Lie Theory and Special Functions
Mathematics in Science and Engineering A Series
of Monographs and
Textbooks
Edited by RICHARD BELLMAN, University of Southern California
1. TRACY Y. THOMAS. Concepts from Tensor Analysis and Differential Geometry. Second Edition. 1965
Y. THOMAS. Plastic Flow and Fracture in Solids. 1961 2. TRACY ARIS. The Optimal Design of Chemical Reactors: A Study in Dynamic 3. RUTHERFORD Programming. 1961
4. JOSEPHLASALLEand SOLOMON LEFSCHETZ. Stability by Liapunov’s Direct Method with Applications. 1961
(ed.) . Optimization Techniques: With Applications to Aero5. GEORGELEITMANN
6. 7. 8. 9.
space Systems. 1962 RICHARD BELLMAN and KENNETH L. COOKE.Differential-Difference Equations. 1963
FRANK A. HAIGHT.Mathematical Theories of Traffic Flow. 1963 F. V. ATKINSON.Discrete and Continuous Boundary Problems. 1964 A. JEFFREYand T. TANIUTI. Non-Linear Wave Propagation: With Applications to Physics and Magnetohydrodynamics. 1964
10. JULIUST. Tou. Optimum Design of Digital Control Systems. 1963 11. HARLEYFLANDERS. Differential Forms: With Applications to the Physical Sciences. 1963 M. ROBERTS. Dynamic Programming in Chemical Engineering and Process 12. SANFORD Control. 1964
13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
SOLOMON LEFSCHETZ. Stability of Nonlinear Control Systems. 1965 DIMITRISN. CHORAFAS. Systems and Simulation. 1965 A. A. PERVOZVANSKII. Random Processes in Nonlinear Control Systems. 1965 111, Methods of Matrix Algebra. 1965 MARSHALL C. PEASE,
V. E. BENES.Mathematical Theory of Connecting Networks and Telephone Traffic. 1965 18. WILLIAMF. AMES. Nonlinear Partial Differential Equations in Engineering. 1965
19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
J. ACZEL.Lectures on Functional Equations and Their Applications. 1966 R. E. MURPHY.Adaptive Processes in Economic Systems. 1965 S. E. DREYFUS.Dynamic Programming and the Calculus of Variations. 1965 A. A. FEL’DBAUM. Optimal Control Systems. 1965 A. HALANAY. Differential Equations : Stability, Oscillations, Time Lags. 1966 M. NAMIKOCUZTOWI.Time-Lag Control Systems. 1966 DAVIDSWORDER. Optimal Adaptive Control Systems. 1966
MILTONASH. Optimal Shutdown Control of Nuclear Reactors. 1966 DIMITRISN. CHORAFAS. Control System Functions and Programming Approaches ( I n Two Volumes). 1966 28. N. P. ERUGIN.Linear Systems of Ordinary Differential Equations. 1966 MARCUS.Algebraic Linguistics; Analytical Models. 1967 29. SOLOMON Stability of Motion. 1966 30. A. M. LIAPUNOV.
31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42.
43. 44. 45.
.
GEORGE LEITMANN (ed.) Topics i n Optimization. 1967 MASANAO AOKI. Optimization of Stochastic Systems. 1967 J. KUSHNER. Stochastic Stability and Control. 1967 HAROLD MINORUURABE. Nonlinear Autonomous Oscillations. 1967 F. CALOGERO. Variable Phase Approach to Potential Scattering. 1967 A. KAUFMANN. Graphs, Dynamic Programming, and Finite Games. 1967 A. KAUFMANN and R. CRUON.Dynamic Programming: Sequential Scientific Management. 1967 J. H. AHLBERG, E. N. NILSON,and J. L. WALSH.The Theory of Splines and Their Applications. 1967 Y. SAWARACI, Y. SUNAHARA, and T. NAKAMIZO. Statistical Decision Theory in Adaptive Control Systems. 1967 RICHARD BELLMAN. Introduction to the Mathematical Theory of Control Processes Volume I. 1967 (Volumes I1 and I11 in preparation) E. STANLEY LEE. Quasilinearization and Invariant Imbedding. 1968 WILLIAM AMES.Nonlinear Ordinary Differential Equations in Transport Processes. 1968 WILLARD MILLER,JR. Lie Theory and Special Functions. 1968 PAULB. BAILEY,LAWRENCE F. SHAMPINE, and PAUL E. WALTMAN. Nonlinear Two Point Boundary Value Problems. 1968 P. PETROV. Variational Methods in Optimum Control Theory. 1968
In preparation
A. KAUFMANN and R. FAURE.Introduction to Operations Research N. K. JAISWAL. Priority Queues ROBERT HERMANN. Differential Geometry and the Calculus of Variations 0. A. LADYZHENSKAYA and N. N. URAL’TSEVA. Linear and Quasilinear Elliptic Equations Comparison and Oscillation Theory of Differential Equations C. A. SWANSON. ROBERT P. GILBERT. Function Theoretic Methods in the Theory of Partial Differential Equations YUDELL LUKE.The Special Functions and Their Approximations (In Two Volumes) HUKUKANE NIKAIDO.Convex Structures and Economic Theory
This page intentionally left blank
Lie Theory and Special Functions
Willard Miller, Jr. DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA
Academic Press
New York and London
1968
COPYRIGHT 0 1968,
BY ACADEMIC PRESS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
INC.
NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED I N ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. Berkeley Square House, London W.l
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBER: 68-18677
PRINTED I N THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
In Memory of Professor Bernard Friedman
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
This monograph is the result of an attempt to understand the role played by special function theory in the formalism of mathematical physics. I t demonstrates explicitly that special functions which arise in the study of mathematical models of physical phenomena and the identities which these functions obey are in many cases dictated by symmetry groups admitted by the models. I n particular it will be shown that the factorization method, a powerful tool for computing eigenvalues and recurrence relations for solutions of second order ordinary differential equations (Infeld and Hull [l]), is equivalent to the representation theory of four local Lie groups. A detailed study of these four groups and their Lie algebras leads to a unified treatment of a significant proportion of special function theory, especially that part of the theory which is most useful in mathematical physics. Most of the identities for special functions derived in this book are known in one form or another. Our principal aim is not to derive new results but rather to provide insight into the structure of special function theory. Thus, all of the identities obtained here will be given an explicit group-theoretic interpretation instead of being considered merely as the result of some formal manipulation of infinite series. T h e primary tools needed to deduce our results are multiplier representations of local Lie groups and representations of Lie algebras by generalized Lie derivatives. These concepts are introduced in Chapter 1 along with a brief survey of classical Lie theory. I n Chapter 2 we state our main theme: Special functions occur as matrix elements and basis vectors corresponding to multiplier representations of local Lie groups. Chapters 3-6 are devoted to the explicit analysis of the special function ix
X
PREFACE
theory of the complex local Lie groups with four-dimensional Lie . algebras g(0, O), g(0, l), %(I, 0) and six-dimensional Lie algebra F6 Many fundamental properties of hypergeometric, confluent hypergeometric, and Bessel functions are obtained from this analysis. Furthermore, in Chapter 7 it is shown that the representation theory of these four Lie groups is completely equivalent to the factorization method of Infeld and Hull. I n Chapter 8 we determine the scope of our analysis by constructing the rudiments of a classification theory of generalized Lie derivatives. T hi s classification theory enables us to decide in what sense the results of Chapters 3-6 are complete. Chapter 8 is more difficult than the rest of the book since it presupposes a knowledge of some rather deep results in local Lie theory and an acquaintance with the cohomology theory of Lie algebras. Hence, it may be omitted on a first reading. Finally, in Chapter 9 we apply some of the results of the classification theory to obtain identities for special functions which are not related to the factorization method. It should be noted that we will be primarily concerned with the representation theory of local Lie groups, a subject which was developed in the nineteenth century. T h e more recent and sophisticated theory of global Lie groups is by itself too narrow to obtain many fundamental identities for special functions. Also, unitary representations of Lie groups will occur only as special cases of our results; they will not be our primary concern. T h e scope of this book is modest: we study no Lie algebras with , dimension greater than 6. Furthermore, in the six-dimensional case, F6 we do not give complete results. (The so-called addition theorems of Gegenbauer type for Bessel functions would be obtained from such an analysis.) However, it should be clear to the reader that our methods can be generalized to higher dimensional Lie algebras. We will almost exclusively be concerned with the derivation of recursion relations and addition theorems. T h e manifold applications of group theory in the derivation of orthogonality relations and integral transforms of special functions will rarely be considered. For these applications see the encyclopedic work of Vilenkin [3]. T h e overlap in subject matter between that book and this one is relatively small, except in the study of unitary representations of real Lie groups. This monograph has been strongly influenced by the work of Bargmann [ 1 4 ] , Infeld and Hull [I], Schwinger [I], Weisner [l-31, and Wigner [l, 21. T h e author’s primary contribution has been to weave these papers into a coherent theory relating Lie groups and special functions. A knowledge of the basic elements of complex analysis, functional
PREFACE
xi
analysis, local Lie theory, and the theory of special functions is desirable for a proper understanding of the work presented here. This would correspond roughly with the background of an advanced graduate student in theoretical physics. I wish to dedicate this book to the memory of Professor Bernard Friedman, in the hope that it will in a small way help to bridge the gap between the pure and applied sciences, a cause for which he was such an eloquent advocate.
January 1968
WILLARD MILLER,JR.
This page intentionally left blank
Contents PREFACE .
...............................
ix
CHAPTER 1
RCum6 of l i e Theory 1-1 1-2 1-3 1-4
Local Lie Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Local Transformation Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples of Local Transformation Groups . . . . . . . . .
.. . .
1 5 12 19
CHAPTER 2
Representations and Realizations of Lie Algebras 2-1 Representations of Lie Algebras . . . . . . 2-2 Realizations of Representations . . . . . . . 2-3 Representations of L ( 0 , ) . . . . . . . . . 2-4 The Angular Momentum Operators . . . . 2-5 The Lie Algebras s(a.b) . . . . . . . . . 2-6 Representations of S(a. b) . . . . . . . . . 2-7 Realizations of S(a. b) in Two Variables . . . 2-8 Realizations of '3(a. b) in One Variable . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
.......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
25 27 31 33 36 38 45 49
CHAPTER 3
l i e Theory and Bessel Functions 3-1 The Representations Q(w. m.) . . . . . . 3-2 Recursion Relations for the Matrix Elements 3-3 Realizations of Q(w. m. ) in Two Variables . 3-4 Weisner's Method for Bessel Functions . . 3-5 The Real Euclidean Group E. . . . . . . 3-6 Unitary Representations of Lie Groups . . . . . . . . 3-7 Induced Representations of xiii
. . . . . . . . . . .
...........
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
52 57 59 63 65 67 70
CONTENTS
xiv
3-8 The Unitary Representations ( p ) of E. 3-9 The Matrix Elements of ( p ) . . . . 3-10 The Infinitesimal Operators of ( p ) .
..............
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
71 75 76
CHAPTER 4
Lie Theory and Confluent H ypergoemetric Functions 4-1 The Representation R(w. m., p) . . . . . . . . 4-2 4-3 4-4 4-5 4-6 4-7 4-8
4-9 4-10 4-11 4-12 4-1 3 4-14 4-15 4-16 4-17 4-18 4-19 4-20 4-21
........
The Representation to. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . TheRepresentation bW. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Differential Equations for the Matrix Elements . . . . . . . . . . The Representation @ ............... A Realization of R(w. m. p ) by Type D Operators . . . . . . . . A Realization of to.,,by Type D Operators . . . . . . . . . . . Transformations of Type C' Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type C' Realizations of R(w. m. p) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Type C' Realizations of The Group S4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Induced Representations of 9. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Hilbert Space S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Unitary Representation (A. I) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Matrix Elements of (A. I) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Unitary Representations (A. -I) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Tensor Products (A. I) Q (A'. l') The Representations (A. I) Q (A'. 4') .............. The Representations (A. I) Q (A'. 4). . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Representations ( p ) Q (A. I) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Contraction of Y(O.1) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
tolSpl t%.,,
.
.
79 85 89 91 94 101 104 106 109
111 113 114 117 119 122 125 127 131 136 146 150
CHAPTER 5
Lie Theory and Hypcrgoemetric Functions 5-1 The Representation P ( u . m.,) . . . .
tu
.............
5-2 The Representation .................... 5-3 The Representation ,, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-4 The Representation D(2u) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-5 The Tensor Product D(2u) Q D(2u) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-6 The Tensor Product Q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-7 Differential Relations for the Matrix Elements . . . . . . . . . . 5-8 Type B Realizations of D(u. m.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-9 Type B Realizations of . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-10 Weisner's Method for Type B Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-11 Type A Realizations of D(u. m.,) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5- 12 Type A Realizations of . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-13 Type A Realizations of . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-14 Type A Realizations of D(2u) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-15 Weisner's Method for Type A Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-16 The Group SU(2) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-17 The Group G. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-18 Unitary Representations of G, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-19 Contractions of 9(1. 0 ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4
tu t t
t -1
155 161 165 167 170 176 180 183 187 190 194 200 205 206 210 214 221 226 238
CONTENTS
xv
CHAPTER 6
Special Functions Related to the Euclidean Group in I S p a c e Representations of .Te. . . . . . . . . . Type E Operators . . . . . . . . . . . Type F Operators . . . . . . . . . . . The Euclidean Group Es . . . . . . . The Matrix Elements of ( w . s) . . . . .
6-1 6-2 6-3 6-4 6-5
........... ........... ...........
............ . . . . . . . . . . . .
243 249 253 255 262
CHAPTER 7
The Factorization Method
7- 1 Recurrence Relations . . 7-2 The Factorization Types .
................... ...................
268 272
CHAPTER 8
Generalized Lie Derivatives
8-1 Generalized Derivations . . . . . . . . . . 8-2 Cohomology Classes of Realizations . . . . 8-3 Computation of the Cohomology Classes . 8-4 Tables of Cohomology Classes . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
........ ......... ......... . . . . . . . . .
278 281 289 293
The Lie Algebra X6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Lie Group K I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Representations of X5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Representation R'(w. m,. p ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Lie Algebra Z'J., . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Lie Group G,.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Representations of 'ZJn.@ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recursion Relations for the Matrix Elements . . . . . . . . . . . Realizations in Two Variables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generating Functions for Generalized Bessel Functions . . . . . .
299 300 301 302 308 312 313 314 316 318 320
CHAPTER 9
Some Generalizations 9-1 9-2 9-3 9-4 9-5 9-6 9-7 9-8 9-9 9-10 9-11
Appendix I 2 3 4 5
t;.
The Gamma Function . . . . . . . . . . The Hypergeometric Function . . . . . . The Confluent Hypergeometric Function . Parabolic Cylinder Functions . . . . . . Bessel Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . .
........... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ ...........
324 325 327 328 329
Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
330
.............................
336
INDEX
This page intentionally left blank
Lie Theory ond Special Functions
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER
1 R6sumi5 of Lie Theory
This chapter contains the fundamental definitions and results from the theory of local Lie groups that will be needed in the remainder of the book. The basic theorems are presented largely without proofs, since the material is treated in standard works on Lie theory (Lie [I], Cohn [I], Pontrjagin [l], Guggenheimer [l]). Although a good understanding of these theorems is desirable for a proper appreciation of group-theoretic methods in special function theory, it is not essential, as we will be primarily concerned with specific examples for which we can directly verify the validity of our group-theoretic manipulations. The treatment of Lie theory given here is based on that of Guggenheimer [l], which is a reformulation of Lie’s original approach. This treatment is characterized by its dependence on local coordinates. T h e study of special functions requires detailed computations in explicitly given coordinate systems, so modern coordinatefree methods in Lie theory are not particularly useful. The examples of local Lie groups and local Lie transformation groups presented in Sections 1-2 and 1-4 are important since they will recur frequently throughout the book.
1-1
Local Lie Groups
I t is assumed that the reader is familiar with the concept of a (global) Lie group: A Lie group is both an abstract group and an analytic manifold such that the operations of group multiplication and group inversion are analytic with respect to the manifold structure (Hamermesh [I],
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
2
Helgason [l], Pontrjagin [l], Eisenhart [l]). I n much of this book, however, we shall be concerned with groups which are defined and analytic only in some neighborhood of the group identity element, that is, with local Lie groups. Let @, be the space of complex n-tuples g = (g, ,g,,...,g,) where gi E @ for i = 1, 2,..., n, and define the origin e of @% by e = ( 0 , O ,..., 0). Suppose V is an open set in @n containing e. Definition A complex n-dimensional local Lie group G in the neighborhood V C gn is determined by a function cp: x @n + such that
cn
(1)
cp(g,h) E @"
for all
en
g, h E V.
(2) V(g, h) is analytic in each of its 2n arguments. (3) Ifcp(g, h) E V , v(h, k) E V , then cp(cp(g,h), k) = cp(g, cp(h, k)). (4) cp(e, g) = g, cp(g, e) = g for all g E V . I n particular, a neighborhood of the identity element of a global Lie group is a local Lie group. It follows from (4) and the implicit function theorem that if G is a local Lie group there exists a neighborhood V' of e such that for every g E V' there is a unique element denoted g-l in V with the property cp(g, g-l) = V(g-', g) = e . T h e mapping p(g) = g-l is analytic in the n arguments of g. T o simplify notation, we shall often write cp(g, h) = gh. I n terms of this definition of group multiplication, property ( 3 ) is the associative law (gh)k = g(hk) and property (.4) defines e as the group identity element. Furthermore, if g is in a small enough neighborhood of e then 8-l E V where g-l is the multiplicative inverse of g. Let G be a local Lie group and let t + g(t) = (gl(t),...,g,(t)), t E @, be an analytic mapping of a neighborhood of 0 E @ into V such that g(0) = e. We can consider such a mapping to be a complex analytic curve in G passing through e. T h e tangent vector to g(t) at e is the vector
Every vector CY E gn is the tangent vector at e for some analytic curve. I n particular, the curve at = (OLlt, OLZt,..., ant)
has the tangent vector
CY
=
(01,
,..., an) at e .
(1.2)
1-1. LOCAL LIE GROUPS
3
If g ( t ) , h(t) are analytic curves in G with g(0) = h(0) = e and tangent vectors 01, 8 at e, respectively, then the analytic curve g(t)h(t)has tangent /3 at e. Here, the plus sign (+) refers to the usual vector vector 01 addition in Cn. With g ( t ) , h(t) as given above, define the commutator [ 0 1 , / 3 ] of 01 and /3 to be the tangent vector at e of the analytic curve
+
k(t) = g(T)h(T) g-'(T) h-'(T),
t
=T
(1.3)
~ .
Thus,
T h e commutator has the properties:
(1) [a, 81 = -[851,
(2)
[al%
+
a2a2 >
011,
PI
a51,
=a 1 C . 1
8 e Cn,
, 81 + a2[O12
7
PI,
+
a1 011
3
a2 E
C51,
8 E en,
, 01.2,
(3) "a, 8151,rl "P51, rl51,a1 = "a, rl, 61. T h e Lie algebra L( G) of the local Lie group G is the set of all tangent vectors at e equipped with the operations of vector addition and Lie product. Definition A complex abstract Lie algebra 9 is a complex vector space together with a multiplication [a, /3] E 9 defined for all a, 8 E 9 such that
81 = -[/351, 4, (2) [%% + aza2 81 = %[a1 81 + 4%PI,
(1)
[a,
51,
(3)
"%
8151,rl
+ "8, rl, a3
7
9
= "%
71, 81.
a, 011
a2 E @, , 012 8 E 9, 7
7
Clearly, L(G) is a complex abstract Lie algebra. (Note: Unless otherwise stated all Lie algebras are assumed to be finite-dimensional. See Section 2-1 for a definition of this concept.) Definition An analytic homomorphism of a local Lie group G into a local Lie group G' is a map p: G + G', where p ( g ) is defined for g in a suitably small neighborhood W of e, such that
CLW) = Ad Ah),
g, h, gh E
w,
(1.5)
and p is an analytic function of the coordinates of G. T h e group multiplication on the right-hand side of (1 S ) takes place in G'.
1. Rl%UME OF LIE THEORY
4
It follows from (1.5) that p(e) = e', where e' is the identity element of G', and p(g-') = p(g)-l for g in a suitably small neighborhood of e in G. A homomorphism which maps G one-to-one onto a neighborhood of e' in G' is called an isomorphism. An isomorphism of G onto G is a n automorphism. Note that an element h of G defines an automorphism &)
= hgh-l,
g E G-
(1.6)
Automorphisms of the form (1.6) are called inner automorphisms. Let 9,9'be complex abstract Lie algebras with operations +, [., .] and [., .]', respectively.
+',
Definition A homomorphism from 3 to 9'is a map such that
(1)
(2)
T(aO1 $-
PI)
r([a,
bp) = aT(a) f '
bT(@),
a, 01,
4311'.
E
T:
9 -+ 3'
@,
fi E 9,
= [7(a>,
A Lie algebra homomorphism which is a one-to-one map of 3 onto 9' is called an isomorphism. An isomorphism of 9 onto 3 is an automorphism. Theorem 1.1 An analytic homomorphism p : G -+G' of the local Lie groups G, G' induces a Lie algebra homomorphism p * : L(G)-tL(G') defined by
where g ( t ) is an analytic curve in G with tangent vector 01 at e. T h e p* is an isomorphism (automorphism) if and only if p is an isomorphism (automorphism). We can now state the basic Theorem 1.2 (Converse of Lie's Third Fundamental Theorem) A complex abstract Lie algebra is the Lie algebra of some local Lie
group. Two local Lie groups with isomorphic Lie algebras are isomorphic. Thus, up to isomorphism there is a one-to-one correspondence between local Lie groups and Lie algebras. Let G be a local Lie group and let g, h E V . Then
gh
= Cpk,
h)
=
( d g ,h),...,vn.n(g,h))
1-2. EXAMPLES
5
is an analytic function of g and h. This function can be expanded in a Taylor series in the components of g about g = e. Thus,
+ &%Fij(h) + ... n
d g , h ) = hi
( 1-71
3=1
where g= e
Let g ( t ) = (gl(t),...,g,( t ) ) be the integral curve of the system of differential equations
with the initial condition g(0) = e. T h e function g ( t ) is uniquely determined by a E L(G) and is defined for suitably small values of I t I. We write g ( t ) = exp at. Theorem 1.3 T h e integral curve exp at is a 1-parameter subgroup of G such that exp a(tl t,) = exp atl exp at, for suitably small values of I t , 1, 1 t, I. T h e tangent vector of exp at at e is 01 = ( a , ,..., a,). Since the elements of L(G) are n-tuples, we can consider L(G) to be induces a topology in L(G). defined in @. T h e usual topology of
+
Theorem 1.4 T h e mapping a-ex p a is an analytic diffeomorphism of a neighborhood of 0 EL(G) onto a neighborhood of e in G. (Here, 0 is the additive identity ofL(G).) Th a t is, the mapping defines a local one-to-one analytic coordinate transformation in U p to now we have been concerned with the theory of complex local Lie groups. However, there is an analogous theory of real local Lie groups. The relevant definitions and theorems for real groups can easily be obtained from the foregoing analysis by replacing the word “complex” and the symbol C‘ (complex field) by the word “real” and the symbol R (real field).
en.
1-2
Examples
T h e 2 x 2 complex general linear group GL(2) is the set of all 2 by 2 nonsingular matrices g=
(f
i),
a , b, c, d € Q, ad
-
6c # 0,
(1.9)
1. RESUME
6
OF LIE THEORY
where the group operation is matrix multiplication (Boerner [l], Chapter 2). (We will sometimes use the notation G(l, 0) for GL(2).) Clearly, the identity element of GL(2)is the matrix
I n a neighborhood of e in GL(2) we can introduce coordinates for the group element g by setting g
= (g, g, 7
1
,
g3 g4)
= ( a - 1, b, c, d - 1).
(1.10)
With this coordinate system it is easy to verify that GL(2)is a 4-dimensional complex local Lie group. These coordinates are valid only for g in a suitably small neighborhood of e ; they cannot be extended over all of @4. Any local Lie group obtained from (1.9) and (1.10) by introducing an analytic invertible change of local coordinates is locally isomorphic to the group constructed here. Thus, it makes sense to speak about the local Lie group GL(2).(GL(2)is also a global Lie group, see Pontrjagin [ l ] . ) Let g(t), g(0) = e' be an analytic curve in GL(2) with tangent vector at e given by
We can identify
01
with the complex 2 x 2 matrix (1.11)
and L[GL(2)]= g42) with the space of all 2 x 2 complex matrices a. I n terms of this identification, an explicit calculation using (1.4) gives [ a , 81 = 4
-
8.
(1.12)
for a , /3 ~ g Z ( 2where ) the multiplication on the right-hand side of (1.12) is matrix multiplication. T h e special elements f + , 8-,f 3 , G,
(1.13)
1-2. EXAMPLES
7
form a basis for gZ(2) in the sense that every uniquely in the form a = a,$+
+ a&- +
.3y3
+
a,&,
a,
01
~ g Z ( 2can ) be written
, a2 , a3 , a4 E e'.
These basis elements obey the commutation relations
where 0 is the 2 x 2 matrix all of whose components are 0. - T h e 2 x 2 complex special linear group SL(2) is the abstract matrix group of all 2 x 2 nonsingular matrices
such that det g = 1. Clearly, SL(2) is a subgroup of GL(2). We can introduce coordinates for a group element g in a neighborhood of the identity e of SL(2) by setting g
+
= (g1 ,g, , g3) = ( a - 1, b, 4.
(1.16)
Here, d = (1 bc)/a. I n terms of these coordinates SL(2) is a 3-dimensional local Lie group. (It is also a global Lie group.) Suppose g ( t ) , g(0) = e, is an analytic curve whose tangent vector at e is a = (9? a2
a
,a 3 )
=
d
1, b ( t ) ,c(t))j
(a(t) -
t=o
;
can be identified with the complex 2 x 2 matrix (1.17)
since d
dt
i1 +
b(t)cft)
~
a(t)
Thus, L[SL(2)]= 4 2 ) is the space of all 2 x 2 complex matrices with trace zero. As in our first example, the Lie product is given by [a, /3] = a/3 - /3a for a, /3 E 4 2 ) . T h e elements
8
1. RESUMC OF LIE THEORY
satisfying the commutation relations [f3,
$+I
=
$+,
[f3 $-I ,
=
-Y-, [Y+, 2-1 = 2x3
(1.19)
form a basis for sZ(2). Since SL(2) is of great importance in special function theory we will study it in somewhat more detail than GL(2). For g E SL(2), a E sZ(2), Eqs. (1.8) can be written in the matrix form (1.20)
T h e solution of this equation is (1.21)
which converges for all t E @. Thus, in this case exp at = eat and the map a ---t e m is an analytic diffeomorphism of a neighborhood of 0 E $42) onto a neighborhood of e E SL(2). Some particular examples of this mapping which will be useful later are
Corresponding to any g E SL(2) define the inner automorphism ps of
SLCa bv ,
-
h E s~5(2),
d h ) = ghg-l,
(1.23)
where g-1 is the matrix inverse to g. By Theorem 1.1, pg induces an autornorphism p.g* of 4 2 ) where $(a) =
If a = xl$+
+ x2$- +
(1.24)
CtESE(2).
gag-', x3f3
=
(s,!'2 -x2
-xl
-x3/2
)
direct computation shows that the action of pp* on a is
ad -
+
bc x3 - bdx,
+ acx,
--abx3
+ b2x, - a2xl
-x3 + bcx,
' -bc
This equation will prove useful in Chapter 5 .
- acx1
.
(1.25)
1-2. EXAMPLES
9
The abstract group G(0,l) consists of all 4 x 4 matrices of the form a , b, c, 7 E @,
(1.26)
where the group operation is matrix multiplication. It is easy to verify that G(0, 1) is in fact a group. Indeed, g-l
=
and
1
-C
0
e-5 0
0
0
-U+bC
-T
!) E
G(0, 1)
(1.27)
where g, and g, are matrices of the form (1.26). We can introduce coordinates for the element g in G(0, 1) by setting ( a , b, C,
g
(1.29)
T).
Thus, G(0, 1) is a complex 4-dimensional Lie group. I n this case the coordinates (1.29) are valid over the entire group and not just in a neighborhood of the identity. The group G(0, 1 ) is said to be simply connected (Pontrjagin [13, Chapter 8). L[G(O, l)] can be identified with the space of 4 x 4 matrices of the form
a =
i" : : ") 0 0
0
0
0 0
0
0
with Lie product [a, /3]
= a/3
-
0 0 0 0 0 O 0 01,
.=(. .), 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
x1 , x2 1 x,
7
x4 E
@,
(1.30)
.-(. oj,
POI,a , /3 EL[G(O,l)].
f+=(o0
0 0 0 0
'
The matrices
0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 E = (0 0 0
0 O 0 0
1 O 0 0
0
0) 0 0
(1.31)
10
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
with commutation relations
where 0 is the 4 x 4 zero matrix, form a basis for L[G(O, I)]. The exponential map exp a, a EL[G(O,l)], defined by Eqs. (1.8) takes the form
and in this case is an analytic diffeomorphism mapping all of L[G(O, l)] onto G(0, 1). In particular,
expTf3 =
0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
(: oj,
0 0 0 1
.).
0 0 1 01 0
l O a O e x p a € = (o0 0 1 01 0
0 0 0 1
0 0 0 1
c
exPC%-=
exp by+=
o
o
a, b, c,
T
E
(1.33)
G'.
If gE G(0, I), the inner automorphism po of G(0, 1) defined by pp(h)= ghg-1, induces an automorphism p$ of L[G(O,l)] where &a) = gag-' for a EL[G(O,I)]. If a = x , f + x2$x3j3 x48,
+
direct computation yields p:(a) = ( x p
- x3b)/+
+
+
+ (x2e-' + x3c)f-
+ x 3 f 3 + (xIceT - x,be-l
- x3bc + x4)€,
(1.34)
where g is given by (1.26). We will make use of this equation in Chapter 4. The matrix group T3 is the set of all 4 x 4 matrices
1-2. EXAMPLES
11
T h e inverse of g E T, is given by
(1.36)
and the product g,g, by 0
71
+
72
(1.37) 1
where g, and g, are matrices of the form (1.35). We can establish a coordinate system for T , by assigning to g E T3 the coordinates g = (b, c, 7 ) .
(1.38)
T, is clearly a 3-dimensional complex local Lie group. Moreover, the coordinates (1.38) can be extended over all of Thus, T , has the topology of and is simply connected (Pontrjagin [l], Chapter 8). 9, = L( T3) can be identified with the space of matrices of the form
c3.
c3
o o o x , (1.39)
0
0
0
where the Lie product is [a, /3] is provided by the matrices
0 =
a/3 - Pa, a, ,0 E
;;?)I
0 0 0 0
8+=(:
0 0 0 0
8 - =(o0
0 0 o)l 1
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
(:-; ; :) 0
0
0
1
0
0
0
f3=
0
with commutation relations
. A basis for F3
(1-40)
12
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
T h e mapping a + exp a of F, onto T , , Eq. (1.8), is exp a Some particular cases of interest are 1
0
0
0
0
0
=
em.
1 0 0 0
1
.j.
0 0 0 1
(1.42)
1 0 0 0 0 1 0 exPC%-= (o 0 1
0 0 0 1
T h e map pz defined for g E T , by automorphism of F, . If a = x l f + (1.35) we have Cl-,(a) = (x,eT
1-3
-
bx,)$+
&(a)
=
gag-’ for all a E F, is an and g is given by
+ x2f- + x3f3
+ (x2ecT+ cx,)/- + x3Y3.
(1.43)
Local Transformation Groups
This section contains the principal results of the Lie theory of local transformation groups which are applicable to special function theory. I n particular, Theorem 1.10 will be used frequently in the remainder of this book. All the definitions and theorems will be stated for complex groups acting on complex manifolds; the results for real groups acting on real manifolds are completely analogous. Let G be an n-dimensional local Lie group and U an open set in Cm. Suppose there is given a mapping F: U x G + Cm and write F(x,g) = x g E C m f o r x . U , g E G . Definition G acts on the manifold U as a local L i e transformation group if the mapping F satisfies the conditions:
(1) xg is analytic in the coordinates of x and g; (2) xe = x; g, g‘ E G. (3) If xg E U then (xg)g’ = x(gg’), Here e is the identity element of G and X E U is designated by its coordinates x = (xl ,..., x,J. With the exception of the identity e, the elements of G have been printed in lightface type to distinguish them from elements of U .
1-3. LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
13
If x E U and g is in a sufficiently small neighborhood of e, conditions (2) and (3) yield the relation (xg)g-' = x. Thus, the map x ~ x isg
locally one-to-one for fixed g. Let exp at, a E L(G), be a 1-parameter group in G. If xo E U we call the curve x(t) = xo exp at the trajectory of xo under exp at. The function x ( t ) can be expanded in a Taylor series in t about the point t = 0: or
where (1.45)
Thus, the vector with components
Qi=
c ajPjf(x), n
i
=
1,..., m,
(1.46)
j=l
is tangent at x to the trajectory of exp at through X. If f ( x ) is a function analytic in a neighborhood of some point xoE U, we define analytic functions [(exp a t)fl(x ) for a E L(G) and suitably small values of [ t I by [(exp atlfl(x) = f(x exp a t ) .
( 1.47)
Definition The Lie derivative Laf of an analytic function f ( x ) is
By direct computation we obtain
or n
La
=
c m
ajPj,(X)-
+l i=l
a axi
(1.48)
The commutator [ L aLa] , of the Lie derivatives L a ,L, is defined by [ L a La] = L.Jp - L&a . 9
14
1. RCSUME OF LIE THEORY
Theorem 1.5 (Lie's Second Fundamental Theorem) The set of all Lie derivatives of a local Lie transformation group G forms a Lie algebra which is a homomorphic image of L(G).I n fact, L + a g = aLa
+
4
3
9
Lca.gl = [La *L,l
for all a, b E @, a,9 , EL(G ) . If L(G) is isomorphic to the algebra of Lie derivatives of a local transformation group G we say G acts effectively. Given x E U and a E L ( G ) ,let x ( t ) be the solution of the system of equations i = 1 , 2,...,m,
(1.49)
with the initial condition x(0) = xo. The function x ( t ) is uniquely determined by a and is defined for suitably small values of 1 t I. Theorem 1.6 (Lie's First Fundamental Theorem) solution of the equation d -x dt
=Lax,
The unique
x ( 0 ) = xo
is the trajectory x ( t ) = xoexp at. Consequently, a knowledge of the Lie derivatives L, determines the action of G on U . T h e following result, which is of basic importance for the approach to special function theory presented in this book, states that any Lie algebra of differential operators is the algebra of Lie derivatives of a local Lie transformation group. Theorem 1.7 (Converse of Lie's Second Fundamental Theorem) Let j = 1,2,...,n,
be a set of n linearly independent differential operators defined and analytic in an open set U C e(m. If there exist constants C:k such that
1-3. LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
15
the complex n-dimensional Lie algebra generated by the L, is the algebra of Lie derivatives of a local Lie transformation group G acting effectively on U. The action of G on xoE U is obtained by solving the equations d -x dt
=
(
x(0) = xo,
a j ~ x, j )
aj constant.
1=1
(The operators L, are said to be linearly independent on U if there exist no constants uj E @, not all zero, such that Ctf=, ujLjf = 0 for all analytic functions f on U.) I n this book we shall often be concerned with a variant of the last theorem. Let L j ,j = 1, 2, ..., n, be differential operators defined in an open set U C Cm+l and satisfying the hypotheses of Theorem 1.7. Suppose also,
a aXrn+l
+ 1,
i = 1 ,...,m
Pj,(x)= 0,
j = 1,...,n,
for all x E U . In other words,
a
[cI ,Lj
= 0.
T o emphasize the distinction between xm+l and the remaining components of x, we set xmtl = w and write x = (x‘, w )
where x’ = (xl,..., xm). According to Theorem 1.7, the Lj generate a Lie algebra which is the algebra of Lie derivatives of a local Lie group G acting on the open set U C gm+l.T h e action of G on U is given by integration of the equations d
-xi(t) dt dw
dt (2)
n
=
2 ajPji(x’), i=l
c n
=
j=1
ajpj
rn+l(x’),
i = 1,..., m, (1.50)
x(0) = xo.
Since the right-hand side of these equations is independent of w , the action of the 1-parameter group exp art on x takes the form x exp at = (x’ exp at, q(x’, exp at)
+w)
16
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
where q is a complex-valued analytic function of its arguments. T h e action of G on U is completely determined by the group elements exp at, so we have
xg
=
(x’g,dx’,g )
+ w),
g E G.
(1.51)
If xg E U , g’ E G, then (xg)g’ = x(gg’), which leads to the relations (x’g)g’= x’(gg’), or
dx’,gg’) = dx’,g) + q(x’g,g’),
4x’,gg’) = 4 X ‘ t 81 4x2,g’)
(1.52)
where v(x’,g) = Moreover, if g = e , then q(x’,e ) = 0, v(x’,e) = 1, for all x E U. Let LZw be the set of all functions f(x) on @+l, analytic in a neighborhood of some fixed point X O E U and such that f(x) = ewf’(x’),i.e., e-”f(x) is independent of w. Without loss of generality we can assume xo = 0 = (0,..., 0). Given g E G, define the mapping TB: LZw -+LZw as follows: TgfW =f(xg), f E a w * (1.53) Expression (1.53) is valid only for x in a sufficiently small neighborhood Moreover, for suitably restricted choices of g, g’ E G, x E U of 0 E @+l. and f E LZw , we have T”g‘f(x)= Tq(Tr‘f)(x). (1.54) Let LZ‘ be the set of all functions f’(x’) on @, analytic in some neighborhood of 0’ = (0,..., 0). There is a one-to-one mapping p of LZ‘ onto LZw given by f ’ E a‘. p : f’(x’)+ ewf‘(x‘), Since this mapping is invertible it is easy to see that the operators TQ on LZw induce operators T’g = p-1Tgp on GY with the following properties: (1) [T’”’l(X’) = +‘, g)f‘(x’g), (2) [T’‘f’](x’)= f ’ ( ~ ’ ) ,
(1.55)
’1 (x’) = [T’gl(T’”zf’)](x’), (3) [T’Q~gzf valid for all f‘ E a’, x‘ E @m, g, g, ,g, (1.55) make sense.
E
G such that both sides of Eqs.
Definition Let G be a local Lie transformation group acting on an 0 E U , and let LZ be the set of all complexopen neighborhood U of
cm,
1-3. LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
17
valued functions on U analytic in a neighborhood of 0. A (local) multiplier representation T.of G on 6Z with multiplier v, consists of a mapping P(g) of Gl onto 6Z defined for g E G, f E Gl by xE
[ T w f l ( x ) = 4x9 g)f(xg),
where
V(X, g)
u 9
is a complex-valued function analytic in x and g, such that
(1) v(x,e ) = 1, all X E U , (2) v(x,g1g2) = v(x, g,)v(xg, g2), 9
g1 gz g1g2 E G. 9
Property (2) is equivalent to the relation rW,g2)fl(x)
-
I ~ ( g , ) ( T ( g J11 f (x).
Thus, the mappings T’ given by Eqs. (1.55) define a multiplier representation of G. Furthermore, every multiplier representation of G arises in this way. T hat is, if T.is a multiplier representation of G on U C grn we can define an action of G as a transformation group on a neighborhood of @+I by ( x , w) -+ (xg,w ln[v(x, g)]) where x E U and w is a complex number. T h e mapping T’(g)induced by this action is just P(g). Let T.be a multiplier representation of G and let f E Gl. If 01 E L ( G ) then Tu(exp a t ) f E GZ for sufficiently small values of 1 t j. Definition T h e generalized Lie derivative D,f of an analytic function f ( x ) under the 1-parameter group exp at is the analytic function
(1.56)
For v = 1 the generalized Lie derivative becomes the ordinary Lie derivative. By direct computation from (1.56) we obtain
are defined by (1.45) and the analytic where the analytic functions Pi,(x) are defined by functions Pj(x)
I n analogy with Theorem 1.5 we have:
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
18
Theorem 1.8 T h e generalized Lie derivatives of a local Lie transformation group form a Lie algebra under the operations of addition of derivatives and Lie product [D, D,I 7
=
D,D,
-
D,D,
'
This algebra is a homomorphic image of L(G): D,,,
=
D,
+ D,
7
D,,,,
=
Da,
[D, Do], 3
=
aD,
-
Definition A Lie group G acts effectively in a local multiplier representation TY if L(G) is isomorphic to the algebra of generalized Lie derivatives. Making use of the relationship between local transformation groups acting on Cm+l and multiplier representations on Cmpresented above we can easily prove the following analogies of Theorems 1.6 and 1.7: Theorem 1.9 A local multiplier representation TY of G is completely determined by its generalized Lie derivatives. Theorem 1.10
Let
1 Pj,(x)ga + Pj(x), m
Dj(x)=
i = 1,..., n,
i=l
be a set of n linearly independent differential operators defined and analytic in an open set U C Cm. If there exist constants C,!k such that n
[Dj , Dk] = DjDk - DkDj =
CikD,,
1 <j,
k
1=1
< n,
then the complex linear combinations of the D j form a Lie algebra which is the algebra of generalized Lie derivatives of an effective local multiplier representation TY. T h e action of the group is obtained by integration of the equations
d
n
dt xi(t)=
C ajPji(x(t)),
j=1
~ ~ (= 0 )x i ;
i
=
1, 2,..., m, (1.58)
d dt
-v(xo,
n
exp at) = v(x0, exp a t )
where x ( t ) = xoexp cut, a EL(G).
1 ajPj(x(t)),
3=1
v(x0, e)
= I,
1-4. EXAMPLES OF LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
19
According to this theorem the action of the 1-parameter group exp at on f E a is given by [TY(exp at)f](xO)= v(xo,exp at)f(xO exp at)
(1.59)
where v and x ( t ) are the solutions of Eqs. (1.58). Since G is completely determined by the elements exp a , a EL(G), Eqs. (1.59) completely determine TY. Moreover, [T.(exp at)f](x)is an analytic function of t for I t 1 sufficiently small. By direct computation, dn dt
-[TTexP .t).fl(x)l
t=o
=
[D,nfl(X)
(1.60)
where D: = DUDU ..Be( n times). Expansion of [T.(exp at)f] (x) in a Taylor series proves Theorem 1.1 1 [TY(exp at)f](x) =
t" 1[Dzf](x). O0
n-1
Theorem 1.11 is another justification for the use of the exp notation. Let T " k be a multiplier representation of the local Lie transformation group Gk acting on an open neighborhood U , of Qrn for k = 1,2, respectively . Definition T h e multiplier representations T"1, T"2 are isomorphic if there is an analytic isomorphism p of G, onto G, and an analytic one-to-one coordinate transformation ~p of a neighborhood of 0 E U, onto a neighborhood of 0 E U , such that
'p(x1g1) = cp(xl>P.(gl), (2) v2(Cp(x1), p.(g1)>= v 1 b 1 g1)
(1)
7
for x1 E U, , g, E G, . Ordinarily we shall not distinguish between isomorphic multiplier representations.
1-4
Examples of Local Transformation Groups
I n this section the fundamental theorems on local transformation groups will be illustrated by means of examples. Furthermore, a brief indication of the relationship between each example and special function theory will be given. T h e next four chapters constitute a detailed and systematic study of the relationship between Lie groups and special functions which is indicated here.
20
1. RESUME OF LIE THEORY
Consider the differential operators J+, J-, 53
=
--
d u+z--, dz
J+
+
=~ U Z
2'-
J3
defined by
d
dz '
J-
==
d
--
dz '
(1.61)
where z is a complex variable taking values in some neighborhood U of 0 E @, and 2u is a nonnegative integer. These operators satisfy the commutation relations
[J3, J']
=
[J3, J-]
J+,
=
-J-,
[J+, J-I
=
2J3
which are identical with the commutation relations (1.19) for the generators of L[SL(2)]= sl(2). Thus, by Theorem 1.10 the operators J+, J-, J 3 generate the Lie algebra of generalized Lie derivatives of a local multiplier representation TY of SL(2).We will explicitly verify this and compute the multiplier V. According to (1.58) the action of the 1-parameter group exp T j 3 , T E @, is obtained by integration of the differential equations d
d7z=z,
d
dT v(zo, exp ~ -
3= --uv(zo, ~ )
exp T f s )
(1.62)
with initial conditions z(0) = zo, v(zo,e ) 3 I. T h e solution is easily seen to be Z ( T ) = zoeT, v(zo,exp Ty3)= cUT. (1.63) Thus, iff
E Ul
is analytic in some neighborhood of zo E U then [TY(exp T f 3 ) f ] ( Z o )
for
= e-u7f(zoe7)
(1.64)
1 T 1 sufficiently small. Similarly, we obtain
defined for
REMARK T o give a precise meaning to Eqs. ( .64) and (1.65) it would be necessary to state explicitly the values of T, b, c, zo and the functions f for which the equations are defined. However, these values are easily determined by inspection once the domain o ff is given and ordinarily we will not bother to write them down. Similar remarks hold for all the computations involving local transformation groups considered in this book.
1-4. EXAMPLES
OF LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
21
Equations (1.64) and (1.65) completely determine TY. T o show this we use (1.22) and compute the product
Thus, if
is in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the identity we can write g uniquely in the form g
=
exp b'$+ exp c'$-
where er'l2 = d-I, 6' = -b/d, c' f E GZ is then given by
=
exp 7'y3
(1.67)
-cd. T h e operator F(g) acting on
[ ~ ~ g =i [ Wm ~ P b ~ + ) m e CY-) x ~
WXP
7 ' 9 3 1 m )
(1.68)
+
+
and we have v ( z , g ) = (bz + d)211,zg = ( U Z c)/(bz d), defined for z and g in suitably small neighborhoods of 0 and e, respectively. I t is easy to verify directly that Eq. (1.69) defines a local multiplier representation of SL(2)and that the differential operators J+, J-, J3 are generalized Lie derivatives of T.. Now that we have constructed the multiplier representation (1.69) we will indicate its relation to special function theory. Let V'-(u)be the vector subspace of G! consisting of all complex linear combinations of
22
1. RESUME OF
LIE THEORY
the 2u + 1 functions h,(x) = 21, I = 0, 1,..., 2u. I t follows from (1.69) ) Tu(g)fEV ( u ) . Furthermore, for f~ Y'-(u) the rightthat i f f € V ( uthen hand side of (1.69) is defined for all g E SL(2),not just for g in a suitable neighborhood of e, and TY(g,g,)f = T(g,)[TY(g,)f] for all g, ,g2 E SL(2). T h e matrix elements Dzk(g)of P with respect to the basis functions h , are defined by
c Dz,(g) hz(z), 2U
[TY(g)hJ(z)
=
z=o
g 6 =(2),
k
=
0 , I,..., 2%
(1.70)
or, explicitly, (ax
+ c ) ' ( ~ z+ d)'"-'
221
=
C D&)z'
(1.71)
l=O
(z
where g = i). Since TY is a multiplier representation of SL(2) the matrix elements satisfy the addition theorems
Using the binomial theorem to expand the left-hand side of (1.71), we obtain the following expressions for the matrix elements D,,(g):
if
2u>k>l>O,
(1.73)
if 2 u > l > k > O .
Here, F is a hypergeometric polynomial, see (A.4). Thus, the matrix elements are well-known special functions and Eqs. (1.72) yield addition theorems for these functions. As a second example consider the differential operators Jf, J-, J 3 defined by (1.61) where now 2u E @ is not a nonnegative integer. I n exact analogy with the preceding example, these operators induce a multiplier representation TY of SL(2) defined by (1.69)'
where z and g are in suitably small neighborhoods of 0 and e, respectively. Since 2u is not a nonnegative integer, the multiplier v ( z , g ) =
1-4. EXAMPLES OF LOCAL TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
23
+
( b z d)2uis defined by its power series expansion in z about z = 0. This power series converges only if I bz/d 1 < 1. Furthermore, if f E GZ and z is in the domain off then
is in the domain o f f and 1 az/c 1 < 1, I bzld I < 1. There is now no finite-dimensional vector subspace of polynomials in z which is invariant under (1.69)', so we consider the action of TY on all of GZ. Since the elements of GZ are just those functions with convergent power series expansions about z = 0, the action of TY on GZ can be determined from I = 0, 1 ,2 ,... . Thus, a knowledge of TY on the basis functions h z ( z )= zz, we define the matrix elements B,,(g) with respect to the basis functions (1.74)
(1.75)
Since TY is a multiplier representation we have (1.76)
for g, ,g, in a sufficiently small neighborhood of e . T h e precise domain of validity of the addition theorems (1.76) will be determined in Chapter 5. T h e matrix elements can be computed by expanding the left-hand side of (1.75) as a power series in z and calculating the coefficient of zz. T h e result is
if k & Z > O ,
Bzk(g)
r
+
i
&d2u-'bZ-'T(2u - k 1) F -k, -2u r ( 2 u - I + 1)(1 - k ) ! if Z > k > O ,
+ I; I
-
k
+ -)
(1.77)
bc 1; ad
where is the gamma function and F is the hypergeometric function (see the appendix). This is an example of a multiplier representation of
24
1. RtSUME OF LIE THEORY
SL(2)that is purely local; it is defined only in a neighborhood of e, not on all of SL(2). T h e connection between addition theorems for special functions and matrix elements of local multiplier representations presented here has general validity. I n fact, we will show that the basic addition theorems for hypergeometric functions can be obtained from the study of multiplier representations of SL(2),the basic addition theorems for confluent hypergeometric functions follow from the study of multiplier representations of G(0, I), and addition theorems for Bessel functions can be obtained from multiplier representations of T,.
CHAPTER
2 Representations and Realizations of
Lie Algebras
I n Chapter 2 we establish a fundamental relationship between Lie groups and certain special functions: Special functions appear as basis vectors and matrix elements corresponding to local multiplier representations of Lie groups. T h e correspondence is sketched in Section 2-2, then illustrated by the familiar example of angular momentum operators and spherical harmonics. T h e 4-dimensional Lie algebras 9 ( a , b) are introduced in Section 2-5. Later, it will be shown that the representation theory of 9 ( a , b) corresponds to a study of special functions of hypergeometric type. As preliminary material toward the demonstration of this fact we classify the abstract irreducible representations of 9 ( a , b) in Section 2-6, and construct realizations of 9 ( a , 6) by means of generalized Lie derivatives in one and two complex variables in Sections 2-7 and 2-8.
2-1
Representations of Lie Algebras
I n this section the concept of a representation of a Lie algebra on an abstract vector space will be introduced. I t is assumed that the reader is familiar with the basic definitions and results of the theory of vector
26
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
spaces (Halmos [l], Dunford and Schwartz [l]). However, since most elementary textbooks on linear algebra are concerned primarily with finite-dimensional vector spaces it may be useful to review some of the fundamental definitions in a wide enough context to apply to infinitedimensional spaces. Infinite-dimensional abstract vector spaces will appear frequently in this book. Let V be a vector space over the field F. (Here, F will always be either the real numbers R,or the complex numbers, @.)We denote the additive identity of V by 0 and the additive identity of F by 0. A subset S of V is said to be linearly independent over F if for every finite subset v1 , w 2 ,..., w, of distinct elements of S and every sequence (a, , a, ,..., a,) of elements of F the equality C?=, u p i = 8 implies a, = a, = = a, = 0. A nonvoid linearly independent subset B is called a basis of V if it is maximal, i.e., if B is not a proper subset of some linearly independent set in V. It can be shown using Zorn's lemma that every vector space with at least two elements contains a basis (Dunford and Schwartz [l], Chapter 1). Furthermore, if B is a basis for V then any v E V can be written uniquely as a finite linear combination of elements of B: v = alwl
+ azwz + + unw, , *.*
a,
,...,a, E F ,
v1 ,..., vn E B.
T h e cardinality of a basis depends only on V and is called the dimension of V. If B contains m elements, V is rn-dimensional. If B contains an infinite number of elements, V is infinite-dimensional. (Similarly, if g is a Lie algebra over F a basis of 2'2 is a subset Y which is a basis of 59 considered as a vector space. The dimension of Y is the cardinality of a basis.) A linear operator on V is a mapping T : V -+ V such that
T h e product T,T, of two linear operators T , and T , on V is the linear operator defined by (T,T,)(v) = Tl(T,(v))for o E V. The sum T, T, is the linear operator defined by ( T , T,)(a) = T,(v) T2(w). If a E F and T is a linear operator we define the scalar multiple aT of T by (aT)(v)= aT(w) for all w E V. The set of all linear operators on V with the operations of product, sum, and scalar multiple forms an algebra. Moreover, if we define the commutator [ Tl , T,] of the linear operators T,, T , by [ T , , T,] = T,T, - T,T, , the operators on V together with the commutator [.,.I form a Lie algebra 9(V). Let Y be a Lie algebra over F.
+
+
+
2-2. REALIZAT1ONS OF REPRESENTATIONS p:
27
Definition A representation of 9 on V is a homomorphism 9 ---t 9( V). That is, p satisfies the conditions
(1)
p(a)~9(V)
(2) (3)
p(L.9 p(aa
PI)
=
+ bP)
for all a € 9,
b(4,P(P)19 = up(.)
+ b(P),
a, b EF, a,p E
9.
A subspace W of V is said to be invariant under p if p(a)w E W for all a E 9,w E W. A representation p of 9 on V is irreducible if there is no proper subspace W of V which is invariant under p. Two vector spaces V, V' over F are isomorphic if there exists a mapping p of V onto V' such that (1)
+
+
a2021 = alP(%) a2A4 for all a, , u2 E F, vl , v2 E V. (2) If p ( v) = 8' then v = 8. (3) For every v' E V' there exists a er E V such that p(v) = v'.
p(a1v1
Let p, p' be representations of 9 on V , V', respectively. p and p' are said to be isomorphic if there exists an isomorphism p of V and V' such that p(p(a)v) = p'(a)p(v) for all a E 9,v E V.
2-2
Realizations of Representations
Let G be a local Lie group with Lie algebra L(G) and suppose p is a representation of L(G) on the abstract vector space V. In analogy with the theory of local transformation groups presented in Chapter 1, it would seem natural to construct a mapping 6 of G into 9(V) as follows:
where a EL(G),v E V , and t E @. Unfortunately, the right-hand side of (2.1) may not be defined as an element of V since it involves an infinite
linear combination of vectors. Thus, expression (2.1) may be meaningless and the analogy between Lie algebras and local Lie groups breaks down. However, suppose p satisfies
CONDlTlON (A) V can be realized as a vector space whose elements are functions analytic in a neighborhood of some point zoE Crnand such that the operators ~ ( c YCY) ,E L ( G )are differential operators analytic at 2".
28
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
T o be more precise, let Ulzo be the set of all functions analytic in some neighborhood of zo(the germs of functions at zo, see Gunning and Rossi [l], Chapter 2). a,, can be given the structure of a complex vector space in the usual manner. Assume the existence of an isomorphism p of the abstract vector space V onto a subspace V of Ul,, . Then, the operators p’(0r) on V induced by the operators p(a), d ( G ) on V (p’(a)p(z,) = plp(a)z,],z, E V) obviously define a representation of L(G). Second, assume there exists a representation of L( G)by generalized Lie derivatives D, on Ule such that D, = p ( a ) on V for all (Y EL(G).If these two hypotheses are satisfied the vector space V can be considered as a subspace of GZzoand the operators p(a) can be identified with the generalized Lie derivatives D, . Under these circumstances Theorem 1.10 (or a slight modification of it; see Section 8-1) states that the representation p of L(G) induces a multiplier representation TY of G on a,, . I n particular, Eq. (2.1) is now well defined since the right-hand side of the equation is an infinite sum of analytic functions which converges to an element of Ole for I t I sufficiently small. (Here, the topology on GZzois the usual one of uniform convergence on compact sets of Qm.) According to Theorem 1-10, $(exp tor)z, = TY(exp ta)w for all E L ( G ) ,e, E V , and I t I sufficiently small. As noted above, V is invariant under the operators D, but not necessarily invariant under the operators ‘P(g), g E G.T o remedy this we extend V C Ule to a larger subspace 7 which is invariant under TY. Namely, we define P to be the intersection of all subspaces W of az0 which obey the conditions: W 3 Y and TY(g)w E W for all g E G, w E W such is the smallest subspace of aewhich that TY(g)w is defined. Clearly, contains V and which is invariant under TY. T h e elements of 4 are just the finite sums of elements of the form TY(g)o, where g E G,z, E V . Consequently, if condition (A) is satisfied a representation p of L(G) will induce a multiplier representation TY of G which leaves invariant. I n general, TY depends critically on the dimension m of Crnand on the choice of V . T o preserve the one-to-one correspondence between local Lie groups and Lie algebras, we need to find conditions which guarantee that the action of TY on P is in some way uniquely determined by p. If o1,..., ok ,... is a basis for V , the functions p(vl), p(oZ),..., p(‘uk),-.. form a basis for V . We say that the { p ( w k ) } form an analytic basis for 9 if every element u of Y can be expressed uniquely as a countable linear combination of the basis functions p(vk),uniformly convergent in some neighborhood of zo. Furthermore, it is required that the coefficients in this expansion be bounded linear functionals of the argument u (in the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets), i.e., if u =& ck(u)p(vk) then ck(u)+ 0 as u --t 0. (Y
(Y
2-2. REALIZATIONS OF REPRESENTATIONS
29
From Eq. (2.1) we obtain
~ E L ( G ) k,
=
1,2,...,
(2.2)
for I t 1 sufficiently small. If {p(ok)}is an analytic basis the right-hand side of (2.2) converges to an element of Q which is a (possibly infinite) linear combination of the functions p(vk). I n terms of this basis the matrix elements T,,(exp ta) are uniquely defined by m
TY(exp t a ) p ( v k ) =
k = I , 2,... .
1Tlk(expt a ) p ( v l ) ,
1=1
(2.3)
In fact, Eqs. (2.2) show that the matrix elements are uniquely determined by p for g in a sufficiently small neighborhood of e E G and are independent of the choice of Crnand V . Thus, restricting ourselves to vector spaces V of analytic functions which satisfy CONDlTlON (8) p(ol), p(w,) ,..., p(wk),..., is an analytic basis for 7,
we find that the matrix elements of the operators F(g) depend only on
p and the chosen basis of V; not on V . Let G, p, I/, {wk}, p, V be given such that conditions (A)and (B) are satisfied. Clearly, p(wl), p(w2),.,,,is an analytic basis for 7". Using this
analytic basis and (2.3) we can easily derive the following addition theorem for the matrix elements:
defined for g, ,g, in a suitably small neighborhood of e. T h e relation TY(g)p(wk) =
ct
Tlkk)
P(wl),
G,
?!
(2.3)'
1=1
can be regarded as a generating function for the matrix elements T I P ( gand ) the basis functions p ( v I ) . Finally, the equations D - P ( Z ) ~=) &(a)
nk),
a €L(G),
k
=
1,2,***,
(2.5)
can be interpreted as differential recursion relations for the functions p(wk).
30
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
The connection between these results and special function theory is now apparent. The matrix elements T&) are functions on the local group G and, if we make the proper choices for G and a basis of V, they will turn out to be familiar special functions. Moreover, the analytic functions p(qJ will often be expressible as special functions. I n this case Eqs. (2.4), (2.3)’, and (2.5) constitute addition theorems, generating functions, and recursion relations for the special functions T,,(g)and p(vk). I claim that a significant portion of special function theory is contained in these three sets of equations. Much of the remainder of this book will be devoted to the documentation of this claim by means of explicit computations. (Recall Section 1-4 where it was shown that the Jacobi polynomials appear as matrix elements of local multiplier representations of SL(2).) T o systematically study the special functions related to a given Lie algebra L(G) we could proceed as follows: (1) Classify “all” representations p of L(G). This is primarily an algcoraic problem. In order to obtain practical results it will ordinarily be necessary to study only those representations which possess certain convenient properties. In particular, we shall cla ;sify only the irreducible representations of L(G). (2) Classify “all” realizations of L(G)by generalized Lie derivatives. This is a problem in classical Lie theory which will be studied in Chapter 8. The basic difficulty here is how to decide when two realizations of L( G)by generalized Lie derivatives are “essentially” the same. (3) For each representation p of L(G) and each realization of L(G) by generalized Lie derivatives D, , find a realization 9 ‘ - of V such that conditions (A) and (B) are satisfied. (4) Choose a “suitable” basis in I‘ and compute the matrix elements T,,(g) and basis functions p(vk). For the low-dimensional Lie algebras considered in this book it will ordinarily be clear which basis in V should be chosen. The above description of a relation between Lie algebras and special functions is general and heuristic. T o show that this procedure leads to practical methods for uncovering the group structure of special functions we will henceforth be very specific. In particular, we will examine in detail the special functions associated with the Lie algebras L(SL(2)), L(G(0, l)), and L( T3).The special functions will turn out to be hypergeometric functions, confluent hypergeometric functions, and Bessel functions. These familiar functions will occur both as matrix elements and as basis vectors for irreducible representations of the above Lie algebras.
2-3. REPRESENTATIONS OF L(0J 2-3
31
Representations of L(0,)
Perhaps the best known example of the relation between Lie groups and special functions presented in Section 2-2 is the connection between the rotation group and spherical harmonics. Although this example is treated in most books on quantum mechanics, it may be instructive to examine it again to see how it fits into the general framework of the last section. It is a remarkable fact that essentially the same methods which are used to derive the fundamental properties of spherical harmonics from the representation theory of the rotation group, suffice to derive the fundamental properties of hypergeometric, confluent hypergeometric and Bessel functions. The rotation group 0, in 3-dimensional space is the group of real 3 x 3 matrices A such that A A L= I and det A = + I (Hamermesh [I]). Here A t is the transpose of A and I is the 3 x 3 identity matrix. 0, is a real 3-parameter Lie group. The real Lie algebra L(0,) has a , , y 3with commutation relations basis
x2
Let p be a finite-dimensional irreducible representation of L ( 0 3 ) on the complex vector space V and define the operators J1 , Jz , J3 on V by p($?jk) = J k , k = 1, 2, 3. These operators generate a Lie algebra which is a homomorphic image of L(0,). However, for many purposes it is more convenient to use the operators J+, J-, J3: J3
= iJ,,
J+ = -J,
+ iJ1,
J- = J,
+ iJ,
(i =
a) (2.7) .
The commutation relations become
[J3, J+l
=
J+,
[J3, J-I
=
-J-,
[J+, J-I
= 2J3
(2.8)
where now [A, B] = A B - BA. Note that (2.8) is formally identical to Eq. (1.19) for the commutation relations of the generators of the complex Lie algebra 4 2 ) . T o determine all finite-dimensional irreducible representations of L ( 0 , ) it is sufficient to classify (up to isomorphism) all nonzero complex vector spaces V and operators Jf, J-, J3 on V satisfying ( 2 4 , such that no proper subspace of V is invariant under J+, J-, J3. Let V be one such vector space and let h, E V be a nonzero eigenvector of J3 with eigenvalue q: J3h, = qh,.
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
32
+
T h e relation [J3, J+] h, = J+h, implies J3(J+h,) = (q 1) J+h, . Hence, either Jfh, = 0 or J+h, is an eigenvector of J3 with eigenvalue q 1. Similarly it is easy to show that either J-h, = 0 or J-h, is an eigenvector of J3 with eigenvalue q - 1. By repeating the above argument we find J3(J+)'ha
= (4
+ k)(J+)"ha
J3(J-)"g
x=
+
( 4 - k)(J-)kh,
for all positive integers k . Since V is finite-dimensional there must
exist an integer Y 3 0 satisfying (J+)'h, # 0 and (J+)'+'h, = 0. Set = f i where 1 = q Y , so that J"fr = r f i . By a similar argument there is an integer s 3 0 such that (J-)"fi # 0 and (J-)s+'fi= 0. We will show that the vectors f k , k = 1, 1 - 1,..., 1 - s, defined by fZpj= ( J-)ifi , j = 0, ..., s, form a basis for V . One way to demonstrate this is by means of the operator Cls0= J+JJ3J3 - J3 (the Casimir operator). As can easily be verified from the commutation relations (2.8), Cl,o commutes with J+, J-, and J3:
+
(J+)'h,
+
[Cis,
9
11'
=
+
J3J?fi
[Ci,o
J-I
=
[C,,o
9
J31
(2.9)
= 0.
Moreover, Ci.ofi
=
J'J-fi
= (I-J'
so Cl,ofz= Z(Z J- we have
- JYi
+ 2J3)fi + (12 - l ) f i
+ l ) f i , because
= J-J+fi
+ l(l +
1)fi
;
J+fz = 0. Since Cl,o commutes with
Cl,ofi--, = Ci,o(J-)'j~ = (J-1' Ci,ofi
+
10 + l)(I-)'fi
= l(1
+ 1)fl-j
for j = 1, 2 ,..., s. Thus, Cl,ofk = l(1 l)fk for k = 1, 1 - 1,..., 1 - S. On the other hand we can evaluate Cl,ofi-, directly: Ci.ofi--s
= (J'J-
+ J3J3 - J'))i-s
= ( I - s)(l - s -
1)fi-8
9
since J-fi-, = 0. Comparison of these two results yields 1(1+ 1) = (1 - s)(I - s - 1) or s = 21. Since s is a nonnegative integer, 1 is either an integer or half an integer. Another direct computation proves C1,ofi-j
=
J+(J-)"'fi
=
J+fi-j-1
+
J3J3fi-j
+ (1 - j ) ( l
- J"fi-9
-j -
+
1)fi-J
for j = 1 , 2,..., s - 1 . From Cl,of i V j = Z(l l)fl-j we obtain 1) fk+l for k = 1 - 1, 1 - 2 ,..., -1. These J+fk = ( I - k)(I k results show that the (21 1)-dimensional subspace of V generated by the vectors f k , k = 1, 1 - 1,..., -1, is invariant under J+, J-, and J3.
+ +
+
2-4. THE ANGULAR MOMENTUM OPERATORS
33
Moreover, this subspace must coincide with V itself because V is irreducible under p. We know how the operators J+, J-, J3 act on the basis vectors fk of V , so p is completely determined: J”fk
= kfK 9
J-fk
= fk-i
J + ~ E= ( I
,
+
K
=
-
+k+
l)fk+i
9
(2.10)
I, I - 1,..., -I.
I(I l ) f k , (On the right-hand sides of Eqs. (2.10) we make the convention:fk = 0 if k is not in the spectrum of J3.) Conversely, for any nonnegative integer 21 it is easy to verify that the operators J+, J-, J3 on V defined by (2.10) satisfy the commutation relations (2.8) and thus determine an irreducible representation D(21) of 0,. The irreducible representation D(21) is uniquely determined by and uniquely determines the spectrum of the operator J3 in this representation, i.e., the eigenvalues {+l, 1 - 1,..., -I>. However, the basis vectors {fk} are not uniquely determined by D(21). In particular, if {Yk}, k = 1,..., -1, is a set of nonzero complex constants the vectorsf; = r k f k will also form a basis of V consisting of eigenvectors of J3. A most convenient basis for V is obtained by choosing the constants Yk such that yk+Jyk = [(I k 1)(1 k = 1 - 1, 1 - 2,..., -1. For the new basis vectors {f:}, relations (2.10) become C,,,f,
=
+ +
JY; J+fk
= kf;,
=[(l-
kMI+
J-j;
=
[(E
+ k)(I- k + l)]l’Yk-l,
+ l)ll’Y;+l,
C1,,fk
= I(/+
1)f;
-
(2.11)
Relations (2.11) are especially convenient for the study of unitary representations of 0, (see Section 5-16). From the above discussion we can conclude that the only finitedimensional irreducible representations of L( 0,) are the representations 0(21), 21 a nonnegative integer. The representation space corresponding to D(21) has dimension 21 1 and contains a basis fi , fi-l ,...,fllsuch that the action of J+, J-, J3 on the basis is given by (2.11).
+
2-4 The Angular Momentum Operators In the study of the quantum theory of angular momentum the differential operators
a ax,
J, = x , - - x
-,a
ax,
J, = XZ
a ax, a - XIa JZ=X~--X
ax1
8x2
a
- 7
ax,
(2.12)
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
34
occur, where x, , x, ,x, are real Cartesian coordinates (Landau and Lifshitz El], Chapter 4). These operators satisfy the commutation relations (2.6) and thus generate a Lie algebra isomorphic to L (0 ,). I n terms of the spherical coordinates I, 0, p' defined by x1 = r cos 8 cos p,
I>o,
x3 = r sin 0,
x p = T cos 3l sin p,
o
~
e
O~ < ~~ P ,, ~ ~ ,
the operators J+, J-, J3 take the form
2) a(P
J3=-i-.
a
av
'
(2.13)
T o relate the above results to special function theory we look for a realization of the representation D(21) such that the basis space Y is a space of analytic functions of the real variables 8, cp and the operators J+, J-, J3 are given by (2.13). Thus, we try to find the functions YF(0, p') such that
+ k)(l - k + l)]l/'Yf-', J+YL = [(I - k ) ( l + K + l)]1/2Yy1, C,,,Yf = 1(1 + l)Yf, J'Yf
= kYf
,
J-Yk
= [(I
(2.14)
1
k From
J3 =
--i
a/+
= 1,l - 1,..., -1.
there follows the relation
so Yf can be written in the form Yf(0, cp) = Pf(0)e"r. The problem of finding functions Y: satisfying (2.12) thus reduces to the problem of determining the functions P:. Furthermore, the requirement J+Yt = 0 leads to the differential equation
dp: - 1 cot e P; = 0 dd
with solution Pt(0) = cLsin' 0
= c,(l - cos2
e)z/z
where c, is an arbitrary nonzero constant. The functions Pfcan now be defined recursively from Pi by the condition
2-4. THE ANGULAR MOMENTUM OPERATORS
35
By induction, we obtain the explicit expression
k The requirement J-Y;'
= 1,l - 1,..., -1.
(2.15)
= 0 leads to the condition
This condition is satisfied only if 1 is an integer; if 1 is not an integer the constructions fails. I n case 1 is an integer the functions f; = Y f ,k = 1 , l - 1,..., -1, form a basis for the representation D(21) of L(0,). T o see this, note that we have mimicked the abstract construction of the representation D(21) given in Section 2-3. Thus, we have found a function f; = Y : such that J+fi = 0 and have determined the functions fi defined by
f; = Yf =
[(21)!(1 (+I k)!k ) ! l -
k
(J-)"'Y;,
= 1, 1 -
1,..., -1.
Since J-Yi' = J-fLr = 0, the argument in the previous section proves that the basis functions satisfy Eqs. (2.1 1). That is,
+
+ + +
d K)(I - K dB d - Pf - k cot 0 Pf = [(I - k)(l k dB
- -P; - K cot e P; = [(I
k
=
1)11/2 ~ f - 1
1)]1/2
Pf+1
(2.16)
1, 1 - 1 ,..., -1,
where the last equation is obtained by writing Cl,of; = 1(1+ I ) f; in terms of the differential operators (2.13). The arbitrary constant c I in Eq. (2.15) is usually fixed by the requirement
,:"1: 1 Y:(O,v)i2
sin 0 d0 d v = 1.
Evaluating this integral we find
where the phase factor (- 1)' is introduced to conform to convention.
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
36
T h e functions Y:(O,p’) = P;(O)& are known as spherical harmonics and Eqs. (2.16) give fundamental recursion relations and a differential equation for these functions (ErdClyi et al. [l], Vol. 11). Thus, if I is a nonnegative integer the spherical harmonics Y : form a basis for the representation D(21). Although we have failed to find a realization of those representations for which 1 is not an integer, in Section 5-14 we will find such realizations by choosing homomorphisms of L(0,) by generalized Lie derivatives different from (2.12). The representations of L(0,) realized here can be extended to local multiplier representations of 0, . T h e matrix elements can be computed and the results yield generating functions and addition theorems for the spherical harmonics. These results are well known (Gel’fand et al. [ 13) and will be included in Section 5-16. T h e methods used to relate spherical harmonics to representations of L(0,) are applicable to a wide variety of special functions. I n the next section a family of Lie algebras 9 ( a , b) will be introduced and the irreducible representations of these Lie algebras will be classified, subject to suitable restrictions. We will find realizations of the irreducible representations in terms of generalized Lie derivatives acting on spaces of analytic functions. For each such realization there will exist a natural basis of special functions. T h e special functions so obtained are the hypergeometric, confluent hypergeometric, and Bessel functions. This relation between Lie algebras and special functions provides insight into special function theory.
2-5
The Lie Algebras 9(0,6)
For any pair of complex numbers (a,b) define the 4-dimensional complex Lie algebra 9 ( a , b) with basis $+, $-, $,, 8 by
[$+, 9-1=
- b&,
[f3,
$+I
=
$+,
[f3,
9-1= -$-
(2.17)
[ f +81 , = [8-, 61 = [ f 3 , 81 = 8, is the commutator bracket and 0 is the additive identity
where [.,.I element. (It is easy to verify that relations (2.17) do in fact define a Lie algebra.) For special choices of the parameters a, b, %’(a,b) essentially coincides with one of the Lie algebras introduced in Section 1-2. I n particular we have the following isomorphisms: cg( 1,O)
4 2 ) 0(a),
g(0, 1)
L[G(O, I)],
9(0,0)
L(T3) 0(8)
where (a) is the 1-dimensional Lie algebra generated by 8.Recall that a subset 9’of a Lie algebra 29 is a subalgebra of 9 if ’3” is itself a Lie
2-5. THE LIE ALGEBRAS
"(0,
b)
37
algebra under the scalar multiplication, addition, and commutator bracket of 8.If 8 is a Lie algebra and 8, , g2are subalgebras of 9,then 8 is the direct sum of 8, and 8,,8 = 8,@ 8, , if considered as a vector space 8 is the direct sum of its subspaces 8,, g 2 ,and further, [a1, a2] = 0 for all a1 E gl , a, E 8,. Lemma 2.1
I
s ( a , b)
9(1,0) "(0, 1) s(0,O)
if a # 0, if a = 0, b # 0, if a = b = 0.
PROOF If a # 0, set $'+ = a-l$+, 3'- = a--l$-, f f 3 = - (ba-,/2) 8,8' = d. I n terms of the primed basis elements the commutation relations for %'(a,b) given by (2.17) become identical with those for 8(1,0). If a = 0, b # 0, set 8' = bd. I n terms of the basis f + , $-, f 3 , &", the isomorphism between 8 ( a , b) and 9(0, 1) is evident. This lemma shows that there are only three distinct Lie algebras of the form 8 ( a , b), up to isomorphism. However, it is often useful to consider the entire family { 8 ( a , b), a, b E @}of such Lie algebras because Eqs. (2.17) determine relationships between the nonisomorphic algebras %'(1, 0), 8(0, l), and 8(0,0). To spell out these relationships we introduce the notion of contraction of Lie algebras. Let 8 be an n-dimensional complex Lie algebra with basis {a,}, i = l,,.,, n. T h e structure constants Cfj of 8 relative to this basis are given by $3
[ai
,aj] =
n
1 Cfja, ,
i, j
= 1
,..., n.
k-1
If P = (P:)is a nonsingular n x n complex matrix we can define a new basis {a;}for 8 by a;= Pfa,, i = 1,..., n. I n terms of the new basis the structure constants become
x:=l
C::
P4P,hC;A(P-1):,
=
i,j , k
= 1,..., n.
l.A.r=l
We now introduce a one-parameter family P(t) of nonsingular matrices defined for all values of t > 0 in such a way that the matrix elements P$t) are continuous in t. Suppose this family of matrices has the property that the limits n
38
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
exist. It is easy to show that the {C$) are the structure constants of an n-dimensional Lie algebra (Saletan [l], Sharp [l]). If limi+,, P ( t ) = P where Po is a nonsingular matrix then the constants C:j” are structure constants for 9 relative to the basis
However, if limi-,o P ( t ) is a singular matrix or if the limit does not exist, the constants C:: may be structure constants for an n-dimensional Lie algebra 9’which is not isomorphic to 9.I n such a case we say that 9‘is a contraction of 99 (Wigner and Inonu [I], Saletan [I], Sharp [l]). According to Lemma 2.1 we can always find a basis for the Lie algebra 9 ( 1 , 0 ) in the form (2.17) where u # 0 and b is arbitrary. If u +0 in (2.17) we get in the limit either 9(0,1) or 9(0,0)depending on whether or not b = 0. This shows that 8(0,1) and S(0,O) are contractions of 9(1, 0). Similarly, 99(0,0) is a contraction of 9(0,1). This relationship between the Lie algebras S(a, b) will turn out to be of fundamental importance in special function theory. 2-6
Representations of %(a, b)
Let p be a representation of 9 ( u , b) on the complex vector space V and set
These linear operators obey the commutation relations
[J+, J-1
= 2a2J3- bE,
[J+, E]
=
[J3, J+]
[J-, El
=
J+,
= [J3, E] =
[J3, J-]
=
-J-,
(2.18)
0,
where now [ A , B] = AB - B A for linear operators A and B on V. Define the spectrum S of J 3 to be the set of eigenvalues of J3. T h e multiplicityof the eigenvalue X E S is the dimension of the eigenspace VA, V A= {W
E
V : J3v = Av}.
I n analogy with the example presented in Section 2-3 we will analyze the irreducible representations of 9 ( u , b) and for each such representa-
2-6. REPRESENTATIONS OF S(O,b)
39
tion find a basis for V consisting of eigenvectors of J3. T o be precise, we will classify all representations p of S(a, b) satisfying the conditions: (i) p is irreducible (ii) Each eigenvalue of J3 has multiplicity equal to one. There is a countable basis for V consisting of eigenvectors of J3.
(2.19)
These conditions are satisfied by the representations of L( 0,) classified in Section 2-3. Moreover, they enable us to construct representations of S(a, b) by mimicking the construction of representations of L(0,). T h e basic justification for the requirements (2.19) is that they quickly lead to connections between S ( u , b) and certain special functions. This claim will be thoroughly documented in the chapters to follow. Also, j 3 and 8 generate a Cartan subalgebra of S(a, b) (Jacobson [l]), so in analogy with the theory of finite-dimensional representations of semisimple Lie algebras it is natural to try to find basis vectors for V which are simultaneous eigenvectors of the operators corresponding to the elements of this Cartan subalgebra. (We will show that if p satisfies (2.19) then E = p(d) is a multiple of the identity operator and every non-zero vector in V is an eigenvector of E.) Condition (ii) can be written in forms which are apparently much weaker, though actually equivalent. In particular we could replace (ii) by (ii)'
J3
has an eigenvalue of finite multiplicity.
I t is not difficult to show that conditions (i) and (ii)' imply (ii). The necessary ingredients for the proof will be developed in the process of classifying the representations satisfying (i) and (ii), but the details will be left to the reader. We use condition (ii) for the sake of convenience. T o classify the representations of $(a, b) for arbitrary a, b E fZ' it is enough to consider the three cases: 9(1,0), Y(0, l), S(0,O). However, for the time being it will be convenient to treat these three cases simultaneously by studying $(a, b) without being specific as to the values of a and b. We will consider, therefore, a representation p of g ( a , b) on the complex vector space V such that (2.19) is satisfied. Our objective will be the enumeration of all possibilities for p. T o carry out this enumeration the following remarks will be helpful:
(A) Define the operator Ca,b on V by Ca,b = J+J-
+ a2J3J3- u2J3 - bJ3E.
(2.20)
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
40
It is easy to check that a E S(a, b). Thus, [ca,b
J’]
ca,bcommutes
== [ C a , b
, J-I
=
LCa,b
t
with every operator p(cy),
J31 = I C a , b EI t
= 0.
We will show that c o , b = hJ where I is the identity operator and A is a constant depending on p. ( B ) If S is the spectrum of J3, condition (ii) guarantees that S is countable and that there exists a basis for V consisting of vectors f m , J”f, = mf, , defined for every m E S . Suppose q E S . Then the equation [J3, J+]f, = J+f, leads to the result J3(J+f,) = ( q 1) J+fQ ; so either J+fQ = (,+,f,+l where c,+, is a nonzero constant and q 1 E S, or J+fQ = 0. Similarly, the equation [J3, J-If, = - J-f, implies either J-f, = qqfq-, where 7, is a nonzero constant and q - 1 E S , or J-f, = 0. T h e equation [E, J3] f , = 0 implies Ef, = p, f , for some constant pQ and [C,,b, J3] f, = 0 implies C,,,f, = A, f , for some constant A, . (C) Since p is irreducible the results of ( B ) show that the spectrum S must be connected, i.e., if q E S then S is of the form
+
S
=
+
+ n: n an integer such that nl < n < n2}
{q
where n, and n2 are integers. We do not exclude the possibilities n1 = - 00 or n2 = 00. In addition, if m, m 1 E S then gm+, , 7m+l # 0, since otherwise the irreducibility of p would be violated. 1 E S. Then the equation [E, J+]fm = 0 leads ( D ) Suppose m, m to (m+l(pm+l - pm) = 0, which implies p m = p,+l . Thus, pn, = p = constant for all m E S and E = pI is a multiple of the identity operator on V . A similar argument proves A, = A for all m E S so that Ca,b = AI. T h e equation ca,b ftn = Af, leads to the relations
+
+
+
+
for all m E S ,
5m7m u2m2 - u2m - 6mp = h
obtained from the definition (2.20)of ca,b, (If m - 1 $ S then 7, These relations can be rewritten in the form tmqm= h - u2m(m - 1)
Moreover, since [J+, J-] Ca,b
=
=
J-Jf
bpm.
=
0.)
(2.21)
2a2J3- bE the operator ca,bis also given by
+
dJ3J3
+ a2J3
-
6J3E- bE
From this expression we obtain the relations (2.22)
2-6. REPRESENTATIONS OF q ( a , b)
41
+
defined for all m E S, where [,n+, = 0 if m 1 6 S. Thus, Eq. (2.21) is valid for all m such that m E S or m - 1 E S. ( E ) If { y m , m E S } is a set of nonzero constants, we can introduce a new basis {fk} for V by means of the definition f,t,, = y m f m , all m E S. I n terms of the new basis: , ,
J-fk
= rlmfm--l
(2.23)
, Ym-1 tm = -t m , 7 ; Ym
Ym
= -"lm. Ym-1
+
(We assume f m + l = 0 if m 1 4 S and q m = 0 if m - 1 4 S.) Again the constants & , vi, must satisfy the condition
6'm 7'm
= X - a*m(m -
I)
+ bpm.
It follows from these considerations that for all m E S such that m - 1 E S we can choose the nonzero constants qm arbitrarily and define the constants tmby (2.21). (If m - 1 $ S then q, = 0 and tmis not defined.) We can always find a basis { fn, } of V such that q,,, , tmsatisfy (2.23) (without the primes). ( F ) T h e representation p of %(a, b) is uniquely determined by the constants A, p and the spectrum S of J3. The nonzero constants f , , 77, are not unique and may be chosen arbitrarily, subject only to conditions (2.21). This is as far as we can go without making any assumptions as to the values of a and b. At this point we use the fact that we need consider only the Lie algebras 9(1,0), 9(0,l), and 9(0,0). Theorem 2.1 Every representation of 9 ( 0 , 0 ) which satisfies (2.19) m,) and for which J+J- f 0 on V is isomorphic to a representation P(w, defined for p, w , m, E (Z' such that w # 0 and 0 Re m, < 1. S = {m, n: n an integer}. For each representation QP(w, m,) there is a basis for V consisting of vectors f , , m E S, such that
<
+
J Y m = mfm J+fm
=
9
ufm+l,
Co.ofm
E f m = Pfm J-fm
=
= (J+J-)fm =
The representations P(u,m,) and Qfi(
-w,
i
Wfm-1,
WYm
-
m,) are isomorphic.
(2.24)
42
2. REPRESENTATIONS
OF LIE ALGEBRAS
PROOF Set a = b = 0 in Eq. (2.22). If p is a representation of 9(0,0) satisfying (2.19) and such that J+J- + 0 on V, we have tmqm= X # 0 for all m such that m E S or m - 1 E S. Thus, there exists no element m, in S for which J+fm, = 0 for a nonzero fml E Vml and no element mp such that J-f,,,, = 0 for a nonzero fm, E Vma. If m, E S then S must be of the form {m, n: n an integer}. Without loss of generality we can assume m, is the element of S with smallest positive real part, i.e., 0 < Re m, < 1. Since tmqm= X # 0 we can also assume that 5m = qm = w for all m E S. Then X = w2 and w is determined only up to sign. This proves that every representation p satisfying the hypotheses of the theorem can be cast into the form (2.24). Conversely, it is easy to show that the representations Qp(w, m,) satisfy the hypotheses of the theorem. Q.E.D. The irreducible representations of 9 ( 0 , 0 ) for which J+J- = 0 are easily seen to be 1-dimensional. They are of little interest for our purposes so we will not bother to classify them.
+
Theorem 2.2 Every representation of 9(0, 1) satisfying (2.19) and for which E & 0 is isomorphic to a representation in the following list:
(i) T h e representations R(w, m, , p ) defined for all w , m, , p E C? such that p # 0, 0 Re m, < 1, and w + m, is not an integer. S = (m, n: n an integer). (ii) T h e representations tw,rdefined for all w , p E f2 such that p # 0. S = {-w n: n a nonnegative integer}.
<
+ +
For each of the cases (i) and (ii) there is a basis of V consisting of vectors fm defined for each m E S such that J Y m = mfm
= t+frn+lY
J'fm
=
Co.1fm
= pfm
Efm
9
= (m
J-fm
(J+J- - EJ3) f m
+
9
w)fm-19
= pwfm
(2.25)
-
(On the right-hand side of these equations we assumef, = 0 if m 6 S.) (iii) The representations Jw,r defined for all w , p E f2 such that p # 0. S = {-w - 1 - n: n a nonnegative integer}. For each of the representations there is a basis of V consisting of vectors f,,, defined for each m E S such that =
JYm J+fm
=
-(m
C0,lfm
mfm >
Efm
=
+w +
l)fm+l
9
(J+J-
- EJ')
fm
=
-pfm
9
J-fm
=
-pwfm.
pfm-1,
(2.26)
2-6. REPRESENTATIONS OF Y(o, b)
43
PROOF Let p be a representation of 9(0, 1) satisfying the hypotheses of the theorem and let S be the spectrum of p. Then Eq. (2.21) becomes t,r), = p(w m) for all m such that m E S or m - 1 E S. (We have set a = 0, b = 1, and h = pw in (2.21).) Let m, E S and suppose o + m, is not an integer. Then, S = {m, n: n an integer}. Without loss of generality m, can be taken to be the element of S with smallest positive real part, 0 Re m, < 1. According to the remarks in (E) there exists a basis for V such that 5 , = p, r), = w m for ail m E S. Thus, p is isomorphic to the representation R(w, m, , p ) listed in (i). If there is an element ml in S such that w m1is a nonnegative integer, the equation &,,r), = p(w m) implies - w E S and there exists a nonzero vector f - u E V such that J”f-w = -wf-,,, and J-f-u = 0. I n this case S = {-w n: n a nonnegative integer). There exists a basis of V such that , 5 = p, vrn= w m for all m E S. Thus p is isomorphic to the representation tu,rlisted in (ii). We say that this representation is bounded below. If there is an element m2 in S such that w m 2 is a negative integer we find - w - 1 €43 and - w $ S. Thus, S = { - w - 1 - n: n a nonnegative integer). There exists a basis of V such that 5 , = w m, 7 , = p for all m E S. In this case p is isomorphic to the representation JW,& listed in (iii). This representation is bounded above. Conversely, it is easy to verify that the representations (i)-(iii) actually satisfy conditions (2.19). Q.E.D. The irreducible representations of 9(0, 1) for which E = 0 can be considered as representations of 3T3 ; hence they are just the representations QO(w, m,) classified in Theorem 2.1.
+
+
<
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Theorem 2.3 Every representation p of 9(1,0) satisfying conditions (2.19) is isomorphic to a representation in the following list:
(i) The representations D ( u , m,) defined for all complex p, u, m, such that m, u, m, - u are not integers and 0 Re m, < 1. S = {m, n: n an integer}. D ( u , m,) and D ( - u - 1, m,) are isomorphic.
+
+
<
(ii) The representations T;, p, u E C?, where 2u is not a nonnegative integer. S = {--u n: n a nonnegative integer}.
+
(iii) The representations 4; , p, u E C,where 2u is not a nonnegative integer. S = {u - n: n a nonnegative integer}. (iv) T h e representations Dr(2u) where 2u is a nonnegative integer. (24, u - 1,.“, -24 1, -u}.
s=
+
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
44
For each of these representations there is a basis of V consisting of vectors f, , defined for each m E S such that JYm
C,,,fm
= mfm
=
J-fm
=
(J'-
-(m
m f ' J
>
+ + J3J3
=
(m - u ) f m + l , Efm == /+fm
uIfm-19 - J3)fm
(2.27)
9
+ 1)fm
=~ ( u
*
(We make the convention on the right-hand side of Eqs. (2.27) that = 0 if m I$ S.)
fm
PROOF Let p be a representation of 9(1,0) satisfying the hypotheses of the theorem. From (2.21) we obtain the equations t,r), = u(u + 1) - m(m - 1) = - ( m u)(m - u - 1) valid for all m such 1). Suppose there that m E S or m - 1 E S. Here, we have set h = u(u is an element m, in S such that neither m, u nor m, - u is an integer. I n this case the product t,~,can never be zero for any element m or m - 1 in S. Thus, S = {m, + n: n an integer}. Without loss of generality we can assume that m, is the element in S with smallest nonnegative real part: 0 Re m, < 1. According to remark (E) there exists a basis of V such that 5, = m - u - 1, r), .= - m - u. Thus, p is isomorphic D ( - u - 1, m,) to the representation B ( u , m,) listed in (i). D ( u , m,) since both u = u, and u = -u, - 1 lead to the same value of A. If the spectrum of p takes the form S = {ml n, n a nonnegative integer}, the formula tmvm = h - m(m - I), m E S , implies h = ml(ml - l).Settingm, = -uweobtainh = u(u 1)andS = {-u n: n a nonnegative integer}. As before we can find a basis of V such that 4, = m - u - 1, qnl = -m - u . Here, p is isomorphic to the representation 1;. T h e 1: is bounded below. If the spectrum of p takes the form S = {m, - n: n a nonnegative integer}, the equations (,,r), = h - m(m - 1) for m E S or m - 1 E S, imply X = (m, I)m,, i.e., t,,+l = 0. Setting m2 = u we have h = u(u 1) and S = {u - n: n a nonnegative integer}. Choosing tnL= m - u - 1, T ) , ~= -m - u we see that p is isomorphic to 1:
+
+
+
<
+ +
+
+
+
(bounded above).
+
If S contains finite elements m3, mq such that S = {m3, m3 1,..., m3 k ,..., m4} the equations .f,,,r),), = X - m(m 1) imply h = m3(m3 - 1) = (m4 l)m4 (since = qn,, = 0). Set mq = u and m 3 = u - n where n is a nonnegative integer. Thus, u(u 1) = ( u - n)(u - n - I). T h e only possible solution of this equation is n = 224. We conclude that S = { - u , - u + 1,..., + u} and p is isomorphic to the representation D(2u). Since the possibilities for S have been exhausted, the theorem lists all representations p satisfying (2.19). Q.E.D.
+
+
+
+
2-7. REALIZATIONS OF %(a, b) IN TWO VARIABLES
2-7
Realizations of
"(0,
45
b) in Two Variables
I n accordance with our general program we will try to find realizations of the irreducible representations p of " ( a , b) listed in Section 2-6, such that V becomes a vector space of analytic functions and the operators p(a), a E " ( a , b), form a Lie algebra of analytic differential operators acting on V . As a first step we will determine some possible candidates P(4-
Suppose, first, that the p(a) are differentia! operators acting on a space of analytic functions of two complex variables, x and y . For the moment we will not be concerned with the precise domains of the functions in this space. Define the differential operators J+, J-, J3, E by
AB+)= J+,
P(B-)= J-,
Since p is a representation of usual commutation relations [J+, J-]
= 2a2J3- bE,
p(f3> =
J3,
~ ( 6=) E.
s(a,b) these operators must satisfy the
[J3, J*]
=
& J*,
[J*, El
=
[J3, El
= 0.
(2.28)
T h e number of possible solutions of Eqs. (2.28) is tremendous. To obtain useful results it is convenient to make more restrictive assumptions as to the form of the operators p(0r). Thus, we assume that these operators take the form
a
(2.29)
J3=37,
where p is a complex constant and k, j are functions of x to be determined. T h e operators (2.29) are natural generalizations of the angular momentum operators (2.13) related to 0, . However, we will not give a detailed justification for this choice of differential operators now. In Chapter 8 a theory of generalized Lie derivatives will be developed which will enable us to classify all solutions of (2.28) by differential operators in two variables. It will follow from the classification that nothing of importance for special function theory is lost through the restrictions
(2.29).
T h e operators (2.29) automatically satisfy all of the commutation relations (2.28) except [J+, J-] = 2a2J3- bE. An easy computation shows that this last relation will be satisfied provided k a n d j are solutions of the differential equations dk (x) dx
+ k(x)2 = -a2,
dx
(x)
+ k(x)j(X) = - bP 2 '
(2.30)
2. REPRESENTATIONS
46
OF LIE ALGEBRAS
Thus, to find all operators of the form (2.29) it is sufficient to find all solutions of Eqs. (2.30). 8(1,0)
If a = 1, b = 0, Eqs. (2.30) have the solutions type A
or type B
j(x)
k ( x ) = i,
=
p-aZ
where p , q are complex constants and i = d q .T h e type designation is based on the classification of factorization types due to Infeld and Hull [l]. 8 ( 0 , 1)
If a = 0,b k(x)
=
1, the solutions are type C'
1 x+p'
j ( x ) = - tL(x
=-
+P)
4
4 +
x+p
or type D'
P
k ( x ) = 0,
j(x) = -2
+q
where p and q are complex constants. Q(0,O)
If
a =
b = 0, the solutions are type C" 1 K(x) = x
or type D"
+p'
k ( x ) = 0,
4 =x+p
j(x) =q
where p and q are complex constants. Suppose we are able to realize an irreducible representation p of S ( a , 6 ) classified in Section 2-6 in such a way that the operators p ( m ) are
differential operators of one of the types listed above and the basis space V is a space of analytic functions of x and y . T h e basis functionsf,(x, y ) , m E S, satisfy the equations
a
J?fm(X,.Y) == --fm(x,
aY
Y ) = m-frn(x, Y ) .
Thus, f m ( x ,y ) = gnl(x)emg for all m E S , where g,(x) is an analytic function of x. Since p is irreducible, we have C 0 . b fm
= hfm
m E S,
(2.31)
2-7. REALIZATIONS OF %(a,b) IN TWO VARIABLES
47
where the constant X is uniquely determined by p. However, in terms of our realization Cm,*is a second order partial differential operator and the relations (2.31) are a system of second order partial differential equations for the basis functionsf,(x, y). Sincef,,(x, y ) = g,(x)emv the dependence on y can be factored out and the relations simplify to a system of second order ordinary differential equations for the functions g,(x). The g,(x) will turn out to be special functions and the action of p will yield recursion relations, generating functions and addition theorems for these functions. T o determine the possible functions g,(x) which can arise in this way we recall Ca.b = J'J+ u2J3J3- u2J3- bJ3E and evaluate (2.31) for each of the operator types. The following differential equations are obtained for g,(x). For type A operators Eq. (2.31) becomes
S(l,O)
According to Theorem 2.3, X
= u(u
+ 1). One solution of this equation is
+ w)-"F(m - u, -q
grn(x)= w(m-Q)/2(1
+
- u; m - q
+ 1; - w )
where w = tan2[(x p)/2]. If m - q is not a positive integer there is a linearly independent solution of the form g,(x)
+ w)-"F(q - u, -m
= w'q-m)-/2(1
- u; q - m
+ 1; -w).
These results show the connection between type A operator realizations of 9(1,O) and the hypergeometric functions. For type B operators we obtain -e-iz
d dx
. -gm( d dx
]
x) t [ -q 2e-2iz
+ 2mqe-'"]
g,(X)
+ 1) grn(x)
=~ ( u
where u(u + 1) = A. If 2u is not an integer this equation has the linearly independent solutions g,(x)
=
(24z)u+le-*" ,F,(u - m
g,(x)
=
(2q2)-"
+ 1; 2u + 2; 2qz)
and e-9"
,F1(-u
-
m ; -224; 2qz)
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
48
where z = -ierix. This shows the relation between type B operator representations of 8(1,O) and the confluent hypergeometric functions. 8 ( 0 , 1)
For type C’ operators Eq. (2.31) becomes
= pwgm(x),
, I= p w .
If m - q is not an integer this equation has the linearly independent solutions
.26
+ +
+ 1; x2/4)
+
where t = ( m - q)/2 and 77 = ( p / 2 ) ( m q 2w 1). These solutions are “functions of the paraboloid of revolution,” and are closely related to the confluent hypergeometric functions. Type D’ operators yield the equation , I= pw.
This is the parabolic cylinder equation which has as linearly independent solutions the parabolic cylinder functions Dmtw(2/@), Dm+w(- &&). Ce(0,O) sakfy
The functions g,(x)
corresponding to type C” operators
This is Bessel’s equation and its solutions are cylindrical functions. In particular, the Bessel functions JnL(wx)and J-,(wx) satisfy this equation. For type D“ operators we obtain d2 -dxz g r n ( X )
= wzgm(x),
, I=
~~a
T h e solutions e i i & are special functions of a very simple kind. This brief survey shows the deep relationship between functions of hypergeometric type and the Lie algebras %(a,b). I n the next three chapters this relationship will be examined in detail.
2-8. REALIZATIONS
2-8
OF
'3(a,b) IN O N E VARIABLE
49
Realizations of 9 ( a , b ) in One Variable
I n the last section we found differential operators J+, J-, complex variables, satisfying the commutation relations:
[J3, J']
=
J+,
J3,
E in two
[J+, J-] = 2a2J3- bE, [J3, I-] = -J-, (2.32) [J3, El ='[I+, El = [J-, El = 0.
An analogous problem, which will be solved now, is to find realizations of (2.32) in terms of linear differential operator's in one complex variable z. I n particular we look for all nonzero differential operators of the form d J3=h+z-,
E=p
dz
J'
= ji(z) +j2(z)
d
J-
9
= h(z)
+
k2(z)
(2.33)
d
such that the commutation relations (2.32) are satisfied. Here, X and p are complex constants and j , ,j2, K, , k2 are functions of z to be determined. J3 has been chosen so that its eigenfunctionsf,n will be of the form z ~ - i.e., ~ , powers of z. Although this choice of J3 appears special it will be shown in Chapter 8 that every realization of 9 ( a , b) by differential operators in one complex variable is equivalent to a realization of the form (2.33). T h e operators (2.33) satisfy the commutation relations (2.32) if and only if c3 jl(z) = clz, j z ( z ) = czz2, k,(z) = k d z ) = c4 2 '
where the constants c, c2c4' =
,..., c4 satisfy the equations 4 2 ,
czcg
+
ClC4 =
-2a *A
+ bp.
(2.34)
I t is enough to solve these equations for the three cases 9(1, 0), 9(0,I), q o , 0).
%(I, 0 ) Conditions (2.34) become
~
2 = ~ -1, 4
~
2
By a change of variable z if necessary, we can assume
+
~ tic4 3 =
c2 = -c4
-2. =
1.
This leaves only the condition c, - c, = -2. Thus, the general solution is d J3=X+z--, E=p dz (2.35) d J+ = (2h + c3)z + 2 2 J- = 5 dz ' z dz where t3is a constant.
d
50
2. REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE ALGEBRAS
+
~ p. 4 We 9 ( 0 , 1) Conditions (2.34) become c,c4 = 0, ~ 2 ~ ~3 1 = assume p # 0. If c, = 0 then c4 # 0 and clc4 = p. By a change of the variable z if necessary, we can assume c1 = p, c4 = 1. Thus, we obtain the solution d J3=h+z-, E=p, dz (2.36) J+=pz, J-=%+C 3 € @. z dz'
If, however, c4 = 0 then c, # 0 and c2c3 = p. We can assume c, = p, c, = 1 to obtain the solution d J3=h+z-
dz '
J+ = clz
d +22 dz '
E=p, J - = I". z'
c, E
c.
(2.37)
+
3 = 0. In order 8(0,0) Conditions (2.34) are c2c4 = 0, ~ 2 ~ clcp that Jf $ 0, J0 we must have c, = c4 = 0. By a change of the variable z if necessary, we can assume c1 = c, # 0 and obtain the solution d J3=h+z--, E=p, J+=clz, J-= 5 C,E @. (2.38) dz 2 '
+
In the next three chapters the differential operators (2.35)-(2.38) will be used to construct realizations of the abstract representations of 3 ' ( a , b) classified in Section 2-6.
CHAPTER
3 Lie Theory and Bessel Functions
The machinery constructed in Chapters 1 and 2 will here be applied to the study of Bessel functions. As was demonstrated in Section 2-7 these functions are related to the representation theory of 9(0,0). The Bessel functions appear in two distinct ways: as matrix elements of local irreducible representations of G(0, 0) and as basis functions for irreducible representations of 9(0,0). The first relationship will yield addition theorems, and the second will yield generating functions and recursion relations for Bessel functions. @ (&), the nontrivial part of the representation Since 9 ( 0 , 0 ) 9, For a theory of theory of "(0,O) is concerned with the subalgebra 9,. Bessel functions, it is sufficient to study the representation theory of F3 and the local Lie group T , . Thus, we restrict ourselves to Y, throughout this chapter. The Euclidean group in the plane E, is a real 3-parameter global Lie group whose Lie algebra is a real form of Y 3 The . faithful irreducible unitary representations of E, are well known as is the fact that with respect to a suitable basis, the matrix elements of these representations are proportional to Bessel functions of integral order (Vilenkin [I], Wigner [2]). In Section 3-4 we will study the relationship between local representations of T , and unitary representations of E, . The computations involved in this chapter are rather simple and will serve as an introduction to the much more complicated theory of hypergeometric and confluent hypergeometric functions.
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
52
3-1
The Representations Q(w. m,)
Each irreducible representation of 9(0,0) classified in Theorem 2.1 is designated by the symbol Qp(w, m,) where p, w , m, are complex constants such that w # 0 and 0 Re m, < 1. T h e spectrum S of this representation is the set (m, n: n an integer} and the representation space I'has a basis {f,: m E S},such that
<
+
JYm
= mfm
= wfm-1,
J-fm
T h e operators J+, J-,
[J3, J']
=
Efm
9
J3,
f J*,
= pfm
Co,"fm
J'jm
9
= wfm+l*
= (J+J-)fm
w"f,
1
(3.1)
-
E satisfy the commutation relations
[J+. J-I
[J*, E]
= 0,
=
[J3, E]
= 0.
We will try to find a realization of the algebraic representationQr(w, m,) in terms of linear differential operators acting on a vector space of functions of one complex variable. I n particular we will realize Qp(w, m,) in such a way that the differential operators take the form (2.38). T h IS ' can be accomplished as follows: Let Yl be the complex vector space consisting of all finite linear combinations of the functions h,(z) = zn,n = 0, f l , &2,... . In Eqs. (2.38) set h = m,, c1 = w , i.e., J+
Define the basis vectorsf, of Yl byf,(z) and n runs over the integers. Then, (m,
= WZ, =
2
h,(z) where m
=
m,
+n
+ z dz ") zn = (no+ n)zn = mfm ,
J3fm
=
J+fm
= (WZ)Z" = W Z " + ~ = wfm+l>
J-fm
= (w/z)z" = wzn-l - wfm-1
Efm
J-
(3.3)
= pfm
for all m E S. These equations coincide with (3.1) and yield a realization of Q p ( w , mo), Now that we have realized the abstract representation Q*(w, m,) in terms of differential operators acting on analytic functions, we can apply the Lie theory of transformation groups to obtain a multiplier representaHowever, before tion of the local Lie group whose Lie algebra is 9(0,0). beginning this computation it will be convenient to simplify the problem
3-1. THE REPRESENTATIONS Q(w, m,)
53
slightly. Since 9(0,0) 9, 0(a)and p ( 8 ) = E is a multiple of the identity operator for every irreducible representation p, the nontrivial part of the representation theory of 9 ( 0 , 0 ) is given by the action of p on 9, . We will lose nothing of importance for special function theory if we study only those representations Qp(w, m,) for which E = p = 0. Moreover, the representations Qo(w, m,) induce an irreducible represenT h e action of tation Q(u, m,) of the 3-dimensional subalgebra F3. Q(u, m,) is obtained explicitly from Eqs. (3.1)-(3.3) by suppressing the operator E. I t was shown in Section 1-2 that F , is the Lie algebra of the local Lie group T 3 ,a multiplicative matrix group with elements
We will extend the representation Q ( w , m,) of F , , defined on Vl , to a multiplier representation of T , . Let a, be the vector space of all functions of z analytic in some neighborhood of the point z = 1. Clearly V1C a1. According to Theorem 1.10 the differential operators (3.5)
generate a Lie algebra which is the algebra of generalized Lie derivatives of a multiplier representation A of T, acting on a, . We will verify this fact and compute the multiplier v. T h e action of the group element on , T E @, is obtained by solving the differential equations exp ~j~ dz
_ -- z, dT
d
- v ( z 0 , exp T 9 ' ) = mov(zo,exp T f 3 ) dT
with initial conditions z(0) = 9,~ ( e) 9, = 1. (See Section 1-2 for the definition of exp T j ' . ) T h e solution of these equations is Z(T)
exp T f 3 ) = e m o r ,
= zoer,
v(z0,
Thus, i f f € 67, is analytic in a neighborhood of 9 then [A(exp T f 3 ) ) f ] ( Z o ) for 1
T
=
[exp r J 3 ] f ( z 0= ) emo'f(zOef)
1 sufficiently small. Similar computations yield [A(exp b Y + ) f l ( z " )= exp(bwF)f(zO), [A(exp c f - ) f ] ( z o )= exp(cw/zo)f(zo).
54
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
If g E T, is given by (3.4) we find g
= (exp b$+)(exp
Hence, for 1 T 1, 1 b 1, 1 f E 152,takes the form
c
cf-)(exp
~$3).
1 sufficiently small the operator A(g) acting on
~ ~ w i (=z [WXP )
c f - 1 WXP
V+)WXP
T ~ 3 m z )
= exp(bwz)[~(expCY-){A(~XP 4 3 ) m z )
= exp w (bz
+ f) [A(exp . f 3 ) ) f l ( z )
= exp ( wbz
+ -z + mo7)f(eTz), WC
(3.6)
defir.ed for z in a sufficiently small neighborhood of z = 1. The m*dtiplier v is given by v(z,g) = exp(wbz + wc/z m,,.). Conversely, (3.6) defines a multiplier representation of T, whose generalized Lie derivatives are the differential operators (3.5). The elements of Vlare analytic for all values of z # 0, so iff E V, and z # 0 the expression
+
[A(g)f](z)
= exp ( wbz
+ “c + moT)f(eTz) 2
defines an element of C?l1 for all g E T, , not just for g in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the identity. We define the vector subspace 7, of a, (the completion of TI, see Section 2-2) as the space of all finite linear combinations of functions of the form A(g)f for all g E T,, f E Vl . By definition, TIis invariant under A: Ak)feTl
for all
f € v 1 , g e T,.
Furthermore, iff E Y1, g, , g, E T, , then
A k d f = AkI”k2)fl.
(3.7)
a,
By restricting from to Q, the space on which the local multiplier representation A acts, we have been able to extend A over the whole , has been “exponentgroup T, . Thus, the representation Q(w, m,) of F iated” to yield a global representation of T, . The basis functions fm(z) = h,(z) = zn, n = 0, & l , ..., m = m, n, for V,form an analytic basis for 9,(see Section 2-2). This is true because every element f in Vlis analytic at all points z # 0 in G’; hence, f has a unique Laurent expansion
+
c W
f(2) =
n=--m
unzn,
I%,
3-1. THE REPRESENTATIONS Q(w, m,)
55
which converges for all z # 0. Thus, we can define the matrix elements A,,(g) of the operators A ( g ) on 4, by
Using (3.6) we obtain exp wbz (
+ -z + (k + m , ) ~ ) WC
=
f
l=-m
&(g)z’
(3.9)
which can be regarded as a generating function for the matrix elements. From A(g,g,)h, = A(g,)[A(g,)h,] there follows the identity
Comparing coefficients of h,(z) = zl we obtain the addition theorem
c A,,(gl) m
Az,(g,g,)
=
j=-m
Ajk(g2),
I, k- = 0, 31, f2,...9
(3.10)
valid for all g, ,g, E T , . T o find an explicit expression for the matrix elements A,,(g) it is sufficient to compute the coefficient of zi on the left-hand side of (3.9). Thus,
=
e(k+mo)‘
m
(Wb)s(CU)s+k--l
1”
s!(s
I, k
& l , &2 ,..., (3.11)
l=--m
+ k - I)!
’
so Azk(g)= e(k+mJT(c
w)k-z
F
(w2bc)S s!(s
+ k - l)!,
= 0,
56
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
where the sum extends over all nonnegative integral values of s such that the summand is defined. Specifically,
where the function F , , is defined by its power series expansion (A. 21). These two cases can be combined into the single expression
valid for all integral values of I, k. If bc # 0 the matrix elements are closely related to Bessel functions. To see this we introduce new group parameters r, v in place of b, c by
<
< arg b, arg c T,or briefly, r = (ibc)1/2and v = (b/ic)1/2. where r-, With these definitions it follows that b = rvi2, c = -rv-1/2, and this coordinate change is one-to-one if bc # 0. I n terms of the coordinates T , ZI the matrix elements (3.11) can be expressed as A,,@) = e(m,,+k)T(
-q~)l-k
J~-~(-uY),
k = 0,f l , &2 ,...
(3.14)
[see (A. 2O)J. T h e functions J l are Bessel functions of integral order. I n particular, for T = 0, ZI = -1, w = -1, k = 0, substitution of (3.14) into (3.9) yields the well-known generating function exp
(z
-
z-l)] =
f
~~(r)zl.
(3.15)
k-CC
for Bessel functions. We can obtain addition theorems for the functions di; by substituting (3.12) into (3.10). After some simplification one finds
3-2. RECURSION RELATIONS FOR MATRIX ELEMENTS
57
where n is a nonnegative integer and b, , b, , c1 , c2 E @. Some special cases of this formula are of interest. If b, = 1, b, = c1 = 0, c, = x, (3.16) reduces to
which is the power series expansion for .(We have used the fact that p,(K;0) = 1.) If b, = 1, b, = 0, c, = x, c, = y, then
0, c1 = -c2
If 6 , = x, b,
=
For b, = c1
= x,
=
1 there follows
b, = c, = y we obtain
.O F d I i I
+ 1; x2)
$1(1
n -j
I
+1;~~).
T h e addition theorem (3.10) can also be used to derive identities relating Bessel functions of integral order. However, it will be more convenient to derive these results in Section 3-3 as special cases of identities relating Bessel functions of arbitrary order. 3-2
Recursion Relations for t h e M a t r i x Elements
T h e matrix elements A,,(g), g E T, , computed in (3.1 1) are entire analytic functions of the group parameters T , b, c. Hence they can be considered as analytic functions on the group manifold. Denoting by a(T,) the space of all functions on T, which are analytic in some neighborhood of the identity element, we see that A,, E a(T 3 )for all integers I, k, where the Aj, are matrix elements corresponding to the representation Q(W, mo).There is a natural action P of T3 on a(T,) as a local transformation group. P is defined by
58
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
for all j~ @(T3)and all g', g in a sufficiently small neighborhood of E T3 (the neighborhood depends on f). From (3.17) it is evident that
e
P(glg2)f = Pkl)[Pk2)fl,
if g, ,g, , and g, g, are in the domain off. Thus, P defines T3as an effective local transformation group on the 3-parameter group manifold of T3 . The action of P on the matrix elements A j k is easily determined:
for all g, g' E T3 ,j , k = 0, f1, &2,... . Comparing this expression with (3.8) we see that for fixed j the functions { A j k , k = 0,fl, &2,...}, form a basis for the representation Q(u, m,) of T , . The Lie derivatives J+, J-, J3 defined by
for all f~ @( T3),must, therefore, satisfy the commutation relations
and act on the basis vectors Ajk as follows:
These expressions give recursion relations and differential equations for the matrix elements Ajk. T o evaluate them it is necessary to compute the Lie derivatives defined by (3.19). The. elements of O!(T,) can be considered as analytic functions of the group coordinates b, c, 7 , so the Lie derivatives are linear differential operators in these three complex variables. However, if we wish to relate our results to Bessel functions it is more convenient to use the group coordinates Y , c,7 , (3.13). As we
3-3. REALIZATIONS OF Q(w, m,) IN TWO VARIABLES
59
have seen, in terms of the I, v coordinate system the matrix elements are given by (3.14): A&)
= e(mo+k)r(-v)l--k
Jl--k(-W+
This coordinate system is not defined over the whole group but only for those group elements such that bc # 0. If g has coordinates (I, v , r ) and
1
g' = (0
0
0
e-7'
0
0 0
e7' 0
0 0
")
1
a simple computation shows that the coordinates of gg' are given by e-lc'v
(r[l - 2-
Y
2erb' + tp,- 4
7 1 b'c'
1
lI2
v
+ 2erb'/rw
[ 1 - 2e-7cIv/r
for I b' I, I c' I sufficiently small. From this result and the definition (3.19) of the Lie derivatives there follows
Substituting (3.14)and (3.21) into (3.20) we obtain, after factoring out the dependence on v and r ,
where n is an integer.
3-3
Realizations of Q(w, m,) in Two Variables
In the previous sections realizations of the representation Q(w, m,) of .Z3have been determined on spaces of functions of one and three complex
variables, respectively. We will now find realizations of this representation on spaces of functions of two complex variables, x and y. In particular? we look for functionsf,,(x, y) = Z,(x) emu, such that
60
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
+ k: k an integer), where the differential operators
for all m E S = {m, J*, J" are given by
(3.24)
These operators are the type C" operators classified in Section 2-7. (The constants p , q occurring in the expression for the type C" operators can be set equal to 0 without any loss of generality.) The content of (3.23) is, thus, a series of equations relating the functions Z,(x):
The complex constant o in these equations is clearly nonessential; we could remove it by making the change of variable x' = w x . Hence, we wilI assume w = -1. (For this choice of w , Eqs. (3.25) agree with the conventional recursion relations for cylindrical functions, (A. 23).) Nonzero solutions of these equations are well known. If m, = 0 so that the elements of S are integers, we see from (3.22) that Z,(x) = J,,,(x) is a solution for all m E S . Furthermore, for arbitrary complex values of m, we can obtain the solutions Znt(x)= J m ( x ) , J-,,,(x), H:)(x), HZ'(x), Nm(x),for all m E S (Magnus et al. [l]). Thus, the Bessel functions of first and second kind, the Hankel functions of first and second kind, and the Neuman functions each satisfy the recursion relations (3.25) for o = - 1. Each of these functions is analytic for all values of x except x =
0.
If, conversely, functions Z,(x) defined for each m E S satisfy (3.25) for w = -1, then the vectors fin(x, y ) = Z,(x) emu form a basis for a . This Lie algebra realization of the representation Q(- 1, m,) of 9, representation induces a local representation of T,. In fact if 02 is the space of all functions analytic in some neighborhood of the point (9, y") = (1, 0), the Lie derivatives
define a local multiplier representation T of T3on 0. From Theorem 1.10, [T(exp b f + ) f ] ( x , eY) = f ( x ( b ) , ey(*)),
b E C?,
j c @,
3-3. REALIZATIONS OF Q ( u , ~ , ) IN TWO VARIABLES
61
where dx
db (b) = e*(b),
-dY( b )
=
db
-
eu(b)
x(b) ’
x(0) = x, y ( 0 ) = y .
T h e solution of these equations is
where for convenience we use the new variable t = eu. Similar computations yield
g =
1 ‘j, 0
0 e;
eT o
0
c
0
0
1
a g in a then g = (exp b$+)(exp c2-)(exp T f ’ ) . So, for f ~ and sufficiently small neighborhood of the identity we have
An explicit computation gives
[T(g)f](x, t )
=
1
+-
(3.26)
defined for I 2bt/x 1 < 1, j 2c/xt I < 1. According to Section 2-2, our on the space generated realization of the representation Q(- 1, m,) of F3 by the functions’f,,(x, y ) = Z,(x) emu, m E S, can be extended to a local representation of T3 where the group action is given by (3.26). In particular, the functions fn(x, y ) form an analytic basis for this space, as can easily be seen from (2.2) and the y-dependence emu of the basis vectors. Thus, the matrix elements of this local representation
62
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
with respect to the basis f, are uniquely determined by Q(-I, m,) and without computation we immediately obtain the relations
(3.28)
where the matrix elements A,,(g) are given by (3.12) (o = -1). T h e region of convergence of these relations is determined by examining the singularities of the functions on the left-hand side of (3.28). Since 2, , m E @, is analytic in x for all nonzero values of x, it follows that the infinite series (3.28) converges absolutely for I 2bt/x I < 1; I 2c/xt I < 1. Explicitly,
(3.29)
Several of the fundamental identities for cylindrical functions are special cases of this formula. If c = 0, t = 1, Eq. (3.29) becomes
If b = 0, t = 1, one obtains
I n the case where 2, of Lommel.
= J , , (3.30) and (3.31) are known as the formulas
3-4. WEISNER'S METHOD FOR BESSEL FUNCTIONS
63
If bc # 0 we can introduce the coordinates Y , o defined by (3.13), such that b = rv/2, c = - ~ / 2 v . I n this case A,,(g) = e(mo+K)T(
-v)t-k
Jl-k)
and Eq. (3.29) simplifies to
m
1x1
T
Izl
(3.32)
For 2, = Jm this is a generalization of Graf's addition theorem (ErdClyi al. [l], Vol. 11, p. 44).
et
3-4 Weisner's Method for Bessel Functions Expressions (3.27) are valid only for group elements g in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the identity element of T 3 . However, we can also use the type C" operators (3.24) to derive identities for cylindrical functions associated with group elements bounded away from the identity. T h e following remarks are pertinent. If f ( x , t) is a solution of the equation Cosf = coy, i.e., (3.33)
then the function T(g)f given formally by
satisfies the equation Co,o(T(g)f) = w2(T(g)f) whenever T(g)f can be defined. This follows from the fact that Co,ocommutes with the differential operators J+, J-, 53. Furthermore, iff is a solution of the equation (xiJ'
+ 4-+ x3JS)f(x, t )
Mx,t)
(3.34)
for constants x1 , x2 , x3 , A, then T(g)f is a solution of the equation
+ x2J- + x3J3)T(g-')I[T(g)fl
[T(g)(xiJ+
= V'"g)fI
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
64
where
+ xzJ- + x3J3)T(g-')
+ (xze-. + cx3)J- + x3J3.
= (xleT - 6x3)J+
T(g)(x,J+
(3.35)
This is a consequence of Eq. (1.43). As an example of the application of these remarks consider the function f ( x , 1 ) = J,,,(x)t", m E @. Here Co,,f = f, = mf, so the function
JY
satisfies the equations
If
7
=
b
=
0, c
=
-1, we can write (3.36) in the form
h(x, t ) = (x2
2x
+ t) Im -ml2
[(XZ
+
y]+ (2
xtp.
Since x-mJ,,,(x) is an entire function of x, h has a Laurent expansion about t = 0:
c hn(x)t", m
h(x, t )
=
n=-m
1 x t I < 2.
Substituting this expansion in the first equation (3.37) we see that h,(x) is a solution of Bessel's equation
for each integer n. T h e function h(x, t ) is bounded for x = 0, so we must have h,(x) = c,J,(x), c, E C?' [see (A.22)]. Thus,
From the second equation (3.37)' (- J- + J3) h ( x , t ) = mh(x, t ) , it follows that cnfl = (rn - n ) c , . T h e constant co can be determined
3-5. THE REAL EUCLIDEAN GROUP
€3
directly by setting x = 0 in h(x, t ) . T h e result is co = l / r ( m whence c, = l / r ( m - n 1). Thus, we obtain the identity
+
I x t I < 2.
65
+ I),
(3.38)
Equation (3.38) is obviously not a special case of (3.29). For other examples of generating functions derived by this method see Weisner [3]. T h e above results were all obtained by using type C" operators. T h e type D" operators lead to no new results for special functions so we will not consider them here. 3-5
The Real Euclidean Group E,
T h e Euclidean group in the plane, E,, can be defined as the real 3-parameter group of matrices cos0 g(0, xl, x p ) = sin 0
( 0
-sin 0 x1 cos 0
0
(3.39) 1
where x1 , xg are real and 8 is a real variable determined up to a multiple of 277. As is well known, E, acts as a transformation group in the plane. If y = (yl ,yz)is a point in the plane R2the action of E, is given by y
---f
+ ( y z - xz) sin 0, sin 0 + ( y z x2) cos 0).
g-ly = ((yl - xl) cos 0 - (yl
-
xl)
-
This action corresponds to a translation (yl ,y 2 )-+ (yl - x1 ,y z - xz), followed by a rotation through the angle 8 in a clockwise direction about the point (0, 0). I t is easily verified in terms of the group parameters that the group multiplication is given by g(4 x1 , = g(O
R(O',
.;x;) 1
+ O', x; cos 0 - x;
sin 0
+ x1 ,x; sin 0 + x; cos 0 + xz).
(3.40)
T h e identity element of E, is the identity matrix g(0, 0, 0) and the inverse of g(8, x1 , x2) is g-1(0,
, x2) = g( -0,
-xl
cos 0 - x2 sin
0, x1 sin 0 - x2 cos O),
66
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
since g(8, X, ,x2)g( -8, -xl
cos 8 - x2 sin 8, x1 sin 8 - x2 cos 8) = g(0, 0,O).
As a basis for the real Lie algebra 8, of E, we choose the elements fl
=
i),
f
[),
f
f 2 =
:)
(h 8 0 -1
J%=
0
(3.41)
with commutation relations [A1 9
A1 = 0,
[ A* A1 = f
2
9
[ A A1 = - f 1 + iYl,2-= y 2+ 9
matrices ,$+ = - f 2 Y 3= if3, i = satisfy the commutation relations
The
complex
[f3,
$+I
47, =
f-1
[f3,
%+I
=
-f-,
f-I
[ff,
=0
which are identical with the relations (1.41) for a basis of 9,Thus, . the complex Lie algebra generated by the basis elements (3.41) is 9,We . is the complexification of 8,and 8,is a real form of F , say that 9, (See Helgason [l], p. 152). Due to this relationship between F , and 8,, induces an irreducthe abstract irreducible representation Q(w, m,) of ible representation of 8,. There is another matrix realization of E, which we will find useful. Namely, we define matrices [eie
x1 ,x2 E R,
(x2 - ixJ2 \ (-xz - ix1)/2
0
0 <8
< 2a,
1
I
,
mod 27~.
(3.42)
These matrices form a realization of E, isomorphic to the realization by the matrices (3.39). I n fact,
g(4
.; +
x1 9 x2)g(B', = g(8
7
B', x; cos 8 - x; sin 8
+ x1 , x; sin 8 +
X;
cos 8
+ x2)
in agreement with (3.40). I t will sometimes be convenient to use, instead of the coordinates xl, x 2 , the polar coordinates r 2 0 and defined by x,
+ ix, = r&,
3-6. UNITARY REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE GROUPS
67
where we assume that r e 9 = 0 implies Y = v = 0. In terms of these new coordinates the matrices (3.42) take the form
1
If g' has coordinates [O', Y ' , v'] and g" has coordinates [O", Y", q"] then an easy computation shows g'g'' has coordinates [O, Y, v] where 0 = 8' + O",
reiq
= y'efo'
In particular, the coordinates of g'-l are
+ y"ei(cpn+e')s
[-el,
Y',
q'
- 8'
(3.43)
+
7r].
3-6 Unitary Representations of Lie Groups We shall be interested in the connection between the local multiplier representations of T3 and (global) unitary representations of E3 on a Hilbert space. Hence, we make a brief digression to discuss unitary representations. The basic concepts of the theory of unitary representations of (global) Lie groups are presented in several standard references (Naimark [1, 21; Helgason [13). Here, a few of the fundamental definitions rnd results in this theory will be listed which are useful for the study of special functions. It is assumed that the reader is familiar with the basic concepts of Hilbert space theory. Let X be a complex Hilbert space with the inner product of two vectors f, f ' in X denoted by (f,f') and the norm o f f by /-f 1 = ((f, fW2.We aSSume (f, a f ' ) = a ( f , f'), (Uf, f')= d(f, f'> for every a E @, i.e., the inner product is linear in the second argument, conjugate linear in the first argument. A sequence of vectors {f,&}, n = 1, 2,,,.,is said to converge to f EX,(f,,+ f),if limn+mI f, - f I = 0. Let 9 be a vector subspace of X . 9 is dense in X if for every f E X there is a sequence of vectors f, E 9 such that f,, +f. 9 is closed if every convergent sequence of vectors in 9 converges to an element in 9. X is closed by definition. If @ is a subspace of X, 9,the closure of @ is defined to be the intersection of all closed subspaces of X containing a.It is easy to see that 3 is closed. A linear operator U on X is unitary if (Uf, U f') = (f,f')for every f, f ' E X. If U is unitary, so is U-1 where U-l is the unique operator such that UU-' = I, (I is the identity operator). Let G be a real (global) Lie group. A unitary representation of G
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
68
on X consists of a family of unitary operators U(g) on X , defined for every g E G, with the properties:
U(gg') = U(g) U(g')
for all g, g' E G, if g,+g in the topology of G then U ( g , ) f 4 U(g)f in X , (2) for all f EX. (1)
Since the unitary operators have unique inverses, it follows easily from ( 1 ) that U(e) = I and U( g-l) = U(g)-l. Property (2) states that the operators U( g) are strongly continuous as functions of g. A unitary representation of G on SEO is irreducible if there is no proper closed subspace of X which is invariant under all the operators U( g), i.e., if there is no proper closed subspace X ' of X such that U(g ) f E X ' for all f EX',gE G. Let '3 be the Lie algebra of G and exp a, a E '3, the exponential map from '3 to G. If the operators U( g) form a unitary representation of G, then in analogy with Section 1-3 we might try to construct a representation of 3 in terms of linear operators L, on SEO defined by
where the limit exists in the sense of the norm of X . However, the limit may not exist for all vectors f so L, may not be well defined as a linear operator on SEO. Denote by 9 ( L , ) the set of vectors f for which this limit exists. Obviously, B(L,) is a subspace of X . Suppose there is a dense subspace 9 of X with the properties:
(1) 9 C 9 ( L , ) for all 3, (2) B is invariant under all the operators U(g), (3.45) (3) 9 is invariant under all the operators L, , (4) For a n y f g 9 the vector U(g)fis an analytic function on G. We say a vector-valued function h of G on X is analytic at goE G if there exists a coordinate system (yl ,...,y m }on a neighborhood W of go such that yl( go) = ... = ym(go) = 0 and h(g) ==
n,.
1
....n,>o
an,**.n,yl(g)n'
yni(gP,
g E W*
Here, the coefficients u , ~ ~ belong . . . ~ ~to X and CIL1,...,n,>O 1 an,...n,I < rn (Helgason [ I ] , p. 440). If such a subspace 9 exists we can immediately carry over the standard methods in Chapter 1 relating Lie groups to Lie algebras. On the dense
3-6. UNITARY REPRESENTATIONS OF LIE GROUPS
69
subspace 9 Theorems 1.8-1.1 1 relating local multiplier representations to algebras of Lie derivatives have exact analogs. Thus, forf E 9 we have
(3.46)
(4)
d dt U(exp tor)f = L,(U(exp tor)f).
-
These results follow from the fact that U ( g ) f i s analytic in g (Naimark [2], Chapter 3). Convergence in (3) is in the sense of the norm. Equations (3.46) show that on 9 the infinitesimal operators Lu completely determine the unitary operators U(g) for g in a neighborhood of the identity. However, since 9 is dense in 2f and U(g) is a bounded operator it follows from a standard argument that U(g) is uniquely determined on S? for all g in the connected component of the identity element in G (Naimark [2], p. 100). I t can be shown that such’a subspace 9 described above actually exists for every unitary representation of a Lie group G (see Helgason [ 11, p. 441, and references given there). Thus it is always possible to use Lie algebraic methods to derive information about (possibly infinite-dimensional) unitary representations of Lie groups. We will not need this result but quote it here to show that the methods used in the rest of this chapter are not as special as they might appear. Lemma 3.1 of G, then
If the operators U(g) form a unitary representation
=
-(f,L,h)
(3.47)
for all f,h E 9 and all or E 9. PROOF Since the operators U(g) are unitary and form a representation of G we have
(U(exp t a ) f , hj
=
(f,U(exp - tor)h)
for all real t. Differentiating both sides of this equation with respect to t and evaluating at t = 0 we obtain the lemma. Lemma 3.1 gives necessary conditions that operators L, must satisfy to be obtained as the infinitesimal operators of a unitary representation of G.
70
3-7
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
Induced Representations of g3
T h e above results can now be applied to find unitary irreducible representations of E, . Let U be an irreducible unitary representation of E , on the Hilbert space X and let B be a dense subspace of X satisfying the properties (3.45). First of all, from (3.39) and (3.41) we find
Thus E , is uniquely determined by y1, yz, y,. Equations (3.46) then show that the operators U(g) for all g E E, are uniquely determined by the infinitesimal operators La. Second, if B’ C 9 is invariant under all the infinitesimal operators La of an irreducible unitary representation of E, , then 9’is dense in B. For, if 9’ is invariant under the L a ,it is clear from (3.46) that 3’ (the closure of 9’)is invariant under U( g) for allg E E, . Since the unitary representation is irreducible we have G’ = X. Thus, 9’is dense in both B and X . We can conclude that 9 contains no proper closed subspaces invariant under the La. Define the infinitesimal operators Jk on B by
for all f E 9. These operators satisfy the commutation relations
and determine a representation of 8, on B. Therefore, the operators J* = Jz iJ1 , J3 = iJ3 satisfy the relations
+
Clearly, J*, J3 induce a representation p of the complex Lie algebra F, on 9.We will investigate which of the irreducible representations Q ( w , mo) of F , can be obtained in this way on some dense subspace 9’ of B, i.e., the conditions under which p restricted to 9’is isomorphic to &(w, mob According to Lemma 3.1,
3-8. THE UNITARY REPRESENTATIONS (p) OF
E3
71
for all f,h E 93. Thus,
<JY$h> = - i ( J 3 f , <J+f* h>
=
<(-Jz
h> = + i ( f , J3h) =
+
iJI)f,
h>
Recall that the representation the relations J Y m = mfm
=
+ iJ#>
(3.50) =
(fi
J-h).
(3.51)
m,) of F3was determined by
Q(w,
>
(f, J3h>
J*fm
= wfm*tl
where w # 0, m = m, + k, and k runs over the integers. Now we assume that the vectors f , are in 93 and use (3.50) and (3.51) to find restrictions on o and m,. From (3.50), Thus (6- n) (fn, ,f n ) = 0 for all m,n in the spectrum of J3. If m # n this relation proves (f,, fn) = 0. However, if m = n we have ( f i - m) Ifm l2 = 0. Since f, # 0, the eigenvalue m must be real. Further, from (3.46) we find U(exp Of,)
fm =
exp(-iO
J3) fm
.
= rimym
Since exp(2rr2,) is the identity element of E, , we must have e-*&, = 1 for all m in the spectrum of 5,. Thus, m must be an integer and m, = 0. From (3.51) W
,fm+l>
= (J’fm
rfm+J
1
J-fm+l>
=
4 f m ,fm>
for all integers m. Hence, w/W = I f,+l f, l2 > 0. This relation can be satisfied only if w is real and I f f f l + lI = 1 f , 1. Consequently, all the vectors f , have the same length and without loss of generality we can assume 1 f , I = 1 for all integers m. This analysis proves that any. irreducible representation of F , induced by a unitary representation of E3 must be of the form Q(w, 0) where w is a nonzero real number. Furthermore, the vectors fnz , m an integer, form an orthonormal basis for 93 (hence, for X ) :
3-8 The Unitary Representations (p) of E3 Conversely, we will show by explicit computation that, in fact, all of the representations Q(w, O), w real, induce unitary irreducible representations of E, . (Since Q(w, 0) Q( - w , 0), without loss of generality we
72
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
can assume w < 0.) T h e unitary representations of E, can be obtained formally through an examination of the multiplier representation (3.6) of T,. If m, = 0, (3.6) depends on the parameter T only in the form e‘ (if m, # 0 this is not true): (3.6)’
Thus, the operators (3.6)’ define a single-valued multiplier representation of the multiplicative matrix group Ti with elements
(0
cT0
g(T,
b, c ) =
0
eT
0
c
b), 1
b, c, 7 E c.
(3.52)
T h e matrices (3.52) are obtained from the matrices (3.4) of T , by eliminating the first row and last column. Ti is not simply connected. However, as local Lie groups, Ti and T , are isomorphic. Comparing (3.52) and (3.42) we can consider E , as the real subgroup of T i consisting of the matrices (3.52) such that Re T = 0 and b = --E. I n fact,
o G e,
< 2.rr, Y 2 0.
(3.53)
Using this embedding of E, in Ti we can define a multiplier representation of E , directly from (3.6)’ by restricting the group elements to E, :
Since 1 eiez I = I z I for all 8, the representation (3.54) can be restricted to functions defined on the unit circle: z = eia, 0 01 < 2n. T h e basis functionsf,,*(z) = zmrestrict tofm(a) = e i m o for all integers m. Now we have the ingredients required to define irreducible unitary representations of E, . Let S‘ be the complex Hilbert space consisting of all functions f(01), 0 01 < 277, mod 277, such that
<
<
J O
3-8. THE UNITARY REPRESENTATIONS (p) OF E,
73
The inner product on S? is
(3.55) As is well known, the functions m = O , f l , f 2 ,...,
i, ~
fm(a) = e
form an orthonormal basis for S?, =L
(fm ,fn>
We define a representation (p), p on X such that
, n*
> 0, of E,
by unitary operators U(g)
[U(g)f](a) = eipr cos(-)f(,
-
0)
(3.56)
where f E Xand g = g[B, Y,~p]E E, . The expression for U(g) follows immediately from (3.54) by setting z = eiu, p = --w. The operators U(g) are unitary since
for all f, h E X , g E E, . We define the matrix elements of (p) with respect to the basisf, by unm(g) =
=-
9
U(g)fm>
2w
0
exp[+ipr C O S ( ~9') - im0
- jn-mei[(m-n)~-m8]
Jn+,&y),
-m
+ i(m - .)a] < n,
m
da
< a, (3.57)
where the J,reare Bessel functions of integral order. T o justify the last equality note that for z = ieiu,Eq. (3.15) becomes m
e i r COS
O(
=
C
ilJt(y) e i h .
l=--00
Thus the exponential functions under the integral sign in (3.57) can be expanded in a series of Bessel functions and integrated term by term to obtain the indicated result. Note the similarity between (3.14) and (3.57).
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
74
By construction, the operators U(g) satisfy the representation property U(g')
= U(g)
W')
(3.58)
for all g, g' E E , . However, we can also verify this directly. I n terms of the coordinates (0, x1 , x2) for g, (3.56) becomes [U(g)f]((~) = exp[ip(xl cos (Y
+ x2 sin .)If(..
-
0).
Thus, if the group elements g and g' have coordinates (0, xl, x2), (O', x i , x@, respectively, we find U(g)[U(g')fl(4 = exP[G4% cos = exp{zp[(x,
+
X;
x2
cos (Y
sin(or
-
= exp{ip[(x; cos
+ sin 4llU(g')fl((Y - 0) + x2 sin a) + (xi cos(a - 0)
0))]}f(a - 0 - 0') 0 - x; sin 0
+ xl)
+ ( x i sin 0 + x; cos 0 + x 2 ) sin =
[U(gg')f](a)
+ 0', X;
cos 0
- 0 - 0')
(Y]}~((Y
for all f EX,
since the coordinates of gg' are (0
cos (Y
- x; sin 0 + x1 , x; sin 8
+ x; cos 0 + xJ.
This proves that ( p ) is indeed a unitary representation of E,. T h e methods introduced in Section 3-7 could also be used to show that ( p ) is irreducible. However, we will give a direct proof of this fact. Lemma 3.2 T h e representation (p), p
> 0, is irreducible.
PROOF We assume (p) is reducible and obtain a contradiction. Thus, suppose there exists a proper closed subspace 9 of X such that U(g)fE 9 for all g E E, , f~ 9.Let P be the self-adjoint projection operator on 9. That is, P is the operator on X uniquely defined by the conditions (a) Pf = f f o r all f~ 9; and (b) Ph = 0 for all h E 91where 9'l
= { h EX: (h,f) =0
for all f~ 9}.
From elementary considerations in functional analysis it follows that (i) (Ph', h") = (A', Ph") for all h', h" EX,i.e., P is self-adjoint; (ii) P2 = P; and (iii) U(g)P = PU(g) for all g E E3 (see Naimark [I], Chapters 4,6). Furthermore P # 0, I, since 9 is a proper subspace of X . Let gobe the element of E, with coordinates (0, 0,O).Then U(g,)f,,, = cirnsf,wheref,, is a basis vector for X . From (ii) we obtain U(ge)Pfm=
3-9. THE MATRIX ELEMENTS OF (p)
75
for all integers m. Since the vectors f, form a basis for ,W we must have Pf, = 01, f, , a, a constant. T h e property P2 = P implies C Y = ~ a m , hence am = 0 or or, = 1 for each integer m. By hypothesis there exist nonnegative integers m',m" such that Pfm*= 0,Pfmn = f,n. Thus, Umfrn.(g) = (fm' U(g)PfmH) = ( f m ' PU(g)fmn) = (Pfm' U(g)fmn) = 0 for all g E E, . However, from (3.57) we see that no matrix element Un,(g) of ( p ) is identically zero. This contradiction proves the lemma.
e--im@Pf,,
9
3-9
3
9
The Matrix Elements of (p)
We can obtain information about Bessel functions of integral order from expression (3.57)for the matrix elements of (p). Since the operators U(g) are unitary and form a representation of E, , the matrix elements satisfy Unm(g-')
=
umn(g),
or
JnW.
J-n(r) =
(3.59)
Moreover, U,,(e) = an,, where e is the identity element of E,. In terms of Bessel functions this implies if n # 0,
Jn(0)= 0
],(O)
=
1.
(3.60)
Using the Schwarz inequality, we have
I unm(g)I
=
I(fn
>
< Ifn
Uk)fm>l
I . I U(g)fm I
= Ifn
I * Ifm I = 1
<
I Jn(d 1. Since U(g'g")= U(g') U(g") for all g', g"E E, the matrix elements satisfy the addition theorem so
unm(g'g")
m
=
unk(g')
ukm(k!n).
(3.61)
k---a,
Substituting expressions (3.57) for the matrix elements and simplifying we obtain m
e-im'Jm(y)
=
C
e - W V + ( m - k ) ~ ' l Jm-k(y') Jk(y")
(3.62)
kc--ao
where ieiq = r'eiw' case of (3.32).
+ r"eiq". This
is Graf's addition theorem, a special
76
3. LIE THEORY AND BESSEL FUNCTIONS
If
v'
I' = Y" = x,
=
0, and q" = T,then r = 0, v = 0, and m
C
k=-m
JIc+n(X)
.Id.)
= 8n.o
where we have used (3.59) and (3.60). = 0, r = r' + Y", and (3.62) becomes = T'' = 0 then If Jm(7'
+
m
I") =
C
k=--m
Jm-dy')
J k ( O
Finally, we can derive a useful integral formula for the product of two Bessel functions from (3.62) by setting v' = 0 and multiplying by einc". Integrating both sides of the resulting equation with respect to cp" we obtain
where
reiq =
rf
+ r"ei""
3-10 The Infinitesimal Operators of ( p ) T h e infinitesimal operators of the representation ( p ) defined by (3.49) are easily computed to be Jl = i p cos a,
. .
Jz = zp sin a,
= -
J3
a z.
(3.64)
These operators are all defined on any dense subspace 9 of 3? satisfying properties (3.46) and they leave B invariant. Forming the operators Jf, J-, 53 in the usual manner, we have J+
w&,
J-=
we-i~,
J3
=
a -i -, aff
w = -p.
T h e action of these operators on the analytic basis vectorsf,,(a) = eima is given by J+fm
= wfm+l,
J-fm
=
wfm-1,
J"fm
= mfm
in agreement with Eqs. (3.1) for the representation Q(w, 0) of F3 . Thus, each representation Q ( w , 0), w < 0, induces an irreducible unitary representation ( - w ) of E3 .
3-10. THE INFINITESIMAL OPERATORS OF (p)
77
As in Section 3-2 we could derive recursion relations and differential equations for the matrix elements of (p). However, we shall omit this as the results are merely special cases of the corresponding results in Section 3-2. Similarly the addition theorem (3.62) is a special case of the addition theorem (3.16). From the general theory of Lie groups it can be shown that up to unitary equivalence all of the irreducible unitary representations of E, are of the form (p), p > 0, except for the trivial 1-dimensional representations x,, , n an integer, defined by xn[g(O, XI 9
XPll = elne
(see Bingen [l], Vilenkin [l, 31). Thus, the Lie algebraic methods presented in this chapter suffice to find all the irreducible unitary representations of E, . T h e reason for this is essentially topological: T h e l-parameter subgroup C = {exp Of,} of E, is compact. Because C is compact, the Peter-Weyl theorem guarantees that any unitary representation U of E, when restricted to C can be decomposed into a direct sum of 1-dimensional irreducible representations of C. Since the 1-dimensional representations of C are of the form p,,(exp O$,) = ein@,n an integer, it is always possible to find a basis for the representation space of U consisting of eigenvectors of the operator J, = -iJ3. If U is irreducible it is not difficult to show that each eigenvalue has multiplicity one. Thus, the hypotheses (2.19) of Section 2-6 are satisfied and our methods succeed in determining all unitary irreducible representations of E , . Another real Lie group whose Lie algebra is a real form of F, is T,". The elements g of T,"are those matrices of T, which are real:
In contrast to E, , the group Tf has no compact 1-parameter subgroups. In this case the Peter-Weyl theorem will not help and, as the reader can verify for himself from Lemma 2.1, none of the representations &(w, m,) of 4 induce unitary representations of Tf.T h e importance of T," in special function theory is related to the study of integral transforms and is beyond the scope of this book (see Vilenkin [3]).
CHAPTER
4 Lie Theory und Confluent Hypergeometric Functions
I n the last chapter fundamental properties of the cylindrical functions were deduced by relating those functions to the representation theory of 9(0,0). Here, analogous arguments will be used to study confluent hypergeometric functions as they relate to the representation theory of 9 ( 0 , 1). Besides treating the general confluent hypergeometric functions lFl(a; b; x), we shall also consider certain special cases: the Laguerre polynomials L,"(x), the parabolic cylinder functions DnE(x),and the Hermite polynomials H,(x). These special cases arise naturally. I n Section 4-11 we will introduce a real (global) Lie group S, whose Lie algebra is a real form of g(0, 1). We will examine the relationship between the irreducible representations of g(0, 1) and the unitary irreducible representations of S, . This study leads to addition theorems and orthogonality relations for the Laguerre polynomials. T h e problem of decomposing tensor products of unitary representations of S, into irreducible parts will also be considered. T h e solution of this problem leads to identities expressing the product of two Laguerre polynomials as a sum of Laguerre polynomials (Section 4-17), and as an integral over Bessel functions (Section 4-19). Furthermore, the product of a Laguerre polynomial and a Bessel function can be expressed as a sum of Laguerre polynomials (Section 4-20). Each of these expansions will be given an explicit group-theoretical interpretation. Finally in Section 4-21 we will use the fact that g(0,O) is a contraction of g(0, 1) to derive a formula for Bessel functions as limits of Laguerre polynomials.
4-1. THE REPRESENTATION R(w. m, , p)
79
Note: There is another real form of 9 ( 0 , 1) (the Lie algebra of all real matrices (1.30)), distinct from the one we consider here. A study of the representation theory of this new real form leads to integral identities involving confluent hypergeometric functions (see Vilenkin [3]). 4-1
The Representation R(w, m, , p)
The irreducible representation R(w, m, , p ) of 9 ( 0 , 1) is determined by complex constants w , m,, p such that p # 0, 0 Re m, < 1, and w + rn, is not an integer (Theorem 2.2). T h e spectrum of this representation is the set S = {m, n: n an integer},
<
+
and the representation space V has a basis {f,}, m E S, so that JYm J-fm
= (m
= mfm
+
Efm
9
w)fm-19
= pfm
9
= (J'J-
c,,,fm
J'fm
= tLfm+l*
- EJs)fm
= pwfm
-
(4.1)
The commutation relations satisfied by the infinitesimal operators are
[I3, 11'
=
&J*,
[I+,J-I
[I*, E]
--E,
=
=
[I3,E] = 0.
(4.2)
We will find a realization of this representation in such a way that the operators J*, J3, E become the linear differential operators (2.36) acting on a vector space of functions of one complex variable, z. Let the representation space Vl be the complex vector space consisting of all finite linear combinations of the functions h,(z) = zn,n = 0, f l , &2, ..., and set A = m, , cg = m, + w in Eqs. (2.36) to obtain the operators
on V l . Define the basis vectors m = m, n for all m E S. Then
+
JYm= (m,+ z
"1
of Vl by fm(z) = h,(z) where
fm
+ n) zn = mfm ,
zn = (m,
J+fm
= (pz) Z" = p ~ " + l= tLfm+l*
J-fm
=
Efm
( & + -)dzd Z
= tLfm
Zn =
(m
+ w ) zn-1
7
and we have a realization of R(w,m, , p).
=
(m
+w)
fm-l,
80
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
As in Chapter 3 we use this realization by differential operators to obtain a local multiplier representation of the local group G(0, 1) whose Lie algebra is 9 ( 0 , 1). The matrix elements of this local representation with respect to the basis { fm} will be confluent hypergeometric functions. Although the realization of R(w, m, , p) given above was constructed from the differential operators (2.36), it could also have been constructed from the operators (2.37). As far as the computation of matrix elements is concerned it makes no difference which operators we use. T h e matrix elements are uniquely determined by the Lie algebra relations (4.1) and do not depend on the particular realization of these relations. In Section 1-2 it was shown that 9(0,1) is the Lie algebra of the local Lie group G(0, 1):
We can extend the realization of R(w, m, , p ) defined on Vlto a local multiplier representation of G(0, 1) defined on a,, where QIl is the complex vector space of all functions of z analytic in some neighborhood of the point z = 1. Clearly 0, 3 Vl and QIl is invariant under the operators
According to Theorem 1.10, these operators generate a Lie algebra, isomorphic to 9(0,I), which is the algebra of generalized Lie derivatives of a multiplier representation A of G(0, 1) acting on QI, . We will compute the multiplier v explicitly. From the theorem, the action of the I-parameter subgroup {exp c f - , c E fZ'} of G(0, 1) on a, is obtained by solving the equations
_ dz - 1, dc
d
dc v(z0,
exp c f - )
m +w =0 v(z0, exp c$-) 2
with initial conditions z(0) = 9 # 0, v ( 9 , e) = 1. Here, e is the identity element of G(0, 1) and exp c f - is given by (1.33). The solution of the differential equations is
4-1. THE REPRESENTATION R(w, m, , p)
Thus, iff
E
81
GI, is analytic in a neighborhood of 20 then
and A(exp c f - ) f is an element of domain off. Similarly we obtain "exp
a, for
1 cjz" I < 1,
20
+ c in the
bf+)fI(z") = exp(PWf(z"),
' ) emoTf(eTz"), [A(exp ~ f ~ ) j ] ( z =
[A(exp a & ) f ] ( z o )= ewf(z").
If g E G(0, 1) has coordinates (a,b, c, g
= (exp
T)
it is easy to show that
bf+)(exp c$-)(exp
.f3)(exp a&).
Thus, for I c I, I T I sufficiently small, the operator A(g) acting on f E QI, is given by [A(g)fl(z) = M e x P by+) W X P c f - ) AlexP 7 f 3 )N e x P aS)fI(z)
T o make sense out of this expression we restrict g to the open set M C G(0, 1) where M = {g E G(0, 1): I c I < I}. As a local Lie group, M is isomorphic to G(0, 1). For everyfE 6Zllet D, be the domain off, i.e., the open set in containing 1, on which f is defined and analytic. Define W,(g), the domain ofg E M, by &?,(g) = { f Q~ I, : eT(1 c) E D,}. It follows from these definitions that for any g E M and f E W,(g) we have A(g) f E QIl, where A(g)f is given by (4.5). I n fact, DA(g)f = {z E G ': I c / z I < 1 and eT(z + c) E D,}, so 1 E DA(0)f. (The factor (1 ~ / z ) ~ o + in w (4.5) is defined by its Laurent expansion about z = 0.) The problem of properly defining the domain of the operator A(g) on QIl is analogous to the problem of defining the domain of an unbounded operator on a Hilbert space. We can given a precise interpretation of the representation property of the operators A(g) as follows: If g, ,g2 , g,g2 E M and f E QI, such that f E W,(gz) and A(g2) f E al(gl),then f E ~ d g 1 g z and )
c,
+
+
A(g1g2)f = A(g,)"g,)fl
Ea 1
-
(4.6)
The problem of properly interpreting (4.6) is analogous to the problem of defining the product of two unbounded linear operators on a Hilbert space.
82
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
The elements of V, are analytic for all z # 0 so for any f E V, , g E M , the expression A ( g ) f is well defined as an element of 02, . I n fact Da(p)f= { z E f2: I z I > I c I} 3 {I}. Consequently, if h E 7, then Dh = {I z I > dh} where dh is a constant such that 1 > dh 20. (Recall from Section 2-2 that 9, is the space of all finite linear combinations of functions of the form A ( g )f where g E M and f E 6 . By definition, 7, is invariant under A.) Thus, if h E 7, then h has a unique Laurent expansion m
h(z) =
1 anzn,
an€
n=--co
e:
which converges absolutely for all I z I > dh . According to the above results the subspace 9, is invariant under A, and the basis functions fnt(z)= h,(z) = zn,m = m, n, for *y; form an analytic basis for 7 , (see Section 2-2). As usual the matrix elements A,,(g) of the operators A ( g ) on TI are defined by
+
m
[A(g)hJ(z)
=
C
l=-m
At&) h i ( z ) ,
g E M , k = 0, &1,--.,
(4-7)
or
I c/z 1 < 1.
(4.8)
(4.9)
we obtain the addition theorem Atkk1g2)
m
C
=
Atj(g1) Ajk(g2),
I,
= 0,
*2,.** *
(4.10)
j=-m
Equation (4.9) is defined only for those group elements g , ,g , E M such that g,g, E M and A(g,)h, E W,(gl).However, we shall soon see that the matrix elements A,,(g) are entire functions of the complex group parameters (a,b, c, T) of g ; hence, the matrix elements can be defined by analytic continuation for all g E G(0, 1). Moreover, the group parameters of g,g, are entire functions of the parameters of g , and g , : &?,(a1 > 61 > C l
9
71)
= glg2(al
g2(a, > b,
9
c2
9
72)
+ a, + clb2eT5b, + eT1b2,c1 + e-'lc,
,T~ + T ~ ) . (4.11)
83
4-1. THE REPRESENTATION R(w, m o tp)
Thus, by analytic continuation the addition theorem (4.10) is valid for all g1 ,g, E G(0, 1). To derive an explicit expression for the matrix elements A,,(g) we expand the left-hand side of (4.8) in a Laurent series in z and compute the coefficient of z,. T h e result is
where the sum extends over all nonnegative integral values of s such that the summand is defined. For convenience we have set p = m, + W . Comparing with (A. 10) we have
*
Az,(g)
=
lFl(-p
exp[p
. ,F,(-p
-
I; K
-I
+ 1 ; -&)
if k 2 I ,
-K
+ 1; - 4 c )
if
+ (m,+ k M ( t ~ b ) ~ - ~ (1 --PY
-
K; I
12
(4.12)
K.
Here, p is not an integer. The functions are the confluent hypergeometric functions defined by their power series expansions. I t is clear from (4.12) that the matrix elements are entire analytic functions of the group parameters. Perhaps the most convenient form in which to express the matrix elements is in terms of the generalized Laguerre functions L r ) , (A. 15): A Zk (g)
= e ~ 5 + ( m o + k ) ~ ~ k - p+z Z L ( k (-pbc), -1)
k, 1 integers.
(4.13)
Substituting (4.1 3) in (4.8) and simplifying, we obtain the generating function e-clt(l
+t
m
)= ~
1 tlLjyL(c),
O < 1 t I < 1.
(4.14)
Z=-cc
#
Note that the Laguerre polynomials L t ) , n an integer, do not occur as matrix elements of R(w, m, , p). Laguerre polynomials will arise in the computation of matrix elements of TU,@ and la,,+to be considered later. We can obtain addition theorems for the Laguerre functions by substituting (4.13) into (4.10). After some simplification there results e-clbz(cl
+
c
+ b,)(c, + 4 1
m
=
j=--03
(Cl)j+n
L;j+"'[b,C,](c,)-jL;;;;,[b2C2]
(4.15)
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
84
where n is an integer, p is not an integer, and b, , b, following limits can be verified from (4.14): (0
if n if n
(-n)!
where n is an integer. Therefore, if (4.15), we obtain
, cl, c, E f2. T h e
> 0,
< 0, (4.16)
c1 =
b, = 0, c2 = 1, b, = x in
which is the power series expansion for the generalized Laguerre functions. If c1 = 0, c2 = 1, b, = x, b, = y in (4.15), one obtains
while for c1 = 1, c,
If c1
= -c,
=
=
1, b,
0, b, = x, b,
= x,
=y,
b, = -y we have
c (-1)jL;-")(x)L'-? W
eY (Y - x)" n!
=
p+3-n
(y),
n 3 0,
j=-m
and m
0=
1 (-l)jLbj+"'(x)L~;::,(y),
n
> 0.
j=-rn
As a final example, set c1 = c,
=
1, b,
= x,
b, = y to obtain
rn
e-VL;)[2(x
+ y ) ] = C L ~ + " ) (L:&( x) j=-
y).
4-2. THE REPRESENTATION
4 2 The Representation p
TU,@
85
tamp
The irreducible representation of 9(0,1) is defined for each @such that p # 0. The spectrum S of tw,@ is
W,
E
S
= {-w
and there is a basis { fm , m properties J Y m = mfm
=
J-fm
(m
+
3
+ n: n a nonnegative integer} E
S> for the representation space V with the Efm
wIfm-1,
= tLfm
G.1fm
J'fm
9
=
(J+J-
== tLfm+l>
- E J S ) f m = tLwfm
*
(Heref-,, = 0, so J-f-w = 0.) As in the last section, we can construct a realization of this representation such that J*, J3, E take the form of linear differential operators (2.36) acting on a space of functions of m e complex variable. Namely, we designate by Yzthe space of all finite linear combinations of the functions h,(z) = zn, n = 0, 1, 2, ..., and define operators on V2by setting X = -0, c3 = 0 in (2.36): J3
=
-W
+z-& d '
E
= I.19
J+ = pz,
J-
=
d dz .
(4.17)
The basis vectors fm of V2are defined byf,(z) = h,(z) = zn where m = --o n and n 2 0. These operators and basis vectors satisfy the relations
+
J Y = ~ (-w
zn
= (-w
+ n ) = ~ mfm, (4.18)
for all m E S. Relations (4.18) yield a realization of Tw,p. We can extend this realization to a multiplier representation of G(0, 1) defined on a,, the complex vector space of all entire analytic functions of z. Obviously, GZ2 is invariant under the operators (4.17) and contains Y2as a subspace. According to Theorem 1.10, the operators (4.17) induce a local multiplier representation B of G(0, 1) acting on the space of all functions analytic in a neighborhood of z = 0. However, it will turn out that B(g)fE OZz for all f~ GZz , g E G(0, l), so without loss of generality, we can restrict B to GZz .
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
86
Since the differential operators
+
are formally identical with the operators (4.2) for the case m, w = 0, the action of G(0, 1) on GZ, induced by these differential operators is obtained from the corresponding result (4.5) in Section 4-1 by setting m, = - w . Thus, we have operators B ( g ) defined for all g E G(0, I), such that [B(g)f](z) = e p ( b z + a ) - w f(eTz + eTc), (4.19) f E a, .
+
T h e multiplier v is given by v ( z , g ) = exp[pbz pa - w ~ ] Clearly, . if f E GY2 , i.e., iff is an entire function of z, then B(g)f is an entire function of z ; therefore the space is invariant under the operators B(g). Furthermore, the operators B(g) are defined on GZ, for all g E G(0, 1) and satisfy the representation property
a,
(4.20)
B(g1gz)f = B(g,)[B(gz)fl
for all f E GZ2 and all g, ,g , E G(0, 1). Equation (4.20) is a consequence of Theorem 1.10. However, it is simple to verify its validity directly. Thus, if g, and g, have coordinates ( a , , b, , c1 , T , ) and (a,, b, , c, , r,), respectively, then g,g, has coordinates ( a , a, eT1clb2, b, e%, , cl e-'lc,, r1 r,) and we find
+
B(g,"(g,)fl(z)
+
+ +
+
=
exp[CLb,z
= exp[p(b,
+ Pal
-
+
WT11[B(g2)fl(eT1z
e71c1)
+ e71b,)z + ~ ( a +, a2 + e'1clh) + (c +
- f(e(Ti+To)z
e(Ti+Tz)
1
4 7 1
+ .,>I
e-Tlc2)>
= [B(g1gz)fl(z) for all f E a,. Every function f in has a unique power series expansion
a,
m
f(z)
=
1 anz",
?l=O
an E
C,
convergent for all z E @. Thus, the basis functions h,(z) = zn,n 3 0, of V, form an analytic basis for a,. With respect to this analytic basis the matrix elements B,,(g) are defined by m
[B(g)h,l(z) =
C Bdg) ht(z),
1=0
g E G(0, 11, k = 0,1,2,***, (4.21)
la,+
87
1 B,,(g)zl. =o
(4.22)
4-2. THE REPRESENTATION
or, from (4.19), ep(bZ+O)+(k-wh
(z
+ 4,
W
=
1
T h e group property (4.20) leads to the addition theorem m
Bt,(g,gz)
=
C BtjW Bjkz),
Z 0, g19 g2 E G(O, 1)- (4.23)
1,
G O
T h e matrix elements B rk(g)are easily determined by expanding the left-hand side of (4.22) in a power series in z and computing the coefficient of 21. T h e result is
k, 1 2 0, (4.24) where the (finite) sum is taken over all nonnegative integral values of s such that the summand is defined. We can express these matrix elements in terms of known special functions. Comparison of (4.24) with (A. 10) yields
if l > k > , O .
T h e matrix elements can also be written in the convenient form B, , ( g) = e w z + ( k - w i . r C k - 2 ~ (1k - 1 )
(
-
I
4
9
k, 12 0,
(4.26)
where the functions Lp' are the associated Laguerre polynomials. Substituting (4.26) into (4.22) and simplifying, we obtain the generating function (4.27)
Note the great similarity between the expressions for matrix elements of t,, and the matrix elements of R ( w , m, , p ) given by Eqs. (4.12), (4.13). T h e matrix elements computed here can be obtained from the earlier results by setting p = 0 and restricting the indices I, k to nonnegative integral values.
88
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
I n accordance with our usual procedure, we can obtain identities for the associated Laguerre polynomials by substituting (4.26) into the addition theorem (4.23). T h e results are (after simplification)
(4.28) j-0
+
where n, I are integers, I >, 0, I n 2 0, and b, , b, , c1 , c2.€ C?. Comparing (4.26) and (4.24) we can easily derive the relations if n
CnL~)(bc)I,=,
=
I(
if n
> 0,
< 0,
(4.29) n + l c n
n
if n 2 0 , if n
0
< 0.
These relations can be used to derive identities for the associated Laguerre polynomials which are simple consequences of (4.28). Thus, if c1 = b, = 0, c2 = 1, b, = x, (4.28) reduces to
which is the series expansion for the associated Laguerre polynomials. For c, = 0, c2 = 1, b, = x, b, = y , Eq. (4.28) reduces to
and if c1
=
1, c, = 0,b, = x, b,
= y,
it becomes
4-3. T H E REPRESENTATION J,*+
For c1 -- -c,
=
1, b,
= x,
b,
89
the resulting expressions are
= --y
for all 1 2 n 2 0, and
for all
I, n 2 0. If c1
= c2 = 1, b, = x,
e-112nL'n)[2(x
b,
= y,
we obtain
+y)] = 1L y y x )L;+n-j'(y). m
j=O
4-3
The Representation
Jw,r
As was stated in Theorem 2.2, the irreducible representation lo,, of w , p E @ such that p # 0. T h e spectrum of I,,,,is the set S = {-w - 1 - n: n a nonnegative integer},
9(0,1) is defined for each
and there is a basis { fm , m J"fm
= mfm J-fm
9
Efm
= t.frn-19
E
S } for the representation space V such that J'fm
== -t.fm, Co,,fm
=
=
-(m
(J'J- - EJ3)fm
+ + l)fm+l, w
(4.30)
= -wfm-
(We setf-, = 0, so J+f--, = 0.) I t is impossible to find a realization of this representation in terms of differential operators of the form (2.36). I n fact, if J+ = pz it is impossible to find a nonzero analytic functionf-,,(z) such that J+f-,-, = 0. We could find a realization in terms of the operators (2.37). However, it is more convenient to use the following modification of (2.36):
As is easily seen, these operators satisfy the commutation relations (4.2), hence they generate a Lie algebra isomorphic to 9(0,1). We will define a realization of I,,, such that J*, J3, E take the form of the differential operators (4.31) acting on the vector space V,of all finite linear combinations of the functions h,(z) = z", n = 0, 1, 2, ... . Namely, we define the
90
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
basisvectorsf,of T h e n we have
Vzbyfm(z) = h,(z)
=
znwherem = --n
-
w -
1 E S.
for all m E S. Comparison with (4.30)shows that our choice of differential operators and basis vectors leads to a realization of J u . p . As in Section 4-2 we can extend this realization to a multiplier representation of G(0, 1) defined on the complex vector space B2of all entire analytic functions of z. Since the details of the computation are so similar to the computation for Iw+ it will be sufficient to merely list the results. T h e generalized Lie derivatives (4.31) induce a multiplier representation of G(0, 1) defined by operators C(g),g E G(0, l), on L I Z :
for all f E Bz, z E @. T h e representation property is
and the matrix elements C,,(g) are defined by
or
g E G(0, l), K 2 0.
T h e addition theorem for the matrix elements is
(4.34)
4-4. DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS FOR MATRIX ELEMENTS
91
From the generating function (4.34)we can obtain the following explicit formula for the matrix elements: C,,(g) = exp[p(bc
- Q) - (w
+k +
k, 1 3 0. (4.36)
l)T]bk-z Lik--”(-&),
We can derive addition theorems for the associated Laguerre polynomials by substituting (4.36)into (4.35).However, the resulting expressions are identical with expressions (4.28)derived in the last section, so we will omit this computation.
44
Differential Equations for the Matrix Elements
T h e individual matrix elements of the representations R(w, m, , p), , and J, are all entire functions of the complex group parameters a, b, c, T and can be considered as analytic functions on the group manifold of G(0, 1). Let GI[G(O, l)] or Ol for short, be the complex vector space of all entire analytic functions on G(0, 1). There is a natural action of G(0, 1) on GI as a transformation group. For every g’ E G(0, 1) we can define a linear operator P(g’):a + a by
t,,,
(4.37)
From this definition it is evident that P(glg2)f = P(gl)[P(g,)f] for all gi 9 g2 E G(0, 1). Clearly each of the matrix elements Ajk(g),Bjk(g),Cjk(g)computed above is a member of GI. Furthermore, the action of P on these matrix elements is easily determined. We have
c A,&’) m
[P(g’)A,,l(g)
= A,,(gg’) =
I=-m
A,Z(d,
j , k integers, m
[P(g‘)B,,I(g)= Bjd&)
1 B&’)
= I=O
j,
Bdg),
k nonnegative integers,
m
[P(g’)Cj,I(g)
=
Cjk(gg’) =
C Cldg’) Cjdg), z=o j , K nonnegative integers.
(4.38)
92
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Comparing these expressions with (4.7), (4.21), and (4.33) we see that for fixed j , the functions {Aik}form a basis for the representation R(o, m, , p), the functions {Bjk} form a basis for the representation t o , r , and the functions { c j k } form a basis for the representation J w , p . Therefore, the Lie derivatives J+, J-, J3, E defined on @ by
must satisfy the commutation relations (4.2), and their action on the matrix elements Ajk, Bjk, c j k must be given by
J3cjk(g) = ( - W J-Cjdg)
- 1 - k) Cjdg), = tLCi
k+l(g),
Co.1Cj&)
=
J+Cjkk) = k c j k--l(g)r
EC&) -PWCj&)
= -PCjdg),
(4.42)
for all nonnegative integers j, k.
These expressions yield recursion relations and differential equations for the matrix elements. To evaluate them we must compute the Lie derivatives J*, J3, E defined by (4.39). In terms of the usual coordinates (Q, b, c, T ) for elements of G(0, 1) the Lie derivatives will be linear differ-
4-4. DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS FOR MATRIX ELEMENTS
93
ential operators in these four complex variables. However, the confluent hypergeometric functions and Laguerre functions associated with the matrix elements Ai,, B j , , Ci,are functionally dependent only on the product bc of the group parameters. For this reason it is convenient to adopt new coordinates [a, I, c, r] where a, c, r are defined as before, but Y = bc. This new coordinate system is not uniquely defined over the whole group, but only for those group elements such that c # 0. If g E G(0, 1) has coordinates [a, Y , c, T] and
0
0
0
then the coordinates of gg‘ are [a
+ a’ + evcb‘, r (I + e-Tc’ +
b‘c’
1
+ eTb‘c ), c + e-qc’, + r 7
7’
3
in the new coordinate system. Using this result and the-definition (4.39) of the Lie derivatives, we obtain J+ = eTc
(a, a +ay ,
J-
=
e-7
a
a
r a (-aca + --j, c ar (4.43)
E = -aa ’
J 3 =z 7
C0,I
=r
a2
p
a +ar + c -ac ar ‘ m+c--- acaa a2
a2
a2
a2
ar aa
+
*
In terms of the new coordinates, A j , and B j , are given by A,,(g)
= e’a+(m,+P)sCX.-iL(~-;i) p+j
p = m,
(-PI),
+
w,
B,,(g) = e’a+(-w+k)rc~-jL(~-j) j (-P+
Substituting these expressions into (4.40), (4.41) and simplifying we obtain the relations
-aq y Y ) ar
- L ( y y )= -LW+l)(y), P
P
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
94
valid for p E @, k an integer. I n fact, these relations follow from (4.40) when p is not an integer and from (4.41) when p is an integer. Similar results can be derived for the matrix elements Cik(g).However, we will omit this computation.
4 5 The Representation to,,+,6I,,,,, As was demonstrated in Section 4-2, the representation Tw,, , p # 0, of 9 ( 0 , 1) can be realized on the space V, of all finite linear combinations of the basis functions hk(z) = zk, k = 0, 1, 2, ... . I n terms of this basis the matrix elements Bj;*")(g),g E G(0, I), are defined by (4.26). ( T h e superscripts have been added to denote the particular representation To,+ .) We will define a representation to,,,, Q To,,+, of 9(0,1) on the space V, @ V, of all finite linear combinations of the basis functions h,,,(z, w ) = z k w l ,k, 1 = 0, 1, 2,... . Note that Vz@ Vzis contained in the vector space GZ, Q GZ, consisting of all entire functions f ( z , w ) in the complex variables z and w . T h e functions hk,,(z,w ) form an analytic basis for GZz Q 02, since every element f of this space has a unique power series expansion
c m
f(Z,w ) =
UL1ZLW1,
E
@,
4
7
Ukl
k.l=O
convergent for all z, w E IT. T h e operators T(g), [T(g)fl(z, w )
= exp[b(plZ
+ pzw) - (ul +
+ eTc, e7w + eTc),
= g(u,
6 , c,
T)
E
( ~ 1
f~ aZ@ 02, ,
*f(e7z
where g
+ + PZ)QI (4.45)
G(0, l), clearly satisfy the group property
T(g,gz)f
= T(g1)"m)fl
for all g, ,g, E G(0, 1) and thus define a multiplier representation of G(0, I ) on Q GZ, . This multiplier representation of G(0, 1) induces a representation of "(0, 1) in terms of the generalized Lie derivatives
a,
J3 = - ~ 1- W Z
a +wa , +zaz aw
+
J' = p l ~
~ Z W ,
(4.46)
T h e representation of 9(0,1) on VzQ Vzdefined by these operators, which we denote t,,,,, @ f o e , r 2 , is not irreducible. We will decompose
4-5. THE REPRESENTATION
T,,, 0T,.,
95
V2@ V2into a direct sum of subspaces such that each subspace is irreducible under the action of Y(0, 1) as given by (4.46). Successful completion of this task will enable us to derive formulas expressing the product of two associated Laguerre polynomials as a sum of Laguerre polynomials. I n order to carry out this decomposition, however, we must require p, , p2 # 0, pl p2 # 0. Let Q[.,.] be the complex symmetric bilinear form on V2@ V2 defined by
+
for all a1 , u2 E @, f, ,f 2 ,f3 E V2@ V2. Equation (4.47) together with (4.48) completely determines Q. We will use this bilinear form as a _. bookkeeping device. Lemma 4.1 If J+, J-, f 2 E V2@ % , then
J3,
E are defined by (4.47) and f, ,
(i) Q[J”f, 9 f i l = Q[fi JYJ, Q[fi J-f21, (ii) Q[J+fl9fil (iii) Q P f I , f 2 3 = Q[fi Ef21. PROOF Properties (i) and (iii) are trivial. Since Q is bilinear, it is and sufficient for the proof of (ii) to consider the case wheref, -f2 = h,,,,, . From (4.47) we have 9
9
1
9
Q[J+h,.z , hk’.2’]
+
= Q[(P~z ~ 2 wzkw’, ) z“~”] = plQ[z”+’w’, z“w“]
which proves (ii).
+ p 2 Q [ ~ k ~z“w”] 2+1,
96
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
T h e bilinear form Q was defined by (4.47) just so Lemma 4.1 would be valid. We will decompose V2@ Y2into subspaces, each of which forms the basis space for a representation tw,rof 9(0,1). One way to determine this decomposition is to compute the eigenvectors f of J8 which are of lowest weight, i.e., the eigenvectors of J3 such that J-f = 0 where J8 and J- are given by (4.46). Thus, we look for solutions of the equations
a a +zaZ + w -)f(z, aw
J3f(z,W ) = (-q - w2
W)
= hf(z,w ) ,
where the eigenvalue h is to be determined. To within an arbitrary constant the solutions are the functions I n fact,
fs,o(z, w) J”fs.0
= (S
= (z - W ) * ,
- ~1
-4 f s . o
,....
(4.49)
= 0.
(4.50)
s = 0,1, 2 9
J-fs.0
From (4.47) and (4.49) it is a straightforward computation to obtain the result (4.51)
+
(Recall the assumption p1 p2 # 0.) We now define basis vectors f8.k E Y2@ V2 Iby fs.k =
(PI
(4.52)
k)-*(J’>kfs.~
for all integers s, k >, 0. It is easy to see that each function fs,k is a polynomial of order s k in z and w. Moreover, for every positive integer I there are exactly I 1 functions fs,k such that s k = I, i.e., there are I + 1 such functions which are of order I in z and w. Hence, if the set { fs,k} is linearly independent it forms a basis for V2@ v2and an analytic basis for @ .
+
+
a, a,
+
4-5. THE REPRESENTATION
twl+,0 tw2+
+
97
+
-
PROOF (i) J'-f8.k = (PI P2)-k((J')k+fs,o = (PI p2)fS.k+l 0 is easily proved (iii) The identity [J3, (J+)k] = k( J+)k for all K by induction. Then J"fd.k
>
+ = (pi + P~)-'(J+)~ + (pi + = + s + K)(A + = +s + -
= (PI
J3(J')"fs.o
~2)-'
J"fs.0
(-wi
"2
(-w1-
~2
1 1 2 ) ~4J')'fs.o ~
~2)-~(J+)~fs.o
h)fa,k
(iv) Obvious. (ii) We use induction on K. From (4.50), J-f,,, = 0, so the equation is vaiid for k = 0. Assume it is valid for K k, . Then J-fs,k,+i (pi ~2)-'J-J+fs,k,from property (i). But, J-J+ = J+JE, so from (I), (iv) and the induction hypothesis we have
7
<
+
+ = + (A+ = (ko + l)(/%+
J-J+fs.r, = J+J-fs.k,
koJ+fs.k,-l
Efs.k,
~2)fs.k~
/+)fs,k.
+
+
-.
Therefore, J-f8,k,+l = (KO l)fs.k,. Q.E.D. Lemma 4.2 implies that for a fixed value of s, the vectorsf,,, , K = 0, 1, 2, ..., form a basis for the representation fw,+02-8,rl+rl of 9(0,1) (compare Lemma 4.2 with Eqs. (4.18)). Thus, the action of G(0, 1) on the vectors f 8 . k is m
[T(g)fSJ(z, w )
=
z=o
B:p+Ws-s+l+*r) (g)fa.dz,w)*
A, s 2 0, g E G(O, I),
(4.53)
where the operator T(g) is defined by (4.45) and the matrix elements B\g+"*-8*~1+p~) (g)are given by (4.26) (w = w1 wp - s, p = pl p2).
+
+
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
98
Since
by (4.51), it is an easy induction argument to obtain Q [ f s , k , f s , k ] = Msk for all s, k 3 0. T h e property Q[J”f,,k ,f s ’ , k ’ ] = Q [ f y , ,kJ”fs,,k,] implies (S k - Sf - k’) Q [ f s , k , f s , , k , ] = 0. Hence, Q [ f s , k , f s * , ~ = * ] 0 Unless s k = s’ k’. If k > k’ it is obvious from (ii), Lemma 4.2, that (J-)kf,,,k, = 0 for all s‘ 3 0. Thus,
+ +
+
~ [ Jf~ W ~I=. (pl~+ p 2 ) - k Q[(J+)v~.~ J-~,.~~I (PI
+
~
for all S, S’ 2 0,
=0
2 QCfs.0 ) ~ (J-)’fs,.k’] ~
and Q[fs,k,f s ’ , k ’ ] = 0 unless k = k’. Collecting all these facts together, we have the lemma. Among other things Lemma 4.3 proves that the vectors { f s , k ) are linearly independent. Hence, by our earlier remarks they form a basis for V2Q “yz and an analytic basis for bY2 Q GT2. V, @ V, can be decomposed into a direct sum of subspaces
where Vi is the subspace spanned by the basis vectors {fs,k), k = 0, 1, 2,... . T h e VL transforms under g(0, 1) according to the irreducible representation fW1+WZ-s,Pl+pz . This decomposition induces an analogous decomposition of bY2 Q a,.
We define Clebsch-Gordan coefficients H(p1 , I ; p, ,j I s, k), nonzero o n l y i f s k = I + j , by
+
c
s+k
fS.k
=
1=0
WPLI 1; ‘2, 9
S
+ k - 1 I s, A)
h,,,+k-,
,
A, S 3 0, (4.54)
+
i.e., f, t ( ~w, ) = xjLi H(pl, I ; p 2 , s k - 1 I s, k ) z ~ w ~ + A~ -simple ~ . consequence of this definition and (4.47) is the relation Q [ f s . , t h,,J , =
I! j!
W1,1; t ~ ,j 2 I S, h ) 7 sj,s+k-t he2
,
k, S, L i 3 0-
(4.55)
4-5. THE REPRESENTATION fo,,,,,
0To,, ,
We can use this relation to invert Eq. (4.54). Since "v, @ V2we can write
Fall
h1.j =
a=O
f
1 . j a.Z+i-a
9
99
is a basis for
1,i 2 0,
. An easy computation using Lemma 4.3 gives
for suitable constants
Comparing (4.55) and (4.56) we have
and finally
h,j = 1 '+j
s=o
H(pl, 1; p a ,j 1 s, I + j - s) I! j ! fs.l+i-s 4~iZMs. l+j-s
-
(4.57)
I t is easy to obtain a generating function for the Gkbsch-Gordan coefficients directly from (4.53). I n fact, for k = 0 and g = exp 6$+ in (4.53) one obtains the generating function
m s+1
=
1 "("
1=0 i=O
17'
P2)GH(pl
,j ; p2 ,s + I
-
j 1 s, I ) zjw8fZ-j. (4.58)
Equating coefficients of 6' on both sides of this expression we find
(I*lz -tP2w)x( z - w)' P1 + P2
s+ k
= 5=0
H(pl ,j ; p 2 , 5
+ k -j
I s, k) ziWa+k-j
or
-
k! s! (pl
+
n k-n
s+n-i
PlP2 (-1) p 2 ) k : n! ( j - n)! (k - n)! (s -j
+ n)! , s + k -j 3 0, (4.59)
where the sum on the right-hand side is taken over all integral values of n such that the summand is defined. The Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are independent of w1 and w 2 .
100
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
These coefficients are closely related to the Jacobi polynomials. In fact,
.F(-k,
-s
- k +j ;j - k + 1; -pa/&) r(j - k 1)
+
(4.60)
where we adopt the convention (A. 5) on the right-hand side of this equation. If we apply the operator T(g),g E G(0, l), to both sides of Eq. (4.57) we obtain
The right-hand side of this expression can be expanded in terms of the basis vectors h l , k .Equating the coefficients of hl,kon both sides of the resulting expression we get
s=o
or
The reader can work out some of the special cases of this formula for himself.
4-6. A REALIZATION
OF R(w, m , , p)
101
The above analysis demonstrates in a particular case the close connection between the reduction of tensor products of group representations into irreducible parts and identities expressing products of special functions as sums of special functions. We could carry out the same analysis for the representations ,,J, 8J Y a l p a . However, this procedure would lead to no new results for the associated Laguerre functions, so we omit it. T h e method presented here for the reduction of a tensor product of representations works only if the tensor product can be decomposed into a direct sum of irreducible representations. In particular, representations of the form R(w1 9 m19 PI>(20 R(W2 9 m2 9 P.2) or Ll,, 8lw2,-, cannot be so decomposed and our procedure fails. However, when we consider unitary group representations in Section 4-18, we will be able to use the tools of functional analysis to obtain deeper results relating the properties of Laguerre functions to tensor products of group representations. 4-6
A Realization of R(w, rn, , p) by Type D’ Operators
I n the first four sections of this chapter the irreducible representations of 9(0,1) were realized on spaces of analytic functions of one and four complex variables. Now we will construct realizations on a space of two complex variables, x and y . In fact, we will study those realizations of irreducible representations of 9(0,1) such that the operators J*, J3, E take the form
a
73=5,
J*
= e*Y
(*axa -
where p is a nonzero complex constant. These are the type D’ operators defined in Section 2-7. (The constant q occurring in the expression for the type D’ operators can be set equal to zero without any loss of generality.) T o begin with we construct a realization of R(w, m, ,p) (0 Re m, < 1, p # 0, and m, w is not an integer). Thus, we look for nonzero functionsf,(x, y ) = Zm(x)emvsuch that
+
<
102
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
+
for all m E S = {m, n: n an integer}, where the differential operators J*, J3, E are given by (4.64). In terms of the functions Zm(x), relations (4.65) reduce to (i)
d (z - h) Zm(4
= PZrn+l(X)I
T h e complex constant w is clearly irrelevant as far as the study of the special functions 2 , is concerned, since we could remove it by relabeling Hence, without loss of generality we can the functions 2, = ZA+o. assume w = 0. Also, there is no loss of generality for special function theory if we set p = 1 . The solutions of Eqs. (4.66) are well known. As remarked in Section 2-7, (iii) is the parabolic cylinder equation and its solutions are the parabolic cylinder functions D,(x), see (A. 16). In fact, for all m E S the following choices for Z, satisfy (4.66):
(4.67) Since w = 0 we must have 0 < Re m, < 1; hence, the elements m of S are not integers. I t follows from the above discussion that if the functions 2, , m E S, are given by either (1) or (2) in (4.67), then the functions f m ( x , y ) = Zm(x)emg form a basis for a realization of the representation R(0, m, , 1) of g(0, 1). By Theorem 1.10 this representation of Y(0, 1) by Lie derivatives can be extended to a local multiplier representation of G(0, 1). Thus, if we denote by 62 the space of all entire analytic functions of x and y, the operators (4.64) will uniquely define a multiplier representation T of G(0, 1) on GT. We will compute the induced multiplier representation in the usual manner. Since J+ = ev( ajax - ax) it follows that [T(exp b % + ) f ] ( x , eV) = Y ( X , ev, exp b / + ) f [ x ( b ) , bE/Z1,
fEGK
where d db
- x(b) = e y @ ) , d db
d dby(b) = 0,
-Y ( X , ev, exp b f + ) = - $x(b) ev(%(x,
ey,
exp b y + )
4-6. A REALIZATION OF R(w, m , , p)
103
= x , y(0) = y , ~ ( x ew, , e) =
1. T h e solution is
with initial conditions x ( 0 )
where t = ev. Similarly we find [T(exp c $ - ) f ] ( x , t) = exp
-xt-’c )f(x
- ct-1, t),
2
As mentioned in Section 4-1, i f g E G(0, 1) has parameters (a,b, c, T) then g = (exp b$+)(exp cf-)(exp .f3)(exp
a&).
Thus, T(g)f
=
T(exp b y + ) T(exp c$-) T(exp T $ ~ )T(exp aE)f
for all f~ a. Direct computation gives
.f(x
+ bt - ct-l, eTt) (4.68)
a.
for all g E G(0, l), f E (Note that t = ev # 0.) According to Section 2-2 the matrix elements of the operators T(g) with respect to the basis vectors fnL(x,t ) = Zm(x)tmare given by the matrices A,,(g), Eq. (4.13) ( w = 0, p = 1). This follows from the fact that the functionsf,, satisfy condition ( B ) . Thus, we obtain the relations
valid for all g E G(0, l), or exp
(-
t2b2- xtb - x t - l c 2 2 ~
+ t-2c2 -)bc2 -
D,(x
+ bt - ct-’)
a
(-c)-zL(-l)(-bc) m+l
= I=--m
Dm+L(x)ti, if
Zm(x) = (-l)”-m~Dm(x). (4.70)
104
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Various special cases of these relations are worth investigating. If we set c = 0, t = 1, and make use of the limits (4.16) we obtain exp
b2 - -)xb D,(x -
(-
4
(-b)' Dm+dX)* + b) = C 7
2
z=o
If x = 0 this relation becomes
1, Eq. (4.70) reduces to
For b = 0, t
=
and, for x
0, to
=
4 7 A Realization of Iw,, by Type D' Operators
To obtain a realization of the representation I,,, of 8(0,1) by type D' operators acting on CZ it is necessary to find nonzero functionsf,(x, y) = Zm(x)emv( m = --w k, k 2 0) such that
+
JYm
= mfm
Efm
= Pfm Co.1fm
where
a
J3=3j9
J'fm
9
=
(J+J-
= Pfm+l
t
- EJ3)fm ==
(
J-fm Pwfm
"
J* = efv f- - &px ,
ax
= (m
+
w)fm-1,
(4.71)
9
E
= p.
In terms of the functions Z,(x) these relations take the form (4.66) where, as remarked earlier, without generality we can assume w = 0, p = 1. Thus,
(4.72)
(-
d2 xe 1 p +- - - m) Zm(x) = 0,
4
2
4-7. A REALIZATION OF
tw+
105
m = 0, 1, 2, ... . We can use these relations to explicitly compute the functions Z,(x). In fact, the relation J-fo = 0 implies
which has the solution Zo(x)= c exp(-xX2/4), c E fZ'. Choose For m > 0 we define the function Z,(x) by
c =
1.
zm(x) emu = fm(x9 Y ) = (J+)"fo(x, Y ) = (J+)"(zO(x)).
A straightforward induction argument yields zm(x) = exp
cf)
am
Gexp
(-
X2
T),
m = 0,1,2
,....
(4.73)
At this point we have found functions f m ( x ,y ) = Zm(x)emv, m 2 0, such that J3fm = mfm J+fm = f m + l , J-fo = 0. 9
We can then proceed exactly as in the proof of Theorem 2.2 to show that these functions must actually satisfy all the relations (4.71) for w = 0, p = 1. Hence, the functions Z,(x) defined by (4.73) are the solutions of (4.72). The Z,n(x) are easily expressed in terms of parabolic cylinder functions or Hermite polynomials H,(x). In fact, Zm(x) = (- 1)" D,(x) = (- 1)" exp( -x2/4) 2-m~2H,,,(2-1~2x),
m
= 0, 1, 2
,....
(4.74)
According to the above discussion the functions fm(x, y ) = Zm(x)emv, m 2 0,form a basis for a realization of the representation . As usual this representation of B(0, 1) can be extended to a multiplier representation T of G(0, 1) on a. The action of the operators T(g) has already been determined and is given by (4.68). T h e matrix elements of this representation with respect to the analytic basis {f,} are the functions B,,(g) computed in Section 4-2 ( w = 0, p = 1). Thus, we have m
[T(g)f,l(x, t ) =
1 B&) z=o
fi(x, t ) ,
K
= 0,1, 21.-,
or exp
(-
t2b2
-
xtb - xt-lc 2
~
2
+t-v
-
-)bc2
D,(x
+ bt - ct-1)
t'(
(4.75)
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
106
where t = eu. This last relation is valid for all b, c, x, t E fi?such that t # 0. I n terms of the Hermite polynomials H,,,(x)
=
exp(x2/2)2m/2Dm(21/2~),m
= 0,
1,2, ...,
Eq. (4.75) takes the form exp( - t W - 2xtb)Hk(x+ bt - ct-1)tk If c
=
0, t
=
m
=
1
(-bc)H,(x)tl.
(-c)k-lLi*-l)
(4.76)
1=0
1, this equation reduces to
and in the special case K
=
0, b = - y , it becomes (4.77)
which is a well-known generating function for the Hermite polynomials. Finally, when b = 0, t = - 1, Eq. (4.76) reads
We could find a realization of the representation I,,, using type D' operators in exact analogy with the procedure for tw,,. However, this construction will be omitted since the analysis leads to no new information about special functions. 4-8
Transformations of Type
C'
Operators
T h e type C' operators classified in Section 2-7 take the form
a
Js=6,
J i = e i . ( + - - - - - -a+ + P )l , a
ax
xay
4
E=p
(4.78)
x
where q, p E @, p # 0. (Without loss of generality, the constant p in the expression for the type C' operators can be set equal to 0.) These operators generate a complex Lie algebra isomorphic to g(0, 1). I n analogy with Section 4-6 we try to find a realization of the representation R(w, m, , p), where now the operators J*, J3, E have the form (4.78).
4-8. TRANSFORMATIONS OF TYPE C' OPERATORS
Thus, we look for nonzero functions fm(x, y ) {m, + k: k an integer}, such that JYm J-fm
= (m
= mfm
+
9
u)f-1*
Efm
,
= pfm Co,,fm
2
J+fm
(J'J-
=
107
Zm(x)emu, m E S =
= /tfm+l,
- EJ3)fm
= pufm
(4.79)
where the differential operators are given by (4.78). As was shown in Section 2-7, the functions Z,(x) must satisfy the equation
= pwZm(x),
111 E
s.
T h e solutions of this equation are called the functions of the paraboloid of revolution, ErdClyi et al. [l], Vol. 11, p. 126. I n particular, one such solution is (x2/4)' exp(-x2/8)
Pi(5 - 7
+ 4 ;25 + 1; x2/4)
+ +
where 4 = &(m - q) and 77 = $ p ( m q 2w integer there is a linearly independent solution (x2/4)-6exp( -x2/8) IFl(-5 - 7
+ 1). If m - q is not an
+ 4 ;- 25 + 1;xa/4).
Expressed in terms of generalized Laguerre functions, there are linearly independent solutions (1) (xa/4)' exp(--x2/8)Lf!i-+(xa/4) (2) (x2/4)4exp( -x2/8) Li;!5)+(x2/4).
and (4.80)
If we wish to study directly the properties of the confluent hypergeometric functions (or the generalized Laguerre functions), however, it is more convenient if we can find differential operators whose eigenfunctions are of the form
We shall transform the type C' operators into a new set of differential operators to bring about this desirable situation. To begin with we assume w = 0, p = 1. (As far as special function theory is concerned this is no loss of generality.) Then, the first solution (4.80) is f,,l(u, t ) = u-q/2e-U/2L (m-q) (u)tm where the variables u, t are defined by u = x2/4, t = eux/2. Denote by F the space of all functions
108
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
analytic in a neighborhood of the point (uo, 20) = (1, 1) and define the transformation cp of 9onto F by [cpfl(u,t) = u-Q/2e--u/2f(u, t ) , f E S. We can consider the mapping cp to be multiplication by the function y(u, t) = u-QJ2e--uJ2. This mapping is invertible with inverse cp-' defined by [cp-'fl(u, t) = u+Q/2e+u/2f(u, t). Under cp-l the basis function fm(u, t) defined above is mapped into [cp-lfm](u,t) = Lim-Q)(u)tm, which is in the desired form (4.81). If J is a linear differential operator on 9define the linear differential operator p on F by p(cp-If) = ( ~ p - ~ J c p ) ( < p - I f) = q+(J f) for all f E 9, i.e., p = (p-lJv.As a consequence of this definition we have
Properties (2) and (3) are trivial. Q.E.D. Thus the map J-. Jv' is a Lie algebra isomorphism. If
a a I =fW),, +fZ(%t),
+f3(%t),
fl I f 2 , f 9 E S ,
an explicit computation gives
(4.82)
where ~ ( ut), = u-Q/2e--u/2, y-l(u, t) = uQ/2eU/2. (Although we have made a special choice for q ~ ,Lemma 4.4 and Eq. (4.82) are clearly valid for any nonzero function y in F.)
4-9. TYPE C' REALIZATIONS OF R(w, m , , p)
109
Armed with these facts, we can compute the operators (J3)v, (J*)(P, (E)q where J3, J*, E are given by (4.78) ( p = 1). In terms of the coordinates u, t (u = x2/4, t = eYx/2), the results are (J')"
a
= t -at,
(E)V = 1 ,
As an example we verify the computation of (J+)v. Under the change of variables from (x, y) to (u, t), J+ becomes
Moreover,
Therefore,
T h e other relations are proved similarly. 49
Type C' Realizations of R(w, m , , p)
-
By construction the differential operators (4.83) generate a Lie algebra isomorphic to 9(0,1). These operators can be used to find a realization of the representation R(w, m, , p ) on F.Thus, we look for nonzero functions fnl(u,t) = Zm(u)tmdefined for all m E S = {m, k, k an integer}, such that relations (4.79) are valid. Here the differential operators are given by (4.83) and the superscript cp has been omitted. (There is no loss of generality for special function theory if we set o = 0, p = 1.) In terms of the functions Z,,(u) these relations are
+
110
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
for all m E S. The solutions of these equations are generalized Laguerre functions or, what is the same thing, confluent hypergeometric functions. Indeed, for all m E S the choice
zm( u ) = (-l)m-m,L(m-q) Q
(4
(4.85)
satisfies (4.84), see (A. 13). (It is left to the reader to find additional solutions.) Since w = 0 we must have 0 < Re m, < 1, so the elements m of S are not integers. I n the special case where m, - q is an integer the functions (4.85) have been obtained as matrix elements of representations R(o,m, , p). However, when m, - q is not an integer these functions do not occur as matrix elements. The above remarks have established the fact that the functions fm(u, t) = Z,,(u)t", m E S, form a basis for a realization of the representation R(0, m,, 1) of 3 ( 0 , 1) if the Z,(u) satisfy (4.84). I n the usual manner this realization can be extended to a local multiplier representation T of G(0, 1) on the space .F. According to Theorem 1.10 and relations (4.83), the local multiplier representation takes the form
for f E .F. If g E G(0, 1) has parameters ( a , b, c,
T),
then
T(g) = T(exp by+) T(exp c j - ) T(exp ~ $ 3 ) T(exp a&)
and [T(g) fI(u, t )
=
eaPbt(1 - c / t ) - q f [ ( u + b t ) ( l
-
c / t ) ,eT(t - c)]
(4.87)
for I c j t j < 1, ~ E The F .matrix elements of T(g)with respect to the analytic basis { f J u , t) = Zn,(u)tm},(4.85), are the functions A,,&) defined by Eq. (4.13), ( W = 0, p = 1). (The fact that this basis is analytic follows from (2.2) and the t dependence of the basis functions.) Thus,
4-10. TYPE C' REALIZATIONS OF
to,l
111
which simplifies to the identity
+ c/t)pL:)[(u + bt)(l + c / t ) ] = 1 c - l L ~ ~ ~ + , ( b c ) L : p + l ) ( u ) t l , I c / t I < 1, p , q E @, p + q not an integer. (4.89) a3
e-bt(l
Z=-m
Using the limits (4.16) we can investigate two special cases of this identity: If c = 0, t = 1, there follows L r ) ( u + b ) = eb
(-b)l
OD
-L:"fl)(u),
I!
1=0
while if b = 0, t = 1, there follows m
(1
+ c)pLy[u(l + c)] = 1
Ic I < 1.
(PTQ) c'L';-yu),
1-0
410 Type
C'
Realizations of
To,l
T o obtain a realization of the representation
to,lof 8(0,1) by operators
acting on .F we must find nonzero functions fm(u, t) m = 0, 1, 2,..., such that
=
Z,,,(u)tm,
-
Efm
J Y m = mfm
J-fm = mfm-1
v
fm
Co.1fm
==
J+fm
(J'J-
=fm+lp
- EJ3)fm
(4.90)
=0
for all m 2 0. (We assumef-, = 0.) Conditions (4.90) will be satisfied if and only if the special functions Z2n(u),m 2 0, satisfy the equations d (z - 1) &&) (-u
= Zm+1(4,
dZ
- + (q - m du2
(-u-&
-
I
d
-m
+ 41
= m&n-,(u),
+ u)- q ) ~ , ( u ) = 0. du d
(4.91)
(Here, Z-,(u) = 0.) Equations (4.91) determine the functions Z,, to within an arbitrary constant. Thus, the relation J-fo = 0 implies
112
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
+
q) Zo(u)= 0, which has the solution Zo(u) = cup, c an arbitrary constant. To normalize our solution we set c = 1. For m > 0 the functions ZnL(u)can be defined recursively by Zm(u)tm= fm(u,t ) = (J+)mfo(u,t ) = (J+)mZo(u). A straightforward induction argument yields ( - u d/du
m = 0 , 1 , 2,....
By definition the functionsf,(u, JYm =
mfm
t), m J'fm
i
(4.92)
> 0, satisfy the relations J-fo = 0.
=f m i l v
However, it follows immediately from the proof of Theorem 2.2 that thef,,, must actually satisfy all of the relations (4.90), and the functions Z,(u) must satisfy all the equations (4.91). The special functions 2, are conveniently expressed in terms of associated Laguerre polynomials I.:), m a positive integer. In fact,
,... .
Zm(u)= m! U ~ - ~ L : - ~ ' ( U )m , = 0, 1,2
(4.93)
This realization of 9(0,1) can be extended to a multiplier representation T of G(0, 1) on where the action of the operators T(g),g E G(0, 1) is given by (4.87). The matrix elements of T(g)with respect to the analytic basis {f,} are the functions B,,(g) studied in Section 4-2 (w = 0, p = 1). Thus, W
[T(g)fk](u, t ) =
1 Bzk(g)fz(u, t ) ! z=o
k
= 0,
1,2,---*
which leads to the identities k ! e-bt(1
+ b t / ~ ) q - ~ L ; - ~ ) [+u (bt/u)(l l - c/t)]tk (4.94)
valid for all b, c, t, u , q E @ such that I btju I < 1. Making use of the limits (4.29) we can derive some simple consequences of (4.94). For c = 0 , u = 5,
and, setting k = 0 in this expression we obtain a well-known generating function for the associated Laguerre polynomials:
+b ) = ~ C bW J - I ) ( u ) , m
e-bu(1
z=o
qE
c,
I b 1 < 1.
4-11. THE GROUP S,
When b
=
0, u
= t,
113
Eq. (4.94) becomes Ljp’(u - c )
=
c -L‘9+”(u). I! IC
1=o
cl
k--l
We could also use the type C‘ operators to find a realization of the representation lo,r. However, the identities for Laguerre polynomials obtained from such a realization are just (4.94) again, so this analysis will be omitted. In Chapter 5 we will derive additional identities for the Laguerre functions by relating these functions to the representation theory of sZ(2).
411 The Group 5, S, is the real 4-parameter Lie group of matrices 1 4e-%Z
<
+
where w = x iy E fZ‘, 0 multiplication law for S, is R{W,a,
a> * g@’,
= g lw
+i6 - weUj8 (4.95)
0 01
< 27r, (mod 27r), and 6 is real. The group
a’,8‘)
+ e-iw’, a + a’,6 + 6’ + s2 (iik.o’e-ia - w5’efiu)/.
(4.96)
Thus, g{O,O, 0} is the identity and the inverse of a group element is given by g-’{w, a,6) = g{ -e%, -a, -6). (4.97) As a basis for the real Lie algebra 0
-i/2
0
Y4of S , we can choose the elements
0
0
(4.98)
0
with commutation relations
K
= 1,2,3.
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
114
T h e 3 x 3 matrices
y*
=
%+, ,f-,
Tf2
8,
f3,
+ iYl,
2 3
=i
8
f3,
=
-i9,
must then satisfy the commutation relations [/3,
y*1 = hy*,
[Y+, /-I
=
-8,
[B,/'I
=
[E, 3 3 1 = 0.
Clearly, the complex Lie algebra generated by the basis elements (4.98) is 9(0,1). Thus 9(0,1) is the complexification of yk and 9, is a real form of 9(0,1) (see Section 3-5). Due to this relationship between the two Lie algebras, the abstract irreducible representations R(o,m, , p), I,,, , and Lw,, of 9(0,1) induce irreducible representations of .u?, . We shall investigate which of these irreducible representations of Y4can be extended to an irreducible unitary representation of S, on a Hilbert space. The technique for carrying out this investigation was discussed in Section 3-6 and applied to the real Lie group E3 in Section 3-7.
4-12
Induced Representations of Y4
As in Section 3-6 we consider a unitary irreducible representation U of S4on a Hilbert space X and define the infinitesimal operators J1 , J 2 , J3 9 Q by
for all f E B. Here, B is a dense subspace of X satisfying properties (3.45) and (3.46). On 9 these operators obey the commutation relations
[JI J21 = tQ, 9
[J3 Ji1 = I2 9
[J3 Jz]
=
-Ji
9
[Jk
k
3
Ql = 0,
=
1,2,3,
follows immediately from (4.99). Moreover, the operators J*, J3, E defined by J* = J2 + iJ1, J3 = iJ, , E = -iQ (4.101)
as
satisfy the commutation relations
[J+, J-I
=
-E,
[J3, J*]
=
iJ*, [J*, El
hence, these operators determine a representation algebra 9(0,1) on 9.
=
p
[J3, El
= 0;
of the complex Lie
4-12. INDUCED REPRESENTATIONS OF 9,
115
We shall first investigate which of the representations R(w, m, , p) of 9(0,1) can be induced by p on some dense subspace 9'of 9.According
to Lemma 3.1 we must have
k = 1,2939 -
f, h )
=
can write these conditions in the form
<J+f,hh) =
<J3f,hh>=
,
<Ef,hh)
=
(f, Eh)
(4.102)
for all f, h E 9.T h e representation R(w, m, ,p) is determined by the relations JYm J+fm
= mfm
=dm+l
=d m
Efm
9
J-fm
(m
1
+
<
+
9
(4.103)
w)fm-i
where p # 0,O Re m, < 1, m = m, k and k runs over the integers. We will assume that the basis vectors fn, are in 3 and use conditions (4.102) to find restrictions on w , p, and m, . Thus, M
= (JYm
,fn>
=
<
fm > JYn)
= n
9
fn),
(4-104)
or (6- n) ( fm ,fn) = 0 for all m, n in the spectrum of J3. Setting n = m, we can conclude that m is real, hence I m m, = 0. If m # n we have
,fm>
= <J+fm-I
,fm>
= (fm-19
J-fm>
+
=
(m
+
wI(fm-1
jfrn-1)
(4.105)
implies 0 < If, lz/\fm-l l2 = ( m w ) / p for all m E S. Since this last condition can never be satisfied for all m E S it follows that none of the irreducible representations R(w, m, ,p) of 9(0,1) are induced by unitary representations of S , . However, we shall have better luck with the representations tw,, of 9 ( 0 , l), determined by conditions (4.103) where now p # 0, o is arbitrary, and m = - w k where k runs over the nonnegative integers. As in the preceding case, in order that the operators (4.103) be obtained from a unitary representation of S, we must require (i) 0. From (3.46) we can show U(exp ay.)f m = exp( -ia J3))fm = cfmY,,,
+
+
116
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
for all m in the spectrum of J3. Since exp 27rY3= exp 0 = e (the = 1 for all m in the specidentity element of s,),we must have rZrim trum of J3. Thus, m and w must be integers. If we define new basis vectors jk by
K = 0 , 1 , 2 ,..., it is a simple consequence of conditions (i) and (iv) that (jk,jk,) = b S,,,, for all k, k’ >, 0, where b is a positive constant which without loss of generality can be set equal to 1. We can draw the following conclusions from this analysis: Any irreducible representation t,,, of ”(0, 1) induced by a unitary representation U of S, must be such that w is an integer and p > 0. Furthermore, the vectors form an orthonormal basis for H and satisfy the relations
Gk}
for all k >, 0 (j-l= 0). Conversely, we will soon show that each such representation (4.106) induces a unitary irreducible representation U of S, on a Hilbert space. A similar analysis proves: If the irreducible representation of ”(0, 1) is induced by a unitary representation of S, then w is an integer, p > 0 and there is an orthonormal basis Gk}, k = 0, 1, 2,..,,for satisfying the relations
for all k >, 0 (j-l= 0). Conversely we will show that each such representation (4.107) induces a unitary irreducible representation of S, on a Hilbert space. From (4.95) and (4.98) it is easy to verify the relations expyY1 = g{iy, 0, 0}, exp xY2 = g{x, 0, 0}, exp a f 3 = g{O, a,0}, and exp 6 1 = g{O, 0, S} for x, y, a, 6 real. If w = x iy it follows from (4.96) that is g{w, a,S} = (exp xYz)(exp yY,)(exp aY3)(exp(S XY/4)9). Thus, uniquely determined by the elements Yl, Y 2 Y , 31 , of 9,and according to Eqs. (3.46), the operators U(g), g E S , are uniquely determined by the infinitesimal operators J1 , J2 , J3 , Q defined by (4.100). The irreducible representations (4.106) and (4.107) uniquely determine the unitary representations from which they are derived. Before proceding with the determination of the irreducible unitary representations of S, it is useful to examine a realization of the represen-
+
+
s,
4-13. THE HILBERT SPACE 9
117
tation to,l of .Y4which is of importance in quantum mechanics: the occupation number space formalism for bosons. Let iX? be a complex Hilbert space with orthonormal basis vectors 1 n), n = 0, I, 2, ... . On &? we consider the annihilation operator a and its adjoint, the creation operator a+, defined by a 1 n) =
1 n - l),
a+ I n) = (n
+ 1)1/2 1 n + l),
n = 0, 1,2,..., (4.108)
and linearity. The number-of-particles operator N is defined by N = a+a and has the property NIn)=nln),
n = 0 , 1 , 2 ,....
(4.109)
As the names of the operators suggest, the eigenstates I n) of N are interpreted as eigenstates of n bosons. The vacuum or no-particle state is 10). From their definitions it is easy to verify that the four linear operators a, a+,N,I, (I is the identity operator on X ) satisfy the commutation relations [N, a+] = a+,
[a+,a] = -1,
[N, a] = -a,
[a+,I] = [a,I] = [N, I] = 0.
(4.1 10)
Comparison of Eqs. (4.106) and (4.108)-(4.110) shows that the occupation number space formalism gives a realization of the representation to,l of 9(0,l), hence, of Y4. In Section 4-14 this representation will be extended to a unitary representation of S, .
4 1 3 The Hilbert Space .F Our aim is now to extend the representations (4.106), (4.107) of 9, to unitary irreducible representations of S, . For this purpose we first define the Hilbert space 9on which these representations will operate. S is the space of entire analytic functions f of the complex variable t such that
+,
where d ( ( t ) = w-1exp( -lit)& dy, t = x + and the domain of integration is the complex plane. Every function f E .F can be expanded uniquely in a power series f(t) = x z = O a n t nwhich converges everywhere. The inner product (., .) is
=
Jfow&(th
f,
E
.F.
(4.1 11)
118
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
It is easy to see that the functionsj,(t) = P / ( ~ z !n) = ~ /0, ~ ,1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal basis for 9. I n fact, introducing polar coordinates t = reie, we have 1
eih-n'NJ
dB
I
m
p+n'+l
exp( - y 2 ) dr.
0
(4.1 12)
For any two functions f(t) = C antn and h(t) =
c
C b,tn
in 5 we find
m
(f,h )
=
(4.113)
n! inbn
n=O
and (4.1 14)
From (4.114), an entire function f is an element of 9 if and only if m l2 < CL). Equation (4.112) shows that the vectors G,} are orthonormal while (4.114) shows that they are complete; hence, they form an orthonormal basis for 9. T h e space 9 was introduced by Segal [I] and studied in detail by Bargmann [3,4]. We mention here some of the special properties of this space.
z n s o n ! I a,
I. Define the function e b E 9 for some complex constant b by xz=o(6t),/n!. It follows from (4.1 13) that for any f E 9,
e,(t) = exp(6t) =
(eb,.f> =
m
1 bnan = f ( b ) ,
(ea
eb>
= eb(b) = exp(6b).
n=O
Thus, eb acts like a delta function. Use of the vectors eb will greatly simplify the computations to follow. 11. Define the norm of a vector f E 9 by llfll = ( f , f ) ' / 2 . From the Schwarz inequality, I f(b)l = I<eb,f > ~ II e b II IIf II = exp@b,Q)IIf II. Thus, iff, h E 9,then I f ( b ) - h(b)l exp(6b/2) 11 f - h 11 which shows that convergence in the norm of 9 implies pointwise convergence, uniform on any compact set in C. 111. Finally, we quote without proof a theorem from Bargmann [3] which will be needed to justify several of our computations. Let Rk be
<
<
4-14. THE UNITARY REPRESENTATION (A, I )
119
k-dimensional real Euclidean space and Cm be m-dimensional complex space. We are concerned with integrals of the form
where D is a measurable set in Rk and z = (zl ,..., zm)is a point in an open set 8 of Cm. Assume that, for every z in a neighborhood N(lz, - bi 1 < pi) of the point b in 8, f is analytic in z for every 7 , measurable in T, and If(z,~)l< v(T),
I zj - bj I < Pi
9
where 7 is summable over D . Then F(z) is analytic in N, and its partial derivatives are obtained by differentiating under the sign of integration, the resulting integrals being summable. I n the following computations we freely interchange summation and integration without explicitly constructing the appropriate ~ I ( T ) .
4-14
The Unitary Representation (A, I )
We will now verify that all of the representations To+ of g(0, 1) with an integer and p > 0 induce unitary irreducible representations of S, . T o find these representations of S , note that for w an integer the multiplier representation (4.19), induced by to,+, depends on the parameter T only in the form e‘:
w
[B(g)f](z) = efi(br+a) (e7)-f(eTz
+ eTc),
f E @,
(4.1 15)
where g E G(0, 1) has parameters ( a , b, c, T). (If w is not an integer (eT)-w is not a single-valued function of eT.) Thus, the operators B(g) define a multiplier representation. of the 4-parameter matrix group G(0, 1)‘ with elements ceT
0
0
(4.1 16) 1
The matrices (4.1 16) are obtained from expression (4.4) for the matrices
of G(0, 1) by eliminating the last row and column. G(0, 1)’ is not simply connected. I n fact, g’(a, b, c, T ) = g’(a, b, c, T 27~i).However, G(0, 1) and G(0, 1)’ are isomorphic as local Lie groups, i.e., they have isomorphic
+
Lie algebras.
120
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Comparison of (4.95) and (4.1 16) shows that S, can be considered as the real subgroup of G(0, 1)' consisting of all matrices g'(a, b, c, T ) such that Re 7 = 0, b = -t, and Re(-bc/2 + a ) = 0. Thus, g{w, a,S}
= g(i8 - w6/8,-w/2,5/2, -;a)
where w E fZ', 0 Q OL < 27, (mod 27), and 6 is real. Since S, can be embedded as a subgroup of G(0, 1)' we can obtain a global multiplier representation for S, by restricting the operators B(g), (4.115), to the group elements g in S,: [B(g)f](z)
= exp[p(-wz/2'+
i8 - &/8)
+ i u ~ ~ ] f ( e -+~e-"G/2), z
(4.117)
defined for every entire analytic function f and every element g in S, with parameters {w, 01, S}. It will be convenient to write this expression in a slightly different form. T o emphasize the fact that p and w can assume only restricted values we set p = I > 0 and w = h where h is an integer. Further, we introduce the new complex variable t defined by t = 1'I2z and the polar coordinates reie = w/2. I n terms of these new variables (4.117) becomes
where f is an entire function of t. T h e generalized Lie derivatives of this multiplier representation of S , are readily computed:
J3
Thus,
=i
(A - t
-),dtd
Q
= il.
4-14. THE UNITARY REPRESENTATION (A, I )
121
Applying these operators to the basis functions j J t ) = n = 0, 1, 2,..., we have
JYn = (n - 4jn, J+jn = [1(n
+
Ej,, = lin
,
.
J-j,,= (In)'/,
P/(n!)1/2,
.
These relations are identical with the relations (4.106) derived in Section 4-12. Thus to define unitary representations of S, induced by tl,* we need only introduce a Hilbert space such that the functionsj, form an orthonormal basis. The action of the group on this Hilbert,space will be given formally by (4.118). As we saw in the last section the Hilbert space 9 has the required property. Using the preceding facts as motivation we now construct the unitary representation (A, Z) of S, on 9. Here, A is an integer and 1 > 0. Let g be an element of S, with parameters {w, a, S} = {2reis, a,S}. Define the linear operator U(g) on 9 by [U(g)f](t) = exp[-W2treie - lr2/2
+ i1S + ix~!]f(te-~~ + ll/%e-h-i@),
f~ S. (4.1 19)
If g, and g, are elements of S, with coordinates rl , O1 , a, ,al and 1, , 8, , a 2 ,a,, respectively, one readily finds the coordinates I, 8, a, 6, of g,g2 E S, to be given by
Theorem 4.2
PROOF (i) have
(A, Z) is a unitary representation of S ,
Using the inner product (4.111) on 9 we
Unitarity.
(u(g>f, U(g)h) = m-1
.
J expI-1112ire-ie
-
/1/2treie - lr21
.,f( te-iu
+ /l/2ye-M-ie)
.h(te-iu
+ 11/2ye-iu-i0 ) exp(-tt)dxdy,
t =x
+ +,
for all g E S, , f, h E 9. With the introduction of the new complex variable t' = x' + iy' = te-iu + /l/zre-i=-i@this integral simplifies to 7r-l
Ifv)
h(t') exp(-t't';) dx' dy' = (f,h ) .
122
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
(ii) Representation property. given above, we have
If g, ,g, E S, with coordinates as
[U(g,) U(g,)f](t) = exp[-ZWr,ei@i - Zr,2/2 + i16, (te-hi
+ iAaJ[U(g,)f]
+ z1/2rle-%-%)
= exp[-ZWre'@
- lr2/2 + i16
+ iAa]f(te-ia + 21/2re-'U-'e
)
= [U(g,gJfl(t)
for allfE S, where the variables reie, a,6 are defined by (4.120).
4-15
Q.E.D.
The Matrix Elements of (A, 1)
Given g E S, with coordinates rete, a, 6, we shall compute the matrix e1ements n, m = 0,1,Z---, un,m(g) = < i n U(g)jm>, 9
with respect to the orthonormal basis {in).I n fact we can easily derive a generating function for these matrix elements. T o do this note that
(4.122)
where the last equality follows from (4.121). By equating coefficients of powers of s and u we easily find expressions for the matrix elements themselves. T h e result is Un,,(g) = exp[ia(A - m)
+ i16 + i(n - m)O]
4-15. THE MATRIX ELEMENTS OF (A,/)
or,
Unam(g)= exp[ia(X - m)
123
+ iZ6 + i(n - m)q
- exp (-
+
where the functions L p ) , a, b integers, a b 2 0, are the associated Laguerre polynomials. This result can be used to derive a new generating function for the associated Laguerre polynomials. Choose 0 = 01 = 6 = 0, I = 1 and substitute (4.123) into (4.122) to obtain (4.124)
Lemma 4.5
The representation (A, I ) is irreducible.
PROOF The method of proof is completely analogous to that of Lemma 3.2. Assume the lemma is false. Then, there exists a proper closed subspace JId of 9such that U(g) f E J?Y for all g E S, ,f E .1Let . P be the self-adjoint projection operator on A. Since JId is a proper subspace of 9 it follows that P # 0, I. Moreover, U(g)P = PU(g) for all g E S, . Let g, be the element of S, with coordinates (0,a,0}, i.e., reie = 6 = 0. Then, U(gol)jn = eia(A-n)jn for all n 2 0, which implies U(gol) Pj, = eiu(A-n)Pjn . Thus, Pj, = a&, a, a constant. Since P2 = P we have a t = a, for all n >, 0; hence, a, = 0 or a, = 1. By hypothesis there exist integers no , n1 2 0 such that Pj,, = 0, Pjnl = jnl. Thus, un0&9 = (in, U(g) Pj7Ll> = = 0 for all g E S, . This is a contradiction since none of the matrix elements (4.123) is identically zero for all g E S, . Q.E.D. T h e generating function G”l(g; s, u ) and the matrix elements U,,,(g) are functions of the group parameters r, 0, a, 6; hence, they can be integrated over the group manifold with respect to a suitable measure. As is well known from the general theory of topological groups (Naimark [I]), there is a unique (up.to a constant) measure d(g) on S, with the property 9
J f k J 4 g ) = JfW 4 g )
(4.125)
for every integrable function f on S, and every go E S , . (The domain of integration is the entire group manifold S, .) This measure is called the. (right invariant) Haar measure. The suitably normalized Haar measure on S, is given by d(g) =
Y
dr dB da d6
16,+
124
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
where r, 8, a, 6 are the coordinates of g E S, . Thus,
The reader can verify directly that d(g) has the property (4.125). T h e constant ( 16rr3)-I has been chosen for purposes of normalization. We now compute the integral
I GA*l(g;
m
u, S) GA'*''(g; u', s') d(g) =
1
p.q.n,m=O
m)
(The superscripts A, I are used to denote the representation (A, 0.) T h e first inteBral can be evaluated directly if one makes use of the simple expression (4.122) for G(-)and the properties of the vector eb . T h e result of the straightforward integration is Y
6(1 - I') J GAJ(g; U,S) GA'*"(g;u',s') d(g) = 41
exp(tiu'
+ is').
Here a,, is the Kronecker delta while 6(I - 1') is the Dirac delta function which arises from the symbolic integration formula
Theorem 4.3
6(Z - 1')
U;::(g) UA:p'(g) d(g) = 7 6A.A,6p,naqem.
Theorem 4.3 gives orthogonality relations for the matrix elements of the unitary representations (A, I). If the matrix elements are expressed in terms of associated Laguerre polynomials by (4.123), these orthogonality relations reduce to the formula
+
valid for all integers m, n 2 0 and all integers k such that n k 2 0, m+k>O. The group property U(g,g,) = U(gl)U(g,) leads to an addition theorem
m
=
C
I
u(gz>im>
4-16. THE UNITARY REPRESENTATIONS (A, - I )
125
for the matrix elements of (A, 1). Substituting expressions (4.123) for the matrix elements and simplifying we obtain (feie)m-nLcm-n)(f2) n
exp[
ei(e,-B
1 2
)
+
where m, n >, 0 and reie = r,eiel r2eiea. This formula is, of course, only a special case of the addition theorem (4.28) for the matrix elements of
Tw,c.
We can use (4.127)to derive a simple integral formula for the product of two associated Laguerre polynomials by setting 8, = 0 and multiplying both sides of the equation by ei(p-)ea. Integrating with respect to 0, we obtain
+
where reie = rl r2ei@sand p is a nonnegative integer. Since the operators U(g) are unitary and the basis vectors jnhave norm one it follows that
I un.m(g)I = I ( j n , U ( g ) j m > I G 1, which implies
4-16
I L;m-*)(r2)( < (m!/n!)1/2
n,m 2 0 , gESq* exp(r2/2).
The Unitary Representations (A, -I)
In exact analogy with the work of Section (4-14) we can construct unitary irreducibIe representations (A, -I) of S, on the Hilbert space which are induced by the representations J A , l of 9(0,1) (A an integer, 1 > 0). Rather than repeat the motivation for this construction we merely present the results. The construction of the representations (A, -1) of S, on .F is very similar to that for (A, 0. Define the linear operator V(g), on 9by [ V ( g ) f ] ( t= ) exp[Pttre-ie - h2/2
.f ( t e i u
- /1/Zreiu+if3 ) I
where g E S, has coordinates reie, a, 8.
+ ia(A + I ) - iD] f E 9 ,
126
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Theorem 4.4 (A, - 1 ) is a unitary representation of S, . The matrix elements of (A, Z) are given by vn.m(g) = ( i n 7 V(g)i,>,
g
E
s, -
In analogy with (4.121) and (4.122), we obtain the generating function
=
exp[icu(A
+ 1)
-
i16 - &lr2 + u&(s - / W e i e ) + /1/2sre-ie], (4.129)
with the result V,,,(g)
= exp[ior(A *
+ m + 1) - i16 + i(m - n)O]
exp( -1~~/2)(n!/m!)~~~( -/1~2~)m--nL~mlm-n)(l~2). (4.130)
Note that the matrix elements (4.123) and (4.130) have the same dependence. They differ only in their dependence on a, 6, and 8. Lemma 4.6
The representation (A, Z) is irreducible.
because of the integration over the variable 8. The infinitesimal operators of the representation (A, -Z) f z , f 3 , 9 of Y4are given by to the elements
J~ = i (A
+I +t
J+ = -J,
+ iJ, = /l/z
= iJ3 = -A
d
dt '
-1-t-,
corresponding
dt
Hence,
J3
Y
d dt
J- = Jz
E
=
+ iJ1= /1/2t, -'
tQ = -1
4-17. THE TENSOR PRODUCTS (A, I) @ (A’, 1‘)
127
and the action of these operators on the basis vectorsj,(t) = tn/(n!)lPis J8jn
= (-A
-1
J+jn = ( l n ) 1 ’ 2 j n - 1 ,
-.)in, Ejn = -lj n ? J-j,
= [l(n
+ 1)I1’’jn+1
for all n 2 0. These relations are identical with Eqs. (4.107) (w = A, I ) and show that the representation (A, -l) of S, induces the representation of 9 ( 0 , 1).
p =
4-17
The Tensor Products (A, I )
0(A’,
1’)
We begin a study of tensor products of representations of S, by considering the representation (A, 1) @ (A‘, 1’)where A, A‘ are integers and 1,Z’ > 0. This representation is defined on the space S2 909 of entire functions f(t, p ) of the complex variables t and p such that
+
iy, and the domain of where d [ ( t ) = d e x p ( - t i ) dx dy, i = x integration is @. Clearly 9, is a Hilbert space with inner product
T h e action of g E S, on f E S2is given by
where g has the coordinates I, 0, OL, 6. It is simple to check that the operators UAJ(g) @ UA’.’‘(g) define a unitary representation (A, I ) @ (A’, 1‘) of S, on S2. However, this representation is not irreducible. T h e following paragraphs will be devoted to decomposing (A, 1) 0(A’, 1’) into irreducible representations. Since S, is not a compact group, general theorems on locally compact groups tell us only that (A, 1) @ (A’, Z’) is unitarily equivalent to a direct integral of unitary irreducible representations of S, . However, we shall show that in fact it is unitarily equivalent to a direct sum of unitary irreducible representations of S , .
128
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
T h e vectors jm,n= t"p"/(m! n ! ) l l 2 ,m, n = 0, 1, 2, ..., form an orthonorma1 basis for S2.By means of a change of variable a new basis can be introduced in S2on which the action of (A, 2) @ (A', l') becomes more transparent. Define new variables u and o by (4.132)
These equations can be inverted to give f = (1%
p
=
+ Z'y, + I1/2u)/(I+
- 1'1/2u)/(1
(l'%
I')1/2.
Furthermore, by evaluating the appropriate Jacobian it is easy to show d5(t) 4 p ) = d t ( u ) d5(b).
(4.133)
A polynomial in t, p can be written as a polynomial in u, w, and conversely. Indeed, i f f € S2,then f(t, p ) E h(u, o), where t, p , u, and w are related by (4.132) and h is an entire function of u, o. Again the converse holds. From these remarks and (4.133) we see that the functions unwm/(m!n ! ) l / 2 ,n, m = 0,1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal basis for .F2 . We @ UA'.''(g)defined by (4.131) to the funcnow apply the operator U**'(g) tion h(u, o) = unk(v) E S2, where n is a nonnegative integer and k is an entire function of o. T h e result is [UAeL(g) @ UA'-l'(g)h](u,v)
+ 1')1/2 vieie - &(l + I')r2 + ia(h + A' - n) + iS(I + l')]unk (ve-ia + i ( 1 + Z')1/2 e-fe-is). (4.134)
= exp[-(I
*
Thus, the functions u"k(v) E S2for fixed n form a basis space for the irreducible representation ( A A' -n, 1 Z') (compare with (4.1 19)). This proves:
+
+
Theorem 4.6
(A, 1) @ (A', l')
n=o
@ (A
+ A'
-n, 1
+ 1').
To study this decomposition in greater detail we adopt a new notation. Set
-
unvm
( m ! n!)1/2'
n , m = 0 , 1 , 2 ,....
4-17. THE TENSOR PRODUCTS (A, I) @ (A', 1')
129
Here, the superscripts on h denote the representation to which the corresponding basis vectors belong. From the last theorem, both the collection of vectors Gm,n}and the vectors {h$+A'-n*'+l')}form orthonorma1 bases for S2.Thus the j basis vectors and the h basis vectors can be expressed as linear combinations of one another, the coefficients of the expansion being known as Clebsch-Gordan coefficients. We now compute these coefficients. Clearly, m
Thus,
(4.135) Define the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients K [ l , q; 1',s 1 n, m],zero unless q s=n m, by
+
+
K[I, q; Z', s I n, m]
=
>'.
( j q , 8h:+A'-n*Z+Z') ,
From (4.135) we obtain K[1, q; I', s I 11, ml
0
if m + n # q + s ! (m)!( m
+ n - q)! (q)! (1/1 ) + ' n-q11/ 2
(1
Z/l')rn+"
Here the summation is taken over all integer values of a such that the summand is defined. Clearly, the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are independent of A, A' and depend only on the ratio 111' of 1 and l'. It is easy to prove from (4.136) that K[Z, q; ,'Z
s I n, m] = (-l)n
K[Z', s; I , q I n, m].
130
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
It is also easy to find generating functions for the coefficients K. From
(4.135),
Since the left-hand side of this expression is invariant under the simultaneous transpositions w tt p, t t)z, K[Z, q; Z',
1 n, m]
s
=
K[Z, n; l', m 1 q, s].
T h e decomposition of (A, 1) 0 (A', l') into irreducible parts as given by Theorem 4.6 can be considered as a special case of the decomposition of the representation 0to,,r,of 9(0,1) studied in Section 4-5. I n fact, if w1 = A, w 2 = A', pl = I, p1 = l', the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients H, Eq. (4.58) in Section 4-5, are related to the coefficients K by the equation
-
(-l)n+m-Qn!
(n
F(-m, q
+ m - q)! (1 + l'/l)m
-n
- m; q - m $. 1; -z'/1)
T(q - m
+ 1)
.
(4.138)
T h e H and K coefficients differ by multiplicative factors because they have been defined with respect to different basis vectors. I n analogy with Eq. (4.62), we can derive the formula
g E S, , (4.139)
expressing the product of two matrix elements as a sum of matrix elements. T h e sum over k is finite because the coefficients K are nonzero for only a finite number of values of k.
4-18. T H E REPRESENTATIONS (A, I ) @ (A’, -1’)
131
By definition the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients satisfy the unitarity conditions m
These conditions can be used to derive identities for the Jacobi polynomials. T h e method needed to decompose the tensor product (A, -I) @ (A’, 4’) (A, A‘ integers, 1, 1’ > 0) is almost identical to that for (A, 1) @ (A’, I’). We define the unitary representation (A, - I ) @(A’, -l’) of S, on 55, by means of operators V**-l(g)@ W’P-~’ (g),g E s,9 given by [V”-yg) 0VA’.-’’( g ) f I(4 P ) = exp[(ll/zt
.f ( t e i u
pre-ie) - t ( l + i‘jr2 + ia(~+ A’
+~
- eiu/1/+ei9,
+ 2)
-
+
i ( ~ I’>s~
1.
(4.141)
peia - erul’1/2yei9
Introducing the variables u, ZI defined by (4.132) we can easily decompose this representation into its irreducible parts. The result is Theorem 4.7
(A, -1) @ (A’, -1’)
C 0 ( A + A’ n=o co
g
+ n + 1, -1-
I’).
T h e Clebsch-Gordan coefficients for this decomposition are (.&A ‘
’ p+A’+n+l.-Z-t’))’ m
=
K[I,
Q;
l‘, s 1 n, m],
(4.142)
where the coefficients K are defined by (4.136).
4-18 The Representations (A, I) @ (A’, -/’) T h e problem of decomposing the unitary representation (A, 1)@ (A’, -l’) where A, A‘ are integers and I, I‘ > 0 is more difficult than the problems considered in the last section. It naturally divides into three cases: (1) 1 > Z‘, (2) 1’ > 1, and (3) I = Z’. I n each case we define the representation (A, 1) @ (A’, - l ’ ) on S, as follows: For each g E.S,,designate by UA.#(g)@ VA‘n-J‘(g) = W(g) the operator [ W ( g ) f ( ] tp, )
+ l’1/2pre-ie + 1 ’ ) f + ia(A + A’ + 1) + i(l - l’)S]
= exp[ -1Wreig
- $(I
.
f(te-iu
+ ll/Zye-i9-k ,pek - [‘l/Pyei.eiB+iu 1
(4.143)
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
132
for all f E S2.It is easy to verify that these operators yield a unitary representation of S, on S2. CASE 1. I > 1'. We could treat this case by Lie algebraic methods in analogy with the work of Section 4-5. Indeed, we could compute the possible eigenvectors fo in S2of the operator J3 = -A - A' - 1 + t a / a t - p a/ap with the property J-fo = 0, where J- = P I 2 ajat W 2 p .For each such fo we could then show that the vectors (J+)"f0,n = 0,1, 2, ..., form a basis for an irreducible representation of S , . Here, Jf = PI2t I'll2 a/ap. Rather than work out the details of this construction it will be more convenient to present the results and verify that they are correct. We define the function t , P complex, by (4% u, t , p ) ,
+
+
G(u, a, t , p )
=
exp[(ut + vp)(l - 1'/Z)lI2
+ (uv - fp)(1'/1)1/2](1 - 1'/1)112
(4.144)
G(-)is a generating function for the vectors h p ) E .Z2which are defined by (4.144). Clearly, G(.) is an entire analytic function of each of its variables. Also it is square integrable with respect to either of the measures d((u) d((v) or d&t) d&p) taken over the domain C2. It will be shown that the vectors h p ) form an orthonormal basis for S2, and the matrix elements of W(g) with respect to this basis will be computed. T o this end we evaluate the inner product (G(u,v , *, .), [W(g)l G(w,z, - 7 --
I
.D' ( h p ) ,W(g) hLm))',
g E S4
.
(4.145)
The integration is carried out over the variables p , t . The inner product on the left-hand side of (4.145) can be evaluated directly by making use of the definitions (4.143), (4.144). This integration is elementary and can be performed with no other tool than the delta function property of the vectors eb . The result is
(4.146)
4-18. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I )
0(A',
-/')
133
where g E S, has coordinates I, 8, a, 8. We can draw several immediate conclusions from this equation. Lemma 4.7
(hin),W(g) hhm))' = 0 unless m
Lemma 4.8
For fixed n,
=
n.
(4.147)
PROOF Equate the coefficients of ( W Z ) on ~ both sides of (4.146). Comparing the generating function (4.147) with (4.122) we see that the vectors hin), k = 0, 1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal basis for the irreducible representation ( A A' n 1, I - )'Z of S4. Furthermore, i f g is the identity element in S4 (Y = 8 = a = 6 = 0), then according to Eq. (4.146) the vectors {hin)},n, k = 0, 1, 2,..., form an orthonormal set. We must still show that the {hin)}form a basis for Sz. T o do this we evaluate the inner product
+ + +
*7
-9
t,p)>'
u,v,
t,p € @.
This inner product can be computed directly by using the vectors The final result is exp(zit
+~
p =)
1 h',n'(u,v ) hjlR)(t,p). w-
eb
.
(4.148)
k.n=O
We have proved only pointwise convergence in (4.148), but convergence in the mean ( d [ ( t )d [ ( p ) ) follows from the orthonormality of the hin'. Set eu,Jt,p) = exp(zZt C p ) . From I, Section 4-13, we find (eu,o, f)' = f(u, v ) for all f~ S2. Thus,
+
m
f ( u , v ) = (e U . V
,f>'=
C
k.n=O
@P),.f>'hp)(u,v ) ,
proving that the h p ) form an orthonormal basis for S2.
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
134
If 1 > I'
Theorem 4.8
> 0 then
I) 0(A', 4')
(A,
2 @ (A + A' + n + 1 , l - l'). m
n=O
T h e basis vectors h p ) are easily computed from the generating function G( .): hjc")(t,p )
exp[ - ( t / / ) l / z t p ]
=
1(k!n!)1/*(t/ly/2(1 - I'/l)[(K+n+l)/z-aI a
tk-aPn-a
a ! (k - a)! (n - a ) ! '
k , n = 0 , 1 , 2 ,....
T h e summation is carried out over all values of a such that the summand is defined. Using this expression we can calculate the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients
where jp,s(t, p)
=
tQps/(q!s!)'/*, q, s 2 0. T h e result is
G [ l ,4;l', s 1 n, kl 0 -
s+k#q+n
if (9
+
tl
- k)! K ! n! (z'/i)*-k
1 ; 112
(q
(- l)Q-k(- r p ( 1 - l'/l)-a k a ) ! u! (k - a)!(n - a)!
-
+
if s + k = q + n .
(4.149)
From (4.144)one readily deduces the generating function exp[(ut
+ vp)(l
- f'/i)112
+ (uv - tp)(l'/l)llZ](l- l'/1)llz (4.150)
This function is invariant under the simultaneous transpositions t and u t)z, which implies
p
t)
G[l,4; 1', s I n,k] = G[l,S; l', q I k, n]
for all q, s, n, K 2 0. Another symmetry is u t)I, G[I,4; l', s I n, k]
=
z,
HP, which implies
G[2, k; l', 12 I S, q].
Comparing the generating functions (4.137) and (4.150) we find G[I,4;I', s I t l , k] = (1 - 1'/l)'I2 K[1 - l', 4; f ' , n I S, k].
4-18. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I ) @ (A', -1')
135
As a simple consequence of the definition of Clebsch-Gordan coefficients one obtains the formula
expressing the product of two matrix elements as a sum of matrix elements. In terms of the associated Laguerre polynomials these relations become
F(-m, -n; k
-
n
+ 1; -I'/(l
r(k - n
.L(q-s-m+n, m-n+k [(I
+ 1)
1'))F(-q,
~
--s;
k -s
+ 1 ; -I'/(Z
q k -s + 1)
- l')Y'].
- I'))
(4.151)
CASE 2. 1' > 1. In this case the functions hLn)are no longer elements of S2(since Z'/l > 1) and we must modify our procedure. I n terms of our Lie algebraic method we would look for eigenvectors f, of J3 such that J+f, = 0 and use these 'vectors to generate a new orthonormal basis for F2. However, we omit this and merely verify the validity of the results. The functions (t, p ) E 2F2, n, k = 0, 1,2, ..., are defined by means of the generating functions F(u, o, t, p ) :
fr)
F(u, v , t , p )
=
exp[(up
= exp[-
+ vt)(l
-
1/1')1/2
$(I' - Z ) Y ~ + im(X
+ (uv
-
tp)(l/I')1/2](1 - 1/1')1/2
+ A' + 1) - i S ( f ' - I)
136
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
( fp’,W(g)
Lemma 4.9
f?’)‘ = 0 unless m
= n.
Comparing this expression with the generating function (4.129), we see that the vectors { fp’}, k = 0, 1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal basis for the representation ( A A‘ - n, -(Z’ - I)) of S, . Finally, in analogy with case 1 we can show
+
where the convergence is in the mean. This is the completeness relation for the set { fp):”’) and proves: Theorem 4.9 (A,
If I’
> I > 0 then
I) @ (x’, -1‘)
1 @ (A + x’ co
g
71,
-(l’ - I)).
n=O
The Clebsch-Gordan coefficients for this decomposition are given by
,fF)>‘= G[l,s; l‘, q I n,4
<j**8
where G[*] is defined by (4.149). Note the interchange of s and q in the above expression. 4 1 9 The Representations (A, I ) @ (A’, - I ) According to (4.143) the representation (A, -I) @ (A’, --I) follows: Let g E S, with coordinates I, 8, a, 8. Then, [ W ( g ) f ] ( t , p= ) exp[11/2(pre-ie - treie) - 1r2
.
f(te-i.
+ y/l/2e-f@-iu
acts on T2as
+ ia(X + A’ + I ) ]
,peh - y/l/zeie+iu )
(4.152)
for every f~ F2. This representation of S, is independent of the parameter 6 ; hence, every element of the normal subgroup D of S, ,
D
= {g E
S, : g
= exp 6 9 , 6 real},
4-19. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I ) @ (A’, - I )
137
is mapped into the identity operator on P2.Thus, this representation can be considered as a representation of the (global) factor group S,/D g E, . In fact, if g, ,g2 E S , have coordinates y l , 8, , a1 and yZ, 8, , aZ , respectively, then the element gig,E S, has coordinates Y, 8, OL given by re’e
= r,e%
+ yzei(%*i),
+ a2
=
OL
(we ignore the parameter 6). For tp = -a these relations become = y,e%
+ y.#%+cpi),
+ Vz
V = Vl
9
which are identical with expression (3.43) giving the coordinate transformation for the product of two group elements in E, . From (4.152) it is easy to show that the infinitesimal operators J k , K = 1, 2, 3, and Q of the representation (A, l ) @ (A’, --I) are given by ip12
j1 = - -( t
2
a + p + -), a +at aP
a
p/2
= -( - - t
J2
-t-
2
a
a
J3=i(h+A’+1- ‘ z + P % ) ,
at
a + P - -)> aP
Q=O
with commutation relations
[Ji Jzl I
= 0,
[J3
7
Ji1 = J2
3
[J3
9
121
=
-Ji
Thus the infinitesimal operators generate a real Lie algebra isomorphic to Cf3. According to the above remarks, (A, I ) @ ( A ’ , --I) can be considered as a unitary representation of E, . From the general theory of representations of locally compact groups we know that this representation can be decomposed into a direct integral of irreducible representations of E3 (Naimark [l], Chapter 8). I n terms of special function theory this would yield an expression for the- product of two associated Laguerre polynomials as an integral over Bessel functions. We will determine this decomposition explicitly. Our realization of (A, I ) @(A’, --I) on the Hilbert space 2Ez is not a convenient one to use for this decomposition. However, there is another realization which is more convenient for tnis purpose. Bargmann has studied 9and S2in connection with the relationship between the usual representation of the canonical commutation relations in quantum mechanics and the Fock representation (Bargmann [3]). In the course of this study, he established a useful unitary mapping A of the Hilbert space L2(R)onto 9. The Lz(R)is the space of all complex functions on
138
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
the real line, square integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure, and with inner product
Since A(t,.) EL,(R) for each t E @, the above integral is always defined. T o understand the origin of the operator A and to verify its unitarity, we compare (4.154) with the generating function (4.77) for the Hermite polynomials. Clearly, m
In
m
(4.155)
where
It is elementary to verify the integral formula
On the other hand, using property 111, Section 4-13, we have
Thus,
These are the orthogonality relations for the Hermite polynomials, and they show that the functions {qn},n = 0, 1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal set in L,(R). I n fact, it is well known that the {p),} form an orthonormal basis for L,(R). We shall not demonstrate this here since group theoretic methods do not appear to simplify the proof. However, see Courant and Hilbert [l], and Bargmann [3].
4-19. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I )
0(A',
+
-I)
139
+
If + E L , ( R ) , then can be written uniquely in the form, = , c, E @, where convergence is in the mean. From (4.153) and (4.155) we have
z-o c,~,
f = A$
c cnjn m
=
E9
n=O
where the Gn}form an orthonormal basis for 9. Thus,
where the first norm is in 9while the second is in L,(R). Therefore, the linear mapping A is one-to-one, onto, and norm preserving, i.e., A is a unitary mapping from L,(R) onto 9. By construction we have jn = A v n , t f = 0 , 1 , 2 ,..., so the inverse map A-l of 9 onto L,(R) must satisfy the relations A-Yn . This suggests that the unitary mapping A-l is given by the integral
yn =
(A-YM
=
J.#AKt q ) f ( t )4 t )
(4.157)
for all j~ 9. However, this integral is not properly defined because A(., q) is not an element of 9for q E R. (Recall d&t) = r-l exp(-tf) dx dy where t = x iy.) To get around this difficulty note that
+
I 4 4 Q)I
< c exp(l t 12/2)
for all t E @ where C is a positive constant depending on q. If 0 < p < 1 we have I A(& q)] C exp[(p2 I t 12)/2].The A(@, q) is square integrable with respect to the measure d( for all q E R; hence, A ( p t , q) is in 9. Indeed direct computation (using property 111, Section 4-13) yields
<
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
140
Equating these expressions we obtain
0
< p < 1,
(4.158)
which is equivalent to Mehler's formula. (This is a special case of a generating function for Hermite functions which will be derived in Chapter 9.) Returning to the problem of justifying (4.157) we see that if f= c,& E . F and 0 < p < 1 then $,, EL,(R)where
x:Lo
W
+p(q)
AW, q ) f ( t )d t ( t ) =
=
1 p"cnvn(q).
n=O
If we define $ E L,(R) by $ = A-l f = C cnyn we have
II #
- #p
112
m
=
1 I cn 12(1 -
n=O
< II # (I2-
A simple limit argument shows
$,, -+ $ in the mean as p --f 1. Therefore, the unitary map A-l of 9 onto L,(R) can be defined by the expression so
(4.159)
for all f E .F. Clearly, f
=
A# if and only if $ = A-'f for $ EL,(R),
f E 9 .
Using the unitary maps A and A-' we can define operators TAs2(g), TA*-'(g), on L,(R) such that TA.Z(g) = A-1UA.t(g)A,
T**-'(g)= A-'V**-'MA.
T h e operators TA**'(g)for all g E S, define unitary representations of S, on L,(R) unitarily equivalent to the representations (A, *Z) of S, on F. These operators can be computed explicitly. If [z] is the element of S, with parameters (Y, 8, OL, 6) = (I,8, 0, 0), where z = x iy = 2Z1/*1eie, then [T**."zI+l(d= l.A-'UA*z[zlA#l(~). (4.160)
+
4-19. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I) @ (A', - I )
141
Following Bargmann [3], we set
f Then,
= A$,
fi
= UA*'[~]f,
T"."[z]$=
fdt) = Jrn exp[--tz/2 - z5/81A(t + 4 2 , q ) $( 4, !I) -03
and from the identity exp[-tz/2 - 22/81 A(t
+ 5/2, q) = exp[$iy(-d/2q
f 4211 A(t, p - X
/ d )
Thus,
for all t,4 EL,(R).Similarly, if (6) is the element of S, with coordinates ( r , 8, 01, 6) = (0, 0, 0, 6), we easily obtain
Let (a)be the element of S, with coordinates (0, 0, a, 0). Then,
Ife-& - 1 then TA.l(a) = I, while if e-im = - 1 we have [T** 2(a)$](4)= +(-q). However, if e-ia # fl it follows from Fubini's theorem that [TA-."(a)+](q) = eieA lim *+m
1"-,,
4'
u(e-'", q', q)
(4.163)
where u(e-im, q', q ) =
J A(t,)A(e-&t, q') de(t).
An explicit computation yields u(e-im,q', q ) =
e-ir(n/4-8/2)
( 2 I ~sin a
exp [i (qz + 4") 2
cot a
-
g-.
(4.164)
142
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
+
Here, OL = 2k7r $3, k an integer, E = k l , 0 < /I< m. (See Bargmann [3] for details. Equation (4.164) is presented for completeness. It will not be needed in the proofs of the various identities for special functions to follow.) When a! = r / 2 , TA-I(.rr/2)$is the Fourier transform of $. In a similar manner we can compute the operators T*--I(g)on L,(R), induced by the operators VA--l(g)on 9. T h e results are
[T"-'(WI(q) = e - " W q ) ,
[TA*-'(a)#](q) = e'e(A+l)lim n+w
(4.165)
1" -n
++t",
q', 9) $Q') 4'
for all fi €Lz(R),where the function u is given by (4.164). From the relation VA:k(g)= (jn , UA-l(g)jm) = (vn,TA*l(g)cpm) and Eq. (4.161), we obtain the identities n (44) exp(x2/8)(x/2)"-" Lcm-n)
=
1
+
00
[7~1/~2(n+~)/~n!]-l exp[-q2 - q x / d / Z ] H&) Hm(q x / l / Z ) dq, -00
(4.166)
exp(-y2/8)( ~ / 2 ) " Lhm"-")(y2/4) -~ - [7T1/22(n+m)/2n!]-1 Jm -m
exp[-q2 - @Y/d21K&)
4
where m, n are nonnegative integers and x, y >, 0. Equation (4.152) defines the representation (A, 1) @ (A', - I ) acting on 9, .F @ 9.We shall find it more convenient to consider this representation of S, as acting on the Hilbert space L,(R2)E L,(R) @L,(R). T h e appropriate transformation is easily carried out through the use of Eqs. (4.161)-(4.165). T h e elements of L,(R2) are complex functions square integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure in the real plane R2.TheLz(R2) is a Hilbert space with inner product
T h e operators T"'(g) @ T"p'(g) = A-' @ A-'(UA.'(g)@ V"*-'(g))A @ A
= M(g)
4-19. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A. I ) @ (A’, - I )
143
are defined on L2(R2)as follows:
z=x+iy,
for all Y E L , ( R ~For ) . notational brevity we have suppressed the dependence of M on A, A’, 1. T h e operators M(g) generate a unitary representation of S, such that M(6) = I for all (6) E S, . As remarked above this representation can be considered as a unitary representation of E, . As such it can be decomposed into a direct integral of irreducible unitary representations (p) of E, . We will carry out this decomposition. Given Y E L ~ ( Rwe~ define ) the function @ E L ~ ( Rby~ ) @(sl
, s2) = Y
-s1
+
s2
-s1
- s2
,
sl, s 2 €
Introducing the change of coordinates s1 = -(ql (ql - q2)/1/2, we obtain
R.
+ q2)/1/2, s2 =
Note that dql dq2 = ds, ds, . T h e operator M[z] acting on operator, which we will also call M[z], acting on @, [M[z]@](s,, s2)
Let the function
= eisi@(sl
, s2
(4.168)
Y induces an
+ x).
(4.1 69)
6 be defined by
6(s1 , u2) = (27~)-1/1
m -m
e-iu*s4(s1 , s2) ds, n
,
u2E
R.
(4.170)
(To be more precise we should write lim m,,Jin place of the integral in (4.170). However, this will be assumed to be understood in the following paragraphs.)
144
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
It is easy to show that M[z] acting on 0 induces an operator, which will also be called M[z], acting on 6 and given by [ M [ z ] ~ ] (,su2) , = e i ( s i ~ + u 2 x ) 6 ( s ,1 u,).
(4.171)
We now pass to polar coordinates and set x = T cos
y = T sin 0,
0,
where from (4.160) we have Define & by
=
T
&(P, Y) =
T h e action of M[x] induced on
s1 = p sin y ,
u, = p cos y ,
2 P h . Note that ds, du,
= p dp dy.
%Jsin Y,P cos Y).
6 then becomes
[M[z]&](p,y )
= eirp
(4.172)
coe(~-8@(p,y )
where & is square integrable with respect to the measure p dp dy. A comparison of Eqs. (4.172) and (3.56)gives the motivation for the above manipulations. We collect our results and use them to compute the matrix element (!PI , M[z]Y2), Yl, Y2€L,(R2).T h e result is (by use of the Plancherel theorem for the Fourier transform)
where the & j , j = 1, 2, are defined by
Using the Fourier integral theorem, we can invert (4.174): Yj(ql , q2) = (2n)-’I2
Iw exp[iu,(q, -W
- q2)/1/2]
rq
, u2) du,
.
(4.175)
Finally, a straightforward computation gives
(!PI , M ( a ) Y 2 )= exp[-ia(h
+ A’ + I ) ]
Comparing these results with the formulas for the irreducible representations ( p) of E, derived in Section 3-8, we obtain Theorem 4.10
(A, I )
0(A’,
-I)
@
I (PIP W
dp.
145
4-19. THE REPRESENTATIONS (A, I ) @ (A', - I )
Theorem 4.10 is merely a symbolic way of denoting the relationship between (A, I ) @(A', -1) and ( p ) given by Eqs. (4.173) and (4.176). Explicitly, we can use our decomposition to relate matrix elements for the representations on the left- and right-hand sides of (4.173). T h e vectors Yn,m(ql , q2) = Fn(ql) Vm(q2),0 d a, m < 00, form an orthonorma1 basis for L2(R2).From (4.174) the transformed vectors &,,,(p, y), peiy = u2 is, , are given by
+
where the last equality follows from (4.161) and a change of variable. Equation (4.175) then yields the relation
between associated Laguerre polynomials and Hermite polynomials. T h e matrix elements of M[z] acting on L,(R2)are given by
, M[zI Ymsj>= q:;([4) yy(".I>.
On the other hand, from (4.173), (4.177), and (3.57), we have
(4.178)
146
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
where m, j, n , k , are nonnegative integers. This equation is the desired identity between associated Laguerre polynomials and Bessel functions whose existence is suggested by Theorem 4.10. As a special case of (4.178) set K = j = 0 to obtain
420 The Representations (p) @ (A, I) As we have seen, the representation (p), p > 0, of E, on the Hilbert space H,constructed in Section 3-8, can be considered as a representation of S, . Thus, it makes sense to define a representation (p) @ (A, 1) of S4on the Hilbert space H @ 9, We will decompose (p) @ (A, 1) into a direct sum of irreducible representations. The elements of H @ 9 are formal series
such that
c m
m
n=-m k=O
I :C l2 < 00;
2, c: E
@, 0
< 297,
(mod 297).
Clearly f ( y , .) E 9for almost every y and f(., t) E H for fixed t . In general f ( y , t) does not converge pointwise. H @ 9 is a Hilbert space with inner product
Thus, if f ( y , t)
=
cteinytk/(k!)1/2, h(y, t)
bk,einytk/(k!)1/2,we have
c c$$ m
=
m
n=-m k=O
’
0, form an The vectors fn,k(y,t) = einYtk/(k!)ll2, n, k integers, k orthonormal basis for H @ 9. (For a careful treatment of tensor products of Hilbert spaces see Murray and von Neumann El].) Corre-
4-20. THE REPRESENTATIONS (p) @(A, I )
147
sponding to everyg E S4with coordinates ( I , 8,a, 6 ) we define the operator T(P)(g)@ UA,l(g)= N(g) on 3? 69 as follows: [N(g)f](y,
t) =
+ i d + i16 + ipr cos(8 - y ) ] f ( y + a, te+ + l1I2re-i(O+a)),
exp[--ill%efe - h2/2
f E 2P 09, (4.179) where h is an integer and p, 1 > 0. I t is a straightforward computation to check that the operators N(g) yield a unitary representation (p) 6 (A, I ) of S , . T h e infinitesimal operators J k , K = 1,2, 3, and Q corresponding to this representation are
Q
= il.
These operators satisfy the commutation relations
[Ji JJ 9
=
$0,
[J3
3
J11
=
J2
9
[J,
9
J21
= -Ji
9
[Jk
k
9
Q] = 0,
=
1,2,3,
so they generate a Lie algebra isomorphic to yk . As in Section 4-5, we can use the operators J+ = -J,
a . + iJ1 = 11Pt - iee-iy, J- = + J z + iJ1= 11P- + ?&Y 2 at 2 a . a J3=iJ3=--h+t-++-, E=-iQ=l at ay
to decompose 3? @ S into a direct sum of subspaces, each subspace
irreducible under the action of N(g). Rather than repeat this analysis, however, we will merely present the results and verify that they yield the desired decomposition. Let n be an integer, u E fZ’, and N(n, u; y , t ) the function N(n, u; y , t ) = exp[-p2/81
+ iny + ut + ~pe+/21l/~- t ~ e ~ y / 2 P / ~ ] (4.180)
N( -) is a generating function for the vectors hLk)E X @ .F defined by (4.180). Clearly, N(.) is an entire function of the variables u, t and is an element of 3? @ .F for all values of n and u.
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
148
We will show that the vectors hAk),k = 0, I, 2,..., n = 0, f l , A 2,..., form an orthonormal basis for M Q 9 and will calculate the matrix elements of N(g) with respect to this basis. T o do this we compute the inner product (in X Q 9)
where the integration is taken over the variables y, t . (The validity of the expansion on the right-hand side of (4.181) follows from property 111, Section 4-13.) The integral on the left-hand side of this expression can be evaluated directly using the delta function property of the vector eb and the fact that (zT)-1 ei(m-n)ydy = m.n * 0
The result of the integration is 8m,nexp[ia(A
+ n) + ilS
-
lr2/2
+ ue-iu(s + 11/2re-ie)- sP/2~eie] (4.182)
The following are immediate consequences of (4.182): Lemma 4.11
If m # n, then (h%),N(g)h;?) = 0 for all g E S,
Lemma 4.12 For fixed n the vectors {hik’},k = 0, 1, 2, ..., form an orthonormal basis for the irreducible representation (A n, I ) of S, .
+
PROOF If m = n, Eq. (4.182) is identical with the generating function for the matrix elements of the representation (A n, I ) . Equation (4.182) shows that the totality of vectors {hik’},k = 0, 1,2, ..., n = 0, f l , f 2 , ..., form an orthonormal set in M @ 9. We will sketch the proof that they span M Q 9. Suppose the vectors {hik)}do not span. Then, there exists f E S? @ S, f # 0, such that (f,hkk)) = 0,k, fn = 0, 1, 2,... . From (4.180)
+
0=
“ 9
c; .hf> *I
for all integers n and complex numbers u. Using the delta function property of the vectors eb where b = u - pe-i~/2P/~, we obtain
o _= [
27
- 0
f (7, u
-
-)pe-iv 2111’
[
exp -in7
1-upe‘y
-t
21’12
’
dy.
(4.183)
4-20.THE REPRESENTATIONS (p) @ (A, I )
149
This equation forces us to conclude that
for all y, u ; hence, f = 0. This contradiction proves that the vectors hkk)form an orthonormal basis for 3? @ 9.
5 m
Theorem 4.11
( p ) @ (A,
I)
n=-m
@ (A
+ n, I).
T h e basis vectors hkk) are easily computed from the generating function (4.180): h r ) ( y ,t )
=
(k!)-'/"t
+ (pe-*y)/211/2)kexp[-p2/8Z + iny
-
(tpeiy)/2W2]
(4.184)
where th last summation is taken over all integer values of such that the summand is defined. The Clebsch-Gordan coefficients for the decomposition given by Theorem 4.1 1 are obtained directly from (4.184). Recall that the vectors fW,*(y, t) = e i w W / ( q ! ) 1 / 2 ,q, &w = 0,1, 2,..., form an orthonormal basis for X @ 9. The Clebsch-Gordan coefficients E(w, q ; n, R ; p 2 / l ) are given by E(w, q; n, k P 2 / 4 =
, y))
if w + k = n + q .
(4.185)
Here q, R are nonnegative integers and n, w are integers. From (4.180) there follow the generating function N(n, u ; y , t ) = exp[--p2/8Z
+ iny + ut +
- tpei~)/2P/2]
(4.186)
150
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
and the symmetry relations
E(w,q; n,k;p2/1) = E(w
+ m - n,q; m,k;p2/Z) = E(w - n,q; 0,k. / '" ')'
E(w, 9; 0,k;p2/1) = (-l)"+"E( -w, k;0,q; p2/1).
(4.187)
Comparison of (4.186) with the generating function (4.124) for associated Laguerre polynomials yields ( q ! / k ! ) 1 /exp 2
(-
-$)
(p/21112)"qLbk-+")(p/211/2)= E(q - k,q; 0, k;p2/1). (4.188)
I n terms of matrix elements with respect to the two sets of basis vectors { f w , , ) and {h$), the decomposition given by Theorem 4.11 becomes
1 E(w, q ; n, n + n=-m m
u:;(g) ui:i'(g) =
*
E(s, k;n, n
+k -
- w ;p2/1) S; p2/1) u ~ ~ ~ ! n + k - - s ((4.189) g)-
Here, w and s are integers while q and k are nonnegative integers. The matrix elements Ug,)s(g)are expressed in terms of Bessel functions by Eq. (3.57). Making use of (4.188) we can reduce (4.189) to the identity exP(f2)(r)s-w
J w J W Jy-Q'(t.2)
where the sum is taken over all integers n such that n 2 s - k and n 2 w - q. If q = w = s = k = 0 this formula simplifies to the wellknown relation
The decomposition of the representation ( p ) @(A, -I) of S, is very similar to that presented above and leads to no new relations for special functions. We quote only Theorem 4.12
(p)
0 (A, --1)
C
n=-m
@(A
+ n, -I).
421 A Contraction of g(O.1) In Chapter 2 it was shown that the Lie algebra g(0,O) E F3@ (8) was a contraction of g(0, 1). Here, we shall use this fact to obtain relations between associated Laguerre polynomials and Bessel functions.
4-21. A CONTRACTION OF 59(0,1)
151
The infinitesimal operators J k , k = 1, 2, 3, Q corresponding to the representation (A, I ) of S, on 9are given by
")dt
J3=i(A-t
'
Q=d
and obey the commutation relations
We relabel the orthonormal basis vectors jk(t) = tk/(k!)'12 of 9 as follows: f, = jA+,, n = -A, - A 1, - A 2,... . I n terms of this basis the matrix elements of the operator J3 are given by
+
(J;'),,,.
=
= --in an,,,
n, R' = -A,
k
+
-A
(4.192)
+ 1, -A + 2,... .
Moreover it follows from Chapter 3, Eq. (3.64), that the operators K, 2, 3, given by
= 1,
K,
=
-ipcosa,
K,
= -+sin
U,
,
a aa
K - -3
-
are infinitesimal operators induced by the representation ( p ) of E, on the Hilbert space H,and obey the commutation relations [K3,
Kl]
=
Kz ,
[K, , K2] = -Kl ,
[K, , K2] = 0.
(4.194)
152
4. CONFLUENT HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Clearly, K, , K2 , K, generate a Lie algebra isomorphic to 8;.In terms of the orthonormal basis h,(or) = eina, r t n = 0, 1, 2,..., for X‘the matrix elements of these operators are
(4.195)
Here, the inner product (., .)* corresponds to the Hilbert space X . Choosing a parameter > 0 we define a new set of generators for the Lie algebra 9,. T h e new operators are Gi
=~
J
i
G2 = cJ2 ,
t
G3 = J3 ,
Go = EQ.
(4.196)
T h e structure constants for the commutation relations of the G operators are functions of E . I n fact, [G3 G11 9
=
G2,
[G3
7
‘321
=
-GI
[GI , G2]
9
=
+Go
9
[Gk Go] = 0, k = 1,2,3. 9
As E -+ 0 the structure constants approach limits which are the structure constants for a new 4-dimensional Lie algebra. In the limit we have [G3 ,GI]
=
[G3 G21
‘32
9
= --GI
9
[GI , G2]
= 0,
[G,, Go] = 0, k = 1, 2, 3.
This Lie algebra is isomorphic to 8,@ {Go],where the commutation relations for a basis of g3are given by (4.194) and {Go}is the 1-dimensional real Lie algebra generated by G o . Thus, 8, @(Go} is a contraction of 9, (see Section 2-5). We show how an irreducible representation of the contracted algebra 8, @ {Go}can be obtained from a sequence of representations of 9,. Consider the representation (A, p2) of S , (A an integer, p > 0). T h e matrix elements of the G operators for this representation can easily be computed from (4.193) and (4.196). We take the limit of these matrix elements as E -+ 0 and A -+ 00 in such a manner that r2A -+ 1. For GI the result is lim(Gf-*~p2)n,n~ = !-y ( f, , E Jlfn,)
+
r+O
ezA+l
= -
4 d L . d + &+i.n,)
= (K%.n*
(4.197)
4-21. A CONTRACTION OF 9(0,1)
153
(n and n' are held fixed). Similarly, we find
l j ~ ( G ~ a ~ p 2=) n0,. n ~ n,n' = 0,fl, A 2,... .
Thus, we have derived an irreducible representation of the contracted algebra 8.@ {Go}as a limit of irreducible representations of Y4. T h e effect of this limiting procedure on the matrix elements of the representation (A, p2) of the group S4is easily computed from the above considerations. For example, from (4.123) we know that the matrix elements of the unitary operator e--YJl = UA+"(g),y > 0 ( g has coordinates {reie, a ,A} = {--&iy, 0, 0}), are given by
Similarly from (3.57) we see that for the representation ( p ) of E , the matrix elements of e--YK1 are given by
(4.200)
which simplifies to the relation lim m-nynL2)(y2/m)= Jn(2y). m-m
(4.201)
This proof of the limit (4.201) is merely formal; we have not verified the validity of (4.200). However, now that this limit relation has been motivated it is easy to prove it directly from the power series expansions for Laguerre and Bessel functions. T h e preceding discussion was concerned with the relationship between matrix elements of unitary representations of S4and E, . The restriction to unitary representations is not essential, however, and similar arguments can be used to relate matrix elements of irreducible representations of G(0, I ) and matrix elements of irreducible representations of T3 . We omit this.
CHAPTER
5 Lie Theory and Hypergeometric Functions
With respect to a suitable basis, the matrix elements of irreLxi le representations of g(1,O) g $42) @ (8) can be expressed in terms of hypergeometric functions. In Sections 5- 1 to 5-7 these matrix elements will be computed and employed to derive identities and differential relations for the hypergeometric functions. Sections 5-8 to 5-15 are devoted to the realization of irreducible representations of 4 2 ) in terms of type A and type B differential operators. I t will be shown that the most general hypergeometric function can be obtained as a basis vector transforming under the type A operators. Similarly, the most general confluent hypergeometric (Laguerre) function will arise as a basis vector transforming under type B operators. This connection between type A and B operators and special functions will prove to be a powerful tool for deriving identities involving hypergeometric and Laguerre functions. U p to isomorphism the complex Lie algebra $42)has two distinct real forms: su(2) and L(G,). I n Sections 5-16 to 5-18 all of the unitary irreducible representations of the real Lie groups SU(2) and G3 will be obtained by restriction of corresponding local multiplier representations of SL(2).The implications of unitarity for special function theory will be briefly discussed. Finally, in Section 5-19 the Lie algebraic fact that F3 is a contraction of 4 2 ) will be used to derive a formula expressing Bessel functions as limits of Jacobi polynomials.
5-1. THE REPRESENTATION D ~ ( umo) ,
5-1
The Representation
155
m,)
Dp(u,
According to Theorem 2.3 the irreducible representation Dp(u, m,) of g(1,O) is defined by complex constants p, u, m, such that neither m, u or m, - u is an integer, and 0 Re m, < 1. The spectrum of this representation is the set S = {m, n: n an integer}. There is a basis {fm : m E S}for the representation space V such that
+
+
for all m
E
<
S. These operators satisfy the commutation relations
[J3, J*]
=
[J+, J-]
&J*,
= 2J3,
[J*, E]
=
[J3,
E]
= 0.
(5.1)
We will construct a realization of the algebraic representation Dp(u, m,) such that Jf, J3, E take the form of the differential operators (2.35) acting on a vector space of analytic functions of the complex variable z. Let Vl be the complex vector space of all finite linear combinations of the functions h,(x) = zn, n = 0, f l , *2,... . I n Eqs. (2.35) set h = m, , tg = -u - m, , to obtain
The basis vectorsf,, , m E S, are defined byf,(z) and all integers n. Thus,
+
J"fm= (m, z J+fm
=
"1
((m,- u)z
Efm
= pfm
m,
+n
+ n)zn = mfm,
zn = (m,
+ z2 dz d l zn = (m - u)znf1 = (m -
d (+ + z)
~ -= j - ~
= h,(z) for m =
Zn
+ u)z+l
=
(m
-
+
, (5-3) %I-1
1
*
Clearly, the operators (5.2) define a realization of Dp(u, m,) on "v; . We can now apply the procedure described in Section 2-2 to extend this realization of Dr(u, m,) on Vl to a local multiplier representation of
156
5. LIE THEORY AND HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
the local Lie group G( 1,O) =GL(2).However, since 9(1,O) s $42) 0(8) and p ( b ) = E is a multiple of the identity operator for every irreducible representation p of 9(1, 0) listed in Theorem 2.3, the nontrivial part of the representation theory of 9(1,O) is concerned solely with the action of p on 4 2 ) . We can set E = p = 0 without loss of generality for special function theory. It is clear, moreover, that the representation D ( u , m,) of 9(1, 0) induces an irreducible representation D(u, m,) of sZ(2). T h e action of D(u, m,) is obtained from Eqs. (5.1)-(5.3) by suppressing the operator E. In the remainder of this section we will study the representation D(u, m,) of 4 2 ) and extend it to a local multiplier representation of the local group SL(2). Similarly, rather than study the representations t", I:, D(2u) of 9(0,1) given by Theorem 2.3, we will restrict ourselves to the representations t,, I,, D(2u) of $42) obtained by setting E = p = 0. It was shown in Section 1-2 that sZ(2) is the Lie algebra of the local Lie group SL(2), SL(2) = lg
a b d ) : a , b, c, d , E @, detg = 1
= (c
i.e., the group of all 2 x 2 complex matrices with determinant equal to 1. Theorem 1.10 can be applied to extend the realization of D(u, m,) defined on V, to a local multiplier representation of SL(2) defined on (2, , where OT, is the complex vector space of all functions of z analytic in some neighborhood of the point z = 1. Clearly, OTl 3 V, and M, is invariant under the differential operators (5.2). Thus, these operators generate a Lie algebra of generalized Lie derivatives corresponding to a local multiplier representation A of SL(2) acting on QI, . T h e action of the 1-parameter subgroup {exp cy-,c E e'} of SL(2) on (2, is obtained by solving the equations
+
dz
-- - 1,
dc
d
"(9, exp c/-)
=
-
u
+ m,
v(z0, exp c f - ) Z
with initial conditions z(0) = zO # 0, "(9, e) = 1, where exp c f -
=
(-c
1 0 1).
T h e solution of these equations is z(c) = zo - c,
v(zo,exp c f - )
If j~ OT, is analytic in a neighborhood of [A(exp c / - ) f ] ( z o )
=
(1
=
(1 - C / Z ~ ) U + ~ O .
we have
- c / ~ ' ) u + m 0 f ( 9- c )
5-1. T H E REPRESENTATION D ~ ( um,) ,
157
and A(exp c f - ) f E Qdl if 1 cis? [ < 1 and s? - c is in the domain off. Similarly, 20 [A(exp b f + ) f ] ( . “ ) = (1 - bzO)u-mof
(-)1 - bzo
where A(exp by+) f E a, if domain of f;and
I b y I < 1 and P i ( l
-b
y ) is in the
[A(exp ~ / ~ ) f ] ( z “ )= emosf(eTzO)
where A(exp 7 f 3 ) f E Qdl if eTs? is in the domain off. If g E SL(2) and d # 0 it is a straightforward computation to show that g
=
(exp b’f+)(exp c’f-)(exp
T‘f3)
<
where b’ = -b/d, c‘ = -cd, = d-l, 0 Im 7’ < 4 ~ Thus, . for I b’ I, 1 c’ 1, 17’ 1 sufficiently small, the operator A(g) is given by
for f ad
-
E Qd, and z # 0 in the domain of f. We have used the fact bc = 1. T h e multiplier Y takes the form
v ( z , ~= ) (d
+
+
b ~ ) u - m o ( ~ C/Z)”+~O.
As it stands, the final expression in (5.4) is not well defined; it is not even a single-valued function of the group parameters. However, it is obvious that for g in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the identity element, v ( z , g ) has a unique Laurent series expansion in z. TOgive a precise definition of the operators A(g) we restrict g to the open set N c SL(2), N
= { g E SL(2) : I c/u
I < 1 < 1 d/b 1,
-7
< arg a , arg d < T}.
As a local Lie group, N is isomorphic to SL(2). Given f E CZl let Dfbe the domain of f, i.e., the open set in containing 1, on which f is defined and analytic. For every g E N, z E @ let zg be the complex number
c,
az
+c
zg = bz Id
and define 9,(g), the domain of g, by q ( g ) = (f.
uc, : Ig E D,},
1E
c.
158
5. LIE THEORY AND HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
Then, ifg E N , and f E 9,(g) we have A(g) f E 0ll where A(g)f is defined by the Laurent series expansion of v in (5.4). In particular, D*G)/ = (I cl. I
< I z I < I dlb I> n (2 : zg E 0,).
T o give a precise statement of the representation property of the operators A(g) we define the set N(g,), for every g o E N , by N(g,) = {g E N : gg, E N} and let ”(go) be the connected component of N(g,) containing the identity element e E SL(2).Then, ifg, E N , g , E “(g,) we have g,g, E N; and, for every f E a1 such that f E 9 , ( g Z ) and A(g,)f E g1(gl),we can conclude that f E g1(gz2)and “g,gz)fl(z)
=
[A(gdA(gz)f)l(z)
(5.5)
for all z in some nonzero neighborhood of z = 1. (The restriction of
g, to N’(g,) is needed to make the representation single-valued.)
Following the procedure of Section 2-2 we can restrict the multiplier to TI. (T, is the space of all finite linear representation A from combinations of functions of the form A(g) f where g E N, f E Vl .) Clearly is invariant under A. Furthermore, every h E 7,has a unique Lsurent expansion m
h(z) =
C
anzn,
n=-m
a n € @,
which converges absolutely in an open annulus Dh about z = 0, including the point z = 1 in its interior. Thus the basis functions f,(z) = h,(z) = zn, m = m, n, n an integer, form an analytic basis for Tl (see Section 2-2). are defined by The matrix elements A&) of the operators A(g) on
+
m
[ A ( g ) h J ( z )=
l=-m
Azk(g)hz(z),
g EN, k
= 0,
&2,*--, (5.6)
or
where I cia I From ( 5 . 9 ,
< I z I < I d/b 1,
-7r
< arg a, arg d < r , andad - bc = A(gl)[Ak2)hkl,
which leads to the addition theorem
= 1:
5-1. THE REPRESENTATION DI.(u, m,)
159
valid for all g, , g, E N such that g, E N'(g,). Expanding the left-hand side of (5.7) by means of the binomial theorem and computing the coefficient of z' we obtain an explicit expression for the matrix elements: =
+ +
us+w-%-'r(s k 1) F(- s - I, - t r(S 1 + 1)(k - I)!
+
+ k;k - 1 + 1; bc/ad) if k >, 1, (5.9)
if 1 k. Here g E N, r is the gamma function, F is the hypergeometric function defined by its power series expansion, (A.4), and s = u m,, t = u - m, . Note that neither s nor t is an integer. The two expressions (5.9) can be combined into one by noting that
+
F(-
s - I, - t
is defined even when K - I we obtain
+
k; k - 1 r ( k - 1 1)
+
+ 1; b c / ~ d )
+ 1 is a negative integer. In fact, using (AS)
(5.10) for all integers I, k. The matrix elements can be written in other equivalent forms by making use of the transformation formulas (A.8), but this will be left to the reader. It will sometimes be convenient to adopt a different coordinate system for N. Namely, we write
= (exp a$3)
(exp -w
("+
2
+
"-))
(exp BY3)-
A simple computation shows that the coordinates a, b, c, d = (1 are related to the coordinates a, /3, w by
+ bc)/a
5. LIE THEORY AND HYPERGEOMETRIC FUNCTIONS
160
T o make this change of variable one-to-one on N we would have to put some restrictions on the range of the complex variables a, /3, w. Thus, (a, /3, w ) and (a i?~,/3 - ir, - w ) correspond to the same coordinates u, b, c. Further the coordinate transformation is not defined for bc = 0, so the coordinates (a, /3, w ) cannot be extended over all of N. For our purposes,however, it is enough to note that if we can assign to g E N coordinates (a, /3, w ) satisfying (5.1 l), then for suitably restricted values of the parameters the matrix elements A,,(g) are given by
+
+
where cosh w = 2bc 1 and 231sm(z) is defined by (A.9), (iii). (Indeed (5.12) is obviously true for a, /3 real and w > 0. Its domain of validity can then be extended by analytic continuation.) Clearly, the branch points of B>'"(z) are located at z = -1, + I , 00. Thus, if the z-plane is cut along the real axis from - 00 to 1 this function can be analytically continued to the whole z-plane outside the cut. Furthermore, we have the relations 23yyz) = 2 y ( z ) , 2 3 y ( z ) = 23?E1(z). (5.13)
+
An important special case is b;*-r(z) = Sp(z)
where the generalized spherical harmonics 23: are defined by (A.9), (ii). T h e functions B;"(z) will be encountered frequently in