Learning Cultures in Online Education Robin Goodfellow and Marie-No¨elle Lamy
Continuum International Publishing Grou...
66 downloads
2212 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Learning Cultures in Online Education Robin Goodfellow and Marie-No¨elle Lamy
Continuum International Publishing Group The Tower Building 11 York Road London SE1 7NX
80 Maiden Lane Suite 704 New York, NY 10038
www.continuumbooks.com C
Robin Goodfellow, Marie-No¨elle Lamy and Contributors 2009
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publishers. Robin Goodfellow, Marie-No¨elle Lamy and Contributors have asserted their right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as Authors of this work.
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN: 978-18470-6062-4 (hardcover)
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Learning cultures in online education / [edited by] Marie-No¨elle Lamy and Robin Goodfellow. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-1-84706-062-4 (hardcover) 1. Multicultural education. 2. Distance education–Social aspects. I. Goodfellow, Robin, 1947– II. Lamy, Marie-No¨elle, 1949– III. Title. LC1099.L38 2009 370.117–dc22 2008024038
R Inc., New Delhi, India Typeset by Aptara Printed and bound in Great Britain by Biddles Ltd, King’s Lynn, Norfolk
Contents
List of Contributors Foreword
vii x
Professor Mark Warschauer, University of California, Irvine, USA Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
1
Robin Goodfellow and Marie-No¨elle Lamy 1
When the Solution Becomes the Problem: Cultures and Individuals As Obstacles to Online Learning
15
Charles Ess 2
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures: A Cross-Cultural Study
30
Charlotte N. Gunawardena, Ahmed Idrissi Alami, Gayathri Jayatilleke and Fadwa Bouachrine 3
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education: Challenging and Developing Teacher Identities
52
Robert O’Dowd 4
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning: The Online Learner’s Emerging Identity
71
Christine Develotte 5
Being and Learning in the Online Classroom: Linguistic Practices and Ritual Text Acts
93
Leah P. Macfadyen 6
Technology As a ‘Cultural Player’ in Online Learning Environments Anne Hewling
113
vi 7
Contents Trouble and Autoethnography in Assessment Genre: A Case for Postnational Design in Online Internationalized Pedagogy
131
Catherine Doherty 8
New Learning Cultures: Identities, Media and Networks
151
Jay Lemke and Caspar van Helden Conclusion: New Directions for Research in Online Learning Cultures
170
Robin Goodfellow and Marie-No¨elle Lamy References
184
Internet References
209
Author Index
210
Subject Index
215
Contributors
AHMED IDRISSI ALAMI received his PhD from Indiana University, USA. He has published articles on the issues of cross-cultural perception and representation as well as constructions of identity across national and cultural frontiers. He is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Foreign Languages & Literatures and the Director of the Arabic Program at Purdue University, USA. FADWA BOUACHRINE is a lecturer in the Center for Academic Development at Al Akhawayn University, in Ifrane, Morocco. Building on her engineering background, she is passionate about research areas such as culture, behaviour, and technology; the digital divide; internet freedom and technology use; and socio-economic trends and use of technology. CHRISTINE DEVELOTTE is Professor of Information Science at the Institut National de Recherche P´edagogique in Lyon and a member of the ICAR research laboratory. For the last 10 years her main research interests have been linked to computer-mediated communication (CMC). Her research includes two aspects: the semio-linguistic aspect of online communication and the social aspect (focusing on the analysis of human behaviour). CATHERINE DOHERTY lectures in the sociology of education and sociolinguistics in the Faculty of Education, Queensland University of Technology. She came to teacher education with experience in adult literacy and community education, migrant English programs and curriculum and policy roles. Her research focuses on how cultural identity interacts with pedagogy, curriculum design and globalization processes. CHARLES ESS is Professor of Philosophy and Religion and Distinguished Professor of Interdisciplinary Studies, Drury University (Springfield, MO, USA). He has received awards for teaching excellence and scholarship, and publishes in Computer-Mediated Communication (CMC) and crosscultural approaches to Information and Computing Ethics. With Fay Sudweeks, Dr. Ess co-founded and co-chairs the biennial conferences ‘Cultural Attitudes towards Technology and Communication’ (CATAC).
viii
Contributors
ROBIN GOODFELLOW is a senior lecturer in Teaching with New Technology at the UK Open University. He currently directs an online Masters course in e-learning. His research interests are in the literacies and social and cultural practices of online learning. He is co-author of Challenging E-Learning in the University: A Literacies Perspective, published by McGraw Hill/Open University Press. CHARLOTTE NIRMALANI GUNAWARDENA is Professor of Distance Education and Instructional Technology in the Organizational Learning and Instructional Technology Program, University of New Mexico, USA, where she coordinates the online Master’s and certificate in e-learning. For the past 20 years she has published on distance education and currently researches the social construction of knowledge and the sociocultural context of online learning communities. ANNE HEWLING is the e-learning specialist at the UK Open University Library and Learning Resources Centre. She endeavours to bridge the cultural spaces presently occupied by new technologies, information professionals, learning developers and faculty through staff training events and case-by-case advice. She also facilitates culture change activities with colleagues in the Digilab – a hands-on university ‘play space’ for faculty and staff wanting to integrate new technologies into teaching and learning practice. In her spare time she teaches online courses in e-learning and international development. BUDDHINI GAYATHRI JAYATILLEKE is a Senior Lecturer in the Educational Technology Division at the Open University of Sri Lanka. She holds a BSc from the University of Colombo, Sri Lanka, an MA from the University of London and a PhD. from the Open University, UK. Her research interests are in media and student learning, online learning, instructional design and science communication. ¨ MARIE-NOELLE LAMY is Professor of Distance Language Learning at the UK Open University. She has 15 years of experience in designing language courses for online study, involving extensive use of e-tutorials, text-based as well as voice-based. Her research interests are in technology-mediated learning conversations, particularly in multimodal settings. She has recently co-authored Online Communication in Language Learning and Teaching , published by Palgrave MacMillan. JAY LEMKE is Professor of Educational Studies at the University of Michigan in the PhD programs for Learning Technologies and Literacy Language & Culture. He is the author of Textual Politics: Discourse and Social Theory and Talking Science: Language, Learning, and Values. Currently co-editor of Critical
Contributors
ix
Discourse Studies, he was formerly co-editor of Linguistics and Education (for 10 years). LEAH P. MACFADYEN is a research associate in Skylight – the Science Centre for Learning and Teaching – in the Faculty of Science at The University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada. Formerly a researcher in UBC’s Distance Education and Technology unit, she developed the interdisciplinary online undergraduate course ‘Perspectives on Global Citizenship’ in 2005, and now co-teaches it through UBC’s Faculty of Arts. Her research interests include the uses of the internet and communication technologies in science education and international education initiatives. ROBERT O’DOWD is a teacher of EFL and Foreign Language Methodology at the University of Le´on in Spain. He has a PhD from the University of Duisburg-Essen in Germany on the use of network-based language teaching. Some of his recent publications include Telecollaboration and the Development of Intercultural Communicative Competence (Langenscheidt, 2006) and the edited volume Online Intercultural Exchange: An Introduction for Foreign Language Teachers (Multilingual Matters, 2007). His current research interests include the role of online technologies in foreign language teacher education. CASPAR VAN HELDEN is a PhD candidate at the University of Michigan’s School of Education. His research is in (multimodal) discourse studies, and he focuses on the influence of popular culture on learning biographies, identities and identification. Currently working with video ethnography and experimental methodologies, he was formerly the producer of European media for young people.
Foreword
The concept of culture has a long and inglorious history in educational policy and practice. Racist interpretations of culture have led to entire nations being written off as uneducable. In some ethnically diverse yet highly stratified countries, students from marginalized groups have long been taught in ways that fail to recognize and nourish ways of making meaning valued in their communities. And in the United States and elsewhere, language minority students found themselves ridiculed, expelled or beaten merely for speaking their native language in school, during parts of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In recent decades, we think ourselves more enlightened, and indeed we are. Schools of Education offer courses in multicultural education, where teachers learn to be respectful of diverse groups. Insensitive portrayals of ethnic minorities are barred from the classroom and school library. Posters of ethnically diverse leaders and scholars adorn school walls. Yet, our approaches to culture too often veer into the simplistic, as in a university class I observed where the teacher informed the students that culture consisted of ‘ “(1) climate, (2) food/clothing, (3) music/dance/entertainment, (4) school/education, [and] (5) family values,” and instructed students to write cultural comparison essays that contrasted these topics in two countries’ (Warschauer 1998: 74). If ever a more complex and nuanced understanding of culture were needed, that time is now. The postindustrial era has brought a global cross-mingling of people as never before in human history. Migrants are pouring into not only traditional immigrant countries such as the United States and Australia, but also into heretofore ethnically defined nations such as Germany. Large countries such as China, India and Brazil also face unprecedented internal migration, as people stream into mega-cities looking for work. Not only labour, but also capital, production, management, markets technology and information are organized across national boundaries. These demographic, social and economic trends are problematizing the traditional view of culture as a reified set of unitary beliefs and practices for a given community.
Foreword
xi
Of course the most revolutionary new medium for cross-cultural contact and communication is the internet. The number of internet users worldwide has increased from about 16 million in 1995 to more than 1.3 billion in 2008 (Miniwatts Marketing Research, 2008). The fastest growth rates in internet use are occurring in the Middle East, Africa, Latin America and Asia. Billions more people have mobile phones, which are increasingly able to access the internet as well. Online communication is affecting virtually every walk of modern life, from politics to entertainment to dating to education. In the latter realm, we must consider not only the rapidly growing number of online courses around the world, but also the even larger number of courses that combine traditional in-person meetings with some forms of online interaction. It is the intersection of these two phenomena – the changing notion of culture in today’s world, and the vastly expanding amount of online interaction in education – that this book addresses. This represents a complex terrain, precisely because understandings of culture vary so dramatically. The editors have rightly settled on the term ‘learning cultures’, which narrows the field substantially. Specifically, they focus on four interrelated areas of cultural contact and change: transnational and cross-border education, the take-up of computer-mediated interaction by previously marginalized populations, the growth of new forms of knowledge production, and the spread of social networking phenomena and their use in education. Each of these four topics is itself worthy of a book. Bakhtin (1986) pointed out the value of transnational exchange for education decades ago, noting that It is only in the eyes of another culture that foreign culture reveals itself fully and profoundly [. . .] A meaning only reveals its depths once it has encountered and come into contact with another, foreign meaning: they engage in a kind of dialogue which surmounts the closedness and one-sidedness of these particular meanings, these cultures. We raise new questions for a foreign culture, ones that it did not raise for itself; we seek answers to our own questions in it; and the foreign culture responds to us by revealing to us its new aspects and new semantic depths. (1986: 7) Several chapters in this book address how this phenomenon plays out in online learning, which, in contrast to pre-internet forms of long-distance educational exchange, potentially brings together students from many countries in fast-paced interaction, thus accelerating the dialogic learning process. Similarly, the inclusion of marginalized populations is a major purported goal of online education efforts, but one that is not so easily reached, due
xii
Foreword
in part to the somewhat limited affordances of online communication compared to symbolically richer forms of face-to-face interaction (Warschauer 2003). Again, the potential of new forms of online communication to both include and exclude students on the margins is critically assessed throughout this book. New forms of knowledge production (Gibbons et al. 1994) and social networking (Warschauer & Grimes 2007) flow from both the organization of the information society and the tools available to it. Both address the ways that people interact and learn through networked communication, and how this overlaps with issues of identity and media. These topics, too, are well covered throughout the book, with the relationship to gender, language and genre thrown in for good measure. That editors and authors have successfully addressed such a wide range of topics in a single compact book is a testament to the selection of chapters, the quality of authors’ contributions, and the editors’ thoughtful framing of the issues in the Introduction and the Conclusion. As a result, the empirical breadth of the book, based on case studies in diverse international contexts, is matched by a rich theoretical perspective capturing the essence of these studies. The many aspects of learning cultures presented in the book are thus brought together in a way that enhances our multifaceted understanding of how new and engrained ways of believing, valuing, communicating and producing knowledge co-occur in online education. Mark Warschauer University of California Irvine, USA
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures Robin Goodfellow and Marie-No¨elle Lamy The Open University, UK
It would be customary to begin discussion of a topic like ‘learning cultures in online education’, with a definition of terms. However, in the case of a concept like ‘culture’ we feel justified in sidestepping this task, because, as some of the authors who have contributed to this book, and many of those in the literature they refer to, have pointed out, it is simply too complex an idea to do justice to in a single definition. Why then, address it at all, when there are so many other less theoretically problematic aspects of teaching and learning in online environments waiting to be investigated? Well, in a sense, the whole project of this book is about answering that question. As editors, we have, through our shared background in the use of technology for distance teaching across languages and other domains of social difference, become convinced that cultural issues are inseparable from educational, linguistic and technological ones. Indeed, a review of past research that is focused on the cultural dimensions of learning with technology suggests to us that the cultural perspective necessarily incorporates consideration of other areas such as curriculum, interaction, collaboration, pedagogy, language or assessment, albeit it can be argued that these are more readily definable. In our view, discussions of theory and practice in all these areas usually leave implicit questions that a ‘cultural’ perspective throws up explicitly: who the participants are, what determines how they relate to each other, who values what and why, who has power and who has not. Further, our attention has sharply focused on these issues because of the international, multilingual and increasingly ‘global’ context in which we now work. Increasingly the technologies of online education are being used to extend teaching and learning policies and practices developed by
2
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
and for universities in the Anglophone world (Britain, North America and Australasia), to nontraditional and transnational audiences. This is a process in which issues of culture and cultural identity, however defined, are inevitably raised, but as the research literature also shows, are not often satisfactorily addressed.
Defining a new ‘gap’ for research on culture in online learning Several observers have suggested that there is a dearth of research in the field of culture in online learning (e.g. Edmundson 2007: ix; Mason 2007; Rogers et al., 2007). It may be the case that there is not much empirical research, at least by comparison to some of the aforementioned areas (see, for example, the very considerable research literatures on ‘collaboration’ and ‘community’). However there has been a reasonable amount of discussion of issues and observation of effects over the past two decades, going back to Henderson’s cultural critique of the design of multimedia (Henderson 1996), then two seminal special journal editions on culture: the British Journal of Educational Technology (1999, volume 30, number 3), and Distance Education (2001, volume 22, number 1), and more recently Edmundson’s edited book on globalized e-learning (Edmundson 2007). And there has also been discussion and empirical work on culture-related issues in other disciplines – including the sociology of communication, organizational studies, foreign language learning and intercultural studies, the social-psychology of the internet – much of which is relevant to online education. The scope of this discussion and the cross-disciplinary dimension of the research are two other reasons why we hesitate to attempt a definition of culture in the early part of this book. Better, we think, to let the range of approaches to its problematization adopted by the contributors to this book tell the story. In compiling ‘Learning Cultures in Online Education’, therefore, we are not looking primarily to fill a gap in existing empirical research, but instead to draw together perspectives that problematize the workings of culture in online education from a range of theoretical and disciplinary positions. This, we hope, will help define a gap that we ourselves, and others, may be motivated to try to fill empirically in our future research. We are also, in the interests of cross-disciplinarity in educational research, setting out to draw attention to drivers of educational change other than the purely instructional or pedagogical. In particular, we consider the following general educational and sociotechnical developments to be significant for our work: r The growth of multiculturality and ‘widening participation’ policies in national systems of higher education, which are intended to address the
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
3
increasing diversity of learners and their family, community, educational and work backgrounds. r The rapid expansion of transnational e-learning, including enrolments of ‘foreign students’ and staff development of corporate, governmental, agency and other ‘noneducational’ providers. r The spread of new media communication practices (i.e. internet community, socializing and informal learning practices), which are beginning to influence educational development through the incorporation of Web 2.0 technologies into course design.
Developments driving the need to problematize ‘learning cultures’ – the growth of multiculturality Many nations now have governmental policies on widening participation in tertiary level or higher education in order to increase the numbers of students from sections of society that traditionally do not continue their education beyond school-leaving age. In the United Kingdom this includes people from economically poorer areas, and those who have been out of formal education for some time, as well as those from identifiable ethnic backgrounds under-represented in university populations (Bowl 2001). Globally, there are additional groups that have found themselves excluded from educational opportunity at any level. For example, in India: the disabled, women, ethnic minorities, castes and tribes, prison inmates, senior citizens, nomads and migrants, the geographically isolated (Sharma Sen 2002). As a development of ‘open learning’ systems, which have espoused the educational cause of these marginalized sections of society (Singha Roy 2002: 269), online learning is now seen as one of the instruments of national policies of inclusion. However, for many of these nontraditional learners, formal education at university level itself represents a cultural challenge, further compounded by the ‘digital gap’ and the constraints of low IT literacy and unfamiliarity with online systems and pedagogies. A ‘widening participation’ approach to multiculturalism – which aims either at ‘assimilation’ or the celebrating of superficial aspects of ‘diversity’ – without acknowledging aspects of cultural difference that identify and separate minority groups from the dominant cultural mainstream – has been criticized by cultural studies researchers (e.g. Hall 2000; Eriksen 2006) who question the individualistic and neo-liberal perspective from which it emanates. In one sense societies and communities may be considered to be enriched by multiculturalism, a view that prevailed in ‘the West’ at the end of the twentieth century, as typified by a UNESCO report on ‘Our Creative Diversity’ (World Commission on Culture and Development 1995). Yet, in another
4
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
sense they could be thought to be divided by it, as is increasingly felt to be the case in the contemporary context of globalization, economic migration and religious and ideological intolerance (Eriksen 2006). We will develop this point further below in a discussion of essentialist frameworks and their association with ‘Western’ online learning practices. Research in online learning in multicultural contexts has reflected these tensions around multiculturalism, and the meanings of cultural diversity (e.g. Goodfellow et al. 2001; Chase et al. 2002; Gunawardena et al. 2003; Goold et al. 2007). Henderson (1996), commenting on the design of interactive multimedia for use by groups including indigenous learners, critiqued three common attitudes of designers: an ‘inclusive’ approach, which incorporates cultural perspectives from minority groups but does not challenge the dominant model; an ‘inverted’ model, which designs from the minority cultural perspective but does not provide admittance into the mainstream culture; and a ‘unidimensional’ model, which simply denies diversity and treats everyone the same (Henderson 1996: 86). Henderson’s work has informed researchers contributing to each of the special editions and the edited book mentioned above, in particular the work of McLoughlin (1999, 2001, 2007) who argues for a pluralistic approach to designing for multicultural learners, using constructivist online teaching techniques, which she considers are capable of adaptation to the degree of cultural inclusivity required. Others, however, taking the view that neither online learning technologies nor their associated pedagogies are themselves culturally neutral (Doherty 2004; Reeder et al. 2004; Hannon & D’Netto 2005) highlight the role that ‘institutional needs, structures and strategies of implementation play in shaping learning experiences’ (Hannon et al. op. cit.), and cast doubt on the feasibility even of pluralistic design as a solution to the problems of difference in multicultural learning communities. As a further aspect of the institutional shaping of learning that is currently driving practice in higher education, we can point to the growing focus on ‘mode two’ knowledge production in the curriculum (Gibbons et al. 1994), which responds to employability agendas and the developing interdependence between academic, professional and work-based learning contexts, especially in the ‘new professions’ such as Business, Education, Healthcare, Engineering, etc. While this is not usually seen as a cultural issue, it qualifies for consideration here, in our view, because of the differences that arise in expectations, pedagogies, and literacies between traditional disciplinebased academic practices and work-based and professionalized ones (see Goodfellow & Lea 2007, for a more developed discussion of this). In the context of online learning, some research has suggested that not only do ‘academic’ and ‘business’ values inflect learner approaches to online communication differently (Goodfellow 2004), but that differing institutional
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
5
values relating to the purpose and conduct of online communication can inflect patterns of participation differently in learner populations with otherwise similar ‘cultural’ profiles (Goodfellow & Hewling 2005). As workbased and professional development practices penetrate further into the traditional subject-based curriculum of the university, collisions of different value systems in the conduct of online learning are likely to become more frequent. We would also incorporate, within this overview of ‘multiculturality’ as a driver of research into learning cultures, the kinds of issues that have been addressed by researchers in the fields of language learning and intercultural communication, particularly those who have worked in the context of the European Community’s notions of ‘cultural’ and ‘intercultural competence’. Europe is keen to educate its citizens in mutual tolerance (because of the trauma of World War II), and through the Council of Europe (set up in 1949) it has funded much educational research into interculturality. However, the notion of intercultural communicative ‘competence’ that has emerged is a problematic one. Within applied linguistics and language learning and teaching research, intercultural communication has been not only an aspiration, but also an obstacle, to theoretical and pedagogical progress, because of a lack of problematization of the notion of culture itself. For instance, in research where a major component of culture has been ascribed to individuals’ psychobiographies, Sealey and Carter (2004) found that: ‘some of the key concepts used in mainstream studies of intercultural communication are vulnerable to criticism’, in particular those that present culture ‘as though it were an attribute of the individual, a property of – or possession held by – people as a result of where they live, the religion they practice, the colour of their skin and so on’ (2004: 153). In the practice of telecollaboration (putting pairs of language learners in different countries in contact via e-mail, so that they may learn each others’ languages) that has grown up in the last few years, the construct of culture has been reinterpreted in social terms, leading to a preoccupation with ‘intercultural’, ‘cross-cultural’ or ‘inter-discourse’ communication, depending on school of thought (see Piller 2007). However, research into telecollaborative projects for language learning carries many stories of full or partial failure, not in the use of the code (French, Spanish, Japanese, etc.) but in the partners’ understandings of each others’ cultures. Such failures of intercultural communication are described through the rhetoric of ‘styles’ and ‘genres’, assumptions of ‘culturally-contingent conversational styles’ (Belz 2003: 82), or typified by observations such as: ‘When computer users from different cultures communicate online with one another, they may have different views on what genre (discourse type and discourse style) is appropriate for the exchange’ (Ware & Kramsch 2005: 191). In this
6
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
literature, even when cultural conflicts are welcomed as learning opportunities, the assumption that a coherent ‘genre’ or ‘style’ is characteristic of national cohorts is rarely interrogated. Robert O’Dowd, one of the contributors to this book, has faced up to the pedagogical implications of this problem by drawing attention to the frequency of ‘Failed Communication’ in telecollaborative exchanges (O’Dowd & Ritter 2006) and proposing a detailed remedial scheme for practitioners faced with intercultural communication failure. Yet O’Dowd and Ritter’s notions of ‘intercultural communicative competence’ at the individual level, and ‘communicative style’ at the socioinstitutional level, are themselves problematic. As Cameron (2002) shows, through an examination of communication in service industries, of increasing importance in neo-liberal economies primarily in the Anglophone world since the 1960s, the culture of ‘effective communication’, bears ‘a noncoincidental resemblance to the preferred speech-habits of educated middle-class and predominantly white people brought up in the USA’ (2002: 70). In this more critical understanding of culture, a socioeconomic view of intercultural communication, focused on the commodification of languages, is emphasized over the interpersonal.
Developments driving the need to problematize ‘learning cultures’ – the expansion of transnational e-learning Socioeconomic development is to the fore in the second of the developments motivating our interest in online learning cultures at this point in time; that is, the growing use of online and distance learning by educational institutions to increase enrolments of ‘foreign students’ on programmes developed primarily for domestic use (Garrett & Verbik 2003), and by corporations and other organizations to support the learning of their staff around the world (Dunn 2007: 257). Garrett and Verbik’s analysis of data from the UK Higher Education Statistics Agency shows, for example, that there were over 101,000 students from all over the world taking courses from UK universities outside the United Kingdom in 2003. These student numbers are outstripped by those of corporations, many of the largest of which originate from the United States. According to Rogers et al. (2007), the Cisco Corporation has 400,000 students in 10,000 academies in 150 countries (figures taken from Dennis et al. 2005), and the Global University of Springfield has 600,000 students in 178 countries, teaching in more than 145 languages. Rogers et al. also draw attention to the global instructional programmes of international agencies such as UNESCO and the World Bank, which may be assumed to have more broadly social aims. Many of the students on these programmes are currently being taught face-to-face,
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
7
but it is clear that the deployment of online technologies and pedagogies is seen by these organizations as a key strategy for future development. Research that focuses on the cultural implications of transnational online learning in these contexts has gathered momentum in recent years, as evidenced by Edmundson’s edited book (Edmundson 2007), which has nineteen chapters on accounts and discussion under the heading ‘Globalized E-Learning Cultural Challenges’. Much of this research is motivated by a concern for what Wild called, in his 1999 editorial for the special issue of the British Journal of Educational Technology (1999) ‘appropriate’ design for cultural diversity. This perspective puts a clear focus on the problem of learning designs that originate in ‘single cultural identities’ (Wild 1999: 198) being imposed on culturally diverse learners, and incorporates an awareness that the ‘reach’ of dominant cultures is being extended via electronic media. However, the approach tends not to concern itself with the institutional context of the learning, be it personal/professional development, employment training or basic education, but instead concentrates on the effect of differences between the learners, or between the cultural assumptions of the learners and those embedded in the design of materials. The understanding of the notion of cultural difference that underpins most current research arises from a view of culture as the manifestation in individuals of all the values, beliefs and ways of thinking and doing things that come with the membership of particular national, tribal, ethnic, civic or religious communities. Culture, in this view, is a consequence of geographical, historical, climatic, religious, political, linguistic and other behaviour and attitude-shaping influences that are assumed to act on everyone who shares the same physical and social environment. It implies that individuals are habituated, or have their minds ‘hard wired’, through upbringing, schooling and the acquisition of language and social customs, and that they can be characterized by ways of behaving and interacting that are typical to people of that nationality or ethnic group. Much of the research into cultural issues in transnational e-learning contexts is framed by this kind of conceptualisation, often referring to the work of Hofstede and others who have developed categorizations of national cultural characteristics (e.g. Hall & Hall 1990; Hofstede 2001). These accounts determine differences between nationalities and ethnic groups by the use of categories such as: ‘individualism’ (focused on self interest) and ‘collectivism’ (centred on the interests of family and the wider community); or ‘high-context ‘ (using the entire social context of an interaction: physical location, status of participants, body language, etc. to interpret its meaning), and ‘low-context’ (focusing on the direct content of messages, seeking specific information and/or expecting particular responses).
8
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
Essentialist frameworks such as these (descriptions of individuals in terms of cultural attributes) have proved highly useful to researchers wishing to tailor the design of online learning to the assumed cultural preferences of individuals or groups. For example, Gunawardena et al. (2001) used the power-distance categorization initially to distinguish between US and Mexican students, before showing that online textual communications can equalize differences in status between the groups. Kim and Bonk’s (2002) study of collaboration between US, Korean and Finnish university students drew attention to differences between the three groups in terms of individualism and collectivism, high and low context and task and relationship focus. Morse (2003) used the low-context/high-context categories to distinguish between the attitudes to online collaborative learning of students from the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand on the one hand, and Pakistan, China, Singapore, Sri Lanka and Thailand on the other. Several of the contributors to Edmundson’s edited book (2007) discuss these frameworks, and indeed Hofstede himself provides the Foreword to the book. As Edmundson notes (2007: ix–x), much of the research on culture in e-learning has been conducted by Westerners, and critics such as Fougere and Moulettes (2007) and Kim (2007) have pointed to the ethnocentricism implied by this. Fougere and Moulettes, for example, observe that so-called ‘individualistic’ societies identified in the research literature are implicitly presented as ‘more technological, more legal, more urban, more educated, more literate, more wealthy, more democratic, more equal, more questioning, more socially mobile, etc.’ (2007: 11). These are, of course, the same societies of the Anglo/North American/Australasian, English-speaking, ICT-intensive cultural paradigm whose economic and educational ideology and technology has framed the development of globalized e-learning. We will take up this discussion in our Conclusion chapter.
Developments driving the need to problematize ‘learning cultures’ – new media communication practices The third development driving our interest in online learning cultures is the emergence of ‘new’ cultural and social identities in virtual learning communities, which draw on contemporary cybercultures of the internet as well as systems of cultural relations inherited from conventional educational or corporate settings. Whereas the phenomenon of community in online settings has been widely discussed in terms of its ability to generate human feelings and behaviours closely analogous to those experienced in physically located communities (see, for example, the collection of sociological accounts of virtual community in Smith and Kollock (1999), or
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
9
the more learning-oriented collection in Renninger and Shumar (2002), it is only relatively recently that internet cultures started to be theorized on their own terms (Gibbs & Krause 2000). Examples of such theorization related to learning can be found in social-psychological studies of virtual identity, which draw in the notion of culture, for example, Conoscenti’s (2004) study of cross-cultural interactions in an online military training context. Yet currently there is, to our knowledge, little research that relates what might be called learner cyberidentities to cultures in online learning. Reeder et al. (2004) explored some of the implications of Western/Anglo ‘values’ embedded in cyberculture; Goodfellow and Hewling (2005) examined the role of ‘cultural narratives of participation in online communities’ in shaping learner behaviour; Bayne (2005) has discussed ‘modes of identity formation’ by learners and teachers online and the anxiety generated in the former by the multiple ‘selves’ that were available to be taken up. More recently, theorizations of new learner identities have to take account of new communication practices developing around technologies such as web logs (blogs), wikis (e.g. wikipedia), social networking sites (e.g. MySpace), usergenerated content sites (e.g. YouTube) and other tools and environments collectively known as Web 2.0 (O’Reilly 2005). These are being explored in relation to younger learners and conventional school contexts (see Lemke & van Helden’s contribution to this book), but have yet to surface in a significant way in research on the cultural dimensions of online learning.
New configurations of users We believe these trends point to the likelihood of increasingly unpredictable configurations of learners, teachers, employers, content-producers, managers, administrators, technologists, researchers and others coming together in online networks for educational purposes in the not-so-distant future. However, as the dominant cultural influence in both the designing and the researching of these diverse configurations, is likely to be an Anglo/North American, English-speaking, ICT-intensive, pedagogically constructivist educational paradigm, we wished to produce a more reflective and critical perspective on the nature of culture in online education than is currently to be found in the literature on online learning. We were aware that there are a number of writers and researchers who are exploring the idea that there is more to the issue of culture in the online classroom than simply that which is brought in by individual learners from their national backgrounds. These writers try to reflect the fact that constructions of difference between groups of learners, whether framed as ‘cultural’ or more broadly social, are always ideological; that is, they are always part of wider
10
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
discourses of power and social identity. Asking the authors whose work is represented in this book to help us develop the concept of ‘learning cultures’ was a step towards such a perspective, one which we hope will help ensure that the social and pedagogical benefits from the trends and developments listed above will keep pace with the corporate and institutional ones.
Conceptualising ‘learning cultures’ – the structure of the book A theoretical introduction to the complex concept of culture in online education is undertaken by Charles Ess. Ess is one of the founders of the Cultural Attitudes to Technology and Communication conference (CATAC) and has written widely on the subjects of culture, education and technology (e.g. Ess 2002a, 2002b; Ess & Sudweeks 2005). His opening chapter provides a framing for the concept that is built on throughout the book. He rehearses a critique of essentialist perspectives, arguing that cultural identity is hybrid and has many more dimensions than nationality or mother tongue, making it too complex to be adequately circumscribed by systems of categorization such as Hofstede and his followers have developed. Ess develops the argument that online scenarios are themselves culturally coded spaces, inviting the formation of ‘third cultures’ (from Raybourn et al. 2003) in which individuals combine elements from the different cultural traditions in which they were socialized to form their own, new, self-created identity. His view that there are no ‘well-grounded theory/theories sufficiently comprehensive to do justice to the multiple dimensions of “culture”’ leads him to challenge the very idea of online ‘learning cultures’. Instead, he concludes with a challenge to the designers of online learning spaces to recognize that face-to-face contact is essential to significant learning, since it is only when we encounter one another face-to-face that we ‘recognize that we are dealing with one another as distinctive human beings first – not simply as tokens for overly simple and overly generalized accounts of cultures and subcultures’. The theme of online cultural hybridity is taken up by Charlotte Gunawardena and her co-writers – Gayathri Jayatilleke, Ahmed Idrissi Alami and Fadwa Bouachrine. Gunawardena was one of the contributors to the 2001 special edition of Distance Education mentioned above, and also to CATAC 2002, and has researched into culture and other dimensions of online communication (e.g. Gunawardena et al. 2003). In this chapter the authors address aspects of the playing out of cultural identity in internationalized internet chat spaces, via an empirical study. Although they are reporting on research with men and women of Moroccan and Sri Lankan nationality,
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
11
and the discussion takes account of the indirectness that they claim is characteristic of personal communication patterns in both these national cultures, their findings emphasize the possibility for hybrid cultural identities to emerge out of local systems of activity such as internet chat. In particular, they stress the role of the medium of interaction, the cyberculture, rather than the specific national cultural characteristics of the participants, in constructing the shared knowledge, beliefs and behaviours that make up an online group’s reality. This lays a basis for discussion of the ways that participants’ identities, including gender and religious identities, are enacted and/or concealed as part of the process of negotiating norms of communication online. The implications of the emergence of ‘unique online cultures’ for designers of online learning spaces are clearly drawn. Other contributors address the concept of learning culture directly, drawing on this wider understanding of culture as an ongoing process of identityconstruction through interaction, and relating it to different online learning contexts, including ones in which face-to-face teachers and learners are moving online for the first time as part of new institutional e-learning policies. Robert O’Dowd has published extensively in the field of language and intercultural learning, and is responsible for the ideas about ‘failed’ intercultural communication mentioned earlier. In his chapter he discusses the implementation of online learning in a Spanish campus-based university, and shows how the professional identities of teachers are implicated in the attempt both to adapt new media to existing practices, and to develop the new social constructivist practices which the tools claim to promote. For example, teachers who take up online practices may regard themselves as ‘progressive’ in the sense of having a commitment to learner-centred teaching. However, in the early stages, at least, they may use the environment to reconstruct conventional teacher-centred approaches, such as exercising covert control through the facility for student monitoring that the online environment affords. Through three case studies he demonstrates how learning cultures operate at several levels, including at the level of the community of practitioners (the faculty), the policy initiatives of the institution, and the wider discourses of educational professionalism, as well as in the self-positioning of the teachers themselves. Christine Develotte addresses the same theme of induction into online learning cultures as O’Dowd does, but with a focus on learners, and on what she sees as ‘significant moments’ of pedagogical socialization, when there is a break between the kind of behaviour associated with on-site (face-toface) learning, and that which is appropriate to online interaction. She uses a study of student reflections on the experience of taking an online in a course in Teaching French As a Foreign Language to analyze the characteristics of the ‘discursive space’, which the online learning environment has
12
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
represented for these learners, and to track their emotional and cognitive adaptation to the new ‘job’ of being an online learner. In her analysis, while learners may view themselves as emancipated from their ‘student’ roles through online social interaction, at the same time they experience online textual activity as socially demanding because it involves the production of writing, which is subject to critique by teachers and more capable peers. Nevertheless, she argues that the learning culture which is constructed in the process is capable of being more convivial, less competitive, having more connections between students and between students and teachers and having a different relationship to knowledge, than the more familiar, but less dynamic, on-site condition. The textuality of online learning environments is further explored by Leah Macfadyen, in particular the relation of ‘textual reality’ to the idea (introduced by Ess) that significant learning necessitates physical embodiment. Macfadyen has been involved in the production of two seminal texts exploring postessentialist views of culture in online learning (Chase et al. 2002 and Reeder et al. 2004) and here she discusses online learning cultures as communities in which the ‘rules of engagement’ have to be coconstructed. This is a process that involves the performing of aspects of normally embodied identities, including age, status and racial or ethnic origins, via online textual rituals during which self-identity is necessarily reconstructed. She contextualizes this view of online learning cultures as constructed in context through an account of interactions between participants on an online course in global citizenship, some of whom came to realize that by participating in such a course they were indeed reconstructing themselves as global citizens. Like Macfadyen, Anne Hewling explores the nature of ‘textualized’ interaction, and its role in the negotiation of culture in the online environment, taking up the concept of ‘third culture’ introduced by Ess, to describe the social reality that emerges out of interaction between online learners from different cultural, and indeed multicultural, backgrounds. Her argument is informed by observations from a study of students on an online Masters course in open and distance learning. Like O’Dowd and Develotte, she focuses on the appearance and functionality of the virtual learning environments in which online learning takes place, but she goes on to criticize the functional efficiency of the systems in practice, describing a number of ways in which the technology of a virtual learning environment can appear to be functioning autonomously, sometimes taking on a role as the site of institutional authority in place of the university itself. Unpredictable system functionality, when distributed over space and time, she argues, leads to a situation where, from the human participants’ point of view, the technology appears to behave as a cultural actor. The combination of the unpredictable
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
13
technology and, for some learners, the unfamiliar pedagogy based on collaborative learning principles, proved to be a cultural challenge even when the learners’ own national cultural backgrounds were the same as that of the host institution. The variability and unpredictability of system behaviour within the current generation of virtual learning environment platforms is now further amplified by recent developments in networking and mobile technologies, creating an even wider range of communicative possibilities for online learners, and an even greater impression of the technology as proactive in the interaction. Hewling’s approach to theorizing these observations is to introduce the notion of cultural ecology as a metaphor for the ways in which the identities of the human participants in online education are in negotiation as much with the technology as with each other. Some of the wider implications of ‘new’ cultural configurations in online education are discussed from the perspectives of social theory in a chapter on postnational pedagogical genres by Cathie Doherty. Doherty’s most recent work has focused on the wider social phenomenon of internationalized education, and in this chapter the online learners are characterized not by assumed national characteristics but by their relation to the providing institution, either as ‘domestic’ or as ‘international’ students depending on the extent to which they share familiarity with the procedures and text genres that frame teaching and learning practices in this particular institution. Her study comes from an Australian university’s online Masters in Business Administration course, and focuses on the ‘troubling’ of assessment procedures, and the rhetoric of self-description by students who are distanced from the local pedagogical conventions of the course by their ‘transnational’ life worlds rather than by their national cultural characteristics. Doherty argues that truly postnational learning cultures should position all students as international, regardless of the provenance of the learning material or the national identity of the participants. Jay Lemke and Caspar van Helden’s position on learning cultures is expressed as a critique of schooling reminiscent of Ivan Illich’s (1971) well-known attack on formal education systems. Lemke has written extensively on new media and education and also on virtual culture (e.g. Lemke 2005a). Here, he argues that contemporary culture reflects an unstable mix of identities drawing on marketing and popular media as well as the traditional resources of ethnicity and nationality, class and age, gender and sexuality, etc. They argue that younger learners who live a ‘globalized, individualized, lifelong-learning biography’ find their formal education to be an obstruction to their development. For many of these learners and other users of internet-based resources, popular culture media and personal social networks (including online communities) have become key sources of identity models and cultural resources for affiliation and identification. This
14
Introduction: A Frame for the Discussion of Learning Cultures
addresses what education does not, and is meaningful for students in ways the curriculum is not. The authors go on to argue that although we may believe there is an imbalance of power between corporate media producers and distributors, and individual consumers, research on ‘fan communities’ around television programs, computer games and movies, suggests a different picture. Individuals and their informal communities transform and re-appropriate media to fashion identities and subcultures that are often subversive of marketing messages and dominant economic interests. The implications of this for online learning follow from the need to ‘go beyond both the offline culture of schools and the online culture of media’ and investigate how young people learn successfully outside the school and curriculum, including the role of passion, affect and emotion in learning, and the processes by which learners are motivated to identify with particular elements of popular culture, affinity groups and personal and social projects and agendas.
Summary To sum up our approach to this book, then, we offer a frame for the discussion of learning cultures, by opening with a critique of the best-known frameworks available for cultural analysis outside the online world, coupled with a challenge to the very possibility of developing a notion of online culture. We go on to provide counterpoints to this, by showcasing six studies that claim that the online situation allows people to construct identities that would not be available to them in face-to-face situations, as men or women, as professionals (continuing and initial teachers) and as citizens partaking in the discourses of globalization, or trying to gain some purchase over the unpredictable, changeable semiotic effects generated by their interaction with IT systems. The range of learner types and data discussed allows multiple perspectives on the online learning experience (affective, cognitive, semiotic, symbolic, ergonomic, political) to emerge, suggesting ways through which the nature of ‘learning cultures’ can begin to be understood. Finally, while the first frame of the book showed how traditional theories of culture faced up to the social practices of the online life, through our final frame we turn towards the future, no longer asking what we know about online learning cultures but what the traditional guardians of learning do not know about the ever-expanding learning cultures of tomorrow’s learners.
Chapter 1
When the Solution Becomes the Problem: Cultures and Individuals As Obstacles to Online Learning Charles Ess Drury University, USA
Introduction In keeping with and reflecting the then-prevailing views of computermediated communication (CMC), the first bloom of enthusiasm in the 1990s for the seemingly unlimited possibilities of online learning was marked by the rhetoric of ‘revolution’. This rhetoric rested on especially two sets of assumptions. The first were those articulated by the French philosopher Ren´e Descartes, whose notions of mind and body have deeply shaped the modern West (e.g. 1637, 1641). For Descartes, the split between thinking mind and unthinking body is so radical that whatever takes place in the material and bodily domain has no real effect on the person as essentially mind (Slater 2002: 538; Ess 2004; Cavanagh 2007: 120–125). Known as Cartesian dualism, this assumption then played into a second set of assumptions driving the then-dominant postmodernism. Echoing Descartes’ radical split between mind and body, many postmodernists argued for an equally radical split between modernity and postmodernity. (Broadly construed, ‘modernity’ was taken in these contexts to be defined by Enlightenment understandings of emancipation through reason, science and technology – emancipation further tied to the communication technologies of literacy and print. Postmodernity, in contrast, begins with a radical rejection of such Enlightenment notions). Out of the modernity/postmodernity dichotomy emerged visions of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) as instantiating postmodern rejections of ostensibly ‘linear’ Enlightenment reason and logic
16
Learning Cultures in Online Education
(seen to be tied to the communication technologies of literacy and print): specifically, these technologies made possible nonlinear hypertexts and, more broadly, a radically free space of play, creativity and interconnectivity widely referred to in terms of ‘cyberspace’ (first used by the science-fiction novelist William Gibson, 1984). In particular, the text-based communication facilitated in cyberspace was widely characterized, following the work of Ong (1982), as a ‘secondary orality’, one that moves beyond literacy and print to recover something of an earlier, primary orality – the communication technology of pre-literate peoples that emphasizes association, repetition, rhyme, the emotional, the particular and other aspects of narrative as techniques of memory. To be sure, Ong himself emphasized that secondary orality rested on and incorporated both literacy and print. As a simple example: exchanges in a chat room or through an instant messaging service closely resemble early orality insofar as these exchanges are relatively quick and spontaneous, often more emotive, and nonlinear (i.e. easily taking different, not always obviously connected paths). At the same time, however, literacy is apparent in the exchanges themselves as primarily text-based: and, insofar as such exchanges may be recorded and archived, they thereby move towards the functionality of print, which makes words into objects, removed from their authors. But where secondary orality for Ong was thus more of a synthesis of current and earlier communication technologies, postmodern theorists characteristically applied the distinction between secondary orality, on the one hand, and print and literacy, on the other, in a dualistic fashion: the result was (again) the radical split between modernity (literacy-print) and postmodernity (secondary orality). These two sets of dualisms then made it possible to believe that an emerging cyberspace would quickly and completely replace the practices and institutions associated with Enlightenment reason, literacy and print. (For more detailed accounts of this brief overview, see Slater 2002, Cavanagh 2007). If we are, in fact, simply disembodied minds inhabiting a virtual cyberspace radically divorced from what enthusiasts contemptuously referred to as ‘meatspace’ (Gibson 1984: 239; Barlow 1996), then education would indeed be most ideally carried out in an exclusively virtual online environment as well. Hence, at least within the US context, along with the imminent end of ‘meatspace’ in general, 1990s enthusiasts proclaimed the impending end of the book, along with the disappearance of ‘bricks-and-mortar’ schools and so-called ‘seated’ (in contrast with online or virtual) classrooms: all of this unpleasant materiality would be replaced instead by communication in the form of information processed and exchanged exclusively through electronic media. These early visions of revolution, however, quickly crashed upon a range of both theoretical and real-world problems. To begin with, the Cartesian
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
17
mind-body dualism – itself long rejected by philosophers on various grounds – was dramatically countered in emerging research in such disciplines as learning theory and cognitive psychology. More contemporary understandings of the human being as a knowing subject now stress the essential role of embodiment to our processes of learning, recalling and then enacting our knowledge in the world (cf. Stuart forthcoming). Similarly, overly simple postmodernist dualisms fell by the wayside, including the dualistic (mis)reading of the secondary orality of cyberspace as opposed to print and literacy. Finally, while these developments were taking place at more theoretical levels, at the pragmatic level, initial efforts to develop online education in earnest began to demonstrate that the real costs of developing and implementing online educational materials far exceeded initial estimates. Finally, especially as institutions sought to cash in on a burgeoning global demand for online courses, online educators quickly encountered two sorts of stubborn obstacles. The first are the manifold problems created by the diverse, and oftentimes conflicting, cultures of online participants. To see how this is so, I begin with representative efforts to take up frameworks of cultural analysis – starting with those developed by Hall (1976) and Hofstede (1980, 1983, 1984, 1991) – first with regard to intercultural communication via ICTs in general, and then specifically with regard to online learning. While Hofstede and Hall are widely and, up to a point, effectively, used by researchers for such analyses, several important criticisms of these frameworks make clear two important limits to their usefulness. One is their inability to appropriately inform the design of online environments for participants of multiple cultures, including instructors. The other is their lack of interest in issues about how to ‘be’ in these environments, a dimension that I address next, and which has also been foregrounded by other chapters in this book. Indeed, once these serious limitations to Hall and Hofstede become clear, we are then faced with an embarrassing ‘theory gap’: while more sophisticated theories are emerging (e.g. Baumgartner 2003, Cantoni et al. 2006), there appears to be no well-grounded theory/theories sufficiently comprehensive to do justice to the multiple dimensions of ‘culture’ that have been demonstrated to impact cross-cultural online communication and learning. The second obstacle is nothing less than the individual learner as such, that is, the person who blends multiple cultures and subcultures in specific ways, unique to each individual, coupled with his or her own characteristic learning style. I highlight two levels of difficulty here, beginning with the individual as a member of multiple and shifting cultures, and who thereby represents a distinctive set of the multiple possible combinations of national and linguistic cultures, youth culture(s), ethnic and/or other subculture(s), etc. Such individuals may largely escape the relatively broad
18
Learning Cultures in Online Education
frameworks developed by Hall and Hofstede. Moreover, as Hewling (2005) has documented with particular force regarding online teaching environments, such individuals online create in collaboration with one another their own new cultural amalgams – distinctive syntheses of various elements drawn from diverse cultures that again escape even our limited models of cultural analysis as applied to online learning. As I emphasize in my concluding remarks, none of these observations are intended to pose fatal objections to the enterprise of online learning. Rather, I offer these in the conviction that only by recognizing both the strengths and limitations of our technologies – most especially, vis-`a-vis the central but still relatively neglected role of culture – will we be able to realize their best potentials for teaching and learning.
Revolution versus reality: The 1990s’ promises and the twenty-first century realities of online education As we have begun to see, English-language conceptions and enthusiasms for ‘cyberspace’ – the metaphorical place in which human beings and machines (such as artificial agents) may communicate with one another by way of networked ICTs – were marked early on by a presumed Cartesian, radical split between mind and body. In the terms made popular by William Gibson’s seminal novel, Neuromancer , the body belongs to an openly despised ‘meatspace’ – while the mind can enjoy god-like freedom in ‘cyberspace’ (e.g. Gibson 1984: 239). The peak of techno-utopian optimism regarding such liberation in cyberspace is represented in Barlow’s ‘Declaration of the independence of cyberspace’ – a declaration that likewise calls for ‘liberation’, largely in the form of escape from ‘meatspace’ (Barlow 1996). The 1990s rhetoric of ‘revolution’ via ICTs was further fuelled by a prominent theory of communication – one affiliated with the work of Innis (1951), McLuhan (1962, 1964), Ong (1982) and Eisenstein (1983) and for discussion, see Chesebro and Bertelsen 1996). Taking diverse forms of communication as (at least necessary) conditions of culture, this framework argued that modern institutions (e.g. democratic polity, natural science, the liberal state, etc.) were closely wedded to the communication technologies of print and literacy. As we have seen, Ong famously argued that an emerging cyberspace would be marked by a ‘secondary orality’. While for Ong, secondary orality of necessity rested on and incorporated both literacy and print, for postmodern enthusiasts caught in the spell of simple dualisms between modernity (as affiliated with literacy and print) and postmodernity (affiliated with secondary orality), Ong’s contrast, when (mis)understood dualistically, nicely supported the larger vision of an imminent and revolutionary overturning of modern institutions.
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
19
It is also the case (at least in the West) that ‘revolution’ sells, and so it is not an accident that more or less every new technology and technological development, ranging from personal computers to blogs, is introduced into the marketplace with breathless claims that technology X is ‘revolutionary’ (‘Join the blog revolution!’ etc.). Given this matrix of economic, political and theoretical factors, it is not surprising that higher education likewise jumped on the ostensibly revolutionary bandwagon inaugurated by networked ICTs and prevailing conceptions of ‘cyberspace’. At least within the US context, proponents of distance education – now migrating from its primarily paper-based correspondence models and early efforts to exploit radio and TV into the online world – hailed the imminent end of the book, and with it, ‘bricks-and-mortar’ schools and their ‘seated’ classrooms (both pejorative terms defining traditional higher education from the standpoint of the purely ‘virtual’). But as symbolized by the (in)famous dot.com collapse at the beginning of the twenty-first century, 1990s ‘proponents’ visions and claims of imminent revolution, whether in the political or educational orders, soon ran aground on several stubborn realities. In addition to emerging insights regarding the essential role of embodiment for the learning, knowing and enacting self, additional empirical research began to demonstrate that Cartesian assumptions regarding a radical mind-body split fail to materialize, so to speak, in a ‘cyberspace’ radically distinct from an ostensible ‘meatspace’ (cf. chap. 9: 120–131). So, for example, while ‘virtual communities’ certainly offer unique facilities and advantages, in large measure, such communities remain closely connected with their participants’ real-world bodies, and thereby their real-world histories, values, traditions, etc. (e.g. Baym 2002; Slater 2002; Cavanagh 2007, ch. 8: 102–119). Similarly, what we may call the postmodernist (mis)reading of the Innis-Ong schema began to fray in the face of several challenges, beginning with a criticism of its tendency towards an overly simple technological determinism that is likewise no longer supported by empirical evidence (Ess 1999; Slater 2002: 534). Perhaps most persuasively, emerging economic realities likewise confounded 1990s enthusiasms. In particular, contrary to hopes that distance education would serve as a lucrative cash cow for universities facing continuously increasing costs (Carr 2001), experience and a number of hard-nosed analyses demonstrated that the costs of designing, producing and implementing computer-mediated distance education far exceeded original assumptions and estimates (e.g. Rumble 2001; Trucano 2005; cf. Ess 2006). Finally, as institutions understandably sought to profit from a burgeoning global demand for online courses, two sorts of additional obstacles emerged, beginning with the manifold problems created by the diverse, and oftentimes conflicting, cultures of online participants. As educators attempted to come to grips with the role of culture in shaping online interaction and
20
Learning Cultures in Online Education
communication by taking up a number of frameworks for cultural analysis – primarily, those developed by Hall (1976) and Hofstede (1980, 1983, 1984, 1991) – a second difficulty emerged: namely, that of the individual learner who, for a variety of important reasons, confounded the cultural analyses initially sought by online educators as ways of resolving the problems and conflicts, ostensibly rooted in culture, which appeared in the online classroom.
Transnational online learning: ‘culture’ as a solution – ‘culture’ as a problem ‘Culture’ interacts with online learning in a range of ways, beginning with a characteristic effort to ignore it altogether. Despite the fact that ICTs now connect more than one-sixth of the world’s population, thereby facilitating cross-cultural contact with astonishing speed and scope, there remains a remarkable assumption among many ICT designers (including those in the field of online education) that ‘culture’ is largely irrelevant to their efforts. So, for example, in their interviews with instructional designers, Rogers et al. quote an interviewee they refer to pseudonymously as ‘Derek’: I believe that good instructional design principles and techniques are universal, cross-cultural. It doesn’t matter where in the world they are coming from [. . .]. (Rogers et al. 2007: 210) The available evidence suggests exactly the contrary. As with every other dimension of human activity, so with ICTs: their design, usages and effects are deeply shaped by culture. Broadly, this can be seen in a wide range of examples of failures of ICT design and implementation. Such failures can be traced to, and thereby bring to the foreground, fatal contrasts and conflicts between the cultural values and communicative preferences embedded in ICTs (i.e. their design, implementation and intended outcomes), and the communicative preferences and cultural values of the ‘target’ cultures in which specific users are located. (For a representative overview of this literature, see: Ess 2001; Ess & Sudweeks 2001a and b, 2003, 2005). But this means more specifically that online learning technologies and techniques grounded in one’s culture/s will likewise reflect the cultural values and communicative preferences of that culture, including basic assumptions regarding what sorts of knowledge(s) are of value (and hence to be learned) and how those knowledges are to be acquired. As we shall soon see, when taken up by students in cultures shaped by different assumptions and values, including different understandings of what counts as valuable knowledge and how such knowledge is to be acquired, such implementations generally fail.
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
21
So, for example, Postma has documented how South African Learning Centres – as designed by whites for use by indigenous South Africans – fail to accomplish their well-intended goals of helping indigenous peoples acquire the skills and literacy needed to successfully engage in the ‘information society’. In particular, Postma notes a sharp cultural conflict between the pedagogical and epistemological assumptions of the ICT designers, and those of their indigenous clients. Briefly, white designers follow the European ‘quiet library’ model (my term), one that emphasizes individual and silent study of texts – thereby requiring high literacy skills. In contrast, for many indigenous peoples, knowledge and learning are usually collective activities – and these are indeed often noisy, in part as they emphasize group oral discussion and/or performative expression of important knowledge in song and dance as technologies of memory appropriate to oral societies (Postma 2001; cf. Addison and Sirkissoon 2004; Snyman and Hulbert 2004). Similar contrasts have been documented with regard to efforts to work with the Maori people of New Zealand (Duncker 2002; Keegan et al. 2004). In both instances, the not-so-surprising result is that these Learning Centres largely fail to accomplish their intended goals. Of course, there have been efforts to analyze ‘culture’, both with regard to intercultural communication online more generally, and within online learning in particular, in order to avoid these sorts of culturally rooted failures (e.g. Williams 2000; Chambers 2003). As mentioned earlier, within the larger literature, briefly, a number of important analyses begin with the work of Hall (1976) and Hofstede (1980, 1983, 1984, 1991). Three of the five cultural axes developed by Hofstede have emerged as especially salient to online analyses of culture: Individualism vis-`a-vis Collectivism: more collective cultures (indigenous cultures, classical China, Panama, Ecuador) stress the importance of cooperation and group harmony, while more individualist cultures (United States, Australia) stress individual initiative, competition and recognition. Uncertainty Avoidance: high uncertainty avoidance cultures (Greece, Portugal) avoid uncertainty, including change, while low uncertainty cultures (Jamaica, Singapore) tend to embrace change. Power Distance: high power distance cultures (e.g. Malaysia, Guatemala, Mexico) accept hierarchies and affiliated disparities between power, wealth and status, while low power distance cultures (Austria, Israel, New Zealand) emphasize greater equality. (Callahan 2005; Hermeking 2005) The remaining two axes – Long-Term Orientation (the ‘Confucian’ axis) and Masculinity (emphasizing traditional gender roles) – generally
22
Learning Cultures in Online Education seem to have little impact on online communication: but see Baumgartner (2003).
To be sure, numerous researchers have made good use of these first three axes as frameworks for analyzing cross-cultural communication online (e.g. ¨ Callahan 2005; Hermeking 2005; Wurtz 2005). At the same time, however, Hall and Hofstede have shown themselves to be vulnerable to both theoretical critique and empirical limitations. To begin with, L¨ubcke (2006) has documented how Hofstede’s work assumed a national culture as something largely fixed and shared in equal degrees by all its members. This approach misses, however, equally critical elements of regional cultures within a national culture (e.g. between northern and southern France: see Deyrich & Matas-Runquist 2006). Moreover, Hofstede assumed that ‘culture’ was something largely fixed and homogenous – whereas ‘culture’ appears rather to be fluid and in a constant process (whether slowly or quickly) of interacting with and thereby hybridizing with other cultures. Also, specific individuals can vary significantly in terms of how far they reflect Hofstedian cultural characteristics such as Uncertainty Avoidance, Individualism-Collectivism, Power Distance, etc. (L¨ubcke 2006: 536–539). Moreover, the relatively small number of cultural dimensions identified by Hofstede (as well as Hall), while useful up to a point, clearly fail to encompass ‘culture’ as more broadly implicating some fifty to seventy elements as identified by anthropologists and linguists (e.g. the widely used ‘iceberg’ model of culture, Roche 2008: 230.) For his part, Hall developed the distinction between high context/low content (HC) and low context/high content (LC) cultures (1976). As the term suggests, communication in HC cultures depends more on context, including the rich milieu of specific social and family relationships, and as conveyed at least as much by nonverbal forms of communication such as gaze, gesture, body distance, etc., as by explicit verbal/textual statements. HC communication tends to be more indirect than direct: in HC cultures, the responsibility for understanding a message lies more with the receiver than the sender (W¨urtz 2005). LC cultures, in contrast, stress the content of a message and a correlative emphasis on explicitness and clarity as the responsibility of the sender. Broadly, the Germanic cultures (the Netherlands, Germany, Austria and the Scandinavian countries) are strongly LC, while Arabic and Japanese cultures are strongly HC. Between these two poles, Anglo-American cultures are moderately LC, while Latin cultures (French, Italian and Latin-American, respectively) are increasingly HC (see Hermeking 2005: Figure 3). While more recent research and frameworks find that Hall and Hofstede remain salient and useful, it appears that at least twenty-two cultural factors affect the design and appropriation of new technologies (Baumgartner
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
23
2003). Hence, while Hall and Hofstede remain useful starting points for analyzing cross-cultural communication online, it is increasingly clear that their frameworks must be expanded and refined (Ess & Sudweeks 2005). A similar pattern of development may be discerned in the domain of online education – what Koch has called ‘intercultural e-learning’ (2006: 218). To begin with, Rogers et al. observe that, just as in CMC and HumanComputer-Interaction (HCI) literature more broadly, there is a limited but growing awareness of the role of culture and cultural differences in online instructional design (2007: 198). Nonetheless, they identify three major obstacles to attending to culture – beyond, that is, the sort of na¨ıve ethnocentrism at work in designers such as ‘Derek’ who appear to believe that their understanding of things is universal. These obstacles are: (1) primary attention to content development; (2) lack of evaluation in real-world practice; and (3) organizational structures – including economic limitations – that work against attending to culture (Rogers et al. 2007: 207ff.) For her part, Koch agrees that there has been relatively little attention paid to ‘culture’ in the literature and research relevant to online education – even though the influence of social constructivism in both traditional and online pedagogical theory and research inevitably points to the role of culture (2006: 218ff.). Nonetheless, Koch identifies three different conceptions of ‘culture’ in an emerging literature in intercultural e-learning: culture as structure (including the approaches associated with Hofstede); culture as text (e.g. approaches shaped by cultural anthropology, including the seminal figures of Geertz 1973, and Hannerz 1992); and culture as practice and community (affiliated especially with Lave & Wenger 2002). While all three offer advantages, the second approach – culture as text – begins with a critical assumption regarding culture, one that overcomes one of the main weaknesses we have seen in Hofstede: rather than viewing ‘culture’ as homogenous, static and hermetically sealed off from other cultures, this approach rather begins with: [. . .] a more flexible understanding of culture in which the adaptability, flexibility and creativity of cultural communities are emphasized. Cultural belonging is then understood as the result of a self-portrayal, or rather the construction of an individual identity, which is actively produced and performed situationally, in order to create differences between one group and others or to differentiate oneself. (Koch 2006: 220) This approach further recognizes that ‘technology itself [is] a culturally produced and thus also culturally shaped ‘artifact’ (sic) – in contrast, that is, with the technological instrumentalism that predominates in much HCI and CMC literature; that is, the view that technology is somehow culturally neutral (‘just a tool’) and hence that its design and implementation require
24
Learning Cultures in Online Education
no attention to its cultural origins, etc. More broadly, this approach means that: Digital communication environments are seen here as places in which identity can be constructed and negotiated through interaction with other participants. Online scenarios are therefore relatively open, only slightly culturally coded spaces, which, because of this openness, invite the formation of a so-called ‘third culture’. (Raybourn et al. 2003) In this ‘third culture’, individuals combine elements from the different cultural traditions in which they were socialized to form their own, new, self-created identity. In doing so, they transcend their own traditionally, nationally or ethnically influenced cultural ties in favour of constructs in which elements from different traditions are recombined to form a new cultural self-perception. (Koch 2006: 220). Such ‘third cultures’ are increasingly manifest – in part, precisely, as artefacts of the rapidly expanding cross-cultural encounters online made possible by the internet and the web. For example, Japan, China and Thailand have – until recently – viewed anything resembling individual privacy as strongly negative (e.g. Nakada & Tamura 2005; Lu¨ 2005; Rananand, 2007, for the respective countries above). This characteristic suspicion of, and contempt for, individual ‘privacy’ rests on assumptions central to each culture – assumptions sharply contrasting with those undergirding modern Western notions of the individual and of the correlative importance of personal privacy as a primary good and essential right. It is hence striking that in these countries, young people – as influenced by their extensive exposure to Western cultures through diverse media – increasingly insist upon Western-like notions of individual privacy. These notions, however, remain shaded and limited by their specific contexts in societies still deeply shaped by Confucian and Buddhist traditions. What is emerging here, then, is a ‘third culture’ notion of privacy, one that conjoins both Western and Asian values and views (see Ess 2005, for further discussion). Hence, the ‘culture as text’ approach seems especially well-suited to online classrooms involving participants from more than one culture, precisely as practitioners here point towards just the emergence of ‘third identities’ as part and parcel of the online educational experience, an emergence that frequently eludes the broad cultural frameworks (e.g. as affiliated with Hofstede) that educators have sought to apply to the online environment. So, for example, in addition to Raybourn et al. (2003), Rodrigues (2004) documents the emergence of a hybridization between (North) American formality and Brazilian informality in an internet-based learning project.
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
25
Individuals as the problem: cultures, subcultures and learning styles Hybridization in online classrooms thus evades extant frameworks of cultural analysis: moreover, the individual learner likewise escapes such frameworks – first, as we have seen, as the individual is more than simply a token for a presumptively monolithic national culture. In addition, individuals represent a constantly shifting intersection of multiple cultures and subcultures, which in turn alter over time at varying rates, that is, from national/linguistic cultures that change relatively slowly, to youth cultures, which change very quickly (e.g. as we have seen, with regard to such fundamental notions as privacy and the nature of the self). A given individual may further reflect some number of ethnic and/or other subcultures, including those shaped by economic and social class. Insofar as each individual may be thought of as a distinctive construction and inflection of each of these diverse levels of ‘culture’, she or he may inhabit a near-infinite continuum of possibilities that are only poorly and incompletely captured by the five cultural dimensions articulated by Hall and Hofstede. More radically, as we have seen, the cross-cultural online learning environment facilitates such individuals’ creation of distinctive new syntheses and amalgams of diverse cultural elements that again escape overly simple frameworks of cultural analyses. Hewling (2005), for example, documents forcefully how students in one of her intercultural online classrooms repeatedly exhibited communicative behaviours and values that (a) either could not have been predicted by using Hofstede or, worse yet (b), directly contradicted whatever predictions one might have made on the basis of those schema. So Hewling finds that among her students – Canadians, a North American, and a Sudanese – concerns about authority are expressed primarily by the (North) Americans. But according to Hofstede’s framework, (North) Americans, as members of a low-power distant country, should be least concerned about issues of authority. Rather, as members of an individualist country, according to Hofstede, these students should be most likely to express their opinions directly and without hesitation. Hewling (2005), however, shows that this was not the case. For her part, Hewling proposes a content analysis methodology that she argues is more appropriate for analyzing the intercultural communication that takes place in online classrooms (2005) – a methodology that we can understand to incorporate both Koch’s second approach (‘culture as text’) and third approach (‘culture as community and practice’) to cultural analysis (Koch 2006: 221ff.). Additional frameworks for cultural analysis have also been proposed. One of the most notable has been developed by Cantoni and his colleagues. Their frameworks take up Baumgartner’s much
26
Learning Cultures in Online Education
more complex matrix of cultural dimensions, one that adds to Hall and Hofstede an additional seventeen cultural factors developed in part from the theoretical work of Gould (2005). The resulting framework is then applied to a project involving ICTs for teacher-training in Brazil (Cantoni et al. 2006). But again, this sophisticated enhancement of Hall and Hofstede as a framework for cultural analysis of intercultural online learning reiterates the point already made regarding intercultural communication online: while Hall and Hofstede (among others) may be used in initial ways, these frameworks provide only limited, and sometimes profoundly misleading, approaches to the realities of intercultural communication online. While new, more comprehensive frameworks and approaches are being developed (e.g. by Cantoni et al.) that promise to offer us better understanding of online intercultural communication – and thus, of how we can shape both our technologies and their uses to foster the most effective intercultural communication and e-learning. We have only just begun.
Conclusion: ‘culture’ betwixt and between We have seen that with regard to intercultural communication online in general, and intercultural learning online in particular, the role of culture is both central (contrary to ethnocentric assumptions that one’s own views, principles, etc., may be universal) and profoundly challenging. Some initial frameworks – such as Hall and Hofstede – can help at least up to a point. But they are also limited in important ways: in particular, as providing us with perhaps five useful cultural dimensions, they thereby omit an extensive range of additional factors that have been demonstrated to affect implementation and use of ICTs across diverse cultures. While more recent approaches (e.g. Cantoni et al.) take up more sophisticated frameworks, we are nonetheless left with a remarkable ‘theory gap’: despite the clear role and centrality of cultural factors in intercultural communication online, including intercultural e-learning. As yet, we cannot point to a theory or set of theories regarding culture, communication and ICTs that is sufficiently sophisticated to adequately (much less completely) capture ‘culture’ in ways that would help us design still more effective online learning environments and approaches. In addition, we have seen that the individual learner confounds even the best efforts at cultural analysis, both because she or he represents a m´elange of diverse cultural and subcultural elements, in varying degrees and at various times, and because she or he, precisely as facilitated by the communicative venues of online learning, is able to construct in, collaboration with her or his cohorts distinctive new syntheses of diverse cultural elements.
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
27
Metaphorically, these new syntheses and amalgams – each a unique permutation of an expansive range of diverse cultural and subcultural elements (themselves also in flux) – pop up like mushrooms after a spring rain: each one theoretically predictable as the outcome of a limited set of known factors, but wildly prolific in reality, exploding out of our simple coordinate grids into nearly infinite possible combinations that confound even the best efforts at analysis. As Spivak has said, ‘No langue-parole or system-process distinction can catch this play, culture at work. Culture alive is always on the run, always changeful’ (1999: 356ff.). But Spivak goes on to say that ‘[t]here is no reason to throw up one’s hands over this’ (ibid). As the work of Cantoni et al. (2006) and Rogers et al. (2007) suggest, new and promising approaches to analyzing cultural dimensions of online communication and learning are emerging. But clearly, much remains to be done, starting with overcoming the prevailing and stubborn ethnocentric belief that the technologies, pedagogies and instructional design techniques of one’s own culture are somehow ‘universal’. As an increasing number of researchers are starting to make very clear, such an assumption is simply na¨ıve and inevitably fatal to efforts to exploit ICTs for effective cross-cultural communication. So, for example, in his study of Chinese vis-`a-vis German website design and user responses, Bucher has pointed out that ‘. . . design indeed is highly culturally specific and [. . .] universal principles – for example of website usability – are implausible’ (2004: 425). At the same time, within the domain of online learning, Chen and Mashhadi point out that some are beginning to realize that ‘culture itself cannot be objectified as just another factor to be programmed into designing a distance learning course’ (Chen & Mashhadi 1998: 10; cited in Rogers et al. 2007: 214). Online education clearly offers important pedagogical advantages and opportunities – including the opportunity to engage with ‘the Other’ – that is, the other human being in the manifold ways in which she or he is not simply like us, but also irreducibly different from us (e.g. Levinas 1963). But if we are to successfully exploit these advantages and possibilities, we must learn to avoid the sorts of failures resulting from na¨ıve ethnocentrism, including what I have called ‘computer-mediated colonization’ (Ess 2002a). Such colonization of ‘the Other’ is a matter of attempting to eliminate the irreducible differences that define the Other as radically distinct from oneself. We attempt to eliminate these differences by foisting our own values, beliefs, practices, etc., upon the Other, and thereby remaking him or her in our image. Such colonization – whether in its well-known historical forms or its more recent instantiations in online environments, including in the very design of online learning tools – follows from the ethnocentric insistence (especially on the part of those already politically, economically and
28
Learning Cultures in Online Education
culturally dominant in our world) that our own approaches are universal rather than culturally relative. Since the time of the ancient Greeks, people in diverse cultures have recognized precisely the dangers of such colonization and its affiliated ethnocentrism. To overcome ethnocentrism and thereby avoid colonization requires us to know the Other as ‘the Other’; that is, in ways that recognize, respect and foster the irreducible differences that define us as distinct from one another. So far, at least, this is done more easily and directly by encountering the Other face-to-face – ideally, within his or her cultural context, rather than our own – so as to minimize the temptation to impose our own cultural values and practices, as ostensibly ‘universal’ upon the Other. The critical value of such direct encounters is only reinforced by our increasing recognition of the role of embodiment in our learning, knowing and enacting our knowledge: from this perspective, we come to know the Other as a complete human being only by experiencing one another as embodied human beings who are members of specific communities, marked by specific cultures and subcultures, etc. (cf. Dreyfus 2001). At the same time, however, our encounters with one another online – at least with current technologies and applications – often miss much of the elements of our face-to-face encounters with one another that most powerfully convey our irreducible differences from one another. That is, in our offline encounters with one another as embodied beings, the full difference of the Other is on display, so to speak, for example, through dress, actions, voice, gesture and the whole suite of behaviours that both define much of our sense of who we are – and at the same time are culturally relative. But many, sometimes most, of these elements are eliminated in the online context, making it easy to presume that ‘the Other’ is indeed more or less just like us, and hence we need not worry about ethnocentrism and its attendant dangers. In this light, we can now see that the 1990s dualisms and enthusiasms for the disembodied mind in cyberspace raised the dangers of computermediated colonization in two ways. Again, insofar as we ignore culture in the design and implementation of ICTs and online-learning environments, and thereby simply assume in a na¨ıve ethnocentrism that our ways are universal, we will almost inevitably colonize ‘other’ cultures by imposing our ways. Moreover, insofar as our engagements with one another online mask or suppress the many ways we represent ourselves as embodied beings and thereby as irreducibly different from one another, these engagements thus reduce our sense of the irreducible differences between ourselves and the Other: in doing so, they make it all the easier to presume, again, that our ways are universal. That is, this presumption is not as readily or dramatically challenged in online environments that minimize the forceful
When the Solution Becomes the Problem
29
representation of radical difference by the Other as an embodied being: such interactions thus reinforce the temptation of na¨ıve ethnocentrism to assume that our ways are indeed universal. Happily, more recent developments in our understanding of embodiment further underline the importance of face-to-face encounters to the learning experience – and thereby promise to help offset the dangers of na¨ıve ethnocentrism in an immaterial cyberspace. This importance is recognized in praxis, for example, in the hybrid models of online education that are increasingly preferred in those contexts where at least one or two face-to-face meetings per course can be arranged; (Ess 2006; cf. Slater 2002’s discussion of businesses moving to similar hybrids, so-called ‘clicks and mortar’ companies – in sharp contrast with the 1990s promised elimination of ‘bricks and mortar’ [2002: 544]). Moreover, when meeting face-to-face is not an option, the central importance of encountering the Other as an embodied being is further apparent, for example, in online learners’ efforts to ‘write the body back in’ in their virtual encounters with one another (Macfadyen, this book). Similarly, Lamy has described how online learners find ways to coconstruct with one another ‘perceptual spaces’ that include possibilities of re-presenting aspects of their embodied selves (forthcoming: 399; cf. 2006, 85ff.). These observations and developments thus speak powerfully against the Cartesian belief that all we need to know about one another is contained within a disembodied mind as manifested in a virtual reality. Rather, when we encounter one another face-to-face – or, absent that option, when we seek to recreate our embodied selves online – we recognize that dealing with one another in strong ways is to deal with one another as embodied beings. And most importantly for our purposes: when we deal with one another as embodied beings – whether face-to-face and/or in online encounters that seek in various ways to write in at least some of the sensual elements of face-to-face meetings – we engage with one another as distinctive human beings first, not simply as tokens for overly simple and overly generalized accounts of cultures and subcultures.
Chapter 2
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures: A Cross-Cultural Study Charlotte N. Gunawardena University of New Mexico, USA
Ahmed Idrissi Alami Purdue University, USA
Gayathri Jayatilleke Open University of Sri Lanka, Sri Lanka
Fadwa Bouachrine Al Akhawayn University, Morocco
Introduction The integration of the internet into contemporary society worldwide has had a profound impact on the way we communicate, relate to ourselves and to each other. Different users, depending on various characteristics such as age, gender, education and sociocultural background, access the internet for various communication needs such as exchanging e-mails, making new friends or engaging in a serious discussion. Whatever the goal, users need to adjust to this new computer-mediated interactive environment, and they do so either in ways that reveal native cultural values, or reflect the creation of new cultural norms and conventions. The nature of the tool that mediates communication impacts and alters their perceptions of the communication process as well, and how they perceive their social roles. As Joinson (2003) observes ‘tools are more than just something to make a task easier. They change your way of thinking, of approaching a task (and indeed the nature
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
31
of the task itself) and can reap unimagined wider social changes’ (2003: 2–3). The development of tools from the early alphabetic and numbering systems to the new communication technologies has transformed not only the tasks performed by interacting with them, but also human capabilities. Vygotsky (1978) referred to this as ‘mediation’ and argued that tools as well as other people allow for the extension of human capabilities. Cole and Engestr¨om (2007) observe that artefacts that mediate human activity have changed. So, how does computer-mediated communication (CMC) with its ability to provide for both synchronous and asynchronous, text-based interaction between individuals or groups, across geographical distances and cultures, impact the communication process? Ellerman (2007) describes three main approaches to understanding the impact of CMC on society: (1) the technological determinism approach (McLuhan 1967), which examines the ways in which technology shapes society, but takes little account of social context or individual action; (2) the ‘uses and gratifications’ approach adopted by social psychologists who examined human needs first and how technology was adopted to satisfy these needs, an approach later developed into social information processing perspectives (Walther & Parks 2002) that attempted to understand interpersonal communication on the internet; and (3) the historical context approach, which examines the various contexts in which the technology is introduced and employed, and how technology affects and is, in turn, affected by the social, technological, and political context (Rowland 1997). The second and third approaches enable us to examine the psychological and sociocultural processes that underpin mediated communication online from the standpoint of the native cultures of the participants. This chapter aims at developing our understanding of the sociocultural processes of synchronous online communication from the perspective of two different cultural contexts, Morocco and Sri Lanka, in order to draw implications for the development of learning cultures within online communities. To better understand the sociocultural processes that play a role in CMC, it is important to examine the informal use of the medium in different cultural contexts to determine the communication conventions naturally developed by internet users; in this way, we can begin to understand how various communities adapt their media-rich communication styles to the text-oriented medium of the internet. People, when communicating in person, automatically generate meaning through different ways such as dress, nonverbal behaviour, spatial distance, manner of speaking, etc. However, in cyberspace, users must depend on other means of creating such nuanced presentations of themselves, their ideas and even their personalities. We have chosen, then, to look at two communities, which have high-context cultures, namely, Morocco and Sri Lanka.
32
Learning Cultures in Online Education
The purpose of the preliminary study discussed in this chapter was to explore what happens when individuals whose self-images are characterized by a sense of group identity based on factors such as nationality, ethnicity, religion, gender, language and socioeconomic status, use the culturally heterogeneous and technically ephemeral forums of the internet to pursue personal communication goals. We undertook the study with the intention of developing a conceptual framework for the sociocultural environment of an online community based on the factors that emerge from the communication conventions and processes employed by internet chat users in Morocco and Sri Lanka. Such a framework would enable us to suggest implications about the role of learning cultures in the activity of such a community. In addition, it could provide insight in to how we can design online environments or learning spaces, which encourage the types of communication we are striving to support, especially when we may be addressing participants from high-context and/or multilingual cultures.
Study design and context We adopted a qualitative ethnographic perspective (Merriam 1998) to conduct interviews with participants and examine communication conventions, and grounded theory building (Glaser & Strauss 1967; Strauss & Corbin 1998; Charmaz 2003) to develop the conceptual framework for a sociocultural environment for online communities. Our collaborative study design involved four researchers who understood the cultural contexts studied and brought in an interdisciplinary perspective to the study. Interview questions addressing the purpose of the study were initially developed by the lead researcher and revised in collaboration with the co-researchers who also participated in data collection and analysis. Interview questions were translated into Moroccan Arabic, French, Sinhala and Tamil, and interviews were conducted in these languages and English. The interdisciplinary nature of the research team, the diverse expertise and cultural knowledge, enabled the conduct of culturally sensitive research, and culturally appropriate understanding of the issues. The study was conducted in the Middle Atlas region of Morocco between September and January 2004, and in small and large towns in Sri Lanka from February to July 2005. Morocco and Sri Lanka exemplify two very different cultural contexts. Morocco is an Arab, Berber, Muslim, Mediterranean African country, more recently colonized by the French, speaking standard Arabic, Moroccan Arabic and Berber and French. Sri Lanka is a Sinhalese, Tamil and Muslim country, predominantly Buddhist, more recently colonized by the English, speaking Sinhala, Tamil and English.
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
33
Both countries are similar in that they have diverse minority groups with different languages and religions represented in the population. Interviews were conducted in internet caf´es or cybercaf´es and university computer labs in four different locations in the Middle Atlas region of Morocco, and in the western, southern and eastern part of Sri Lanka, which represented the ethnic and religious diversity in the population. Participants were predominantly the general public who used internet caf´es and university students who used the internet in campus labs. Although the internet is constantly growing in popularity in these two countries, many cannot afford computers and internet connections in their homes, and gather at internet caf´es to use the internet. We gathered data conducting individual and focus group interviews with fifty-five adults in Morocco, which included thirty-six males and nineteen females, and with fifty adults in Sri Lanka, which included thirty-three males and seventeen females. This study focused primarily on participants who used chat forums to engage in conversation and build relationships with people they did not know. In both these countries, fewer women frequented internet caf´es, reflecting social taboos. In Morocco, the caf´e was and still is the domain of men and this transferred to the concept of the internet caf´e as well. In Galle, a mid-size, fairly conservative town in Sri Lanka, only one in ten users was a female.
Culture online As we began this study, our major challenge was to arrive at a definition of culture. As Faiola and Matei (2005) have noted, there are two aspects to be considered: the computer as a mediator in the communication process, and the people engaged in the communication as persons influenced by a complex blend of cultural contexts. We wanted to look for a definition that would incorporate both these elements. Given the centrality of culture to human life (Vygotsky 1978; Shuter 1990) and subscribing to the view that culture is present in mediated communication in the language employed and the manner in which communication happens, we felt that it was necessary to adopt an encompassing definition of culture for describing the two cultural perspectives (Moroccan and Sri Lankan) in our study. While we will refer to participants in our study as Moroccan or Sri Lankan, indicating a national context, we believe that these individuals do not subscribe to a specific, fixed, national culture in the online context. The bipolar dimensions of nationally held cultural values put forward by Hofstede (1980, 2001) individualism-collectivism, power distance, uncertainty avoidance, masculinity-femininity and long-term
34
Learning Cultures in Online Education
orientation, while a useful explanatory framework despite criticisms leveled at it (Carbaugh 2007; Fougere & Moulettes 2007; Kim 2007) is not an appropriate framework to describe communication processes in the online context. For example, although Sri Lankan and Moroccan societies would be classified in Hofstede’s framework as high-power distance societies, participants from these countries look to the online medium as a liberating medium that equalizes status differences, thereby providing them with a level playing field. Cultural indicators such as social position, age and authority, personal appearance are relatively weak in the CMC context (Reid 1995). Therefore, their interactions online will not necessarily reflect high-power distance communication. Graiouid (2005) takes this point further by stating that internet chat and discussions are dismantling the traditional power structures in Morocco by allowing previously disenfranchised groups to publicize their concerns. Ess and Sudweeks (2005) and Ess (this book) support this view by providing a considered critique of the applicability of Hofstede’s framework to the online context. The authors note that what interests CMC researchers is how national, as well as other cultural identities such as ethnicity, youth culture, gender, etc., interact with intercultural communication online; that is, removed from the face-to-face setting. Very often those who communicate online identify with multiple frames of reference. The authors note that Hofstede’s framework and to a lesser extent Hall’s (1976, 1984) conceptualization of culture appear to be limited to national cultural differences and thus less well-suited for understanding and researching the multiple cultural differences within nation-states, including the ‘third’ or hybrid identities that are themselves fostered by the cultural flows facilitated by the internet and the web. Despite the criticism, we found Hall’s (1976, 1984) conceptualization of high context and low context communication styles, and implied indirect and direct communication styles, useful for analyzing cultural differences in communication online. In both Moroccan and Sri Lankan cultures, context is important to understanding a message and its connotations. Many Moroccans and Sri Lankans adopt indirect communication styles in face-to-face communication. Therefore, Hall’s conceptualization helped us to analyze if there were changes in communication styles when participants interacted online, or whether they were using the same communication styles online as they would use face-to-face. As we explore how cultural variability plays a role in online communication, ‘the variation within a culture in terms of situations, individuals and socioeconomic status may account for as much or more of the variation in intercultural interpretations of messages as does the difference between the cultures of the individuals involved’ (Rogers & Steinfatt 1999: 96). Kincaid
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
35
(1987) has shown the shortcomings of Western approaches to understanding cultural differences in communication processes. Miike (2000) points out three important themes that emerge in establishing an Asian paradigm of communication: relationality, circularity and harmony, with the underlying assumptions that (a) communication takes place in ‘contexts’ of various relationships; (b) the communicator is both active and passive in multiple contexts; and (c) mutual adaptation is of central importance as adaptation is the key to harmonious communication and relationships. In this regard, it is worthwhile to consider the model developed by Shaw and Barret-Power (1998), which provides a detailed and precise mapping of the elements that constitute cultural differences by stressing the importance of considering the impact of both apparent and less visible aspects of cultural differences. The model differentiates between two sources of cultural differences – readily detectable attributes such as age, gender or national/ethnic origin, and underlying attributes, such as values, perspectives, attitudes, beliefs, conflict resolution styles, socioeconomic and personal status, education, human capital assets, past work experiences and personal expectations. With this understanding of the myriad ways in which cultural variability can be observed, and interpreted, we tried to come to terms with the complexity of culture online, by defining it from the perspective of the internet as a culture in its own right, blurring the boundaries between the real and virtual worlds. Creating and participating in new communities is one of the primary pleasures people are taking in CMC (Baym 1995). Reid (1995) notes that the conventions of CMC enable users to weave a web of communication that ties each person into a sociocultural context. ‘This web of verbal and textual significances that are substitutes for and yet distinct from the networks of meaning of the wider community binds users into a common culture whose specialized meanings allow the sharing of imagined realities’ (1995: 183). Therefore, we adopted the definition of ‘idioculture’ developed by Gary Alan Fine and cited by Cole and Engestr¨om (2007) as our definition of culture online: An idioculture is a system of knowledge, beliefs, behaviors, and customs shared by members of an interacting group to which members can refer and that serve as the basis of further interaction. Members recognize that they share experiences, and these experiences can be referred to with the expectation they will be understood by other members, thus being used to construct a reality for the participants. (Fine 1987: 125) This definition accommodates the idea of culture as a locally emerging activity system involving a briefer stretch of history (Cole & Engestr¨om
36
Learning Cultures in Online Education
2007), and includes multiple cultural selves and hybrid identities on the internet that interact with each other cross-culturally to form unique cultures of their own. The definition fits well with the ephemeral, fluid nature of the internet, which fuels the development of cybercultures, cultures that emerge among those who use the internet to communicate, developing its own etiquette, norms, customs, ethics and mythology, just as an idioculture does. Along with this definition of culture online, we used frameworks for understanding cultural patterns developed by Sri Lankan researchers (Disanayaka 1998; Wickramasinghe 1997, 2004), and Moroccan researchers (Mernissi 1975; Sadiqi 2003; Graiouid 2005; to explore to what extent the larger sociocultural context of the participants in our study were reflected in their internet communication.
Emerging conceptual framework Through the qualitative ethnographic perspective and the inductive theory generation process employed in the preliminary data analysis, three major themes were identified to constitute a conceptual framework to explain the sociocultural context of internet chat users in Morocco and Sri Lanka. The three themes were identity, gender and language, interacting with each other in their expression in synchronous chat. Identity is expressed through language reflecting the gender roles, either real or assumed, in the online sociocultural context. Three properties emerged related to the expression of identity. They were trust building, self-disclosure and face negotiation. Gender differences were observed in the expression of identity, trust building, self-disclosure and face negotiation. The following sections discuss these themes in detail.
Identity online In chat sessions, identity is expressed by asking for the communicator’s ASL (Age, Sex and Location). Depending on the context, chatters either reveal their true identity, create a different identity, blend or communicate their identity using a pseudonym (referred to as an ID) that expresses their true or imagined character. The chatter uses this information to create an image about his/her interlocutor. Ahmed stated that the revelation of his identity depends on the first question. If he feels the chatter is truthful he would give his real name. On the other hand, Javad noted that it depends if he wants to play, amuse himself and have fun or attempt a serious communication. He usually does not give his real identity. Joinson (2003) has observed that constructing identity through text provides opportunity for people to craft
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
37
an identity that exists quite apart from the usual pressures of real life and impression management. In both countries, chat is perceived as a playful activity, a form of entertainment, a therapeutic agent and a game that does not require the disclosure of true identity from the beginning. It is also perceived as an addiction as many were described as ‘chat addicts’. A participant from Sri Lanka describes the therapeutic nature of chat: One of my females advised me to use Chat when I was undergoing a bad period. She said that chat would help me to boost myself. She told me how to login and how to reply. She advised me to give a false name. But I gave my true name; only the first name. I found that most of them use false names. Chat addiction is also reported by Graiouid (2005), whose study participants indicated that chat has become an essential part of life, and like morning coffee a chat session is necessary to start the day. Others reported parental concern for the amount of time and money spent in the cybercaf´es. For cybercaf´e owners, chat addicts are good clients since they generally spend more for their cybernetic journey. Asynchronous forum discussions on a topic of interest, on the other hand, are regarded as more serious, since they represent an arena for debating ideas and defending opinions. Therefore, respondents would feel more comfortable divulging their true credentials in a forum discussion. The sociocultural context influences online communication as well as gets affected by communication in cyberspace and virtual environments. ‘Whereas the Western concept of “self” is based on the individual, the Moroccan concept of self is based on the Islamic notion of jamac¸ah “community/group” and is, thus inherently plural’ (Sadiqi 2003: 65). One aspect of the collective self is the difficulty that Moroccans have in talking about themselves in public because it is generally considered in Moroccan society as ‘lack of modesty’ (2003: 67). Sadiqi notes that the language of introductions reveals many aspects of a Moroccan’s self. Introductions involve interplay of cultural, social, situational and identity variables, which range from sex, local geographical origin, class, setting, participants’ age and selfinterest. Given this sociocultural context it was interesting to observe the freedom with which many Moroccans played with their identity online. It appears that of the three elements, age and sex are more important than location. Hamid gives his real age and sex. ‘If the other person is not interested in your location, you do not tell’. Giving the location can sometimes hinder access to chatters. Lal, a Sri Lankan male, noted that although he wanted to chat with Western females, they would not respond, only women from the Philippines did.
38
Learning Cultures in Online Education
Cultural and social stereotyping occurs through names, nicknames and pseudonyms. Mohammed used to have an ID ‘Mohammed’, but decided to change it because when he entered North American and British chat rooms, he was accused of terrorism and was verbally assaulted. He feels his new ID ‘green Python’ is attractive enough to gain access to people. Other IDs used by female participants included: ‘Scarlet’, ‘Diva’ and ‘Tzay’. Sarath, a Sri Lankan male, noted that to appeal to different audiences, he changes his identity. As in this instance, disclosing real names that are strongly associated with a religious, racial or ethnic group could hinder communication online, whereas a nickname can enable a chatter to stay in an online relationship and probably build social presence through other means such as ideas, and taste (Gunawardena et al. 2006). Continual construction and reconstruction of self-identity requires fluidity during virtual interactions (Khalsa 2007), and may influence the way self and group identity is perceived during team interactions in online communities. Discussing how CMC and cybercaf´e culture are appropriated by individuals and groups in Morocco, Graiouid (2005) argues that CMC mediates the construction of cybernetic identities and promotes the rehearsal of invented social and gender relations. This inventive accommodation of the internet referred to as ‘virtual hrig’ in Morocco makes computer-mediated interaction especially through chat and asynchronous discussion groups act as a contradiction to dominant patriarchal and conservative power structures. He points out that cyber interaction is contributing to the expansion of the public sphere in Morocco, and that the construction of ‘cybernetic identities provides disenfranchised communities with a resistance space to deal with global exclusion and marginalization’ (2005: 59). In the traditionbound, isolated and impoverished village of Ainleuh in Morocco, many of the women were looking for relationships with foreigners and Moroccans outside their community as a form of escape. Therefore, construction of identity on the internet and the anonymity afforded by the medium will pave the way for marginalized individuals to express their ideas freely within an online community. Building trust Identity is closely linked to building trust. Many will not reveal their true identity until they can trust the other person. From the initial encounter chatters spend their time trying to determine the trustworthiness of the other person. Chatters use several techniques to establish the trustworthiness of the other person before revealing their true identity. The most common trust-building technique is to ask a series of questions in the initial online contact and ask the same questions again later to determine the
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
39
consistency or inconsistency in the answers. Many mentioned time as an important factor for building trust. This is clear in the technique of using questions over time and repeating them to establish continuity and sameness. If in the same country, chatters give out their mobile phone numbers in order to verify the trustworthiness of the other. Most respondents prefer e-mail when the online relationship gets longer and stronger. They feel that e-mail communication is more ‘serious’ and ‘honest’ than chat. Another advantage of e-mail is that there is less time pressure to answer immediately. Some cannot write fast and this can affect the flow of communication and even the chatter’s interest. Therefore, the speed of writing can be a factor in establishing trust. The use of mobile phones and e-mail is significant because it suggests the ways in which chatters view the development of cyber relationships and how they ‘hierarchize’ the methods of communication: chatting – low risk and easy to dismiss; e-mail – more personal involving larger risk; mobile phones – higher risk, requiring a degree of trust. Self-disclosure Self-disclosure emerged as a factor related to trust-building and expression of identity. Many participants indicated that the trustworthiness of the other is expressed through the disclosure of their private life. They insist on the importance of personal experiences, intimate problems as well as ideas to get to know each other better. Anonymity increases the ability to self-disclose. Joinson (2003) confirms this finding by citing studies that show that visually anonymous CMC leads to higher levels of self-disclosure. Where there is an unequal distribution of power in society, such as in Sri Lanka and Morocco, online communication equalizes participants. Respondents felt that talking online can break barriers to communication between people of different classes, professions and sexes. Anonymity also encourages relationships that are superficial. A male participant noted that it is not necessary to reveal the truth, because he does not have an intention of continuing the friendship. When trust is established, participants are more likely to reveal their true identity. Face negotiation Face is an identity phenomenon. Ting-Toomey (1994) defines face as ‘the presentation of a civilized front to another individual within the webs of interconnected relationships in a particular culture’ (1994: 1). For our study, we defined face as an individual’s claimed conception of his/her positive self-image within interpersonal online interactions. Face negotiation
40
Learning Cultures in Online Education
was defined as the individual’s intentions to portray his/her self-image in a positive manner to others by utilizing verbal, nonverbal and self-representation methods to support his/her conception of face. In online chat sessions, the nature of the relationship determines reactions to insults and the negotiation of face. Chatters will close the window if the relationship is weak, and employ a variety of techniques to resolve misunderstandings and negotiate face if the relationship is stronger. A 35year-old Sri Lankan male respondent observed: It depends on the friendship. If the friendship is new then you are not bothered. If the friendship is deep then you feel that the person is next to you. In that instance you would like to continue the friendship. Generally, many respondents would first seek an explanation and then decide on other courses of action, such as shutting down the communication, ignoring the person, insulting back, or asking for an apology. An apology is requested if the person or the relationship is valued. E-mail is resorted to in order to clarify the situation, settle misunderstandings and present apologies. E-mail is preferable if the relationship has been going on for a long time and if the insulted person thinks that it is not intentional but is the result of a misunderstanding. According to Oetzel et al. (2000), three distinct factors are consistent with categorizations of face concerns in face negotiation: (1) dominating face work behaviour; (2) avoiding face work behaviour and; (3) integrating face work behaviour. The first factor, dominating face work behaviour, emphasizes the importance of asserting and defending one’s face or self-interest with the use of direct tactics to threaten the other party’s face in order to defeat the other person for self-gain. This behaviour is seen in individuals who are aggressively trying to ‘win the conflict’ and do not care about the other’s face. The second factor, avoiding face work behaviour, emphasizes obliging or saving the face of the other party involved in the conflict in order not to embarrass the other person’s face directly. This behaviour is seen in individuals who do not want to deal directly with the conflict, or are concerned with maintaining relational harmony. The third factor, integrating face work behaviour, emphasizes a mutual concern for both self-face and other-face by compromising or discussing the conflict in private. This behaviour is seen in individuals who are interested in maintaining selfand other-face while dealing directly with the conflict in a private setting. Gunawardena et al. (2002) supported these categorizations for the online context from their research with ethnically diverse participants. The ability to confront people and read their faces is not possible while chatting unless there is a camera. In Morocco and Sri Lanka, face-to-face
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
41
communication patterns are more high context and less direct than in the United States. It is generally difficult to communicate context in the online medium. In Morocco, for example, there are many taboos and behaviours that imply ‘hchouma’ or ‘shame’, and which thus should be avoided during communication. Many questions do not get answered because chatters cannot be very direct and tell them to the face of the other. This opens up room for interpretation and sometimes miscommunication. Sadiqi (2003) observes that the concept of collective self is so deep in the Moroccan psyche that an individual’s self-image is not cultivated internally, but derives from others’ opinions and attitudes, which is manifested clearly in the concept of ‘hchouma’, which may be defined as the ‘fear of losing face in front of others’ (2003: 67). This explains the heavy pressure within the Moroccan family to protect all its members because bad behaviour from one member affects the reputation of all. To avoid ‘shame’ Moroccans may refrain from admitting blatant realities in public if they involve a loss of face. According to Ting-Toomey (1988), low-context cultures emphasize individual identity, self-face concern, and direct verbal and nonverbal expression. In contrast, high-context cultures emphasize group identity, otherface concern, and indirect verbal and nonverbal expression. However when online, whether a person is from a high-context or from a low-context culture does not matter, as anonymity is a factor in the attempt to negotiate face. The elimination of title, gender and other status cues can create a more neutral atmosphere. If the person who threatens face is a stranger, he or she will be ignored. Therefore, attempts to negotiate face depend on the strength of the relationship that has been built. Face-saving strategies are adopted when there is a bond and when there is an interest in maintaining the relationship. If not, in the real-time world of chat, the general tendency is to close the window and forget the person.
Gender online The results of our analyses indicated that men and women employ different communication styles when chatting. Men and women value different forms of communication and different kinds of online interactions. The online environment gives them the anonymity and freedom to act out gender roles and experiment with gender identity. Graiouid (2005) observes that in order to understand reconstruction of gender relations on the internet, it is important to consider the norms that rule the distribution of space in Moroccan society. In Moroccan society, interaction between men and women is produced and reconstructed through a hierarchical mapping of space. Citing the work of Mernissi
42
Learning Cultures in Online Education
(1975), Graiouid points out how this gender divide is institutionalized through a strict definition of spatial practices: ‘(strict) space boundaries divide Moroccan society into subuniverses: the universe of men, the Umma (nation) universe of religion and power and the universe of sexuality and the family’ (Mernissi 1975: 81). Sadiqi (2003) affirms this dichotomy between public and private space in Morocco, where public space is the street and the market place, the domain of men, and private space is the home, where women live. In general, though women have access to public spaces, stepping out into the street is still felt by many as an act of trespassing into a hostile male domain. Sadiqi further elaborates that Moroccan culture is of a type that strongly constrains the behaviour of men and women and lists eight influences on gender perception, gender subversion and language use: (1) history (2) geography (3) Islam (4) morality (5) multilingualism (6) social organization (7) economic status and (8) political system. Given this sociocultural context, internet communication provides a tremendous opportunity to create virtual identities that can breach the dichotomy of public and private space that exists in Moroccan society. Graiouid (2005) notes that this may explain why female chatters enjoy the anonymity of the World Wide Web, which allows them to build relationships without compromising themselves. Gender stereotypes prevail in the creation of identity as reflected in the following perspectives from Moroccan participants. Jamal admits that it is easy to disguise himself as a woman. He tries to describe the experience of a woman chatting with a man but thinks that the experience is bound to be short-lived. In posing as a woman, he talks about women’s topics such as dress and fashion. Hamid thinks that women rarely discuss social issues. They are mostly interested in personal experiences, and love affairs. When asked about how he can tell if a man is posing as a woman, he says that exaggeration is what gives away a man posing as a woman. For example, somebody you have known for a short time saying that ‘they cannot live without you or that they love you’ is likely to be male. Hassan thinks that women tend to discuss their daily schedules and errands more than men. He thinks that chat is like a game that could turn into a healthy relationship or end quickly. Analysis of interviews from Sri Lanka also indicated gender differences in the expression of identity. Generally males disclose their true ASL identity from the start, irrespective of the purpose of the communication (chat or academic forums). A 23-year-old male student observed: I’ll tell that I am a webmaster from Sri Lanka and this is my website. I also tell my age and gender. Usually when males get to know that I am a male, they won’t continue. But if someone is interested in my research area then they will continue. Usually chatting among males is less. But females prefer to chat with females.
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
43
Sri Lankan females are much more cautious than males. They do not reveal their true identity in unknown communities. They either give only the first name or use a pseudonym and do not reveal much personal information. Once they establish the relationship then they will talk more about their personal lives. On the other hand, if females are chatting to get academic help, then, they reveal their true identity. A 34-year-old female responded: I give my name, interests and field. Don’t say the age and location. If I want to get information then I give the name of the institution. If they ask personal information, then, I ignore those and if that person is a difficult one, then block the use. A majority of females prefer to communicate only with females. They are reluctant to talk with unknown male counterparts unless they have been introduced by one of their friends or relations, reflecting social norms and practices. Most of them chat with local and Asian communities, as they feel more secure communicating with them. A 26-year-old female observed: I will reveal about myself; true name, country, my age and sex. I usually log on to the Asian countries’ chatting rooms. I feel that it is not dangerous to chat with the Asians and I feel that they are not bad compared to other western countries. So I will reveal my own identity. Gender differences emerged in establishing social presence. Many felt that you need to choose adequate and suitable topics when talking with someone of the opposite sex. Tone is also important. Male participants claim that they do not talk in the same way to males and females. With females they are more cautious and more flattering. As to communicating with females, most respondents suggest that they depend on establishing social presence by asking about tastes in music, movies, reading, sports and dress styles. They feel that women tend to communicate their presence through description of their daily lives and their personal problems. When males chat with other males, subjects of discussion tend to be about political, social and abstract problems. Preferences for chat partners differed. Moroccan men were mostly interested in chatting with Western girls, and Moroccan women were mostly interested in men outside Morocco, predominantly Europe. Graiouid (2005) points out that the negative image Moroccan female chat users have of Moroccan males partly accounts for their interests in correspondents from other countries. Female informants in his study, consider Moroccan male chat users to be poorly conversant with the etiquette of interaction and
44
Learning Cultures in Online Education
discussion. In general, they hold against them a lack of genuine commitment to the virtual relationships they start and a general absence of tact and sensitivity. Graiouid (2005) presents further insights on this issue from his cybercaf´e research in Morocco. He notes that while European chat rooms where males and females inter-mingle freely are very popular with Moroccans, most of his female informants stated that they are also regulars at www.arabia.com because it is the congregation site for Arabs from different geographic locations. According to his informants, Moroccan female chat users prefer cybernetic correspondence with fellow Muslims from Europe or North America, because in case the virtual interaction develops into a more serious relationship it would be ethically viable and socially more acceptable for them to wed a Muslim. This is why most of them prefer not to commit to a correspondence when the user’s identity does not correspond to the profile they seek. He further discusses his visit to a cybercaf´e located near a mosque in Rabat, the capital city of Morocco, where at the call for prayer, chatters exit the ‘profane’ World Wide Web and cross over to the sacred realm of the mosque. These examples indicate that while the invention of identity and openness of communication in synchronous chats can be a liberating experience, there is still the underlying influence of sociocultural norms and conventions in traditional society, which the chat communicants find difficult to overcome. Unlike the Moroccans who sought European chat rooms in this study, many Sri Lankan men and women spent their time chatting with the opposite sex within the same country. A Sri Lankan male noted that he prefers to discuss his personal problems with females, as they are apt to give better advice than a male. Sri Lankans reported less chatting among males, whereas females prefer to chat with females. These findings indicate differences in the ways men and women interact online. Women and men do exhibit different styles in posting to the internet, contrary to the claim that CMC neutralizes distinctions of gender. Gender and self-disclosure When trust is established, participants are more likely to reveal their true identity. Generally, both females and males have reservations when revealing their personal details to an unknown group of people. Both do not reveal their personal information till they build up their relationship. Building up this relationship takes time with several messages (sometimes about 3 months). The basis is mere instinct, the ‘feeling’ that they get from reading messages, the ‘feel’ of the other or ‘social presence’ in mediated communication. Once they feel that the person is ‘genuine’ then they start revealing their personal details. A 23-year-old female observed:
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
45
If I feel that this person is a genuine person and could be trusted then I reveal myself. I prefer if that person is open with me. Females are very cautious of the way they write and also expect respect from others. Manel, a 27-year-old female observed: Yes, I am very cautious. I won’t reveal my personal information. I think twice and write. It’s too much effort from my part to write answers like this and is an additional burden for me. Sri Lankan women were not comfortable with self-disclosure, hardly ever divulging information on private life in a chat session. Ramani, a 34-year-old Sri Lankan female responded: Some ask unnecessary questions – comment on your figure, mention about body parts etc. We are not used to those. It’s our culture. I know this is normal to the rest of the world. So I take precautions and tell them that I am not that sort of lady. Let them respect us as well. Some males do not hesitate to place their own photograph on the web. One particular male uses different font sizes and colours to make it more attractive: ‘ I use a webcam and give a profile with the picture. I usually use 14–16 font with shaded colors’. Females hardly ever send their photographs. But some who are familiar with computers use different fonts, colours and emoticons (smileys) when they send messages. ‘I use emoticons. Those are quick. Use font like comic sans for friends and Arial and Centre Gothic with official group. Use short cuts like Y, U, etc. Different techniques for different people’. Chat users have developed various conventions to present their identity and persona in chat sessions and will reveal their true identity depending on the context. Gender and face negotiation Herring (1994) illustrates gender differences in face negotiation from her study sample. The female style takes into consideration the ‘face’ wants of the addressee – specifically, the desire of the addressee to feel ratified and liked (e.g. by expressions of appreciation) and her desire not to be imposed upon (e.g. by absolute assertions that don’t allow alternative views). The male style, in contrast, confronts and threatens the addressee’s ‘face’ in the process of engaging him in agonistic debate. Both female and male respondents in our study noted that they take extra care to resolve their online misunderstandings and negotiate face if
46
Learning Cultures in Online Education
the relationship is strong. If they fail online, they will telephone and explain the situation. Females are more likely to negotiate even when the relationship is not that strong. Usually males chat for entertainment and they do not expect long-lasting relationships online. Therefore, when there is a misunderstanding and misinterpretation, they do not make an extra attempt to resolve the conflict. On the other hand, females make the extra effort to resolve the misunderstanding. Davidson and Schofield (2002) support this finding by citing research on virtual interactions that indicates women are more relational than men – women are more likely to approach the world as an individual within a social network; more likely to acquire skills in developing and sustaining personal connections and more likely to seek out situations and develop behaviours that foster relationships. Gender and online harassment Harassment online emerged as an issue of concern related to gender and the expression of identity. A female Moroccan participant described how she used to give her true credentials at first and got into trouble, and then changed her approach and started to claim a different identity (that of a French girl) when she entered chat rooms in order to avoid being harassed. Another female Moroccan participant noted that she used to present herself by giving her real name and real information. Then a friend told her how stupid that is, ‘because it is different, a man can feel alright about giving his real information but a woman can’t’. Because she is a girl, she now asks chatters to guess her name. If the chatter is from Europe or America she gives him her real name, but not if he is from Morocco. Women tend to hide their identities more because they will be targeted by chatters and harassed. Females were more cautious than males in revealing their identity online for fear of being harassed. This is a cultural feature of online communication that transcends nationality. Harassment online is a serious concern not only for women but also for children.
The language of chat Innovations in language forms to adapt to communication via chat was one of the most interesting findings of this study. While the predominant language of chat in Morocco was French and in Sri Lanka, English, participants interjected the native language using the Latin keyboard to increase their level of social presence and connectedness when they were chatting with people who understood the native language. Moroccan Arabic is an oral language and its transliteration into the Latin script enabled participants to express their affective, emotional self
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
47
to connect with the other through text-based communication. Hassan said he could convey his true feelings by using Moroccan Arabic expressions when the other party knows the language. Examples of Moroccan Arabic written in Latin script in chat sessions and in text messaging (SMS) follow: (1)
(2)
(3)
MNIN DEFNOU’H MA ZA’ROU’H (‘Since they buried him, they forgot about him’) an expression that means, ‘After you used me, you forgot me’. This is a common expression written in numbers (3, 7, 9), which carries a similar meaning to: ‘Why have you not kept in touch with me?’ Numbers used to express Arabic characters and sounds 3 → (ain) 9 → (kah) 8 → (hah). Salam 3alikoum! (Greeting).
These examples show conventions that chatters have adopted for chat and SMS to express cultural understanding in written form through the creation of commonly understood ways of symbolizing social and emotional meaning and contexts. As Sadiqi (2003) observes, orality is an important component of Moroccan culture; speech carries greater significance than writing in regulating everyday life, as communication is mainly channelized through unwritten languages. Chatters have therefore developed conventions to express the nuances of unwritten languages in a written medium. Mounia chats in English and French and switches to French when she gets angry. She does not insult in English but responds in French. She feels that insulting in Moroccan Arabic is ‘low’ and despicable, but insulting in French is acceptable. Many who were fluent in French and Moroccan Arabic indicated that French would be the language to use for insults as insulting in Arabic would lower their status. For Mustapha, changing languages would mean that he is weak and afraid, so he would continue in the same language. Khalid sometimes uses Moroccan Arabic because expressions are shorter than French. For example, ‘how are you?’ in Arabic is ‘ki dayer?’ Chatters mix both French, a written language and Moroccan Arabic and an oral language if their communicants understand both languages. These are examples of code-switching, which is a common practice in a multilingual society like Morocco. ‘Code-switching is the use of more than one, usually two, languages or “codes” simultaneously’ (Sadiqi 2003: 258). Both men and women use code-switching in their everyday conversations in Morocco, but codeswitching is more associated with women than with men. Sadiqi observes that code-switching indicates social attributes and composite identities.
48
Learning Cultures in Online Education
The switching of Berber and Moroccan Arabic is both a rural and an urban phenomenon and involves literate and nonliterate speakers as Moroccan Arabic and Berber are nonwritten mother tongues, whereas switching of Moroccan Arabic and French, and switching of Berber and French are typically urban and involve educated speakers only. While the switching of Berber and Moroccan Arabic is seen in all social classes, switching of Moroccan Arabic and French is more characteristic of middle and upper classes. Similar innovations in the use of native languages via the Latin keyboard were observed in Sri Lanka. In Sri Lanka, the predominant chat language is English for the Sinhalese, Tamils and Muslims. In Sri Lanka, the variety of English spoken is different from that spoken in Britain and other parts of the world because of the influences the native languages have exerted on the structure of English (Disanayaka 1998). Chatters often communicate by writing their native language using the English alphabet. Sinhala and Tamil are phonetic languages, which can be written using the English alphabet and Latin keyboard. Perhaps the technique the chatters have adopted to transliterate their native language using the English alphabet and the Latin keyboard maybe one way to solve the language problem in Sri Lanka. Both Sinhala and Tamil chatters can learn about each other’s language without having to learn a new alphabet and a new script if they are able to write their language in English. Sri Lankans also used code-switching, the mixture of English and Sinhala, for example. Ramani explained that writing in Sinhala generates more feeling than writing in English. Examples of Sinhala written in English include: (1) Ayubowan – How are you? (2) Paw – I feel sorry for you Examples of Tamil written in English include: Aniyayam – what a waste! Sri Lankans also felt that phrases such as ‘machan’, which means ‘buddy’ when written in English, generate closeness and social presence. The level of language and the quality of opinions help chatters in Morocco build each other’s profiles. Kenza relies on language (idiomatic expressions such as the ones associated with native French speakers) to generate social presence. Abdelali examines the English used by chatters and the amount of mistakes made, especially if the person claims to be from an Englishspeaking country such as the UK or USA. In this case, the level and type of language use can be a factor in creating credibility. Chatters enhance their social presence by using other media such as mobile phones and webcams. It was fairly common to see chatters talking
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
49
to the same person on the mobile phone while chatting online. Some Moroccans spoke Arabic on the mobile phone and French online indicating their versatility in moving between different languages. The use of the two types of media enhanced their presence and connection with each other. Some chatters used emoticons (icons that express emotion) or smileys to enhance their presence and express their emotions. Others stated that they use text to express their emotions. Hamid expresses his persona through icons. He is very interested in showing that he is a man and that he is Moroccan, and that in Morocco the man is the one who decides for the woman. When asked if women continue to keep talking to him after this admission, he said that they keep on the discussion to know more about his perspectives and that it is a good way to exchange cultural aspects about the topic. In analyzing communication conventions online, it is evident that chatters have developed unique forms of textual language and visual expressions to communicate their ideas and feelings through a new medium. They bring with them the conventions of their native language, which embody cultural traits as well as their prior use of the second language, English or French. ‘Language and culture develop together. Language is an essential part of culture’ (Wickramasinghe 1997: 25). This implies that as online learning cultures develop, students and facilitators will have to adjust to new modes of communication and interaction. Since language is an important factor in the negotiation of meaning in an online community, it is important to develop theoretical models of language to guide future practice (Tusting 2005). ‘An important step towards cross-cultural understanding could therefore be the development of policies and practices which allow for an element of multi-lingual communication, making space for the expression of social behavior free of the constraints of operating in a second language’ (Goodfellow et al. 2001: 80).
Implications for online learning communities We now address the implications we can draw from these findings of informal synchronous communication within two different cultural contexts for the development of online learning communities. We found that CMC is not a mere neutral technological innovation but a practice that is affected by the culture and society of its users. As discussed earlier, we used the definition of ‘idioculture’, developed by Fine (cited in Cole & Engestr¨om 2007) as a system of knowledge, beliefs, behaviours and customs shared by members of an interacting group to which members can refer and that serve as the basis of further interaction, as a framework for examining
50
Learning Cultures in Online Education
culture online. This definition enabled us to examine online culture as a unique phenomenon in its own right. Three themes emerged from the data analysis: identity, gender and language, interacting with each other in their expression in synchronous chat. Given the unique online cultures developed by interacting groups, and the themes that emerged, we draw the following implications for learning cultures. 1. The creation of identity and playing with identity online enables a participant to learn about herself/himself. It is a psychological tool that enables one to experience the real world in a new way. The ability to change one’s environment and try out different ways of being will lend itself well to role play and computer simulations as favoured learning methods in online learning communities. 2. Expression of identity through introductions is important for relationship building in online learning communities. However, self-disclosure may not be easy for some participants. Since identity is expressed in different ways by diverse individuals, careful attention must be given to how self-presentation and introductions are done online. Therefore, rather than making self-introductions an open-ended activity, guidelines and protocols should be provided for how introductions should be done, and the type of information desired, also allowing for some degree of anonymity. An alternative technique might be to have participants introduce each other online, rather than themselves. Introductions also assist in the building of social presence, or the feeling that the other is a real person, when communication is mediated by the computer. 3. Since posting photographs with introductions can lead to stereotyping and reduce the anonymity that will make a learning community a level playing field, it is important to devise other means of self-disclosure, especially to provide a comfort zone for women who are more reluctant to self-disclose to an unknown community, and to maintain social equality of the group. For example, participants could be asked to post a picture or image that represents them, with an explanation as to why the picture/image represents them. 4. Building trust and relationships are crucial for the health and wellbeing of a learning community. Trust-building group activities should be conducted during pre-course activities or during the first 2 weeks of an academic course to help participants build trust and become comfortable with each other. 5. Attempts to negotiate face and resolve conflict depends on the strength of the relationship that has been built. Therefore, face-saving strategies should be part of the communication protocols developed for online
Identity, Gender and Language in Synchronous Cybercultures
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
51
learning communities. Learners should be encouraged to use e-mail to resolve misunderstandings and post mutually agreed-upon understandings for the group when conflict situations arise. Women are more likely to make an attempt to resolve misunderstandings and negotiate face and should be encouraged to take up moderating roles in team interactions. Communication protocols developed for online learning communities need to alert participants to gender differences in communication patterns. Context is important to understanding messages and therefore participants should be encouraged to provide the context to enable the deciphering of messages communicated through an ephemeral and fluid medium. Moderators or facilitators play an important role in relationship building and community-building activities, and in maintaining a safe and conducive environment for all participants, and therefore, should be present online frequently. It is recommended that online designs allow for an element of multilingual communication, and diversity, in the expression of English. This will promote cross-cultural understanding and a comfort zone in online communication. In many developing countries, the internet caf´e maybe the only resource centre where learners will gather to participate in online learning. Academic institutions wishing to provide access to learners in geographically isolated locations should make arrangements with internet caf´es to provide technology access and resources necessary for their academic programs.
These implications and guidelines will hopefully lead to the design of online learning environments that foster community and knowledge building. Issues of identity, gender and language will continue to provide impetus for further research in our efforts to understand the learning cultures that develop in these environments.
Acknowledgment This research study was supported by a Fulbright Regional Research Scholarship awarded to the principal author by the United States Department of State, 2004–2005.
Chapter 3
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education: Challenging and Developing Teacher Identities Robert O’Dowd University of Leon, ´ Spain
Introduction Tools of online communication have been used widely in the field of foreign language education due to their capacity to engage learners in authentic intercultural communication with members of other cultures (Belz 2003; O’Dowd 2007), and also due to their ability to facilitate collaborative project work and student publishing. In general, attitudes to the integration of such online activity in the world of foreign language education have been (in Western societies, at least) very positive and teachers who take part in such online activity are generally portrayed as innovative and progressive (Hides 2005). These positive attitudes have often been accompanied by the assumption that language-learning activity online is by nature communicative and learner-centred. This belief stems perhaps from the discourse of Network Based Language Teaching (NBLT), which, as is the case of e-learning in general, is generally located within sociocultural and social constructivist approaches to learning and thereby lays great emphasis on learner-centred learning and on active participation of the learner in online communities (Warschauer & Kern 2000; Oliver et al. 2007). While we would argue that the learner-centred approaches to learning promoted by researchers and educators are essentially positive, we would also suggest that this trend has been at the cost of developing a deeper understanding of the experiences of the teacher in online environments,
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
53
with the online teacher being described in very general terms such as a ‘guide on the side’ or ‘a facilitator of knowledge rather than the font of wisdom’ (Warschauer & Healey 1998: 57)’. Laurillard confirms this emphasis on the learner in her introduction to a publication on e-learning in Higher Education: Whatever their original discipline, the most eminent writers on learning have emphasized the importance of active learning. The choice of language may vary – [. . .] Piaget’s constructivism, Vygotsky’s social constructivism [. . .] – but the shared essence is the recognition that learning concerns what the learner is doing rather than what the teacher is doing. (Laurillard, 2005: 2–3, our italics) Against this backdrop, we would argue that it now becomes particularly important to engage in research which looks not only at how teachers are coming to terms with the tools and practices of online education (see Egbert et al. 2002), but also at how they deal with the prevalent ‘didactic culture’ (i.e. pedagogical beliefs and discourse), which permeates online learning and which is often employed in the design of online learning tools (Dyke et al. 2007). While so-called ‘innovators’ may have taken relatively quickly to the practices and pedagogies of online education, many other educators have found themselves entering this new world of learning and teaching, not out of conviction or desire but rather due to the social or institutional pressure to engage in an activity which is seen as inherently positive and progressive. Furthermore, these educators have at times found themselves in situations where widely held assumptions about the nature and the practices of online activity have clashed with their own beliefs about how learning takes place and how students learn. The question arises as to what will be the outcomes of online learning activity where the beliefs and practices of teachers do not reflect the common practices of online learning and its accompanying discourse and pedagogy. This chapter begins by exploring how the prevalent didactic culture of social constructivism has been represented in the design of Moodle, a popular Virtual Learning Environment (VLE). This educational tool allows teachers to create a location on the internet where a class of learners can view course materials, interact and collaborate with classmates and their teacher using synchronous and asynchronous tools, access reference materials and engage in interactive activities (Franklin & Peat 2001; Cole 2005). Following that, Layder’s (1993) research map for social realism is used to examine how three educators at a university in Spain employed the platform, what significance its use had for them as professional educators, and, most significantly, how they dealt with similarities and differences between their own approaches to learning and teaching and that of the pervasive
54
Learning Cultures in Online Education
culture of online learning. The three case studies illustrate how the culture of online learning and teaching that surrounds many online learning artefacts is limited or shaped by the social and institutional contexts in which the tools are located, as well as by the dispositions and agency of the individuals involved.
Didactic culture in online foreign language education Despite its origins and development in the United States and Western Europe, the internet has often been thought of as a culture-free environment, which can be exploited by all those who have the economic and literacy resources available to them to do so. However, as early as 2000, writers such as Hawisher and Selfe had questioned the accuracy of this perception and had highlighted how this utopian vision of the web is closely related to the North American image of the global village (2000: 6–7). The authors describe how this concept of the global village originated in the time of the telegraph and depicts technology as a tool for establishing a global network, which erases difference between cultures and establishes a sense of international community and union. The authors are unconvinced by this interpretation, suggesting that many cultures are likely to see the extension of these technologies as ‘less a neutral and welcome medium for global communication than a disturbing and unwelcome system for broadening western colonial culture and values’ (2000: 9). As researchers have moved away from the assumption that the internet somehow removes or suppresses cultural difference, a growing number of publications (in particular special issues of journals such as the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication (volume 11, page 1) and the British Journal of Educational Technology (volume 30, page 3), have looked more critically at the interaction that takes place between online cultural norms and the educational cultures in which learners are operating. In this interpretation of online learning, online learning tools are seen to have their own culturally determined etiquettes of use, which has been heavily influenced by Anglo-American values and norms of communication. This culture of online behaviour is based on the principles of speed (i.e. quick responses to interaction), openness (as opposed to privacy), debate and informality (Reeder et al. 2004) and it is argued that online cultural behaviour will be constructed through the interaction of these online norms with those of the learning and teaching cultures in which individuals are operating in their local educational institutions. For example, Thorne (2003) found that communication tools such as e-mail or instant messaging were not neutral educational objects but rather carried certain cultural associations and characteristics that they have acquired from their use in
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
55
everyday life in specific cultural contexts. Thorne took the example of the use of e-mail in an online intercultural exchange between an North American and a French student and explained how the project failed to gather momentum as neither student saw e-mail as an appropriate tool for exchanging informal messages with partners of their own age. E-mail, according to the North American student in the study, was suitable for more formal communication between students and teachers, while studentto-student communication was considered more suited to tools such as Microsoft MessengerTM . As VLEs have achieved great popularity among online educators, their relationship with online culture and online didactic culture has taken on particular relevance. Along with Blackboard and WebCT, Moodle has become one of the most popular examples of these tools in educational institutions around the globe. Evidence of this success can be found in the statistics provided by the Moodle homepage and elsewhere (Cole 2005). Moodle’s authors report, for example, that there are over 24,000 registered institutions using the platform in their classes. These institutions are located in 175 countries and are offering courses in 75 different languages. In Spain, the country where this study was carried out, over 1,300 schools and universities are using Moodle, and many Spanish universities have taken the step of adapting Moodle as the official institutional platform of use (Molist 2006). The principal difference between Moodle and other platforms (e.g. WebCT or First ClassTM ) is that its authors lay claim to a particular didactic philosophy and culture, which they refer to as ‘socioconstructionist’ pedagogy. This theory of learning has much in common with other studentcentred approaches, which have been used to orientate the integration of online technologies into education such as ‘active learning’ (Laurillard 2005), ‘collaborative and social-interactive learning’ (Kramsch & Thorne 2002) or ‘social constructivist learning’ (Parks et al. 2003). (As it is this final term which has become most widespread in the literature, this will be the one used from now on.) Based on the sociocultural theory of Vygotksy (1978), these approaches involve a shift from a cognitive to a social perspective on education and see learning being achieved most successfully when learners are actively engaged in meaningful collaborative project work and problem solving with their classmates and other more capable peers (Windschitl 2002; Felix 2005). Moodle does indeed carry a great many functions, which can, in principle at least, be used to support student interaction, collaboration and the construction of shared artefacts. The platform offers teachers the possibility of introducing communicative functions such as synchronous chat and asynchronous discussion forums and also includes tools, which enable collaboration and evaluation of documents such as the wiki and workshop functions.
56
Learning Cultures in Online Education
We would argue that the presence of such a wide variety of communicative and collaborative tools, in combination with the platform’s statement of didactic principles and the location of this discourse within the pervasive discourse of online education with its emphasis on socioconstructivist learning practices, may act as an indirect pressure on teachers to use the VLE in this way. However, in order to identify whether Moodle is actually used in this fashion in a particular educational context, it will be necessary to situate the online learning activity within the broader socioinstitutional context. Factors such as the pedagogical approach of the teachers using the platform and the social and educational culture within which they are operating are likely to determine how the VLE is employed and what the outcomes of this learning activity are (Warschauer 2003). In the following section, a research methodology is presented, which serves to highlight this interconnectedness between the activity of using a VLE, social and institutional contexts and, finally, the aims, beliefs and past experiences of the teachers involved.
Research methodology The principal aim of this study was to explore how the teachers’ use of the online platform was influenced by aspects of their institutional context such as the educational culture in which they were operating, their own beliefs about learning in general and about the didactic culture which the platform (and the discourse surrounding online education in general) generally support. In order to achieve such an understanding of what online learning signified in this particular context, Layder’s (1993) research map for social realism was chosen. This map encourages the researcher to understand social activity (in this case, the integration of a VLE into a foreign language department) as being shaped by the complex interaction of both structure and agency. Structure refers to the macro-cultural context (e.g. societal attitudes to online technologies) and the local setting (e.g. university administrative policy in relation to technological innovation), while agency refers to the situated activity and the individual’s self -identity and social experiences (e.g. the teachers’ pedagogical beliefs and previous experiences of using technologies). Layder insists that all these elements should be seen as a whole and that ‘viewing the elements as a series of interwoven layers is useful since it helps us to understand how social activity is influenced by different aspects of society at specific points in time’ (1993: 10). Table 3.1 shows the four categories of Layder’s research map and also identifies the main themes which were of relevance in each category for this particular study. The final column identifies sources of the data for each
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
57
Table 3.1 A Research Map for Online Learning
Category
Description of category
Relevant categories and themes in this study
Sources of data used in this study
Context (macrolevel)
Macro-social organization Values, traditions, forms of social organization and power relations
Prevalent attitudes and beliefs in the educational community about online learning; online practices in Spain; use of technology in Spanish universities; Spanish attitudes to using technology in education
Surveys Newspaper reports
Setting (macrolevel)
Intermediate social organization – how institutions and bureaucracies are organized
Approaches to online learning at local institution; degree and types of institutional support for online learning initiatives
Survey data and reports from the local educational institution
Situated activity (microlevel)
Social activity – how the activity is understood, as it is affected by context and settings (above) and dispositions of individuals (below)
The activity of using the VLE in the University courses
Teacher interviews; student surveys; observations of classes and online practices
Self (microlevel)
Self-identity and individual’s social experience
The teachers and students involved and their sense of identity; perceptions of the world and their beliefs about (online) teaching and learning
Interviews, questionnaires, examples of online activity
Source: Adapted from Layder 1993.
58
Learning Cultures in Online Education
of the categories. The data used in the study was principally qualitative but quantitative statistical data was also employed when relevant. For example, statistical data about the use of new technologies in Spanish education in general was combined with in-depth interviews with the teachers at various stages during the academic year. These interviews were also triangulated with other sources of data such as observations of contact classes and online activity, teacher questionnaires and the collection and classification of artefacts such as on-line documents and extracts from on-line interaction.
Context and setting: online technologies in Spain and in the local institution In this study the context and setting in which the situated activity of using Moodle was located included a variety of elements, including the discourse surrounding online learning in the educational literature, the attitudes towards online learning of important national and local stakeholders such as university administrations and national government and, of course, widely held beliefs among university staff and students as to what online learning should involve. The online practices of young Spanish people has an undoubted importance here as it is this social group that makes up most of the teachers’ classrooms. Recent statistics by www.Red.es – a website run by the Spanish Ministry of Industry, Tourism and Commerce to inform about online activity in Spanish society – revealed that only 34 percent report using the internet for study and research purposes, while a survey carried out among the students of the Modern Languages Department as part of this particular study confirmed this limited take-up of online practices by Spanish students. Here, a significant minority of students (42 percent) reported not having access to the internet in their homes while 61 percent of the respondents reported logging on to the internet only ‘once’ or ‘two or three’ times per week. Furthermore, interviews carried out at the beginning of the university year with students who would be taking part in Moodle-enhanced courses revealed a rather traditional image of what on-line learning could and should involve. One student suggested: ‘I see online platforms as a helpful, back-up tool. It could be a gate to other online resources and it could contain texts in more syllabus-heavy subjects’, while another commented: ‘I imagine this could be a comfortable way of submitting homework without having to go to class and maybe finding links to new activities and resources’. In the first decade of the new millennium, in Spain (as in many other countries), great importance has been attributed to online learning and the integration of information and communication technologies (ICT)
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
59
at university level education. However, the integration of online learning structures in Spanish campuses remains very much a work in progress, which often stems from administrative and governmental initiatives rather than from teacher-initiated activity. For example, an extensive study carried out on the integration of ICT across the Spanish university system (Barren ´ & Burillo Lopez 2006) revealed that while universities were clearly investing heavily in online resources and facilities, the staff uptake of online learning initiatives remained limited. The study reported, for example, that only 15 percent of university teaching staff had completed training in how to use ICT in their classes. It also found that while 96 percent of Spanish universities had an e-learning platform under development, only 43 percent of teachers had reported using platforms in their classes. Recent developments at the University where this study was carried out reflect this general national interest in online learning and teaching. For example, in the 2 years before this study, a new state-of-the-art centre for information and communication technologies had been established and wireless internet access had been made available throughout the campus. The university had also made it possible for students and teachers to carry out a great deal of course administration online, such as the publishing of exam results and registration for courses and had introduced its own e-learning platform, which contained basic administrative and communicative functions. A report published in a daily provincial newspaper highlights the importance of the development of the University’s online learning initiatives in the local community, but, significantly, also serves to illustrate common local perceptions of what online learning might involve. The headline ran: ‘The web of a thousand and one uses: The University digitalises its administrative affairs and next year will include a tool which will enable teachers to move their class content online’ (Gonz´alez 2005: 3). It is within these national and local settings (i.e. the context and setting in Layder’s framework) that the three case studies reported here are located. In general it is a context where students are gradually becoming more at home in online environments and where online learning initiatives in education are highly valued both by society and by university administrations. However, these high levels of economic investment, ‘top-down’ initiatives and support are not always reflected in significant increases in online activity by teachers in their courses. Furthermore, common perceptions of what online learning should involve tend to refer to new ways of publishing and disseminating materials (i.e. the publication of collections of links and the transfer of materials from hard copy to virtual formats) rather than to the development of new didactic practices. The department of Modern Languages at this University adopted the virtual learning environment Moodle in the academic year 2004–2005. The
60
Learning Cultures in Online Education
director of the department encouraged all teaching staff to use the platform in their undergraduate teaching as having an online presence was, he argued, ‘an important part of the profession’s future’. An introductory workshop was organized by technical support staff to introduce teachers to the technicalities of using the Moodle platform, such as how to set up a course and register students. However, at no stage was staff trained in how to use the platform pedagogically. During its first year of availability at the English department in question, the platform was used in a blended format (i.e. combined with contact classes) by six different teachers for courses in foreign languages (i.e. French and English) and in various subjects related to Linguistics and Applied Linguistics. In my role both as researcher and as someone who had previous experience with the use of VLEs, I took the opportunity to study in what way three of the teachers used the online platform with their students. The three teachers who chose to use the platform and to allow me to observe and help in their experiences taught courses in English for Special Purposes (Isabel), Linguistics (Barbara) and English as a Foreign Language (Andrew). The following case studies look at the key issues that arise when the tools and didactic culture of online learning come into contact with teachers who form part of this particular socioeducational context.
Case study 1: step-by-step into online learning Barbara, a teacher of linguistics and grammar, is in her early thirties and has used technologies such as concordancing software, PowerPointTM and other Microsoft OfficeTM tools in her classes before. Recorded interviews and informal discussions with Barbara at the outset and during her first year using Moodle reveal an interesting range of findings in relation to why teachers turn to VLEs such as Moodle and the complex interplay of factors at context, setting and self -levels (see Table 3.1), which determine the meaning of the situated activity of VLE use. The first example of the interplay between micro and macro factors from Table 3.1 emerges from Barbara’s explanations as to why she chose to use the VLE in her teaching. Beginning at the level of self , Barbara appears to have opted to introduce Moodle into her classes in order to challenge herself as a teacher and also as a way of expanding her repertoire of teaching techniques. She describes her aims in the following way: I see it as a way of learning more myself, and a way of motivating myself to renew the content of my courses and above all, the way of teaching this content. It’s also about wanting to be up-to-date, meeting the challenge of finding online activities which suit the content of my course . . . this gives me a certain personal satisfaction.
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
61
However, these comments also reflect that, at the context level, incorporating online activities into one’s teaching in Spain is often associated with being a ‘modern’ teacher and wanting to improve and develop oneself professionally. Barbara therefore makes a connection between the situated activity of integrating an online platform and her own perception of self identity of being ‘up-to-date’ and with the process of motivating herself to renew her course material and to refresh her skills as a teacher. However, reflecting the common beliefs at the local setting level of what online learning actually involves (see the previous section), she does not believe that using the platform will actually affect the way she teaches her course. She explains, for example, that it is the online activities that have to adapt to ‘suit the content of my course’. The platform, therefore, has the function of being essentially a new form of delivery of current content and classroom activities. Barbara also identifies the potential that Moodle carries for increasing teacher-student contact and she relates the role of online learning to increasing student participation in general: The platform obviously improves the opportunities for collaboration both between students and between teacher and students. I can imagine that it will also increase their level of motivation and their desire to participate more in their learning as they will feel more involved, more “the centre of attention” because the online work strengthens the level of personalized attention. It’s a more interactive type of learning – they have to do different things such as registering and going online in order to get materials. They may also be more worried about not doing their exercises because this will be more obvious in the online platform than it would be in class when we correct exercises as a group. Here, the situated activity of teaching online takes its meaning firstly from the context level and the widespread beliefs in the educational community that online pedagogy calls for learning to be more student-centred and ‘active’. But this belief is filtered by Barbara’s own beliefs and understanding of what teacher and student roles should involve and, as a result, ‘studentcentred online activity’ is reduced to getting students to ‘log on’ in order to access material and to obliging them to do activities out of fear of being shown up in the online platform. In her courses, Barbara uses essentially three different functions of the platform. First, she provides students with the PowerPoint presentations, which have been previously viewed in class. Second, she publishes Word documents containing exercises based on the content of class work. Finally, she uses the ‘assignment’ function so that students can upload their completed worksheets on to the platform for correction. Despite her comments as to
62
Learning Cultures in Online Education
why she intended to use the platform, Barbara does not exploit the communicative functions of the platform in order to encourage student communication or to engage in more collaborative activities with the material at hand. Nevertheless, her evaluation of the platform towards the end of the course continues to refer to other, possibly more innovative, situated activities: The advantages of Moodle are enormous. One important aspect is the quantity of paper and time which it allows us to save: the students do not have to print out or hand in work in a printed format; neither do they have to queue up at the photocopy shop in order to get materials. As well as that, it’s a great tool for “sending them” to useful web pages and other resources which can be updated easily. Also, it strengthens teacherstudent communication and also the communication between the students themselves outside of class so that they can delve into aspects of our subject together in more detail, by carrying out debates, for example. Why does Barbara continue to refer to the potential of the platform for supporting learning practices based on student-student interaction even though she herself does not introduce these activities? It would appear that Barbara is happy to be associated professionally with a tool that offers these online communicative activities even though her own use of the VLE does not incorporate them. Once again, the meaning that the use of the VLE has in this context is strongly related to the positive and ‘modern’ associations, which online communication has in the learning communities at both setting and context levels, and it is this meaning that Barbara stakes claim to in her explanation of why she uses Moodle. However, a further possible explanation for the differences between Barbara’s aspirations and actual teaching practices emerges in the interviews, which suggests that impediments at the setting level may hinder or limit teachers’ plans. She explains that she was adapting a gradual approach to integrating the VLE due to the organizational and technical challenges which introducing an online learning platform is seen to involve: In my Linguistics course I realise I can add a lot more different activities, but considering this was my first “attempt” I am pretty happy [. . .] Next year I’ll repeat the things I’ve done this year and I’ll try out some new activities. I’ll include more resources like articles and web pages and above all I’ll develop the aspect of communication between the students with debates, online forums, etc. For Barbara, the move from traditional learning scenarios to blended formats using Moodle will take various stages which involve, first, transferring familiar class content and practices more or less directly into the online
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
63
platform and then, when this stage has been completed, gradually introducing more innovative aspects such as online debates. This explanation echoes the findings reported by Egbert et al. (2002) that many teachers find that factors at the setting level, such as time restrictions and curricular demands, can hamper their transition from traditional teaching scenarios to innovative forms of online and blended learning. These authors conclude that teachers may need a period of time to become more comfortable working with new technologies and exploiting them to the full. Similarly, Dutton et al. warn that ‘it takes time for individuals to discover how new technologies enable them not only to do things in new ways, but also to do new things’ (2004: 78). Looking at the case of Barbara through the lens of Layder’s social realism it becomes clear that, if the platform is to be used by many teachers for any activity beyond the transfer of materials from one format to another, then a lot more is necessary than simply a platform, which claims to support this particular approach to learning. Change will be necessary at the self level as teachers will have to gain a better understanding of the pedagogical consequences of taking on student-centred approaches, while at the setting level institutions will have to support and encourage training in studentcentred approaches to online learning and increase awareness as to what innovative online teaching practice may involve.
Case study 2: old light through new windows Isabel is a Spanish native and teaches English for Specific Purposes to a group of approximately thirty-five students. Isabel shows great interest in using the platform from the moment it is introduced in the department and is observed in the weeks before the course starts investing a great amount of time experimenting with the different organizational options that Moodle offers. As with Barbara, initial interviews with Isabel reveal that her motivation for using Moodle stems to a great extent from the positive, modern, connotations which online learning seems to carry in the context of Spanish education and society. She explains: I want to change my methods of teaching. I want to integrate the new technologies and I feel it was a good opportunity having the platform ready for use. The situated activity of using the VLE also appears to carry the meaning of making her teaching practices more communicative and of establishing a more personal approach to teacher-student interaction. This is confirmed
64
Learning Cultures in Online Education
in her following comments about the communicative possibilities offered by the new medium: I plan to use most of the tools and activities available but I think that the forums and chats will be a very important part of the after class tutorials. I’ve never liked the noninteraction between the teacher and student. It [using Moodle] is a good opportunity for one-to-one interaction. When they ask me questions about their activities, instead of having to explain things globally to the whole class I can get to know them better in a personal and in a professional way. Also, I feel they would be more open to me if they could write to me on a one to-one relationship. It becomes clear that the teacher initially sees the online communicative functions of the platform as a manner of establishing a closer, more personal form of contact with her students. Here, the general discourse of student-centred online pedagogy and cultural models of teacher-student relationships, which are present at context level, seems to shape the teacher’s own hopes and beliefs about what introducing Moodle can bring to her classes. Through the use of the message boards, personal messaging and chat options, the teacher believes she will have greater opportunities to interact on a one-to-one level with her students and thereby to establish better relationships with them – something that appears not to be occurring in her classes at the moment. (Elsewhere in this book, Develotte outlines some of the changes in teachers’ models of the teacher-student relationship, which may have to be involved in order that teachers such as Isabel can manage the change to their own values.) However, as was the case with Barbara, positive attitudes to the communicative and collaborative functions of the platform do not automatically lead to their implementation in the classroom. Isabel’s Moodle course is full of activities and resources for the students to access and work through, both in-class and at home. These include links to web pages related to the course subject, PowerPoint presentations based on grammar points, interactive quizzes, a mini-dictionary created by the teacher with the glossary function and scans of book extracts containing graphs and diagrams related to course content. In general, the online element of the course follows a traditional ‘present – practice – produce’ format, which involves presenting grammar and vocabulary themes through Powerpoint presentations and textbook extracts and then testing these items through interactive quizzes and the submission of worksheets in Word format. Even though Isabel originally mentions the opportunities for increased student communication and participation, which the platform offered to teachers, her use of the platform does not take up these possibilities. Instead, her online activity appears
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
65
to reflect common local perceptions (present at the setting level) of what should go on in online learning. It was noted earlier that many students involved in these courses had reported understanding online learning as the transfer of text-based materials to a digital format and this is what appears to be happening here to a great extent. Isabel justifies this approach in the following extract by arguing that the direct transfer of activities from hard copy to the online platform was having a motivating effect on the students: At the beginning I had the usual listening and reading activities [in the classes] but then I discovered that the students were uninterested in them so I moved these activities to the computer platform. And they became much more interested. They expected me to have all the activities in the platform and they were even sending me e-mails about the work that they had to do. So they really got involved in the activity. Interviewer: So to what extent did you take the materials you usually do in class and put them online? Did that happen a lot? Yeah, it was easy to convince them that we were doing a different activity even though it was simply a matter of uploading a word document onto the platform instead of printing it out to use in class. Interviewer: Didn’t the students realise this? No, I’m not sure. They definitely reacted in a much better way to this approach. I think it’s because they are not used to be in front of the computer working. They associate the computer with enjoyment. They associate the teacher in front of them as a type of work but they feel more free in front of the computer. And they have already made up their mind that they are going to have a good time. It’s like “Wow! Computer lab! We’ll have a great time”. Interviewer: Did you try any activities in Moodle which you wouldn’t do normally? I tried the chat but it wouldn’t work properly. And we didn’t use the message boards much because they are not mature enough to use it. You know, we tried it at the beginning but all their messages were, like, “Sylvia is a fool”. The situated activity of online teaching now seems to take on a meaning of distracting learners or duping them into believing they are engaging in new learning activities. More communicative or collaborative functions of the platform such as using the message board to engage the students in interaction with each other and with others outside the classroom is rejected due to a perceived lack of student maturity. Unlike what we observed in the previous case study, the reasons why Moodle is used in such a way would appear to go beyond a lack of training
66
Learning Cultures in Online Education
in the communicative and collaborative tools and options available on the platform. Instead, it is Isabel’s attitudes to her students and to the concept of appropriate teacher and student roles on the self level, which rule out an exploration of a social constructivist approach to learning and its studentcentred principles. Isabel’s beliefs here may be seen to be a product of an educational system where communicative methodology has generally failed to make its way into the foreign language classroom. In their review of the teaching of foreign languages in Spain, Carmena et al. suggest that ‘it is fair to ask whether these new didactic approaches have really impregnated the actual practice of language teaching’ (Carmena L´opez et al. 2000: 299, our translation) and Isabel’s beliefs and online practices would seem to reflect a local culture of teaching and learning, which is essentially teacher-centred and is based on the transfer of information from teacher to learner. As becomes clear in the following case study, it is only when the technology is employed by teachers willing to move away from this approach that its potential for innovation becomes tangible.
Case study 3: developing through a community of practice Andrew is a native speaker of English who has been living and teaching in Spain for over 15 years. He has been working at this particular university for 8 years and teaches courses in literature and in English as a Foreign Language to undergraduates of English Philology. He begins to use Moodle in a first year EFL course in the second semester after the platform has already been in use in the department for approximately 6 months. In the course of the many interviews and conversations about the platform, Andrew repeatedly underlines his lack of computer and electronic literacy and he often describes himself depreciatively as ‘technologically shy or challenged’. Nevertheless, his uses of Moodle are probably among the most innovative in the department and are those that come closest to the social constructivist principles of Moodle’s developers. Andrew uses the platform as a location for a bilingual online intercultural exchange between his students and students of Spanish as a Foreign Language at a North American university. In the platform, students have access to asynchronous message boards where they can write to their partners, and they find worksheets with task descriptions and ‘reminders’ of deadlines, which Andrew posts on the teachers’ message board. Andrew spends between 2 and 3 hours each week reading the messages posted by his students and their North American partners and often brings printouts of messages into class in order to discuss their linguistic and cultural content with the group.
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
67
The teacher’s reasons for using Moodle echo those of Isabel and Barbara to a certain extent in that he too sees the platform as an opportunity for developing professionally as a teacher. However, unlike his colleagues’ comments, his own appear to go a step further and suggest that he is making clear changes to his approach to teaching: For a start it [using the platform] adds variety. But it also allows you to move away from the classic situation where the teacher is simply passing on knowledge to the students. It takes the onus away from the teacher being the only source of knowledge. It’s also a way of being open to potential change and obviously if you are in touch with technology you have a chance for professional development [. . .] It’s a refreshing thing for yourself as a teacher – it keeps you up to date. Here it is evident that Andrew believes that the type of online work in which he engages his students enables him to move towards a particular approach to learning and teaching, which involves fewer teacher-centred activities. In a later interview he returns to this theme, explaining how the online exchange ‘encourages students to move away from the teacher and stop looking at him as a source of knowledge about everything’. Towards the end of the project, he demonstrates a critically reflective approach to his online activity as he explains how his approach to using Moodle and the online exchange has developed over time: [A]t the beginning I used it [the online intercultural exchange] as a sort of add on activity that students had to do outside of class – but I found it was much less successful when I did it that way so now I try to incorporate it more into the classroom and prepare students for tasks before they do them online and all round I feel I am trying to use more features available in Moodle. Andrew attributes great importance to the support he received from other colleagues who were already using the platform in their teaching. Apart from the teachers reported in these case studies, various other instructors with considerable experience in using on-line technologies in their classes had taken up Moodle during its first year of availability and had used the VLE for international collaborative activities similar to Andrew’s online teaching. Andrew had shown interest in how these colleagues were using the platform and he reports in his interviews that seeing how this activity was used at the setting level had given him confidence and had convinced him of the advantages of integrating Moodle into his own classes: When I saw what they were doing I could see that it worked. I could see that other teachers were using it and that their students were benefiting
68
Learning Cultures in Online Education
from it. So I thought it could have a motivational value for my own students as well. This is a significant illustration of how factors at a setting level can support as well as hinder the integration of VLEs into the classroom. Here, models of good practice available at the local institution provide an impetus or even a pressure for Andrew to innovate in his teaching practices. He returns to this theme in another interview where he suggests that seeing other colleagues working with the platform not only gave him the confidence to use it but also served him as a reminder that he needed to keep updating his own teaching practices: I feel that the use of Moodle in the platform has been quite contagious. The actual use of the platform by other teachers made me realise its benefits and also at the same time to feel the need to update my own practice. Andrew’s experiences of using Moodle are a reminder of how the development of a teaching culture, which involves innovative uses of technology, will require the appropriate conditions across self, setting and context levels. A teacher who, at self level, has the pedagogical capacity and conviction to engage is social constructivist activities will have the opportunity to thrive in a setting where colleagues are integrating new technologies into their classes and are willing to share their experiences with others, and is also likely to find inspiration in the attitudes to student-centred approaches to online learning, which exist in the literature of online education.
Discussion: understanding local interpretations of online teaching practice This chapter set out, first, to explore the manner in which an online learning platform with its own particular culture of learning and teaching was taken up by the teaching staff at the foreign language department of a Spanish university and, second, to establish how the local educational and cultural contexts and the teachers’ own beliefs and pedagogical practices would influence how the platform was actually employed. First, it became evident that all three teachers involved in these case studies saw the use of the on-line platform as related to the principle of being a progressive, up-to-date teacher. It was seen in the description of the local cultural context that there exists a general tendency in the world of education (and in particular in Spanish society) that teachers should use online activities with their learners and this external pressure undoubtedly pushed these teachers to look for opportunities to incorporate learning tools such as Moodle into their classes.
Entering the World of Online Foreign Language Education
69
While it is perhaps of little surprise that teachers should associate on-line technologies with pedagogical innovation and professional development, it is nevertheless significant that two of the three teachers essentially limited their online activity to the transfer of materials and activities onto an online format and avoided any use of the communicative and collaborative functions available to them. Both teachers suggested that these tools and activities would come at a later stage and offered various explanations for this approach, including, first, the complexity of learning how to use the platform’s functions properly and, second, their students’ high level of satisfaction with using the new medium in their classes. However, their interview data reveal that although the teachers pay lip service to the transformative possibilities of the technology, they are essentially using it to reinforce their control over student behaviour or to ‘fool’ their students into doing the same activities in what the students may think are more innovative ways. For example, both teachers mentioned using functions of the VLE to check up on student participation and to force them to access materials, while Isabel’s transfer of hard copy materials online was due to her students’ perceived pre-disposition to online activity. In many senses, it appears that the use of the VLE is an attempt to benefit from the connotations of innovation and student-centred learning, which online learning holds for students and for Spanish society in general, while at the same time allowing teachers to continue in practice with teacher-centred approaches. Analyzing this situation with a social realist lens means that any change to these practices must involve development and change at both micro and macro levels of Layder’s model. For example, it was seen in the case of Andrew that the inspiration and motivation for using the platform in innovative ways did not originate in ‘top-down’ macro-level initiatives involving in-service training, but instead from an active community of practitioners within the department itself. If a number of colleagues are seen to be successfully using a platform in their classes, then they can become a model for others to follow. They can also help to maintain momentum and provide their fellow teachers with new ideas of how to use the technology in innovative ways. Sandholtz, Ringstaff, and Dwyer comment: Not only can teachers serve as models for each other, their experiences can give teachers who are learning to use technology a road map for the process. By knowing what to expect, teachers can more easily manoeuvre around the obstacles and more quickly reach their destination. (1997: 182) Second, it was seen that if the introduction of VLEs such as Moodle are to support social constructivist methodology, it is first of all necessary for a culture of teaching to be present where teachers are knowledgeable of and
70
Learning Cultures in Online Education
interested in engaging their learners in student-centred learning practices involving a relinquishment of teacher control and a greater emphasis on discovery- and project-based learning. If teachers are unaware of, or disagree pedagogically with, such practices, then it goes without saying that the introduction of any technologies such as Moodle will not serve to bring them about. As part of this book’s effort to construct the notion of learning and teaching cultures, we may therefore reflect on the relationship between the ‘introduction’ of a VLE and the ‘presence’ of a culture of student-centred learning. As we have shown, interrelated macro and micro factors shape both and bring them together in ways that need to be better understood if such practices as we have described here are to change.
Conclusion Over the past decade the internet and virtual learning platforms such as Moodle have undoubtedly become an integral part of education in Western society and have helped to shape the expectations and hopes that teachers and students now bring to formal education. However, perhaps due to simplified portrayals in the media and in the academic literature of what online learning and teaching actually involve, there exists what Jane Healy describes as an ‘unreasonable and unfounded fascination and belief in [. . .] technology’s educational power (Healy, cited in Bax 2003: 25)’. This often leads to an unfounded hope that the internet will make revolutionary changes to the way learning and teaching take place in our classrooms. In this chapter we have recognized the potential of Moodle and its learning culture for more innovative, student-centred approaches to learning but we believe that the case studies have also provided a reminder that the eventual impact of online learning continues to be very much dependent on the culture of learning and teaching, which exists in each school or university’s socioinstitutional context and also in the minds and behaviour of the teachers who put them to use. Whether the minds and behaviour of students also reflect these socioinstitutional contexts is a question, which, while not part of our aim in this chapter, nevertheless can be asked, as other chapters in this book show. Change and innovation can be brought about through the use of online technologies, but only if there is support and will for change on all four levels of Layder’s research map. This will include administrative-supported training initiatives in online pedagogy, a genuine interest from teachers themselves in exploring student-centred approaches and a willingness on their behalf to take an active part in communities of practice with colleagues.
Chapter 4
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning: The Online Learner’s Emerging Identity Christine Develotte Institut National de Recherche Pedagogique, France ´
Introduction Over the last few years, online learning has made it possible for a new audience to access continuing education. For example in France, online Professional MAs in Language Teaching and Learning have attracted many teachers of French-as-a-foreign-language, most of them already posted abroad. The internet allows them to enrol on programmes offering university-level professional qualifications. This chapter explores one such programme, launched in Grenoble in November 2006 as a partnership between the Centre National d’Enseignement a` Distance (or CNED, French national centre for distance education, see Internet References section) and the Universit´e Grenoble 3. Within this programme, a module entitled ‘A Discourse Approach to Intercultural Issues’ offers the opportunity for researchers to collect a corpus for observing and analyzing aspects of the identity of these online learners. It is clear that, prior to enrolment in our module, the types of learning cultures surrounding most of these students, many aged around thirty, are tied in to traditional face-to-face classrooms. Their move to the online setting is a significant ‘moment’, which the study aims to capture, because at that point a break occurs with habits, behaviours and ‘representations’ (in Moscovici’s understanding of the term, as discussed later in this chapter), rooted in a previous, different context. Our research methodology takes the above module as a starting point and aims to identify the main aspects of that new learning culture, which could be called the ‘newly networked learning culture’. Students were asked to analyze the different aspects of the
72
Learning Cultures in Online Education
learning cultures implicit in their course, based on their reflective observations, which constitute our corpus. The following are the questions addressed in the study: r How do we move from the situation of the traditional classroom learner to that of the online student? r Which learning practices need to be deconstructed, modified and adapted to this new context? r Which new learning strategies seem to come into play at the sociocognitive and socioaffective levels? To answer these questions, it may be fruitful to focus on the particular context of online learning. Before examining individual experiences, we will look at the different social situations which give rise to them.
Background The role of the social environment in constructing the individual Following Piaget (1977) and Vygotsky (1978), among others, we now know that the social dimension precedes individual knowledge: Cognitive work occurs in a human, social and cultural world, and far from being independent from it, it is on the contrary strongly determined by it. (1978: 78) It is upon this socioconstructivist conception that the present analysis will be based. From this point of view, our knowledge of the world is based on the ordering and organization of a world, which is constituted by our individual experiences and our collective knowledge, transmitted primarily through language. Given the extent to which our social and discursive environment influences and conditions our vision of the world (L´evi-Strauss 1985), we can hypothesize that a change in learning environment will destabilize online students who, for the first time, must face a different learning environment from that of the traditional classroom, and that they will look for ways of adapting to this change. This will include making adjustments to their previous learning strategies, and it is certain aspects of those adjustments that we will analyze, with two different aims in mind. One is to understand how individuals adapt to a new pedagogical reality. The other is to address the following, more sociological question: How does a student adapt to this new learning environment? (A process described by Coulon (1993) as ‘affiliation to the job of [online] student’ (1993: 96.) These differentiated aims will underpin our exploration of the research questions set out in the previous section.
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
73
Displayed spaces and spaces for production on the platform In line with Vygotsky, we relate online pedagogical socialization to the aspects of the development of the online learner’s individual identity that the different types of interaction encourage. In order to specify more clearly which sort of environment is likely to influence the way in which this socialization occurs for each learner, we focus on the relationship between space and discourse, realized in screen and text form. To this aim, we use a notion that brings together spaces in which discourse is displayed to learners, and spaces for their production of discourse, which we call ‘Espace d’Exposition Discursive’ (EED), although it is important to note that in stressing the screen and text-related interpretation that we give to the phrase ‘Espace d’Exposition Discursive’ and encapsulating it in an acronym, we intend to set it apart from the notion of ‘discursive space’ as known, for example, in discursive psychology. Elsewhere (Develotte 2006), we have spoken of the EED of an online teaching platform. By this we mean the digital (graphico-scriptural) environment to which online learners are exposed when they come to the platform. Whereas traditional classroom learners enter a classroom (with desks, a board, i.e. a marked-out and norm-governed social space), online learners connect to a platform, which involves a sense of ‘d´ej`a-l`a ’. In contrast to situations of ‘d´ej`a-vu’, in which the individual recognizes something that she or he has already seen before, we can coin the phrase ‘d´ej`a-l`a ’ (already there) to indicate that what they find, when they come online, is a world that is both established (it pre-exists their arrival) and unfamiliar to them. For example, the presentation of the course by teachers or administrators, the creation of course headings, the organization of information and the creation of web links are all ‘already there’. As is clear from Figure 4.1, the discursive space to which the learner is exposed does not reflect prior practices in terms of learning culture (except in the case of two or three students who have already experienced a similar kind of training). Also, the EED introduces a social space for teaching/learning and new discursive practices. Learner socialization is therefore shaped both by the EED and by the teachers’ and the administrators’ discourses that take place there, before the arrival of the learners. The EED, which is also linked to didactic and pedagogical choices, conditions the form and the content of the discursive productions of the students. For example, on the Dokeos platform studied here, the courses are structured according to the following model: folders with the headings ‘activities’ and ‘work’, where the students’ monthly work is sent; and a ‘forum’, which allows students to ask questions related to the course or to other matters. More general headings allow students to communicate with each other in a ‘R´ecr´e ’ (recreation) space reserved, as the name suggests, for relaxing,
Who’s who
Recreation area
Figure 4.1 Discursive Space
Learning Cultures in Online Education
Alumni
74
Course administration
75
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning Table 4.1 Three Variables of the Learning Situation Traditional classroom, co-presence
At a distance, by correspondence
At a distance, via digital forum
Interpersonal communication through the synchronous written forum
Direct, oral, visual
Written, on paper
Mediated through technology (including different tools)
Teacher-learner relations
Synchronous, frequent, spontaneous
Asynchronous, infrequent, programmed for regularity
Asynchronous, frequent, a degree of spontaneity possible
Learner-learner relations
Synchronous
Absent
Asynchronous, mediated by technology
Interlocutors’ perceptions
Direct, sensorial,
Almost none, few clues (anonymity)
Indirect, through online interaction or information
or for communicating with an administrator for the Master’s degree at the Universit´e Grenoble 3. It is this digital environment for socialized learning that provides the right soil for the culture of online learning of participants. At this stage it is useful to compare pedagogical communication in three learning situations experienced by the students from a social point of view. The comparison, expressed through three variables, is summarized in Table 4.1. We start by putting forward two hypotheses, based on our foregrounding of the social over the individual, one related to the system, and the other to the individuals involved in it: The “techno-semio-pragmatic” specificities, to use Peraya’s (1998) term, of the learning environment influence the subculture that develops among users, and therefore influences their identity as online learners. In other words, participants do not express themselves in the same manner in cases where pedagogical communication is carried out solely via asynchronous writings (as it is in the Dokeos-mediated course being discussed in this chapter), or via synchronous exchanges, be they text-based or
76
Learning Cultures in Online Education
multimodal. Thus it cannot be assumed that the online learning culture will be the same in these different contexts. Each digital environment is a reflection of conceptions in educational and pedagogical engineering that pre-exist the “arrival” of the user. Within each, a set of specific discursive norms and conversational rituals develops, and each engenders a different ethos for the participants. This is the first hypothesis put forward in this study. The second hypothesis is that the learners, as individuals, have an identity marked by their multiple previous experiences of learning (most frequently in traditional classroom environments) and that their characteristics (age, origin, sex) as well as their profiles (technical knowledge, personality, time available, etc.) also influence the social dynamics of the group. This had already begun to happen when we interviewed the learners. In the study we therefore have access to individual representations expressed by learners who had inserted themselves into the social dynamics of the pedagogical forum two months earlier. Moscovici (1973) describes social representations as: cognitive systems with a logic and language of their own. [. . .] They do not represent simply “opinions about”, “images of” or “attitudes towards” but “theories” or “branches of knowledge” in their own right, for the discovery and organisation of reality, of systems of values, ideas and practices with a two-fold function: first, to establish an order which will enable individuals to orient themselves in their material world and to master it; and secondly, to enable communication to take place among members of a community by providing them with a code for naming and classifying unambiguously the various aspects of the world and individual and group history. (1973: xiii) Moscovici stresses the need to use social representations as ‘a drawbridge between the world of the individual and the social world, to relate them to the perspective of a changing world’ (1991: 83, our translation). As a psycho-social research tool, the representations of subjects engaged in a training situation have long been of interest to educational researchers (Rosenthal & Jackobson 1971; Giordan 1983). Using the above framework, this chapter investigates learner representations among a group of students new to online learning. Based on the hypothesis that recurrent representations may be held up as signs of an emerging identity, our chapter looks towards identifying the representations that our students have of their learning, as a contribution to a description of the diversity of learner experiences online. Through an analysis of representations, we aim to explore the differences and commonalities – among learner variables – specific to this online-learning culture.
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
77
The study Context of the training The study discussed in this chapter examines the experience of learners enrolled in the second year of a professional Master’s level online training course ‘Didactique du FLE et approches discursives de l’interculturel’(Teaching French as a Foreign Language: A Discourse Perspective on Intercultural Issues). This course is delivered by the CNEDUniversit´e Grenoble 3 and it offers teachers of French as a Foreign Language the opportunity to bring their professional qualifications up to date. In other words, the students, who are already teachers, are seeking to acquire a professional certification related, in this case, to online teaching/learning. They are therefore as interested in the form of transmission and the cognitive processes that it entails, as in the content of this training. Moreover, all are French native speakers and 80 percent of them work outside France. Here are some details on the teaching/learning environment: students receive the course documents (on paper or in a pdf file) and are supported via asynchronous online tutoring in their eight classes. The tutorials are mostly managed by the teacher in charge of the module (sometimes in association with one or two colleagues). In these tutorials regular interactions occur, with each tutor connecting around twice a week in order to answer students’ questions concerning the set activities or comprehension problems in relation to the class. The module in which the data examined here was gathered (Teaching French as a Foreign Language: A Discourse Perspective on Intercultural Issues) offered students a choice between continuous assessment and a final thesis or essay. Note that this approach to assessment would in itself have had implications for the cultural dimension of this online course, but student data does not refer to it, and it is therefore excluded from the present study. The twenty students who are the subjects of this study chose continuous assessment. The course began with six tutorials. Two months later, three further tutorials were added, among which were those that were taught by the author and are under study in this chapter.
Study corpus and methodology The corpus of data upon which this study is based was gathered during the initial online activity carried out by a cohort of students enrolled between 2006 and 2007. With a view to raising their awareness of the cultural dimensions related to online learning, we encouraged them to think about the changes introduced into their learning culture by the computer-mediated dimension of their distance study. They were given the following instructions
78
Learning Cultures in Online Education
(bearing in mind that this was the author’s first tutorial, although the students had by that stage already experienced online tutorials by other tutors): You began this online training two months ago, and we will start this course with an exploration of this teaching/learning. I would like to invite you to test the techniques of reflexive analysis suggested in Chapter 1 of the course by observing your own habits, behaviour and representations associated with online learning (in comparison with the traditional classroom teaching culture to which you were exposed before). Try to describe your perception of anonymity, of solitary work, of the integration of the technological dimension into this type of learning (and of the temporal and spatial specificities related to this) and of every other variable you consider relevant to understanding your experience as a learner. Do not hesitate to give examples to illustrate each of your perceptions. Twenty reflective student assessments, each about 2,000 to 2,500 words, were collected (without the students having access to each other’s representations): fourteen stated the novelty of this online learning experience for them; three showed experience of distance learning through paper-based correspondence only; and three had already had experience of online teaching the previous year, that is, the first year of their 2-year Master’s programme. For 85 percent of the students it was therefore their first experience of online learning. Thirty percent of students had experience of distance learning, but for half of these it had involved correspondence only. As a large majority (70 percent) of these learners had been educated in France, where a transmission model of teaching is favoured, we considered that in spite of possible influences from outside school, learners would have mainly constructed their learner identities from a traditional classroom experience, and that their cultural references would be linked to a classic form of transmission of knowledge, which privileges the contents over the learning processes. Using the variables in Table 4.1, we will identify those characteristics that are brought to the fore by students, to specify online interpersonal pedagogical relationships. Which elements in this table are mentioned by the learners? Which ones are not? Which ones are new? In the following analyses we will dissociate those representations which are linked to the specificities of the pedagogical communication system from those that are more precisely linked to the socioaffective aspects of the training, thus reflecting the two aims that we formulated earlier, of studying how individuals adapt to a new pedagogical reality, and how they affiliate to the job of an online student. This will allow us to draw up sociocognitive
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
79
and psycho-cognitive profiles for the learners, taking full account of the particular technological and human context of this online training. This analysis is organized around elements collected in a thematic way from within the students’ accounts. Sixteen students have been teachers for 5 years on an average (in France or outside France). Because of their presumed interest in the learning process, we assume that they are in a position to give a critical and detached view of their learning experience. In order to make visible the representations regarding relations to the technological system and interpersonal relations, we used a method consisting of dividing up each student’s contribution thematically, to produce data categorized according to the columns of Table 4.1. The extracts from the different students’ assignments were thus juxtaposed and analyzed. Within each thematic category, we found that students had expressed themselves through questions, positive critique or negative critique. We quantified the data according to these modes of expression so as to form an idea of the overall corpus analyzed. (The number of students appears in each case in round brackets in the sections that follow, while square bracketed numbers identify each individual student). For each mode of expression (i.e. questioning, positive or negative) extracts of the students’ discursive productions were selected, illustrating the different themes that were broached. Through this first exploratory investigation of the corpus we seek to highlight the representations conveyed by the learners as part of their discursive productions, ‘zooming in’ on them, as it were. In the conclusion of the analyses of the four themes broached, we try to show how the main identity traits specific to the online learner are represented in the asynchronous online pedagogical environment under study. We start with representations concerning online interpersonal communication, before dealing with those related to teacher-learner relations, then learner-learner relations and finally those that refer to the perceptions of interlocutors in this kind of discursive space.
Discussion Interpersonal communication through the synchronous written forum All of the students gave their viewpoint on the particular form taken by the pedagogical communication in the Dokeos platform. We examine which aspects were appreciated and which received the most negative evaluations. Among those elements mentioned by the students, we retain those specific to this form of learning and we discard, for example, those concerning distance only, as being applicable not only to this but also other forms of teaching (i.e. by correspondence).
80
Learning Cultures in Online Education
Among the twenty student productions, in our analysis of the extracts concerning technological communication via the forum, we identify twelve responses, which give ‘negative’ evaluations, seven ‘positive’ evaluations and one ‘questioning’ evaluation. We therefore begin with ‘negative’ representations and we define the different levels to which they refer. Feeling of insecurity when facing technology The negative comments covered two points: the complexity of the platform (8) and the difficulty of communicating via this medium (4). The first point refers to two difficulty levels: the sheer number of messages, and the way they are visually organized on the platform. Thus ‘the multiplicity of links on the platform makes it tentacular (or sprawling)’ according to one student, while another student spoke of ‘the impression of a tangle of new information, in comparison with a traditional tutorial in which the reactions and the remarks of the teachers or the students follow the outline of the class’. Other students referred to Kafka and Ionesco to express what they saw as the absurd and frightening world of this online platform. Thus a general feeling of insecurity was created, contrasting with the level of organization that learners experienced in their previous studies. [5] At first I had the feeling of being invaded by an unpredictable flux of heterogeneous information and modalities, for which I had to keep searching, with the feeling nonetheless that I had no control at all over the situation; or partial control at best. How do we explain this mind-blowing cognitive insecurity? Perhaps predictably, the technical problems were expressed (8) both in terms of the weaknesses of the teaching system, and of the learners’ unpredictable access and own limitations with regard to the use of technology (2). Thus three students (located in Asia) mentioned the connection problems caused by an earthquake, which occurred on 26 December 2006, one of the consequences of which was that the underwater optic cables carrying the greater part of the internet connections were ruptured, interrupting the online pedagogical communication for 10 days. These two levels of difficulty enter into what Kupersmith (1995) calls ‘technostress’, pointing, perhaps, to the need for a further study to check if there is a relation between the students’ technical competence and the expression of their feeling of insecurity. It is, in any case, a hypothesis worth putting forward: that the lesser the technical knowledge, the greater the stress among the students.
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
81
Perceptions of unequal appropriation of the communication environment The images associated with the forum as a place of discursive production were seen very differently by individual students. Some found it easier to express themselves than others (7): [10] The use of forums breaks barriers and inhibitions. There is no longer a gulf between those who dare and those who don’t dare speak up. I’m someone who is usually reserved in front of a large group, and for me this tool is reassuring. Other students (5), however, felt inhibited while using the platform: [13] Sending a message on the Dokeos platform amounts to hurling oneself into the void, with no chance of checking the relevance of a question by seeing the reactions of your interlocutors. By writing a message, we must accept a much larger part of responsibility for what we say: once the message is sent, we cannot change it, even if we have realized that we have made an error. I think that I can analyze this attitude as a sort of apprehension of “the other”, an uneasiness to which I react by asking fewer questions than I would if I were in a classroom. These images are very varied and the way that they evolve would merit a study on its own. It might then be possible to find out whether reactions like those of student [13] are temporary, linked to the initial discovery factor, or whether they are likely to become permanent, associated with the ethos that this individual built up through the use of the platform. It is often the case that the same aspect is seen in different ways by individual students. For example, the public character of the statements on the forum can be experienced as a lack of confidentiality or, conversely, as a sharing of the training process between the students. [11] The forums [. . .] lack a dimension of confidentiality. Sometimes I compensated by contacting the other member of the work group by email. [4] What I particularly like is the fact that nothing is hidden or wellguarded, like it is when we are in a classroom where sometimes only a few students can benefit from the information given, since the questions which are posed outside courses and classrooms don’t circulate to every student and, similarly, don’t necessarily make it to the ears of the teachers. But in the case of distance learning, both teachers and students participate regularly in all of the online “dialogues”. Similarly, the asynchronous aspect of exchanges was liable to trigger positive or negative reactions; according to the students:
82
Learning Cultures in Online Education
[20] There is no immediate feedback from the teacher; each participant is always waiting for the response from a professor, from a student, or from a member of the administration. [1] The asynchronous style teaches us to be patient and to organize our work in advance so that we take into account the time we must wait before we receive a response. One area for further exploration suggested by our findings – which are limited by the broad view that we have adopted in this study – would be to refine the grain of the analysis by including biographical details relating to the learners’ previous educational experiences, their affinities (or otherwise) for using technology and their orientation towards autonomous learning, etc. Indicators of a change of culture We offer two examples of students’ impressions, which may be precursors to cultural changes in the domain of learning. The first example is that of a student who asks herself the following questions: [3] I also asked myself about certain aspects of the operation of the platform, in particular about the possibility of seeing who is connected and about the recording of the frequency of our connections. Does knowing that others are online, without being able to come into contact with them, serve to maintain the motivation of the group or, rather, to consolidate a feeling of belonging to a community, for example? As for the information about our connections, I suppose that it permits the teachers to judge the “health” of the platform by means of statistics. In effect, these questions attest to the knowledge of this particular technical culture that this student has1 ; her inferences relate to the limits of the platform, on one hand, and, on the other hand, to the functions of control linked to the system of technological traces. The majority of teachers do not use the statistical information about students’ connections, but the totality of this student’s productions must, presumably, take place while she has in mind the possibility that somebody (teacher or administrator) could lurk and check what she is doing while she works on the platform. Such potential checks undeniably form part of the available technico-discursive machinery. In our opinion, these remarks may be considered as the start of changes to the image of what a pedagogical exchange is, when carried out online. In the same vein, the ideas of the student below indicate that her perception of writing has changed because of her experience of using the platform:
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
83
[13] While I would allow myself to ask spontaneous questions in class, when learning online I prefer to put my doubts to one side and think about the question myself or else re-read the notes I took to find the response. It’s only when I’m sure of my lack of understanding of the subject matter that I ask the question on the platform; this clearly makes questioning much less impulsive. My vision of what writing is surely enters into the game, here. Indeed, I am used to informal exchanges when writing in a personal style (letters, chats, diverse synchronous exchanges), but, in my thinking process, writing in a university setting is immediately associated with work that is definitive, thought-out, constructed, and often liable to be evaluated. Whereas I see oral communication as a system of propositions, of hypotheses, of reflections, and of questioning, written trial and error is difficult for me to envision. As it were, I feel that I have less of a right to make a mistake when writing than when speaking. The discussion forum at the university is thus another perturbing element in my cognitive process, since its goal is to be a system of exchanges of doubts and questions that are written. Accounting for my thoughts on the matter, sending a message on the platform is, for me, taking a singular risk which requires more tolerance of uncertainty than one would find in oral participation in a classroom learning situation. The relationship with writing is ingrained in our social practices and it models our behaviours. The reflections above reflect the necessity of a cultural appropriation of this new relationship to writing online in the context of learning. This type of writing distinguishes itself from traditional writing at university because of its more spontaneous character, in that it is less determined by a search for formal perfection. Teacher-learner relations Concerning relationships with their teachers, students expressed ideas that related to the idea of greater freedom of expression online, which goes back to what Walther (1996) has called ‘hyperpersonal’ interaction. This aspect, that is, relations that are more relaxed than they are in the classroom, was noted by nine students: [19] The relationships between the students and the teachers are friendlier and more relaxed. The latter are also present on the Qui est qui (Who’s Who) forum. Mr. M. uses smileys to wink at us, Mr. C. jokes around [. . .] The online relationship helps to lose inhibitions. I say things that I would never permit myself to say in a classroom (what I am in the process of writing for you, for example); things like humor, criticism. [. . .] There are failures of communication due to technical problems (disappearance
84
Learning Cultures in Online Education
of forums2 ); (would I ever make such an allusion in a classroom, and wink at you?). The teacher thus appears paradoxically, ‘closer and more accessible despite the distance and the asynchronicity’. One can also link this aspect to the fact that the teachers were involved in the design of the pedagogical communication environment and that they had deliberately chosen a form of tutorial support that was appropriate to supporting students in a socioaffective manner. Learner-learner relations All 20 students mentioned the new type of relationship that distancelearning sets up with other students, if only because they were surprised, as in the case of the following individual: [19] The image of distance learning that I had was very different. First, I imagined only a teacher/student relationship. But I realized that one enters into a new mode of learning in which interaction and collaborative work have an essential place. Thus, there is a strong support system: tutorial support, exchanges (forums, chats, collaborative groups). At no time did I ever think of exchanges between students. Three subthemes are addressed in the framework of relationships between students: first and foremost collective work, then solidarity and the feeling of noncompetition and, finally, the absence of conversations outside class time. Collective work Ninety percent of the students dedicated a part of their reflections to collective work, which appeared to be the element perceived as most prominent in the relationship between students. Indeed, eighteen students were interested in work, which prompted them to co-operate in an activity with another student. The evaluations of this aspect of relationships in distance learning were varied: seven students had a negative judgment of this type of work, six mentioned their interest, two expressed puzzlement, and three others had negative impressions at the start, which evolved during the course, becoming more positive at the end. The following are examples of the difficulty which was most often cited (10), that is choosing a partner to make up a pair: [11] I would express my reservations most especially with the work done in pairs or in groups. We need to collaborate with one or several other
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
85
people chosen in a completely random way. It is true that we have a description of each person on the forum at our disposal, but ultimately that doesn’t say much about the personality of the individual and whether or not we are going to be able to get along. Henri (2007) considers, after more than 20 years of analyzing the process of online collaboration, that collaboration requires preparation and that it is necessary to teach students how to collaborate and to make sure that stages are not skipped, because these are useful in preparing for later work. In only one case did the difficulty mentioned earlier come from a student’s own acknowledged shortcomings: [5] Collaborative work is still difficult for me [. . .]. I admit, of course, that I have an independent personality, difficulties with delegation and trust, and even a need for control. The students also made a link between other ways of communicating (outside the platform) and the collective work in pairs (6). The following examples demonstrate that the students used initiative and appropriated the different tools available in order to adjust as much as possible to the constraints of communication: [18] Time-management was the triggering factor of reorganization in the communication. The multitude of details to deal with in our pair work made it necessary to move to synchronous exchanges via Windows MessengerTM . The problems with time-management, in these types of training courses, were mentioned by all the students. Similar difficulties are discussed by Thorpe (2006: 506), who adds that ‘Conferencing and on-line tutorials can also add to study workload if they are not well-moderated or wellstructured. More time is required to read large numbers of messages when conferences are not tightly threaded or a tutor does not weave together the themes effectively or summarize and guide the discussion’. Certainly the pedagogical communication environment that is offered to students is capable of improvement in numerous ways. Indeed these communicative protocols are not yet familiar ground for teachers or educational designers, and both these communities constantly seek to improve them through attention to developments highlighted in studies like the current one. In addition to the time factor that is cited by students to justify moving over to other modes and tools of communication, there is also a need to
86
Learning Cultures in Online Education
compare one’s thoughts and feelings about the training courses with those of others. [17] I notice that I immediately reintroduced a “corporal” and “perceptible” dimension into my group, notably by using a communication tool that is synchronous and “more human”: the telephone. Although not in the physical presence of our peers, it allows us to be in contact with a voice, with something that is alive, which is also reassuring. This underlines the need on the part of students to share emotions socially (Rim´e 2005), the lack of which was mentioned in a number of ways by them. Solidarity/absence of competitiveness Several students (5) mentioned their surprise or their pleasure when they were helped by other students. [6] Having received my courses two months after the beginning of the training course, I felt very alone when faced with my learning. Happily, two students sent me messages of support and encouragement, which really surprised me but also “remotivated” me. I think, here, that distance learning allows this type of intervention more easily than classroom learning. Would I have had the support of two perfect strangers in a classroom situation? This expression of solidarity among students, which is surprising for a teacher who is used to classroom culture, seems to be something specific to online learning and could be linked to the reduced feeling of competition, which was also noted by several students. Loss of socializing time in-between formal face-to-face sessions The uniquely ‘professional’ character of the relationships between students on the teaching platform was highlighted (4): [6] One of the disadvantages of distance learning is that the contact remains linked only to the training course. Personal connections, which are also a source of motivation, are absent. It is clear, then, that the lack of relationships with other students was felt most often in the motivational and social aspects, which help to share emotions (e.g. stress or others). [6] I also think that, when everyone is physically present, information circulates more easily than in distance learning. In a classroom, while
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
87
waiting for a teacher, for example, or during the breaks, the students chat and exchange information very easily and naturally. [. . .] So it’s not very reassuring to work alone, in front of a computer that will never say to you, “In fact, you had started working on. . .” or, “You handed in. . .”, or even, “This assignment is really hard. . ., how did you start it?”, etc. It seems that in separating recreational topics (‘R´ecr´e ’) from ‘serious’ topics and putting them into different ‘boxes’, the platform through its structures has broken with the usual mix that is customary in on-site classes, which bring together the speeches and lectures in the classroom with the talk that goes on in the hallway or the cafeteria. Perhaps on future distance teaching/distance learning platforms, these EEDs, which are more hybrid, will become prevalent if the demand for them highlights their pedagogical importance. Constructing one’s interlocutor Among the themes that we had suggested to students as ways of structuring their accounts of their experience with distance learning was the theme of anonymity, which was an important element to consider when looking at the perceptions (or, rather, the nonperceptions) of the interlocutors on the platform. In fact it seems that anonymity did not emerge as a particularly relevant theme because more than half of the students (11/20) did not feel that this form of distance learning conveyed a feeling of anonymity (the other nine did not address this theme): [17] I construct images of personalities from the information that each person gives, so as to adapt to this change and recreate a universe that mixes the known and the unknown. [3] Names took on a face because some people included a photo on their course blog (for the ‘computer-assisted collective learning ’ module). [5] On Dokeos, one can read not only detailed answer keys and personal information, but also warm exchanges and links to personal sites. I myself have Googled the names of teachers in order to know more about their academic careers and frames of mind. Thus, according to the success of my searches, sometimes I do my work with faces and sometimes I do it while trying to guess the personality traits of my partners. Both ways are pleasant. One interesting find was the way in which the students restored reality to their professors who were not present (i.e. who were connected to the
88
Learning Cultures in Online Education
forum) by using online or imaginary information; the virtual here took on its true meaning. But it shows the necessity of having an image of the other, which is projected or otherwise seen, in order to experience a pedagogical relationship online, at least for some people: [19] I also find it funny that I imagine faces by using other people’s introductions of themselves, their questions, and their personalities (although some people have put their picture on their blog). For one of the students, the people who remained anonymous were those who did not frequently use the forum; for the others, clues allowed the imagination to compensate for the lack of information to which we are accustomed in on-site learning: [8] Style or tonality are revealing, and one cannot neglect what might appear while reading between the lines [. . .]. This student seems to be in a hurry because there are several typos in his text. That one is not coherent in his usage of typography. Another one takes great care that her text flows well. Or a recurring error shows a nonnative speaker (our emphasis). One question that emerged concerned the universality and types of experience, that is, whether all students experienced this, what form this experience took and what role this imaginary projection played in the learning process (motivational level, etc.). In the final part of our study, we examine the traces that indicate how individuals appropriate a new learning culture generated by the move to on-line/distance learning. This emerging learning culture foreshadows new learning identities, which are currently being constructed. Emerging identities Our aim in undertaking this study was to answer questions about the move from classroom learner to online student, and in particular to identify new learning practices and strategies, coming into play at the sociocognitive and socioaffective levels. In the final section, we now address these two dimensions. Sociocognitive level Another finding of note concerns the differences between what, according to the students (5), was seen as the ‘good performance’ of an online learner
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
89
and the real behaviours that had been adopted up to this point in the course (i.e. 2 months after the start). Here is an example: [19] Although the didactic intentions of this training course aim for student/student and student/teacher interactions, I prefer student/teacher exchanges most of the time. However, I remain persuaded that the best way to learn is to get involved actively. So, why didn’t I play the game? This understanding of the issues and of the modalities of teaching was not enough to reorient the work habits that had been ingrained for many years, as the same student explains: [19] The first reason, I think, is that I was used to the traditional teacher/knowledge/student triangle, and that the change in the way that speech acts are enacted through technological mediation was difficult. The second reason is my lack of self-confidence as a learner. The sanction of success and of failure can be destabilizing when one is an adult. As a result, I no longer have confidence in my co-learners. How can they respond to my questions when they aren’t professors? To give advice to other students seemed pretentious to me. This narration is in the past tense because the student later explains in what manner her impressions evolved and lead to behaviours that were more adapted to the pedagogical situation online. The next section provides examples of new strategies of learning, which emerged in order to respond appropriately to the pedagogical communication mechanism. Psycho-cognitive level The five students who declared which learning strategies they had used all started from the need to rethink their way of learning, taking into account the disappearance of elements which they were accustomed to use as part of the framework of a classroom situation. [13] In order to catch up with my learning strategies in the classroom, I had the use of new strategies to simulate interactions: not only did I decide to proceed with creating personal evaluations in the form of tests that reproduce the system of questioning someone else, but I also forced myself to evaluate my appropriation of knowledge by regularly speaking out loud and imagining myself to be in the middle of explaining the situation to someone. In these examples we see the fundamental role that imagination plays in the capacity to leave behind the strategies which were previously used in other learning situations and which are, in distance learning, seen as
90
Learning Cultures in Online Education
ineffective and thus in need of modification. Sometimes, however, the students were less advanced in their appropriation of these strategies, and they noted their helplessness in sticking to the student model that they previously had in their minds: [5] Being the 2nd-year postgraduate student that I am, I must now confess that I print most of the forum discussions, the activities, the links, and the documents, and I put them in a folder with a multitude of colored inserts. If I do nothing, I still fear that an important announcement will escape the clicks of my mouse. It is the obsession of wanting to manage and master everything. In the next few months, I am most probably going to need to accept the fact that this is no longer possible, that one cannot work with this illusion in one’s head. There is clearly some guilt attached to the lack of respect of what is implicitly established as the ‘good behaviour’ of the online student. This emotion is in fact representative of a multitude of others (among which we find stress, frustration, a feeling of insecurity) that are generated by the early stages of an online learner’s career. Five students associate discomfort with interest (in the description of their experience), as in the following example: [2] I find the experience oppressive but interesting. To break from one routine to find another brings about new methods of work and allows me to really sort out the things I usually do effectively from the ones I do less effectively. These impressions reflect the work of Oxford (2003), who maintains that distance-learning students are more likely to develop strategies than other students. From a didactic point of view, one possible follow-up would be to use the diversity of the behaviours described by the students: the behaviours which, according to them, were the first changes that they had to make on becoming online learners could be used as a basis for encouraging future newly registered students to develop their own method of learning. Psycho- and socioaffective level Winkin (1981) speaks of an ‘invisible college’ to refer to the informal network of researchers who opened up new avenues for studying communication in the 1970s. Using his idea, we can speak of ‘invisible colleagues’ who link students online with a learning community. These invisible colleagues are not only present in their physical absence, but they generate expectations and interests that are reconfigured by the technologized discursive
From Face-to-Face to Distance Learning
91
mise en sc`ene. In other words the platform as a specific social space sets a physical scene within which these particular expectations and interests are enhanced. Throughout the entirety of the short duration of the training course (6 months), teachers and students are linked by space (discursive platform space) and time to this type of communication: at any hour, day or night, one can potentially communicate, responses are possible, and a kind of quasi-continuous expectation of vigilance or attentiveness is generated, which is specific to this environment. ‘It is necessary to add to my palpable social network the reality of a second, virtual network in which I must regularly make an effort to participate’, says one student.
Conclusion This chapter has attempted to describe and evaluate the modification in social dynamics that results from the fact that learning no longer takes place on-site, but online. The EED of a pedagogical platform exposes students to communication methods that often elicit reactions of stress and insecurity, at least at the start. However, the study revealed that new learning methods are appearing, making up for the loss of old reference points, which came from on-site situations, by constructing behaviours that are adapted to online situations. In relation to the new context of learning, these sociocognitive adjustments may be facilitated through meta-cognitive practices enabled by the self-reflection and personal learning strategies that are necessary when managing one’s path of study alone (Oxford, 1990). The online student is thus developing identity traits that are different from those that she or he previously had as an on-site student. Also, a new relationship to knowledge is being put in place through the dynamics of online learners’ interactions, of which we have shown several aspects such as the change in the relationship to writing. Finally, new behaviours are arising, for example, more convivial interpersonal relationships between teachers and students, and less competitive, more connected, interpersonal relationships between students. The latter are supported by various communication forms (e-mail, chat, telephone) as a function of the message to be transmitted. We thus note that technological mediation includes the majority of practices, as in the example of ‘Googling’ teachers to find a few bits of information about their interests. The findings of this study reveal some of the constituent elements of the learning cultures of newly networked online learners. Seen from the two perspectives that are adopted in this chapter (their adjustment to the new pedagogical environment and their affiliation to their new job of online learner), these elements can be linked to:
92
Learning Cultures in Online Education
r emotion (e.g. insecurity-provoking contact with the environment, and the ambivalent feelings about contact with others, both socioaffectively and in collective tasks); r heightened awareness of the self in transition, particularly when former cultures are perceived to conflict with online needs or opportunities (e.g. in relation to writing, to newfound informality with teachers or to compensating for the disappearance of physical hallways and embodied interlocutors). The asynchronous online student is forging a complete identity; and it is up to the educational researchers to explore it, in order to better respond to its specificities.
Notes 1. While the question of whether and how the community is being tracked may have been in the awareness of more students than just the one quoted here, and therefore may have played a role in shaping the collective learning culture, we have not found empirical traces of this in our data and have therefore had to leave this question aside. 2. This refers to a previous error on my part, in which I caused the content of the forum to disappear.
Chapter 5
Being and Learning in the Online Classroom: Linguistic Practices and Ritual Text Acts Leah P. Macfadyen University of British Columbia, Canada
The ‘problem’ of online learning In this chapter, I explore an apparent difficulty in the development of effective learning cultures in virtual learning environments: the reality that much of the contemporary literature on educational research and pedagogical theory assumes (and, occasionally, insists) that physical presence is of critical importance for good teaching and good learning. The real-life encounter is often emphasized as a critical component of effective learning and intellectual development, and of the development of ‘real’ personal relationships that support good learning. Examples abound. Proponents of experiential learning – which rests on the educational philosophy of John Dewey (1966) – point to the importance of learners’ corporeal experience in integrating new ideas. Certainly, the social and intellectual impact of some of the educational movements that have embraced his ‘learning by doing’ pragmatism cannot be denied: Outward Bound and Service Learning, to name but two. Social constructivists have meanwhile built on the early work of Vygotsky (1962) and Piaget (1952) to emphasize the ways in which learners interact with others, and with their physical environment, to construct new understandings of self and world. In the realm of transformative learning, for example, Parks Daloz (2000) reports that meaningful educational encounters with ‘different others’ (2000: 112) are critical for perspective transformation and development of a commitment to social action. It is tacitly understood that meaningful encounter means embodied physical encounter. Perhaps even more significant is our understanding of the importance of social context in learning. Optimal learning environments do not simply
94
Learning Cultures in Online Education
create opportunities for individual learners to engage intellectually with course materials, or individually encounter their worlds as isolated selves that lack ‘community, tradition and shared meaning’ (Martin 2004: 25). Rather, optimal learning environments permit dynamic interaction between instructors, learners and tasks, and offer learners opportunities to create their own understanding through interaction with others, highlighting the importance of community, culture and context in knowledge construction (Derry 1999; McMahon 1997). In principle, online learning should offer learners a wider mix of interpersonal and cross-cultural encounters, over a shorter time span than can be offered by traditional face-to-face learning environments. But can a virtual classroom offer learners the kinds of community, collectivity and encounter with others, necessary for cognitive and intellectual development? Some educational theorists would argue that it cannot. Most famously (and perhaps most vehemently), Dreyfus (2001) has argued that learners cannot possibly experience risk-taking and vulnerability in virtual learning environments – conditions which he maintains are critical to the development of the transactional authenticity required for learning beyond ‘mere competence’ (Burbules 2002: 390). True mastery, real-world action and moral commitment, Dreyfus argues (2001), call for an affective intensity in learning that can only be achieved through embodied presence. The literature of social psychology might also appear to support Dreyfus’ contention. A growing body of empirical data gathered by investigators in this field supports the early predictions of social constructivist educational theorists, and demonstrates that embodiment plays a ubiquitous role in cognitive processing, both directly and indirectly (Barsalou et al., 2003). Theories of social embodiment that seek to explain these research observations point out that the body is extensively involved in all human activity, and argue that human knowledge is laid down in patterns of situated conceptualization that involves embodied states. The body, then, is deeply implicated in the social, cultural, experiential and cognitive processes of learning, in ways that might be perceived to make learning in virtual contexts deeply problematic. Individual bodies are understood to be the site of interlinked embodied states and cognitive processes that are triggered by social stimuli (Barsalou et al., 2003). And in interpersonal encounters, an individual’s authenticity – a term that in English connotes ‘truth’ and ‘accuracy of (self)representation’ and ‘trustworthiness’ – is supposed to be guaranteed by physical presence (Feenberg 1989) and the evidence of the senses. Cyberspace (and, in particular, virtual learning environments), on the other hand, remains overwhelmingly ‘a discursive and rhetorical space’ (Nakamura 2002: xiii). Despite recent experiments in the development of
Being and Learning in the Online Classroom
95
graphically represented virtual worlds such as Second Life, cyberspace is still primarily a ‘written world’ (Feenberg 1989: 23), constructed from written discourse, or text. In the text-based communications of cyberspace, bodily markers of identity such as physical attributes and vocal accent, are often invisible and bodily participation in gesture and ritual is usually impossible. Zurawski (2000) went as far as to argue that the physical body is, in effect, ‘banned from the Internet’ (n.p.). Concerns therefore persist about the internet as a problematic site for meaningful learner interaction, reflecting a historic preoccupation with material elements in the symbolic construction and representation of self and others.
Tools of authenticity in textual reality What do we mean by a learning culture? Poster (2001) has asked: Can there be a form of culture that is not bound to the surface of the globe, attaching human beings to its particular configurations with the weight of gravity, inscribing their bodies with its rituals and customs [. . .]? (2001: 150) Can there be learning cultures (to paraphrase Poster) that do not depend for their existence on geographical location or physical presence? If so, how can we best characterize their nature and development? Careful reflection on these questions reveals the intimate connection between individual learner identities and development of a group culture. Using the word culture complicates the task of characterization, of course, because of the degree of dispute over its meaning (Williams 1983). The definition of community is similarly disputed (see, for example, Jacobs 2004). And yet, I think it can be meaningfully insisted that a culture, however localized, is a shared feature of a group of some kind, let us call it here a community. Moreover, communities do not comprise homogeneous anonymous beings, un-differentiated neutral points between whom communication and interaction ‘happens’. Rather, they are a heterogeneous mixture of individuals who may or may not share common values, worldviews or perspectives. In considering what a learning culture may imply, Barker’s (1999) rather utilitarian perspective on culture is useful: [. . .] there is no “correct” or definitive meaning attached to it [. . .] Culture is not “out there” waiting to be correctly described by theorists who keep getting it wrong. Rather, the concept of culture is a tool which is of more or less usefulness to us [. . .]. (1999: 35)
96
Learning Cultures in Online Education
In a newly established learning environment, diverse learners – already inscribed with the rituals and customs of other communities to which they belong – will encounter each other. The idealized expectation is that they will engage intellectually with peers, course materials and instructors, through such intellectual performances as elaborating arguments or criticizing ideas. And yet this kind of intellectual performance presupposes a wealth of background understanding and shared assumptions (‘concepts, assumptions and methods of argument’ according to Xin and Feenberg 2006: 4) that learners must co-construct if they do not arrive with a common cultural (and intellectual) heritage. They must, in other words, co-construct a learning culture in which the ‘rules of engagement’ are understood and shared. Commonly referred to as a process of ‘negotiating meaning’, this process itself implies the revealing, sharing and negotiating of differences. That is to say, for a learning community to develop, for the construction of a learning culture to begin, learners must first be able to enact their authentic and differing identities in the learning space. Investigators concerned with the processes by which virtual learning communities begin to negotiate a shared culture have tended to focus on the discursive processes of community-building (getting to know each other, building relationships of trust, bonding around shared tasks or common experiences and group dynamics evident in virtual (learning) communities (see, for example, Bucher 2002; Conrad 2002; Oliveira Medeiros 2003). Some have used conversation analysis, for example, to examine details of message exchange (who speaks to whom), details of addressivity or patterning of social networks (Freiermuth 2000; Choi & Danowski 2002; Picciano 2002; Aviv et al. 2003; Reeder et al. 2004). Others have sought to elucidate learners’ perceptions of social presence in online learning environments as an indicator of the development of virtual community (Rourke et al. 2001; Swan & Shih 2005, and references therein). A growing number of studies have also sought to explore the cultural context of online learning. As Hewling (2005) points out, however, [. . .] much of the research into culture as it impacts the online class situates itself within a paradigm that equates culture with membership in a particular nation state. Online interaction, for example, is frequently looked at using interpretations drawn from the work of Hofstede (2001), Hall (1959, 1966), or Hall & Hall (1990). In other words, analyses of social context has tended to focus on the processes and communications between or uniting learners, while investigations of cultural context have tended to conceive of learners as
Being and Learning in the Online Classroom
97
representatives of rather essentialized notions of ‘national’ cultures – encultured automatons who arrive in the online classroom pre-programmed with a nonnegotiable suite of behaviours and communicative preferences. I will argue here that learners in text-based virtual learning environments begin the process of co-constructing a virtual learning culture by performing and sharing their unique virtual identities, and that one of the key strategies that individuals and newly forming virtual communities make use of in this process is ritual.
The role of ritual Sociologist Paul Connerton (1989) has demonstrated in fine detail the powerful collectivizing role played by ritual in human societies. On the role of ritual in the construction of collective memory – the communal narrative of a group – he writes: Both ritual and myth may quite properly be viewed as collective symbolic texts; and on this basis one may then go on to suggest that ritual actions should be interpreted as exemplifying [. . .] cultural values. (1989: 53) As with most sociological theory, there is much disagreement about the exact definition of ‘ritual’. A substantive overview of competing theoretical perspectives is beyond the scope of this chapter, and these have been thoroughly reviewed by Bell (1992). For our purposes here, however, it is useful to consider the definition proposed by Lukes (1975), who suggests that a ritual is a ‘rule-governed activity of a symbolic character which draws the attention of its participants to objects of thought and feeling that they hold to be of special significance’ (1975: 291). Rituals, clarifies Connerton, are repetitive and often stylized; they are expressive rather than instrumental, and they are expressive ‘by virtue of their conspicuous regularity’ (1989: 44). Most significant here is Connerton’s argument that the expressive influence of ritual is not limited to the ritual moment itself – rather, the expressive power of ritual thoroughly permeates nonritual action, ‘the whole life of a community’ (1989: 45). Importantly, although many rituals appear to be a re-enactment or commemoration of the past – ‘an explicit claim to be commemorating continuity’ (1989: 45) – Connerton points out that human communities routinely invent new rituals, ceremonies and commemorations in the rewriting (or re-interpreting) of collective identity. (For example, he points to the politically motivated invention by the Republican bourgeoisie in 1880 of a rite
98
Learning Cultures in Online Education
to commemorate Bastille Day, as a means of reasserting France’s collective identity as ‘the nation of 1789’ (1989: 51). While most ritual theorists have tended to focus on the bodily practices of rites and ceremonies, Connerton explores the ways in which language, too, can be performative and ritualistic. Discussing the linguistic rituals of liturgy, for example, he points out that liturgy is not a ‘verbal commentary on an action external to itself [. . .] in and of itself liturgical language is an action’ (1989: 57). Oaths, blessings, curses, recitations, songs, stories, poems and prayers similarly make use of repeated patterns of syntax, vocabulary and sequencing, with powerful mnemonic effect. Austin’s (1962) philosophy of language explains that performative utterances possess ‘illocutionary force’ – they do not simply offer statements about the world that can be characterized as true or false. Instead, speech acts, or illocutionary acts, do something instead of simply saying something: they fulfil a range of symbolic purposes, including representing the self and the nature of the self’s relationship with others. In other words, rituals – corporeal and/or linguistic – are both performative and creative. They acknowledge and commemorate existing elements of identity, and they contribute to the construction of new forms, and new interpretations, of community and collective identity. They allow individuals to celebrate, maintain and reinforce existing bonds, and they are routinely employed to create new social and interpersonal bonds. Ritual might appear, then, to be a perfectly suited strategy for navigating the tension that virtual learners experience between their need to represent their existing identities in a new learning context, and the need to collaborate with new peers in the construction and enlargement of the common ground – the learning culture – that is necessary to permit advancement of the learning agenda. At first glance, however, the notion of ritual as a community-building strategy in cyberspace also seems to suffer from the ‘embodiment problem’ discussed earlier. Bell (1992) and other respected ritual theorists have written extensively about the crucial involvement of the body in ritual. Bourdieu (1990) similarly argues that ritual imposes and inculcates ‘habitus’ in individuals: our way-of-being in the world that comprises ‘a set of learned dispositions which the body can express within an appropriate social context’ (Harris 2004: n.p.). ‘The fundamental feature of ritualization is that its strategies are rooted in the body’, says Harris, and its outcomes are a ‘somatic knowing’ (ibid.). As early as 1989, however, Feenberg presciently described the ways in which computer-mediated communication has disrupted the traditionally imagined continuum of communicative forms, which positions written, typed, and printed forms of communication as less intimate and less
Being and Learning in the Online Classroom
99
personal than speech; in this continuum, face-to-face communication has been assumed to be the most authentic. What Feenberg noticed, with surprise, was that computer-mediated communication did not appear to be as ‘inhuman’ as it was purported to be, but instead that its ‘lively, rapid iterations’ are ‘almost lively enough to recall spoken conversation’ (1989: 23). Text-based online communications, he argued, violate ‘our deeply ingrained cultural assumptions about communication’ (ibid.). I, and others, have also proposed elsewhere (Yates 1996; Macfadyen 2006) that the language of virtual worlds should no longer be viewed simply as text. Though appearing as print, the writing of the virtual world is ‘text-becoming-speech’ (Macfadyen 2006) and as such, I have proposed that it also has the capacity to play a performative and creative ritualistic role. What precedent is there for imagining that rituals might be practiced in textually mediated virtual spaces? While theorists have historically understood ritual practice to be necessarily embodied, a newer cohort of investigators has begun to examine ritual practices in online environments (see, for example, the work of Gregor Ahn and team at the University of Heidelberg, in the Research Centre ‘Ritual Dynamics’). Langer et al. (2006) have also usefully begun to describe the process of ritual transfer : ‘the transfer of ritual from one context into another or – more generally – a change of the context surrounding the ritual’ (2006: 1). These authors point out that rituals are dynamic and changing. Changes can be minor modifications or major transformations of ‘one or more of its internal dimensions’ (ibid.) such as ‘script, performance, structure, communication or mediality’ (Miczek 2007: 7). Below, I begin to describe how online learners transfer ‘first life’ rituals of representation, symbolization and collectivization into virtual learning environments, transforming practices that might previously have taken place through embodied action and sensory perception into explicit articulations in text. Learners re-inscribe their bodies into the text of their communications, and they participate in an evolving sequence of textual rituals that serve to expand their common ground – the collection of shared values and assumptions that are necessary for continuing dialogue and collective construction of meaning.
Investigating textual practices in online learning The virtual learning environment