GRAHAM GREENE
GARLAND REFERENCE LIBRARY OF THE HUMANITIES VOLUME 1684
GRAHAM GREENE AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
ROBER...
61 downloads
3718 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
GRAHAM GREENE
GARLAND REFERENCE LIBRARY OF THE HUMANITIES VOLUME 1684
GRAHAM GREENE AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
ROBERT HOSKINS
GARLAND PUBLISHING, INC. A MEMBER OF THE TAYLOR & FRANCIS GROUP NEW YORK AND LONDON 1999
Published in 1999 by Garland Publishing Inc. A Member of the Taylor & Francis Group 19 Union Square West New York, NY 10003 This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” Copyright © 1999 by Robert Hoskins All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or here after invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Hoskins, Robert. Graham Greene : an approach to the novels/by Robert Hoskins. p. cm.— (Garland reference of the humanities ; vol. 1684) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8153-1265-2 (alk. paper) 1. Greene, Graham, 1904–—Criticism and interpretation. I. Title. II. Series. PR6013.R44Z633478 1998 823'.912—dc21 98–39990 CIP
ISBN 0-203-00963-0 Master e-book ISBN
For my mother, and in memory of my father
Contents
Introduction Acknowledgements
vii xvii
Chapter One:
Protagonists of the First Phase
Chapter Two:
Letters and Diaries
31
Chapter Three:
A Gun for Sale
51
Chapter Four:
Brighton Rock
77
Chapter Five:
Protagonists of the Second Phase
99
Chapter Six: Chapter Seven:
1
The Strategy of Allusion in the Second Phase
119
Portraits of the Artist
135
The End of the Affair
135
The Quiet American
154
A Burnt-Out Case
163
The Comedians
176
Chapter Eight:
Travels with My Aunt
189
Chapter Nine:
The Honorary Consul
215
The Human Factor
231
Chapter Eleven:
Dr. Fischer of Geneva
245
Chapter Twelve:
Monsignor Quixtoe
259
The Captain and the Enemy
287
Selected Bibliography
311
Chapter Ten:
Chapter Thirteen:
vi
Index
317
Permissions Acknowledgements
321
Introduction
As an unapologetic admirer of Graham Greene’s writing, I feel a certain awkwardness in introducing a book about him that he probably would have disliked. He admired Philip Stratford’s Faith and Fiction and Father Leopoldo Duran’s La Crisis del Sacerdote in Graham Greene—these, he said, were the best critical books about him—but he was impatient with a great deal of the critical writing about his work. “Save me from these American academics,” he wrote in a friend’s copy of the volume of essays edited by R.W.B.Lewis and Peter Conn in the Viking Critical Library edition of The Power and the Glory—a collection that I have always regarded as first-rate. His attitude toward critics appears to have been linked with his determination to avoid repetition in his work: he was sensitive to the charge that he was a “one-book man”—a charge he rightly denied—and he feared that too keen an awareness of the “patterns” in his work would stifle his own creativity and make patterns harder rather than easier to avoid. As he explains in Ways of Escape, the fear became acute midway through his career, when his growing reputation as a Catholic novelist threatened to limit the range in which he was expected to work: Writing a novel does not become easier with practice. The slow discovery by a novelist of his individual method can be exciting, but a moment comes in middle age when he feels that he no longer controls his method; he has become its prisoner. Then a long period of ennui sets in: it seems to him he has done everything before. He is more afraid to read his favorable critics than his unfavorable, for with terrible patience they unroll before his eyes the
viii
unchanging pattern of the carpet. If he has depended a great deal on his unconscious, on his ability to forget even his own books when they are once on the public shelves, the critics remind him—this theme originated ten years ago, that simile which came so unthinkingly to his pen a few weeks back was used nearly twenty years ago in a passage where…. (140–41) A foray into film writing had provided Greene with a way of escape from entrapment in his own pattern, or so he had thought, but “The Third Man only beckoned me into another and more luxurious prison.” At this time he was inspired to pursue another escape—the use of first person narration—by his reading of Dickens’s Great Expectations (141). Greene reiterated his concern over critics and “patterns” in an interview with Marie-Françoise Allain. Asked whether there existed somewhere a “true image” of him, he replied: That’s for others to discover, not me. I expect you’re familiar with Henry James’s words about “the pattern in the carpet.” In any body of work there’s always a pattern to be found. Well, I don’t want to see it. When a critic discovers certain keynotes, that’s fine and may be of interest, but I don’t want to be steeped in his discoveries, I want to remain unaware of them. Otherwise I think my imagination would dry up. For the same reason I never reread my books; I know I would come across all too many repetitions due quite simply to forgetting what I had written before. I’ve not the slightest wish to have my nose rubbed onto “the pattern in the carpet.” (23) It was characteristic of Greene to allude to Henry James in commenting on his own life and work as a writer and equally characteristic for him to be modestly evasive with regard to his own figure. At the same time it is not hard to imagine why Greene, or any writer, would need to regard the beginning of each new book as an entry into uncharted territory. His character Maurice Bendrix, himself a novelist and the first protagonist-narrator in the novels, describes himself somewhat miserably early in The End of the Affair as a traveler in a strange
ix
land, a traveler without a map. For better or worse, the literary traveler who sets out to negotiate the territory of Greene’s works will experience nothing of the sort, for there have long been many maps and signposts, some of them extremely helpful. Brief introductions to Greene as well as more comprehensive surveys of his work are sufficiently numerous that to survey all of them would be beyond the scope of this introductory chapter. A description of a few of the key critical works—especially those that have attempted to identify patterns in the course of Greene’s career—may serve to place my own study in a useful context. The early work by Kenneth Allott and Miriam Farris, The Art of Graham Greene (1951), though limited now in that it extends only through The Heart of the Matter, remains interesting and important as the first book-length study of Greene in English and an intelligent, lucid account of his obsessional themes and his emerging craftsmanship influenced by his admiration for James, Stevenson, and Conrad. My own indebtedness to Allott and Farris’s discussion of Greene’s interest in “the divided mind” will be obvious to anyone familiar with their work; although the topic has long been familiar in Greene studies, it could not be overlooked at the outset of the approach I have taken in chapter one. Among the briefer early studies, David Lodge’s Graham Greene (1966) is exemplary. Lodge sees the Catholicism in Greene’s fiction as not a body of belief requiring exposition and demanding categorical assent or dissent, but a system of concepts, a source of situation, and a reservoir of symbols with which he can order and dramatize certain intuitions about the nature of human experience—intuitions which were gained prior to and independently of his formal adoption of the Catholic faith. (6) In the novels that followed The End of the Affair, Lodge observes a weakening of the “challenge” by divine order to the “secular and cynical view of life,” and in The Comedians he finds evidence of “Greene’s progress from a fiction based upon a ‘tragic’ conflict between human and divine values, to fiction conceived in terms of comedy and irony in which the possibility
x
of religious faith has all but retreated out of sight in the anarchic confusion of human behavior” (44). John Atkins’s Graham Greene (1957; rev. 1966), A.A.DeVitis’s Graham Greene (1964; rev. 1986), Gwenn Boardman’s The Aesthetics of Exploration (1971), Roger Sharrock’s Saints, Sinners and Comedians (1984), Grahame Smith’s The Achievement of Graham Greene (1986), Brian Thomas’s An Underground Fate (1988), and V.V.B.Rama Rao’s Graham Greene’s Comic Vision (1990) are especially noteworthy. Atkins’s personal style of criticism is informal and often eccentric—he is antagonized to the point of distraction by Greene’s treatment of Catholicism, so that in one chapter he quotes statistics on crime to show that Catholics in fact behave rather worse than Protestants. Nevertheless, he demonstrates an intuitive grasp of connections between Graham Greene’s fiction and his personality and private life. Atkins describes Scobie, protagonist of The Heart of the Matter, as “a distorted reflection of his creator, a man who cannot disguise or hide his feelings. He can always be seen through” (159). This view of his work was not congenial to Greene, but after four decades and the appearance of several biographical studies, the evidence is in Atkins’s favor. DeVitis’s chief interest is in explaining “what use Graham Greene makes of religious subject matter and religious belief.” By “analyzing the place of religion in the overall pattern of his novels,” DeVitis traces “as far as possible—the development of his thought as it affects his art” (ii). The author’s works prior to 1938 are of interest to DeVitis “not only as fictions but frequently as preliminary sketches and as tentative efforts for those more serious works that beguile and enchant Greene’s readers” (iii). The “grand theme” of Greene is expressed in the three Catholic novels following Brighton Rock, concluding with The End of the Affair (1951), in which Greene progresses from melodrama into a greater psychological realism. In later books, Greene’s artistic maturity is evidenced by his greater dependence upon character rather than plot devices and his blending of “religious theme” and “overall pattern” so effectively that theme and plot become inseparable. In this way, DeVitis argues, Greene “developed the scope of the novel in England” (106) and became “the finest living writer in our language” (195).
xi
Gwenn Boardman, in The Aesthetics of Exploration (1971), adopts Bendrix’s metaphor and interprets Greene’s fiction as expressing his “artistic quest” through the “central metaphor of the map.” The author’s journeys to Liberia, Mexico, Indo-China, and the Congo mark stages of his artistic growth, Boardman says, and his writing records “his own explorations in terms of psychological as well as aesthetic exploration” (2). Thus, his journey to Liberia in the mid-1930s involved an exploration of the “region of the imagination” and contributed to Brighton Rock. Mexico, by intensifying his awareness of the emerging secular “civilization of hate” and the need to learn the lesson of God’s love, stimulated the remaining Catholic novels through The End of the Affair; Indo-China provided the occasion for Greene’s variation of the Jamesian conflict between old and new worlds, American innocence and European experience and, as his “Indo-China Journal” (1954) suggests, it moved him in the direction of comedy and an expression of the idea that “under the shadow of the Cross it is better to be gay” (3). Finally, his journey to the Congo “in search of a character” led to his acceptance of absurdity as a condition of contemporary life and his creation of a mature protagonist who confronts that absurdity, Querry in A Burnt-Out Case. Roger Sharrock, in Saints and Sinners and Comedians: The Novels of Graham Greene (1984), acknowledges the movement into comedy but asserts that “the novelist of spiritual dryness and despair has never been a novelist of the absurd” (25). Sharrock sees Greene’s novelistic career as consisting of two phases, with A Burnt-Out Case as the novel that inaugurates the second phase. The first phase was characterized by Greene’s treatment of Catholic themes of fallen humanity and the mysterious working of God’s grace, and—especially in the pre-World War II novels—a scope sufficiently narrow that its “personal obsessiveness” defined Greeneland, the fictive world in which “The hunted figure in a shabby mackintosh against a shabby urban background conveyed an impressive personal vision of a world evil and corrupt” (13). Sharrock does not undervalue this phase of Greene’s work; on the contrary, he sees Greene’s “great technical achievement” as the “elevation of the form of the thriller into a medium for serious fiction” (12). Nevertheless, Sharrock feels that this fertile but narrow field was insufficient to establish Greene as a “world writer” or to
xii
earn him “major status.” It remained unclear whether the world he depicted was an actual world or merely “the product of personal trauma” (14). The Greene of the later phase was, according to Sharrock, a superior artist whose scope broadened as he turned outward from himself and from England, entering “into his full maturity as a realistic writer drawing people and scenes in Asia, Africa, South America, and Hertfordshire which make the backgrounds of his earlier thrillers seem sketchy” (24). Greene, like his character Querry, turned away from “religious practice” in order to follow “his soul’s authenticity”; his novels drift steadily toward comedy and secularization. “We can define the later phase,” Sharrock contends, “by calling it not sectarianly Catholic, not dealing in the miraculous; less negatively we could see it as a body of fiction celebrating each meeting and departure of human beings in the world of nature as not casual but meaningful, therefore miraculous” (25). Sharrock defines the two phases stylistically and rhetorically as well as thematically. In the earlier “morality” phase, best represented by Brighton Rock and The Power and the Glory, Greene is able to control the tone of his novels by means of a rhetoric based on expressionist images, while his narrative scenes and transitions are sustained by the forms of the cinema (274). In the later, secularized phase, the “flowering” of which can be found in The Comedians and The Honorary Consul, a true realism is achieved, and the role of trains of poetic imagery subdued but not abandoned…. But all the time, quite apart from the use of similes or the exchange of melodrama for the believably quotidian, an urging of language has continued to eliminate self-consciousness by utterly bare and natural statement. (274) The function of this bareness of style is “to point to experience of which language cannot speak directly” (274). In The Achievement of Graham Greene (1985), Grahame Smith discusses a complex of related themes in Greene’s work— for example, the sadness of “personal relations permeated by the fear of betrayal, self-knowledge too long delayed, the missed opportunity” (216); the “terror of life’s unpredictability” counterpointed against a longing for “peace” (215); the “fusion of love and responsibility” (89)—in order to show that Greene’s
xiii
political, social, and religious themes interact in varying degrees throughout the novels. Smith is also concerned with the roots of Greene’s enormous popularity, which he attributes in part to Greene’s avoidance of the experimental techniques of the great modernists such as Joyce, Woolf, and Faulkner, and to Greene’s interest in and borrowing from the popular art of film. Smith finds a likely influence upon Greene in Dickens, one of several writers who achieved, as the Western and the thriller have done in film, the ability to “turn reality into myths of good and evil” (41). Greene’s major achievement in this vein is The Ministry of Fear, “where the ministry itself is transfigured by the intensity of Greene’s vision from an institution concerned with espionage to a mythic recreation of aspects of twentiethcentury life.” This finest of entertainments flawlessly blends the “excitement of the thriller with the insight of the novels” (41). The organization or pattern Smith sees in Greene’s novels may be summarized briefly: the first three novels, 1929–31, are romances; these apprentice works are followed first by a period of entertainments and early political novels (1932–36), then by a period of entertainments and Catholic novels (1939–1951) ushered in by the transitional Brighton Rock, and finally—after several works that are not classified by period—by the “later Greene,” beginning with The Honorary Consul (1970). More broadly, Smith sees Greene’s career as consisting of two major phases: [W]e might say that Greene’s first outstandingly creative period was marked by a visionary inwardness, a turning in on the self in order to make a fictional examination of spiritual issues. His second phase involved a move outwards to the public world of international politics. (181)
Consul thus marks, in Smith’s view, the fulfillment of artistic maturity which for DeVitis had occurred in earlier works like The End of the Affair. In Consul Greene “moves on to a plane of achievement which develops and combines the interests of earlier work in a fusion that is both a summation and a new departure. Distinctions such as entertainment, faith, politics or allegory…lose their separate identity in becoming the seamless web of a subtly blended whole” (176). The best book on Greene,
xiv
Allott and Farris’s, goes much deeper to discover that “the terror of life, a terror of what experience can do to the individual, a terror at a predetermined corruption, is the motive force that drives Greene as a novelist.” Smith agrees, “with the sole qualification that a writer as interesting as Greene is capable of being motivated by more than a single obsession.” Smith defines his own emphasis as “the effect of this terror, the emotion it generates within the books and for the reader” (215). Brian Thomas’s An Underground Fate (1988) sees a major transition in Greene’s fiction occurring around 1950, a shift from the tragic vision, especially in the Catholic novels prior to The End of the Affair, to a comic mode—not the comedy of existential absurdity but that of comic romance as defined by Northrop Frye in The Secular Scripture. The narrative pattern is that of the quest that moves from a journey into the underground toward a rebirth. V.V.Rama Rao finds a similar movement from tragic to comic in Graham Greene’s Comic Vision (1990), though Rao’s model comes not from Frye but from Susanne Langer’s theory of “tragic rhythm” (the “deathward advance” through unrecoverable stages of “growth, maturity, and decline”) and “comic rhythm” (the “vital rhythm of selfpreservation”). Greene’s novels evolve in three phases, Rao contends, which “may be analysed in terms of the artistic exploration of modes of experience; tragic, comic and tragicomic” (1). The tragic phase ends with Brighton Rock; A Burnt-Out Case marks the transition between tragicomedy and comedy. Rao’s assertion that Greene was able to mix comic and tragic rhythms in his work as great writers like Dante and Shakespeare had done is plausible, and in pointing to a drift toward the comic he shares the views of several other critics. At times, however, his argument is strained, as when he suggests that, as a grotesque figure, Pinkie in Brighton Rock “inevitably belongs to the world of farce” (51), or that Sarah’s death in The End of the Affair (a novel he says “soars high” with comedy) “makes for comedy” (96). (Robert Pendleton’s Graham Greene’s Conradian Masterplot (1996), a study of the pervasive influence of Conrad on Greene’s fiction, has not been considered here because it appeared after my own work was virtually complete.) It would probably be unwise to attribute exclusive validity to any single “pattern.” The movement toward comedy, the broadening of perspective toward “international” themes, the
xv
seeming displacement of religious concerns by political ones— such patterns in Greene’s work have been discussed plausibly and at considerable length and have become familiar in the way the “Catholic” readings of his works once were. In my own work I have tried to build upon these earlier discussions of Greene in order to emphasize qualities in his work which have been inadequately discussed or, in some cases, ignored altogether. I have adopted for convenience the predictable term phases because I believe that a revealing and important pattern in Greene’s work has gone unnoticed, and I have taken up the familiar subject of intertextuality in his novels because I believe that even though a great deal has been said about the topic, much remains that is both interesting and instructive. The study that follows, then, will be directed toward three primary concerns: First, I will examine the evolution of Greene’s career in terms of significant changes in the relationship between the novelist and his protagonists, from those first-phase protagonists, culminating in James Raven and Pinkie Brown, whose warped perspectives and complete alienation from life place them, ostensibly at least, at the greatest imaginable distance from their creator; to the second-phase protagonists whose increasing age, experience, education, and culture make them closer to the novelist himself. This second phase originates with D. in The Confidential Agent (1939) and culminates in a series of what I will call “portraits of the artist” through which Greene confronts more directly and personally the tensions and conflicts of his private life and also examines the role of the novelist as one who explores and exploits those tensions. I will suggest, second, that the letters and diaries written by Greene during his years as a fledgling novelist reveal not only the lifelong habit of allusion and borrowing but also the tendency to see both his own experience and that of his characters in what might be called a “literary frame” consisting of literary analogues or parallels invoked to shape and interpret experience. An examination of the letters, especially, reveals Greene in the dual role as author, one who persistently projects literary experience into his own view of life, and who subsequently projects both his experience and its “literary” interpretation into his created fiction.
xvi
Finally, I will suggest ways in which the later fiction (from Travels with My Aunt onward) moves toward a resolution, or at least a philosophical acceptance, of those tensions and conflicts that have plagued the real and figurative novelist in Greene’s portraits. In this period the fiction becomes increasingly reflexive as Greene revisits and examines old characters, themes, and settings. Monsignor Quixote treats the subject of religious faith with a spirit of affirmation unseen in Greene’s novels for at least three decades. In The Captain and the Enemy, the final novel, Greene returns once more to the subject of writing and the figure of the artist. It should perhaps be pointed out that the space devoted to individual works does not reflect a judgment of their relative merit. I regard The Power and the Glory and The Honorary Consul, for example, as considerably superior to A Gun for Sale and Travels with My Aunt, although the latter books demand much more attention in the approach to the novels I have developed here. My approach to each of the two phases of Greene’s novels begins with a description of the qualities of the protagonists in that phase and progresses to a discussion of individual works.
Acknowledgements
I would like to express my gratitude to the College of Arts and Letters of James Madison University for the Edna Shaeffer Humanist Award which enabled me to complete this work far more easily than I could have done otherwise; to the Humanities Research Center at the University of Texas, Austin, for allowing me to examine the superb collection of Greene’s letters and manuscripts, and to Catherine Henderson and other members of the staff there for their efficient and friendly assistance; to Kristi Long, literary editor at Garland Publishing, and to Phyllis Korper, formerly of Garland, for advice and encouragement; to Father Leopoldo Duran, for permission to quote from his book Graham Greene: Friend and Brother; to South Atlantic Review and College Literature, for permission to reprint substantial portions of articles which appeared in those journals in 1983 and 1985, respectively; to Penguin-Putnam, for permission to quote from The Man Within, Stamboul Train, England Made Me, A Gun for Sale, Brighton Rock, The Power and the Glory, The Ministry of Fear, The Heart of the Matter, The Third Man, The End of the Affair, Loser Takes All, The Quiet American, Our Man in Havana, A Burnt-Out Case, The Comedians, Travels with My Aunt, The Captain and the Enemy, the Collected Stories and the Collected Essays of Graham Greene, and Norman Sherry’s Life of Graham Greene; to Simon and Schuster, for permission to quote from The Honorary Consul, The Human Factor, A Sort of Life, Ways of Escape, Dr. Fischer of Geneva, The Tenth Man, Monsignor Quixote, and Marie-Françoise Allain’s The Other Man: Conversations with Graham Greene; and especially to my wife, Betty, for her tireless support and wise counsel in every stage of the preparation of this work.
xviii
GRAHAM GREENE
CHAPTER ONE Protagonists of the First Phase
YOUTH
Stamboul Train (1932) and It’s a Battlefield (1934) do not have single protagonists, but certain of their central characters, together with all of the protagonists of the other novels from Greene’s first-published novel The Man Within (1929) through Brighton Rock (1938) have several qualities which taken collectively distinguish them from those of the later works. First and most obviously, they are young men. Pinkie Brown, at seventeen, is the youngest, and Anthony Farrant, at thirtytwo, seems oldest and most experienced and the only one whose character is more or less fully formed. All of the others undergo experiences that change them or at least have the potential to do so in some significant way, and even Anthony is brought to a crisis in which a single moment of the clearsightedness that characterizes his sister Kate could radically alter the course of his future. Anthony maintains wistfully and, it turns out, prophetically that he does not have a future, and the same can be said about many of the young protagonists to be discussed in these pages: Andrews, Crane, Conrad, Raven, Pinkie. The sense of doom hangs so heavily over their youth that to imagine them maturing into old or even middle age is impossible for the reader, as it seems to have been for the author. In later works Greene’s characters will age as he does (though not as much), but the first-phase novels are centered around youthful protagonists.
2 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
DIVIDED SELVES
The youthful first-phase protagonists are further characterized by the self-division that afflicts them. Most sharply defined in these terms is Francis Andrews of The Man Within, whose story is a soul-struggle between the lustful, cowardly self shaped by his previous actions and the courageous man of integrity, the “man within” longing to emerge. Andrews’s selfdivision seems traceable in part to the parents whose qualities he has inherited—a harsh, brutal father and a quiet, gentle, affectionate mother whom the father mistreated—and it extends to his own perception of other characters. Carlyon, regarded by Andrews as both friend and enemy, is also a divided self, an apelike man with a romantic soul, a brute and a poet. The saintly Elizabeth, whom Andrews loves, and the sluttish Lucy, who seduces him away from his briefly-discovered virtue and courage, are perhaps less convincing as dramatic characters than as projections of Andrews’s immature understanding of human nature, although the text does not imply that Greene intended an irony of that sort. As variations of the familiar dichotomy of woman as madonna and whore, these characters participate in the duel of angels for Andrews’s soul. Andrews’s fatal cowardice may be usefully compared with that of another Francis and a contemporary in Greene’s fiction, the boy Francis Morton who dies of fright in “The End of the Party,” also published in 1929. Indeed, the kinship among the earliest protagonists is more conspicuous as a result of Greene’s use of similar names: the first names of Francis Andrews, Francis Morton, and Francis Chase (in Rumour at Nightfall); the last names Chant, Chase, Crane. In Oliver Chant, hero of Greene’s next novel The Name of Action (1930), the condition of self-division is less critical than in Andrews, as befits a novel in which romantic adventure is more important than psychology. Nevertheless, it is present in his mixed motives for his journey to Trier: he wants to be involved in the overthrow of a repressive dictatorship, but he also seeks to escape from boredom and to pursue his infatuation with the dictator’s wife, Anne-Marie, whom he has seen in a photograph; eventually his desire for Anne-Marie will jeopardize the very cause he has vowed to support. The duel of angels carried on through the characters of Elizabeth and Lucy in The Man Within is located more plausibly in this novel in the
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
3
mind of the protagonist, who at first imagines Anne-Marie Demassener as a paragon of virtue as surely as she is of womanly beauty. His later repulsion at the discovery of her lustfulness and her infidelity to her husband is symptomatic of his own immaturity and divided aims, since on some level of consciousness these must have been the very qualities he wanted to inspire in her. Kenneth Allott and Miriam Farris suggest plausibly in their study of Greene that Chant’s dual nature is represented in the novel by two sharply contrasted figures, the libertine revolutionary poet Kapper, and the puritanical dictator Demassener (67). Closer in spirit to The Man Within than to The Name of Action and less successful than either, Rumour at Nightfall (1931) is an almost allegorical treatment of the theme of selfdivision. The dual protagonists Chase and Crane are clearly two halves of a single personality: Crane, like Andrews, is cowardly and uncertain, temperamentally romantic and spiritual; his friend Chase is brave, rational, skeptical, secular. Chase has the ability to endure and to change; Crane must die, perhaps tragically and no doubt, in terms of the symbolic relationship between these incomplete personalities, necessarily: he is figuratively the imprisoned “man within” Chase who must die in order to be released. The duality of these characters extends to Eulelia Monti, the object of first Crane’s and then Chase’s affection. Known first (like AnneMarie) through a photograph, Eulelia is initially perceived as saintly and then suspected of sluttishness; in fact, she is a complex character who is deeply religious (Catholic) and in the main virtuous, although she once gave herself to the guerrilla leader Caveda in defiance of her mercenary mother, who had expected to profit from the marriage of the beautiful and virginal daughter. Like Francis Andrews, Eulelia traces the divided qualities of her own nature to her parents, but with the qualities reversed: a good, spiritual, intellectual father; an evil, sensual, greedy mother. Stamboul Train, the novel that followed Rumour at Nightfall, is so different from it in character, setting, pace, and narrative skill that it seems the work of another author altogether. Whereas the action of the earlier work was so internalized as to become virtually unintelligible at times, that of Stamboul Train is vivid, fast-paced, and sharply defined. The book is probably
4 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
the least psychological of the first-phase novels, but it contains nevertheless an echo of the divided self in the character of Carleton Myatt, whose impulse to kindness (he gives his sleeping compartment to Coral Musker, who is ill) is at odds with his willingness to accept sexual favors in return. Myatt is genuinely charitable to Coral, yet sees her selfishly as the means of satisfying the indiscriminate lust expressed through his dream of furtive sexual encounters with women on London’s Hampstead Heath. Further acquaintance with Coral only reveals his inability to reconcile spontaneous affection with calculated self-interest. His proposal to keep her as his mistress demonstrates the former, but his eventual decision to enter a marriage of expediency with Janet Pardoe shows that the latter will determine his actions. A sense of class and propriety prevents him from proposing marriage to Coral, yet his stated desire to make her a well-kept mistress has at least a foundation in real affection. Myatt is easily dissuaded from this ambition, however, and his calculating acceptance of a marriage with Janet Pardoe, arranged as part of a business deal that will further his financial interests, testifies to his willingness to value money over human feeling. It’s a Battlefield, with its multiple centers of interest, is closer in technique to Stamboul Train but closer in spirit to the earlier works, and it carries forward Greene’s concern with selfdivision in individuals and with paired or contrasted characters who represent opposite poles of personality. The pitiable Conder, who carries on during the day an elaborate charade of life as the father of a large family, only to return to his solitary room at night, is an example of the former. Conder’s double selfhood extends to his dual role as journalist and Communist party member; his apparent commitment to the party’s agenda masks his more important interest in getting a story, and his sense of his true identity falters in the presence of so many selves: “His personalities flickered so quickly that he was himself confused, uncertain whether he was the revolutionary, the intimate of Scotland Yard, or, a new part this, the master spy” (49). Mr. Surrogate, the Communist intellectual who is unable to unite his professed principles with his lifestyle (he writes leftist tomes and makes bold speeches but lives the life of a wealthy man of leisure and is unable to sympathize with or understand authentic working-class people), is a further
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
5
example of self-division. Similarly, the young and uncertain Jules Briton recalls both Andrews and Eulelia in tracing his opposed qualities to his parents (a puritanical English mother and a supposedly libertine French father) and resembles Myatt in his subordination of his love of a woman to his love of money: Jules wants, indeed plans, to marry Kay Rimmer but changes his mind upon realizing how quickly he is spending his small legacy from his father on her. More interesting than these single characters in Battlefield are the pairs whose contrasting qualities strongly suggest the halves of a complete individual. Jim Drover and his brother Conrad are most prominent in this regard. Jim is simple, brave, untroubled, and happily married—until his arrest for the murder of a policeman destroys his life and home. Conrad is complex, troubled, insecure, jealous; his intelligence and his hypersensitivity (connected with his name, for which schoolmates mocked him) have left him lonely and unhappy. Jim’s wife, Milly, and her sister, Kay Rimmer, form a similarly contrasted pair: Kay, a factory worker, is independent, single, untroubled, reckless in her pursuit of sexual pleasure to offset the numbing round of her work; Milly is domestic, shy, cautious, sensitive, and although she has been faithful and happy in her marriage, she eventually gives herself to Conrad out of sadness and physical desire. Kay is happily amoral and able to enjoy sexual pleasure because she dissociates it from love; Milly cannot do so and cannot take pleasure in her brief affair with Conrad, nor can he—although he loves Milly—escape sufficiently from guilt to experience pleasure. An impossible longing for union by two incomplete characters is at the heart of Greene’s next novel, England Made Me (1935). The central figures here, the twins Anthony and Kate Farrant, are doomed to failure and unhappiness by their incestuous love which only Kate is willing to acknowledge and accept. The failure is that of Anthony, a prodigal son who in his feckless, wandering life has been unable to achieve success or stability; in spite of his failure and his incurable dishonesty, however, he retains an antiquated idealism, a shadow of Victorian morality, that makes him far less able than Kate to compete in the modern world of the novel. Anthony’s dilemma is further expressed in the symbolic opposition of the two women with whom he is involved: the worldly Kate and the provincial “Loo”
6 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
Davidge, who is hopelessly innocent in spite of her willful assumption of sophisticated attitudes toward sexuality. Kate is the stronger, surer twin: steady, hard-working, with greater confidence and self-understanding, much more honest than Tony because she does not rely on fakery (the tall stories, the Harrow tie) in personal relations, and much more willing to accept the modern world on its own terms. In this last regard she resembles Anne-Marie Demassener as seen by Oliver Chant —someone who belongs to the modern age. James Raven, protagonist of the fast-paced entertainment A Gun for Sale (1936), is more memorable as the icy assassin to whom murder “didn’t mean much” than as a serious variation on Greene’s theme of self-division. For the most part he is drawn with very broad strokes that emphasize the connection between his impoverished, brutalized childhood and his life of crime. Yet Raven is also a preliminary sketch for one of Greene’s most psychologically complex characters—Pinkie of Brighton Rock—and Raven himself calls attention to his own dim awareness of the deep conflicts of his inner life. “I was reading once…something about psicko, psicko”—he tells Anne Crowder (124), and the reader senses that within his murderous heart there is, if not the “man within” of Greene’s earlier writing, certainly a “child within” whose memory gives depth and poignancy to Raven’s situation. For Raven’s character encompasses, as will Pinkie’s in Greene’s next novel, the division between the cold-blooded murderer and the suffering child; that is why the two books incorporate Greene’s earliest ironic allusions in the novels to Wordsworth’s “Immortality Ode” and its recollection of the paradise from which the child emerges “trailing clouds of glory”; and it is why Raven’s death, arguably the bitterest and most painful in all of Greene’s writing, is described through an elaborate simile of childbirth: Death came to him in the form of unbearable pain. It was as if he had to deliver this pain as a woman delivers a child, and he sobbed and moaned in the effort. At last it came out of him and he followed his only child into a vast desolation. (170)
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
7
The “child within” Raven is one who loves kittens, responds with pitiful eagerness to the prospect of friendship and affection, demonstrates intense loyalty to the one person (Anne Crowder) who has been kind to him, and dreams of a quasifilial relationship with the kindly old man he has murdered: “Shoot, dear child” the victim says to him in the dream. “We’ll go home together. Shoot” (123; italics added.) While it would be easy to exaggerate the extent to which this brisk narrative reveals the potential for goodness in him, it seems true nevertheless that Raven, who was an orphaned child, occupies a symbolic middle ground between the book’s two other prominent orphans, both of whom represent, as old men, the fulfillment of their opposed natures: the Liberal humanitarian Minister whom Raven assassinates and the wicked capitalist Sir Marcus who has plotted the event in order to further his company’s interests and satisfy his own greed. It is significant that the two were friends as children and that Sir Marcus, in turning toward evil, had symbolically betrayed his childhood friend long before plotting the literal betrayal. (A similar form of betrayal will be seen later in The Third Man in the remembered pasts of Rollo Martins and Harry Lime, who were close childhood friends. Harry has betrayed his friend’s ideal, but in this case it is the virtuous Rollo who kills his old companion.) The form of division seen in Raven—inside him is not the “man within who is angry with me” but the wounded, suffering child whose anguish has made adult acceptance of the world impossible—is given its fullest expression in Pinkie Brown of Brighton Rock, Greene’s first Catholic protagonist and his first of many characters who are failed priests. As a former choir boy who once wanted to become a priest in order to protect himself from the horror of life (especially sexual life) he fears, Pinkie has rejected the divine, heavenly Father for a criminal, earthly one, the mobster Kite. At seventeen Pinkie is a child-man, a believer who trusts no one, not even God; more than any of Greene’s characters since Andrews and Crane, Pinkie longs for peace, but he is fatally determined to attain it on his own terms before accepting the peace of God. What distinguishes Brighton Rock as the culmination of Greene’s treatment of divided selves in the first-phase novels is the way in which various rhetorical and structural elements in the work express, develop, and parallel the polarities within the
8 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
protagonist. Those polarities are expressed rhetorically by the often-discussed oxymorons that both describe Pinkie and link him symbolically with the world-view that pervades the novel: his “young-old” face, the “annihilating eternity” of his grey eyes, his “scared lust” and the “fear” that “straightened in him like lust”—all give shape to his complex and troubled inner life. When a gull sweeps through the “iron nave of the Palace Pier… half-vulture and half-dove” (131) as Pinkie thinks of his marriage, the submerged metaphor (Pier as cathedral) subtly links Pinkie’s duality (child, priest-child, dove vs. murderer, vulture) with that of the larger world of Brighton Rock. Structurally and thematically a corresponding duality is expressed in the novel in two primary ways: by the crosscutting between the world of Pinkie (Catholic, figuratively subterranean, joyless, irrational, permeated by evil) and that of his nemesis Ida Arnold (pagan and superstitious, sunny, pleasurable or fun-loving, insistent upon rational concepts of right and wrong, justice and/or revenge); and by the almost schizophrenic ordering of images, symbols, and ideas into the sacred and the profane—the lost world that was informed by the religious sense, and the modern world of secular values. Greene establishes the pattern by setting the opening action of Hale’s murder on the religious holiday Whitmonday, the bank holiday after Whitsun, or Pentecost. From this occasion and its reminder of the way in which the modern “holiday” has betrayed the “holy day” from which it was derived, Greene develops a story in which his familiar conception of self-division within the protagonist extends into a view of the world at large, a world whose outlines may be signified in a brief listing of the stated and implied contrasts through which it is revealed: Sacred
Secular
Holy Day (Whitsun) Cathedral Pinkie as choir-boy, child, priest Dove Holy Ghost Rose Oil of extreme unction Good and evil
Holiday (Bank Holiday) Palace Pier Pinkie as gangster, murderer Vulture Ida’s “ghosts” Ida Pinkie’s bottle of vitriol Right and wrong
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
Sacred
Secular
Mercy The old priest
Revenge or justice The old lawyer Prewitt
9
The youthful Pinkie and his even younger bride Rose continue Greene’s use of “two children” figures (Francis and Peter Morton, the young Anthony and Kate Farrant) and of characters who in their closeness and unique correspondence seem halves of one incomplete self. Jack Biles has commented on this aspect of doubling in Brighton Rock: Rose and Pinkie make up the principal double [in the novel]…. Despite their having thoroughgoing antitheses of character and outlook, Greene fuses Rose and Pinkie into a modern instance of “the Platonic, or epipsychean, longing for the unification of the severed halves of man.” Rose and Pinkie are man and wife; hence, both church and state see them as one flesh. Her name-color suggests to many people pink rather than red or white, as in rosé, a pinkish table wine; the inference seems warranted, for Rose and Pinkie then have identical given names as well as the surname Brown, a condition underscoring the oneflesh conception. They even look alike in their meagerness, boniness, and shabbiness. And in the pub where they go for a drink after the wedding, Pinkie sees Rose and himself as a “double image in the mirror” behind the bar. Like all symbolic twins (doubles), they “are both divine and mortal, black and white,” positive and negative, an inversion-symbol of the alternation of light and darkness, life and death, appearance and disappearance. (34–35) Biles further points out, as numerous commentators have done before him, the importance of Pinkie’s discovery that Rose’s goodness is somehow essential to the fulfillment of his own evil nature. Rose’s identical slum origins and her comparably miserable family life have not weakened her obedient faith or soured her essentially hopeful view of life; in that sense she creates a
10 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
counterweight to the strong pull of naturalism in the conception of Pinkie’s character; moreover, as will be discussed later, she seems capable of bringing about change in him. Her potential for doing so, and the care with which that potential is linked through the novel’s imagery with the religious themes that appear full-blown here for the first time in Greene’s work, suggest another way in which Brighton Rock represents the culmination of development of the first-phase protagonists. WOMEN AND REDEMPTION All but one of the first-phase novels offer the prospect that the male protagonist’s crises and/or conflicts may be escaped or resolved through his relationship with a woman. Greene establishes this pattern in The Man Within, where the beautiful and saintly Elizabeth not only cares for Andrews, hides him, and shelters him but responds to his higher, inner self by trusting in his capacity for courage and integrity. Elizabeth moves Andrews toward a redemption of his own cowardly and dishonest past by persuading him to testify in court against the smugglers who were his comrades. Because she demonstrates the innocence, faith, and courage that Andrews so miserably lacks, he sees her as “so clear, so terribly sane,” while he is “twisted” (182). “I envy you,” he says to her; “You seem so certain, so sane, at peace” (188). She tries to convince him of the reality of his own better nature (“Why do you always make so little of the good you do, and so much of the bad?” [188]), and he recognizes the change in himself under her influence: “You are filling me with yourself. That means courage, peace, holiness” (189). The attribute of “holiness” is one of many indicators of the extent to which the primarily secular redemptions of Greene’s first two novels acquire religious overtones. Elizabeth, who appears early in the novel as “a saint surrounded by white birds,” and who explains to Andrews that her determination to remain chaste before marriage involves “a belief in God” which she “can’t alter” even for him (196), is so emphatically a religious figure that the prospect of his change begins to seem like a religious conversion, which it is not. Clearly it is through Elizabeth that Andrews has real hope of directing his life onto its proper course, but in Lewes, without the strengthening influence of her presence, he reverts to his
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
11
lustful and cowardly ways, sleeping with the trollop Lucy and abandoning Elizabeth to the menace of the gang of smugglers. Andrews, then, is not redeemed, yet much of the plot’s interest turns upon our ability (and his and Elizabeth’s) to believe that he could have been. Oliver Chant, in The Name of Action, is if anything even more insistent upon the idea that through a woman—in this case Anne-Marie Demassener—he will be able to give meaning and validation to the life he has believed to be worthless. Chant’s problem is not a ruined past of which he is ashamed but rather the boredom and meaninglessness of life as he has experienced it in the dull round of London drawing rooms. From such a life and the spiritual nullity of modern existence—“a life of which he had grown inexpressibly tired, a life without meaning, without risk and without beauty” (72)—he hopes, albeit in an adolescent romantic fashion, that Anne-Marie will save him: [H]e had not himself known for what he had hoped. Some undefined desire to make her depend on him for safety, to show her that he was at least something to be regarded with interest by the most uninterested eyes, was all that he could grasp. Now every second those hopes were deserting him with a measurable speed. If there were twelve hours more of silence he must return to London, to Mrs. Meadmore’s and a succession of incurious friends who would not have noticed his absence…. (168) Contrasting Anne-Marie with the devout Catholic and domestic Frau Weber, Chant reflects: “They were born in an age of doubt and to a class which wished to know too much. She would never make ‘a good wife and a good Catholic’ in that calm, tender, and unquestioning way, nor he a ‘good husband’” (257). Any redemption which Chant might hope to attain through AnneMarie, then, is secular and is offered as the only possible one in the secular age in which they live. Indeed, what he longs for becomes almost a substitute religion, for his emotions are consistently felt in terms suggestive of religious devotion. We see it, for example, in the pivotal garden scene:
12 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
“You have come,” he said in such a voice of wonder, almost fear, as might belong to an unbeliever whose mechanical prayer had been completely granted. (84) and in Chant’s willed effort to elevate his love to the level of actual worship: “I love you,” he was saying. “I swear to you that I will never question what you do. I will never ask what you mean. I will never try to know you more than you want to be known. I love you as men have loved God.” He meant that he would never try to bring a light into the mystery of who and what she was, and he forgot that men have always tried to solve the mystery of God, whether by mathematics or by prayers, by astronomy or by fastings. (259) and again in his conviction of the holiness of his purpose as he awaits her in a church near the end of the novel: “O God, O God,” he murmured, not praying to the figure before him, but still conversing with himself, “I wish that I could believe in Your infinity…. They talk of marriage as a sacrament, and I want to marry her. I am here for that. There is something holy in my purpose.” (264–65) The romantic Michael Crane in Rumour at Nightfall discovers a similarly holy purpose in his relationship with the mysterious heroine, Eulelia Monti. As Allott and Farris have pointed out, Crane most resembles Francis Andrews among Greene’s protagonists for his mingling of fear with an intense longing for “peace.” “What do I always fear?” he says to his friend and alterego Chase early in the novel (69). Crane’s answer to his own question—“Danger, pain… Death”—emphasizes physical cowardice, but the further unfolding of his character reveals at the center of his unhappiness a more abstract and generalized terror of life, of the “dark vigil of the future” (138) and the anxieties and uncertainties inseparable from human experience. The escape, even momentary, from this complex fear defines for Crane the meaning of “peace.” In the past he has pursued peace through flight and evasion, or through sexual
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
13
pleasure—“the nullity of a satiated body”—ways of escape that are always temporary. The novel traces his discovery, in Eulelia, of the prospect of an enduring peace. The uneven course of the brief relationship between these lovers, conveyed unfortunately in some of the worst writing in all of Greene’s novels, bears more than a passing resemblance to that of Chant and Anne-Marie. Crane, attracted to Eulelia by her photograph (as Chant was drawn to Anne-Marie), experiences in his first meeting alone with her a fleeting moment of the “peace” he has long desired. He links this experience and his admiration for her with a sense of her virtue and “rectitude” as well as her beauty, only to undergo a painful disillusionment upon learning that she has been the lover of the outlaw Caveda. Yet his pain causes him to consider the possibility that his cowardice, his fear of life, may in fact be paradoxically a measure of his humanity: I have had truth, he said to himself, and it has brought me pain. I am not yet ready for truth. We live all our life with evasions…. He wondered: If I had felt no pain when I heard that she had lain with Caveda, should I have been happy? And the question robbed him of passivity. No, no, he almost cried aloud, this pain is precious; if I had felt no pain, I should have been damned indeed. There would have been nothing human left in me…. And for the first time it occurred to him: Because I am a coward, am I fortunate? Are these terrors that I know await me to-day, to-morrow and every future day until I die, not my good fortune, the blessing of my birth, because I enjoy perhaps more keenly than others the alleviations? I am on the borders now of that cold inhuman land; I have only to relinquish pain, to know the truth and not to care, and I need never fear again. (155) From this realization he progresses to the critical moment in which he must choose between the two forms of escape he has always known and the chance to attain a lasting peace through Eulelia: I’ve been offered a woman, he thought, and I’ve been offered flight. Is the one any better than the other? Will
14 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
one last longer? and he remembered with a sense of homesickness the peace he had found that morning. That peace had lasted for seconds only, but he could recognize in it a quality of timelessness, which flight could not possess. Those seconds might have never ended; they might have become eternity…he had become conscious of the existence of peace, but the peace had been there always, not bounded by the walls of the room, which was tagged down by every nail, by every board, by every picture to space and time, not enclosed even in the body of Eulelia Monti, a body which belonged to San Juan and the man who caressed it, but bounded only, if the infinite can be a boundary, by the belief in the mind of the woman. But if I leave, he thought, I belong to time…. (174) At Chase’s urging he chooses flight, only to turn back after meeting Eulelia once more and accepting the fact that her love has altered him, that he has no “home” apart from her. Crane’s apprehension of this change within himself is presented in an elaborate simile linking Eulelia with a figure much admired by Greene, St. Joan of Arc: He had the sense that she was driving him back upon his final defenses. He had built up so many barricades of cowardice, fears, evasions, that he had thought the citadel impregnable. The citadel, he supposed, was truth, sincerity, self-knowledge. Now his defenses crumbled before the very simplicity of her assault. He had been prepared for any degree of guile or of the treachery of friends, but he had not been ready for a woman who came like St. Joan, where the wall was thickest, to touch it with the tip of her banner. (210–11) For the now-defenseless Crane the redemptive love of this St. Joan figure makes religious faith possible. As Greene had done with Chant in Action, he locates the critical moment of intersection between belief and love in a church, where Crane, like Chant, voices his urgent desire to marry his beloved. Unlike Chant, however, Crane reaches a stage of belief well beyond Chant’s vague sense of “holy purpose.” The difference is
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
15
apparent in Crane’s response when the priest is reluctant to marry them immediately: “We are both old enough to know our minds. Is it that I am not a Catholic? Tell him I will become that or anything. I believe now, in this moment. Isn’t that enough? If I lose you, I lose faith. I can believe in mystery with you here, in God upon the altar, in God upon the tongue. Let him marry us while I believe.” (217) In The Man Within and The Name of Action Greene had presented secular concepts of redemption that acquire the aura of religious experience through the setting (the scene in church in Name) or the saintliness of the women in question (real in the case of Elizabeth, imagined in the case of Anne-Marie). In Rumour at Nightfall, however, he moves his protagonist toward a more authentic religious conversion that anticipates the Catholic novels just as it bears strong and obvious resemblance to the experience of the author who embraced Catholicism because of his passionate love for a woman. Even so brief an initiation into the mysteries of Catholic faith alienates Crane from Chase, his alter-ego or double as discussed earlier. In Chase’s view Crane is now in league with priests, crucifixes, ecstasies, flames, and damnation, and as a result the two friends will no longer be able to communicate. Chase’s attitude may well be correct, but Crane’s death on the night of his wedding not only obviates the need for that form of “communication” but transfers to the worldly Chase the dual legacy of both the beautiful Eulelia (whom Chase will marry) and the greater mystery of the faith (Chase wants to “share the pain” of his dead friend, implying that he has been united with Eulelia and a more profound experience of life through the suffering of his friend). Crane’s death therefore performs implicitly the imitation of Christ. The similarity of theme and the disheartening progression represented by Greene’s second and third novels—each less successful artistically and commercially than its predecessor— may account in part for the diminished power of women as redeemers in the next three novels, and it is not merely coincidental that in two of these works (Stamboul Train and England Made Me) the link between Catholic belief and the
16 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
protagonist’s redemption is missing entirely. Yet these three works also hold out the prospect that the protagonist’s crises and/or conflicts may be escaped or resolved through his relationship with a woman. Carleton Myatt, the insecure Jewish currant merchant in Stamboul Train, discovers in the chorus girl Coral Musker someone who satisfies both his sexual longing and his need for self-esteem. Inexperienced and unconfident with women, Myatt is attracted by the superficial charms of Janet Pardoe, the beautiful but shallow lover of Mabel Warren, yet Coral’s simple friendliness and vulnerability give him confidence: “…I should be dumb before [Janet], he thought. I could not talk to her easily as I can to Coral; I should be conscious of my hands, of my race; and with a wave of gratitude he turned to Coral, ‘You’re good to me’” (99). Coral is ill (an affliction of the heart, appropriate to the unhappy outcome of her relationship with Myatt), and after Myatt gives her his sleeping compartment for the night she repays his generosity by yielding up her virginity to him out of a naive sense of worldly propriety. Myatt’s anticipation of their first night together brings into focus several conflicting elements in his own nature: he weighs the idea of romantic intrigue and seduction acquired from his reading with the mundane reality of his existence (he is not handsome, he is growing fat, and he travels “in currants and not with a portfolio of sealed papers” [120]); in addition he vacillates between his belief that she is “common” (“you can find her any night on the Spaniards road”) and his awareness that she has brought a freshness and pleasant unfamiliarity to his life: He began to think of her as he had never thought before of any woman who was attainable: she is dear and sweet, I should like to do things for her. It did not occur to him for several moments that she had already reason for gratitude. (121) Nothing about their relationship is idealized or spiritualized, yet the genuine affection between the two suggests that Coral could bring to Myatt a form of happiness and security he is unlikely to find elsewhere. Coral accepts Myatt’s offer to support her as his mistress in a London flat, but their
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
17
prospective happiness is thwarted when Coral is captured along with Dr. Czinner by the police in Subotica. Myatt attempts to rescue her but fails, and he is able to forget her altogether when the seemingly inaccessible Janet is offered to him through a marriage to be arranged by Stein, her uncle and Myatt’s business partner. Loneliness similar to Myatt’s can been seen in Battlefield in the person of Jules Briton, who in private moments feels the alienation of “one abandoned by his mother’s death to fight his way in a land which was his only by the accident of birth” (47). Alone, Jules is “lost,” melancholy, frightened of his own loneliness: “Only a woman, only a noise, only a gramophone playing or people talking could save him then from sinking back, back into himself…” (46). Oliver Chant’s linking of the religious impulse and the love of a woman arises from his own imagination rather than from any religious qualities in the woman herself. Jules makes a similar error: his sense of the saving power of a woman who could protect him from his own melancholy is focused somewhat ironically on the promiscuous Kay Rimmer. With Kay in the car beside him, he is distracted by the thought that he will “never be alone again” and has difficulty keeping his eyes on the road (144). Unlike Oliver Chant, Jules is a religious person who does not misunderstand the character of the woman he loves: “He felt no bitterness that he was not the first man she had known; one did not expect as much when wages were so low, employment so precarious, everything which made life worth living, the cinema, the dance hall, powder and scent and rouge and stockings, so dear” (149). Jules longs to set Kay free from the drudgery of the factory work that has led her to pursue pleasure as a form of escape. In the alien world of the Soho cafe where he works, he is distracted from his best and deepest longings; he wants to redeem his life through action, to find “something he could follow with passion…to be saved from the counter and the tea urn, the ‘Weights’, and the heartless flippancy of the café” (40– 41). Only in the church—“the only France he knew”—does he feel sufficiently “at home” to concentrate his thoughts upon serious purpose: In the café the day before he had been uninterested, all his mind absorbed with the need of remembering things,
18 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
but in the church while the wine was made blood, the most unlikely things seemed possible, emotion came easily, the desire for sacrifice, the desire for love, the desire for tenderness. (140) Thus it is in the church that Jules, in meditation, unites his ideals of political action (to free Jim Drover from jail) and of love (to “free” Kay Rimmer from an oppressive life): “Jules, praying for Drover, thought of Kay. He joined her life to his (the tea urn and the counter and the cigarettes), her life of eight to five tending a machine, in a mutual dissatisfaction. He wanted to release her, to release Drover” (140). In the context of the novel’s concern for social and economic justice, the joining of these two ideals is appropriate, for Greene presents Drover’s literal imprisonment and Kay’s figurative imprisonment as consequences of the same unjust organization of society. In England Made Me the protagonist’s longing to escape the crises toward which his life is moving is linked with his romantic interest in a young woman he identifies with the England that made him. Anthony Farrant, working in Stockholm as bodyguard to his sister’s lover Erik Krogh, is both geographically and temporally displaced in the emphatically modern world of international finance. He forms a brief relationship with “Loo” Davidge, a Coventry girl traveling with her parents. When Anthony’s tenuous links with England and his identification with the past there are further threatened by the pressure of Kate’s passion and his own discovery of largescale corruption in Krogh’s affairs, he promises to return to England to meet Loo in Coventry—for him a symbolic return to security and a sense of moral order. Raven, in A Gun for Sale, is prevented by his ugliness and alienation from forming any genuinely romantic relationships, yet the novel suggests strongly that his radical disaffection could be altered by the ability to believe that one young woman —Anne Crowder, whom he abducts from the railway station in Nottwich—could be his sympathetic friend. Only the faintest shadow of the old sourness and isolation touched his spirits. She’s straight, he swore with almost perfect conviction, she wouldn’t grass, we are together in
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
19
this, and he remembered with a sense of doubtful safety how she had said, “We are friends.” (150) The long confession scene in which Raven admits to Anne that he is a murderer and then recounts the worst horrors of his childhood illustrates precisely the impulse described contemptuously by Crane in Rumour: It was extraordinary…how men who denied religion still seemed to retain the crying need of absolution. They would pour out their sins, not to a priest, but to a woman, and thought themselves purified by her comfort, the vulgar comfort of pity and admiration. (146) Anne’s eventual betrayal of Raven destroys both his desire to live and his potential for change. It is a measure of the emotional power of the book that Greene is able to persuade us that such a change, however unlikely, is truly possible and only so through the agency of a woman. In this regard, as in several others, A Gun for Sale prefigures Brighton Rock, the novel in which once again the reader’s ability to believe in the possibility that a woman might bring about change in a young, murderous, alienated protagonist is essential to a grasp of the author’s themes. Brighton Rock fuses many of the most prominent features and concerns of Greene’s first-phase novels: social consciousness, murder and betrayal, alienation, lost children, the Catholic faith, the image of woman as redeemer. As might be expected in a work in which the religious theme is prominent, the possibility of change is specifically linked with confession, repentance, and the sacraments. The possibility of Pinkie Brown’s repentance generates much suspense in the second half of the novel; the important question becomes not whether Pinkie will be caught, but whether he will be saved. Thus, the drama of salvation which had appeared openly in The Man Within and Rumour at Nightfall, and, more tentatively, in both religious and secular contexts in the other works of the first phase, occupies the heart of the novel in Brighton Rock. Greene focuses attention on the question of salvation by setting the murder which opens the novel on the Bank Holiday Monday for Whitsun, or Pentecost, the day which
20 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
commemorates the descent of the Holy Spirit to Christ’s apostles. Pinkie’s story thus becomes a spiritual conflict in which his possible salvation is revealed dramatically through his relationship with Rose and metaphorically through bird images suggestive, in this context, of the dove in whose likeness the Holy Spirit descended to Christ (Matthew 3:16). An early instance of this imagery occurs when Spicer walks beneath the Palace Pier, contemplating his remorse over the murder of Hale and his fear of being caught: A seagull flew straight towards him between the pillars like a scared bird caught in a cathedral, then swerved out into the sunlight from the dark iron nave…. He stumbled on an old boot and put his hand on the stones to save himself: they had all the cold of the sea and had never been warmed by sun under these pillars. (85) The comparison of Pier and cathedral adds another dimension to the pervasive ironic contrast between sacred and profane in Brighton Rock, for the Palace Pier is a modern shrine of the secular world that worships peep shows, shooting galleries, and other cheap amusements. Greene reinforces this contrast later when Pinkie and Dallow approach the pier. Dallow urges Pinkie to relax and join him in the pleasures of a nearby roadhouse; Pinkie, preoccupied by thoughts of his two murders as well as his impending marriage, pauses to contemplate the scene: An old man went stooping down the shore, very slowly, turning the stones, picking among the dry seaweed for cigarette ends, scraps of food. The gulls which had stood like candles down the beach rose and cried under the promenade. The old man found a boot and stowed it in his sack and a gull dropped from the parade and swept through the iron nave of the Palace Pier, white and purposeful in the obscurity: half vulture and half dove. In the end one always had to learn. “All right, I’ll come,” the Boy said. (130–31; italics added) The ambivalence of the final image reflects strikingly the state of mind of a tortured youth who grew up an unloved child in a
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
21
miserable slum ironically named “Paradise Piece,” and who is torn between the ministry of the Holy Spirit and the memory of Kite, his spiritual father in the Brighton underworld. Appropriately, Kite’s name is that of a predatory bird, the antithesis of the descending dove. Denied affection as a child, Pinkie is unable to give or receive love and is thus morally and spiritually crippled. At first he despises Rose and her seeming naiveté; yet it is through her love that he comes closest to repentance, to the receiving of the Holy Spirit and, thus, to the peace for which he longs. Against his will he is drawn to her by a kinship rooted in the Catholic heritage he cannot escape. It will be recalled that the Holy Spirit descended to Christ’s Apostles in part because they gathered “with one accord”—united in a shared belief that set them apart from the rest of the community. Rose and, ironically, the murderer Pinkie are similarly isolated by their Catholicism from the pagan world of Brighton: “They were two Romans together in the grey street. They understood each other” (166). Knowing that their “state-made ceremony” constitutes mortal sin, Pinkie is drawn closer to Rose because only she shares his feeling: “[H]e was touched by the sense of communion between himself and Rose—she too knew that this evening meant nothing at all, that there hadn’t been a wedding” (170). Rose’s moving confession that she has no worldly possessions, nothing to offer but her love, becomes a vain effort to penetrate his armor of pride and bitterness. And Greene’s use of bird imagery to describe Pinkie’s response implies once more that Pinkie is resisting the Holy Spirit: “Her words scratched tentatively at the barrier like a bird’s claws on a window pane. He could feel her all the time trying to get at him: even her humility seemed to him a trap” (172). Although Rose’s love never completely overcomes Pinkie’s resistance, his hatred of her clearly weakens. Indeed, his inner conflict becomes more complex as he confronts the necessity of murdering Rose even when his loathing has begun to give way to affection. To Dallow the beginning of this change in the Boy now that Pinkie has a “girl” is nothing more significant than “growing up—like your father.” Pinkie’s reaction to this idea is a measure of the considerable changes that have followed his marriage: “He couldn’t blame his father now…it was what you came to…you got mixed up, and then, he supposed, the habit
22 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
grew… You gave yourself away weakly. You couldn’t even blame the girl” (220). With this admission, Pinkie becomes vulnerable to the feelings of tenderness, pity, and affection that conflict strongly with the “poison” and the terrible pride that have determined his conduct in the past. Thus, in the hotel at Peacehaven where he and Rose stop for a drink before they are to carry out the double suicide plan, Pinkie is aware that he is not repulsed by memories of his dreaded wedding, and that being in a tavern with his girl could actually be a pleasant moment: This was the kind of moment one kept for memory—the wind at the pier end, Sherry’s and the men singing, lamplight on the harvest Burgundy, the crisis as Cubitt battered at the door. He found that he remembered it all without repulsion; he had a sense that somewhere, like a beggar outside a shuttered house, tenderness stirred, but he was bound in a habit of hate. (231) The same tenderness stirs again when Pinkie overhears two men at the bar speak insultingly of Rose, but the “habit of hate” is once again too strong; he leaves the tavern still determined to carry out his plan. The climax of Pinkie’s spiritual conflict comes as the two drive on in the rain at Peacehaven. For one last time he resists the human love that prepares the heart for divine love, and in so doing he renounces God’s peace and the ministry of the Holy Spirit. Once more Greene uses the image of a bird to symbolize that great power against which Pinkie struggles: It was quite true—he hadn’t hated her; he hadn’t even hated the act. There had been a kind of pleasure, a kind of pride, a kind of—something else. The car lurched back on to the main road; he turned the bonnet to Brighton. An enormous emotion beat on him; it was like something trying to get in; the pressure of gigantic wings against the glass. Dona nobis pacem. He withstood it, with all the bitter force of the school bench, the cement playground, the St. Pancras waiting-room, Dallow’s and Judy’s secret lust, and the cold unhappy moment on the pier. If the glass broke, if the beast—whatever it was—got in, God
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
23
knows what it would do. He had a sense of huge havoc— the confession, the penance and the sacrament—and awful distraction, and he drove blind into the rain. (239– 40) Pinkie’s rejection of Rose and of the redemptive power that her love represents is a final manifestation of his pride—of the belief that he can attain through his own efforts and on his own terms that peace which in fact does not exist apart from God. At this crucial moment he might have begun the movement toward God that could change his eternal destiny, if not his earthly one. Instead he persists in his infernal plan to destroy the only person who loves him. When Ida and the police arrive in time to save Rose, Pinkie’s brief journey from Paradise Piece to Peacehaven ends not with the leap of faith but with the terrible, fatal leap into the sea. MARRIAGE IN THE FIRST PHASE The frequency with which Greene’s first-phase protagonists seek to resolve their deepest conflicts through relationships with women makes especially ironic a characteristic shared by all of them: they cannot marry successfully, or, as is more often the case, they cannot marry at all Francis Andrews’s dream of a marriage with Elizabeth is thwarted by his own cowardice. His weakness leads first to her death and then to his own, both suicides. And although Andrews is drawn with sufficient skill and subtlety to make convincing the prospect of his change under Elizabeth’s influence, one might ask seriously whether the reader should be expected, or was intended, to give credibility to the prospect of a future for this pair in the “enchanted cottage” setting the novel provides. Oliver Chant’s passion for Anne-Marie is curtailed not by his own but by her weakness and lust—qualities that are revealed to have compromised her failed marriage with the dictator Paul Demassener. The novel does indeed contain very briefly one of the few portraits of happy marriage in the first phase—that of the Webers—but as Allott and Farris have remarked, the good Frau is utterly devoid of sex appeal, and the early novels invariably separate romantic love from domestic marital happiness and fidelity (70–71).
24 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
In his ill-fated marriage to Eulelia Monti, Michael Crane expects to find the peace of mind he has long sought. In spite of the danger of the moment, the narrative holds out for a few pages the suggestion that such an ideal union is indeed possible, but in the end it is not: on the very night of his wedding Crane is shot by Caveda’s men, an indication that the peace he seeks can be found only in death. Chase inherits his friend’s bride, and their implied union provides a subdued but nominally happy ending, although their marriage will take place offstage, after the conclusion of the novel. As discussed earlier, Myatt never intends to marry Coral, the woman with whom he has at least a credible prospect of a stable and happy relationship. They are separated following the arrest of Dr. Czinner, and Myatt’s caution and his mercenary heart lead him to an arranged marriage with Janet Pardoe, the niece of a business partner. Myatt’s motives, together with Janet’s vacuous character and her recent lesbian relationship, leave no basis for the belief that a fruitful or meaningful relationship can develop through this marriage. Indeed, Myatt never imagines Janet as more than a suitable prop for the domestic establishment of a successful businessman. Stamboul Train, then, is not seriously concerned with marriage at all; It’s a Battlefield, however, is more remarkable than any of the earlier books for its failed, thwarted, or unhappy marriages. At the center of this novel is the marriage of Jim and Milly Drover, which once had every reason to be happy except for Milly’s inability to believe that happiness could last: Her happiness had always been shot through with touches of malice. Her husband contented with his job and his pay had been the Communist; not Milly, contented with nothing but his love, suspicious of the whole world outside. She had never believed that they would be left alone to enjoy each other. (65) It is a bitter irony that Jim’s crime in defense of Milly—he has killed a policeman he believed was going to hurt her—brings about the loss of her happiness and his. His imprisonment for eighteen years is a less happy outcome than his execution
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
25
would have been; when he and Milly are rejoined, they will be middle-aged—a condition the author himself seems to have regarded as unthinkable at this time—and their potential for marital happiness will have been wasted. The prison chaplain explains this sense of loss to the Assistant Commissioner after Jim unsuccessfully attempts suicide: “Drover wasn’t afraid of death, but he’s very fond of his wife. She’ll be a middle-aged woman when he comes out of prison; do you think any woman can be faithful for eighteen years to a man she sees once a month? And they love each other” (200). In the meantime Conrad, the younger brother, is hopelessly in love with Milly, who in loneliness and sexual longing takes him into her bed one night in what may well be the least joyful scene of sexual love in all of Greene’s writing. Elsewhere in the novel, marriage seems either untenable or at best unenjoyable. Lady Caroline Bury appears to have been happy but is a widow; Mr. Surrogate preserves hypocritically the memory of his late wife, the one person who saw through the sham of his intellect and idealism; Jules Briton’s ambition to marry Kay Rimmer disappears abruptly as the cost of supporting her for even one weekend becomes clear to him. The Assistant Commissioner remains a confirmed bachelor, and the journalist Conder, whose stories of married life and fatherly responsibility are an elaborate charade, depicts married life as difficult and taxing. In England Made Me the incestuous love of Anthony and Kate Farrant has prevented either from forming a marriage or a permanent and genuine love relationship with another person. Anthony recalls nostalgically his cheap affairs with the prostitute Annette and an older woman named Mabel who paid him (in gifts, not cash) for companionship. Kate has used sex more pragmatically: her affair with Krogh, to whom she is both mistress and secretary, provides security and presumably sexual pleasure while it serves the long-term purpose of drawing Anthony to her; she does consent, late in the novel, to a marriage with Krogh, but that is purely a business arrangement and a legal strategy designed to prevent her from being required to testify against him in court if his fraudulent business deals should land him there. Anthony’s plan to rejoin Loo Davidge in Coventry may carry the wistful suggestion of possible marriage, but even before his death the sense of fatalism that hangs over his character, together with his own
26 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
conviction that he has no future, is a clear sign that no such marriage could ever take place. For James Raven, marriage is obviously unthinkable, since his hideous disfigurement precludes any romantic relationship with a woman. His brief friendship with Anne Crowder only accentuates the hopelessness of his condition in that regard. By contrast, Anne looks forward at the end of the novel to her marriage with the stolid police detective Mather, long-delayed but made possible at last by the reward money she receives for her role in the pursuit and killing of Raven. This marriage—or prospect—is the best in all of the books of the first phase, the youthfulness of the characters rendering it more appealing than that of Weber and his wife in The Name of Action. Even so, it is placed in ironic perspective by the repeated emphasis on Mather’s dullness and predictability and by the suggestion in the closing paragraphs that the “unshadowed happiness” of Anne’s return to the safety of London with Mather is a retreat into childish unreality. Anne becomes figuratively one of the children she sees from the train, and she is described as resembling a child “whose mother has died,” watching the family she must care for “without being aware that the responsibility is too great.” Moreover, her happiness is the final betrayal of Raven: “If his immortality was to be on the lips of living men, he was fighting now his last losing fight against extinction” (184). An even greater irony arises in A Gun for Sale from Greene’s treatment of the marriage of the mad defrocked clergyman Acky and his evil wife Tiny. They are in love, they are faithful and devoted, and their marriage has withstood the tests of time and adversity. (To find a comparably appalling portrait of domestic bliss between two despicable characters, readers would have to turn to the marriage of the comically loathsome Wackford Squeers in Dickens’s Nicholas Nickleby.) Pinkie Brown, for whom marriage, sexuality, women generally, and all physical contact and domestic intimacy are repulsive (he says he would rather hang than submit to marriage), represents the most corrosive attack on the idea of marriage to be found anywhere in Greene’s writings. In his embittered outlook can be found a distillation of almost every conceivable doubt and misgiving about marriage. Subjected as a child to the regular witnessing of “Saturday night ritual”
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
27
copulations of his parents, he has grown up—to age seventeen, at least—unloved, unhappy, and in fear and loathing of sexuality. And thus the complication of the plot, demanding that he marry Rose (as Kate had planned to marry Krogh) to protect himself from her testimony, provides an extremely bitter irony. Rose brings to their relationship a background almost as miserable as Pinkie’s: if his parents traumatized their son with the heat of lust, Rose’s parents (whom we actually see in the novel) exhibit such emotional coldness and deadness that we understand immediately how the starvation for affection has made her vulnerable to Pinkie’s false display of care. The marriage of these “lost childhood” characters is a most unlikely and clearly a doomed one, and yet ironically it may be the only one in the novels of this phase that is apparently not sterile. At the end of the novel Rose believes that she is pregnant, and the old priest’s words to her suggest strongly that the reader should believe her to be—a condition that caps off nicely her role as foil to the pleasure-seeking Ida (in her long-term promiscuity a seasoned version of Kay Rimmer), whose marriage to “Tom” failed and who has never had children of her own even though her many lovers have expected her to mother them. Marriage looks grim elsewhere in Brighton Rock: in the relationship of blind Billy and his wife Judy, who carries on an adulterous affair with Dallow; and in that of the wicked lawyer Prewitt, who calls his wife “the old mole” and insists that she has ruined his life. It is perhaps a predictable corollary of the persistent inability of the first-phase protagonists to marry successfully or at all, that we do not see in any of their lives an image of happy domestic life that can endure. Indeed, in most cases there is no familiar “home” life at all, since several of the protagonists (Tony, Pinkie, Raven) and numerous other important characters (Minty, Ida, Conder, Rose, Coral, and Anne) live in single rented rooms. And the others discussed here are similarly detached from ordinary domestic life: Andrews appears at Elizabeth’s cottage as a homeless fugitive whose life as a smuggler precluded home life; Chase, Crane, and Chant are involved in quests that take them away from domestic life altogether. Such images of home that remain are tinged with unhappiness or perversity: Elizabeth, now alone, has lived for years with the lodger who after her mother’s death tried to
28 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
seduce her; Mabel Warren recalls with drunken sentimentality the flat in which she kept her lover Janet Pardoe, and even that relationship falters at the end of the novel; Conrad Drover sleeps with his brother’s wife; Acky and Tiny prop up their domestic establishment by converting part of it to a bawdy house. THE LITERARY FRAME Conrad Drover, in It’s a Battlefield, recalls having been named after a sailor who once rented a room from his parents. Anthony Farrant, in England Made Me, hears lines from Baudelaire’s “Invitation au Voyage” over the radio. Pinkie, in Brighton Rock, listens to his lawyer Prewitt quote from Marlowe’s Dr. Faustus. All three incidents are typical of Greene’s method of enriching the texture and resonance of his fiction through the use of allusions and parallels drawn most frequently, though not exclusively, from literary sources, and all three point to another distinction of Greene’s first-phase protagonists: The protagonists have no significant knowledge or understanding of any structure of allusion or “literary frame” that envelops them and their stories. Conrad does not know that the sailor who was his namesake was the great Polish novelist whose works deeply affected the young Graham Greene and whose novel The Secret Agent had a direct influence on the novel in which Conrad appears. Of course, Conrad Drover could not be expected to know that he is in a fiction at all. The quasi-ancestral relationship between the character and the novelist may anticipate the metafictional qualities of Monsignor Quixote, in which the protagonist is a descendant of the fictional Quixote. Anthony is unaware that Baudelaire’s poem (“Aimer á loisir, / Aimer et mourir, /Au pays qui te ressemble”) (193) deals with the incestuous love of brother and sister, a condition central to Anthony’s experience in the novel. Raven hears lines from Tennyson’s “Maud” over the radio but has no sense of the poem’s subject or meaning apart from three or four isolated lines. Pinkie is unaware that Prewitt’s invocation of Mephistopheles (“This is hell, nor am I out of it”) reflects upon both the old man’s condition in life and more importantly Pinkie’s own, which as I will demonstrate later has a Faustian dimension. In these representative instances and in all
PROTAGONISTS OF THE FIRST PHASE
29
significant cases of literary or historical allusion and parallels, the protagonists of the first phase are ignorant and uninformed. What passes is a communication exclusively between Greene’s narrator and the reader, who is by implication possessed of a literary sensibility much more like the author’s than the protagonist’s. THE FIRST-PHASE PROTAGONIST AND THE AUTHOR The protagonist’s ignorance of the allusive context of his story is entirely consistent with the last of the qualities of Greene’s first-phase protagonists to be discussed here: The protagonists become increasingly distant from the author. Andrews, Chant, and the dual protagonists Crane and Chase resemble their creator in several obvious ways: the latter three are all journalists, as Greene was, and they undertake travels to foreign lands in search of meaningful experience and in flight from boredom, as Greene had done in his youth and would continue to do throughout his life; and the same three are drawn, in spite of their natural proclivities and/or backgrounds, toward a fascination with the Catholic religion. For Crane and Chase this fascination is linked with the love of a young woman, as indeed it was for the author. A host of reasons, chief among which were the critical and commercial failures of the second and third books, led Greene away from heroes tied so clearly by age, education, experience, romantic temperament, and (with the exception of Andrews) social class to himself. As discussed earlier, he abandoned the focus on single or dual protagonists altogether in the next two books, Stamboul Train and It’s a Battlefield, populating those novels instead with multiple centers of interest—a Jewish merchant, a chorus girl, a policeman, an aging revolutionary, a waiter, an insurance clerk (the list is very long indeed)—most of whom are considerably beneath the author in class and education. Quinn Savoury, the novelist whom Greene satirizes; Dr. Czinner, the intellectual, displaced revolutionary; and Lady Caroline Bury are the only characters whose education and social standing are comparable to the author’s, and they appear only briefly. Anthony Farrant in England Made Me may be a partial exception because he is modeled after Greene’s irresponsible older brother Herbert and
30 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
because as a boy he, like the author, ran away from the boarding school he disliked. Yet even Anthony’s sensibility seems rather unlike the author’s, and in any case Greene’s letters indicate how strongly he disapproved of his brother’s behavior and how distant he felt toward him. The first phase culminates in two memorable protagonists whose slum-bred origins and monstrous crimes distance them from their creator as completely as might reasonably be imagined. In summary, this distinct drift of the characters farther and farther from the novelist himself might seem to have its causes in the broadening of Greene’s own experience and interests as well as in the pragmatic search for material more marketable than that which gave rise to The Name of Action and Rumour at Nightfall. But other factors may have come into play as well—factors suggestive of a personal as well as a professional need. The following chapter will discuss what seem to be important connections between the author’s life and the foregoing characteristics of his first-phase protagonists.
CHAPTER TWO Letters and Diaries
LETTERS TO VIVIEN While it is always necessary to be cautious in reading backwards from the works to the life of any author, it is impossible not to see powerful elements of Greene’s life and personality in the novels of the first phase. The obsessive themes of betrayal, divided loyalties, the terror of life have long been noted by critics who, with some encouragement from the author, have traced the roots of those themes to Greene’s childhood unhappiness and the Berkhamsted School. Yet the very frequency with which these elements have been observed and the ease with which Greene talked about them may have served as a kind of smokescreen behind which other details have passed unobserved. The familiar themes of self-division and the insistent dichotomy between sexual and spiritual love in the early works, for example, have roots not only in the literary sources emphasized by Allott and Farris in their excellent early study of Greene, and not only in what is in some respects a familiar quality of youthful experience, but also in the circumstances of the author’s own courtship and marriage. The sense of self-division was rooted in part in Greene’s own uncertainty, ambivalence, and lack of self-understanding. On the one hand he longed for marriage, even a highly spiritualized one, with intense coziness and the superaddition of Catholic mystery; on the other he desired travel, excitement, adventure, the ever-needful escape from boredom, and, of course, material for his books. He sometimes expressed the idea of marriage as an adventure, accompanied by images of seas, shores, and sunsets, but he knew just as well that such adventure was
32 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
incompatible with the restraints of modest income and the responsibility for children. Most likely there was no way to unite permanently these conflicting desires, and Greene in attempting to do so would initially make the wrong choices— wrong in the sense that as he matured he would discover his own unsuitedness for the very idea of marriage that he most wanted to achieve. As Norman Sherry’s biography reveals, Greene at times conceived of his own experience in terms of a divided selfhood. In letters to Vivien Dayrell-Browning during the two years prior to their marriage in 1927, he mentions the pseudonymous “Hilary Trench,” a name under which some of his writings appeared in the Oxford Outlook and elsewhere, as a dark side of his personality which with her help he wanted to repress. Trench is cynical, irreverent, disillusioned, unhappy; Greene under Vivien’s influence is happier, more trusting, optimistic, kind. Greene occasionally distinguished, in the letters, between the “Oxford Graham” and the “You-Graham” (Sherry 1:191), implying a favorable change under her influence. Like many of the first-phase protagonists, he saw himself as experiencing some form of redemption through his relationship with an idealized woman, and like them he experienced the frustrating difficulty of uniting the concepts of sexual and spiritual love. The young woman he courted and eventually married was deeply religious, shy, and so reluctant to accept the physical side of romantic love that she proposed on at least one occasion that her mother adopt Greene so that the two of them could be united as brother and sister. Understandably he was not attracted to such a proposition, yet his ardor was sufficiently strong that he did eventually propose to her the idea of a celibate marriage. However preposterous that notion might seem in retrospect, the fact that Greene proposed it at all suggests not just the strength of his ardor but also the obvious way in which conditions in his own life enforced upon him the serious consideration of the division between romantic love and sexuality found in his first-phase protagonists. He certainly idealized Vivien, saw himself as a man redeemed by her love and her beauty both physical and spiritual, and praised her transforming power in memorable and often extravagant language. Vivien was, by his own testimony, the “philosopher’s stone” whereby baser materials like himself could be purified.
LETTERS AND DIARIES 33
He attributes to her more than once a form of saintliness by comparing her with Shaw’s St. Joan, a character whose story was so important to him that he would later write the screenplay for the film based on Shaw’s play. (As mentioned in the preceding chapter, Crane compares Eulelia with St. Joan. And Greene’s later use of the St. Joan comparison in Travels with My Aunt will be a measure of his changing attitudes.) To see how such literary comparisons point toward correspondences between Greene’s life and works, it is necessary to look at two sources outside the novels: the courtship letters and the diaries. For scholars interested in the origins of Greene’s imaginative writing and his methods and habits of mind in that formative period when he emerged from promising but uneven apprentice work into the more enduring achievement of the novels from Stamboul Train through Brighton Rock, the sources housed in the manuscript collection of the Humanities Research Center at the University of Texas, Austin, provide fascinating and indispensable reading: the letters to his future wife Vivien, written during the period of their courtship, and the diaries of 1932–33. Both are filled with revelations of Greene’s tastes and enthusiasms and inspirations, recorded privately as he endeavored, in the letters, to convey an impression of himself as he was and, perhaps, as he wanted to be; and as he recorded, in the diaries, his progress as a writer and his impressions of individuals, events, and writers and works. One records primarily the course of romance, the other of his struggle to write, beginning with Stamboul Train and proceeding through It’s a Battlefield and England Made Me. Both bear close examination especially in relation to Greene’s fiction of the thirties, and both reveal certain habits and tendencies that can be seen throughout much of the later work as well. My purpose here is to look first at these early sources in order to demonstrate how the specifically literary conception of experience in the letters and the extensive readings listed in the diaries provide insight into Greene’s creative method. To that end I will examine two novels that most easily reveal their genesis through Greene’s reading and his responses to it: A Gun for Sale and Brighton Rock. The more than 700 letters written by Greene to Vivien during the period of his intense courtship of her and their subsequent
34 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
engagement (1925–27) testify to the energy and persistence as well as the urgency of Greene’s passion. Still unpublished but quoted extensively by Norman Sherry in volume one of the authorized biography, these courtship letters may surprise many of Greene’s readers with their fervent romanticism and, at times, their somewhat cloying sentimentality. The creator of grotesque, alienated characters like Pinkie and Raven, of weary, disillusioned middle-aged lovers like Fowler and Brown, seems enormously distant from the young author who sent his sweetheart the following “wanted” notice: Wanted—by Me. Miss Dayrell Alias Vivienne, Dear one, Darling, darling heart, marvellous wonderful, adorable one, Angel, Loveliest in the world, Sweetest Heart, Dear only love for ever, sweet one, old thing, dear desire. Description: Hair—dark & lovely & long; eyes, greygreen & more beautiful than any other eyes; figure, perfect; complexion, wonderful; skin in texture as a rose petal; feet: very small & very adorable; disposition: sleepy. Known to her companion in crime as My Love. May be infallibly recognised by her stars [Vivien’s code word for kisses]. (Sherry 1:184) Neither this youthful romantic ardor nor the marriage it led to would endure. Whether or not that fact explains the nearcomplete absence of the voice of youthful romanticism from the more mature fiction that begins with Stamboul Train is a matter of conjecture, but the voice can be heard often in the first three published novels. And it is possible to see a correspondence between the effusive sentiments of the courtship letters and the idealizing protagonists of those earlier works. We see it, for example, in Oliver Chant, hero of The Name of Action, who wants to love Anne-Marie Demassener “as men have loved God.” We see it even more obviously by comparing Francis Andrews’s reflections on the virtuous Elizabeth (in The Man Within) with Greene’s own feelings as recorded in the letters: Andrews, to Elizabeth:
LETTERS AND DIARIES 35
“I don’t fear [death] any longer. You are filling me with yourself. That means courage, peace, holiness.” (189) Greene, in a letter to Vivien:
How God knows, for every corner of me is now filled with the love & the want of you. (Sherry 1:353; Greene speaks of his intention to love Vivien more every year.) Andrews, in meditation: He thought of seasons they would see together; of summer, blue sea, white cliffs, red poppies in the golden corn; winter, to wake in the morning to see Elizabeth’s hair across the pillow…. (196) Greene, in a letter to Vivien (24 April 1927):
All by ourselves in a foreign land—hundreds of miles from relations!! I think one will feel tempted to behave scandalously! No one who would recognize us anywhere near. One will be able to bathe and suddenly be affectionate in the middle of a breaker, go for a gentle stroll towards the Pyrenees and then sit down and rest and exchange thick clusters of stars [kisses] by the roadside and not have to think—“we ought to be getting back. They’ll be waiting dinner for us.” Linger until dusk and then go even slower back. O darling, it will be lovely tiptoeing into your room in the morning (will the sea be outside the window?) and waking you. (Sherry 1:348) Andrews, to Elizabeth: “Let’s pretend we have been married for years,” he said, “and do pleasant ordinary things, cook food, wash up, talk to each other as if we had seen each other yesterday and would see each other tomorrow.” (201) Greene, in a letter to Vivien (22 April 1927):
36 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
It will be such fun doing odd jobs for you, turning on your bath water, cutting your bread, helping you tidy up, ringing up the butcher and the greengrocer, tucking you up in bed! What fun arranging holidays too with maps and timetables, sitting on the floor with them spread out. O we are going to be so happy! (Sherry 1:353) Greene, in a letter to Vivien (9 August 1925):
And there’ll be winter evenings, when we can make hot buttered toast for each other…& there’ll be summer days with the sea sparkling blue…& days on the down, & night expresses, & evenings sometimes, when we are both sleepy and tired & we’ll just read, or I’ll write & you’ll put in a few touches to a design. (Sherry 1:202) Such passages suggest a direct transfer of the author’s own emotions into the lives of his characters. The result is not inevitably bad art, yet it comes as no surprise that Greene would later see as a major weakness in these early works his own inability to distance himself from his material: I realized later…that my two books Rumour at Nightfall and The Name of Action were bad because I had left too little distance between them and myself. The umbilical cord was left unbroken, you might say. (Allain 45) Greene would break that cord in time by discovering a mode that would place the very tenderest emotions and the ideals of bourgeois domestic coziness in an ironic perspective. The practice of doing so runs throughout the mature work, receiving its most memorable expression in the warped view of Pinkie, to whom the idea of marriage is repulsive, “like ordure on the hands.” Hiding from Colleoni’s men in the garage of a house in the “barren bourgeois road” near the racecourse, Pinkie views with scorn the decaying evidence of middle-class family life: Whoever the owner was, he had come a long way to land up here. The pram-wheelbarrow was covered with labels—the marks of innumerable train journeys…. You couldn’t have any doubt that this was the end, the mortgaged home in
LETTERS AND DIARIES 37
the bottom; the untidy tidemark on a bench, the junk was piled up here and would never go farther. And the Boy hated him. (108) Such disillusionment is not to be found in the courtship letters, which are full of tenderness and humor as well as poignant expressions of loneliness and unhappiness. For the Greene whose notoriously troubled youth had left him disillusioned, manic-depressive, agnostic, and somewhat cynical, they give free play to a latent romanticism that he would eventually suppress. More importantly for my purpose here, the courtship letters reveal the workings of Greene’s imagination in ways that illuminate his strategies and habits as a novelist. In this last regard the letters demonstrate Greene’s persistent tendency to conceive his romance, his emotional state, his ideals of Vivien, and his own writing through references to literature—chiefly poetry—drawn from his current readings and interests as well as his capacious memory of older favorites (Browning, Tennyson). The courtship letters are filled, perhaps to an even greater degree than the generous selection published in Sherry’s biography suggests, with literary allusions, quotations, questions, judgments, analogies. In one sense this is unremarkable, since quoting poetry to woo one’s sweetheart is (or was, at least) a time-honored procedure. It is obvious, too, that Vivien’s literary interests—she worked for publisher Basil Blackwell and had published a small volume of poems at age fifteen—would have evoked literary comments from a suitor desperately eager to appeal to her interests. The strategy of quotation may have been calculated in other ways as well: as Norman Sherry points out, for example, Greene quotes from Donne’s “Extasy” as part of a seductive argument to persuade Vivien to accept the sexual side of love (1:292–93). Whether they arise from deliberate strategy or spontaneous enthusiasm, or from both, the various literary allusions and quotations are so extensive as to deserve examination both as measures of Greene’s tastes and as evidence of the creative process that grew out of his responses to literature. He uses literary allusion in the letters to express literary judgments and enthusiasms; to interpret Vivien’s character and her effect on him; to describe his own moods and emotions, largely through analogies; and finally to identify source material for his own
38 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
writings. In doing so he demonstrates a remarkable memory for specific passages, quoting long passages from Tennyson, for example, only to express exasperation at the end that he cannot remember more. Yet clearly the enterprise was serious enough to demand that he sometimes copy passages from current new readings (e.g. Edna St. Vincent Millay) and from new and old works by favorite authors (Hardy). It is clear, too, that Vivien often commented and quoted, but it is impossible to determine the extent to which her own comments inspired his. Greene’s judgments and enthusiasms are lively and entertaining. For example, in a letter of 21 September 1925, he responds to Vivien’s praise of a Drayton sonnet by ranking it alongside one of his own favorites, Brooke’s “Now God be thanked, who has watched with us this hour”; Greene quotes “the image in the fourth line, which has always peculiarly attracted me, ‘To turn as swimmers, into cleanness leaping’” and “the marvellous ending: ‘Naught broken save…is but Death.’” He admires Yeats generally but loathes the too-obvious music of “Innisfree.” Suggesting (12 January 1926) that Vivien has greater potential than other living writers even though not everything she does is marvelous, he sees an analogy in the uneven performance of Tennyson, the author of “Ulysses” and “The Lotos Eaters” and a rather bad poem with some good lines: “Maud.” A week later he mentions T.E.Brown as one of his “enthusiasms” on whom he could talk at great length if he had a copy of Brown’s work handy (Sherry 1:129). Later that year (June 1926) he praises minor poet E.C.Blunden extravagantly and, in the same letter, responds to a selection of Huxley’s poems that Vivien has given him by expressing surprise at the discovery that Huxley was influenced by Rupert Brooke. And he expresses other literary opinions of interest: Greene has a theory that Hamlet could be produced as a tragicomedy—a production he has thought of undertaking in order to make critics pay notice—a version that would heighten its poignancy. He praises the frightening reality of a death scene in Woolf’s The Voyage Out; he urges Vivien to read Joyce’s stories in Dubliners, especially “The Dead,” which he praises for its extraordinary beauty. Greene’s impressions of Vivien are frequently expressed through literary comparisons. He quotes from Verlaine and Brooke, for example, to say that both poets knew her—a
LETTERS AND DIARIES 39
hyperbole that becomes less happy when Greene, in a mood of doubt about her affection in September 1925, quotes lines from Brooke’s “Peace” to suggest that Vivien is less fond of him than before: She’ll give me all I ask, kiss me & hold me, And open wide that holy air The gates of peace & take my tiredness home, Kinder than God. But, heart, she will not care. In a happier mood Greene invokes Chesterton’s Napoleon of Notting Hill, specifically the line “When the cord of monotony is stretched out tight, then it breaks with a sound like a song.” The song Vivien has been singing to him in recent days is beautiful, he adds (7 August 1925). Almost a year later (26 July 1926) he suggests that someone should invent a new name to describe Vivien, whom he then praises by quoting from Hardy’s sonnet “Her Definition”: As common chests encasing wares of price Are borne with tenderness through halls of state For what they cover, so the poor device Of homely wording I could tolerate, Knowing its unadornment held as freight The sweetest image outside Paradise. In November he quotes from Eliot’s “Preludes”—“The vision of an infinitely gentle, infinitely suffering thing”—suggesting that he had tried to remember that poem the night before when thinking of her; now that he remembers, the lines— superficially, at least—no longer seem to apply. But when he reads, in March 1927, Donne’s “She, whose fair body no such prison was…,” he sees not Donne’s wife but Vivien. Greene interprets his own plight as lover with even more abundant use of literary sources. In a tender letter in September 1925 he quotes affectionately Yeats’s “No one has ever loved but you and I,” and less than a week later he says that while Yeats’s “Never give all the heart” is excellent advice, it comes too late for him, since he has given his heart completely to Vivien and no longer has room in it for poems, places, and other people. At times he is exuberant and
40 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
confident, as when he describes himself in November 1925 as wanting to chant Meredith’s “Love in a Valley” at his office. Such declarations often give the impression of a fine spontaneity, and the sheer volume of Greene’s writing in the courtship letters (he sometimes wrote more than once a day, and the letters often have a breathless quality) suggests that they were indeed spontaneous. And yet at times the selection of a particular passage or poem seems the result of deliberation. In a letter of apology following a quarrel, Greene quotes Rupert Brooke’s “Retrospect” to give an emotional resonance to his longing for forgiveness: I would come back, come back to you, Find you, as a pool unstirred, Kneel down by you, & never a word, Lay my head, & nothing said, In your hands, ungarlanded…. To explain his uneasy state of mind prior to meetings with Vivien, Greene uses two poems by Thomas Hardy. In the first of these (20 November 1925) he copies “The Minute Before Meeting,” an early sonnet he has just been reading, offering it to Vivien because it describes perfectly the slightly depressed feeling he sometimes experiences just prior to seeing her: The grey-gaunt hills dividing us in twain Seemed hopeless hills my strength must faint to climb, But they are gone; and now I would detain The few clock-beats that part us; rein back Time, And live in close expectance never closed In change for far expectance closed at last, So harshly has expectance been imposed On my long need while these slow blank months passed. And knowing that what is now about to be Will all have been in O, so short a space! I read beyond it my despondency When more dividing months shall take its place, Thereby denying to this hour of grace A full-up measure of felicity.
LETTERS AND DIARIES 41
In the second letter (3 December 1925), his fear that she will not come to an appointed meeting in Nottingham—or that she will come but will feel uncomfortable there—is described by a quotation from Hardy’s “A Broken Appointment”: “You did not come/And marching Time drew on & wore me numb/Yet less for loss of your dear presence there….” Greene adds that his own unhappiness, his question of why they were brought together if they are not to be happy, reminds him of Hardy’s idea of Fate or God. Four days after the “Broken Appointment” letter Greene, in a mood of loneliness and dejection, indicates a profound sense of futility that is not ameliorated by his new interest in Vivien’s Catholicism: “Don’t you ever wonder, in moods, now and again what the use of going on is? Religion doesn’t answer it. One can believe in every point of the Catholic faith, and yet at times like this hate the initiator of it all, of life I mean” (qtd. in Sherry 1: 260). Even in such apparently painful frankness, he assesses his own condition through a literary comparison: his love of second-rate philosophical talk that never leads anywhere makes it easy to see why he is fond of Chekov. Five days later, Greene explains that a recent letter he sent to Vivien was the result of “ennui,” which, he further explains, finds its “most perfect expression” in Eliot’s “Prufrock,” from which he quotes several lines. A similar measure of Greene’s care in selecting works or passages that describe accurately his own state or their relationship can be seen in a letter from the following month in which he quotes lines from the poem by Edna St. Vincent Millay he has read just that day: “Time does not bring relief; you all have lied/Who told me time would ease me of my pain….” He says that earlier, when Vivien had told him not to love her, this poem applied to their relationship, but now that her attitude has changed, it no longer does. Both the diaries and the letters show Greene as a writer who often conceived of his own work in response to other works— poems, novels, plays, films. In April 1926 he wrote to Vivien: I want to write a novel called The Gaudy Ship’. Do you know the Yeats poem called, I think, The [sic] Dream. A man dreams he’s steering a boat along the edge of the sea
42 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
with a dead man in it, & a crowd are running along the shore shouting & singing. Though I’d my finger on my lip, What could I but take up the song, And running crowd & gaudy ship Cried out the whole night long. I made a list about a month ago of plots for short stories, with their rough lengths, including one or two short sketches I’d got already done & it was enough for 30,000 words. Half a book. (qtd. in Sherry 1:310) Greene did not write “The Gaudy Ship,” but this would not be the last time when a poem was at the heart of his conception of a novel. After seeing the film The Merry Widow, he wrote again to Vivien of his inspiration to write a poem based upon lines from Browning’s “Fra Lippo Lippi”: “The breathless fellow at the altar foot, /Fresh from his murder, safe & sitting there” (Sherry 1:244). This inspiration seems also to have failed him, however, for it led—on the immediate occasion, at least—only to a rereading of the same poet’s “Andrea del Sarto.” If “His Dream” and “Fra Lippo Lippi” did not contribute significantly to Greene’s own work, other enthusiasms revealed in the letters and diaries certainly did. On the same date as the “Gaudy Ship” letter, for example, Greene responds to a letter from Vivien in which she quoted Tennyson’s Maud, a poem close to his own heart even though he was sometimes critical of it; the lines she chose are ones, he says, which have been running through his head for two months or so, but he has lacked the courage to put them on an envelope. Having introduced “Maud,” he goes on to say that anthologists regularly choose bad lines from the poem (“Come into the garden, Maud”) instead of the ones she quoted or the “excellent” ones he especially likes: Oh me—why have they not buried me deep enough? Was it kind to have made a grave so rough, Me that was never a quiet sleeper?
LETTERS AND DIARIES 43
The copiousness of Greene’s memory is suggested by the fact that he initially misquoted the first of these lines but then crossed out the incorrect version; he very likely did not look up the correction, for afterward, in commenting on his fondness for lines about “Viziers nodding/In an Egyptian night,” he again misquotes, substituting virgins for viziers. He would get this quotation right when he used it later at the end of his 1969 essay “The Worm inside the Lotus Blossom,” and he would invoke Maud in the conclusion of Travels with My Aunt as the inspiration for a May-December romance between Henry Pulling and his child-fiancée, Maria. More important for this study, as I will explain in a later chapter, is that Greene would draw heavily upon Maud for characters, emotions, and themes in the second of his entertainments, A Gun for Sale. DIARIES Much briefer, and stripped of both the rhetorical purpose and the fervent emotion of the courtship letters, the diaries too provide fascinating reading. They reveal much about the author’s daily habits (morning for writing, afternoons and evenings for reading, visits, walks); his domestic life (including Vivien’s first pregnancy and a poignant account of the death of their dog Pekoe); his literary acquaintances (Elizabeth Bowen, David Higham, Elizabeth Sprigge, Lady Ottoline Morrell, and others). Greene records fascinating bits of literary gossip, some of which are accurate (Elizabeth Bowen tells him of the unhappiness of T.S.Eliot’s marriage), some inaccurate (someone has told Greene that writer Francis Ihles is really Aldous Huxley). He notes briefly a variety of travels—to Warwick Castle; to Bletchley and the cottage of prophetess Joanna Southwood; to Moreland’s Match factory in Gloucester and Wandsworth Prison in London, both for settings to be used in It’s a Battlefield; to London overnight with Vivien for dinner and theatre, or by himself to transact business and to sell review copies of books in Charing Cross Road. Greene also mentions his indiscretions with the London prostitute Annette, whose character and last message (“No milk today”) he later transcribed directly into England Made Me. The diaries are equally interesting as a record of Greene’s struggle—fairly desperate—to complete Stamboul Train, and
44 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
his reward at last in the encouragement of editor Charles Evans, who regarded it as the best book Greene had written. He tracks his progress from the early stages of the “cinematically” conceived “Opus V” through numerous decisions and revisions leading to its completion and his choice of a title—It’s a Battlefield. He comments at length on ideas for a novel based upon spiritualism and incest; the book was never written as intended, but the idea for it contributed significantly to the incest theme in England Made Me and the use of spiritualism in The Ministry of Fear. Greene continues to demonstrate, in the diaries as he had done in the letters, his fondness for allusions and quotations and his tendency to be stimulated to creativity by his responses to other writers. The diaries offer an abbreviated account of Greene’s tastes, enthusiasms, inspirations, and borrowings. Among the writers he reads and comments on are Virginia Woolf (he is critical of her essays which, he says, make her more important than the works); E.M.Forster (he enjoys Howards End but is suspicious of the feminine quality in Forster’s narrative); minor writer Elizabeth Sprigge (who moves him to most uncharitable generalizations about the distinctive qualities of women writers); and Flaubert (whose Madame Bovary he regards as one of the great achievements). The diaries frequently show Greene as a writer who delights in memorable phrasing and provocative ideas encountered in his reading and who is eager to learn from them or to store them in his lumber-room for later use in his own writing. He copies many passages, often quite lengthy ones, from a remarkable variety of writers: dramatists Lee and Shadwell; poets Keats and Gittings and Wigglesworth; the revolutionary Trotsky; essayist Samuel Rogers. He records comments on R.L.Stevenson, Ibsen, and Dumas from Henry James’s essays. From James’s Preface to Wings of the Dove he copies a passage that explains to him the failure of what is now recognized as perhaps the poorest of his novels, Rumour at Nightfall. James had written: There was the “fun,” to begin with, of establishing one’s successive centres—of fixing them so exactly that the portions of the subject commanded by them as by happy points of view, and accordingly treated from them would
LETTERS AND DIARIES 45
constitute, so to speak, sufficiently solid blocks of wrought material, squared to the sharp edge, as to have weight and mass and carrying power; to make for construction, that is, to conduce to effect and to provide for beauty. (xvi) Greene writes that he had tried to create Jamesian “solid blocks” in Rumour but had made the final block too thin. Moreover, he had shifted his point of view to the central figure Chase at the end of that novel, whereas James with greater subtlety had seen Milly, the central figure in Wings, from an angle. Greene also copies James’s description of that circuitous approach to his “unspotted princess”: “So, if we talk of princesses, do the balconies opposite the palace gates, do the coigns of vantage and respect enjoyed for a fee, rake from afar the mystic figure in the gilded coach as it comes forth into the great place” (xxx). This is the method, Greene adds, that he may attempt in his planned novel about spiritualism—a plan he never carried to fulfillment. Greene’s seriousness about learning from the Old Master is paralleled by the seriousness of his search for epigraphs. It is doubtful that any novelist chose epigraphs more carefully than Greene did. The diaries show how his tentative and final choices often grew out of current reading. His entry for 23 July 1932, for example, indicates that Greene had been reading Santayana without much pleasure, but he liked one passage well enough to copy it into the diary: “Everything is lyrical in its ideal essence; tragic in its fate & comic in its existence.” If Greene intended at the time to make this an epigraph he did not mention it in the diary, but eventually he chose it for Stamboul Train. On March 13 of the following year Greene found in Adelphi a passage from Ortega y Gasset’s Revolt of the Masses and copied it into his diary: This is the simple truth—that to live is to feel oneself lost —he who accepts it has already begun to find himself, to be on firm ground. Instinctively, as do the shipwrecked, he will look around for something toward which to cling, & that tragic, ruthless glance, absolutely sincere, because it is a question of his salvation, will cause him to bring order into the chaos of his life. These are the only genuine ideas;
46 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
the ideas of the shipwrecked. All the rest is rhetoric, posturing, farce. He who does not really feel himself lost, is lost without remission; that is to say he never finds himself, never covers up against his own reality. (157) Clearly this idea of the shipwrecked man lingered in Greene’s memory; the passage appears as the epigraph on the title page of the autograph manuscript of the novel England Made Me, and although Greene crossed it out and replaced it with an epigraph from Walt Disney’s The Grasshopper and the Ants, he chose The Shipwrecked as the title for the 1953 American edition of the book. Moreover, the novel retains a strong echo of Ortega y Gasset in an important passage in which the financier Krogh suddenly realizes that the key to his own freedom lies in his ability to break away from the past: “I’ve been thinking too much about the past. He had always despised people who thought too much about the past. To live was to leave behind; to be as free as a shipwrecked man who has lost everything” (133; italics added). As he worked on “Opus V” Greene came across a quotation from Cymbeline (quoted by Ison Brean in The Observer) that he thought would make a perfect epigraph for that novel: “O for the charity of a penny coud.” But he discarded this impulse rather quickly, for in early July 1933 he writes that he has decided on the title It’s a Battlefield, with a quotation from Alexander Kinglake’s Crimea as the epigraph. The epigraph explains, and apparently inspired, the novel’s title: In so far as the battlefield presented itself to the bare eyesight of men, it had no entirety, no length, no breadth, no depth, no size, no shape, and was made up of nothing except small numberless circlets commensurate with such ranges of vision as the mist might allow at each spot…. In such conditions, each separate gathering of English soldiery went on fighting its own little battle in happy and advantageous ignorance of the general state of the action; nay, even very often in ignorance of the fact that any great conflict was raging.
LETTERS AND DIARIES 47
Greene’s occasional references to film in the diaries suggest that the fiction of the period may have been influenced by film in ways beyond his often-discussed cinematic style. On 12 June 1932, for example, after seeing The Murder of Karamazov he recorded in the diary his ambition to use actress Anna Sten as a model for the heroine of his next book, of which he had already imagined sizable portions. His judgment of this film—that it interpreted only the worldly part of the novel and left out heaven and hell—may perhaps be taken as an early sign of the direction Greene would follow only a few years later in those novels that so emphatically do not leave out heaven and hell. (This was, after all, the Greene who had written to Vivien, in December 1925, that the appeal of Catholicism lay in its picture of hell.) Karamazov may also have piqued an interest in Dostoevsky: one week later the diary states that Greene’s reading of Carr’s Life of Dostoevsky has given him an idea for his next novel to follow “Opus V”; it is to be a story in which a medium alternates periodically between debauchery and nobility. On the following day, the diary notes, Greene went to the Oxford Union and read a book on spiritualism in preparation for writing the next novel, and a month later on July 11 he writes that he has received, read, and taken notes (for the next novel) on Confessions of a Medium, which he ordered from the Central Library. Greene, who had been diagnosed wrongly as epileptic and was believed by some to have mediumistic powers, copied into his diary on 19 July 1932 a passage from Carr’s biography a passage asserting that some victims of epilepsy experience, just before an attack, an elevated spirit and a sense of transcendent power. In March 1933, as Greene drew close to the completion of It’s a Battlefield and was already contemplating the next novel that would become England Made Me, he saw Howard Hawks’s popular film Scarface, one of the most famous crime films of the decade. Although he found it inferior to City Streets and The Front Page, Greene liked Scarface, and there is reason to believe that he gleaned ideas from it. The novel contains several references to the methods of American gangsters, and the autograph manuscript contains similar references that Greene deleted before publication. Doubtless the incest theme involving “Scarface” Camonte and his sister Cesca would have caught Greene’s attention, since he was already planning to deal with
48 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
an incestuous brother and sister relationship in the next novel. But Scarface has other qualities that invite comparison with Greene’s fiction of the period. As a fairly early sound film (1932) it was notable for its use of an operatic motif—“Che me freno?” (“Who restrains me?”)—from Donizetti’s Lucia de Lammermoor—to accompany the scene in which Camonte murders a rival gang leader. Greene uses opera prominently in England Made Me, where Anthony (coincidentally, “Scarface” Camonte is also “Tony”) goes with Krogh to see Tristan (which Krogh confuses with Carmen) and eventually identifies his sweetheart Lucia (“Loo”) Davidge with the black sail from Wagner’s opera. The specific use of Tristan may have been inspired by The Waste Land, a poem whose effect on Greene has been demonstrated by several critics and will be discussed later here; but Lucia’s name, like that of her brother Roderick, is drawn from Scott’s Bride of Lammermoor, her father’s favorite novel and the original source for Donizetti’s libretto. In no other book does Greene show a comparable interest in opera, although later works such as Travels with My Aunt will evince an interest in Scott. The actual milieu of England Made Me has little in common with the criminal underworld depicted in Scarface, but that is not the case with Greene’s next two novels (A Gun for Sale and Brighton Rock), and both of those works, especially the second, use music from a variety of sources (radios, gramophones, barroom singing, Pinkie’s memory as a choir boy) to comment ironically on the current action. Like Scarface (but unlike any of Greene’s earlier or later books), both Gun and Brighton Rock begin with a murder planned and executed by a completely remorseless underworld character. Moreover, the novels and the film all juxtapose murder with holiday cheer: Pinkie murders Hale on Whitmonday; Raven’s revenge murders are carried out during the Christmas holidays; and “Scarface” Tony Camonte machine-guns an entire rival gang on St. Valentine’s Day. Pinkie, of course, never musters the firepower to carry out a slaughter on the scale of the St. Valentine’s Day massacre, but his imagination at least suggests that possibility (“Have I got to have a massacre?” he asks more than once); and the rise of Tony Camonte from punk hoodlum to an emperor of crime is precisely the course Pinkie, in Brighton Rock, would like to follow. Carlos Clarens, in his study Crime Movies, calls
LETTERS AND DIARIES 49
attention to the “essential childishness which is Camonte’s most winning quality” in the film (87). Pinkie, much closer at seventeen to real childhood than Camonte is, has no winning qualities at all; his youthfulness is a source of horror rather than amusement. Brighton Rock remains, in spite of such recognizable similarities, a very different sort of work from Hawks’s film. Yet it seems fair to say that the decision to call the Boulting Brothers’ 1947 film version of the novel Young Scarface in its American release may have been more than a mere commercial expedient. The case of Scarface offers a minor variation on a major theme of my approach to Greene’s fiction. It will be apparent that any or all of these resemblances between Hawks’s film and the three novels might be the result of coincidence rather than conscious or unconscious influence. Yet, as I have tried to demonstrate, the letters and diaries offer such abundant evidence of Greene’s love of quotations, allusions, parallels, and a “literary” view of experience, together with his conscious borrowing and his testimony to the power of other writers’ works to inspire his own creativity, that attention to these elements is crucial to an understanding of the genesis of his own works. Greene was a speedy and prolific reader even during periods of intensive work at his own writing. The task of trying to examine all of his readings (or film viewings) for the purpose of tracing influences on the fiction is beyond the scope of this study, yet by looking selectively one can learn a great deal about his methods and about certain cases in which the intertextual relationships may serve as aids to interpretation and to an understanding of the genesis of Greene’s works. To that end the next two chapters will examine representative novels for which this method of investigation may be seen to yield especially instructive results.
50
CHAPTER THREE A Gun for Sale
In his fascinating study Mixing Memory and Desire: The Waste Land and British Novels, Fred Crawford identifies Graham Greene as a writer profoundly influenced by T.S.Eliot. Asserting that “Greene’s development as a novelist paralleled his growing understanding of The Waste Land,” Crawford traces carefully the stages by which Greene learned to make novelistic capital out of the vast resources of Eliot’s poem: Greene’s early reading of Eliot’s criticism and poetry, which began when Greene was still at Oxford, provided an explanation of and memorable imagery for “the real world…full of lust, betrayal, violence, and exploitation” which dominates his work. Yet because he did not understand The Waste Land’s relation to his own ideas until he had read Eliot’s critical essays, Greene’s early attempts to profit from The Waste Land were less successful than in his later writing. Only when he placed Waste Land imagery into its proper context, could Greene create his own Waste Land. Once he had accomplished that, he was able to select particular aspects of Eliot’s poem to fit his purpose as a writer. (105) Having thus established Greene’s use of Eliot as a measure of artistic maturity, Crawford judges individual works accordingly. Brighton Rock (1938) becomes a watershed, Greene’s first successful rendering of characters who “confront the dilemmas of The Waste Land, struggling to find meaning in an empty world” (103). Among the earlier works, A Gun for Sale is noteworthy for having failed largely because of Greene’s unsuccessful use of Eliot’s poem in it:
52 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
Greene alludes to Eliot’s poems throughout, but he manages only to create a physical atmosphere similar to that of The Waste Land. The applications of Eliot’s Hanged Man and Death by Water motifs to the characterization of Greene’s figures fail because they are too obviously allusions, they occur too often, and they have no direct bearing on the characters of Anne Crowder or Mather. With Raven the motif becomes too pointed, although the memory of his hanged father, suicidal mother, and orphanage upbringing explains much of his bitterness. (108) Professor Crawford carefully limits the scope of his study to the question of such borrowing from Eliot, and within that limitation his findings are instructive. Nevertheless, a close examination of A Gun for Sale reveals that The Waste Land is only one of several literary sources, and not necessarily the most important one, that Greene drew upon in creating the novel. The children’s Christmas pantomimes Aladdin and especially Dick Whittington figured prominently in the author’s ironic treatment of Raven as a “lost childhood” figure, and Greene’s reading of Faulkner’s Light in August may have influenced aspects of several characters as well. On a more important level two Victorian poems—Browning’s “Childe Roland” and Tennyson’s Maud—contributed heavily to Greene’s handling of structure, character, and imagery. Just as Brighton Rock could be called a “Pentecost novel,” deriving as it does sustained irony from the juxtaposition of the religious holiday with violence and murder in Brighton, A Gun for Sale is a “Christmas novel” in which the familiar trappings of the holiday season lend poignancy to the situation of James Raven, the lonely, ugly, embittered protagonist for whom the Christmas story has no meaning: In a religious shop by the Catholic Cathedral he found himself facing again the images that angered him in the Soho café; the plaster mother and child, the wise men and the shepherds. They were arranged in a cavern of brown paper among the books of devotion, the little pious scraps of St Theresa. ‘The Holy Family’: he pressed his face
A GUN FOR SALE
53
against the glass with a kind of horrified anger that that tale still went on. (89) Greene recalls in A Sort of Life the pleasure of the family’s annual attendance at the most popular of all the Christmas pantomimes—Peter Pan—at the Duke of York’s Theatre in London. His interest in that story would surface many years later in his claim that both Raven and the character for whom he was “a first sketch”—Pinkie in Brighton Rock—are Peter Pan figures: “[Raven] is a Pinkie who has aged but not grown up. The Pinkies are the real Peter Pans—doomed to be juvenile for a lifetime. They have something of the fallen angel about them, a morality which once belonged to another place” (75). Before Pinkie’s character had been created, however, Greene clearly saw Raven’s experience in contrast to the familiar material of the children’s Christmas pantomimes. Greene’s comment appears to represent a retrospective discovery rather than something remembered about the process of writing, and the texts offer no evidence to suggest that Peter Pan was used consciously in the creation of either novel. It is clear, however, that two pantomimes of comparable popularity, Aladdin and Dick Whittington, were very much in Greene’s mind as he wrote Gun. As Anne Crowder, the novel’s perky showgirl heroine, prepares to leave London for a job in Nottwich, her landlady asks which pantomime she will perform in. “You said Dick Whittington, didn’t you?” “No, no,” Anne replies, “Aladdin” (21). If the novel owes more than this obvious element of plot to Aladdin, the indebtedness may lie in the fact that in the early scenes of the novel and the play two characters meet (Aladdin and the Magician, Raven and Davis/Cholmondeley) in circumstances with distinctive similarities: in both works the older man uses a large cache of money (the magician’s bag of gold, Davis’s stolen bank notes) to manipulate and ultimately to deceive the younger one whom he uses as a tool for his own greedy purposes; in both stories one of the characters (Aladdin, Davis) is excessively fond of sweets and offers sweets to the other, who refuses; and in both one of the characters is identified with a ring symbolic of power and control (the magician’s magic ring which calls forth the “slave of the ring”; Davis’s emerald ring, singled out for attention several times in
54 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
the novel as a sign of his power). In the fairy tale of Aladdin, of course, the boy triumphs over the evil magician and gains vast wealth, power, and happiness through his marriage to the Princess Baldroubador. Greene’s thriller derives irony through the deliberate subversion of such happy endings: although Raven does triumph in the sense that his killing of Davis satisfies part of his craving for revenge, his own life ends in great pain and bitterness. The happy-ending story which is deliberately counterpointed against Raven’s story is not Aladdin, however, but Dick Whittington. The pantomime is based on the legend of the real Richard Whittington, a poor boy who became first a wealthy merchant and then “thrice mayor of London.” In this story the poor, homeless Dick, whose only friend and companion is his cat Bow Bells which he rescued from certain death at the hands of a mob of witchhunters, is taken into the household of alderman Fitzwarren. When the alderman embarks upon a trading venture to the court of the sultans of Barbary, young Whittington sends along his cat, the only thing of value he has in the world, as an investment in his future. The cat rids the sultan’s palace of troublesome rats and thereby earns Dick an enormous fortune. Subsequently the wealthy young man marries Alice, Fitzwarren’s daughter, and becomes mayor. The experience of Greene’s antihero Raven parallels and/or inverts the Dick Whittington story at several points. Like Whittington, Raven is young, orphaned, homeless, and friendless; the only creature for whom Raven feels any affection at the outset of his story is his kitten. Obviously neither handsome nor lucky, Raven nevertheless also knows an Alice— not an alderman’s beautiful daughter, but the humpbacked maid who cleans his room, is abused by him, and hates him even though he buys her a dress for Christmas with the stolen money he receives from Davis. She betrays him to the London police. Later, when Raven meets Anne Crowder in Nottingham and finds to his surprise that she may become his friend, he wishes he could give her as a gift of friendship the kitten he left in London. And Greene emphasizes Anne’s role as a human counterpart to Raven’s cat. When the police visit the new cottage where Anne was last seen, Mather wants to know,
A GUN FOR SALE
55
“How did she get in?” “The lock of the door’s busted.” “Could a girl do that?” “A cat could do it. A determined cat.” (78) Later, when Anne and Raven are holed up in the railway yard shed overnight, they exchange stories. His tales are of dreams which thinly disguise the truth of his crimes; hers is a pointed fable about a cat which outsmarts a fox—suggestive of her own intent to outsmart Raven. And when she does escape from him, only to be shot at by the policeman Saunders who does not recognize her, she compares herself with a cat: “Well, I’ve got six lives left” (136). Greene’s evocation of Raven as a sinister Dick Whittington is one of his most striking variations on certain familiar themes in his works: corrupted innocence, ruined or traumatic childhood, the terrifying gap between childhood fantasy and adult reality. By juxtaposing the criminal underworld with the world of children’s pantomimes and fairy tales, he creates in A Gun for Sale a particularly dark irony suitable for the drama of a Europe slipping toward war. That irony will appear again in the best of the entertainments, a book set during the war itself: The Ministry of Fear. The pantomimes nevertheless form only a part of the literary background of this novel. Several memorable elements seen here for the first time in Greene’s work appear to have been inspired by a great American novel which Greene’s diary shows that he had read in February 1933, when he was still writing Battlefield and had only begun planning England Made Me. These elements include the murderous, alienated hero from an orphanage where he was treated cruelly in the name of charity; the mad clergyman cut off from his church; the use of the razor as a murder weapon (instead of the clubs actually used, according to contemporary accounts, by racecourse gangs); and the ironies associated with “Christmas”—all of which are equally prominent in William Faulkner’s Light in August. Now A Gun for Sale is so unlike Faulkner’s novel in most respects that an influence might at first seem unlikely, yet the striking parallels suggest the opposite. Moreover, such borrowing is typical of Greene’s method, especially in this period. He was still a young writer of modest success and more promise than
56 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
achievement; he was possessed of a sensibility that regularly conceived of plot events and ideas in a literary frame; and in his “entertainments” he was working quickly for money, drawing upon sources with a fresh and vigorous appetite which allowed a less complete digestion of them than can usually be found in the serious novels. For these reasons it is important to consider other sources which arguably are the most important of all in A Gun for Sale: Browning’s “Childe Roland to the Dark Tower Came,” from which Greene adapted the structure of his novel as a failed heroic quest; and Tennyson’s Maud, from which he derived key elements of character, image, and theme. Readers of Greene’s autobiographical writings will recall that Browning’s poetry was a powerful influence on the young Greene long before The Waste Land was published. In A Sort of Life he describes his father’s “enthusiasm for Robert Browning” as “the bacillus of a recurring fever.” The elder Greene gave his son an edition of Browning as a gift for Confirmation, “but it was certainly not a belief in God that Browning confirmed. I had emerged from my psychoanalysis without any religious belief at all…and what I took from Browning my father might well have thought unhealthily selective” (117). Indeed, before assuming as Crawford does that Greene’s “explanation and imagery” for the lust, betrayal, and violence of the “real world” came from Eliot, we might do well to consider Greene’s own account of what he found in Browning: “With Robert Browning I lived in a region of adulteries, of assignations at dark street corners, of lascivious priests and hasty dagger thrusts, and of sexual passion far more heady than romantic love” (118). A curious resemblance between Greene’s career and Browning’s points up the way in which Browning’s poetry—and Tennyson’s—answered Greene’s specific needs at this juncture in his career. Browning’s early poetry was characterized by an intensely personal, confessional quality heavily influenced by Shelley’s Romantic lyrics. After being castigated severely in a famous review by John Stuart Mill, Browning turned away from such subjective poetry and toward the objectivity of the dramatic monologue. Greene’s career involves an analogous shift: his first three published novels were excessively personal works in which the foreign and/or historical settings failed to separate adequately the material from the personality and
A GUN FOR SALE
57
emotions of the author. As discussed earlier in these pages, Greene himself traced the failure of The Name of Action and Rumour at Nightfall to the insufficient distance between himself and his subject. And Greene’s break with his own excessively personal work was precipitated, as Browning’s had been, by unfavorable reviews. The New Republic, for example, had described the characters in Rumour as staggering “under the overwhelming weight of their own mental questionings and probings” (Sherry 1:395), and Frank Swinnerton, in an Evening News review on 20 November 1931, had criticized the same novel for its baffling dialogue and incomprehensible characters: “Not one of these people can give a plain answer to a plain question. Their tongues jump heavily into irrelevance. They are not so much evasive as gravely incomprehensible, even to one another” (qtd. in Sherry 1:396). Greene later cited Swinnerton’s judgment as most influential in bringing about the change of direction in his novels. The immediate result of the transition for Greene was his Buchanesque thriller Stamboul Train, which effectively substituted quick pacing and multiple centers of interest for the depth of characterization and psychological complexity he had attempted in the earlier three books. Yet neither in this work nor in the two that followed would Greene fully discover the voice that would sustain him in his major fiction. Certain of his limitations had become clear: he was unable to present convincingly the inner lives of lower class characters like Kay Rimmer or Milly Drover in It’s a Battlefield, or of wealthy capitalists like Erik Krogh in England Made Me. He could not reproduce Huxley’s ironic voice, although, as John Atkins has pointed out, he echoes it at times in It’s a Battlefield, and he was only partly successful in writing stream-of-consciousness narrative in England Made Me. What he needed was a mode that would enable him to combine his familiar habit of framing his subject in the context of literary parallels and allusions while simultaneously creating a point of view that gave release to the tensions and conflicts within himself—tensions arising, for example, from his latent romanticism, soured and tempered by experience; from his uneasiness in the marriage and family life, which he had sought obsessively and, it seems, betrayed compulsively; from his Catholic faith, accepted intellectually but not felt emotionally, and pursued from the beginning out of
58 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
questionable motives; and from his aspiration to rise in the literary establishment while harboring contempt for the bourgeois society that underpinned it. The mode Greene discovered reached its fullest expression in the final novels of the first phase, A Gun for Sale and especially Brighton Rock. Both are novels that create a great deal of tension by detaching the reader’s sympathy from the social norms upon which it is usually founded and forcing it toward radically alienated, sociopathic characters. Neville Braybrooke, in a perceptive early essay on Greene as a “pioneer novelist,” called attention to the personal element as well as the narrative device Greene used in these and later novels: Greene is a writer who constantly transposes sentiments and comments expressed in his autobiographical work to his fiction. It is a habit fraught with dangers for the novelist, but a method for which Greene has fashioned his own simple technique. It is the adaptation of the dramatic soliloquy to the confines of the novel; in the process, histrionics are abandoned, so that one has the impression not of somebody declaiming his thoughts to the world at large but of somebody whispering his inmost doubts and conflicts to one by telephone. (6) The description is not strictly precise; what Greene employs is a combination of vivid objective omniscient narration with free indirect discourse to plunge the reader directly into the world defined by his characters’ sensibility and experience, and he presents in each work a central, powerful, grotesque character whose world-view is inevitably the one readers identify with the novel even though other centers of interest are presented. Greene’s skill in such distorted world views led Wayne Booth to advance a caution in behalf of naive readers: Graham Greene’s Catholic readers have often reproached him for making his evil characters too sympathetic, for making evil itself attractive. Such readers, presumably, have not themselves been harmed; at least they always speak only of the potential harm to other readers. But we can infer that the really harmful misreading, the most tragic false identifications of the reader with the vicious
A GUN FOR SALE
59
centers of consciousness, never are discussed in print. Even the great satires, in which the moral issues would seem to be crystal clear, often lead naive students astray in this regard. How much more often must the naive reader be led into disastrous conclusions by overlooking the subtle condemnations embedded in the works of Greene? (389) It is not surprising that in creating A Gun for Sale Greene was drawn to the dramatic monologues of Browning and Tennyson. While a detailed discussion of the dramatic monologue as practiced by the Victorian poets is beyond the scope of this chapter, a few key points may serve to emphasize the connection with Greene’s late first-phase writing. First and most obvious is the way in which the dramatic monologue enables the writer to explore ideas removed from his own, or to present extreme versions of his own ideas from behind a mask. What Greene does in the two concluding works of the first phase had been hinted at in his treatment of Conrad Drover in It’s a Battlefield. He throws his already familiar themes—the problem of injustice, the misery and degradation of poverty, the sense of life as a perpetual battlefield in an undeclared war— into sharp relief by filtering them through the consciousness of sociopathic characters whose alienation from the world is complete and unalterable. A second point of connection is what Robert Langbaum describes as the tension between sympathy and judgment that the dramatic monologue generates in the reader; it does so by giving primacy to experience over idea (85). Many of Greene’s first-phase protagonists, but most clearly the last two (Raven and Pinkie), create in most readers the contradictory impulses to sympathize and to condemn. That explains in large measure why Greene himself, looking for an appropriate epigraph for all of his novels, turned to a dramatic monologue—Browning’s “Bishop Blougram’s Apology”: My interest’s in the dangerous edge of things, The honest thief, the tender murderer, The superstitious atheist, demi-rep That loves and saves her soul in new French books—
60 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
We watch while these in equilibrium keep The giddy line midway. A third connection is what Carol Christ identifies as the imprisoned self of the monologue’s speaker: Browning portrays character after character engaged in the Romantic project of asserting the center of the universe that is ‘I’ while being, seeing, knowing, tasting, feeling all. But these characters are typically so grotesque and eccentric that the poems emphasize not the discoveries but the limitations that self-consciousness involves. Browning’s dramatic monologues characteristically concern the prison of self which the speaker constructs in attempting to encompass and control his world. (18) Greene’s grotesque characters express such radically alienated and distorted views of life that in the end they cannot learn or change. Yet much of the interest in his plots derives from their focus on the seeming possibility of such illumination or change; both novels explore the possible conditions under which change might occur, and both turn away from that possibility in the end. His most grotesque protagonists appear at the end of the first phase where they are, by most measures, at the extreme opposite end of the spectrum of subjectivity from those early figures whose resemblance to their creator was too transparent. In that regard they represent the end of one possible line of development after which Greene would undertake a new direction, creating characters who slowly begin to display unmasked qualities of the author himself.
A GUN FOR SALE AND BROWNING’S “CHILDE ROLAND” The influence of literature, Greene writes in A Sort of Life, can outlast that of religious teaching, and after fifty years he finds certain lines of Browning to have been more influential and memorable for him than the Beatitudes. To emphasize the point he quotes several passages from Browning’s verse. The
A GUN FOR SALE
61
second of these passages—“I never saw a brute I hated so; /He must be wicked to deserve such pain”—includes the line from “Childe Roland to the Dark Tower Came” recalled by policeman Saunders as he watches outside the shed where James Raven is hiding in A Gun for Sale. For Saunders, who learned his Browning in night school, the suggestion that Raven or any other criminal “must be wicked to deserve such pain” is “comforting”: “[T]hose who followed his profession couldn’t be taught a better; that’s why he remembered it” (104). By offering a convenient rationalization that obviates the need for sympathy toward the hunted man, the line from Browning’s poem ironically increases the reader’s sympathy for the friendless Raven. And it establishes one brief but emphatic connection between Greene’s knowledge of “Childe Roland” and his conception of character and event in the novel. The kinship between the two works runs much deeper than this, however, and involves subtle but distinct similarities in structure, atmosphere, and theme. Both “Childe Roland” and A Gun for Sale are structured around a journey or quest in which a lonely protagonist must vindicate his life in some way by reaching a mysterious place of testing where he can demonstrate his courage and honor. In Browning’s poem this mysterious testing-place is the Dark Tower which the knight does not even recognize until he is already upon it; in Greene’s novel the place is also a tower—the Midland Steel Tower in Nottwich, headquarters of the evil industrialist Sir Marcus—which is revealed to Raven as his destination only at the end of his journey. For both characters the object of the quest is entirely personal. Browning’s knight does not explain what the Dark Tower is or why he pursues it; we know only that he attains some kind of fulfillment by reaching it and blowing his horn to send forth a challenge. The meaning of his act, apart from its obvious testament of courage and perseverance, is simply whatever it means to him. James Raven’s quest is similarly personal: he seeks revenge, and the fact that by achieving it he may prevent the outbreak of war in Europe is of no consequence to him. Within these larger structural and thematic similarities are parallel motifs, emotions, and images which further suggest Greene’s indebtedness to Browning’s poem. For example, both journeys are initiated by acts of betrayal that confirm the
62 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
protagonist’s sense of hopelessness and the certainty of death. Browning’s knight is directed toward the Dark Tower by a “hoary cripple, with malicious eye” who cannot suppress his “glee” at having ensnared another victim. The knight knows that if he accepts the old man’s “counsel” and turns “Into that ominous tract which, all agree, /Hides the Dark Tower,” the cripple will laugh and write his epitaph in the dust. Yet he does follow that counsel, not with hope but with hopelessness and “gladness that some end might be” (st. 3). Clearly his hopelessness is the expression of a life of suffering and failure, although the specific terms of that suffering are not revealed: For, what with my whole world-wide wandering, What with my search drawn out through years, my hope Dwindled into a ghost not fit to cope With that obstreperous joy success would bring— I hardly tried now to rebuke the spring My heart made, finding failure in its scope. (st. 4) Raven is also betrayed, first by “Cholmondeley” (Davis), whose eyes “twinkle” with pleasure during the meeting in which he pays Raven with stolen money; and then by Alice, the maid who describes him to the police. Raven, too, is utterly hopeless, and the terms of his despair, unlike those of the knight’s, are abundantly clear. The death of his father, also a criminal, by hanging; the suicide of his mother; the ugliness of his harelip; and the cruelty and misery of his childhood in an orphanage— these are the representative conditions of the only life he has known or expects to know, and therefore his pursuit of Davis and Sir Marcus becomes an attempt to gain revenge against the whole of life. Raven’s hopelessness is an immediate practical matter as well, for he is guilty of a crime more serious than the one for which he has been framed, and both his deformity and his lack of money make it impossible for him to escape the police for long. The only question is whether he can escape long enough to gain revenge against his betrayers. He knows London well and is safest in its vast expanses, but he gambles even that questionable safety in order to pursue Davis to the unfamiliar Nottwich. On the train he stands at the window, his hare-lip pressed against the glass, “watching London recede from him…
A GUN FOR SALE
63
like a man watching something he loves slide back from him out of his reach” (34). In that backward glance is an attitude of fatalism comparable to that of Browning’s Roland as he turns “quiet as despair” into his new course toward the Dark Tower and, “pledged to the plain,” pauses “to throw backward a last view/O’er the safe road…naught else remained to do” (st. 4). The mood of despair is reflected in the landscapes through which the protagonists journey. Nottwich, when Raven’s train arrives, is like a city of eternal night: “There was no dawn that day in Nottwich. Fog lay over the city like a night sky with no stars. You had only to imagine that it was night” (40). This dark city, swept by icy winds and freezing rain, surrounded by “damaged fields” and “slag heaps” (51), images the hostility of the world as experienced by Raven. Nothing in it seems to affirm life or hope, and therefore he contemplates death—the murder of Anne, or the likelihood of his own death—with detachment: “He didn’t mind death; it was foolish to be scared of death in this bare, wintry world” (49). He does not murder Anne, however, but eventually makes her his hostage. Detective Mather pursues the two of them in the fog and darkness across a dreary railroad yard, “a dark desolate waste of cinders and points, a tangle of lines and sheds and piles of coal and coke. It was like a No Man’s Land full of torn iron across which one soldier picked his way with a wounded companion in his arms” (103). Professor Crawford finds in such imagery evidence of Greene’s reproduction of the physical world of The Waste Land, but it should be worth pointing out that “Childe Roland” depicts a waste land hardly less memorable than Eliot’s. The journey in Browning’s poem resembles a nightmare or dream vision of a phantasmagoric landscape, a “starved, ignoble nature,” a land of “Bog, clay, and rubble, sand, and stark black dearth,” where the few remnants of vegetation are suggestive of disease: “As for the grass, it grew as scant as hair/In leprosy; thin dry blades pricked the mud, /Which underneath looked kneaded up with blood” (st. 13). Indeed, the landscape of “Childe Roland” not only mirrors the despair of the protagonist, as that of A Gun for Sale does, but offers two details that remind us, in this context, of Raven himself. The “great black bird” (st. 27) that sails past the knight may only coincidentally point toward Raven’s symbolic name and his association with the underworld, but the
64 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
ruined tree in the preceding stanza is strikingly suggestive of his deformity: “Then came some palsied oak, a cleft in him/Like a distorted mouth that splits at its rim/Gaping at death, and dies while it recoils” (st. 26; italics added). Raven’s harelip is of course a symbolic deformity, the external sign of the deep psychological wound stemming from his brutal childhood, the death of his father, and the scene of his mother’s suicide which left him, figuratively at least, “gaping at death.” Indeed, the inability of Raven’s memories to evoke anything other than pain and unhappiness may be compared with the failure of memory to comfort and sustain Browning’s character, who closes his eyes in an effort to recall “earlier, happier sights” and “taste of the old time to set all to rights,” but is only saddened by memories—of Cuthbert, victim of some unspecified disgrace, and of Giles, hanged for treason, his body “spit upon and cursed” (st. 16–17). “Better this present,” the knight concludes, “than a past like that,” and he commits himself again to the “darkening path” (st. 18). Greene’s character proceeds in a similar mood of grim fatalism, his progress marked by other images suggestive not so much of striking parallels but of a more pervasive influence of the poem upon the young writer whose long familiarity with it is a matter of record. Thus, the knight’s sense of entrapment upon the sudden discovery that he has reached his destination —“Where, in the very nick/Of giving up, one time more, came a click/As when a trap shuts—you’re inside the den!” (st. 29)— may be echoed in Raven’s awareness, triggered by abrupt, severe pain, of what his father felt “when the trap sprang and his neck took the weight” (42). And the knight’s fear that in fording the river he may have thrust his spear into a man’s hair or beard—or worse, into a baby—has a curious resemblance to Greene’s depiction of the ancient, evil, bearded Sir Marcus as a helpless infant, too weak to clean or feed himself, subsisting on a diet of milk and biscuits. When Raven shoots him, he falls forward, upsetting his glass of warm milk. The ending of Raven’s quest, however, provides again specific parallels to the ending of “Childe Roland.” There is a rush of noise as Browning’s knight prepares for final combat: “Not hear? When noise was everywhere! it tolled/Increasing like a bell” (st. 33). Noise, specifically the sound of bells, accompanies the final violence in A Gun for Sale: Sir Marcus sounds the
A GUN FOR SALE
65
alarm bell in the hope of being saved from Raven, and after both Sir Marcus and Davis have been shot, “a siren blew up over the town its message that the sham raid was over, and immediately the church bells broke into a noisy Christmas carol…” (168). That a Christmas caroling of bells would sound the death-knell for Raven is consistent with the ironies surrounding the Christmas setting. Browning’s character also hears a death knell at the end, the somber ringing not of actual bells but of the names of his dead comrades: Names in my ears. Of all the lost adventurers my peers— How such a one was strong, and such was bold, And such was fortunate, yet each of old Lost, lost! one moment knelled the woe of years. (st. 33) The knight sees them all, “ranged along the hillsides, met/To view the last of me, a living frame for one more picture!” (st. 34). Raven, in the moment before his death, is similarly affected by memories of his former comrades: Even Kite would have been alive now if it hadn’t been for a skirt. They all went soft at one time or another: Penrith and Carter, Jossy and Ballard, Barker and the Great Dane. He took aim slowly, absentmindedly, with a curious humility, with almost a sense of companionship in his loneliness: the Trooper and Mayhew. (169–70) Nothing at the end of Raven’s life violates or alleviates the pattern of loneliness, betrayal, and suffering of which that life has consisted; instead, the manner of his death merely confirms his own experience of life. In that regard he is like the speakers of dramatic monologues who, according to Robert Langbaum, undergo not moral change but intensification as they understand and articulate what was already known to them. In creating Raven’s story, Graham Greene may well have been influenced by the mood and imagery of Eliot’s great poem; but it seems equally obvious that he took from “Childe Roland” the journey motif, the failed romantic quest, the disillusioned hero
66 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
who asserts himself defiantly in the face of betrayal, entrapment, and death.
A GUN FOR SALE AND TENNYSON’S MAUD In its darkly ironic quest motif that leads James Raven toward a sinister modern incarnation of the dark tower, A Gun for Sale is indebted to “Childe Roland,” and it generates a uniquely English irony by setting Raven’s grim fate against the mythical success of Dick Whittington. Yet in its psychology and emotional tone the novel seems even closer to another Victorian poem: Tennyson’s monodrama Maud. Greene’s fondness for Maud is well documented. He mentions it twice and quotes several lines from it in the courtship letters, and he alludes to it strategically in Travels With My Aunt. Moreover, in the early 1930s Greene had encountered skillful intertextual uses of Tennyson’s poetry in two novels. His diary indicates that in October 1932 he read Virginia Woolf s To the Lighthouse, in which Mr. Ramsay quotes from “The Charge of the Light Brigade” in impassioned but absent-minded moods of self-absorption. The line “Someone had blundered,” which Ramsay imagines as an expression of his own misfortune, forms an ironic refrain that calls attention to his own thoughtless blunders in relationships with his family— especially his son James. Perhaps more important is that use of Tennyson’s verse—again, the “Light Brigade”—to reveal character and comment on the action is prominent in Light in August, which Greene read in January 1933. In that novel the Reverend Hightower withdraws from life into the imagined world of Tennyson’s poem, confusing the heroic moment of the poem with the antiheroic death of his grandfather in a raid on Grant’s stores in Vicksburg, Mississippi. Hightower finds in Tennyson a vision of life to which ordinary reality does not conform, and therefore he regards the reading of Tennyson as better than prayer. (And this Protestant version of the “failed priest,” the man whose name “Gail Hightower” symbolizes his choice of vocation as an attempt to escape the severe “gales” of life, may also have influenced Greene’s later conception of Pinkie, whose boyhood desire to become a priest was an attempt to escape from life.) Greene’s intention that Maud be involved in some way in the reader’s understanding of A Gun for Sale is made clear at the
A GUN FOR SALE
67
end of Part 2, where Raven, hiding in the garage of a semidetached house to escape the icy storm, hears a critic named Druce Winton reading a selection from the poem on the BBC National Programme: Raven couldn’t help but hear, standing in the cold garage by the baby’s pram, staring out at the black hail: ‘A shadow flits before me, Not thou, but like to thee; Ah Christ, that it were possible For one short hour to see The souls we loved, that they might tell us What and where they be.’ He dug his nails into his hands, remembering his father who had been hanged and his mother who had killed herself in the basement kitchen, all the long parade of those who had done him down. The elderly cultured Civil Service voice read on: ‘And I loathe the squares and streets, and the faces that one meets, Hearts with no love for me…’ He thought: give her time and she too will go to the police. That’s what always happens in the end with a skirt, —‘My whole soul out to thee’— trying to freeze again, as hard and safe as ever, the icy fragment. (66–67) The scene gives additional poignancy to Raven’s circumstances not only by identifying him with a familiar literary figure but by articulating his misery in language more elegant and precise —and easier for readers to identify with—than any Raven himself could employ. Moreover, the doleful lament “Ah Christ, that it were possible” becomes a convenient shorthand suitable for the thriller’s pace and economy: by having Raven recall it on two later occasions Greene can evoke a powerful set of related emotions in the briefest time.
68 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
The effective but obvious parallel between Raven’s unhappiness and that of Tennyson’s speaker in the monodrama is a fairly mechanical piece of allusion, and Tennyson’s story, in its outline at least, seems entirely unlike Greene’s. In the first of the poem’s three parts, the speaker, a young man, declares his disillusionment and grief over the death of his father, a victim of betrayal by a friend, the old man who is lord of the neighboring Hall, with whom the father was involved in the failure of some “vast speculation.” In spite of his bitterness, the speaker finds himself falling in love with Maud, the beautiful daughter of his father’s enemy. Eventually they declare their mutual love, but in part two the speaker quarrels with Maud’s brother and kills him in a duel. The shock of his death is fatal to Maud. When she dies, the speaker leaves the country, falls into despair, and is placed in a mental institution. In part three he recovers somewhat, returns home, and finds a kind of salvation by immersing himself in a just war. None of this seems to have much in common with Greene’s story of hired political assassination, flight, and revenge murder. But in fact the resemblances run very deep and deserve careful study, for some of the imagery as well as thematic concerns and a good deal of the emotional rhythm of A Gun for Sale recall Maud. Like Tennyson, Greene uses the point of view of a tortured mind—lonely, alienated, disaffected—to point up weaknesses in the social fabric. Both characters are victims of profound injustice; both have been emotionally scarred in their youth and have lost their ability to believe in the goodness of life. The most powerful trauma in the life of Tennyson’s speaker has been the death of his father, apparently a suicide, followed by the decline and death of his mother: For my dark-dawning youth, Darken’d watching a mother decline And that dead man at her heart and mine; For who was left to watch her but I? Yet so did I let my freshness die. (1. 690–94) Stricken by grief and a deep sense of wrong, he acquires a gloomy, pessimistic view of the world as an evil place, a view that makes him feel, early in the poem, that Maud is inaccessible to him. In his own words he is
A GUN FOR SALE
69
…splenetic, personal, base, A wounded thing with a rancorous cry, At war with myself and a wretched race, Sick, sick to the heart of life, am I. (1. 362–65) He refers several times to his heart which has turned to stone. Such conditions are, if anything, typically intensified in Greene’s novel. Although Greene’s metaphor is not stone but a “chip of ice” in the heart (the image is from Anderson’s fairy tale, “The Snow Queen”), his character is similarly hardhearted, and for similar reasons: his father was hanged as a thief, and his despairing mother committed suicide by cutting her throat at the kitchen table, without troubling to prevent the child from discovering the grisly scene. Raven’s harelip is a visible symbol of this emotional scarring, and his trauma is doubled in effect by the revelation that the old Minister whom Raven assassinates in the opening scene of the novel was actually one of his own kind, an orphan whose father was a thief and whose mother committed suicide. At least two further qualities suggest a more than coincidental resemblance between the two characters: a complete mistrust of human actions, growing out of a deep cynicism toward life; and a willingness to suspend that cynicism —in other words, to undergo a fundamental change in outlook— in response to the affection and friendship of a woman. Both characters become involved in an implicit wager: they gamble their ability to believe in the goodness of life on the fidelity of the woman—Maud, obviously, in the poem, and Anne Crowder in the novel. The poem so familiar to the author of the courtship letters and prominent in the literary background of this novel presents in secular form the same drama of salvation seen in Greene’s depiction of many of his first-phase protagonists and, in those letters, of himself. Mistrust is so deeply ingrained in the speaker of Maud that he initially doubts the signs of friendliness in the girl, whom he suspects of being used by her brother for political gain—that she might feign “A face of tenderness” so that “A wretched vote may be gained.” His description of his fundamental guardedness and mistrust employs a metaphor that seems very likely the source for the name of Greene’s character: “For a
70 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
raven ever croaks, at my side, /Keep watch and ward, keep watch and ward, /Or thou wilt prove their tool (1. 245–47; italics added) Raven’s experience in the novel begins with a lesson in mistrust: he carries out a political assassination in a coldly efficient manner and trusts his employer to pay him according to contract. The anonymous employer does not trust him, however; the payoff in stolen notes is intended to ensure that Raven will be put safely away by the police. He has, to borrow Tennyson’s phrase, “proved the tool” of powerful forces in a deadly political game. Minor but significant betrayals follow: his landlord and the maid, Alice, both betray him eagerly to the police, and the disreputable Dr. Yogel feigns a willingness to operate on Raven’s harelip while his nurse tries to telephone the police. Raven has no friends, no one to help him, nowhere to go. Only his kitten offers affection, and he must leave it behind in making his escape. It is Anne Crowder (whose symbolic identification with the kitten was discussed earlier in this chapter) who offers him the possibility of friendship, affection, and trust. Anne’s attitude toward Raven is ambivalent: she finds him repulsive but senses his need for sympathy, and she understands that her life may depend upon her ability to conceal her fear of him; moreover, she genuinely wants to help him as long as she believes that he is innocent of the murder of the Minister and is trying to prevent the outbreak of war. Raven in turn bases his entire belief in the possibility of goodness on the question of her friendship and fidelity. It is Anne who brings about a thawing of that symbolic “chip of ice” in his breast. Thinking “with astonishment” of Anne’s refusal to betray him to the police, of the possibility that she might actually believe him, he is suddenly aware of the change in himself and of the danger it represents: These thoughts were colder and more uncomfortable than the hail. He wasn’t used to any taste that wasn’t bitter on the tongue. He had been made by hatred; it had constructed him into this thin smoky murderous figure in the rain, hunted and ugly…. He had never felt the least tenderness for anyone; he was made in this image and he had his own odd pride in the result; he didn’t want to be unmade. (66)
A GUN FOR SALE
71
Raven voices the same mixture of affection and regret after he has begun his long confession to Anne: “I’d always said I wouldn’t go soft on a skirt. I always thought my lip’d save me. It’s not safe to go soft…. Now I’ve gone soft, as soft as all the rest” (125). In the novel’s violent climax Raven, having killed Sir Marcus and thereby accomplished his primary act of revenge, confronts the whining Davis as the man who tried to kill—Raven hesitates before using such an unfamiliar word—his “friend” Anne. When Davis reveals that Anne is “a policeman’s girl” who led the police to him, the despairing Raven shoots him, “for that and nothing else” (168), using two bullets when only one is necessary, “as if he were shooting the whole world in the person of stout moaning bleeding Mr Davis”: And so he was. For a man’s world is his life and he was shooting that: his mother’s suicide, the long years in the home, the race-course gangs, Kite’s death and the old man’s and the woman’s. There was no other way; he had tried the way of confession, and it had failed him for the usual reason. There was no one outside your own brain whom you could trust: not a doctor, not a priest, not a woman. (168) He has gambled his desire to live on Anne’s fidelity, and lost. Tennyson’s character makes a similar gamble. His speaker lives alone, harboring a “morbid hate and horror” of the world until the “strong new wine of love” affects his “heart of stone,” transforming his view of life. Repeatedly his emotion is expressed as an implied wager: Maud’s love and truthfulness against the bitterness of life. What will he be like at fifty, he asks, If I find the world so bitter When I am but twenty-five? Yet, if she were not a cheat, If Maud were all that she seem’d, And her smile had all that I dream’d, Then the world were not so bitter But a smile could make it sweet. (1. 277–85)
72 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
He will retain the desire to live “as long, O God, as she/Has a grain of love” for him. The speaker calls Maud “my only friend”; Raven (who is “about twenty-five”) calls Anne “my friend,” and clearly he has no other. Maud is faithful and true to her lover, but she dies before they can marry, leaving him in madness and despair. Anne’s betrayal of Raven leads to his death and deprives him forever of the hope expressed passionately by Tennyson’s speaker: Let the sweet heavens endure, Not close and darken above me Before I am quite quite sure That there is one to love me! Then let come what may To a life that has been so sad, I shall have had my day. (1. 405–11)
Maud continues to hold interest not only for its memorable portrait of personal grief, jealousy, and frustrated love but for its criticism of society at large. Tennyson was able to do what Greene would later do in several novels—Brighton Rock, A Gun for Sale, and The Ministry of Fear—to use the perceptions of a distorted mind to render in stark forms some of the authentic terrors of life as well as the failings of contemporary society. Tennyson’s speaker projects his own unhappiness against a background of greed, selfishness, and suffering in English society at large. He interprets the betrayal and death of his father as a consequence of murderous greed operative in that society. Without hope or trust prior to the reappearance of Maud in his life, he sees the world as sordid, full of “vitriol madness” and characterized by “filthy by-lanes” in which husbands beat their wives, “And chalk and alum and plaster are sold to the poor for bread, /And the spirit of murder works in the very means of life….” (1. 39–40). Lies, theft, violence, greed—these form a way of life that seems to grow out of the natural order of the world, in which “[N]ature is one with rapine,… And the whole little wood where I sit is a world of plunder and prey” (1. 123–25). Central to the irony in the hero’s embittered view of life is the contrast between the ostensible peace enjoyed by his country and the condition of war that exists beneath the peaceful surface. Peace is meaningless, he says, when men are dishonest
A GUN FOR SALE
73
—“unworthy,” he says—when “only the ledger lives” and “the poor are hovell’d and hustled together, each sex, like swine” (1. 34). There is “Peace in the vineyard—yes!—but a company forges the wine” (1. 36). Peace becomes not a blessing but a curse; the real condition of life is not peace at all but war: “Civil war, as I think, and that of a kind/The viler, as underhand, not openly bearing the sword” (1. 27–28). The charge is reiterated on behalf of children who are victims of the age’s selling out to Mammon: When a Mammonite mother kills her babe for a burial fee, And Timour-Mammon grins on a pile of children’s bones, Is it peace or war? better, war! loud war by land and by sea, War with a thousand battles, and shaking a hundred thrones! (1. 45–48) It is perhaps in Tennyson’s link between suffering children and the “undeclared war” that Maud is closest in spirit to A Gun for Sale, the first of Greene’s novels to dramatize the “lost childhood” theme so often discussed in his work. The next five novels will depict prominent victims who are literal or figurative lost children: Brighton Rock (Pinkie and Rose); The Confidential Agent (Else Crowle and Rose Cullen); The Power and the Glory (the priest’s daughter Brigitta and Coral Fellows); The Ministry of Fear (a double effect through Rowe’s amnesia as well as the loss of his innocent past); and The Heart of the Matter (Scobie’s daughter and the little girl who dies after the shipwreck). (There are seven books in this sequence if one includes the multiple anonymous victims of Harry Lime’s penicillin racket in The Third Man.) The memories of Raven’s miserable childhood have been detailed earlier in this chapter. He is, in Gwen Boardman’s terms, “a lost child symbolic of all those wailing in England’s tenements” (34). The undeclared war that Tennyson’s hero recognizes as the true state of the society he lives in is felt by Raven in immediate, personal terms: “All this talk of war. It doesn’t mean a thing to me. Why should I care if there’s a war? There’s always been a war for me”(129). Samuel Hynes has written the best commentary on the role of war in A Gun for Sale. Describing the novel as “a war-novel
74 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
before the event” (232), Hynes notes that the book is “about the fear of war…a feeling that all Englishmen shared in 1936”: The threat of war fills the novel: characters discuss it, newspaper headlines and hoardings report it, it is uttered in radio broadcasts and written on moving news-signs. But there is another war, too, a war that is less public and newsworthy, but is already going on—the war of the powerful against the weak, the rich against the poor, the ‘big organized battalions’ against the loners and outsiders. (233) The “other war,” Hynes points out, helps to create the temporary alliance between the outlaw Raven and Anne, “a cheerful working-class girl, loyal to her class and against the big battalions” (233). Greene’s evocation of the industrial cityscape through battlefield images sustains the theme, seen earlier in It’s a Battlefield, that “a city is the scene of a continuous war for survival” (234). Hynes sees the “core of meaning” in A Gun for Sale as “the relationship between these two wars”: The poor, like Raven, have always had their war; but now the same antagonists—the men who control money and power—threaten to extend that conflict onto another, more destructive plane, to bring all of Europe into war. (234) On the question of possible outbreak of an actual war, Tennyson’s speaker is, prior to his experience of love for Maud, indifferent. He prefers a detached “philosopher’s life” remote from the “clamor of liars”: “Shall I weep if a Poland fall? shall I shriek if a Hungary fail? …/I have not made the world, and He that hath made it will guide” (1. 147–49). But later he seeks to overcome his grief over the death of Maud by losing himself in the larger cause of a just war. He sees war as a redemptive act, uniting a “loyal” people in worthy purpose; the thought of war in defense of “right” lightens his despair. Of such fervent declarations of public loyalties, and of the idea of war as an alternative to despair, A Gun for Sale forms
A GUN FOR SALE
75
an implicit criticism. In this novel, as in many of Greene’s works, only the private loyalties have validity. Certainly the impending war should be averted at all costs; there could be no glory, no meaning at all in a conflict arising from the machinations of a corrupted capitalist like Sir Marcus. War would be, as Hynes suggests, the “ultimate expression” of evil already incarnate in monstrous characters like Acky, Davis, and especially Sir Marcus. A Gun for Sale, though not one of Greene’s major achievements, remains provocative and highly entertaining and offers an excellent vantage point from which Greene’s evolution as a novelist may be seen. The courtship letters show how Greene as an ardent young lover regularly saw, and encouraged Vivien to see, their relationship in a kind of literary frame; the strategy accomplished the multiple functions of (1) allowing him to express emotions more elegantly and precisely than he might otherwise have been able to do; (2) elevating the courtship by linking his own feelings with those of great literary figures; (3) participating in the enterprise of literature in something like a vicarious way—i.e., by creating through the imagination a world in which life and literary art are interpenetrable, so that each performs a comment on the other. A Gun for Sale carries those habits of the writer-suitor into the realm of novel-writing; not only does Greene borrow strategies (as in the case of Eliot’s allusive technique and Faulkner’s characters), but he also creates a narrative that both sustains and comments on familiar Victorian poems that had helped to shape his own imagination since childhood. The allusive method (including Browning and Tennyson again, but drawing primarily upon earlier writers), the embittered, alienated protagonist, and the motif of war with its accompanying imagery would appear again soon in a book that in many respects is a distillation of Greene’s narrative art of the period and is a major turning-point in his work: Brighton Rock.
76
CHAPTER FOUR Brighton Rock
Brighton Rock represents both a major achievement and a crucial turning point in Greene’s work. Richly allusive, superbly paced in a quick, nervous style, with plot and imagery drawing upon the cinematic devices of cross-cutting and montage, the novel is as entertaining and suspenseful as any of the “entertainments,” the category to which Greene originally assigned it. Brighton Rock carries on the study of a tormented criminal mind begun in A Gun for Sale; the novel centers around a character, Pinkie Brown, in whom Greene develops more fully, and with tragic overtones, the embittered, murderous antihero first presented in James Raven. Like Raven, Pinkie is young, vicious, alienated, unloved (until he meets Rose) and perhaps incapable of love; Pinkie similarly bears scars from a traumatic childhood, but unlike Raven’s harelip his scars are internal and are given a Freudian explanation. Brighton Rock also continues Greene’s presentation of a point of view through which the pieties and cheerful optimism of middle-class life are savagely attacked. In Greene’s practice the method serves a narrative voice which projects a distinctly literary and usually soured romanticism as a dim backdrop to the often lurid melodramatic surface of contemporary life. It is a voice which will persist in later works in spite of other changes in tone and the conspicuous paring down of Greene’s style, and in several second-phase books it will be identified with a narrator-protagonist. Brighton Rock also takes Greene into new territory as the first of the “Catholic novels” that would form the initial basis of his reputation as a major writer of his age. To do justice to the novel’s complexity as well as its important position among Greene’s works, I will discuss it under several headings in this chapter, with
78 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
emphasis first upon its continuities of theme, image, and allusive method with the earlier work, and second upon its literary background and its religious themes. PINKIE AS NAPOLEONIC STRATEGIST Greene’s depiction of his tormented protagonist is rich in literary associations and analogues, including carefully plotted links between Pinkie and a number of historical and literary figures remarkable not only for their ambitious plans but also for their attempts—finally unsuccessful—to translate those ambitions into reality through military force. Indeed, the allusions to battlefields, warships, military tactics, and real or would-be conquerors are so numerous in Brighton Rock as to suggest strong continuity between this work and the two earlier books similarly concerned with the condition of English society: It’s a Battlefield, in which Greene used the battlefield as metaphor for political and economic struggle in modern urban life; and A Gun for Sale, in which the prospect of war only threatens to make palpable to all the condition of life already experienced by many. Unlike the battlefield metaphor in the earlier work, however, the many allusions in Brighton Rock are frequently ironic and tinged, finally, with the mock-heroic, serving to depict not just the power and danger of Pinkie’s designs but their preposterousness and inevitable failure as well. Central to this aspect of Greene’s conception of Pinkie are the figures of Napoleon I and Napoleon III. Pinkie, whose youth and diminutive stature are in this context reminiscent of Napoleon I (the “little corporal” who received his first commission at age sixteen), conceives of life as “a series of complicated tactical exercises, as complicated as the alignments at Waterloo.” He laments the lack of sufficient time for quasimilitary planning: “Tactics, tactics, there was never any time for strategy” (137). Consistent with this impression of Pinkie is his posture after he has been attacked by Colleoni’s men at the racetrack, an image which recalls the familiar pose of Bonaparte with one hand tucked inside his coat: “Pinkie limped along the sand with his bleeding hand hidden, a young dictator…” (133). Later, at the sight of Pinkie’s wounds, his
BRIGHTON ROCK
79
lawyer Prewitt picks up the image of combat: “Oh dear, oh dear,” he says, “you’ve been in the wars” (143). Ida, the nemesis who defeats this would-be Bonaparte in the end, is associated with nautical imagery and naval battles. Determined to pursue Rose relentlessly until the girl reveals the truth about Pinkie’s murder of Fred Hale, Ida moves through Snow’s restaurant “like a warship going into action, a warship on the right side in a war to end wars, the signal flags proclaiming that every man would do his duty” (148). Yet her attempt to persuade Rose to betray Pinkie meets “militant” resistance both literally and figuratively when Rose refuses: The bony and determined face stared back at [Ida]: all the fight there was in the world lay there-warships cleared for action and bombing fleets took flight between the set eyes and the stubborn mouth. It was like the map of a campaign marked with flags. (248) Ida leaves the encounter looking “a little flushed, a little haughty sailing down the street” (249; italics added); and later, after her defeat of Pinkie is complete, she is described as resembling “a figurehead of Victory,” a comparison which not only confirms her triumph but also recalls the famous warship Victory, aboard which Lord Nelson led the defeat of Napoleon’s naval forces at the Battle of Trafalgar. (Even Greene’s choice of Nelson Place as the site of Rose’s miserable home would seem to echo the Napoleonic theme. Greene has written that a real Nelson Place did exist in Brighton, but even so the choice of one such location over another may have been influenced by—or may have influenced—his use of allusions to Napoleon.) Pinkie’s “Napoleonic” ambition links him also with Louis Napoleon, or Napoleon III, the “little Napoleon” whose dream of restoring his uncle’s empire led finally to humiliating defeat and capture. Largely successful as an administrator of France’s internal affairs, Napoleon III attempted to expand the power and influence of the Second Empire through a militant foreign policy. Successful at first against Russia (in the Crimean War) and Italy, he failed seriously in ventures against Mexico and Austria and, in 1870, against Prussia, who defeated the French soundly at the Battle of Sedan. While Napoleon remained in captivity after Sedan, his government at home was overthrown;
80 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
consequently, upon his release in 1871 he went into exile in England, where he stayed for a time in Brighton with wife Eugénie. In the novel Greene makes him a one-time resident of the fictional Cosmopolitan Hotel, now the home of Pinkie’s oily arch-rival, Colleoni. Pinkie, on his first visit there, is fascinated by the elegant arm-chairs and couches stamped with “Napoleonic crowns” and adorned with gold and silver thread. “Napoleon the Third used to have this room,” Colleoni tells him, “and Eugénie.” But Colleoni relishes no irony and knows little history in this case; when Pinkie asks who Eugénie was, Colleoni replies, “Oh, one of those foreign polonies” (77). Pinkie’s own dim perception of a connection between himself and Napoleon III turns not upon historical knowledge but upon ambition. He wants the luxurious trappings of power and authority, and these in turn he associates with heroic conquest. The pervasive imagery of conquest extends even to the boy’s attitude toward sexuality, an attitude vividly conveyed in the scene in which he contemplates with “scared lust” the prospect of a brief sexual encounter—for him, an initiation—with Spicer’s girlfriend, Sylvie. For Pinkie the occasion foreshadows his forthcoming marriage to Rose: He put his hand on her thigh with a kind of horror: Rose and he: forty-eight hours after Prewitt had arranged things: alone in God knows what apartment—what then, what then? He knew the traditional actions as a man may know the principles of gunnery in chalk on a blackboard, but to translate the knowledge to action, to the smashed village and the ravaged woman, one needed help from the nerves. (164–65) Pinkie knows that if he joins Sylvie in the back seat of the Lancia he will compound his own prior sins of murder and betrayal with the shared evil of Sylvie’s lust and infidelity; moreover, she represents the spoils of victory—of his murder of Spicer. Yet the ultimate victim of his strategy is of course Rose, and Pinkie senses, as he looks toward the secular marriage that will place both Rose and himself in mortal sin, that the power to corrupt her soul along with his own is greater and more profound than the power to murder:
BRIGHTON ROCK
81
He was conscious for a moment of his enormous ambitions under the shadow of the hideous and commonplace act: the suite at the Cosmopolitan, the gold cigar-lighter, chairs stamped with crowns for a foreigner called Eugeen. Hale [his murder victim] dropped out of sight, like a stone thrown over a cliff; he was at the beginning of a long polished parquet walk, there were busts of great men and the sound of cheering, Mr. Colleoni bowed like a shopwalker, stepping backward, an army of razors was at his back: a conqueror. Hooves drummed along the straight and a loud-speaker announced the winner: music was playing. His breast ached with the effort to enclose the whole world. (166) The tone of the passage approaches the mock-heroic, for the reader knows that Pinkie’s ambition “to enclose the whole world” is both childish in its absurdity and tawdry in its few specific aims. Pinkie would most probably be quite content to take over the world of Napoleon III’s heir-apparent in Brighton, Colleoni. Furthermore, the scene concludes ironically with Pinkie’s turning away in fear and disgust from the prospect of the encounter: “Marry, he thought, hell, no; I’d rather hang” (167). Pinkie’s murder of Spicer, the loyal gang member he no longer trusts, is an act of desperation which grows out of his own earlier failure as “Napoleonic” strategist. His initial plan is to lead Spicer to the Brighton racetrack to be killed by Colleoni’s men. When, on that occasion, the unsuspecting Spicer places a bet on the four o’clock race, the result reveals still more of the author’s allusive technique. The winning horse, “Black Boy,” is Ida’s horse; her winnings will enable her to remain in Brighton long enough to pursue Pinkie to his death. The second horse, “Momento Mori,” is Spicer’s—unknown to him, an omen of death. The third horse, “General Burgoyne,” calls to mind the failed master plan of the British general who attempted to divide and conquer the American colonies with a three-pronged attack on Albany, N.Y. His object was to separate New England from the other colonies, and his initial success at Fort Ticonderoga made him confident of victory. The other “prongs” failed to materialize according to plan, however;
82 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
Burgoyne was consequently defeated at the Battle of Saratoga in 1777, and his entire campaign was lost. The story of still another figure of enormous ambition and scheming is recalled, indirectly and humorously, in Brighton Rock through the presence of Ida’s friend Clarence, the “old ghost” who once seduced her by pretending to be fatally ill. Clarence appears only twice in the novel—once before Ida learns of Hale’s death, and once at the end after she has carried out her scheme of vengeance. On both occasions she addresses him as “ghost,” and both times he sits in Heneky’s next to a wine barrel—a humorous allusion to the Duke of Clarence, victim of the murderous schemes of Shakespeare’s Richard III and best known for his legendary death by drowning in a butt of Malmsey wine. The ghost of Clarence appears to Richard shortly before the latter’s death on Bosworth Field: “To-morrow in battle think on me,” says the ghost, “And fall thy edgeless sword: despair and die” (V. iii. 134–45). Richard III is another figure whose careful strategies lead to temporary victory and then ultimate defeat, specifically a military defeat. Greene’s protagonist shares with him his scheming, his lack of conscience regarding the act of murder, and notably his hypocritical wooing of a young woman (Anne in the play, Rose in the novel) he does not love but plans to murder. Greene’s use of the ironic allusions to the Napoleons and General Burgoyne, together with his wryly humorous placing of the “ghost” Clarence by the wine barrel early and late in Brighton Rock, suggests a narrative strategy in which texture is enriched and character deepened through the ironic humor shared by the narrator and his reader but not by any character except the lawyer Prewitt, whose literary bent expresses itself through allusions, primarily to Shakespeare and Marlowe, that are lost upon Pinkie. Although Prewitt does not speak of military campaigns except in the brief instance mentioned earlier, he nevertheless contributes to the allusive pattern whereby the failure of Pinkie’s strategies and ambitions is foreshadowed. Meeting Pinkie and Rose at the registry office where they will be married, Prewitt picks up a rose from the tiled floor and quotes—“promptly” and “inaccurately”—“Roses, roses all the way, and never a sprig of yew” (207). Greene’s deliberateness, first in providing his character with this jumbled allusion, and second in labeling it inaccurate, speaks
BRIGHTON ROCK
83
for itself. The first half of Prewitt’s line comes from Browning’s poem “The Patriot,” in which the speaker—a proud figure who, like Icarus, “leaped at the sun” and fell—recalls his lost glory as a political leader: a year earlier he had ridden down a rosestrewn pathway through cheering crowds, amid waving banners and ringing bells; today he rides to his execution. The second half of Prewitt’s line, from Arnold’s “Requiescat,” provides a note of funereal gloom and points to the death of a lover—a fitting note for the wedding that is to follow. Significantly, this allusion appears only a few lines after Pinkie, contemplating his and Rose’s “corruption” through the coming secular marriage, is “filled with awe at his own powers.” Pinkie’s confidence at the moment has been fed, of course, by the ease of his earlier triumph in persuading Rose to accept his offer of marriage: it is by this strategy that he intends to protect himself from the only possible testimony that could incriminate him in the murder of Fred Hale. Yet even the moment of his successful marriage proposal is undercut by the author’s technique of ironic allusion: in the brief proposal scene the narrator twice mentions a “badly foxed steel engraving of Van Tromp’s Victory” (127) that hangs in Rose’s room; she looks “from Van Tromp’s Victory to the two looking-glasses” (128) before accepting Pinkie’s offer. Greene’s allusion to the Dutch Admiral Tromp could concern any of several occasions celebrated by Dutch and English painters and engravers. The context of the allusion, however, suggests that he may have had in mind Tromp’s temporary victory over the English at the outset of the first Anglo-Dutch naval war in 1652. According to legend—almost certainly untrue—Tromp boasted of his victory by sailing the Channel with a broom at his masthead, thus signifying that he had swept the Channel clear of English forces. Tromp’s victory was short-lived, however; he lost the next battle and, a few months afterward, was killed in the battle of Terheijde in 1653. If indeed Greene had this occasion in mind, the connection between Tromp’s temporary victory and Pinkie’s seems clear enough. Pinkie believes he has saved himself by arranging a marriage that in fact will lead to his defeat and death. Greene emphasizes this ironic parallel by linking the figurative blindness of Rose—who awaits Pinkie’s kiss, after his proposal, “like a blind girl,” and who moves him to a rare moment of pity
84 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
at the sight of her “blind lost face” (128)—with the blind band Pinkie encounters in the streets of Brighton at the beginning of the next chapter (and on the very next page of the text). The band’s plaintive music is “like a voice prophesying sorrow at the moment of victory” (129). There remains at least one military figure in the allusive background of Brighton Rock whose name is associated with neither death nor defeat. Appropriately he is Bartolomeo Colleoni, the namesake of Pinkie’s arch-rival in the Brighton underworld. The historical Colleoni was an outstandingly successful Venetian general, a master of field artillery tactics who has been called the greatest military strategist of fifteenthcentury Italy. He retired, undefeated, to a prosperous life. For Greene’s Colleoni, the prospects are similarly good; he appears firmly ensconced in the luxuries of the Cosmopolitan Hotel, where his feigned respectability is no longer threatened by Pinkie or the police. Colleoni, Tromp, Burgoyne, Richard III less directly, and the two Napoleons more directly—all of these historical and literary figures contribute to the ironic portrait of Pinkie, the Napoleonic strategist whose satanic determination to rule in the underworld rather than serve God is mocked by the novel’s allusive structure, which foreshadows his inevitable failure as it highlights the absurd disproportion between his vast ambition and the limited means and tawdry goals to which it is attached. Greene’s method in this regard could hardly be more fitting for the period of the late thirties, that troubled decade in which Europe saw the rise of a new dictator of such monstrous evil that even Pinkie quickly pales by comparison. Generations to come would compare this man with the anti-Christ, and he would persistently regard himself as a modern Napoleon. The menacing cloud of Nazism aside, Greene’s use of the Napoleonic theme can be traced to likely sources mentioned in the diaries. Napoleon III appears in a seance in Confessions of a Medium, one of the books Greene read in his investigation of spiritualism, and he is a subject of “Prince HohenstielSchwangau,” a dramatic monologue by Browning, whose importance for Greene has already been discussed. Of more importance is Napoleon Bonaparte. In this regard Pinkie Brown’s precursor is not Raven but Dostoevsky’s Raskolnikov, the youthful murderer who saw Napoleon as the personification
BRIGHTON ROCK
85
of the superman and formed his own murderous ambitions as part of an attempt to become like Napoleon. Although neither the 1932–33 diaries nor the courtship letters mention Greene’s reading of Crime and Punishment, evidence exists to show that the great Russian author and the Napoleonic theme touched upon his imagination during the period. Greene saw the film The Murder of Karamazov in June 1932 (it was the film in which Anna Sten inspired him), and shortly afterward he read E.Carr’s Life of Dostoevsky. For The Spectator of 13 March 1936 (about six months before beginning the novel) he reviewed Crime et Châtiment, a French version of Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment, commenting that “the theme of the book” is stated in the film when the magistrate Porphyrius “suggested to Raskolnikov that by confessing he would renounce his crazy egotistic Napoleonic fetish, which had proved in the act of murder so bestial, and discover ‘the ordinary current of life’” (Pleasure Dome 58). One week later he reviewed an American film version of the same novel, damning it with a voice similar to that of the narrator in Brighton Rock when describing Ida Arnold: whereas the French film had “at least something of Dostoievsky’s religious and unhappy mind,” Greene writes, the American one “is vulgar as only the great new World can be vulgar, with the vulgarity of the completely unreligious, of sentimental idealism, of pitch-pine ethics, with the hollow optimism about human nature, of a salesman who has never failed to sell his canned beans” (61). Pinkie’s Napoleonic ambition, his story which begins with a first, calculated murder and then mingles suspense with salvation as the forces of justice (embodied in Ida Arnold rather than the police) draw near, and his potential for redemption through the love of a Catholic girl are strongly reminiscent of Dostoevsky’s great novel. CHARACTERS AND NAMES Greene’s own testimony shows repeatedly how his imagination responded to current or past reading, or to a film, as well as to observation. Passages from his favorite poems provided the vocabulary through which he interpreted his own feelings and his situation and declared his love. The diaries, as we have seen, recorded memorable passages from an amazing variety of
86 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
sources, germs of ideas that were stored up for future use— often as epigraphs, as in the case of Stamboul Train, England Made Me, and It’s a Battlefield. In the case of Brighton Rock, it appears that his interest in the Napoleons—both the historical figures and the Napoleon of Raskolnikov’s imagination—was also fermenting in Greene’s creative mind, waiting for a local habitation and a name. The habitation presented itself to Greene through the widely publicized racetrack wars in Brighton in the mid-thirties. His interest in these matters has been extensively documented by Norman Sherry, who points out that the kidnapping of Hale was based upon an actual kidnapping that occurred in Brighton in April 1928; the victim, Ernest Friend Smith, was beaten and robbed and later died of his injuries (1:634). More important, the idea of basing a novel on the race gang feud came from the Lewes Assize cases in the early 1930s, and the scene in Brighton Rock in which Pinkie and Spicer are attacked at the race course by Colleoni’s men was inspired by an incident, reported in the Brighton Argus on 29 July 1936, and in the London newspapers, in which a bookmaker and his clerk were attacked by sixteen men. As Sherry explains, this event certainly caught Greene’s eye. He went to Brighton only a few days later (August 4) to see the track and related low-life haunts at first hand. The leader of the attacking gang, Spinks, would provide inspiration for the occupation of Greene’s protagonist; in a fittingly ironic context, Greene would invest him with remnants of the kind of Christian tragedy familiar to readers of Dostoevsky. Sherry’s argument that Pinkie’s nemesis Ida Arnold is drawn from the popular Hollywood star Mae West (1:635) is convincing yet seem incomplete. The following paragraphs will suggest, first, why this is so, and second, why a careful examination of the literary background of Brighton Rock aids in the understanding of its genesis and meaning and is essential to a grasp of its richness and complexity. To establish the derivation of Ida from Mae West, Sherry points to the review of Klondike Annie in which Greene writes that West evokes in that film the atmosphere of smoky pubs complete with advertisements for Guinness, the beverage with which Ida is frequently associated (1:635). Compelling as this argument may be, I believe that at least part of Ida’s portrait
BRIGHTON ROCK
87
was derived from an earlier source: Clifford Bax’s Pretty Witty Nell, a biography of Nell Gwyn reviewed by Greene for The Spectator in December 1932. Greene’s review criticizes Pretty Witty Nell as padded and sometimes inaccurate but credits Bax with “two contributions to our knowledge of Nell Gwyn.” One of these—the theory that she died from syphilis—Greene finds unsurprising and therefore negligible. The other, he writes, “is the horoscope one on which [Bax] bases her character, to the unbeliever with comic effect…” (898). What especially amused Greene was Bax’s elaborate use of Nell Gwyn’s horoscope (for 2 February 1650) to interpret her character as highly sexed but essentially goodhearted: Jupiter in Scorpio (a sexual sign) and in trine to Venus and the Moon would make her ardent, loving, and richly sexed, but the position of the Moon in Cancer (the sign of the mother and the home) supports another of my earliest impressions: namely, that Nell Gwyn, though destiny made her a courtesan, was by nature maternal. (242) As an orange-girl in the theatre, Nell was, according to Bax, “comparable to barmaids in the Victorian period” and was “not a natural wanton, but…so easy going as to be easily led.” She was a rare type which often misses marriage by giving too readily. It does so because, being fundamentally maternal, it looks upon men, not as would-be clever simpletons from whom money and marriage is to be extracted, but as wilful and lovable children who must be comforted at any cost. She might, therefore, have passed from man to man, adored and deserted by all of them and, finally, remembered by all of them with tenderness and gratitude. (43) Amusing as it may have been to Greene, this horoscopic view of Nell seems to have lingered in his mind long enough to make its way into the portrait of Ida, whose character displays many of the qualities Bax attributes to Nell. Ida is not a Victorian, of course, but she is a barmaid, and she certainly is “easily led”: she confesses to Hale that she was once seduced by a man who
88 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
pretended to be dying. Ida too has “missed marriage,” at least in the sense that her one marriage (to a man named Tom who does not appear in the novel) has failed. And she has passed “from man to man” and is remembered fondly by at least two of those men, as her conversation with Clarence in Chapter Three of Part One reveals: “Why, I don’t even know how you live or how many husbands you’ve had.” “Oh, there’s only been one Tom,” Ida said. “There’s been more than Tom in your life.” “You ought to know,” Ida said. “Give me a glass of Ruby,” the sombre man said. “I was just thinking when you came in, Ida, why shouldn’t we two come together again?” “You and Tom always want to start again,” Ida said. “Why don’t you keep tight hold when you’ve got a girl?” (29) Greene does not provide a horoscope to account for the abundant sexuality that leads Ida from man to man, but he does invest in her a comparable interest in the occult: Ida believes in ghosts, consults the ouija board in pursuit of the truth about Hale’s death, and offers a palmist’s explanation of her casual sexual morality: “‘I’m not a Puritan, mind. I’ve done a thing or two in my time—that’s natural. Why,’ she said, extending towards [Rose] her plump and patronising paw, ‘it’s in my hand: the girdle of Venus’” (122). One could say of Ida, as Bax does of Nell, that she “took the sexual relationship as a matter of course” (46). More important, however, is that Ida displays the “fundamentally maternal” quality which Bax sees as central to Nell Gwyn’s character (but which Greene, in his film review cited above, does not ascribe to Mae West). None of this is intended to suggest that Mae West was not an important source for the creation of Ida. To the contrary, Ida’s associations with “ribald luxury,” her appearance surrounded by men in saloon bars, and much of the humor derived from her character almost certainly owe a great deal to the Hollywood star. My point is rather that the earlier source is too important to be neglected.
BRIGHTON ROCK
89
BRIGHTON ROCK AS A FAUSTIAN NOVEL When asked by Marie-Francoise Allain whether he did not consider his character Pinkie in Brighton Rock to be “the very incarnation of evil,” Graham Greene replied: I tried, as a sort of intellectual exercise, to present the reader with a character whom he could accept as worthy of hell. But in the end, you remember, I introduced the possibility that he might have been saved “between the stirrup and the ground.” I wanted to instill in the reader’s mind a fundamental doubt of hell. (148) Readers of the novel are likely to be surprised by this expression of doubt, for there is probably no work of Greene’s that suggests the reality of hell more forcefully than Brighton Rock does. Pinkie’s admission to Rose that he believes in hell but not in heaven establishes a kind of spiritual geography in the novel, and his defiant “Credo in unum Satanum,” together with his territorial ambitions in Brighton, aligns him with Milton’s Satan as a character who would rather rule in hell than serve in heaven. Furthermore, the Catholic characters think and talk of hell a good deal: Rose speculates that Ida “couldn’t burn if she tried,” and Pinkie thinks just before his wedding day that to marry would be worse than to be hanged. The corrosive vitriol which Pinkie carries in his pocket and which explodes in his face and causes him to leap to his death seems to prefigure the tormenting flames of hell itself; yet Pinkie’s end was always implicit in his beginning—in the ruined slum whose ironic name “Paradise Piece” evokes the condition of man in the fallen world: “Hell lay about him in his infancy.” In short, the idea of hell is so powerful and vivid in Brighton Rock that one might seriously question whether the novel is successful in instilling that “fundamental doubt” which Greene wanted the reader to experience. My concern here, however, is not with the question of Greene’s personal belief but rather with what his idea of Brighton Rock as an “intellectual exercise” suggests about the method of its composition—specifically with Greene’s use of literary sources and allusions appropriate to his design of
90 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
presenting the reader “with a character whom he could accept as worthy of hell.” It is widely known that Greene began Brighton Rock as a detective story and changed direction during the writing. Although his conversion to Catholicism had taken place ten years earlier, his earlier novels, even those with serious themes, had subordinated religious ideas to other concerns. What was it that brought about the change in direction and led Greene into the creation of an “intellectual exercise” in which the themes of salvation and damnation are memorably fused with conventions of crime melodrama? Only Greene himself could have answered the question conclusively, and he was predictably reticent about the subject. But certain influences can be enumerated as partial explanation. That the novel, like the works of so many writers of the period, was strongly affected by The Waste Land has been demonstrated at length by other critics such as Fred Crawford, discussed in an earlier chapter here, and Robert O. Evans. And, as Philip Stratford has pointed out, Greene had come increasingly to believe that the serious writer needed a strong spiritual dimension, a “religious sense” to give depth and meaning to his work. He had found that dimension in the novels of Henry James and in Jacobean drama, and he had found in Eliot’s critical writings a confirmation of his own belief in its necessity (127–32). Henry James was the subject of essays Greene published in 1933 and 1936 that point rather directly toward Brighton Rock. Greene’s reading of James tends to be highly personal and idiosyncratic, perhaps because he found in the Old Master a world view that corresponded to his own. He said, again in the interview with Allain, that his experience of life in boarding school made him “ready to believe in the existence of evil,” and as most students of Greene are aware, he claimed to have found in Marjorie Bowen’s The Viper of Milan an image of evil that confirmed many of his own attitudes. But Bowen was not a great writer to be read and reread and imitated. James was, and Greene was an avid reader of James’s fiction and criticism throughout his life. In the 1936 essay on James, he argued that “the ruling fantasy which drove [James] to write” was “a sense of evil almost religious in intensity.” James’s greatness, according to Greene, lay in his determination to render even evil “the highest kind of justice”:
BRIGHTON ROCK
91
[I]t is in the final justice of his pity, the completeness of an analysis which enabled him to pity the most shabby, the most corrupt, of his human actors, that he ranks with the greatest of creative writers. He is as solitary in the history of the novel as Shakespeare in the history of poetry. (34) Putting aside the question of the greatness of Brighton Rock, or even of Greene himself, it is clear, as Stratford has observed, that the novel is one of several in which Greene achieved that quality of pity which he attributed to James (217). Critical interpretations of Brighton Rock have often linked Pinkie Brown’s character with T.S.Eliot’s memorable lines from the essay on Baudelaire: It is true to say that the glory of man is his capacity for salvation; it is also true to say that his glory is his capacity for damnation. The worst that can be said of most malefactors, from statesmen to thieves, is that they are not men enough to be damned. These lines were quoted by Greene in his 1933 essay “Henry James: The Religious Aspect,” where he adds that “This worst cannot be said of James’s characters: both Densher and the Prince have on their faces the flush of the flames” (41). Greene’s readers probably see that flush more clearly on the face of Pinkie in Brighton Rock than on that of any of Greene’s other characters. And there are numerous additional ways in which the essays on James seem to point toward Brighton Rock. The process by which the miserable experiences of slumbred childhood led Pinkie to believe in hell but not in heaven has a curious analogue in Greene’s comment, in 1933, on James’s religion: “His religion was always a mirror of his experience. Experience taught him to believe in supernatural evil, but not in supernatural good” (43). Finally, readers who are disturbed by the apparent bleakness of Brighton Rock might keep in mind Greene’s statement in 1936 that the novels of James “are only saved from the deepest cynicism by the religious sense…” (41). Greene contended that the “religious sense” disappeared from the English novel with the death of Henry James. It seems that in Brighton Rock—perhaps after he had already begun the novel—Greene set out to restore that loss through his own work.
92 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
If Greene’s view of Henry James contributed heavily to his sense of purpose in the “intellectual exercise” of Brighton Rock, there remained the immediate question of the concrete means by which that purpose could be achieved. Here again he made significant use of literary sources. Greene, of course, is a wonderfully inventive storyteller, and any discussion of his use of literary sources should stress that he is never slavishly imitative but is often cleverly allusive, using quotations, echoes, images, and parallels—often ironically—to create complex meanings. Brighton Rock is productive territory for source hunters, and many of the important allusions to Wordsworth, Shakespeare, Browning, Arnold, Marlowe, and most importantly T.S.Eliot have been noted elsewhere. The source which has often been mentioned but not discussed adequately is the Ford, Dekker, and Rowley play The Witch of Edmonton (1623), which provided the epigraph to Brighton Rock: “This were a fine reign, /To do ill and not hear of it again.” Critics have remarked that the epigraph announces the revenge motive common to both the play and Greene’s novel, and that the play involves a young man who marries a girl and then murders her, as Pinkie plans to do with Rose in Brighton Rock. Furthermore, the distich of The Witch of Edmonton could almost be taken as a brief description of the action of Brighton Rock: “Forc’d marriage, murder; murder blood requires, / Reproach, revenge; revenge hell’s help desires.” Graham Greene’s familiarity with The Witch of Edmonton may have had a long history; certainly his biography of Rochester and his brief study British Dramatists (1943) demonstrate his extensive knowledge of seventeenth century English literature. Nevertheless, it seems likely that his use of The Witch of Edmonton as a source for Brighton Rock, which he was planning in the fall of 1936, may have been influenced by the revival of that play at the Old Vic in London in December 1936. Greene was in London at the time, could hardly have been unaware of the revival, and may well have seen the play. The comments of the reviewer for The Times suggest interesting ways in which the play has important qualities in common with that earlier-mentioned ability of Henry James to render “the highest kind of justice” and pity to shabby and corrupt characters:
BRIGHTON ROCK
93
It is stamped with sympathy for the outcast and suffering and is able to see always two sides of the human picture, even when the picture is of a villain or a witch…it is probably better to think of the play as a plainly melodramatic morality which here and there has given Dekker an opportunity to say that the wicked are not always as guilty as the fortunate suggest but are sometimes driven to a second wrong by the very remorse that arises from the first. (9 December 1936) Pinkie in Brighton Rock is driven to a “second wrong” (second murder) by expediency, not remorse; but in all other respects the reviewer’s comments could apply aptly enough to Greene’s treatment of character in the novel. The prominent revenge motive in The Witch of Edmonton arises from two rather different stories. One of these traces events in the life of Mother Sawyer, an old woman who is unjustly persecuted as a witch until she turns to real witchcraft in order to gain revenge against her tormentors. She conjures the devil, who appears, as in Goethe’s Faust, as a black dog. The Dog demands that she sell her soul to him and seal the pact with a blood covenant reminiscent of the one Mephistopheles demands of Marlowe’s Faustus. Once loose in the world, the Dog works evil not only against Mother Sawyer and her enemies but against others as well, providing the dramatic link between her story and that of Frank Thorney. Frank, who has tried to escape disinheritance by keeping his marriage to Winnifrede a secret from his father, finds himself trapped in an arranged marriage to Susan Carter, whom he does not love. He contemplates possible means of escape from his dilemma but takes no action until the black Dog rubs against him; then he murders Susan and subsequently tries to place the blame on the innocent Warbeck. The cycle of murder and revenge are thus clearly depicted as the devil’s work: Somerton, who loves Susan, is reported willing to sell his soul in order to get revenge against Warbeck. But the same black Dog that instigates the murder eventually points the way to the discovery of Frank’s guilt. Greene’s protagonist has characteristics in common with both Frank Thorney and Mother Sawyer. Like Frank, Pinkie marries a girl he does not love and then plots her death; also
94 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
like Frank, who is led into “deeper mischief” than he intended, Pinkie feels “as if he were being driven too far down a road he only wanted to travel a certain distance.” But Pinkie’s more important kinship is with Mother Sawyer, the Faustian character who sells her soul for revenge against her enemies. Pinkie commits his first murder to avenge the death of Kite, his gang-leader and spiritual father. Yet it is clear that Pinkie’s whole life—his turning to crime, his rejection of the church, his hatred of women and pleasure—is an act of revenge against the world that has afforded him nothing but misery and unhappiness: [A] prick of sexual desire disturbed him like a sickness. That was what happened to a man in the end: the stuffy room, the wakeful children, the Saturday night movements from the other bed. Was there no escape— anywhere—for anyone? It was worth murdering a world. (92) Ironically, these same emotions might have led Pinkie in a different direction. Once he was a choir boy who thought of becoming a priest—probably for the seclusion and privacy of the celibate life. Now he keeps life at bay with a razor blade. Even so, fragments of the liturgy intrude regularly into his thoughts, and beneath a vicious and violent exterior he preserves a paradoxical innocence, neither smoking nor drinking nor consorting with women. He never ceases to think of the possibility of repentance and the sacraments. “Corruptio optimi est pessimas” the old priest says to Rose after Pinkie’s death; the worst is corruption of the best. The same judgment could be made of Marlowe’s Faustus, and it seems clear that Pinkie’s decision to murder Fred Hale for revenge is a Faustian pursuit of power and knowledge. The power Pinkie pursues is “Napoleonic” power, as discussed earlier, to supplant Colleoni as ruler of the Brighton underworld, to be a conqueror. The Faustian knowledge Pinkie discovers is a metaphysical fusion of the spiritual and the sexual attained through his relationship with Rose. Greene emphasizes this double meaning by using know in its Biblical as well as its popular sense when Pinkie, Dallow, and Cubitt
BRIGHTON ROCK
95
discuss Pinkie’s forthcoming marriage and Pinkie accidentally reveals that he has murdered Spicer: “You think you know things.” All the Boy’s hatred was in the word “know” and his repulsion: he knew—like Prewitt knew after twenty-five years at the game. “You don’t know everything.” He tried to inject himself with pride, but all the time his eyes went back to the humiliation…. You could know everything there was in the world and yet if you were ignorant of that one dirty scramble you knew nothing. (149) The marriage holds out the prospect of not only carnal knowledge but also the darker knowledge of the most profound corruption: the corruption of another soul. Pinkie and Rose plan to enter a permanent state of mortal sin through their secular marriage. Rose cannot make confession that morning, and Pinkie exults in the knowledge of his role as evil seducer: He had a sense now that the murders of Hale and Spicer were trivial acts, a boy’s game, and he had put away childish things. Murder had only led up to this—this corruption. He was filled with awe at his own powers. “We’d better be moving,” he said and touched her arm with next to tenderness. As once before he had a sense of needing her. (167) That “once before” is also part of Pinkie’s journey into knowledge, the discovery that evil needs goodness to corrupt: “What was most evil in him needed her; it couldn’t get along without her goodness…. She was good, he’d discovered that, and he was damned: they were made for each other” (126). Pinkie may be unlearned, but he understands intuitively both the consequences of this knowledge and the Faustian penalty it entails: “his temporal safety for two immortalities of pain.” His view of the wedding contract recalls the blood-sealed contracts of Faustus and Mother Sawyer and identifies Pinkie himself as at least potentially a tragic character: [I]n the good old days, it occurred to him, you signed covenants like this in your blood…. He had no doubt
96 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
whatever that this was mortal sin, and he was filled with a kind of gloomy hilarity and pride. He saw himself now as a full grown man for whom the angels wept. (169) Toward the end of the novel Pinkie’s evil counsellor, the lawyer Prewitt, affirms the boy’s Faustian role by quoting to him the appropriate lines of Marlowe’s Mephistopheles: “Why this is hell, nor am I out of it.” The allusion is insistent, since Prewitt repeats it a few lines later. It offers no discovery, however, to Pinkie, who realizes as much shortly after the consummation of his marriage: “This was hell then; it wasn’t anything to worry about: it was just his own familiar room” (182). Perhaps Pinkie has realized the truth discovered by Marlowe’s Faustus: that to cut oneself off from God is to be in hell. But Greene’s literary approach to hell extends beyond such similarities in plot, character, and theme and into the patterns of imagery in the novel as well. In Goethe’s Faust and in The Witch of Edmonton the reality of evil, indeed the very presence of Satan in the world, is embodied in the black dog. Greene alludes to that same presence by introducing the superstition about black dogs into the novel and by using repeated images of dogs to suggest the pervasiveness of that evil in the world. When Ida Arnold places her bet on Black Boy in the four o’clock at the Brighton racecourse, the bookie Tate records it incorrectly, as Ida points out: “You’ve written Black Dog.” “Black Dog…. What was I thinking of. Black Dog, indeed.” “That means Care,” Ida said. “Well,” he barked with unconvincing geniality, “we’ve always something to worry about.” (70) Greene’s introduction of the image of the black dog here seems casual, but a brief look at the pervasiveness of dog images in the novel suggests otherwise. Ida, for example, speaks of an engagement at the Dirty Dog (10), the gramophone plays a song about a watchdog which “talks of our love” (51), Dallow grins “like a large friendly dog” (53), and Colleoni, whose name sounds doggish, has “something a little doggish” in his eyes (65). When Pinkie enters the lobby of Colleoni’s hotel, a “little
BRIGHTON ROCK
97
bitch sniff[s] at him and talk[s] him over with another little bitch on the settee,” but when Colleoni approaches they stop talking (61). Ida extends a “plump and patronizing paw” to Rose, then “barks” at her to be sensible and abandon Pinkie. Tate “barks” at Ida, and Dallow threatens to shut Judy up “if she barks” (122–23). Interviewed at the police station, Pinkie reads notices about “Dog Licenses,” and when Cubitt later discovers that Pinkie will need a marriage license he says, “You dog, you…. You’re a young one at the game” (116). Later, an unhappy Cubitt hears boats in the channel blowing their sirens “like dogs at night waking each other” (155), and when Ida offers him twenty pounds for information about Pinkie, he watches her indifferently, “as if he had lost his grip on thought as you loose a dog’s lead…” (162). On their wedding day Pinkie and Rose watch a romantic film in which the prelude to a sexual encounter foreshadows their own that night. The film’s music—“I know in my heart you’re divine”—makes love sound heavenly, but to Pinkie it is hellish: “It was the commonest game under the sun—why be scared at what dogs did in the streets?” (179). To marry, he thinks, is “like ordure on the hands” (101). And Dallow, hearing Pinkie’s explanation of how he once wanted to become a priest, laughs and steps into dog’s ordure. Near the end of the novel, when Pinkie and Rose stop at a Peacehaven hotel enroute to their rendezvous with death, Pinkie encounters an old schoolmate whose appearance brings back much of the bitterness and hostility of his boyhood. Greene writes: “[T]hey bristled like dogs at the sight of each other” (229). In the meantime, music in the lounge wails “upward like a dog over a grave” (231), and a moment later two men enter the lounge and shake “out their moisture like dogs,” then fall silent “scenting the girl in the lounge” (237). The satanic black dog of The Witch of Edmonton brings evil visibly into the world and leads fundamentally good but weak man like Frank Thorney to commit murder. If the play demonstrates how quickly and easily the devil enters the lives of men, that devil nevertheless remains a localized intruder. Greene’s images of dogs have the obvious function of reducing his characters’ motives and actions—particularly those involving love and sexual desire—to a bestial level, a process that
98 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
underscores the strong current of naturalism in the novel while it accounts for no small part of the seediness in this memorable version of the author’s ravaged world. Moreover, as allusions to the black dogs of Faust and The Witch of Edmonton these frequent references to dogs suggest not just the reality but the omnipresence of evil in the world. Greene’s literary approach to hell therefore succeeds in creating not only a character whom the reader can believe worthy of hell but also a visible world whose surfaces and textures as well as its spiritual dimension make hell credible.
CHAPTER FIVE Protagonists of the Second Phase
Brighton Rock is most often regarded, and understandably so, as a significant beginning for Greene, for it is his first novel centered around the Catholic themes on which his reputation as a major twentieth-century writer would be built. Yet in another sense Brighton Rock, with its extremes of alienation, cruelty, and blasphemy, its cinematic style and its profuse overlay of allusion and literary parallels, represents the end of a period, the full achievement of the direction in which Greene had taken his first-phase protagonists. No subsequent novel by the author would be quite so rich in simile or so stark in its juxtaposition of good and evil; no ending would be quite so bleak as that in which the widowed Rose goes to her room alone to confront offstage “the worst horror of all”; no protagonist would seem more completely unlike his creator or provide a voice from which such withering blasts against the sanctities of bourgeois existence could be delivered. Pinkie is the last of Greene’s first-phase protagonists; in D., hero of The Confidential Agent (1939), we can see the beginning of the second phase. AGE Jim Baxter, the young narrator of Greene’s final novel The Captain and the Enemy (1988), represents in several respects a return to the narrative of romantic adventure seen in Greene’s earliest novels. His story will be discussed in a later chapter, but he needs mention here as the sole exception to an obvious yet significant generalization about Greene’s second-phase novels: In contrast to the youthful Andrews, for example, or the sophomoric Chant, or the “lost child” figures of Raven, Pinkie,
100 GRAHAM GREENE: AN APPROACH TO THE NOVELS
and Rose, Greene’s protagonists of the second phase are mature men whose age is often close to that of the novelist himself at the time of writing. D., the literary scholar forced by war into the unfamiliar role of “confidential agent,” is the first of these; at forty-five he is older than any of the earlier protagonists and has a much wider experience of life. In his resigned belief that “wherever he was, there was a war” he is akin to Pinkie and especially to Raven, yet his attitude is not an expression of warped psychology but the embittered conclusion of a man who has seen his quiet, cultured life disintegrate in the face of years of civil war. From the outset the text calls attention to his age, as when he finds it difficult to explain to a customs officer why he looks so unlike his three-year-old passport photograph: He said: “It’s an old photograph.” It must have been taken before he went to prison, before his wife was killed, and before the air raid of December 23, when he was buried for fifty-six hours in a cellar. But he could hardly explain all that to the passport officer. (13) Greene usually provides a general rather than a specific indication of his protagonist’s age, but middle-aged weariness is a common denominator among D.’s successors. Maurice Bendrix, who describes himself in the last lines of The End of the Affair as “too old and tired to learn to love,” is a prime example. Eduardo Plarr of The Honorary Consul (1973) is the youngest (mid-thirties), although he shares the center of interest much of the time with the eponymous honorary consul Charlie Fortnum, who is sixty-one. Fortnum, Henry Pulling (about fifty-five) and Maurice Castle (in his sixties), Alfred Jones (thirty years older than his young wife), and Father Quixote are the oldest. Experience as well as age distinguishes the second-from the first-phase characters. One measure of the difference lies in the fact that all of these later characters have a significant past which is not childhood. Another is that the earlier books are about the experience of young people and therefore look toward the future. When their plots have a calamitous outcome, as in the deaths of Andrews, Crane, Anthony Farrant, Raven, and Pinkie, they convey a powerful sense of wasted youth, for the novels bring these young characters to a point where the reader
PROTAGONISTS OF THE SECOND PHASE
101
can briefly imagine the possibility of a different future for them. But the second-phase novels (excepting the entertainments Loser Takes All and Our Man in Havana) are frequently and sometimes morbidly concerned with the past. Their protagonists contemplate from a middle-aged viewpoint the sadness of a ruined life (D., Rowe, Querry), a failed marriage (Fowler, Scobie), a failure in love (Bendrix, Brown), or a burden of guilt borne in consequence of some past crime or personal failure (Rowe, Fowler, the whisky priest). Just as many of the author’s early short stories centered around unhappy or traumatic childhood events (“I Spy,” “The End of the Party,” and “The Basement Room” are notable), the first-phase novels contain central figures whose inner lives betray effects of suffering in childhood. Raven, Pinkie, and Rose are the most familiar in this regard, but Andrews (brutalized by his father), Anthony Farrant (disciplined