INTRODUCTION
TO THE SERIES
The aim of the Handbooks in Economics series is to produce Handbooks for various branches o...
98 downloads
1661 Views
30MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
INTRODUCTION
TO THE SERIES
The aim of the Handbooks in Economics series is to produce Handbooks for various branches of economics, each of which is a definitive source, reference, and teaching supplement for use by professional researchers and advanced graduate students. Each Handbook provides self-contained surveys of the current state of a branch of economics in the form of chapters prepared by leading specialists on various aspects of this branch o f economics. These surveys summarize not only received results but also newer developments, from recent journal articles and discussion papers. Some original material is also included, but the main goal is to provide comprehensive and accessible surveys. The Handbooks are intended to provide not only useful reference volumes for professional collections but also possible supplementary readings for advanced courses for graduate students in economics. KENNETH J. ARROW and MICHAEL D. 1NTRILIGATOR
PUBLISHER'S
NOTE
For a complete overview of the Handbooks in Economics Series, please refer to the listing at the end of this volume.
CONTENTS O F T H E HANDBOOK
VOLUME 1A PART 1 - E M P I R I C A L A N D H I S T O R I C A L P E R F O R M A N C E
Chapter 1 Business Cycle Fluctuations in US Macroeconomic Time Series JAMES H. STOCK and MARK W WATSON
Chapter 2 Monetary Policy Shocks: What Have we Learned and to What End? LAWRENCE J. CHRISTIANO, MARTIN EICHENBAUM and CHARLES L. EVANS
Chapter 3 Monetary Policy Regimes and Economic Performance: The Historical Record MICHAEL D. BORDO AND ANNA J. SCHWARTZ
Chapter 4 The New Empirics of Economic Growth STEVEN N. DURLAUF and DANNY T. QUAH PART 2 - M E T H O D S O F D Y N A M I C A N A L Y S I S
Chapter 5 Numerical Solution of Dynamic Economic Models MANUEL S. SANTOS
Chapter 6 Indeterminacy and Sunspots in Macroeconomics JESS BENHABIB and ROGER E.A. FARMER
Chapter 7 Learning Dynamics GEORGE W. EVANS mad SEPPO HONKAPOHJA
Chapter 8 Micro Data and General Equilibrium Models MARTIN BROWNING, LARS PETER HANSEN and JAMES J. HECKMAN
vii
Contents of the Handbook
viii PART 3 - MODELS
OF ECONOMIC
GROWTH
Chapter 9 Neoclassical Growth Theory ROBERT M. SOLOW
Chapter 10 Explaining Cross-Country Income Differences ELLEN R. McGRATTAN and JAMES A. SCHMITZ, Jr. VOLUME
1B
PART 4 - CONSUMPTION
AND INVESTMENT
Chapter 11 Consumption ORAZIO E ATTANASIO
Chapter 12 Aggregate Investment RICARDO J. CABALLERO
Chapter 13 Inventories VALERIE A. RAMEY and KENNETH D. WEST PART 5 - M O D E L S
OF ECONOMIC
FLUCTUATIONS
Chapter 14 Resuscitating Real Business Cycles ROBERT G. KING AND SERGIO T. REBELO
Chapter 15 Staggered Price and Wage Setting in Macroeconomics JOHN B. TAYLOR
Chapter 16 The Cyclical Behavior of Prices and Costs JULIO J. ROTEMBERG and MICHAEL WOODFORD
Chapter 17 Labor-Market Frictions and Employment Fluctuations ROBERT E. HALL
Chapter 18 Job Reallocation, Employment Fluctuations and Unemployment DALE T. MORTENSEN and CHRISTOPHER A. PISSAR/DES
Contents of the Handbook
VOLUME 1C PART 6 - F I N A N C I A L M A R K E T S A N D T H E M A C R O E C O N O M Y
Chapter 19 Asset Prices, Consumption, and the Business Cycle JOHN Y. CAMPBELL
Chapter 20 Human Behavior and the Efficiency of the Financial System ROBERT J. SHILLER
Chapter 21 The Financial Accelerator in a Quantitative Business Cycle Framework BEN S. BERNANKE, MARK GERTLER and SIMON GILCHRIST PART 7 - M O N E T A R Y A N D F I S C A L P O L I C Y
Chapter 22 Political Economics and Macroeconomic Policy TORSTEN PERSSON and GUIDO TABELLINI
Chapter 23 Issues in the Design of Monetary Policy Rules BENNETT T. McCALLUM
Chapter 24 Inflation Stabilization and BOP Crises in Developing Countries GUILLERMO A. CALVO and CARLOS A. VI~GH
Chapter 25 Government Debt DOUGLAS W. ELMENDORF AND N. GREGORY MANKIW
Chapter 26 Optimal Fiscal and Monetary Policy V.V. CHAR/and PATRICK J. KEHOE
ix
PREFACE TO THE HANDBOOK
Purpose The Handbook of Macroeconomics aims to provide a survey of the state of knowledge in the broad area that includes the theories and facts of economic growth and economic fluctuations, as well as the consequences of monetary and fiscal policies for general economic conditions.
Progress in Macroeconomics Macroeconomic issues are central concerns in economics. Hence it is surprising that (with the exception of the subset of these topics addressed in the Handbook of Monetary Economics) no review of this area has been undertaken in the Handbook of Economics series until now. Surprising or not, we find that now is an especially auspicious time to present such a review of the field. Macroeconomics underwent a revolution in the 1970's and 1980's, due to the introduction of the methods of rational expectations, dynamic optimization, and general equilibrium analysis into macroeconomic models, to the development of new theories of economic fluctuations, and to the introduction of sophisticated methods for the analysis of economic time series. These developments were both important and exciting. However, the rapid change in methods and theories led to considerable disagreement, especially in the 1980's, as to whether there was any core of common beliefs, even about the defining problems of the subject, that united macroeconomists any longer. The 1990's have also been exciting, but for a different reason. In our view, the modern methods of analysis have progressed to the point where they are now much better able to address practical or substantive macroeconomic questions - whether traditional, new, empirical, or policy-related. Indeed, we find that it is no longer necessary to choose between more powerful methods and practical policy concerns. We believe that both the progress and the focus on substantive problems has led to a situation in macroeconomics where the area of common ground is considerable, though we cannot yet announce a "new synthesis" that could be endorsed by most scholars working in the field. For this reason, we have organized this Handbook around substantive macroeconomic problems, and not around alternative methodological approaches or schools of thought.
xi
xii
Preface
The extent to which the field has changed over the past decade is considerable, and we think that there is a great need for the survey of the current state ofmacroeconomics that we and the other contributors to this book have attempted here. We hope that the Handbook of Macroeconomics will be useful as a teaching supplement in graduate courses in the field, and also as a reference that will assist researchers in one area of macroeconomics to become better acquainted with developments in other branches of the field. Overview The Handbook of Macroeconomics includes 26 chapters, arranged into seven parts. Part 1 reviews evidence on the Empirical and Historical Performance of the aggregate economy, to provide factual background for the modeling efforts and policy discussion of the remaining chapters. It includes evidence on the character of business fluctuations, on long-run economic growth and the persistence of crosscountry differences in income levels, and on economic performance under alternative policy regimes. Part 2 on Methods of Dynamic Analysis treats several technical issues that arise in the study of economic models which are dynamic and in which agents' expectations about the future are critical to equilibrium determination. These include methods for the calibration and computation of models with intertemporal equilibria, the analysis of the determinacy of equilibria, and the use of "learning" dynamics to consider the stability of such equilibria. These topics are important for economic theory in general, and some are also treated in the Handbook of Mathematical Economics, The Handbook of Econometrics, and the Handbook of Computational Economics, for example, from a somewhat different perspective. Here we emphasize results - such as the problems associated with the calibration of general equilibrium models using microeconomic studies - that have particular application to macroeconomic models. The Handbook then tunas to a review of theoretical models of macroeconomic phenomena. Part 3 reviews Models of Economic Growth, including both the determinants of long-run levels of income per capita and the sources of cross-country income differences. Both "neoclassical" and "endogenous" theories of growth are discussed. Part 4 treats models of Consumption and Investment demand, from the point o f view of intertemporal optimization. Part 5 covers Models of Economic Fluctuations. In the chapters in this part we see a common approach to model formulation and testing, emphasizing intertemporal optimization, quantitative general equilibrium modeling, and the systematic comparison of model predictions with economic time series. This common approach allows for consideration of a variety of views about the ultimate sources of economic fluctuations and of the efficiency of the market mechanisms that amplify and propagate them. Part 6 treats Financial Markets and the Macroeconomy. The chapters in this part consider the relation between financial market developments and aggregate economic
Preface
xiii
activity, both from the point of view of how business fluctuations affect financial markets, and how financial market disturbances affect overall economic activity. These chapters also delve into the question of whether financial market behavior can be understood in terms of the postulates of rational expectations and intertemporal optimization that are used so extensively in modern macroeconomics-an issue of fundamental importance to our subject that can be, and has been, subject to special scrutiny in the area of financial economics because of the unusual quality of available data. Finally, Part 7 reviews a number of Monetary and Fiscal Policy issues. Here we consider both the positive theory (or political economics) of government policymaking and the normative theory. Both the nature of ideal (or second-best) outcomes according to economic theory and the choice of simple rules that may offer practical guidance for policymakers are discussed. Lessons from economic theory and from experience with alternative policy regimes are reviewed. None of the chapters in this part focus entirely on international, or open economy, macroeconomic policies, because many such issues are addressed in the Handbook of International Economics. Nevertheless, open-economy issues cannot be separated from closed-economy issues as the analysis of disinflation policies and currency crises in this part of the Handbook of Maeroeconomics, or the analysis of policy regimes in the Part I of the Handbook of Macroeconomics make clear.
Acknowledgements Our use of the pronoun "we" in this preface should not, of course, be taken to suggest that much, if any, of the credit for what is useful in these volumes is due to the Handbook's editors. We wish to acknowledge the tremendous debt we owe to the authors of the chapters in this Handbook, who not only prepared the individual chapters, but also provided us with much useful advice about the organization of the overall project. We are grateful for their efforts and for their patience with our slow progress toward completion of the Handbook. We hope that they will find that the final product justifies their efforts. We also wish to thank the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, and the Center for Economic Policy Research at Stanford University for financial support for two conferences on "Recent Developments in Macroeconomics" at which drafts of the Handbook chapters were presented and discussed, and especially to Jack Beebe and Rick Mishkin who made these two useful conferences happen. The deadlines, feedback, and commentary at these conferences were essential to the successful completion of the Handbook. We also would like to thank Jean Koentop for managing the manuscript as it neared completion. Stanford, California Princeton, New Jersey
John B. Taylor Michael Woodford
Chapter 11
CONSUMPTION
*
ORAZIO P. ATTANASIO
University College London, Institute for Fiscal Studies and NBER
Contents
Abstract Keywords 1. Introduction 2. Stylised facts
742 742 743 745 746
2.1. Aggregate time series data 2.2. Household consumption expenditure
750
2.2.1. Nature of the data sets and their comparability with the National Account data 2.2.2. Life cycle profiles
3. The life cycle model 3.1. The simple textbook model 3.2. Quadratic preferences, certainty equivalence and the permanent income model 3.3. The Euler equation approach 3.4. Precautionary motives for saving 3.5. Borrowing restrictions 3.6. Taking into account demographics, labour supply and unobserved heterogeneity 3.7. Bequest motives
4. Aggregation issues 4.1. Aggregation across consumers 4.2. Aggregation across commodities
5. Econometric issues and empirical evidence 5.1. Aggregate time series studies 5.2. Micro data: some econometric problems
751 752 760 761 762 765 770 772 777 780
781 781 782 783 784 785
5.2.1. Consistency of estimators derived from Euler equations
785
5.2.2. Average cohort techniques
787
* A preliminary draft of this chapter was presented at a conference at the New York Fed., February 27-28 1997, where I received useful comments from my discussant, Chris Carroll and several participants. Tullio JappeUi provided many careful and insightful comments for which I am very grateful. I would like to thank Margherita Borella for research assistance and James Sefton for providing me with the UK National Accounts Data. Material from the FES made available by the ONS through the ESRC Data Archive has been used by permission of the Controller of HMSO. Neither the ONS nor the ESRC Data Archive bear any responsibility for the analysis or interpretation of the data reported here.
Handbook of Macroeconomics, Volume 1, Edited by J.B. Taylor and M. Woodford © 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved 741
742 5.2.3. Conditional second (and higher) moments 5.3. Micro data: some evidence 6. Where does the life cycle model stand? 7. Insurance and inequality 8. Intertemporal non-separability 8.1. Durables 8.2. Habit formation 9. Conclusions References
O.P. Attanasio 788 789 791 795 798 799 802 804 805
Abstract Consumption is the largest component of GDP. Since the 1950s, the life cycle and the permanent income models have constituted the main analytical tools to the study of consumption behaviour, both at the micro and at the aggregate level. Since the late 1970s the literature has focused on versions of the model that incorporate the hypothesis of Rational Expectations and a rigorous treatment of uncertainty. In this chapter, 1 survey the most recent contribution and assess where the life cycle model stands. My reading of the evidence and of recent developments leads me to stress two points: (i) the model can only be tested and estimated using a flexible specification of preferences and individual level data; (ii) it is possible to construct versions of the model that are not rejected by the data. One of the main problems of the approach used in the literature to estimate preferences is the lack of a 'consumption function'. A challenge for future research is to use preference parameter estimates to construct such functions.
Keywords consumption, life cycle model, household behaviour JEL classification: E2
Ch. 11:
Consumption
743
1. Introduction
In most developed economies, consumption accounts for about two thirds of GDP. Moreover, it is from consumption that, in all likelihood, utility and welfare are in large part determined. It is therefore natural that macroeconomists have devoted a considerable amount of research effort to its study. In modern macroeconomics, consumption is typically viewed as part of a dynamic decision problem. There is therefore another sense in which an tmderstanding of consumption is central for macroeconomics. Consumption decisions are also saving decisions from which the funds available for capital accumulation and investment arise. Therefore, consumers attitudes to saving, risk bearing and uncertainty are crucial to understand the behaviour of capital markets, the process of investment and growth and development. It is not by chance that modern consumption theory is also used to characterise asset prices equilibrium conditions. The desire consumers might have to smooth fluctuations over time determines the need for particular financial instruments or institutions. Understanding recent trends in consumption and saving is crucial to the study, both positive and normative, of the development of financial markets, of the institutions that provide social safety nets, of the systems through which retirement income is provided and so on. One of the main themes of this chapter is that consumption decisions cannot be studied in isolation. Exactly because consumption and saving decisions are part of a dynamic optimisation problem, they are determined jointly with a number of other choices, ranging from labour supply to household formation and fertility decisions, to planned bequests. While modelling all aspects of human economic behaviour simultaneously is probably impossible, it is important to recognise that choices are taken simultaneously and to control for the effects that various aspects of the economic environment in which consumers live might have on any particular choice. This is particularly true if one wants to estimate the parameters that characterise individual preferences. Implicit in this argument is another of the main themes of this chapter: consumption decisions should be modelled within a well specified and coherent optimisation model. Such a model should be flexible and allow for a variety of factors. Indeed, I think it is crucial that the model should be interpreted as an approximation of reality and should allow for a component of behaviour that we are not able to explain. However, such a model is crucial to organise our thinking and our understanding of the data. Without a structural model it is not possible to make any statement about observed behaviour or to evaluate the effect of any proposed change in economic policy. This, however, is not a call for a blind faith in structural models. Inferences should always be conditional on the particular identification restrictions used and on the particular structural model used. Such models should also be as flexible as possible and incorporate as much information about individual behaviour as is available. It should be recognised, however, that without such models we cannot provide more than a statistical description of the data.
744
0.17. Attanasio
The other main theme of the analysis in this chapter is that to understand aggregate trends it is necessary to conduct, in most situations, a detailed analysis of individual behaviour. In other words, aggregation problems are too important to be ignored. This obviously does not mean that the analysis of aggregate time series data is not useful. Indeed, I start the chapter with a brief summary of the main time series properties of consumption. Estimation of structural models of economic behaviour, however, cannot be performed using aggregate data only. This chapter is not an exhaustive survey of the literature on consumption: such a literature has grown so much that it would be hard even to list it, let alone summarise all the contributions. What I offer, instead, is a discussion of the current status of our knowledge, with an eye to what I think are the most interesting directions for future research. In the process of doing so, however, I discuss several of the most important and influential contributions. Omissions and exclusions are unavoidable and should not be read as indicating a negative judgement on a particular contribution. At times, I simply chose, among several contributions, those that most suited my arguments and helped me the most to make a given point. Moreover, notwithstanding the length of the chapter, not every sub-fields and interesting topic has been covered. But a line had to be drawn at some point. There are four fields that I did not included in the chapter and over which I have agonised considerably. The first is asset pricing: while much of the theoretical material I present has direct implications for asset prices, I decided to omit a discussion of these implications as there is an entire chapter of this Handbook devoted to these issues. The second is the axiomatisations of behaviour under uncertainty alternative to expected utility. There are several interesting developments, including some that have been used in consumption and asset pricing theory, such as the KrepsPorteus axiomatisation used by Epstein and Zin (1989, 1991) in some fascinating papers. The third is the consideration of within-household allocation of resources. There is some exciting research being developed in this area, but I decided to draw the line of 'macro' at the level of the individual household. Finally, I do not discuss theories of consumption and saving behaviour that do not assume optimising and fully rational behaviour. Again, there is some exciting work in the area of social norms, mental accounting, time varying preferences, herd behaviour and so on. In the end, however, I decided that it would not fit with the rest of the chapter and rather than giving just a nod to this growing part of the literature I decided to leave it out completely. The chapter is organised as follows. In Section 2, I start with a brief description of some stylised facts about consumption. These include both facts derived from aggregate time series data and from household level data. Throughout the section, I use in parallel data from two countries: the USA and the UK. In Section 3, I discuss at length what I think is the most important model of consumption behaviour we have, the life cycle model. In that section, I take a wide view of what I mean by the life cycle model: definitely not the simple textbook version according to which the main motivation for saving is the accumulation of resources to provide for retirement. Instead, I favour a flexible version of the model where demographics, labour supply, uncertainty and precautionary saving and possibly
Ch. 11: Consumption
745
bequests play an important role. In other words, I consider the life cycle model as a model in which consumption decisions are determined within an intertemporal optimisation framework. What elements of this model turn out ot be more important is largely an empirical matter. Indeed, even the presence of liquidity constraints, or borrowing restrictions, can and should be incorporated within this framework. In Section 4, I discuss aggregation problems. In particular, I focus on two different kinds of aggregation: that across consumers and that across commodities. The aim of this section is not just to give lip service to the aggregation issues and proceed to sweep them under the carpet. With the development of computing and storage capability and with the availability of increasing large number of micro data sets, it is important to stress that scientific research on consumption behaviour cannot afford to ignore aggregation issues. In Section 5, I consider the empirical evidence on the life cycle model and discuss both evidence from aggregate time series data and evidence from micro data. In this section I also address a number of econometric problems with the analysis of Euler equations for consumption. In Section 6, I take stock on what I think is the status of the life cycle model, given the evidence presented in Section 5. In Section 7, I address the issues of insurance and inequality. In particular, I present some of the tests of the presence of perfect insurance and discuss the little evidence there is on the evolution o f consumption inequality and its relationship to earning inequality. Most of the models considered up to this point assume time separability of preferences. While such a hypothesis is greatly convenient from an analytical point of view, it is easy to think of situations in which it is violated. In Section 8, I discuss to forms of time dependence: that induced by the durability of commodities and habit formation. Section 9 concludes the chapter.
2. Stylised facts In this section, I document the main stylised facts about consumption behaviour using both aggregate and individual data. I consider two components of consumption expenditure: on non-durable and services and on durables. In addition I also consider disposable income. While most of the facts presented here are quite well established, the evidence in this section constitute the background against which one should set the theoretical model considered in the rest of the chapter. The data used come from two western countries: the United States and the United Kingdom. I have deliberately excluded from the analysis developing or less developed countries as they involve an additional set of issues which are not part of the present discussion. Among the developed countries I have chosen the USA and the UK both because data from these two countries have been among the most widely studied and because the two countries have the best micro data on household consumption. For
O.P. Attanasio
746
4000
UK USA - disposable income and consumption ~------150000 100000
2000
-
disposable income and consumption
50000
J J
97.1
2319 55
6's
75
as
&
65
75
85
95
Fig. 1. Disposable income (top curve) consumption, divided into durables (bottom curve) and nondurables (middle curve).
the UK, in particular, the Family Expenditure Survey runs for 25 consecutive years, giving the possibility of performing interesting exercises. 2.1. Aggregate time series data In this section, I present some of the time series properties of consumption expenditure and of disposable income. While the models considered in the following sections refer to household behaviour, typically the consumption aggregates considered in the National Account statistics include outlays of a sector that, together with households, includes other entities, such as charities, whose behaviour is unlikely to be determined by utility maximisation. While this issue is certainly important, especially for structural tests of theoretical models of household behaviour, in the analysis that follows I ignore it and, instead of isolating the part of total expenditure to be attributed to households, I present the time series properties of National Account consumption. Seslnick (1994) has recently stressed the importance of these issues. In Figure 1, I plot household (log) disposable income along with consumption divided into durables and non-durables and services for the UK and the USA. The series have quarterly frequency and run from 1959:1 to 1996:3 for the USA and from 1965:1 to 1996:2 for the UK. The data are at constant prices and are seasonally adjusted. From the figure, it is evident that non-durable consumption is smoother than disposable income. Durable consumption, on the other hand, which over the sample accounts, on average, for 13% of total consumption in the USA and around 14% in the UK, is by far the most volatile of the three time series. This is even more evident in Figure 2 where I plot the annual rate of changes for the three variables. In Table 1, I report the mean and standard deviation of the three variables. These figures confirm and quantify the differences in the variability of the three variables considered. In Tables 2 and 3, I consider two alternative ways of summarising the time series properties of the three series I analyse for both countries. In Table 2, 1 report the estimates of the coefficient of an MA(12) model for the same series. The advantage of such an un-parsimonious model is that it avoids the sometimes difficult choice among competing ARMA representations. Furthermore, its impulse response function
Ch. 11:
747
Consumption
USA- disposable income and consumption rates of growth
UK- disposable income and consumptionrates of growth
0.2
0.2
0.1
0.1
0
0
-0.1
-0.1
-0.2
-0.2
55
65
75
85
95
65
75
85
95
Fig. 2. Annual rates of change for the variables of Figure 1. Table 1 Mean and standard deviations (annual rates of growth) US
Disposable income Nondurable consumption Durable expenditure
UK
Mean
St. dev.
Mean
St. dev.
0.032 0.023 0.048
0.025 0.018 0.069
0.026 0.017 0.043
0.026 0.021 0.112
can be easily read from the estimated coefficients. I also purposely decided to be agnostic about the presence o f random walks in the time series consumption or income, even though this has implications for the so called 'excess smoothness' puzzle briefly discussed below. In Table 3, instead, I report the M a x i m u m Likelihood estimates o f a parsimonious A R M A m o d e l for the first differences o f the log o f the three variables. While in some cases there were alternative specifications that fitted the data as well as those reported in the table, the latter all pass several diagnostic tests. The Q-statistics reported in the table indicates that the representations chosen capture adequately the dynamic behaviour o f the series over the period considered. The time series properties o f the rate o f growth o f the three variables are remarkably different. Notice, in particular, the fact that both in the U K and in the USA, the sum o f the M A coefficients for non-durable consumption is positive, while that for durables is negative. The time series properties o f non-durable consumption differ remarkably: in Table 2 the sum o f the first 12 M A coefficient is much larger in the U K than in the USA. Furthermore, while the US data are well represented by an M A ( 3 ) (with the first and third lag large and very strongly significant), the U K require an AR(2) model 1.
I The presence of an MA(3) effect in the non-durable series for the USA is evident even in the MA(12) representation but it is not very robust. If one truncates the sample to 1990 or dummies out the few quarters corresponding to the 1990-91 recession, 03 is estimated non-significantly different from zero
748
O.P Attanasio
Table 2 MA(12) representation a US
0i
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 010 011 012
~ ) 2 I 0i
UK
Disposable income
Non-durable consumption
Durable consumption
Disposable income
Non-durable consumption
Durable consumption
-0.30 (0.091) 0.15 (0.094) 0.092 (0.094) -0.092 (0.088) -0.15 (0.087) 0.11 (0.088) -0.13 (0.087) -0.17 (0.088) 0.38 (0.088) 0.20 (0.095) -0.06 (0.096) -0.27 (0.091) -0.25
0.41 (0.096) 0.18 (0.103) 0.43 (0.104) 0.12 (0.110) -0.057 (0.108) 0.100 (0.108) 0.11 (0.107) -0.20 (0.107) 0.05 (0.109) -0.03 (0.100) 0.05 (0.099) 0.08 (0.092) 1.23
-0.092 (0.088) -0.035 (0.089) 0.063 (0.089) 0.084 (0.086) -0.16 (0.085) 0.15 (0.077) -0.45 (0.077) -0.021 (0.085) -0.23 (0.085) -0.03 (0.088) 0.005 (0.087) -0.23 (0.086) -0.95
-0.10 (0.094) 0.12 (0.095) -0.06 (0.092) -0.18 (0.088) -0.19 (0.089) 0.22 (0.088) 0.21 (0.088) 0.14 (0.087) -0.14 (0.086) -0.20 (0.087) 0.05 (0.088) -0.05 (0.086) -0.18
0.005 (0.094) 0.20 (0.093) 0.004 (0.093) 0.28 (0.092) 0.19 (0.093) 0.19 (0.094) 0.09 (0.094) 0.22 (0.092) -0.11 (0.090) 0.23 (0.091) 0.18 (0.091) 0.03 (0.093) 1.51
-0.29 (0.094) -0.14 (0.096) 0.24 (0.097) -0.45 (0.099) 0.15 (0.106) 0.05 (0.107) -0.07 (0.106) -0.18 (0.104) -0.08 (0.098) 0.02 (0.095) -0.20 (0.094) -0.02 (0.089) -0.97
a Standard errors are given in parentheses. The sum o f the M A coefficients for disposable income in both countries is quite small in absolute value, but is positive in the U S A and negative for the UK. As far as a 'parsimonious' specification is concerned, in the U S A I chose an MA(1) for the first differences, even though its coefficient is not very large and is statistically insignificant. This model was almost indistinguishable from an AR(1) model. In the UK, the best model for disposable income is an ARMA(1,1). The richer dynamics o f the U K series is also evident in the pattern o f the M A coefficients in Table 2.
both in the MA(12) and in the MA(3) model. The same result is obtained if one excludes services from this series.
Ch. 11:
749
Consumption
Table 3 ARMA representation a Variable
US Disposable income
'[Pl
--
--
'10 2
--
_
01
-0.19 (0.088)
0 2
--
03
-
UK
Non-durable D u r a b l e Disposable Non-durable Durable consumption consumption income consumption consumption -0.103 (0.089)
-0.77 (0.293) -
0.684 (0.339)
0.38 (0.083) 0.18
0.015 (0.087) 0.28 (0.087) -
-1.09 (0.098) -0.45 (0.082) 0.85 (0.077)
-
0.85 (0.077) 7.22 (0.30)
(0.088)
Q-stat (p-value)
13.40 (0.10)
0.39 (0.082) 7.35 (0.28)
-
10.09 (0.26)
0.684 (0.339) 11.79 (0.11)
11.49 (0.12)
a Sample 1965:3-1996:3 (125 observations). Standard errors are given in brackets. The properties of durable consumption are particularly interesting. The fact that the time series properties are inconsistent with a simple model which adds durability to the standard random walk property derived from some version o f the permanent income has been noticed by Mankiw (1982). Such a model would imply an MA(1) model for the changes in expenditure with a coefficient that would differ from minus one by an amount equivalent to the depreciation rate. As can be seen from Table 2, the US series' best representation is indeed an MA(1) with a negative coefficient; but that coefficient is far from minus one 2. Caballero (1990b) has interpreted this and the fact that, as reported in Table 3 :for b0th~eountries, the sum o f the 12 M A coeflici~fits is negative and much larger in absolute value, as an indication o f the presence of inertial behaviour that 'slows down' the process o f adjustment o f durables. Having characterised the main time series properties o f consumption and income, the next step would be the estimation of a multivariate time series model that would stress the correlations among the variables considered at various leads and lags. Indeed, some of the studies I cite below, such as Flavin (1981), do exactly this with the purpose of testing some of the implications o f the life cycle-permanent income hypothesis. For the sake of brevity, I omit the characterisation o f the multivariate time series process o f consumption and other macro variables. One of the reasons for this omission is the belief, discussed below, that aggregation problems make it very difficult to give
2 For durable consumption in the UK, the best model is an ARMA(2,1), by far the most complex model I fitted to these data.
750
0.17 Attanasio
structural interpretation to this type of results. This does not mean, however, that aggregate time series studies are not useful. The careful specification of a flexible time series model for consumption and other variables can be quite informative, especially if the dynamic specification allows for the type of dynamic effects implied by the microeconomic behaviour. Several of the studies by David Hendry and his collaborators are in this spirit; one of the most widely cited examples of this literature is the paper by Davidson et al. (1978). The approach taken in these papers, which received a further motivation by the development of cointegration techniques, is to estimate a stable error correction model which relates consumption to other variables. The statistical model then allows to identify both short run and long run relationships between consumption and its determinants. While the theory can be informative on the choice of the relevant variables and even on the construction of the data series, it does not provide explicit and tight restrictions on the parameters of the model. A good example of a creative and informative use of this type of techniques is Blinder and Deaton (1985). While it is difficult to relate this type of models to structural models and therefore they cannot be directly used for evaluating economic policy, they constitute useful instruments for summarising the main features of the data and, if used carefully, for forecasting. Often the lack of micro economic data makes the use of aggregate time series data a necessity. The only caveat is that these studies cannot be used to identify structural parameters.
2.2. Household consumption expenditure In this section, I use two large microeconomic data set to document the main stylised facts about consumption. The two data sets used are the US Consumption Expenditure Survey (CEX) and the UK Family Expenditure Survey (FES). Both data sets are run on a continuous basis to gather information for the construction of the weights for the CPI (RPI in the UK). They have, however, been extensively used by researchers and have now become an essential tool to study household consumption and saving behaviour. The focus of the analysis is going to be the household. No attempt will be made to attribute consumption to the single household members, even though some (limited) information on this does exist 3. Most of the descriptive analysis presented below attempts at describing the main features of the life cycle profile for consumption expenditure and some other variables.
3 Both data sets containvery detailed information on the expenditure on individual commodities. Some of this information can be used to attribute some items to some household members. For many items, however, such attribution is difficult both in practice and conceptually. Browning (1987) has imputed expenditure on alcoholand tobaccoto the adults to checkwhether predictedchangesin householdincome and composition(such as the arrival of children with consequent- at least temporary- withdrawal from the labour force of the wife) cause changes in consumption. Gokhale, Kotlikoffand Sabelhaus (1996) in their study of saving behaviourhave attempted to impute all of consumptionto the individual household members.
Ch. 11: Consumption
751
This approach reflects the fact that the theoretical discussion in the next sections will be focused around the life cycle model.
2.2.1. Nature of the data sets and their comparability with the National Account data The FES is now available for 25 consecutive years. Each year around 7000 households are interviewed and supply information on their consumption patterns as well as their demographic characteristics and several other economic variables such as employment status, income, education and so on. Each household stays in the sample for two weeks, during which it fills a diary in which all expenditure items are reported. At the end o f the two week period an interviewer collects the diaries and asks additional information on durables acquired during the previous three months and on all major expenditure items reported in the diary and periodic expenditures such as utilities. The CEX is available on a continuous and roughly homogeneous basis since 1980. Each year about 7000 different households are interviewed for 4 subsequent interviews, with quarterly frequency 4. Each month new households enter the survey to replace those that have completed their cycle o f interviews. During each interview the household is asked to report expenditure on about 500 consumption categories during each o f the three months preceding the interview 5. The panel dimension of the CEX is unfortunately very short: because each household is only interviewed four times, seasonal variability is likely to dominate life cycle and business cycle movements. In what follows, I do not exploit the panel dimension o f the survey. There have been several discussions about the quality o f survey data and the importance o f measurement error and about their ability to reproduce movements in aggregate consumption. Several studies, both in the U S A and the UK, have addressed the issue 6. It should be stressed that the aggregated individual data and the National Account aggregate should be expected to differ for several reasons. First o f all, for many consumption categories, the definitions used in the surveys and in the National Accounts are quite different. Housing, for instance, includes imputed rents in the National Accounts data but does not in the surveys. In the CEX, health expenditure
4 In total there are data for over 20000 interviews per year. Each household is in fact interviewed five times. However, the Bureau for Labor Statistics does not release information on the first (contact interview). The Bureau of Labor Statistics also rtms a separate survey based on diaries which collects information on food consumption and 'frequently purchased items'. s Unfortunately,the monthly decomposition of the quarterly expenditure is not very reliable. For several commodities and for many households, the quarterly figure is simply divided by three. Given the rotating nature of the sample, the 'quarters' of expenditure do not coincide perfectly. For instance, somebody interviewed in December will report consumption in September, October and November, while somebody interviewed in November will report consumption in August, September and October. 6 See, for instance, Seslnick (1992) and Paulin et al. (1990) for comparisons between the aggregate Personal Consumption Expenditure and the CEX in the USA and the papers in Banks and Johnson (1997) for comparisons on the FES and the UK National Accounts.
752
O.P. Attanasio
measures only out-of-pocket expenditures, while~ the National Accounts definition includes all health expenditures regardless o f the payee. Furthermore, the populations of reference are quite different. Surveys, for instance, do not include institutionalised individuals, while the National Accounts do. Finally, National Account data arc not exempt from measurement error that, for some items, can be quite substantial. Should major difference emerge, it is not obvious that the National Account data should be considered as being closer to the 'truth'. The issues that arise are different for the two data sets. Overall, the degree o f correspondence between the aggregated individual data and the National Account data seems to be higher in the UK. For most consumption components, aggregating the FES data, one obtains about 90% o f the corresponding National Accounts figure, while the same ratio is about 65% for the CEX in the 1980s. This is probably due to the use o f diaries rather than recall interviews. The latter, perhaps not surprisingly, tend to underestimate consumption. In both surveys, however, because o f the consistent methodology used over time, there is no major trend in the ratio o f the aggregated individual data to the corresponding National Accounts aggregates 7. Furthermore, the dynamics o f consumption and income growth and o f saving in both the aggregated CEX and FES data do not track the corresponding macroeconomic aggregates badly. The data are therefore not only useful to characterise individual behaviour and its shifts over time, but also to make inferences, based on individual behaviour, about possible explanations o f the observed macroeconomic trends.
2.2.2. Life cycle profiles In the second part o f the chapter, in which I discuss the main theoretical model o f consumption behaviour, a substantial amount o f attention is devoted to the life cycle model in its several incarnations. In this section, I present life cycle profiles for consumption, its components and various other variables in the USA and the UK. In this sense, the life cycle model is the conceptual framework that I use to organise the presentation of the microeconomic data. As the data sets I use are not panels, to estimate age profiles, I am forced to use grouping techniques. These techniques were first used within life cycle models by Browning, Deaton and Irish (1985)8. The idea is quite simple. Rather than following the same individual over time, one can follow tile average behaviour o f a group of
7 There are substantial differences in this ratio between the early CEX surveys (1960-61 and 1972-73) and those of the 1980s, probably due to the differences in the methodology employed. In the FES the one commodity for which a (downward) trend in the ratio is apparent is tobacco. 8 Ghez and Becker (1975) use observations on individual of different ages to study life cycle behaviour. However, as they use a single cross section, they do not control for cohort effects as Browning et al. (1985) do. Deaton (1985) and, more recently, Moffitt (1993) have studied some of the econometric problems connected with the use of average cohort techniques. Heck~manand Robb (1987), MaCurdy and Mroz (1989) and Attanasio (1994) discuss identification issues.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
753
individuals as they age. Groups can be defined in different ways, as long as the membership o f the group is constant over time 9. Within the life cycle framework, the natural group to consider is a 'cohort', that is individuals (household heads) born in the same period. Therefore, to compute the life cycle profile o f a given variable, say log consumption, one splits the households interviewed in each individual cross section in groups defined on the basis o f the household head's year o f birth. This involves, for instance, considering all the individuals aged between 20 and 24 in 1980, those aged between 21 and 25 in 1981 and so on to form the first cohort; those aged between 25 and 29 in 1980, between 26 and 30 in 1981 and so on to form the second cohort, etc. Having formed these groups in each year in which the survey is available, one can average log consumption and therefore form pseudo panels: the resulting data will have dimension Q x T, where Q is the number o f groups (cohorts) formed and T is the number o f time periods m. Even if the individuals used to compute the means in each year are not the same, they belong to the same group (however defined) and one can therefore study the dynamic behaviour o f the average variables. Notice that non-linear transformations o f the variables do not constitute a problem as they can be computed before averaging. The resulting age profiles will not cover the entire life cycle o f a given cohort, unless the available sample period is longer than any o f the micro data set commonly used. Each cohort will be observed over a (different) portion o f its life cycle. These techniques can be and have been used both for descriptive analysis and for estimating structural models. Their big advantage is that they allow to study the dynamic behaviour o f the variables o f interest even in the absence o f panel data. Indeed, in many respects, their use might be superior to that o f panel data ~1. Furthermore, as non-linear transformations o f the data can be handled directly when forming the group means, they allow one to solve various aggregation problems that plague the study o f structural models with aggregate time series data. In what follows, I define groups on the basis o f the year o f birth and educational attainment o f the household head. The length o f the interval that defines a birth
9 Group membership should be fixed over time so that the sample is drawn from the same population and the sample mean is a consistent estimator of the mean of the same population. Attanasio and Hoynes (1995) discuss the implications of differential mortality for the use of average cohort techniques. Other possible problems arise, at the beginning of the life cycle, from the possible endogeneity of household formation and, more generally, from migration. ~0 Here I am implicitly assuming that the pseudo panel is a balanced one. This is not always the case as each group might be observed for a different number of time periods. Suppose, for instance, to have data from 1968 to 1994. One might want to follow the cohort born between 1965 and 1970 only from the late 1980s or the early 1990. On the other hand, at some point during the 1980s one might want to drop the cohort born between 1906 and 1910. l~ Time series of cross sections are probably less affected by non-random attrition than panel data. Furthermore, in many situation, averaging across the individuals belonging to a group can eliminate measurement error and purely idiosyncratic factors which are not necessarily of interest. As most grouping techniques, average cohort analysis has an Instrumental Variable interpretation.
O.P. Attanasio
754 Table 4 Cohort definition and cell size Cohort
Year of birth
Cell size US Average size
Years in sample
Averagesize
UK Years in sample
1
1895-1999
-
-
338
1968-1977
2
1900-1904
-
-
459
1968-1982
3
1905-1909
-
-
526
1968-1987
4
1910-1914
232
1980-1992
560
1968-1992
5
1915-1919
390
1980-1992
519
1968-1992
6
1920-1924
333
1980-1992
653
1968-1992
7
1925-1929
325
1980-1992
572
1968-1992
8
1930-1934
317
1980-1992
546
1968-1992
9
1935-1939
345
1980-1992
562
1968-1992
10
1940-1944
420
1980-1992
594
1968-1992
11
1945-1949
566
1980-1992
652
1968-1992
12
1950-1954
657
1980-1992
547
1971-1992
13
1955-1959
734
1980-1992
508
1976-1992
14
1960-1964
-
-
463
1981-1992
15
1965 1969
-
-
334
1986-1992
cohort is chosen taking into account the trade-off between cell size and within-cell homogeneity. Table 4 contains the definition o f the cohorts and the average sample size for both surveys. We start, in Figures 3 and 4, with the life cycle profile of (log) consumption and disposable income at constant prices for both countries. The units o f measurement for income and consumption are chosen so that the two graphs would be roughly in the same scale, enabling to stress the differences in the shape of the age profile. In the figures, I plot the average cohort (log) consumption at each point in time, against the median age o f the household head. Each connected segment represent the behaviour o f a cohort, observed as it ages, at different points in time. As each cohort is defined by a five year interval, and both surveys cover a period longer than five years, at most ages we observe more than one cohort, obviously in different years. It might be tempting to attribute the differences between adjacent cohorts observed at the same age, to 'cohort effects'. It should be remembered, however, that these observations refer to different time periods and might therefore be reflecting business cycle effects. The plotted profiles reflect age, time and cohort effects 12 that, without
12 As well as measurement error and small sample variability.
755
Ch. 11." Consumption USA - disposableincome
UK - disposable income
25000
~'250 200
20000 150 15000
O
lOO 8 50
10000 20
40
Age
60
70
20
40
Age
60
70
60
70
Fig. 3. USA - total consumption 25000
~
20000
UK - total consumption 250
~
~2o0 "~150
~o
o
&loo
15000
05
8
10000
0 20
40
Age
60
70
50 20
40
Age
Fig. 4. an arbitrary normalisation or additional information from a structural model, cannot be disentangled. Several considerations are in order. First of all, both consumption and income age profiles present a characteristic 'hump'. They both peak in the mid 40s and decline afterwards. The picture seems, at first glance, to contradict the implications of the life cycle model as stressed in the typical textbook picture which draws a 'hump shaped' income profile and a flat consumption profile. For total disposable income, the decline around retirement age is faster in the UK than in the USA, but approximately of the same magnitude. This probably reflects the more synehronised retirement of British individuals. The consumption profiles, however, present some strong differences. The most notable is the fact that UK consumption declines much more at retirement than US consumption. Total consumption at age 70 is roughly 35% of the peak in the UK and above 50% in the USA. I discuss the decline of consumption at retirement below. In the UK consumption profile, the consumption boom of the late 1980s, followed by the bust of the early 1990s, is quite apparent. Notice, in particular, the fact that the aggregate consumption boom is accounted for mainly by the youngest cohorts. I have discussed elsewhere how to interpret that episode. It is worth stressing, however, that the analysis of the cross sectional variability of consumption can be useful to shed some light on the nature of episodes that the analysis of the time series data cannot
0.17. Attanasio
756 Table 5 Variability of consumption and income Standard error (%)
Variable
Total consumption Total consumption per adult equivalent Non-durable consumption Non-durable consumption per adult equivalent Durable consumption Non-durable consumption (from levels) Income
USA (CEX)
UK (FES); age < 81
UK (FES); 10 cohorts, year < 86
2.94 2.39 2.60 1.95 15.79 2.58 3.68
2.46
2.65
2.62 2.30 2.49 9.54
2.64 1.88 2.05 8.54
2.31 3.05
1.86 3.60
explain. Information about which groups in the populations where mainly responsible for a determinate episode can be informative about alternative hypotheses 13 It is not obvious how to assess the time series volatility o f (log) consumption and income. The main reason for this is that a large part o f the variation o f consumption over the life cycle is very predictable and can be explained by age and cohort effects. Furthermore, given the limited size o f our samples, the year to year variation in the average cohort data reflects both genuine time series variation and the measurement error induced by sample variation. As Deaton (1985) has stressed, some information about the size o f the measurement error can be gained using the within-cell variability o f the variables used. Using this information, one might correct for that part o f variability accounted for by sampling variation and attempt to isolate the genuine time variation. In an attempt to isolate this component, I run a regression o f log consumption and income on a fifth order polynomial in age and cohort dummies and consider the deviations o f the observed profiles from such a profile. The standard deviation o f the changes in these deviations, corrected for that part which can be attributed to sampling error, is my measure o f time variability 54. These estimates o f volatility for (log) income and consumption are reported in Table 5 along with those for the other variables considered. The first column refers to the USA, while the second and third columns are computed using the U K data. The former includes the whole sample,
i3 See Attanasio and Weber (1994). Groups do not need to be formed on the basis of age. In Attanasio and Banks (1997) that analysis is extended considering not only the variability across cohorts but also across regions. 14 The sample mean • is distributed around the population mean as a random variable with variance given by o2/N, where N is the cell size and cr is the within-cell variance. The latter can be estimated from the available micro data. These estimates can be used to correct our estimates of volatility.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
757 UK - non-durable consumption per household and per adult equivalent
USA - non-durable consumption per household and per adult equivalent ~"
15000
200-
10000 100E
8
5000 20
40
Age
60
70
5020
40
Age
60
70
Fig. 5.
while the latter truncates it to 1986 to remove the effect of the consumption 'boom and bust' of the last part of the sample. As in the case of aggregate time series, total consumption appears less volatile than disposable income, both in the UK and in the USA. In particular, the standard deviation of changes in total disposable income at the cohort level is above 3% in both countries. That of total consumption is between 0.6% and 0.95% less. It may be argued that the differences in the consumption profiles for the two countries are due to the differences in the definitions used in the two surveys. For this reason, I next focus on a narrower definition of consumption which excludes a number of items which might be recorded in different fashion in the two countries. In particular, in Figure 5 I plot (log) expenditure on non-durables and services against age. This definition excludes from total consumption durables, housing, health and education expenditure. The other advantage of considering consumption of non-durables and services, is that I avoid the issue of durability and the more complicated dynamics that is linked to durables. The main features of the two profiles, however, including the larger decline observed in the UK, are largely unaffected. In Table 5, the volatility of non-durable consumption is considerably less than that of total consumption, especially in the UK when data up to 1986 are used. An important possible explanation for the life cycle variation of consumption over the life cycle (and between the two countries considered), is the variation in needs linked to changes in family size and composition. To control for this possibility, I have deflated total household expenditure by the number of adult equivalents in the household. For such a purpose, I use the OECD adult equivalence scale 15. The most evident result is that the life cycle profile of consumption looks much flatter now. In this sense, we can say that a large proportion of the variability of consumption over the life cycle is accounted for by changes in needs. This result is perhaps not surprising
15 No adult equivalence scale is perfect. Different alternatives, however, do not make much difference for the point I want to make here. The OECD scale gives weight 1 to the first adult, 0.67 to the following adults and weight 0.43 to each child below 19.
O.P. Attanasio
758 USA - durables
UK - durables
5000-
4000-
looo-
30002000
8
1000-
~0
4o
6o
~0
Age
~0
40
6'o
8S
1;0
Age
Fig. 6. if one considers that the life cycle profile of the number of adult equivalents (or of family size) is also 'hump-shaped'. It may be argued that changes in needs are, to a large extent, predictable. In terms o f the measure o f volatility in Table 5, it is greatly reduced for the USA, while is slightly increased for the UK. While the profile for non-durable consumption per adult equivalent is quite flat in the first part of the life cycle, a marked decline is still noticeable in the last part. It seems that the decline corresponds roughly to the time of retirement. In the UK, where retirement is much more synchronised than in the USA, the decline is much more rapid. The fact that per adult equivalent consumption declines with retirement suggests that this might be due to a link between labour market status and consumption. A possibility, for instance, is that some components of consumption are linked to labour market participation. More generally, it is possible that consumption and leisure are non-separable and, therefore, need to be analysed jointly. These issues have been recently discussed by Banks et al. (1998). Finally, it is of some interest to consider the life cycle profile of expenditure on durables. The life cycle profiles for durables are plotted in Figure 6. Consistently with the findings in aggregate time series data, the life cycle profiles for durable expenditure are much more volatile than those for non-durables and services. The measure in Table 5 for durables is 5 times as large as that o f total consumption for the USA and almost 4 times as large for the U K 16. Several variables are likely to be important determinants of, or determined jointly with consumption. I have already stressed the important role which is likely to be played by demographics and retirement behaviour in shaping the life cycle profiles o f consumption. Similar considerations can be made for other labour supply variables
16 Because durable expenditure can be zero at the individual level I do not compute the average of the log. Therefore, the deviations from the life cycle profiles are not percentage deviations, but are measured in constant dollars. Because of this, in Table 5, in the row corresponding to durables I report the coefficient of variation, rather than the standard deviation. For comparison, I adopt the same procedure for non-durable consumption, in the following row.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
759
such as the participation rate of females to the labour market and the total number of hours of work. A characterisation of the life cycle patterns of these variables and their differences between the U K and the USA would go beyond the scope of this section 17. However, it is important to stress that, as I argue in Section 5 and 6 below, one cannot test any model of consumption without controlling for these factors, that, for the most part, can only be analysed using household level data. In Table 5, I only report the variability of the various components of consumption and of disposable income. As with the aggregate time series data, it would be interesting to characterise the autocorrelation properties of these variables and their covariances. This analysis could be quite informative about the plausibility of alternative structural models 18. One of the implications of the textbook version of the life cycle model I discuss in Section 3, is that consumption and current income should not be related. And yet, comparing Figures 3 and 4, one cannot help noticing the similarity in the shape of the two life cycle profiles. This similarity was interpreted as a failure of the life cycle model by Thurow (1969) and reinterpreted in terms of non-separability of consumption and leisure by Heckman (1974). To pursue this issue, in Figure 7, I plot the life cycle profile of (log) disposable income and non-durable consumption for four education groups in the USA defined on the basis of the educational attainment of the household head: high school dropouts, high school graduates, some college and college graduates. An interesting feature of this figure is that the differences across groups in the shape of the income profiles are mirrored in differences in the consumption profiles. In particular, notice that both income and consumption profile of better educated individuals present a more pronounced hump; not only are their income and consumption higher, but the profiles are also much steeper in the first part of the life cycle. These differences where interpreted within a life cycle model by Ghez and Becker (1975), but have interpreted as a failure of the model by Carroll and Summers (1991) in an influential paper. An interesting question, addressed below, is whether a version of the life cycle model I discuss could generate these profile and account for the differences across education groups. In Table 6, I compute the variability of income, consumption and its components as in Table 5, but splitting the sample by education. The most interesting feature of this table is the fact that the only large difference in volatility among the groups is in durable consumption. Expenditures on durables by high school dropouts is twice as variable as that of college graduates, while the figure for high school graduates is in the middle. 17 Interested readers can find the life cycle profiles for several variables in Attanasio (1994), Banks, Blundell and Preston (1994) and Attanasio and Banks (1997). a8 MaCurdy (1983) and Abowd and Card (1989) perform analyses of these kinds for earnings and hours of work and use the results to assess the plausibility of different structural model. No similar analysis exists for consumption and/or its components.
O.P. Attanasio
760 log i n c o m e a n d n o n d u r a b l e c o n s u m p t i o n by e d u c a t i o n high school graduates
high school dropouts
40000l 30000
20000
-°°°°l 10000
3--~
5459.04
I
i
some college
i
i
college graduates
30000
20000
10000
5459,04
q
20
910
410
50
age
Fig. 7. Table 6 Variability of consumption and income by educational group Variable
Standard error (%) High school dropouts High school graduates Morethan high school
Total consumption Non-durable consumption Durable consumption Income
2.88 2.40 22.85 5.98
2.74 2.93 16.58 6.53
2.88 2.25 9.66 5.17
3. The life cycle model In this and in the next few sections, I will sketch what 1 think is the most important model of intertemporal consumption behaviour: the life cycle-permanent income model. In doing so, I take a fairly wide definition of the model: I consider a very general framework in which consumption (and saving) decisions are taken as a part of an intertemporal decision process. This general definition includes both the initial formulations of the life cycle and permanent income models and more recent and sophisticated developments, such as the precautionary saving model or the bequest motive. While the emphasis given to various aspects of the problem is different in the various incarnations of the general model I will consider, they have in common the hypothesis that consumption decisions are taken by a decision unit that
Ch. 11: Consumption
761
maximises utility over time. The various versions of the model will then differ for their assumptions about optimisation horizon, uncertainty, curvature of the utility function, assumptions about separability and so on. Which of these various versions is the most relevant is in part a matter of taste and, above all, an empirical matter. 3.1. The simple textbook model
The main attractiveness of the life cycle-permanent income model, developed during the 1950s in a number o f seminal contributions 19, is the fact that consumption decisions are treated as part of an intertemporal allocation problem. The allocation of consumption over time is treated in a fashion similar to the allocation of total expenditure among different commodities in demand analysis. The model recognises, therefore, that intertemporal prices and the total amount of resources available to an individual are bound to be important determinants of consumption. This approach immediately gives the study of consumption solid microfoundations and constitutes a discontinuous jump with respect to the Keynesian consumption function which assumed consumption to be a simple function of current disposable income. The main difference between the life cycle and the permanent income model in their original formulation lies in the time horizon considered. The life cycle model is, almost by definition, a finite horizon model, while in the permanent income model the horizon is infinite. In both cases, however, consumers decide how much to consume keeping in mind their future prospects. If no uncertainty is introduced in the model, its predictions are quite straightforward: concavity of the utility function implies a desire to smooth consumption over time; the main motivation for saving is to smooth out fluctuations in income; consumption increases with current income only if that increase is a permanent one. In the case of the life cycle model, the explicit consideration of retirement, that is a period in which income declines considerably, generates the main motivation for saving: households accumulate wealth to provide for their consumption during retirement. An interesting implication of the life cycle model in its simplest incarnation is the way in which aggregate saving is generated. It is quite obvious that in a stationary life cycle economy with no growth aggregate saving is zero: the younger generations will be accumulating wealth, while the older ones will be decumulating it. Aggregate saving, however, can be generated in the presence of growth. I f the amount of resources available over the life cycle to younger generations is larger than that available to older ones, it is possible that the amount accumulated at a point in time exceeds the amount that is decumulated. This introduces a relationship between aggregate saving and growth that Modigliani has stressed in several studies. It should be stressed, however, that such a relationship depends on a number of factors including the life
19 Modiglianiand Brumberg(1954) contains the first formulation of the life cycle model. The permanent income model was sketched in Milton Friedman's 1957 volume [Friedman (1957)].
762
O.P. Attanasio
cycle profile, the way in which growth is generated and who benefits from it and so on.
The life cycle-permanent income models were developed to provide an answer to several needs. First, by framing consumption decision within an intertemporal problem, immediately introduces dynamics into the picture. This gives the possibility of fitting some of the empirical facts that seemed at odd with the Keynesian consumption function 20, such as the difference between average and marginal propensity to consume in the short and long run. In addition, the introduction of dynamics is obtained in a theoretically consistent fashion which is appealing to economists. The model gives an obvious explanation of the smoothness of consumption relative to disposable income linked to some well defined preference parameter (the concavity of the utility function). Obviously, the first empirical applications of the model were quite different from the studies of the last 20 years, mainly for the much more sophisticated treatment of uncertainty which I discuss below 21. The model, however, seemed to score a number of empirical successes. I have already mentioned the fact that the model accounts for differences between short run and long run responses of aggregate consumption to disposable income (or other variables). More generally, it was clear that the model was able to generate very rich dynamic patterns for aggregate consumption and its response to disposable income. It could also explain the relationship between consumption and wealth and provide a rationale for the relationship between wealth-income ratios and growth. Indeed, as Modigliani has pointed out, the simplest version of the model is capable to generate an aggregate wealth to income ratio of 5 which is close to what this number is for the USA. Furthermore, the model also seemed able to explain some of the regularities observed in cross sectional data. Just to mention one, Friedman showed how the permanent income model can explain the fact that black households seem to save, at each level of income, a larger fraction of their income than white households 22.
3.2. Quadratic preferences, certainty equivalence and the permanent income model One of the problems with the life cycle-permanent income model is that the dynamic problems that consumers are assumed to solve can be quite complex. As a
20 Carroll and Kimball (1996) provide quotes from Keynes' General Theory in which he suggested a concave consumptionfimction. 21 Friedman(1957) essentially approximatedpermanent income with a distributed lag of current income. Modigliani and Ando (1963) stressed the role played by wealth (in addition to disposable income) in aggregate consumptionequations. Both the Modigliani and Ando paper and Friedman's book contained interesting discussions of the aggregationproblems that were absent, for a long time, from subsequent empirical studies. 22 This fact is still true: data from the Consumer Expenditure Surveyfrom 1980 to 1992 confirm that the saving rates of household headed by a black are systematicallyhigher, for any interval of income, than those of household headed by a non-black.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
763
consequence, if one considers an uncertain environment, unless strong assumptions about the nature of uncertainty and preferences are made it is not possible to obtain a closed form solution for consumption. A popular parametrization of the model which can yield an analytical solution is that of intertemporally separable and quadratic preferences. Indeed, a large part of the profession has come to identify the 'permanent income model' with such a parametrization of preferences with the additional assumptions of infinite horizon, constant interest rates and stochastic labour income. The analysis of the model is greatly simplified by the linearity of the marginal utility of consumption. This, and the fact that the only uncertainty comes from labour income, allows the derivation of an analytical solution for consumption which depends only on the first moment of future labour income. In particular, under the assumptions listed in the previous paragraph, consumption at time t can be expressed as a simple fimction of 'permanent income': Ct = kY p,
(1)
where k= 1 if the (fixed) interest rate equals the subjective discount factor, and permanent income YP is defined as
j=0 (1 +r)J where r is the fixed interest rate, ;~=r/(1 +r), At is the value of current wealth, and y is disposable labour income. The main attraction of Equations (1) and (2) is that they provide a straightforward relationship between the stochastic process that generates income and consumption. These relationship give rise to a number of testable implications that have been studied at length in the literature. Flavin (1981) and Sargent (1978) were the first studies to exploit the fact that Equations (1) and (2), together with the hypothesis that expectations about future labour income are rational, imply cross equation restrictions on the bivariate VAR representation of consumption and disposable income. Flavin (1981), in particular, estimated such a system using US time series data and rejected the restrictions implied by Equations (1) and (2). Flavin finds some evidence of excess sensitivity of consumption to income. Campbell (1987) proposes a slightly different interpretation of Flavin's results. From Equations (1) and (2) it is possible to obtain the following expression for saving 23: OO
st = )~ ~ j-0
EtYt+j -Yt (1 + r)J
(3)
23 s on the left-hand side of Equation (9) coincideswith saving (i.e. income minus consumption),only when k in Equation (7) is equal to 1. Otherwise,s = y - c/k.
764
0.17. Attanasio
The restrictions implied by Equation (3) are the same as those implied by Equations (1) and (2). The nice thing about Equation (3), however, is its interpretation. The fact that consumers smooth consumption over time is reflected in Equation (3) in the fact that saving anticipates expected decline in disposable income. It is for this reason that Equation (3) has been dubbed as the 'saving for a rainy day' equation. Formally, the implication of Equation (3) can be written as saying that actual saving should equal the best forecast of labour income declines. Consistently with Flavin's findings, Campbell (1987) rejects the implications of the model. Campbell, however, finds that the time series pattern of actual saving is not far from that implied by the model. He claims that excess sensitivity of consumption to income within this framework "is more naturally interpreted as insufficient variability of saving than as a correlation between changes in consumption and lagged changes in income" (p. 1272). Related to the tests of excess sensitivity discussed above, and using the same framework, are those papers discussing the issue of 'excess smoothness' of consumption. Campbell and Deaton (1989) were the first to stress that, because Equations (1) and (2) can be used to derive the relationship between changes in consumption and innovations to the process generating income, the relationship between the volatility of consumption (or permanent income) and that of current income depends on the stochastic properties of the process generating the latter. In particular, if labour income is difference stationary (rather than trend stationary), permanent income, and therefore consumption, will be more volatile than current income. Intuitively, this result follows the fact that if labour income is not stationary, current innovations are persistent and will therefore imply a permanent revision to permanent income. Therefore the observation that consumption growth is less volatile than current disposable income growth contradicts the permanent income hypothesis 24. This result is ironic as one of the original motivations for the development of the permanent income model was, indeed, the observation that consumption is smoother than income. The most problematic issue with this branch of the literature is the well known difficulty in distinguishing between trend stationary and difference stationary models 25. The version of the model with quadratic preferences has also been used to introduce further refinements to the model. Goodfriend (1992) and Pischke (1995), for instance, consider the implications of the lack of complete information on contemporaneous aggregate variables. Pischke, in particular, explains the excess sensitivity results typically obtained with aggregate data with this type of phenomena 26. In a recent paper, Blundell and Preston (1998) use the assumption of quadratic preferences to devise a clever way of decomposing transitory and permanent components of income shocks. The idea is quite simple: under the permanent income
24 For a clear discussion of these issues see chapters 3 and 4 in Deaton (1992). 25 See, for instance, Christiano and Eichenbaum(1990) 26 Deaton(1992) also discusses the possibilitythat the informationset used by individual agents differs from that available to the econometrician.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
765
model, consumption should react to innovations to permanent income and not to transitory income. Consumption variability can therefore be used to isolate that part of the observed volatility of income which is to be attributed to permanent shocks.
3.3. The Euler equation approach Without the assumption of quadratic utility (and of uncertainty confined to the exogenous income process), one is left with the problem that it is not possible to derive an analytical solution for the level of consumption. The most important theoretical development since the development of the life cyclepermanent income model is the rigorous treatment o f uncertainty introduced in the late 1970s, after the rational expectations revolution in macroeconomics. In a famous paper, Hall (1978) used what is the main implication of the intertemporal optimisation problem faced by a generic consumer to derive empirically testable restrictions that have been at the centre of much of the empirical analysis in the last 20 years. The idea is simple and elegant: in a situation in which consumers maximise expected utility under uncertainty, they act so to keep the expected (discounted) marginal utility of consumption constant. This condition is equivalent to the equalisation of the marginal rate of substitution to relative prices in consumer demand. The beauty of the approach lies in the way in which the difficulties associated with the presence of uncertainty are circumvented. The effect of future variables on consumption at a given point in time is summarised by the multiplier associated to the budget constraint: the marginal utility of wealth. This object is eliminated by considering the equations for two different periods and considering the optimal pattern for the evolution of the multipliers. It is now time to introduce a bit of notation and formalise what said so far. Suppose a consumer maximises expected life time utility subject to an intertemporal budget constraint. She consumes a homogeneous consumption good C, receives labour income y and has the possibility of investing in N different assets A i that pay a rate of return R I at the end of period t. Both rates of returns and labour income are uncertain. This setup is formalised in the following equation: T-t
max Et ~
fiJ U(Ct~j, zt+j, vt+j)
j-0
(4) N
subject to Z i-1
N
A~+j+, = Z AI+J(1 + RJ+t)+Yt+i-Ct+J ' i=l
where I allow the instantaneous utility function U to depend on a vector of observable variables z, and an unobservable variable v. The operator Et denotes expectations conditional on the information available at time t. I omit an index for the individual for notational simplicity. Implicit in Equation (4) are a number of simplifying assumptions of various nature that will be relaxed in the following sections. It is useful to list some of them along with ways in which they can be rationalised.
766
o.P. Attanasio
(i)
Equation (4) assumes that utility is separable over time. This is a strong assumption and rules out at least two important phenomena: habit formation and durable commodities. The marginal utility o f consumption in any given time period does not depend on consumption expenditure in any other period. We also assume that expenditure coincides with consumption. One obvious possibility to rationalise this model without excluding the existence o f durables is to assume that the instantaneous utility function is additively separable in non-durables and in the services provided by durables. In this case, a term for expenditure on durables should be added to the intertemporal budget constraint. (ii) Utility is derived from an homogeneous consumption good. The conditions under which intertemporal choices can be summarised by a single price index are seldom discussed. The two situations that are treatable are the absence o f changes in relative prices, so that one can construct a Hicks composite commodity, or that preferences take the Gorman polar form. These issues are discussed below. (iii) Labour income is exogenous. No labour supply choices are considered. One can reconcile a situation in which labour supply is endogenous with the model discussed above, assuming that the instantaneous utility function is additively separable in leisure and consumption. In this case, one should modify only the budget constraint o f the problem (4) above. (iv) The duration o f life is certain. This assumption is easily relaxed to assume an uncertain life time. Davies (1981) has shown that this equivalent to assuming a discount factor fi that varies with age as a consequence of a varying probability o f survival. Utility at future ages is discounted not only because it accrues in the future but also because its accrual is uncertain. I will not discuss this issue any further, except when I discuss some o f the issues relevant for the analysis of consumption based on numerical methods. (v) The rate o f return on assets does not depend on the net position on that asset or on the total level o f wealth held by the consumer. The model, however, can easily accommodate a situation in which several assets are subject to various kinds of constraints, as long as there is at least one asset in which is possible to borrow and lend at the same rate 27 (vi) For simplicity, I have not considered explicitly the presence o f inflation. Obviously the presence of (uncertain) absolute price changes is simply accommodated in the model above by changing appropriately the budget constraint and the definition o f interest rates. Under these assumptions it is possible to derive an extremely useful first-order condition for the intertemporal maximisation problem described above. I f we denote
27 This is the condition under which the first-order condition derived below holds. If the rate of return on a given asset changes with the net position in that asset in a continuous and differentiable fashion, that is if the intertemporal budget constraint is concave and does not present kinks, the first-order condition derived below can be easily modified. More complicated is the situation in which there are discontinuities and kinks for all assets at some level of net worth (for instance zero).
Ch. 11: Consumption
767
with )~t the multiplier associated to the intertemporal budget constraint at time t, it can be shown that two of the first-order conditions for the problem in Equation (4) are
OU(Ct, zt, 03 OCt
(5)
-- i~t,
)~t = Et D~t+x/3(1 +R~+,)] ,
i= l,...,m.
(6)
Equation (6) holds for the m (m ~
i = 1,...,m,
(7)
where Uc is the derivative of the instantaneous utility function with respect to consumption. It is Equation (7) that Hall (1978) used to derive his famous 'random walk' property of consumption. These can be derived for the level of consumption if utility is assumed to be quadratic, or, under some distributional assumptions, for its log if utility is isoelastic. Notice that I have allowed instantaneous utility to depend on a number of observable variables (the vector z) for which I have not specified any property. Such variables could in principle be choice variables determined in the same intertemporal maximisation problem. Indeed, the variables z constitute the vehicle through which I introduce a number of factors such as the effect of demographics or of labour supply. As long as we control for their effect on the marginal utility of consumption (and treat them as endogenous at the estimation level), I do not need to model them explicitly. It should be stressed that Equation (7) is not a consumption function, but only an equilibrium relationship that can be used (and has been used) to estimate structural (behavioural) parameters and/or to test some of the implications of the model. The big advantage of Equation (7) is the elimination of the term that represents the marginal utility of wealth and therefore the necessity of explicitly modelling the way in which the distribution of future variables influences consumption choices. The price of this simplification, however, is not a small one: we lose the ability to say anything about the levels of consumption. While it is true that given the level of current consumption, we can use Equation (7) to forecast the expected level of future consumption, we do not
28 MaCurdy (1981) uses this frameworkto construct his 'A-constant' labour supply function.
0.17. Attanasio
768
know how consumption reacts to unexpected changes in the economic environment. These include changes to taxes or any other policy instruments that might affect consumption decisions. The elimination of the tmobservable marginal utility of wealth is similar to the elimination by quasi differencing of fixed effects in econometrics. The problem here is that the 'fixed effect' that is differenced out is one of great importance. Hall (1978) used quadratic utility to derive his famous 'random walk' result. After his paper, several studies developed and used the Euler equation approach with different assumptions about preferences. Hansen and Singleton (1982), for example, used isoelastic preferences to derive an expression whose parameters they estimated by GMM on aggregate time series data for consumption and several rates of return. In particular, Equation (7) with isoelastic preferences (and neglecting the z and v variables) implies c t-Y+l
The assumption of rational expectations and the fact that expectations in Equation (8) are conditional to the information available at time t can be used to find valid instruments to identify the structural parameters of Equation (8), which, once again, can be considered for several rates of returns. If we denote with q the dimension of the vector of parameters [in Equation (8), q = 2], with m the assets for which (8) holds and with k the number of instruments considered, Equation (8) yields m k - q overidentifying restrictions that can be used to test the model. The results obtained by Hansen and Singleton on aggregate data indicate that the model is strongly rejected whenever several returns are considered simultaneously. On the other hand, when one asset is considered in isolation, the overidentifying restrictions are not violated, but the preference parameters are estimated at somewhat implausible values. Hansen and Singleton (1983) considered a log-linear version of Equation (8). If one assumes that the rate of returns and consumption growth are joint log-normal, from Equation (8) one can derive the following expression: Alog(Ct+l) = 1 [log/3 + g2vart(Alog(Ct+l )) + vart (log(1 + Rit+l)) (9) +2Cov(Alog(Ct+l), log(1 +R)+I))] +
log(1 +Rt+l) ) + et+l,
where et+l is an expectational error uncorrelated with all the information available at time t. The advantages of Equation (9) are that it is (log) linear and some of its coefficients, as the one on the interest rate, have a natural and interesting interpretation. When the utility function in Equation (4) is isoelastic, its curvature parameter y plays a double rote. On the one hand it is equal to the coefficient of relative risk aversion and therefore summarises consumer's attitude towards risk. On the other,
Ch. 11:
Consumption
769
its reciprocal is equal to the elasticity o f intertemporal substitution and therefore measures as consumption growth changes when the relative price o f present and future consumption changes 29. The linearity of Equation (9) allowed a number o f researchers to estimate it by linear instrumental variables methods. Valid instruments include, as before, any information available to consumers at time t - 1. Hall (1988), however, noted that if the frequency with which consumption decisions are taken is higher than the frequency o f observations, the residuals o f equations will not be uncorrelated over time, as implied by the assumption o f rational expectations, but have, under certain assumptions, an MA(1) structure with a positive coefficient. If this is the case, valid instruments will be any variable dated t - 2 or earlier. The choice of lagged two instruments has become the common practice for the studies who estimate versions o f Equation (9) using aggregate time series data 3°. Most empirical applications that used a version o f Equation (9), including Hansen and Singleton (1983), typically assume that the conditional second moments that appear on its right hand side are constant over time so that they can be estimated as an intercept term. I discuss the role o f the conditional variances in Section 5. For the time being it will suffice to notice that assumption o f constant second moments can be relaxed to the weaker one that the innovations to the second moments in Equation (9) are uncorrelated with the instruments used in estimating the equation. Having found the instruments that allow the (over) identification o f the parameters o f Equation (9), it is possible to estimate its parameters and test the model. Alternatively, it is possible to test for the significance of additional variables that might be o f particular interest and that, according to the simplest versions o f the model, should not appear in the equation. A test which has received considerable attention is the addition o f the expected value o f current labour income growth. One o f the main examples o f this approach, is a series o f papers by Campbell and Mankiw (1989, 1991) who have estimated on aggregate time series data an equation like the following: Alog(Ct+l) = a + ort+l + )~Alog(yt+l) + et+l,
(10)
where y is labour income and r an interest rate. Both o f the variables on the right hand side are instrumented. According to the model the parameter )~ should be zero and the residual term should be orthogonal to the information available at time t. Equations (8) and (9) illustrate one of the main advantages o f the Euler equation approach. Even if it is not possible to obtain a closed form solution for consumption, it
29 For a discussion of the interpretation of such a parameter and the links between intertemporal substitution and risk aversion see Hall (1988), Attanasio and Weber (1989) and Epstein and Zin (1989, 1991). 3o Carroll et al. (1994) argue for the explicit consideration of the MA(1) process that would allow the use of the orthogonality conditions with instruments dated t - 1 and therefore yield more precise estimates and more powerful tests.
770
O.P.Attanasio
is possible to consider equilibrium relationships that can be used to estimate structural parameters. While these, as I discuss below, are not sufficient to answer many important policy questions, they constitute a basic ingredient of any answer. Furthermore, the orthogonality restrictions implied by the equations (and the assumption of rational expectations) can be used to test the validity of the model. Finally, the model can encompass a number of features that make it quite realistic without loosing its empirical tractability. In particular, it is possible to consider the effects that variables such as durables, labour supply, children and so on have on the marginal utility of non-durable consumption without having to model explicitly these variables. Having said this, however, one should also stress that the empirical implementation of the Euler equation is not without problems. First of all, data requirements can be quite formidable. Furthermore, a number of subtle econometric problems needs to be considered. I discuss these problems and some o f the available empirical evidence in Section 5.
3.4. Precautionary motives for saoing The assumption of quadratic preferences, which makes it possible to derive a closed form solution for consumption, is not very appealing. In addition to various shortcomings of quadratic preferences, many would find certainty equivalence, i.e. what makes the model easy to handle, questionable. It is therefore not surprising that a large literature has developed in the attempt to go beyond quadratic preferences. The first paper to consider explicitly the effects of non-linear marginal utility is Dreze and Modigliani (1972). While the Dreze and Modigliani contribution focuses on a two period problem, it contains many of the insights of the precautionary saving literature, such as the fact that the importance of the precautionary motive for saving depends on the third derivative of the utility function. Kimball (1990) discusses within a rigorous framework the conditions under which one can expect to observe precautionary savings. In particular, he proves that precautionary saving will occur when the utility function exhibits 'prudence', that is when the 3rd derivative of the utility function is positive. Under a CRRA utility function this will always be the case. To see this it is sufficient to consider Equation (6) above, that is the log-linearization of the Euler equation under the assumption of lognormally distributed random variables 31. Notice that, keeping the other variables constant, an increase in the conditional variance of consumption increases, at time t, the expected rate of growth of consumption between t and t + 1. This can be achieved by decreasing consumption at t, that is increasing saving at t. It is this that is usually referred to as precautionary
31 Alternatively, an equation similar to Equation (6) can be obtained by a Taylor expansion of the marginal rate of substitution, as in Dynan (1993). Banks, Blundell and Brugiavini (1997) use an approximation of the Euler equation developedby Blundell and Stoker (1999).
Ch. 11:
Consumption
771
motive for saving. As Browning and Lusardi (1996) stress, the fact that the effect that the conditional variance has on the rate of growth of consumption is scaled by the coefficient of relative risk aversion is an artefact of the CRRA utility function in which a single parameter controls both risk aversion and prudence (as well as the elasticity of intertemporal substitution). More generally, Carroll and Kimball (1996) have proved the concavity of the consumption function under precautionary saving. It should be noticed that the variance of consumption is not an exogenous variable. While it is likely to depend on the overall uncertainty facing the consumer, it is not obvious how it reacts to the arrival of new information or how it is related to uncertainty in income and interest rates. To evaluate this relationship it would be necessary to solve for the level of consumption and establish how consumption at t+l reacts to changes in the economic environment which, under CRRA preferences, is not possible. Caballero (1990a,b, 1991) using the exponential utility function as a parametrization of within-period utility obtains, with some additional assumptions, a closed form solution for consumption. In an interesting example, he expresses consumption as a function of permanent income (as in the case of certainty equivalence), minus a term which summarises the effect of the precautionary motive. He then goes on to evaluate the effect that precautionary saving is likely to have in reality. While the results obtained with the exponential utility give useful insights about the potential importance of the precautionary motive, such a parametrization of the utility function is not exempt from criticism. It is therefore important to evaluate the importance of precautionary saving using more general functional forms for the utility function. Unfortunately, when one uses different utility functions is not possible to obtain a closed form solution for consumption. It is therefore necessary to use numerical methods to obtain solutions and additional assumptions about the nature of the problem faced by consumers. This is the approach taken in a number of studies, such as those of Skinner (1988), Zeldes (1989b), Deaton (1991), Carroll (1994) and Hubbard, Skinner and Zeldes (1994, 1995). A disturbing feature of these studies is that the quantitative importance of the precautionary motive depends crucially on the properties of the distribution of the income process in the left tail. Bounding away the income process from zero (or from arbitrarily small realisations) greatly reduces the precautionary motive. While the reason for this is clear (consumers will want to insure themselves against disastrous events), the realism of such a mechanism is questionable. It might be worth investigating how the precautionary motive would change in the presence of insurance mechanisms other than self insurance (such as a safety net supplied either by society or by family and relations). Carroll (1994, 1997a) has strongly advocated the precautionary saving motive (or 'buffer stock saving') as an explanation of most empirical puzzles in consumption, including the tracking of expected consumption and income. I discuss the empirical findings on the precautionary motive and more generally on the Euler equation in Section 5. From a theoretical point of view, however, it should be stressed that while the
772
O.P Attanasio
precautionary motive is likely to be important for impatient consumers and especially in the early part of the life cycle, it is also clear that if retirement savings become, at some point during the life cycle, important, they can be used to buffer unexpected fluctuations to income. This effect, however, can be limited if most retirement wealth is held in the form of claims to future benefit or in other illiquid assets (such as special retirement accounts, housing, social security etc.). The relevance of the precautionary saving motive is ultimately an empirical matter, as it depends on preference parameters, on the features of the individual income process and on the availability of safety nets and insurance mechanisms. An attractive possibility to test the relevance of the precautionary motive for saving is to relate observed saving behaviour to perceived uncertainty. Guiso, Jappelli and Terlizzese (1992) is the only paper that uses direct observations on the perceived variance of the income process to assess the importance of precautionary savings. They use a unique data set (the Bank of Italy Survey of Household Income and Wealth) in which individuals are asked not only about their income expectations, but about the complete probability distribution of future income 32. This allows the authors to compute individual variances, which they then relate to individual savings, finding some mild evidence of precautionary savings. One obvious problem with this approach is the possibility that the individuals who have selected themselves into riskier occupation are less risk averse and, maybe, less 'prudent'. A similar argument was used by Skinner (1988) to justify his finding that self-employed individuals seem to save less than the average. More recently, Guiso, Jappelti and Terlizzese (1996) have studied the implications of the precautionary motive for portfolio composition. They show that, in the presence of different and unrelated sources of risk, individuals with higher and undiversifiable earning uncertainty will tend to invest in relatively 'safer' portfolios. 3.5. Borrowing restrictions
Related to the issue of precautionary saving is that of the presence of borrowing constraints. The standard model sketched above assumes that individuals can borrow against future labour income to finance current consumption at the same rate at which they can lend. Of course, if this is not the case, the basic model has to be amended in that the maximisation problem in Equation (4) has to take into account the additional constraint. It has now become customary to interpret evidence of 'excess sensitivity' of consumption growth to labour income as an indication of 'liquidity constraints', by which it is usually meant the presence of some imperfection in financial markets that prevents people from borrowing. However, there is no reason to believe that liquidity constrained individuals consume their disposable income. Only when the constraints are actually binding will this
32 Individuals are asked to divide 100 probabilitypoints over several intervals of income growth.
Ch. 11:
ConsumpHon
773
occur. Therefore, excess sensitivity tests and, more generally, Euler equations are not the best way to identify the presence o f liquidity constraints. Furthermore, as we discuss below, there are several reasons why predicted income and consmnption might be related that have nothing to do with the presence of liquidity constraints. With these considerations, I do not want to dismiss the possibility of liquidity constraints as unimportant or unrealistic 33. Especially for some groups in the populations, they might be quite relevant and have an important effect on aggregate consumption. Early contributions to the literature on the policy implications of the permanent income-life cycle models, such as the papers by Flemming (1973) and Tobin and Dolde (1971), were quite aware of the importance o f liquidity constraints. It is crucial, however, that the presence o f liquidity constraints is incorporated in the optimising framework sketched above. The definition o f liquidity constraints I use in what follows appeal to partial equilibrium considerations: the interest rate schedule is taken as given. General equilibrium considerations, however, even though they are rarely made, can be quite important. In a world o f identical consumers, the possibility o f smoothing consumption over time will be constrained by the technology available to transfer resources over time. In equilibrium, interest rates and asset prices will adjust depending on the demand for borrowing (saving) and on the available technology. In such a situation, nobody is liquidity constrained at the current interest rates. With heterogeneous consumers, it is possible that some will want to borrow and others will be saving. The equilibrium interest rates will then reflect these factors. While the focus o f most o f the considerations in this section is on the partial equilibrium effects, it is worth keeping in mind that aggregate fluctuations, for instance a recession, might have effects on asset prices that reduce the demand for loans relative to what would be observed under constant interest rates. The first step in the integration of borrowing restrictions in the model above must be their exact definition. There are several possibilities. The first and most general alternative is to allow the interest rate paid on assets to depend on the net asset position. As a simple example o f this alternative, consider the possibility o f a difference between borrowing and lending rate. Such a wedge induces a kink in the intertemporal budget constraint. One can then consider Euler equations for individuals who are net borrower and net savers: the interest rate relevant for the two groups will be different, but the Euler equation still holds as an equality. For the individuals that will cluster at zero net assets, however, the Euler equation (with either interest rate) holds as an inequality.
33 As Hayashi (1996) stresses, most specifications of preference implicitly imply a form of borrowing restrictions. If the marginal utility of consumption is infinite a zero consumption, consumers will not want to borrow more than the present discounted value of the minimum realisation of income, even though the probability of this event is very low. This is because they want to avoid the possibility of zero consumption even with a very small probability.
O.P. Attanasio
774
It is also possible that the interest rate varies continuously with the quantity borrowed or saved. I f that is the case, at any point in which the function is differentiable, it is still possible to write down an Euler equation which, relative to Equation (8), contains an additional term referring to the derivative of the interest rate with respect to the asset position 34:
OAf ,'/3
(l +
Et
= 1
(al)
At those points of the intertemporal budget constraint where the interest rate changes discontinuously (such as zero), Equation (11) will be replaced by an inequality. An alternative to the consideration of interest rates varying with the amount borrowed (or saved) is the assumption that individuals face a limit to the amount they can borrow (which can be zero). Obviously this can be interpreted as a case o f the previous situation, with the borrowing rate being infinite at the limit. Even in this case, however, there are several alternatives. It is possible, for instance, that the limit an individual can borrow is not fixed but a function of some variables which, in turn, can be endogenous 35. Finally, it is possible to consider the existence of collateralizable loans. When liquidity constraints take the form of a limit to borrowing, it is still possible to write the Euler equation for consumption, as long as the constraint is not binding. When it is binding, instead, the Euler equation will hold as an inequality, or as an equality with the addition of a slack variable (a Kuhn-Tucker multiplier). Equation (8) becomes E,
[ C'+Yl(1
]
= 1 +~tt,
(12)
where #t is an unobservable Kuhn-Tucker multiplier associated to the borrowing restriction. If instead of considering a homogeneous consumption good, one considers several commodities explicitly, assuming that none of them is durable or can be used as a collateral, for each of these commodities it is possible to obtain an equation of the following form: OU( ) _ ,~,p~ + ~,,
where At is the marginal utility of wealth and Pl is the relative price of commodity i. Notice that gt appears in the first-order conditions for all commodities, so that any
34 A paper which contains this type of analysis is Pissarides (1978). 35 Alessie et al, (1989) and Weber (1993) consider the possibility that the limit to borrowing is a function of earnings.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
775
two of these equations can be used to eliminate it. This implies that the intratemporal first-order conditions hold regardless of the presence of liquidity. Meghir and Weber (1996) used this intuition to distinguish between liquidity constraints and intertemporal dependence in preferences. They consider three different non-durable commodities and stress that the presence of dynamic effects in the Euler equation can be rationalised with intertemporal non-separabilities only if the same dynamic effects are found in the intratemporal first-order conditions. On the contrary, if one finds that the intratemporal conditions do not show any sign of dynamic effects while these appear in the Euler equations, one should interpret this evidence as a sign of binding liquidity constraints. Some studies have explored the possibility that some commodities, such as durables, can be used as collateral to relax the severity of borrowing restrictions. Because durables can be used as collateral, when liquidity constraints are binding, they become relatively more attractive than non-durables. This fact has implications for the withinperiod allocation of resources between durables and non-durable consumption. In the absence of liquidity constraints, this would depend only on the relative price and on their marginal rate of substitution (where the relevant price for durables would be their user cost). In the presence of liquidity constraints, however, an additional term has to be added to the first-order condition to reflect the fact that it is possible to use durables to borrow against future resources. Therefore, as Chah, Ramey and Starr (1995), Brugiavini and Weber (1994) and Alessie, Devereux and Weber (1997) have noted, the possibility of using durables as collateral and the presence of liquidity constraints distorts the intratemporal allocation of resources between durables and nondurables. At several points in the discussion so far ! have stressed that even when liquidity constraints are present, if they are not binding, the Euler Equation (8) will hold. Therefore, such an equation and the mis-specification tests conducted on it (such as tests of 'excess sensitivity') are likely to be a poor tool to identify the presence of borrowing restrictions. In addition to the power considerations just made, in what follows I also stress that evidence on excess sensitivity can often be interpreted as evidence of non-separability between consumption and leisure. The fact that the Euler Equation (8) holds whenever the borrowing restrictions are not binding does not mean that these constraints have no effect on the level of consumption. Indeed, as discussed clearly by Hayashi (1987), the presence of potential liquidity constraints has the same effect as that of a shortening of the horizon relevant for current choices. Alternatively, one can interpret the presence of liquidity constraints (when they are not binding) as an increase in the discount factor. From a policy perspective, liquidity constraints are important because of their effect on the level of consumption, rather than on its changes. In other words, what matters is how consumption reacts to unexpected changes in the economic environment (including policy changes). Euler equations are not informative about this. Deaton (1991) provides one of the first analysis of the effect of liquidity constraints on the level of consumption. By solving the Euler equation numerically, he shows that the behaviour induced by the presence of liquidity constraints is similar to that
776
O.R Attanasio
associated with a precautionary motive for saving. As in the precautionary motive for saving, people will accumulate a buffer stock to avoid the possibility of needing a loan that they cannot obtain. Furthermore, the liquidity constraint will be binding only occasionally as during most periods, individuals avoid, by their optimal behaviour, to find themselves constrained. For liquidity constraints (or precautionary saving) to be relevant for individual behaviour, it is necessary that the households concerned want to borrow, that is they face an increasing income path and are impatient enough to -want to bring resources from the future to the present. Even in such a situation, however, it is not necessary that the Euler equation restrictions are violated. If one rules out the possibility of dying in debt and considers finite lives and a marginal utility of consumption that goes to infinity when consumption goes to zero, it is possible that 'liquidity constraints' are generated endogenously by the model. In particular, to avoid the possibility of having zero resources (and therefore zero consumption) in the last period of life, individuals will not want to borrow any amount in excess of what they can repay with probability one. Notice that in such a situation, consumption in any two periods satisfies the Euler
equation 36. From a theoretical point of view, the considerations above indicate that a profitable research strategy is one which aims at characterising the response of consumption to various news when liquidity constraints are relevant (regardless of whether they are binding). Deaton (1991) constitutes a first important step in this direction. On a more specific level, the analysis in Hubbard, Skinner and Zeldes (1994, 1995) constitutes another good example of how a consistent theoretical model incorporating borrowing restrictions can be used and be informative about important policy issues 37 Several other interesting problems remain to be modelled and understood. If labour supply choices are endogenous, the presence of liquidity constraints might induce female labour force participation. These effects might be strengthened if the ability to borrow is linked to earnings 38. All these issues are examples of the need to be able to use the model to make statements about consumption levels that I discuss again below. Identifying the presence and the relevance of borrowing restrictions is not easy. One possibility is to use direct questions on the matter. Jappelli (1990) used this strategy and analysed the answers to some questions contained in the Survey of Consumer Finances in the USA. The households interviewed in 1983 were asked whether they were denied credit or whether they did not applied because they felt they would be denied. The main problem with this research strategy is that very few household surveys contain questions similar to those analysed by Jappelli.
36 This point was also noted in Hayashi (1987). 37 Jappelli and Pagano (1994) eharaeterisethe link between liquidityconstraints, saving and growth. 38 See O'Brien and Hawley(1986).
Ch. 11: Consumption
777
The presence of (binding) liquidity constraints has some direct implications for the demand for loans. Its analysis constitute therefore an interesting possibility for the identification of borrowing restriction and for evaluating their importance. If consumers are subject to binding borrowing restrictions they will be at a kink (or in a relatively steep section) of an intertemporal budget constraint. Their demand for loans, therefore, will not be much affected by changes in the interest rate. On the contrary, if consulners are not at a corner (or in a relatively fiat part of the budget constraint) their demand for loans will be elastic to the interest rate. The effects of maturity, however, should be opposite. A consumer who is not affected by borrowing restrictions will be indifferent to changes in maturity. On the other hand, a constrained consumer, for whom an increase in maturity will effectively increase his ability to borrow by reducing the size of the payments to maturity, will increase its demand for loan. Juster and Shay (1964) were the first to use this intuition using semi-experimental data. They asked a sample of consumers whether they would finance the hypothetical purchase of an automobile when faced with different packages of interest rates and maturity. The packages of interest rate and maturity were randomised to the individuals in the sample so to enable the estimation of the interest rate and maturity elasticity of the demand for loans. In a recent paper, Attanasio and Goldberg (1997) develop the work of Attanasio (1995b) and perform a similar exercise but on a sample of households who actually purchased (and occasionally financed) automobiles. The main advantage of the Attanasio and Goldberg exercise is that their data refer to actual choices. The main disadvantage relative to the work of Juster and Shay (1964) is that for the households that decided not to finance their car purchases neither interest rates nor maturity are observed. This poses a number of econometric problems that are similar to those that labour economists deal with when analysing participation choices and labour supply.
3.6. Taking into account demographics, labour supply and unobseroed heterogeneity In the previous sections, for the sake of expositional simplicity, I have neglected the vector of observable variables z and the unobserved component v in Equation (4). Their exclusion, however, especially if one wants to estimate or test the model, would be unrealistic. It is quite obvious, for instance, that family size and composition affect the marginal utility of a given amount of consumption expenditure. It is also likely that labour supply behaviour, and in particular female labour supply, will also affect the utility derived from expenditure. Working often implies bearing a certain number of costs that range from transport, to eating out, to clothing. Furthermore, if both spouses work, a number of services that would be produced at home by the partner not participating in the labour force would have to be purchased on the market and would be counted as consumption. More generally, it is plausible that consumption and leisure are not separable in the utility function and that consumption, saving and labour supply choices are taken simultaneously.
o.P. Attanasio
778
Given these considerations, it is important, especially if one wants to bring the model to the data, to consider a specification that allows for these factors. While it is true, as shown in Section 2, that consumption life cycle profiles often mirror income profiles, it is not obvious that one should interpret this as evidence of the empirical failure of the model without considering explicitly the possibility of important demographic effects and that consumption and leisure are not separable. These are not new arguments and I discuss them at length in Section 5, where I interpret the available evidence. The point of this section, however, is to stress that the consideration of these factor is not only important, but also relatively simple. If one does not want to model explicitly these variables, controlling for them does not jeopardise the empirical tractability of the model illustrated by Equations (8) and (9). I re-write a slight modification of Equation (4) for convenience: T-t
max Et Z [3J U(Ct+j, nd zt+j, vt+j), j=o
(4')
where the superscript nd indicates that I am now modelling explicitly only non-durable consumption. As before, the vector of observable variables z indicates variables that are relevant for the intertemporal optimisation problem. The variable u is unobservable to the econometrician. The latter variable is sometimes referred to as 'taste shift'. More generally, it represents all the unobservable factors that affect consumption choices and that we do not model or control for. The variables included in the vector z may range from demographic variables, to labour supply variable, to other components of consumption (such as services from durables). Notice that these variables may be either exogenous to the choice problem (age is a good example), or chosen simultaneously with non-durable consumption (such as labour supply). Even if one does not wish to model these latter variables explicitly, it is possible to identify, using Equation (4I), conditional preferences and the associated parameters under very mild conditions 39. If the z variables in Equation (4 ~) enter the utility function in an additive separable fashion there is no need to consider them. If, on the other hand, they affect the marginal utility of non-durable consumption, they will enter the corresponding Euler equation. As an example, let us consider the following parametrization: U ( C t d, zt, ot) -
(cpd)l-7 exp(O'zt + 1-y
ut).
(13)
A possible interpretation of Equation (13) is that the discount factor varies with variables z and v. Such an interpretation is particularly attractive for demographic variables. In this case, the vector of parameters 0 implicitly represents an equivalence scale.
39 See the discussion in Browningand Meghir (1991) on demand systemsconditionalon labour supply.
Ch. 11:
779
Consumption
Under the parametrization used in Equation (13), the Euler equation for non-durable consumption will be
E, [ \ ~ - j
[(,q,+a)
(1 + R ~ + , ) / 3 e x p [ O ' ( z t + l - z , ) +
v t + x - vt]
l
= 1.
(14)
It should be stressed that Equation (14) holds even if some of the variables included in z are endogenous choice variable, regardless of the way in which they are determined. Modelling labour supply or durable consumption, for example, can be quite difficult because of corner solutions, intertemporal (non)-separability and transaction costs. These problems do not need to be tackled explicitly and Equation (14) can be considered as an equilibrium relationship that holds at the optimal values of the endogenous z, regardless of how these are obtained. Equation (14) can be linearised in the same fashion as Equation (8) to obtain a log-linear expression similar to Equation (9). Neglecting the second moments, that I incorporate into the constant of the equation, we have: Alog(C~dl) = const. + oR~+1 + OtAZt+ 1 + Avt+l + et+l.
(15)
Notice that because of the presence of the term representing unobserved heterogeneity and taste shocks, the residual of equation has now two components, one which represents an expectational error and, by the assumption of rational expectations, is likely to be uncorrelated over time, and another that has an MA(1) structure if taste shocks are i.i.d, over time. If the unobserved heterogeneity term v has a time invariant component which is individual specific, it will be eliminated in the first differences. On the other hand, it is possible that such a term is persistent (rather than white noise) but not fixed and/or that the 'pure' discount factor/3 is individual specific. In the former case the term Av in Equation (15) would have a structure more complex than a simple MA(1), while in the latter, Equation (15) would have a fixed effect. In Section 5, I discuss these econometric problems. The particular parametrization considered in Equation (13) is just an example. More complex structures may be and have been considered. It is possible, for instance, to allow some of the variables in the vector z to affect the curvature of the utility function as well as the rate at which utility is discounted. Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994) and Attanasio and Browning (1995) have used this approach and found significant deviations of estimated differences from the simple isoelastic case. The issue is particularly important in that preferences of this kind can allow for systematic differences in the elasticity of intertemporal substitution across consumers. Attanasio and Browning (1995) also stress the fact that to estimate an Euler equation and its parameters, it is not necessary to specify explicitly the within-period utility function. It is possible and analytically convenient to start from a flexible specification
780
0.17. Attanasio
for the marginal utility of consumption and, if needed, obtain the corresponding utility function by integration 4°.
3.7. Bequest motives
According to the simplest version of the life cycle model sketched at the beginning of the section, the main motivation for individual saving is to provide resources during the last part of the life cycle, when, following retirement, income is low. In such a situation aggregate wealth can be generated by and associated with productivity growth, if the generations that save (the young) are relatively wealthier than those that dis-save (the old). I f the bequest motive is operative, on the other hand, the mechanism through which aggregate wealth is accumulated is quite different. A lively exchange on whether a large or small proportion of aggregate wealth in the USA is accounted for by bequeathed wealth or retirement saving wealth developed in the 1980s between Kotlikoff and Summers [Kotlikoff and Summers (1981), Kotlikoff (1988)] on one side and Modigliani (1988) on the other. The result of that debate remained somewhat ambiguous, as the answer seems to depend mainly on whether one considers the interests earned on bequeathed wealth as originating from bequests or not. A bequest motive can be simply added to the basic model (1) by considering a term which is a function of the bequest left. As it is obvious such a term does not affect the Euler equation for consumption in subsequent periods. It will, however, affect the level of consumption (and saving). One of the implications of the simplest version of the life cycle model is that wealth is decumulated in the last part of the life cycle. While the rate at which wealth is decumulated depends on the parameters of the model and in particular about beliefs about longevity, the result that wealth should decline seems to be robust. The evidence on this point is mixed, in that several studies do not find strong evidence of decumulation of wealth by the elderly 41. When bequests motives are operative, from a theoretical point of view, the wealth age profile can take different shapes in the last part of the life cycle. In an important paper Hurd (1989) has characterised several of these profiles. Hurd also showed that for several realistic sets of parameters, the wealth age profile under bequests is also declining in the last part of the life cycle. From an empirical point of view, Hurd (1989) stresses the importance of conditioning on the labour force status of the individuals in the sample. In particular, whether individuals are retired or not seems to be crucial for the decumulation of their wealth.
40 If one follows such a procedure, one should check the integrability conditions. 41 JappeUiand Modigliani (1997) have forcefully argued that pension benefits should be considered as decumulation of pension wealth.
Ch. 11: Consumption
781
4. Aggregation issues The models considered in Section 3 refer to the dynamic optimisation problem faced by an individual consumer (or household). The early contributors to the life cyclepermanent income model were quite aware of the aggregation issues involved with the empirical implementation of the theory of intertemporal optimisation. These issues, however, were largely ignored by the literature of the late seventies and early eighties which focused mainly on the rigorous introduction of uncertainty in the model. Aggregation problems, however, cannot be ignored when the model is tested and when is estimated to evaluate structural parameters. In this section, I consider briefly two problems: the aggregation across consumers and that across commodities. 4.1. Aggregation across consumers
The Euler equations for (non-durable) consumption that can be derived from the problem in Equation (1) are, for most specifications of preferences, non-linear. As they refer to individual households, their aggregation is problematic. A number of papers have shown that the dynamics of aggregate consumption implied by the Euler equation for individual consumption cannot be described simply by the first moments of the cross-sectional distribution of consumption. Attanasio and Weber (1993), Blnndell, Pashardes and Weber (1993b) and Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994) have shown that higher order moments can play an important role. Attanasio and Weber (1993), in particular, have stressed that the use of aggregate data to estimate an Euler equation is equivalent to omit high moments of the cross sectional distribution of consumption and might cause systematic biases in the estimation of structural parameters and lead to rejections of the over-identifying restrictions 42. These contributions will be discussed when I evaluate the empirical evidence, at this point I only wanted to stress that exact aggregation is in general impossible when considering the Euler equation for consumption. This implies that aggregate data cannot be used to estimate structural preference parameters and/or to test the model. Individual panel data on consumption might be very difficult to obtain. Partly because of this, many of the papers I discuss in Section 5 use the average cohort data that I have used in Section 2 to describe the individual data. The use of grouped data allows one to use time series of repeated cross section to study dynamic models. In this sense, average (or synthetic) cohort data are particularly useful to study life cycle models. It is important to stress, however, that synthetic cohort data are aggregate data; the difference relative to National Accounts data is that the aggregation process is controlled directly. As a cohort ages, the researcher can follow the evolution of the variables of interest, that range from consumption to income, to family size and
42 Blundell, Pashardes and Weber (1993b) make a similar point for a demand system. Similar results were obtained in an asset pricing frameworkby Constantinides and Duffle (1996).
782
O.P. Attanasio
composition, to labour supply behaviour. The presence ofnon-linearities in the relevant equations (as long as they are linear in the parameters) does not constitute a problem, as one can compute the relevant non-linear transformations before averaging the data. Unlike in the aggregate data, therefore, time series of the average of any non-linear transformations of the variables of interest is readily available. In addition to the standard aggregation problems caused by the non-linearity of the Euler equations, there is another sense in which aggregation across consumers can be problematic. As discussed above, it is likely that demographic variables are likely to be important for the determination of consumption. If one does not want to make arbitrary assumptions about the effects that these demographic variables have on the utility function, it might be necessary to consider individual data explicitly 43. In the aggregate, demographic variables move quite slowly so that, even neglecting nonlinearities, their effect cannot be estimated precisely from those data. On the contrary, differences across cohorts, observed over different parts of their life cycle, can be profitably be exploited to identify these effects. Finally, because repeated cross sections are much more common than long panels, one can estimate the structural parameters using a relatively long time period. The importance of a 'large T' in getting consistent estimates is discussed in section 5. The use of average cohort data is not without problems. Probably the most important is that of the presence of measurement error and sample variation. Particular care has to be devoted to evaluating the quality of the data and to use the appropriate econometric techniques. 4.2. Aggregation across commodities
Another important aspect which is often neglected in the literature on the Euler equation is the aggregation of expenditure on different commodities. In principle, one should consider simultaneously the allocation of total expenditure across time periods and the allocation within each period across different commodities. I f one had detailed enough data on expenditure on individual commodities and was willing to specify the form of the direct utility function, the problem could be addressed in a straightforward manner. One could consider the Euler equation defined in terms of the marginal utility of each individual commodity. The issue, however, is to determine under what conditions one can consider the within-period utility function defined in terms of total consumption and assume that the allocation of expenditure over time can be determined with the help of a single price index. One obvious and not particularly interesting answer is when relative prices do not change so that it is possible to construct a Hicks composite commodity. Gorman (1959) was the first to provide a more interesting answer in that he derived
43 Estimation of the effects of demographic variables can be interpreted as the estimation of adult equivalent scales and is therefore important for a variety of reasons.
Ch. 11: Consumption
783
the conditions that the utility function has to satisfy so that it is possible to consider a single commodity 44. In particular, it is necessary that preferences take the generalised Gorman Polar form, that is, i f X is the K x 1 vector of commodities andp the vector of corresponding prices, the indirect utility function has to take the form
V(X, p) = F(X/b(p), a(p)),
(16)
where b(p) and a(p) are functions homogeneous of degree 1 and degree 0 respectively and depend on within-period preferences. From the specification in Equation (16) one can derive an Euler equation for total consumption expenditure: two-stage budgeting can be used to separate the intertemporal from the within-period allocation. To implement Equation (16) it is necessary, however, to estimate the price functions a(p) and b(p), which requires the specification and estimation of a within-period demand system. In an important paper, Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994) estimate a demand system and use the resulting price indexes to estimate the Euler equation for total consumption expenditure. A remarkable result they obtain is that a Stone price index (which does not require the knowledge of preference parameters) constitutes a good approximation to the price indexes in Equation (16). This result is important because points to a simple way to implement Euler equations for non-durable consumption without estimating the entire demand system. The results in Blundell, Browning and Meghir are generalised to a demand system with quadratic Engel curves by Banks, Blundell and Preston (1994). Attanasio and Weber (1995) with a different parametrization of the indirect utility function find a statistically significant role for the zero-homogeneous price index a(p) on US data. If one is willing to specify a utility function defined over several commodities, one can derive an Euler equation for each of these commodities. Under the assumption of additive separability, each of these Euler equation depends only on expenditure on that commodity, nominal interest rates, changes in the commodity-specific price index and on the relevant controls. On the other hand, when additive separability does not hold, the individual commodity Euler equation depends also on the consumption of other commodities. This is an important point in that creates problems for the use of data sources which contain information only on some components of total expenditure, such as the US PSID which gives only information on food consumption. Attanasio and Weber (1995) show that the consideration of food consumption in isolation can yield very misleading results. 5. Econometric issues and empirical evidence
I now move to consider the empirical evidence on the life cycle-permanent income model. In the process of doing so, I also discuss some of the econometric problems 44 See Deaton and Muellbauer (1980) for a clear discussion of these issues.
784
O.P. Attanasio
relevant for theanalysis. As I want to have a rigorous treatment of uncertainty, I only consider the contributions that followed the Hall (1978) paper. I start with a discussion of studies based on aggregate data and then discuss some based on individual data. As ! focus mainly on studies based on Euler equations, I do not discuss a large empirical literature, which has estimated flexible error correction models for aggregate consumption that I have mentioned in Section 2. 5.1. Aggregate time series studies
Because of the aggregation problems discussed in Section 4.1, it is my opinion that aggregate time series data cannot be used to estimate structural preference parameters and test the life-cycle model. Indeed, some papers, such as Attanasio and Weber (1993, 1995), have shown that aggregation issues can easily explain some of the rejections of the model found in the literature. Nonetheless, the papers that have tested the life cycle-permanent income model using aggregate time series data are many and almost impossible to list. Many of the most influential papers in the literature on consumption, such as those by Hall (1978, 1988), Hansen and Singleton (1982, 1983) and Flavin (1981), have been useful conceptual exercises that have brought to the attention of the profession many important issues. Among the most influential and most widely cited studies of aggregate time series papers are those of Campbell and Mankiw (1989, 1991). In these papers the authors consider a simple version of the Euler Equation (5) and estimate it on aggregate data with the addition of income growth on the right hand side. The justification they use for such a specification is that there is a fraction )~ of consumers behaving according to the permanent income-life cycle model while the remaining follow a 'ruleof-thumb' which consists in setting their consumption equal to their disposable income. Several scholars have since interpreted the coefficient ( 1 - ) 0 estimated by Campbell and Mankiw as the fraction of consumers that are 'liquidity constrained'. Campbell and Mankiw estimate their equation by instrumental variables 45 and obtain a coefficient ( 1 - ) 0 of 0.4. There is no reason to believe that the 'excess sensitivity' of consumption to income, as summarised in such a coefficient, represents the fraction of consumers that behave according to Campbell and Mankiw's rule of thumb. First of all, one would have to assume that, if the consumers behaving according to such a rule were the same, the fraction of income (and consumption) accruing to them was constant over time. Second, one would have to believe that the non-linearities in the Euler equation have no effect and could not generate such a result. Finally, to exclude that income and consumption are unrelated under the life cycle model, one would have to believe that consumption and leisure are separable in the utility function.
45 Because they worry about time aggregation, Campbell and Mankiw use instruments dated t - 2 and earlier.
Ch. 11: Consumpgon
785
More recently, in the spirit of the Campbell and Mankiw studies, several papers have studied the time series properties of aggregate consumption and have tried to interpret its relation to a number of other variables in terms of the life cycle-permanent income model or as alternative deviations from it. Carroll et al. (1994), for instance, relate consumption to the index of consumer confidence and provide some interpretation of the high predictive power that such a variable has. Ludvigson (1997), on the other hand, relates consumption to consumer credit and finds that 'excess sensitivity' of consumption to such a variable is even more marked than that to labour income. In the past, some of the papers that used aggregate time series data have also tried to incorporate in the model the possibility that consumption and leisure are not separable in the utility function. Bean (1986), Eichenbaum and Hansen (1988) and Mankiw, Rotemberg and Summers (1985) are examples of these attempts. The presence of corner solutions in labour supply, such as those observed in the case a spouse does not participate to the labour force or in the case of retirement, make the aggregation issues even more complicated.
5.2. Micro data: some econometric problems The analysis of household data on consumption presents a variety of problems that range from the availability and reliability of individual consumption data, to some subtle econometric problems. Of the many problems that is worth stressing three in particular are relevant for the discussion at hand. The first relates to the way in which consistent estimates are achieved from the orthogonality conditions implied by an Euler equation for consumption. The second concerns instead estimation and inference with average cohort data instead of genuine panels. The last point is about the presence of conditional second moments in the (log) linearised Euler equation.
5.2.1. Consistency of estimators derived from EuIer equations The first issue was pointed out by Chamberlain (1984) and subsequently discussed by Itayashi (1987), Altug and Miller (1990) and Deaton (1992) among others. The Euler equation for consumption for a generic individual i can be written as follows: i i Et [h(xt+l,x t, 0)] = 0,
(17)
where 0 is a vector of parameters and x a vector of observable and unobservable variables. Equation (17) states that a function of parameters and variables is orthogonal to information available at time t. If the unobservables are i.i.d, innovations to stationary processes, we can, without loss of generality, restrict the vector x to be made of observable variables. In such a situation one can identify a vector of instruments wt that, if its size is greater than the dimension of the parameter vector, can be used to identify it. The problem arises if one tries to exploit the cross sectional dimension rather than the time dimension to construct the sample equivalent of Equation (17). Equation (17)
786
o.P. Attanasio
implicitly defines expectational errors, which by rational expectations are orthogonal with lagged information, o f which, typically, the instruments are part. There is no reason to believe, however, that expectational errors average to zero in a cross section, at a given point in time. Analogously, there is no reason to believe that the cross sectional covariance o f h in Equation (17) with the vector o f instruments w equals zero. The addition o f time dummies, therefore, is not a solution for the problem at hand: each orthogonality condition one considers would imply the inclusion o f a vector of dummy variables. The only condition under which one can use the cross sectional equivalent of Equation (17) under which introducing a vector o f time dummies can solve the problem is when the expectational errors at a point in time are known to be exactly the same across individuals. But this is equivalent to assume complete markets. This is the option chosen, for instance, by Altug and Miller (1990) and by Atkeson and Ogaki (1996). If one is not willing to assume complete markets, the only alternative is to have a sample covering a long time horizon. This is necessary so that expectation errors average out to zero. Notice that the 'large T' refers to the total length o f the sample period over which individuals (or groups of individuals) are observed and not to the length over which a single individual is observed 46. The necessity of a 'large T' to obtain consistent estimates of the parameters o f an Euler equation follows from the nature o f the residuals of such an equation which incorporate expectational errors. The same argument does not apply to the residuals o f intratemporal (within-period) first-order conditions. Indeed, if expectational errors are the only component o f the residuals, such equations should have a perfect fit. It is for this reason that the consideration o f unobserved heterogeneity is crucial in the specification o f preferences [see Equation (13) above]. As mentioned in Section 3.6, the presence o f unobserved heterogeneity has implications on the nature o f the residuals of the Euler equation. The specification of preferences in Equation (13) implies that in Equation (9 ~) unobserved heterogeneity enters in first differences, so that, depending on the time series properties o f v~, the properties of the Euler equation residuals will be different. If the unobserved heterogeneity term v I has a time invariant component which is individual specific, it is differenced. If v I has a unit root, its differences would be white noise. I f the deviation o f v~ from a constant component are white noise, the residuals of the Euler equation are an MA(1) process. This has implications for the choice o f instruments and the computation o f the standard errors. The situation is more complicated if the deviations o f v I from its fixed component are persistent (rather than white noise) and/or if the 'pure' discount factor /3 is
46 A problem similar to the one just discussed is the issue of the presence of individual fixed effects in the Euler equation for consumption. These could arise, for instance, if the discount factors contain an individual specific component. In this case, the use of weakly exogenous instrument would be invalid. For a discussion of the issues related to this problem see Keane and Runkle (1992) and the comments to that paper in the Journal of Business and Economic Statistics.
Ch. 11: Consumption
787
individual specific. In the former case the term Ao in Equation (9 ~) would have a structure more complex than a simple MA(1), while in the latter, Equation (9 ~) would have a fixed effect. In such a situation the choice of instruments is not trivial, in that lagged individual variables are, in principle, correlated with the residuals of the Euler equation. The problem might be less severe if one uses average cohort data: grouping the individuals belonging to a given cohort averages out the individual fixed effects and leaves only the cohort specific ones. Here the availability of a long time period is once again crucial: it is possible to estimate cohort specific fixed effects (say in discount factors) by introducing cohort dummies in the Euler equation. The necessity of a 'large T' to obtain consistent estimates of the parameters of an Euler equation follows from the nature of the residuals of such an equation which incorporate expectational errors. The same argument does not apply to the residuals of intratemporal (within-period) first-order conditions. Indeed, if expectational errors are the only component of the residuals, such equations should have a perfect fit. It is for this reason that the consideration of unobserved heterogeneity is crucial in the specification of preferences (see Equation 13 above).
5.2.2. Average cohort techniques The lack of true panel data has often forced researchers to use the synthetic cohort data, which I have used in Section 2 for descriptive purposes, to estimate and test dynamic models, such as the Euler equation for consumption. The use of these techniques, pioneered by Browning, Deaton and Irish (1985) and discussed by Deaton (1985) and more recently by Moffitt (1993), has several advantages over real panels 47. Nonrandom attrition, for instance, is much less of an issue. On the other hand, one should be careful about the econometric problems induced by these data. In particular, because the size of the cell one uses to compute averages of the variables of interest is less than infinite, one should consider explicitly the presence of sampling error in the data one uses. Furthermore, because the averages are computed on the levels of variables and one is typically interested in the first differences of variables, the presence of sampling error induces an MA(1) structure on the residuals of the Euler equation estimated on synthetic cohort data. The presence of MA(1) residuals obviously has implications for the choice of the instruments and the computation of standard errors. The fact that synthetic cohort data are typically constructed out of independent repeated cross section, however, suggests simple valid instruments: by lagging the instruments an extra period should guarantee consistency of the IV estimator 48.
47 Average cohort techniques can be interpreted as an example of an estimator using complementary data sources of the kind discussed in Arellano and Meghir (1992). 48 The Consumer Expenditure Survey used, for instance, in Attanasio and Weber (1995) is a rotating panel so that the construction of valid instruments is more complicated.
788
O.P. Attanasio
The structure of the errors is even more complicated when one considers more cohorts simultaneously. In this case, one has to keep into account the possibility that the residuals of different cohorts in the same time period are correlated. The variance covariance matrix of the residuals is therefore quite complex. Its computation is, however, important to make correct inferences 49. Besides adjusting the estimated standard errors for the presence of an MA(1) error and the correlation among the expectationat errors of different cohorts, it is also possible to use a GLS type of scheme to improve the efficiency of the estimator. One should be careful, however, in filtering the data so to avoid the inconsistency caused by the correlation of lagged expectational errors with the instruments 5o. 5.2.3. Conditional second (and higher) moments
In Equation (9~), as in Equation (10), I have neglected the presence of conditional second (and, if the log-normality assumption does not hold, higher) moments that follows from the log-linearization of the Euler equation in (6). In theory, this is not quite correct in that these variables are likely to vary as new information is made available to the individual consumer. This is particularly true for the conditional variance of consumption which is endogenously determined by the model (consumption is a choice variable). Incorporating these variables in the constant is equivalent to assuming that innovations to the conditional second (or higher) moments of consumption and interest rates are uncorrelated with the variables typically used as instruments. Assessing the plausibility of this assumption is very difficult, especially because the answer is likely to depend on the time series properties (and in particular on the heteroscedasticity) of the determinants of consumption levels (income, wages and so on). In a recent paper, Ludvigson and Paxson (1997) have used numerical methods to compare the consumption function obtained from a log-linearised Euler equation to the 'true' one. Their method, however, does not provide estimates for the bias introduced in Euler equation estimation. Carroll (1997b) also uses numerical techniques to simulate log-linearised Euler equations, but focuses on the cross sectional rather than time series dimension, which, given the considerations in 5.2.1 is the relevant one. An interesting and novel approach to this problem is the one used by Banks, Blundell and Brugiavini (1997) in a recent paper. These authors use an approximation to the consumption fimction derived by Blundell and Stoker (1999) which implies weighting the conditional second moments by the ratio of income to wealth at a given point in time. Banks et al. (1997) also try to identify separately the effect of aggregate and cohort specific shocks. The main findings of the exercise are two. First, conditional
49 A technical problem arises from the fact that is not easy to guarantee that the estimated variance covariance matrix is positive definite in finite samples. 50 See Hayashi and Sims (1983).
Ch. 11:
Consumption
789
second moments are significant in the Euler equation; and second, the estimate of some important structural parameters, such as the elasticity of intertemporal substitution, is not much affected by the introduction of the conditional second moments. Yet another alternative to the log-linearization procedure is the one proposed in Attanasio and Browning (1995) who start with a flexible functional form for the (log) marginal utility of consumption so to avoid the necessity of approximating an Euler equation. Should one be interested in the utility function that generates such a function, one can obtain it by integration. Not only does this method avoid dealing with the issue of linearization, but gives the possibility of estimating much more flexible functional forms than the isoelastic one. This is not to say that precautionary motives are unimportant, but that their relevance is going to depend on the curvature of the marginal utility of consumption and is, in the end, an empirical matter. The alternative of estimating a non-linearised Euler equation (such as Equation 8) is particularly unappealing because it would imply assuming away measurement error and would, in any case, make the use of average cohort techniques much harder, if not impossible. 5.3. Micro data: some evidence
In this section, I do not discuss in detail all the papers that have estimated and tested Euler equations for consumption using micro data. Rather, I summarise some of the main contributions with an eye to the overall evaluation of the evidence which I give in the next sub-section. One of the first papers to consider the implications of the permanent incomelife cycle models with micro data is Hall and Mishkin (1982) in which the authors used PSID data to test and reject the implication that consumption changes were uncorrelated with lagged values of current income. Hall and Mishkin (1982) evidence was later criticised by Altonji and Siow (1987) because it did not allow for measurement error. Hall and Mishkin (1982) focused on the permanent income hypothesis and did not consider explicitly the Euler equation that one can get from the consumer intertemporal optimisation problem. One of the first, and probably the most influential article to take such an equation to the data, was the paper by Zeldes (1989a), who implemented ideas very similar to those in Runkle (1991). In both articles, the Euler equation is fitted to observations on food consumption from the PSID. In both articles, the authors consider explicitly the possibility of liquidity constraints and the possibility that these constraints affect different group in the population differently. Effectively, Zeldes (1989a) and Runkle (1991) estimated versions of Equation (12) for different groups of the populations that had, on the basis of an observable variable, different probabilities of having/tt = 0. The results they get, however, are quite different. Zeldes (1989a), in particular, splits the sample according to the wealth held and finds that the rate of growth of consumption is related with the lagged level of income for the low wealth sample. The
790
O.P. Attanasio
same result does not hold for the high wealth sample. Zeldes interprets this results as evidence of binding liquidity constraints for a large fraction of the population. Runkle (1991), who uses a different extract of the PSID, and different econometric techniques, obtains different results 51. Since Zeldes (1989a) and Runkle (1991), many papers, including Hayashi (1985a,b), Garcia, Lusardi and Ng (1997), Lusardi (1996), Mankiw and Zeldes (1994) and Shea (1995), have used PSID data, either alone or in conjunction with other data, to estimate and test various versions of the model. Shea (1995), in particular, identifies a subsample of PSID households for whom he can track their union wage contracts and therefore construct a good measure of their expected wage growth. As many others, Shea (1995) tests (and marginally rejects) the hypothesis that consumption growth is not related to wage growth. Shea (1995), however, also notices that liquidity constraints imply an asymmetry between households who expect a decline and a rise in wages, because the former should be saving rather than borrowing. As he fails to identify these effects, his results cast doubts about the plausibility of liquidity constraints as an explanation of the excess sensitivity of consumption growth to income or wage growth. One of the main problems with the PSID is that the measure of consumption that is included in the survey refers only to food consumption. I have stressed above the theoretical problems with such a measure. Attanasio and Weber (1995) show how the use of such a measure of consumption can lead to misleading results. In that paper, my co-author and I use average cohort data constructed from the CEX for the period 1980-1992 to show that some of the excess sensitivity results obtained on micro data can be accounted for by the non-separability of food and other consumption. The other two issues on which Attanasio and Weber (1995) focuses are the effects of aggregation over consumers and over commodities. As far as the aggregation over commodities is concerned, Attanasio and Weber (1995) find significant effects of the zero-homogeneous price index in Equation (14) that, however, are not quantitatively important. This evidence is consistent with that for the UK FES reported in Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994) and Banks, Blundell and Preston (1994). About the aggregation over individuals, Attanasio and Weber (1995) report evidence which shows that the effect of the non-linearities in the Euler equation can be quite important. This is consistent with the evidence reported in Attanasio and Weber (1993) on FES data. In the latter paper, my co-author and I show that aggregating the individual data so to obtain an aggregate conceptually similar to the National Accounts statistics (i.e. taking the log of the arithmetic mean of consumption) one obtains results that are quite similar to those obtained with aggregate times series data. In particular, it is possible to obtain excess sensitivity to predicted income, a low estimated elasticity of intertemporal substitution and rejection of the overidentifying
51 Keane and Rtmkle (1992) have recently re-estimated Zeldes' equations on his data but using different econometrictechniques. Jappelli, Pischke and Souleles (1997) match SCF data, which contain information on self reported 'liquidity constrained' status with PSID data.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
791
restrictions. The results obtained aggregating the data in the proper way (i.e. taking the average of log consumption), however, are much more consistent with the theoretical model. In particular, there is no rejection of the overidentifying restrictions. The difference between the log of the average and the average of the log is a measure of inequality which varies over the business cycle and is likely to be correlated with the instruments used in estimating the Euler equation. The last group of papers I have cited [Attanasio and Weber (1993, 1995), Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994), Banks, Blundell and Preston (1994), Attanasio and Browning (1995)] all stress the importance of controlling for demographic factors and for labour supply effects. These papers, which use average cohort data for the UK and the USA (the data presented in Section 2) show that once one controls for the influence that demographics and labour supply might have on the marginal utility of consumption, there is no evidence of excess sensitivity of consumption to income or rejection o f the overidentifying restrictions. Female labour force participation and family size seem to be particularly important in this respect 52. If one believes that the estimation of the Euler equations discussed in this section yields consistent estimates, the parameter on the real interest rate can be interpreted as the elasticity of intertemporal substitution. Such a parameter is of some importance for a number of policy issues and its size has been discussed at length. Hall (1988) in particular, claims that the use of the correct instruments delivers very low estimates of this elasticity. However, the evidence that emerges from the micro studies which use an isoelastic specification of preferences [such as Attanasio and Weber (1993, 1995), and Blundell, Browning and Meghir (1994)], is that, both in the UK and in the USA, the elasticity of intertemporal substitution of consumption (EIS) is just below 153. From the discussion above, it is clear that in addition to the EIS, a number of other parameters, measuring the effect of leisure, that of demographics or other variables affecting the marginal utility of consumption are likely to be extremely important in determining the level of consumption. Their interpretation, however, is not easy without a solution for the level of consumption.
6. Where does the life cycle model stand?
It is now time to take stock on the empirical relevance of the models discussed so far. My reading of the evidence briefly presented in Section 5 is that the life cycle model, enriched to account for the effect of demographic and labour supply variables, is not rejected by the available data. Alternatively, and perhaps more accurately, one could
52 Demographicvariablesmight be capturing the effect of the conditional second (and higher) moments ignored in the log linearization procedure. Lusardi (1996) criticises the use of income data in the CEX as they might be affected by measurement error. 53 As mentioned above, the use of aggregate rather than individual data and aggregation problems can explain part of the differences in the size of the estimatesof the elasticity of intertemporal substitution.
792
0.t?. Attanasio
say that the life cycle model can be made complex enough not to be inconsistent with the available data. This view is not widely accepted in the profession so that it deserves some discussion. Before discussing these issues, however, a number of caveats are in order. First, the model has been fitted with success only to households in the middle of their life cycle. While these account for a large fraction of aggregate consumption, additional work is needed to understand the behaviour of young and elderly households. The behaviour of retirees in particular, can be quite difficult to model. I f leisure and consumption are non-separable in the utility- function, a radical change in labour supply could be linked to a change in consumption. Furthermore, a number of other important factors, ranging from family size, to health status, to the probability of death, changes dramatically in the years after retirement. In section 2, we have seen that both in the USA and especially in the UK, consumption drops substantially at retirement. This could be related to insufficient savings and a misperception about the amount of (public and private) pension benefits. Alternatively, the drop in consumption could be explained within the optimisation framework of the life cycle model if considered together with all the changes mentioned above. This important topic is studied in a recent paper by Banks, Blundell and Tanner (1998) who find that, even ignoring health status and mortality issues, two thirds o f the drop in consumption observed around retirement can be rationalised by an optimisation model. Second, while the endogeneity of labour supply choices can be controlled for in the empirical analysis, the joint modelling of consumption and of labour supply is extremely valuable and is still at the beginning 54. Similarly, expenditure on durables, which is an important component of total expenditure, needs to be modelled in a different way, as discussed in Section 8. Third, the fact that a particular specification of preferences fits the data reasonably well and that one can obtain consistent estimates of the structural parameters, does not mean that borrowing restrictions and liquidity constraints are unimportant. The Euler equation can be a very poor tool for identifying the presence of such phenomena, as the equation holds whenever the constraints are not binding. For the notion of liquidity constraints to be useful, however, it is necessary to model the behaviour of constrained individual explicitly and determine what the aggregate implications of these constraints might be. A literal interpretation of the papers mentioned in the last part of Section 5 is that a flexible version of the life cycle model, which allows for demographic and labour supply effects in the utility function, cannot be rejected by the data. Neither excess sensitivity tests, nor tests of overidentifying restrictions reject the null. The strength
54 Surprisinglyfew studies analyse consumption and labour supply choicesjointly. An almost exhaustive list includes MaCurdy (1983), Browning, Deaton and Irish (1985), Hotz et al. (1988), Altug and Miller (1990), Blundell, Meghir and Neves (1993a) and Attanasio and MaCurdy (1997). Of these only the last two papers consider female and male labour supply jointly.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
793
of a result that does not reject the null, however, obviously depends on the power of the test used. The power of the tests of overidentifying restrictions or of the excess sensitivity tests that fail to reject within a sufficiently complex version of the model might be questioned. If an Euler equation is saturated with demographic and labour supply variables, it might be hard to measure precisely the coefficient on expected income or, more generally, reject overidentifying restrictions. This problem might be particularly serious if some of these variables, such as labour supply, are correlated with expected income. In this sense, this criticism is equivalent to state the difficulty in distinguishing hypotheses about preferences from hypotheses on budget constraints. A possible response to this kind of criticism is to check whether the preferences parameters of the model that is not rejected by the data are sensible and, most importantly, whether the model is able to explain facts other than those that have been used to fit it. An example will make this argument clear. In Attanasio et al. (1996), my co-authors and I consider a relatively simple version of the life cycle model where the within-period utility function includes demographic variables and whose parameters are assumed to be the same across education groups. Such a specification of the model is estimated on US average cohort data and it is not rejected by the data. The elasticity of intertemporal substitution is estimated to be just below 1. Given some hypotheses about the stochastic process that generates income, interest rates and demographic variables, and given an assumption on terminal conditions, one can solve numerically for the consumption function at each age. We do so and then simulate the model for income and demographic profiles calibrated on different education groups. With this technique we are able to reproduce some of the main feature observed in the data, that is, that the consumption profiles are steeper for the groups that have a steeped income profiles. This feature of the data has been interpreted as a failure of the life cycle model by Carroll and Summers (1991). Our exercise, however, shows that a flexible version of the life cycle model incorporating some realistic features, such as the effect of family composition on utility, can explain it. The result is remarkable because there is nothing, at the estimation level, that fits the particular feature of the data (differences in consumption age profiles by education groups) that the estimated preferences (assumed to be the same across groups) and the differences in demographic profiles are able to explain. In this sense the exercise constitute a genuine 'out-ofsample' verification of the ability of the model to fit the data. As the utility function is of the CRRA type, the model also incorporates the precautionary motive linked to income uncertainty which Carroll (1997a) has recently advocated as the most likely explanation of the relationship between the shape of consumption profiles and that of income profiles. The simulations show, however, that this effect is quantitatively less important than that generated by differences in demographic profiles. Indeed, most of the 'tracking' of consumption and income profiles is generated by corresponding similarities in demographics. This argument
794
O.P. Attanasio
is also consistent with the evidence presented in Section 2 where consumption 'per adult equivalent' profiles are quite flat over the life cycle 55. The simulation techniques used in Attanasio et al. (1996) are similar to those used by Deaton (1991) and by Hubbard, Skinner and Zeldes (1994), among others, to obtain a closed form solution for consumption. These techniques are the only way, if one is not willing to assume quadratic utility or CARA utility [as in Caballero (1990a)] 56, to obtain a consumption function in the presence of uncertainty. They are quite expensive as they are numerically intensive for any problem which goes beyond the simplest assumptions and require the researcher to take a stand on any detail of the optimisation problem (from the terminal condition to the nature of the income process). The payoff one can obtain can, however, be quite large. The Euler equation approach, first used by Hall (1978) in the consumption literature, was a major innovation. It allowed the rigorous consideration of uncertainty in a complicated dynamic decision problem while preserving the empirical tractability of the model. The beauty of the approach consists in the fact that exploits the main implication of the life cycle-permanent income model, that is that an optimising consumer keeps the discounted expected value of the marginal utility of consumption constant, to eliminate the unobservable 'fixed effect', the marginal utility of wealth, which incorporates the influence of expectations and all the variables that are relevant for the consumer optimisation problem. The price that one pays by differencing out the marginal utility of wealth is, however, non-negligible. While it is true that one can use the Euler equation to estimate structural parameters, one looses the ability of saying anything about the l e v e l of consumption. This implies that without additional information and structure, it is not possible to answer a number of extremely important questions. In other words, the Euler equation for consumption is n o t a consumption function and therefore it does not tell us anything about how consumption reacts to news about the economic environment in which economic agents operate. The symptom of this unsatisfactory state of affairs are apparent in the literature. If one reads, for instance, the literature on saving, which in recent years has dealt with a number of interesting issues that range from the decline in personal saving rates in the USA to the effects of tax incentives on personal and national saving, one rarely finds a systematic use of Euler equation estimates or even references to the Euler equation literature. Indeed, the use of structural models of consumption behaviour is quite rare. On the other hand, the same literature suffers from a number of identification problems that arise from the inability or unwillingness to put more structure onto the descriptive analysis. A good example is the debate on the effectiveness of fiscal incentives to retirement saving.
55 It can be argued that the demographics in the Euler equation for consumption are picking up the effect of the omitted conditional higher moments. 56 Both in the case of quadratic and CARA utility a number of additional assumptions about interest rates are necessary.
Ch. 11: Consumption
795
It seems that, 40 years after the publication o f Friedman's book, we still have not been able to construct a 'consumption function' which incorporates the main features of the dynamic optimisation model without loosing analytical and empirical tractability. The development o f the numerical solution techniques referred to above is one possible avenue. The main problem with these techniques, however, is that they require a complete specification of the economic environment (including terminal conditions) in which the agent lives. Therefore, to make the problem treatable, even with the use o f powerful computation methods, very strong assumptions are needed. Furthermore, we cannot use the conditioning arguments which simplify the estimation o f an Euler equation. While at the estimation level variables such as durables and labour supply can be rigorously treated as endogenous without modelling them explicitly, at the level o f numerical solutions, they cannot be ignored.
7. Insurance and inequality One o f the main implications of the life cycle model sketched in Section 3, is the fact that households attempt to smooth consumption over time. I f one sees an individual household in isolation, this can be achieved only through the accumulation of buffer stock saving or through borrowing. However, if one considers the interaction of many households, one realises that if individual shocks are not perfectly correlated, there is scope for the diversification o f idiosyncratic risk and for welfare improving contracts that allow the individual households to share part o f the risk they face. The essence o f a risk sharing situation, as formalised, for instance, by Townsend (1994), is well described by one of the characters in Shipping News, the novel by Anne Proulx set in Newfoundland. Describing life in one of the small islands off the coast, he declares "... it was never easy ... on Gaze Island, but they had the cows and a bit of hay, and the berries, the fish and the potato patches, and they'd get their flour and bacon in the fall from the merchant over at Killiek-Claw, and if it was hard times, they shared, they helped their neighbor. No they didn't have any money, the sea was dangerous and men were lost, but it was a satisfying life in a way people today do not understand. There was a joinery of lives all worked together, smooth (pp. 16~169) in places, or lumpy, but joined." Social and economic interactions in modern western societies are probably much more complex than those that prevailed on Gaze Island. It is however an interesting question to establish to what extent institutions of various kinds are used to smooth consumption across households and to diversify idiosyncratic risk. In other words, it might be interesting to establish the extent to which implicit or explicit contracts, family networks, social safety nets and so on can approximate the intertemporal allocation that would prevail under complete contingent markets o f the kind described in an Arrow-Debreu equilibrium. Furthermore, it might be interesting to establish what are the welfare costs implied by the lack o f complete contingent markets, given the nature of the observed idiosyncratic shocks.
796
O.P Attanasio
From a theoretical point of view, the basic proposition can be derived if one considers the allocation problem faced by a central planner who maximises, given a set of Pareto weights, the average of individual utilities given the resource constraint. This framework is particularly useful because it can be used to control easily for a number of factors and in particular for the presence of multiple commodities, non-separable leisure and so on. The basic implication is that the rate of change of the marginal utility of consumption (which might depend on leisure and other commodities) is equalised across individuals. Townsend (1994) was one of the first to consider the empirical implications of complete market, that is that under certain conditions "... individual consumptions are determined by aggregate consumption, no matter what the date and history of shocks, and so individuals' consumption will move together" (p. 540) 57. While Townsend (1994) considered data from India, other studies, such as Mace (1991), Cochrane (1991) and Hayashi et al. (1996), performed similar exercises using US data, that is either the CEX or the PSID. Both Cochrane (1991) and Hayashi et al. (1996) reject the implications of the risk sharing hypothesis. Cochrane (1991) finds that food consumption changes in the P SID are related to changes in health and employment status. Hayashi et al. (1996) use the same data but control for the possibility that the relationship between changes in wages and consumption is generated by the non-separability of leisure and consumption in the utility function. By following spin-offs in the PS1D, they also test (and reject) the hypothesis that risk is shared among families. Attanasio and Davis (1996) have matched data from the Current Population Survey and the CEX to test the hypothesis that movements in relative wages are reflected into movements in relative consumption or, to be precise, in marginal utilities of consumption. Attanasio and Davis consider education and year of birth cohorts. Most of the variability in relative wages comes from the shifts in the wage distribution across education groups that occurred during the 1980s. They find that such movements were mirrored in movements in the consumption distribution, indicating a 'spectacular failure' of the perfect insurance hypothesis 58. The analysis of Attanasio and Davis is particularly damning for the perfect insurance paradigm because it focuses on economy wide, well observed shifts, and therefore the relationship between consumption and income cannot be explained with models which consider private information such as those in Phelan and Townsend (1991). Attanasio and Davis (1996) also try to evaluate the welfare cost of the lack of an institutional framework that allows for the diversification of idiosyncratic risk. The evaluation of such a cost obviously depends on preference parameters and on
57 Townsend (1994) credits Diamond (1967) and Wilson (1968) with the first versions of this proposition. 58 As Hayashi et al. (1996), Attanasio and Davis (1996) use lead as well as lags of wages as instruments. Both studies consider short and long tun shocks.
Ch. 11: Consumpgon
797
the nature o f the shocks considered. Attanasio and Davis (1996) under a set of plausible assumptions and a coefficient o f relative risk aversion of two, evaluate the cost of the lack of insurance to 'group specific shocks' at 2.5% of consumption. This estimate is considerably larger than the cost of business cycle fluctuations evaluated by Lucas (1987) and is more in line with the results reported by Imrohoroglu (1989). It should also be stressed that Attanasio and Davis (1996) estimate completely ignores 'within-groups' shocks and focuses mainly on relative low (rather than business cycle) frequencies. Whilst the analysis of Attanasio and Davis (1996) can be framed in terms of a test of the perfect insurance hypothesis, it can also be interpreted as documenting the evolution in inequality in consumption and wages in the USA during the 1980s. The increase in inequality in wages in the USA has been analysed in many studies by labour economists. On the other hand, the evolution o f inequality in consumption has not received much attention until quite recently. Little is known about the evolution of consumption inequality over the business cycle and over different stages of the process of economic growth. In addition to Attanasio and Davis (1996), Cutler and Katz (1991) analyse the evolution of inequality in consumption during the 1980s using CEX data. Goodman, Johnson and Webb (1997) provide an exhaustive analysis of the recent trends in both income and expenditure inequality in the UK. The lack of evidence on consumption inequality is somewhat disconcerting, especially if one compares it to the amount of evidence on wage and income inequality. From a theoretical point of view, it is not completely obvious which of the two measures of inequality is more interesting. Blundell and Preston (1998) discuss the advantages and drawbacks of both: consumption inequality is more likely to reflect the cross sectional variability of permanent income, while income inequality is more affected by temporary shocks. The relationship between the two, however, depends on a number of factors that range from the specification of preferences to the nature of the income shocks, to the institutions and instruments available to households to (self) insure against idiosyncratic shocks. More generally, a theoretically consistent analysis of consumption inequality cannot avoid the discussion of the implications of different preference specifications and market institutions. Suppose, for instance, that individual households are prevented from borrowing. If labour supply behaviour is considered exogenous, these households will engage in precautionary saving to avoid the effects of extremely negative shocks to income. On the other hand, if one models labour supply choices and in particular female participation in the labour market, it is quite possible that the role of precautionary saving is taken by labour supply. That is to say, it is possible that households, rather than consuming less goods, decide to consume less leisure. Another important element, which has been only recently analysed, is the availability of means tested safety nets. Hubbard, Skinner and Zeldes (1994) consider the effect that liquidity constraints and means tested safety nets have on the pattern of consumption using numerical techniques to solve the consumption function.
798
O.P. Attanasio
Browning and Crossley (1997) have recently considered another potentially important channel that some households might use to smooth the marginal utility of consumption over time: what they call small durables. The idea is intuitive: individuals that have no access to savings or loans to smooth out fluctuations in income, might postpone the replacement of small durables. The features that characterise the 'small durables' in Browning and Crossley's problem are the durability and the irreversibility (due to the lack of a second hand market) of such items, as well as the fact that scrappage decisions are not only determined by the physical depreciation but also by the economic situation faced by the agent. Browning and Crossley (1997) present both some theoretical results and some empirical evidence on a sample of Canadian unemployed supporting the importance of this type of smoothing behaviour. The evidence I presented in Table 6, about the relative variability of durable expenditure for groups of households with different levels of education is consistent with the idea that poorer individuals might use durables to smooth out fluctuations in income. Browning and Crossley (1997) focus on items that cannot be used as collateral (such as clothes or small appliances) to obtain loans. It would be interesting to consider the implications of the same ideas for the replacement of items for which reasonably efficient second hand markets exists and which are collateralizable such as automobiles and, to a certain extent, 'white goods'. Greenspan and Cohen (1996) have stressed the important role that scrappage of old cars plays in forecasting expenditure on automobiles which, in turn, is a very important indicator of the status of the business cycle. A few studies, recently, have started to study the evolution of inequality over the life cycle. The idea is quite simple: if consumption follows a random walk, the cross sectional distribution of individual consumption should 'fan out' over the life cycle. That is, the cross sectional variance of individual consumption should be increasing, on average, over long periods of time. This idea was first exploited by Deaton and Paxson (1994) who analysed average cohort profiles for the variance of (log) nondurable consumption in three different countries, the USA, the UK and Taiwan.
8. Intertemporal non-separability In the discussion so far, I have assumed that preferences are separable over time. While this is an extremely convenient assumption, it is easy to think of situations in which it is violated. In this section I consider the implications of the fact that current expenditure might have lasting effects. After sketching the general problem, I discuss in detail two particular examples of time non-separability of some importance: that of durability and of habit formation. As is clear from the discussion, the complication implied by time dependence of preferences is only one of the things that make the treatment of these phenomena extremely hard. The general problems can be stated in reasonably simple terms if one states the problem in terms of a flow of services derived from a 'stock' and assumes that there
Ch. 11: Consumption
799
are no costs in changing the 'stock'. The simple problem in Section 3, can therefore be re-written as: T-t
max
Et v(s,+j) j=0
IAt+j+l~l+rt+j)At+j+Yt+j-st+j,
subject to [St+j = Z
(18)
= 1
k=0
where St is the 'stock' from which utility is derived, st is expenditure and the coefficients ak define the type of time dependency. As we see below, such a model can easily incorporate durability as well as habit formation. It is also straightforward to consider the case in which S is a vector whose components have different degrees of durability 59. A rational individual, in choosing the level of expenditure s will take into account the effect that this has on the level of the 'stock' in the current as well as in the future period. It is straightforward to verify that the first-order condition for such a problem is going to be
Etmt = Et[3(1 + rt+l) mr+l, T
(19)
t
where m t = ~-~'~k=0~ku1(St+k) ak" Notice that if the ak s are different from zero, mt is not a variable known at time t as it depends on the future marginal utility of the stock S. In general, therefore, it will not be possible to express Equation (19) in terms of the rate o f growth of mt as is usually done [see, for instance, Equation (8)]. Notice also that the marginal utility of expenditure mt depends on a potentially very large number of terms. To make an equation such as (19) operational it will be necessary to simplify it by some algebraic manipulation whose nature depends, once again, on the pattern of the coefficients ak. The two models of non-separability I consider below (durables and habits) differ on the nature of the time dependence. In the first case we have substitutability, while in the latter we have complementarity of expenditure over time.
8.1. Durables As illustrated in Section 2, expenditure on durables, both at the aggregate level and at the cohort level, is by far the most volatile component of consumption. In addition, the dynamic of durable expenditure seems much more complex of that of the other components o f consumption. A simple model of durable consumption can be obtained
59 See, for instance, Eichenbaum and Hansen (1990).
O.P Attanasio
800
from the system in Equation (18) if it is assumed that ak = (1 - 6) k. In this case S can be interpreted as the value of the stock of durables, and 6 as the depreciation rate, and the third equation in system (18) becomes St = (1 - 6)St_1 +st.
(20)
Assuming quadratic utility, Mankiw (1982) generalised Hall's random walk model to durable expenditure. In particular, he showed that under these circumstances the model implies that changes in expenditure should follow an MA(1) process with coefficient equal to ( 1 - 6). This implication is strongly rejected by the aggregate data, as shown, for instance, in Section 2. Dunn and Singleton (1986) have used a more attractive preference specification and considered the Euler equation for durable consmnption and its implications for asset pricing. The most comprehensive treatment of durability and of the Euler equations associated with a variety of preferences is found in Eichenbaum and Hansen (1990) who use a Gorman-Lancaster technology that converts expenditure into stocks and stocks into services over which utility is defined. The aggregation issues I discussed in Section 4 are obviously relevant for durables as well. The aggregation problems are actually even more complicated because of the possibility of corner solutions, i.e. households that decide not to own a durable (a car for instance), that can be safely ruled out for non-durables under the assumption that the marginal utility goes to infinity at zero or low levels of consumption 6°. A possibility for the deviations of the dynamics of aggregate durable expenditure from that implied by the simple model is that of the existence of adjustment costs. It seems natural to assume that adjusting the stock of durables involves costs, motivated both by the existence of imperfections in the second hand market and by 'pure' adjustment costs (such as search costs, taxes and similar). The literature first studied convex (typically quadratic) costs of adjustment. A typical example is Bernanke (1984, 1985), who estimated models with quadratic costs both with aggregate and individual data. Eichenbaum and Hansen (1990) also incorporate the possibility of adjustment costs in their technology. Such attempts, however, have turned out to be unsuccessful. The main reason for this is that convex adjustment costs predict a smooth adjustment towards an equilibrium. To avoid increasing costs households will adjust their stock of durables often and by small amounts. Even casual observation suggests that this is not a very accurate description of household behaviour. The next step is then to consider non-convex costs of adjustment; that is either fix or proportional costs. The characterisation of optimal behaviour under this type of costs is obviously much harder because for many households in many periods the optimal policy involves no adjustment. The first paper to characterise the optimal
6o Bernanke (1984) and Hayashi (1985a,b) are among the few studies that have used individual data to analyse durable expenditure.
Ch. 11: Consumption
801
adjustment policy under non-convex costs was Grossman and Laroque (1990) who studied a problem of a consumer deriving utility from a single durable and solving a dynamic optimisation problem involving the choice of the optimal size for the durable and the optimal portfolio investment for her financial wealth. Grossman and Laroque (1990) proved that the optimal strategy involves an (S, s) rule of the kind considered in the optimal inventory literature of the 1950s. Specifically, they proved that the value function associated to the consumer problem is a function of a single state variable, the ratio of the value of the durable to financial wealth, and that the durable is adjusted to a 'target' level when the state variable crosses a lower or an upper bound. When the state variable is within the two bounds the optimal policy is not to adjust the durable. In addition, Grossman and Laroque (1990) characterised the size of the inaction band as a function of the parameters of the problem, as well as the optimal portfolio strategy. One of the problems of the Grossman-Laroque model is that a solution can be obtained only if the problem can be expressed as a function of a single state variable. This precludes, for instance, the consideration of labour income. More recently, Eberly (1994) and Beaulieu (1993) have extended the Grossman-Laroque model in various directions. Eberly (1994), has showed that changes in the durable stock between periods in which an adjustment is performed obey to an Euler equation. Beaulieu (1993) has reformulated the Grossman-Laroque model and expressed the (S, s) rule in terms of the ratio of durables to non-durables. The attractiveness of the (S,s) model of adjustment lies in its implications that, in most periods, consumers do not adjust their stock of durables and when they do adjust, they usually make substantial adjustments. These features (large and infrequent adjustments), that can be generated by the (S, s) model, are the exact contrary of those of the quadratic adjustment model which yields small and frequent adjustments. The consideration of large and infrequent adjustments poses an entire new category of aggregation problems. Caplin (1985) was the first to consider them. Caplin and Spulber (1987), in the context of a model of price adjustment, provided (stringent) conditions under which lumpy individual adjustment could result in a smooth aggregate adjustment. Bertola and Caballero (1990) analysed the implications of the (S,s) type of adjustment for the dynamics of aggregate durable expenditure and stressed that the assumptions needed to generate the type of neutrality results obtained by Caplin and Spulber are indeed very fragile. (S, s) models can generate very rich and complicate dynamics that seem not to be inconsistent with the observed autocorrelation of durable expenditure. Caballero (1990a,b, 1993), in particular, has stressed how (S,s) models can generate patterns of MA coefficients that are similar to those I reported in Section 2. Caballero and Engel (1991) have studied more generally the aggregate properties of (S, s) economies. Caballero (1993) has tried to estimate the parameters of the (S, s) model by fitting the highly non-linear model resulting from the aggregation of a simple (S, s) rule to aggregate time series data. The estimation of (S, s) models with individual data is not an easy task for several reasons. First of all, the data requirements can be quite formidable: information on the value of the stock of durables before and after the adjustment is necessary. It is
802
o.P Attanasio
also desirable to follow households over some time to bound the range of inaction by the households that are observed not to adjust. In addition, the numerical problems in estimation can be quite formidable. The first attempt at estimating such a model with individual data was by Lam (1991) who estimated by maximum likelihood an (S, s) rule defined in terms of the ratio of the stock of automobiles over permanent income. Eberly (1994), also estimated the width of the (S, s) rule for the subset of consumers who were observed to adjust the stock of their automobiles in her sample 6~. B eaulieu (1992) also uses individual observations but follows a different approach. He considers a single cross section and computes the ergodic cross sectional distribution to which the economy would converge in the absence of aggregate shocks. The parameters of this distribution will depend on the parameters of the (S, s) rule. He can then estimate them from the parameters of the observed cross sectional distribution which is assumed to coincide with the ergodic distribution. Like Lain (1991), I have estimated the parameters of the (S,s) rule by maximum likelihood on individual data in Attanasio (1995a). However, I formulate the (S, s) rule in terms of the ratio of the stock of automobiles to non-durable consumption, allow for observed and unobserved heterogeneity in both the target and the band width and consider a more flexible stochastic specification. The consideration of unobserved heterogeneity in both the target level and the band width makes the model equivalent to a recent formulation of lumpy adjustment by Caballero and Engel (1991) who consider, rather than a strict (S, s) rule, a 'hazard function' which gives the probability of adjusting as a function of the difference between the current stock and its target level. While substantial progress in the understanding of the behaviour of models with lumpy adjustment has been made (not only in consumption but also in investment and labour demand), a lot of research is still necessary to establish the empirical relevance of these models and to quantify their parameters. The aggregate dynamics of an (S, s) system depends crucially on the properties of several stochastic processes about which we still have little or no information. These include the process by which the state variable changes when no adjustment occurs, the process by which the target level changes, the degree of heterogeneity in target levels and band width, the degree of persistence of individual shocks to band width (cost of adjustment) and the correlations among these variables.
8.2. Habit formation A form of intertemporal persistence of preferences alternative to durability is that of habits. As said above, habits can be obtained using a specific patterns for the 61 Eberly (1994) also splits the samplebetween consumers who are likelyto be liquidity constrained and those that are liquid. In doing so she uses both the procedure used by Zeldes (1989a) and a switching regression model.
Ch. 11:
803
Consumption
coefficients a in Equation (18). For instance, Heaton (1995) and Constantinides (1990) use the following specification: O<3
St = ct - a(1 - 0) ~
OJet a~;
O~a~l,
0~0~1.
(21)
j-0 The term (1 - 0) ~ ) ~ 00Jct-l-j is referred to as the 'stock of habits', which depreciates according to the parameter 0. A particularly simple specification is obtained when 0 = 0, in which case the stock of habits is simply given by last period consumption. As with the cases considered above, the marginal utility of time t expenditure is a function of both present and future variables, so that it is now known at time t. The habit formation model has a long history, dating back at least to Gorman (1967), Pollak (1970) and Houthakker and Taylor (1970) 62. Spynnewin (1981) presents an ingenious reparametrization of the optimisation problem which, by an appropriate redefinition of prices and quantities, allows the maximisation of an intertemporally additive function. However, it is only in the 1980s that habits models are coupled with the hypothesis of rational expectations and preferences incorporating temporal persistence are used to derive Euler equations analogous to Equation (19) above. Examples of this practice include Eichenbaum and Hansen (1988) (for a model with habit forming consumption and leisure), Eichenbaum and Hansen (1990), Novales (1990) and Constantinides (1990), while Hotz, Kydland and Sedlacek (1988) and Kennan (1988) consider habit formation in leisure. Browning (1991) uses a dual approach to derive the equivalent of 'Frisch' consumption functions in the presence of intertemporal non-separability 63. More recently, Heaton (1993, 1995) has considered the interplay between time aggregation and habit formation. His argument is that at high frequency consumption seems to exhibit substitutability, while at lower frequencies, there is evidence of complementarities. Heaton argues that the local substitutability of consumption could be explained by time aggregation. In general, he presents preferences that are flexible enough to accommodate the 'slow' formation of habits. Most of the work on habit models so far has been done on aggregate time series data. One of the reasons for this is the fact that very few panel data contain information on consumption. The CEX, which I used in Section 2, contains only up to four quarterly observations per households. The average cohort analysis that is used in the study of dynamic models of consumption, cannot be used in the analysis of habit formation, because these models involve the covariance of subsequent consumption observations f o r the s a m e household. In other words, we cannot aggregate the product C h t C ht k over the household index h, unless we have observations for times t and t - k for the same households. 62 Browning (1991), however, has citations from Marshall and Haavelmo. 63 Browning's simple structatre can encompass both substitutability and complementarities over time. The main problem with his approach is that he can only introduce uncertainty by considering points expectations about the future.
804
O.P. Attanasio
The only paper that studies time dependence in preferences using micro data is, to the best of my knowledge, Meghir and Weber (1996), that I discussed in the section on liquidity constraints. Another novelty of that paper is that it considers different components of consumption and allows for different levels of persistence depending on the commodity considered. The interesting evidence is that, when durable commodities are controlled for, there is no evidence of persistence in the 3 equations demand system that Meghir and Weber (1996) consider.
9. Conclusions
Rather than summarising the various sections that compose the chapter I prefer to conclude the chapter comparing the status of our knowledge and understanding of consumption behaviour to that of twenty years ago. It is fair to say that substantial progress has been made. In the last twenty years we have learned how to deal with uncertainty in a rigorous fashion and have recognised the importance that this may have for consumption and saving decision. Indeed an entire branch of the literature, that on precautionary saving, has developed to deal with these issues. While the emphasis given to the proper treatment of uncertainty and the lack of appropriate data sources has meant that many studies have focused on aggregate data, it has now become clear that it is very hard, if not impossible, to estimate preference parameters from aggregate time series data. Aggregation issues are important in many dimensions. In addition to the standard aggregation problems created by the non-linearity of the relevant theoretical relationships, there are other ways in which aggregation issues become important. Corner solutions and participation decisions (in labour and financial markets), inertial behaviour and transaction costs, all add a new dimension of complexity and make the cross sectional distribution of the variables under study relevant for the dynamics of the aggregate. The Euler equation has been the main instrument to analyse consumption both in micro and macro data, to estimate preference parameters and to test the overidentifying restrictions implied by the consumers' optimisation problem. In the process we have learned a lot about the econometric problems of estimating Euler equations. In particular, we have learned what are the identifying assumptions that one needs to make to get consistent estimates from the available data. The Euler equation is a powerful tool in that it allows the consideration of complex and flexible preference specifications without loosing the empirical tractability. As long as the variable over which one is optimising can be adjusted without cost and is not at a corner, one can derive an Euler equation which, even if it includes the values of other endogenous variables, delivers orthogonality restrictions that can be used to estimate preference parameters. The empirical research has used Euler equations for non-durable consumption and its components that have become, in the attempt to fit the observable data, increasingly complicated. This level of complexity is probably unavoidable if one is serious about taking the model to the data.
Ch. 11: Consumption
805
As I stressed several times during the chapter, the price one pays in dealing with Euler equations is not negligible: one loses the ability of saying anything about the level of consumption. The empirical tractability of the Euler equation is obtained differencing out the marginal utility of wealth, and therefore one of the main determinants of consumption levels. The challenge for future research is to construct a consumption function that incorporates the insights of the Euler equation and yet allows us to say something about the levels o f consumption and about how consumption reacts to changes in the economic environment. Such a consumption function is necessary to make predictions about future consumption, about saving behaviour, and about the effects of alternative policy measures. One possibility that is being explored is the use of numerical techniques. They have proved to be useful both to improve our understanding of the dynamic optimization problems typically postulated and to characterise the implications of different preference structures and economic environments on consumption and saving behaviour. They can also be used to validate, indirectly, the preference specifications implied by the Euler equation estimates that best fit the consumption growth data. Their main limitation, however, is an important one: they can only be used to analyse extremely simplified models and they require the full characterisation of the agents' economic environment. Several other areas of research are important and exciting. I will just mention two. Our understanding of consumption smoothing and of the evolution of inequality is still at the beginning. The development of this understanding and of the importance that different institutional frameworks and financial instruments have for these issues is an extremely important research agenda both from a positive and from a normative point of view. Related to this is also the issue of the time series properties of individual consumption: unlike for earnings and hours of work, next to nothing is known about this. Our understanding of durable expenditure is still very limited and yet it is an extremely important issue, both because durables are the most volatile component of consumption and because they have a number of features (the fact that they can be used as collateral, transaction costs, the durability itself) that make them difficult to model.
References
Abowd, J., and D. Card (1989), "On the covariancestructureof earnings and hours changes",Econometrica 57:411-445. Alessie, R., B. Melenberg and G. Weber (1989), "Consumption, leisure and earnings related liquidity constraints: a note", Economics Letters, 27:101-104. Alessie, R., M. Devereux and G. Weber (1997), "Intertemporal consumption, durables and liquidity constraints: a cohort analysis", European Economics Review 41:37-60. Altonji, J.G., and A. Siow (1987), "Testingthe response of consumption to income changes with (noisy) panel data", Quarterly Journal of Economics 102:293-328. Altug, S., and R.A. Miller (1990), "Household choices in equilibrium", Econometrica58(3):543 570.
806
O.P. Attanasio
Arellano, M., and C. Meghir (1992), "Female labour supply and on the job search. An empirical model estimated using complementary data sets", Review of Economics Studies 59:537-557. Atkeson, A., and M. Ogaki (1996), "Wealth-varying intertemporal elasticities of substitution: evidence from panel and aggregate data", Journal of Monetary Economics 38:507334. Attanasio, O.E (1994), "Personal saving in the US", in: J. Poterba, ed., International Comparisons of Household Savings (NBER/Chicago University Press) 57-124. Attanasio, O.E (1995a), "Consumer durables and inertial behavior: estimation and aggregation of (S, s) rules", Working Paper No. 5282 (NBER). Attanasio, O.E (1995b), "The intertemporal allocation of consumption", Carnegie-Rochester Conference on Public Policy, Supplement to the Journal of Monetary Economics. Attanasio, O.E, and J. Banks (1997), "Trends in household saving", Economic Policy, No. 27, 549-583. Attanasio, O.P., and M. Browning (1995), "Consumption over the life cycle and over the business cycle", American Economic Review 85:1118-1137. Attanasio, O.E, and S.J. Davis (1996), "Relative wage movements and the distribution of consumption", Journal of Political Economy 104:1227-1262. Attanasio, O.E, and EK. Goldberg (1997), "On the relevance of borrowing restrictions. Evidence from car loans in the US", mimeograph (University College London). Attanasio, O.E, and H.W Hoynes (1995), "Differential mortality and wealth accumulation", Working Paper No. 5126 (NBER); Journal of Human Resources, forthcoming. Attanasio, O.E, and T.E. MaCurdy (1997), "Interactions in household labor supply and their implications for the impact of EITC", mimeograph (Stanford University). Attanasio, O.E, and G. Weber (1989), "Intertemporal substitution, risk aversion and the Euler equation for consumption", Economic Journal 99(Suppl.):59-73. Attanasio, O.E, and G. Weber (1993), "Consumption growth, the interest rate and aggregation", Review of Economics Studies 60:631-649. Attanasio, O.E, and G. Weber (1994), "The UK consumption boom of the late 1980s: aggregate implications of microeconomic evidence", Economic Journal 104:1269 1302. Attanasio, O.P., and G. Weber (1995), "Is consumption growth consistent with intertemporal optimization? Evidence from the consumer expenditure survey", Journal of Political Economy 103:1121-1157. Attanasio, O.P., J. Banks, C. Meghir and G. Weber (1996), "Humps and bumps in lifetime consumption", Working Paper No. 5350 (NBER); Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, forthcoming. Banks, J., and EG. Johnson, eds (1997), How Reliable is the Family Expenditure Survey? Trends in Income and Expenditures over Time (The Institute for Fiscal Studies, London). Banks, J., R. Blundell and L Preston (1994), "Life-cycle expenditure allocations and the consumption cost of children", European Economic Review 38:1234-1278. Banks, J., R. Blundell and A. Brugiavini (1997), "Risk pooling and consumption growth", mimeograph (University College London). Banks, J., R. Bhmdell and S. Tanner (1998), "Is there a retirement saving puzzle?", American Economic Review, forthcoming. Bean, C.R. (1986), "The estimation of 'surprise' models and the 'surprise' consumption function", Review of Economics Studies 53:497-516. Beaulieu, J.J. (1992), "Aggregate movements in durable goods with fixed costs of adjustment", mimeograph (MIT). Beaulieu, J.J. (1993), "Optimal durable and non-durable consumption with transaction costs", Federal Reserve Board Washington, Finance and Economics Discussion Series, 93-12. Bernanke, B.S. (1984), "Permanent income, liquidity, and expenditure on automobiles: evidence from panel data", Quarterly Journal of Economics 99:587-614. Bernanke, B.S. (1985), "Adjustment costs, durables, and aggregate consumption", Journal of Monetary Economics 15:41 68. Bertola, G., and R.J. Caballero (1990), "Kinked adjustment costs and aggregate dynamics", in:
Ch. 11:
Consumption
807
O.J. Blanchard and S. Fischer, eds., NBER Macroeconomics Annual (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) 237-288. Blinder, A., and A. Deaton (1985), "The time-series consumption revisited", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1985:465321. Blundell, R., and I. Preston (1998), "Consumption inequality and income uncertainty", Quarterly Journal of Economics 103:603-640. Blundell, R., and T. Stoker (1999), "Consumption and the timing of income risk", European Economic Review 43(3):475-508. Blundell, R., C. Meghir and E Neves (1993a), "Labor Supply and lntertemporal Substitution", Journal of Econometrics 59:137 160. Blundell, R., E Pashardes and G. Weber (1993b), "What do we learn about consumer demand patterns from micro data?", American Economic Review 83:570-597. Blundell, R., M. Browning and C. Meghir (1994), "Consumer demand and the lifetime allocation of consumption", Review of Economics Studies 61:57-80. Browning, M. (1987), "Eating, drinking, smoking, and testing the lifecycle hypothesis", Quarterly Journal of Economics 102:329-345. Browning, M. (1991), "A simple nonadditive preference structure for models of household behavior over time", Journal of Political Economy 99:607-637. Browning, M., and T. Crossley (1997), "Socks and stocks", mimeograph (McMaster University). Browning, M., and A. Lusardi (1996), "Household saving: micro theories and micro facts", Journal of Economic Literature 34:17921855. Browning, M., and C. Meghir (1991), "The effect of male and female labour supply on commodity demands", Econometrica 59:925-951. Browning, M., A. Deaton and M. Irish (1985), "A profitable approach to labor supply and commodity demand over the life cycle", Econometrica 53:503-544. Brugiavini, A., and G. Weber (1994), "Durable and non durable consumption: evidence from Italian household data", in: A. Ando, L. Guiso and I. Visco, eds., Saving and the Accumulation of Wealth (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) 305-329. Caballero, R.J. (1990a), "Consumption puzzles and precautionary savings", Journal of Monetary Economics 25:113-136. Caballero, R.J. (1990b), "Expenditure on durable goods: a case for slow adjustment", Quarterly Journal of Economics 105:727-743. Caballero, R.J. (1991), "Earnings uncertainty and aggregate wealth accumulation", American Economic Review 81:859-871. Caballero, R.J. (1993), "Durable goods: an explanation for their slow adjustment", Journal of Political Economy, 101:351-384. Caballero, R.J., and E. Engel (1991), "Dynamic (S, s) economies", Econometrica 59:1659-1686. Campbell, J.Y. (1987), "Does saving anticipate declining labor income? An alternative test of the permanent income hypothesis", Econometrica 55:1249-1273. Campbell, J.Y., and A.S. Deaton (1989), "Why is consumption so smooth?", Review of Economic Studies 56:357074. Campbell, J.Y., and N.G. Mankiw (1989), "Consumption, income and interest rates: reinterpreting the time series evidence", in: O.J. Blanchard and S. Fischer, eds., NBER Macroeconomies Annual 1989 (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) 185-216. Campbell, J.Y., and N.G. Mankiw (1991), "The response of consumption to income: a cross-country investigation", European Economic Review 35:715-721. Caplin, A.S. (1985), "The variability of aggregate demand with (S, s) inventory policies", Econometrica 53:1395-1409. Caplin, A.S., and D. Spulber (1987), "Menu costs and the neutrality of money", Quarterly Journal of Economics 102:703-726.
808
O.P. Attanasio
Carroll, C.D. (1994), "How does future income affect current consumption?", Quarterly Journal of Economics 109:111-147. Carroll, C.D. (1997a), "Buffer-stock saving and the life cycle/permanent income hypothesis", Quarterly Journal of Economics 112:1-55. Carroll, C.D. (1997b), "Death to the log-linearised Euler equation", mimeograph (Johns Hopkins University). Carroll, C.D., and M. Kimball (1996), "On the concavity of the consumption function", Econometrica 64:981-992. Carroll, C.D., and L.H. Summers (1991), "Consumption growth parallels income growth: some new evidence", in: B.D. Bernheim and J.B. Shoven, eds., National Saving and Economic Performance (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) 305-343. Carroll, C.D., J.C. Fuhrer and D.W. Wilcox (1994), "Does consumer sentiment forecast household spending? If so why?", American Economic Review 84:1397 1408. Chah, E.Y., V.A. Ramey and R.M. Starr (1995), "Liquidity constraints and intertemporal consumer optimization: theory and evidence from durable goods", Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 27:272-287. Chamberlain, G. (1984), "Panel data", in: Z. Griliches and M.D. Intriligator, eds., Handbook of Econometrics, vol. 2 (North-Holland, Amsterdam) 1247-1318. Christiano, L.J., and M. Eichenbaum (1990), "Unit roots in real GNP: do we know and do we care?", Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 32:7-61. Cochrane, J.H. (1991), "A simple test of consumption insurance", Journal of Political Economy 99: 957-976. Constantinides, G.M. (1990), "Habit formation: a resolution of the equity premium puzzle", Journal of Political Economy 98:519-543. Constantinides, G.M., and D. Duffle (1996), "Asset pricing with heterogeneous consumers", Journal of Political Economy 104:219-240. Cutler, D.M., and L.E Katz (1991), "Macroeconomic performance and the disadvantaged", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1991(1): 1-74. Davidson, J., D. Hendry, E Srba and S. Yeo (1978), "Econometric modelling of the aggregate time-series relationship between consumers' expenditure and income in the UK", Economic Journal 88:661-692. Davies, J.B. (1981), "Uncertain lifetime, consumption, and dissaving in retirement", Journal of Political Economy 89:561-577. Deaton, A. (1985), "Panel data from time series of cross sections", Journal of Econometrics 30:109-126. Deaton, A. (1991), "Saving and liquidity constraints", Eeonometrica 59:1221-1248. Deaton, A. (1992), Understanding Consumption (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Deaton, A., and J. Muellbauer (1980), Economics and Consumer Behavior (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Deaton, A., and C. Paxson (1994), "Intertemporal choice and inequality", Journal of Political Economy 102:437-467. Diamond, P. (1967), "The role of a stock market in a general equilibrium model with technological uncertainty", American Economic Review 57:759-776. Dreze, J., and E Modigliani (1972), "Consumption decisions under uncercainty", Journal of Economics Theory 5:308-335. Dunn, K.B., and K.J. Singleton (1986), "Modeling the term structure of interest rates under non-separable utility and durability of goods", Journal of Financial Economics 17:27-55. Dynan, K.E. (1993), "How prudent are consumers?", Journal of Political Economy 101:1104~1113. Eberly, J.C. (1994), "Adjustment of counsumers' durables stocks: evidence from automobile purchases", Journal of Political Economy 102:403-436. Eichenbaum, M., and L.E Hansen (1988), "A time series analysis of representative agent models of consumption and leisure under uncertainty", Quarterly Journal of Economics 103:51-78.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
809
Eichenbaum, M., and L.E Hansen (1990), "Estimating models with intertemporal substitution using aggregate time series data", Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 8:53-69. Epstein, L.G., and S.E. Zin (1989), "Substitution, risk aversion, and the temporal behavior of consumption and asset returns: a theoretical framework", Econometrica 57:937-969. Epstein, L.G., and S.E. Zin (1991), "Substitution, risk aversion, and the temporal behavior of consumption and asset returns: an empirical analysis", Journal of Political Economy 99:263-286. Flavin, M. (1981), "The adjustment of consumption to changing expectations about future income", Journal of Political Economy 89:974-1009. Flemming, J.S. (1973), "The consumption function when capital markets are imperfect. The permanent income hypothesis reconsidered", Oxford Economic Papers 25:160-172. Friedman, M. (1957), A Theory of the Consumption Function (Princeton University Press, Princeton, N J). Garcia, R., A. Lusardi and S. Ng (1997), "Excess sensitivity and asymmetries in consumption", Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, forthcoming. Ghez, G., and G.S. Beeker (1975), The Allocation of Time and Goods over the Life Cycle (NBER/ Columbia University Press, New York). Gokhale, J., L.J. Kotlikoff and J. Sabelhaus (1996), "Understanding the postwar decline in U.S. saving: a cohort analysis", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1996(1):315-390. Goodfriend, M. (1992), "Information aggregation bias", American Economic Review 82:508-5 l 9. Goodman, A., R Johnson and S. Webb (1997), Inequality in the UK (IFS, London). Gorman, W.M. (1959), "Separable utility and aggregation", Econometrica 27:469-481. Gorman, W.M. (1967), "Tastes, habits and choices", International Economic Review 8:218522. Greenspan, A., and D. Cohen (1996), "Motor vehicle stocks, scrappage and sales", Federal Reserve Board Finance and Economics Discussion Paper, No. 96-40. Grossman, S.J., and G. Laroque (1990), "Asset pricing and optimal portfolio choice in the presence of illiquid durable consumption goods", Econometrica 58:25-51. Guiso, L., T. Jappelli and D. Terlizzese (1992), "Earnings uncertainty and precautionary savings", Journal of Monetary Economics 30:307-337. Guiso, L., T. Jappelli and D. Terlizzese (1996), "Income risk, borrowing constraints and portfolio choice", American Economic Review 86:158-372. Hall, R.E. (1978), "The stochastic implications of the life cycle-permanent income hypothesis: theory and evidence", Journal of Political Economy 86:971-987. Hall, R.E. (1988), "Intertemporal substitution in consumption", Journal of Political Economy 96:339-357. Hall, R.E., and ES. Mishkin (1982), "The sensitivity of consumption to transitory income: estimate from panel data on households", Econometrica 50:461-481. Hansen, L.E, and K.J. Singleton (1982), "Generalized instrumental variables estimation of nonlinear rational expectation models", Econometrica 50:1269-1286. Hansen, L.P., and K.J. Singleton (1983), "Stochastic consumption, risk aversion and the temporal behavior of asset returns", Journal of Political Economy 91:249-265. Hayashi, E (1985a), "The effects of liquidity constraints on consumption: a cross section analysis", Quarterly Journal of Economics 100:183-206. Hayashi, E (1985b), "The permanent income hypothesis and consumption durability: analysis based on Japanese panel data", Quarterly Journal of Economics 100:1083-1116. Hayashi, E (1987), "Tests for liquidity constraints: a critical survey and some new observations", in: T.E Bewley, ed., Advances in Econometrics: Fifth World Congress, vol. Ii, 91-120. Hayashi, E (1996), "A review of empirical studies of household saving", mimeograph (Columbia University). Hayashi, E, and C.A. Sims (1983), "Nearly efficient estimation of time series models with predetermined but not exogenous instruments", Econometrica 51:783-792.
810
O.P. Attanasio
Hayashi, E, J. Altonji and L. Kotlikoff (1996), "Risk-sharing between and within families", Econometrica 64:261~94. Heaton, J. (1993), "The interaction between time-nonseparable preferences and time aggregation", Econometrica 61:353-386. Heaton, J. (1995), "An empirical investigation of asset pricing with temporally dependent preferences", Econometrica 63:681 718. Heckman, J.J. (1974), "Life-cycle consumption and labour supply: an exploration of the relationship between income and consumption over the life cycle", American Economic Review 64:188-194. Heckman, J.J., and R. Robb (1987), "Using longitudinal data to estimate age period and cohort effects in earnings equations", in: W.M. Mason and S.E. Fienberg, eds., Cohort Analysis in Social Research (Springer, Berlin). Hotz, V.J., EE. Kydland and G.J. Sedlacek (1988), "Intertemporal preferences and labor supply", Econometrica 56:335-360. Houthakker, H.S., and L.D. Taylor (1970), Consumer Demand in the United States: Analyses and Projections, 2rid edition (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA). Hubbard, R.G., J.S. Skinner and S.P. Zeldes (1994), "The importance of precautionary motives in explaining individual and aggregate saving", Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 40:59-125. Hubbard, R.G., J.S. Skinner and S.P. Zeldes (1995), "Precautionary saving and social insurance", Journal of Political Economy 103:360-399. Hurd, M.D. (1989), "Mortality risk and bequests", Econometrica 57:779-813. Imrohoroglu, A. (1989), "Cost of business cycle with indivisibilities and liquidity constraints", Journal of Political Economy 100:118-142. Jappelli, T. (1990), "Who is credit constrained in the US economy?", Quarterly Journal of Economics 105:219-234. Jappelli, T., and E Modigliani (1997), "Is the age-saving profile consistent with the life cycle hypothesis?", mimeograph (MIT). Jappelli, T., and M. Pagano (1994), "Saving, growth and liquidity constraints", Quarterly Journal of Economics 109:83-110. Jappelli, T., J.-S. Pischke and N. Souleles (1997), "Testing for liquidity constraints using complementary data sources", Review of Economics and Statistics, forthcoming. Juster, ET., and R.P. Shay (1964), "Consumer sensitivity to finance rates: an empirical and analytical investigation", NBER Occasional Paper No. 88. Keane, M.P., and D. Rankle (1992), "On the estimation of panel-data models with serial correlation when instruments are not strictly exogenous", Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 10:1 9. Kennan, J. (1988), "An econometric analysis of fluctuations in aggregate labor supply and demand", Econometrica 56:317-334. Kimball, M.S. (1990), "Precautionary saving in the small and in the large", Econometrica 58:53-73. Kotlikoff, L.J. (1988), "Intergenerational transfers and savings", Journal of Economic Perspectives 2:41-58. Kotlikoff, L.J., and L.H. Summers (1981), "The role of intergenerational transfers in aggregate capital accumulation", Journal of Political Economy 89:706-732. Lam, P.S. (1991), "Permanent income, liquidity and adjustment of automobile stocks: evidence from panel data", Quarterly Journal of Economics 106:203-230. Lucas Jr, R.E. (1987), Models of Business Cycles (Blackwell, New York). Ludvigson, S. (1997), "Consumption and credit: a model of time-varying liquidity constraints", mimeograph (Federal Reserve Bank of New York). Ludvigson, S., and C. Paxson (1997), "Approximation bias in linearized Euler equations", mimeograph (Princeton University). Lusardi, A. (1996), "Permanent income, current income and consumption: evidence from two panel data sets", Journal of Business Economics and Statistics 14:81-90.
Ch. 11:
Consumption
811
Mace, B.J. (1991), "Full insurance in the presence of aggregate uncertainty", Journal of Political Economy 99:928-956. MaCurdy, T.E. (1981), "An intertemporal model of portfolio choice and human capital accumulation under uncertainty with extensions incorporating taxes, consumer durables, imperfections in capital markets and non separable preferences", Working Paper E-81-18 (Hoover Institution). MaCurdy, T.E. (1983), "A simple scheme for estimating an intertemporal model of labor supply and consumption in the presence of taxes and uncertainty", International Economic Review 24:265-289. MaCurdy, T.E., and T.A. Mroz (1989), "Measuring macroeconomic shifts in wages from cohort specifications", mimeograph (Stanford University). Manldw, N.G. (1982), "Hall's consumption hypothesis and durable goods", Journal of Monetary Economics 10:417-425. Mankiw, N.G., and S.P. Zeldes (1994), "The consumption of stock owners and the consumption of non stock owners", Journal of Financial Economics. Manldw, N.G., J.J. Rotemberg and L.H. Summers (1985), "Intertemporal substitution in macroeconomics", Quarterly Journal of Economics 100:225-253. Meghir, C., and G. Weber (1996), "Intertemporal non-separability or borrowing restrictions? A disaggregated analysis using a U.S. consumption panel", Econometrica 64:1151 1181. Modigliani, E (1988), "The role of international transfers and life cycle saving in the accumulation of wealth", Journal of Economic Perspectives 2:15-40. Modigliani, E, and A. Ando (1963), "The life cycle hypothesis of saving: aggregate implications and tests", American Economic Review 53:55-84. Modigliani, E, and R. Brumberg (1954), "Utility analysis and the consumption function: an interpretation of cross-section data", in: K.K. Kufihara, ed., Post-Keynesian Economics (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ) 128-197. Moffitt, R. (1993), "Identification and estimation of dynamic models with a time series of repeated cross-sections", Journal of Econometrics 59:99-124. Novales, A. (1990), "Solving nonlinear rational expectations models: a stochastic equilibrium model of interest rates", Econometrica 58:93-111. O'Brien, A.M., and C.B. Hawley (1986), "The labor force participation behavior of married women under conditions of constraints on borrowing", Journal of Human Resources 21:267-278. Paulin, G., M. Boyle, R. Branch and R. Cage (1990), "Comparison of 1987-1988 CE integrated survey and PCE annual estimates", mimeograph (BLS). Phelan, C., and R.M. Townsend (1991), "Computing multi-period information constrained optima", Review of Economic Studies 58:853-881. Pischke, J.-S. (1995), "Individual income, incomplete information, and aggregate consumption", Econometrica 63(4, July):805-840. Pissarides, C.A. (1978), "Liquidity considerations in the theory of consumption", Quarterly Journal of Economics 92:279-296. Pollak, R.A. (1970), "Habit formation and dynamic demand functions", Journal of Political Economy, 78:745-763. Runlde, D.E. (1991), "Liquidity constraints and the pernaanent-income hypothesis: evidence from panel data", Journal of Monetary Economics 27:73-98. Sargent, T.J. (1978), "Rational expectations, econometric exogeneity and consumption", Journal of Political Economy 86:673-700. Seslnick, D. (1992), "Aggregate consumption and saving in the postwar United States", Review of Economics and Statistics 585-597. Seslnick, D. (1994), "Are our data relevant to the theory? The case of aggregate consumption", mimeograph (Rice University). Shea, J. (1995), "Union contracts and the life-cycle/permanent- income hypothesis", American Economic Review 85:186-200.
812
O.P. Attanasio
Skinner, J.S. (1988), "Risky income. Life cycle consumption and precautionary savings", Journal of Monetary Economics 22:237-255. Spynnewin, E (1981), "Rational habit formation", European Economic Review 15:91-109. Thurow, L. (1969), "The optimum lifetime distribution of consumption expenditures", American Economic Review 59:371-396. Tobin, J., and W.C. Dolde (1971), "Wealth, liquidity and consumption", Reserve Bank of Boston, Monetary Conference Series No. 5. Townsend, R.M. (1994), "Risk and insurance in village India", Econometrica 62:539-592. Weber, G. (1993), "Earnings related borrowing restrictions: empirical evidence from a pseudo panel for the UK", Annales d'Economie et de Statistique 29:157-173. Wilson, R. (1968), "The theory of syndicates", Econometrica 36:119-132. Zeldes, S.P. (1989a), "Consumption and liquidity constraints: an empirical analysis", Journal of Political Economy 97:305-346. Zeldes, S.E (1989b), "Optimal consumption with stochastic income", Quarterly Journal of Economics 104:275-298.
Chapter 12
AGGREGATE INVESTMENT
*
RICARDO J. CABALLERO MIT and NBER
Contents Abstract Keywords 1. Introduction 2. Basic investment t h e o r y and findings 2.1. Pre 1990s: Dismay 2.2. "Econometrics": Cost of capital and q matter 2.2.1. Long-run 2.2.2. Short-run 3. L u m p y and irreversible investment 3.1. Plant/firm level 3.1.1. Microeconomic adjustment: characterization 3.1.2. "Representative" problem 3.1.3. A detour: q-theory and infrequent investment 3.1.3.1. On the fragility of marginal q 3.1.3.2. When does q-theory work? 3.1.3.3. Taking stock 3.1.4. Another detour: Several misconceptions about irreversible investment 3.1.5. Adjustment hazard 3.2. Aggregation 3.3. Empirical evidence . . . . . 3.3.1. Microeconnmic data 3.3.2. Aggregate data 3.3.3. Pent-up demand 3.4. Equilibrium 4.
814 814 815 816 816 818 820 821 822 822 823 824 828 828 830 832 832 835 837 838 838 839 841 842
Entry, exit and scrapping
844
4.1. Competitive entry and irreversibility 4.2. Technological heterogeneity and scrapping
844 847
* I am grateful to Andrew Abel, Steve Bergantino, Olivier Blanchard, Jason Cummins, Esther Duffio, Eduardo Engel, Austan Goolsbee, Luigi Guiso, Kevin Hassett, Glenn Hubbard, John Leahy, Kenneth West, and Michael Woodford for many useful comments. I thank the NSF for financial support. Handbook of Macroeconomics, Volume 1, Edited by JB. Taylor and M. WoodJbrd~ © 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
813
814 5. Inefficient investment 5.1. Informationalproblems 5.2. Specificityand opportunism 5.2.1. Genericimplications 5.2.2. Credit constraints 6. Conclusion and outlook References
R.J. Caballero 848 849 851 854 856 857 858
Abstract
The 1990s have witnessed a revival in economists' interest and hope of explaining aggregate and microeconomic investment behavior. New theories, better econometric procedures, and more detailed panel data sets are behind this movement. Much of the progress has occurred at the level of microeconomic theories and evidence; however, progress in aggregation and general equilibrium aspects of the investment problem also has been significant. The concept of sunk costs is at the center of modern theories. The implications of these costs for investment go well beyond the neoclassical response to the irreversible-technological friction they represent, for they can also lead to firstorder inefficiencies when interacting with informational and contractual problems.
Keywords sunk costs, irreversible investment, (S, s) models, adjustment hazard, aggregation, non-linearities, private information, incomplete contracts, pent-up investment
JEL classification: E22, D21, D23, E32
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
815
1. Introduction
Aggregate investment is an important topic. Cotmtries and firms are often judged by their performance along this dimension, since investment is viewed as providing hope for future prosperity. It is not surprising, therefore, that much has been written about investment. It is even less surprising that many surveys, and surveys of surveys, already exist ~. Rather than surveying the surveys of surveys, as one would expect from a handbook chapter, I have chosen to focus most of my discussion on that which is relatively new. The cost of this, of course, is that most of the theories I will discuss have not yet passed the test of time and are often only half the distance toward full development. Most, but not all, of the subjects I plan to discuss relate directly to investment in equipment and structures. Investing means trading the present for the future; as is the case, for example, when a firm purchases equipment, builds structures, trains its workers, restructures production, spends resources on R&D, hoards labor during a recession; or when a worker leaves a job to search for another one, invests in human capital; or when a country undergoes a structural adjustment, a trade liberalization or a fiscal reform. The more theoretical sections of this survey apply to most of these examples. Further, except for specific empirical results, a large part of the discussion about equipment and structures also applies to other forms of investment. The style of this review article is mostly empirical in early sections and mostly theoretical in later ones. This ordering is highly correlated with the chronology of research on investment. It follows that I am implicitly advocating for more empirical work on the newest theories. The layout of the chapter is as follows. Section 2 is rather traditional in content. It describes the basic investment theory and findings, taking the view that the pre 1990s empirical literature was in disarray with respect to finding a role for the cost of capital in investment equations. During the 1990s, however, we have learned from long run relationships and "natural experiments" that the cost of capital does indeed have significant effects on investment, although it is probably not the most important explanatory variable. Neither, I should add, is measured q. Section 3 describes what has been well known but largely ignored until recently: that microeconomic investment is lumpy and mostly sunk. It turns out that changes in the degree of coordination of lumpy actions play an important role in shaping the dynamic behavior of aggregate investment. The old concept of pent-up demand is back. This section contains a more detailed description of models and techniques than the others. It also attempts to clarify several misconceptions about the implications of these models. Section 4 is about equilibrium interactions and scrapping. It describes the consequences of free entry and different assumptions about the elasticity of the supply 1 See, for example, Chirinko (1993), Hassett and Hubbard (1996b), for excellent surveys of traditional investment equations.
816
R.J. Caballero
of capita~'~.for equilibrium investment anti, scrapping, :Vimage and putty-clay models are briefly mentioned as a natural environment in which to address the economic obsolescence issue. This concept is particularly relevant for understanding capital accumulation during episodes of rapid growth and after substantial shocks to the price of intermediate inputs. Section 5 discusses inefficient investment. The first part of the section deals with informational problems. Discontinuous action due to irreversibility and fixed costs are compounded by the presence of private information and create a powerful drag on investment. Inaction is a natural information trap, small information flows lead naturally to further inaction, and the feedback process goes on. Aggregate investment will appear too sluggish given the ex-post information of an econometrician, and it will probably be too slow in responding to new conditions relative to first and second best scenarios. The second part of this section describes how the sunk nature of investment, when combined with contractual incompleteness, can lead to underinvestment and, through general equilibrium, to a series of distortions in the scrapping margin and in the response of investment to aggregate shocks. Financial constraints are discussed within this context. The concept of rationing, the effects of underinvestment on complementary factors (and vice versa) and the relation between excessive capital/tabor substitution and investment are also part of this section. The issue of property rights and investment also fits very naturally here. Section 6 concludes.
2. Basic investment theory and findings 2.1. Pre 1990s: Dismay
Since very early on, economists have attempted to explain investment behavior using both scale and relative price variables, and since very early on, the former have been more successful than the latter. One of the first "theories" of investment was the accelerator model [Clark (1917)]. Scarcely a theory, the accelerator model is derived by inverting a simple fixed proportion production function and taking first differences. Unable to account for the serial correlation of investment beyond that o f output growth, this model was soon transformed into the flexible accelerator model [Clark (1944), Koyck (1954)]: n
I, = Z/3~AKT-r'
(2.1)
"~-0
where I denotes investment, the/3r's are distributed lag parameters, and K* is the desired, as opposed to actual, level of capital. In the simple fixed proportions world, K* can be written as a linear function of the output level, Y: K* = a Y
where a is a parameter.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
817
The absence of prices (the cost o f capital, in particular) from the right-hand side of the flexible accelerator equation has earned it disrespect despite its empirical success. Jorgenson's (1963) neoclassical theory o f investment intended to remedy this situation. Starting from the optimization problem o f a perfectly competitive firm facing no adjustment costs, myopic expectations, and constant returns Cobb-Douglas technology, Jorgenson obtained the standard static first-order condition:
K = aY/Ck, where Ck stands for the cost of capital and a is now the share o f capital in a simple Cobb-Douglas production function. As with the accelerator model, this model was unable to account for the serial correlation o f investment, and so gave way to the flexible neoclassical model o f Hall and Jorgenson (1967), where
K* = aY/Ck,
(2.2)
was now used in Equation (2.1). Soon it was shown, however, that by constraining the coefficient o f the cost o f capital to be the same as the coefficient of out-put, this model imposed rather than found a role for the cost o f capital in the investment function. Eisner (1969) estimated a modified Hall and Jorgenson model which allowed for different coefficients on output and the cost o f capital and found no independent role for the cost o f capital. The cost o f capital's rise and fall from grace was not an unknown experience, however. Several decades before, authors such as Tinbergen (1939) and Meyer and Kuh (1957) had pointed out the dominance o f liquidity variables over interest rates for short run investment 2. None o f these are full theories of investment, rather they are theories conditional on the level o f output 3. The famous q-theory o f Tobin (1969) and Brainard and Tobin (1968) went one step further. They argued that investment should be an increasing function o f the ratio o f the value of the firm to the cost o f purchasing the firm's equipment and structures in their respective markets. This ratio, known as average q4, summarizes most information about future actions and shocks that are of relevance for investment 5. Indeed, average q would later be shown to be a sufficient statistic for investment in a wide variety o f scenarios. Thus, the new canonical investment equation became I = yq, where • is a strictly positive parameter. 2 See Chirinko (1993) for a more thorough review of the history of the debate over the role of the cost of capital, profits and output in investment decisions. 3 Things are even worse for the basic frictionless neoclassical model; it is ill defined as a full model because firm level output is not determined under constant reta.trns and perfect competition. 4 It is also often referred to as Tobin's q. 5 This includes the optimal path of output.
818
R.J. Caballero
The elegant theoretical contributions o f Abel (1979) and Hayashi (1982) connected the existing theories and partial theories. They showed that the neoclassical model with convex adjustment costs yields a q-model. This q, known as marginal q, should be interpreted as the marginal value o f an installed unit o f capital, which corresponds to the shadow value o f a trait o f capital in the firm's optimization problem. Further, Hayashi showed that (for price-taking firms) when the production function and adjustment cost function are linearly homogeneous in capital and labor, marginal and average q are equal. This is an important result from an empirical standpoint because marginal q is unobservable to the econometrician whereas average q is, in principle, observable to the econometrician 6. Soon, however, the q-model, along with expanded and ad-hoc "flexible-q" models (i.e. with additional lags o f q on the right-hand side), joined models based on the cost o f capital in their lack o f empirical success. Scale variables such as cash-flows always seemed to matter more in investment equations than q which, in principle, should have been a sufficient statistic 7. Figure 2.1, which reproduces figures 1 and 3 o f Hassett and Hubbard (1996b), helps us understand the statistical reasons for the problem. The bottom line is clear: In aggregate US data (which is probably representative o f many other data sets for this purpose) the unconditional correlation between cost o f capital and investment is low, and so is that between average q and investment. On the other hand, cash flows and sales's growth closely track aggregate investment. The 1980s discontent with respect to investment equations is probably well captured in Blanchard's (1986) discussion o f Shapiro's (1986) investment paper at Brookings: "... it is well known that to get the user cost to appear at all in the investment equation, one has to display more than the usual amount of econometric ingenuity, resorting most of the time to choosing a specification that simply forces the effect to be there ..." [my emphasis] Today, the first emphasized statement still holds, but the second one probably does not. This takes me to the next subsection. 2.2. "Econometrics": Cost o f capital a n d q matter
Econometric "ingenuity" eventually pays off, although this often means isolating that part o f the relationship which conforms with the theory, rather than explaining a 6 I have mixed feelings about this equivalence result, however. Not about its theoretical derivation, which is elegant and useful; rather about its abuse in empirical work. Too often, it is used to justify substituting average for marginal q on the right-hand side of investment equations, even though the assumptions required for the equivalence between the two are not nearly satisfied in the industry or firms studied (e.g. Compustat). This does not mean that average q should not be used, but it says that we should not pretend that the foundation for its use is beyond the basic intuition provided by Tobin (1969), and that the additional properties that hold for marginal q are to be expected from average q (e.g. sufficiency). 7 Fazzari et al. (1988) started a large literature documenting the role of these variables, even after conditioning for average q. I will return to the interpretation of these regressions later in the survey.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment o
o
819
o
o -
!
o
0 o
o
cq
1
i
"/"
:'.::::::5 :
~:~ --
.~- ~ ~
ixl
:+:+:.:.:.:.~ . . . . ........................
~
•.:.:.:::.:::::~ .~:::::::::::::::::::::::::::, k
e
~
]~.
v, o
. ..
:
!~!!!iiii:: ;
i!: ~
"~! i :-:+:+ ~ ' :~: : : : :
::i ~
-
°
~ o
I g :i
,'~
"
e~
u
~
o
820
R.J Caballero
substantial fraction of the movements of the left-hand side variable, or even relating a significant fraction of the volatility of the right-hand side variables to that of the left-hand side variable. In my view, this is the type of payoff obtained from the recent incarnations of the "traditional" line. Still, it is progress. Going from less to more ambitious, there are two generic developments I wish to discuss. First, ignoring high and medium frequency variations, we have come to the realization that the low frequency aspects of the data are not inconsistent with theories that assign an important role to the cost o f capital in determining the rate of capital accumulation. Second, there are distinctive episodes during which changes in the cost of capital are sufficiently dramatic that it becomes possible to demonstrate the importance of the cost of capital at higher frequencies as well. Other recent developments within the traditional line include the use of Euler equation procedures. In my view, and unlike the case in basic finance and consumption applications, these procedures are a form of morphine rather than a remedy: their lack of statistical power allows us to sometimes not see the problem. Since my goal is to discuss progress, I will skip results obtained with these procedures s. 2.2.1. L o n g - r u n
Many of the problems with investment equations have to do with the presence of complex and not well understood dynamic issues (more on this in the next sections). From early on, researchers have found it useful to think about investment in two steps: first, derive some simple expression for a "target" stock of capital, which I have called K* here; and second, model dynamics as a, possibly complex, function of contemporaneous and lagged changes in K*. It seems sensible, therefore, to start by asking whether the first step resembles what we expect before going into the difficult issues of timing. Taking logs on each side of Equation (2.2), disregarding constants, and relaxing the unit elasticity constraint on the cost of capital, yields k* - y
= yck,
(2.3)
where lower case letters denote logarithms and y is the parameter of interest. This expression cannot be estimated, of course, because k* is not observed. There is a simple argument based on cointegration, or a close small sample "cousin," which allows us to get around this observability problem, however. The whole purpose of deriving k* is to then model k as trying to keep pace with it. Thus, differences between these two variables should only be transitory (up to constants). I f k* and k are
See Oliner, Rudebusch and Sichel (1995) for a damaging evaluation of the statistical properties of these procedures.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
821
sufficiently volatile (ideally with unit roots, in large samples), then we can "ignore" the discrepancy between these two variables in estimating y. Let k = k* + e, with c a stationary residual that captures transitory discrepancies between the two variables due to adjustment costs. Substituting this expression into Equation (2.3) yields an equation that can be estimated: k - y = yck + c.
(2.4)
Estimating this equation by OLS (the simplest o f the cointegration procedures) yields, for aggregate US data, an estimate o f y o f -0.4; significantly different from zero 9. We can do better, however. In any small sample, the cointegration argument will not take its full bite, and the estimates o f ~/will be affected by the correlation between regressors and e. Caballero (1994a) argues that this is particularly serious and systematic in models with slow adjustment (e.g. due to adjustment costs). The intuition behind this idea is simple. A partial adjustment mechanism implies that, in any finite sample, the variance o f K/Y ought to be less than the variance o f K * / Y , which means the lefthand side o f Equation (2.4) ought to be less volatile than the right-hand side of Equation (2.3), or yck lo. However, by the normal equations o f OLS, the estimated counterparts o f yck and e on the right-hand side o f Equation (2.4) must be orthogonal, so that the variance o f k - y is greater than the variance o f )ck, which is equal to the variance o f the estimated £'* - y . Since this inequality is in contradiction with what is implied by adjustment cost mechanisms, we conclude that the estimate o f y is biased toward zero. Using Monte Carlo simulations, I showed in that paper that this bias can be substantial, and then proceeded to correct it using Stock and Watson's (1993) procedure. I obtained an estimate o f ~/close to minus one, very near the neoclassical benchmark 11. 2.2.2. Short-run
Demonstrating a relationship between capital accumulation and the cost of capital at higher frequencies has required two changes in approach: first, a change in emphasis from aggregate to microeconomic data; and second, the use of natural
9 This estimate of g was obtained using US quarterly NIPA data for the period 1957:1-1987:4. Capital corresponds to equipment capital and cost of capital is constructed as in Auerbach and Hassett (1992). l0 Note that if adjustment costs are non-convex it is possible, at the microeconomic level, and in a sufficiently short sample, to have these relative volatilities reversed. This is not an issue for the aggregate data results discussed here. See the next section for more on non-convex adjustment cost models. 11 Similar estimates were obtained by Bertola and Caballero (1994) and Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995) with different data sets.
822
R.J Caballero
experiments, such as periods of tax reform, which present the econometrician with more accurate measures of (often substantial) changes in the cost of capital and q. Measures of q, for example, are not only very noisy because of the substitution of average q for marginal q, but also because there may be substantial "non-fundamental" movements in the value of firms, making average q mismeasured as well. However, there are certain episodes (e.g., periods of tax reform) when the movements in q are likely to be large, in a predictable direction, and for the "right reasons". As with cointegration, during those episodes problems with the residual can be more or less disregarded. The movement from aggregate to microeconomic data, by itself, has not done much to improve affairs. Although microeconomic data has improved precision, coefficients on the cost of capital and q in investment equations have remained embarrassingly small. Combined with the use of natural experiments, however, emphasis on microeconomic data has had much higher payoffs. The work of Cummins, Hassett and Hubbard (1994, 1996a) is salient in this regard. They isolate periods with important tax reforms and find that the coefficient on q is much larger in those episodes. Most recently, using firm level data for 14 developed countries, they find that while using standard instrumental variable procedures yields coefficients on q which range from 0.03 to 0.1, when contemporaneous tax reforms are included among the instruments, the estimates jump to a range between 0.09 to 0.8, with median and mean not very far from 0.5. In the USA, for example, the estimate of the coefficient on q jumps from 0.048 to 0.6512 Although these empirical results represent significant progress, there is still plenty of work needed to retrace the steps back to the aggregate and we must not forget that a substantial component of the variation in aggregate and microeconomic investment remains unexplained. The next sections describe progress on both fronts.
3. Lumpy and irreversible investment Investment is a flow variable, and as such it is very sensitive to obstacles. Investment is the by-product of the process by which the capital stock catches up with its desired level; but there are many paths leading the former to the latter. In this section I begin discussing some of these obstacles, emphasizing those that have had prominence in the recent literature. 3.1. Plant~firm level
The most basic form of friction occurs at the level of microeconomic units, and goes under the general heading of adjustment costs.
12 See Caballero (1994b) for a discussion of their results, interpretations and procedures.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
823
3.1.1. Microeconomic adjustment: characterization
There are essentially three basic types o f adjustments observed at the establishment level: (a) ongoing frictionless flow (maintenance); (b) gradual adjustments (e.g. refinements and training dependent improvements); (c) major and infrequent adjustments 13 The structural literature o f the 1980s and before, based explicitly or implicitly on convex adjustment cost models (the quadratic adjustment cost model, in particular) dealt with (a) and (b). The implicit "hope" was that the smoothness brought about by aggregation would make disregarding the importance o f infrequent adjustments for individual units, unimportant for aggregate phenomena. Instead, the idea was to derive aggregate investment equations as coming from the solution to the optimization problem of a fictitious agent facing adjustment costs which only led to smooth adjustments o f type (a) and (b). Many authors disagreed with this strategy [e.g. Rothschild (1971)]; but for most the relative simplicity of the quadratic model was too enticing to resist. A combination of factors eventually led economists to revisit and reevaluate some o f the shortcuts which were in widespread use by the end o f the 1980S 14. First, there was frustration with the disappointing empirical results described above. Second, techniques which could handle models of lumpy investment became part of the modern economist's tool kit. And third, microeconomic data made the obvious even more apparent: microeconomic investment is extremely lumpy, and this lumpiness is unlikely to fully "wash out" at the aggregate level. The work o f Doms and Dunne (1993) was instrumental in stressing the last point. They documented investment patterns o f 12 000 plants in US manufacturing over the 17 year period, 1972-1989. Their findings are many, of which I have chosen to emphasize those that are most closely related to the purpose o f this survey. For each establishment, Doms and Dunne constructed a series o f the proportion o f the total equipment investment o f the establishment (over the 17-year period) made in each year. They found that on average the largest investment episode accounts for more than 25 percent o f the 17 year investment o f an establishment and that more than half o f the establishments exhibited capital growth close to 50 percent in a single year. They also note that the second largest investment spike often came next to the largest investment spike (right before or right after) suggesting that both spikes correspond to a single investment episode. 15 Combining the two primary spikes, they find that nearly
~3 Which may, in turn, have a time to build aspect. 14 Chronologies are never exact, of course. For example, Nickell had already discussed irreversible investment and many of its implications in 1978; but the mode did not move until much later. 15 All investment project may not be fully counted within one year since not all projects start on January 1, and certainly may take more than a few days to implement. One should not confuse "time to build" with the standard convex adjustment costs. Time to build is the optimal scheduling of a given lumpy project, while in the standard convex adjustment costs model the firm changes this project continuously and smoothly [see Caballero and Leahy (1996)].
R.J Caballero
824
40 percent of the sample investment of the median establishment probably corresponds to a single investment episode 16. Moreover, this is likely to be a lower bound on the lumpiness of investment since these numbers correspond to establishments that remained in the sample during the entire 17-year period. Adding entry and exit would undoubtedly make the evidence on microeconomic lumpiness even more apparent. As for evidence on the macroeconomic relevance of microeconomic lumpiness, Doms and Dunne offer several hints. First, using data on about 360 000 establishments for Census years 1977 and 1987, they document that about 18 percent of aggregate investment is accounted for by the top 100 projects. As a metric, only 6 percent of employment is in the top 100 employers, and less than 10 percent of production occurs in the top 100 producers. More importantly, they show that the time series correlation between aggregate investment and a Herfindahl index of microeconomic investments is very high (close to 0.45). They also constructed a series with the number of firms undergoing their primary investment spike during each year. They show that this measure, rather than the average size of these spikes, closely tracked aggregate investment 17. The subsections that follow describe models which are broadly consistent with these findings, and reviews structural evidence based on these models which lends further support to the view that microeconomic lumpiness is very important for aggregate investment dynamics.
3.1.2. "'Representative" problem There is by now a vast literature (and surveys of it) describing microeconomic models able to capture the essence of the lumpy and discontinuous adjustment highlighted by the evidence described above. Rather than giving a thorough presentation of the canonical model, I refer the interested reader to one of these surveys 18. Instead, I will only sketch the problem, mostly to characterize the nature of the solution and to develop notation which will prove useful later. Let actions and realizations of shocks evolve in discrete time, with time intervals, At. Having optimized over all inputs but capital during the period, a firm with stock of capital K and facing conditions 0, has a flow of profits net of rental cost of capital:
II(K, O)At = (KYO- rK)At
0 < ~ < 1,
(3.1)
where K is the firm's stock of capital; 0 is a profitability index that combines demand, productivity and wage shocks; r is the discount rate; and 7 represents the elasticity 16 Cooper, Haltiwanger and Power (1994) go one step further in characterizing infrequent lumpiness. Using a data set similar to that of Doms and Dtmne, they show that the probabilityof a firm experiencing a major investment spike is increasing in the time since the last major spike. This feature of the data is highly consistent with the implications of the models reviewed later in this section. 17 Where aggregate investmentcorrespondsto the investmentof all the establishmentsin their sample. 18 Dixit (1993) provides an excellent discussion of the basic problem and the mathematicaltechniques needed to solve it.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
825
o f gross profits with respect to capital. It is less than one as long as the firm exhibits some degree o f decreasing returns or market power, which ! assume to be the case. For convenience, capital does not depreciate. It will also facilitate things to assume that increments in the logarithm o f 0 are i.i.d., and that time and the sample paths of 0 are "ahnost" continuous (i.e. At is small and changes in the value of 0 over an interval o f time At are small). I make these assumptions so I can, informally, use all the convenience o f Ito's lemma and Brownian motions. I choose to depart from strict continuous time, on the other hand, because discrete time will allow me to present this section in a more ratified manner. As in the previous section, we can find an expression for the static optimum of the stock o f capital, or "desired" capital: I I-y
K* = argmaxxH(K, 0) =
.
(3.2)
It is apparent from this expression that K* inherits the stochastic properties of 0, so it also follows a geometric random walk. Moreover, the measure o f capital "imbalance": Z=
K K*
'
also inherits the geometric random walk process, for any given K. Substituting this expression into Equation (3.1) and using Equation (3.2) to solve for 0 yields
H(Z,K*) = 7r (ZY - 7Z) K*
0 < 7 < 1.
(3.3)
In order to generate infrequent actions, the cost of adjusting the stock o f capital must increase sharply around the point of no adjustment. A cost proportional to the size of adjustment is enough to do so. Lumpiness requires a little more, for there must be an advantage in bunching adjustment; increasing returns in the adjustment technology is the standard recipe, o f which a fixed cost is the simplest. Let C(rI, K*) denote the cost o f adjusting the capital stock by K ' t / :
C(rI, K . ) = { A K ~ e O } K .
(cf+c~rl
/ cf-Cprl
if if
t/>0, t/<0,
(3.4)
where the K* term ensures that the relative importance of adjustment costs remains unchanged over time 19. Figure 3.1 illustrates an example of C(., .)/K*.
19 This goal would also be accomplished by K, but K* yields slightly simpler mathematical expressions at a low cost in terms of substantive issues. Also, I have allowed proportional costs to differ with respect to upward and downward adjustments in order to talk later about the irreversible investment case; for this purpose, I could have done it equally well through asymmetric fixed costs. Allowing for both forms of asymmetries simultaneously is a trivial but uninteresting extension.
826
R.J. Caballero
\ J Cf
<
)rl
Fig. 3.1. Adjustment costs.
The problem of the firm can be characterized in terms of two functions of Z and K*: V(Z,K*) and ~'(Z, K*). The function V(Z,K*) represents the value of a firm with imbalance Z and desired capital K* if it does not adjust in this period, and V(Z,K*) is the value of the firm which can choose whether or not to adjust. Thus, v ( z , , I,:?) = rt(z,, I
(3.5)
~'(Zt,K[)=max {V(Zt,K[),m~x {V(Zt + rI,K[)-CQI, K[)} }.
(3.6)
and:
The nature of the solution of this problem is now intuitive. Given the function
V(Z, K*), Equation (3.6) provides most of what is needed to characterize the solution. First, since C is positive even for small adjustments, it is apparent that when Z is near that value for which V(Z,K*) is maximized, the first term on the right-hand side of Equation (3.6) is larger than the second term; that is, there is a range of inaction. Second, since both adjustment costs and the profit function are homogeneous of degree one with respect to K*, so are V and ~'. Thus, it is possible to fully characterize the solution in the space of imbalances, Z. Among other things, this implies that the range of inaction described before, is fixed in the space of Z. Let L denote the minimum value of Z for which there is no investment, and U the maximum value for which there is no disinvestment; thus the range of inaction is (L, U). Third, conditional on adjustment, changes must not only be large enough to justify incurring the fixed cost, but also the (invariant) target points must satisfy Vz(/) = Cp
(3.7)
and
Vz(u) = -Cp, where Vz is the derivative of
(3.8)
V with respect to Z, while 1 and u denote the target points from the left and right of the inaction range, respectively. These first-order
827
Ch. 12." AggregateInoestment "-.. ............."..... '...........
el
I ..../........
V ( z, K*) / K*
i" <
> L
1
u
U
Fig. 3.2. Value fimction. conditions are known as "smooth pasting conditions," and simply say that, conditional on adjustment taking place, it must cease when the value of an extra unit of investment (or disinvestment) is equal to the additional cost incurred by that action. There are two additional smooth pasting conditions:
Vz(L) = Cp
(3.9)
and v z ( u ) = -Cp,
(3.10)
which ensure no expected advantage from delaying or advancing adjustment by one At around the trigger points. These smooth pasting conditions are enough to find the optimal (L, l, u, U) rule, given the value function. In order to find the latter, however, we need to go back to Equation (3.5). Standard steps reduce this equation, in the interior of the inaction range, to a second-order differential equation. The two boundary conditions required to find V are obtained from equalizing the two terms on the right-hand side of Equation (3.6):
V(L,K*) = V ( I , K * ) - (cy + c p ( l - L ) ) K*,
(3.11)
V(U,K*) = V ( u , K * ) - (of + cp(U - u)) K*,
(3.12)
which simply say that since the investment rule (optimal or not[) dictates that once a trigger point is reached, adjustment must occur at once, the only difference in the value of being at trigger and target points must be the adjustment cost of moving from the former to the latter. Figure 3.2 illustrates the value function. Smooth pasting says that the tangents at L and l have slope Cp, while those at U and u have slope -Cp. Value matching says
828
R.J. Caballero
that the value function evaluated at the target minus the value function evaluated at the trigger point is equal to the variable cost paid at adjustment plus the fixed cost (all these normalized by K* in the figure). There are a few particular cases which are worth highlighting because they appear often in the literature: (1) If there is no variable cost of investment, once the adjustment decision has been taken, adjustment from both sides is complete since the marginal cost of adjustment is zero. Thus, the (L, l, u, U) rule reduces to an (L, c, U) rule, where c is the common target for investment as well as disinvestment, and is that value which maximizes V(Z, K*) for any K* 2o. (2) If there are variable costs but no fixed cost, there is no reason for adjustment to be lumpy, for there are no increasing returns in the adjustment technology 21. Once the boundaries of the inaction range, L and U, are reached, the firm adjusts just enough to avoid crossing outside the inaction range; that is L and U become reflecting barriers. (3) If there is a large (not necessarily infinite) cost to disinvestment, then investment becomes irreversible. In the absence of investment costs, the investment rule reduces to a single reflecting barrier L, which is to the left of one (reluctance to invest). This is the standard irreversible investment case.
3.1.3. A detour." q-theory and infrequent investment One of the main manifestations of the empirical failure o f previous investment theories, has been the difficulty in finding either a significant and sizable role for q, or evidence that it is a sufficient statistic for investment. Do the theories studied in this section help explain these empirical failures? I see two reasons to believe so. The first one is rather negative, q-theory is no longer robust in our setting, so there :are many scenarios where we should not expect it to work. The second one is more positive. In the subclass o f models where it does work, the functional form relating q and investment is likely to be highly non-linear, thus quite different from the standard linear regressions leading to the rejection o f q-theory.
3.1.3.1. On the fragility of marginal q. It is apparent from the lack of global concavity o f the value function in Figure 3.2, that traditional q-theory is not likely to work in the presence o f jumps. Caballero and Leahy (1996) develop the argument in detail, which I summarize below.
20 Note that in general c ~ 1. That is, the optimal dynamic target is generally different from the static one. 21 And we have already assumed that shocks are "small" in any given At.
829
Ch. 12." Aggregate Inoestment
(a)
lqw...-....-..---.---.....~ J ~ ~ q m 1+ C+p S
qm(z)
il-c<
L
1
u
U
(b) qm
1 + C+p
1 - c-p
>
<
U=u
L=I
Fig. 3.3. Marginalq. The value of the firm is equal to K + V, thus marginal q is 22 qM(Z) = 1 + Vx = 1 + K~.
(3.13)
Figure 3.3a plots qM against the imbalance m e a s u r e Z 23. Smooth pasting implies that qM must be the same at trigger and target points (because Vz must be the same at trigger and target points); if there are jumps, these are points very far apart in state
22 Recallthat P was definedas the presentvalueof profitsnet of adjustmentcosts and interestpayments on capital. 23 See, for example, Dixit (1993) for a characterizationof the (L, l, u, U) solutionin terms of a similar diagram.
830
R.J. Caballero
space. Two points with the same value of qM lead to very different levels of investment (zero and large). Moreover, since the value function becomes linear outside the inaction range, all points outside the inaction range (on the same side) have the same q~t, and all of them lead to different levels of investment. It is apparent, therefore, that the function mapping qM into investment no longer exists. Worse, in between trigger and target points, the relation between qM and Z is not even monotonic. What is happening? Marginal q is the expected present value of the marginal profitability o f capital. Far from an adjustment point, it behaves as usual with respect to the state o f the firm: if conditions improve, future marginal profitability of capital rises, and so does q~. Close to the investment point, on the other hand, the effect of a change in the state of the firm over the probability o f a large amount of investment in the near future dominates. An abrupt increase in the stock of capital brings about an abrupt decline in the marginal profitability o f capital as long as the profit function is concave with respect to capital 24. Thus, an improvement in the state of the firm makes it very likely that it invests in the near future, reducing the expected marginal profitability o f capital in the near future, thus lowering the value of an extra unit of installed capital. Caballero and Leahy (1996) show that adding a convex adjustment cost to the problem does not change the basic intuition of the mechanism described above. They also show, somewhat paradoxically, that average q, which is often thought o f as a convenient albeit inappropriate proxy for marginal q, turns out to be a good predictor of investment even in the presence of fixed costs, although it is no longer a sufficient statistic, except for very special assumptions about the stochastic nature of driving forces. 3.1.3.2. When does q-theory work?. The failure o f q-theory described above is rooted in the presence of increasing returns in the adjustment cost function (3.4). This feature of the adjustment technology is responsible for the loss of global concavity of the value function, which is behind the non-monotonicity o f marginal q 25. Monotonicity of qM inside the inaction range is recovered by dropping the fixed cost from Equation (3.4), as was done in cases 2 and 3 in Section 3.1.2. Figure 3.3b portrays this scenario. Adjustment at the trigger points no longer involves large projects, thus proximity to these triggers no longer signal the sharp changes in future marginal profitability of capital which were responsible for the "anomalous" behavior of qM 26 There is still the issue that in the (very) rare event that a firm finds itself outside the inaction range it will adjust immediately to the trigger, at a constant marginal cost, so
24 Which I take to be the standard case. z5 Indeed, value functions for (S, s) models are often only K-concave. 26 Of course, once at the trigger, large projects may result from the accumulated and - more or less continuous response to a sequence of shocks with the same sign. But this does not give rise to a sharp change in profitability since investment occurs only in response and to offset new, as opposed to accumulated, changes in profitability.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
831
different levels of investment are consistent with the same value o f qM. This is easily remedied by adding a convex component to the adjustment cost function27:
c(.,K*) =
0tK* {c l,I +c l.I
> 1.
(3.14)
This is essentially what Abel and Eberly (1994) do 28. Absent the advantage of lumping adjustment brought about by the presence o f fixed costs, standard q-theory is recovered whenever the firm invests. Provided adjustment takes place, the firm equalizes the marginal benefit of adjustment and the marginal cost o f investing, which is now an increasing function o f adjustment: qM = 1 + sgn(r/)
(Cp +/3Cqlr/l~-l) ,
for t / ~ 0. By setting ~ to zero, we can obtain the boundaries o f inaction in qM_space. Indeed, investment will not occur if
1-cp
27 Which, at the same time, makes transitions outside the inaction range less rare. 28 Needless to say, it is trivial to add asymmetries to the adjustment cost function. But that is beside the point of this section. 29 Alternatively, if one assumes perfect competition and constant returns to scale, the profit function becomes linear with respect to capital (if the other factors of production can be adjusted at will), so changes in investment do not feed back into q. In this extreme case, the modified (i.e. with an inaction range) q-theory works well even in the presence of traditional fixed costs.
832
R.J Caballero
range relevant for different types of investments could explain the negative BarnettSakellaris finding. 3.1.3.3. Taking stock. One may be inclined to conclude from this section that before going ahead with q-theory one should check whether investment literally exhibits jumps or not. This is not the lesson I draw, however. For once, this is not right. It is not difficult to add a time to build mechanism such that a lumpy project is decomposed into a fairly smooth flow, without altering the argument of why marginal q fails in the presence of fixed costs. But more importantly, I suspect the main lesson is one of modesty. I doubt that researchers will often find the required data and/or patience to determine whether one scenario or the other holds. In this case, we might as well acknowledge that the relationship between marginal q and investment is not robust, and that average q is unlikely to be a sufficient statistic for investment. Of course it is important to include variables that capture knowledge of the future on the right-hand side of investment equations, but we should avoid reading "too much" from these regressions. 3.1.4. Another detour." Several misconceptions about irreuersible investment As I mentioned before, when describing the special case of irreversible investment, the regulation barrier, L, is to the left of one. That is, investment occurs only when the stock of capital is substantially below the frictionless stock of capital. Alternatively, investment occurs when the marginal profitability of capital is substantially above the cost of capital. This is the famous "reluctance to invest" result. There are several misconceptions about the implications of this "reluctance" result. I will mention three of them. It is often said that, (a) reluctance implies that, in the presence of irreversibility, the firm accumulates less capital; (b) since reluctance rises with uncertainty (the regulation point moves further to the left), more uncertainty implies less capital; and (c) standard present value techniques are inappropriate because reluctance reflects the value of the "option to wait" for more information before irreversibly sinking resources and this is not taken into account by the standard formulae. In order to show the fallacious nature of the first statement, it is useful to go back to our canonical problem and simulate the path o f the (log of) stock of capital of a firm facing no irreversibility constraint. Panel (a) in Figure 3.4 does so for a random realization of the path of 0. Panel (b) in the figure shows the corresponding path of the marginal profitability of capital, which is equal to the constant - frictionless - cost of capital, r 3°. Imagine now imposing an irreversibility constraint on the firm, but assume that the firm does not modify its "frictionless" investment rule whenever it can invest. This is
3o These figures are from Caballero (1993a).
833
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment (a)
(b)
[I
~r
~L IlL o;
~L ~o s
lo
rs
20
~
~o
~
40
4S
l
~0
l
l
l
l
l
,
t~ne
l
l
P~E~ ]
l
tlme
(c)
(d)
I~rg. Prof.
~o
;
;
;
g
,;
~
io ,',
~
r
i
i
i
tlme
'i
| .............
i Is
t
I
i ............ I?'--
t Io
r
(f)
Al
i ~
i
tlme
(e)
o
i
i zo
r zls
time
i ao
l
i ~
- -
/
In Kf
- - -
In K d
--
InK i 4o
tl 4s
c --
/
c+h
Mar'g. so
:
,_
.:
,
,
5
I0
m
~o
J 2'~
time
Fig. 3.4. Reluctance and its counterpart.
t ~
~
~ 4o
Prof i 45
"
J
so
834
R.J Caballero
portrayed in panel (c) of the figure. The solid and dashed lines represent the actual and frictionless stocks o f capital, respectively. It is apparent that the firm would, on average, have too much capital, for it would have the same stock o f capital in good times, but too much in bad times. The counterpart o f this is in panel (d), which shows that on average the marginal profitability of capital is below the cost o f capital. Reluctance to invest in good times is an optimal response attempting to offset the natural tendency to over-accumulate capital induced by the irreversibility constraint. Panel (e) illustrates this point. The solid and dashed lines represent the same variables as in panel (c), while the dotted line illustrates the target stock of capital when the firm behaves optimally. The counterpart o f the negative value of ln(Ka/Kf ) is a positive constant h in the marginal profitability o f capital required for investment to take place (panel f). It is apparent that whether the stock o f capital is on average higher or lower than without the irreversibility constraint is unclear; the firm has too little capital during good times but too much during very bad times. A precise answer depends on things about which we know little, and which may turn out to yield only secondorder effects 31. It is now easy to see the fallacious nature of the second statement. More uncertainty raises reluctance precisely because it raises the need to reduce the extent o f excessive capital during the now deeper recessions. Without raising reluctance, an increase in uncertainty would raise the average stock o f capital in the presence of irreversibility constraints. This occurs because there would now be greater capital accumulation during extremely good times which would not be offset by large disinvestment during extremely bad times 32. The third misunderstanding is o f a different nature. In my view, it is the result of insightful but, unfortunately, abused language. First, what is right: there is nothing mysterious about irreversibility constraints as a mathematical problem. Dynamic programing works, in the same way it does with other, more traditional, adjustment frictions. This means that present value formulae, using the correct calculation of future marginal profitability of capital also work. O f course such calculations must be performed along the optimal investment path, constraints included! What is wrong: the standard analysis must be modified to consider the value of the "option to wait".
3a See Bertola (1992), Caballero (1993a), Bertola and Caballero (1994) for early discussions of this issue and of the related uncertainty-investment misconception. More recently, Abel and Eberly (1996b) have formalized these claims and made them more precise. 32 This does not mean that one cannot construct scenarios where an increase in uncertainty reduces investment. For example, if there is an increase in perceived future uncertainty, the investment threshold may jump today - i.e., before the variance of shocks does - resulting in an unambiguous decline in investment. Also, one should not confuse changes in uncertainty with changes in the probability of a bad event. The latter links increases in uncertainty to a reduction in expected value, an entirely different and more straightforward effect on investment. One can find traces of this confusion in the (informal) credibility literature.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
835
As we have seen, there is no need to do so. However, one may choose to follow an alternative path, in which one starts by evaluating the future marginal profitability o f capital without considering the effect o f future optimal investment decisions on marginal profitability. This "mistake" can then be "corrected" with a term that has an option representation. This alternative way o f doing things is akin to the arbitrage approach in finance, and it was nicely portrayed in Pindyck (1988). The confusion arises, in my view, from mixing the language in the two approaches 33. A related claim exists for a once and for all project (as opposed to incremental investment). It is said that the simple positive net present value rule used in business schools to decide whether a project should be implemented does not hold because it does not consider the option to wait and decide tomorrow, when more information is available. Since I have never taught at a business school I cannot argue directly against that claim. However, if the issue is whether to invest today or tomorrow, the right criterion has never been invest if NPV is positive - at least that is what we teach economics undergraduates. This is a case of mutually exclusive projects, thus the fight criterion has always been to compare their net present value and take that with the highest NPV, provided it is positive. If investment is irreversible, the project invest tomorrow has a lower bound at zero (because investment will not occur if N P V looks negative tomorrow), which the project invest today does not. Thus, other things equal, irreversibility necessarily makes investing tomorrow more attractive than investing today. 3.1.5. Adjustment hazard
At a qualitative level, the (L, l, u, U) models described above capture well the nonlinear nature o f microeconomic adjustment. Maintenance expenditures aside, investment is mostly sporadic and often lumpy; scarcely reacting to small changes in the environment but abruptly undoing accumulated imbalances when they become sufficiently large, and with possibly significant asymmetries between investment and disinvestment. At an empirical level, however, these characterizations are too stark. For reasons, some o f which we understand and most of which we do not, firms respond differently to similar imbalances over time and across firms. Caballero and Engel (1999) propose a probabilistic instead o f a deterministic adjustment rule. Rather than having a clear demarcation between regions o f adjustment and inaction, they model a situation where large imbalances are more likely to trigger adjustment than small ones 34.
33 See Bertola (1988) for one of the first discussions of this issue in the economics literatme. There is also a related discussion in applied mathematics; see, for example, E1 Karoui and Karatzas (1991). Abel et al. (1996) have recently revisited and expanded the discussion on the relation between the two approaches. 34 Another advantage of this approach is that it nests linear models as the probability of adjustment becomes independent of Z.
R.J. Caballero
836
There are many formal motivations for such an assumption. A particularly simple one, pursued by Caballero and Engel (1999), is to assume that cf in the adjustment cost fimction (3:4) is an i.i.d, random variable, both across firms and time. Although technically more complex, the nature of the problem is not too different from that of the simpler (L, l, u, U) model. Let ~o denote the random fixed cost, and G(w) its time invariant distribution. It is possible to characterize the problem of the firm in terms of two functions similar to those used before: V(Z, K*) and ~'(Z, K*, w), the value of a firm with imbalance Z, desired capital K*, and realization of fixed adjustment cost w. In particular, V(Z,K*) is the value o f the firm provided it does not adjust, while [/(Z,K*, w) is the value o f the firm when it is left free to choose whether or not to adjust. Thus,
V(Zt, 1£7) = H(Zt, K t )At + (1 - rAt)Et [V(Zt+At,K~+At,Wt+At,)],
•
V(Zt,K; ,~o)-max
{ V(Zt,K[),max {V(Zt+ tl, K[)-C(tI, K[,wt)}
}
(3.15)
.
(3.16)
Not surprisingly, the nature of the solution is not too different from that o f the (L, l, u, U) case. Indeed, conditional on c~ it is an (L, l, u, U) rule, although there are additional intertemporal considerations, since the firm weighs the likelihood of drawing higher or lower adjustment costs in the future. Without conditioning on ~o, it is a probabilistic rule in the space of imbalances. In order to simplify the exposition, I will suppress the proportional costs. Thus, conditional on adjustment, the target point is the same regardless of whether the firm is adding or subtracting to its stock of capital (i.e. l = u = c). Moreover, let me define a new imbalance index centered around zero: x - In (Z/c). The probability of adjustment rises with the absolute value of x because there are more realizations of adjustment costs which justify adjustment. This is the sense in which the (S, s) nature of the simpler models is preserved. Let A(x) denote the function describing the probability of adjustment given x, and call it the adjustment hazard function [see Caballero and Engel (1999)]. Given an imbalance x, it is no longer possible to say with certainty whether or not the firm will adjust, but the expected investment by the firm is given by E
11, ]
K/t x = (e ~ -
1)A(x) ~ - x A ( x ) ,
(3.17)
which is simply the product of the adjustment if it occurs, and the probability that adjustment occurs 35. Aggregation is now only a step away. 35 Caballero and Engel (1999) refer to A(x) as the "effective hazard" to capture the idea that, through a normalization, it also captures scenarios where adjustment, if it occurs, is only a fraction of the imbalance X.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
837
3.2. Aggregation Unlike microeconomic data, aggregate investment series look fairly smooth. Large microeconomic adjustments are far from being perfectly synchronized. The question arises, and this was the maintained hypothesis during the 1980s, as to whether aggregation eliminates all traces of lumpy microeconomic adjustment. The answer is a clear no. Doms and Dunne's evidence on the role of synchronization of primary spikes in accounting for aggregate investment, and on the high time series correlation between aggregate investment and a Herfindahl index of microeconomic investments, as well as the more structural empirical evidence reviewed in the next section, support this conclusion, With the setup at hand, aggregation proceeds in two easy steps. To simplify things further, I will define the aggregate as the behavior of the average, rather than the weighted average 36. Both steps rely on having a large number of establishments, so that laws of large numbers can be applied. In the first step, one takes as the average investment rate (i.e. the ratio of investment to capital) of establishments with more or less the same imbalance of capital, x, the conditional expectation of this ratio given in Equation (3.17):
It ,~x = -xA(x),
(3.18)
g)
where the superscript x denotes the aggregate for plants with imbalance x. The second step just requires averaging across all x. Let f(x, t) denote the cross sectional density of establishments' capital imbalances just before investment takes place at time t. Then the aggregate investment rate at time t, (It/Kt) A, is
( It ~A = - f xA(x)f(x,t)dx.
g)
(3.19)
This is an interesting equation, with macroeconomic data on the left and microeconomic data on the right-hand side. An example serves to illustrate this aspect of the investment equation: If the adjustment hazard is quadratic,
A(x) = )~o+ ;qx + )~2x2, Equation (3.19) reduces to I, ~A = __~r~,-(1)__~lXt(2) g)
_ •2X(3),
(3.20)
where Xt(1), Xt(2) and Xt(3) denote, respectively, the first, second and third moments of the distribution of establishments' imbalances. 36 Using microeconomicdata, Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995) show that in US manufacturing this approximationis. See Caballero and Engel (1999) for a detailed discussion of the issue.
838
R.J. Caballero
If t l l = ,~2 = 0, the model only has aggregate variables, both on the right and left• hand side. Indeed this case corresponds to the celebrated partial adjustment model, and it also coincides with the equation obtained from a quadratic adjustment cost model with a representative agent [e.g. Rotemberg (1987) and Caballero and Engel (1999)]. If either )!.1 or/~2 is different from zero, however, information about the cross sectional distribution o f imbalances is needed on the right-hand side. All the microeconomic models discussed in this section yield situations where higher moments o f the cross sectional distribution play a role. 3.3. Empirical evidence There are two polar empirical strategies used to estimate Equation (3.19), with a continuum o f possibilities in between. At one extreme, one can use microeconomic data to construct all the elements on the right-hand side; in particular one can construct the path o f the cross sectional distribution and estimate the adjustment hazard as an accounting identity, or estimate a parametric version o f it. At the other extreme, one can attempt to learn about the adjustment hazard from aggregate data only, by putting enough structure on the stochastic processes faced by firms and by starting with a guess on the initial cross sectional distribution. Both avenues have been explored, with similar results along dimensions they can be compared. 3.3.1. Microeconomic data Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995) use information on approximately seven thousand US manufacturing plants from 1972 to 1988 to empirically recreate the steps described in the previous section 37. The figures below were constructed with data from that paper 3s. The procedure used by Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger is essentially accounting, except for the first step, which requires estimating a series of frictionless capital for each establishment, and, from this, a m e a s u r e ofxit (an index of the capital imbalance o f firm i at date t). The series o f frictionless capital were constructed using a procedure similar to that described in Section 2, but cointegration regressions were run at the individual establishment level 39. The average estimate of the long run elasticity of capital with
37 As in Doms and Dunne (1993), we used data from the Longitudinal Research Datafile (LRD). The LRD was created by longitudinally linking the establishment-level data from the Annual Survey of Manufacturing. The data used in that paper is a subset of the LRD, representing all large, continuously operating plants over the sample. The data sets include information on both investment and retirement of equipment (i.e. the gross value of assets sold, retired, scrapped, etc. 38 Warning: x in that paper corresponds to ~ in this survey. 39 The results reported there constrained the coefficient on the elasticity of capital with respect to its cost to be equal across two-digit sectors, but all principal results were robust to different constraints and specifications.
Ch. 12: Aggregate lnvestment
839
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
I -2
-1
0
1
o.o
Fig. 3.5. Adjustment hazard.
respect to its cost was close to minus one, with substantial heterogeneity across sectors. The measures ofxit, up to a constant, correspond to the difference between actual and estimated frictionless capital4°. There are two results from that paper which seem particularly relevant for this section of the survey. One on the shape o f the adjustment hazard, and the other on the consequences o f this shape for aggregate dynamics. I discuss the former here and the latter after the next subsection. Figure 3.5 reports the average adjustment hazard constructed from simply averaging the investment rates o f establishments in a small neighborhood o f each x, divided by minus the corresponding x. The hazard is clearly increasing for positive adjustment (i.e. expected investment rises more than proportionally with the shortage o f capital), as one would expect from the nonlinearities implied by (L, 1, u, U) type models, and unlike the linear models which imply a constant hazard. The estimated hazard is also very low for negative changes, suggesting irreversibility 41 . Following a similar procedure, Goolsbee and Gross (1997) have studied very detailed and high quality microeconomic data on capital stock decisions in the US airline industry. They found clear evidence of behavior consistent with non-convex adjustment costs.
3.3.2. Aggregate data I f only aggregate data are available, one needs to make some inference about the path o f the cross sectional distribution of capital imbalances, f ( x , t), from these data. This is possible if enough structure is placed on the stochastic processes faced by firms.
40 The establishment specific constants were estimated as the average gap between their respective kit and k/t for the five points with investment closest to their median (broadly interpreted as maintenance investment). 41 Retirements include assets sold, scrapped or retired. It is possible that observations are very noisy on this side. The right-hand side of the figure should therefore be viewed with some caution.
840
R.J Caballero
The basic operations affecting the evolution o f f ( x , t) are quite simple. Given the density, or histogram, at time t - 1, there are three basic operations in its transformation into f ( x , t). First, aggregate shocks and common depreciation shift everybody's x in the same direction; second, given the adjustment hazard, the density at each x is split into those that stay there and those that adjust and move to some other position in the state space (in the simplest case, they move to x = 0, but this is not necessary); and third, idiosyncratic shocks hit, which amounts to a convolution o f the density resulting from the second step and that o f idiosyncratic shocks. Making distributional assumptions about idiosyncratic shocks and the initial cross sectional distribution, is enough, therefore, to keep track o f the evolution o f the cross sectional density, conditional on aggregate shocks and for a given adjustment hazard. In continuous time, and assuming Brownian motions for aggregate and idiosyncratic shocks, Bertola and Caballero (1994) estimated the irreversible investment model, and Caballero (1993b) did so for the (L,/, u, U) model. 42 In discrete time but continuous state space, Caballero and Engel (1999), estimated the more general adjustment hazard model described in the previous sections, assuming that both idiosyncratic and aggregate shocks were generated by log-normal processes. We did so for US manufacturing investment in equipment and structures (separately) for the 1947-1992 period 43. The results were largely consistent with those found with microeconomic data by Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995). There is clear evidence o f an increasing hazard model; that is, the expected adjustment o f a firm grows more than proportionally with its imbalance 44. An important point to note is that since only aggregate data were used, these microeconomic nonlinearities must matter at the aggregate level, for otherwise they would not be identified. The improvement in the likelihood function from estimating this non-linear model rather than a simple linear model (including the quadratic adjustment cost model) was highly significant, and so was the improvement in the out-of-sample forecasting accuracy 45.
42 See Bertola and Caballero (1990) for a discrete time and space model and estimation procedure. 43 Another important difference between this and the previous papers is that estimation was done by a single step maximum likelihood procedure, which did not require estimating frictionless capital separately. 44 We did not allow for asymmetries between ups and downs but this turned out not to matter much because given the strong drift induced by depreciation and the small value we found for the hazard in an interval around zero, the model effectively behaves as if investment is irreversible (i.e. It is very asymmetric around the median value of x and with a very small hazard for values of x much higher than that.). 45 For within sample criteria, we ran Vuong's [Rivers and Vuong (1991)] test for non-nested models, and we rejected strongly the hypothesis that both models (linear and non-linear) are equally close to the true model against the hypothesis that the structural (non-linear) model is better. For out-of-sample criteria, we dropped the last ten percent of the observations and evaluated the Mean Squared Error of the one step ahead forecasts for these observations [see Caballero and Engel (1999)].
841
Ch. 12." Aggregate Investment 3.3.3. Pent-up demand
What is the aspect of the data that makes these models better than linear ones at explaining aggregate investment dynamics? The simplest answer comes from an example. Suppose that a history of mostly positive aggregate shocks displaces the cross sectional distribution of imbalances toward the high part of the hazard. Such a sequence of events will not only lead to more investment along the path but also to more pent-up investment demand; indeed, the cross sectional distribution represents unfulfilled investment plans. But as unfulfilled demand "climbs" the hazard, more units are involved in responding to new shocks; incremental investment demand is more easily boosted by further positive aggregate shocks, or depressed by a turnabout of events. This time-varying/history-dependent aggregate elasticity plays a very important role for aggregate investment dynamics. It captures the aggregate impact of changes in the degree of synchronization of large adjustments; already an important explanatory variable in Doms and Dunne's less structural study. In particular, their observation that the Herfindahl of investment rises during episodes of large aggregate investment matches well this mechanism. Using the path of cross sectional distributions and hazards described at the beginning of this subsection, Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995) found an important role for the mechanism described above. Figure 3.6 depicts the relative contribution of the time-varying aggregate elasticity for aggregate investment dynamics. A positive value reflects an amplification effect (micro-nonlinearities exacerbate the economy's response to aggregate shocks), while a negative value reflects an offsetting effect. The impact of the time-varying elasticity appears to be especially large after the tax-reform of 1986 (when tax-incentives for investment were removed). The decline in investment was 20 percent greater than it would have been under a linear model.
Fraction 0.15 0.10 / 0.05 0 - 0.05
-0.10 -0.15 I
1976
1978
I
1980
I
I
1982
1984
1986
Fig. 3.6. Relative contributionof time-varyingmarginal response, 1974-1988.
842
R.J. Caballero d CD
d
A
LO 0
d
o
V
[___
c)
Fig. 3.7. Equipment-mean-difference. The importance of the time-varying elasticity is confirmed by Caballero and Engel (1999), this time using only aggregate data. As before, it is the flexible cyclical elasticity o f the increasing hazard model which allows it to better capture the high skewness and kurtosis imprinted on aggregate data by brisk investment recoveries 46. The solid line in Figure 3.7 plots the difference between the path o f the US manufacturing equipment investment-capital ratio and the predictions o f a linear model (partial adjustment) fed with the shocks estimated for the increasing-hazard model; the dashed line portrays the path o f the aggregate investment-capital ratio around its mean. It is apparent from these figures that the linear model makes its largest errors at times o f large investment changes. 3.4. Equilibrium The literature described in the previous section only considers exogenous aggregate shocks. What the econometric procedures identified as aggregate shocks are in all likelihood a combination o f " d e e p " aggregate shocks and the feedback and constraints brought about by factor markets, goods markets, and intertemporal preferences, among other things. Bottlenecks may certainly limit the extent o f synchronized investment. Equilibrium constraints not only affect the response of aggregate investment to deep aggregate shocks, but also affect the nature o f the stochastic processes faced
46 Note that just allowing for skewness and kurtosis in shocks, although it improves the performance of linear models, is not nearly enough to make the linear model as good as the non-linear one. In Caballero and Engel (1999) we compared the structural model with normal shocks (to the rate of growth of desired capital) with a linear model which flexibly combined normal and log-normal shocks (which allows for skewness and kurtosis). We found that Vuong's test still favored the non-linear model very clearly. Moreover, in Caballero, Engel and Haltiwanger (1995) we found no evidence that would allow us to reject the hypothesis that shocks have a normal distribution.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
843
by firms and the dimension of the state space. It is this last observation which has inhibited progress in constructing general equilibrium versions of these models. In principle, the entire cross sectional distribution is needed to forecast future prices faced by any particular firm, which means that actions today, and therefore equilibrium determination, depend on these complex forecasts, and so on. We are, however, beginning to see progress along this dimension. Much of this has occurred in models with active extensive margins, and will be discussed in the next sections, together with the reasons why the presence o f an extensive margin (entry and/or exit) may facilitate rather than complicate the solution of the model. However, there has also been recent progress along the lines of the intensive margin models discussed up to now. Krieger (1997) embeds the heterogeneous agents irreversible investment model of Bertola and Caballero (1994) into a more or less standard Real Business Cycle model. He deals with the curse of dimensionality by arguing that, except for very high frequency aspects of the data, expectations can be well approximated by keeping track of a finite (and not too large) number of statistics of the Fourier representation of the cross sectional distribution. I suspect that the quality of this approximation is facilitated by the fact that, in Krieger's model, aggregate shocks occur only infrequently. Nonetheless, I view his as an important step forward. At this stage, the primary effect of general equilibrium is not surprising. It brings important sources of aggregate convexity into the problem, smoothing further the response of aggregate investment to aggregate shocks. How important are aggregate sources of convexity? I suspect that, together with time to build considerations, they are among the main sources of convexity in the short run. On one hand, we have already presented substantial evidence on microeconomic lumpiness, which is largely inconsistent with a dominant role for generalized convexity at the microeconomic level. On the other, not only is it well known that estimated partial adjustment coefficients grow with the degree of disaggregation of the data, but we also have direct evidence on the importance of bottlenecks. Goolsbee (1995a) provides interesting evidence on the latter. He exploits the variation across time and assets (capital) in investment tax incentives, as instruments for short-run investment demand. He shows that the price of assets is highly responsive to ITCs: A 10 percent increase in ITCs leads to an average increase in the price of capital goods of about 6 percent. This price effect slowly vanishes over the following three years 47. Equilibrium considerations will play a central role in the sections that follow. In particular, the issue of the elasticity of the supply of capital, generally interpreted, as well as that of other bottlenecks will be revisited often.
47 In further work, Goolsbee (1997) concludes that an important fraction of the increase in short rnn marginal cost is due to an increase in the wages of workers who produce capital goods. In the last part of Section 5 I will discuss the connection between sunk investment and payments to complementary factors. Questioning the robustness of Goolsbee's(1995a) findings, Hassett and Hubbard (1996a), find evidence of a positive effect of tax credits on prices of capital goods before 1975 but not after that.
R.J Caballero
844
4. Entry, exit and scrapping Changes in the aggregate stock of capital are not only due to the expansion of existing establishments and projects, but also result from the entry (creation) decisions of existing and new entrepreneurs, the exit decisions of some incumbents, and the restructuring of possibly outdated forms of production. There is a very extensive and interesting industrial organization literature on these issues which I will not discuss here. Instead, I will focus on issues that directly relate to our current discussion: the impact of sunk costs on aggregate investment and the feedback of equilibrium considerations into individual decisions about lumpy actions. This section contains three main messages: First, by truncating the distribution of perceived future returns, free entry acts as if each competitive investor internalized the negative effect of its entry decision on expected future industry prices. Second, equilibrium scrapping and creation are closely connected: if industry wide creation costs are linear, scrapping will be less responsive to aggregate shocks than if these costs are convex (i.e. if there is an upward sloping short-rtm supply of (newly) installed capital). Among other things, this is important for capital accumulation and the patterns of its mismeasurement. And third, in equilibrium, shocks to the scrapping margin can lead to investment booms, and to double-counting problems in the measurement of capital 48.
4.1. Competitive entry and irreversibility Dixit (1989), Leahy (1993), and Caballero and Pindyck (1996), among others, have provided simple models of competitive equilibrium investment in which the only meaningful investment decision of firms is whether or not to enter into and, in some cases, exit from the industry 49. Below, I sketch a representative model of this type. Investment is sunk upon entry in the sense that selling the firm's capital does not change its productivity. The flow accruing to a firm i at time t is summarized by the product of an idiosyncratic productivity level, Sit > 0 and the industry price, Pt. The idiosyncratic productivity level is such that industry output, Yt, is
Yt =
/o
Sit d i = N~,
(4.1)
where Nt is the measure of firms at time t. Given Art, the industry price is determined from the demand equation:
Pt
= V t Y t -1/~1 =
VtNt 1/~,
(4.2)
48 See Greenspan and Cohen (1996), for a discussion of the importance of considering endogenous scrappage to forecast sales of new motor vehicles in the USA. 49 See Hopenhayn (1992) for an elegant characterization of the steady state properties of a competitive equilibrium model of entry and exit.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
845
where Vt is an aggregate demand shock that follows a geometric Brownian motion with drift/~ > 0 and standard deviation a, and t/ is the elasticity of demand with respect to price 50. Let there be an infinite supply of potential entrants, whose initial productivity upon entry is drama from the distribution of productivities of existing firms. There is an entry cost F and no depreciation or higher productivity alternative use (issues of exit will be discussed in the next subsection). Free entry implies:
F >~Ei { Et [f ~ PsSi,e-r(" Odsl } .
(4.3)
Using Fubini's Theorem (i.e. moving the expectation with respect to the idiosyncratic shocks inside the integral) allows us to remove the idiosyncratic component from Equation (4.3), yielding
F>~Etlft°°P,.er(St)dsJ.
(4.4)
Given Nt, the industry price is exclusively driven by the aggregate demand shock. Thus, absent entry, the right-hand side of Equation (4.4) is an increasing function of Pt, call it j~(P). Entry, however, cannot always be absent, for that would occasionally violate the free entry condition. Indeed, as soon as J~(P) > F, there would be infinite entry which, in turn, would lower the equilibrium price instantly. There is only one price, call it/5o, such that the free entry condition holds with equality. Once this price is reached, enough entry will occur to ensure that the price does not cross this upper bound; but, to be justified, entry must not occur below that bound either. Entry, therefore, changes the stochastic process of the equilibrium price from a Brownian Motion to a regulated Brownian Motion. This change in the price process, however, means that.]~ is no longer the right description of the expression on the right-hand side of Equation (4.4). There is a new function, Ji(P), which is still monotonic in the price, but which satisfies Ji(P) < J~(P) for all P because of the role of entry in preventing the realization of high prices. This, in turn, implies a new reservation/entry price P1 > P0, which leads to a new function )~(P), such that j~ > y~ > Ji, which leads to a new regulation point in between the previous ones, and so on until convergence to some equilibrium, ~(p),p)51. Thus, through competitive equilibrium, we have arrived at a solution like that of the irreversible investment problem at the individual level, but now for the industry as a whole. Periods of inaction are followed by regulated investment (through entry) during favorable times. The constructive argument used to illustrate the solution isolates
50 Adding an aggregate productivity shock is straightforward. The Brownian Motion assumption is not needed, but it simplifiesthe calculations. 51 Needless to say, this iterative procedure is not needed to obtain the solution of this problem.
846
R.J Caballero
the feedback of equilibrium on individual decisions. Potential entrants (investors) know that if market conditions worsen they will have to absorb losses (this is where irreversibility kicks in), while if market conditions improve, entry will occur, limiting the potential gains (since the price will never be higher than/5). As a result, they delay entry because the expected value of future market prices is necessarily lower than the current/entry price. There is a methodological angle in this literature. Entry (and exit) is a very powerful mechanism. With the "appropriate" assumptions about potential entrants, entry often simplifies the computation of equilibrium in models with heterogeneity and sunk costs. Essentially, the methodological "trick" is that the degree of complexity of the computational problem in cases where both extensive and intensive margins are present is often largely determined by the nature of the distribution of potential entrants, which can be made much simpler than the endogenous evolution of the cross sectional distributions discussed in the previous section. Of course, in reality there is substantial inbreeding, so the distribution of potential entrants is in all likelihood related to that of incumbents. Nonetheless, the current set of models are convenient machines that allow us to cut the chain of endogeneity before it gets too forbidding, but after the first stage, where there are no endogenous interactions. This methodological advantage has allowed researchers to explore some of the equilibrium issues left open in Section 3. Caballero and Hammour (1994) have explored in more detail the consequences of different assumptions on the supply of capital for the pattern of aggregate investment (job creation) and scrapping (job destruction). The latter is a very important, and often disregarded, aspect of the timing of capital accumulation. I will return to the scrapping issue in the next sections, but for now I just want to interpret it as an incumbent's decision (as opposed to a potential entrants' decision). The issue at hand is how does the entry pattern affect the response of incumbents to aggregate shocks. A scrapping margin can easily be added to the entry model discussed above by, for example, allowing Si to take negative values (e.g. due to the increase in the price of an intermediate input). Imagine, however, that the drift in the aggregate shock (and/or the failure rate of incumbents) is strong enough so there is continuous entry. Since the supply of capital faced by the industry is fully elastic (the entry cost is constant), continuous entry implies that the industry price is constant and equal to/5 (corrected for the exit possibility). That is, aggregate shocks are accommodated by the flow of investment by new entrants; fully insulating insiders from aggregate shocks. Insiders go about their scrapping decisions only considering their idiosyncratic shocks; adding a standard intensive margin does not change the basic insight [see Campbell and Fisher (1996)]. Caballero and Hammour (1994) refer to this result as perfect insulation. From a technical point of view, the simplicity of the computation of equilibrium in the perfect insulation case carries through to situations where the cost of investment fluctuates exogenously, although in that case perfect insulation breaks down. If the industry faces an upward sloping supply of capital, a sensible assumption at least in the
Ch. 12: Aggregateinvestment
847
short run (remember Goolsbee's evidence), we return to a scenario in which the "curse of dimensionality" appears. Caballero and Hammour (1994, 1996a) have dealt with this case in scenarios where aggregate shocks follow deterministic cycles 52. Besides the specific issues addressed in those papers, the main implication for the purpose of this survey is that investment by potential entrants becomes less responsive to aggregate shocks, which also means a break down of perfect insulation and therefore a more volatile response of the scrapping and intensive margins. Krieger (1997) also discusses equilibrium interactions between creation and destruction margins, although he obtains positive rather than negative comovement between investment and scrapping. In his model, a permanent technology shock leads to a short term increase in interest rates which squeezes low productivity units relative to high productivity ones. The ensuing increase in scrapping frees resources for new higherproductivity investment. Similarly, Campbell (1997) studies the equilibrium response of entry and exit to technology shocks embodied in new production units. He argues that the increase in exit generated by positive technological shocks is an important source of resources for the creation of new production sites. 4.2. Technological heterogeneity and scrapping Scrapping is an important aspect of the process of capital accumulation. Understanding it is essential for constructing informative measures of the quantity and quality of capital at each point in time. Nonetheless, the scrapping margin is seldom emphasized, I suspect, mostly because of the difficulties associated with obtaining reliable data53. As a result, many time series comparisons of capital accumulation and productivity growth (especially across countries) are polluted by inadequate accounting of scrapping. Effective capital depreciation must surely be higher in countries tmdergoing rapid modernization processes. Partly to address these issues, vintage capital and putty-clay models have regained popularity lately. Benhabib and Rustichini (1993), for example, describe the investment cycles that follow scrapping cycles in a vintage capital model. While Atkeson and Kehoe (1997) argue that putty-clay models outperform standard putty-putty models with adjustment costs in describing the cross sectional response of investment and output to energy shocks. Gilchrist and Williams (1996), on the other hand, embody the putty-clay model in an otherwise standard RBC model and document a substantial gain over the standard RBC model in accounting for the forecastable comovements of economic aggregates. And Cooley et al. (1997) describe the medium/low frequency
52 In work in progress [Caballero and Hammour (1997b)], we have obtained an approximate solution for the stochastic case, in a context where the sources of convexity are malfimctioninglabor and credit markets. 53 See Greenspan and Cohen (1996) for sources of scrapping data for US motor vehicles.
848
R.J Caballero
aspects of a multisectoral vintage capital economy, and show how tax policy can have significant effects on the age distribution of the capital stock 54. The technological embodiment aspect of these models captures well the creativedestruction component of capital accumulation and technological progress 55. Salter's (1960) careful documentation of the technological status of narrowly defined US and UK industries is very revealing with respect to the simultaneous use of different techniques of production and the negative correlation between productivity ranking and the technological age of the plant 56. For example, his table 5 shows the evolution of methods in use in the US blast furnace industry from 1911 to 1926. At the beginning of the sample, the "best practice" plants produced 0.32 gross tons of pigiron per man-hour, while the industry average was 0.14. By the end of the sample, best practice plants productivity was 0.57 while the industry average was 0.30. While at the beginning of the sample about half of the plants used hand-charged methods of production, only six percent did at the end of the sample. As mentioned above, obsolescence and scrapping are not only driven by slowly moving technological trends, but also by sudden changes in the economic environment. Goolsbee (1995b) documents the large impact ofoil shocks on the scrapping of old and fuel-inefficient planes. For example, he estimates that the probability of retirement of a Boeing 707 (relatively inefficient in terms of fuel) more than doubled after the second oil shock. This increase was more pronounced among older planes. Once more, the endogenous nature of the scrapping dimension must be an important omitted factor in our accounting of capital accumulation and microeconomie as well as macroeconomic performance. The sunk nature of technological embodiment is a source of lumpy and discontinuous actions at the microeconomic level. The (S, s) apparatus, with its implications for aggregates, is well suited for studying many aspects of vintage and putty-clay models. In particular, episodes of large investment which leave their technological fingerprints, and remain in the economy, reverberating over time.
5. Inefficient investment
Fixed costs, irreversibilities and their implied pattern of action/inaction, have microeconomic and aggregate implications beyond the mostly technological (and neoclassical) ones emphasized above. Indeed, they seed the ground for powerful inefficiencies. This section describes new research on the consequences o f two of
54 Jovanovic(1997) studies the equilibrium interactionof the cross sectionalheterogeneityimplied by vintage capital and putty-claymodels with heterogeneityin labor skills. 55 Besides obsolescence and scrapping, these models are also useful for studying the issues of "mothballing" and capital utilization. 56 This correlation is less clear in modern data; perhaps because retooling occurs within given structures.
Ch. 12: AggregateInvestment
849
the most important sources of inefficiency in aggregate investment: informational and contractual problems. 5.1. Informational problems
Information seldom arrives uniformly and comprehensively to every potential investor. Each investor probably holds part of a truth which would be more easily seen if all investors could (or would) pool their information. Actions by others are a partial substitute for information pooling, for they reveal, perhaps noisily, the information of those that have taken actions. If, however, investment is irreversible, it may pay to wait for others to act and reveal their information before investing. Moreover, if lumpiness leads to periods of no or little action, information may remain trapped for extended periods of time, and when agents finally act, an avalanche may occur because accumulated private information is suddenly aggregated. These issues form the crux of a very interesting new literature, summarized in Gale (1995) under the heading of "social learning." There are two themes emerging from this literature which are of particular importance for this survey. The first is the existence of episodes of gradualism, during which industry investment can occur at an excessively slow pace, or even collapse altogether. The second is an exacerbation of the aggregate nonlinearities implied by the presence of fixed costs; aggregation of information coincides with the synchronization of actions, further synchronizing actions. Caplin and Leahy (1993, 1994) cleanly isolate the issues I have chosen to stress here. Caplin and Leahy (1993) describe a model very similar to the free entry model reviewed in Section 4.1, except that their model has neither aggregate nor idiosyncratic shocks. Instead there is a flow marginal cost of producing which is only known to industry insiders. Insiders have the option to produce one unit of output or none and they will produce if price is above marginal cost. This generates an information externality. If all incumbents are producing, potential investors know that marginal cost is below the current equilibrium price; if not, the industry's marginal cost is revealed to be equal to the current price. Whenever a new establishment is created, equilibrium price either declines or stays constant, improving the precision of potential investors' assessment of the industry's marginal cost. In a second best solution, investment occurs very quickly up to a point at which, even if marginal cost has not yet been reached, no further investment takes place because it is very unlikely that the present value of future social surpluses is enough to cover the investment costs. The industry equilibrium outcome has the same critical point at which investment stops, but unlike the second best outcome, it yields a much slower pace of industry investment. A potential entrant must weigh the value of coming early into the industry (expected profits are higher than they will be later), not only against the cost of capital (as in the second best solution) but also against the probability o f learning in the next second from the investment decisions of others that it was not worth entering
850
R.J. Caballero
the industry. Caplin and Leahy show that the price process x(t) obeys the following differential equation:
where F is the fixed entry cost paid by the firm and r is the real interest rate. This equation has a natural interpretation which captures the idea that competitive firms are indifferent between entry today and entry tomorrow. The left-hand side represents the loss in current revenue incurred by a firm which delays entry for a brief instant beyond t s7. The right-hand side captures the expected gain from this delay. The term rF reflects the gain due to the postponement of the entry cost, while the last term represents the saving due to the possibility that delay will reveal the true industry's marginal cost, aborting a wasteful investment sS. In equilibrium, entry is delayed and price declines slowly; "gradualism" maintains prices high enough for sufficiently long so as to offset (in expectation) the risk incurred by investors who act early rather than wait and free-ride off of others' actions s9. Caplin and Leahy (1994) characterize the opposite extreme, one of delayed exit. The key connection with the previous sections is that the problem of information revelation arises from the fact that, as we have seen, fixed costs of actions make it optimal not to act most of the time. Thus, information that could be revealed by actions remains trapped. Their model is one of time-to-build. Many identical firms simultaneously start projects which have an uncertain common return several periods later (e.g. a real estate boom). Along the investment path, firms must continue their investment and receive private signals on the expected return. The nature of technology is such that required investment is always the same if the firm chooses to continue in the project. The firm has the option to continue investing ("business as usual"), to terminate the project, or to suspend momentarily, but the cost of restarting the project after a suspension is very large. Project suspension reveals (to others) negative idiosyncratic information; if nobody suspends, it is good news. However, the costly nature of suspension delays it, and therefore information revelation is also delayed. Bad news may be accumulating but nobody suspends, because everybody is waiting for a confirmation of their bad signals by the suspension of other people. Eventually, some firms will receive enough bad signals to suspend in spite of the potential cost of doing so (i.e., if they are wrong
57 At the time when the industry starts, potential investors' priors are that the price is distributed uniformly on [0, I]. As entry occurs and the price declines, the priors are updated. If convergence has not happened at time t, marginal cost is assumed uniformly distributed on [0,x(t)]. The expected cost of waiting is, therefore, equal to the price minus the expected marginal cost, ½x(t). 58 Here ~ d t is the probabilitythat price hits marginal cost during the next dt units of time. 59 Even though entrants make zero profits in expectation, ex-post, early entrants earn positive profits, while late entrants lose money.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
851
in their negative assessment o f market conditions). Since the number of firms in their model is large, the number of firms that suspend for the first time fully reveals future demand: if demand is low, everybody exits; if it is high, all those that suspended restart. If it were not for the interplay between inaction (investment as usual) and private information, the fate of the market would be decided correctly after the first round of signals. Information aggregation does not take place until much later, however. Thus, substantial investment may turn out to be wasted because the discrete nature of actions inhibits information transmission. The title of their paper beautifully captures the expost feeling: Wisdom after the fact. The "classic" paper from the literature on information and investment is due to Chamley and Gale (1994). In their model all (private) information arrives at time zero; the multiple agent game that ensues may yield many different aggregate investment paths, including suboptimal investment collapses. In reviewing the literature, Gale (1995) illustrates the robustness of the possibility of an inefficient investment collapse (or substantial slowdown and delay). He notices that in order for there to be any value to waiting to see what others do before taking an action (investing for example) it must be the case that the actions of others are meaningful. That is, the action taken in the second period by somebody who chose to wait in the first period must depend in a non trivial way on the actions of others at the first date. If a firm chooses to wait this period, possibly despite having a positive signal, it will only invest next period if enough other firms invest this period. It must therefore be possible for every firm to decide not to invest next period because no one has invested this period, even though each firm may have received a positive signal this period, in which case, investment collapses. This is a very interesting area of research for those concerned with investment issues and is wanting for empirical developments. 5.2. Specificity and opportunism
The quintessential problem of investment is that it is almost always sunk, possibly along many dimensions. That is, the number of possible uses of resources is reduced dramatically once they have been committed or tailored to a specific project or use. Every model I discussed in the previous sections, at some stage hinges in a fundamental way on this feature of investment. To invest, often means opening a vulnerable flank. Funds which were ex-ante protected against certain realizations of firm or industry specific shocks, for example, are no longer so. In equilibrium, investment must also allow the investor to exploit opportunities which would not be available without the investment. If the project is well conceived, the weight of good and bad scenarios is such that the expected return is reasonable. Indeed, this is precisely the way I characterized the standard irreversible investment problem early on. The problem is far more serious, and more harmful for investment, when the probability of occurrence of the bad events along the exposed flanks are largely
852
R.J Caballero
controlled by economic agents with the will and freedom to behave opportunistically. In a sense, this is a property rights problem, and as such it must have a first-order effect in explaining the amount and type o f capital accumulation and, especially, differences in these variables across countries. Thus, the window for opportunism arises when part o f the investment is specific to an economic relationship, in the sense that if the relationship breaks up, the potential rewards to that investment are irreversibly lost. Further, such opportunism is almost unavoidable when this "fundamental transformation" from uncommitted to specialized capital is not fully protected by contract [Williamson (1979, 1985)] 60 Specificity, that is, the fact that factors o f production and assets may be worth more inside a specific relationship than outside o f it, may have a technological or an institutional origin. Transactions in labor, capital and goods markets are frequently characterized by some degree o f specificity. The creation of a job often involves specific investment by the firm and the worker. Institutional factors, such as labor regulations or unionization also build specificities. There is a very extensive and interesting microeconomic literature on the impact of unprotected specificity on the design o f institutions, organizations and control rights. Hart (1995) reviews many o f the arguments and insights. For the purpose o f this survey, however, the fundamental insight is in Simons (1944), who clearly understood that hold-up problems lead to underinvestment: ... the bias against new investment inherent in labor organizations is important .... Investors now face ... the prospect that labor organizations will appropriate most or all of the earnings .... Indeed, every new, long-term commitment of capital is now a matter of giving hostages to organized sellers of complementary services. More recently, Grout (1984) formalized and generalized Simons' insight, and Caballero and Hammour (1998a) studied, at a general level, the aggregate consequences o f opportunism 61. Here, I borrow the basic model and arguments from that paper to discuss those aspects o f the problem which are most relevant for aggregate investment. Everything happens in a single period 62. There is one consumption good, used as a numeraire, and two active factors o f production, 1 and 2 63. Ownership o f factors 1 and 2 is specialized in the sense that nobody owns more than one type of factor.
60 This is known as the hold-up problem. 61 For specific applications which relate to investment see Kiyotaki and Moore (1997) [credit constraints]; Caballero and Hammour (1996a, 1998b) and Ramey and Watson (1996) [turnover and unemployment]; Caballero and Hammour (1996b), Blanchard and Kremer (1996) [transition economies and structural adjustments]; Caballero and Hammour (1997b) [interactions between labor market and credit market oppor~nism]; Acemoglu (1996) [human capital investment]. 62 Many of the insights discussed here can and have been made in dynamic, but more specialized contexts. I am confident, therefore, that this section's discussion is fairly robust to generalizations along this dimension. 63 Also, there is a passive third factor which earns the rents of decreasing returns sectors.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
8 5 3
There are two modes o f production. The first is joint production, which requires, in fixed proportions, xl and x2 units of factors 1 and 2, respectively, to produce y units o f output. Let E denote the number of joint production units, so Ei = x i E represents employment o f factor i in joint production. The other form o f production is autarky where each factor produces separately, with decreasing returns technologies Fi(Ui), and where Ui denotes the employment of factor i in autarky, such that Ei + Ui = 1. The autarky sectors are competitive, with factor payments, pi: Pi = F;(Ui).
(5.2)
For now, there are no existing units. At the beginning of the period there is mass one o f each factor o f production. There are no matching frictions so that, in the efficient/complete contracts economy, units move into joint production (assuming corners away) until y-p~xl
+p2x2,
(5.3)
where asterisks are used to denote efficient quantities and prices. Specificity is captured by assuming that a fraction q~i of each factor of production cannot be retrieved from a relationship once they have agreed to work together. I f the relationship breaks up, (1 Oi)xi units of factor i can return to autarky, where it produces for the period, while ¢)ixi is irreversibly wasted. In the simple deterministicsingle-period model discussed here, specificity plays no role in the efficient economy, where there are no separations. Contracts are needed because investment occurs before actual production and factor participation. There are myriad reasons why contracts are seldom complete. An extreme assumption which takes us to the main issues most directly, is the assumption that there are no enforceable contracts. It turns out that, in equilibrium, the incomplete contracts economy has no separations either; but unlike the efficient economy, the mere possibility o f separations alters equilibrium in many ways. Generically, equilibrium rewards in joint production will have ex-post opportunity cost and rent-sharing components. For simplicity, let us assume that factors split their joint surplus 50/50. Thus, the total payment to the xi units of factor i in a unit of joint production is 64 -
wixi = (1
1
-
~)i) xiPi -1- ~S,
(5.4)
where s denotes the (ex-post) quasi-rents of a production unit: s ~- y - (1
- q}l)plXl
- (1 - q}2)p2x2.
64 Factors bargain as coalitions within the production unit.
(5.5)
854
R.J. Caballero
For a factor of production to willingly participate in joint production it must hold that WiXi ~ pixi.
(5.6)
Substituting Equations (5.4) and (5.5) into Equation (5.6), transforms factor i's participation condition into y ~ p l x t +p2x2 + Ai,
(5.7)
Z~i ~ ~)iPiXi -- ~ j p j x j ,
(5.8)
with
which measures the net sunk component of the relationship for factor i. In other words, it is a measure of the "exposure" of factor i to factor j. When Ai is positive, part of factor i's contribution to production is being appropriated by factor j 65. 5.2.1. Generic implications
Figure 5.1 characterizes equilibrium in both efficient and incomplete contract economies. The two dashed curves represent the right-hand side of condition (5.7) for factors 1 and 2. They are increasing in the number of production units because the opportunity cost of factors of production (the pis) rise as resources are attracted away from autarky. The thick dashed curve corresponds to that factor of production (here factor 1) whose return in autarky is tess responsive to quantity changes 66. If one thinks of capital and labor, arguably capital is this factor; which is a maintained assumption through most of this section. The horizontal solid line is a constant equal to y, which corresponds to the left-hand side of condition (5.7). Equilibrium in the incomplete contracts economy corresponds to the intersection of this line with the highest (at the point of intersection) of the two dashed lines. In the figure, the binding constraint is that of capital. An efficient equilibrium, on the other hand, corresponds to the intersection of the horizontal solid line with the solid line labeled Eft. The latter is just the sum of the exante opportunity costs of factors of production [the right-hand side of Equation (5.3)]. This equilibrium coincides with that of the incomplete contracts economy only when both dashed lines intersect; that is, when net appropriation is z e r o (A i = - A j = 0). There are several features of equilibrium which are important for investment (or capital accumulation). First, there is underinvestment; equilibrium point A is to the left of the efficient point A*. Because it is being appropriated, capital withdraws into autarky (e.g. consumption, investment abroad, or investment in less socially-valuable
65 It should be apparent that A i = -Aj. 66 That is, autarky exhibitsrelativelyless decreasingreturns for this factor.
855
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
(2) Eft. B ~ y , ~ (1) ~ l /
.'i//
//
///
U. / / /
~.
E
Fig. 5.1. Opportunism in general equilib-
rium.
activities) 67. Second, the withdrawal of capital constrains the availability of jobs and segments the labor market 68. In equilibrium, not only are there fewer joint production units, but also the right-hand side of condition (5.7) for labor is less than y, reflecting the net appropriation of capital; outside labor cannot arbitrage away this gap because its promises are not enforceable. Third, investment is more volatile than it would be in the efficient economy 69. Changes in y translate into changes in the number of joint production units through capital's entry condition (thick dashes), which is clearly more elastic (at their respective equilibria) than the efficient entry condition ("Eft" line). If profitability in joint production is high enough, equilibrium is to the right of the balanced specificity point, B. In that region, it is the labor entry condition which binds. In principle, problems are more easily solved in this region through contracts and bonding. I f not solved completely, however, there are a few additional conclusions o f interest for an investment survey. First, there is underinvestment since the complementary factor, labor, withdraws (relative to the first best outcome) from joint production. Second, capital is now rationed, so privately profitable investment projects do not materialize. Third, investment is now less volatile than in the efficient economy. Changes in y translate into changes in the number of joint production units through labor's entry condition (thin dashes), which is clearly less elastic than the efficient entry condition ("Eft" line).
67 See Fallick and Hassett (1996) for evidence on the negative effect of union certification on firm level investment. 68 This holds even in the extreme case where capital and labor are perfect substitutes in production. See Caballero and Hammour (1998a). 69 In a dynamic model, this translates into a statement about net capital accumulation rather than, necessarily, investment. The reason for the distinction is that the excessive response of the scrapping margins and intertemporal substitution effects on the creation side may end up dampening actual investment. See Caballero and Hammour (1996a).
856
R.J Caballero
The equilibrium implications of incomplete contracts also affect the scrapping decisions of firms. The easiest way to see this is to examine an existing production unit and ask how low its profitability would have to be for it to scrap itself and seek other opportunities. Moreover, assume that neither factor suffers from specificity in this production unit, so that the efficient rule is scrap whenever profitability is less than y. Two, apparently contradictory, features characterize the incomplete contracts economy. First, because the opportunity cost of factors of production is depressed by the excessive allocation to autarky, there is sclerosis; that is, there are units with profitability below y which are not scrapped because the opportunities in autarky are depressed. Second, given the depressed level of investment, there is excessive destruction. Since the appropriating factor earns rents in joint production, some of them leave socially valuable production units in order to improve their chances of earning these excess returns. Caballero and Hammour (1998a,b) argue that, over the long run, capital/labor substitution takes place. If capital is being appropriated, it will seek to exclude labor from joint production by choosing a capital intensive technology. This effect goes beyond purely neoclassical substitution, as it also seeks to reduce the appropriability problem 70. At a general level, of course, unenforceability of contracts results from the absence of well defined property rights. There is plenty of evidence on the deleterious consequences of such problems for investment. Two recent examples in the literature are Besley (1995) and Hall and Jones (1996). The former provides a careful description of land rights in different regions of Ghana. He documents that an "extra right" over a piece of land increases investment in that land by up to 9 percent in Anloga and up to 28 percent in Wassa 71. Hall and Jones (1996) use a large cross section of countries to show, among other things, that capital/labor ratios are strongly negatively related to "divertment activities." 5.2.2. Credit constraints
There is by now a large body of evidence supporting the view that credit constraints have substantial effects on firm level investment. Although there are a number of qualifications to specific papers in the literature, the cumulative evidence seems overwhelmingly in favor of the claim that investment is more easily financed with internal than external funds 72. I will not review this important literature here because there are already several good surveys 73.
70 We argue that this is a plausible factor behind the large increase in capital/labor ratios in Europe relative to the USA. 71 Rights to sell, to rent, to bequeath, to pledge, to mortgage, etc. 72 For a dissenting view, see e.g. Kaplan and Zingales (1997) and Cummins, Hassett and Oliner (1996b). 73 See e.g. Bernanke et al. (1996, 1999) and Hubbard (1995) for recent ones.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
857
While there are extensive empirical and theoretical microeconomic literatures, the macroeconomics literature on credit constraints is less developed. Notable exceptions are: Bernanke and Gertler (1989, 1990), Kiyotaki and Moore (1997) and Greenwald and Stiglitz (1993)74. Although the exact mechanisms are not always the same, many of the aggregate insights of this literature can be described in terms of the results in the preceding subsections. Changing slightly the interpretation of factor 2, from labor to entrepreneurs, allows us to use Figure 5.1 to characterize credit constraints. Rationing in the labor market becomes rationing of credit available to projects. To the left of point B, which is the region analyzed in the literature, net investment is too responsive to shocks; there is more credit rationing as the state of the economy declines; and there is underinvestment in general. Internal funds and collateralizable assets reduce the extent of the appropriability problem by playing the role of a bond, and introduce heterogeneity and therefore ranking of entrepreneurs. Since the value of collateral is likely to decline during a recession, there is an additional amplification effect due to the decline in the feasibility of remedial "bonding" 75.
6. Conclusion and outlook
This survey started by arguing that the long run relationship between aggregate capital, output and the cost of capital is not very far from what is implied by the basic neoclassical model: in the US, the elasticity of the capital-output ratio with respect to permanent changes in the cost of capital is close to minus one. In the short run things are more complex. Natural-experiments have shown that, in the cross section, the elasticity of investment with respect to changes in investment tax credits is much larger than we once suspected. How to go from these microeconomic estimates to aggregates, and to the response of investment to other types of shocks is not fully resolved. We do know, however, that these estimates represent expected values of what seems to be a very skewed distribution of adjustments. A substantial fraction of a firm's investment is bunched into infrequent and lumpy episodes. Aggregate investment is heavily influenced by the degree of synchronization of microeconomic investment spikes. For US manufacturing, the short run (annual) elasticity of investment with respect to changes in the cost of capital is less than one tenth the long run response when the economy has had a depressed immediate history, while this elasticity can rise by over 50 percent when the economy is undergoing a sustained expansion.
74 Also see Gross (1994) for empirical evidence and a model integrating financial constraints and irreversibility. 75 See e.g. Kiyotaki and Moore (1997).
858
R.J Caballero
Still, the mapping from microeconomics to aggregate investment dynamics especially equilibrium aggregate investment dynamics - is probably more complex than just the direct aggregation o f very non-linear investment patterns. Informational problems lead to a series o f strategic delays which feed into and feed off o f the natural inaction o f lumpy adjustment models. This process has the potential to exacerbate significantly the time varying n a c r e o f the elasticity o f aggregate investment with respect to aggregate shocks. Moreover, sunk costs provide fertile ground for opportunistic behavior. In the absence o f complete contracts, aggregate net investment is likely to become excessively volatile. The lack o f response o f equilibrium payments to complementary - and otherwise inelastic - factors (e.g. workers), exacerbates the effects o f shocks experienced b y firms. Also, the withdrawal o f financiers' support during recessions further reduces investment. Thus, capital investment seems to be hurt at both ends: workers that do not share fairly during downturns, and financiers that want to limit their exposure to potential appropriations from entrepreneurs which cannot credibly commit not to do so during the recovery. The last two themes, equilibrium outcomes with informational problems and opportunism, are wanting for empirical work. I therefore suspect that we will see plenty o f research filling this void in the near future.
References Abel, A.B. (1979), Investment and the Value of Capital (Garland, New York). Abel, A.B., and J.C. Eberly (1994), "A unified model of investment under uncertainty", American Economic Review 84(December):1369-1384. Abel, A.B., and J.C. Eberly (1996a), "Investment and q with fixed costs: an empirical analysis", mimeograph (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, January). Abel, A.B., and J.C. Eberly (1996b), "The effects of irreversibility and uncertainty on capital accumulation", mimeograph (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, May). Abel, A.B., A.K. Dixit, J.C. Eberly and R.S. Pindyck (1996), "Options, the value of capital, and investment", Quarterly Journal of Economics 111(3, August):753-777. Acemoglu, D. (1996), "A microfoundation for social increasing returns in human capital accumulation", Quarterly Journal of Economics 111(3, August):779-804. Atkeson, A., and EJ. Kehoe (1997), "Models of energy use: putty-putty vs. Putty-clay", Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department, Staff Report 230 (March). Auerbach, A.J., and K.A. Hassett (1992), "Tax policy and business fixed investment in the United States", Journal of Public Economics 47(2):141-170. Barnett, S., and E Sakellaris (1995), "Non-linear response of firm investment to Q: testing a model of convex and non-convex adjustment costs", mimeograph (University of Maryland, August). Benhabib, J., and A. Rustichini (1993), "A vintage model of investment and growth: theory and evidence", in: R. Becker, ed., General Equilibrium, Growth and Trade, vol. II (Academic Press, New York). Bernanke, B.S., and M. Gertler (1989), "Agency costs, net worth, and business fluctuations", American Economic Review 95:14-31. Bernanke, B.S., and M. Gertler (1990), "Financial fragility and economic performance", Quarterly Journal of Economics 105:87-114.
Ch. 12: Aggregate Investment
859
Bernanke, B.S., M. Gertler and S. Gilchrist (1996), "The financial accelerator and the flight to quality", Review of Economics and Statistics 78:1-15. Bernanke, B.S., M. Gertler and S. Gilchrist (1999), "The financial accelerator in a quantitative business cycle framework", ch. 21, this Handbook. Bertola, G. (1988), "Adjustment costs and dynamic factor demands: investment and employment under uncertainty", Ph.D. Dissertation (MIT, Cambridge, MA). Bertola, G. (1992), "Labor turnover costs and average labor demand", Journal of Labor Economics 10(4):389-411. Bertola, G., and R.J. Caballero (1990), "Kinked adjustment costs and aggregate dynamics", in: O.J. Blanchard and S. Fischer, eds., NBER Macroeconomics Annual (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) 237-288. Bertola, G., and R.J. Caballero (1994), "Irreversibility and aggregate investment", Review of Economic Studies 61(2, April):223-246. Besley, T. (1995), "Property rights and investment incentives: theory and evidence from Ghana", Journal of Political Economy 103(5, October):903-937. Blanchard, O.J. (1986), "Investment, output, and the cost of capital: a comment", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1986(1):153-158. Blanchard, O.J., and M. Kremer (1996), "Disorganization", mimeograph (MIT, October). Brainard, W.C., and J. Tobin (1968), "Pitfalls in financial model building", American Economic Review 58(May):99-122. Caballero, R.J. (1993a), "On the dynamics of aggregate investment", in: L. Serven and A. Solimano, eds., Striving for Growth After Adjustment, The Role of Capital Formation (The World Bank, Washington, DC) 81-106. Caballero, R.J. (1993b), "Durable goods: an explanation for their slow adjustment", Journal of Political Economy 101(2, April):351-384. Caballero, R.J. (1994a), "Small sample bias and adjustment costs", Review of Economics and Statistics 76(I, February):52-58. Caballero, R.J. (1994b), "A reconsideration of investment behavior using tax reforms as natural experiments: a comment", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1994(2):62 68. Caballero, R.J., and E. Engel (1999), "Explaining investment dynamics in U.S. manufacturing: a generalized (S, s) approach", Econometrica 67(4, July). Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1994), "The cleansing effect of recessions", American Economic Review 84(5, December):1350-1368. Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1996a), "On the timing and efficiency of creative destruction", Quarterly Journal of Economics 111(3, August):805-852. Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1996b), "On the ills of adjustment", Journal of Development Economics 51(1, October):161-192. Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1997b), "Improper churn: financial constraints and factor markets", mimeograph (MIT, May). Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1998a), "The macroeconomics of specificity", Journal of Political Economy 106(4, August):724-767. Caballero, R.J., and M.L. Hammour (1998b), "Jobless growth: appropriability, factor substitution, and unemployment", Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 48(June):51-94. Caballero, R.J., and J. Leahy (1996), "Fixed costs: the demise of marginal q", Working paper No. 5508 (NBER, March). Caballero, R.J., and R.S. Pindyck (1996), "Uncertainty, investment, and industry evolution", International Economic Review 37(3, August):641-662. Caballero, R.J., E. Engel and J. Haltiwanger (1995), "Plant-level adjustment and aggregate investment dynamics", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1995(2):1-54. Campbell, J.R. (1997), "Entry, exit, embodied technology, and business cycles", Working Paper No. 5955 (NBER, March).
860
R.J Caballero
Campbell, J.R., and J.D.M. Fisher (1996), "Aggregate employment fluctuations with microeconomic asymmetries", mimeograph (University of Rochester, August). Caplin, A., and J. Leahy (1993), "Sectoral shocks, learning, and aggregate fluctuations", Review of Economic Studies 60(4, October):777-794. Caplin, A., and J. Leahy (1994), "Business as usual, market crashes and wisdom after the fact", American Economic Review 84(3, June):54%565. Chamley, C., and D. Gale (1994), "Information revelation and strategic delay", Econometrica 62: 1065-1085. Chirinko, R.S. (1993), "Business fixed investment spending: a critical survey of modelling strategies, empirical results, and policy implications", Journal of Economic Literature 31 (December): 1875-1911. Clark, J.M. (1917), "Business acceleration and the law of demand: a technical factor in economic cycles", Journal of Political Economy 25(March):217-235. Clark, J.M. (1944), "Additional note on business acceleration and the law of demand", in: American Economic Association, Readings in Business Cycle Theory (Blackiston Company, Philadelphia, PA). Cooley, T.E, J. Greenwood and M. Yornkoglu (1997), "The replacement problem", Working paper No. 444 (Rochester Center for Economic Research, August). Cooper, R., J. Haltiwanger and L. Power (1994), "Machine replacement and the business cycle: lumps and bumps", mimeograph (Boston University). Cummins, J.G., K.A. Hassett and R.G. Hubbard (1994), "A reconsideration of investment behavior using tax reforms as natural experiments", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1994(2):1-59. Cummins, J.G., K.A. Hassett and R.G. Hubbard (1996a), "Tax reforms and investment: a cross country comparison", Journal of Public Economics 62(1/2, October):237-273. Cummins, J.G., K.A. Hassett and S.D. Oliner (1996b), "Investment behavior, internal funds, and observable expectations", mimeograph (New York University, October). Dixit, A. (1989), "Entry and exit decisions under uncertainty", Journal of Political Economy 97:620-638. Dixit, A. (1993), The Art of Smooth Pasting (Harwood Academic Publishers, Langhorns, PA). Doms, M., and T. Dunne (1993), "An investigation into capital and labor adjustment at the plant level", mimeograph (Center for Economic Studies, Census Bureau). Eisner, R. (1969), "Tax policy and investment behavior: a comment", American Economic Review 59(June):379-388. E1 Karoui, N., and I. Karatzas (1991), "A new approach to the Skorohod problem, and its applications", Stochastics 34:57-82. Fallick, B.C., and K.A. Hassert (1996), "Investment and union certification", Discussion paper No. 1996-43 (FED, November). Fazzari, S.M., R.G. Hubbard and B.C. Petersen (1988), "Financing constraints and corporate investment", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1988(1):141-195. Gale, D. (1995), "What have we learned from social learning?", mimeograph (Boston University, August). Gilchrist, S., and J.C. Williams (1996), "Putty-clay and investment: a business cycle analysis", mimeograph (Boston University, May). Goolsbee, A. (1995a), "Investment tax incentives and the price of capital goods", mimeograph (Chicago GSB). Goolsbee, A. (1995b), "Factor prices and the retirement of capital goods", mimeograph (Chicago GSB,
July). Goolsbee, A. (1997), "The incidence of investment tax subsidies: to the workers go the spoils?", mimeograph (Chicago GSB, February). Goolsbee, A., and D.B. Gross (1997), "Estimating adjustment costs with data on heterogeneous capital goods", mimeograph (Chicago GSB, September). Greenspan, A., and D. Cohen (1996), "Motor vehicles stocks, scrappage, and sales", Working paper No. 1996-40 (FED, October).
Ch. 12:
Aggregate Investment
861
Greenwald, B., and J. Stiglitz (1993), "Financial market imperfections and business cycles", Quarterly Journal of Economics 108(1, Febrnary):77-114. Gross, D. (1994), "The investment and financing decisions of liquidity constrained firms", mimeograph (Chicago GSB). Grout, RA. (1984), "Investment and wages in the absence of binding contracts: a Nash bargaining approach", Econometrica 52(2, March):449-460. Hall, R.E., and C.I. Jones (1996), "The productivity of nations", mimeograph (Stanford University, August). Hall, R.E., and D.W Jorgenson (1967), "Tax policy and investment behavior", American Economic Review 57(3, June):391-414. Hart, O. (1995), Firms, Contracts and Financial Structure, Clarendon Lectures in Economics (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Hassett, K.A., and R.G. Hubbard (1996a), "New evidence concerning the openness of the world market for capital goods", mimeograph (Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, June). Hassett, K.A., and R.G. Hubbard (1996b), "Tax policy and investment", Working Paper No. 5683 (NBER, July). Hayashi, E (1982), "Tobin's marginal Q and average Q: a neoclassical interpretation", Econometrica 50(1, January):213-224. Hopenhayn, H.A. (1992), "Entry, exit, and firm dynamics in long run equilibrium", Econometrica 60:1127-1150. Hubbard, R.G. (1995), "Capital-market imperfections and investment", mimeograph (Columbia University). Jorgenson, D.W.. (1963), "Capital theory and investment behavior", American Economic Review 53(2, May):247-259. Jovanovic, B. (1997), "Obsolescence of capital", mimeograph (New York University, February). Kaplan, S.N., and L. Zingales (1997), "Do investment-cash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of financing constraints?, Quarterly Journal of Economics 112(1, February):169 216. Kiyotaki, N., and J. Moore (1997), "Credit cycles", Journal of Political Economy 105(2, April):211~48. Koyck, L.M. (1954), Distributed Lags and Investment Analysis (North-Holland, Amsterdam). KriegeL S. (1997), "The general equilibrium dynamics of investment, scrapping and reorganization in an economy with firm level uncertainty", mimeograph (Chicago, July). Leahy, J. (1993), "Investment in competitive equilibrium: the optimality of myopic behavior", Quarterly Journal of Economics 108:1105-1133. Meyer, J.R., and E. Kuh (1957), The Investment Decision: An Empirical Study (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA). Nickell, S.J. (1978), The Investment Decisions of Firms (Cambridge University Press, Oxford). Oliner, S.D., G.D. Rudebusch and D. Sichel (1995), "New and old models of business investment: a comparison of forecasting performance", Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 27:806-826. Pindyck, R.S. (1988), "Irreversible investment, capacity choice, and the value of the firm", American Economic Review 78(5, December):969-985. Ramey, G., and J. Watson (1996), "Contractual fragility, job destruction and business cycles", mimeograph (University of California at San Diego, June). Rivers, D., and Q.H. Vuong (1991), "Model selection tests for nonlinear dynamic models", Working paper No. 91-08 (University of Toulouse). Rotemberg, J.J. (1987), "The new Keynesian microfoundations", in: O.J. Blanchard and S. Fischer, eds., NBER Macroeconomics Annual 1987 (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) 6~104. Rothschild, M. (1971), "On the cost of adjustment", Quarterly Journal of Economics 85(November): 605-622. Salter, W.E.G. (1960), Productivity and Technical Change (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge). Shapiro, M.D. (1986), "Investment, output, and the cost of capital", Brookings Papers of Economic Activity 1986(1):111 152.
862
R.J. Caballero
Simons, H.C. (1944), "Some reflections on syndicalism", Journal of Political Economy 52:125. Stock, J.H., and M.W Watson (1993), "A simple MLE of cointegrating vectors in higher order integrated systems", Econometrica 61(4, July):783-820. Tinbergen, J. (1939), "A method and its application to investment activity", in: Statistical Testing of Business Cycle Theories, vol. 1 (Economic Intelligence Service, Agathon Press, New York). Tobin, J. (1969), "A general equilibrium approach to monetary theory", Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 1:15-29. Williamson, O.E. (1979), "Transaction-cost economics: the governance of contractual relations", Journal of Law and Economics 22(2, October):233-261. Williamson, O.E. (1985), The Economic Institutions of Capitalism (Free Press, New York).
Chapter 13
INVENTORIES * VALERIE A. RAMEY
University of California - San Diego KENNETH D. WEST
University of Wisconsin
Contents Abstract Keywords Introduction 1. Sectoral and secular behavior of inventories 2. Two stylized facts about inventory behavior 2.1. Procyclical inventory movements 2.1.1. Illustrative evidence 2.1.2. A survey of results 2.2. Persistent movements in the inventory-sales relationship 2.2.1. Illustrative evidence 2.2.2. A survey of results
3. Linear quadratic models 3.1. Introduction 3.2. A model 3.3. A first-order condition 3.4. Whose inventories?
4. Decision rule 4.1. Introduction 4.2. Derivation of decision rule 4.3. Persistence in the inventory-sales relationship 4.4. Summary on persistence in the inventory-sales relationship
5. The flexible accelerator model
864 864 865 868 872 873 873 875 877 877 880 882 882 882 885 887 887 887 888 891 892 893
* We thank the National Science Foundation and the Abe Foundation for financial support; Clive Granger, Donald Hester, James Kahn, Anil Kashyap, Linda Kole, Spencer Krane, Scott Schuh, Michael Woodford and a seminar audience at the University of Wisconsin for helpful comments and discussions; and James Hueng and especially Stanislav Anatolyev for excellent research assistance. Email to: kdwest @ facstaff, wisc. edu; vrameyOweber, ucsd. edu.
Handbook of Macroeconomics, Volume 1, Edited by J.B. Taylor and M. Woodford © 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserued 863
864 6. Dynamic responses 7. Empirical evidence 7.1. Introduction 7.2. Magnitude of cost parameters 7.3. Shocks 7.4. Interpretation 8. Directions for future research 8.1. Introduction 8.2. Inventories in production and revenue functions 8.3. Models with fixed costs 8.4. The value of more data 9. Conclusions Appendix A. Data Appendix Appendix B. Technical Appendix B.1. Solution of the model B.2. Computation of E(Q2 - S2) B.3. Estimation of B.4. Social planning derivation of the model's first-order conditions References
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
894 902 902 903 906 906 909 909 909 910 911 912 913 914 914 919 919 919 920
Abstract We review and interpret recent work on inventories, emphasizing empirical and business cycle aspects. We begin by documenting two empirical regularities about inventories. The first is the well-known one that inventories move procyclically. The second is that inventory movements are quite persistent, even conditional on sales. To consider explanations for the two facts, we present a linear-quadratic model. The model can rationalize the two facts in a number o f ways, but two stylized explanations have the virtue o f relative simplicity and support from a number o f papers. Both assume that there are persistent shocks to demand for the good in question, and that marginal production cost slopes up. The first explanation assumes as well that there are highly persistent shocks to the cost o f production. The second assumes that there are strong costs of adjusting production and a strong accelerator motive. Research to date, however, has not reached a consensus on whether one of these two, or some third, alternative provides a satisfactory explanation o f inventory behavior. We suggest several directions for future research that promise to improve our understanding o f inventory behavior and thus o f business cycles.
Keywords J E L classification: E22, E32
Ch. 13:
Inventories
865
Introduction In developed countries, inventory investment typically averages less than one-half of one percent of GDP, whereas fixed investment averages 15% of GDP and consumption two-thirds. Perhaps with these fractions in mind, macroeconomists have concentrated more on the study of consumption and fixed investment than on inventories. Inventories generally do not appear as separate variables in dynamic general equilibrium models, nor in exactly identified vector autoregressive models. It has long been known, however, that other ways o f measuring the importance of inventories suggest that inventories should receive more attention, especially in business cycle research. Half a century ago, Abramowitz (1950) established that US recessions prior to World War II tended to be periods of inventory liquidations. Recent experience in the G7 countries indicates this regularity continues to hold, and not just for the USA. In six of the seven G7 countries (Japan is the exception), real GDP fell in at least one recent year. Line 2 of Table 1 shows that in five of those six countries (the United Kingdom is now the exception), inventory investment also declined during the period of declining GDP, accounting in an arithmetical sense for anywhere 12-71% of the fall in GDE And Table 1 's use of annual data may understate the inventory contribution: Table 2 indicates that for quarterly US data, the share is 49 rather than 12% for the 1990-1991 recession, with 49 a typical figure for a post-War US recession. Such arithmetical accounting of course does not imply a causal relationship. But it does suggest that inventory movements contain valuable information about cyclical fluctuations. In this chapter, we survey and interpret recent research on inventories, emphasizing empirical and business cycle aspects. Among other points, we hope to convince the reader that inventories are a useful resource in business cycle analysis. They may be effective in identifying both the mechanisms of business cycle propagation and the sources o f business cycle shocks. Our chapter begins by documenting two facts about inventories. The first is the well-known one that inventories move procyclically. They tend to be built up in expansions, drawn down in contractions. The second, and not as widely appreciated, fact is that inventory movements are quite persistent, even conditional on sales. In many data sets, inventories and sales do not appear to be cointegrated, and the firstorder autocorrelations of supposedly stationary linear combinations of inventories and sales are often around 0.9, even in annual data. To consider explanations for the two facts, we use a linear quadratic/flexible accelerator model, which is the workhorse for empirical research on inventories. In our model, one source of persistence is from shocks to demand for the good being put in inventory - "demand" shocks. ("Demand" is in quotes because we, and the literature more generally, do not attempt to trace the ultimate source of such shocks; for example, for an intermediate good, the shocks might be driven mainly by shocks to the technology of the industry that uses the good in production.) But even if this shock has a unit root, our model yields a stationary linear combination of inventories
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
866
Table 1 Arithmetical importance of inventory change in recessions of the 1990s (annual data)a Country
Canada France
(1) Peak year trough year b (2) Peak-~ough change in inventory change as percentage ofpeak-to-~oughfallin GDP c
West Italy Japan Germany
UK
USA
1989 1991
1992 1993
1992 1993
1992 1993
n.a.
1990 1992
1990 1991
50
71
19
30
n.a.
-0.
12
a The figures are based on annual real data. The inventory change series is computed by deflating the annual nominal change in inventories in the National Income and Product Accounts by the GDP deflator; see the Data Appendix. b The trough year was found by working backwards from the present to the last year of negative real GDP growth in the 1990s. There were no such years in Japan. The peak year is the last preceding year of positive real GDP growth. c Computed by multiplying the following ratio by 100: inventory change in trough year-inventory change in peak year GDP in trough year- GDP in peak year By construction, the denominator of this ratio is negative. A positive entry indicates that the numerator (the change in the inventory change) was also negative. The negative entry for the United Kingdom indicates that the change in the inventory change was positive.
Table 2 Arithmetical importance of inventory changes in post-war US recessions (quarterly data) a Peak quarter-trough quarter
Peak-to-trough inventory change as a percentage of peak-to-trough fall in GDP
1948:4-1949:2
130
1953:2-1954:2
41
1957:1-1958:1
21
1960:1-1960:4
122
1969:3-1970:1
127
1973:4-1975:1
59
1980:1-1980:3
45
1981:3-1982:3
29
1990:2-1991:1 b
49
a The figures are based on quarterly real data. See the notes to Table 1 for additional discussion. b The figure for the 1990-1991 recession differs from that for the USA in Table 1 mainly because quarterly data were used. It also differs because in this table the inventory change is measured in chain weighted 1992 dollars, whereas Table 1 uses the nominal inventory change deflated by the GDP deflator.
Ch. 13: Inventories
867
and sales. This stationary linear combination can be considered a linear version of the inventory-sales ratio. We call it the inventory-sales relationship. And our second inventory fact is that there is persistence in this relationship. While the model is rich enough that there are many ways to make it explain the two facts, we focus on two stylized explanations that have the virtue of relative simplicity, as well as empirical support from a number of papers. Both explanations assume a upward sloping marginal production cost (a convex cost function). The first explanation also assumes that fluctuations are substantially affected by highly persistent shocks to the cost of production. Cost shocks will cause procyclical movement because times of low cost are good times to produce and build up inventory, and conversely for times of high cost. As well, when these shocks are highly persistent a cost shock that perturbs the inventory-sales relationship will take many periods to die off, and its persistence will be transmitted to the inventory-sales relationship. The second explanation assumes that there are strong costs of adjusting production and a strong accelerator motive. The accelerator motive links today's inventories to tomorrow's expected sales, perhaps because of concerns about stockouts. Since sales are positively serially correlated, this will tend to cause inventories to grow and shrink with sales and the cycle, a point first recognized by Metzler (1941). As well, with strong costs of adjusting production, if a shock perturbs the inventory-sales relationship, return to equilibrium will be slow because firms will adjust production only very gradually. Both explanations have some empirical support. But as is often the case in empirical work, the evidence is mixed and ambiguous. For example, the cost shock explanation works best when the shocks are modelled as unobservable; observable cost shifters, such as real wages and interest rates, seem not to affect inventories. And the literature is not unanimous on the magnitude of adjustment costs. While the literature has not reached a consensus, it has identified mechanisms and forces that can explain basic characteristics of inventory behavior and thus of the business cycle. We are optimistic that progress can continue to be made by building on results to date. Suggested directions for future research include alternative ways of capturing the revenue effects of inventories (replacements for the accelerator), alternative cost structures and the use of price and disaggregate data. The chapter is organized as follows. Section 1 presents some overview information on the level and distribution of inventories, using data from the G7 countries, and focussing on the USA. We supply this information largely for completeness and to provide a frame of reference; the results in this section are referenced only briefly in the sequel. Section 2 introduces the main theme of our chapter (business cycle behavior of inventories) by discussing empirical evidence on our two facts about inventories. Procyclical movement is considered in Section 2.1, persistence in the inventory-sales relationship in Section 2.2. In these sections, we use annual data from the G7 countries and quarterly US data for illustration, and also summarize results from the literature.
868
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
Sections 3 - 7 develop and apply our linear quadratic/flexible accelerator model. Sections 3-5 present the model. Much o f the analysis in these three sections relates to the process followed by the inventory-sales relationship, because this process has not received much direct attention in existing literature. The discussion focuses on analytical derivations, for the most part deferring intuitive discussion about how the model works to Section 6. That section aims to develop intuition by presenting impulse responses for various configurations o f parameters. Section 7 reviews empirical evidence from studies using the model. In Section 8, we discuss extensions and alternative approaches, including models that put inventories directly in production and profit functions, models with fixed costs, and the use o f different data. Section 9 concludes. A Data Appendix describes data sources, and a Technical Appendix contains some technical details.
I. Seetoral and secular behavior of inventories In this section we use basic national income and product account data from the G7 countries, and some detailed additional data from the USA, to provide a frame of reference for the discussion to come. As just noted, for the most part this is background information that will not loom large in the sequel. Lines 1(a) and 1(b) of Table 3 present the m e a n and standard deviation of the real annual change in economy wide inventory stocks in the G7 countries, over the last 40 years. These were computed from the national income and product account data on Table 3 Basic inventory statistics Canada
France
West Germany
Italy
Japan
UK
USA
(1) Annual NIPA change in inventories, 1956 1995a,b (a) Mean
2.32
37.4
12.3
12.3
2.41
1.81
23.6
(b) Standard deviation
3.91
40.1
12.7
9.8
1.44
3.04
21.6
(2) Reference: 1995 GDP c
721
6882
2608
1351
453
584
6066
(3) 1995 Inventory leveld
131
n.a.
411
n.a.
71
104
971
a The inventory change series is computed by deflating the annual nominal change in inventories in the National Income and Product accounts by the GDP deflator; see the Data Appendix. Units for all entries are billions (trillions, for Italy and Japan) of units of own currency, in 1990 prices. b Sample periods are 1957-1994 for West Germany and 1960-1994 for Italy, not 1956-1995. c GDP entries for Italy and Germany are for 1994, not 1995. d The "level" entries for Canada, West Germany, Japan and the UK are computed by deflating the nominal end of year value by the GDP deflator; see the Data Appendix. The entry for the US is the Department of Commerce constant (chained 1992) dollar value for non-farm inventories, rescaled to a 1990 from a 1992 base with the GDP deflator.
869
Ch. 13." Inventories
Table 4 Sectoral distribution of US non-farm inventories a,b (1) Percent of total level, 1995
(2) Mean (s.d.) of change
(3) Mean (s.d.) of growth
100
21.4 (22.5)
3.5 (3.5)
37
7.0 (11.6)
2.8 (4.2)
Finished goods
13
2.5 (4.4)
3.0 (4.8)
Work in process
12
2.3 (5.9)
2.8 (6.0)
Raw materials
12
2.2 (5.4)
2.6 (6.2)
52
12.2 (13.4)
4.4 (4.5)
Retail
26
5.9 (10.3)
4.2 (6.7)
Wholesale
26
6.2 (7.3)
4.5 (4.8)
11
2.2 (5.1)
3.1 (5.8)
Total Manufacturing
Trade
Other
a Data are in billions of chained 1992 dollars, 1959:I-1996:IV. b The inventory change differs from the US data on changes in Tables 1 7 in coverage (Tables 1-3 include changes in farm inventories), in sample period (195%1996 here, 1956-I995 in Table 3) and in base year (1992 here and Table 2, 1990 in Tables 1 and 3). the change in aggregate inventories. See the notes to the table and the Data Appendix for details. Upon comparing line 1(a) to line 2, we see that in all seven countries, the average change in inventories is small, about one percent o f recent GDP in Italy, well less than that in other countries. Inventory changes are, however, reasonably volatile, with the standard deviation roughly as large as the mean in all seven countries. We have less complete data on the level (as opposed to the change) o f inventory stocks. Line 3 o f Table 3 indicates that in the countries for which we have been able to obtain data, total inventories are about one-sixth o f GDP. This implies a monthly inventory-sales ratio o f about 2, a value that will be familiar to those familiar with monthly US data. Table 4 has a breakdown o f US non-farm inventories by sector. We see in column 1 that about h a l f o f non-farm inventories are held by retailers and wholesalers (including
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
870 I
I
I
I
I
I
,I
I
I
I
I
06
o6
.9
~
current dollars
h
A
4
.8
,7
,'\ ,..,,,,',,,",
,,.
.6 "t " ~ ""
""~
•
'
chained 1992 dollars
,5
56
6b
66
76
year
ob
Fig. 1. Quarterly ratio of nonfarm inventories to final sales.
non-merchant wholesalers who are associated with particular manufacturers), whereas somewhat over a third are held by manufacturers. The remaining "other" category reflects holdings by a number of industries, including utilities, construction, and service companies. Like the aggregates in Table 3, investment in each of the components is positive on average, and has standard deviations about the same size as means. This applies whether one looks at arithmetic changes (column 2) or growth rates (column 3). For future reference, it will be useful to note that manufacturers' inventories of finished goods, which have received a fair amount of attention in the inventory literature, are only 13% of total inventories, and are not particularly volatile. Figure 1 plots the ratio of total non-farm inventories to final sales of domestic product. The dashed line uses real data (ratio of real inventories to real sales), the solid line nominal data. In the real data, the inventory series matches that in line 1 of Table 4, but over the longer sample 1947:I-1996:IV (Table 4 uses the 1959-1996 subsample because the disaggregate breakdown is not available 1947-1958.) The real ratio shows a run-up in the late 1960s and early 1970s, followed by a period of slight secular decline. At present, the ratio is modestly above its value at the start of our sample (0.63 vs. 0.56). It will be useful to note another fact for future reference. The figure suggests considerable persistence in the inventory-sales ratio, an impression borne out by estimates of first-order autocorrelations. These are 0.98 for the sample as whole, 0.93 if the autocorrelation is computed allowing for a different mean inventory-sales ratio for the 1947:I-1973:IV and 1974:I-1996:IV subsamples.
871
Ch. 13: Inuentories I 1096.7
I
I
I
I
-
.pi
.S I
I
E
20t.8 3513
'
17A3.97
final sales of domestic business
Fig. 2. Quarterly inventories and sales, 1947:1-1996:4, in billions of chained 1992 dollars.
Readers familiar with the monthly inventory-sales ratios commonly reported in the US business press may be surprised at the absence of a downward secular movement. Such monthly ratios typically rely on nominal data. The solid line in Figure 1 shows that the ratio of nominal non-farm inventories to nominal sales of domestic product indeed shows a secular decline. Evidently, the implied deflator inventories has not been rising as fast as that for final sales. We do not attempt to explain the differences between the nominal and real series. We do note, however, the nominal ratio shows persistence comparable to that of the real ratio. The estimate of the firstorder autocorrelation of the ratio is 0.97 whether or not we allow a different mean inventory-sales ratio for the 1947:I-1973:IV and 1974:I-1996:IV subsamples. To return to the secular behavior of the real series: we see from column 3 in Table 4 that the rough constancy of the overall ratio hides some heterogeneity in underlying components. In particular, raw materials, and to a lesser extent, work in progress, have been growing more slowly than the aggregate, implying a declining ratio to final sales. This fact was earlier documented by Hester (1994), who noted that possible explanations include just-in-time inventory management, outbasing of early stages of manufacturing to foreign countries, and a transitory response to transitory movements in costs. In the sequel we do not attempt to explain secular patterns in inventory-sales ratios; see Hester (1994) for a discussion of US data, for retail as well as manufacturing, West (1992a) and Allen (1995) for discussions of Japanese data. Instead we hope that the reader will take the message away from these tables that inventories and sales are positively related in the long run: they tend to rise together. This is illustrated quite
872
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
strikingly in Figure 2, which is a scatterplot o f the inventory and sales data. A second message in the tables and the autocorrelations reported above is that while inventory movements are small relative to GDP, they are volatile and persistent. Characterizing and explaining the stochastic, and especially business cycle, behavior o f inventories is the subject o f the rest o f this chapter.
2. Two stylized facts about inventory behavior Our essay focuses on the business cycle aspects o f inventory behavior, and is oriented around two stylized facts: (1) inventory movements areprocyclicaL (2) the inventorysales relationship is highly persistent (the inventory-sales relationship is our term for a linear version o f the inventory-sales ratio). These facts serve two purposes. First, they demonstrate the potential role o f inventories in understanding economic fluctuations. Second, they serve as a measure by which we j u d g e inventory models and, more generally, theories o f the business cycle. For each o f the two "facts", we present illustrative evidence from annual, postWorld War II data, for the G7 countries, as well as from quarterly post-War US data. We then review estimates from the literature. For the first o f our stylized facts (procyclical movements), Section 2.1.1 below presents estimates, Section 2.1.2 presents the review. Sections 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 do the same for the second o f our facts (persistence in the inventory-sales relationship). The remainder o f this introductory subsection describes the data used in both 2.1 and 2.2. For the G7 countries, we continue to use the aggregate (nation-wide) change in inventory stocks used in previous sections, and construct a time series o f inventory levels b y summing the change 1. We measure production as GDP and sales as final sales. The quarterly US inventory data are that used in the previous section, total non-farm inventory and final sales o f domestic product in chained 1992 dollars, and with sales measured at quarterly rates 2.
1 When we summed the AH t series, we initialized with H 0 _: 0. Given the tinearity of our procedures, the results would be identical if we instead used the AH t series to work forwards and backwards from the 1995 levels reported in Table 3. The reader should be aware that when prices are not constant, a series constructed by our procedure of summing changes typically will differ from one that values the entire level of stock at current prices. Those with access to US sources can get a feel for the differences by comparing the inventory change that figures into GDP (used in the G7 data, and in NIPA Tables 5.10 and 5.11) and the one implied by differencing the series for the level of the stock (used in our quarterly US data and NIPA Tables 5.12 and 5.13). 2 We repeated some of our quarterly calculations using final sales of goods and structures, which differs from total final sales because it excludes final sales of services. There were no substantive changes in results.
Ch. 13: Inventories
873
All of these measures are linked by the identity production = sales + (inventory investment), or
Qt = st +AHt,
(2.1)
where Qt is production, St are sales, and Ht is end of period t inventories. This relationship holds by construction, with St being final sales.
2.1. Procyclical inventory movements 2.1.1. Illustrative evidence Procyclicality o f inventory movements can be documented in several ways. A simple indication that inventories move procyclically is a positive correlation between inventory investment and final sales. Consider the evidence in Table 5. In column 1 we see that all the point estimates of the correlation are positive, with a typical value being 0.1-0.2. The correlation between sales and inventory investment is related to the relative variances of production and sales. As in Table 5, let "var" denote variance, "cov" covariance. Since (2.1) implies var(Q) = var(S) + var(AH) + 2 cov(S, AH), it follows from the positive correlation in column 1 that var(Q)> var(S) (column 2). Other indications of procyclical behavior include two variance ratios robust to the possible presence of unit autoregressive roots. The column 3 estimates indicate that var(AQt)/var(ASt)> 1, the column 4 estimates that E(Q2-S2t)>O. [E(Q~-S~) is essentially an estimate of var(Q)-var(S) robust to the presence of unit autoregressive roots; see the Technical Appendix.] To illustrate the pattern of correlation over different short-run horizons, we present impulse response functions. The responses are based on a bivariate VAR in the level of inventories and sales for the quarterly US data, including eight quarterly lags, a time trend, and breaks in the constant and trend at 1974. In accordance with this section's aim of presenting relatively unstructured evidence, we present responses to a one standard deviation shock to the VAR disturbances themselves, and not to orthogonalized shocks. Figure 3 shows the responses of inventories and sales to a disturbance to the sales equation, Figure 4 the responses to a disturbance to the inventory equation. To prevent confusion, we note that on the horizontal axis, we plot the pre-shock (period - 1 ) values of the variables; the shock occurs in period 0. Figures 3 and 4 both show a positive comovement of inventories and sales. In Figure 3, by construction the contemporaneous (period 0) response of inventories is zero. But the 7 billion (approximately) dollar rise in sales in period 0 is followed in the next quarter by a 1.5 billion dollar increase in inventories. Inventories continue to rise for the next five quarters, even after sales turn down. Both series smoothly decline together. Figure 4 shows that after a 3 billion dollar shock to inventories, sales rise by nearly 2 billion dollars. Both inventories and sales subsequently show some wiggles.
874
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
Table 5 Relative variability of output and final sales a-e Country
Period
(1) corr(S, AH)
(2) var(Q)/var(S)
(3) var(AQ)/ var(AS)
(4) 1 + [E(Q 2 - S 2)/ var(AS)]
Canada
1956 1995 1974-1995 1956 1995 1974-1995 1957-1994 1974-1994 1960-1994 1974-1994 1956-1995
0.14 0.17 0.17 0.32 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.11 0.23
1.16 1.21 1.36 1.63 1.10 1.08 1.30 1.27 1.07
1.53 1.55 1.65 2.09 1.36 1.27 1.81 1.83 1.10
1.41 1.24 1.68 1.41 1.01 1.03 1.12 1.08 1.30
1974-1995 1956-1995 1974-1995 1956-1995 1974-1995 1947:I-1996:IV 1974:I-1996:IV
0.51 0.28 0.26 0.26 0.25 0.30 0.14
1.15 1.21 1.17 1.19 1.21 1.26 1.13
1.08 1.52 1.38 1.48 1.50 1.39 1.40
1.12 1.10 1.04 1.12 0.98 1.41 1.48
France West Germany Italy Japan UK USA USA
a "var" denotes variance, "corr" correlation, Q = output, S = final sales, A H - change in inventories. The variables are linked by the identity Q = S + AH. b In all but the last row, data are annual and real (1990 prices), with Q=real GDP, S=real final sales, AH=real change in aggregate inventories. In the last row the data are quarterly and real (1992 prices), with S=final sales of domestic business goods and structures, AH=ehange in non-farm inventories, and Q _=S + AH. See the text and Data Appendix for sources. c In colmnns 1 and 2, Q and S were linearly detrended, with the full sample estimates allowing a shift in the constant and trend term in 1974 (1974:I in the last row); AH was defined as the difference between detrended Q and S. In columns 3 and 4, AQ and AS were simply demeaned, again with the full sample estimates allowing a shift in the mean in 1974 (1974:I). d In column 4, the term E(Q 2 - S 2) essentially is the difference between the variance of Q and the variance of S, computed in a fashion that allows for unit autoregressive roots in Q and S. See the Technical Appendix for further details. e The post-1973 sample, as well as the post-1973 shifts in the full sample estimates, were included to allow for the general slowdown in economic activity.
This s h o c k a p p e a r s to h a v e m o r e p e r s i s t e n t e f f e c t s t h a n does the sales s h o c k , w i t h i n v e n t o r i e s still over 2 b i l l i o n dollars a b o v e t h e i r initial level after six years. T h e i m p o r t a n t p o i n t is t h a t b o t h sets o f i m p u l s e r e s p o n s e f u n c t i o n s offer t h e s a m e p i c t u r e o f p r o c y c l i c a l i n v e n t o r i e s as t h e statistics i n Table 5. T h u s , i n v e n t o r i e s s e e m to a m p l i f y r a t h e r t h a n m u t e m o v e m e n t s i n p r o d u c t i o n .
Ch. 13. Inventories
875 I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Ig
2b
2~
I
I
I
lg
2b
2a
8.7077
v,%.
o~ 01
/ o
~
inventories
/
,--4
/ i ...........................................
~
o
~
~
quarter
Fig. 3. Response to sales equation shock, quarterly VAR. I
5.01083
I
I
I
/ " ~__ inventories d \ /.f-~
f_
(7} 01
d
~
quarter
Fig. 4. Response to inventory equation shock, quarterly VAR. 2.1.2. A survey o f results
As many readers no doubt are aware, similar findings have been reported for many though not all data sets. A brief summary of estimates o f variance inequalities in studies using aggregate data: Fukuda and Teruyama (1988) report comparable results
876
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
for industrialized countries, but also conclude that by contrast in less developed countries GDP tends to be smoother than final sales 3. Beaulieu and Miron (1992) report that in manufacturing in some industrialized countries, seasonals in production are no less variable than those in sales. For US quarterly economy-wide or monthly two-digit manufacturing data, the pattern is as pronounced as in Table 5. This applies first of all to demeaned or detrended data such as is reported in Table 5. For example, Blinder (1986a) reports var(Q)/var(S) > 1 for 18-20 two-digit manufacturing industries. It also applies to deterministic seasonals [West (1986), Miron and Zeldes (1988), Cecchetti et al. (1997)]: in US manufacturing, seasonal variation in production tends to be larger than seasonal variation in sales 4. Finally, for both deterministic and stochastic terms, studies that have taken sampling error into account sometimes but not always find it quite unlikely that sampling error alone accounts for the lack o f evidence production smoothing [West (1986, 1990b)]. Does aggregation substantially account for the lack of production smoothing evident in these studies, either because o f measurement error in aggregate data sets, or heterogeneity across firms? Probably not. It has been argued persuasively that disaggregate data measured in physical units are more accurate than the aggregate data used in most studies [see Fair (1989), Krane and Braun (1991), and Ramey (1991)] 5 But as summarized below, studies with disaggregate data still find production more variable than sales in many cases. For evaluation of the effects o f firm heterogeneity, analytical arguments are not particularly helpful. I f var(Q) > var(S) for a single firm, the inequality may be shown analytically to apply to an aggregate o f firms if each individual firm solves a linear quadratic problem such as the one presented below with identical parameters, regardless o f the correlation o f demand shocks across firms [West (1983)]. But if the cost functions are different for different firms, analytical results appear not to be available. Lai (1991) and Krane (1994) show by example that aggregate variance ratios might differ substantially from individual firm ratios. And even if we assume identical parameters across firms, which as just noted implies that var(Q)/var(S)<~ 1 in the aggregate, this aggregate ratio may be larger (or smaller) than that o f individual firms, with the direction o f the bias depending on the correlation across firms of demand shocks. So to consider possible biases from aggregation we must turn from analytical to empirical studies of data disaggregated to the firm or perhaps physical product level.
3 So far as we know, there have been no systematic attempts to explain this finding. It is possible that measurement error plays a large role. 4 Carpenter and Levy (1998) report a related finding: for manufacturing, the spectra of inventory investment and production show very high coherence at seasonal frequencies. 5 And the G7 data that we use for illustration are among the worst measured. In some countries, the change in inventories apparently is constructed at least initially as the difference between product and income estimates of GDP, and thus includes the statistical discrepancy. See West (1990a).
Ch. 13." Inventories
877
The disaggregate picture is broadly similar though less striking than the aggregate one, at least in the relatively well-studied USA. Production smoothing is markedly absent in the automobile industry [Blanchard (1983), Kashyap and Wilcox (1993)]. But Krane and Braun (1991) found production is less variable than sales in about two thirds of a set of 38 physical products. Finally, Schuh (1996) found deseasonalized production less variable than deseasonalized sales in only one fourth of 700 manufacturing firms; deterministic seasonals in production were less variable than those in sales in about half the firms. For the deseasonalized data, Schuh reports that the median ratio of production to sales variance was about 1.1, which is consistent with the US figure reported in column 2 of Table 5. 2.2. Persistent movements in the inventory-sales relationship Our second stylized fact is that the inventory-sales relationship is highly persistent. While there may be a steady state linear relationship between inventories and sales, movement towards that steady state is very slow. This characteristic may be more recognizable to inventory experts if it is stated as a "slow speed of adjustment"; a link between persistence in the inventory-sales relationship and the speed of adjustment is demonstrated formally in Sections 4 and 5 below. Section 2.2.1 illustrates this with the annual G7 and quarterly US data used above, Section 2.2.2 documents it with citations to various papers. 2.2.1. Illustrative evidence To illustrate persistence, we use a standard technique described in the Technical Appendix to attempt to find a stationary relationship between the levels of inventories and sales. This yields Ht - ~OSt for a parameter 0 estimated from the data. Those familiar with the literature on cointegration will recognize Ht - OSt as the (estimated) error-correction term if inventories and sales have unit autoregressive roots and are cointegrated. We refer to H t - OSt as the inventory-sales relationship, sinee it is a generalized linear version of the inventory-sales ratio. More precise terminology for this variable is "deviation from the long-run inventory-sales relationship." In our view, the disadvantages of the length of this term outweigh the advantages of being more precise. After obtaining 0, we estimate the first two autocorrelations in the putatively stationary variable Ht - "OSt, to gauge the extent of persistence in the relationship. We emphasize that our aim is merely to document quickly evidence of high persistence, not to work towards a complete time series model, nor even to endorse the use of unit roots as a modeling device; among other tasks, the latter would require testing for unit roots in Ht and St, perhaps allowing for a one-time shift in mean in 1974, and so on. Rather, this is a way of organizing facts and theories about inventories that has some rough plausibility for a wide range of data.
878
V..A. Ramey and K.D. West
Table 6 Persistence in stationary linear combinations of inventories and sales a,b Country
Period
(1) Estimate of cointegrating parameter 0
(2) First two autocorrelations of H t - OSt
Canada
1956-1995
0.16
0.92
0.82
France
1956-1995
0.31
0.95
0.89
West Germany
1957 1994
0.27
0.93
0.82
Italy
1960 1994
0.45
0.88
0.80
Japan
1956-1995
0.22
0.97
0.91
UK
1956-1995
0.20
0.95
0.87
USA
1956-1995
0.24
0.88
0.82
USA
1947:I-1996:IV
0.68
0.94
0.88
USA
1947:~1996:IV, H and S in logs
1.12
0.95
0.90
a See notes to Table 5 for description of data and variable definitions. b In the inventory-sales relationship H t - O S t , the estimate 0 is obtained with the Stock and Watson (1993) procedure to estimate a cointegrating vector. Details are in the Technical Appendix. If the inventory and sales series have unit autoregressive roots, the adjective "stationary" used in the title to this table applies only if the inventory and sales series in fact are cointegrated, and then only asymptotically.
Table 6 p r e s e n t s results. T h e T e c h n i c a l A p p e n d i x d e s c r i b e s c o m p u t a t i o n a l details. C o l u m n s 1 a n d 2 p r e s e n t the e s t i m a t e s o f 0 a n d t h e first two a u t o c o r r e l a t i o n s o f H t - OSt. I n c o l u m n 1, the e s t i m a t e s o f 0 are all p o s i t i v e , s u g g e s t i n g t h a t i n v e n t o r i e s a n d sales m o v e t o g e t h e r p o s i t i v e l y in t h e l o n g r u n 6. B u t e v e n i f this is the case, the result t h a t w e w i s h to e m p h a s i z e is in c o l u m n 2: all o f the first-order a u t o c o r r e l a t i o n s are a b o v e 0.8. T h e r e is o f c o u r s e a d o w n w a r d b i a s i n e s t i m a t e s o f a u t o c o r r e l a t i o n s n e a r 1, a n d a n a d d i t i o n a l b i a s i m p a r t e d b y t i m e a g g r e g a t i o n (recall t h a t t h e d a t a are a n n u a l or q u a r t e r l y r a t h e r t h a n m o n t h l y ) . T h e c o l u m n 2 e s t i m a t e s t h u s s u g g e s t that m e a n r e v e r s i o n takes p l a c e quite s l o w l y 7.
6 The technique used is not invariant to normalization. For the annual data, we re-estimated with S t on the left instead of H t. Positive estimates of (1/0) resulted. On the other hand, if time trends are
included, negative estimates of 0 result for 4 of the 7 annual data sets. 7 Consistent with the high autocorrelation, the null of no cointegration cannot be rejected at the 5% level in three of the seven annual data sets (Canada, Japan, USA), nor in the quarterly US data. This suggests that for these three countries an appropriate model might be one in which there is no steady-state linear relation between inventories and sales. As we shall see, the model to be presented rationalizes such lack of a steady state with unit root cost shocks. When we quickly investigated the extent to which a onetime change in regime in 1974 could account for the persistence, we got mixed results. With post-1974 annual data, the autocorrelations fell; what is perhaps notable is that in one case (the USA) the fall was dramatic, to 0.28 (vs. the 0.88 reported in Table 6). Next, using the quarterly data, we re-estimated using
Ch. 13: Inventories
879
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P-_ B.7077
B.7077 P-_ I/ -4.58753
inventory-sales relationship
V' quapteP Fig. 5. Response to sales equation shock, quarterly VAR.
We note that this g e n e r a l i z a t i o n applies w h e n we use logs instead o f levels o f inventories and sales (last r o w o f the table). We noted above that the i n v e n t o r y - s a l e s ratio displays h i g h autocorrelations. The upshot o f the last row is that transforming to logs, and a l l o w i n g 0 ¢ 1 - that is, considering not log(Hi~St) but log(Ht/S °) for a freely estimated 0 - still suggests considerable persistence 8. To illustrate the persistence f r o m a different perspective, Figures 5 and 6 depict the response o f sales and the i n v e n t o r y - s a l e s relationship to shocks, u s i n g the same V A R estimated for Figures 3 and 4. The sales responses are identical to those in Figures
the whole sample but allowing for different means in the 1947:I-1973:IV and 1974:I-1996:IV sample. This reduced the estimate only slightly, to 0.89 and 0.94 (vs. the 0.94 and 0.95 values in Table 6). Rossana (1998) carefully investigates the question of stability in two-digit US data. He finds evidence of instability, and lack of cointegration within subsamples. s Now seems an appropriate time to comment on the use of logs versus levels of the data, in response to comments by two of the readers of an earlier version of this paper. Much empirical work in inventories, and a distinct majority of work using intertemporal dynamic models, has relied on levels rather than logarithms of the variables in question. We follow that convention in most of this paper. Working in levels has the advantage of preserving the identity that links inventories, production and sales [see Equation (2.1)]. In addition, inventory investment, as reported by the National Income and Product Accounts, is defined as the change in the level of inventories, and is frequently negative, which further discourages the use of logarithms. In a few cases, such as in the last row of Table 6, we do use logarithms. That little turns on levels versus logs is suggested by the similarity of the results in the last two rows in Table 6, and, more generally of the review of the literature that we are about to present: flexible accelerator studies typically use data in logs, while linear quadratic studies typically use levels. Both find great persistence.
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
880 I
3.74996
~ . ,,'~'~
I
I
I
I
I
~
~4 "0 t~ t~ O~ ~4
0
quapter, Fig. 6. Response to inventoryequation shock, quarterlyVAR. 3 and 4. The inventory-sales relationship is computed using the estimated value of = 0.68 from Table 6 to form a linear combination of the impulse response functions for sales and inventories. In response to a positive one standard deviation shock to the sales equation, inventories rise, but less rapidly than do sales (see Figure 3). This induces the fall in the inventory-sales relationship depicted in Figure 5. Eventually, inventories build up more rapidly, leading to overshooting and an increase relative to the initial position. Since both inventories and sales are close to their pre-shock values after six years (see Figure 3), the inventory relationship returns as well, as Figure 5 shows. By contrast, a shock to the inventory equation leads to a complicated pattern displaying more persistence. The inventory-sales relationship rises initially by construction, and then declines erratically for eight quarters before briefly rising again and then slowly decaying. At the end of six years, a return to the pre-shock value is not evident: these unrestricted VAR estimates suggest great persistence in the inventory-sales relationship. 2.2.2. A suruey o f results
Table 6 and Figures 5 and 6 suggest that there is little mean reversion in economywide inventory-sales relationships. Congruent evidence comes from two sources, unstructured tests such as in Table 6, and structural estimates of what is called a "speed of adjustment". Consider first the unstructured tests. Using quarterly economy-wide data, West (1990b, 1992b) cannot reject the null of no cointegration for the USA and for
Ch. 13: Inventories
881
Japan. Using monthly US data, Granger and Lee (1989) find only mild evidence for cointegration in monthly two-digit manufacturing and trade series; fewer than a third of their 27 data sets reject the null of no cointegration at the 5% level, and the median first-order autocorrelation of the putatively stationary linear combination of inventories and sales is about 0.99. Rossana (1993, 1998) uses similar data and allows a vector of cost variables W t to enter the cointegrating relationship. He uses regression techniques to search for a combination H t - OSt - otI W t that is stationary. Wt is defined to include real wages, real materials prices, nominal interest rates and inflation. In the end, however, he finds mixed evidence of cointegration across H t , St and Wt. (He does not report autocorrelations o f stationary linear combinations.) In addition, a large literature has used structural inventory models to estimate the "speed of adjustment". We shall describe such models below. For the moment, what is relevant is that under conditions described below, a slow speed of adjustment is equivalent to persistence in the inventory-sales relationship. Let p be the largest autoregressive in H t - OSt, or H t - OSt - ct~Wt, with the latter variable the relevant one if, as in the Rossana (1993, 1998) papers cited above, a vector of cost variables is entered into the cointegrating relationship. The large empirical literature has estimated inventory equations, with results implying that ~ is near 1. A typical value in quarterly data is around 0.8-0.95. The following are some examples. Using quarterly economy-wide data for some industrialized countries, Wilkinson (1989) found ~ - 0.75-1.0, with W t including one or more of: sales shocks, inflation, wages, raw materials prices and capacity utilization. Similar results have repeatedly been found using monthly or quarterly US manufacturing data. Examples include Maccini and Rossana (1981), Blinder (1986b), and Haltiwanger and Maccini (1989). In these papers, Wt included one or more of: factor prices such as wages, raw materials prices and real and nominal interest rates, other factors of production such as labor, and sales expectational errors. Does aggregation across heterogeneous firms substantially account for this high serial correlation? We are not aware of analytical arguments establishing genera] conditions under which aggregate estimates of p will be higher than typical firmspecific estimates, though no doubt such arguments could be constructed. Simulations in Lovell (1993) and a limited amount of empirical evidence suggests that aggregation does impart a bias. Schuh (1996) reports that for monthly data for 700 manufacturing firms, the median estimate of p is about 0.6 (Wt includes a real interest rate); for quarterly data for some publicly owned firms, and with Wt including measures of credit conditions, ~ is reported to be about 0.6-0.8 by Carpenter et al. (1994, 1998), although a somewhat higher value of about 0.9 is found by Kashyap et al. (1994)10 9 The autocorrelation was computed from the Durbin-Watson statistic reported in the last column of Table II in Granger and Lee, using 2(1 -~) = d.w. 10 A small literature has discussed how estimation ofp is affected when the decision interval for firms is smaller than the sampling interval of the data [Christiano and Eichenbaum (1989), Jorda (1997)]. Such time aggregation does not appear capable of explaining the high persistence.
882
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
Of course, tests for cointegration have notoriously low power. And there is heterogeneity of estimates o f p implied by the flexible accelerator literature. But these results suggest that there is little evidence that mean reversion of Ht - OSt towards its mean takes place rapidly, and considerable evidence of persistence. To interpret such persistence, as well as the procyclical behavior discussed in the previous section, we now present a standard inventory model.
3. Linear quadratic models 3.1. Introduction
The linear quadratic inventory model dates back to Holt et al. (1960). Although this book is written in an operations research style that suggests that its main aim was to provide practical advice to managers, it may still be profitably reviewed by economists interested in inventory behavior. In fact, Holt et al. (1960) develop models more general than those in many of the applications we review here: they allow for stockout costs, order backlogs, and stochastic variation in costs. Early uses of a linear quadratic model to interpret macro data include Childs (1967) and Belsley (1969). Tools developed in the 1970s and 1980s to estimate and interpret decision rules and first-order conditions from rational expectations models [e.g., Hansen and Sargent (1980), Hansen and Singleton (1982)] were subsequently used by many authors to estimate one or another version of the model. Some papers used aggregate data (sometimes economy wide, sometimes at the two-digit level); some used data at the level of individual firms or physical products. It is this more recent literature that we review in this and the next four sections. The focus of this literature, and of our discussion, is on how production parameters and constraints influence the intertemporal interaction between production, sales and inventories. While different papers of course vary in the details of the model, there is sufficient commonality that the model presented in Section 3.2 may fairly be described as representative. Section 3.3 derives a first-order condition. Section 3.4 discusses whether the model is applicable to a wide range of inventories. Table 7 lists notation, and may be a useful reference in this and subsequent sections. 3.2. A model
We assume that a firm maximizes the present value of future cash flows. In macro applications this will be a representative firm. In the formal statement of the model about to be given, we omit constant, linear and trend terms for notational simplicity. Earlier work provides tediously detailed treatment o f such terms, allowing for trends that are either arithmetic [West (1983)] or geometric [working paper versions of West (1988, 1990b)].
Ch. 13:
Inventories
883 Table 7 Variable and parameter definitions a
A. Definitions of basic variables H t
inventories at end of period t
H t -H i
stationary linear combination o f l i t , S t and W t when Udt and W t have unit autoregressive roots, but Uct does not; H t - H i = H t - ( OS t + aI W t )
H t -- OS t
inventory-sales relationship
Qt
production in period t
St
sales in period t
Uct
cost shifters, Uct = ~ W t + uct
uct
cost shock, unobservable to the economist
Udt
demand shock, unobservable to the economist
Wt
vector of observable cost shifters
B. Definitions of basic parameters
Mnemonic
Description
a0
cost o f changing production
Section b 3.2
a1
cost o f production
3.2
a2
inventory holding cost
3.2
a3
accelerator term for inventories
3.2
b
discount factor
3.2
g
inverse of slope o f demand curve
4.2
a
a = - ( b a 2 ) ~(1- b ) a , coefficient vector on W t in H ;
3.3
coefficient vector on W t in Uct
3.2
0c
AR(1) coefficient of Uct , uct = 0cUct_l + ect
4.2
0d
AR(1) coefficient of Udt, Udt =0dUdt-I +edt
4.2
qSw
AR(1) matrix o f coefficients of W t , Wt = ~ w Wt 1 + ewt
4.2
0
= a 3 [al(1-b)/ba2] , coefficient on S t in H i
3.3
:~H
an autoregressive root in H t - H i when a 0 - 0
4.2
:v t, :v2
two autoregressive roots in H a H T when a 0 ~ 0
4.3
a All variables and parameters are scalars, with the exceptions of ewt, W t , a, ~t and q~w. The variables in panel A are introduced in Section 3.2. b Section where parameter is introduced.
W e u s e t h e f o l l o w i n g n o t a t i o n : P t is real p r i c e (say, r a t i o o f o u t p u t p r i c e to t h e w a g e ) , St
real sales, Q t real p r o d u c t i o n , H t
real e n d o f p e r i o d i n v e n t o r i e s , Ca real p e r i o d
c o s t s , b a d i s c o u n t f a c t o r , 0 ~< b < 1, a n d E t m a t h e m a t i c a l e x p e c t a t i o n s c o n d i t i o n a l o n
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
884
information known at time t, assumed equivalent to linear projections. The objective function is T
max l i m r ~
Et Z
bj(Pt +ySt +j - Ct +j)
j-o subject
(3.1)
to ~ Ct = 0.5a0AQ 2 + 0.5alQ 2 + 0.5a2(Ht-i - a3St) 2 + U c t Q t ,
( Qt = St + He -
He 1.
The scalar Uct is a cost shock, and, as discussed below, may depend on both observable and unobservable variables. The term Pt +jSt +j is revenue. The analysis in this section does not depend on specification of demand or market structure, so we defer discussion o f P t + j S t +j until the next section.
The cost function Ct allows two possible roles for inventories. One is a production smoothing role, in which inventories facilitate intertemporal allocation of production. (N.B.: in much of the inventory literature, the phrase "production smoothing" references smoothing from demand shocks; we use it to reference smoothing from cost shocks as well.) This role is reflected in the terms in AQ 2 and Q2. The second role is a revenue role, in which inventories allow a firm to satisfy demand that cannot be backlogged. This role is reflected in the " a 3 S t " term in (Ht-1 - a3St)2; (He 1 - a 3 S t ) 2 induces an accelerator motive. In our discussion o f these terms, we assume for the moment that a~ and a2 are positive, ao and a3 nonnegative. The first production smoothing term, aoAQ2t, captures increasing costs of changing production and of production. This represents, for example, hiring and firing costs. Not all authors include this term, and, as discussed in Section 7, some empirical tests find estimates of ao insignificantly different from zero. The second production smoothing term, a~Q 2, reflects costs of production. It can be interpreted as the second order term in a quadratic approximation to an arbitrary convex cost function associated with a decreasing returns to scale technology. In data with trends, this approximation would likely be around a growth path. (Recall that constant and trend terms are omitted for notational simplicity.) The accelerator term a 2 ( n t - 1 - a 3 S t ) 2 embodies inventory holding and backlog costs. Consider first when a3 = 0, so that the term becomes a2H2t 1. Then this can be interpreted as the second order term in a quadratic approximation to an arbitrary convex inventory holding cost function. When a3 ~ 0, the term is intended to reflect backlog (stockout) and batch as well as inventory holding costs, and thus captures a revenue-related motive for holding inventories. Stockout costs arise when sales exceed the stock on hand, perhaps entailing lost sales, perhaps entailing delayed payment if orders instead are backlogged. Batch costs vary inversely with the stock of inventories, since fewer production runs and larger lot sizes imply larger inventory levels on average. Ceteris paribus, the higher the stock of inventories, the less likely is a stockout and the lower are stockout costs. As well, higher stocks result when the number of batches
Ch. 13: Inventories
885
falls, since lot sizes rise. On the other hand, higher stocks entail higher inventory holding costs. This quadratic term approximates the tradeoff between the two costs, with a3 rising as stockout costs rise relative to backlog costs. Holt et al.'s (1960) formal derivation o f this time invariant approximation to this inherently nonlinear, and timevarying, cost is presented in Section 8. Note in any case that in many applications, inventories are strictly positive and large relative to sales in all time periods, perhaps in some data sets because o f aggregation over heterogeneous firms. So in such data, careful treatment of nonlinearity may have limited empirical payoff. Section 8 below discusses alternative approaches. The final term in the cost function is UotQt. This captures exogenous stochastic variation in costs. (We omit terms o f the form cost shock x A Q t and cost shock × H t to avoid needless algebraic complications.) In some applications Uct = 0 and this shock is absent [West (1986)]; in others it is not observed by the economist and follows an exogenous process [Eichenbaum (1989)]; in still others it has both observable and unobservable components [Ramey (1991)]. To cover all three cases, we write Uct = a' W t + Uct.
(3.2)
In (3.2), Wt is a vector o f observable components; uot is unobservable to the economist and follows an exogenous process. In one or another paper, Wt includes variables such as real wages, materials prices and real and nominal interest rates. If there are no such components, W t - 0; if cost shocks are entirely absent, Uct =- 0 as well. For convenience we refer to uct as a "shock", even though it may be serially correlated and partially or fully observable. 3.3. A first-order condition
A n optimizing firm will not expect to increase cash flow by producing one more unit this period, putting the unit in inventory, and decreasing production by one unit next period, all the while holding revenue constant. Formally, upon differentiating the objective function (3.1) with respect to H t we obtain 11 E t [a0(AQ, - 2bAQt +1 + b 2zxQt+2) + a l (Qt - bQt+ l) + ba2 (Ht - a3S,+ 1) + Uct
b Uct+i ] = O.
(3.3) For discussion of the second o f our stylized facts (persistence in the inventory-sales relationship), it will be helpful to note a low frequency implication o f Equation (3.3), namely, that inventories and sales are cointegrated if St is I(1) and Uct is I(0). [Here,
11 The first-order condition derived assuming that [O(pt+jSt+j)/OHt]- O. This assumption is not particularly appealing, since a 3 > 0 is motivated in part by stockout costs, and presumably increases in H t will decrease stockouts and increase revenues (increase p,St). As noted above, our modeling of stockout costs is crude but given data constraints in some applications the gains from more sophisticated treatments perhaps are small. See Section 8 below for alternative treatments.
EA. Ramey and K.D. West
886
we use standard time series notation: a variable that is integrated o f order 0 - I(0), for short - is one that is covariance stationary, with a spectrum that is finite and strictly positive at all frequencies. An "integrated" variable - I(1), for short - is one whose arithmetic difference is I(0). I(1) variables are sometimes called "difference stationary", or as having unit autoregressive roots (a term that we used in Section 2).] To see the cointegration result, write the term in brackets in Equation (3.3) as xt+2, so that (3.3) is Etxt+2 = 0. If we replace expectations with realizations, we can write (3.4)
Xt+2 = ~ t + 2 , tlt+2 ~ (Xt+2 -- Etxt+2) ~ I(0).
Note that even if some or all o f the variables that comprise xt+2 are integrated, ~t+2 will still be stationary. Kashyap and Wilcox (1993) observe that xt+2 may be rewritten Xt+2 =
ao( AQt - 2bAQt+l + b2 AQt+2) - b a l ( A H t + l
+
Agt+l) + all'r-It
- a2a3ASt+l - ba2OASt+l + ba2(Ht - OSt) + Uct - bEtUct+b
(3.5)
al(1 - b ) O~a
3
ba2
Suppose U c t ~ I ( O ) but H t , S t ~ I ( 1 ) . Then A H t ~ I ( O ) and A Q t ~ I ( O ) , and Equainventories and sales are tion (3.4) (stationarity o f xt+2) requires H t - O S t - I ( O ) : cointegrated with cointegrating parameter 0. We focus on St ~ I ( 1 ) for concreteness and empirical relevance, but it is worth noting that 0 is still economically interpretable in other cases. I f St and Uct are both I(0), then O = E H t / E S t is the inventory sales ratio evaluated at steady state values o f St and Hr. (Recall that we have omitted deterministic terms for notational simplicity.) I f St and H t have deterministic drift ( E A S t ~ 0) - which is consistent with Uct either I(0) or I(1), and St either I(1) or I(0) around trend 12 _ then O = E A H t / E A S t . Suppose there are observable cost shifters. I f Uct = ~ l W t + u c t with W t ~ I ( O ) or W t ~ I ( 1 ) [see Equation (3.2)] then from similar logic Uct~[(O) ~ H t - O S t + (ba2) 1(1 - b ) ' a I W t z H t - O S t - o f f W t =- H t - H t ~ I(0): after controlling for possibly nonstationary observable cost shifters, inventories and sales are cointegrated. (Once again, OSt + a ~W t remains economically interpretable under other conditions on presence or absence o f unit roots.) We summarize the preceding two paragraphs as follows: if St HI(l), H t - H t ~ I(0), Uot ~ I(O) Uct ~ I(O)
~ =~
H t = OSt, Ht -
1-b
O = a3 - al - ba2 '
OSt + a ' W t ,
a =_
(3.6)
l-b_
--a. ba2
Observe that this result does not require parametrization of the demand curve, or specification o f market structure. Rossana (1995, 1998) assumes exogenous revenue 12 A variable xt is 1(0) around trend if Ext = m o + m lt for some m l ~ 0 and xt -Ex~ = I(0). Such variables are sometimes called trend stationary.
Ch. 13: Inventories
887
and uses the resulting decision rule to provide a complementary proof that Uct ~ I(O) [Uct ~I(0)] implies cointegration between H t and St (between H t , St and Wt). 3.4. Whose inoentories?
The preceding description o f the model suggests that manufacturers' inventories o f finished goods are a natural area for applying the model. Indeed, a large fraction of the inventory literature focuses on manufacturers' finished goods inventories, often in six two-digit industries that are known as "production to stock". 13 To some, in fact, the model is not a particularly attractive one for studying any other types of inventories [e.g., Blinder and Maccini (1991)]. In connection with our discussion of Table 4's sectoral breakdown o f US inventories, however, we noted that manufacturers' inventories of finished goods are a small and not particularly volatile component of total inventories. If, indeed, the model is applicable only to finished goods inventories, then it has limited relevance for aggregate inventory fluctuations. We conclude this section by briefly noting that this arguably constitutes an unadvisedly narrow reading of the model. First, works in progress inventories apparently function as a buffer in many industries, particularly ones that are production to order [West (1988)], and thus fit naturally into the model. More importantly, however, it is possible that an invisible hand causes a large aggregate to solve an optimization problem such as (3.1), using transactions not explicitly modeled in Equation (3.1) to do so. This point was first made by Blanchard (1983), who combined data from the production and retail sectors of the auto industry, modelling explicitly the transactions between the two sectors, and showed that the industry as a whole solved an optimization problem such as (3.1). This is an illustration of the equivalence between a social planning and a decentralized equilibrium, which is well known to occur under general circumstances. We are therefore sympathetic to the view that there has been too strong a focus on manufacturers' inventories o f finished goods. But we feel the implication may be not that the model is of limited relevance, but that it, or related models that capture similar forces, should be applied more widely.
4. Decision rule 4.1. Introduction
Section 4.2 briefly reviews alternative treatments of demand, and solves for a decision rule under a simple specification. Section 4.3 derives the process followed by the
13 "Production to stock" industries are ones that typically sell finished goods off the shelf. By contrast, "production to order" industries are ones that maintain order backlogs, often deferring final assembly until orders are in hand. See Abramowitz (1950) and Belsley (1969).
888
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
inventory-sales relationship, and may be skipped without loss of continuity. Section 4.4 summarizes the implications of Section 4.3 for persistence in the inventory-sales relationship. We present a detailed treatment o f the inventory-sales relationship because this process has not received much direct attention in existing literature. Discussions o f procyclicality in subsequent sections will cite analytical results in existing literature. 4.2. Derioation o f decision rule
Derivation o f a decision rule requires specification o f revenue because current and expected sales and output appear in the first-order conditions. We begin by reviewing some alternatives. We then work through in detail a specification that is relatively tractable. In some applications, sales is taken as exogenous, with cost minimization (i.e., m i n E t }--~/~0 bJCt+j) the objective 14. Examples include Holt et al. (1960), Belsley (1969) and Blanchard (1983). The use o f this assumption in industry-wide data is valid only if the demand curve facing the industry is vertical. In other applications, an industry equilibrium is analyzed, and a linear demand curve is specified [e.g., Eichenbaum (1984)]. We write such a demand curve in inverse form as
Pt = - g S t + g [ f dt ~ -gSt + Udt.
(4.1)
In (4.1), Udt and Udt are stochastic. The demand curve is written in this form so that exogenous sales is a special case of Equation (4.1), implemented by letting the parameter g --+ oo and specifying ~rdt as exogenous; with g ---+ oo, St = Udt. In practice, one needs to allow for serial correlation in Udt. In principle one might want to rationalize such serial correlation with (say) costs of adjustment on the part of purchasers, or with observable shifters o f the demand curve [West (1992b)]. But since the model focuses on production, and, moreover, is typically not used to study the effects of a hypothetical intervention or change in regime, taking such serial correlation as exogenous is a useful simplification that will be maintained here. Finally, Christiano and Eichenbaum (1989) and West (1990b), building on Sargent (1979, ch. XVI) derive the linear demand curve (4.1) in general equilibrium. Both papers assume a representative consumer whose per period utility is quadratic in St and linear in leisure. The disturbance Udt is a shock to the consumer's utility. There is no capital; the only means o f storage is inventories. See the cited papers for detail.
14 TO prevent confusion, we note that the first-order condition (3.3) also results if one assumes cost minimization. So if one aims to use condition (3.3) to estimate model parameters, one can motivate the equation by reference to cost minimization without taking a stand on the how revenue is determined (apart from the caveat stated in Footnote 11).
Ch. 13: Inventories
889
Here, we do not derive Equation (4.1) in general equilibrium but take (4.1) as given. We do not attempt to trace the demand shock back to preferences or other primitive sources. We therefore caution the reader that despite the label "demand", Udt should not be thought of as literally a nominal or monetary shock, since it (like all our variables) is real. As well, one can imagine scenarios in which Udt reflects forces typically thought of as supply side. If the good in question is an intermediate one, for example, one can imagine that shocks to the technology of the industry that produces the good dominate the movement of Uat. Whatever the interpretation of Udt, we derive an industry equilibrium assuming a representative firm. Even so, to obtain a decision rule, we must be specific about market structure and the structure of the demand and cost shocks. We assume here that the market is perfectly competitive, and normalize the number of firms to one. If the firm is a monopolist, the reduced form is identical, but with a certain parameter being the slope of the marginal revenue curve rather than the slope of the demand curve. We assume that Wt, Udt and Uct follow exogenous AR processes, possibly with unit autoregressive roots. By "exogenous" we mean "predictions of Wt, Udt and uot conditional on lagged Ws, Uas and uos are identical to those conditional on lagged Ws, Uds, uos, and industry-wide H s and Ss: Wt, Uat and uot are not Granger-caused by industry-wide Ht or St". (Of course in general equilibrium, such exogeneity of Wt is doubtful.) Finally, for notational simplicity, and to make contact with the literature on the "speed of adjustment" (see the next section), we tentatively assume that a0 = 0.
(4.2)
This assumption is arguably not a good one empirically, and we will relax it below. Under the assumption of perfect competition, there are two equivalent methods for deriving the decision rules for inventories and sales. The first method, which studies the decentralized optimization problem, derives the individual firm's first-order conditions and then incorporates those into the industry equilibrium. The second method, which uses a social planning approach, derives the first-order conditions for the social planner problem and obtains decision rules for those. Both methods yield identical answers. We exposit here the decentralized method, and present in the Technical Appendix the social planner approach. With a0 = O, the first-order condition for sales St for the representative firm is Pt - Et[alQt - a2a3(Ht-i - a3St) + Uct] = O.
(4.3)
In the absence of inventories, this would simply tell our competitive firm to set marginal revenue Pt equal to marginal cost a l Q t + U c t . The additional term aaa3(Ht 1 - a3St) is the effect on inventory holding costs of an additional unit produced for sale. Upon using Pt = - g S t + Udt in Equation (4.3) and Qt =St + A H t in Equation (4.3) and the inventory first-order condition (3.3), we obtain a pair of linear stochastic
V.A. Ramey and K.D. West
890
difference equations in Ht and St. This two equation system is solved in the Technical Appendix. The resulting decision rule is Ht = YgHHt-1 + distributed lag on uct, Udt and Wt,
(4.4a)
St = ~sHt 1 + a different distributed lag on uct, Udt and Wt.
(4.4b)
In (4.4a), srH is the root to a certain quadratic equation, ]~H[ < 1. Both ~ / a n d ~s depend on b, g, al, a2 and a3. (Note two differences from the relatively well-understood case of exogenous sales. Even when as, a2 > 0, i f g < oc: (a) it is in principle possible to have :v~ ~<0, and (b) the accelerator coefficient a3 affects ~/t.) The distributed lag coefficients on Uct, Udt and Wt depend on b, g, al, a2 and a3 as well as the autoregressive parameters governing the evolution of the uct, Udt and Wt. In the empirically relevant case of z~H > 0, ~H increases with marginal production costs al and decreases with marginal inventory holding costs a2. The signs of OJvH/Oa3 and OYfH/Og a r e ambiguous. The solution when revenue is exogenous (g --+ c~) is obtained by replac~g Udt with gUdt [see Equation (4.1)] and letting g ~ c~. In this case, :Vs =0, St = Udt and the solution (4.4) may be written in the familiar form H t = ~HHt I + distributed lag on St and on measures of cost,
(4.5a)
St N exogenous autoregressive process.
(4.5b)
On the other hand, when revenue is endogenous, :rs ~ 0 and we see in Equation (4.4b) that inventories Granger-cause sales. The intuition is that forward looking firms adjust inventories in part in response to expected future conditions. Thus industry-wide stocks signal future market conditions, including sales. This signalling ability is reflected in Equation (4.4b). These same results can be obtained directly from the social planner problem that maximizes consumer surplus plus producer surplus, which is equal to the area between the inverse demand and supply curves. See the Technical Appendix. In empirical application, matching the data might require allowing shocks with rich dynamics. Such dynamics may even be required to identify all the parameters of the model. Blanchard (1983), for example, assumes that the demand shock follows an AR(4). For expositional ease, however, we assume through the remainder of this section that all exogenous variables - Udt, uct, Wt - follow first-order autoregressive processes (possibly with unit roots). Specifically, assume that Et-1 Wt = (I-)wWt 1,
Wt = CrAwWt-1 + ewt,
Et_lewt = O,
I I - ~wZl = 0 ~ Izl/> 1, Et l Uct = q~cuct-1, Et-1 Udt = ~ d U d t - 1 ,
Uct = q~cUct-1 + ect,
Udt = ~JdUdt-1 + edt,
Et-leot = 0, Et ledt = O,
[q~c[ ~< 1,
]•d[
~< 1. (4.6)
Ch. 13:
Inventories
891
(Given the growth in the number of symbols, it may help to remind the reader that Table 7 summarizes notation.) The Technical Appendix shows that the distributed lags in Equation (4.4) are all first order, and Equation (4.4) is H t = YfHHt-1 +f~/w W t + f HcUct + f HdUdt,
(4.7a)
St = ~sgt-I
(4.7b)
+ f t s w W t + f scUct + f sdUdt.
See the Technical Appendix for explicit formulas for the ')¢"s in terms of b, g, al, a2, a3, qJw, q~c and q~d. Of course, if ~ = 0 so that Uct =uct, thenfHw = f s w =0. 4.3. Persistence in the inventory-sales relationship
To analyze the second of our stylized facts (persistence in the inventory-sales relationship), we now further assume that the demand shock and the observable cost shifters follow random walks: (bd = 1, Udt = Udt 1 + edt, qDw = I , W t = Wt-1 + ewt.
(4.8)
Recall that if Uct is stationary, H t - OSt is stationary as well, where the cointegrating parameter 0 is defined in Equation (3.5). When there are no observable cost shifters (~ = 0 ~ fHw = f s w = 0), tedious manipulation o f Equation (4.7) yields H t - H t =~ H t - OSt = ~ H ( H t - l
- OSt-1) + mocuct -t- mlcUct l + modedt,
(4.9)
where moo, ml~ and m0d depend on O, f H o , f H d , f S c and f S d (see the Technical Appendix). Let "L" be the lag operator. Since ( 1 - ~ c L ) u c t = e c t , it follows from Equation (4.8) that (1 - ~,vL)(1 - (bcL)(Ht - H t ) = vt, vt = mocect + m~cect-i + mOdedt -- ~)cmOdedt-1 ~ MA(1).
(4.10)
Thus, H t - H t ~ ARMA(2, 1) with autoregressive roots Jr/4 and ~bc. (This presumes that the moving average root in vt does not cancel an autoregressive root in H t - H i, which generally will not h