FUNDAMENTALS OF INTERFACE AND COLLOID SCIENCE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FUNDAMENTALS OF INTERFACE AND COLLOID SCIENCE
VOLUME III LIQUID-FLUID INTERFACES
J. Lyklema With contributions from: G.J. Fleer. J.M. Kleijn, F.A.M. Leermakers. W. Norde, T. van Vliet
ACADEMIC PRESS A Harcourt Science and Technology Connpany
San Diego San Francisco New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright © 2000 by ACADEMIC PRESS
All Rights Reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or tramsmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press A Harcourt Science and Technology Company 32 Jamestown Road, London, NWI 7BY, UK http://www.academic press.com Academic Press A Harcourt Science and Technology Company 524 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA http://www.academic press.com
ISBN 0-12-460523-0 A catalogue record for this book is avaiilable from the British Libreiry Library of Congress Card Number: 00-101585
Printed in Great Britain by MPG Books Ltd., Bodmin, Cornwall 00 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 M P 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
GENERAL PREFACE Fundamentals of Interface and Colloid Science (FICS) is motivated by three related but partly conflicting observations. First, interface and colloid science is an important and fascinating, though often undervalued, branch of science. It has applications and ramifications in domains as disparate as agriculture, mineral dressing, oil recovery, the chemicsd industry, biotechnology, medical science and many more provinces of the living and non-living world. The second observation is that proper application and integration of interface and colloid science requires, besides factued knowledge, insight into the many basic laws of physics £ind chemistry upon which it rests. In the third place, most textbooks of physics eind chemistry pay only limited attention to interface and colloid science. These observations give rise to the dilemma that it is an almost impossible task to simultaneously master specific domains of application and be proficient in interface and colloid science itself, along with its foundations. The problem is aggravated by the fact that interface and colloid science has a very wide scope: it uses parts of classical, irreversible and statistical thermodynamics, optics, rheology, electrochemistry and other brsinches of science. Nobody can be expected to commaind all of these simultaneously. The prime goal of FICS is to meet these demands systematically, treating the most important interfacial and colloidal phenomena starting from basic principles of physics and chemistry, whereby these principles are first reviewed. In doing so, it will become clear that common roots often underlie seemingly different phenomena, which is helpful in identifying and recognizing them. Given these objectives, a deductive approach is required .Throughout the work, systems of increasing complexity are treated gradually, with, as a broad division, in Volume I the fundamentals (F), in Volumes II and III isolated interfaces (I) and in Volumes IV and V interfaces in interaction and colloids (C). The chosen deductive set-up serves two purposes: the work is intended to become a standard reference but with parts that will be suitable for systematic use, either as a self-study guide or as a reference for courses. In view of these objectives, a certain style is more or less defined and has the following characteristics: - Topics are arranged by the main principle(s) and phenomena on which they rest. Since mauiy researchers are not immediately familiar with these principles £ind as more than one principle may determine a phenomenon met in practice, an extensive and detailed subject index is provided, which in some places has double or triple entries.
11
As FICS is a book of principles rather thcin a book of facts, no attempt is made to give it an encyclopaedic character, although important data are tabulated for easy reference. For factual information, references are made to the literature, in particular to reviews and books. Experimental observations that illustrate or enforce specific principles are emphasized, rather than given for their own sake. This also implies a certain preference for illustrations with model systems. Some arbitrariness Ccinnot be avoided; our choice is definitely not a 'beauty contest'. - In order to formulate physical principles properly, some mathematics is unavoidable as we cannot always ignore complex and abstract formalisms. To that end, specialized techniques that are sometimes particularly suitable for solving certain types of problems, will be introduced when needed; much of this in the appendices to Volume I. However, the reader is assumed to be familiar with elementary calculus. - Generally, the starting level of Volume I is such that it can be read without having an advanced command of physics and chemistry. In turn, for the later Volumes, the physical chemistry of Volume I is the starting point. - In view of the fact that much space is reserved for the explanation and elaboration of principles, we had to restrict the number of systems treated in order to keep the size of the work manageable. Given the importance of interfacial and colloid science for biology, medicine, pharmacy, agriculture, etc., wet' systems, aqueous ones in particular, are emphasized. 'Dry' subjects such as aerosols and solid state physics are given less attention. Experimentad techniques are not described in great detail except where these techniques have a typical interfacial or colloidal nature. Considering all these features, FICS may be thought of as a work containing parts that can also be found in more deteiil elsewhere but rarely in the present context. Moreover, it stands out by integrating all these parts. It is hoped that through this integration many readers will use the work to find their way in the expanding literature and, in doing so, will experience the relevance and beauty of interface and colloid science and become fascinated by it. Hans Lyklema Wageningen, The Netherlands 2000
PREFACE TO VOLUME n i : LigUID-FLUID INTERFACES Having laid down the physico-chemical basis of interface a n d colloid science in Volume 1, a n d t h e n presented a systematic t r e a t m e n t of solid-fluid interfaces in Volume II, we now conclude the interface science part of FICS with a t r e a t m e n t of liquid-fluid interfaces. Colloids will be discussed in Volumes FV a n d V. In line with the general set-up of FICS, we try to keep the t r e a t m e n t systematic and deductive. Recurrent features are that each chapter begins, a s m u c h a s possible, with t h e general thermodynamic a n d / o r statistical t h e r m o d y n a m i c foundations a n d the various p h e n o m e n a are presented in order of increasing complexity. The r e q u i r e m e n t t h a t t h e work be both a reference a n d a textbook is reflected in its being comprehensive a s far a s the fundamentals are concerned a n d in its didactic style. Completeness always remains a matter of dispute, b u t it is hoped t h a t m a n y r e a d e r s will find the information they are looking for, especially regarding basic issues a n d m a i n principles. No attempt is made to give the book a n encyclopaedic character a s far a s the facts are concerned; exceptions are selected d a t a collections, a s in appendices 1 a n d 4. Experiments are included w h e n they help to illustrate certain points; there may be some arbitrariness in the choice. Typically we s h u n , multivariable systems because their very complexity might obscure basic features. The level is about the same a s t h a t of papers in m o d e m j o u r n a l s dealing with the subject. It is to be hoped t h a t readers without the background c a n find m u c h of the desired information in FICS, going back to earlier c h a p t e r s or to Volume I where needed. To facilitate this process, extensive back-referencing h a s b e e n applied, although, where appropriate at the beginning of each chapter, the relevant background in the previous volumes is briefly reviewed, so t h a t the present book s t a n d s on its own. For more specialistic background information, reference is m a d e to the literature a n d we provide a very extensive cumulative subject index. In a n u m b e r of instances a decision h a d to be t a k e n a s to w h a t to call 'fundamentals' a n d w h a t advanced'. As a rule, we have avoided detailed descriptions of a s s u m p t i o n s made, a n d p a r a m e t e r s selected, in statistical-thermodynamic analyses, although it is appreciated t h a t the results depend heavily on these choices. In a n u m b e r of places we have elaborated some principles ourselves. Interfacial rheology is introduced in some detail; we feel t h a t its relevance is not generally appreciated. In order to streamline the systematics, all monolayer techniques c a n be found in the chapter on Langmuir monolayers, which, as a consequence, grew to become t h e largest in t h e book. Wetting is, in a s e n s e , a n application of t h e preceding four chapters, b u t because of its relevance a full chapter is devoted to it. Regarding symbols a n d u n i t s of quantities, lUPAC recommendations have, a s a rule, been heeded. However, the very wide scope of FICS leads to a n u m b e r of clashes t h a t forced u s to deviate from these rules now and then. For example, we prefer F for Helmholtz energy instead of A because of the confusion with A for area.
iv
It is also unavoidable that sometimes the same symbol is used for different physical quantities, because we wanted to avoid excessive use of subscripts and superscripts. Mostly this does not give rise to problems, but in those places where it might, we have added a caveat. For instance, cross-sectional areas per molecule have different meanings in lattice theories and in surface pressure isotherms for Langmuir monolayers; we explain this in sections 3.3 and 3.4. As for the spelling of names, we prefer that of the country of origin. So, if referring to people, we would write for instance van der Waals, Deryagin and d'Arcy. However, for phenomena or laws, capitals are used (Van der Waals equation'). For Slavic names, originally written in the Cyrillic alphabet, we adhere to the Chemical Abstracts transcription. However, many Slavic authors have the custom of transcribing their names differently in different languages, and as literature citations should be verbatim, some inconsistency is unavoidable. Where appropriate, identifications are made (Deryaguin, Derjagin, Derjaguin, etc. = Deryagin). In a systematic text the size of FICS, numerous cross-references are unavoidable. We prefer to refer to sections, rather than to pages or to facilitate consultation, to subsections, where possible. References to Volumes I or II are preceded by I or II, respectively. Co-operation and acknowledgements In writing this book I have benefitted from the help of many people, whose cooperation is gratefully acknowledged. In the first place I am particularly indebted to: Prof. G.J. Fleer (subsecs. 3.4i, J and 3.8f, g). Dr. J.M. Kleijn (sees. 3.7 and subsec. 3.8c), Dr. F.A.M. Leermakers (parts of sees. 3.5 and 4.7), Dr. W. Norde (sees. 3.1-3.3 and subsec. 3.8d), and Dr. T. van Vliet (sees. 3.6 and 4.5), who actually wrote (parts of) sections for me, or at least laid the foundations for them. These contributors are acknowledged on the title page. In addition, I thank Dr. T. Golub for her assistance in completing appendix 1 and Dr. H. Visser for setting up appendix 4. For chapter 4, I could adways rely on Prof. B.H. Bijsterbosch to act as a 'sparring partner', by critically reading and commenting on just-drafted sections. For the corresponding expert help with chapter 5, I thank Dr. T.D. Blake, Dr. E.M. Blokhuis and Prof. A.-M. Cazabat, who also assisted me greatly in providing course material, written for other purposes. Professor P. Walstra's careful and constructive screening of chapters 3 and 4 is wholeheartedly appreciated, and so is Prof. G.A. Barnes' critical reading of chapter 3. Prof. A. Marmur's comments to chapter 5 are also appreciated. I found the comments of staff members and students on completed chapters particularly useful, because it helped me to 'try them out'. Often they gave rise to
textual improvements. My thanks in this respect go to Dr. R. Barchini (chapters 4 and 5), Dr. K. Besseling (parts of chapters 1, 2 aind 3), Prof. B.H, Bijsterbosch (chapters 1 and 2), Dr. T.D. Blake (chapter 1), Dr. E.M. Blokhuis (chapter 2, parts of chapter 3), Dr. J.A.G. Buys. Prof. A.-M. Cazabat (chapters 1 and 2), Prof. J. de Coninck (part of chapter 2), Dr. E.P.K. Currie (parts of chapters 2 and 3), Prof. G.J. Fleer (peirts of chapter 3), J. van der Gucht (part of chapter 4), Dr. A. de Keizer (chapter 1, parts of chapter 3 and much other 'scientific-logistic' help), Dr. L.K. Koopal (chapters 1, 2 and 4), Prof. E. van der Linden (part of chapter 3), Dr. H. van Leeuwen (parts of chapters 3 and 4), Drs. J. Lucassen and E.H. Lucassen-Reynders (lively discussions on interfacial thermodynamics and rheology), Dr. F. MacRitchie (chapter 3), Dr. W. Norde (chapters 1 and 2), J. van den Oever (parts of chapter 4), Dr. S.M. Oversteegen (parts of chapters 1 and 2), Mrs. J. Slofstra (chapter 1), L.H. Tom (chapter 3). Dr. R. Tuinier (chapters 1-4) and Dr. T. van Vliet (chapter 1). Obviously, I am responsible for any errors and imperfections which may remain after all this screening. I am greatly indebted to Mrs. Josie Zeevat for the actual lay-out and typing, all of it done with much dedication and technical skill, largely in her own spare time. FIGS is, in a sense, also her book. The airt work was again in the capable hands of Mr. G. Buurman. Many people in the Depairtment assisted me in different ways of services. Of them 1 would like to mention Mr. A.W. Bouman. All this help and encouragement has been instrumental in completing this third volume. Last but not least, I wish to express my sincere gratitude to my wife for her understanding and tolerance.
Hans Lyklema, Wageningen, The Netherlcinds April 2000
VI
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS 1 Interfacial tension: measurement 1.1 General introduction to capillarity and the measurement of interfacial tensions 1.2 On the mathematics of curvature 1.3 Capillary rise 1.3a Vertical cylinder 1.3b Vertical plate 1.3c Other geometries 1.4 Shapes of drops and bubbles on surfaces 1.5 Free drops in a density gradient or electric field 1.6 Drop weight method 1.7 Maximum bubble pressure 1.8 Force required to hold objects at an interface or to pull them through it 1.8a Wilhelmy plate 1.8b DuNouyring 1.8c Other geometries 1.9 Spinning drops and bubbles 1.10 Surface light scattering 1.11 Miscellaneous other static methods 1.12 A case study: the surface tension of water 1.12a Room temperature 1.12b FromO°- 100°C 1.13 Measuring the surface tension of solids 1.14 Surface tensions under dynamic conditions 1.14a Pure liquids 1.14b Solutions 1.14c A note on the pristine state of LG and LL surfaces 1.15 Bending moduli 1.16 Applications 1.17 General References 1.17a lUPAC recommendations 1.17b Tabulations 1.17c Capillarity, shapes of fluid bodies etc. 1.17d Measuring interfacial and surface tensions
1.2 1.7 1.12 1.12 1.21 1.23 1.24 1.31 1.33 1.36 1.39 1.39 1.45 1.48 1.49 1.53 1.56 1.58 1.58 1.59 1.65 1.67 1.68 1.70 1.76 1.77 1.82 1.84 1.84 1.85 1.85 1.86
viii
2 Interfacial tension: molecular interpretation 2.1 Introductory considerations 2.2 Thermodynamic and statistical thermodynamic fundamentals. Flat interfaces 2.3 Interfacial tension and interfacial pressure tensor 2.4 Interfacial tensions and distribution functions 2.5 Van der Waals theory 2.5a Some elements of van der Waals' theory 2.5b Comments and consequences 2.5c Van der Waals theory in the Hamaker-de Boer approximation 2.6 Cahn-Hilliard theory 2.7 Interfacial tensions from simulations 2.8 The thickness of the interfacial region 2.9 Quasi-thermodynamic approaches. Effects of temperature and pressure. Corresponding states 2.9a Influence of temperature. Energetic and entropic contributions 2.9b Influence of pressure 2.9c Surface tensions as capillary waves 2.10 Lattice theories for the interpretation of interfacial tensions 2.11 Empirical relationships 2.11a Relations containing molar volumes and compressibilities 2.11b Relationships for interfacial tensions, containing geometric means 2.11c Other empirical relationships 2.12 Conclusions and applications 2.13 General references 3 Langmuir Monolayers 3.1 Langmuir- and Gibbs monolayers. Distinctions and analogies 3.2 How to make monolayers 3.3 Two-dimensional phases and surface pressure 3.3a Determination of the interfacial pressure. Film balances 3.3b Introduction to 2D phase behaviour 3.3c Some representative illustrations 3.4 Monolayer thermodynamics 3.4a General formalism and definitions 3.4b Some expressions of general validity 3.4c Application to a real system 3.4d The thermodynamics of phase transitions
2.3 2.5 2.9 2.11 2.17 2.18 2.25 2.31 2.34 2.37 2.43 2.48 2.48 2.57 2.59 2.60 2.64 2.64 2.68 2.72 2.73 2.76
3.2 3.6 3.13 3.14 3.18 3.23 3.28 3.28 3.33 3.36 3.38
IX
3.4e Two-dimensional equations of state 3.4f Mixed Langmuir monolayers 3.4g Half open Langmuir monolayers 3.4h Ionized monolayers 3.4i Polymer monolayers 3.4j Brushes 3.5 Monolayer molecular thermodynamics 3.5a Some general considerations 3.5b Strictly two-dimensioned approaches 3.5c Monte Carlo (MC) simulations 3.5d Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations 3.5e Mean field lattice (MFL) theories 3.6 Interfacial rheology 3.6a Some basic issues 3.6b A review of bulk rheology 3.6c Basic interfacial rheology 3.6d Intermezzo. Dispeirate definitions of interfacial tension 3.6e Coupling of interface and bulk motions. Marangoni effect 3.6f Experimental methods to determine surface rheological properties. Principles 3.6g Wave propagation and damping 3.6h Relaxation processes in Langmuir monolayers 3.6i Equivalent mechanical circuits 3.7 Measuring monolayer properties 3.7a Monolayer transfer on solid substrates: LemgmuirBlodgett films 3.7b Reflection and diffraction 3.7c Spectroscopic techniques 3.7d Scanning probe microscopy 3.7e Rheology 3.7f Volta potentials 3.8 Case studies 3.8a A note on equilibrium and reproducibility 3.8b Fatty acids, fatty alcohols and related compounds 3.8c Phospholipids 3.8d Cholesterol 3.8e PMA at the air/water interface 3.8f PEG brushes 3.9 Applications
3.39 3.46 3.48 3.49 3.53 3.58 3.62 3.62 3.65 3.67 3.69 3.75 3.79 3.82 3.84 3.91 3.95 3.96 3.102 3.109 3.120 3.125 3.131 3.132 3.141 3.156 3.174 3.180 3.190 3.194 3.194 3.200 3.215 3.223 3.227 3.231 3.235
3.10 General references
4
3.241
3.10a lUPAC Recommendations
3.241
3.10b Monographs, reviews
3.242
3.10c Classical a n d molecular thermodynamics
3.243
3.10d Interfacial rheology
3.243
3.10e C h a r a c t e r i z a t i o n
3.244
3.10f Langmuir-Blodgett layers
3.247
3,10g Data collection
3.247
Gibbs Monolayers 4.1
Introduction
4.1
4.2
The surface tension of miscible binary mixtures
4.2
4.2a General features a n d thermodynamics
4.2
4.2b From F^"^ to y
4.6
4.2c F r o m / t o F^"^
4.18
4.2d A note on surface excess entropy
4.20
4.3
Dilute solutions of simple molecules
4.20
4.3a Experimental techniques
4.21
4.3b Theory
4.22
4.3c A case study: alcohols
4.27
Simple electrolytes
4.34
4.4
4.4a The pristine surface of water
4.35
4.4b Electrolytes at the air-water interface
4.36
4.4c Electrolytes at water-oil interfaces)
4.41
4.4d Some practical implications
4.45
4.5
Rheology a n d kinetics
4.46
4.5a Identification of basic transport p h e n o m e n a
4.48
4.5b Basic mathematics
4.51
4.5c Experimental techniques
4.58
4.6
Surfactants
4.68
4.6a Surfactants in solution
4.69
4.6b Surfactant monolayers. General features
4.73
4.6c Non-ionics
4.76
4.6d Ionic surfactants
4.83
4.7
Curved interfaces
4.93
4.8
Applications
4.97
4.9
General references
4.99
XI
5
Wetting 5.1 General considerations 5.1a Principles and definitions 5. lb The laws of Young and Neumann 5.2 Thermodynamics of wetting and adhesion 5.3 The relation between adsorption and wetting. Wetting films 5.3a The disjoining pressure in wetting films 5.3b Film formation by adsorption 5.3c Case studies 5.3d A note on film thinning 5.4 Measuring contact angles 5.4a Factors affecting contact angles 5.4b Sessile drops and captive bubbles on a flat surface 5.4c Contact angles from forces on objects in interfaces 5.4d Tilted plates 5.4e Capillary rise or depression 5.4f Vertical plates and cylinders 5.4g Fibres 5.4h Individual colloidal particles 5.4i Powders and porous materials 5.4j Concluding remark 5.5
Contact angle hysteresis 5.5a The phenomenon 5.5b Origins 5.5c Interpretations 5.5d Hysteresis on model surfaces 5.6 Line tensions 5.7 Interpretation of static contact angles 5.8 Dynamics 5.9 Porous systems 5.10 Influence of surfactants 5.11 Applications 5.1 la Characterization of the wettability of solid surfaces 5.11b Flotation 5.11c Particles at interfaces 5.lid Various other applications 5.12 General references 5.12a lUPAC recommendation 5.12b Books, Reviews and Symposium Proceedings
5.3 5.3 5.10 5.12 5.22 5.23 5.28 5.33 5.38 5.39 5.39 5.41 5.47 5.47 5.48 5.50 5.53 5.54 5.56 5.58 5.59 5.59 5.60 5.63 5.66 5.68 5.73 5.77 5.83 5.89 5.93 5.94 5.96 5.98 5.101 5.103 5.103 5.103
xii
Appendices APPENDIX 1 Surface Tensions of Pure Liquids and Mixtures a. Surface tension of some inorganic fluids b. Surface tensions of some molten metals c. Surface tension of some molten halides d. Surface tensions of some low boiling point liquids e. Surface tensions of linear alkanes f. Surface tensions of linear aliphatic n-alcohols g. Surface tensions of linear ailiphatic n-sddehydes h. Surface tensions of linear n-amines i. Surface tensions of n-aliphatic acids J. Surface tensions of n-cdiphatic nitriles k. Surface tensions of n-aliphatic isomers compared 1. Surface tensions of some other common cdiphatic compounds m. Surface tensions of some triglycerides n. Surface tensions of benzene and some mono-substituted benzenes o. Surface tensions of some other cyclic compounds p. Surface tensions of some binary mixtures References, indicating methods where appropriate APPENDIX 2 a. Integral characteristic functions of flat interfaces b. Differential characteristic functions of flat interfaces
Al. 1 Al. 1 A 1.6 A 1.7 A 1.8 A 1.9 Al.l 1 A1.15 A 1.16 A 1.17 A 1.19 A1.22 A1.24 A1.27 A1.29 Al .34 A1.38 A 1.45 A2.1 A2.1
APPENDIX 3 Some principles of variational calculus
A3.1
APPENDIX 4 Contact angles
A4.1
a. Contact angles on metals b. Contact angles on polymers c. Contact angles on oxides, minerals and metalloids SUBJECT INDEX
A4.1 A4.5 A4.13
xiii
CONDENSED CONTENTS OF VOLUME I 1 Introduction to interfacial and colloid chemistry 1.1 First encounter 1.1 1.2 A first review of interface and colloid science 1.3 1.3 Further insights 1.8 1.4 Guiding principles 1.28 1.5 Structure of this book 1.30 2 Thermod3mamic foundations of interface and colloid science 2.1 Thermodynamic principles 2.1 2.2 Thermodynamic definitions 2.2 2.3 Equilibrium, reversibility and relaxation 2.4 2.4 The First Law 2.8 2.5 The excess character of interfacial energy. The Gibbs dividing plane 2.11 2.6 Enthalpy and interfacial enthalpy 2.15 2.7 Heat capacities of bulk phases and interfaces 2.17 2.8 The Second Law 2.20 2.9 Entropies of bulk phases and interfaces 2.23 2.10 Gibbs and Helmholtz energies of bulk phases and interfaces 2.24 2.11 Differential and integral characteristic functions of bulk phases and interfaces. 2.28 2.12 Thermodynamic conditions for equilibrium 2.30 2.13 Gibbs-Duhem relations, the Gibbs adsorption equation and the Phase Rule 2.35 2.14 Relations of general validity. Properties of toted differentials 2.37 2.15 Gibbs-Helmholtz relations 2.42 2.16 Homogeneous mixtures. General features 2.44 2.17 Ideal homogeneous mixtures 2.50 2.18 Non-ideal mixtures and solutions 2.58 2.19 Phase separation and demixing 2.64 2.20 The laws of dilute solutions 2.68 2.21 Chemical equilibrium 2.75 2.22 Further discussion of the Gibbs adsorption equation 2.78 2.23 Curved interfaces. Introduction to capillarity and nucleation 2.86 2.24 Thermodynamics of solid interfaces 2.100 2.25 Concluding remarks 2.102 2.26 General references 2.103 3 Statistical thermodjmamic foundations of interface and colloid science 3.1 Basic principles and definitions 3.1 3.2 Partition Functions 3.9 3.3 Statistical and classical thermodynamic equivgdence. Characteristic functions 3.15 3.4 Derivation of macroscopic quantities from partition functions 3.18 3.5 Partition functions of subsystems 3.19 3.6 Partition functions for systems with independent subsystems 3.26 3.7 Fluctuations 3.33 3.8 Dependent subsystems 3.39 3.9 Classical statistical thermod3namics 3.56 3.10 Concluding remarks 3.72 3.11 General references 3.72 4 Interactions in interface and colloid science 4.1 Types of interactions 4.1 4.2 Pair interaction curves. The disjoining pressure 4.3 4.3 Force fields and potentials 4.10 4.4 Van der Waals forces between isolated molecules 4.16
XIV
4.5 4.6
Molecular forces in a medium 4.41 Van der Waals forces between macrobodies. The Hamaker-De Boer approximation 4.57 4.7 Van der Waals forces between macrobodies. The Lifshits theory 4.75 4.8 Measuring Van der Waals interactions between macrobodies 4.82 4.9 References 4.84 5 Electrochemistiy and its applications to colloids and interfaces 5.1 Some basic issues 5.2 5.2 Ionic interactions in electrolyte solution 5.15 5.3 Ion-solvent interactions 5.33 5.4 Solvent structure-originated interactions 5.66 5.5 Interfacial potentials 5.71 5.6 Surface charge 5.89 5.7 The Gibbs energy of an electrical double layer 5.103 5.8 General references 5.109 6 Transport phenomena in interface and colloid science 6.1 Transport fundamentals 6.3 6.2 Elements of irreversible thermodynamics 6.12 6.3 Stochastic processes 6.17 6.4 Viscous flow phenomena 6.31 6.5 Diffusion 6.53 6.6 Conduction 6.73 6.7 Mixed transport modes 6.88 6.8 General References 6.94 7 Optics and its application to interface and colloid science 7.1 Electromagnetic waves in a vacuum 7.2 7.2 Introduction of the Maxwell equations and medium effects 7.9 7.3 Interaction of radiation with matter 7.13 7.4 Sources of electromagnetic waves 7.20 7.5 Particle-wave duality 7.23 7.6 Quasi-elastic light scattering (QELS) techniques 7.25 7.7 Quasi-elastic scattering of liquids 7.42 7.8 Quasi-elastic scattering by colloids 7.47 7.9 Neutron and X-ray scattering by colloids 7.67 7.10 Optics of interfaces 7.71 7.11 Surface spectroscopy and imaging techniques 7.84 7.12 Infrared and Raman spectroscopy 7.91 7.13 Magnetic resonance techniques 7.94 7.14 Anisotropic media and polarization phenomena 7.96 7.15 Measuring diffusion coefficients: a review 7.101 7.16 General references 7.104 Appendices 1 Fundamental constants 2 Common SI prefixes 3 Integral characteristic functions for homogeneous bulk phases and for two phases, separated by a flat interface 4 Differentials of characteristic functions for homogeneous bulk phases and for two phases, separated by a flat interface 5 Integral characteristic functions for flat interfaces and their differentials 6 Derivation of macroscopic quantities from partition functions 7 Vectors and vector fields. Introduction to tensors 8 Complex and imaginciry quantities 9 Hamaker constants 10 Laplace and Fourier transformations 11 Time correlation functions
CONDENSED CONTENTS OF VOLUME II 1 Adsorption at the solid-gas interface 1.1 Selected review of Volume 1 1.2 Characterization of solid surfaces 1.3 Thermodynamics of adsorption 1.4 Presentation of adsorption data 1.5 Adsorption on non-porous, homogeneous surfaces 1.6 Porous surfaces 1.7 Surface heterogeneity 1.8 Conclusion 1.9 General references 2 Adsorption from solution. Low molecular mass, uncharged molecules 2.1 Basic features 2.2 The interface between solids and pure liquids 2.3 The surface excess isotherm 2.4 Adsorption from binary fluid mixtures. Theory 2.5 Experimental techniques 2.6 Binary systems, a few illustrations 2.7 Adsorption from dilute solutions 2.8 Kinetics of adsorption 2.9 Conclusions and applications 2.10 General references 3 £lectric Double Layers 3.1 Some examples of double layers 3.2 Why do ionic double layers form? 3.3 Some definitions, sjmibols and general features 3.4 Thermodynamics. Application of the Gibbs equation 3.5 The diffuse part of the double layer 3.6 Beyond Poisson-Boltzmann. The Stem picture 3.7 Measuring double layer properties 3.8 Points of zero charge and isoelectric points 3.9 Interfacial polarization and the ;|f-potential 3.10 Case studies 3.11 Double layers in media of low polarity 3.12 Electrosorption 3.13 Charged particles in external fields 3.14 Applications 3.15 General references 4 Blectrokinetics and Related Phenomena 4.1 Basic principles 4.2 Survey of electrokinetic phenomena. Definitions of terms 4.3 Elementary theory 4.4 Interpretation of electrokinetic potenticds 4.5 Experimental techniques 4.6 Generalized theory of electrokinetic phenomena. Application to electrophoresis and experimental verification 4.7 Electrokinetics in plugs and capillaries 4.8 Electrokinetics in alternating fields. Dielectric dispersion 4.9 Less familiar types of electrokinetics 4.10 Applications 4.11 General References
1.1 1.7 1.19 1.36 1.42 1.81 1.102 1.109 1.111 2.1 2.5 2.19 2.28 2.46 2.57 2.64 2.83 2.86 2.89 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.11 3.17 3.44 3.84 3.101 3.118 3.127 3.186 3.188 3.206 3.220 3.225 4.2 4.4 4.8 4.37 4.44 4.64 4.104 4.111 4.122 4.126 4.133
XV i
5 Adsorption of Polymers and Polyelectrolytes 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Polymers in solution 5.3 Some general aspects of polymer adsorption 5.4 Polymer adsorption theories 5.5 The Self-Consistent-Field model of Scheutjens and Fleer 5.6 Experimental methods 5.7 Theoretical and experimental results for uncharged poljmiers 5.8 Theoretical and experimental results for polyelectrolytes 5.9 Applications 5.10 General references Appendices 1. Survey of adsorption isotherms and two-dimensional equations of state for homogeneous, nonporous surfaces. 2 Hyperbolic functions 3 Pristine points of zero charge
5.1 5.3 5.17 5.28 5.36 5.57 5.67 5.84 5.96 5.98
xvii
Contents planned for Volume IV Introduction to colloid science Characterization, size distributions Preparations lyophobic colloids, suspensions DLVO part of stability, application to thin films, particulate systems Coagulation kinetics Phase formation Rheology Contents planned for Volume V Poljnners £ind their effects on colloid stability Polyelectrolytes and their effects on colloid stability Proteins (colloidal aspects) Association colloids (including micro-emulsions, vesicles, bilayers) Emulsions, foams Porous systems, membranes
xviii This Page Intentionally Left Blank
SYMBOL LIST
xix
LIST OF FREgUENTLT USED SYMBOLS (Volumes I, II and W) S)mibols representing physical quantities are printed in italics. Thermodynamic functions: capital for macroscopic quantities, small for molecular or subsystem quantities (example: U = total energy, u = pair energy between molecules). Supers;cripts standard pressure t standard in genercd o * pure substance; complex conjugate interfacial (excess) a E excess, X (real) - X (idccd) in solid, liquid or gaseous state S,L,G 1 normal to surface parallel to surface // Subscripts m molar (sometimes molecular) a aread (per unit area) g per unit mass Reciurent special symbols 0( 1020) of the order of lO^o AX X(final) -X(initial). Subscript attached to A to denote type of process: ads (adsorption, diss (dissociation), hydr (hydration), mix (mixing), r (reaction), sol (dissolution), solv (solvation), subl (sublimation), trs (transfer), vap (vaporization, evaporation) Some mathematical signs and operators Vectors bold face. Example: F for force, but F^ for z-component of force Tensors bold face with tilde ( ) complex quantities bear a circumflex ( ), the corresponding conjugate is * IXI absolute value of x (x) averaged value of x Fourier or Laplace trsmsform of x (sometimes this bar is omitted) For vectorial signs and operators (V, V^, grad, rot, and x), see I.appendix 7.
XX
SYMBOL LIST
Latin a
activity (mol m-^) mean activity of an electrolyte (mol m*^) attraction parameter in Van der Waals equation of state (N m"^) two-dimensional attraction parameter in Van der Waals equation of state (N m^) radius (m) radius of gyration (m) Eirea per molecule (m^) area (m^) specific area (m^ kg"^) Hamaker constant (J) Hamaker constant for interaction of materials i and J across material k (J) volume correction parameter in Van der Waads equation of state (m^) magnetic induction (T = V nr^ s)
a+ a a^ a ag a^ A Ag A A y(y b B, B BgCT) B^ (T)
c c c C C^ C* C C^ C^ C^ Cp Cy C^
first
C^ Ca d d^^ d^ d^"
second virial coefficient (m^ mol"^ or m^ molecule" M interfacial second virial coefficient (m^ mol-^ m^ molecule"^
or-) velocity of electromagnetic radiation in a vacuum (m s"^) concentration (usually mol m"^, sometimes kg m"^) principal curvature (m"^) (differential) electric capacitance (C V-^ or, if per unit area, C m-2 V-i) (differential) electric capacitance of diffuse double layer (C m-2 V-i) (differential) electric capacitance of Stem layer (C m~^ V"^) BET-transformed (-) bending moment (N) second bending moment (J) (time-) correlation function of x (dim. x^] molar heat capacity at constant pressure (J K"^ mol~^) molair heat capacity at constant volume (J K~^ mol"^) interfacial excess molar heat capacity at constant airea per unit area (J K"^ m"^ mol"^) interfacial excess molar heat capacity at constaint interfacial tension per unit area (J K"^ m-^ mol"^) capillary number (-) layer thickness (m) electrokinetic thickness (m) hydrodynamic thickness (m) ellipsometric thickness (m)
SYMBOL LIST d®^
xxi
steric tJiickness (polymeric adsorbates) (m) diffusion coefficient (m^ s"^) D^ surface diffusion coefficient (m^ s"^) Dj. rotational diffusion coefficient (s"^) Dg self-diffusion coefficient (m^ s-^) D, D dielectric displacement (C m"^) De Deborah number (-) Du Dukhin number (-) e elementciry charge (C) E, E electric field strength (V m-^) Ejj^ irradiance (J m-^ s"^ = W m-^) E^^^ sedimentation potential (V m"^) E^^ streaming potential (V m^ N"^) / friction coefficient (kg s"^) / activity coefficient (mol fraction scale) (-) /y Mayer function for interaction between particles i and j (-) F Fciraday constant (C mol"M F Helmholtz energy (J) ^ i ' ^mi partial moleir Helmholtz energy (J mol~^) Fjjj molar Helmholtz energy (J mol~^) F^ interfacial (excess) Helmholtz energy (J) pa po^^ interfacial (excess) Helmholtz energy per unit area (J m-^) F, F force (N) g(r) radial distribution function (-) g^^^ hth order distribution function (-) g(q, t) time correlation function, if real (light scattering usage) (dimensions as C^^) g standard acceleration of free fall (m s"^) G Gibbs energy (J) ^ i' ^mi partial molar Gibbs energy (J mol"^) G^ molgir Gibbs energy (J mol"^) G^ interfacial (excess) Gibbs energy (J) G^, G^/A interfacial (excess) Gibbs energy per unit area (J m-2) G{z) segment weighting factor in polymer adsorption theory (-) G(z, s) endpoint distribution in a segment of s segments (polymer adsorption (-) h Planck's constant (J s) n h/2n (J s) h (shortest) distance between colloidal particles or macrobodies (m) h height (m) h(r) total correlation function (-) D
xxii
SYMBOL LIST
H
enthalpy (J) H^, H^
partial molar enthalpy (J mol"^)
H^
molar enthalpy (J mol"^)
H^
interfaclal (excess) enthalpy (J)
H^, H^/A
interfaclal (excess) enthalpy per unit area (J m-^)
H H
magnetic field strength (C m-i s"^)
H(p,q)
Hamiltonian (J)
i
intensity of radiation (V^ m~2) ii
incident intensity (V^ m"^)
IQ
i n t e n s i t y i n a v a c u u m (V^ m~2)
ig
s c a t t e r e d i n t e n s i t y (V^ m"^)
i
unit vector in x-direction (-) (not in chapter L7)
I^^^
streaming current (C m^ N"^ s"^)
/
ionic strength (mol m"^)
/
radiant intensity (J s"^ sr -^ = W sr -^)
IJCD)
spectral density of x (dim. x^ s)
j
. unit vector in y-direction (-) (not in chapter L7)
jj
(electric) current density (A m'^ = C nr^ s"^) j ^ , J^
J, J
flux
surface current density (C m-^ s"^) (mol m"2 s"^ or kg m"^ s"^)
J^
surface flux (mol m'^ s~^ or kg m"^ s"^)
J°
interfaclal compliance (mN"^)
J
first, or mean, curvature (m~i)
k
Boltzmann's constant (J K"^)
k
rate constant (dimensions depend on order of process)
fcj
bending modulus (J)
k
saddle splay modulus (J)
fc
unit vector in y-direction (-) (not in chapter L7)
k,
wave vector (m-^)
!?C
Optical constant (m^ kg"^ or m^ moH)
K(R)
optical constant (V^ C-2 m"^)
K(o))
absorption index (-)
K
chemical equilibrium constant (general) K K^
K
on pressure basis (-) on concentration basis (-) (integral) electric capacitance (C V-^ or C m-^ V-^)
K^
(integral) electric capacitance of diffuse layer (C m-^ V"^)
K^
(integrcd) electric capacitance of S t e m layer (C m-^ V-^)
K pj
Henry constant (m)
Kj
distribution (partition) coefficient (-)
KL
Langmuir constant (m^ mol"^)
SYMBOL LIST K
xxiii
conductivity (S mr^ = C V-^ nr^ s'^) surface conductivity (S = C V-^ s'^) interfacial dilational modulus (N m - ^ contour length (polymers) (m) cross coefficients in irreversible thermodjniamics (varying dimensions) bond length in a polymer chain (m) m a s s (kg) (relative) molecular m a s s (-) (M)^, M ibid., m a s s average (-) {M)^, M^ ibid.. Z-average (-) (M)^, M ibid., n u m b e r average (-) refractive index (-) n u m b e r of moles (- or moles) n^ n u m b e r (excess) of moles in interface (- or moles) unit vector in x-, y- or z-direction (-) (chapter L7 only) number of segments in a polymer chain number of molecules (-) N^y Avogadro constant (mol"^) Ng number of sites (-) bound fraction (of polymers) (-) pressure (N m"^) Ap capillcuy pressure (N m-^) stiffness (persistence) parameter (poljnners) (-) dipole moment (C m)
K"" K^ L Ljj^ ^ m M
n n n^yz N N
p p p p, p
^ind' ^ind p, p P P, P Pe q q(isost) q q q q q, q Q Q(N,V,T) Q^^ ^
Induced dipole moment (C m) {= mv) momentum (J m"^ s) probability (-) polarization (C m'^) Peclet number (-) heat exchanged (incl. sign) (J) isosteric heat of adsorption (J) generalized parameter indicating place coordinates in Hamiltonian subsystem canonical partition function (-) electric charge (on ions) (C) persistence length (polymers) (m) scattering vector (m-^) electric charge (on colloids, macrobodies) (C) canonical partition function (-) electro-osmotic volume flow per unit field strength (m^^ V"^ s"^)
xxiv Q J r r
SYMBOL LIST
electro-osmotic volume flow per unit current (m^ C"^) distance (m) fg Bjerrum length (m) r number of segments in a polymer (-) R gas constant (J K'^ mol'^) R (principal) radius of curvature (m) R Poynting vector (W m-^) Rg Rayleigh ratio (m'M Re Reynolds number (-) S entropy (J K'^) ^ V '^mi partial molar entropy (J K"^ mol'^) Sj„ molar entropy (J K"^ mol'^) S^ interfacial (excess) entropy (J K"^) S^, S^/A interfacial (excess) entropy per unit area (J K'^ m'^) S(q, R, Q) spectral density as a function oio)^- o\ = Q (V^ m'^ s) Slq, c) structure factor (-) S (s) ordering parameter of s (-) t time (s) t trainsport (or transference) number (-) T temperature (K) Ta Taylor number (-) u (internal) energy per subsystem (J) u (electric) mobility (m^ V-^ s'^) U (internal) energy, general (J) U ^, Uj^j partial molar energy (J mol"^) U^ molar energy (J mol"^) U^ interfacial (excess) energy (J) U^, U^/A interfacial (excess) energy per unit airea (J m-^) V excluded volume parameter (polymers) (= 1-2;)^) V, V velocity (m s"^) V electrophoretic velocity (m s'^) V electro-osmotic velocity (m s"^) V slip velocity (m s"M V volume (m^) Vp V^^ partial molar volume (m^ mol"^) V^ molar volume (m^ mol'M w work (incl. sign) (J) w interaction parameter in regular mixture theory (J mol-^) w interaction energy between pair of molecules or segments (landJ) (J) X mol fraction (-)
SYMBOL LIST X X. X y y z z z Z lN,p,T) Z^ Greek a a a a, a j3j2 /3 J3D /^K /^L P P 7 y Y y r 5 6A: 5(x) A AX "A^X "A^0 "AV "AVdiff e £ £ ^
xxv distance from surface generalized force in irreversible thermodynamics (varying units) activity coefficient (molar scale) (-) dimensionless potential {Fy//RT] (-) coordination number (-) distance from surface (m) valency (-) isobaric-isothermal pairtition function (-) configuration integral for N particles (-)
real potential (V) degree of dissociation (-) contact angle (-) polailzabmty (C V-i m^ = C^ J-^ m2) twice binsiry cluster integral (-) V a n d e r W a a l s c o n s t a n t (molecular) (J m"^); Debye-Van der W a a l s c o n s t a n t (molecular) (J m"^) Keesom-Van d e r W a a l s c o n s t a n t (molecular) (J m"^) London-Van d e r W a a l s c o n s t a n t (molecular) (J m"^) E s i n - M a r k o v coefficient (-) d a m p i n g coefficient (m"^) interfacial or surface tension (N m"^ or J m"^) activity coefficient (molal scale) (-) shccir s t r a i n (-) rate of s h e a r (s"^) surface (excess) c o n c e n t r a t i o n (mol m"^) diffusion layer thickness (m) small variation of x (dim. x) Dirac delta function of x (dim. x'M displacement (m) X (final) - X(initial) X(phase p) - X ( p h a s e a) (Galvani) potential difference (V) (Volta) potential difference (V) liquid Junction potential (V) relative dielectric permittivity (dielectric constant) (-) dielectric permittivity of vacuum (C^ N-^ m-^ or C m"^ V-^) porosity (-) electrokinetic potential (V)
xxvi
SYMBOL LIST
6
surface coverage = F/F (saturated monolayer) (-)
9
angle, aingle of rotation, loss angle (-)
K
reciprocal Debye length (m"^)
K
capillary length (m)
E
grand (c£inonical) partition function (-)
A
wavelength (m)
A
charging parameter (-)
A
ionic (or molar) conductivity (C V"^ m^ s~^ mol"i = S m^ mol"^)
A
molar conductivity (S m^ mol"^)
A
thermal wavelength (m)
A
penetration depth of evanescent waves (m)
A/Q
magnetic permeability in v a c u u m (V m"^ C"^ s^)
ju
magnetic dipole moment (C m^ s~^)
ju
chemical potential (J mol"^ or J molecule'^)
jj.
kinematic viscosity (m^ s'^)
rj
dynamic viscosity (N s m~2) T]^
interfacial s h e a r viscosity (N m~^ s)
r]^
interfacial dilational viscosity (N m"^ s)
V
frequency (s"^ = Hz)
^
coupling pcirameter (Kirkwood) (-)
^
grand (canonical) partition function of subsystem (-)
n
surface pressure (N m"^ or J m"^)
77
osmotic pressure (N m"^)
n(h)
disjoining pressure (N m"^)
p
density (kg m"^) p^
n u m b e r density [N/V) (m"^)
p
space charge density (C m-^)
a
distance of closest approach for h a r d spheres (m)
a
surface density of b r u s h e r (m-^)
G, (T°
surface charge density (C m"^) o;
contribution of ionic species i to surface charge (C m~^)
G^
surface charge density diffuse layer (C m"^)
a^
surface charge density S t e m layer (C m"^)
G^
s t a n d a r d deviation of X (dim. x)
T
characteristic time (s)
T
interfacial stress (N m~^)
r
line tension (N)
T
turbidity (m'M
T
stress tensor (N m"^) T^
interfacial stress tensor (N m"^)
SYMBOL LIST T^y T^ Tj. 0 (p 0 X X , (p XiX^^) Xe X^ Xl^^ If/ CO 0)^ (0^ (o Q D Q £2 £2^ £2^ Q(N, V, U)
xxvii flux
of x - m o m e n t u m in y-direction (kg m"^ s"^) = s h e a r s t r e s s (N m"2), one of the nine components of the stress t e n s o r rotational correlation time (s) rotational relaxation time (reorientation time) (s) osmotic coefficient (-) volume fraction (-) p h a s e (-) excess interaction energy p a r a m e t e r (-) critical values of x a n d (p a t p h a s e separation interfacial potential J u m p (between p h a s e s p a n d a) (V) electric susceptibility (-) adsorption energy p a r a m e t e r (-) critical value of x^ at the adsorption/desorption point electric potential (V) angular frequency (rad s"^ or s"M a n g u l a r frequency of incident radiation (rad s"^ or s"^) a n g u l a r frequency of scattered radiation (rad s"^ or s"^) degeneracy of subsystem (-) degeneracy of a system or n u m b e r of realizations (-) 0)^- (o^ (rad s"^ or s"^) solid angle (sr) g r a n d potential (J) interfacial (excess) g r a n d potential (J) interfacial (excess) grand potential p e r u n i t area (J m-^) n u m b e r of realizations = microcanonical pgirtition function (-)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1 Interfacial tension: measurement 1.1 General introduction to capillarity and the measurement of interfacial tensions 1.2 On the mathematics of curvature 1.3 Capillary rise 1.3a Vertical cylinder 1.3b Vertical plate 1.3c Other geometries 1.4 Shapes of drops and bubbles on surfaces 1.5 Free drops in a density gradient or electric field 1.6 Drop weight method 1.7 Maximum bubble pressure 1.8 Force required to hold objects at an interface or to pull them through it 1.8a Wilhelmy plate 1.8b DuNoiiyring 1.8c Other geometries 1.9 Spinning drops and bubbles 1.10 Surface light scattering 1.11 Miscellaneous other static methods 1.12 A case study: the surface tension of water 1.12a Room temperature 1.12b FromO°- lOOX 1.13 Measuring the surface tension of solids 1.14 Surface tensions under dynamic conditions 1.14a Pure liquids 1.14b Solutions 1.14c A note on the pristine state of LG and LL surfaces 1.15 Bending moduli 1.16 Applications 1.17 General References 1.17a lUPAC recommendations 1.17b Tabulations 1.17c Capillarity, shapes of fluid bodies etc. 1.17d Measuring interfacial and surface tensions
1.1 1.2 1.7 1.12 1.12 1.21 1.23 1.24 1.31 1.33 1.36 1.39 1.39 1.45 1.48 1.49 1.53 1.56 1.58 1.58 1.59 1.65 1.67 1.68 1.70 1.76 1.77 1.82 1.84 1.84 1.85 1.85 1.86
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
This Volume deals with various aspects of surface tensions and interfacial tensions. Together with the phenomenon of adsorption (enrichment of molecules at interfaces), these tensions constitute the basic characteristics of interfaces. The concept of surface tension is a very old one. Reportedly, Leonardo da Vinci had already observed and recorded the spontaneous rise of liquids in narrow, wetted capillaries, bores and plugs^^. From this rising the phenomenon acquired its name: capillus (lat.) = hair: the bores should be as narrow as a hair. Nowadays the term capiRary phenomena is used more widely (in this book also) to indicate not only capillary rise, involving curved interfaces, but also all phenomena determined by the tendency of interfaces to adopt a minimum area, such as drop shapes, bubble shapes, liquid bridges and wetting. An important historic development was the insight that surface tension is a surface- aind not a bulk-property. Newton^^ had already discriminated between cohesive and adhesive forces. A decisive discriminative experiment was carried out by Hawksbee^^ He investigated liquid rise in capillaries and between glass plates and found that the thickness of the glass did not matter. So the phenomenon of wetting was established as a surface phenomenon, although the depth of the interactions responsible for the various tensions still remains an issue today (chapter 2). In chapter I.l we introduced the notions of surface and interfacial tensions phenomenologically. Volume II mainly dealt with interfaces of solids. For such systems, the adsorption of molecules and ions is the primary phenomenon. Interfacial tensions Ccinnot generally be measured, although interfacial pressures are obtainable from adsorption isotherms using Gibbs' law. As a logical sequel, in this third Volume of FICS, liquid-fluid (LG or LL) interfaces will be treated. For such systems the interfacial tension y is the primary, and measurable, variable. Often the areas involved are so small that the analytical determination of adsorbed amounts (F' s) is difficult. In those cases Gibbs' law can be used to relate interfacial tension to the adsorption, provided adsorbate and 1) A footnote by C. Wolf, Pogg. Ann. 101 (1857) 551 refers to this. ^^ I. Newton, Optiks, for instance 3rd ed., 31st Query. Wand J. Innys, St. Paul's London (1721). ^^ F. Hawksbee, Physico-mechanical Experiments, Lx)ndon (1709) 139.
1.2
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
solution are in equilibrium with each other. For systems with large LG or LL areas, like foams a n d emulsions, adsorbed a m o u n t s are often more easily m e a s u r e d , b u t then it m u s t be realized t h a t the surface excesses are to a large extent determined by t h e history of t h e s a m p l e s , a n d therefore not necessarily representative of t h e adsorption equilibrium in systems with low a r e a s . Foams a n d emulsions will be dealt with in Volume V. In line with the systematics of FIGS, it is logical to s t a r t with the m e a s u r e m e n t of interfacial tensions. This will be done in t h e p r e s e n t c h a p t e r , e m p h a s i z i n g p u r e liquids. A selection of r e s u l t s will be t a b u l a t e d in Appendix 1. This chapter is followed by one on interpretations, two on
fluid-fluid
interfaces carrying adsorbates, a n d finally the Volume will be r o u n d e d off with a discussion of t h r e e - p h a s e contacts, i.e. with wetting p h e n o m e n a . In view of the scope of FIGS, results u n d e r ambient conditions of temperature a n d p r e s s u r e will be emphasized. Regarding the t e r m s interface and surface, we follow the convention adopted in Volume I. 'Interface' is the general term; the word surface' is restricted to p h a s e b o u n d a r i e s in which one of the p h a s e s is gaseous, or to indicate specifically t h e o u t m o s t p a r t of a condensed p h a s e u n d e r consideration ('the surface of a n oil droplet in a n oil-in-water emulsion'). In the literature this distinction is n o t always so systematically maintained. In other places the symbol for interfacial or surface tension is a or / . We prefer the latter because a is widely used for surface charge density, a n d the two do occur simultaneously in some equations. Much background information about the notion of interfacial tension, its thermodynamical a n d statistical interpretation a n d a n u m b e r of other a s p e c t s have already been dealt with in Volumes I a n d II ^^ We start by briefly reviewing these. 1.1 General i n t r o d u c t i o n t o capillarity and t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of interfacial t e n s i o n s For the m e a s u r e m e n t of interfacial tensions no molecular models are needed. It is e n o u g h to know t h a t the interfacial tension is a m e a s u r e of the tendency of all a r e a s to become a s small a s possible. Following chapter 1.2, this contractile action c a n be interpreted thermodynamically or mechanically. Thermodynamically,
the interfacial tension is interpreted a s the increase in the
Helmholtz or Gibbs energy of the system w h e n the area of the interface u n d e r consideration is increased reversibly by a n infinitesimal a m o u n t d A at c o n s t a n t t e m p e r a t u r e a n d composition, a n d at constant volume or c o n s t a n t p r e s s u r e , respectively. We can express this a s
^' Where expedient, some results of this discussion will briefly be repeated. When reference is made to equations, sections or chapters of Volumes I or II, these will be indicated by I or II, respectively; references not preceded by a roman number refer to the present Volume (III).
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT y = OF/aA)^^ „
1.3
y = (aG/aAl^^ „
w h e r e n is a n abbreviation for the set of a m o u n t s n^, n^
I l . l a , b) t h a t define t h e
composition of the system. The dimensions of / are [energy/area]; we shadl express them in m J m~^. As F a n d G are in principle measurable, so is 7 . Mechanically,
the interfacial tension is the contractive force per u n i t length,
acting in t h e interface a n d parallel to it. The dimensions are [force/length], a n d o u r u s u a l u n i t is mN m"^ = m J m"^*^ Interfacial t e n s i o n s a r e m e c h a n i c a l l y m e a s u r a b l e a s the forces required to enlarge a n interface by a n infinitesimal a m o u n t . For isotropic interfaces this force is the same in each direction. At equilibrium the thermodynamical a n d mechanical interpretations s h o u l d b e equivalent. In sec. 1.2.3, in connection with fig. 1.2.1, this equivalence w a s a d d r e s s e d a n d found to be achieved provided the extension of the area is done reversibly, t h a t is, at low Deborah n u m b e r (De «
1). Only u n d e r this condition h a s
the interface enough time to come to equilibrium, t h a t is, to achieve full relaxation of all a d s o r p t i o n equilibria. The v a l u e s of 7 obtained in t h i s way a r e t h e equilibrium values 7(eq.), i.e. those tabulated in reference books. When we w a n t to distinguish t h e s e from the non-equilibrium, or dynamic, interfacial tensions, we call t h e m t h e static interfacial tension. Under non-equilibrium conditions t h e mechanical interpretation r e m a i n s valid, b u t the thermodynamical one becomes ill-defined. This b r i n g s u p the question of how this s c h e m e h a s to be modified w h e n equilibrium is not attained. The answer is t h a t the identity of thermodynamical a n d mechanical m e a s u r e m e n t persists, b u t t h a t the value obtained for y
differs
from 7 (eq.); in fact, often 7 (non-eq.) > 7 (eq.). Suppose a given interface is created very rapidly a n d t h e n s t a r t s to relax with a time scale r. At a n y time t
and G{p,T, n] to become minimal at equilibrium (sec. 1.2.12). When only
relaxation of the interface takes place, 7 m u s t decrease. However, when the bulk p h a s e s also relax slowly or w h e n the relaxation is determined by adsorptiondesorption processes, 7 may also increase. For instance, this would be observed if
*' The obsolete units dyne cm"^ = erg cm"^ are still found in the literature, especially in physics. The conversions are: 1 dyne = 10"^ N, 1 erg = 10"^ J; 1 dyne cm"^ = 1 mN m"^; 1 erg cm"^ = 1 mJ m~^.
1.4
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
the a r e a of a n interface, containing a (slowly) desorbing adsorbate, is s u d d e n l y reduced. T e n s i o n s of non-relaxed interfaces are sometimes k n o w n by t h e adjective 'dynamic'; dynamic
surface tension or dynamic
interfacial tension. The term 'dyn-
amic' is not absolute. It depends on De (i.e. on the time scale of the m e a s u r e m e n t a s compaired with t h a t of the relaxation process). Some interfacial processes have a long relaxation time (polymer adsorption-desorption), so t h a t for certain p u r p o s e s (say t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of y) they may be considered a s being in a state of frozen equilibrium. This last notion w a s introduced at the end of sec. 1.2.3. Unless otherwise stated, we shall consider static tensions a n d interfaces which are so weakly curved t h a t curvature energies, bending moments, etc. may be neglected. The t h e r m o d y n a m i c a l a n d mechanical interpretations of interfacial t e n s i o n s point to two ways of measurement: either the reversible work or the force required to extend a n interface should be determined. In practice it is often easier to balance the interfacial force against others, say against gravity. In general, t h e results c a n be interpreted in t e r m s of t h e capillanj
pressure
Ap created by t h e interfacial
tension a c r o s s curved interfaces. From sec. 1.2.23 we know t h a t t h e required relation is given by the Young-Laplace 1
Ap= y V
1 -I-
—
equation [1.2.23.191
1
11.1.2]
— 2 7
where R^ a n d JF^ are the principal radii of curvature, defined in sec. 1.2.23a. See also sec. 1.2. The pressure is higher on the concave (hollow) side. Capillary pressures are zero for flat interfaces (R^ = R^ = oo] a n d for t h e special c a s e of saddle-type curvatures, where R^= - R^, The reciprocals Cj = Rj"^ a n d Cg = i^2^ are known a s the principal curvatures.
The Young-Laplace equation can therefore also be written
as A p = y{c^+c^)
11.1.3)1)
We also introduced the first, or mean, curvature of a n interface a s j = Ci + C2 =Ri^
+^2^
[1.1.41
and the second, or Gauss curvature through K = c^c^ = ( R i R 2 ) ' ^
ll-l-^l
1^ In addition to capillcuy pressure', Ap is also referred to as the Laplace pressure. We shall follow this use for the sake of convenience, although Young-Laplace pressure would be more appropriate.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.5
These definitions recur in the treatment of capillanj phenomena, a term that we shall use generally for all features of spatially curved interfaces. For the definition of curvatures and their mathematical treatment, see sec. 1.2. Forces resulting from [1.1.2] are called capillary forces. Anticipating later sections, it is noted that for curved interfaces at equilibrium and in the absence of gravity, Ap is the same everywhere, hence so is the first curvature. In the presence of gravity, this is no longer the case. In the present chapter only macroscopic interfaces will be discussed (i.e. those having areas that are large in comparison with molecular dimensions). This is in line with treating interfacial tensions phenomenologically. Such tensions can be unambiguously obtained experimentally. In other words, they are thermodynamically defined and functions of state, as set forth in sec. 1.2.14c. In the literature the notion of interfacial tension is sometimes used on a molecular scale, say for water around the aliphatic chain of a surfactant. Such tensions cannot be measured and are therefore thermodynamically undefined; nor can they be evaluated without making major assumptions, for instance by equating this 'molecular' tension to the (thermodynamically operational) macroscopic interfacial tension of a paraffin-water interface, either with or without correction terms. Models for computing interfacial tensions on the basis of molecular models will be discussed in chapter 2. Obviously, such analyses can also be carried out for very strongly curved interfaces, but the results can never be experimentally verified. Similarly, interfacial tensions of solid-liquid interfaces [y^^] or of solid surfaces [y^] cannot be measured either, because there is no practical way of extending a solid surface reversibly without stretching or cleaving (sec. 1.2.24). Nevertheless, y^ and y^^ are thermodynamically defined because in principle the Gibbs or Helmholtz energies of stretching and cleaving can be accounted for. Therefore y^ and y^^ are functions of state, a feature that we have already used several times, for instance in cross-differentiations involving the total differential d/^^ in sec. II.3.4. Some experimental approaches for obtaining approximate values for y^ and y^^ will be discussed in sec. 1.13. For determining interfacial tensions, it is expedient to anticipate chapter 5 and to recall the notion of contact angle, introduced in sec. 1.1.3. Consider the situation of fig. 1.1. The contact angle a is the angle under which the liquid L meets the surface S. Instead of the gas phase G, one might meet a situation where the second fluid is also a liquid. The extent of partial wetting of the solid by the liquid is quantified by the value of a: the better the wetting, the lower is a. Examples of poorly wetting systems are mercury on glass and water on hydrophobic surfaces, where one can see little liquid drops that may roll over the surface. At the opposite extreme, complete wetting occurs when the liquid fully covers the solid. In that case
1.6
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
S Figure 1.1. Contact angle for a sessile drop on a flat horizontal surface. the liquid spreads spontaneously over the surface, and no contact angle can be defined. For the present purpose the force balance determining a under equilibrium conditions is relevant. In fig. 1.1 the three interfacial tensions acting on the threephase junction are drawn as arrows, indicating the strength and direction of the contractile actions of the respective interfaces. Alternatively, the equilibrium can be approached thermodynamically by minimizing the Gibbs energies of the three interfaces for a drop of given volume. Consider the horizontal component of the force balance. We can immediately see that y S G ^ ^ L G ^ Q g ^ ^ ySL
[ j ^ g]
or ySG_ ySL
COS a = ^
TTA-
[1.1.7]
This is known as the Young equation. We shall return to its derivation, intricacies and naming in sec. 5.2, but note in passing that the vertical component y^^ sin a is compensated by the tensile strength of the solid. Contact angles are measurable and in a number of methods such measurements run in conjunction with those of interfacial tensions. It follows that 11.1.7] cannot be used to establish the interfacial tension of a solid, although the difference y^^ - y^^ is experimentally measurable. The introduction of contact angles gives rise to another interfacial characteristic, the line tension. This is the contractile tension acting in the three-phase contact perimeter around drops as in fig. 1.1, and may phenomenologically be considered the one-dimensional analogue of the interfacial tension with SI units of N or J m"^ As it is a typical three-phase characteristic, we shall not treat it here, but in sec. 5.6. Interfacial tensions are routinely measured by a variety of methods, and for some of them, commercial instruments are available. For high-quality measure-
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.7
ments great care is required with respect to the chemistry' of the system. One of the dilemmas is that even traces of surface-active impurities can lower the tension. Such impurities may originate from the surfaces of the glassware or from the surrounding atmosphere. The problem then arises that the slow accumulation of such impurities causes the tension to decrease slowly with time, whereas often longer term measurements are wanted to ensure (adsorption) equilibration of substances that are intentioncdly present. No general rules can be given, except for pure liquids, for which the rule of thumb is 'the highest measured tension is the best'. Although the value of the interfacial tension itself is a good measure of the purity of an interface, in many cases the variation of this tension upon rapid area changes may be an even more sensitive criterion. The reason is that inadvertent surface-active impurities, even if present in minute amounts, may give rise to Marangoni effects (sec. 1.6.4 ad. (4)). These show up upon expansion or compression of the interface and give rise to certain interfacial rheological phenomena^). Typically, absence of such impurities implies that the measured interfacial tension does not depend on the rate at which the interface is expanded. Other studies may be aimed at the dynamics itself. For instance, the rate of adsorption of surfactants, as reflected in the rate of decrease of the interfaciad tension, is an important pgirameter, affecting rates of wetting, foaming and other processes of great technological relevance. Some interfacial tension measurement techniques are essentially static, i.e. they operate at low Deborah number (De « 1): capillary rise, shapes of sessile and pendant drops. Others (drop weight amd detachment techniques) require extension of the interface. Then the procedure is static or dynamic depending on the rate of extension relative to the rate of adsorption equilibration, i.e. on De. To be systematic, we shall treat static measurements first, followed by dynamic ones in sec. 1.14. Interfacial rheology will be considered in chapters 3 and 4. 1.2 On the mathematics of curvature The treatment of capillary phenomena usually requires the mathematical analysis of curved fluid-fluid interfaces. As a preliminary to this chapter and to chapter 5, we shall now repeat and extend pairts of sec. 1.2.23a, where this matter was introduced. The description of curvature is a prerequisite for applying the Young-Laplace equation [1.1.2]. The simplest spatially curved shapes are of course those of spheres and
^^ For further reading about criteria for the pristine state of interfaces, see sec. 1.14c and K.J. Mysels, A.T. Florence, in Clean Surfaces: Their Preparations and Characterization for Interfacial Studies, G. Goldfinger, Ed., Marcel Dekker (1970) 227; J. Colloid Interface Set 43 (1973) 577; R. Miller, K. Lunkenheimer, Colloid Polym. Set 264 (1986) 273; K. Lunkenheimer, R. Miller. J. Colloid Interface Set 120 (1987) 176.
1.8
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
cylinders. Spherical s h a p e s are found in isolated drops in emulsions, air-bubbles, micelles a n d vesicles; cylindrical s h a p e s in certain pores a n d cylindrical micelles. However, in m a n y capillary p h e n o m e n a t h e s h a p e s a r e more complicated, although axial symmetry is often conserved. Once a n analytical equation for the s h a p e is available the principal radii of curvature, R^ and R^ in [1.1.2], a n d hence the capillary pressure, can be obtained. Let u s briefly recall the notion of 'principal radius of curvature' (fig. 1.2.14). The curvature of a curve in a plane at each point P can be defined by the r a d i u s of a tangent circle at a n d a r o u n d P. This r a d i u s is the radius of curvature, t w o - d i m e n s i o n a l c a s e it is identical to t h e principal
radius
a n d in this
of curvature,
R.
Mathematically, the curvature is defined a s R
ds d0
[1.2.1]
where d s is a n infinitesimal part of the curve a n d d0 the angle of the supporting circular segment (see fig. 1.2), t h a t is the angle between the tangents to the curve a t points Pj and P^, determining d s . In the limiting case, where P^ a n d P^ approach each other, to merge into the point P where the curvature h a s to be established, 0 occurs in the triangle P^^^^ taiKJ)
dz_ dx
with [1.2.2]
For a spatially curved interface, two radii are needed (and are sufficient) to describe the s h a p e at any point. If at point P these radii are required, the normsd to the interface a t P is drawn a n d a plane constructed through the interface, containing the normal. An infinite n u m b e r of s u c h planes can be made, each intersecting the interface at P, a n d for each a radius of curvature r^ can be found. Constructing a second plane now, normal to the former a n d to the surface, a second r a d i u s of curvature, r^, in P is obtained. These two radii completely define the curvature at P.
Figure 1.2. Meaning of symbols in the derivation of an analytical expression for the radius of curvature for a curve in a plane.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.9
It can be shown that r~^ + r^ Ms a constant, independent of the choice of the pair of planes. An infinite set of such pairs of radii is possible, so this is not a useful means of description. For standardization purposes the first plane is rotated around the normal till the radius of curvature in that plane has a minimum, i.e. till the strongest curvature has been met. The other radius then has a maximum. The two radii, obtained in this way are the principal radii of curvature, R^, R^ and the corresponding curvatures c^ = ^l^ ^^'^ ^^ = K"^ are the principal curvatures. The capillary pressure [1.1.2] is a physical quantity and therefore independent of the actual choice of the two radii. At a particular location on a surface, the sum of the reciprocals of all pairs of radii is invariant. However, for practical purposes we shall only work with the principal radii, R and R^. Often we shall draw R^ in the plane of the paper and R^ normal to it. Furthermore, in Cartesian co-ordinates the directions x and y define a horizontal plane and z is the verticcd. As an introduction to a generad description of spatial curvature, let us first discuss some simple geometries. First consider a sphere with radius a. Its equation in Cartesian co-ordinates is x2 + /
^ z^ = a^
11.2.3J
Because of axial symmetry around the z-axis, the profile is fully determined by the cross-section in the z, x plane, for which x2+ z^ = a^
[1.2.4]
The two radii of curvature are both equal to a, hence Ap = 2y/a. As 2AdA: = 2zdz = 0, the slope is given by ^ =- ax z
(x,z
[1.2.5]
For a cylinder of radius a, one radius is equal to a, as before, the other is infinite. Now Ap = y/a. For an ellipsoid with axes a, b and c the equation is X^
L/2
z2
^ + -TT + ^ = 0 a"^ b^ c^
[1.2.6]
In this case R^ and R^ depend in each point on two out of the three lengths a, b and c. General analytical formulas are available for R and R^ and hence for Ap. For a surface of revolution with arbitrary shape, z is only a function of x. Drawing the plane containing R^ and the z-axis in the plane of the paper, the curvature is given by the following formula of analytical geometry:
1.10
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
d^z/dx^
c, =
^
^1
dz/dx d;
213/2
[l + (dz/dx)2]
[l + [dz/dxY
1/2
[1.2.7]
We have met this equation before, see [1.2.23.7]. In the plane normal to the paper, see [1.2.23.6], 1
dz/dx
^2
x[l + (dz/dxf]^
[1.2.8]
/2
Equation [1.2.7] can be derived as follows. In the triangle "^^^2^ ^^ ^^^' ^''^' ^^^^^ ^ (dx)^ -f [dzf or
ds = dx
dx = d
.d.^^T^^ dxj
rdz_ dx
dx(l + tan^2 0)AU2
dtan(/> =
V - = (1 + tan^0)d0 = U +
[1.2.9]
fdz^ dx
dz
which may be combined with [1.2.9] to obtain [1.2.7]. The other expressions can be derived in a similar way. It is readily verified that for a sphere both c^ and c^ reduce to a"^ Using [1.2.7 and 8] analytical expressions for J and K, defined in [1.1.4 and 5], are immediately found. For the capillary pressure [1.1.2 or 3] across a surface of revolution
Ap = y\
d^z/dx^ [l + (dz/dx)2f^'
dz/dx x[l + (dz/dx)2f^'
[1.2.10]
When the interfacial profile is not axisymmetric, the equations for c^ and c^ contain partial derivatives: [dz/dx], (dz/dy), [d'^z/dxBy] and [d^z/dy^]. General formulas for J and K for this case are available, see [1.2.23.2 and 3]. Curvatures can also be expressed trigonometrically. Consider fig. 1.3, where a cross-section through an axisymmetric profile is given. The example concerns a sessile drop, but the reasoning is general; it also applies to pendent drops, to menisci in capillaries, etc. The radius R^ is in the plane of the paper. By way of example, its value in a given point A is given. Radius ^2 indicates the curvature normal to the paper. At any arbitrary point B a plane BDC can be drawn. Its normal BC is in the plane of drawing and equal to R . Because of the axial symmetry, such a plane is the same for any azimuthal angle. The angle between R^ and the z-axis is 0. This angle, and the position where the normal intersects the zaxis varies with the position of B on the contour. As sin 0 = BD/BC = x/R^.
1.11
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Figure 1.3. Goniometric interpretation of radii of curvature. R^ is measured in the plane of drawing, R perpendicular to it.
sin
'^ = R:
[1.2.11]
At point B, RJ is in the plane of the paper and I
d
'^=R
sin ^ _ d cos 0 dx dz
[1.2.12]
In Volume I we also gave the alternative, see [1.2.23.7], c^ = sin 0 =
d^z dx'
[1.2.13]
We repeat t h a t all these c's are positive if the radii are on the concave side of the meniscus, a s in fig. 1.3; otherwise a m i n u s sign is needed. The trigonometric expressions for J and K are J =
K =
sin 0 X
d sin 0 = —— (x sin 0) = sin 0 dx xdx
sin 0
d sin 0
— + s m 0 —TjX ^ dx^
sin^ 0 d^z
dx
[1.2.14]
[1.2.15]
dx'
The area is. from [1.2.23.8],
A = 2nj
zdx sm
and the capillary pressure is, from [1.1.3, 4 and 1.2.14],
[1.2.16]
1.12
Ap = 7
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT dsin0 dx
sin0 X
1 . 2 ' sin 0 — + sm X
= 1-1-
(x sin
X dx
dx''
[1.2.17]
A third way of describing curvature is vectorially. When in fig. 1.2 P^ approaches Pg the two radii CPj and CPg will merge into the resultant CP. This line may be given vectorial character, in that the direction indicates the tangent, and the length is a measure of the curvature. For concave surfaces the vector points the other way. We shall not use this formalism. For further reading on capillarity and the mathematical description of curvature, see the references in sec. 1.17c. 1.3 Capillary rise As there is no clear hierarchy of measuring methods with respect to increasing complexity, the sequence of treating the various procedures is a matter of choice. We will start with capillary rise methods because this phenomenon has been known since ancient times. We already introduced it at the beginning of FICS I.l, using as an example the ability of plant roots to find water above the ground water table. Capillary rise techniques are some of the best methods for measuring surface tensions; they provide a bridge to wetting studies and their analysis anticipates that of other techniques of / measurement. When an object is partly immersed in a wetting liquid, a concave meniscus is spontaneously formed where solid and liquid meet. The resulting negative capillary pressure Ap may be interpreted as the upward force on the liquid. The rise continues until Ap is just balanced by the gravity pressure. So, the surface tension can in principle be obtained from the curvature of the meniscus, the capillary rise, the density difference between the two fluids and the gravitational constant. Similar reasoning can be applied to capillary depression, the situation encountered for non-wetted objects. 1.3a Vertical cylinder For both cases, idealized situations are sketched in fig. 1.4. In the left case it is assumed that the meniscus is hemispherical. The contact angle of the liquid with respect to the inner side of the capillary is zero on the left hand side; in the right hand case a = 180°. At equilibrium Ap is equal to the hydrostatic pressure drop of the column over the flat reference surface, Ap^fh (or p^gh = pgh if the density of the vapour phase is neglected). The precise meaning of h has to be considered later because the meniscus is not flat. For the spherical meniscus i^^ = ^2 = a, if a is the inner radius of the capillary, hence
1.13
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
(a)
(b)
^j
r "" 1 kzj L
J
—
.
:h
'
Figure 1.4. Capillary rise (a) £ind depression (b). Elementary situations, with semi-spherical menisci. The surface tensions are different between cases (a) and (b). [1.3.11
Ap = 2 7 / a
Recall from sec. 1.2.23b t h a t t h e p r e s s u r e is lower on t h e convex side of t h e meniscus; hence in case b, R and R
are negative a n d so is A p . Equating t h e two
pressures, h =
2y/pga
[1.3.2]
so t h a t from the height the surface tension can be obtained. For capillary rise h a n d a a r e positive, for capillary depression they a r e negative. The interfacial tension between two liquids c£in be obtained aifter replacing the gas by the second liquid a n d Ap now represents the density difference between the two liquids. In e q u a t i o n s like t h i s t h e quotient y/pg
or y/Apg
often occurs. It h a s t h e
dimensions of area. For t h a t reason it is often convenient to introduce the capillary length ^ = ir/pg)
xl/2
or
K- =
1/2
[y/Apg)
[1.3.3a, b]l'2)
The capillary length is a materiad property. In table 1.1 some typical examples are given, from which it a p p e a r s t h a t K is 0(mm), t h a t is, of the s a m e order of ^^ Some authors define the capillary length as {2y/pg)^^^. '^^ Confusion with K~^ , a measure of the thickness of a diffuse double layer is unlikely; the latter is lower by a factor of 10^-10^ (table 1.5.2).
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.14
m a g n i t u d e a s the sizes of menisci or droplets usually encountered in capillarity. The quotient y/h^p^g
= K^/b^ where b represents this size, is dimensionless a n d is
a m e a s u r e of t h e ratio between the capillary force (a surface force) a n d t h e hydrostatic force (a body force). Depending on the liquid, in droplets smaller t h a n a m m the former dominates, a s is illustrated by the well-known tendency of spilled mercury droplets to a s s u m e a spherical shape. The quotient pgcL^
[1.3.3c]
E6
where a is the capillairy radius, is the dimensionless ratio between hydrostatic a n d surface forces. It is sometimes called the Eotvos number. Some a u t h o r s prefer this expression with a factor of 2 in the denominator. Of course the Eotvos n u m b e r c a n also be used for other systems, say spheres or plates at a n interface, where a is the radius or a^ h a s to be replaced by the cross-sectional area of the plate, respectively. Table 1.1. Capillary lengths of some liquids with respect to vacuum; Ap = p ^ , ^ = 9.807 m s"2. Surface tensions from appendix 1. Liquid
T/K
/ / mN m ^
p^/kg m-^
K/mm
argon
88
12.34
1,400
0.95
carbon tetrachloride
293
27.04
1,595
1.31
ethanol
298
21.97
785
1.69
997
2.72
13,546
1.91
water
298
mercury
298
72.14 485.5
With the capillary length defined in this way t h e capillary rise c a n also b e written a s [1.3.4]
h = 2K^/a
volume Ka^/3
Figure 1.5. Excess volume above the lowest point of meniscus.
1.15
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
A mechanical way of deriving [1.3.2] starts from the balance of forces. The u p w a r d force is the surface tension of the liquid j u s t below the contact with the cylinder. There, the driving force is vertical a n d equal to 27ca/. The downward force of t h e liquid column is pgna^h.
Equating these two immediately gives [1.3.2].
A first refinement of the method is to account for the volume of liquid above the lowest part of the meniscus, see fig. 1.5. This additional volume equals the volume of a cylinder segment of length a, [na^], (271 a ^ / 3 ) , i.e. na^/3. h = 2y/pga
-
m i n u s the volume of half a s p h e r e
With this correction [1.3.2] becomes [1.3.5]
a/3
where h is now the height of the lowest point of the meniscus: this is t h e quantity t h a t is usually m e a s u r e d . In order to see how Icirge this volume correction is, we write y explicitly pgcL
[1.3.6]
3 indicating t h a t it depends on the ratio of a and h, as expected.
Figure 1.6. Spherical meniscus with finite contact angle in capillary.
The next step is to relax the premise t h a t the inner wall is fully wetted by the liquid. Let t h e c o n t a c t angle b e a , see fig. 1.6. Then, cos a
= a/R,
hence
Ap = (2y cos a]/a, so that h =
2/cos a pga
[1.3.7]
Mechanically, this equation can be derived by recognizing t h a t the u p w a r d component of the surface tension j u s t below the contact point is / cos a. In this case t h e correction for the volume above the m i n i m u m of the m e n i s c u s is a bit more complicated a n d a m o u n t s to 7c[^(R 2 7ca^[l/(cosa)
g tan a^^
^2x3/2
a^r
R(R^-a^)l
or goniometrically.
^- (1 - sin a] /(cos^ a)]. The correction is smaller t h a n in the
case of complete wetting, to which these expressions reduce for R = a, or a = n /2, respectively.
1.16
INTERFACLAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
In t h e m o s t general case, the contact angle is not zero a n d t h e profile n o t s p h e r i c a l . T h e n a t e a c h position x in t h e horizontal direction, Ap a n d t h e hydrostatic p r e s s u r e have a different value, so the curvature is no longer the s a m e everywhere a s it is for interfaces in the absence of gravity (sec. 1.2), although the s h a p e r e m a i n s fully determined by y a n d cos a. The balance of forces is now, using [1.2.17], y d / \ yj = Apgz Ap = -i (x sin 0) X dx a n d the profile of the meniscus obeys K z(x) =
d V 7 ;— (x Sin 0) = — X dx Apg
[1.3.8]
d (x sin
[1.3.9]
dx
For the meaning of z and 0, see fig. 1.7. It is historically interesting t h a t t h e linearity between t h e m e a n r a d i u s of c u r v a t u r e a n d the elevation, embodied by [1.3.8], w a s already known to Young^^ Lopez de R a m o s et al.^^ u s e d this feature to develop a n alternative procedure of obtaining the surface tension from the curvature of a pendent drop, which we will come to in sec. 1.4. Not only is t h e profile fully determined by / and cos a, so too is the weight w of the liquid column t h a t is drawn u p above the zero level by the capillary p r e s s u r e . To verify this, consider a n a n n u l a r liquid ring of infinitesimal t h i c k n e s s d x a t distance x from the axis. Its weight is 2nxdxzApg
. The total weight is found by
integration over x from 0 ^ a:
\
h
a
// 11 / 1 / 1 / 1
y^
/« ' 1
|<
>
1
1
1d x
Figure 1.7. Computation of the weight of the risen column for an arbitrary meniscus shape.
1) T. Young, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London, 95 (1805) 65. 2) A. Lopez de Ramos, R.A. Redner and R.L. Cerro, Langmuir 9 (1993) 3691.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
w = 2KApg J xzdx
1.17
[1.3.10]
0
which is easily solved after substitution of [1.3.9] and realizing that for x = a sin (/> = cos a. The result is w = 2Kaycosa
[1.3.11]
which confirms the mechanical interpretation of capillary rise: the upward force is /cosOf multiplied by the perimeter 2na, and independent of shape. Otherwise stated, the shape is not an independent parameter; once y, cos a and Ap are given, the shape is also fixed. For interpretational reasons this is a rewarding result, but not for determining interfacial tensions, because in practice it is not the weight of the column that is measured but rather the profile: no analyticcd solution of [1.3.8] for, say h in the lowest point of the meniscus, is available. Hence, numerical solutions are required. For axisymmetrical interfaces, as in cylindrical capillaries, pendent and sessile drops, this is often achieved by introducing the radius of curvature b at the apex or lowest point as the measure of the meniscus size, anticipated in table 1.1. At that point R^ = K = b, hence J = 2/b and at the top Ap = 2y/b. If z is now measured with respect to that apex (positive or negative, depending on the case under consideration), the pressure at any z can be given as 7 J = Apgz + 2y/b
[1.3.12]
For J = c^+ c^ one may substitute the sum of [1.2.7 and 8] or one of the expressions [1.2.14]. One way in which this equation is often rewritten involves the introduction of a dimensionless parameter
with which [1.3.12] and [1.2.11] converts into the, also dimensionless, expression
^
sin^^£z^2 x/b b
11.3.141
The parameter p is positive for oblate figures of revolution (for instance, a sessile drop or a meniscus in a capillary) but negative for prolate ones, like a pendent drop. In the absence of gravity /3 = 0 and the profile is spherical. Equation [1.3.14] is deceptively simple, but it must be realized that c^ and sin0/x = c^ (see [1.2.11]) are given by [1.2.7 and 8]; hence [1.3.14] is a second order differential equation. Only for very narrow capillaries (b/K —> 0) and complete wetting does it reduce to c^+c^=2/b, the Laplace pressure for a spherical
1.18
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
m e n i s c u s of r a d i u s b. In all other s i t u a t i o n s n u m e r i c a l analysis is required. Basically, t h e profile is m e a s u r e d , u s u a l l y by some optical t e c h n i q u e , a n d compared with the numerical d a t a to obtain y (and cos a ) for which t h e fit is maximized. The archetype numerical tabulations of x(z) profiles date back to Bashforth a n d Adams (almost to 1853^^). These tables were used for more t h a n a century, either in their original form or after modification, until their significance w a n e d with the advent of m o d e r n c o m p u t e r s . The tables do not only apply to liquid menisci in capillaries, b u t also to cross-sections of sessile drops, pendent drops, etc. They also contain s u c h information a s the diameters and heights of sessile drops a n d contact angles. They give x / b and zib a s a function of 0 for various closely-spaced ^ values. Their a p p l i c a t i o n r e q u i r e s successive a p p r o x i m a t i o n b e c a u s e /J c a n only be established if y is known. A starting value of y could, for instance, be obtained from one of the simpler equations, say from [1.3.2 or 6]. Several a u t h o r s have extended Bashforth a n d Adams' tables or rendered t h e m more useful. One of the earliest was Sugden-^^ who dealt with the problems t h a t b is sometimes difficult to m e a s u r e accurately a n d t h a t the tables do not extend into the region of t u b e s t h a t are so small t h a t b -^ a. He gave tables relating r/h to V/K a n d p a r t s of t h e s e tables have been reproduced by Adamson a n d Padday*^^. The Sugden tables are convenient for obtaining the capillary length from the r a d i u s of the t u b e a n d t h e capillary rise. Later elaborations have been provided by Padday a n d Pitt'*^ who compared different t a b u l a t i o n s a n d Lane^^ who gave a c c u r a t e polynomial r e p r e s e n t a t i o n s of t h e profile. Erikson^^ p u b l i s h e d
computer-
calculated a r e a s . See further the references in sees. 1.17c a n d d. Some of t h e s e contain useful tables. In practice, the capillary rise method was (and p e r h a p s still is) one of the best a n d most precise m e t h o d s , b e c a u s e the experimental variables c a n be well controlled. In order to g u a r a n t e e visibility of the meniscus, the capillaries are invariably m a d e of glass. One of the best situations for m e a s u r i n g is t h a t of complete wetting. To t h a t end the inner side of the capillary should be meticulously clean a n d it is advisable to m e a s u r e the receding contact angle by first sucking the liquid m e n i s c u s higher into the capillary a n d t h e n letting it sink to its equilibrium position. Care should be t a k e n that, if the surface tension of solutions is to be m e a s u r e d , the solute does not react with, or adsorb on the glass, so changing the ^^ F. Bashforth, J.C. Adams, see the reference in sec. 1.17c. 2) S.Sugden, J. Chem. Soc. 119 (1921) 1483. ^^ See the references in sees. 1.17c cind 17d, respectively. Note that their a equals our K-V2. 4) J.F. Padday, A. Pitt, J. Colloid Interface Set 38 (1972) 323. ^^ J.E. Lane, J. Colloid Interface Set 42 (1973) 145. 6) T.A. Erikson, J. Phys. Chem, 6 9 (1965) 1809.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.19
contact angle. This may, for example, h a p p e n with catlonic surfactants t h a t could r e n d e r glass hydrophobic, or in the Lippmann electrometer (see below) u s e d to m e a s u r e the interfacial tension of mercury in solutions of sodium fluoride; t h i s solute is often studied because it exhibits no specific adsorption in the double layer, b u t it reacts with glass a n d may give rise to erosion^^. The capillary should have a circular cross-section. Its internal diameter can be obtsiined optically or by filling it, or p a r t s of it, with mercury and weighing. In situations where m e a s u r e m e n t of the height suffices, high-grade, vibration-free cathetometers should be used. Otherwise the full meniscus profile h a s to be measured, usually optically. Harkins a n d Brown^) have summarized a n u m b e r of precautions which need to be taken to optimize the performance of this method. These recommendations are old, b u t not obsolete a n d some have already been mentioned above. Another one involves the proper establishment of the zero-level (the horizontal liquid surface in fig. 1.4). To e n s u r e horizontality, the vessel with liquid should be large enough a n d t h e implication is t h a t the method requires relatively large a m o u n t s of liquid. Harkins a n d Brown suggested locating the exact position of the level by observing the reflection of a needle j u s t above the fluid. Measurement of the rise with respect to a horizontal reference level can be avoided by placing two capillaries of different r a d i u s next to each other, a n d determining the height differenced^ capillary
[differential
rise method). For instance, in the very simple case t h a t [1.3.1] is a
r e a s o n a b l e approximation
2K-^
P9
1 V 1
1
[1.3.15]
2J
Variations to improve accuracy, facilitate handling, or r e n d e r t h e m e t h o d applicable to special s y s t e m s have been proposed. For i n s t a n c e , Richards a n d Carver^) developed a capfllary with a reflush device (a wider tube, parallel to the vertical capillary) to facilitate rejuvenation of the liquid surface. This a p p a r a t u s w a s modified by Young a n d Gross^^. R a m a k r i s h n a n a n d Hartland^^ developed a p r o c e d u r e of m e a s u r i n g surface t e n s i o n s in t h e a n n u l a r ring b e t w e e n two concentric cylinders. This approach w a s duplicated by Agrawal a n d Menon^^. Long ago Sentis^^ experimented with a n isolated capillary on the lower end of which a 1^ A. de Battisti, R. Amadelli and S. Trasatti, J. Colloid Interface Set 6 3 (1978) 61. 2) W.D. Harkins, F.E. Brown. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 41 (1919) 499. ^^ N. Pilchikov. Zhur. Fiz. Khim, Obshch. Sen Fiz. 2 0 (1888) 65; S. Hartland, S. Ramakrishnan, Commun. Jom. Com. Esp. Deterg. 12th (1981) 419. 4) T.W. Richards. E.K. Carver. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 4 3 (1921) 827. ^^ Mentioned by W.D. Harkins. in Physical Methods of Organic Chemistry 1. 2nd ed. A. Weissberger. Ed., Interscience (1927) p. 367. ^J S. Ramakrishnan, S. Hartland, J. Colloid Interface Set 80 (1981) 497. "^^ D.C. Agrawal. V.J. Menon, Am. J. Phys. 52 (1984) 472. ^^ M.H. Sentis, J. Phys. Theor. Appl Ser. 2, 6 (1887) 571; Ser. 3. 6 (1897) 183.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.20
hanging drop appeared (see sec. 1.4), so he virtually combined two techniques. Prigorodovl) modified this idea by working with a capillary t h a t w a s thin at t h e top a n d thick a t its lower end. The advantage over differential m e t h o d s is t h a t m u c h less liquid is needed. This brings to mind the familiar feature of the small a m o u n t of fluid remaining in a pipette after emptying (fig. 1.8). This left-over h a s a negligible influence on the accuracy of the dispensed a m o u n t s of liquid because it is constant a n d determined by the balance between the two Laplace pressures, the contact angle(s) a n d gravity. Even if the pipette is t u r n e d upside down (fig. 1.8a,c) the upward pull of the top m e n i s c u s against the concerted action of the downward pull of the lower m e n i s c u s a n d gravity k e e p s the liquid in the tip. Heller et al.^) have used this principle to develop a method for determining surface tensions. The method is suitable for very small a m o u n t s of liquid, b u t requires elaborate calibration if absolute values of the surface tension are required.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 1.8 A tiny plug of liquid in the conical tip of a pipette. For p r a c t i c a l r e a s o n s t h e capillary rise t e c h n i q u e is rarely u s e d for t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of interfacial (rather t h a n surface) tensions; large a m o u n t s of the two liquids are needed a n d there are suitable a n d convenient alternatives. An exception to this is the m e a s u r e m e n t of the interfacial tension between m e r c u r y a n d (mostly) a q u e o u s solutions at various potential differences applied across the liquid-liquid interface. S u c h m e a s u r e m e n t s are done in a so-called capillary
electrometer,
Lippmann
already described in the chapter on electric double layers
(fig. II.3.47). Capillary rise is very high if the capillary is well-wetted and narrow. In a wetted capillary with a n internal r a d i u s of 0.1 or 0.01 mm, water a s c e n d s a b o u t 15 cm or 1.5 m, respectively. This not only a c c o u n t s for the possibility of plant growth far above the g r o u n d water table, it also indicates why the method is so sensitive; u n d e r favourable conditions surface tensions can be m e a s u r e d down to ± 0 . 0 5 mN m"^ Most of the surface tensions reported in the appendix have been obtained
1) V.N. Prigorodov, Koll Zhur. 3 3 (1971) 168 (transl. 139). 2) W. Heller. M-H. Cheng and B.W. Greene, J. Colloid Interface Set 22 (1966) 179-194.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.21
by this technique^^. 1.3b
Vertical
plate
Consider a flat plate of length £ a n d width b(i
» b), immersed in the liquid to
be measured, a s sketched in fig. 1.9a. The geometry is now simple b e c a u s e in fig. 1.9b only t h e r a d i u s of curvature in the plane of the paper h a s to be considered^^ This sweeping s t a t e m e n t n e e d s clarification b e c a u s e it implies t h a t no end corrections are required. The problem h a s attracted m u c h discussion in the literature a n d h a s led to confusion. Whether there are s u c h things a s edge effects depends on the observations m a d e a n d on the deductions drawn from them. According to [1.1.3], at equilibrium t h e s u m Cj + c^ m u s t be the same everywhere. Let c refer to the curvature perpendicular to the plate. In the centre of the large flat part of the plate it is the only one;
(a)
b)
Figure 1.9. Capillary rise on a flat plate. Top: general view, bottom: meniscus details.
^^ We shall not give illustrations for each individual technique but shall later make a comparison (sec. 1.12). '^^ For a detailed mathematical treatment of such profiles see e.g. J.E. McNutt, C M . Andes, J. Chem, Phys. 30 (1959) 1300.
1.22
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
this is the c u r v a t u r e considered in fig. 1.9b. Near the e n d s of the plates the curvature c^, normal to the former, also plays a role. The result is t h a t near the end, h tends to decrease. If the end-effect is interpreted a s this downward trend, we speak of a real effect, t h a t h a s been observed by a variety of investigators. However, this end-effect h a s no consequences
for the capillary force exerted on
the plate. In this respect there is no end-effect in the measurement; adding 'correction terms' to [1.3.20] is wrong. Laplace^^ recognized this long ago a n d demons t r a t e d t h a t t h e a m o u n t of liquid, risen above t h e equilibrium level, m u s t be c o n s t a n t per u n i t length of t h e projection of the perimeter of t h e object on t h e equilibrium surface plane. The risen liquid at the edges h a s to come from a larger surface area t h a n in the central p a r t s of the plates, so there the capillary rise is lower. This also explains why the capillary rise outside thin t h r e a d s is so m u c h smaller t h a n against flat p l a t e s ^ l Laplace himself elaborated this principle for the capillary rise inside a capillary of non-circular cross-section a n d stated explicitly t h a t it remained valid for polygons. More recently, Loos^' extended this work to the o u t s i d e of cylinders a n d s y s t e m s with other geometries. This work h a s a t t r a c t e d little a t t e n t i o n , p e r h a p s b e c a u s e it w a s written in D u t c h , b u t t h e relevance is n o t easily overestimated; certainly it applies to t h e
often-used
Wilhelmy plate (sec. 1.8a). Let u s now consider the rise sdong the long sides of the plates. At any point on the m e n i s c u s the Laplace pressure is bcdanced by gravity pressure. For the former we have, according to [1.1.3] a n d [1.2.12], / d c o s ^ / d z , w h e r e t h e angle 0 is indicated
in fig. 1.9b, a n d for the latter Apgz, where z is counted with respect to
the horizontal level. Integration is straightforward: d c o s ^ / d z c a n be written a s - sin0d(/> (d>/dz); the integration boundaries are z = 0, cos(/> = 1 a n d z = h, c o s 0 = sin a if a is the contact angle. The result is i-Ap^fh^ = y d - s i n a)
[1.3.16]
or 2 ( 1 - s i n a)
[1.3.17]
In t e r m s of t h e capillairy length A/2
h = ^^
(1-sina)
[1.3.18]
K
For the simple case of complete wetting ^^ See his Mecanique Celeste, Supplement au Livre X (1806) 440; or Oeuvres completes de Laplace, quatrieme tome, 2nd Supplement au Livre X, 439 ff, Gauthiers-Villars, Paris (1880). 2^ D.F. James, J. Fluid Mech. 6 3 (1974) 657. 3) R. Loos, Verhandelingen Koninkl Vlaamse Acad. Klasse Wetensch., XII (1950) 5.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT 7 = iApgh2
1.23 [1.3.191
These equations may be compared with those for cylinders, see for instance [1.3.2]. For flat plates one does not have to worry about complications of the details of the profile, but this advantage is offset by the much lower rise. Typically, h is of order K~^ , i.e. h = O (mm) and y is proportional to h^ whereas it scales with ah in capillaries. Over the last few decades laser-opticsd techniques for scanning the meniscus and establishing h down to about 10"^ mm have become available l'^'^'"^^. In a modem variant of the Wilhelmy plate technique, to be described in sec. 1.8a, the force needed to pull the plate out of the liquid is measured as a function of the height above the zero level. In this way the surface tension and contact angle can be determined simultaneously. Alternatively, the method can be used to obtain contact angles, i.e. from [1.3.16] after / has been measured by some other technique. The weight of the liquid pulled up along the plate, or rather the capillary force, can be obtained in a way similar to the derivation of [ 1.3.11]; the result can also be written down immediately ii;(plate) = 2U + b)y cos a
[1.3.20]
The factor 2 accounts for the two menisci, on both sides of the plate. Studying capillary rise at vertical plates in electrolyte solutions is important for a number of interfacial electrochemistry issues, such as electroplating and electrocapillarity. 1.3c Other geometries Capillarity equations have been elaborated for a variety of other geometries, but not always with the prime goal of measuring surface tensions. Often the attention is focussed on the force that keeps objects connected to a liquid if they are pulled out. The liquid bridge that, in the case of wetted materials, keeps object and fluid together is characterized by a concave meniscus, i.e. by an attractive Laplace pressure. Such studies are relevant for the interpretation of some adhesion problems. One other illustration is shown in fig. 1.10. Two vertical, wetted glass plates are placed in the liquid. The rod creates a separation, increasing proportionally with £ from left to right. To a first approximation, at any position the capillary rise is proportional to the gap width, b and hence to i, but in practice it seems more like that shown in the figure. This has to do with the change of the meniscus IJ I. Morcos, J. Chenh Phys. 55 (1971) 4125. 2) K. Rodel, P. Friese and G.-R. Wessler, Z. Phys. Chem. (Leipzig) 254 (1973) 289. ^^ K. Rodel, K. Lunkenhelmer, Tenside Deterg. 15 (1978) 135. ^^ S. Lahooti, O.I. del Rio, A.W. Neumcinn and P. Cheng, Axisymmetric Drop Shape Analysis (ADSA), ch. 10 in the book edited by Neumcinn and Spelt, mentioned in sec. 1.17c.
1.24
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Figure 1.10. Capillary rise in a wedge. profile. To the left, where this profile approaches sphericity, h-- b, j u s t a s h ~ a for capillaries, [1.3.4], b u t to the right, where the two plates are further a p a r t t h a n a few times the capillary length, h is given rather by [1.3.18] and is independent of ^. The s e t - u p is suitable for verifying computed h(0
profiles a n d , if theory a n d
experiment m a t c h , the surface tension is obtainable. For narrow wedges W)
is a
hyperbola. However, it is also useful for analyzing h[i) for t h e case t h a t , in addition to the capillary pressure, a disjoining pressure /7(h) acts between the two s u r f a c e s . The m a t h e m a t i c a l generalization of t h i s s y s t e m to a n y m o n o t o n i c function
/7(h) h a s been given by Kagan and Pinczewski^^
P a d d a y et al.^^ analyzed the m e n i s c u s profile for a vertical cylindrical rod, either standing in the fluid, or being moved upward without detachment. From the pull on the rod the surface tension can be obtained. See also ref. ^\ For detailed analyses of s u c h capillary p h e n o m e n a we mostly refer to the references in sec. 1.17c. However, we shall consider a n u m b e r of these in connection with m e t h o d s in which the force is measured either to keep objects in a n interface or to detach them completely (sec. 1.8). 1.4
S h a p e s of drops and bubbles on surfaces'^)
A n u m b e r of systems such as sessile drop, captive bubble, hanging, or pendent drop in which a drop or bubble is kept in position on a surface belong to this category.
1^ M. Kagan, W.V. Pinczewski, J. Colloid Interface Set 180 (1996) 293. 2) J.F. Padday, A.R. Pitt and R.M. Pashley, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 7 1 (1975) 1919. ^^ C.J. Lyons, E. Elbing and I.R. Wilson, J. Colloid Interface Set 162 (1984) 292. ^^ This technique has been pioneered by A.M. Worthington, Phil. Mag. 19 (1885) 46.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.25
The s h a p e s of these drops and bubbles are governed by the competition between the contractile surface tension a n d gravity, j u s t a s in capillary rise p h e n o m e n a . The p r o c e d u r e for obtaining interfacial tension normally c o n s i s t s of t h e following steps: (i) The profile m u s t be mathematically defined a n d elaborated into appropriate tables a n d / o r analytical solutions for certain limiting conditions. (ii) An experimental technique h a s to be developed to m e a s u r e the contours in sufficient detail. This is not a trivial problem: the drop is not a two-dimensional opaque screen b u t a three-dimensional, usually refracting, body. (iii) Theoretical a n d experimental profiles are matched, with / and, sometimes, cos a a s the parameters. Essentially, t h e s e s t e p s are similar to those for capillary rise. For (i) t h e Bashforth-Adams tables a n d their modern v a r i a n t s c a n be u s e d . Regarding (ii) l a s e r - o p t i c a l reflection t e c h n i q u e s c a n n o w a d a y s yield profiles w i t h
great
precision, so t h a t accurate 7 values can be obtained. We shall now discuss some of t h e m a i n features, leaving the n u m e r o u s technical details t o t h e specialized literature, except for noting t h a t m o d e r n image a n a l y s e s a n d a u t o m a t i z a t i o n render steps (i) and (ii) less tedious, if not obviating parts of them.
y///////AV///////////A 7
/ / \ V \V
\ \—
1
X
h
_ .^—• ^ " - "
Figure 1.11. Captive bubble, h is the vertical distance between the equatorial phase and the apex.
An example of a sessile drop was shown in fig. 1.3, together with the definitions of the two radii of curvature R^ a n d jR . The m a t h e m a t i c a l laws governing t h e c u r v a t u r e are general, b u t the geometry may be different for different situations. W h e n t h e surface on which t h e drop is sitting is homogeneous, t h e profile i s axisymmetric, so t h a t t h e cross-section of this profile suffices to describe t h e entire system. In t h e example the contact angle is o b t u s e , b u t t h i s i s n o t a requirement. Some drops do not have a n equator. The s h a p e also d e p e n d s on the volume (or weight) of the drop: very small drops (size <, capillary length) tend to be spherical whereas lairge drops are flattened. Other systems belonging to this category include sessile b u b b l e s a n d h a n g i n g drops a n d bubbles, sketched in figs. 1.11 and 12. For sessile bubbles and drops the mathematics of the curvature is the same as before: the radii of curvature are given by [1.2.7 a n d 8], or by [1.2.11 and 12] and the profile is determined by [1.3.9, 12 or
1.26
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
14). T a b u l a t i o n s of n u m e r i c a l r e s u l t s (Bashforth-Adams a n d i m p r o v e m e n t s or extensions) c a n be found in t h e references of sec. 1.17c a n d t h e s e allow, in principle, determination of the surface tension. As stated before, very small droplets tend to be more spherical t h a n large ones, especially if the capillary length of the liquid is large. The case of very large drops is also relevant a n d allows the simplification t h a t all c u r v a t u r e s n o r m a l to t h e plane of the p a p e r m a y be neglected: in fig. 1.3
^2 "^ °°' S "^ ^ ' ^^ 11-2.10] t h e
second term on the r.h.s. may be dropped, so that the balance of forces reduces to
[1 + (dz/dx)^] or, in t e r m s of the capillary length.
[1 + (dz/dx)' This differential e q u a t i o n c a n be integrated by i n t r o d u c i n g d z / d x a s a n e w variable with t h e result z^ —o" =
2*^
1 rro + const.
[1.4.3]
[1 + (dz/dxf ]^
The integration c o n s t a n t c a n be determined by introducing the distance h between the apex a n d the equatorial plane, if s u c h a plane exists. For the captive bubble this quantity is indicated in fig. 1.11; for the sessile drop it is defined in the s a m e way (the sign of h d e p e n d s on w h e t h e r z is c o u n t e d u p w a r d s or downwards). For I z I = I h I, d z / d x = 00, so 2Y\^IK^ is a constant if z is counted from t h e equatorial plane. Moreover, for z = 0, d z / d x = 0, therefore h = K'V2 , so the result is simple: 7=iAp^h2
(1.4.41
This m e a n s t h a t t h e surface tension is solely determined by the vertical distance between t h e equatorial plane a n d t h e (almost or entirely flat) apex, a n d independent of the contact angle. However, the caveat m u s t be made t h a t in practice, a s R^ i n c r e a s e s , h goes t h r o u g h a m a x i m u m before declining to its limiting value.
Figure 1.12. Large flat drop.
1.27
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Therefore, R^ needs to be quite large for this method to work, a point t h a t is not always appreciated. For a very large flat drop, a s sketched in fig. 1.12, a simple equation c a n b e derived, irrespective of the presence of a n equator. Let the drop be circular with r a d i u s r, a n d let it be placed on a surface of area A. The Helmholtz energy of t h e s y s t e m F c o n s i s t s of t h r e e contributions: (i) t h a t of t h e uncovered surface, y^^(A-nr^);
(ii) t h a t of the weight of the drop. ^Apgh^nr^;
a n d (iii) t h a t of t h e two
t e n s i o n s , on b o t h sides of t h e drop, 7cr^(/^ + 7^^). This Helmholtz energy is minimized with respect to changes in h (i.e. d F / d h = 0) u n d e r the condition t h a t the drop volume remains constant (r^ = c o n s t / h ) . Carrying o u t the differentiation, using [1.1.7] one obtciins ,2
r=
Apgh^ 2(1 - cos a)
[1.4.5]
where h is now the height of the drop, indicated in fig. 1.12. For spreading liquids (cos a -^l) s u c h drops carmot be formed.
b)
a) Figure 1.13. Hanging drop and sessile bubble.
For the hanging or clinging drops of fig. 1.13 a new feature emerges. Consider the situation in (a). If the a m o u n t of fluid in the drop increases, constriction of t h e liquid t a k e s place with R^ changing sign along the contour. Geometric c h a r a c teristics are now the m a x i m u m a n d minimum widths, d and d , respectively. At the apex, point 0 in the figure, the shape m u s t approach t h a t of a sphere. So, there R^=R^=b,i{we
again introduce this reference parameter. At equilibrium,
at any z the equilibrium contour m u s t obey [1.3.12], which for this case becomes
_!_ ^1 ^
_1 ^2J
=-Apgz
+
27
[1.4.6]
1.28
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Figure 1.14. Sessile drop, separated from the supporting plate by a thin disjoining film. with, a s before, R~^ given by [1.2.7 or 12] and K'^ by [1.2.8 or 11]. In the BashforthAdams tables numerical results are also given for this system. The variables are again x/b and z/b and the parameters 0 and p, with 0 as indicated in fig. 1.11 a n d /3 given by [1.3.13]. An interesting a p p r o a c h for obviating the contact angle problem h a s b e e n proposed by Padday and Pitt ^ I The method can be applied for drops sepeirated from the surface by a t h i n liquid film, a s sketched in fig. 1.14. Depending on t h e densities of the two fluids, it can be used for surfaces a n d interfaces, in the sessile or captive mode. The a u t h o r s showed t h a t for this situation Y = ^Apgh''
[1.4.7]
where h is indicated in the figure. The procedure works well for small droplets or bubbles, particularly for lower tensions ( - - 0 . 1 - 1 mN m"^) a n d is more or less the counterpart of t h a t described in fig. 1.12. A variety of operations, alternative m e t h o d s , drop imaging t e c h n i q u e s a n d devices for a u t o m a t i o n have been presented in the literature. We shall give some examples to illustrate the kinds of approaches t h a t have been, a n d are still being considered. An example of a relatively fast procedure, b a s e d on a very limited n u m b e r of m e a s u r e m e n t s w a s given by Lyons et al.-^l They obtained interfacial tensions from the co-ordinates of only two points on the contour, not including the origin, where the choice of t h e s e points is optimized. Another example w a s provided by Couc o u l a s a n d D a w e ^ ^ who c o m p u t e d the interfacial tension from drop height, m a x i m u m r a d i u s a n d contact angle. The latter technique only works with o b t u s e contact angles a n d is then less approximate t h a n t h a t leading to [1.4.4], where only the height a p p e a r s . Prokop et al."^^ developed a procedure along similar lines.
1^ J.F. Padday, A.R. Pitt, Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A329 (1972) 421. 2) C.J. Lyons, E. Elbing and I.R. Wilson. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. II81 (1985) 327. ^^ L.M. Coucoulas, R.A. Dawe, J. Colloid Interface Set 103 (1985) 230. "^^ R.M. Prokop, A. Jyoti. M. Eslamian, A. Garg, M. Mihaila, V.I. del Rio, S.S. Susnar, Z. Policova and A.W. Neumann, Colloids Surf. A131 (1998) 231.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.29
allowing interfacial tensions to be computed from the drop diameter a n d vertical distance to the apex at arbitrary, horizontal planes in the drop. The method works well for contact angles ranging from a b o u t SO'^-ISO'', to give results within 5% for tensions down to 10"^ mN m " ^ Many examples of optical methods for drop image data acquisition a n d processing c a n be provided. For a n older, b u t still readable review relating to p e n d e n t drops, see Ambwani a n d Fort^^. This paper describes principles a n d t e c h n i q u e s . Optimal imaging w a s reviewed by Nikolov a n d Wasan^^. More r e c e n t e x a m p l e s w h i c h deserve mentioning include the pioneering work in N e u m a n n ' s group^^. Other groups also contributed. N e u m a n n calls his method ADSA, for axisymmetric drop s h a p e analysis. The method, with applications, is reviewed in c h a p t e r 10 of the book by N e u m a n n et al., mentioned in sec. 1.17c. One of these applications involves m e a s u r i n g the surface tension response induced by a periodic change in the drop volume'^K Work by Girault et al.^^ on video image processing, designed for automatic digital m e a s u r e m e n t s of co-ordinates w a s extended to obtain ultra-low interfacial tensions, down to the ^Nm"^ range^l This w a s also reported by Kwok et al. (loc. cit. 1995). Similar things have b e e n achieved by Ling a n d H w a n g ^ ^ Thiessen et al.^^ described a robust digital image analysis of p e n d e n t drops. Still other examples of fast a u t o m a t e d techniques of fairly wide application (in some t e c h n i q u e s a PC suffices to complete the analysis) include work by H a n s e n ^ ^ A n a s t a s i a d i s et al.^^^ a n d by Song a n d Springer^ ^^. Faour et al.^^^ described a
^^ D.S. Ambwani, T. Fort, Pendant Drop Technique for Measuring Liquid Boundary Tensions, in Surface and Colloid Set Vol. II, R.J. Good and R.R. Stromberg Eds., Plenum (1979), chapter 3. ^^ A.D. Nikolov, D.T. Wasan, Fluid-Fluid Interfaces: Optical Imaging of Capillary Systems, in The Handbook of Surface Imaging and Visualization, A.T. Hubbard Ed. CRC. Press (1995) chapter 16. ^^ D.Y. Kwok, P. Chiefalo, B. Khorshiddoust, S. Lahooti, M.A. Cabrerizo-Vilchez, O. del Rio and A.W. Neumann, in Surfactants Adsorption and Surface Solubilization, R. Sharma Ed., Am. Chem. Soc. Symp. Series (1995) chapter 24; Y. Rotenberg, L. Boruvka and A.W. Neumann, J. Colloid Interface Set 9 3 (1983) 169; P. Cheng, D. Li, L. Boruvka, Y. Rotenberg and A.W. Neumann, Colloids Surf 4 3 (1990) 151; D.Y. Kwok, W. Hui, R. Lin and A.W. Neumann, Langmuir 11 (1995) 2669. See also J.W. Jennings, N.R. Pallas, Langmuir 4 (1988) 959. ^^ R.M. Prokop, et al., loc cit. S) H.H.J. Girault, D.J. Shiffrin and B.D.V. Smith, J. Electroanal Chem 137 (1982) 207; J. Colloid Interface Set 101 (1984) 257. ^^ J. Satherley, H.H.J. Girault and D.J. Shiffrin, J. Colloid Interface Set 136 (1990) 574. "7^ S-Y. Ling, H-F. Hwang, Langmuir 10 (1994) 4703. ^^ D.B. Thiessen, D.J. Chione, C.B. McCreary and W.B. Krantz, J. Colloid Interface Set 177 (1996) 658. ^^ F.K. Hansen, J. Colloid Interface Set 160 (1993) 209. 1^^ S.H. Anastasiadis, J.K. Chen, J.T. Koberstein, A.F. Siegel, J.E. Sohn and J.A. Emerson, J. Colloid Interface Set 119 (1987) 55. 11^ B. Song, J. Springer, J. Colloid Interface Set 184 (1996) 64. 12) G. Faour, M. Grimaldi, J. Richou and A. Bois, J. Colloid Interface Set 181 (1996) 385).
1.30
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
pendent drop tensiometer in which the interfacial area and the interfacial tension can be controlled. This set-up permits the study of adsorption either at constant area or at constant interfacial tensions and hence allows the investigation of dynamic features under controlled conditions. Pallas and Harrison^^ describe an automated drop shape apparatus capable of operating at very high pressures. One of the variants of the technique involves a pendent drop on a conical tip-^^. The reason for experimenting with this geometry is to reduce drop vibrations, always a source of error if high accuracy is required. Sessile drops and pendent drops on inclined surfaces have been investigated by Nguyen et al.^^ and by Lawal and Brown'^^ respectively. For such systems the drops are no longer axisymmetric. In other cases the technique has been particularly adapted or extended to study special systems or phenomena. Drop shapes of mercury are interesting because they can complement electrocapillary data obtained by the Lippmann electrometer. If so required, a potential difference can be applied across the interface because the mercury-aqueous solution interface is, over a large potential range, polarizable (sec. 1.5.5b). The method was pioneered by Kingery and Humerick^^ and by Smolders^^ but has since been improved^^ Combination with scanning tunnelling microscopy^^ has been used as a technique to study the consequences of vapour-deposited octanethiol. One of the problems that had to be surmounted was that of suppressing, obviating, or rather eliminating the vibrations of the drop. Pendent drops can also be used to study insoluble monolayers. By changing the volume of the drop, the monolayer can be expanded or compressed, so that surface pressure-area curves can be obtained. For an example (dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline at the n-dodecane/water interface) see ^\ We return to such monolayers in chapter 3. Special consideration of the surface tension of polymer melts has been given by Bhatia et al.^^^ using the pendent drop technique with digital image processing. These examples of elaborations and applications are by no means complete but
1) N.R. Pallas, Y. Harrison, Colloids Surf. 4 3 (1990) 169. 2) S.R. Babu, J. Phys. Chem. 90 (1986) 4337. ^^ H.V. Nguyen, S. Padmanabhan, W.J. Desisto and A. Bose, J. Colloid Interface Set 115 (1987) 410. "^^ A. Lawal, R.A. Brown, J. Colloid Interface Set 89 (1982) 332. ^^ W.D. Kingeiy. M. Humerick. J. Phys. Chem. 57 (1953) 359. ^^ C.A. Smolders, Rec. Trav. Chim. 80 (1961) 635. ^^ S. Bordi, M. Carla and R. Cecchini, Electrochim. Acta 34 (1989) 1673. ^^ C. Bruckner-Lea, J. Janata, J. Conroy, A. Pungor and K. Caldwell, LangmuirS (1993) 3612. 9) J. Li, R. Miller, R. Wiistneck, H. Mohwald and A.W. Neumann, Colloids Surf A96 (1995) 295. 1^^ Q.S. Bhatia, J-K. Chen, J.T. Koberstein, J.E. Sohn and J.A. Emerson, J. Colloid Interface Set 106 (1985) 353.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.31
serve to illustrate t h a t n o w a d a y s t h e m e t h o d h a s obtained a high degree of sophistication a n d t h a t tedious m e a s u r i n g p r o c e d u r e s c a n be avoided. U n d e r o p t i m u m conditions interfacial tensions a s low a s 10"-^ mNm"^ c a n be m e a s u r e d . Both surface a n d interfacial tensions can be studied, a n d only small a m o u n t s of liquid are needed. The method is essentially static, although changes with time cam be studied for processes of Deboraih n u m b e r »
1, see [1.2.3. ll^K When problems
occur, t h e s e often stem from the 'chemistry' of the system r a t h e r t h a n from t h e m a t h e m a t i c s or imaging procedure; slow equilibration for highly viscous
fluids,
creeping of dissolved molecules to the solid-liquid interface beyond the drop with c o n c o m i t a n t c h a n g e in contact angle, d e p a r t u r e from axial s y m m e t r y for n o t homogeneously wettable solids a n d slow accumulation of adsorbable impurities at t h e interface. In conclusion, provided
the investigator is c o n s c i o u s of t h e s e
possibilities, the method is very powerful and versatile. 1.5
Free drops in a d e n s i t y gradient or electric field
A v a r i a n t of the drop s h a p e method is t h a t of a free drop in a solution with a density gradient. The droplet will move u p or down till it a t t a i n s a n equilibrium position where the average densities of droplet and suspending medium m a t c h . As Ap^gf now varies over the drop, the s h a p e is no longer spherical b u t b e c o m e s oblately spheroidal with axis of symmetry in t h e direction of t h e gradient. T h e extent of departure from sphericity increases with drop size, with the magnitude of t h e density g r a d i e n t a n d with decreasing interfacial t e n s i o n . L u c a s s e n
has
analysed this system^) a n d h a s demonstrated t h a t the interfacial tension c a n be obtained from the shape. Values as low a s 10"^ mNm"^ are measurable. The advantages of the method are t h a t low interfacial tensions c a n be readily m e a s u r e d a n d t h a t no solid surfaces are needed, t h u s avoiding problems incurred with c o n t a c t a n g l e s a n d their h y s t e r e s i s . The limitations a r e t h a t d e n s i t y gradients require changes in chemical composition, which themselves may lead to interfacial tension gradients, and t h a t only very low tensions c a n be m e a s u r e d , presenting the risk of s p o n t a n e o u s emulsification. Because of t h e s e restrictions, work with this method, interesting a s it may be, h a s not led to a follow-up. When the interface between a free drop and the suspending m e d i u m is polarizable t h e s h a p e of t h e drop c a n be affected by a n electric field. The practical relevance s t e m s from obtaining uniform droplets by electric field t e c h n i q u e s in discharge a n d spray phenomena. Figure 1.15 sketches what h a p p e n s . In this case
1) For instance, G. Faour et al. (J. Colloid Interface Set 181 (1996) 385) developed an automated pendent drop tensiometer allowing 3-5 measurements per second, so dynamic processes slower than that could be studied. 2) J. Lucassen, J. Colloid Interface Set 70 (1979) 355.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.32
the top part of the drop is polarized negatively and drawn towards the anode. The inverse applies to the lower part. The deformation is counteracted by the interfacial tension. For the final shape, if the drop is a fluid metal (£ = <«). it can be shown thatl) a-b
9
a +b
16
^
££ a E o w
[1.5.1]
o
y
where £ is the dielectric constant of the suspending medium, and a^, a and b are indicated in the figure. Semiquantitatively the quotient on the r.h.s. of [1.5.1] can be understood by realizing that the energy of a polarized sphere of polarizability a in an electric field K is given by -^aE^, see [1.4.4.7]; a - 47C£^a^, see [1.4.4.6]. This energy is counteracted by the surface Gibbs energy, = 47ca^y; division yields this quotient. The relative dielectric permitUvity £^ enters because in a medium one needs the product DE instead of E^, where D = e^e^E is the dielectric displacement, defined in [1.4.5.12]. The quotient on the l.h.s. is a measure of the deformation. The pendant of equation [1.5.1] has been experimentally verified by O'Konski and Gunther^) for the case of hanging drops. Moriya et al.^^^ studied the time dependence of the deformation in very viscous fluids. This relaxation can be well represented by multiplying the r.h.s. with a factor [1 - exp(-t/r)] where t is the time and T a characteristic relaxation time, proportional to the sum of the viscosities of droplet and medium. It is recalled that t/r is just the reciprocal Deborah number De -1
Figure 1.15. Change of shape of an isolated, polarizable droplet caused by polarization in an external electric field. The ellipticity is alb. Drawn curve; unperturbed drop, radius a , dashed: after application of the field E.
1) Ch.T. O'Konski, H.C. Thacher, J. Ph^s. Chem. 57 (1953) 955. 2) Ch.T. O'Konski, R.L. Gunther, J. Colloid Interface Set 10 (1955) 563. 3) S. Moriya, K. Adachi and K. Tokata, Langnmir2 (1986) 155.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.33
Equation [1.5.1] h a s been extended by Allan a n d Mason^^ a n d by Torza et al.^^. When the relative permittivity of the droplet e^ is not infinitely high [1.5.1] h a s to be modified to a-b a-^b
9e e a o w
ley
\2
(e^ V d
E^
[1.5.2]
wy
Torza et al. also described the extension to include a.c. fields (one r e a s o n w a s to avoid droplet electrophoresis) a n d presented experimental r e s u l t s . The c o n d u c tivities of droplet a n d m e d i u m t h e n also play their roles. At very high field s t r e n g t h s the droplet may eventually b u r s t . S u c h p h e n o m e n a may have relevance for the electrocomminution of emulsions. Droplet deformation in electric fields allows t h e interfacial t e n s i o n to be determined, b u t obviously suffers from the problem of how to keep the object in position. The modern way of achieving this is by levitation, a t e c h n i q u e which h a s , for instance, been applied to m e a s u r e the surface tension of molten metals^K 1.6
Drop weight m e t h o d
This m e t h o d is b a s e d on determining the weight of a drop t h a t c a n b e k e p t s u s p e n d e d by the contractile action of the surface, or interfacial tension. Figure 1.16 gives a sketch of one of the possible situations. Upon growing, t h e droplet r e m a i n s hanging on the lower end of a capillary until it becomes so heavy t h a t the surface tension can n o longer s u p p o r t its weight. In the m o s t simple case t h e s u p p o r t i n g surface force is j u s t equal to the surface tension times t h e o u t e r circumference of the capillary a n d is vertical at the position of the arrow before the drop b r e a k s away. Then, u;(drop)= 2K ay
[1.6.1]
This very old approximate expression is known a s Tate's law^h The average drop weight can be accurately established either by weighing a known n u m b e r of drops, or by counting the n u m b e r of drops released per u n i t volume. Traditionally this w a s done in a graded cylinder with a narrow inner capillary, displaying a wider part, a n d having the lower orifice constructed in s u c h a way a s to better define the geometry at the m o m e n t of detachment. S u c h a device is called a
stalagmometer.
Nowadays it is more common to u s e micrometer s)^inges to release accurately
1^ R.S. Allan, S.G. Mason, Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A267 (1962) 45. 2) S. Torza, R.G. Cox and S.G. Mason, PhU. Trans. Roy. Soc. (London) 269 (1971) 295. 3) M.E. Fraser, W.K. Lu, A.E. Hamielec and R. Murarka, Metall. Trans. 2 (1971) 817; K. Schaefers, G. Kuppermann, U. Thiedemann, J. Qin and M.G. Frohberg, Int. J. Thermophys. 17 (1996) 1173. 4) After T. Tate, Phil. Mag. 27 (1864) 176.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.34
external G or L p h a s e
Figure 1.16. Drop suspended at the lower end of a capillary. The density of the liquid to be measured is higher than that of the gaseous or liquid phase into which it is released.
liquid to be measured k n o w n volumes of liquid. See for instance^^ The method is simple a n d rapid, it requires no costly a p p a r a t u s a n d can easily be modified for liquids t h a t are less dense t h a n the s u r r o u n d i n g fluid, by measuring the upward flow from the top of a capillary. In a sense, this procedure (detachment of liquid from a material object) is the counterpart of the detachment methods of sec. 1.8 (detachment of a n object from the liquid). However, for precise absolute m e a s u r e m e n t s [1.6.1] is inadequate. When t h e droplet falls down, p a r t of the liquid r e m a i n s on the capillary a n d t h e counteracting surface force is not vertical. The breakaway p h e n o m e n o n is r a t h e r complicated-^^ a n d may r a t h e r look like fig. 1.17. Using high speed cinematography, details of t h e d e t a c h m e n t p h e n o m e n a c a n be seen. As the e x p a n s i o n of t h e interface is a dynamic process, the rate at which the interfacial tension can adjust.
Figure 1.17. Successive stages of the breakaway of a liquid drop from the orifice of a stalagmometer. Details of the process depend on the dynamics of the surface expansion, mechanical vibrations and oscillations. The little additional drop in the last sketch is called a satellite. Sometimes there are more of these.
1^ H.C. Parreira, J. Colloid Set 90 (1965) 44. 2) P. Guye, F.L. Perrot, J. Chim. Phys. Arch. Set Phys. Nat 15 (1903) 178.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.35
relative to t h e rate of droplet formation determines t h e kinetic details. For p u r e liquids t h e time scale of equilibration of a surface is « time scale of d e t a c h m e n t , i.e. De «
1. so during the process y maintains its static value. On t h e other h a n d ,
for s o l u t i o n s of d e t e r g e n t s equilibration m a y t a k e more t h a n
IQ-^-lO"^ s,
d e p e n d i n g on t h e molecular weight of t h e detergent a n d t h e viscosity of t h e solution; t h e n De m a y become of order of u n i t y a n d u p o n e x p a n s i o n of t h e interface, g r a d i e n t s in / m a y be created, resisting further expansion t h r o u g h Marangoni effects (see sec. I.6.4d, ad. (4)). Let u s consider p u r e liquids a n d surfaces of solutions u n d e r low De conditions. Instead of [ 1.6.1] we write u;(drop)= 2narf
[1.6.2]
where / is a correction factor to account for deviations from hemisphericity. After earlier a t t e m p t s by others, Harkins a n d Brown ^^ tackled this problem by computing t h e profile u s i n g w h a t w a s essentially a variant of [1.4.6]. From this, they derived t h e ratio of t h e volume of t h e p a r t of t h e drop t h a t is detached from t h e total volume. (In fig. 1.13 t h e p a r t below d will, u p o n increasing t h e volume, become unstable a n d fall off.) They found t h a t / d e p e n d s on t h e ratio aV~^^^, where V is t h e drop volume a n d tabulated their results. For aV~^^^ -^ 0, / - ^ 1.000, a s expected b u t for higher values of this p a r a m e t e r / m a y become a s low a s 0 . 5 . There are r e a s o n s to try a n d work in the range over which aV~^^^ is between a b o u t 0.6 a n d 1.2, where /
varies m o s t slowly with this p a r a m e t e r , a t least for relative
m e a s u r e m e n t s . Padday^) a n d Harkins a n d Brown checked their results for water a n d benzene, i.e. for surface tensions of about 2 8 a n d 78 mN m"^ (precise values in appendix I). Lando a n d Oakley3) (gee also Strenge"^^) extended t h e Harkins-Brown tables, a n d m a d e t h e m easier to handle. Wilkinson a n d Aronson^^ studied t h e a p plicability of t h e technique to high surface tensions, with mercury a s the example. Hartland a n d Srinivasan^^ discussed t h e various forces determining the s h a p e a n d m a x i m u m supportable weight in some detail. Boucher a n d Kent^^ studied i n s t a b ilities which, u n d e r certain conditions, may occur. E a m s h a w et al.^^ subjected t h e
^J W.D. Harkins, F.E. Brown, J. ATTL Chem, Soc. 4 1 (1919) 503. ^^ See the references in sec. 1.17c and d. The corrections are also reproduced in the International Critical Tables, IV, McGraw Hill (1928). ^^ J.L. Lando, H.T. Oakley, J. Colloid Interface Set 25 (1967) 526. ^) K.H. Strenge, J. Colloid Interface Set 2 9 (1969) 732. ^^ M.C. Wilkinson, J. Colloid Interface Set 40 (1972), 14; M.C. Wilkinson, M.P. Aronson, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 7 6 9 (1973) 474. ^^ S. Hartland, P.S. Srinivasan, J. Colloid Interface Set 4 9 (1974) 318. '^^ E.A. Boucher, H.J. Kent, J. Colloid Interface Set 6 7 (1978) 10. ^^ J.C. Eamshaw, E.G. Johnson, B.J. Carroll and P.J. Doyle, J. Colloid Interface Set 177 (1996) 150.
1.36
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
method to error analysis. Their work contains improved tables, essentially to o b t a i n / i n [1.6.2]. Kisil'^^ described a differential method (two drops sitting on capillaries of different radii) to measure the pressures directly and, from it the interfacial tension. However, he did not report results. When these corrections are properly accounted for, and the purity and d3niamics under control, interfacial tensions of pure liquids can be obtained accurately to ± 0.15%. This is also the case for mixed systems provided system and measuring conditions are such that De « 1. The technique has been automated^) and several variants exist^^K Commercial apparatus are also available. Interfacial tensions can also be measured if the droplet falls or rises in a second liquid, depending on the sign of Ap^. Of course, the ascending mode applies very well for gas bubbles rising from a nozzle^^ The advantage of this method is that no knowledge of contact angles is required. 1.7
Maximum bubble pressure
From a fundamental point of view this method is very attractive because it attempts to measure the capillary pressure directly. So, if the radii of curvature are known in one point of the interface, the interfacicd tension can be computed. In principle, the contact angle does not have to be known. However, in practice a number of problems have to be surmounted. The principle is sketched in fig. 1.18. Consider a vertical capillairy in the liquid to be studied. If left to itself, the liquid would rise as in fig. 1.4a. If now a gradually increasing pressure p is applied inside the capillary the liquid level can be pushed down. Upon arriving at the bottom of the capillary the meniscus passes successively through the stages 1, 2 and 3. In this order the bubble radius first diminishes, then rises, so p will pass through a maximum p(max). This maximum can be recorded as the pressure where the bubble starts to expand spontaneously, generally within 10"^ s. At that point p(max) = pgh +2y/R
[1.7.1]
where the two terms on the r.h.s. represent the Archimedes pressure at the bottom of the bubble below the liquid level cind the capillary pressure, respectively. The equation immediately shows both the power and problems: if h is measured and R ^ a (the capillary radius) / is rapidly found, but on closer inspection one has to ask what depth and radius are required and how deviations from sphericity have to be
1) I.S. Kisil', Zhur. Fiz. Khim, 59 (1985) 1988 (transl. 1175). 2) R. Miller, K-H Schano, Tenside, Surfactants, Deterg. 27 (1990) 238. 3J See for instance, E. Tomberg, J. Colloid Interface Set 60 (1977) 50. "^J T. Ohsawa, T. Ozaki, Rev. Set Instmm. 52 (1981) 590.
1.37
INTEPa^ACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Figure 1.18. Principle of the method of maximum bubble pressure. Crosssection of a vertical capillary in a wetting liquid. By applying an internal pressure p, the meniscus can be pushed down till at p = p(max) the bubble starts to grow spontaneously.
handled. The technique may also be applied to LL interfaces if the density of t h e liquid to be measured is lower t h a n that of the external one. In the opposite case the heavier liquid m u s t be pushed upward ('emerging bubble'). The method is very old, dating back to Simon^^ in 1851. After further developm e n t s by Cantor^), Sugden*^^ investigated it thoroughly, thereby modifying t h e Bashforth-Adams tables to the case a t h a n d , which is essentially a v a r i a n t of [1.4.6]. At the bottom of the bubble R^= R^=b,
a s before, so there the capillary
pressure is 2y/b. To this the hydrostatic pressure pgz m u s t be added to obtain p . Here z is the vertical distance between the apex and the external liquid level. If the pressure is measured a s a hydrostatic head h, it follows that h =
+ z
11.7.2]
h where K is again the capillary length. Sugden introduces the variable X = so t h a t X~^ is a m e a s u r e of the applied p r e s s u r e p . At fixed
xJK, x/X
1K^Ih, passes
through a maximum a s a function of x/b. Here x is the radial distance, a s before, and x/b
is the size factor. These maxima have been tabulated'^K As in the sessile
drop a n d o t h e r m e t h o d s , iteration is required b e c a u s e a priori t h e capillary
1) Simon, Ann. Chim. Phys. 32 (1851) 5. 2) M. Cantor, Wied,. Annalen 47 (1892) 399. 3) S. Sugden, J. Chem. Soc. 121 (1922) 858; 123 (1924) 27. "^^ S. Sugden, The Parachor and Valency, Routledge (London), 1930, table 80, p. 219. (Reproduced by Padday and by Adamson, see references in sec. 1.17c and d.)
1.38
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
c o n s t a n t is not yet known. Sugden's tables have been revised, extended a n d m a d e more convenient by J o h n s o n a n d Lane^^. These a u t h o r s give Ap(mcix) over a wide range of a, u s i n g polynomial functions. Polynomials in t e r m s of t h e Eotvos n u m b e r [1.3.3cl have also been derived by Holcomb a n d Zollweg^^ A variety of a u t h o r s have experimented on the detciils of b u b b l e growth a n d detachment. We specially refer to Mysels*^^ who scrutinized its various aspects a n d proposed a n u m b e r of improvements. He showed t h a t a sensitivity of 10"^ mN m"^ c a n be attained if a n u m b e r of precautions are considered. By changing the drop time, the evolution of yit) can be monitored over five orders of magnitude of time, so dynamic surface t e n s i o n s c a n also be estimated. Some of his improvements include: (i) Siliconizing the lumen of the capillary, leaving the rest clean. This fixes t h e position of b u b b l e a t t a c h m e n t to the hydrophilic/hydrophobic b o u n d a r y a n d avoids the formation of ill-defined liquid films inside the capillary. (This problem w a s also e n c o u n t e r e d with m e r c u r y - d r o p p i n g electrodes, a s u s e d in electroanalysis^^.) (ii) Mounting t h e capillary slightly inclined. For a perfectly flat capillary tip a n d perfectly vertical capillary there is no reason for the droplet to escape. However, it does so because the situation is mechanically labile. S u c h a d e t a c h m e n t is sensitive to local d i s t u r b a n c e s which are difficult to control. Inclination provides a somewhat earlier, b u t regular escape. (iii) Very precise a n d vibrationless mounting of the capillary. (iv) Accurate p r e s s u r e control, using a precise a n d lag-free m a n o s t a t (instead of adjusting a n d m e a s u r i n g the gas flow, a s is usually done, b u t which is more difficult to keep c o n s t a n t over protracted periods of time). In addition, a n u m b e r of theoretical corrections were implemented. This brief review shows how a technique t h a t reputedly is difficult to control, can be perfected if the c a u s e s for the imperfections are recognized cind eliminated. The m e t h o d also exists in t h e differential mode, u s i n g two capillaries of different bore. The purpose is to obviate the precise establishment of the depth of submersion w h e n the liquid level is changed (only the difference between the two is relevant). To gain advantage of the differential mode requires the wetting c h a r a c teristics of the two capillaries to be identical^^ Passerone et al.^^ described a
1^ C.H.J. Johnson, J.E. Lane, J. Colloid Interface Set 47 (1974) 117. 2) CD. Holcomb, J.A. Zollweg, J. Colloid Interface Set 134 (1990) 41. ^^ See K.J. Mysels, Colloids Surf 43 (1990) 241 where references to older experimental work by himself and others can be found. ^^ P. Nikitas, A. Pappa-Louisi, J. Electroanal Chem. 237 (1987) 27. ^^ R. Razouk, D. Walmsley, J. Colloid Interface Set 47 (1974) 515; L.L. Schramm, ibid. 133 (1989) 534: C D . Holcomb. J.A. Zollweg, ibid. 154 (1992) 51. ^^ A. Passerone, L. Liggieri, N. Rando, F. Ravera and E. Ricci, J. Colloid Interface Set 146 (1991) 152.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.39
variant for the interfacial tension between two liquids of a b o u t the s a m e density. O l t h u i s et al.^^ described a variant in which t h e b u b b l e s were electrolytically produced on a constant nucleation site. 1.8 Force required t o hold objects at an interface or t o pull t h e m through it Methods belonging to this category are b a s e d on directly m e a s u r i n g t h e force needed to keep objects at a n interface or pull them upward from a liquid. This force h a s a gravity a n d a capillary contribution, the latter depending on surface tension a n d contact angle. So, if the former is accounted for, the product of surface tension a n d contact angle c a n be obtained^^. When the object is completely wetted by t h e liquid, the surface tension is accessible. In some variants the contact angle plays a m i n o r role. I n s t r u m e n t s by w h i c h s u c h forces are m e a s u r e d
are
called
tensiometers. Operationally speaiking, four experimental modes cam be distinguished. (i) The object is pulled u p until it is entirely free from the liquid
[detachment
mode). As the i n s t a n t of breaking loose is well-defined, the force at t h a t m o m e n t c a n be r a t h e r easily determined. However, the interpretation is not so simple. (ii) Keeping the object stationciry in the surface [stationary
mode] avoids t h e s e
i n t e r p r e t a t i o n a l p r o b l e m s . Instead, a n analysis of the capillary force is now required a s a function of position. The result depends on the geometry of the object. (iii) The object is lowered from the dry state until it touches the surface [touching mode). The position is then well-established and the m e a s u r e m e n t is again static. (iv) The object is kept in the interface where it is moved u p a n d down [oscillatory mode). As compared with (ii) this approach allows a more precise determination of the position and enables the study of contact angle hysteresis. In all t h e s e a p p r o a c h e s the weight of the object p l u s the a d h e r i n g fluid is m e a s u r e d . Basically t h e inverse p r o c e s s in which the weight of t h e liquid is m e a s u r e d is also possible, by placing the vessel with liquid on a sensitive toploading analytical balance. Christian et al.*^^ proved the viability of this concept for the pulling-out of a vertical rod ('Padday's pencil', see sec. 1.8c). We shall now discuss some of these methods, first considering to the flat plate, or Wilhelmy plate techniques because for these the geometry is relatively simple. 1.8a
Wilhelmy
plate
In this case the object is a thin vertical plate, suspended from a (micro)balance.
1^ W. Olthuis, A. Volanschi and P. Bergveld, Sensors and Actuators B49 (1998) 126. ■^^ The product 7cos a is sometimes called the adhesional tension', but this term is discouraged by lUPAC. ^^ S.D. Christian, A.R. Slagle, E.E. Tucker and J.F. Scamehom, Langmuir 14 (1998) 3126.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.40
Figure 1.9 s h o w s the situation with the plate partly submerged; in t h e accompanying section 1.3b the rise of the liquid w a s studied. Because of this rise the object a p p e a r s heavier t h a n it would have been on the b a s i s of its weight, after s u b t r a c t i n g t h e Archimedes buoyancy of the submerged part. Plates for which G > 90° seem lighter because the capillary forces tend to p u s h them upward. From this additional force the surface tension can be obtained if the plate is fully wetted. The m e t h o d derives its n a m e from Wilhelmy who long ago^^ described t h e d e t a c h m e n t of a t h i n g l a s s plate. Although n o w a d a y s static, or s e m i - s t a t i c m e t h o d s are preferred, t h e n a m e of Wilhelmy r e m a i n s associated with t h e s e t e c h n i q u e s . This 'static Wilhelmy' approach s t e m s from Dognon a n d Abribat^^ who also introduced roughened platinum plates to improve wetting. S u c h plates r e m a i n popular. Quantitatively, the force F to be exerted to keep a plate of total height z, width b and length [ in the surface with h a s shown in fig. 1.19, is given by^^
^^2 i i
1^1
G
>
t
;^ ^ 6
.^0
L
—
1
—
_
-\
ts"-^
i
1
—[[2
i
1 4
-| 1
1
—
T
1
\~ — —"
\
\poi —
[■5
J- 1 —
—
-j L —
— —- J:6—1
Figure 1.19. Force exerted on a vertical plate, kept partly or completely immersed in a liquid. Side-view of fig. 1.9. One cycle of the oscillatory mode is shown.
1) L. Wilhelmy, Ann. Phys. Chem, Reihe 4 29 (1863) 177. 2) A. Dognon, M. Abribat, Con^jt Rend. Acad. Set (Paris) 208 (1939) 1881. ^^ Similar equations but only for ^ » b have been rigorously derived by F. Neumann, Vorlesungen uber die Theorie der Capillaritdt, Leipzig (1894), D.O. Jordan, J.E. Lane, Austr. J. Chem. 17 (1964) 7. £ind others.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT F(h) = pghib
-h (z - h)Apgib + 2{i + b]y cos a
1.41 [1.8.1]
The first term on the r.h.s. is the weight of the part of the plate above the liquid, with p the density of the plate material (density of the vapour p h a s e neglected). The second term is the weight of the submerged part, corrected for buoyancy a n d the third is the required capillary contribution. Note t h a t the buoyancy of the p a r t of the plate t h a t is in the meniscus above the fluid level (indicated by h in fig. 1.9) does not have to be accounted for. In practice b is kept a s smedl a s is practically possible. For m e a s u r e m e n t of the interfacial tension between two liquids t h e equation changes in that p is replaced by [ p(plate) - p{L^)] and Ap by [p(plate) - p(L^)] if L^ is the heavier of the two liquids L^ and L^. Generally these m e a s u r e m e n t s tend to be less precise because usually /^^ < y ^ . Let u s postpone t h e discussion of practical problems like establishing t h e zero level a n d now consider the various measuring modes, starting with the oscillatory mode. Let also b « ^, unless stated otherwise. Figure 1.19 illustrates one cycle. The forces F
F^, F^, etc. refer to heights h = h , h , h , etc., above the m e n i s c u s . In
position 0 the plate is completely submerged. F^ is determined by the second term on the r.h.s. of [1.8.1] with h = 0. Now the plate is raised to attain a certain height h above t h e zero level (position 1). The force is now higher, partly b e c a u s e t h e buoyancy is less a n d partly b e c a u s e of the capillary contribution / 1 cos a. Upon further increase F(h) increases linearly b e c a u s e of the steady reduction of t h e Archimedes term; the capillary contribution does not depend on h. This increase continues until a certain maximum (position 3) is reached, after which the process is reversed (positions 4, 5, ... until complete resubmersion). Under ideal conditions the forward cind backward traces coincide, b u t in practice the r e t u r n force is lower b e c a u s e of contact angle hysteresis:
the advancing contact angle cf(adv) always
exceeds the receding one, a(rec). We shall discuss this further in sees. 5.1 a n d 5.5. As a c o n s e q u e n c e t h e
trace F{h] t h a t , after a u t o m a t i o n , c a n be r e a d from a
c o m p u t e r screen may look like t h a t in fig. 1.20. Extrapolation of the two linear parts to h = 0 yields / cos a(adv) or / cos a(rec). It follows t h a t this oscillating mode gives a good insight into the extent of contact angle hysteresis, b u t t h a t y c a n only be obtained
F/i
^
^
1^ /cos a (rec)
" f rs
ycos a (adv)
-^
4
0,6 I
height
Figure 1.20. Example of an F[h) diagram for pulling a Wilhelmy plate out of a solution (->) followed by resubmersion (<-). The points 0, 1, 2, ... correspond to the positions of the plate in fig. 1.19.
1.42
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
.4^ (a)
b)
c)
Figure 1.21. Three stages in the detachment of a Wilhelmy plate. From left to right the angle (p increases. The force to be exerted passes through a maximum at, or somewhat above, (p = n/2. if the plate is fully wetted, or nearly so (for a = 10°, 20° or 30° cos a differs by 1.5, 6 or 13.4% from unity). This problem of course recurs with other stationary objects. On the other h a n d , if y is known from other experiments, t h e advancing a n d receding contact angles can both be obtained ^^ Another feature t h a t may occur in oscillatory m e a s u r e m e n t s is the deposition of so-called Langmuir-Blodgett
layers
on the plate. We shall come back to this in sec. 3.7a. The touching method is a variant of the stationary mode a n d h a s the advantage that the height with respect to the reference level is easily established. When t h e plate is lowered until contact, a n d the a p p a r a t u s provides for keeping the plate in t h a t position (null displacement force measurement) there is no buoyancy correction (fig. 1.21a). This is possible with most m o d e m balances. In a variant the dry, clean plate is s u s p e n d e d from the tensiometer and the liquid raised till contact is made; the plate is then pulled down, after which it is moved u p to the touch position by applying a force via the tensiometer. In this way the position of fig. 1.21a is also reached. The advantage of absence of buoyancy corrections is t h a t the density of the hquid is not required. Strictly speaking, a small correction h a s to be applied to a c c o u n t for t h e lowering of the liquid level in the vessel b e c a u s e of t h e
fluid
w i t h d r a w n to create the m e n i s c u s . For similar r e a s o n s , the size of t h e vessel should not be too small. D e t a c h m e n t m a y t a k e place a s illustrated in fig. 1.21a-c. In s i t u a t i o n (a) equation [1.8.1] applies with z = h F = pgzib
+ 2U + b)Y cos a
[1.8.21
^^ For a computer-controlled analysis of such cycles, see D.A. Martin, E.A. Vogler, LangmuirV (1991) 422.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT = pgzib
1.43
+ 2{i -h b)Y sin (p
[ 1.8.3]
which for very thin plates reduces to F = pgzib
+ 2 ^ / c o s or = pgzib
+ 2lys\n(p
[1.8.4a, b]
The m e a n i n g of the angle (p is indicated in the figure. Under ideal conditions the m a x i m u m pull is obtained in situation b where sin (jp = 1, so that from F^ - F(max) = pgz^b
+ 2ly
[1.8.5]
the surface tension is immediately obtained. Upon pulling the plate beyond this position the liquid constricts spontaneously, (p becomes obtuse a n d the pull on the plate goes down. Often it is possible to pull until slightly above the m a x i m u m force w i t h o u t d e t a c h m e n t , so t h a t F(max) c a n be well e s t a b l i s h e d . U n d e r t h e s e conditions the contact angle does not occur in the equation. Equations which do not contain this angle can be derived where the force is maximized a s a function of the extent of pull-out, or a s a function oi (p^\ In practice, deviations from ideality m a y b e c a u s e d by end effects (near the edge the m e n i s c u s m a y be lower, so d e t a c h m e n t may start there and transfer to the flat plate) or because the necking of the liquid leads to the formation of a thin film with a certain stability (this may especially be so for surfactant solutions). Thin plates have the advantage t h a t the pgz^b
term in [1.8.5] is low, b u t with thicker plates it is easier to find the maxim-
u m force a s a function of height above the force where d e t a c h m e n t t a k e s place^^. This advantage may be significant for systems where the establishment of mechanical equilibrium is at stake, because this maximum can now be approached from either side. Some of these problems may be the reason why m a x i m u m pull a n d d e t a c h m e n t do not always give the same results. In recent practice the d e t a c h m e n t mode is not often used. In a variant of this method the height of the base of the plate over the zero level is measured; its maximum value m u s t then be related to the surface tension. From this review it follows t h a t for practical p u r p o s e s a variety of Wilhelmy plate m e t h o d s are available. Which one to choose is often a matter of practicality; the choice may also depend on the problem at h a n d . As a trend the 'rapid' m e t h o d s are less precise, b u t for m a n y p u r p o s e s high precision is not needed. The choice also depends on the 'chemistry' of the liquid. For instance, if a solution, containing slowly diffusing solute is studied, t h e stationary plate mode is r e c o m m e n d e d , b e c a u s e t h e n one can m e a s u r e the force a s a function of time. Alternatively, w h e n non-zero c o n t a c t angles pose a problem, the plate c a n be m a d e intentionally hydrophobic and the downward
force measured.
1^ J. Burri, S. Hartland, Colloid Polym. Set 255 (1977) 675. 2) G. Loglio, A. Ficalbi and R. Cini, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 383.
1.44
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
The ultimate precision obtainable by one of the Wilhelmy plate modes d e p e n d s on a n u m b e r of different factors. One of these is the intrinsic interfacial chemistry of the system, determining not only the surface tension and the contact angle, b u t also their variations with time a n d / o r with speed. Basically these are the items we are interested in, although it should always be kept in mind t h a t in the case of slow e s t a b l i s h m e n t of adsorption equilibrium, long waiting times (i.e. working a t low De) also have a drawback w h e n there are inadvertent impurities which a d s o r b slowly. This complication is felt not only in the time dependence of t h e contact angle a n d surface tension, b u t may also lead to spurious influences of the n a t u r e of the vessel wall or the area of the liquid surface in the vessel. The reason for this p h e n o m e n o n is t h a t for non-zero surface elasticity the surface loses its extensibility. Hence, u p o n pulling out a n object the surface acts a s a skin t h a t can even withdraw liquid from the wetting layer at the inner side of the vessel. We shall return to this issue in sec. 1.12 b u t already note t h a t such dynamic p h e n o m e n a are often responsible for large disparities between methods a n d a u t h o r s if surfactant solutions are investigated. Sometimes it is possible to choose the material of t h e plate to suit certain p u r p o s e s . For instance, it can be m a d e intentionally hydrophobic, or repellent for certain c o m p o n e n t s in t h e system (aluminium p l a t e s covered by a t h i n layer of Al^O
at not too high pH would repel cationic s u r -
factants). The overall precision is n o t limited by the quality of the force m e a s u r e m e n t . Several sensitive a n d accurate tensiometers are available, some commercially, the well-known C a h n electrobalance being one of these. The force m e a s u r e m e n t is b a s e d on a few basic principles, like the torsion of a wire or electromagnetic feedback. Of t h e s e t h e former is obsolete nowadays. However, a n everyday good, analytical balance is also adequate. Good t e m p e r a t u r e control is another prerequisite for precision m e a s u r e m e n t s . Local t e m p e r a t u r e gradients are coupled to local evaporation a n d (re-) condensation with concomitant uncontrollable variation in surface tension. Regarding the application of the method, two further complications have to be considered. The first complication is the width of the vessel. Wilhelmy-plate methods require fairly large a m o u n t s of liquid; the vessel should be sufficiently large so t h a t the horizontal (null-) level can be unambiguously established. When there is insufficient liquid available, the liquid menisci at the plate a n d vessel wall m a y overlap. Furlong a n d H a r t l a n d ^ ^ following similar work for rings by H u h a n d Mason (sec. 1.8b), analyzed this effect. Another consequence of the closeness of the menisci at the plate a n d the vessel wall is t h a t the e n s u i n g capillary attraction moves the plate sideways against the vessel wall.
IJ D.N. Furlong, S. Hartland, J. Colloid Interface Set 71 (1979) 301.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.45
The second consideration is the need for edge corrections a s first explained by Sentis^K By 'edge corrections' we u n d e r s t a n d the depression of h n e a r the edges, which h a s to be considered in precision m e a s u r e m e n t s if b/i
is not small. If
properly m e a s u r e d , there is no consequence for t h e interfacial t e n s i o n t h a t is eventually c o m p u t e d , see sec. 1.3b. Derivation of analytical formulas for t h e change of h n e a r the edges is a not so simple analytical problem. Generalizations to geometries other t h a n Wilhelmy plates have been given by Hall^^ a n d by Orr et al.^^. Plate end effects have been considered by Padday^^, Kawanishi et al.^^ a n d by Pike a n d Bonnet^^. These, and other, a u t h o r s have also published m e a s u r e m e n t s on plates of varying i/b
ratio. S u c h m e a s u r e m e n t s do not produce deviations in
t h e weight, t h a t is in the ultimately determined y, b u t reflect the accuracy of the experiments. Pike a n d Bonnet found a variation of less t h a n 1% for a b o u t a 3 0 0 fold variation in i/b.
This variation is also determined by s u c h features a s t h e
horizontal positioning the plate, which may be more difficult for long plates. With all t h e s e corrections implemented - or avoided by the choice of system a n d / o r procedure - surface tensions with a n accuracy of 0.01 mN m"^ c a n be obtained. The Wilhelmy plate technique h a s also been modified to m e a s u r e surface or interfacial t e n s i o n s u n d e r special conditions. By way of illustration we mention t h e application to t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of electrocapillary
curves
for t h e mercury-
a q u e o u s electrolyte solution interface by Montgomery a n d Anson^^ extending earlier work by Smith^^ Electrocapillary curves are plots of 7 a s a function of t h e potential applied across the interface, which should be polarizable. In fig. II.3.48 we already gave a few s u c h curves. Montgomery cmd Anson found t h a t their curve in 10"2 M NaF agreed within 0.005 mN m-^ with data obtained using the m a x i m u m bubble pressure. Wilhelmy plate tensiometry is also commonly used in Langmuir t r o u g h s (sec. 3.3). The difference between the surface tensions on the two sides of the barrier is identical to the surface pressure. 1.8b
Du Noiiy
ring
Methods similar to t h a t of the Wilhelmy plate have been developed for objects of other geometries. Of these the circular ring, or wire, h a s become prominent. The
^J H. Sentis, J. Phys. 9 (1890) 384; Pha. Mag. 32 (1891) 564. 2) T.P. Hall, PhU. Mag. 36 (1893) 385. ^J F.M. Orr. L.E. Scriven and T.Y. Chu, J. Colloid Interface Set 60 (1977) 402. "^J J.F. Padday, Proc. 1st Int. Congress Surface Activity, Lx)ndon (1957), Vol. 1, 133. ^) T. Kawanishi, T. Seimiya and T. Sasaki, J. Colloid Interface Set 32 (1970) 622. ^) P.P. Pike, J.C. Bonnet, J. Colloid Interface Set 34 (1970) 597. ^^ D.D. Montgomery, F.C. Anson, Langmuir, 7 (1991) 1000. ^) T. Smith, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 3 (1972) 161.
1.46
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 1.22. Three stadia in the detachment of a ring (idealized). Cross-section.
idea goes back to Timberg^^ and Sondhaufs-^^ but got its name through the work of Du Noiijr^^ who described a convenient apparatus for the detachment mode. The advantage of the ring over the plate is that c^ and c^ are independent of position but this is to a large extent offset by the disadvantage of the much more complicated geometry. Du Nouy rings are often employed in the detachment mode. Under idealized conditions this detachment may proceed as sketched in fig. 1.22. Maximum pull is obtained in situation b), beyond which the liquid necks spontaneously. When the ring is completely wetted the capillary force equals 2n(R - a)y + 2K[R + a)y, similar to the flat plate situation. Usually R»a so that F = u;(ring) + 4nRy
1) G. Timberg, Wied. Ann. Phys. Chenh Neue Folge 30 (1887) 545. 2) C. Sondhaufs, Ann. Phys. Ergdnzungsband 8 (1878) 266 ^^ P. lecomte Du Noiiy, J. Gen. Physiol. 1 (1919) 521.
[1.8.6]
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.47
if u;(ring) is the weight of the ring (corrected for the buoyancy of the part of the ring below the liquid zero level) plus t h a t of the wires from which the ring is s u s p e n d e d . Unlike [1.8.1] a n d its variants for the d e t a c h m e n t mode, [1.8.6] is not a c c u r a t e . Empirical correction factors have b e e n evaluated by H a r k i n s a n d J o r d a n ^^ in pretty m u c h the same way a s with the drop weight method: a s in [1.6.2] they wrote F = u;(ring) + AnRyf
[1.8.7]
w h e r e / i s their correction factor. It d e p e n d s on two dimensionless ratios, and R/a
R^/V
if V i s the volume of the meniscus. Depending on conditions, / c a n be a s
low a s 0.75, leading to a corresponding error in / if this correction is neglected. The value of V is obtained from the total force required to pull the ring from the surface, which is divided by the liquid density. The function / h a s been tabulated by Padday, see the reference in sec. 1.17c. The H a r k i n s - J o r d a n corrections were extended a n d recalculated by Zuidema and Waters-^^ and by H u h a n d Mason^^ who also tabulated numerical data. In a s u b s e q u e n t paper, H u h a n d Mason also considered the wall effect for the case of vessels which are not large'^^* in t u r n , this correction w a s further detaiiled a n d experimentally checked by Furlong et al.^^ a n d Gifford^^ who generalized ref.^^ for more contact angles. For the application of the ring method, either in the static or dynamic mode, the p r e c a u t i o n s n e c e s s a r y for high precision are similar to t h o s e required for t h e Wilhelmy plate. The ring should be perfectly circulcir a n d the diameter of the wire c o n s t a n t . It should be positioned perfectly horizontally. Making the ring t h i n n e r facilitates t h e analysis b e c a u s e the influence of cos a is reduced, b u t h a s t h e d r a w b a c k of risk of deformation. Complete wetting is strongly recommended a n d in certain cases the variant of measuring the force required to p u s h down a fully hydrophobic roughened ring may be considered. For surfactaint solutions slow e s t a b l i s h m e n t of contact angle a n d surface tension equilibrium m a y offer t h e u s u a l problems, to which we shall r e t u r n in sec. 1.12. Especially w h e n the ring is
Figure 1.23. Possibility of film formation upon detachment of a Du Noiiy ring.
1^ W.D. Harkins, H.F. Jordan. J. Am. CherrL Soc. 52 (1930) 1751. See also B.B. Freud, H.Z. Freud, ibid. 1772. 2) H.H. Zuidema, G.W. Waters, Ind. Eng. CherrL Anal Ed., 13 (1941) 312. ^^ C. Huh, S.G. Mason, Colloid Polym. Set 253 (1975) 566. "^^ C. Huh, S.G. Mason, Colloid Polym. Set 255 (1975) 460. ^^ N. Furlong, P.A. Freeman, I.M. Metcalfe and L.R. White, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 79 (1983) 1701. ^^ W.A. Gifford, J. Colloid Interfaee Set 64 (1978) 588.
1.48
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
small, t h e formation of a thin film between solution a n d ring, a s sketched in fig. 1.23, may give rise to irreproducibilities.^^ 1.8c
Other
geometries
Pull-out a n d / o r pull through methods have also been developed for a n u m b e r of other objects. Mostly they have been designed to avoid some of the physical drawbacks of the plate a n d ring methods, b u t they do not remove the chemical problems of insufficient wetting or high De. In fact, a s long ago a s 1880 Gay Lussac measured the force to be exerted on a horizontal plate to pull it free from the surface of a liquid^). Among t h e s e other geometries the sphere h a s received some attention. Two a d v a n t a g e s are (i) the relatively simple geometry a n d (ii) the a b s e n c e of vertical alignment problems (plates a n d rings behave differently if tilted). Yarnold*^^ u s e d this m e t h o d to investigate contact angle hysteresis of mercury. Scheludko a n d Nikolov^^ studied spheres in the static mode, whereas H u h a n d Mason investigated d e t a c h m e n t ^ ^ Fieber a n d Sonntag^^ gave a formula for the force b u t did n o t describe experiments. So far the most complete study h a s been m a d e by Zhang et al.^^ who developed a n oscillatory mode, of which the Wilhelmy-equivalent h a s been discussed in some detail in sec. 1.8a. The maximum force and the position of the s p h e r e at t h a t m a x i m u m allow the computation of surface (or interfacial) tensions a n d the contact angle; the cycles yield information on hysteresis, if any. In practice the method a p p e a r s to have some drawbacks; cleaning a s p h e r e by flaming is certainly more difficult t h a n cleaning a plate or a ring. The method h a s not found wide application. P a d d a y et al.^^ described a method for obtaining surface t e n s i o n s from t h e m a x i m u m pull on a rod (a 'pencil'). This is also a n equilibrium method, the advantage over the sphere being t h a t the perimeter is independent of the height. The disadvantage is t h a t preventing tilting can pose a problem Tilting can be reduced by choosing a relatively heavy pencil, s u s p e n d e d from a thin wire, b u t t h e n the weight of t h e puUed-up liquid is relatively smaller. In line with the experience obtained with other methods, from the maximum pull / cos a can be obtained a n d
1) P.J. Gram, J.M. Haynes, J. Colloid Interface Set 35 (1971) 706. 2) N.F. Gay Lussac, Oeuvres 4 (1880) 467. ^) G.D. Yarnold, Proc. Phys. Soc. 58 (1946) 120. 4J A.D. Scheludko (= Sheludko), A.D. Nikolov, Colloid Polyuh Set 2 5 3 (1975) 396; see also A. Nikolov, God. Sofii Univ., Khim Fak. 72 (1981) 151. ^^ C. Huh, S.G. Mason, Can. J. Chem. 54 (1976) 969; J. Colloid Interface Set 17 (1974) 271. ^^ Ch. Fieber, H. Sonntag, Colloid Polym. Set 253 (1975) 32. ^^ L. Zhang, L. Ren and S. Hartland, J. Colloid Interface Set 180 (1996) 493. ^J J.F. Padday, A.R. Pitt and R.M. Pashley, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 7 1 (1975) 1919.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.49
the contact angle. The. influence of the contact angle can be further reduced by polishing the sides of the rod, but roughening the lower end (as in stalagmometers). Then a situation as in fig. 1.21c is attained. The wall effect for this geometry has been theoretically and experimentally investigated by Furlong and Hartland^^ A variant of Padday's pencil for interfacial tension determination of hydrophobic liquids, using a teflon rod, was elaborated by Buboltz et al.^l Padday^^ and Ugarcic et al."^^ also experimented with a cone. A relatively long time ago, Lenard^^ developed a method based on the measurement of the force needed for keeping a rectangular frame holding the liquid verticaUy in the interface. In fact, only the upper wire carried the liquid. The frame was suspended from a torsion balance through a contraption resembling a clothes hanger, hence the name 'Buglermethode'. Using this device, Moser^^ measured the surface tension of water from 0-100°C and his results match well with more recent data, as will be shown in fig. 1.26. Other geometries include two concentric cylinders, a hollow cylinder, a tilted plate and horizontail cylinders. Details can be found in the book by Rusanov and Prokhorov, cited in sec. 1.17c. Obviously, application of all these geometries in the four modes discussed for the Wilhelmy plate may be considered. Several times in this section liquid bridges have been encountered, i.e. bodies of fluid with concave surfaces, connecting a solid object and a fluid. In connection with fig. 5.46 we shsdl briefly address these. In pgirticular such bridges play important roles in the adhesion between two solid macrobodies, say between the pcirticles in a powder. Depending on conditions, the Laplace underpressure in the bridge may result in a stronger adhesive force than that caused by Van der Waals forces. 1.9 Spinning drops and bubbles This method for obtaining interfacial and surface tensions is reminiscent of those discussed in sec. 1.5 in that an external force is applied, deforming the drop against the surface force. The applied force is derived from centrifugation; a special set-up is required to facilitate the experiment. See figure 1.24. A horizontal cylinder is rotated along its axis with angular speed of revolution (0. It contains a bubble or drop a in a fluid p, with which it is immiscible. Phase a
1^ D.N. Furlong, S. Hartland, J. Chem, Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 76 (1980) 457, 467. 2) J.T. Buboltz, J. Huang and G. Feigenson, LangmuirlS (1999) 5444. 3) J.F. Padday, J. Chem Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 75 (1979) 2827. ^) Z. Ugarcic, D.K. Vohra, E. Atteya and 8. Hartland, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 77 (1981) 49-61. 5^ P. Lenard, Ann. Phys. 74 (1924) 381. ^) H. Moser. Ann. Phys. 82 (1927) 993.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.50
{-^cx
— 1 - ^ : = ^
Figure 1.24. Spinning drop or bubble, (a) low rotation speed; (b) high rotation speed. should be less dense t h a n p h a s e p. As a result of the rotation the drop moves to the axis. With increasing rotational rate the drop s t a r t s to elongate, b e c a u s e t h e centrifugal force grows with respect to the surface force it transforms the drop into a prolate spheroid a n d at sufficiently high speeds it eventually a t t a i n s a cylindrical-like s h a p e . The analysis for the general case is relatively complicated ^''^''^^. Here, we shall r e s t r i c t o u r s e l v e s to the m o s t frequently considered limiting s i t u a t i o n of a cylindrical s h a p e , where the contributions of the two semi-spherical c a p s at the two e n d s may be neglected. The rotational energy is 1 Ico^ if / is t h e m o m e n t of inertia of the cylinder, given by
/ = J 27ir dr ^ Ap r^
[1.9.1]
where r is the radial distance from the axis of revolution, i the length a n d a the r a d i u s of the cylinder; Ap = p - p^ where p and p
are the densities of p h a s e s p
a n d a, respectively. Integration yields / = -VApa^ 2
[1.9.2]
where the volume V of the cylinder is constant a n d equals na^i. This volume is of course identical to t h a t of the originally spherical drop, 47ca^/3, if a original radius. Hence, for the rotational energy we obtain
1^ B. Vonnegut, Rev. Set Instr. 1 3 (1942) 6. 2^ D.K. Rosenthal, J. Fluid Mech. 12 (1962) 3 5 8 . 3) H.M. Princen. I. Zia a n d S.G. Mason, J. Colloid Interface Set 2 3 (1967) 9 9 .
is t h e
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
l/(rot) = -VApco^a^ 4
1.51
[1.9.3]
The interfacicd Gibbs energy of the cylinder is U(int) = 2Kaiy
2V = =^y a
[1.9.4]
The s u m of [1.9.3 a n d 4] is the total Gibbs energy of the drop. The length £ of the cylinder, or for t h a t m a t t e r the r a d i u s a, adjusts itself in s u c h a way t h a t in the stationary state this total energy is a m i n i m u m a s a function of a. This r a d i u s is therefore found from d da
2 2
IT..
4
^
2V a ^
= 0
[1.9.5]
where V is a constant. The result is y = ^^-^^ ^ 4
[1.9.6]
which is sometimes called the Vonnegut equation. It applies for i > 4a. W h e n t h e condition ^ »
a is not satisfied more complicated e q u a t i o n s are
r e q u i r e d ^'2^. Usually the drop m u s t have a certain m i n i m u m volume in order to a s s u m e cylindrical s h a p e upon centrifugation. Experimental problems may be encountered with unfavourable wetting of t h e inner wall of t h e cylinder. The u s u a l situation is t h a t t h e wall is m a d e of glass (because of its t r a n s p a r e n c y a n d water-wettability) a n d t h a t the o u t e r p h a s e is water or a n aqueous solution ((3 in fig. 1.24). Phase a is then a bubble or 'oil' which usually does not wet glass in the presence of water. When this favourable situation is not met in practice problems may arise, b u t these are not u n s u r m o u n t a b l e . For instance, if the t u b e is preferentially wet by the 'oil' the situation of fig. 1.24a m a y prevail. With mild, or stronger rotation it will convert into situations 1.24b a n d c, respectively. W h e n the t u b e is wide enough a n d co sufficiently high, cylindrical s h a p e s may again a p p e a r so t h a t interfacial or surface tensions - a n d sometimes contact angles - can be measured'^K Sometimes oil drops do not come off t h e wall easily. This problem c a n be remedied by increasing co, provided the t u b e is wide enough. Another non-trivial problem is t h e image analysis, especially for s i t u a t i o n s where length a n d width have to be established. The problem is t h a t the spinning
^^ Princen et al. (1967) loc. clt. 2) J.C. Slatteiy, J-D. Chen, J. Colloid Interface Set 64 (1978) 371. ^^ H.M. Princen, J. Colloid Interface Set 169 (1995) 241.
1.52
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
co = 0
(a)
>0'
(c)
^WE^^g^^f^y^
£
A CO low
j CO high
Figure 1.25. Profile changes upon rotation of an oil-wetted tube p < p . drop is not opaque; drop, a q u e o u s solution a n d capillary wall give rise to complicated refraction phenomena. Puig et al. ^^ have analyzed this in some detail. When t h e appropriate precautions are t a k e n the method a p p e a r s particularly suited for m e a s u r i n g very low tensions (<, 10"^ mNm"^ sometimes even a s low a s 10"^ mN m"^). S u c h ultralow tensions are for example encountered in micro-emulsion s y s t e m s a n d in j u s t p h a s e - s e p a r a t e d polymeric or micellar solutions.
For
p h a s e - s e p a r a t e d colloid-polymer systems de Hoog a n d Lekkerkerker^) even reported values down to a few )LIN m"^ reproducibly being obtained after implementing a n u m b e r of methodical improvements. (Alternatives for low tensions are the sessile a n d pending (micro-) drop b u t these do not usually go below 10"^ mN m"^) Commercial a p p a r a t u s are nowadays available. A variant proposed by T h a n et al.^^ employs a thin rod in the axis of the cylinder, to reduce spin-up time a n d s u p p r e s s drift. Another variant, proposed by Kokov, analyses the centrifugal field required to squeeze liquid out of a n orifice"^^. All t h e above-mentioned m e t h o d s consider the steady state s h a p e w h e n t h e drop, the c o n t i n u o u s p h a s e a n d the tube all rotate with the same angular velocity. In other words, they behave a s rigid bodies. Another condition is t h a t the tension should be the same everywhere. However, j u s t a s in the case of sec. 1.5 the transient
1^ J. E. Puig, Y. Seeto. C.V. Pesheck and L.E. Scriven, J. Colloid Interface Set 148 (1992) 459. 2) E.H.A. de Hoog. H.N.W. Lekkerkerker, J. Phys. Chem. B103 (1999) 5274. ^^ P. Than, L. Preziosi, D.D. Joseph and M. Amey, J. Colloid Interface Set 124 (1988) 552; D.D. Joseph, L. Preziosi. J. Fluid Mech, 285 (1987) 323. ^^ The method is described in Rusanov and Prokhorov's book, mentioned in sec. 1.17c.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.53
state towards the stationary one also contains interesting features, although the mathematical analysis is complicated 1^. In this case, as intuitively expected, the viscosities of the two phases enter the equations. By oscillating the drop it is possible to let drop and tube rotate out of phase to an extent determined by the interfacial shear viscosity, a parameter to which we shall return in sec. 3.6. Princen^^ has extended the spinning drop technique to the case that the rotating cylinder contains a liquid (L2) and an air bubble (G) dispersed in another liquid L^. When drop Lg and bubble G do not touch each other, the surface tension y^ and the interfacial tension y^^ can be simultaneously determined. However, under certain conditions bubble and drop adhere to each other. Then, as well as the two tensions, the three three-phase contact angles can be simultaneously measured. 1.10
Surface light scattering
On a molecular scale liquid surfaces are not flat, but subject to fluctuations. These irregularities have a stochastic nature, meaning that no external force is needed to create them, that they cannot be used to perform work and are devoid of order. Their properties can only be described by statistical means as explained in sec. L3.7. Surface fluctuations are also known as thermal ripples, or thermal waves, in distinction to mechanically created waves that will be discussed in detail in sec. 3.6. Except near the critical point, the amplitudes of these fluctuations are small, in the order of 1 nm, but they can, in principle, be measured by the scattering of optical light. X-ray and neutron beams. From the scattered intensity the root mean square amplitude can be derived and this quantity can, in turn, be related to the surface tension because this tension opposes the fluctuations^^ Methods based on this principle differ in two respects from those discussed so far. First, the driving force needed to extend the interface isothermally and reversibly is not external but intrinsic; it is the thermal energy. Second, the method is dynamic in the sense that continuous motions on a molecular scale are involved. Here it may be appropriate to note that in the literature the term dynamic interfacial (or surface) tension is used in two senses, viz. (i) as the tension obtained by a dynamic method such as scattering or (ii) as that obtained under nonequilibrium conditions, i.e. tensions measured at non-zero De, for interfaces that relax during the observation. We shall reserve the term 'dynamic interfacial tension' for the latter case, that is, for interfaces that are not equilibrated (sec. 1.14). Interfacial tensions derived from scattering are essentially static, although 1) H.H. Hu, D.D. Joseph, J. Colloid Interface Set 162 (1994) 331. 2) H.M. Princen, Langmuir 15 (1999) 7386. ^' For a review on the analysis of surface light scattering, see J.C. Eamshaw, Appl Opt 36 (1997) 7583.
1.54
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
the measuring method has a dynamic origin. When the interface is not at equilibrium, so that the tension changes with time (at a time scale longer than that needed to perform the measurements), dyneimic tensions can also be measured by this method. In this latter respect the scattering method is not different from, say the Wilhelmy plate technique, applied to non-relaxed interfaces. The theory of scattering by interfaces is relatively complex and mostly beyond the present scope. We introduced it already in sec. 1.7.10, and recall some basic elements. Scattering experiments are usually carried out by (laser-) light, although X-ray and neutron scattering also works, especially if shorter amplitudes are required. Scattering differs from light reflection, where the angles of incidence and exit are identical. However, scattering takes place in all directions, that is, at all elevational (6) and azimuthal ((p) angles. See fig. 1.7.22 for an illustration. The reflecting angle is defined with respect to the normal to the surface, but the scattering angle is defined with respect to the reflecting angle. There is only one reflecting angle but a spectrum of scattering angles. For the formulation, for each wave, i.e. to each 9, a scattering wave vector q is defined. It is in the plane of the interface and equal to the vectorial difference between the projections on this plane of the reflected wave and the selected scattered wave. The scattered spectrum is the intensity of the scattered light as a function of q, i.e. i [q]. Surface fluctuations are quantified in terms of the deviation ^ of a surface element in the perpendicular direction z from the averaged position. So f is f(z, t) and = 0 because of the stochastic nature. However (f(z,t)^> is finite. Experimentally ^{q,t) can be measured; it is the Fourier transform of ^{z,t), and a complex quantity. The scattered intensity is proportional to the time-averaged amplitude, i.e. to
where A is the area of which the scattered intensity is measured. On the right-hand side the thermal driving force is in the numerator, the forces opposing extension of the interface in the denominator. Basically this is the story of determining / from surface light scattering. The shape of [1.10.1] appeals immediately. The /cTis in the numerator, it is the driving force. Interfacial tension and gravity oppose, the former because it inhibits increase of area. The extent to which the interfacial tension, counteracts depends on the wavelength; this is accounted for by the q^ factor. Recall that q has the dimensions of a reciprocal length, so yq^ has the dimensions of an energy. A fluid like mercury, which has a very high surface tension scatters almost no light, but reflects very strongly. Surface-contracting forces are also operative in the damping of waves (sec. 3.6.6).
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.55
In practice, a n u m b e r of experimental problems have to be s u r m o u n t e d (the scattered intensity is weak and is m e a s u r e d in the presence of a d o m i n a n t reflection intensity) b u t it is also possible to extract additional information from t h e spectra. Anticipating later sections, we first note that the spectrum can be analyzed to give the real a n d imaginary part, the latter accounting for t h e d a m p i n g of t h e fluctuations. tainly,
Interpretation of this damping is a m a t t e r of a c t u a l r e s e a r c h . Cer-
fluctuations
are damped by the bulk viscosity, 77. The interesting problem
arises w h e t h e r on top of this there is also a surface esoteric p a r a m e t e r , b e c a u s e surface
elasticity
excess
viscosity
rf. It is a n
also contributes to t h e d a m p i n g
(unless t h e liquid is entirely devoid of surface-active solutes which is rarely t h e case), a n d this elasticity usually h a s a m u c h larger, though indirect, effect on t h e damping (it alters the flow near the surface). Another interesting property is the bending
energy of a n interface, t h a t is t h e
energy required to (strongly) bend it beyond the c u r v a t u r e preferred, given t h e n u m b e r s a n d orientations of t h e molecules a t t h e interface. For simple onecomponent fluids this energy is usually negligible, b u t it may become i m p o r t a n t when surfactants etc. are adsorbed. Equation [1.10.1] h a s been extended to include this bending energy by writing
ICIV 11/
2 f"^
^ 4
[1-10-21
/q^ + Apg + Ar^q^
where k^ is the [elastic) bending modulus of the interface. Its SI u n i t s are [Nm] or [J]. The problem with this equation is t h a t the deviations from the ideal behaviour of [1.10.1] are entirely attributed to bending, whereas possible concomitant viscous a n d elastic contributions are ignored. As a consequence, t h e p a r a m e t e r k , a s determined from [1.10.2] h a s a compounded nature, a feature t h a t h a s to be kept in mind if interpretations are offered. We shall come back to surface viscosities a n d (this a n d other) bending moduli in sees. 1.15 a n d 3.6, respectively. For further reading a review by Langevin a n d Meunier can be r e c o m m e n d e d ^K In a n o t h e r review, Earnshaw^) emphasized the relation to interfacial rheology. Returning to the present theme of measuring surface a n d interfacial tensions of simple fluids, examples can be quoted which prove t h a t light scattering gives the s a m e r e s u l t s a s the other methods. Hard a n d Johansson^^ u s e d the method in a slightly different way; for electrolyte solutions they m e a s u r e d t h e frequency spectrum a n d obtained the surface tension from the frequency at the peak a n d the
1^ D. Langevin, J. Meunier, Interfacial Tension: Theory and Experiment in Micelles, Membranes, Microemulsions, and Monolayers, W.M. Gelbart, A. Ben-Shaul and D. Roux, Eds., Springer (1994) chapter 10. 2^ J.C. Earnshaw, Light Scattering as a Probe of Liquid Surfaces and Interfaces, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 6 8 (1996) 1. 3^ S. Hard, K. Johansson, J. Colloid Interface Set 60 (1977) 467.
1.56
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
viscosity from the width of the power spectrum. Within experimental error this tension agreed with data obtained with the Wilhelmy plate technique. Moreover, the viscosities appeared within a few percent identical to their bulk equivalents. So there was no indication of an excess surface viscosity. A few years earlier, Langevin^^ observed the same. This observation, if corroborated, leads us to the interesting distinction from fluids near solid walls, where substantial excess viscosities are observed, leading to stagnant layers in electrokinetics (sec. 11.4.1). Probably this difference is caused by the difference of stacking fluid molecules, which at solid-liquid interfaces takes place in layers but leads to a smooth density-distance profile at fluid-gas interfaces, against an attractive wall. We shall return to this in the next chapter. Finally, it may be noted that in principle surface tensions obtained by scattering are slightly lower than the corresponding macroscopic quantities ^K Attention to this feature was drawn by Buff et al.^^ The reason is that in [1.10.1 and 2] the coupling between the various fluctuation modes is ignored. The difference between the two depends on the angle at which the measurement is taken: /(scatt.) = /(macr.) + ^ ^ ^
[1.10.31^)
871
and vanishes for small q, that is for long wavelengths. The agreement between the two 7's, obtained so far indicates that the correction term in [1.10.3] is small. Probably the uncertainties involved in the surface rheology are greater. 1.11
Miscellaneous other static methods
In addition to the variety of techniques discussed in sees. 1.3-10, a number of other procedures exist that are not so familiar, although they may appear useful for certain situations and/or systems. Some of these will now be considered briefly. They are all different, but some are more different than others. In the method of the falling meniscus a liquid-wetted tapering tube is placed vertically in a reservoir, as in fig. 1.26. Inside the tube liquid is held by the capillary pressure. The tube is now moved upwards - or the liquid in the vessel downwards - to increase the hydrostatic pressure head, and this is continued until the liquid in the capillary collapses. From the hydrostatic head the Laplace pressure is obtained and from that the surface tension. The method is very simple and may be considered as the counterpart of the maiximum bubble pressure technique; there are also similarities to the situation sketched in fig. 1.8a. The idea is rather old ^^ D. Langevin, J . Meunier, loc. cit. 2) F.P. Buff, R A , Lovett a n d F.H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. Lett 1 5 (1963) 6 2 1 . 3^ J . Meunier, J . Phys. 4 8 (1987) 1819.
1.57
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
rzr-
— / / =/ / / // ^ ^ ^ / / /^ >/ / : / z^rz —msnz / ^Lzrz / ^^=^^=^ / -z-
—
~
r
^~
J/ / :-_-_—— :
—=-1_;
=
1 ^
~ : .~ Figure 1.26. Falling meniscus.
a n d apparently due to Hiss^^. It h a s not become popular a n d w a s mostly u s e d for the m e a s u r e m e n t of the dynamic tension of water. A variant is the micro-pipette
method, which is also similar to the m a x i m u m
bubble p r e s s u r e technique. A drop of the liquid to be studied is drawn by suction into the tip of a micropipette. The inner diameter of the pipette m u s t b e smaller t h a n the r a d i u s of the drop; the m i n i m u m suction p r e s s u r e needed to force t h e droplet into the capillary can be related to the surface tension of the liquid, u s i n g t h e Young-Laplace equation ll.l.2]2K This technique can also be u s e d to obtain interfacial tensions, say of individual emulsion droplets. Experimental problems include accounting for t h e extent of wetting of the inner l u m e n of the capillary, rate problems because of the time-dependence of surfactant (if any) adsorption on the capillary and, for narrow capillaries accounting for the work needed to b e n d the interface. Indeed, this method h a s also been used to m e a s u r e bending moduli (sec. 1.15). Graebling a n d Muller^^ developed a rheological procedure for polymer emulsions, w h i c h are s h e a r e d in a n oscillatory way in a dynamic r h e o m e t e r . The dynamic complex shear m o d u l u s can be measured a s a function of the frequency co of the s h e a r field. The emulsion droplets are subjected to a s h e a r force which t e n d s to deform t h e s h a p e a g a i n s t t h e restoring capillary force. From t h e real a n d imaginary p a r t s of t h e m o d u l u s the viscosity of the droplets a n d the interfacial tension c a n be established. However, a large n u m b e r of u n k n o w n variables are involved. A variant considers the rate of retraction of drops t h a t were first b r o u g h t in a n o n - s p h e r i c a l s h a p e by shearing. The rate of decay of t h e deviation from
^^ R. Hiss, Ph. D. Thesis, Univ. of Heidelberg, (1913), quoted by Rusanov and Prokhorov, see sec. 1.17c. 2^ E. Evans, W. Rawicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 6 4 (1990) 2094; A. Yeung, T. Dabro and J. Masliyah, J. Colloid Interface Set 298 (1998) 241. 3) D. Graebling, R. Miiller, Colloids Surf 55 (1991) 89.
1.58
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
sphericity depends on the interfacial tension^^. An original method involves quadrupole oscillations of drops^K The drop (a) in a host liquid (p) is acoustically levitated. This can be achieved by creating a standing acoustic wave; the time-averaged second order effect of this wave gives rise to an acoustic radiation force. This drives the drop up or down in p, depending on the compressibilities of the two fluids, till gravity and acoustic forces balance. From then onwards the free droplet is, also acoustically, driven into quadrupole shape oscillations that are opposed by the capillary pressure. From the resonance frequency the interfacial tension can be computed. The authors describe the instrumentation and present some results for a number of oil-water interfaces. Of the various other methods we mention a few of a more dynamic nature. From wave damping y(co) can in principle be obtained; co is the frequency of the applied wave. See sec. 3.6g. Guido and Villone'^^ proposed a procedure to obtain interfacial tensions from the rate at which shear-deformed droplets retracted to their equilibrium spherical shape. De Hoog and Lekkerkerker"^^ determined very low interfacial tensions by following the initial state of the Rayleigh break-up of elongated drops. Although these methods are unlikely to develop into routine procedures, they demonstrate how wide the methodical spectrum is. 1.12 A case study: the surface tension of water Before continuing, it is appropriate to consider the accuracy and reproducibility of the various static methods discussed so far. To that end data for the surface tension of water, 7^, obtained by different investigators with different materials and conditions will be compared. In appendix 1 data for many other monocomponent mixtures can be found. The graphs in that appendix give surface tensions as a function of temperature. They contain Jasper's linearization together with individual data, so that additional reproducibility checks can be made. Two issues present themselves: what is the absolute value at a given temperature (say, 20 or 25°C) and what is the temperature derivative dy/dT. The former requires a comparison between data by different authors, using a variety of methods (sec. 1.12a); the latter follows in sec. 1.12b. 1.12a Room temperature Table 1.2 gives a detailed overview of water surface tensions in the 20-25°C range. Although / ^ is one of the most important and well-studied surface tensions. 1^ J . M . Rallison, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 1 6 (1984) 4 5 ; S. Guido, M. Villone, J. Interface Set 2 0 9 (1999) 2 4 7 . 2) C-J. Hsu, R.E. Apfel, J . Colloid Interface Set 1 0 7 (1985) 4 6 7 . ^J S. Guido, M. Villone, J. Colloid Interface Set 2 0 9 (1999) 2 4 7 . 4) E.H.A. de Hoog, H.W.N. Lekkerkerker, J. Phys. Chem. B 1 0 3 (1999) 5 2 7 4 .
Colloid
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.59
it a p p e a r s t h a t its absolute value c a n n o t be narrowed down to less t h a n a b o u t 0.1 mN m-2 (or p e r h a p s to 0.05 mN m"^ if some extreme values are, more or less arbitrarily, excluded). Studying the original literature, it is virtually impossible to t r a c e t h e origins of t h e (small) disparities a n d r e c o m m e n d a 'best' v a l u e . A multitude of minor error sources have to be considered, s u c h a s those involved in: temperature control (a 0.5 deg. uncertainty in the surface temperature gives rise to a b o u t 0.08 mN m"^ uncertainty in y , a n d to more if gradients in / arise), wetting (for techniques where the contact angle is needed), d a t a acquisition a n d elaboration (for s h a p e - b a s e d methods), calibration of (electro-)balances (for d e t a c h m e n t a n d pull m e a s u r e m e n t methods), presence of minor impurities in the fluid or g a s p h a s e (some gases dissolve in the water a n d may be surface active), the qugdity of the various corrections etc. Some of the more important error sources (incomplete wetting, impurities) tend to lower the a p p a r e n t surface tension b u t this does not automatically imply t h a t t h e higher values are better. Mostly t h e more r e c e n t p u b l i c a t i o n s , having t h e benefit of hindsight, devote some a t t e n t i o n to d a t a comparison, although a u t h o r s rarely consider their own d a t a inferior.The reader m a y find a discussion between Gaonkar-Neumginn a n d Pallas-Pethica useful by way of illustration 1^ As c a n be inferred from table 1.2 the differences in absolute values between these t e a m s are very minor. It may p e r h a p s be added t h a t older m e t h o d s are not necessarily inferior. Even though in the earlier p a r t of the 2 0 t h century no computers or sophisticated electro-optical instrumentation were available, so rendering the analyses more laborious, the feeling for the 'chemistry' of the system w a s often well-developed. In particular Harkins' old d a t a still compare well with recent results. Is it i m p o r t a n t to know / ^ to s u c h accuracy except for academic r e a s o n s ? Hardly. Theoretically determined values (chapter 2) differ from actual values by several mN m"^ In virtually every case in practice, changes of / ^ (as a function of time, t e m p e r a t u r e , solute concentration, etc.) r a t h e r t h a n its absolute value a r e considered, or / ^ is considered in combination with other surface a n d interfacial tensions (e.g. in spreading and wetting). Even if the absolute value is not exactly k n o w n , variations in it c a n usually be established with a n a c c u r a c y t h a t is satisfactory for the problem at hand. In conclusion, we shadl refrain from recommending a best value. For practical purposes either one of the standard data (top entries in table 1.2) may be used. 1.12b
FromO°-
100°C
Data over the range from freezing to boiling point are scarcer t h a n those t a k e n at room temperature. These m e a s u r e m e n t s present the additional problems of tem-
IJ N.R. Pallas, B. Pethica, Colloids Surf. 6 (1983) 221; 36 (1989) 369; 6 1 (1991) 355; A.G. Gaonkar, R.D. Neumann. Colloids Surf 27 (1987) 1; 6 1 (1991) 353.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.60
Table 1.2. Surface tensions of water in mN m-^ obtained by various investigations using different techniques. Temperatures in degrees Celsius. Abbreviations for methods: CR = capillary rise, WP = Wilhelmy plate, DNR = Du Nouy ring, DM = other detachment method or object in the surface. HD = hanging (pendent) drop, SD = sessile drop, MBP = maximum bubble pressure; DW = drop weight. Surface tension 20° 72.88
other temp.
72.75
Method
'cR
71.99
CR
2)
72.11 72.16 72.31 72.00 72.04
CR rect. wire HD CR HD diff. CR MBP DM CR CR DW diff. CR WP DNR
72.03
WP DM
71.95
DM
72.60 72.04 71.97-99 71.98-72.42
WP CR WP DW HD
3) 3a) 4) 5) 6) 7) 7a) cylinder 8) 9) 10) 11) 11) 12) 12) 13) surface light scattering 14) 15) vertical rod, interpolation as in ref. 16 16) cone, short extrapolation by authors of ref 18. 17) 18) 18) 18) 19) 20) cylinder 21) 22) 23)
71.79 73.0 72.00 71.80-71.84
72.75 72.75
71.98 72.00
72.85 73.08 19.98 73.04 72.76 72.79 21
72±2
73.04 72.74
73.36
72.75-73.12 73.06 72.64-72.75 25.2 71.98 72.94 72.85-72.93
references to this table). | Jasper's linearization, see app. 1. NBS standard data, reproduced in the 'Handbook of Chemistry and Physics'
25° 72.25
72.59-72.81
72.78
Ref. Remarks (see also the
WP 72.13 WP 71.98-72.07 SD
IT
1) J . J . J a s p e r , J. Phys. CheirL Ref Data 1 (1972) 8 4 1 . 2) N.B. Vargaftik, B.N. Volkov, L.D. Volyak. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 1 2 (1983) 8 1 7 . 3) S. Sugden, J . Chem. Soc. (1921) 1 4 8 3 . 3a) H. Moser, Ann. Physik 8 2 (1927) 9 9 3 . 4) G.W. Smith, L.V. Sorg, J. Phys. Chem. 4 5 (1941) 6 7 1 . These r e s u l t s a p p e a r s o m e w h a t high, b u t r e s u l t s for organic liquids agree well with other literature data. 5) W.D. H a r k i n s , in Physical Methods of Organic Chemistry, A. Weissberger, Ed. Vol. 1, p a r t 1, Interscience (1949) 3 6 9 .
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.61
6) H.W. Douglas, J. Set Instmm. 27 (1950) 67. 7) L.D. Volyak. Dokl Akad, Nauk. SSSR 74 (1950) 307. 7a) B.Ya. Teitel'baum, T.A. Gortalova and E.E. Sidorova, Zhur. Fiz. Khim. 2 5 (1951) 911. 8) E.J. Slowinskl, W.L. Masterton, J. Phys. Chem. 6 5 (1961) 1067. 9) W.D. Harkins, The Physical Chemistry of Surf ace Films, Reinhold (1962). Together with ref. 5 long established as being of excellent quality. 10) W. Drost Hansen, Ind. Eng. Chem 57 (1965) 18. 11) G.J. Gittens, J. Colloid Interface Set 30 (1969) 406. 12) R. Cini, G. Loglio and A. Ficalby, J. Colloid Interface Set 4 1 (1972) 287; see also G. Loglio, A. Ficalbi and R. Cini, ibid. 64 (1978) 198. 13) D. Langevin, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. / 70 (1974) 95. 14) J.A.G. Taylor, J. Mingins, J. Chem Soc. Faraday Trans. 171 (1975) 1161. 15) J.F. Padday, A.R. Pitt and R.M. Pashley, J. Chem Soc. Faraday Trans. I 7 1 (1975) 1919. 16) J.F. Padday, J. Chem Soc. Faraday Trans. 7 7 5 (1979) 2827. 17) W. Kayser, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 622. 18) N.R. Pallas, B.A. Pethica, Colloids Surf. 6 (1983) 221, Replacement of air by He or Ng at 1 atm. gave no measurable difference but CO2 gave a reduction of 0.07 ± 0.02 mN m~^ at that pressure. 19) S. Ross, R E . Patterson, J. Chem Eng. Data24 (1979) H I . 20) D.N. Furlong, S. Hartland, J. Chem Soc. Faraday Trans. I 76 (1980) 467. 21) T. Kawanishi, T. Seimiya and T. Sasaki, J. Colloid Interface Set 32 (1970) 622. 22) A. Gaonkar, R.D. Neumann, Colloids Surf 27 (1987) 1. 23) N.R. Pallas, Y. Harrison, Colloids Surf. 4 3 (1990) 169. p e r a t u r e control a n d of preventing evaporation a t higher t e m p e r a t u r e s . Results m a y differ s o m e w h a t depending on t h e way in which this is realized; strictly s p e a k i n g t h e surface tension should be m e a s u r e d against its own vapour, b u t s o m e t i m e s other v a p o u r s or g a s e s a r e intentionally a d d e d . Only w h e n t h e s e additives are inert (not surface active) do no problems arise. See t h e note to Pallas' a n d Pethica's work (ref. 18) in the references to table 1.2. Nevertheless, a n u m b e r of detailed m e a s u r e m e n t s of y{T) a r e now available; some d a t a a r e collected in table 1.3 a n d fig. 1.27 gives a representative plot. To avoid overcrowding n o t all available data are reproduced; further information c a n be obtained from table 1.4. Part of t h e incentive for t e m p e r a t u r e d e p e n d e n c e investigations s t e m m e d from a s e a r c h for t h e p r e s e n c e of 'kinks' (significant irregularities) in t h e y(T) behaviour^^ This contention could not be confirmed. In addition to t h e results represented, a n u m b e r of a u t h o r s studied t h e t e m p e r a t u r e dependence carefully, without reporting absolute values. As c a n be seen from fig. 1.27, the lowering of 7 a s a function of T is more or less linear between freezing point a n d room t e m p e r a t u r e . Above t h a t m o s t investigators observed a stronger downward trend, though there is some spread in t h e results. The best way of comparing d a t a by different a u t h o r s is by v o t i n g y{T) a s the series expansion
1) W. Drost Hansen, Ind. Eng. Chem 57 (1965) 18.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.62
Table 1.3. Surface tension of water from 0-100°C. As in table 1.2. 0
5
10
75.60
74.84
75.70
74.96
20
45
50
30
35
74.09 73.33 72.56
71.79
71.01
70.21 69.39 68.57
67.73
74.27 73.51 72.75
71.98
71.21
70.37 69.52 68.76
67.92
(75.26) 74.58 73.78 (73.04) 72.26
71.34
70.68 69.84 69.14
(72.31) (71.58) 70.76 69.78 69.02
(75.29) 74.55 73.75 73.08 75.84
74.36 73.62 72.88 73.3
75.64
40
25
15
74.95
74.23 73.50 72.75
72.14
71.40
70.66 69.92 69.18
72.6
71.8
71.0
71.20
70.41 69.60 68.78
71.99
70.2
69.2
68.45 68.5 67.94
1 (0.01°) 55
60
66.87
66.02
67.05
66.18
65
65.15
70
64.26
75
63.37
80
85
62.48 61.57
90
95
100
Method
60.67
59.74
58.78
HW
DW
diff. CR 66.97
65.49
67.6
66.8
65.9
65.0
64.0
63.1
67.10
66.24
65.36
64.47
63.58
62.67 61.75
Ref.
Remarks
1)
Pendent horizontal wire
2)
Max. bubble pressure
3)
data interpreted from author's table
61.80
62.54
64.01 62.2
60.22
WP
59.7
WP
61.3
60.5
60.82
59.87 58.91
CR
3) 4)
Jasper's linearization
5) 6)
[ri
Data estimated from author's fig. 2 Am. NBS standard data
1) H. Moser, Ann. Physik. 82 (1927) 993. Horizontal wire hanging in the interface ('Biigelmethode'). Moser gives his data in mg mm"^ (conversion 1 mg mm"^ = 9.8067 mN m~M. 2) B.Y. Teitel'baum. T.A. Gortalova and E.E. Sidorova, Zhur. Fiz. Khim. 25 (1951) 911. 3) G.J. Gittens, J. Colloid Interface Set 30 (1969) 406. Careful data in small temperature steps. One of the aims was to check whether kinks occurred in y{T); their existence could not be confirmed. 4) J.J. Jasper, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 1 (1972) 841. 5) D.K. Thakur, K. Hickman, J. Colloid Interface Set 5 0 (1975) 523 for in-process repurification with overflow.
1.63
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
6) W. Kayser, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 622. Emphasized equilibrium with water vapour. 7) N.B. Vargaftik, B.N. Volkov and L.D. Volyak. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 12 (1983) 817. For 0-20°C these data are identical to those of L.D. Volyak, Doklady Akad. Nauk. SSSR 74 (1950) 307; from 30°C onwards the Volyak data become lower till 0.06 mN m"^ at 100°C. The NHS tables give the surface tension till the critical point (374°C).
76L o X a A T
74 72
J a s p e r ' s linearization NBS Gittens Kayser Moser Teitel' b a u m et al.
'^^«
70
^^X
'^^o^
68
^R^
^^K°.
66
Vs
64 62
Av
NE
60
10
20
30
40
_L 50
60
^.
1:^°
70 80 90 temperature
V
58 Figure 1.27. Surface tension of water 0-100°C. y = y(T ) + AT + BT^ + a n d comparing coefficients. Here, T is in deg. Celsius and T
[1.12.1] the melting point on
the same scale (i.e. zero). Results are collected in table 1.4. It a p p e a r s t h a t there is reasonable c o n s e n s u s a b o u t A. Its average value is - 0 . 1 4 1 ± 0.0087 mN m-^ K'^ However, the variation in B is m u c h larger a n d a b o u t a factor of two. This spread is not surprising because all the errors of subtracting the AT term p l u s all the subtleties in carrying o u t m e a s u r e m e n t s at elevated temperatures aire compounded in the BT^ term. Perhaps temperature control is the most difficult; slight deviations between the bulk a n d surface t e m p e r a t u r e (due to evaporation/condensation) may lead to convection ('streamers') affecting t h e force needed to keep surfaces at a n interface or to detach them. Maybe the higher B value by J o h a n s s o n a n d Eriksson is a real feature caused by their u s e of He in the gas p h a s e which does not dissolve in water. The difference between the d a t a by Cini
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.64 Table 1.4.
Coefficients 7(T^), A and B in eq. [1.12.1]. y in mN m-i, T in deg.
Celsius*^ A in mN m-^ T " \ B i n mN m-^ T"^. Codes of the methods as in table 1.2. Author(s)
Year
ref.
Method
y^^J
-A
-Bxl03 1
Moser
1927
75.66
0.1409
0.1981
1951
1) 2)
rect. wire
Teitel'baum et al.
MBP
75.69
0.1413
0.2985
Gittens
1969
3)
DW
75.94
0.1365
0.3827
1969
3)
CR
76.05
0.1480
0.1619
1972
4)
DNR
75.65
0.1379
0.2717
1972
4)
WP
75.67
0.1396
0.2885
Johansson-Eriksson
1972
5)
diff. WP
0.1385
0.445
Kayser
1976
6)
WP
76.24
0.1379
0.3124
1977
7)
DNR
75.72
0.1416
0.2505
Cini et al.
1 Loglio et al.
1
J
1) H. Moser, Ann. Physik. 82 (1927) 993 (range 5-100°C in air; A and B from his formula 141). 2) B.Y. Teitel'baum, T.A. Gortalova, E.E. Sidorova, Zhixr. Fiz. Khim, 25 (1951) 911 (range 0-45°C). 3) G.J. Gittens, J. Colloid Interface Set 30 (1969) 406 (range 5-45°C in N2). 4) R. Cini, G. Loglio and A. Ficalbi, J. Colloid Interface Set 41 (1972) 287 (range 0-50°C, in air). 5) K. Johansson, J.C. Eriksson, J. Colloid Interface Set 40 (1972) 398 (range 5-40°C in He atmosphere); see also K. Johansson, ibid. 48 (1974) 176. 6) W. Kayser, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 622 (range 20-100°C, against vapour). 7) G. Loglio, A. Ficalbi and R. Cini, J. Colloid Interface Set 64 (1977) 198 (improvement of Cini et al. (1972)). et al. a n d Loglio et al. is not attributable to different experiments b u t reflects different accounting for corrections of [1.8.7] (Huh and Mason instead of Harkins). Lacking more detailed information, we settle for the average B = - 0.29 ± 0.08 x lO-^mNm-^T"^. Besides helping to obtain some feehng for the accuracy of d a t a , the above exercise serves a physical purpose; the coefficients A a n d B are, or are closely related to, the surface excess entropy S^ a n d the surface excess specific heat. Regarding the former, it may be recalled from [I.A.5.31 t h a t F"" =
YA
+
^
ju.n^ = LT^ - TS^
[1.12.2]
w^here the superscript a indicates surface excesses. For a monocomponent liquid R^ = 0 (in the Gibbs convention), so
Hi. A
T— A
[1.12.3]
Linearity of y{T] t h e n suggests that the slope is j u s t the excess interfacial entropy
*^ In appendix 1, dealing with a variety of liquids, the temperature is in (rounded) deg. Kelvin.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.65
per u n i t area. As expected, it is a positive quantity. When y[T) is not linear t h e splitting of y in a n energetic and a n entropic part becomes less obvious. We shall return to this in sec. 2.9 b u t note that the expansion [1.12.1] is not without physical meaning. From molecular c o n s i d e r a t i o n s a variety of /(T) r e l a t i o n s h i p s have b e e n proposed. They will be discussed in chapter 2. For anal5rtical p u r p o s e s empirical equations m a y be useful. The NBS-data in table 1.3 are well represented over the whole range u p to the critical temperature T , by ^1.256r
y = 0.2358
1 - 0.625
T cy
T
[1.12.4]
cy
with T =647.15 K. 1.13
Measuring t h e surface t e n s i o n of solids
Measuring the surface tensions of solids poses a problem b e c a u s e it is almost impossible to extend a solid-fluid interface isothermally and reversibly. Stretching a solid-fluid interface is not performed against the interfacial tension, b u t against the interfacial
stress
r. The difference between T a n d / d e p e n d s on the kinetics
a n d history of the extension, so t h a t generally the work w performed is not a sole characteristic of / or, for t h a t matter, a function of state. Only when the extension can be carried out reversibly is it possible to relate r and y. As T is a second order tensor (it h a s normal amd s h e a r components) a n d / is a scalar, this relation is complicated. For the very simple case t h a t r does not depend on direction (a r a t h e r unrealistic situation for solids) a n d a s s u m i n g reversibility the relation is^^
so t h a t from dw = rdA in principle / can be found. The new element a s compared with fluid-fluid interfaces is of course the d / / d A term. For liquids it is zero, b u t very few solids satisfy this requirement. They should be ductile, isotropic a n d perfect, i.e. without crystal faults along which the solid would crack upon stretching. In the literature a n u m b e r of procedures for assessing t h e surface t e n s i o n s of solids have been proposed-^^, b u t none of these is unambiguous. Examples include:
^^ We derived this in sec. 1.2.24. 2) A.W. Adamson, A.P. Gast, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, e.g. 6th ed., Wiley (1997) sec. VI1.5, reviews some of these methods. See also chapter 8 of the book by Rusanov and Prokhorov, mentioned in sec. 1.17c, and the more recent review H.-J. Butt, R. Raiteri, Measurement of the surface tension and surface stress of solids, in Surface Characterization Methods: Principles, Techniques and Applications, A.J. Milling, Ed., Marcel Dekker (1999) ch. 1.
1.66
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
- m e a s u r i n g t h e energy of cleaving crystals (mica). The process is not reversible and at best a n energy is measured, not a Helmholtz energy. - m e a s u r i n g the h e a t of solution of finely dispersed solids a s a function of t h e extent of comminution, i.e. a s a function of interfacial area to be destroyed. Not a n interfacial tension b u t a n excess enthalpy is obtained, a n d the result is a n average over a set of crystal planes. - m e a s u r i n g t h e surface tension for t h e molten material a s a function of t e m p e r a t u r e a n d extrapolate to below the freezing point, T^. This method fails to account for the entropy changes caused by freezing, which, as judged by the U^ a n d TS^ contributions to / (sec. 2.9) may amount to errors of several tens of percents. - s u s p e n d i n g a weight from a (metallic) foil or wire at a temperature close to the melting point. The metal m u s t behave liquid-like, i.e. it flows slowly (exhibits creep). Creep is opposed by the action of the surface tension. When the force of this tension is balanced by t h a t of the suspended weight there is no more creep, a n d the surface tension can be measured (method of zero creep). - deducing interfacial tensions from the change of solubility with size, using the Ostwcdd equation [1.2.23, 25] RT In
c{a) C(oo)
2V^y —2LL
[1.13.2]
where c(a) a n d c(oo) s t a n d for the solubilities for a sphere of r a d i u s a a n d a n infinitely large sphere, respectively, a n d V^ is the molar volume of t h e solid. The m e t h o d requires very precise m e a s u r e m e n t s . Moreover, solid crystals are never perfect s p h e r e s a n d the obtained tension y is some average over t h e v a r i o u s exposed crystal faces. The corollary is t h a t recrystallization o c c u r s s i m u l t a neously by Ostwald ripening. - deducing surface tension from the vapour pressure increase of small spherical particles. According to the Kelvin equation [1.2.23, 24] RT In
Pia) p[o
[1.13.3]
- inferring surface tensions from homogeneous nucleation studies, a s s u m i n g t h e validity of some theory. For i n s t a n c e , according to t h e classical theory, discussed in sec. 1.2.23d, the growth of a (spherical) nucleus from a s u p e r s a t u r a t e d vapour or solution is counteracted by the surface Gibbs energy needed to enlarge the area. Beyond a certain radius a(crit) the driving force c a u s e d by s u p e r s a t u r a t i o n outweighs the counteracting surface force. From a(crit) it is possible to compute y. Apart from the quality of the m e a s u r e m e n t s which are not easy, the validity of the applied theory is a prerequisite, a n d then it is not certain t h a t the value of the obtained tension is representative for macroscopic surfaces.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.67
It may be added that wetting studies cannot give surface or interfacial tensions of solids either. From the contact angle, using Young's law, only the difference between two of such tensions is obtainable, say y^^ - y^^ for a droplet of liquid L on a surface S in vapour G. Had there been an experimental procedure to obtciin an additional relation between y^^ and y^^ the issue would be solved. However, such measurements are not available. In addition, Zisman's critical tension of wetting is an interfacial tension and a chciracteristic of the solid under study, but it cannot be identified as the interfacial tension. We shall return to these issues in sec. 5.1 la. What do we conclude? Except for a few special cases, surface tensions of solids are inoperational quantities. At best some indirect empirical methods are available to obtain data. These data are not better than within several tens of a percent, mainly because reversibility and hence the entropic part is not adequately accounted for. The closest one can come by unambiguous methods is to extrapolate the surface tension of the molten material down to the freezing point. To that end we have, in the tables of appendix 1, made this extrapolation. See the data for y[T ). It may perhaps be repeated that, other things being equal, procedures estimating for y^(T) are always superior to those leading to U^(T), because the former do contain the energetic and entropic contribution (via the GibbsHelmholtz relations) whereas the latter do not give the entropy. The thermodynamic inoperability of /^ does not mean that it is not allowable to use Gibbs' adsorption law, because changes of y^ with T and ju^'s can be carried out reversibly provided the solid is inert. So, the inaccessibility of y^ for dispersed colloid particles does not invalidate the thermodynamics of double layer formation and the various equations obtained by cross-differentiation (see e.g. sees. 1.5.7, II.3.4 and II.3.12a). 1.14 Surface tensions under dynamic conditions In this section we address the measurement of interfacial tensions that are time dependent because the interface is not at equilibrium. Sometimes such tensions are called dynamic surface tensions but we prefer non-equilibrium surface tensions. Their measurement will be discussed in this section, particularly against the background of the techniques described so far. Most of the interpretation (in terms of surface rearrangements, transport to and from interfaces, etc.) and additional monolayer techniques (wave damping, for instance) will be deferred to chapters 3 and 4. For presentation purposes it is expedient to distinguish between pure liquids and solutions. For the former systems the time-dependence is solely determined by the time required for the molecules in the surface to attain their equilibrium distribution. This process is typically of order of milliseconds. In fact, it may be
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.68
vertical cross section
Oooo 0 o
Figure 1.28. Oscillations in a liquid jet, emanating from an elliptical orifice. difficult to disequilibrate a n interface m u c h faster t h a n that. On the other h a n d , for solutions adsorption a n d desorption processes usually determine t h e r a t e of equilibration. Depending on the system and conditions, the time scale can be m u c h longer, of the order of seconds, minutes or even hours. 1.14a
Pure
liquids
One of the oldest examples is a seminal experiment by Lord Rayleigh (1879), sketched in fig. 1.28. A liquid is forced from left to right out of a t u b e t h r o u g h a n elliptical orifice. J u s t outside the cylinder the elliptical perimeter is not the m o s t stable one. The (non-equilibrium) surface tension pulls it b a c k to a circular geometry, b u t d u e to inertia, overshoot takes place so t h a t oscillations ensue. These oscillations a r e d a m p e d by viscous friction. Ultimately, the j e t b r e a k s u p into droplets b e c a u s e of Rayleigh instability (fig. 5.47) (not shown in fig. 1.28). From the liquid velocity, t h e wavelength A, the ellipticity of the cross section a n d a few other p a r a m e t e r s , the surface tension can be determined a s a function of position in t h e oscillating jet, t h a t is, a s a function of age^^ Various corrections a r e needed^^. One of the i s s u e s to be considered now is to a c c o u n t for the velocity profile within the j e t a n d , in this connection, determine the age of the surface. Figure 1.29 gives a typical result. These data agree well with those from the falling meniscus method (sec. 1.11). It is seen that j u s t after leaving the orifice the surface tension is a b o u t 15-20% higher t h a n u n d e r equilibrium conditions a n d t h a t t h e surface of water relaxes within a few milliseconds. After about 3 m s n o difference with the static value is observed anymore. This result was also obtained by Caskey a n d Barlage^^ The decrease y[t) agreed within ca. 4% with older data by Schmidt 1^ N. Bohr, Phil Trans. A 2 0 9 (1909) 281; simplified by R. Defay, J.R. Hommelen, J. Colloid Sci. 13 (1958) 553. 2^ A.I. Rusanov, V.A. Prokhorov, Interfacial Tensiometry (see sec. 1.17c), chapter 6 describes these in some detail. ^^ J.A. Caskey, W.B. Barlage, J. Colloid Interface Set 3 5 (1971) 46.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.69
and Steyer^l So, the order of magnitude of this surface relaxation appears well established. We note that this surface relaxation time is several orders longer than that of individual molecules in bulk liquids and surface layers. Perhaps the collective motion of large sets of molecules involved in surface relaxation is responsible for this relative slowness. Experiments with other liquids would be useful. Kochurova and Rusanov^) extended their dynamic surface tension measurement of water to dynamic Volta potential % measurements of the water surface, using a dynamic condenser method. We introduced the notion of Volta potential in sec. 1.5.5 and return to its measurement in sec. 3.7f. Figure 4.20 gives another illustration. Kochurova and Rusanov observed that /^(t) and ;if^{t) have about the same relaxation time, namely = 0.4 ms, indicating that both measurements refer to the same physical process, i.e. the restructuring of water surfaces. It was found that x^ becomes more positive with time by some tens of mV. In sec. II.3.9 we summarized the present-day insight into j^^(eq.) and concluded that it is positive, although the absolute value is uncertain. Positive x^ potentials mean that molecules at the surface of water point with the negative sides of their dipoles outward. The implication is that for a very fresh surface the surface dipole orientation has the same sign as for a relaxed surface, but is qucintitatively stronger. Most experiments by the authors related to teflon capillaries; perhaps the preferential orientation with respect to a hydrophobic surface is somewhat more pronounced than for a hydrophilic surface, like glass. More detailed experiments would be highly interesting, particularly with a variety of orifices. A variant, with reminiscences to sec. 1.5, is based upon the capillary instability of jets, a topic that has drawn recent interest because of the increasing application of ink jet printers. Such printers are based on the deflection of a liquid jet in an electric field. The idea goes back to Sweet^^ and has given rise to much printing technology. For the present purpose, oscillations in the jet are not produced by an elliptic orifice, but applied externally, say piezo-electrically. Dynamic surface or interfacial tensions can be obtained from, for instance, the (quadrupole) oscillations of drops that have just broken away from the jet, or from the oscillations in the jet just before breaking. Measurements can be carried out down to 10-4 s4). Kochurova and Rusanov also gave a comparison between /"^(t) data obtained by different authors, using a variety of methods. The trends are the same as in fig. 1.29, but there are quantitative differences that are probably related to the nature of the experimental method. We refrain from giving an interpretation of fig. 1.29 1) F. Schmidt, H. Steyer, Ann. Phys. 7 9 (1926) 4 4 2 . 2) N.N. Kochurova, A.I. Rusanov, J. Colloidlnterface Set 8 1 (1981) 2 9 7 . ^^ R.G. Sweet, Rev. Set Instr. 3 6 (1965) 131. "^^ M. Ronay, J. Colloid Interfaee Set 6 6 (1978) 5 5 .
1.70
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
85
o
80 75
o"\, A n
70
^n X
DA
_L
0.001
0.003
0.005
0.007 s time
Figure 1.29. Surface relaxation of pure water. Data from oscillating jet compared with those from falling meniscus (drawn curve). The different symbols refer to experiments with different capillaries. (Redrawn from N.N. Kochurova, Yu. A. Shvechenkov and A.l. Rusanov, Koll Zhur. 36 (1974) 785, transl. 725.) except for noting t h a t the observed decrease with time agrees with a change toward lower interfacial excess Helmholtz energy. 1,14b
Solutions
In contrast to the situation for pure liquids, for which data are scarce, there is a n a b u n d a n c e of information a b o u t non-equilibrium interfacial t e n s i o n s for solutions, particularly for solutions of surface-active s u b s t a n c e s . One r e a s o n is t h a t the latter effect is more m u n d a n e a n d therefore easier to observe. Moreover, it also h a s practical i m p o r t a n c e in m a n y industrial processes. E x p l a n a t i o n s a r e readily offered, a l t h o u g h on closer inspection interpretation of t h e observed relaxation is not always straightforward. One of t h e r e a s o n s why non-equilibrium interfacial t e n s i o n s are easier to m e a s u r e for surfactant solutions t h a n for a p u r e solvent is t h a t the time scale is longer. How m u c h longer d e p e n d s on the system a n d / o r the m e c h a n i s m . Time scales for diffusion of small surfactant molecules to a surface are of the order of 10~2 s or more. When minor components diffuse to the interface, replacing molecules already t h e r e , longer times are found. Conformational c h a n g e s a t t h e interface by polymers or biopolymers may be relatively slow. This is also the case for the exchange of polymer molecules by longer ones. (Polymer solutions a r e usually heterodisperse; the shorter ones diffuse more rapidly t h a n the larger ones (see 115.3d a n d 5.7c) b u t the larger ones adsorb more strongly, so in the long r u n they will displace the shorter molecules.) Some chemical reactions at the interface are also relatively slow (slower t h a n milliseconds). An example is the interfacial hydrolysis of dodecylsulfate to dodecylalcohol; the latter is very surface-active. When, a s part of a measuring technique, a n interface is very rapidly expanded, the check for the initial interface being pristine is t h a t for t -^ 0 y ^ /(solvent).
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.71
M e t h o d s for m e a s u r i n g non-equilibrium interfacial t e n s i o n s of (surfactant) solutions can be divided into two groups. (i) Basically the static techniques discussed so far, modified where required to c a p t u r e the short time range. Some are intrinsically quasi-static. (ii) Techniques specifically designed to m e a s u r e the time-dependence of interfacial properties. Mostly these are not restricted to interfacial t e n s i o n s b u t also allow interfacial rheological properties to be determined, s u c h a s interfacial viscosity a n d elasticity. To this group belong m e t h o d s in which interfaces a r e intentionally subjected to oscillatory or other periodic changes (pulsating bubbles, capillary waves, etc.j^K One of the potentialities of s u c h m e a s u r e m e n t s is t h a t by controlling the frequency a large time regime can be scanned which, u n d e r favourable conditions, m a y include characteristic relaxation t i m e s . W h e n t h e s c a n covers the range from De > 1 till De < 1 the characteristic time (De = 1) is included. We shall defer group (ii) to sec. 3.6 a n d beyond, where interfacial rheology will be more systematically treated. However, we should be aware of the possibility t h a t interfacial rheological p h e n o m e n a m a y interfere, a n d u n d e r certain conditions lead to surprising observations. For example, Lunkenheimer a n d Wantke-^^ found, for certain surfactant-vessel combinations t h a t the pull on a Du Nouy ring depended on the size of the vessel. For other types of vessels a n d for p u r e solvents this effect w a s absent. The observation w a s attributed to the combination of a surface film having a surface elasticity a n d the formation of a wetting film on t h e inner side of the vessel. By pulling u p the ring surface is not newly-created b u t sucked out of t h e wetting film. Regarding group (i) the issue can be split into two sub-problems. First the timedependence of some physical property (capillary rise, s h a p e , weight, ...) is noted a n d measured. Second, this change with time is analyzed to p e l d /(t) where t now indicates the age of the interface. The former is mostly a m a t t e r of technical prowess; experimental set-ups have to be designed to disequilibrate the interface in a controlled way a n d rapidly measure the required physical property. As a rule, the m e a s u r e m e n t of the interfacial tension is easier t h a n establishing the age of the interface; in fact, to obtain y essentially the methods described in sees. 1.3-1.11 can be used. However, determining the age t of the interface requires insight into the physico-chemicad p h e n o m e n a proceeding at, a n d n e a r to, the interface, a n d these involve more t h a n j u s t time-dependent interfacial tensions. More often t h a n not, interfaces out of equilibrium p o s s e s s t r a n s i e n t gradients in the interfacial tension (V/). In t u r n , these lead to hydrodynamic flows, also contributing to the relaxation of the interface. Gravity often also plays a role. So, in order to extract ^^ In rheological parlance such types of measurements are called dynamic', but we shall not use the term in this sense to avoid confusion with non-periodical djmamic measuring techniques. 2) K. Lunkenheimer, K.D. Wantke, J. Colloid Interface Set 66 (1978) 579-81.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.72
the required yit) relationship from the observed change in the physiced variable, one should have insight into the interplay between surface, hydrodynamic, gravitationad and inertia forces. These relationships require models and many of these models are very complicated. For instance, the assumption can be made that y{t) at a fixed area is diffusion-controlled; from that Vy and the ensuing Marangoni-type flows are analyzed, and in turn the time-dependence of the observable ensues. The quality of the premises, and hence the reliability of y{t) proper, then follows from the quality of the fit (Do we observe a decay with t^^^ or with log t ? And over what time range?) Such analyses require much effort and scrutiny. From a practical point of view the issue is often compounded by the fact that many surfactants are not 100% pure. Most non-ionic surfactants are not homodisperse and ionic surfactamts may contain minor, but very surface-active impurities, for which it is often difficult to account. Hence, the problems with the establishment of y and t may be interconnected. With these caveats in mind, let us now discuss some procedures. Table 1.5 reviews the capabilities of the most common (quasi-) static methods (we excluded the very fast oscillating jet and pulsating bubble), obtaining dynamic information. Some of these are intrinsically dynamic in that the measurement requires the extension of an interface (drop weight, maximum bubble pressure), so that yit) data can in principle be obtained when the rate of extension can be varied in a controlled fashion. Others aire basically static (shapes of sessile or pendent drops and bubbles), but can be rendered dynamic by disequilibration. Table 1.5. Extension of some quasi-static techniques to obtain time-dependent surface and interfacial tensions for (surfactant) solutions.*^ Modified after S.S. Dukhin, G. Kretzschmar and R. Miller, Dynamics of Adsorption at Liquid Interfaces (Elsevier, 1995), 142. Method
Shortest time
Temperature
attainable (s)
range (°C)
Suitability LG
Pendent drops Drop weight or volume Max. bubble pressure Wilhelmy plate
LL 1
10
20-25
+
+
1
10-90
+
+
10-3
10-90
+
-
10
20-25
+
-
Du Noiiy ring
30
20-25
+
-
Growing drops/bubbles
10-2
10-90
+
+
^Typically djmamic techniques (overflowing weirs, cylinders, capillary waves, etc,) will be discussed in sec. 3.7 on interfacial rheology.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT Capillary
1.73
rise does not appear in the list, although the rate of rise c a n be very
well m e a s u r e d . However, this rate is mainly determined by the rate of wetting of t h e capillary a n d is easily complicated by irregularities in t h e l u m e n of t h e capillary or by depletion of t h e rising m e n i s c u s (if t h e rise is very fast).. An additional complication is t h a t the contact angle is dynamic a n d may well vary with velocity (fig. 5.5). Hence, y{t) relations are not easily extracted. A variant, proposed by Horozov a n d Amaudov^^ deserves a t t e n t i o n . Liquid flows o u t of a capillary. When the flow is suddenly interrupted, the liquid Jets b r e a k s very rapidly, leaving a small drop with a fresh surface a t the end of the tip. The volume of this drop r e m a i n s constant, b u t u p o n surfactant adsorption t h e capillary p r e s s u r e c h a n g e s , which c a n be m e a s u r e d . The experimental s e t - u p allows y{t) m e a s u r e m e n t s down to 0.05 s. In passing, these a u t h o r s also review the s t a t u s quo of dynamic m e a s u r e m e n t s . Sessile drop m e a s u r e m e n t s also are q u a s i static, although slow changes can be picked u p . Similar things can be said a b o u t pendent
drops. These two measuring techniques can be m a d e more 'dynamic' by
devising a gadget t h a t allows the volume to be changed rapidly, after which t h e change of the profile is measured a n d analyzed a s a function of time, a s described in sec. 1.4. The drop weight, or drop volume method (sec. 1.6) is intrinsically dynamic; the time scale c a n be varied by applying a variable p r e s s u r e on t h e capillary. The volume of the drop is measured as a function of time, and theory is needed to derive y[t]. Practically speaking, this technique is convenient although t h e interpretation m a y offer p r o b l e m s ; t e m p e r a t u r e control is simple, t h e a c c u r a c y is = 0.1 mN m-i and LG and LL interfaces can both be studied. In the maximum bubble pressure method, the interval between two bubbles (~ the lifetime of one bubble) is the only m e a s u r e of the age of the growing surface. S u c h intervals can nowadays be varied between milliseconds and several h o u r s . M o d e m p r e s s u r e t r a n s d u c e r s allow small pressures to be measured rapidly a n d accurately. The trend is t h a t the m a x i m u m p r e s s u r e increases with increasing flow rate, a s expected. Wilhelmy plate, Du Noiiy rings a n d other objects kept in a surface may give rise to a force changing with time. However, this change is attributable not only to t h e time dependence of y b u t cdso to t h a t of cos a. In order to sequester t h e second t r e n d it m a y be expedient to compare m e a s u r e m e n t s with objects of differing wetting properties. In the detachment mode, the influence of the contact angle m a y be reduced or even eliminated, b u t then the hydrodynamics of the process h a s to be considered to obtain the real age of the surface. The Wilhelmy plate method c a n be combined with overflowing weirs or cylinders; then time-scales of order 0.1 s c a n be reached b u t this is beyond the plate method proper. 1^ T. Horozov, L. Arnaudov, J. Colloid Interface Set 219 (1999) 99.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.74 Growing drop methods
constitute a more recent group of techniques, not dis-
c u s s e d so far. They have in common t h a t a drop is formed at the tip of a narrow capillary, inside which the pressure is measured by a very sensitive t r a n s d u c e r . A variety of sophisticated designs to carry out the m e a s u r e m e n t can be found in the recent literature^^. It is beyond t h e p r e s e n t scope to d i s c u s s experimental a n d interpretational details. For further information a review by Miller et al.^^ a n d the book by Dukhin et al., mentioned in sec. 1.17d, may be consulted^l In view of the interpretational p r o b l e m s it m a y be r e c o m m e n d e d to c o m p a r e r e s u l t s obtained by different a p p r o a c h e s . S o m e t e c h n i q u e s , with a r a t h e r rheological n a t u r e (falling or overflowing films, pulsating bubbles, capillary waves, etc.) recur in chapters 3 a n d 4. Anticipating this, in figs. 1.30-1.32 we give some recent illustrations. In fig. 1.30 the surface tension of a sodium dodecylsulfate (NaDS) solution, a s m e a s u r e d by t h e m a x i m u m bubble p r e s s u r e is given. The m a x i m u m age of t h e bubble replaces the time axis. Very fast processes cannot be obtained, so the range of 7 -> 72 mN m-^ for t ^ 0 is not attainable. This experiment illustrates the wellk n o w n complication of the hydrolysis of NaDS to produce the strongly surface 50
h ^
s 45
•*•.
40 -I
1.1111
il.
10
-J
I
' I 111 ii
iiL
lO-^s 10^ bubble age
Figure 1.30. Surface tension of a 6.2 mM solution of purified sodium dodecyl sulfate. Maximum bubble pressure method. (Redrawn from K.J. Mysels, Colloids Surf. 4 3 (1990) 241.) Discussion of the regions I and II in the text.
^^ A. Passerone, L. Liggieri, N. Rando, F. Ravera and E. Ricci, J. Colloid Interface Set 146 (1991) 152, see also ibid.. 169 (1995) 226.; R. Nagarajan, D.T. Wasan. ibid. 159 (1993) 164; C.A. MacLeod, C.J. Radke, ibid.. 160 (1993) 435; X. Zhang, M.T. Harris and O.A. Basaran, ibid. 168 (1994) 47. ^^ R. Miller, P. Joos and V.B. Fainerman, Dynamic Surface and Interfacial Tensions of Surfactant and Polymer Solutions, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 49 (1994) 249. ^^ Recall that at the end of sec. 1.11a few dynamic methods were briefly mentioned.
1.75
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
active dodecyl alcohol (DOH). The initial sample was free of this admixture. The two regimes I and II may probably be attributed to adsorption of NaDS and DOH, respectively, and give some feeling for the rates of the processes involved. Figure 1.31 gives one example of a comparison between results from two different techniques, applied to one and the same system. In this case the (nonionic) surfactant was specially synthesized and well-defined: p-tert.butylphenol with 10 EO groups. It is seen that the results of the (faster) maximum bubble technique and the (slower) drop volume method, connect well. Many more 70 h
maximum bubble pressure ■■■■■■■
50i-
drop volume
A^ "^ ^Wv • ^"'""""""^""^^-"-^--^-A.A,^ . '""
°''°°°° 10"^ M ^-v,,,^5xlO-^M
40 ° ^oocooro
coocccoo
2.5x10"^ M
30
10r2
10"
10"
lO^s
10 time
Figure 1.31. Juxtaposition of the time dependence of the surface tension of a non-ionic surfactant (p-tert butylphenol-Ejo) as measured by two different techniques. (Redrawn from R. Miller, P. Joos and V.B. Fainerman, Progr. Colloid Polyrrt Set 97 (1994) 188.) 40 h cTco^
e S
35
---rH
30 CO
25h
^"^^-a^
c=10-^M
rH 10
15
20s
Figure 1.32. Non-equilibrium interfacial tension at the oil-water interface system: water + hexane, containing palmitic acid, of which the concentration c is indicated. The drawn curves relate to a model interpretation involving diffusion. (Redrawn from J. van Hunsel, G. Bleys and P. Joos, J. Colloid Interface Set 114 (1986) 432.)
1.76
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
examples of s u c h methodical comparisons can be found in the book by Dukhin et al., mentioned in sec. 1.17d. Disagreement between disparate studies can have a methodical (measuring technique), interpretational (computation of surface age) or chemical (purity of surfactant) background. Figure 1.32 deals with adsorption of palmitic acid from hexane to the oil-water interface, using t h e drop volume method. As the drop volume method is relatively slow, t h e initial decay from the pristine hexane-water interfacial tension to t h e first reported d a t a c a n n o t be given. Otherwise stated, t h e d a t a refer to t h e later stages of diffusion. The trend is t h a t equilibration is somewhat slower t h a n t h e adsorption of surfactants from aqueous solution. 1.14c
A note on the pristine
state
ofLG
and LL
surfaces
Surface or interfacial tension m e a s u r e m e n t s offer one possibility of verifying the absence of impurities at interfaces. First, measured values should not change with time (provided the fast surface r e a r r a n g e m e n t s discussed in sec. 1.14a are fully relaxed). Second, the absolute Vcilues should agree with s t a n d a r d data, where available. The latter a r g u m e n t is not fully u n a m b i g u o u s b e c a u s e the conditions u n d e r which t h e experiment w a s carried out may have played a role (the tension may depend on the n a t u r e of the gas applied to obtain a given pressure) a n d even s t a n d a r d d a t a may be subject to improvement. See the introductory notes to table Al. However, t h e dynamics of interfaces offer a n additional, a n d more sensitive option to ascertain virginity. Pristine surfaces should have tensions t h a t neither depend on the area nor chamge u p o n compression or expansion. When, on the other h a n d , impurities a r e p r e s e n t t h e t r e n d is t h a t their interfacial c o n c e n t r a t i o n s increase with compression and decrease with expansion, both to a rate-determined extent, with a concomitant change in the tension. Figure 1.33 gives a n illustration^^. In this case the interfacial tension of the commercial product is not only lower t h a n t h a t of the purified sample, b u t it also c h a n g e s u p o n a l t e r n a t i n g compression a n d expansion cycles. Generally, gradients of interfacial t e n s i o n s a n d their dependence on area changes are more sensitive indicators of interfacial impurities t h a n t h e absolute values. S u c h m e t h o d s c a n detect the presence of impurities, b u t c a n n o t identify their nature-^^ An illustrative example refers to the n - a l k a n e - w a t e r interface, a s reported by Goebel a n d Lunkenheimer*^). For a n u m b e r of 'as received' a l k a n e s the interfacial tension against water appeared to decrease a s a function of time; moreover it went u p upon expansion cind down u p o n compression. Apparently, the alkanes contained a slowly adsorbing surface-active 1) Basically the same idea was already suggested by Mysels and Florence, J. Colloid Interface Set 4 3 (1973) 577. 2^ K. Lunkenheimer, R. Miller, J. Colloid Interface Set 120 (1987) 176. 3) A. Goebel, K. Lunkenheimer, Langmair 13 (1997) 360.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.77
52 ^.''lllll'BKavMM^IiriPillllUB^III ■B""%V'B'I''IL%1I""H"HI!''VVII"'I"""""WH"'IIIH' 1
(a)
-
s
51 -
50 1
1
ci'^DPD°n'a-n-D^ 49
\ 500
1 1 1
1 1 1
[JCn^DDn-n-D
\
\
1
1000
1500
2000 s time
Figure 1.33. Test for the pristine state of the water-decane interface. The interfacial tension is measured during compression and expansion cycles: (a) meticulously purified decane, (b) commercial decane sample. (Redrawn from R. Miller, P. Joos and V.B. Fainerman, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 49 (1994) 249.) component. This impurity could be removed by passing t h e a l k a n e s a b o u t five times over a column of alumina. After this cleaning procedure, t h e obtained tension w a s slightly higher t h a n those tabulated in t h e literature. Most interestingly, these critically-evaluated tensions showed indications of a n odd-even
alteration
as
a function of chain length, t h e tension being slightly, b u t significantly ( - 0 . 3 mN m"^) higher for t h e even hydrocarbons. So far, s u c h effects have commonly been reported for b u l k properties, like melting points, molar volumes a n d solubilities in water, b u t n o t yet for surface properties. P e r h a p s they a r e related to packing constraints. 1.15
Bending moduli
Basically, all t h e m e t h o d s for measuring interfacial tensions described so far have in common t h a t t h e Helmholtz energy for extending a n interface is determined. Upon this extension, t h e interfacial tension should not vary, otherwise t h e q u a n tity y would become ill-defined. One of the changes t h a t might be incurred could result from strong curving of t h e interface. In t h e present chapter this i s s u e w a s avoided b e c a u s e we have only considered macroscopic interfaces with radii of c u r v a t u r e s above 0 ( 1 0 - 1 0 0 nm). Already in sec. 1.2.23c we showed t h a t / is t h e n still independent of curvature. Another way of changing the Helmholtz energy of a n interface is by bending it. For simple fluids t h i s force will b e negligible, u n l e s s t h e r a d i u s of c u r v a t u r e becomes a s small a s t h e 'thickness' of t h e interface. Here we shall disregard this
1.78
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
situation, b e c a u s e t h e n the macroscopic n a t u r e of interface loses its meaning, a s d o e s t h a t of interfacial tension. However, interfaces carrying m o n o l a y e r s of s u r f a c t a n t s , lipids, etc. u s u a l l y display a significant r e s i s t a n c e to b e n d i n g a t weaker c u r v a t u r e s , say for radii in the colloidal range. Moreover, b e c a u s e of t h e packing of these surfactants, s u c h interfaces may exhibit a spontaneous
curvature
a n d work then h a s to be done to change this curvature. From the required force the so-called bending moduli (sometimes called bending elastic moduli) can be derived. Like
the
interfacial
tension,
bending
moduli
are
system-characteristic
parameters. Measurement of bending moduli is a n issue of growing interest. Obviously they m u s t play a role in the formation a n d stability of micro-emulsions, where t h e type of e m u l s i o n formed (o/w or w/o) will be p r e d o m i n a n t l y d e t e r m i n e d by t h e s p o n t a n e o u s curvature of the interface and by its resistance against further curving. (Macro-emulsions are thermodynamically unstable, for these this a r g u m e n t does not apply. Moreover, usually the curvature is not strong.) Vesicles provide a n o t h e r relevant example. More indirectly, bending moduli also play their roles in some properties of thin liquid films a n d m e m b r a n e s . The reason is t h a t each free liquid interface is subject to small thermal fluctuations, ripples or
undulations.
The interfacial tension opposes this rippling, b u t the extent to which this h a p p e n s is determined by the change of y with bending. For bilayers a n d vesicles y ~ 0 a n d resilience against c h a n g e s in curvature is entirely d u e to the resistance against bending. One of the consequences is t h a t physically observable p h e n o m e n a like (i) surface rugosity a n d (ii) undulation forces, depend on the moduli. This suggests m e t h o d s of m e a s u r e m e n t . Regarding the former, [1.10.2] may be recalled, where a bending modulus k^ a p p e a r s in the denominator, the k^q^ term accounting for t h e inhibition of surface u n d u l a t i o n s because of the restoring bending force. The l.h.s. is m e a s u r a b l e . Regarding (ii) there are two famous equations by Helfrich^). For the Helmholtz energy per unit area, caused by undulations F^^(bending) = i / C j ( j - j j ^ +k^K
[1.15.1]
a n d for the interfacial tension yiJ.K)
= 7(0,0) + ^k^J^- k^J^J-^k^K
[1.15.2]
Here, a s before, J is the first, or mean, curvature a n d K t h e second, or G a u s s , curvature, see [1.1.4 a n d 5]. J
is the s p o n t a n e o u s m e a n c u r v a t u r e . For sym-
metrical interfaces ^Q = 0. Here, we shall neglect the spontaneous G a u s s curvature. The interfacial tension for the u n b e n t surface is 7(0,0). The two bending moduli have dimensions of energy a n d are of the order of k T . We shall call k^ a n d k^ t h e ^^ W. Helfrich, Z. Naturjorsch. 28c (1973) 693; 33a (1978) 305.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
(a)
(b)
1.79
(c)
Figure 1.34. Illustration of the bending types responsible for the moduli k^ (from (a) to (b)) and k^ (from (a) to (c)). first, or mean, a n d the second, or Gauss bending modulus, respectively^^. These two moduli a r e t h e r m o d y n a m i c , r a t h e r t h a n m e c h a n i c a l q u a n t i t i e s ; t h e y h a v e a n entropic a n d a n energetic pairt. Sometimes k^ is called the saddle modulus
splay
(bending)
b e c a u s e it expresses the resilience against saddle-like bending (fig. 1.34),
a t l e a s t if it is positive. For colloid science u s u a l l y k^ is t h e
determining
parameter. For instance, Helfrich derived from [1.15.1] a n 'undulation force' across thin liquid films originating from the correlations between the u n d u l a t i o n s on the two surfaces. The Helmholtz energy F(und) w a s inversely proportional to k^ a n d decreased a s h~^ (h is t h e film thickness), j u s t a s the Van der Waals energy, see [1.4.6.2], F(und) h a s to be added to the other components of the disjoining pressure. The second bending m o d u l u s plays a role in, for instance, p h a s e diagrams. Measuring k^ and k^ is subject to various pitfalls. One of t h e difficulties is t h a t bending is rarely the sole physical process taking place. Usually, extension of t h e area c a n n o t be avoided, so t h a t the bending term appears in equations next to the / d A t e r m , which is m u c h higher (see the denominator of [1.10.2]). Only for very low y c a n t h e bending term dominate. Brochard et al.-^^ argued t h a t this would b e t h e case for vesicles. Very low interfacial tensions are also needed to obtain microemulsions. Another issue is whether the bending takes place at constant n u m b e r of moles (n.'s) in the system or at constant chemical potentials (A^.'S). In t h e former case t h e chemical potentials c h a n g e u p o n bending; in t h e latter curving a n interface will lead to changes in the adsorbed a m o u n t s (r.'s). Still a n o t h e r problem is t h a t of interfacial rheology, discussed in sec. 1.10. The conclusion is t h a t we are dealing with a subtle feature t h a t rarely s t a n d s on its own a n d requires precise definition of the process conditions. The thermodynamics to lay t h e foundations for t h a t will be considered in sec. 4.7. Anticipating this, we shall now briefly indicate the line of reasoning. For a curved interface, the Gibbs equation requires two additional t e r m s , to
^ In_the literature, the nomenclature may vary. Some authors use the pair k and K, k and k, k and K, or k^ and k^. Sometimes only one modulus, called kor k , is used, tacitly identified with our k^, or with k.-\-k^/2. 2J F. Brochard, P.G. de Gennes and P. Pfenty, J. Phys. 37 (1976) 1099.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.80
account for the two curvatures. Formally, dy = - S^dT - ^
[1.15.3]
rdju^ + C^dJ + C^dK
The coefficients C^ and C^ are the first a n d second bending momenU respectively. Formally their definitions are
'='-m
<=.=©]
[1.15.4a,bJ
T./ip
T./i/!
Cj h a s the dimensions of a force, C^ those of a n energy. The constancy restraint on the chemical potentials indicate t h a t the underlying bending h a s to be carried o u t a t c o n s t a n t composition. When T a n d the u's are fixed, / is only a function of J and K. Expanding y[J, K) in a Taylor series u p to second order a r o u n d the u n b e n t state ( J = 0 , K = 0 ) , YiJ.K) = x(0,0) + q ( 0 , 0 ) J + 0^(0,0)K + -EjjJ^
-^'^KK^^
+
^JK^^ [1.15.5]
Here, /(0,0) is t h e interfacial t e n s i o n , considered t h u s far in t h i s c h a p t e r . Expansion a r o u n d ( J , K = 0,0) implies t h a t strong c u r v a t u r e s are neglected, i.e. K^(~ R~^] and JK{- R"^) should be small. Then the term with J^(~ R"^) dominates. Negligible values of K^ a n d JK m e a n t h a t the thickness of the interface is « JR . The t h r e e coefficients E are elastic
moduli;
they are related to t h e s e c o n d
derivatives of / with respect to J and K and, using [1.15.4 and 5], can be written as
^jj
=
KK
dJ
T.M.s.K
fdC^'' ^JK-
dK
[1.15.6a,b]
(dKJT./i.'s.J
[1.15.6c,d]
^^ = T.n's.J
T,M's,K
The coefficients C^ and C^ in [1.15.5] in the perturbed state can be related to the state where 7 is a minimum, i.e. to the spontaneous curvatures J^ and K^: Cj(0,0)
^jj^o-
C^{0,0] =
^KK^O
[1.15.7a]
^JK^O ■
[1.15.7b]
^JK^O
Substitution in [1.15.4] yields yiJ.K)
= y(0,0) ^ {-E^J^ + ^E^j'^-¥
- E^^K^)j
i EKK K^-^ E
^ [-E^K^
JK
-
E^^J^)K [1.15.8]
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.81
This equation may be compared with Helfrich's expression [1.15.2]. It is concluded t h a t Helfrich neglected terms with K^ and JK and t h a t the following identies hold: '^1 = ^ . .
^2 = ^2(0.0)
11.15.91
where J ^ follows from the criterion (dy/dJ)^^ = 0 , or from [dy/dJ]^^
=0^(0,0) =
This derivation confirms t h a t k^ a n d k^ are t h e r m o d y n a m i c , r a t h e r t h a n mechanical quantities. We shall generalize the thermodynamic formalism in sec. 4.7. Bending moduli c a n in principle be obtained for two types of s y s t e m s : (i) extended, flat surfaces or interfaces, the subject m a t t e r of this section, a n d (ii) surfaces t h a t are already strongly curved, a n d for which y is zero or extremely low, s u c h a s in vesicles or micro-emulsions. For instance s u c h moduli c a n b e inferred from s h a p e
fluctuations,
from the Kerr effect (sec. 1.7.14] or from polydispersity
using some scattering technique. We repeat t h a t this type of m e a s u r e m e n t is often a m b i g u o u s because the bending contributions to the Helmholtz energy c a n only be estimated when all other contributions are accurately known. Group (i) techniques include various scattering methods a n d ellipsometiy. Light scattering w a s already discussed in sec. 1.10. X-ray reflectivity is a n alternative. It is less a c c u r a t e t h a n ellipsometry, b u t can be applied for relatively large surface t e n s i o n s , like those of monolayers a t the solution-air interface^^ Ellipsometry leads to a p a r a m e t e r containing s t r u c t u r a l information of t h e interface together with information a b o u t surface r o u g h n e s s a n d the two contributions have to be deconvoluted^K Ellipsometry works well if / < 10"^ mN m"^ and k = 0{kT). In table 1.6 some r e s u l t s are collected. The presence of electrolytes in t h e a q u e o u s p h a s e a n d admixtures s u c h a s b u t a n o l (which partitions over t h e two phases) serves to reduce the interfacial tension considerably. AOT is one of the few s u r f a c t a n t s that, without s u c h co-surfactants, c a n lower interfacial t e n s i o n s so drastically t h a t micro-emulsions can form spontaneously. Accepting the various problems in t h e m e a s u r e m e n t , it is provisionally concluded t h a t all k values are 0(kT),
except for solid monolayers, for which the m o d u l u s is higher by two orders
of magnitude. Anticipating further discussions on micro-emulsions, p l a n n e d for volume V, it is noted t h a t k^, or k^, or the combination (2/Cj -^k^) can also be obtained u s i n g scattering techniques or, preferably, combinations thereof. For instance, n e u t r o n spin echo spectroscopy (NSES) can be combined with small-angle n e u t r o n scattering (SANS) or with d y n a m i c light scattering. Alternatively,
2k^ + k^ c a n be
obtained from the polydispersity of the micro-emulsion a n d t h e n a second type of
1^ J. Meunier, L.T. Lee, Langmuir? (1991) 1855. 2) J. Meunier, Condens, Matter 2 (1990) SA.347.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.82
Table 1.6. Bending moduli (k) for some flat monolayers. Method
k^/kT
Ref.
Water phase, containing
Non-aqueous phase
Surfactant
NaCl
toluene + butanol
NaDS
ellipsometry
1.0
1)
NaCl
dodecane + butanol
NaHBS
ellipsometry
0.4
1)
NaBr
toluene + butanol
DTAB
ellipsometry
0.4
1)
NaBr
dodecane + butanol
CTAB
ellipsometry
0.4
1}
_
heptane
AOT
ellipsometry
1.6
2)
alkanes, Cfi-Ci4
AOT
ellipsometry
1 ^ 0
3)
_
octane
^10^4
ellipsometry
0.8
4)
-
air (liq. monolayer)
BA
X-ray
~1
5)
-
air (solid monolayer)
BA
X-ray
120-300
5)
Notes. NaDS = Na dodecylsulfate, DTAB = dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide, CTAB = cetyltrimethylammonium bromide, AOT = Aerosol-OT (di-n-octyl Na sulfosuccinate) BA = behenic acid. References: ^^B.P. Binks, J. Meunier, O. Abillon and D. Langevin, LAingmuir 5 (1989) 415 (data renormalized using [1.10.3]; ^^D. Langevin, J. Meunier, Interfacial Tension: Theory and Experiment, in Micelles, Membranes, Micro-emulsions and Monolayers, W.M. Gelbart, A. Ben-Shaul and D. Roux, Eds., Springer (1994), their table 10.1, p. 505; ^^B.P. Binks, H. Kellay and J. Meunier, Europhys. Lett 16 (1991) 53. [k^ decreases rather rapidly between CJQ and Cjj); ^U. Meunier, L.T. Lee, Langmuir 7 (1991) 1855; ^^J. Daillant, L. Bosio, J.J. Benattar and J. Meunier, Europhys. Lett 8 (1989) 435. m e a s u r e m e n t allows the e s t a b h s h m e n t of k^ and k^ separately. In table 1.7 some illustrative r e s u l t s are collected. For a discussion of the r a t h e r involved analysis a n d the interpretational steps see the original literature. The results are in line with those in table 1.6. The increase of k^ with hydroc a r b o n c h a i n l e n g t h of t h e s u r f a c t a n t is well e s t a b l i s h e d a n d a g r e e s w i t h expectation. Negative values of the saddle-splay m o d u l u s k^ m e a n t h a t t h e oil t e n d s to form droplets in the water. It is expected t h a t in the n e a r future more a n d better d a t a will be m e a s u r e d , because there is considerable theoretical effort in this area. 1.16
Applications
Interfacial a n d surface tensions are the most important characteristics of fluidfluid interfaces a n d hardly any paper exists in which s u c h tensions do not play a central role. In fact the entire present volume of FICS will be devoted to them. In c h a p t e r 2 a molecular interpretation will be given. Chapters 3 a n d 4 deal extensively with liquid-fluid interfaces containing s p r e a d a n d a d s o r b e d molecules, respectively a n d c h a p t e r 5 will treat three-phase contacts. For all t h e s e applications, m e a s u r e m e n t is a first and necessary element. Langmuir troughs, to be described in sec. 3 . 3 . 1 , also involve a kind of interfacial tension determination since
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
Table 1.7
B e n d i n g m o d u l i k^ a n d k
1.83
for m i c r o - e m u l s i o n s .
Interface
Surfactant
Techniques
k^/kT
-k^/kT
Ref.
D2O - Cg (d)
^10^5
NSES + DLS
0.98
0.38
1)
D2O - Cg (d)
^10^5
scattering + spinning drop
0.9
0.31
2)
^10^5
NSES + DLS
1.25
0.8
3)
D2O - Cio (d)
{2k^+k2)/kT D2O - Cjo (d)
^8^3
polydispersity
1.20
4)
D2O - Cio (d)
^10^4
polydispersity
2.28
4)
D2O - Cio (d)
^12^5 C12DMAO
polydispersity
3.42
4)
polydispersity
1.98
5)
D2O - Cio (d)
C14DMAO
polydispersity
4.18
5)
1 D2O - Cio (d)
CigDMAO
polydispersity
5.53
5)
D2O - Cio (d)
Notes. Cg = octane, CJQ = decane, DMAO = dimethylamine oxide; code for non-ionics as before (sec. II.2.7d); (d) means deuterated. References: ^^T. Hellweg, D. Langevin, Phys. Rev. E57 (1998) 6825. 2)T. Sottman. R. Strey, J. Chem. Phys. 106 (1997) 8606. 3)T. Hellweg, D. Langevin, Physica A264 (1999) 370. "^^M. Gradzielsky, D. Langevin and B. Farago, Phys. Rev. E53 (1996) 3900. ^^M. Gradzielsky, D. Langevin, T. Sottmann and R. Strey, J. Chem. Phys. 106 (1997) 8232. they m e a s u r e a n interfacial pressure, t h a t is, the difference between the tensions in the presence amd absence of a n adsorbate or spread layer of insoluble molecules. L i p p m a n capillary electrometers are also b a s e d on t h e m e a s u r e m e n t of a n interfacial tension, in this case a s a function of a n applied potential. We already discussed these in sec. 11.3.10b. In volumes IV a n d V interfacial tensions will also recur frequently. Heeding FICS style, we have restricted our discussion to ambient conditions of temperature a n d pressure. Thus, a s a matter of choice, extreme conditions, s u c h a s m e a s u r e m e n t s close to the critical point or at t e m p e r a t u r e s where m e t a l s melt have b e e n excluded. The former is r a t h e r of theoretical interest. The latter is relevant for casting, welding a n d soldering, a n d one might recognize c o m m o n features (the s h a p e of a sessile molten iron drop may change v^th time b e c a u s e of chemisorption of oxygen from the atmosphere). Besides the applications to follow, several of the measuring m e t h o d s discussed in this chapter, are b a s e d on p h e n o m e n a having applications of their own right. Let u s j u s t mention a few examples. Capillary
rise plays a n i m p o r t a n t role in agriculture, since it allows crop
production in levels above the ground water table (already mentioned in sec. 1.3b). In tall trees water can rise by over 50 m through narrow capillaries. This h a p p e n s without cavitation. Capillary depression is u s e d in mercury porosimetry;
from t h e
a m o u n t of mercury t h a t c a n be pressed into a porous surface a s a function of the applied pressure, insight about the pore size distribution can be obtcdned, see sec.
1.84
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
II. 1.6b. Phenomena involving capillary penetration will be discussed in sec. 5.9; they are very relevant for a number of industrial processes. In fact, several techniques yield / cos a rather than / ; the trend is that / is more easily measured than cos a. Capillary pressures also recur widely. Capillary liquid bridges between particles tend to pull these particles together. It is one of the reasons for the coherence of moist powders, which may become fluffy upon drying. Such capillary forces have to compete with double layer repulsion and Van der Waals attraction, and under some conditions may outweigh these. Oscillating Jets find a modern application in ink jet printing, but are also encountered in vairious spray-techniques. When a fluid is pressed out of a manifold through a nozzle under an overpressure, the emanating jet usually breaks down into droplets of irregular size. By applying a rapidly alternating pressure, say piezo-electrically, the oscillations in the jet can be controlled, and after break-up due to the Rayleigh instability the ensuing droplets are homodisperse. Applications of interfacial tensions under dynamic conditions are manifold. Processes involving foaming or emulsijication (say in froth flotation or in the food industry) require rapid expansion of interfaces, immediately followed by adsorption of stabilizing surfactants. Properties of the final product are to a large extent determined by the djniamics during the preparation stage. An example is the rather general Bancroft rule for emulsions, which states that the type formed (o/w or w/o) is such that the liquid into which the emulsifier dissolves best becomes the continuous phase. This rule can be explained by the dynamics of the creation and subsequent resilience against coalescence of new interfaces. See sec. 4.8. Flooding of oil fields is another example where interfacial reactions lead to changes of the interfacial tension. The issue is essentially a wetting problem; the oil in the pores of the shales should be displaced by the fluid applied, which may be (caustic) water, a polymer solution, steam, or still something else, depending on the demands of the system, including the relative water- or oil-wettability of the rock. Under conditions where the interfacial tension is, or becomes, very low not only does the tension itself become relevant but also the bending moduli. More information will follow in chapters 3-5. 1.17
General References
1.17a lUPAC recommendations Manual of Symbols and Terminology for Physicochemical Quantities and Units: Appendix II. Definitions, Terminology and Symbols in Colloid and Surface Chemistry, part I, Pure and Appl Chem. 3 1 (1972) 577. (This general recommendation also covers interfacial tensions and related topics.)
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.85
1.17b Tcibulations F.R. de Boer. R. Boom, W.C.M. Mattens, A.R. Miedema and A.K. Niessen. Cohesion in Metals, Transition Metal Alloys, North Holland (1988). (Contains a table of surface energies, of metals, obtained by extrapolation of yV^^^ down to the melting point.) J.J. Jasper, The Surface Tension of Pure Liquid Compounds, J. Phys, Chem. Ref Data 1 (1972) 841-1010. (Extensive tabulations, mostly as a function of temperature. Linearized plots are given, valid for at least part of the Y(T) range between 0 and 100°C, see fig. 1.27.) G. Korosi, E.G. Kovats, Density and Surface Tension of 83 Organic Compounds, J. Chem. Eng. Data 26 (1981) 323. (Mostly from 20-80°C; attempts to discriminate between conflicting literature data.) Electrical Properties of Interfaces. Compilation of Data on the Electrical Double layer on Mercury Electrodes. J. Lyklema. R. Parsons, Eds. Publ. U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Natl. Bur. Standards, Office of Standard Reference Data (1983). (Contains electrocapillaiy data for the mercury-aqueous solution interface.) N.B. Vargaftik, B.N. Volkov and L.D. Volyak, J. Phys. Chem. Ref Data 12 (1983) 817. (Surface tension of water between 0 and 374°C.) 1.17c Capillarity, shapes of fluid bodies etc. F. Bashforth, J.C. Adams, An Attempt to Test the Theories of Capillary Action. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge (UK) (1883). (Extended tables giving the profile x(z] in eq. [1.3.14] as a function of 0 for various closely spaced values of p. Boucher et al. noted that these tables involved painstaking efforts of C. Powalky. In addition, several students, working with hand-driven calculators, contributed. The computations were completed as early as 1853.) E.A. Boucher, Capillary Phenomena: Properties of Systems with Fluid/Fluid Interfaces, Rep. Progr. Phys. 43 (1980) 496-546. (Analysis of basic capillarity laws, apphcation to the shapes of drops, bubbles, holms and fluid bridges and the determination of interfacial tensions.) E.A. Boucher, M.J.B. Evans and T.G.J. Jones, The Computation of Interface Shapes for Capillary Systems in a Gravitational Field. Adv. Colloid Interface Set 27 (1987) 43. (Analysis of equations for interfacial shapes and numerical analysis of the involved differential equations; contains computer program in BASIC.) S. Hartland, R.W. Hartley, Axisymmetric Fluid-Liquid Interfaces. Tables giving the Shape of Sessile and Pendent Drops and External Menisci, with Examples of their Use. Elsevier (1976). (Comprehensive Runge-Kutta integration, computer
1.86
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
program in Fortran included.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, A.W. Neumann, J.K. Spelt, Eds., Surfactant Science Series, no. 6 3 , Marcel Dekker (1996). (Capillarity, interpretation of interfacial tensions, wetting, theoretical rather than applied.) J.F. Padday, Surface Tension, Part 11. The Measurement of Surf ace Tension in Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 1, E. Matijevic, Ed. Wiley-Interscience (1969), p. 101 (review of methods, contains some required tables); J.F. Padday, Surface Tension, Part III Tables Relating the Size and Shape of Liquid Drops to the Surface Tension, ibid, p. 151. (Collation of Bashforth and Adams' tables and extensions or modifications to make them more suitable for actual situations; contains an introduction to explain the conversion of parameters in different geometries.) H.M. Princen, The Equilibrium Shape of Interfaces, Drops and Bubbles. Rigid and Deformable Particles at Interfaces, in Surface and Colloid Science, E. Matijevic, Ed., Wiley-Interscience (1969), 1. (Analysis of a variety of shapes, including those around floating fluid or solid objects.) Interfacial Tensiometry, A.I. Rusanov, V.A. Prokhorov, Eds. Original Russian version Khimiya, St. Petersburg (1994), English transl. Elsevier (1996). (This book is especially valuable because of the very detailed analysis and documentation on capillarity and interfacial tension determination.) H. Schubert, Kapillaritdt in porosen Systemen, Springer (1982). (Emphasis on capillary bridges in porous systems, static and dynamic systems, wetting and dewetting. The book was primarily intended for engineers.) D.W.G. White, A Supplement to the Tables of Bashforth and Adams, Queen's Printers, Ottawa, Canada (1967). K.L. Wolf, Physik und Chemie der Grenzfldchen, Band II, Die Phdnomene in Besonderen, Springer (1959). (Chapter A, entitled Gestalt und Uberformung, deals with capillary phenomena.) 1.17d Measuring interfacial and surface tensions A.W. Adamson, A.P. Oast, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, e.g. sixth ed. (1997). (Their second chapter, entitled Capillarity, reviews several methods of measuring surface tensions, mostly in less detail than here.) A Couper, Surface Tension and its Measurement, chapter 1 in Investigations of Surfaces and Interfaces, Part A. B.W. Rossiter, R.C. Baetzold, Eds., Physical Methods of Chemistry Series, IXA, 2nd ed. Wiley (1993). (A fairly complete review also containing a section on non-equilibrium tensions.)
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MEASUREMENT
1.87
S.S. Dukhin, G. Kretzschmar and R. Miller, Dynamics of Adsorption at Liquid Interfaces, Elsevier (1995). (Although the emphasis is on the kinetics of adsorption, desorption and chemical reactions at interfaces, much information on the measurement and interpretation of interfacial and surface tensions can be found.) Drops and Bubbles in Interfacial Research. D. Mobius, R. Miller, Eds., Elsevier (1998). (Includes discussion of some of the measuring techniques described in this chapter.) A.W. Neumann, R.J. Good, Techniques for Measuring Contact Angles, in Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 2 (1979), E. Matijevic, Ed., p. 31. (Review contaiins many technical details relevant for surface tension measurements.) J.F. Padday, (1969). See the reference in sec. 1.17c. J.R. Partington, An Advanced Treatise of Physical Chemistry, Vol. Ill, The Properties of Liquids, Longmans (1951) 174. (Sections 12-17 inclusive, give a review of surface tension measurements with abundant references to older work.) A.I. Rusanov, V.A. Prokhorov, (1996). See the reference in sec. 1.17c. (The main part of this book is devoted to interfacial tension determination.) K.L. Wolf, Physik und Chemie der Grenzfldchen, Band I, Die Phdnomene im Allgemeinen, Springer (1957). (Notion of interfacial tension, measurement, interpretation.)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9
2.10 2.11
2.12 2.13
Introductory considerations Thermodjniamic and statistical thermodynamic fundamentals. Flat interfaces Interfacial tension and interfacial pressure tensor Interfacial tensions and distribution functions Van der Waals theory 2.5a Some elements of van der Waals' theory 2.5b Comments and consequences 2.5c Van der Waals theory in the Hamaker-de Boer approximation Cahn-Hilliard theory Interfacial tensions from simulations The thickness of the interfacial region Quasi-thermodynamic approaches. Effects of temperature and pressure. Corresponding states 2.9a Influence of temperature. Energetic and entropic contributions 2.9b Influence of pressure 2.9c Surface tensions as capillary waves Lattice theories for the interpretation of interfacial tensions Empirical relationships 2.1 la Relations containing molar volumes and compressibilities 2.11b Relationships for interfacial tensions, containing geometric means 2.11c Other empirical relationships Conclusions and applications General references
2.3 2.5 2.9 2.11 2.17 2.18 2.25 2.31 2.34 2.37 2.43 2.48 2.48 2.57 2.59 2.60 2.64 2.64 2.68 2.72 2.73 2.76
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Interfacial tensions of fluid-fluid interfaces are well-defined system properties, and measurable by a variety of methods. It may be stated that interfacial tensions are the prime characteristics of phase boundaries. They must have their roots in the molecular interactions and distributions in the interface. No wonder that over almost two centuries attempts have been made to establish such molecular interpretations. At present the situation is such that no generally valid theory is quantitatively available to interpret interfacial tensions of all liquids at all temperatures between the melting point and the critical point. Approaches to interpret interfacial tensions can, in a broad sense, be classified into the following categories. (i) Formalistic interpretations, in which interfacial tensions are, as rigorously as possible, written in terms of intermolecular interactions and distributions. Examples are the Kirkwood-Buff and van der Waals/Cahn-Hilliard theories. The rigour of these formalisms is partly offset by the non-availability of the required molecular information. (ii) Theories based on specific molecular models for the liquid state, like regular solution or lattice-hole theories. Such approaches are less general than those of the first category, but can produce precise predictions in specific cases. (iii) Simulations (Molecular Dynamics or Monte Carlo) offer promises but require objective information on interaction energies and require substantial computer power, because heterogeneous systems have to be covered. (iv) Purely empirical estimations in which interfacial tensions are related to other physical characteristics of the system, say, the molecular volume or the compressibility. The predicting value is limited but orders of magnitude are sometimes readily obtainable. In the present chapter we will attempt to systematize and analyze the fundamentals of the various approaches. In doing so, we will try to attain a level that is high enough to cover the essential physical phenomena, but will avoid advanced mathematical arguments. Roughly speaking this will be done in the above sequence. Readers who are not interested in formalistic approaches can therefore start later in this chapter, and conversely. We shall only consider flat, macroscopic fluid-fluid, one- or two-component systems, meaning that for the moment only surface tensions of pure liquids against their vapour and interfacial tensions between two, immiscible but mutually
2.2
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Figure 2.1. Schematic diagram of a possible molecular distribution across the interface between two fluids. Molecules of equal size, absence of adsorption. The p^'s represent number densities. Molecules a dissolve better in fluid p than the other way around. When the a molecules are absent the diagram represents the surface of liquid p. s a t u r a t e d , otherwise p u r e liquids will be considered, without a d s o r b a t e s . The dependence y(T) is a n important characteristic, almost a s relevant a s the value of 7 itself b e c a u s e it represents the interfacial excess entropy. Therefore, temperature effects will b e c o n s i d e r e d from t h e very o n s e t . Curved interfaces
become
particularly important w h e n adsorbates are present a n d will therefore be deferred to c h a p t e r 4. Very strongly curved m o n o c o m p o n e n t surfaces a r e theoretically interesting a n d relevant for e.g. nucleation p h e n o m e n a . However, t h e relevant
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.3
surface tensions depend on the r a d i u s a n d cannot be m e a s u r e d . In line with our macroscopic interpretation s u c h strongly curved surfaces will not be considered. Interfacial tensions for macroscopic a r e a s of binary mixtures a n d solutions will be d i s c u s s e d in c h a p t e r 4, following the t r e a t m e n t of s p r e a d monolayers. The general s t r u c t u r e is deductive; after a n introduction (sec. 2.1) first t h e general thermodynamic a n d statistical thermodynamic framework will be given (sees. 2.22.4). After t h a t other general approaches will follow (sees. 2.5-9). More specialistic a n d empirical treatments are postponed till sees. 2.10 and 11. All in all, the e m p h a s i s of this chapter is on the u n d e r s t a n d i n g of interfacial regions r a t h e r t h a n on predicting interfacial tensions. 2.1
Introductory considerations
It is instructive to start with the following, common, b u t basically incorrect interpretation of surface tension: 'Create a surface by cutting a b u l k liquid into two halves. Some molecules t h a t originally found themselves homogeneously s u r rounded by their neighbours (so that the average force exerted on t h e m is zero) will, after the cutting, appear in the newly created surface, where they will experience a n e t inward force. Because of this u n b a l a n c e d force the surface is the seat of a n excess energy. This energy, if expressed per unit area, is the surface tension a n d it is for this reason t h a t surfaces tend to contract'. The flaw in this reasoning is t h a t it is m e c h a n i c a l l y incorrect; a s y s t e m on which a n e t force w o r k s is n o t a t equilibrium. What v^U h a p p e n is t h a t after cutting the ordering of the molecules in the surface will change. After this rearrangement is completed the average local n u m b e r density p ^ will gradually decrease from its value in the liquid, pjj to t h a t in the vapour, p ^ ^^ Figure 2.1 sketches a possible distribution for the interfacial region between two liquids, a and (3. As will be shown later, s u c h density profiles often have a hyperbolic tangent-type s h a p e . In t e r m s of m e c h a n i c s , t h e excess potential energy t h a t interfacial molecules may have (by being torn away from their energy-distance m i n i m u m which they occupied in t h e liquid state), is c o m p e n s a t e d by additional kinetic or configurational energy t h a t is a c q u i r e d t h r o u g h t h e r e a r r a n g e m e n t . The s i t u a t i o n c a n be described even b e t t e r in thermodynamic terms: interfaces not only have a n excess energy U^ b u t also a n excess entropy S^. Therefore, surface tensions are not energies, b u t energies,
Helmholtz
F^. It is because of the entropic contribution TS^ t h a t the t e m p e r a t u r e
d e p e n d e n c e plays its i m p o r t a n t role. Interfacial t e n s i o n s are
thermodynamic,
r a t h e r t h a n mechanical quantities. Although interfaces are the seat of a n excess Helmholtz energy F ^ , one cannot gain useful work by transporting molecules from t h e b u l k to t h e interface. For a system in equilibrium s u c h a p r o c e s s is not
^^ In sec. 1.3d this quantity was called (p).
2.4
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
possible. The reason is t±iat if such a molecular transport were to be carried out, any gain in Helmholtz energy would be exactly compensated by the work needed to enlarge the interfacial area against the interfacial tension. As the structure of the surface, and hence U^ and S^, are unique for each liquid and completely determined by the nature of the molecules and their interactions, it follows that this also applies to / a n d dy/dT. Therefore, it mEikes sense to search for molecular interpretations of both of these quantities. However, direct relationships between the surface tension and bulk properties, such as energy densities or Hamaker constants, are basically incomplete unless they take the interfacial rearrangements into account. At best one can say that bulk properties and the surface tension are different manifestations of the same interaction. From the data in sec. L12 and app. 1, it is concluded that neglecting the TS^ term can lead to errors of several tens of a percent. An interesting recurrent aspect is that of the thickness of the interfacial layer. It is of more than historical interest that Gibbs and van der Waals took opposite points of view. Gibbs explicitly speaks of 'surfaces of discontinuity' in heterogeneous systems. He analyzed interfacial excesses by assigning all of them to (what is now called) the Gibbs dividing plane (sees. 1.2.5 and 1.2.22a). This is a formalism: measurable thermodynamic and mechanical quantities (such as the interfacial tension) cannot depend on the location of that plane. In the present chapter we intend to consider explicitly the density profile pAz] in the interfacial layer. The first attempt at doing so goes back to van der Waals^^ (see sec. 2.6). Van der Waals was aware of Gibbs' work and proved that his model and Gibbs' phenomenological approach were compatible. How thick an interfacial layer is in reality is not always simple to state. It depends on the criterion and/or the method of measurement. However, by a variety of experimental, theoretical and simulation techniques it is now established that for simple fluids and solids at ambient temperatures the layer is a few molecules thick. This thickness increases with temperature to become very large near the critical point. We shall return to this issue in sec. 2.8. Before giving a more systematic treatment we shall review and extend some of the thermodynamic and statistical-thermodynamic foundations laid down in Volume I. This framework serves to find relationships and to determine the limits of application, and can later be extended, for instance to include curvature phenomena. Given the scope of FIGS we shall restrict ourselves to liquid-fluid interfaces (i.e. interfaces for which tensions can be measured), emphasizing ambient conditions (say 0-100°C and atmospheric pressures) and systems of simple, low molecular mass molecules. For the same reason, we shall not consider
1^ The title of van der Waals's seminal paper, Z Phys. Chem. 13 (1894) 657, explicitly states "... unter Voraussetzung stetiger Dichteanderung".
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.5
critical p h e n o m e n a in detail notwithstanding their intrinsic academic interest ^K 2.2
Thermod3mamic and s t a t i s t i c a l t h e r m o d y n a m i c f u n d a m e n t a l s . Flat interfaces
Consider macroscopic flat interfaces of any n a t u r e (LG, LL, SL, etc.). As a primer for later discussions we shall generalize here to include systems in which a d s o r b a t e s m a y be p r e s e n t . The interfaces are at equilibrium with t h e two adjoining b u l k p h a s e s . In Volume I, sees. 1.2.5, 1.2.10-11, 1.2.13, 1.2.22 a n d appendices 1.3-5, we derived F = -pV
+ yA + ^
[2.2.1]
ji^n^ =U-TS
dF = - SdT - pdV + 7dA + ^ . /x^dn.
[2.2.2]
dG = - SdT + Vdp + ydA + ^ . ^^^dn^
[2.2.4]
with F the Helmholtz energy, G the Gibbs energy, p the external p r e s s u r e , V t h e volume of the total system, y the interfacial tension, A the interfacial area, ju a n d R. the chemical potential a n d n u m b e r of moles of component i, respectively, a n d T the temperature of the system. Because of equilibrium, T, p and ju^ are equal in t h e two adjoining p h a s e s a a n d p. As t h e Helmholtz energy is a function of state, t h e total differential d F from [2.2.1] may be equated with d F in [2.2.2], resulting in Ady = - S d T -H Vdp - ^ which is the Gibbs-Duhem
n^d//^ equation
[2.2.5] for a system consisting of two h o m o g e n e o u s
p h a s e s a t equilibrium. Equations [2.2.1 and 2] are therefore consistent. By t h e same procedure [2.2.5] can be obtained from [2.2.3 and 4). Equation [2.2.2] can also be used to 'define' the pressure p and interfacial tension /as P = -{^]
[2.2.6]
and
^^ Further information can be found in the books by Davis, and Rowlinson-Widom mentioned in sec. 2.13.
2.6
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
=M
y= \f-\
12.2.71
respectively. Here the subscript [n^] s t a n d s for the set of n^'s t h a t have to be kept constant. So, [2.2.71 is particularly suited for closed systems. By the same token.
E q u a t i o n s [!^.2.7 a n d 8] define interfacial tensions phenomenologically a s differential surface Helmholtz or Gibbs energies. For interpretational p u r p o s e s it is more expedient to work with the surface e x c e s s c o u n t e r p a r t s of [2.2.1-41. We recall from [1.2.5. U a n d [1.2.9.31 t h a t [/^ = L/- LT" - LT^ S"" =S-S''-
S ^ F ^ = U'' - TS"" and G"" = F"" - yA a n d repeat
from Lapp. 5 F"" = yA + ^.n"^ 1^^ = U"" - TS"" d F ^ = - S^dT + ydA + ^
[2.2.91
ju^dn^
[2.2.101
dG^ = - S^dT - Adx + Y a d n f
[2.2.121
where the superscript a refers to interfacial excesses. Note t h a t in this convention
G""
=G-G''-G^-yA.
In equations [2.2.9-121 the excesses V,
S"", F"", G"" a n d n^ are counted with
respect to a reference system of homogeneous bulk p h a s e s whose volumes a n d / o r a m o u n t s are defined by a suitably chosen dividing surface, the Gibbs dividing
plane.
As t h i s p l a n e is infinitely thin, V ^ = 0 . For e s t a b l i s h i n g relations b e t w e e n m e a s u r a b l e quantities this formalism h a s no consequences. However, in model studies the finite thickness h a s to be considered, and this will often be done in this chapter. Using [2.2.91 the surface tension of a pure liquid can be split into its entropic a n d energetic contribution. For a pure liquid, where the Gibbs dividing plane is determined by setting n ' ' = 0, introducing U^ =U''/A
and S^ =8''/A
a s t h e interfacial
excess energy and entropy per unit area, respectively , we have y = Ul-
TS^
[2.2.131
from which the following Gibbs-Helmholtz relationships are immediately found
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.7
S"" = - ^ dT
12.2.141
Lr^=y_T-^ a ^7-
[2.2.15]
These equations are analogous to those for the molar entropy and molar energy in b u l k p h a s e s (sec. 1.2.15). For interfaces containing a d s o r b a t e s more scrutiny is needed, because / and F^ now also depend on Xi /^i^^i which is also t e m p e r a t u r e dependent. Equating dF"" from [2.2.9] with dF"" in [2.2.10] leads to t h e Gibbs
adsorption
equation dy=-SldT-^,r^dfi. where the surface concentration
[2.2.16] F^ = n^/ A. The Gibbs adsorption equation [2.2.16]
is nothing other t h a n the surface equivalent of the Gibbs-Duhem relation [2.2.5]. Usually it is more a p p r o p r i a t e to analyze interfacial t e n s i o n s in t e r m s of Helmholtz energies t h a n to work with Gibbs energies because: (i) in [2.2.2] both the b u l k a n d surface work are m a d e explicit: a n d (ii) there is some a r b i t r a r i n e s s in defining G^; in effect in our convention (which is a s recommended by lUPAC) G^ does not even contain the interfacial tension. See also the text following [4.2.25]. In real situations surface a n d volume changes are often m a d e with systems t h a t are at equilibrium with their environment, characterized by a set of chemical potentials [jj,^], r a t h e r t h a n keeping [n] fixed, a s in [2.2.7 a n d 8]. In other words, area c h a n g e s in open systems are considered. In statistical t h e r m o d y n a m i c s t h e conversion from closed to open implies the transition from the canonical to t h e g r a n d canonical ensemble. The characteristic function of t h e latter is n o t h i n g other t h a n the s u m of the bulk a n d surface mechanical work t e r m s (see [1.3.3.12] and [I.A6.23J) which are the quantities of interest: -pV
+ yA = -kTlnE{{ju.],
A, V, T )
[2.2.17]
where S is the grand canonical partition function. Let u s consider this conversion in some detail. Thermodynamically, a new function of state Q is introduced: n^F-
^.fi,n.
Here £2 is generally known a s the grand potential
[2.2.18] Strictly speaking, £2 is not a
potential b e c a u s e it h a s the dimensions of a n energy. However, we shall u s e this n a m e to remain in line with common usage. From [2.2.1,2, 17 and 18]
2.8
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION n = -pV
+ yA = -/cTln£(liUjl, A, V, T )
i.e. 12 is the characteristic
function
in the grand
[2.2.19] canonical
ensemble.
Equation
[2.2.2] is replaced by dQ = - S d T -pdV
+ ydA-
^
n.d^^
[2.2.20]
so t h a t the interfacial tension can also be expressed in terms of a derivative of Q a s ^ ]
^ - k T { ^ ^
[2.2.21]
This is a central equation in t h e theoretical evaluation of interfacial t e n s i o n s : w h e n the grand canonical partition function can be obtained from some model, / c a n immediately be found by differentiation with respect to A. Because V is kept constant, only interfacial work is considered. To obtain the counterparts of [2.2.9 a n d 10] in terms of £2, the interfacial excess of Q is defined a s r2^ = 12 - r2« - r^P
[2.2.22]
where 12" a n d Q^ are the grand potentials for the two bulk p h a s e s a a n d |3. Grand potentials a r e m e c h a n i c a l quantities a n d m e a s u r a b l e . Applying the p r o c e d u r e followed for U"", S"", F"", etc. (see sec. 1.2.11) we obtain 12^ = F ^ - ^
ju. n^ = yA
dI2^ = - S^dT + xdA - ^
[2.2.23] n^dju.
[2.2.24]
so t h a t / c a n also be written in terms of Q^ as y = Q^'IA = Ql
^^^^
[2.2.25]
[2.2.26]
Because of [2.2.25] it follows t h a t Q^ m u s t be i n d e p e n d e n t of t h e choice of dividing plane. This fact m u s t be heeded in any model of interfacial tensions. For easy reference the expressions for the various surface excess functions are collected in appendix 2. These thermodynamic a n d statistical equations constitute the framework onto which further elaborations are anchored. All thermodjmamic interfacial excess functions, except Q^, depend on the choice of the dividing plane. Of course, n o n e of the measurable quantities are sensitive to this choice. Charged interfaces a r e also covered, provided t h e charge is c a u s e d by t h e preferential adsorption of one of the ionic species. Then, the components i refer to electro-
2.9
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
n e u t r a l combinations of ions, along the lines discussed in II.3.4. When t h e charge is imposed by a n external source, a s for double layers at the mercury-solution interface, a n additionail electric term is required in all thermodynamic equations, see sec. 11.3.10b. All the above equations also apply to solid-liquid a n d solid-gas interfaces b u t because the interfacial, or surface, tension for these systems c a n n o t be measured. This part of the analysis is more academic. 2.3
Interfacial t e n s i o n and interfacial pressure tensor^)
For isotropic bulk p h a s e s at equilibrium, the pressure is a scalar a n d the s a m e everj^where. This is Pascals
law. In inhomogeneous systems, like interfaces, this
is no longer t r u e . Then, very generally, the p r e s s u r e acquires tensorial n a t u r e , characterized by nine components. P
P
P
^xx
^xy
^xz
P
P
P
-^ yx
-^ yy
^ yz
P
P
P
^ 2X
^ zy
"^ zz
12.3.1]
In sec. 1.6b we have u s e d a similair matrix notation for the stress tensor T a n d in sec. Lapp.7f we did so for the polarizability tensor a. We assume the system to be at mechanical equilibrium, i.e. the fluids are at rest. This m e a n s t h a t the isotropic pressures in the bulk phases m u s t the same everjAvhere (p" = p^). Then [2.3.2]
div. p = 0
Equation [2.3.2] describes the m o m e n t u m balance in s u c h a liquid. Under t h e imposed restriction all t e r m s in [2.3.1] except the diagonal ones vanish, i.e. only the normal stresses remain. Hence, what is left is 0 0 0
p
0 0
0
[2.3.3]
p
In isotropic p h a s e s these three components are identical. Consider now the heterogeneous interfacial layer a n d let z b e t h e direction normal to the surface. For interfaces, planar or curved, t h a t are isotropic in the x-
^^ Most of the features of this section can already be found in G. Bakkers Handbuch der Experimentalphysik (Akad. Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig), Vol. VI (1928), 18, 412. For an extensive and rigorous discussion, see H.T. Davis, L.E. Scriven, Stress and Structure in Fluid Interfaces, Adv. Chem. Phys. 49 (1981) 357-484.
2.10
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
P-Ptiz) z k
Figure 2.2. Construction for finding the relation between interfacial tension and pressure tensor. The shape of the p- p (z) profile in fig. b. is arbitrary. It does not need to be symmetrical, may have a more complicated shape, eind the maximum does not necessarily coincide with z = 0. In fact there is some arbitrariness in locating the dividing plane. a n d L/-directions, parallel to the surface, p
= p
= P, a n d p
= p , the
s u b s c r i p t s t a n d n referring to tangential a n d normal, respectively^K To obtain a relation between p^, p ^ a n d y, consider fig. 2.2. Interface A separates p h a s e s a a n d p. The tangential component of the stress tensor in the x- or y-direction may be a s in fig. 2.2b. The precise s h a p e is immaterial; the width in the z-direction is directly coupled to the thickness of the interfacial region. The interfacial tension is defined a s t h e isothermal reversible work of expanding t h e a r e a A by a n infinitesimal a m o u n t . To achieve this, the area is extended by displacing the r.h.s. of the box over a distance dx. The surface work required for this is obtained from integration of ^ p [z] over z from -h to +h. However, at the same time, volume work h a s been done, which h a s to be subtracted. It amounts to 2p^ hd x, which C£in also be written a s a n integral of ^ p over z from -h to +h, because the isotropic pressure p is independent of z and p " = p ^ . In a more rigorous derivation^^ account h a s to be m a d e of the fact t h a t u p o n this expansion V" a n d V^ also change. For flat interfaces this h a s no
1^ It is noted that 'normad' is used in two ways, viz. as indicating the normal {= S3mimetriccil or diagonal as opposed to the tangential, or asymmetric) terms in the pressure tensor and as indicating the normal direction (perpendicular to the surface, as opposed to parallel, or tangential, to it). 2) R.C. Tolman. J. Chem, Phys, 16 (1948) 758.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.11
consequences for the final result. We find +h
+h
y idx = - £ J p j z j d x d z + £p J d x d z -h
-h
or +h
7 = j [ p - p^(z)jdz
[2.3.4]
-h
As the regions far from the interface do not contribute to the interfacial tension, we may replace the limits of integration in [2.3.4] by -<» and +oo, respectively: -too
7=1 [p-p^(z)]dz
[2.3.5]
It appears that in the interfacial layer I p J » p. For ein interfacial layer of width == 1 nm and /=- 30 mN m-^ we estimate the value of [p - p^(z]], at about 3 x 10"^ Pa, whereas p i s only 10^ Pa. Hence, p (z) is a somewhat bizarre function that assumes considerable values at the interface. In some theories, where [2.3.5] is used to predict surface tensions, the local value of p^[z) is ambiguous, but the integral is always well-defined. Last, but not least, it is noted that p^{z) is a negative quantity; in the interface the molecules are torn apart against their attraction, and hence there is a tendency of interfaces to contract. 2.4 Interfacial tensions and distribution functions In homogeneous isotropic fluids the distribution of molecules can be advantageously defined in terms of distribution functions, which are, at least in principle, measurable by scattering techniques (sec. 1.7.7). Generally, distribution functions describe probabilities of finding molecules at a certain position with respect to one or more other molecules, i.e. they are functions of distances (r) or positions (r). They carry information about the extent to which the local density differs from its value p^ = N/V, averaged over the system, i.e. over the volume or, for an interface, over a thin layer in this interface. Some basic principles were introduced in sees. I.3.9d,e. Distribution functions of various orders can be distinguished: (i) The singlet distribution Junction g^^Hr^) is so defined that g^^Hr^) dr , expresses the probability of finding a molecule in a volume dr . In a homogeneous isotropic liquid all positions are equivalent and g^^^ = p , the average number density. For a flat interface we write g^^\z)dr^ for the probability of finding a molecule in a volume dr^, that is flat and thin. (ii) The pair distribution function g^^\r^, r^), also known as the pair correlation junction, is defined in such a way that g^^\r r ) dr dr is the probability of finding one arbitrary molecule in a small volume dr^ and simultaneously another
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.12
arbitrary molecule in dr^. For an isotropic, homogeneous liquid, g^^^ is the same as the radial distribution function g{r), which indicates by how much the local density at distance r from the first molecule differs from the average. (iii) The hth order distribution Junction, or hth order correlation coefficient g^^\r^.r^.r^ ... r^) is defined so that pjjfif^^Hr^.r^.Tg... r^) dr^dr^dTg ... dr^ is the probability of simultaneously finding the first molecule in dr^, the second in dr^, etc. Mechanical properties of the fluids are related to these distribution functions. For instance, for simple liquids we had for the energy and the pressure of a homogeneous isotropic fluid (see [1.3.9.25, 26]), [2.4.1]
U = — - — + — ^ J u{r)g{r]4nr^dr 0
[2.4.2]
p = p ^ , T - i ^ J r ^ , ( r ) 4 . r ^ d r
respectively. Here, u (r) is the pair interaction energy. Thermodynamic psirameters are more elusive because they require information about the coupling between molecules which eventually accounts for part of the entropy. i
g | ^ 2 (■^^2.^2'^)
1
Pi (xi,yi,Zi)
T
dzj
1 ^^
^
^
^
_^ ^
1
1
y
^1
^
^
^
-i
y^
^
X
My^
i Figure 2.3. Definition of co-ordinates in the calculation of interfacial tensions.
/
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.13
At i s s u e now is w h a t changes have to be introduced if p h a s e b o u n d a r i e s a r e present, i.e. if inhomogeneous systems are considered, a n d w h a t relation exists between t h e required distribution functions a n d t h e interfacial tension. In other words, we are looking for t h e two-dimensional analogue of [2.4.2]. Obviously, t h e distribution functions ^f^^^ and g^'^^ aire now functions of z (co-ordinates a s in figs. 2.2 and 3), i.e. we must write g^^^ as g^^\z) = p^iz) a n d for g^'^^ we either continue to write
g^^Hr^.r^).
g^^\ z^,z^\r^^\),
whilst
realizing
that
the
r's
a r e in t h e i n t e r f a c e
or
where z^ a n d z^ are two values of z a n d r^^ ^^ ^^^ (vectorial) dis-
t a n c e between molecules 1 a n d 2. For interfaces g^^^ m a y n o longer b e called 'radial'. With this in mind, let u s derive the required relation for the simplest case of t h e flat interface b e t w e e n a m o n o c o m p o n e n t h o m o g e n e o u s fluid of s p h e r i c a l molecules a n d its vapour. We follow a derivation offered by Hill^^ which goes b a c k to a more general paper by Kirkwood a n d Buff^^ Consider fig. 2 . 3 . The surface is flat a n d located in t h e z = 0 plane. For t h e p r e s e n t discussion it is immaterial where exactly in the surface zone the plane z = 0 is located. We want to compute t h e x-component of the pressure tensor, t h a t is, the force between alL molecules to t h e left of t h e vertical plane a t x = 0 a n d all those to t h e right. First consider t h e attraction between a molecule in P j , a t position x , y = 0, z^, aind a second a t Pg at x^, y^, z^. Counting of x stairts a t t h e vertical plane; x^ < 0 cind
x^ > 0. The x-
component of t h e vector r connecting Pj a n d Pj is (x^ - x^). The force between t h e molecules at P2 a n d Pj is - d u(r) / d r ; its x-component is -(x - x^jd u(r) / r d r . A pair p^{z^]g^'^\z^,
distribution
function
g^^\z , z , r) is n o w defined
such
that
z^, r) dr^ is t h e m e a n n u m b e r of molecules in t h e infinitesimal
volume dr^ = dx^dy^dz^
when there is a molecule at Pj. This distribution function
is not radicd b e c a u s e it depends on z^ a n d z^. It is noted t h a t this g^^^ is fully determined by z^, z^ a n d r a n d t h a t p^{z^)
replaces t h e singlet d i s t r i b u t i o n
function, which is now z-dependent. For large r, g^^^ -^ 1. The normal c o m p o n e n t of t h e force exerted by t h e molecule a t x^, y^. z^ on t h e molecules in dx2 dy^ dZg a m o u n t s to
The horizontal force component exerted on all molecules with x^ > 0 is obtained by integration over x^ from 0 to 00, a n d over y^ a n d z^ from -00 to +00. We note in passing t h a t this m e a n s t h a t all forces aire taken to be additive. Let t h e result b e called -G(Xj, z^):
^) T.L. Hill, Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics, Addison-Wesley (1960), sec. 17-5. 2) J.G. Kirkwood, F.P. Buff, J. Chem Phys. 17 (1949) 338.
2.14
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
- G ( x , z.) = - J I J
^
^
^ ^ . J - 2 ) 9 ' ^ ' ( - . -r r) d x , dy, d z .
The horizontal component of the force exerted by the molecules in an infinitesimal layer of width £, thickness dz^ and extending to x^ = -«> (indicated in fig. 2.3) is o
-MZj I G(Xj, Zj)p^(2j)dXj and if this expression is divided by the area, ^dz^, we obtain the corresponding pressure experienced at a certain location z^. TTiis is Just the interaction part of the tangential pressure tensor occurring in [2.3.4] gind [2.3.5]. Adding the contribution of the kinetic energy, i.e. the momentum transport part, p^[z^)kT, we obtain o
p^iz^] = p^(z^)kT - p^iz^) J G(x^, z^)dx^
[2.4.3]
which may be considered the 'interfacial' equivalent of [2.4.2]. Some further elaboration is possible by changing variables from x^, y^, z^ to x._ = x_ - X,, y,o- Un' y^^ 2._ = z_ - z,, i.e. to intermolecular distances thereby eliminating the position of the vertical plane in fig. 2.4. The distance r equals (^fg +yf2 '^^12^^^^ ^^^ ^ ^ lower integration boundary of x^^ equals -x^. After these substitutions Gi.,z^)
= J 7 J
M ^1
^
P . ( z . -zj^^^)(z,z,,,r)dx,,dy,,dz^.
'
[2.4.4] The integration over x^ in [2.4.3] can be done by parts. Basically, 0
0
0 UK.
J G ^ . z , ) dx. = G[x^,z^) x j ^ - J x^ ^ ^ X —oo ax.
— oo
dx,
1
where the first term on the r.h.s. is zero (the product is zero for x^ = 0 and also for Xj = -oo because G decays more rapidly than x^). The derivative of G with respect to Xj is, according to [2.4.4], a differentiation with respect to an integration boundary which simply yields the integrand, x^, and leads to an x^^, rather than to an x^^» term. This can be verified by temporarily rewriting [2.4.4], everywhere replacing Xj2' by Xj throughout, also in r; an x^ is then obtained. By symmetry, we can extend the range of integration from -<» to +oo, provided we multiply by i . However, as Xj is now a dummy variable, it may be converted back to x^^ • The final result of these manipulations is
2.15
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
+00 +00 +00 /
2
-00-00-XjV
^
J
which Ccin be combined with [2.3.5] to give the surface tension / :
-I
p-p^{z)kT
+
+ 00 +00 +00
r
dr
P N K 2 + 2y'1^1'^12''*K2^^12^^12 dz [2.4.6]
which is the Kirkwood-Buff formula. The parameter z in [2.4.6] is identical to z^ in [2.4.5]; it denotes a certain position in the interface; integration over z is required to obtain the surface tension. On the other hand, z^^ indicates the (normal component of the) distance to another parallel plane, and the distribution function g^^^ formulates the correlation between the molecules in these layers. Equation [2.4.6] shows how 7 is determined by intermolecular interactions and distributions; the energetic and entropic components, are both included. Apart from the limitations set forth (flat interface, one-component system of spherical molecules, only second-order correlations) [2.4.5] is rigorous. It gives y when the profile and the interactions are known, but does not yield this profile. To that end other approaches are required. We shall consider these in sees. 2.6 onwards. For a multicomponent mixture, [2.4.5] can be generalized to
^Zp..K)IJiJ
^x?J du(r) 12 [2.4.7]
and the corresponding expression for y can be written. The pair interaction energies u include dissimilar (i ^ j) and similar (i = j) pairs. As each component can be found in both phases (given by the profile p^ (z^)) the resulting y stands for the interfacial tension of any liquid-liquid phase boundary. The conclusion is that surface tensions are related to distribution functions and pair interactions in the interface. Basically, distribution functions can be related to these interactions, but the steps to be taken are by no means simple. One of the basic problems is that multimolecular interactions must in some way be
2.16
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
converted into (sums over) pair interactions, for which a n u m b e r of procedures are known. In the domain of chemical physics these 'closures' are abbreviated a s BOY (for Born, Green a n d Yvon), HNC (for hypernetted chain), Kirkwood, PY (PercusYevick) a n d o t h e r s . So far only approximate solutions exist a n d even t h e s e approximations often have a complexity t h a t is beyond the p r e s e n t scope.
For
further information, see the appropriate references in sec. 2.13. More a m e n a b l e expressions c a n be obtained if the asymmetric distribution function g^'^\z^, z^^, r] in [2.4.6] can in some way be related to the corresponding distribution function for the bulk fluid, g^^Hr). Basically s u c h a relation m u s t exist b e c a u s e the two functions are both based on the same interaction energies. Kirkwood a n d Buff (loc. cit.) elaborated s u c h a procedure. Its level of m a t h e m a t i c a l a b s t r a c t i o n is beyond t h a t of FIGS. In their theory higher order densities p{^^ a p p e a r in the surface layer. These pj^^'s apply to a s u b s e t of h molecules, t a k e n from the whole a n d are studied in terms of the Bom-Green theory for liquids^*. It t u r n s o u t t h a t pj^^ c a n be related to pi^^^^ by a set of complicated integrodifferential vector equations. The purpose is eventually to reduce pj^^ to pj^^ To evaluate these densities the surface excesses F are needed. Referring these to the Gibbs dividing plane, a mathematical analogue is obtained, in which on one side of this plane the liquid is homogeneous and the distribution function is J u s t
g^^\r).
The final result is
, =^
J
r^(f] 0
^
g.^.Mdr
12.4.81
^
plus higher terms. This result (without higher terms) w a s also obtained by Fowler^^ on the a s s u m p t i o n t h a t the density profile is a step-function. Equation [2.4.8] is, a s it should be, independent of the actual choice of the Gibbs dividing plane. It is not possible to a s s e s s the quality of the approximation off-hand. Kirkwood a n d Buff computed y for argon at 90 K using a certain set of Lennard-Jones interactions for u{r] a n d found 14.9 mN m"^ a s compared with 11.9 mN m~^ experimentally. This difference is larger t h a n for the Cahn-Hilliard model, see table 2.1 in sec. 2.6. A more m o d e r n check would be to determine g^^Hr) from appropriate scattering experiments a n d from t h a t compute y. For a recent state of the art survey see^\ Kirkwood a n d Buff also give a n equation for the surface excess energy in the s a m e approximation:
K=-
- % ^ j ^^ ^f^^ ^^^^(^) d^
12.4.9]
^^ M. Bom, H.S. Green, Proc. Roy. Soc. A188 (1946) 10. 2) R.H. Fowler, Proc. Roy. Soc. A159 (1937) 229. '^' Scattering and Surface Forces, seven contributions, edited by D. Langevin and J. Penfold, Curr. Opinion Colloid Interface Set 3 (1998) 285-320.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.17
This equation is cdso based on the Gibbs convention ( F " = 0 for the surface tension of liquid a). For m a n y - c o m p o n e n t systems U^ d e p e n d s on t h e location of t h i s plane, unlike the surface tension. This difference corresponds with our findings in sec. 2.2. 2.5
Van der Waals theory
As a corollary to his famous work on non-ideal gases a n d c o n d e n s a t i o n p h e n omena, v a n der Waals also studied t h e properties of liquid-vapour interfaces. His work is embodied in a v o l u m i n o u s p a p e r ^^ which m a r k s t h e a d v e n t of t h e molecular-thermodynamic (rather t h a n mechanical) interpretation of interfacial s t r u c t u r e a n d interfacial tensions. In several aspects van der Waals w a s a h e a d of h i s time. For instance, he u s e d a molecular interpretation a t a time w h e n t h e existence of molecules w a s not yet certain, a n d long before t h e advent of q u a n t u m mechcinics. Further, he introduced a m e a n field picture containing explicitly t h e interfacial density profile, p^(z). A key element in his reasoning w a s t h a t in b u l k t h e Helmholtz energy is a t any position fully determined by t h e local density, w h e r e a s in a p h a s e b o u n d a r y it is also determined by the density further away. This Helmholtz energy w a s minimized a s a function of the function p^(z), essentially u s i n g w h a t is now called density functional theory-^^ Van der Waals also applied a s u m over additive pair interaction energies to find t h e interfacial excess energy. In this way he was about 40 years ahead of the Hamaker-de Boer method for obtaining t h e Van der Waals attraction c o m p o n e n t to t h e disjoining p r e s s u r e between two macrobodies. (We described this in sec. 1.4.5.) All in all, van der Waals developed a universal theory on interfacial s t r u c t u r e , interfacial tension, corresp o n d i n g s t a t e principles, etc., with specific material p a r a m e t e r s s u b s u m e d in p a r a m e t e r s like the constant a in the Van der Waals equation of state [p + an^/V^)
{V-nb)
= nRT
[2.5.1)3)
which can also be written on a moleculcir basis a s [p + aN^/V^)
{V-Nb)
= NkT
[2.5.1a],
or in the Hamaker constant A, which for a homogeneous fluid is given by [1.4.5.4],
Ai = ^^ PUPI^
1^1
[2.5.2]
^^ J.D. van der Waals, Z. Phys. Chem. 13 (1894) 657. (German transl. of the Dutch original; for (modified) French and English translations, see sec. 2.13). -^^ Density functionals are functions of functions. Although this technique is powerful in describing heterogeneous systems and often applied in advanced papers, we shall not go so far in this book. Chapter 9 of Davis' book (1996). mentioned in sec. 2.13, introduces the topic. However, in appendix 3 some aspects of variational calculus will be outlined. '^^ In [1.4.4.1] of FICS-I the exponent 2 in the denominator of a/V^ is missing.
2.18.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
A^, = n^P,,pl^
Ul
I2.5.2I
with P^ J the London-van der Waals attraction constant between two molecules of n a t u r e 1 in a v a c u u m u^j(r) = - ^
[2.5.31
Van der Waals' work w a s well received, b u t later fell into oblivion. For instance, it is not acknowledged in Defay a n d Prigogine's well-known book^) a n d only in p a s s i n g in t h e well-acclaimed publication of C a h n a n d Hilliard^^ viz. by referring to v a n der Waals' equation [2.5.29] for the temperature dependence of the surface tension. Only a few a u t h o r s referred to i t ^ l Much credit goes to Rowlinson a n d Widom"*^ for its reappraised a n d modernization. Because of t h e l a n d m a r k n a t u r e of van der Waals' work we shall now d i s c u s s some important aspects of his theory. In doing so a selection h a s to be m a d e (the German version of van der Waals' paper r u n s to over a hundred pages!). We shall u s e FICS-nomenclature a n d follow a s m u c h a s possible van der Waals' own a r g u m e n t s a n d derivations, although p a r t s of the latter can nowadays be carried out
more
efficiently. For instance, the minimization of the Helmholtz energy a s a function of t h e profile s h a p e c a n nowadays be elegantly done by variational calculus, the principles of which will be outlined in appendix 3 . 2,5a
Some elements
of van der Waals'
theory
Consider a one-component fluid of simple molecules in equilibrium with its v a p o u r a t given temperature. The interface is flat, gravity is ignored. At the interface t h e density profile p^(z) will adjust itself in s u c h a way a s to minimize F a t given T and V. The energy per molecule in the liquid p h a s e , u ^ , consists of a kinetic a n d a potential part. Van der Waals writes - ap^ for the latter where a is the c o n s t a n t in [2.5.1a]. The negative sign m e a n s t h a t he only considered attraction, not repulsion. Nowadays we would prefer to consider the self-energy, see sec. 1.4.5c. When t h e molecule is transported to a position z
in the interface, t h e kinetic energy does
not chctnge b u t the potential energy is augmented by a n integral a m o u n t so t h a t
1) R. Defay, I. Prigogine, Tension Superficielle et Adsorption (1951) (English transl. by D.H. Everett, Longmans, 1966). 2) J.W. Cahn. J.E. Milliard, J. Chem. Phys. 28 (1958) 258. See also sec. 2.6. ^^ For instance, P.D. Fleming, J. Colloid Inter/. Set 65 (1978) 46. H.T. Davis, L.E. Scriven, Adv. Chem. Phys. 4 9 (1981) 357. "^^ J.S. Rowlinson, B. Widom, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Clarendon press (1982); B. Widom, Faraday Symp. Chem, Soc. 16 (1981) 7.
2.19
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
0
[2.5.4]
u{zj = -ap]^ + i j / ( z ) d z
here z is again normal to the surface; z = 0 is the reference somewhere in the bulk of t h e liquid, u ^ ( z = 0) = 0, a n d / ( z ) is t h e force a g a i n s t w h i c h t h e molecule is transported. The factor i is needed b e c a u s e half of the work is attributed to t h e molecule u n d e r consideration, the other half is assigned to all other molecules with which it interacts. Since in the interfacial layer the molecules are further apairt t h a n in the bulk, it is allowed to interpret / ( z ) in t e r m s of attractive forces only, t h a t is, t h e Van der Waals contribution to t h e L e n n a r d - J o n e s interaction energy. Essentially, van der Waals used the pair interaction curve of fig. I.4.3c. To establish / ( z ) see the construction in fig. 2.4. Consider two parallel layers of infinitesimal t h i c k n e s s dAz, positioned at z^ + Az a n d z^-Az. the molecule at z
The n e t force on
is given by the difference between the attraction by t h e lower
a n d u p p e r layer. Now consider a ring in the lower layer of r a d i u s t a n d t h i c k n e s s d t . Its volume is 27ctdtdz a n d it contains 27ctdtdAzp^(z^ - Az) molecules. If / (r) is t h e intermolecular attraction force between a pair of molecules, a d i s t a n c e r apart, the vertical component of this force exerted on the molecule at z^ is Az d/(ring) = 2Kt dt dAz p^(z^ - Az) — f^{r) where Az/r
[2.5.5]
= t a n 0 . Since r^ = (Az)^ +1^ we can use the quadratic substitution
tdt = ndr. Integration over t from 0 -^ oo converts into one over r from Az -^ Hence,
z G
dAz
Az
part of interfacial range
Az ^^^^^^1
dAz
1 1
L z = 0 in bulk of liquid Figure 2.4. Construction for determining the force exerted on a molecule positioned in z .
2.20
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
d/(lower plate) = 2n j p^(z^ - b.zSt^z / p ( r ) d r dAz
[2.5.6]
r=Az
The integration over r can b e carried out. As - J / (r)dr is j u s t the extra potential energy u (r), we obtain d/(lower plate) = 27c p^[z^ - Az)Az u(Az)dAz
[2.5.7]
which v a n der Waals formally abbreviates to d/(lower plate) = - p^(z^ - Az)d\if [Az]
[2.5.8]
Van der Waals consciously omitted contributions of the profile s h a p e to t h e interfacial excess entropy. In other words, at each position in t h e transition layer t h e local entropy is only determined by the local density, p^(z) • On the other hand, t h e total Helmholtz energy is considered to depend both on P^(z) a n d o n t h e profile p (z) over the entire transition range, see later in this subsection. All of this is in line with t h e a s s u m p t i o n s m a d e in m e a n field theories for low-molecular m a s s molecules ^^ Similar to [2.5.8], we derive the contribution of the upper plate to the force: d / ( u p p e r plate) = - p^{z + Az)dy/[Az)
[2.5.9]
The total force on t h e central molecule is obtained by subtracting of [2.5.9] from [2.5.8] a n d integrating over Az from 0 to infinity (or, r a t h e r integrating t h e lower half to -oo and the upper half to +oo aifter adding the two terms). So the result is
/ = - J [ p ^ ( z ^ - A z ) - p^(z^ + Az)]dv^(Az)
[2.5.10]
0
for the total downward force. Integration by parts gives r IOC 7 [^fp^^(2: -Az)-pAz +Az)l] / = - V^(Az)[p^(z^ - Az)- p^(z^ + Az)]^ + J v^lAz) -^^^^-^ a X T ^ M^^
= I'^Ha!iKK-H-allk^^o + HK^ 0
'^
[2.5.11]
^
The integrated term vanishes because it is zero a t the two limits: for Az = 0 because then the two p 's are equal; for Az = ©o because v^(oo) = 0 . To m a k e further progress p
is developed in a Taylor series airound z - z , i.e.
^^ For a discussion of the energetic and entropic contributions to the Helmholtz energy of the interfaclal layer, see O.K. Rice, J. Phx^s. Chem. 8 1 (1977) 1388.
2.21
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
p(z
- Az] = piz
So - — \ P A Z
) - Az
(Azp 2!
dz
- Az)| becomes - ' — -
dz
/^^2
^PM
(AzT 3!
dz'
/^^3
(AZ)2
+ Az
+ ...
dz^
fdV,(z)^
2
+ ...
and similarly for the derivative of p^lz^ + Az). Substituting this in [2.5.11] we find that the quadratic terms cancel. Hence the first two terms of the series expansion of / become
/(^J = - 2 ~ ^ ^
Jv^(Az)d(Az)
dz^
J(Az)^V/^(Az)d(Az)- ... z. 0
[2.5.12] In other work by van der Waals where the function VA(AZ) also occurs, it was found that the integral j v^(Az)d(Az) = a
[Jm^l
[2.5.131
where a is the constant in [2.5.1]. Let us also introduce the following abbreviation f (Az)^v^(Az)d(Az) = C
[Jm^]
[2.5.14]
then [2.5.12] reduces to /(z) = - 2a
- C K
dz
,
I dz3 J
+ ...
[2.5.15]
The constants a and C are recognized as the zeroth and second moment of y/. To obtain the energy from the force, as required by [2.5.4], [2.5.15] must be integrated with respect to z, from 0 to z^. After integration the first differential quotient in [2.5.15] becomes ip^iz) - p^) (because the zero point is in the bulk of the liquid); the second becomes
3z2
V
J z^
[ 3z^ J
of which the second term is zero because of the homogeneity of the bulk phase. So eventually the potential energy as a function of z can be written as u ( z j = u''(kin)- c i p ^ ( z ) - ^
dVfl' dz^
12.5.16]
2.22
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
The last term represents the excess energy in the transition layer felt by a unit amount of matter situated at z = z o . This excess term is determined by the second derivative of p , that is, on the curvature of the profile at that point. The extent to which the various parts of the trcinsition layer contribute depends on the nature of pA7)\ the interfacial contribution to u is zero if dz is located in one of the bulk phases and also for any bending point that may occur in the profile (fig. 2.1). The next step is to find the Helmholtz energy of the layer as a whole. Generally, for a bulk phase the total Helmholtz energy F is obtained as the isothermal reversible work JpdV, which can be computed if p(V), that is, the equation of state, is known. The Helmholtz energy can be expressed per unit of volume, per mole, or per molecule. We prefer the last option. So we write j pdV and call this quantity g. Van der Waals himself worked with molar quantities and his choice for the equation of state was of course [2.5.1]. However, for the present purpose the precise shape of the equation of state is immaterial. Let the contribution to the Helmholtz energy of the molecules situated in an infinitesimally thin layer dz at z be d F . For this quantity we now have (dF) = g{z ) - ^o o 2
^dV,N
[J]
dz^
[2.5.17]
where the value of gizj depends on the value of p^ at z^, but where the shape is determined by a general law, i.e. by the equation of state. All terms in [2.5.17] have the dimensions of energy. The last term is the extra term caused by the asymmetry of the intermoleculai* attraction, derived in [2.5.16]. The total Helmholtz energy per unit area is found by multiplication of d F by P^(zJ and integration over z from 0 to oo: d^p
JP;v(^)l = j
dz^
dz
[Jm-2]
[2.5.18]
where we have replaced z^ by z. We have written the Helmholtz energy as F^[p^(z)J to indicate that it is a function of the function pj^(z), i.e. it is a density Junctional. More precisely, it is a function of p^(z) and of d^p^(z)/dz^. To obtain the equilibrium value of F , this functional has to be minimized with respect to the most probable density distribution, with the total amount of matter in the system fixed.
J "^{^x)dz
= constant
[2.5.19]
as the boundary condition. Nowadays such issues are resolved using the formalism
2.23
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
of density functional theory (appendix 3). According to this technique the solution of the problem is dealt with in two steps. First, the auxiliary condition is eliminated
by
introducing
£2^ = F^ - uj p^dz,
the
grand
potential
through
[2.2.23],
i.e.
using
which does not have this restrictive condition. (Recall t h a t a
similar t r a n s i t i o n w a s applied in t h e statistical derivation of t h e BET g a s adsorption equation, see after [II. 1.5.37].) As a second step Q^ is minimized. The technicalities are beyond the general level of this book, b u t we shall d i s c u s s this variational
calculus
in appendix 3 . Van der Waals w a s not familiar with t h i s
technique, so h e h a d to invent his own. His derivation is somewhat unwieldy b u t gives the proper result, [2.5.28], £ind we shall now briefly repeat it. The t a s k is to compute the variation 5 F u p o n infinitesimal variations 5p^ a n d 6(d^p^/dz^) in t h e two variables, u n d e r the condition t h a t t h e a c c o m p a n y i n g variation of [2.5.19] is zero. The procedure is t h a t [2.5.19] is multiplied by a p a r a m e t e r jj. a n d t h e n its variation is s u b t r a c t e d from 5 F . At this s t a t e t h e quantity /i is undetermined, except t h a t it m u s t have the dimensions of a n energy per molecule. So the mathematical problem to solve is '^'P.
^ ] P N 9-
dz'
-
[2.5.20]
^ dz = 0
As 5(xL/) = xby + y5x, this equation can be rewritten a s
j^p.
'<19'
g+p^
dz
■jPs'
dp^J
dz^
dz = 0
[2.5.211
The second integral is solved through integration by p a r t s
^<^Wd z
- - f 2 J PN
dz
f "A dz
_ £e _d_ 2 J ''w dz
3
ii-
'V d z
dz = -
i PN d z=0
5:^PN dz
-jr-tw^
[2.5.22]
2=0
= 0 In order to combine [2.5.22], with [2.5.20] this integral should be reworked to one containing 6p^, which can be achieved by a second partial integration C 2
M^K-f/^KK = "^PN
z=0
£K1 dz
PN
^dV
- f I ^P'^dz^
dz
[2.5.23]
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.24
a n d this integral j u s t cancels out the integral remaining in [2.5.22]. Substitution of 12.5.23] into [2.5.21] therefore gives
]^PN
)+
9{PN
- C
PN
-
i"
[2.5.24]
dz= 0
According to the theory of Lagrange the factor between square b r a c k e t s becomes zero at any dp
9{PN
)+
for a specific value of /i, which now is no longer undetermined;
- c
PN
[dz^J -
^ = 0
[2.5.25]
(J)
which m a y be recognized a s the Euler-Lagrange equation for this case. Let u s multiply by p ^ a n d integrate over z to obtain quantities per unit area
JPN
9+ P,
dz^
^d,^
[2.5.26]
dz
\ "^PN ^N J
0
In our language, the t e r m s with g are, after integration, identified a s (minus) the excess Helmholtz energy in the interface, F ^ , so that, according to [2.2.18 a n d 23] the r.h.s. corresponds to 12^. Hence the l.h.s. is j u s t the interfacial tension^^ [2.5.27]
dz
■^]PN 0
or, alternatively, a s ^2
= cjfe dz
[2.5.28]
dz
0
which may also be written a s
-=J
dz
[2.5.28a]
dz
because we located the reference for z deep into the liquid. The identity of [2.5.27 a n d 28] is easily verified:
dz
dz z=0
dz
^PN
=
PN
dz
0
-j PN dz^ d z 0
= -J ^"
dz^
dz
Alternatively, [2.5.27] can be integrated by parts to obtain [2.5.28].
Van der Waals lilmself discussed tiiis transition more rigorously and called y the 'capillary energy per unit area'.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION Equation [2.5.28] is the famous square gradient
2.25
law. Since v a n der Waals, this
law h a s been rederived by others and for other systems, in particular by C a h n a n d Hilliard (sec. 2.6). With hindsight the occurrence of the square of the gradient is expected because of the argument t h a t the result should be invariant with respect to the direction of increasing z. The linear term dp^/dz
does not contribute to the
excess interfacial energy b e c a u s e i n c r e m e n t s at z + d z are j u s t b a l a n c e d by decrements at z - d z . This is one of the important insights obtained by v a n der W a a l s 1^. If higher order terms are included only even powers of the gradient will occur. The above derivation leads to a n equation for y in terms of [dp^ / dzf". Van der Waals' p a p e r also contains a variety of other items, s u c h a s stability considerations, the p r e s s u r e in the interfacial layer, spherical interfaces, t h e value of / n e a r the critical point, a discussion on the thickness of the transition layer, the effect of higher terms in the series expansion of the profile a n d corresponding state features. Van der Waals also showed t h a t his theory agreed with Gibbs' adsorption law, a n issue t h a t w a s later discussed in more detail by Widom-^^. In the p r e s e n t context we shall not discuss these features further, except to mention t h a t for the temperature dependence close to the critical point T van der Waals predicted 3/2
(T-^T) V
[2.5.29]
cJ
According to m o d e m insights the exponent is overestimated. In fact, van der Waals himself already gave some experimental illustrations indicating t h a t [2.5.29] does not work very well. 2.5h
Comments
and
consequences
Van der Waals' theory is a typical example of a mean field theory in t h e s e n s e t h a t z is the only position variable. The interfacial layer h a s the s a m e averaged properties everywhere parallel to the surface. This model works well a s long a s the temperature is far below its critical value. When T -^T^
fluctuations
in the density
profile s t a r t to become i m p o r t a n t so t h a t taking average values b e c o m e s less accurate. This is the main reason why [2.5.29] is not a good approximation. Regarding the profile far below the critical point, reconsider [2.5.18]. Let u s first note, by way of digression, t h a t for liquid-liquid interfaces if t h e t e m p e r a t u r e a p p r o a c h e s t h a t of solidification of one of the two, the other liquid s t a r t s to show
^^ We recall that this is only valid for flat interfaces. When the interface is (strongly) curved this symmetiy no longer holds and then terms with z~^[dp^/6z) or z"^(dp^/dz) for cylindrical and spherical interfaces, respectively, enter the equations. 2) B. Widom, Physica 95A (1979) 1-11
2.26
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
oscillations typical for the packing of liquids n e a r solids (sec. II.2.2). There are also examples of models exhibiting this feature^^. However, here we shall consider t h e liquid-vapour b o u n d a r y for w h i c h t h e r e is no r e a s o n for s u c h d e n s i t y oscillations. Then, b e c a u s e of t h e equality of [2.5.27 a n d 28], we m a y also write [2.5.18] for the case of a n equilibrium profile a s
-I
PN9^2
dz
dz
[2.5.30]
Note next the difference between FJp^{z)] in [2.5.18] and F^ in [2.5.30]. The former is the general expression for the functional, whereas the latter describes the equilibrium situation b e c a u s e it w a s minimized. As a consequence, [2.5.30] implicitly describes the s h a p e of t h e profile, to which we r e t u r n below. This equilibrium profile is a compromise between two opposing t r e n d s , viz. between one for t h e profile to s h a r p e n a n d one for it to broaden. The former is recognized in the first t e r m on t h e r . h . s . This term only c o n t a i n s the local density, n o t t h e profile. According to the Van der Waals equation of state (but other equations may serve a s well) p h a s e s e p a r a t i o n into a c o n d e n s e d a n d a v a p o u r p h a s e is a first order transition. The function g is representative for bulk fluids. If this were the only term, there would be a discrete, s h a r p transition between liquid a n d vapour; t h e t h i c k n e s s of t h e transition zone would b e zero. The second term c o n t a i n s t h e profile. Had minimization of this term been t h e sole trend, the profile would be infinitely flat a n d the t h i c k n e s s of the
transition zone infinite. Interestingly
enough, neither in the first nor in the second situation would there be a n interfacial tension! The real interfacial tension is the result of a complicated energyentropy compensation, with t h e surface tension corresponding to J u s t twice t h e second term in [2.5.30]. This issue is reflected in the way in which liquid a n d vapour phaseseparate. Consider to t h a t end fig. 2.5, which shows the trend of F^iPj^) w h e n p h a s e separation can take place. Here, F ^ is the molar Helmholtz energy. The figure h a s the same features a s G [x] in fig. 1.2.9 or 10. Phase separation can take place if this curve h a s a n instability region depending on the value of p . The double tangent defines the densities of the co-existing phases, p ^ and p ^ , identified a s p ^ a n d respectively, also called binodals.
p^,
If p h a s e separation were a first order process,
leading to a discrete border between G a n d L coinciding with the Gibbs dividing plane, F would, a s a function of z , j u m p from F " to F^ a n d there would b e no interfacial excess of this quamtity. The input of van der Waals w a s the insight t h a t F ^ is n o t only a function of p^(z) b u t also of d p ^ / d z , a n d in v a n der Waals'
^^ S. latsevitch, F. Forstmann, J. Chem. Phys. 107 (1997) 6925.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.27
Figure 2.5. Molar Helmholtz energy for the case that demixing takes place.
analysis the second functionality is a square gradient. The interfacial excess of F^ was recognized as the excess pressure in the interface, which essentially is identical to [2.3.5] and leads to [2.5.28]. In thermodynamic terms, this excess pressure is the excess grsmd potential JQ^, which equals / A , see [2.2.23]. This quantity is independent of the choice of a dividing plane. For a more detailed discussion see chapter 3 of Rowlinson and Widom's book, mentioned in sec. 2.13. The insight that the surface tension equals 12^ offers a way for modelling more complicated interfacial regions, for instance in the presence of adsorbates. When the local 12^-density, Q^{z), can be computed in terms of composition and interactions on the basis of some model, integration with respect to z yields / . Equation [2.5.25] describes p^(z) and on the basis of the present or other models this relation can be made explicit. Differential equations of this type give rise to a hyperbolic tangent-type of P^(z) relation. Various elaborations of the present situation, which we shall not discuss here, also give rise to such behaviour for the profile. In our case, the result can be represented as
p.(-) = ^(p^+p^)-Mp^p^)H
[2.5.31]
In passing, [2.5.31] can be derived from van der Waals' theory; van der Waals himself did not give this equation, but only its integrated form. This expression contains a parameter ^ which has the dimensions of a length. We shall not go so far as to give a detailed model expression for it, but note that ^ may be interpreted as a correlatton length. We recall from sec. 1.7.7c that the parameter ^ quantifies the distance over which fluctuations are correlated. For distances « ^ this correlation is very strong, for distances » ^ it is absent. Close to the freezing point, <J is, in liquids, smaller than the molecular radius but for T -^ T it becomes very large.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.28
^0/10
Figure 2.6. Hyperbolic tangent density profile. The zero point of z is placed in the centre of the profile. At that point p^{z] = | [ p j i + P^) • The trend is sketched in fig. 2.6 The density r u n s from p " for z =
(the
reference density, say p^) to p ^ for z = +oo, say the liquid density m i n u s t h a t in the gas p h a s e . In this approximation the profile is symmetrical a r o u n d z = 0. Within the p r e s e n t model some semiquantitative m e a s u r e of the interfacial t h i c k n e s s c a n b e given. Strictly speaking it is infinitely thick, b u t m o s t of t h e density variation t a k e s place over a distance t., obtaiined by extrapolation of the linear part. A simplification of the real profile would be to replace it by the linear step function. This linear p a r t is mathematically represented by the linear term p^(z)
= z/^
(recall t a n h x = x-x^/3
+ 2 x V l 5 - ...). We find [2.5.32]
t ^ - ^ with ^ = ^{a.C)
Given t h e m e a n i n g of <J this result is more or less expected. Equation [2.5.32) u n d e r e s t i m a t e s the thickness. An alternative definition occurring in the literature is the '90-10 thickness' standing for the range of t over which p ^ c h a n g e s from 9 0 % below p ^ to 10% above p ^ . S u c h a definition is not without s e n s e b e c a u s e simulation methods can produce the profile p^(z)- We call it t^^ ^^; it is somewhat less t h a n 2t^ a n d also indicated in the figure. Knowing the complete profile [2.5.31], the surface tension can be computed using [2.5.28al. From [2.5.31],
dz
~
(^pN^ dz
Af ^ N ) d tanh(z/<5) 2 dz
4$
d(tanh(2/a) d(z/a
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.29
with X = z / ^. +00
As the integral equals
^
^C[PN 3
J (cosh xY^dx
sinhx 2 sinhx + — 3(coshx)^ 3 coshx
PN) §
— we obtain 3 [2.5.33]
Recall from [2.5.14] that C is the second moment of van der Waals' energy function VA. So it describes how the excess molecular energy is distributed across the interface. We shall r e t u r n to the precise interpretation of C later. Before doing that, let u s m a k e a rough estimate of the n u m b e r of molecules N^ per u n i t a r e a t h a t is counted a s the surface excess. Approximating the area under the profile (j t a n h x d x = In cosh x) by a triangle, N^ is found to be
^° = | K - P ^ )
(™-')
'2-5-341
If reasonable values for ^ (0(nm)) and the p ^ ' s are substituted, values for N^ are found t h a t correspond to lower areas per molecule t h a n for a compact fluid layer. The reason is t h a t the layer h a s a certain thickness; not only the molecules a t t h e outer border contribute, also those more inward. So, per unit area, there are more molecules. Furthermore, a s the surface tension is a Helmholtz energy per unit area, we cam invoke a scaling a r g u m e n t by letting 7 » ^
12.5.351
where q is some temperature-dependent, b u t dimensionless factor. Eliminating (p^ - p^) between [2.5.33 a n d 34], q can be related to N^ a n d C, t h a t is, to t h e n u m b e r of molecules contributing and to the (integrated) interaction energy. Returning to the basic equations for the surface tension [2.5.27 a n d 28 or 28a], we automatically a s k how useful these are for predicting 7 for a given liquid. The answer is t h a t for practical u s e these equations are not very suitable b e c a u s e the problem is translated into two esoteric sub-problems, viz. the m e a s u r e m e n t of t h e profile p^(z) a n d the determination of van der Waals' constant C. Determination of t h e profile is not simple. To t h a t end optical methods s u c h a s ellipsometry a n d reflectivity m e a s u r e m e n t s are needed, whose interpretation is not u n a m b i g u o u s b e c a u s e the profile cannot be obtained without making certain a s s u m p t i o n s . We return to this in sec. 2.8.
2.30
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Van der Waals himself defined C through [2.5.14]. The m o d e m way is by statistical t h e r m o d y n a m i c s . We described t h e principles in c h a p t e r 1.3. For t h e interpretation of C the formalism of distribution functions (sec. 1.3.9) is the most appropriate. In sec. 2.4 we already gave a n ab initio derivation for t h e surface tension, b u t now concentrate on the interpretation of C. According to v a n der Waals, for a homogeneous bulk phase C = - i j j j rMr)dr
[J m^l
[2.5.36]
where the integration over r covers the entire space. For instance, if u[r) consists of a h a r d repulsion for r
(J
The more general expression r e a d s ^^ C-~jjj
r^cf^mr
12.5.371
where c^^^ is the direct pair correlation function for the pair of molecules 1 a n d 2. In sec. 1.3.9 we defined the total pair distribution function (= pair correlation function) h{r) for a homogeneous fluid. This function describes the total correlation between two molecules a distance r apart. The qualification 'total' m e a n s t h a t t h e overall r e s u l t c o n s i s t s of two portions: a direct p a r t a n d a n indirect p a r t , transmitted by all t h e molecules in which the pair is embedded. The function h[r) is m e a s u r a b l e by scattering techniques. In order to obtain the direct part, t h e indirect portion h a s to be subtracted. This requires a n assumption; the following, proposed by Ornstein a n d Zemike, is frequently used:
-y..) = ^K) - P.jjj -%.] K^a^K
[2.5.38]
According to this equation, c^^^fr^^) is obtained from ^(''12) by subtraction of t h e weighted indirect interactions via third molecules, integrated over t h e entire space. Equation [2.5.38] applies to bulk phases. For a n inhomogeneous liquid^^
1^ See e.g. J.R. Henderson, Heterogeneous Chem. Revs. 2 (1995) 233. Interpretations of C in terms of correlation functions go back to work by D.G. Triezenberg and R. Zwanzig, Phys. Rev. Lett 2 8 (1972) 1183 and R. Lovett, P.W. DeHaven, J.J. Vieceli and P.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 58 (1973) 1880, G.W. Woodbury, J. Chem. Phys. 60 (1974) 3674 gave more thermodynamic interpretations which may be suited for lattice theories. For a review (for curved interfaces) see E.M, Blokhuis, D, Bedeaux, Heterogeneous Chem. Revs. 1 (1994) 55, ^^ J,S. Rowlinson, B, Widom, loc. cit, sec, 4.2.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION c'^'(r..r,) = h(r,.r,) - j J J c'^'(r..r3)p,(r3)h(r3,r,)dr3
2.31 [2.5.391
From [2.5.28a and 37] Rowlinson and Widoml^ derived
' = f l ( ^ I ^ 4 J '■n -'^'('-.•P.^d'-.a
12.5.401
where the last two integrations run pargdlel to the surface. Equation [2.5.40] may be considered a 'face-lift' of van der Waals' equations [2.5.28 amd 36]. Obviously, molecular models are needed to use this equation to predict surface tensions. Hence, this approach remains rather academic and [2.5.40] is an alternative to [2.4.5 and 7f\ The above discussion does not exhaust modem approaches for interpreting surface tensions and interfacial profiles on the basis of van der Waals' ideas. Improvements include: (i) Modification of the Van der Waals equation of state to account more explicitly for excluded volume and/or deviations from the sphericity or apolarity of the interacting molecules. For instance, 'hard spheres' can be introduced into this equation. (ii) Using formal density functional theory. (iii) Relaxing the imposed mean field approximation. Implementation of (some of) these extensions is generally achieved in terms of a modem statistical framework. Such theories are usually referred to as generalized van der Waals theories. So far, elaboration has been restricted to simple molecules. For a recent example, see ref. ^^ where introductions to older literature can be found ^l 2.5c Van der Waals theory in the Hamaker-de Boer approximation For practical purposes it is expedient to drop part of the formalism described so far, by substituting an explicit function for u(r]. In particulcu*, [2.5.3] can be used for the attractive part. One of the cirguments which we aire now considering is that the r"^ power law applies generally for all types of attraction between isolated pairs of molecules (sec. 1.4.4) in the unretarded range. As far as the London forces are concerned, these are 'reasonably' additive, where reasonably' means that attractive forces between macrobodies computed on this basis by Hamaker and de Boer differ by less than 10-20% from the more exact, but not so readily accessible, Lifshits results. So one would anticipate that for simple liquids surface tensions,
1^ Ibid, sec. 3.6. ^^ For a more recent elaboration along these lines, see P.M.W. Comelisse, C.J. Peters and J.D. Arons, J. Cherrt Phys. 106 (1997) 9820, where references to older work can be found. 3^ S. Abbas, S. Nordholm, J. Colloid Interface Set 166 (1994) 481.
2.32
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
would yield values within, say also 10-20% of the experimental ones. We repeat that in this approximation the entropy is ignored. Proceeding in this way gives a striking twist to the historical development in that van der Waals himself did not discover the r~^ power law, although nowadays all molecular forces obeying this dependence are called 'Van der Waals forces'. One could say that the underexposure of van der Waals' theory for the surface tension received retribution by this name-giving. Of course the HdB method is more than 40 years younger than van der Waals' theory. Implementation of the HdB method is not routine, because this approximation applies to forces between macrobodies that are several molecular distances apart. At such distances the discreteness of matter can be ignored, meaning that in the sums of all pair energies only the attractive part has to be counted and the sums may be replaced by integrals over volume elements. In transition zones this is not allowed because these zones are in direct contact with the adjoining bulk phases. Ignoring the repulsive part in the Lennard-Jones interaction (sec. 1.4.5b) would lead to infinitely high adhesive energies. Hence, these have to be taken into account in some way, at least in the most proximate layer. A construction for estimating / is sketched in fig. 2.7. The profile is assumed linear. The increasing dilution of the molecules in going from the bulk liquid to z = ^ leads to decreasing attraction between the molecules in the triangular wedge (hatched in the figure). So, the surface tension is interpreted as the result of the interactions between all the molecules in the liquid with those in the wedge. This can be done in the HdB approximation provided the integration of the attractive energies does not start from z = 0, where it would be infinitely high, but from, say the minimum in the Lennard-Jones interaction curve. The logic behind this choice is that in the liquid the molecules find themselves on average in this position; out of which they are drawn apart in the surface. This separation takes place against the attractive Van der Waals forces.
^N^
Figure 2.7. A cross-sectional view of a construction for the computation of surface tension in the Hamaker-de Boer approximation. The attractive energy of one molecule at distance z from the surface and the
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.33
The attractive energy of one molecule at distance z from the surface a n d t h e entire liquid c a n be shown by a procedure equivalent to t h a t in sec. 2.5a, see [1.4.6.1], to be =1, phase L
^
12.5.411
6z
C o n s i d e r a t h i n slice of liquid of a r e a
A
and thickness
dz,
containing
P^[z) = pjj [z/^] molecules. The total attraction between this slice a n d t h e b u l k liquid is 7c/3.,(pM A z d z
A,Adz
where we have introduced the Hamaker constant A^^ according to [2.5.2]. Integrating from our chosen reference point, where the attractive energy w a s by definition set to zero, to z = ^ and dividing by A leads to ^
[2.5.43]
6K^
Equation [2.5.43] is of course oversimplified, both in method (by using c o n t i n u u m theory for a layer t h a t is only a few molecules thick) a n d in interpretation (the entropy is neglected, only dispersion forces are counted, so the model is restricted to liquid noble gases, simple alkanes, etc.). The equation c a n be compared with [2.5.35] with t h e interesting physical difference t h a t in [2.5.35] t h e Helmholtz energy is seen a s the driving force whereas [2.5.43] is purely energetic. These two are of course coupled. Regarding the order of magnitude, for alkanes A
~ 10 /cT (table LApp. 9.2) a n d
7 ~ 25 m J m"^ (App. 1), so for ^ we find about 0.3 nm, which is a little small b u t of the right order of magnitude. Equation [2.5.43] can be used a s a starting point for other simplified models for surface a n d interfacial tensions. For instance, for relating t h e interfacial tension y^^ between two liquids a a n d (3 to the individual surface tensions / " a n d y^, the additional
a s s u m p t i o n s could be made t h a t for all three cases ^ remain the s a m e
a n d t h a t the dispersion energy is the only contribution to / to have a long e n o u g h range to penetrate significantly the adjacent p h a s e . In fig. 2.7 replacement of the emptied wedge by substance (3 would lead to a reduction A
/6K^^ where A
is the
Hamaker c o n s t a n t for the hetero-interaction between liquids a and p. Likewise, for liquid f.(3, its surface tension A /6n^'^ would be reduced by a n a m o u n t A Hence,
y-^ = ~^(A 6K^^
\ ««
+ A , - 2A J = ^ "" ^^
«P/
671.^
/^^
/6K^^ .
[2.5.44].
2.34
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
/ a/2 where we have used Berthelot's principle A = A^^A 1 , see [1.4.5.5]. Reasonings like this underlie models for writing interfacial tensions a s the s u m of t h e individual tensions m i n u s a work of adhesion
term t h a t is interpreted a s
being c a u s e d by dispersion interaction. We find y-^ = y"+f-g{Yyf^
[2.5.45]
where y s t a n d s for t h e dispersion contribution to the tensions a n d g is some factor t h a t is still the subject of debate. Comparison with [2.5.44] shows t h a t /
xl/2
1/^ 2 A A„J 9{ryf - ^ :j'
'2.5.461
We will come back to such models in sec. 2.1 l b . 2.6
Cahn-HiUiard t h e o r y
In 1958 C a h n a n d Milliard proposed a phenomenological theory for surface a n d interfacial t e n s i o n s t h a t w a s b a s e d on a general formalism for h e t e r o g e n e o u s s y s t e m s ^^ It h a s a certain analogy with the descriptions of non-uniformities in magnetic a n d ferro-electric d o m a i n s in solids. The basic idea w a s t h a t t h e local Helmholtz energy density per molecule / is expamded in a Taylor series a b o u t / » the corresponding quantity in a uniform p h a s e . Mathematically, F[xlz)] = NJjj^fdV
= NJjj^[f^(x)
+ K^V^x + K^i^xf
+ ...]dy
[2.6.1]
where x is t h e mole fraction of the component u n d e r consideration (the other, which r e p r e s e n t s v a c u u m for surface tensions, is ( 1 - x ) ) . The c o n s t a n t s K are called gradient energy coefficients (Sl-units J m^) a n d are formally defined a s K^ = [3//3V^X]Q, etc. To keep t h e formalism general at this stage of t h e theory n o a s s u m p t i o n is m a d e about the geometry of the heterogeneities, hence the vectorial notation. The quantity F[x(z)] is, a s in van der Waals' theory, a density functional. Using a vector t h e o r e m similar to o u r [I.A7.51] t h e t e r m with V^x eliminated. Introducing K = K^~ dK^/dx
can be
the authors converted [2.6.1] into
F[x{z]] = N J J J [/^(x) + K{Wxf + ...]dV
[2.6.2]
In physical t e r m s t h i s m e a n s t h a t to a first approximation the Helmholtz energy of a small volume of a non-uniform system can be expressed a s the s u m of two contributions: (i) the Helmholtz energy t h a t this volume would have if it h a d 1^ J.W. Cahn, J.E. Hilliard, J. Chem. Phys. 28 (1958) 258.
2.35
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
been homogeneous at the same composition, and (ii) a square gradient term. This is a more formal equivalent of van der Waals' finding, compare [2.5.30]. Both theories a s s u m e t h a t on the scale of the heterogeneities, /
is a c o n t i n u o u s function of
position. In later publicaUons, Cahn a n d Hilliard omit the N b u t s u b s u m e it in / ^ a n d K. This new /
is identical to p^g in van der Waals' theory, see for instance
[2.5.18]. If [2.6.2] is applied to the flat p h a s e b o u n d a r y between two coexisting p h a s e s a and P it reduces to
F[x(z]] = ANJ
v^'H^J
[2.6.3]
dz
where we henceforth neglect higher order terms. The more gradual the density profile is, t h a t is, closer to the critical point, the better the simplification becomes. Bongiorno a n d Davis presented a r g u m e n t s to the effect t h a t [2.6.3] r e m a i n s a successful approximation over the entire coexistence curve 1^. The excess Helmholtz energy per u n i t area F^ = / is obtained by s u b t r a c t i n g from [2.6.3] t h e Helmholtz energy t h a t the system would have if the properties of the p h a s e s were c o n t i n u o u s t h r o u g h o u t , i.e. x^^(eq) + (l-x)//"(eq) integrated over t h e profile. Figure 2.8 illustrates t h e m e a n i n g of the symbols; it follows from t h e general theory of p h a s e separation introduced in sec. [1.2.19], a n d in passing we note the great similarity to fig. 2.5. Introducing A/(x) = f^M = x[^\x]
- [x//P(eq) + ( 1 - x)Ai«(eq)] = [2.6.4]
-/xP(eq)] + (l-x)[Ax"M-A/"(eq)]
/(O)
/iP(eq)
A^"(eq)
P
1
1^ V. Bongiorno, H.T. Davis, Phys. Rev. A12 (1975) 2213.
Figure 2.8. Illustrating the meaning of symbols in the Cahn-Hllliard model.
2.36
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
[2.6.3] can be rewritten a s
\n.u{^J
y = NJ
Idz
(2.6.51
where A/(x) may be regarded a s the Helmholtz energy per molecular volume with respect to a s t a n d a r d state of a n equilibrium mixture of p h a s e s a a n d (3 or a s the Helmholtz energy needed to transfer one molecule of material from a n infinitely large reservoir of composition x " and x^ to the composition
x(z).
As already stated in the discussion of [2.5.30] the two terms on the r.h.s. of [2.6.51 are dependent. Reduction of the square gradient contribution K[dx/dz)^
to / c a n
only be achieved at the expense of introducing more material to the transition zone at n o n - e q u i l i b r i u m composition, which would increase A/(x). E q u i l i b r i u m is attained if the r.h.s. of [2.6.5] is a minimum. Cahn and Hilliard demonstrate t h a t this equilibrium is attained if the two t e r m s are identical A/(x) = K[^]
[2.6.6]
This result is again equivalent to t h a t of van der Waals, referred to between [2.5.23 a n d 24]. So one finally obtains y = 2N j KI — ] dz
[2.6.7]
which is equivalent to -foo
y = 2NJ Af{x)dz
[2.6.8]
or, by changing variables using [2.6.6]
y = 2NJ [K Af{x]f^ dx
[2.6.9]
x«
The analogy between the various steps in the derivation a n d between the results of this theory a n d t h a t of van der Waals (compare [2.6.8] with [2.5.28]) is striking. In c o n t e n t t h e C a h n a n d Hilliard theory c o n t r i b u t e s little more t h a n v a n der Waals', a l t h o u g h t h e formalism is easier to h a n d l e . Nevertheless, C a h n and Hilliard do n o t cite v a n der Waals' pioneering work, except for m e n t i o n i n g [2.5.29]!).
!^ In 1999 Cahn told the present author that when developing his theory he was ignorant of Van der Waals' achievements. When he learned about these a few years later it came to him 'as a great shock'.
2.37
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Like van der Waals, C a h n and Hilliard also elaborated their theory. Close to t h e critical point they confirmed van der Waals' 3 / 2 power in [2.5.29], b u t with a reinterpreted c o n s t a n t . Their profile also obeyed the t a n h law [2.5.31] a n d they applied the regular solution theory (see sec. 1.2.18c) to obtain quantitative values for the surface tension. In table 2.1 some results are collected for simple liquids for w h i c h this theory is s u p p o s e d to apply. These d a t a give some feeling for t h e achievements. Table 2 . 1 .
Observed a n d computed surface tensions. Cahn-Hilliard model for
regular solutions. Liquid
T/K
T
/K
/(exp)/mN m ^
7(comp)/mN m ^
c
Ne
26.6
44.8
4.99
5.68
Ar
87:o
150.7
12.59
13.45
80.0
126.0
8.30
8.32
80.0
154.3
15.70
16.33
\^2
1^2
^ Experimental data for the surface tension of Ar, Ng and O2 taken from (interpolation of) table A1.4. Other data taken from E.A. Guggenheim, J. Chem. Phys. 13 (1945) 253. The difference between Guggenheim's and our data is not significant. For the t h i c k n e s s of the interface t, defined a s in fig. 2.6, the a u t h o r s write (ll/7)^^'^r^,
where r^ is the intermolecular distance. For details, see the original
paper. From this it is concluded t h a t the correlation length ^, introduced in sec. 2.5, is again of the order of molecular distances. Of course for more complex liquids the correlations will have a longer range. In conclusion, the Cahn-Hilliard theory is a modernization of van der Waals', confirming a n d extending the latter. With these theories a n d their m a n y v a r i a n t s a n d e x t e n s i o n s the framework is basically available for c o m p u t i n g interfacial t e n s i o n s from molecular interactions. Carrying out the c o m p u t a t i o n s is no easy m a t t e r , especially if t h e molecules are not spherical a n d if their i n t e r a c t i o n s c o n t a i n c o n t r i b u t i o n s other t h a n those of the L e n n a r d - J o n e s type. T h e n t h e quality of the results is determined by the quality of the choice of the p a r a m e t e r s , analytical approximations, truncations, etc. A promising alternative is to invoke computer solutions, which will be treated in the next section. 2.7
Interfacial t e n s i o n s from simulations
There is r e a s o n for considering Monte Carlo (MC) a n d / o r Molecular Dynamics (MD) computer simulations a s a welcome alternative a n d extension for predicting surface t e n s i o n s in t e r m s of molecular properties a n d i n t e r a c t i o n s . Existing theories, s u c h a s the Kirkwood-Buff approach (sec. 2.4), tend to be intractable.
2.38
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
except for the most simple molecules, because the required multi-body correlations in the transition layer cannot be independently obtained and, if the formulas are written in terms of measurable functions (like g^^\r) in bulk phases), assumptions are introduced the quality of which is hard to assess. Mean field approaches, like those of van der Waals (sec. 2.5) and Cahn-Hilliard (sec. 2.6) are subject to the restrictions inherent to these methods, like the neglect of fluctuations, and contain a constant that is difficult to evaluate anyway. For these reasons it is hardly surprising that nowhere in the literature tables are found in which, for a variety of liquids, the surface tension and its temperature dependence are interpreted in terms of such theories. In principle, but not yet necessarily in practice, simulations offer a way out. Basically the problem is now of a technical nature: one starts from [2.4.6] which is modified into a weighted sum over all pair interaction forces. To achieve this, one needs to know the composition of the molecule, with its internal degrees of freedom and interaction (potential) energies between the various constituting molecular groups as functions of distance and orientation. Moreover, the reduction of the issue to sums of pair interactions begs the questions of additivity and range of action, i.e. the distance at which the interaction becomes negligible (issue of cut-off length). Given a large enough sample and enough computer time eventually interfacial properties like y, S^, t and pAz) are obtainable in terms of the mentioned molecular parameters. However, in these approaches also, the technical problems are formidable so that in practice simplifications have to be made. The problems to resolve include: (i) Establishing the shape of the interaction u.ir,0) of all i-j pairs. For simple monatomic molecules the Lennard-Jones model (sec. 1.5b) suffices. Then, only two parameters are needed, usually u , the energy of the minimum, and a, the distance where u[r) = 0 (i.e. where repulsion and attraction just balance), or r , the distance of the minimum (indicated in fig. 1.4.9). In this case the surface tension follows from the average over pair energies as^'^^
where the symbols are as in sec. 2.4. Energies are counted in each time-step, but the averaging over several time-steps adds configurational information, i.e. converts the sum into a Helmholtz energy. For slightly more complicated (= more realistic) molecules, [2.7.1] remains essentially valid, but pairs of atoms inside molecules now have other types of interaction, for instance vibrational ones between the carbons in butanol, CHg(CH2)3 0H, and rotational ones in C-C bonds in the chain. ^^ P.P. Buff, Z. ElektrocherrL 5 6 (1952) 3 1 1 . 2^ G.A. Chapela, G. Saville a n d J . S . Rowlinson, Faraday
Discuss.
Chem. Soc. 5 9 (1976) 2 2 .
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.39
In t h i s still relatively simple molecule all pair interactions between the nine Ha t o m s at the carbons, the H at the hydroxyl, the four carbons a n d the oxygen, have to be accounted for. Treating the OH-group interaction also via a L e n n a r d - J o n e s interaction plus a n added (ideal) dipole contribution is already a n approximation b e c a u s e intermolecular d i s t a n c e s are too s h o r t to t r e a t dipoles a s ideal. In m a t h e m a t i c a l t e r m s , t h e e x p r e s s i o n s derived for Debye- a n d
Keesom-type
i n t e r a c t i o n s (1.4.4c) are only first a p p r o x i m a t i o n s , t h e more so b e c a u s e t h e rotation of the dipole is restricted. In practice there is often no cdtemative t h a n to m a k e 'clever guesses' a b o u t the various u (r) functions. It is always possible to group some types of interaction together, to obtain more detailed expressions for yA.
S u c h a n equation for dumb-bell types of molecules have b e e n given by
Alejandre et al.^^ and by Harris '^\ S u c h types of equations can also be formulated for the tangential component of the pressure tensor, p.(z), which for simple molecules is a curve with a m a x i m u m , a s sketched in fig. 2.2. In passing it is noted t h a t the asymmetrical c o m p o n e n t s of this tensor c a n in principle also be obtained, both in the b u l k liquid a n d n e a r surfaces, a n d that, from the integral over the time-correlation function of t h e s e components, the viscosity is obtainable. Such computations are very demanding of c o m p u t e r power. For liquids n e a r h a r d walls the viscosity a p p e a r s to b e anisotropic, the normal viscosity being higher t h a n the tangential one*^^. (ii) Establishing t h e values of t h e p a r a m e t e r s . For very simple fluids, like c o n d e n s e d argon, u
a n d a are well-established from c o m p a r i s o n of o t h e r
simulations against experimental data, b u t for more complex s y s t e m s t h e extra p a r a m e t e r s needed are in fact adjustable. The problem is compounded by the fact t h a t any defect in the choice of u^Xr) functionalities is reflected in the values to be assigned to the parameters in order to obtain realistic macroscopic data. How good functionalities a n d parameter values really are h a s to be judged on the basis of the capability of adequately interpreting d i s p a r a t e d a t a (like t h e triple point, t h e v a p o u r p r e s s u r e a n d its t e m p e r a t u r e dependence a n d the surface entropy a n d energy) with the same set. (iii) Limiting the n u m b e r of molecules counted, a n d / o r the n u m b e r of time-steps involved with the purpose of reducing computer time. Because of the heterogeneity of the system m u c h larger n u m b e r s of molecules have to be sampled t h a n for bulk systems, a n d this m u s t be done at various temperatures'^l As a trend it requires less computer time to obtain p^^iz), and hence t, t h a n 7, because the former is a
1^ J. Alejandre, D.J. Tildesley and G.A. Chapela, J. CherrL Phys. 102 (1995) 4574. 2^ J.G. Harris, J. Phys. Chem. 96 (1992) 5077. ^^ J. Lyklema, S. Rovillard and J. de Coninck, Langmuir 14 (1998) 5659-63. "^^ For a review of the statistical backgrounds, but without any example of a surface tension computation, see D. Nicholson, N.G. Parsonage, Computer Simulation and the Statistical Mechanics 0/Adsorption, Academic Press (1982).
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.40
mechanical, the latter a thermodynamic quantity. Considering all these uncertainties it is p e r h a p s appropriate to summarize the s t a t e of affairs a s promising, b u t w a n t i n g more experience to improve
u.^r)
functions a n d parameter values. Against this background, we may recall that, in Volume II. computer simulation r e s u l t s for interfacial properties have already been discussed. These include the density profile of a L e n n a r d - J o n e s fluid against a solid wall (fig. II.2.4), a MD simulation of self-diffusion of 'soft' spherical molecules n e a r a h a r d ' wall (fig. II.2.5), a n d distributions of molecules between solid surfaces (figs. II. 1.38 a n d 2.6). Moreover, the discussion in sec. II.3.9 included simulation results for the average polarization of water at the water-air interface. For a n update on the free surface of water see^^. S u c h results give some feeling for accuracy a n d / o r statistical error. Generally, o u r finding t h a t the thickness of the transition layer corresponds to a few molecular layers is confirmed. The oscillations found for fluids in c o n t a c t with h a r d walls are of course not encountered for LG interfaces. Only for liquidliquid i n t e r f a c e s
between
two completely i n c o m p a t i b l e fluids
may
such
oscillations b e expected, b u t this is a r a t h e r academic situation. Even water a n d hydrocarbon molecules a t t r a c t each other; the hydrophobicity of h y d r o c a r b o n s h a s a n entropic reason which is not readily accounted for by a Lennard-Jones type of interaction. An illustrative simulation w a s given by Stecki a n d
150
200
250
300
350
ToxvaerdflK
400
T/K Figure 2.9. Surface tension of a diatomic liquid, mimicking CI2, obtained by MD. Discussion in the text (redrawn from J. Alejandre, D.J. Tildesley and G.A. Chapela, Molec. Phys. 85 (1995) 651). 1) V.P. Sokhan, D.J. Tildesley, Mol Phys. 92 (1997) 625. 2^ S. Toxvaerd, J. Stecki, J.Chem. Phys. 102 (1995) 7163; J. Stecki, S. Toxvaerd, J. Chem. Phys. 103 (1995) 4352.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.41
who,
P^iz)
for simple Lennard-Jones fluids, found oscillations in b o t h p^{z) a n d
if a a n d p do not mix. There was even a thin layer of v a c u u m between the two liquid slabs. We shall not consider this situation any further. In addition to the simulation results on the s t r u c t u r e of interfaces, reported so far in FICS, we shall now give some outcomes on surface a n d interfacial tensions. In so doing, we m a k e the conscious decision to omit most of the technical details (numbers of molecules a n d time steps, interaction functions, accounting for internal degrees of freedom etc.) although the results depend, sometimes critically, on these. Therefore, our examples merely serve a s illustrations of the achievements. Figure 2.9 is our first example. The molecule, mimicking chlorine, is still too simple to be representative of the types of fluids commonly considered in FICS, b u t gives a n illustration of the achievements. The results are a n improvement on those by T h o m p s o n 1^ who w a s apparently the first to simulate the surface of diatomic liquids. The open a n d the closed circles are MD results for a cut-off length of 1.29 a n d 1.50 n m , respectively. Beyond the cut-off length the a u t h o r s applied a longrange correction. In passing, Blokhuis et al.^^ noted t h a t this correction is often not properly applied w h e n it is b a s e d on a tail correction by Chapela et al.^^ b e c a u s e t h e latter is subject to a n algebraic error. With this correction there is no significant difference between the two cut-off lengths. An accuracy of a b o u t 2 % required 10^ time steps for p ^ but 10^ for / , which w a s calculated from a variant of [2.7.1]. For more computational detafls, see the original paper. The c o m p u t e d surface t e n s i o n s compare very well with experimental ones'^^ indicated by t h e d r a w n line. Figure 2.10, from the s a m e a u t h o r s , simulates hexane. The open a n d black circles refer to different models of computation; the thick line r e p r e s e n t s experim e n t a l r e s u l t s . These results for / agree better with experiments t h a n those of Harris^^ whose computed values overestimate y by about 20%, although the trend a s a function of T w a s simflar. Harris simulated decane (CJQH22) a n d eicosane (C2QH^2)' t>y considering the CH^'s and CH2's a s connected 'Lennard-Jones atoms', taking b o n d angles a n d torsional energies into account. He found t h e overall profile to be monotonic, although the central segments of the chain tend to enrich the centre of the density profile a n d chain ends dominate the outer surface. For decane at 300 and 400 K he computed / = 29 and 17 mN m"^ (exp. 23.2 and 14.0 mN m"^) a n d for eicosane at 400 K y = 28-31 mN m"^ (exp. 20 mN m"^). In sec. 2.10 we shall amplify these results using a n advamced lattice-hole theory.
^^ S.M. Thompson, Faraday Discuss, Chem. Soc. 66 (1978) 107. 2) E.M. Blokhuis, D. Bedeaux, CD. Holcomb and J.A. Zollweg, Mol Phys. 85 (1995) 665. ^^ G.A. Chapela, G. Saville, G. Thompson and J.S. Rowlinson, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. Ill 81 (1977) 1133. ^^ International Critical Tables. Ill (1928). ^^ J.G. Harris, J. Phys. Chem. 96 (1992) 5077.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.42
25
E 20
e 15
10
250
300
350
400
450
500
T/K Figure 2.10. Surface tension of a hexa-atomic liquid, mimicking hexane. Part of the range is supercritical. Same source as in fig. 2.9. Line without data points, experimental data from table A 1.5. The water-water vapour interface h a s been studied by various a u t h o r s , u s i n g increasingly sophisticated models, interaction energies a n d more powerful comp u t e r s ^\ We give in table 2.2 molecular dynamics results in which a more refined water model w a s used (the so-called extended simple point charge' model, SPCIE, a three-point charge distribution in which the partial charges were adjusted by fitting t h e self-energy of liquid water). The long range i n t e r a c t i o n s p a r t w a s considered in some detail, and in addition to the dipole moment in v a c u u m (1.85 D) a n induced m o m e n t w a s included, resulting in p(eff) = 2.35 D. The results can be compared with the best experimental data available, presented in fig. 1.24. Over the available r a n g e t h e r e s u l t s agree within the indicated error, so t h a t a t least consistency with bulk properties h a s been achieved. The a u t h o r s did not compute the ;^-potential for the water-water vapour interface. The methanol-vapour interface w a s studied over a wide temperature range (160350 K) using MD by Matsumoto and Kataoka^^ As expected, the CH3 groups point outward. The dipole of the OH-group is almost horizontal with a very low %potential (-30 mV at 2 9 8 K). Ellipsometry w a s included b u t no interfacial tensions were reported.
1^ C.Y. Lee, H.L. Scott, J. Chem. Phys. 7 3 (1980) 4 5 9 1 ; C.A. Croxton, Physica 1 0 6 A (1981) 2 3 9 ; M.A. Wilson. A. Pohorille a n d L.R. Pratt, J. Phys. Chem. 9 1 (1987) 4 8 7 3 ; M. M a t s u m o t o , Y. K a t a o k a , J . Chem. Phys. 8 8 (1988) 3 2 3 3 ; A. Pohorille, M.A. Wilson, J. Molec. Struct 2 8 4 (1993) 2 7 1 ; G.C. Lie, S. Grigoras, L.X. Dang, D.Y. Yang a n d A.D. McLean, J. Chem Phys. 9 9 (1993) 3 9 3 3 . 2) M. Matsumoto, Y. Kataoka, J. Chem Phys. 9 0 (1989) 2 3 9 8 .
2.43
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION Table 2 . 2 . Surface tension of water, obtained by Molecular Dynamics.
N= 1000
Ar=512
1
T/K
y/mN m ^
T/K
y/niN m ^
328 367 435 479 538 573
66.0 58.5 45.7 39.3 20.1 17.7
316 411 504
71.5
1
53.2 30.8
The uncertainty in y is 3-4 mN m"^ N is the number of molecules sampled. Source: J. Alejandre, D. J. Tildesley and G.A. Chapela, J. Chem. Phys. 102 (1995) 4574. Liquid-liquid interfacial tensions c a n in principle also be obtained by simulations, b u t for the time being, the technical problems are prohibitive. Benjamin^^ studied the djmamics of the water-l,2-dichloroethane interface in connection with a study of transfer rates across the interface, b u t gave no interfacial tensions. In a s u b s e q u e n t study^^ the interface between n o n a n e a n d water w a s simulated by MD, with some e m p h a s i s on the dynamics. Nonane a p p e a r s to orient relatively flat towards water. The s a m e trend, b u t weaker, w a s found with respect to vapour. Water dipoles adjacent to n o n a n e adsorb about flat, with a broad distribution; the ordering is a few molecular layers deep. Fukunishi et al.^^ studied the octane-water interface, b u t with a very low n u m b e r of molecules. Their approach differed somew h a t from t h a t t a k e n in the simulations described previously; they computed t h e potential of m e a n force for transferring a solute molecule to t h e interface. The interfacial tension was 57 ± 11 mN m ~ \ which is in the proper range (experimental value 50.8) b u t of course not yet discriminative (for all hydrocarbons t h e interfacial tension with water is very similar). In a n earlier study Linse investigated the benzene-water interface by MC s i m u l a t i o n ^ l He found t h a t the water-benzene orientation in t h e interface w a s similar to t h a t in dilute solution of b e n z e n e in water. At the interface the water dipoles tend to a s s u m e a parallel orientation. The a u t h o r did not compute a x -potential. Obviously, there is m u c h room for further developments. Simulations for the surfaces of binary solutions will be included in sec. 4.2. 2.8
The t h i c k n e s s of t h e interfacial region
How thick is the transition layer between two adjacent homogeneous bulk p h a s e s ?
^^ I. Benjamin, J. Chem. Phys. 97 (1992) 1432. 2^ D. Michael. I. Benjamin, J. Phys. Chem. 99 (1995) 1530. ^^ Y. Fukunishi, T. Tateishi and M. Suzuki, J. Colloid Interface Set 180 (1996) 188. 4) P. Linse, J. Chem Phys. 86 (1987) 4177.
2.44
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
This is a somewhat academic question because the answer depends on the definition; of this. Two possibilities for this have been given in fig. 2.6. Nevertheless, for interpretational purposes it is sometimes useful to have some feeling for 'the' thickness t. The issue may be compared with that of defining 'the' thickness of an electric double layer. Strictly speaking such layers are infinitely thick but for many practical purposes, like colloid stability and electrokinetics, it has proved convenient to introduce the Debye length, K:"^ as a representative measure of t. Making this choice for double layers involves three elements: (i) a model is accepted (in this case a diffuse double layer on a flat surface); (ii) in terms of this model a distance-dependent characteristic is formulated (i.e. the potential, y/]; (iii) based on this formula, using some mathematical device, a cut-off length is defined (i.e. K~^ is the distance over which y/ has reduced from its value at the outer Helmholtz plane to its e-th part in the situation of low potentials). Experience has shown that this decision makes sense. Reasons for this are: (i) the model is sufficiently general. Even if the surface is not flat and the potentials are not low, K~^ remains a useful pairameter (see sees. II.3.5e-g). Only when the double layer is not diffuse at all, does the notion of K~^ lose its meaning; (ii) the model is realistic in that a large fraction of the countercharge resides within x< K~^', (iii) the parameter K~^ can be simply computed and is experimentally accessible, say from thin film thicknesses, using DLVO theory. The comparison with assessing electric double layer thickness is appropriate because in defining t we are facing exactly the same kind of problems. First, from the theoretical side, we need a model that is sufficiently general to be representative. For simple LG and LL interfaces, in the absence of a third, adsorbing component, we do have such an equation, viz. the hyperbolic tangent distribution [2.5.31]. Such a distribution occurs in the theories of van der Waals, Cahn-Hilliard and other mean field approaches. Moreover, MD-simulated pAz) profiles can often be well fitted with a tanh functionality. So, pAz] is our obvious distancedependent characteristic. For a two-component system (as in fig. 2.1), for reasons of symmetry the thickness based on p^iz) is identical to that based on P^(z)- To quantify t we can take the (oversimplified) extrapolated linear part (t in fig. 2.6) or the more realistic t^^ ^^, which is longer by a factor of about 1.5. For simulations tgQ/jQ is a good measure because at the 90/10 level (p^> is still discernible against the background noise that is also felt in the bulk fluids. The question then arises as to what thickness is physically measured. Besides the issue how t relates to ^ there is the additional problem om that we have not tried to give an interpretation of this correlation length. Such an interpretation of ^ would be possible using the theory of van der Waals or CahnHilliard. Such models predict ^ to increase with T, although there is some
2.45
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
0.8
6 u
0.6
0.4
0.2
10 n m
-10
Figure 2.11. (Weight-) density profile for a slab of hexane, corresponding with the data of fig. 2.10, T= 299 K (same source as in fig. 2.9).
T=328K
4 nm
Figure 2.12. (Weight-) density profile for water, corresponding with the data of table 2.2 (same source). discussion about the strength and shape of the <J(T) dependence. As we decided not to go into so m u c h detail we should rather discuss results from simulation or from physical experiments ^'. We p r e s e n t a first set of results in figs. 2.11 a n d 2.12, t h e density profiles corresponding to the surface tension d a t a for hexane in fig. 2.10 a n d for water in
^^ For a review on this matter, see A.I. Rusanov, Recent Investigations on the Thickness of Surface Layers, in Progr. in Surface and Membrane Set 4 (1991) 57-114.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.46 table 2.2, respectively.
These two figures show the profile twice because for computational reasons (viz. to introduce periodic b o u n d a r y conditions) it is easier to work with a slab of the liquid u n d e r consideration. As expected, the transition layer is thicker a t higher temperatures. The weight densities aire readily converted into n u m b e r densities. It a p p e a r e d t h a t t h e profiles could be well fitted with a t a n h function, so t h a t a n effective thickness may be derived, say t
. - See fig. 2.13.
The absolute values of t h e s e thicknesses correspond with, or r a t h e r confirm, our earlier estimations t h a t for water at room temperature the interfacial layer is a few molecular layers thick. For hexane t^Q,^Q is, at similar t e m p e r a t u r e s , not m u c h higher t h a n t h a t for water and m u c h less t h a n the contour length. In fact, one would not expect the hexane molecules to be stretched a n d oriented parallel in the transition layer. Of course, for higher temperatures t rises progressively t h e closer T is approached. With d a t a for y a n d t available it is now possible to m a k e a rough estimate of the H a m a k e r c o n s t a n t u s i n g t h e simplified formula A^Sny^^, Replacing ^jy t^
see [2.5.43].
, choosing ^ = 0.34 and 0.29 n m and / = 22 and 71 mN m"^ for
hexane a n d water a t 3 0 0 K, respectively (obtained from fig. 2.10 a n d extrapolated from table 2.2, respectively), we find A = 27.6 fcT for water and A = 11.8 /cT for hexane. The tabulated values are 10-15 kT and 10 fcT in this order. So for h e x a n e the agreement is good (and d a t a for other organic liquids are required to find o u t w h e t h e r this result is fortuitous) b u t for water there is a significant disagreement which m u s t be attributed to the fact t h a t its surface tension is to a large extent determined by other t h a n dispersion forces, especially by hydrogen bonding.
Wio
300
350
550 K
Figure 2.13. The thickness ^90/10 from MD simulations for hexane and water, inferred from figs. 2.11 and 2.12. N = 1000. ■ Experimental values by Matsumoto and Kataoka (see text); open symbols, simulations.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.47
It is also possible to assume the correctness of the van der Waals-Cahn Hilliard profile and from there compute the thickness, invoking empirical observations to quantify the parameters. By way of example, Stott and Young^^ did so for van der Waals fluids using the experimental fact that the product of surface tension and isothermal compressibility of a liquid is fairly independent of temperature. For argon at 90 K and 120 K they found 0.83 and 1.29 nm, respectively for tg^/jQ' ^^ satisfactory agreement with experimental data (from scattering) by Beaglehole^^: 0.79 ± 0.05 and 1.5 ± 0.01 nm, respectively. Experimentally a measure of t can be obtained from ellipsometry or X-ray reflectivity. None of these methods is unambiguous. The principles of ellipsometry have been set forth in sec. 1.7.10b. For the ellipsometric thickness of an interlayer over which the index of refraction n changes with position we gave the following Drude equation p ( z ) - [n-f] p ( z ) - [n^f] ^eU =
[2.8.1]
This is II.7.10.17] after replacing e l^ n^ and h by t. We also discussed how t^jj can be experimentally measured. Ellipsometry is usually applied to adsorbed layers that have good optical contrast, but it can of course also be obtained to find t^^j for pure liquid-vapour or liquid-liquid interfaces. The problem of [2.8.1] is that to learn what kind of thickness is obtained r?{z) must be known and this is determined by p^(z) • Hence, this is not an independent experiment. The alternative to this technique is reflectometry, of which the principles can be found in sees. 1.7.10a and b. As with ellipsometry, it is necessary to make some assumption about the profile. By way of illustration we give some literature data for the water-vapour interface. Some of these results are reproduced in fig. 2.13 as black squares. Matsumoto and Kataoka^^ reported 0.41 and 0.83 nm for tg^/jQ at 300 K, obtained from ellipsometry and X-ray reflectivity, respectively. Again, the ellipsometric thicknesses are not independent; in this case the required a^(z) profile was obtained from the simulated profile p^(z) through the Clausius-Mossotti equation, [1.4.4.lOJ. These authors also determined the ;^-potential and found +0.16 V at 300 K (negative side outward). Sign and order of magnitude agree with the collected evidence from electrochemistry, sec. II.3.9. The polcirization is not restricted to preferential orientation of water molecules in the outer surface layer only.
1^ M.J. Stott, W.H. Young, Phys. Chem. Liq, 11 (1981) 95. 2J D. Beaglehole, Phys. Rev. Lett 43 (1979) 2016. 3^ M. Matsumoto, Y. Kataoka, J. Cherrh Phys. 88 (1988) 3233.
2.48
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Schwartz et al.^^ m e a s u r e d the surface roughness (t^) at 298 K and obtained 0.28 n m . According to Simister et al.^^ for a t a n h profile t^^ t
equals 2.423 (t^), so
becomes 0.69 n m . Hence, the conclusion is t h a t these optical m e t h o d s also
give rise to large uncertainties, ailthough the orders of magnitude are right. Various liquid surfaces have been studied ellipsometrically by KlzeV'^K Far more experimental d a t a are available for interfaces carrying adsorbates, b u t t h a t will be discussed in detail in chapters 3 and 4. 2.9
Quasi-thermodynamic approaches. Effects of temperature and pressure. Corresponding s t a t e s
It is possible to obtain more insight into t h e s t r u c t u r e of liquid surfaces by subjecting empirical findings to thermodynamic reasoning. The reasoning may be fairly rigorous, b u t the validity a n d applicable range of t h e c o n c l u s i o n s a r e determined by the quality a n d generality of the factual information on which they rest. S u c h quasi-thermodynamic approaches are more general a n d h e n c e we let t h e m precede interpretations based on specific models (sec. 2.10) a n d those of a n entirely empirical n a t u r e (sec. 2.11). 2.9a
Influence
of temperature.
Energetic
and entropic
The empirical rule with the widest applicability is t h a t of
contributions the t e m p e r a t u r e
dependence of the interfacial tension, Y(T) . For m a n y liquids this trend is linear, provided the temperature is close to the melting point T
and its range is not t a k e n
too great^K The d a t a in fig. 1.24 a n d in appendix 1 illustrate this general trend. At higher t e m p e r a t u r e s / gradually approaches zero at the critical point b u t for t h e moment we will not discuss t h a t part of the range b u t will consider y = a-hT
(^-^^m^
■^•^•^'
For p u r e liquids [2.9.1] is immediately interpreted as [2.2.13]: y = Ul - TSl
[2.9.2]
so t h a t linearity (or deviations thereof) is recognized a s temperature independence (or deviations thereof) of the surface excess energy a n d entropy. Before considering the data we note that measurements of y(T) for various liquids m u s t in some c a s e s
^^ D.K. Schwartz, E.K. Schlossman, G.J. Kellog, P.S. Persham and B.M. Ocko, Phys. Rev. A41 (1990) 5678. 2^ E.A. Simister, E.M. Lere, R.K. Thomas and J. Penfold, J. Phys. Chem, 96 (1992) 1373. 3^ V.A. Kizel', Zhur. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 29 (1955) 658. ^^ One of the few exceptions are molecules like p-azoxyanisol, p-azoxyphenetol and anisaldazine, which form anisotropic liquids and for which Wolf [Physik und Chemie der Grenzfidchen, Vol. 1, Springer (1957), p. 44) reports y{T) curves with kinks.
2.49
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
• BFO
0.18
(a)
Ar
0.16
e "0
CO
HoO
CI2
0.14
HCN / H 2 S
0.12
•AgCl
0.10
HCl j
0.08
AsClc
CSNO3 RbCl KF^RblKBr/ NaCl
PH3I
ca. 50 organic liquids
0.06 0.04 Y
•RbF
»SbCL
I pcf
Csl • •^** RbBr \
NaBr
LiCl
• KF •K2SO4
NaNOc, KCl
He
HoSO^
Nal
0.02 0
50
100
250 m J m~^
200
150
a. 0.18 I 0.16
V
LiF.
(b)
'Pb
1H9O
0.14 0.12
•Au . 1
.
1 AgCl, ^RbF
.sn
" ^ s e e low 0.10 \ IC^region 0.08 0.06 Y
•
K2SO4
0.04 i-
Bi
Nal
0.02 1
0
,
__L
200
.
1
400
,
1
600
,1
800
.
1
1000
1200 m J m-2 ^ o
Figure 2.14. Relation between surface excess entropy and -energy. Temperature not far above the melting point, T (a) Substances with lower T ; (b) with higher T . be carried out over widely diverging p r e s s u r e s , to avoid evaporation. Sometimes this is achieved by creating a vapour p h a s e containing other gases; if t h e s e gases are not inert they may adsorb and hence affect y and d y / d T . Mostly the effect of p r e s s u r e is not prominent, see sec. 2.9b a n d for the p r e s e n t p u r p o s e we shall disregard it. It is enlightening to consider the collected data for S^ and U^ in fig. 2.14. On the a b s c i s s a e axis the surface excess energy per unit area is plotted j u s t above the melting point of the liquid. These data are t a k e n from our tables in appendix 1. Values for S^ are obtained a s - d / Z d T a n d \J^. Note t h a t always U^ exceeds y
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.50
because it equals y-T{dy/6T)
a n d dy/dT
is negative. Surface excess entropies are
always positive, a t least for p u r e liquids a n d liquid mixtures. Their absolute values are r e a s o n a b l y well established, a t least for the better studied materials. The column giving -A in table 1.4 in sec. 1.12 illustrates how good this statement is for water; for less profoundly studied liquids the disparity in S^ between different investigators is usually not more t h a n 0.010-0.020 mN m"^ K"^ Accepting t h e uncertainties for w h a t they are, the striking conclusion is t h a t , broadly s p e a k i n g , t h e r e is n o entropy-energy coupling. Although U^
varies
by more t h a n a factor of u p to 10^, S^ r e m a i n s c o n s t a n t between a b o u t 0.07 a n d 0 . 1 5 mN m"^ K"\ i.e. within a b o u t a factor of two. Hardly a n y significant trend is observed. For alkanes there is a trend of S^ to decrease somewhat with increasing hydrocarbon c h a i n length in the homologous series, a s is illustrated in fig. 2.15, w h e r e a s for n-alcohols there is no cleeir trend. For other homologous series the corresponding t r e n d s can be inferred from the tables in appendix 1. Regarding t h e alkames, it is likely t h a t the decreasing trend of S^ is related to the way in which t h e molecules are arranged in the interface. Evidence from the work of adhesion, light scattering a n d h e a t s of mixing^'2) indicates t h a t the higher n-alkanes tend to orient parcdlel to one another, a n d to the interface. This p h e n o m e n o n m a y reduce 0.24 mJm-^KT^
0.221-, 0.20 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.10
°^o^o
0.08
A
0.06 0
A
^
alkanes -°-o-o-o-o-o—o-o-o-o.
alcohols _l_
10
15 20 number of carbon atoms
25
Figure 2.15. Surface excess entropy for n-alkanes aind n-aliphatic alcohols at temperatures just above the melting points. Data from tables A1.5 and 6, except for the value for ethcine which is taken from A.J. Leadbetter, D.J. Taylor and B. Vincent, Can, J. Chem. 4 2 (1964) 2930, and that for methane which stems from from S. Fuks and A. Bellemans, Physica 32 (1966) 594.
1) R. Aveyard, J. Colloid Interface Set 52 (1975) 621. 2) F.M. Fowkes, J. Phys. Chem. 84 (1980) 510.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.51
S^ a n d m a k e it chain length-independent if the chain is long enough. For lower alcohols the OH-group may keep S^ low a s compared with the alkanes of the s a m e length. However, although these a n d other t r e n d s offer fodder for theoreticians, they are minor a s compared with the basic trend of constancy a s exhibited in fig. 2.14. Even water does not take a n exceptional position and S^ is not very different between condensed noble gases a n d molten metals, provided readings are t a k e n for T -> T^. The conclusions may also be stated a s : the surface excess energy is a substance-speci/ic quantity whereas the corresponding entropy is rather generic. This remarkable feature is not widely recognized in the literature and suggests a kind of corresponding
state
principle. It may be recalled t h a t t h e notion of
corresponding s t a t e s w a s introduced by van der Waals. If his equation of state [2.5.1] were universally valid, it should be possible to express the critical p r e s s u r e , p , temperature, T , a n d volume, V in t e r m s of his c o n s t a n t s a a n d b a n d t h e n rewrite [2.5.1) in terms of reduced pressures, temperatures a n d volumes, p/p
= p^,
etc. The resulting reduced van der Waals equation reads ^^ 3 V
(3V - l ) = 8T^ c J
[2.9.3]
and, if his corresponding state principle applies, [2.9.3] should be identical for a n y s u b s t a n c e . In practice, t h i s equation does not apply so generally. However, a corresponding state principle may act in other domains of physical chemistry a n d n e e d s n o t be referred to the critical point. Formulating it generally for a b u l k p h a s e , a corresponding state principle applies if in the relation
Pc = fK
K)
12.9.41
/ is a universal, b u t not necessarily simple, function. Here, the subindex c refers to a n agreed reference. As mentioned before, it is c u s t o m a r y to relate physical quantities to their values at the critical point, b u t for / , U^ a n d S^ this is not a viable option because interfaces vanish at this point. So for the present t h e m e t h e corresponding state principle is t h a t for T -^T
[2.9.2] applies with S^ a b o u t
constant. (Experience h a s shown t h a t for many liquids T / T is about the same, so t h a t after all a renormalization in t e r m s of T can be made.) c
This principle c a n be p u t on a general footing by considering the canonical partition function. Absence of energy-entropy coupling m e a n s t h a t this partition function is separable, i.e. it consists of the product of purely en tropic a n d purely energetic contributions-^^ Generally, the (classical) canonical partition function 9(N, V, T) can be related ^^ W.J. Moore, Physical Chemistry, e.g. 5th ed., Longman (1972), chapter 1, sec. 15. -^^ The basic features of separable and non-sep£irable partition functions were introduced in FICS I, sees. 3.5 and 3.8.
2.52
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
to the configurational integral Z^ = J... j e ' V ^ ^ r ^ i ' ^ r ^2- ^NJ/'^^dXjdy^dZjdx^ ... d z ^
[2.9.5]
through
9(iV,V,T) = [2=piSZ:j''"%5L
[2.9.61
We derived this before, see [1.3.9.6 and 7]. The configurational integral requires the computation of the potential energy U
of the system for all configurations of the
system, t h a t is for all x, y, z positions of all molecules (numbered 1, 2, ... AT) in a volume V. E q u a t i o n s [2.9.5 a n d 6] are exact for three-dimensional s y s t e m s of monatomic fluids, be they ideal or non-ideal. Now we apply them to a surface p h a s e a n d introduce approximations compatible with the energy-entropy de-coupling. Consider a volume V^ enclosing the heterogeneous interfacial layer, V^ = At. Let this volume contain N^ molecules, so the average density (p^) = N^/V^.
On a
molecular level p ^ drops over the layer from its bulk value to its value in t h e vapour p h a s e (almost zero) according to some decay pattern p^iz] t h a t will depend on the n a t u r e of the molecules. It might be a hyperbolic tangent functionality, a s in [2.5.31]. In this statistical analysis we shall refer the surface excess energy U^ to Lr(bulk of the liquid); it is non-zero because, in the interface, the molecules are further apart. Because of the observed de-coupling, we may consider U^ completely mechanically. At each position z in the gradient the local contribution to U^ c a n be computed if p^iz] and the pair interaction energies are known. As the molecules are separated against the long-range attraction this pair interaction will mostly be of t h e v a n der Waals type. For the m o m e n t we do not consider t h e details of interaction a n d density profile b u t realize t h a t the total energy U
can be written
as N^(u^), where (u^> is the excess energy per molecule, averaged over V^. For t h a t situation t h e contribution of each molecule to Z^, is the s a m e a n d a m o u n t s to exp(-(u^) / kT] • V^ where the factor V^ results from the integration over the entire surface phase. Because of the experimentally observed de-coupling, the configurational p a r t of the entropy e n t e r s the configurational integral a s a multiplicator t h a t we shall write a s exp(S^^^^/fc). Here, S^^^^ contains all contributions to the excess entropy in the interfacicd region referred to the bulk, including any entropy of mixing. For the present purpose there is no need to specify S^
further, except for noting t h a t it
c o n t a i n s all e n t r o p i c c o n t r i b u t i o n s except t h e t r a n s l a t i o n a l o n e , w h i c h is accounted for by the factor in p a r e n t h e s e s in [2.9.6]. With all of this in mind we find for a surface layer containing N^ molecules Z ^ = e-^conf/'^ e-^^^"'>/^ . [v-f For the complete partition function we obtain
[2.9.7]
2.53
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
27im/cTf^^/2
9^(N^,V^,T)
-N^(u")/fcT
conf/k
e
N^!
rt
[2.9.8]
This relatively simple partition function suffices to a c c o u n t for the observed constancy of U^ and S° and the independence of these functions. To show this, we u s e the well-known formulas for obtaining S^ and U^ from Q^, see I.[A6.7 a n d 8]. From [2.9.8], using Stirling's approximation InN! = NlniV - iV, a n d writing N^ a s N^lne com
ln9^(N°,V^,T) =N^ln
Lr^ = /cT^
fa In 9^
ar
[2.9.9]
[2.9.10]
-N^fcT+ N^(u^> N^.V*'
of course. Had we expressed N^ per unit area, U^ would have been obtained. For the surface excess entropy. S^ = / c l n g ^ + fcT
a In©
/dV^ln
f27crnJcTf/^
V^e^/2 N^
conf
[2.9.11] where V^/N^
is the reciprocal average n u m b e r density in t h e surface layer. If
expressed per unit area S^ = WV^ hi
[2.9.12]
a, conf
which is the surface equivalent of the Sackur-Tetrode
equation for the entropy of
ideal gases, [1.3.1.9]. For the latter systems the potential energy is zero, which is not the case here. However, because of the de-coupling this does not affect the entropy. From [2.9.10] it is seen that U^ is slightly temperature dependent b e c a u s e of the translational contribution
^N^kT; 2
however, t h e i n t e r a c t i o n
term
a
N^(u^) a ^
'
d o m i n a t e s a n d is substance-specific. (In fact, if the translational energy is also referred to t h e liquid, t h e translational excess is zero.) Similair things are noted a b o u t the entropy, which is dominated by the configurational term. F u r t h e r model analyses are needed to show why S^
is rather generic.
Perhaps the specificity of U^, a s opposed to the genericity of S^ can be explained s u c h t h a t U^ is mainly determined by the inner (liquid) side of the surface layer, where the molecules are still close, whereas S^ would be dominated by the o u t e r a
-^
(vapour) side, where the molecules are further apart, a n d the configurations hence more generic. Equation [2.9.8] is one of the simplest formulas capturing all features. More advanced descriptions are necessary, b u t all should feature t h e entropy-energy decoupling in the low temperature range.
2.54
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Along a s o m e w h a t different vein, Guggenheim ^^ also invoked a corresponding state a r g u m e n t . He wanted to predict the y{T) dependence of Lennard-Jones (LJ) liquids close to the critical point^^. He started from [2.9.4], relating the p r e s s u r e to t h e canonical partition function t h r o u g h p = -kT[d\nQ/dV]^ two-dimensional equivalent. Closer to T = T
^, formulating t h e
non-ideality c a n n o t be ignored;
there y(T) is not linear a n d empirical information is required to describe deviations thereof. According to Guggenheim, kT
[2.9.131
N^/CT where f^
N^CT
is some universal function of the p a r a m e t e r s u
and a, respectively,
s t a n d i n g for t h e d e p t h of the LJ m i n i m u m a n d the intermolecular separation a t which u{r) = 0, see fig. 1.4.9. For bulk fluids V Ic^ t h i s s h o u l d also apply for F'^a^/kTA u n i v e r s a l value, yV^^^/hfT
is a universal function of T^;
a n d hence for ya^/kT.
As V^^^/cr^ h a s a
s h o u l d also be a universal function of T . Using
empirical d a t a from K a t a y a m a 2 \ who corrected the empirical Eotvos equation, [2.11.1], he ultimately arrived at \ll/9
T^ 7 = 7, 1 -
(T--^T)
[2.9.14]
cJ
Guggenheim showed t h a t [2.9.14] works well for neon, argon, nitrogen a n d oxygen. The e x p o n e n t 1 1 / 9 m a y be compared with the v a l u e s of 1.21 suggested by Ferguson*^\ Guggenheim also contended that van der Waals predicted 1.234 for the exponent, without giving a reference. This n u m b e r differs from t h a t in [2.5.29]. Postponing model interpretations until the next sections, let u s reconsider the relative constancy of S^. It is interesting to note t h a t a similar trend is observed in the molar entropy of evaporation, A
S . For all the liquids mentioned in fig.
2.14 t h e e n t h a l p y of vaporization, A increasing U^. However, if A A
S
vap m
=A vap
H /T m
H
H
t e n d s to i n c r e a s e strongly with
is divided by the boiling point T^, the quotient
a p p e a r s to be relatively i n d e p e n d e n t of t h e n a t u r e of t h e b
^'^
-^
^
liquid. This observation is known a s Trouton's By analogy, t h e relative invariance of S^ may b e called Trouton's rule for surfaces. The conclusion is t h a t
^^ E.A. Guggenheim, J. Chem. Phys. 13 (1945) 253; see also Watkinson-Lielmezs, J. Chem. Phys. 4 7 (1967) 1558. 2^ M. Katayama, Tokohu Imp. Univ. Set Repts. 4 (1916) 373. '^^ A. Ferguson, Trans. Faraday Soc. 19 (1923) 407; Proc. Phys. Soc. 52 (1940) 759. "^^ Usually referred to F. Trouton, Phil Mag. 18 (1884) 54, although J.R. Partington in his Advanced Treatise of Physical Chemistry, Vol. II, The Properties of Liquids (Longmans, 1951), p. 361. attributes this rule to Pictet.
2.55
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
both with respect to evaporation a n d interfacial excess, the enthalpy is a specific property whereas the entropies are rather generic. Automatically the question is raised a s to whether there is a relation between t h e two sets. Intuitively one feels t h a t the interface is 'somewhere between liquid a n d vapour'; in it the molecules are further apart t h a n in the liquid, b u t n o t yet a s far a s in the vapour, a n d the entropy is higher t h a n in the liquid, b u t n o t yet a s high a s in the vapour. To m a k e this approach more quantitative, actual d a t a a n d dimensional conside r a t i o n s a r e needed. Values for A
S
c a n b e found in general textbooks o n
vap m
°
physical chemistry^^ or derived from A
H a n d T t a b u l a t i o n s . Their average
value is about 100 J K'^ m o l ' ^ The spread in the d a t a is comparable with t h a t in S^ in fig. 2.14 in t h a t for m a n y liquids, including condensed noble gases, organic fluids, water a n d molten metal, it falls within a b o u t ± 2 5 % of this 'Trouton average'. So, t h e c o m p a r i s o n
can be made between this average and,
say
S^ ~ 10"^ J K"^ m"^. Let the surface layer in which the excess entropy is found contain n^ moles m - ^ then S^'/n'' a
a'
- 10"^ J K"^ m o r \ and S^/n^A a
a
a
S
- 10"^.
vap m
A similar exercise can be carried out with U^. In fig. 2.16 a plot is given for the relation b e t w e e n LT*' a n d a
A
LT == A
vap
m
H . The t r e n d is t h a t t h e two a r e
vap
m
correlated, b u t this relationship is not linear. For the simpler molecules t h e ratio U^ I n^A 200 a
a
U vap
is about 5 x 10~^, of the same order a s t h a t for the entropy. A similar ^-^
m
1
E
150
N2H2
^
• H2O
*5 CO
:D
• 100
NO
H2S
Br2
HBr/ NH3 CO2 ^ * • . . ^2 • CI2 / •^CHCl3 Kr o/v CCI4 5 0 - Ar o * . x e SO2 ^ Ne • • • He^ Ho %
£
2 1
10
_1
1
1
1
1
20
30
40
50
60
L.
70
^vap ^m / ^ mole ^ Figure 2.16. evaporation.
Relationship between the excess surface energy and the latent heat of
^^ For instance, E.A. Moelwyn-Hughes, Physical Chemistnj, 2nd ed., Pergamon (1961) p. 273; or W.J. Moore. Physical Chemistry, 5th ed., Longmans (1972).
2.56
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
trend m a y be inferred from tabulations by Abdulnur^^ for (mostly) organic liquids covering the range u p to about 80 m J mr^ for U^, i.e. covering the range n e a r t h e origin of fig. 2.16. The ratio U"" / n^'A ^
<=>
a
a
U
w a s found to be 2-4 x 10"^. There is h o
vap m
r e a s o n to expect the ratios for the entropy a n d the energy to be exactly identical b e c a u s e the two excesses refer to the entire density profile, b u t may weigh t h e various p a r t s of it differently. A n o t h e r way of looking at this is by a s s u m i n g t h a t t h e excess interfacial entropy is primarily a n entropy of the mixing of molecules of type a a n d type p. When p h a s e a is a gas we speak of mixing molecules with holes, this mixing entropy is of the n a t u r e -R[x(z)Inx{z)
+ {l- x{z)] I n j l - x(z)], see [1.2.17.1] or [1.3.6.16].
When for the profile x(z) a n expression is available, the total entropy is obtainable by integration over z. For the tanh-profile of [2.5.31] this leads to S"" = K'^R/6
=
13.6 J K"^ mol"^ (the integration is complicated; we only give the result). This value is independent of ^, i.e. independent of the temperature. Most of the entropy s t e m s from the p a r t of the profile a r o u n d z = 0 in fig. 2.6. Using S^ = n^S^,
one
calculates for n^ - 0 . 0 2 nm^ for the pile of interfacial molecules, constituting the profile. This is in t h e right order of m a g n i t u d e a s the layer is a few molecular diameters thick a n d for simple molecules the cross-section is about 0.1-0.2 nm^. In this connection, a n empirical study by Keeney a n d Heicklen m a y also be m e n t i o n e d 2 \ These a u t h o r s concluded t h a t for a variety of liquids the following linear relationship holds A vap
H
=kya'^ m
+k'
[2.9.15]
'
where a is the r a d i u s of the molecule in the liquid, following from 4na^/3
=
M/p,
w h e r e p is t h e density, a n d where k a n d /c' are specific, b u t t e m p e r a t u r e independent parameters. A
H
, y a n d a are t e m p e r a t u r e - d e p e n d e n t . T h e s e
a u t h o r s introduced coefficients a a n d a' to indicate the fraction by which the molar energy a n d entropy, respectively, in the interface approached their v a p o u r values. They also found a to exceed a', although by less t h a n a factor of 4. All in all, it is gratifying that the ratios for the entropies a n d energies are of the same order of magnitude. Within the domain of phenomenological interpretations this is a b o u t a s far a s we wish to go. It is appropriate to stress that the quantities n^ and N^ are phenomenologically defined a s n u m b e r s per volume, where this volume is heterogeneous in the z -direction. The heterogeneity is reflected in z -dependencies of the density p^{z),
t h e molecular energy u (z) and entropy s (z) b u t not necessarily in h e
same way. As a consequence, the relation between the surface tension and n^ or N^ is complicated, although fixed for a given species at given p a n d T . By the s a m e 1) S.F. Abdulnur, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 9 8 (1976) 4039. 2^ M. Keeney, J. Heicklen, J. Inorg. Nucl Chem. 41 (1979) 1755.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.57
token, the Scime can be stated about the reciprocals A^ and a^ , the areas needed to m
^
m
accommodate n^ moles or N^ molecules in a layer of given thickness- a n d density distribution. Model interpretations are required to make progress. In sec. 2.10 we shall give a rather advanced example of this and in sec. 2.11 a range of (semi-) empirical rules. 2.9b
Influence
of
pressure
The influence of p r e s s u r e on surface tensions is less pronounced t h a n t h a t of temperature. So, for practical purposes this counterpart is not t h a t relevant. However, its interpretation gives rise to some interesting academic i s s u e s . Here t h e m a i n aspects are briefly considered. The first thing to note is t h a t a monocomponent two-phase liquid-mixture at fixed t e m p e r a t u r e is monovariant. This follows from the p h a s e rule [1.2.13.6]. In practice it m e a n s that, at fixed temperature, the pressure can only be increased by adding a foreign gas to the vapour. S u c h a n addition, however, h a s a dual effect: it will increase the tension by the sheer pressure effect (which interests u s a t present) b u t will also reduce it because it may absorb and adsorb, which gives rise to a reduction (according to Gibbs' law). Experience h a s shown t h a t most gases, including N2, O2, H2 a n d CO2 lead to a lowering of the surface tension. Only He is sufficiently inert to lead to a positive p r e s s u r e coefficient. Then the relation y(p) is linear u p to pressures over 10^ Pa. Regarding t h e phenomenological i n t e r p r e t a t i o n it is relevant, n o t i n g t h a t [dy/dp]
h a s the dimensions of a length. The absolute magnitude of this length is
low, a b o u t 0.02 n m for oil-water interfaces a n d u p to a b o u t twice a s large for surfaces^^. Obviously this length is m u c h less t h a n the thickness T of t h e interfacial region. From a purely phenomenological point of view, starting from II.A.4.81 for a twop h a s e system with a flat interface dG = - SdT + Vdp -h ydA + ^
^.n.
12.9.16]
it follows immediately t h a t [m]
[2.9.17]
In words, [dy/dp]^ ^ ^ ,^ equals the increase in volume if the a r e a is increased a t fixed p,T
a n d composition. This increase obviously stems from the fact t h a t t h e
molar volume in the interfacial layer is larger t h a n t h a t in the b u l k phase(s). So, the r.h.s. of [2.9.17] Ccm be interpreted a s a molar volume per molar area. ^^ L.A. Turkevich, J.A. Mann, Lxingmuir 6 (1990) 445, 457, collected data to compare with their own theory.
2.58
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
A further analysis requires scrutiny in defining the meaning of the interfacial t h i c k n e s s r , a n d its relation to (dV/dA) in the r.h.s. of [2.9.171.To t h a t end the Gibbs convention is ill-equipped because it entirely ignores the thickness (V^ = 0). So, other conventions in which some thickness T occurs are needed. As s u c h the Guggenheim convention, mentioned in sec. 1.2.5 may be invoked or t h a t by H a n s e n 1^ Both of t h e s e feature two planes, demarcating the interfacial layer, although the ways of elaboration differ. Perhaps the most rigorous elaboration is t h a t by Turkevich a n d M a n n (loc. cit.) who invoked t h e Cahn-Milliard density g r a d i e n t formalism to obviate p r o b l e m s i n c u r r e d in defining t h e thickness. They found that [dy/dp)
interfacial
is not only proportional to r , b u t also to the
change in V^ of the constituents in the interface. The theory is applied to LL and LG interfaces. One of their findings is t h a t the r contribution dominates t h a t of V^. Space c o n s t r a i n t s preclude a detailed discussion of this analysis. Instead, in [2.9.18] we give a result for a two-component system, derived by Rusanov^K ^ \
A Here A
= v ^ - yt. _ V m
mA
;
[2.9.18]
is t h e molar surface area of the m a i n component of L, p is t h e a d d e d
g a s e o u s component with mole fractions x^^, x^^ a n d x^
in the liquid, gas a n d
interfacial layer, respectively. A s o m e w h a t different equation w a s derived by Kahlweit^l As V^ m
> V^ a n d x^^ > x^^ the sign of the last term on the r.h.s. of [2.9.18] is *=*
m
determined by the sign of [x^^ - x^^). If this difference is > 0, i.e. if adsorption of p takes place, this term is negative. As [V^ - V ^ ) > 0 conditions may arise where t h e negative (Gibbs) t e r m d o m i n a t e s . For a gas like helium t h a t is entirely inert x^^ = x^^ = 0 , in which case t h e 'pure' p r e s s u r e effect is the only contribution.
Herice, for an inert gas [2.9.18] becomes ^1
A
= V^o _ V"-
{> 0)
[2.9.19]
m
which can also be written as {dp
■ 1 = T - rv'-
[2.9.20]
where F is the 'self-adsorption' of the liquid at the interface, a negative quantity. It can be established by making some assumption about r , for instance by setting it equal to zero, i.e. by letting, in the Guggenheim convention, the u p p e r a n d lower IJ R.S. Hansen, J. Phys. Chem, 66 (1962) 410. -^^ See the book by Rusanov and Prokhorov, mentioned in sec. 2.13, their sees. 1.8 and 1.10. ^^ M. Kahlweit, Ber. Bunsenges Phys. Chem. 74 (1970) 638.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.59
b o u n d a r y coincide. However, according to the more rigorous theory of Turkevich and Mann, the F V^ term dominates anyway, i.e. the pressure dependence of a pure fluid is mainly determined by the 'self adsorption' term. Regarding F Rusanov a n d Prokhorov report values between - 0 . 2 a n d - 0 . 4 |j.mol m"^ for the surfaces of simple organic liquids, a n d - 2 . 5 ^mol m"^ for water^^; Motomura et al. found values for water-oil interfaces'^^ to be lower by a factor of a b o u t 2. Intuitively it is felt t h a t self-adsorption is more p r o n o u n c e d in b o u n d a r i e s with air t h a n with a n o t h e r liquid. The self-adsorption decreases with increasing temperature^^ In conclusion, for practical p u r p o s e s the p r e s s u r e dependence of surface a n d interfacial t e n s i o n s m a y mostly be ignored. Atmospheric fluctuations play a negligible role unless adsorbing gases are present. For this reason we disregard the p r e s s u r e effect in appendix 1, except where explicitly mentioned. However, from a n interpretational point of view some interesting features for this dependence have been identified . 2.9c
Surface
tensions
as capillary
waves
Let u s now briefly mention a n approach t h a t is popular among physicists, a n d which comes down to correlating surface tensions to capillary waves. The u n d e r lying idea is t h a t each fluid-fluid interface is subject to a superposition of a large n u m b e r of thermal waves. The amplitudes of these waves are related to t h e interfacial excess energy a n d t h e n u m b e r a n d frequencies to t h e interfacial excess entropy, hence the total information obtainable yields F^, a n d hence / . The idea d a t e s back to Mandelstam"^^ a n d h a s been taken u p by others, including Frenkel'^^ a n d Buffet al.^). We shall not p u r s u e this approach here b e c a u s e it does not help u s m u c h in finding a molecular interpretation, certainly not for U^. Even in the a b s e n c e of waves (solidified liquids), U^ is substantial. Rather, this interpretation deals with a contribution to y them with / itself. However, we recall t h a t the 'capillary wave connection' h a d already occurred in the technique for measuring surface tensions from surface light scattering, see Mandelstam's equation [1.10.1], from which a n explicit formula for y may be derived.
^^ A.I. Rusanov and V.A. Prokhorov, loc. cit. p. 31. 2^ K. Motomura, H. lyota, M. Aratono, M. Yamanaka and R. Matuura, J. Colloid Interface Set 9 3 (1983) 264. See also K. Motomura, M. Aratono, Langmuir 3 (1987) 304. ^^ V.N. Khabarov, A.I. Rusanov and N.N. Kochurova, Koll Zhur. 3 8 (1976) 120 (English transl. 101). 4) L. Mandelstam. Ann. Phys. 41 (1913) 609. ^^ Ya.I. Frenkel', Kinetichesky Teoriya ZhidkosteJ (transl. J. Frenkel, Kinetic Theory of Liquids, Dover reprint (1955), chapter VI.) ^) F.P. Buff. R. Lovett and F.H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 15 (1965) 621.
2.60
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.10 Lattice theories for the interpretation of interfacial tensions This section is the counterpart of the previous one in that a lattice model is assumed for the liquid(s). and this model is extended to cover the interfacial range. Mostly (statistical) thermodynamical arguments are invoked, using empirical data to substitute realistic values for the parameters. Lattice theories are approaches in which the statistics of the fluid are explicitly taken into account. Discretization is achieved by allowing only a limited number of positions and orientations of molecules, usually by confining molecules, or parts of them, to sites, or cells on a grid or lattice. Experience collected from a variety of systems has shown that such theories are good alternatives to those involving distribution functions, having at the same time the advantage of being much more amenable. Lattice models need vacancies, otherwise the density and its changes cannot be accounted for. (In MD or MC simulations and in statistics involving distribution functions, density fluctuations are automatically accounted for.) The role of vacancies becomes immediately transparent in the transition zone between a liquid and its vapour, where the volume fraction of vacancies cp [z] increases from its low value inside the liquid to almost unity in the vapour. To indicate that vacancies are explicitly considered, one sometimes speaks of lattice-hole', or 'cell-hole' theories. Such theories have since long been applied for predicting surface and interfacial tensions 1'2'*^J. Most of these solutions lack generality. Theories were restricted to special kinds of fluids (noble gases, organic liquids, molten salts or metals). More often than not only one temperature was considered - or only the region close to the critical point - and/or only the surface energy excess was computed, which was then identified with the surface tension. The consistency of parameters has presented another problem. These problems are not yet solved and so we hope that more and better results will come forth. Generally speaking, detailed analyses, involving more than the most simple fluids, had to wait until the advent and implementation of powerful computers. By way of illustration we now discuss in some detail a comprehensive study of the alkane-alkane vapour interface, modelled by Schlangen et al.^^ who followed on similar work for the same systems by Sanchez et al.^^ and Theodorou^^. Basically, the model is that of Scheutjens and Fleer (SF), originally developed for ^^ S. Ono, Handbuch d. Physik, Band X, Springer (1960) 249. 2^ E.A. Guggenheim, Mixtures, Clarendon Press (1952). ^^ J.C. Eriksson, Arkiv, Kern. 26 (1966) 117. 4^ L.J.M. Schlangen, L.K. Koopal and J. Lyklema, J. Phys. Chem, 100 (1996) 3607. ^^ I.e. Sanchez, R.H. Lacombe, J. Phys. Chem. 80 (1976) 2353; C.I. Poser, I.C. Sanchez, J. Colloid Interface Set 69 (1979) 539. ^^ D.N. Theodorou, Macromolecules 22 (1989) 4578.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.61
polymers at interfaces and described in sec. II.5.5. In the present case three p h a s e s have to be considered, the (homogeneous) vapour, the (heterogeneous) interfacial region a n d the (homogeneous) liquid. For the latter SF theory r e d u c e s to FloryHuggins (FH) theory. One of the strong points of the present model is t h a t both the temperature and the chain length dependence of the surface tension were predicted on the basis of only two pairameters, viz. the FH % - parameter for vacancies in bulk (580/T) a n d the segment volume (i; = 0.027 nm^). Segments a n d holes have the s a m e volume; t h e n u m b e r of statistical u n i t s in the c h a i n is identical to t h e n u m b e r of CHg's or CHg's in t h e chain. It w a s first verified t h a t t h i s pair of p a r a m e t e r s could satisfactorily describe (i) the vapour pressure a s a function of T a n d c h a i n length; a n d (ii) the critical point; (iii) the e n t h a l p y a n d e n t r o p y of vaporization. Having t h u s established t h a t bulk p h a s e equilibria are well produced, 7 w a s computed a s a function of T a n d chain length. The equation for t h e surface tension reads
LkT
- - l ^ - l i ^ - ^ l l l
;^apK(^)(^p(^)> -
Here, L is the n u m b e r of cells in each lattice layer; k indicates all molecules a n d vacancies in the system; a a n d P refer to the segment types (CH2(3) or vacancy); u'(z)//cT is a n - essentially entropic - contribution following from the self consistency of t h e method which t a k e s care t h a t all sites are occupied by s e g m e n t s (or molecules or vacancies) a or P; ;^
is the Flory-Huggins parameter for interactions
between segments (etc.) a and p; v^ is the surface excess of k-segments (i.e. the total a m o u n t in the system m i n u s those in the bulk); (p a n d (p s t a n d for volume ^
,
1
i
1
^
^
r—
(b)
a) 30
experimental (C5, Cg, Cg, CjQ, Cj2)
Cj, C2. C4
E 15
200
400
600 K
0.2 T/T^
Figure 2.17. Surface tension of linear alkanes as a function of (a) temperature and (b) reduced temperature. Cj, C2, etc. refer to alkanes with 1, 2, ... CH2 groups per chain. Lattice hole theory, redrawn after Schlangen et al. (J. Phys. Chem. 100 (1996) 3607.)
2.62
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
fractions; a n d {cp (z)) is the neighbour-averaged value of (p , defined before, see [II.5.5.8]. For derivation and details, see the original. Figure 2.17 is the first result. Comparison with experimental data^^ is m a d e visible by plotting / a s a function of the reduced temperature T/T . Experimental d a t a a r e at least semiquantitatively accounted for, including t h e surface excess entropy (i.e. t h e slope of the curve) which decreases with increasing chain length, tending to become independent of it if the chain is sufficiently long, in full accord with the experimental data of fig. 2.15. Its generic n a t u r e (sec. 2.9a) is borne out, although the absolute value is a b o u t 10% lower t h a n t h e experimental ones. For these systems S^ h a s a (molecular) configurational a n d a mixing contribution. At low t e m p e r a t u r e s t h e predicted surface tension falls progressively below t h e experimental one. The a b s o l u t e value (fig. 2.18) at fixed t e m p e r a t u r e , b u t for different c h a i n lengths, h a s the proper trend; although the latter dependence is underestimated. Note the rather expanded ordinate axis scale. Considering t h a t this is a n ab-initio
theory w i t h o u t p a r a m e t e r s t h a t were
adjusted to fit the p r e s e n t issue, it can of course be applied advantageously to obtain information on the molecular distribution (fig. 2.19). The density profiles (panels (a) a n d (c)) display the familiar tanh-like shapes. The layer thicknesses are of the same order as, b u t larger than, those met before (figs. 2.12 a n d 13). The two right-hand-side panels show a subtlety of the theory t h a t we have so far not yet met: it is possible to specify the volume density fractions according to the r a n k s in the chain. These two panels demonstrate t h a t the tail segment (s = 1 a n d 4 for C^ a n d s = 1 a n d 8 for Cg) enrich t h e outer side of the transition layer. In t h i s connection, it may be recalled that, in connection with fig. 2.15, it w a s noted t h a t
experimental ^ ^ ^ • " ^
28
• y
24
y
/ o-°'
X-" ^.o.o
°-'°
lattice fluid
..• 20 /
0-
• 16 -
/ • \
5
\
1
1
10 15 20 length hydrocarbon chain
Figure 2.18. Surface tensions of alkanes of varying chain length at 293 K. As in previous figure.
1) J.J. Jasper, E.V. Kring, J. Phys. Chem. 5 9 (1955) 1019. Note that on this scale the differences in slope, given in fig. 2.15, do not show up.
2.63
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
-|—I—I—I—I—I—I—I—r-
1—I—I—I—I—I—I—I—I—|-
:b)
(a) o—o—o—o—o—o—o—6
1.5 s = l or 4 .•^" -•-t*-'ii:8^** s=2
•>8-«-«-«-«-«1.0 •0..0--
0.5 ♦ - t - » - #-#-■#■ i-H—I—I—I—I—\—I—I—h
A
(c) ^o—o—o—o—o—o—o—6
/
H—I—I—h
'
\ s = l or
d) 2.0 8
V
/
y s=2 or 7 •
•1.0
^^v y 4 ^ s=3 or 6 s = 4 or 5 ' A . . ^ z+5
^=>#-#-iz+10 layer number
z
z+5
A.
z+10 layer number
0 z+15
Figure 2.19. Panels (a) and (c). Volume fraction profiles. Closed symbols: hydrocarbon, open symbols, vacancies. Panels (b) and (d) relative segment distribution; s indicates the position of the C-atom in the hydrocarbon chain T= 290 K. (Reference as fig. 2.17). for long a l k a n e s there is experimental evidence t h a t they orient parallel to t h e surface. The p r e s e n t model shows t h a t this orientation does not apply to t h e extremities of the molecules. At this stage it is enlightening to compare the results of this study with those obtained for hexane by MD simulations (figs. 2.10 a n d 13). The essential difference between the two approaches is the different part of the phase space t h a t is sampled. Lattice theories give ensemble averages. MD simulations time-averages. Although in the p r e s e n t case the lattice results are more detailed, the results for ylT] are at least very similar. Further it is noted t h a t the r a n k effect, established above, w a s also found by MD simulations for decane and eicosane (see reference to J.G. Harris, in sec. 2.7). It is also appropriate to r e t u r n briefly to the work by Poser a n d S a n c h e z ^^ of which the theory j u s t discussed w a s a variant. The liquid consists of r - m e r s a n d v a c a n c i e s , r a n d o m l y mixed, with n e x t n e i g h b o u r i n t e r a c t i o n s . This energy, together v^ath the lattice volume a n d r define the fluid. For the interface C a h n -
1^ C.I. Poser, I.e. Sanchez, J. Colloid Interface Set 19 (1979) 539.
2.64
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
Hilliard theory is used, thereby introducing K a s another parameter, see [2.6.9]. For the latter, the a s s u m p t i o n is made t h a t the entropy only depends on the local density a n d not on the gradient. This is van der Waals' assumption. Obviously this model contains less detaiil t h a n given in fig. 2.18; nevertheless the results for y and dy/dT
for a n u m b e r of oligo- and polyhydrocarbons were satisfactory. The value of
K r e m a i n s to a certain extent adjustable which renders it less ab initio t h a n t h e p r e v i o u s model. For polymer m e l t s t h i s theory o v e r e s t i m a t e s S^. With K optimized it w a s found t h a t / decreases with M~^^^ in the homologeous series. This
rule
was
found
experimentally
by
LeGrand
and
G a i n e s ^^ a s
y = y(M = oo) - const M^^^, where the constant is empirical. It may be added t h a t in fig. 2.18 both curves also obey this dependence. The conclusion is t h a t lattice theories are achieving a high level of proficiency. 2.11
Empirical relationships
Intuitively, surface a n d interfacial tensions may be expected to be related to a n u m b e r of physical characteristics of the liquid or the liquid-vapour transition. Two of these are the enthalpy a n d entropy of evaporation, discussed in sec. 2.9. Other p a r a m e t e r s t h a t come to mind are the molar volume V , t h e i s o t h e r m a l compressibility K
a n d t h e expansion coefficient. The combination of certain
powers of s u c h p a r a m e t e r s a n d y sometimes leads to p r o d u c t s with interesting properties, like t e m p e r a t u r e independence or additivity. Several of s u c h scaling rules have been proposed over the p a s t century, mostiy with limited quantitative success. A few of these will now be discussed. 2.11a
Relations
containing
molar
volumes
and
compressibilities
An a b u n d a n c e of semi-empirical relationships c a n be found in the literature which relate / in some way to V
(or its molecular pendant, v ). Partington listed
a b o u t 20 of t h e m ^ ^ The logic b e h i n d this connection is the obsolete t r e n d of interpreting surface tensions a s the result of net forces exerted on molecules in the surface, without considering the finite thickness of this layer. At some stage of the c o m p u t a t i o n t h e a r e a per molecule in the interface, a n d h e n c e t h e packing is needed. A variety of elaborations can then be set up, depending on the value t a k e n for V
(at room temperature or in a more expanded state?), how V
is related to the
density (under w h a t conditions?), whether or not the latent energy of evaporation A vap
U
also enters the equation, whether the surface tension or the surface excess m
^
energy is taken, etc. Nowadays s u c h approaches are known to be dated; interfacial layers have finite thicknesses where molecules at different positions z contribute 1^ D.G. LeGrand, G.L. Gaines, J. Colloidlnterface Set 131 (1969) 162. 2^ J.R. Partington, An Advanced Treatise on Physical Chemistry, Vol. II Longmans (1951) 148 ff.
2.65
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
to a different extent to U^ a n d S^. At best a kind of averaged n u m b e r n^ or N^ of a
a
°
a
a
participating moles or molecules, respectively, per unit area can be established, see the discussion at the end of sec. 2.9. Alternatively, values for t h e aireas needed to a c c o m m o d a t e n^ or N^ molecules in a given distribution over a layer of finite thickness, A^ a n d a^ respectively, c a n be introduced a n d molecular interpretations sought for them. For lack of further information or insight, these two a r e a s are often replaced by V^^^ or v'^^^ with the inherent problems j u s t mentioned. The b e s t known example is t h a t by Eotvos^^ who in 1886 suggested t h a t the product yV^^^ would be proportional to the temperature: yV^^^ = kjT '
m
=
-T]
£\
c
kJT
/
[2.11.11.
£ c
where T is the critical t e m p e r a t u r e . This equation w a s derived on the b a s i s of corresponding state reasonings, at a time t h a t the very existence of molecules a n d their behaviour w a s not yet fully established (Eotvos a n d v a n der Waals were contemporary). The idea by multiplying y [an energy per areal with a [volume]^/^ in order to get rid of the [areal, b u t the result is awkwcird, b e c a u s e k
is d i m e n s -
ionally a n [entropyl [moll"^/^. Moreover, it is not easy to include asymmetrical m o l e c u l e s . For m a n y liquids k^
a m o u n t s to 2.1 x 10"^ JK"^ mol'^^^, b u t if
considered over a larger rcinge^^ it appccirs t h a t k
is not really constant. R a m s a y
a n d Shields^^ improved the constaincy of k , replacing T^ in [2.11.11 by (T^- 6). We n o t e d t h a t t h e derivation of Guggenheim's equation [2.9.141, is b a s e d on a n adjustment of k^ by Katayama. A more recent variant of [2.11.11 h a s been proposed by Skapski"^^ yA '
=-/V2/3^1/3d7 m
*^
where A
m
[2.11.21
Av ^ j "
is the molar area and / a packing factor, computed to be equal to 1.09 or
1.12 for a hexagonal close-packed or body-centred cubic lattice. If we write A
=N^ a . w h e r e a m
is t h e m o l e c u l a r c r o s s - s e c t i o n , a n d i n t r o d u c e
the
m
Av m
molecular volume u
■V / N^ , [2.11.21 converts into m '
Av' ^
'
m
ya '
=-fv m
"^ ,2/3 n
dT^
[2.11.3]
This equation does not obey the general low temperature trend y = a-bT.
In fact.
the temperature dependence is 'hidden' in the way in which {v ^ a^) depends on T. In this way the separation into a n energetic and a n entropic contribution becomes 1) R. von Eotvos, Wied. Ann. 27 (1886) 456. 2) K.L. Wolf, Physik und Chemie der Grenzjldchen, Vol. I, Springer (1957) p. 38. 3J W. Ramsay, J. Shields. J. Chem. Soc. (1893) 1089. 4) A.S. Skapski, J. Chem. Phys. 16 (1948) 386.
2.66
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
o b s c u r e . Nevertheless, Good^) u s e d this equation to obtain the molar
surface
entropy (from d y / d T a s occurring in it) for a range of liquids. He found t h a t this quantity w a s a b o u t constant at 24 J mole"^ K"^ for non-hydrogen bridged fluids a n d a b o u t 14 J mole"^ K"^
for those with strong hydrogen bridges, attributing t h i s
difference to s t r o n g e r interfacial orientation in t h e latter case. Accepting t h e empirical n a t u r e of the approach, it is nevertheless interesting to note t h a t t h e s e molcir entropies correspond with about 24 and 14% of the Trouton values (sec. 2.9). The above d i s c u s s i o n leads to the consideration of a n o t h e r empirical rule involving the (bulk) isothermal
compressibility
K . It is defined as
a n d j u s t equal to the reciprocal of the bulk elastic modulus. It m e a s u r e s the extent to which liquids c a n be compressed by applying a n external p r e s s u r e . At room temperature K^ varies between about 5 and 10 x 10"^^ m^ N"^ for water a n d organic fluids. As expected, K rises strongly with temperature. It is not too far-fetched to expect also a relation with / a n d / o r the correlation length ^ b e c a u s e the negative pressure reigns in the interfacial region, tearing t h e molecules a p a r t a n d increasing the molar volume. It is known t h a t y decreases with T , whereas ^ increases. It now appears t h a t the quotient q = UY^r
l-l
'2.11.51
is nearly temperature-independent. For water a n d organic liquids, ^ = 1-2 run, / = 30-70 mN m"^ and K : ^ = 5 - 1 0 X 10"^^ m^ N~^ Substituting these values, q is found to be 0(10). Before some feeling for the meaning of the correlation length ^ w a s developed, the fact t h a t the product y K^ h a d the dimension of a length, a n d t h a t this length w a s of molecular order of magnitude, drew some attention. Several a t t e m p t s have been m a d e to test the variability of yK^ a s a function of the n a t u r e of the liquid and, for a given liquid, a s a function of the temperature. S u c h approaches include combination with other liquid properties of dimension [length], s u c h a s V^^^ or (dV/dA)
. In this way a surface property is entirely interpreted in t e r m s of b u l k
properties. For a discussion of some of these models see refs.'^'*^^ However, it seems more appropriate to look for a correlation with a characteristic interfacial length, hence our introduction of E,. The c o n s t a n c y of q h a s been given a statistical background by Henderson'^^
1) R.J. Good, J. Phys. Chem. 61 (1957) 810. 2^ I.e. Sanchez, J. Chem, Phys. 79 (1983) 405. 3^ I. Vavruch. Coll Surf. 40 (1989) 85. "^^ J.R. Henderson, Mol Phys. 39 (1980) 709.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.67
extending earlier work b y Fisk a n d Widom^^ Present-^^ a n d others. H e n d e r s o n considered v a n der Waals liquids, obeying [2.5.28 a n d 37], elaborating t h e direct correlation function which implied the introduction of the p r o d u c t p^K in t h e p h a s e boundciry, b u t this product is about identical to t h a t in the adjoining p h a s e s . The final equation contains a product that, for a hyperbolic tangent profile of t h e type [2.5.31], equals TC^^ / 6 4 . The result for a n interface between a and P is
^ap ^ i L i A ^ L + higher order terms 64 (pa)^a
[2.11.6]
where (p^f'K^ = (p^f'K^^. If applied to the surface tension,
._^K-pt.ja^
i2.ii.7i
So, according to this analysis q = 6 4 / TI^ which h a s the right order of magnitude. From this analysis we can see t h a t temperature-independence is connected with the t e m p e r a t u r e insensitivity of the quotients of densities. For predicting of surface tensions [2.11.5] is not sufficiently precise. It may b e m e n t i o n e d t h a t alternative statistical analyses do not lead to significantly different outcomes for / a n d for the profile yi^) - Such analyses are beyond the scope of FICS. Another empirical quantity is the parachor
P, introduced b y Sugden'^^ a n d
based on empirical findings by McLeod^^. It is defined a s
where p is the density (kg m"^). The parachor h a s peculiar dimensions a n d lacks physical justification. Quayle h a s given extensive t a b u l a t i o n s for organic compounds^^ . From these data a certain constancy (within a factor of two) for a variety of low molecular weight s u b s t a n c e s is indeed observed, b u t with increasing M , P rises more strongly with M t h a n accounted for by [2.11.8]. Nevertheless P a p p e a r s to b e fairly i n d e p e n d e n t of t e m p e r a t u r e a n d roughly additive for a t o m s a n d functional groups. Because in the parachor / scales with 1/4, the parachor is not 1^ S. Fisk, B. Widom, J. Chem. Phys. 50 (1969) 3215. 2) R.D. Present, J. Chem. Phys. 61 (1974) 4267. 3^ B.F. McCoy, L.E. Scriven and H.T. Davis, J. Chem. Phys. 75 (1981) 4719. "^^ S. Sugden, various papers in J. Chem Soc. (1924-1926). ^^ D.B. MacLeod, Trans. Faraday Soc. 19 (1923) 38. ^^ O.R. Quayle, Chem Revs. 5 3 (1953) 439. See also R. Grzeskowiak et al., J. Chem Soc. (1960) 4719.
2.68
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
very sensitive to the surface tension, and so not a n accurate predictive tool. For low temperatures, where p^ » p ^ constancy of P implies t h a t y = const. {v^J^
[2.11.9]
dlny dlnV^ ^^-^^^--4 2L
[2.11.10]
or
dT
dT
according to which the (relative) t e m p e r a t u r e coefficient of y should be proportional to four times the (relative) thermal expansion coefficient of the liquid. Let u s finish t h i s s u b s e c t i o n by mentioning a more recent example of a n empirical relationship. Moldover^^ observed t h a t for a large n u m b e r of liquids Y = R^kTJ^^
[2.11.11]
satisfies, with t h e c o n s t a n t R^ = 1 / 1 0 . Here T^ is the critical t e m p e r a t u r e . It is interesting to compare this finding with the scaling law [2.5.35]. 2.11b
Relationships
for
interfacial
tensions,
containing
geometric
means
This group of model interpretations refers typically to interfacial tensions, say 7^^ between condensed p h a s e s a and p, and their relations to the individual surface tensions / " and y^. Intuitively it is felt t h a t s u c h a relation should exist, since, at a given temperature and pressure / " and y^ are unique functions of the composition of p h a s e s a and (3, respectively, and so is y^^ fully determined by the interface t h a t is s p o n t a n e o u s l y formed u p o n contact between p h a s e s a a n d p. As, however, t h e interpretation of / " in terms of molecular properties of p h a s e a is not so simple (as proven by t h e preceding p a r t of this chapter), the relation 7 ^ ( 7 " , / ^ ) is n o t a s obvious either. Nevertheless, a n u m b e r of semi-empirical relationships have b e e n p u t forward, a n d applied with some success. Many of these contain the geometric mean ( 7 " 7 M
or (7^7^)
. where 7 is the contribution to y of dispersion forces.
Literature reveals no lack of suggestions for relations y^^iy^^y^)-
The oldest
one, ^«P = y«_yP
(for 7«>7<^)
[2.11.12]
w a s proposed by Young in his seminal 1805 paper-^^ a n d later promoted by Antonow^^ whose n a m e it b e a r s nowadays: Antonow's
rule. The rule d a t e s from
before the time t h a t concrete insight into the interaction forces between molecules h a d developed. Equation [2.11.12] is too simple to be generally true. A review of its 1^ M.R. Moldover, Phys. Rev. A31 (1985) 1022. 2) T. Young, Phil Trans. Roy. Soc. (London) 95 (1805) 84. 2) G. Antonow. J. Chim. Phys. 5 (1907) 364, 372.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.69
validity has been given by Winter 11 In 1890 Lord Rayleigh^) proposed instead {y'^^f'' = {rr-{/f''
[2.11.131
which can also be written as j^otP = y^^y^
_ 2[y''Y^f^'^
12.n. 141
So, this is the first example of an equation containing the geometric mean. Equation 12.11.14] can be physically interpreted as describing the work of adhesion: when two flat phases a and p of unit area unite, the surfaces of phases a and p disappear, whereas that of ap is formed, leading to the accompanying reduction of the grand potentials per unit area £2^'^ and Q^'^ and creation of 12^"'^, with X2^ = r , recall 12.2.25]. The work of adhesion, w ^^ is defined as the work to be a
'
adh
done to tear the phases a and P isothermally and reversibly apart, see sec. 5.2, so '^.^h-y'^^y^-y"^
12.11.15]
and hence, according to Rayleigh, xl/2
adh
= 2(7V)
12.11.16]
This result is not too far-fetched. It is logical that w is determined by the attractive forces between a and p, and as / " and y^ are also determined by these forces, a relation containing 7" and y^ is expected. However, it is not obvious whether this should be a geometric average and why the factor is two. Since the 1950s several improvements have been proposed. Girifalco and Good^^ replaced 12.11.14] by y«P = 7« +7P _ 20(x«xP)^^^
12.11.17]
where 0 is an, essentially empirical, interaction parameter. These authors gave the interpretation a physical footing by considering the geometric mean as caused by the Berthelot principle for the psiir energies in equations like u^l^M = [u«(r)u^(r)]^^^
12.11.18],
of which we will assess the applicability below. Moreover, these authors tested 12.11.17] for no fewer than 137 pairs of liquids and found 0 to vary between 0.32 (for water-mercury) and 1.17 (water-di-n-propylamine). A certain correlation with the nature of the interactions in the two liquids was established. For instance, for
1^ A. Winter, Antonow's rule 85 Years Later, in Heterog. Chem. Revs. 2 (1995) 269-308. 2) Lord Rayleigh. Phil Mag. 15J 30 (1890) 456. ^^ L.A. Girifalco, R.J. Good, J. Phys. Chem. 61 (1957) 904.
2.70
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
mercury-aliphatic a n d mercury-aromatic hydrocarbons
[2.11.19]
Recall t h a t we already derived a similar expression from the van der Waals theory u n d e r a n u m b e r of restrictive simplifications, see [2.5.44 a n d 45]. There the geometric m e a n w a s related to the same m e a n of Hamaker c o n s t a n t s . This equation c a n b e tested experimentally; for liquids like water, in which a variety of forces are operative, y^ c a n be established by measuring interfacial tensions against organic liquids
in w h i c h t h e interaction is dominated by t h e dispersion forces. This
analysis c a n be illustrated with the data of table 2 . 3 . In [2.11.19] a is a n organic liquid (like a hydrocarbon, he) for which it w a s a s s u m e d t h a t only dispersion forces determined the surface tension: y^ = y^. Consequently, y^
is t h e only
unknown. Its value a p p e a r s to be invariant at about 22 m J m-^, comprising 3 0 % of the total tension. The s u c c e s s of this approach h a s led to a n u m b e r of elaborations, s u c h a s the sequestering of other contributions to y, including polar, hydrogen bridge a n d acid-base interactions, for which also geometric m e a n s were suggested"^'^'^-^^. How good is this approach? In analyzing this, one should consider at least two aspects: (i) Is it thermodynamically allowable to split interfacial tensions into various components? (ii) If yes, is the geometric m e a n the most appropriate mathematical form? ^) R.J. Good, J. Colloid Interface Set 59 (1977) 398. 2^ R.J. Good, Intermolecular and Interatomic Forces, in Treatise on Adhesion and Adhesiues. Vol. 1, R.L. Patrick, Ed., Dekker (1967) p. 9. 3) F.M. Fowkes, Adv. Chem. Series 4 3 (1964) 99; J. Phys. Chem. 6 7 (1963) 2538; 7 2 (1968) 3700; 84 (1980) 510. ^^ Y. Tamai, T. Matsunaga and K. Horiuchl, J. Colloid Interface Set 60 (1977) 112. ^^ J. Panzer, J. Colloid Interface Set 44 (1973) 142. ^^ C.J. van Oss, M.K. Chaudhuiy and R.J. Good Adv. Colloid Interface Set 28 (1987) 35; C.J. van Oss, R.J. Good and M.K. Chaudhury, Langmuir 4 (1988) 884. '^^ J. Kloubek, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 38 (1992) 99.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION Table 2 . 3 .
2.71
Estimation of the dispersion contribution y^ to the surface tension
according to Fowkes' method (J. Phys. Chenh 6 7 (1963) 2538). Data in m J m-2, temp. 20°C, t a k e n from Fowkes; they differ insignificantly from o u r s in table A 1.5. yhC
yhc/w
y"^
1
n-hexane
18.4
51.1
21.8
1
n-hept£ine
20.4
50.2
22.6
n-octane
21.8
50.8
22.0
n-decane
23.9
51.2
21.6
Hydrocarbon (he)
n-tetradecane
25.6
52.2
20.8
cyclohexane
25.5
50.2
decalin
29.9
51.4
22.7 22.0
The m o s t basic objection is t h a t interfacial tensions are Helmholtz
1 1 energies,
w h e r e a s interpretations according to [2.11.13 or 15] treat t h e m a s energies,
neg-
lecting entropic contributions. Mixing entropies do not obey geometric mean-laws b u t r a t h e r go with the logarithm of the composition. This defect is immediately recognized when the temperature influence is considered: a s y decreases with T, one would find lower values for y^ at higher T, which conflicts with the implied p u r e l y m e c h a n i c a l i n t e r p r e t a t i o n a s d i s p e r s i o n forces. This point is rarely recognized b e c a u s e experiments are mostly limited to room t e m p e r a t u r e a n d , for t h a t matter, to water-organic fluid interfaces. If only the energetic contribution LT^ to y is considered, the geometric average is a very a c c e p t a b l e choice, b e c a u s e dispersion forces prevail a n d t h e s e obey Berthelot's rule very well, a s discussed in some detail in sec. I.4.4d. However, there is n o physical ground to a s s u m e t h a t this principle will also apply to acid-base or hydrogen b o n d interactions. Moreover, these contributions are s h o r t - r a n g e a n d are likely to £iffect the m u t u a l interpenetration of the two p h a s e s , hence giving rise to density profiles t h a t may differ substantially between the mixed (ap) a n d single (a a n d (3) phase boundaries. With this in mind there is a n a r g u m e n t for separating the energetic a n d the entropic contributions to the work of adhesion. From [2.11.15] w ^^=A ^M"" - TA ,^S^ adh adh
adh
a
a
a
adh a
a
adh a
a
[2.11.20]
a a
a
with, to a good approximation
[2.11.21] [2.11.22]
2.72
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
A .M" adh
= 2([;<'« y p y ' ^ a
\
a,d
12.11.23]
a.d/
In this way, instead of [2.11.15] y^ '
= Y^ +y^ - TA , S^ - 2(U^'« LT^'^r^ '
'
adh a
V a.d
[2.11.241
a,d/
The purely energetic dispersion contributions are independent of the temperature; the entropic term now accounts for the temperature dependence. Quantitatively, all tensions y have to be replaced by [y-T[dy
/ dT)], which is
higher. For instance, for water at 20°C / = 72.9 m J m-2 (table 1.3), TS^ = 293 x 0.14 = 41.0 m J m-2, so a ^ = 113.9 m J m-2; for hexane and decane (table 2.3 and fig. 2.15) LT^ becomes 18.4 + 293 x 0.11 = 50.6 and 23.9 + 293 x 0.091 = 50.6 m J m-2 for both. a
The result is t h a t t h e values found for U^
are significantly higher t h a n t h o s e
reported for y^, w h i c h they replace. To m a k e t h i s quantiative, a s y s t e m a t i c literature s t u d y of dy / dT d a t a for liquid-liquid interfaces h a s to be carried out, yielding S^•"^ At this instance it m a k e s sense to recall the corresponding state principle of sec. 2.9: all surface excess entropies are very similar. Assuming this to also be the case for the corresponding interfacial excesses, we conclude t h a t the term TA^^^^S^ in [2.11.24] is more or less generic. This is probably the reason why equations like [2.11.15] work fortuitously well, even if tensions are misinterpreted a s energies. T h e i s s u e of relating interfacial t e n s i o n s to t h e surface t e n s i o n s of t h e constituents is a n essenticd element in the treatment of adhesion shall briefly r e t u r n to this in sec. 5.7. 2.11c
Other
empirical
a n d wetting. We
relationships
A variety of o t h e r empirical r e l a t i o n s h i p s involving surface or interfacial t e n s i o n s c a n b e found in t h e literature. Mostly they have only historical value. Inspection of t h e s e models invariably leads to the conclusion t h a t i m p o r t a n t features have been overlooked or neglected. Often y is interpreted a s if it were a surface energy; t h e inadequacy of this simplification is directly reflected in t h e impossibility of properly accounting for the temperature dependence y(T). By way of example we mention a n old proposal, sometimes called Stefan's rule (but which more appropriately should be called the Stefan-Ostwald
rule^h t h a t in
our nomenclature would read y ' m
=^A 2
U vap
[2.11.25] m
*■
'
^^ After J. Stefan, Ann. Phys. 2 9 (1886) 655, who pointed to the qualitative relation ;tween y and A U between U^ and W. O Ostwald, Z. Phys. Chem. 1 (1887) 45, who argued that the m factor in '[2.11.24]vapshould be 0.5.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION Here, y
is t h e surface t e n s i o n per mole a n d A
vaporization. Conversion of y into y
U
2.73 t h e m o l a r energy of
requires a model to establish the n u m b e r of
molecules contributing to y in the interface, a problem t h a t is h i d d e n in t h e oversimplified formula. Establishing a relation with the energy of vaporization is not, in itself, far-fetched, b u t the situation is more complicated a n d requires in the first place a proper distinction between y and L^^. We cdready discussed this at the end of sec. 2.9, see fig. 2.16. Vavruch^^ concluded t h a t the factor should be lower t h a n 0.5; moreover, it d e p e n d s on the n a t u r e of the liquid a n d for some liquids, including water, it is strongly temperature-dependent. N u m e r o u s a t t e m p t s to interpret t h e Stefan-Ostwald c o n s t a n t in t e r m s of molecular models have been reviewed by P a r t i n g t o n 2 \ Some of the proposed equations contain, not surprisingly, V"^^^ or v^^^, with the i n h e r e n t dimensional problem of non-integer powers of n u m b e r s of moles. Others contain the latent h e a t of evaporation, or A A
H
vap
U , or both. By way of illustration Abdulnur^^ found t h a t
= const. V^/^U^ m
m
] [2.1L26
a
He also gave a n interpretation of the c o n s t a n t in t e r m s of two simple molecular models; t h i s elaboration is a bit woolly a n d suffers from d i m e n s i o n a l inconsistencies (he u s e s ergs a n d kilocalories in the s a m e equation). Nevertheless, t h e information t h a t t h e linearity of [2.11.26] holds for a b o u t 3 0 liquids (with L^^ ^ 90 m J m~^) may be useful to keep in mind. 2.12
Conclusions and applications
This c h a p t e r w a s devoted to the interpretation of fluid-fluid interfacial t e n s i o n s for simple s y s t e m s in the a b s e n c e of adsorbed or spread molecules. Only flat interfaces were considered. To keep the t r e a t m e n t accessible the level w a s s u c h that, based on this topic, the reader should be able to a s s e s s the m o d e m literature critically a n d to find his way in the, sometimes tortuous, richness of a p p r o a c h e s ranging from formalistjcally rigorous to purely empirical. Limitations imply exclusions. Fluid-fluid interfaces c o n t a i n i n g s p r e a d or adsorbed molecules will be discussed extensively in chapters 3 a n d 4, respectively. Regarding the matter of curved interfaces, two things have to be noted; (i) Bending of interfaces is a m a t t e r of considerable interest, for i n s t a n c e in capillary p h e n o m e n a a n d micro-emulsion studies. Experience h a s shown t h a t the interpretation of bending moduli mostly involves interfaces carrying a d s o r b a t e s . For this reason this matter will be deferred to sec. 4.7 after adsorbed monolayers 1^ I. Vavruch, Colloids Surf 15 (1985) 57. 2^ J.R. Partington, An Advanced Treatise on Physical Chemistry, Vol. II, Longmans (1951), chapter VIII, sec. 6. ^^ S.F. Abdulnur, J. Am, Chem. Soc. 9 8 (1976) 4039.
2.74
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
have been extensively treated. (ii) Tensions for interfaces that are curved on a molecular scale are not considered because they are physically inoperable. There is no way of measuring them, and even the definition of an excess Helmholtz energy per unit area is ambiguous because the result depends on the location of the interace. According to advanced lattice theories ^^ the hydration of molecular-size holes and flat suraces differes drastically. Simulations^^ confirm this. We shall therefore never speaik of 'the interfacial tension of water around the hydrophobic tail of a surfactant'. When the curvature is not yet so strong that the notion of surface tension as a macroscopic quantity loses its meaning there is already the lowering of this tension as a result of the bending itself. We discussed this matter in sec. 1.2.23b and refer to a classical paper by Tolman^^. Our restriction to simple fluids was meant to emphasize general laws and phenomena. For this reason, we did not discuss theories of the surface tension of solids, for which a variety of models have been elaborated^K One of the considerations for omitting these was that such tensions cannot be measured, so that a check of the quality is also impossible. We also consciously excluded the surface tensions of liquid metals, liquid crystals, molten crystals and polymer melts. However, spread and adsorbed polymer layers will be considered in chapter 3 and 4, respectively. For similar reasons, and because most practical applications involve ambient temperatures, we did not extensively discuss critical phenomena, notwithstanding their intrinsic interest. Under critical conditions the surface energy - surface entropy balance differs considerably from that at lower temperatures, emphasized in this chapter. The interfacial (excess) heat capacity is another interfacial characteristic that we decided to disregard. The reason for doing so is not in its intrinsic interest. On the contrary, as with bulk heat capacities, they reflect the structure, or ordering (see e.g. FIGS I, sec. 5.3c). However, it is very difficult to establish these values experimentally. Basically the second derivative of the interfacial tension with respect to the temperature at a constant pressure is needed (see sec. 1.2.7), amd to obtain this extremely precise measurements are needed. The spread in the quadratic coefficient B in [1.12.1] indicates the uncertainty, even for a well-studied liquid like water. Yang and Li^^ showed, by a thermodynamic analysis, that for LL interfaces this heat capacity is related to the two bulk heat capacities, the inter-
im N.A.M. Besseling. J. Lyklema, Pure Appl Chem. 67 (1995) 881. 2^ G.N. Patey, G.M. Torrie, Chem. Scr. 29A (1989) 39; G.M. Torrie, G.N. Patey, Electrochim. Acta 36 (1991) 1677. 3) R.C. Tolman, J. Chem. Phys. 17 (1949) 333. ^^ For a review, see R.J. Good's Kendall Award lecture, J. Colloid Interface Set 59 (1977) 398. ^) C. Yang, D. Li, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 92 (1996) 4471.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.75
facial tension, the interfacial thickness and the molar densities. We disregarded models that ignored the finite thickness of the interfacial region. Although in presenting the mathematical framework 'advanced' notions like correlation functions and pressure tensors were mentioned and briefly explained, we avoided mathematical analysis that involved them. The same may be said about density functionals and veiriational Ccdculus. However, because of the more general interest of these latter techniques, for the present and following themes a brief outline will be given in appendix 3. The above is a post scriptum account of the contents of this chapter. On the business side the questions have to be asked (i) how well can we predict y and dy/dT nowadays and (ii) where can the obtained knowledge be applied? Regarding the former question: we do not yet have one comprehensive theory that on an ab initio basis can predict all interfacial tensions and their derivatives in terms of molecular properties. However, the field is not without promise. Favourites are molecular dynamic simulations (sec. 2.7) and lattice theories (sec. 2.10). These two techniques span complementary parts of the phase space and are of comparable merit. For factual information, of which an abundance is available, the reader is referred to the tabulations in appendix 1. Nowadays there is little demand for simple empirical relations to estimate the surface tension. As to applications, some recur in chapters 3 and 4. However, the vast field of wetting phenomena, to be addressed in chapter 5, offers wide opportunities for applying and extending the insights achieved. Here, additional physical phenomena [critical wetting tension, contact angles, adhesion, line tensions, heterogeneous nucleation, ...) come into view; they may either or both require advanced modelling and/or give additional information. For instance, if contact angles of a liquid on a solid are measurable, one knows y^^ - y^^ (or y^ cos a) in addition to y^^ and the question has to be raised as to what can be done with the extra information. Straightaway it can be stated that this combined information (two facts) is insufficient to establish y^^, y^^ and y^^ (three unknowns) individually, but perhaps theory may help. Another interesting phenomenon is homogeneous nucleation. In the process of condensation of molecules to form an embryonic drop, new surface is created. During this accretion stage the system passes from the molecular size, where an interface cannot yet be defined, to that where it has macroscopic dimensions with a well-defined interfacial tension. In sec. 1.2.23d we presented the classic picture in which y was considered constant. This approach is of course too simple; a statistical analysis of the growing body is needed, whereby some of the models discussed in this chapter may appear helpful. Control of this process is very relevant for the
2.76
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
purposeful synthesis of colloids by the condensation method ^^ and for the understanding of fog formation. In conclusion, this chapter contains a large variety of ideas and incitement for modelling, elaboration and application. 2.13 General References D. Bedeaux, Non-equilibrium Thermodynamics and Statistical Physics of Surfaces, Adv. Chem, Phys. 64 (1986) 47-109. (Theoretical and advanced; includes discussions of the phenomenologicad equations for interfaces and fluctuations.) I. Benjamin, Molecular Structure and Dynamics at Liquid-Liquid Interfaces, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 48 (1997) 407-57. (Review on structure, dynamics, transfer across interfaces and simulations; theory and experiment.) A.I. Burshtein, Simple Liquid Surface Structure and Surface Tension, Adv. Colloid Interf Set 11 (1979) 315-374. (Theoretical; surface energy, surface tensions, profiles for some models, including a generalized van der Waals model; application only to monatomic and diatomic liquids.) H.T. Davis, L.E. Scriven, Stress and Structure in Fluid Interfaces, Adv. Chem. Phys. 16 (1981) 357-459. (Rigorous formalism; part of this recurs in the following book.) H.T. Davis, Statistical Mechanics of Phases, Interphases and Thin Films, VCH 1996. (Extended textbook on statistical thermodynamics with applications to surfaces. Some emphasis on phase formation. Contains a chapter on handling (density) functionals. Mostly more advanced than the present chapter.) R. Defay, I. Prigogine and A. Bellemans; English translation by D.H. Everett, Surface Tension and Adsorption, Longmans (1966). French version was published in 1951 by Maison Desser, Liege, Belgium. (Emphasis on thermodynamics.) R. Evans, Microscopic Theories of Simple Fluids and their Interfaces, in Liquides awe Interfaces/Liquids at Interfaces, Les Houches, Session XLVIII, Course 1, J. Charvolin, J.F. Joanny and J. Zinn-Justin, Eds., Elsevier (1988). (Rather rigorous statistical theory of bulk fluids and fluid-fluid interfaces.) R. Evans, The Nature of the Liquid-Vapour Interface and other Topics in the Statistical Mechanisms of Non-Uniform Classical Fluids, Adv. Phys. 28 (1979) 143200. (Theoretical; emphasis on simple molecules, extensive discussion of the
^^ See for instance V.I. Kalikmanov, M.E.H. van Dongen, J. Chem. Phys. 103 (1995) 4250.
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
2.77
statistical thermodynamic background behind our sections 2.3-2.6. Widom and Rowlinson csilled this an 'admirable review'. ) F.C. Goodrich, Thermodynamics of Fluid Interfaces, in Surface and Colloid Science, E. Matijevic, Ed., Wiley (1969), Vol. 1, p. 1. (Formal thermodynamics, mechanics, tensors, curved interfaces.) J.R. Henderson, Physics Beyond van der Waals, Heterog. Chem. Rev. 2 (1995) 233. (Discussion of van der Waals theory with the hindsight of modem insights into heterogeneous fluids.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, A.W. Neumann, J.K. Spelt, Eds., Marcel Dekker, 1996). (Contains various chapters dealing with the exploitation of the geometric mesm models of sec. 2.1 lb.) D. Nicholson, N.G. Parsonage, Computer Simulation and the Statistical Mechanics of Adsorption, Academic Press (1982). (Mainly theoretical; also contains discussion on the statistical background of interfacial tensions.) J.F. Padday, Surface Tension I. The Theory of Surf ace Tension, in Surface and Colloid Science, E. Matijevic, Ed., Vol. 1, Wiley (1969) 39. (Considers some aspects of our sections 2.9-2.11.) J.S. Rowlinson, The Surface of a Liquid, (Liversidge lecture) in Chem. Soc. Rev. 7 (1978) 329-43. (Older but not dated, very readable review: structure, density profiles, simulation.) J.S. Rowlinson, B. Widom, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Clarendon Press (1982). (Thermodynamics, statistical thermodynamics, simulations. Strongly recommended text about the principles.) A.I. Rusanov, Fazovye Ravnoveciya i Poverkhnostnye Yavleniya (Khimiya, USSR, 1967). German transl., Phasengleichgewichte und Grenzfldchenerscheinungen. Akademie Verlag DDR, 1978.) (Thorough thermodynamic analysis on the role of interfacial tensions in phase equilibria.) A.I. Rusanov, V.A. Prokhorov, Interfacial Tensiometry, Elsevier (1996). (Although this book emphasizes measurements of surface and interfacicd tensions, it also contains much interesting information on thermodynamic backgrounds and interpretations.) A.I. Rusanov, Recent Investigations on the Thickness of Surface Layers, in Progress in Surface and Membrane Set 4 (1971) 57-114. (Thermodynamics, models, experiments.)
2.78
INTERFACIAL TENSION: MOLECULAR INTERPRETATION
M.M. Telo da Gama, B.S. Almeida, The Liquid State, Set Progr. Oxford 72 (1988) 75. (Review with some emphasis on the statistical thermodynamics of pure liquid surfaces.) J.D. van der Waals, Verhandel Koninkl Akad. Wetenschap, Amsterdam, Sec. 1 No. 8, (1893). German transl. (by J.J. van Laar), Z Phys. Chem. 13 (1894) 657; French transl. (perhaps by van der Waals himself), Arch. Neerl 28 (1895) 121; English transl. (by J.S. Rowlinson), J. Stat Phys, 20 (1979) 197. (The translations are not identical. The Dutch and German versions are the seminal papers which anticipate several modem developments.) Tabulation For an extensive tabulation of surface tensions of pure liquids and mixtures as a function of the temperature, see appendix 1. O.R. Quale, The Parachors of Organic Compounds, An Interpretation and Catalogues, Chem Revs, 53 (1953) 439-486. (Appendix with 255 references p. 487589.) (Includes recommendations for submolecular constituent parts to the parachor; only for organic molecules.)
3 LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS 3.1
Langmuir- a n d Gibbs monolayers. Distinctions a n d analogies
3.2
3.2
How to m a k e monolayers
3.3
Two-dimensional p h a s e s a n d surface pressure
3.13
3.3a Determination of the interfacial pressure. Film bcdances
3.14
3.4
3.3b Introduction to 2D p h a s e behaviour
3.18
3.3c Some representative illustrations
3.23
Monolayer t h e r m o d y n a m i c s
3.28
3.4a General formalism a n d definitions
3.28
3.4b Some expressions of general validity
3.33
3.4c Application to a real system
3.36
3.4d The thermod5mamics of p h a s e trainsitions
3.38
3.4e Two-dimensional equations of state
3.39
3.4f
3.5
3.6
Mixed Langmuir monolayers
3.46
3.4g Half open Langmuir monolayers
3.48
3.4h Ionized monolayers
3.49
3.4i
Polymer monolayers
3.53
3.4j
Brushes
3.58
Monolayer molecular t h e r m o d y n a m i c s
3.62
3.5a Some general considerations
3.62
3.5b Strictly two-dimensional a p p r o a c h e s
3.65
3.5c Monte Carlo (MC) simulations
3.67
3.5d Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations
3.69
3.5e Mean field lattice (MFL) theories
3.75
Interfacial rheology
3.79
3.6a Some basic issues
3.82
3.6b A review of bulk rheology
3.84
3.6c Basic interfacial rheology
3.91
3.6d Intermezzo. Disparate definitions of interfacicd tension
3.95
3.6e Coupling of interface a n d bulk motions, Mareingoni effect
3.96
3.6f
Experimental methods to determine surface rheological properties. Principles
3.7
3.6
3.102
3.6g Wave propagation and damping
3.109
3.6h Relaxation processes in Langmuir monolayers
3.120
3.6i
3.125
Equivalent mechanical circuits
Measuring monolayer properties
3.131
3.7a Monolayer transfer on solid s u b s t r a t e s : LangmuirBlodgett films
3.132
3.7b Reflection a n d diffraction
3.141
3.7c Spectroscopic techniques
3.156
3.7d S c a n n i n g probe microscopy
3.174
3.7e Rheology
3.180
3.7f Volta potentials
3.190
3.8
Case studies 3.8a A note on equilibrium and reproducibility 3.8b Fatty acids, fatty alcohols and related compounds 3.8c Phospholipids 3.8d Cholesterol 3.8e PMA at the air/water interface 3.8f PEG brushes 3.9 Applications 3.10 General references 3.10a lUPAC Recommendations 3.10b Monographs, reviews 3.10c Classical and molecular thermodynamics 3.10d Interfacial rheology 3.10e Characterization 3.10f Langmuir-Blodgett layers 3.10g Data collection
3.194 3.194 3.200 3.215 3.223 3.227 3.231 3.235 3.241 3.241 3.242 3.243 3.243 3.244 3.247 3.247
3
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
About two thousand years ago, affluent Romans used to enjoy sports, including wrestling, after a working day. For this they had their skin greased by oil that was washed off afterwards in a bath. The water subsequently became covered by an oil film that had to be removed at night by slaves. Depending on the conditions, this layer may have been so thick that interference colours could have been seen, or so thin that we would now call it a (saturated or unsaturated) monolayer, invisible to the eye, but detectable because of the lowering of the surface tension with respect to that of pure water. Had the Roman masters had tensiometers to hand, they could have evaluated very critically the quality of their slaves' cleaning. In fact few, if any, would have passed scrutiny. Nowadays we know that a drastic lowering of the surface tension of water is achieved by simply poking in it with an unwashed finger. Another historical illustration which involved monolayers, was when sailors poured oil on the sea in oder to calm 'troubled waters' and so protect their ship. This worked by wave damping or, more precisely, by preventing small ripples from forming in the first place so that the wind could have no effect on them. Very little oil is required; to achieve this, less than a saturated monolayer. Marangoni effects are basic to this phenomenon: sudden local area expansions lead to locally enhanced surface tensions and the resulting surface pressure gradient promotes contraction of that area, so further area growth is counteracted. In other words, the resulting Marangoni flow opposes the flow associated with the wave action. For optimal effect the oil should not dissolve in the water. In 1765 Benjamin Franklin mimicked this phenomenon by spreading a monomolecular layer of oil on a lake near Clapham Common in London, England. Franklin's curiosity was in part triggered by the observation that the sea behind a convoy of ships, on which the cooks used sea water to rinse the fatty left-overs of dishes, was much smoother than that behind ships where this did not happen. He then remembered Plinius' description of how the sea could be calmed, when diving or in stormy weather, by the addition of oil. From his experiments Franklin learned that, on the treated parts of the surface, the wind had much less effect than on non-treated parts; the surface remciined mirror-like. One teaspoon of oil was enough to calm several hundreds of square metres. Franklin noted the rapidity of the spreading oil and its strength, which was enough to cause small floating objects like straws and leaves to recede away from the drop. He wrote that there was
3.2
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
seemingly a repulsive force between the oil molecules and the water. The title photograph in the book Interfacial Phenomena by J.T. Davies and E.K. Rideal (Academic Press, 1961) shows such a mirror-like surface on a lake in Scotland, which had had hexadecanol spread on it. Nowadays we cam sometimes deduce from such an absence of wind-ripples that the surface must be contaminated, for instance in the wake of boats. It is typical of monolayers that limited numbers of molecules, down to nanograms per cm^, can have drastic consequences^^. A third example illustrating the same type of system involves people in some hot areas, such as Australia, who have tried to conserve precious water supplies in ponds or lakes by covering the surface with a (saturated) monolayer of an insoluble substance, like a fatty alcohol. They hoped in this way to reduce evaporation. For long-term use this method has only been moderately successful, but the fact is established that such monolayers do inhibit water transport. We will return briefly to this in sec. 3.9. These three illustrations (to which more could be added) have in common that they deal with very thin (down to molecular scale) layers of molecules at fluidliquid interfaces. In this way they serve to introduce the subject matter of this, and the following chapter, namely Langmuir- and Gibbs monolayers, respectively. 3.1 Langmuir- and Gibbs monolayers. Distinctions and analogies In interfacial science the term monolayer is used in a number of different ways. Although this rarely leads to confusion one needs to be aware of them. In the chapters on adsorption on solids (chapters II. 1 and 2) the notion of 'monolayer' was sometimes used to distinguish it from bilayer or multilayer, and implying that all adsorbed molecules are in contact with the adsorbent. Whether or not this layer is completely filled does not matter in that case. However, the packing did matter in other instamces where the amount adsorbed in a completely filled layer was at issue, as for example in the plateau of the Langmuir adsorption isotherm (r(oo)), or in the volume V in the BET theory, corresponding to the volume of gas that would be adsorbed in one completed monolayer. In those instances where confusion could arise we spoke of unsaturated or incomplete monolayers as opposed to saturated or complete ones. The equivalent layers at liquid-fluid (LG or LL) interfaces, are commonly called monolayers, whether saturated or not. It is often the case that researchers tacitly
^^ A very readable historical accountt was written by C. Tanford, under the title Ben Franklin Suntiled the Waves, with the subtitle An Informal History of Pouring Oil on Water with Reflections on the Ups and Downs of Scientific Life in General Duke Univ. Press (USA) (1989). See also J.T. Davies, Surface Phenomena in Chemistry and Biology. Pergamon Press (1958). The historical introduction by C.H. Giles, S.D. Forrester and G.G. Roberts in the book by G. Roberts, mentioned in sec. 3.10b, is also worth reading.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.3
refer to LG or LL interfaces when speaiking of monolayer studies. In chapters 3 and 4 we shall use this somewhat loose jargon to avoid tedious repetition of long, but more precise terms, only specifying our objects further when confusion may arise. With respect to the nature of the monolayers we shall at least discuss all the equivalents of those treated in Volume II, i.e. layers consisting of low-molecular mass molecules, ionic layers (be they diffusely distributed or in a Stern layer) uncharged polymers, polyelectrolytes, surfactants, etc. Particular attention will be paid to lipids and lipid-like molecules. In keeping with the style and purpose of FIGS, monolayers of single components will be emphasized, although there is a wealth of information on two- and multicomponent systems, allowing for the study of synergistic or antagonistic phenomena, interfacial reactions, partial solubility etc. There is little point in trying to make a sharp distinction between monolayers in the strict sense and those having some extension, normal to the surface, like the diffuse parts of double layers or the loops and tails in polymeric adsorbates. Thermodynamically, all this material belongs to. the surface excess in the sense of Gibbs' law. We shall briefly introduce multiple surfactant layers on solid surfaces, so-called multiple Langmuir-Blodgett layers. On the other hand, other films of colloidal thickness (^ 1 nm) and beyond will be discussed in Volume FV, although some aspects will be dealt with in chapter 5. Protein monolayers will be deferred to Volume V. Another distinction that is usually made refers to the mode through which the monolayer is prepared; via adsorption (adsorbed monolayers) or via some deposition technique, like spreading {spread monolayers). The second procedure only works for molecules that do not, or hardly, dissolve in the subphase. Hence, such layers are also called insoluble m.onolayers. We shall refrain from identifying monolayers in terms of the procedure of preparation, but distinguish between monolayers in which no exchange with the liquid phase takes place on the time scale of the experiment, and those where this is possible. Following modem usage, these types will henceforth be called Langmuir monolayers and Gibbs monolayers, respectively. The former will be treated in this chapter and the latter in the following. To mark the basic differences, let us first consider the extreme (idealized) cases of fully insoluble Langmuir monolayers and completely reversible Gibbs monolayers, deferring the issue of the time scale till later in this section. Besides the obvious difference in preparation, there is a difference in principle between these two categories. Langmuir monolayers are at thermal equilibrium with the liquid subphase, but not with respect to the exchange of material. So in this case the liquid should, strictly speaking, not be called 'solvent'. On the other hand, Gibbs monolayers are both in thermal and material exchange equilibrium. Langmuir monolayers can be compressed by sweeping the molecules together to a smaller area. (Such a compression can for instance be realized in a so-called
3.4
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
Langmuir trough or film balance, to be described in sec. 3.3.1). With such compression the surface pressure n increases. Surface equations of state, relating K to the area A and the temperature T can be formulated, entirely analogous to the threedimensional equivalent. For instance, for a very dilute, 'gaseous', monolayer the two-dimensional equation of state is ;rA = n^RT
[3.1.1]
for n^ moles spread on the area A. This equation is fully equivalent to the three dimensional equation TIV = nRT for the osmotic pressure. For non-ideal monolayers other equations of state aire needed. We shall come back to these in sees. 3.35, but note that in these equations the properties of the liquid carrier do not occur. The monolayer acts as a phase on its own, the properties of which can be aiffected by external forces. When the compression continues, eventually a saturated monolayer is attained; upon further increase of the pressure the film starts to bulge out (it collapse^. By contrast, Gibbs monolayers are continually at equilibrium with the subphase which, in this case, may be called a solution. Surface tension and concentration are related through Gibbs' law, so that the surface pressure can be related to the solution concentration. By analogy with [II. 1.1.6 and 7] we have for a single adsorbed component in an ideal solution r ^ HI K = / * - / = RT [ r ' d l n c = RT f F ' ^ - ^ dT' J J dF' o
[3.1.2]
o
where /* stands for the surface tension of the pure solvent, T' is the variable surface concentration and F the final surface concentration for which the surface tension is y. When a Gibbs monolayer is compressed, the molecules desorb until, upon maximum compression, all adsorbed molecules have disappeared. They will readsorb when the area is recreated. Although there is a certain formal amalogy with the three-dimensional pressure of a gas confined in a volume, the origin of the surface pressure is quite different. The gas pressure originates from gas molecules colliding against a wall and the resulting momentum transfer but the interfacial pressure is the result of a difference in contractile force between a covered and a non-covered interface. Thermodynamically the interfacial pressure is equivalent to the osmotic pressure difference between a solution and a solvent, separated by a barrier (membrane) that does not allow transport of the solute, see sec. 3.4. In Langmuir troughs, the barrier separating the monolayer-covered interface from the clean interface acts as a semi-permeable membrane. The molecules of the aqueous subphase equilibrate between both sides of the bsirrier, whereas those of the monolayer are restricted to one side of the barrier. For a Gibbs monolayer it is impossible to make a barrier
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.5
separating the monolayer from the surface of the pure solvent. The distinction between Langmuir and Gibbs monolayers resembles that between an ideally polarizable and an ideally relaxed electrified interface (sec. 1.5.5b). An interface is polarizable when no charges (ions or electrons) can cross it; it is reversible when such transport takes place until equilibrium between electrode and solution has been attained. In the former case the potential across the interface has to be applied from an external source so that it is an independent variable. For a relaixed interface this is not the case; the potential is spontaneously established by preferential adsorption or desorption of ionic species. In practice, idealized Langmuir and Gibbs monolayers are not always realizable; intermediate situations with more or less materiad trainsport may exist, depending on the chemistry of the system and on the time scale of the experiment. We may extend the analogy to the distinction between polarized and relaxed interfaces because this distinction is not absolute either. Polarized interfaces can become relaxed by adding a redox component (a 'depolarizer') whereas relaxed interfaces can be polarized by operating at such high frequencies that exchange currents are suppressed. For monolayers, the equivalent phenomena are that the solubility of certain molecular species can be affected by changing the composition or that the time scale of the experiment is adjusted in such a way as to suppress or promote exchange with the subphase. As an example of the former, fatty acids are scarcely soluble at low pH (where for all practical purposes they form Langmuir monolayers) but fully soluble at high pH (where de facto they form Gibbs monolayers). As to the time scale of the experiment, the Deborah number De enters the picture (reccdl sec. 1.2.3). At low De the system is relaixed because transport from monolayer to subphase has enough time to come to equilibrium, whereas at high De it is the other way around. In interfacial rheology (sec. 3.6) these interesting dynamic distinctions will be exploited to study mechanisms and rates of interfacial transport processes. With regard to the surface pressure, for ideedized Langmuir monolayers ;r is an independent, externally applied vairiable, whereas for idealized Gibbs monolayers K is determined by adsorption of molecules. The obvious question is whether surface equations of state.are identical between Langmuir and Gibbs monolayers. The answer is, in principle, yes. Relations between 7t, A and F are completely determined by the numbers of, and interactions between, the molecules in the monolayer, irrespective of whether or not equilibrium with an adjacent phase has been established. The statistical derivation underlines this. The two-dimensional pressure can be obtained canonicaRy from
or grand-canonically from
3.6
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS 7iA = kT{lnE/E^)
[3.1.4]
(see [1.3.3.13], so that
where Q = Q(N,AT) and 5= £(//,A,T) are the canonical and grand-canonical partition functions, respectively. Equations [3.1.3 and 4] are the two-dimensional variants of [I.A6.11 and 23], respectively. The resulting equations for n are the same, although canonically the monolayer is considered a closed system (representing Langmuir monolayers) whereas grand-canonically the monolayer is open (representing Gibbs monolayers). Given this definition of idealized Langmuir and Gibbs given, we shall now treat these systems systematically in this chapter and the next. Techniques and properties that Langmuir and Gibbs monolayers have in common will be dealt with in this, longer, chapter. Although in Langmuir monolayers the spread molecules are not surfactants in the usued meaining of 'dissolved molecules with a high affinity for a surface that is offered', we shall nevertheless occasionally call them so for the sake of simplicity. 3.2 How to make monolayers It follows from the above that there will be a difference in principle between the preparations of Langmuir and Gibbs monolayers. For the latter the procedure is simple. The substance to form the monolayer must be dissolved in the liquid substrate from which it will adsorb spontaneously as soon as the solution is brought into contact with air, or with another, immiscible, liquid. There are different ways in which to carry this out. For instance, an air bubble may be grown in the solution or the second liquid may be emulsified if the adsorbing molecules also act as an emulsifier. For macroscopic surfaces the amount adsorbed cannot usually be determined analytically, but the surface tension, and hence the surface pressure, can be measured by one of the. methods described in chapter 1. If this tension is available as a function of the equilibrium concentration in the bulk, the surface concentration can be inferred from Gibbs' law. For emulsified systems the surface concentration can usually be determined analytically, but then the determination of the surface tension may pose problems. One of the problems that has to be considered is that, in the case of incomplete reversibility, the composition of an emulsion interface may differ from that of a quiescent one because the former is the result of the complex rupture and recoalescence processes during the emulsification stage. This issue returns in sec. 4.8.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.7
/ /
/
/
\
\
\
\
Figure 3.1. Spontaneous spreading of a monocomponent liquid of amphipolar molecules. For the preparation of Lcingmuir monolayers, a detour is required, except when such layers can be made from Gibbs monolayers, by changing the composition of the substrate aifter adsorption has taken place, for example by changing the pH. The need for a detour is typical and requires some form of spreading. By this technique the amount of molecules at the interface is known and the interfacial tension or pressure are basically measurable. Hence, n{A] curves are obtainable. Spreading may take place directly by depositing either a crystal of the insoluble surfactant, or a drop of the solution of such a surfactant in a volatile solvent at the interface. Spreading requires the spontaneous breakdown of the three-dimensional structure of the solid or the liquid, respectively, and the creation of the twodimensional monolayer. Figure 3.1 illustrates this process for a liquid. Most monolayers, however, are obtained by dissolving the materiad to be spread in a volatile solvent that will spread spontaneously over the interface and disappear soon thereafter by evaporation (GL interfaces) or by dissolution in one of the liquid phases (LL interfaces). Obviously, the spreading solvent should satisfy the following conditions: - it should spread spontaneously, meaining that its spreading tension should be positive (see below) - its density should be between those of the sub-phase and the upper phase - it should be a good solvent for the monolayer material - it should be volatile (GL) or readily soluble in one of the phases (LL). On the other hand, if it is too volatile, manipulation of the spreading solvent may become tricky. It follows that the choice of the solvent depends on the material to be spread. Familiar solvents are n-hexane, cyclohexane, benzene, chloroform and ethyl ether. Mixtures may also be used. Figure 3.2 shows the cross section of a drop of liquid (3) at an interface between the phases (1) and (2). Consider point A, where the three interfaciad tensions 7^^, y^^ and y^^ are simultaneously active. The curvatures of the 13 and 23 interfaces are determined by the fact that the Laplace
3.8
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
yl2
Figure 3.2. Spreading of a solution of amphiphilic molecules (3) at the interface between fluids (1) and (2). p r e s s u r e s a c r o s s t h e m m u s t be identicad (except for a small gravity correction); ^23^j^23 ^ yi3//^i3 for spherical interfaces (i.e. in the absence of gravity; for large droplets gravity leads to flattening). In the figure it is, j u s t for the sake of argument, assumed that y^^ = 2y^^.
(When 2 is a vapour and 1 a liquid y^^ < y^^, then the cur-
v a t u r e s a r e opposite to those in the figure.) The drop flattens by s p r e a d i n g if 7^^ > y^^ cos co^^ + y^^ coso)^^. When the drop h a s flattened to the extent t h a t both co^^ and co^^ approach 0° and, hence, their cosines approach unity, further spreading depends on the sign of the spreading tension^\
defined a s
Sl2(3) ^ ^ 1 2 _ ^ 1 3 _ ^ 2 3 During the process S^^^^^ decreases. As long a s
[3 2.1] S^^^^^ > 0, spreading continues.
S p r e a d i n g a n d drop s h a p e s will be discussed in some detail in sec. 5.2 ff. At equilibrium, S < 0 . In appendix 1 examples of liquid-vapour surface tensions a n d of liquid-liquid interfacial t e n s i o n s a r e given. From this tabulation spreading t e n s i o n s c a n b e computed. As a rule, a liquid of low surface tension s p r e a d s over a liquid of high surface tension. For instance, from the tabulated values it follows t h a t a t 2 9 3 K benzene initially spreads over water, because S^^^^^ (= 72.8 - 28.9 - 35.0) > 0 mN m ' ^ However, benzene a n d water are not completely
immiscible; after some time there
will be m u t u a l saturation. As the surface tension of water s a t u r a t e d with benzene equals 62.2 mN m'^ a n d t h a t of benzene s a t u r a t e d with water 28.8 mN m - ^ t h e corresponding value for s^^^^^ < 0. This explains why a drop of p u r e benzene, deposited on a surface of p u r e water, initially s p r e a d s (before t h e liquids a r e mutually saturated), b u t retracts into a lens afl:er some time. Having t h u s considerd the mechanism of spreading, the question h a s to be asked whether the final result is unique in the sense t h a t the obtained monolayer of given average area per molecule a. h a s properties independent of the m a n n e r of spread-
^^ S is sometimes called spreading parameter, or spreading coefficient, terms that are less precise. lUPAC has proposed the symbol a, but we prefer the S because it is very common and because a will be needed for the surface charge density in charged monolayers.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.9
ing. In particular, these properties should not depend on the n a t u r e of the spreading solvent, or on the rate of spreading, or, for mixed layers, on the order of addition 1). E x p e r i m e n t s to verify t h e s e i n d e p e n d e n c i e s do n o t always give c o n s i s t e n t results. The problem is t h a t minor differences in manipulation a n d / o r purity may affect them. For instance, - the spreading solvent may contain minor surface active impurities, enriching the monolayer after evaporation or dissolution - the solvent itself may not completely evaporate - this solvent may solubilize part of the monolayer material - evaporation of the solvent may give rise to domsiins of inonolayer molecules of a size depending on the n a t u r e of the solvent (particuleirly its volatility) a n d t h e monolayer material. In addition, t h e r a t e s of s p r e a d i n g are different between different
spreading
solvents^^. For instance, a drop of alcohol on water is known to spread rapidly a n d with some turbulence, whereas chloroform a n d hexane, other popular solvents, do so m u c h more slowly, with concomitant consequences for t h e homogeneity of t h e layer. Depending on the method of spreading or deposition, it is always possible t h a t non-relaxing local heterogeneities are formed. After all, if monolayers a r e formed by spreading on a fixed £irea, the earlier added molecules experience a lower c o u n t e r p r e s s u r e thcin those arriving later. Therefore, spreading on a fixed a r e a is u s e d only w h e n no alternatives are available. As t h e rate is determined by t h e n a t u r e of the solvent, rate- and solvent features are mixed. This does not help in the s e a r c h for t h e origin of any inconsistencies. In practice, if t h e surface p r e s s u r e rises before spreading is complete, the film is usually discarded. Several examples c a n be found in the literature where the a u t h o r s attempted to trace the origin(s) of method-dependent monolayers. For instance, Mingins et a[.^^ reported t h e influence of t h e solvent on 7t(A) c u r v e s for
octadecyltrimethyl
a m m o n i u m bromide spread from five different solvent mixtures or from crystals on a s u b s t r a t e of 0.1 M NaCl in which the surfactant is insoluble. At a given area n w a s found to differ between the various spreading solvents by a variation of 0.3 mNm"^ at low F to 3 mN m"^ at high F . Iwahashi et al.^^ found t h a t K(A] curves obtained for the spreading of fatty acid crystals depended on the sizes a n d s h a p e s of the crystals, apparently caused by irregular dissolution rates. For a comprehensive discussion see ref.^^. 1^ H.-D. Dorfler, W. Rettig and P. Hennersdorf. Coll Polym. Set 258 (1980) 1271. ^^ See for instance, A. Gericke, J. Simon-Kutscher and H. Huhnerfuss, Langmuir 9 (1993) 2119. ^^ J. Mingins. F. Owens and D.H. lies, J. Phys. Chem, 7 3 (1969) 2118; this study was an extension of L. Ter-Minassian-Saraga, Proc. 2nd Int. Congress Surface Activity, Vol. I (1957) Butterworth. "^^ M. Iwahashi, N. Malhara, Y. Kaneko, T. Seimiya, S.R. Middleton, N.R. Pallas and B.A. Pethica, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. (I) 81 (1985) 973.
3.10
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
The dissolution of surface-active components in the spreading liquid greatly affects its spreading behaviour. For instance, £in amphiphilic substance (e.g. oleic acid) will adsorb strongly at the water-benzene and benzene-air interface, thereby reducing 7^^ and 7^^ considerably. As a result, a solution of oleic acid in benzene spreads readily over the water surface. For a quantitative interpretation of monolayer studies it is required to know exactly the amount of material in that layer. Therefore, the spreading should be complete and the material should not dissolve in the upper and/or lower phase. As a rule, the amount of monolayer materied deposited at the interface is far less, say, by a factor of three or four, than that corresponding to a close-packed monolayer. However, after spreading, the interfacial area comprising the spread molecules may be compressed to obtain such a close-packed monolayer (see sec. 3.3). A fresh interfacial area needs to be created directly before depositing the monolayer material. This can be achieved by sweeping the surface; remnants of a previous experiment or inadvertant surface-active impurities are collected by compressing the cirea, followed by suction of the reduced area. This manipulation can be repeated several times. Preferably after compression the surface pressure should be ^ 0.1 mN m"^. In most cases, some tens of a |i^ of the spreading solution is supplied by using a micrometer syringe. In the case of a liquid-gas interface, a drop of the spreading solution may just be deposited on the surface, provided the monolayer material is insoluble in the liquid phase. However, in the case of
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.3. Two spreading techniques, (a) The tip of the syringe is wetted by the lower phase: (b) Trurnit method. Method (a) becomes more effective when the syringe is at an angle.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.11
spreading at a liquid-liquid interface or at a liquid-gas interface where the material to be spread is soluble in the liquid phase (as for soluble polymers that form virtually insoluble monolayers), the tip of the syringe should be exactly in the interface. This can be achieved by having the syringe tip made of a material that is wetted by the lower phase but not by the upper phase. The syringe is lowered until it touches down onto the interface, after which it is lifted slightly so that it forms a meniscus, as shown in fig. 3.3a. Another spreading method, often applied when insoluble monolayers of soluble components (polymers) are to be made, involves a rod that is placed on the bottom of the container and that has its roughened tapered top Just penetrating the upper phase, as shown in fig. 3.3b. The rod should consist of material that is preferentially wetted by the lower phase, so that it remains covered with a film of the lower liquid. The tip of the syringe is placed on the top of the rod and the solution is spread in the direction of the arrows, shown in fig. 3b. In this way Trumit, who invented this method, successfully spread protein molecules from an aqueous solution on an air-water interface ^^ When the monolayer material is spread from its pure liquid or pure solid (crystal), the amount deposited at the interface is so small that it may be difficult to measure accurately. For instance, covering a surface of, say 500 cm^ with a spread amount of 0.5 mg m"^ requires the accurate weighing and application of 25 [ig of material. As may be understood from fig. 3.2, the driving force for spreading is localized at the three-phase boundairy between the phases 1, 2 and 3. For a rapidly spreading solvent the driving force is the gradient in the surface pressure or, for that matter, the gradient of the spreading tension, V;r or VS^^^^^. In the stationary state this gradient is compensated by viscous drag of the form, ri(dv /dz). See [1.6.4.21]. Elaboration is not straightforward because it is difficult to account for the thickness of the layer and for the non-stationary nature. We shall come back to this in sec. 5.8. As a check on regular 7t[A) measuring procedures, the spreading process may be monitored by sprinkling some inert powder on the surface of the sub-phase. Upon the application of the spreading liquid the powder sweeps back and accumulates at the liquid's periphery. The movement of the drop perimeter thus indicates the spreading rate. More sophisticated alternative, non-invasive methods have also been proposed. For instance, O'Brien et al.-^^ used sensitive thermistors at the advancing front to monitor transient temperature drops resulting from local evaporation which in turn was caused by stirring produced at the leading edge. In a subsequent paper^^ these authors present rates which may be up
1^ H.J. Trumit. J. Colloid Set 15 (1960) 1. 2) R.N. O'Brien, A.I. Feher and J. Uja, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 469.
3.12
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
to ~ 300 mm s-^ or about 12 km hr-^ depending on the nature of the surfactant (smaller molecules spread more rapidly). As a first approximation, the rate of spreading of a liquid is proportioned to S^^^^^ and inversely proportional to the sum of the viscosities T]^ and r/^ of the under- and overlying phases, respectively rate of spreading - constant x S^^^^^ /{T]^ +r]^)
[3.2.2]
The dependence of the spreading rate on the sum of the viscosities of phases (1) aind (2) results from the fact that the spreading film drags the two adjacent phases along; energy is dissipated in both fluid phases. In this connection we may refer back to equations [1.6.4.20a and b] which also contain the sum of the viscosities in the denominator. We shall return to this in sec. 3.6. Spreading from a solid requires a much higher activation Gibbs energy than spreading from a liquid, and therefore the rate of spreading from a solid is much slower. As with liquids, the formation of a monolayer from a solid occurs at the perimeter of the solid with the interface. The spreading rate depends on the length of this perimeter of the solid-hquid-gas (or liquid) interface, according to rate of spreading ~ constant * perimeter * [;r - ;r(t)|
[3.2.3]
where n(t] is the interfacial pressure and the subscript e refers to the final state. In this case, the constant reflects the coherence of the solid and the factor [jt - 7t{t)] replaces S^^^^^ in [3.2.2]. Even after all these problems of ensuring complete spreading have been overcome, the issue of hysteresis in n{A) curves remains. Otherwise stated, the problem arises whether the finad state is the absolute equilibrium state, or some metastable intermediate state. The question is whether expansion aind compression cycles give rise to the same K at given A. One of the most fi-equent origins of such hysteresis is that, upon compression, a certain structure is created or collapse takes place in the monolayer, which upon subsequent expansion does not break down or, at least, not fast enough. If it does not break down at all, the system passes through a series of metastable states; then we may speak of real hysteresis. If the structures do break down, the rate at which this occurs becomes relevant and what will be observed depends on the Deborah number, (T(relax)/T(obs)). So, to get a feeling of what's happening it is worth considering the time effect. Another useful procedure is to repeat cycles; it is possible that upon the first cycle some structural elements are created that in subsequent cycles remain intact. Such cycles tcike us to the domain of interfacial rheology, to be discussed in sec. 3.6. Obviously, no general rules can be given. The trend is that hysteresis is more prominent when, during the cycles.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.13
phase transitions have to be passed^^. Some illustrations of relaxation processes in Langmuir monolayers will be discussed in sec. 3.6h. The caveat must be added that nowadays instrumentation is used, in which the step-wise compression and expemsion are automated. Depending on the criterion of equilibration, such set-ups may not be fully satisfactory in picking up hysteresis. Finally, the necessity for keeping the contact angle zero at the Wilhelmy plate must be mentioned. Returning to the reproducibility of the vairious spreading methods, it may be concluded that the present state-of-the-airt is that absolute accuracy with regard to the 7t{A) curves has not yet been achieved. As a result, analyses involving absolute values of K must be viewed with some reservation. Additionsd measurements may be helpful to find out to what extent layers with a different history are identicad. Such measurements include surface rheology, surface potential measurements, the absence or presence of hysteresis upon extension/compression, etc. The influence of the rate of extension/compression cycles, essentially measuring the Deborsih number of the monolayer is another interesting phenomenon. For an lUPAC recommendation on reporting film balance data, including a check-list and advice about the manipulation and handling the chemiceds, see the paper by Ter-Minassian-Saraga, mentioned in sec. 3.10a. 3.3 Two-dimensional phases and surface pressure Ever since Franklin's discovery of monolayers, their pressure and rheology, attempts have been made to further the basic understanding. Regarding the application, wave damping is of course of imminent interest for sea-going nations. In Scotland John Shields carried out large-scale wave-damping experiments and lodged a patent in 1879. Lord Rayleigh also developed a great interest in surface waves and their damping. From the scientific side he realized that surface tensions can be lowered by contamination. Although he had no method to measure exactly the thickness of monomolecular films he estimated them to be 1-2 nm. He also pointed out that, in this way, information on the size of molecules was obtainable, long before the very existence of molecules was generally accepted. The first measurement of (what is now called) a 7t{A) curve comes from Pockels-^K She did many experiments on her kitchen table and realized the relevance of sweeping the surface before measuring. Langmuir gave generous credit to her work, although he largely independently developed the film balance that nowa-
1^ See for example E.I. Franses, C.-H. Chang, J.B. Chung, K. Coltharp-McGlnnis, and S.Y. Park, Dynamic Adsorption and Tension of Spread or Adsorbed Monolayers at the Air-Water Interface, chapter 18 in Micelles, Micro-emulsions and Monolayers, D.O. Shah, Ed., Marcel Dekker (1998). 2) A. Pockels, Nature 4 8 (1893) 152.
3.14
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
barrier
float
(b)
1^-1
barrier
.^"^
^J^UMU^JJ
(c)
K^///^/////////^/////////J/////^///
Figure 3.4. Basic elements of a Langmuir trough, (a) Original Langmuir-type trough in perspective view. BB', barrier; D, float; H, bridge; RR' support for barriers; T, torsion balance; (b) The same, cross-section; (c) cross-section of current troughs, containing two Wilhelmy plates, WP-1 and WP-2. Modem balances contain various additional gadgets, for instance, a cover to suppress evaporation, controlled drives to move the barrier at a given rate, electrodes for measuring Volta potentials or optical devices. days b e a r s his n a m e ^^. One of the new characteristics of the Langmuir trough w a s t h a t a direct m e a s u r e m e n t of the film pressure could be derived from the deflection of a movable float, separating the film from clean water. We shall now describe this trough. 3.3a
Determination
of the interfacial
pressure.
Film
balances
The basic features of the original Langmuir trough are shown schematically in fig. 3.4. The t r o u g h usually consists of a rectangular tray containing t h e fluid phase(s). It is equipped with a barrier t h a t floats on the surface (i.e. it is positioned in the interface). The areas at both sides of the barrier can be varied in a controlled way. Spreading molecules at one side of the barrier results in a difference between the
1) I. Langmuir, J. Am, Chem. Soc. 39 (1917) 1848.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.15
interfacial tensions at the two sides of the barrier. This difference, 7* - 7, exerts a force {Y*-y)C on the barrier of length i in the direction of the clean surface. The force per u n i t length, 7* - 7, equals, according to eq. [3.1.2], the interfacial pressure n. It is a tw(>dirnensional pressure. The force at the barrier may be m e a s u r e d directly by a calibrated torsion wire t h a t is mechanically attached to the barrier. However, nowadays t h e surface tensions a t b o t h sides of the barrier are m e a s u r e d independently u s i n g one of t h e appropriate methods in sec. 1.8, mostly by the static Wilhelmy plate technique. The latter method h a s the advantage t h a t any leaikage of monolayer material across t h e barrier c a n be easily detected. Sliding the barrier over the interface in the direction of t h e covered a r e a confines t h e molecules of the monolayer material to a smaller a r e a . As a r e s u l t 71 increases. If the n u m b e r of molecules in the monolayer is known, K can be related to the interfacicd area A or to the average area a available per molecule 1^. Comparing t h e limiting value for A with the molecular dimensions of t h e c o m p o n e n t
in-
volved may serve to verify whether all the added surfactant is really in the monolayer. The increase of K[A) with decreasing A, at c o n s t a n t t e m p e r a t u r e , is t h e twodimensional analogue of a n osmotic pressure-concentration isotherm. S u c h surface pressure
isotherms
axe the prime source of information a b o u t t h e orienta-
tional a n d / o r conformational properties of the molecules in the monolayer; they reflect their dimensional properties a s well a s interactions between t h e m . In this respect, 7i[A) isotherms have a b o u t the s a m e function a s adsorption i s o t h e r m s . This matter wiU be discussed in more detail in sees. 3.4 and 5. In designing Langmuir troughs a few practical points should be considered. The m o s t important are; -
The interfaces at both sides of the barrier should be sufficiently large to allow
accessibility for m a n i p u l a t i o n s a n d space for devices for m e a s u r i n g simultEineously other monolayer characteristics, s u c h a s interfacial concentration, thickness, interfacial electric potential, spectroscopic a n d optical properties, etc. -
It is essential t h a t the trough a n d its contents are ultra-clean, b e c a u s e even
traces of impurities may c a u s e large errors, particularly in n. Therefore, it is b e s t to place the film balance in a n environment of clean air, often established by a lamincir flow of purified gas over the trough. It can t h e n be placed in a cabinet with remote control to shield it from external pollution.
1^ We shall use a^ for the variable average area per molecule i; a^ = A/N^. To retain the analogy with adsorption on solids, a ^ ^ will be used for the moleculcir area in a saturated monolayer. The subscript i can be omitted if no confusion arises with a as the radius of a molecule. For condensed monolayers molecular cross-sections are usually obtained from breaks in 7t{A) curves; .depending on the number of transitions observed, a variety of corresponding cross-sections can be distinguished.
3.16 -
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
In order to prevent leakage of monolayer material over the edges of the trough
a n d across t h e barrier, the edges and the barrier should not be wetted by the s u b p h a s e liquid, b u t the underside of the barrier, somewhat submerged into the liquid, should be wetted. For air-water interfaces Teflon is t h e most preferable material. Obviously, it should not contain soluble impurities. -
B e c a u s e t h e influence of the t e m p e r a t u r e on monolayer properties m a y give
relevant information (see fig. 3.8), it is desirable to have the trough equipped with a temperature-control unit. The single movable barrier trough, a s described above, may be modified to serve different p u r p o s e s . In order to eliminate leakage problems and in view of the requirement of s u b p h a s e level a d j u s t m e n t , t h e monolayer may b e enclosed within a c o n t i n u o u s flexible barrier. The area within the barrier may be varied in different ways^K The flexible barrier is often made of Teflon tape, typically ca. 3-4 cm. in height a n d 0.1 m m thick. S u c h a device not only works for liquid-air surfaces b u t also allows the investigation of monolayers a t oil-water interfaces. Convenient film b a l a n c e s for use at oil-water interfaces have also been described by Brooks a n d Pethica-^^ Blight et al.^^ a n d Murray a n d Nelson"^^. Instead of a rectangular trough, a circular one can also be used^^. This shape h a s the advantage t h a t the circular motion of the motor driving the barrier does n o t need to be transmitted into a linear motion. On the other hand, it may be difficult to control the g r a d i e n t s
in the rate of monolayer compression or expansion. A
circular s h a p e is also suitable for constructing a multi-compartment trough. The multi-compartment trough described by Fromherz h a s two barriers which enables c o m p r e s s i o n / e x p a n s i o n , a s well a s t r a n s p o r t (at c o n s t a n t area) of the monolayer. The principle of s u c h a multi-compartment trough is shown in flg. 3.5. In t h e c o m p r e s s i o n / e x p a n s i o n mode the barriers are uncoupled so t h a t they c a n move independently, w h e r e a s in the t r a n s p o r t mode they are clamped together to allow the monolayer to be transferred, at constant area, from the one compartment to the other. T h u s , the monolayer may be spread on one s u b p h a s e , shifted to a compartment containing a different s u b p h a s e and then back to the original s u b p h a s e . For instance, after spreading a monolayer at a given pressure, it cam be transferred to a
1^ D.B.Zilversmlt, J. Colloid Interface Set 18 (1963) 794; J.H. Brooks, F. MacRitchie, J. Colloid Interface Set, 16 (1961) 442; R.M.Mendenhall A.L. Mendenhall Jr. and H.J. Tucker Ann. N.Y. Acad. Set 130 (1966) 902; P. Somasundaran M. Danitz and K.J. Mysels. J. Colloid Interface Set 4 8 (1974) 410. 2) J.H. Brooks, B.A. Pethica, Trans. Faraday Soc. 60 (1964) 208. ^^ L. Blight. C.W.N. Cumper and V. Kyte, J. Colloid Set 20 (1965) 393. "^^ B.S. Murray, P.V. Nelson, Langmuir 12 (1996) 5973. 5^ C. Sucker, Kolloid Z. 190 (1963) 146; J. Boyle III, A.J. Mautone, Colloids Surfaces 4 (1982) 77; T. Smith, J. Colloid Interface Set 26 (1968) 509.
3.17
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
movable barriers
.jMymw.. |rz"
--ij 1
Tf^^^^ -— F^^^^"
i:z-^=r^
Yi —j 1
(a)
"^
(bl
JMUJML L
L-
_ .:=
jI
ZH-
^'■'■'.mmug :c) Figure 3.5. (a) Principle of a multi-compartment trough. It contains independent hydrophobic barriers, enclosing the film. The set-up is such that the films can either be transported (as in flg. (b), compressed or expanded. Redrawn after P. Fromherz, Rev. Sci. InstnirrL 46 (1975) 1380. The drawing is a simplification along the lines of M.C. Petty, W.A. Barlow, in Langmuir-Blodgett Films, ch. 3, G. Roberts, Ed., Plenum, 1980. s u b - p h a s e in which a reactant is dissolved so t h a t the interfacial reaction can be studied. Then, by moving the monolayer back to the original s u b p h a s e t h e reaction stops a n d the effect of the reaction on the 'original' monolayer can be assessed ^K Details a b o u t manipulations with film balances can also be found in t h e lUPAC recommendation by Ter-Minassian-Saraga, mentioned in sec. 3.10a. Finally it m u s t be noted that, although the Langmuir trough is by far t h e m o s t popular i n s t r u m e n t to m e a s u r e reliable 7t(A) curves, it is not the only one. S u c h curves c a n also be obtained with sessile drops of which the volume can be varied by externally adding or removing drop material. When the drop surface carries a n insoluble monolayer, drop c h a n g e s result in area a n d surface tension c h a n g e s which c a n be m e a s u r e d by techniques like those described in sec. 1.4. Another alternative is with oscillating hamging drops.
1^ P. Fromherz, Biochem. BLophys. Acta. 225 (1971) 382.
3.18 3.3b
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS Introduction
to 2D phase
behaviour
In this section we shall concentrate on monolayers of non-poljrmeric s u r f a c t a n t s at the air-water interface. (i)
Generalities Two-dimensional p h a s e diagrams, i.e. K{A) curves at various temperatures, are
one of the basic m e a n s for studying the rich behaviour, whether the layers are gaslike, liquid-like, solid-like, or mixed, including t h e s t r u c t u r a l t r a n s i t i o n s t h a t monolayers c a n exhibit. Let u s for the moment a s s u m e t h a t s u c h 7t(A] i s o t h e r m s have b e e n properly m e a s u r e d , t h a t hysteresis is u n d e r control, etc. By way of introduction to t h e types of p h a s e s , a n d their succession t h a t m a y b e observed, consider first the schematic picture of fig. 3.6. This way of plotting is p h e n o m e n ological; A is t h e total area. However, in describing specific examples, it is more useful to u s e the average area per molecule (C4, in nm-^), obtained a s A/N^.
Here,
N"^ m u s t be inferred from the a m o u n t of surfactant spread. If so desired, the surface concentration, F^ = n'^/A (in mole m"^) can also be reported. When there is only one component, the subscript i may be dropped. As t h e density of t h e molecules in t h e surface is gradually increased, t h e monolayer, starting from a very dilute, gaseous monolayer, may undergo a series of p h a s e transitions from a 'gas' (G) p h a s e via a 'liquid expanded' (LE), into a 'liquid condensed' (LC) and, fincilly, into a 'solid' (S) state. These transitions are not always distinct; in other systems more t h a n one condensed p h a s e may occur. The G, L a n d
'0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6 0.7 a^ I nvc?
0.8
Figure 3.6. Schematic example of a ;r(A) isotherm, exhibiting a variety of 2D phases that may be encountered. G = gas, LE = liquid expanded, LC = liquid condensed, S = solid. Curves like this are typical for lipid monolayers.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.19
S phase are the two-dimensional analogues of the corresponding bulk phases. Twophase regions may also be observed, depending on the nature of the molecules. When it is perfectly horizontal the LE+G part can be interpreted as a G-L coexistence region, see fig. 3.15. However, sometimes linear parts are observed that are not horizontcd. Then the question may be asked whether these parts are two-phase coexistence regions. The slope depends on the order of the transition; if it is firstorder, the curve should be flat. As already S2iid, more than one L or S phase may be observed, depending on the nature of the molecules. The richer polymorphism compared with 3D systems must be related to the fact that condensed 2D phases do not have the constraint of matching a 2^^, 3^^, ... etc., layer. Usually optical and/or other techniques are needed to further identify and characterize the various phases (sec. 3.7). From the kinks in the curves we can deduce the corresponding molecular cross-sectionsd areas (ct^j)- Such areas can be compared with the molecular areas found for saturated adsorbed monolayers on solids or at the air/solution interface. The slope of surface pressure isotherms is a measure of their compressibility; the steeper it is, the more difficult it is to compress the monolayer. Recall [2.11.4], where the isothermal bulk compressibility K was defined as -[dhiV/dp]^. By analogy we introduce the two-dimensional isothennal compressibility through
Two-dimensional gases are readily compressible (relatively high K^], but 2D solids have a low K^ . Similar one can define the isobaric two-dimensional expansion coefficient (also called expansivity coefficient) as
^ ]
IK-M
13.3.21
which is obtainable from surface pressure isotherms at different temperature. Like K^, this quantity is large for G-films and low for S-films. We shall return to k^, a^ and other thermodynamic characteristics of Langmuir monolayers in sec. 3.4. (ii) The gaseous state At very low molecular densities, i.e. at very low interfacial pressures, the monolayer exhibits gaseous behaviour. The molecules are far apart, but, unlike in a three-dimensional gas, they are not completely disordered. Because of their amphipolar nature, the molecules exhibit a preferential orientation relative to the surface-normal. As stated in sec. 3.1, the interfacial pressure exerted by an ideally dilute monolayer is equivalent to the osmotic pressure of an ideal three-dimensional solution. Ideal gaseous monolayer behaviour means obeying relation [3,1.1].
3.20
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
Deviation from ideal gas behaviour can be best detected by plotting 7iA vs. n, which should be c o n s t a n t for a n ideal G-monolayer. Ideal gas behaviour is observed a t Kvalues below typically 0.5 mN m - ^ This implies that, at room t e m p e r a t u r e (where kT = 4.11 X 10-21 N m), the area per molecule in the monolayer is above a b o u t 8.2 Equation [3.1.1] h a s been empirically modified to correct for excluded surface, a s follows K(A-A
where A
) = N^/CT
[3.3.31
is a n empiriccd constant accounting for the excluded area. This equation
will be discussed more fundamentally in sec. 3.4. An interesting question is whether in a 2D gas the molecules are oriented flat in the interface (as in fig. 3.7a) or have their tails out into the n o n - a q u e o u s p h a s e (as in fig. 3.7b a n d c). Situation (b) may be entropically more favourable, b u t in situation (a) the Van der Waals attraction between the tail a n d the aqueous s u b p h a s e is more favourable. Situation (a) is preferable when the toplayer is a vapour r a t h e r t h a n a n oil.
~a^S/^v/S/\ T7
A^A^A^A^
(a)
^^^^^J-^^^^^(b)
Figure 3.7. Possible orientations of amphiphilic molecules in an interface. The lower phase is aqueous, (a) Monolayer gaseous; (b), (c), (d) and (e), from liquid expanded via liquid condensed to a solid state; (f) collapse.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS (Hi) Liquid'expanded
and liquid-condensed
3.21 states
The transition from gas to solid is more complicated in a monolayer t h a n in a three-dimensional system. In a monolayer often two liquid p h a s e s are observed, a liquid-expanded (LE) a n d a liquid-condensed (LC) state, interconnected by a region where the two states coexist. Some possible molecular arrangements are presented in fig. 3.7. When there is a horizontal p a r t in the 7t{A] curve, a s for t h e (G + LE) region in fig. 3.6, one is dealing with the two-dimensional analogue of t h e 3D vapour-liquid condensation, with co-existence of the two p h a s e s . J u s t a s described by van der Waals for the 3D case. S u c h behaviour indicates a first order p h a s e transition. The pressure at which G-LE transitions occur is low, i.e., in the range of a few t e n t h s of mN m~^ Extrapolation of K from the LE part of the n{A) curve to ;r= 0 yields a limiting area per molecule of, typically, « 0.5 nm^ for single chain, s a t u r ated, u n b r a n c h e d amphiphiles. This value is m u c h larger t h a n t h a t obtained for a close-packed monolayer, b u t it is less t h a n t h a t expected w h e n t h e entire hydroc a r b o n c h a i n w a s free to move in the interface. We conclude therefore, t h a t on reaching the LE state hydrocarbon c h a i n s are partially detached from t h e s u b p h a s e . The hydrocarbon portion remaining in the interface together with the h e a d group, determines the average area per molecule in the LE state. See fig. 3.7b. It is historically interesting t h a t Langmuir ^^ proposed a n equation of s t a t e for LEmonolayers based on the a s s u m p t i o n t h a t the interfacial p r e s s u r e is composed of separate contributions from the polar groups and the non-polar groups. The polar groups are a s s u m e d to have no interaction and therefore behave gaseously, whereas t h e contribution from the apolar hydrocarbon chains, K , is given by the spreading tension (see sec. 3.2.1). Linear combination of these contributions leads to (7t-Kj{A-AJ where n
and A
= N'^kT
[3.3.4]
are empirical c o n s t a n t s . Langmuir d e m o n s t r a t e d t h a t t h e LE-
regions of a series of K[A) isotherms could be fitted to eq. [3.3.4] using a value of - 1 1 . 2 mN m ~ l for n
a n d values for A
t h a t vary linearly with t e m p e r a t u r e .
Anticipating sec. 3.4 we note t h a t [3.3.4] is at variance with a 2D Van der Waals equation of state. Upon further compression of the monolayer, a pronounced break, or discontinuity in the isotherm m a r k s a region of co-existence of the LE a n d the LC states. In most research p a p e r s it is stated t h a t n{A) still increases u p o n compression beyond the beginning of the LE-LC transition region. Breaks may be indicative of higher-order p h a s e transitions. The order of s u c h a transition d e p e n d s on the extent of co-operativity between the aliphatic c h a i n s . However, t h e p r e s e n c e of s u c h transitions is not always well established. Pallas a n d Pethica-^^ found t h a t
1 ^ . Langmuir, J. Chem. Phys. 1 (1933) 756. 2) N.R. Pallas, B.A. Pethlca, Langmuir 1 (1985) 509.
3.22
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
7t(A) remains c o n s t a n t over the entire co-existence region for a n u m b e r of systems in which they applied ultra-pure components, at not too high compression rate a n d a relative humidity between 9 8 % and 100%. Other a u t h o r s studied this region by optical techniques, s u c h a s fluorescence ^^ Brewster angle microscopy^^ or FTIR*^^ a n d were able to d e m o n s t r a t e the presence of two phases'^^. Anj^way, so far the n a t u r e of the LE-LC transition h a s not been explained unequivocally a n d satisfactorily. It is m o s t likely t h a t t h i s type of behaviour is very specific. Additional characterization of t h e properties of t h e monolayers in t h e various s t a t e s is still necessary. To t h a t end one or more of the techniques to be described in sec. 3.7 may be used. At least a variety of 2D liquid crystals have been observed. In t h e LC s t a t e essentially all the aliphatic moieties are p u s h e d o u t of t h e interface a n d interact strongly with each other (see figs. 3.7c and d). It implies a low compressibility of the LC phase, i.e. in this state the molecular area is only slightly dependent on the surface pressure. Ultimately, statistical t h e r m o d y n a m i c s c a n be invoked to i n t e r p r e t
such
transitions (sec. 3.5). (iv) Solid state and monolayer
collapse
Only a small reduction in A (but substantial increase in pressure) is needed to convert t h e LC-state into the solid (S)-state. In the S-state the s t r u c t u r e of t h e monolayer m a y be considered a s a two-dimensional crystal. Now the compressibility is essentially zero (see [3.3.1]); all the amphiphilic molecules are closely packed a n d the hydrophobic tails are aligned parallel to each other a s in fig. 3.7e. The value of a. corresponding with the S-region equals the close-packed molecular cross-sectional area. For amphiphiles with relatively small head groups, e.g. fatty acids, X-ray m e a s u r e m e n t s have shown t h a t the hydrophobic chains are oriented normal to the interface^^; a then corresponds to the chain cross-sectional area a s found for a l k a n e crystals. For monolayers of amphiphilic molecules with bulky head groups, e.g. phospholipids with phosphatidylcholine h e a d s , the hydrophobic tails are tilted, even u n d e r strong compression. Here, a
is determined by the
cross-sectional area of the (hydrated) headgroup and the tilt is necessary to obtain a close packing in the chain region, t h u s meiximizing lateral hydrophobic a n d Van d e r W a a l s i n t e r a c t i o n s . For d i p a l m i t o y l p h o s p h a t i d y l c h o l i n e
(DPPC)
X-ray
diffraction revealed a tilt angle of 30° with respect to the normal of the interface^^.
1^ M. Florscheimer, M. Mohwald, Colloids Surf. 55 (1991) 173. 2) G.A. Lawrie, I.R. Gentle and G.T. Barnes, Colloids Surf. A155 (2000) 69. 3^ B.F. Sinnamon, R.A. Dluhy and G.T. Barnes, Colloids Surf A146 (1999) 49. ^^ See sec. 3.7 for explanations of these techniques. ^^ H. Mohwald, C. Bohm, A. Dietrich and S. Klrstein, Liquid Cryst, 14 (1993) 265. ^^ G. Brezesinskl, A. Dietrich, B. Struth. C. Bohm, W.G. Bouwman, K. Kjaer, and H. Mohwald, Chem. Phys. Lipids, 76 (1995) 145
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.23
Figure 3.8. Surface pressure isotherms for DMPA monolayers as a function of temperature. Breaks at K^, a and K , a combinations are indicated. The points M and '^ s m.s c m.c '^ M' border the part where the isotherm is almost linear. Further discussion in the text. (Redrawn from O. Albrecht, H. Gruler and E. Sackmann, J. Phys. (Paris) 39 (1978) 301. Further compression of the monolayer in the S-state leads to a sharp break in the K(A) isotherm, the so-called collapse point This point indicates the onset of molecules bulging out of the monolayer, which may lead to the formation of multilayers, i.e. of a new phase. This is schematically depicted in fig. 3.7e. The collapse point occurs around K = 20-50 mN m-^ depending on the nature of the amphiphile and, particularly, on the interaction of the amphiphile with the subphase and/or super-phase. 3.3c Some representative illitstrations Before discussing the theoretical background, some illustrative examples of 7t[A) trends will now be given. The first concerns the temperature effect for a monolayer of the phospholipid DMPA (I^-a-dimyristoyl phosphatidic acid) at an air/water interface (see fig. 3.8). As the temperature is lowered the pressure at the onset of the LE-LC transition, K^ , decreases and the corresponding area per molecule, a , increases. Hence, the monolayer may change from an expanded into a condensed state when the temperature is lowered. Furthermore, the region of co-existence of the LE + LC phases shortens with increasing temperature. After lowering the temperature further, the LC-LE transition disappears; for the system of fig. 3.8 this occurs below 24''C. The LC-S transition is nearly independent of temperature; K and a being
3.24
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
primarily determined by the packing constraints of the amphiphile in the twodimensional crystalline S-state. It may be good to note here that various molecular cross-sections have now been considered. In the treatment of adsorption on solid surfaces a was introduced. Interpreting this area in terms of lattice models a is not a property of the adsorptive molecule but of the adsorbent. It is possible to imagine a situation where a greatly exceeds the real molecular cross-section. On the other hand, for mobile monolayers on homogeneous surfaces a is the real molecular cross-section or, for that matter, it is the excluded area per molecule. To avoid an undue abundance of symbols we have used the same symbol for both situations, for instance in table 3.3 in sec. 3.4e. It is to be expected that a and a , obtained by compression of m,c
*^
m.s
"^
*■
monolayers, are more similar to the a 's for adsorbed mobile monolayers on homogeneous substrates than to those for localized monolayers. Phase transitions in monolayers may be treated thermodynamically analogously to those in three-dimensional systems. As will be derived in sec. 3.4, the Clausius-Clapeyron equation, relating the variation of pressure with temperature for a two-dimensional situation, reads arj^o
[3.3.5]
TAa.
where q is the heat involved in the phase transition and Aa, ~ Aa . the difference ^
i
^
m.i
in molecular areas of the two co-existing phases. These cireas may be obtained by extrapolating to ;r = 0 those parts of the ;r(a)-isotherm corresponding to the respective phases. For a reversible isothermal process the entropy change of the phase transition follows from q, via to AS = q/T. By way of illustration, values for q and AS thus Table 3.1. Heat and entropy changes for the LC-^LE transition in monolayers of myristic acid at an air-water interface*^. AS (J K-i mol-i)
Temperature (°C)
q (kJ mol"^)
7.2
34.3
121.2
9.1
30.1
108.7
12.1
24.7
87.8
14.1
21.3
75.2
17.0
18.4
62.7
18.0
18.0
62.7
22.3
16.3
54.3
26.2
14.6
50.2
*^Data from M.C. Phillips, D. Chapman, BiocherrL Biophys. Acta 163 (1968) 30.
1
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
7
6 6
3.25
30
1. stearic acid C^y COOH 2. palmitic acid 0^5 COOH 3. myristicacid Cjg COOH
22 24 21
0.60
a^ I nvar Figure 3.9. Comparison of surface pressure isotherms for fatty acids of different chain length. pH = 2. Redrawn from (1), M. Tomoaia-Cotsiel, J. Zsako, A. Mocanu, M. Lupea and E. Chifu. J. Colloid Interface Set 117 (1987) 464; (2) N. Gershfeld ibid. 85 (1982) 28; (3) M.L. Agrawal, R.D. Neuman, ibid. 121 (1988) 353. obtained for the LC^LE transition in monolayers of myristic acid at an air-water interface are given in table 3.1. For the change from the condensed into the expanded state, heat is required to disrupt energetically favourable bonds £ind to increase disorder in the system (reflected by increased entropy). However, at lower temperatures this may be pairtially offset by the endothermal formation of hydrocarbon-water contacts. It is further worth noting that for the LC^LE transition the surface excess heat capacity change AC^ = (dq / dT] < 0. If q is plotted as a function of T it is observed that this quantity is about constant till 16°C after which it changes abruptly to a lower, but also constcint value. Such data contain interesting molecular information, and contribute to the development of molecular pictures for phase transitions. Figure 3.9 illustrates the influence of the hydrocarbon chaun length. Allowing for minor uncertainties due to slight variations in temperature for the individual isotherms we can conclude that the limiting area for a fatty acid molecule in the condensed phase (as found by extrapolation of the LC-part of the isotherm to K = 0) is slightly but significantly affected by the length of the hydrocarbon chain. It varies from 0.24 nm^ for myristic acid (C^gCOOH) to 0.28 nm^ for stearic acid (Cj^COOH). This result is consistent with expectation based on the configuration in fig. 3.7d; in the condensed state the molecules are oriented perpendicular to the interface with only a limited degree of freedom for the hydrocarbon chains protruding into the air. This slight freedom is probably responsible for the trend
3.26
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
for the cross sectional a r e a s a ^ to increase with chain length. However, the trend is not always in t h e s a m e direction, see sec. 3.8b. It is remarkable t h a t only for myristic acid is a detectable surface p r e s s u r e built u p in the expanded p h a s e . In addition to t h e positions, the slopes of the LC p a r t s of the isotherms only show little variation, if any, between the three fatty acids. According to [3.3.1], t h i s implies t h a t t h e compressibility of the monolayer in t h e c o n d e n s e d p h a s e
is
essentially invariant with chaiin length. Branching of t h e hydrocarbon chain prevents close-packing of t h e molecules in the monolayer. This is reflected in the area per molecule in the condensed p h a s e . Figure 3.10 illustrates this effect clearly. As the b r a n c h e d molecules are less densely packed, their monolayer h a s a higher compressibility. The occurrence of cis-double bonds h a m p e r s dense packing. Trans-double b o n d s do not have this effect; elaidic acid (which h a s s u c h a bond) packs like stearic acid. The effect of the cis-bond in the hydrocarbon chain is shown in fig. 3.1 l b , where it is observed t h a t in the condensed p h a s e the molecular area of C^^COOH increases from 0.28 nm^ for the fully s a t u r a t e d hydrocarbon chain (stearic acid), via 0.40 n m ^ for t h e single u n s a t u r a t e d chain (oleic acid) to 0.49 nm^ for t h e doubly conjugated u n s a t u r a t e d chain (linoleic acid). In line with this, the collapse point, i.e. t h e value for a^ w h e r e t h e monolayer b r e a k s down to form a multilayer, increases with decreasing degree of saturation. The p r e s s u r e corresponding to t h e collapse point is lower w h e n the fatty acid contains more double b o n d s (see t h e arrows in the figure). COOH ■
COOH
S 30 'Z
6
stearic acid
I1
^>. ^ 20
10 -
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
Qj / n m ^
Figure 3.10. Influence of branching on surface pressure isotherms. pH = 2; temp. 23°C. (Redrawn after F.M. Menger, M.G. Wood, S.D. Richardson, Q.Z. Zhou, A.R. Elrington and M.J. Sherrod, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110 (1988) 6797.)
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.27
1. stearic acid 2. oleic acid 3. linoleic acid
OL^M
Figure 3.11. Influence of the degree of saturation on surface pressure isotherms. All isotherms for Cj^COGH at pH = 2 and 22°C. (Redrawn from M. Tomoaia-Cotisel, J. Colloid Interface Set, 117 (1987) 464.) Figure 3.12 shows how the ;r (a )-isotherm is affected w h e n the n u m b e r of t h e h y d r o c a r b o n c h a i n s in t h e s u r f a c t a n t molecule is doubled. A m o n o l a y e r of cationic-anionic surfactant pairs, behaves phenomenologically a s if it consisted of double chain molecules; in the condensed p h a s e the molecular area more or less doubles a s compared to single chains. For the distearoyl phosphatidyl choline t h e more bulky p h o s p h a t e head group further increases the cross-sectional area per molecule. This is consistent with some tilt in the orientation of the molecules with respect to the normal of the interface (cf. sec. 3.3b, ad (iv)). In addition to fatty acids a n d phospholipids, steroids form a n o t h e r class of surfactants t h a t are often subjected to monolayer studies. As a n example a 7t(a.)isotherm for cholesterol is shown in fig. 3.13. Up to a molecular area of 0.50 nm^ the spread molecules hardly interact with each other. The limiting area in the condensed p h a s e is ca. 0.40 nm^ per molecule, which is compatible with a n orientation of t h e cholesterol molecules in t h e monolayer a s indicated in t h e inset. It is historically interesting t h a t establishing this cross-section h a s c o n t r i b u t e d to solving the structure of sterols. These examples illustrate how molecular properties affect lateral packing and, h e n c e surface p r e s s u r e isotherms. Eventually we m u s t look for explanations in t e r m s of molecular models, using a n appropriate thermodynamic a n d statisticalthermodynamic framework. This is the basis of the following sections.
3.28
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
/COOH
1. stearic acid
2. o c t a d e c y l c L m m o n i u m \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / ^ \ / \ y ' ^ '/NH; ' ^ ^3 octadecanoate / \ y \ y \ y \ y x / \ y \ y v /COO" O O-P-O/V
1, 2 distearoyl phosphatidylcholine
N(CH3)3
40 3. (4.4 M NaCl, 25°C)
30 h
20
10
Figure 3.12. Effect of chain doubling on surface pressure isotherms. (Redrawn from F.M. Menger, M.G. Wood, S.D. Richardson, Q.Z. Zhou, A.R. Elrington and M.J. Sherrod, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110 (1988) 6797; O. Shibata. S. Kaneshina, M. Nakamura and R. Matuura, J. Colloid Interface Set 9 5 (1983) 87; D.G. Bishop, J.R. Kenrick, J.H. Bayston, A.S. Macpherson and S.R. Johns. BiocherrL Biophys.Acta 602 (1980) 248.) 3.4
Monolayer t h e r m o d y n a m i c s
This section will set out the thermodynamic framework underlying the properties of Langmuir monolayers. Typically, we look for phenomenological relations (i.e. relations t h a t are not b a s e d u p o n a molecular model) between t h e r m o d y n a m i c functions characterizing the monolayer. More crudely, w h a t thermodynamic information is available a n d w h a t can be derived from it? 3.4a
(jeneral
formalism
and
definitions
The starting material is really nothing more t h a n K(A) curves at different temp e r a t u r e s . Additional evidence from spectroscopy or Volta potential m e a s u r e m e n t s is of a molecular, r a t h e r t h a n thermodynamic n a t u r e , a n d rheological p a r a m e t e r s are not characteristic for a system at rest (although it is possible to obtain certain
3.29
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
50 E 40h 30 20 10
W/-
0.40
0.60
1.0
0.80 aj / nm^
Figure 3.13. Surface pressure isotherm for cholesterol, (pH = 5.5, temperature 23.5°C) with proposed orientation at the interface. (Redrawn after Q.L. Hirshfeld, M. Seul, J. Phys. (Paris) 5 1 (1990) 1537.) rheological parcuneters from n(A) curves). Let u s a s s u m e t h a t s u c h a set of
n(A,T)
curves is available, a n d t h a t the data refer to equilibrium states, free of hysteresis. S u c h a set may look like fig. 3.8. As far a s the spread molecules are concerned, the system is dosed in the thermodynamic sense, (even if colloquially these s u b s t a n c e s aire referred to a s 'surfactants'). Upon compression or expansion they c a n n o t leave or enter t h e monolayer b e c a u s e they are insoluble in the liquid (although we continue calling it 'solvent' or 'water'). This layer is, via a barrier, sepsirated from a surface t h a t does not contain s u r f a c t a n t s . However, water molecules a n d molecules dissolved in it, including electrolytes, cam p a s s u n d e r n e a t h the barrier, so for these components the system is open.
The e n s u i n g stationary s t a t e is a typical example of a
equilibrium,
membrane
t h a t is a n equilibrium between two p h a s e s when (at least) one of t h e
components is present in one of the p h a s e s only (sec. 1.2.12). Membrane equilibria give rise to a pressure difference between the two p h a s e s . For three-dimensional systems this is the osmotic sional systems it is the surface pressure,
pressure
/ 7 , for two-dimen-
n. For osmosis the driving force is the fact
t h a t t h e chemical potential of t h e w a t e r is lower on t h e side c o n t a i n i n g t h e molecules t h a t cannot p a s s the m e m b r a n e . As a result, water is imbibed a n d this process continues until the water transport h a s resulted in a p r e s s u r e compensating n.
The driving force is primarily entropical a n d s t e m s from t h e mixing
entropy; the osmotic pressure follows from A/x = UV
, see [1.2.12.15].
By c o m p a r i s o n with Langmuir monolayers, the analogy is t h a t by confining
3.30
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
surfactants to a certciin area their entropy is reduced, leading to an expansion. Pressure exerted on the barrier is needed to counter this expansion. With respect to the water, there is both a pressure and a chemical potential difference between the molecules in the monolayer (between the surfactant molecules) arid in the bulk. Their equilibrium obeys Au = nV^ , where V^ stands for the molar volume in ^
'^w
-^
m.w
m.w
the monolayer. This equilibrium is fully equivalent to the 3D osmotic case. Obviously there is no pressure or chemical potential difference between the water underneath the monolayer and that on the other side of the barrier; the vapour pressures on both sides of a 3D semipermeable membrane, which are also the same. The closure of the monolayer for surfactants implies that upon compression expansion cycles the amount in the interface n^ is fixed. As F = n^ IA it follows that Adr + r d A = 0 [3.4.1] s
s
or dlnA + d l n r = 0
[3.4.2]
which are useful boundary conditions. Which quantities can be defined for the monolayer? First we have the three state variables ;r, A and T, the two-dimensional equivalents of the three-dimensional set p , V and T. The temperature is well-defined as being that of the underlying liquid, because layer and surroundings are in thermal equilibrium. Without further ado from the set ;r(A, T) compressibilities and expansion coefficients can be defined. Recall [3.3.1 and 2]. The 2D isothermal compressibility is
^, ^_l^ainA^
(^^r^
(m N-M
[3.4.3]
T
When only one single phase is present, it decreases with decreasing area. Its inverse (
K!=-l d
^^
I a In A
dn
ainr
[3.4.4]
is called the interfacial dilational modulus. It increases with decreasing area and plays an important role in interfacial rheology (sec. 3.6.3, eq. [3.6.19]). It is a measure of the resistsmce of the monolayer agciinst area changes, aind may be compared with the 3D case of an elastic body, for which the 3D elasticity modulus is a measure of its resilience against dilation. For free films, i.e. a water layer flainked by monolayers, the latter type of interfacial elasticity is called Gibbs elasticity (a bit confusing because we are discussing Langmuir monolayers). However, sometimes we shall also use this term for single monolayers. In certain monolayers, such as 2D protein sheets, network elasticity can cdso occur, but now as a consequence of a
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.31
change in the cross-link density. In sec. 3.6.3 we shall return to this distinction but note that as long as only the phenomenology is considered, the first equality in [3.4.4] remains the same, whatever the molecular interpretation of K^. The quantities K^ and K^ are mechanical, i.e. they can be determined without introducing the notion of temperature. The isobaric 2D expansion coefficient defined in [3.3.2]
is a thermod3niamic quantity. Regarding the energy, entropy, Helmholtz and Gibbs energies of the monolayer, some care is needed when considering the reference states. Appendix 2 reviews the differentiad and integral characteristic functions of flat monolayers. The excesses in these functions aire counted with respect to a reference state in which the two adjoining bulk phases have constant properties up to a Gibbs dividing plane. In monolayer studies the monolayer is always compared with the empty interface at the other side of the barrier. So, the (excess) energy of the monolayer is referred to the (excess) energy of the interface at the other side of the barrier; it is an excess of an excess. To keep the symbols simple we shall write LT^^^ for [/^"^ - L^^^ where LT^"" and U^^ are the interfacial excess energy of the monolayer (m) and reference (r) respectively. In the same fashion, S^^^ = S^™ - S^^, etc., and of course y^ - y^ = -n. For the chemiced potentials the situation is different. For the surfactant the chemical potential in the monolayer //™ is not defined by that in the subphase because of the absence of transport. Nevertheless, this qusintity is well-defined as the molar Helmholtz energy needed to add more surfactant to the layer; 3F^^0
an"
T,A,n?, j*s
(dF'' dn"^ s
[3.4.6] T,A,nl *'"-''j?*s
If there are other components, J ^ s, for which equilibrium is established, //J" = /^\' Parallel to this, n'" is the analytical amount of s in the monolayer, whereas ^(o) _ ^m _ ^r PQJ. j Qj^^ could think of a low molecular weight solute that might adsorb more strongly in the monolayer than at the liquid-air interface, or of an electrolyte which may be more strongly negatively adsorbed from a charged monolayer than from the reference interface. With the above in mind, the set of expressions for the integral and differential characteristic functions of monolayers can be derived. To this end the equations of appendix 2 are written twice, once for the monolayer and once for the reference state, and then subtracted. For easy reference, they are collected in table 3.2. The integral expressions follow from [A2.1, 3 and 5]; equations [A2.2 and 4] do not contadn a nA term.
3.32 Table 3 . 2 .
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS Relations between the characteristic functions of Langmuir m o n o -
layers. (For flat interfaces, the (a) equations apply to a monocomponent monolayer of surfactant s in the presence of low M solutes, whereas the (b) equations apply to the same in their absence.) a. Integral
expressions
71A = -U^""^ + TS^""^ - ^^n^ - ^
^^nj^^
KA = -LT^^^ + TS^""^ - ^^n^ KA = -F^^^ - ^^n^
- ^
[3.4.7al [3.4.7bl
^n^^^
13.4.8al
KA = -F^^^ - A/"'n"'
[3.4.8b]
nA = -Q^""^
[3.4.91
s
b. Differential
s
expressions
AdTt = dH^°^ - TdS^^^ - ^T^^T ~ X ^ j ^ ^ ^
'^•^* ^^^^
Adji = dH^^^ - TdS^^^ - ^^dn^
[3.4. lObJ
Adn = dG^^^ + S^^^dT - ^"^dn"^ - Y /i dn^^^
[3.4.1 la]
AdK = dG^^^ + S^^^dT - ja^dn^
[3.4.1 lb]
TtdA = -TdS^^^ - lu^dn^
- ^
^ .dnj^^
[3.4.12a]
TtdA =~TdS^''^-^^dn^
[3.4.12b]
TtdA = -dF^^^ + S^^^dT - l^^dn^
- ^
^^^dnj^^
TtdA = -dF^^^ + S^^^dT - ^/"'dn"' '^ s
[3.4.13a] [3.4.13b]
s
;rdA = -dr2^^^ + S^^^dT - n^d^^"^ - ^ TtdA = -dn^""^ + S^^^dT - n^'dAx"'
n^.^M//.
[3.4.14a] [3.4.14b]
In these equations the superscripts (a) and m refer to the excess in the monolayer with respect to the surface at the other side of the barrier and the absolute amount in the monolayer, respectively.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.33
We have more options for the differential expressions. From [A2.7 a n d 9] equations [3.4.10 a n d 11] are derived in the same way. Often the jj, da™ t e r m s cancel because n^
is fixed. To derive [3.4.12-14] we write the required equation of t h e
monolayer with dA a n d the corresponding one for the reference with - dA, again followed by subtraction. The set of e q u a t i o n s in the table m a y serve a s s t a r t i n g p o i n t s for further analyses. We note in passing t h a t t h e s e equations are general a n d p h e n o m e n o logical; no assumption whatever h a s been made a b o u t the properties of the surfacta n t s , n e i t h e r w a s it necessary to m a k e a restriction with respect to t h e p h a s e properties (i.e. one homogeneous p h a s e or more p h a s e s at equilibrium with each other). There w a s n o need either to m a k e special provisions for charged monolayers, b e c a u s e all double layers are electroneutral, the D o n n a n exclusion being accounted for by /^saj^dn^^^. Extension to mixed monolayers (two surfactants) is straightforward, see sec. 3.4.6. However, t h e effect of so-called line t e n s i o n s is ignored; we will come back to these in sec. 5.6. 3.4b
Some expressions
of general
validity
From table 3.2 a host of relations a n d definitions can be formulated, similar to the 3D case (chapter 1.2). By way of illustration a selection is now given. Regarding the definition of /i"^, [3.4.13] is consistent with [3.4.6]. It becomes useful, though not obviously so, if F^^^ is measurable. Generally, from [3.4.13a] [3.4.15]
dA =
J
where constancy of ri"^ is automatically realized for Langmuir monolayers, b u t t h a t of n[^^ poses a problem. For instance, if a charged monolayer is compressed, t h e surface charge density will increase a n d so will t h e c o n c o m i t a n t D o n n a n exclusion. This problem could be avoided by introducing a new variable, leading to a 'semigrand' ensemble with a /z^dn™ a n d a set of n^^^d^ terms; see sec. 3:4.7. Considering the simple case of no added solutes, [3.4.15] reduces to
n = ■
dA
(surfactant only) T.n"
[3.4.16]
T.n"
SO t h a t A
F'^iA] = F'"(A = oo)- J ;r'dA'
[3.4.17]
where n' and A are the pressure and area variable, respectively. So the Helmholtz energy is nothing other t h a n the area u n d e r the n{A) curve, starting a t the reference value for n = 0 (at large A). We note in passing that, because the p h a s e equilibrium
3.34
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
between the G and the condensed state(s) may occur at very low (barely measurable) surface pressures, yet extend to large areas, the corresponding contribution to the integal in [3.4.17] may not be negligible. In sec. 3.4c we have assumed that the lower pressure part (not so clear in fig. 3.8), obeyed the ideal 2D gas law. Upon compression F™ increases because dA < 0. So, from each K{A) curve the Helmholtz energy can be obtained at any A, that is, at any n. If such curves are available at different temperatures the entropy can also be found. From [3.4.13b] using
As F^^^ = U^*'^ - TS^^^ (compare the r.h.s.'s of [3.4.7b and 8a]) the energy of the monolayer can now also be found as r r(o) _ i7«(o) _ y
[3.4.19]
dT
This is an example of a 2D Gibbs-Helmholtz equation. For the 3D equivalents see sec. 1.2.15 where other 3D examples can be found for which 2D equivalents may also be formulated. The Gibbs energy of a pure monolayer follows from [3.4.1 lb] GHK] = C'in = 0) + j A dn'
[3.4.20]
;r'=0
which is the pendant of [3.4.17]. In [3.4.10] TdS can be identified as the heat absorbed (dq). Upon integration at given n"" A
j Ad;r = H ^ - q
[3.4.21]
A'=oo
where the l.h.s. is equal to the Gibbs energy. The relevance of [3.4.21] is primarily academic in that it shows the analogy with the 3D equivalent (G = H- TS) but in practice it is not useful because heats of expansion or compression are difficult to measure. Equation [3.4.9] may be compared with [2.2.25]. As with interfaciad tensions, the interfacial excess grand potential may play a part in the molecular interpretation of the interfacial pressure. The set of table 3.2 is also useful for the analysis of 2D phase transitions (sec. 3.4.4). Besides mentioning a number of manipulations that can be carried out with our
3.35
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
0.24 nm^ per molecule
0.2 0.25
0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 2 a I nm per molecule
0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 a / nm^ per molecule
5
10
15
20 25 TI °C
30
0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 a / nm^ per molecule
-5|-10 -15 Figure 3.14. Characteristic functions for the DMPA acid monolayer of fig. 3.8.
-20 -25; -30
-L
JL
-L
J_
0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 a / nm^ per molecule
3.36
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
set of equations, it may be a good idea to note something that cannot be done; equations [3.4.10-141 are not total differentials as defined before (sec. 1.2.14c) because, in the process of spreading, n^ can be changed externally without changing p, T or A. For Gibbs monolayers, where material equilibrium prevails, we used the total differential propensity of dU^, or whatever interfacial excess characteristic function, to derive the Gibbs equation (sec. 1.2.13) which was really an interfacial Gibbs-Duhem equation, relating the chemical potentials to each other, p, T, and 7. For Langmuir monolayers we cannot do that; we cannot, say, take the differential of [3.4.8b] and compare the result with the sum of one of AdTT cind one of the ;rdA expressions. 3.4c Application to a real system To obtain some feeling for the trends that can be obtained by subjecting ;r(A, T) data to thermod5niamic analysis, some expressions from the previous subsections will be applied to the data of fig. 3.8. The results are collected in the various panels of fig. 3.14. First the accuracy of this exercise has to be considered. Taking derivatives or slopes of (sets of) curves requires very precise data over sufficient ranges of ;r(A, T). The original data points (not shown in fig. 3.8) do not, for instance, allow computation from [3.3.1] of the compressibility K^ or its inverse, the dilational modulus, K^ = [K^T^, see [3.4.4]. First, because there are discontinuities in the isotherm (in the (pseudo-)plateaus d;r/dlnA is very small, if not close to zero). Second, because no precise data at high pressure are available; for instamce, one cannot say whether at 7t -25 mN m'^ K^ for the expanded film is higher or lower than that of the condensed one. The expansion coefficient a^ cannot be evaluated in a reliable way from [3.3.2] either, because the temperature steps in the original figure are too irregular. Figure 3.8 is often cited as one of the nicer older examples of a Langmuir monolayer; for its thermodynamic interpretation it has obvious defects and strong points. But we shall now consider how much can be achieved from these isotherms thermodynamically. Panels (a) and (b) present the Helmholtz energy F^^^ of the layer, plotted in two different ways, using [3.4.17]. F^^^ is the isothermal work to compress the monolayer from infinite area (the reference) to the state under consideration. As expected, at given T, F^^^ increases with compression (panel (a)) and at given a^ it grows with T (panel (b)). Upon entering the (pseudo-) plateau region the 7t{a^) curve has breaking points but these are not reflected in F^^\a.]\ even if n remains constant, further compression work has to be done. Panel (c) shows the Gibbs energy G^^\ obtained from [3.4.20]; this is isobaric work and therefore does show the horizontal parts. G^^^ is higher than F^^^ because of the -j;rdA term. Compare [3.4.11b with 13b]. Both are O (kJ mole-i) which is relatively low. Below it will be seen that F^^^ is the small difference between the two large quantities U^^^ and
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.37
T S^^^. Besides K , F^^^ is an important characteristic because it is a quantity that can be used to test 2D equations of state. Panel (d) gives the molar entropy S^^^ computed from [3.4.18]. (This, and the following set of curves do not contain data points because they are obtained from regression curves for F^^^; first integrating K with respect to A or In A gives sufficient reliability to allow later differentiation with respect to T.) Again, S^^\7t,a^,T] is referred to the reference state (0, oo, T). Upon compression the entropy decreases, as could be expected. That S^^^ is more negative at lower temperatures is also logical. At large a^, S^^^ is small and hardly temperature dependent. Under these conditions the gas is expanded, and in the ideal limit it should be represented by an equivalent of the Sackur-Tetrode equation. We already derived [2.9.12]; S^^^=/cN^ln| a
27rmfcTf/' te^/^ + S"" , J N"" a. com.
[3.4.22]
It refers to a thin surface volume of area A and thickness t. Incidentally, had we derived the full 2D equivalent, the number of degrees of freedom would have to be reduced by one; as a result 3/2 would become 2/2, etc. The Sackur-Tetrode term is the first term on the r.h.s. This expression cannot be rigorously valid because it requires the ideality condition, U^^^ = 0, which we cannot be sure is is satisfied, see panel (e). It follows from [3.4.22] that in this rcinge the temperature dependence is small; if expressed per mole , dS^ ~ dS^^^ = ^ R d In T, so over a temperature range of, say 30° the entropy increases by « 3R / 2 x (AT / T) « 3R / 20 = 1.25 J K"^ mol"^, hardly visible on the scale of panel (2). It is noted, however, that this is a positive entropy whereas experimentally a negative value is found. Perhaps the significance of the experimental data derived in this way should not be overemphasized. On the other hand, it is a real feature that below a^~ 0.4 nm^ molecule"^ a different process sets in. In this regime interaction starts between neighbours, with pronounced reduction of the excess entropy. Multiplication of S^^^ by T give values of 0(10 kJ mole-i), much larger than F^^'K Panel (e) shows that S^""^ and U^""^ obey similar trends. In fact, TS^^^ and U^^^ are not far apart and have the samie sign. This is the reason that F^^^ is relatively small. So, there is very distinct entropy-energy compensation. The relatively high attractive energy corresponds approximately with the attraction between the hydrocarbon groups minus a few RT per mole for the head group repulsion. Over the range studied, and given the accuracy of the data used, no sharp breaks in U^^\a^) are observed. Thermodynamic analyses, like the one discussed, require very accurate equilibrium data but have the advantage that they are phenomenological; no model assumptions are needed. Only aifter the characteristic functions have been established can models be invoked for interpretation. It appesirs that in the literature
3.38
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
this approach is largely unexploited. It would seem particularly promising to carry out such computations for monolayers of varying chain length and with different counterions. Obviously, such 'basic' data sets can always be amplified by employing one, or more, of the techniques of sec. 3.7. 3.4d The thermodynamics of phase transitions Consider two Langmuir monolayers, called a and p, in equilibrium with each other. Equilibrium requires ;r" = K^ and ^™" = 12^^ but other equilibrium conditions can also be formulated, similar to the situation in three dimensions (sec. 1.2.12). As both phases aire defined with respect to the same reference state, we do not have to worry about the distinction between U^^^ and LT™, etc. As a first example, let us discuss the change in n required to retain equilibrium when T is changed. In the 3D case the most suitable characteristic to solve this problem is the Gibbs energy, G[p, T) and in two dimensions it is logical to work with G"". At equilibrium with -da™" =dn™P = 0 application of [3.4.11b] to the equilibrium condition dG"^" = dG'"^ yields immediately (A« - A^)d7j; = (S""" - S™P)dT
[3.4.22]
or qma _ omp
A"-AP
^ ^ AA
[3.4.23]
The condition of 'isostericity' (no surfactant transfer between a and P) is not always easy to realize in practice. Equation [3.4.23] can be further simplified if one of the phases is gaseous, so that we can approximate AA = A^ - A^ == A^; ^ G ^ j^mGj^ ^ ^ replace AS"' by AH'^/T to obtain ain/r^l BT LmG
AH"' mG rDT«2 n'^^RT
[3.4.24]
which is a 2D-Clapeyron equation. Earlier, we derived Clapeyron equations for chemical equilibrium [1.2.21.11 and 12], for solubility [1.2.20.6] and for gas adsorption on solids [II. 1.3.39]. So the generality of this equation is recognized but the application in practice is not obvious, considering the approximations that had to be made. The Clapeyron equation in a slightly different form has already been used to obtain AH (or - q) and AS for the LC -^ LE transition of monolayers of myristic acid, see [3.3.5] and table 3.1. Upon the formation of two-dimensional phases a new interfacial quantity, the line tension enters the ancdysis. Phenomenologically the line tension is the onedimensional analogue of the interfacial tension. It has the dimensions of a force and acts in the perimeter of three phase contacts. When it is positive it tends to
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.39
contract the perimeter, but when it is negative it promotes extension. A difference with the interfacial tension is that the three-phase contact perimeter can be stable even though the line tension is negative. The former situation leads to phases of circular geometry, the latter to fingering. Measurement and interpretation require considerable scrutiny and will be deferred to sec. 5.6. Equation [3.4.24] does not need a line tension because changes in the states of bulk phases are considered; for the same reason the three-dimensional Clapeyron equation does not contain the surface tension. 3.4e Two-dimensional equations of state Equations of state are relations between pressure, volume, temperature and the amount(s) of substaince in the system. In the two-dimensional case the corresponding equation relates ;r to A, T and all aj's, or to the fractions 6. of the surface covered. Such equations are important for several reasons. (i) They are based on a molecular model, and as ;r(A, T, n^ ' s) can be measured, the validity of these models can be tested. (ii) When the validity of a model is established, molecular parameters become available. (iii) Equations of state are helpful to describe phase behaviour. Critical points are often sensitive characteristics of a model. (iv) With equations of state available, several mechanical and thermodynamic quantities can be evaluated, for instance the compressibility [3.4.3], the dilational modulus [3.4.4], the expansion coefficient [3.4.5] and the Helmholtz energy [3.4.17]. (v) Equations of state supplement the phenomenological equations of table 3.2; in combination with thermodynamic quantities they can give a molecular interpretation. To obtain some feeling for the kind of information that such equations offer, consider the two best known 3D equations of state. For an ideal one-component gas, containing n moles in volume V pV = nRr
[3.4.25]
and for a non-idesd Van der Waals gas, from [1.2.18.26], .2\
an ^
T7-2
\{V-nh) = nRT
[3.4.26]
in which a and b are constsints, accounting for the attraction between the molecules and their own volume, respectively. The two-dimensional analogues are TtA = n'^RT
[3.4.27]
or 71 = RTF
[3.4.27a]
3.40
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
and
[A-n^'b'') =n'' RT
n^-a
[3.4.28J
K^J
[71 +aT^)
( l - r b ^ ) = RTF
[3.4.28b]
respectively, where a^ and b^ are the corresponding 2D-constants. Below we shall d i s c u s s their derivations a n d alternatives. From t h e s e e q u a t i o n s we c a n for instance find t h a t in a n ideal monolayer,
^''-r[^l=^r.m.)
[3.4.29]
s t a t i n g t h a t t h e dilational m o d u l u s is J u s t identical to t h e surface p r e s s u r e . However, for non-ideal monolayers the relation is more complicated. For instance, from [3.4.28b] after some algebra, [3.4.30]
[l-bTf or K^ =
7r(id.)
[l-bTf
2a^r2
[3.4.30a]
Similar exercises c a n be carried out for a^, F ^ , etc. a n d for other e q u a t i o n s of state.
Figure 3.15. Sketch of a K{A) diagram according to van der Waals' two-dimensional equation of state. The temperature increases in the direction T^
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.41
It is further recalled t h a t [3.4.26] predicts p(V) plots at various t e m p e r a t u r e s . At t e m p e r a t u r e s below their critical value, T , p{V) isotherms contain so-called Van der Waals loops. Of these loops only three p a r t s are experimentally accessible, viz. those representing t h e vapour, the vapour-liquid co-existence a n d the liquid p a r t s . In physical chemistry this is familiar. Assuming [3.4.28] valid, the s a m e c a n be said for the two-dimensional case a n d n(A). Van der Waals plots m a y look like those sketched in fig. 3.15. In the lowest temperature curve the loops are sketched; t h e two h a t c h e d a r e a s are equal. With increasing t e m p e r a t u r e the co-existence range s h o r t e n s , to v a n i s h at the critical point. Above this point t h e s y s t e m is h o m o g e n e o u s a n d g a s e o u s . At the criticad t e m p e r a t u r e T
t h e horizontal co-
existence p a r t j u s t disappears. This temperature can be expressed in t e r m s of the p a r a m e t e r s a^ and b ^ ; T = ^ ^ 27b^K
[3.4.31]
If these results are compared with the general diagram of fig. 3.6 a close analogy is observed; of course v a n der Waals' picture allows for only one liquid state. (One could try another equation of state to describe the LC-LE equilibrium.) Comparison with d a t a for real monolayers (as in fig. 3.8 a n d 81) also indicates t h a t this model c a p t u r e s a t least the m a i n features, although sometimes t h e 7t{A) p a r t for coexistence is not horizontal, b u t descends with increasing A, which is a t odds with a Van der Waals loop. Historically, v a n der Waals himself did not apply h i s e q u a t i o n of s t a t e to Langmuir monolayers, b u t others did. For instance, already in 1925 Volmer a n d M a h n e r t formulated [1.1.5.23]!^ which is equivalent to [3.4.28] if t h e p r e s s u r e correction is zero a n d the excluded area constant. Langmuir's relation [3.3.4] does not agree with the positive sign of the p r e s s u r e correction for attraction between the molecules. Having t h u s established t h a t 2D equations of state play central roles in t h e analysis of n{A) curves, we shall now review the most relevant ones, leading to the anthology of table 3.3. Let u s first m a k e some general basic s t a t e m e n t s a b o u t t h e u s e of statistical t h e r m o d y n a m i c techniques. i) Equations of state do not have a thermodyncimic n a t u r e . They are b a s e d u p o n a molecular model, although, in the derivation, thermodynamic a r g u m e n t s m a y have been invoked. For this reason, the equations of tables 3.2 a n d 3.3 are complementary. ii) Statistical thermodynamics is the most adequate approach for deriving s u c h equations. Most of table 3.3, stemming from Volumes I a n d II, is derived in t h i s 1^ M. Volmer, P. Mahnert, Z. Physik. Chem. 115 (1925) 239.
3.42
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
Table 3 . 3 . Two-dimensional equations of state. One component, low MW, not too high surface coverage; (i) and (m) refer to localized' a n d 'mobile', respectively. [3.4.33]
Ideal Langmuir {£)
;ra^=-kTln(l-0)
[3.4.34]
Volmer (m)
na
[3.4.35]
Virial (m or ^)
na
FFG (^)
Tua =-kT\n{l-e) m
Quasi-chemical {£)
jia m = - f c T l n ( l - 0 ) -2- k T l n
Sc£ded particle (m)
na
=kTe/{l-e) =kT0-\-kTB^[T)G'' /a + ^wO^ 2
e-
= -kT\
+...
[3.4.37] j9-hl-20 [P + mi-O]
2AuA&f kT
[l-O^r Hill-deBoer(^) (2D van der Waals)
"^
\-6
r^c^
or
7t-\'a
[3.4.38]
[3.4.39]
[3.4.40]
a
[A-N^'a^)
[3.4.36]
= N'^kT
[3.4.40a]
K^J
6 = N^/N^[max); & is reduced surface coverage as explained in the text, w = pair interaction energy, z = co-ordination number (for lattices); a^ = surface Van der Waals constant, B'^iT) = second surface virial coefficient; y3^ = 1-4^(l-0){l-exp(-uj/fcT)}; u^ = depth of the Lennard-Jones minimum, FFG = Frumkin-Fowler-Guggenheim = Bragg-Williams; Quasi-chemical also known as Guggenheim-Bethe. lillustrative plots for several of these equations can be found in chapters 1.3 and II. 1. way. In this respect, the present subsection anticipates sec. 3.5. iii) In t h e derivations we can advantageously exploit the strategy expledned in sec. 3.1 a n d embodied in the equivalence of equations [3.1.3 and 4a]; a s the applied equation of state should be valid for the conditions for which it is derived,
and
represents a relation containing interfacial characteristics only, it does not m a t t e r by w h a t route t h e final result is obtained. Specifically, if a n equation of state is derived u n d e r the a s s u m p t i o n of adsorption equilibrium (as in a Gibbs monolayer), t h e r e s u l t r e m a i n s valid w h e n no s u c h equilibrium exists (as in L a n g m u i r monolayers). However, in the latter case the physical meaning of some p a r a m e t e r s becomes questionable. Let u s illustrate t h e last point. For Gibbs monolayers the obvious thermody-
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.43
namic starting point for an interfacial equation of state is the Gibbs adsorption equation d;r = S^dT + ^
r^d/z^
[3.4.32]
J
In this case fi is the chemical potential of substance j in the solution, and d/i can be found if activity coefficients are available. Or, if an analytical expression for /I {x ) is available, this can be substituted. For Langmuir monolayers the Gibbs equation of course remains vedid, but no progress can be made unless £in assumption is made about the dependence of the various // 's on composition. Writing djU = RTd In A^, where A^ is the absolute activity, only shifts the problem to that of defining such a two-dimensional activity ^^ The limiting case d/x = K T d l n r is exact but not helpful since it is only valid for ideal gaseous monolayers. In fact, this leads to [3.4.27al. If we remain inside the domain of thermodynamic formadism, some progress can be made by assuming that deviations from ideality can be split additively into two contributions, one stemming from the lateral surfactant interaction, the other from the limitation in the available area. The former leads to an RTlnf^^O -type contribution to ^^, the latter to a ;ra -type where a is the partial area of substance j in the monolayer. For a monolayer of surfactaints only, the former leads to a RTlnG term in /i^ the latter to a - R T l n d - ^ ) contribution^), so that the total gives rise to a ^[G) relation that is obtained statistically on the basis of localized adsorption, viz. [3.4.41], below. An advantage of such an approach is that it shows that the corresponding Langmuir-type of equation of state, [3.4.34], can also be obtained without the premise of localisation. On the other hsind, relaxing the assumption of no lateral interaction leads to more evolved jniO) relationships, for which statistical thermodynamics is more appropriate, because classical thermodynamics is entirely phenomenological. Many of the equations in table 3.3 stem from II, appendix 1. We shall briefly discuss them here. In contrast to the appendix, the area A is now written explicitly. Equation [3.4.33] needs no further comment, but the Langmuir expression, [3.4.34] does. In [I.A 1.2b] it was written as Ka =-fcTln(l-^), where a is the area of one site. m
^
'
m
Recall that the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and equation of state were derived
^^ For solid-liquid interfaces this issue was considered in sec. II.2.3e. ■^^ For a further discussion of monolayer functions of state from a thermodynamic, or pseudo-thermodynamic, point of view, see for example E.H. Lucassen-Reijnders, Progr. Surface Membr, Set 10, D.A. Cadenhead, J.F. Danielli Eds. Academic Press (1976) 253; G.L. Gaines Jr., J. Chem. Phys. 6 9 (1978) 924; S-S. Feng, H.L. Brockman and R.C. MacDonald, Langmuir 10 (1994) 3188.
3.44
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
for localized adsorption, with equal area a
for the filled a n d open sites. However,
monolayers are mobile and site a r e a s should not occur in the equations, so some re-interpretation is needed. In lattice theories a
also functions to formulate the
m a x i m u m coverage; with increasing degree of occupancy 0 the average n u m b e r of sites available to each molecule decreases till it h a s reached unity. In a fluid monolayer the equivalent is t h a t a decreases to its limiting vadue a^.. The interpretation of a . becomes less trainsparent if more t h a n one condensed p h a s e exists a n d requires further interpretation for mixtures of molecules with different sizes (see sec. 3.4.6). However, we shall interpret a
a s the area a^ where u p o n further
reduction of the area, the pressure shoots u p . In fact, one may not expect the equations of table 3.3 to hold well if this limiting area is approached. So we have a^^ = A/N'^imax) = A/N ^^n^ [max] = (r^(max)N^J-^ Hence, in the table the interpretation of a
and
0^=rj
r^(max) = rq/n''^(max).
is somewhat different for e q u a t i o n s
derived either from a localized or a mobile picture. A more basic question is whether there is any Justification for applying localized lattice theory to monolayers where one can hardly recognize sites. The s h a p e of [3.4.34] stems from the configurational part of the canonical or grand-canonical partition function, (conf) = N^\/(N^ Taking
logarithms,
applying
- N^)\N^\,
Stirling's
where N
is the n u m b e r of sites.
approximation
and
using
[3.1.3]
immediately yields {3.4.34]^^ For s u c h a monolayer the chemical potential in t h e interface is typically ^^ = ^^'^ + RT In
g ^—
[3.4.41]
i.e. it also contains the empty fraction (1-9^), Statistically, one c a n n o t distinguish between t h e configuration of empty sites a n d sites covered with a second type of molecule. In fact, [3.4.41] can also be formulated in terms of areas (total, covered by monolayer a n d empty) a n d t h e n t h e s t e p to t h e application to mobile layers becomes acceptable. O t h e r justifications are (i) t h e fact t h a t the Langmuir adsorption i s o t h e r m equation c a n also be derived kinetically, without making the restriction t h a t there are localized sites (see sec. 11.1.5a), (ii) t h a t thermodynamic derivations w i t h o u t this restriction c a n also be given (see above), a n d (iii) the experience t h a t lattice theories c a n often represent properties of liquids satisfactorily. All in all, practice h a s shown t h a t [3.4.34] often works well for coverages which are not too high, whether or not it is theoretically justified. The Volmer equation [3.4.35] is valid for a mobile monolayer, a n d should be the first option to try. Remarkably this equation of state is rarely tested. Neither [3.4.34] nor [3.4.35] a c c o u n t s for lateral attraction between t h e s u r -
'-' This stcindard procedure is described in detail in II.ch. 3.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.45
factants, so they cannot predict condensation. The FFG cind quasi-chemical equations of state are b o t h b a s e d on a lattice model, with the inclusion of a lateral interaction parameter w. For attraction w < 0, for repulsion w > 0. Equation 13.4.37] is in the Bragg-Williams approximation, where it is a s s u m e d t h a t lateral interaction h a s no consequences for the configurational entropy. The quasi-chemical approximation is better in this respect, see sec. 1.3.8a, a s is inferred from the fact t h a t it can better account for p h a s e equilibria. Scaled particle theory h a s not yet been discussed. Equation [3.4.39] is t a k e n from B a u m e r a n d Findenegg^' b u t originally dates back to Helfand et al.^K The equation is rigorous for h a r d disk-like molecules; it is combined with a m e a n field lateral L e n n a r d - J o n e s pair interaction. In this equation their a diameter of the disk, u
= Ka^/4
if a is t h e
is the depth of the Lennard-Jones pair interactions (i.e.
the m i n i m u m in fig. 1.4.1.a). In this case 6'= a T ; its m a x i m u m in a close-packed monolayer corresponds to 0' (max) = 0 . 9 0 6 . The accent e m p h a s i z e s t h i s different scaling. B a u m e r a n d Findenegg applied [3.4.39] to dilute m o n o l a y e r s of 1chlorobutane, perfluorohexane a n d fluorobenzene, adsorbed on water from the g a s phase. Finally, the Hill-de Boer equation, which is equivalent to the 2D Van der Waals equation h a s been derived in sec. Il.l.Se. Variant [3.4.40] shows t h a t it is a n extension of the Volmer expression in t h a t lateral interaction is now also accounted for. The equivalent equation [3.4.40a] is identical to [3.4.28b], except t h a t the excluded volume is now more explicit. In conclusion, with table 3.3 we have a variety of 2D-equations of state at o u r disposal, of differing sophistication. It is noted t h a t the lateral interaction between molecules in t h e s e models is accounted for by only one energetic paraimeter, w, B^ or a^. For simple molecules, or for not too closely packed surfactants this m u s t be enough, b u t more densely packed surfactants require more advanced models; we shall treat these in sec. 3.5. Therefore, none of the present set of equations is expected to remain valid close to p r e s s u r e s where condensation sets in. Prediction of p h a s e transitions is a s h a r p e r criterion for correctness t h a n t h a t for K[a) curves. The energetic p a r a m e t e r s apply to interaction a c r o s s t h e solvent a n d therefore their v a l u e s will b e different between monolayers at the LL and LG interface. Table 3.3 h a s not been systematically applied, i.e. in t h e literature for given high-quality sets of 7t(A) or 7t(6) curves the quality of the fit for all these equations h a s n o t b e e n systematically compared. So there is, for i n s t a n c e , n o definitive general answer to the question a s to whether localized models serve u s a s well a s 1^ D. Baumer, G.H. Findenegg, J. Colloid Interface Set 85 (1982) 118. 2^ E. Helfand, H.L. Frisch and J.L. Lebowitz, J. Chem. Phys. 34 (1961) 1037; see also H. Reiss, Adv. CherrL Phys. 9 (1965) 1.
3.46
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
mobile ones. Most authors compare only a few from the arsenal in table 3.3 and often add one of their own. The equations of state of table 3.3 do not generally apply to polymer monolayers. These will be dealt with in subsec. 3.4i. 3.4f Mixed Langmuir monolayers Starting from the principles described above, a variety of extensions can be formulated. Three of these will be discussed in this and the following subsections. Consider first mixed Langmuir layers, built up from the two surfactants, s i and s2. Both are insoluble, so for neither of them may ji^ be equated to fi (bulk). Such layers can only be made by spreading the mixture. Experimentally this offers some problems; the right spreading fluid should be found, no pockets' of one of the two should be formed (unless the system demixes spontaneously) and no non-equilibrium states should develop if one of the components spreads much faster than the other. Here, it will be assumed that the system obtained is fully relaxed, and that all other experimental problems are solved. For such systems the thermodynamics is readily formulated because it is entirely equivalent to that of three-dimensional (non-ideal) mixtures already treated in sec. 1.2.18. First, two-dimensional partial quantities can be introduced. For the area, A^^ = 0A/3n^J ^^c ; it represents the increase in molar area if an infinitesimal amount SI 7t,l .'ig2
of s l is added at fixed K, Tand n^_. In the same way, F"" = [dF^'/dn''.] „ a . etc., and ^si ~ ^si * ^ ^ these characteristics depend on the composition, that is, on the mole fraction 0 {= 6 = n^ /[n^ + ri^ ). For a monocomponent system we just have ^
S^
1S
A =A/n^= A ,orA = A/nf=A s
s
m
i
i
4^3
,, the molar area^^ m.i
In a mixture the average molar area A is defined as ^/(^si''"^s2^* ^^^^ quantity depends on ;:, of course. As a function of 0, A varies from A , to A ^
J
^
r-
'
m
m.sl
m,s2
A possible trend is given by the solid curve in fig. 3.16. This case may be expected for monolayers where molecules s l and s2 attract each other. The linear crossing (dashed line) refers to ideal mixing, i.e. to additivity of the individual areas A =(1-6>)A ,+9A , [3.4.42] m
^
'
m.sl
m.s2
Deviations from additivity depend on the natures of s 1 and s2 and on it. For low K the system is nearer to ideality and the additive approximation is better (or, in the limit, completely) obtained. The trend is for deviations to grow with n. An illustration is the mixture of octadecanol and docosylsulfate at temperatures between 288 and 318 K. The substrate was a 0.1 M KCl solution to suppress the solubility of the
^^ Note that we use here a different notation from that in [II.2.4.38]; there we used a's for molar area.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.47
An
An.s2
An (ideaU^ ^ ^
^"^^^^A^ ^2
An,sl ■Al
OB
J^
(1-0B)
e Figure 3.16. Possible dependence of the molar area in a binary Langmuir monolayer on composition, K and Tare fixed. A and A are the partial areas of s i and s2 in point B. a n i o n i c ^ \ (See table 3.7a for t h e n a m e s of organic surfactants.) In principle, u p w a r d deviations, reflecting repulsion between the surfactants, aire also possible, b u t if these become too strong the entropy of mixing can no longer compensate a n d p h a s e separation ensues. To describe the real curve, in [3.4.42], the (constants) A
, and A
^ have to be
replaced by the (composition-dependent) partial values A^^ and A^^ ^m=(l-«)Ai+^^s2
13.4.431
In the figure, A^^ a n d A ^ can be evaluated from the dotted tangent at B. This is a familiar construction in thermodynamics; it is t h e two-dimensional equivalent of fig. 1.2.6. By a similar procedure the two chemical potentials are obtained from t h e Gibbs energy. For any 0 ju^f0) = G^ - 0
[3.4.44al
30
A^sy^) = ^ ^ ^ ( i - ^ )
dG ^ \
de
[3.4.44b]
7C,T
Generally, G^ consists of three parts: (i) t h e s u m of t h e chemical p a r t s contributed by each component, (1 - 0)G^^ + 9G^^, where t h e molar values of G^, a n d G^„ are identical to t h e two chemical s2
si
s2
potentials //^^ and ji^^ for the monolayers consisting of p u r e s i a n d p u r e s2, at t h e given n and T, respectively. 1) I.S. Costin, G.T. Barnes, J. Colloid Interface Set 6 4 (1978) 111; K.J. Bacon, G.T. Barnes, ibid 67 (1978) 70.
3.48
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
(ii) a contribution of the entropy of mixing, RT(1 - 0) ln(l -6) + RTO In 0. (iii) an excess term G^^ accounting for non-ideality. This last one is usually the most interesting and the most esoteric. Basically, obtaining G^^ is beyond thermodynamics. Some empirical expressions appesir to be fairly general, e.g. G^ =e[l-e)w''
[3.4.45]
where w^ is an empirical surface lateral interaction parameter, independent of 6 but dependent on T. In bulk, equation [3.4.45] gives rise to so-called regular solutions. Monolayers obeying it may be called regular monolayers. However, given the amphipolar nature of surfactants it is unlikely that only one interaction parameter suffices to describe lateral interaction; at best [3.4.45] is a first approximation. With G° established over the entire range of 0, conditions for phase separation can be formulated. When G^^ < 0 the G^ [9] curve is concave (it has a minimum like that of A in fig. 3.16) but in the opposite case it may exhibit a maximum, separating two minima, (as in fig. 1.2.9 for the three-dimensional equivalent) leading to demixing. The critical G^^ for incipient phase separation follows from the criteria (d^G o de'
f^^QC
^
=0
de'
T
\
=0
[3.4.46]
T
For regular solutions we derived [1.2.19.8] w^ =2RT, for the critical point. As expected, w^ >0 (repulsive), and stronger repulsion is needed to achieve demixing if the temperature is higher. Finally, once G^ [0] is available as a function of temperature, H^ and S^ can be immediately obtained using the appropriate Gibbs-Helmholtz relationships S^ = -OG^ / dT) a. = -OF^ / dT)^ a, , etc. compare [3.4.18 and 19]. 'A.nr
3,4g Half open Langmuirmonolayers This term will be used for Langmuir monolayers containing additional molecules, adsorbed from the liquid substrate. Phenomenologically speaking, the monolayer is now 'mixed Langmuir-Gibbs'. Such systems cire of practical relevance. They are for instance encountered when reactions with monolayers occur, when studying pervaporation and other transfer processes of low MW molecules, and when the double layer is charged. In the latter case, when the head groups are weakly acidic, as with fatty acids, H^ and/or OH" ions desorb/adsorb, depending on the pH of the solution. Even for monolayers of strongly dissociating surfactants, transport of electrolyte takes place. Remember that charged surfaces exhibit negative adsorption of electroneutral electrolyte, the so-called 'Donnan exclusion' (sees. II.3.5b and 7e). In fact, ionized monolayers are often made on substrates containing concentrated electrolytes, to reduce the solub-
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.49
ility of t h e s u r f a c t a n t s . Charged monolayers will b e considered in t h e following subsection. The 'half-openness' h a s no consequences for the application of our formal thermodynamics. The equations in table 3.2 are general a n d r e m a i n valid. The only differences are that: (i) for t h e species j for which adsorption equilibrium with the b u l k is e s t a b lished, t h e chemical potential ji^ may be equated to ^^(bulk), and (ii) for s u c h species, adsorption will genercdly also take place a t the reference interface on the other side of the barrier, so t h a t n™ m u s t be replaced by n^^^, the phenomenological excess defined in sec. 3.4.1. We shall not rewrite all t h e equations for this new case b u t will simply give one illustration. Suppose the layer contains one insoluble surfactant a n d one soluble molecule j a n d consider [3.4.13a]. This equation is now modified into TTdA = -dF^^^ + S^^^dT - jU^'dn"' - jU dn^^^ s
s
'^ j
[3.4.47}
J
The chemical potential jj, does not need a superscript because it is the s a m e everywhere; it c a n now be written a s n^ + RTlnfx RT ]
where / . a n d x are t h e activity
coefficient aind mole fraction in solution. 3.4h
Ionized
monolayers'^
A variety of a u t h o r s have paid attention to the question of how the charging of a monolayer affects the (Helmholtz or Gibbs) energy, a n d hence the interfacial pressure. (See for instance refs.'^'*^'^'^'^^) Thermodynamics can help to answer some of the basic questions t h a t have given rise to unnecessary confusion in the literature. The first is; does dissociation of the monolayer lead to a n additional t e r m F^^'Hel) to F^^^ or G^'^Hel) to G^^'K depending on whether ;r or A is fixed? The answer is no. Thermodynamically one cannot state anything a b o u t the positions a n d distributions of ions in a monolayer, no more t h a n a b o u t any s p o n t a n e o u s charge separation t h a t may take place. Given a monolayer at fixed p , T, A, ;r, n^^^'s, n a t u r e itself t a k e s care of the orgainization of the system, which will proceed in s u c h a fashion t h a t F^^^ (or G^^^) attains a minimum. The resulting F^^^ depends on the distribution of segments, head groups, charges of the counter - aind co-ions. At best, one can try and sequester part of F^^^ and call it F^^Hel); the remaining p a r t is
^^ In this subsection we consider the notions of charged monolayer, ionized monolayer and dissociated monolayer as synonymous, although the term ionized' is preferred over charged' because monolayers are not externally charged. 2^ J.T. Davies, Proc. Roy. Soc. A208 (1951) 224; J. Colloid Set 11 (1956) 377. 3^ Th.A.J. Payens, PhUips Res. Repts. 10 (1955) 425. "^^ G.M. Bell, S. Levine and B.A. Pethica, Trans Faraday Soc. 58 (1962) 904. ^^ S. Hachisu. J. Colloid Interface Set 3 3 (1970) 445. ^^ R.O. James, Colloids Surf. 2 (1981) 201.
3.50
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
then F^^^ (non-el); pia] ^ p(a)(^i) ^ F^^Hnon-el)
[3.4.48]
This subdivision is as un-operational as trying to split electrochemical potentials into electric and chemical parts (see sec. 1.5c). There is only one case where F^*'^(el) comes on top of F^^^ and that is when an electric field is applied externally. This is for instance the case for monolayers on mercury, where the mercury can be polairized^^ We shall not consider this case. If we do write F^^^ in two terms, the second question is whether F^^^(el) is positive or negative. The answer is again unambiguous; F^^Hel) < 0 because the double layer forms spontaneously. The sign of the contribution of ;r(el) to TT can be inferred from [3.4.15]; mostly it is positive, depending on the way in which chairge and potential are related. Can one write a general expression for F^^\e\)? No, because the result depends on the way in which the charge is distributed which, in turn, depends on the nature of the monolayer, n, c , pH and other variables. However, one can solve the problem analytically for some limiting cases. Below we shall analyze one of these to indicate how to proceed. Consider a purely diffuse chairge distribution. Let the head groups be strong, all of them positioned in the same plane where the potential is y/^. Surface pressure and area are fixed. Now F^''\e\] = F"'(el)- F'^^(el), with F"" the Helmholtz energy of the charged monolayer, and F^^^ the same for the solution-air interface on the other side of the barrier. We note that in almost all theories the latter contribution is forgotten; indeed such double layers are not 'strong' but not always negligible, see sec. 11.3. lOf. Now we are concerned with F™(el). This quantity is found by applying a charging process similar to that used for solid-liquid interfaces (sees. 1.5.7 and II.3.4). Let us start with the uncharged state; all protons (or sodium ions) are bound to the head groups. Spontaneous dissociation ensues. The driving force is the difference in chemical potential of the protons between the adsorbed state and in the solution, A;t/^+. Assume for the moment that this amount is the same for each ion. Then for N ions the Helmholtz energy gain is NAjii^+ (in the present situation Helmholtz and Gibbs energies are almost indistinguishable). Upon charging, or rather charge-separation, a potential difference is created. The electrical work of withdrawing protons against this potential is AF(charging) = J v/^^'dcx^'
[3.4.49]
1^ T. Smith, Monomolecular Films on Mercury, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 3 (1972) 164. (This paper does not discuss the above charging issue thermodynamically.)
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.51
where v^° and a^' are the (variable) surface potential and (variable) surface charge during the charge separation, respectively. This Helmholtz energy is positive because y/^ and <7° are both negative; had [3.4.49] been the only contribution, no charge separation would take place. The process continues till for the last proton to dissociate, AjU^+ equals -z^ey/^, the counteracting electric attraction. So r^+A;U^+ = -<7°v^°, if r^+ is the number of protons per unit area that is dissociated. This is the chemical contribution, AF(chem) to F™(el). The total is F"^(el) = J v^°'dcj°'-(jV°=- j cj°'dv^°' a°'=0
[3.4.50]
v/°'=0
where we have used the definition of partial differentiation. Note that F™(el) is negative, as it should be for a spontaneous process. In this derivation we tacitly assume that the double layer is diffuse; nowhere did we worry about the fact that some counterions remain closer to the surface than others, i.e. that there is a certain potential- and countercharge distribution. As long as the system is ideal in the sense that at any position in the double layer the number of ions per unit volume and the potential are given by the Boltzmann equation there is indeed no need for worry. This is typical for a diffuse double layer. Yet another assumption has been made in passing, viz, that A^^+ remained constant during the charge separation. For solid particles, as considered in DLVO theory, this is an acceptable approximation, but for monolayers it is less satisfactory because the charging of the head groups may lead to the redistribution of the surfactant layer. For some double layer sketches, see fig. 3.17. Panel (a) applies to a G-monolayer with protons as the sole counterions. In this case (T° = aFF where a is the degree of dissociation (a = 0.75 in the sketch). For a fully dissociated monolayer (j° is known. When the countercharge is diffuse y/^ is also accessible because now [II.3.5.14] may be used with y^ and a^ replaced by L/° and a°;
y° = I ln[-pcT° + V(P^°)2+1
[3.4.51a]
where L/° = Fy/^/RT and p = {Se ec RT)^^^ where c is the (z - z) electrolyte concentration. This is rigorous provided the double layer is smeared out, which is a good approximation as long as the distance between the surface charges is «K~^. Panel (b) pictures the case corresponding to that of double layers with a chargefree Stem layer, considered in sec. II.3.6c. To indicate that the counterions, say Na^ ions, retain their hydration shells they are given a bigger volume. For the diffuse part L/^ = Fy/^/RT is obtainable from
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.52
( a ) Low K countercharges = point charges
^ y/O y/d
^
^
^
^
^
^
^^m
( b ) Higher K (hydrated) counterions have finite radius
( c ) Still higher jt part of counterions dehydrated and between head groups
Figure 3.17. Pictorial representation of some potential distributions across monolayers. Co-ions ignored. Discussion in the text.
z
-PCJ^ + V(pCT^)^+l]
[3.4.51b]
with (j^ = - a ° . In this situation there is no unambiguous way of establishing y/^. In these two cases F"^(el) can also be expressed, using [11.3.5.20]. (In passing, since we are considering monolayers at given K, A and F , the distinction between F™(el) and G^(e\) is negligible.) The results are
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
F"^(el) = - 8cRT
cosh
F™(el) = - 8cRT
cosh
3.53
'zy^^
'zy<^
-1
I3.4.52al
-1
[3.4.52b]
for cases (a) and (b), respectively. In many equations of state found in the literature, [3.4.51 and 52] are proposed. Except for low n such equations are not expected, or indeed found, to be satisfactory. In chapter II.3 many examples have been given, delimiting the domain of applicability of diffuse double layer models to low potentials and charges. Panel (c) depicts one of the many situations that may cirise at still higher surface pressures. It is assumed that the layer has not yet collapsed but that the strong lateral repulsion between the head groups is still partially relieved by positioning some of them more inward than others and by intercalation of counterions. These have lost their hydration shells, indicated by small circles with positive charges in the figure. General statements about the chcirge- and potenticd distribution can hardly be made; neither v^° nor v^*^ is unambiguously accessible, see sec. 3.7.6 for further discussion. For an example of a triple layer elaboration see ref. ^\ An intermediate situation between cases (b) and (c) is that of a Stem layer with specific adsorption, for which the general charging formalism is available from sec. II.3.6f. The result is, see [II.3.6.65], F'"(el)=-
8cRT 2C!
cosh
-1
[3.4.53]
where Cj and C^ are the differential capacitances of the inner and outer Helmholtz layer, respectively. Generally, these capacitances are adjustable. With regard to the charges and potentials; the specifically adsorbed charge a^ does not enter the equations because of the charge balance cr° + cr* -H a^ = 0; a^ and y^ are related via [3.4.51b]; sometimes y^ can be assessed if electrophoretic mobilities are available of air bubbles, stabilized by a monolayer identical to that under study, setting C, and a° can in favourable cases be obtained as aFF . ¥ 3.4i Polymer monolayers The possibility of chain parts protruding into the solution makes polymer monolayers more complex than those of small molecules. These protruding chain parts (loops, tails) may also contribute to the surface pressure, the extent of which depends strongly on the conditions. Figure 3.18 sketches a number of possible scenarios. 1) V.V. Kalinin, C.J. Radke. Colloids Surf. A114 (1996) 337.
3.54
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
''crit
(a]
(c )
mushroom'
■ b)
'high coverage'
(d:
'pancake'
'brush'
Figure 3.18. Monolayers of physisorbed homopolymers at low coverage (a and b) and at high coverage (c). Diagram (d) shows a so-called brush of end-attached chains at high grafting density, where the hairs are forced to stretch. In fig. 3.18a and b two situations are depicted where the coverage is so low that the individual chains do not feel' each other. When the affinity of the segments for the interface (as expressed by the adsorption pairameter x^ * defined in [II.5.4.1]) is very close to the critical value x^^^^ the typical chain conformation is that of a perturbed coil, sometimes called a mushroom. As soon as Ax^ ^ X^ ~ Zcrit exceeds a value of order I V N , where N is the number of segments per chain, the chain conformation is essentially flat, and is often denoted as a pancake (fig. 3.18b). In this limit of isolated chains, the ideal equation of state [3.4.33] still holds both for mushrooms and pancakes; 7cA = N^kT or ;r = {N^/A)kT = FRT, where (N^/A) = rN^^ is the number of chains per unit area. For polymers, the segment density is much higher than the chain density N^/A because the N^ adsorbed chains contain a total number of NN^ segments, where N is often high. It is customary to express the adsorbed amount NN^/A of segments in terms of equivalent monolayers; G = NN^a /A, where a is the cirea per segment and 0 is unity when the amount present at the interface corresponds to a close-packed layer with the thickness of one segment. In general, the polymer segments have a certain distribution in the direction perpendicular to the interface. We express the distance z from this interface in
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.55
terms of segment lengths (hence, z is dimensionless), a n d define 0(z] a s the average volume fraction of segments at distance z. Then 0 is equal to t h e integral over
G{z)\ 0 = JG(z)dz. In the situations shown in fig. 3.18a a n d b , 0 is quite low. With N^/A = 0 / ( N a ^ ) the ideal surface pressure can then be written a s 7ta^=kT0/N
[3.4.54]
Hence, t h e surface pressure a t a given (low) value of 0 is inversely proportional to the chain length. For high N the ideal gas region t h u s corresponds to extremely low surface pressures. As t h e coverage increases, this ideal expression no longer holds. Analogous to [3.4.36], a virial expansion c a n be used to account for deviations from ideality; ^«^ kT
0 N
K a
0^2 2^...
N^ + B!N2 J71 L = iL_ kT A 2
N° A
\2
+ ...
[3.4.55a, b]
Equation [3.4.55b] m a y be compared with its monomeric analogue (N = 1) a s given in [3.4.40a]. When the monomers have no other interaction t h a n t h a t caused by t h e e x c l u d e d v o l u m e (i.e., w h e n a^ = 0), [3.4.40a] m a y b e e x p a n d e d to give n/kT
= N^+a
(N^/Af".
Hence, for m o n o m e r s t h e second virial coefficient is
coupled to t h e molecular area. For the three-dimensional case we discussed this in [1.3.9.13]. T h e s a m e h o l d s for polymers, b u t n o w B^N"^,
t h e s e c o n d virial
coefficient, accounting for t h e lateral interaction between chains, corresponds to the area of t h e entire chain, which is m u c h larger t h a n a , the area per segment. When attractions play a role ( a ^ > 0), these also show u p in the term contciining t h e second virial coefficient (compare sec. 1.2.18 for a Van der Waals-gas), making t h e effective excluded volume smaller. For gases there is a so-called Boyle point where B^ is zero, for polymers t h e second virial coefficient v a n i s h e s u n d e r ideally poor solvency conditions, usually referred to a s 6)-conditions. For polymers there is t h e additional complication t h a t t h e point where the second virial coefficient monomers
between
vanishes, does n o t completely coincide with the point where t h e second
virial coefficient between
chains is zero (except in t h e limit N -^ oo); we refer to t h e
literature ^^ for these subtleties. In good solvents we t h u s have B^N^ = R^, where R is either t h e r a d i u s of t h e m u s h r o o m (roughly equal to the radius of gyration in solution) or of t h e p a n c a k e . In t h e f u r t h e r a n a l y s i s , we c o n c e n t r a t e on t h e p a n c a k e s . From
computer
simulations aiid scaling a r g u m e n t s ^^ it is known t h a t for a two-dimensional chain R-
N^^"^. This exponent is between t h a t for a three-dimensional chain in a good
solvent (R- N^^^) a n d a one-dimensional excluded-volume chain (which is a rod
^^ P.G. de Gennes, Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics, Cornell Univ. Press (1979).
3.56
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
with R-'N). Hence, for pancakes in a good solvent B^ is expected to scale as {R/Nf ~N-^/2. At still higher coverage, as depicted in fig. 3.18c, virial expansions become impractical as the higher-order terms dominate. The chains now overlap and a concentration profile 6(z] develops which is more or less homogeneous in the lateral direction. The total coverage 0 = 11 9{z) may well exceed one (or even several) equivalent monolayers. For physisorbed layers of a homopolymer (as in fig. 3.18c), the train layer of segments in contact with the air gives the leading contribution to ;r, as we shall show below. However, for brushes (fig. 3.18d) the contribution of the entire layer must be considered; we shall discuss brushes in subsec. 3.4]. For situations of overlapping chains, where lateral fluctuations in the segment concentration become rather small, mean-field descriptions become appropriate. The most successful of this type of theory is the lattice model of Scheutjens and Fleer (SF-theory). In chapter II.5 some aspects of this model were discussed. This theory predicts how the adsorbed amount and the concentration profile 6(z) depend on the interaction parameters x^ ^^^ X ^^^ o^ the chain length N. From the statistical-thermodynamic treatment the Helmholtz energy and, hence, the surface pressure K can also be obtained. When K is expressed as a function of the profile 0(z), the result may be written as^^
^
^
z
z
z
[3.4.56]
Here, ^^ is the segment concentration in the bulk solution, and {6(z)) the contact fraction of a site in layer z with its neighbouring sites. For example, in a simple cubic lattice where each site has six neighbours, four of them being in the same layer, (0(z)> is given by [e(z - 1) -h 40(z) + 6(z +1)1 / 6. Note that x^ does not explicitly enter [3.4.56]. The effect of x^ is indirectly accounted for through its influence on the profile 6(z]. As a matter of fact, [3.4.56] is not an exclusive result of the SF-theory; earlier polymer adsorption models such as those of Roe^^ and Helfand*^^ give exactly the same form for TT as a functional of the profile, although these theories predict a different profile as a function of x^ and X (and, hence, lead to different numerical results for K). Equation [3.4.56] may be considered as the lattice version of a density functional. This equation does not only apply to adsorbed homopolymer layers, but it is also valid for brushes (where 1^ J.M.H.M. Scheutjens and G.J. Fleer, J. Phys. Chem. 83 (1979) 1619; G.J. Fleer, MA. Cohen Stuart, J.M.H.M. Scheutjens, T. Cosgrove and B. Vincent, Polymers at Interfaces, Chapman and Hall (1993), equation [4.2.75]. 2) R.J. Roe, J. Chem, Phys. 60 (1974) 4192. ^^ E. Helfand, Macromolecules 9 (1976) 307.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.57
the 0{z) profile is quite different). In the latter case the bulk concentration 6^ may be set at zero. It is instructive to consider some limiting cases of [3.4.56]. For monomers (N = 1) in an athermal solvent ix =0), only the logarithmic term remains; the sum reduces to the term for z = 1 (trains). For dilute solutions (6^ « 1), we thus obtain 7ta^ =kTln(l-6^), which is identical to the Langmuir expression [3.4.34] with 0 = 6{1) = 6. For monomers in a poorer solvent (where multilayers may form due to attraction between the monomers) the layers z > 1 also give a contribution, according to the last term on the r.h.s. of [3.4.56]. For polymeric species (N » 1) , we first consider very low coverage in a good solvent ix =0). Now the logarithm may be expanded up to the linear term, which then exactly cancels the term -1 in the first term on the r.h.s. The result for 0^ « 1 is Tia = kTO/N, which is again the ideal contribution [3.4.54]. The same holds for a theta-solvent ix =1/2), where now the logarithm should be expanded up to the quadratic term; this quadratic term cancels against (1/2)S 9^(z) from the last term in [3.4.56], obteiined by approximating {6[z)) = 9{z). In a similar way, a virial-type expansion as in [3.4.55] is recovered from [3.4.56]. In a good solvent the quadratic term is the leading one for N »1 and low 0 (but with 9» N~^]; TT ~ E 6{z]^. In a theta solvent the quadratic term vanishes (as long as (Oiz)) may be replaced by 6], and K ~ ^^0{zf for low 0 (but with 0 » N~^^^). In both cases the term for z = l (i.e., the train contribution) dominates for physisorbed polymers. For higher surface concentrations this expansion of ln[l-0(z)] is not allowed for z = 1, 6(1] = 0^. Now we have to retain the logarithm for the train layer. Moreover, in the steep concentration gradient we may no longer use {6^) = 0^\ instead we approximate (6^) ^ X^O^, where A^ = 4 / 6 in a simple cubic lattice. Now a reasonable approximation of [3.4.56] reads na n
/cT
4l^-^]^-'4-^]-Kxel
I3-4-571
VN
Hence, the main contribution to n stems again from the trains. Loops (and tails) substantially contribute to the adsorbed amount 6), but not much to the surface pressure K. We briefly comment on some other treatments. One of the oldest precursors comes from Singer ^^ who applied lattice theory but assumed all segments to be restricted to the train layer. Frisch and Simha^) presented a model accounting for loops and tails in addition to trains, using random-walk statistics with a Boltzmann factor for train segments. However, their statistical treatment is incorrect IJ S.J. Singer, J. Chem. Phys. 16 (1948) 872. 2) H.L. Frisch and R. Simha, J. Chem. Phys. 27 (1957) 702.
3.58
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
b e c a u s e in t h e evaluation of the partition function the conformations crossing the interface are not discarded (as should be done) b u t retained as reflected conformations. Lucassen-Reynders a n d Benjamins^'-^^ derived a n equation for protein monolayers, considered to be purely two-dimensional. The protein molecules are treated a s discs of molecular area a
, floating in a solvent (water) of molecular area a
.
Lateral interaction is accounted for in terms of a partial molar heat of mixing H , related to w in the FFG equation [3.4.37] or x in the Floiy Huggins picture. Their equation r e a d s —nL = L ^ n _ _ l 0 _ i n i - m - _ i i L ^2 kT \a \ ^ ^ RT
[3.4.58]
Although their premises are r a t h e r different from those considered above for flexible c h a i n s , t h e similarity between [3.4.57] a n d [3.4.58] is striking. The ratio a
la
may be set equal to N, which in a lattice model is the ratio of the molar
c h a i n volume a n d t h e molar solvent volume. The t e r m s - 0 , which is t h e Gibbs excess term, and ln(l - G) due to the mixing entropy (excluded volume) in the surface layer, occur in both models. In both cases the quadratic term a c c o u n t s for lateral interaction, whereby the p r o d u c t A j in [3.4.57] m a y be considered a s a 'twodimensional' / - p a r a m e t e r , which in the Flory-Huggins model is t h e enthalpy of interaction divided by the thermal energy, see sec. 1.3.8c. Clearly, the difference between the two models is t h a t [3.4.57] is a two-dimensional simplification of the more general [3.4.56], where the contributions of the segments outside the train layer are m a d e explicit. This is especially important for b r u s h e s , which we shall discuss in the next section. 3Ai
Brushes
A simplified picture of a b r u s h is shown in fig. 3.18d. On a solid surface s u c h a s SiOg, the c h a i n s can, in principle, be end-grafted on the surface by some chemical procedure. However, at a n a i r / w a t e r interface this is clearly impossible. In t h i s case a b r u s h may be obtained by spreading a block copolymer containing a small b u t highly insoluble block a n d a long hydrophilic block. An example of s u c h a brush-forming c h a i n is a PS-PEO block copolymer, where t h e hydrophobic poly(styrene) (PS) block floats on the surface a n d serves a s a n a n c h o r preventing the soluble poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) tails to escape towards the bulk solution. This is a prime example of a Langmuir monolayer; there is no exchange with t h e b u l k solution a n d the b r u s h region can be treated as a separate phase. Obviously, at low
1^ E.H. Lucassen-Reynders. Colloids Surf 91 (1994) 79. '^^ J. Benjamins and E.H. Lucassen-Reynders, in Proteins at Liquid Interfaces, D. Mobius, R. Miller, Eds., Elsevier (1998) 341.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.59
coverage no b r u s h e s develop; the individual molecules form m u s h r o o m s or p a n cakes, depending on x^ of the soluble moiety. For PEO x^ is high e n o u g h to p r o m o t e p a n c a k e formation. A b r u s h is formed only w h e n the coverage is increased, for example by compressing the monolayer in a Langmuir trough. When the layers are compressed (far) beyond the point where the p a n c a k e s overlap, t h e soluble c h a i n s are forced to stretch into the solvent and layers are formed of which the thickness m u c h exceeds the radius of gyration of isolated coils in solution. The b r u s h t h i c k n e s s is a function of the c h a i n length a n d t h e coverage, a n d also d e p e n d s on the solvency. The b r u s h s t r u c t u r e (outside the train layer) is hardly affected by ;^^. There is now a v a s t a m o u n t of literature a b o u t b r u s h e s , comprising scaling theory, analytical self-consistent-field models, n u m e r i c a l lattice d e s c r i p t i o n s s u c h a s the SF-model, and Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulations. It is well established t h a t the concentration of polymer s e g m e n t s in a b r u s h is n o t homogeneous, a s p r e s u p p o s e d in initial scaling descriptions. For example, in a good solvent the profile 6(z] of segments h a s approximately a parabolic s h a p e ; it decays roughly a s 0(z) = 6^(\-z^
/ H ' ^ ) , where 0^ is t h e volume fraction a t t h e
interface a n d H is a p a r a m e t e r t h a t may be identified a s t h e 'thickness' of t h e b r u s h . As in the previous section, we u s e dimensionless distances z a n d H by expressing them in u n i t s of the monomer length. The values of 0^ and H depend on the length N of the hairs and on the grafting density a =
N^/A.
Nevertheless, a simple scaling a r g u m e n t for a box-like profile given by e(z) = 6
for
0
shows all the proper trends predicted by more advanced (and more complex) models a s to the dependence of the b r u s h thickness H a n d the surface p r e s s u r e n on t h e p a r a m e t e r s N and a. Therefore we restrict ourselves here to this simple scaling description. We define the grafting density a and the b r u s h concentration 6 by a = ^—= —^ A Na
e =— = —2i_ H H
[3.4.59a,b]
m
where 0 = Na a is t h e n u m b e r of equivalent monolayers in t h e b r u s h a n d a^ is again the area of a monomer. For a tj^ical b r u s h with long hairs, 0 is m u c h higher t h a n unity. The dimensionless grafting density a o" is (much) smaller t h a n unity. The theoretical m a x i m u m of one c h a i n per segmental a r e a a^ c o r r e s p o n d s to a G = 1, 6 = 1 and 0 = N, which would m e a n no solvent between the hairs a n d fully perpendicular chains. The b r u s h thickness is determined by the balance between the stretching energy of the c h a i n s a n d the osmotic interactions. The probability distribution of a G a u s s
3.60
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
chain with a distance r between its endpoints is P(r) - exp(-3r^/2K^) where R- N^^^ is the average end-point distance of an unperturbed coil. We discussed Gauss distributions before, see [1.3.7.14]. The entropy loss for a chain stretched to a distance r = H between its end points is AS = k ln[P(H) / P{R]] « -kH^/R'^ = -kH'^/N; as is customary in scaling descriptions we omit all numerical coefficients and we assume H » R. The elastic Helmholtz energy of stretching is given by F^^ - -TAS. For a brush consisting of iV*' chains we then have -M^ = f^^ELkT N
[3.4.60]
Obviously, F ^ increases with increasing brush thickness H, i.e., with increasing degree of stretching. The osmotic interactions depend on the solvency. In a good solvent only the bare excluded volume (of the order of the segment volume) plays a role. In a homogeneous environment of volume fraction (p this leads to a contribution (1 - 2x)(p per segment (in /cT units). If we set X -^ ^^^ replace (p by 6, the osmotic free energy is equal to NOkT per chain or N^'NOkT for the brush. Substituting e = Najj/H according to [3.4.59b] we find for a good solvent - ^ ^ = N^'a a^^ fcT "^ H As expected, F ^
[3.4.61]
decreases as the brush thickness increases (i.e., when the brushes
osm
become more dilute). The dependence of H on N and G is found by minimizing F^^ + F^^^ with respect to H for constant JV, cr and N''; OF / dH)^ f^<^ c^^' H = N[ajjf^
^^^ result is [3.4.62]
which shows that the brush thickness scales linearly with N . This feature always applies, whatever the solvency. In a good solvent, H increases with coverage as G^^^. These dependencies have been checked by, for example, numerical selfconsistent-field calculations. The Helmholtz energy difference AF between a surface with and without a brush is obtained by substituting [3.4.62] into [3.4.60] or [3.4.61]; ^
= N^N[a^G]^^^ = N^N[a^N')^'^A-^^^
[3.4.63]
The difference in surface tension, which equals -;r, follows from differentiating AF with respect to the area A, at given N^. Then we obtain —SL = ^[a
a\
[3.4.64]
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.61
In section 3.8f we will consider a case study where this dependence ;r ~ cr^'^^ is corroborated experimentally. Equations 13.4.61-64] apply for a good solvent. It is not difficult to find analogous expressions for a theta solvent. The difference lies in the osmotic contribution; in a theta solvent the linear term (1 - 2x]0 in the excluded volume vanishes, and the quadratic term in the expansion of ln(l - 0) is now dominant. Hence, the osmotic contribution is much smaller and, consequently, the brush is expected to be denser than in a good solvent. We now write F /kT^N^NO^, or, with osm'
°
e = Na
a/H,
osm — = N^{a^cy) ^ kT
[3.4.65]
The Helmholtz energy is found by combining [3.4.60] and [3.4.65]. Minimization with respect to H gives the scaling law for the brush thickness in a theta solvent; H = N{a^af^^
[3.4.66]
Since the dimensionless grafting density a a is (much) smadler than unity, the power 1/2 in [3.4.66] implies a smaller thickness than the exponent 1/3 in [3.4.62], as already £inticipated above. The procedure for finding the surface pressure is fully analogous to that described for a good solvent; AFis found by substitution of [3.4.66] into [3.4.60] or [3.4.65], and TU follows from d(AF)/dA at constant iV^. The result is m
= N[a^af
[3.4.67]
which shows that in a theta solvent 7t depends more strongly on the coverage than in good solvent. Moreover, since a a « 1, the surface pressure at given coverage is smaller in a theta solvent. It is illustrative to compsire these scaling dependencies for 7t with the general mean-field relation [3.4.56], which fully accounts for the variation of the profile. In brushes we can, for long chains, neglect the ideal term; 1 / N -^ 0. Moreover, 6^ in [3.4.56] is then zero. If we now take 9{z) = {6{z)) = 6 over a range H and expand the logarithm,, we can simplify [3.4.56] to
^«^
.Ml
\2
e
3
In a good solvent the first (quadratic) term dominates; K ~ HO'^ = H'^iNa^af. After substitution of [3.4.62] for H, the scaling dependence K ~ N{a a)^^^ is obtained, in full agreement with [3.4.64]. On the other hand, in a theta solvent the quadratic term vanishes and K ~ HO^ = H~^[Na of. With H = N{a af^ according to
3.62
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
[3.4.68], we find exactly t±ie scaling relation [3.4.67]. This example shows once more the versatility of the density functional relation [3.4.56]; it applies to physisorbed polymers as well as brushes, it recovers the seeding regimes but describes the transition between those regimes as well, which is a notoriously difficult problem in scaling theory. This does not necessarily mean that those transitions are described rigorously, since the basis is a mean-field model, which neglects spatial variations taken explicitly into account in scaling. Extensions of [3.4.56] to more complex situations (mixtures, block and random copolymers, polyelectrolytes) can also be found. However, we will not treat such systems here. 3.5 Monolayer molecular thermodynamics Statistical thermodynamics of monolayers is the obvious pendant of phenomenological classical thermodynamics, discussed in the previous section. In this approach some model assumptions are made on the properties and interactions of molecules, moving from a molecular picture to macroscopic properties, using statistical strategies, the foundations of which were laid down in chapter 1.3. Basically two approaches are open; (i) Through the vehicle of partition functions expressions can be derived for macroscopic quantities from moleculcir parameters. Examples of such quantities are the surface pressure, and, for Gibbs monolayers, the adsorbed amount. Fluctuations in extensive quantities, like the number density or the interfacisd excess energy, may adso be obtained (sec. 1.3.7). (ii) Use molecular dynamics (MD), Monte Carlo (MC) or other types of simulations to arrive at structural and dynamic information at a molecular level, starting from essentially the same primary assumptions as under (i), see sec. 1.3. le. Simulation results for pure fluid-fluid interfaces have already been discussed in sec. 2.7. Because of mathematical complexities, derivations of analytical expressions via the first approach remain restricted to a number of relatively simplified situations, whereas the increasing power of modem computers means that the second provides more insight into the fine-structure of condensed monolayers. Although the present section is intended to deal with Langmuir monolayers the statistical thermodynamics automatically address aspects of Gibbs monolayers and, hence, anticipate chapter 4. 3.5a Some general considerations What we have available regarding statistical equations of state (appendix 2) is of limited value. These equations contain at most two parameters, one accounting for the molecular cross-section {-a ) and the other for lateral interaction. Such mc
equations serve at best for a monolayer of disc-like molecules, i.e. a 2D discotic jluid. For such monolayers, only a few features can be described, one of these being
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.63
the formation of a densely packed layer at sufficient compression. This more or less exhausts the achievements of the statistical models studied so far. More realistic models rapidly become analytically unsolvable, so recourse has to be made to computer simulations or to lattice models. Computer simulations seem at first to be the most appropriate approach, because fundamental molecular parameters, such as sizes, interaction energies, bond lengths and bond flexibilities, can be fed in, so that, with the available algorithms, representative results are obtainable, given enough computer time and capacity. However, the parameter choice is sometimes ambiguous and, in order to keep the computer time within acceptable bounds, some truncations, or cut-offs, usually have to be introduced. Lattice models, if implemented with Ccire, are excellent alternatives; replacing that a fluid system by a (fixed) lattice appears to work better than expected. The expectation is that a lattice model works well if the systems considered are large compared to a lattice site, but problems can arise for molecular details below this limit. Remarkably enough, continuum models also have this complication. In practice this disparity between the two approaches disappears because often lattice models aire elaborated in a mean field approximation. In that case, the required computer time is much shorter than with simulations, because time-averaging is replaced by ensemble-averaging. However, molecular dynamics (MD), at the expense of much computer time, does provide a picture of the monolayer dynamics which is not available using equilibrium lattice theories. Let us now review some monolayer properties which may be examined by statistical methods. (i) At low surface pressure the quesion arises about how the tails will be oriented. Recall the discussion of fig. 3.7. Consider terminally anchored surfactants with unbranched chains. At very low coverage, where lateral interaction does not yet count, it is not obvious that the chains will stick out into the vapour phase. In visual representations this is often sketched this way 'because hydrocarbon chains are expelled by water'. The argument fails because hydrocarbon tails in a vacuum are attracted to the water surface by Van der Waals forces. So, energetically speaking, there is a tendency for flattening. On the other hand, confinement to such an orientation is entropically unfavourable: hence some compromise may result (see fig. 3.7). In this range, when the molecules are so far apart that they do not interact, the monolayer is gaseous ideal. (ii) At slightly higher pressure, where interaction sets, in ideal gas laws have to be changed into 2D Van der Waals or virial expressions. The situation is already more complicated than with 3D systems of spherical molecules because the configuration of individual molecules is affected by lateral interaction. Again, this is a topic for molecular thermodynamics. (iii) At further compression condensation takes place. Molecules aggregate to form pairs or small clusters, requiring them to stick out further. As well as anal-
3.64
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
yzing the configurations, an interesting statistical issue is to determine the sizes and size distribution of these clusters, an issue that is closely related to that of the order of the GL transition. (iv) Upon still further compression, the issue of tilt enters the story. By tilt we mean the angle between the (parallel oriented) tails and the surface. Tilt is a cooperative phenomenon. Experience has shown that the tilt angle is rarely 90°. It depends on the size difference between head groups and CH2 groups in the hydrocarbon chain and on the corresponding pair interactions. Tilt is absent in monolayers of FlCH^jgQF, which contain molecules of which the size of the head group is identical to that of the chain elements^^. On the basis of simple Helmholtz energy considerations. Schmid and Lange concluded that molecules with smaller head groups tilt towards next nearest neighbours, and molecules with larger head groups towards nearest neighbours'^^. Under certaiin conditions, parcels of surfactants with identical tilt may promote the formation of micelle-like aggregates'^ under other cases this is not the case (as for octadecanol monolayers, see"^^). (v) The order in a hydrocarbon chain can be expressed in terms of the ordering parameter S(s), defined in [1.6.5.58], in sec. 1.6.5g. It will recur in [3.5.1]. For completely random hydrocarbons it is zero, for crystalline phases it is unity. In a solid-like monolayer S(s) can be close to unity for the CHg groups (s = 1) and somewhat less near the end (s = 12, 14, or otherwise, depending on the chain length). In a liquid-like monolayer S(s) is rather around 0.2. Only when S(s) is high does the notion of tilt have any meaning. All of this is a question for molecular thermodynamics. (vi) At high and very high compression, molecular thermodynamics may help to identify the various condensed phases in molecular terms. Recall from sec. 3.3b that notions like 'liquid condensed', 'liquid', and 'solid' are purely phenomenological; there is no molecular picture behind these, other than that 'packages of molecules' are formed. Several monolayer formers, phospholipids among them, exhibit more than one condensed phase. (vii) In connection with (vi), the phase behaviour can be established in more detail than in fig. 3.15. Figure 3.19 sketches how a T{aJ phase diagram might lookS).
^^ M. Li, A.A.Acero, Z. Huang and S.A. Rice. Nature 367 (1994) 151. 2^ F. Schmid. H. Lange. J. Chem. Phys. 106 (1997) 3757; also see F.Schmid. Phys. Rev. E55 (1997) 5774; F. Schmid, D. Johannsmann and A. Halperin, J. Phys. France II 6 (1996) 1331. 3^ S.A. Safran. M.O. Robbins and S. Garoff, Phys. Rev. A33 (1986) 2186. "^^ G.A. Lawrie, G.T. Barnes. J. Colloid Interface Set 162 (1994) 36. ^^ For a review of condensed phases in monolayers, see CM. Knobler, R. Desai, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 4 3 (1992) 207; F. Schmid gives a somewhat more detailed picture than fig. 3.19, see Phys. Rev. ESS (1997) 5774; F. Schmid and M. Schick, J. Chem. Phys. 1 0 2 (1995) 2080 give a nice review of phase behaviour in Langmuir monolayers.
3.65
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
Figure 3.19. Schematic sketch of a 'generic' phase diagram for a Lsingmuir monolayer. Generally the pressure (and the compression) increase from right to left. The LE + G coexistence phase has a critical point; this may or may not be the case for the LE + LC coexistence. The dashed line represents a possible second order LE-LC transition. In region I several condensed phases may occur, exhibiting different order in one or more quantities. The achievements of statistical models on t h e s e various levels will b e illustrated in t h e following subsections. It may be noted t h a t the rich variety of condensed p h a s e s (region I in fig. 3.19) is a t the same time the subject of experimental s t u d i e s . Differences between p h a s e s may be difficult to perceive £ind t r a n s i t i o n s m a y relax slowly. It is beyond t h e b o u n d a r i e s of FIGS to d i s c u s s all of t h i s comprehensively. 3.5b
Strictly
two-dimensional
approaches
The first Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of a 2D h a r d disk fluid w a s carried out by Metropolis et al.^^. The discs were considered 'hard', i.e. having no lateral a t t r a c tion a n d a n infinitely high repulsion u p o n contact. The model m a y r e p r e s e n t monolayers of h a r d globular proteins in the dilute regime where lateral b o n d s are not yet formed. The simulation w a s carried out in the N,;r,T-ensemble. With this simulation it is possible to identify the first order G^C
p h a s e transition, b u t it is
difficult to analyze the packing at high compression. The observation of t h e p h a s e transition is interesting; since lateral attraction is ignored the transition m u s t be fully entropically driven. Condensation of part of the discs (which itself is entropically unfavourable) may deplete the remainder to s u c h a n extent t h a t its entropy gain overcompensates for this loss. The phenomenon is known for h a r d s p h e r e s in three dimensions.
1) N. Metropolis, A.W. Rosenbluth, M.N. Rosenbluth, A. Teller and E. Teller, J. Chem. Phys. 2 1 (1953) 1087.
3.66
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3h
1.0 P{ni 0.8
2h
:a) 0.6
d ti
0.4 0.2 0 1.2
10
1.4
Figure 3.20. Monte Carlo simulation of 408 hard discs, (a) 7c{a^) curve; a ^ is the hard sphere area of the disc, (b) Distribution of neighbours for a^^^Tr/kT = 2.61 (O); 8.05 (A); 10.0 (•); 11.8 (▼) and 26.2 (♦). (Redrawn from Fraser et al.. loc. cit.) The densification process of 2D discotic fluids h a s also been a d d r e s s e d by geometrical m e t h o d s , for instance by Sutherland^^ and Mason^). The latter carried o u t a c o m p u t e r simulation from which 2D radial density distributions could be derived. With increasing density the peaiks became s h a r p e r a n d more manifold. Sutherland estimated the onset of dense random packing to be at a packing density of 0.82-0.83. Figures 3.20a a n d b stem from work by Fraser et al.^l (In fig. 20a the open a n d filled circles are t a k e n from refs. "^^ a n d ^h) This w a s a MC simulation of 4 0 8 discs where a special geometrical device, the so-called Voronoi tesselation' w a s invoked to keep track of n e a r e s t neighbours. The available area a^ and the reduced surface p r e s s u r e 7t / kT are expressed in u n i t s of the h a r d sphere area, a^^ a n d
a^^,
respectively. From fig. 20a it can be read t h a t this simulation is of j u s t sufficient quality to allow u s to observe a hint of a n incipient
fluid-crystalline
transition.
Figure 2 0 b . shows a distribution of neighbours. With increasing p r e s s u r e
this
distribution b e c o m e s more narrow; a t the highest p r e s s u r e the co-ordination is purely hexagonal. Exercises like the ones discussed have also been carried out for 2D molecules of other s h a p e s (ellipses, d u m b bells, needles, ...); for some of these, 2D equations of state have also b e e n derived. However, for our p r e s e n t p u r p o s e they are of no consequence. S u c h 2D models of monolayers are still far from reality.
1) D.N. Sutherland, J. Colloid Interface Set 60 (1977) 96. 2) G.D. Mason, J. Colloid Interface Set 56 (1976) 483. *^J D.P. Fraser, M. Zuckermann and O.G. Mouritsen, Phys. Rev. A42 (1990) 3186. 4) W.G. Hoever, B.J. Alder, J. Chem. Phys. 46 (1967) 686. 5) J.J. Erpenbeck. M. Luban, Phys. Rev. A32 (1985) 2920.
3.67
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.5c Monte Carlo (MC) simulations Let us now consider the opposite approximation; the configurations that the chain can assume are analyzed, but the distribution of the head groups is fixed. An example was elaborated by Mouritsen et al.^^ who considered phase transitions in the LC state of lipid monolayers, a theme of ongoing research. As in the LC state, the lateral interactions responsible for the phase transitions under study, stem from the tails. The head groups are nailed to the water surface, far apart, and with pinheads', mimicking the molecular area a . With further analysis these areas disappear. The hydrocarbon parts of the chain can be in one often states (n = 1, ..., 10). These states were chosen by Pink et al.-^^ on the basis of considerations on optimcd packing in condensed 2D systems and requirements for low conformational energy. The n = 1 state is the all-trans state; n = 10 corresponds to a conformationally disordered state, characteristic of a fluid. The remaining eight intermediate states have different degrees of high conformational order. Entropies, 701-
60
1 ^°
\
20
10
54.0 °C
\
40
30
V.
1
"~«..
••••••-.'i;.i.
v-
34.1 X
A
20.5 °C
\ '••• »•..
16.0 °C
\
..>....30.o°c
•—• 0.5
- ^ y.^ •-n%r,V.
± \^
0.6
0.7
a; Figure 3.21. Monte Carlo surface pressure isotJierms for llpid-like molecules having 10 different conformational states available. 10.000 chains; anchoring groups not specified. The filled circles are computed; drawn lines are guides for the eye. Model parameters mimic dipalmitoyl phosphatidyl choline (DPPC) monolayers. (Redrawn from Mouritsen et al. (1989).)
1) O.G. Mouritsen, J.H. Ipsen and M.J. Zuckermann. J. Colloid Interfce Set 129 (1989) 32. 2) D.A. Pink. T.J. Green and D. Chapman, Biochem. 19 (1980) 349.
3.68
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
energies and molecular cross-sections can be assigned to each state. On this basis the Hamiltonian (see sec. 1.3.9) can be written, and from there all relevant thermodynamic and mechanical quantities are established. In the present case this was not carried out analytically but by MC simulation (up to 2000 MC steps per site). Figure 3.21 shows the resulting ;r(a ) curves. The overall trend is similar to that found experimentally, see fig. 3.8. The steep descent to the right in the G-phase is not realistic because free volume between the chains was not taken into account. (Typically such simulations are better for lower a..) However, the plateau and steep rise to the left are realistic representations. The figure addresses an interesting issue, viz. whether the G <1 LC transition is first or second order. In the former case (full co-operativity) there should be a perfectiy flat horizontal part in the isotherm. Co-operativity stems from attraction between chain segments in neighbouring molecules. For hard discs there should be a flat part, as in fig. 3.15. In fact, there has been a discussion on the question as to whether impurities in the layer may have been responsible for deviations from horizontality. We addressed this briefly in sec. 3.3b under (iii). The present statistical analysis supports the idea that, with increasing temperature, skewing does occur, the discrete transition giving way to a gradual one (second order) above 34.1°C. So, the transition from first to second order appears to be a real feature. Second order indicates partial co-operativity, attributed to the ten different states in which the chcdns may be found. With decreasing a^ and T p2irallel association of parts of the chain in parts of the monolayer occur. The fraction of ordered micro-domains could also be established. By changing the number of MC steps per second the authors could mimic hysteresis. At 30°C and 1000 steps per second there was almost no hysteresis, but at 100 steps distinct hysteresis loops developed. This may also be a realistic feature, the more so since above 44.5°C hysteresis was no longer observed. MD simulations may be more suitable for investigating such phenomena. The above model may be compared with results from the group of Rice and coworkers^^ in which a monolayer with interacting flexible chains was also studied using MC simulation. In this case the chain conformations were mimicked by random walks on a cubic lattice. Unlike the previous case, head groups are accounted for; they also find their positions on a cubic lattice, with the restraint that they all have to remain in the surface, i.e. the lattice layer z = 0. It is forbidden for them to submerge into the liquid (z < 0). Fourteen hydrocarbon chain elements are considered, so z = 14 at most. When the occupancy of the z = 0 plane with head groups is low, chain elements aire aUowed to enter this layer. Interactions are accounted for in terms of nearest neighbour pair energies, of which four types enter as
^^ J. Harris, S.A. Rice, J. Cherrh Phys. 8 8 (1988) 1298. See also J. Popielawski, S.A. Rice, ibid, 1279 and Z.G. Wang, S.A. Rice, ibid, 1290.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.69
4h CO
-a 3 c
^7^°^°v ■ ^ 0.25
V
\
s •s X!
Ih
\
v\
D
^ 8
fli^l
%
10 12 layer number
g^S—i
14
16
Figure 3.22. Segment density profiles for cimphiphiles in monolayers • , Q mean field; A, O, Monte Carlo. The normalized density distribution noraicd to the surface is givenas a function of distance, characterized by the layer number, at two indicated values of the surface coverage. T= 300; 14 chain elements. (Redrawn from Wang and Wee, loc. cit.) parameters, viz. u^, u^^, a^^ and u^, with h, t and s standing for head group, tail segment and surface group, respectively. These energies can be grouped together as Flory-Huggins (excess) ^-P^i'ameters for the unlike contacts (see sec. 1.3.8c). The three papers by Rice and co-workers involve differences of elaboration. Figure 3.22 compares a mean field with a MC approach, between which not much difference is found. Density profiles are typicsd results from this type of ansdysis. The quantitative outcome depends of course on the choice of paramieters, which is analyzed in some detail by the authors; the reader is referred to their papers for further information. As expected, the layer becomes thicker at higher surface occupancy; it is also seen that at low occupancy some segments close to the head group cire in contact with the solvent. Using this approach it is also possible to define and compute effective layer thicknesses and to find the distribution of chain elements touching the surface. The trend is that this distribution becomes more random with increasing temperature (not shown). Finadly fig. 3.23 gives two snapshot configurations. 3.5d Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations This technique has become increasingly popular because of the better availability of advanced powerful computers and commercial packages. As compgired with MC, the new feature is the dynamics of the monolayer. Specifically, using MD one may hope to learn more about
3.70
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
;a)
(b)
Figure 3.23. Monolayer sample configurations from MC simulation. Lattice 20 x 20 sites in the X L/-plane. Surface fraction occupied by head groups (a) 0.01; (b) 0.50. The filled circles represent head groups. (Redrawn from Harris and Rice, loc. cit.) (1) fluctuations around the equilibrium state; (ii) phase transformation processes; (iii) equilibration of the amphiphiles with the bulk (transition from Langmuir to Gibbs monolayers and vice versa). As a trend the characteristic time scales increase from process (i) to (ii). For practical purposes one could therefore only consider (i), keeping (ii) and (iii) frozen, or look at (i) + (ii), keeping the molecules (terminally) anchored. What is probably the first illustration dates back to Kox et al.^hn 1980. The model is relatively simple, but does already exhibit several essential physical features (fig. 3.24). In this approach the chains are mimicked by bond lengths and -angles corresponding to those in free hydrocarbons, around which smadl harmonic fluctuations sire allowed. Chain-chain interactions are of the hard core type, i.e. essentially determined by steric repulsion. The advantage of allowing the head groups to move over the surface is that equilibration is relatively rapid. The technique can 2dso be applied to find G ^ L C trainsistions. The interesting issue is to what extent this transition is entropically or energetically determined. In the former case, if a spatial ordering is called for, even a slight energetic contribution (say, by pinning headgroups to the subphase) can prevent condensation. On the other hand, if energetic contributions are in line with the entropic ones, the former can act as a promoter'^l Order parameters can also be established. From [1.6.5.58] 1) A.J. Kox, J.P.J. Michels and F.W. Wiegel, Nature 287 (1980) 317. 2) A. Halperin, I. Schechter and S. Alexander, J. Chem. Phys. 86 (1987) 6550; ibid 91 (1989) 1383. See also B.C. Moore, J. Chenh Phys. 91 (1989) 1381.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.71
Figure 3.24. Equilibrium configuration of a monolayer. Head groups are represented as terminally anchored discs. The 90 chains have seven repeating units, the CHg groups at the end are represented by an *. Truncated Lennard-Jones interactions between the head groups, which can move in the subphase surface. (Reproduced from Kox et al. with permission.) we repeat their definition S(s)-{|cos2 0 3 - i Here, 0
[3.5.1]
is t h e angle between segment s a n d the director (in this case t h e z-
direction). The b r a c k e t s indicate ensemble averages. S r u n s from zero for completely r a n d o m orientations, where (cos^ 0 ) = i to u n i t y for a set of parallel stretched c h a i n s for which (cos^ 0 = 1). It equals - -^ for c h a i n s perpendicular to the director. Results are given in fig. 3.25; it is concluded t h a t ordering increases if the layer is m a d e more dense. This is in line with the findings in fig. 3.22. The paper by Kox et al. may be considered seminal. After its publication a large n u m b e r of more advanced MD simulations have been published. One more example of a n ordering pgirameter is given in fig. 3.26. This study h a s been carried out by MC dynamics 1^ a n d concerns the effect of double b o n d s in the chain. The figure shows -S^j^(s), t h e order p a r a m e t e r of c a r b o n - d e u t e r i u m e l e m e n t s . D e u t e r a t i o n w a s needed in order to compare simulation r e s u l t s with those obtained from NMR e x p e r i m e n t s (for t h e s a m e c h a i n incorporated into a biological membrane^^). Recall t h a t S < 0 for chain elements normal to the z-axis. The dip at s = 10 is c h a r a c t e r i s t i c , irrespective of t h e positions of t h e double b o n d in t h e c h a i n
1^ J. Seelig, N. Waespe-Sarcevic, Biochem. 17 (1978) 3310. 2) Y.K. Levine, A. Kolinski and J. Skolnick, J. Chem. Phys. 9 8 (1993) 7581.
3.72
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
1.0
^_
S(s)
—o
0.8
""^"^o 0.7
■—o
V ^
^-^o
0.6
^
0.5 ° 0.3
0.4 0.2 1
1
1
1
1
1
Figure 3.25. Ordering parameter for three overall densities in the monolayer simulated in fig. 3.24. (Redrawn from Kox et al., loc. cit.) considered. The double bond aligns preferentlcdly along the z-axis, as a result the CD-bond makes an angle of 60° with this, the result is a low value for S^^. Nowadays the emphasis has switched to the study of phase transitions in condensed systems (left hand side of fig. 3.19). This is not surprising because it is a region to which modem optical techniques are often applied. As a systematic discussion is beyond the scope of FIGS we make do with a few illustrations. Karabomi et al.^'^.S) studied by MD Langmuir monolayers composed of surfactant molecules, consisting of one dipolar head group and 19 methylene units. These head groups were modelled as spheres with a fbced diameter (0.3527 nm) and fixed pair interacting energies between them (0.665 kJ mole"^). Bond lengths were kept fixed, but the intramolecular consequences of angle bending and rotation over quartets of adjacent segments were included. The head group size was fixed at 0.422 nm and in this simulation the water was structureless. Head group interaction was purely repulsive. Head group-water interaction was accounted for, using solubility data both for methylene groups and head groups. In other words, the heads are not pinned at the surface but may reside inside the water or out of it. This is a much more realistic picture than the ones discussed before. For further parameter details, see the original. Various parameters could be evaluated, including the surface pressure (from a variant of [2.7.1]).
IJ S. Karabomi, S. Toxvaerd and O.H. Olson, J. Phys. Chem. 96 (1992) 4965. 2) S. Karabomi, Langmuir 9 (1993J 1334. 3) S. Karabomi, S. Toxvaerd, J. Chem, Phys. 97 (1993) 5876.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
-0.3 >CD)
3.73 o
•
V
• simulated oleic acid chains
-• o
-0.2
o
experimented
X. o
-0.1
X
• J
0
1
I
4
1
8
- J
X
12
1
I.
16 s
Figure 3.26. Ordering parameter profile for carbon-deuterium segments in a model 9-10 cis-unsaturated chain in a monolayer!*). The open circles refer to results from NMR. (Redrawn from Levine et al., loc. cit.)
0.21
0.25
Figure 3.27. Snapshot of hydrcarbon tails through the z, x-plane, obtained from MD. (Redrawn from Karabomi and Toxvaerd (1992).) Figure 3.27 gives three MD s n a p s h o t s at different molecular cross-sections (indicated). At 0.25 nm^ the layer is disordered, the more strongly c o m p r e s s e d layers are ordered. The change in tilt is pronounced. In the simulated n[a^) diagram a small double knee-bend is observed (not shown) between 0.21 a n d 0 . 2 3 nm^. T r a n s l a t i o n a l diffusion coefficients s q u a r e displacement
D^
c a n be obtained from t h e root m e a n
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.74
20 h
e u
o .
X
o=
8
^
Q
/ / l—O'O^O^OOO-'-
0.20
0.24
0.28
0.32
Figure 3.28. Lateral surface diffusion coefficient for the head groups of the monolayer depicted in fig. 3.27. (Redrawn from Karabomi and Toxvaerd loc cit) r.a ^ lim Jr^Jt))
[3.5.2]
Figure 3.28 shows the result for the head group. (For the m a s s centre of the molecule a similar trend w a s observed.) The transition between (almost) zero diffusion a n d incipient lateral motion, Just below 0.22 nm^, is clear. The absolute vcdue of D?, is, at large a., of the s a m e order of (but not identical to) the experimental value in a decanol-decanoate bilayer. A variety of other molecular properties c a n be found, including details of t h e spatial distribution of segments, the probability of gauche-conformations, b o n d o r d e r p a r a m e t e r s (which display a l t e r n a t i o n s between odd a n d even c h a i n elements, counted from the head group) a n d tilt behaviour 1^. Figure 3.29 s h o w s density distributions for a n u m b e r of lipid monolayers on water, a s obtained by MD simulations^. We see t h a t DPPC and GLCB have a broader interface, which is a result of their bigger head groups. The thickness of the interface is less for hydrophobic surfaces. It c a n n o t be seen from these pictures t h a t water molecules occasionally penetrate the hydrophobic core, b u t video a n i m a tions showed t h i s clearly. Various other dynamic p a r a m e t e r s (rates of v a r i o u s internal motions) could be established. The water dipole contribution to the Volta potential V^^^ was also assessed. Recent i n t e r e s t of monolayer MD is focussed on obtaining a more detailed insight into s u c h aspects as;
1^ J.P. Bareman, M.L. Klein, J. Phys. Chem. 94 (1990) 5205 (for supported monolayers). 2) A.R. van Buuren, S.-J. Marrink and H.C.J. Berendsen, Colloids Surf. 102 (1995) 143.
3.75
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
LIPID PHASE
WATER PHASE
z (nm) Figure 3.29. Segment density (in arbitrary units) profile against the normal for lipid monolayers on water, according to MD simulations. DPPC = dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, (membrane), GLCB = decyl-p-glucoside (monolayer at decane-water interface), DEC = decane/water, GLYC = dilauroyl-sn-glycerol (monolayers on water). (Redrawn from van Buuren et al., loc. cit.) - n a t u r e of the polar head-polar head interaction, - n a t u r e a n d influence of the water structure, - more details of the tail-tail interactions (Lennsird-Jones pair energies, effects of stereoregularity, conformational matching between adjacent chains), - detailed (multi-) p h a s e behaviour, - excluded volume effects, - tilt; collective alignments of (groups of) chains, - translationad cind rotational (axial) diffusion of molecules, - application to multilayers, (like LB systems) a n d to monolayers deposited on solids, - application to mixed monolayers, including consideration of chain matching, - providing a b a s i s for the u n d e r s t a n d i n g of applied systems, like fluctuations (in connection with m a s s transfer a n d evaporation control) a n d hole formation in biological m e m b r a n e s . Space limitation does not allow u s to digress into this challenging multitude of developments. 3.5e
Mean field
lattice
(MFL)
theories
Basically these theories involve a lattice onto the sites of which segments can be placed. In this context, 'segment' can also m e a n a solvent molecule, or a head group.
3.76
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
or part of it. Large groups can be assigned to more than one site. Configurations of molecules can be quantified, each with its own weight, depending on interactions and spatial constraints. Interactions are usually restricted to those with neighbouring segments (the Bragg -Williams approximation is applied). Moreover, mean fields are often considered, meaning that the interaction energy of a segment, etc. at z only depends on z, but not on x and y. In this 'standard MFL model' the concessions made with respect to configurations and interactions are well worth the trouble because computer time is reduced by several orders of magnitude as compared with MD simulations. The basic reason for this efficiency is that in such standard models ensemble averages, rather than time averages are taken. The standard MFL model can be improved, for instance by including the rotational isomeric state (RIS)-scheme, which can account for gauche-trans isomery. On the other hand, in the mean field approximation it is difficult to account for features such as density fluctuations parallel to the surface. In sec. II.5.5 the main elements were applied to polymer adsorption. In this section adsorption of surfactants is at issue. Working with shorter chains mesins fewer computational steps; the gain in speed can be re-invested by investigating additional molecular details such as RIS or the alignment of (parts of) chains. According to present-day insight, such lattice theories are powerful tools; for polymers they are matching scaling predictions. Here, we shall not explain all the
1 2 3 Figure 3.30. Three possible configurations of a Cj^H-type surfactant in a monolayer MFL model. (Only the plaines z = 1, 2 ... M are drawn.) Discussion in the text.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.77
molecular and computational details^^ but shall go straight to some results. The first example of an elaboration concerns the G-LE transition which takes place in dilute monolayers (fig. 3.6). Figure 3.30 gives a 2D-representation of a surfactant, consisting of a head group H and 14 CH3(CH2) groups, C^, Cg ... 0^4. Only the layers parallel to the surface are drawn. Experience has shown that the geometry of the lattice (cubic, hexagonad, tetrahedral, ...) is not a very important variable. The anchoring of H to the 'wall' W (water or another liquid) is monitored by adjusting the x^ parameter; if it is high, the molecule is effectively bound and the molecules form a Langmuir monolayer. By lowering x^» ^ gradual transition to Gibbs monolayers can be achieved. The remaining space between z = 1 and z = M is occupied by vacuum 'monomers' V. In this example we address the problem of the configuration of isolated and weakly interacting adsorbed surfactants. This is point (i) of sec. 3.5a. The choice of the various ;^-parameters is as follows; ;^ =0.5 (slightly repulsive), x^^ =1.5 (strongly repulsive), XQ^ = 1 [also strongly repulsive but less than for the H-groups). As the H groups are anchored, they cannot leave the interface; it appears sufficient to specify how much more tail segments prefer the liquid than do V monomers: ^cw~ ^vw ~~^' Ot)viously, by playing around with this set of parameters the balance between the rather flat (top configuration in fig. 3.30) and the rather extended (bottom configuration in fig. 3.30) can be shifted. The present set is selected in such a way that they correspond to the parameters in the MC simulation by Rice et al., discussed in sec. 3.5c. Results are given in fig. 3.31. The pressure is normalized as nb^ / fcT, where b^ is the area of a lattice site (square lattice). The family of 7r[a^) curves is completely in 290 h
0.04
fe
T
(a) 0.03
t^
280 1
r-T=300
0.02 - I /
A-286.5
270
}\y / /-275 0.01 - | l / _ N C ^ /-265 i
50
1
100
260 1
i
150 200
1
250
0
50 100 150 200 250 300
a,/b'^ Figure 3,31. Surface pressure isotherm (left) and generic phase diagram (right) for monolayers of the of a Cj^H-surfactants of fig. 3.30. Mean field lattice theory. Discussion in the text. ^^ The computations in this subsection were carried out by F.A.M. I^ermakers.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.78
line with expectations; the p h a s e transitions are predicted (the temperature enters the picture by changing % -parameters; x ^^ values differing from 3 0 0 K are found by multiplying t h e quoted values by 300/T). O u r critical point, T^ = 286.5 K, is higher t h a n in the MC model of Wang a n d Rice (estimated slightly below 2 0 0 K). This difference of a b o u t a factor 2 / 3 is the result of a different way of counting interactions; through-bond interactions do not occur in MC simulations, w h e r e a s in the MFL model they are not distinguished from other contacts, requiring a correction to the t e m p e r a t u r e in the MFL which can indeed be proven to be the 2 / 3 factor. The r . h . s . of fig. 3.31 p r e s e n t s liquid-gas coexistence curves, of which curve I relates to the conditions of fig. 3.31a. Curve II, arises from somewhat improved lattice statistics. For curve I the chain is fully flexible, implying t h a t each bond c a n bend back to coincide with the previous one. In statistical parlance it is said t h a t the chain h a s n o self-avoidance a n d obeys first-order Markov statistics. In curve II a s e c o n d - o r d e r Markov approximation w a s used^^ in which t h r e e consecutive b o n d s in the chain are forbidden to overlap a n d a n energy difference of l / / c T i s assigned to local sets of three t h a t have a bend conformation. The figure demonstrates t h e extent of this vairiation; T is reduced a s a result of the loss of conformc
ational degrees of freedom. Figure 3.32 illustrates the effect of the adsorption energy of the tails (expressed 10^ (N
10'
pV 14.4
10
^ - ^ \ ^2^4\. V^
■iU
1 0.3^
10 - 2
\\rN\ nQ\\>\^
O]11 1
1—1
1—1_
...li
10
1
I I .
^"**^^*^"**»^ • . < •1
100
111 ii
1000
Figure 3.32. The influence of the adsorption energy of the tails on ;r(a.) curves, MFL theory. Conditions as in curve II of fig. 3.31b at T = 250 K; the difference ;tvw ~-^cw *^ given.
1^ C.C. van der Linden, F.A.M. Leermakers and G.J. Fleer, Macromolecules 2 9 (1996) 1172.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
aj
b^=
1.875
3.79
0.3
0.2
0.1
Figure 3.33. Segment density profiles for the terminally anchored surfactant molecules corresponding to the system of fig. 3.32a. Adsorption energy parameter Xy^^ - XQ^^ = 4.8 (a) total profiles; (b) profile per ranking number. H is the head group. through the difference Xy^^ - ZQW' on the K[a^ isotherm. Note the double-logarithmic scales. The result is r a t h e r complicated; for high adsorption energies there is only one first-order p h a s e transition ( G ^ L E ) . At smaller a^ a kink shows up; it is found at s u c h values t h a t the surface layer is exactly filled (Q = 1), so t h a t it is related to desorption of chain segments. For lower adsorption energies, irregularities appear, related to the consecutive filling of lattice layers with chains. Finally, fig. 3.33 gives segment density profiles,
ZHV
interaction parameters, LL interfaces are easily included. 3.6
Interfacial rheology
Rheology is, briefly, t h e science of deformation a n d flow, a n d in t h i s section deformations of, a n d flow in a n d nccir to, insoluble monolayers will be discussed. In three-dimensional systems application of a force, can lead to flow (for viscous
3.80
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
fluids), to elastic deformation (for solids and gels) or to a behaviour exhibiting both viscous and elastic features (for viscoelastic systems). Do such phenomena also occur in essentially two-dimensional systems like Langmuir monolayers? The answer is yes. In fact, in many colloidal systems containing large liquidfluid interfaces, such as foams and emulsions, there is abundant evidence for the action of surface rheology in addition to the omnipresent rheology of the adjoining bulk phases. Let us give three illustrations. (i) There is a dramatic difference in drainage behaviour between so-Ccdled mobile and rigid soap films. Soap films are thin layers of liquid (mostiy water), on either side flanked by a surfactant monolayer. Mobile soap films are very common. Such soap films have a low surface shear viscosity, mostiy a few |iN m"^ s^ as a result of which patches of film can move with respect to others. In foams and soap bubbles this process is visible as rapid movements of colours (i.e. of thinner and thicker parts with respect to each other). On the other hand, rigid films have a high surface shear viscosity, which prevents such motion; the films appear to be quiescent. Typical examples are aqueous soap films stabilized by monolayers consisting of an equimolecular mixture of sodium dodecylsulphate and dodecylalcohol. Soap film rigidity is typically a surface-rheological feature; the bulk viscosities of mobile and rigid films are about identical. The practical consequences are immense; mobile films drain faster than rigid ones by a factor of a thousand because in the latter case marginal regeneration is prevented. (Marginal regeneration is the exchange of thick patches of film for thinner ones at the borders between film lamellae.) (ii) One would intuitively expect a fluid droplet of a material with a low viscosity in a medium of high viscosity (e.g. a gas bubble in pure water or a water droplet in an oil) to move electrophoretically faster at a given ^-potential than a solid sphere with the same density. This expectation is dictated by the consideration that, due to internal circulation, a situation would arise at the interface that phenomenologically corresponds to slip between the droplet or bubble and the continuous phase. However, at least for small droplets, experiments do not support this. Such bubbles behave rather as if the interface has solid-like properties; there is no slip. Apparently, one has to ascribe these mechanical properties to the propensity of the interface to resist stresses exerted on it. Phenomenologically speaking, a high interfacial dilational viscosity has to be assigned to these interfaces. As a variant to this, it is known from flotation and similar studies that the mobility of surfactantstabilized droplets (in emulsions) or bubbles is retarded because the surfactant molecules tend to become depleted at the front side, leading to an interfacial tension gradient. (iii) The study of local dynamic processes at fluid interfaces reveals other illustrations of the important consequences of interfacial mechanical phenomena. For instance, calming of sea by putting oil on it, mentioned in the introduc-
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3,81
tion of this chapter, c a n be explained in terms of the damping of small wavelets. The wind tries to create ripples, causing local excesses a n d local deficits of oil molecules; t h e ensuing gradients (V;r's) in the surface p r e s s u r e are the opposing driving forces. Viscous dissipation of energy in the adjoining bulk liquids leads to damping, a n d hence prevents the formation of Icirger waves ^^ The coupling between interfacial cind bulk transport processes will be discussed in sec. 3.6e. These, a n d other observations take u s into the domain of interfacial
rheology.
Generally, in interfacial rheology we study the relationship between t h e deformation of a n interface, the stresses exerted in and on it, a n d the resulting flows in the adjacent fluid. The examples given illustrate not only the practical relevance of u n d e r s t a n d i n g a n d describing interfacial rheology b u t also indicate the necessity for further specification. For instance, the distinction between mobile a n d rigid soap films is a matter of interfacial shear (patches of given area moving with respect to each other) whereas wave damping is a dilational p h e n o m e n o n (patches of given n expand at the expense of patches with different n). These two interfacigd viscosities are very different quantities. Moreover, on closer inspection, wave d a m p ing is dominated by dilational
elasticity.
So, a variety of interfacial rheological
p a r a m e t e r s play their parts. Historically, one of the first conscious experiments in interfacial rheology d a t e s b a c k to P l a t e a u ^ \ He compared the damping of a magnetic needle immersed in a liquid with one placed on the liquid surface and found t h a t the surface presented a higher r e s i s t a n c e a g a i n s t deformation t h a n t h e bulk. Plateau a t t r i b u t e d t h i s observation to excess surface s h e a r viscosity. However, Marangoni^^ realized t h a t liquid surfaces are almost always contaminated a n d t h a t Plateau's observation should be explained via (what is now called) a Marangoni
effect
t h e movement of
the needle leads to surface compression in front of it a n d to dilation b e h i n d it. This, in turn, creates a gradient Vn or Vy, opposing the motion. In, fact Marangoni referred to a n older publication by himself (Pavia, 1865) in Italian, w h i c h h e entirely paid for, a n d on this basis claimed - and received - priority. Interfacial rheology is a very important tool in u n d e r s t a n d i n g t h e formation, stability a n d other properties of emulsions and foams. It also contributes to the characterization of monolayers, in addition to spectroscopic, electric a n d other methods. Hence, there is a clear motive for considering it in some detail. In this section some basic formalisms regarding interfacial rheology will b e IJ Already in 1890 [Proc, Roy. Chem. 4 8 (1890) 127) Lord Rayleigh recognized the relevance of the local expansion and contraction of the surface in understanding damping. The notion of surface viscosity was introduced by Boussinesq, Ann. Chim. Phys. 2 9 (1913) 349. 2^ J.A.F. Plateau, Phil. Mag. (4) 38 (1869) 445; Bull. Acad. Set Belg. (2) 34 (1872) 404. ^^ C.G.M. Marangoni, Poggendorfs Ann. Phys. 142 (1871) 337; Nuovo Cimento (2)5-6 (1872) 239; (3)3 (1878) 50, 97, 193.
3.82
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
introduced. The discussion will be unconventional to the extent t h a t it anticipates a systematic treatment of bulk rheology, which is planned for Volume IV, c h a p t e r 4. However, the present topic cannot be fully treated without some insight into bulk rheology, which therefore will be briefly reviewed first. We can rely on some b u l k rheological notions a n d p a r a m e t e r s related to viscous flow p h e n o m e n a t h a t have already been dealt with in Volume I, sec. 6.4. Here we will a p p r o a c h interfacial rheology from a phenomenological point of view. This m e a n s t h a t we shall u s e molecular models only to visualize w h a t is going on. Interfacial rheological p a r a m e t e r s will b e operationally defined. Where appropriate, t h e analogy with t h e corresponding feature in bulk rheology will be given. To be specific, the most relevant interfacial rheological p a r a m e t e r s referred to are the interfacial
excess
viscosities
and elasticities.
Plurals are needed, b e c a u s e
several types c a n be distinguished, depending on the method of m e a s u r e m e n t (in dilation or in shear). Measuring only one of these p a r a m e t e r s is a m a t t e r of concern; often 'coupling' of p h e n o m e n a is unavoidable. For example, area expansion in a trough often involves some shear along the edges. We u s e the term 'excess' to indicate a n y t h i n g additional to the reference state in which the b u l k properties remain u n a l t e r e d u p to the dividing plane, in analogy to the definition of Gibbs surface excesses. For m a n y p u r p o s e s monolayers c a n be phenomenologically treated a s two-dimensional (just like Gibbs adsorbates). Interfacial rheology is not simple, neither experimentally nor interpretationally. In this section we shall therefore discuss the various definitions, elaborations a n d techniques at some length, attempting to strike a balance between m a t h e m a t ical complexity a n d physical insight. In particular, in line with previous volumes, we shall sometimes u s e tensor notation, because it is h a n d y on a descriptive level. However, t e n s o r analysis, which is rigorous, a n d helps to describe t h e general formalism, will be avoided b e c a u s e it t e n d s to be abstract a n d requires additional m a t h e m a t i c a l skills. For convenience, the word 'interface' will be used to denote both liquid-liquid a n d liquid-gas interfaces. 3.6a
Some basic
issues
Possibly the most typical property of a liquid-fluid interface is t h a t it cannot autonomous;
be
it only exists a s the b o u n d a r y between two adjacent bulk fluids. Any
movement or flow in a n interface will c a u s e some corresponding motion in t h e adjacent b u l k p h a s e s a n d vice versa. To identify interfacial [excess)
rheological
properties, m e a s u r e d rheological properties of the system have to be divided into two p a r t s , one attributable to the interface and one to the bulk. S u c h a division is always somewhat arbitrary and may depend on the experimental method used. The mechanical coupling of a n interface with the two adjoining b u l k fluids also implies t h a t interfacial rheology is more t h a n j u s t the two-dimensional analogue
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.83
of t h e c o m m o n three-dimensional rheology of b u l k materials. For Gibbs m o n o layers a further complication is t h a t the interface also interacts with the adjoining b u l k p h a s e s by material exchange, resulting in additional changes in composition. These processes will greatly affect the time dependence of interfacial rheological properties. This aspect will be treated further in sees. 4.3 and 4.4. Another direct consequence of the n o n - a u t o n o m o u s character of interfaces is t h a t they can be created or annihilated by deforming the adjoining b u l k p h a s e s . The three-dimensional analogue of this phenomenon does not exist; isotropic compression or expansion of a bulk material can only be carried out in s u c h a way t h a t the a m o u n t s of matter remain constant. One cannot compress a three-dimensional p h a s e to a zero volume. Bulk liquids have a finite compressibility. Three types of interfacial deformations Ccin be distinguished (see fig. 3.34); (a) dilation a n d compression;
deformations involving a change in a r e a (AA or
dA) a t c o n s t a n t curvature, implying a t fixed princip2d radii of c u r v a t u r e (R^ a n d R^) or a t fixed principal curvatures, (c^ = R~^ a n d c^ =^2^). a s in sec. 1.2. The deformation is called dilation if AA or dA > 0, a n d compression
for AA or dA < 0 .
We note in passing t h a t some authors use the term dilation' in a more general sense in t h a t it refers to amy area change; their 'positive dilation' is our dilation or expansion, w h e r e a s their negative dilation' is equivalent to our compression. These two types are sketched in fig. 3.34a. For a (perfectly insoluble) monolayer, dilation leads to a reduction of the surface pressure TT (unless at a first order p h a s e transition). For a Gibbs monolayer the reduction of n is partly or completely offset by
A+AA
(a)
Figure 3.34. Basic deformation types of an interface in dilation (a), shear (b) or bending (c). Deformations (a) and (b) are in-plane; deformation (c) is outof-plane.
3.84
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
adsorption from the solution, to an extent determined by the relative time scales (i.e. by the Deborah number De] of extension and adsorption. Moreover, in this case the outcome depends on the conditions of expansion, at constant chemical potentials or at fixed amounts of all components. Converse phenomena can be observed for compression. Local dilation or compression leads to n gradients counteracting further dilation/compression, leading to the phenomena of interfacial elasticity and interfacial viscosity. (b) shear, upon which parts of the monolayer shift with respect to adjacent parts at fixed A, c^ and c^. The process is sketched in fig. 3.34b. Material exchange does not occur. When the viscosity is non-zero, shear leads to energy dissipation and, hence, interfacicd shear viscosity comes into play. (c) bending, in which the curvature is changed at constant area. Two types of bending can be distinguished, see fig. 1.34. Figure 3.34c shows the situation where only the curvature normal to the plane of drawing is altered. Bending causes a certain increase in elastic energy, each type being characterized by its own modulus. In sec. 1.15 these two moduli were defined, analyzed, and their measurement was discussed. In practice it is often difficult to apply only one of these three types of deformations. Often mixed types of deformations are created. For instance, bending is mostly accompanied by area changes, so that forces caused by ;r-gradients and by bending elasticities operate simultaneously. Only when interfacial shapes can be modified without accompanying adsorption or desorption, can a comparison be made with the corresponding deformations studied in bulk rheology. There one distinguishes deformation in shear and elongation (see sec. 1.6.4). Typically, bulk liquids are almost incompressible, so elongation in one direction is automatically coupled to compression in the other two. For liquids this compression is also an essentially viscous flow process. However, interfaces are not at all incompressible, except perhaps for close-packed Langmuir monolayers. As a result dilation plays a significant role. So, there exist marked factual differences between bulk and interfacial rheology. Nevertheless, because part of the phenomenology of bulk rheology recurs in interfaces we shall first briefly review some important features of the former. Strong bending, involving bending moduli, will be deferred till sec. 4.7. Weak bending, for which Laplace's law suffices, will be encountered in the subsection on wave damping, sec. 3.6g. 3.6b A review of bulk rheology (i) Strains, stresses, viscosity and elasticity. In this section some general rheological notions will be introduced in so far as they are necessary to understand twodimensional rheology, the topic of this chapter. A more extensive discussion of bulk rheology is planned for Volume IV. Generally, rheology concerns the relation between deformation and flow of
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.85
m a t e r i a l s , c a u s e d by m e c h a n i c a l forces exerted on t h e m . In order to o b t a i n material properties t h a t are independent of sample size, forces are expressed a s stresses
(forces per unit area, SI u n i t s N m-^) a n d deformation is t a k e n relative to
specimen dimensions [strain, dimensionless). If the deformation of the specimen is not homogeneous, the strain varies from place to place. A first rough division of materials according to their rheological behaviour, is t h a t between [ideally) solid a n d [ideally) Jluid materials. These two categories are the extremes of a range of intermediate situations. They differ with respect to t h e fate of the energy added to the system by a n external mechanical force. This energy is the product of a force and a displacement. If the force is counted per unit area, i.e. a s a s t r e s s (N m"^) a n d the displacement a s a strain (-) the supplied energy is obtained a s J m"^. Under a n applied s t r e s s ideally solid materials m a y deform, b u t they do n o t flow. When t h e force is released the deformation relaxes. The energy, supplied to the material in order to obtain the deformation, remains stored; u p o n terminating the stress, this energy.is fully a n d immediately released. S u c h a system is Ccilled (ideally)
elastic.
On the other hand, u n d e r stress a n ideal fluid merely flows. During this flow all supplied energy is dissipated into heat. In rheology it is usually stated t h a t this energy is lost Thermodynamically speaking this is incorrect b e c a u s e according to the First Law energy cannot be lost; it is only degraded into a form with which no more work can be done. However, the word 'energy loss' is so generally accepted t h a t we Ccinnot avoid using it. In the same vein later we shall speak of 'loss moduli', 'loss angle', etc. Typical for s u c h loss' is t h a t after removing the s t r e s s t h e fluid stops flowing (apart from inertia effects). S u c h fluids are (ideally)
viscous.
A typical distinguishing feature between ideally elastic a n d ideally v i s c o u s systems is t h a t in the former case the deformation (and its release) are virtually ^^ i n s t a n t a n e o u s . Equations describing the relation between stress a n d strain do n o t contain time. However, viscous flow continues a s long a s s t r e s s is applied. This s t r e s s may be constant, increasing, decreasing or alternating. As a result the fluid flows at a certain strain rate (change in strain per unit time, s"^) a n d t h e energy supply h a s to be counted per unit time (stress x strain rate, J m"^ s"^). E q u a t i o n s describing the relation between flow and stress also contain the rate, i.e. the time. In order to appreciate the orders of magnitude of rates of s h e a r encountered in practice, here are some examples; spraying, 10"*-10^ S"^; mixing or stirring, 10- 10^ s~M sedimentation of particles, 10"^-10"^ s"^; chewing, 0.5-5 s-^; growth of holes in some cheeses, 10~^-10~^ s"^; flow of glaciers < 1 0 ^ s-^ As discussed in sec. 1.6.1, in general nine components are needed to completely
^^ Elastic deformations are transported at sonic speeds.
3.86
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
describe a stress. The nine T components together constitute the stress
tensor. In
Cartesian co-ordinates, T
T = IT
T
XX
T
xy
T
yx T zx
yy T zy
xz
[3.6.11
T yz T
zz
The SI u n i t s are N m"^. Grouping nine components together into a 3 x 3 matrix does not automatically lead to a tensor; for t h a t other criteria should hold, s u c h a s invariance u n d e r change of coordinates. In [3.6.1] the three diagonal t e r m s ( r ^ , T , T ), known a s normal stresses, yy
act normal to the six faces of a cube of the
zz'
m a t e r i a l . For isotropic s y s t e m s application of n o r m a l s t r e s s e s only l e a d s to c o m p r e s s i o n or e x p a n s i o n . The other six, k n o w n a s t h e shear stresses,
or
tangential
act parallel to a n d in the plane of t h e six faces considered. Strictly
speaking, r
is the flux of x - m o m e n t u m t h r o u g h a face normal to the z - a x i s . It
a c c o u n t s for t h e extent to which motion in the x -direction is, by viscous traction, transferred into the z -direction. For a solid, application of a shear stress r ^ leads to a shear strain Ax / Az, w h e r e a s for a liquid it leads to flow with a shear dv /dz = d(Ax / Az) /dt^K
rate
Generally there are nine s t r a i n s Ax / Az, Ax / Ay, etc.,
or, for infinitesimal deformations, dx / d z , dx / d y , etc., which can be grouped into a strain tensor, analogously to [3.6.1]. Six of these strains are s h e a r strains, the other three are tensile strains. By the same token, the nine rates of strain, i.e. the nine possible r a t e s together constitute the rate of strain tensor. Tensorial notation is m a n d a t o r y to rigorously formulate the relations between all s t r e s s e s a n d all s t r a i n s . In particular for inhomogeneous systems, including s y s t e m s containing p h a s e b o u n d a r i e s , this is a necessity b e c a u s e of these couplings (thus, n o r m a l stresses can lead to shear). In the present text we shall not be so rigorous. In formal rheology, relations between these three t e n s o r s are formulated a n d analyzed. Only for the two extremes of viscoelastic behaviour are s u c h relations simple. For purely elastic materials there is a relation between the s t r e s s tensor a n d the strain tensor; it contains the elasticity m o d u l u s a n d t h e Poisson
ratio,
accounting for the extent to which extension in one direction is accompanied by concomitant compression in the other two. For purely viscous fluids there is a relation between the stress tensor a n d the strain rate tensor. As extension in one direction is concomitamt with (viscous) compression in the other two, in this case only one viscosity is required. For incompressible Newton fluids eventually a n expression with only one viscosity results, see [1.6.1.13].
^^ In rheological literature / a n d y are usually written for Ax/Az and d(Ax/Az)/dt, respectively, but in view of the confusion with the surface tension and its time derivative we shall not use these symbols.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS T
T
T
T
r
T
r
T XX
zx
MM
xz
= -^
T zz
3.87
2dvjdx {dv /dx + dv /dy) M
X
M
[dvjdx + dvjdz]
ZM
(dvjdy + dvjdx) 2dv /dy [dv /dy + dv /dz)
{dvjdz + au^/Bx) [dv /dz + dv /dy) M
z
2dvjdz [3.6.2]
where 77 is in N in"^ s or Pa s. Equation [3.6.2] may be considered as tlie operational definition of ri. Tlie matrix on ttie r.h.s. is the rate of strain tensor, written in such a form that [3.6.2] can be read 'term by term'. Generally, r..=-ri{dv^/dj
+ dv^/di)
[3.6.2al
where i and j stand for x, y, z. For example, T^=-2n3y^/3x
[3.6.3]
T^ = -4^v^ /dz-\- dv^ I ax) = T^
[3.6.4]
etc. For the simple situation of monodirectional shear, say in the x-direction (assuming the operationality of applying such a shear), r ^ = -^(^^x / ^^)
^xz = ^
[3.6.5a,b]
As long as stresses and rates of shear are proportional we can speak of linear viscous behaviour. We shall not consider situations and systems where linearity is not satisfied. For the elastic equivalent, see [3.6.6], linearity is also supposed to apply. Fluids obeying linear viscous behaviour are called Newton fluids. Only one material parameter, the viscosity rj, is needed to define their rheological behaviour. Many colloidal systems are non-Newton in that t] depends on the shear rate and often also on shearing time. Then the ratio of shear stress over shear rate is termed apparent viscosity, vjiapp). When r/(app) decreases with increasing shear rate the fluid behaviour is called shear thinning whereas, if it increases, the phenomenon is known as shear thickening. These terms are often used and we cannot avoid them, but they are vague, if not misleading, because what is called shear thinning and/or thickening is sometimes caused by elongation or compression, or by a combination of these and shear 1^. It is even possible that the resistance against deformation increases with increasing strain but decreases with increasing strain rate. So strain rate thinning/thickening are more precise terms and, if the phenomenon is not understood at all, just calling it thinning or thickening would suffice. When, at constant shear rate, r^Capp) depends on the time of shearing, four cases can be distinguished. When r](app) decreases reversibly one speaks of thixotropy; if the de^^ In industrial practice, where rheology often plays an important role, sloppy Icinguage use is commonplace. People may say that a system picks up rheology', or that a fluid has a lot of rheology' which is perfectly clear to insiders, but which is not precise at all.
3.88
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
crease is irreversible the behaviour is often called work softening or shear breakdown. More specifically, this term is also used for the lowering of yield values. We note in passing that here the notion of reversibility has a wider meaning than in the thermodynamic sense; the breakdown leading to viscosity lowering is usually not infinitely slow and thixotropic recovery may take some time. On the other hand, when r/Capp) increases with time, the behaviour is called anti-thixotropy and work hardening, for reversible and irreversible changes, respectively. For an ideally elastic material the ratio between stress and the accompanjdng strain is called the modulus G (units N m"^). The elastic counterpart of [3.6.2] reads Ty = Gy tan(Ai/Aj)
[3.6.6]
where i and j can be either x, y or z. Like the stress, nine components of G can be distinguished, and if so desired these can be collected into a 3 x 3 matrix. For nonisotropic systems, G depends on the direction of the applied stress; for isotropic systems this is not the case. In the linear range, that is at small deformations, G is independent of the applied shear stress. Usually linearity is lost at larger deformations. Moreover, G may also depend on the time that a shear is applied. Such systems are no longer called 'elastic'. (ii) Viscoelasticity, Most systems are neither ideally viscous nor ideally elastic. Rather they react to a stress or strain partly through a viscous and pcirtly through an elastic response. Such systems are called viscoelastic. Their rheological properties partly resemble those of a fluid and partly those of a solid. A viscoelastic system is called linear when the elastic effects obey [3.6.6] and the viscous ones [3.6.5]. In this case the stress to strain ratio depends only on time and not on the magnitude of the strain. Hence, for the rheological characterization of a viscoelastic material in its linear regime, it is necessary and sufficient to measure either the strain or the stress as a function of time. For viscoelastic systems the ratio between the viscous and elastic components depends on time. One way of analyzing the two contributions and their time influences is via rheological equivalent circuits, to be discussed for 2D-systems in sec. 3.6i. More usual is the control of time effects by carrying out oscillatory experiments, subjecting the sample to a harmonic stress (or strain), and measuring the resulting strain (or stress). In suitable rheometers the frequency (co) dependence of the modulus can be measured, which typically contains an elastic ('storage') and a viscous ('loss') component. The higher co the more elastic the system. We would expect this because then the system has less time to dissipate energy. The frequency range where the transition from 'solid like' to 'liquid-like' takes place depends on De for the system under consideration. Under ambient conditions water is viscous, but it must be elastic at frequencies above 10^^ s"^; silly-putty balls bounce perfectly but flow to become a pancake if left to themselves for several minutes. Water has a
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.89
very low T(relax)l^ so to see water in the unrelaxed (elastic) state, experiments m u s t be carried o u t over a n extremely short time, or a t a very high frequency; for sillyp u t t y t h e relaxation time is O(minutes), so at t h a t time scale of observation De = 0(1). The m a t h e m a t i c s of the elaboration of oscillatory rheological m e a s u r e m e n t s is exactly identical to t h a t for dielectric spectroscopy, already described in sec. II.4.8a. Since the m o d u l u s h a s two components it is advantageous to exploit t h e formalism of complex quantities.
One of the components (the elastic component G')
is plotted on the real axis ( x ) , the other (the viscous one, G") on the imaginairy or y axis. Each point in the (x.i/)-plane, also called the complex plane, r e p r e s e n t s the system rheologically in t e r m s of G' a n d G". Different frequencies yield different points. The overall m o d u l u s is now a complex quantity written a s G. It is related to G' and G". G((o) = G'ico) - iG^cp]
[3.6.7]2)
No general rules can be given for the frequency dependence of G' a n d G", because t h e s e depend on the n a t u r e of the system, which may relax according to severed processes, each with its own time scale. However, for the case of only one relaxation process £ind a harmonic oscillation the m a t h e m a t i c s becomes r a t h e r simple. The phase angle 0 can be introduced a s before (Lapp. 8 and sec. II.4.8a). This angle m e a s u r e s the extent to which the strain lags behind the applied strain or t h e s t r e s s is a h e a d of the straiin. An illustration will be given in fig. 3 . 4 1 . In this case G can be written a s G = IG I e^^ = IGI (cos 6 + i sinO)
[3.6.8]
with G' = | G | C O S 0 a n d G" = | G | s i n 0 . Here, 0 is the angle between the direction of t h e m o d u l u s a n d the positive real axis, in this case the G' axis. In i m a g i n a r y parlance,
G is called the m o d u l u s of G. So
Equation [3.6.8] is Eulefs
G is the m o d u l u s of a m o d u l u s .
law.
If we w a n t to introduce the time a n d / o r frequency explicitly we c a n replace exp i6 by exp ico t (for the applied strain (or stress) a n d exp i(co t - 0) (for t h e response). So, for a harmonic oscillation of a n extension to the area A, A = A cos cot
[3.6.9]
o
we can u s e the complex notation ^^ Note that the sjonbol T is used both for stress and relaxation time. Where necessary, to avoid confusion, we shall distinguish them by labeling and/or using subscripts. '^^ In Volume I appendix 8 gives an introduction to complex and imaginary quantities. Note that other authors may use G[(o] = G' + iG"[co] instead of (3.6.7]. The choice is a matter of convention; it has no consequences for the sign in the r.h.s. of [3.6.8] but leads to an inversion of the sign in the most r.h.s. of [3.6.12].
3.90
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
A = A^Ree*^^
[3.6.10]
where Re means 'the real part of. The prefix Re is often omitted. Here A is the maximum deviation of A. The response of G, lagging behind by a phase 0, can be written as G(t] = G^ cos(cot - 0) = G^ cos (p cos cot -f G^ sin 0 sin cot
[3.6.11]
As ft; ^ oo, 0 -> 0 and G{t) ~ G coscot, in phase with A; for co -> 0, 0 -^ 7c/2, representative of purely liquid behaviour. This is the stationary limit. Models are needed to express 0 as a function of o). In I.appendix 8 we discussed damped harmonic oscillations. Returning to [3.6.7], it is customary to call the ratio - G" / G' the loss tangent or _tan0 = - ^ ^
=^
COS 0
13.6.1211)
G'
and 0 is then the loss angle. The loss tangent is a measurable quantity, indicative of the phase lag. At the same time tan 0 characterizes the extent to which the behaviour is elastic or viscous. We would expect intuitively that tan (p and the Deborah number De are related, since both refer to the ratio between the rates of an imposed process and that (or those) of the system. The exact shape of this relationship depends on the number and nature(s) of the relaxation process(es). So let us anticipate [3.6.41a] for the loss tangent of a monolayer in oscillatory motion, which describes a special case of [3.6.12], namely - t a n 0 = rj^co/ K^\ Here, co is the imposed frequency, equal to the reciprocal time of observatiort, t{obs) =(o~^. The quotient K^*/^^ also has the dimensions of a time; in fact it is the surface rheological equivalent of the MaxwellWagner relaxation time in electricity. (Recall from sec. 1.6c that for the electrostatic case relaxation is exponential ith r = e e / K where £ £ is the dielectric permittivity and K the conductivity of the relaxing system. In other words, T is the quotient between the storage and the dissipative part.) For the surface rheological case r therefore becomes rj^ / K^'. The exponential decay that is required for such a relaxation is indeed often found, (see the illustrations in sec. 3.6i). Hence, - t a n 0 = -^^— = —^- = De [3.6.13] ^ K^' t(obs) For more complicated relaxation mechanisms the relation to De is more involved and more than one 0 and corresponding De's may occur. That's enough on bulk rheology for now. A more detailed treatment is planned for Volume IV. Several of the above features recur in the following sections on surface rheology. 1^ See footnote to [3.6.7]
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.91
3.6c Basic interfacial rheology In sec. 3.6b definitions were given for the stress tensor, the viscosity and the modulus of bulk matericds. Now we discuss the two-dimensional equivalents of these characteristics. For phenomenological purposes interfaces are considered infinitesimally thin. This is an abstraction from reality because real interfaces have a finite thickness which is 0(nm) for pure liquids (sec. 2.8) up to O(10 nm) for polymeric layers. If we talk of interfacial excess viscosities or moduli we mean 'excess with respect to the reference state in which the bulk values of these parameters remain unaltered down to an infinitely thin interface'. These excesses, even though they are formally assigned to this plane, in reality reflect the overall effect of a layer of final thickness. Let z be the direction normal to that interface; X and y are in that interface. For interfaces at rest, the normal component r of the stress tensor T must be the same everywhere because otherwise the interface would rise or descend. However, the tangential components differ from those in the adjacent bulk phases, giving rise to the interfacial tension, see sec. 2.3. In a twodimensional co-ordinate system {x, y] the forces acting at a certain point are fully defined by four components which together constitute the interfacial stress tensor^'
Ir^ T^ I
T^ = ^
T \ yx
J^
T
[3.6.14]
yy \
Some authors call this tensor the surface (or interfacial) tension tensor. The interfacial tensor is an excess quantity, (hence the superscript a) and acts in two dimensions (its SI units are N m"\ as compared with N m"^ for bulk stresses). Equation [3.6.14] applies to an isolated interface. In reality isolation is of course impossible; the interface is in contact and at mechanical equilibrium with the bulk. Otherwise the interface would accelerate, slow down, or display shear with respect to the adjacent bulk. An alternative way of formulation would be to retain the bulk tensor [3.6.1] of which five components are zero in the interface. The tensor [3.6.14] contains two asymmetric components r^ and r^ , and two symmetrical ones, T^ and r^ . Following bulk rheology usage, the symmetrical XX
yy
components could also be called normal components', but in view of confusion with T we shall avoid this nomenclature. These symmetrical components account for interfacial dilation or compression and generally contain elastic and viscous contributions. The elastic contributions may have more than one origin. The more common is the Gibbs elasticity, resulting from the creation of interfacial tension (or interfacial pressure) gradients. This mechanism prevails in surfactant monolayers. There are indications that, particularly for polymeric monolayers, a ^^ To describe bending of interfaces, nine components are required, but we shall not consider those here.
3.92
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
network
elasticity
m a y also exist, resulting from cross-linking between groups in
the surface. In practice it is virtually impossible to discriminate between these two because one would have to prove t h a t in the network case extension of the area does not lead to a n increase of the interfacial tension a n d this quantity c a n n o t b e m e a s u r e d for s u c h a monolayer. In practice s u c h polymeric monolayers are rarely purely two-dimensional; extension may force loop a n d tail s e g m e n t s to become train segments. In the absence of network elasticity, [3.6.14] may be rewritten a s T^ =
-7
[3.6.15]
1 - ^
The m i n u s sign is needed because at mechanical equilibrium / and T
or T
Just
deformation.
For
compensate each other. The a s y m m e t r i c c o m p o n e n t s r^ -^
'^
a n d r^
xy
refer to shear
yx
isotropic monolayers these two stresses £ire identical. Extending t h e analogy with bulk rheology, for linear s h e a r deformation of a n interface it is possible to define a surface
(or interfacial)
shear viscosity
rf^ a n d a
surface (or interfacial) shear m o d u l u s G^. In a Cartesian co-ordinate system, with again the z-axis normal to the interface dv yx
's
T"
5y
z=0
xy
dv [3.6.16a,b]
y_
=
ax
Jz=0
and T^ = G^ t a n yx
s
I
xy
G^tan
f^i \^Jz=0
[3.6.17a,b]
where the viscous component is contained in G^. Equations [3.6.16 and 17] presuppose linearity a n d isotropic monolayers, characterized by only one rj^ a n d one G^, independent of the direction of shear. For easy reference, these a n d other rheological characteristics are collected in table
3A^\
Equations [3.6.16 a n d 17] define the interfacial viscous a n d elastic components if surfaces are deformed by s h e a r . Their c o u n t e r p a r t s refer to deformation by dilation (extension), or compression. Now we are concerned with relative extensions AA / A , or, infinitesimally, d In A . As before, for purely elastic surfaces t h e following two options should be considered; (a) there is a network-type elasticity, a s in a two-dimensional gel a n d (b) s u c h a skin is absent; elasticity is of t h e Gibbs
^^ In this table we largely follow the lUPAC recommendations (sec. 3.10a), but complete adherence is not feasible because of interference with symbols already used elsewhere in FICS. For instance, we prefer rf^ for the interfacial dilational modulus over the lUPAC recommendation ^.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.93
Table 3 . 4 . Glossary of interfacial rheological quantities. The superscript a refers to interfacial excess properties. Symbol
\i^ \<
Ud
Name
SI u n i t s 1
interfacial stress tensor (4 components)
Nm"^
interfacial s h e a r viscosity
N m"^ s
interfacial dilational viscosity
N m"^ s
interfacial s h e a r m o d u l u s
Nm'^
K^
interfacial dilational m o d u l u s
Nm"^
K^
S
complex interfacial dilational m o d u l u s (= K ^ - i K ^ " ) ;
Nm"^
K^'
dilational storage m o d u l u s
Nm"^
K^"=r]>
dilational loss m o d u l u s
Nm'^
J^
interfacial compliance
mN'^
e
loss angle
-
(0
frequency (in oscillatory experiments)
s-^
Note. The table contains J]^ twice. Although we use the same symbol for the interfacial dialtional viscosity (commonly measured at large strain) and the dynamic interfacial dilational viscosity (small strain, oscillatory measurements) the values obtained may differ (as found for instance for some protein monolayers). type. In the former case a relative extension AA / A of the area leads to a n increase of T^ a n d / o r T ° by a m o u n t s Ar^ a n d / o r Ar^ , depending on t h e direction of extension a n d the anisotropy of the monolayer. In the linear regime, to which we shall limit ourselves, the r e s p o n s e is proportional to the dilation AlnA. For t h e network (nw) a n d Gibbs type of elasticity we write AT^ =K'' XX
AlnA
13.6.181
nw.x
and [3.6.19]
A7 = -A;r = K ' ' A l n A respectively. Here, the two K^'s are interfacial
dilational
moduli. For infinitesimal
dilations we have seen this equation before, see [3.4.4]. Generally, K^ is the inverse of the isothermal compressibility
of the film.
Dilational moduli play a n important p a r t in a n u m b e r of practical p r o c e s s e s involving interfacial a r e a c h a n g e s , where K^ is a m e a s u r e of t h e r e s i s t a n c e a monolayer h a s against creating a n interfacial tension gradient Vy u p o n extension or compression. Emulsification a n d foam formation are representatives of s u c h processes. On the other hand, once V / h a s been created, the m o d u l u s controls the r a t e of relaxation. Historically, only static values have b e e n considered. Recall t h a t for elasticities of the Gibbs type, expressions for K^ can be formulated on t h e basis of two-dimensional equations of state, see [3.4.30 a n d 30a]. In more m o d e m developments t h e m o d u l u s is also studied u n d e r dynamic, or non-equilibrium
3.94
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
conditions. The practical relevance is obvious. Then the modulus becomes timedependent and contains a storage and a dissipative part. To distinguish the two we shall use the complex notation for the latter, K^, See below, subsec. 3.6f, ad (ii), eq. [3.6.34 and following]. For a review, including a historical section, see^^. Formally, the change in surface tension Ay can, by analogy to the situation described above, be related to the rate at which the interface is enlarged or compressed by Ar = 77," ^
[3.6.201
where rj^ is the surface dilational viscosity (N m"^ s). However, this is an academic situation because so far no measurements are available to show that upon extension some monolayers behave in a purely viscous manner. There is also always an elastic contribution, so it is more realistic to consider the more general case where Ay will be given by some combination of [3.6.19 and 20]. What this combination looks like depends on the way in which the viscous and elastic processes are coupled. One obvious possibility is Ay = K^AlnA + T]^ ^ ^
[3.6.21]
i.e. the elastic and viscous contribution to Ay are added but A In A is the same for both. Consequently, Ay is time-dependent. As will be discussed in sec. 3.6.9, this scheme represents a so-called Voigt (or Kelvin) rheological element. One of the (many) alternatives is the Maxwell element where the contribution to Ay is the same for the elastic and viscous part but where A In A differs. The performance of the model depends on the type of monolayer (more 'solid-like' or more 'liquid-like'). At this instance it may be noted that generally ri^ and t]^ are different quantities. Shearing surfactant molecules with respect to each other in a monolayer or compressing or dilating them gives rise to different energy dissipations. For bulk phases this is also the case but, as already stated, for isotropic (Newtonian) fluids only one viscosity suffices. However, monolayers are typically anisotropic in the z-direction; the question is whether they are also anisotropic parallel to the surface, in which case one would not expect a general and simple relationship between 77^ and r]^. Experiments will decide. Similar things can be said about the differences between G^ and K^. As a reminder it may be added that for Gibbs monolayers the situation becomes very different because t]^ is mainly determined by diffusion rates of the surfactant molecules (and becomes strain rate-dependent), whereas rj^ is independent of diffusion transport.
1^ G. Kretzschmar, R. Miller, Adv. Colloid Interface Set 36 (1991) 65.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.95
3,6d Intermezzo. Disparate definitions of interfacial tension Having now encountered interfacial tension in the interfacial stress tensor it makes sense to review and compare the various definitions that we have so far encountered. The primary definition is the thermodynamic one (sec. 1.2.3), according to which the tension is the force per unit length needed to expand the area by an infinitesimal amount, isothermally and reversibly. It is typical for thermodynamic definitions that they are based on processes that in principle can be carried out, i.e. they involve operational quantities. When the expansion cannot be carried out isothermally and reversibly it is impossible to define the interfacial tension operationally. This is for instance the case with solids (sec. 1.2.24) but also with monolayers in which expansion involves energy dissipation as a result of the irreversible breaking of bonds. Reversibility implies that interfacial tensions can also be interpreted as Helmholtz or Gibbs energies per unit area (see [1.2.10.9 and 10]);
>' = f ^ l
= fl?l
I3.6.22a,bl
These expressions define the isothemicd reversible work done on the system; after the enlargement the resulting Helmholtz or Gibbs energy resides in the interface. The definition y = (dU/dA)^^^,^ is cdso operational, but virtually impracticable; how can one enlarge an interface iso-entropically? When an interface contains an elastic network, it remadns possible to measure the force needed for expansion but now the notion of interfacial tension loses its meaning because the force depends on the strain. In all these definitions, interfacial tensions are interpreted as scalars. Of course, forces are vectors, but the force per unit length to be applied to enlairge the area reversibly, always finds the same opposing contractile force, irrespective of direction. The next set of definitions involves relations to other thermodynamic interfacial excesses. In particular, from [2.2.23] y=K-
Xi^i^i = ^a
[3.6.23a,b]
Between [3.6.23a £ind b] there is a difference of principle, in that the identity y - Q^ is operational, whereas in the first equality; F^ and the F^'s depend on the choice of the Gibbs dividing plane. Their sum, the grand potential per unit area, is independent of this choice. Equations [3.6.23a and b] do not help to measure interfacial tensions, but serve in interpreting them. The mechanical interpretation is [2.3.5]
3.96
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
7 = 1 [p-pjz)]dz
[3.6.24]
According to this expression, the interfacial tension is interpreted as the excess of the tangential component of the bulk pressure tensor. The z-dependence is now made explicit (as in fig. 2.2), - in contradistinction to the thermodynamically, defined Gibbs excesses. As to interpretation on the basis of models, £2^ can also be obtained by first finding the grand potential per unit volume at each z (in J m"^) and then integrating with respect to z. For monolayers this functionality usually has positive and negative regions, depending on the nature of the interaction (attraction or repulsion) at each z. The same Ccin be said of pAz); obviously the two interpretations are basically identical. Finally we recall [3.6.15] which is a mechanical definition for an infinitesimally thin monolayer. The interfacial stress tensor T^ is a more general quantity than Y because it also contains the shear components. When shear stresses are absent 'i^ reduces to -7 0
0 -y
[3.6.25]
so that then r° = r^ = - / . 3,Ge Coupling of interface and bulk motions, Marangoni effect As interfaces are not autonomous, any movement or flow in an interface will cause some corresponding motion in the adjacent bulk liquids and vice versa. The law for conservation of momentum requires that there must be continuity of momentum [pv] over the interface (in addition to mechanical equilibrium). In sec. I.6.4d we briefly discussed the difference between the coupling of flow along a fluidfluid interface free of any adsorbate and the generation of flow in the adjacent fluids due to the presence of a gradient in the surface tension caused by the unequal distribution of an adsorbate (Marangoni effect). Here, these flow phenomena will be further elaborated taking into account the development of shear-induced interfacial stress gradients or dilational deformations of the interface. In an interface between pure fluids relaxation processes proceed so fast that, in the absence of temperature and pressure gradients, interfaces may be considered as being homogeneous and likewise the interfacial tension. We exclude the extremely dynamic situations considered in sec. 1.14a. Then the shear components of the interfacial tension tensor will also vanish and the normal or symmetric components are, except for the sigh, identical to the interfacial tension, which is the same everywhere and, hence, no stresses can be built up in the interface. Any motion of, and in, such interfaces is entirely determined by the momentum transport of the adjacent bulk phases. For an illustration see sec. I.6.4d, example 3.
LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS
3.97
Now we consider the more complicated case t h a t the interface carries a monolayer. If, for some r e a s o n , t h i s monolayer is i n h o m o g e n e o u s , t h e interfacial tension a n d all interfacial s t r e s s e s a n d elastic moduli will vary from place to place. In mathematical language, gradients, which are vectors, will develop. One writes either grad / or V / , V T^, etc.^). The presence of a gradient like Vy implies t h a t t h e r e is a s t r e s s acting along t h e interface, which leads to motion in t h e interface. The energy produced in this process is dissipated into the two adjoining p h a s e s which start moving. So, adjacent fluid starts to flow with Vy a s t h e driving force. On t h e other h a n d , externally applied fluid flow u n d e r n e a t h a n interface may create surface tension a n d / o r surface