Innovation in English Language Teaching ‘This v o l u m c brings to the fore divcrsc, f u n d a m c n t a l issucs a b o u t thc processes a n d politics of c u r r i c u l u m c h a n g e and i m p r o v e m e n t , new t e c h n o l o g i e s , a n d concepts of language use, c o m m u n i c a t i o n , a n d i n s t r u c t i o n vital to g u i d i n g the organization a n d practiccs of teaching English internationally.’ Alister Cumming, Ontario lnstitritqfbr Studies in Education, Ilniversiq, $Toronto
Teaching English Language Worldwide A sclcction o f r e a d e r s ’ commmts o n the series: ‘This thrcc-part series offkrs a map to ELT research and practice . . . it represents the best that EI.T, as an Anglo-Saxon institution, has dcvclopctl over thc last thirty years for the teaching of English around the \vorld . . . Readers will f n d in this scrics the Who’s Who guide t o this dynamic antl expanding community.’ Claire Kramsch, Unitwsiy !/‘Cul!/brnia, Berkele)., CulIfbrnia ‘Experienced knglish language instructors sccking to tlecpen their kno\vlctlgc ant1 abilities will find this series forms a coherent basis to d lop their understanding of current trcntls, sociocultural diversity, and topical interests in teaching English as a second or foreign language around the \vorld. All thrcc \olumcs pro\ idc ample flexibility for discussion, interpretation, antl adaptation in local scttings.’ ,41ister Ctirnrning, Ontario Institute for S t t i d i e s in Educarion, Universiy ?ffToronto
‘This scrics pro\ ides a collection of essential readings \vhich will not onl! pro\ itlc the TEFI./TESOL student anti tcachcr \\ ith access to the most up-to-tlatc thinking and approaches to the subject but mill give any person interested in the suhjcct an over\ ic\z of the phenomenon of thc usc antl usage of English in the modern nurltl. Perhaps morc importantly, this series \vi11 be crucial to thosc studcnts \z ho do not h a w available t o them articles that providc both a \vide spectrum of information antl the neccssary analytical tools to investigate the language turthcr.’Josepb,l. E’olej;Soiitbeu. iu Jlinirters oftducation Orpnisution, Regionul Lungiiule Centre, Singapore
‘The strong rcprcscntation o f the seminal Anglo- Australian tlc\clopmcnt o f the European functional tradition in the study of languagc antl language education makes this a rclrcshingl! bracing scrics, \z hich should hc \vitlcl! used in tcachcr education tor English languagc teaching.’ Liicin Reid, / n y t i r r i t e f E d u c u t i o n , IJniversiy of/.ondon ‘In a principled antl accessible manner, thcsc thrcc 1 olumcs living together major bvritings o n essential topics in the stud? o f English languagc tcaching. They provide broatl coverage of current thinking and debate o n major issucs, providing an in\ aluable resource for the contcmporarq postgraduate student.’ Guy Cook, llnii crsit?, of Reading
Teaching English Language Worldwide Companion volumes The companion volumes in this series are: Analysing English Language i n a Global Context, edited by Anne Burns and Caroline Coffin English Language Teaching in its Social Contextedited by Christopher N. Candlin and Neil Mercer These three readers are part of a scheme of study jointly developed by Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia, and the open University, United I
The Open University M A in Education is now established as the most popular postgraduate degree for U I< education professionals, with over 3,500 students registering each year. From 2001 i t will also be available worldwide. The M A in Education is designed particularly for those with experience in teaching, educational administration or allied fields. The M A is a modular degree and students are free t o select, from a range of options, the programme that best fits in with their interests and professional goals. The M A in Education programme provides great flexibility. Students study at their own pace and in their own time. They receive specially prepared study materials, and are supported by a personal tutor. (Successful completion of the M A in Education (Applied Linguistics) entitles students t o apply for entry t o the Open University Doctorate in Education (Ed.D.) programme.) The Professional Development in Education prospectus contains further information and application forms. To find out more about the Open University and request your copy please write t o the Course Reservations and Sales Centre, The Open University, PO Box 724, Walton Hall, Milton I<eynes M1<7 bZW, or e-mail
[email protected], or telephone +44 ( 0 ) 01908 653231 or visit the website www.open.ac.ul<. For more information on the M A in Education (Applied Linguistics), visit www.open.ac.uk/applied-linguistics.
Macquarie University introduced distance versions of its influential on-campus degrees in 1 9 9 4 and now has students in over thirty countries. Both the Postgraduate Diploma and the Master's are offered in three versions: Applied Linguistics, Applied Linguistics (TESOL) and Applied Linguistics (Literacy). Credits are freely transferable between the Diploma and the Master's and between the three versions, and students may change between distance and on-campus modes or mix modes i f desired. Students study at their own pace, with specially developed materials and with support and feedback provided directly from lecturers in the Linguistics Department through e-mail, web, fax, phone and post. A specialised library service is provided through the Resources Centre of the National Centre for English Language Teaching and Research (NCELTR). External doctoral programmes are also available. Information about the Macquarie programmes and application forms are available on www.ling.mq.edu.au or by writing t o the Linguistics Postgraduate Office, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia tel.: + 6 1 2 9850 9243; fax + 6 1 2 9850 9352; e-mail:
[email protected]).
I n n o v a t i o n i n E n g l i s h Language Teaching
Innovation i n English Language Teaching provides both theoretical perspectives and practical tools for analysing, developing and evaluating English language teaching curricula. It presents English language teaching in a variety of specific institutional, geographic and cultural contexts. This Reader focuses particularly on curriculum change in context. The articles - which include both classic and specially commissioned pieces - have been selected and edited to highlight the debates, discussions and current issues from different parts of the Englishspealcing and English-using world. Academics and teachers from around the world examine the role and influence not just of language teachers and students, but of parents, teacher-trainers, the local community, the press, politicians, and all who have an interest in what goes on in the language classroom. Issues are illustrated and discussed in different contexts, including: teaching migrants in English speaking countries; teaching large classes in developing countries; teaching English for academic purposes; using information technology in the classroom. Articles by: Michael P. Breen; I
David R. Hall is Head of the Department of Linguistics at Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia. Ann Hewings is a lecturer in the Centre for Language and Communications at the Open University, U I<.
Innovation in English Language Teaching A Readev
Edited by
David R. Hall and Ann Hewings
2
Theopen University
MACQUARI E UNIVERSITY - SYDNEY
London and New York in association with Macquarie University and The Open University
FOV my parents, Ron and Anne Hall
Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 1 0 0 0 1 Routledge is an imprint o f the Taylor & Francis Group
0 2001 Compilation, original and editorial material Macquarie University and The Open University; individual articles 0their authors Typeset in Perpetua and Bell Gothic by I<eystroke, Jacaranda Lodge, Wolverhampton Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Innovation in English language teaching : a reader I edited by David Hall and Ann Hewings. p. cm. - (Teaching English language worldwide) Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. English language-Study and teaching- Foreign speakers. I.Hall, David, 194711. Hewings, Ann. 111. Series. PE1128.A2 I 5 4 2000 428'.007 -dc21 ISBN 0-415-24123-5 (hbk) ISBN 0-415-24124-3 (pbk)
00-059194
Contents
List o f illustrations Acknowledgements
X
xii
D a v i d R. H a l l a n d A n n H e w i n g s 1
INTRODUCTION
P A R T ONE Directions i n c u r r i c u l u m change Michael P. Breen and Christopher N. Candlin 1
T H E E S S E N T I A L S OF A C O M M U N I C A T I V E C U R R I C U L U M
9
IN LANGUAGE TEACHING
David Nunan and Clarice Lamb 2
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
27
Michael Lewis 3
46
LEXlS I N THE SYLLABUS
Michael McCarthy and Ronald Carter 4
DESIGNING THE DISCOURSE SYLLABUS
55
Guy Cook 5
T H E USES OF C O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E CORPORA
64
A R E P L Y TO R O N A L D C A R T E R
Ann Hewings and M a r t i n Hewings 6
APPROACHES TO T H E S T U D Y IN ACADEMIC WRITING: DESIGN
OF
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION
I M P L I C A T I O N S FOR S Y L L A B U S
71
Viii
CONTENTS
PART TWO Political and institutional constraints i n curriculum development Ronald Carter 7
POLITICS AND I
87
Gary M. Jones 8
BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN: TOWARDS A WORI
99
I
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS: AN INFUSION M O D E L OF C U R R I C U L A R I N N O V A T I O N
108
Nurna M a r k e e 10
T H E D I F F U S I O N OF I N N O V A T I O N I N L A N G U A G E T E A C H I N G
118
Zakia Sarwar 11
A D A P T I N G I N D I V I D U A L I Z A T I O N T E C H N I Q U E S FOR LARGE CLASSES
127
W i l l i a m Savage a n d Graerne Stover 12
AN EMERGENT LANGUAGE PROGRAM FRAMEWORK: ACTIVELY INVOLVING LEARNERS I N NEEDS ANALYSIS
Defeng 13
137
L
TEACHERS
PERCEIVED DIFFICULTIES I N INTRODUCING
T H E C O M M I N I C A T I V E A P P R O A C H I N S O U T H I
149
PART THREE Planning and implementing curriculum change Adrian Holliday 14
ACHIEVING CULTURAL CONTINUITY IN CURRICULUM I NNOVATION
169
I
A F R A M E W O R I < OF COURSE D E V E L O P M E N T P R O C E S S E S
16
ACTION RESEARCH I N LANGUAGE EDUCATION
178
David Nunan 197
CONTENTS
ix
Susan Feez 17
CURRICULUM EVOLUTION I N THE AUSTRALIAN ADULT MIGRANT ENGLISH PROGRAM
208
David R. H a l l 18
MATERIALS PRODUCTION: THEORY AND PRACTICE
229
Simon Sergeant 19
CALL INNOVATION I N THE ELT CURRICULUM
240
P A R T FOUR E v a l u a t i n g c u r r i c u l u m change P a u l i n e R e a - D i c k i n s a n d I<evin G e r m a i n e 20
P U R P O S E S FOR E V A L U A T I O N
253
David R. Carless 2 1
A C A S E S T U D Y OF C U R R I C U L U M I M P L E M E N T A T I O N I N H O N G IKONG
263
Joan Lesikin 22
DETERMINING SOCIAL PROMINENCE: A METHODOLOGY FOR U N C O V E R I N G G E N D E R B I A S I N E S L T E X T B O O I < S
Index
275
284
Illustrations
Figures 1.1 2.1 2.2 2.3 8.1 10.1 11.1 11.2 11.3 12.1 12.2 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 15.1 16.1 17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 18.1 18.2 19.1
The curriculum Three phases or perspectives on the curriculum process Three alternative ways of grouping learners Planning grid for general English course BICS and CALP An S-shaped diffusion curve Individualization in large classes Worlcsheet 1: radio news Worksheet 2: self-created cloze The initial language program framework The revised language program framework Cultural continuity Professionally constructed image of ‘the learner’ Professionally constructed image of ‘the stakeholder’ ‘Us’- ‘them’ configuration The completed syllabus grid Reflective practice model of professional education/development Certificates in Spolcen and Written English: curriculum structure Outcomes fov Certificate I in Spolcen and Written English Competency 13: Can write a short recount Methodology t o support learners working towards CSW E outcomes Worksheet 1: student A only Worksheet 2: student B only Perceived program use
10 37 41 44 101 122 131 132 133 139 147 170 171 172 175 187 198 217 218 219 223 234 235 244
Tables 2.1 2.2 2.3
Learner roles in a learner-centered curriculum Learner-centeredness in the experiential content domain Learner-centeredness in the learning process domain
28 30 30
ILLUSTRATIONS
2.4 2.5
2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 6.1 6.2 8.1 8.2 9.1 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 13.1 15.1 16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 21.1 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4
Changing views on the nature of language and learning Curriculum decision-making in high-structure and low-structure contexts I<ey curriculum questions, procedures, and areas Approaches t o needs analysis Types of information required in a learner-centered system Communication and learning-how-to-learn goals A classification system for the grammatical subject Average distribution of GSs in different disciplines and sub-disciplines Compulsory and examinable subjects in Brunei primary and secondary schools An alternative distribution of subjects in the Bruneian education system Journals publishing articles on World Englishes topics Interacting Language use Writing and reading M etacogn itive Reported difficulties in implementing CLT Framework components The action research cycle: an ESL example The action research cycle: a foreign language example Questions for establishing the reliability and validity of a study The inservice programme in outline How has your teaching changed? Excerpt from a lesson transcript Participant roles of nouns and pronouns Grammar in Use: frequency of gender-specific nouns and pronouns as theme and rheme in ‘unmarked’ clauses Grammar in Use: frequency of gender-specific nouns and pronouns as theme and last stressed element in ‘unmarked’ clauses Grammar in Use: frequency of participant roles of gender-specific nouns and pronouns in ‘unmarked’ clauses
xi
31 34 36 39 40 43 78 79 100 106 114 142 143 143 144 153 179 199 200 201 203 205 268 278 279 279 280
Ac I<now Ie d ge me nt s
The editors and publishers would like to thank thc following for permission to use copyright material: Kimberley Brown and Blackwcll Pulilishers Ltd for ‘World Englishes inTESOL programs: an infusion model of curricular innovation’ in World Englishes, Vol. 12: 1 , 1993. Michael P. Brccn and Christopher N. Cantllin for ‘The essentials of a communicative curriculum in language teaching’ in Applied Linguistics, 1980. Reprintctl by permission of Oxford University l’ress. David Carless for ‘A case study of curriculum implementation in Hong Kong’. Reprinted from System,Vol. 26, 1998, with pcrmission from Elsevier Science. Ronald Carter antl Michael McCarthp for matcrial from Language as Discourse: Perspectives for Language Teaching ( Longman Group U K Limited 1990.) Rcprintcd by pcrmission o f I’earson Education Limited. Ronald Carter and Taylor & Francis Iiooks Ltd f‘or ‘Politics and knowledge about language’ in fnvestigating English Discourse, 1997. Guy Cook for ‘The uses ofrcality: a reply to Ronald Cartcr’ in ELT,/ourna/,Vol. 52, No. 1 , 1998. Reprintctl by permission o f EI.Tlourna1 and Oxford University Prcss. Kevin Germaine and Pauline Rca-Dickins for ‘Purposes for cvaluation’ . Rcproducetl by permission of Oxford Univcrsity Press from Erulriution by Pauline Kca-Dickins and Kevin Germainc (Oxford University I’ress 1992 .) Kathleen Graves and Cambridge Univcrsity 13 . for ‘A framework of course development processes’ in K . Graves (cd.) Ecichers us Course Developers, 1996. David Hall antl SEAMEO Regional Language Centre for ‘Material production: theory and practice’ in A.C. Hidalgo, D. Hall antl G.M. Jacohs (e&) Getting Started: Materialr Writers on Materials Writing, 1995. Adrian Holliday for ‘Achieving cultural continuity in curriculum innovation’ in C. Kennedy (cd.) Innovation and Best Practice (l’carson Education Limited 1999). Reprinted by permission of Pcarson Education Limited. Gary M. Jones and Multilingual Matters for ‘Bilingual education and syllabus design: towards a workable lilucprint’ in journal of’Multilingual and Multiculttiral Devclopment,Vol. 17: 2 4 , 1996. Joan Lesikin antl College ESL for ‘Dctermining social prominen a methodology for uncovering gcndcr bias in ESL textbooks’ in Colle‘qe ESL,Vol.8, No. 1, 1998.
A C I< N 0 W L E D G
E M ENTS
x i ii
Michael Lewis and LanguageTeaching Publications (LTP) for ‘Lcxis in the syllabus’ in The Lexical Approach:The State of E1.T and a Way Forward, 1993. Dcfeng Li and TESOL for ‘It’s always more difficult than you plan and imagine: teachers’ perceived difficulties in introducing the communicative approach in South Korea’ in TESOL Quarterly,Vol. 3 2 , No. 4, 1998. Numa Markee and Cambridge University Press for ‘The diffusion model of innovation in language teaching’ in Annual Review $Applied /.inguistics, 1 3, 1993. David Nunan for ‘Action research in language education’ in J. Edge and K. Richards (eds) Teachers Develop Teacher Research Papers on Classroom Research and Teacher Derdopment, 1993. Reprinted by permission of Macmillan Press Ltd. Includes table: ‘Types of information required in a lcarner-ccntered system’ from G. Krindley Needsilnalysis and Objective Setting in the Adult Mi‘qrant Program, 1984, reproduced hy permission of NSW Adult Migrant Education Scrvice. Includes material from table: ‘Three altcrnative ways of grouping learners’ from E S L Curriculum Guidelines, South Australian Education Department, 1 990, reproduced by permission of The Department of Education, Training and Employment (SA). Includes material from table: ‘Three alternative ways of grouping learners’ from K . Willing, Learning S v l e s In Adult Migrant Education, 1998, reproduced by permission of N CE LTR . David Nunan, Clarice Lamb, and Cambridge University Prrss for material from The Se!fl Directed Teacher: Managing the Learning Process, 1996. William Savage and Graeme Storer for ‘An emergent language program framework: actively involving learners in needs analysis’ reprinted from $stem, Vol. 20, No. 2 , 1992 with permission from Elsevier Science. Simon Sergeant for ‘CALL innovation in the ELT curriculum’ in C. Kennedy, 1’. Lloylc and C. Goh (cds) Exploring Change in English Language Teaching, 1999. Kcprinted 11: pcrmission of Macmillan Press Ltd. Zakia Shanvar and English Teaching Forum for ‘Adapting intlividualisation techniques for ’ in English Teaching Forum, April 1 99 1 . While the publishers and editors have made every effort to contact authors and copyright holders of lvorks reprinted in Innovation in English / , a n p a g e Euching, this has not been possil,lc in every case. They would \celcomc correspondence from individuals or companics thcy have bccn unable to trace. Wc \vould likc to thank thc authors who contributed thcir chapters, as kvell as colleagues within and outsidcThe Open University and Macquaric University \Tho gave advice on the contents. Special thanks are due to the following people for thcir assistance in the production of this book: Helen Boyce (course manager) Freda Barnfield, Pam Burns and Libby 13rill (course secretaries) Liz Freeman (Copublishing) Nanette Ileynolds, Frances Wilson and the staff of the Rc-source Centrc of the National Centre for English Language Teaching and Research, Macquarie University.
Critical readers Professor Vijay K. Rhatia (L)ept of English, City University, I long Kong) Gcoff Thompson (Applied English Language Studies Unit, 12iverpool University, UK) Professor Leo van Lier (Educational Linguistics, University of Montcrey, USA)
x iv
A C I< N 0 W L E D G E M E N T S
External assessor Professor Ronald Carter (Dept of English Studies, Nottingham Unil ersity, UK)
Developmental testers Ilona C7iraky (Italy) Eladyr Maria Norhcrto da Sil\a ( B r a d ) Chitrita Mukcrjee (Australia) Doricn GonLales (UK) Patricia Williams (Denmark)
We ha\-e reproduced all original papers and chapters as faithfully as we have been alde to, givcn the inevitable restrictions of space and the nccd to produce a cohcrcnt and readablc collection for rcaders worldwide. W h r r e wc have had to shorten original material substantially, these chapters arc markcd as adapted. Ellipses within square brackets indicate where text has bcen omitted from thc original. Individual refcrcncing styles have been retained as in the original texts.
Introduction D a v i d R . H a l l and A n n Hewings
H E N M A C Q U A R I E U N I V E R S l T Y I N S Y D N E Y , Australia, and The Open University in the UK decided to collaborate on the tlevelopment of new curriculum materials for study at Masters level, the partnership brought together the considerable experience and expertise of the two universities in open antl distance learning, applicd linguistics and language cducation.The collection of essays in this book antl the two companion volumes is a result of that collaboration. While the edited collections have been designed as one part of an overall study programme, they stand alone as extensive yct focused collections of essays which address key contemporary issues in English language teaching antl applicd linguistics. A major concern in editing these three volumes has been thc desire to prrscnt English language teaching (ELI‘) in a variety of specific institutional, geographical and cultural contexts. Hence, as far as possible across the three volumes, lve have attemptcd to highlight debate, discussion and illustration of current issues from diffcrcnt parts of the Englishspeaking and English-using world, including those where English i s not learnt as a first language. In doing this we recognise that English language teaching comprises a global community of teachers antl lcarncrs in a range of social contexts. The chapters in this volume address issues relating to curriculum change in context, and all three terms in this noun phrase are important. The cssays deal with the tliffcrc-nt ways in which actual classroom practices change, whether at an individual o r a system 1 Rccognising that languagc teaching docs not take place in a ncutral o r value-free environment, they look at the choices that have to be made ivithin institutional o r cultural constraints when designing curricula and evaluating their success. They examinc the role o have an intcrcst in what goes on in the and influence of all the stakeholders ~ h might language classroom: not just language teachers and students, but parents, teacher-trainers, the local community, the press, politicians, antl s o on. The titles of all four parts of the volume contain the word ‘curriculum’.Thc different usages in the literaturc of words such as ‘curriculum’, ‘syllabus’ and ‘programmc’ (or ‘program’) arc cvidence that prrcise definitions of these terms are hard to pin down. In some cases the words are differentiated Tvhilc in others they are used almost interchangcahly, and you will notice diffcrcnt meanings attached to thc tcrminology by different authors in this volume. Here, wc intend the tcrm ‘language curriculum’ in its widest sense, covering all the issues rclating to the planning, implemcntation and evaluation of a scrics o f languagclearning events conceived as a coherent whole n i t h a specified purpose. The first part, ‘Directions in curriculum change’, raises somc issues underlying
2
DAVID R. HALL AND ANN HEWINGS
curriculum design by examining the theoretical underpinnings of a number of reccnt approaches. This docs not attempt, of course, to cover all the different ways of specifying a curriculum, antl is not meant to be a historical survey (but see the Feez article in part 3 for a contextualiscd account of the tlevelopmcnt of language teaching practices).’l’hc assumption underlying our choice of essays for part 1 is the view which few people in language curriculum design ~ o u l dnow argue Lvith that content and classroom practice must be considered togethcr: a curriculum is not simply a list of items t o be taught.Thc first chapter liy Breen and Candlin, covering work done at Lancastcr Univu-sity on communicative language teaching ( C I S ) , \vas extremely influential in bringing this \-iew into language teaching, although the focus o n the process of learning rather than just the product is consistent with a much older tradition in gencral education. CLT is not a nionolithic packaged set of procedures, tlespitc frequent talk in the no literature of the ‘communicative method’. All of the authors of essays in part 1 ~ . o u l d doubt place themselves in the communicative tradition. Where CUT has heen introduced or encouraged or atlvocatctl in specific contexts around the xvorld it has often been in thc form of a package, introduced t o p - h v n as a grcat antl rc+ietl ncw idea rather than arising from and de\+ictl within the classroom antl the needs and problcms of particular teachers antl learners. As the name of CLT has hccn invoked as a justification for a process of change taking place in speci tic geographical, cultural and temporal contexts, some of its underlying principles and practices have lieen contested o r reinterpreted, as \vi11 be seen in later chapters in this volume. Its influence is such, howwer, that anyone putting forward an alternative paradigm has to detinc it in relation to CLI’. The essays by Nunan antl Lamb a n d by I.c\vis both place themselves in the communicativc tradition by cmphasising the ccntralitv o f the learner and the learning pro The first explores task-based learning. Although the \vord ‘task’ is overused in many published textbooks to the extent that it is often little more than a synonjm for ‘exercise’, and although it i s certainly possible to tlcvisc, context- and c.omnlunic.ation-frcc ‘tasks’ in this sense, the proponents of‘a task-based syllabus have something more specific in mind. Thcy take tasks to be the interactive lcarning procedures through which learners both in and out o f the classroom learn to understand each other antl to make thcmselves understood, so gaining conlitlencc antl cxpcricncc in using the target language.l’hc links to Lewis’s proposal to replace thc traditional Prescnt~Practisc~Protlucc teaching procedurc with Ohserve-Ilypothcsisc~Expcrimentarc clear. l‘hc observing, hypothesising and experimenting are all being undertaken by the learner in actually using the target language. The emphasis is on the learner, antl the teacher’s role changes from ‘presenter’to something more like ‘collaborator’ or ‘facilitator’. I h c n (1 984: 5 3) claims for CLT that its ‘grcatcr concern lvith capacity for communication rather than repertoire of communication, with the acti\ ity of learning a language itself, and with a focus upon means rather than prctlctcrminctl objectives, all indicate priority of process ovcr content’. We cmphasisc that this docs not say ‘process to the exclusion o f content’, although some have seen CLT as a methodology that rejects the teaching of formal aspects of the language altogcthcr.Thcrc are parallels here with argumcnts that have been used about \vholc-w ord teaching of rcading as opposed to phonics-hased methods, antl about process writing as opposed to the teaching of scntcnce-grammar, spelling and punctuation.Thc differing roles assigned to process, product, content and form still constitute a major sitc of struggle hvithin language curriculum tievclopment. This struggle untlerlics much of’ the argument between the Cook essay and that by McCarthy and Carter. McCarthy antl Carter argue that the curriculum must take account of variation and of context, and this means that learners’ interaction with texts must take
INTRODUCTION
3
account of the ‘dynamism inherent in linguistic contexts’. The understanding of the dynamism of language and contextual variation is reinforced in McCarthy and Carter’s own work on language corpora, large collections of actual texts stored on computer and accessible for quantifiable linguistic analysis. To an extent, then, thcy may he seen as advocating teaching programmes based o n quantitative data, an argument that dates hack many ycars (see, for example, West’s General Servicc List of English Words, liascd on kvord counts, and first published in 1936). Cook argues that language teaching should not br a slave to language description, that thc processes of learning antl traching are not coincident with the records of language behaviour evidenced through corpora. The argumcnt comcs back, as many times before in the history of language pedagogy, to the role played liy formal language description in helping teachers to teach and learners to learn. N o linguist \voulcl dispute the ubiquity and importance of language variation over time, space, context, purpose, etc. The essay by Hewings and Hc\vings, which ends part 1 antl provides a link with the first chapter of part 2 , dcals with the variation in language use betwccn academic disciplines. Particularly when applied to the teaching of English for Specific Purposes, this is an area which is attracting growing attention, \vith increasing Ic\-cls of research being undertaken around thc world (see, lor example, the essays in Candlin and FIvlantl, 19YY).The capacity of computers to store large and spccialised corpora of languagt, as it is actually used is, whatcvcr we may think of the Cook argumcnt, beginning to rcvolutionisc the way we see language. Where corpora are sufficiently spccialised, they underline differences in lexical patterns, word meanings, grammatical pattcrns and tcxtual cohesion in a way that ivas possible only in a limited and largely intuition-based way beforc the corpus databases ivere created. This development has already hatl an influence on tieltls such as lexicography, forensic linguistics, English for academic purposes and curriculum antl syllabus design. The approaches takcn by Hewings and Hclvings and by McCarthy and Carter are illustrative of these last two. Further dcvelopmcnts in thcsc areas may scrve to inform and/or challcnge both learners and teachers in the futurc. The incorporation of variation into language curricula is not, at present, a midesprcatl practice, and the essay h y Cartcr which opens part 2 gives some indication of why it is not. In fact, all of the essays in part 2 deal in one way or another with the political and institutional constraints in curriculum development. Language, as an intimate component of individual and national identity, is a particularly emotional issur, and cui-riculum developers tamper with ‘the hvay things have always been donc around herc’ at their o\vn risk. Cartcr \vas brantlcd in some sections of the press as a revolutionary traitor to the nation for his emphasis on knowletlge about language and how it functions. Even at a local bel, teachers working b y thcmsclves in individual classrooms and taking ivhat seem like innocent decisions ahout the day’s activities can easily tind themselves the subject of parents’ or the school principal’s ire. All but one of thc seven chapters in part 2 deal \vith attcmpts to change curricula in spccific contcxts.The cxccption is the cssay by Markce, which prcsents a framchvork for thc introduction of innovations. As might hc expected from an examination of Markee’s categorics and criteria, none of the projects reported could be judged uncquivocallq. as a failure or a success. He dcals with issues such as: A t \vhat point can an innovation be judgctl as satisfactor?? What is the critical mass which determines whether an innovation has been adopted by the population for which it was intcndrd? Each of the other essays in this section could lie examined in thc light of Markee’s criteria and follo\vetl up to see what has happened in the period since the first publication of the essay. Have the innovations discusscd by Carter, Jones, Brown, Sarwar, Savage and Storer, and Li actually hatl any lasting effect? Iiave, for example, Carter’s ideas set o u t in the IJNC project influenced British tcachers’ views on language? Has the mix of Malay and English in thc Brunei school system actually liccn
4
DAVID R. H A L L AND ANN HEWINGS
modified following the publication o f Jones’s essay? Has Kimberley Brown managed to persuade American libraries to stock more world-English titles? Has Zakia Sarwar convinced her colleagues to introduce similar methods in their classes, or transferred what she was doing to the mainstream, official curriculum? Have the needs analysis procedures of Savagc and Storer been extended to other contexts? And have Defeng Li’s Korean teachers adapted, adopted or rejectcd a communicative approach? These would be interesting questions to follow up, and sometimes they can lie pursued through publications in journals (see, for example, Storer and Savage, 1999, for furthrr extensions of their own work) and incrcasingly through internet discussion lists. Part 3 examines both the planning and the implementation of curriculum change. Many curriculum dcvelopment tcxtbooks treat these two aspects separately, but it is clear that the processes involved are circular rather than linear, and that both need to involve or at least take into consideration all of the stakeholders. This part, then, continucs the theme of curriculum development in its social and institutional context. All the essays in this part examine the ways in which change is brought about.They also raise the question of whether change is always desirable, particularly in cases where successful models from one context arc imported into new contexts. This is currently a much-disputed point in language teaching in rclation to the recent insistence in some circles on learner autonomy as a necessary condition for successful language learning.Thc chapters Iiy Sarwar and Savagc antl Storer in part 2 hoth deal with the introduction o f autonomous approaches. In the first essay in part 3, however, Holliday presents a rather differcnt and provocative view of learner~centrcdness.For Holliday, ‘learner-centredncss’ has become a short-hand way of referring not to individuals but to thc skills antl compctencics we can equip thcm with and thc evaluative mechanisms that can lie used to test how effective wc as teachers have bcxn.This teachcr-centred interprctation of learner-centredness is a highly contentious position, with those advocating learner-ccntredncss strongly disputing this understanding oftheir approach (see, for cxamplc, Savagc, 1997). Clcarly, thcrc arr complex antl sometimes contradictory arguments involved here, with both sides claiming to hold the moral high ground.Thc relationships lxtwccn different stakeholtlers between donors and recipients, policy-makers antl practitioners, native and non-native speakers, teachers and learners, insiders antl outsiders, cxpcrts antl novicrs arc dclicatc antl involve many more issues than how to tcach language, as \vc see again antl again in these essays. While Holliday assumes a top-clown model (Lvhich he attacks), the chapters by Graves and liy Nunan 110th look at ways in which innovation can be instigatctl by the teachcr o r by teachers and others working togethcr. Feez givcs cxamplrs of this collalxxative approach when she describes in some detail the \vays in irhich curriculum change has taken place within a large systcm. Although systcmic innovation necessarily in\ olvcs some form of imposition, it will be seen that through consultation and Lrorkshops, teachers at all levcls have been involvctl in thc various reformulations o f the curriculum. Hall tlc ribes four tliffercnt curriculumdevelopment projects antl examines thrm in thc light of their capacity for helping the learners to learn. Hall’s introduction of the irnportancc of defining what you are trying to do in tlcvcloping curricular innovations leads on to the final chapter in this part, in which Sergeant analyses the various uses made of computcrs in the language classroom and the motivations attachetl to those uses. He makes a va1ual)le distinction between ‘change’ brought about by computer-assisted language learning (CALL), which he sees as a superficial addition to the curriculum, antl ‘innovation’ using CALL, which is embedded in the curriculum and encourages new ways of teaching and lrarning. This separation of superficial versus embeddcd, change versus innovation is applicablc to all areas of the curriculum, not just CALL. ~
INTRODUCTION
5
Part 4 focuscs on evaluating curriculum change, placing this as an integral component of the planning and implementation cycle. While evaluation is an essential element underpinning all the essays in the volumc, this section looks in some detail at different kinds of evaluative processes. Rea-Dickins and Germainc, in answer to the question of why we might need to evaluate at all, provide an overview of the different purposes for which evaluation is conducted. The kind of evaluation exemplified in the Carlcss essay is one of a growing number of research projects using qualitative methods. His case-study approach, involving what is sometimes called a ‘thick’ description, turns a microscope on onc specific cvent in one specific context. As a rcsearch methodology, it may not yet havc the academic cachet of quantitative and controllcd research methods, and may not he able to uphold claims to generalisability in the same way as quantitative methods do, but it can rcveal much more about why ideas that seem fine in theory work rather differently, if at all, in real life. In the longer term, as more and more small-scale context-cmtieddcd research projects are reported, it may tie that these stories will constitute the most \-aluablc resource for the teacher and curriculum dewloper. The final chapter, by Lcsikin, provides a framework for evaluating and analysing language-teaching materials. Using the tools of systemic-functional grammatical analysis shc uncovers systematic gender bias in a published textbook. Lesikin’s procedures are \-cry much in thc tradition of critical discourse analysis, and it is clear that they could be uspd in contexts other than that outlined here. The essays in this collection are designed as a source of thought-provoking ideas for all students of language teaching, language teachers, teacher-trainers, curriculum d e d o p e r s and educational administrators. They exemplify a range of work b y academics with wide experience in different parts of the world and b y teachers who are still very close to the chalk-face. They make the link between theory and the actual circumstances in which language learning takes place or fails to take place. This volumc is not a handbook, and has no predetermined answers to the problem of finding appropriate ways of putting together language curricula s o that lcarners can learn. Instcad, it provides a series of conccptual frameworks within which such a quest can be undertaken.
References Breen, M. P. 1984. ‘Proccss syllabuses for the language classroom’, in C. Brumfit (ed.) General English Syllabus Design: Crirriculum and Syllabus Design-for the General English Classroom, ELT Documents I 18. Oxford: British Council and Pcrgamon Press. Candlin, C. N. and Hyland, K . (eds) 1999. Writing: E m ,Procecses, and Practices. Harlow: 1,ongman. Savage, W. 1997. ‘Language and development’, In B. Kenny and W. Savagc (cds) Language and Development. Harlow: Longman, 283-325. Storer, G. and Savage, W. 1999. ‘Extending an emergent frarnc\vork to other contexts’, System, 27. 3: 421-5.
PART ONE
Directions in curriculum change
Chapter 1
Michael P. Breen and Christopher N. Candlin T H E E S S E N T I A L S OF A C O M M U N I C A T I V E CURRICULUM I N LANGUAGE TEACHING
Introduction
A
T A T I M E W H E N T H E R E I S A R E C O G N I S E D N E E D inlanguagcteaching to give adequate attention to language use as well as language form, various ‘notionalfunctional’ or so-called ‘communicative approaches’ to language teaching are lxing advocatcd. In this context, the present paper is offered as a sct of proposals in an effort to dcfine the nature of communicative language tcaching. Any teaching curriculum is designed in answer to three interrelated questions: What is to be Icarned? How is the learning to be undertaken antl achieved? To what cxtent is the former appropriate and the latter effective?A communicative curriculum will place language teaching within the framework of this relationship between some specified purposcs, the methodology which will be the means towards the achievcment of those purposcs, antl thc evaluation procedurcs \vhich will assess the appropriatencss o f the initial purpo and the ell’cctiveness of the methodology. This chapter presents the potential charactcristics of communicative languagc teaching in terms of such a curriculum framework. I t also proposes a set of principles on \vhich particular curriculum designs can be based for implemcntation in particular situations and circumstances. Figure 1 . 1 summarises the main areas with w.hich this chapter \vi11 dcal. In discussing the purposes of language teaching, we will consider ( 1 ) communication as a general purpow, (2) thc underlying demands on the learner that such a purposc may imply, and (3) thc initial contributions which learners may bring to the curriculum. In discussing the potential methodology of a communicative curriculum, \ye \vi11 consider (4) thc proccss of teaching and learning, ( 5 ) thc roles of teacher and learncrs, antl (6) thc role of content within the teaching antl karning. Finally (7) we \rill discuss the placc of evaluation of learner progress and cvaluation of the curriculum itself from a communicativc point of view. Inevitably, any statement almut the components of the curriculum runs thc risk of pi-csenting in linear form a framettsork which is, in fact, char-actcrised hy intcrtlependcnce and overlap among the components. In taking purposes, methodology, antl evaluation in turn, therefore, wc ask readcrs to bcar in mind the actual interdependence between them. What follows is a consitleration of those minimal requirements on communicative language learning and teaching which, in our view, must now he taken into account in curriculum design and implcmcntation.
’
10
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D C H R I S T O P H E R
THE CURRICULUM 1 Communication
/
\
The classroom process Teacher / learnei' roles
\
6 Role of content
I \
7 Of learner Figtire
Of curriculum
I . 1 Thc c.urriculum
1 What is the purpose of the curriculum? The communicative curriculum tlcfincs languagc lcarning as lcarning how to communicate as a membcr of a particular socio-cultural group.Thc social convcntions governing languagc form and hehaviour within the group arc, therefore, central to the process o f languagc learning. In any communicative evcnt, intlivitlual participants bring with them prior knowledge o f meaning and prior knowledge of how such meaning can be realiscd through the conventions of language form antl Iichaviour. Since communication is primarily intcrpersonal, these conventions arc subject to variation \vhilc they are being uscd. In cxploring shared knowledge, participants \ f i l l he modifying that knowlctlgr. They typically exploit a tcnsion between the conventions that are cstahlishcd and the opportunity to modify these conventions for their particular communicative purposes. Communicating is not merely a mattcr of folloning conventions hut also of negotiating through and ahout thc convcntions thcmselvcs. It is a convention-creating as well as a convention-follo\ving activity. In communication, speakers and hcarcrs (and writers antl readers) are most often engaged in the work of sharing meanings \vhich arc 110th dcpendcnt on the conventions of interpersonal hehaviour antl created b y such Iiehaviour. Similarly, thc itleas o r concepts which are communicated about contain differcnt potential meanings, and such potential meanings are expressed through antl tlerivctl from the formal system of text during the process of communication .To understand the conventions which underlie communication, therefore, we not only have to understand a system of ideas or concepts and a system of interpersonal bchaviour, we have to understand how thcse itlcas and this interpersonal bchaviour can be realiscd in languagc in connectcd texts. Mastering this unity ofideational, interpersonal and textual knowledge allows us to participate in a crcative mcaning-making process and to express o r interprct the potential meanings within spoken or written text (Hallitlay, 1973). There is an additional characteristic of this unificd system o f knowletlgc. The social o r interpersonal nature of communication guarantees that it is permeated liy personal and socio-cultural attitudes, values and emotions.These different ufects will determine what we choose to communicate about and how we communicate. The convcntions governing ideas o r concepts, interpersonal hehaviour, and their realisation in texts all scrve and create attitudes, judgements and feelings. Just as communication cannot be affectively neutral, ~
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
11
learning to communicate implies that the learner will come to terms with the ne\v learning to the extent that his own affects will be engaged. A t that point, thc learner’s affccts become further involved in a process of negotiation with those affects which are embodied within the communicative performance of the target community. So, affective involvement is both the driving-force for learning, and also the motivation behind much everyday communication and the inspiration for the recreation of the conventions which govern such communication. Communication in everyday life synthcsises ideational, interpersonal, and textual knowledge - and thc affects which are part of such knowledge. I3ut it is also related to and intcgrated with other forms of human lxhaviour. In learning how to communicate in a new language, the learner is not confronted by a task which is easily separable from his other psychological and social experiences. The sharing and negotiating of potential meanings in a new language implies the use and refinement of perceptions, concepts and affects. Furthermore, learning the conventions governing communication within a new social group involves the refincrnent and use of the social roles and the social identity cxpectcd b y that group of its members. Thus, learning to communicate is a socialisation process. [. . .] Therefore, it makes sense for the teacher to see the overall purpose of language teaching as the development of the learner’s communicative knowlcdge in the context of personal and social de\ ~1op ment. 7c
2 What underlies the ultimate demands on the learner? A language teaching curriculum, from a communicative point of view, will specify its purposes in terms of a particular target repertoire (Gumperz, 1964). Different curricula will hopefully select their own particular repertoires from a pool of communicative pcrformance on the basis of a sociolinguistic analysis of thc target situation. This does not imply that any one curriculum will 11cnecessarily entirely distinctive in the target reprrtoire to which it is devotcd. A t the surface there will be inevitable overlap among different repertoires. However, underlying any selected target repertoire there will be an implicit target competcnce. It is this target competence which we may define as the capacity for actual use of the language in thc target situation. So, in specifying the purposes of the curriculum, a rcquiremcnt for thc communicative approach would be to make an initial distinction between the target repertoire ultimately demanded of the learner and the target competence which will undcrlie and generate such a repertoire. How can tve characterisc this target competence? We have already proposed that learning to communicate involves acquiring a knowledge of the conventions which govern communicative pcrformance. In addition, we have proposed that such communicative knowledge can lie seen as a unified system ofideational, interpersonal, and textual knowledge, which incorporates a range of affccts. We have also suggested that communication and learning how to communicate involve the participants in the sharing and negotiating of meanings and conventions. Such sharing and negotiating implies the existence of particular communicative abilities as an esscntial part of competence. Therefore, we may identify within competence both the knowledge systems and the abilities which call upon and act upon that knowledge. These abilities can be distinguished within competence more precisely. In order to sharc meaning, the individual participant needs to be able to interpret the meanings of others and to express his own meanings. However, such interpretation and expression will most often take place in the context of interpersonal and personal negotiation. The ability to negotiate operates between participants in communication and within the mind of the individual participant
12
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D CHRISTOPHER N. C A N D L I N
the latter negotiation is perhaps more conscious during new learning. More obviously, participants in communication negotiatc hvith one another. Rut, in endeavouring to interpret and express with a new language, thc learner will himself negotiate lictwecn the communicative competence he already possesses and that which underlies the new learning.’ Wc suggest, thcreforc, that the communicative ahilitics of interpretation, expression, antl ncgotiation arc the essential or ‘primary’ahilitics within any target competence, I t is also likely that these three ahilitics continually interrclatc with one another during communicative performance and that they are complex in naturc.l’hey will involve psychological processes for the handling of rich and variablc (lata thc attcmtion and memory processes, for cxample - antl they may contain within them a rangc of sccontlary abilities such as ‘coding’, ‘code substituting’ and ‘style-shifting’ (Ret-nstcin, 1971, I Iymes, 1971, LAov, 1970). The use of these communicative abilitics i s manifested in communicative performance through a set of skills. Speaking, listening, reading antl lvriting skills can lie sccn to scrve and depend upon the untlerlying abilities o f interpretation, expression antl negotiation. In this \vay \ve arc suggesting that the skills i-cprcscnt o r realise underlying communicative abilities. The skills arc the meeting point lict\vccn underlying communicative competence and ot)serval)le communicati1.e pcrformancc; they arc the means through which k n o d e d g c and ahilitics are translated into pcrfoi-mancc, and vice vcrsa. In sclecting any target repertoire, thcrefoi-c, a communicative curriculum also distinguishes antl specifics the target compctcncc o n \vhich the performance of such a rcpertoire depends and through which it is achic\.ctl.This specification would indicate the ideational, interpersonal and tcxtual conventions and the affective aspccts of such as a related antl underlying tcm of knoLvlcdgc which i s shared and conventions developed within the target community. The specification ~ v o u l dalso indicate the demands upon the lcarncr’s communicative aliilitics of intcrprctation, cxprcssion, and negotiation similarly underlying communicative performance in the target community and the range of skills which manifest these abilities. Such a specification \zould account for what thc learner nerds to know, antl how thc lcarncr needs to bc alilc to use such knowledge. Thc ultimatc demands on the learner in terms of some specific target repertoire will, in our vie\v, derive from antl depend upon this underlying competence of communicative kno\vledgc antl communicative abilities. -
~~
~
~
3 What are the learner’s initial contributions? [. . .] A communicativc specification o f purposes supports the principle that the roots of our ohjecti\-cs can already be discovered in our learners however liencath the surface of the actual targct repcrtoii-c these roots may lie. We need to try to rccognisc what the learner knoivs and can do in communicative performance with the first language and not assumc that thc Icarncr’s ignorance of the target rcpcrtoii-c implies that the learner is a naive ~
communicator or someone who evaluates communication in only a superficial \lay. This principle, which scems to rcquirc us to credit thc kat-ner with a highly relevant initial competcncc, of communicative kno\vletlgc antl aliilitics, has often been overlooked or only partially applied in language teaching. In the past, it has seemed easier to somchon. separate the learner from the knonletlgc to I x lcarnctl to ‘oljcctily ’ thc targct language as something completely unfamiliar to the learner. This olijrctification o f the language in relation to the learner has perhaps been encouraged hy a narrow definition of what the object of learning actually is, antl by an incomplete view of what the learner has to offer. Wc have tended to see the target only in terms of ‘linguistic competence’ o r tcxtual knowledge, and we have limited such knowledge to the level of syntax without reference
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
13
to structure above the sentence. Thus, ideational and interpersonal knowledge, which continuallv interact with textual knowledge and from which textual knowledge evolves, have tended to be overlooked or neutralised. We have often seen the learner primarily in terms of the first language, and we have often assigned to it ‘interference’ value alone again taking a narrow textual knowledge as our criterion. More recently, due to tlevclopmcnts within sociolinguistics, we haw recognised the significance of ‘ sociolinguistic competence’ and also of the ‘functional’ aspect of language. However, a partial antl knowledge-based view of learner competence seems to remain with us and the lcarncr’s communicative abilities underlying the initial repertoire still need to bc more thoroughly exploited. Rather than just allowing the use of the first language in the classroom, we should perhaps be more conccrned with activating that which underlies thc initial repertoire of the learner, and to evoke and engage what we mav describe as the lcarncr’s ongoing or process compctencc.j Once we define the object of learning as communication, then \ve arc enahled to perceive the learncr in a new light. His initial textual knowlcdge is placed in its proper perspective - it is merely the tip of the iceberg. Language teaching need no longer be primarily conccrned with ‘linguistic competence’. We can begin mith the assumption that text is the surface realisation o f communicative knowledge antl abilities antl that text is used and created and learned on the basis of thcm.7’he communicative curriculum seeks to facilitate even guarantee the involvement of the learner’s communicative knowledge and abilities from the outset rather than overlook them for the sake of some apparent er, lcarners not only contribute prior kno\vledge antl ‘fluency’ \vith text. I. . .] Ho ing o f a language. What the curriculum abilities, they also have expectations about the le must be balanced by what the learner seeks to achicve in terms o f any specified purp personally expects of the curriculum. Perhaps the current interest in teaching language for ‘special purposes’ may eventually reveal the challenge to curriculum designers: that all learners regard themselves as learning a language for some special purpose. We can identify several types of learner expectations and these may, of course, influencc one another. We can ask: What is the learner’s own vicw of the nature of language?What is the learner’s view of learning a languagr? (Thc answers to these questions ma)- lie in the learner’s previous formal education, and how he reacted to that experience.) We can also distinguish between, first, ho\v the learner defines his o\.cn language learning ncrds; secondly, what is likely to interest the learner both within the target reprrtoire antl thc learning process; and, third, \\,hat the learner’s moti\rations are for learning the target rcpertoire. All these initial expectations arc disti ti need to be discovered in somc \vay so that areas ofpotential match antl mismatch be learncr expectations antl the selected target repertoire antl its underlying competence can be best anticipated. Two important problems nrctl to be identified h c r r in accounting for learncr expectations. Thesc expectations are inwitably various antl more significant1)-- thc)- are subject to change over time. So, the curriculum will need to accommotlatc and allow for a heterogeneity of lcarner expectations. It will also ncetl to allow for changes in different learncrs’ perceptions of their needs, in ivhat interests different learncrs, and in the motivations of differrnt learners. In this way, curriculum purposes should account for initial cxpectations of lcarners and anticipate changes in expectations during the learning teaching process. Such an account and such anticipation may appear to be an impracticable dream when confronted with the variety and fluctuation in the real expectations of learners. That we should try to account for and anticipate these is a further motivation for a communicative curriculum, and more particularly for a communicatjvr methodology (scc sections 4ff). However, there is a second important aspect of learner cxpectations: expectations can tie educated. For this to happen, learners need to be enabled to express their own expectations; ~
~
~
~
~
~
14
M I C H A E L P. BREEN AND CHRISTOPHER N. C A N D L I N
to explore them and the sourccs from which they derive. They also need to be enabled to interpret the expectations which the specific purposes of the curriculum make upon them as learners. They need to interpret at the start of the learning- teaching process and throughout this process what the target repertoire and its underlying competence demands of them. Howcver vague a learner’s initial interpretation may be, he is not going to learn anything unless he has an idea of what he is trying to achievc. Therefore, a process of negotiation between the learner’s contributions including expectations and the target repertoirc, and the means b? which thesc two are brought together, is likely to bc characteristic of a communicative methodology. Curriculum purposes inform and guide methodology, and an account of learner cxpcctations within purposes can enable methodology to involve these subjective contributions of the learner and, thereby, call upon thc genuine intersubjective rcsponsibility of that learner. ~
~
~
~
~~
4 How are the curriculum purposes to be achieved? 4. I Methodology as a communicative process Language learning within a communicative curriculum is most appropriately seen as communicative interaction involving all the participants in the learning and including the various material resourccs on which the learning is cxercised.Therefore, language learning may be seen as a process which grows out of the interaction lietween learners, teachers, texts and activities. This communicative interaction is likely to engage the abilities within the learner’s developing competence in an arena of cooperative negotiation, joint interpretation, and the sharing of rxprcssion. The communicative classroom can serve as a forum characterised liy the activation of these abilities upon the learners’ new and developing knowledge. This activation will depend on the provision of a rangc of differcnt text-types in different media spoken, written, visual and audio-visual which the participants can make use of to develop their competencc through a variety of activities and tasks. The presence of a range of text-types acknowledgcs that the use of communicative abilities is not restricted to any one medium of communication.The earlier distinction we saw between underlying abilities and the set of skills which serve and depend on such abilities enables us to perceive that the learner may exploit any selected skill o r combination of skills to develop and refine his interpretation, expression and negotiation. Thr learner need not be restricted to thc particular skills performance laid down by the target repertoire. Because communicative abilities permeate each of the skills, they can be scen to underlie speaking, hearing, reading and writing and to be independent of any prcscribcd selcction o r combination of these skills. Similarly, just as no single communicative ability can really develop independently of thc other abilities, so the developmcnt of any single skill may well drpend on the appropriate development of the other skills. In other words, a refinement of intcrprctation will contribute to the refinement of expression, and vice-versa; just as a refinement of the skill of reading, for example, will contribute to the refinement of the skill of speaking and viceversa. Classroom procedures and activities can involve participants in 130th communicating and metacommunicating. We have rcferrcd to the characteristics of communicating in section 1 of this paper. By metacommunicating we imply the learner’s activity in analysing, monitoring and evaluating those knowledge systems implicit within the various text-types confronting him during learning. Such metacommunication occurs within the communicative performance of thc classroom as a sociolinguistic activity in its own right. ~
~
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
15
Through this ongoing communication and metacommunication, learners not only become participants in the procedures and activities, they may also become critically sensitised to the potential and richness of the unified system of knowledge, affects and abilities upon which their communication depends. [. . .] In particular, the involvement of all the participants in a process of communicating through texts and activities, and metacommunicating about texts, is likely to exploit the productive rclationship hetwcen using the language and learning the language.
4.2 Methodology as a diflerentiated process The emphasis given in the previous section to the interactive nature of the communicative curriculum suggests, in turn, the need for a communicative curriculum to be differentiated. A communicative curriculum begins with the principle that we should differentiate within purposes between the target repertoire and the communicative knowledge and abilitics which underlie it. A second principle is that the learner’s process competence needs to be differentiated from the target competence, and that different learners may exploit different process competenccs as the means towards some particular target. These kinds of distinctions involve differentiation at the curriculum level bctwecn purposes and the methodology adopted to achieve such purposes. Within mcthodology, differentiation is a principle which can be applied t o the participants in the learning, the activities they attempt, the text-types with which they choose to work, and the ways they use their abilities. It is worth considering differentiation within these areas in more detail: (a) Learners’ contributions
Individual learners bring individual contributions to the language learning process in terms of their initial competence, their various expectations about language learning, and their changing needs, interests and motivations prior to and throughout the language learning process. Wc can recognisc that, even in the achievement of some common target conipctcnre, diffcrent lcarners through their changing process competcnce may well adopt different mcans in attempting to achieve such competence. (b) Routes
The emphasis within a communicative curriculum on the communicative process of language learning, with the consequent emphasis on cooperative learner activities, offers a natural means for differentiation, Different learners need the opportunity of following different routcs to the accomplishment of some individual or common group objective . Such variation in choice of route typically involves selection among alternative skills o r combinations of skills, and hence the choice of alternative media. The variation may be motivated by the need to work at a different pace from other learners, or by the desire to pursue alternative content. This sclection among routcs can itself be open t o joint interpretation, the sharing of expression and cooperative negotiation. (c) Media
In order to allow for differences in personal interest and ease of access, or to permit the search for alternative perspectives on the content, learners should be offered the possibility of working with one or more of a range of media. We mean by this that learners would be
16
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D C H R I S T O P H E R N . C A N D L I N
expected to act upon text-types in the appropriatr medium: written texts would be read, spoken ones listened to, visual ones seen. Just as communication is governed I>yconventions, so we can see that the different media represent and obey conventions specific to themselves. Learning dialogue by reatling, for cxample, may neutralise the authentic conventions of spoken discourse, and bve may tie asking thc learner to hccomc involved in using and applying knowledge in a distorted \vay.
Whatever the route chosen o r the media antl tcxt-types selected for communicative learning, different learners will have differentiated ways of making use of the abilities xvithin their communicative compctence, antl \vi11 therefore adopt different learning strategies. Such heterogeneity is often secn as problematic for the teacher, but a communicative methodology would take advantage of this differentiation among learning strategies, rather than insisting that all learners exploit the samc kinds of strategy. Thcse four illustrations of the principle of tliffercntiation within a communicative methodology imply morc than merely offering t o individual lcarncrs opportunities For differential communication and learning, or acknowledging differences between pcrformancc repertoires antl the developing compctcnces underlying them. Differentiation demands and authcnticates communication in the classroom. The various perspectives offered by alternative media, the accomplishment o f shared objectives through a variety of routcs, and the opportunities for exploiting different learning strategics, all facilitate the conditions for authentic communication among the participants in the learning. Differentiation also enahlcs the lcarner to authenticate his own learning and thcreby become involved in genuine communication as a means to\vartls it. Further, if ~ v confront e learners kvith texts and text-types lvhich are also authentic, this obliges us to allow for different interpretations antl differences in holv learners will themselves negotiate with texts.
4.3 Methodology exploits the communicative potential of the learning-teaching context We are easily tcmptcd to cxcuse the classroom as an artificial or synthetic language learning context as distinct lrom somc natural o r authentic environment, The communicative curriculum sceks to exploit the classroom in terms of \vhat it can realistically offer as a resource for learning. This would not necessarily mean changing o r disguising the classroom in the hope that it will momentarily servc as sonic kind of ‘communicativc situation’ resembling situations in the outside \vorltl. The classroom itself is a unique social environmcnt with its own human activities and its own conventions governing thesc acti\itics. I t is an environment where a particular social-p hological and cultural reality is constructcd. This uniqueness antl this rcality implies a communicativc potential to be exploited, rather than constraints lvhich haw to be overcome or compensated for. Experimcntation Lvithin the prior constraints of any communicativc situation is, as w c have seen, typical of the nature of communication itself, and thc prior constraints of classroom communication need he n o exception. We can make a distinction betwren the different contributions offered to learning by, on the one hand, the ‘formal’ language learning contexts ofthc classroom and, on the other, the ‘informal’ learning which takes place at any time, anywhere. The classroom can be charactcrised by the kinds of learning which are best generated in a group context, while ‘informal’ lcarning undrrtaken beyond the classroom is often an individual commitment, ~
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
17
espccially in the contcxt of foreign language learning. Thus the ‘formal’ context is one where the interpersonal relationships of the classroom group have their own potential contribution to make to the overall task. Within the communicativc curriculum, thc classroom i and the proccdurcs and activities it allows can serve as the focal point of the learningteaching process. In adopting a methodology characterised by learning and teaching as a communicative and differentiated process, the classroom no longer needs to bc seen as a pale representation of somc outside communicative reality. It can become the meeting-place for realistically motivated communication-as-learning, communication about learning, and metacommunication. It can he a forum where knowledge may be jointly offered and sought, rcflectcd upon, and acted upon. The classroom can also crucially serve as the source o f feedback on, and refinement of, the individual learner’s own process competcnce. And it can serve as a springboard for the learner’s ‘pcrsonal curriculum’ lvhich may be undertaken and developed ‘informally’outsidc the classroom. As a coparticipant in the classroom group, the learner’s own progress can lie both monitored and potentially sustained by himself on the basis of others’ feedback and by others within some shared undertaking. To cnsurc that the special and differing contributions offered by both ‘formal’ and ‘informal’ contexts of learning can be fully exploited, a communicative mcthodology has to try to relate the two.The classroom can deal with and explore phenomena which are significant in the cxpericnced ‘outsitlc world’ of the lcarner, and it can hccomc an observatory of communication as everyday human behaviour. As well as looking outwards, the classroom has a rcflcxivc role as a laboratory where observations can ticcome thc mcans for the discovery of new knowledgc and the tlevclopmcnt of abilities. A communicative methodology \vi11 therefore exploit the classroom as a resource lvith its own communicative potential. The classroom is only one resource in languagc teaching, but it is also the meeting-place of all other resources learners, teachers, and texts. Each of these has sufficiently hctcrogcncous characteristics to makc classroom -based negotiation a necessary undertaking. 1. . .] The authenticity of the classroom lies in its dual rolc o f ohscrvatory and laboratory during a communicative learning-teaching process. ~
~
5 What are the roles of the teacher and the learners within a communicative methodology? 5 . 1 The teacher Within a communicative methotlology thc teacher has two main roles. The tirst I-ole is to facilitate the communicative process between all participants in the classroom, and l i c t u w n these participants and the various activities and texts. The second role is to act as an interdependent participant within the learning-teaching groups. This latter role is closely related to the objective of thc first role and it arises from it. Thcsc roles imply a set of secondary roles for the teacher: first, as an organiser ofresources and as a resource himself. Second, as a guide within the classroom procedures and activities. In this role the teacher endeavours to make clear to the Icarnei-s what they need to do in order to achirvc somc specific activity or task, if they indicate that such guidance is necessary. This guidance rolc is ongoing and largely unpredictable, so the tcacher needs to share it with other learners. Related to this, the teacher and other learners can offcr and seck feedback at appropriate moments in learning-teaching activities. In guiding and monitoring the teacher needs to be a ‘seer of potential’ with the aim of facilitating and shaping individual anti group knowledge and exploitation of abilities during learning. In this way the teacher will he concentrating on the process compctcnces of the learners. ~
18
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D C H R I S T O P H E R N. C A N D L I N
A third rolc for the teacher is that of researcher and lcarner - with much to contribute in terms of appropriate knowledge and abilities, actual and observed experience of the nature of learning, and organisational capahilitics. As a participant-observer, thc teacher has the opportunity to ‘stcp back’ and monitor the communicative pro tcaching. As an interdrpcndent participant in thc process, the teacher needs to actively share the responsibility for learning and teaching with the 1carncrs.This sharing can provide the basis for joint negotiation which itself releases thc teacher to become a co-participant. Perceiving thc learners as having important contributions to make in terms of initial comprtence and a rangc of various and changing expcctations can enable thc teacher to continually seek potential antl exploit it. A requirement on the teacher must he that he distinguish between learning and t h c performancc of Irhat is being learned. The tcachcr must assume that the performance within any target rcpertoire is separablc from thc means to the achievement of that rcpertoirc. Also, he must assume that learners are capablc of arriving at a particular objective through tlivcrsc routes. The teacher nccds to recognise learning as an interpersonal undertaking over which no single person can have full control, and that there will be differences between ongoing learning processes.The teacher has to accept that different learners learn different things in different bvays at different times, and he needs to bc patiently awarc that somc learners, for cxamplc, \vi11 enter periods when it s w m s that little or n o progress is being made and that, sometimes, learning is typified by silent refkction.
5.2 The learner Regardless ofthe curriculum in lvhich they \vork and rcgartllcss of whether o r not they are being taught, all learners o f a language arc confronted by the task of discovcring how t o learn the language. All lcarncrs \vi11 start with differing cxpcctations about the actual learning, but each individual learner will be required to adapt and continually readapt in the process of relating himself to what is being learned. The knowledge will be redefined as the learner uncovcrs it, and, in constructing and reconstructing his own curriculum, the learner may discover that earlier strategies in the use of his abilities need to be replaced h y other strategies. Thus, all learners in thcir own w y s have to adopt the role of negotiation bet>vecn thcmselvcs, thcir learning process, and the gradually revealed object of learning. A communicative methodology is charactcrised b y making this ncgotiative role - this learning how to learn a public as well as a private undertaking. Within the context of the classroom group, this role is shared and, thereby, made interpersonal. If we recognise that any knowledge which we ourselws h a w mastered is always shared knowledge and that we always seck confirmation that \vc ‘know’ something b y communicating with other people, \re have to conclude that knowledge of anything and thc learning of anything is an interpersonal matter. Also, if we recognisc that real knowledge is always set in a context and this context is both psychological and social what is known will always be contcxtualised with other knowlcdge in our minds antl will always carry with it elements of the social context in which it was experienced then we also have to conclude that a significant part of our learning is, in fact, socially constructed. These justifications for a genuinely interpersonal methodology are quite independent of the nature of what is to bc learned. If the object of learning is itself communication, then the motivation to enable the learner to adopt an interpersonal means to that learning is doubly justified. Quite simply, in order to learn to communicate within a selected target repertoire, the learner must be encouraged to communicate to communicate about the learning process, and to communicate about the ~
~
~
~
~
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
19
changing object of learning on the basis of accepting that ‘learning ho\v to learn’ is a problem shared, and solved, h); othcr learners. Within a cornmunicativc methodology, the rolc of learner as negotiator between the self, the learning proccss, and the object oflcarning emerges from and interacts with the role of joint negotiator mithin the group and within the classroom procedures antl activities which the group undcrtakes.l’hc implication for the learner is that he should contribute as much as he gains, and thereby learn in an interdependent way. The learner can achieve interdependence by recognising responsibility for his own learning and by sharing that responsibility with other learners and the teacher. This commitment can be initiated anti supportcd by a milieu in which the learncr’s own contributions - interprctations, exprcssions, and cfforts t o negotiate are recognisrd as valid and valuable. Such a context \vould he typified by the acceptancc of ongoing success andfuilure as necessary prcrcquisites to\vards some ultimate achievement, where it is assumed that lcarners inevitably bring with thcm ‘mixed abilities’ antl that such a ‘mixture’ is, in fact, positively useful to the group as a whole. Commitment to communication on the learner’s part need not he regarded as something unattainable or threatening even for the ‘beginning’ learner because he is expected to rely on and develop that which is familiar: his own proccss competence and experience o f communication. As an intcrdcpendent participant in a cooperative milieu where the lcarner’s contributions arc valued and used, the individual learner is potentially reLvardct1 by having his own subjectivc expectations antl decisions informed and guided by others. In a context where different contributions and differential learning are positively encouraged, the learner is allowed to dcpend on othcr learners and on the tcacher kvhen the need ariscs, and also enablctl to be independent at appropriate moments of the learning. He can feel free to exploit independent strategies in order to learn, to maintain and dcvclop personal affective motivations for learning, and to decide on different routes and mcans which liecome available during learning. The paradox here, of course, is that genuine independence arises only to the extent that it is intcrdcpendently granted anti interdependently a Learning seen as totally a personal and subjective matter is seeing learning in a vacuum; indeed w-c may wonder whether such learning is ever possible. Lcarners also have an important monitoring role in addition to the degrec of monitoring which they may apply subjectivcly to their own learning. The learner can be a provider of feedback to others concerning his own interpretation of the specific purposcs of‘ the curriculum, and the appropriateness of methodology to his own learning experiences and achievemcnts. In expression antl negotiation, the learner adopts the dual role of being, first, a potential teacher for other learners and, second, an informant to the teacher concerning his own learning progress. In this latter role, the learner can offer the teacher and other learners a source for new directions in the learning-teaching process of thc group. Essentiall?, a communicative methodology would allow both the teacher and thc learner to bc interdependent participants in a communicative proccss of learning and teaching. ~~
~
~
~
~
6 What is the role of content within a communicative methodology? Language teaching curricula have often been traditionally defined by their content. Such content has itself been dcrivetl from a target repertoire in tcrms of somr sclccted invcntories of items analysed prior to thc commenccment of the teaching-learning proccss and often acting as predeterminants of it. Similarly, sets of formal items takcn from an analytic grammar of the language, or sets of ‘functions’taken from some list of semantic categories,
20
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N AND CHRISTOPHER N. C A N D L I N
have been linked to themes antl topics tlccmctl in advance to lie appropriate to the expectations of the particular learners. Communicative curricula, on the other hand, do n o t look exclusively to a selectcd target repertoire as a specifier of curriculum content, for a number of reasons. First, the emphasis o n the process of Iiringing ccrtain basic abilitics to bear on the dynamic conventions of communication prccludcs any specification of content in terms of a static invcntory of language items grammatical or ‘functional’ to be learned in some prescribed way. Sccond, the central concern for the development and refincmcnt of underlying compctcncc as a basis for a sclcctcd target repertoire requires a distinction bctwccn that target and an)’ content which could be used as a potential means towards it. Third, the importance of the curriculum as a means tor the activation and refincmcnt of the process competcnccs of different learners IiresupIioses differentiation, ongoing change, antl only short-term prcdictability in \\.hat may lie appropriatc contcnt. The communicative curriculum \vould place contcnt within methodology and provide it with the role of servant to the Icarning-tcaching process. Thus, content would not necessarily be prescrihcd by purposes but selected and organisctl within the communicative and differentiated prucess by learners and teachers as participants in that process.Therefore, the learner would usc the content 01’ the curriculum as the ‘carrier’ of his process competence and as the provider of opportunities lor communicativc cxpcricnces through \vhich personal routes may lie sclcctcd antl explored as a means to the ultimate target competence. From this concern with mcans rather than ends mith the process of learning-teaching rather than with the product the communicative curriculum will adopt critcria for the selection and organisation 01’ content which will be suliject to, and defined by, communicative learning and teaching. ’l’hc content o f any curriculum can lie selected and organised on the basis of some adolited criteria, and th criteria will influence five basic aspects of thc content: its focus, its scqucncc, its subdivision (or hrcakdo\vn), its continuity, and its direction (or routing). What arc the critcria for the selection and organisation of content within the communicative curriculum? ~
~
(a) Focus
Content within communicative mcthotlology is likely to focus upon knowledge both cognitive and affective \vhich is personally significant to the Icarncr. Such knowledge n-ould 1)c placcd in an interpersonal context hvhich can motivate personal and joint negotiation through the provision of authcntic and ~irolilcm-posingtcxts. If content is to bc sensitive to thc process of learning antl to the interpersonal concerns of the group, it needs to reflect and support the integration of language hvith other forms of human experience and hehaviour. ~
~
(/I,
Scy1rence
If \vc accept that the communicative process requires that \vc deal with dynamic and creativc convcntions, \vc cannot assume that any stcii-by-stcp or cumulativc sequcnce of content \vi11 ncccssarily be appropriatc. In learning, the various antl changing routes of the lcarncrs crucially affect any orticring of content, so that scqucncing derives from the state f r h e learners rather than from the implicit ‘logic’ of the content itsclf. I t may be naive to assume that what may he ‘simple’ for any one learner is likely to be ‘simplc’ for all learners. Sequencing in communicative content is therefore likely to be a cyclic process where learners are continuall? developing related lrameworks or aggregations of knowledge and ability use,
21
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
rather than accumulating separalde blocks of ‘static’ knowledge or a sequence of ordcrctl skills.Thus, content hccomcs something \vhich lcarncrs move into antl out from, antl to which they return in a process o f finer analysis and rcfincd synthesis. Curriculum dcsigntm cannot, thcrcforc, predict \z ith any certainty thr ‘levels’ of contcnt on which learner5 \vi11 tlecitlc to cvolve their own sequencing in learning. [. . .] (c) Suhtlrvision
Traditionally content has been subdividetl into scrialisrd categories o f structurrs or ‘functions’. A communicative view of content precludes this fragmentation and argucs for subdivision in terms of whole frameworks hvhercin there is interaction Iictwern all the various componcnts of the knowlcdge system ideational, interpersonal antl textual and all the abilitics involved in using such kno\vlcdge. Content would he subdivided or broken down in terms of activities and tasks to he undertaken, whcrcin both knowledge and abilities would lir engaged in the learners’ communication and mctacommunication. ‘l‘he various activities antl tasks would be related liy sharing a holistic ‘core’ of knowledge and abilities. So, we \vould not be concerned with ‘units’ o f contcnt, hut with ‘units’ of activity \vhich gencratc communication and metacommunication. ~
~
((1) Cont in u I
Thc need to providc continuity for the learner has, in the past, bccn liased upon contcnt. Within a communicative methodology, continuity can he identified within at least four areas. First, continuity can reside in the activities and the tasks within cach activity; antl from one activity to another and from one task to another. Second, continuity potentially resides within communicativc acts during the learning and teaching: either at the ‘macro’ level in terms of the \\.hole lesson and its ‘micro’ sequenccs of negotiation, or lvithin the structure of discourse in terms o f t h c ‘macro’ communicati\-c act with its ohvn coherent scqucncv o f uttcrances.Thirt1, continuity is provided through the ideational system. At thc ‘macro’ level the learner may have access to continuity of theme, VI hilc at the ‘micro’ level the learner can have access to conceptual or notional continuity Ideational continuity is rcalised through a rcfincment of tcxtual kno\vlcdgc the rcfincment of a concept, for example, can imply a rcfinernent of its linguistic cxprcssion, and vice-versa. Fourth, antl finally, continuity can reside bvithin a skills repertoirc or a cycle of skill-use during an activity. I;or examplc, thcre could he a progression from reading t o notr-taking to speaking for the achic\cment of a particular activity. A communicativc mcthotlology would exploit cach of these areas of continuity as clusters of potential continuitics, rather than cxploit any one alone. All can l x inherent in a single activity.‘I‘hcsr kinds of continuity offcr two important advantagcs.‘I‘hcy can servc the full proccss competcnccs of Iearncrs k n o ~ v l t ~ l gsystems c antl abilities antl they can allo\v for differentiation. Learners need to bc cnaliletl to scck and achic\-c their own continuity and, thcrcfore, the criteria for their onm progress. In thc process of accomplishing some immediate activity, lcarners will impose their o\vn personal and interpersonal order and continuity upon that acti\ it?, the communication lzhich the activity generates, the interpersonal, ideational and textual data which they act upon, antl on thc skills they nccd to use in thc activity’s achievemcnt. As a result, the progrcssivc refinemcnt of the learner’s om n pro compctcnce can provide an overall lcurning continuity. Once the tcacher can acccpt that cach of thew areas provides potential continuity for different to he a problem if different learners pursue scvcral routcs or progress at different rates. ~
~
22
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D C H R I S T O P H E R N. C A N D L I N
(e) Direction
Traditionally, learners have been expected to follow the direction implicit in some prescribed content. Typically an emphasis o n content led the learner from the beginning, through the middle, to the end. From \\.hat has been indicated so far, a communicative methodology would not cxxploit contrnt as somc’ lire-drtcrminctl route with specific entry and exit points. In a communicative methodology, content ceases to become some external control over learning-teaching proerdurw. Choosing directions becomes a part of the curriculum itself, and involvcs negotiation bct\vccn lcarncrs and learners, learners and teachers, and learners and text. Who or what directs content becomes a justification for communication about the selection and organisation of content with methodology, and about the various routes to he adoptctll>y thc learners through any agreed content. Content can be predicted within methodology only to the extent that it serves the communicative learning process of thc participants in the group. It might \vcll be that the teacher, in negotiation with learners, will ~ i r o p o s cthe adoption of aspects of the target rcpcrtoirc as appropriate content. Ilo\vcvcr, the teacher \vould recognisc that thc ccntral objective of developing underlying communicative knowledge antl atiilities can lic achi range of alternative content, not nccesrarib. including aspects of the target repertoire. Such *carrier’content can tic as tli\crsc as the different routes learners may take towards a common target: perhaps contcnt can bc more various antl morc varialile. Also, the teacher \voultl remain frer to build upon the contriliutions of learners their initial competences and expectations and exploit thc inevitably different \vays in which learners may attain the ultimate target. [. . . ]
7 How is the curriculum process to be evaluated? Thc communicativc curriculum insists that c,valuation is a highly significant part of communicativc intcraction itscll. Wc judge ‘grammaticalit?’ , ‘appropriatcncss’, ‘intelligibility’ , and ‘cohcrrncc’in communicative performance o n the basis of shared, negotiated, antl changing convcntions. Evaluation ivithin the curriculum can exploit this ‘judging’ clement of everyclay communicative hchaviour in the asscssmcnt of learners’ communication antl mctacommunication.‘I‘hc highlj evaluative aspect of communication can be atloptcd as thc evaluation proccdurc of thc curriculum. If so, the csscntially intcrsuhjectivc nature of evaluation can be seen as a strong point rather than, possilily, a Lveakncss. How might lve evaluate lcarncr progrc Evaluation of oncsclf, cvaluation of others, and evaluation of self‘ b y others is intersuhjcctivc. In this xvay, evaluation need not be regarded as external to the purposcs of the curriculum or external to the actual process of learning and teaching. In rccognising that relative su or failure in the sharing of meaning, or in the achievement of somc particular task, is most often an intcrsubjccti\-c matter, the communicative curriculum ~ v o u l drely on shared and negotiated evaluation. Criteria for eventual succcss in some particular task could lie initially ncg ctl, achirvemcnt of the task could be rclatctl to thcsc agreed criteria, antl degrees o f su or failure could he themselves further negotiated o n thc tiasis of the original criteria. Evaluatiyr criteria, therefore, \vould be rstahlishcd antl applied in a thrcc-stage process: (i) What might ‘success’ mean? (ii) Is the learner’s perhrmancc of the task succcssful! (iii) If so, hom succcssful is it? Each stage \vould lit, a matter for communication. Instcad of the teacher hcing obliged to teach toxvards somc cxtcrnally imposed criteria manifested most often by some external examination or stantlartlisetl test he can exploit the interpretation of these external or standardiscd criteria as part of the joint negotiation within the classroom. The group’s ~
~
1
~
~
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
23
discovery of the critcria inherent in such cnd-of-course or summativc assessment \loultl lie one means for the establishment of the group’s own negotiatcd criteria and, crucially, for the sharing of responsibilities during the learning-teaching process. In a communicative curriculum we are dealing with an intcrdcpcntlencc of the curriculum components of purposes, methodology, antl evaluation. It follolvs that any evaluation within the curriculum also involves an evaluation of the curriculum itself. Any joint negotiation among the various participants within the curriculum may obviously deal with the initial purposes and ongoing methodology which have been adopted. Indeed, communicative evaluation may wcll lcad to adaptation of initial purposes, of methodology, antl of the agreed criteria of c\-aluation themselves. Evaluation within and of the curriculum can lie a pokverful and guiding force. Judgements are a crucial part of kno\vlcdgc, Icarning, ~ judgements to the curriculum itself, evaluation by and any educational process. 1 3 applying the uscrs ofthat curriculum can be brought into the classroom in an immediate and practical sense. Once within the classroom, evaluation can be made to scrvc as a basis for new . of teaching and learning. nicative use of evaluation will lcad towards an emphasis on firmurive or ongoing evaluation, rather than summativc or cntl-of-course e\duation Ivhich may be based on some prcscribetl criteria. That is, it can shape antl guide learning and guide decisions within t h r curriculum process. Any shared antl negotiatcd cvaluation within the classroom will generate potentially formative feedback for and Iwtween learners antl between lcarncrs and the teacher. Formative evaluation may not only indicate the relative successes and failures of both learner and curriculum, it can also indicate new and different directions in which both can m o \ e and dcvclop. [. . .] This placing of evaluation within the communicative process as a formative activity in itself docs not necessarily invalitlatc thc place of summativc cvaluation. Summativc evaluation becomes valuable if it can reveal the learners’ relative achi ment o l a particular target repcrtoirc. I Iowever, we have already proposed that any target repertoire needs to be seen as the tip of an iceberg. Therefore, an essential requircmcnt on any summativc evaluation \rould be that it can adcquately account for the learner’s progress in the refinement of a particular underlying competence the communicative knowledge antl aliilities which provide the capociy for the use of a target repertoire. Summativc evaluation, in other words, needs to be sensitive to differential competences which may undcrlie some common target. As such, summative evaluation within a communicative curriculum ncctls to focus on the assessment of the learner’s developing communicative knowlcdgc and aliilities as well as on his actual pcrformance \\ ithin the target rcpertoire. [. . . I Therefore, the essential characteristics of evaluation within a communicative curriculum Lvould be that such evaluation is itself incorporated within the communicatily process of teaching and learning, that it serves the dual role of evaluating lcarncr progress and the ongoing curriculum, and that it is likely to hc formative in the achievement ofthis dual role. ~
8 Achieving communicative language teaching We cmphasised at the outset of this paper that any curriculum framework for language teaching and learning nccrssarily in\ olvcs designers, materials writers, teachers and learnci-s in a process of relating the three components of purpose’,mcthodology and evaluation. Even so, we need to ackno\vlcdgc that any curriculum including a communicati\c curriculum cannot strictly be designed as a whole from the start. We can only deduce and propose thc principles on which a varicty of communicative curricula may bc based. Any curriculum is a personal and social arcna. A communicative curriculum in particular, with its emphasis ~~
~
24
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D CHRISTOPHER N. C A N D L I N
on the learning and teaching o f communication, highlights a communicative process whereby the intcrrclating curriculum components arc themselves open to negotiation and change. From this it follows that the communicative curriculum no more than any other can ncvcr bc one uniquelp itlcntifialde language teaching curriculum. In a real sense thcrc can lie no such thing as an ideal antl uniquclp applicablc language teaching curriculum since any realisation of the curriculum must rctlcct a realistic analysis o f t h e actual situation within which the language teaching will take place. 'lh cope cvith this requirement of appropriateness to situation, thc communicative curriculum has to be proposcd as a flcxihlc and practical set of hasic principles 1% hich underlie a \vholc range o f potential communicative curricula. It i s this set of principles which \vc have tried t o present in this paper, in the knowledge that such proposals need to Iic translated into action in thc classroom in ortlcr to test their obvn valitlity.This is, after all, the only means by which curriculum theory and practice can develop. Even though thc curriculum dcsigncr may h a w takcn account of the actual language teaching situation, hc has t o rccognise that from tlcsign to implementation . J. M . Stephens (1 967) idcntificd this process when he is itsclf a communicative p r o c said:
-
The curricular rcforms emanating from the conference room \vi11 be cffcctive only insofar as they become incorporated into the concerns that the teacher is led to express. Any statcmcnts or decisions coming from thc curriculum committee will not lie transportctl intact into the li o f pupils. Such statements must work through a complex chain o f interactions. 'l'he original statements of the committee will act as stimuli for one set of pcoplc such as sulijcct-matter super\-isors.Thcse pcoplc, in turn, \vi11 react to the stimuli, possililp mcrclp mirroring \vhat they rcceive, more likely, incorporating much of themselves into thc reaction. Their reactions will then act as stimuli for a second s c t o f p ~ o p l c\z ho cvill also rcact in their mz-n way. After a number of such intermctliary transactions somconc, thc tcachcr, will apply some stimuli to the pupil himself.
(pp. 12-1 3) While Stephens, in talking about stimuli, docs not cmphasisc transactions as a t\vo-\vay process, he clcarlp implies that the translation from principlcs through design to implementation is most oftcn a proc ' ofi-cintcrprctation of the curriculum, and a process of negotiation lietcvccn the curriculum antl its users. If adopted lcithin the design and implementation procedure, the conditions or minimal rcquircmcnts on any communicative curriculum must take account o f those situational constraints which arc unchangeable. However, such minimal requirements should also serve as the gcncral criteria against which any situational constraints \vi11 lie tcstctl in order to assess lvhcthcr or not the constraint is genuincly immutal)lc o r lvhcthcr it may I>covt~rconit~. If a curriculum Inscd upon the principles \vhich \vc havc examined here is not implementalilc \Tithin a particular situation, then it tnay lie that a gcnuincly communicative curriculum is simply not ialdc. It may Iic the c a w that curriculum dc-signers antl teachers in such a situation nccd t o consider lvhcthcr thc achicv,mcnt of language learning as communicution is appropi-iate. Communicative curricula ncctl through timc and according to situation to lie open and suhjcct t o ongoing developments in theory, research, antl practical classroom experience. Communicative curricula arc essentially the means of capturing variability. Variability \vi11 exist in selected purposes, methods, and evaluation procedures, hut -
A COMMUNICATIVE CURRICULUM
25
variability must also be seen as i n h r r r n t in human communication and in the ways it is variously achieved 11y different learners antl teachers. T h c classroom its socialhological reality, its proccdurcs and activities is potentially a communicative cnvironm c n t whcrc the effort to pull together such variability is undcrtakcn.Thc learning-teaching process in the classroom is the meeting-point o f all curriculum components anti it is t h r place \z here their coherence is continually tested. T h e learning-teaching process in the classroom is also thc catalyst for thc dcvclopmcnt and rcfincmcnt of thosc minimal rcquircmcnts which will underlie future curricula. ~
Notes ‘Curriculum’ can he distinguished from ‘ayllabus’ in that a syllabus is typically a specification of the content of’ the teaching anti learning antl the organisation antl sequencing of the content. Content and its organisation is subsumed n ithin a curriculum as part of methotlolog! (Section 6 of this paper). A syllabus is thcrcforc only part of thc overall curriculum M ithin which it operates. For interesting discussions of curriculum theory antl ticsign scc, inter ulio, I a v t o n , 1973; Stenhouse, 1975; Colby et ul., 1975. This ncgotiativc interaction u itliin the learner hctwccn prior kno\vlctigc and the ncnlearning has Iwcn a conccrn \vi hology for many years. See, [or rxamplc, Piagct (1 95 3), Bruner ( 1 9 7 3), and Nc ’l‘his ‘process competcncc’ is changing antl de\ eloping communicatil c kno\vletigc and abilities as learner moves from initial compctcncc ton.ards the target competence. It is partly I- alcd through a series of ‘Interlanguagcs’ (Sclinkcr, 1972, Taronc, 1977, Corder, 1978).
References Bernstein, B., 1971. Clciss, Codes unci Control, Volume 1 : Theoretical Stutlies tori-urds u Sociolo
26
M I C H A E L P. B R E E N A N D C H R I S T O P H E R N. C A N D L I N
Stephens, J. M., 1967. The Process ?f Schooling: A P.y.chological Examination. New York: Holt, Rinehart &Winston. Tarone, E., 1977. ‘Conscious communication stratcgics in inter-language: a progress rcport’ . Paper prescntcd at the 1 1 t h T t S O L Convention, Miami, F1. 1977.
Chapter 2
David Nunan and Clarice Lamb M A N A G I N G T H E L E A R N I N G PROCESS
“I dunno,” Jimmy said, “I forget what I was taught. I onl) remember what I’ie learnt.” (Patrick W hitc) You are g l e n the experiences 4ou need to understand thc norld. (Paulo Coelho)
Introduction
T
H E D E C I S I O N S T H A T T E A C H E R S A R E R E Q U I R E D tomakc duringthc instructional proccss are all driven by the nature of the program, the goals o f instruction, and the necds of the individual learners. I t is therefore critical for us to considcr thcsc issues before turning to thc management of the learning proccss in the classroom.
[.
‘
.I In this chapter we cover the following issucs and concepts: Setting the conreit and cle_f;ningterm.s
key
terms defined arc “learnci--ccntci-c-dnC‘ss,”
“cxperiential learning,” “humanism,” “learning-centeredness,” “communicative language tcaching,” “high-structure and low-structure teaching” C u r r i c u l u m processes the scope of curriculum development and the importancc of curriculum development for the managcmcnt of learning Needs analysis definition and examples of needs analysis Setting goals and objectives from learner needs to learning goals, illustration of goals antl objectives, how clcarly stated goals and objectives provide a sound basis for managing thc lcarning process
Setting the context and defining terms
I. . .I Learner-centeredness The concept of learner-crnteredness has been invoked with increasing frequency in rcccnt years. What docs thc tcrm mean? Likc many widely used terms, it probably means rather different things to different people (Nunan antl Brindley 1986). For us, lcarner-centcrcd classrooms are those in which learners are actively involved in their o\vn learning processcs.
28
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
The extent t o mhich it 15 possil~lcor tlcsiratilc tor learners t o lie in\ol\cd in their omn lcarning nil1olniouslq \ a r ) trom context to context (and, intlccd, from Icarncr to learner). If learners are t o lcarn anJthing at all, ho\zc\cr, ultimatel! thcy ha\e to do the learning for themsel\ es Thus it 15 a truism to sa! that the> \hould I,c in\ ol\ et1 in their OM n learning. In an ideal learning-centcrcd contcxt, not on14 \\ill deciwms about M hat to lcarn antl hov to learn be made n i t h reference to the lcarnci s, Init the learner5 themsel\cs will be i n i o h e d in the decision-making pi-oc t a c h clcmcnt i n the curriculum proce5s will inbolkc the learner, a s l a l i l c 2 1 .;ho\zs Tuhlc 2. l Learner roles in a learner-ccntcrctl curriculum Curriculum ctagc Planning
Role qflecirnei
I earners arc consultcd o n \\.hat thcy Lvaiit to
go a h o u t learning. of ncctls analysis facilitates this process. Lcarncrs arc in\olvctl in setting, monitoring, antl modifying the goals and objccti\ cs of the programs being dcsignctl for thcm. learn antl ho\v thcy want t o
Implementation
I cai-ncrs' language skills tl Icarncrs actively using ant1 reflecting on the
language insitlc and outsitlc the classroom. They are also involved in modifying antl crcating their o\vn Icarning tasks and language data. Asscs\mcnt antl c\aluation
Lcarncrs monitor ant1 a. The! arc also activclv involvrtl in the evaluation antl modification o f tcaching and Icarning during thc course and aftcr it has hccn completed.
Thc philosophy of Icarner-ccntcreclncss has strong links \vith experiential Icarning, humanistic psychology and task-liasrtl language tcaching. Thcsc links arc evident in the following quotes:
[A Icarnci--centered] curriculum \vi11 contain similar clcmcnts to thosc contained in traditional curriculum tlcvclopment, that is, planning (including needs analysis, goal and objective setting), implementation (including methodology antl materials dcvclopment) antl evaluation (see for cxamplc Hunkins 1980). However, the key differrncc lietween learner-ccntrctl antl traditional curriculum tlcvclopment is that, in the formcr, the curriculum is a collaborativc cf'fort between tcachcrs and learncrs, since learners arc closcly involved in the decision-making process regarding the content of the curriculum antl how it is taught. This change in oricntation has major practical implications for the entire curriculum pro ',since a negotiated curriculum cannot be introduced antl managed in the same \ray as one which is prescribed hy the teacher o r tcaching institutions. In particular, it places the liurden for all aspects of curriculum de\ elopmcnt on thc teacher. (Nunan 1988: 2)
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
29
The proponents of humanistic education have broadened our concept of lcarning by emphasizing that meaningful learning has to he self-initiated. Even if the stimulus comcs from outsidc, the sense of discovery, ho\vever, and the motivation which that \,rings has to come from inside drivrn hy the basic human dcsirc for self-realization, well-bcing and growth. . . . [I]. terms of personal and interpersonal compctcncc the urity, cooperation -oriented classroom revolves around issues of risk and and competition, self-dircct~dnessand other-directedness; antl meaningful and meaningless activities. We ha\,e also tried to make clear that “teachers \vho claim it is not their job to takc these phenomena into account may miss out on some ofthc most essential ingredients in the management of successful learning” (Undcrhill 1989, 12.
252). (Lcgutkc andThomas 1991 : 269)
Wt. can scc from these extracts that learnei--centeredncss is stronglj rooted in traditions dcri\cd from general education Our \ iem is that language pc(lagog> nerd\ to drav on its hich it has not not al\z a) s done. In fact, some general educational roots for sustenancc, 1% language programs seem to ha\ e suffcrcd an “educational 1) pass ” Learning-centeredness
Tahlc 2 1 ,
M hich scts out the role of the learner in relation to curriculum planning, implementation and elaluation, represents the ideal As tcac hers and course dcsigncrs, me h a c heen in relatncly fc\z situations in \\ hich leal ncrs trom an cad! stage in the learning process h a c been able to make criticall? infoi-mcd decision\ about \z hat to lcai n and ho\\ to lcarn In our experience, learners nccd to be s\ sternaticall) taught the skills ncetletl to implement a learner (cntcrcd approach to petlagog) In other words, language programs should ha\e t\\ in goals language content goals antl learning piocc\s goals \uch a program \\e \zould charactcri7c as being “learning centered ” UJ tcmaticall) educating learners about \\hat it means to lie a learner, Icarncrs reach a point \\here the) are ahlc to inakc informed ticcision, aliout 1% hat thri n a n t to lcarn and ho\z thc! mant to lcarn It is at thi, point that a truly learner-ccmtcrcd curriculum can lie implemented Lcai ning c c n t c i c h e s s I \ thus designed t o lead to learner-centerednrss The pre\ ious discussion undci lines the fact that learner ccntci cdncss is not an all-ornothing process Rather it is a continuum trom rclati\cl) lcss to relatnel! more learner centered Nunan ( 1 99511) has captured this continuum in the tollow ing tables, which shobz that learner ccntcrctlness can be implementcd at a numlicr o f different lc\cls The tables also illustrate some ot the practical steps that can he taken in implementing a lcai nci oriented approach to in\truction Table 2 . 2 relates to the experiential contcnt domain It demonstrates that, all other things licing equal, a classroom in \z hich learners are made am arc of thc pedagogical goals and content of instruction is morc lcarncr-centered than one in \z hich goals antl content arc left implicit We \\auld argue that all learners should, in thc hrst instancc, IIC alerted to goalr and content In collecting data for this book me nere surprised at hom tntrequcntl) this step happened Ho\ze\er, wc \zould go furthcr, and arguc that it is just a first step along a path that, gi\en the appropriate context and types of lcarncrs, could takc the lcarnei 5 through a gradual learning process in mhich the) made selections trom a range of altcrnatii es, modihed and adapted goals and content, created their 0x2 n goals and selected their own cxpericntial content area, antl finall! mo\ cd be>ond the classroom itself (kor practical descriptions antl illustrations of thew processes, see Nunan 19951) ) Ho\z far one
30
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
chooscs to movc along the continuurn d e p e n d s o n onc’s learners and the c o n t e x t and environment of the instructional process. Table 2.3 shoxvs how t h e continuum can apply t o the learning process domain. O n c e again, we see that l e a r n e r - c c n t c r c d n w s is n o t an all-or-nothing process, b u t can lic implemented in a series of gradual steps.
Tuble 2.2 Learner-ccntcredncss in the experiential content domain Level
Leurner
1
Abvarcncss
1.carnc.n arc matlc aware of the pdagogical goals antl content of the course.
2
In\ olvcmcnt
Lcarncrs arc involved in sclccting thcir o\vn goals and ol>jcctivcsfrom a range of altcrnati\-cs on offcr.
3
Inter\ cntion
Lcarncrs arc in\ olvctl in modifying and adapting the qoals and content of the learning program.
4
Crcation
Lcarncrs crcatc thcir o\vn goals ancl ohjcctivcs.
5
Transccntlcncc
I.carncrs go I x y o n d thc classroom and make links t)ct\\ccn the contcnt of the classroom antl thc \vorld
act ion
Glo,r
bcvond thc classroom,
Tuble 2.3 Lcarncr~ccntcrcdncssin the lcarninc process domain I.cve1
Lecirner action
Gl0s.s
1
A\varcncss
L,carncrs itlcntify stratcg! implications 01’ pcdagogical tasks antl idcntil) thcir o\vn prctcrrctl learning s t j Ics/stratcgics.
2
Involvcnicnt
Lcarncrs makc choices among a range o f options.
3
Intervention
Lcarncrs niodif) /adapt tasks
4
Crcation
Lcarncrs crcatc thcir own tasks
5
Transccndcncc
Lcarncrs \>cconieteachers antl rescarchcrs
Communicative language teaching C o m m u n i c a t i w language teaching cmcrgcd from a numlicr of disparatc sources. D u r i n g t h c 1970s and 1980s applied linguists antl languagc e d u c a t o r s began to re-evaluate pedagogical practice in the light of changrtl views o n the nature o f language and learning, and t h e role of teachers and l c a r n e r s in thc light o f these changing vicws. The contrast lietween what for want o f h e t t c r t e r m s we have called “traditionalism,” and communicative language teaching (CLT), is shown in Tablc 2.4 in relation to a numlicr of key variables within the curriculum. The table prcscnts contrasts in relation t o theories of language and learning, and in relation t o objectives, syllabus, classroom activities and the roles of learners, teachers antl materials. The vicws illustrated represent points on a c o n t i n u u m , rather than
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
31
cxclusive categories, and m o s t teachcrs \vi11 m o w back and forth along t h e continuum in response to t h e n e r d s of the students and thc overall contcxt in which they arc teaching. The t r u t h is that language is, a t one and t h e same t i m e , h o t h a system of rule-govcrnetl structurcs and a system for the expression of meaning. Learning is a m a t t e r o f habit formation as \vel1 as a proccss of activation through the deployment of' communicative tasks. The challenge for t h e teacher, the textbook w r i t e r and the curriculum developer is to shobv how the rule-governed structures enable t h e language user t o make meanings.
Table 2.3 Changing vic\vs on thc nature of language antl learning: Traditionalism and CLT Teach I ng
Traditionalism
Commun ica ti re lung uagc
Theory of language
Language is a svstcm of rulegovcrnctl structures hierarchically arrangctl.
Language is a s! stem for the expression of meaning: primar) function interaction.
Thcor! of learning
Habit formation; skills arc leal-nctl more effectively if oral precedes \vrittcn; analogy not anal!
Acti\ itics inwlving real communication; carrying out meaningful tasks antl using language that is meaningful t o the Icarncr promote learning.
Ohjectii e\
Control of' thc structures of sound, form and order, master) oicr mhol\ ot the language; goal natil c spcakcr master!.
Olijcctiws \vi11 reflect thc nccds of the learner; they \z ill include lunctional skills as \vel1 as linguistics objectives.
Gradctl syllabus of phonology,
Will includc some or all of the follo\ving: structures, functions, notions, thcmcs antl tayks. Ordering \vi11 Iic guided by lcar tier ne et l s .
Svllahus
morphology, antl syntax. Contrastiw analysis.
~
pi-acticc.
Engage learners in communication; in\ol\ c proccsscs such as information sharing, negotiation of meaning and interaction.
Rolc ol lcarncr
Organisms that can he tlircctctl bq skilled training tcchniqucs to produce correct responses.
Learner as ncgotiator, interactor, gi\ ing as nell as taking.
Rolc of tcac hcr
Central antl active; tcachcrdominatctl method. I'ro\ itlcs mo(lcl; controls tlircction antl pacc.
Facilitator of the communication process, ncctl\ analyst, counselor, process manager.
Rolc of materials
Primarily tcachcr oricntctl. Tapes and visuals; language lab oftcn
Primary role of promoting communicative language use; task based, authcntic matcrials
Acti] itics
Dialogues and drills; repetition and memorization; pattern
used.
32
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
We do not Ilclievc that many classrooms can h e defined exclusively in t e r m s of a particular methodology. Whether a classroom is characterized as “traditional” o r “communicativc” is therefore determined by the relative emphasis and degrcc to which the views listed in the table underpin \\.hat happens in the classroom rather than on the cxclusiw adherencc to one set of views to thc exclusion of an); other. Thc difference lies, not in the rigid adherence to onc particular ap[iroach rather than another, but in the basic orientation. Somc teachers operatc out of a traditional paradigm, making occasional forays into CL2T, and for others it is the other \.ray around. In the ESI. and EFIJ classrooms vvc have worked in and studied in rcccnt !cars, the Ix-cvailing t r c d has hcrn to\vard CLT, although by no means exclusively so.
High- and low-structure teaching
The insight that communication \vas an intcgratetl process rather than a set o f discrete learning outcomes created a dilcmma for language cducation. It meant that the destination (functioning in another language) and thc routc (attcmpting t o learn thc target language) moved much closer togethcr, antl, in some instances (for examplr, in role plays and simulations), became indistinguisha1,lc.. The challenge for curriculum devclopcrs, syllahus designers, materials writers and classroom teachers revolved around decisions associated w i t h thc movements 1,ctween points on the continua set out in the tables in the preceding section. Questions such as the follo\ving therefore appeared Ivith increasing frequency in teacher-training kvorkshops: Ho\v do I integrate “traditional” excrcises, such as drills, controlled conversations antl the like, Lvith communicative tasks such as discussions, tlebatcs, role plays, etc.? Ho\v do I manage decision making and the learning pro classroom sessions devoted to communicative tasks Lvhich, by definition, require m c to hand over substantial amounts of tlccision-making p v c r antl control t o the Icarners? How can I equip learners thcmselvcs \vith the skills thcy \vi11 nccd to makc tlccisions \viscly and to embrace po\vcr cffccti\-ely? For some individuals the solution la? in wjccting the changing vie\vs along with their inconvenient pedagogical implications. Others lvcnt t o the oppositc extreme, eschewing “traditional” solutions to their materials clcvelopmcnt antl language-teaching challenges. In most contcxts, h o u cr, a more Iialanccd \icw prcvailctl.
For some time after thc rise of CL‘I; thc status of grammar in the curriculum \vas rather uncertain. Somc linguists maintained that it \vas not ne grammar, that the abilit? to LISC a second language (“knowing how”) \vould develop automatically if the learner \vcrc required to focus on meaning in the proccss of using the language t o communicatc. In rcccnt ?cars, this vicw has come under serious challenge, and it now seems t o 1~ widely accepted that there is value in classroom tasks kvhich require lcarncrs t o focus o n form. It is also accepted that grammar is an essential resource in using languagc communicatively. (Nunan 1989: 13) In educational terms, a useful \.ray of viewing this emerging dilemma in language cducation is in terms of high- antl low-structure tcaching. Iligh-structure tasks arc those in which teachers have all the p v c r and control. Low-structure tasks are those in which power and control are devolved t o the students. We have borrowd the terms “high-structure” and “lowstructure” from Biggs and Telfcr (1 987). They suggest that the successful management of thc, learning process depcntls on teachers knowing kvhere t o locate themselves on the high-
MANAGING THE LEARNING PROCESS
33
to Ion-structure continuum in relation to a given task. In a high-structure task, students are placed in reactive roles and accorded relatively little choice. In a low-structure context, c not equate highstudents haw many options antl maximum autonomy. EIomww-, ~ v do structure with non-communicative and Ion-structure with communicativc tasks. In ccrtain communicative tasks, learners have relatively little freedom of maneuver. Howcvcr, ~ v do c believe an association exists bctwecn lolv-structure antl CLT and that the incorporation of communicativc tasks Lvith Ion-structure implications into the classroom increases thtcomplexity of the decision-making process for the teacher. We \vould argue that the kinds of managerial issues that arise and the sorts of decisions that teachers arc required to make will be largely driven by the degrcc of structure implied. This concept is illustrated inTablc 2.5, which provides exemplary questions relating to highand loM--structure contexts as these apply to key elemcnts at the levels of curriculum planning, implemcntation, and evaluation.This schema will be referred to constantly in the pages that follow, as it is one of the key organizational framcworks underpinning the work as a whole. It allows us to deal coherently with the following key managerial questions antl to demonstrate that the answers \.rill vary according to the tlcgrec of structuring called for by the instructional goals guiding the intcraction at that particular time. What aspects of tcachcr talk (direct instruction, feedback, instructions, antl questioning strategies) facilitate or impair cffcctive learning? What issues nccd to bc taken into consideration in lesson planning and preparation? How can the tcacher most effectively cxploit resources in the classroom? What stratcgics cxist for setting u p diffcrcnt modes of classroom interaction, from teacher-fronted through small group, pair and individual Lvork? What arc the implications of affective attitudes (e.g., motivation, attitude and aptitude) for the effective managcmcnt of learning? What tools, tcchniques, and strategies cxist for the ongoing monitoring and evaluation of classroom interaction and acquisition? (All of these questions can be explored through thc investigative procedures suggested in Nunan 1990, 1992).
The curriculum in outline Implicit in the foregoing discussion i s thc fact that classroom dccision-making antl the effective management of thc learning process cannot be made without rcfcrcncc to the larger context within which instruction takcs place. The context and cnvironmcnt of the learning pro including the curriculum plans that should tlri\ e the pedagogical action, arc criticall! important hcrc. In other \vortls, classroom dccisions cannot be made \vithout rcfcrcncc to structures operating outsidc of the classroom, at the level of the curriculum. Language curriculum development has been greatly influenced by changing vi the naturc of teaching and learning.’l’hesc changing viclvs are reflected in the objectives and content of language programs, as well as acti\ities, materials, and tcachcr/lcarner roles. The influence of these diffcrcnt viovs was made clear in the Table 2.4, which contrasted traditionalism n i t h CLT. As hve can sec from Table 2.5, communicative language teaching has had a major influence on languagc curriculum dcvclopment. First, curriculum tlcvclopmcnt has hccomc much morc complcx. Whereas txvcnty or thirty years ago, thc point of tlcparturc for curriculum development trntlrd to be restricted to the identification of the Icarncr’s currrnt lcvcl of proficiency, \z ith thc dcvelopmcnt of communicativc language tcaching and thc insight that curricula should reflect learners’ communicative ncetls antl learning prcfcrcnccs,
Table 2. J Curriculum decision-making in high-structure and lo\\ -structure contexts
Curricular elements
High-structure contexts
Lowstructiire contexts
What docs the institution tell nic to teach? What arc the managerial decisions entailed in thc
Ho\v do I tlesign/adapt my o\vn content/ goalsltasks?
.It the planning ctage
Course dc5ign
teacher’s manual?
Nectls analysis
Collegial
Ho\v can I identify the learning prcfci-cnccs of m y students?
Ho\\ can I i n \ o l \ c my learners in identifying and articulating thcir o\vn needs?
H o ~ vcan I coopcratc \\-ith collcagucs in Course
What opportunitics exist
hi-
team teaching?
planning? Ho\\ can 1 get the most out of staff meetings? Holy can staff meetings contributc t o cffccti\ c planning? Resources
HOMd o I manage ujc o f act text?
Hmv do I niotlifq/adapt the t e x t ? Ho\v do I crcatc my olvn resources? Holy do I design split information tasks that \vi11 be cffcctirc in mv context?
A t the implementation rtagc
Talk/interaction
What arc cffectiw strategies for direct instruction?
W h a t questioning strategies facilitate learner
Hoiv do I give feedback on high-structure tasks?
How do I give feedback in lo\\--structurc tasks?
contributions t o low-structure tasks? W h a t types of teacher questions maximize student output?
Learner language
H ~ do M I correct learner errors?
Hoxv do I deal \r-ith group conflicts? Hmv do I deal with student resistance to learner initiated tasks?
Learner attitude
Group configuration
Hon- can I provide language models in small group role plays in xvhich the principal focus is on the exchange o f meanings?
Hoxv do I organize controlled practice? Ho\v do I managc teacher-fronted instruction
Ho\v do I set up small group learning? What strategies exist for setting communicatix-e
effectively ?
tasks in Lvhich students Lvork independently?
What techniques \vi11 help m e t o asscss the achic\cment of my learners?
How can I help my learners de\-clop effective tcchniqucs for sclf-assessmcnt?
A r the eraluation stage Learner assessment Sclf-cvaluation of the learning process Formal e\ aluation
Ho\\ can l e a r n e n be in\olxcd in proxidlng input to the e\ aluation procc$s?
36
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
much more information about and by learncrs came to be incorporated into the curriculum process. Thc other major modification occurred with the emergence of the communicative task as a central building block within the curriculum. Instead of being designed to teach a particular lexical, phonological or morphosyntactic point, tasks were designed to reflect learners’ communicative necds. I ,anguage focus cxerciscs \vere developed as a second-order activity. In summary, we can say that curriculum dcvclopmcnt represents a delicate juggling act involving the incorporation of information about the learner, about the language, and about the learning process. Language content questions include what are we tcaching, why are we teaching it, antl when ~ ’ arc e teaching it. Learning process qucstions, which are methodological in character, include how are \vc arranging the learning environment. Among other things, when we focus on the lcarner, we must ask how well the learner has done and how well the curriculum has done in serving the necds of the learner. Wc can relate thcsc key qucstions to each other in terms of the central curricular elements of syllabus design, which has to do Lvith thc selection, sequencing and grading of content; methodology, which is concerned with task selection and sequencing; and assessment and evaluation, which are concerned with determining how well students have done, as well as evaluating how well the instructional process has met curricular goals.These relationships are set out schematically inTahlc 2.6. Table 2. h Kc! curriculum questions, p r o w d u r c s , and arcas Question.,
,lrcus
ProceJirrcs
Contcnt
What? Why? When?
Sclccting Justifying Grading
I’roccsscs EIO\V?
When? Outconics Ho\v \vcll?
How cffccti\c?
1
tnacting Sequencing
1
Methotlolog!
Asscssing
Asscssmcnt
E\ aluating
k\ aluation
O n e vicw of “curriculum” has it that curriculum processes have to do with thc dc\-clopment of tactical plans for action. In this vicw, “curriculum” is taken to refcr to statements about what should happen in the teaching and lcarning situation. According to this vie\v, the curriculum specialist’s task ends when the ink is dry on the various documents that have been produced to guide teaching and learning. Wc believe that this vicw is simplistic and nai‘vc, that while “curriculum” includes the planning process, it also includes the processes of implementation antl evaluation .These three phasc-s are captured in Figure 2.1 . The final point we wish to makc is that the language curriculum should concern itself, not only bvith language content goals, but also with learning pro goals. Learners should be focused o n the processes through which lcarning takes place as well as on thc target language they arc learning. It is our contention that learners cvho h a w developed skills in identifying their own preferred learning skills and strategies \vi11 be more effective language learners.
37
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
Phase I:
Planning (initial nccds analysis, goals antl (hjcctives, contcmt, antl process)
Phase 11:
Implcmrntation (ongoing ncrtls analysis, monitoring, action I-cscarch)
Phase 111: E\ aluation (assessmcnt, self-asscssmrnt, program cvaluation) h p r c 2. I Thrcc phascc or pcrspccti\cs on the curriculum process
Curriculum goals
I anguage content
For example, to tle\rlop the abilit! to olitain goods and scr\ ices in the target language
Lcarning process
For cxamplc, to d e l elop skills in learning hov to lcarn
Task Aim To familiarize you \z ith some ofthc key tasks conccrncd n i t h cui-riculum dcwlopment and to provide an opportunity for you to relatc thcsc to your on-n tcaching situation. Procctlurc
1.
2.
The following list contains somc of the tasks that need to be carried out in the course of dcsigning and implcmcnting a curriculum. Study the activitics and decide kvhich of them, in relation to a context Ivith which you arc familiar, should be carried out by a teacher, a curriculum specialist, a counsclor, a director of studics, ctc. Write these down in thc spaces provided. Sclcct those areas for xvhich thc teacher has primary responsibility. What arc somc of the decisions that need to be made? Exprcss these as questions.
Data
Intel-\ iem students
~~
Conduct needs anal!iis Assign studcnts to class g r o u p Carry out diagnostic test Arress studcnts’ current le\el of English Ihagnosc indn idual learning difhcultics Identify indn itlual lcarning \t!lei Sclcct and grade linguistic contcnt (grammar, 1 ocabular!, functions, notion\) ~
~
~
~
-~
~~
Select cxpcriential content (topics, thcmcs, situations, settings, etc.) Sct out course goals Write performance objecti\cs __ Select, adapt or develop lcarning tasks and material\ Monitor student progrcss ~
~
_
_
38
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
A s e s s learning outcomes ELaluatc language program(s) ~
~
~
_________
~
~
~
~
~
~
___________
~
In some teaching contexts, teachers will lie rcsponsiblc for all these tasks. In others, they will have little control. Some of the questions r a i d by teachers in rclation to interviews, needs analysis, and assigning students to groups include the follo\ying: ~
~
~
Student intervicu,s Should these he carried out I d o r c , during, or after the course has begun? Should the learners he forced to respond in the target language? HOWdo I get information from lo\v-proticiency learners \vhen I don’t spcak their language? A‘eeds ana@s What techniqucs exist for doing nccds analysis? How can the resulting information be used for writing course goals and ohjcctivrs?What if my learners have conflicting needs? dssigning students t o groups What criteria, other than proficiency level, can be used to assign students to groups? Is it possible to have diffcrent configurations at different times during thc- teaching day?
Needs analysis In the course of designing a teaching program from scratch o r modifying an existing one, it is generally tlesirahlc to collect and interpret (lata about the learners and the institutional context in which they learn.l’his information may Ile collected formally or informally before the course and once the course has begun. A variety of different t y c s of information can be collectctl. Such information might include biographical information about the learners, data on the types of communicative tasks that learners might want or nccd to carry out in the target language, information on the ways in tvhich the learners prcfcr to learn, and so on. A \vide range of information can hc collected through nccds analysis procedures of various kinds, as will be seen in the sample instruments provided in this section. In the initial planning stages, the extent to which Icarners’ subjcctive nccds can be canvassed dcpends on the range and extent of lcarncrs’ previous cxpcricnccs. (It \vould l ~ cunrealistic, for example, to ask learners lvhcthcr they like to learn through rolc play and simulations ifthcy have never expericnccd such activities.) In attempting to obtain information from learners, as well as allout learners, additional limitations and constraints will apply \vith young Icarncrs, or with lowproficiency learners if the teacher docs not speak the learners’ first language and docs not have the benefit of bilingual assistants or other first language resources. Rrintllcy (1 989) suggests that there arc basically thrcc different approaches to nccds analysis. He calls thrse the language proficiency orientation, the psychological/humanistic orientation and the specific purposc orientation. The thrcc approaches arc differentiated according to their educational rationale, the type of information collected, the method of data collection and the l ~ u r ~ i o sfor e s \vhich the data arc collcctetl.The salient characteristics o f t h c three approaches are set out inTable 2.7. In learner-oriented contexts, the types of information requircd and the purposes to which thc information \vi11 b e put will vary somewhat from programs tlevelopctl without reference to the learners themselves, and those for which any preliminary analysis will be largely restricted to thc needs of the institution or thc educational system that the curriculum is intended to serve. Within a second, rather than foreign, language context, Rrindlcy suggests types of information and purposes that are important (scc*Ial~le 2.8).
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
39
Table 2.7 Approaches to needs analysis Lungnage proficicnc). orientation
P.y chological /humanistic orientation Spec$c purpose orientation
Educational rationale Learners Icarn morc txffectivcly Lcarners learn more effectively ifini-ol\cci in the learning
if gi-oupcd according to
Learners Icarn morc cffecti\ el\ if content is relevant to their
procchs.
specific arcas of nrrd/intcrcst.
Language proficitmcy/languagc
Attitude$, moti\ ation, lrarning
Information o n nativc speakcr
tlifficul tics
Ttratcgy pretcrcnccu
use of language in learners’ target
proficiency.
7jy of
information
communication situation Method ?f collection Standardized forms/tcsts
Stantlartlizetl forms
I anguagc analysis
Obscr\ ation
Observation, inter\ icws and
Surveys of learners’ pattcrns o f
survcys
language use
S o lcarncrs can be placed in
So Icarncrs’ individual
groups of homogeneous
characteristics as learncrs can bc
language proficiency
@\,endue consideration
S o that lcarncrs \vi11 be prescntctl ivith language data rclcyant to thrir communication goals
Purpose
So tcaclicrs can plan language
So Icarncrs can bc hclpd to
content relevant to lcarncrs’
1,ccomr sclf-dirccting b y bring
So motivation will I)c cnhanccd I)?relativeness of language
involved in decision making
content
proficirncy I c ~ c l
about their learning Source: After Rrindlry 1989: 67 69. Used b y pc.rmission
A major purpose for- conducting needs analyses is to categorize and group lcarners. This grouping process facilitates the specification of content and learning procedures that arc consonant with some aspect of the learner data that has been gathered. Figure 2 . 2 excmplifics some ways in which data can be used for grouping purposes.
Setting goals and objectives In the contcnt domain, needs analysis provides a basis for setting goals and objectives. Goal and objective setting arc important tasks in most educational contexts, because they pro\ ide a rationale for selecting and integrating pedagogical tasks, as well providing a point of reference for thc decision-making process. Goals arc broad statements that provide gcncral signposts for course development. Thc following sample goals have hcen extracted from a variety of second and foreign language programs. They are expressed in the 1)roadest possible terms.
To dcvelop sufficient oral and written skills to obtain promotion from unskilled \vorker to site superyisor To establish and maintain social relationships through exchanging information, itleas, opinions, attitudcs, feelings, and plans
40
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
Tuhle 2.8 T! pes of information required in a Icarncr-centered
yystcm
So that tcachcrs have a Iiasis on \vhich to tlctcrminc
Lcarncrs’ lift, goals
o r prcdict Icai-ncrs’ language goals, communicative nct\\.orks antl social roles
Language goals, communi( ativc
net\\ orks
antl social rolcs
So lcai-iicrs ilia) Ilc placrd in a g r o u p basctl o n
(‘oninion social roles, antl tcachcrs m a y makc
pi-c>lirninarytlccisions alwut coui-cc content a p p r o p r i a t e t o learners’ social r o l e s
Olljcctivc nccds, patterns of language usc,
S o Icai-ncrs can 1)c grouped according t o theii
personal rcsourccs (including time)
t i e t d \ a n d /or
Imguagc. proticicncy antl language clifficultics
intcrc-sts
So Icarnci-s can Iw grouped accoi-ding to thcir language proficicne\
Sul>jcctivcncctls including learning stratcg! prcl‘crcnccs, atlccti\ c nccds, learning a d \ it!
So that tcachcrs ma! adapt learning activities t o Icarning Ytratcgr prclci-cnccs, indi\ itlual needs
prcfci-cncrs, p a c ~ o f learning, attitudc t o \ v x ( l
correction
Information about I r a r n c r s ’ attainnicnt o f objccti\ cs
So that t h r tcachcr can m o n i t o r Iicrformancc and inotlitj progr,im accordingl!
Inloi-mation almut tlcvclopnicntal p r o u ~ s s c s
S o that t c x h c i - s can gear Ianguagc content antl
in second language learning, including
tiiatci-ids to learners’ stage o f tlcvclopmcnt
learners’ communicative strategic.; Sourre: Adapted f r o m Rrintllcy 1984. Used liy pc~riiiission.
~
~
To tlevclop communicati\ kills in ortlcr t o acquirc, rccnrd and use intwmation from a variety of aural sourccs ‘lh tlcwlop acatlcmic Iistcning skills in order- t o cxtract key information from university lccturcs To dcvclop Iiasic communicativc skills in ortlcr to olitain basic goods and services as a tourist
Morc limited goals, couched in functional terms, can Ilc found in tcaching matcrials of various sorts. The follo\ving h a w been taken from an intcrmcdiate~lcvcltextbook. In this book you will: Make comparisons Ask for and give advicc Express obligation Talk ahout past cxpc,ricnccs Exprcss opinions aliout cntcrtainmcnt. (Nunan 1995a) These goal statements arc very general in nature and can encompass numcrous subsidiary . Most curriculum tlocumcnts Iiasctl on a goal and olijcctivcs approach contain a
MANAGING T H E LEARNING PROCESS
[
41
Languagc proticicnc,y protilc 1
Students
\\
ith oral skills, but \I ith re\\ or no literacy skills in 1-1
2 Students \vho belong in a nc\v arrivals program 3
Studrnts
\\
ho rcquirc gcncral support in the mainstrcam
4 Stutlcnts with spccific affrcti\ e , language antl communication 5 Students \vho arc approximating nativclikc proficirnc!
ncctla
(Atlaptctl lrom S.A. ESI Guitlrlincs)
11 I earning strategy protile 1 "Concrete" learners 'l'hcsc learners tend to like gamcs, picturcs, films, vitlro, using cassettes, talking in pairs antl practicing English outside class.
2 ".tna~trcii/"learner.s'l'hcsc Icarnrrs like to study grammar, stucly English hooks, and rratl ne\\ s p a p u s ; they also likr to study alonc, find their own mistakes, anti \vork on problems set b y the tcachcr. tudcnts like t o l e a r n b! bvatching, listening to native 3 "Cornrnunicarivc" learners Th sion in h g l i s h , using tnglish out speakers, talking t o fricnds in English a n d Lvatching t ot'class in shops, trains, ctc., learning nc\v \vortls hy hcaring them and learning I>) con\ crsations.
4 " ; I ~ i t h o r i ~ - o r ~ ~ n/eurner.s t e d " 'I'h learners prclcr the trachcr to explain crything in a notebook, t o study grammar, learn likr to h a \ c their o\vn tcxtbo 1 ) ~rratling, and lcarn ne\? \vortls (Atlaptctl from Willing 1988) 111 Ilcarning purpose 1 Ne\\- arrivals 2 English in t h r \vorkplacc 3 English for further study 4 English lbr professional cmplo! nicnt 5 English for access to \ ocational tl-aining and cmploymcnt
Figtire 2.2 Three altcrnati\ e w a v s o f grouping learners
limited number of goals (perhaps five or six) that p r o d c a basis for the development o f objectives. Formal pcrformancc objectives specify kvhat learncrs should lie able to do as a result of instruction. Formal objcctivcs should contain a perfbrmancc (which sets out what learncrs arc to do), conditions (specifying the conditions and circumstances under which the learners should perform) antl standards (setting out how \vel1 they should pcrloi-m). The three objcctivcs that follow illustrate the thrcc components o f performance, conditions, and standards. ~
~
~
Working in pairs, learnci s \T ill pro\icle cnough information for their pai-tnrr to drau their famil! trcc The) \z ill pro1 i t l c cnough information for a thrcc gcncration famil! trcc to lie d r a n~. Students m ill extract and record estimated minimum antl maximum tcmperatui e4 from a tapcd radio neather forcca5t Thc) must accuratclj record tour of the ~ I regions Cwercd by the forecast. While matching a Iidcotaped conxerqation bctneen t\zo natixc speaker5,5tutlcnts v ill
X
42
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
identify the various topics discussed and points at which they are changed. All topics and change points arc to l x x idcntificd. The use of an objectives approach has k e n criticized in general education on the grounds that precise statements of what thr learner should lie able to d o at the end of a course is somehow undemocratic and neetllr~sslyrestricting on both the student and the teacher. Others argue that such precise specification greatly facilitates other steps in the design process. I t forces the designcr to he realistic about what learners can achieve and helps guide the selection of appropriate materials and classroom activitics. It i s also an essential prerequisite for devising appropriate forms of learner assessment. Some years ago, an interesting set of specifications was developed in Australia. Called the Australian Language Levels (ALL) guidclines, these specifications were intended to be general enough to help materials writers and teachers nm-king in a range of second and foreign languages. The ALL guidclines take as their point of departure a number of broad goals that are refined into specific goals, as shown i n l i b l c 2.9. You can get some idea from this furthcr example of thc breadth of the goal-setting exercise. You can also see how numerous subsidiary objectivcs could be formulated from each of the goal statements. Interestingly, the designers of the ALL guidelines chose to move directly from goals to the specification of task o r activity types without elaborating detailed sets of objectives. We also have employed this procedure in some of our work. Although we do not feel it necessary to dcvrlop formal three-part objectives for everything we wish to teach our learners, we do believc that a sample set ofohiectivcs can greatly assist in managing the learning process. They can be particularly useful in the ongoing monitoring and assessment of the learning process. The latest manifestations of the goals and objective approach to curriculum devrlopmcnt have appcareti in competency statements that attempt to specify what learners should be able to do a t different levels. The following arc extracts of core competencies designed for an adult immigrant program. Once again, you can see they arc formulated in terms of what the learners should be able to do as a result of instruction.
Englishfor
1.
2.
3. 4.
5. 6.
Stti(+
Can understand the context of further cducation/training in Australia Can utilise a range of learning strategies relevant to further cducationltraining context\ Can Understand an oral prcscntation relevant to further education/training contexts Can negotiate complex/problematic spoken cxchangcs rclated to further educational/ training contexts Can participate in group discussions relevant to further cducational/training contexts Can deliver short oral presentations relevant to further educational /training contcxts
[.
. .I
Vocational English
1.
Can understand the context of work in Australia
MANAGING THE LEARNING PROCESS
43
Table 2 9 Communi( ation and learning ho\\ -to learn coals Broad goal
Spectf;c gods
Communication
To be able to use the targrt language to:
By participating in acti) itics organized around use o f the targct language, learners will acquire
establish and maintain relationships and discuss
~
topics of intcrcst
communication skills in the targct language, in
exchange of
experiences, plans)
order that they may widen their nct\vorku of interpersonal relations, havc direct access to
(e.g., through
information, ideas, opinions, attitudes, fcclings, participate in social interaction rclated to
~
solving a problem, making arrangements,
inlorniation and use their language skills for study, vocational anti lrisurc-based purposes
making decisions with others, and transacting to obtain goods, srrviccs, and public information obtain information by scarching for spccihc
~
dctails in a spoken or written trxt and thcn process and use the information obtained obtain information by listening to or reading a
~
spoken or Lvrittcn tcxt as a wholc, and thcn and use the information obtaincd give information in spoken or written form (c.g., givr a talk, write an essay or a set 01‘ instructions) listen to, read or vie\\, and respond personally to a stimulus (c.g., a story, play film, song, poem, picture, play)
1.enmin~~hon-to-learn Leamcrs \vi11 be able to take a grobving
To develop: ~
cognitive processing skills (to enahlc them to
responsibility for the management of their own
understand values, attitudes and feelings to
learning so that they learn how to Irarn, anti hou
Iirocc’ss information, and to think and respond
to lcarn a language
crcativcly)
~
Icarning-ho\\ -to-lcarn skills communication stratcgirs (to enablc them to sustain communication in thc target languagr)
Source: Atlaptcd from Scarino ct al. 1988.
2.
Can utilise a rangc of learning strategies relevant to employment contexts
3.
Can understand an oral presentation relevant to workplace contexts Can negotiate complex /problematic spoken exchanges relevant to employment contexts Can participate in group discussions/mcetings Can participate in casual conversations
4.
5. 6.
1. .I ’
English for community access
1.
Can understand the context of wclfarc/community services in Australia
44
DAVID NUNAN AND CLARICE LAMB
2.
Can utiliw a I-angc of learning strategies relevant to the local community context
3. 4.
Can understand an oral report relevant to the local community context spoken exchanges for personal business and Can negotiate com~)lcx/l~rol~lcmatic community purposcs Can participatc in casual con\w-sation
5.
[.
’
.I (NSW Adult Migrant kducation Scri ice Ilraft Competencies)
Anothcr useful tool is the curriculum-planning qritl. Planning grids such as Figure 2.3 can be used to rclatr goal and olijcctivc statements kvith other curricular elements (such as grammar, functions, or topics). In Figure 2 . 3 the task or pcrformancc elements from a set of olijectives are cross-refercncctl ivith scttings.Thc gritl \vas dcvclopcd for a gcnci-al English speaking course.
Key to settings 1 At work 3 Using public transport 2 At home 4 In barkoffee shop
5 On holiday 6 In a store
7 At the market 8 At school
9 At a dinner party 10 In a government office
h p r c 2 3 Planning gritl tor gcncral Lnglish coui v
Task Aim To appl> the planning gritl dc\crilictl in this wction to >our own tcaching situation.
Develop a planning grid, similar to thc one in 1;igurc 2 . 3 , to a course of your choosing.
MANAGING THE LEARNING PROCESS
45
In th15 section \\e haie tried to illustrate a range of \Ea)\ in \\ hich goals and olijcctiics can be exprcssctl Dcspite tht-ir tlitlercncc\, all of these goal5 antl oblccti\es share somcthlng in common; the! all describe what learners should lit. able t o do as a result 01 instruction We l>cIie\e that all language programs should take as their point ot tlrparturc goals antl objectii CY, ho\z e i (’1- couchcd, that ha\ e been dcrii et1 from an anal
Summary and conclusions The hasic themc of this chaptcr is that a firm h i s for d‘frctivc classroom decision making and managemrnt must hr laid c w l l bcfore the teacher sets foot in the classroom. It is difficult, if n o t impossible, t o sa); whcther many managerial decisions are eithcr good or had Lvithout refercncc to the ncctls of t h r learners or thc goals and objectives ofthr curriculum. ions that teachcrs are required to make during the insti-uc nature of the program, the goals of instruction antl t h individual learners, i ~ - inclutlc c a detailed description and discussion of t procedures in the chaptcr. I. . .]
References Riggs, 1. and R.Tr1ft.r 1987. The Process o f l e a r n i n g . 2nd ctln. Sydney: Prenticc-1 Iall. Brindle!; G. 1984. A7eeds .hub,.sis und 0bjcctic.c Setting in [he :tdiilt Illigrunt Llocution frogrum. Svdncy : NSW Adult Migrant Education Service. Rrintlley, G. 1989. Ac.se.s.sing .4chie~eincntin u Leurner-Centred Curriculum. Sydney: NCELTR. Flunkins, F. 1980. Crirriculoin Deielopment: frogrum Improrcmcnt. Columl>us, Ohio: Charlcs Mrrrill l’ublishing Co. I q u t k e , M. and H. l’honias 1991. Process und Experience in t h e h n g u u g e Classroom. London: I nngman , Nunan, 1). 1988. The Lcurner Centred Curriculum. Cambridge: Cambridge. Univcr-sity P r e s . Nunan, D. 1989. Designing 7b.sk.s f i r the Communicative Clussroom. Cainbritlgc: Cambi-itlgr University Press. Nunan, 11. 1990. “Action rcscarch in thc language clas.;room.” In J. Richards and I). Nunan (ctfs.), Second L u n g t i u p Teucher Educarion. Ne\vYork: Cani\)ritlgc Univcrsit) Prcss. Nunan, 1). 1992. Reseilrch .l)fcthoJs in I a n g t i q e Leurnlng. NcivYork: Cambridge Univcrsity Press. Nunan, D. 1995a. ;ITL:lS: ~.ctrrn1n,4~C‘entcreti Communication. Boston: Hcinlc 8( Heinlc. Nunan, I). 199511. Closing the gap I)eti\ccn lcarning antl in\truction. TE5OL Q i u r t c r b , Spring 1995. Nunan, D. antl G. Brindle!. 1986. “The leal-ncr-ccntretl curricdum in theory antl pi-acticr,” paper prcscntctl at the AnnualTESOI. Convrntion, Anahrim, April 1986. Scarino, A , , D. Vale, 1.’ McKay antl J. Clark. 1988. .4tistruliun Lmgiiuge L c i d s Guiclelincs. Canberra: Curriculum Devclopmcnt Centre. Untlcrhill, A . 1989. “Pro in humanistic education.” Lnglish Lungiiugc Teuching ]ournul, 43, 250 256. Whitc, P, 1961. The Tree ?[,bfun. London: Penguin. Willing, K . 1988. Learning Sr,iiles in .Itloll ,1Iigrunt Etlncution. .4tIclaitle: National Curriculum Rrsourcc Ccntrc.
Chapter 3
Michael Lewis LEXIS I N THE SYLLABUS
S
Y L L A B U S I N T H I S C H A P T E R is interpreted in what Nunan calls the ‘narrolv’ sense thc content of the teaching programme. Willis, in The Lexical S y l l ~ hobserves , that an approach involves both syllabus specitication and methodology, and that syllabus and mcthotlology arc not discrete options: indeed, syllabus may be specified in terms of goals, performancc ohjcctiws, or other critcria such as l’rabhu’s procedural syllabus. Here, I am concerned with the contribution lcxis may make to the specification of content. Historically, syllabuses wcre structural; the Communicative Approach introduced functions, antl certain re-ordcrings. The question naturally arises as to kzhat similar changes are called for by the Lexical Approach. The search for a strictly lcxical syllabus is likelv to be frustrating for theorist, tcacher and studcnt. Witldo\vson has olxcrved that a strictly lrxical syllabus would begin Ivith one word texts each complete in itself, proceed to two word tcxts, and so on to ever more complex tcxts but where, at all timcs, any grammatical complexity was obligatory as thc language uscr’s meaning became incrcasingly complex, and demanded additional grammaticalisation. Even if such a syllalius were I)ossihlc to devise, it is difficult to imagine it being pedagogically acccptablc. Similarly, thc attempt by Cobuiltl to ticfine a Icxical syllalx~saround the most frequent words ofthc languagc has not, despite its fascinating theoretical base, met with widespread acceptancc. Some of the reasons I perceive for this arc discu. ti 11rlow. I cmphasisc that my own conccrn is to look at thc contribution ivhich lcxical items of different kinds can make in determining content. ~
Educational syllabus Language teaching is part of a \vidcr M hole, the education of individuals. Every learning cxyeriencc should contributc to thc dcwlopment of maturc individuals. Although cclucational experiences w i l l differ in the \vay they contributc for every participating in&\ itlual, effective educational experience should increase curiosity, wonder and awe, confidence and self-worth. In addition it should increase the individual’s ability t o concentrate, appreciate, argue a case, tolerate, take responsibility antl
co-operate. There is in all education a hidtlcn agenda which secks to tlc skills, the most important of lvhich arc inwlvcd in:
1
2
Itlcntifying problem\. Collecting information, data antl cvidence.
lop particular intellectual
LEXIS
3
4
5 6 7 8
IN T H E S Y L L A B U S 47
Classifying data, bv recognising similarity antl difference. Ranking, making hierarchies, separating more from less important. Evaluating evidence and argument. Estimating, so that the plausiliility of an answw may bc ci-aluatctl. Taking decisions hasetl on complete or partial data. Communicating results effectively. ~
It will he noted that much traditional language teaching is in direct conflict with some o f these otijectivcs.The I’-P-P (prcscnt, practise, produce) paradigm, repetition, and controlled pattern practice arc elements of this kind. A task-hascd methodology, and an O - H - E (obscrl e , hypothesisc, experiment) paradigm arc in sympathy with the \vitler educational syllabus.This is important, for nothing which happens in the classroom should conflict \vith the educational ideals \vhich the ahove summary expresses. The single most distinctive feature of the Lexical Approach is that it proposes a fundamentally differcnt attitude to the treatment of text. Firstly, it is suspicious of dccontcxtualiscd languagc, recognising the importance of co-text, antl thcreforc preferring extended text o r discourse. Secondly, it proposes a range of aivarencss-raising actilitics directing students’ attention to the chunks of which text is compowd. Texts play a rolc in introducing interesting content, b u t also act as a major linguistic resource from \vhich students can extract lexical itcms for study, expansion, and recording in appropriate formats. A basic classroom strategy will he helping students to avoid becoming preoccupied hv grammar or vocabulary, concentrating instead on different kinds of lcxical item. Syllahuscs are normally thought of as listing, and perhaps sequencing, course content. In tact, thrcc factors arc important: inclusions, exclusions and sequencing,
Inclusions, exclusions and sequencing As all teachers kno\v, courses are invariably too short. Although a case can lie macle for including any language which is ne\v for the student, a principal role for the syllabus is to providc- principled ways of including only maximally useful itcms. What is maximally useful is n o t intrinsic to the languagc, but relatcs to particular courses, antl ei.en particulaistudcnts. A primarv distinction is lwt\vccn long courscs perhaps over sevcral years in school and short intensive coui-scs intended to hale a high surrender valuv. Too many coursvs are constructed on the implicit assumption that thcy arc intermcdiatc stages on the way to full language comprtcncc. Only rarely is this the ca most students \vi11 remain intermediate and this should influence the language selected for inclusion. ~
Within the I .cxical Approach: ~
All lo\\ lexel t o u r w s \ \ i l l gi\c students a large \ocal)ular), eicn if the! are initiall) unable to grammaticalise it Pragmaticallj useful lcxlc al item\, partitularl) in\titutionalited uttcrancct, Iorm a significant component of all coursc5 A halance v 111 he maintaincd bet\\ n (relati\ el! rai e ) I\ ord5 cari jmg considcralilc incaning, and (rclati\el\ v idc antl frrqucnt) pattern5 1% ith Ion mcaning content
Three principal reasons may he itlcntifietl for excluding material: it is not identified, not valued, or not prioritised. In the days of structural syllabuses, mastery of structure was rcgarticd as synonymous with language learning; the consequent emphasis of structure within syllabuses \vas wholly to lie expected. When the influence of pragmatics \vas felt
48 M I C H A E L L E W I S in language teaching, functions became a familiar term to teachers. As a result CZbtildyou l i k e . . .? was re-identified as Ofleering; its re-identitication allowctl it to bc re-valued, and replaced, much carlier in courses. Within the Lexical Approach diffcrcnt kinds of lexical item may lie identified, o r in relation to traditional language teaching, re-identified. Examples are trcating would as a single \vord lexical item, rather than part o f ‘the conditional’ (see hclow), o r the recognition of fully institutionalised utterances which may be introduced and treated as unanalyscd wlmles contributing to, rather than tlcrived from grammatical competence.
The tension of syllabus v language and learning Most language syllabuscs still list discrete items; this listing naturally, but misleadingly, suggests that languagc: may be learned in a similar kvay, by ‘accumulating entities’. Nunan (1988: 34), i n his comprehensive survey 5jllubu.s Design, remarks that ‘there arc general arguments against grammatical grading of content, whethcr this grading be based on traditional critcria or on more reccnt critcria stemming from SLA research’. And he quotes Widtlowson as observing, as early as 1979: Inventories of functions antl notions do not necessarily reflect the way languages arc learncd any more than the inventories of grammatical points and lexical items. This comment reflects WitldoLvson’s claim that ‘Dividing language into discrete units of whatever type misrepresents thc naturc. of language as communication’. The tension bctwecn language as communication antl the supposcd neccssity for tliscrctc item listing for language sTllahuses is reflected in Willis’ comment (1 990: viii):
An approach \vhich itcrniscs language seems to imply that items can be learned discretely, and that the language can he built up by an accretion of thew items. communicative methotlologj i s holistic in that it relics on the ability of learners to abstract from the language to which thcy arc exposed, in order to rccrcate a picture of the target languagc.7’hc lexical syllabus attempts to rcconcile thrse contradictions. language minutely, resting on a large body of It docs itemisc language. It itcmi research into natural language. O n the basis of this research it makes realistic and economical statements about lvhat is to be Icarned. But the methodology associated with the lexical syllabus does not depend on itcmisation. Wilkins distinguishes lict\vecn synthetic antl analytical syllahuscs, the former being ‘a process of gradual accumulation of parts until the whole structure of language has hccm built up’, \vhile in the latter, Nunan ( 1 988: 28) suggests: Learners arc prcscntrtl ivith chunks of language which may include structures of varyin dc recs oftlifficulty. A starting point for syllabus design is not the grammatical b .g system ot the language, liut the communicative purpose for ichich the language is used. J
Prahhu (1 987: 1 ), tlcscrihing his \\ell documented Bangalore Project, tlcscrilio its origins:
A strongly-felt pedagogic intuition that the development of compctcncc in a second language requires not systcmatisation of language inputs or maximisation of planned practice, liut rather thc creation of conditions in which learners engage in an effort to cope with communication.
LEXIS I N THE SYLLABUS
49
Pratihu, Widdowson, Nunan, Willis and indced many others would concur with Nunan’s judgement that: Evidence from second language acquisition research suggests that learning docs not occur in a simple additive fashion.
(1988: 30) Syllabuses tend to isolate, divide and sub-dividc. The tacit assumption is that macro-skills are a synthetic assembly of micro-skills; that larger units of discourse are assembled from words and structurcx. Thesc assumptions arc almost certainly untrue but this raises pedagogical difficulties. Thc implications are that we should adopt a morc holistic view of language, and a task-based approach to learning, but, as Willis ( 1 990: 1 29) observes:
A shortcoming oftask-tiascd approaches is that they make it difficult to specify syllabus content, and as teachers \IT cannot he sure what has lm-n learned in the course of a given language activity or a given unit. ‘I’here is a fundamental conflict between the teacher’s natural desire to give clearly focuscd and effective lessons, and the non-linear nature of language and learning. Although therc is substantial theoretical support for task-based goal-orientated syllabus specification, most teachers continue to demand much more specific linguistic objectives for cach lesson. While endorsing and encouraging a mcthodology based on tasks and skills, rathcr than spccifically linguistic criteria, we can identify explicitly linguistic changw which arc consistent with the Lexical Approach.
Content specifying lists One of the most intlucntial attempts to specify contcnt \vas the Threshold Level, which attempted to dc-vclop in detail the \vork summarised in A’otional Syllabuses. Somewhat surprisingly, whilst claiming a primary focus on meaning, Wilkins (1 976: 2 1 ) had a rathcr cavalicr attitude to vocabulary: Rut it is tlicreforc with the general aspects of mcaning and use that thc categorics presented here are concerned, though they arc not less significant for being gencral in character.lhis also explains why no attempt is made in this framework to account for a lexical contcnt of 1earning.This is probably hettcr approached in terms of subjectmatter and situation. A t the same time, lcxical aspects cannot bc entirely excluded since grammatical and lexical tleviccs often interact significantly. To a certain, though limited, cxtcnt the scmantico-grammatical categories themsclvcs have applications for the lexical content . . . The lexical content of Icarning, therefore, can be largely derived from an analysis of the typical topics which occur in the language use of a given group.
( 1 976: 76) Wilkins’s vicw is, thus, that ho\vrver important vocabulary may be, it has no defining role to play within syllahus design. In contrast, Willis (1 990: v), dacloping Sinclair’s ideas, regards vocatiulary, and quite specifically words, as the key to syllabus specification:
50 M I C H A E L L E W I S Sinclair advanced a number of arguments in favour of the lcxical syllabus, liut the underlying argument \vas to do with utility and with the po\vcr of thc most frcqucnt lvords of English. . . . We tlccitlctl that \vord frequency \vould determine the content of our course Instead of specifying an inventory of grammatical structures or a set of functions, each stagc of thc course \vould bc h i l t round a lexical syllabus.This lvould specify \vords, then meanings antl thc common phrases in which thcy were used.
(1 990: 15) It \vi11 bc notcd that, despite the retercncc to ‘phrases in which they occur’ Sinclair and Willis largely equate the lexical syllalius with a word-based syllabus. Inherent in this intcrpretation are three problems which manifcst themselves in thc coursc tlescrilied in Willis’s The Lexical Syllabus:
1.
2.
3.
The most frequent ‘\vurds’ are lrcquently items previously regarded as structural and, ironically, \vords of low semantic contcnt.Thcsc largely delexicalised words are highly frequent precisely becausc they often have scvcral meanings, antl their pattern profiles are cxtremcly complex. Mastcry of wortls like t o , with, have is considerably more difficult than mastcring a voca1)ulary itrm with highcr meaning content: accident, soot, slump. The word-based syllabus introduced words with Imth their highly frequcnt and much rarer meanings together. A preoccupation with the word as a unit meant infrequent meanings of high]! frequent lvords \vcre givcn preferc:nce over highly frequent meanings of rather lcss frcqucnt words within thc corpus. Some of these rarer meanings of high frequency words appear as of relatively low utility, and a relatively high confusion-factor for elcmcntary studcnts. Multi-word lcxical itcms arc untlcr-valucd antl under-cxploitcd.
The Lexical Approach I propose avoids these dangers. It is specifically not a lexical syllabus, and explicitly recognises word patterns for (relatively) delexical words, collocational power for (relatively) semantically powerful words, and longer multi-\vord items, particularly institutionaliscd sentences, as requiring tlifferrnt, and parallel, pedagogical treatment. The old structural syllabuses specifically restricted vocabulary to the level necessary to exemplify structural patterns. Ironically, Willis ( 1990: 74) in his word-based approach explicitly espouses the samc principle: We .set out to achieve the best coverage we could with as little extraneous lexis as possible (i.e. extraneous to the most frequent 700, 1,500 and 2,500 ‘words’ which they selected as the basis for Parts 1 , 2 , 3 of their course). In contrast to their urge to restrict vocahulary at low levels, I advocate encouraging the learning of a comparatively large repertoire of high-meaning content nouns, adjectives and vcrbs. Although the \vords learned will inevitably he in corpus terms comparatively low-frequency, by definition they carry meaning. Rut words carry more meaning than grammar, and if it is communicative power which is thc primary objective, increased vocabulary will play a larger contribution than additional mastery of even the most highly frequent patterns of high frcquency words.There is an additional, pedagogical advantage. Willis observes that ‘profiles hccome lcss complex as one moves down the frequency scale’.This means that from a naive, student point of vicw the words are easier to learn, and any L2 L1 equivalence, which students almost incvitably make, is more likely to be accurate. ‘Learnability’ and communicative power arc at least as important in selecting words for inclusion as frequency.
LEXIS I N THE SYLLABUS
51
Lexis contributes as a syllabus component in the folloicing lvays:
1 . Certain words deserve lexical rather than grammatical treatment are typically high frequency, de-lexicalised items. Those items \vhich enter into the widest range of patterns, and are thus usefully if not maximally generative, arc words which themselves carry least meaning. De-lcxicalised verbs huve, get, p u t , take, make, do represent an important subcategory. Function words, often thought of as prepositions of, w i t h , j ; ) r , by, are anothcr. The modal auxiliaries, including would, are a third. Most importantly, would should be dealt with early in a course from a lexical point of view. I!I/ould was trcatcd in structural courses as ‘the conditional’; functions moved it to an earlier, but comparatively marginal, non-generative position. It dcscrvcs high priority as a oneword lcxical item. Interestingly, it is one ofthe items which mcrits fullest discussion in The Lexical . ~ l l a h u s . ~
~
~
2. Increased attention to the base form of lexical verbs A preoccupation with grammar and structure has obscured the importance ofthe base form of the verb in English. Willis comments on courses which ‘spend an inordinate amount of timc on the verb phrase’, that is, on the structure of the verb, and so-called tense formation. In fact, the simple present is about eight times as common as the present continuous in naturally occurring English and is, with thc marginal inconvenicncc of the third person -s, identical \vith thc base form. The Lexical Approach advocates the nred for a large rcpcrtoire of verbs in their lmsr or lexical form with increased attention to the highly frcquent present simplc.
3.
De-contextualised teaching of semantically dense items
Communicative power is most rapidly increased by expanding studcnts’ vocalmlarics, meaning their repertoire of lcxical items, but particularly simple high-contrnt words. Thcrc is no need for over-elaborate contextualisation in the early stagcs of learning: simplc identification of signification, although in no sense mastery of the word, is an appropriate and valuable basis for increased communicative power.
4. Collocations As soon as the inadequacy o f the grammar/vocabulary dichotomy is rccognised, it heconics natural for collocation to assume an important syllabus generating role. This applirs particularly to relatively high content nouns. When these arc introduced, it should he natural to introduce with them verbs and adjectives which form pow.l-erfu1or relatively fixed collocations. The statistical evidence of corpus lexicography hcrc clearly reveals the nccessity of acknowledging both literal and metaphorical meaning. Often it is the lattr-r which is more frequent.
5.
Institutionalised utterances
Traditional grammar exercises usually include a sample sentence which providcs the model for students to produce ‘similar’ sentences. Modern research into both grammar and learning suggests that students could usefully be offered a group of sentences for comprehension and reflection. These would not exemplify ‘the grammar’, hut be pragmatically identifiablc institutionaliscd utterances which students could both use immediately to increase communicative power, and as a resource the analysis o f which would provide a basis for the gradual perception of pattern.
6. Sentence heads These are very similar to institutionalised utterances. Scntcnce heads can frcqucntly he identified and provide both an immediate increase in communicative power, and a resource
52 M I C H A E L L E W I S to aid acquisition. These scntcncc heads frequently lie somc\vhcrc Iwtwccn grammar and function on a conventional syllabus. ‘Grammar’ in grammar practices frequently tried to cover all elements o f the paradigm, consciously introducing first, second and third person subjects, singulars antl plurals; in functional practice a single sentence head C f b u l d p i like t o . . . requires students to complete thc scntcncc in different \.rays. Introspection or statistical data, ho\ve\ cr, 110th r e \ d that some combinations of, for example, a particular modal antl a particular person are much morc frequent than others; compare C o u l d ~ o u . . . and Coiild she . . .; contrast 1 might . . . and Might 1 . . .?Doyon thinkyou might . . .? and D o j o t i think 1 might . . .? Paradigms cxcmplify the possible sentences of English; \vcllchosen groups of scntcncc heads exemplify the frequent or probable patterns of English. Functions arc all too often ungcneralisablc, \zhilc scntcncc head groups arc gcncralisablc. I t is noticeable that the institutionalisctl uttcranccs antl scntcncc heads of spoken English arc vclry different from those of the \\ rittcn language. McCarthy is only one of many to suggcst that ‘vocabulary \vork in spoken language requires separate and additional procedures from vocaliulary teaching using written texts’.
7. Supra-sentential linking Traditionally this has liccn practised only o n a grammatical level, concerning tags, interested responses etc. In fact, supra-sentcntial lexical linking is an important cohesive device in spontaneous conversation, suggesting lexically, rather than structurally, based cxcrciscs would be morc natural and morc pragmatically c4l’cctivc. McCarthy (1 99 1 : 7 1 ) quotcs data in which: People did not typically agree or disagree with phrases such as ‘I agree’ o r ‘I disagree’ (beloved of English course book writers); rather, there seems to lie a preference for simply using some sort of lexical relation between turns. This suggestion is borne out in Willis’s work, antl hc goes further, suggesting that much spontaneous conversation is based on joint production, in which participants contribute matching, complementary or contradictory lexical items in the devclopmcnt of a single unit of meaning. Supra-sentential linking of this kind is central to spoken discourse, but quite different, and equally important features apply to the crration of cohrrent and cohcsivc written text. A central requirement of the Lexical Approach is that language material should be text and tliscoursc, rather than scntcncc hascd. Again Willis agrees, constantly reasserting that ‘only by drawing attention to occurrences in text’ can learners begin to h i l d up an adcquatc picture of language in use.
8. Synonyms within the existential paradigm This is a particular cxamplc of supra-sentential linking. Observations of r e a l data show that in spontaneous speech the ability to usc altcrnativc language items as value-synonyms, although they have different signification, is a key fcaturr of fluency. Thcsc value-synonyms may be both individual words (daffbdils/flower5) or fully grammaticalisctl utterances realising the same pragmatic function (That has my full support. /ilbsolut+, I’dgo d o n g with that).
9. ‘Synopsising’ words Traditional grammar taught so-called reported speech. As discussed elsewhere, this category is wholly untypical of naturally occurring data. Most often, thc speaker reports a whole event, rather than manipulating the words that were spoken. The ‘reporter’ summarises or synopsises the whole nt lexically and so rcquircs an adcquatc repertoire of synopsising verbs.
LEXIS I N THE SYLLABUS
53
10. Metaphorical patterning Metaphor is often perceived as an essentially literary device. Modern philosophical and linguistic research rcveals that far from k i n g rcstrictcd to literary language, it is intrinsic to thc nature of language itself. Lakoff and Johnson ( 1 980: 7ff), in a seminal 1vol-k belonging ntiallv to the field of philosophy, have demonstratctl convincingly that there arc many concepts which cannot be discussed except in metaphorical language. ‘l’hcy give many examples but here a single example must suffice: TIME IS M O N EY . Thcy point out that this i s an English proverb, but more than that, it is impossible to talk about time without basing the conceptualisation on the metaphor ‘I‘IMI. IS M O N E Y .They developed the idea as fol1on.s (in slightly abbreviated form): Time is moncy i s a metaphorical concept. It i s metaphorical since \vc are using our everyday experiences of money, limited resources and the valuable commodities to conccptualise timc.This isn’t a necessary way for human beings to conceptualise time; it is tied to our culture. Thcre are cultures where time is none of these things.
Wc are adopting thc practice of using the most specific mctaphorical conccpts, in this casc time i s money, to charactcrise the entire sjstcm.
This is an example o f the \Yay in lvhich metaphorical entailments can catcgorise a cohcrent system of metaphorical concepts and a con-csponding coherent system of metaphorical expressions for those concepts. They point out that in English many of the lvords used to descrilie time can also he used to describe moncy: spend, invest, hudger, profitah!,y. Here are somc o f their examples: How do y o u spendyour time these duys.; 1 haven’t enough time to sppnre-fir thut. Is it worthjrour while? You don’t usegour time proptuhb. You ore wasting my time. This p d p t will s m e j ’ o u hours.
Clearly, there i s a pattern here which it is \vorth\z-hilc to draw to thc attention ofstudents. Many ofthe \vords which arc uscd to talk about m o n c j can also be uscd to talk about timcy. This i s not fully gencralisahle, but it still constitutes a powerfully generati\ e pattern s~ stem. The importance of I.akoff and Johnson’s \vork i s difficult to over-emphasisc. It is essential reading for anyone inttwstetl in how language works. When the Berlin n d l \vas breached, at first a trickle of peoplc camc through. Latcr, as the gap was widened, pcop1e.Jloodcd through. There \vas a constant streum of people anxious to visit friends, or rcstorc family contacts. Oncc the initial excitement wort off, thc,porr. o f people dried up. The above passage rcprcsents my own observations of the language used hy the K.B. C. Nexvs to rcport the destruction of thc Berlin wall. An important metaphor is involvctl: cro\vtls of people movc like VI atcr. It i s almost impossil)lc to descrilir those events without resorting to ‘water-\vords’. Rut notice, as Lakoff and Johnson constantly emphasise, metaphor highlights only at the expcnse of supprcssing. Peoplc in movement may movc like water, but they are not water, water docs not rc-cstablish family contacts.l’hcrc is a useful linguistic pattern, but not an identification. Editors on the Cobuild project were initially surprised at the prcpondcrancc of
54 M I C H A E L L E W I S metaphorical usage torrents arc morc likely to be of abuse o r French than water. Lexicographic difficulties arise if metaphorical use is morc frequent than thc litcral, and therefore supposedly core, use should it be placed first in the dictionary?Their editors have observed, for example, the importance of plant-based metaphor in discussing abstractions such as government policy: The problem has its roots . . ,;Since the beginning oftheyear, we have seen a j o w e r i n g . . . . For language tcaching, thc importancc lics in rccognising: ~
~
a
b
That metaphor is a part of everyday language. That such metaphorical usage is patterned, often in accessible, gencralisable ways.
Functions and skills The development of communicative poivcr will be aided by incorporating a well-balanced range of lexically derived activities in the classroom. These must reflect the different kinds of lexical item. The change, however, is a mattcr o f emphasis not revolution. Grammar retains a place, but a reduced onc; lcxis plays an incrcascd role. Language content can, however, never be wholly scparatcd from othcr elements of syllabus specification. Most functional syllabuses concentrate on micro- rather than macro-functions and ‘nice’ rather than ‘nasty’ events. For many students such functions as cxprcrsing irritation, expressing dishelie_f; distancing the speaker.from the content ~ f w h a ist said, expressing condolence, telling and responding to jokes may be at least as important as accepting and reJising invitations politely. In a similar way, a lexical approach suggests that thc skills syllabus needs to be broadened. Two skills central to the Lexical Approach arc developing the students’ ability to use the dictionary as a learning resource, rather than reference work, and, most importantly of all, helping students to identify lexical phrases in tcxt.This rcturns us to the single most powerful methodological implication, namcly a tliffcrcnt attitude to, and use of, texts.
Bibliography Lakoff, G. and Johnson, M. MetaphorslVe Lire By. Univ. of Chicago Press 1980 McCarthy, M. Discourse Analy~is~fbr Language Teachers. CUP 1991 Nunan, D. Syllabus Design. OUP 1988 Prabhu, N. S. Second Language Pedagogy. OUP 1987 Widdowson, H . Proper Words in Proper Places. ELT‘ News No. 8. British CouncilVienna July 1989 Wilkins, D. Notional S,vllahuses. OUP 1976 Willis, D. The Lexical Syllabus. Collins Cobuild 1990
Chapter 4
Michael McCarthy and Ronald Carter DESIGNING THE DISCOURSE SYLLABUS*
1 Introduction
T
HE A D E Q U A T E D E S C R I P T I O N OF L A N G U A G E is vital as a precursor of languagc tcaching syllabuses. A t the macro- and micro-level, from issues of genre down to individual grammatical and lexical choices, our findings (McCarthy and Carter 1994) have implications for how we look at the syllabus and, consequently, its content and the kinds of activities that it generates in the class. This chaptcr concentrates on those implications in discussing the design of the discourse syllabus.
2 The notion of ‘discourse competence’ Ever since Chomsky (1 965) made the distinction between competence and performance, that is what a person knows about his or her language as opposed to what can be observed from manifestations of actual use, linguists have debated just what ‘competence’ might mean. Chomsky was concerned with the fact that native-speakers have an underlying knowledge of what constitutes a well-formed scntcncc in their own language, and hc sct about trying to account for such knowlrdgc. But it was not long before thc notion of competence was expanded to embrace what a speaker needs to know about how a language is used in particular situutions for effective and appropriate communication, in other words communicative competence (see Hymes 1971). The notion of communicative compctcncc has had a very powcrful influence on language teaching, both in terms of methodology and the goals set by syllabus planners which learners are supposcd to achieve. Thus the term communicative syllabus is a familiar one to most language teachers. Typically, a communicative syllabus will set out a variety of communicative abilities that thc learner should be able to dcmonstrate at the end of a prescribed course or period of learning. O n e such English Language syllabus, a pioneer in its day, recommended that learners should be able to (among other things) makc and receive telephone calls, handle friendly and social correspondence, makc short notes to record salient information, ask questions and makc comments for gleaning further information, and so on.This was the Malaysian (1 976) Communicational Syllabus for Forms 4 and 5 of secondary school (see British Council 1983; 1986). The syllabus was a classic
*
Thi\ text ha\ heen atlaptcti
56 M I C H A E L McCARTHY A N D RONALD CARTER communicative one, \vith no rcal emphasis on rorrcctncss in grammar and vocabulary, and every cmphasis on the ability to communicate antl achi goals, a balance ofprioritics for which it came into much criticism in its o\vn country (See Mohidccn 1991). It was criticism ofthis swing ofthc pcmclulum an.ay fi-om linguistic. (i.c. grammatical and lexical) competence t o a prcoccupation bvith communicativc. compctcncc alone, not just in Malaysia, hvhich led applied linguists t o question whrthcr compctcncc could ever lie seen as a monolithic concept. Might it make morc sense t o think of the lcarnrr developing a set of competences, each one csscntial to using language cffcctivcly, but each one separable in terms of what could bc dcscribed and prescribed tor the syllalius and lcarning programmc?Thus grammatical and lexical kno\vlctlgc as one of thc scvcral compctences came to the fore again as an issue in language teaching. Applied linguists argued that communicativc ability was a hollow notion without kno\vlctlgc of thc grammatical system that cnablctl actual realizations of communicative acts (but also vice w r s a ; scc Canalc antl S\vain 1980). Equally, there \vas a return of interest in the prol)lcm of i-ocahulary building, lvithout Lvhich little rcal communication hias possible (McCarthy 1984; s ~ also c Carter antl McCarthy 1988: ch. 3 for a survey of these arguments). Linguistic compctencc, it mas argued, was a ne though not sufficient, condition for communicative ability. From such pressures h \\.hat most \vould agrcc i s a healthier balancc hctm n the tlcvclopment of competence in tem antl compctcncc in its use, as exemplified in so-called eclectic .an and Walter 1984 Cambridge English Course is a good example), and in what Yaltlcn (1 98 3) calls the proportional syllalius, \vherc the proportions of systemoriented knowledge and communication-oi-icntctl skills arc increasingly altcrcd in favour of the latter as the learner progresses from beginner level. The lcxical syllabus (Sinclair and Rcnouf 1988;Willis 1990), based on a faithlul description of how words arc used, represents anothcr move in the direction of integrating knowlcdgc o f the system antl knou ledge o f use. Rut othcr questions remain for thc guagc tcachcr. If the description of language is o f discoursc, and if discourse-level constraints incomplete without a description of the 1 operate simultaneously with Icxico-grammatical ones, then is thcrc something akin t o a discourse competence that can he tlescrihetl antl articulatcd as a sct of‘goals for the syllabus t o aspire to? Rcccnt tlcliatcs in syllabus design have tended t o assume that there is. Those linguists antl applied linguists who have moved a m y from the idea of competence as a monolithic concept have already addcd to thc basic notion ol’communicativc competence subdivisions such as socio-linguistic competence and strategic competence. As Canalc (1 98 3) uses these terms, they ma); I><, hricfly glossed as follo\vs: Socio-linguistic competence an entity consisting o f two suh-components: socio-cultural
rules of use and rulcs of discoursc. Socio-cultural rulcs arc conccrnctl with appropriacy of use with regard t o such features as topic, roles, attitude and register. Kules of discourse arc conccrnctl bvith features o f cohesion antl coherence. Strategic competence vcrbal and non-vcrlnl communication stratcgics for solving problems in communication, whcthcr Icxico-grammatical problems or problems
associated with sociolinguistic appropriateness. Among the problems facing the language tcachcr who tries t o interpret these notional divisions and subdivisions arc not least that of whethcr ‘socio-cultural’ concerns can h e scparatcd from ‘discourse’ and jvhcthcr such notions can cvcr lie vielied as items or entitics ‘to be taught’, if ~ ’ are e faithful to the view that a svllabus i s indeed a list of things to he
DESIGNING THE DISCOURSE SYLLABUS
57
taught and goals to lie achieved. The first problem, the separation of socio-cultural features from discourse ones, is cspccially problematic givcn, as ~ v have c argued clsewhcrc (McCarth? and Carter 1994), that such things as register antl mode are integral to the creation ot’tliscourse, not in some \vay ‘parallel’or complementary to it. Wc haw also sought to demonstrate that isolated lists of spccch acts are insufficient to tlrscribe \\.hat sIieakcrs/ writers do and how they manage interaction over extended language cvcnts. In other Xvords, \vc see the chaining together of’functions or speech acts as inseparalile from the creating of largcr pattcrns and gcmres in discourse. By the same token, ~ v esee the realization of rcgistcrs, attitudinal features and topics as inseparable from cohcrcncc and its manifestations in surface cohesion. Even more to the point, grammar antl \ ocabulary kno\vledge should invol\e ho\\. these aspects of linguisticjbrrn create discourse; in other \vords, linguistic competence cannot be separated from discourse competence. These views have a direct bearing on the second concern, xvhcther things can he itemized for teaching and given socio-cultural, strategic or discourse laliels antl thereti? allotted their rightful place in the syllabus inventory or check-list. How we analyse and classify language for our syllabus necessarily affects our methodology and Lvhat \ve do in thc classroom.
3 Analysis and classification Some notable writers on syllabus design follow the view that the analysis of language into is a feasihle hasis for its various levels antl the classification of fcaturcs within those 1 syllabus specifications.Yalden’s (1 98 3) description of syllabus components sccms implicitly to accept this with a section cntitlcd ‘A further component: discourse structure’ ( 1 983: 78), and her syllahus chcck-list ( 1 98 3: 169-72) includes the following discourse components:
A 13
C 1)
Cohesion and rcfcrcncc (basrd large17 on Halliday antl Hasan 1976) Operations on text (for cxamplc extracting salient information, expanding a text) Rhetorical organization (textual functions such as generalization, classification, ctc) Overt transactional skills in spoken discourse (for example initiating, introducing topics, closing, turn-taking) .
Thcse categories certainly represcnt innovativc clcmcnts in syllabus specifications and are faithful to \vhat discourse analysts have described as above-sentence features. Wc should note, though, that categories A and C seem to be languagc fcaturcs, while I3 and D w ~ ~ ~ l d seem to fit bcttcr under the heading of‘ skills or stratcgics. This is no mere hair-splitting, antl is at the heart of thc process of analysis and classification that precedes specification antl itcmization. For instance, it could I)c argued that a feature such as lexical cohesion is an aspect of the language system antl can thus be taught as languagc knowledge, just like teaching the grammatical facts about tenses or dctcrmincrs. This would mean not only telling learners what the synonyms and hyponyms ofa particular word or set of words arc, but also demonstrating that synonymy and hyponymy in tise are often involved in the creation of wellformed text and interacti .pccch (see McCarthy 1984; 1988). Howcvcr, another vie\v might he that lexical cohesion is a language universal; as such, it liecomes more a matter of skill-training, practice and training in an intuitive skill in order to improve one’s proficiency in its use, without any need to ‘present it’ as knowlcdgc or fact.This is a crucial decision in the categorizing of syllabus components: Yaldcn ( 1 983), for example, has clearly flaggcd features such as turn-taking and closing as ‘skills’, suggesting a different emphasis from that attached to cohcsion antl reference, while ‘opcrations on a text’ are unambiguously things
58 M I C H A E L McCARTHY A N D RONALD CARTER we ‘do’ with language, rather than fcaturcs Lvhich ‘exist’ in the language system. But separating the ‘ivhat’of thc language . tcm from the ‘how’ of language skills and strategic use can also bc misleading: thcrc is every reason to suppose that knowing ‘what’ can inform and support knowing ‘holv’. Munby (1 978) has a simi , though much more tlctailctl, specification of discourse jiutures (cohcsion, initiating, d c oping thc tliscoursc, ctc) mixed in with textual operations (‘reading between the lines’, extracting salient points, skimming antl scanning the text, etc), lvhich, among man: other things, form a continuum from basic phonemic and ler the heading of ‘language graphemic discrimination through to macro-planning, all skills’. ‘Discourse lcvel units’ (Munhy 1978: 27) arc still , though, as separate from , and discourse is a level or language micro-functions antl grammatical/lcxical rcalizat layer of language rather than integral to its cntirc operation. Although, as we shall see, kvays of implementing the notion of a discourse element in the syllabus vary considerably, thcrc docs seem to I)c witlcspread agreement that the idea of discourse cannot he ignored; syllabus tcmplatcs antl check-lists as offered by applied linguists such as Munly ( 1 978) antlYaldcn ( 1 983) have a discourse clement built in. But we must now consider how more integrative vic\vs of discourse influcncc the nature of the syllabus and the tcaching that evol\-cs from it. O n e problem with thc vie\vs of comniunicativc competence as implied by the syllabus specifications that we have looked at so far is that thcy havc assumed that language use can hc analyscd and described as a sct o f components of various kinds. This assumption often crcatrs difficulties in that the separation of’componcnts can produce a false picture oftheir role in creating the overall message. A good example of this is the sort of list often found in syllabus specifications of speech acts or functions, such as promising, directing, enquiring, apologizing, etc. As Candlin (1 976) points out, an inventory of speech-acts o f this kind ‘cannot scrvc any more than sentences as thr direct endpoint of a communicative syllabus’. Any syllabus consisting solcly of such a list lvould fail in two directions simultaneously: it would fail to provide the learner with a clear vicw o f thc interrelated and structured nature of elements of the language system such as modality antl mood, and it would fail to show how apologies, enquiries, promises, and so on arc actually realized in interaction and as part of a .sequence o f utterances antl how such realizations depcndcd on higher-order constraints of genre. In other words, we \vould hc guilty of dealing bvith (some of> ‘the components of discourse, not with discourse itself’ (Widdowson 1979: 248). Widdowson and Candlin both come at the problem from the other direction: communicative compctcncc is not a list of learnt items, but a set of strategics o r proccdurcs ‘for realizing the value of linguistic elements in contcxts of use’ (Widdowson 1979: 248), and, just as learners may be expected , so thcy should be given the opportunity to pcrccive grammatical regularities in scntcn to interpret pragmatic clues for the attachment of value to utterances in discourse, and become themselves analysts of discoursc (Candlin 1976). One highly innovative approach to incorporating an integrative view of discourse into thc syllabus is provided hy Aston (1 988). One ofAston’s concerns is to redress the imbalance towards transactional language common in much language tcaching (which wr comment on in section 4) and to get to grips with the problem of creating the contexts for interactive discourse in thc classroom. Aston too moves away from simply adding discourse as an extra component in the syllabus and effectively builds his syllabus around central and fundamental fcaturcs of interactive discourse. For Aston (as we havc argued) interactive discourse is concerned not only with illocutionary uptake (the realization of speech acts), nor just with ‘cognitive convergence’ (achieving shared knowledge and pcrlocutionary effect), but also with affective convergence (an essentially humanistic notion), with the processes of creating
DESIGNING THE DISCOURSE SYLLABUS
59
and hvith the global and local strategies negotiated in individual contexts for achieving them. Aston recognizes the problems created by analysis and classification as thc precursor o f syllabus specifications: any analysis claiming to describe competence and to itemize it for a syllabus \vi11 fail to capture the fact that discourse is realized by the crcative exploitation of the resources that constitute competence (Aston 1988: 1 6 3 4 ) . In this sense, the learner can engage properly with discourse only ly Cioind it.This would seem to be a strong argument in favour of thc task-hascd approach as expounded by Prabhu (1 987). In the task-lnscd classroom, languagc is tised in the process of solving preordained tasks, \vith the purpose o f promoting and enhancing uptake antl Icarning, rather than presented and lcarnt in orticr to . or outside in the real world. be used later in cxcr Aston, however, sees many problcms arising from more extreme views of the taskbased approach (the extremest form of which would be the completely negotiable syllabus, with nothing preordained and everything open to negotiation among lcarncrs and teachers, which Clarke (1 991) claims would be unworkable anyvay). Aston seeks to build a syllalius Xvherein the learning process is not just left to gct on with itsclfin unpredictable ways, hut in which teaching can operate as a guidance.lb this end, it is not sufticirnt just to specify a set of tasks for learners to undertakc. For one thing, many of the task-types advocated by task-based syllabus designers fall into the same trap as the information-gap activities of communicative approachcs, in that they cncouragc a transactional vimv of language at the expense of the interactional. Furthermore, simply specifying tasks ignores the fact that lcarncrs can be guided in the procedural knowledge (the ‘ho\.r,things are done’ in particular speech communities) as well as the declurutive kno\vledge of‘what is clone’, both of which arc essential to the creation of coherent discourse. Aston, therefore, favours a task-liasetl approach that does not shy axvay from specifying the discour. ,tratcgics that thc lcarner \vi11 need; these will l x specified in a strategic pre-syllabus, which hc sees as a ‘contcntl m d ’ one (Aston 1988: 188). But c n with this pre-syllabus, tasks involving the learnelin creating discourse as the main syllabus are not enough. For Aston, the main syllabus is two-stranded, and the second strand involves the learner in hecoming a discourse-analyst, or indeed a sort of anthropologist (1 988: 184), observing and cieconstrLrcting how discourse is created. Aston’s final model therefore, looks like this:
contcxt-lmctl syllabus
construction
tlcconstruction (Aston 1988: 188)
Aston’s viem- of the syllabus seems to recognize that discourse is a process rather than a product (which tends to be the view of those who see ‘discoursC-as-a-layer’ in language use), but, sensibly, he sees the value both of an analysis and classification of discourse strategies as a precursor to selecting tasks for the classroom antl of making the learner stand liack a little from language and become an observer of it, though as a tliscoursr-analyst rather than as the sentence-parser and rule-discoverer of some approaches to traditional grammarbased syllabuses. O u r s is also an intcgrativc vicw, whcrcin the ovcr-arching pcrspcctivc of languagcas-discourse will affect e r w y part of thc syllabus, including any conventional ‘system’ (lexico-grammatical) components and functional/specch-act components, however they
60 M I C H A E L McCARTHY AND RONALD CARTER arc treated, whether as a series o f layers of language, or as realizations within general specifications o f discourse strategies.
4 Analysis as the precursor of tasks Aston’s programmc favoured a ‘ lire-syllalius’ oriented tolvards strategic issues in discourse. Specifying strategics i s something that can lie done in different ways and at different levels. Some syllabuses (for example ICC 19x6) specify a gcncral set of strategies, but it is also possiblc t o conceive of a highly detailed set lvhich translate some of the more traditionally conccivrd ‘features’ of language use into the strategic domain, and this is Ivhat we would like hriefly t o consider in this wction. What \z.c propose are a sct of strategy-headings that can act as a s o r t o f filter lictn n the learning group antl i t s need and the specification of tasks. Each heading is follon.ctl by example qucstions that arc raised liy each onc and the s o r t of practical issues that arc likely t o l x encountered in the detailed specification of tliscourscfiattrrcs that might bc encountcrcd in the subscquent tasks. W e say ‘likely’ because \ r e cannot always guarantee what thc outcome o f a task will lie. It will he noted that the global sct o f strategy headings can subsume what has previously h e n seen as a scparate discourse ‘layer’ by some svllalius designers. Thc most gcncral heatlings are as follows.
1 Genre-related strategies W h a t are the mctlia and modes that the learners \I i l l encounter? W h a t genres arc likclj to be most useful? W h a t patterns of interaction arc most useful (c.g. narratix e , lirohlem-4olution),
2 Coherence-related strategies What aspects of topic managcment, turn-taking, ctc, \vi11 hc involvctl? W h a t types of cohesion (c.g. stronger emphasis o n across-turn lexical cohesion for intcractionally oriented tasks; tlil’fcrcnt types of ellipsis in tliffcrcnt media)?
3 Politeness strategies What aspects of facc \vi11 need t o Iic atltlrcssctl? What forms of address will I>citnolvctl (c.g. pronoun systems, m o o d systcms)? Holv important will reciprocity be (c.g. very important in interactional tasks)?
4 Planning strategies W h a t sorts o f anticipator! strategies will he i d u l (c.g. cnuniei-ativc labelling, cataphoric uses o f articles)? Will special conditions for i-efcrcncc apply (c.g. anaphora across paragraph tiountlarics in written metli um) ? W h a t scquences o f t m s c , aspect and voicc arc likely t o 1~ involvcd (c.g. con\rntions rclatcd to genre)? What degree of crccitiri~.antl risk-taking with language is fcasihlc antl appropriate?
5 Convergence strategies Informational or cogniti~econ\crgcntc: and modalit! \I ill be in\ol\ctl?
\I
hat aspects of categories such as theme, m o o d
DESIGNING THE DISCOURSE SYLLABUS
61
Affective convergence: \\,hat adjacency-pair typcs arc likcly (c.g. solidarity routines, Ixoblcmsharing, agrccmcnt~disagrcemcnt)? What transaction-boundary features are likely (pitch-sequcncing, markcrs)! What role will repetition play in creating convcrgrncc in diffcrcnt modes and genres? W h a t tlcgrcc o f cultural convcrgcncc w i l l be required? How w i l l ‘knowing almut’ language anti culture a in solving convcrgcncc problems?
6 R e p a i r strategies W h a t arc the risks ol communicational prolilems o r cultural misunderstandings? Is repair likcl! to lie largcly self repair, or m o r c global, ncgotiablc repairs? Stratcgirs invarialily overlap. Iyor example, repair strategies may involve politeness, which in itself involves cultural awareness and the problem of convcrgcncc, antl s o o n . Rut given the practical exigencies of dividing the discourse process, n-c \vould arguc that thc stratcgic list I-epresents a manageable antl reasonably faithful framework for syllabus and task design. W h a t one docs with a list o f strategies for a particular learner group dcpcnds o n onc’s philosophy concerning methodology. The d i s c o u r s e - h a d approach (i.c. w h c r c \ve slur[ with discourse as the overall driving force of our syllalius) lends itself best, \vc have implied, to a task-liasetl methodology, in that, in this way, language is not atomized antl treated as product, thus destroying the basic notion of discourse as engaging Ivith language as process antl meaning as ncgotiatcd and contextual. Ho\ve\er, in the real world, teachers often have to \vork within clear and restrictive constraints Lvhere they arc expected to \vork to explicitly statcd classroom input and to achicvc explicitly measuralilc o u t p u t , in o t h e r \\-or&, syllaliuses that say rihar is to lie learnt and in \vhat ordcr. We see n o contradiction het\vecn o u r proposed list of tliscour tratcgics and the sulisequcnt spccification of the syllalius in terms of a set of specific performance goals, only that we start from a different premise: that all such goals can, and should he, expressed as discourse goals rathcr than as Iexico-grammatical or notional-functional oncs. Ibr example,\\e might cnvisagc a ‘learners should be able t o . . .’ lcaturc including something like the follo\ving:
Ask 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
significant favours of othcrs in appropriate secluences in\ olving signals of opening explaining thc problrm asking minimizing reinforcing acccding thanking.
The asking of a la, our is thus conceived o f as a genre rather than as a function or spccch-act, and inlolves not only sp h-act realizations at the micro-lc 1, hut also a strategic Icvcl involving politcncss strategies (l’acc), planning (opening), convergence (reinforciny), and s o o n . At the Icxico-grammatical interface, o n c could specify modalitv and (drlirnding on level) use of idioms. The point is that the conventional syllat,us~as~inventoi-y view can still be meaningfully adapted to a languagc~as~tliscourse approach \vithout just atitling discourse as a layer upon the o t h e r layers. t..qually, such an in\-cntory, in o u r opinion, tloex not sarily preclutle additional use of well-choscn tasks in class that can subscribe t o Aston’s (1 988) conditions of construction and deconstruction, nor docs it necessarily ~irecludesomc
62 M I C H A E L MCCARTHY A N D R O N A L D C A R T E R sort of proportional syllabus approach such asYalden (1983) advocates. For us, it is the analysis of‘language needs through a discourse perspective which is most important as a precursor to tasks and activities, whether such tasks are additional to a more conventional communicatively oriented syllabus o r whether the analysis is merely a pre-syllabus for the selection of open-ended tasks that will form a whole task-based syllabus in themselves. If analysis from a discourse point of view is to the pre-syllabus for a task-based one, then we would strongly support Aston ( 1 988) in his view that an analysis based on interactional language is just as important as one based on transactional uses of language. Real data show that the two types of language use rarely occur discretely (see McCarthy and Carter 1994: 1 17-24; Iklton 1988; McCarthy 1991 : 1 36--7). For an interactional view of language to have an input into task dcsign, the understanding of how natural conversation works, how speakers/writers orient towards rcciprocity and convergence, how they do so using systcmatic resources such as lexical cohesion and how features such as topic management are realized arc all central. It is hcrc, we feel, that syllabus designers have most to learn from what discourse analysts can offer. Designing tasks is no easy matter, and much useful literature exists which treats with more rigour than space allows us hcrc thc factors which can make o r break tasks (see especially Nunan 1989). It does seem worth underlining here, howcvcr, that tasks which promote only or mainly transactional uses of languagc (e.g. information-gap tasks) are unlikely to engage learners in a full range 01’ discour. trategies. Discourse strategies, we have argued, are concerned with human heings presenting a picture of themselves, not just conveying information to one anothcr.Thcrcforc, if‘gaps’or ‘problems’ arc the core features of tasks which motivate their completion, thcn we need to build in much more than just information or ‘opinion’ gaps (see Aston 1988: 192 -9 for a critique of information- and opinion-gap approachcs). Gaps in rapport, prohlcms of sensitivity, convcrgrnce towards acquaintance or friendship, gaps in self-image, problc~msof face, all of these will assume as much importance as gaps in placcs on a map, o r gaps in agrccing on where to spend a Saturday night, the stock-in-trade of many prcscnt classroom tasks. Tasks can fulfil some of these interactional criteria by dclibcrately ‘designing in’ unpredictable reactions, ‘diflicult’ participants, goals where conversational well-king is morc important than informational transaction, and s o on. An example of an attempt at building into a task interactional constraints demanding politeness and convergence strategies, taken from the International Certificate Conference’s teacher-training programme for teachers intending to use their discourse-strategy and taskbased syllabus (ICC 1986), involl participants in a consensus activity to agrce on the arrangement of furniture for a school opcn-day. Much of the task is transactionally oriented, culminating in leaving instructions for the school caretaker to execute the furniture plan. However, the person who role-plays the caretaker is required to take offence at the tone of the instructions and the task therefore cannot be complctcd until oil has been poured on troubled waters and ‘affective’ convergence has been achieved, even though cognitive convergence is already prcscnt in the written instructions for the furniture plan.This is only one small example, but it shows how task dcsign can attempt to replicate a wider range of discourse conditions, and how the ‘pre-syllabus’ might fecd into thc constructional syllabus in a more controlled way, if the dcsirc is to follow a task-based approach.
5 Conclusion We hope that the discussion in this chapter has pointed to the following conclusion: that awareness o f discourse and a willingness to take on board what a language-as~discourseview
DESIGNING
T H E D I S C O U R S E S Y L L A B U S 63
implies can only makc us b e t t e r and m o r e efficient syllabus designers, task designers, dialogue-writers, materials adaptors and evaluators of everything \ve do and handle in thc classroom. Above all, the approach we have advocated enablcs us to b e m o r e faithful to what language is and what people use it for. Thc m o m c n t one starts to think of language as discourse, the entire landscape changes, usually, for ever.
Bibliography Aston, G. 1988 Learning C o m i y . Bologna: Editrice CLUER Rclton, A . 1988 ‘Lexical naturalness in native and non-native discourse’. English Langnugc Research Journal (ns) 2: 7 9 105 British Council 1983; 1986 English Teaching Prof;rIe on .h‘ala,vsia. London: British Council Canale, M. 1983 ‘From communicative competence to Communicative language pedagogy’. In Richards, J. C., Schmidt, R. (eds) Language and Communication. London: Longman, pp. 2-27 Canale, M., S\vain, M. 1980 ‘Theoretical bases of communicative approaches to . language teaching and testing’. Applied Linguistics 1 : 1 47 Candlin, C. N. 1976 ‘Communicative language teaching and the debt to pragmatics’. In Kameh, C. (ed) Georgetonm Universiy Round Table on LungLiuges ant/ Linguistic<.Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, pp. 237-56 Carter, R. A,,McCarthy, M. J. 1988 Ibcahulay and Language Teuching. London: Longman Chomsky, N. 1965 ,4spects ofthe T h e o y ofSyntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press Clarke, D. F. 1991 ‘The ncgotiatccl s&hus: what is it and how is it likely to work?’ Applied Linguistics 12 (1): 13 28 Hallitlay, M. A. K . , Hassan, R. 1976 Cohesion in English. 1,ondon: Longman. Hvmes, D. 1971 ‘ O n communicative competence’. In Pride, J. Homes, J. (cds) SociolingLiistics. 1972. Harmontlsworth: Penguin, pp. 269-93 ICC (Intcrnational Certificate Conference) 1986 Foreign Languages in Adult and Continuing Education: Spec!fications,fir Stage 3 I.evel of the International Certfj?cate Conference Language Certificate System. Bonn Frankfurt: Deutscher Volkshochschul~Vcrbandc.v. McCarthy, M . J. 1984 ‘A new look at vocabulary in EFI,’. Applied I.ingnistics 5 (1): 12-22 McCarthy, M. J. 1988 ‘Some vocabulary patterns in conversation’. In Carter, R. A , , McCarthy, M . J. Ibcnhulay and Language Eaching. London: Longman, pp. 181-200 McCarthy, M . J. 1 9 9 1 Discourse .Ana!ysissisfor h n g i i a g e Teuchcrs. Cambridge: Camhridgc Univcrsity Press McCarthq, M., Carter, I<. 1994 Lunguage 0.5 Discourse: Perspcctirzsfor LungLmqe Teaching. London: Longman. written English of Malay students at preCardiff: University ofWales Munhy, J. 1978 Communicutive Syllabus Design. Cambridge: Cambridge Uniwrsity Press Nunan, 11. 1989 Designing Tasks f i r the Communicative Classroom. Cambridge: Cambridgc University Press a Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press Prabhu, N. 1987 Second Language Ped~~qogy: Sinclair, J. Mcli., Kenouf, A. 1988 ‘A lexical syllabus for language learning’. In Carter, R. A , , McCarthy, M. J. Ibcahulay und Language Teaching. London: Longman, pp. 140-60 Swan, M., Walter, C. 1984 The Cambridge English Course. Volume 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Widdowson, H . G. 1979 Explorutionv in Applied Linguistics 1 . Oxford: Oxford Univn-sity Prrss Willis, D. 1990 The Lexical Syllabus. London: Collins Yalden, J. 1983 The Communicative Syllabus: Evol[ltion, Design and Implementution. New York: Pergamon
Chapter 5
Guy Cook T H E U S E S OF C O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E C O R P O R A : A R E P L Y TO R O N A L D C A R T E R
Introduction
C
O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E C O R P O R A have inspired s o m c of the m o s t important insights in rcccnt linguistics. They have sho\vn us, for example, that actual language us(’ is less a matter of coml)ining alistract grammar rules v i t h individual lexical items, and m o r e a matter o f collocation; that thcrc arc grammatically possible utterances hich do not occur, and others lvhich occur ivith tlispro1,ortionatc f r c q w n c y ; that in .tcmatic descriptions o f occurrcnccs, grammar and lcxis cannot l i e as casily separated as have Iiccn traditionally, either in pedagogy o r in linguistics. Ronald Carter is right to such insights ‘cxciting’, antl his o\vn \vork with Michael McCarthv on the CANCOIlE corpus has added t o t h e m . As his articlc (1 9 9 8 ) illustratcs vcry \vcll, the grammatical constructions \ve find in actual con\.crsations arc not a l \ v a y accountctl for in traditional grammars. Clearly all thcsc findings arc important, and thcy d o have implications for language teaching. The problcm is, howcvcr, that somc corpus linguists (c.g. Sinclair 1991, Stubbs 1996) ovcrrcach thcmsclvcs.Thcy talk as though thc cntirc study of languagc can I x replaced by the study o f t h c i r collcctions, antl as though all important insights \vi11 emerge only from automatic scarchcs of their data antl no\\ hci-c clsc. Clearly such solutions to thc study of cductivc p v c r . If the tratlitional concern complex human phenomena cxcrt a good deal ological complexity could be replaced of linguistics language in all its cultural and 11 hy a neat computer hank o f data, life \vould Iic much siinplcr. Yet thc leap from linguistics t o pcdagogv is as Carter realizes far from straightforward. He is not one o f t h c extremists, antl his paper is, for that rcason, a \vorth\vhilc and interesting eontriliution to language teaching. He proc (1s cautiously, providing s o m e interesting ‘rcal’ data, antl pointing out significant diffcrcnccs Ixt\vccn actual antl texthook English. He d o c s not say one should replace the othcr. In his view., materials should l i e influenced by, hut not slaves to, corpus lintlings. (In this hc sccms to agree with the view of Summers antl Rundcll (1 995) that pedagogic matcrials should be ‘corpus based not corpus h o u n d ’ , and t o disagree lvith the CORUILL) slogan that they should lie ‘corpus driven’ (Stuldis 1997).)This is eminently rcasonalilc, though for that very rcason not particularly radical. My problem with \vhat Carter says is that he seems a little hcsitant or perhaps unwilling to say \\here he stands. Ilocs he reject the fundamentalist views ofthose linguists and languagc tcaching theorists for \z h o m corpus findings arc the only source of truth? ~~
~~
~
~~~
THE USES
O F C O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E CORPORA 65
My first aim in this rcplv is to pursue some of the shortcomings o f corpus-tlri\en approachcs which I think Carter avoids confronting. I shall also consider some of the more extreme applications of corpus findings to language teaching. My argument is that there is an important difference bet\\ een the hard antl soft linc approachcs, that the former, by appcaring to offer yet another easy ‘scientific’ solution, can do immense damage, and that \vc all, including Carter, \voultl do \cell to consider more precisely \vhether \z e think corpus tindings mcrcly add a new dimension to earlier approachcs, or replace them.
Uses and abuses of corpora A number 01’ Ialse conclusions can lie reached about corpora. It is often assumed, for example, that as a description of language brhaviour, thcy arc the only valid source of facts about language; the same as a description of language in the mind; provide a goal and a route for language 1carning.Thei-e is much in computerized corpus analysis to makc us reconsider received ideas about the learning, representation, and use of language. But whcrc pcdagogy is concerned, corpus statistics say nothing about immcasurablc but crucial factors such as students’ and teachers’ attitudes and expectations, the personal relationships lxt\\ their o\cn wishes, or the diversity of traditions from which thcy comc. Conscqucntly computer corpora cchile impressive antl interesting records of crrtain aspects of language use can ncvcr bc mort- than a contribution to our understanding o f cffcctivc languagc teaching. ~
Corpus a s f a c t Evcn as a rccord of‘facts’ computer corpora are incomplete.They contain information aliout production but not about reception.Thcy say nothing about how many people have read or heard a text or utterance, or how many times.’Thus a memo hastily skimmed by one person antl consigned to the wastepaper Iiasket counts equally Icith a tabloid headline read b v millions, or with a text, such as a prayer or poem, which is not only often repeated but also deeply valued. Occurrencc, distrihution, and importancc, in other \vords, are not the same. This applics to whole tcxts, hut also to shorter units. Some phrases pass unnoticed preciscly because of thcir frequency, othcrs strikc and stay in the mind, though they may occur only once. And becausc tliffcrcnt intlividuals noticc tlil’ferent things, such saliency can n inclutletl in a corpus.The same is true o f a whole host of aspects of language use: metaphors, speech acts such as apologies or compliments, interactive cvcnts such as intcrruption or Is o f formality. They arc not ‘facts’ but matters ol‘ is a truism to obscrvc that there is no straightfor\vartl correlation tictv use, the intentions thcy had in thcm, and the interpretations which other pcoplc put upon thcm. If this were not so, there would be no disputes ovcr the mcaning of what people say.
Corpus as record Corpora are records of language lichaviour. The patterns which rmc’r-gc in that lichaviour do not ntxcssarily and directly tell us how people organizc antl classify language in thcir mvn minds? and for thcii- o\vn use, o r how language is best systcmatized for teaching. Linguists’ analyses ol’thcse data are not ne arily users’ analyses, or thosc ivhich arr most useful to teachers and Icarncrs. Thcy arc just one kind o f fact. The ways in \vhic.h b nrainmarians antl pcdagogucs ha\ c organizctl thcir matcrial in grammars, syllaliuscs, antl dictionaries are also facts about language. So are people’s emotional lielirfs that one type ~
of language use is better than another-. We should not promote some kinds of facts at the expense of othcrs. Corpora are only partial authorities. The cumulative languagc experience of an individual, though lcss amenable to systematic ac remains far larger anti richer. Even a three hundred million word corpus is cqui\ alent to only around thrcc thousand books, or perhaps the language experience o f a teenager. This is why our intuition (in cffwt o u r random antl incomplctc, access t o our total cxpcricmce of the language) can still tell us facts about the language which cannot 1)c evidenced by a corpus (Witltlowson 1990). For example, the canonical forms of sayings antl provcrI)s occur 1 cry rarely in corpora, though they are obviously well knoum by ~icoplc(Aston 1995). Such omissions, hobvevcr, arc not merely a quantitative issue; they cannot lie rcmcdicd simply by making corpora larger and larger. They arc inrvitalilc in an approach lvhich accepts only one o f the three sources o f fact about language: observation; and ignores o r villainizes t\vo othcrs: introspection and elicitation. For there arc aspccts o f language which arc knolvn but not used. Corpus linguists are fond ofobscrving that thc commonest uses of words are not the same as their standard definitions. ‘I bet’, for example, is more rarely used in the sense of‘wagcr’, and most often in the sense of ‘suppose’ (Sinclair 1987: xi i). Rut this unsurprising olxcrvation does not at all invalidate thc view that ‘\vagcr’ is a ccntral prototypical meaning for many speakers to Ivhich more colloquial uses arc attachcd. (And indeed, thr ‘wager’ meaning is still given as the first meaning o f ‘bet’ in the Coliuiltl dictionarv.) 1,
Description and prescription But let us assume for thc sake of argument that corpora arc accurate records of language behaviour, that they do catalogue antl I-cwal all the important ‘facts’ahout the language.The question then arises as to lvhosc language hchaviour is accurately recorded antl the question takes on a particularly sinistcr signifcancc whcn the corpora in question start being used not as data for dcscriptiw linguistics, but as sources o f prcscription for TESOL. For thc answ-er to the question is (as Cartcr scctns painfullv awarc) that corpora arc primarily records o f native speakers’ languagc Iichaviour. ‘Kcal’ languagc in cffcct means nativespeaker English, and the only language excludcd from this category (apart from the invrntetl cxamplcs o f linguists antl textbook writcrs) is that usetl to antl by language learners. To his crcdit, Carter confronts this issue, and intends to remedy it. But the proposed addition of ‘a wider variety of international Englishcs’ will not solve the problem. This will only add other standard Englishes as spoken by their o\vn native speakers. And then a second question arises to which Cartcr explicitly refers, hut does not anskvcr. Why should the attested language usc o f a native-speaker community bc a model for learners of English as an international language? If a certain collocation occurs frequently among British or American English speakers, must it also lw used by the Japanese o r the Mexicans? This is where lve encounter an easy slippage from description to prcscription, in cffcct making the former into the latter.Thc English which is used by one or more nativespeaker communities, it is implied, ought to lie the English learned for international communication. The ready-made lexical phrases \zhich corpora reveal to he so frequent in native speaker use are moreover as Carter readily recognizes very often culturally specific and loaded. In deploying such units, thc foreign speaker is very likely to produce corpus-attested but contextually inappropriate language. (This is why attempts to teach set phrases arc likely to he as tragicomically disastrous in lexical syllabuses as they \vere in functional ones.) In the terms of Hymes’s (1 972) four parameters of communicative competence, corpus-driven ~~
~
~
T H E U S E S OF C O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E C O R P O R A
67
language teaching always risks stressing what is actually done at the expense of what is appropriate in a particular context.
Pedagogical issues In an extensively quoted, and in itself excellent, essay liy Pa\vlcv and Syder (1 983) on nativclike sclcction and fluency, corpus-liascd language teaching finds a source o f inspiration, providing a potential link lietwccn the facts of language Iieliaviour antl a theory of how language is acquired and processed in the mind. Here is the claim that mature native spcikcrs (for this is whom the essay is explicitly about) have ‘hundrcds of thousands’ of institutionalized lexicalized or semi-lexicalizctl units in memory. Though many of these units can be analysed grammatically, the likelihood is, so the argumcnt goes, that they arc often produced and understood holistically. Nativc speakers acquire, represent, and process language in lexicalizcd chunks as \\ell as grammar rulcs and single \vords. Yet it h y no means follows that foreign lcarners must do the same.Thcy may not \rant to study language in this way; they may live within culturally tli\ ersc pedagogic traditions not compatilile with this approach; they may not aspire to or nccd native-like English; thcy may not have as much time available as native-speaker children; above all, as adults with conscious learning strategies available to them, they can choose. And \vhy should th choosr to continue vicwing the language as grammar structures and slot-filling word may not lead to native-like English, but it may lead to communicative and expressive English. It may be learnt morc quickly. And it will avoid the tedious rote learning of mundane phrases, or the bc\z.ildering refusal to teach grammar, which arc the inevitable consequences of an overemphasis on ‘lexical chunks’. Yet cvcn if appearing native-likc were accepted as the goal of languagc learning, it \voultl still not follo\v that frequency and tlcsirability arc the same. Thcre is a hidtlcn irony in the dogma that frequcnt native-likc collocations are the best model to imitate. It is that e\en \i.ithin the native-speaker community it is often the infrequcnt \vortl or expression which is most p o n - c d d antl most communicatively effective, antl therefore most sought after. This is also \\ hy foreigners’ speech is often expressive and striking. t b t h for native and non-native speakers there is an altcrnati\e goal to seeking the most usual, the most frequent or, in short, the most clichktl exprcssion. It is the goal of rich, varied, antl original language. Among native speakers it is unusual language kvhich is valued. Should non-native spcakers lie trcatcd tliffercntl y ? This lcatls to the important point that not all types of language arc cquallp valued, either by native spcakers or foreign learners. Something is not a good model simply liecause it occurs frequcntly. A good dcal of actual language use is inarticulate, impoverished, and inexpressive. Inevitably, because onc cannot teach cvcrything, part of the job o f teachcrs and coursc designers is to sclcct the languagc use which they \4.ish their students to emulate. Many foreign language students have strong feelings about this too. They tlo not Lvant to learn just any English because it occurs in a corpus, and it is patronising to overrule them. In advocating selection and modelling of corpus data, in the use of literary rather than transcribed dialogues, and in his recognition that one of the topics in his authentic data (‘straggly hair’) may have a limited topic life in many classrooms, Carter seems to agree. To be corpus driven, in short, deprives cvcryone (native antl non-native spcaker alike) of the opportunity for choice antl to make their own impact on the language. Corpora are inevitably records of what has happened rather than what is happcning.They prcscnt us with a,fuit accompli, a fixed product rather than an open process.
68 G U Y Cool<
Means and ends So corpora do not neccssarily provide a goal for languagc learners. Yet even if they did, it would not follow that the liest route t o this goal is t o present rcal language usc, and to try t o persuade them to emulate it straight allay. I lcre there is a certain oddity in the corpus argument. O f course expert-spcakcr use of the language, and the rulcs which generate it, is usually more complex than that of language learners. If it were not, there would lie nothing to learn. Hardly surprisingly, the description of English which emerges from corpus analysis (taking into account as it docs the lvay in \vhich linguistic items and structures vary across genres, social groups, and linguistic contexts) is dauntingly complcx antl particular. But this description cannot h e prcscntctl t o students all at once. The issue still remains how to simplify and stagc the language prcscntctl t o Icarncrs, a n d t o simplify the rulcs used t o cxplain it, in a Ivay tvhich will enablc thcm t o comc gradually closer t o native speaker usc (if that is their goal). Surely the point of grammars antl textbooks is that they select, idealizc, and simplify thc language t o make it more acccssihlc? Intlectl, this s w m s to l x Cartcr’s view too. For language tcachcrs the issue remains as t o \\.hat thc principles for selection, idealization, and siniplification should he. I Icrc thcrc is already a wcalth of long standing ideas (dating back at least t o the work of Palmer ( 192 1 ) and West ( 1 926)) concerning the rclationship lietwccn the frequency with bvhich an item occurs and the point at which it should be taught itleas of lvhich many corpus linguists, in their haste t o atlvcrtise thcmselves as promulgating a totally ne\\’ approach to language, seem unaware. For cxamplc, an item may hc frequent but limited in rangc, or infrequent hut useful in a wide rangc of contexts. Or it may lie infrequent h i t very useful, or appropriate for some pedagogic reason. These are factors lieyond mere description. Unlike many corpus linguists, Carter does show himself awarc of such considerations in his conclusions. But that leaves m e wondcring whether his approach is such a break from tradition as he suggests.
The hard line This Iirings m e from Cartcr’s views moclcratc, sc-nsil,lc, anti informed t o the more extreme, b u t unfortunately associated, views o f language teaching based o n corpus linguistics. Herc is the belief that what is perceived as a linguistic revolution necessarily constitutes a pedagogic one. Very often \vritcrs arc carricd a v a y I)? a single insight into language, taking it illogically to be sufficient t o change I u n g u q c tcaching.Thus Willis (1 990) elevatcs frequcncy counts t o the guiding principle for his lexical syllalius. Lewis (1993) considers the high occurrence of lexical chunks as a cue to tlecrcc (in a diatrilie characterized liy bombastic asscrtion rathcr than rcxonetl argument) that language tc-aching has changed forevcr, t o be rcplacetl by ‘the \Yay lorward’ (p. 196), with an ominously authoritarian definite articlc: his o\vn lexical approach. ‘Abstract, absolute kno\vlctlge of a system has had its day’, antl people who think other ‘are wrong’ (p. 74); ‘\voolly mindedncss in this mattcr leads t o I d practice which has ncgatilc long tcrm cffccts’ (p. 167). Such approachcs arc firmly in the tradition of using linguistics theory to dictate to language teaching practicc. Their gross over- gcncralization antl over-confidence arc potcntially damaging t o good teaching practice. Thcy invoke corpus linguistics as an unassailable authority, side-step all serious cngagcmcnt in debate, anti cannot take on board the kind ofrcscrvations cxpresscd hy Carter. Such corpus-driven pedagogy is a vain attempt to resuscitate a patriarchal attitude to EI.T, invoking the latest linguistics theory t o intimidate tcachcrs into Iiclicving that all prcvious practicc, all thcir owm antl thcir students’ intuitions, ~~
~
T H E U S E S OF C O M P U T E R I Z E D L A N G U A G E C O R P O R A
69
all the culturally various pedagogic traditions in hvhich they \vork antl study, arc, as I x w i s \vould put it, ‘hvrong’.
Conclusion 1 have contrasted throughout this rcply what I scc as the soft and the hard line \ ie-\vs of the relevance o f corpus findings t o language teaching. In thc one, CI\ have the wicc of moderation urging a limited application ‘modclling’ as Carter calls it ivhich b y \ii-tuc of its very reasonableness does n o t amount to anything very radical. In the other, \vc have thc stronger view: cvangclical, authoritarian, antl dismissive of tradition, assuming that a little of the latest linguistics theory is all that is needcd t o changc- the coursc of languagcteaching. I believe that if Carter lvcrc t o follo\v his arguments through to their conclusion, he too \vould explicitly reject, as I do, the morc extreme versions h t h of corpus linguistics antl of corpus-driven language teaching, Rut it is b: no means clear whether he d o c s so. ~
~
Notes 1
2 3
This point has bcrn made hy corpus linguists thcmsclves (Francis 1979, Stul)lw 1996: 1 I ) , hut the point is not adequately taken on board, either in corpus construction or analysis. Stubbs (1996: 2 1 ) tells us that thr. ‘deep patterning’ rcvcalrd by corpuh anal! ‘bcyond human ol)servation antl memory’, This issue is clouded by snolhish and chauvinistic claims that a particdar national o r sociolcct is l x t t c r than anothcr. But this is not a necessary componcnt of the notion that literary, xvrittcn, or simpl\ eloquent and elegant one^ arc morc crrtain usages desirable models than others. ~
References Aston, G. 1995. ‘Corpora in language pdagogy: matching theory antl practice’ in G. Cook and B. Scitllhofcr (cd.;.). Principle cind Prcictic-e i n Applied I.inguittic.>.Oxti)rd: Oxfo~-tlUni\ c r h i t y Press. Cat-trr, I<. 1998. ‘Orders of reality: CANCODE, communication, antl culture’. ELY’journcil, 5 2 , 1 , 4 3 56. Francis, W. N. 1979. ‘Prol)lcms of asscmhling and computerising largc corpora’ in H. Bergcnholtz anti I$. Schader (etls.). Empiri.sche Textn.imm.ychczft. Berlin: Scriptor. I Ivmex, D. 1972. ‘On communicative competence’ in J. B. l’ridc and J. Holmes (cds.). sociolinguistic^. Harmonds\vorth: Penguin. Lchvis, M. 199 3. The Lexical A p p r o c ~ h Hove: . LanguageTeaching Publications. McCarthv, M. and Carter, R. 1994. Language as Discourse: Persprctivcs for 1-anguagc Teaching. I .ondon: Longman. Palmer, H. E. 192 1 . 7’hc Principles c?f Language StucG.. London: Flarrap (Republished 1)) Oxford Univcrsit) Press, 1964, edited b? K. Mackin). h v l c y , A. and F. Sydcr. 198 3. ‘T~vopuzzlcs for linguistic theory: nativclikc selection and nati\rlike fluency’ in J. Richards anti J. Schmidt (ctis.). h n g u u g e cind Coinmunitation. London: Longman. Sinclair, J. et ul. 1987. Collins Cohuilcl English l anguuge Dictionar).. London: Collins. Sinclair, J. M. 1991 , C o r p u , Concordance, Colloccltjon. Oxford: Oxford University I’rms. Stulhs, M. 1996. Text cind C o r p s .$nci@s. Oxford: Rlack\vell. Stubbs, M. 1997. Review of Il.sinfl Corpora,/& /-anguci,qc Re.scarch..lppliecl Linguistics 18/2: 240 3 .
70 G U Y C O O K Summers, D. and M. Rundell (etls.). 1995. Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English. London: Longman. West, M. P. 1926. Learning to Read a Foreign Language. NcwYork: Longmans, Grccn. Widdowson, H. G. 1990. ‘Discourses of enquiry and conditions of relevance’in J. E. Alatis (etl). Linguistics, Language Teaching and I.angnup Acq~iisition.Washington DC: Georgetown University Press. Willis, D. 1990. The Lexical .$llabns. London: Collins.
Chapter 6
Ann Hewings and Martin Hewings A P P R O A C H E S TO T H E S T U D Y OF DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC W R I T I N G : I M P L I C A T I O N S FOR S Y L L A B U S DESIGN
1 Introduction N R E C E N T Y E A R S , S Y L LA B U S E S for academic writing in higher education have increasingly focused on teaching students about the features of differing written genres. S o , for instance, we find published material on laboratory and technical reports (for example Dudley-Evans, 1985), expcrimental rcscarch reports and other research papers (for example Wcissberg and Buker, 1990), theses and dissertations (for example Anderson and Poole, 1994) and essays (for example Roberts, 1997). The gcncral motivation of this approach is thc need to offrr appropriate dcxcriptions and models of generic texts so that thc students’ ability to understand and produce them is improved. More specifically, students arc taught about thc textual features, both tcxt structural and sentence-level, that are characteristic of‘ each gcnrc. While this represents a valuablc development from earlier approaches which treated ‘academic writing’ as an undifferentiated, homogeneous entity, it is important to recognisc that variation is found not only from genre to genre, but also within genres. Evidcncc is accumulating that single genres vary over time (Bazerman, 1988; Dudley-Evans and Henderson, 1990; Selager-Meyer, 19959, vary from one cultural context to another (Taylor and Chcn, 1991), and varv from discipline to discipline (Berkenkottcr and Huckin, 1995; Prior, 1998). This essay is primarily concrrncd with the third of these and, in particular, thc methods that have been adopted for the study of disciplinary variation and the implications of findings to date for syllabus design. Knowledge of disciplinary variation is liccoming especially important with the growing trend towards inter- and multi-disciplinary study in higher education so that students may be required to work within a number of disciplines which have different views on the naturc of academic writing. We begin by reporting threc arcas of applied linguistic investigation which have explored the question of disciplinary variation in rather different ways and with rather different implications for syllabus design. First, we present Swales’s approach to genre a n a h i s and discuss studies of disciplinary variation based on this approach, in particular those which have explored variation in thc academic rmcarch
I
72 A N N H E W I N G S A N D M A R T I N H E W I N G S articlc. Second, we outline lvork \vhich has cxamincd metadiscourre in academic \vriting that is, the part o f a tcxt Lvhich helps thc rcadcr organisc, classify, c d u a t e and react to the propositional contcnt (Vandc Kopplc, 1985) and the \ l a y this varies in texts taken from different disciplines. Third, i \ c r e p o r t studies o f one clause-level feature of t e x t , t h r ~qrammaticalsiihjcct, that have tlcmonstratcd its significance in reflccting how m.ritcrs reprcscnt data, previous research antl thcmsclvcs in the tcxt, and h o w this varies across disciplines. A discussion o f the implications of the findings o f such work for academic writing syllabuses concludes the essay. Throughout, our attention is primarily o n gcm-es Ix-oduccd within an academic context, either clussroom genres those produced IIV students for purposes of asscssmcnt, such as essays, dissertations and thcscs, 1al)oratot-y and case study reports, and litcraturc reviews or prof;ssional p r e s thc tcxts by which scientists antl scholars communicate \vith o t h e r scientists antl scholars, such as conference papcv-s, research articles, monographs, technical reports, working papers, and grant proposals. ~
2 Approaches t o the study of disciplinary variation 2. I Genre
Within the context of English for Spccific I’urposcs, the teaching o f academic lvriting has Ixcn greatly influencctl by the apliroach t o gcnrc arising from work by John Skyales (for example 198 1 , 1984, 1990). This approach considers a non-fictional gcnrc t o be:
’
a rccognizahlc communicati\ c cvcnt charactcrizctl b y a sct of communicative purposc(s) idcntificd antl mutually understood by mcnil)crs of t h r professional or academic community in \vhich it regularly occurs. Most often it is highly structured and conventionalized with constraints o n allo\vahlc contributions in t e r m s o f their intent, positioning, form and functional valuc. (Bhatia, 1993: 13)
The primary critcrion, thcn, b y \vhich tcxts arc consitlcrctl to lie o f tht. samc g e n r e is communicative purpose. If tcxts have tliffcrcnt communicative purposes, they are likely t o be o f a tliffcrcnt genrc, antl it is this shared communicative p ~ i r p s ethat produces the convcntionalisctl form of the gcni-e antl its chai-actcristic linguistic features. The analysis of a genre for pedagogical purposes involves the identification o f thcsc regularities in tcxt organisation and Icxico-grammatical features antl, in addition, an attempt to explain how thcv relate t o the tlisrource cornmnniy (Hcrzbcrg, 1986; S\valcs, 1990; Bizzcll, 1992) Tvithin \vhich the genre is produced. Such analysis can thcn bc converted into syllabuses and materials that aim t o teach students aliout tcxt organisation antl relevant language forms. S\valcs’s ( 1 9 8 1 , 1990) pionccring lvork itlcntifictl a set of ‘movcs’, and ‘steps’ within t h e m , which were rccurrcntly found in the introductions t o research articles in o r d e r t o contcxtualise an author’s o\vn research. A move is a unit \\ hich is rclatrd both t o the purpose writers h a w antl t o the contcnt they n i s h t o communicate, \vhilc a stcp is a component o f a move which is a morc tlctailcd option availaldc to the kvritcr in setting o u t a move (DudlcyEvans and St John, 1998: 89). Swales proposed ( 1 990: 141) a three-movc model for articlc introductions (modifictl from four in his 198 1 lvork):
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
Move 1
Move 2
Move 3
73
Establishing a territory Step 1 Claiming centrality unti/or Step 2 Making topic gencralisations clnti/or Step 3 IievicLving items of previous research Establishing a niche Step 1A Counter-claiming or Step IB Indicating a gap or Step 1C Question-raising or Step ID Continuing a tradition Occupying the niche Step 1A Outlining purposes or Step 1B Announcing prescnt resrarch Step 2 Announcing principal findings Indicating research article structure. Step 3
Typically, academic discoursc communities are bound togcther by subject matter, antl professional academic writing is seen as adding to the body of kno\vlcdge Lvhich is at thc core of the discipline. In addition to disciplinary knowledge, the way subject matter is discussed the genrc conventions used is also of importancc. To hecome ‘good academic xvl-iters’, students need to become a\varc ofthesc conventions, that is, how the tcxtual forms and communicative functions arc related to the expectations of the academic community to which they belong.
Swalcs’s movc and step approach has been used not only to identify the characteristics o f particular genres, Iiut also to compare texts of the same genre but from different disciplines. For example, in the prcliminarics to an invcstigation of active and passive vcrb forms in t\vo astrophyics journal articles, laronc et a1. ( 1 998) notc that S\valc,s’s ( 1 990) overview of the organisation ofthc rcsearch article as having an ‘hourglass’ shapc is not applicable to articles in astrophysics. ‘ I Iourglass’ articles hegin with a broad overview of the ficltl, narrow the focus tlo\vn to a specific area of interest Lvhich is then expcrimentcd on in somc way, and conclude w i t h a widening-out of the discussion to rclatc findings to t,roadcr issues relcnnt to the ficltl.Astrophysics papers, however, are consitlcretl hy‘l-arone et (11. to have an ‘inverted pyramid’ construction in which the focus of‘ the paper is gradually narro\\ccl down, beginning with general physics, through the particular phcnomcna to explain, thc specific physics of relevance, spccific equations, to a specific solution.Thc reason, thcv argue, is that hvhile thc hourglass is a satisfactory rcprcsentation of reports of cxperimcntal studies, astrophysics attends to suliject matter \vhich cannot lie cxpcrimentcd on, so that papers in the discipline prescnt logical arguments rather than expcrimcnts. A number of studics have examined how scctions of rcscarch articles vary across tlisciplines.Thc typical sections of research articles arc an introduction, a mcthods section which explains the procedures undertaken (often experimental procedurcs in the casc of scientific research articles), a report ofthc results ofthc procedurcs, antl finally a discussion of these results antl their significance. Brett’s (1 994) starting point is Swales’s ( 1 990: 175-6) proposal that tlisciplinary differences in research articles are likcly to lie in methods and results sections rather than introductions antl discussions. He examines results sections in research articles from sociology and observes certain communicative categories within them, such as his Substuntiation of Findings antl .Yon-vu/itlation of’ Findings, not prcviousl)
74 ANN H E W I N G S AND M A R T I N H E W I N G S documented as appearing in rcsults o r discussion sections (for example in Relanger, 1982; Dudley-Evans, 1989; Hopkins antl I>utllcy-Evans, 1988; Weissberg and Kukcr, 1990). He relates thcsc to the methods of quantitati ,ociological research in which ahstract concepts such as ‘ethnic identification’ or ‘satisfaction’ arc prcscnted as numcrical data. These data arc then manipulated using accepted statistical techniques, and the resulting statistics intcrprcted to produce deductions about human tiehaviour. Not only are the effccts on the dependent variahle of the most significant indcpcndcnt variables tliscussetl, but so are the effects of other variables. The second o f thcsc, I3rctt found, took up more space than the discussion of the most significant findings, kvhilc thc effects of secondary variables arc assessed as either supporting (Substantiation (rf Fintiings) or lcssening the validity o f ( AJonvalidation o_f‘Fzntfings)the main findings. As in Taronc et al.’s work, then, Brctt suggests that thc suliject matter and the mcthotlologics deployctl intluencc the constitution of written text within the tlisciplinc. Holmcs ( I 997) undertakes a comparative study of the organisation of the discussion sections of articles presenting original research from the disciplines of political science, sociology and history using a Sudcs-typc m o w analysis. He identifics a total of eight moves (Background information, Statement OJresult, (Iln)expectcd outcome, Rcfirence to previous research, Explanation of unsatisfactoy result, Gcnerali.sation, Recommendation, and Outlining parallel or subsequent derdopmcnts). In comparison with similar \vmk on articles in the natural or hard sciences (Pcng, 1987) Holmes (1997: 3 3 2 ) finds that discussion sections in the social sciences, as represented bv political scicnce and sociology, are less complex, employing a restricted repertoire of moves, j e t arc less predictable. O n the other hand, social science introductions have ticcn found to display ‘qreatcr complexity than those in the hard sciences (Crookcs, 1986; Holmcs, 1995). O n the basis of such cvidencc, research articles in the social sciences \vould seem to display greater complexity and elaboration at the bcginning than at the end while the revers<’ is thc case in the hard sciences. A number of explanations for such differences might be put forward. Gi\cn the rclative lack ofconscnsus on goals and methods of research in the social scicnccs, there may tic greater need to establish more overtly and in greater detail the parameters of research in the field. Morc generally, Holmes (1 997: 3 32) proposes that the greater conventionalisation o f rcscarch articles in the hard sciences is a reflection of their higher tlcgrce of bureaucratisation, measured ‘by reference to quantitative data, collaborative authorship and external financial support’ (ibid.).This view is supported by the observation that discussion sections in history, the least burcaucratiscd discipline of the three studied, have less in common with those in the hard sciences and are the least prcdictablc. Evidence of generic variation across disciplines is also found in ‘classroom genres’ in the writing of students in higher education. In a comparison of master’s-lcvel dissertations written in highway engineering and plant biology, Dudley-Evans ( 1993) notes particular diffcrences in the discussion sections. In plant biology, considerable spacc and attention is given over to comparison of present rcsults with previous findings reported in the literature. Thus, claims about present rcsults antl explanations of unexpected outcomes are supported with refcrcnce to previous work. In highway engineering, in contrast, emphasis is on stating present results antl making recommrndations based on thrsc results, with less attention to the relationship betwern present results antl previous research in the field. From his reading of thc dissertations, Dudley-Evans’ impression ( 1 993: 145) of highway engineering is of a discipline in which there is not a huge amount of previous research to refer to and which sees its work in the context of practical suggestions that the practising engineer can put into operation in the tieltl.
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
75
Such studies, thcn, suggest that the nature of a particular discipline, as indicated in its subjcct matter, its methods of investigation, the amount of previous research in the ficld, the level of consensus on agrerd knowlcdgc, and the degree of bureaucratization in the discipline may he reflected in its generic convcntions.This has direct implications for syllabus design. I t reinforces the need to move away not only from academic writing as a homogeneous entity, but also from homogeneous genres. While information on, for example, the sections of the research article may be useful as a prcliminary, students also need to be made aware of the specifics of what to include, what to cmphasisc, antl what to cxclude within each scction for their own particular disciplinc.
2.2 Metadiscourse A rather different approach to the in tigation of the relationship lictwcen disciplinary communities and their tcxts is found in studies of metadiscourse in academic writing. A distinction can be made bctlveen the propositional content of a text, its information o r subject matter, and metadiscourse, that part of the text which helps the reatlcr organisc, classify, evaluate and react to the propositional content (Vantle Kopplc, 1985). The elemrnts of metadiscourse have heen divided (scc, for example, Hyland 1999a) into those which, in the terminology of systemic functional grammar, serve a textual function and those hvhich scrvc an interpersonal function. Halliday (1 973: 66) descrilxs the textual function as an enabling function, that of creating text . . . It is this component that enables the speaker [or writer] to organise what he is saying in such a w’ay that it makes sense in the contcxt antl fulfils its functions as a messagr, while the intcrpcrsonal function is said to include all that may he understood by the expression of our olvn personalities and personal feelings on the one hand, and forms of interaction and social interplay with other participants in the communication situation on the other hand. Mctadiscoursc, thcrefore, allows hvriters not only to show ho\v a text is organised and ho\v different parts of the text arc rclatetl, but also to express thcir attitude towards the subject matter of thc text and towards the intcndcd readership. Academic disciplines have conventional ways in which writers are allowed both to present thcir arguments and to reprcscnt themselvcs, and this is achicvcd mainly in thc metadiscoursc in text. I t is through the study of metadiscourse in the texts of a particular disciplinary community, therefore, that the characteristics of that community can bc explored. Studies of metadiscourse in academic text have looked at cultural antl gender variation (Crismorc et a]., 1993; Mauranen, 1993) and the use of metadiscourse in particular academic genres (Hyland, 1999a; Hcwings, 1999). Howc\w, it is Hyland’s (1 99911) work on metadiscourse and disciplinary variation that is of main concern here and reported below. In a study of fifty- six research articles takcn from eight disciplines (microbiology, physics, marketing, applied linguistics, philosophy, sociology, mechanical engineering, and electrical engineering), Hyland considers variation in the writers’ stance. Stance is part of the interpersonal component of metadiscourse and defined as the ways that writers project themselves into thcir texts to communicate their integrity, credibility, involvement, and a relationship to thcir subject matter and thcir readers. (19991-3: 101)
76 A N N H E W I N G S A N D M A R T I N H E W I N G S It
iy
considered to hale f i ~ cmain components:
hedges (c.g. po.ssib/e, might, perhaps, belicr.c), through which the Ivritcr Ivithholds full commitment to a proposition; emphutic.~(c.g. it is ohriotis, chfinitclv, o/‘cotir.sc), through \vhich the writer cmphasises the force of a proposition; attituck markers, concerned \\ ith the \vr-itcr’s attitutlc to \\.hat is said and signalled bv such devices as uttitutle r~erhs(c.g. I ci
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
77
2.3 The grammatical subject A third approach to the stud! of tlisciplinar; \ariation has de\elopcd from the v o r k of MacDonald ( 1 992, 1994) on the p ~ ~ m m a t i c iruhlect ll Thc subject, o r grammatical suhlt.ct (G$), has all? a)\ been rccogniwd a4 a signhcant component o f English in both ti aditional and functional grammars. The t! pica1 English sentence pattern I S 5ul1~ect Vcrli O b l c c t , lor example Su7anne Sirhlect
playcd T‘erh
her I iolin Object
and the subject is an obligatory clement in all sentences with the exccption of inipcrativcxs. MacDonaldk rationale for focusing o n the GS \vas that it is the constituent defining the topic of the scntcnce that \vhich the sentence is ‘about’ antl which it presupposes as its point of departure. (Quirk et ill., 1985: 79) ~
Thus the GS is important for determining \\,hat a \vriter is writing ohorit antl ho\v they represent data, previous research and themselves in their texts. In her invcstigation into disciplinary differences in professional \vriting in the humanities and social sciences, MacDonald developed a mcthod of classifying GSs o n the h i s of Ivhether the); contriliutc to the content of a text o r hvhethcr they are more concerncd lvith consolidating knowledge construction in a discipline that is, the huilding of knowledge o n foundations laid h y other rcscarchcrs. For some disciplines, the consolidation o f knowledge is of such importance that it is reflcctcd not only at text level hut also in scntcncelevel choices. Analysis of the GS is used to demonstrate the rhetorical practices of such disciplines. For example, acadcmic texts with sentences beginning ‘Work 1:, Jamcs . . .’ or ‘Experimental cvitlencc . . .’ are clearly liuiltling on a foundation constructctl for thc discipline h y those within it.The GSs can thus l i e said to have an epistemic focus, one which is concerned \vith methods of study and the validity of knowlctlge claims. b o r other disciplines, the people, things antl events that constitute the phenomena or content that arc studied arc foregroundcd. For example, in literature studies, ‘Shakespeare’s plays’ might \vel1 lic the content o r subject that is being ivrittcn about, and where thcsc \?-or& occur as the GS thcrc is said to be a phenomenal focus. Within this Iiroad two-fold division, MacDonaltl rccognises a further disciplinary characteristic. Disciplines such as those in the humanities are more concerned with specific ~icople,placcs and events, whereas those in, for examplc, the social sciences rely more on gencralisations and abstractions. This is again reflected in the choice of G S , with a cline existing hetlveen those GSs Lvhich represent phcnomena at their most specific and individualistic through to those which are most abstract. On this basis, MacDonald (1992) has developed a classification system for GSs, a modified version of tvhich is summarised inTable 6.1 . Thc \ - d u e of this \vork for the study of disciplinary variation becomes apparent if \vc compare findings from psychology, history and literature (from Macl)onald, 1992) antl wildlife hchaviour, conservation biology and legislative history (Samraj , 1995). Macnonald’s (lata are hascd on an analysis offour journal-length articles in cach discipline, \vhile Samraj analysetl six student papers from thrcc different courses which formed part of a US Mastcr’s programmc in environmental studies. The figures inTablc 6.2 show the percentagc average distribution of cach of thc seven classcs of GSs in the texts. ~
78 A N N H E W I N G S A N D M A R T I N H E W I N G S Table 6 . I A classification system [or thr grammatical subject
Summary of grammatical subject classification Phenomenal
Phenomenal grammatical subjects are thosc which deal u ith the material that a researcher or writer studics or writcs about. Class 1 (Particulars) contains nouns rcfcrring to spccitic people, placcs, or ohjrcts, usually named
(e.g. the USA,
Stalin, Europe, the storm).
Class 2 (Non-Spcxcific Groups) contains gcncralisctl or grouprd nouns
(..e. large ureas o f t h e country,
gullies, downland soils, the tsetsepy poptilotion).
Class 3 (Attributes) contains the most abstract, least material nouns in the phenomenal category. They arc nouns cxprcssing properties, attributes, actions o r motivations of the people or things in
1 and 2 (e.g. agricultural practices, rainfall intensities, planning). Epi,stemic
Epistcmic grammatical subjects rcprcscnt thr concepts, catcgorics, abstractions or methodological tools the researcher uses to reason ahout the subject. Class 4 (Research Matters) contains rctrrcnccs to the constitucnts of rcsrarch and the activities of researchers such as data collection and analysis, gcnrrating itlcas and comparing and contrasting tiitfcrcnt theories
(c.g. the eyoations, the,Fnal hypothesis,
it
has been argued t h a t ) .
Class 5 (Researchers antl Studies) contains rcfercnccs to published research and to writers in the
field (e.g. Pinch and S t o r y , /YY2.I ) . Class 6 (Audience) contains suhjccts like thr gcncraliscd w e (hut not thc actual we which refers to authors) and one oryou. Class 7 (Discoursal) contains suhjccts which refer to the text itsclf, cithrr in whole or in part, and rhctorical questions used to organisc the discourse
(c.g. this cssoy, Figure 2 , Why are mobile homes
popular uith pensionen?).
An examination of the tablc shows some very large variations in the types of GSs favoured by different disciplines antl the grouping of these into phenomcnal or cpistemic categories. Disciplines with more epistemic subjects (classcs 4-7) foreground research methods, inferences and findings rather than the phenomena that are being studied o r written about (classes 1-3). Some disciplines are clearly more phenomenal in their focus and some more epistemic. Psychology, for example, has a total of 62 per cent epistenlic grammatical subjccts, whereas literature has 84 per ccnt phenomenal. At the levcl of individual classes, legislative history and literature usc more class 1 (particulars) than the other disciplines. This undcrlines thcir conccrn with specific pcople, places and objects. In contrast, psychology uses less than 1 per ccnt of class 1 GSs. Instead, it favours non-specific, more generalised referenccs to phenomena as found in class 2 . Most disciplines, except literature, but especially the two histories, have fairly high numbers of non-specific groups of people, places or things. Class 3 GSs are frequent in all disciplines except psychology. They arc nouns which express properties, attributes, actions o r motivations of thc people o r things in classes 1 and 2. Hewings (1 999) has used MacDonald’s techniques to examine writing development among undergraduate students within the discipline of geography at a British university.
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
79
Tuble 6.2 Average distribution (Yo) of GSs in tliffcrcnt disciplines antl sub-disciplincs (data from MacDonald 1992 and Samraj 1995)
GS
Psychology
History
Litcraturr
class 1
01
6
2
27
44
3 4 5
I1 49 12 1
26
6
15
6 3
30 10 44 7 5
4
Wildlife
Conservation
I egislati\ c
hchaviour'
hiology
history
1 30 29
28
30
44
18
9
18
8
28 I 2
7
35
~
/
Comparing essays written by students in the first and final (third) years of their programme, she found a substantially higher proportion of phcnomenal to epistcmic GSs in first-ycx essays (76 per ccnt and 24 per ccnt respectively), while the proportion of epistcmic GSs was higher in final-year essays (56 per cent phenomenal and 44 per ccnt epistrmic). Firstvear essays showcd a greatcr focus on the real-world phenomena that geography invcstigatrs, as in the following example in which GSs, all phenomenal, are underlined: Bus and rail are the obvious components of a mass transit system. The 1x1s is t h c cheaper of the two options, but even with designated bus lanes it still adds to thc problem of congestion antl has a lower capacity. on the other hand is much more expensive but has a higher capacity and takes travcl away from the roads. There arc a m highly c number of examples of mass transit systems around the world, ~ ~ are successful others arr not. These clearly foreground the phenomena that are bring studied and indicate a priority of content over rhctorical motivations. While third-year essays were also concerned with rcal-\vorltf phenomena, thcsc were oftcn displaccd from thc subject position b y cpistemic GSs, underlined in the following examplc: ExDerimcnts by Morpan et al. (1982) on 'detachment of soil particlcs from a sandy soil by raindrop impact in storms of 50mm/hr and 61 m m / h r for 5 minutcs duration showed that the rate of erosion untlcr a cover of hrusscl sprouts dccrrasetl as the canopy cover increased from 0-1 5 25%, but erosion increased if the canopy cover increased any more antl at 50% cover the erosion rate equalled that of bare soil' (Morgan 1986). Similar experiments were done on potato crops with similar findings. These results add to thosc ofvis which show under certain circumstances plant covers are associated with high rather than low ratcs of erosion mainly due to their influence on the kinetic energy of intercepted raindrops. Othrr cxiieriments such as bv De Ploev et al. (1 976,)recorded an increase in soil erosion with an incrrasc in grass cover. . . . Morpan (1980) showed in his study on soils in Silsoc that sandy soils in Bedfordshire are ten times more erodible in summer than in n-intcr. O n a gcneral lc\cl, then, the model is uscful for indicating certain disciplinary trends within writing. It provides a way o f focusing o n a particular linguistic fcature and uses it to tease out aspects of the disciplinary culture which would otherwise be obscure. Bv this
80 A N N H E W I N G S A N D M A R T I N H E W I N G S means, advice on writing can he tlircctctl morc specifically to those features which reflect the underlying culture of a particular disciplinary community. GSs in successful and less successful student writing could lie coniliared and stuclcnts encouraged to classify the GSs, initially using their own criteria antl later using the I)roatl phenomenal/cpistcmic classification given aliovc.
3 Implications for syllabus design Thc starting point of this essay \vas that the recent trend to\r ards genre-based approaches to the teaching o f academic lvriting \\as a positive tlcvelopment when compared Ivith those which rrprcscntctl a homogeneous viclv of academic M riting, undifferentiated across genrcs. Indccd, in current thinking o n tertiary academic literacy it is now taken almost as axiomatic that an understanding o f generic comcntions, particularly in terms of moves but also steps and their lcxicogrammatical rcalisations, is essential in achicving academic succcss. I h c a r c h is shobving both how genrcs differ antl how kno\vlctlgc of one gcnre may tic inadequate preparation for the production of another. For cxamplc, Hylantl’s ( 1 999a) work on the metadiscourse of textbooks leads him to concludc that students need to tic steered a n y from using textbooks as models. Too close a familiarity with the lvays that textbooks address readers, organise material and prcsent facts may mean that learners arc poorly pi-clm-cd \vhcn assigned research articles by their subject lecturers or kSP tcachcrs o r when asked to write argumentative prose. (Hylantl, 1999a: 2 1-2)
Ho\\-c-ver,in the design of syllabuses for academic writing programmes, it is necessary to rccognisc the lesson ofthc research rcportcd in this essay: that helping students to develop a knowledge of gcnrcs is insufficient in a number of \vays. First, i t is important to guard against teaching gcnres as a set o f templates to lie copictl unsxvervingly. Razerman’s (1 988) investigation of the cxprrimental article in science leads him to offer thc following caution: the largest lesson that this study holds is not that thcrc are simple gcnres that must be slavishly followed, that \vc must give students an appropriate s c t of cookie cutters for their anticipatctl careers, h u t rather that the student must understand and rethink the rhetorical choiccs embedded in each generic haliit to master thc genre. (l3azcrman 1988: SO) Second, it is ncccssary to dcvelop students’ sensitit ity to the fact that gcnres vary, particularly across disciplines. This is incrcasingly important given the growing number of studcnts in multi- or inter-disciplinary academic programmes whcrc success is dependent both on being abvarc of disciplinary variation in communication practices and on developing sufficient flexihility t o producr writing that reflccts the predilections of a particular disciplinary community. Such Ilcxibility is unlikely to he achieved simply by learning the prcfcrred conventions of a discipline, but must be untlcrpinnctl hy a deeper understanding of how this reflects such matters as thc dcgrcc of consensus within the disciplinc on the definition of prolilcms and appropriate methodologies to address thcse problems, the amount of prc-vious research that it is convrntional to ackno\vlcdge, and the cohesiveness of the hody of agreed kno\vlcdgc within the discipline. Third, we need a reassessment of ‘common-core’ and ‘discipline-specific’components of academic writing programmes (see also Rhatia, 1 999). Common-core teaching, focusing
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
81
on the ‘language and conventions related t o the general requirements of the academic community’ (Ihdlcy-Evans, 1 995), has the advantage of being addressctl to studcnts from across tlisciplines and is thercfore efficient both in t e r m s of thc n u m h c r of students taught and, often, financially. €Io\z.ever, it has the disadvantage o f h c i n g relatively insensitive to thc pi-c~t‘crrctlwavs of writing in particular disciplines. Discipline-specific components providc this sensitivity but usually have the disadvantages of addressing smaller numbers of stutlcnts, needing specially focused research antl being less cost-efficient, and will often h a w t h e atltlitional complexity of requiring the input at some stage of a subjcct specialist. Perhaps o u r goal is that of c o m m o n - c o r e tcaching mediated through a disciplinary filtcr. Whilc helping students develop an awareness of the general significance of certain of thc characteristics o f writing in particular genres text organisational patterns, metadiscoursal features, grammatical subjects, for example at the same time we need to provide them with the strategies for examining how thcse operate and why this should be s o ti? reflecting on the subject matter, working practices, valucs and idcologies of the discipline or disciplines within which they are working. ~
Note 1
2
Whilc the ESP approach to genre analysis has been particularly influential in pedagogical applications, other perspectives exist, antl Hyon (1 996) has itlentifed t\vo additional broad areas of scholarship rcsearching non-literary genres: North American Rhetoric studies and work within Australian systcmic functional linguistics (for cxxample Martin 2000). Samraj had a further category, ‘miscellaneous’, which is not included here. Ilcnce the figures (lo not add up to 1 00Yo.
References Anderson, J. and Poolc, M. (1994) T ~ C S Iand S ignment Il’riting. 2nd edn. Brisbane, Queenslantl: Jacaranda Wiley. Bazcrman, C. (1 988) Shaping I1~’rirtenKnorvletlge: The Genre and ActiviLy $ [ h e Experimental ’4rticle in Science. Madison: University ofWisconsin Press. Bclanger, M. (1982) ‘ A preliminary analysis of the structure of thc discussion sections in tcn neuroscicnce journal articles’ (mimeo). Rcrkcnkotter, C. and Huckin,T. ( 1995) Genre Knowletige in Disciplinuy Communication. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Bhatia,V. K.( 1 993) Ana!y.sjng Genre: Longt~agcUse in fr&-sional Settings. London: 1.ongman. Bhatia, V. K . (1999) ‘Disciplinary variation in husiness English’. In M. Hewings antl C. Nickerson (ctls) Business English: Research into Practice. Harlow: Longman, 1 2 9 4 3 . Kizzell, P. ( 1 992) Academic Discourse antl Critical Consciousness. Pittsburg: University of Pittsburg Press. Brett, P. (1 994) ‘A genre analysis of the results section of sociology articles’. English,fbr Specific Purposes 1 3 : 47 59. Crismore, A., Markkanrn, R. and Steffenscn, M. ( 1 993) ‘Mctadiscoursc in persuasive writing: a study of tcxts written Iy American antl Finnish university students’. IWritten Communication 10: 39 71. Crookes, G. (1 986) ‘Towards a valiciatcd analysis of scirntific text structure’. Applied Linguistics 7:57-70. Dudley-Evans,T. (1 985) Writing Laborator// Reports. Melbourne: Nclson. Dudlcy- Evans, T. (1989) ‘Genre analysis: an invcstigation of the introduction antl discussion
82 A N N H E W I N G S A N D M A R T I N H E W I N G S rtations’ , In M . Coulthard (etl.) Talking about Ext. English Language of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK, 128 45. I)udlcy-Evans, T. ( 199 3) ‘Variation in communication pattcrns bctlveen discourse communities: the case o f Highway Engincct-ing and Plant Biology’. In G. Blue (ctl.) Language, Learning and Siiccess: Stiit+ing through English. Inndon: Macmillan, 141-7. Dudley-Evans. T. (1 995) ‘Common-core antl specific approaches to thc teaching of academic writing’. In D. Bclchcr and G. Rrainc (ctls) ilcatlcmic CVriting in il Sccontl Language: E.s.says on Research and Pctlagogj. Nor\\-ood, N]: Ahlex. Dudley-EI ans, T. and Henderson, W. ( 1990) ‘The organization of article introductions: evidence of changc in economics lvriting’ . I n T Dudley-Evans antl W. L. Henderson (eds) The Lungiia‘qe qf’ Economics: The ,4no!p.s c$’ Lconomics Discourse. London: Modern English Publications/ British Council, 67--78. Dutllcy-Evans, T. and St John, M. ( 1 998) Dei.elopments in English for Specific Purposes: .4 Multirlisciplinay ‘4pprouch. Camhritlgc: Cambritlgc University Press. Halliday, M. A. K. (1 973) Explorations in t h e Functions of’l.anguuge. London: Etlward Arnold. Herzherg, B. (1 9S6) ‘The politics of discourse communities’ . P a p presented at Conference o n College Composition and Communication, New Orleans, 1986. Cited in Bizzcll, 1992. I Icwings, A. (1 999) ‘Disciplinary cngagemcnt in untlcrgraduatc writing: an investigation of clause-initial elements in geography cssavs’ . Unpu1)lished Ph.11. thcsis,The University of Birmingham, UK. Holmcs, R. (1995) ‘Genre analysis antl thc social scienc an investigation of the introductions, background sections antl discussion sections of research articlcs in history, political science antl sociology’. Unpublishctl MA dissertation, Univcrsity of Surrey, UK. Holmcx, R. (1 997) ‘Genre analysis antl thc social sciences: an investigation of the structure of research article discussion sections in thrcc disciplines’ . Engli.sh,for Specific Prirposes 16: 321 37. Hopkins, A. and Dudley-Evans, ’I.. ( I 988) ‘A genre-based investigation of thc discussion sections in articles and tlisscrtations’. English-fir Specjfific Purposes 7 : I I 3 22. Hylantl, K . (1 999a) ‘Talking t o students: metatliscoursc in introductory courscbooks’ . English for Spec!$c Purposes 18: 3-26. Hvland, K . ( 1 99911) ‘Disciplinary discourses: writer stancc in rescarch articles’. In C. Candlin and K . Hylantl (eds) Il’riting: Exts, Procc.s.ses and Practices. I Iarlow: Addison- WesleyLongman, 99-1 2 1. Ifyon, S. (1 996) ‘Genrc in thrcc traditions: implications for ESL.’. TESOI. Quarter(v 30: 693 -722. MacDonald, S. P. ( 1992) ‘A method for analyzing sentence-level differences in disciplinary knowledge making’. IVritten Communication 9: 533 -69. MacDonald, S. P. (1 994) Pr~fe.ssiona1Acarlemic Writing i n the Numanitier. Carbondale: Southcrn Illinois University Press. Martin, J. K. (2001) ‘Tcchnicality and ahtraction: language for the creation of specialised texts’. In A. Burns and C. Coffin (eds) Analysing English in a Global Contexr. London: Routlcdge. Mauranen, A . ( 1 993) Cultural Differences i n Academic Rhctoric:/l Textlinguistic Stu+. Frankfurt-amMain: Peter Lang. Peng, J. ( 1987) ‘Organisational featurcs in chcmical cngineering research’. English Language Research Journal 1 : 7 9 1 1 6. Prior, P. (1 998) M/riting/Disciplinaritl~/I Sociohistoric h c o u n t of Literate Activity in the Academy. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Quirk, R . , Grecnbaum, S . , Leech, G. antl Svartvik, J. (1 985) A Comprehensive Grammar of’the English Language. London: Longman.
DISCIPLINARY VARIATION I N ACADEMIC WRITING
83
Roberts, I). ( 1 997) The Student s: G t ~ i d eto I?.iiting Essuys. London: Kogan Page. Samraj, B. T. R. (1995) ‘The nature of academic Lvriting in an interdisciplinary field’, Unpuldishetl Ph. D. thc , University of Michigan. Sclager-Meyer, F. ( 1 999) ‘Kcfercntial bchaviour in scientific writing: a diachronic study (1810-1995)’. Englishfbr Speczpc Purposes 18: 279-705. S\vales, J. (1 981) :Ispects pf;4rticle Introductions. Birmingham:The University ofAston, Language Studies Unit. Swales, J. ( 1 984) ‘Research into the structure of introductions t o journal articles antl its application t o the teaching of academic writing’. In R. Williams, J. Swales antl J. Kirkman (ctls) Coinrnon Ground: Shilretl Interests in ESP a n d Communicution Sttidies. EIT Documents
1 17: 77-86. Swales, J. (1 990) Genre ,Anu!ysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Tal-one, E., Dwyer, S., Gillettr, S. antl Ickc,V. (1 998) ‘On the usc o f t h e passhe antl active voice in Astrophvsics journal papers: with cxtcnsions t o other languages antl other ficltls’ . Englishfbr Spec,i/;c Purposes 17: 1 1 3 32. Tavlor, G. antl Chcn, T. ( 1 991) ‘Linguistic, cultural antl subcultural issues in contrastive discourse analysis: Anglo-American and Chinese scientific. texts’. Applied I inguistics 1 2 :
319 36. Vande Kopple, W. J. ( 1 98 5) ‘Somc exploratory discourse on metadiscourse’ . College Composition and Communication 36: 82-93.
Weissbcrg, R. and Buker, S. (1 990) lVriting u p Research. Engle\vood Cliffs, N J : 1’1-cnticc-Hall.
P A R T TWO
Political and institutional constraints in curriculum deve Iop me nt
Chapter 7
Ronald Carter P O L I T I C S A N D I
1 Introduction
T
H E R E L A T I O N S H I P B E T W E E N P O L I T I C S and knoLvletlge about language is both comprehrnsive and complex. In this chapter three main perspectives are offered: a brief overview of a national language education initiative in England and Wales with a particular focus on keywords in discourses about language, English and education; thc place of grnre theory in relation to such an initiative; some research and developmcnt questions for teaching school students about language.
1 . 1 Examining language Here is part ofa General Secondary Education paper set for 15-1 6-year-old pupils in Britain in the 1940s. Questions of this kind about grammar constituted between 20 and 30 per ccnt of thc total examination paper: Question 1 (a) Analyse into clauses the following passage. Give the grammatical description of thc clauscs and show their connection with each other: In that year (1 85 1 ) when the Great Exhibition spread its hospitable glass roof high over the elms of Hydc Park, antl all the world came to admire England’s wealth, progress and enlightenment, there might profitubb have been another ‘exhibition’ to show how our poor were housed and to tcach thr admiring visitors some of the dangers that beset the path of the vaunted nelv era. (13)
State the grammatical features o f t h c words italicized in (a).
Reference is made to such an examination exercise at the very beginning of this chapter bccause the views of language and of language teaching enshrined within it go right to the very centre of current debates in Britain about language tcaching in the context of the new National Curriculum for English in England and Walcs. The debate is characteriscd by different political positions antl, in particular, by strenuous efforts by the British government
88 R O N A L D C A R T E R to persuade teachers to a return to thc 1940s antl to the kinds of practiccs of language teaching illustrated by this cxamination paper. What are the practi Tvhich arc illustrated by this examplc? Why do government ministers wish to see the reinstated? What do tcachcrs think of them? What is the viekv taken by linguists of such practic AnsLvcrs to such questions may begin to explain why the materials for teachers protlucctl by the Language in the National Curriculum (henceforth, LINC) project \vert not only rcfuscd puldication by the British government, but also hccamc the centre of contesting iic\vs almut languagc and education.
1.2 Views of language and language teaching The different \ i e w s of language and language tcac hing in rcspcct of this reprcscntati\c examination paper held ti) go\ crnmcnt, English teachers antl 1): linguist5 mal be lx-oatll! wmmarisctl under three hcatlings ( 1 ) go\crnmcnt 1 IC\$ 5 , ( 2 ) teachers’ l i e n s , and (3) linguists’ \ I C W S GOTernment
1.
2.
3.
il e i i 7
The examination papcr illustrates a manifest conccrn with measurable knoMledge. A bocly of linguistic facts can hc taught, learned b y pupils and thcn tested. Answers are either right o r wrong, the liody of knowlctlgc taught is dcfinite and measurable, and teachers can even be assessed lw ho\v \vel1 they teach it. The learning \vhich cnsucs is tlisciplincd antl takes places nithin a clear framework. It contrasts vividly with what is felt to he the vaguc and undirected concern with creativity and personal cxprcssion which charactcrises ivork in many English lcssons at the prcscnt timc. Such practiccs w i l l help to guarantee corrcct grammar antl standard English. They will remove sloppiness in expression antl eradicate a climate in which errors are viewed only in relation to a process of language dcvelopment and thus not always immediately corrected.
7iacherc’ rreris
Until recently, teachers’ views have bccn rcgularlv dominated by what are described as ‘romantic’ conceptions of h g l i s h as a subjcct (. Christie, 1989; Carter, 1988). Romanticism in English teaching involves a classroom emphasis on languagc use \vhich is . the capacity o f thc individual for originality and creativity, person-centred, lvhich str and a concern that strict rulcs and conventions may be inhibiting to pupils anti, in the , restrict thcir capacitirs for using the language. There is a particular stress on the primacy of speech, even in writing where indivitluals arc cncouragctl by thc teacher to find their olvn personal voice. During the coui-sc of thc LINC project shifts in tcachcrs’ perception of’formal language study were recorded, but strong rc tance remains, on thc above grounds, to the tlccontcxtualised study of language, to aching practiccs and pedagogics which arc ncc .aril! transmissive and narrolvly kno\vletlgc-bascd, and which allow little or no scope for an emergence of the pupil’s owm ‘voice’.
POLITICS AND KNOWLEDGE ABOUT LANGUAGE
89
Linguists have taken a prominent role in the shaping ofthe National Curriculum for English in England and Wales. Most take the follohving main viclvs of grammar-haset1 tcaching and testing of linguistic knowlcdgc:
1
2
3
They point out ho\v examination papers from the 1940s and 1950s are prc(~ccupietl with the written rather than the spoken language. They point out that the analysis is invariably decontcxtualisetl since the dcfinitions required of pupils arc formalistic. Examinations such as thosc above arc exercises in the naming of parts. They point out that such examinations arc concerned lvith scntcnccs rather than texts. In fact, the text here is genuinely incidental. The focus is on a bottom-up analysis of the smallest units of language with little o r no interest in eliciting from pupils how such units might combine to form larger functional mcanings and effects.
Accordingly, thosc linguists lvho advised the government did not recommend a return to the 1940s antl to a tcaching of grammatical forms by m a n s of decontextualisctl drills. But they did not reject a formal study of language. Instead, they strongly advocated programmes of study for pupils in knowledge about languagc (KAL), based on a wider range of analysis than grammar, and [. . .] clearly rooted in theories of language variation, both spoken and written. The government \vas quick to rccognise that knowledgc about language, based on a variety of texts, includes discussion of language in context, and that discussion of context is often necessarily social. Such an orientation served only to rcinforcc for the g o x r n m e n t the desiraliilitv of dccontcxtualiscd drills and exercises.
2 LINC: An in-service teacher education project LINC is designed to make the theories and descriptions of language in the nc\r National Curriculum accessible to teachers, antl to assist them with thc language components ol’the National Curriculum lor English. [ . . .] In basic outline the main projcct team \vas asked to produce study units for tcachcrs which were to be used in in-service courses, in school-based follow-up and (ti and in sclf-stud! sessions. The resulting training package is therefore activity-lnscd antl open-entletl. I t contains many linguistically hascd tasks with accompanying commentarics so that teachers can work on the material in a range of‘contexts.
2.1 The LINC ban
The LINC project assumed political prominence \\hen the government dccidctl that it did not wish to publish the materials produced by the project. Neither would it allow commercial publication in spite of interest on the part o f . ral international puhlishcrs in publishing the complete training package. Although the projcct \vas a l l o w d to continue anti although the LINC training package could be made available in photocopied form for purposes of in-service training courses, such dccisions amounted to an effective ban on \videspread publication and dissemination of LINC materials.
[.
’
.I
l>cIiatcs surrounding thc LINC ban ccntrc o n certain key\vortls. They are tht. satnc keywords which recur repeatedly at times o f social and cultural change when questions of language and the nature of English as a subject are always central.
90 R O N A L D C A R T E R I t is no semantic accidcnt that words such as standard, correct, and proper are among the kcy\vortls. Debates ahout the state and status of the English language are rarely debates about language alone. The tcrms 01’ thc deliatc are also tcrms for defining social bchaviour.The term English is synonymous with Englishncss, that is, with an understanding of who the proper English are. A vimv o f one English with a single set of rules accords with a monolingual, monocultural version of society intent o n preserving an existing order in which everyone knows their place. A view which rccognises Englishcs as well as English and which stresses variable rules accords with a multilingual, culturally divcrse wrsion of society. Both positions include politically extrcmr versions. Thcsc range from a view that standard English is correct English and must tic uniformly enfbrccd in all contexts ofuse (with dialects extirpatcd) and that children not drilled in t h r rules of stantlard grammar are both deviant and discmpo\vercd (strong right-wing position) to a view that standard English is a badge of upper-class power, antl that to require children to learn it is a form of social enslavement (strong leftning position I) to a view that standard English must be taught to working-class children so that they can \vrcst linguistic power from those more privileged than themselves (strong left-wing position 11). It is striking how political positions converge in certain respects and how the pedagogical positions arc oftcn identical.
2.2 L l N C a n d g r a m m a r [.
’
.I
In the LlNC training materials therc is no advocacy o f a return to the dccontextualised drills and exerciscs of the 1950s. Instead therc is systematic exploration of grammatical differences lietwecn spccch antl writing, Iietwwn standard and non-standard forms of the language, and between diffcrcnt varieties of English. In spite of tieing described in certain national newyapcrs as a dialect project, 97 per ccnt of the examples is a LlNC materials are of pupils speaking, reading and lvriting in stantlard English. They also dcmonstrate that one of the most effective 1%-aysof learning standard English is for pupils to compare and analysc diffcrences between their o\vn dialects and thc tlialcct of standard English, discussing explicitly how and when differcnt forms are appropriate. [. . .] Here is an example of LINC’s approach to grammar taken from some local training materials. The example is liascd on a text in the form of a postcard delivered through the letterbox of customers of a water company. The following tcxt communicatcs information; in this case the information concerns the interruption to water supply. Whenever instructions arc given, a ‘modality’ enters the relationship between the writcr and reader of a text. ‘Modality’ takes a number of diffcrcnt forms in English liut the presence of modal verbs is particularly significant. Hcrc are some of the main modal vcrlx in English: can; could; will; izould; must; should; shall; may What i s the function of modal verbs in thc tcxt that follows? What other verb forms work, in particular, to establish a relationship between the Water Company and the customcrs to whom it has distrilmted this notice? Commentary This tcxt is in a curiously mixed mode. The Water Company has to inform its customcrs that repairs are unavoidable. I t has to give its customers instructions which
POLITICS AND KNOWLEDGE ABOUT LANGUAGE
91
Notice of interruption to supply We are w r r y to inform you that nccc55ar) mains repair5 in the area ma) cause an interruption to Jour 13 atrr supply hetuccn the hour5 olerleaf.
1 . Every effort will be matlc to keep inconvenience and thc duration of the shut-off to a minimum. 2. Do not draw more water than your minimum requircmcnts. 3. If the water docs go off, do not leave taps open or flooding may result when the supply is restored. 4. You may use water from thc hot tzater systrm but it must be boiled before drinking. 5. Even if the domestic hot \vater supply runs dry there will bc no risk of damage to the system, liut as a precaution kccp a lo\v fire where a back hoilrr is installed antl
turn or switch off other sources of heating thc water by gas, oil or electricity. Central heating systcms can continuc to be used at moderate tempcratures. The main \vi11 be flushed before the supply is restored b u t discolouration and or chlorine may persist for a short time. Allo\v your cold tap to run for a frw minutes to clear this watcr from your scrvicc pipe. Do not use your washing machine or other appliances during the discolouration.
We apologise again for any inconveniencc this may cause you and request your paticncc and co-operation. In case of any difficult! please contact the Nottingham District Office.
Please remember neighbours who may be older or disabled - they may need your help they nerd to follow both in their own intcrcsts antl in the intcrcsts of other consumers. At the same time the company ncctls to reassure its customers that a more or I t x normal service is still available, that, in spite of the interruption to supply, the company still providcs a good service and, above all, that there are n o safety or hcalth risks involved for its customers s o long as they comply with the guidelines and instructions issued with the notice. I t is important therefore that the company is clearly seen to lie in control.This ‘mixed mode’ is inscribed in the different modal verbs in the texts along the following gencral lines: Mode qf rcassurance/possihi/it/c.:may cause an interruption; may persist for a short
time; they may nccd your help; every effort will be madc; flooding may result; any inconvcnicncc this may cause you. Mode ofcontrol: must be boiled before drinking; the main will be flushed; can continuc to be u s d .
Notice that some modal w r b s can signal possibility ant1 control, depending o n the other words which s u r r o u n d thcm as well as on the context in which thcy arc used. For cxample, ‘you may use water’ (primarily control); ‘they may nccd your help’ (primarily possibility).
92 R O N A L D C A R T E R ‘Control’ 15 also established through an cxtensne u w of imperatne forms of the \.z hich unambiguouslj inform us u hat to do and M hat not to do. For example.
herb
Do not lea\ c taps open Allow your cold tap to run
Do not uw )our
1% ashing machine Please remember neighbours
Ac tivi tv Collcct examples of further texts in lvhich you would expect modal verbs t o be used quite extensively. For example, horowopcs mcather forccayts problem pages
school notices recipes legal tcxts
What other examples can ~ o find? u Wh) arc modal Lcrbs concentratcd in some tcxts but not others? It is one key fcature of the IJNC approach to grammar that teachcrs and pupils should, where possible, explore grammar in complete texts, in relation to social and cultural contexts and \vith reference both t o forms and functions. It is primarily concerned with how grammar works to construct meanings in the kinds of literary texts with which many English teachers arc familiar antl, as in the ahovr example, in the everyday texts we all encountcr in our daily lives.
2.3 Keywords What was effcctivcly a ban on the puldication of I SNC training materials probably should have hcen expcctctl.The emphasis on language variation antl on language in context led to a too frequent rcfercnce to social theory antl an emphasis on sociolinguistic persprctives. For governments of a particular political persuasion the word social is directly equitable with the word socialrst.’l’hc training packagc itself was tlcsignctl, it was said, in too activitybased and open a manner.The govcrnmcnt cvcntually made it clear that it had preferred all along training matcrials \vbich cmphasiscd right and wrong uses of English, reinforcing such an emphasis with drills antl cxerciscs for teachers and pupils to follow, antl with a printed appcndix containing the correct answers to the exer .The emphasis should be on factual knowledge which is measurable and tlctcrminahlc, and which can be transmittctl from a position of authority rather than be discoverctl through activity-centred processes. A kcyword here is thc wort1 drill. Finally, it \vas said that certain keyvords do not appear in a sufficiently unambiguous \Yay. In the training package words such as correct, standard and proper arc always rclativiscd t o specific contexts and practices of teaching. In respect of such key\vortls, linguists antl teachers tlo, in fact, need to find a w.ay of talking about language M h Iwttcr controls and engages \vith the cxisting public discourses, especially those of most ions of thc prcss antl mctlia. In this connection, English teachers have to apply thcir knowlctlge about language t o a major problem of communication. The very \mcabulary currently available t o talk about language variation offers only apparently negative or oppositional tcrms which play neatly into the hands of those with the most simplistic notions of language and education. Thus, t o talk about non-standard English can be seen as a departure from standards; t o talk about the dangers of absolute rules of corrcctncss is sccn as an endorsement of incorrcct English o r as a failure to correct pupils’
POLITICS AND I
93
\vork; to suggcst that proper English is relativc to contexts of use is itself improper. Space docs not allon- further exposure o f these antinomies (othcrs are traditional \-. trendy; national v. unpatriotic; basic \-. progrrssiyc; simple v. complex) but it is ea. thc generally moderate antl Iialanccd h g l i s h teacher is constructed as an ordcr, decency antl common sense. Rather than talk in terms o f standard and non-standard English, it \vould he prcferalile to talk in terms of d riptive language such as ‘gcncral’ and ‘special’ English.
3 LINC and genre theory [. . .] One of the most significant recent developments is in the field of genre theory and in the teaching, in particular, of gcnres of lvriting. It is a controversial area of teaching antl learning and LINC in-service training courses and materials engage in places directly \vith key aspects of gcnrc theory, as developed in the United States, \vithin the context of European text linguistics and of work in Australia lvithin the context of linguistics. Here is a sample of the kind of analysis undcrtaken in project materials within thc frame\\ ork of genre theory (teachcrs haw already undcrtaken analysis and classification of a range of different genres of writing): The following piece of \vriting \vas produced by a 1O-year-old girl in a junior school in England.To which ‘genre’ of lvriting might it be assigncd?Which particular features of language use support your decision? Does the writing have itlentifiablc ‘stages’ o f gcncric structure?
Snakes arc rcptilcs.They belong to thc lizards family. Snakes ha\? no legs but for a long time ago they had c h v s to help thcm slither along. Snakes arc not slimy, they arc co\ered in scalcs.Thc scales are just bumps on the skin.‘l.hcir skin is hard and glossy. Snakes often sunbathe on rocks.This is because snakes are coltl-lilootled and they nccd the warm s u n in orclcr to heat their body up. Most snakcs li\es in the country. Some snakcs live in trees, somc livc in water, b u t most livc on land in thick, long grass. A snakc \vi11 usually eat frogs, lizards, mice and r v r n small crocodiles. (Jenny, aged 1 0) Commentary
(1% rittcn
1), a group of teacher\)
The first stage o f the lvriting classifies the phenomenon; the second stage provides further descriptive information ahout the phenomenon (in this instance a snakc) .‘I‘hc gcnrc is that of an inJbrrnation report. This report i s characterised by the following linguistic features: a timeless, simple present tense used to make generalisations antl to con\ general truths antl facts (lire, .srinhuthc, hure).The iterative will (a snakc ‘will’ usuall: t) also serves in this instance to convcy the sense of a general, repeated action. The \vriting is charactcrisetl ljy an absence of personal pronouns. In fact, nouns are more common than pronouns and many of the nouns are in a form (with an indciinite article ‘a’ or in the plural form ‘snakcs’) \vhich dcscribcs it as a gcncral rather than an intlividualiscd or unique ‘relational’; for example, I S , hurt, belong phenomenon. Many of thc \-crlx used are t o , consist ofsupport a tlefining stylc o f pr The vocabulary used i s neutral rather than cmoti\ e o r attitudinal antl this
94 R O N A L D C A R T E R corresponds t o a report lvhich i s one o f impersonal classification rather than personal ohscrvation. Such impcrsonality is rcinforccd by the use of the passivc voice (‘they are covered in scales’).
3.1 Reactions to genre-hased teaching 1.
2.
3.
LINC tcams have lieen convinced b y the strcngth and depth of arguments for making the language structure of texts tnorr visililc o n the grounds that genuine intervention by thc teacher and c o n s c y c n t tlevclopnient in pupils’ language use arc n o t possiblc unless the relevant patterns of language arc identified. [. . .] LINC teams have acccptcd that a primary concern with personal shaping of expericnce has resulted in classrooms in \vhich thcrc i s an ovcr-concentration on narrative t o the exclusion of other gcnrcs. In a related way LINC has adopted a morc inclusivc 1 ic\v o f authorship, especially in the writing classroom. It a pts the view of Pam Gilbert (1 990: 70) that: ‘Authorship i s but one of the ncncst of a long line of discursive devices which serve to entrench 11-oriented theories o f writing in schools.’ Although personalist, individualist, SIJ such a position obscures important developmental connections between spcech and M-riting, it establishes a basis lbr inore impersonal Lvriting motlcs, and thus a \vider rangc of generic types o f ivriting o n lzhicli LINC has built. LINC’s introduction o f a m o r c gcnrc-liasctl approach t o lvriting has provoked some hostility on the I n r t of British tcachcrs. A major concern i s that such writing practices arc inherently conservative antl are designed t o produce unreflective operatives \vho will b c able to do n o morc than sustain a market economy for a conservative society. The concern of gcnrc thcorists for a \vitlcr rangc o f Mriting typcs which arc in turn closer- t o the rcquircnicnts 01’ thc \vorltl o f \vork is intcrprctcd as a narrow vocationalism. W h a t has hclpcd t o change this pcrccption is the notion of critical literacy, \vhich augments functional litci-acy to cnablc learners not only to comprehend antl produce society’s discourses, but also t o criticisc antl rcdircct them, if necessary. As Michael Hallidav ( I 996: 357) has put it:
To be literate i s not only t o participate in the discourse of an information socicty; it is also to resist i t . . . it i s rathrr pci-vcrsc t o think you can engage in discursive contest without engaging in the languagc- of the discourse. Such mark underlines that gcnrc-Imcd teaching is both revolutionary antl reactionary. British tcachers havc bccoinc increasingly impressed by thc precise analytical work \vhich has cnablcd central, prototypical featurcs of particular genres t o be identilied. It i s the samc explicitncss o f anal . which has helped both pupils and tcachcrs to develop a critical linguistic literacy. LING tcams have valuctl the overt, cxplicit and rctricval)le arguments advanced in particular I)? Martin (1989) antl KI-css (1989) b u t also 1w others. Taking such strong, clear argumentative lines cnablcs others t o ai-guc with or argue against in a systematic \lay.
POLITICS AND I
95
3.2 Problems and irsues Work on the LINC prolcct has also enahlcd teacher5 to identit) what sccm to them to be some problems 111th currcnt mark in gcnre theor!, and which ma) suggest directions for tuturc research and dc\clopment Such I \ the rxtcnt of interest in Britain in genre-based work that solutions to somc of these problcm~arc alread) being explored in a numlx,r of action-rewarch projects in UK schools and teacher-training collcgcs. 1 he main points of concern arc stated belo\r
1.
2.
Existing descriptions o fgenre lvithin a systemic functional tradition may have tended t o neglect \voi-k in other traditions of description. There has lxcn a concentration on the rcalisations of schematic and generic structure in the lexico-grammar of texts. ~. 1 hcrc is now a largc hody of \vork within the traditions o f text-linguistics antl Xvritten discoursc analysis o n lexical patterning, cohesion, coherence antl textual macrostructure. LINC teams keep coming across texts which do not conform to any single generic structure. They are the, rcsult of mixed gcnrcs. Examples of mixed genrrs arc arguments which make use o f narratiw structures, narratives which have reporting or exposition structures embeddcd lvithin them, and reports Tvhich arc simultaneously impersonal and personal in form, that is, they arc reports \vhich also contain personal accounts of events antl specific, person-bascd rccommcntlations. LINC teams \vould thus want to emphasisc that gcnrcs are not autonomous systrms, and that accounts o f gcnrc and genre teaching may be limited in their considerable potential if they become too simplistic or narrowly monologic.
[. .I Work within the framclvork o f Australian and British genre theory on the genre of narrative tends to hc a little too simplistic overall. Recause spoken narratives unfold sequentially in time, they do n o t normally have the charactrristic cmhctltlings, shifts in point of view, and complexities o f narratorial presentation which charactcrise most written narrati] era1 area of continua lxt\vccn spoken and \vrittcn gcnrcs it is in11 , that literacy is n o t wholly construed as '
3
4.
5.
\vrittcn texts. Early examples lvithin Australian \vork of teachcrs modelling gcnrcs to a \vholc class ~ T T Cpcrc.cived by I J N C to 11c possibly over-rigid antl tlctcrministic. A common \ icw is that thcrc has been a tendency among some genre theorists to swing thc pendulum too far in the opposite direction from romantic conceptions o f learning and teaching. arch in domains of both first- antl sccontl-language teaching sholvs that ~ v edo learn cffcctivcly b y making things our o\vn, and by being personally involvcd in the ' o f constructing a text. It has also been demonstrated that process-lnscd approaches to writing, with an emphasis on o\z-ncrship of the text, lead to increased motivation to use language. In a parallel \Val;, there may lw among theorists in a tcmic functional tradition a tendency to ovcrcmphasise factual, impersonal gcnrcs at the expense of the personal. Accordingly, British teachers and linguists have heen particularly imp-essrtl h y rcccnt mmk o n modelling in relation to joint and individual construction which operates successfully to show writing to he both processand Ix-oduct-based, antl that work on gcnrc can hr integrated with more holistic approaches to language learning and dcvclopmcnt. The identification o f genres for dcscription antl teaching tends to he internal t o thc school .Thcrc is little attempt to identify the gcnrcs of Lvriting commonly required in
96 R O N A L D C A R T E R
6.
the workplace. For example a rcport gcnrc in a junior school is markedly different from a rcport genre in industrial o r business work settings. Text-intrinsic accounts o f genre need t o take fullcr cognisance of the audiencc, purpose and context in which particular genres operate. Encouragement to pupils t o rcllcct o n language has tendcd t o lie restrictcd to the patterns of IanguagcT in the gcnrc in focus. Instead, a gcncral classroom climatr needs t o he established in which talking and writing almut language leads to [. . . ] language airureness that is, gcncral scnsiti\ it\. t o different styles and purposes of language use. These include tliffcrcnces l x t m w n spoken antl written language, cxplorations of the languagc of literature, thc language o f jokes, advertising, pop fiction, and political rhetorics, and investigations of’the continua I>ct\vccn different accents and dialects, ary habit-forming prelude including standard English. Such cxplorations arc a nc to looking m o r e closely antl analytically at the linguistic patterns \vhich make u p different genres. Analysis is not al\vays best fostcrcd by practising analysis of and reflection o n language solely within the context of individual genres. ~
Several of these observations arc hardly ncw, and many of’thcrn have been advanced by genre theorists themselves. Teachers in Britain intcrestctl in lzriting development arc bcginning positively t o e m l r a c c xzork on gcnrc-theory and on gcnrc bvithin a functionalist pcrspcctivc in particular. Thcsc observations should I>c vicwwl in a correspondingly positive light.
I. . .I 4 Conclusions: the lessons of LINC A project of the scale antl complexity o f LlNC cannot escape criticism. It is important that the lessons of both succcss and failure arc i x ~ o t - d c d 1:or . cxamplc, for all their S U C C ~ S S C S \vith tcachers, LINC materials ncctl t o he further adapted in three main ways. First, materials o n reading should Iic t l lopctl t o cxcmplify in grcatcr detail what a mixed methods approach to r c d i n g entails. Morc examples antl case studies ~ - o u l dillustratc how readers use a rangc- o f different cucs and cluc-s, syntactic antl semantic, phonic and visual, of learning t o read. Morc action rescarch \voultl illustrate when t o mix vhcn t o concentrate o n a xinglc teaching ptwccdurc. Future LINC materials ) must also cnablc teachers Iictter t o analysc the linguistic tliffcrcnccs between real books and hooks from gr-adctl reatling schcmcs. Sccontl, supplements to existing units arc ncccletl o n diffcrenccs bct\vccn spoken and Lvrittcn English, particularly in relation t o the teaching of punctuation, which depends crucially on the relationship Iiet\vccn grammatical structure and the rhythms and contours of spccch. More examples arc also nccdcd o f how standard English varies across spoken and written modcs hvhile still remaining standard English. Third, inorc cxxaniplcs arc nccdctl t o show how literary texts can stimulate enhanced kno\vlcdgc about language, especially the history of the language, antl how greater linguistic kno\vlcdgc underpins literary appreciation. 1
4.1 Negative conclusions Even if the gcncral tlcvclopmcnts outlined ahovc take placc, they \vi11 take placc against a cultural background in lvhich both positive antl negative factors arc at w o r k . The main negative factors arc, first, that some teachers will continue to pcmist with the worst cxccsscs of romanticism in their view of language learning and tcaching.l’hcy will continue t o make linguistic processes invisildc antl regard language only in so far as it provides a \vindo\v o n
POLITICS AND KNOWLEDGE ABOUT LANGUAGE
97
to content, the expression of the individual self, the kvorltl of ideas. They will continuc to refuse to see forms of language as a powerful resource for creating significant domains of meaning. Second, governments may want to intervene more directly in the shaping of the English curriculum. If so, and Lyhatevcr their political persuasion, governments may not want to endorse classroom language study which explores relationships between language and society, and which subjccts those relationships to interrogation. They are likely to continue to be especially disturbed by classroom K A L work which encourages childrcn to investigate such rclationships indcpcndently. Thcy may exert their powers to impose a language study which is ‘neutraliscd’b y being more decontextualisctl, formalist rather than functionalist in orientation, and \vhich, above all, can be easily assessed and measured. The currently very overt demands by thc British government for grcatcr attention to phonics in the teaching of reading is but a signal of an increasing emphasis on the basics in so far as 1% hat is ‘basic’ often involvcs a dccontextualiscd language focus.
4.2 Positive conclusions It is a positive factor that governments are drawing attention to language, recognising it as
both medium and mcssagc, mounting arguments in relation to the ‘proper’ study of English, attacking the positions adopted by those with a profwsional interest in language. Although the battles will continue to be bet\\ n those who have thc power but not the knowlcdgc, and those who have the knowledge but not the power, the \-cry fact that governments arc forced to mount explicit arguments about language is healthy both lor proccsscs of public debate and for the cause which espouses the ccntrality of language to the school curriculum. Increasing attention to language on the part of teachers, coupled with high degrees of enthusiasm and conviction, will lead to pupils being progrcssi\-cly interested in language. Increasing knowledge about language among pupils will produce within a generation a society which is likely to be less prejudiced and ignorant and more informed and articulate about matters to do with language. Finally, a morc positi\e view of applicd linguistics emerges from projects such as thc LINC project. It is a view in which teacher and linguist work more collaborati\ely ton.ards common agendas. As a result, tcachcrs become more a\varc of the problems of linguistic description and, in turn, linguists begin to address problems identified by teachers, rathcr than only those problems itlentifietl by linguists themselves. [. . .] Incrcasingly, all concerned with language have come to appreciate how notoriously fascinating, complex and ultimately dangerous language and language study arc. In a project inspired by thc work of Michael Halliday, the final word must be left to Halliday (Halliday, 1982):
. . . there is a real sense in kvhich linguistics is threatening; it’s uncomfortable, and it’s subversive. It’s uncomfortable because it strips us of thc fortifications that protect and surround some of our dccpcst prcju . As long as xve keep linguists at bay ~ v can c go on believing \\.hat ~ v \\,ant e to hcli >outlanguage, both our own and ... More than any other human phenomenon, language reflects and reveals the inequalities that arc cnshrinctl in the social process. When we study language sjrstcmatically . . . we see into the power structure that lies behind our ever);day social relationships, the hierarchical statuses that are accorded to different groups \vithin society . . . ClSC~’S
98 R O N A L D C A R T E R
Bibliography Carter, R. (1988) ‘Some Imvns for Kingman: language education and English teaching’, in Grun\vell, P. (etl.) .,Ipplied Linguistics in S o c i c : ~ 3 , British Studies in Applied Linpi.stics (CIIT, London) pp. 5 1-66. Christie, I;. (1 989) I unguugc Edricirtion (Oxford University Press, Oxford). Gilbert, P. ( 1990) ‘Authori7ing disadvantage: authorship and crcativity in the language classroom’, in Christic, F. (cd.) Literuy fi)r a Chunging Cihrld (Australian Council for Educational Research, Halvthorn, Victoria), pp. 54-78. Halliday, M. A. K . (1982) ‘Linguistics in teachcr cducation’, in Cartcr, R. (etl.) Linguistics a n d the Zucher (Routledge, London), pp. 10 16. Halliday, M. A. K. (1 996) ‘Literacy and linguistics: a func.tional pcrspectivc’, in Hasan, R. and Williams, G. (eds) Literacj, in Sociecl, (Longman, Lnndon), pp. 339 75. Krcss, G. (1 989) Liniqtiistic P r o c e w s in Sociocultural fructicc (Oxford University Prcss, Oxford). Martin, J. ( 1 989) Fuctuul IVriting (Oxford Univcrsity Press, Oxford).
Chapter 8
Gary M. Jones B I L I N G U A L EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN: TOWARDS A WORI
Introduction
B
R U N E I D A R U S S A L A M (henceforth Brunei) has a hilingual education system in which two languages, Rahasa hlelayu and English, are used. As this paper will suggest, ho\\ ever, the two languages should not lie regarded as indcpcntlcnt variables or in any way as competing with one another, but as k i n g highly intcr-dcpcndent and complementary. In Brunei, the final school leaving examination (the GCE ‘0’lewl) has determined the syllabuses of the individual school subjects, with the result that subject syllabuses have been planned in isolation and then joined to create the school curriculum. In a bilingual system, such subject-centred planning makes little pro1 ision for the tlevclopmcnt of t\vo languages as intcrlocking variables. Language development is considered in much the same way as any other ‘suliject’: in isolation rather than as complementing other sulijects antl playing a key rolc in the child’s owrall cognitivc as well as educational d lopmcnt. As I hope this paper \vi11 demonstrate, syllabus design should play a crucial role in a bilingual education system and careful consideration must lie given to the timing and introduction of the various school subjects and their allottcd language medium.
[.
.
.I
The current curriculum The present school syllabus, as sho\vn inTable 8.1 , shifts in three stcps from a predominantly Malay-medium to a predominantly English-medium system. These stage shifts, how are abrupt rather than gradual. At Primary 4, when the pupils arc eight ycars old, the first and most important of the transitional stcps is taken. A t this time, in addition to English Language as a subjcct, Mathcmatics, Science, History antl Geography are introduced antl taught through English. This is a most demanding and difficult change for pupils and tcachcrs alike. Ramirez et al. (1 99 1 ) haw notcd that: there is some evidence that suggests that when limited English-proficient students receive most of their instruction in their home language, thry should not lie aliruptly transferred into a program that uses only English. (Ramirez et al., 1991 : 40)
100 G A R Y M . J O N E S Tcihle 8. I Compulsory and cxaminablc suhjccts in Rrunri priniarv antl sccontlarv schools
English Language
Englith Language Mathematic5 Mictor)
Science
Gcograph: English I.anguagc Mathematics Science
I oii cr PrimoLy (age 5-8) Mala! I anguagc Mathematics General Studies Islamic Rcligious Kno\z.le.tlgc Physical Education Arts antl Handicraft Civics llppcr Primor) (ugc 9 I I ) Malay Languagc Islamic Religious Kno\z.lctlge Physical Education Arts and Handicraft Civics 1 . o cr ~ Seconduy (uge 12 I J) Malay Languagr Islamic Kcligious Knowlcclgc Historv
Geography English I anguagc Mathematics Scicncc/Art/T'echnical Subjccts (clcpcntling o n stream)
Although some Malay continues to be usctl in the RI-uncian system, at Primary 4 thcrc is an abrupt change, antl this occurs at a time when the pupils have only a limited proficiency in English. Not only is the number of English-medium hours greatly increased, but the incrcasc is in some of' the most cognitivcly demanding subjects, subjccts which Cummins (1 984) would characterise as precisely those that require a well-tlcvclopcd L2 proficiency.
BICS and CALP Cummins (1 984) has in fact distinguished bctween two sets of language skills: basic interpersonal communication skills (BICS) and cognitive acadcmic language proficiency (CALP). He argucs that children will be unable to cope with the school curriculum unlcss their cognitive academic language proficicncy (CAW) is sufficiently dcvclopcd. A child's l to cope with the curricular language-cognitive abilitics nccd to be sufficiently ~ . c ltlevclopcd processes of the classroom. This proficicncy could be tlevcloped in either of the tiilingual child's languages o r in both simultaneously. In Cummins's ( 1 984: 143) opinion, CALP involvcs some universal undcrlying proficicncy which is shared across languages. Once acquired in one language it can tic transferred to any other language. Thus, proticicncy of this sort acquired in Malay could hc transferred to English-medium classes antl vice versa. Cummins develops thc concept of RICS antl CALI' in the four quadrant model which is reproduccd as Figure 8.1 .
BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN
101
Cogillti\ cl) undcmantling
(RICS)
H
B
c
I)
Contcxt rctluc c d
ConCcxt-cmbctltlctl
(CAI P) C‘ogniti\ cl\ tlcinantling Flgtrre
8. I RICS ant1 CALI’
Sorrrcc: Curnmins. 198 1
In the Brunei context, subjects such as Mathematics and Science, which arc cognitively demanding and often context-retlucrd (based on abstract rather than concrete examples), would be placed in the fourth quadrant (D), whilc those such as Art and Physical Education, which arc cognitively undemanding and generally context-embeddetl, xvould be placed in the first quadrant (A). What should be of some conccrn to curriculum designers in Brunei is that Cummins (1 98 1 ) hclicvcs that it often takcs one or t\vo years for a child to acquire language that might IK d context-eml~edde~l second language fluency (the typ in Art or Physical Education classes), but from fivr to years to accluirr context-reduced case, then after only three years fluency (working with more abstract subjects). If thi of English 1,anguagr as a subject at lower primary school, Bruncian children arc unlikely to haw thc rcquired English proticicncy to study the type of cognitivel! demanding, contcxtreduced subjects that the); arc currcntl); introduced to in Primary 4. [. . .] Cummins’s concept o f BlCS and CALP has been criticiscd for being too simplistic. Romaine (1 989) argues that language skills cannot be compartmentalisetl as neatly as Cummins suggests and that Cummins is guilty of equating semantic development with cognitive development. I t is ccrtainly the case that not all subjects can be simply and easily placed in their rrspcctivc quadrants. Science will allvays be cognitively demanding, but it could be taught in a context-cmbcdded as \vel1 as a contcxt-rcduccd style.’l’he same is true of most subjects: much dcixnds upon the style and skill of the teacher. Nevertheless, while it might he difficult to neatly place all school subjects into one of‘ the four quadrants, Cummins’s motlcl does provide insight into Lvhy pupils \vorking in a sccond language may struggle in some subjects hut do wrll in othcrs. Most important is that Cummins hcli context-reduccd, cogniti\rl!.-demantling communication capaliility develops intlependcntly and can be promoted by either or both languages. [. . .] If kno\\lctlgc is transferable across languages, then thew is no nerd to begin the study of thcsc academically tlrmanding subjects at an early age through the medium of‘ English to prcparc for an English-medium examination that will he takcn eight years later.
1. .I ’
Threshold levels The present assuniption in Brunei is that subjects which will be examined in English at ‘0’ level at age 16 should bc taught through the medium of English from as early an agc as possihle. Subjects that arc eventually examined in Malay are therefore taught through the medium of Malay throughout. [. . .] This present division of Malay-medium/English-medium subjects, cspccially a t thc primary lc\-cl, is putting an unncccssary strain on pupils and the education system. Many
102 G A R Y M. J O N E S pupils have an insufficient command of English to prolxrly follo\v their new subjects, cspecially Mathematics antl Science. The result is that many pupils arc failing to acquire either sufficient subject knowledge o r to imlx-ove thcir language skills. 1. . .] The shift to cognitivcly and linguistically dcmantling tasks at Primary 4 is at present made on the assumption that pupils ha\ c sufficient mastcry of English t o actually study through the medium of English (as \\‘as originally cnvisagetl in 1951). This assumes that pupils have attained some miniinurn languagc aliility or threshold. [. . .] Although language thresholds \vert not discussed as such hack in the 1950s, rcccnt clarification of what they involve helps to licttci- clarify the situation in Brunei and relate language levels there to those attained elsc\vhci-e. Van Ek andTrim ( I 991) d c rilie the threshold level in terms of the type of functions that a young European learner should be alilc t o pcrfoi-m in the target language. These functions are incvitalily Euroccntric, rcflccting the nccds of Europcan stutlents.They include being alile to understand and use the target languagc as a medium of instruction antl as a language of social interaction in English classes antl among learners during breaks and at mealtimes; lwing able to report and discuss prolilcms relating to teaching, social conditions and accommodation and also how t o follow admission procedures t o cntcr teaching institutions. Van Ek and Trim ( 1 991 ) specify thc numlicr of tcaching hours that should be needed to attain the threshold level of proficiency: t\vo t o thrcc hours per Lvcck, 35 to 40 \vccks a w a r over two t o three years. A minimum o f 140 hours of teaching and a maximum of 360 hours. In Bruneian lower primary schools, prior to transfer to Primary 4 and the teaching of acadcmically demanding subjects through the medium of English, Hruneian pupils receive approximately 262 hours teaching in and on the English language (two and a half hours per week, 35 weeks a year over three years). It should also Iic rcmcmbcrcd that these Bruneian children arc very young (oltlcr Icarncrs may n o t ncccssarily lie Iwttcr learners but they d o understand the educational Iiroccss and a r c thcrcforc faster Icarncrs, as Singlcton, 1 989, has oliservetl), that they may not ha1.c a v c r v supportive learning c n \ ironmcnt outside school, especially for the tlcvclopnient o f Lnglish, antl that English is unrelated to any of their other languages. These arc condition5 \vhich must surely crcatc greater language studying difficulties than for their European peers. I . . . ] In 195 1 , with selected pupils following intcnsivc personal tuition, minimum proficiency levels \z-crc presumahlv consitlercd attainable. Ho\\ er, the Same is not true today of large mixed ahilitj classcs ofchiltlrcn. Many pupils arc failing to attain a minimum proficiency in English liefore the introduction of cognitivcly and thcrcby linguistically dcmanding English-medium sulijccts. It is probably the case that they are only reaching such a level w h m they cntcr Lower Secondary school, at \vhich time thcv should really be functioning at an intermediary level hcyontl the sccond threshold. This level, in turn, may only be reached at the point these pupils rcach upper secondary, at which timc the pupils have t o take their ‘0’levels, which require an cvcn higher language Ic\cl. As a result of problems ticginning at primary school, pupils continue to lag behind their required level or threshold of language proficiency antl the majority never really rcach the language standard which their age might assume. Sornc c.vidcncc for this has been gathcrcd b j Lewis Larking, w h o tested the reading comprehension ability of Bruncian pupils in Primary 5 and 6. He found that at Primary 6, 700/0of pupils were helow their nativespeaker equivalent grade level in English reading comprehension ( 2 8% were one year below grade Icvcl; 38% two or more years Iiclow antl 4% three or more years hclow gradc level). Interestingly, only 7% of thcsc same pupils \ \ w e hclow grade level in Malay reading comprchcnsion (Larking, 1994: 58). 1. . .]
BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN
103
Subject order: some considerations Given the mix of primar hool subjects and the various degrees of cognitive demands thcy make antl opportunities for language interaction they offer, perhaps the easiest and most urgent changes would be to the subjects that are taught through the mcdium of English at upper primary and to the nature of thc transition from predominantly Malay-medium to English-medium subjects. Instead of teaching the cognitivcly demanding, ‘contrxt-rcduccd’ subjects in English and the cognitively undemanding, ‘contcxt-cmbeclded’ subjects in Malay, the easiest proposal would be to switch subjects. Thus Mathematics and Science would rcmain Malay- medium subjects (at lcast, until Lower Secondary) whilc Art and Physical Training would be taught as English-mcdium subjects at the primary Icvcl. Support for retaining thc tcaching of Mathcmatics and Science in the mother tongue (at lcast until secondary school) can also be seen in Ramirez et al. (1 991) where it is noted that students Ivho were abruptly moved into almost exclusive instruction in English ‘. . . experienced a marked dccrcasc in growth in mathematics skills over timc’ (Ramircz et a ] . , 1991 : 33). To avoid the sudden incrcasc in English-medium subjects at Primary 4, morc Englishmedium subjects could be introduced at lower primary level. [. . .] A r t and Physical Education arc not literacy but oracy and participatory activitics that should not endanger the acquisition of first language literacy. Thus these two subjects could be introduccd in English-medium at lower primary, together with English Language, lvithout harming thtx pupils’ ability to first become literate in Malay.
Age and language acquisition: some considerations Harlev (1 986) antl Singleton ( 1 989) have shown that the question of age antl language acquisition is complcx and does not lend itself to an easy and universal anslvcr. Most of the research supporting the ‘younger is better’ position does so with reference to phonological advantages, while that supporting the ‘older is better’ stand is on the basis of syntax antl morphological measures of ability. Hamcrs antl Blanc ( 1 989) and others question the evidence for there being a sensitive period and a biologically tlctcrmincd optimal age for L2 acquisition. [. . .] The conclusion that younger learners arc at an advantage because they have more time to learn and are less likely to suffcr interfcrencc from their first language matches quite closely, though for different stated reasons, the conclusions that Genesee ( 1 987) has drawn concerning the various immersion programmes in Canatla: Second language proficiency tends to increase the earlier immersion begins and the more second language exposure the learner has. Thus, early total immersion generally yiclds higher lcvcls of second language pruficicncy than carlp partial immcrsion, delayed immersion, o r late immersion. (Genesee, 1987: 191) Singlcton (1 989) argues that many factors arc involved in language acquisition and that cxamples of age-related research have to be analpsed individually, noting the peculiaritics of each study. Singleton concludes that: there is a fair amount of cvidcncc suggcstivr of a long-term adbantagc for learners whoa(, c,xpcrirnce of the target language begins in their childhood yrarr. . . . with
104 G A R Y M. J O N E S regard to short-term attainment, the picture is more confused. Hobvcvcr, the Iialance o f evidence docs sccm to indicate an initial advantage for oldcr learners at least as far as grammatical dcvclopmcnt i s conccrncd. (Singleton, 1989: 122) Dcspite his extensive research o n the sulijcct, Singleton remains undecided about the benefits of one approach over thr other:
(1)
The a\ailablc e\ idcncc doc5 not consistcntl: \upport the hJpothcsis that youngcr
(2)
second language learner? arc gloliall~m o r e cfhcicnt and ruccc5sful than oldcr learners. Nor 15 it possililc t o conclude f r o m t h e (x\itlcnce that o l d c r second language learners arc glol)all! more cfhc lent and 5ucccssfuI than Joungcr learners (Singleton, 1989: 138)
Although Singleton docs not favour cithcr an carl! o r late start, he does suggest that Cuinmins’s RICS/CALI’ distinction rcconcilcs contradictions in the cviclcncc aliout agerelated differences among second language learners, citing Cummins’s o\vn proposals:
the older learners, \vhosc‘ CALP i s Iwttcr tlcvelopcd, \voultl acquire cognitive/ academic I .2skills more rapidly than youngcr learners; however, this \vould not necessarily he the case for those aspccts of L2 proficicncp unrclatccl to CAI,P (i.c. L2 BICS). (Cummins, 1979. In Singleton, 1989: 1 1 3)
This lcntls support t o the type of sul3jcct division rccommcndctl earlier for Brunei, ~lc‘tl preceding with the study of cognitivcly untlcmantling, c o n t ~ ~ x t - c r n l ~ c ~ l suhjccts cognitively demanding, context-rcduccd subjects. The majority o f Bruncians u.ho voluntccrcd a reply to the question’ Are there anj. comments thatyou u d d like t o make ahout Dri,ihuhusci!’ in a national attitude questionnaire that \\-as concluded rccrntly suggested that more English should introduced at an earlier age. It \voultl lie \cry cas! t o dismiss such suggestions as Iicing uninformed and subjective, b u t I think that this \vould bc \\rang and a misjudgcnicnt of‘ the rcspontlcnts. Rruncians havc hcen exposed t o a varicty 01’ school tcms.’l‘hcrr can bc little doubt, ho\vevcr, that the Bruneians w h o arc most at case \vith the English language arc those who attcndcd English-medium mission schools at an earl! age. Some of thcsc pcoplc continued their education in the mission schools ivhilc others \vent on t o government schools. In either case, an advantage seems t o have Iiccn tlcrivctl from early cxposurc- to English. Of course, an ability with English \voultl also he tlcpcndent upon factors outsidr school, especially languages iisetl in the home, and it can I>cassumed that many parents \vho sent their children to English-medium mission schools \z oultl themselves very prohalily usc English at home. But this would n o t havc been the case for all familics. The English language a b i l i t j of graduates from such schools is takcn as cvitlcncc Iiy Bt-uncians that early exposure to English results in ticttcr acquisition of the 1anguagc.This conclusion ma! bc subjective, hut in Brunei it is accepted as self-evident and is the most commonly cited reason given 1iy Rruncian parents \vho can afford it for sending their chiltlren to English-mctlium kindergartens. Although research \voultl obviously h a w t o lie undertaken to provc the point, my own imprrssion fi-om oliscrvations in Brunei is that as \vcll as phonological atlvantagcs, early exposure t o English also appears to result in a greater cor$dencc among learners in actually h
c
BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN
105
using thc language. Such confidrncc results in fewer inhihitions antl a willingness to experiment with thc language. A t its simplest, the Bruneians who haw acquired English early at mission schools are gencrally more confident, and therefore more at case with the language antl thus likcly to use antl experiment with the language, than their peers who went to government schools.
The relevance of The German Model A wcll established motlcl of bilingual education that has given consideration to the timing and sequencing of the school subjects in its system is that no\v referred to as ‘The German Model’ (Masch, 1993). Bilingual Gymnasium (‘grammar’) schools in Germany make a gradual transition from German to a second language, introducing the new language through a sequcncc of subjects that are chosen to complement each other as \vel1 as to aid both language and subject acquisition. [. . .] In sequence, the subjects chosen as 1-ehiclesfor bilingualism in The German Model arc: (1) Art; (2) Geography; (3) Politics (Civics); (4) History. Art is considered to provide a concrete situational base from which to develop language skills (as well as subject ability). Geography performs a refcrcntial, information giving function and provides a relatively simplc start to description. Geography is also recognised as pcrforming a second hut crucially important role in bilingual education in Germany. While some scicncc subjects are considered to bc language poor because of the spccialisetl content ofthcir subject-specific languagc (Masch cites Biology as an example), ‘Geography alone sufficiently covers virtually all the necessary elements from thc natural sciences through physical geography and geophysical phenomena, and from the application of mcthodological skills through its work with figures, statistics, graphs and sketches’ (Masch, 1993: 163). Politics (Civics) antl History arc included in the lilingual education system in Germany as much for integration and a better understanding of the country’s European neighbours as for the language benefits of the subjects. Nevertheless, the study of politics does include a recognisablc languagc function: [. . .]The aims ofthe course in politics suit thc bilingual section: an ability to rccognisc tliffcrcnt types of action antl a capacity to form an opinion. (Masch, 1993: 1 6 3 4 )
Physical Education Physical Education is not mentioned in Masch’s dcscription ofthe German Model. However, this subject docs lend itself particularly to communicatiw activities because it emphasises n language and physical movement. A physical education lecturer at the Univcrsitv of Brunei Darussalam has noted the link l x t w e r n his suhjcct and language acquisition in Brunei. He maintains that physical education creates a language rich cnvironmcnt :
[. . .] The most noticeable change in students’ attitude o r lxhaviour \vas a readily discernible increase in confidence . . . Emanating from this incrcase in contidrncr a noticeablc improvement in fluency together with greater self-assurance whilst making statements was evident in the studcnts’ performance. (Austin, 1992: 25 -6)
106
G A R Y M. JONES
Revised syllabus As an alternative to the present distribution o f suhjects and language media, and with due l RICS/CALP and the threshold levels, consideration to language acquisition antl age as ~ . c las I would suggest that compulsory and examinable sulijects in Bruneian primary and secondary schools might be more appropriately distributed as shocvn inTalile 8.2. Table 8.2 An altcrnatiLc distribution of subjects in the Kruncian education 9ystcm
English medium
English Language Arts (antl I Iantlicraft) Physical Education
,WO/UJ medium
I ower P r i r n q Malay Languagc Mathematics
General Studies Civics Islamic Religious Kno\\ lctlgc llpper Priniar)
English Languagc
Malay Languagc
Arts (and Handicraft)
Mathematics
Physical Education
Civics
Grography
Scicncc
1 Iistory Islamic Rcligious Kno\vlctlge Luiwr Seconclucv
English Language
Malay Language
Mathematics
f Iistory
Geography
Islamic Rcligious Kno\vlctlgc
Science [Jppcr Scconday. English Language
Malay Languagc
Mathematics Science/Art/TcchnicaI Sulijccts (depending on stream)
Physical Training and Art Mould join English Language as English-medium subjccts in the lower primary curriculum. Geography, givcn the expcricncc of the German Model, would also seem an appropriate subject to introduce at thc primary level. Mowcvcr, rather than tax the pupils with too many English-medium subjects at once, the introduction of Geography might best lie postponed until upper primary. In this revisctl system, History would remain a Malay- medium subject throughout (there arc not the same integrative political considerations operating in Brunei that encourage the bilingual teaching of this subject in Europe) and the introduction of Scicncc and Mathematics \vould be dclaycd until secondary school. I. . .] The system described above is open to a number of permutations. For instance, should three subjects bc introduced simultaneously from Primary 1 or would it be bcttcr to introduce them consccutivcly, one year at a time? Is there any advantage to lie gained in switching History from Malay to English-medium? Ideally, a number o f permutations might be triallcd until the most appropriate model for Brunei is arrived at. Of course, this would takr time and may not tic feasible because of the common national examinations that have
BILINGUAL EDUCATION AND SYLLABUS DESIGN
107
to be taken at the end of primary school. However, givcn the research that has been conducted into threshold levels and the timing of their acquisition, as well as considerations of contcxt-embedded /context-reduced, cognitivcly demanding/cognitively undcrnanding subjects, then this revised model for the introduction of subjects in the Brunei education syytem, in one form or another, would seem more appropriate than that currently employed. While I bcliew that the above \vould he a better system than the present distribution of subjects, there arc a number of practical considerations which would impede the implementation of this proposal. As well as the problem of new examinations and syllabuscs, there would also be the huge task of supplying o r retraining teachers for new media of instruction. Givcn that providing a sufficient number of properly qualificd teachers has always been a problem in Brunei, changing the language-medium of some subjects would, in the short term at least, further compound this problem. Malay-medium Art, Geography and Physical Education teachers may not be willing or able to teach in English; Englishmedium Mathematics, History and Science teachers may not be able to teach in Malay. Ncvcrthclcss, the introduction and redistribution of school subjects at thc primary level is an issue that should eventually be addressed.
References Austin, S. ( 1 992) ‘Languagc development through education’. Paper presented at a seminar in thc University of Brunei Darussalam, December 1992. Cummins, J. (1 979) ‘Cognitixe/academic language proficiency, linguistic inter-dependence, the optimum age question and some other matters’. Ilbrking Papers on BilingLiulism 19, 198 203. ___~ (1 98 1 ) ‘Thc role of primary language developmcnt in promoting educational succcss for language minority students’. In The California State Department of Education (ed.) Compendium on Bilingual-Bicultural Education. Los Angeles: California Statc Department of Education. (1 984) Bilingualism and Special Education: lssues in Assessment and Pedagogy. Ckvedon: Multilingual Matters. Genescc, F. (1 987) Learning Through E o Languages. Cambritlgc, MA: Ncwbury I Iouse. Hamcrs, J. F. and Blanc, H. A. (1989) Bilinguals and Bilingualism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Harley, B. (1 986) Age in Second Language Acquisition. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. Larking, L. (1 994) ‘Reading comprehension ability of Primary 5 & 6 children in Malay and English in Brunci Darussalam’. In M. L. Tickoo (ed.) Reatling and Research in Writing. Singaporc: Rcgional Language Centre. Lenneberg, E. H. (1 967) Biological Foundations $Language. New York: Wiley. Masch, N. (1 993) ‘The German Model of bilingual education: An administrator’s pcrspcctivc’. In H. Ractcns Rcardsmorc (cd.) European Model.$ ?f Bilingual Education. Clcvcdon: Multilingual Matters. Ramirez, J. D., Yuen and Ramey (1 991) Longitudinal Study of Immersion Earlj-exit and Late-exit Transitional Bilingual Education Programs .for Language M i n o r i y Children. Mountain View, CA: SRA Technologies. Romaine, S. (1 989) Bilingualism. Oxford: Basil Blackwcll. Singleton, D. (1 989) Language Acquisition: The Age Factor. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. Van Ek, J. A. and Trim, J. L. M. (1991) Threshold 1-eve/ 1990. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Press. ~
Chapter 9
Kimberley Brown WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL P R O G R A M S : A N I N F U S I O N M O D E L OF CURRICULAR INNOVATION
Introduction T H A S B E E N S U G G E S T E D (c.g. Kachru, 1988)thatitistimeforaparadigmshit‘t which takes into account the changing roles antl functions of English around thc world in linguistic research antl in languagc pcdagogj. In spite of clearly articulated arguments and n d - d c f i n r d calls for applied and theoretical research in the languagc education community, Kachru’s perspective on the role and functions o f English as an international language remains a minority perspective. Even though t\vo gcncrations of scholars have been rcfining the elements of what has comc to Iic termed thc World Englishes paradigm (Kachru, 1992a), there is little evidence of its infusion intoTcaching English to Speakers of Other Languages (TESOI.) preparatory programs (Vavrus, 1991a). This paper examines possiblr explanations for the lack o f incorporation of this paradigm in TESOL preparatory programs. In an attempt to find a \ v a j to incorporate thc World Englishes paradigm intoTESO1, programs, I kvill draw upon Hamnctt et al.’s (1 984) threepronged approach to what they term ‘thc intligenization of social science research’ (78). This paper will also explore impediments to curriculum design and teaching practice that may hamper the inclusion o f the World Englishes pcrspcctive into TESOL preparatory programs. A paradigm refcrs to a particular thcorctic framcmvork o r perspcctivc. The World Englishes paradigm (hereaftcr referred to as the WE paradigm) may lie charactcrizcd by three elements (Kachru, 1988: 1 ) :
I
a ticlicf that there is a ‘repertoire of modcls for English’ a belief that ‘the localized innovations [in English] have pragmatic Iiases’ a belief that ‘thc English languagc now bclongs to all those who use it’.
Paradigm shifting and diffusion o f innovation Within meta-theory research, i.e. theories about theories, I’atton (1 975) explores the relationship betwecn the context in which information is lcarnctl and the dcgrcc to which people remain attached to that information. I IC statcs: ‘. . . paradigms are deeply embedded
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS
109
in the socialization of adherents and practitioners telling them \\hat is important, what is legitimate, what is reasonable’ ( 1 975: 9). By implication then, any process of shifting paradigms cannot be a simple proccss.Tollcfson (1 991 ) suggests that the intellcctual belief system an individual may adhere to is often not seen as a particular s e t of lenses; i.c. individuals may hold to particular ideologies without evcn recognizing that there is something subjective about these idcologies. Thus before any shift in ideologics can comc about, the first step must be to recognize and name the paradigm to which one has bccn intellcctuallp socialized. [. . .] It is possible to see the introduction of a new paradigm into the intellectual arena as similar to thc diffusion o f an innovation into a particular setting. In thc social sciencc literature that explores attributes of innovations, Rogers (1 983) examines variahles affecting the rate a t kvhich innovations are adopted. One is o f particular relevance to this discussion if the WE paradigm can be considercd an innovation. Rogers terms this variable ‘perceived attributes of [an] innovation’ (1 983: 233). The five facets of this variablc are compatibility, relative advantage, complcxity, trialability, antl obscrvahility. Rogers suggests that compatibility ofthc new idea with current idcas (or paradigms) antl with client needs (in this case teacher and learner needs) affects whether thc new idea is adopted. An exploration of currcnt idcas in TESOL reveals two frameworks incompatible with an underlying framework in thc WE paradigm IvhichVavrus (1 99 1 a) terms the ‘Dynamic Paradigm’ .To avoid confusion, h o cr, the term ‘perspective’ will be used instead of paradigm. Much of the underlying theory in the WE paradigm belongs to what Vavrus ( 1 99 1 a , 199 111) calls the ‘Dynamic’ perspective, a framemnrk in which non-native varieties of English arc sccn neither as fossil-ridden examplcs of interlanguagcs, nor as inferior cxamples of incorrect speech. She suggests that most language teaching fraine\vorks may lie characterired as belonging to one of t\vo perspectives. The Deviational perspective supports the notions that all errors arc due to fossilization or to learners being at various stages of interlanguage transfer.Thc Deficit perspective supports the notion that errors occur because learners arc deficient in their command of English. Neither the Deficit nor Ileviational perspectives arc compatible with the Dynamic pcrspcctive. The lack of compatibility tictwccn these thi-ec pcrspecti\es thus affccts the rate at which thcWE paradigm may tic adopted. Until cducators hccomc more aware of the reasons for adopting a WE paradigm or of thc conse‘quenccs of not adopting it, they may resist this innovation. The remaining elements in Rogers’ pcrccivetl attributes of innovations arc rclatiw advantage, complexity, trialaliility, and ohscrvability. Relative advantage refers to a pcrception that the new idea is better than prcvious ones. Complexity is sclf-explanatory. Rogers suggests that if an idea is n as being too complex, it \vi11 not lie atlopted.Trialaliility rcfcrs to ‘the tlegrec to which a nnovation may be experimented with on a limited liasis’ (1 983: 231). Research suggests that if individuals can work with a new idea on a trial basis, they may lie more likcly to adopt it. Finally, ohscruability refers to how visible an innovation is. If individuals arc quite familiar with an idca, they are more likcly A t the present time, the WE paradigm docs not clearly po compatibility, and ob \-ability. I do not bclicve the WE pcrspcctiv . But much of the early work in World Englishcs is not in a userthan other perspccti friendly format for c room teacher educators. This does affect the trialability factor. (. . .] Hamnctt et a / . (1984) discuss thrcc elements that have a direct connection to nce of the WE perspective in TESOL prcparatory programs. Thc first is thcoretic indigenization ‘in Lvhich the social scientists of a nation are involved in constructing distinctive conceptual framc\vorks and mctatheories that reflect their om-n world vie\\ s,
theoretic indigenization would involve the crcation and refinement of thcory. A t thc present time, these parameters arc well developed (scc Kachru, 1992a).Therc does appear, however, to be a problem with access to antl availability ofinformation.This problem will be discussed more thoroughly in a later section of the paper. Another aspect of the theoretical dimension of the WE perspective is also presented by Lincoln, who looks at the politicization of the research process and suggests that at the present time ‘some groups and research models [are] favored over others, with some definitions of problems morc acceptable than others with avenues to funding and support clcarly discriminatory’ ( 1 990: 70). The second is structural indigenization, defined ‘with rcfcrence to national institutional and organizational capabilities for social science knowledge [including capabilities for] educational and research institutions, a community of indigenous scholars, and locally produced social science literature’ (Hamnrtt et a l . , 1984: 78).Within the WE perspective, in Outer Circle countries, i.e., those countrirs once colonized by England o r the USA and who use o r have used English for intra-country purposes (Kachru, 1 988), structural indigenization would involve thc development of institutions which sponsor a particular type of research, the development o f scholars committed to working within the WE paradigm, and the development of locally produced WE literature and empirical o r qualitative studies. In Inner Circle countries, i.e. the USA, UK, Australia, New Zcaland, o r Canada (Kachru, 1988), the structural challenge is to support the development of young scholars from Outer Circle and also Expanding Circle countries (Kachru, 1988), i.c. those countries in which English has been taught as a foreign language, who will return home to promote structural changes in how English is taught, antl to support Inner Circle scholars developing collaborative frameworks with Outcr and Expanding Circle colleagues for their teaching. For cxample, the cooperative small group antl pair work in communicative language settings is a standard concept promoted in most TESOL Methods courses. In many O u t e r and Expanding Circle countries, large classes and a standardized Ministry of Education curriculum which prepares students for college-level entrance exams are common. Small group o r pair work may be proscribed. Having successful teachers from these large classroom settings prepare lcssons on how to teach large classes, which could then he infused into current Methods c o w . , would hclp Inner Circle teachers learn from O u t e r and Expanding Circle colleagues. The third element in Hamnett et al.’s text involvx substantive indigenization, which is ‘concerned with the content focus o f the social sciences [such that] the main thrust of research and teaching in a country be toward its own society and people and their economic and political institutions’ (1 984: 78). Within the WE perspective, substantive indigenization would call for the development in Outer and Expanding Circle countries of’ their own research and teaching focus. The challenge in Inner Circle teacher preparatory programs would be to encourage Outer and Expanding Circle students to return home to conduct research on topics and with agendas that may not have been those suggested in basic research design courses. A further challenge would be to prcpare Inner Circle students planning on teaching overseas to understand and appreciate the integrity of the possible alternative planning frameworks they would be working under. Shifting paradigms in TESOL programs is a difficult task. Individuals who have completed their own profcssional preparation under one paradigm may not see a reason to shift. It is necessary for those scholars who have called for the paradigm shift to see themselves as change agents and to actively engage in effective promotion efforts so that teacher educators and practitioners in the held can understand the perceived attributes of the WE perspective. This promotion process may involve contributing to the development of WE
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS
111
theory and collaborating with colleagues in Outer and Expanding Circle countries to support the tlevelopmcnt of indigenous institutions, scholars, literature, and empirical or qualitatkc studies. Further, it may involve bringing to the attention of scholars in Inncr Circle countries details of the current research and teaching focus of English language cducation programs in Outer Circle and Expanding Circle countries. Many efforts on US campuses to ‘internationalize’thc curriculum have drawn upon an injusion model in which supplementary units on particular topics are worked into cxisting curricula. [. . .] In addition to the overall difficulties with respect to any paradigm shift or curricular innovation, there arc at least five other possible impediments: amount of time necessary for truc diffusion of scholarship; student and instructor background schemata; text availability and level of difficulty; supporting material availability; and workshop and short-term courscwork availability for Methods instructors.
Time for diffusion of scholarship There are currently two major centers in the USA \\here scholars are conducting extensive research in World Englishcs, at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) and a t the East-West Center (connected to the University of Hawaii at Manoa) in Honolulu. By extension, Methodology courses taught in these centers are likely to incorporate the WE perspective. A second generation of scholars who have graduated from these institutions are teaching a third generation of teachers and scholars to incorporate such a perspective in institutions from upstate New York to Indiana to California. Other scholars who havc begun to publish extensively in this ficld havc come to places like UIUC antl the East-West Ccntcr for short periods of time antl have returned to teaching positions throughout the world. Even in Outer Circle countries, though, it has only been recently that master’s students in language education have been encouraged to conduct their research from hzithin the WE perspective. For example, Robert Raumgardner, an cxpcrt in thc ficld of Pakistani English, writes that in Pakistan, the first master’s degree paper to look at a WE issue was presented in 1985 (personal communication). Research being conducted around the world may not make its way into mainstream journals for three to five years after its coniplction. Anthologics of matcrial publishcd by places like the Regional English Language Centre (supported through SEAMEO) arc not publicized in materials catalogues that most teachers in US T E S O L programs have ready access to. When multiple copies of texts arc requested from halfway around the world, many Inner Circle bookstores balk at filling orders because of currcncy exchange difficulties and policies which prohibit them from ordering materials from other countries.
Student and instructor background schemata Many stutlcnts cntcring TESOL programs havc not had any prior cxpcricnccs identifying paradigms and ideologies. They may not have been trained in identifying their underlying assumptions cultural and paradigmatic, pedagogical, o r personal. They arc not critical readers in thc scnsc that they haw not bccn asked to read material in linguistics and language cducation in order to categorize the ideology of thc authors. One explanation for this is that much of the writing students cncountcr is heavily centered in what R. Paulston (1 976) calls the ‘equilibrium paradigm’, e.g., structural-functionalist and systems theories as contrasted with theories in the ‘conflict paradigm’, e.g. Freirian, Marxist, o r nco-Marxist theories. The rhetoric in structural-functionalist and systems theories is less readily ~
112 K I M B E R L E Y B R O W N identifiable. To ask students to consider making a paradigm shift when they cannot yet identify paradigms is problematic. International students in TESOL programs may sometimes possess low self-esteem regarding thcir o\vn language proficiency and, as Ihxtcr (1 980) points out, may never have had the chance to reflect upon antl respond affirmatively to the question ‘Arc you a speaker of English?’To identify thcir oxvn idcologics and move to a point of grcatcr acceptance of whatever their variety of English may bc comes at the expense of the amount of time necessary to absorb such a perspective. Just as it may lie difficult for students to name the ideologies and planning frameworks they work under, it may also lie difficult for their teachers. Paradigm shifts cannot be made when people do not overtly idcntify paradigms which currently dominate the field. Both Tollefson ( 1 991) and f’hillipson ( 1 992) deal extensively with this issue in their texts.
Text availability and level of difficulty Three of the most popular Methods texts, Cclcc-Murcia (1991), Brown (1987), antl Long and Richards (1 987), devote one chaptvr or less to the concept of World Englishes. In Celce-Murcia, there is no mcntion at all ofanything related toworld Englishes. In Brown (1 987), while there is rcfermce made to Kachru, and the institutionalized vcrsus performance varieties of English, the total number of words is less than 200. In Long and Richards (1 987), one chapter by Judd defines the term ‘English as an International and Intranational’ language. There is no chapter dealing specifically with the concept of institutionalized versus performance varieties of English, the role of native and non-native speakers of English, or any of the points highlightctl by Kachru ( 1 992a) as bcing central to WE theory. Five other concepts Ivhich need to 1)c rc-examined within traditional Methods courses if a WE perspectives is infused into the curriculum arc the presentation of instrumental antl integrative functions of language without introducing the expressive (Pride, 1979) function of language; the presentation of interlanguage continuum inlormation and its relationship to sociolinguistic continuum information; terminology used to refer to the teaching we do; thc role ofnative spcakcrs in instruction in the Outer Circle (i.c. E X countries like India, Nigeria, Malaysia, and Ghana) antl the Expanding Circle (i.c. EFL countries like Japan, Germany, antl Brazil); antl approaches antl techniques for helping students from Outer Circle countries versus students from Expanding Circle countries improve the international intelligibility of their varieties of English. Most introductory M<>thoclstexthooks cover instrumental and integrative reasons for learning a language (Gardner and Lambert, 1972). Choosing to learn a language for the purpose of expressing one’s identity or choosing to \\.rite in Filipino English or Malaysian English to express certain \vays of being and knolving arc not cxamined in traditional Methods texts. [. . . ] In units on second languagc acquisition, the interlanguage continuum concept which, as Vavrus ( I 991 a) noted, is part of the Deviational perspective is usually not presented in conjunction with information \vhich is part of the Dynamic perspective. Terminology referring to the teaching of English still falls most consistently into the polar terms English as a Second Language (ESL) and English as a Foreign Language (EFL). Until the time when more inclusive alternative terms are used, lie they ‘English as an International Language’ or, as Canadian colleagues have long practiced, ‘English as an Additional Language’ , attitudes toward Inner Circle, Outer Circle, and Expanding Circle varieties of
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS
113
English are not likely to change. Speakers of Outer Circle and Expanding Circle varieties of English in the program where I teach continuously remark on the lack of relevance of some material in stantlard Mcthods courses to their ncctls in their countries. Kegarding materials xvhich focus exclusively on World Englishes, Giirlach states ‘the books published in 1982-84 make up a particularly impressive list: it is no cxaggcration to say that the following ten books more or less sufticc to teach a full academic course on thc topic [ofWorld Englishes]’ (1 991 : 1 l).Yct one ofthc Kachru texts, The Indianiyation ofEnglish (1 983), would not be ordered as a class text by some US collcgc bookstores because the text is published outside the USA; and Kachru (ed.), The Other Tongue: English Across Cultures was out of print until just recently, and a revised cdition with substantial changes has just been published (see Kachru, ed., 1992b). Another Kachru text, The Alchemy $ English (1 986), is too difficult for most undergraduate Methods students, although with stud: questions and referral to Richards et d . ’ s 1985 Dictionaiy $Applied Linguistics, currently also out of print, students can manage. Platt et a/.’s The New Englishes (1 984) as m.cll as Pride’s 1982 New Englishes arc out of print. Gorlach’s 1991 volume Englishes: Studies in Varieties pf English, 1984-1 988 is published by John Benjamin; one of its representativcs at the 1992 American Association of Applied Linguistics meeting in Seattle commented that this publishing tirm docs not exhibit at international TESOI, meetings as it is not Lvorth their financial while.Teacher educators attending a key meeting in their lield would thus not have access to this text to even peruse for potential course adoption. Finally, even chapters dealing with World Englishes in fine texts such as Rerns (1 990) have been termed ‘too difficult’ by some teacher educators for use with undergraduate students.
Supporting material availability Often, instructors mill assign research papers o r annotated bibliographies on World Englishes topic. Over the past three years, when such assignments have been made in our Mcthods classes, at least one or two students per quarter have decided to research topics such as the ‘Non-native English speaking teacher’. Resources such as ERIC list few references on WE. Difficulty in obtaining articles reflecting a WE perspective deters students from pursuing these topics. A cursory comparison of US library holdings via an on-line search through the Online Computer Library Ccnter (OCLC) and Research Library Information Network ( R U N ) of eight journals, six of which routinely publish articlcs reflecting the WE perspective antl t\vo of which sometimes publish articles in this arca (TESOI. Quarterk and journal $Applied Linguistics), r als significant diffcrcnccs in the number of journals availahlc throughout the USA. In addition to the TESOI. QuarterbJ antl the journal ofApplied Linguistics, the other journals include English Toduy, English I~/orldivicic, World Englishes, the RELC j o u r n a l , the Indian Journal of Lingtiisrics, and the Indian Journal of Applied Linguistics (sccTablc 9.1). As Table 9.1 illustrates, there is a very evident accessibility prohlcm. Journals which consistently carry WE perspective articlcs are much lcss availahlc to teachers and students inTESOL programs than arc other journals. This portion of the paper has examined structural impediments to infusing a WE pcrspcctivc in current TESOL programs. The next portion of thc paper documents \vhy it is critically important to \vork to infuse a WE perspective in the Methods sequence.
114 KIMBERLEY BROWN Table 9. I Journals publishing articlcs on World Englishcc topics ]ournu/
A'wnhcr ofstates
.Ytirnhcr ofinytitutions
TESOL Qiarterly
46 42 44 32 26 26 11 9
384 I23 64 68 57
Journal of'.4pplicd Linguistic5
English Today Ilbrld Englishrs English Ilbrldwidc REI C Journal lndian Jotirnal of Linpisrics Indian Journal ?f,lppliecl I inguistict
55 13 14
Student responses in coursework The following excerpt is from aTESL certificate student paper; the student was exposed to less than four hours of information rclatctl to World Englishrs in ninety hours of Methods courses. [SampleA ] The lack of TEFL-specific materials may lie a result o f a hclicf that most EFI. teachers should themselves be non-nativcs [i.c. non-native speakers o f English] with the result being that thc majority of tcaching matcrials are in the teachers' native languagcs, not English. But i f a person who has learned English from a non-native then teaches EFL to yet someonc else, the English of the last learner may lie far removed in quality from that of a native. . . . cr, more EFI. teachers kvcre native speakers, then more TEFLspccific materials in English \voultl be tlemandcd and produced. Also, the matcrials might bc of better quality, giving thc quality of EFL tcaching more of a chance to improve . . . TEFL materials oricntcd toward native English speakers will help thcm to give clear explanations of what they already know. A native speaker is better able to combine his or her inherent knoivlcdgc with the information provided in an EFL textbook to give a more comprehensive grammatical explanation. However, this is hest achieved if the textbook is written \vith the cxpcctation that the user will be a native. Another lienefit from having a nativc speaker teach English is that students get more exposure to English, especially when interacting with the teacher outside the classroom. A teacher whose native languagc is also the students' native language is more likely to converse hvith them in that language when class is not in session, whereas practice with a native English-spcaking teacher outside of a stressful classroom, where performance will not be graded, can be most helpful.
The second sample was written by an individual who had complctcd ninety hours in a Methods course and thirty hours in a World Englishes class. [Sample B] As a result of the reading and thought involved in doing this paper, I now believe that as part ofthc shift being made in ESLIEFL teaching to accommodate needs for English as an international language rather than a language used only to communicate with
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS
115
native or very proficient speakers from countries whcrc English is learncd as a first languagc, \ve need to shift or perhaps, more properly, expand our views of reading. We nccd to extend learncrs’ knowledge of literacy antl reading rather than changc it, lvhich I believe lve often implicitly if not explicitly attempt to do through our methodology antl ethnocentric view as middle-class, gcncrally white educators for a post industrial countrj. . , . As a result of this paper, I have also come to realize that in my own teaching o f reading, I have too heavily emphasized U.S. mainstream reading styles antl strategies lvhich may lie of littlc usc to students learning English as a world or international language, and who arc most likely to read knglish written by writcrs not using discourse or newspaper styles Ivhich are predominant in the U.S. The comments made in the first papcr are geocentric, i.e., focused on Inner Circle countries’ English, antl rcflcct an attitude o f linguicism. Skutnabb-Kangas and Phillipson in I’hillipson (1 922: 47) dcfinc linguicism as: idcologier, structures, and practices n hich are used t o Icgitimatc, effectuate, and reproduce an unequal c l i i~ m n of pomer and resources (both material and immaterial) liet\\ ccn groups \\ hich are tlcfincd on the basis of language. The comments in thc second papci- are much less ethnocentric and reflect an attitudc of tolerance antl respect for multiple varieties of English. Both individuals are leaving the same TESL certificate program. In the first case, I held an cxtensivc conference with the student to indicate \\.hat I found prohlrmatic in many ofthc statements and lines of argument of thc paper. 1 lielicw the confcrcnce was useful, but as the culture contact litcrature revcals, siinply having individuals with two different pcrspectives mcct to talk about ideas may not result in long-term attitude changc. [. . . ] [. . .] It is possible for a paradigm shift to occur. However, necessary resources to facilitate such shifts ncctl to find their way into Methods textbooks and Methods courses. Much work remains to be (lone at thc structural and substantive levels. A n infusion model o f curricular revision is the most practical means to diffusc the innovation inherent in the World Englishes paradigm. The folloxving recommendations arc also key elements in promoting the diffusion of this perspective within Methods courses and ivithout.
Recommendations Languagc education preparatory programs must name the paradigmatic frameworks lve work under. We must activcly comllat linguicisrn and gcocentrism, particularly institutional linguicism, charactcrixed by structures which promote inequality. Wc must help promotc a diversity of perspcctives, not only a perspective which suggests that the native speaker of an Inncr Circle variety of English is the most appropriate professional language educator. Professional language education organizations and their respective journals must continue to provide a forum for oral and \vrittcn dialoguc, e.g. within TESOL: the TESOL Quarterh:, the TESOL journal, the TESOL international conference, and the TESOL summer institute. In like manner forums should be provided with IATEFL: International Association ofTcachrrs of English as a Foreign Languagc, and NAFSA: Association of Intcrnational Educators.
116 K I M B E R L E Y B R O W N
5 6
7 8
Professional language education organizations should work t o crcatc a resource bank of World Englishcs scholars antl materials. Professional language education organizations should promote mid-carccr professional cxchange to bring World English scholars as tcachers to Inner Circle teacher preparatory programs tor one or tlvo tcrms. I’rofcssional language education organizations should support activities which hclp lireak down structural Imrricrs t o promoting an infusion model of curricular reform. Puldishing houses and authors of kc? texts in English language education programs should liroadcn thcir rcpcrtoirc of citations.
References Raxtcr; Jarncs ( 1 980) ‘Ho\v shoul(l I s p k English! American-I!, Japanese-ly, or internationally!’ ].ILTjournul, 2, 3 1-61 . Rcrns, Margic ( 1 990) Conlexts of Competence: Sociill anti Culrurul Consitlerirtion.~in Communicative L ang tiuge Euc h ing . N civ Yor k : Plcnum . HroTvn, H. Douglas (1 987) Principlec clf’Lungticigc I.ccirning and Teciching. 2nd edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prenticc-Hall Kcgcnts. Cclcc-Murcia, Marianne, cti. ( 1 991) Teuching English us u Second or Foreign lunguuge. NenYork: N c d u r y House. Gai-dncr, Kichartl and Lambert, Wallacc ( 1 972) .il/itridcs antl .Ilotirotion in Second Lungtiage learning. Rmvley, MA: N c d i u r y HOLISC. Gijrlach, Manfrctl ( 1 991 ) Encq/i.shes: StriJicr in I;lrJe~ie.so/’ Englirh, 1 Y81 1988. Amsterdam/ Philadelphia: John Benjamin. Hamnctt, Michael, Porter, Douglas, Singh, Amai-jit and Kurnar, Krishna ( 1 984) Ethics, Politics, ant/ lnternotionul Socrcil Science Rcceurch: From Critiyue t o Pruxis. Honolulu, Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press. Kachi-u, Braj R. ( 1 98 3) T h e Inditini/ution o/’En!ylish:T h c English I.ung~icycin India. NC\VDclhi: Oxtord Univcrsity I’rcss. Kachru, Rraj B. ( 1 986) T h e ,4/chcn;i. ?f’English: T h e Spread, Function.r, ant1 Models ?f Non-l\ative Englirher. Oxford: I’ergamon Press. (I
1111. 67-87. Long, Michacl antl Richards, Jack, c d s . ( 1987) .Ilcthotlol0~7,v in TESOL: ,4 Book ?f’Reatlings. Nc\v York: Newbury I Iousc. Patton, M. ( 1 975) .iltcrnutir~eEinlticition Rcsecirch Pcirc~c1rgm.s.Grand Forks, N D : University oi‘ North Dakota Prcss. I’aulston, Rollantl ( 1976) C o ? f l i c t i n ~Theories ~ ofSociul ‘inti kdiicc7tional Change:,/l $pological Review. I’ittslm-gh, PA: University Ccntci- Ibr International Studies. I’hillipson, Robert ( 1 992) Lingriistic Imperiulism. I .ondon: Oxford Univcrsity Press. Platt, John, Weber, Heidi and Lian, H . ( 1 984) The .\en, Englishes. London: Routledge.
WORLD ENGLISHES I N TESOL PROGRAMS
117
Pride, John ( 1 979) ‘Communicatirc needs in the usc and learning of English’. In .YewVarieriec ?f English: I.s.sucs and i1pproachc.s. Etlitcd by Jack Richards. Singapore: SkAMEO Rcgional I.anguagc Centre, pp. 33 72. Pride, John, ed. ( 1 982) New .knglishcs. l
Chapter 1 0
Numa Markee T H E D I F F U S I O N OF I N N O V A T I O N I N LANGUAGE TEACHING
Introduction
T
H E LAST T W O D E C A D E S I N A P P L I E D L I N G U I S T I C S -whichroughlv coincide with thc evolution of the communicative approach in language teaching have seen the tlevelopmcnt of a numhcr of languagc tcaching innovations, including the notional/ functional syllabus, the process syllabus, the Natural Approach, the procedural syllabus, and task-based languagc teaching. All of these proposals have contributed in important ways to an understanding of theorctical issues related to designing innovative language syllabuses. Rut it is onl? rather rcccntly that applied linguists have hrgun to investigate the problcms associated n i t h implcmcnting thcsc innovations. Indeed, with the exception of such pionecrs as White (1 988), Henrichsen (1 989), and a number of other hvritcrs, not many language tcaching spccialists h a w developed any familiarity with the voluminous literaturc that already exists in a number of disciplines on how and why innovations tliffuse.This is unfortunate Iwcausc, as Kenncdy (1 988) and Beretta (1 990) demonstrate, a ‘tliffusion~of~innovations’ perspective on syllabus design provides curriculum spccialists, materials dewlopcrs, and tcachcrs mith a coherent set of guiding principles for the development and implemcntation of language teaching innovations. Furthermore, it supplies evaluators with critcria for retrospcctive evaluations of the extent to which thesc innovations have actually been implemcnted. In other words, this perspective provides a unified framework for conceptualizing both the development and evaluation of innovations in language teaching. Thus, although the terminology used may at first sound cxotic and unfamiliar, a diffusion-of-innovations pcrspectivc on syllabus design, for example, addresses concerns that arc central to all language tcaching specialists. In contrast to applied linguistics, education alrcady po c s a well-cstablished tradition of innovation rcsearch and practice (Fullan 1982, Miles 1964, Nicholls 1983, Kudduck 1991), as do such disciplines as sociology (Rogers 1983), urban planning (Lambright and Flynn 1980), and language planning (Cooper 1989).7’hus, a rcviekv o f t h c issues that define innovation in thc specific contcxt of language teaching nil1 draw on these academic specializations to dcvelop a multi-disciplinary framework, inspired particularly by Cooper’s work on innovation in language planning. The framework for this discussion consists of the following composite qucstion: “Who adopts what, where, when, why and how?” (Cooper 1989), with responses to each individual componcnt o f the question. In this w y , the basic issues
T H E D I F F U S I O N OF I N N O V A T I O N
119
that are of intcrcst to practitioners may be defined. This framework should be sufficiently encompassing to account for practitioners who wish to engage in any innovation related to language education.
On defining innovation: “who” Teachers arc kcy playcrs in any attempt to promote innovations in syllabus design. At thc same time, other individuals will also be involved in the innovation process (Fullan 1982). The actual participants who become involved in deciding whcthcr an innovation will be adopted vary from context to context. Whatever the specific context of implcmcntation, however, participants tend to assumc certain social roles which define their rclationships with othcr participants. The urban planners, Lamhright and Flynn ( 1 980), have suggested that individuals relate to each othcr as adopters, implementers, clients, supplicrs, o r entrepreneurs (also known as change agents). Kcnncdy (1 988) suggests that, in thc context o f a materials project inTunisia, ministry of education officials, deans, heads of dcpartmcnt, and others play the role of adoptcrs; teachers are implementcrs; students are clients; curriculum and materials designers are suppliers; and the expatriate curriculum cxpcrt acts as the change agent. As Kennedy points out, in practice these roles arc not mutually exclusive. Indeed, it is quite likely that the samc person will play different roles, somctimes simultaneously, somctimes at varying times during the course of a project. Thus, teachers may at times also be regarded as adopters; furthermore, in some cultures, they may take on the roles of change agents and suppliers. With the exception of thc change agent, any of these individuals may also adopt thc role o f resisters who oppose an innovation. Thus, a broad range of people playing out different social roles is always involved in the design and implementation of any innovation.
“Adopts” Adoption has been conceptualized in terms of individuals o r institutions engaging in a decision-making process which may be divided into a number of different phases. Rogers (1 983), a rural sociologist who is onc of the leading authorities on the diffusion of innovations, suggests that there are five steps in this decision-making process.Thesc involvc potential adopters 1 ) gaining knowledge about an innovation, 2) bcing persuaded of its d u e , 3) making a preliminary decision to adopt the innovation, 4) implementing their decision to adopt, and 5) confirming their decision to continue using thc innovation. The educator Fullan (1 982) proposes a slightly different sequence of four steps which he calls initiation, implementation, continuation, and outcome. From an evaluator’s perspective, adoption may also be conceptualized in terms of“leve1s of implementation,” a measurc which specifics thc depth to which any changes have occurred. Berctta (1 990), for examplc, in his evaluation of the procedural syllabus (Prahhu 1987), uses this notion to evaluate thc extent to which tcachers actually implemented thr task-based methodology associated with that syllabus. Lack of space precludes detailed discussion of Keretta’s rcsults, hut it is noteworthy that only 4 7 percent of the teachers involved in implementing the procedural syllabus reached what Beretta catcgorizied as an “adcquate” level of implementation; only 1 3 percent reachrtl what ma! I)r considered an “expert” levcl of implementation.This result shows how difficult it is to promotc innovation at a fundamental level. I t is salutary to remember that all innovation is a risky business and that close to three quarters of educational innovations arc likely to fail over time (Adams and Chcn 198 I ) , either because they arc never fully adopted or else do not survive the confirmation stage posited by Rogers (1 98 3).
120 N U M A M A R K E E
“What” Innovation itself, as a concept, is central to the implementation and/or evaluation of n c w ideas and ne\v procedures. Synthesizing what she claims are basic characteristics of innovations, Nicholls states: An innovation is an idea, object or practice perceived as ne\v by an individual o r individuals, which is intended to bring about improvement in relation to desired objectives, which is fundamental in naturc and which is planned and deliberate
(1983: 4). However, in language teaching contexts, her definition is somewhat problematic. For the purposes o f this paper, innovation \vi11 be defined as proposals for qualitative change in pedagogical materials, approaches, and values that arc perceived as new by individuals who comprise a formal (language) education system. Nicholls’ idea of“ncwncss”bcing a subjcxctivc matter of users’ perceptions is important in languagc teaching contexts.This perspective correctly permits the inclusion of the Natural Approach as an innovation despite the fact that Krashen antl Terrell (1983) view this approach simply as a rcdi )very of the underlying principles of traditional “natural” or direct methods popular earlier in this century suitably reformulated and updatcd in light of current second language acquisition rcscarch findings. While Krashen and Terrell’s asscssmcnt of the absolute innovativeness of their proposals is accurate, there is no doubt that from a user’s perspective, the Natural Approach was regarded as an innovation by teachers in the early 1980s. It continues to be viewed in this light by new teachers who are introduced to it for the first time today. r, in terms o f the ti\ c examples of language teaching innovations \vc have alrcady idcntiticd in the introduction (the notional /functional syllabus, the proccss syllabus, the Natural Approach, the proceclural syllabus, and task-based language teaching), the remaining components of Nicholls’ definition arc either too restrictive o r clsc omit defining criteria that are important for languagc teaching situations. Therefore, the alternative definition given above is more appropriate to language teaching contexts.The need for this alternative definition is suggested by a critique of Nicholls with respect to the follokving four issues: 1 ) the systemic context of innovations; 2 ) the fundamental naturc of innovations; 3) thc cxtcnt to which innovations actually improve o n the status quo; and 4) the cxxtcnt to which inno\-ations are necessarily dc~libc-rateantl planned for. First, the systemic contcxt in hvhich an innolation is implemented scc‘ms to be an important dctermincr o f whether or not the innovation will IIC adopted. As Prabhu (1 987) points out, the fact that a procedural syllabus u a s implcmcntcd in primary antl secondary schools in India placed some major constraints on the project since it was decided that thc procedural syllabus should not be used ivith students who hvcrc due to take various state matriculation exams. By omitting any specific mention of the systemic contcxt of innovations, Nicholls lays herself open to bcing interpreted as saying that individuals are frcc to innovate as they wish. Clearly, individuals do not enjoy such a degree of freedom. This observation suggests that the relationship lietween individuals antl systems must be considered in a dctinition of innovation. Second, it is only through a modification of pedagogical values that innovation can be said to involve “funtlamental” change. At the less complex levels of using new materials and approaches, teachers can adopt ncw practices with littlc or n o undcrstanding of why they arc using these new materials antl approaches which hardly counts as a fundamental ~
THE DIFFUSION OF INNOVATION
121
alteration in behavior. This limitation d o c s not mean that such surface changes arc not in any sense innovative nor that they cannot lead to deeper change later. Furthermore, the “inno\.ativencss” of an innovation decreases o\ er time as it lieconics institutionalixtl antl more familiar t o u s c ~ s .Iior example, notional/functional syllabuses wcrc initially claimcd to be 1Lintlamrntally diff‘crcnt from structural syllabuses bccause languagc contcnt was organized in semantic rather than syntactic tcrms. Ho\\.c\cr, it \vas soon recognized that, although notional /functional syllabuses arc indccd qualitatii ely different from structural syllabuses, all the criteria for organizing the contcnt o f instruction in both types of syllabus (i.e. , notions, functions, grammatical structures, wcabular!; r t c . ) are still linguistic (Long and Crookes 1992). Consequently, it is difficult to argue that the re-orientation implied by notional/functional syllahuscs is fundamental in any meaningful sense of this w-ord.‘l‘hus, it is liettcr t o dctinc innovations in t c r m s o f qualitative change, a t e r m ivhich conveniently covers all three lei-cls of innovative Iiehavior (materials, approaches, and values). ‘I‘hird, although innovations arc certainly intentled to improve on the status quo, it is not the casc that thev al\vavs do constitutc an improvement o n previous practicc ( I d l a n 1982). For example, Urumfit ( 1 98 1 ; 1984a) has sharply criticized notional/functiorial syllaliuses as bcing in some instances an untlcsirahlc innovation. He argues that ivhcn thc syllabuscs arc uncritically implemented, they dcprivc learners of the generative potential of grammar (i.c., the ability t o use sjntactic rules to crcatc nciv sentences), \vhicli Bruintit indispensable resource for learning. This criticism suggests that improvcmcnt rily a defining characteristic of innovations in actual practice. Indccd, in some cases, innovations should be rcsistctl rathcr than promoted because their adoption may lie m o r e harmful than bcncticial. Fourth, and finally, the notion of “delihcratc planning” is problematic for languagc teaching in t \ v o \Yay. I;irst, although the notional/functional syllabus is indeed a product ofcxtensive planning, the only aspect ol‘a project that can hc planned is \vhat is to be taught or tcstcd, n o t lvhat is to he learned (Urumfit 198411). Second, it is doubtful that the articulation of the principles of t h c procrdural syllabus, ivhich \vas achieved through a process of trial antl error (Prabhu 1987), can rcally count as an rxamplc of tlclibcr-ate planning. [. . .]
“Where” T h e question of where an innovation is implemented is conceived in sociocultural t c r m s (Cooper 1989). That is, the concrrn is lvith specifying t h c sociocultural contcxt of an innovation rather than its geographical location. Practitioncrs w h o \z ish to introduce innovative syllabuses into an educational em must rccognizc the potential impact (lvhcthcr positivc or negative) of n r i o u s soci tural constraints on their acti\-itics. For example, Markee ( 1 986a; 1986b) identifies cultural, ideological, historical, political, economic, administrative, institutional, and sociolinguistic factors that affected the implementation o f an aitl-f‘undctl project in the Sudan. [. . . ] In addition, some attempts have becm made t o address thc issuc of when thosc sociocultural constraints should lie considered in thc Cooke 1982, Munbv 1978; 1984). The relati\e imI anct’ of thesc constraints \vi11 \ a r v from one contcxt of implementation to another. [ . . . ] Expcrience suggests that these constraints cannot Iic accounted h r in a discrete, linear fashion; rather, they \vi11 impinge on all aspects of innovati Ilalius design, implcmcntation, and evaluation.
122 N U M A M A R K E E
“When” While some adopters will implement a given innovation relatively quickly, others will nred more time to carry out the same innovation.Thus, if one knows whcnA adopts an innovation and when B, C, or D adopt the same innmation, it is possible to specify the ratc at which an innovation diffuses among a group of potential adopters and also to distinguish bctw different catcgorics of adopters. Diffusion may be expressed as the perccntagc of adopters who implement an innovation over a g i w n period of time (Kogers 1 98 3). Figure 10.1 shows a typically S-shaped diffusion curvc.Thc lazy slope of the toe of the curve sho\vs that adoption at first occurs very slowly; if a critical mass of approximatel: 2 5 percent of potential adopters accept the innovation, it may take off. At this point, the slope in the midsection of the curvc bccomcs stccpcr (i.c., the ratc of adoption accelerates) as people “jump on the band\vagon.” Finally, the curve plateaus as diffusion slo\vs down and cvcntually tapers off, either because every potential adopter has adopted or else I~ecauscthe innovation stalls.
%
of adoption
Figure 10. I An S-shapctl diffusion curvc
With respect to diffusion ratc, fivc catcgorics of adopters h a w been idcntified (Huberman 1973, Rogers 1983).These include innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards; as already noted in thc scction cntitlcd “Who,” people who never adopt a particular innovation are known as resisters. In terms ofthe S-shaped diffusion curve shown in Figure 10.1, innovators antl early adopters occupy the first 25 percent ofthe curve. Early antl late majority occupy the steepest portion of the curve. Laggards occupy the last part of the curve as it flattens out to form a plateau. This information has at least two kinds of potential applications. First, it a l l o w program designers who introduce an innovative syllabus to focus on those teachers most receptive to the innovation. Since each category of adopter tends to be associated with personal characteristics bvhich are either conducive o r not conducive to innovation, recognition of early adoptcrs would hc important to the innovation process. Second, such data allow evaluators to determine how successfully and how quickly an innovation has sprcad among a group of potential adopters.
“Why” The reasons 1% hy innovations are adopted or rcjectctl arc many and varied. The section entitled “Where” already addressed a number of the sociocultural constraints that come into play. In addition, there arc individual psychological factors with respect to the persons involved, and innovations themselves possess various attributes that influence adoption.
T H E D I F F U S I O N OF I N N O V A T I O N
123
Rogers (1 98 3) notes that individuals with particular psychological profilrs tend to display specific adoption behaviors. For example, individuals who adopt early tend to travel widely and are usually \vcll-cducatcd antl upwardly mobile; they tend to seek out and be open to ne\v idcas, and they tend to have a high degree of exposure to mass met1ia.Their contacts with other people are often extensive, antl they are usually able to tolerate high levels of uncertainty. Laggards, on the other hand, tend to display diametrically opposite characteristics while the pcoplc in between exhibit intermediary traits. attributes which tend to promote or inhibit their Finally, innovations themselves po adoption. A number of writers (Bricknrll 1969, Henrichsen 1989, Kelly 1980, I.e\ ine 1980, Zaltman and Duncan 1977) havc proposed different sets of attributes of innovations. The attributes proposed by Rogers ( I 987) arc usctl here because they are derived from some 1,500 empirical and/or theoretical studics on innovations across disciplines antl also because they are the most well-knolvn. Thcse attributes include the following: the relative advantage to potential adoptccs of adopting an innovation (i.c., the co or benefits); the compatibility o f the innovation \vith previous practice (i.c., how different o r similar the innovation is to \\.hat the potential adoptcr already uses); thc complexity of the innovation (i.c., how difficult the inno\ation is t o understand or usr); the trialability of the innomtion (i.c., ho\v easy it is to try out in stages); antl the observability of thc innovation (i.e., hou visible the inno\-ation is).
“How” In Henrichsen’s (1 989) account of the extent to kvhich audiolingualism diffused in Japanese schools in the aftermath of the Second World War, he notes that scveral difrercnt theories exist bvhich seck to account for how change occurs. These include equililirium thcory, evolutionary theory, conflict theory, rise and fall theory, and diffusion theory. Only the last of these is directly relevant to language teaching. Within a diffusion-of-innovations perspective, the cducator I lavelock ( 1971 ) distinguishes bct\reen three basic models of innovation. He laliels these three the Research, tlcrdopment and tlifjiusion (RD anti D) model, the problem-solving model, and t h r social interaction model rcspcctivcly, from Lzhich hc synthcsizcs a hybrid linkuge model. Similarly, the social scientists Chin antl Benne (1 976) idcntifv t h r r r familics of innovation strategies which they respecti\ ely call empirical-r~itionul,normutive-reeciucutirz, antl power-coercive strategies of innovation. These models antl strategies “pair up” and haw lieen used, mostly unconsciously, by developers o f various language teaching innovations. Empirical-rational innovation strategies assume that pcople are rational and \I i l l therefore be persuaded to adopt an innovation if it can he demonstrated that it is in their rational self-intcrcst to do so. Such stratcgics tend to be used by pcople who subscribe to an RD and D model of innovation. A good example of this combination is the initial development of notional/ functional syllahu. by scholars associated \vith the Council of Europe (Wilkins 1976). This model is rational, systematic, and theory-based. I t depends vcry heavily on longterm planning and involvcs a division of labor among teams of highly trained specialists \\ ho 1vot-k on separate phases of an overall project. Thc planning process is basically linear (although fcxdback loops may be built into the framcwork) antl assumes that thc cnd product will be used by a passive, though rational, consumer. Planning hcgins with basic research,
124 N U M A MARI<EE which is then follon.cd liy phases of applied research, development and testing of prototypes, mass production and packaging o f the product, antl finally, mass dissemination to potcntial users. It is assumcd that the high development costs will bc offset by the long-term benefits of efficiency and the anticipated high quality of thc innovation (Havelock 1971 ). A power-coercive innovation strategy which involves the application of political, administrati\e, or economic p v c r to resolve a prolilem may also be used in conjunction with an R D and I) model of innovation. This occurs when a ministry of education decides to develop and disseminate a new syllabus countrywide. A good example of this combination is the adoption of notional/functional syllaliuscs in primary and/or secondary schools by the Dutch and Malaysian ministries o f education. Normative-re-educative strategies arc based on the assumption that uscrs’ decisions arc not exclusively based on rational criteria. Rather, sociocultural and personal value systems arc held to be equally important determinants of behavior. These stratcgics tcnd to bc uscd by intlividuals who lielie\ c in a problem-solving model of innovation. As Havelock (1 971 ) remarks, this is the most faorctl model of innovation in ctlucation, at least hy writers in the United States antl Britain. A good example of this comhination in language teaching is the process syllabus. The problem-solving model is based o n a qualitatively quite different approach to planning from the one uscd in the KD antl 1) model. More specifically, users employ action to articulate a problem and diagnose ho\v thcy n a n t to solve it. This diagnosis is follonul by a search and retrieval phase in \vhich uscrs try to gather whatever information is relevant to their necds and which will enable thcm to formulate and/or select an appropriate innovation. After identifying the innovation, a process of adaptation, trial, antl evaluation follows. During this timc, uscrs assess whether the solution they have devised really solves the problem that sct thc whole pro into motion in the first place. If the users judge that the innovation is deficient or unsatisfactory in any way, thc process liegins again until a satisfactory solution is found (Havelock 1971). Social interaction models of innovation oftcn employ normative-re-educative strategies, certain elements of which underlie Kennedy’s (1 988) work in7unisia.This model emphasizes the importance of social relationships as a key variahle in adoption. Other factors that are stresscd arc noted as follo\vs: 1 ) the position of potcntial atlopters in their social network (i.c., how conncctcd or disconnected thcy arc from pccrs xvho might influence their decision); 2) the role of informal pcrsonal contacts as a functional mechanism for exchanging information ahout innovations; 3) the importance of group membership and referencrgroup identification as predictors o f individual adoption; and 4) the typically S-shaped pattern-of-diffusion curve [ . . .]. l’hc major insight offered liy this model in an educational context is the important role played by communication in promoting or inhibiting the diffusion o f innovative curricula (I Iavclock 1971 ). Finally, there are hybrid, or “linkage” models. Henrichsen points out that: ~
~~
while a [linkage perspective] allows for research and dcvclopmcnt of an innovation, it docs not assume that KL) and L)is all that is recpired for successful implementation of an innovation. Furthermore, a linkage model allows for the ‘dynamic’ of change to lie an outside force, making it appropriate for explaining directed contact change even across cultural boundaries. (1 989: 68)
T H E D I F F U S I O N OF I N N O V A T I O N
125
Conclusion I t has been argued that the adoption of a diffusion-of-innovations perspective by practitioners is crucial to the development of language teaching theory and practice. Such a point o f \ ie\\ provides a unified framework for conceptualizing both the dcvclopmcnt and evaluation of innovations in languagc teaching. In ordrr to illustratc Ivhat issucs arc relevant to understanding a diffusion-of-inno\ ations pcrspcctivc on language teaching, innovation has been analyzed in t e r m s of Cooper’s (1 989) question: “Il’ho udopts what, where, when, rvhj, and how.?” This framchvork providcs an appropriate set of criteria for analysis:
1 2
3 4 5 6
a profile of participants’ socially defined roles and their adoption behaviors; a ctelinition of innovation in the context of language teaching; an account of the sociocultural factors which constrain innovations; a definition of diffusion; an overview of the prrsonal factors which constrain innovations, as \vel1 as the attributes of innovations which either promote or inhibit thcii- adoption; and a synopsis of various innovation models and stratcgics which ma); lie used to promote change in language education.
The most important characteristic of emerging “post communicative” approaches t o approaches which are explicitly based o n a diffusion-of-inno\.ations course design pcrspcctivc is or will be their focus o n t\ro issues: 1 ) the e x t r n t to \z hich teachers actually use new materials and approaches, antl 2) the dcgrce to which they actually reconstruct thrir pedagogical values. This shift of cmphasis from design to implcmcntation antl evaluation is both dcsirable and also long ovcrduc. ~~
Bibliography Atlama, K. and D. Chcn. 198 1 . The process of’ educational ~nnovation:An internutionul pcr.spcctir.c. London: Kogan Page in association with the UNESCO Press. Kcrctta, A . 1990. ‘Implrmcntation of the Bangalore projcct’. Applied Linguistics. 1 1 . 32 1-37. Brickcll, H. M . 1969. ‘Appraising thc cffccts of innovation in local schools’. In K. W.’Ijler (cd.) Educutionul evaltiotion: XCM. roles, new means. Chicago, IL: National Society for thc Stud) of Education. 284-304. R r u m k , C. 198 1 . ‘Notional syllabuses revisited: A response’ . .4pplietl Linguistics. 2 . 90 92. 1984a. Introduction. In C. Brumfit (ed.) Gcnerul English y,llabu.s design. Oxford: Pcrganion. 1-4. [ELT Documents 118.1 19841).‘Function and structure o f a state school syllalms for learners of second or fweign languages with hetcrogcncous needs’. In C. Brumfit (cd .) General English yllahus desi. Kcnnc, R. Chin and K . E. Corcy (cds.) The plunning of’changc, 3rd etl. Ne\vYork: Ilolt, Rinehart and Winston. 2 2 45. Cooper, R. L. 1989. I ungna,cle plunning and social change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Fullan, M . 1982. The meaning oJed~c~7r1onal chonge. NenYork:Tcachcrs College Prcas. Havclock, R. G. 1971. ‘Thc utilization of educational research and tlcvclopmrnt’. British journal ?f Educational Echnologj,. 2.84 97. Henrichscn, L. E. (1 989). Dijfiision !finnovations In English language teaching: The ELEC effort in Japan, 1956-f 968. New York: Grecnwood Press. Holliday,T. antl C. Cooke. 1982. ‘An ecological approach to ESP’. In A . Waters (etl.) /.ss.sues in ~-
~
126 N U M A M A R K E E
ESP. Oxford: Pcrgamon Press. I24 143. [ Lancaster Practical Papers in English Language Education 5.1 Huberman, A. M. 1973. llndersranding change in cducation:iin introtluction. Paris: OECD. Kelly, P. 1980. ‘From innovation to adaptability: The changing perspective of curriculum tlrvelopmcnt’ . In M. Galton (etl.) Curriculum change: Thc lessons of a ticcade. Izicester: Leicester Univcrsity Press. 65--80. Kennedy, C. 1988. ‘Evaluation of thc management of change in LLT projects’. Applied linguistic.^. 9(4). 329-42. Krashen, S. and T.Terrell. 198 3. 7he ncirurcil approach. Nc\vYork: Pergamon. Lambright, W. H. and P. Flynn. 1980. ‘ T h c rolc o f local burcaucracy-centered coalitions in technology transfcr to the city’. In J. A . Agile\\ (ed.) Innovation research and public p o l i y . Syracuse, NY: Syracusc University Press. 243---282. [Syracuse Geographical Series No. 5.1 l.evine, A . 1980. LIyhy innorrrtion fiiils. Alhany, NY: State Llnivcrsity of NclzYork Press. Long, M. I I. and G. Crookes. 1992. ‘Three approaches t o task-liasctl syllabus design’. TESOI. QiiarterLv. 26.27-56 . Male?, A. 1984. ‘Constraints-bascd syllabuscs’. In J. A . S . Read (cd.) Trends in language .yllahns design. Singapore: SEAMEO-RF1.C. 90 1 1 I . Markee, N. 1986.3. The importancc of sociopolitical factors to communicative course design. The ESP Journal. 5 . 3 16. 198611 ‘Toward an appropriate technology model o f communicative course design’. EnglishJor SpccJfic Purposes. 5 . 1 6 1 1 72. Milcs, M. B. 1964. ‘Educational innovation: The naturc of the problem'. In M. R. Milcs (cd.) Innovution in education. Ne\\ York: Teachers College Press. 1 4 8 . Munhy, J. 1978. Coinmunicutii,c ~i.llcihustlcsign. Cambritlgc: Cambritlgc University Press. 1984. ‘Communicative ~ v l l a l i u sdesign: I’rinciplcs antl prohlcms’ . In 1. A. S. Read (et!.) Trentls in language .;r//ahos design. Singapore: SLAMLO-RLLC. 5 5 67. Nicholls, A . 1983. Manc7ging eJucationul innoimions. I onclon: Allcn & Un\vin. Pralihu, N. S. 1987. Second lanpu
~
-
~
Chapter 1 1
Zakia Sarwar ADAPTING INDIVIDUALIZATION T E C H N I Q U E S FOR L A R G E C L A S S E S
I
N H I S R E S E A R C H F I N D I N G S hascd on responses from nonnative teachers of
English from Indonesia, Japan, Nigeria, Senegal, antl South Africa, Coleman ( 1 989) lists four prol)lcms faced by teachers of large classes (1 OOf). First, thcy feel self-conscious, nervous, antl uncomlortalde; it is indeed tiring t o lie the constant focus of 1 00+ pairs o f eyes for three to four periods a day. Secondly, large classes pose disciplinary antl classtnanagement proldems, in ivhich the noise level must be kept down so as n o t t o disturb others. Thirdly, it is difficult to evaluate the oral or \vrittcn \fork of so many learners; teachers of large classes seem to lie Iiuried under an endless pile of hoinc\vork. And lastly, teachers feel that liccausc intlivitlual attention cannot lie given, very little learning takcs place. From 1983 to 1985, as a part of my studies for a master’s degree at Sydncy Unhcrsity (Sarwar 1983 85), I dcsigncd and cxccutcd a r rch project cntitlcd “li~achingEnglish as a Forrign Language with Limited Resources. n e o f the aims o f the research \vas to experiment with communicative language techniques and activities that \I oultl be effective in large classes o f l o o + . Communicative techniques \voultl naturally include the Ixoad conccpt of individualization. Finding effective techniques for large class concern in o r d e r to cxaniinc the teachers’ popular belief that in large cl nominal and the interactive approach, relying on group/pair \vork, is n o t possiblc.
Thc conccpt of individualization Before outlining my r arch and describing the tasks antl actilities that encouraged individualization in my rners, I want to clarifj my t e r m s of rcfcrcncc for thc conccpt of individualization. The uinbrclla title, indirriduulizution, covers “such s c ~ m i n g l ytlivcrse topics as one-to-one teaching, h o m e study, intlivitlualized instruction, sclf-a self-directed learning, and autonomy, I)ccausc thcy all focus o n the learner as an individual” (Geddcs and Sturtritlgc 1982). It also encompasses a learner-centred approach t o language and takes special n o t e of ethnolinguistic aspects of language lcarning, in which the autonomous rolc of the learner- is colourcd by their “second language self-image” and the teachcr/lcarner roles prevalent in thcir sociolinguistic sphere (Riley 1988).There are also certain underlying basic assumptions regarding learning whcn \vc talk of“individua1ization .” According to 1,ogan ( 1 980):
128 Z A K I A S A R W A R People lcarn even the same material in different ways (this implies accepting different learning styles). People can lcarn from a varicty of sour , cvcn i f the final goals arc thc same implying that the instructional matcrials can vary. Direct teaching liy a tcachcr is not essential for lcarning; it is only one of many possible expericnccs which mcans that a tcachcr can be a facilitator instead of a preacher. A variety of learning activities can take place simultaneously referring to integrative language-learning activities. Pcoplc may have a variety of goals o r objectives lor learning a second language implying that learners learn lor tliftcrcnt reasons. ~
~
~
~
Another pcrspcctive is addctl I>\ Altman ( 1 98O), who clcarl) talks of three liasic tenets that charactcri7c Individuali/ctl language teaching: a syllabus that meets the nccds, aliilitics, and interests of cach lcarncr personalized goals, mcans, antl expectations for learners teaching methods tailored to thc n c d s of the learners
Logan’s assumptions and Altman’s tcncts \vcrc cxamincd for my research in gcneral, and lor the sclf-learning programme in particular, to dctcrmine how the conccpt of individualization could be exploited for lar-gc classes, \\.here learners needed (u)exposure to language learning, ( h ) activities for confidcncc building, and ( c ) a lcarner-centred approach to build rapport bctween the tcachcr and the learners. Obviously, a tailor-made syllabus antl teaching methodology for cach learner was out of the question for my large classes of 1 OO+. All the same, the learners \vcrc still considered to be the focal point of the learning programme, with realistic appraisal that they \nm~ldall Ihllow their own pace of learning and reach achicvcmcnt levels congrucnt with the goals they set for thcmsclvcs. I t was also accepted that if Logan’s five assumptions lvcrc applicable in small classes, they could very well be applied to large classes, so long as thc lcarning programme offered thc learners a variety of optional actil ities.
The four Rs of individualization The \\.orking definition that emerged from these deliberations was the acceptance of Altman’s “Thrcc Rs of Individualization: Reeducation, Responsibility, and Relevance” (Williams and Williams 1979) but mith thc addition of one more R , signifying Rapport, which can lie taken for granted in one-to-one instruction or in a small class. This rapport is difficult, though just as (if not more) essential, to achieve in a large class. In the context of my research, the meaning of thcse four lis of indivitlualization arc as follows. ~
Reeducation This means reconstructing thc role of the teacher as facilitator and the lcarncr as the active agent in the process of learning. In the Pakistani context, this change nccds to be emphasized all the more, since the teacher and the taught are both used to the lecture pattern oftcaching in which thc student is a passive learner as the teacher “talks” without any interaction or Iireak for the whole teaching period.
ADAPTING INDIVIDUALIZATION TECHNIQUES
129
Responsibility This implies that learners take charge of thcir own learning, For the Pakistani learner this is a conceptual leap as they are used to rote learning and lack confidence in their own cognitive capabilities. It also implies the teacher’s responsibility to set up clcarly stated tasks that can be monitorcd by learners on their ovvn antl ensure the availability of self-learning materials for learners.
Relevance
A? most of the glossy and readil) a\ailalde material 1 5 tleiisctl for the nonnati\e lcarncr stud)ing EFL in the West, we need matcrials rclclant to our learners. Alw, r r l r \ a n w means finding contexts of learning that arc mcaningful for our lcarncrs.
Rapport
A class of 100+ is a class-managcmcnt chalknge for any teacher. It is only through the proper rapport that an atmosphere conducive to learning can bc built up. Also, “humanizing”a lai-gc class is perhaps thc only way to motivate learning.
The research programme I devised a 50-hour rclmcdial English course that focused on reading comprchcnsion and writing skills. I t was a voluntary, non-credit course, taught for two hours three times a week, and lasting approximatcly right and a half weeks. The learners (1 04 volunteers, who 1vei-e selected on a first-comc, first-scrved basis) agreed to stay after their regular classes for this course.Thcy were young fcmalc adults between 16 antl 20 years of age, the majority coming from a middle-class background. Thesr students \vere false beginners of English, having studied it For approximately n ycars. They had little o r no exposure to English in their day-today lives except for studying it as a “subject”in the Faculty of Humanities. Whilc discussing thc lcarncrs’ expectations for the programmc o n thc first day, it \vas mutually agreed that since 50 hours of class work would not he sufficient for any tangiblc improvement, the learners ~vouldsupplement their bvork by following a self-monitored learning programme that included listening, reading, and writing skills. Learners ivere given a three-part qucstionnairc hcforr and at the end of the project to cvaluatc thcir progress. The questionnaire was devised to find out (1) thc Icarncrs’ background, (2) thcir attitude towards learning English, and (3) their proficiency level in English, through a readingcomprchcnsion check and paragraph writing. The response performance as \vel1 as feedback from the project group \vas very encouraging. For the purposes of this article, hom r, I shall only focus on the steps uscd for putting the concept of individualization into practice. Thc four Rs were taken as a rcfcrcncc point in a two-pronged thrust: ( u ) individualization in largc classcs, and ( b ) individualizing learning tasks (see Figure 1 1 . 1 ) . ~
Individualization in the classroom This section deals with the last R of individualization: rapport. I t focuscs on activities that “humanized” this largc class for me by helping me familiarize mysclf with the learners as persons. I t also helped to a great extent in class management.
130 Z A K I A S A R W A R Voluntary learning T h e 104 students mho enrolled tor the language project (LP) clitl so \oluntaril) Thc) mere told that the aim of the programme mas flucnc! rather than accurac!, antl that they \ ~ o u l d be taught skills rather than prescribed textbook4 The\ were under n o pressure to p i n the course especial$ as it \%a\a non crdit"unollic ial"course, carricd out a? part of a research projcct. In the lollo\\ ing >cars I h a c used the concept of \oluntar) lcarnmg ti) consulting the student\ at thc l x y n n i n g ot each academic !car betorc setting u p the >car's teaching programme tor compulsor\ classes ~
Background questionnaire Learners \vere given an hour-long questionnaire on their first day in class. Learning about their background, attitudes, and pcrcci\wl ncctls, as \vel1 as their proficiency level, helped m e a great deal in undcrstanding m y learners. It also clariticd thcir course expectations. The responses gave m e information about the socioeconomic antl ethnolinguistic community o f the learnel-s, Lvhich proved uscf~ilin organizing their group activities and outside class projcc