder can be considered to be made up of two components, the fraction above and below a certain size and assumptions made as to the weights of the individual grains in each of the two components. Equation (2.2) may then be used to determine the sampling accuracy of a single powder. Furthermore, if the particles are counted instead of weighed, a more general equation is applicable [1]:
(2.4) where p is the fraction of particles greater t h a n a certain size, Ns is the number of particles counted, and Nb is the number of paraticles in the bulk. (This equation is also used to determine the accuracy of public opinion poles.) It is obvious from the preceding equations, that the larger is the sample, the smaller is the sampling standard deviation.
46
Chapter 2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
2.3.3 Sampling Methods Unfortunately, the size of a practical analytical sample is often minuscule compared to the bulk material being sampled and even the analytical sample is subject to a large degree of sampling variation. There are two ways to reduce this variation. One way is to make up a large laboratory sample from many increments of the bulk and divide the laboratory sample to produce an analytical sample. This laboratory sample is often retained for replicate analyses to determine the standard deviation of the analytical method. The second way to reduce sampling variation is to take a number of replicate samples and mix them together to make an analytical sample. A representative sample is difficult to obtain when one considers that 1. Particles encounter many types of segregation that will bias the sample. 2. Many different conditions are to be sampled. Frequently, one must sample a continuous stream, batches, bags, heaps, hoppers, or trucks. The most important segregation-causing property is particle size, and this problem is exacerbated with flowing material. In a heap, the fine particles tend to concentrate at the center of the heap as shown in Figure 2.1. In a vibrating container, coarse material tends to concentrate at the surface, even if the coarse material is denser than the fine material. This problem was observed to the chagrin of a farmer who ordered a railroad car of wheat seed. When the car arrived it looked from the top surface as if he had received a carload of beans. The 1% impurity, beans, had segregated to the top of the load with the gentle railroad vibrations in shipping. An understanding of these tendencies of particles to segregate prevents careless sampling practices.
2.3.4 Golden Rules of Sampling [1] For the many possible situations in which sampling has to be performed, two principles can be given that will decrease segregation: Rule 1. A powder should be sampled when in motion. Rule 2. The whole stream of powder should be taken for many short increments of time in preference to part of the stream being taken for the whole time. In many possible situations a sample has to be obtained under conditions that often necessitate the use of inferior sampling techniques, however, observance of these Golden Rules will lead to the best sampling procedure.
2.3 Powder Sampling
47
FIGURE 2.1 Cross-section of a pile of binary powder showing demixing of larger black particles ( - 1 ram) to the periphery and finer white particles (-0.2 ram) to the center of the pile. Taken from Figure 1.11 in Allen [1].
For bag sampling it is best to select the bags at random and repeatedly use a splitter to homogenize the sample, taking a portion of one of the splits as the sample is in motion. For heap or hopper sampling it is important to note that the cross-section is likely to contain large degrees of segregation with fine particles concentrated near the axis and coarse particles concentrated at the periphery of the heap. Since this segregation is a common occurrence, static sampling is not suggested unless all the particles are <44 ~m, where segregation is greatly redued. Once a representative sample has been obtained, the particle size distribution and other powder characteristics can be determined.
48 2.4
Chapter 2
PARTICLE
Ceramic Powder Characterization
SIZE
2.4.1 S t a t i s t i c a l D i a m e t e r s Imagine an irregularly shaped particle like that shown in Figure 2.2. For this particle, an infinite number of statistical diameters radiating from the center of gravity of the particle exist. The average unrolled diameter of the projected contour is the integrated average defined by [2]
-dR
=
f~~ r -dO -.
(2.5)
This calculation is tedious to perform for each particle of a distribution even with the advent of computer aided image analysis. Faster techniques simply measure a linear dimension parallel to some fixed direction and assume that the particles are oriented randomly so that these measurements average out when a sufficiently large population has been sized. Several linear dimensions typically are used. Feret's diameter is the mean value of the distance between pairs of parallel tangents to the projected outline. Martin's diameter is the mean cord length of the projected outline of the particle. In addition, the maximum
200
.150
n,.
E(R)
(b)
,
0
,..........
I
~"
50
, ......
~R
0
2x
FIGURE 2.2 Multitude of particle diameters: (a) definition of unrolled radius R; (b) unrolled curve. Taken from Figure 4.1 in Allen [1].
2.4 Particle Size Feret's
49
Diameter
P a r t i c l e Outline Martin's Diameter Projected Area Diameter Maximum H o r i z o n t a l I n t e r c e p t
F I G U R E 2.3
Different particle diameters. Taken from Stockham and Fortman [3].
and minimum horizontal intercepts are also used as linear dimensions. All of these linear dimensions are shown in Figure 2.3 [3]. Another commonly used measure of a particle's diameter is the projected area diameter, which is the diameter of a circle having the same area as that projected by the particle. Other particle size definitions are given in Table 2.1. A commonly used size dependent property is the equivalent spherical diameter. The equivalent spherical diameter is the diameter of a sphere with the same volume as the particle. For a cube this sphere would have a diameter 1.24 times the edge length of the cube. Another common equivalent spherical diameter is the Stokes diameter. The Stokes diameter is the diameter of a sphere that has the same terminal settling velocity as an irregular particle. (Note: Settling has to be under laminar flow [i.e., Reynolds number less than 0.2] in both cases and the density of both the particle and the sphere are assumed to be the same). The sieve diameter is the length of a side of the minimum square aperture through which a particle will pass. An irregularly shaped particle will pass through the smallest possible mesh only if it is presented in the optimum orientation. Sieving times for elongated particles approach infinity because only two orientations will allow the particle to pass the smallest sieve. Long sieving times can cause problems since some amount of particle breakage will inevitably result during this time. A common solution to this dilemma is to sieve for a specific period of time with all samples of the same type and live with the error and breakage that results. For distributions of irregular-shaped particles, the size distribution measured is dependent on the method of measurement. For this reason, the sizing method employed should duplicate the property of interest (e.g., for pigments, the projected area diameter is of interest; for catalyst substrates, the surface to volume diameter is of interest, etc.). There are many different methods of measuring size distribution. Table 2.2 gives the most common methods utilized and the type(s) of size dimension(s) measured. These methods of size measurement have to be coupled with either some counting or weighing method to determine the
T A B L E 2.1
Symbol
Definitions of Particle Size a
Name
dv
Volume d i a m e t e r
ds
Surface d i a m e t e r
dV$
Surface volume d i a m e t e r
dd
Drag diameter
df
Free-falling d i a m e t e r
dstk
Stokes's d i a m e t e r
Formula
Definition 77
Diameter of a sphere having the same volume as the particle Diameter of a sphere having the same surface as the particle
V=gd3v
Diameter of a sphere having the same external surface to volume ratio as a sphere Diameter of a sphere having the same resistance to motion as the particle in a fluid of the same viscosity and the same velocity (d d approximates to ds when R is small) Diameter of a sphere having the same density and the same free-falling speed as the particle in a fluid of the same density and viscosity
dsv =
The free-falling diameter of a particle in the l a m i n a r flow region (Re < 0.2)
S = 7rd2s de~
FD = CDApwV2/2, where COA = f(dd), FD = 37r dd~Y Re < 0.2
de~ d2 = ~d
da
Projected area diameter
d~
Projected area diameter
de
Perimeter diameter
dA
Sieve diameter
dR
Feret's diameter
dm
Martin's diameter
dur
Unrolled diameter
a
Diameter of a circle having the same area as the projected area of the particle resting in a stable position Diameter of a circle having the same area as the projected area of the particle in random orientation Diameter of a circle having the same perimeter as the projected outline of the particle The width of the minimum square aperture through which the particle will pass The mean value of the distance between pairs of parallel tangents to the projected outline of the particle The mean chord length of the projected outline of the particle The mean chord length through the center of gravity of the particle
77 A=~d2a
Mean value for all possible orientations d~ = ds for convex particles
dur = E(dR ) = _1 f ~ dRdO R
Taken from Table 4.1 in T. Allen, Particle Size Measurement (London: Chapman and Hall, 1981).
7]"
52
Chapter 2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
TABLE 2.2 Methods of Size Distribution Analysis Method
Dimension measured
Gas absorption Coulter counter (Electro-zone) Inertial separation Light scattering Photon correlation spectroscopy Permeability
Projected Area diameter Feret's diameter Martin's diameter Perimeter diameter Unrolled diameter Sieve diameter Stokes's diameter Drag diameter Free-fall diameter Surface to volume diameter Volume diameter Stokes's diameter Scattering diameter Sixth moment diameter Surface to volume diameter
Microscopy
Sieve Settling
amount of particles in each size range. In the case of microscopy, the n u m b e r of particles is counted. With sieving, the weight of particles in a size range is measured. With settling, either the optical density of the suspension of particles in the size range is measured or the percent mass in the size range is measured by X-ray absorption. With Coulter electro-zone counting, the n u m b e r of particles in a particular volume range is counted. All other techniques of sizing do not have separate m e a s u r e m e n t s of either the weight and size or number and size of particles in a particular size range. With light scattering, the number density and the size distribution are best-fit parameters for a series of scattered light intensity m e a s u r e m e n t s at different angles. With gas adsorption and gas permeability, the average surface to volume diameter of the particles is determined.
2.4.2 Mean P a r t i c l e Size The mean particle size measured by these various methods is different depending on the method used. The mathematical definition of the various mean sizes, with their mathematical definitions, follow [1]. Number, length mean diameter or arithimatic diameter: di -~lQi 9
_ ZNi"
dgL = dav -
(2.6)
Geometric m e a n diameter by number: deN = aloglo
~;-~//
.
(2.7)
2.4 Particle Size
53
Number, surface mean diameter: ( X N i ' d ~ ) 112 d n s = \ ~]QI
(2.8)
Number, volume mean diameter: dNy= \
ZNi
] "
(2.9)
Length, surface mean diameter: ZNi " d~ dsn = ZNi " d i "
(2.10)
Length, volume mean diameter: ( X N i ' d ~ ~/2 dvL = \ E n i ~ / "
(2.11)
Surface, volume mean diameter: dvs = ENi " d 2. ENi d i
(2.12)
Volume, moment mean diameter and weight (or mass), moment mean diameter: ENi " d4 dv = dw = dM = ENi " d~"
(2.13)
P r o b l e m 2.2. M e a n P a r t i c l e S i z e
An example of microscopic size analysis is given in Table 2.3 (taken from Stockham and Fortman [3]). Here the number of particles found in various particle size ranges is measured. From this data, determine various mean sizes, including the arithmetic mean size, dav ; the geometric mean by number, dgN; the surface mean, dNs ; the volume mean, dNy; the volume to surface mean, dys; and the weight or mass mean, dw. For the various mean sizes, the mathematical definitions are given in equations (2.6) to (2.12). The relevant columns of sums are given also in Table 2.1, allowing the calculation of various mean sizes as follows:
day -
12248 1000
= alo
= 12.2/zm
10(
)
= 100 m
T A B L E 2.3
Calculation of Various Average Diameters a ,,,,,,
Particle size interval (Ixm)
1.0-1.4 1.4-2.0 2.0-2.8 2.8-4.0 4.0-5.6 5.6-8.0 8.0-12.0 12.0-16.0 16.0-22.0 22.0-30.0 30.0-42.0 42.0-60.0 60.0-84.0 Totals
Middle size (txm), d
1.2 1.7 2.4 3.2 4.8 6.8 10.0 14.0 19.0 26.0 36.0 51.0 72.0
Frequency of occurrence n
Count frequency of n (%)
2 5 14 60 100 190 250 160 110 70 28 10 1 1000
0.2 0.7 2.1 8.1 18.1 37.1 62.1 78.1 89.1 96.1 98.9 99.9 100.0
a Taken from Stockham, J. D. and Fortman, E. G. [3].
nd
2 8 34 192 480 1292 2500 2240 2090 1820 1008 510 72 12248
n log d
0.16 1.15 5.32 30.31 68.12 158.18 250.00 183.38 140.66 99.04 43.58 17.08 1.86 998.84
nd 2
nd a
3 14 81 614 2304 8785 25000 31360 39710 47320 36288 26010 5184 222673
3 25 194 1966 11059 59742 250000 429040 754490 1230320 1306368 1326510 373248 5752965
Mass frequency of nd 3 (%)
n
0.1 0.3 1.3 5.6 13.2 26.3 47.7 70.4 93.5 100.0
nd t
4 42 464 6291 53084 406246 2500000 6146560 14335310 31988320 47029248 67652010 26872856 196991436
55
2.4 Particle Size
(222673~ 1/2
dNS = \ ~ - ~ ]
= 14.9/~m
d y y = (5 750-~065)1/3
= 17.9/~m
5752965
dvs = 222673
dw =
196991436 5752965
= 25.4/xm
= 34.2/~m.
As you can see from this set of data, m a n y different m e a n sizes can be calculated. Therefore, reporting a mean size without reference to the statistical method used is utterly useless.
2.4.3 Size Distribution Accuracy With sizing techniques t h a t count the particles, it is desirable to know the accuracy of the size distribution after counting a given n u m b e r of particles. Figure 2.4 gives the number of particles to be counted to give a specific accuracy [3]. For a less t h a n 1% error in a given size
% w g t in Size Interval
z~
2.0-
2%
5%
10% 15% 20%
!.._
0
I,,, I,,
!11 "0 0 .,., 1.0 0 (I) e,J X III
0
1
10
100
,
10 ,000
Number of Particles C o u n t e d in S i z e Range
FIGURE 2.4 Expectederror in the size distribution based on the number of particles counted in the size range and the weight percent in the size interval. The curves in this figure have been calculated with the equation Ei, j = Wj/V~ii.
56
Chapter 2 CeramicPowder Characterization
range where 20% of the mass appears, more than 400 particles must be sized. For a less than 0.1% error in a given size range where 20% of the mass appears, more than 40,000 particles must be sized. For size intervals where fewer numbers of particles were counted, the expected error increases. This sizing error should be kept below the sampling error (see Section 2.1) so that the total error is not dominated by the analysis error. P r o b l e m 2.3. D e t e r m i n e t h e E r r o r of t h e P a r t i c l e Size D i s t r i b u t i o n G i v e n in T a b l e 2.3
For each size interval, we must first determine the weight percent. Then using the number of particles counted in that size range, we can determine the error for that size range. For the size interval 16-22 t~m, 110 particles were counted out of 1000. The weight fraction, Wj, of particles in this size interval is 13%. Using Figure 2.4 [3] with values of 13% for the weight percentage in the size interval and 110 for the number of particles counted, Nj, we find an error, Ej, of -1.2% for the 16-22 ftm size interval. The curves in this figure have been calculated with the equation Ej
= ~Nj"
(2.14a)
This process is repeated for each size interval to complete the analysis. The largest error in this size distribution occurs in the 60-84 t~m size interval, where one particle accounted for 6.5% of the mass. This is the largest error (~5%) for any size category. The total error for the size distribution, ET, c a n be calculated by a sum of the products of the error for each size interval Ei with the weight percent in each size interval, Wi" N
ET = ~ Ei Wi. i=l
(2.14b)
For this problem the total error was calculated to be 2%.
2.5 PARTICLE MORPHOLOGY The size of a cubic particle is uniquely defined by its edge length. The size of a spherical particle is uniquely defined by its diameter. Other regular shapes have equally appropriate dimensions. With some regular particles more than one dimension is necessary to specify the geometry of the particle as, for example, a cylinder, which has a diameter and a length. With irregularly shaped particles, many dimensions
2.5 Particle Morphology
57
are required to completely specify the shape of the particle. As we have seen in Figure 2.2, a single particle can have an infinite number of statistical diameters, hence these diameters are meaningful only when a sufficient number of particles have been measured to give average statistical diameters in each size range. The numerical relation between the various diameters of a single particle depends on the particle's shape.
2.5.1 Shape Factors A dimensionless combination of different average diameters of a distribution of particles is called a shape factor. Shape factors have three functions: 1. Proportionality factors between different particle size determination methods (e.g., the average size determined by surface area is proportional to the average size determined by volume and the proportionality constant is a shape factor). 2. Conversion factors for expressing results in terms of an "equivalent sphere." 3. Transformations of the square and cube of the measured particle diameter into the particle surface area and particle volume, respectively. Shape factors can be applied to an individual particle or to a distribution of particles. They are not sensitive to the size distribution discussed later in this chapter. For a distribution of particles, the shape factor measured is an average value. Shape factors are always understood relative to two methods of particle size determination. The volume shape factor ~v is defined as [4]
Yt Yt
_
(2.15a)
Nt
%
ZNid~ ZNid~ Nt where Vt is the total volume of the sample, Nt is the total number of particles in the sample, Ni is the number of particles with a diameter di. For a population of spheres av is 7r/6 or 0.52, whereas for a population of cubes av is 1.0. For all other shapes, values greater than 0.52 are observed when the major axis of the particle is used for di. The surface shape factor, a~, is defined as [4] St St as
~ , N i d i2
_
N t ....... 2 ~N id i ...........
Nt
(2.15b)
58
Chapter 2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
where St is the total surface area of the sample. For a population of spheres as is 7r and for a population of cubes as is 6.0. Another useful shape parameter is the ratio of as to av [4]: St
% _ ENid~ av Vt
(2.15c)
EN~d~ This ratio is obtained easily from experimental gas adsorption data for the surface area per unit volume, Sv = St/Vt (which equals 6/dv~ for a sphere, where dvs is the volume to surface mean diameter defined by equation (2.11)). Because spheres have a minimum surface area per unit volume, all values of %/% will be larger than 6 when the major axis is used for di. When the minor axis is used for di, values of %/% can be both smaller and larger than 6. Table 2.4 [1] gives calculated shape factors for various geometric shapes. Their values cover a broad range. A particular value of the shape factor does not specify a particular geometry because many geometries can give the same shape factor. The dynamic shape factor, K, is defined as the resistance of a particle to motion divided by the resistance of a sphere to motion when the particle and the "equivalent sphere" have the same volume. When the particle is settling under laminar flow, K is given by [4] (dNv~2 K= \-~t ]
(2.16)
where dNy is the mean volume diameter (equation (2.7)) and dst is the Stokes diameter. The dynamic shape factor, K, is equal to the reciprocal TABLE 2.4
Calculated Values of Shape Coefficients a
,,,,,
Form Sphere Spheroid
Ellipsoid Cylinder
Proportions
1 : 1:2 1:2:2 1:1:4 1:4:4 1:2 : 4 height height height height height
= = = = =
diameter 2 diameters 4 diameters 89 diameter 88 diameter
Linear dimension used as D
Ols
OLv
OLs/Olv
Diameter Minor axis Minor axis Minor axis Minor axis Shortest axis Diameter Diameter Diameter Diameter Diameter
3.14 5.37 8.67 10.13 28.50 15.86 4.71 7.85 14.14 3.14 2.36
0.52 1.05 2.09 2.09. 8.38. 4.19 0.79 1.57 3.14 0.39 0.20
6.00 5.13 4.14 4.83 3.40 3.79 6.00 5.00 4.50 8.00 12.00
a Taken from Table 4.6 in T. Allen, Particle Size Measurement (London: Chapman and Hall, 1981).
2.5 Particle Morphology
59
of the square root of the sphericity, Cw, one of the earliest shape factors used: K = Cwu2
(2.17)
Sphericity [5], Cw, is defined by Cw =
Surface area of a sphere having the same volume as the particle Surface area of the particle [dyv~2 (2.18)
The volume to surface mean diameter is given by (2.19)
dvs - d~vs - CwdNv
which is directly related to sphericity. At a low Reynolds number, the drag diameter equals the surface diameter of convex particles. For this case, the Stokes diameter, defined as the free-fall diameter in the laminar flow region, is related to sphericity as follows: {d~rv~ u2 "--
u4n W
LbNV
o
(2.20)
Shape factors do not provide specific information on the geometry of the particles but simply give a number for comparison purposes. To provide particle geometry information, a model geometry (i.e., cube, tetrahedron, sphere, etc.) must be selected and the particles of the population compared to that geometry to see how closely the particles correspond to it. This approach, pioneered by Heywood [6], can be used only when three mutually perpendicular dimensions of the particle can be determined. This amount of information on each particle is typically not available, which prevents the common use of this technique to give detailed particle shape information.
2.5.2 Shape Analysis Shape regeneration can be performed by Fourier transformation techniques. First the particle's center of gravity is found from its outline. Then a polar coordinate system is set up. Schwarcz and Shane [7] traced the outline of the particle and generated a plot of R n v e r s u s On, where n is the number of equal angles utilized. Meloy [8-11] used a Fourier transform to generate the Fourier coefficients, An, associated
60
Chapter 2
Ceramic P o w d e r Characterization
with the angles 0 n and found that particles have signatures that follow the empirical equation A n -
Aon-s
(2.21)
A plot of log A n v e r s u s log n gives a straight line with a slope o f - s , which is the shape signature of the particle. Generalizations of this method to three-dimensional particles are also possible. Particle shapes can be analyzed and reproduced using this Fourier transform method.
2.5.3 Fractal Shapes When a particle's surface is not uniformly smooth like that of a sphere but has a texture like that of broccoli or cauliflower, the particle is said to be fractal [12]. With the two-dimensional projection of a fractal particle, we find that the perimeter of the particle increases without limit as the size of the ruler used as a measure decreases in length. The circumference, C, estimated with a ruler of size x is proportional to C x OL X 1-D
(2.22)
where D is the fractal dimension of the particle. An example of a computer generated fractal particle [13] is shown in Figure 2.5. To determine the fractal dimension of a particle, a series of circles are drawn with different centers and different radii. A plot of the average number of the particle subunits within the circle is plotted versus the radius of the circle on log-log paper and the slope is the fractal dimension, D. Fractal shapes are traditionally produced by agglomeration
Two-dimensional computer generated fractal aggregate. Taken from Hurd [13], copyright 9 1986 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
F I G U R E 2.5
2.5 Particle Morphology
61
FIGURE 2.6 Electron micrograph of a silica cluster. Bar = 5000 /~. Taken from Schaefer, D. W., Martin, J. E., Wiltzius, P., and Cannell, D. S., Phys. Rev. Lett. 52(26), 2371-2374 (1984).
processes occurring in precipitation of sol-gel particles and in flame, plasma, and laser synthesis of ceramic powders. A classic example of a silica sol aggregate is shown in Figure 2.6 with a fractal dimension of 2.1. Flame synthesized carbon black also has a fractal geometry with fractal dimensions between 1.7 and 2.5. The properties of fractal ceramic powders depend on their fractal dimensions. The density, p, of a fractal particle depends on its radius, R, and the fractal dimension: po~R D-3.
(2.23)
The surface area per unit mass, A, of a fractal particle depends on the radius of the individual particles, ro, the radius of the aggregate, R, and the fractal dimension: Aa(ro) -1 9R D.
(2.24)
Fractal particles modify external phenomena in the surrounding space (e.g., a conducting fractal modifies the electric field around it, an absorbing fractal modifies the concentration of the diffusing species around it, and a fractal immersed in a fluid modifies fluid flow around
62
Chapter 2 CeramicPowder Characterization
it). The basic laws governing these external processes can be expressed in terms of the fractal dimension, D [14]. Another interesting property of fractals is the intersection probability between two fractals. The number of intersections, M~2, between two fractal particles 1 and 2, both of size R, are placed independently in the same region of space is M120lR D1+D2-3
(2.25)
where D~ and D2 are the fractal dimension of each particle, respectively. If the power of R is negative, the probability of intersection decreases as the size of the fractal, R, increases. For this reason, two fractals with the same fractal dimension will have a low intersection probability if D1 = D2 > 1.5. As a result, fractals with fractal dimensions greater than 1.5 act as individual spheres in dilute solution. In concentrated solution, fractals with a fractal dimension less than 1.5 can be forced to interpenetrate strongly, unlike hard spheres, during settling and dewatering of fractal sol-gel ceramic powders.
2.5.4 Internal Porosity Porosity within a particle is a manifestation of the shape of a particle. Fractal particles will have internal porosity as a result of their shapes. Fractal particles with low fractal dimensions (i.e., <2.0) will have a broad pore size distribution, where the largest pore approaches the size of the aggregate. Fractal particles with large fractal dimensions (i.e., >2.0) will have narrower pore size distributions with most of the porosity occurring at a size much smaller than that of the aggregate. Calcination of metal salt particles or metal hydroxides to produce oxides is another common method to produce internal porosity. In the gas evolution that takes place in transformation to the oxide, pores are opened up in the particle structure. The opening of pores in a hydrous alumina powder can increase its surface area from 0.5 m2/gm (its external area) to 450 m2/gm (its internal pore area). Two methods are used to measure the pore size distribution in a powder: mercury porosimetry and adsorption-desorption hysteresis. Both methods utilize the same principle: capillary rise. A nonwetting liquid requires an excess pressure to rise in a narrow capillary. The pressure difference across the interface is given by the Young and Laplace equation [15]. AP = - 2T cos 0
(2.26)
2.6 Powder Density
63
where T is the surface tension of the liquid, r is the capillary radius and 0 is the contact angle between the liquid and the capillary walls and is always measured within the liquid. For contact angles greater than 90 ~, the pressure difference is negative and the level of the meniscus in the capillary will be lower than the level in a surrounding liquid reservoir. The pressure difference is the pressure required to bring the level of the liquid in the capillary up to the level in the surrounding reservoir. Therefore, the absolute pressure required to force a nonwetting liquid into a pore of radius r is AP when we start with the powder in an evacuated state. The volume of liquid entering the pores is measured separately at each applied pressure giving a pore volume versus radius plot. One of the disadvantages of applying equation (2.26) is that pores are not cylindrical in cross-section. Therefore, pore size distribution results can only be comparative. In addition, "ink bottle" pores will give different sizes depending on whether the size is measured upon filling or emptying. Porosity can be an advantage or a disadvantage in ceramic powders, depending upon the processing and final application. Tailoring of the pore size distribution is very important for catalytic substrates, because access to the catalytic sites depends on these diffusional pathways.
2.6 POWDER D E N S I T Y The weight of a powder divided by the volume it occupies is its bulk density. The bulk density of a powder is often much less than the density of the individual grains that make up the powder. The true density of the individual grain is determined by pyncnometry. In pyncnometry a given mass of powder is placed in a vessel with a calibrated volume. Then a fluid is used to fill the vessel. The volume of the fluid filling the vessel and the actual volume of the powder are measured by the difference between the volume of the empty calibrated vessel and the actual volume of the fluid used to fill the vessel containing the powder. This volume combined with the powder weight allows the true density to be calculated. When the fluid is a gas, the actual volume of the gas used to fill the void space of the vessel to a given pressure is measured directly. Inert gases are used for this measurement to minimize adsorption. When the fluid is a liquid, the mass of the added liquid is measured and the liquid density at a given temperature is used to calculate the volume of the liquid filling the void space in the vessel. Care must be exercised in the selection of the liquid because nonwetting liquids will not enter the pores of the powder particles.
64
Chapter 2 Ceramic Powder Characterization
2.7 SURFACE AREA The specific surface area of a ceramic powder can be measured by gas adsorption. Gas adsorption processes may be classified as physical or chemical, depending on the nature of atomic forces involved. Chemical adsorption (e.g., H20 and A120a) is caused by chemical reaction at the surface. Physical adsorption (e.g., N2 on A12Oa) is caused by molecular interaction forces and is important only at a temperature below the critical temperature of the gas. With physical adsorption the heat of adsorption is on the same order of magnitude as that for liquefaction of the gas. Because the adsorption forces are weak and similar to liquefaction, the capillarity of the pore structure effects the adsorbed amount. The quantity of gas adsorbed in the monolayer allows the calculation of the specific surface area. The monolayer capacity (Vm) must be determined when a second layer is forming before the first layer is complete. Theories to describe the adsorption process are based on simplified models of gas adsorption and of the solid surface and pore structure.
2.7.1 First Layer Adsorption--Langmuir Adsorption The first theoretical equation relating the quantity of gas adsorbed to the equilibrium pressure of the gas was proposed by Langmuir [16]. Using the kinetic theory of gases, Langmuir balanced the rates of condensation and evaporation of the gas molecules at the solid surface, giving the volume adsorbed, V, as a function of the gas pressure, P:
V bP = 0=~ Vm 1 +bP"
(2.27)
In this equation, Vm is the monolayer capacity, 0 is the fractional surface coverage, and b is defined as
b = X/27rmkT where ro is the molecular vibration time, m is the molecular mass, k is Boltzmann's constant, T is temperature, and Q is the energy evolved when a gas is adsorbed. The Langmuir equation is usually written in the form P
1 -
t
P
VbVmVm"
(2.29)
A plot of P/V versus P is linear and gives the monolayer capacity Vm as the reciprocal of the slope. To relate this to the specific surface
2.7 Surface Area
65
area, it is necessary to know the area occupied by a molecule, (r, and use the following equation: S - NAv~
(2.30)
where NAV is Advogadro's number and 17 is the molar volume = 22,410 cm3/mole. The Langmuir analysis is limited to monolayer adsorption for both physical and chemical adsorption. This analysis can sometimes be applied to the adsorption of solutes from solvents.
2.7.2 Multilayer Adsorption--BET Adsorption An extension of the Langmuir approach to multilayers adsorption was made by Brunauer, Emmett, and Teller, BET [17]. They assumed that the Langmuir equation applies to each layer. The heat of adsorption of the first layer was assumed to have a special value, but for the subsequent layers, the heat of adsorption was assumed to be equal to the heat of condensation of the gas. The volume adsorbed is then a summation of the adsorbed volumes of each layer. Upon evaluation of the summation, the BET equation results: V V~
-
cP (Po - P)[1 + (c - 1)(P/Po)]
(2.31)
where P0 is the saturation pressure at the temperature of adsorption and c is defined as c - ~albi exp[(Q1 - Qv)/RT]
(2.32)
where ai and bi are the condensation and evaporation rate constants, respectively, for the ith layer, Q~ is the heat of adsorption of the first layer, and Qv is the heat of vaporization. The BET equation is often written as P _ 1 c-1 V(Po - P) Vmc + Vmc (P/Po).
(2.33)
A plot of P/[V(Po - P)] versus P/Po gives a straight line from which the monolayer capacity, V~, and the constant c can be determined. The specific surface area of a powder can be determined using equation (2.30) and the adsorbed area of a gas molecule. Nitrogen with an area of 16.2/~2 at its boiling point, 77 K, is the gas of choice for powder surface area analysis because this gas has a high c value. For low surface area powders, krypton gas is used at its boiling point of 120 K,
66
Chapter 2
Ceramic Powder Characterization
because it has a higher heat of vaporization t h a n nitrogen. Theoretical problems are associated with the interpretation of krypton adsorption isotherms due to a lack of knowledge of (r for krypton on different surfaces and ai and bi. Once the average shape of the particles in a powder has been established by one of several means and its ramifications on shape factors, fractal dimensions, surface area, and porosity are determined, the distribution of particle sizes is the next piece of information necessary to characterize the powder.
2.8 P A R T I C L E
SIZE DISTRIBUTIONS
The microscopic size data for a population of particles shown in Table 2.3 can be plotted as a histogram like that shown in Figure 2.7, where the number of particles counted in a size range is proportional to the height of the rectangle. Another plotting method is to construct the rectangles so that the area of the rectangle is proportional to the number of particles. For this histogram, the total area is proportional to the total number of particles. If a sufficient number of particles is counted and sized, a smooth curve can be plotted when a large number of intervals are used for size classification. Often, a cumulative distribu0.50
0.40 c 0 (D 0 . 3 0 13..
-> 9 0.20
a-a
O.lO
o.oo
1.4
. ~ r--!
2.8
F;. s'.6
~-] r--1
,
4'2 6b 84
Size ( m i c r o n s )
FIGURE 2.7 Size distribution histogram: % mass versus size.
2.8 Particle Size Distributions
6~
%
100 90
8O c
|
o
k--
70
D.
60
>
50
==m
ID
lz
30
20 10 0
1.4
2
2.8
4
5.6
8
Size
FIGURE 2.8
12
16
22
30
42
60
84
(microns)
Cumulative size distribution: Relative % less than versus size.
tion gives a more convenient display of the data. Two types of cumulative distribution are possible: a percent greater than distribution and a percent less than distribution. The percent greater than distribution is a summation of all the particles larger than a given size plotted as a function of size. The percent less than distribution is a summation of all the particles smaller than a given size plotted as a function of size. The cumulative distribution of the microscopic size data given in Table 2.3 is shown in Figure 2.8. The cumulative distribution has the advantage that the mean size and the percentage between any two sizes can be easily read off the plot. If the range of particle size is very large for either the histogram or the cumulative plot, a logarithmic size scale can be used. Cumulative distributions can be fitted by a linear function if the data fit a suitable mathematical function. This curve fitting gives no insight into the fundamental physics by which the particle size distribution was produced. Three common functions are used to linearize the cumulative distribution: the normal distribution function, the log-normal distribution function, and the Rosin-Rammler distribution function. By far athe most commonly used is the log-normal distribution function.
68
Chapter 2 Ceramic Powder Characterization
50,
402; 30-
.-%
/
20-
100
20
0
l'U
40
60
80
(microns)
Diameter
FIGURE 2.9 Normal distribution histogram: % mass versus size.
2.8.1 N o r m a l D i s t r i b u t i o n This type of distribution occurs when the measured value of the size is determined by a large number of small additive effects, each of which may or may not operate. This distribution gives the well-known bellshaped curve shown in Figure 2.9. It might be expected that many distributions follow this function but only narrow size ranges of classified material follow this distribution. Real distributions are skewed to larger sizes. The equation representing a normal distribution is [18] f(x)
1 (r~exp_
[-(x_
2~r2
j
(2.34)
where r is the standard deviation with units of length and E is the arithmetic mean size giving f ( x ) units of length -1. The distribution is normalized so that
f~
f(x)dx=
1.
(2.35)
oc
The cumulative distribution is the integral of the distribution function. F(x) =
f
X
f(x) dx.
(2.36)
-- o~
Tables of values of the normal distribution function, f(Z), and the cumulative distribution function, F(Z), are given in the appendix of
2.8 Particle Size Distributions 90
,
,,,
69
,,,,,,
80 .~60 9 ~o
~5 20
0
o.ol
FIGURE 2.10
~b io 3'o ~ ~;o6"07b 8'0 9'o 9's 9'8 s'9 9~8 Cumulative Percent M A S S (%)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,,
Linearized normal distribution: Cumulative
99.99
% l e s s t h a n v e r s u s size.
this book. In these tables Z = (x - ~)/(r. A plot of the cumulative normal distribution is linear on normal probability paper, like that shown in Figure 2.10. A size distribution that fits the normal distribution equation can be represented by two parameters, the arithmetic mean size, ~, and the standard deviation, or. The mean size, ~, is the size at 50% of the distribution, also written as xs0. The standard deviation is easily obtained from the cumulative distribution as O" -- X84.13 -- X50 :
X50 -- X15.87.
(2.37)
The normal distribution has the disadvantage t h a t finite fractions of the distribution occur at sizes less than zero, which is physically unrealistic.
2.8.2 Log.Normal Distribution The log-normal distribution is frequently observed in ceramic powder processing. The log-normal distribution is skewed to larger sizes compared to the normal distribution and has no finite probability for sizes less t h a n zero as seen with the normal distribution. It is obtained by replacing x with z = In d in the normal distribution, which gives the following distribution function [18]:
f(z) =
1 [ - (z - ~)2 (rz-----~ exp ~-~ j
(2.38)
70
Chapter 2 CeramicPowder Characterization
where (rz is the standard deviation of z and 5 is the mean value of z. The cumulative distribution is again simply the integral of the distribution function: F(z) =
fz f ( z ) d z
(2.39)
--or
This distribution can be rewritten in terms of size, d, as follows:
1
(ln(
In o-eX/~ exp
l) 2
2(ln %)2
'
(2.40)
where d e is the geometric mean size and % is the geometric standard deviation. The normal probability function table given in the appendix of this book can also be used for values of the log-normal distribution function, f, and the log-normal cumulative distribution function, F. In these tables Z = [ln(d/de)/(ln %)] is used. A plot of the cumulative log-normal distribution is linear on log-normal probability paper, like that shown in Figure 2.11. A size distribution that fits the log-normal distribution equation can be represented by two numbers, the geometric mean size, d e , and the geometric standard deviation, %. The geometric mean size is the size at 50% of the distribution, dso. The geometric standard deviation is easily obtained from the following ratios: ds4.1a _ dao _> 1.0. (rg- dso d15.87
(2.4:1)
If the number distribution follows a log-normal distribution then the surface area and the weight distributions also follow log-normal distributions with the same geometric standard deviation. Conversion from one log-normal distribution to another is easily done using the following equations for the various mean sizes [18]: In day = In dNs= In dNv = In dNM = In dvs = In dw =
In dgN + In dgN + In dgN + In dgN + In dgN + In deN +
0.5 In 20-g 1.0 In 20"g 1.5 In 20"g 2.0 In 2 o'g 2.5 In 20"g 3.5 In 2 o-e
(2.42) (2.43) (2.44) (2.45) (2.46) (2.47)
where dgN is the geometric mean size of the number distribution and the other means sizes are defined by equations (2.6) through (2.12).
2.8 Particle Size Distributions 10.
71
,,,,,
E 0 N
1
o.m
CO
0.1 0.01
....
FIGURE 2.11 versus size.
lb
2'0 3'0 Lo,~ 6'o 7be'o %
9b s's 9'8 9'9 9~.8'
99.99
Linearized log-normal distribution plot: Cumulative % less than
To transform from the geometric mass mean, dgM, to other mean sizes the following equations are used [18]: In dgy = In d a v In dy8 = In dNy= In d w = In d y s =
In dgM In dgM In dgM In d~M -In dgM + In dgM -
3.0 In 2 (rg 2.5 In 2 (rg 2.0 In 2 (rg 1.5 In 2 (rg 0.5 In 2 (rg 0.5 In 2 (rg.
(2.48) (2.49) (2.50) (2.51) (2.52) (2.53)
P r o b l e m 2.4. D e t e r m i n e the M e a n S i z e s [18] from a Log-Normal Distribution
Using the best fit of a log-normal distribution in Figure 2.11, calculate the mean sizes, d g y , dys, dNy, dgM, dsv with equations (2.41) through (2.46) and compare these results to those obtained in the problem in Section 2.3.1 for the same data. Using Figure 2.11, we find t h a t the dgy = d s o = 10.0/~m and the value of (rg = ds4.~3/dso = 18.5/10.0 = 1.85. With these values, we can substitute into equations (2.41) through (2.46) and get the following
72
Chapter 2 CeramicPowder Characterization
values that are compared to those obtained in the problem in Section 2.3.1"
dgN day
dNs dNy
dgM dvs
Equations (2.41)-(2.46) ftm
Problem in Section 2.3.1 ftm
10.0 12.1 14.6 17.6 37.4 25.8
10.0 12.2 14.9 17.9 34.2 25.4
The differences between the two methods of calculation seen here are a result of the linearization of the data. The results from the problem in Section 2.3.1 are the more accurate because the data is not linearized for these calculations.
2.8.3 R o s i n - R a m m l e r D i s t r i b u t i o n For materials that have undergone comminution, the Rosin-Ramruler distribution [4] is frequently applicable. The Rosin-Rammler weight distribution is given by f ( x ) = nbx n-1 e x p ( - b x n)
(2.54)
where n is a characteristic of the material and b is a measure of the range of particle size, x, being analyzed. Integration of this distribution gives the cumulative weight distribution F ( x ) = e x p ( - b x n)
(2.55)
which gives a straight line when the double log ofF(x) is plotted versus log x. (Note: Equation (2.5) is also the Weibull distribution.) The ratio of tan-~(n) to x36.s is a form of variance of the size distribution. The mass mean size, X M -- ~ x i W i / ~ , W i , is given by F(n -1 + 1) XM=
(2.56)
(nN/-b)
and the volume to surface mean diameter by mass, Xys = ~x~Wi/~,x iWi, 2 is given by X,s = [nV~F(1 - n-~)] -~
(2.57)
These values can be evaluated from tabulated values of the gamma function, F, given in the appendix of this book and experimentally determined values of n.
2.9 Comparison of Two-Powder Size Distributions
73
2.9 C O M P A R I S O N OF TWO-POWDER SIZE D I S T R I B U T I O N S For quality control purposes, ceramists are often required to determine if the particle size distribution of one batch of powder is the same or different from another. This determination is difficult when the two batches of powder have similar mean sizes. A statistical method [19] must be used to make this distinction. To determine if two particle size distributions are the same or different, Student's t-test is used by applying the null hypothesis to the two sample means. For normal distributions the t-statistic is defined as the ratio of the difference between the two sample arithmetic means (A1 and A 2) to the standard deviation of the difference in the means [20]" t =
A1 - A 2 . o~1-~2)
(2.58)
Using the definitions of the normal size distributions, the t-statistic can be formulated as follows [20]" v
~1 + ~2/
(~1 - 1)(r~ + (~2 - 1)(r~
(2.59)
where V~ and V2 are the n u m b e r of size classifications used to determine the size distributions of samples 1 and 2, respectively; (r~ and (r2 are the standard deviations of samples 1 and 2, respectively; and v is the number of degrees of freedom defined by [20] v = ~ + ~72- 2.
(2.60)
When two samples are very similar, t approaches zero; when they are different, t approaches infinity. The value of t is used to calculate the P value using Student's t-test tables, given in the appendix of this book. The P value is the probability that the two distribution means are the same; that is, A~ = A 2. When the P value is greater t h a n a critical accepted value (typically 5% [21] or the experimental error due to both sampling and size determination if it is larger) then the null hypothesis (Ho" A~ = A2) is accepted (i.e., the two populations are considered to be the same). Ceramic powder size distributions are often represented by log-normal distributions and not by normal distributions. For this reason the t statistic must be augmented for use with lognormal distributions. Equation (2.59) can be modified for this purpose to
74
Chapter 2 CeramicPowder Characterization
give [19]
T~2]'t
t = (ln ~gl _ in ~g2) [ (T~1~1.__~2_[_
(2.61)
(~1 - 1)(ln o-e~)2 + (r12 - 1)(ln %2)2 In the preceding equation the subscripts refer to samples 1 and 2, Dg is the geometric mean size (size that 50% is less than), % is the geometric standard deviation of the particle size distribution ((rg -Ds4.13%/Dso% -= Dso%/D15.s7~ >- 1.0), ~?is the number of the size classifications used to determine the particle size distribution, and v is the number of degrees of freedom defined by equation (2.60), V~ and V2 have the same meaning as before. Again, the lower is the value of t, the more likely the two particle size distributions are the same. With a value of the t statistic, Student's t-test tables can be used to determine the P value and test the null hypothesis (Ho" In Dgl = In Dg2) (i.e., when the P value is greater than a critically accepted value, then the two populations are considered to be the same). Please note that the two geometric mean sizes must be on the same basis (i.e., count or mass) for this analysis to be valid.
Problem 2.5. Comparison of Two Size Distributions [19] The particle size distributions of each of these two samples was determined by sieve analysis using five sieves. The cumulative size distribution is plotted on log probability paper in Figure 2.12. Compare the two ceramic powders, 1 and 2. A best fit of the data gave the following parameters: Sample
Dg(ftm)
%
1 2
7.0 7.8
1.2 1.5
5 5
Using the previous equations, we find that the number of degrees of freedom is 8 and the t value is 0.49. Using the standard t-test, a P value of 64% is obtained. This means that the probability that the two populations are the same is 64%. Because the P value is gTeater than 5%, we can say that these two powders are essentially the same. For most applications, powder 1 may be substituted for powder 2. For more exacting applications, a higher P value may be necessary for successful powder substitution. As a result, for each ceramic powder application a critical P value for powder substitution should be determined.
75
2.10 Blending Powder Samples [1] 300
200
100" 90" 80-
~
60 50
a
4O
10
0
1
tO 2'0 3'0''4'0 5'06"0 7'0 8'0 9"0
9'8
99:9
99.99
% Less Than FIGURE 2.12 Comparison of two log-normal size distributions.
2.10 BLENDING POWDER SAMPLES [1] The blending of two batches of powder is often performed to yield a new batch with a different mean size. The blending of two nonintersecting log-normal distributions is shown in Figure 2.13(a) where 40% of one powder with D ~ = 7.2 ~m and r = 1.6 is mixed with 60% of another powder with Dg2 = 30.6 ~m and ~g2 = 1.3. This gives a mixture with a size distribution that asymptotically approaches the 60% parent size distribution at large sizes and asymptotically approaches the 40% parent size distribution at small sizes. The location of the S-shaped intermediate size distribution depends on the relative fractions of each of the parent size distributions used. A relative percentage plot of the mixture size distribution and of the two parent size distributions is shown in Figure 2.13(b). Here we see two intersecting size distributions that when mixed show a bimodal distribution. The blending of two intersecting log-normal distributions is shown in Figure 2.14(a), where 40% of one powder with D_~1 = 14.4 and %1 = 1.3 is mixed with 60% of another powder with D~2 = 12.6 ~m and crg2 = 2.8. This gives a mixture with a size distribution that asymptotically approaches the 60% parent size distribution at both large and
76
Chapter 2 a
Ceramic Powder Characterization
lO0 -
E .N (/)
60% 10-
40% 0
..........
0.01 1() 50 9'0 99.99 Bimodal n o n - i n t e r s e c t i n g distributions.
b F(d)
0.5
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
d, s i z e ( ~ m )
FIGURE 2.13 Mixing two size distributions, bimodal nonintersecting distributions: (a) linearized log-normal plot, (b) relative % versus size. Taken from Figures 4.14 and 4.15 in Allen [1].
small sizes and approaches the 40% parent at the point of intersection of the two parent distributions. A relative percentage plot of the mixture size distribution and of the two parent size distributions is shown in Figure 2.14(b). Here we see two overlapping size distributions that when mixed show a monomodal distribution.
Problem 2.6. Mixing Two Log-Normal Size Distributions [22] Determine the relative mass fraction of a mixture of two powders, one with Dgl = 3.0 ftm and %1 = 2.0 and the other with Dg2 = 5.0 t~m and (rg2 = 1.5, which has a composite of D5o%mix = 4 ftm. The mixture size distribution, Fro(Z), is simply the sum of the cumulative distributions of each of the parents (i.e., FI(Z) and F2(Z), see equa-
2.10 Blending Powder Samples [1] a
7~
lOO size
(pro)
10-
0% ~~60%
distributions
cure.% u n d e r s i z e
0 0.01
lb
s'0
9'o
9~.99
Bimodal intersecting distributions.
b 1.5 -
f(d) 1=
0.5
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
d, size(~m)
FIGURE 2.14 Mixing of two size d i s t r i b u t i o n - m o n o modal intersecting distributions: (a) linearized log-normal plot, (b) relative % versus size. T a k e n from Figures 4.16 and 4.17 in Allen [1].
tions (2.38) and (2.39)) multiplied by the mass fraction of the parent distributions: Fro(Z) =
0.5
= Y~ . F ~ ( Z ) +
(1
-
Y~) . F 2 ( Z )
(2.62)
where Z = l n ( D s o ~ m i J D g ) / l n ( ( r g ) for their respective distributions. In this example we want a Ds0~m~ of 4/~m, so F r o ( Z ) = 0.5. Using the normal distribution table in the appendix of this book, we find F I ( Z 1 = 0.42) = 0.6628 and F 2 ( Z 2 = -0.55) = 0.2912. Using the preceding equation, we find that the mass fraction of powder 1 in the mixture, Y~, is 0.56. Blending more than two powder size distributions follows the same general rules outlined here.
78
Chapter 2 Ceramic Powder Characterization
2.11 SUMMARY This chapter has described the various techniques of ceramic powder characterization. These characteristics include particle shape, surface area, pore size distribution, powder density and size distribution. Statistical methods to evaluate sampling and analysis error were presented as well as statistical methods to compare particle size distributions. Chemical analytical characterization although very important was not discussed. Surface chemical characterization is discussed separately in a later chapter. With these powder characterization techniques discussed, we can now move to methods of powder preparation, each of which yields different powder characteristics.
Problems 1. Calculate the sphericity form factor for a cylinder having a diameter D and a length K โข D when the cylinder changes from a needle to a flake (i.e., K = ~, 89 1, 2, 4, and 8). 2. Two TiO2 powders have been analyzed for their size distributions, which follow. Can powder B be substituted for powder A? Justify your answer. D (~m)
Powder A % GT
Powder B % GT
10.0< 10.0-9.0 9.0-8.0 8.0-7.0 7.0-6.0 6.0-5.0 5.0-4.0 4.0-3.0 3.0-2.0 2.0-1.0 <1.0
100 99.9 99.2 98.7 97.5 96.6 92.2 88.5 71.7 43.2 0
100 99.9 99.5 99.2 98.4 97.8 94.6 91.6 76.6 47.6 0
3. The following table represents a distribution of size made by screening a powder of density 2500 kg/m 3. Calculate the surface area per unit mass assuming that the particles are spherical. Using microscopic counting of the same particles, a surface area per unit mass was directly determined to be 2.95 cm2/gm. Calculate the ratio between the mean diameter found by screening and that determined by microscopy. d(~m) Weight %
295 0
211 5
152 25
104 40
75 25
33 5
References
4. For and that 5. You
79
a powder with a log-normal size distribution Dg N = 1.05 t~m (rg = 1.84 measured by number, calculate the mean diameter would be measured by screening. have two powders: A B
5.2 tLm DgM = 25 t~m
D g N --
(rg = 1.9 % = 1.9
If you mix 20% in mass of A with 80% in mass of B what is the mean diameter of the mixture. 6. For a 10,000 kg batch of powder (size distribution given in problem 3) we have analyzed 20 gm. If we are concerned with the fraction of particles larger than 211 t~m in size, what is the sampling error? 7. For the powder with the size distribution determined by microscopy, which follows, determine the error in the size distribution. Assume that the particles are cubic with a density of 2500 kg/m 3. Size interval (t~m) 300-200 Number counted 3
200-150 5
150-100 25
100-75 40
75-30 25
30-0 5
References 1. Allen, T., "Particle Size Measurement." Chapman & Hall, London, 1981. 2. Tsubaki, J., and Jimbo, G., Powder Technol. 22, 161-178 (1979). 3. Stockham, J. D., and Fortman, E. G., "Particle Size Analysis." Ann Arbor Sci. Publ., Ann Arbor, MI, 1977. 4. Herdan, G., "Small Particle Statistics," p. 173. Butterworth, Stoneham, MA, 1960. 5. Wadell, H., J. Geol. 43, 250-280 (1935). 6. Heywood, H., J. Pharm. Pharmacol., Suppl. 15, 56T (1963). 7. Schwarcz, H. P., and Shane, K. C., Sedimentology 13, 213-231 (1969). 8. Meloy, T. P., "Screening." AIME, Washington, DC, 1969. 9. Meloy, T. P., in "Advanced Particulate Morphology" (J. K. Beddow and T. P. Meloy, eds.) pp. 85-99. CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL, 1977. 10. Meloy, T. P., Powder Technol. 16(2), 233-254 (1977). 11. Meloy, T. P., Powder Technol. 17(1), 27-36 (1977). 12. Mandelbrot, B. P., "Fractal Form Chance and Dimension." Freeman, San Francisco, 1977. 13. Hurd, A. J., in "Physics of Complex and Supermolecular Fluids" (S. Safran and N. Clark, eds.), p. 501. Wiley, New York, 1986. 14. Witten, T. A., and Cates, M. E., Science 232, 1607-1611 (1986). 15. Adamson, A. W., "Physical Chemistry of Surfaces." Wiley (Interscience), New York, 1967. 16. Langmuir, I., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 40, 1361 (1918). 17. Brunauer, S., Emmett, P. H., and Teller, E., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 60, 309 (1938). 18. Irani, R. R., and Callis, C. F., "Particle Size: Measurement, Interpretation and Application." Wiley, New York, 1963. 19. Shen, A. T., and Ring, T. A., Aerosol Sci. Technol. 5, 477-482 (1986). 20. Meyer, S. L., "Data analysis for Scientists and Engineers," pp. 280-281. Wiley, New York, 1975. 21. Schefler, W. C., "Statistics-Concepts and Applications," p. 246. Benjamin/Cummings, Menlo Park, CA, 1988. 22. Orr, C., "Particulate Technology." Macmillan, New York, 1966.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PART
!! CERAMIC POWDER SYNTHESIS In this part of the book we will discuss the various methods used to synthesize ceramic powders. Ancient ceramic powder synthesis techniques are shown in Fig. II.1. Up to now, we have discussed raw materials that are either natural in origin or a natural mineral after thermal decomposition. These materials require crushing and grinding to obtain a desirable particle size distribution for most ceramic processing. The fundamentals of comminution and classification will be discussed in Chapter 4. To make the best use of the potential properties of ceramics, new ceramic powders with high chemical purity and fine particle size are necessary. For this reason, methods have been developed to synthesize ceramic powder raw materials. Table II.1 gives an overview of the various methods for powder synthesis. These methods are generally broken into three categories: 1. Solid phase reactant 2. Liquid phase reactant 3. Gas phase reactant. Chapter 5 will be devoted to solid phase synthesis of ceramic powders; Chapter 6, to liquid phase synthesis; and Chapter 7, to gas phase synthesis. Other miscellaneous methods of ceramic powder synthesis are discussed in Chapter 8. All of these ceramic powder synthesis methods have one thing in common, the generation of particles with a particular particle sized distribution. To predict the particle size distribution a population balance is used. The concept of population balances on both the micro and
82
Part H
Ceramic Powder Synthesis
F I G U R E II.1
Ancient ceramic powder synthesis.
macro scale are presented in Chapter 3 for repeated use in the other chapters in this part of the book. In solid phase reaction synthesis, there are three types of chemical reactions: oxidation or reduction of a solid, thermal decomposition of a solid, and solid state reaction between two types of solid. With liquid phase synthesis of ceramic powders, there are five different methods: drying of a liquid, precipitation, sol-gel synthesis, hydrothermal synthesis, and reactions of a liquid metal melt with a gas to give a solid ceramic. There are basically three operational principles for precipitation; temperature change, evaporation, and chemical reaction. Sol-gel
TABLE ILl
Ceramic Powder Synthesis Methods.
Solid phase reactant
Liquid phase reactant
Gas phase reactant
Solid state reactant Thermal decompositions of a solid Oxidation or reduction of a solid
Precipitation Solution heating or cooling Evaporative salting-out Chemical reaction with insoluble product Hydrothermal synthesis Forced insolubility Dissolution reprecipitation
Evaporative Condensation Gas phase reaction with solid product Thermal decompositions Oxidation or reduction reactions Combination reactions with a solid product
Miscellaneous synthesis methods Solvent removal Spray drying Freeze drying Spray roasting Sol-gel synthesis Melt solidification
Part II Ceramic Powder Synthesis
83
synthesis is essentially a precipitation method; however, the solid precipitated is of nanometer size and can be organized into a gel network or sol particle depending on conditions. Hydrothermal synthesis methods use high pressure to make a specific solid phase insoluble. Gas phase ceramic powder synthesis methods include evaporation-condensation and chemical reactions in the gas phase. These gas phase reactions include thermal decomposition, oxidation or reduction, as well as chemical combination reactions. With all of these ceramic powder synthesis techniques, chemical and crystal phase purity are desired in addition to controlled particle size distributions. As with all techniques some processes are better suited than others for a specific type of ceramic powder. In addition to technical advantages of various processes, advantageous production costs also influence process selection. Some examples of commercial ceramic powder processes include solid phase synthesis of Si3N4 and SiC, liquid phase synthesis of A1203 and Zr02, and gas synthesis of Ti02 and Si02.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
3
The Population Balance
3.1 O B J E C T I V E S The population balance is used as a method of accounting for particles as they go through a process, such as grinding, classification, crystallization, aggregation, or grain growth. This chapter is devoted to the development of population balances, because it is of fundamental importance to several other of the chapters in this book. The chapter draws heavily on the excellent text Theory of Particulate Processes by Randolph and Larson [1]. The number density of particles N(L) (with units of number of particles per unit volume) is equal to the integral of the population ~?0(L) from size L to L + hL and is defined as f L+hL
N(L) = ~
~?o(L)dL.
(3.1)
JL
The units on the population ~o(L) are number of particles per unit volume per particle length, L. The population can be decomposed into
85
86
Chapter 3 The Population Balance
the product of the particle size distribution, f0(L), and the number density, n, with units of number of particles per unit volume
Vo(L) = nfo(L).
(3.2)
The number density, n, is, in general, a function of location (x, y, z) within the process equipment and time, t, because particles can be produced or destroyed so n ~ n(x, y, z, t). The particle size distribution, fo(L), with subscript zero is based on number and has the units (size) -1 as discussed in Chapter 2. This particle size distribution must be normalized such that 1 = f o fo(L) dL, to be used in population balances. Before completing this introduction, it is necessary to discuss moments of the distribution. The number density of the population, N T = f : ~o(L) dL, is essentially the zero moment, mo, of the distribution function ~?o(L). The j t h moment is described as or
mj -- fo Lj v~
dL.
(3.3)
The average size of the population is simply equal to the ratio of the first moment, m~, to the zeroth moment, mo. These moment definitions are slightly different for the population, ~0(L), when compared to the size distribution, f(L), discussed in Chapter 2.
3.2 M I C R O S C O P I C
POPULATION
BALANCE
The microscopic population balance is obtained by accounting for all the particles in a differential volume AV = hx hy hz as shown in Figure 3.1. The population for particles in a differential volume can be stated as Accumulation = I n p u t - Output + Net generation.
(3.4)
The accumulation term is the change in the population with time, d~?o/dt. The input and the output terms are considered together. For the input-output terms, we have one term due to flow and another (X+AX,y+Ay,z+Az)
X
(x,y,z) "~! FIGURE 3.1 Control volume for population balance.
3.3 Macroscopic Population Balance
87
due to internal variables like particle growth. For input-output due to flow we have d(vx ~o) d(vy ~o_____~) d(vz ~o) V . v ~?o = ~ + dy +T
(3.5)
where Vx, Vy, v z are the velocity components in the x, y, and z directions. For output-input due to growth or other internal variables x~ we must add V" Pi "1~0-"
d(vi ~?o)
(3.6)
dx i
where vi is the velocity of an internal variable for example the grow rate, G, and xi is an internal variable for example the size of the particle. For the net generation terms we have birth, B, minus death, D. Combining all these terms we have the microscopic population balance: 070 ~ 0 (VxTO) + 0 O----'t-- O--X
0
~ y ( p y T~O) -~" ~Z ( Pz T~O)
m 0 + /~'=~X~X[V~ / ~?0] -- B + D = 0.
(3.7)
This differential equation is the fundamental population balance. This equation together with mass and energy balances for a system form a dynamic multidimensional accounting of a process where there is a change in the particle size distribution. This equation is completely general and is used when the particles are distributed along both external and internal coordinate space. External coordinate space is simply the position x, y, and z in Cartesian coordinates. Internal coordinates xi are, for example, the shape, chemical composition, and the size of the particles. More convenient and more restrictive forms of the population balance will be subsequently developed.
3.3 M A C R O S C O P I C
POPULATION
BALANCE
A population balance over a macroscopic region has many engineering applications. For this type of balance the general population balance developed in equation (3.7) can be simplified. Into a macroscopic volume, we can have an arbitrary number of inputs and outputs at flow rates: Qk. In addition, if we assume that the suspension is well mixed within the volume, multiplying (3.7) by d V and integrating over the volume of the system gives j~ (~~-~ + V " ve ~o + V " Vi ~o + D - B ) d V = O.
(3.8)
88
Chapter 3 The Population Balance
The terms involving the velocity of the moving surfaces are essentially equal to the sum of the input-output streams multiplied by the population contained in them: f~ V " Ve ~?0d Y = ~k Qk ~ok +
7o d_____V dt "
(3.9)
In addition the moving surfaces of the system account for the change in the volume of the system with time. This special population balance may be written as 0~?o ~ V.v~ ~o + Ot
~?od(log V ) ( Q ~ o k ) = B -D- ~ dt
k
(3.10)
after dividing by the volume and rearranging. This is the macroscopic population balance, which is a more useful form of population balance for describing transient and steady state particle size distributions in well-mixed vessels. This population balance in conjunction with mass and energy balances gives a complete description of particulate processes in well-mixed vessels.
P r o b l e m 3.1. Constant S t i r r e d Tank Crystallizer Simplify the macroscopic population balance to describe the particle size distribution in a continuous constant volume isothermal wellmixed crystallizer with mixed product removal operating at steady state. Assume the crystallizer feed streams are free of suspended particles, that the crystallizer operates with negligible breakage, and that agglomeration and crystallization cause no change in the volume of the system. The macroscopic population balance gives a(G~o) 0~o+~ +~o ot
OL
d(log V) = B - D - ~ dt
k
~okVQk
(3 "11)
where G is the growth rate. Due to the conditions imposed, the birth, B, and death, D, due to breakage or agglomeration, the volume charge term, d(log V ) / d t , and volume accumulation, dVo/dt, terms are set equal to 0. The right-hand side of equation (3.11) represents only the mixed suspension discharge, Vo(t, L) Q/V. Assuming McCabe's law for the growth rate (i.e., G # f(L)), we may extract it from the differential, giving 0"00 70 G~-E + - - = 0 T
(3.12)
where r is the mean residence time of the vessel and is equal to the volume of the reactor, V, divided by the flow rate, Q (i.e., r = V/Q).
3.4 Population Balances and Property Conservation
89
The boundary condition for this equation results for the nucleation of particles of size Lo and is defined as v0(L) = B(Lo)/G
a t L = Lo
(3.13)
where B(Lo) is the nucleation rate. Therefore, the solution after integration of equations (3.12) is Vo(L) = Vo(Lo) exp[-(L - Lo)/(Gr)] = B(Lo)/G exp[-(L - Lo)/(G~)]
(3.14)
Here we see an exponential size distribution is predicted by the population balance. (B(Lo) is also the birth term due to nucleation of particles of size L o. It could also be used in the population balance substituting for B directly, but this approach requires a LaPlace transform solution, which also results in equation (3.14).) Many inorganic precipitations operate in this way with small supersaturation; that is, nearly all the mass is precipitated in one pass through the precipitation. This equation for a well-mixed constant volume crystallizer will be discussed in further detail in Chapter 6.
3.4 POPULATION BALANCES WHERE LENGTH, AREA,
AND
VOLUME
ARE
CONSERVED
Both the macro and micro population balances just derived conserve the number of particles. In some cases, it is appropriate to perform balances where the particles' length, area, or volume (or mass) is conserved. For example, length conservation is critical in grinding fibers and volume conservation is critical in grinding other particle shapes. Such conservation equations can also be developed under the umbrella of a population balance, but this population balance must be different than those previously derived, where particle number is conserved. The way to make them different is to couple to the population balance an appropriate conservation equation. The population based on length, area, and volume (or mass) can be derived from the population based on number as shown in Table 3.1. Let us illustrate this idea of property conservation with an example showing conservation of length.
3.4.1 Conservation of Length in the Batch Grinding of Fibers In this case, the conservation of length is maintained by assuring that
OLT(t) O f~ T~I(L, t) dL = f : Ov~(L't) ....... Ot. . . ._ O~ O ~ dL = O
(3.15)
~
Chapter 3 The Population Balance
TABLE 3.1 Population Balance Substitutions for Conservation of Length, Area, and Volume
Quantity conserved Number
Length
Area
Volume
Mass
Population, units
Normalization, units
Conversion from number based population
Size distribution, f i(L)
1
fo(L) = ~o(L)/NT
~?o(L), no./vol./m,
NT = f : ~o0(L)dL,
vl(L), length/vol./m,
LT = f : ~I(L) dL,
~2(L), area/vol./m,
AT = f : v2(L) dL,
v3(L), solid vol./vol./m,
VT = f: ~3(L)dL,
~3(L) = fig L 3
solid vol./vol.
~o(L)/NT
~m(L), solid mass/ vol./m,
no./vol. ~I(L) = flL L
Vo(L)/NT
length/vol.
"02(L)= flA L2
~o(L)/NT
area/vol.
MT = f : ~m(L) dL = ~m(L) = fig L 3 ~o(L )/NT f: Ps~3(L) dL,
fl(L) = 71(L )/L T f2(L) = v/2(L)/AT f3(L) =
~3(L)/VT f3(L) =
~Om(L )/M T
mass/vol.
in addition to the population balance equation. To cope with this situation, first of all the macroscopic population balance appropriate for a batch grinding
OVo(L, t) =B -D Ot
(3.16)
is solved for ~?o(L, t). The population, Vo(L, t), is then used to construct the population based on length, ~ (L, t), which from Table 3.1 is given by ~ (L, t) = flLL ~?o(L, t)/NT(t)
(3.17)
where flL is the length conversion factor (which is 1.0 for fibers where L is their length). Using the conservation of length, equation (3.15), we note that ~?~(L, t) must not vary with time. Hence, temporal changes in the population, ~o(L, t), must be just compensated for by increases in NT(t) with the grinding time. As a result the population, Vo(L, t), must be separable into a function of time equivalent to NT(t) and a function of size. But this is not surprising because ~o(L, t) was defined in equation (3.2) as
77o(L, t) = fo(L, t) n(t)
(3.18)
3.5 Population Balances on a Mass Basis
91
where fo(L, t) is the size distribution at a particular time and n(t) is the number of particles per unit volume or NT(t). Combining equations (3.15), (3.17), and (3.18), we find that
f : O~l(L , t) dL = (~ O[flLL ~?o(L, t)/NT(t)] dL at Ot ~o
_- f: O[flLLotfo(L,t)] dL
= 0
(3.19)
which is the governing equation for grinding fibers. As the length of the fibers decreases with time according to the population balance, the size distribution accommodates this increase, assuring that equation (3.19) is obeyed. Therefore, the conservation equation plays an important role in the population balance by placing limits on the population. In general, these conservation equations are sometimes coupled into the definitions of the birth and death functions, B and D, in the population balance, thus assuring both the conservation of a property and the balance of the population simultaneously, without the necessity of two separate differential equations--population balance and property conservat i o n - t o be solved simultaneously. Such birth and death formulations will be discussed in Chapter 4 for grinding.
3.5 P O P U L A T I O N
BALANCES
ON A MASS
BASIS
3.5.1 P o p u l a t i o n B a l a n c e s on a Discrete Mass Basis In some cases population balances are performed on a cumulative basis. One reason for such a population balance is so that theory can be easily compared to experimental data obtained from sieve analysis. To predict the mass on a sieve with size L, which came from the sieve above of size L + AL, we must perform the integral L+AL
m(L) = (
"L
L+AL
psfiV L3 '~o(L) dL = Ps fi
'~3(L)dL.
(3.20)
The mass is related to the cumulative (percent less than) size distribution by volume (or mass), F3(L), as follows:
m(L) = MT[Fa(L + AT.) - Fa(L)]
= M T
fa(x) dx
(3.21)
where MT is the total mass per unit volume and f3(L) is the size distribution by volume (or mass). Therefore if either the microscopic or macroscopic population balance is multiplied by psflyL3 and integrated over
92
Chapter 3 The Population Balance
the domain L to L + AL, we obtain population balances based on mass, which for the microscopic population balance is given by
Om(L,x,y,z,t) + V. vemm(L,x,y,z, t) at + V. v~m(L, x, y, z, t) =Bm - D m
(3.22)
and for the macroscopic population balance is given by
Om(L, t) + V . vim(L, t) + m(L, t)d(log V) Ot dt (3.23) where B~ and Dm are the birth and death functions on a discrete mass basis using sieves of a particular size.
3.5.2 P o p u l a t i o n B a l a n c e s on a C u m u l a t i v e Mass Basis In addition, population balances can be performed using the cumulative population on a mass basis. To obtain the cumulative population on a mass basis, M(L), from the population based on number, ~o(L), we must perform the following integration: L
M(L)= fo
L
L o(L)dL : fo .s (L)dL
r
The cumulative population on a mass basis is related to the cumulative (percent less than) size distribution by mass, FM(L), as follows:
M(L) = MT[FM(L)] = VTPs [ f : f3(x) dx ]
(3.25)
where MT is the total mass per unit volume and f3(L) is the size distribution by volume. Therefore, if either the microscopic or macroscopic population balance is multiplied by psflyL3 and integrated over the domain L = 0 to L, we obtain population balances based on the cumulative population on a mass basis, which for the microscopic population balance is given by
OM(L, x, y, z, t) + V. veM(L , x, y, z, t) Ot + V" viM(L, x, y, z, t)
= B M -
D M
(3.26)
and for the macroscopic population balance is given by
OM(L, t) + V . viM(L, t) + M(L, t)d(log V) ot dt (3.27)
3.6 S u m m a r y
93
where B M and DM are the birth and death functions on a cumulative mass basis. Population balances on a discrete mass basis and on a cumulative mass basis are frequently used in grinding circuits, which are discussed in Chapter 4.
3.6 S U M M A R Y In this chapter we have developed both predictive and descriptive methods for particle size distributions in various types of processes using the population balance. The population balance can be used to conserve one of the following properties: number, length, area, or volume (or mass), when appropriate conservation equations are used in conjunction with the population balance. The population balance together with (1) a property conservation equation and (2) associated mass, momentum, and energy transport equations and their associated boundary conditions provide a unified predictive theory for particulate systems. The population balance was represented in two general forms: microscopic and macroscopic. Each has advantages in the description of specific systems. These forms of the population balance together with their restrictions and advantages follow for easy reference. These two forms of the population balance can also be rewritten on either a discrete mass or cumulative mass basis.
3.6.1 Microdistributed Population Balance ~7~0 ~- V " VeT~O "~- V " ViTrO : B - D
(3.28)
ot
Uses Assumption
Spatially distributed systems Particles are numerous enough to approximate a continuum, and each particle has an identical trajectory in particle phase space.
3.6.2 Macrodistributed Population Balance 0~____~o+ V" Vi~o + Ot Uses Assumptions
dt
k
+ B -D
(3.29)
Well-mixed systems Same as microdistributed balance. Only internal coordinate particle velocities are considered.
3.6.3 List of Symbols AT f/(L) Fi(L)
= -~
Total area per unit volume (area/m 3) Size distribution (mass/m 3) Cumulative size distribution
94
Chapter 3 The Population Balance
L
Size (m)
LT Total length per unit volume (length/m 3) m(L) Population density on a mass basis for a discrete size interval L to L + AL (mass/m 3) Total mass per unit volume (mass/m 3) Cumulative population density on a mass basis (mass/m 3) Number of particles of size L to L + AL per unit volume (no./m 3) Total number of particles per unit volume (no./m 3) V Volume t Time v Velocity vector (subscript i is internal variable, subscript e is external variable) xi Internal variable vector components G Growth rate (m/time) B Birth rate D Death rate vi(L) Population density [i = 0, no./(m 3 9m)] my j t h moment of the population
MT M(L) N(L) NT
3.6.3.1 Greek Symbols flL Conversion factor for length flA Conversion factor for area fig Conversion factor for volume r
Mean residence time (time)
3.6.3.2 Subscripts e i i = i = i = i = flh m M
External variable Internal variable or basis for population 0 Number basis 1 Length basis 2 Area basis 3 Volume basis moment Discrete mass basis Cumulative mass basis
Reference 1. Randolph, A. D., and Larson, M. A., "Theory of Particulate Processes." Academic Press, New York, 1971.
4
Comminution a n d Classification of Ceramic Powders
4.1 O B J E C T I V E S To use natural minerals it is necessary to grind them down to a desired particle size distribution. Grinding can be performed with the minerals dry or slurried in liquid. In most laboratories, this process is performed in a batch jar mill while on an industrial scale, continuous comminution equipment is used in conjunction with size classification equipment to recycle the coarse material. Figure 4.1 shows a typical comminution circuit with classification and recycle steps, as well as separation of the mineral from the conveying fluid. Classification can be performed by centrifuges, cyclones, or air classifiers. In this chapter, the fundamentals of comminution and classification will be discussed in addition to a review of the different types of equipment used for these two steps. Comminution and classification are the most important methods of transformation of minerals to ceramic powders. They are also used for synthetic ceramic powders, because 95
96
Chapter 4
Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
FEEDMATERIAL
~ FLUID
CLASSIFIED R:)WDER RECYCLE
I su,soo .u,o ~ PRO~JCT FIGURE 4.1 Grindingcircuit. powders produced by chemical reaction often have undesirable particle size distributions. For this reason, comminution and classification are often used for thermally decomposed minerals and synthetically produced ceramic powders.
4.2 C O M M I N U T I O N
4.2.1 C o m m i n u t i o n E q u i p m e n t This description of communition equipment draws heavily from the same materials in the Chemical Engineering Handbook [1]. Different types of particle size reduction equipment are used, depending upon the type of material and its initial and desired particle size distribution. Table 4.1 lists these different types. When considering ceramic powders, we generally find relatively narrow size distributions are desired with the mean size less than 5 fLm. To meet these needs various types of mills are used, including (1) mills with balls, pebbles, and rods as the medium; (2) high-speed peripheral mills; and (3) fluid energy mills. Fluid energy mills are able to produce the very finest powders. Figure 4.2 shows the various types of grinding equipment. The jaw
4.2 Comminution T A B L E 4.1
97
Types of Size-Reduction
Equipment Jaw crushers (continuous) Gyratory crushers (continuous) Heavy-duty impact mills (continuous) Rotor breakers Hammer mills Cage impactors Roll crushers and shredders (continuous) Tumbling media mills (batch and continuous) Ball mills Rod mills Autogneous Stirred media mills (batch and continuous) Stirred ball mills Stirred sand mills Vibratory media mills (batch and continuous) Fluid shear mills (batch and continuous) Colloid mills Microatomizer Fluid impact mills Opposed jet Jet with anvil Centrifugal jet
crusher has an articulating arm that moves the jaws back and forth, crushing material to a size small enough to fall from the bottom of the jaws. This type of crusher can be as large as 3 m across, producing powders of 5 cm at the outlet, or as small as 10 cm across, producing powders of 1 mm at the outlet. It is commonly used in large-scale mining operations. A more efficient grinding mill for the same duty is that of a gyratory crusher. The gyratory crusher can also be as large as 3 m in diameter, producing material of 5 cm in diameter at the outlet. It consists of a cone-shaped pedestal, oscillating within a larger cone-shaped bowl. The angles of the cone are set such that the width of the passage decreases toward the bottom of the working faces. The pedestal consists of a mandrel that is free to turn on its spindle. The spindle is driven from an eccentric bearing below. Differential motion causing attrition can occur only when pieces are caught simultaneously at the top and bottom of the passage due to the different radii at these points. Gyratory crushers generally require about one-fourth of the energy input per ton of material for grinding similar to that of the jaw crusher [4]. For smaller particle sizes, the hammer mill is often used. Here the material is impacted with a heavy duty hammer
Crushing and grinding equipment. (a) Jaw crusher, (b) gyratory crusher, (c) vibratory mill, (d) fluid shear mill, (e) pin mill, (f) fluid jet mill, (g) hammer mill, and (h) ball mill. Redrawn from various figures in Perry and Chilton [1], Lowrison [2], and Van Cleef [3].
F I G U R E 4.2
98
F I G U R E 4.2
(Continued)
99
100
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
FIGURE 4.2
(Continued)
mounted on a horizontal shaft. Material is forced at high speed into the breaker plate and then falls through a grating at the bottom of the device. H a m m e r mills often clog and as a result are designed so as the motor can be reversed to unclog them. By far the most common mill for fine particle sizes is a ball mill. Here material is continuously fed to grinding media that are in constant motion, tumbling one over another. The impact of balls (media) against each other grinds the material trapped between them. After the material has been in the mill for a certain period of time, it is flushed out of the system by a flowing over a central part of the cone at the exit of the mill. The balls, which are generally larger, are retained inside the mill by a grate. Other media mills use the same comminution concept as the ball mill (i.e., collision of media with material trapped between) but apply the energy in the form of vibrational energy (e.g., vibro-energy mill) or mechanical stirring energy (e.g., a colloid--or attrition--mill). The fluid energy mill consists of a high-speed jet of particle laden gas that impinges on either another jet directed in the opposite direction or a hard wall. Particles are broken by the impact of high-speed collision. Fluid energy mills are able to produce the very finest powders, because with this method all the energy is absorbed by the particles to be communited. None is lost to other grinding media.
101
4.2 Comminution
4.2.2 E n e r g y R e q u i r e d f o r S i z e R e d u c t i o n The energy required to grind a metric ton of material with the different types of mills is given in Figure 4.3. For the very smallest grind, between 10 and 1 ftm typically used for the production of ceramic powders, ball mills, pin mills, vibratory ball mills, fluid energy mills and attrition mills are the most frequently used. The energy required for these types of mills can vary drastically from 10 kWhr/ton to 1000 kWhr/ton. The largest values are associated with the fluid energy and attrition mills. This energy is a sum of the energy required (1) to move the machine, its kinetic energy, and friction; (2) to move the material, its kinetic energy, plastic and elastic deformation, and internal friction; and (3) to break the material into smaller particles. In almost all cases, the energy required by the mills shown in Figure 4.3 is very poorly utilized. The energy required to break the material is often less t h a n 1% of the total energy needed to run the mill [4,5]. The energy, E, required to grind material into a smaller particle size, L, from size, L 0, can be described by [6]:
E =-
-~dL
(4.1)
0
where C is a constant. This equation has an exponent, n, which is given by the following "laws" [7]:
,
1000
o
: e.
LIJ >,, O)
0 Q.
r
"laws"
1 2 1.5
Kick's Ritenger's Bond's
~Attrition mill : Fluid-energy mill
100
10.
C 0
9
n
r
-
~ ~
~.Vibratory : ="-~-Ball" mill Rod
mill=
1
0.1
,
o:,
mill
--Autogenous-mill -Roller mill
% R o l l crusher = "Jaw crusher ~Hammer mill ~. -: Gyratory crusher
c o
........ 0 .... o obo, o~o~o:o~
ball
,
1.0
..........'
v
10:0 100'.0 1000.0
Feed-product size, cm
F I G U R E 4.3 Average energy required for size-reduction equipment, 9 is typical product size, @ is typical feed size.
102
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
Ritenger's law suggests that the energy required to fracture material is simply the energy required to generate new surface area. Kick's law on the contrary suggests that the energy required to fracture a particle is related to the energy stored within the volume of the particle. Bond developed a theory where n = 1.5, corresponding to a best fit of the data from many ball mill runs. Peterson [7] has suggested that there is a critical diameter above which the energy required to comminute a particle is related to the Kick's law and below which the energy required to fracture a particle is related to the Ritenger's law. The energy required to fracture material given in equation (4.1) corresponds to less than 1% of the energy required to run the mill, as shown in Figure 4.3. In comparing dry grinding with wet grinding, the value of constant C in equation (4.1) for dry grinding is 30% higher than that for wet grinding the same material [1]. For this reason, the energy utilization is 30% better for wet grinding than for dry grinding.
4.2.3 Comminution Efficiency Grinding material to smaller and smaller sizes is a process that requires more and more energy. Part of the reason is that smaller particles have more strength than larger particles, because the smaller material has fewer defects than the larger particles. An example of this phenomenon is shown in Figure 4.4 [8], where the strength of quartz glass spheres is measured at different diameters. At 80 t~m diameter, the strength is on the order of 103 N / m m 2 but at 10 tLm the strength has increased threefold simply as a result of their being fewer volume defects in the smaller particles. The Griffith law [9] of failure applies to both large and small particles. Chemical treatments can also affect particle strength. Soda glass treated with molten LiNO3 is weaker in tension by an order of magnitude [7] (the Weibul modulus increases also). Lithium ions diffuse into the glass replacing the sodium ions with a classic ~v/time dependence. This causes microcracking of the glass surface. These weakened glass particles are ground to smaller particle size faster than the untreated beads in identical ball mill tests. The other reason for the high energy required to grind to smaller sizes is the inefficiencies of grinding [6]. These inefficiencies can be separated into two major categories: mechanical, having to do with the transfer of useful energy from the grinding media to the particles being comminuted, and fluid, having to do with the transport of particles through the grinding zone. Other mechanical losses are also present, such as mechanical drive losses, but these are either minor or easily remedied. The mechanical losses in a conventional ball mill stem largely
4.2 Comminution
4.10 3
t
103
strength of quartz glass spheres, tempered for 2 hours at 1010~
3.1o3
04
E E z
v
2.1
e-
l-
,.
10~
1-
N ='10 N=22
I
N=20
........
.
0
20
40
N=20
N=20
60
80
i
l
1
100
sphere diameter x/pm F I G U R E 4.4
Strength of glass spheres. Taken from Leschonski [8].
from the fact that the energy is put into the grinding media rather than into the material to be ground. When a ball tumbles one diameter, trapping material between the impacting balls, more than 10 times the energy necessary to fracture these particles is available [7]. As a result, most of the energy is absorbed into the grinding media through losses of frictional heating or stored elastic energy. Fluid losses are harder to quantify but the movement of fluid in a ball mill drags the particles to be ground out of the way of the impacting balls, as shown in Figure 4.5.
4.2.4 P o p u l a t i o n B a l a n c e Models for Comminution Mills Generally, two types of grinding mills are used in ceramic processing. One is a batch mill or jar mill, used frequently in ceramic powder processing laboratories, and the other is a continuous mill where material is continuously fed and removed, used in industry. These continuous mills are often used in conjunction with classification circuits to recycle large material for regrinding. In this section, we consider the application of the population balance to both the batch and the continuous open-circuit mill without classified recycling. With the population balance we can describe the change in the particle sized distribution that results upon passage through the mill. For these mills we start with the macroscopic population balance from Chapter 3 which is given as follows.
104
Chapter 4
F I G U R E 4.5
Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
Fluid-particle interaction at grinding media impact.
4.2.4.1 M a c r o s c o p i c P o p u l a t i o n B a l a n c e o n a D i s c r e t e Mass Basis
Om(L, t) = _ ~ (Qkm~L, t!) + B m - Dm Ot
(4.2)
k
where Qk is the flow rate of various s t r e a m s into ( - ) and out of (+) the mill, V is the volume of the mill, Bm and Dm are the birth and death functions on a discrete mass basis using sieves of a particular size, and m(L) is the m a s s of material t h a t will fall onto a sieve of size L from the sieve above at L + AL, defined as L+AL
m(L) = ~
JL
psfiy L3 To(L) dL.
(4.3)
4.2.4.2 P o p u l a t i o n B a l a n c e s o n a C u m u l a t i v e Mass Basis
OM(L, t) = _ ~ (Qk Mk(L, t)) + BM_ DM c~t
k
(4.4)
Y
where L
M(L) = fo PsflyL3 v~
dL = MT[FM(L)]
(4.5)
and FM(L) is the cumulative (percent less than) size distribution by mass and B M and DM are the birth and death rates on a cumulative mass basis.
4.2 Comminution
105
In these population balance equations, the volume change term is zero and the internal velocity term is also zero and therefore are not included. When the population balance is performed on a number basis, it is necessary to have a conservation equation, which for grinding is usually the total particle volume. 4.2.4.3 C o n s e r v a t i o n of V o l u m e in C o m m i n u t i o n
For conservation of volume, the constraining equation is
dVTdt - fly_f: d[L3~~
t)] dL
= lpsfo d[m(L,dt t)] dL =0
(4.6)
where fly is the volume conversion factor, which is 7r/6 for a sphere where L is the sphere diameter. For conservation of volume to be applied, the population balance must be written in terms of either number or mass and either discrete or cumulative. This conservation of volume is then used to develop the birth and death functions appropriate for these population balances. 4.2.4.4 B i r t h a n d D e a t h F u n c t i o n s
The death rate in grinding is also referred to as the breakage rate and, for the population balance on a discrete mass basis, is given by [11]
DIn(L) = S(L) m(L).
(4.7)
The function S(L) is the specific breakage rate, which is dependent on particle size because smaller particles are usually stronger than larger ones, see Figure 4.4. This death rate has been shown by Sedlatschek and Bass [12] to be in accord with probability theory. The specific breakage rate, S(L), has several definitions in the literature. The simplest is [13]
S(L) = k (L/Lo) ~
(4.8)
where k and fl are constants for a given material in a particular mill under stated operating conditions and L o is a reference size. The more complex form of the specific breakage rate is [14]
S(L) = k (L/Lo)~ (1 + L/L1) A
A> 0
(4.9)
where L~ is another reference size, corresponding to the size where the grinding media is too small to nip the particle or the size of particle where fines cushion it, preventing breakage. The birth function for conservation of volume must be consistent with the death function because each particle death results in the birth of smaller particles, resulting from communition. When particles of size L break, they produce a suite of daughter particles, called the primary progeny, with a size distribution p(x, L). This function applies
106
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
strictly to the primary progeny before rebreakage. The term p(x, L) may be described as the mass fraction broken from size L that appears in size x. The birth function can now be constricted as follows: l"
BIn(L) = ly=L S(y)p(L, y) m(y, t) dy
(4.10)
where S(y) is the specific breakage rate. Combining the birth and death rates into the population balance on a discrete mass basis, we have
(
) s;
Ore(L, t) = _ ~, .Qk ink(L, t) + S(y)p(L y) re(y, t) dy Ot k V -L ' -
S(L)
(4.11)
m(L, t).
The resulting particle size distribution therefore depends to a large degree on the primary progeny function p(x, y) and to a lesser extent on the specific breakage rate. Much effort has been extended in describing the primary progeny function in a cumulative form:
P(x, y) =
f:p(z, y) dz
(4.12)
where P(x, y) is described as the cumulative mass fraction of particles ofsizey broken into sizes belowx. The t e r m P ( x , L ) m u s t be a normalized function; thus [15]
fo'P(x, y) dx = 1.
(4.13)
For mass conservation, the following must also apply [15]:
2
f2xP(x,3,) dx = 3'
(4.14)
assuming one particle breaks into two pieces. Several mathematical representations of the cumulative primary progeny function are given in the literature [11, p. 282]:
P(x,y) = ~j Ix a- y1] + [1 P(x, y) =
-- (I~j]
[ x -~l y]
1 - exp( -x/y) 1 - exp(- 1)
P(x, y) = P~(y/x)-*
with O > 0
note, nonnormalized!
The progeny function has been shown to be independent of mill diameter, ball density, ball loading in a limited range, powder charge, and hold-up but dependent on media diameter and shape as well as mill
4.2 C o m m i n u t i o n
107
linear geometry. The cumulative primary progeny function can be used with the population balance on a cumulative mass basis as follows [11, p. 329]" aM(L , t ) = _ Ot
k
/
~ l
\
v
t) } + BM -- DM /
(4.15)
where the birth and death terms are given by f
BM - DM = ly =L S ( y ) P(L, y) M ( y , t) dy - S(L) M(L).
(4.16)
Using integration by parts, the population balance can be rewritten as OM(L, t) = _ ~ Ot k
Qk _
, t)
+
s;
:L
S(y)P(L, y) OM(y, _t_____dy _~) Oy
(4.17)
which is a more condensed way to write the population balance for comminution. 4.2.4.5 B a t c h C o m m i n u t i o n
In batch comminution, the summation term in equation (4.11) is zero because there are no flows into or out of the mill. Therefore the population balance on a discrete mass basis is simplified to Om(L,ot t) = fy=L S ( y ) p ( L , y ) m(y, t) dy - S(L) ra(L, t).
(4.18)
This integro-differential equation has a similarity solution [16] for certain cases corresponding to specific forms to the functions S(y) and p(x, y). The similarity solution is of the form m(L' t) =
l--~-Z
(-4.19)
where the similarity function, Z, depends only upon the dimensionless particle size, L/X(t). The size scaling factor or the characteristic particle size, X(t), is the first moment of the normalized particle size distribution X(t) =
fl
L re(L, t) d L
(4.20)
and it varies in time according to dX(t) - - k Ko[X(t)] ~-~ dt
(4.21)
where Ko is a dimensionless constant. The preceding equation holds when the specific breakage rate, S(x), and the primary progeny function,
108
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
p(x, y), have the following definitions:
(4.22)
S(x) = k x ~ p(x,y) =
(4.23)
thus providing the definitions of k and ft. The resulting solution to the population balance is given by [17] m(L,t)=~t)~-~)
~-~ exp
[ - ~ o1
(4.24)
where K~ is a normalizing factor. Inspection of this equation shows it is self preserving. This means that when X(t) m(L, t) is plotted as a function of (L/X(t)) the function generated at different grinding times should collapse on a single curve, which is characterized by Z(L/X(t)), see equation (4.19). Employing the cumulative distribution, M(L, t) = MTFM(L, t), the similarity can be written as m
(4.25)
M(L, t) = Z(L/Lso ~)
or any other percent mass for that case where Z is the appropriate similarity function on a cumulative mass basis. This similarity analysis has been performed on data for the grinding of agglomerated A1203 platelet particles as is shown in Figure 4.6. In Figure 4.6(a), the cumulative particle size distributions are provided as a function of ball mill grinding time. Figure 4.6(b) shows the same data replotted as a function ofL/Lso~. In this figure, the data collapses to one curve for all grinding times beyond 0.5 hr and the Lso~ shows the time dependence shown in Figure 4.6(c), which suggests that a is 2.0, see equation (4.22). For the case when a = fl and a > 0, the similarity solution is given by m(L, t) = e x p [ - k L ~ t] M(L, O) + k t ~ L ~-1
M(x, t = O) dx .
(4.26)
This can be rewritten on a cumulative greater t h a n mass basis as m(x, t) dx =
m(x, t = 0) dx e x p [ - k L" t]
(4.27)
which is a R o s i n - R a m m l e r size distribution [19]. Over the years this distribution has been found to be reasonably satisfactory for many grinding systems [11, p. 330], including minerals and ceramics. In general, the similarity solution for comminution is of considerable
~ 2 Comminution
109
F I G U R E 4.6 Grinding data for Atochem A1203 Platelets Grade 1. Cumulative percent mass versus diameter for various grinding times. (a) Batch grinding, average of three measurements using Horiba Capa-700. Data from Mulone and Bowen [18]. (b) Ball mill grinding. (c) L50%versus time for grinding the platelets.
110
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders C
10
E ::::L
o~ o i.o
_..!
1
0
.....
'
1'0
..............
9
....
20
Time (hrs)
FIGURE 4.6 (Continued)
importance because it gives valuable insight into batch comminution. It shows t h a t the initial size distribution is smoothed out after a sufficiently long time and the size distribution given by the similarity solution is independent of the initial conditions. For this reason, the similarity solution is not valid for the initial comminution periods.
4.2.5 Array Formulation of Comminution Generally, these simplified progeny functions have been shown to be inadequate. As a result, the more recent approach is to use the population balance on a discrete mass basis for a series of sieves of a given range of sizes. These sieve sizes correspond to the sieves used in the analysis of the particles on a routine basis to characterize and control the product of the mill. In this case, the progeny function is averaged over L to L + AL, corresponding to the size range between sieves. This tends to smooth the progeny function, giving
Omj(t) [Qk vJk(t) ] i-1 ~ +~ -: -Sjmj(t) + [Sjp~;j my(t)] (4.28) Ot j=li>l where my(t) is the mass of material on the j t h sieve as a function of time, t (asj increases the size of the particles in the size range increases), Sj is the specific breakage for material in the size range j, and P i;j is the progeny for the j t h size range broken into the ith size range. The
4.2 Comminution
111
summation on the right-hand side is simply the birth function and replaces the integral in equation (4.28). The right-hand side of equation (4.28) can be rewritten in a r r a y nomenclature as follows"
o~
(4.29)
where re(t) is a time dependent vector of masses corresponding to each size range with elements my(t), I is the identity matrix (Iij = 0 when i ~ j, and Iij = 1, when i = j), P is the cumulative progeny matrix with elements corresponding to Pi, j, and S is the vector of specific breakage rages with elements Sj.
4.2.5.1 Batch Comminution For a batch mill, the summation of the left-hand size of the above equation is zero. In this case, an analytical solution can be obtain to the population balance (equation 4.29)" re(t) = e x p [ - (I - P) S t] m(t = 0)
(4.30)
where m(t = 0) is the vector of masses corresponding to the feed size distribution. For the case where no two specific breakage rates are the same, the matrix exponential is easily simplified by a similarity transformation into [20] mbatch(t)
--
T J(t) T -1 m(t = 0)
(4.31a)
where
{exp(-Sit); Jij(t) = {0;
T~j =
i =j} i ~j}
(4.31b)
{0;
i <j}
{1;
i =j}
i~ [ eikSk Tkj]" i>j}.
(4.31c)
In this array form, these equations can easily be solved on a computer. But, for m a n y cases, the n u m b e r of sieves used in analysis is relatively small, often less t h a n five, making m a n u a l manipulation also possible. In addition, the coefficients of the T J(t) T -~ matrix can be determined for a mill if the input and output size distribution on a mass basis is known [21]. In addition to its usefulness in batch mill simulation, this equation plays a role in the description of continuous grinding as we will see in the next section.
112
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders FEED QF = FLOW RATE "rio(L) = FEED POPULATION
MILL
V3.LlVlF_,V
PRODUCT Q =FLOW RATE q(L) = PRODUCT POPULATION
FIGURE 4.7
O p e n - c i r c u i t g r i n d i n g mill.
4.2.5.2 Continuous Grinding Figure 4.7 is a schematic diagram of a well-mixed open-circuit grinding mill. Here a powder is fed to a grinding mill with a volume V. The outlet flow rate Q is equal to the inlet flow rate QFat steady state. The mean retention time, z, is the ratio of the mill volume to the flow rate (i.e., 9 = V/Q). We have two options to attack this problem. The first is to directly use the population balance:
and a t t e m p t a solution. To do this we must know the effective volume of the mill, the flow rate in and out, as well as the masses in each size range entering and leaving the mill. If we assume that the mill is well mixed, the masses in each size range leaving the mill are the same as those in the mill, re(t). Furthermore, if the flow rate in is equal to t h a t leaving the mill, we can rewrite the population balance as
where minput(t) is the inlet masses in each size range and r is the m e a n residence time. For steady state operation, neither the inlet, outlet, nor the mill mass vector varies with time, giving upon r e a r r a n g e m e n t the simplification I n = [ I -- ( I -- P ) S T ] - 1 m i n p u t .
(4.34)
This solution, however, is only good for well mixed mills. In Figure 4.8 [22,23], the change in the particle size distribution is shown for
4.2 Comminution
1.0 ! fl=1.0 (D
113
~k~=4018
"
~
j
k~:=
1.0
k't':
0
o,
~E ~r
-5"~ EE
0.4
~/a
0.2
3 ~ 0.0 0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
Particle size, in Cumulative size distribution of ground material after various dimensionless times in a continuous open-circuit ball mill, size selectivity S(x) = kx#, ]3 = 0. Taken from AIME [22] and Randolph and Larson [23].
F I G U R E 4.8
different values of kr with a size selectivity, fl, of 1.0 (see equations (4.22) and (4.23) with a = fl). Here we see the size distribution becomes finer as the time in the mill (or the grinding rate constant) increases. At long times, the curvature of the size distribution also changes. Figure 4.9 shows the effect of the size selectivity parameter, fl, for k~ = 1.0 1 o0 .
k~'=1.0 .
.
.
.
.
!
.
08
o
~N
=4.0
~~
"~9 0.6
~a
,>~ 04
;11
~s 0.0,
0.00
,
0.02
,
i
0.04
,
!
0.{)6
0.68
Particle size, in Cumulative size distribution of ground material at a dimensionless time of 1.0 in a continuous open-circuit ball mill with various size selectivities of fl, S(x) = kx#. Taken from AIME [22] and Randolph and Larson [23].
F I G U R E 4.9
114
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
starting with the same initial size distribution as in Figure 4.8. Values of fl less t h a n 1, corresponding to the idea that small particles are stronger t h a n large particles (see Figure 4.4), gives selective grinding of the smaller particles whereas values offi larger t h a n 1 gives selective grinding of the larger particles. The second approach to a solution is appropriate for other types of mixing. The mixing is characterized by a residence time distribution, E(t), which is the distribution of time that the material is in the mill. When linear breakage kinetics occur and all particle sizes are characterized by a single residence time distribution, a general relationship between input and output of the mill can be established, using the following equation: l
moutput -- J~ m b a t c h ( t ) 0
(4.35)
E(t) dt
where the output is simply a sum of the responses of the mill to the feed size distribution treated as a sequence of impulses based on batch grinding weighted by the distribution of residence times in the mill. Making the substitution for the batch residence time and rearranging we get [21] moutput =
T
[So
]
J(t) E(t) dt T -1 m i n p u t
--
T Jc(~) T -1 minput (4.36a)
where r is the mean residence time and
J~(t) =
fo
E(O) exp{-(Si~')O} dO; i =j
{0;
(4.36b)
i C-j}
where 0 is the dimensionless time variable 0 = t/r. In this ease, any residence time distribution can be used for the mill, and the mill output can be determined from the mill input. In array form, these equations can easily be solved on a computer. But for many cases the number of sieves used in analysis is relatively small, often less than five, making manual manipulation also possible. In addition, the coefficients of the T J(r) T -1 matrix can be determined for a mill if the input and output size distribution on a mass basis is known [21]. For the well-mixed ease the residence time distribution is given by
E(O) = exp(-0)
giving
Jcij(r)
= (1 + S i r ) -1
for i = j
(4.37)
which is exactly the same as the preceding approach for a well-mixed mill; and for a plug flow case, the residence time distribution is given by
E(O) = 8(0 - 1)
giving Jcij(r) = exp(Sir) for i = j
(4.38)
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
115
In addition, several other two-parameter residence time distributions have been formulated [24]. With these or any other residence time distribution, the specific breakage rate, and the progeny array, the mill output can be determined from the mill input thus the comminution step is mathematically described.
4.3 CLASSIFICATION OF CERAMIC POWDERS Classification is the separation of particulates into a coarse and fine fractions. Classification should be distinguished from solid-fluid separation (a step also shown in Figure 4.1), although the two unit operations overlap. Classification is usually by size, but may also depend on other properties of the particles: density, particle shape, electric, magnetic, and surface properties. Classification of particulates usually takes place in a conveying fluid either liquid or gas. Classification equipment generally operates in the 1000-0.1 ftm range by the selective application of any of the following forces: gravity, drag, centrifugal, and collision. Table 4.2 gives a listing of various classification equipment.
4.3.1 Dry Classification Equipment Dry classification equipment uses a gas stream to convey the solids. The gas used most often is air, and for that reason the term air classifiers is often used to describe this type of equipment (see Fig. 4.10). Air classifiers evolved from two sources, the original simple expansion chamber and the Mumford and Moodie separator, patented in 1885.
TABLE 4.2
Classification Equipment
Classification
Size range
Wet Screens Sedimentation Classifiers Hydrocyclones Elbow Classifier Centrifuge
1 1 500 100 50
m - 4 4 ftm m m - 1 0 t~m tLm--0.1 ftm ftm-0.1 t~m t~m-0.1 t~m
1 100 1000 500
m - 4 4 ftm ftm-10 t~m ftm-0.1 ftm ftm-0.1 ftm
Dry Screens Expansion chamber Air Classifier Gas Cyclone
Air classification equipment: (a) cyclone, (b) expansion chamber, (c) modern complex air classifier, and (d) classifier based on particle inertia.
FIGURE 4.10
116
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
117
In the former, coarser particles drop out of a gas stream as its velocity is decreased upon expanding to a larger space. Baffles, vanes, or other directional and impact devices were later incorporated into the expansion chamber to change the flow direction and provide collision surfaces to knock out coarser particles, as in the Mumford and Moodie separator. In the Mumford and Moodie separator, shown in Figure 4.11, solids are fed into a rising gas tream with a rotating distributor plate that imparts a centrifugal force to them. While the coarser particles drop into an inner cone, the fines are swept upward by the action of an internal fan, move with the gas between the vanes in the expansion section of the outer cone, and are collected at its bottom. The gas is then recirculated up toward the distributor. Many types of classification equipment are commercially available. Klumpar et al. [25] discussed the major designs in a review article. Basically, there are classifiers with and without rotors that collide with the particles, those with an updraft, those with a side draft, and other miscellaneous equipment. Equipment designed for classification takes advantage of a number of different phenomena: small particles settle more slowly in a fluid than large particles; small particles have less inertia and can change their direction with gas flow more easily than large particles; larger particles require a higher conveying velocity; larger particles have a greater centrifugal force in cyclonic flow than small particles; and large particles have a larger probability of collision with a rotating blade. A classifier is designed to minimize particle-particle interactions in the classification zone allowing the fluid-particle interactions to facilitate classification.
4.3.2 Classifier F u n d a m e n t a l s 4.3.2.1 F o r c e s
Forces acting on the individual particles are responsible for directing large and small particles into their respective collection chambers. The forces that act on the particles in the classification zone are gravity, aerodynamic drag, centrifugal force, and collision. Each type of equipment listed in Table 4.2 uses one or more of these forces. The interplay among these forces is complex and not very well understood. Hence, comprehensive mathematical models for classification equipment are few and far between. Gas classifiers with internal rotors, as shown in Figure 4.11, will be used in the following discussion. The individual expressions described for the forces here are valid for all other classifiers, both dry and wet. However, the directions of
118
Chapter 4
Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
F I G U R E 4.11 Forces acting on a particle in a gas classifier. T a k e n from K l u m p a r et al. [25, pp. 17-19].
the force vectors may be different and some forces may not be applicable. In this classifier design, the feed is introduced at the center of a horizontal rotating feed plate. Friction with the plate accelerates the particles radially. Once the particles have an angular velocity, their centrifugal force accelerates them, and they bounce and roll to the outside edge of the feed plate, where they fall off. The final velocity attained by the falling particles will approach that of the angular velocity of the outside edge of the feed distributor plate. The direction of this velocity vector is tangential to the circumference of the distributor plate. Once in the gas, the particles encounter gravity, aerodynamic drag,
119
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
and centrifugal force vectors, ]/, that change the velocity vector, 2, both in direction and in magnitude according to Newton's Second Law [26]: ~ ~i - m d Ct i dt
(4.39)
where m is the mass of the particle (pTrd3/6 for a sphere of diameter d and density p). The gravity force, fv, will be directed downward in the classifier, as shown in Figure 4.11, and will be given by [13] [cv = m ( p -
(4.40)
Pfluid)g
where g is the gravitation constant. Fluid enters the classifier tangentially and then gradually turns radially into the rotor. The net slip velocity vector, ~ (= Uga~- /~particle), between this flow and the velocity of the particle will lead to an aerodynamic drag force vector, fD, that will act in a direction opposite to the slip velocity vector, as shown in Figure 4.11. leD =
88
1 " ~Pfluid
~2 " CD.
(4.41)
In this expression 88 2 is a characteristic area of a spherical particle, 1 -2 is a characteristic kinetic energy for the flow, and CD is the ~PnuidU drag coefficient [27]. For spheres, the drag coefficient is given as a function of the Reynolds number (Nae Ctpd/t~), as shown in Figure 4.12 [28]. At low Reynolds -
-
102
O
10 - "
r
~9
+-
.
'
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
~
Ellipsoid 1:0.75
Stokes,s l a : \ ~
u--~d [~ Disk
,-
~
0
...........
u---~d (~
~ ........
~.J---
u
o m 10-1_
l Sphere
m L_
!
'
u__ ~ ,~_.~,.~.
'
/
Ellipsoid 1:1.8 10-2 2 x 10-1
I
1
I
10
. I. . . . . . I . . . . . .I . 102 103 104
I
10 s
106
Reynolds number (Re) F I G U R E 4.12 Drag coefficient for particles moving relative to a fluid. Adapted from Eisner [28] and K l u m p a r et al. [25, pp. 17-19].
120
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
numbers, (i.e., NRe < 1.0), Stokes's law applies, reducing the drag force to the simple formula [14] ]~D= 3~rt~t2.
(4.42)
Owing to the forces acting on the particles, there may be a component of angular velocity, Va, in the particles' motion. This component will give rise to the centrifugal force vector [13],/~c"
[c = mv2a r
(4.43)
directed radially as shown in Figure 4.11 from the radial position, r, of the particle. The magnitude of all these forces is highly dependent upon the diameter of the particle, either through its dependence on the mass of the particle, which is equivalent to pTrd3/6, or through the drag coefficient and characteristic area. As a result, the large particles will be affected more by gravity and centrifugal forces and less by aerodynamic drag, and they will end up in the coarse particle chamber. Intermediatesized and fine particles will be affected more by aerodynamic drag and less by gravity and centrifugal forces and will be directed towards the rotor. Sufficiently small particles will pass through the pins without contact and out through the fine particle chamber with the bulk of the gas flow. (Fine particles are separated from the gas flow by an external cyclone.) The intermediate-sized particles are deflected by the pins into the coarse particle chamber. Numerical techniques have been used to predict the gas flow fields in air classifiers. These flow fields are used to compute particle trajectories using the preceding equations, giving rise to the prediction of performance of air classifiers [29]. 4.3.2.2 C o l l i s i o n
For a collision to occur, the particle must be aerodynamically captured by the rotating pin shown in Figure 4.11. There are primarily three ways [30] for this to occur (Figure 4.13): 1. direct interception, 2. inertial deposition, 3. electrostatic deposition. Electrostatic deposition and other mechanisms of capture such as diffusional deposition and thermal deposition will not be discussed in this section, as they affect only the smallest particles, which might remain stuck to the pins until being knocked off by large colliding particles. The efficiency of collision, Ek, is given by the ratio of the crosssectional area of the fluid stream from which all the particles are removed to the cross-sectional area (projected in the flow direction) of
4.3 Classification of" Ceramic Powders
121
F I G U R E 4.13 Streamlines and particle trajectories approaching a pin. Taken from Klumpar et al. [25, pp. 17-19].
the pin. Each collision mechanism has its specific collision efficiency relationship. For direct interception the collision efficiency Ek is given by -1
=
-
.
(4.44)
For other geometries, other collision efficiency expressions will apply [31]. A discussion of flat plate geometry is given by Rajhans [32], and one for spheres is given by Ottavio and Goren [33]. For inertial collision, the collision efficiency is a function of the Stokes number, as shown in Figure 4.14 [34], where the Stokes number is given [1] by N8 t
=
(Ypin - /~particle)(P -- Pfluid) d2 18/-tdpin
(4.45)
where Vapin is the angular velocity of the pin with diameter dpi n (-- Db in Figure 4.14). Other pin geometries are also presented in Figure 4.14. The total collision efficiency for both mechanisms is simply the sum of the efficiency from all the active mechanisms. For classification using cylindrical pins, the collision efficiency is dependent on the angular velocity of the pins, the number of pins in the circle, the diameter of the pins, and the diameter and density of the particles. As a result, both the feed characteristics and the operating conditions will determine what intermediate sizes will be deflected by the pins back toward the coarse particle chamber. The force imparted to a particle during contact with a pin will determine its rebound velocity. Once a particle is in free flight again, gravity, drag, and centrifugal forces must be
122
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders 1.0 O O.89" -
.!
0.7-
..-...O=o
Oz
0.1-
(9
01 0.3(~ 0.2I"= 0.10
0.01
Intercepts: Ribbon or
cylinder:
//0.~.1
--
1
Sphere:~ i
",
''I
9
01
,
,
,
i'"'~ ............... ,'
I0
1.
I
,
i
i
w
!
I
10
'
'
'
'
'
100
Nst FIGURE 4.14 Capture efficiency by inertial impaction for spheres, cylinders and ribbons. Taken from Langmuir and Blodgett [34].
accounted for to establish the dynamics of the particle. With a sufficiently large collision force, particles may fragment, resulting in the comminution of the feed.
4.3.2.3 Nonspherical Particles In the preceding sections, it has been convenient to define a spherical shape equivalent in volume to irregularly shaped particles. This is a typical simplification used throughout the classification industry, but it is fundamentally in error. For irregularly shaped particles, the specific drag force will not be parallel to the motion of the particle unless the particle has a certain symmetry or a specific orientation. For most real particles, the drag force will cause the particle to rotate as well as change translational velocity. Therefore, both force and moment analyses must be performed for precise accuracy. Moment analysis adds a level of complication that is often neglected. The drag on irregularly shaped particles is discussed in detail by Clift et al. [35]. Basically, the irregularly shaped particle gives rise to a different drag coefficient versus Reynolds number expression, as shown in Figure 4.12 for simple geometries. For aspect ratios less than 1, the drag coefficient is less than that of an equivalent sphere, but for aspect ratios greater than 1, the drag coefficient is greater than that of an equivalent sphere, as shown in Figure 4.12. Equations describing the gravity and centrifugal forces for irregularly shaped particles will not differ from an equivalent sphere if the movement of the center of mass of the particles is considered.
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
123
4.3.3 Size Selectivity, Recovery, a n d Yield Size selectivity is the best measure of classifier performance under a given set of operating conditions. Size selectivity, SS(d), is defined as the ratio of the mass of particles of size d entering the coarse stream to the quantity of size d in the feed. The equivalent mathematical expression is [36] SS(d) =
WcFc(d) WcFc(d ) + WwFw(d)
(4.46)
where We is the mass flow rate of coarse fraction, WWis the mass flow rate of the fine fraction, Fc(d) is the cumulative percent mass less t h a n size d of the coarse stream, and Ff(d) is the cumulative percent mass less t h a n size d of the fine stream. Selectivity of a typical classifier is plotted as a function of size in Figure 4.15. Selectivity monotonically increases from 0 to 1 as size increases (Curve b-b'). Even though size selectivity is a complete measure of classifier performance, the user is often required to take a shortcut method of expressing performance on a specific feed material. A practical m e a s u r e m e n t of overall classification performance for a given application can be obtained by calculating recovery and yield. Recovery is the relative amount of material in the feed that is finer t h a n size d that is recovered in the product. Recovery, R(d), expressed
100
>,, >
,,,,,,,
(,,)
a) 50
m,,,
q) w
ffl
L
Dso%
_--
O0
Particle diameter, D (pm) F I G U R E 4.15 17-19].
Types of size selectivity curves. Taken from Klumpar et al. [25, pp.
124
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
as a fraction of the feed, can be calculated from the cumulative particle size distribution data as follows. When the fine stream is the product [11, p. 329] WfFf(d) Rf(d) = WwFw(d) + WcFc(d)
(4.47)
and when the coarse stream is the desired product Re(d) =
WcFc(d) WwFw(d) + WcFc(d)"
(4.48)
The difference between the fine and coarse stream recovery is sometimes called classifier efficiency (i.e., E ( d ) = Rf(d) - Re(d)). Yield, on the other hand, is a measure of the product obtained regardless of quality and calculated as a fraction of the feed. When the fine stream is the product [11, p. 329], WW Yf-- w f + w c
(4.49)
and when the coarse stream is the product Yc =
We
wr+ Wc"
(4.50)
4.3.4 Classifier Efficiency The perfect classifier would send all particles in the feed larger than a designated "cut size" to the coarse stream and all the particles smaller than the designated cut size to the fine stream (curve a - a ' Figure 4.15). This assumes that size is the only characteristic influencing particle trajectories. Other characteristics such as specific gravity and shape will also affect the forces acting on the particles and influence their trajectories and therefore will significantly affect a classifier's performance. Real classifiers suffer from two types of inefficiency. The first type occurs because the trajectory taken by a specific particle size varies from particle to particle. The probability that a particle smaller than the "cut size" will end up in the coarse stream is not 0. Instead, the probability increases monotonically from 0 for particles much smaller than the cut size to 1.0 for particles much larger, resulting in misplaced material (curve b - b ' , Figure 4.15). The identity of the cut size is, therefore, lost in real classifiers. A substitute cut size is defined at SS(d) = 0.5 and is the size, d, of the particles whose probability of entering either stream is 50%. A measure of the slope of the probability function at the cut size is the Sharpness index, s, which is the ratio of size of the particles whose
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
125
probability of entering the coarse stream is 25% to the size of the particles whose probability of entering that stream is 75%. s = dss~d)=O.25
(4.51)
dss(d)=O.75"
An ideal classifier would have a sharpness index of 1.0; real classifiers have values less t h a n this. Industrial classifiers operating properly will have sharpness index values between 0.5 and 0.8. Actual sharpness index values will change as a function of the properties of the feed and operating conditions. The other type of classifier inefficiency is apparent bypass, a. If, because of mutual interference or other reasons, some of the feed material bypasses the separation and reports to either the fine or the coarse streams, then a certain percentage of one of the product streams will have the same particle size distribution as the feed material. Both the apparent bypass and the sharpness index dictate the performance of classifiers.
4.3.4.1 Effects of Apparent Bypass and Sharpness Index A comparison of the effects of apparent bypass and the sharpness index on the particle size distributions of the coarse and fine streams is given in Figure 4.16(a)-(d). In each figure, the product is defined by a single control point (i.e., 95% less t h a n 150 t~m) and produced from the same feed ( i.e., 50% less than 150 ftm). Figure 4.16(a) shows the results from an ideal classifier, where the apparent bypass is 0 and the sharpness index is 1.0 (a = 0, s = 1.0). Figure 4.16(b) shows the results from a real classifier with an apparent bypass into the coarse stream of 30% (a = 0.3, s = 1.0). Bypass into the coarse stream is essentially the only type of bypass observed in classification equipment. The apparent bypass does not affect the size distribution of the fine stream. However, it does affect that of the coarse stream: the ratio of the coarse stream mass to the fine stream mass increases and the recovery of 150 t~m particles decreases. Figure 4.16(c) shows the results from a real classifier with a sharpness index of 0.6 (s = 0.6, a = 0.0). The cut size, ds0, must be lowered to achieve the desired control value of 95% less t h a n 150 ftm. This trend is typical of classifier behavior. The lower the sharpness index, the smaller is the cut size required to produce the desired single-point control value. Figure 4.16(d) represents a typical industrial air classifier having both types of inefficiency (a = 0.3 and s = 0.6). The ratio of the coarse stream mass to the fine stream mass is further increased and the recovery value of the 150 ftm particles is further decreased by the combination of both types of inefficiency.
126
Chapter 4
35
a=O
....... s = 1.0
""I
Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders '
'
'
' ' " ' 1
/'
a=O
3 0 - _ d5o= 150 ~m
s=0.6
d5o=122.51~m
25 ~o
20 Fine
r
arse
-~ 9 15
0 a
~,~Feed~
10
|
35 30
i
' ' a=0.3
25
~
,
,
,
, , , I
...... s=l.0
C
i
,
i
i
Jli,
l
1 , , , ..... 1 dso =15011m
Feed~
~
I
J
:
J
,
JiJl
i
I
i
i
i
|ii
a = 0.3
~
_
, I
s = 0.6
i
,,
~
I
I
,t
!
I , , i
i
,
i
,
i,,
I
d5o = 122.5 l~m
Fines A
2o
Fine
arse
~ 15
Feed
10
b
, , l. , , , i i 100
D (~m)
l
, I t i ,,,,I 1000 10
1O0
D (llm)
10()0
F I G U R E 4.16 Size distributions for various types of classifier performance. Taken from Klumpar et al. [25, pp. 17-19].
The effects of bypass on size selectivity are shown in Figure 4.15. Bypass reporting to the fine stream changes curve b to curve c. Bypass reporting to the coarse stream moves from curve b' to curve c'. Comminution of the particles in a classifier will give rise to a size selectivity curve such as d. Analysis of various types of industrial classifiers has led to the observation that the sharpness index is essentially constant for a classifier (with a fixed geometrical configuration) over its normal operating range. Assuming that bypass is minimal, only two things affect the size distribution of the fine stream: the size distribution of the feed and the cut size. Hence, if the size distribution of the feed is constant, only the cut size (dso) will affect the size distribution of the fines. Bypass can be minimized by proper design and operation of the classifier.
4.3 Classification of Ceramic Powders
127
4.3.5 Wet Classification Equipment Wet classification is performed by filtration, settling, centrifugation, and hydrocyclones. When operated in conjunction with grinding equipment, the wet classification equipment must operate continuously and give a pumpable fluid. This is often accomplished in practice with hydrocyclones because the other methods are unsuitable (e.g., settlers and centrifuges are used for dilute suspensions, filters and screens produce a nonpumpable cake.) 4.3.5.1 H y d r o c y c l o n e s (and Cyclones) Hydrocyclone operation has been reviewed in two books, one by Svarovsky [37] and the other a conference proceedings edited by Svarovsky and Thew [38]. Hydrocyclones are generally geometrically similar to one of two families described by Rietema [39] and Bradley [40]. The geometric characteristics of these two families are given in Figure 4.17. In hydrocyclone design, the particle laden flow enters radially and rotates within the body of the hydrocyclone. Forces of gravity, centrifugal and drag, act on the particles to force a separation. The particles larger than the cut size are sent to the underflow, and the particles smaller than the cut size are sent to the overflow along with most of
Overflow Inlet
r
im
I
il
L',
c
\
\
Ou
Hydrocyclone Family
DI/Dc
Do/D c
Rietema
0.28
.34
Bradley
1/7
1/5
F I G U R E 4.17
I/D e
/
/I'
t
Underflow
L1/D c
I./D c
0
.4
-
5.0
10"-20" ....
1/3
1/2
Cyclone dimensions.
9" .........
128
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramiv Powders
the liquid. The cut size of a hydrocyclone has been shown by Svarovsky [41] and Medronho [42] to be determined from the Stokes number, Nsts0 = [(Ps - Pf)Vcdso~]/18ttDc, where Vc is the superficial velocity in the cyclone body and D e is the diameter of the cyclone. The product of the Stokes number and the Euler number, NEu = 2AP/pfV2c, where AP is the pressure drop across the cyclone, is a constant for the geometrically similar hydrocyclones. For Rietema's hydrocyclones the product is a function of the volumetric flow rate underflow to throughput ratio, Rw, and feed solids volume fraction, ~bs: NstsoNEu = 0.474 [ln(1/Rw)] ~
exp(8.96 ~bs).
(4.52)
Two other dimensionless equations 42 describe the operation of Rietema's hydrocyclones. 371.5 x,~70"ll6Reexp(-2.124~s)
NEu =
(Du~ 4"75 ~r-o.3o Rw = 1218 \De/ X'Eu
where the hydrocyclone Reynold's number is given by N R e -- D cVcPW
tt and the superficial velocity in the cyclone body, Vc = 4Q/~rD2c, where Q is the volumetric feed flow rate. The second design equation for the flow underflow to throughput ratio, Rw, is given in terms of the underflow diameter, Du, and the Euler number, which is a useful aspect of this engineering correlation. Similar equations for the Bradley family of hydrocyclones with different geometries are [43] NstsoNEu
NEu
=
0.055[ln(1/Rw)] ~ exp(12(bs)
=
258 N~e87
(4.53) ~ D u ~ 2"63 ~7-1.12 Z'Eu 9
Rw = 1.21 โข 10 s \Dcc]
The size selectivity, SS(d), of these types of hydroeyelones is given either by Lynch and Rao [45]: 1
SS(d) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . exp 3'
(4.54) + exp(7) - 2
where dso~ is the "cut size" defined earlier, d is the particle diameter, and 7 is an experimentally determined parameter typically 4.9 [45] to
4.4 Comminution and Classification Circuits
129
5.1 [26], or by Plitt [46],
[
SS(d) = 1 - exp - 0.693
d
n
(4.55)
where n is an experimentally determined constant typically n = 3.12. Other size selectivity curves have also been published [44, 47]. Apparent bypass is minimized by the section of the overflow tube that extends inside the cyclone to a level below the feed port as shown in Figure 4.17. These equations with the operating parameters give the performance characteristics of a specific hydrocyclone design. A similar series of equations can also be used to describe the performance of gas cyclones of different, geometrically similar design. Gas and liquid cyclones are also often used for size classification in grinding circuits. Much more sophisticated models for hydrocyclones have been developed by Rajamani and Miln [48] and Heiskanen [49]. They have used numerical solutions to the Navier-Stokes momentum balance equation for the swirling flow of the hydrocyclone [50]. They also used laser doppler velocimetry to validate this velocity profile, as shown in Figure 4.18(a). They then used a force balance on the different types of particles in the feed to determine the particle trajectories in this swirling flow, shown in Figure 4.18(b). These particle trajectories determine the spacial particle concentration profile, one of which is shown in Figure 4.18(c). This spacial particle concentration profile shows the high density of particles at the wall. This plot also shows some apparent bypass is occurring for this relatively high inlet volume fraction as there is a return of particles that have once migrated to the wall at the bottom of the cyclone. With the spacial particle concentration established, the viscosity can be readjusted because suspension viscosity depends upon the volume fraction of particles. With several interactions of this numerical scheme the size selectivity curve can be predicted for the hydrocyclone under these operating conditions as is shown in Figure 4.18(d).
4.4 C O M M I N U T I O N A N D C L A S S I F I C A T I O N
CIRCUITS Grinding with classified recycled material is commonly practiced in industry. Some industrial grinding circuits contain many mills of different types that operate in conjunction with classifiers of different types. By far the most common type of grinding mills and classifiers is schematically shown in Figure 4.19(a), where material is fed to a grinding mill that is followed by a classifier. The classifier is used to
(a) Left: Measured and predicted tangential velocities in a 75-mm hydrocyclone; right: measured and predicted axial velocities in a 75-ram hydrocyclone. (b) Predicted fluid streamlines and particle trajectories in a 75-ram hydrocyclone.
F I G U R E 4.18
130
FIGURE 4.18 (Continued) (c) Predicted particle volume fraction for 35% weight CaCO3 powder in a 75-mm hydrocyclone. (d) Experimental and predicted size selectivity curves for 35% weight CaCO3 powder in a 75-mm hydrocyclone (the interactions correspond to viscosity corrections made for the particle volume fraction distribution within the hydrocyclone). From Rajamani and Miln [48].
131
132
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders a FEE) QF =FLOW RATE 1TIF(L) = POPULATION FLOW RATE = Q (L)
CLASSIFIER I:EC'Ys
QR=FLOW RATE
II
mR(L) =POPULATION
PRODUCT
QP=FLOW RATE raP(L) =POPULATION
FEED
QR=FLOW RATE
QF =FLOW RATE
mR(L)= POPULATION
mF(L) = POPULATION CLASSIFIER
PRODUCT v
QP=FLOW RATE raP(L) =POPULATION
FLOW RATE
-Q
GRINDING MILL VOLUME ,V
POPULATION=rlI(L)
FIGURE 4.19 Schematic of (a) postclassification closed circuit grinding and (b) preclassification closed circuit grinding.
4.4 Comminution and Classification Circuits
133
separate the desired particle size distribution and return the larger particles to the grinding mill. This return stream is called the recycle. The recycle ratio, R, is given by
R - QR_ QR QP
(4.56)
QF"
Performing a population balance on the classifier, we find (4.57)
Qm(L) = Qpmp(L) + QRmR(L)
which can be simplified if we define a classification function, C(L), as
C(L)=QRmR(L)_ R mR(L)_ R (SS(L)) Qm(L) R + 1 m(L) R +1
(4.58)
where SS(L) is the size selectivity function shown in Figure 4.15, which is characteristic of the operation of the classifier. Several classification functions, C(L), are given in Figure 4.20. Here, the fraction of particles by mass reporting to the recycle stream is given as a function of particle size, L, for a screen and a cyclone. Several authors have used empirical classification functions instead of classifier performance curves with reasonable results for the overall comminution-classification circuit control. The steady state (i.e., dm/dt = O) macroscopic population balance on a discrete mass basis over the grind-
PJ(R+I) ,i,
1.0 SIEVE
OR CLASSIFIER C(L)
0
L(cut) FIGURE 4.20
SIZE, L
Size selectivity function for sieves and classifiers.
134
Chapter 4
Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
ing mill is given by 0 = QFmF(L) + QRmR(L) _ Qm(L_____~)+ BIn(L) - DIn(L) V V V
(4.59)
where B ~ ( L ) and D ~ ( L ) are the birth and death functions for the total system. This equation can be simplified using the classification function C(L), the definition of the recycle ratio, R, and the mean residence time r = V/(QR + QF),
0
= mR(L)
~(R + 1 ) -
1 -- C ( L ) m ( L ) + BIn(L) - Dm(L)
r
(4.60)
or upon rearrangement, mR(L) + r m ( L ) = [1 - C(L)](R + 1) [1 - C(L)] [BIn(L) - DIn(L)].
(4.61)
At this point we must use the birth and death functions described in Section 4.2.4.4 and solve this equation for the population in the mill. Then using the population balance over the classifier equation (4.57), the product population, mR(L) , c a n be determined from the population inside the grinding mill, m(L), as follows: mR(L) = (1 - C(L))(1 + R ) m ( L ) .
(4.62)
This analysis can be used in segments to describe the behavior of multistage comminution classification systems. The cumulative distribution of particles for the feed to the mill, the material in the mill, and the classified product are given in the accompanying Figure 4.21. This figure was constructed by using a R o s i n - R a m m l e r size distribution (L o = 1.0 ~m) both entering and exiting the mill (fl = 1 and kr = 0.5 ~ m - i ) and entering the 5 ~ m sieve classifier with a recycle ratio of 10. In this figure you can see the effect of grinding and the effect of classified product removal. This two step population balance for communition and classification can be rewritten in array form [21]: m
R
[I - C][TJ(t)T-i]{I - C[TJ(t)T-i]}-imF
=
(4.63)
where C is the classification array and [TJ(t)T -i] is the operational a r r a y for a continuous mill operating on the mill feed equal to the sum of the process feed, mR, and the recycle, mR, which is described by equations (4.31c) for T and (4.36b) for J(t). The classification array is defined by a population balance around the classifier: m
R -
Qm [I - C ] ~ = [I - C](1 + R)m. ~F
(4.64)
4.5 Summary
FIGURE 4.21
135
Size distribution for a ball mill grinding circuit.
By analogy between equations (4.62) and (4.64), we can see that L+AL [I
-
C] ~ f JL
[1 - C(L)] dL
(4.65)
for each element of the C array. In some cases, the feed powder has a sufficient fraction of material within the desired size range to w a r r a n t its separation before grinding, as shown in Figure 4.19(b). In this case, the classifier is placed before m R --
{ ( I - C ) [ I - (TJ(t)T-1)C]-I(TJ(t)T-1)C
+
I}m F.
(4.66)
This case can also be easily calculated with knowledge of the various arrays that have the same definitions as here except that the classification array has a different definition, which can be determined from the following equation: mR = (I -- C) (Q m + QFmF)
(4.67)
4.5 S U M M A R Y In this chapter, the fundamentals of classification and comminution of ceramic powders have been described. Comminution is described by birth and death functions in a population balance. These birth and
136
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
death functions depend on two parameters characteristic of the material being ground (i.e., the specific breakage rate and the primary progeny function). Classification of ceramic powders according to size can be performed by m a n y different types of equipment depending on whether the powder is being ground wet or dry. Each type of equipment has its own characteristics for operation. These operating characteristics can be reduced to a selectivity curve. Combining this selectivity curve and the population balance for the grinding mill a model of a comminution circuit can be developed which is useful for their design and control.
Problems 1. Experiments have shown that 750 kWhr/ton is required to grind an A1203 powder form 1 mm to 10 t~m. Determine the energy required to grind the same powder from 10 t~m to 1 t~m using the laws of Kick, Ritenger, and Bond. Note that C is different for each grinding law. 2. For a hydrocyclone with De, of 10 cm operating on an aqueous suspension of ZrO2 fed at a velocity of 5 m/sec, determine the size selectivity function. 3. For an open circuit ball mill 5 liters in volume operating at a flow rate of 1 liter per hr the product is a ZrO2 suspension with a Rosl i n - R a m m l e r size distribution with a weight mean size of 0.5 tLm and a volume to surface mean diameter of 0.7 t~m. Determine the feed distribution to the mill assuming the value of fl the grinding selectivity factor is 1.0 and k is 0.5 (hr/tLm) -1. 4. If a 0.8 t~m screen with recycle ratio fixed at 5 was used as a classifier in combination with the preceding ball mill, what would be the size distribution leaving the mill? What would be the size distribution leaving the classifier?
References 1. Perry, R. J., and Chilton, C. H., "Chemical Engineers' Handbook," 5th ed. McGrawHill, New York, 1973. 2. Lowrison, G. C., "Crushing and Grinding." Butterworth, London, 1974. 3. Van Cleef, J., Am. Sci. 79, 309 (1991). 4. Committee on Comminution and Energy Consumption, "Comminution and Energy Consumption," Rep. No. NMAB-364. National Materials Advisory Board, National Academy of Science. Washington, DC, 1981. 5. MacPherson, A. R., Society of Mining Metallurgical Engineers-American Institute of Mining Engineers Fall Meet. Exhib., Denver, CO, Prepr. No. 6184 (1963). 6. Bond, F. C., Min. Eng. (Littleton, Colo.) March, p. 315 (1953). 7. Peterson, C. R., Weiss, M. A., Klumpar, I. V., and Ring. T. A., "Shale Oil Recovery Systems Incorporating Ore Beneficiation," Final Rep. DOE/ER/30013. Dept. of Energy, Washington, D.C. October 1982.
References
137
8. Leschonski, K., "Possibilities and Problems encountered in the Mechanical Production of Submicron Particles," in Ceram. Powder Process. Sci., Proc. Second Ann. Mtg. on Ceram. Powder Process. Sci., Bergtesgaden, FDR, Oct. 1988, H. Hausner, G. L. Messing, S. Hirano, Eds., Deutsche Keramische Gesellschaft, Koln, Germany, p. 521-534. 9. Griffith, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 221, 163 (1920). 10. Ikazaki, F., Kamiya, K., Uchida, K., Gotoh, A., and Kawamura, M., Proc. World Congr. Partic. Technol. 2nd, Kyoto Japan, 1990. (1990), p. II-345-351. 11. Prasher, C. L., "Crushing and Grinding Process Handbook," pp. 267-285. Wiley, Chickchester, 1987. 12. Sedlatschek, K., and Bass, L., Powder MetaU. Bull. 6, 148-153 (1953). 13. Austin, L. G., Shoji, K., Bhatia, V. K., Jindal, V., Savage, K., and Klimpel, R. R., Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev. 15(1), 187-196 (1976). 14. Austin, L. G., Klimpel, R. R., and Beattie, A. N., in "Design and Installation of Communinution Circuits (A. L. Mular and G. V. Jergensen, eds.), pp. 301-324. AIME, New York, 1982. 15. Ramkrishna, D., Rev. Chem. Eng., July, p. 58 (1986). 16. Kapur, P. C., Chem. Eng. Sci. 25, 899-901 (1970). 17. Kapur, P. C., Chem. Eng. Sci. 27, 435-431 (1972). 18. Mulone, R., and Bowen, P., Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland (1992), private communication. 19. Rosin, P., and Rammler, E., J. Inst. Fuel 7, 29-36 (1933). 20. Gandy, G. A., Gumtz, G. D., Herbst, J. A., Mika, T. S., and Fuerstenau, D. W., Trans. Aime 241, 538-549 (1969). 21. Herbst, J. A., Rajamani, K., and Kinneberg, D. J., "ESTIMILL, A Program for Grinding Simulation and Parameter Estimation with Linear Models--Program Description and User Manual." Utah Comminution Center, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, 1988. 22. AIME, AIME Meet., New York, Prepr. 71-B-78 (1971). 23. Randolph, A. D. and Larson, M. A. "Theory of Particulate Processes." Academic Press, New York, 1971. 24. Levenspiel, O., "Chemical Reaction Engineering," pp. 270-300. Wiley, New York, 1972. 25. Klumpar, I. V., Currier, F. N., and Ring, T. A., Chem. Eng., March 3, (1986) p. 77. 26. Housner, G. W., and Hudson, D. E., "Applied Mechanics and Dynamics," 2nd ed., p. 2. Van Nostrand-Rheinhold, New York, 1959. 27. Bird, R. B., Stewart, W. E., and Lightfoot, E. N., "Transport Phenomena," p. 192. Wiley, New York, 1960. 28. Eisner, F., Proc. Int. Congr. Appl. Mech., 3rd, 1930, p. 32 (1930). 29. de Silva, S. R., Walsh, D. C., Johansen, S. T., BergstrOm, T., and Bernotat, S., Kona (Hirakata, Jpn.) 9, 131-138 (1991). 30. Wong, J. B., Ranz, W. E., and Johnstone, H. F., J. Appl. Phys. 27, 161-169 (1956). 31. Licht, W., "Removal of Particulate Matter from Gaseous Wastes--Filtration." Am. Pet. Inst., Washington, DC, 1961. 32. Rajhans, G. S., in "Air Sampling Instruments" (P. J. Lioy, and M. J. Y. Lioy), 6th ed. p. Q-1. 1983. 33. Ottavio, T. D., and Goren, S. L., Aerosol Sci. Technol. 2, 91-108 (1983). 34. Langmuir, I., and Blodgett, U.S. Army Air Forces Tech. Report 5418, (U.S. Dept. Comm., Off. Tech. Serv., Rep. PB27565) (1946). 35. Clift, R., Grace, J. R., and Weber, M. E., "Bubbles, Drops and Particles," p. 69. Academic Press, New York, 1978. 36. AIChE Equipment Testing Procedures Committee, "Particle Size Classifiers--A
138
Chapter 4 Comminution and Classification of Ceramic Powders
Guide to Performance Evaluation," AIChE Equipment Testing Procedure, AIChE, New York, 1980. 37. Svarovsky, L., "Hydrodyclones. " Technomic Publ. Co., Inc., Lancaster, PA, 1984. 38. Svarovsky, L., and Thew, M. T. eds., "Hydrocyclones: Analysis and Applications." Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1992. 39. Rietema, K., Chem. Eng. Sci. 15, 298-325 (1961). 40. Bradley, D., "The Hydrocyclone," p. 129. Pergamon, Oxford, 1965. 41. Svarovsky, L., "Hydrocyclones," pp. 1-11 and 44-57. Holt, Rinehart & Winston, Eastbourne, PA, 1984. 42. Medronho, R. A., Ph.D. Thesis, University of Bedford (1984). 43. Antunes, M., and Medronho, R. A., in "Hydrocyclones: Analysis and Aplications" (L. Svarovsky and M. T. Thew, eds.), p. 8. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1992. 44. Rosin, P., Rammler, E., and Intelmann, D., Z. VDI 76, 433-437 (1932). 45. Lynch, A. J., and Rao, T. C., Proc.--Int. Miner. Process. Congr. 11th, Cagliari, Italy, 1975, pp. 1-25 (1975). 46. Plitt, R. A., CIM Bull., 69(776) 114-123 (1976). 47. Yoshioka, N., and Hotta, Y., Chem. Eng. Jpn. 19(12), 632-640 (1955). 48. Rajamani, R. K., and Miln, L., Proc. Int. Conf. Hydrocyclones, 4th, South Hampton, UK, 1992 (published by BHRA-Fluid Engineering Center, Cranefield, Bedford, England). 49. Heiskanen, K., Kona, (Hirakata, Jpn.) 9, 139-148 (1991). 50. Hsieh, K. T., and Rajamani, R. K., AIChE J. 37, 735-746 (1991).
5
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with S o l i d Phase Reactant
5.1 O B J E C T I V E S This chapter discusses the fluid-solid and solid-solid reactions used to produce ceramic powders. The first aspect of this discussion is the spontaneity of a particular reaction for a given temperature and atmosphere. Thermodynamics is used to determine whether a reaction is spontaneous. The thermodynamics of the thermal decomposition of minerals and metal salts, oxidation reactions, reduction reactions, and nitridation reactions is discussed because these are often used for ceramic powder synthesis. After a discussion of thermodynamics, the kinetics of reaction is given to determine the time necessary to complete the reaction. Reaction kinetics are discussed in terms of the various rate determining steps of mass and heat transfer, as well as surface reaction. After this discussion of reaction kinetics, a brief discussion of the types of equipment used for the synthesis of ceramic powders is presented. Finally, the kinetics of solid-solid interdiffusion is discussed.
139
140
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
FIGURE 5.1
Shrinkingcore model.
5.2 I N T R O D U C T I O N A solid is a reactant in two general types of powder synthesis reactions. One type is a fluid-solid reaction, where the fluid is either a liquid or a gas. The other type is a solid-solid reaction. Fluid-solid reactions can be represented by A(fluid) + b B(solid)--~ d D(solid)
(5.1)
A(fluid) + b B(solid)--* d D(solid) + e E(fluid)
(5.2)
b B(solid)--* d D(solid) + e E(fluid).
(5.3)
With each of these reactions, a solid of one type (B) is the reactant and a solid of another type is the product (D). A fluid is also a reactant or a product of the reaction. In some cases, the solid product (D) forms a shell on the outside of particle B, giving a diffusion barrier for further reaction. This type of reaction is modeled as a shrinking core, as seen in Figure 5.1. In other cases, the product D flakes off the surface of particle B, because there is a large difference in the molar volume of reactant B and product D. This type of reaction is modeled as a shrinking sphere as seen in Figure 5.2 [1].
Shrinkingsphere model. From Levenspiel [1], copyright 9 1972 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
FIGURE 52,
5.3 Thermodynamicsof Fluid-Solid Reactions
141
Fluid-solid reactions include thermal decomposition of minerals, roasting (oxidation) of sulfide ores, reduction of metal oxides with hydrogen, nitridation of metals, and carburization of metals. Each type of reaction will be discussed from the thermodynamic point of view. Then reaction kinetics for all of the various rate determining steps in fluid-solid reactions will be discussed for two general models: shrinking core and shrinking particle. Solid-solid synthesis reactions operate by different mechanisms, which include solid state diffusion and chemical reaction. Diffusion in ceramic solids is always ionic in nature and depends on defect or hole diffusivity, as well as, electron conductivity. Once the ionic reactants are in close association, chemical reactions can take place. Before the reaction kinetics can be discussed, the thermodynamics must be discussed to see if the reactions are either spontaneous or at equilibrium. To determine if a reaction is either spontaneous or nonspontaneous as written, the Gibbs free energy for the reaction must be determined. The Gibbs free energy of reaction may be calculated from the free energy of formation for each of the species in the balanced reaction equation after correction for the reaction conditions (i.e., temperature and pressure). When the free energy of reaction is negative, the reaction is spontaneous. When the free energy is positive, the reaction is nonspontaneous; and when the free energy is zero, the reaction is equilibrium. A discussion of the thermodynamics of fluid-solid, thermal decomposition and solid-solid reactions important to ceramic powder synthesis is discussed next.
5.3 T H E R M O D Y N A M I C S REACTIONS
OF FLUID-SOLID
The thermodynamics discussed in this and the following section draws heavily from the book Physical Chemistry by Castellan [2]. A classic example of a solid-fluid ceramic powder synthesis reaction is that of calcination and dehydration of natural or synthetic raw materials. Calcination reactions are common for the production of many oxides from carbonates, hydrates, sulfates, nitrates, acetates, oxalates, citrates, and so forth. In general, the reactions produce an oxide and a volatile gaseous reaction product, such as CO2, SO2, or H20. The most extensively studied reactions of this type are the decompositions of magnesium hydroxide, magnesium carbonate, and calcium carbonate. Depending on the particular conditions of time, temperature, ambient pressure of CO2, relative humidity, particle size, and so on, the process may be controlled by a surface reaction, gas diffusion to the reacting
142
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
surface, or by heat transfer to or from the reacting surface. The kinetics of each of these rate limiting steps is considered later. Let us first consider the thermodynamics of decomposition of calcite (CaCO3). CaCO3(s)--~ CaO(s) + CO2(g)
kcal A~o-29S = 44.3 ~ ~"RXN mole
(5.4)
where ~AR~Z0-29S X N is the enthalpy of reaction at standard conditions (i.e., 1 atm pressure and 298 K). This reaction is strongly endothermic (i.e., AH RXN ~ is +), which is typical of most salt decompositions. This means that heat must be supplied to the reaction for it to continue. At different temperatures, the heat of reaction, AHRxN (T), is given by [2]" FT AHRxN(T) = AHRxN(298)+ ~ ACpd T (5.5) J298 where hCp is the sum of the molar heat capacities (at constant pressure) of all the products of the reaction times their stoichiometric coefficients minus the sum of the molar heat capacities of all the reactants times their stoichiometric coefficients (i.e., CpcaO -~ Cpc02 - Cpcac03 ). The standard free energy, AG O, of reaction is determined by noting [2] AGRxN = AHRxN -- T ASRxN, where ASRxN is the entropy change of the reaction. Tables of AGRxN, AHRxN, and ASRxN are available in the appendix of this book. For the thermal decomposition of calcium carbonate (barium carbonate, magnesium carbonate, and magnesium hydroxide), the standard free energy, AGO, of reaction is plotted as of function of temperature in Figure 5.3 [3]. The standard free energy, AGO, is only part of the total free energy of reaction, AGRxN: AGRxN = AGO + RgT In K
(5.6)
where Rg is the gas constant. A second term contains the distribution coefficient [2], K, which is defined as follows for the decomposition of calcium carbonate: K = fCO2 aca~ aCaC03
Pc~
(5.7)
PTOT
where fco2 is the fugacity of CO2 (= Pco2/Pwowfor a n ideal gas) and a is the activity of either CaO or CaCO3. The activity of the solids is always assumed to be 1.0, giving the preceding simplification. The second term (with the sign reversed) is plotted in Figure 5.3 as the dashed lines for various values of Pco2When the free energy of reaction, AGRxN, is positive, the reaction is nonspontaneous. When it is negative, the reaction is spontaneous.
143
5.3 Thermodynamics of Fluid-Solid Reactions
30-
PCOz or PH20(atm)
/,
~~.
22-
o
\\~. .
~'~c;~,,.~
,.>~.Q
O
e"
I
/
/
1
i
-
o
.c: rr
-6
.
.
.
/
i"
.
i
.i
11
'"
~
,,"10 T / / " ///10-'
1 /
.,~
..G-' .-" .--"~%,"
x. /
I
,/""
.
.
,I-"
.
~."
O
~
I U
,
~' ..... -----~"'-"~"""""--
,
. ....
i .......- "~
-..-"" ,
9
.
i
_ ...........
_" _
I 10
-14
.
---"
.......
.
/-"
///"
......
,.O' o 1O -, .._ ---...,. 9 102
~ "
..
"~ ~'-..
"~ " "
~"
" - - .. 1 0 3 "-...
-18 -22
-24
, , , , , 2 0 0 300 4()0 500 " ....... 600 7()0 800 " go0 1000 11'001200 1300
Temperature
(K)
F I G U R E 5.3
S t a n d a r d free energy of reaction as a function of temperature: --equilibrium gas pressure above oxide/carbonate or oxide/hydroxide. D a t a from Kingery et al. [3], with additions by T. A. Ring.
When it is zero, the reaction is in equilibrium and the standard free energy, AGO, is related to the equilibrium constant [2] AGO = - R g T In
K e.
(5.8)
For the calcite decomposition reaction, the equilibrium constant, Ke, has the same definition as the distribution coefficient, K, given
in equation (5.7) giving the equilibrium partial pressure of CO2. The dependence of the equilibrium constant on temperature is given by the Clausius-Claperon equation [2]" d l n K e AHRx N (T) = dT RgT 2 "
(5.9)
When AGObecomes zero, the equilibrium partial pressure of CO2, Pco2, above CaCO3 becomes 1 atmosphere. The temperature at which
144
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
this occurs is 1156 K (for MgCO3, T = 672 K, and Pn2o = 1 atm for Mg(OH)2, T = 550~ The free energy associated with the partial pressure of CO2 in air in contact with calcium carbonate at different t e m p e r a t u r e s is shown in Figure 5.3. From the CO2 partial pressure, we can determine the temperature at which the mineral becomes unstable when heated in air. For example, calcium carbonate becomes unstable above 810 K (MgCO3 T > 480 K, Mg(OH)2 T > 445 K, depending on relative humidity). At other partial pressures of CO2 different destabilization temperatures are applicable. The thermal decomposition of metal sulphates, acetates, oxalates, nitrates, and so forth can also be considered with similar thermodynamic considerations. Because the partial pressure of these gaseous decomposition products are minuscule in air, these salts are unstable at all t e m p e r a t u r e s where AG Ois negative. The kinetics of decomposition of these salts, however, is slow at low temperatures. These reaction thermodynamic fundamentals are applicable to all other reactions discussed in this chapter. 5.4
OXIDATION
REACTIONS
Two types of oxidation reactions are of interest in ceramics: oxidation of metals and oxidation of sulfides. The oxidation of sulphides is a common extractive metallurgical process, generating an oxide ceramic powder. The oxide product is usually an intermediate product on the way to metal production but if sufficiently pure it can be used directly as a ceramic powder. A common example is the roasting of zinc sulphide to form zinc oxide, O2(g) + 2 ZnS(s)-* 2 ZnO(s) + 2 SO2(g) kcal AH ~ - - 166.9 ~ RXN -mole
(5.10 )
or the roasting of iron pyrite, FeS2, by the reaction O2(s) + 2FeS2(s)--* Fe203(s) + 4SO2(g) AH ~ RXN
- - 5 9 2 kcal mole
--
(5.11)
These reactions are strongly exothermic, which is typical of these types of oxidation reactions. This means that the heat produced by the reaction will heat up the particle and further increase the reaction rate. The equilibrium constant for the oxidation of zinc sulphide is given by 2
Ke =
1
P~o2P~ow Po2
(5.12)
5.4 Oxidation Reactions
145
assuming all gasses are ideal and the fugacities are equal to the partial pressures. The equilibrium constant is related to the standard free energy, AGO, as shown in equation (5.8). When the ratio of partial pressures, P~so2/Po2,is less t h a n that at equilibrium, the reactant, ZnS, is unstable at that temperature. The oxidation of metal powders is a method to produce relatively pure oxides. A common metal oxidation is O2(g) + ~4 A1 ~ ~2 A1203
A~Z0-29S_ _ 268.4 kcal ~'~ RXN -mole"
(5.13)
This reaction, like all metal oxidation reactions, is strongly exothermic. The standard free energy of this and m a n y other oxidation reactions are given in Figure 5.4. Written in this form, the distribution coefficient for all metal oxidation reactions is given by -1
K = Po2 Pwow
(5.14)
assuming an ideal gas. The distribution coefficient and the standard free energy make up the total free energy of reaction according to equation (5.6). The term -RgT In Po2 is also given in Figure 5.4 [4,5] on the outside scale of the graph (pt O and scale). When the standard free energy, AG~ is less t h a n -RgT In Po2/Pwowthe oxide is stable. In gas fired metal oxidations, the fuel gives a combustion gas of a particular CO2 and H20 composition. At these high temperatures, the decomposition of CO2 CO2 ~ CO + 89 02
A~0-2~S _ _ 94.2 kca___ll ~'- RXN -mole
(5.15)
creates an equilibrium partial pressure of oxygen that influences the metal oxide stability at temperature, as does the decomposition of water H20(g) ~ H2 + 89 02
kcal A~z0-2~S_ --57.8 ~ ~'- RXN -mole"
(5.16)
Using the axes exterior to the graph in Figure 5.4, different Po2 values can be easily accounted for by noting either the ratio of H2/H20 using the water decomposition equilibrium (pt. H and H2/H20 scale) or the ratio CO/CO2 using the CO2 decomposition equilibrium (pt. C and CO/CO2 scale).
Problem 5.1. Free Energy of Oxidation Using Figure 5.4 determine the Gibbs free energy of reaction for the oxidation of Mn at 600~ in air (Note" air has aPo2 = 0.21) and combustion gases with the ratio CO/CO2 = 0.1.
146
Chapter 5
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant Hz/Hz0 ratio 1/1G'1/1/0 ? 1/1"06
Temperature 200
(~
400
CO/CO'rati;1/(O?1/1061/iOS
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1/~0 s
1 / ; 0 z'
1/~0+ 1600
1/1"0:3
11~03
1800
2000
1: lO'
l/;OZ 2200
20
1-
2400
1
161-~
,
r'o
-20-~
'
I0 z. M
"
-4o-i -60
1
lO -~ ~6L 3"
i
+'1
-80
-
11~ 6 -
9
..~-100-
103. I0!
1~~.
,q
~-120-
R
r -140-
%
=
:s ,,,0
+
I~1 - 1 6 0 "
lO'
.~-18o. // -~,oo ~
-
-
./
.~>~"
/
,:~,1
"T- T-1
/
. "
10 ? I0611~#"
T " "Tt
" ]-
1~ lO?110'I
--o
10' 10is. -T - 10 s TElement lOxide'
o,
-
2
"
8
~
0
-
- 3 0 0 I....... 473 .l_A._b__Ab solt ute zero
I Melting point
~
I Boiling point
I Sublimation point I Transition point
673
8"t3
10'73
1273
Temperature
14'73
(~
16'73 18'73 20'73 C0/COzratio 1 ~ + HzlHzO ratio
.....1~oo"'i~1s .. o l
,
1_ ~o_'~176 109 110, -2o 1":
.
16100169010 e~ 1(~?~ ~
~
~
~
1060 ~
10 sO
10 42
~
~
ld3e' *,
I
,
2 2 7 3 2473 lOj~
ld;
,
2673-T"
11012
+
1 ~f 1p- ~
+da+1-22 ++ 0 . I
16ze
....
102 ~
1~ +
FIGURE 5.4
S t a n d a r d free e n e r g y of f o r m a t i o n of oxides as a f u n c t i o n of t e m p e r a t u r e . D a t a t a k e n f r o m R i c h a r d s o n a n d Jeffes [4], modified by T. A. Ring, as well as D a r k e n a n d G u r r y [5].
At 600~ the oxidation of Mn line gives AG o = - 1 5 3 kcal/mole. For the partition coefficient term we have + R g T In K = - R g T In PoJPToT = 2.7 kcal/mole
giving a total free energy of reaction of AGRxN = h G ~ + R g T l n K
= - 150 kcal/mole
5.5 Reduction Reactions
147
which is nicely spontaneous. For the combustion gases case, we have a partition coefficient term given by
+RgT In K = - R g T In Po2/PToT. The P02 can be determined for the equilibrium
2CO 2 ~ 2CO
+
0 2
which has the equilibrium equation
Po2P~o
AG O=
-RgT In Ke = -RgT In P~o----~"
Drawing a line between point C and the ratio of 0.1 on the scale outside the graph gives the value of the term -RgT in Po2 for the oxidation of Mn at to 600~ of ~ - 9 0 kcal/mole. This gives the total free energy of Mn oxidation of AGRxN = AGO +
RgT In K = - 6 3 kcal/mole
which is still spontaneous. Such calculations predict that most metals want to oxidize in air, and they do at the surface. Fortunately, this oxide layer grows very slowly in some cases like A1. This slow growth is due to the low electrical conductivity of the oxide layer as electrons, necessary for the oxidation of the metal, must also be transfered across the oxide layer.
5.5 REDUCTION REACTIONS The reduction of oxides in reducing atmospheres is also an important industrial fluid-solid reaction that produces a powder. Because these types of reactions can affect ceramic powder synthesis, they are included in this chapter. However, these reduction reactions are frequently used to produce metal powders and are not often used to produce ceramic powders. These reduction reaction can, however, be the first step in a sequence of steps to produce carbide and nitride powders. Several examples of fluid-solid reduction reactions are Fe304(s) + 4H2(g)-o 3Fe(s) + 4H20(g)
L~/0-298 +36.6 ~kcal RXN =
CuO(s) + H2(g)--> Cu(s) + H20(g)
./0-298_-20.2
RXN --
mole
kcal mol-----e"
(5.16)
(5.17)
These reduction reactions are treated thermodynamically and kinetically in the same way as other fluid-solid reactions in this chapter.
148
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
5.6 N I T R I D A T I O N
REACTIONS
The direct nitridation of metal powders is commonly used to produce Si3N4, BN, A1N, and other nitrides: N2(g) + 3Si(s)--* 89
ATzo-29s 89.5 kca___ll ~'~ RXN = mole
(5.18)
N2(g) + 2Al(s) --* 2A1N(s)
~'~ RXNA ~Z0-298 = 152.8 molekCa---ll
(5.19)
kcal A~zo-298= 1 2 0 . 4 ~ ~'~ RXN mole"
(5.20)
N2(g) + 2B(s)--* BN(s)
These and other nitrogen reactions are strongly endothermic, requiring energy to continue. The standard free energy of several nitridation reactions are given in Figure 5.5. The distribution coefficient is defined by
-1PTOT9 K=PN2
(5.21)
This and the s t a n d a r d free energy make up the total free energy of reaction as shown in equation (5.6). In a gas mixture w h e r e PN2 = 0.79 atm and the rest is an inert gas, all the metal nitrides are stable with respect to their metals, except Fe above 250 K and Cr above 1325 K. In air where PN2 = 0.79 atm, this result is not true because the metals may also oxidize. Due to the presence of oxygen in air, we must also consider the oxidation reactions at the same time as the nitridation reactions. This is done in the next section. In addition to metal nitridation, metal carbides may be reacted as follows: N2(g) + TiC(s)-~ TiN(s) + C(s) N2(g) + MgC2(s)--* MgCN2(s) + C(s)
(5.22) (5.23)
to produce nitrides or carbonitride powders.
5.7 T H E R M O D Y N A M I C S REACTION SYSTEMS
OF M U L T I P L E
In a given system that consists of a solid and an atmosphere, several reactions are possible. For example, a metal powder could react with the nitrogen or the oxygen in air to form the metal nitride or metal oxide. This reaction can be predicted by determining the Gibbs free energy of the various reactions possible and selecting the reaction with most negative Gibbs free energy.
5.7 Thermodynamics of Multiple Reaction Systems
149
60-
40-
0
"~ E
20
0
600
800
1000
1200
1400
ir
7 r
i-.n,"
-20
I|
-40
-60
-8o
I
f "t ~ / ~
~ ~
~'~"
-140 160
FIGURE 5.5 S t a n d a r d free e n e r g y of f o r m a t i o n o f n i t r i d e s as a f u n c t i o n of t e m p e r a t u r e .
P r o b l e m 5.2. W h a t Is the R e a c t i o n P r o d u c t When A1 M e t a l Is E x p o s e d to A i r a t 800~ Two possible reactions are possible: 4 2 N2(g) + 2Al(s)--* 2A1N(s) and 02(g) + ~ A1--, ~ A1203(s)
150
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
The Gibbs free energy is calculated from the equation
AGRxN = AGO+ RgT In K for both reactions. For the oxidation reaction K = Po~ PTOT and for the nitridation reaction K = PN~ PTOT.Using Figure 5.4, the standard Gibbs free energy, AG ~ for the oxidation reaction can be determined at 800~ giving - 2 1 2 kcal per mole. The [RgT In K] term for the nitridation is given by
RgTlnK=l.98cal/mole.lO98Kln[
~J=3.4kcal/mole
yielding
AGRxN = AG O + RgT In K
= - 2 1 2 kcal/mole + 3.4 kcal/mole = - 2 0 8 . 6 kcal/mole of 02
which corresponds to the oxidation of ] moles of A1. Thus the Gibbs free energy per mole of A1 is -156.4 kcal/mole for oxidation. Using Figure 5.5, the standard Gibbs free energy, AG~ for the nitridation reaction can be determined at 800~ giving - 112 kcal per mole. The [RgT In K] term for the nitridation is given by
RgTlnK
= 1.98 eal/mole 91098~
[lO] ~
= 0.5 keal/mole
yielding AGm,e~ = AGo + RgT In K = - 1 1 2 keal/mole + 0.5 keal/mole = -:-111.5 kcal/mole of N2 which corresponds to the nitridation of 2 moles of A1. Therefore, the Gibbs free energy per mole of A1 is -55.75 kcal/mole for nitridation. Considering these two reactions, A120 a will be the equilibrium product because it has the most negative Gibbs free energy of reaction. The competition of metals for oxygen to form their oxides and for carbon to form their carbides is also a common problem for complex equilibrium calculations. In principle, multiple oxide and formation reactions can be considered simultaneously. This is the case for the reactions [6] W + 02 ~ W02
W02 + 102 ~-- W03 C+
89
~CO
2W + 2 C 0 ~ W2C + C02 W2C + 2CO ~ 2WC + CO2
5.9 Fluid-Solid Reaction Kinetics
151
2CO ~ C + CO2 W2C + C ~ 2WC. Which will be considered later in Figure 5.17, which is a plot of log
[Pco2/Pco] versus 1/T for Pco = 1 atm. Here we will see regions of the diagram that show that a particular solid product (e.g., WO2, WO3, W2C, or WC) is stable compared to all the other solid products. The most stable one is determined from the most negative Gibbs free energy of formation. The lines between two regions are constructed when the reaction that transforms one solid into the other is in equilibrium, i.e. hG = 0.
5.8 L I Q U I D - S O L I D
REACTIONS
Several reactions between solids and liquids produce ceramic powders: Ba(OH)2 (1, solution) + TiO2(s)--~ BaTiO3(s) + H20(1)
(5.24)
3H20(1) + 2 A1N(s)--* A1203(s) + 2 NH3(1, solution) (5.25) These reactions take place at ambient temperature and follow shrinking core kinetics [7,8] similar to the solid-gas reactions discussed earlier. These reactions have reasonably fast reaction kinetics at low temperatures because the liquid has a very high concentration of reactant compared to the gas phase.
5.9 F L U I D - S O L I D
REACTION KINETICS
This section draws heavily from the excellent book Chemical Reaction Engineering by Levenspiel [1]. Extensions of this basic theory to heat transfer have been made by the author. For more detail on the effects of heat transfer on the reaction kinetics, please see Wen et al. [9-13]. To consider fluid-solid reaction kinetics a generalized reaction will be considered: A(g) + bB(s) ~- rR(g) + sS(s)
(5.26)
A fluid for our consideration here is either a liquid or a gas. F l u i d solid reactions can be kinetically limited by several steps [8]: 1. Surface reaction, 2. Mass transfer in the boundary layer surrounding the particle, 3. Diffusion in the product layer,
152
Chapter 5
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
4. Heat transfer in the boundary layer surrounding the particle, 5. Heat conduction in the product layer. These rate determining steps are shown in Figure 5.6. As the reaction is written in equation (5.26), mass transfer in the boundary layer and mass transfer by diffusion in the product layer can be limiting for the reactant gas, A, making its way in from the bulk gas to the unreacted core, or for the product gas, R, making its way out. In the case of thermal decomposition of a mineral, there is only the solid B on the left-hand side of equation (5.26). These thermal decompositions can also be treated by the same rate limiting steps as given previously. Although the product layer is often porous, it can produce a slower rate of either heat conduction or diffusion t h a n the boundary layer. As a result fluid-solid reactions occur at a sharply defined reaction interface, at a position r within the particle of size R. The mass flux associated with boundary layer mass transfer is given by
J1 = 47r R2K~(CAB - CAR) ~ 47r R2Kg CAB
(5.27)
where Kg is the mass transfer coefficient (given by the Colburn analogy for a sphere),* CAB is the concentration of A in the bulk gas CAB = PAB/ RgT CAR is the concentration of A at the surface of the particle of radius
R(CAR = PAR/RgT). If the concentration of A at the surface of the sphere, R, is near zero, the boundary layer mass transfer is the rate determining step. Simultaneously, there is a diffusive flux of A through the product layer, J2, given by
dCA
J2 = 47r r 2DAE - ~ r
= constant
(5.28)
r
where DAE is the effective diffusion coefficient of A in the product layer. The effective diffusion coefficient for a porous layer is given by (5.29) where OK (= a ~/i8RgT/TrMw) is the Knudsen [14] diffusion coefficient (a is the pore radius), D A is the molecular diffusion coefficient through the gas in the pores, s is the void fraction of product layer, ~ is the tortuosity of the pores (typical value is 2.0). Without a gaseous product, rR(g), the equilibrium concentration of A at the reaction surface, r, is given by CAE = (RgT) -1 exp(-AG~xN/RTr) (5.30) * Colburn analogy: 2 KgDRAA= 2.0 + 0.6 Re1/28cl/3, where Re is the Reynold's number for flow around the sphere of radius R, Sc is the Schmidt number, and DAis the diffusion coefficient for A in the bulk gas.
153
5.9 F l u i d - S o l i d Reaction Kinetics
Moving
Gas
r eJa c t i o_ n
s_u r f a_c e ~ - .- . ~ ( '.f i l m
ffime, i--~-~
,
/
yProduct
I-..
I', IN
I ~
I
\1
i'
B
"
.~
~
'
I
R
f t-:
.,i
I" V I
,/1\ "\
I
- T - - -T - - ---l " ~= E ~;A~--, CRc__~_-] o -a o=,= - - er,~ , ~, - - 7 , 9, ~0~C o , ----4/-- ~..- - 4 ..1 R. c.~-
layer..__
,~.;-.,~i~.i:i:-Yi/!~ A
'
i~ !'\! ",LI .:~"~4 I-'-''~'1IA 14 i/i\\I i i',,
-~..~,.o 8~<
_
i ~ c t _ d d _ ' ~ ~, IXi~'e._ ! t ~ c e'...-'.'] | !-"~ - ~ i
,\ i\,
I
,'
/ /
..---
particle
of
~/Surface
I
I
/I
I
\
~"-~"--
\
~ ~"'
t----"-+~-l---,c i t i , .. I---- ~T-T--i--"'r T s ~x . ' s . . .l / I -
.
.
"~i~
~
I I
,
i
',
'
o
Tg
I
~
'= "~ '--
E
(:~
r 0 rcr R tRadial p o s i t i o n F I G U R E 5.6 Representation of temperatures and concentrations of reactants and products for the reaction A(g) + bB(s) --. rR(g) + sS(s) for a particle of unchanging size.
where A G ~ x N is the standard Gibbs free energy of reaction at the temperature of the reaction plane. The flux due to surface reaction is given by J 3 = 4~r r 2 k r ( e A r -
CAE) ~ 47r r 2 k r
CAr
(5.31)
w h e r e k r is t h e f i r s t - o r d e r r a t e c o n s t a n t for t h e s u r f a c e r e a c t i o n ( T a b l e 5.1 g i v e s v a l u e s c o r r e s p o n d i n g to t h e r m a l d e c o m p o s i t i o n of v a r i o u s
TABLE 5.1
Surface Reaction Rates, a k r - ko exp
Re ac t a n t
Ag2CO3 CuSO4- 5H20 CuSO4- 3H20 KCr(SO4)2- 12H20 KAl(SO4)2- 12H20 NiSO4- 7H20
k o (cm/sec)
1.3 3.3 2.8 2.8 1.2 8.0
x x x โข x x
105 107 102 1011 106 108
EA
EA (kcal/mole)
23.4 18.3 15.6 22.6 16.6 19.0
a Data from Shultz, R. D. S., and Dekker, A. O., J. Phys. Chem., 60, 1095 (1956).
154
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
solids) and CAr is the concentration of A at the reaction plane r. If the reaction is far from equilibrium, the concentration of A in equilibrium with the solid B is essentially zero allowing the previous simplification. The total mass transfer is related to the total heat transfer, making sure that the amount of mass reacted is equal to the heat available for reaction. This balance gives J =
Q AH~
(5.32)
The heat flux can be composed of two parts: the heat flux in the boundary layer, Q~ = 47r R 2 h ( T s - TR)
(5.33)
where h is the boundary layer heat transfer coefficient (given by the Colburn analogy* for a sphere), TB is the bulk gas temperature, and TR is the temperature at the surface of the sphere; and the heat flux through the product layer, dT Q2 = 47r r 2 K e-~r
= constant
(5.34)
r
where Ke is the effective thermal conductivity of the product layer. If the product layer is porous the effective thermal conductivity is given by Ke-[1-~+ ks~ f ]
-1
(5.35)
where e is the void fraction in the porous product layer, ks is the thermal conductivity of the solid, and k f is the thermal conductivity of the fluid (liquid or gas) in the pores. To complete the picture, the flux of gas, A, must be related to the change in B and the size shrinking core radius, r. This can be accomplished by considering that the change in moles of B is equal to b times the change in the moles of A, from the reaction stoichiometry, which is also equal to the flux J described by equations (5.27), (5.28), (5.31), and (5.32): -dNB = -bdNA = -bJ.
(5.36)
The change in the number of moles of B is related to the change in the volume of B in the core: - d N B = - - P B d V = - - P B 47r r 2 d r
(5.37)
where PB is the molar volume of the solid (i.e., moles per cc). Using the relation between the flux J and the change in core radius given in * Colburn analogy: 2hR/kf = 2.0 + 0.6 Re 1/2Pr 1/3,where kf is the thermal conductivity of the bulk gas, Re is the Reynolds number, and Pr is the Prandlt number.
5.9 F l u i d - S o l i d Reaction Kinetics
155
equations (5.36) and (5.37) with the definitions of the fluxes for mass and heat transfer equations (5.27), (5.28), (5.31), (5.32) (with eq. (5.33) and (5.34)), it is possible to determine the time dependence of the fractional conversion, X B : ,,:1
'
for the shrinking core model (see Fig. 5.1) for a sphere (cylinder and plate) as given in Table 5.2. For all of these rate limiting steps the fractional conversion is a function of the time, t, divided by the time for complete conversion of the particle, r.
T A B L E 5.2 C o n v e r s i o n , XB, v e r s u s Time for S h r i n k i n g C o r e Model: A ( g ) + b B ( s ) ~rR(g) + sS(s) ,
,,,,
,
B o u n d a r y layer
Pore diffusion
Surface reaction
S p h e r e XB = 1 -- (r/R )3 Rate Controlling Step--Mass Transfer t/r = XB t/r = 1 -- 3(1 -- XB)2/3 + 2(1 -- XB)
pBR r = 3b K g C ~
pB R2 r = 6b De-----~
Rate Controlling Step--Heat Transfer t/r = X s t/r = 1 - 3(1
AH~xN PBR r = 3bh (TB - Ts)
-
X B)2/3
~_
t/r = 1 - (1 - XB) 1/3 T--
2(1
-
PBR bkrCAB
X B)
A H ~ ps R2 r = 6bKe (T B - T S)
P l a t e XB = 1 -- (x/L), L is t h e p l a t e t h i c k n e s s . Rate Controlling Step--Mass t/T = XB
Transfer t/r =
PBL = 3bgg-----~
pB L2 T = 2bDe'----~
Rate Controlling Step--Heat
T
~
t/r = X s AH~xN ps L b h ( T s - Ts)
t i t = XB PBL T-bkrCAs
Transfer
T--
t/r = X 2 AH~xN ps L 2 2 b k e ( T s - Ts)
C y l i n d e r XB = 1 -- (r/R)2 Rate Controlling Step--Mass
Transfer
t/r = XB PBR
t/r = XB + (1 -- XB) In (1 - XB) psR 2
~" = 2bgg-----~
~" = 4bDe-----~
Rate Controlling Step--Heat
t/r = XB AH~zcN pBR r = 2bh(TB - T s) ,,,,
Transfer
t/r = XB + (1 -- XB) In (1 -- X B) AH~xN ps R2 r = 4bke(T s _ Ts) ,
,
,,
,,
t i t = 1 - (1 - XB) 1/2 7"---
PBR bkrCAs
156
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
1.0
Particles of constant size Gas film diffusion
0.8
f~ C h e mcontrols ical
0.6
.x/
reaction
~fcontrols /~ Ash layer diffusion 'controls
,\\
fl0
x i
~
\
X \\ ~
0.4 ~k
<~
_ \
\,
Shrinking particles ~ fStokes regime 1x ~ L a r g e , turbulent regime
~
'" ~V_Reaction "~ ~ ' > ( ~ x cOntrOls
0.2
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
t/'~
FIGURE 5.7 Conversion versus time of a single spherical particle reacting with a surrounding fluid, r = time for complete conversion. From Levenspiel [1], copyright 9 1972 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
The results of these various models for a sphere are plotted Figure 5.7. All these models have similar trends with respect to conversion, XB versus dimensionless time, t/r. When the time scale has dimensions, then it is much easier to determine the rate controlling mechanism, because the time for maximum conversion, r, is so different for the different rate determining steps. The time for all fractional conversions, t, that are the same, has a very different dependence on the particle size, depending on the rate controlling step, as follows: t ~ R 15-2~ for boundary layer mass transfer or boundary layer heat transfer (the exponent drops as the Reynolds number rises, i.e. turbulent flow), t a R 2 for product layer diffusion control or product layer heat conduction control, t a R for chemical reaction control. Hence, kinetic runs with different particles of the same size can be used to distinguish between different rate determining steps. In the equations given in Table 5.2 the surface temperature is not known. The surface temperature is obtained by making the heat and mass transfer fluxes equal as given in equation (5.32). This is equivalent to equating the expressions for the values of~ for heat and mass transfer
5.9 Fluid-Solid Reaction Kinetics
157
given in this table. The largest r value is that of the rate determining step. There is always one rate determining step for heat transfer and another for mass transfer. Neglecting heat transfer as others [1] have done requires that the surface temperature be assumed. Only by equating heat and mass transfer steps can the surface temperature be calculated. These conversion time expressions assume that a single rate resistance controls the reaction of the particle. For a sphere these conversions are plotted in Figure 5.7 as a function of time for different regimes of control. The relative rate of each of the resistances changes as reaction time progresses. As shown schematically in Figure 5.8, initially the product layer provides no rate resistance because it is very thin. After some degree of reaction, however, the product layer grows thicker and can become rate controlling. For this reason, it is not reasonable that just one resistance controls the reaction rate throughout the whole reaction. Accounting for the simultaneous action of these resistances is straightforward because all are linear in reactant concentration. Thus a sum of the time values for each step is a means to obtain the total reaction time" Ttota1 :
TMT -Jr- TpD -~- TSR -F- THT ~- THC
(5.39)
where the r values are those given in Tables 5.2 and 5.3, where the subscripts correspond to mass transfer, MT; pore diffusion, PD; surface reaction, SR; heat transfer, HT; and heat conduction, HC.
Chemical reaction step controls
jFilm
diffusion controls fusion controls
o
Temperature T
FIGURE 5.8 Rate of reaction versus temperature. Because of the series relationship among resistances to reaction, the net or observable rate is never higher than for any individual steps acting alone. From Levenspiel [1], copyright 9 1972 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
158
Chapter 5
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
5.3 S p h e r e C o n v e r s i o n , XB = 1 (r/R)3, v e r s u s T i m e for S h r i n k i n g S p h e r e :
TABLE
A(g) + bB(s) ~
rR(g) + sS(s)
Boundary layer
Surface reaction
Rate Controlling Step--Mass
XB) 2/3 T psR2 r = 2bKg----~ t = 1 - (1 -
Rate Controlling Step--Heat
Transfer t = 1 -- (1 -- XB) 1/3
r
PBR r = bkrCAB Transfer
XB) 2/3 AHRxN PsR2 2 b h ( T s - Ts)
t = 1 - (1 -
r T"-
5.9.1 Shrinking Sphere Model When the product layer flakes off as fast as it is formed, the reaction may be considered to be occurring at the surface of a shrinking particle (see Figure 5.2). This type of reaction is described by the following steps: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Mass transfer of A to the surface of the particle, Surface reaction between A and B, Mass transfer of any product gas away from the particle, Heat transfer to or from the particle surface, depending on whether the reaction is endothermic or exothermic.
As with the shrinking core model, boundary layer mass and heat transfer fluxes are applicable as well as the surface reaction flux. The fluxes are combined in a way similar to that of the shrinking core model to give the results in Table 5.3 for a shrinking sphere model. When this model is applicable, the particle morphology changes drastically during reaction from particles to flakes of particles. In the equations given in Table 5.3 the surface temperature is not known. The surface temperature is obtained by making the heat and mass transfer fluxes equal, as given in equation (5.32). This is equivalent to equating the expressions for the values of 9 for heat and mass transfer given in this table. The largest ~ value is that for the rate determining steps. There is always one rate determining step for heat transfer and another for mass transfer.
5.9.2 Comparison with Kinetic Models Thermal decomposition of CaCO3 has been studied by Satterfield and Frales [15]. They found that at low temperatures the crystallite size had a strong effect on the decomposition rate, indicating that pore
159
5.9 F l u i d - S o l i d Reaction Kinetics 1800 A
'
,
982oc
1760
o
1720 933
E
1680
Center
~
temperature
1640
1600
0
,,
2'0 4'0
6'0
8'0 1;0 120
883~
(rain)
Time
F I G U R E 5.9 Comparison of furnace temperature to center-line temperature of a cylindrical CaCO ~sample thrust into a preheated oven. Taken from Satterfield and Feales [15].
diffusion was the rate determining step. At high temperatures, the rate controlling step was heat transfer. Figure 5.9 shows the centerline temperature of a pressed cylinder of CaCO3 powder with time after being inserted into a furnace at 1780~ (= 971~ The center-line temperature increases to a maximum at 1680~ (= 915~ where CaO nucleation takes place. The subsequent decrease in temperature is a result of the endothermic heat of reaction. For the balance of the reaction, the center-line temperature is ~150~ (= 65~ less than the furnace temperature. At the end of thermal decomposition, the temperature increases to the furnace temperature. The effect of ambient CO2 partial pressure on reaction kinetics was studied by Hyatt et al. [16] and is shown in Figure 5.10.
6.0~
~
I\ I
-=
.~,~ E~
~._~ 9 3.o oo~ 2.0 o
I i
O,
---
\~
Theoretical
\.
O0~ \ss0oc ~ ~ 9
0
o o Experimental
~'.
0.1
0.2
,
0.3 C02
o
,
0.4
h
0.5
"
,
0.6
, .......
0.7
,
0.8
'
-
0.9
pressure (atm)
F I G U R E 5.10 Rate of CaCO 3 decomposition in C O 2 atmosphere. From Hyatt et al. [16]. Reprinted by permission of the American Ceramic Society.
160
Chapter 5 CeramicPowder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
40 .............. x
1-2p
-!
3o
4-6p i 2o
lO
=5 0 0
'
2{~0 '
400
' 6{]0
800
10'00
12'00
Time (minutes)
FIGURE 5.11 Kaolinite decomposition at 400~ in a vacuum. From Holt et al. [17]. Reprinted by permission of the American Ceramic Society.
These results show that the rate of CaCO3 decomposition follows: 1 Surface reaction rate . . . . .
Pc02 P$02 1
(5.40)
SP~o 2 + R--~o where P~02 is the equilibrium CO2 partial pressure, Ro is the decomposition rate in an atmosphere void of CO2, and B is a constant. This surface reaction rate has the asymptotic behavior of rate = kr(CRE -- e R r ) given in equation 5.31 when Ro is negligible and BP~o 2 is a constant for a particular temperature. Here the subscript R corresponds to the product gas rR(g) in reaction (5.26) with its concentration e R r - - PRr/RgT at the reaction surface, r, and at equilibrium, e R E -PRE/RgT.
Some of the clay minerals, kaolin in particular, decompose in a twostep manner. Above 500~ the water of crystallization evolves by a shrinking core model, assuming a flat plate particle structure. Figure 5.11 [17] shows the typical X~ versus t plot for the decomposition of three size fractions of kaolinite at 400~ in vacuum. The product layer is a pseudomorph of the original crystal structure with vacancies at anion sites. This pseudomorph structure remains until 980~ when it collapses into crystalline mullite and silica releasing energy. The kinetics of the second solid state reaction is controlled by solid state diffusion. A similar situation is observed for the decomposition of A1203 93H20 gibbsite. The thermal decomposition of magnesium hydroxide was studied by Gordon and Kingery [18]. Their results, given in Figure 5.12, show
161
5.9 F l u i d - S o l i d Reaction Kinetics 1.0 m
x
~D r 0
o.
E
0.5
0.2
0 r
lo C
O
0.1
C
o
t~ L It.
0.5
"1
I 0
O
o 40
80
120
160
200
240
280
Time (min)
Decomposition of Mg(OH)2 at various temperatures, showing first-order reaction kinetics. From Gordon and Kingery [18]. Reprinted by permission of the American Ceramic Society.
FIGURE 5.12
that either boundary layer mass transfer or heat transfer controls the rate of thermal decomposition.
5.9.3 K i n e t i c M o d e l s W h e r e N u c l e a t i o n a n d G r o w t h Are Combined When nucleation takes place throughout a reacting solid particle and it is of the same speed as the growth of these grains, a different kinetic mechanism must be used. The mechanism called nucleation kinetics has been developed to combine these two steps into a single step. An example of this mechanism is the carboreduction of boron oxide to boron carbide. This overall reaction is written to imply that it follows a liquid-solid reaction pathway: 7C(s) + 2B203(1)-* B4C(s) + 6CO(g) However, it proceeds by a two step process of (1) a solid-liquid reaction to form a gaseous suboxide, C(s) + B203(1)--~ B202(g) + CO(g) and (2) a gas-solid reaction, 5C(s) + 2B202(g)--~ B4C(s) + 4CO(g). This reaction mechanism is limited by both the nucleation and growth of B4C(s). As a result it follows "nucleation kinetics." An extensive explanation of this mechanism is treated by Avrami [19-21], Tompkins
162
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
[22], and Erofeyev [23] and contains complicated mathematical treatment that is beyond the scope of this book. However, the simplified results of these two rate determining steps is that the kinetics follow: m
ln(1 - X B) = -(kt) m.
(5.41)
This nucleation kinetic mechanism is based on the activation of reaction sites, followed by growth of the product nucleii (B4C, in this case) through chemical reaction. The global rate constant, k, describes either of these two rate determining steps for the reaction mechanism. The values of m corresponds to m
Product crystal geometry
Rate determining step
4 3 3 2 2 1
Polyhedra Polyhedra Platelet Platelet Needle Needle
Nucleus activation Isotropic growth Nucleus activation Crystal growth Nucleus activation Crystal growth
In the case the carbo-reduction of B203 to B 4 C , w e find that m = 3 [24] and k is 3.86 โข 106 s -1 exp(-301 kJ/mol/RgT) for the temperature range 1803 K to 1976 K and 2 โข 1020 s -1 exp(-820 kJ/mol/RgT) for the temperature range 1976 K to 2123 K. The B4C particles produced are platelets. These experimental results are typical of other experimental data [22].
5.10 F L U I D - S O L I D
REACTORS
This section draws heavily from the book Chemical Reactor Engineer-
ing by Levenspiel [1]. Various methods of contacting fluids with particulate solids are shown in Figure 5.13. These contacting methods include countercurrent, crosscurrent, and cocurrent plug flow as well as mixed solids flow-intermediate gas flow, and semi-batch operations. Consideration of the residence time distribution for each type of fluid-solid contact is necessary to understand its effect on the conversion. As a result of a given residence time distribution, E(t), the average conversion of B, XB, is given by oc
1 -XB =
-
f0
[1 -XB(t)]E(t)dt
(5.41)
whereXs(t) is the conversion function given in Tables 5.2 or 5.3, depending on the model applicable. The residence time distribution can take
5.10 F l u i d - S o l i d Reactors
163
Various contacting patterns in fluid-solid reactors: (a-c) countercurrent, crosscurrent, and cocurrent plug flow; (d) intermediate gas flow, mixed solid flow; (e) semi-batch operations. From Levenspiel [1], copyright 9 1972 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
F I G U R E 5.13
any form. However, two simplified residence time distributions are frequently used: back mixed flow, E(t)
-
e -t/o 0
where 0 is the m e a n residence time; and plug flow,
where 8 is a delta function centered at t = O.
(5.42)
164
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
Equation (5.41) assumes that the gas is of a uniform composition throughout the reactor at all times. If the gas composition changes with the time or position within the reactor, a different equation must be used. To account for the effect of particle size distribution in addition to the residence time distribution is difficult because different size particles can remain in the reactor for different periods of time. To account for these effects completely a population balance must be performed, where the conversion is an internal variable (see Chapter 3). This type of treatment is beyond the scope of this chapter. A simplified method of accounting for the effects of a particle size distribution, m(R), on the mean conversion, XB, is by 1 -Xs =
-
f0
[1
-Xs(R)]m(R)dr
(5.44)
where m(R) is the normalized population weight distribution. This equation assumes that all the particles of different size have the same residence time within the reactor. This is not always a good assumption because fine particles follow the gas stream lines much
100 ....
8 7
6 5 4
~
Gas dilffusion controls
3
fReaction controls _Product layer ,~diffusion controls
108
CD
24 1 7 64 4" 3 2 0.1 0.01
2
3
4 56780.1
2
3
4 5678
1.0
1-X B
FIGURE 5.14 M e a n c o n v e r s i o n v e r s u s m e a n r e s i d e n c e t i m e in m i x e d flow r e a c t o r s , single size solid.
165
5.10 Fluid-Solid Reactors
50
,,
,, .............
, . . . . . . .
,,
Sin~lle Stage ~~. ~ x = 10 ii
N ~Gas
film diffusion controls
~Reaction controls ~~>~-Ash layer diffusion controls
"---2_'.-......
i ,,l,,,, I "~'-'
\ "
controls-"
-,
~'~
Reaction "" ~.~ controls -~~ Two Stages (t'=2t i) " ~ ~ ~ m , ~ 1
0.01
.........
I
I
I ....
I
I
I
I
"~"
0.1
I
I "'
I
'
I
l
I
I
!
9
1.0
1--X B u
Comparison of holding times needed to obtain a given conversion for mixed flow and plug flow of single size solid. From Levenspiel [1], copyright 9 1972 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
F I G U R E 5.15
better than the large particles, which tend to settle. For single sized particles, the mean conversion for a mixed flow reactor is given in Figure 5.14. The mean residence time, 0, must be much larger than the maximum time for reaction, r, for the average conversion, XB, to be complete (i.e., XB = 1.0) for all of the rate determining steps. In a plug flow reactor, however, the mean residence time, 0, needs to be only slightly larger than the maximum time only for reaction, r, for complete reaction. A comparison of the time for a certain conversion in a mixed and a plug flow reactor is given in Figure 5.15. For a specific conversion XB, the mixed flow reactor time is always larger than the plug flow reaction time.
P r o b l e m 5.3. Conversion o f a Size M i x t u r e o f Ceramic Powders A batch of spherical ZnS particles is to be oxidized in air in a crucible placed in a tube furnace at 800~ The mixture of 30% 0.5/~m particles, 40% 1.0 ftm particles, and 30% 2.0/~m particles is spread thinly over the bottom of the crucible so that the particles will have good contact
166
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
with the air. Taking each of these size fractions separately, previous experiments have determined the time for complete conversion as 5, 10, and 20 min for the particles size fractions in increasing size order. Find the average conversion for the mixture if a residence time of 8 min is used. Equation (5.44) is applicable for finding a solution: or
1 --XB =
-
fo
[1 - X B ( R ) ] m ( R ) d R
= [1 - x B ( o . a ~ m ) ] * 3 0 %
+ [1 - X B ( 1 . 0
txm)]*40%
+ [1 - XB(2.0/zml]*30% Because for the three sizes of particles, RI'R2"R 3 --TI'T2"T 3
we see from Table 5.2 that chemical reaction controls the conversion time characteristic. Thus, t/~ = 1 - (1 - XB) 1/3
which can be rearranged to give 1 - X s = (1 - t / r ) 3
allowing the average conversion to be calculated as 1 -XB
= [1.0-
1.o]*3o% +
= o + o.oo32 +
1 -i-0
*4:0%+
1 -2-0
*30%
0.0648 = 0.068
yielding X B = 93.2%.
5.11
SOLID-SOLID
REACTIONS
This section draws heavily from the book I n t r o d u c t i o n to C e r a m i c s by Kingery et al. [3]. The reaction between two (or more) types of solid is frequently practiced to produce multicomponent ceramic powders. Several examples include NiO(s) + AleO3(s)--) NiO(s) + SreO3(s)--* MgO(s) + FeeO3(s)~ ZnO(s) + A1203(s)--) BaCO3(s) + SiO2(s)-*
NiAleO4(s) NiCreO4(s) MgFeeO4(s) ZnA1204(s) BaSiO3(s) + CO2(g)
5.11 Solid-Solid Reactions 1
โข 2
167
+ 2BaCO3(s) + 3CuO(s)--~ YBa2Cu3065(s) + CO2(g) 4B(s) + C(s)--* B4C(s) 7C(s) + 2 B203(1, g)--~ B4C(s) + 6CO(g) SiO2(s) + C(s)--* SiC(s) + CO2(g) WO2(s) + C(s) = WC(s) + CO2.
The first six reactions form mixed oxide ceramic powders. The last three reactions are carbothermal reductions to produce different metal carbides. The most famous is the Atcheson process for synthesis of SiC from SiO2 and carbon, where the carbon in the mixture of reactant powders is used as a resistive electrical conductor to heat the mixture to the reaction temperature. This reaction is performed industrially in a 10-20 m long bunker fixed with two end caps that contain the source and sink for the dc current. The reactant mixture is piled to a height of 2 m in the bunker and a current is applied. The temperature rises to the reaction temperatures, and some of the excess C reacts to CO, providing further heat. The 10-20 m bunker is covered with a blue flame for most of the reaction period. The resulting SiC is loaded into grinding mills to produce the ceramic powders and abrasives of desired size distributions. Carbothermic reduction can also be used in combination with other reactants as follows: 3SiO2(s) + 6C(s) + 2N2(g)--* Si3N4 + 6CO(g) Solid-solid reactions proceed by two different mechanisms. One mechanism is solid interdiffusion, where the two solid state reactants interdiffuse at the points of powder particle contact. This mechanism is applicable for the first six reactions given earlier and many others that form mixed oxide ceramic powders. The second mechanism is not truly a solid-solid reaction. It entails the vaporization of one of the reactants (by one of several mechanisms) and then reaction of this vapor with the other solid.
5.11.1 Vaporization of One Solid Reactant The carbothermic reduction of silica is believed to follow [25] a reaction mechanism given by SiO2(s) + C(g)--* SiO(g) + CO(g) SiO(g) + 2C(s)---> SiC + CO(g)
(5.45) (5.46)
Figure 5.16 [26] shows the free energy of these two reactions and that of the carbothermic reduction as a solid-solid reaction mechanism. At a temperature greater than 1900 K the solid-solid reaction becomes
168
Chapter 5
500 '-I
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
Si02*C -- SiO(g)+CO (g)
300
10~
7
-,OOl
.......
!
-30( SiO(g)+2C-- SiC+CO (g) -500
300
1500
1700
~go0
T(K) FIGURE 5.16 Free energy change for carbothermic reduction of SiO2 as a function of temperature and pressure. From Kvorkijan et al. [26].
spontaneous (i.e., AG < 0). By comparison the vaporization mechanism to produce silicon monoxide is spontaneous at -1550 K, and the reaction that produces SiC from the monoxide is spontaneous at all temperatures. Almost all carbothermic reactions that involve silica proceed via the monoxide because it is produced at low temperature and is highly reactive. As another example, we look at the carbothermic reduction of tungsten oxide, which follows a reaction mechanism C(s) + 1/2 O2(g)--~ CO(g) WO2(s) + 3 C O ( g ) ~ WC(s) + 2CO2(g).
(5.47) (5.48)
Figure 5.17 gives the phase diagram for the system tungsten oxidetungsten carbide. WC is formed above 630~ than 1.0
i.e., log
\Pco/<0
when the \ P c o ] is less
. This is equivalent to the case where
there is free carbon in the system (see the dashed line). Yet another example of the vaporization of a solid is shown in the following reaction mechanism [24]:
I ) ~ B202(g) + 2CO(g) 5C(s) + B202(g)-->B4C(g) + 4CO(g).
C(s) + B203(s ,
5.11 Solid-SolidReactions
....
850 I
750
....
169
650 Temp./oC
I
I
+10 0
I:1..o 0 O1 O
-10.9
1
750
650 Temp./~
I
|
............
WO 3
".
~
w2,,
o ~
o
_o -1
lw2c
vvc+c
wo2
2-L+ c ....
+c
=
!
0.9
1
!
1.1 10 "Y 3 / K
1
FIGURE 5.17 P h a s e diagrams of the system WO3-WO2-W2C-WC-Clog Pco2/Pco versus 1/T a s s u m i n g Pco = 1 atm. F r o m Lemaitre et al. [6].
These vaporization and solid-fluid reactions have kinetics which are limited by either the vaporization reactions or the subsequent solid-fluid reaction. The vaporization reaction was discussed in Section 5.3 in the paragraph on the thermal decomposition of minerals and follows the traditional solid-fluid reaction kinetics discussed in this chapter, where the bulk gas concentration in Tables 5.2 and 5.3 is replaced by the equilibrium gas concentration at the temperature of decomposition. The vaporization reaction is, however, often at equilibrium, giving a vapor concentration that may be small but is sufficient to keep pace with the solid-fluid reaction. Therefore solid-fluid reaction kinetics can be used to analyze solid-solid reaction when a vapor phase is formed from one of the reactants.
170
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
FIGURE 5.18 Extent of solid state particle reaction in a particle assembly.
5.11.2 S o l i d - S o l i d
lnterdiffusion
A mixture of ceramic powders that interdiffuse at the points of contact is illustrated in Figure 5.18. In the shaded regions, interdiffusion and reaction are taking place. As time progresses, the region ofinterdiffusion will increase. As an example, let us consider the diffusion couple between one oxide, AO, and another, B203, giving a mixed oxide product, AB204. Interdiffusion can take place with different ions limiting the speed of interdiffusion. Figure 5.19 gives several examples of the types of diffusion species: cations, anions (i.e., oxygen), and electrons. Depending on the relative rates of diffusion of these species, the reaction can take place at either the AO/AB204 or the B203/AB204 interface. When diffusion is slower than the rate of reaction, the thickness of the product layer follows a parabolic growth law like that observed in Figure 5.20 for NiA1204. The flux of a species i, Ji, is a result of the electrochemical potential gradient, d~i/dx.
d~i Ji = CiBi dx
(5.49)
where C~ is the concentration of species i; Bi is the ion mobility, = Di/ kBT; and ~i = ~i + ZiF&, where ft i is the chemical potential of species i of valence Z i given by kBTdCi
dt~ = ~
Ci
(5.50)
5.11 Solid-Solid Reactions
AO
AB2041
1 71
B203
A2+ _1
3
B2o,) B2o3
AO
1_ 2B3+1
0e-I
AO
AB204
B203
L.. 2B3+ ! A2+..._I 02 -] (2) Yl
2B3+ I i-~-~
302-
(3)
FIGURE 5.19 Representation of several mechanisms that may control the rate of AB2Ot (e.g., Spinel) formation. From Kingery et al. [3], copyright 9 1970 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
where F is Faraday's constant, k B is Boltzmann's constant, T is the absolute temperature, Z~ is the valence of species i, and (b is the electrical potential at the location of the flux to obtain electrical neutrality given by
Jo + Je'
= JMe"
(5.51)
For the case of oxidation of a metal shown in Figure 5.21 the net flux is given by
Jox = IJ01 + IJMel which is also the oxidation rate,
Jox.
(5.52)
1 72
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant .........
1500oC
20-
-140
15-
-122
P~
%O
r
tO L O
-.
O
"~: 10 -
-100
.9 r. l-v
.9 tI-
9 1400~
5-
0
~ r-
71
r
0
100
'" ' "'''"
200
Time (Hr) FIGURE 5.20 Thickness of NiA1204 formed in NiO-AI203 couples as a function of time heated in argon at 1400 and 1500~ From Pettit et al. [27]. Reprinted by permission of the American Ceramic Society.
Ambient atmosphere
Metal
Oxide
3M~
Pg,
0e
[ P(~z=e(+AG~
~~]o
J F I G U R E 5.21 Chemical potential gradients across an oxide layer on a metal. From ~ngery et al. [3], copyright 91970 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Repented by permission
of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
5.11 Solid-Solid Reactions
173
The general results can be expressed as Jox =
Crte'
]ZMe1F2 (to +
d ~{~1Tie tMe)
dx
(5.53) o't e, d/z o -iZol F e (to + tMe) - - ~ where (r is the electrical conductivity of the oxide and t i is the transference number (= (ri/(r) equal to the fraction of the total conductivity carried by species i. Assuming that t i and (r are average values for the layer and do not vary with composition, gives a result that is the parabolic rate law: dx K = -dt x
-
-
(5.54)
where K = ~-[e/IZMe I F 2 (to + tme)[A~(Lmel- Recalling that
ti(r =
CiZ~e2F 2 kBT Di
(5.55)
we can see t h a t the oxidation rate is controlled by atomic diffusivities as well as electrical conductivity of the solid AB204. Calculation of K requires knowledge of the diffusion coefficient for all ionic species, together with the chemical potential for each species as related to their position in the reaction product layer. The most rapidly moving ions (or ions plus electrons) arriving at the interface control the reaction rate. For the example of NiO-A1203, Pettit et al. [27] found the parabolic law explains the experiment data well as shown in Figure 5.20. Reconsidering a mixed assembly of spheres shown in Figure 5.22 reacting by a parabolic diffusion couple, the volume of unreacted material at time, t, is 4 V = ~ 7r(R - y)3. (5.56) The volume of unreacted material is also given by 4 V = ~ 7rR3(1 - XB)
(5.57)
where XB is the conversion (or volume fraction reacted). Combining the two preceding equations and solving for y we obtain y = r[1 - (1
-ZB)l/3].
Combining with equation (5.54), rewritten as follows,
dy2_2K dt
(5.58)
1 74
Chapter 5 Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
FIGURE 5.22 Schematic representation of reaction product layers forming on the surface of particles in a powder assembly. From Kingery et al. [3], copyright 9 1970 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Reprinted by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
and integrating, we find [ 1 - [1 -XB)I/3] 2 = ~-~ 2K t
(5.59)
where 2 K / R 2 is essentially a reaction rate constant that is characteristic of reaction conditions with K, given by equation (5.54). This relationship has been found to hold for many solid-state powder reactions, including silicates, titanates and ferrites. Figure 5.23 illustrates the applicability of this equation to the solid state powder reaction between SiO2 and BaCO3 giving BaSiO3 plus CO2 (gas). In Figure 5.23(a) the linear time dependence of [1 - (1 X B ) I / 3 ] 2 is plotted for several temperatures. The slopes equal to 2 K / R 2 are plotted as a function of R -2 in Figure 5.23(b). Figure 5.23(c) shows the Arrhenius expression, K = K ~ exp - ( R ~ )
(5.60)
that is expected from the dependence of K on the solid state diffusion coefficient. J a n d e r [28] found similar fits for the reactions CaCO3 + SiO2 --~ CaSiO3 + CO2(g)
"~RXNA TZ29S _-- _ 25 kcal/mole (5.61)
CaCO 3 + MoO 3 --~ CoMoO 4 + CO 2(g)
~'~ RXNA TZ29S --_ _ 15 kcal/mole. (5.62)
5.11 Solid-Solid Reactions
175
a 0.03 Xl~3 0"02"
~
870~_
o.olo
0
20
40
60
Time b
100 120
c
-2,100 t . . . . . . . . . . .
~
80
"~ ;Z
80
(min)
o
.j 0
/
1.2 ........
m"" 1.0
I i
, ..... 200 400 600 800 1 / R 2 ( 1 / m m 2)
o.. o0.2
0 0.8s
0.9o
0.95
1000/T (K) F I G U R E 5.23 Solidstate reaction between silica and BaCO3, showing(a) time dependence, (b) particle size dependence, and (c) temperature dependence of reaction. From Jander [28].
There are two important simplifications in this equation: 1. It is valid for small reaction thicknesses; 2. It assumes product and reactants have the same molar volume. When corrections are made for these two simplifications, Carter [29, 30] has shown the following equation to be applicable: 2K [1 + ( Z - 1)(XB)] 2/3 + ( Z - 1)(1 - - X B ) 2/3 = Z + (1 - Z ) - ~ s t (5.63) where Z is the ratio of equivalent volumes product to reactants. Figure 5.24 [31] is a demonstration of the validity of this equation for the reaction of ZnO + A1203--~ ZnA1204
(5.64)
for conditions from zero to complete conversion. This equation is also valid for the oxidation of metal powders (see previous Carter references [29, 30]). In comparing the K values observed for powder reactions with those calculated, difficulties often arise because of the dependence of the reaction rate on the structure of the product layer. In most cases, the product layer is formed incoherently, with m a n y fissures and defects
176
Chapter 5
1.55
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
19 m i c r o n s 25 m i c r o n s
-
.0.0 0.2 0.4 0.60
1.51 OO
x! v A
T
"O
1.47 -
-o.8o
1.43
-0.90
N X
T
0 r
e-
o
.u 0 r
N
.39
-0.95
-~
1.35
u.
-1.0
!
0
0:8
1:6 Time
2.4
3:2
3.6
(hr)
FIGURE 5.24 Reaction between ZnO and A1203 to form ZnA1204 at 1400~ in air (two spherical particle sizes). From Schmalzried [31].
t h a t result from the volume change upon reaction. The diffusion coefficient observed may well be a surface diffusion coefficient or a grain boundary diffusion coefficient instead of the diffusion coefficient for a single crystal or a dense polycrystalline body. When new phases are formed, there is a strong tendency for the initial lattice p a r a m e t e r to be a nonequilibrium value corresponding to a coherent interface with the reactant. The diffusion coefficients for such nonequilibrium lattices are normally larger t h a n for equilibrium lattices. As a result, the calculation of K from diffusion data for single crystals or dense polycrystalline bodies sets a lower limit for the actual diffusion coefficient operating in a solid state powder reaction. Reactors for solid-solid reactions are designed in the same way as that for the fluid-solid reactors (see Section 5.10) but with these reactions the mixing of the gas does not need to be considered.
5.12 S U M M A R Y This chapter has discussed fluid-solid and solid-solid reactions as a means to produce a ceramic powder of a particular chemical composition
5.12 Summary
1~
and crystal structure. First, the thermodynamics of these reactions was discussed especially the Gibbs free energy and its change with temperature. Complex reaction schemes can be evaluated as to the most spontaneous using the Gibbs free energy as a criterion. Once the most probable reaction was determined, the kinetics of the reactions were discussed. Fluid-solid reactions have several possible rate determining steps, including surface reaction and mass transfer and heat transfer in the boundary layer and in the product layer. The kinetics of each of the rate limiting steps was discussed for shrinking core and shrinking particle models. Solid-solid reactions take place by solid state diffusion, which may be limited by the diffusion of ions (metal or oxygen) or electrons. Kinetic expressions for the solid state diffusion in ceramic particles was discussed. Reactors for these reactions were also described.
Problems 1. At 25~ and I atm total pressure determine the equilibrium partial pressure of CO2 over CaCO3 particles. (Answer is 1.6 โข 10 .23 atm.) 2. Using the enthalpy of the CaCO3 decomposition reaction given in equation (5.4), determine the equilibrium partial pressure of CO2 over CaCO3 at 600~ and 1 atm total pressure. 3. Determine whether W will form an oxide or carbide in air at 900~ Assume that the Pco2 in air is 5 โข 10 .4 atm. 4. Does Cr form a oxide or a nitride in air at 700~ 5. Pure metal particles react with a gas of a given composition and at a given temperature to give a ceramic product. What can you say about the kinetics of the reaction if the rate of reaction per gram of solid is (a) proportional to the diameter of the particles, (b) proportional to the square of the particle diameter, (c) independent of the particle size. 6. A batch of spherical monodisperse silicon metal particles is treated in a uniform ammonia gas. The solid is converted to Si3N4 with the same particle morphology, according to the shrinking core model. Conversion is seven-eighths complete after 1 hr and totally complete after 2 hr. What is the rate determining step? 7. Spherical particles of ZnS of size 2.0 t~m are reacted in an 8% oxygen gas stream at 900~ A reaction takes place according to equation (5.10). Assuming that the reaction proceeds by a shrinking core model and that the boundary does not present an important rate resistance,
178
Chapter 5
Ceramic Powder Synthesis with Solid Phase Reactant
(a) Calculate the time needed for complete conversion of a particle and the relative resistance of product layer diffusion during this reaction. (b) Repeat the procedure for particle of size 0.5 ftm. Data: solid density 4.13 gm/cc, reaction rate constant, k r - 2 cm/ sec, gas diffusion in ZnO layer, D A e -- 0.08 cm2/sec.
References 1. Levenspiel, O., "Chemical Reactor Engineering." Wiley, New York, 1972. 2. Castellan, G. W., "Physical Chemistry." Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1969. 3. Kingery, W. D., Bowen, H. K., and Uhlman, D. R., "Introduction to Ceramics," 2nd ed. Wiley (Interscience), New York, 1970. 4. Richardson, F. D., and Jeffes, J. H. E., J. Iron Inst. 160, 261 (1948) 5. Darken, L. S., and Gurry, R. W., "Physical Chemistry of Metals." McGraw-Hill, New York, 1953. 6. Lemaitre, J., Vindick, L., and Delmon, B., J. Catal. 99, 415-427 (1986). 7. Diaz Guemes M. I., Gonzalez Carreno, T., Serna, C. J., and Palacios, J. M., J. Mater. Sci. 24, 1011-1014 (1989). 8. Bowen, P., Highfield, J. G., Mocellin, A., and Ring, T. A., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 73, 724-728 (1990). 9. Wen, C. Y., and Wang, S. C., Ind. Eng. Chem. 62, 30 (1970). 10. Wen, C. Y., Ind. Eng. Chem. 60, 34 (1968). 11. Kunii, D., and Levenspiel, O., "Fluidization Engineering." John Wiley, New York, 1969. 12. Ishida, M., and Wen, C. Y., Chem. Eng. Sci. 26, 1031 (1971). 13. Ishida, M., Wen, C. Y., and Shirai, T., Chem. Eng. Sci. 26, 1043 (1971). 14. Knudsen, M., "The Kinetic Theory of Gases." Methuen, London, 1934. 15. Shatterfield, C. N., and Frales, F., Aiche J. 5(1) 115 (1959). 16. Hyatt, E. P., Cutler, I. B., and Wadsworth, M. E., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 41, 79 (1950). 17. Holt, J. B., Cutler, I. B., and Wadsworth, M. E., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 45, 133 (1962). 18. Gordon, R. S., and Kingery, W. D., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 50, 8 (1967). 19. Avrami, M., J. Chem. Phys. 7, 1013-1112 (1939). 20. Avrami, M., J. Chem. Phys. 8, 212-224 (1941). 21. Avrami, M., J. Chem. Phys. 9, 177-184 (1941). 22. Tompkins, F. C., in "Treatise on Solid State Chemistry" (N. B. Hanny, ed.), pp. 193-232, Vol. 4. Plenum, New York, 1976. 23. Erofeyev, B. V., C. R. Acad. Sci. URSS 52, 511 (1946). 24. Weimer, A. W., Moore, W. G., Roach, R. P., Hitt, J. E., Dixit, R. S., and Pratsinis, S. E., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 75(9), 2509-2514 (1992). 25. Wei, G. C., Kennedy, C. R., and Harris, L. A., Bull. Am. Ceram. Soc. 63, 10541061 (1984). 26. Kvorkijan, V., Komac, M., and Kolar, D., in "Ceramic Powder Processing Science" (H. Hausner, G. L. Messing, and S.-I. Hirano, eds.). Dtsch. Keram. Ges., Koln, Germany, 1989. 27. Pettit F. S., Randklev, E. H., and Felten, E. J., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 49, 199 (1966). 28. Jander, Z., Anorg. Allg. Chem. 163, 1 (1927). 29. Carter, R. E., J. Chem. Phys. 34, 2010 (1961). 30. Carter, R. E., J. Chem. Phys. 35, 1137 (1961). 31. Schmalzried, H., "Solid State Reactions," p. 102. Academic Press, New York, 1974.
6
Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
6.1 O B J E C T I V E S In this chapter the production of ceramic powders from liquid phase precipitation is discussed. In most cases, ceramic powder precursors (i.e., sulfates, carbonates, oxalates, hydroxides, etc.) are produced by precipitation. These powders must be thermally decomposed to their oxides in a separate step that frequently maintains their precipitated particle morphology although some degree of particle sticking often occurs. This chapter focuses on the fundamental steps of nucleation, growth, and aggregation in precipitation. Control of the kinetics of each of these fundamental steps controls the particle morphology and size distribution during precipitation. The nucleation and growth subjects discussed in this chapter are the same as in gas phase precipitation, to be discussed in Chapter 7. The population balance is used to predict the particle size distribution for idealized batch and constant stirred tank precipitators. 179
180
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
6.2 I N T R O D U C T I O N Using liquid phase reactants, ceramic powders are produced by spray drying, spray roasting, or precipitation. Spray drying and roasting have an initial step of precipitation. They are treated in Chapter 8 since they also include drying and thermal decomposition. Ceramic powders produced by precipitation typically fall into the following categories: metal hydroxides, nitrites, sulfates, oxalates, imides, and so forth. These precursor powders must be thermally decomposed to give the desired ceramic powder as discussed in Chapter 5. One of the most important industrial examples of precipitated ceramic powders is that ofA1203 93H20(gibbsite) precipitated from a sodium aluminate solution that is thermally decomposed to give alumina. Another example is the precipitation of Mg(OH) 2 from a brine solution, which is again calcined to give "dead burnt" magnesia. The main reason precipitation is used to make ceramic powders is that it gives a pure solid product, rejecting to the supernatant most of the impurities. In addition, with precipitation the particle morphology and the particle size distribution can be controlled to some degree. Precipitation has the disadvantage that the powders must be separated from their supernatants and dried, as well as, frequently thermally decomposed to the desired ceramic material. This drying and calcination often leads to aggregates that are cemented together. Special precautions must be used to prevent aggregate formation during drying and calcination (e.g. calcination in very dry atmospheres). The precipitation of powders involves nucleation and growth from a supersaturated solution. There are several ways to cause a solution to become supersaturated to induce nucleation and growth, as illustrated in Figure 6.1. For systems in which the solubility is not a strong function of temperature, evaporation is used to cause supersaturation. For those in which solubility increases with temperature, cooling is used to supersaturate the solution. High pressures are also used to precipitate a particular crystal phase that may not be stable at ambient pressure (e.g., rutile TiO2 instead of Ti(OH)4). The use of high pressure precipitation is referred to as hydrothermal synthesis. Supersaturation can also be produced by adding another component in which the solute is insoluble. Although these methods can be used to generate ceramic powders, the most common method, reactive precipitation, occurs when a chemical reaction produces an insoluble species. Reaction-induced supersaturation is often very high, giving high nucleation rates. With the high number densities of nuclei produced, agglomeration is an important growth mechanism leading to spherical particles that are either polycrystalline or amorphous. The fundamentals discussed in this chapter are useful in understanding melt crystallization in addition
6.2 Introduction
181
~9
>~ .
m
o
Temperature,T FIGURE 6.1 Solubility curves for various types of crystallization systems: Curve A, isothermal solubility; curve B, positive temperature coefficient of solubility; curve C, negative temperature coefficient of solubility.
to precipitation from liquid solution. Melt crystallization is used to make large crystals by slow cooling of molten A1203, for example. When a substrate is transformed from one phase to another, the change in the molar Gibbs free energy, A(~, at constant pressure and temperature is given by AG = (t~2 - t~l)
(6.1)
where t~ is the chemical potential of phase I (solute) and phase 2 (solid). When h(~ < 0, the transition from 1 to 2 is a spontaneous process. When h(~ > 0, it is not thermodynamically possible, on a macroscopic scale. A necessary and sufficient condition for equilibrium is when AG = 0, given by the lines in Figure 6.1; above the lines, AG < 0, and below the lines AG > 0. A supersaturated solution can be called undercooled if dCeq/dT > 0 (curve B in Figure 6.1), or superheated if dCeq/dT < 0 (curve C in Figure 6.1). If T Ois the temperature where the solubility is equal to the actual concentration, then at a temperature T T
AG = - fo AS d T = A I ~ ( T - To)/T o
(6.2)
where AS is the molar entropy and ~ is the molar enthalpy change for the phase transformation. This equation is used for melt crystallization. The molar Gibbs free energy can also be expressed as
AG = - R g T ln(a/ao) = - R ~ T ln(S)
(6.3)
where Rg is the gas constant, T is the absolute temperature, a is the activity of the solute, and a0 is the activity of the pure solute in equilibrium with a macroscopic crystal. Assuming the activity coefficients are one, AG becomes equivalent to - R g T ln(S), where S is the
182
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
saturation ratio given by C S - Ceq
(6.4)
where C is the actual concentration in solution and Ceqis the solubility at the temperature and pressure of the system. For ionic crystal precipitation, the solubility is given by the solubility product as shown in the following example: A +2 + 2B- --, AB2(s) K~p = [A ยง 2]o[B - ]~
(6.5)
where [Aยง o and [B-] o are the ionic concentrations of A and B at equilibrium, respectively. The expression used for the saturation ratio, S, for this example becomes (6.6)
S = [A+2][B-]2/K~p
where [A +2] and [B-] are the actual ionic concentrations of A and B, respectively. In some complex cases, several salts can precipitate from the solution but only one will be the least soluble at the specific pH of the system. Such a complex equilibrium is observed in Figure 6.2,
-2
m t~ 0
o
3
o 0
..,.,I
i
4
5
6
7
8
9
pH
FIGURE 6.2 Influence of temperature on the solubility isotherms of hydroxyapatite, dicalcium phophate (CaHPO4, monetite) and calcite in the system Ca(OH)2H3PO4-KOH-HNO3-CO2-H20([Ca]./[P] = 1, Pco 2 = 10 -3.52 atm, free ionic strength). Taken from Vereecke and Lemaitre [1].
6.3 Nucleation Kinetics
183
where the solubilities [1] of different salts of calcium and phosphate are shown as a function of solution pH. The particle size distribution produced during precipitation is a result of the relative rates of reaction, nucleation, growth, and agglomeration, as well as the degree ofbackmixing in the precipitator. The kinetics of each of these steps will be discussed next.
6.3 N U C L E A T I O N
KINETICS
The material in this section draws heavily from an excellent book by Neilsen [2]. During precipitation new particles are born into the size distribution by nucleation processes. The nucleation rate, which appears as a boundary condition at size L = L* ~ 0 in the population balance, generally has a dominating influence on the particle size distribution. Nucleation is also the least understood of the various rate processes in precipitation. There are three main categories of nucleation: 1. P r i m a r y homogeneous, 2. P r i m a r y heterogeneous, 3. Secondary. Homogeneous nucleation occurs in the absence of a solid interface; heterogeneous nucleation occurs in the presence of a solid interface of a foreign seed; and secondary nucleation occurs in the presence of a solute particle interface. The mechanisms governing the various types of primary and secondary nucleation are different and result in different rate expressions. The relative importance of each type of nucleation varies with the precipitation conditions.
6.3.1 Homogeneous Nucleation In very small quantities of m a t t e r such as clusters of solute molecules, a large fraction of the molecules are at the surface in a state of higher potential energy t h a n the interior molecules (i.e., fewer and weaker bonds). This excess energy is not compensated by an excess of entropy and consequently the free energy for the surface molecules is greater t h a n the free energy for the interior molecules. In a macroscopic body, this excess free energy can be expressed by the surface free energy per unit area, T. In a cluster consisting of a small number (10-100) of molecules or ions, the definition of surface area and surface free energy is r a t h e r ambiguous. None the less, in the theory presented here, we will use the concepts of surface area and surface free energy for convenience. In addition, the surface free energy per unit area has been
184
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
m e a s u r e d for only a few solid materials. Because both the surface a r e a and the surface free energy are ill-defined for a cluster, it is justified to use very simple expressions for them. Classical theories [2-4] of p r i m a r y homogeneous nucleation a s s u m e t h a t in s u p e r s a t u r a t e d solutions solute molecules combine to produce clusters, or "embryos." The overall free energy per cluster, AG, of the aggregates is a result of two terms, the free energy due to the new surface and the free energy due to the formation of new solid:
AG = - ( v / ~ r ) R g T ln(S) + ~/a
(6.7)
where v( = fie r3) is the volume and a ( - [Jar2) is the a r e a of the aggregate, V'is the m o l a r volume of the precipitate, and ~/is the surface free energy per unit area. The a r e a and volume for a n y polyhedron can be used to give a generalized particle radius, r (= 3v/a), which is the exact definition of the r a d i u s of a sphere. This generalized particle radius can be used to calculate the total free energy: hG(r) = -(fivr3/~')RgT In(S) + 3/[Jar2
(6.8)
where flv is the volume conversion factor and ~a is the surface a r e a conversion factor. For a sphere, fie = 4rr/3 and fie = 4~r. W h e n the s u p e r s a t u r a t i o n , S < 1.0, hG(r) is always positive and cluster formation is nonspontaneous. W h e n the supersaturation, S > 1.0, AG(r) has a positive m a x i m u m at the critical size, r*, like t h a t shown in Figure 6.3 [4a]. Clusters larger t h a n the critical size will (_9 <]
-
/
>~ cLd D_ 03 .E) _s
cp o c-
.!
S~
=1 QX
~
~
A
G
_
( 0 ,
S
)
1
Criticol Nuclei Size, r
9
co ..c: (J
Nuclei Size, r
FIGURE 6.3 Classicalnucleation theory dependence of nuclei size on Gibbs free energy at a function of saturation ratio, S. AS > 0 ~ nonspontaneous formation, AG= 0 transient equilibrium, AG < 0 ~ spontaneous formation of a solids phase. Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
6.3 Nucleation Kinetics
r*
d
I w
r:t ~
.m
~D
185
In(S)
rr"
q) (9
z 0
r ,
:
I
2
:
I
3
,
I
.......
4
I
"
5
I
,
I
6
,
7
I
8
,
I
9
Saturation Rctio, S
FIGURE 6.4 Critical nuclei size (i.e., AG = AGmax) as a function of saturation ratio. For a given value of S, all r -> r* will grow and all r < r will dissolve. Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a], r*d = 2flayV/(3flvRgT). Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
decrease their free energy by further growth, giving "stable nuclei" that grow to form macroscopic particles. Below the critical size, clusters will decrease their free energy by dissolving. The critical size, r*, is obtained by setting d G ( r ) / d r = 0, giving r* = 2 f l a y V / ( 3 f l v R g T
In S).
(6.9)
Nielsen [2] has adopted the terminology that an embryo is subcritical and a nuclei is supercritical in size. This critical size corresonds to a value of the free energy at the maximum of AGma x = yfla r.2/3
(6.10)
Figure 6.4 shows the critical nuclei size as a function of saturation ratio S. The standard critical size nuclei is given by * = 2flayV/(3flvRgT) rstd
(6.11)
which occurs in the limit of S = e(= 2.718). This standard critical size has the following values for spherical nuclei using the molar volume of 100 cc/mole and a temperature of 300 K.
r*d(/k) y(J/m 2) 802 401 40 20
1.00 0.50 0.10 0.05
For a given value of S, all particles with r > r* will grow and all particles with r < r* will dissolve. This phenomenon, referred to as
186
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
r i p e n i n g [5], will be discussed in more detail later in this chapter. At high supersaturations, the critical size, r*, approaches the size of an individual molecule (see Figure 6.4), where the theory is invalid. At such large supersaturations, the rate of nucleation is limited by the collision of molecules by diffusion.
6.3.1.1 Embryo Concentrations Using these free energy concepts, the equilibrium number density of embryos of size r is given by Ne(r )
AV(r)]] =N -~-A exp [ - R--~
(6.12)
where NA is Advogadro's number. This embryo size distribution function is shown in Figure 6.5. The rate at which a nuclei of critical size assembled from an embryo and an additional atom is given by the equilibrium reaction X(atom) + X ( e * - a t o m ) ~ X ( r * ) which has the rate d N ( r * ) / d t = kiN(atom)N(r* - atom) - k _ l N ( r * ) t,Q
E (,3 O9 o
200
13..
150
-% z
I O0
5o o
_.J
-50 -I00 -150 o (D O >,, l_
E
-200 0
5
10
15
Nuclei Size,
20 r
25
50
(~,)
LU
FIGURE 6.5 Embryo size distribution function for various values of the saturation
ratio. Plot generated for a sphere of V = 100 cm3/mole, T = 300 K, and T = 0.005 J/m 2. Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
6.3 Nucleation Kinetics
187
where k~ is the second-order forward rate constant for the assembly of a critical nuclei from an embryo and one atom (or ion) and k_l is the unimolecular backward rate constant for the splitting off of one atom (or ion) from a nucleus. This rate can be approximated to give
dN(r*) _ k - k exp dt 1--~- 2 --~
RgTI"
(6 13)
"
The term in square brackets can be further simplified by considering this step to be the diffusion of molecules in solution:
[kl-~-k2]
= ~exp
[ - AG~I RgTI
(6.14)
where h is Planck's constant, k B is the Boltzmann's constant, and AG~ is the activation energy for diffusion. (The preceding equation is a weak point in the theory.) This gives a nucleation rate, J, of
j = dN(r*) kBT [ AG~I NA [ G(r*) 1 dt = - ~ exp - RgTI ~ exp RgT J"
(6.15)
The kinetic factors in this equation (i.e., kBT/h exp[-hG~/RgT]Na/~') have a value o f - 1 0 33 cm -3 sec -1 for liquids near their melting points and this is the maximum nucleation rate, Jmax. Alternatively, Einstein's equation [6] for the relation between the root mean square displacement ~, and the diffusion coefficient D,
;~2/2t = D
(6.16)
can be used if we identify t -1 with t-1=
kl~-k2
- d2
(6.17)
and ~, with the molecular diameter, d. This alternative expression gives a nucleation rate
j = dN(r* ) 2D [ G(r* )] dt = d5 exp ~ j.
(6.18)
The kinetic factor in this equation [i.e., 2D/d 5] has a value of ~10 3~ cm -3 sec -~ for liquids and is the maximum nucleation rate, Jma~. A generalized log-log plot of the nucleation rate described by J = Jmax exp(-hG(r*)/RgT) versus supersaturation ratio, S, can be generated as shown in Figure 6.6. The nucleation rate has been made dimensionless by dividing the nucleation rate at S --~ oo (or more precisely as (log S) -2 --. 0) as follows:
log(J/Jmax) = -A(log S) -2
(6.19)
188
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation X
o
E "~
0
g. ._J ~
-10
~_~
g g
-2O
Z
-3O
n-:
(1) ~if) c-
E k5
-4O 10
1O0
1000
: E4
Saturation Ratio, S
FIGURE 6.6 Generalized nucleation rate diagram that describes the homogeneous
nucleation rate as a function of the saturation ratio. The number of ions in a critical nucleus, n*, is given by equation (6.21) andA = 4f13aT31z2/{27f12v[kBTln(10)]3}.Experimental nucleation rates, O, are from a BaSO4 precipitation reaction. Redrawn, with permission from Nielsen [2]. where A = 4fi3a T3V2NA/[27f12v(RgT lnl0)3].
(6.20)
From a critical value of S = Sc, given by the x-intercept, the nucleation rate increases with a very steep slope and then asymptotically approaches its m a x i m u m value. The critical value of S depends on A and n*, the critical n u m b e r of atoms, molecules, or ions in the critical nucleus. This critical n u m b e r is obtained from the following equation, d ln(J) = n* = NAflvr*3/(~ ") d lnS
(6.21)
and is related to the critical radius, r*, as shown previously, giving an equation for the nucleation rate as follows: log(J/Jma~) = - n *
(log S ) / 2
(6.22)
This equation is used to give the straight lines in Figure 6.6. Using this type of general diagram Nielsen [2,7] has plotted the data obtained for the nucleation of BaSO4, as shown in Figure 6.6. He found t h a t when S > 1,000, the data followed the generalized plot with a value ofA = 220. The surface energy-, T, of barium sulfate was obtained from this value of A giving 126 erg/cm 2. The value of n* is 18 for this data.
6.3 N u c l e a t i o n K i n e t i c s
189
Below S = 1000, the nucleation rate was essentially constant at 105 cm -3 sec -1. Mullin and Gaska [8] have also verified this theory experimentally with the nucleation of K2SO4 from aqueous solution. The low S data corresponded to heterogeneous nucleation, which will be discussed later in this chapter. When conditions for homogeneous nucleation are first created, an induction time or delay time is required before the steady state nucleation rate, Jo, is established. The nucleation rate has the following transient behavior [9]: J(t) = Jo exp(-t/~)
(6.23)
where the time constant, ~, can be written as [3] -~ 6 d 2 n*/(D lnS).
(6.24)
As S increases, the value o f t decreases. In many liquid systems, the induction time, r, is only several t~sec. In viscous sucrose solution where the diffusion coefficient, D, is large [9], r may be 100 hr. To use the nucleation rate with population balance models, it is necessary to divide the nucleation rate J = dN(r*)/dt by the critical size of the nuclei, r*, giving d~o dt
= J/r* = dN(r*)/(r*dt)
(6.25)
r--*r*
where dVo/dt is the time derivative of the population density by number, Vo, and is measured in m -4 sec -~, which is different than the units of J in m -3 sec -1. Upon further substitution (dVo/dtl~r.) can be defined as = 2D/d 5 exp
d~o dt
- AV(r*)] RgT J/(3AG(r*)/Tfia)I/2"
(6.26)
r-->r*
This expression for the rate of change in the population density of nuclei will be used later in the population balance model as an initial condition. Katz has shown that classical nucleation theory predicts well the dependence of the supersaturation ratio [10] on the nucleation rate.
6.3.2 Heterogeneous Nucleation Most nucleation is in practice likely to be heterogeneous nucleation induced by solid impurite surfaces other than the solute. Nucleation on a foreign surface has a lower surface energy, which leads to a lower critical supersaturation. The rate of heterogeneous nucleation is the same form as that describing homogeneous nucleation in equation (6.13), except that the surface energy, % of the solid-liquid interface is replaced by the surface energy of the solid-seed interface. The only
190
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
difference between the homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation is that, once the heteronucleii are used up, there are no more of them, limiting the maximum heterogeneous nucleation rate J~a~ n to JJmax
(t - r ) -
J(t)dt/(t
(6.27)
- ~)
where N S is the number of foreign seed nuclei per unit volume, t is time required for heterogeneous nucleation on all of foreign nuclei, and r is the induction time. Thus the total nucleation rate J T is the sum of the homogeneous and the heterogeneous nucleation rates:
JT--Jhomo "+" J h e t e r o
(6.28)
A plot of these two nucleation rates and the total is given in Figure 6.7. Here we see the heterogeneous nucleation (A = 2) taking place at a lower saturation ratio, giving a maximum nucleation rate of 10 -6, which corresponds to all the foreign nuclei. At higher supersaturation, homogeneous nucleation (A = 200) takes place. This type of total nucleation picture was observed by Neilsen [2] for barium sulfate, as shown in Figure 6.8. Attempts to measure primary nucleation kinetics are fraught with difficulties, because the specific mechanisms that give the nucleation rate in any situation are extremely hard to define. Attempts to verify the rate equation and estimate surface energies are complicated by the fact that, before they can be detected, nuclei must grow to a reasonably large size compared to their embryo size. A number of authors [11-14] have attempted to incorporate growth into the analysis 3
CD
~.~
0
..
O~ ._1
I
-51
o
~
-5
t~
/ / ~ u r f o c e Nucleotion - 1021 ~/c
/
~ /
-
-
Heterogeneous
Nucleation
c)
-~ -lO
_,o
/
I /
.--/Ho~ogt~ou~_Nucleob'on -15
~ -2o! I I c(~ 1
E L5
/
10
, 100 Saturation Ratio, S
1oio0
-20 E4
c_ ~c_ L~
FIGURE 6.7 Generalized nucleation rate diagram describing the characteristic differences between homogeneous, heterogeneous, and surface nucleation for this particular example. Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
191
6.3 Nucleation Kinetics Ex O o
mE -) O
--) v C~ O _J
q~
HomogeneousNuclection Jrnox = 1030 # / c m 3 s e c
-10
A = 200
0 c 0 -9
0 q)
-20
HeterogeneousNucleation A=2
0
z
co o9 CD C 0 "-(O q~
E
. ~
121
o / ~
3
Jmox -- 105 #/crn sec 9
/~o 9
-
9
9
9
-30
--40
10
1O0
1000
1E4
Saturation Ratio, S
Generalized nucleation rate diagram fit to BaSO4 precipitation data. Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
F I G U R E 6.8
of nucleation kinetics, but their assumptions gave ambiguous results. Others have used the nucleation induction time as a means of theory verification [ 15]. Because of the form of the nucleation rate, primary nucleation, either homogeneous or heterogeneous, would be expected to dominate at high supersaturations. Such conditions are characteristic of precipitation processes where relatively insoluble materials are produced by mixing two or more reactant streams, which is a common method of making ceramic particles. This method has problems controlling the distribution of particle sizes produced. The addition of seed particles can be used to stimulate heterogeneous nucleation and thereby control nucleation. Without the seed, homogeneous nucleation will take place that is very sensitive to small variations in supersaturation and thus not easily controlled (see Figure 6.7). With the seed, heterogeneous nucleation takes place at a lower rate than homogeneous nucleation, allowing the control of nucleation and hence particle size distribution. Heterogeneous nucleation is also important in the coating of ceramic particles with another ceramic. Here seed, consisting of the core ceramic particle, is added to the precipitating solution. The supersaturation must be controlled so that only heterogeneous nucleation on the seed takes place. If the supersaturation is too high, homogeneous nucleation will take place and secondary particles of the coating materials will be
192
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
precipitated in addition to the coating itself. For this reason, coating operations require delicate control of the supersaturation.
6.3.3 Secondary Nucleation Secondary nucleation results from the presence of solute particles in solution. Recent reviews [16,17] have classified secondary nucleation into three categories: apparent, true, and contact. Apparent secondary nucleation refers to the small fragments washed from the surface of seeds when they are introduced into the crystallizer. True secondary nucleation occurs due simply to the presence of solute particles in solution. Contact secondary nucleation occurs when a growing particle contacts the walls of the container, the stirrer, the pump impeller, or other particles, producing new nuclei. A review of contact nucleation, frequently the most significant nucleation mechanism, is presented by Garside and Davey [18], who give empirical evidence that the rate of contact nucleation depends on stirrer rotation rate (RPM), particle mass density, MT, and saturation ratio. B 0 ~(S - 1)~ MJT (RPM) h.
(6.29)
Typical values of b lie between 0.5 and 2.5. These values are much lower than the typical ones for primary nucleation by either homogeneous or heterogeneous mechanisms, where b values between 6 and 12 are more common. The importance of M T is first order (i.e., j = 1), suggesting that contact of the crystals with the walls and impeller is the important phenomenon. However, some systems (i.e., K2SO4 [19] and KC1 [20]) have much lower values ofj - 0.4. Typical values of h range from 0 to 8 but most fall between 2 and 4, which are expected from semi-theoretical models [21]. Micro-attrition at a crystal surface was directly observed by Garside and Larson [22]. They found that large numbers of particles were produced in size ranges between 1 and 10 t~m and the size distribution and number density of crystal fragments produced depended on the saturation ratio. At large values of S, more and larger fragments (or nuclei) are produced. A rougher, more fragile crystal surface results from growth at high saturation ratio. It is known [23] that there is a large hydrodynamic shear force just before and another just after contact of a particle with a surface. The influence of these hydrodynamic shear forces on nucleation is unclear, but there is substantial evidence [24-27] that such forces initiate secondary nucleation. After a particle is nucleated, it can grow by various mechanisms. The kinetics of these growth mechanisms are important in determining the resultant particle structure and size distribution. In the next section, we will discuss the more common growth mechanisms.
6.4 Growth Kinetics
193
6.4 G R O W T H K I N E T I C S The material in this section draws from the excellent book by Elwell and Scheel [28]. The process of crystal growth can be described at several size levels: molecular, microscopic, and macroscopic. At the macroscopic level, mass transport limitations control crystal growth. In solution, heat transfer is relatively fast and seldom controls crystal growth. Only when the heat of crystallization is very great (either exothermic or endothermic) might heat transfer play a role. On the other hand, mass transport limitations are frequently important. The macroscopic concentration gradient influences the surface concentration profile, which can lead to the instabilities that cause "step bunching" and dendritic structures. At the microscopic level, step bunches are observed. These consist of hundreds of molecular layers on the surface that have grouped together because of the decreased diffusive flux to each layer in the bunch, compared to the region far away from the bunch. Such step bunches are frequently responsible for trapping solvent inside the crystal structure and other defects. At the molecular level, "growth units" diffuse to the crystal and attach themselves to the surface of the crystal, they diffuse over the surface, and eventually are incorporated into the structure of the crystal or return to the fluid. Of critical importance is the nature of the crystal-solution interface. Both atomically smooth and rough surfaces are shown in Figure 6.9. On the smooth surface, all the atoms represented by cube A are identical. This picture is far from reality. Inside a crystal, an atom will have six neighbors with a binding energy of three times the bond energy (3Ea_a) because each bond is shared by two atoms. For simplicity, only nearest neighbor interactions are considered. If a single new atom is added to the smooth surface, it can form a bond with only one nearest neighbor, so that its binding energy is only one-half the bond energy (1-2Za_a). Other atoms with extra bonds may add to this atom and stabilize a cluster; however, the small binding energy of the first atom is clearly a major barrier to the growth of the crystal. An atom added to a rough surface has several possible sites with different binding energies as follows: Site
Binding energy
A*
1E** a-a
B
Ea_ a
C
~Ea_ a
The site marked * is equivalent to the two-dimensional picture shown in Figure 6.9. The energy marked ** is the same as the addition to atomically smooth surface. Any atom incident on a rough surface has a greater sticking probabil-
194
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation A ........
B[-
a b FIGURE 6.9 Simplistic representation of the solid-solution interfaces in a growing crystal: (a) Atomically smooth surface and (b) rough crystal surface. Redrawn, with permission from Elwell and Scheel [28].
ity t h a n one incident on a smooth surface because this sticking probability will depend o n e x p ( ~ a _ a / k s T ) , exp(Ea_a/kBT), and so on. From this simple argument, it can be concluded that the growth rate on a rough surface will be larger t h a n on a smooth surface. Rough surfaces tend to remain rough during growth when adatoms attach at sites that create new corners, which are preferential sites for subsequent adatom additions. On a smooth surface, the rate limiting growth steps is an addition of an atom to the surface, because the subsequent addition to other adatoms at the newly created corners is relatively easy. This quickly completes the new layer, giving rise to a new smooth surface. In the following discussion, layered growth occurs on a smooth surface and continuous growth occurs on a rough surface. Tempkin [29] and Jackson [30] characterized the roughness of a crystal surface with a surface entropy factor, a, defined as
a = 2(Es_s + EW_W- Es_f)/ks T
(6.30)
where Ea_ a is the bond energy. Subscripts f and s correspond to fluid and solid, respectively. The free energy change due to solidification AG s is given in Figure 6.10 as a function of the fractional occupation of a single layer X and the surface entropy factor, a. When a < 2, the minimum hGs occurs at X = 0.5, yielding a rough surface. When a > 2, the minimum hGs occurs n e a r X = 0ยง or X = 1-, yielding a smooth surface. Keeping in mind t h a t rough surfaces produce continuous growth and smooth surfaces produce layer growth, estimated values of a can be used to determine the type of crystal growth that will take place, and for this reason, estimates for a are of interest. Bennema and van der Eerden [31] have given the following equation for estimation purposes:
6.4 Growth Kinetics
In
= #(AHs/RgT-
Xeq)
195 (6.31)
where AH s is the enthalpy of the solidification or precipitation, Xeq is the equilibrium mole fraction in solution, and ~: is a crystallographic factor (<1.0) equal to w for a cubic lattice. Bourne and Davey [32-35] have combined estimates of ~ with m e a s u r e m e n t s of growth rates. Generally, these estimates of ~ can be used to successfully predict the observed growth mechanism (layer for smooth surfaces with ~ > 2 and continuous for rough surfaces with ~ < 2). The state of these estimation techniques has been reviewed by Bennema and van der Eerden [31] and Davey [36,37] and Bourne [38]. The observation of flat, light reflecting facets on most crystals grown from solution suggests t h a t these are nearly atomically smooth surfaces. If a crystal is nucleated in a roughly spherical shape, the rough surfaces will grow rapidly and then tend to disappear, leaving flat crystal surfaces. The crystal habit will eventually be bounded by the relatively slow growing crystal faces. These faces are not perfectly flat on the atomic level (note the minima in Figure 6.10 for ~ > 2 do not occur exactly at X = 0 or X = 1), but growth is limited by the nucleation of new layers. Such surfaces are referred to as s i n g u l a r surfaces. The mechanisms and kinetics of surface nucleation will be discussed later in this chapter; however, it may be noted that surface nucleation sites will often be lattice defects, although growth by random two-dimensional surface nucleation on singular surfaces is also possible.
cl, = 1 0
v
v
o_ F<
o_ _u. ._J
o
o 0 el.--' 2 iJJ z w
0
'
1
FRACTION OF SURFACE OCCUPIED, x FIGURE 6.10 Dependenceof fraction of the surface occupied on the Gibbs free energy
for various degrees of surface roughness. Redrawn with the permission of Jackson [30].
196
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
6.4.1 Stages of Crystal Growth Elwell and Scheel [28] describe two types of surface sites where atoms (or growth units) can be integrated into the growing crystal structure: a step and a kink. As shown in Figure 6.10, a step is a location where two nearest neighbor bonds can be made by an adatom with a crystal. A kink site is a location where three nearest neighbor bonds can be made with the crystal. These definitions are necessary to consider the various stages of crystal growth. The process of crystal growth occurs in the following stages: i. Transport of solute from the bulk solution to the crystal surface, ii. Adsorption on the crystal surface, iii. Diffusion over the surface, iv. Attachment to a step, v. Diffusion along a step, vi. Integration into the crystal at a kink, vii. Diffusion of coordination shell of solvent molecules away from crystal surface, viii. Liberation of heat of crystallization and its transport away from crystal. The solute is often an ion that is solvated by a coordination shell of solvent atoms (or other ions). At the crystal surface, desolvation of one or two of the solvent molecules in the coordination shell must occur before the solute can (1) adsorb, (2) attach to a step, and (3) integrate into the crystal at a kink. The diffusion of solvent molecules (or other coordination ions) away from the crystal surface may limit the diffusion of solute toward the crystal surface and thus limit the growth rate. The solute does not become a part of the crystal until the enthalpy of crystallization has been liberated and desolvation is complete. Figure 6.11 schematically presents these processes along with the energetics of each step [35].
6.4.2 Diffusion Controlled Growth Fick's first and second laws describe the diffusion of solute to the surface and the diffusion of solvent and other coordination ions away from the surface of a growing crystal. J = - D VC d C / d t = D V2C
(6.32) (6.33)
In these equations, J is the flux perpendicular to VC and V2C is the Laplacian of the concentration of solute, solvent, or other coordination
6.4 Growth Kinetics
197
The energetics of crystal growth from solution: (a) Movement of the solvated solute molecule and (b) corresponding energy changes for each transformation. Redrawn, with permission from Elwell and Scheel [28].
FIGURE 6.11
ion. Those equations require numerical solutions when the boundary condition is a polyhedron. For a spherical symmetry, however, there is an analytical solution. For spherical coordinates, Fick's first and second laws become J = D dC/dr d C / d t = D [ d 2 C / d r 2 + (2/r) d C / d r ]
(6.34) (6.35)
The spatial boundary conditions are the following: C ( r = R , t) = Ceq C ( r = ~, t >- O) = Ca
(6.36)
corresponding to the concentration C~ far from the crystal and the concentration Ceq at the crystal surface r = R. The initial condition corresponds to the concentration being C~ everywhere, including the surface of the crystal at t = 0. C ( r = R , t = O ) = Ca
(6.37)
1~8
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
These equations have the following error function solution [39]" C -- C e q + (Coo -
Ceq)
{1 - (R/r) erf[(r - R)/(2Dt)I/2]}
(6.38)
When t --, ~ (i.e., steady state), C -
Ceq +(Coc
-
Ceq)[1 -
(R/r)].
(6.39)
In the case of slow crystal growth, it can be assumed that this steady state (in reality, a pseudo-steady state) is set up faster than the crystal grows and
dR/dt-vj-
(TD dC/drlR = ~rD(C~-
Ceq)/R = V D C e q ( S -
1)/R (6.40)
where the crystal radius R has the following time dependance R = [2 (zD(C~ -
Ceq)t]
1/2
-
[2 ~rDCeq(S -
1)t]
1/2
(6.41)
and V is the molar volume of precipitate. Neilsen [40] and Reiss and LaMer [41] solved the same problem with its moving boundary and pseudo-steady state assumption, giving R = [2 VD(C~ -
Ceq)t/q]
1/2
=
[2 T~rDCeq(S
--
1)t/q] 1/e
(6.42)
where q ( < l ) is a function of the volume fraction of precipitate, VCeq (S - 1). Values of q are given in Table 6.1. When VCeq(S - 1) is small, the pseudo-steady state approximation is good. This solution is only good for an isolated sphere. Spheres can be considered in isolation if l?Ceq(S - 1) < 0.001. When many other particles are growing in the
T A B L E 6.1 Full Transient Solution Adjustment Factor, q, in Equation (6.42) as a Function of Volume Precipitate for the Exact Solution to Equation (6.35) as Solved by Nielsen a ~r(C:r - Ceq)
q
I?(C= -- Ceq)
q
0.00001 0.00002 0.00005 0.0001 0.0002 0.0005 0.001 0.002 0.005 0.01 0.02
0.996 0.994 0.991 0.987 0.982 0.972 0.960 0.944 0.912 0.877 0.827
0.005 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00
0.730 0.626 0.485 0.382 0.300 0.232 0.172 0.120 0.073 0.034 0.000
a
Redrawn, with permission from A. E. Nielsen, Kinetics of
Precipitation. Pergamon, Oxford, 1964.
6.4 Growth Kinetics
199
neighborhood of this isolated sphere, the effective concentration is reduced, and this will decrease the growth rate. For that reason, these equations can be used only when the distance between neighboring particles is 10 times their diameter [42,43]. For a crystal moving in a supersaturated solution, the diffusion is enhanced by convective mass transport. The flux for convective mass transport can be written as J = Kc(C~
-
Ceq)
(6.43)
where Kc is the mass transfer coefficient given by K c = D / 6 , where 6 is the boundary layer thickness. This gives a growth rate of dR/dt = VD(C~-
Ceq)/~--
YDCeq(S
-
1)/6.
(6.44)
For a sphere, the mass transfer coefficient can be obtained from the Colburn analogy for the Nusselt number: NUAB = K c ( 2 R ) / D = 2.0 + 0.6 Re 1/2 Sc 1/3
(6.45)
where Re [= u(2R)/t~] is the Reynolds number calculated from the slip velocity, u, and Sc [= t~/(pD)] is the Schmidt number (/z = solution viscosity, p = solution density). For other shapes, the boundary layer thickness, 6, can be evaluated, using Carlson [44] analysis with a slip velocity Reynolds number: 6 = {0.463 Re 1/2 Scl/3}-1.
(6.46)
Carlson's theory predicts that 6 ~ u -~/2 so that d R / d t should be u 1/2. This is in reasonable agreement with experiments by Hixon and Knox [45] ( d R / d t ~ u ~ and Mullin and Garside [46] ( d R / d t ~ u ~ Equally useful is the Burton, Prim, and Slichter [47] [BPS] analysis of a crystal rotating at an angular velocity of co in solution giving a boundary layer thickness: 6 ~ 22/3 (~lp)l/~ D1/3co-1/2.
(6.47)
The BPS theory predicts the 6 a co-1/2 so that d R / d t should be a co1/2. At low co < 50 rain -1 Coulson and Richardson [48] and Landise, Linares, and Dearborn [49] found good agreement with the BPS theory. The effect of mixing on particle growth becomes very important when the average power transferred to a fluid is less t h a n that needed for elimination of concentration gradients in the precipitator. When pockets of local supersaturation develop within the reactor, different growth rates will be observed in these pockets. These pockets of local supersaturation can also be generated in systems where the particles are smaller t h a n the mean turbulent eddy size. Therefore, some of the small particles will grow in an effectively stagnant environment. The size at which convection plays a bigger role t h a n Brownian motion as a propelling
200
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
force for the particles can be estimated by considering the average slip velocity of the particles in a precipitator. This value can be estimated by either knowing the energy distribution due to mixing or the circulation time and path in the precipitator. When the crystals are smaller than ~ 10 t~m, the growth rate is typically controlled by diffusion. When the particle number density of these small particles is high, the interparticle distances are comparable to the boundary layer thickness and significantly higher growth rates are observed. Jaganathan and Wey [50] calculated growth in a "crowded environment" and showed higher growth rates for sparingly soluble species.
6.4.2.1 Two C o m p o n e n t Diffusion with Different Concentrations If two components are needed to complete the crystal structure [e.g. Na and C1] then each species has its own diffusive flux: (6.48)
Ji = D i ( C ~ - C i q ) / R .
For a given precipitation a A +~ + b B -~ <-> AaBb (s)
the following solubility product, Ksp, results (6.49)
gsp = [cA] a [CBq] b.
For the crystal A ~ (s) to be formed, the flux of A, J A , and the flux of B, J s , must be related to the crystal stoichiometry, giving J A / a = J s / b = D A ( C A - c A q ) / ( a R ) = D B ( C B - CBq)/(bR).
(6.50)
Here J = R, good for particles smaller than 5-10 tLm [130, 131]. Both CeA and Ces are related through the solubility product. For the case of a 1 : 1 [a :b] stoichiometry with similar diffusion coefficients, (6.51)
D = DA = DB
and the analytical solution is obtained by eliminating Ce~ and C seq yielding 82 1/2} C~)/4]
(6.52)
d R / d t = V J A = V D / R {(CA - C S ) / 2 -- [Ksp + (C A - CB)2/4] 1/2}
(6.53)
JA . J s
. D / R { ( . CA
.C S ) / 2 .
[gsp+(C A
which gives the following growth rate
When CA >> C s this reduces to dR/dt = VDCB/R
a result equivalent to one component diffusion limited growth.
(6.54)
201
6.4 Growth Kinetics
6.4.2.2 C h e m i c a l R e a c t i o n If a chemical reaction is used to generate the insoluble species, the rate of chemical reaction is another possible rate limiting step. To account for the chemical reaction rate, a growth effectiveness factor, ~, is defined as [3,4,51] Growth rate observed = Growth rate when interface is exposed to bulk solution
(6.55)
which is a function of the Damkohler number, D a , 9/ = (1
(6.56)
71Da) n
-
where
Da kr(C =
-
kr[Ceq(S--
Ceq) n-1
-
g c ................
1)]n-1 (6.57)
gc
Ceq
and is the equilibrium concentration, k r is the reaction rate constant, Kc is the mass transfer coefficient, and n is the order of the reaction to form the insoluble species. The effectiveness factor, ~/, varies from 1.0 to 0.0 as D e goes from 0 to = as shown in Figure 6.12 [52]. From this plot we can see the effectiveness factor, ~/, is low for large Damkohler number corresponding to large saturation ratio, S, where growth is limited by diffusion not chemical reaction.
,,Z 0 o o
LL (/1 (/1 ~)
1.00
/9 =
1.0
(Atomistic Growth)
0.80
c
(D > r r
0.60
4--
I,I
.c: 0 L
(.9 o O3
r
>.,
0.40 0.20
0.00 0.01
,
O. 10
1.00
,
10.00
,
100.00
Domkohler Number, Do Crystal growth effectiveness factor as defined by equation (6.56). Redrawn, with permission from Garside [52].
FIGURE 6.12
202
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
6.4.3 Surface Nucleation of Steps The material in this section follows a treatment taken from the excellent book by Nielsen [2]. The generation of a new step on a fiat crystal surface takes place by "two-dimensional" nucleation. In twodimensional nucleation theory [2], it is convenient to treat a cylindrical embryo of radius r (= 2 area/circumference) and height, d, corresponding to the height of one growth unit (i.e., atom or molecule). The total change in Gibbs free energy is given by
AG[otal = --([~A r2 d/V)RgT
ln(S) +
~/e
flL r
where Te is the edge energy per unit length surrounding the embryo. The first term of this equation corresponds to the change in free energy due to the volume of the embryo. The second term corresponds to the free energy due to the length of the edge surrounding the embryo. For a cylindrical embryo f l A - - 7/" and f l L - - 4.* When S > 1.0, AVtStalhas a maximum value
AG~ax = T2e f12 V/[2flA d RgTln(S)] = T2e f12L d2/[2flA ksTln(S)]
(6.58)
occurring at
r~ = "~e [~LV/[2[~A d RgT ln(S)] = ")/e[~L d2/[2flA ks T ln(S)]
(6.59)
The last term of the preceding two equations were obtained by setting = NA d 3, where NA is Avrogado's number. The number of molecules in a critical nucleus is
n* = flA r* 2~de = T2efi2 de/(4flA[ks T ln(S)]e).
(6.60)
The mole fraction of surface embryos, Xr, of size r is given by
Xr = exp[-hGS(r)/R~T].
(6.61)
From which the surface nucleation rate, Js, with units of embryo cm -e sec -1 is given by
Js = D/d4 exp[-AGSax/Rg T]
(6.62)
w h e r e D / d 4 = ( k s T / h ) e x p [ - A G $ / R g T ] as before. Here, AG$ is the activation energy for diffusion in the liquid. A typical value of D / d 4 is 1021 cm -2 sec -1 (i.e., D = 10 -5 cm2/sec and d = 3 x 10 -s cm). Figure 6.6 can also be used for surface nucleation as a function of supersaturation. Because the values of hG~ax are lower than hGmax for homogeneous nucleation, supersaturations lower than the critical supersaturations for homogeneous nucleation will give reasonably high * For a square embyo of edge length, l, and of height, a, the effective radius r = 1/2, ~A = 1, i l L = 4 .
6.4 Growth Kinetics
203
values of the surface nucleation rate. Considering homogeneous, heterogeneous, and surface nucleation at the same time, as shown in Figure 6.7, we have a critical value of the supersaturation ratio, S, for each. These critical supersaturations ratios are arranged in decreasing order, as follows: Sc,homo > Sc,hetero > Sc,surfac e > 1. This order is indicative of the relative magnitudes of the nucleation activation energies that control the different nucleation mechanisms.
6.4.4 Two-Dimensional Growth of Surface Nuclei The growth of a surface nucleus is achieved by either surface or bulk diffusion to the step or kink site at the edge of the growing nucleus. For the liquid phase, bulk diffusion is more important [3], giving a surface growth rate, drs/dt = d 2 D ( S - 1) NACeq. (6.63) This 2-D growth rate must be compared to the surface nucleation rate Js. To make this comparison, the time between two nucleation events, (JsA) -1, on a surface of area, A, is compared to the time necessary to grow a 2-D layer over the whole surface [L/(dr/dt)], where L is the maximum length from the nuclei to the edge of the crystal. When (JsA) -1 > [L/(drs/dt)], each layer, on average, is the result of one nuclei site (Figure 6.13). This gives a macroscopic crystal growth rate for "mononuclear" growth of (dR/dt)MN = flA R2 Dd-3 e x p ( - hGSax/Rg T]
(6.64)
where flA is a crystal shape factor given by area/R 2. When (JsA) -1 > [L/(drs/dt)] , surface nucleation is so fast that each layer is a result of the intergrowth of numerous surface nuclei (Figure 6.13(b)). This gives a macroscopic crystal growth rate for "polynuclear" growth of d [NACeq(S - 1)]2/3 exp[-hG~ax/kBT]. [dR/dt]pN = D --~
(6.65)
When the two mechanisms are equally important (JsA) -~ = 0.6[L/drs/dt].
(6.66)
This corresponds to the crossover point between mononuclear and polynuclear layer growth. At this crossover point, the crystal growth rate is given by d R / d t = 0.2VD Ceq(S - 1)/R (6.67) which is 0.2 times the diffusion controlled growth rate. This indicates that when the growth rate is 20% of the diffusion controlled growth
204
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
R
b FIGURE 6.13 Two-dimensional growth of surface nuclei by (a) mononuclear growth and (b) polynuclear growth models. Redrawn, with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a].
rate, mononuclear layer growth rate dominates; and between this value and a growth rate equivalent to diffusion controlled growth, polynuclear layer growth dominates.
6.4.5 S c r e w D i s l o c a t i o n G r o w t h At supersaturations less than the critical supersaturation ratio for surface nucleation, Sc, surface~ 1.5, layer growth has been experimentally observed [35]. These new layers are produced by a dislocation that is a continuous source of step and kink sites. The presence of a step associated with an emerging line dislocation at a surface removes the need for surface nucleation. Figure 6.14 shows a crystal face with such a dislocation emerging at point B. Molecules are quickly integrated into the crystal at this mononuclear step. At all points on the line AB, the step moves such that the angular velocity decreases with the distance from point B giving a "screw" or spiral growth pattern to the surface, illustrated in Figure 6.14. The presence of growth spirals has been established on a large variety of crystals grown from vapor [53], from aqueous solution [54], and from melt [35]. The presence of growth spirals gives evidence for Frank's screw dislocation concept [55]; however, the height of the step is typically 50-150 rather than a mononuclear layer as envisaged by Frank. Burton, Cabrera, and Frank [56] and Bennema and Gilmer [57] have developed a theory to predict the crystal growth rate for screw dislocations. The growth rate will depend on the shape of the growth spiral. For an Archimedian spiral, shown in Figure 6.14 [58], the distance between the steps of the spiral Y0 is Y0 = 47rr*
(6.68)
6.4 Growth Kinetics
205
A @
I
\
(a)
Archimedian growth spiral: (top) Schematic presentation of Archimedian growth. Redrawn, with permission from Burton et al. [56]. (bottom) Spiral growth on rare earth crystal. Printed, with permission from Tolkdorf and Welz [58].
FIGURE 6.14
206
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
Jv
Z
Jv
v
FIGURE 6.15 Simple view of the solute flux to a step site. Redrawn, with permission from Elwell and Scheel [28].
where r* = flL~ed2/[2flAks T ln(S)] is the critical radius for the surface nucleation when the supersaturation ratio in solution is S. A more exact t r e a t m e n t [51,59] gives Y0 = 19 r* =
19flL~/ed2 2flAksT ln(S)
(6.69)
which will be used in subsequent development. The base angle, 0, of the growth cone formed by the spiral is given by
0 = tan-l(d/yo).
(6.70)
With each t u r n of the spiral, a new layer of thickness, d, is deposited. The rate of deposition is a result of the flux due to volume diffusion, Jv, and surface diffusion, Js, to the step where integration into the crystal takes place. For simplicity, consider that the curvature of the spiral can be neglected and the rate of movement of the spiral is slow compared to surface diffusion. With these assumptions, the following simple view of the surface can be given as shown in Figure 6.15. At steady state, the two fluxes must balance, giving
djs(y)/dy - Jv = 0.
(6.71)
The surface flux, js, with units of moles cm -1 sec -~ can be expressed in terms of a surface diffusion coefficient, Ds, and a surface concentration, ns"
Js = - D s dns/dy = -Dsnse d(rsldy
(6.72)
where (r~ is the local surface supersaturation ratio. The volumetric flux, Jr, is expressed in terms of a volume diffusion coefficient, De, and a
6.4 Growth Kinetics
207
concentration at the surface Cs = nse (rs/d and that in the bulk solution C = n s e S / d (given in terms of the surface concentration of a hypothetical crystal, nse ) Dvnse[S - O's]
Jv = -
d6
= -
Dv[C- Cs] 6
(6.73)
where d is the thickness of a layer, 6 is the boundary layer thickness, and S is the supersaturation ratio in solution. Substituting these two fluxes into the flux balance equation, we have the following differential equation. y2s d2(rs
+ crs = S
(6.74)
where Ys = [Dsd6/Dv] ~/2 is the mean distance traveled by the solute molecules on the surface, which is much smaller than Yo, the average distance between steps. The boundary conditions for this equation are S-
(rs = fiS crs = S
at y = Yo a t y = 0.
(6.75)
This equation has the following solution: cosh (Y/Ys) S - (rs(y)= fiS cosh (Yo/Ys)
(6.76)
where fl = 1 - Crs/S at the step (i.e., y = Yo). This equation is valid only in the regime where the distance between each kink site is much smaller than the distance between the steps (i.e., x o < Ys) as shown in Figure 6.15. Ifxo > Ys, it is necessary to introduce an extra factor into this equation to account for the nonplanar growth fields. The flux of molecules to the step may now be written as d(rs ] D s n s e f i S tanh(yo/Ys) ! - ~j ys yo
jS[y~ - - D s n s e ~
(6.77)
The crystal growth rate, d R / d t , is calculated from the flux of steps multiplied by their height, d: dR/dt =
Jstepd.
(6.78)
The step flux step, Jstep, is given by
JSbo Jstep -- p d y 0
(6.79)
where p is the crystal density. Making these substitutions, the crystal
208
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
growth rate is given by
dR/dt = DsnsefiS tanh( yo/Ys) yoYspd
(6.80)
Dsnsefl(~l) t a n h ( ~ ) y2p where $1 = S Yo/Ys = 9.5Ted2/ksTys Due to the complications associated with parameter determination, the first term in this equation is usually reduced to an experimentally determined constant. This theory predicts quadratic, dR/dt ~ S 2, behavior when S is less than the critical value (i.e., S < $1) and linear, dR/dt ~ S, behavior when S is greater than the critical value (i.e.,
S>S~). If a number of screw dislocations emerge at the same line dislocation, emerging at the crystal surface, a more complex spacial pattern will be produced. To account for the cooperative effect of multiple spirals, a factor ~ is introduced, giving the crystal growth rate as dR~dr
Ds nse [3~ S 2 Y~ O
$1 tanh
This factor ~: is always less than 1.0 because multiple growth steps close together limit the diffusion rate to each step. In fact, the step height observed experimentally [35] is between 50/~ and 150/~, which corresponds to 10 to 50 steps bunched together. When a two-dimensional diffusion field for the volume diffusion equation is solved [60], the concentration profile associated with each step is cylindrical, as shown in Figure 6.16 [61]. When these diffusion fields overlap significantly, the steps in the middle have a reduced flux and grow more slowly, allowing subsequent steps to catch up, building a step bunch. This step bunch then has its own dynamics and leads to imperfections (vacancies, defects, and occlusions) in the crystal structure.
6.4.6 Summary of Growth Rates All of these crystal growth rates are summarized in Table 6.2. The growth mechanism presented in this table occur in the following order as supersaturation increases. Screw Dislocation: Monosurface nucleation : Polysurface nucleation: Bulk Diffusion. Chemical reaction and heat transfer yield growth mechanisms that are slower than bulk diffusion. The supersaturation driving force, S - 1, given in Table 6.2, can be replaced by S - S(R*) when the
6.4 Growth Kinetics
2{}9
F I G U R E 6.16 Cylindrical solute concentration profile around each kink or step site. Redrawn, with permission from Chernov [61].
particles are small. Here S ( R * ) = exp 3 R * fiv
(6.82)
comes from the Kelvin equation and describes the saturation ratio at which particles of size R* will dissolve. When S - S ( R * ) is positive, particles will precipitate from solution; when S - S ( R * ) is negative, particles smaller than size R will dissolve and particles larger than
TABLE 6.2
Summary of Crystal Growth Rates: dR~dr = K*f(S)*g(R)
Growth mechanism
Diffusion b u l k Monosurface nucleation Polysurface nucleation Screw dislocation Heat conduction Chemical reaction
C ~rDCeq flADd -3 (Dd/3) (NACeq)~3 Dsnsefl/(y2p)
~rkg RgT2/AHf ~VDCeq
f(S)
g(R)
Ref
S - 1 exp[hG,/kBT]w
1/R R2
(S - 1)w3 exp[hG*/ksT] w
1
b
1 1/R 1/R
c
$2/$1 tanh(S1/S) w167 In S w167167 S - 1
a
b
Note. ~r is the molar volume, NAy is Advogadro's number, Ceq is the equilibrium concentration, D is the diffusion coefficient, sub-s surface, L~-/f is the heat of fusion, V is the Damkohler number, k H is the thermal conductivity, flA is the area shape factor for surface nucleii, Yo is the distance between steps, nse is the equilibrium surface concentration, fl = 1 - (rs/S is one minus the maximum surface supersaturation divided by the solution supersaturation, and p is the density. wh V * = fi2~2d2/(4flAksT In S) w167 $1 = (yo/Ys)S w167167 In S = f T AHw/(RT 2) d T a Volmer, M. M., "Kinetik der Phasenbildung," p. 209, Steinkopff, Dresden, Leipzig, 1939. b Nielsen, A. E., "Kinetics of Precipitation." Pergamon, Oxford, 1964. c Elwell, D., and Scheel, H. J., "Crystal Growth from High-Temperature Solution." Academic Press, London, 1975.
210
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
size R* will grow. This dissolution of fines and reprecipitation on larger particles, referred to as Ostwald ripening, occurs in many batch precipitation systems because the supersaturation ratio, S, decreases with time as the batch precipitation proceeds. Initially, at high supersaturation, nucleation produces large numbers of fine particles. This decreases the supersaturation, preventing further nucleation and leading to slow growth, which further decreases the supersaturation ratio. When the saturation ratio falls below the critical value, S(R*), for the fine particles previously precipitated, they will dissolve, holding the supersaturation ratio constant. At this constant supersaturation ratio, only particles larger than R* will grow or ripen at the expense of all smaller particles present in the suspension.
6.5 C R Y S T A L
SHAPE
The material in this section draws from similar material in the excellent book by Ewell and Scheel [28]. The shape of a crystal (i.e., crystal habit) can be controlled by either thermodynamics or kinetics. Only for crystals grown under very, very low supersaturation ratios is a crystal habit established by thermodynamic considerations. These crystals tend to be of mineralological origin. For most other crystal growth conditions, the kinetics of the slowest growing crystal faces give rise to a crystal shape.
6.5.1 Equilibrium Shape Gibbs [62] gave a thermodynamic description of the equilibrium shape of a crystal. The total free energy of a crystal is the sum of free energies associated with its volume, surfaces, edges, and corners. Gibbs shows that the edge and corners have an effect only when the crystal is small and the surface free energy decreases in proportion to the crystal size. For crystals of the same volume, the surface free energy (~ Ti * Ai) will be a minimum for the equilibrium shape, where Ti is the specific surface energy for face i with areaAi. Wulff[63] established that, for a crystal of a fixed weight, one shape has the lowest free energy; where the equilibrium shape is determined by the ratio of h~, the perpendicular distances to a face, to Ti, the specific surface energy of that face, as shown in Figure 6.17. This theorem corresponds to the formula
h_A= h2 T1
T2
hi = --.
(6.83)
Ti
When an equilibrium-shaped crystal grows, the growth rate of each face is proportional to its surface energy. High surface-energy surfaces have the smallest area because of their high growth energies. They are
6.5 Crystal Shape
211
/ hi
FIGURE 6.17 Equilibrium crystal shape as described by Wulff's theorem; in this case,
3'1 < 3"2.Redrawn with permission from Neilsen [2].
also rougher, which leads to higher growth rates. Wulff's theorem has been confirmed by careful experiments by V a l e n t a n [64] for small crystals ~ 1 0 ftm. In Figure 6.18, the flat F faces, stepped S faces, and kinked K faces are shown for a cubic crystal system. The rougher S and K faces grow very quickly and are rarely, if ever, observed. The crystal habit is
F FIGURE 6.18 Hypotheticalthree-dimensional crystal presenting the three main types
of possible faces: flat (F), step (S), kink (K) faces. Redrawn, with permission from Elwell and Scheel [28].
212
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
dominated by the slow growing F faces. From a knowledge of the crystal structure, it is possible to predict the slow growing F faces and therefore the final crystal morphology. Gibbs notes that for macroscopic crystals, the free energy associated with the volume of the crystal will be larger than changes in free energy, due to departures from its equilibrium shape. For these crystals, their shape will depend on kinetic factors, which are affected by crystal defects, surface roughing, and impurities in the solvent.
6.5.2 Kinetic S h a p e The rate determining step for crystal growth of the F faces of a crystal determines its kinetic shape. The S and K faces will almost always grow faster than the F faces. The only exception to this rule is when an impurity is adsorbed on a S or K face, drastically reducing its growth rate to that below an F face. Growth rates of different F faces often exhibit different dependences on the supersaturation ratio. A power law approximation for the growth rate, dR/dtli, of each face has been suggested by many authors [65-68]. This approximation can be expressed as
dR/dtli = ki S mi
(6.84)
which is written in terms of a rate constant ki and a power mi that depend on the growth mechanism and the growth conditions. The relative growth rates for two faces denoted 1 and 2 are
dR/dtll dR/dt]2
kl S ml k 2S m2
(6.85)
If, for example, these growth rates have the form shown in Figure 6.19, face 2 will be the slowest growing and dominate the crystal structure at low supersaturation and face 1 will dominate the crystal structure at high supersaturations. This behavior has been seen in many systems [69]. In one example, potassium iodide changes crystal morphology when precipitated from aqueous solution at a supersaturation ratio of 1.12 [70]. Frequently, during batch precipitation, the supersaturation ratio decreases as crystallization proceeds. This can lead to a change in crystal habit with time. Because the parameter ki depends on temperature, crystal habit will normally change when the growth temperature changes drastically. Crystal defects (dislocations, twins, and inclusions) are also responsible for morphological changes. The flow of solution around a crystal also influences its shape as is discussed in the next section. But the most important factor that can be used to change crystal habit is the addition of impurities to the precipitating system.
6.5 Crystal Shape
213
FACE 2
10 n," qD t~ IZ J::
FACE 1
O L
Saturation Ratio, S
FIGURE 6.19 Comparison of hypothetical growth rates, G1 and G2, for two F faces as a function of the saturation ratio, S. Redrawn, with permission from Elwell and Scheel [28].
6.5.2.1 D i f f u s i o n S h a p e A two-dimensional "square crystal" is shown in Figure 6.20. To the left are drawn curves with the same concentration in solution surrounding the crystal. To the right is drawn the shape of the crystal after different times. The growth rate is ~60% higher at the corner than at
~ C
4-
t~
C1
FIGURE 6.20 Diffusion controled growth of a square crystal. The left-hand side shows a hypothetical concentration gradient around the crystal. The right-hand side shows the growing crystal with time. Redrawn, with permission from Nielsen [2].
214
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
the middle of the face. From this figure we can conclude that the corner of a crystal will tend to grow faster than the center of the faces when diffusion controls the growth rate. In the extreme, this leads to dendrite growth.
6.5.2.2 Surface Nucleation Shape When surface nucleation is so slow that each layer on an F face originated from a single surface nucleus, the shape of the crystal is given by the nucleation rate on the different F faces; those with the lowest nucleation rate are the largest surfaces. At higher supersaturations, several surface nuclei grow together straightening the surface. Since surface nucleation is highly dependent on surface concentration, above a critical supersaturation ratio, diffusion in the bulk liquid will give a nonuniform surface concentration, and the faces will no longer be planar and smooth.
6.5.2.3 Growth Spiral Shape The surface of a screw dislocation will convert an F face to the shape of a pyramid or a cone. The angle, 0, of the cone can be calculated by [51] 0 = tan-l(d/yo)
= tan-l(ks T I n S / ( 1 9 T e d ) ) .
(6.86)
This equation is not accurate at high supersaturation because several spirals operate at once, leading to "step bunching." Non-Archimedian growth spirals occur due to (1) a pair of dislocations of either like or opposite sign, (2) a group of dislocations lying along a line, or (3) "wobbling" at the center of the spiral, giving macroscopic spirals.
6.5.3 Aggregate Shape Particles can aggregate by either Brownian or shear induced aggregation. With Brownian aggregation, diffusion of particles by Brownian motion causes particle collisions. With shear induced aggregation, fluid movement causes particle collisions. The shape of aggregates has been studied by computer modeling in two ways: aggregation particle by particle [71-73] and aggregation cluster by cluster [74,75]. In these models, new particles are added to a growing cluster with different fractal trajectories (i.e., reaction limited with fractal dimension of the trajectory, D t = 0 ; ballistic with D t -- 1 , and diffusion limited with D t - 2 ) . The resulting aggregate shapes are fractal with fractal dimensions given in Table 6.3. When diffusion is responsible for aggregation, the fractal dimensions vary from 2.5 for aggregation particle by particle to 1.8 for aggregation cluster by cluster. Figure 6.21 is a two-dimensional example of a computer generated aggregate grown under conditions of diffusion limited aggregation particle by particle. It has a fractal dimension in 2-D of 1.71. Cluster by cluster aggregates are less dense
215
6.5 Crystal Shape
TABLE 6.3
Fractal Dimension, Df, from Different Aggregation Modelsa
Space dimension
Reaction limited, D t = 0 2 3 Ballistic, D t = 1.0 2 3 Diffusion limited, D t = 2.0 2 3
Particle-cluster
Polydisperse cluster-cluster
2.00 3.00
1.61 2.10
2.00 3.00
1.55 1.95
1.71 2.50
1.45 1.80
a Data taken from Meakin, P., in R a n d o m Fluctuations and Pattern Growth (H. E. Stanley and N. Ostronsky, eds.), pp. 174-191. Kluwer Academic Publishers, London, 1988.
on a v e r a g e t h a n t h a t s h o w n in F i g u r e 6.21. D u e to s h e a r forces, w e a k l y b o n d e d a g g r e g a t e s c a n r e o r g a n i z e to m o r e c o m p a c t s h a p e s (i.e., h i g h e r f r a c t a l d i m e n s i o n ) . M e a k i n [76] h a s c a l c u l a t e d t h e i n c r e a s e in f r a c t a l d i m e n s i o n d u e to b e n d i n g , f o l d i n g a n d t w i s t i n g of c l u s t e r - c l u s t e r a g g r e g a t e s as s h o w n in T a b l e 6.4.
Computer generated aggregate assuming particle-particle aggregation. Fractal dimension of 1.5 in two dimensions made to simulate a fractal dimension of 2.5 in three dimensions. Printed, with permission from Sutherland [72].
F I G U R E 6.21
216
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
T A B L E 6.4 Effective Fractal Dimension Obtained from Reorganization of 3-D Cluster-Cluster Aggregatesa
Trajectory
Original
Bending
+ Folding
+ Twisting
Reaction limited, D t - - 0 D t -- 1 Diffusion limited, D t = 2
2.09 1.95 1.80
2.18 3.13 2.09
2.24 2.18 2.17
2.25 2.19 2.18
Ballistic,
a Data taken from Meakin, P., in Random Fluctuations and Pattern Growth (H. E. Stanley and N. Ostronsky, eds.), pp. 174-191. Kluwer Academic Publishers, London, 1988.
6.5.4 Crystal Habit Modification by Impurities All of these changes in crystal habit caused by kinetic factors are drastically effected by the presence of impurities that adsorb specifically to one or another face of a growing crystal. The first example of crystal habit modification was described in 1783 by Rome de L'Isle [77], in which urine was added to a saturated solution of NaC1 changing the crystal habit from cubes to octahedra. A similar discovery was made by Leblanc [78] in 1788 when alum cubes were changed to octahedra by the addition of urine. Buckley [65] studied the effect of organic impurities on the growth of inorganic crystals from aqueous solution, and in Mullin's book [66] he discusses the industrial importance of this practice. Because crystal growth is a surface phenomena, it is not surprising that impurities that concentrate at crystal faces will affect the growth rate of those faces and hence the crystal shape. With some surface active impurities, small traces, about 0.01%, are all that is required to change crystal habit during crystallization. These impurities can: 1. Reduce the supply of material to the crystal face, 2. Reduce the specific surface energy, 3. Block surface sites and pin the steps of the growing crystal. The impurities that modify crystal habit fall into four categories: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Ions, either anions or cations; Ionic surfactants, either anionic or cationic; Nonionic surfactants like polymers; Chemical binding complexes (e.g., organic dye compounds or enzymes).
Each of these surface active impurities has a propensity to adsorb on a specific crystal surface. The change in the specific surface energy,
6.5 Crystal Shape
21g
d~/, that results from the adsorption of F atoms per unit area is given by Gibbs [62] as -d~/ = F RgT d(ln a2)
(6.87)
where a2 is the activity of the impurity in solution. The adsorbed amount F is frequently related to the impurity activity by the Langmuir adsorption isotherm [79] P :
FM
ba2 1 + ba2
_
or
ba2
F
-- FM-----~F
-
0 1- O
(6.88)
where O is the fractional surface coverage, b(=K/al) is related to the distribution coefficient K and the activity of the solvent al and can also be written as b - b' exp(AH/RgT)
(6.89)
where A H is the enthalpy of adsorption. This Langmuir adsorption isotherm is frequently used to describe the adsorption of ions, chemical binding complexes, and ionic surfactants but not polymers. More than one solvent molecule is displaced by the adsorption of one polymer molecule leading to a slightly modified form to this equation [80], ba2 =
O ~.(1 - O ) ~
(6.90)
where e is the number of solvent molecules displaced per polymer molecule. Ionic surfactants have the possibility of complexation in solution (i.e., micellization) as well as multilayer adsorption, which gives rise to more a complex adsorption isotherm [81] ba2(1/n + k2a~ -1) F = FM1 + ba2( 1 + k2a~_l)
(6.91)
where n is the aggregation number for surface micellization (i.e., number of layers) and k2 is the equilibrium constant for micellization. Ionic surfactants strongly adsorb on oppositely charged crystal surfaces at concentrations much less than the critical micelle concentration (CMC), (i.e., a2 ~- 0.01 9CMC) [82]. On similarly charged surfaces, ionic surfactants will adsorb without selectivity at concentrations near the CMC. Each face of the crystal has a different structure and as a result will be different with respect to adsorption. For example, kaolin platelets have an edge that is predominantly A12Oa and a face that is predominantly SiO2. Consequently, each crystal face will have its own adsorption isotherm, Fi. Kern [70] discusses the adsorption of ions like Cd, in the habit modification of a NaC1 (and Pb in the habit modification of KC1). There is a similarity between the {111} planes of NaC1 and the
218
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
{111} planes of CdC12. Kern postulates that a Cd adsorption layer completely covers that face of a growing NaC1 crystal and its growth is entirely surpressed. The adsorption of impurities at a particular surface decreases the area of the crystal face available for adsorption of solute molecules and therefore the growth of this surface, according to Burrill [83]. Mullin et al. [84] suggest that imputity ions in the vicinity of the surface will (1) reduce the effective surface supersaturation, (2) retard diffusion, and (3) hinder the incorporation of growth units into the crystal. Carbrera and Vermilgeer [85] note that if the mean distance between strongly adsorbed impurities is comparable with the size of the critical surface nuclei(r*), then the step will be "pinned" by the impurities, which decreases the growth rate and traps impurities in the crystal structure. Albon and Dunning [86] have observed step pinning on sucrose crystals caused by raffinose impurities. Decreased growth rates caused by step pinning have been observed with the electrolytic growth of Ag whiskers [87]. Chernov [60] suggests that there are two effects of impurities: reduction of the number of kinks if the impurities are relatively small and mobile, and action as an obstacle for the movement of the steps (i.e., step pinning) if the impurities are large and immobile. Reducing the number of kinks will also decrease the crystal growth. For these conditions, Chernov estimates that an impurity concentration ~10 -3 M will drastically reduce the growth rate. Slavnova [88] has observed qualitative confirmative of Chernov's theory. Sears [89] discussed the effects of poisons on subcritical nucleation kinetics and on the spiral shape. Crystal habit can be drastically changed by the specific adsorption of ionic surfactant impurities at concentrations below their critical micelle concentration. An example of this phenomena is the use of anionic and cationic surfactants to change the habit of adipic acid crystals during precipitation [90]. The addition of cationic surfactant will specifically adsorb on the negatively charged surfaces of adipic acid and limit their growth, yielding platelike particles, as shown in Figure 6.22. Anionic surfactants will adsorb on the positively charged surfaces of the adipic acid crystals and limit their growth rate, yielding needle-like particles. The preferential and strong adsorption of ionic surfactants is frequently used industrially to control crystal habit. Whatever the details of the kinetic mechanism, impurities cause crystal habit modification. Buckley [65] has classified many impurity effects on different crystal habit modifications. In most cases, impurities decrease the growth rate of specific crystal faces, which lead to a change in the crystal habit because the slowest growing faces will dictate the crystal morphology. In some exceptional cases, impurities can increase the growth rate of a particular crystal face. For example, 1% Fe added
6.5 Crystal Shape
219
~" ~..2~~~~ieOn~Cnt
deterg~~! anionic
L-d +LJ ,aces0'is
reta.0ationo,0ro .on
aac~ iS,
needles
FIGURE 6.22 Influence of impurity adsorption on the crystal habit, for the case of adipic acid. Redrawn, with permission from Nielsen [2].
to precipitation of ammonium dihydrogen phosphate gave high-quality, impurity-free crystals that grew at 10 times the rate of the pure solution. Such an increase may be caused by a decrease in the surface energy, reducing the size of the critical nucleus, which increases the surface nucleation rate more than is compensated for by a decrease in step velocity [83]. The effect of impurities, like PPM levels of Pb +2 in the precipitation of NaC1, can improve the quality of the crystals [91] and not enter the crystal lattice. Impurities can also cause the appearance of crystal faces not observed in pure solutions. H a r t m a n [92] has proposed that some impurities will cause step or kink faces to become flat, due to impurity adsorption at the "rough surface." Lateral growth is possible only at steps and growth on this surface is similar to that on an F face [93]. Polymeric surfactants are sometimes used for specific adsorption but more often as steric stabilizing surfactants to control the colloid stability of the suspension during precipitation [94]. A change in the interparticle forces due to polymer adsorption leads to different aggregate structures (i.e., fractal dimensions). These interparticle forces also determine the ease with which the aggregate structure can be reorganized. Jean [95] used the physical adsorption of hydroxy-propyl cellulose onto TiO2 to control its colloid stability during precipitation from alcohol solution. For steric stabilization, the adsorbed polymer must be well solubilized (i.e., better than a theta solvent). The effect of colloid
220
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
stability on aggregate size distribution during precipitation will be discussed in the next section.
6. 6 S I Z E D I S T R I B U T I O N EFFE C T S ~ P OP ULA T I O N BALANCE AND PRECIPITATOR
DESIGN
Coupled with a mass balance, the population balance accounts for all of the particles of each size that are generated in a precipitator. The population balance was first formulated by Randolph [96] and Hulbert and Katz [97]. A general review is provided by Randolph and Larson [98]. The population balance, when performed on a macroscopic scale like that of the whole precipitator, is given by
a~o(R) a(avo(R)) ~k VoKQK ยง = + B(R) - D(R) at aR V
(6.92)
where Vo(R) is the population of size R, G = dR/dt is the atom by atom growth rate given in Table 6.2, B(R) is the birth function, D(R) is the death function, QK is the flow rate in (+) or out ( - ) with population VOK, and V is the reactor volume. For this macro balance, the terms represent the accumulation of particles in size range R to R + dR due to growth, net particle input from entry and exit streams, and birth and death of particles directly into the size range by nucleation, aggregation, abrasion, or fracture. As written this equation assumes no volume accumulation in the reactor.
6.6.1 C o n t i n u o u s S t i r r e d T a n k R e a c t o r The simplest continuous reactor to consider is that of a constantly stirred tank reactor (CSTR) or precipitator, also called a mixed suspension, mixedproduct removal crystallizer (MSMPR) [98], shown in Figure 6.23. This type of precipitator has a constant volume, V, with an input flow rate equal to its output flow rate, Q. The population ~?0(R) in the precipitator is that which leaves as product. In this case, the population balance is used at steady state (i.e., a~o/at = 0):
Ga~o(R) ~oQ oR V -
(6.93)
where the growth rate, G, is constant and not a function of R (i.e., polynuclear or screw dislocation growth mechanisms that occur at low supersaturations).
6.6 Size Distribution Effects
O] [0
221
Product
Feed .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Uniform mixing profile
F I G U R E 6.23
Schematic representation of a continuous stirred tank reactor.
The birth and death functions are assumed for simplicity to be zero. The solution to this differential equation is given by ~?o=~ o exp( - ( R Gr - R*))
(6.94)
where r = V / Q is the mean residence time and 7 ~ is the number density, 7o, at R -- R*. The nucleation rate, B ~ is given by BO = 070 R--~R*
OR = To G o-7 o
(6.95)
The size distribution is solely determined by the mean residence time and the rates of nucleation and growth. In general, the total number of particles present in the system can be calculated by the following integral: N T = fo ~?~
= B~
(6.96)
which is normalization of the distribution function. For determining particle size distributions, it is convenient to use the normalized cumulative distribution function, Fi(R), defined as x ~n ( x ) d x F~(R) =
(6.97) x i n(x)dx
222
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
For example, the cumulative n u m b e r distribution (i.e., i = 0) is given by N(x) = B~ exp(-x)
(6.98)
whereas the cumulative mass distribution (i.e., i = 3) is given by M ( x ) = [1 + x + (1/2)x 2 + (1/6)x 3] exp(-x)
(6.99)
where x ( = ( R - R * ) / G r ) is the dimensionless size. In practice nuclei are produced at some finite size, R*, which is typically several orders of magnitude smaller t h a n the smallest particle size measured to determine the particle size distribution. As a result this critical size is often set to zero. Linear extrapolation of number density to R = 0 implies that the small particles grow in the same m a n n e r as larger particles, which is unlikely, but this is frequently the assumption used. As a result, this type of reactor can be used to obtain information for the average growth rate, G, and the average nucleation rate, B ~ from the slope and intercept of a population plot of equation (6.94). When experiments are performed at different supersaturations, the dependence of nucleation rate and growth rate on supersaturation can be evaluated.
6.6.1.1 C o n t i n u o u s Stirred Tank R e a c t o r with R e c y c l e The width of the size distribution is often measured in terms of the coefficient of variation (c.v.) of the mass distribution. Randolph and Larson [98] have shown that the coefficient of variation of the mass distribution is constant at 50% for this type of precipitator. This coefficient of variation is usually too large for ceramic powders. Attempts to narrow the size distribution of particles generated in a CSTR can be made by classified product removal, as shown in Figure 6.24. The classification function, p(R), is similar to those discussed in Section 4.2 and can be easily added to the population balance as follows: d~o(R) -~o(R)p(R) = dR Gz
(6.100)
Classification functions that fit the classification technique, whether a hydrocyclone or another method discussed in Chapter 4, give rise to specific populations. A convenient classification function shown in Figure 6.25(a) is given by 1 + aR 2 p ( R ) = --------~ 1 + bR
(6.101)
which has the properties that p ( R ) --, 1 as R ~ 0, p ( R ) ~ a/b as R --* ~, and d p ( R ) / d R ---> 0 as R -o 0 and R --~ ~ (Note: a/b must be less
6.6 Size Distribution Effects
Input
223
Reactor no(R)
Stream
Recycle stream
l
Product classifier
p(R) TIo(R)
Output stream 1-p(R) %(R) F I G U R E 6.24
Schematic drawing of a continuous stirred t a n k reactor with a classifica-
tion loop.
than 1.0). Using this classification function, Bourne et al. [99] solved for the population (1 - a/b) tan-l(RbU2)]
(6.102)
which gives narrower particle size distributions than without classification, as shown in Figure 6.25(b). Basically the fine particles are returned to the reactor and are grown to a larger size before they are allowed to leave the system. Narrower particle size distributions are needed for ceramic powders, so this is a useful method of particle synthesis. 6.6.1.2 C a s c a d e of C o n t i n u o u s Stirred T a n k R e a c t o r s Another way to decrease the width of the particle size distribution generated is to use a cascade of CSTRs, where the output from the ith reactor is the input for the (i + 1)th reactor. If nucleation occurs in the first tank of the cascade, followed by growth in all subsequent tanks, then the population leaving the last (Nth) reactor is given by Abegg and Balakrishnan [100] as
TON(x) (Nx) N-1 e-Nx ~o
( N - 1)!
(6.103)
224
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
g Q_ ~
g
1.0
0.8
Total Recycle: p(R) = 1.0 No Product Classification: p(R) = 0.0
0:6
LI_ 0.4
Fines Destruction
0
"~
a=t
0.2
" b=5
o=
121
1
9 b=
10
0.0
Particle
Size,
R
b o gEE R"
1.0
d
o -~ D
0.8
C~
lassification
.....,
.~ a
0.6
nesOo _, u ,on
r
n Z CO ~D
0.4
=1
0.2
i
b = 10 9 b=5
C
o "~ C
E
0.0 Dimensionless
Particle
Size,
x (=R/TO)
(a) Classification function as described in equation (6.101). (b) Particle size distribution effects with classified product removal (i.e., equation (6.102). Both redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
FIGURE 6.25
where N is the number of tanks in the cascade and x[=(R - R * ) / G r , N
i
r = F~i=l r ] is the dimensionless size.
The particle size distribution as a function of the number of tanks, N, is given in Figure 6.26(a) in terms of the cumulative weight distribution. From this figure, it is evident that the size distribution becomes narrower as the number of tanks in the cascade, N, increases. If nucleation occurs in each tank in the cascade, the population leaving the last tank has the following form:
a
1.0
c
._o o D
0.8
D_
_c
0.6
(b (D
.> _o a E (D
N=IO N = 20
0.4 0.2 0.0
I
).1
1.0
Dimensionless b c 0 ._
u 0
LL 4-,
_c ._~ (b
_o
E
Particle
10.0
Size, x (=R-R*/~-G)
1.0 0.8 0.6
~J
.>
........7
N = 100
,
,
,
0.4 0.2
LP
0.0 O.
1.0
Dimensionless C
,..--.,,, v
E
Particle
10.0
Size, x (=R-R*/'rG)
60 5O
0
o
40
C3
>
3O Multi-Point Nucleation
0
cq)
2O
~(1) 0 Q)
10 0
Single-Point Nucleation
'
2i0
'
Number
4t0
...........
of Tanks
601
,
in S e r i e s ,
8'0
'
......O0
N
F I G U R E 6.26 The effect of the number of tanks in series, N, on the cumulative weight distribution of a precipitated powder. (a) This plot is for the case of nucleation in the first tank only and further particle growth takes place in the remaining cascade. Recalculated from Equation (6.103) in terms of a weight distribution. (b) This plot is for the case of nucleation in all N tanks of the cascade. Recalculated from equation (6.104) in terms of a weight distribution. (c) Coefficient of variation = 100[(x16% x84%)/(2xs0%)] for both single- and multipoint nucleation. The coefficient of variation for this graph is calculated from panels (a) and (b). All panels redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK. -
226
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
VON(x) 7o
~~ [(Nx) ~ (Nx) g-~ ]
- 1 + -= [ i!
+ ~ ( N - 1)! e-yx
(6.104)
which is plotted in Figure 6.26(b) in terms of the cumulative weight distribution. Again, as the number of tanks increases, the particle size distribution becomes narrower. The coefficient of variation of the particle size distribution, defined as c.v. = 100(x16~ - xs4~)/(2Xso~), is plotted in Fig. 6.26(c) as a function of the number of tanks in series for both single- and multipoint nucleation models. For all numbers of tanks in a series, the multipoint nucleation model gives a larger c.v. than the single point nucleation model. For a large number of tanks in a series, the value of c.v. continuously decreases for single point and multipoint nucleation models. Increasing the number of tanks in the series decreases the width of the particle size distribution, thus giving more uniform ceramic powders.
6.6.2 Batch Precipitation Batch precipitation reactors are used through out the industry on a variety of size scales to produce ceramic powders. Examples include Cr203 for magnetic recording media, ferrites for magnets, and AgI for photographic emulsions. By far the most frequent utilization of batch precipitation is for small scale precipitation. Another example of a batch precipitation is during the initial stage of spray drying, when a droplet may be considered a small evaporative batch precipitation reactor. The population balance for the batch reactor in the absence of breakage and agglomeration is given by
a~o O(G*~o) +~ = 0 Ot OR
(6.105)
where 7o is the population, which is a function of time, t, and size R. The growth rate, G = dR/dt, is elaborated in Table 6.2 (i.e., dR/dt = K*f(S)*g(R)). The mass balance including the chemical reaction kinetics (i.e., k R CeqS) provides the time dependance of S, the saturation ratio, and thus the time dependence of f(S); for example,
dS dR Ps Ceq --~ = kR CeqS - [4/37rR .3 B ~R* + 47rR2 -~- Vo(R, t) R] ~
(6.106)
where B ~ is the nucleation rate. A particular solution to the population balance gives the population, To(R, t), as a function of time. The preceding equation is separable if v0(R, t) is a product of a time function, T(t), and a size function, ~(R), i.e., To(R, t) = T(t)*~(R)), giving a solution [4a] as follows:* * Note g'(R) g - ~ dR = d In g(R).
227
6.6 Size Distribution Effects
=
<,,
(6,107) where X.i is the eigenvalue and a i is the eigenvalue coefficient for this equation. The eigenvalues and coefficients are obtained from the initial condition, Vo(R, t = O) = i=1 ~ a i exp -
L g(R)
g*-ff(R)
dR
= ~~ (6.108)
and from this initial condition the eigenvalue coefficients can be determined: ai
= ~=~ E V~
exp
-
[g(R)
(6.109)
K*-ff(R) d R .
For a constant supersaturation (i.e., S # function of time) and a growth rate that is not a function of size (i.e., g(R) = 0 corresponds to polynuclear and screw dislocation growth), the size distribution at any time is simply a shifted version of the initial size distribution, T~ after the nucleation is completed: ~~
= R*, t = O) = ~~
(6.110)
- R* - Gt, t).
For different values of n in g(R) = R n, other kinetic expressions can be developed, if all the nuclei are the same size R*'. Integration of the growth rate (i.e., dR~dr = K * f ( S ) * g ( R ) ) gives: ('Kf(S)dt Jo
= Kf(S)t = ~ R-ndR
= [--nR(1-n)]R,
JR*
or =
ln[RR---g]
forn for n = 1.
This equation assumes that all the nuclei are the same size, R*. The equation gives an expression for the increase in particle size with time for various growth rate mechanisms. This expression is similar to that used by Nielsen [2] in his chronomal analysis. The only difference is that chronomal analysis uses the fraction precipitated, a(t), as a variable instead of the mean particle size, R(t). The fraction precipitated is defined as a(t) = C o - C(t)= ~ R(t! .~3 C 0 -
Ceq
\ R ( t = ~)}
where Co is the initial concentration of the precipitating species. Linear plots of the various chronomals, given in Table 6.5, versus time are used to verify the various growth mechanisms.
TABLE
6.5
G r o w t h Chronomalsa: I i ( a ( t ) ]
Growth mechanism Diffusion l i m i t e d
=
Kit Ii(a)
Ki
l~nI~l1--OL ~ 0~,3~] - ~tao ~I1 +~2 a l / 3 /1
R.2 3VDCeQ(S - 1)
-2
0.55 R* P o l y n u c l e a r surface M o n o n u c l e a r surface
x -2/3 (1 - x) -p dx,
p = (m + 2)/3
{kdTD2[Ceq(S - 1)](m+2~}1/a w h e r e "-Is = k[Ceq(S - 1)]m
- 3 a 1/3
d 3 e x p [ A G * / k s T]
3DR* a
D a t a t a k e n f r o m Nielsen, A. E., Kinetics of Precipitation, P e r g a m o n , Oxford, 1964.
229
6.6 S i z e D i s t r i b u t i o n Effects
MONO- NUCLEAR/POLY- NUCLEAR GROWTH n=+l ..... ~
E 0
D .s t ~
4
#
= 0.5
#m
a
=
0.2
pm
For all five distributions, are I = 2 0 %
O3
c~
3
# 0.82 pxn a = 0.17/zm =
_0
E
2
z
/ r ~ /~ = 1.36 pm f i a = 0.27 # m
-(3
' 2 I ,/"~
L / a \
~N 0
E
L
0
Z
0
0
J
1
,u = 2.24 w'rJ
2
.-.o.., 5
4
5
6
Particle Size, R (~m)
F I G U R E 6 . 2 7 M o n o n u c l e a r a n d p o l y n u c l e a r g r o w t h c u r v e s , b a s e d on t h e g r o w t h m o d e l of d R / d t ~ r n ( w h e r e n = 1). C u r v e 1 initial d i s t r i b u t i o n (t = 0), ft = 0 . 5 / ~ m , G = 0.2 /~m, O're1 - - 20%; c u r v e 2 , d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 0.5 t i m e u n i t s , / ~ = 0.82 ftm, cr = 0 . 1 7 ftm, OreI - - 20%; c u r v e 3 , d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 1 t i m e u n i t , ft = 1.36 ftm, o- = 0 . 2 7 / ~ m , O're1 - 20%; c u r v e 4, d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 1.5 t i m e u n i t s , ft = 2 . 2 4 / ~ m , G = 0 . 4 5 / ~ m , Gre] = 20%; a n d c u r v e 5, d i s t r i b u t i o n at t - 2 t i m e u n i t s , ft = 3 . 7 0 ftm, o- = 0 . 7 4 / ~ m , O're1 - - 200~. R e d r a w n w i t h p e r m i s s i o n f r o m D i r k s e n a n d R i n g [4a]. R e p r i n t e d from [4a], c o p y r i g h t 1 9 9 1 , w i t h k i n d p e r m i s s i o n f r o m E l s e v i e r S c i e n c e Ltd., T h e B o u l e v a r d , L a n g f o r d L a n e , Kidlington 0X5 1GB, UK.
For different values of n in g(R) = R n, the standard deviation of the particle size distribution [101] will (1) increase with time for n > 0, (2) remain constant for n = 0, and (3) decrease for n < 0. These three cases are illustrated in Figure 6.27 for n = 1, Figure 6.28 for n = 0, and Figure 6.29 for n = - 1 (i.e., diffusion limited growth). During diffusion limited growth, the standard deviation of the particle size distribution decreases as the particles grow. Diffusion limited growth can be obtained relatively easily using higher supersaturations, as discussed in conjunction with Table 6.2. For these reasons, batch precipitation with diffusion limited growth is frequently used for the precipitation of ceramic powders where a narrow size distribution is required.
6.6.3 Effect of Aggregation on the Particle Size Distribution In this section, the population balance will be used to model batch and CSTR precipitators where aggregation is a competing growth mechanism. Figure 6.30 is an example of the aggregate microstructure in
230
Chapter 6 L i q u i d Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
DIFFUSION CONTROLLED GROWTH c" 0 ..Q
~
L. .,4,-/
03 o~ C3
(D Xb
E
........
20 18
a = 0.03 # = 1.50/Jm
14 f/. --- 1 . 1 2 / ~ m .
IT
Crre I = 1.2
#m
= 1.6
==
O're I = 2 . 2
i
.
~
8
# = 0.5 urn a=0.1 #m
6
9
~
a = 0.03 pm
12 10
/z = 2 . 0 6 # m o = 0.02 #m
/z= 1.81 p r n
16
Z -o
I"1----1
22
4
N
o
2
E t-
5i
0 0.0
O
z
0.5
1.0
1.5
Porticle Size, R (/~m)
:
2.0
2.5
Polynuclear growth curves, based on the growth model of d R I d t ~ r n (where n = 0). C u r v e 1, initial distribution (t = 0), tL = 0 . 5 t~m, o" = 0 . 1 t~m, O're] = 2 0 % ; curve 2, distribution at t = 0 . 5 time units, t~ = 1 . 0 t~m, (r = 0 . 1 t~m, O'rel 1 0 % ; curve 3, distribution at t = i time unit, t~ = 1.5 t~m, o- = 0 . 1 t~m, O're1 6 . 7 % ; c u r v e 4, distribution at t = 1 . 5 time units, tL = 2 . 0 tLm, (r = 0 . 1 t~m, (rre] = 5 . 0 % ; and curve 5, distribution at t = 2 time units, t~ = 2 . 5 tLm, o- = 0 . 1 t~m, Grel 4 . 0 % . Redrawn with permission from Dirksen and Ring [4a]. Reprinted from [4a], copyright 1991, with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington 0 X 5 1 G B , U K .
FIGURE
6.28
- -
- -
- "
which we can see the individual nuclei 50/~ in diameter building up the structure of the 0.3 t~m particle produced by the precipitation of CeO2 by forced hydrolysis [102]. To begin this development, the macroscopic population balance is rewritten: O~qo(R______~+) Ot
O(G~qo(R)) OR
~ ~oKQK + k = B(R) - D(R) V
(6.111)
with birth, B(R), and death, D(R), by aggregation included. In this form of the population balance, we assume a negligible volume accumulation and no particle breakage. For a solution to this population balance, a mathematical relationship must first be developed for the birth and death functions. The birth and death functions predict the importance of particle aggregation on the final particle size distribution. The aggregation rate was first developed by von Smoluchoski [103] in his rapid coagulation theory. His equation predicts the time change in the number of particles per unit volume consisting of k primary particles"
ONk Ot
--
I i=~-1i=k-1 ~., ~ 47rR~jDijN~Nj-Nk ~ 4~rRikDikN~ 2 i= l j = k - i i= l
(6.112)
231
6.6 Size D i s t r i b u t i o n Effects
P O L Y - N U C L E A R GROWTH o~
A
r o :+~
6
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
n=O .
.
.
.
F o r oil five d i s t r i b u t i o n s ,
c~ "E
#=o.5~m
."+-' Or)
O're1 ~ 2 0 %
~ = 1.O~m ~ = 1.5~m or
.~10~
or
= 6.7~
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
cr = 0.1 /zm
~=2.0~'n
are I ~ 5 . 0 ~
Cb
~-2.5~m
are1.4.0
L.
(D ..0
E
:3 Z "0
._N o
E
L 0 Z
O! 0.0
2
3
1:0
1;5
=
" 0.5
2[0
2.5
9 3.0
Particle Size, R (um~ F I G U R E 6.29 Diffusion controlled g r o w t h curves, b a s e d on t h e g r o w t h model of d R / d t = r n ( w h e r e n - - 1 ) . C u r v e 1, initial d i s t r i b u t i o n (t = 0), ft = 0.5/~m, r = 0.1 fern, r 1 = 20%; curve 2, d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 0.5 t i m e units, ~ = 1.12 ram, cr = 0.04 ram, O're1 3.9%; curve 3, d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 1 t i m e unit, tL = 1.5 t~m, (r = 0.03 t~m, O're1 2.2%; curve 4, d i s t r i b u t i o n a t t = 1.5 time units, t~ = 1.81 t~m, (r = 0.03 t~m, O'rel 1.6%, a n d curve 5, d i s t r i b u t i o n at t = 2 t i m e units, t~ = 2.06 t~m, (r = 0.02 tLm, (rre] = 1.2%. R e d r a w n w i t h p e r m i s s i o n from D i r k s e n a n d Ring [4a]. R e p r i n t e d from [4a], c o p y r i g h t 1991, w i t h k i n d p e r m i s s i o n from E l s e v i e r Science Ltd., T h e Boulevard, L a n g f o r d Lane, K i d l i n g t o n 0X5 1GB, UK. -
-
-
"
-
-
F I G U R E 6.30 F o r m a t i o n of CeO2 p a r t i c l e s by t h e forced h y d r o l y s i s of a n acidic Ce(804)2 solution at 90~ ( a - c ) P a r t i c l e f o r m a t i o n over a 6 h r period a n d (d) final p r o d u c t a f t e r 48 h r of a g i n g (with p e r m i s s i o n [102]).
~~
Chapter 6 Liquid Phase Synthesis by Precipitation
where Rij( = R i + Rj) is the sum of radius i and j, Do(= kBT/6rrl~ *(1/R i + 1/Rj)) is the relative Brownian diffusion coefficient for two particles, i and j. The two summation terms on the right-hand side of this equation are the birth and death functions, respectively, but they do not have the same units as the population balance. To make this formulation compatible, it must be divided by Rk, giving B(R, t) - D(R, t) 10Nk Rk Ot
k B T i=~-l J=~-I (R i -F Rj )2 2kB ~ (Ri + Rk) 2 31-r i=l j=k-i R i Rj g i g j - 3t ~Tgk~i=l RiRk gi" (6.113)
The birth and death functions now have the same units as the population balance. To attempt a solution, an integral or continuous approach will be used in place of this discrete summation. This suggests that there is a continuous distribution of particle sizes (i.e., the sizes of interest for the population balance are much larger than that of singlets, doublets, etc.). Some key substitutions for this integration are necessary: Ni = x Vo(X)
Ri = x
Nj = (R - x) ~?o(R - x)
Rj = R - x
Nk = R Vo(R)
Rk = R
i=i=~_k-l, i=j=k-lk-i_E__l =
dx
= =
lfo dx .
Substitution of these relationships into the discrete form of the birth and death functions yields R
(6.115)
B ( R ) = Ka fo Vo(X)Vo(R - x) dx
D(R) = 2
~R2
~ (x + R)2Vo(X) dx = 2 Ka Vo(R) NT
~ + -~ + 1
)
(6.116) where NT is the total number of particles per unit volume, Ka[ = kBT/ 3/zW] is the aggregation rate constant, W is the colloid stability factor averaged over all particle sizes, and (~i) is the ith moment of the distribution, given by ~oc
fo x,o(X)dx = J0 xi,o(X) (~i) = fo ~o(xl d x
NT
(6.117)
6.6 Size Distribution Effects
233
The governing differential equation for particulate growth now becomes O~o(R) ot
t
= Ka
0[avo(R)] oR
s:
~k VoKQK V
~Oo(x)rlo(R - x ) d x - 2Ka~o(R)NT
R-5 + ~- + 1 .
(6.118)
An analytical solution to this integro-partial differential equation is not possible without some simplifying assumptions. In the sections that follow, analytical solutions are presented for particle growth in a CSTR and batch precipitation reactors. For systems in which shear is the dominant collision mechanism and not Brownian diffusion, the birth and death functions can be rewritten in terms of the mean shear rate, ~/, as follows [104]. B(R) = -~R 4/
x(R - x) ~)o(x) rlo(R - x) dx
4 ~o(R) D(R) - -~ R ~/ f0~ x(R + x) 3 ~o(X) dx
(6.119) (6.120)
Shear aggregation brings an added complexity to the modeling of aggregation kinetics. This complication due to shear is not discussed further.
6.6.3.1 C o n t i n u o u s Stirred Tank R e a c t o r with Aggregation The role agglomeration plays in a CSTR is explained by considering the macroscopic population balance at a steady state: V O~o(R) + ~o(R___~) OR T = Ka ~jo rio(x) ~oo(R - x) dx - 2Ka ~o(R)NT
+
+ 1
(6.121)
where G is the atomistic growth rate, which is assumed to be not a function of size R (i.e., either polynuclear or screw dislocation growth). Making the assumption used by Dirksen and Ring [4a] that the term (x2/R 2 + 2~/R + 1) is equal to 4 and putting equation (6.121) in dimensionless term